id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06696v1 | Simple and Effective Input Reformulations for Translation | 2023-11-12T00:23:37 | 2023-11-12T00:23:37 | Brian Yu, Hansen Lillemark, Kurt Keutzer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Foundation language models learn from their finetuning input context in
different ways. In this paper, we reformulate inputs during finetuning for
challenging translation tasks, leveraging model strengths from pretraining in
novel ways to improve downstream performance. These reformulations are simple
data level modifications, require no additional collection of training data or
modification of data at inference time. They can be applied either on single
language pair translation tasks or massively multilingual translation tasks.
Experiments with these techniques demonstrate significant performance
improvements up to $\textbf{3.5 chrF++ on the Flores200 translation
benchmark}$. We hope our research accessibly improves finetuning data
efficiency, enabling more effective training to scalably improve
state-of-the-art performance. Our code is released
$\href{https://github.com/bri25yu/LanguageModelExperimentation}{here}.$ | [
0.0211633835,
0.0415561125,
0.0033505417,
0.0387774482,
-0.0060864966,
0.020125147,
0.0406230241,
-0.0318769552,
-0.0750322267,
-0.0282122269,
-0.0562493019,
-0.0207447708,
0.0319772512,
0.0015286489,
0.0656417757,
-0.0559404306,
0.0345019288,
-0.0326130688,
-0.0433964245,
0.0082486738,
0.0104585811,
0.0103046121,
0.0145544466,
0.0106060058,
0.0210829433,
0.0054659154,
0.0110159209,
0.0509218499,
0.0173157398,
-0.0096625388,
0.016573349,
0.0576105155,
0.0105743287,
0.0689332783,
0.0000019072,
-0.0180773009,
-0.0146371583,
0.0136857415,
-0.0218371786,
0.0396176949,
0.0518571064,
-0.055853948,
-0.0266381968,
0.0208742339,
-0.0246815979,
-0.0482376516,
0.0537323803,
0.0336647667,
0.0418355875,
0.0744026154,
-0.009083828,
-0.0158253405,
0.0105582923,
-0.0869823992,
-0.0434077419,
-0.0475010686,
-0.0037576682,
-0.0074940706,
-0.0466696545,
0.0232488234,
-0.0266304221,
0.0478220545,
0.0196893401,
0.0373988599,
-0.0113171311,
0.0066926116,
-0.0561899096,
-0.0364802331,
-0.0022274554,
0.0798780248,
-0.0552918948,
-0.0169536415,
-0.0217850972,
-0.0055259145,
-0.022668615,
-0.0491925552,
-0.0266444068,
-0.0075930418,
0.0113668628,
0.0081703328,
0.0392665826,
0.0135255391,
0.060370788,
0.0227463152,
-0.0811582208,
0.0112223355,
0.0375491008,
-0.0029827207,
0.0106489081,
-0.0080677876,
-0.01401392,
-0.0186655167,
0.0023520859,
-0.0197982471,
-0.022564711,
0.0066715451,
-0.0399101488,
-0.0438745581,
0.0184586067,
-0.0227804761,
0.053605333,
0.0621969029,
-0.0224466901,
0.0430880003,
-0.0209730417,
0.03798794,
-0.0363497846,
0.0375410058,
-0.0746597126,
0.012992953,
0.0098934909,
0.0431130528,
-0.0462983437,
-0.0380708687,
-0.0631814525,
-0.0164710563,
0.0012246307,
-0.0026597315,
0.0261167083,
-0.018798545,
0.0138990888,
-0.0315866396,
-0.0966519788,
-0.016425753,
0.0377151072,
0.0697757006,
-0.0521729365,
0.008911836,
0.0268787481,
-0.0851354823,
-0.0244885553,
-0.0022367467,
0.021468753,
-0.0518328846,
0.0035249458,
0.0241412576,
-0.0136757391,
-0.0390941203,
-0.0240034647,
0.0015568526,
0.0137506211,
-0.0732812285,
-0.0031976681,
-0.0605797432,
0.059354648,
0.0046788342,
0.0251953937,
-0.0374245383,
-0.0045128134,
-0.0029823703,
-0.0192615818,
0.0719356164,
-0.0132043865,
-0.009957511,
0.0163374245,
-0.0083649438,
0.0103125507,
0.0770210847,
0.0338909402,
0.043757651,
0.0300472546,
0.0011014086,
-0.0334295295,
0.0959197953,
0.0316333883,
0.0503401831,
-0.023718873,
-0.0015532245,
0.0101130828,
0.0358458534,
0.0299721565,
0.0268125255,
-0.0478783175,
0.0433553532,
0.071522519,
0.0119145699,
0.0216377173,
0.03609097,
0.0427956842,
-0.0189613868,
-0.0101988642,
-0.0034656199,
-0.0545860231,
0.0007491963,
0.0067673307,
0.0202268846,
0.0265729465,
0.0618502013,
-0.0293743573,
-0.0143632079,
0.010622561,
-0.0023940436,
0.0208268911,
-0.0138803245,
0.0387653261,
0.0577269755,
-0.0447278358,
0.0121480022,
0.0337081105,
-0.0457269363,
0.02885307,
-0.0003791425,
-0.0359984785,
0.0393994525,
0.0361533724,
0.0146542257,
-0.0480495915,
-0.0115218563,
0.0327232629,
0.018589709,
0.0994458944,
0.0076214494,
0.047517702,
-0.0603114143,
-0.0054133907,
0.0335479602,
0.0279527027,
0.0236736983,
0.0035890287,
-0.0007185857,
0.0453037508,
-0.0395051315,
-0.0608628802,
0.0395645276,
-0.0469006859,
-0.03148105,
-0.0082531162,
0.0334923826,
0.0020773953,
-0.0136308018,
0.0032332509,
-0.00064228,
0.0200468786,
-0.0370677374,
0.0283681434,
0.001994563,
-0.0308391303,
-0.059712939,
0.0420283861,
0.0092290947,
-0.0004424313,
0.0140288612,
-0.059976358,
-0.0482835844,
0.0066697779,
0.0119247716,
-0.0052028541,
-0.0375438966,
0.033600226,
0.0081967749,
0.0207717828,
-0.0361272208,
-0.0106811868,
0.0045849076,
0.0204957146,
0.0060412819,
0.0128039755,
0.0172526073,
-0.0299066268,
-0.0294885729,
0.0043352968,
-0.000022849,
0.0325763375,
0.0142685222,
0.0300643966,
-0.0294477828,
-0.0257851966,
-0.0519758277,
0.0366890058,
-0.0376843996,
0.052237343,
0.0343889408,
0.0443861634,
0.00589561,
-0.0092156176,
-0.0127659347,
0.0094430866,
-0.0113415001,
0.0266935322,
-0.0153674819,
0.0141487326,
0.0021583317,
-0.0427054018,
-0.0166909099,
0.0155119039,
0.0285241585,
-0.0165467635,
-0.014831176,
-0.0545759052,
0.0059114234,
-0.0190983787,
0.035915371,
-0.0197629966,
-0.0731387734,
-0.0088174297,
-0.0522690788,
0.0318458416,
0.0677013993,
-0.0252992716,
0.0170845482,
0.0038693768,
-0.0007407796,
-0.042692218,
0.0045224787,
-0.0149442889,
-0.0129221538,
-0.0561486743,
-0.0307054389,
-0.0159422122,
0.0439857468,
-0.0126004219,
0.0016445359,
-0.0622576661,
0.0059971213,
-0.0080728866,
0.0092720501,
0.0053208089,
0.0367554314,
-0.0125785507,
0.0552168451,
-0.0460623614,
-0.0488387644,
0.0475938544,
-0.0596650839,
-0.0203265343,
-0.019757241,
0.0172555726,
-0.0141721889,
0.0477123,
0.0029791757,
0.0121351779,
0.0095611876,
-0.0016677962,
-0.0679170713,
0.016859211,
0.0214584917,
-0.0226444062,
0.0487987101,
-0.0434531383,
-0.0285297483,
-0.0424682945,
-0.0471233577,
-0.0025253878,
-0.0295581333,
-0.0030350622,
0.0115622757,
0.0001005833,
-0.0182052497,
-0.0244688783,
-0.0041432451,
-0.0075354911,
0.0999015495,
-0.0502696447,
0.0090682926,
-0.0286587458,
0.0067159706,
0.01365788,
0.0077595799,
0.0226133838,
-0.0644477233,
0.0061682644,
0.0094666686,
0.0179141909,
-0.0203958433,
-0.0555847995,
-0.0161031354,
0.0407502316,
0.0305144675,
-0.0282108933,
-0.0078408662,
0.0704468638,
-0.0643360466,
-0.0253200307,
0.0955174863,
0.0041342457,
-0.0243128687,
0.010013354,
0.0204953905,
0.0597626008,
0.0436410196,
0.0233530886,
-0.036135789,
-0.03648936,
0.0266559497,
0.0455925912,
0.0402164869,
0.0111754518,
-0.0068325857,
-0.0888393819,
0.0126864193,
0.042843245,
-0.0712906048,
-0.0426519401,
-0.0027248655,
-0.0065386631,
-0.0318540856,
0.0300025865,
0.0025507205,
0.0114783552,
0.0196815543,
0.0244567115,
0.0387845077,
-0.0645625442,
-0.0087478012,
-0.0747463182,
0.0476401821,
0.0775734186,
0.0103290277,
0.0002390266,
0.0002315583,
0.0643874034,
-0.0425750017,
-0.0069905943,
-0.015240686,
0.0376919545,
0.0184906255,
-0.0358213782,
0.0369860195,
0.0187203735,
-0.0314260423,
0.0227711461,
0.0087737599,
0.0430368781,
0.0040933923,
0.025039399,
0.0440591089,
-0.0356835574,
-0.0019069556,
0.0404815152,
0.044694826,
-0.0157209691,
0.0130034024,
-0.0365990363,
-0.014899713,
-0.0557403527,
-0.0127838105,
-0.005733151,
-0.0295970421,
-0.0515917614,
-0.0766510963,
-0.0610820092,
0.0390173681,
0.06683366,
0.0069880364,
-0.0004321692,
-0.0044073272,
-0.022411542,
-0.0058117677,
0.0614380687,
-0.0371668525,
0.0278518368,
-0.057319209,
0.0084225694,
0.0321113318,
-0.0246546976,
0.0081349919,
0.0441817716,
-0.0923181698,
-0.0750039518,
0.0020456028,
0.0610263012,
0.0220893063,
0.0403393768,
-0.0478857122,
-0.0459663607,
-0.0223945826,
0.0077818478,
-0.0395360813,
0.0147348959,
0.0574517995,
-0.0413665771,
-0.0096053137,
0.060830012,
-0.0032574981,
0.0072363201,
0.0325831473,
0.0696816295,
-0.0231948476,
-0.0513248332,
0.0132852346,
0.01956659,
0.0565603077,
-0.0311988406,
-0.0058703544,
-0.0430393629,
0.027207803,
-0.005711826,
-0.0253262613,
-0.0457369126,
-0.0148332343,
0.053046111,
0.0143578351,
-0.0087001482,
0.0080918884,
0.0365346298,
0.0121438317,
-0.0341520123,
-0.0216091163,
-0.0124076642,
0.0241068639,
0.0325976536,
0.0268712342,
-0.0298136882,
0.0172447301,
-0.0083020516,
0.016602328,
-0.0620578788,
0.0425123796,
0.0286597777,
0.0094410321,
-0.0616401173,
0.0309220031,
-0.0372241288,
-0.029276615,
-0.0271242317,
-0.0086508142,
0.0436955914,
-0.0070903515,
0.1015538424,
0.0003362289,
-0.0433959179,
-0.0277473778,
0.0471836068,
-0.0099491272,
-0.0186121017,
0.0242106169,
0.0020591454,
0.0041798423,
0.0077806432,
0.0534960553,
-0.0137481065,
0.0277407393,
0.0062621674,
0.0236688443,
-0.0085222051,
-0.0103906319,
-0.0205476563,
-0.0175956991,
-0.0222991183,
0.0069806902,
-0.014571202,
-0.0782851875,
-0.016806731,
0.0144907581,
-0.0116145452,
-0.0230749883,
0.0164984576,
0.0722562298,
-0.0540811755,
0.0132223805,
-0.0375152417,
-0.0098664183,
0.0455301069,
-0.0123220328,
-0.0398732498,
-6.307209714e-33,
-0.0294150021,
0.0420920849,
0.0132386433,
-0.027080046,
-0.0544216968,
-0.0235396605,
-0.0387142859,
-0.0130073661,
-0.0243747644,
0.0128356293,
-0.0240945853,
0.0041689705,
0.0263518598,
0.0149324099,
-0.029207522,
-0.0001052159,
0.0899069458,
0.0005414261,
-0.0348879956,
0.0198569559,
0.0128740929,
0.0318904147,
0.0775021762,
-0.0508539267,
-0.0010472522,
-0.0314128324,
-0.0483084507,
0.0439569987,
-0.0072106435,
0.015463857,
0.0077138925,
-0.0039737136,
0.0053401249,
-0.0412505195,
-0.0375064798,
-0.0259191878,
-0.1275346875,
0.0007596028,
0.0134590678,
0.0457307622,
-0.0341282785,
-0.03621912,
0.0525104664,
-0.0321048461,
0.0205017626,
-0.0198432039,
-0.0244347341,
-0.059026774,
-0.0571518913,
0.0079235677,
-0.0796960145,
0.0273193866,
0.0025802031,
-0.0292718373,
0.040305458,
0.0253985617,
-0.0141581381,
-0.0260655452,
-0.041564554,
-0.0270940606,
0.0325042643,
0.078693673,
0.0580765568,
0.0406715125,
-0.0153611172,
-0.0028128098,
0.004620655,
0.0060680299,
0.0575537942,
-0.0074498444,
0.0747097731,
0.0183245949,
0.0429469198,
0.0672611818,
0.0406253077,
-0.0218313485,
-0.0540433638,
0.0173122957,
0.0176867545,
-0.0047227088,
0.0088224262,
0.0052586221,
-0.0095906649,
-0.0172567181,
-0.0797343403,
-0.0318984166,
-0.0352993347,
-0.0035991576,
0.0103170443,
0.0456736572,
-0.0167521127,
-0.0077991053,
0.0619883128,
-0.0312223528,
0.0095322654,
0.0155360634,
-0.0294468105,
0.0150381671,
-0.0271686707,
0.0395711288,
-0.0111334622,
-0.0485208929,
0.018763341,
0.0168786496,
0.0112969847,
-0.0177612584,
0.0903824419,
0.0303918533,
-0.0623543039,
-0.0019922303,
-0.05540023,
0.010895839,
0.0135436254,
0.0607042499,
0.028102817,
-0.0073804911,
-0.0088602249,
0.0430571102,
0.0356823057,
-0.0057144449,
-0.0264612753,
0.0010662705,
0.0360601917,
0.036942821,
-0.0362196714,
0.0045159627,
-0.0374196321,
0.0213610884,
0.051700782,
-0.0500408709,
-0.0442028753,
0.0212776605,
2.581e-7,
0.0622359961,
0.0489429757,
0.0142891277,
0.0263758302,
-0.0054686037,
0.027607115,
-0.0353956819,
0.0018604822,
0.0124969995,
0.0258036498,
0.0338489562,
0.0309060216,
0.0767092034,
0.0142402956,
-0.0477224141,
-0.0255799536,
-0.022401657,
0.0361930057,
-0.0360292643,
-0.0320197903,
0.0085504474,
0.1294054091,
-0.0067499862,
-0.0045201341,
0.0275671091,
-0.0101772845,
0.0556149483,
-0.0126049444,
0.0016385403,
0.0277891178,
-0.0062437705,
0.0340259522,
-0.0467209183,
-0.029644357,
-0.0314137973,
0.0188154057,
0.009036825,
0.0821244866,
0.0049978145,
0.0036537198,
0.0340866372,
-0.0532696918,
-0.0224133674,
-0.044938419,
0.047153566,
-0.064079307,
0.0065578711,
-0.0016581954,
-0.0156315826,
0.0359564722,
-0.0041659647,
-0.0596587658,
-0.030880468,
0.049664095,
0.0620464161,
-0.0052348701,
-0.046258904,
-0.0622909665,
-0.0372633189,
0.0002208779,
-0.0108947447,
-0.048269432,
-0.0313108005,
-0.0075229718,
-0.006549167,
-0.0465357788,
0.0047463374,
2.529997895e-34,
0.0439817496,
-0.0123117073,
0.0163936671,
-0.0144849643,
0.0410493501,
-0.0382904261,
-0.0189009253,
-0.0015391527,
-0.0060142991,
-0.0639382973,
-0.0334442295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06694v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06694v3 | Which One? Leveraging Context Between Objects and Multiple Views for Language Grounding | 2023-11-12T00:21:58 | 2024-04-06T22:14:25 | Chancharik Mitra, Abrar Anwar, Rodolfo Corona, Dan Klein, Trevor Darrell, Jesse Thomason | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.RO | When connecting objects and their language referents in an embodied 3D
environment, it is important to note that: (1) an object can be better
characterized by leveraging comparative information between itself and other
objects, and (2) an object's appearance can vary with camera position. As such,
we present the Multi-view Approach to Grounding in Context (MAGiC), which
selects an object referent based on language that distinguishes between two
similar objects. By pragmatically reasoning over both objects and across
multiple views of those objects, MAGiC improves over the state-of-the-art model
on the SNARE object reference task with a relative error reduction of 12.9\%
(representing an absolute improvement of 2.7\%). Ablation studies show that
reasoning jointly over object referent candidates and multiple views of each
object both contribute to improved accuracy. Code:
https://github.com/rcorona/magic_snare/ | [
0.041484762,
0.0136656826,
0.0295426082,
0.0199903082,
-0.0159320869,
-0.0082030417,
0.0649071112,
-0.0384603292,
-0.0252260715,
-0.0421037115,
-0.0600064993,
0.0167659726,
0.0477489829,
-0.0112497965,
0.0332755148,
-0.044265002,
0.0338271372,
0.0071719862,
-0.0719610453,
-0.0221339241,
-0.0010768087,
0.0343045704,
-0.0351254754,
0.0459508076,
-0.0647788569,
0.0431263559,
-0.0323779956,
0.0288790856,
0.0210545845,
-0.0683614165,
0.0029017238,
0.0504960828,
0.0455098078,
0.0084195072,
0.0000022266,
-0.0459547676,
-0.0029044412,
-0.0133294696,
0.0305238888,
-0.0172451232,
0.0090978146,
-0.0212319884,
-0.0004253604,
0.0079978891,
-0.0249023642,
-0.0130500309,
0.121478416,
0.0768712983,
0.0107813459,
-0.0021326647,
-0.0209871475,
-0.0322759859,
-0.0183710977,
0.0033554367,
0.0759612694,
-0.0390635766,
0.0029751917,
0.060734462,
0.0105344635,
-0.0170495305,
-0.048924569,
0.0122823678,
0.0353829116,
-0.0003021406,
0.0466214269,
0.0431007408,
-0.0273463856,
-0.0319403261,
0.0030871523,
0.0880966783,
-0.0004684696,
-0.0348279439,
-0.0216637086,
0.0256579984,
0.004481466,
0.0330960341,
-0.0039003522,
-0.0000042281,
-0.0077432501,
0.0156144202,
-0.07264819,
0.0337213203,
-0.0021762955,
0.0137029644,
-0.0213018302,
0.0214771964,
-0.0019169378,
0.0225917175,
0.0492881425,
0.0332709625,
0.0220748391,
-0.065830797,
0.0319075882,
0.0039300788,
-0.0462624766,
-0.0327874087,
-0.0376145877,
0.0119477781,
-0.0187278595,
-0.0478504188,
0.022942856,
0.0436044298,
-0.0465087816,
0.0449232124,
-0.0480045192,
0.0611061268,
-0.0416660458,
-0.0021283014,
-0.0226885732,
-0.0015424698,
-0.0397068784,
0.0030941265,
-0.0519925728,
0.027076304,
-0.0632038042,
-0.0519911647,
-0.0070064012,
-0.0352295749,
-0.0664893836,
-0.0314299762,
-0.0701355189,
0.0573220588,
-0.0226720758,
0.0249523763,
-0.0028395578,
0.0167616028,
-0.0232090894,
0.0611366965,
-0.0347196423,
-0.0473261625,
-0.0222622659,
0.0184459928,
0.0063361092,
-0.0167414118,
-0.0163217131,
0.0459044352,
-0.0277239699,
-0.0264133532,
0.0098691229,
-0.0058678933,
-0.0018213858,
-0.0330341458,
0.0364876501,
-0.0733494684,
-0.0133427968,
-0.036259748,
0.0016601024,
-0.0720582157,
0.0357647575,
0.0000496918,
0.0164636038,
0.071762383,
-0.0249775704,
-0.0091874013,
-0.0100218439,
0.0152759999,
0.035300523,
0.053522639,
-0.0099960221,
0.0067735077,
-0.0365897417,
-0.0025979597,
0.0027830845,
-0.001900139,
-0.0210536625,
-0.0095165996,
-0.0458377004,
-0.0484151207,
-0.0121713486,
0.0261795446,
-0.0023087033,
0.0201532207,
-0.0372761525,
0.0005416159,
0.0434957109,
0.029862335,
-0.0997697785,
-0.0080484962,
0.02224629,
-0.0291715357,
-0.0244075973,
0.0033615753,
-0.0599492267,
0.0923447609,
-0.0025410473,
-0.0127286166,
-0.0520513915,
0.018674897,
-0.0340678655,
-0.0222080871,
0.0016580214,
-0.0028861407,
0.0326943099,
0.0186206698,
0.0477307029,
0.0322611295,
0.0089828139,
0.080960393,
0.002075426,
-0.0460511297,
-0.0439424887,
0.0199208762,
-0.0145369275,
-0.0092225466,
-0.033654999,
-0.0034095417,
-0.0578108504,
-0.0011699818,
0.0568763725,
0.1132838354,
-0.0070783491,
0.014244861,
0.0219717305,
-0.0000288285,
-0.0480653457,
-0.0056045563,
0.0177888833,
0.0325396582,
0.0106386151,
0.0113134291,
0.0201876182,
0.0063961744,
0.0581279509,
0.0404852293,
-0.0152625684,
0.0572577231,
-0.0449184738,
0.0076315864,
0.0162037052,
0.0123094134,
-0.0254462194,
-0.0118047316,
0.0066812122,
-0.0050082286,
0.0334339961,
0.0429143012,
-0.0490841642,
0.017202748,
0.0504016876,
-0.0433899686,
-0.0147213116,
0.0031591901,
0.0166580845,
-0.0250458624,
0.0529057831,
0.0028146401,
0.0766084269,
-0.0156770144,
0.0048948526,
-0.0466313921,
-0.0021691341,
-0.0161194392,
0.0295465086,
-0.0183175914,
-0.0079659158,
-0.0159849394,
-0.0085775126,
0.0339514501,
-0.041360721,
0.014289693,
0.0620047674,
0.0073894123,
0.0089247813,
0.0100293607,
0.0449874289,
-0.0558625795,
0.0083221924,
-0.04452217,
-0.0665672421,
0.0060821846,
-0.0494127162,
-0.0082490891,
-0.0259574037,
0.0145429093,
-0.0216963924,
-0.0112935193,
0.0270728208,
-0.0292015895,
0.0041393512,
-0.0145362047,
-0.0117838141,
-0.029530324,
-0.0511184782,
0.024845589,
0.0105195232,
0.0392122008,
0.0583790615,
-0.0701131225,
-0.0501707494,
0.0339125209,
-0.0787568018,
0.0333901979,
0.0104706818,
-0.0120684216,
0.0285461023,
-0.0333070979,
0.001838989,
0.0780862868,
-0.0658235028,
0.0003664992,
0.0807482675,
-0.0224508792,
-0.0770094469,
-0.0196374878,
0.0298163462,
-0.0177570917,
-0.0260179322,
-0.0055928659,
0.0168106034,
0.0303829741,
-0.0197076164,
-0.002964593,
-0.0483139902,
0.0557232499,
-0.0033905865,
-0.0577659458,
-0.0175025556,
-0.0253640469,
0.0115207145,
0.0396708623,
-0.057101734,
-0.0071055102,
0.0282480866,
-0.060160134,
-0.0089429179,
0.0364821553,
0.0511650182,
0.0174987745,
0.0456531383,
0.0084401481,
0.0207504164,
-0.0196427945,
-0.0114635695,
0.0042853933,
0.0057986905,
-0.0005140876,
0.0293224379,
0.014557085,
-0.093044132,
0.0401802361,
-0.0047818185,
-0.0487303734,
-0.0060858666,
0.0775901377,
-0.0590318441,
0.0161814429,
-0.1039919853,
-0.0080949832,
-0.0659587607,
-0.0086053107,
0.0033975507,
0.0470259339,
-0.0188133996,
0.0090704821,
-0.031559255,
-0.0556360744,
0.0129612815,
0.0258223061,
-0.001709398,
-0.0138691338,
-0.001744009,
0.0531559512,
0.0207821354,
-0.003777894,
-0.0911989063,
0.0506290831,
0.0288561843,
0.0365619399,
-0.0151711535,
-0.0088611189,
0.037443731,
-0.0207481608,
-0.033430621,
0.0821143314,
-0.0010397459,
-0.0496720709,
-0.0122096296,
-0.0505953729,
0.0057147881,
0.0398468636,
-0.0203181971,
-0.0251719262,
-0.0451406129,
0.0253835917,
-0.0294830427,
0.0908279642,
-0.0568888076,
0.0140118785,
-0.1052960828,
0.0090496,
0.0010339491,
-0.0958350599,
-0.1208527088,
0.014408933,
0.0565521047,
-0.01029047,
-0.0047099018,
0.0297706649,
-0.0168717243,
0.0265547279,
0.0135088563,
0.0472421609,
-0.0145974923,
-0.0027419822,
-0.0302830432,
0.0086310422,
0.0397168696,
0.0274223853,
-0.009340114,
-0.0272778422,
0.0338817872,
0.0288350303,
0.0079305973,
-0.049562417,
-0.0007609369,
0.0114819417,
-0.0172629431,
0.0172127709,
0.0199216753,
0.0107061146,
-0.037663687,
-0.0525154956,
0.0240481719,
-0.0093292287,
0.0474109687,
-0.00558186,
0.0240435116,
-0.000265608,
0.0269407909,
0.0366438292,
-0.0118598016,
-0.0413199477,
-0.0047741863,
0.038490586,
0.0319527909,
-0.0651611611,
-0.0107772602,
-0.0629868358,
-0.044172205,
-0.0899727941,
0.0262004957,
0.0720768496,
0.0597431064,
0.0230344441,
-0.0217002872,
0.0048317886,
0.0063451207,
-0.0120704705,
0.042419944,
0.0030955179,
0.003523224,
-0.0084642619,
0.020094227,
0.0224384889,
-0.0391036049,
-0.0154891731,
0.0001725483,
0.0159645844,
-0.0281148944,
0.0212347023,
0.0325492546,
0.0310582928,
0.0326536298,
-0.0039900932,
-0.0037179668,
-0.0468245223,
0.0001105287,
0.0081368526,
0.0697286278,
-0.0026835231,
0.0098188343,
0.003566979,
0.0192735679,
-0.0550689027,
0.0581688285,
0.0193647817,
-0.0089383591,
-0.0231917426,
-0.0371514894,
-0.0106973872,
0.0007179574,
0.0804993585,
0.0065108393,
0.0409841463,
-0.0365196727,
0.00962858,
0.0124561004,
0.0010200876,
-0.0775174871,
0.0229877811,
0.0066136643,
0.0186481345,
0.0466588475,
0.0112288762,
0.0200096704,
0.0659852773,
0.0312639847,
-0.023492733,
0.0101906704,
-0.004399017,
-0.0213712007,
0.0212124903,
-0.0159849711,
0.0000216125,
-0.0253286529,
0.0664318055,
-0.0303393956,
0.0425516218,
0.0240271352,
-0.0259685479,
-0.0350080281,
0.0199997425,
0.0140823526,
-0.0210636444,
-0.0051432922,
0.0121147688,
0.0617705807,
-0.0361496881,
0.0602928251,
-0.0071643912,
-0.0083760088,
0.019700665,
0.0595190227,
0.0176686943,
-0.064654842,
0.009992999,
0.0025762457,
0.0212478358,
-0.005981179,
0.0241300054,
0.0104572382,
0.0341355763,
0.0020847993,
-0.0173164774,
-0.0113520259,
-0.0239251032,
-0.0141887879,
-0.0008726306,
0.0249559507,
0.0261459146,
-0.033640638,
-0.0546027757,
-0.0083989715,
0.037479911,
-0.0264310054,
0.0151641266,
0.068904154,
0.0161614735,
0.0317028984,
-0.0423536748,
0.0387952253,
-0.0436900333,
0.005751756,
-0.0132996188,
-0.0278675798,
-5.525340666e-33,
-0.0711123571,
-0.0200481098,
-0.0173695516,
-0.0095667178,
-0.0495839231,
0.0195621327,
-0.0497946851,
0.0253107641,
-0.0129988361,
0.0241578706,
0.04646549,
-0.0187844578,
0.0114987893,
-0.0004884552,
0.0113049904,
0.0182704348,
0.0131765567,
0.028290011,
0.0133326584,
-0.0212059356,
0.0439577028,
0.0050127376,
0.0853666663,
-0.0907938108,
-0.0164354146,
0.0601985455,
-0.0016537824,
0.0234788526,
-0.0436084419,
0.0205269195,
-0.0114960019,
-0.0004817446,
-0.0171141922,
-0.0008599893,
-0.0051159961,
0.0071489275,
-0.0809540302,
-0.0786006153,
-0.0025628086,
0.0200599898,
-0.0178167261,
0.0000539052,
0.0160601288,
-0.044141721,
-0.0361885726,
-0.0045637153,
0.0267674718,
-0.0603044182,
-0.0279440563,
0.0152187832,
-0.0544146001,
-0.0166388564,
-0.0156552102,
-0.0229870416,
0.0506792292,
0.0192723125,
-0.0075930911,
-0.0114784017,
-0.0384552628,
0.0128124217,
-0.0740609393,
-0.0047025802,
0.032806702,
0.0587941892,
0.0260710754,
0.116864264,
0.0785672441,
-0.0667450726,
-0.0409109816,
-0.019260291,
0.0385125019,
0.0729893893,
0.0618672036,
0.0464566611,
0.0043709665,
0.0295170043,
-0.0592980273,
0.0259246845,
-0.0452880487,
0.08730115,
0.0180544108,
0.0178670716,
-0.0023364821,
-0.011507662,
-0.0267308969,
-0.0067443955,
0.0044124736,
-0.0211888328,
0.0227228664,
-0.0075190254,
-0.015212236,
0.0064879702,
0.0504042469,
0.0023810398,
-0.0096033979,
0.0137197236,
-0.0016005421,
0.037101008,
-0.0025351478,
-0.043708466,
-0.0341449454,
0.0000481144,
0.039997261,
0.0002380579,
0.0681652948,
0.0009883291,
0.0141721275,
-0.0130913118,
-0.0476969667,
-0.001312622,
-0.0306897722,
-0.0117319515,
0.0254181009,
-0.0028035196,
0.045480106,
0.0040492392,
-0.0263870154,
0.0148691004,
0.0144492127,
-0.0408448502,
-0.0301855132,
0.0047874497,
-0.0578585006,
0.0357281193,
-0.0509524271,
0.0020662742,
-0.039380759,
-0.0197057407,
0.0580121428,
-0.0620392822,
-0.0201431904,
0.0309639946,
2.888e-7,
0.0091369385,
-0.0004827396,
0.0248774476,
0.0187816862,
0.0045642243,
0.0309716836,
-0.0104018534,
0.0444357879,
-0.0002846211,
-0.0683137625,
-0.0518176109,
0.0549151786,
0.0217966735,
-0.0072694132,
-0.0647234246,
0.0581866577,
-0.0173723493,
0.0055928691,
-0.0387561917,
-0.0052381996,
-0.0306073893,
0.005557328,
0.0201592036,
-0.0169988126,
-0.0007860547,
-0.0116400328,
0.0198345874,
-0.0715016127,
0.0632414222,
-0.013012304,
0.0254815016,
0.0025139016,
-0.0046815798,
0.0289033391,
0.0202768855,
-0.0010160285,
0.02933437,
-0.0208540335,
-0.0731196254,
0.0240936652,
-0.0203009453,
0.0300818533,
-0.0064228722,
-0.0130164903,
0.0793481842,
-0.0147318412,
0.0104671754,
0.0342995003,
-0.0190384202,
0.0002086717,
0.0102535449,
0.011709515,
-0.0366597176,
-0.0089636436,
-0.007075524,
-0.0163726229,
-0.0436110348,
-0.033124309,
-0.0051870248,
-0.0023031125,
-0.0298182312,
-0.0009923441,
0.0351325795,
-0.0733816028,
-0.0226243064,
-0.0368777774,
-0.0471342951,
2.283209973e-34,
-0.0156869888,
0.0342627466,
0.0352504775,
0.0451026894,
0.0257943235,
0.0144515969,
0.0263436437,
0.029008925,
-0.0222371817,
0.0120067699,
0.0032653234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06668v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06668v3 | In-context Vectors: Making In Context Learning More Effective and Controllable Through Latent Space Steering | 2023-11-11T21:19:44 | 2024-02-13T22:37:39 | Sheng Liu, Haotian Ye, Lei Xing, James Zou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate emergent in-context learning
capabilities, where they adapt to new tasks based on example demonstrations.
However, in-context learning has seen limited effectiveness in many settings,
is difficult to quantitatively control and takes up context window space. To
overcome these limitations, we propose an alternative approach that recasts
in-context learning as in-context vectors (ICV). Using ICV has two steps. We
first use a forward pass on demonstration examples to create the in-context
vector from the latent embedding of the LLM. This vector captures essential
information about the intended task. On a new query, instead of adding
demonstrations to the prompt, we shift the latent states of the LLM using the
ICV. The ICV approach has several benefits: 1) it enables the LLM to more
effectively follow the demonstration examples; 2) it's easy to control by
adjusting the magnitude of the ICV; 3) it reduces the length of the prompt by
removing the in-context demonstrations; 4) ICV is computationally much more
efficient than fine-tuning. We demonstrate that ICV achieves better performance
compared to standard in-context learning and fine-tuning on diverse tasks
including safety, style transfer, role-playing and formatting. Moreover, we
show that we can flexibly teach LLM to simultaneously follow different types of
instructions by simple vector arithmetics on the corresponding ICVs. | [
0.0219880678,
0.0298872199,
-0.0118427183,
0.0299048889,
-0.0064516724,
0.0199028198,
-0.0006869803,
-0.0130614853,
-0.0395713821,
-0.0194854047,
-0.0423598401,
-0.0615428165,
-0.0156778209,
0.018729344,
0.0642920136,
-0.0723258555,
0.042554345,
-0.0564590879,
0.0048859916,
0.0076506222,
0.0128256148,
-0.0192538649,
-0.0421010256,
0.0542731285,
-0.0062408368,
-0.0271326676,
-0.0242684297,
0.014641216,
0.0071943272,
-0.0382107273,
0.0362792388,
0.0388623551,
0.0861476734,
0.0090575824,
0.0000019467,
-0.0028378994,
0.0140489647,
-0.0287778489,
0.0024699864,
0.0219378434,
0.0508960858,
0.0178122241,
-0.0357898809,
0.0458893813,
-0.0500381216,
-0.0265046582,
0.0338871107,
0.0218976494,
0.0544959046,
0.0795670375,
-0.0007508118,
-0.0032796406,
-0.0055329395,
-0.0393647589,
0.03890853,
-0.0527870543,
0.0103837652,
-0.0280273464,
0.0271691699,
0.0121420808,
-0.04961906,
0.0533412397,
0.0309215542,
-0.0483089797,
-0.0228519347,
0.0547045209,
-0.0097771697,
0.0067993505,
-0.0323748365,
0.0680341795,
-0.0339375846,
-0.021805821,
0.0132045392,
-0.0107155275,
0.0103311976,
-0.0028978453,
-0.091217041,
0.0099670691,
0.0367010012,
0.0077744513,
-0.0054828594,
-0.0014449037,
0.0252904911,
-0.0042938013,
0.0099784611,
0.0170859806,
0.0025268376,
-0.0437671691,
-0.0385570787,
-0.0214852449,
-0.0489842631,
-0.0505705401,
0.0015435084,
0.040129032,
-0.076601781,
0.0442272015,
-0.0546000786,
-0.033301644,
-0.0050890734,
-0.0407399461,
0.0605703257,
0.0353856832,
0.0060682786,
0.0446731932,
-0.0125835305,
0.0640027672,
-0.0289324522,
0.0561311282,
-0.0296610929,
0.0357280858,
-0.0404937677,
-0.021548111,
-0.0441644751,
-0.003956696,
-0.0145189548,
-0.044458475,
0.0047638086,
0.0731161907,
-0.0266485233,
0.0226904247,
-0.001928572,
0.0178404693,
-0.03866788,
0.0255761556,
0.0122012831,
0.0165091306,
-0.0170661416,
0.0225241259,
0.0267709568,
-0.0094064418,
-0.0319072455,
0.016004933,
0.0206496846,
-0.0088248793,
-0.0171029363,
0.0402482785,
-0.0474237166,
-0.0455856808,
-0.0072510219,
0.0081482725,
-0.0068410551,
-0.0347422883,
0.0260029566,
-0.0480425656,
0.0099098617,
0.0090877106,
-0.0060066916,
-0.0263131149,
0.0052096383,
0.0453468151,
0.0031129273,
0.0557610206,
0.0390380695,
0.0298159719,
0.0415421128,
0.0205533002,
-0.0111509226,
0.0681891069,
0.0526133813,
0.0140256323,
0.0121578369,
0.0167282615,
0.0213142224,
0.0393739901,
0.0349232145,
0.0350983329,
-0.0457717367,
-0.003083288,
0.033615347,
0.0553346761,
0.0306151491,
0.0485037714,
-0.0356130637,
0.0234451573,
0.0691518486,
0.0329497904,
0.0330174491,
-0.0283921603,
0.0733523741,
0.0172380991,
-0.0050392211,
-0.0073670992,
-0.0850040764,
0.0418194644,
0.0055216351,
0.0111733936,
0.0126695279,
-0.0069180606,
-0.0411555953,
-0.0245273281,
0.0009567746,
0.0061890204,
0.0027228037,
-0.0004932487,
0.0229821447,
0.0430194698,
-0.0627185255,
-0.0118510686,
0.0204793159,
-0.0479061715,
0.0217665192,
-0.0507455245,
0.0449819937,
0.0576969348,
0.0460396186,
-0.0409388505,
-0.0441367477,
-0.0325054936,
0.0666045472,
0.0312528014,
0.0235067122,
-0.0501582175,
-0.0047315462,
-0.0380329117,
-0.0246582925,
-0.0153670199,
0.0161310565,
-0.0202536564,
0.038467858,
-0.0074061509,
-0.0095208939,
-0.0270992611,
0.0126261832,
0.0487978496,
-0.0581323877,
-0.0476184972,
-0.0403359309,
0.0056661963,
0.0161616411,
-0.0014733393,
0.009559175,
0.0028737606,
0.0433742814,
-0.0297041088,
0.0162396915,
0.0228669569,
-0.1005311161,
-0.0645969287,
0.0103944745,
-0.0015683929,
0.0080836881,
-0.0038269488,
-0.0439780988,
-0.0163521878,
-0.0093193687,
-0.0197612103,
0.0582002327,
-0.0276475139,
0.0006791642,
-0.0097937826,
-0.0345267318,
-0.018136492,
0.0560657755,
-0.0120279472,
-0.0119702946,
0.0668255687,
0.0601470731,
-0.0593638197,
-0.0155315856,
-0.0050105792,
-0.0013764692,
0.003145962,
0.027837012,
-0.0058855852,
0.035693679,
-0.0335872583,
-0.0148500074,
-0.0615535267,
0.0128505016,
-0.0545726493,
0.002424211,
0.0356511548,
0.0074290838,
-0.0179466959,
-0.0122653116,
-0.0316971689,
-0.0187858399,
-0.0171185881,
0.0180681609,
0.0122637255,
0.0377986282,
-0.0056188516,
-0.0354540311,
-0.0012951972,
-0.0195570681,
0.0270007811,
-0.0348917954,
0.016229691,
-0.0533355474,
0.0355834253,
0.0272602979,
0.0424507447,
-0.0445467196,
-0.0030181701,
0.0317453071,
-0.0392578244,
0.0509785078,
0.0649909526,
0.0243979264,
0.0468536653,
0.0459658392,
-0.0034295027,
-0.0710980594,
0.0289029274,
-0.0249963272,
-0.0131743047,
-0.0490799434,
0.0353802554,
0.0032821053,
0.0519245714,
-0.0055295164,
0.0079648504,
-0.0896598846,
0.0021161085,
-0.0122983065,
-0.0444190875,
-0.0237420686,
-0.0291232597,
-0.0609046221,
-0.0115376972,
-0.0271882601,
-0.0407790542,
0.0623784326,
-0.0135347247,
-0.029566627,
-0.0145757142,
-0.0107051264,
-0.0152175277,
0.036195334,
-0.0062722093,
0.0053017759,
-0.0369903408,
-0.0506565161,
-0.0686403438,
0.0161896124,
0.0265548937,
-0.0225093327,
0.0670691431,
-0.0572422557,
-0.0017460748,
0.0097151501,
-0.041010879,
-0.0664403588,
-0.0297179483,
0.0204419587,
0.0163856037,
-0.0101796985,
-0.0211677533,
-0.00983073,
0.0019218789,
0.0501064099,
0.0701984912,
-0.0299286563,
-0.0067929435,
-0.0329021327,
-0.0005666438,
0.050194446,
0.0255361833,
-0.0294661056,
-0.0682910904,
0.0107222591,
0.0423870496,
0.0700587109,
-0.0519638285,
-0.011254875,
0.0100385044,
0.025109129,
-0.0187595207,
-0.0069508376,
0.0530322269,
0.0807319507,
-0.072050415,
-0.0580406189,
0.1010112986,
0.0251565501,
-0.0586267598,
0.0071357228,
0.023936579,
0.0296414196,
0.0297801308,
0.0351986736,
-0.0455325805,
-0.0202542115,
0.0215244032,
0.0394293815,
0.0392579883,
-0.0042831032,
-0.014495627,
-0.1006872058,
0.0207786039,
0.0176399853,
-0.0786476433,
-0.0329765789,
-0.0297091734,
0.0214612409,
-0.0038190936,
0.0488558486,
0.0354924425,
-0.0407168791,
0.0100286715,
0.0252268519,
0.0353569463,
-0.1014010683,
-0.003950973,
-0.0339260101,
0.066115424,
0.0575264059,
0.0109534785,
0.0146926725,
-0.0558586083,
0.0158831496,
-0.0213927981,
0.0136793107,
-0.0318939202,
0.0288777258,
-0.0315520391,
0.0137757389,
0.0133402683,
0.0611001626,
0.0014778593,
-0.0379370749,
-0.0111063579,
0.069539398,
-0.0143412091,
-0.0077517899,
-0.0213670861,
-0.0290321559,
0.0521743409,
0.0522897802,
0.0494422354,
-0.0635848939,
-0.0184909999,
-0.0264650006,
-0.0166561045,
-0.0055127046,
-0.0068036965,
-0.0379850157,
0.0111105246,
-0.0029684114,
-0.0655261204,
-0.0059811808,
0.0589638688,
0.0688127801,
0.0063972026,
0.0000974395,
-0.0232727006,
-0.0137623828,
-0.0474037044,
-0.0074248267,
-0.0345808193,
0.035246484,
-0.0538888313,
-0.0058965953,
0.037111938,
-0.0393860899,
-0.0131219635,
-0.0060319901,
-0.0632124469,
-0.0846356153,
0.0098448005,
0.065704748,
0.0129615376,
0.0562659651,
-0.0093552116,
-0.0649216846,
0.0837945417,
0.0388469584,
-0.0312134326,
0.025832504,
0.0197895244,
0.0173037983,
0.0138093736,
0.0313562714,
-0.0549078993,
-0.0223029666,
0.0136712594,
0.0645605996,
-0.0321546458,
0.0028495542,
0.0160750151,
-0.0529686287,
0.0415724479,
-0.0204016548,
0.002522239,
-0.0613534488,
0.0114015518,
-0.0002582108,
-0.0059122262,
-0.0444261394,
0.0079373932,
-0.0049228491,
0.0215468556,
-0.0157912485,
0.0138378637,
0.0174516067,
0.0182076413,
-0.0658954307,
0.0264494363,
0.0275227111,
0.0109323822,
0.0431075469,
0.0513707511,
0.0046815858,
0.0043027475,
-0.0070983595,
0.0197792258,
-0.0104771145,
0.0604947619,
0.052045133,
-0.019307334,
-0.0123167587,
0.0435209461,
-0.0910895094,
-0.0075553712,
-0.0376225077,
0.0317435153,
0.0465291664,
-0.0103052892,
0.0292205531,
-0.0217899121,
0.0094383005,
-0.0040589827,
0.0084577342,
-0.0076443567,
-0.0662965402,
0.0441890061,
0.0409875698,
0.0296281595,
0.0003330625,
0.0668949559,
-0.0007860285,
0.0553415231,
-0.020727003,
0.0468536131,
-0.0358881615,
-0.004327313,
0.0697578862,
0.0380749777,
-0.0361555777,
0.0163898505,
-0.0219507031,
-0.0516556278,
-0.023142701,
0.0184212774,
-0.0454558916,
-0.0265780389,
0.0414278433,
0.0397601686,
-0.0133742094,
-0.043028608,
-0.0309220664,
-0.0221246723,
0.0191347729,
-0.0387513191,
-0.0291715153,
-6.175016558e-33,
-0.0364120565,
-0.0328634866,
0.0462691337,
0.0219958033,
-0.0326150581,
-0.0183590762,
-0.056584619,
0.0030116613,
0.0084324433,
-0.0016307433,
-0.0474329218,
0.0163481347,
-0.0007563677,
0.0257068444,
0.0180644821,
-0.0283416193,
0.0534199588,
-0.019914072,
-0.0309804864,
0.0468377694,
0.0059739728,
0.0291781854,
0.0454617925,
-0.0745368004,
0.0205243435,
-0.007409866,
-0.027070526,
0.0372816697,
-0.023827618,
0.0516344421,
0.0098530054,
0.0214240067,
0.0006355474,
-0.0442987755,
-0.0405343845,
0.0334861353,
-0.0697003826,
-0.0296799745,
0.0014152576,
0.0008517801,
-0.0597390905,
-0.0133520076,
0.0501012579,
-0.026232155,
0.0008056436,
0.0052267099,
0.032938607,
0.0012652545,
-0.021760406,
-0.0353253707,
-0.064272359,
0.0039617638,
0.01651638,
-0.0450689159,
0.028473787,
0.019514218,
0.0015533858,
-0.0206076633,
-0.0710204095,
0.0330733135,
-0.0130946161,
0.0210071094,
0.0624968819,
0.0518859811,
0.0093313362,
0.0401812084,
-0.0137470458,
0.0044942871,
0.0019388977,
-0.034452308,
0.072836861,
0.0227095578,
0.0060930159,
0.0105898101,
0.0200708043,
-0.0022771861,
-0.0138179781,
0.0118860789,
0.0139004756,
0.0373947062,
0.0135792214,
0.0420769677,
-0.0380953439,
-0.0186932683,
-0.0463951156,
0.0090409471,
-0.0063801226,
-0.0224052891,
0.0580577143,
0.0491347164,
-0.0184268393,
-0.0217623245,
0.0309904665,
-0.0259364806,
-0.0383384824,
0.0160393324,
-0.0058455761,
0.0441585407,
-0.0067930818,
0.0104562547,
-0.0798650905,
-0.0377507396,
0.0445120148,
-0.0152732767,
-0.0018490173,
0.0027176198,
0.034555681,
0.085023731,
-0.0658867359,
-0.0114009343,
-0.026563108,
0.0311233122,
0.0255272184,
-0.0134665901,
0.0369054005,
-0.0146426028,
-0.0220897496,
0.0401156582,
0.0151044754,
-0.0698878318,
-0.0238881018,
-0.021145178,
-0.0310644731,
0.0105256103,
-0.0556627996,
-0.0040664994,
-0.0299894754,
0.059491422,
0.0378334299,
-0.06571839,
-0.0160313156,
0.0319145136,
2.612e-7,
0.0175492577,
0.0573007539,
0.0001214188,
0.0236181766,
0.0269329343,
0.0296417307,
-0.0381888114,
0.0297161732,
0.0151736755,
-0.0052199815,
0.0288044289,
0.0569611229,
0.0343497097,
0.0022848332,
-0.0926324874,
0.0038734968,
-0.0589650944,
0.0321614146,
-0.0189751107,
-0.0123632848,
0.0272442233,
0.066700615,
0.0170330945,
0.0098885298,
0.0191015806,
-0.031756267,
0.0502205454,
-0.010498425,
0.0360461771,
-0.0001747143,
-0.0420268215,
0.0265495628,
-0.0062307594,
-0.007871937,
-0.0245112237,
0.0272573195,
-0.0069738887,
0.0753290951,
-0.0003939934,
-0.0076025845,
0.0020629475,
0.0044335853,
0.0013192672,
-0.0607743561,
0.0637186617,
-0.0802040994,
0.0214614309,
-0.0297646355,
0.0224736072,
-0.0246738587,
-0.0070202583,
-0.0057082837,
-0.029771626,
-0.0022870426,
0.0178059097,
0.0109909596,
-0.0080898991,
-0.0898086056,
-0.0323851034,
0.0108173732,
-0.0499731377,
-0.0251770858,
-0.0582706966,
0.0339657478,
-0.0209225137,
-0.0218204726,
0.0005871873,
2.572201126e-34,
0.0085113021,
-0.0351876877,
0.0101808086,
0.0295833033,
-0.0110694142,
0.0074306992,
0.0284036547,
0.0225739162,
0.0690575764,
-0.0600633733,
-0.0484233908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07611v1 | Intentional Biases in LLM Responses | 2023-11-11T19:59:24 | 2023-11-11T19:59:24 | Nicklaus Badyal, Derek Jacoby, Yvonne Coady | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study we intentionally introduce biases into large language model
responses in an attempt to create specific personas for interactive media
purposes. We explore the differences between open source models such as
Falcon-7b and the GPT-4 model from Open AI, and we quantify some differences in
responses afforded by the two systems. We find that the guardrails in the GPT-4
mixture of experts models with a supervisor, while useful in assuring AI
alignment in general, are detrimental in trying to construct personas with a
variety of uncommon viewpoints. This study aims to set the groundwork for
future exploration in intentional biases of large language models such that
these practices can be applied in the creative field, and new forms of media. | [
0.0457973443,
0.0318449996,
-0.0367455855,
0.0241220612,
-0.0280597433,
-0.009702676,
0.0463782996,
-0.0015031057,
0.0128290476,
-0.0070166495,
-0.0478395969,
-0.0200004149,
-0.0312072914,
0.0319670551,
0.0128134396,
-0.0552371778,
0.0137470663,
-0.018773105,
0.0633115321,
-0.0423638299,
-0.0015875662,
0.0605305061,
-0.0275644381,
0.0534077883,
-0.0071519944,
-0.0324543193,
0.0200142115,
0.0274315998,
0.0421491973,
-0.0123001356,
-0.0058184671,
0.0360921323,
0.0422303192,
0.0074062166,
0.0000019201,
-0.0762999654,
0.0133893769,
-0.0305027626,
0.0082461378,
-0.0149437906,
0.0202380493,
0.0398542881,
-0.0157570336,
-0.0087833479,
-0.0461181067,
0.0449669249,
0.0524452329,
0.0318002477,
0.051741153,
0.072914958,
-0.0028927389,
-0.0312954262,
0.0159197524,
-0.0009806709,
0.0226509105,
-0.0268300455,
-0.0090436786,
-0.0167024024,
0.0149300136,
-0.0246687252,
-0.0116038918,
0.0101677235,
0.0038811737,
0.0012867842,
0.0359032825,
0.0185311362,
0.0031447913,
-0.0479236953,
0.0009806692,
0.0613293089,
0.0614913069,
0.014243261,
-0.0173109919,
-0.0057627377,
0.0399301052,
0.0322651528,
-0.0466653258,
0.0401001088,
0.0038627833,
0.0005057157,
-0.0120082656,
-0.0025938973,
0.0018539053,
0.0086960718,
-0.0048833448,
0.0662942529,
0.0446922928,
-0.0176914167,
-0.0167337451,
0.0034767811,
0.0057646213,
-0.0801476389,
-0.0266296975,
0.0392336287,
-0.0177436434,
0.0231278054,
-0.0360721797,
0.0389198512,
-0.0170155689,
-0.0272339731,
0.0559151247,
0.0542601608,
0.0066947048,
0.0369023532,
0.0284328647,
0.0426091664,
-0.0318097435,
0.0061640292,
0.0158816352,
0.0345895141,
-0.029313663,
-0.0347013436,
-0.0006857902,
0.018893972,
-0.0098966779,
-0.0191843864,
-0.0247462559,
0.034240108,
-0.0528566167,
0.0204558391,
-0.0090295253,
0.022266021,
-0.021748824,
-0.0271787401,
-0.079735443,
0.0523319133,
-0.0538613573,
0.0370171815,
-0.0234222189,
-0.0574958548,
0.0087763956,
0.023925025,
-0.0225987993,
-0.0372782908,
0.0049808375,
0.0726899058,
0.0186508298,
-0.0099850968,
-0.0095673008,
-0.0288374126,
0.010085973,
-0.0604040623,
-0.0065461588,
-0.0542685948,
0.0344105288,
0.0095733562,
0.0091422396,
-0.0757640898,
-0.0221126527,
0.0003585534,
-0.0257055555,
0.0259462018,
-0.0213523954,
0.0562252179,
0.0296717603,
0.027472036,
-0.0287452508,
0.0536146089,
0.0358193219,
-0.0036051967,
0.0195804462,
-0.0165075045,
0.0517817587,
0.0458962731,
-0.0472338982,
0.0086296406,
-0.0502954908,
0.0120618483,
-0.0275242198,
0.0614620149,
0.0741551593,
0.0428297184,
-0.0265951045,
0.0162570905,
0.0946173966,
0.0323669314,
0.0022586235,
0.0211094953,
0.039033059,
0.0098438524,
0.0348655619,
0.0411627479,
-0.0307854284,
0.056319695,
0.0107248183,
-0.0002728301,
-0.0085419696,
0.041118402,
-0.0260502845,
-0.0165447965,
0.0062691402,
0.0318716243,
-0.0272474121,
0.007424077,
-0.016162511,
-0.0063129119,
-0.0328137726,
0.023026621,
-0.0061307587,
-0.0694534928,
-0.0008395676,
-0.0326951258,
0.0490510054,
0.070226416,
0.0081394827,
-0.0091117052,
-0.0087727401,
-0.0167667996,
-0.01307684,
0.0849797651,
0.0670688078,
-0.0135055119,
-0.0336348712,
-0.0215659961,
-0.0001182344,
-0.0586054996,
0.0020184012,
0.061867658,
-0.0387761295,
0.0220805611,
-0.0325622521,
-0.0070635751,
0.0121619608,
0.0072395261,
-0.0547501072,
-0.044827383,
-0.062083099,
0.0105963163,
0.0401972122,
0.0480338857,
-0.0510126054,
0.0047169626,
0.0130938916,
0.0084526129,
-0.001191704,
0.0222977269,
-0.0233580768,
0.0450261571,
0.0474810377,
-0.0747531652,
-0.0020386856,
-0.0138991782,
0.029336717,
-0.031922169,
0.0346061476,
-0.018949993,
0.0711680055,
-0.019494364,
0.0282112733,
-0.0229740981,
0.0047263526,
-0.0406150296,
0.0450099483,
0.0138351433,
-0.0169563144,
0.0346744731,
-0.0039589289,
0.0038707266,
-0.0703980699,
-0.0016565928,
0.0363858193,
0.0321391188,
0.0168042723,
0.0194879919,
-0.0180490185,
-0.0692869648,
-0.0607799888,
-0.098721683,
0.0001545875,
-0.0010194303,
-0.0143147809,
0.0147067159,
-0.0125109795,
-0.0688351616,
0.0331934355,
-0.056521792,
-0.0512793697,
0.0050313491,
0.0160625782,
0.0177416969,
0.0045710006,
-0.0303237457,
-0.0081534674,
0.0137461592,
-0.0232452061,
0.0055475212,
0.0348879211,
0.0009183233,
-0.0468759798,
0.0125762466,
-0.0643591881,
-0.0115280468,
-0.0248114988,
-0.0206460692,
0.0508027934,
-0.0043968265,
0.0412687212,
0.021514127,
0.0081971893,
0.0506339036,
0.0556450561,
-0.0212971084,
-0.0615841262,
0.0150375674,
0.021273654,
-0.0168482587,
-0.0443040617,
-0.0473606363,
0.0069963587,
0.0081692934,
0.0195182152,
0.0171370469,
-0.0656137094,
0.1104759499,
0.0206567962,
-0.056111265,
0.068291001,
-0.0579488985,
-0.0408106782,
0.076986447,
-0.0006320933,
-0.0159820877,
0.0344852619,
-0.0309759323,
0.0039470643,
0.0111188767,
0.0112029873,
-0.0400550626,
0.0135396998,
-0.0284212418,
0.04034454,
-0.0069706813,
-0.008655766,
-0.1009594426,
0.0077610868,
0.0242402889,
-0.0394677892,
0.0324879624,
-0.01950307,
-0.0187664907,
-0.0031588429,
0.0008237706,
-0.0426174961,
0.0116808545,
-0.0302829538,
-0.0204537194,
0.0226320494,
-0.014123898,
-0.0338886641,
0.0080256891,
0.0256227385,
-0.0285329707,
-0.0195927583,
0.0110575231,
-0.0312288273,
-0.030982418,
0.0575423315,
0.0230273008,
-0.0114638992,
-0.0420430973,
0.0288563017,
-0.0067702495,
-0.0196755156,
-0.0171594955,
-0.0307311751,
0.0246006362,
0.0645490289,
-0.0242080502,
-0.0377060138,
0.0353721194,
0.0807397738,
-0.0333169214,
0.056284409,
0.1262489259,
-0.0001557472,
-0.0751412585,
-0.0177979637,
-0.0227387939,
-0.0026624913,
0.0290957652,
0.0236880798,
-0.0537036918,
0.0317564942,
-0.012712962,
0.0175914764,
-0.0268147476,
-0.0436139181,
-0.0204771906,
-0.1283413172,
0.0770610869,
0.0322130099,
-0.0105603002,
-0.0154221626,
0.0051542516,
0.0224163737,
-0.0018122443,
0.0188780036,
0.0034566312,
-0.0210450795,
0.0137280561,
-0.0009537289,
-0.0214167424,
-0.0248220079,
-0.0125352349,
-0.0508879274,
0.1096487194,
0.0422887579,
0.034943305,
-0.0250964649,
-0.0615337193,
-0.0163607132,
0.0296979435,
0.0309650972,
0.0170694347,
0.031317316,
-0.0280953515,
0.0151127912,
-0.0292103104,
-0.0051823906,
0.0136629045,
-0.008956003,
0.0103215706,
0.056561403,
-0.0313605964,
-0.023084471,
-0.0482607298,
0.0159897711,
0.0048469761,
0.0696113259,
0.0158734191,
-0.0694037229,
-0.0022330051,
-0.0110231107,
0.00941299,
-0.0022033835,
-0.0685679913,
0.003745365,
-0.0165846962,
-0.0251843762,
-0.0160949621,
-0.0519151501,
-0.0014395271,
0.0694497153,
0.0501059964,
0.0026207261,
-0.0488077216,
-0.0038295698,
0.023229273,
0.0328027867,
-0.0257196911,
0.0182067994,
-0.0402285308,
-0.0309048649,
-0.0148243317,
-0.0801358297,
0.026770765,
-0.0143724009,
-0.0293980557,
-0.0770155489,
0.0145805031,
0.0484328419,
0.0460760742,
0.0348949432,
0.0385663733,
-0.0706228614,
0.0493240096,
0.0065341932,
-0.0226293895,
0.0677063763,
-0.0109552518,
0.0535108708,
-0.0178003721,
0.0155284377,
-0.0436632112,
-0.0054078144,
0.038584426,
0.0477770567,
-0.0225391407,
-0.0918240994,
0.0105332509,
0.0262058973,
-0.005090449,
-0.0463386253,
0.0238871053,
-0.0460373685,
-0.0233820993,
-0.036894042,
-0.0146329841,
-0.022332307,
-0.0374110341,
0.0289363228,
0.0061479812,
0.0123066669,
-0.0070066126,
-0.0549782552,
0.0205570869,
-0.0451061837,
0.0128385648,
0.0066643073,
-0.0192499701,
-0.0062711756,
0.0167286508,
-0.0152615653,
0.0474499054,
-0.0236812942,
0.0397315025,
0.0572499521,
0.0726773217,
0.0115258116,
0.0115701361,
-0.0029841422,
0.0394251235,
-0.0449206829,
-0.0863455757,
0.0186519716,
0.024441611,
0.0473796763,
-0.0180216152,
0.041775059,
-0.0106074149,
0.0190721024,
0.0070337174,
-0.005409257,
0.0216945987,
-0.0129025346,
0.0328018852,
0.0186929964,
-0.0126738176,
-0.027357595,
0.0369673893,
-0.0350255482,
0.0206081811,
-0.0514268912,
-0.0124091916,
-0.0188899487,
-0.043920286,
0.0286195409,
-0.0011221524,
0.0181097351,
-0.0263473596,
-0.0929127783,
-0.0473571122,
0.0142952632,
-0.0202946588,
-0.0153900264,
-0.0453397706,
0.0050617694,
0.0590518229,
-0.0057151532,
-0.0248081516,
-0.0246406831,
-0.0244088098,
-0.0522943698,
-0.0018857061,
-0.013217194,
-6.008355703e-33,
-0.0466006733,
-0.0193678662,
0.0277704708,
-0.0199581515,
-0.0663521141,
-0.0419966057,
-0.0258173775,
0.0258078147,
-0.0149457045,
-0.0222786646,
-0.0267307833,
-0.0292522237,
0.0093195383,
-0.0484955497,
0.0132410079,
-0.0076690624,
0.0486835688,
0.0142634176,
-0.0578147806,
-0.0098168962,
-0.0039965897,
-0.0084218038,
0.0178040452,
-0.0982376263,
0.0353987664,
-0.0272917189,
-0.0301114358,
-0.0241857897,
0.0046773637,
0.0593179576,
0.0037605884,
0.0307378266,
0.0163074899,
0.0006546516,
0.0067979801,
0.0064181453,
0.0253637396,
-0.0385584086,
0.0524675362,
0.0196330138,
0.0200673267,
-0.0750116706,
0.0326789208,
-0.0060953647,
-0.0593959577,
-0.0053058863,
0.0564114973,
-0.0185127296,
0.0365346968,
0.0157033149,
-0.0755675361,
-0.0051281541,
-0.0347635821,
0.0286366101,
-0.0167984292,
-0.016287392,
0.0176399481,
0.0038913593,
-0.0474982709,
0.0350240767,
-0.0185447615,
-0.0292732678,
0.0730725974,
0.0353908911,
0.0118584717,
0.055130709,
0.0646916777,
0.0416070409,
-0.0729550719,
-0.0446381904,
-0.0037169138,
0.056527622,
0.0164766107,
0.0776974931,
-0.0235098228,
0.0116287107,
0.0195583701,
0.0222573392,
0.0171287432,
0.0135190524,
0.0319446288,
0.025232289,
-0.0425666012,
-0.0085818805,
-0.0134939402,
-0.0635960773,
-0.0140079036,
-0.0558152795,
0.0151214153,
-0.0356252417,
0.0141815133,
-0.0409193486,
0.0497946702,
-0.0434751846,
0.0269111395,
-0.021664761,
-0.0579324402,
0.0414009951,
0.005102348,
0.0108251823,
-0.0152976923,
0.0091218557,
0.0302445497,
0.0118619762,
0.043045871,
0.0371058881,
-0.0446327329,
0.0364187323,
-0.0529460162,
-0.0226405319,
-0.0170166008,
0.0061311862,
0.045979552,
0.0000429873,
0.0272505358,
-0.0168424863,
-0.0083204526,
-0.0149026886,
0.0157508813,
-0.0160717983,
-0.0301099867,
-0.0226504523,
-0.0596270785,
-0.0202443432,
-0.048691988,
0.0214440953,
0.0107442709,
0.0254885443,
0.0477302335,
-0.0545339696,
-0.0515218191,
-0.0146680865,
2.888e-7,
-0.0007802134,
0.010735875,
-0.0136149395,
0.0557386018,
0.0372907631,
0.0282766148,
-0.0205324143,
0.0368461423,
0.0312505849,
-0.0188546032,
0.0309255756,
0.0323518254,
0.0234664083,
0.034510728,
-0.0901802108,
0.0051122443,
-0.029454859,
0.0356405415,
-0.0609897561,
0.0309847593,
0.0714565441,
0.0150392363,
0.0314165615,
-0.0264347494,
-0.016677402,
-0.0150812715,
0.0326273441,
-0.0365089476,
0.0126107475,
0.0355680659,
0.0620328784,
-0.02471634,
-0.0053828089,
0.0452294722,
0.0268318709,
0.040194001,
0.0155271376,
0.0514583811,
-0.0203873403,
-0.0157278161,
0.0030796581,
0.0201195199,
0.0016935874,
-0.0613032505,
0.051492814,
0.0553055108,
-0.028084103,
-0.0065808655,
-0.0521106757,
-0.0470546633,
0.0237863101,
-0.034437038,
0.0039544357,
0.0186445378,
0.0074460669,
-0.0060261306,
-0.0187984165,
-0.05060241,
-0.0075878776,
-0.0180859137,
-0.0499487743,
-0.0696372166,
0.0098969014,
0.0173858553,
0.0300673004,
-0.0677353218,
0.0225099623,
2.468582907e-34,
-0.0097591132,
0.0128179472,
0.0155692967,
0.0234617908,
0.0468243919,
0.0374787003,
-0.0115211401,
0.022691926,
0.0255119354,
-0.0730228871,
-0.0171289667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06649v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06649v1 | A Template Is All You Meme | 2023-11-11T19:38:14 | 2023-11-11T19:38:14 | Luke Bates, Peter Ebert Christensen, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Memes are a modern form of communication and meme templates possess a base
semantics that is customizable by whomever posts it on social media. Machine
learning systems struggle with memes, which is likely due to such systems
having insufficient context to understand memes, as there is more to memes than
the obvious image and text. Here, to aid understanding of memes, we release a
knowledge base of memes and information found on www.knowyourmeme.com, which we
call the Know Your Meme Knowledge Base (KYMKB), composed of more than 54,000
images. The KYMKB includes popular meme templates, examples of each template,
and detailed information about the template. We hypothesize that meme templates
can be used to inject models with the context missing from previous approaches.
To test our hypothesis, we create a non-parametric majority-based classifier,
which we call Template-Label Counter (TLC). We find TLC more effective than or
competitive with fine-tuned baselines. To demonstrate the power of meme
templates and the value of both our knowledge base and method, we conduct
thorough classification experiments and exploratory data analysis in the
context of five meme analysis tasks. | [
0.0513054319,
0.0339693464,
-0.0236962829,
-0.0083927475,
0.0145879826,
0.0449946858,
-0.0265369955,
0.0214673448,
0.0138204945,
-0.0411319211,
0.0060703857,
-0.0186754446,
-0.0352810919,
0.0529030599,
-0.0011678677,
-0.0769191831,
-0.0057487204,
0.0430391952,
0.0140976505,
-0.0286029018,
0.0164795704,
0.0449821316,
0.0155991903,
0.0339693427,
-0.0654887334,
0.0004506351,
0.0475727096,
0.0367949232,
0.0045469785,
-0.033270482,
0.0275906622,
0.0183099248,
0.0385758355,
0.0003353943,
0.0000019065,
-0.0406183042,
0.0289614275,
-0.0433786549,
-0.0274193343,
-0.030361997,
0.0307580512,
-0.0281555429,
-0.000865443,
0.0031492673,
0.009228861,
0.0211841837,
0.0697918981,
0.0563356876,
0.0412230901,
0.0418597348,
-0.0287417267,
-0.0731301755,
-0.0223416314,
-0.0051634102,
0.0402472131,
-0.0092677511,
0.0252420958,
-0.0161234681,
-0.0297074299,
0.0202219021,
-0.0073783156,
0.0508939214,
0.017037522,
0.0118001094,
0.0131335557,
0.0602267422,
0.014047699,
-0.0341130458,
-0.0037733254,
0.0457595363,
-0.0055194125,
-0.0249776691,
0.0687358752,
-0.0026836258,
0.0334537551,
-0.0002852507,
-0.0800590664,
0.0045852517,
0.0412351117,
0.0204316843,
-0.0178932361,
0.0382389203,
0.0158036891,
0.0231775399,
0.0011502003,
-0.0297832359,
0.011299408,
-0.0045828545,
-0.0079349782,
0.0213544555,
-0.0019462685,
-0.0382863656,
0.0020354507,
0.0091205109,
0.0063533164,
0.028833665,
-0.0378243774,
-0.0589518547,
0.0247544013,
-0.0606998131,
0.0055862758,
-0.0406055599,
-0.0154979071,
0.0720508844,
-0.0082861995,
-0.0154085271,
-0.0106758894,
0.0223465636,
-0.0002296135,
-0.0145369461,
-0.0713676661,
0.0102510992,
-0.0232350882,
0.051532194,
0.0576518364,
-0.0383278579,
-0.0810578316,
0.0618369021,
-0.0008329323,
-0.0007743847,
-0.0408697799,
0.0284106433,
0.048480466,
0.0501544252,
0.0110510867,
-0.0027523795,
-0.0399478748,
0.011529482,
-0.0259148367,
-0.0494976118,
0.0440517478,
0.006992219,
0.0616518036,
-0.0161403604,
0.0225525107,
0.0487328544,
0.0284177307,
-0.0243796464,
-0.0071633928,
-0.0369364917,
-0.0466498658,
-0.0172866117,
0.007785372,
-0.1069650054,
0.0184295271,
0.0260471962,
0.029018715,
-0.0085193021,
-0.0009447902,
0.015882723,
-0.0550885759,
0.0412227027,
0.0350563228,
0.0000973998,
0.0430225022,
0.0498467013,
-0.02179428,
0.0355943888,
-0.0299347863,
0.0781980008,
0.0953468606,
-0.0331112258,
0.0026370019,
0.03313642,
0.0265827887,
0.0179208424,
-0.0019324089,
0.033111643,
-0.0198001228,
-0.0381735899,
-0.0219703056,
0.0128371771,
-0.0066713654,
-0.0252483003,
0.0742890686,
0.0077254255,
-0.0196785703,
0.0263306182,
-0.0262221992,
0.0184267499,
0.0312373824,
-0.0488554239,
-0.0088855922,
0.0231860057,
-0.0284613278,
-0.0160182621,
0.0334469639,
0.0176898073,
-0.0574209727,
-0.0212896243,
0.0139397569,
-0.0277082883,
0.0009934246,
-0.0039549768,
0.0535733439,
-0.0113367261,
0.0010116772,
0.0593596883,
-0.012574031,
-0.0357436351,
-0.0037398962,
0.0118819857,
0.0342326835,
0.0063679875,
0.0246173274,
-0.0254900176,
-0.0199765489,
-0.0141585898,
0.0083230063,
0.0092082489,
-0.0115377782,
0.0235055238,
0.0094292387,
-0.0230851825,
-0.0108684413,
0.0098520927,
0.0270058829,
0.0131338518,
0.0171943754,
0.0466687828,
0.0229085367,
0.0259631779,
-0.0317504853,
-0.0167999994,
0.0486776046,
-0.0056722136,
0.0300829131,
0.0093311481,
0.0467227101,
0.0275664795,
-0.0151705202,
-0.0458944514,
0.0269365758,
-0.0436076932,
-0.0355584733,
-0.0040394934,
-0.0681600347,
-0.0181726161,
0.039045915,
-0.0732639506,
-0.0273290016,
0.0491922051,
-0.0309828315,
-0.0181843303,
0.0869920999,
-0.0464328267,
0.0688661933,
-0.0481407382,
-0.0576211028,
-0.0302615054,
0.0150427073,
0.0306751244,
0.0526798554,
-0.0097490959,
-0.0158426818,
0.0082792062,
-0.0381148458,
0.0105948476,
0.0255258363,
-0.0387387499,
-0.0277203284,
-0.0279267542,
0.0195107162,
0.0397567153,
-0.0018272417,
-0.0721719787,
-0.0219477732,
-0.1051499099,
-0.0259254798,
-0.0207279604,
-0.0069020893,
0.0116078444,
-0.0105288923,
-0.017228419,
-0.0696886778,
-0.078065522,
-0.002761052,
-0.0056727058,
0.035994228,
0.0213271882,
0.0414165184,
0.0086135007,
-0.0127769606,
0.0061415327,
0.0200819243,
0.068092376,
0.03055696,
-0.0116810389,
0.0317816809,
-0.0121285366,
-0.0424785204,
-0.0439057238,
0.0097488007,
-0.0108460626,
0.0136563936,
0.0121938176,
0.038063135,
-0.0045960685,
0.0291781183,
0.0594571494,
-0.0121256802,
0.0122192921,
-0.044114437,
-0.0478703938,
-0.0258524865,
0.0041443668,
0.0054254588,
-0.0642884076,
0.0190244131,
0.019719908,
-0.0054973592,
0.0251756012,
-0.0524610244,
0.0704590827,
0.0258289445,
-0.0277087055,
-0.0651478097,
0.000588537,
0.0138298636,
0.0052408492,
0.0007569187,
-0.0376608819,
0.031797979,
0.0048620841,
-0.0267281402,
0.0566710122,
-0.0171098169,
-0.0244597793,
0.0726464093,
0.0165680144,
0.0351028293,
0.0365929343,
-0.0190190095,
0.0384684466,
-0.062608242,
0.0002559131,
-0.0460991152,
-0.0245448556,
0.0304127,
-0.0103762047,
-0.0015426476,
-0.0369620845,
-0.0466101877,
-0.020983357,
-0.0190372895,
-0.0077945157,
-0.0090029016,
-0.0224143099,
-0.0142707638,
-0.0224610046,
0.0072590751,
-0.0411700718,
0.0293781236,
-0.0416341238,
0.0318875015,
0.0901367515,
0.0556743555,
-0.0551099367,
0.0045917993,
-0.0219675824,
-0.018746268,
0.0527249612,
0.0395006761,
0.0115849273,
-0.0568752214,
-0.020998532,
0.0022079474,
0.008800582,
0.0089936657,
-0.0203124173,
0.0085090706,
-0.0169008262,
0.0225408077,
0.1238132045,
0.020381324,
-0.0244477578,
0.0009858111,
0.0481924303,
0.0147408526,
0.0086138062,
0.0051014754,
-0.0636767969,
-0.0343111865,
-0.0516030155,
0.0104846014,
-0.0373366512,
-0.000714515,
0.0160126369,
-0.0418713987,
0.0264997613,
0.0194831546,
-0.0088963509,
0.0161368474,
-0.0148256831,
0.0119080516,
-0.0463594347,
-0.0561495684,
-0.0621556155,
0.0020696442,
0.0198763963,
0.0064473036,
-0.0252727773,
-0.0787911117,
0.0092445314,
-0.0297340676,
0.0354064107,
0.0133653861,
0.0403993987,
-0.0355163813,
-0.0441560484,
0.0321845412,
-0.0191692486,
-0.0019775312,
-0.0417250991,
0.0501155555,
-0.0027612727,
-0.0418455862,
-0.0398406424,
-0.0094270371,
-0.0491547808,
0.0074946736,
-0.0147883799,
0.0653153285,
-0.0158147309,
-0.03140378,
-0.0704337656,
-0.0261326805,
0.0066720289,
0.0628779829,
0.0537302196,
-0.0249273553,
0.0091715408,
-0.021338189,
0.0102295084,
-0.0113862613,
-0.034882687,
-0.0758639425,
-0.0206886288,
-0.008558304,
-0.0676140487,
-0.0014191858,
0.0080822064,
0.0338530168,
-0.0127754388,
-0.0135438796,
-0.029001575,
-0.0286870413,
-0.0453445837,
-0.007615888,
-0.0245130565,
0.0270035565,
-0.0571692325,
-0.0369022302,
0.0427037776,
-0.0090535544,
-0.025870759,
0.0165474471,
-0.0493588932,
-0.05133605,
-0.0079584802,
0.0581589118,
0.0177166313,
0.0250040814,
0.0149645731,
-0.0295944102,
0.1247289702,
0.0996405259,
-0.0091015352,
-0.0081592323,
0.0173217207,
-0.049459707,
0.0119561534,
0.0262917317,
-0.0372920148,
0.0574475527,
0.0419675931,
-0.063634336,
-0.0786790773,
0.0051397574,
-0.0257171113,
-0.0158576667,
0.0201524403,
-0.0190168209,
-0.0289878044,
0.0274747126,
-0.0018629197,
0.0229567941,
-0.0122131417,
-0.0116589218,
-0.0309098847,
0.0149629107,
0.0182744488,
-0.0541770123,
0.0312206279,
-0.0033647905,
0.0832600668,
-0.040406689,
0.0113118934,
0.0083816694,
0.0446846411,
-0.0263299737,
-0.0216101054,
-0.0059161917,
0.0339934565,
0.0385401249,
0.0335358009,
0.0122422902,
0.0046824776,
-0.0285045337,
-0.0227243323,
0.001035568,
0.059668202,
0.0048261681,
-0.0226606727,
0.0303797722,
-0.0186917577,
0.0697016418,
-0.0684528425,
-0.0064898818,
-0.01259345,
-0.0168924797,
-0.0349874236,
0.0004232757,
-0.0178120825,
-0.0139308125,
-0.0082339887,
0.0065877745,
0.0095452126,
0.0089832526,
0.0212224182,
-0.0173582509,
0.0076345662,
0.0436218269,
-0.0460677594,
-0.0177264567,
0.0637167692,
0.0287878923,
0.0216097739,
-0.0140599357,
0.036748115,
-0.053884726,
-0.0738746598,
0.0341500342,
-0.0429109633,
0.0359823219,
0.0723516643,
0.0080724731,
0.0351594128,
0.0269217193,
0.0440483019,
-0.0197354667,
0.0104301656,
-0.0526218452,
0.0025806769,
0.0154180229,
-6.813517906e-33,
0.0089423051,
-0.0352043062,
-0.0642405078,
-0.005785563,
-0.0048119468,
0.0240437556,
0.0033911788,
-0.0196415819,
0.0477783605,
-0.0046478529,
-0.0065842122,
-0.0210761409,
-0.0022910803,
0.0017107695,
0.0239071418,
0.0024385047,
0.0072036139,
0.0302761607,
-0.0587100983,
0.0237520933,
0.0267583206,
0.0364943296,
0.0321277864,
-0.1392115802,
-0.0173828062,
0.0090146055,
-0.0017648063,
-0.0194865596,
0.0619093962,
0.0636088178,
-0.0020034027,
0.0694127157,
0.0231032744,
-0.0153467152,
-0.0009725889,
0.0777053162,
-0.0585631132,
-0.033574786,
0.003486671,
0.0256794207,
0.0043616015,
-0.0490670465,
0.0560497232,
-0.032593701,
0.0066386652,
0.0267731305,
0.0587219261,
-0.0377181098,
0.024194805,
-0.018567536,
0.0128052523,
0.0324533619,
-0.022178445,
-0.0109579256,
-0.0049363943,
0.0157663003,
0.0424686261,
0.054817725,
-0.0772683769,
0.0730324611,
-0.0022303802,
-0.0475471467,
0.0589922518,
0.0225458462,
0.0205244906,
0.0693933666,
-0.0002672095,
0.0294570606,
-0.0118424548,
-0.0478966683,
-0.0142079657,
0.0320221633,
0.0774186254,
0.0301038325,
0.0646816343,
-0.0023349179,
-0.0338689312,
0.0251848679,
-0.0094115958,
0.0062288688,
0.0175664406,
0.0230983794,
-0.0467453748,
0.0148692979,
-0.0022476679,
-0.0442534052,
-0.0455109663,
-0.0520585887,
-0.0167374481,
-0.0065082172,
-0.064921774,
0.0368552953,
0.0223275833,
-0.0227583013,
-0.0505563095,
-0.0112955971,
0.0529514141,
0.0233391989,
0.0111763021,
-0.0265607759,
-0.0432429872,
0.014481266,
0.0692399889,
-0.0276840478,
0.0036768164,
0.0190680195,
0.0726043656,
0.0382827073,
-0.0757802352,
-0.0315309092,
-0.011463169,
-0.0194561668,
-0.0369122513,
-0.037045531,
0.0320034027,
0.0344044641,
-0.0388718769,
-0.0039396151,
0.0142163606,
0.0019804246,
-0.0312508121,
-0.0090500871,
-0.0469242521,
0.0252756905,
-0.0096650887,
-0.0526021235,
-0.0335644968,
-0.0144771338,
0.0249906648,
-0.0379553996,
0.010474341,
-0.0322757252,
2.658e-7,
0.0143588958,
0.021414211,
-0.0036349639,
0.0192531217,
0.0297053438,
0.0841296688,
-0.0302820578,
0.0244641062,
-0.0239777043,
-0.0323020108,
0.0578238405,
0.0410661772,
-0.0078006582,
0.0091744661,
-0.0447712503,
0.0257334672,
-0.0617136694,
0.02384758,
-0.044371523,
0.005422425,
0.0418793671,
0.0640868247,
0.0668600574,
-0.0483246148,
-0.0065262406,
-0.0186174475,
0.0876859799,
-0.0599366203,
0.0183441769,
-0.0568730719,
0.0191104114,
0.0137301246,
0.0048224125,
0.0056783874,
-0.0225909296,
-0.0430676118,
0.0342291109,
0.0056747487,
0.0049782423,
0.0187379681,
-0.0068739248,
0.0246834364,
0.0180804022,
-0.0637876838,
0.0341666304,
-0.0425543524,
-0.0133037828,
-0.0771277174,
-0.0605138727,
-0.0153586995,
0.079339847,
0.0004707627,
-0.0615236349,
-0.009352034,
0.0027278871,
-0.0294343643,
0.0064797369,
-0.0846766457,
0.0114077078,
0.0056043766,
-0.0060373968,
0.0063988548,
-0.0759505108,
-0.0052414429,
0.0091232909,
0.0159300976,
0.0076147225,
1.844226544e-34,
0.0341531672,
-0.0206216555,
-0.0185160246,
-0.0004529776,
0.0053431452,
-0.0111644575,
0.0316182449,
-0.0131778503,
0.0359933525,
-0.04446337,
0.0348823406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06647v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06647v2 | Robust Text Classification: Analyzing Prototype-Based Networks | 2023-11-11T19:34:06 | 2024-06-18T02:53:04 | Zhivar Sourati, Darshan Deshpande, Filip Ilievski, Kiril Gashteovski, Sascha Saralajew | cs.CL | cs.CL | Downstream applications often require text classification models to be
accurate and robust. While the accuracy of the state-of-the-art Language Models
(LMs) approximates human performance, they often exhibit a drop in performance
on noisy data found in the real world. This lack of robustness can be
concerning, as even small perturbations in the text, irrelevant to the target
task, can cause classifiers to incorrectly change their predictions. A
potential solution can be the family of Prototype-Based Networks (PBNs) that
classifies examples based on their similarity to prototypical examples of a
class (prototypes) and has been shown to be robust to noise for computer vision
tasks. In this paper, we study whether the robustness properties of PBNs
transfer to text classification tasks under both targeted and static
adversarial attack settings. Our results show that PBNs, as a mere
architectural variation of vanilla LMs, offer more robustness compared to
vanilla LMs under both targeted and static settings. We showcase how PBNs'
interpretability can help us to understand PBNs' robustness properties.
Finally, our ablation studies reveal the sensitivity of PBNs' robustness to how
strictly clustering is done in the training phase, as tighter clustering
results in less robust PBNs. | [
0.0407603681,
0.0574752055,
-0.0360577442,
0.041327823,
-0.0159046482,
0.0087797185,
0.0486207381,
0.0128315883,
-0.0049628047,
-0.0490840897,
-0.0194457397,
-0.0496071093,
0.0248068236,
0.0378955975,
0.050875321,
-0.0469659604,
0.0023618934,
-0.0112450821,
-0.0438336357,
0.013610119,
0.0245605819,
-0.0176378414,
0.0167051144,
0.0329901539,
0.0267744828,
-0.0005112376,
0.0021019664,
0.0106771784,
-0.0324896649,
-0.0048640976,
0.0319042318,
0.0687124506,
0.0285385363,
0.0589635819,
0.0000020237,
0.0068615805,
0.0238353778,
0.0037603879,
0.0139934458,
0.0227490645,
0.1130064875,
-0.0204940494,
-0.0155398408,
0.0164970141,
-0.0192226321,
-0.0683465973,
0.0510582849,
0.0468997173,
-0.0016837607,
0.0515010543,
-0.0194694474,
-0.0132402126,
0.0467428602,
-0.0198145099,
-0.0178172812,
-0.0007732101,
0.0284417942,
-0.0602646172,
-0.0495521687,
0.0027660283,
0.0143551026,
-0.0032319,
0.0185617227,
0.021714706,
-0.0225697029,
0.0488067456,
-0.0341105573,
-0.0255704001,
0.0326630175,
0.0620632246,
-0.0270627905,
-0.0299484022,
-0.0028433071,
-0.0062258653,
0.0099360524,
-0.0173395313,
-0.0195448808,
-0.024151925,
0.0016968311,
-0.0050192825,
-0.0286333151,
0.0432552993,
0.0553752631,
0.0220009778,
-0.0134891393,
-0.0194165055,
-0.0045092385,
-0.0003049195,
-0.0318617411,
0.0147688994,
-0.0077903825,
-0.0152149573,
0.0072887051,
-0.0001906424,
0.0585938357,
0.016314717,
-0.0904966071,
-0.047189299,
0.0081051355,
-0.0667618737,
-0.0046239505,
-0.0224112216,
-0.0268598627,
0.024246892,
-0.0297389682,
0.0093283039,
-0.0155170457,
0.0377286561,
-0.0181052666,
0.0086994069,
-0.065555267,
-0.016801089,
-0.0057392898,
0.0347576737,
0.013078792,
-0.0030361477,
-0.0417086259,
0.0421242826,
-0.0305135474,
0.036267627,
-0.0633307919,
0.0381575152,
-0.0277762357,
-0.024712909,
0.003781599,
-0.0393787473,
0.0181108434,
0.0310978796,
-0.0231373515,
-0.0509794056,
0.0054942905,
0.0425033905,
-0.0218703523,
-0.0035371936,
-0.0028771986,
0.1022983864,
-0.0013930864,
-0.0739655644,
-0.064523086,
-0.012110916,
-0.0153571256,
-0.0229148027,
-0.0287297796,
-0.0523435399,
-0.0254647359,
0.016324861,
-0.0304286126,
-0.0614673048,
-0.0076747881,
0.0094746798,
-0.0318303108,
0.1041289791,
0.0063496218,
-0.0618771724,
0.0270862784,
0.0171302427,
-0.0272681005,
0.0426474065,
0.0315236412,
0.0340426974,
0.0537578911,
0.0107287159,
0.0256471466,
0.0213075206,
0.0029257271,
0.0040575257,
-0.0390706062,
0.0081668543,
-0.0035567868,
0.0068676397,
-0.005437667,
0.0263520963,
-0.0364198163,
-0.0530581065,
0.1147691607,
0.0594836399,
-0.0290268604,
0.0915395096,
-0.0132097201,
-0.0151416929,
0.0020901582,
0.0035753888,
-0.0884602964,
-0.0082613863,
-0.0507008806,
-0.0391367674,
-0.0517675467,
0.0068577393,
-0.055245094,
-0.0560498759,
0.0002701979,
-0.0305584017,
0.0384724773,
-0.0274850857,
0.0801058114,
0.0157160833,
-0.0269106589,
-0.0280373171,
0.0020950069,
0.0002637374,
0.0162087865,
-0.0608747341,
-0.0080921166,
0.0272456445,
0.0497586615,
-0.0443046726,
0.0188373979,
-0.0297130011,
0.0029984347,
0.016568182,
0.0263856836,
-0.0001204678,
0.0331536867,
-0.0444556288,
-0.0037698329,
-0.0219166595,
0.0211934652,
0.0289882831,
0.00579315,
-0.0157918669,
0.0070404005,
-0.0712056234,
-0.0325385556,
0.0399716124,
0.0338014029,
-0.0073015764,
0.0406157486,
0.0210399218,
0.0063191992,
-0.0123961074,
-0.0187395141,
-0.0043996377,
0.0277107209,
-0.0132794138,
0.0027137415,
-0.0055921702,
-0.0009815651,
-0.0063818828,
-0.0137129882,
-0.0132589638,
-0.0186370723,
0.0588871799,
-0.0533585772,
-0.0003381413,
0.0479362048,
-0.007600253,
0.025342403,
-0.0465647243,
0.0022846749,
-0.0370125771,
0.0354863144,
-0.0420280769,
0.0487149805,
-0.0022059933,
0.0057278639,
-0.0262198523,
0.0234820973,
0.0180441998,
-0.0097509734,
-0.0455953628,
-0.0022988052,
-0.0163365006,
0.0348206982,
-0.011629398,
-0.0491299964,
0.0059374138,
-0.0347421505,
-0.0278151389,
-0.0199892316,
-0.0282882173,
0.0044555287,
0.0188259259,
-0.0136643341,
0.0202089436,
-0.0245315712,
-0.0031027116,
0.0485671163,
-0.0192251541,
0.0043712002,
0.0545818023,
-0.0010707867,
-0.0078360084,
-0.0218986869,
-0.0282181632,
0.01481135,
0.1052486598,
0.0076522259,
-0.006222052,
-0.0557082817,
0.0333217829,
0.0041240915,
0.06153813,
-0.0230388083,
-0.0361266322,
0.0071633612,
0.0113328239,
-0.02391815,
0.0662864372,
0.0235503074,
0.0542664118,
0.0357583724,
0.081520766,
-0.0043133115,
-0.0503681451,
-0.0286260732,
0.0284518767,
-0.0536305867,
0.0036378277,
-0.0131114703,
0.0378658585,
0.0190480147,
-0.0263967142,
-0.0399399586,
0.0424925946,
0.0221742243,
-0.0126347439,
-0.0449293368,
-0.0117523996,
0.010749314,
-0.0042985897,
-0.0554134436,
-0.0813832507,
0.0951051787,
-0.0249214806,
0.0011385021,
0.0216330811,
-0.0734950751,
0.015821591,
0.0394994095,
0.0543329231,
-0.0074604014,
0.0324265882,
-0.0158741027,
-0.0772671103,
-0.0364066735,
0.0070260875,
-0.0031422263,
0.0520302206,
-0.0124556869,
0.0086318925,
0.0034903339,
-0.0320795961,
-0.0529334098,
-0.0191110615,
0.0086383056,
0.0258869622,
-0.0031212077,
-0.0047897385,
-0.0606319197,
0.0292201936,
-0.0092487214,
0.05180116,
-0.018424239,
-0.0144488309,
-0.0159132518,
0.0702131167,
0.0095106456,
-0.0487040728,
0.0211804789,
-0.0420671888,
0.0118607786,
0.0754458159,
0.0104598394,
-0.012821435,
-0.0770644322,
-0.0089409938,
0.0014350532,
0.0153198214,
-0.0433644392,
0.0155716548,
-0.0065462692,
-0.0410703719,
-0.0449997447,
0.0504816957,
-0.0066410443,
-0.0609363914,
0.002602855,
0.0423019342,
0.0492934622,
0.0183352157,
0.0260442011,
0.0130866151,
-0.0037709109,
-0.0133001199,
0.0586331971,
0.0059192642,
-0.0011359192,
-0.0129509466,
-0.0587614812,
0.0322323516,
0.0157293882,
-0.0812064931,
-0.0496954136,
-0.0429046117,
-0.0081847403,
-0.0311963819,
0.0212745778,
-0.0085476944,
0.0376496129,
0.0023781736,
0.030206386,
-0.0497684143,
-0.0464971922,
-0.0147305503,
-0.0252828579,
0.034347441,
0.0256898012,
-0.0086425319,
-0.0292508677,
0.0189604107,
0.0349804573,
-0.0944780335,
-0.0100179901,
0.0139633361,
0.0777317286,
-0.0136094531,
-0.0029646379,
0.004618255,
0.0305601377,
-0.031070821,
-0.0258641932,
-0.0106605021,
0.0153817916,
-0.0244260915,
-0.0446402989,
-0.0395442359,
-0.0263937451,
0.0096259536,
0.0389383659,
0.019886557,
-0.055389218,
-0.0402607732,
-0.0369343534,
0.0068329484,
-0.0440458842,
0.0070610405,
0.0122140171,
0.0365759097,
-0.0292138103,
-0.0398038588,
-0.0216122568,
-0.0216540974,
0.0273674279,
-0.0158395264,
-0.0000563292,
-0.0190568082,
-0.0065336986,
-0.0340274014,
0.0246577505,
0.0363137871,
-0.0034519404,
-0.050802812,
0.0045587393,
0.0606343113,
-0.0724474788,
-0.0341223888,
0.0094026458,
-0.0753484517,
-0.0584346056,
0.0341753587,
0.0301324502,
0.0141670406,
0.0283230972,
-0.0322681777,
-0.1113411784,
0.1007897556,
0.0577263795,
0.0201283935,
0.0030445885,
0.0434954539,
-0.0146264946,
-0.0092607243,
0.0297861751,
-0.0272057243,
0.0445168428,
0.066585049,
-0.0611334965,
-0.0610683858,
-0.0364647917,
-0.0364844613,
-0.0380985923,
0.0824963078,
-0.0065322258,
-0.0232758652,
-0.0140948258,
0.0143037224,
0.0495650098,
-0.0033448045,
-0.0129602626,
-0.0002899414,
0.0314446278,
0.0182904676,
-0.0275305342,
-0.0370238274,
-0.0010482774,
0.0692874193,
0.0101380218,
-0.0247920025,
0.0236839335,
0.0578057356,
0.0086694397,
0.038769342,
-0.0228823517,
0.0404822715,
-0.0413957201,
0.0374513194,
-0.0364386812,
-0.0021712023,
0.031937547,
0.0068752319,
-0.0471207462,
0.0390900336,
-0.095050998,
0.0248337053,
-0.0603650734,
0.0280223172,
0.0284224227,
0.0237519629,
-0.0550070964,
-0.0419204794,
-0.0109359398,
-0.0310097989,
0.0103169037,
0.0124593545,
-0.0333539546,
0.0594776683,
0.0255906414,
0.0019154353,
0.0527175479,
0.0450223461,
0.0455904081,
0.0442842394,
0.019461982,
-0.02891168,
-0.0414290875,
-0.0105164461,
0.063729912,
0.0378546529,
-0.0178247299,
0.0225807335,
-0.0208922755,
-0.0589170307,
0.0410781316,
-0.0027775096,
0.0298799276,
-0.0113597708,
0.0107150292,
0.0552473776,
0.0194360316,
0.0293462425,
-0.0096292365,
0.009138586,
0.0146039277,
-0.0062802304,
0.0090621114,
-6.000692582e-33,
0.0215372052,
-0.0410869345,
-0.0356675982,
-0.0138348341,
0.0266437959,
0.0090727536,
0.0052347672,
-0.0005521125,
-0.009366381,
0.0002997592,
0.0113815088,
0.0195417032,
-0.0218551457,
0.0293476284,
-0.046192605,
-0.0419048592,
0.0328384377,
-0.0135706495,
-0.0091717467,
0.0114956526,
0.051204212,
0.0190675389,
0.0235456154,
-0.0648395121,
0.0030709349,
-0.0154025629,
-0.0308661386,
-0.0088305986,
-0.0008618016,
0.0644178763,
-0.0081992168,
0.0629134178,
0.0156943128,
0.0436038934,
-0.0149366586,
0.0274097454,
-0.0549664423,
-0.0027717352,
-0.0406396464,
0.0309108831,
0.0058223703,
-0.0018163344,
0.0748806,
-0.0178641565,
0.0031199283,
-0.0227738414,
0.0631052703,
-0.0132940449,
-0.0531522483,
-0.0002739145,
-0.0000981306,
0.0330670625,
-0.0080437483,
0.0305279884,
0.0321879946,
-0.0028167162,
0.0150452508,
0.0193352718,
-0.1110350043,
0.0008809337,
-0.0362009779,
0.0346114598,
0.0138007449,
0.0455584712,
-0.0065279263,
0.0591054223,
0.0524409525,
0.0411124416,
-0.0131052751,
-0.0233769193,
0.0545519181,
0.0142419524,
0.0928466916,
0.067276977,
0.0423491932,
-0.0216029305,
-0.0803014562,
0.0138388453,
-0.0077903238,
-0.0026735561,
0.0435890071,
0.0217710063,
-0.0408908091,
-0.0161940288,
-0.031606596,
-0.1115255579,
-0.0503003523,
-0.0331178606,
0.0041105268,
0.0037473752,
-0.0509099662,
0.0000597079,
-0.0143941771,
-0.0574882403,
-0.0130080795,
0.040466927,
-0.0127450367,
0.0434016548,
0.0069592847,
0.0057179942,
-0.0157524627,
-0.0537570715,
0.0240011699,
0.0271972511,
0.0146129373,
-0.0019789403,
0.0656028539,
0.0143899471,
-0.0412434824,
-0.0152356401,
-0.0011116752,
0.0161623619,
0.0343421139,
0.0278577413,
-0.0019462707,
-0.0184431486,
-0.0026112911,
0.0118239028,
0.0139991445,
-0.0008920096,
-0.0042350776,
0.0261745993,
-0.0281015486,
0.0362511687,
-0.0151822669,
-0.0354797691,
-0.0140932826,
0.0172830429,
0.0797865838,
-0.0788346604,
-0.0003640194,
-0.0062422631,
2.763e-7,
0.0259323213,
0.0361261629,
0.0061477288,
-0.0191143863,
0.0558005795,
0.0736773536,
-0.0108238691,
0.0361828767,
-0.0072970605,
0.0008476628,
0.0200161748,
0.0139078768,
0.034433011,
0.0174695682,
-0.0370290577,
0.0124327438,
-0.0413803346,
0.0488061719,
-0.0183590539,
0.0273619536,
0.0474976152,
0.0921217799,
0.0324586928,
-0.0143723013,
0.014385663,
-0.0830232129,
0.0507577732,
-0.0270444751,
0.0444099605,
-0.0111170607,
0.0072069191,
0.0249027759,
-0.0068728221,
0.026238095,
-0.0196904261,
0.0056252796,
0.0090710633,
0.0244348217,
-0.0294913091,
0.0111897476,
-0.0045528491,
-0.0033235054,
0.0013953628,
-0.0606493354,
0.0659223124,
-0.0772369727,
-0.0182271563,
0.0206798632,
0.0045097182,
-0.0596088916,
0.034107849,
-0.0050479588,
-0.0198983233,
-0.0090625286,
0.0073674247,
-0.0380562283,
-0.0033123486,
-0.0946761072,
-0.0062973495,
0.0056579169,
-0.0445109829,
-0.0207398701,
-0.0313067697,
0.03031631,
0.0844042301,
-0.0199711137,
0.0041578063,
2.511042359e-34,
0.0308823343,
0.0060476698,
-0.0242790803,
-0.0194029734,
0.0030114921,
-0.005431714,
0.0623672642,
-0.0134657687,
0.0207001884,
-0.0544826165,
0.0021721039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06622v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06622v2 | TrainerAgent: Customizable and Efficient Model Training through LLM-Powered Multi-Agent System | 2023-11-11T17:39:24 | 2023-11-23T10:57:10 | Haoyuan Li, Hao Jiang, Tianke Zhang, Zhelun Yu, Aoxiong Yin, Hao Cheng, Siming Fu, Yuhao Zhang, Wanggui He | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Training AI models has always been challenging, especially when there is a
need for custom models to provide personalized services. Algorithm engineers
often face a lengthy process to iteratively develop models tailored to specific
business requirements, making it even more difficult for non-experts. The quest
for high-quality and efficient model development, along with the emergence of
Large Language Model (LLM) Agents, has become a key focus in the industry.
Leveraging the powerful analytical, planning, and decision-making capabilities
of LLM, we propose a TrainerAgent system comprising a multi-agent framework
including Task, Data, Model and Server agents. These agents analyze
user-defined tasks, input data, and requirements (e.g., accuracy, speed),
optimizing them comprehensively from both data and model perspectives to obtain
satisfactory models, and finally deploy these models as online service.
Experimental evaluations on classical discriminative and generative tasks in
computer vision and natural language processing domains demonstrate that our
system consistently produces models that meet the desired criteria.
Furthermore, the system exhibits the ability to critically identify and reject
unattainable tasks, such as fantastical scenarios or unethical requests,
ensuring robustness and safety. This research presents a significant
advancement in achieving desired models with increased efficiency and quality
as compared to traditional model development, facilitated by the integration of
LLM-powered analysis, decision-making, and execution capabilities, as well as
the collaboration among four agents. We anticipate that our work will
contribute to the advancement of research on TrainerAgent in both academic and
industry communities, potentially establishing it as a new paradigm for model
development in the field of AI. | [
0.0868592486,
0.0338168666,
-0.0295164101,
0.0600221083,
-0.0551774502,
-0.0013424768,
0.0309871621,
-0.0188750513,
0.0122772576,
-0.0726791024,
-0.0209728219,
-0.0194261782,
-0.0716920048,
0.0482326709,
-0.0079039186,
-0.0491566397,
0.0184357427,
-0.0347061753,
0.0258136112,
-0.006198863,
0.0098782098,
0.0030476379,
-0.0224502198,
0.0469005294,
-0.0469489731,
-0.0206223987,
-0.0173478648,
-0.0098900627,
-0.0041797557,
-0.0196366515,
0.0333050191,
0.0314882286,
0.0595282726,
0.0208299812,
0.0000021961,
-0.0629830807,
-0.0272370763,
0.0032564022,
-0.0549904108,
-0.0086334748,
0.0950270966,
0.0209242105,
-0.0062391902,
0.0101920776,
-0.0673479065,
0.0436783768,
0.0350652076,
0.0299467687,
0.0747793317,
0.0636989847,
-0.0059763384,
-0.0314982384,
0.0126433475,
0.0243840721,
-0.0453212671,
-0.045997113,
0.0222000685,
0.0098825525,
0.0213538893,
-0.0236274377,
-0.0122575024,
0.0147948926,
0.0146134868,
0.0072063897,
0.0310247429,
0.0279566906,
-0.0171961002,
-0.0448375978,
-0.0529512726,
0.0473738387,
0.0031680975,
0.0095938193,
-0.0073493905,
0.0105553186,
-0.0031504994,
0.0134633742,
-0.0122380983,
0.0166843906,
0.0039380956,
0.0008444224,
0.0127504617,
-0.0188537687,
-0.0228629783,
0.0495256223,
0.0044366908,
0.0608753674,
-0.0240844376,
-0.0243395604,
-0.0098847365,
-0.0060458397,
0.0134846354,
-0.0595637821,
0.0240777172,
0.0482974201,
-0.0600960478,
0.0241006613,
-0.03185248,
-0.0351184383,
-0.003058936,
-0.0538195483,
0.0653359741,
-0.0063774404,
-0.0081367912,
0.0497577041,
-0.0284331199,
0.062631458,
-0.0015483613,
0.0184165239,
-0.0279908553,
0.0040772334,
-0.0758466125,
0.0034945381,
-0.0608779155,
0.0435095578,
-0.0288104787,
-0.0163689069,
-0.0169053022,
0.0488048941,
-0.0457582437,
0.0207138322,
-0.0007763515,
0.0434279889,
-0.0233431663,
-0.0208347142,
-0.0795474946,
-0.0143493097,
-0.0328347906,
0.0316208676,
-0.0091068707,
-0.0649528727,
0.0394461416,
0.0282762144,
0.0013389296,
0.0178837366,
0.0206204392,
0.0967416838,
-0.0165467169,
-0.0330693647,
-0.0684702769,
-0.0379848741,
0.0537347756,
-0.076782085,
-0.0138007263,
-0.0608929694,
0.003659575,
-0.0298884474,
-0.008746827,
-0.0490279347,
0.0177769698,
-0.0260988548,
0.0089607732,
0.1077059358,
-0.0241726749,
0.0372269936,
0.0317578986,
0.0119792689,
-0.0418914184,
0.0757672638,
0.0492568724,
0.0548229888,
0.0645857304,
-0.0009525784,
0.0415585861,
0.0426812656,
-0.0561289303,
0.0071890992,
-0.0171007253,
0.0249718111,
-0.0224459618,
0.0364467241,
-0.0060806088,
0.0270206556,
-0.0303036124,
0.0147562847,
0.0866585597,
0.0725107491,
0.0121882251,
0.0305118728,
0.0587558746,
0.0341347344,
-0.0111233154,
-0.0346572734,
-0.0327936336,
0.0068472004,
0.008514286,
-0.02071568,
-0.0802574903,
0.0495322607,
-0.0384442359,
-0.0643521249,
0.0121362666,
-0.0517050251,
0.039213907,
0.0127179753,
0.061011117,
-0.0270028878,
-0.0623734519,
-0.0083773853,
0.002468559,
-0.040402554,
-0.00205576,
-0.0908087343,
0.0218105484,
0.1153912395,
0.0580316037,
-0.0416450165,
-0.0326039568,
-0.0163341984,
0.0088663902,
0.0273271836,
0.0245519243,
-0.0349665508,
-0.0176357813,
-0.0476334691,
-0.0556726567,
0.0124402698,
0.0068765413,
0.0243041422,
0.0275381859,
-0.0152428169,
0.0008705106,
0.0135657806,
-0.0584568717,
0.0587614402,
-0.03588048,
-0.0308105834,
0.0018532788,
0.0212814976,
0.0576421656,
0.0195056628,
-0.0065624816,
-0.008673626,
0.0542255305,
-0.0195318796,
-0.0316074863,
0.0085686166,
0.0264328774,
0.0438224301,
0.0415711477,
-0.0082248235,
0.0232083425,
0.0356800817,
-0.0253091529,
-0.0218181256,
0.0065634893,
-0.0363974683,
0.0077202702,
-0.0464610457,
0.0196197275,
-0.0202235803,
-0.0104953013,
-0.0204603765,
0.0599652939,
0.0286736693,
-0.0598494932,
-0.0030559266,
0.0053832354,
-0.0062477193,
-0.0354357436,
0.0020207309,
0.0061092549,
0.0256111156,
0.0633255318,
0.0274847187,
-0.0047777584,
-0.0493243821,
-0.0118036838,
-0.0701490864,
0.0151281385,
-0.0000024502,
0.0125220818,
-0.0179067589,
-0.0232106131,
-0.023800347,
-0.0308086593,
-0.0315962546,
0.0211856849,
-0.0092334263,
0.0277634244,
0.0097797913,
0.0220816787,
-0.0718957111,
-0.0201913659,
0.0259860698,
0.0010345479,
0.0080315862,
0.0479282364,
-0.0097151967,
-0.0873931646,
0.0225447267,
-0.0369234383,
0.0564692393,
0.0007667094,
-0.0346577913,
0.0014363122,
-0.0062313778,
-0.0191792753,
0.0796970502,
0.0032433332,
0.0340059772,
0.0534065291,
0.002211486,
-0.0692594945,
0.0336184911,
-0.0307316035,
0.0090488009,
-0.0616900697,
-0.0056293658,
0.003652924,
0.0351286978,
-0.0319434889,
0.005975944,
-0.0458207913,
0.0284674689,
0.0132712871,
-0.0444068313,
0.0018885764,
-0.0184329432,
-0.0145046236,
0.0573741272,
-0.0029325096,
-0.0440579802,
0.0728600994,
0.0068310914,
-0.0094559779,
-0.0118394587,
-0.0654204115,
-0.0322473049,
0.0594586916,
-0.0045699142,
0.0332123302,
-0.0030041251,
0.0199451558,
-0.0442797467,
0.0107998904,
0.0385203324,
-0.0362172537,
0.0356736965,
-0.0723107904,
0.0138980234,
0.0171383359,
-0.0427727737,
-0.0583239309,
-0.0036886651,
-0.0445295945,
0.0218264461,
-0.0353604145,
-0.0003931795,
-0.0494647548,
0.0192120466,
-0.0031658099,
0.0301861912,
-0.0062694312,
-0.0120979268,
-0.0296323355,
-0.0192365441,
0.0470363759,
0.0080077806,
0.0060788244,
-0.0128500015,
0.0549318269,
0.0547019616,
0.0250376128,
-0.0436615199,
-0.0658441111,
0.0014432699,
0.0223034713,
-0.0426712632,
0.0122909751,
0.0331807509,
0.0212480389,
-0.0562568493,
0.002395075,
0.0699351653,
0.0084651243,
-0.0380011015,
0.0219574459,
0.0009207245,
-0.0059739123,
0.0393301733,
0.0540320538,
-0.0462787151,
-0.0066908891,
-0.0223565735,
0.0458400585,
-0.0322242007,
-0.0319081545,
-0.0126966992,
-0.0818943903,
0.0846726522,
-0.0203913115,
0.0146572758,
-0.0038834945,
-0.0665265992,
0.0025356922,
-0.0393635556,
0.0028571931,
-0.0066808439,
0.0035194303,
-0.03465214,
0.0267271586,
-0.0017880813,
-0.0536872633,
0.0071574789,
-0.0618008077,
0.0412394144,
0.0898816139,
-0.0029287774,
0.0158201456,
-0.039604079,
-0.0083387448,
0.079845503,
0.0328619964,
0.0104699675,
0.0256380774,
-0.0314459763,
0.00859496,
0.0119641991,
0.0282750893,
-0.0465847403,
0.0012327237,
0.0317517295,
0.0836384594,
-0.0107130548,
0.012438341,
-0.0304770879,
-0.0271181911,
0.034971986,
0.0683042631,
-0.0220202468,
-0.0625967905,
-0.0287334844,
-0.0072003691,
0.0160291288,
-0.0277196635,
-0.0177147593,
0.0105804317,
-0.0715244263,
-0.0050921384,
-0.0621258318,
-0.0479927287,
0.0395013653,
-0.0019642962,
0.0131025296,
-0.0277837738,
0.021570025,
0.0321233496,
-0.0182236414,
-0.0035147998,
-0.0388048962,
0.027115602,
-0.0564633645,
-0.0443562791,
0.0374809653,
-0.0415556915,
0.0030227951,
-0.0122128269,
-0.0649198964,
-0.0434149057,
-0.0108497711,
0.074874416,
0.0250266884,
0.0359362699,
0.0003871113,
-0.0484469235,
0.0069329161,
0.0266793538,
-0.052654583,
-0.0059119104,
0.0154607324,
-0.012668944,
-0.0048692226,
0.0122873457,
-0.054226283,
0.04237758,
0.0166826565,
-0.0039846967,
-0.0602789707,
-0.0317327231,
0.0272855032,
0.0222238302,
-0.0069525307,
-0.0223524701,
-0.029903356,
-0.0383151472,
0.0191722363,
-0.0053706593,
-0.0207177848,
-0.075936608,
-0.0072033792,
-0.0061668321,
0.0022651427,
0.0632391125,
-0.0174611509,
-0.0071742469,
-0.0110928686,
-0.0283228103,
0.0337869488,
0.0062523861,
0.0055333804,
0.0052461391,
0.0170326121,
-0.0121294698,
0.0101923672,
0.0012413393,
0.0396372452,
0.0146836452,
0.0538409501,
0.0128380777,
0.0003630697,
-0.0349791311,
0.017811548,
-0.0348143205,
-0.0508800335,
-0.0171094276,
0.0476968065,
0.0366029739,
0.0142160766,
0.0014422982,
-0.0570945032,
0.0081870947,
-0.0144653618,
0.0029039592,
0.002086415,
-0.0383066423,
0.0000896985,
0.0325315781,
0.0022893443,
0.0091261594,
0.063387081,
0.0188624132,
0.0783282146,
-0.0454171076,
-0.0528174713,
-0.0709752142,
-0.0380267128,
0.0306266937,
-0.0094598737,
-0.0269876923,
0.0047558518,
-0.0448548533,
-0.0324247107,
-0.0020388006,
-0.003671851,
-0.0123757645,
-0.0372176096,
0.064131029,
0.0652112067,
-0.0103186714,
-0.0287628174,
-0.0478562675,
-0.0546706691,
0.0012221405,
0.0000879026,
-0.023035299,
-5.660490191e-33,
0.0194008891,
-0.0334548317,
0.0756913349,
0.0108835744,
0.0164971873,
0.0133224279,
0.0171125904,
-0.0239702314,
0.00992373,
0.0018375469,
-0.0041444846,
-0.016205281,
0.0101032406,
-0.0074910834,
0.0088704312,
-0.0023954152,
0.0522040874,
-0.0436695442,
-0.0103659471,
-0.0124896541,
0.00471613,
0.0183233991,
0.0349353477,
-0.0863259286,
0.007479344,
-0.0205925461,
-0.0527076386,
0.0484978259,
0.0006203636,
0.078906849,
-0.0176735111,
0.0362427123,
0.034417931,
-0.0571184792,
-0.002515119,
-0.0050947969,
-0.0266287066,
0.0011258958,
-0.0257338807,
0.0241987798,
-0.0415675379,
-0.019158341,
0.0487410314,
-0.0208867993,
-0.0295776315,
0.0319831111,
0.0691793635,
-0.0471942239,
0.0103795677,
0.0090331249,
-0.0617955588,
0.0095750941,
-0.0086755799,
-0.0383386873,
0.0713803023,
0.0179637112,
0.0076204916,
-0.0261560734,
-0.0393451378,
0.029565433,
0.0486369878,
-0.0410925522,
0.0589245521,
0.0256106071,
0.0007044393,
0.0347245745,
0.0700215772,
-0.0009817771,
-0.0239084177,
-0.0303731412,
-0.004434295,
0.1052528843,
0.0204252154,
0.0424605273,
-0.0344182216,
0.0066093095,
-0.0181625653,
0.0272037741,
0.0516275577,
0.0267798044,
0.0229388233,
0.0262453165,
-0.0422750488,
-0.0047380165,
-0.0012459985,
-0.0072815237,
-0.0075338134,
-0.0362559073,
0.0301047638,
0.0391482525,
-0.0131331086,
0.0122263795,
0.021346081,
-0.0558777638,
-0.0039764242,
-0.0253619216,
0.0199864488,
0.0344601683,
-0.0021957327,
-0.0072059566,
-0.0630577654,
-0.041252844,
-0.007980518,
-0.0348151997,
0.0200987291,
0.0042009461,
0.0183018669,
0.0407603309,
-0.0190253705,
0.0348549299,
-0.0272959024,
0.0216475036,
0.057908617,
0.0197710022,
0.0098342625,
0.0025048598,
-0.0242253318,
0.0395632721,
0.0339757353,
-0.0155521743,
-0.035982091,
0.0048421328,
-0.0061573521,
0.0096376855,
-0.0302429106,
-0.0086898152,
-0.0486010127,
0.0228745453,
0.0361337587,
-0.0215570908,
-0.018201882,
0.0083648982,
2.841e-7,
-0.0110231601,
0.0514837056,
-0.0121996505,
-0.0018479988,
0.0270327721,
0.0671413541,
0.0002776704,
0.0049630529,
-0.0127142342,
-0.007745638,
0.0400089063,
0.0577752851,
0.0318040624,
0.035966929,
-0.0594591387,
-0.0389932804,
-0.0062684286,
0.0274213087,
-0.0855780318,
0.0123304585,
0.038826216,
0.0663221106,
0.0359457508,
-0.0184395518,
-0.0074429107,
-0.038512554,
0.0373844579,
-0.0500751808,
0.0050285473,
0.0468043089,
-0.0004245053,
0.0533622019,
-0.0122926077,
0.0447172299,
0.0003551281,
0.0276179425,
-0.0169397667,
0.0839032382,
-0.0327467769,
0.0048547317,
0.0165534243,
-0.0098038726,
-0.0093617653,
-0.0219999123,
0.0452032909,
-0.0056597167,
-0.0167470425,
-0.0154638719,
-0.0258519482,
-0.0148557164,
-0.0395709798,
-0.0358270109,
-0.0139818238,
0.0049246289,
-0.0101087242,
-0.0405416265,
-0.0215472355,
-0.0644869804,
0.0502801612,
-0.048799932,
-0.0531633124,
-0.0162664205,
-0.016004283,
0.0101298755,
0.0212191604,
-0.0344234444,
0.0437509492,
2.463682105e-34,
-0.0168389864,
0.0223251097,
-0.0036039832,
0.0940475538,
0.0376490802,
0.0263266247,
-0.028005233,
0.0050676605,
0.0134443166,
-0.0461188219,
-0.0211219117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06612v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06612v1 | PerceptionGPT: Effectively Fusing Visual Perception into LLM | 2023-11-11T16:59:20 | 2023-11-11T16:59:20 | Renjie Pi, Lewei Yao, Jiahui Gao, Jipeng Zhang, Tong Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The integration of visual inputs with large language models (LLMs) has led to
remarkable advancements in multi-modal capabilities, giving rise to visual
large language models (VLLMs). However, effectively harnessing VLLMs for
intricate visual perception tasks remains a challenge. In this paper, we
present a novel end-to-end framework named PerceptionGPT, which efficiently and
effectively equips the VLLMs with visual perception abilities by leveraging the
representation power of LLMs' token embedding. Our proposed method treats the
token embedding of the LLM as the carrier of spatial information, then leverage
lightweight visual task encoders and decoders to perform visual perception
tasks (e.g., detection, segmentation). Our approach significantly alleviates
the training difficulty suffered by previous approaches that formulate the
visual outputs as discrete tokens, and enables achieving superior performance
with fewer trainable parameters, less training data and shorted training time.
Moreover, as only one token embedding is required to decode the visual outputs,
the resulting sequence length during inference is significantly reduced.
Consequently, our approach enables accurate and flexible representations,
seamless integration of visual perception tasks, and efficient handling of a
multiple of visual outputs. We validate the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach through extensive experiments. The results demonstrate significant
improvements over previous methods with much fewer trainable parameters and GPU
hours, which facilitates future research in enabling LLMs with visual
perception abilities. | [
0.0055455687,
0.0319374949,
0.0091206273,
0.0656820014,
-0.027358396,
0.0144184679,
-0.0078073451,
-0.0107062291,
-0.0010771021,
-0.069666408,
-0.0156765133,
-0.0061566089,
0.0092362855,
0.0484288856,
0.0516130887,
-0.0464124642,
-0.0031745252,
-0.0531168245,
-0.0131189618,
0.0143056894,
0.0321499892,
0.0053996136,
0.0198591053,
0.0565530434,
-0.0374526232,
-0.0233492833,
-0.0274053719,
0.0138016557,
0.0249759667,
-0.0317008942,
-0.0451334491,
0.0100259297,
0.0942617506,
0.0224855673,
0.0000019424,
-0.0023650064,
0.0000319462,
-0.0136868646,
0.0208052844,
0.0071792002,
0.0302607808,
-0.0531995595,
-0.0041147992,
-0.0140424706,
-0.0212488603,
-0.0456686467,
0.0872861072,
0.0482931063,
0.0529465005,
0.0473345704,
-0.0232636388,
-0.0109218135,
0.0357538797,
-0.0116793718,
0.0233863909,
-0.0054960488,
0.0274054706,
-0.0047717085,
-0.0189860091,
0.0048351693,
-0.0559599139,
0.0174974035,
0.0351292416,
0.0049322299,
-0.004578195,
0.0649755523,
0.0021298758,
-0.0249077622,
-0.0485803001,
0.0334450342,
-0.0664277449,
-0.0161290932,
-0.0099378182,
0.004585471,
-0.0104026226,
-0.0217808001,
-0.0535252169,
0.0233627222,
-0.0047537507,
0.0524040461,
-0.041727107,
-0.008873255,
0.0249670763,
0.0090304147,
-0.0445508696,
-0.0060810968,
0.0270343088,
0.028014088,
-0.074308306,
0.0260976739,
-0.0382455811,
-0.0472449362,
-0.0157189295,
0.0206558406,
-0.0016982389,
-0.0182356276,
-0.0544822328,
-0.0213333126,
-0.0234541893,
-0.012103131,
0.0409166738,
0.0402313881,
-0.067477569,
0.079072386,
-0.0759566203,
0.072419323,
-0.0524846353,
0.0650961772,
-0.0384553224,
-0.03442505,
-0.0113694323,
-0.0171169154,
-0.0160931833,
-0.005838736,
-0.0322743021,
-0.0721085295,
-0.0137625085,
0.0380346663,
-0.027742045,
0.0135190701,
0.0008404526,
0.0091273542,
-0.0098941522,
-0.0269491356,
0.0004474062,
0.040003486,
0.0175237395,
0.0292700678,
-0.0115073323,
-0.0368817672,
-0.0046385257,
0.0609312691,
0.0341405831,
-0.0091744019,
0.003692325,
0.0804216191,
-0.0397274122,
-0.0431123637,
-0.0178784393,
0.0190333761,
-0.028004976,
-0.0266420096,
0.0429920852,
-0.0791547373,
0.0297379252,
-0.0014682243,
0.03217756,
-0.007857657,
0.0141074229,
0.0059638112,
-0.0019036097,
0.0868065283,
-0.0099722547,
-0.0141004436,
0.0030159145,
-0.0050009382,
0.0154865207,
0.0796620995,
0.0499872565,
0.0906910598,
-0.0018721196,
0.011497316,
0.0068635666,
0.052859854,
-0.0325606428,
0.0101449955,
-0.0553246737,
-0.0163072683,
0.0384471007,
0.0252460632,
0.0587378256,
0.0608289838,
-0.0573896654,
-0.0230854489,
0.0769345686,
0.0494543202,
0.0027388048,
-0.0116738845,
0.0336038955,
0.0137830572,
-0.0380835608,
-0.0339164995,
-0.0603856035,
0.0364528075,
0.0239666905,
0.0036313727,
0.0166486502,
0.0575165711,
-0.0276746657,
-0.0022370999,
-0.0224547964,
-0.0363988355,
0.0282148588,
0.0150296586,
0.0572215728,
-0.0110955378,
-0.0384129249,
0.0225699302,
0.0039495584,
-0.0183708519,
0.0077651297,
-0.0493485443,
0.0388698131,
0.0635420606,
0.0148432525,
0.020612292,
0.0159435719,
0.0040151766,
0.0325163789,
0.0324458294,
-0.0279424638,
0.0029364268,
0.0347024798,
-0.069019638,
-0.0367379673,
0.0171005446,
0.0045360527,
0.0314805359,
0.0093648927,
-0.0070651635,
0.0254156478,
-0.0784149393,
0.03956379,
0.0538995825,
0.0755754858,
-0.0028275226,
-0.0317329355,
0.0235061478,
-0.006171464,
-0.0263608266,
0.0022678298,
-0.0037377852,
0.0334999822,
-0.0653668046,
0.0217867792,
0.01859059,
-0.0442566946,
-0.0285956748,
0.036974635,
-0.0194648933,
0.003939447,
0.0171039365,
-0.0686168298,
-0.0219464581,
0.0036933837,
-0.0322350748,
0.0281850845,
-0.0430624895,
-0.0279136058,
0.0294020753,
0.0143875899,
-0.019890001,
0.0219365824,
-0.028507743,
-0.0176213849,
-0.0077289655,
0.026539376,
-0.0032309913,
-0.0151481656,
-0.0204250235,
0.0065587154,
0.0173580963,
0.0036480315,
-0.0108984355,
0.0166197345,
-0.0191073101,
-0.0189703908,
-0.1154689789,
-0.0235700868,
-0.0258544832,
-0.0218464229,
-0.011006007,
-0.0057665771,
0.0210921131,
-0.0303712133,
-0.0194016881,
0.0260025077,
0.0008989163,
0.0227492489,
0.0119018219,
-0.0083569232,
-0.0203122217,
-0.0006408218,
-0.0064138803,
0.0097319828,
0.0630634651,
-0.0220139287,
-0.0502638221,
-0.0516806245,
-0.022760829,
0.0218648333,
0.0380377918,
-0.0246955976,
-0.0314570442,
0.0157969855,
-0.0473261364,
0.0643433779,
0.079645209,
-0.0023038853,
-0.0027061785,
0.0185139775,
-0.0158596914,
-0.0339918137,
-0.0080404738,
0.005181965,
-0.0097438823,
-0.0371849872,
0.0284693651,
-0.0512063205,
0.029053634,
-0.0344789885,
0.0094014797,
-0.0538832173,
0.0087908292,
0.0133620864,
-0.0289305188,
-0.0591228977,
-0.003050104,
-0.0397531688,
0.0087880315,
-0.0592050143,
-0.085650146,
0.0013301076,
-0.0823919699,
-0.0210718922,
0.0517020673,
0.0075366469,
-0.0308851097,
0.1036560312,
0.0616870672,
0.0099003129,
-0.042207133,
-0.0202755053,
-0.0361933038,
0.0313389339,
-0.0324340984,
0.0050286669,
0.0653586388,
-0.0681558549,
0.0086389212,
-0.0345608629,
0.0036000072,
-0.0239161216,
0.0222098902,
-0.0539186746,
0.0160963666,
-0.0228357781,
-0.0209836233,
-0.0166530255,
0.0458937623,
0.0126094315,
0.057110507,
-0.0058992766,
0.0075459536,
-0.0531940944,
0.0187867861,
0.0532573871,
0.0453711152,
-0.0425949059,
-0.0305653736,
-0.0245582014,
0.0965815485,
0.0249366332,
0.0002012525,
-0.0707843602,
0.0337678269,
0.0380885676,
0.0525131002,
0.0081262328,
0.0459302552,
0.0556399561,
-0.0956622884,
-0.0086500049,
0.0655073673,
0.005215962,
-0.0622735247,
-0.0359401293,
0.0316446014,
0.0309104528,
0.0320746712,
-0.0054434258,
-0.072284162,
-0.0690082163,
0.0132384244,
-0.05228756,
0.0408942811,
0.0106773749,
-0.0082748393,
-0.0545247681,
0.049337253,
0.0256319139,
0.0018900671,
-0.0574749559,
0.0067681521,
0.003671088,
0.0075319041,
-0.0091440855,
-0.0145041291,
0.0026756851,
-0.0183997601,
0.008364182,
0.0054217749,
-0.0029939553,
-0.0003167311,
-0.0429074988,
-0.0119735934,
0.0598449148,
0.0179255698,
0.015852686,
-0.0505414456,
0.0333089083,
0.0112304399,
-0.0078835171,
-0.003964243,
0.0141607197,
-0.0570916235,
-0.0245966855,
0.0343835056,
0.0163861588,
-0.0350380912,
-0.041527003,
-0.0113136806,
0.0884649754,
0.0012754246,
0.0066608498,
-0.0090531837,
-0.0572778247,
-0.0279329866,
0.0318627805,
0.0280233789,
-0.0154095553,
-0.0298181176,
-0.0239713956,
-0.0127459662,
-0.0097603556,
-0.0249198377,
-0.0162965339,
0.0279669985,
-0.03460541,
-0.0282561556,
0.0094756363,
0.0587480962,
0.0549090952,
-0.0193127636,
-0.0012595394,
0.0123451417,
-0.001661408,
-0.0789609849,
0.0710950568,
-0.0568491071,
0.0328725502,
-0.0524467602,
0.0184967387,
0.0176106244,
-0.0273351055,
-0.0180354007,
0.0367019698,
-0.1194504127,
-0.040994361,
-0.035271436,
0.0514323823,
0.0045170696,
0.036044497,
-0.0110719521,
-0.0181877855,
0.0454803258,
0.028035881,
-0.001309057,
0.0266990922,
-0.0104149869,
-0.0111921765,
-0.0015709504,
0.0195705388,
-0.0291676819,
-0.0091961231,
0.0033371449,
0.0089002941,
-0.0068514799,
-0.0054319068,
0.0141671533,
-0.0322366618,
0.0657378957,
-0.0164177958,
0.0452209115,
-0.037858095,
-0.0081470516,
-0.0147180529,
0.0144038787,
-0.070699811,
0.0016129571,
0.0199917257,
0.0296847671,
0.0132960938,
0.0196452457,
0.0725638345,
0.0189356059,
-0.0259185378,
0.0249840114,
-0.0060504572,
-0.0245640781,
0.0326470397,
0.0070863296,
0.0085625611,
-0.0186261144,
-0.0540229902,
-0.0113858739,
-0.0240925346,
0.030210305,
0.0382994264,
-0.0438067131,
-0.0452465639,
0.0560366176,
-0.0195963886,
-0.0571261868,
-0.0429872349,
0.0616218336,
0.0568458177,
0.013841901,
0.0241883676,
-0.0212124716,
-0.0250237584,
-0.0355292372,
0.0441872999,
-0.0100077242,
-0.0425720215,
0.0699323043,
0.0370144248,
-0.0314716473,
-0.0455227941,
0.0295228027,
0.0121693667,
0.0030473138,
-0.0167240091,
-0.0066082561,
-0.0271968152,
-0.0354056358,
0.0186989885,
0.0032452736,
-0.0012255261,
0.0414999388,
0.019558046,
-0.049506221,
0.003430631,
0.0223502722,
-0.0083060032,
0.0119223688,
0.0229319148,
0.0338035524,
0.0075552193,
-0.0404849686,
-0.0002495406,
-0.0266382787,
0.0507694483,
-0.0085621374,
0.0143102268,
-5.838592278e-33,
-0.0233753063,
-0.0314201042,
0.0488433056,
-0.0340015478,
-0.0216405597,
0.035496287,
-0.0053130095,
0.0028662274,
0.0101964753,
-0.0123533364,
0.0267194398,
0.0055304808,
0.0163011439,
0.0658089295,
0.0142784258,
0.0041323546,
0.0554984473,
-0.003820281,
0.0169915333,
-0.0240927041,
0.0009711214,
0.0070321988,
0.0460660607,
-0.0221133847,
-0.0434925668,
0.0322009362,
-0.0219546072,
0.0364607088,
0.0261744652,
0.0574036129,
-0.0380999781,
0.0069535766,
0.0275488049,
-0.0045398106,
-0.0328961648,
0.0488951616,
-0.0609261207,
0.0035683974,
-0.0147257196,
0.0605422407,
-0.0805402696,
-0.0141011961,
0.0413436033,
-0.0082644252,
0.0215948708,
-0.0265201237,
0.0208444651,
-0.0201745722,
-0.0239204895,
0.0234151166,
-0.0264921654,
0.0158812422,
0.0336851068,
-0.0119495764,
0.0700098798,
-0.0204147194,
0.0294491556,
0.0215712097,
-0.0603317134,
0.0085258307,
-0.030684568,
0.0469573587,
0.0674995631,
0.0811738074,
0.0399775058,
0.0525860153,
0.0339597091,
-0.0632279143,
-0.0489649884,
0.0060838689,
0.031267006,
0.0252749529,
0.0240391083,
0.035841316,
0.0066286433,
0.0076626879,
-0.0214372184,
-0.0283671189,
-0.0186408851,
0.0612278357,
0.0429405272,
0.0503366664,
-0.0068939435,
-0.0161133334,
-0.0159872472,
-0.0068612508,
-0.0346281268,
0.0103103891,
0.0712021664,
0.0619542822,
0.0073394501,
0.0069847396,
0.073251754,
-0.0264357049,
-0.0082277907,
0.0213695765,
0.0011572618,
0.0527732186,
0.0081147859,
0.0297984947,
-0.0372971855,
-0.0341985896,
0.054332979,
-0.0422614254,
-0.0140381493,
-0.0165991653,
0.0273923688,
0.0253043063,
-0.0750952736,
-0.0098307552,
-0.0474535935,
-0.0365785323,
0.0221639369,
0.0369962342,
0.0510434285,
-0.0175422709,
-0.0178590026,
0.0216491316,
-0.0391833857,
-0.0154886367,
-0.019407222,
-0.0485466868,
-0.0249346532,
0.0268745404,
-0.0243949722,
0.0051517896,
-0.0505334772,
-0.0342471488,
0.0232973062,
-0.0428583696,
-0.0222850777,
0.0201334283,
2.618e-7,
0.0124843419,
0.0142988591,
0.0091695208,
0.0148607194,
0.0159105696,
0.0448303521,
-0.0031034409,
0.030584611,
0.0078091263,
-0.0619625896,
0.00129907,
0.0609780401,
0.0159282051,
-0.0247938074,
-0.0682658926,
0.0634561032,
0.005480085,
0.0143503025,
-0.0286148153,
0.012002809,
0.0641346201,
0.1055334806,
-0.0085364664,
-0.0048932331,
0.0610747039,
-0.049501054,
0.0608957373,
-0.0458139479,
0.0061601009,
-0.0327377357,
-0.0109503195,
0.0203144904,
-0.0092084603,
0.0178871583,
0.029605601,
0.0017541971,
0.021892,
0.0448202938,
-0.0348797515,
-0.0114638787,
-0.0207082685,
0.0128938789,
-0.026756268,
-0.0441000648,
0.0673433095,
-0.0583216213,
0.0009643806,
-0.0582939796,
-0.0004365106,
-0.017766444,
-0.0215019658,
0.0076737674,
-0.0359886885,
0.0214739535,
0.0514979549,
-0.0414498337,
-0.016257422,
-0.0833295882,
-0.026172949,
-0.017297633,
-0.0749778897,
-0.022404829,
-0.0837520286,
0.0053163669,
0.0338990167,
-0.0158359781,
-0.0635120347,
2.335730693e-34,
0.0028000078,
0.0022747293,
-0.0055914768,
0.0320497416,
0.030306438,
-0.0332660452,
-0.030361494,
0.0026504516,
-0.0073198881,
-0.0651449412,
-0.0271721575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06607v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06607v3 | Monkey: Image Resolution and Text Label Are Important Things for Large Multi-modal Models | 2023-11-11T16:37:41 | 2024-02-22T06:23:26 | Zhang Li, Biao Yang, Qiang Liu, Zhiyin Ma, Shuo Zhang, Jingxu Yang, Yabo Sun, Yuliang Liu, Xiang Bai | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have shown promise in vision-language tasks
but struggle with high-resolution input and detailed scene understanding.
Addressing these challenges, we introduce Monkey to enhance LMM capabilities.
Firstly, Monkey processes input images by dividing them into uniform patches,
each matching the size (e.g., 448x448) used in the original training of the
well-trained vision encoder. Equipped with individual adapter for each patch,
Monkey can handle higher resolutions up to 1344x896 pixels, enabling the
detailed capture of complex visual information. Secondly, it employs a
multi-level description generation method, enriching the context for
scene-object associations. This two-part strategy ensures more effective
learning from generated data: the higher resolution allows for a more detailed
capture of visuals, which in turn enhances the effectiveness of comprehensive
descriptions. Extensive ablative results validate the effectiveness of our
designs. Additionally, experiments on 18 datasets further demonstrate that
Monkey surpasses existing LMMs in many tasks like Image Captioning and various
Visual Question Answering formats. Specially, in qualitative tests focused on
dense text question answering, Monkey has exhibited encouraging results
compared with GPT4V. Code is available at
https://github.com/Yuliang-Liu/Monkey. | [
0.0138002662,
0.0905683488,
0.0006953233,
0.0586064979,
0.0034371221,
0.0044629718,
0.0272005685,
-0.0233929493,
-0.011698612,
-0.0810661912,
-0.0271798149,
-0.0139910001,
-0.0022963318,
0.0709183738,
0.0387303717,
-0.0883174911,
0.0130440285,
-0.0206298754,
0.0193943698,
-0.0083523616,
0.0114452271,
0.0257595368,
0.0086986218,
0.0233901497,
-0.0214276034,
-0.0362900048,
-0.04669521,
0.0176444203,
0.0281985532,
-0.0407402106,
-0.0067739091,
0.0398850404,
0.0683785826,
0.0118874516,
0.0000019924,
-0.0022335239,
0.0354279093,
-0.0030777068,
0.0244793538,
0.0213675741,
0.0205785092,
-0.0580263697,
0.0188344847,
-0.0248226542,
-0.0251561943,
-0.032137014,
0.0675963908,
0.0466187857,
0.060596548,
0.0433429852,
-0.0252571478,
-0.0376000106,
0.054566402,
-0.0059538176,
0.0316163003,
-0.0334706753,
-0.011151772,
0.0556139499,
0.0191051681,
0.0238631126,
-0.0640162453,
0.0331131481,
0.0545828268,
-0.0184300225,
0.0136757176,
0.0553666539,
0.0014828827,
-0.0386982858,
-0.0302054584,
0.0845581666,
-0.0145071223,
0.0002752926,
-0.0561084971,
0.0176563971,
0.0011751761,
-0.0115582943,
-0.0370538495,
0.0378800854,
-0.0368805528,
0.0093844105,
-0.0770368278,
-0.0118825361,
-0.0015264333,
0.0210522506,
-0.0146177942,
-0.0321900956,
0.0103942798,
0.0207253322,
-0.0343045667,
-0.0031708318,
-0.0456523225,
-0.0454779752,
-0.0152106145,
0.0606941134,
-0.0280288085,
-0.0293137543,
-0.0339791663,
-0.0098411813,
0.0047723125,
-0.01647784,
0.019434493,
-0.0098393448,
-0.0584279373,
0.0655325204,
-0.0308481753,
0.065325968,
-0.0459151864,
0.0714175552,
-0.0498454571,
-0.042850133,
-0.046339348,
-0.0303121414,
-0.0300970599,
0.0058299475,
-0.0420837998,
-0.0426495522,
-0.0029995539,
0.0477926433,
-0.0127379335,
-0.0035521076,
-0.0450811163,
0.0476534553,
-0.032485839,
-0.0339664556,
-0.0553458259,
0.0650754422,
-0.0333410129,
0.0367028452,
0.0115680238,
-0.0227523744,
-0.0011469265,
0.0203879848,
0.010593541,
-0.0411550999,
0.0002260022,
0.0955740064,
-0.0455625951,
-0.0130107524,
-0.0052483757,
-0.0269751977,
-0.0163507927,
-0.0451512039,
0.0169414952,
-0.0349320956,
0.0437433533,
-0.0158187822,
0.002029977,
0.0034900538,
0.0053548594,
0.0307264738,
0.0034478768,
0.0976763442,
-0.0377048403,
-0.0091513442,
0.0287816338,
0.0265216306,
0.0125206988,
0.0404720195,
0.0293945652,
0.0570599623,
0.017765047,
-0.0279509407,
0.0165212359,
-0.0000705217,
-0.010042958,
-0.0182990115,
-0.0133904787,
0.0189928096,
0.0268495083,
0.0357631259,
0.0563275255,
0.0532936752,
-0.028354656,
-0.019060716,
0.082637772,
-0.0022652599,
0.0110497903,
0.0128362747,
0.0285591595,
-0.0035920297,
0.0005596101,
-0.0029943541,
-0.0688050464,
0.0813003629,
0.0013986474,
0.0134082595,
0.0103036994,
0.061771445,
-0.0372892022,
-0.0245005284,
-0.0118569732,
-0.0242478475,
-0.0013956842,
0.0231077541,
0.0408702046,
0.0147397313,
-0.0085896486,
-0.0034403324,
0.0240718164,
-0.0055450131,
0.0106961075,
-0.0285108034,
0.02997992,
0.0494281128,
0.0284217261,
0.0116218319,
-0.0112843048,
-0.0181696247,
0.0234893225,
0.0307316221,
0.0169273634,
-0.0206465926,
0.0380646326,
-0.0593383461,
-0.0474647358,
-0.0548706055,
-0.02777173,
0.0138050634,
0.0197744425,
-0.0200744625,
0.0188444909,
-0.0462823734,
0.0130626624,
0.0421671756,
0.0288281813,
-0.0266683474,
-0.0160657316,
0.0020613708,
0.0198331885,
-0.0161394347,
-0.0109537728,
-0.0132346861,
0.0340067074,
-0.0398885719,
0.006291714,
0.0047555827,
-0.0485917702,
-0.048184108,
0.011259906,
-0.0554728508,
-0.0192117542,
0.042603828,
-0.0435764939,
-0.0289038531,
-0.0138883879,
-0.0186985005,
-0.0193745904,
-0.0682818145,
-0.0494709797,
0.0206991602,
0.0467484742,
-0.0304893758,
0.0623248816,
-0.0000547608,
-0.0332030319,
0.0376661904,
0.0338609703,
-0.0101588694,
0.0004637488,
-0.0240552276,
0.0139946146,
-0.0098721795,
0.0124934092,
-0.0011957547,
0.0214066543,
-0.037706729,
-0.0177705139,
-0.1076558083,
-0.0135748638,
0.0000755461,
-0.0303166844,
0.0042688074,
0.0140301269,
0.0199632868,
-0.0423739739,
-0.0389122665,
0.0343707055,
0.0161752328,
0.0223073773,
0.0252456758,
0.0320142433,
0.0260385647,
0.001978477,
0.0118677597,
0.0038310271,
0.0625863895,
0.0246327464,
0.0113462284,
-0.0298226383,
-0.0351327807,
-0.035356652,
0.0232549571,
-0.0198251922,
-0.0115262745,
0.0181268509,
-0.0269990899,
0.0350131579,
0.0602316968,
0.0291719697,
0.037515074,
0.0360598937,
0.0009608297,
-0.0245757904,
0.0179778375,
0.0117718652,
-0.050740663,
-0.0290360563,
-0.0098522017,
-0.0346490443,
0.0522075146,
-0.0119776139,
-0.0008699474,
-0.0347790085,
0.0315610096,
0.0424859673,
-0.0447687879,
-0.0782863125,
0.0318258777,
-0.0128340935,
0.019190101,
-0.0477049462,
-0.0776314139,
0.0574635081,
-0.0194309428,
-0.0323475748,
0.0160904564,
-0.0087003708,
-0.0209865049,
0.1067837402,
0.0440063663,
0.0349374525,
-0.0176664479,
0.0098048877,
-0.0490934588,
-0.0043624113,
-0.0011433616,
0.0315829739,
0.0290368795,
-0.0657586753,
0.006764363,
-0.0605079234,
-0.0340389758,
-0.0034849397,
-0.0423360467,
-0.0127568673,
0.0166023597,
-0.0533350073,
0.0240939595,
-0.0042794975,
0.0297823977,
0.0568074994,
0.0136897303,
-0.0200048368,
-0.0084727006,
-0.0145352939,
0.0518489853,
0.054523956,
0.0762289688,
-0.011621356,
-0.0493808612,
0.0137795946,
0.0576462969,
0.0094483243,
0.0209784843,
-0.047597155,
0.0145531017,
-0.0128317755,
0.0576934069,
-0.0026609232,
0.0333779566,
0.0769214109,
-0.0586631559,
-0.0053293514,
0.0677970648,
-0.0119715873,
-0.0470411256,
-0.0081504518,
0.004569096,
0.0448377617,
0.0307565294,
0.0179663729,
-0.0783535466,
-0.0514063872,
-0.039802894,
-0.0332993157,
0.0435109697,
0.0312694646,
-0.0133299371,
-0.0692979246,
0.0426331833,
0.0009894124,
-0.060539335,
-0.042267032,
0.0132715488,
-0.0137207024,
0.0048375791,
-0.0039466508,
0.0118686911,
-0.0095892921,
0.0050347955,
0.0150963003,
0.0725589842,
-0.0324698985,
0.0331486762,
-0.0442030095,
-0.0041995458,
0.0343885906,
-0.0001928143,
-0.0271359459,
-0.02007512,
0.0043819901,
0.0287131444,
0.0077160364,
0.0189206395,
0.0611226857,
-0.0264213104,
-0.0228639059,
-0.0083363205,
0.0241874382,
-0.0285490602,
-0.0219503157,
0.0181926992,
0.0385406315,
-0.0144211818,
-0.005694842,
-0.0344554409,
-0.0028688335,
-0.019852221,
0.0293983743,
0.0191584881,
-0.0300536305,
-0.0496129282,
-0.0149471993,
-0.0240417421,
-0.0483109504,
0.0021199791,
0.0259263348,
-0.0146588366,
0.0023604876,
-0.059534613,
-0.0435615405,
0.0514368787,
0.0366726965,
-0.020279374,
-0.0419072844,
-0.0283917878,
0.030821776,
-0.0537646972,
0.0573611185,
-0.0260234028,
0.0119999247,
-0.0283433944,
-0.0002423254,
0.0422499031,
-0.0389268249,
-0.002291563,
0.029958209,
-0.0704570934,
-0.0107699977,
-0.0495745689,
0.0629542768,
0.0101812249,
0.0607863329,
0.033944577,
-0.0216259807,
0.0031358602,
-0.0047800788,
-0.0034787098,
0.0207165927,
-0.002497772,
-0.0096943974,
-0.0036256658,
0.0208209995,
-0.053495232,
0.0196598265,
-0.0235293228,
-0.0071134237,
-0.0065516531,
-0.0514152646,
0.013350009,
0.0105748624,
0.0350828059,
-0.0162735507,
0.0210249983,
-0.0221376847,
0.0275917482,
-0.00707793,
-0.0158602521,
-0.0537162051,
0.0178535096,
0.0175333414,
0.0034015933,
0.0306406058,
-0.0054624202,
0.0436395369,
0.0440492071,
-0.0349081457,
-0.0163249988,
0.0285110958,
-0.0402037427,
0.0029112461,
0.0350776948,
-0.0250249933,
0.0129963206,
-0.0195502304,
0.0537869036,
-0.0241166335,
0.0659360811,
0.0231172107,
-0.0425221659,
-0.0283839405,
0.0305909496,
-0.0313408487,
-0.0161706265,
-0.0647810921,
0.0272406545,
0.0270483121,
0.0260805357,
0.0017243482,
0.0122785959,
-0.0227627773,
-0.0396430977,
0.0544317625,
0.0193074867,
-0.044903595,
0.0668927133,
0.0242094677,
-0.0086323554,
-0.029042609,
0.073059611,
0.0159128048,
0.0328737907,
0.0234501287,
0.017211413,
-0.0347031876,
-0.0174170639,
0.0219943393,
0.0182090476,
0.0053654979,
0.0415585935,
0.0036490699,
-0.0386531577,
-0.016474722,
0.0242128242,
-0.0098495614,
0.0168060455,
0.0537334308,
0.0304183923,
0.0165948085,
-0.0247569811,
-0.0218464248,
0.0082468428,
-0.0221969578,
0.0364433601,
0.0082380176,
-5.771803261e-33,
-0.0539499968,
-0.0303866137,
0.0358620435,
-0.043143522,
-0.0173236858,
-0.001647893,
-0.0296463352,
0.0151413511,
-0.039968621,
0.0075696302,
0.0401439071,
-0.0338283442,
-0.0060625519,
0.0764698535,
0.020183159,
-0.0025225712,
0.0135443378,
0.0018114316,
-0.0026800022,
0.0089470427,
0.0240241122,
0.0100273909,
0.0540529452,
-0.0333313979,
-0.0266672298,
0.0156706236,
-0.0351855457,
0.0044349465,
-0.0310265031,
0.0678586438,
-0.0465230979,
0.054531794,
0.0498821177,
0.0087066116,
-0.0344427265,
0.02180502,
-0.0825037807,
0.0057014502,
0.0065755779,
0.0098264096,
-0.1002059728,
-0.0195113737,
0.0234049968,
-0.0446891934,
0.0557804704,
-0.0749670044,
0.0599719509,
-0.0473396406,
-0.0184321217,
0.0063650403,
-0.0523785204,
-0.0113138026,
0.0084866779,
-0.0456330292,
0.0149789061,
0.0494728386,
0.0290699229,
0.0342932306,
-0.0136093181,
-0.009531389,
0.0128851384,
0.0203105249,
0.0625606701,
0.0584020726,
0.0128434421,
0.0502320081,
0.0083642527,
-0.0610694885,
-0.0385671258,
0.0253749341,
0.0033262712,
0.0633642897,
0.0495895892,
0.0851205066,
0.025579948,
0.0378750376,
-0.0332787856,
0.0306344442,
-0.0529403351,
0.061686594,
-0.0086487671,
0.0160575826,
0.0464548767,
0.0089052347,
-0.0396968722,
0.02447889,
-0.0426850244,
-0.0195641257,
0.0546245612,
0.0139652733,
-0.0219217464,
0.0231345836,
0.0583950467,
-0.0536870733,
0.0066359374,
0.007693381,
-0.0531035475,
0.0473023318,
0.0069688358,
0.0076692831,
-0.0231762994,
-0.0109593328,
0.0725261196,
-0.0031834301,
0.0029637052,
0.0152376089,
0.0373974703,
0.0213029571,
-0.0326140113,
-0.0059702811,
-0.0521106012,
-0.0040848614,
-0.0064863102,
0.0429144204,
0.0068989778,
-0.0283252448,
-0.0589198805,
0.0104152691,
-0.0344021022,
0.0013725751,
-0.0348729901,
-0.0393583365,
-0.0043695439,
0.035161797,
-0.0237767138,
0.0189550463,
-0.0544806011,
-0.0662019998,
0.0245624967,
-0.0489535779,
-0.0076913596,
0.0692383945,
2.502e-7,
0.0211889856,
0.0122346412,
0.0347028449,
-0.0281680021,
0.0328456089,
0.0515617281,
-0.011378129,
0.0543567725,
-0.0193030778,
-0.062794216,
-0.002705106,
0.0446609631,
0.0442875922,
0.0306816567,
-0.0141334226,
0.036095541,
-0.0537498295,
-0.0136942668,
-0.0442415662,
0.0007353451,
0.0733523518,
0.0987730622,
-0.0344961323,
-0.0210265387,
0.0598711073,
-0.073311381,
0.088698864,
-0.0140089095,
-0.0195021201,
-0.0109879049,
-0.0035027664,
0.0524347648,
-0.0135063417,
0.0227269344,
-0.0087071676,
-0.0529825576,
0.0393736288,
0.080880478,
-0.0205353145,
-0.0281807519,
-0.02412856,
0.0202795062,
-0.0169862881,
-0.0615857467,
0.0926802903,
-0.0720210671,
-0.0353578404,
-0.0377411246,
-0.0239083096,
-0.0249551814,
0.0048302449,
-0.0386185534,
-0.0233782902,
-0.000777136,
0.0167154707,
-0.0137551455,
-0.0243636984,
-0.073291041,
-0.0121808844,
0.0017489314,
-0.0704161078,
-0.0045875921,
-0.0546796992,
-0.0465836078,
0.0664693564,
-0.0576300882,
-0.0479294956,
1.773961369e-34,
-0.0112991724,
-0.0219938271,
0.0107136536,
0.0076689837,
0.0148315467,
-0.0050670574,
-0.0503322817,
-0.0286337435,
-0.0251033604,
-0.069129996,
-0.0324402526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06602v2 | BizBench: A Quantitative Reasoning Benchmark for Business and Finance | 2023-11-11T16:16:11 | 2024-03-12T16:54:57 | Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Michael Krumdick, Viet Lai, Varshini Reddy, Charles Lovering, Chris Tanner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering questions within business and finance requires reasoning,
precision, and a wide-breadth of technical knowledge. Together, these
requirements make this domain difficult for large language models (LLMs). We
introduce BizBench, a benchmark for evaluating models' ability to reason about
realistic financial problems. BizBench comprises eight quantitative reasoning
tasks, focusing on question-answering (QA) over financial data via program
synthesis. We include three financially-themed code-generation tasks from newly
collected and augmented QA data. Additionally, we isolate the reasoning
capabilities required for financial QA: reading comprehension of financial text
and tables for extracting intermediate values, and understanding financial
concepts and formulas needed to calculate complex solutions. Collectively,
these tasks evaluate a model's financial background knowledge, ability to parse
financial documents, and capacity to solve problems with code. We conduct an
in-depth evaluation of open-source and commercial LLMs, comparing and
contrasting the behavior of code-focused and language-focused models. We
demonstrate that the current bottleneck in performance is due to LLMs' limited
business and financial understanding, highlighting the value of a challenging
benchmark for quantitative reasoning within this domain. | [
-0.0134722488,
0.097982727,
-0.0029388249,
0.0339953862,
-0.0073643033,
0.0228791591,
-0.0026437757,
0.0098723406,
0.0009470716,
-0.0124031929,
-0.0075565507,
-0.0242930315,
-0.0193261579,
0.0591286905,
0.0461644977,
0.0008266678,
0.0223661177,
-0.0395660661,
0.0530429445,
-0.0189511683,
0.0093657412,
0.0067675659,
-0.0062716929,
-0.0101527162,
0.0217810851,
-0.030792661,
0.0006777018,
-0.0093431883,
-0.0159553289,
-0.0035618062,
-0.0167805869,
0.0296011399,
0.0142770335,
0.011246616,
0.0000021995,
-0.0677338764,
-0.046613656,
0.0158865731,
-0.0445968956,
0.0108891828,
-0.0071234968,
-0.0112894578,
0.0432150289,
0.0297384728,
-0.0738087669,
0.0378321633,
0.0453462489,
0.0040369495,
0.0607146844,
0.0542303771,
0.0055872006,
-0.0659286305,
0.0024548585,
-0.0254357941,
0.0089260805,
-0.0928508937,
-0.0052855639,
0.1114346012,
0.0359005593,
-0.0256557968,
-0.0275106877,
0.0455560312,
0.0421856195,
0.0027946257,
0.0149493981,
0.0338549875,
-0.0223945677,
0.0140910242,
-0.0192671269,
0.0467331745,
0.0227597933,
0.0293024518,
0.0315912068,
-0.0181012154,
0.0009975409,
-0.0189484414,
-0.0319478661,
0.0340375192,
-0.0231130235,
-0.0065403343,
-0.0049188072,
-0.013674289,
0.0312208589,
0.0164717548,
-0.0461007915,
0.0699968264,
-0.0352925025,
-0.0311465245,
0.0312829651,
-0.0082022585,
-0.0167211983,
-0.0505340472,
0.0008071408,
0.0651786625,
-0.0022428355,
0.012392452,
0.0060639004,
0.0199101605,
0.0009816259,
-0.0460402369,
0.0233291145,
0.0481782705,
0.0176765248,
0.0629098415,
-0.0408555195,
0.0671910495,
-0.0240110196,
-0.0436402373,
-0.0313048437,
0.0176669452,
-0.0531660505,
-0.0231696963,
-0.0473210067,
0.0666932538,
-0.048904676,
-0.0152840335,
-0.0345332697,
0.0087794121,
-0.0305631347,
0.0541685373,
0.0074584922,
0.0111668771,
0.0010694041,
-0.0315465592,
-0.0595674925,
-0.0201702546,
-0.0581419356,
-0.0118163582,
-0.0116974991,
-0.0423047878,
0.0141017111,
-0.0050558639,
-0.0625959784,
-0.0371796191,
0.0537698269,
0.0774405524,
0.0182533972,
0.0319790356,
-0.042225305,
-0.0529512987,
0.01200944,
-0.0832326412,
-0.0205058493,
-0.0676720142,
0.01011186,
0.0337987058,
-0.0394593589,
-0.0267309658,
0.0229682475,
-0.0225942638,
0.006044467,
0.0628061667,
0.0049797553,
-0.0120798759,
0.0170166343,
-0.0117055615,
0.0137627125,
0.0837845802,
0.0297993179,
-0.0114146303,
0.0144596184,
0.0018245641,
-0.0088290507,
0.0294976588,
0.0135125173,
-0.0582370423,
-0.0088214939,
0.1070183292,
-0.0031502908,
0.0163427405,
0.0332830846,
0.0280083288,
-0.0261758622,
0.0052967458,
0.0311944839,
0.0164921507,
0.0471133925,
0.0406215824,
0.006263582,
0.0038891418,
0.0552247278,
-0.0419104695,
-0.0210717022,
0.0554546192,
-0.0274288785,
0.0450131446,
-0.0140611716,
-0.0007350214,
-0.0268768985,
-0.0575161502,
0.0008026003,
0.0097643742,
-0.0269380752,
0.0425958,
0.0257674139,
-0.0167576503,
-0.0347790159,
0.0952200741,
-0.0199479107,
-0.0164723843,
-0.0169240087,
-0.041788701,
0.0635535568,
0.0737847164,
0.0442484431,
-0.0554032996,
0.0155788958,
-0.0074406695,
-0.0186157655,
0.0241142008,
0.073083885,
-0.0192504525,
-0.0167376176,
-0.0280158687,
0.0034705915,
-0.0361411721,
0.0042797388,
0.0200734176,
0.0233689733,
-0.0159640703,
-0.0032125583,
-0.0433921181,
0.0155019639,
0.0017484027,
-0.0481290035,
-0.0469126962,
-0.019253131,
-0.0172487292,
-0.0108961714,
0.019563511,
-0.0044100503,
0.0462526195,
-0.0228444859,
-0.01108923,
-0.0115437321,
-0.0220152251,
-0.0216245558,
0.02135529,
0.0205779057,
-0.0229243655,
-0.0403038897,
0.0124851726,
-0.0343345627,
0.0025067125,
0.0445322134,
-0.024378743,
-0.0009268047,
-0.0396195166,
-0.0230600256,
-0.0144767184,
0.0034801241,
0.0101768421,
0.0718526989,
0.0101383291,
0.0407549031,
-0.0179188605,
0.0130837541,
-0.0082534691,
-0.0454622209,
0.0409921519,
0.0135847284,
-0.0410882123,
0.0267550331,
0.0052636787,
0.0177030731,
-0.0389775001,
-0.0035449441,
-0.0382024162,
-0.0062541002,
-0.0087377494,
0.0533887558,
0.0227573738,
-0.0214844383,
0.003275099,
-0.001985756,
-0.047472313,
-0.0118050817,
0.0053100204,
0.013049338,
0.0577112883,
-0.0011546704,
-0.020635603,
-0.0335718356,
-0.013020088,
-0.0192442108,
0.0297069214,
0.0424983911,
0.0475073643,
-0.0318413861,
-0.023865046,
-0.0417386554,
0.0032660686,
0.0015299608,
0.0222821217,
0.022974018,
-0.024459077,
0.0253589787,
0.0517656282,
-0.0173302982,
0.0271785725,
-0.0291892774,
-0.0375743955,
-0.0441079251,
0.0291606747,
-0.0115211876,
0.0247892011,
-0.0287790205,
-0.0267083365,
0.0033175373,
0.0747403055,
-0.0492137149,
0.0063635446,
-0.0378115661,
0.0890350044,
-0.0038576936,
-0.0048473817,
-0.0436804146,
0.0160301309,
0.0150783034,
0.0931542963,
-0.0042124363,
-0.028564591,
0.0397607535,
-0.0250603613,
-0.0374020971,
0.0006444508,
-0.0001988931,
-0.0735274404,
0.0670652017,
-0.0446873605,
0.0069659203,
-0.0408826508,
-0.0356145315,
-0.0446364619,
-0.0397681072,
0.044435557,
-0.0496974699,
0.0655456856,
-0.0624024831,
0.0087032067,
0.0100035677,
-0.0059443493,
-0.021392012,
-0.0053705447,
-0.0336569138,
0.0324330144,
0.0497212633,
-0.0253779422,
-0.0178850777,
0.0101348348,
0.0366817378,
-0.0252969097,
-0.014067404,
-0.0442611352,
0.0116826817,
0.0153469164,
0.0390807986,
-0.0078664515,
0.079065606,
-0.0487808622,
0.0466796868,
0.0265930407,
0.0273745935,
0.002678941,
-0.0180195421,
0.0090405392,
-0.008611368,
-0.0281789917,
0.0112581681,
0.0377702117,
-0.0066449526,
-0.0532888249,
-0.0318505503,
0.0830435082,
0.0222165342,
0.0470718406,
0.0031883765,
-0.0378666259,
0.0084676547,
0.0356647447,
0.0787874088,
-0.0997556746,
-0.0161085371,
-0.0068938658,
0.0383562073,
0.0119595351,
-0.0731262043,
-0.0509373471,
-0.1312212646,
0.0434982069,
-0.0182493404,
-0.0167116225,
-0.0485383719,
-0.0359717309,
-0.042531155,
-0.03807142,
-0.0147306882,
0.0593716465,
-0.0036622386,
0.0023898473,
0.0043012658,
-0.0657619014,
0.0394322313,
0.0614292435,
0.0174836107,
-0.0419024192,
0.03870482,
0.0369813368,
-0.0087689413,
0.0136707807,
-0.0322592929,
-0.006618828,
-0.0209060945,
-0.0089151086,
0.0325115509,
0.0191804934,
-0.0225921851,
0.0160690229,
0.044037316,
-0.0534929074,
0.0188038442,
0.0322813429,
0.0373459756,
-0.0018069597,
-0.0289184116,
-0.0004261577,
0.0236023106,
-0.0342311189,
0.0678178966,
0.0086595202,
-0.0230760276,
-0.070321843,
-0.0497679226,
-0.0565112904,
-0.0956278965,
0.0147498474,
-0.0245489012,
0.0307349991,
0.005755716,
-0.0590548702,
-0.0486810356,
0.0468073413,
0.0254557189,
-0.0208992045,
-0.034564089,
0.0670377314,
0.0010352479,
-0.0410012715,
0.0083773788,
-0.0697185695,
0.0585060753,
-0.0325421095,
0.0214199908,
-0.0219229292,
-0.0626903027,
-0.0689875633,
0.0184753258,
-0.0903328732,
-0.0320464075,
-0.0055619408,
0.0369517319,
0.0304332394,
-0.0232106932,
-0.0422658287,
0.0141340178,
-0.0180200096,
0.0242665727,
-0.0748375431,
-0.0019357121,
0.0472841226,
0.0111045502,
0.0081223575,
0.0349834524,
-0.076708369,
0.0263761766,
-0.0167883411,
0.0470329821,
-0.0336197615,
-0.0133716902,
-0.0015348434,
0.0341443568,
-0.0375399105,
0.0542394742,
-0.0311808251,
-0.0064736428,
0.0000137202,
0.0011963048,
-0.0194885153,
-0.0314360075,
-0.0288024209,
0.0339629427,
-0.0318084285,
0.0238413606,
0.0156123387,
-0.0079397373,
-0.0167470425,
0.0246051978,
0.0387476198,
0.0038052613,
0.02800202,
0.0505524799,
-0.0575604178,
0.0039384174,
-0.023894703,
0.0036436899,
0.0414725393,
0.0185740609,
0.0403362066,
0.0070244619,
0.0119072879,
-0.0166132078,
-0.0300035775,
-0.0358341746,
-0.0869370922,
0.0320619307,
0.0128613897,
0.0010145443,
0.0006305309,
-0.013516143,
-0.0406563394,
0.0133697577,
0.0249473192,
0.0039029906,
0.0341034755,
-0.0607141964,
0.030887261,
0.0447654687,
-0.0246926006,
-0.053410437,
0.1066124365,
0.009820709,
0.0092764944,
-0.0517995209,
0.0110322358,
-0.0464681759,
-0.0691852868,
0.0056917355,
-0.0061048614,
0.003512257,
0.0131233614,
-0.101092428,
-0.0575978979,
-0.0041427016,
0.0365049243,
-0.0259273946,
-0.007538463,
0.021503076,
0.069302246,
0.0294879396,
0.0248166732,
-0.0050182864,
0.0598695651,
-0.0584460087,
0.0020470624,
-0.0347439274,
-6.245245733e-33,
0.0002522904,
-0.0294220485,
0.0647803843,
-0.0194216445,
0.0443098061,
0.0038778202,
-0.0510594398,
-0.0033382149,
-0.0331606381,
-0.0035782363,
-0.0027167476,
0.0339673124,
-0.0019045001,
-0.0068836608,
0.0217695534,
-0.0154415919,
-0.0047247708,
-0.0253555868,
-0.0234372336,
-0.0208562501,
-0.0081448918,
0.0374407731,
0.0359494463,
-0.0241212193,
0.0281681977,
-0.0104025342,
-0.0270023607,
0.0253380165,
0.0137413042,
0.0371537283,
0.0077579087,
0.0079962518,
-0.0007588213,
-0.0870341137,
-0.0198561717,
-0.0063108634,
-0.0446425788,
-0.0316593498,
0.0165101346,
0.0049642692,
-0.0103474325,
0.0002060683,
0.0405137949,
0.0292937551,
0.0016877707,
-0.0536161065,
0.0157254692,
-0.0323234685,
0.0434586033,
-0.0415034741,
-0.0530131012,
0.0362612233,
-0.0592258759,
0.0379369035,
0.0354422107,
0.0808132142,
-0.0310960896,
0.0346453413,
0.0216059592,
0.014872971,
0.0111983316,
0.0196393449,
0.0694981962,
-0.0193118714,
0.0234369226,
0.0289417412,
0.0091115301,
-0.0127068125,
-0.0074513708,
0.0225563403,
-0.0068039694,
0.0618325807,
0.0599006936,
0.0273961201,
0.0248613581,
0.0261573102,
-0.0565235317,
0.004741509,
0.0044556079,
0.0374763571,
0.0172184501,
0.0130016776,
-0.0208363626,
-0.0272234194,
-0.0269583594,
0.017071845,
-0.0498811491,
0.0035282727,
0.0225380752,
-0.0223777872,
-0.0146364849,
0.0227512736,
0.0097255958,
-0.0452421755,
-0.061893519,
0.0217592642,
0.024747774,
0.0082375519,
0.0241125226,
0.0494654663,
-0.0626264066,
-0.0063675405,
-0.0115211718,
0.0128164105,
0.0396267362,
0.0160072539,
0.009046698,
0.0023840945,
-0.0381022319,
-0.0220441259,
-0.0554623865,
0.048879385,
0.0095259268,
0.0534805954,
-0.0012785917,
0.0399386659,
-0.0019773322,
0.0087085068,
-0.0267104395,
-0.016034225,
-0.0217711926,
0.0006084346,
-0.0071404562,
0.0543418899,
0.0003082155,
-0.020692993,
-0.0197843239,
0.0593658872,
0.0361927673,
-0.0351017639,
-0.0465872772,
0.0836498737,
2.963e-7,
0.0622845292,
0.0422644205,
0.0057721883,
0.0650835112,
0.0098330658,
0.0334875435,
-0.03016367,
-0.0337475464,
0.0066740108,
-0.0132749761,
0.0036678403,
0.0459266789,
0.0623409189,
0.0384574048,
-0.0466606505,
-0.0290439948,
-0.0620884337,
0.0045922417,
-0.0505767465,
0.010209932,
0.0287707429,
0.0384770222,
-0.003458811,
-0.0190105233,
0.0107282456,
-0.0687041506,
0.0352874137,
-0.0300927162,
0.0184089504,
0.0285330694,
-0.0135107283,
0.0129133146,
0.0134910475,
0.0086895954,
-0.0067329509,
-0.0019529839,
0.0142650781,
0.0671518669,
0.0332399048,
0.0142763918,
-0.0031607526,
-0.0456943996,
0.0003516552,
-0.0611755252,
0.0589008145,
-0.0470248051,
-0.0343355611,
-0.0238093045,
-0.0463660769,
-0.0107441461,
-0.0083744144,
-0.0039270404,
0.0324526615,
-0.0032442927,
0.0032571526,
-0.0461858474,
0.0424448885,
-0.0123052374,
-0.0336523503,
0.0309648924,
-0.0265051816,
-0.0043258625,
-0.0483919978,
0.0221633911,
0.0252036564,
-0.0551302657,
0.0076558879,
2.624560446e-34,
0.0578915812,
-0.0207590126,
0.0032306679,
0.0269307662,
0.0915661752,
-0.0032089788,
-0.0442473367,
0.0338546485,
-0.0097657787,
-0.0577653646,
-0.0132540381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06595v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06595v3 | From Classification to Generation: Insights into Crosslingual Retrieval Augmented ICL | 2023-11-11T15:40:21 | 2023-12-02T17:00:27 | Xiaoqian Li, Ercong Nie, Sheng Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to understand and
follow instructions has sometimes been limited by their in-context learning
(ICL) performance in low-resource languages. To address this, we introduce a
novel approach that leverages cross-lingual retrieval-augmented in-context
learning (CREA-ICL). By extracting semantically similar prompts from
high-resource languages, we aim to improve the zero-shot performance of
multilingual pre-trained language models (MPLMs) across diverse tasks. Though
our approach yields steady improvements in classification tasks, it faces
challenges in generation tasks. Our evaluation offers insights into the
performance dynamics of retrieval-augmented in-context learning across both
classification and generation domains. | [
-0.0138992444,
0.0250517093,
0.0149452612,
0.0492712893,
-0.0316360891,
0.0134894121,
0.0348293446,
-0.0136784762,
-0.0129705193,
-0.0403484218,
-0.0644944012,
-0.0693117678,
-0.0235528015,
-0.02079615,
0.0026749286,
-0.0311333425,
0.0362323076,
-0.0453492254,
0.0016985058,
-0.004036956,
-0.0289610885,
0.0297743976,
0.0079557709,
0.0283886772,
-0.0154208662,
-0.0158488546,
0.0054216003,
0.0149245076,
0.0051565948,
-0.0430776402,
0.0014435021,
0.037695013,
0.0161346104,
0.0599931143,
0.0000018584,
-0.0607543476,
-0.0161036942,
-0.0269550309,
-0.0257199463,
-0.0045853159,
0.0240914896,
-0.0315464139,
-0.016960321,
0.0032131865,
-0.0279943552,
-0.0158701856,
0.0301514156,
0.0095527386,
0.0296351779,
0.0835200995,
-0.0004739799,
0.0085503124,
-0.0016363217,
-0.0462242961,
0.0405076966,
-0.0277704895,
-0.0093727214,
-0.0106551703,
0.0070483387,
0.0226870514,
-0.0005479212,
0.0557274036,
0.0497800335,
-0.0098710926,
-0.0484217666,
0.046395313,
0.0006831164,
-0.026718745,
-0.02037533,
0.0734731257,
-0.0354711078,
-0.0185170975,
-0.0305083152,
-0.0187908802,
-0.0040672775,
-0.0446038321,
-0.0411056615,
0.0547429547,
0.0118152499,
0.0153335724,
0.0151235117,
0.0310715195,
0.0265485756,
-0.0130085805,
-0.0195523277,
0.024720151,
0.0364975929,
-0.0324290022,
-0.0102316746,
0.0119207641,
0.0068609673,
-0.0256336574,
-0.0333939679,
0.0415921919,
-0.0720420182,
0.012728462,
-0.0442273058,
-0.0181823522,
0.0411068648,
0.0019062198,
0.0618577823,
0.0302068144,
-0.0395792425,
0.0467826165,
-0.0350783169,
0.0311522707,
-0.0193312671,
0.0129162436,
-0.0563169196,
-0.0231403876,
-0.0167462304,
-0.0112442579,
-0.0411253832,
0.0011829038,
-0.0505959168,
-0.0098735448,
-0.0555583537,
0.0394810326,
-0.0002542408,
-0.0050771772,
0.0042606923,
0.0045798961,
-0.0559622534,
-0.0219530128,
-0.0022241422,
0.0450496711,
-0.0051609841,
-0.0135611473,
0.0452926792,
-0.0663994849,
-0.0138059771,
0.0231917892,
0.0411967002,
-0.0275986139,
0.0208491106,
0.0432287231,
-0.0449918173,
-0.0498261191,
-0.0368650444,
-0.0426449068,
-0.0085738814,
-0.0768893734,
-0.0060840831,
-0.0571371056,
0.0500608608,
-0.0051138066,
-0.0179632269,
-0.0193824656,
0.0032162704,
0.0242026336,
0.002632102,
0.0415357538,
0.0234976187,
-0.0036140583,
0.0051612812,
0.0019364953,
0.0142593635,
0.0539822131,
-0.0195406191,
0.0136922635,
0.0512255393,
0.0334167741,
-0.0004663983,
0.0674980059,
0.0514412634,
0.0482984073,
-0.0178835504,
-0.009091814,
0.0275263079,
0.0135933235,
0.0370651148,
0.0290298909,
-0.0382010937,
0.0314949602,
0.0399784185,
0.0283716377,
0.0169336684,
-0.0190883484,
0.1200350299,
0.0106218103,
-0.0549750887,
-0.0042611174,
-0.0318247788,
0.0231830943,
-0.0076934458,
0.0382255018,
0.0351450816,
0.0345011503,
-0.0574709624,
-0.0226148199,
0.0303003136,
-0.0431301109,
-0.0257175714,
0.0359835327,
0.0422311127,
0.0436632782,
-0.0672241375,
0.0158861149,
0.0315898508,
-0.0709370449,
0.0217628032,
-0.0323980041,
0.0356049724,
0.0440132804,
0.0176735539,
0.016333038,
-0.0328251012,
0.0016735987,
0.0158782154,
0.0488305315,
0.0217484999,
-0.0231547803,
0.0357871093,
-0.0343082324,
-0.0345443301,
-0.0220562071,
-0.0039681871,
0.0572623983,
0.0025511663,
0.0184905529,
0.0600998737,
-0.0020237199,
-0.0086938869,
0.0103390999,
-0.0722305477,
-0.0486499108,
0.0348729305,
0.0378171392,
-0.0010173873,
0.0173272435,
-0.0084536737,
0.0164017007,
0.0262890961,
-0.0640043542,
0.0096169887,
0.0130743291,
-0.0897083282,
-0.0622689351,
0.0166312624,
0.0346046388,
-0.0069494382,
-0.0416295342,
0.0010901556,
-0.0383016691,
0.0135675995,
0.0129716489,
0.066276513,
-0.0720949993,
0.0120884879,
0.0264397152,
0.0090068839,
-0.039607957,
0.0542918779,
0.0109418957,
0.0152633991,
0.0700893626,
0.0453638323,
0.0360189453,
-0.0506505035,
-0.0012844277,
0.0187292863,
-0.0122515298,
0.0126367155,
0.0624776743,
0.0714951977,
-0.0247949939,
0.0079108104,
-0.0884289518,
-0.0068443986,
-0.0456233695,
-0.0069327531,
0.0156134441,
0.0371563323,
-0.012846631,
-0.0331907719,
-0.0315780789,
-0.0064609866,
0.0682913437,
0.0372946933,
0.0037613169,
0.029073894,
0.0033709421,
-0.0183515679,
-0.0071943998,
0.0499597527,
0.0534336343,
-0.0166153256,
0.0228647795,
-0.03532115,
0.0382033288,
-0.0435685068,
0.00237113,
-0.0000371915,
0.0053656111,
0.023273848,
-0.0537065789,
0.0647335947,
0.0135975061,
-0.0197257176,
0.0102240369,
0.0310513172,
-0.0262382124,
-0.0912747607,
0.004005278,
-0.0169367399,
-0.0414376259,
-0.0173647609,
0.0125917578,
0.0220592935,
0.0477874242,
-0.0015499052,
-0.0152680799,
-0.0425553061,
-0.0015922448,
-0.002080871,
-0.0367798246,
-0.0723159984,
0.0131594697,
-0.0134035153,
0.0584032945,
-0.0250523128,
-0.0640139505,
0.0435265638,
-0.0447388813,
-0.0221604183,
-0.0470320843,
-0.0064741583,
-0.0302180201,
0.0540066287,
-0.0150608132,
0.059907306,
-0.0105898511,
-0.0188204162,
-0.046295356,
0.0149466963,
-0.0015955435,
0.0015296709,
0.027319368,
-0.0184347369,
0.0093950946,
-0.0229061116,
-0.0419421829,
-0.0829192773,
-0.0116529381,
0.0121941511,
0.011913836,
-0.0213526543,
-0.0036319199,
-0.0100234225,
-0.0197350327,
0.0513636768,
0.0247211717,
-0.00575617,
-0.0018296823,
-0.0228716861,
0.049588073,
0.0281997863,
-0.0182650741,
-0.0107241971,
-0.0455935486,
0.0147745991,
0.021430349,
0.0449501388,
-0.0231322516,
-0.0052836947,
0.0033940056,
0.0421604626,
0.0132968407,
-0.0118436283,
0.0435053632,
0.0305282958,
-0.0443448834,
-0.0421428569,
0.0893088728,
0.0214740317,
-0.0677260906,
-0.0207104851,
-0.0193700045,
0.0376970395,
0.0264226962,
0.052526325,
-0.0729372725,
-0.0184948463,
-0.0070071095,
-0.0015387543,
0.011514469,
0.0056380657,
-0.0319979489,
-0.1600158811,
0.0378761068,
0.0010486671,
-0.0825507715,
-0.0426343121,
-0.0319186673,
-0.042221047,
0.0457580872,
0.0323883891,
0.0306010153,
0.0028121925,
-0.0040384945,
-0.0055080168,
0.0582741797,
-0.0691214278,
0.0131489839,
-0.0389807746,
0.0057941941,
0.087812759,
0.0153809469,
0.035542924,
-0.0600492507,
0.0415477268,
-0.0463419035,
0.0021440801,
-0.0184135325,
-0.0044385139,
0.0160915181,
-0.0223951377,
0.0312306602,
0.0169864986,
-0.0325755291,
-0.0169118997,
0.004393036,
0.0566177405,
-0.0115729999,
-0.0002963468,
0.006714188,
0.0052953111,
0.0610077716,
0.0618790388,
0.0313267596,
-0.0270783976,
-0.0232851282,
-0.0119946236,
-0.0023344329,
-0.0822813064,
-0.0043107714,
0.0209298003,
-0.0284101572,
0.0004184705,
-0.0636177063,
-0.0671679601,
0.0042673037,
0.0613995455,
-0.0182408784,
-0.0098853353,
-0.0310026705,
-0.0078752888,
-0.0336650088,
0.0236347411,
-0.046215713,
-0.0072721276,
-0.0766775012,
-0.0280658696,
0.0264295228,
-0.054216072,
-0.0016904706,
-0.0052812053,
-0.0388943702,
-0.0483144633,
-0.0410704166,
0.0727191567,
0.0029345741,
0.064715676,
0.0244908426,
-0.0143817812,
0.0931905583,
0.0355097316,
-0.0184021033,
0.0016826856,
0.016844416,
0.0259930305,
-0.0262661893,
0.0466838293,
-0.0543835051,
0.0574368685,
0.0189716462,
0.0608306043,
-0.020618096,
-0.0259854347,
0.0349381231,
-0.0002785013,
0.0060955458,
-0.0545245223,
-0.010207491,
-0.0411882289,
0.0064110681,
-0.0318610035,
-0.0364755839,
-0.0407918729,
-0.0174743775,
0.0202128142,
-0.0493915081,
0.0176854674,
0.0206816271,
-0.0135315759,
0.0338424519,
-0.0059247897,
-0.0358056352,
0.0147524886,
0.0185738001,
0.0160348602,
0.0118690403,
-0.0112668201,
0.0353416726,
-0.0118363183,
0.0433470942,
-0.049813956,
0.0535157882,
-0.0059049404,
0.0037271597,
-0.0279689301,
0.0271554161,
-0.0182764828,
-0.0296327099,
-0.0107496269,
0.0048597706,
0.0827909112,
-0.0105281137,
0.0565182753,
-0.0111271422,
-0.0167763606,
-0.0362926051,
0.0221060645,
0.0114660179,
-0.068181254,
0.0155766644,
0.0009849952,
-0.0097362557,
0.0320851915,
0.088084273,
-0.0339346081,
0.0155242123,
0.0039606411,
0.0355638228,
-0.0382640399,
-0.0276896954,
0.0408907719,
0.0117493244,
-0.0249939803,
0.0213978291,
-0.0232327525,
-0.0622500479,
0.0043154946,
0.0244298112,
-0.0414764062,
0.0360900201,
0.0489382334,
0.0789465085,
-0.0235155802,
0.0191591587,
-0.0466982201,
-0.0015703696,
-0.0282199234,
-0.0196841061,
0.0013401564,
-5.949457926e-33,
-0.0363853164,
0.0013397296,
0.0715429783,
-0.0194255561,
0.0123741981,
0.0124144824,
-0.0566140488,
0.0106916958,
0.0061672111,
-0.0078458078,
-0.0011019896,
-0.0483923331,
0.0078737922,
0.0799538121,
0.0110504795,
0.0115707684,
0.0411505476,
0.0025987222,
-0.0055321539,
0.0771420673,
0.0633024499,
0.0476056077,
0.0376372263,
-0.0303313937,
0.0188133456,
-0.0179658793,
0.0102736913,
0.0315543972,
0.0264569316,
0.0531023927,
-0.028676426,
0.0459636264,
0.0119774416,
-0.0331392214,
-0.0235239975,
0.0080849966,
-0.0443846211,
-0.0089054387,
-0.02785795,
-0.014472222,
-0.0492737554,
-0.0432029665,
-0.0144066829,
-0.0342696682,
-0.002632543,
0.009720291,
0.0114969593,
0.0038584103,
-0.0250142273,
-0.048649326,
-0.1041902155,
-0.0056757703,
0.0163570717,
-0.0324398428,
0.0096039642,
0.0825012326,
0.002048519,
0.0347750261,
-0.0595018491,
0.0501413606,
-0.0463707373,
0.0397518277,
0.0607379191,
0.0292539541,
-0.0177242775,
0.0305432472,
0.0084677022,
-0.0157235134,
0.0373832546,
0.013099947,
0.0569333397,
0.0342033468,
-0.0281667225,
0.1021410748,
0.029264031,
0.0086893924,
-0.0669334456,
0.0537723526,
0.0024404372,
0.0067112609,
0.0227046516,
-0.0257708654,
0.0018123664,
-0.0137669574,
-0.0276874285,
-0.0189581532,
-0.0392194502,
-0.0351864584,
0.049998112,
0.0562572628,
-0.0190160982,
-0.0163577758,
0.091636762,
-0.0052023483,
-0.0274017565,
0.0321122818,
-0.0305270739,
-0.025198929,
-0.0070447684,
0.0470683686,
-0.0553648174,
-0.0470294803,
0.0104041612,
-0.0141437249,
-0.0311304312,
0.0265317596,
0.0630439892,
0.0189968627,
-0.06717439,
0.0232489165,
-0.0420367867,
0.0566350892,
-0.0091326917,
0.0198153406,
0.0043806746,
0.0027226822,
-0.0209514089,
0.0580741316,
0.0164011661,
-0.0398235135,
0.016199531,
-0.03425318,
0.0105168708,
0.0172781721,
-0.0251526739,
0.0211482234,
-0.0591007359,
0.0528044999,
0.0295061059,
-0.0513270982,
0.0030612494,
0.00194657,
2.528e-7,
0.0288816281,
-0.0135084549,
0.0198302399,
0.0171960834,
0.0194387957,
0.0301115401,
-0.0218723696,
0.0180399362,
0.0248388108,
0.0256299991,
-0.0004060414,
0.016971888,
0.0225440394,
0.011567872,
-0.0601363331,
0.0206598267,
-0.0424367525,
0.0006105039,
-0.0620589815,
-0.0053977328,
0.0143088317,
0.0666987672,
-0.0467782803,
-0.0355049856,
0.034175545,
-0.054020822,
0.1078741476,
-0.0259726141,
-0.0272018332,
0.0100724902,
-0.0110653723,
0.0240266602,
0.0232384559,
-0.0207410827,
-0.0227753948,
0.0166358091,
-0.0048919395,
0.0315142572,
0.0367117934,
-0.0731380954,
0.0243599992,
0.0353822298,
-0.0193666704,
-0.0439013839,
0.0634096488,
-0.0737632513,
0.0177590121,
-0.0289033838,
-0.001644963,
0.010685089,
0.0280251931,
-0.0577742271,
-0.0479465425,
0.0326472484,
0.0504128374,
-0.0089943511,
-0.0234750398,
-0.0554643124,
-0.0290786885,
0.0050722063,
-0.0281003732,
-0.0235570278,
-0.0308835004,
0.0007357344,
0.0011370156,
-0.0319649279,
0.0249124654,
2.227086546e-34,
0.0166227277,
0.0126570398,
0.0316541009,
0.001589219,
-0.0132570677,
-0.01216067,
-0.0072694356,
0.0181169305,
0.0104945768,
-0.0254026856,
-0.0302514788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06555v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06555v2 | Heuristic-Driven Link-of-Analogy Prompting: Enhancing Large Language Models for Document-Level Event Argument Extraction | 2023-11-11T12:05:01 | 2024-02-20T03:51:40 | Hanzhang Zhou, Junlang Qian, Zijian Feng, Hui Lu, Zixiao Zhu, Kezhi Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we investigate in-context learning (ICL) in document-level
event argument extraction (EAE) to alleviate the dependency on large-scale
labeled data for this task. We introduce the Heuristic-Driven Link-of-Analogy
(HD-LoA) prompting to address the challenge of example selection and to develop
a prompting strategy tailored for EAE. Specifically, we hypothesize and
validate that LLMs learn task-specific heuristics from demonstrations via ICL.
Building upon this hypothesis, we introduce an explicit heuristic-driven
demonstration construction approach, which transforms the haphazard example
selection process into a methodical method that emphasizes task heuristics.
Additionally, inspired by the analogical reasoning of human, we propose the
link-of-analogy prompting, which enables LLMs to process new situations by
drawing analogies to known situations, enhancing their performance on unseen
classes beyond limited ICL examples. Experiments show that our method
outperforms existing prompting methods and few-shot supervised learning methods
on document-level EAE datasets. Additionally, the HD-LoA prompting shows
effectiveness in diverse tasks like sentiment analysis and natural language
inference, demonstrating its broad adaptability. | [
0.0220297594,
0.0405409709,
0.0330827944,
0.0683269873,
-0.0268904641,
0.0380466878,
0.010782592,
-0.0081896884,
0.0429176055,
-0.0792781115,
-0.0260481909,
-0.0034937074,
-0.0425113104,
-0.0424197093,
0.007497381,
-0.0671231449,
0.0026332659,
-0.0005485048,
0.0263533611,
0.0110521,
0.0025242202,
0.0192709211,
-0.0357626379,
0.0127353799,
0.0087861363,
-0.019920554,
-0.0108611397,
-0.0026631872,
0.0507174209,
-0.0433574766,
0.0053459201,
-0.0080630947,
0.0516386367,
-0.0186524205,
0.0000020831,
-0.094314456,
-0.0247993432,
-0.0264448747,
-0.0467119478,
-0.0310722664,
0.0557621047,
0.0507722348,
0.0057138791,
-0.0055085528,
-0.0285542198,
-0.0339088254,
0.0067280568,
0.0888390988,
0.0110963723,
0.0923857391,
-0.0220619775,
-0.0278628245,
-0.0203509405,
-0.007410883,
-0.0134686502,
-0.0015542511,
0.0093122665,
-0.0045674527,
0.0511843637,
0.0229128152,
0.0154199097,
-0.0048300354,
0.0331094936,
0.0141047472,
-0.0131254951,
0.0454910807,
-0.0311854258,
0.0477770492,
0.0062752631,
0.0780364871,
-0.0021031639,
-0.0354416259,
0.0283818748,
-0.0057788189,
0.0244139377,
0.04874954,
-0.0581845343,
0.0149523094,
-0.0360391811,
0.0557819642,
0.1002645865,
0.0298769586,
0.0171264503,
0.0142661072,
0.005321146,
0.0211874302,
-0.0333990902,
-0.0310646798,
0.049954392,
-0.0045957454,
-0.0085120266,
-0.0589200072,
-0.0066506341,
0.0471809991,
-0.0353439264,
0.0326756872,
-0.0416904464,
0.0113018295,
-0.0105937319,
-0.0954887196,
0.0493607447,
0.0120534208,
0.0268301461,
0.0755999982,
-0.0470548347,
-0.0254985467,
0.0136870844,
0.0092123402,
-0.0189246647,
0.0068131895,
-0.0720198527,
0.0466436855,
-0.0625978559,
0.0272668526,
-0.0241608098,
-0.0195042472,
0.0282589495,
0.0335295647,
-0.0017909162,
0.0325543582,
-0.0352254137,
-0.0241918154,
-0.013244723,
-0.0207562968,
-0.0380234905,
-0.053344138,
-0.0487224907,
0.0230735149,
-0.013998976,
-0.0157248992,
-0.0470388532,
0.0182304326,
0.0125132883,
-0.0269702133,
0.0010863907,
0.0534049757,
-0.0112379668,
-0.0335592516,
-0.0846420974,
-0.0094807446,
0.0305002574,
-0.0467456505,
-0.0019063504,
-0.0678157061,
0.0074089081,
-0.0193547215,
-0.0156297982,
-0.0082534626,
0.0206377022,
0.0169377103,
-0.0368953161,
0.0624897256,
-0.0064463848,
-0.0253158137,
0.0048068645,
0.0069832718,
-0.0724425092,
0.0660240203,
0.028931981,
0.0153102772,
0.0399834849,
0.0369202793,
0.0248632971,
-0.0059763226,
0.0267482158,
0.0332331136,
0.0029379579,
-0.0045014638,
-0.008475326,
0.0216284934,
0.029403368,
-0.009025964,
-0.0474242531,
-0.0090025701,
0.0483114123,
0.0411662832,
0.0130400909,
-0.0048900256,
0.040667437,
0.0060922946,
0.0180104133,
0.0184840448,
-0.0399026908,
-0.0092669511,
-0.0034538482,
0.0052702944,
-0.006956188,
-0.0259928834,
-0.034733288,
-0.0204527676,
-0.0151090985,
-0.0265954081,
-0.0252774302,
0.0091319764,
0.0319412574,
0.0424194224,
-0.0457501672,
0.0094825281,
0.0334639065,
-0.031597659,
-0.0258749183,
-0.0240434818,
0.0511652827,
0.0334360637,
0.0291824043,
-0.0448772535,
-0.0052711507,
-0.0242518093,
0.1001115292,
0.0159828383,
0.0693883151,
-0.0655195564,
0.0272938441,
-0.0402722247,
-0.0135348067,
-0.0608163066,
-0.0098220529,
-0.031410113,
-0.0016970185,
0.0093162209,
0.010331356,
-0.0533575416,
-0.0383553021,
0.0337338261,
-0.0284104142,
-0.0629532933,
0.0023874037,
0.0167952869,
0.0215629544,
0.015482855,
0.0148574011,
-0.0268495474,
0.025005877,
-0.04185725,
-0.003261338,
0.0649130642,
-0.0368418731,
-0.0769058168,
0.0009027087,
-0.0325375833,
-0.0305604003,
-0.0265429206,
-0.0510969907,
-0.014633337,
-0.0200022981,
0.0040187128,
0.0481601022,
-0.0079429382,
-0.0073027816,
-0.0041238274,
-0.0330241509,
-0.032878153,
0.0812946483,
0.0437087938,
-0.0132047804,
0.0176271647,
0.0598743893,
-0.0064072958,
-0.0290368181,
-0.0104549257,
0.0130816847,
0.0439920351,
-0.038443312,
0.0088885128,
-0.0111195045,
-0.0670553222,
0.0087966556,
-0.0936437845,
0.0225711074,
-0.0208627228,
0.0633829236,
0.0305020493,
-0.0324878544,
-0.0276533775,
-0.011871363,
-0.0274281278,
-0.0568895526,
-0.0478979088,
0.0046049873,
0.0811221898,
0.0080630649,
0.0025117421,
-0.0303096417,
0.0360289328,
-0.0273627806,
0.070577912,
0.0202433076,
0.0219886191,
-0.0460022464,
0.0393238924,
0.0271376073,
0.0241323914,
-0.0201344769,
0.0309299529,
0.0186049324,
0.002288254,
0.046921555,
0.0746771395,
-0.0096075218,
0.0411727689,
0.0188784041,
-0.0003300775,
-0.0890652835,
0.0125168031,
-0.0175235923,
0.057783626,
-0.0276257936,
0.0254415832,
0.0363024995,
0.051633507,
-0.0203766115,
0.0223330483,
-0.0170396585,
0.0227781162,
0.0101179928,
0.0159066394,
0.0019487594,
-0.0330023766,
-0.0006402346,
-0.0116211902,
-0.0131504852,
-0.0129532218,
0.0893782824,
-0.0024493041,
0.0066699157,
-0.0712395161,
-0.014649787,
-0.0269815642,
0.0698270872,
-0.040887557,
-0.0072165807,
0.0035372688,
-0.0049863518,
-0.0021850045,
-0.0114477305,
0.0123381121,
-0.0046975082,
0.0535280816,
-0.0490266383,
0.0065718945,
0.0046293871,
-0.0332513116,
-0.0443787687,
-0.0150838215,
-0.0242279153,
-0.0065878243,
-0.0706992298,
0.0371804796,
-0.015805997,
-0.0127007188,
0.0075472794,
0.0426131748,
0.0101966551,
-0.0328252278,
0.0045469855,
0.0357091725,
0.0203462802,
0.0013142894,
0.0154177239,
0.0023432327,
0.0585236773,
0.0569191687,
0.0618677512,
-0.0110095069,
-0.0572011396,
-0.009916421,
-0.0112134218,
-0.0517454483,
0.0036791877,
-0.0247076061,
0.0491219833,
-0.0681985766,
0.0251179617,
0.0926346481,
0.0251129121,
-0.0462886468,
0.0136537375,
0.0032398694,
0.0042790766,
-0.0015583443,
0.0118429502,
-0.0685911551,
-0.0557729714,
0.0006883029,
0.0066195074,
-0.0260625277,
-0.0355888046,
0.0190941729,
-0.1026632264,
0.0393029377,
-0.0030118464,
0.0001750883,
-0.0260528643,
-0.0771878436,
0.0487365648,
-0.0281363819,
-0.0414000563,
0.0241243541,
-0.0326025113,
0.0109279975,
-0.0001257161,
-0.0045452942,
-0.0858809203,
0.01398989,
-0.0385982245,
0.0230659246,
-0.0226308908,
0.0361333527,
0.0351614915,
0.0001787378,
0.0303336363,
-0.0167111754,
0.0017171199,
-0.0371024832,
0.06355685,
-0.01647068,
0.0096448623,
-0.0070415945,
0.0972072706,
-0.0346750878,
-0.0390252098,
0.0166462678,
0.077881828,
-0.032559216,
-0.0107596358,
0.0108815096,
-0.0239958502,
0.0386170782,
0.0674090758,
0.031143507,
-0.027906999,
-0.0111281751,
-0.0049692388,
-0.0169259962,
-0.0519992225,
0.0480255522,
-0.0113793425,
-0.0425715484,
0.0228319392,
-0.0696430057,
-0.0672967657,
-0.0000027648,
0.0673613921,
-0.0170340613,
-0.0135870036,
-0.0246045273,
-0.0010422686,
-0.0091256145,
0.0609850027,
-0.0274238307,
0.0011140815,
0.0253308695,
-0.0166387763,
0.0514190793,
-0.0156267826,
-0.0204706881,
0.0530251302,
-0.0147001278,
-0.0435193628,
-0.0446815304,
0.0053139529,
0.0024246704,
0.0946833491,
0.0033147568,
0.0002026354,
0.0485272035,
0.0137316128,
0.0426715463,
-0.0216193292,
0.0459736884,
0.0166889317,
0.0325302221,
0.0458257049,
-0.0117341047,
0.0515851378,
0.0078647612,
0.0329778455,
-0.0728188828,
0.0011418778,
0.0215333011,
-0.0275012143,
0.0304528344,
0.0088169891,
-0.0446847044,
-0.0398284271,
0.0357680693,
-0.0037374261,
-0.0239968859,
-0.0348328054,
0.043282412,
-0.0400399938,
0.0042179218,
-0.0202504136,
-0.0270765591,
-0.0311505292,
0.0598030947,
-0.0220538303,
0.0374570601,
0.0479991063,
0.0219581425,
0.002953551,
0.015163715,
-0.0380303301,
0.0113078654,
0.0259293187,
0.0216620043,
-0.0271050017,
0.0651162714,
0.0825096667,
-0.0183668807,
-0.0017978369,
-0.0026618815,
-0.0560962968,
0.0016220047,
-0.007329131,
0.0085205389,
0.0552236475,
-0.0673361421,
0.0174015835,
-0.0308698975,
0.011718818,
0.0423601605,
-0.011380624,
-0.0089697577,
0.0078377854,
0.0208046436,
0.0315568745,
-0.0027670301,
0.0397424549,
0.0288724545,
-0.0703244731,
0.0695565268,
-0.0004284479,
0.0081809917,
-0.0401508547,
-0.0312804617,
0.0588942021,
0.0197454877,
0.0048936945,
-0.0212882217,
-0.0283860341,
-0.0061809202,
0.0068435753,
-0.0169019308,
-0.0443378277,
-0.011351537,
0.0460445583,
0.0629014596,
0.0035846296,
0.0048485831,
-0.0215022452,
-0.0161139928,
0.0103269657,
-0.0574401803,
-0.0511814915,
-6.344927654e-33,
0.0001566842,
-0.0151918661,
0.028125789,
0.0681148022,
0.0032545964,
0.0069848718,
-0.0452377237,
-0.0252613835,
-0.0194486007,
0.0514877662,
-0.0032431665,
-0.0352493823,
-0.0060295262,
-0.0069492129,
-0.0034230275,
-0.0228323657,
0.0137094259,
-0.0051519391,
-0.0275871251,
0.0138320997,
0.0406624787,
-0.0017065341,
0.0589397177,
-0.0958483592,
0.0412983485,
0.0119707622,
-0.0130408043,
0.0097520472,
0.0392959453,
0.0422437675,
0.0162690114,
0.0270296559,
0.0357566699,
-0.0348170064,
0.0121238623,
0.0500417426,
-0.0827348307,
-0.051580295,
0.0034381868,
-0.039103508,
-0.010138412,
-0.0296248179,
0.0044787899,
0.0174634736,
0.0054536252,
-0.021705104,
0.0235947073,
-0.0306089614,
0.0250889249,
-0.069828257,
-0.0541241243,
0.0494715646,
0.0028966386,
-0.0244201366,
-0.0013379687,
0.036957629,
0.0026183487,
0.0641998202,
-0.0522187725,
0.000194849,
-0.0256557912,
-0.0273632109,
0.0048323851,
-0.0361573212,
-0.0153448684,
0.0655671433,
-0.0636713952,
0.0016420893,
-0.0198190007,
0.0228697304,
-0.0106684333,
0.043438945,
-0.0057008634,
0.0373879746,
0.0549782477,
0.0279776566,
-0.0754295364,
0.0191902537,
0.0598024242,
0.0073380549,
0.0191733036,
0.0155397905,
-0.0621221922,
0.0189496037,
-0.0209744852,
0.0057349834,
-0.0072062206,
-0.0363627411,
0.0008610755,
0.0134330578,
-0.0047695669,
0.0554442257,
-0.0152902594,
-0.0150487106,
-0.0202481505,
0.00164537,
-0.0307347383,
0.0040396182,
-0.0036295827,
-0.0371673331,
-0.0647956729,
-0.0619051754,
-0.0003534743,
0.0156055568,
0.0227418765,
0.0051346603,
0.0511171035,
0.005761697,
-0.0544262677,
0.0023345905,
-0.0242059305,
0.0082569793,
-0.0123535404,
-0.0101202978,
0.0066331355,
0.0199161395,
-0.0005181216,
0.0789229572,
-0.0111199655,
-0.0397737883,
-0.0091464724,
-0.0071170088,
-0.060545031,
0.0000173635,
0.0039391853,
-0.0275923777,
0.0220742431,
0.0008621945,
-0.0075599109,
-0.0856589302,
-0.0006098524,
0.0163405463,
2.864e-7,
0.0056780134,
0.0483700559,
-0.0026338878,
-0.0088435812,
0.0054643657,
0.0310415644,
-0.0007155701,
0.027052192,
0.0010847857,
-0.0149659384,
0.0119908359,
0.0479692817,
0.0377713293,
0.0521112159,
-0.116643928,
-0.0467714034,
-0.0543854684,
-0.0345634781,
-0.047206495,
-0.0095406333,
0.0937776342,
0.0479067266,
0.0508696437,
-0.0120202331,
-0.0081873499,
-0.0685043409,
0.0478421636,
-0.0270256307,
-0.0237804204,
0.0234401431,
0.0002929953,
-0.0281696841,
-0.0317603275,
0.0605536513,
-0.0115888827,
0.0349116959,
-0.0159204006,
0.0590606593,
0.0101699699,
-0.0083920909,
0.0087270131,
-0.0384753831,
0.0352006219,
-0.0397554152,
0.065048039,
-0.0848324597,
-0.0115317088,
-0.0138266189,
-0.0079203453,
-0.0082021561,
-0.0344017372,
0.0045504179,
-0.0260940809,
0.0267196689,
-0.0109280264,
-0.0111404331,
-0.0026652282,
-0.0769994259,
-0.0031487471,
0.0425107442,
-0.0023804186,
-0.0227999259,
0.029926762,
-0.0226169098,
0.0203493908,
-0.0336263739,
0.0010895444,
2.436812646e-34,
0.0093816863,
-0.0143225566,
-0.0083678942,
0.0661535636,
0.0485349298,
0.0163034853,
-0.013294722,
-0.0085392855,
0.0495746806,
-0.0213671699,
0.0121740671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06549v1 | Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Sentiment Classification under Distribution Shift: an Exploratory Study | 2023-11-11T11:56:56 | 2023-11-11T11:56:56 | Maarten De Raedt, Semere Kiros Bitew, Fréderic Godin, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder | cs.CL | cs.CL | The brittleness of finetuned language model performance on
out-of-distribution (OOD) test samples in unseen domains has been well-studied
for English, yet is unexplored for multi-lingual models. Therefore, we study
generalization to OOD test data specifically in zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer settings, analyzing performance impacts of both language and domain
shifts between train and test data. We further assess the effectiveness of
counterfactually augmented data (CAD) in improving OOD generalization for the
cross-lingual setting, since CAD has been shown to benefit in a monolingual
English setting. Finally, we propose two new approaches for OOD generalization
that avoid the costly annotation process associated with CAD, by exploiting the
power of recent large language models (LLMs). We experiment with 3 multilingual
models, LaBSE, mBERT, and XLM-R trained on English IMDb movie reviews, and
evaluate on OOD test sets in 13 languages: Amazon product reviews, Tweets, and
Restaurant reviews. Results echo the OOD performance decline observed in the
monolingual English setting. Further, (i) counterfactuals from the original
high-resource language do improve OOD generalization in the low-resource
language, and (ii) our newly proposed cost-effective approaches reach similar
or up to +3.1% better accuracy than CAD for Amazon and Restaurant reviews. | [
0.0158072803,
0.0584168062,
0.0192268658,
0.0370084159,
-0.0218122806,
0.0165335014,
-0.0052542137,
0.0138939396,
-0.0323275626,
-0.0772767365,
-0.0616803169,
-0.0481819957,
-0.018966116,
-0.0058163684,
-0.0089792544,
0.0165171251,
0.0129098259,
0.0138620781,
0.004144486,
-0.0319169275,
-0.0086538019,
0.0162554793,
0.0078088734,
-0.0242887586,
0.0155712627,
-0.0076411152,
0.0339351334,
0.0214600526,
0.038785819,
-0.0189942382,
0.0101243164,
0.0244201757,
0.01459016,
0.0315440819,
0.0000019708,
-0.0523800217,
-0.0043806727,
0.0129514299,
0.0260927081,
-0.0110496841,
0.0702279434,
-0.0781966224,
-0.0096860724,
0.0087877084,
-0.0105504058,
-0.0360193029,
0.0639531165,
0.0322077498,
0.0000224714,
0.095158726,
-0.0233627558,
-0.0141702862,
-0.0297927801,
-0.0348746963,
0.000987309,
-0.0423418432,
0.0308702812,
0.0141990315,
-0.0296594482,
0.0054254537,
-0.0423022769,
0.0072939559,
-0.0095022637,
0.0015847451,
-0.0187711604,
0.0172335114,
-0.0428721234,
0.0223283246,
0.0151139321,
0.0450605229,
-0.01540362,
-0.0288315769,
-0.0281178169,
-0.0011610101,
-0.0075209616,
0.0191688929,
-0.0317547321,
0.0111935018,
0.0225586351,
0.0343489237,
0.0218919199,
0.017147962,
0.0487039275,
0.0229203105,
-0.0385044627,
0.0501512066,
-0.0051123281,
-0.0374780782,
0.0381782129,
0.0736852884,
-0.0379231051,
-0.0174372252,
-0.0244388375,
-0.0213037673,
0.037847314,
0.0012923591,
0.0106770331,
-0.0125605697,
0.0242833793,
-0.081440255,
0.0410222933,
0.0073894435,
-0.0553733148,
0.0503982157,
-0.0094724074,
0.0073585636,
-0.021533234,
0.0126806013,
-0.0205946639,
-0.0092728576,
-0.0808376521,
0.0248428565,
0.047267139,
0.0370984338,
-0.0220372714,
0.0238131993,
-0.051223658,
-0.0021941413,
-0.0098198066,
-0.0234116241,
0.0224544313,
-0.0312310737,
0.0064551258,
0.0075055636,
-0.0272123925,
0.0981734693,
-0.0233506802,
0.0274429172,
-0.0476850532,
0.0018767562,
-0.0033868602,
0.0426744744,
-0.0219717976,
-0.0231158268,
0.0278101303,
0.0785682276,
0.0271963291,
-0.0278003924,
-0.0294403899,
0.0270338636,
-0.0327086635,
-0.0985898152,
0.0266366918,
-0.0535373017,
-0.0027930667,
0.0318349786,
0.0015515283,
0.01034215,
-0.0020050721,
0.002749606,
-0.0417848825,
0.0179948527,
0.007814033,
-0.0253687613,
-0.012869061,
-0.0309184343,
0.0047009238,
0.1042976975,
-0.0146397259,
-0.0300194845,
0.0374046117,
-0.0144428201,
0.0235362388,
0.0555660948,
-0.0137394322,
0.0409598388,
-0.0425704643,
0.0000638584,
-0.0304030832,
-0.0274269227,
0.0415531807,
-0.0294622704,
-0.0106482105,
0.0065567479,
0.0206791628,
-0.0176671706,
-0.0303719416,
0.008800691,
-0.000458878,
-0.0128324768,
-0.0529292673,
0.0168566611,
-0.0275290348,
0.0170437265,
-0.0050186287,
0.0072572725,
-0.0217215326,
0.001113779,
-0.0436257459,
-0.0115817459,
-0.0051400154,
-0.0333482958,
0.0539615341,
0.0045358953,
0.1069209501,
0.0048567923,
-0.0029627436,
0.0333019271,
0.0700271204,
-0.0321241878,
-0.0070422371,
-0.0262611415,
-0.0017039783,
0.0346084423,
-0.011644152,
-0.0219378453,
0.0009651974,
-0.0329042897,
0.0094320877,
0.0453982912,
0.0364181958,
0.004779302,
0.0095343674,
-0.030637389,
-0.0209985916,
-0.0152879152,
0.0465152226,
0.0356545523,
-0.0203759968,
0.0612617545,
0.0001684892,
-0.0709164664,
-0.0231087059,
-0.0281494576,
-0.0010326444,
-0.0172840059,
0.0363770127,
0.0139920535,
0.0204175543,
0.0477630794,
-0.0347238593,
-0.0412193537,
0.0059091179,
-0.0344884284,
-0.0390575305,
0.0282787997,
0.0046823504,
-0.0443403646,
0.0138739413,
0.0024089818,
-0.0073496145,
0.0232480504,
-0.0422965027,
-0.0146805169,
0.0319329128,
0.0472925641,
0.0640730262,
-0.0337931104,
0.0132887457,
-0.0400302336,
0.0254865568,
0.0017789567,
0.0445636958,
-0.0073332903,
0.0150005342,
-0.0540046841,
-0.0513740443,
0.0490053743,
0.0244998839,
-0.0304401331,
0.0414618775,
0.0184018556,
0.0367737561,
0.0393622108,
0.0086722309,
-0.0045163711,
-0.0100902067,
-0.085802801,
0.0128926663,
-0.0302577969,
0.0503739454,
0.0336558446,
-0.0058338437,
0.0016791652,
0.0141439764,
-0.0310310591,
-0.0061296569,
0.0113337962,
0.0368111506,
0.0183676518,
0.0151869077,
0.0318404473,
-0.0014855961,
-0.0030282387,
-0.0188352205,
0.037854448,
-0.0340485498,
-0.0258959346,
-0.0445046462,
0.0314658061,
-0.0656767786,
-0.012834142,
-0.0224719457,
-0.0379676521,
-0.051170785,
0.0196666773,
-0.017765753,
-0.0004847957,
-0.0314086564,
-0.0294434745,
0.0475782268,
0.0038490319,
-0.0257330909,
0.0034624788,
0.0117704328,
-0.0569724441,
-0.0296040047,
-0.0159013495,
-0.0194503665,
0.02949211,
-0.0141342375,
-0.0320152752,
-0.053649608,
-0.0205312148,
-0.0421911664,
0.0066750697,
0.0093923071,
0.0244024508,
0.0151794702,
0.0275078807,
0.0116024222,
-0.0010810151,
0.0259477627,
-0.0089790029,
0.034955129,
-0.1009520069,
-0.0190528333,
-0.0316537917,
0.0072814231,
-0.0264634117,
0.0088401651,
-0.0071898676,
0.0203046277,
-0.0019496478,
-0.0343275145,
0.0022841643,
0.0035150715,
0.0495777391,
0.001723976,
0.0186995678,
-0.014035671,
-0.0354282372,
0.0195061956,
-0.077564463,
-0.0215173811,
-0.0054176394,
-0.0204912126,
-0.0265617501,
-0.0243189149,
0.0312878154,
-0.0046608355,
-0.0000051987,
-0.0192604344,
-0.000469838,
0.0326678827,
0.013509783,
0.0385551266,
-0.0129239969,
-0.0254861992,
-0.0253920555,
-0.0101847835,
-0.0027373105,
-0.0225195251,
-0.0093973158,
-0.0068554198,
-0.022044342,
0.0137332911,
0.0130216051,
-0.0249920432,
-0.0462713912,
0.0500182807,
-0.0206525587,
0.0219450835,
0.0779956356,
0.0027125403,
-0.0782432482,
-0.0254426394,
-0.0101377759,
0.0100756371,
0.0513339452,
0.010713309,
-0.1089873388,
-0.0275633316,
-0.0232381206,
-0.0049740276,
-0.0103941681,
-0.0202920195,
-0.0064717494,
-0.1557831317,
0.0121156611,
-0.006746782,
-0.0750861168,
-0.0384277329,
-0.0253631528,
0.0068671936,
-0.016471168,
0.0045346697,
-0.06747403,
-0.0013189288,
-0.0060376115,
0.0052293115,
0.0022429493,
-0.0879186615,
0.0407312512,
-0.0298802927,
0.0013616552,
0.0685810521,
0.0332980454,
-0.0396985859,
0.0204355251,
0.0707197562,
-0.0398384817,
-0.0017573218,
-0.0229472406,
0.08670412,
-0.0073560122,
-0.0207683481,
0.0386321954,
-0.018711254,
-0.0355699323,
0.0345029086,
0.0024946409,
0.0689102188,
0.0379830971,
-0.0444020219,
0.0022608757,
0.0152481478,
0.0093519557,
0.0590313822,
-0.0429243222,
-0.0619112439,
0.0103469761,
-0.0111395158,
-0.0578133017,
-0.0062482264,
0.0164486933,
0.0194574501,
-0.0387563035,
-0.0747760758,
-0.0685254559,
-0.0455552936,
-0.0155065628,
0.0252546407,
0.0156962071,
0.0338529833,
-0.0381513163,
-0.0075207786,
-0.0046011289,
0.0130394623,
-0.0176587589,
0.0009447078,
0.0107241143,
-0.0051504481,
0.0830124617,
-0.0155024892,
-0.0107013639,
-0.0421291478,
-0.0458715521,
-0.0810094252,
-0.0355984755,
0.0463630855,
0.0134448558,
0.0511668138,
0.0124940835,
-0.0169434231,
0.050118994,
0.0689807832,
-0.0162662007,
0.0235570204,
0.0632707775,
0.0284780562,
-0.0106585603,
0.036804948,
-0.0435013101,
0.0365607999,
0.0256138984,
0.0007546121,
-0.0164467823,
-0.0203666054,
-0.010578787,
-0.0245696548,
0.0456840694,
-0.0110728573,
-0.0327290855,
-0.0161167942,
0.0206638444,
-0.0240876786,
-0.0128110349,
-0.0143994521,
-0.0387541167,
0.0464899428,
-0.0270613674,
-0.0428369939,
0.0480863601,
-0.0334172994,
0.0353548527,
-0.0458211415,
0.0475113764,
0.0555923171,
0.0188544951,
-0.0008457491,
0.0369353332,
-0.0115260798,
-0.0147239221,
0.0320941694,
0.0054518552,
-0.0298036914,
0.0577458404,
0.0062494031,
0.0258270521,
-0.0002491228,
-0.0153393811,
-0.0116359033,
0.0326504968,
-0.0049684197,
0.022652559,
0.0467906259,
-0.0819231868,
0.0570610799,
-0.0183251686,
-0.0159418937,
-0.0110291326,
0.032209944,
-0.028437335,
0.0015832772,
0.0310517326,
-0.0003958067,
-0.0328692421,
0.0575589575,
0.0586702302,
-0.0109289149,
0.0148550794,
0.0158070736,
-0.0038861968,
-0.0231540184,
0.030742215,
0.0456521884,
-0.0212754551,
0.0175703857,
0.015020634,
-0.0557731614,
-0.0896444023,
0.0343817472,
-0.0482794866,
0.0228060205,
0.001642412,
-0.0009278308,
0.0741925165,
0.0144432196,
0.051308088,
-0.0421029292,
-0.0234498233,
-0.00122793,
0.0110689038,
-0.0089781303,
-6.389409829e-33,
0.0291405004,
0.0168040637,
-0.0209399108,
-0.0086603565,
0.0135080786,
0.0013145574,
-0.0093222288,
0.0288196113,
-0.0143841011,
0.0396861434,
0.0098241493,
0.0069200573,
0.0166188944,
0.0284339227,
0.0106406379,
-0.0316068195,
0.0436550528,
0.0087192561,
-0.023883326,
0.0095642926,
0.0313395336,
0.0291671045,
0.1086377427,
-0.0999848023,
0.0337869599,
-0.0347290486,
-0.0032910986,
-0.0034621831,
0.0489274748,
0.0286318734,
0.0005058441,
0.0969474688,
0.0480560325,
-0.036639519,
0.0291556641,
-0.0182951447,
-0.0228596758,
0.0143800862,
0.0246006865,
0.0186869502,
0.0585601628,
-0.0037179543,
-0.012104312,
-0.0086694295,
-0.0172610041,
0.0023346965,
0.024064675,
-0.0376273207,
0.013081667,
-0.0238934588,
-0.0817693844,
0.0214869101,
0.0165569615,
-0.0031847509,
0.0344213955,
0.0569140464,
0.0216479935,
0.0575244948,
-0.044692535,
0.0119156139,
-0.040536426,
0.0062002586,
0.0342420526,
-0.019319037,
-0.0177446082,
0.0377431922,
-0.0157396905,
0.0500614867,
0.0195230469,
0.0002716192,
0.0292931255,
-0.0323432125,
-0.0194085687,
0.1271679997,
0.0741120055,
-0.0446963683,
-0.1019492596,
0.0063240766,
0.0056245062,
-0.0404219776,
0.0578362234,
0.0017191236,
-0.0418270119,
-0.0361135416,
0.0161427017,
-0.0408798717,
-0.027138548,
-0.0337005481,
-0.0068529407,
-0.0004440504,
-0.0011320665,
-0.0018263649,
0.0458603352,
-0.054346323,
-0.0672944114,
0.0527892299,
-0.0623589531,
0.0248633623,
0.0066562612,
-0.0074070063,
-0.0484661795,
-0.03003354,
-0.0461913757,
0.0418305658,
0.0174483135,
0.012899329,
0.1028109342,
0.0287374444,
-0.0825324804,
-0.013218727,
-0.0199974421,
0.0196643546,
-0.019911455,
0.1199972704,
-0.0140339276,
0.0308929682,
0.0000604336,
0.0745503232,
0.0478260703,
0.0077631995,
0.0089003071,
0.0365097634,
0.005060677,
-0.0056875586,
-0.0177350137,
-0.0200522449,
0.0437870622,
0.0016085466,
-0.007026047,
-0.0785836503,
-0.0259281863,
-0.0125747295,
2.798e-7,
0.0568927489,
0.0440151691,
-0.0431456268,
-0.0234695002,
-0.0077028503,
0.0500902273,
-0.0558218509,
0.0164465457,
0.0173614137,
-0.00663087,
0.0016223979,
0.0073026144,
0.0137210507,
0.0316968709,
-0.1079333201,
0.0402143225,
-0.0327482931,
-0.0017242604,
-0.013371557,
0.0287805274,
0.0106177218,
0.11423219,
0.0119280489,
-0.0128848134,
-0.0163671281,
-0.0420833975,
0.0815898925,
-0.0495375842,
-0.0412801579,
-0.0186670218,
-0.0339157097,
0.0096857371,
-0.0287877191,
0.0228057448,
-0.0417517275,
0.0476144031,
0.0149842026,
0.0220522005,
-0.0005013905,
-0.0350863971,
0.012687047,
0.0270721447,
0.0017773842,
-0.0289673097,
0.0455061309,
-0.0422043167,
-0.0401147977,
-0.0567136705,
-0.0217201002,
0.0213730186,
0.083088018,
-0.0203899406,
-0.0212648232,
0.0279775374,
0.0200618338,
0.0004832144,
-0.044353094,
-0.0407295823,
-0.0145278284,
0.0764185861,
-0.0029461707,
-0.0373879895,
0.0435931981,
-0.0106645934,
-0.0001246382,
-0.0391967148,
0.0605610013,
2.40782569e-34,
0.0861941203,
-0.0185349379,
-0.0124465944,
-0.0202315096,
0.0177968033,
-0.005779319,
-0.0299222004,
-0.0031493909,
0.0087840082,
-0.0089605879,
0.0360196643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06534v2 | Translating Legalese: Enhancing Public Understanding of Court Opinions with Legal Summarizers | 2023-11-11T11:05:27 | 2024-03-02T17:18:34 | Elliott Ash, Aniket Kesari, Suresh Naidu, Lena Song, Dominik Stammbach | cs.CL | cs.CL | Judicial opinions are written to be persuasive and could build public trust
in court decisions, yet they can be difficult for non-experts to understand. We
present a pipeline for using an AI assistant to generate simplified summaries
of judicial opinions. Compared to existing expert-written summaries, these
AI-generated simple summaries are more accessible to the public and more easily
understood by non-experts. We show in a survey experiment that the AI summaries
help respondents understand the key features of a ruling, and have higher
perceived quality, especially for respondents with less formal education. | [
0.0318962038,
0.0452503935,
-0.0144333597,
-0.028611362,
-0.0281328745,
0.026477335,
0.0034151492,
-0.0145729287,
0.0004839517,
-0.0313915797,
0.0207369924,
-0.006956602,
0.0034130015,
0.017778378,
-0.0198054072,
-0.0915670767,
-0.0020907419,
0.0077570402,
0.0990724117,
-0.0035014837,
0.0373009928,
0.0236177202,
-0.0015372874,
0.0497648455,
-0.0000777653,
-0.0134776952,
-0.0101208482,
0.0034074415,
-0.0163758565,
-0.0062656817,
-0.0502461083,
0.0635434091,
0.0042533018,
-0.0028748701,
0.0000015771,
-0.0523496941,
0.0404601172,
0.0065916763,
-0.0293708537,
0.0098295119,
0.0162365977,
-0.0465612039,
-0.0123732919,
0.0111155091,
-0.0230490528,
0.0274507161,
0.0319019631,
0.0119599197,
0.0626346469,
0.0624526031,
-0.0054978644,
-0.0439096652,
0.0300388038,
-0.0480952561,
0.0102476636,
-0.034352947,
-0.0238796975,
-0.0163863059,
-0.0184080321,
-0.023415897,
0.0529181212,
0.003926652,
0.010355955,
-0.0583224483,
-0.0285290461,
0.0084613366,
-0.0197761245,
-0.0158421565,
0.0120520685,
0.0488146506,
0.0658041015,
-0.0243585762,
0.0064756526,
0.0022266223,
0.0864287019,
0.0481152497,
-0.0480666049,
0.0999914631,
-0.0132758347,
-0.0015483474,
-0.0110269543,
0.0239524879,
-0.0332100801,
0.0070415158,
-0.0185584556,
0.0230020974,
-0.0199596696,
-0.0289132781,
-0.0010155089,
0.0169985481,
0.0436938629,
-0.0934427679,
0.0411013924,
0.0378312804,
-0.0065322346,
0.0327191465,
-0.022826096,
-0.0737480745,
0.0422431752,
-0.0419344977,
0.0436428525,
0.0233069286,
-0.0182246342,
0.0718916729,
-0.0436602719,
-0.0021158555,
0.0227818694,
0.0538149476,
-0.0064921076,
-0.0254420657,
-0.0314441547,
-0.0026188008,
-0.0337296985,
0.0316668116,
-0.0876720026,
0.0048162555,
-0.0259960294,
-0.0124661271,
-0.0053966134,
0.0497409813,
-0.0083723953,
0.0145129487,
-0.0151790148,
-0.0406196527,
-0.0462237485,
0.0015679727,
-0.0892477706,
0.0172569584,
0.0272752196,
0.010616539,
0.0117183728,
0.0283314437,
0.0269635916,
0.0501695201,
-0.0092376377,
0.0703033581,
-0.0277547333,
-0.0220849384,
-0.02359722,
-0.0774967372,
-0.011600323,
-0.0577677675,
-0.0538026579,
-0.0570232309,
0.0252950266,
-0.0027095149,
-0.0082933307,
-0.0583657473,
0.0194648392,
0.0460728444,
-0.0107914275,
0.0398900919,
-0.0373921655,
-0.0040148539,
-0.0103780795,
0.0094225109,
0.0199276153,
0.0018532347,
0.0292392168,
0.0489623956,
0.044511728,
0.0115980031,
0.0426233299,
-0.015077889,
0.003273882,
0.0225778148,
0.0270495564,
0.000472381,
-0.0949997529,
0.0157900807,
0.0233040527,
0.0750188902,
0.0169137157,
0.0518090166,
0.047384806,
0.0761796758,
-0.0035155325,
0.0652309433,
0.0140621662,
0.033588212,
0.0569341965,
0.019950958,
-0.0546189323,
0.064219512,
-0.012366931,
0.0452983305,
-0.0238054693,
0.0031219833,
-0.0207028836,
-0.0688868985,
0.032755103,
-0.0257160068,
0.0063814656,
0.0229959972,
0.0042684237,
0.0240791962,
-0.011956553,
-0.0074030138,
0.0074550649,
-0.0675346628,
-0.021153206,
-0.0118308859,
0.019200718,
0.0579448193,
0.0029739251,
0.0057456889,
0.04385617,
-0.0385026895,
0.0193645284,
0.0509655438,
0.0472755656,
-0.0129276067,
-0.0382138304,
-0.0341953859,
-0.0418939404,
0.0070862435,
0.0472723767,
0.0090263505,
-0.0001320839,
0.0283987969,
0.0730537251,
-0.0750572309,
-0.0350349359,
0.0238669328,
0.0302773248,
-0.0365027003,
0.0184392538,
0.0116680376,
0.0097950026,
0.064124912,
-0.0099108489,
0.012934627,
0.001654944,
0.0213897694,
-0.0038502039,
0.0553958751,
-0.0071977265,
0.0427659638,
0.0186962727,
-0.0927974805,
-0.0329710394,
0.0005388631,
-0.0212438069,
-0.0136241941,
-0.0182421915,
-0.0663166121,
0.0106882267,
-0.0150853172,
0.0085186195,
0.0120551139,
-0.0463978127,
0.020275414,
0.0162650831,
0.0063853539,
-0.0633654594,
0.0347723961,
-0.0341460332,
0.018541377,
0.0008665648,
0.0079201963,
-0.0486534499,
0.0140912076,
0.0155436238,
0.0324503481,
0.0033713898,
-0.0356663726,
-0.0084579792,
-0.0536937527,
-0.0282108467,
-0.0161820073,
-0.0112159802,
0.0277111847,
-0.0066404562,
0.0009915961,
-0.0238250606,
-0.0446665511,
-0.0224170443,
-0.0173621159,
-0.0088363839,
0.0259040631,
0.0243901387,
0.0162273701,
-0.029987406,
-0.0130500598,
-0.0275192522,
0.0182168521,
0.0920615047,
-0.0304374378,
-0.0383636467,
0.007690833,
-0.0051354128,
-0.0284464806,
0.0017109669,
-0.0036997341,
-0.0064036772,
0.0351123214,
-0.0404975154,
0.0555756614,
0.0706665516,
0.0216028951,
0.0522270389,
0.059809763,
-0.0333500355,
-0.0217634737,
-0.011086192,
0.0212233085,
-0.0056282338,
-0.0315598398,
0.0604831167,
-0.0395110585,
0.0224110093,
0.0350519828,
-0.0212534722,
0.0354511552,
0.0033572416,
-0.019841807,
-0.0331992432,
-0.0416315682,
-0.0217726454,
0.0754768848,
0.0073717362,
-0.0626986623,
0.0629146472,
0.010897113,
0.047146529,
-0.0546036772,
0.0211014189,
-0.058897242,
0.0586289354,
-0.031676963,
0.0485152863,
-0.0482495464,
-0.0300214719,
0.0129290083,
-0.0346537903,
0.044559136,
-0.0259643551,
0.079664655,
-0.0437628552,
0.0000191391,
-0.0036612411,
-0.0339694805,
-0.0138276136,
-0.0380634665,
-0.0407483503,
0.0046376344,
0.0734898672,
-0.0278105009,
-0.0328476802,
-0.0221256278,
0.066788353,
0.023105992,
0.0261267647,
-0.0249843933,
-0.0042239279,
0.0161289107,
0.0064544636,
-0.0056440057,
0.0257626511,
-0.0580611043,
0.0030306389,
0.0185879394,
0.0075547202,
-0.0142413359,
0.0210988279,
-0.0612744056,
-0.0181009527,
-0.0641197488,
0.0004175056,
0.020927541,
0.0251121037,
-0.040899571,
0.0616179705,
0.0906484723,
0.0078000487,
-0.0445187725,
-0.0227109715,
-0.0266305506,
0.0102557475,
0.007210806,
0.0323309638,
-0.101042375,
0.0023669649,
0.0072177392,
0.0544013008,
-0.0209718402,
-0.0046328194,
-0.0120964935,
-0.0976945311,
0.0692762062,
0.0126706492,
0.0080305226,
-0.0454689339,
-0.0248942692,
0.0203661863,
0.0071347626,
-0.0136946151,
-0.0036612605,
-0.0201026257,
0.0009310942,
0.0066343653,
-0.0608131513,
0.0211351514,
-0.0146902259,
-0.053503558,
0.0422398932,
0.0585128702,
0.0528285652,
-0.0367384441,
0.0011483066,
-0.0172071401,
0.0062926258,
0.0183057375,
0.0334941112,
0.0724757761,
-0.0157288034,
0.0273151044,
-0.0457721502,
0.0499312468,
0.0170849245,
0.0101590315,
0.086592339,
-0.0086752689,
-0.0078646028,
-0.0420145988,
-0.0298789125,
-0.004029986,
0.0003767993,
0.0720857605,
0.0493880212,
0.0041898643,
-0.0230620764,
-0.0391903818,
0.0052471361,
-0.0656858012,
-0.0385267437,
-0.0334886461,
-0.0176553261,
-0.043039985,
-0.0515443943,
-0.0368921384,
0.015770033,
0.0215975009,
0.0491143614,
-0.018395938,
0.0622808933,
0.0157980584,
-0.0226885173,
0.0017595399,
-0.0520445593,
-0.0044846721,
-0.0272275358,
-0.042232953,
-0.0218850728,
0.0092203012,
-0.0078995191,
-0.0055046543,
0.0423504673,
-0.0080800829,
0.0041391957,
0.0266987495,
0.0227671321,
0.0314256623,
-0.0086187636,
-0.012878703,
0.0501601212,
0.0289227311,
-0.0225239433,
0.0095461896,
0.0494919904,
-0.0251875967,
-0.0164787397,
0.0021623152,
-0.0196576696,
0.0039257612,
-0.0311040543,
0.0073841475,
-0.0398947969,
-0.0371073857,
0.0584264211,
0.0607385971,
-0.0417507924,
0.0040771146,
0.0330216847,
-0.0172540247,
-0.0174758844,
-0.0530724451,
0.0020853416,
-0.0031689676,
-0.0115570063,
-0.017164534,
-0.0086569665,
0.0208284445,
0.0695251822,
-0.0341720358,
-0.0205307659,
-0.0296705421,
0.0577024557,
-0.0178002417,
0.008295835,
-0.0239729024,
-0.0389879942,
-0.0220750738,
0.0270027835,
-0.0387051515,
0.0495082662,
0.0032894025,
0.0018212412,
0.005425625,
-0.022575736,
0.0084347138,
0.0272557251,
-0.0409318954,
-0.0556804948,
-0.0230545849,
0.045195777,
0.0115478672,
0.0045518945,
0.0237651858,
-0.0365288258,
0.0023190468,
0.0182909314,
0.0189388506,
-0.0031008243,
-0.0124444673,
-0.0124590537,
0.0059989667,
-0.0063831089,
-0.0048138276,
0.0395605303,
-0.0736734495,
0.0096028121,
-0.0181930587,
-0.0162059292,
-0.0291150771,
-0.0278071817,
-0.043119356,
0.0385914333,
-0.0084249321,
-0.0911143497,
-0.0802384838,
-0.0108850896,
-0.0295112375,
0.0303518772,
0.0292317439,
0.0024584958,
0.0170785915,
0.0331255011,
0.005724052,
-0.0126452493,
-0.0643153563,
0.0265759602,
-0.0490247123,
-0.0023437205,
-0.019716328,
-5.114062744e-33,
-0.021730613,
-0.0603520796,
-0.0327811725,
0.0106515111,
0.0152609404,
-0.0310617741,
-0.074445419,
0.0342733525,
-0.0126531124,
0.0463639274,
-0.0264030825,
0.0125704147,
0.0263462458,
-0.0283004232,
0.0249276478,
0.0213827435,
0.0448123179,
-0.0091209952,
-0.0302428715,
0.0457798317,
-0.007331871,
-0.0357283615,
-0.005998231,
-0.1416004896,
0.0604493544,
0.0134029118,
-0.0411681905,
-0.0457781702,
-0.0259012301,
0.0178194977,
0.0249012504,
0.0404701084,
0.0109624984,
-0.023690369,
-0.0107711656,
0.0813305303,
-0.0615542606,
0.016050294,
0.0283256415,
-0.0592910461,
-0.027360931,
-0.0414109342,
0.0285193305,
-0.0129987607,
-0.0185700823,
0.0258679427,
0.0478122644,
-0.0444290228,
0.0061321636,
-0.0829178542,
-0.0465451553,
0.0291182436,
-0.0472238474,
0.0014815824,
-0.0069424831,
0.0357803293,
0.004780944,
-0.0099590719,
-0.0443523861,
0.0542230681,
0.0212852545,
-0.022045793,
0.0362547524,
-0.08739274,
-0.0352288894,
0.0152015053,
0.0346367843,
-0.0021837454,
-0.0780661255,
0.004680003,
0.0018482826,
0.0187150929,
0.0625079051,
0.077611424,
0.0385374017,
-0.037335977,
-0.0177688226,
0.036650788,
0.0248587653,
0.0273312312,
0.0193447545,
-0.0465095229,
-0.0648751482,
0.0158186499,
-0.0390927531,
-0.0547969043,
-0.0085489573,
-0.0375114791,
-0.015098922,
0.0197835509,
-0.0060690795,
-0.0525103621,
-0.0456842966,
-0.0153739126,
0.0394439325,
0.0002357726,
-0.0097961007,
0.0341134816,
-0.0126813902,
-0.0286888927,
-0.0484280586,
0.0142358346,
0.0104025844,
0.0370255597,
0.0297367871,
0.00818366,
0.0578542836,
-0.0508963913,
-0.0556382611,
0.0044068592,
0.0370195992,
0.0391486138,
0.0521999933,
-0.0273717884,
0.0036712356,
0.0313082412,
0.0215382949,
0.0168240499,
-0.0145154977,
0.0206467099,
-0.0409814268,
-0.0188653059,
0.024121372,
0.0078432644,
-0.0286133923,
0.0131822973,
0.0004364217,
0.0231409166,
0.0327826887,
0.0201294348,
0.0062639285,
0.008615843,
2.263e-7,
0.0696227252,
0.0398318954,
0.0250040852,
0.0144903241,
-0.0529895313,
0.0352084525,
0.0364507362,
0.0262365695,
0.0349949822,
-0.0230886843,
0.045914039,
0.013711472,
0.0157343503,
0.0442161076,
-0.0900628939,
-0.0467365496,
-0.052008111,
-0.0151774585,
-0.042078115,
0.0633027852,
0.0772793666,
0.0362028889,
0.0119608743,
-0.0142822182,
-0.0104667554,
-0.0097031146,
0.0329223834,
0.00442405,
0.0098598935,
-0.0070489412,
0.0798076317,
-0.0329603814,
-0.0133415814,
0.0267303642,
-0.015897207,
-0.0130929211,
-0.0274545588,
0.0572306253,
0.0299268924,
0.0378072076,
0.0095030479,
-0.0141672483,
0.0299682077,
-0.0035887996,
0.0242371634,
-0.0577848554,
-0.0281061009,
-0.0114207184,
-0.0565058999,
-0.0140714748,
0.0017748341,
0.0195094347,
-0.0502207093,
-0.0174528807,
0.0229581892,
-0.0194540601,
0.032508865,
-0.0665955693,
-0.0017726619,
0.0095789274,
0.0241025276,
0.0023052895,
-0.0064867921,
-0.0115582049,
0.0106069315,
-0.0729836449,
0.0286154803,
1.537952983e-34,
0.0465567186,
-0.0074884794,
0.0187654812,
0.0041316897,
0.0471501239,
0.0235202145,
0.0045937477,
-0.0378544666,
0.0081425672,
-0.0498049036,
0.0173519347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06532v1 | Added Toxicity Mitigation at Inference Time for Multimodal and Massively Multilingual Translation | 2023-11-11T11:02:02 | 2023-11-11T11:02:02 | Marta R. Costa-jussà, David Dale, Maha Elbayad, Bokai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Added toxicity in the context of translation refers to the fact of producing
a translation output with more toxicity than there exists in the input. In this
paper, we present MinTox which is a novel pipeline to identify added toxicity
and mitigate this issue which works at inference time. MinTox uses a toxicity
detection classifier which is multimodal (speech and text) and works in
languages at scale. The mitigation method is applied to languages at scale and
directly in text outputs. MinTox is applied to SEAMLESSM4T, which is the latest
multimodal and massively multilingual machine translation system. For this
system, MinTox achieves significant added toxicity mitigation across domains,
modalities and language directions. MinTox manages to approximately filter out
from 25% to 95% of added toxicity (depending on the modality and domain) while
keeping translation quality. | [
0.0012760387,
0.032827381,
-0.012101491,
0.0451974794,
0.0063774609,
0.0266988166,
0.0016733347,
0.0377455354,
0.0006180988,
-0.0136676114,
-0.0393638015,
0.0373026505,
-0.0185131002,
0.0055056196,
0.0407907628,
-0.0235973243,
0.0477589741,
-0.0055765063,
-0.068853721,
-0.0112328464,
0.0159812346,
0.0377556719,
0.0249779373,
0.0292554162,
-0.0186477788,
-0.0338603109,
0.0116857756,
0.0617943928,
0.0511999726,
-0.0298902951,
-0.0117609557,
-0.002344812,
-0.0159528721,
0.0700262189,
0.0000019558,
-0.0382130705,
-0.0388818681,
0.0145729715,
0.0509990305,
-0.0264425203,
0.0920213684,
-0.0642445609,
-0.0337695181,
0.0347476229,
-0.0240463968,
0.0052375239,
0.0683344007,
-0.0020102717,
0.0887049511,
0.0564311221,
-0.0408979133,
0.0038136663,
0.0077211005,
0.0165931713,
-0.0156313516,
-0.0323668458,
0.0009910919,
-0.0186913293,
-0.0167782176,
-0.0211467631,
-0.0276469961,
0.0647800565,
0.013239421,
-0.0240831673,
-0.0580567941,
-0.0111444201,
0.0070197987,
-0.0708652958,
-0.0074928217,
0.0742171779,
-0.0651854649,
0.0020073182,
-0.0148613518,
0.0043000462,
0.0141953519,
-0.0458879471,
-0.0144127663,
0.0156333707,
-0.0242768694,
-0.0064035067,
-0.0248996057,
0.0618295446,
0.0068712491,
0.0185507555,
-0.0014639141,
-0.0006084227,
0.0267707314,
-0.0077412226,
0.0086834384,
0.0135398321,
-0.0299576893,
0.0109899594,
0.0616597235,
-0.0265527349,
-0.0095036523,
-0.0016509135,
-0.0614006519,
-0.0756155699,
0.0330534428,
-0.1224500984,
0.0027470242,
0.0389560573,
-0.0647723526,
0.0377809517,
0.003190394,
-0.0398154296,
-0.0379938744,
0.0038533285,
-0.0403801724,
-0.0065333331,
0.0480690449,
0.0098764142,
-0.0408307984,
-0.0184690859,
-0.0270251669,
0.0189885069,
-0.0026193904,
0.047750622,
-0.0408460759,
-0.0096562169,
0.0235714447,
-0.0112159811,
-0.0688531473,
-0.008895101,
0.0121902749,
0.0504930951,
0.0007145656,
-0.0182575975,
-0.0333692469,
-0.0438329577,
-0.0030716911,
0.0588227697,
-0.0242037196,
-0.0508542061,
-0.0186684746,
0.1547735929,
0.0060233297,
0.0087448768,
-0.019007165,
-0.0480107814,
-0.046254009,
-0.0565988682,
-0.0103011653,
-0.0213701427,
-0.0009487687,
-0.0010695362,
0.0108737126,
-0.0361684188,
-0.0015233988,
0.0107675875,
-0.0240422115,
0.0567863695,
-0.0045384639,
-0.0425594077,
0.0295962635,
0.0233576987,
-0.0255009122,
0.1020276845,
0.0411474369,
0.0435902886,
0.04462111,
-0.0064939908,
-0.0343845673,
0.07095287,
-0.0103158951,
0.0546109974,
-0.0505523123,
-0.0308230314,
0.0072433171,
0.0154114133,
0.0424665958,
0.0695475936,
-0.0124910362,
0.0030255422,
0.0898558646,
-0.0265464913,
-0.0111276256,
0.0329269096,
0.0306008309,
-0.0053537861,
-0.0483315028,
0.0201124046,
-0.0376080312,
0.0122242337,
-0.011951426,
-0.0498077087,
0.0902755931,
0.084311232,
0.0025193768,
-0.036291413,
0.0073973448,
0.010103845,
0.0165230054,
-0.036065314,
0.0154834129,
0.0159693863,
-0.0508339293,
0.0149679324,
-0.0004574881,
-0.0516393296,
0.0207416862,
-0.0023267656,
-0.0189215429,
0.068505086,
0.0527850464,
-0.0272347461,
-0.0054642512,
-0.0442025252,
-0.0118839946,
0.0360088721,
0.0133501533,
0.0189499967,
0.0675068945,
-0.0255946498,
-0.0351918824,
0.0720915571,
0.0097726882,
-0.0118797142,
-0.0416283049,
0.0644782111,
-0.0037881038,
-0.0206339918,
-0.034284018,
0.0237401891,
0.0467547551,
-0.0249466095,
0.033557497,
0.0309063755,
0.0281409957,
0.0217124429,
-0.0147068948,
-0.024300674,
0.0303106569,
-0.0128422352,
-0.0318684429,
0.070365876,
-0.027360294,
-0.0428985767,
0.0275355857,
-0.0384069048,
-0.015517164,
0.0469402932,
-0.0576470904,
0.0029249857,
0.0098666679,
-0.0412021205,
-0.0045914487,
-0.024841642,
0.0381731987,
-0.0069655557,
0.0591958612,
-0.0270638615,
0.0324638709,
-0.0033517301,
-0.0351428501,
-0.0268934127,
-0.0199419279,
0.0045639724,
-0.0274062008,
-0.0473129116,
0.0167543497,
0.0179287158,
0.0423202589,
0.0283897594,
0.0064115077,
-0.023072632,
-0.0118344883,
-0.0392006449,
0.0166344214,
0.0107727163,
0.0184966661,
0.0295708776,
0.0294299684,
0.0080797719,
-0.00455978,
0.0128886038,
0.0053921188,
0.0204156805,
0.0279894341,
0.0045757014,
-0.0124093909,
0.018698642,
0.0197546929,
-0.0081936177,
-0.0230360907,
0.0688871071,
-0.0013773893,
-0.0668683946,
-0.0790483132,
0.0065842816,
-0.0054299543,
0.0089947302,
0.0437958091,
-0.0758307278,
-0.01823847,
0.0031341154,
0.0333769098,
0.0668961927,
0.0214752741,
0.0150880758,
0.0487422496,
0.0169790778,
-0.0079723597,
0.0058800885,
-0.0121276081,
-0.0117545249,
0.0254086927,
-0.0307336152,
-0.0141751273,
0.0033179962,
0.0036083485,
-0.0016107197,
-0.0389347821,
0.0360295437,
0.0027692262,
-0.0058240648,
0.0237158667,
-0.0175542105,
-0.0146142915,
0.008160606,
0.0140707912,
-0.0524236672,
0.0388916805,
-0.0015012873,
0.0033712348,
-0.0392894857,
0.0279605668,
0.0229705554,
0.0172978453,
-0.0303692967,
0.0505072586,
0.0074545699,
-0.0253050961,
-0.0206367224,
0.0129063623,
0.057262715,
-0.0260608643,
0.0184595864,
-0.0558277741,
-0.0332248844,
-0.0265975408,
-0.0341757759,
-0.0161146279,
-0.0012947079,
0.0123785464,
-0.0236036889,
0.0181041081,
-0.0023567984,
-0.023541877,
0.01523533,
-0.0128156524,
0.0228642467,
-0.0110305585,
-0.0177754406,
0.0037514882,
0.0243519619,
-0.012903871,
-0.0389546007,
0.035031084,
-0.0337400883,
0.0588525496,
0.0981758833,
-0.0543858409,
-0.0293510407,
-0.0348475017,
0.0089033004,
0.0317015983,
0.0490901023,
-0.0109288301,
-0.0154566029,
0.0214772299,
-0.0472887233,
0.0368799306,
0.0263739433,
-0.0177732799,
-0.0626544952,
0.0136645632,
-0.02249185,
0.0351542681,
0.0103624966,
0.0063359994,
-0.1059532836,
-0.0288663693,
0.0173141062,
0.0354350917,
0.0135820368,
-0.0068639689,
0.008484656,
-0.0389458649,
0.027377829,
0.0590016618,
-0.0437635519,
-0.023914462,
0.0180198401,
-0.0398670398,
-0.0387060903,
0.0442636125,
-0.0212900117,
0.0132654952,
-0.0438760407,
0.0090268962,
0.0060908133,
-0.0465783626,
-0.0352421254,
-0.0386579782,
-0.0052375966,
0.0087932283,
0.037192665,
-0.0106766708,
-0.011379879,
0.0602343492,
-0.0083922651,
-0.0334619842,
-0.0215222817,
0.0775112808,
-0.0119967973,
-0.0270481743,
-0.0066977586,
0.005263668,
0.007780055,
0.0027467103,
-0.0028597475,
0.0577103794,
-0.0262980796,
0.0088152485,
-0.010799366,
0.0227790382,
0.0087314053,
0.0453445539,
0.002819197,
-0.0504276417,
-0.0254841652,
-0.0289021619,
-0.0178863034,
-0.0665623471,
-0.0260882918,
-0.0233050399,
-0.0710531175,
-0.1144382283,
-0.1032790914,
-0.0007663448,
-0.0386176035,
0.0518906936,
-0.006714555,
-0.0116543509,
-0.0500511713,
0.0311473068,
-0.0175739266,
0.0336072966,
0.0140769165,
0.0357796811,
-0.0429838337,
0.0614078529,
-0.0270871371,
-0.0136048514,
-0.0024357606,
0.0790183321,
-0.0661893189,
-0.0875744075,
-0.0331527367,
0.0659290776,
0.0190635249,
0.028260272,
-0.0231005941,
-0.0449410677,
0.0368361212,
0.0357405506,
-0.032531742,
-0.012297539,
0.0832894966,
-0.0021261454,
-0.0011229718,
0.0382314958,
-0.0155993914,
-0.0017652162,
0.0136997737,
0.0221656431,
-0.0078608217,
-0.0282850955,
-0.0044075642,
-0.0019581702,
0.0394297764,
-0.061804425,
-0.0214602053,
-0.0138614774,
0.0213931873,
-0.007671752,
-0.0372457206,
-0.0486141033,
0.0449185856,
0.0192689504,
-0.0269325338,
0.001651746,
0.0272968393,
-0.0197261423,
-0.0262598246,
0.014232059,
0.0305181593,
0.0011142974,
0.0054862979,
0.0456696451,
0.0450480618,
-0.0091195358,
-0.0051807528,
0.009746273,
0.0241916534,
-0.0607598275,
0.0280349534,
-0.0059579466,
0.0266845468,
0.0219735559,
0.0846502259,
0.0108376462,
0.0267017391,
-0.0600145198,
0.0129479384,
0.0582681559,
-0.0018593752,
0.1088527814,
-0.0078863408,
-0.0098930169,
-0.0268371683,
0.0359926783,
-0.0140601499,
-0.0418499522,
-0.0234634876,
-0.0251117107,
-0.0099248299,
0.0188115481,
0.0643611923,
-0.03118998,
0.0159919132,
-0.0138185788,
-0.0523950532,
-0.0023471527,
-0.007124709,
0.0475634597,
0.0051482562,
-0.0273758993,
-0.0202103667,
-0.0319342948,
-0.0777175725,
-0.0166815761,
0.001047364,
0.0079655116,
0.0140984105,
-0.0026762919,
0.0387898162,
-0.0014131321,
-0.0346589051,
-0.0245764144,
0.0166700743,
0.0239267871,
0.014550155,
0.0023692723,
-6.160571569e-33,
0.0095123649,
-0.0199857112,
-0.0349777602,
-0.0095311906,
-0.0018255211,
-0.0084233703,
-0.0118417246,
-0.0101643847,
0.0184035916,
0.0156537835,
0.0314852595,
-0.0119111817,
0.0162395574,
-0.0129915392,
-0.0134648867,
0.0353176035,
0.0410761423,
0.0121891815,
-0.0342394821,
0.0281588659,
0.0514428876,
0.0172961075,
0.0628197119,
-0.0686772168,
-0.000256063,
0.0010205832,
-0.0485675484,
0.007134093,
-0.0092126466,
0.040656995,
0.0014572408,
0.0405141525,
0.0078840032,
-0.017406648,
-0.0150422864,
0.0264732558,
-0.0389344506,
0.0223027263,
0.0086226594,
0.0441756807,
-0.0138716241,
-0.0649232641,
0.0694519728,
-0.0301778242,
-0.030322846,
-0.0283599347,
0.0143406903,
-0.0421541892,
-0.0190390255,
-0.0303231981,
-0.0647913888,
0.0336230174,
-0.0160747413,
-0.0226313174,
0.0287739038,
0.0623945929,
0.0282572862,
-0.0149098467,
-0.0500703119,
0.0090959696,
-0.0721152201,
0.0003846996,
0.0667089224,
-0.0139299938,
-0.015749678,
0.0219870787,
0.0062439106,
0.0096230712,
0.0483339205,
0.0051573669,
0.0255006775,
-0.0226837918,
0.0404803902,
0.0758773983,
0.0322424285,
-0.0407041498,
-0.033928711,
0.0545532331,
-0.0033478132,
0.0427285694,
0.0148323914,
0.0210320931,
-0.0178791527,
-0.0086506419,
-0.0159233436,
-0.0362425707,
-0.0272419918,
-0.0183270276,
0.0069030239,
-0.0007136192,
-0.0349238701,
0.0134654343,
0.0574942343,
-0.02542991,
0.0367638879,
0.0046381089,
-0.0308452118,
-0.0007851293,
-0.0251864884,
0.0240938682,
0.0549012646,
-0.0211710334,
0.0173666533,
-0.0128355445,
0.0261579733,
-0.0313044302,
0.0652019233,
0.0398558676,
-0.0671817958,
0.0226548985,
-0.0308919642,
0.0276982076,
0.0199808441,
0.0546386093,
-0.003222856,
-0.0318484679,
0.0118288565,
0.0136261499,
0.0585078709,
0.0494264178,
-0.03950461,
-0.0341572277,
0.0082975877,
0.0266205501,
-0.0556293242,
0.002627342,
-0.0001696481,
0.0189274382,
0.0626456141,
-0.1097233668,
-0.0408940241,
-0.0284099709,
2.757e-7,
0.0486733019,
0.0340289474,
-0.0077032726,
-0.0497173853,
0.0287186373,
0.0337409414,
-0.0194408726,
0.0453765839,
-0.0156555455,
0.0285936613,
0.0033835056,
-0.0151033942,
0.0891783983,
0.0496852659,
-0.0463306867,
-0.0306663848,
-0.0534884445,
0.0197993647,
-0.0519914217,
0.0031583521,
0.0701470077,
0.0922522992,
-0.0127419876,
-0.0393658914,
0.0146903871,
-0.0423578694,
0.0394640043,
0.0081784194,
-0.0003720713,
-0.0371524654,
0.0322924368,
-0.0133929616,
-0.0128178922,
-0.0139525477,
-0.0441802368,
-0.0426000133,
0.0238329601,
0.0560296886,
-0.0303028729,
-0.01300597,
0.0223819427,
-0.0291302707,
-0.0150914965,
-0.038614545,
0.0627873912,
0.0096538123,
-0.0143876383,
-0.0264122114,
-0.0206752736,
-0.0205702931,
0.0425247923,
-0.0429041684,
-0.0879650638,
0.0385243222,
0.0529158339,
-0.0036612321,
-0.0358787626,
-0.076255396,
-0.0318729877,
-0.0361180082,
-0.0186594632,
-0.0796061382,
-0.001589112,
0.0107893376,
0.0141670872,
-0.0550255217,
0.0003186523,
2.607900109e-34,
0.0509518832,
-0.0472098514,
0.0186052695,
-0.0520199835,
0.0296008065,
-0.0111896452,
0.007859285,
0.0037852016,
-0.0015357062,
-0.0191245917,
-0.0268657152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06530v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06530v2 | Exploring ChatGPT's Capabilities on Vulnerability Management | 2023-11-11T11:01:13 | 2024-06-20T06:18:13 | Peiyu Liu, Junming Liu, Lirong Fu, Kangjie Lu, Yifan Xia, Xuhong Zhang, Wenzhi Chen, Haiqin Weng, Shouling Ji, Wenhai Wang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Recently, ChatGPT has attracted great attention from the code analysis
domain. Prior works show that ChatGPT has the capabilities of processing
foundational code analysis tasks, such as abstract syntax tree generation,
which indicates the potential of using ChatGPT to comprehend code syntax and
static behaviors. However, it is unclear whether ChatGPT can complete more
complicated real-world vulnerability management tasks, such as the prediction
of security relevance and patch correctness, which require an all-encompassing
understanding of various aspects, including code syntax, program semantics, and
related manual comments.
In this paper, we explore ChatGPT's capabilities on 6 tasks involving the
complete vulnerability management process with a large-scale dataset containing
70,346 samples. For each task, we compare ChatGPT against SOTA approaches,
investigate the impact of different prompts, and explore the difficulties. The
results suggest promising potential in leveraging ChatGPT to assist
vulnerability management. One notable example is ChatGPT's proficiency in tasks
like generating titles for software bug reports. Furthermore, our findings
reveal the difficulties encountered by ChatGPT and shed light on promising
future directions. For instance, directly providing random demonstration
examples in the prompt cannot consistently guarantee good performance in
vulnerability management. By contrast, leveraging ChatGPT in a self-heuristic
way -- extracting expertise from demonstration examples itself and integrating
the extracted expertise in the prompt is a promising research direction.
Besides, ChatGPT may misunderstand and misuse the information in the prompt.
Consequently, effectively guiding ChatGPT to focus on helpful information
rather than the irrelevant content is still an open problem. | [
0.0221145619,
0.0141854081,
-0.0233734585,
-0.013032198,
-0.045547992,
-0.0134806465,
-0.0164870676,
-0.0059205191,
0.0403003059,
-0.0315450355,
0.0158298612,
0.0168968998,
-0.0057721063,
0.0239956621,
0.0403840616,
-0.0327621214,
0.0658617839,
-0.0432201959,
0.0159098059,
0.0351966806,
0.0088486355,
0.0174358599,
-0.0411737934,
0.0763388127,
0.0127495276,
-0.0353620574,
-0.0172356702,
0.0388058797,
0.0322779864,
-0.0364041254,
0.0121391825,
0.0050425213,
-0.0039982931,
-0.0190830994,
0.0000022442,
-0.0312657021,
-0.0251171403,
0.0411662944,
-0.0004498812,
0.0416454636,
-0.007868154,
0.0081835939,
-0.0070926403,
0.0399037935,
-0.0066043693,
0.0051323092,
0.0496189743,
-0.0160327721,
0.0779556409,
0.0609149411,
0.0193640385,
0.0653683543,
0.0350270942,
0.0193675049,
0.0779760182,
-0.0430045612,
-0.014373593,
0.0185449515,
0.0050749783,
0.0339732654,
0.0201078486,
-0.0075580534,
0.0204916261,
0.0037511245,
0.0094444724,
0.0595492907,
-0.0259201787,
0.0154351853,
0.0043352153,
-0.0134577779,
-0.0443274751,
-0.0014423802,
0.0048615267,
0.0034644613,
-0.0078753214,
0.0088572847,
0.0182538591,
0.0109032905,
-0.0256755017,
-0.0465702452,
0.0421907976,
-0.0061374842,
-0.0000447045,
-0.0303666033,
0.0104549406,
0.0458385572,
-0.0345094092,
-0.0076090801,
0.011293605,
-0.0303231776,
-0.0002082647,
-0.05559301,
-0.0293702781,
0.0335626341,
-0.0154377446,
0.0320154168,
0.0056885998,
-0.0152428504,
0.0585107841,
-0.0298129972,
-0.0676567256,
0.0433661491,
-0.047404483,
-0.0409697071,
-0.0221608635,
0.0199218951,
0.0392946787,
0.049415987,
0.0287747905,
0.0202236474,
-0.0873552784,
-0.0126363654,
-0.0189878959,
0.0393752754,
0.0377789252,
0.0535075366,
-0.0056519574,
0.0460089296,
-0.019213615,
0.0635702759,
-0.028562123,
-0.0459626503,
-0.0530916564,
0.0138466088,
0.0071681128,
-0.0672816709,
-0.0319326408,
-0.034718547,
-0.0370347612,
-0.0526039936,
-0.022626685,
-0.0085446481,
-0.0428309776,
-0.032201916,
-0.0191226546,
0.1011143774,
0.018103689,
0.0165284891,
-0.0491468795,
-0.0419989973,
-0.0123496251,
0.0261419546,
-0.0081798052,
-0.0511549599,
-0.050537467,
0.0144969635,
0.0140190031,
0.0012804801,
-0.0146971717,
-0.0218995996,
-0.0184089411,
0.06556876,
-0.0088898782,
-0.0108647635,
0.0391142108,
0.0560753234,
-0.0037496234,
0.0005882827,
-0.0284933336,
0.0405700617,
0.0091808969,
-0.0430347808,
0.0509738214,
-0.0174066797,
-0.0136724589,
0.0394520611,
0.0604531467,
0.0407739095,
0.0190612152,
-0.0483320691,
0.0213182252,
0.0104060899,
-0.0033663849,
-0.0123772072,
0.0006515307,
0.0202054903,
-0.000720811,
0.0756553411,
0.0362454504,
0.0531775802,
-0.0230232794,
0.0014040648,
-0.0631934702,
0.0450394861,
-0.0484874062,
-0.0139491297,
-0.0485758185,
0.0024468347,
-0.0174223725,
0.0096917255,
-0.0096708313,
0.0327575877,
-0.0356306396,
-0.0139635289,
-0.0186584238,
0.017273508,
0.0157474298,
0.0523448139,
0.0414519459,
-0.0003416858,
-0.0424386784,
-0.0944044441,
-0.023439385,
0.040358942,
0.047877524,
-0.0813172683,
-0.0807872862,
-0.0100042718,
-0.0311366245,
-0.045820076,
0.0486077741,
0.0041120723,
-0.0161546692,
-0.0310192648,
0.0046604755,
-0.0580828711,
0.0201882794,
0.0703618303,
-0.0037353262,
-0.0233436171,
0.0257747602,
-0.032088846,
-0.0222343598,
0.0292731393,
0.0566380061,
-0.0217946544,
0.0157270674,
-0.006721457,
0.0163038839,
-0.015239208,
-0.0261351559,
0.0330773592,
0.0174426772,
0.034217421,
-0.0305249896,
0.0036252441,
-0.0376558602,
-0.0088457381,
-0.0065666214,
-0.0622386076,
0.0066112736,
0.0082646031,
-0.0452738293,
0.0017525414,
0.0544919036,
-0.0612257868,
-0.0150734326,
-0.0006098218,
-0.0159726255,
0.0009459071,
-0.0241791047,
-0.0302118137,
0.0648561269,
0.0682884678,
-0.0183041468,
-0.0491489805,
0.0654460564,
0.0083424188,
-0.0256261099,
-0.038621895,
-0.0076954844,
-0.039621938,
0.0163946841,
0.0291449279,
0.0571270175,
-0.0098393634,
-0.030666152,
-0.1057178155,
0.0018124407,
-0.0192371123,
0.0518724434,
0.0479579195,
0.0065127928,
-0.035106536,
-0.0098238122,
-0.0190375205,
-0.0206366908,
-0.0565001741,
0.0055679334,
0.042207282,
0.0081607569,
-0.0096360426,
-0.0303118788,
0.0000857517,
-0.0578023158,
0.0124295112,
0.0092107709,
-0.0323183499,
-0.0314634554,
0.067764461,
-0.0200459789,
-0.0044310344,
-0.0116645386,
-0.0773042813,
0.0111934952,
-0.0218250491,
0.0143978912,
-0.0067300154,
0.0139798271,
0.048401095,
0.0631530434,
0.0151638584,
-0.0405443832,
-0.0036967725,
0.0382963344,
-0.0705076158,
0.0292602647,
-0.0281414352,
0.0126949726,
0.0260648616,
0.0319169387,
-0.027714448,
-0.0385531709,
-0.0070001977,
-0.0131842736,
0.0421340726,
-0.0101611856,
-0.0508062206,
0.0248417519,
0.0082296152,
-0.0395492911,
-0.0733871013,
0.0667508394,
-0.0168771185,
-0.0351486243,
-0.0788977668,
-0.0350911245,
-0.0693491027,
0.106116049,
-0.0353299342,
0.0023393652,
0.0483434759,
-0.0719884187,
-0.0276521556,
-0.0319903009,
0.0257236343,
-0.002722692,
-0.013454888,
-0.0571770519,
0.0161477569,
-0.0014338192,
-0.0245788526,
-0.0311615858,
-0.039743308,
0.0021939664,
-0.0061481199,
0.0172458645,
0.0082385717,
0.034587346,
0.0194313508,
0.039338246,
0.0229979903,
0.0560796447,
-0.0644367635,
-0.0075188237,
-0.0767957568,
-0.0289302301,
-0.0595110618,
0.0109772505,
0.0368090868,
0.008171645,
0.0581432953,
0.083638899,
0.0254099686,
-0.042433314,
-0.0164832082,
-0.0479435474,
-0.0721572787,
-0.0142501462,
0.0406713672,
0.0265786517,
-0.0444018766,
-0.0287062638,
0.0672931969,
0.0633150637,
-0.0232411437,
0.0339572839,
-0.0103719318,
0.0049223402,
0.0359891243,
0.0445343517,
-0.0764376074,
0.006196171,
-0.0018099071,
0.0357493721,
-0.0185900033,
-0.0294188894,
-0.0050315275,
-0.0771487728,
0.041591756,
0.0004224411,
0.0112343971,
0.0034277947,
-0.0184874833,
0.0000092004,
-0.0066860407,
-0.0404703841,
0.0300322566,
-0.0051190858,
0.0238694418,
0.0060402309,
-0.0788575858,
-0.0074586915,
0.0758359805,
-0.0032435488,
-0.0005307656,
0.0630506054,
-0.019031154,
-0.0032075564,
0.0420452096,
0.0894972906,
-0.0255099256,
0.0461501405,
-0.0067027747,
0.0767111629,
0.0094570732,
-0.0035108109,
0.0499659032,
0.0294878446,
-0.0479640737,
-0.0104636205,
0.0726366267,
0.0084187007,
-0.0533590652,
0.0050034705,
0.0013386525,
-0.0048881653,
0.0342481546,
0.0086050229,
0.0537927896,
-0.0094375834,
0.0110725649,
-0.0359928496,
0.0429226086,
-0.0156628639,
-0.025752075,
-0.0141395703,
0.0029017848,
-0.0460376926,
-0.0670921803,
-0.0390278995,
0.0169965588,
0.0174950361,
0.0294021219,
-0.1133632436,
-0.0422244333,
0.0508292131,
-0.0226915441,
0.0296943113,
-0.0157169476,
-0.0015950911,
0.0178409088,
-0.0234504268,
-0.0024208436,
0.0025212041,
-0.0426490121,
-0.0009154552,
-0.032040026,
-0.0382634103,
-0.020048663,
0.0484194644,
0.0215321016,
-0.029736679,
-0.0708738938,
-0.0254205633,
0.0090499884,
0.0476025715,
-0.0572588444,
-0.0171717722,
0.0333224386,
-0.048155576,
0.0181964841,
-0.0168383364,
-0.0187327713,
0.0009457818,
0.0136839775,
-0.0171238743,
-0.0194422342,
0.0213666018,
0.0386676006,
0.0214687772,
0.08335758,
0.0460329466,
0.026430646,
0.0088162003,
0.0050890245,
0.0284039564,
0.0076563889,
0.0052594543,
0.0160294715,
-0.0310392156,
-0.0389778465,
0.027963819,
-0.0166949686,
-0.0750054792,
0.0238711201,
0.0273210574,
0.0503560379,
0.0450664535,
0.0364775322,
0.0650360957,
0.0007973787,
-0.0115565537,
-0.0218247678,
0.0223649442,
0.0155686513,
0.0087686358,
0.0308402553,
-0.016251158,
0.0322108082,
0.0180432498,
0.0136684217,
-0.0688139275,
-0.0868759379,
0.0483114608,
0.0791389123,
0.0434836634,
0.0572590269,
-0.0256115105,
-0.0344456919,
0.0080356449,
-0.0270661637,
0.0250123497,
-0.0330564305,
-0.0532559901,
0.0100336401,
0.0127759837,
-0.0006185551,
-0.0745734572,
0.0672940388,
-0.0357751586,
0.0391283333,
-0.0141141769,
-0.0603088252,
-0.0407583825,
-0.0125507545,
0.0103435917,
0.004882595,
0.0021870912,
-0.0252453834,
-0.0524905808,
-0.0625934675,
-0.0068268115,
-0.0019287316,
0.0367999449,
0.0262242313,
0.0139594758,
0.0702167004,
-0.0110203167,
-0.0032120114,
-0.0203019269,
-0.0079989545,
-0.0325189419,
-0.0255382918,
-0.0289799143,
-5.567903847e-33,
-0.0249097701,
-0.0196215194,
-0.0164876319,
0.0566231869,
0.0374745764,
0.0058657764,
-0.0435237363,
0.039603129,
-0.0050185123,
-0.0092509892,
0.0026868596,
0.0258756578,
0.000212135,
-0.0704124942,
0.0411717594,
0.0009509095,
0.0074753226,
0.0357148461,
-0.0265754014,
0.0442632176,
0.0135906972,
0.0098993238,
0.0142766349,
-0.0924640298,
0.0230174903,
-0.004029783,
-0.0034121622,
-0.0315659009,
-0.010902293,
0.0499329381,
0.0306570046,
0.0178471338,
0.0042764652,
0.0077254502,
0.0028599515,
-0.0295194574,
-0.0097844712,
-0.080890961,
0.0004920267,
-0.0560975261,
0.0318334252,
-0.0361615531,
0.0051847873,
0.0010993547,
0.0302458294,
-0.0296020117,
0.0123882256,
0.0259574726,
0.0400696173,
-0.0548115261,
0.0144636286,
0.0319952071,
-0.0730652511,
0.0049877986,
-0.0531484112,
0.0211214814,
0.0305628814,
-0.0258679893,
0.0382873639,
0.0020942797,
0.0504444763,
-0.0165530164,
0.0213473625,
-0.0156480484,
-0.0522411317,
0.0085272174,
-0.0364992693,
0.0125661753,
0.0148181636,
0.0187472478,
0.0144405961,
0.0186367445,
0.0214190595,
0.0051430655,
0.0202224143,
-0.0112969847,
-0.0531024188,
0.0438955463,
0.0289787427,
0.0600867458,
0.0265613385,
0.0168703031,
-0.0794594213,
-0.020433845,
-0.0262836404,
0.0197862592,
-0.0271904506,
-0.0558881611,
0.0131633766,
-0.0250961408,
-0.0387944132,
0.0454734415,
-0.0311049353,
0.0039373036,
0.0334670395,
-0.003469357,
-0.0629880503,
0.0065693501,
-0.0480113104,
0.0013222094,
-0.0007250623,
-0.0099035976,
0.0013596141,
0.0020488179,
0.0561993979,
-0.0087269433,
0.0294095334,
0.0263246931,
-0.059008792,
0.0052413587,
-0.0207797047,
0.0544546433,
-0.0410057642,
0.0200619474,
-0.0004129054,
0.0150160342,
0.0151981525,
-0.0111935241,
0.0220363103,
-0.0208345372,
-0.0715517178,
0.0717621893,
-0.0484419875,
0.0178851895,
-0.0064836503,
-0.0115263369,
0.0418263115,
-0.0054449853,
0.0173310246,
-0.0057388199,
-0.0296252873,
0.0188299455,
2.964e-7,
0.0290937498,
0.0104559939,
0.0259382818,
0.0190018862,
0.0163950976,
0.0393779799,
-0.0228038747,
0.0541810729,
0.0228998885,
-0.0344377495,
0.016377883,
0.0090377806,
0.025400145,
0.0654579774,
-0.0171441212,
-0.0544239841,
-0.0270497371,
0.0006771914,
-0.0703677237,
0.0613166504,
0.0899568126,
0.029172089,
0.0040554726,
-0.0053914459,
0.0017268066,
-0.0538239554,
-0.0099386256,
0.0058306786,
0.0133176567,
0.065980874,
-0.025684448,
0.0560632646,
-0.0004283276,
0.0661183223,
-0.0289807264,
-0.0677856281,
-0.0415138192,
0.0446902923,
0.0223930981,
0.0096761538,
-0.0016336935,
0.0098518617,
0.0317844488,
-0.066665858,
0.0356647782,
-0.0379613787,
-0.0046021468,
0.0185336098,
0.0050660805,
0.0003473998,
-0.0083523765,
-0.0040918398,
-0.0126407435,
-0.0044790381,
-0.0382021144,
-0.0179240331,
-0.0089992778,
-0.0490051657,
-0.0306537487,
0.017990863,
-0.0301835425,
-0.0471599698,
0.0054228306,
0.0261817481,
0.0121621964,
-0.0107409097,
0.0444646589,
2.639870341e-34,
0.0193235055,
-0.0381367467,
-0.0121764392,
-0.0489631109,
0.0320894718,
0.0146240676,
0.0222299397,
0.0436857827,
-0.007329158,
0.0798754543,
-0.032886304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03710v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03710v1 | Don't Overlook the Grammatical Gender: Bias Evaluation for Hindi-English Machine Translation | 2023-11-11T09:28:43 | 2023-11-11T09:28:43 | Pushpdeep Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models, though state-of-the-art for
translation, often reflect social biases, particularly gender bias. Existing
evaluation benchmarks primarily focus on English as the source language of
translation. For source languages other than English, studies often employ
gender-neutral sentences for bias evaluation, whereas real-world sentences
frequently contain gender information in different forms. Therefore, it makes
more sense to evaluate for bias using such source sentences to determine if NMT
models can discern gender from the grammatical gender cues rather than relying
on biased associations. To illustrate this, we create two gender-specific
sentence sets in Hindi to automatically evaluate gender bias in various
Hindi-English (HI-EN) NMT systems. We emphasise the significance of tailoring
bias evaluation test sets to account for grammatical gender markers in the
source language. | [
0.0518065728,
0.0362446047,
-0.0217082761,
0.0503715202,
-0.046369262,
0.0198062416,
0.0266425442,
-0.022087004,
0.0017122921,
-0.0328802578,
-0.0218541306,
-0.0726850778,
0.0474179536,
-0.010880867,
0.0184211526,
-0.0355254523,
0.0148418723,
0.0424550697,
0.0171281006,
-0.0071652653,
0.0383056626,
0.056018535,
-0.0084261782,
0.0507245846,
-0.0299548991,
-0.0364204384,
0.0403992943,
0.0750806481,
0.0138618313,
-0.0242487378,
0.0431103408,
0.0583461337,
-0.0141368071,
0.0442665666,
0.0000015986,
-0.0749898702,
-0.0046237432,
0.0085401908,
0.0189267192,
0.0113715138,
0.0779257193,
-0.022811316,
-0.0217155721,
0.0346347019,
-0.0018307276,
0.0267425962,
0.0801411048,
0.0168749392,
0.0637000948,
0.0786596611,
-0.0238894839,
-0.0054585752,
-0.0516479611,
-0.0454902798,
-0.0131969722,
-0.0109400796,
0.0069121518,
-0.0365322866,
-0.0634555444,
-0.0223505665,
-0.0169494525,
0.011939656,
-0.0113131925,
-0.0196256768,
-0.0234080311,
0.0259791054,
-0.0244736653,
-0.0461645573,
0.0073317555,
0.0445043258,
-0.0195617154,
0.0083983866,
0.0169743765,
-0.009594732,
-0.0203680769,
-0.0049796044,
-0.0215168241,
0.0180745795,
-0.0273736734,
0.0017398533,
0.0546863303,
-0.0023597516,
0.0025871901,
0.0535207614,
0.0407303199,
0.0365047418,
0.0238928366,
-0.0169730037,
-0.0102744419,
0.0150149614,
0.0189414788,
-0.025516402,
0.0563133843,
-0.0390800871,
0.0139223542,
0.0064732991,
-0.0102199651,
-0.0478494205,
0.0163838565,
-0.0860045552,
0.0054405816,
0.0538446121,
-0.0062681087,
-0.0071817678,
-0.0039231363,
0.0161714423,
-0.006223355,
0.0157656204,
-0.0472431518,
-0.0224147737,
0.0302738342,
-0.0278385878,
-0.0171569139,
-0.0169972163,
-0.0437697768,
0.0406256728,
-0.0644810572,
-0.0227508731,
-0.0211885739,
-0.0369422361,
0.045375295,
-0.0006353434,
-0.0438295379,
-0.0228672419,
0.026872037,
0.0490419604,
-0.0636832416,
0.0299154129,
-0.0115115959,
-0.1020302325,
-0.0283506494,
0.0153036369,
-0.0208734218,
-0.0458889194,
-0.03442505,
0.0309762452,
-0.016976947,
-0.0323567912,
-0.0319257677,
0.0044176145,
-0.0357991345,
-0.0572327934,
0.0027165082,
-0.0385532863,
0.0460658558,
0.040603932,
0.0250362903,
-0.015123805,
-0.0080951182,
0.0398283601,
-0.0018618467,
0.057423912,
0.0830388814,
0.0048237573,
0.0680084005,
0.0153002059,
0.0119043728,
0.059761446,
0.0548972562,
0.0132825337,
0.0198820233,
0.002429385,
-0.0077519319,
0.0446129926,
0.0134486128,
0.0003949719,
-0.0505993031,
0.0447322726,
-0.046210099,
0.0634866878,
0.0387828052,
0.0236886609,
0.0165039767,
0.0311614182,
0.0452024899,
0.0696649626,
0.0349692181,
0.0737714469,
0.0235930234,
-0.0005339932,
0.0099339047,
0.0238401331,
-0.055477269,
0.0320000313,
-0.0404408686,
-0.0397277661,
-0.0051682326,
0.0392752625,
-0.0025617497,
-0.0221686531,
-0.0074692518,
0.004669881,
0.0077568255,
-0.045078788,
0.0066605904,
0.0209355764,
-0.0055315755,
0.0449112281,
0.0212429259,
-0.0750771388,
0.0188856609,
-0.0285200179,
-0.0058845542,
0.0034183643,
-0.0042973841,
-0.0129921576,
-0.0080255736,
-0.0073397779,
-0.0513543114,
0.0440057218,
0.0560828447,
0.0117626106,
0.0160020422,
-0.0604323521,
0.0127026485,
0.051206287,
0.0250199866,
0.037294995,
0.0152757755,
0.0693103746,
0.0453148894,
-0.021602951,
-0.08048103,
0.0365417935,
0.0300764609,
-0.0218203776,
0.0388032384,
0.0103161391,
0.0594647788,
0.0201226082,
-0.0272857491,
-0.0044970443,
-0.0076949247,
-0.0040340316,
-0.017474005,
0.0420733243,
-0.0379625931,
-0.0649841577,
-0.039017234,
-0.0793602467,
-0.0405524299,
0.0481601357,
-0.0406971797,
-0.0357681736,
0.0298345927,
-0.0273397379,
-0.0435101837,
-0.0471894257,
0.0156108132,
0.0126091372,
0.011340607,
-0.0229812022,
0.0155827338,
-0.0157742649,
-0.055614315,
-0.0020612294,
-0.0393555425,
0.0449299924,
-0.0714147314,
-0.0532603711,
0.0475980639,
0.0352777615,
0.0294334274,
0.0425686352,
0.0101772835,
-0.041584637,
-0.0622184463,
-0.0585917644,
-0.0115722716,
-0.0084255273,
0.0217701253,
0.0190458894,
0.0496072657,
-0.0327518843,
-0.0164128095,
0.0078722667,
-0.0004396354,
0.0177323949,
0.0327411853,
0.054136619,
-0.024167167,
0.0518816337,
-0.0254348852,
-0.043381013,
-0.0566653982,
0.0460313372,
0.0561075583,
-0.0399937257,
-0.0640224218,
-0.0334342942,
-0.0111622754,
-0.0440901071,
0.0019126249,
-0.0766955614,
0.0076416945,
0.0067245187,
0.0268296245,
0.0884885341,
0.0077425973,
-0.0004096056,
0.0252864603,
0.028357571,
-0.0233098119,
-0.0179551989,
0.0317595936,
0.0163336881,
0.0061557111,
-0.0711592436,
-0.006630979,
-0.0003008332,
0.0168869086,
-0.0169848949,
-0.0336992778,
0.030558683,
-0.0294425376,
-0.0004916973,
0.0007620459,
0.0310118292,
-0.001672281,
0.0395993441,
-0.0293858759,
-0.0466326922,
0.0482368432,
-0.0059937239,
-0.0238032565,
-0.066402927,
0.0405341499,
-0.0624854341,
0.0189452209,
-0.0259723924,
0.0180893652,
0.0059028245,
-0.0500901528,
-0.0666264221,
-0.0195990764,
0.0129061211,
-0.0155846532,
-0.0005624975,
-0.0633037835,
0.0097023426,
-0.0264929254,
-0.0254165921,
-0.010667827,
-0.0447565094,
-0.0046603614,
-0.0154003929,
-0.0156409014,
-0.0062913052,
0.0298261642,
0.0483837612,
-0.0477349013,
0.0126727493,
-0.0505986959,
0.019573126,
0.0000805499,
0.0064800829,
0.0362163261,
-0.0174021404,
0.0036699548,
-0.0009317189,
0.0010658578,
-0.0291373171,
-0.0185329262,
0.0342180245,
-0.0230937619,
0.0084992349,
0.0340748839,
-0.024227174,
-0.0090133194,
-0.0109197404,
0.041456528,
-0.024526298,
0.016013233,
0.0990449339,
0.0137307998,
-0.0701926872,
-0.0207173806,
-0.0348818377,
0.0247952677,
-0.0080388077,
0.0259725228,
-0.0429964066,
-0.0055552837,
0.0270505287,
-0.0062673395,
0.0068596522,
-0.0265135039,
-0.0405883454,
-0.1182722896,
-0.0206331052,
0.0134597514,
-0.0302965529,
-0.0343872681,
0.0128310276,
-0.0313725583,
-0.0513353199,
0.0507773422,
0.013152021,
-0.0021198052,
-0.0097946916,
-0.0106833437,
0.004568879,
-0.0377522223,
0.0185349453,
-0.0732876807,
0.048960261,
0.055962611,
0.051527679,
-0.039397873,
0.0092151454,
0.0328833349,
-0.0262023043,
0.0150706805,
-0.0328445807,
0.0358252898,
-0.0470031723,
-0.020529272,
-0.0269815363,
0.0372696593,
0.0519175641,
0.0460885465,
0.0029940787,
0.0189554915,
0.0218482427,
-0.0187710542,
-0.0266717244,
-0.022428073,
0.0067456681,
0.0537224449,
0.0312360581,
-0.0474219322,
-0.0450374633,
-0.0352781378,
-0.0104823662,
0.0140733067,
-0.0407866091,
0.0018406393,
-0.0238037929,
-0.050103277,
-0.0531507805,
-0.0815353245,
-0.0033324778,
0.0207277145,
0.0147575894,
-0.0323019996,
0.0279988572,
0.0287122745,
-0.0280189309,
0.0318641588,
-0.0057866196,
0.0188078545,
-0.0137478672,
0.0183050688,
0.0053808209,
-0.0288913492,
-0.020504253,
0.0016966979,
-0.0272874143,
-0.05522139,
0.0201304872,
0.0516983271,
0.0193323251,
0.0509098619,
-0.0351688713,
-0.0766939819,
0.0219003297,
0.0134189911,
-0.0168537684,
0.0018112637,
0.0324040018,
0.0252964143,
-0.0151450392,
0.0543191172,
-0.0119246114,
0.006812321,
-0.0208093412,
0.0212115869,
0.0087251859,
-0.0448118672,
0.0283319745,
0.0238350779,
0.0224584304,
-0.088410303,
0.0397380739,
-0.0595902875,
-0.0099166716,
-0.0020929915,
-0.0397245474,
-0.0147925187,
-0.0460577868,
0.0787811726,
0.0333061069,
-0.0222607423,
-0.0437920466,
-0.0382682048,
-0.0051776869,
0.0105973063,
0.0153155718,
0.0220401324,
0.0953062102,
-0.0220325775,
0.0215869118,
0.019014148,
-0.0130656157,
-0.0371922515,
0.0139198741,
0.0051880982,
0.0617407002,
0.0072939927,
0.0346698351,
-0.0011001289,
0.0450861081,
0.0211052373,
0.0572224818,
-0.0220224056,
0.0083512943,
0.0417991169,
-0.0386134945,
0.1017979458,
-0.0134720728,
0.0011989194,
0.0094222566,
0.0373818725,
0.0063217673,
0.0278488826,
0.0359975025,
-0.0163968578,
0.0126487501,
-0.0099176383,
0.0296196304,
0.0232907217,
0.0049589477,
0.0155810202,
-0.0545824766,
-0.0130017456,
-0.0074536959,
-0.0271170847,
-0.0801774785,
-0.0017494826,
-0.0106568839,
-0.0712778717,
-0.0314744748,
0.0019823678,
-0.027493706,
0.0524788611,
-0.0135261305,
-0.0097969547,
0.0775331706,
-0.0348693989,
-0.05365064,
-0.0525912493,
0.003105771,
-0.0210220665,
-0.0052292664,
-0.0566670671,
-5.751951365e-33,
-0.0476638414,
0.0008881758,
-0.0195564441,
-0.0121513931,
-0.0248204675,
0.005993953,
-0.0363364331,
-0.0166483577,
0.029368937,
0.0392009653,
-0.0259811897,
0.0548586249,
0.0265524592,
-0.0281252563,
0.0519598238,
0.0053295926,
0.0606092066,
0.0072907982,
-0.0205742512,
-0.0361102447,
-0.0226420909,
0.025669612,
0.0920604542,
-0.0478341058,
0.0958210826,
-0.0456289425,
-0.0326379761,
0.0228279531,
-0.0395382568,
-0.0274556465,
0.0052050673,
0.0282286685,
0.0207094811,
-0.0213776529,
0.0163964331,
0.042005036,
-0.0700828508,
-0.0274991114,
0.0234879479,
0.0694363266,
0.0135014458,
-0.04260258,
0.0569446199,
-0.0186331067,
-0.0614025071,
0.0083475532,
0.0193336364,
0.0192774143,
0.0673624352,
0.0466921814,
-0.0468239896,
0.0291305277,
-0.0326938853,
0.0126683414,
0.0055995048,
0.0351132974,
-0.0170178525,
-0.0190975145,
-0.067165792,
0.0045395247,
-0.0115523199,
0.0067666443,
0.0179062355,
0.0221652444,
-0.0154183367,
-0.0205516126,
0.082195282,
0.0027374208,
-0.0006258512,
-0.0044240635,
0.0056368322,
-0.0359754749,
0.0382374488,
0.0497885384,
0.0638967752,
-0.0097372225,
-0.052393917,
-0.0051379488,
0.0131520284,
0.0520394854,
0.010545752,
-0.0248586964,
-0.0805755034,
-0.0480378866,
0.0109468987,
-0.1189180017,
-0.0160056464,
-0.0291929431,
0.029187711,
-0.0236029364,
-0.041574508,
0.0166004542,
0.0263419114,
-0.035157878,
0.0258800648,
-0.0104601542,
-0.0383272134,
-0.0241376981,
0.0214187391,
0.054102242,
-0.0392984562,
0.0022015758,
-0.0047367285,
0.0685759261,
0.0251342207,
-0.0139392167,
0.006642689,
-0.0044066045,
-0.0483347625,
-0.0103649022,
-0.0264983587,
-0.0121766906,
-0.0128510678,
0.0340351015,
0.0119662574,
0.0239979792,
-0.0127907703,
-0.0061726836,
0.0495353155,
0.0595732145,
-0.0271869004,
0.0139970249,
0.0180871543,
0.0289008357,
-0.0228708424,
0.0361487344,
-0.0121864509,
0.0059906417,
0.0417380854,
-0.0336518809,
-0.0017534447,
-0.0031030544,
2.414e-7,
-0.0159512348,
0.07371144,
0.0467976369,
0.0018666083,
-0.0082863541,
0.0282768868,
-0.0355126485,
0.046372883,
0.0553364567,
0.0694682002,
0.0089747254,
0.0031350621,
0.0305344202,
0.0284261219,
-0.0904729888,
-0.0110849328,
-0.079970181,
0.0460056439,
-0.0087291887,
0.0195376836,
-0.0228956323,
0.0365942009,
0.0272991564,
0.014559471,
-0.0423956439,
-0.0424919091,
0.0399749912,
0.0218069274,
0.0116877649,
0.0347625725,
0.0408470482,
0.0019846968,
-0.0015295319,
-0.002803379,
0.0050661829,
-0.0068366933,
0.0570047647,
0.0560884699,
-0.0359981097,
0.0315209664,
0.0014626597,
0.0188330878,
-0.0333930142,
-0.0472786874,
0.053908892,
0.0145408725,
-0.0449531078,
-0.0079466244,
0.0047850283,
0.0157621372,
0.0921078473,
-0.0160700846,
-0.0126880053,
-0.0086784782,
0.034427762,
-0.0374242067,
-0.0113208266,
-0.0326801725,
-0.0464894474,
-0.0108469119,
0.0053715236,
-0.0458199419,
-0.0029652575,
0.0453351252,
0.0173244942,
-0.0528776199,
0.0034853774,
1.421795889e-34,
0.0330010094,
0.0041585704,
0.0246632397,
-0.0342211202,
0.033730004,
0.0014442448,
-0.0179923028,
-0.0061896173,
0.0365374684,
-0.0237895288,
-0.0327361636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06518v1 | Minimum Description Length Hopfield Networks | 2023-11-11T09:23:54 | 2023-11-11T09:23:54 | Matan Abudy, Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Roni Katzir | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Associative memory architectures are designed for memorization but also
offer, through their retrieval method, a form of generalization to unseen
inputs: stored memories can be seen as prototypes from this point of view.
Focusing on Modern Hopfield Networks (MHN), we show that a large memorization
capacity undermines the generalization opportunity. We offer a solution to
better optimize this tradeoff. It relies on Minimum Description Length (MDL) to
determine during training which memories to store, as well as how many of them. | [
-0.0284188855,
0.0301375613,
-0.0086690066,
0.02501514,
-0.033428438,
-0.0033622966,
0.0227701813,
0.036290396,
0.0091891065,
0.0121745272,
0.0034309432,
-0.0769427717,
-0.0464669801,
0.012109248,
0.0271179937,
-0.0142459469,
0.0752691105,
0.0022861608,
-0.0795244128,
-0.0251322854,
-0.0221431218,
-0.0413340107,
-0.0233048964,
-0.00928545,
-0.0586459525,
0.0053721294,
-0.048304081,
-0.0500149243,
0.0357742384,
-0.0519394279,
-0.0245731343,
0.0146814873,
0.027592795,
-0.0659905151,
0.0000020557,
-0.0270150844,
0.01252943,
0.0021249726,
-0.0269150995,
-0.0362780169,
-0.0302843489,
0.0552226119,
-0.0067564677,
-0.0169439986,
-0.0047024786,
-0.0664102957,
0.0634154826,
0.096060127,
0.0536447689,
0.079984501,
0.0061663408,
-0.0766488463,
0.0553012602,
-0.0298480801,
0.0917517766,
-0.0030119538,
-0.0067635835,
0.0316529758,
0.0015708029,
-0.040407531,
-0.0321446955,
0.0247864835,
0.0184841007,
0.0594949611,
0.0610289946,
0.0361110903,
0.0220559724,
0.032114137,
0.0187119171,
0.0168163925,
-0.0076491786,
0.0031991438,
0.0086780898,
0.0052382238,
0.0189177599,
-0.0098743923,
-0.0294779129,
-0.001089849,
-0.0486135595,
-0.0174146146,
-0.0531505607,
0.0234001521,
0.0374377109,
-0.0097203748,
-0.0174969304,
0.0149281574,
0.0011945141,
-0.0030493173,
0.0087666148,
-0.0783943608,
0.0405491628,
0.014033393,
-0.0091315443,
0.0528438725,
0.0183111522,
0.0099360729,
0.0055951867,
0.0089121955,
0.0159566887,
-0.0317795016,
0.0337182991,
0.032425046,
0.0429092981,
0.0198169947,
-0.0769618303,
0.026372131,
-0.0379630774,
0.0083651096,
-0.0416535027,
0.0173495598,
-0.0800924301,
-0.0078628352,
-0.0529337265,
0.1118586063,
0.0352119096,
-0.0053084013,
-0.050214462,
0.0046529933,
-0.036238011,
0.0302433632,
-0.0495459661,
0.0399783105,
0.0083994977,
-0.0403419472,
-0.0418840609,
-0.0046840813,
-0.0390370227,
-0.0266891327,
0.0151275815,
0.0052697961,
-0.0249498934,
0.0024352842,
0.047429543,
-0.0280630272,
0.0312015489,
0.090257369,
0.0105702253,
-0.0421147272,
-0.0552047342,
0.0021830113,
0.022234058,
-0.059615586,
0.0410818756,
-0.0086604049,
0.0212114435,
-0.0106558241,
0.0344161838,
-0.0418774337,
0.0132867694,
0.0030069798,
-0.0330398493,
0.024221722,
0.0659234896,
-0.078824006,
0.0487274416,
-0.004734783,
-0.0203708522,
0.0225965101,
0.0150989778,
0.066648066,
-0.0132028749,
-0.0125897285,
0.016413033,
-0.0294227581,
0.0531375259,
-0.0214814022,
0.0073170424,
-0.0288696494,
0.0215974748,
0.0387529097,
-0.0166919623,
0.0308015868,
-0.0404418409,
-0.0259813722,
0.022192562,
0.0790752247,
0.0399640165,
0.0502217859,
0.0572924837,
-0.0796302482,
0.0025738154,
0.010174742,
-0.0211190917,
0.0748751462,
0.0196441934,
0.0030731803,
-0.0254062936,
0.0268193819,
-0.0487093329,
-0.0301686842,
-0.0125290519,
-0.0492651388,
0.0137027921,
-0.0347288921,
0.0149964616,
-0.0005341714,
-0.024332799,
0.0855566561,
-0.0082632164,
-0.0299200919,
0.0200253632,
-0.024856627,
-0.0522911064,
0.0426070467,
0.0041593099,
-0.0499632284,
-0.0218431465,
-0.0130291069,
-0.0360910632,
-0.0002181629,
0.0903966352,
0.0031740463,
0.0134710567,
-0.05460402,
-0.0024797893,
-0.0163387302,
0.0149110872,
0.0104743326,
0.0027543211,
-0.0084826471,
0.0550781228,
0.0103448732,
-0.0123603363,
-0.0031381103,
-0.006005195,
-0.0574517548,
0.0212684795,
0.0326402746,
0.0302276611,
-0.0022033013,
-0.0027573993,
0.0180977583,
0.0084971962,
-0.0429644734,
-0.0145164356,
-0.0071506747,
-0.0616533831,
0.0323986895,
0.0135598388,
-0.0105260015,
0.0765817687,
-0.0320501253,
-0.0267765801,
-0.0696456134,
0.0410041995,
-0.0441789255,
0.0895045549,
-0.0322040804,
-0.0139366193,
0.0232625231,
-0.0371998884,
-0.0196416099,
0.0539532229,
-0.0312011,
-0.002752736,
-0.0716697127,
0.0292161629,
0.0214540269,
-0.0136572039,
-0.0226950832,
0.0198165439,
-0.0152302301,
0.0382546224,
0.0201443713,
-0.0608366095,
-0.0316062197,
-0.0127760097,
-0.0325454623,
-0.0001460381,
0.0225376189,
-0.0016634305,
-0.0242309496,
0.0064431527,
0.0517942607,
0.0002743906,
-0.0700523406,
0.0591603629,
-0.0267930571,
-0.0071211229,
0.0306480881,
0.0239984933,
-0.0245039891,
0.0177047923,
-0.0475082658,
-0.00497641,
0.0601442941,
-0.0348504521,
-0.0539837368,
0.0089362198,
0.011110465,
-0.0401074886,
0.0240448453,
-0.0119539425,
-0.0017180681,
0.0102197956,
-0.0156716295,
0.0164066479,
0.0508599877,
0.0285553839,
0.0049548498,
0.010803042,
0.0253081974,
-0.0228328537,
0.0406516194,
-0.0652591288,
0.0155159757,
0.0076904059,
0.003463997,
0.0105177928,
0.0905688778,
-0.0043564499,
-0.0067932494,
-0.064107269,
-0.0265517514,
-0.0040522818,
-0.0002899149,
-0.0661200881,
0.0171976332,
-0.0241242647,
-0.0193202421,
-0.0036396903,
-0.0346023031,
0.0463355109,
0.0130428737,
0.0261416733,
-0.0022726592,
0.013034449,
-0.0108928494,
0.0566072948,
0.0577453561,
0.0734512433,
0.0164967012,
-0.0398237668,
-0.0115374578,
-0.0240656026,
-0.0243014917,
-0.0331412219,
0.0008273904,
0.0189890359,
0.0100497045,
0.0041485312,
-0.0066208444,
-0.0128477141,
0.0570306331,
0.0132239619,
0.0270263217,
-0.0232712552,
-0.0259336606,
0.0011998009,
-0.003628796,
0.0395624675,
0.0704539046,
-0.0323934183,
0.0091918772,
0.0047147083,
0.0211695638,
-0.0151458774,
-0.0020766612,
0.0131490631,
-0.0408249162,
-0.0112457732,
0.0075259623,
0.0398327596,
0.0135270711,
-0.0050495723,
-0.0022453947,
-0.0548160374,
-0.0299471971,
-0.0291413236,
0.0245836973,
0.0007777393,
-0.0372385308,
-0.039011851,
0.0228128824,
0.015691597,
-0.0793620944,
-0.0065409234,
0.0252693836,
-0.0005241026,
0.0052850675,
0.0177416373,
-0.0560459159,
-0.0032416221,
-0.010901547,
-0.0115083819,
0.0031298616,
-0.0483438484,
0.0038996236,
-0.0495385677,
-0.053867165,
0.0535718426,
-0.0789528266,
-0.0502251759,
-0.0241098776,
-0.0873799846,
0.0247674063,
0.0034155855,
0.0086224414,
-0.0030963214,
-0.0359591618,
0.0220995583,
0.0062869121,
-0.0003973222,
0.0194031764,
0.0093327556,
0.0268314332,
0.0666468516,
-0.0288563166,
-0.0085071586,
-0.0521294922,
0.0709749684,
0.0035179257,
0.0533756316,
-0.0180563536,
0.0630505979,
0.006043463,
-0.0324908346,
0.0227768254,
0.0211723149,
0.0027322164,
-0.0228722207,
-0.0509040765,
0.0727367997,
-0.0239750966,
0.0174289234,
0.0163045339,
-0.0225380249,
-0.0170193557,
0.026989473,
0.0244570952,
-0.0075953924,
-0.0257869363,
0.0129431803,
0.0511150993,
-0.1095864847,
0.000309032,
0.0410842411,
0.0266588721,
-0.0133306747,
-0.0139936246,
0.000868629,
-0.0474035293,
0.0512271635,
0.0064184102,
-0.0272827577,
0.0470746644,
0.024312567,
-0.0878233984,
0.0324182324,
-0.0249140281,
-0.0374327339,
-0.0426151119,
-0.0347249918,
0.062428195,
-0.0070732073,
-0.0108099645,
-0.0440285578,
-0.0731083453,
-0.000315917,
0.0291331075,
0.0760952607,
0.0060414141,
0.0230801627,
0.0480557717,
-0.0049863765,
0.0242180694,
0.0004163256,
0.0238811504,
0.0300839562,
-0.001451214,
0.0276442841,
-0.0158021022,
0.0056588948,
-0.0116217583,
0.0441531874,
0.0515653305,
0.0047141723,
0.0092207072,
0.0714642778,
-0.0005578574,
0.0187973231,
-0.0223028753,
0.0422741137,
0.0302311964,
-0.0058127278,
0.0511433296,
0.0309312753,
0.0170972086,
-0.0023226808,
-0.0147834029,
-0.0069749211,
0.0128314337,
0.0061693382,
-0.0516343601,
0.0819311738,
0.0240683183,
0.0587190129,
-0.0045840656,
-0.0255894996,
-0.0401747748,
-0.0056618275,
0.0262572616,
-0.0819956064,
-0.0209998712,
-0.0181706604,
0.0377584994,
-0.0026800777,
0.0435904935,
-0.0089743109,
0.0024430987,
-0.1010445803,
0.000608078,
-0.0331800207,
-0.035615921,
-0.039397724,
0.0285731703,
0.0390784442,
-0.0102865053,
-0.0243992116,
-0.0523600467,
0.0151248612,
-0.0064129257,
-0.0404926725,
0.0061847772,
0.0274482369,
-0.002661569,
0.0438371636,
0.0069368673,
-0.0250647012,
0.0164471678,
-0.0549903177,
0.065326795,
-0.0315767638,
0.0115698325,
-0.0471774824,
0.0160271283,
-0.0132644093,
0.033764407,
0.0110954605,
-0.0213975143,
-0.0632780269,
-0.0066745374,
-0.0134589458,
0.0077247489,
0.0216900278,
0.0040921946,
0.0305974931,
0.0138359377,
0.0171422176,
-0.0196444709,
0.0189104881,
-0.0086165024,
0.0312509276,
0.0309994593,
-0.0237932187,
-6.15572192e-33,
-0.0162402298,
-0.0197957121,
0.0326919034,
-0.0644206181,
-0.0515611693,
0.0455337912,
-0.0205451939,
-0.0074346117,
-0.0536210313,
-0.0377533399,
-0.0099042412,
-0.0405508094,
-0.0004067456,
0.0355701856,
0.035973873,
-0.0009440542,
0.0243274197,
0.0125291664,
0.0107457628,
0.0709412321,
0.0956898034,
0.0396973938,
0.0313430838,
0.0052932561,
-0.028814882,
0.0173699055,
-0.0100829471,
0.0503457785,
-0.0479119904,
0.0014746051,
-0.0586325303,
-0.0202051792,
0.0201985426,
-0.0393346697,
-0.0123679144,
-0.0307949781,
-0.0745737553,
-0.0224995706,
-0.0337422416,
-0.0074444734,
0.039630577,
-0.0492434949,
0.0547735989,
-0.0284593329,
-0.0359914638,
-0.0025869689,
-0.0039979061,
-0.0068613542,
-0.0703211576,
-0.0198552348,
-0.0348399393,
0.0051012165,
0.0407978669,
0.0321609005,
0.0045449212,
0.0027530789,
-0.0426178426,
-0.0298380684,
-0.0426302776,
0.0215416886,
-0.0095579773,
0.0400506966,
-0.0120445155,
0.0490941145,
0.0582727753,
0.0656175613,
0.1265764832,
0.0178216621,
-0.0095938006,
0.0057315817,
-0.0083588585,
-0.0226145182,
-0.0023447438,
-0.0438417867,
0.1031556651,
-0.0565247685,
-0.0056878687,
-0.0525485538,
-0.000361731,
0.0655929372,
0.0328291617,
0.0152466288,
-0.0619495884,
-0.0127999205,
-0.0106044495,
0.0525677241,
-0.0135130221,
-0.0459735133,
-0.0236048121,
0.0003795526,
-0.0265784524,
0.040960107,
0.0209979303,
-0.019376209,
0.0420832112,
0.0176448151,
0.0518645458,
0.0366161726,
-0.0057616821,
0.0024636474,
-0.0424103849,
-0.0809904337,
-0.0669017211,
0.0094293421,
0.0202557687,
0.0067445324,
0.0182903353,
0.0365459993,
-0.0751142427,
-0.0110881794,
-0.0546992347,
-0.0422115587,
0.030269431,
-0.0064906836,
0.0280006621,
-0.015294265,
-0.0040087723,
0.0548810922,
-0.0082669621,
-0.0369276293,
0.0277240351,
0.0151754422,
-0.0220890511,
0.0542604998,
0.006796075,
0.0042222836,
-0.0317037404,
0.0385633931,
0.032111045,
-0.036703065,
0.015507984,
0.0266582388,
2.885e-7,
-0.0321257375,
-0.0092519224,
0.0266310107,
-0.0394046195,
0.003710947,
0.0082710749,
0.0131405722,
-0.000761692,
-0.0463383533,
0.0055901329,
0.0566150062,
0.0512979589,
-0.0172266755,
0.0137772765,
-0.0387951098,
-0.0137793925,
-0.0159631632,
-0.0031403075,
0.0024127441,
0.017220838,
0.0118193822,
0.0334925614,
0.0224302933,
0.0152128879,
0.0375729166,
-0.0350398012,
0.0403306261,
-0.0072538601,
0.0314576961,
0.0166346934,
0.0014852827,
-0.0093255155,
-0.0366057716,
-0.0170360897,
-0.0160627533,
0.0037657123,
-0.0627828017,
0.0083845174,
-0.024599703,
-0.0720639452,
0.0177584253,
0.011220539,
0.0084337592,
0.0225286819,
0.0531150103,
-0.0577323586,
-0.0212682746,
-0.0290701874,
0.0217749327,
0.0415250026,
0.005142964,
0.0271009281,
-0.0051450222,
-0.0047507631,
-0.0323570371,
-0.0031483851,
0.0448956303,
-0.0668234974,
0.0265082568,
0.1098996624,
-0.0245968662,
-0.0417561941,
-0.0277402438,
-0.0125839245,
0.0489795245,
-0.0342407264,
-0.041418463,
2.063116564e-34,
0.0377641283,
-0.0484722182,
0.0336334929,
0.0178476088,
-0.0070735672,
-0.0335876308,
0.0230701435,
-0.0021296195,
0.0297524631,
0.0140969697,
-0.0435655117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06513v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06513v2 | Step by Step to Fairness: Attributing Societal Bias in Task-oriented Dialogue Systems | 2023-11-11T09:06:15 | 2023-11-14T07:30:37 | Hsuan Su, Rebecca Qian, Chinnadhurai Sankar, Shahin Shayandeh, Shang-Tse Chen, Hung-yi Lee, Daniel M. Bikel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent works have shown considerable improvements in task-oriented dialogue
(TOD) systems by utilizing pretrained large language models (LLMs) in an
end-to-end manner. However, the biased behavior of each component in a TOD
system and the error propagation issue in the end-to-end framework can lead to
seriously biased TOD responses. Existing works of fairness only focus on the
total bias of a system. In this paper, we propose a diagnosis method to
attribute bias to each component of a TOD system. With the proposed attribution
method, we can gain a deeper understanding of the sources of bias.
Additionally, researchers can mitigate biased model behavior at a more granular
level. We conduct experiments to attribute the TOD system's bias toward three
demographic axes: gender, age, and race. Experimental results show that the
bias of a TOD system usually comes from the response generation model. | [
0.077172868,
0.0385412574,
-0.0263192728,
0.045071736,
0.0057157823,
0.0212029666,
0.0504171848,
-0.0229013264,
0.0201816838,
-0.0739075691,
-0.032436505,
-0.0153365973,
-0.0108952429,
0.000482329,
0.0169986077,
-0.065607138,
0.0224995837,
0.0089922464,
0.0359562933,
-0.0458430834,
0.0172146279,
0.0081526013,
0.0057996763,
0.065517053,
-0.0088608479,
-0.0057942267,
0.0209553745,
0.0053852224,
-0.0009550438,
-0.0098085739,
0.0514694005,
0.0729676262,
-0.009095056,
0.0426058508,
0.0000018277,
-0.0766930804,
0.0543136038,
-0.0040234984,
-0.0391562879,
0.0118951397,
0.0293853432,
0.0468615219,
-0.00093367,
0.0562024824,
-0.0393996015,
-0.0067872847,
0.0407039374,
0.0433983691,
0.048146382,
0.0192808919,
0.0095871147,
-0.0063099554,
-0.053070046,
-0.0020306744,
0.0127232345,
-0.031416174,
0.0180152096,
0.0141903171,
-0.0215232186,
-0.0227490962,
-0.0066579464,
-0.0167058222,
0.0189827252,
-0.0297937468,
0.0392513201,
-0.0273122881,
-0.0056164442,
-0.0408336036,
-0.0445911773,
0.1209138855,
0.0393702723,
-0.00035514,
-0.0113755669,
-0.0145201962,
0.0291905217,
-0.0166441351,
-0.0493168384,
0.0268973839,
-0.0083051333,
-0.0141655821,
-0.0225481205,
0.020139832,
-0.0044428254,
0.0383831859,
-0.0279810727,
0.0667690039,
-0.0096596545,
-0.0309822429,
-0.0243075117,
0.0496090949,
0.0410615243,
-0.066751875,
0.0099022947,
0.0185191724,
-0.079837054,
-0.0008343951,
0.0020626348,
-0.0101701608,
0.0326331109,
-0.0301447734,
0.0324513428,
0.0259917974,
-0.0078910487,
0.0042547537,
0.0263743307,
0.0246269368,
-0.0219883155,
-0.0154040381,
-0.0426906012,
-0.0208101459,
-0.0213279556,
-0.0053072916,
-0.0121815661,
0.0068985955,
-0.0363654159,
0.0315364338,
-0.0426377505,
0.0342592075,
-0.0588031188,
-0.0528043061,
0.0163868237,
0.0407306887,
-0.0245000869,
0.0179329626,
-0.0618430525,
0.0360709094,
-0.0431955978,
0.0433915295,
0.0042604869,
-0.0858701542,
-0.0040832777,
0.0247122589,
-0.0052996413,
-0.0287243277,
-0.0045869779,
0.0477127619,
0.0017335338,
-0.0056159715,
-0.0191572774,
-0.0593526214,
-0.0166204199,
-0.0630985722,
-0.0214297138,
-0.0166582931,
0.0127113331,
0.036191538,
-0.018536387,
0.0297772139,
-0.0064666788,
0.0208779182,
-0.0792398974,
0.0446718372,
0.0285096727,
0.0320648327,
0.0502047203,
0.0217387639,
-0.0325516351,
0.0669268742,
0.0439186171,
-0.0024596672,
0.0350461565,
-0.0131595582,
0.0091708293,
0.0264993086,
0.0074043442,
0.0118046617,
0.0314744487,
0.0509828664,
-0.0295341108,
0.0039975559,
0.063965328,
0.0439223051,
-0.0121116079,
0.0184617732,
0.0595208965,
0.0412492976,
-0.0249243956,
0.0114020333,
0.0140663479,
0.0075673065,
-0.0264579821,
0.0077471272,
-0.0759320185,
0.0062662321,
-0.0145040601,
-0.0330269523,
0.0532061122,
0.0389855951,
-0.0482037999,
-0.0265062004,
-0.0044137551,
0.0241043754,
0.0139438631,
0.0566015691,
0.0254641119,
0.0096983174,
-0.023215821,
0.043136429,
0.0178484004,
-0.0441471897,
0.0190526433,
-0.0945671201,
0.0191046316,
0.0411594063,
0.0085982904,
-0.0149805918,
-0.0150594143,
-0.0410673097,
0.015771376,
0.0526566133,
0.0814890116,
-0.0174269471,
-0.0026633621,
-0.0415030755,
-0.0660650134,
0.0342966504,
0.0002127379,
0.036941357,
0.0097294152,
0.0200157072,
0.0256562941,
-0.022554921,
-0.0299293473,
0.0181385502,
0.0335208103,
-0.0226526316,
0.0205260161,
0.00203884,
0.0576883629,
0.0442705676,
-0.0223669149,
-0.0028656204,
-0.0200556461,
0.0120643135,
0.00300235,
0.0207268875,
-0.0833286569,
-0.0156974401,
-0.0006394673,
-0.0308268238,
-0.0338324048,
0.0555362403,
-0.0168353543,
-0.0154212611,
0.0514909476,
0.0012972123,
-0.0266068764,
-0.024118498,
0.0064263474,
-0.0087113194,
0.0004912219,
-0.0535099171,
0.0142586343,
0.0057985247,
-0.0153374625,
0.0453612953,
-0.0313513875,
0.0108063472,
-0.0674495101,
-0.0077080172,
0.0193098858,
-0.0145830382,
0.0012525038,
0.0363388658,
-0.0061562839,
-0.0226219464,
-0.0003851005,
-0.1119414568,
-0.0126744257,
-0.0347416326,
-0.0003352519,
0.0056516314,
0.028340552,
-0.0168671776,
-0.0400036499,
-0.0497748554,
-0.0092736278,
0.072649695,
0.0467695631,
0.0193115845,
-0.0145606212,
-0.0084044626,
-0.0295283441,
-0.0156495981,
-0.0189692453,
0.0405822843,
0.0423473977,
0.0019785124,
-0.0843682438,
0.0038537527,
-0.0317372903,
0.0321527086,
0.0056878133,
-0.020735031,
0.0328636803,
0.0654766858,
0.057220351,
0.0958144367,
0.0569104478,
0.0198742319,
0.020897042,
-0.0145835029,
-0.0766049325,
-0.001634213,
-0.0216727238,
-0.0135489823,
-0.0109540084,
-0.0870091319,
0.0122522488,
0.0588470399,
0.0296610612,
-0.0293164402,
-0.0611813925,
0.0517057851,
-0.0455115624,
-0.0681688413,
-0.0236675907,
-0.0507180914,
-0.0126810903,
0.0190880653,
-0.0277192481,
-0.0646253824,
0.04548591,
0.0140647329,
0.0090777939,
-0.0323284008,
0.0141530717,
-0.0433306843,
0.0335940644,
-0.0328202285,
0.0251964964,
0.0338836499,
-0.0466663577,
-0.0646571591,
-0.0231574345,
0.0443447307,
-0.0297019333,
0.0339691862,
-0.0319964662,
-0.0122843636,
-0.01741229,
-0.068092078,
-0.056133531,
-0.0627803132,
-0.0054167486,
0.0081839943,
0.0147696445,
-0.0130800698,
0.0004993966,
0.0150471684,
0.0195958354,
0.0107185356,
-0.0280280896,
-0.0027726588,
-0.0081288209,
-0.0036637648,
0.0382554866,
0.0244945977,
0.0795196816,
-0.0320102349,
0.0236596409,
0.0131804077,
0.0780899376,
-0.0053708036,
0.0157178137,
-0.0111342203,
0.0529668517,
-0.0061436398,
0.0001784177,
0.0210110731,
0.0810441822,
-0.0172215067,
0.0443474166,
0.1036897004,
0.0114641897,
-0.0694615766,
-0.0079646772,
-0.0256472826,
0.0022310263,
0.0274159834,
-0.008407874,
-0.0971769616,
-0.0125945704,
0.0219139457,
0.0395253897,
-0.0401274078,
-0.0472937822,
0.012205475,
-0.1236113906,
0.0365507416,
-0.011051083,
-0.0007146529,
-0.0180960223,
0.0111912042,
-0.00605021,
0.0071821744,
0.0645123124,
0.005426988,
0.0239413306,
-0.0045283926,
0.031812001,
-0.0247537661,
-0.0148210432,
0.0389960594,
-0.0712297782,
0.0778563917,
0.0733142272,
0.0423165485,
0.0157974921,
0.0283148251,
0.0480637066,
-0.0107123172,
0.0014567537,
-0.0197632182,
0.0072980747,
-0.0158366542,
0.0056305858,
-0.0746556967,
0.0315234475,
-0.004787406,
0.0200237166,
0.0226361174,
0.0378690101,
-0.0026003113,
-0.0224801917,
-0.0401608907,
-0.0003747717,
0.0492120646,
0.087776117,
0.0086607579,
-0.0414042808,
-0.0526302457,
-0.0268190932,
-0.0305286609,
-0.0117559899,
-0.0251097716,
0.0075014699,
-0.0154990554,
-0.0132687371,
-0.0370994769,
-0.0562356859,
-0.0041616918,
0.0022333169,
0.005209364,
-0.0469858274,
-0.0061146501,
-0.0091674933,
-0.0094356984,
0.0377676897,
-0.0444009863,
0.0445911475,
-0.0341534987,
-0.0157630835,
-0.0245115925,
-0.0396008715,
-0.0009794952,
0.0179625843,
-0.0387405194,
-0.0490083098,
0.0072642798,
0.0604852177,
0.028570313,
0.0287661441,
0.0235304497,
-0.0533720404,
0.0212767962,
0.0033641129,
-0.0325178429,
0.0245542638,
0.0241139065,
0.0216382965,
0.0025286276,
0.0146798771,
-0.0466198288,
0.0297911745,
0.0277668498,
0.0226808134,
-0.0139111923,
-0.0692630783,
-0.0183768589,
-0.0088368356,
0.0470052995,
-0.0019442836,
-0.0270966012,
-0.034296114,
0.0194285829,
-0.0085632177,
-0.027143307,
-0.0442698859,
-0.0089644976,
-0.0100200959,
0.0081619406,
-0.0007324428,
-0.0134599833,
-0.0519394428,
0.0185369141,
-0.0364407934,
0.0472878367,
-0.0262224767,
0.0213921443,
0.0273684803,
-0.0063186358,
-0.0163539182,
0.0100426376,
0.0258828495,
0.0288387798,
0.0487862825,
0.1044799462,
0.0292237271,
-0.009623819,
0.005275683,
0.0050789514,
-0.0515595116,
-0.0227662791,
-0.0028081883,
-0.0121405227,
0.0246907901,
0.0191779975,
0.0446069352,
0.0149765518,
0.028731782,
-0.005688637,
0.0241798088,
0.0137224998,
0.0170858875,
0.0235166159,
-0.0050804624,
-0.0182428639,
0.0153989969,
0.0591123253,
0.0262122322,
0.019854093,
-0.0304510389,
-0.0443138406,
-0.0131358309,
-0.040371757,
0.0295207854,
-0.0234490428,
-0.027161004,
-0.0297520179,
-0.0671442673,
-0.0539690703,
-0.037523374,
0.0083018206,
0.034535829,
-0.0259839967,
0.0078446697,
0.0516086482,
-0.036762692,
-0.0700625703,
-0.0178048108,
-0.0061278441,
-0.0673154965,
0.001102592,
-0.0211523753,
-6.110827587e-33,
-0.0131255854,
-0.033005707,
-0.0007307598,
-0.0308450945,
-0.02775787,
-0.0360109247,
-0.0102975015,
0.0127997203,
-0.0198316835,
0.002139607,
0.0014203733,
0.0161464252,
0.0214003623,
-0.0071520712,
0.0058629932,
-0.0389534049,
0.0537227467,
-0.0139988456,
-0.0172894076,
0.0273968615,
-0.0171139427,
-0.0017715205,
0.0282319989,
-0.0453577116,
0.0922762156,
-0.0127856871,
0.0116469739,
0.0483090542,
-0.0043897778,
0.0354372934,
-0.0070446441,
0.0794946104,
0.0403548405,
-0.0253532305,
-0.0095392428,
0.0783575103,
-0.0361134037,
-0.0088390503,
0.0290066898,
0.0256426539,
0.0123225786,
-0.0108241038,
0.0058264853,
0.0274816845,
-0.0688184872,
-0.0058434289,
0.0342682488,
0.0126617616,
0.0618910082,
0.0123870326,
-0.0500688553,
-0.0040395497,
-0.0242483448,
-0.0310939848,
-0.0454009548,
0.0569433048,
-0.0025855568,
-0.023422027,
-0.011444849,
0.0136662619,
0.0141376108,
-0.0497381575,
0.0498807728,
0.0528202839,
0.0258061439,
0.027085226,
0.0621084757,
0.0705858842,
-0.0627250969,
-0.1032128334,
-0.0004190412,
-0.0258900356,
0.0291962735,
0.0435175598,
-0.0056091561,
0.0221939161,
-0.0776029602,
-0.0065480694,
0.052757673,
0.0284555629,
0.0463261753,
-0.0137794223,
-0.0665558651,
-0.0440301783,
-0.0407863371,
-0.0149680609,
-0.0364278406,
-0.023973342,
0.0610691383,
0.025956789,
-0.0047900504,
-0.0200415291,
0.0637656003,
-0.0466298983,
-0.0204027519,
0.0306535885,
-0.0012019533,
-0.0278564561,
-0.0032870844,
-0.0100120958,
-0.077733621,
0.0019320688,
0.0145086497,
0.0219053626,
-0.0076308763,
0.0250853393,
-0.0399932638,
-0.014164689,
-0.0568170063,
0.010367888,
-0.0203118064,
0.0423013419,
-0.0201695021,
0.0197122246,
0.0372919627,
0.0170111768,
-0.0006642889,
0.0442549735,
0.0216777064,
-0.0323153734,
-0.0615557767,
0.0004037069,
0.0016248717,
0.0132100321,
-0.0460666008,
-0.0003769539,
0.0050517544,
0.0099743661,
0.0022923399,
-0.00753493,
-0.0383739993,
-0.0542806871,
2.367e-7,
-0.0166773777,
0.0489021167,
-0.0005454142,
0.0562940761,
-0.0020675433,
0.0517056584,
0.0510817878,
0.0536780357,
0.0651301891,
0.0204289537,
-0.0085046999,
0.0114509687,
0.018994689,
0.0056704842,
-0.0872647092,
-0.0389597565,
-0.054379072,
0.0082663568,
-0.0056443568,
0.0191224795,
0.0262508709,
0.0130253546,
0.0037116625,
0.0091428077,
-0.0218864959,
-0.0091115544,
0.0268223248,
-0.04718538,
0.007926099,
0.0182947125,
0.0396679528,
-0.0470459461,
0.0185065921,
0.069948554,
0.0205878504,
0.0247993302,
-0.025639914,
0.0237003397,
-0.0256255474,
-0.0260501932,
-0.0314351693,
-0.0146687888,
0.0104443766,
-0.0782790929,
0.0358962156,
-0.0165756661,
-0.0405006967,
-0.0474361703,
0.0097022504,
-0.0470567495,
0.0135675678,
-0.0195004195,
-0.0007051022,
0.0050291456,
0.0244507734,
0.019452408,
0.0199277848,
-0.0834969506,
-0.0136776529,
-0.0259172674,
-0.0372922309,
-0.1121724397,
-0.0092884703,
0.0230816733,
0.0084881792,
-0.0021511351,
0.0204482693,
1.879766651e-34,
0.0026376755,
0.0162145905,
0.0488138348,
-0.0089993337,
0.0388834849,
0.0379047766,
0.0009225903,
-0.0133477701,
0.0926131606,
-0.0449199118,
-0.028592553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06503v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06503v3 | Knowledgeable Preference Alignment for LLMs in Domain-specific Question Answering | 2023-11-11T07:56:40 | 2024-06-10T09:06:10 | Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Yin Fang, Yanxi Lu, Fangming Li, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deploying large language models (LLMs) to real scenarios for domain-specific
question answering (QA) is a key thrust for LLM applications, which poses
numerous challenges, especially in ensuring that responses are both
accommodating to user requirements and appropriately leveraging domain-specific
knowledge bases. They are the two major difficulties for LLM application as
vanilla fine-tuning falls short of addressing. Combining these requirements, we
conceive of them as the requirement for the model's preference to be
harmoniously aligned with humans'. Thus, we introduce Knowledgeable Preference
AlignmenT (KnowPAT), which constructs two kinds of preference sets to tackle
the two issues. Besides, we design a new alignment objective to align the LLM
preference with different human preferences uniformly, aiming to optimize LLM
performance in real-world, domain-specific QA settings. Adequate experiments
and comprehensive comparisons with 15 baseline methods illustrate that our
KnowPAT is a superior pipeline for real-scenario domain-specific QA with LLMs. | [
0.038757313,
0.0302210711,
0.0045290166,
0.063866131,
-0.0385473892,
0.0017984852,
-0.0235781353,
-0.0294291675,
0.0002187827,
-0.0257088542,
-0.0360110588,
-0.0281460993,
-0.046147991,
0.0050452119,
0.0074446062,
-0.0247773658,
0.0387727842,
-0.0193112679,
-0.0161561407,
-0.0208165068,
0.0266938023,
0.0376432426,
-0.0233305544,
0.0087202834,
0.0505007058,
-0.0732077882,
-0.0035798003,
0.0019582724,
0.0265039206,
0.0047222497,
0.0635069013,
0.039167773,
0.0364160873,
-0.0042715552,
0.0000020133,
-0.0572791621,
-0.0071406546,
-0.0015007466,
-0.0533637032,
-0.0033062662,
-0.0215803813,
0.0351475328,
0.0219484512,
0.0167294443,
-0.0580248609,
0.0342428423,
0.0279025547,
0.0042679221,
0.0433202982,
0.0582224727,
0.0164080113,
-0.0116671873,
-0.0193577874,
-0.0270912685,
-0.0119289439,
-0.0628010854,
0.0270569623,
-0.009523809,
0.0209308621,
0.013359271,
0.0110104559,
-0.0010511325,
-0.0118506784,
0.0214852225,
0.0142932646,
-0.0120781632,
-0.0077120848,
0.0109763434,
-0.0005021917,
0.0991086587,
0.0232138485,
-0.0032804236,
-0.008294479,
-0.0068267332,
0.0086631626,
0.0137127182,
-0.0359230079,
-0.0305600837,
-0.0088426936,
-0.0024169101,
-0.0225821529,
0.0153730456,
0.0054004882,
0.0318500921,
-0.0039113909,
0.1077952459,
0.015453998,
-0.0326866843,
0.0131168868,
0.0259489659,
-0.04077328,
-0.0602939241,
0.0047957394,
0.0479697138,
-0.0507317111,
0.0323032364,
-0.0236089751,
0.0258768182,
0.0433519036,
-0.0250685196,
0.0335141756,
0.0435553491,
0.0219638776,
0.0512130633,
-0.0006608722,
0.0655684918,
-0.0479712039,
-0.0266396441,
-0.0574349873,
-0.0251393039,
-0.0151901823,
-0.0317039564,
0.0114682559,
0.0485488698,
-0.0279978737,
0.017553106,
-0.0315213948,
0.0634598359,
-0.0191105809,
0.0179496855,
0.0175899193,
0.0522572622,
-0.0157522894,
-0.0265211351,
-0.0948864967,
0.0491631962,
-0.0807816684,
0.0365710557,
0.0024125886,
-0.021804776,
-0.0067946012,
0.0372992121,
-0.0247015432,
-0.0541902483,
-0.0053620744,
0.0868289992,
0.0038327728,
0.026177628,
0.0057413038,
-0.0160823092,
0.0048378864,
-0.0499354713,
-0.015054767,
-0.0721110627,
0.0404377282,
0.0208014455,
-0.0228134487,
-0.0708278045,
-0.0211580545,
0.0390605889,
-0.0096565373,
0.0645243153,
-0.0005551263,
0.0230173413,
0.0213589855,
0.001606283,
-0.0215944201,
0.0774381682,
-0.004926418,
0.0160009544,
0.0489692166,
0.0037012263,
-0.0124605773,
0.0230659042,
0.0069128866,
0.0129989376,
-0.0150958952,
0.0893627256,
-0.0153910024,
0.0364477448,
0.076317437,
-0.0069287256,
-0.0072413078,
-0.0508725867,
0.0334530622,
0.0425945111,
0.0275876708,
-0.0079041701,
0.0220449436,
0.0148793738,
-0.0018490513,
0.028986197,
-0.0237467084,
0.0545411743,
-0.0375929102,
0.0337988697,
0.0075379969,
0.0541419499,
-0.0424746685,
-0.0267586969,
-0.0077717933,
-0.005283779,
-0.0611025728,
0.0420892797,
-0.013371991,
-0.0207944456,
-0.0032803593,
0.0637960657,
0.0075597102,
0.0030077139,
-0.0022869851,
-0.0147044463,
0.0478245765,
0.0777188689,
0.0310856514,
-0.0617472045,
-0.0698733926,
0.0135121206,
-0.0040028854,
0.0576553009,
0.0336077251,
-0.0357583016,
-0.0103113996,
-0.0371784903,
-0.050345201,
-0.0093756793,
-0.019098198,
0.0103806332,
0.0707152039,
0.0256958287,
0.0079514682,
-0.0783491209,
0.0233151056,
0.0146525148,
-0.032914944,
-0.016408924,
0.0022559781,
0.0088535761,
0.0369775183,
0.012779654,
0.0185577311,
0.0042264145,
0.0111351097,
-0.0143325981,
-0.0218775235,
-0.024664348,
-0.042961102,
-0.0196183994,
0.0629650429,
-0.0213971697,
-0.0464398302,
0.0619120598,
-0.0478507243,
-0.0149914753,
-0.0503080525,
0.0059814453,
0.0099112168,
-0.0379463732,
-0.013531236,
0.0209454205,
-0.0170087889,
-0.0702643171,
0.065911904,
0.0024514943,
2.756e-7,
0.010443381,
-0.0215141159,
-0.0011322516,
-0.0267243199,
-0.0012944131,
0.0076402519,
0.0115653258,
0.0309082083,
0.0345222019,
0.0040843966,
-0.0714608654,
-0.012313026,
-0.055888135,
0.0296145156,
-0.0042302017,
0.0508854836,
0.0265376121,
0.0204842389,
-0.0051376857,
-0.0152513869,
-0.0984825119,
-0.0068480936,
-0.0088546388,
0.0308003388,
0.066762723,
-0.0010712532,
0.0138699198,
-0.0630352795,
0.0275059845,
0.0023762421,
0.0155795543,
-0.0421337709,
0.0242821034,
-0.0721540824,
0.0369606428,
-0.0568039678,
0.0302112997,
0.0109326709,
-0.0363126919,
-0.0130581278,
0.0226351563,
0.0232873969,
0.0416516513,
0.0246754605,
-0.0403216071,
0.0562700778,
0.0465376601,
-0.0836273506,
0.0183431972,
-0.0369161181,
-0.0254692808,
-0.0541784205,
0.0132356631,
0.0325234495,
0.050308872,
-0.0181346275,
-0.0135253388,
-0.034991432,
0.0456726812,
0.0137752835,
-0.0056123785,
-0.0200333372,
-0.0092970766,
-0.0227869768,
0.0391640328,
-0.0114157703,
-0.0092620496,
0.0977991596,
-0.0026520225,
0.0156680048,
-0.066642873,
0.0008111614,
-0.0741783381,
-0.0157501604,
-0.0244781375,
0.023340039,
-0.0093981465,
0.0004621936,
-0.0767463446,
-0.0216812715,
0.0096641053,
-0.0317814909,
0.0664606467,
-0.0449980609,
0.0332554206,
-0.0299419798,
-0.0641649663,
-0.0691588968,
-0.0554320365,
-0.0345381498,
0.0078158025,
-0.0192397889,
-0.0324741527,
-0.008269893,
-0.0084268572,
0.0331365764,
-0.0047960593,
-0.0032040779,
-0.0109281931,
-0.0139851356,
0.046863772,
0.105269514,
0.0811849684,
-0.0054711574,
0.0383497663,
0.0177488197,
0.0786999241,
0.0238265842,
-0.0025660126,
-0.0227246732,
-0.0151911639,
0.0711592287,
-0.0720471889,
0.0113339219,
-0.0014232857,
0.0378291272,
-0.0024861414,
0.0246003103,
0.1208150759,
0.0209192373,
-0.0661758855,
-0.0139326015,
-0.0366583951,
0.0639936328,
0.0347406678,
0.0501615815,
-0.0683091953,
-0.049510885,
-0.033350572,
0.0438115112,
0.0137814889,
-0.0122956131,
0.0042438093,
-0.1187943369,
-0.0254201982,
-0.0224545375,
-0.0217141919,
-0.0173255634,
-0.0122977858,
0.0439688601,
-0.0259004906,
0.0478486679,
-0.0153954588,
-0.0116726561,
0.0051609557,
0.0360626765,
-0.012422964,
-0.0415035598,
0.0614061132,
-0.0362845361,
0.0257051792,
0.094960995,
0.0171268955,
0.0173744522,
-0.0189998876,
-0.0228435677,
-0.0266296975,
0.016926812,
0.0007177681,
-0.0061126272,
-0.0306484699,
0.0006006616,
-0.019605495,
0.036383599,
-0.0749305561,
-0.0029315192,
0.04953501,
0.0861731544,
-0.0095003545,
0.0280212257,
-0.0385740027,
0.0016904209,
-0.0040469808,
0.0797306895,
0.0137870917,
-0.0684526265,
-0.0089236377,
-0.0044152532,
-0.0352466889,
-0.0433177017,
-0.06328547,
-0.0100249881,
0.0218603685,
0.0416717194,
-0.075145267,
-0.020064773,
0.0240779612,
0.0344045423,
-0.0144758765,
0.0186433531,
-0.0034452269,
-0.0036164452,
-0.0317600779,
0.0383271463,
-0.0596027076,
0.0096057197,
-0.0657168105,
-0.0041839615,
0.0519239567,
-0.0328885354,
-0.0378889441,
-0.0161533449,
-0.0329554677,
-0.0641037077,
-0.026536582,
0.0434977151,
0.0233890992,
0.0480690897,
-0.0263550337,
-0.0409069844,
0.0304569826,
0.0228208601,
-0.0198046863,
-0.0011556154,
0.0058043841,
0.0052692653,
-0.0313383751,
0.0433579646,
-0.0587581024,
-0.0213530511,
-0.0001165692,
0.0311972331,
-0.0332788378,
-0.098952353,
0.0278167557,
0.0013695696,
-0.0118574928,
0.0202766545,
-0.0085854838,
0.0036306188,
0.0343472809,
0.0035112423,
-0.0422187634,
0.0020614886,
-0.0451513045,
0.0087685734,
-0.0462096445,
0.0116012041,
-0.0020917573,
-0.0225631613,
0.0035980258,
-0.0200980715,
0.0032551449,
0.046543166,
0.0222681444,
0.0172197018,
0.0140198153,
-0.0429665223,
-0.0179527905,
0.0005320567,
0.0820655674,
0.0037088641,
0.0467300788,
0.0194290131,
0.0126667498,
-0.0113697834,
0.0375854969,
-0.0306576937,
-0.079033941,
-0.0229740329,
-0.0167961083,
0.0443916805,
-0.0341756083,
0.0249960255,
0.000237604,
-0.0299591329,
-0.0084321611,
-0.014218213,
-0.0142087527,
0.0292074103,
0.0591946989,
0.0478068478,
-0.0272063166,
0.0187565144,
0.0731067359,
-0.0062737381,
0.0304674469,
-0.0367860384,
-0.018051805,
-0.0146974418,
-0.0474853665,
-0.0130543718,
0.0143694244,
-0.0198190995,
-0.0171116535,
-0.0665576309,
-0.0592706129,
0.0067629647,
-0.0016626808,
-0.0472217426,
-0.0119766425,
0.041979745,
0.0455923676,
0.0104273986,
-0.019697357,
-0.0178936254,
0.0065764771,
-0.0688248873,
-0.0206472334,
-0.0370268747,
-6.316781911e-33,
-0.027908111,
-0.0293383189,
0.0298240036,
-0.0525719561,
-0.0296816025,
-0.0211363789,
0.0149202114,
0.0016120882,
-0.0687090978,
-0.0242470913,
-0.0152827948,
-0.0097843986,
0.0032972875,
0.0172342751,
0.0056220707,
-0.0442603119,
-0.0026628894,
-0.0010760977,
-0.0341400579,
-0.0133687239,
0.021756025,
-0.0024644283,
0.0330179483,
-0.028526051,
0.0241330732,
-0.003825095,
0.0122920936,
0.0506650098,
-0.0314798653,
0.0912714973,
-0.0272739287,
0.0418077074,
0.0303354673,
-0.0274072774,
0.0069145584,
0.0129642757,
-0.0325458944,
-0.0344593041,
0.0569020249,
0.0015851458,
-0.0136678703,
-0.0529796965,
0.0093300343,
0.0059528891,
0.0154793197,
-0.0155301653,
0.035976816,
-0.040574275,
-0.0142949792,
0.014326727,
-0.0426902361,
0.0051557226,
-0.0014272463,
-0.01038469,
-0.0100388117,
0.050626304,
0.0230092965,
0.0567317903,
-0.0417773351,
-0.0095300395,
-0.0016135342,
0.0487172008,
0.0870945752,
-0.0029761908,
-0.0280371495,
0.0532478355,
-0.0234920941,
-0.0242889337,
0.0136032309,
-0.0092989374,
-0.0737487599,
0.0326117203,
0.0246621892,
0.094000943,
-0.0106073497,
0.0315061435,
-0.0376368836,
0.063456133,
-0.0206654631,
0.0188991688,
0.0262597557,
0.0157916769,
-0.0419853181,
0.0055445693,
-0.0312831923,
0.0709921867,
-0.0483104289,
-0.0299222041,
0.0260692313,
-0.0176755786,
-0.0318786241,
-0.0120785087,
-0.0025957876,
-0.0434537828,
-0.0052873618,
0.0362358987,
-0.0199162122,
0.0172607582,
0.0195816122,
0.0319936648,
-0.0274856668,
0.0104053598,
-0.0229874663,
-0.0211618021,
-0.0067134695,
0.0356377326,
-0.0145286191,
-0.0243849605,
-0.0423987024,
0.0064132051,
-0.0445334464,
-0.0000330129,
-0.0415323786,
0.0243792273,
0.0013189974,
0.0164337922,
-0.0141996518,
0.0576682687,
-0.0028788277,
-0.0550211146,
-0.0136318551,
-0.0153135117,
0.0078297965,
0.0169066489,
-0.0175775811,
0.0211575069,
0.0002597936,
0.0293907393,
-0.0367144123,
-0.0014577607,
0.0006041027,
0.0104856901,
2.588e-7,
0.0519137084,
-0.0085996538,
0.0360546038,
0.0373628065,
0.0011485859,
0.0565931723,
0.0023493848,
0.0311697144,
0.0183824338,
-0.0270794034,
0.0226208661,
0.0277236607,
0.0458626673,
0.0236816835,
-0.0911206976,
-0.0075849644,
0.0095762964,
0.0011314047,
-0.0412914567,
-0.0360265896,
0.0379995443,
0.061876256,
0.0078696031,
0.0059855324,
-0.0197084602,
0.0063753864,
0.0453276299,
-0.0400886573,
-0.0018860367,
0.0342668779,
0.0308937076,
-0.0060322657,
0.0104068313,
0.0179847945,
-0.0026084213,
0.007523369,
0.0163791161,
0.0978385881,
0.0099633215,
-0.079754062,
-0.0474155657,
-0.035657838,
0.0469300486,
-0.0546604507,
0.0725785121,
-0.0292380564,
-0.0032268947,
-0.0209553204,
-0.0206342731,
-0.0142630301,
-0.0195184611,
-0.0172446668,
0.0037663779,
0.0008290736,
0.0117546534,
-0.0039042681,
-0.0263859592,
-0.0644457489,
-0.003741642,
0.0259923507,
-0.0458287932,
-0.0304594971,
-0.0176220145,
0.0169987977,
0.0328874998,
-0.0588657893,
0.012140844,
1.966416541e-34,
-0.0095267668,
0.0286013503,
0.0195277687,
0.0549331456,
0.0134650441,
0.0144122997,
-0.0111573655,
-0.0091856774,
0.0481473468,
-0.0633450001,
0.0082740821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06493v1 | L3 Ensembles: Lifelong Learning Approach for Ensemble of Foundational Language Models | 2023-11-11T06:59:50 | 2023-11-11T06:59:50 | Aidin Shiri, Kaushik Roy, Amit Sheth, Manas Gaur | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning pre-trained foundational language models (FLM) for specific tasks
is often impractical, especially for resource-constrained devices. This
necessitates the development of a Lifelong Learning (L3) framework that
continuously adapts to a stream of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks
efficiently. We propose an approach that focuses on extracting meaningful
representations from unseen data, constructing a structured knowledge base, and
improving task performance incrementally. We conducted experiments on various
NLP tasks to validate its effectiveness, including benchmarks like GLUE and
SuperGLUE. We measured good performance across the accuracy, training
efficiency, and knowledge transfer metrics. Initial experimental results show
that the proposed L3 ensemble method increases the model accuracy by 4% ~ 36%
compared to the fine-tuned FLM. Furthermore, L3 model outperforms naive
fine-tuning approaches while maintaining competitive or superior performance
(up to 15.4% increase in accuracy) compared to the state-of-the-art language
model (T5) for the given task, STS benchmark. | [
0.0445602015,
0.0547270626,
-0.0102363098,
0.0319898613,
-0.0320001468,
0.0121768955,
0.0263052322,
-0.0361060128,
0.0027667992,
-0.0774401203,
-0.0068216901,
-0.0549643002,
0.0038958348,
0.0371223353,
-0.0126685966,
-0.0415892527,
0.0415701307,
-0.0146461595,
-0.0313712806,
0.0190891419,
0.0037006815,
0.0159995072,
-0.0160749853,
0.0429076403,
-0.0085839666,
-0.0102414871,
-0.005729218,
-0.028441621,
-0.0123057989,
-0.0254117791,
0.0162081737,
0.0654601157,
0.0608259365,
0.0220088474,
0.0000021043,
-0.0494073033,
-0.0374311507,
-0.0002087592,
-0.053251002,
-0.0328457691,
0.0626484752,
0.0185393747,
-0.0260733366,
0.0247570556,
-0.0694493055,
-0.0055962307,
0.0426728576,
0.0275498256,
0.0369319394,
0.0495900884,
-0.0043145744,
-0.0353543423,
0.0370100662,
-0.0025930684,
-0.0066730399,
-0.010375239,
0.0112693058,
-0.0041592447,
0.0006354605,
-0.0302629136,
0.0044637774,
0.0456618927,
0.0014037855,
0.0162368324,
0.0599549562,
0.0246622134,
-0.0536913686,
-0.0023875642,
-0.0312901288,
0.100012593,
-0.0519671589,
-0.0170697309,
-0.0163823217,
-0.0049241455,
-0.0447951667,
-0.0531839058,
-0.0432871617,
0.0165204965,
-0.0096696261,
0.0197431985,
-0.0106789954,
0.0079133594,
0.0349314436,
0.0091715232,
-0.0389519446,
0.0600208305,
-0.0049195215,
0.0042508417,
0.0062248507,
0.0046548075,
-0.0239507146,
-0.0005425904,
0.0104181338,
0.0202843025,
-0.0101809427,
0.0481907949,
-0.0383760408,
-0.015601703,
-0.0201704819,
-0.0187880211,
0.0388544127,
0.0221277997,
0.0163519494,
0.0846134275,
-0.0668428019,
-0.0169586856,
0.0233702511,
0.0067785424,
-0.0370592289,
-0.007254804,
-0.1019805372,
-0.0132063376,
0.0116546117,
0.0754796416,
-0.034416873,
-0.0701032802,
-0.0046875165,
0.0170361903,
0.0325524956,
-0.0158457942,
0.015383373,
0.0236368626,
-0.0254858453,
-0.0192544051,
0.0056209913,
0.031960059,
0.0134980856,
0.0577594154,
-0.0109792827,
-0.0726313591,
-0.0106533254,
0.0101106362,
0.0058682752,
-0.0056316424,
0.0183770563,
0.0696303621,
-0.0103763659,
-0.0554928333,
-0.0243424922,
0.0195215344,
-0.002735415,
-0.055219315,
-0.0047468613,
-0.0626811683,
0.0672694296,
0.001958342,
0.0080017112,
-0.0809083357,
0.0370056033,
0.0051520099,
-0.0238992199,
0.0978727639,
-0.0584591553,
0.0194022451,
-0.0323291048,
-0.0010504726,
-0.0136189833,
0.0581847765,
0.0377982482,
0.0192129016,
0.0476259217,
0.0052712047,
-0.0171897691,
0.0335498638,
-0.005928454,
-0.0133572277,
-0.0290423017,
0.0066472129,
-0.0147905378,
0.0154322078,
-0.0127552599,
0.010509423,
0.0031708267,
0.0433608219,
0.0625446215,
0.0559263043,
0.0324625373,
0.0474850088,
-0.004574073,
0.0068659061,
0.0211303663,
-0.0724803209,
-0.0510561354,
-0.0029910679,
-0.0432900898,
-0.0060367021,
-0.0187135097,
0.0465963557,
-0.0104921116,
-0.0334099233,
-0.0260584466,
-0.0217876118,
-0.0062325755,
0.0084317457,
0.0674633384,
-0.0116897561,
-0.035571035,
0.0483253337,
0.042079594,
-0.0473254547,
-0.0076091895,
-0.0210712198,
0.0126753543,
0.0950680524,
0.0290144309,
-0.0419624224,
-0.0613181554,
-0.0301284697,
0.0290937182,
-0.0025575056,
0.0013431654,
-0.0094182855,
0.0754315406,
-0.0363018252,
-0.0440230556,
0.0467415862,
0.0124318795,
0.027818406,
0.0412015989,
0.0006661292,
0.0191774275,
-0.026283538,
-0.0427495167,
0.0637251884,
-0.0230356548,
-0.0200744271,
0.0467967428,
-0.0078936769,
0.03089251,
0.0071862894,
-0.0275410656,
-0.0173083954,
0.0435521193,
-0.0576450601,
-0.0012436627,
0.0197770186,
-0.0744046345,
-0.0311158914,
0.0388227627,
0.0127593754,
0.0150650665,
-0.014634558,
-0.0412496217,
-0.0273021739,
-0.0008417128,
-0.0103911236,
0.0347709209,
-0.0305111632,
-0.0005148783,
-0.0182085317,
0.0259137563,
-0.0302954558,
0.0695245489,
0.0038720956,
-0.0304719266,
-0.0265496355,
0.0083383527,
0.0086070746,
-0.0270312745,
-0.025314169,
0.0071869479,
0.0029816721,
0.0291981474,
0.0091939075,
0.0199788921,
-0.0544432551,
-0.0247637928,
-0.0721331984,
0.0247740541,
-0.0295827109,
0.0035998353,
0.0140692079,
0.0145642869,
-0.0201043691,
-0.0336705558,
0.0034839383,
0.0089226495,
0.0085568521,
-0.0248212572,
-0.0054079229,
0.0185337439,
-0.0091434494,
-0.0321967714,
-0.008815743,
-0.0013976694,
0.0338658504,
-0.0064619244,
-0.0454330184,
-0.0330490209,
-0.0268497784,
-0.0115094213,
0.0188314207,
0.0047841021,
-0.002258098,
-0.0239591319,
-0.0528426915,
0.0032837442,
0.0725651383,
0.003746321,
0.0316654444,
0.0416285731,
-0.0113175213,
-0.0652849972,
0.0016254371,
-0.040980313,
0.0200114474,
-0.0201386847,
0.0420432352,
-0.0061458787,
0.037528608,
-0.0160744973,
0.0062600756,
-0.047299616,
0.0201534536,
-0.0134506328,
-0.0242212415,
-0.03738207,
0.0085669886,
-0.0308508109,
-0.0046974896,
-0.0088298237,
-0.0367601775,
0.0429436862,
-0.0198987555,
-0.014458973,
-0.0580205843,
-0.0395206138,
-0.0291587729,
0.0955327898,
-0.0066353586,
0.0133371903,
0.0374461934,
-0.0154155232,
-0.021803543,
0.0027936406,
0.0129192341,
-0.0367383882,
0.0370588973,
-0.0660032332,
0.0342603512,
0.0095641743,
-0.0315263048,
-0.0500837453,
-0.0324634388,
-0.0329390168,
0.0081215817,
-0.0275739226,
0.0028064346,
-0.0653157905,
0.0391002521,
0.035355866,
0.0347952731,
-0.0014878924,
-0.0025670002,
-0.0235712118,
0.0243307352,
0.017577108,
0.0231531858,
0.0326000862,
0.0060623693,
0.0394715331,
0.0244364887,
0.0402399302,
0.0100648049,
-0.0695163012,
0.0299376436,
0.0164998267,
-0.0012338058,
-0.0132395364,
0.0230811425,
0.0304764733,
-0.0735584944,
-0.0046456121,
0.1177409366,
0.0251773335,
-0.0237580072,
-0.0046680165,
0.0614602417,
0.0082575232,
0.0136956414,
0.0182549153,
-0.0327037573,
-0.0683426708,
0.0048038927,
0.0377654359,
0.0448502935,
-0.0473375581,
-0.0184265673,
-0.105512917,
-0.0063845348,
0.0291261263,
-0.0322907269,
-0.0003343165,
-0.054261528,
-0.0009648571,
-0.0290781949,
0.0048956447,
-0.0069630672,
-0.0365354232,
0.0067311563,
0.0268967375,
-0.0710232034,
-0.1116223633,
0.068097733,
-0.0453508832,
0.053313829,
0.0721045807,
0.0050315773,
-0.0040533631,
-0.0008207036,
0.0381096564,
-0.0254086312,
0.0151707036,
-0.0287288819,
0.0512580127,
-0.0078368494,
0.0075718858,
0.0202312414,
0.0414999537,
-0.0564203896,
0.0048745489,
0.0066494392,
0.0669748783,
0.019567484,
0.0023394909,
-0.0184173156,
-0.0571550615,
0.0272858534,
0.0596268922,
-0.0094549684,
-0.0426590405,
-0.0274670497,
0.0140771074,
-0.0323344432,
-0.0534685738,
-0.0157969762,
0.0208005924,
-0.0185421202,
0.0022083807,
-0.046630241,
-0.0044678072,
0.0570893027,
0.0487401858,
0.033776734,
0.0413323492,
0.0114248348,
0.0468851402,
-0.0649239346,
0.0268528648,
-0.0069099087,
0.0356060974,
-0.0393622704,
-0.0043948945,
0.0451397151,
0.0020380393,
-0.0068474584,
-0.0128045296,
-0.03873026,
-0.0543433912,
0.0222029705,
0.0848045945,
0.021892406,
0.0499754138,
-0.0370762087,
-0.0418842174,
0.0200909879,
0.0873928368,
-0.0409862846,
-0.0065911817,
0.0055782758,
-0.0575281233,
-0.0019670995,
0.049572479,
-0.0344101414,
0.0348390862,
0.0167181324,
0.0454719551,
0.0027780381,
-0.0134193162,
0.0236345083,
0.0096712857,
0.03991808,
-0.0284559261,
-0.0148785878,
-0.020982353,
0.0099535584,
0.0258046333,
-0.0036291792,
-0.0510204881,
0.0323428996,
0.0137895793,
-0.0094533097,
0.0098432051,
0.0361004844,
0.0284979548,
0.0340068974,
-0.0210590828,
0.0293917656,
0.0181198716,
0.000065819,
0.0446947813,
0.0242394712,
-0.0248427447,
0.0229496006,
-0.0145637318,
0.0149375675,
-0.0539417639,
-0.0114958175,
0.0173285306,
-0.0030071256,
-0.0571463667,
0.0717921853,
-0.0655260757,
-0.0480446704,
-0.0637364089,
0.0284909718,
0.0667195097,
-0.0226814188,
0.0180139914,
-0.0310023706,
-0.0034095524,
-0.0503306799,
0.0468906239,
-0.0178097896,
0.0080269352,
-0.0016385531,
0.0133209992,
-0.0356374644,
0.0187866334,
0.0574736483,
-0.004873096,
0.0356197841,
0.0366591848,
0.0177370626,
-0.0762862042,
0.0178628769,
-0.0020078204,
0.0329121798,
-0.0248969793,
0.0550086908,
-0.0290737543,
-0.0369060971,
0.0278634429,
-0.037253201,
0.02794322,
-0.0002118779,
0.0322156176,
0.0687381253,
0.0046375142,
0.0229826849,
-0.0149336867,
-0.0038346078,
-0.0307136178,
0.0116842305,
0.006654765,
-6.449432775e-33,
-0.0228973553,
0.011836838,
0.0025206248,
-0.0175442249,
-0.0212728456,
0.0053668888,
-0.0275663119,
0.0269708186,
-0.0251396224,
-0.0486169048,
-0.0362550132,
-0.0048579602,
0.0113657806,
0.0453337468,
0.0067512323,
0.0105525814,
0.043152608,
-0.0045523616,
-0.0191374253,
0.0163736083,
0.0623101331,
0.0674951375,
0.0623996221,
-0.0751825571,
-0.0241432022,
0.0181504451,
-0.0067010149,
0.008323065,
0.0193315037,
0.0597942211,
-0.0295160748,
0.029417336,
0.0080931988,
-0.0265881643,
-0.0411019847,
-0.0126186758,
-0.099972941,
-0.0169097111,
-0.0108328452,
0.0153751131,
-0.0110841813,
0.0138087692,
0.0320873372,
0.0003994123,
-0.0094623398,
-0.0037241019,
0.0484490283,
-0.0556411743,
-0.0501796119,
-0.037264958,
-0.0608305819,
0.0331170186,
0.0135073708,
-0.0152120898,
0.0362086631,
0.0038270107,
-0.0200746451,
0.0105787804,
-0.0813347027,
-0.0239146277,
0.0077382526,
0.0414607041,
0.0565404296,
0.0163091272,
0.0206561182,
0.0767356083,
-0.0308506265,
-0.0386884585,
-0.0294254944,
-0.0213752743,
0.0412925854,
0.0664651766,
0.0190030392,
0.017235117,
0.0416254401,
-0.0228693318,
-0.0608337559,
0.0070183794,
0.0623236671,
0.0333816186,
0.0163076911,
0.028813241,
-0.0223678444,
0.0045041423,
-0.0481033809,
-0.0074793622,
-0.0063789305,
-0.033667285,
0.0666065812,
0.0197035167,
-0.0571514294,
-0.0110802157,
0.0491960794,
-0.060759794,
-0.026667377,
0.0069960677,
0.0100561623,
-0.0163164791,
0.0279853437,
0.0352999158,
-0.0815387815,
-0.027477676,
-0.02087529,
0.0191658027,
0.006653843,
-0.0431099683,
0.0414320938,
0.0515564382,
-0.0493395515,
0.0066563007,
-0.0089908978,
0.0041598948,
0.0126836672,
0.0614615083,
0.0347913578,
0.0379774421,
-0.0203418434,
0.0501010977,
-0.0036614994,
-0.0153188612,
-0.0185596868,
-0.0170487482,
0.027788166,
0.0173111241,
-0.0248742588,
-0.0252394397,
-0.0819789395,
-0.0222361982,
0.0414037406,
-0.0454575941,
-0.012770257,
0.0340418741,
2.782e-7,
0.0454630107,
0.0539242812,
-0.0031927661,
-0.0368124843,
0.0266582277,
0.0281702653,
-0.0312444381,
0.0134004718,
-0.0331231244,
-0.0217488594,
-0.0258910786,
0.0381475724,
0.0438198932,
0.0112694427,
-0.0913534388,
0.0052058715,
-0.0369016379,
0.0366550125,
-0.0537268221,
0.0089074317,
0.0538775101,
0.1185807884,
0.0084986361,
-0.028237734,
-0.0129179107,
-0.0343629122,
0.051962804,
-0.0097126216,
0.0405017436,
-0.0031195392,
-0.0116841774,
0.0436131693,
-0.0565801337,
0.010916532,
-0.023322193,
0.0329535641,
-0.0070336005,
0.0515808873,
-0.0264305566,
0.0058629299,
0.0033735039,
-0.0024418968,
0.009834649,
-0.0283733103,
0.0913215876,
-0.07586243,
-0.009263942,
-0.0358292386,
0.0001075118,
0.0004177404,
-0.0150575079,
0.0208317433,
-0.0047563673,
0.0250616595,
0.0115579665,
-0.0191953648,
-0.0577224828,
-0.1293714195,
-0.0220411364,
0.0114303743,
-0.0108689293,
-0.02531958,
-0.0354337916,
0.0219583809,
0.0578226559,
-0.0728316456,
0.0159878787,
2.622920723e-34,
-0.0001515737,
0.0006320956,
0.0167283732,
0.0423525721,
-0.0068370993,
-0.0172912814,
0.0186524298,
-0.003331692,
0.0042721066,
-0.0857717544,
0.0009745397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06467v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06467v2 | ALBA: Adaptive Language-based Assessments for Mental Health | 2023-11-11T03:37:17 | 2024-05-16T07:13:10 | Vasudha Varadarajan, Sverker Sikström, Oscar N. E. Kjell, H. Andrew Schwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mental health issues differ widely among individuals, with varied signs and
symptoms. Recently, language-based assessments have shown promise in capturing
this diversity, but they require a substantial sample of words per person for
accuracy. This work introduces the task of Adaptive Language-Based Assessment
ALBA, which involves adaptively ordering questions while also scoring an
individual's latent psychological trait using limited language responses to
previous questions. To this end, we develop adaptive testing methods under two
psychometric measurement theories: Classical Test Theory and Item Response
Theory. We empirically evaluate ordering and scoring strategies, organizing
into two new methods: a semi-supervised item response theory-based method ALIRT
and a supervised Actor-Critic model. While we found both methods to improve
over non-adaptive baselines, We found ALIRT to be the most accurate and
scalable, achieving the highest accuracy with fewer questions (e.g., Pearson r
~ 0.93 after only 3 questions as compared to typically needing at least 7
questions). In general, adaptive language-based assessments of depression and
anxiety were able to utilize a smaller sample of language without compromising
validity or large computational costs. | [
0.0190129057,
0.0779782981,
-0.0408867896,
0.0125704994,
-0.0011555381,
0.0142058581,
0.0417154841,
0.0454160161,
0.0279048029,
-0.002113635,
0.0104379216,
-0.0306928176,
-0.0324606895,
-0.0068417443,
-0.0015315535,
-0.0249505155,
-0.020412989,
0.0292524584,
0.0556013696,
-0.0066027562,
-0.0085909972,
-0.0165771618,
-0.0293746106,
0.017938938,
0.0418056175,
-0.0140123656,
0.0156324673,
-0.0243401676,
0.0723241121,
-0.0757566243,
0.0145405345,
0.060463056,
-0.0011638225,
-0.0277723595,
0.0000021524,
-0.044732023,
-0.0345545784,
-0.0024526922,
0.0565246828,
-0.0453013293,
0.045264136,
0.049912665,
0.0243652407,
0.0318205766,
-0.0312299766,
-0.0623168312,
0.0191543028,
0.0538608804,
0.0642821863,
0.0541899614,
-0.0265389048,
0.0058898828,
-0.0260439143,
-0.0333199874,
0.0203622319,
-0.0262846202,
0.0296194125,
-0.0336022638,
0.0160775501,
-0.0236777011,
-0.0326478034,
-0.0126998844,
-0.0116312345,
0.0460441671,
-0.0214937087,
-0.0291414671,
-0.0091532357,
-0.0046894848,
0.05164776,
0.059646368,
0.0644758195,
0.0505055375,
-0.0094254427,
-0.0179412402,
0.0630200654,
0.0705307052,
-0.0180454906,
-0.0255219359,
0.0185640864,
-0.0521084219,
0.0377335846,
-0.0057515386,
-0.0388682038,
-0.0497175753,
-0.002756665,
0.086029239,
-0.0021439157,
-0.0486282557,
0.006543444,
-0.0263606925,
-0.027146589,
-0.0247730613,
0.0346417688,
0.0248128362,
-0.0687026158,
-0.0027836056,
0.0132272113,
-0.0616745651,
0.0174876228,
-0.01081073,
0.0513717867,
0.0321684666,
-0.0452723727,
-0.0271356627,
0.053728573,
0.1086110249,
0.0369213112,
0.0207519606,
-0.0618581101,
0.0631954223,
-0.036148876,
0.0125890709,
0.0048563178,
0.0072681187,
0.010344753,
0.0259126797,
-0.0914287418,
0.0041425657,
-0.027090732,
-0.0357596017,
-0.0119094141,
-0.0024495351,
0.0346619971,
0.0542153679,
-0.010263605,
0.0140084755,
-0.0281216558,
0.0130864689,
0.0287693758,
0.033190351,
0.0530630052,
0.0063078534,
-0.0013278842,
-0.0319917239,
0.024353141,
-0.0022402254,
0.0303932223,
-0.0090850359,
0.023147665,
0.0185568128,
-0.0692203194,
-0.0197346006,
0.0079757087,
-0.06170059,
0.0290371887,
0.0261664707,
0.0060455375,
-0.0495177843,
-0.0008748133,
0.0183251426,
-0.0287055373,
0.019314006,
0.0416134559,
0.0166112874,
-0.0042331219,
0.0199802499,
0.045797009,
-0.0106487535,
0.0253086314,
-0.0223919768,
0.0333710499,
-0.0627410114,
-0.0229739733,
0.0221148655,
-0.0064488323,
0.0084961792,
0.0135607766,
-0.0047081979,
-0.0502966084,
0.0183930527,
-0.0251085833,
0.0153719727,
0.0131129799,
0.0212596953,
0.0325202383,
0.0604634956,
0.0335141085,
-0.0187454224,
-0.0211442281,
0.0224614851,
-0.0251116399,
0.0273635443,
-0.0139901042,
0.0055077169,
-0.0182653777,
-0.0306966938,
0.0294664912,
-0.0007103253,
-0.0169512257,
-0.0579338893,
-0.0366800465,
0.0166592728,
0.013508454,
0.0569413118,
-0.0213858467,
-0.0190391298,
0.005910058,
-0.0338500664,
-0.0053616455,
-0.040138647,
-0.0051383534,
-0.0546724275,
-0.0103916954,
0.0674536899,
-0.0109869875,
-0.0534309596,
-0.0066364296,
0.0420738719,
0.0109586483,
0.0138799008,
0.0193831157,
-0.0206046607,
0.0052873543,
-0.0016062909,
-0.0208585951,
0.0484300517,
0.0036138464,
-0.0003832141,
-0.0302202124,
0.0314544924,
-0.0295418147,
-0.0401319377,
-0.0313017704,
0.0449616425,
-0.002471928,
-0.0845101997,
0.0638252348,
-0.0103605753,
0.0606978498,
-0.0038051468,
-0.0079141967,
0.0280379709,
0.0186964739,
-0.0017326267,
-0.0644113943,
0.0025058023,
-0.0076198559,
-0.0373103805,
-0.0064548696,
0.0427995659,
0.0258923918,
0.0618239082,
-0.0277738236,
-0.0390541479,
0.0440000705,
-0.0013395461,
-0.0060334178,
-0.0010056134,
-0.0047490587,
0.0125420131,
0.0238220152,
-0.0939398184,
-0.0037894333,
-0.0238582734,
0.0786297619,
-0.0543026105,
-0.0122360308,
-0.0074593443,
-0.01325469,
-0.0740484446,
-0.0082026571,
-0.0312105007,
0.031536404,
0.0120433606,
0.052077584,
-0.0299014244,
-0.0271529984,
-0.0667552054,
0.0304246526,
-0.0222103186,
0.0056884335,
-0.0058186492,
-0.0018857096,
-0.0212268569,
-0.0214260537,
-0.0385742188,
0.0508748107,
0.0740550011,
0.0652903691,
-0.000942086,
0.0111664608,
-0.0001073951,
-0.0482862219,
-0.0020444843,
-0.0383900851,
-0.0017009844,
-0.0113427909,
0.0307507608,
-0.0256670993,
-0.0380027443,
-0.0683993548,
-0.0237093754,
0.0097615449,
-0.0246563125,
0.023221802,
0.0086932667,
0.0425995626,
0.0207883958,
0.0045764684,
0.0714318156,
0.0314319618,
0.0305649452,
-0.0243980121,
0.0140877748,
-0.0194238946,
-0.0399246216,
-0.0325435549,
-0.0904007405,
-0.0008805979,
0.0579110011,
0.0364223979,
0.0056039034,
-0.050620988,
0.0093941921,
-0.0496081263,
-0.0060734604,
-0.0279645883,
0.0288523361,
-0.033137206,
0.0220648814,
-0.0094335945,
0.0066081006,
0.0446386822,
0.0202159602,
0.0142012592,
-0.0864442587,
-0.0007636181,
-0.0151940305,
0.0501312651,
0.0499069281,
0.0008868346,
0.0111194765,
0.0189069547,
-0.0670253932,
-0.0370379798,
0.0211038291,
-0.042618379,
0.0123161897,
-0.0407025404,
-0.0176575668,
0.0080758166,
-0.042286884,
-0.0361686908,
-0.0162654854,
0.0248548798,
-0.0162577871,
-0.0308116656,
0.0022312794,
-0.0464901254,
-0.0206484813,
0.0380981006,
0.0061166678,
-0.03309514,
-0.0038325007,
0.0435760282,
0.0519525856,
0.0564872883,
0.008429152,
0.00384866,
-0.0412103198,
0.0456136838,
0.0434094109,
0.0183962472,
0.0313721597,
0.0549979508,
0.0384038016,
0.002846889,
-0.0141197629,
0.0027649505,
0.031291645,
-0.0051829489,
0.0214722455,
-0.017114915,
0.09157563,
0.0353156328,
0.0023307302,
0.0233487319,
-0.0338630304,
0.0339283124,
0.04535174,
0.0203753058,
-0.0127708344,
0.0191703644,
-0.0407173596,
0.0846876428,
-0.0227241516,
-0.0316976756,
0.0035243733,
-0.0355048515,
0.0263902154,
-0.0390772559,
-0.0809652954,
0.0419295952,
-0.0201241821,
0.0539842024,
-0.0023661104,
-0.0363437571,
0.0126053756,
0.0347982608,
0.0264195874,
0.0194072332,
-0.0475242808,
-0.0015078621,
0.0583172925,
0.0135233207,
0.0333440341,
0.035982471,
0.0397718176,
-0.0190596282,
0.0100646736,
0.0054998179,
-0.0473643988,
-0.0266402531,
0.0004709772,
0.040114563,
0.0316723101,
0.0134162605,
-0.0422026701,
0.025276456,
-0.0496273413,
-0.0100564575,
0.0300407037,
0.068222262,
0.0230075028,
-0.0221828595,
-0.0195790268,
0.0196465589,
0.025282206,
0.0105475867,
0.0089871828,
-0.0689284131,
0.0319504812,
0.0219779462,
-0.0075775092,
-0.0452061594,
-0.0599844083,
0.018168129,
-0.0134211341,
-0.0174245033,
-0.0878414884,
-0.0793061331,
0.033163555,
-0.0116438521,
-0.0080713322,
-0.0264542755,
0.0018022296,
0.0071060965,
-0.0751715451,
0.0112064201,
0.0759757385,
-0.028019907,
0.0124682989,
-0.0174911339,
0.0382607915,
0.0047360919,
-0.0547015741,
0.0019742588,
-0.0480611585,
-0.0134538673,
0.1148720533,
0.0338084958,
0.001330917,
-0.0598776788,
0.0262226872,
-0.0338477828,
0.0059304317,
-0.0328650177,
-0.0030913979,
0.0464689583,
-0.0205905456,
0.0000461347,
-0.0243500825,
0.0311515983,
-0.0428385176,
0.0571518317,
0.0343504362,
0.0311293509,
0.0182889923,
-0.0551393144,
0.0282775927,
0.0309789069,
0.0098382086,
-0.0212125704,
-0.0732218772,
-0.0239418782,
-0.0206313077,
-0.0195648409,
-0.0237417445,
0.0074361037,
-0.0305679627,
0.0035209146,
-0.0018416736,
-0.0378297977,
-0.0630026534,
-0.0514240414,
0.0151095381,
-0.0810659081,
0.0284987241,
-0.0159008279,
0.0021011764,
-0.0279998928,
0.0323022008,
0.0078676958,
0.0117398556,
0.00928903,
0.0475627668,
-0.0164759606,
0.1037975848,
-0.0238166824,
-0.0047953255,
0.0094437748,
0.0360696092,
-0.0384985059,
-0.0400900617,
-0.0191861242,
0.0288395714,
-0.0244555958,
0.0214366093,
0.0304977689,
0.0079647796,
0.0191381983,
-0.0397889465,
-0.0232402682,
-0.0177008286,
-0.0425398014,
0.0392824709,
0.015234136,
0.0196922384,
0.004933856,
0.022014929,
0.0171250105,
-0.0476970971,
0.0043771034,
0.0028934383,
-0.0529956035,
-0.0074434821,
-0.0218542609,
0.0133666415,
-0.062808387,
0.0090559237,
-0.0495237894,
-0.0650135726,
0.0084631937,
0.0009583943,
0.0182386581,
-0.0110127218,
-0.0364786386,
0.0427236184,
-0.0384071022,
-0.0230982546,
-0.0479568504,
0.0102248667,
-0.0923977643,
-0.0766396299,
0.0041196565,
-5.804589635e-33,
-0.0637957305,
-0.0324428342,
0.0088464664,
-0.0187495016,
0.0270975586,
-0.026965078,
-0.0094886962,
0.0516412593,
0.0103066973,
-0.0041957358,
0.0085295616,
0.0244063232,
0.0131217316,
0.0509065539,
0.020804489,
-0.0146502871,
-0.0063622682,
-0.0261847004,
-0.0344776474,
0.0095175505,
-0.0323326811,
0.0107835308,
0.0689703599,
-0.0631187111,
0.0570967644,
-0.0027930869,
0.0077104019,
-0.0095427055,
-0.0001231773,
0.0490368605,
-0.0252210032,
0.0936167017,
0.0692479089,
0.0037031739,
0.0724611431,
-0.020339204,
-0.0559804887,
-0.0670386925,
0.0035198194,
0.0049253418,
-0.0337500684,
0.0218353402,
-0.0063960981,
-0.0112034259,
-0.0267526694,
-0.028336307,
0.0537004806,
-0.037157461,
0.038202703,
-0.0081005739,
-0.0209266953,
0.0028537789,
-0.0273944158,
0.0074082781,
-0.0636210963,
0.0989899486,
-0.0436001793,
-0.0147526553,
-0.033002533,
0.0169428401,
-0.0212113392,
0.0146028502,
-0.0185727179,
0.0250647198,
-0.0283964667,
0.0423415303,
0.0228836648,
-0.0051433691,
0.0337846801,
-0.0139275473,
0.0074093593,
-0.0124955904,
0.073702991,
0.0391719677,
-0.0009949156,
-0.0166049469,
-0.0443054214,
0.0491287038,
0.005466342,
-0.0228686165,
0.0441630408,
-0.0058286055,
-0.0158122834,
-0.0365892127,
-0.0754370391,
-0.0088654114,
-0.044054959,
-0.0300184526,
0.0679748133,
-0.0095894029,
-0.0332051665,
-0.0798563287,
0.0524643883,
-0.0003260908,
-0.0243623294,
-0.0628133863,
-0.0564150885,
0.044288449,
0.0134723,
0.0362979248,
-0.0012153937,
0.0314550623,
0.0132585233,
0.0338905267,
0.07550174,
-0.0203861687,
0.0269066971,
-0.0415302739,
-0.0547573008,
-0.0083519667,
0.0349448621,
0.0236948244,
-0.0128266243,
0.0508620627,
-0.0357110389,
0.0339195058,
0.0087914504,
0.0528090335,
0.0576953813,
-0.0884399116,
-0.0711495504,
-0.011191613,
-0.0104715377,
-0.0229853429,
-0.0100347372,
0.0099756448,
0.0239833724,
0.0246783346,
0.0107924836,
-0.0530102961,
0.0121726729,
-0.0120554455,
2.761e-7,
0.0237458218,
0.0539148487,
-0.05374505,
0.0071736374,
-0.0076991394,
-0.0049542603,
-0.0274094269,
0.0292864293,
0.0648263767,
0.0313372649,
0.0199614521,
0.0010281388,
0.0002873353,
0.0439887792,
0.0314992182,
-0.0562504008,
-0.0206118487,
0.0083838059,
-0.0259477701,
0.024903249,
0.0834425762,
0.0340116359,
-0.0530398451,
-0.0103310132,
-0.0283787288,
-0.0099537317,
0.0261317231,
-0.0038369829,
-0.0079067098,
0.0213835742,
-0.011925091,
-0.0132756261,
0.03524689,
0.0310511012,
-0.0030843676,
-0.0010616893,
-0.0180861559,
0.0424710289,
-0.018062463,
-0.0215314049,
-0.004223282,
0.0608453751,
0.0123033207,
-0.0469365194,
0.0363027528,
-0.0508460142,
-0.0337084606,
0.0279222541,
-0.0247388985,
-0.0016008305,
0.0511046946,
-0.0187106133,
-0.0251667462,
0.0361638963,
0.0394230746,
-0.0002008,
0.0411334783,
-0.0092155067,
-0.0263237376,
0.051374305,
-0.0318099149,
-0.0353443287,
-0.0141160525,
-0.024828814,
-0.0446845442,
-0.0486931242,
-0.0114289131,
2.363361928e-34,
0.0096730692,
0.0731736273,
0.0009130045,
-0.0145983035,
0.0273814611,
-0.0201833546,
-0.0427513272,
0.0563438497,
-0.001542714,
-0.0924760774,
-0.0376676843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06453v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06453v3 | DocGen: Generating Detailed Parameter Docstrings in Python | 2023-11-11T01:14:37 | 2023-11-17T22:30:27 | Vatsal Venkatkrishna, Durga Shree Nagabushanam, Emmanuel Iko-Ojo Simon, Melina Vidoni | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Documentation debt hinders the effective utilization of open-source software.
Although code summarization tools have been helpful for developers, most would
prefer a detailed account of each parameter in a function rather than a
high-level summary. However, generating such a summary is too intricate for a
single generative model to produce reliably due to the lack of high-quality
training data. Thus, we propose a multi-step approach that combines multiple
task-specific models, each adept at producing a specific section of a
docstring. The combination of these models ensures the inclusion of each
section in the final docstring. We compared the results from our approach with
existing generative models using both automatic metrics and a human-centred
evaluation with 17 participating developers, which proves the superiority of
our approach over existing methods. | [
0.0312206708,
0.0236324351,
-0.0141680343,
-0.0217099544,
0.0245676935,
-0.0045160772,
-0.0319220275,
-0.0169688221,
-0.0429037698,
-0.0374468155,
0.0115358708,
0.0398543999,
0.0285403896,
0.0174083523,
0.0347987823,
-0.0808148459,
0.0064567919,
-0.0117148198,
-0.0129059711,
0.0507814586,
-0.0265147518,
0.0283939894,
0.002586042,
0.0682559311,
0.0156585537,
-0.0435006097,
0.0076352661,
0.012892249,
0.0167161226,
-0.0113840112,
0.0028738957,
0.0055837147,
-0.0304510035,
-0.013695919,
0.00000208,
-0.0078058965,
-0.0045160647,
0.0180454198,
-0.0110892728,
0.0910784751,
0.0319336317,
-0.0237086937,
0.0199583173,
0.0276544839,
-0.0245593842,
-0.0024299456,
0.0395664237,
-0.0216956064,
0.0755202919,
0.048017703,
0.0173595678,
0.019660512,
-0.0046331859,
-0.0064915586,
0.0402240641,
0.0088621257,
-0.0391350016,
0.0436244383,
0.0373190306,
-0.0024994195,
0.0408628397,
0.0134047037,
0.0083908495,
-0.0088567445,
0.0548739173,
0.0505081676,
-0.0209283568,
-0.0293576922,
0.0330166407,
0.0456576236,
-0.0308885649,
-0.0558477938,
0.0286609251,
-0.0425837636,
0.0037315988,
-0.0204939116,
-0.0862331465,
0.0457957052,
-0.0152656855,
-0.0228544213,
0.0053871316,
-0.0161518641,
0.0023549215,
-0.0307252631,
-0.0040254197,
0.000740149,
0.0026656138,
0.018425392,
-0.0421583317,
-0.0404771157,
-0.0174064189,
-0.0716756061,
-0.0051609292,
0.0429908372,
0.0182913505,
-0.004885464,
-0.0323642679,
-0.0856945291,
0.0809072554,
-0.0042583793,
-0.0016444231,
0.0169061553,
-0.0317010321,
-0.0102387508,
-0.0473540351,
0.0215537753,
0.0186522156,
0.0075522647,
-0.0262006111,
0.0076372731,
-0.0356667489,
-0.0153706335,
-0.0202576648,
0.0226378646,
0.0032210094,
0.0273271687,
-0.0144680226,
0.0627339706,
0.0039387504,
0.0390992276,
0.0595763698,
0.0182740875,
-0.0163545161,
0.0074679418,
0.0310939793,
-0.0212092474,
-0.0266740657,
-0.0629823655,
0.0037725912,
0.0032057099,
-0.0347522795,
0.0188278109,
-0.0009948846,
0.0045871325,
-0.0016586605,
0.0743211582,
0.0311882868,
0.0326304063,
-0.0048991395,
-0.059975937,
0.0115558272,
-0.0036530748,
-0.0171402656,
-0.0928005278,
-0.0407713726,
0.0310816448,
-0.0155865038,
-0.0648616329,
0.0033939187,
0.0025858164,
0.001114644,
0.0103267506,
-0.061131034,
0.0288546942,
0.0529218726,
-0.0044256318,
-0.0149846487,
-0.0043286914,
0.0570648536,
0.0426564887,
0.0418554321,
-0.061679963,
0.0444715545,
-0.0092329942,
0.0137012945,
-0.0109887924,
0.0687697902,
0.0090863574,
0.027130641,
-0.0118360035,
0.0336263925,
0.0106927017,
-0.0171723124,
0.00925643,
0.0040657148,
0.0294196513,
0.0330096036,
-0.0103742955,
0.1020585895,
0.06290856,
0.024967039,
-0.0154163223,
-0.000692295,
0.0610398911,
0.0368472822,
0.0684449747,
0.0024473008,
0.0210863147,
0.0079201441,
-0.0638882443,
-0.0219656974,
-0.0202864688,
-0.027560588,
-0.0071589942,
0.0334680714,
0.0057631764,
-0.0723673478,
0.0407717377,
0.0537204295,
-0.0892906785,
-0.031043442,
-0.0078658676,
0.0259890277,
0.030285744,
0.0580441654,
-0.066326037,
-0.0259332918,
-0.0320804939,
0.0150427856,
-0.025485931,
0.0633995384,
-0.0080774883,
0.0167636666,
-0.0515491813,
-0.0131339347,
-0.1086180061,
-0.0061459173,
0.037311364,
-0.0034317821,
-0.0597850978,
0.0748829171,
-0.0349107869,
-0.0970127732,
0.0560524389,
0.0112049254,
-0.0444361977,
0.0402487181,
-0.0281458404,
-0.0016098547,
0.0057237879,
-0.0373925716,
0.0488413237,
0.0484201014,
0.0078471918,
0.0290332809,
-0.0136911748,
-0.0063057756,
0.0148094455,
0.0057171728,
-0.0545363948,
-0.0131325359,
-0.0078244293,
-0.0101900743,
-0.0160983615,
0.0151061909,
-0.0127109913,
0.0353256129,
0.0406664014,
-0.0110620745,
0.0304256547,
-0.0213148687,
0.0164812375,
0.0344630778,
0.0474472195,
0.0129723735,
0.0067623658,
0.0358727314,
0.0419736914,
-0.0173921101,
0.0081965718,
-0.0389854908,
-0.0334336199,
0.01292847,
0.0162471645,
0.0380559489,
0.0005683763,
-0.0382544883,
-0.1008481905,
-0.0290792342,
-0.0052656047,
-0.0015518181,
0.0300619509,
-0.0102867736,
-0.0063036117,
-0.001213502,
-0.0224456061,
-0.0480824411,
-0.0319176055,
-0.022349827,
0.017561106,
-0.0045204018,
-0.0275083296,
-0.0530475751,
-0.0167602841,
-0.0338939875,
0.0419815555,
0.0306997877,
-0.0092185186,
-0.0555537716,
0.0283904616,
0.0123787494,
-0.002871244,
-0.0039755222,
-0.0250842702,
0.0175430253,
-0.0160856899,
0.0738314688,
0.0502743162,
0.0220686104,
0.0148513205,
0.0517301895,
-0.0004066381,
-0.037648093,
0.0052760588,
0.0052144704,
-0.0197627153,
0.0609363951,
-0.0605945475,
0.0330175124,
0.0354317352,
0.0067549166,
0.021463789,
-0.0352067761,
-0.002381433,
0.0128771691,
0.0113078058,
0.0152809145,
-0.0403548293,
0.0123538738,
0.0333828107,
-0.0050174678,
-0.0800036117,
0.0326833799,
-0.050112132,
-0.0054360116,
-0.0082541863,
-0.017951021,
-0.0654102042,
0.0700908825,
0.0138779869,
0.0279928744,
0.0434604771,
-0.022571044,
-0.006196775,
0.0539032966,
0.0426555574,
0.0022711528,
0.0221948624,
-0.0415437855,
-0.0195380766,
-0.0218354575,
0.0001066076,
-0.0055234889,
-0.0039658532,
0.0011591195,
-0.0050262138,
0.0780380964,
-0.0348979533,
0.0245867651,
0.0246225968,
0.0533239134,
0.0335554481,
0.0393241718,
-0.0314740352,
-0.0070247604,
-0.0413540713,
-0.0230690837,
-0.0502629653,
-0.0098484578,
-0.0417235419,
-0.021518413,
0.0089457855,
0.0565994084,
0.0519714653,
-0.025460558,
-0.0587708876,
-0.0281476602,
-0.06213497,
-0.0435051993,
0.0391582064,
0.03224466,
-0.0280669089,
0.0233625658,
0.0577669032,
0.0450984575,
-0.0049763527,
0.0314715058,
-0.0171529111,
0.0571435019,
0.0472263284,
0.0391952842,
-0.0520661734,
-0.0111033013,
-0.0422438346,
0.0783870295,
-0.0140848057,
0.0176264122,
-0.0258644149,
-0.0481971316,
0.0411069095,
0.0074491934,
0.0137366047,
0.0006308021,
-0.0438749939,
-0.0290483739,
-0.0124098277,
-0.0760010108,
0.0376574844,
-0.013472409,
0.0306030642,
0.0185106713,
-0.0907273442,
0.0148260193,
0.0104686907,
-0.0202787798,
-0.0130401468,
0.0552237071,
0.0139927305,
0.0243631471,
0.0127223721,
0.0057078502,
-0.0136344815,
0.0186686646,
0.0059691663,
0.0808962435,
0.0017890575,
-0.0095231617,
0.0579914376,
0.0265386831,
-0.0669104904,
-0.012395151,
0.0274689347,
-0.0049176151,
0.0104359882,
0.0088571254,
-0.0292755794,
0.0072985371,
-0.0081525501,
0.0230894703,
0.0828112587,
0.0237137713,
-0.0402251221,
-0.0457699671,
-0.0150168613,
-0.072028622,
0.0328017138,
-0.0545501299,
-0.0064857076,
-0.0361257046,
-0.0888428241,
-0.0062262402,
0.0402825102,
0.02015361,
0.0170191303,
-0.0130135147,
-0.0122723943,
-0.0004554233,
-0.074364081,
0.0342069119,
0.029785322,
-0.0111940503,
-0.0372691117,
-0.0797701702,
0.0415286161,
-0.0334743485,
-0.0281127281,
0.0687345117,
-0.077511631,
-0.0422127955,
-0.043058686,
0.0701823607,
0.0233449209,
0.0170520227,
-0.0360715352,
-0.0346226953,
-0.0209505819,
0.0361807272,
-0.0249597058,
0.0090983296,
0.0303285699,
0.0059995083,
0.0014979601,
-0.0270406418,
-0.0702504739,
-0.0230164398,
-0.0291208383,
-0.0370611288,
-0.0226677228,
-0.0052421107,
0.0414786972,
0.0301266536,
-0.0078427382,
0.0153370155,
0.0038097519,
-0.0222809184,
-0.0172919855,
-0.0207732376,
-0.0163395777,
-0.0371659175,
0.0665963888,
-0.0179890618,
-0.0230385996,
0.0583094023,
0.0464244746,
-0.0386951566,
0.0362809747,
-0.0257918984,
0.0207722653,
-0.0061534615,
0.0155036654,
0.0085556889,
-0.0329698883,
-0.0225227717,
-0.0069697807,
-0.043331828,
0.0186703242,
-0.0179095455,
0.0324010141,
0.0124904262,
0.0364548862,
0.0213397741,
0.0216817241,
-0.0419056937,
-0.0889703929,
-0.0580735281,
-0.0054932497,
0.0056897611,
0.0367582366,
0.0707640797,
-0.0346114747,
0.0075476021,
-0.0176485293,
0.0925601274,
-0.0049090311,
-0.0048343386,
-0.0403357185,
0.0339222327,
-0.0119069293,
-0.061558459,
0.107995823,
-0.0059836418,
-0.0137868533,
-0.0192628335,
-0.028813839,
-0.044657886,
0.0065236255,
0.0024057112,
0.0142650213,
-0.0158583242,
-0.0261918176,
-0.0510735735,
-0.0205612034,
0.0003456813,
0.0448052436,
0.0346889123,
-0.001509735,
0.0444794632,
0.0635677204,
-0.022849882,
-0.0248918086,
-0.0279732384,
-0.0061851111,
-0.022642877,
-0.0461937487,
-0.0470235124,
-5.123794e-33,
-0.0343636163,
-0.0190993994,
-0.0154237673,
0.0466349125,
0.0346290618,
-0.0001212164,
-0.0451558083,
0.0050807078,
0.0228527896,
-0.032381691,
0.0285012275,
-0.0211648867,
-0.0064040017,
-0.0663745999,
0.0262461603,
0.0362596437,
0.0298133586,
0.0420739688,
-0.0620278046,
0.0815099552,
0.0052961945,
0.0011183007,
0.0429491922,
-0.0650961623,
0.0086805411,
-0.0293577109,
0.0180955678,
-0.0568051487,
0.0376096517,
0.052718211,
0.0105297035,
-0.0054321811,
-0.0010543521,
-0.0020241248,
-0.0346444026,
-0.0237523653,
-0.0535531938,
-0.0161362365,
0.0163563471,
-0.0581735186,
-0.0346721224,
-0.060001716,
0.0694733709,
-0.0053719371,
0.0396739505,
-0.0236763842,
0.0685873777,
0.0138081554,
-0.0379991755,
-0.0844047517,
-0.0401875861,
0.0335961394,
-0.0748177618,
-0.0161094237,
-0.0368281193,
0.0335800312,
-0.0054273643,
0.0277176481,
0.0251568947,
-0.0187180862,
0.0648715869,
0.0523702316,
0.0715464279,
-0.033240471,
0.0096587492,
-0.0099614197,
0.0080027189,
0.0438707843,
-0.0348857157,
0.0055677099,
-0.00937148,
0.0518662259,
0.0330235027,
0.0018923167,
0.0122302128,
-0.0049368232,
-0.0089785159,
0.0436885804,
-0.0365780927,
0.043347124,
0.0010704492,
0.0187967662,
-0.0251181684,
0.00392434,
-0.0274819192,
-0.0215834584,
0.0137087302,
-0.0121346395,
0.0079828901,
-0.0040768012,
-0.0595901087,
0.0049271947,
-0.0113603929,
0.0090153581,
0.0720493272,
0.009833606,
-0.0588738173,
0.0571798123,
-0.0373938605,
-0.051834859,
-0.0027489611,
-0.0004750422,
0.0240680669,
0.0142914951,
0.0776411667,
0.0245986506,
0.0051461887,
0.0057478598,
-0.0388118401,
0.0118307676,
-0.0443276055,
0.0035516878,
-0.0580208339,
0.0182267725,
-0.0038301095,
-0.0048313797,
-0.0061158878,
0.0071733072,
-0.0190661792,
-0.0361860059,
-0.0471572354,
-0.0034756858,
0.0269618426,
0.003590696,
-0.0318997018,
-0.0167848896,
0.0041645556,
0.000567966,
0.0908817649,
0.0367597677,
-0.0553589016,
0.0445932262,
2.606e-7,
0.0367449187,
0.0267236233,
0.0447449461,
0.0282862727,
-0.0277539883,
0.0191270057,
0.014619505,
0.0110770874,
0.0105703967,
-0.0387169756,
-0.0074851275,
-0.0193556175,
0.0348232947,
0.0482192934,
-0.064816013,
-0.0194059275,
-0.0415877812,
0.0017849148,
-0.0634340197,
-0.0003112915,
0.0255213063,
0.0218324568,
0.0196495727,
0.0396172889,
0.021176964,
-0.0303037949,
-0.0035223824,
-0.038119629,
0.0471894592,
0.0736637339,
0.0445529558,
0.0019941262,
-0.0419938117,
-0.0035344257,
-0.0410277918,
-0.0639221594,
0.0331952609,
0.0541038066,
0.0041958522,
0.0447632112,
0.0311839152,
-0.041922152,
0.0170321744,
-0.0830601826,
0.0046977089,
-0.0265278164,
0.0105032744,
-0.0103632109,
-0.0229006223,
0.0440051481,
-0.0266051274,
-0.0108316932,
0.0173550304,
0.0103267608,
-0.0275717266,
-0.0395157263,
-0.0203940924,
-0.0507822335,
-0.049421899,
0.0272586495,
-0.0052106325,
-0.0383982062,
-0.0162224714,
-0.0126616135,
0.0154328095,
-0.0545647405,
-0.01433321,
2.726482235e-34,
0.0455209576,
-0.0574987642,
-0.0076289233,
0.0151336817,
0.0610525459,
-0.0221644863,
-0.0065808734,
0.0042948276,
0.0212313253,
0.0000363552,
-0.0407422371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06446v1 | THOS: A Benchmark Dataset for Targeted Hate and Offensive Speech | 2023-11-11T00:30:31 | 2023-11-11T00:30:31 | Saad Almohaimeed, Saleh Almohaimeed, Ashfaq Ali Shafin, Bogdan Carbunar, Ladislau Bölöni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Detecting harmful content on social media, such as Twitter, is made difficult
by the fact that the seemingly simple yes/no classification conceals a
significant amount of complexity. Unfortunately, while several datasets have
been collected for training classifiers in hate and offensive speech, there is
a scarcity of datasets labeled with a finer granularity of target classes and
specific targets. In this paper, we introduce THOS, a dataset of 8.3k tweets
manually labeled with fine-grained annotations about the target of the message.
We demonstrate that this dataset makes it feasible to train classifiers, based
on Large Language Models, to perform classification at this level of
granularity. | [
0.0669762641,
0.0746136606,
-0.0056986799,
0.0145723103,
-0.013784701,
0.0671087578,
0.039227847,
0.0101799341,
0.0145755019,
-0.0925890654,
-0.0209965985,
-0.0072085662,
-0.0176685192,
0.000455958,
-0.0007802357,
-0.0425766967,
0.038029965,
0.0405628197,
0.0367452465,
-0.0242385995,
0.0619083047,
0.0359807536,
0.0085309809,
0.0321828052,
-0.0602400042,
0.0146639459,
0.0250710305,
0.0013954254,
0.0174039025,
0.0175948944,
0.0670806691,
0.050392013,
0.0147124706,
0.0738161132,
0.0000015993,
-0.0229933783,
0.0113542443,
-0.0039343247,
-0.0081604179,
-0.0214594956,
0.0749841258,
-0.0494104624,
0.0004287978,
0.0172439329,
-0.0244454853,
0.0044651851,
0.0711896122,
0.0584317707,
0.0769870281,
0.0612235479,
-0.0057214084,
-0.030768862,
0.0056872498,
0.0028991336,
0.0162453372,
0.0030061253,
0.0470569991,
-0.0416325405,
-0.0613332056,
0.0282907113,
-0.0039775739,
0.0164066814,
0.0089183133,
0.0336876512,
-0.0071898955,
-0.0225238632,
-0.0344377682,
-0.0254627094,
0.0208791792,
0.0518333539,
-0.0563970804,
-0.0379121527,
0.0048695249,
-0.0163096059,
-0.0292003248,
-0.0520846285,
0.0010074845,
0.0021584628,
-0.007934236,
0.0498980954,
0.016036272,
0.0021524758,
0.0564333349,
0.1120019257,
0.0217391793,
-0.0116902441,
-0.0435952544,
-0.0338325351,
0.0159712583,
-0.0068127555,
-0.0091577079,
-0.0000242542,
-0.0006959126,
-0.0130077843,
-0.0082307672,
0.0036958554,
-0.0671987459,
-0.0362015925,
0.0106833316,
-0.0689613894,
0.0097718416,
0.0317583866,
-0.0189858507,
0.0093277413,
0.0209916495,
-0.0074712127,
0.0158959311,
0.0286238678,
0.0116733387,
-0.0124038756,
-0.0305612758,
0.0085026547,
-0.0170153808,
0.0078346971,
0.0221550521,
0.0377959646,
-0.0631257892,
-0.0236374047,
-0.0493534058,
0.0057987673,
-0.0190227367,
0.001032904,
-0.0131210359,
-0.0116062546,
-0.0031025573,
-0.0105956895,
-0.027848579,
0.0251644235,
-0.0469966643,
-0.055376146,
0.0187575053,
0.0287571847,
0.0007136495,
-0.0157018919,
0.0428189822,
0.0537502356,
0.0283277761,
-0.0445844419,
-0.0260892268,
-0.0381133258,
-0.021111751,
-0.0360114835,
-0.0185252335,
-0.0604976416,
0.0227232762,
0.0116724279,
-0.0339292549,
-0.0645825043,
0.0228816904,
0.0478753559,
-0.0648612529,
0.0866876841,
-0.0003378471,
-0.0084408019,
0.0204106811,
0.022934733,
0.0132225789,
0.0650211722,
0.0295494031,
0.0518247932,
0.055672735,
-0.0069269272,
0.0059374082,
0.065817818,
0.0355391316,
0.0263423473,
-0.0434369445,
0.034029752,
-0.0360002145,
-0.0259848125,
-0.0168104954,
0.0473221838,
0.0223797616,
-0.0483025052,
0.0581290871,
0.0509017669,
-0.0199836884,
0.0146857202,
0.0513542369,
0.0337736011,
-0.0078597348,
-0.0737920031,
-0.0469194166,
-0.0429641455,
-0.0336050019,
-0.0570942983,
0.0383731239,
0.0324712768,
-0.0285466053,
-0.0341063552,
-0.0284206737,
-0.0112636769,
0.0497841015,
-0.0257547442,
0.0405862555,
0.0085126273,
-0.0017558452,
0.0189527646,
0.0576979816,
-0.0108775739,
0.0019801019,
-0.0370517336,
0.0166395139,
0.05313484,
0.0013118896,
-0.0218731575,
-0.0004634566,
-0.0709375963,
0.0290817562,
0.0380873978,
0.016639065,
-0.0143614672,
-0.0012300269,
-0.0384133421,
0.0017156501,
0.0256337244,
0.0072267205,
-0.0001618279,
0.0752235055,
0.0145055316,
0.0235217698,
0.0394510441,
-0.0531770848,
0.0289006606,
0.0236350037,
-0.0406594463,
0.0266155098,
0.0322863273,
0.0514114499,
0.0231139306,
-0.0324918441,
-0.0705129802,
0.0008780121,
-0.00470006,
-0.0240783766,
-0.0295260511,
-0.0143436883,
0.0056581171,
0.017188115,
-0.0003487474,
-0.0378763266,
0.0676473826,
-0.0391029827,
0.0285206903,
0.0522307903,
-0.0232861135,
-0.0294224042,
-0.0183295757,
-0.0360924862,
-0.0562100559,
0.0371990204,
-0.0108480202,
0.0664319769,
-0.0198705159,
0.0003554666,
-0.0048506898,
-0.0675253347,
0.0212492365,
0.0272325594,
-0.0467319228,
-0.041184403,
-0.0341758542,
0.0418045782,
0.0018187225,
0.0247806869,
-0.0187756531,
-0.0099143181,
-0.0527773835,
-0.0011474977,
-0.0242124442,
-0.0201898608,
-0.0042681554,
0.0124598453,
-0.0079706088,
0.013166979,
-0.0163280368,
-0.0049042329,
0.0387206972,
0.0235349052,
0.006157951,
-0.0462635942,
0.002471019,
-0.0280955806,
-0.0185186472,
-0.0174497887,
0.0226412565,
0.0061161192,
-0.0575840473,
0.0480850264,
-0.0061472063,
-0.0124406656,
0.0209407639,
0.0070351441,
-0.0647602528,
0.0174561758,
-0.0070794253,
-0.045367483,
0.0192312654,
0.0488295704,
0.0844449773,
0.0019610156,
0.0016461024,
-0.0330363512,
0.0169099215,
-0.0321483575,
-0.0029736254,
-0.0210001934,
-0.037268322,
-0.0249326024,
0.0900862515,
0.0336234421,
-0.0156748798,
-0.0647898689,
0.0330311581,
-0.0520214178,
-0.0094869798,
-0.041766949,
-0.0363705009,
-0.0104565239,
-0.0403512456,
-0.0384839289,
-0.0791581422,
0.0582485944,
0.006802897,
0.033822991,
0.003176935,
-0.0497350581,
-0.0069250138,
0.0538266301,
0.0185088627,
0.0288755056,
-0.0190855414,
0.023321107,
0.0252005849,
-0.0169801731,
0.001792005,
-0.0158286188,
0.0010638228,
0.0125221517,
0.0163867418,
0.004122559,
-0.050716769,
-0.0622683689,
-0.0847106799,
-0.0718123391,
-0.0343974009,
0.0022336491,
-0.0142580327,
-0.0375260264,
0.0077178082,
0.0183097515,
-0.0298176389,
0.0019377165,
-0.0034866855,
0.0212793723,
-0.0324715227,
-0.0033774937,
-0.0337409005,
-0.0139291091,
0.006400587,
-0.0342372619,
0.0548377112,
-0.0114418697,
0.0378512964,
-0.0257643051,
-0.0143302632,
0.035965424,
0.0138122635,
0.004099539,
-0.0251444932,
0.018342942,
0.0064458535,
-0.0000410231,
0.10113471,
0.0216747299,
-0.0122247934,
0.0079681855,
0.033042293,
0.0024842329,
0.0142816994,
-0.0244063865,
-0.103420727,
-0.0359081551,
-0.0183043219,
0.0341305621,
-0.0770586953,
-0.0508182496,
-0.0087702833,
-0.0619414896,
0.0102653075,
-0.0154434899,
-0.0224692039,
-0.0185135342,
0.0000090205,
0.0148490211,
-0.0237617195,
0.0145717999,
-0.0575147122,
0.0160430837,
0.000242888,
0.0288991146,
-0.0729564428,
-0.0338488519,
0.0427662991,
-0.0099640284,
0.044318106,
0.0075518694,
0.0384792164,
-0.0430072583,
0.0183981173,
0.0591363683,
-0.0002421426,
-0.0179836396,
-0.047225114,
0.0671185628,
-0.02586638,
-0.0494122021,
-0.0226938333,
0.0552842468,
-0.0163204893,
-0.016791366,
-0.0064917565,
0.0288003571,
0.0316250399,
0.0095740333,
-0.0394260474,
0.0412772261,
0.0259624496,
0.0805607438,
0.0253240876,
-0.084350273,
0.0478788242,
-0.0651065931,
-0.0301199164,
-0.0187144764,
-0.0843733028,
-0.0018913213,
-0.0363195613,
-0.0366790146,
-0.0142766889,
-0.0310167018,
0.0596178025,
-0.0060507949,
0.0100875841,
-0.02218071,
-0.0084602591,
-0.0145804612,
-0.0453624353,
0.0133269681,
-0.0069547328,
0.0492064022,
-0.0102034025,
-0.0259887706,
-0.0146941599,
-0.0195852462,
-0.0310631562,
0.0220316406,
-0.0697572082,
-0.0464092568,
0.0688536465,
0.0394177176,
0.0120145148,
0.0033629779,
-0.0140813095,
-0.0716663897,
0.0529519618,
0.1065540388,
-0.0300208293,
-0.0242129155,
0.0432746634,
0.0150490552,
0.015871387,
0.0278126579,
-0.0256836042,
0.0310641136,
0.0489269309,
-0.0693900287,
-0.0679557845,
0.026651606,
-0.0332816355,
-0.0081095276,
0.0643050447,
0.0129030691,
-0.0686872825,
-0.0244712979,
-0.0210599434,
0.0138379587,
-0.0659004748,
-0.0042832,
-0.004633097,
0.022764409,
-0.0260011815,
-0.0634585246,
-0.0209714957,
-0.023417512,
0.036106579,
-0.0560357831,
0.0294906572,
0.0220226757,
0.0267966315,
0.0423971191,
-0.0097504342,
-0.0371902063,
0.020797817,
-0.0108985845,
-0.027513396,
-0.0067319395,
-0.0085826349,
0.0157747902,
0.0360899307,
0.0091839284,
-0.0347318612,
0.0438858345,
-0.0190817863,
-0.0489287488,
-0.0201952048,
-0.0332658477,
-0.0302700214,
0.0163858719,
-0.0044548395,
-0.0239791721,
-0.0087894052,
0.0011165407,
-0.0272348132,
-0.054183159,
0.0107439887,
0.030714456,
-0.0345306434,
0.0308334082,
0.0280844104,
-0.0088200001,
0.0384231322,
0.0924623981,
-0.0432137512,
-0.0145696215,
0.0238794945,
0.0225206502,
0.0446089581,
0.0387160778,
0.0425647758,
-0.0248147845,
-0.0438457243,
0.0081965085,
-0.054006435,
0.0176144149,
0.0160814505,
0.0040246476,
0.0622045584,
0.0104514938,
0.0316672996,
-0.0294334758,
0.0075452588,
0.0046419445,
-0.078075856,
-0.0012979034,
-5.561805971e-33,
0.0192533936,
0.0052315937,
-0.005841983,
0.0088456152,
0.0221181698,
-0.0106371017,
0.066895999,
0.0066107423,
-0.0144370291,
0.0200398602,
0.0000997487,
0.0167398211,
-0.0023991398,
0.0380776152,
0.0039682104,
-0.0341376141,
0.0104921572,
-0.0311447401,
-0.0219146665,
0.0108472183,
0.0535316803,
-0.0142808976,
0.0412085429,
-0.0832889304,
0.0342452042,
-0.0132893519,
-0.0229694266,
0.0214840323,
0.0225303248,
0.0665149242,
-0.0114074051,
0.1074770242,
0.0482655801,
-0.0029229824,
0.016466286,
0.0546665154,
-0.0369146019,
0.0154392021,
0.0097787958,
0.0199664626,
0.0196812376,
-0.014080246,
0.0275789239,
0.0089900792,
-0.0255791768,
-0.0341040753,
0.0244093873,
-0.0297290441,
0.0348114446,
-0.0363345034,
-0.0534874424,
0.0468910672,
-0.0446592644,
-0.0188609306,
-0.0073349816,
0.0223954227,
0.0411798358,
0.0225713793,
-0.0560454316,
0.0198099054,
0.0037689731,
-0.0021913615,
-0.0122094238,
-0.0082644895,
0.0065094787,
0.052575808,
0.0068947682,
0.0231203288,
-0.0247210823,
0.0225955099,
0.0042508412,
0.0456223302,
0.0199242998,
0.0494772457,
0.0270653218,
-0.0798684284,
-0.0632817745,
0.0000852092,
0.0509611964,
0.0021526632,
0.0249630474,
-0.0416002534,
-0.06092453,
-0.0312559754,
-0.0242325943,
-0.0532368794,
-0.0307772942,
-0.007275376,
-0.0069683874,
-0.0099961571,
-0.0178236999,
0.0036886027,
0.0088658379,
-0.0207994692,
-0.0008375248,
0.0455626696,
-0.041767545,
0.0026055041,
0.0078635151,
0.0319815055,
-0.0593655221,
-0.0307245143,
0.0090309475,
-0.0432742871,
0.0380076319,
0.0104144029,
0.0929124579,
0.0373406075,
-0.0753947794,
0.0107405409,
0.009285246,
0.0573079064,
-0.051520437,
0.0317373648,
0.0180302039,
0.0499363467,
0.0042761001,
0.0005379943,
0.0104822144,
-0.0310081001,
0.016455235,
0.013381321,
-0.0344005637,
-0.0277057793,
0.0009824064,
-0.0082066189,
-0.0103614647,
-0.0146109667,
0.0244906917,
-0.0858675689,
0.0346350335,
-0.0449405424,
2.29e-7,
0.0185925309,
0.0671153888,
-0.0279418901,
0.0372021087,
0.0212767441,
0.0492262356,
0.0499928743,
0.0416179001,
-0.0199769195,
-0.0104170097,
-0.0172630399,
0.0493458249,
0.0125378994,
0.0399461836,
-0.0079778722,
0.0026510563,
-0.0545946024,
0.0225680098,
-0.0529069267,
0.0132362768,
0.0092752157,
0.1192590669,
0.0953592807,
-0.0398446508,
-0.0205387641,
-0.0382831208,
0.0192513987,
-0.0515880883,
-0.0143906521,
-0.0076700198,
0.0641055405,
0.0309555661,
0.0185757838,
-0.0003884321,
-0.0191603545,
0.0057068439,
0.0022054778,
0.0438342877,
0.0300170761,
0.0307165608,
-0.0056362655,
-0.0294273496,
-0.0227924976,
-0.0181324054,
0.0607958212,
-0.0419342555,
-0.038580887,
-0.0454350933,
0.0250383113,
-0.0035255107,
0.0244736411,
-0.0295260102,
-0.00248081,
-0.0164638162,
0.0302691143,
-0.0215021819,
-0.0108719058,
-0.0837533772,
0.0160328373,
-0.0085878475,
-0.0294109024,
-0.0290551595,
-0.0128039951,
-0.0142977228,
0.054704722,
-0.0023222989,
0.0541814566,
1.68390266e-34,
0.0159185864,
-0.0249543581,
-0.011409062,
-0.0535859317,
0.0264548995,
0.0247387439,
0.0036240004,
0.0045119203,
0.0509289689,
-0.0509194806,
0.0093971174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06440v1 | Separating the Wheat from the Chaff with BREAD: An open-source benchmark and metrics to detect redundancy in text | 2023-11-11T00:11:50 | 2023-11-11T00:11:50 | Isaac Caswell, Lisa Wang, Isabel Papadimitriou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Data quality is a problem that perpetually resurfaces throughout the field of
NLP, regardless of task, domain, or architecture, and remains especially severe
for lower-resource languages. A typical and insidious issue, affecting both
training data and model output, is data that is repetitive and dominated by
linguistically uninteresting boilerplate, such as price catalogs or
computer-generated log files. Though this problem permeates many web-scraped
corpora, there has yet to be a benchmark to test against, or a systematic study
to find simple metrics that generalize across languages and agree with human
judgements of data quality. In the present work, we create and release BREAD, a
human-labeled benchmark on repetitive boilerplate vs. plausible linguistic
content, spanning 360 languages. We release several baseline CRED (Character
REDundancy) scores along with it, and evaluate their effectiveness on BREAD. We
hope that the community will use this resource to develop better filtering
methods, and that our reference implementations of CRED scores can become
standard corpus evaluation tools, driving the development of cleaner language
modeling corpora, especially in low-resource languages. | [
0.0372745246,
0.0768201947,
-0.0131956944,
0.0346765332,
-0.0446701124,
0.0111458497,
-0.0160662849,
0.0308405906,
-0.0041603302,
-0.0451379865,
0.0203144737,
0.0037006941,
0.0381403267,
0.0244122539,
-0.0044287066,
-0.0396259278,
0.0439336225,
0.0251672398,
0.013337411,
0.0109657105,
0.0425839946,
-0.0153002236,
0.0364868343,
0.0229322501,
-0.0128207942,
-0.0209158659,
0.0248927008,
0.0069524501,
-0.0106761195,
-0.0151957823,
0.0529234149,
0.0563505962,
-0.0711236522,
0.0317164697,
0.0000020365,
-0.0626545697,
-0.0464142561,
0.0100048054,
-0.0135676246,
0.0258869622,
0.0704756379,
0.0055550155,
-0.0211056974,
0.0335424766,
-0.0266249329,
-0.0300394669,
0.0537754558,
0.0752665251,
0.0352959484,
0.0545318723,
-0.0216507949,
0.0001059038,
-0.0327403583,
-0.0088205747,
-0.0169039872,
0.0123400465,
0.0236884113,
0.0061298274,
0.0113131497,
-0.0054414044,
-0.0073253307,
0.0382580571,
-0.0021853531,
0.0123362411,
-0.0281013418,
0.0146347377,
-0.0888411775,
-0.0362712517,
0.0299716536,
0.0495586284,
-0.0305515118,
-0.0451894104,
0.0255587008,
-0.0046428009,
-0.004942155,
-0.0167297311,
-0.0238791984,
0.0328374431,
-0.0160954036,
0.0381930098,
-0.0101716453,
0.0204860773,
0.0288914889,
0.0234457273,
0.0046593291,
0.0146659985,
0.0046578813,
-0.0327030756,
0.0408844277,
0.0265154261,
-0.0042841956,
-0.0603685938,
-0.0180815253,
-0.0299143121,
-0.0121136159,
0.0183626842,
-0.055564791,
-0.0421261266,
0.0519769378,
-0.0462548658,
0.0163998436,
0.005443078,
-0.02922526,
0.0161862411,
-0.0163733438,
0.0149548445,
0.0400750414,
-0.0046573444,
-0.0021729795,
-0.0023654506,
-0.0322264656,
-0.0027909141,
-0.0371519066,
0.0578244664,
0.0445445068,
-0.0294586811,
-0.0130091859,
0.0076740808,
-0.0545351021,
0.0366107635,
0.0074552079,
-0.0018264242,
0.0127030434,
0.0075330012,
-0.0097239017,
0.0052290172,
-0.0463035479,
-0.003247777,
-0.0075284336,
-0.0969837308,
0.0100003583,
0.0311212279,
0.0096606035,
-0.0248364825,
0.0152169112,
0.0211944375,
0.0242386162,
-0.023652643,
-0.0396586433,
-0.0198617503,
-0.0319937505,
-0.0270957015,
-0.0260588545,
-0.0634707361,
0.0021034046,
0.020402031,
0.0278996378,
-0.0517687574,
-0.0101282308,
0.0341105983,
-0.0498394556,
0.0526173934,
-0.0450276509,
-0.0016810747,
-0.0222377889,
0.0109741082,
0.0115901493,
0.036243543,
0.0061817123,
-0.0064359084,
0.0854007229,
0.0011961355,
0.005954111,
0.0475654714,
-0.0300943349,
-0.0186253954,
-0.0025305469,
-0.0076177889,
-0.0314316079,
0.0140418271,
0.0231573656,
0.0765529275,
-0.025800135,
0.0000831555,
0.0552323647,
0.028833827,
0.0309211221,
-0.0249504987,
0.0182502139,
0.060868945,
0.0318192989,
0.037331026,
-0.0173369609,
-0.0274611656,
-0.0057312599,
0.0169056021,
0.0285190083,
0.0139564546,
0.0117555112,
-0.0550048128,
-0.0330469273,
-0.0214648359,
0.0107942335,
-0.0227575507,
0.0066415262,
0.0089482898,
-0.0188279431,
0.0319880098,
0.0186624154,
-0.0585975982,
-0.0065073585,
0.0104417875,
0.0357703939,
0.0405257158,
0.0727384761,
-0.002368385,
0.0092525762,
0.0018300714,
0.0088401316,
0.030072514,
0.0369785428,
-0.0191854872,
0.0512622036,
-0.0504387505,
-0.0436131321,
0.0308354218,
0.0381525718,
-0.0054407544,
0.0313585438,
-0.008064393,
0.0318070017,
-0.0347591043,
-0.0650766492,
0.0418192483,
0.0086515909,
-0.0010010072,
0.0091061126,
0.0118969548,
0.0133353891,
0.0143177025,
-0.0240278859,
0.0263731685,
0.0335694365,
-0.018078858,
0.002313256,
0.009074891,
0.019251097,
0.0157308932,
0.0329192467,
-0.0747639164,
-0.0278423037,
0.0636422113,
-0.0025021378,
-0.0284490641,
-0.0328189097,
-0.0560748167,
0.0559859127,
-0.0421774536,
0.0163600408,
-0.01653485,
0.0131646171,
-0.0274961516,
0.0608717948,
0.0427613743,
0.0543002412,
-0.0030296748,
-0.058316879,
0.0588741489,
-0.0446095131,
-0.0277603585,
-0.0032162992,
-0.0424387455,
0.0373132713,
0.0706641302,
0.0250362288,
-0.0538286977,
-0.0015408252,
-0.0316754766,
-0.0160436053,
0.0009808987,
0.0259151794,
0.0191230625,
0.0112341875,
-0.019392807,
-0.0028788541,
-0.012248409,
-0.0385070853,
0.0045800572,
0.0192833394,
0.0613205731,
-0.0122389263,
-0.0058420324,
-0.0352791846,
0.0183734465,
0.0316126868,
0.0467475429,
0.0075999838,
-0.0497215316,
-0.035999015,
0.0631007552,
0.0053179958,
-0.0098814331,
0.0395875461,
-0.0251013525,
-0.011099305,
-0.0018010453,
0.0236927476,
0.0146535039,
-0.0039024681,
-0.0261395872,
0.0352350026,
-0.0102107096,
-0.067643337,
-0.0467477813,
-0.0260400772,
0.0416179933,
-0.0066196313,
-0.0443051979,
0.0761571452,
0.0128734168,
-0.0317309052,
0.0004386455,
-0.0268792938,
0.0085277446,
-0.0299843866,
-0.0018053133,
-0.0271839909,
-0.0040306905,
-0.0331601314,
0.0346930362,
-0.0062848451,
-0.0240664892,
0.0182051323,
-0.0302016214,
0.0037541913,
-0.020328721,
0.014416757,
-0.0179107226,
0.015388472,
-0.0047758506,
0.009478284,
0.0652727708,
-0.0325003825,
-0.0266849063,
0.0212093685,
0.0579354651,
-0.0192538891,
0.055409763,
-0.0187302753,
0.0342772938,
0.0120944967,
-0.0511215366,
-0.0337354913,
-0.040063832,
-0.0026224304,
-0.0429115035,
0.0086730635,
0.0080358805,
-0.0465830676,
-0.0131943645,
0.0143636232,
0.0431876518,
0.0128709571,
-0.0261652302,
0.0304778814,
0.0768038556,
0.0281691048,
-0.0148984101,
0.0582885966,
-0.0053901193,
0.0009428387,
0.0583020411,
-0.0070093051,
0.0123797571,
-0.0084127402,
-0.0130945127,
0.0083820745,
-0.0385562219,
-0.0074785757,
0.0119261676,
-0.0267154463,
-0.0414422266,
-0.0359846987,
0.1186977178,
0.0168015901,
-0.0358436257,
0.0102538159,
0.0121539412,
0.0752322972,
0.0142718684,
-0.0001854823,
-0.08029145,
-0.0326447189,
0.0335126184,
0.0425825492,
-0.0110223899,
-0.0470538586,
-0.0174580086,
-0.1282731444,
0.0193667188,
-0.0050944928,
-0.0159706399,
-0.0211790837,
-0.051482141,
-0.0044156578,
-0.0513097085,
0.0032168885,
-0.0148445563,
-0.0382645838,
0.0402153879,
0.0169285219,
-0.1084047407,
-0.0934214815,
-0.0123890368,
-0.0613941886,
0.0249450672,
0.0231859554,
0.0272115823,
-0.0306646228,
-0.0080720149,
0.007834346,
-0.0477751531,
-0.0485903844,
-0.0096577052,
0.0831357688,
0.0063812113,
-0.0274583008,
-0.0361914672,
-0.0033172125,
-0.0417285301,
0.0014843327,
-0.0091867205,
0.015966028,
0.0090878159,
-0.0230765007,
-0.0064280876,
-0.0402846001,
0.0139621804,
0.1127991527,
0.0334332325,
-0.0168538298,
-0.0206834115,
-0.014723015,
-0.0044046468,
-0.0583838895,
-0.0234383699,
0.0332272165,
-0.0446167253,
-0.0505642109,
-0.1051355675,
-0.1028522253,
0.0023636124,
0.0039486783,
0.0049262615,
0.0124048656,
-0.0079635801,
-0.0063504335,
-0.0600350238,
-0.0030863797,
-0.0470722951,
-0.000296455,
-0.0818449929,
0.0398066007,
-0.0255698226,
0.0003632771,
-0.0265693422,
0.0134251164,
-0.0742358416,
-0.0403054096,
0.0421688296,
0.0173234418,
0.0256635044,
0.031927485,
-0.0116342539,
-0.0322244205,
-0.0143286269,
0.0496894717,
-0.0376710705,
0.0172404218,
0.0376432501,
-0.0396250598,
0.0169476587,
0.0431909822,
-0.0628517121,
0.0395490862,
-0.0258661732,
0.0323062912,
0.0126220612,
-0.0090329284,
0.0489464551,
0.0395330973,
0.0137074981,
-0.0321448259,
0.0247664154,
-0.0331411436,
-0.0159496665,
0.0058005857,
-0.0375084616,
-0.0343570933,
0.0509241037,
0.0114220306,
0.0397167243,
-0.0365169831,
0.0708863735,
-0.0385642424,
0.068846032,
-0.010428315,
-0.0374355353,
0.009768852,
0.0211525895,
-0.0109083727,
-0.0086551663,
0.011976473,
0.010570067,
0.0003890955,
0.0182783771,
-0.0383827537,
-0.0337843858,
0.032474149,
-0.002441572,
0.0267110076,
0.0455833673,
-0.0154531654,
-0.0100177871,
0.0116410879,
-0.0427085347,
0.0361796468,
-0.0587273091,
0.1095276698,
-0.034386646,
-0.0142187374,
-0.0419616848,
-0.0012247625,
0.0163329635,
0.0020252715,
-0.0370288379,
0.0179248005,
-0.0567898899,
0.0032195563,
0.0997811034,
-0.0323421657,
0.0190563463,
-0.0160743967,
-0.0327500477,
-0.0376306102,
-0.003681025,
0.0264872033,
0.0245521553,
-0.0257802419,
-0.0483394936,
-0.0776036531,
-0.0451810434,
0.0022131051,
0.0148418965,
0.0105836689,
0.0307989512,
0.0056938641,
0.0588638932,
0.0228968263,
0.0663600713,
-0.02118898,
-0.0265379827,
-0.0321937166,
-0.0247091185,
0.0063505634,
-6.504560521e-33,
0.0342410728,
-0.0348705351,
-0.0427953303,
-0.0228430536,
0.0174648035,
0.0539038964,
-0.0344510116,
-0.0177959837,
-0.035331618,
0.0322711878,
0.0156431496,
0.0078180386,
0.0343589187,
0.0040805582,
0.0437986627,
0.0397845395,
0.0241715908,
0.041686099,
-0.0483171605,
-0.0191167276,
0.0292224623,
0.0264661722,
0.0551244281,
-0.0566898398,
0.0478519984,
-0.0072442922,
-0.0328101143,
-0.0094823726,
0.0816702023,
0.0771730021,
-0.0126688033,
0.060945116,
0.0440845639,
0.0079533244,
-0.0241077896,
0.0088725789,
-0.1001228094,
-0.0627998635,
0.0122080632,
0.0093005868,
-0.005024672,
0.0223026499,
0.0452533402,
-0.0440994874,
-0.0209727623,
0.0298123453,
0.0515875407,
-0.0346680768,
-0.0422313139,
-0.0147130657,
-0.0570294522,
0.0555295646,
0.0132982349,
0.0132002188,
0.0365007855,
0.1091099754,
-0.0167741124,
0.0456049591,
-0.0568527505,
0.0400136337,
-0.0443256795,
0.0331863984,
0.0210959073,
-0.0501566492,
-0.0153100304,
0.079429023,
0.0032816941,
-0.005157209,
0.051624909,
0.0066718659,
0.0352109112,
-0.0038612462,
0.0282163471,
0.088796027,
0.0610025115,
-0.0027927377,
-0.046027001,
0.0643207431,
-0.0068767918,
0.0274376608,
-0.0218881536,
-0.0166125968,
-0.0706430972,
-0.0384510495,
-0.01442446,
-0.0028069927,
-0.0227310099,
-0.0148479715,
0.0435385555,
0.011311708,
-0.0371181555,
0.0280688778,
-0.0142151322,
-0.0340212025,
-0.0346075296,
0.0182927884,
-0.0044161398,
0.0064246957,
0.0107145514,
-0.0038339535,
-0.011761779,
0.0039095464,
0.0072124144,
0.0109241484,
0.0264133569,
-0.0274166949,
0.0667285398,
0.0220318958,
-0.0882181972,
0.0062382985,
-0.0039379993,
-0.0061743534,
-0.0240591243,
0.0290721469,
0.0211439151,
0.005286206,
0.0128442002,
0.0231027547,
0.0644799769,
-0.0091013284,
-0.0292276517,
-0.0136247687,
0.0308085028,
-0.0066918018,
0.0079941675,
-0.0246615466,
-0.0226460714,
0.0136622945,
0.0740083754,
-0.0341848359,
-0.0106114009,
-0.0484459028,
2.781e-7,
0.057420671,
0.0543194823,
0.0505749732,
-0.0297177806,
-0.0177052841,
0.0385376215,
-0.0269658137,
0.0277060196,
-0.0744904876,
0.0009958588,
-0.0041249492,
-0.0521288365,
0.04604901,
0.0172814,
-0.0905800462,
-0.0225820467,
-0.0581348203,
-0.0523102283,
-0.0238006581,
0.0024307563,
0.049875211,
0.0964076594,
0.016167134,
-0.0359745398,
-0.016610302,
-0.0519363023,
0.012360855,
-0.0307546537,
0.0233914517,
0.0135580059,
0.0342848189,
-0.0024573028,
0.0091755362,
-0.0411166213,
-0.0349006467,
-0.0079000592,
0.0374855213,
0.0447939746,
0.0362289697,
-0.0128978733,
-0.0097460877,
-0.0695631951,
-0.0141106294,
-0.0659708157,
0.053113088,
-0.001075324,
-0.0225214437,
-0.0319708027,
-0.0594440773,
-0.008900906,
0.043975804,
-0.0016215186,
-0.0469117612,
0.0152851213,
0.0122905122,
-0.003346483,
-0.0394321866,
-0.0542680137,
-0.0412090681,
-0.0223033279,
-0.0082942331,
-0.0232346579,
-0.0172518492,
-0.0144788576,
0.0348915458,
-0.0644961521,
0.0323928297,
2.872172591e-34,
0.0421377793,
-0.018398229,
0.017424183,
-0.0011408456,
0.0126351016,
-0.0046191723,
-0.0119233076,
0.0183597989,
-0.0422633663,
-0.0388415419,
0.0144544309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06427v1 | ChatGPT Prompting Cannot Estimate Predictive Uncertainty in High-Resource Languages | 2023-11-10T23:25:34 | 2023-11-10T23:25:34 | Martino Pelucchi, Matias Valdenegro-Toro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT took the world by storm for its impressive abilities. Due to its
release without documentation, scientists immediately attempted to identify its
limits, mainly through its performance in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. This paper aims to join the growing literature regarding ChatGPT's
abilities by focusing on its performance in high-resource languages and on its
capacity to predict its answers' accuracy by giving a confidence level. The
analysis of high-resource languages is of interest as studies have shown that
low-resource languages perform worse than English in NLP tasks, but no study so
far has analysed whether high-resource languages perform as well as English.
The analysis of ChatGPT's confidence calibration has not been carried out
before either and is critical to learn about ChatGPT's trustworthiness. In
order to study these two aspects, five high-resource languages and two NLP
tasks were chosen. ChatGPT was asked to perform both tasks in the five
languages and to give a numerical confidence value for each answer. The results
show that all the selected high-resource languages perform similarly and that
ChatGPT does not have a good confidence calibration, often being overconfident
and never giving low confidence values. | [
0.0460354239,
0.0097254291,
-0.0183048341,
0.0204639062,
-0.0774649456,
-0.0075730965,
-0.0194634777,
-0.0035799558,
0.038168747,
-0.0410803631,
-0.0119130984,
-0.0480648465,
0.0317046382,
0.0027951708,
-0.0129147591,
-0.0410477668,
0.037122719,
-0.0151997469,
0.0441499501,
-0.0191971976,
0.0097641917,
-0.00977307,
-0.0241230056,
0.057316713,
-0.0114118196,
-0.0088527258,
0.0285826679,
-0.043540746,
-0.0079212962,
-0.0467560291,
0.0315006152,
0.0634954721,
-0.0319019891,
0.0348294489,
0.000001942,
-0.0658232421,
-0.0074433023,
-0.0077027916,
-0.0364573523,
-0.0092759514,
0.0455170162,
0.0377658904,
-0.0190356672,
0.0309438035,
-0.0547795556,
0.0437968783,
0.0600556135,
0.0157590136,
0.0024720796,
0.0483153723,
0.0068545416,
0.0337219425,
0.0309276786,
0.0352897458,
0.0289516132,
-0.0459173843,
-0.0081772478,
0.0377579182,
-0.006170094,
0.0183174349,
-0.0196686871,
0.0395382196,
0.0021598639,
-0.0086882683,
-0.0547937639,
0.0178779792,
-0.0779793635,
-0.0427570604,
-0.0347589403,
-0.0260821357,
0.0130321719,
-0.017507147,
-0.0392642878,
-0.0043715341,
-0.0140887452,
0.0084555643,
-0.0467127375,
0.0110101281,
-0.0255313981,
-0.0000780213,
0.0169844832,
0.0445575267,
-0.0213568565,
-0.0115744723,
0.0462147035,
0.0916844159,
0.0036334214,
-0.0301753413,
0.047578916,
0.0445396528,
-0.0153279416,
-0.0342500955,
-0.018370118,
0.0180930812,
-0.0562610328,
0.0307999533,
0.0098693613,
-0.0040226723,
0.0325457454,
-0.0615245923,
-0.0380499214,
0.0620638169,
-0.0332694277,
-0.0014073331,
0.0085133836,
0.0580572188,
0.0179559477,
-0.0173620414,
-0.0227305349,
-0.012601194,
-0.0421559438,
-0.01711859,
-0.041189611,
-0.011719469,
-0.0330301002,
0.0034122816,
-0.1109907776,
-0.0094209546,
-0.0006724666,
0.0143849701,
0.0324124023,
0.0147264004,
-0.033791177,
-0.0008384544,
-0.0493480526,
0.029477505,
-0.0146682551,
-0.0147262355,
-0.0067288275,
-0.1229017824,
0.0457613133,
0.0164515991,
-0.0374095626,
-0.0255007762,
-0.0040404014,
0.115394026,
-0.0312050525,
-0.011874442,
-0.011826124,
-0.0197130572,
-0.0385089032,
-0.0945589244,
0.004922465,
-0.0487995893,
-0.0271014851,
0.0552645214,
0.0064992947,
0.0362467729,
0.0266138427,
0.0249953456,
-0.0162497405,
0.0642751008,
-0.0173738785,
0.0057738684,
0.0061504203,
-0.0090530217,
-0.0518941134,
0.0734627098,
0.0217918698,
0.0106911827,
0.0730722249,
-0.0087538473,
0.0140183354,
0.0047637559,
-0.0371620059,
-0.0343355797,
0.0364673883,
-0.0023430111,
-0.0059543224,
-0.0013595918,
-0.0114461873,
0.0760084167,
-0.0034406418,
0.0147916563,
0.0520610698,
0.0371289179,
0.003405604,
0.0203572977,
0.0107354289,
0.0116258273,
0.0292179212,
0.032738924,
-0.057287138,
0.0139354616,
-0.0550407805,
0.0141960094,
0.0058838474,
0.0293821357,
0.0244876351,
-0.0520990528,
-0.0417292453,
0.0127866315,
0.0002452441,
0.0059714923,
0.0375258811,
-0.0472803004,
-0.0166101176,
-0.0082622375,
0.0208072551,
0.001164889,
-0.0302054565,
-0.0554052033,
0.0034318583,
0.0173066761,
-0.0012165435,
0.0100134863,
0.0016910344,
-0.0132526373,
-0.0146341352,
0.0074480581,
0.059305992,
0.0168853942,
-0.0132432431,
-0.0448172726,
-0.0071917581,
0.0286880285,
-0.0081171002,
0.0145018669,
0.0431156941,
0.0705390051,
-0.0136909438,
-0.0099617215,
-0.0216332618,
0.0006251766,
0.0129431197,
-0.0262918826,
-0.0161996596,
-0.0305783488,
0.0257854797,
0.0237317067,
-0.0151395071,
0.0269199461,
-0.0161799099,
0.0378685407,
-0.047609169,
0.0360225029,
-0.0436083041,
-0.0382626578,
0.0406968184,
-0.0326240771,
-0.0293177608,
-0.0307980757,
-0.0015528722,
-0.0348682888,
-0.0022323804,
-0.0495719276,
0.0442196429,
-0.053712111,
0.0161320586,
-0.0207836237,
0.0185506511,
-0.0579264499,
0.0597825013,
0.0277513806,
0.059354946,
-0.0002556522,
0.0127830924,
0.0497704744,
-0.0348692201,
-0.0543440357,
0.0294096433,
0.0017105422,
0.0196051151,
0.0700085908,
0.0302624889,
-0.0496319495,
-0.0043268488,
-0.0929312035,
-0.0035082761,
-0.0112019395,
0.0289552547,
-0.0069087967,
-0.0280757938,
-0.0198803078,
-0.0132516911,
-0.0401709899,
0.0247441679,
0.0281483307,
0.0569981448,
0.0210310891,
-0.0182085466,
0.0155262388,
-0.0144085763,
0.0070429789,
-0.0096755736,
0.0076675001,
0.065857172,
-0.0485383756,
-0.042815119,
0.0468227006,
-0.014470432,
0.0131779639,
0.0080436775,
-0.0602787398,
0.0306029189,
0.0114954878,
-0.0003270381,
0.0106944302,
0.0082079936,
-0.0239002705,
0.0182052199,
-0.0188106019,
-0.0171736963,
-0.0015584504,
-0.0533708446,
-0.073416248,
0.0146969594,
-0.0293673221,
-0.0154733742,
0.0461398326,
0.0483140498,
0.0002117426,
-0.0355326757,
0.0082559688,
-0.0510714501,
0.0034612915,
-0.0234857798,
0.0241210926,
-0.0197870675,
0.0773358569,
0.0259908587,
-0.0557642505,
0.0707717836,
-0.0241939332,
-0.0365498848,
-0.0705105811,
-0.0185206849,
-0.0020815281,
0.0386589244,
0.000741986,
0.0149403764,
0.0209050607,
-0.0549845919,
-0.0500787571,
-0.029994173,
0.0657818913,
-0.0312596597,
-0.0142417187,
-0.0319676287,
-0.000954784,
-0.0119334413,
-0.0324307568,
-0.0476396792,
0.0001369287,
-0.0452569015,
0.005135302,
0.0674550459,
-0.0256518088,
0.005910784,
0.0066092666,
0.0154083781,
-0.0070476914,
-0.0427692756,
-0.0323809497,
0.0057993084,
0.0047789714,
0.0241914056,
0.0116892653,
0.0574487522,
0.0429383181,
0.0044609704,
0.0655065179,
-0.0028304728,
0.0080289114,
-0.0317076817,
-0.0032476119,
0.0144862635,
-0.0144424671,
-0.0455255508,
0.0457998142,
0.0667315423,
-0.0250956416,
0.0040439898,
0.1092841402,
0.0280133616,
-0.0050876527,
-0.0145047689,
-0.0531646423,
0.0165212713,
0.0202258434,
0.0238796379,
-0.0556813292,
-0.0140571473,
-0.0177895389,
0.0135122184,
-0.0421786457,
-0.0282508731,
-0.0133556649,
-0.1161479056,
0.0529364608,
-0.0236602612,
-0.0528487489,
-0.0104638254,
-0.022278972,
0.0013035209,
-0.024284387,
0.047297895,
0.0006521195,
-0.0024055918,
0.0280217379,
0.0386970341,
-0.1091685295,
-0.0361286663,
0.0314547978,
-0.0135387816,
0.0599088632,
0.0488204248,
0.0201145299,
-0.0337079503,
0.0143782701,
0.023239987,
0.0064197113,
0.0136475908,
-0.0221002921,
0.0433431268,
0.0378131419,
-0.0044825454,
-0.0367157124,
-0.0214057527,
-0.0076508652,
0.0157044455,
0.0385476612,
0.0738953874,
-0.0397918373,
-0.0137921749,
0.0075922003,
0.0263940599,
0.0335301012,
0.0387600698,
-0.0040085074,
-0.004545779,
-0.0296774339,
-0.0320729762,
0.0067902454,
0.0022903837,
-0.0218791161,
0.0405629314,
-0.0021780047,
-0.033775039,
-0.0770475864,
-0.047523316,
0.0248718765,
0.0162627287,
-0.0042733843,
0.0334527902,
0.0146807274,
0.0430962332,
-0.0101151681,
0.0003156162,
0.0173378959,
0.0240044817,
-0.0478113443,
0.0322562084,
0.0349007882,
-0.0172596816,
-0.0084286537,
0.0124211656,
-0.0451152176,
-0.0746245608,
0.0022839096,
0.0368878245,
0.0372078195,
-0.020743398,
-0.0237274114,
-0.0425487757,
0.0079027172,
0.0332226083,
-0.040730495,
-0.0194523744,
0.0289647039,
0.0699682981,
0.0065167365,
0.0219196063,
0.0110605136,
0.0038928736,
-0.0088780914,
0.0079418737,
-0.0065642479,
-0.0584174991,
0.0239747483,
0.0574961603,
0.0744126886,
-0.0359522849,
0.0212688446,
0.0039349562,
-0.0231011976,
-0.0166836195,
-0.0160891302,
-0.0126333442,
-0.0075847083,
-0.0030912252,
-0.0104039274,
-0.0364731848,
-0.052343186,
-0.0549299046,
-0.0188246295,
-0.0119126467,
0.0342633836,
0.0458936095,
0.0189026166,
0.0449543074,
0.0223701391,
-0.0227537565,
-0.0196993705,
0.025380075,
0.0498640388,
0.0327561051,
0.0560775064,
0.0131966583,
-0.045437187,
0.0353841782,
-0.0232531689,
-0.0733265877,
-0.0715483353,
-0.0162792802,
0.0561961345,
0.0466478914,
-0.0017272684,
0.0095908837,
-0.0633850768,
0.0126873851,
-0.0155017907,
0.0189846978,
0.028540425,
0.0080057597,
0.0531688184,
-0.0319820121,
-0.049195189,
0.0032459022,
0.07172589,
-0.0288730003,
0.0031966614,
0.0022551671,
-0.0812468082,
-0.0244354662,
-0.0309295785,
-0.0193238966,
-0.0067129373,
0.0056807245,
0.0348146781,
-0.0381901711,
-0.0677415505,
-0.0169728398,
0.0213395543,
0.0087343305,
-0.0267967265,
0.0117492648,
0.0694206804,
0.0006604407,
-0.0154379038,
-0.0424292535,
0.0129481936,
-0.0173219219,
0.0346162617,
-0.0451466441,
-6.042768668e-33,
-0.0081088794,
-0.0513171405,
0.007068512,
0.0091589969,
0.0190135036,
-0.006092154,
0.0012547158,
0.0541214049,
-0.0209683143,
0.0341528244,
-0.0433997773,
-0.0295375064,
0.0418468527,
-0.0164966602,
0.0646071732,
-0.0265870057,
-0.0076672346,
-0.0098527838,
-0.0036525964,
-0.0456936434,
0.0357379541,
0.010973311,
0.1241013184,
-0.1073450297,
0.0657731146,
-0.0004900304,
-0.0109355133,
0.0219742917,
0.0076457341,
0.0260539874,
0.0036619809,
0.0881441385,
0.0136592044,
-0.0445624404,
-0.0118603166,
0.0002629538,
-0.0063535348,
-0.1030116752,
0.0424164757,
0.0607180521,
0.0008173882,
0.0477560647,
-0.0171525199,
-0.0535322763,
-0.0647043586,
0.0419913158,
0.0166889057,
-0.0296777822,
-0.0137526849,
-0.0055207806,
-0.0395658873,
0.0297452714,
0.0239562802,
0.0008557708,
-0.01418697,
0.0749538764,
-0.019694617,
-0.0875878111,
-0.0260290019,
0.0002896518,
-0.0017473163,
0.0321286134,
0.055301223,
-0.0058045373,
-0.026165802,
0.0409486368,
0.025733402,
-0.0072947536,
0.023133155,
0.0097553059,
-0.0014767557,
-0.0035820543,
0.0477545559,
0.0697834864,
0.0295961443,
-0.0022584775,
-0.0298789386,
0.0231533572,
0.0788228139,
0.0273240246,
0.0302868225,
-0.0028051417,
-0.0839286149,
-0.0597263686,
0.015937807,
0.0120979613,
-0.0272569116,
-0.0698775798,
0.028954016,
-0.033456549,
0.0462660529,
0.0376370437,
0.0290127322,
-0.0316649005,
-0.0143187288,
-0.0108773466,
-0.0220932029,
0.0256954879,
-0.0101252897,
0.0508444011,
-0.0223512687,
0.0057132407,
-0.0039378991,
0.0121236257,
-0.0006517073,
0.0067198803,
0.0089437002,
-0.0021784806,
-0.0703408495,
0.0242397208,
-0.0278562661,
0.0312504843,
0.0300911311,
-0.0221028477,
0.0146761369,
-0.0324288681,
-0.0289411563,
0.0213066898,
0.0121702859,
0.0077630249,
-0.0332241207,
-0.0158173647,
0.0032384924,
-0.0182247534,
-0.0390161648,
-0.0132471696,
-0.0044986657,
-0.0160927102,
-0.0233512241,
-0.0033167533,
0.0002101528,
-0.0066978331,
2.735e-7,
0.0554852709,
0.0487555824,
-0.013080582,
0.017062204,
-0.0087403078,
0.014294588,
-0.0069462098,
-0.0073333569,
0.0255871434,
-0.0254426934,
-0.0155654466,
-0.0354560278,
0.0360865556,
0.0817553625,
-0.0549258776,
-0.095365271,
-0.0409225821,
-0.0105410712,
-0.0101522282,
0.062075723,
0.0840350762,
0.0762668699,
-0.0036863501,
-0.0002704389,
-0.0322398357,
-0.0413018689,
0.0326643363,
-0.0273246951,
-0.0402906016,
0.0298872292,
0.071432136,
0.0505642891,
0.0277316533,
0.0652915165,
-0.0064616771,
-0.0104128793,
0.0225593876,
0.0084557636,
0.0008349691,
0.0085464455,
0.0303129107,
-0.0250018481,
-0.0079337144,
-0.0510783158,
0.0506914556,
-0.0624865741,
-0.0340653136,
-0.0206612907,
0.0343642458,
-0.0487723574,
0.0750731379,
-0.0212240461,
-0.0196959581,
0.0071679088,
0.0131706716,
0.0112780454,
-0.0343243927,
-0.0350949839,
-0.0124446703,
0.0013498385,
-0.0047584176,
-0.0709081367,
0.0202055611,
0.0053171017,
0.0308962353,
-0.0513053052,
0.0258701164,
2.401112056e-34,
0.040990144,
0.0060934178,
0.0178390425,
0.0069491644,
0.054782398,
0.0235315524,
0.0738176927,
0.0226167385,
0.0191170573,
-0.00309574,
-0.0371820629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06414v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06414v1 | Knowledge Graphs are not Created Equal: Exploring the Properties and Structure of Real KGs | 2023-11-10T22:18:09 | 2023-11-10T22:18:09 | Nedelina Teneva, Estevam Hruschka | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Despite the recent popularity of knowledge graph (KG) related tasks and
benchmarks such as KG embeddings, link prediction, entity alignment and
evaluation of the reasoning abilities of pretrained language models as KGs, the
structure and properties of real KGs are not well studied. In this paper, we
perform a large scale comparative study of 29 real KG datasets from diverse
domains such as the natural sciences, medicine, and NLP to analyze their
properties and structural patterns. Based on our findings, we make several
recommendations regarding KG-based model development and evaluation. We believe
that the rich structural information contained in KGs can benefit the
development of better KG models across fields and we hope this study will
contribute to breaking the existing data silos between different areas of
research (e.g., ML, NLP, AI for sciences). | [
0.0505486205,
0.0229437724,
0.0102301808,
0.0244181696,
0.0007176613,
0.0176953208,
-0.0268002078,
0.0188544132,
0.0760497302,
-0.0319714844,
-0.0143666342,
0.0310693346,
-0.0212445371,
0.0373584442,
0.0274567548,
-0.0038113066,
0.021718571,
0.0403726771,
0.0479914434,
-0.0225051027,
0.0155737344,
0.0019951798,
-0.0546516478,
0.0056685605,
0.0009033177,
-0.021593513,
0.005771582,
-0.0151887974,
0.0334777497,
-0.0397155806,
0.0020212538,
0.0163785052,
0.0048785391,
0.007753599,
0.0000016165,
-0.0559494086,
0.0393401422,
0.0283396095,
-0.0659689829,
0.0075230692,
-0.0217527375,
-0.0499703325,
0.0347776599,
-0.0292815212,
-0.0525961705,
-0.0425256155,
0.042249795,
0.0534065515,
-0.010339723,
0.0776015297,
-0.0120870378,
-0.0609052703,
0.0233165491,
-0.0192050487,
0.0025720065,
-0.0363612324,
0.0641576797,
0.0501937903,
-0.0161139686,
0.0079471795,
-0.0066132159,
0.0505269207,
-0.0098416544,
0.0018432934,
0.0819980428,
0.0518588386,
-0.0413289778,
-0.0022594542,
0.0218221899,
0.129048422,
-0.0007187388,
-0.0296611898,
0.0144972242,
-0.023524588,
-0.0151560418,
0.037119057,
0.0053413557,
-0.0345982425,
0.0070040612,
0.0076050982,
0.0102294423,
0.0134319235,
0.0739267319,
-0.0156702213,
-0.0129407477,
0.0801040307,
0.0035381829,
-0.0347295739,
0.0461485349,
0.0156225273,
-0.0063948082,
-0.0527464449,
-0.0383873545,
0.0233820602,
0.005186528,
0.0498579405,
-0.017107781,
0.0415543616,
0.0260489136,
-0.0441145785,
-0.0227127075,
0.0033658203,
0.0386140421,
0.0752503052,
-0.0404365771,
0.0229187701,
-0.0000086121,
0.0135232341,
-0.0112784347,
-0.0044022165,
-0.0703523085,
0.0005233217,
0.0319072306,
0.0068015917,
-0.0020719047,
-0.0147837037,
-0.051701121,
0.0295160171,
-0.0377939716,
0.0676520467,
0.0351625122,
-0.0015036135,
0.0510371141,
0.0025830849,
-0.0549209416,
0.0109662525,
-0.0337161198,
0.0159771089,
-0.0247574206,
-0.0127663929,
0.002460418,
-0.028748678,
0.0096083973,
-0.0301583149,
-0.0115139605,
0.0426745974,
0.0455854684,
0.0021580588,
0.0050367154,
-0.0319186226,
0.0101547241,
-0.0531927198,
0.028709922,
-0.0200078804,
0.100164324,
0.0310569126,
-0.0235232245,
-0.0555425845,
0.0043238336,
-0.0124618355,
-0.071563445,
0.065514423,
-0.0482012965,
0.0247675441,
-0.0206759181,
-0.0088021355,
-0.0403719395,
0.0500517525,
0.0022046082,
-0.0603149571,
0.0530654453,
-0.0201195963,
-0.0440989509,
-0.020519495,
0.0604996011,
-0.008873241,
0.0410319269,
0.0538766831,
-0.0241316613,
0.0709302872,
0.0056811385,
-0.0125737395,
-0.0221805535,
-0.0041932813,
0.0226825569,
0.0151405884,
0.0309744105,
0.0122962669,
0.0066716354,
-0.0107979933,
0.0356678329,
-0.0306513626,
-0.0327646993,
-0.0065502264,
-0.0490132906,
0.0341929831,
-0.0097785117,
-0.0048043453,
-0.0209030155,
0.0151749523,
-0.0395249352,
0.0137327304,
0.0181848668,
-0.0055143712,
0.0599197894,
-0.0262461118,
-0.0310533792,
0.0291290209,
0.0478333496,
-0.0146131217,
0.0042730523,
0.0357254185,
-0.0098132975,
0.0425862707,
0.041125834,
-0.0247176811,
-0.0574990511,
0.0306434575,
-0.0141126281,
-0.0104697291,
0.0372198075,
-0.033096049,
-0.0130883334,
-0.0434337705,
-0.0535033457,
-0.0387046114,
0.0011393499,
-0.0266738869,
0.0400549732,
0.0538930111,
0.0023046581,
-0.0921735242,
0.0139272232,
0.0357302055,
-0.0689485893,
0.0279577952,
-0.0394260809,
0.0116680423,
0.0253134239,
0.0162554141,
0.0136836851,
0.013509498,
0.0636442751,
-0.007803618,
-0.0008790597,
0.0015309041,
-0.000966834,
-0.0478123501,
0.0463989452,
-0.0021275484,
-0.0234238114,
-0.0058327629,
-0.0544694662,
-0.0305112936,
0.0081863999,
0.0441335142,
0.0876719952,
-0.0080171237,
-0.0081468262,
0.0016587164,
-0.0171858314,
-0.0061932029,
0.0749739334,
-0.0022803983,
0.0480676964,
-0.0213997923,
-0.0272979867,
0.0132828662,
-0.0020212221,
-0.0507008173,
-0.0137091838,
0.0052483398,
-0.0005855084,
0.0174682382,
-0.0725813583,
-0.0628375188,
0.0456854105,
-0.0847607031,
0.0281355474,
0.0243040435,
0.0101260953,
0.0220723227,
-0.0218138676,
0.0205226913,
0.028543042,
-0.0461579077,
0.0182534773,
-0.0102725159,
-0.0140425945,
0.04554433,
-0.0132048028,
0.0238007456,
-0.0051502273,
-0.0158067495,
-0.0414349884,
0.0573087744,
0.0043089702,
0.0129303858,
0.0193186384,
0.0823599026,
-0.0595319346,
0.0141292578,
-0.0254520122,
-0.0034782966,
-0.0241750143,
0.0213555824,
0.0231737848,
0.0550526753,
-0.0420468561,
0.0165091213,
0.0124669531,
0.0042759804,
-0.0442435257,
0.0096710408,
-0.0447082818,
0.0269529726,
-0.0488289595,
0.0177507158,
-0.0160442777,
0.0511809736,
0.0096176723,
-0.0349710695,
-0.0791746303,
0.0040511894,
-0.0127777606,
0.0331500769,
-0.0247976035,
0.0286737159,
0.0370968431,
0.0168480426,
-0.0365759134,
0.010889804,
0.0719580948,
0.0131067801,
0.0291645378,
0.0058720107,
0.0129310982,
-0.0105642695,
0.0330699831,
0.0011405281,
-0.0064924289,
0.0185035579,
0.0404389314,
-0.0221517365,
0.0242200661,
-0.0022478104,
-0.0454362892,
0.0099685816,
0.003579228,
0.0402557328,
0.0232105404,
-0.0060225129,
-0.0411591455,
0.0204413496,
-0.0448328853,
0.0247936677,
0.0208033975,
-0.0353982784,
-0.0279733222,
0.0175869297,
-0.0073390855,
-0.009840847,
0.0465756133,
-0.0031237886,
-0.0120869167,
0.0265169647,
0.0521214493,
-0.0309357271,
0.0238405354,
0.0169451982,
0.0197742451,
0.0428420044,
-0.0001744265,
0.0045582782,
-0.0182715822,
-0.0211941525,
-0.0048802476,
-0.0536820181,
0.0048184241,
-0.023917459,
0.0234220698,
-0.0022702897,
0.0291460957,
0.0931757092,
0.0138096539,
0.0046058446,
0.0246808324,
0.0360081084,
-0.0268423688,
0.0231429357,
0.0039072544,
-0.0855366215,
-0.0144722946,
-0.008232112,
-0.0091440957,
0.0233324524,
-0.0947511345,
0.0111421254,
-0.1016086563,
-0.0292115267,
-0.0102651762,
-0.0141319167,
-0.0742979571,
-0.0555443615,
0.0083731217,
-0.046537526,
-0.0497569814,
-0.0220565833,
0.0203466639,
0.0101668276,
-0.0167853646,
-0.037840195,
-0.0863195062,
0.0543175116,
-0.0558132157,
0.0916335285,
0.0088131707,
0.0523077287,
0.010897466,
-0.0315239616,
-0.0202685259,
-0.011181199,
-0.0479355082,
0.0343449786,
0.0276646577,
-0.010458095,
-0.0067276224,
-0.0484985039,
0.0267818086,
-0.086965099,
-0.0145125492,
0.0221367981,
0.1042978391,
0.0157774296,
-0.058884535,
-0.0291666556,
-0.0008636133,
0.0008505799,
0.0916766003,
-0.0272513404,
0.0345739573,
-0.0024545442,
0.0029024687,
0.0536751188,
-0.0034641195,
-0.0033884086,
0.0511909202,
-0.0289978068,
0.0538602583,
-0.0531464778,
-0.0335432999,
0.0483260825,
-0.0042127175,
0.0087892646,
0.0146836909,
0.0298424754,
-0.0445590168,
-0.0713776648,
0.0327124074,
-0.0212967489,
-0.0055805426,
-0.0093338965,
-0.0185190123,
0.0246759411,
0.0136570111,
-0.0380158424,
-0.0230388977,
-0.0308749471,
-0.0779171661,
-0.0439445265,
0.0292470045,
0.0083231255,
0.0612376817,
-0.0422244184,
-0.0143948365,
0.0591499023,
-0.001424656,
-0.0864745528,
-0.0042477287,
-0.010216373,
-0.0357634388,
0.0157532301,
0.0226260889,
-0.0625681579,
-0.0342351831,
0.0259756409,
0.0488336794,
-0.0543189794,
-0.0344332084,
-0.0163267013,
0.0442872047,
0.0271414407,
0.0266480651,
0.0093475338,
-0.0585467294,
-0.0081591234,
-0.023200158,
0.0023970532,
-0.029466562,
-0.0421491601,
0.0415118039,
0.010988852,
0.0033692464,
-0.0038879572,
0.0014217108,
0.0149574112,
-0.0101747233,
-0.0309193619,
0.0292042494,
0.0014187715,
0.0725037977,
0.0024595119,
-0.0217683129,
0.0437471904,
-0.0175549053,
0.0120892962,
-0.041376844,
0.0209242608,
0.0377750769,
0.0046719173,
0.0224240031,
0.010617855,
-0.0264945086,
0.0019568037,
0.0336644575,
0.0105766151,
0.0632220209,
-0.0444635935,
0.0156694576,
-0.0305527207,
-0.0223073773,
-0.0219840929,
0.0430275686,
-0.0486307666,
-0.0029976198,
0.0318850204,
0.0176719408,
-0.0293941647,
0.0234969519,
0.05630951,
0.0369780585,
0.0749272704,
-0.0005485342,
-0.044698108,
-0.0346081816,
-0.0110494792,
0.001353168,
0.0323423259,
-0.0192813464,
0.0329652466,
-0.0584934689,
-0.0727764368,
0.0328774378,
-0.0284949429,
-0.0710157827,
0.0195957161,
0.0196358375,
0.0267281197,
0.0150271822,
-0.0192253646,
-0.0218131039,
-0.0126570454,
-0.0567045324,
-0.0286921971,
0.0039673848,
-5.51889161e-33,
0.0116218356,
0.0053644944,
0.0255377144,
-0.0278831664,
-0.0246696044,
0.0256012511,
-0.0160248112,
-0.028045414,
-0.0587562583,
0.0486661121,
-0.0070746513,
-0.0017678431,
-0.0172467753,
-0.0123310704,
-0.0233697183,
-0.0102478191,
-0.0224657543,
0.0139045026,
0.0097843828,
-0.0095292525,
0.0168462917,
0.0336158052,
0.0629439652,
-0.0684866458,
0.0302455816,
-0.0287378822,
0.0237489082,
-0.0034585176,
-0.0167008005,
0.0443542749,
-0.0475337543,
0.026427865,
0.0283205453,
-0.0091588404,
0.0177660324,
-0.028751865,
-0.1143176332,
-0.0362143256,
0.0333717018,
0.0246955249,
-0.0418813638,
0.00205818,
0.0352413058,
-0.0028217114,
0.0289516542,
-0.064471215,
0.0427716188,
-0.0080238627,
-0.0599217229,
-0.0549679622,
-0.0274897944,
0.0168166608,
-0.0217246506,
0.0267960373,
0.0119484337,
-0.0056087342,
0.0242324881,
0.0166674424,
-0.1223815084,
0.0153087908,
0.0068725636,
-0.0245993081,
0.0378307141,
-0.027896056,
0.045661319,
0.0421837084,
-0.0097005675,
-0.0246487539,
-0.0565012768,
0.0382514559,
-0.0019579588,
0.0470687523,
0.0033320449,
0.0177184604,
0.0090231383,
-0.0200044103,
-0.1107870564,
-0.0080200974,
-0.024273023,
0.0163039919,
-0.0214635637,
0.0100196339,
-0.0416361541,
-0.0002699753,
-0.0473173074,
-0.0168131571,
-0.0115414215,
-0.0618790574,
0.0023404364,
-0.0316281319,
0.0164427441,
0.022664167,
-0.0158749912,
-0.0856171697,
-0.0102408519,
0.0518446825,
0.0294060875,
-0.0068005328,
-0.0104195094,
0.0305907633,
-0.0994113609,
-0.0157086737,
0.0105370814,
-0.0237007756,
0.023734957,
0.0269649252,
0.0253401268,
-0.0357801765,
-0.0059925159,
-0.0196723472,
-0.0088165542,
-0.0504368655,
0.0060498831,
0.012215944,
0.0410287194,
0.0630295798,
0.0317380615,
0.0414378792,
0.0797969252,
0.0077539659,
0.0037237464,
0.0382082947,
0.0251409784,
0.0009463188,
-0.0079643885,
-0.0229761247,
-0.0318054296,
-0.0202059243,
-0.0109196557,
-0.0369671173,
-0.0069934488,
-0.0183098447,
2.46e-7,
0.0652271286,
0.0103206905,
0.0392028876,
0.0463033058,
-0.0001960311,
0.0196379572,
0.0179363266,
0.0172906797,
-0.0475628823,
-0.039934244,
0.0329702273,
0.0004096899,
-0.0102442792,
-0.0052265301,
-0.0842970759,
0.0133826481,
-0.0435335413,
-0.0438112654,
-0.024616085,
-0.0032197169,
0.0025838211,
0.0473192558,
0.0681045353,
0.0308699869,
0.0053233407,
-0.0283863135,
0.0466855392,
-0.0066044983,
0.0103269378,
0.0324396156,
0.0387588516,
0.0266016275,
-0.0383788906,
0.094833672,
-0.0167400874,
0.019509973,
0.0085855667,
0.0462952591,
-0.0223809872,
-0.0035674013,
-0.0113714123,
-0.0466656499,
0.0165652726,
-0.0619447418,
0.0839836523,
-0.0390323997,
-0.0479083583,
0.0358373672,
-0.0445692278,
-0.0286609493,
0.022146862,
0.0124730133,
0.0406045951,
-0.0088782888,
0.0046386858,
0.0166590326,
-0.0143799428,
-0.0716783628,
0.0071872151,
0.0306778289,
-0.007702786,
-0.0222580675,
0.0160968043,
-0.0325361304,
0.0502038561,
-0.0344424397,
0.0189091563,
2.020049389e-34,
-0.0046427296,
0.0189272817,
-0.0078553092,
-0.0125661688,
0.0319742188,
-0.0569541082,
-0.0119218947,
-0.0161851496,
0.026308395,
-0.0697373971,
0.0399174616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06411v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06411v1 | Analyzing Modular Approaches for Visual Question Decomposition | 2023-11-10T22:14:26 | 2023-11-10T22:14:26 | Apoorv Khandelwal, Ellie Pavlick, Chen Sun | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Modular neural networks without additional training have recently been shown
to surpass end-to-end neural networks on challenging vision-language tasks. The
latest such methods simultaneously introduce LLM-based code generation to build
programs and a number of skill-specific, task-oriented modules to execute them.
In this paper, we focus on ViperGPT and ask where its additional performance
comes from and how much is due to the (state-of-art, end-to-end) BLIP-2 model
it subsumes vs. additional symbolic components. To do so, we conduct a
controlled study (comparing end-to-end, modular, and prompting-based methods
across several VQA benchmarks). We find that ViperGPT's reported gains over
BLIP-2 can be attributed to its selection of task-specific modules, and when we
run ViperGPT using a more task-agnostic selection of modules, these gains go
away. Additionally, ViperGPT retains much of its performance if we make
prominent alterations to its selection of modules: e.g. removing or retaining
only BLIP-2. Finally, we compare ViperGPT against a prompting-based
decomposition strategy and find that, on some benchmarks, modular approaches
significantly benefit by representing subtasks with natural language, instead
of code. | [
0.0158380959,
0.0131730586,
-0.0263818335,
0.0103816949,
-0.0166247413,
0.02079737,
0.0055015888,
-0.005062147,
0.0061180098,
-0.0171103794,
-0.0047608833,
-0.0082282415,
-0.0161571857,
0.031397,
0.0244366676,
-0.0392761119,
0.036605373,
-0.0153351612,
-0.0363995321,
0.0257324781,
0.0174932312,
-0.0218423381,
0.0005685962,
0.0603379421,
-0.0011302929,
-0.0245820582,
-0.038882602,
0.0210630093,
0.0143849356,
-0.005621044,
-0.0360532477,
0.0099719157,
0.0256344061,
-0.0058350568,
0.0000019849,
-0.0029052603,
0.0102754347,
-0.0012446209,
-0.0336970426,
0.0143847782,
-0.0040982487,
0.0081566973,
0.0490057766,
0.040516302,
-0.053488642,
-0.0498375185,
0.0420376621,
0.0128516853,
0.0601228364,
0.0526585542,
-0.0094167497,
0.0109699145,
0.0146465804,
-0.0180015881,
0.0306931324,
-0.0225255843,
-0.0347663909,
0.017821826,
0.024060104,
-0.003325457,
-0.0319972672,
0.0389466584,
0.0757775381,
0.0173819922,
0.0076641012,
0.0487480387,
-0.0302443095,
-0.0104964543,
-0.0244127605,
0.0428951643,
-0.0343608074,
0.0218729954,
0.016125517,
-0.0014646244,
0.0426549613,
-0.0105754798,
-0.080625169,
0.0485492125,
-0.0193504244,
-0.0027572087,
0.0084845014,
0.0004753081,
-0.0134916175,
-0.0406631529,
0.0046335463,
-0.0251526982,
0.0073112771,
0.0019419536,
-0.0293716174,
0.0157502834,
-0.0407186821,
-0.0623493083,
-0.0266541205,
0.0673316047,
-0.0126332929,
0.0016562415,
-0.0496324264,
-0.0302684773,
-0.0532018431,
0.0017799204,
0.0517842062,
0.0584492497,
-0.0396470986,
0.0249516517,
-0.0213278718,
0.0636908412,
-0.0311409067,
0.0465782396,
-0.0656699762,
-0.0183450468,
-0.0649182573,
-0.0136030084,
-0.067518048,
0.0551548004,
-0.0657221749,
-0.0275618322,
-0.0361550488,
0.0613870546,
-0.0001304311,
-0.0009518526,
0.0133583136,
0.0215378758,
-0.0145038618,
0.036333181,
-0.0397313461,
0.0300872549,
-0.0298088063,
-0.0311150961,
0.0187766179,
-0.0292435177,
-0.0052145869,
0.0315602086,
-0.0241849981,
-0.0103798201,
-0.0101229725,
0.0813404247,
-0.0234760903,
-0.0361333974,
-0.0130277406,
-0.0358696803,
-0.0191123169,
-0.0354342945,
0.0620153099,
-0.0719154701,
0.0507659689,
-0.0174292419,
-0.0306481998,
0.0260079093,
-0.0056450586,
0.0234358851,
0.0026026971,
0.0573756061,
0.0193605553,
-0.0084100822,
0.0026218134,
0.0302724633,
-0.0185975358,
0.0826873481,
0.0192723777,
0.031330049,
-0.0076754889,
-0.0070613092,
0.0455440134,
0.0426116511,
-0.0330068655,
-0.0117568653,
-0.0437712893,
0.0084744003,
0.016424058,
0.0113172224,
0.0002470791,
0.0415946692,
-0.0360607468,
-0.0284785721,
0.0418572202,
0.0325762145,
-0.0090692593,
-0.0043046665,
0.0610939302,
0.0172899235,
0.0248646382,
0.0478583202,
-0.0720098987,
0.0797803923,
-0.0281027034,
-0.0300778635,
-0.0440381542,
-0.0080819027,
-0.0604801364,
-0.0796509683,
-0.0017001022,
0.0219900087,
0.0388639867,
0.0371140838,
0.0251097288,
-0.0095262332,
-0.0496250167,
-0.0075565008,
-0.0280100256,
-0.0399582498,
-0.0127932141,
-0.0730703324,
0.0342771038,
0.0091624791,
0.0515934713,
-0.0251552127,
-0.0420544818,
0.0087377708,
-0.0157373082,
0.002635078,
0.0091690393,
-0.0125414915,
0.0451098979,
-0.0484462567,
-0.0231384616,
-0.05466922,
0.001492606,
-0.0149355475,
-0.0036670035,
-0.0362561718,
-0.0141959768,
-0.0120090172,
-0.0093923053,
0.0388433263,
0.0178223606,
0.0008922594,
0.0201039482,
0.0276586879,
-0.0180525314,
-0.0262183473,
0.0059252824,
0.0022035039,
0.0219754018,
-0.0672883242,
0.0156230796,
-0.0027329165,
-0.0367302224,
-0.0839851201,
0.0168278608,
-0.0637605637,
-0.005994739,
0.0506836176,
-0.0390158407,
-0.0152568463,
-0.0033320549,
-0.053192582,
-0.0244932119,
-0.0257202294,
-0.006628592,
0.0115044555,
-0.0036366784,
-0.0337736867,
0.0475635342,
-0.0339850783,
-0.0343722962,
0.0332189612,
0.0056356331,
0.029219985,
-0.0045316531,
-0.0125946458,
0.0145906433,
-0.0290695336,
-0.0003168202,
-0.0225120354,
0.0253205746,
-0.0484187901,
-0.0370051004,
-0.1170959845,
0.0287400074,
-0.0314082354,
-0.0143030547,
0.0328155831,
0.0190734658,
0.0272884984,
-0.008315525,
-0.0662968904,
0.0482070222,
0.0092761833,
0.0136524122,
0.0467343219,
0.0129847862,
0.0003592085,
-0.0093411822,
-0.0391182303,
-0.0012327419,
0.0519349314,
-0.0107441386,
0.0012762171,
-0.0257748161,
0.0189698245,
-0.0233888011,
0.0132143721,
-0.0271103755,
-0.0438657477,
0.038369339,
-0.0292799249,
0.078641288,
0.072558023,
-0.0309293475,
0.0150959883,
0.052827809,
0.0081879627,
-0.0217045899,
0.0553080812,
-0.0043927906,
-0.0045138826,
-0.0041537206,
-0.0428328812,
0.0112815322,
0.0557267107,
-0.02874575,
-0.0000834247,
-0.0889418423,
0.031345956,
0.0159654226,
-0.0234957226,
-0.0127738165,
-0.0322272889,
0.0055977167,
0.0462649129,
-0.0264213476,
-0.0729438066,
0.0437771156,
-0.0061810869,
-0.0344279222,
-0.003453898,
-0.0074072951,
-0.0426609628,
0.0978373289,
0.0251186453,
-0.0079955608,
-0.0008311648,
-0.0342953093,
-0.1228813753,
-0.0062051942,
-0.0006396015,
0.0035374137,
0.0963730738,
-0.0452086441,
-0.0194322057,
-0.0565228015,
-0.0108199511,
-0.0561344326,
0.0233518295,
0.0104855355,
0.0445488952,
-0.01187272,
-0.003277339,
0.0038503888,
0.0147622023,
0.0131926863,
0.0293426123,
-0.0285532642,
-0.0106932865,
-0.0301431045,
0.050664179,
0.0352170765,
0.038985759,
0.0342985354,
-0.0353826806,
0.0559101552,
0.0498613045,
0.0629710257,
0.0249631573,
-0.0104164835,
0.0026817457,
0.0013894297,
0.0137010412,
-0.0195642915,
0.0346526727,
0.0723564029,
-0.0749016181,
-0.0096672671,
0.0613027364,
0.0272614937,
-0.0515253246,
-0.0210142266,
-0.0090682274,
0.0224343203,
0.0673900023,
0.0480689853,
-0.0904952809,
-0.0237239841,
-0.0119810579,
0.0106259463,
0.0049603251,
-0.0154953999,
-0.0207166541,
-0.0565595925,
0.0896898583,
-0.0096421866,
-0.0284545273,
0.0251394846,
0.0359413996,
-0.0289860088,
0.0224116966,
-0.0110396389,
0.0004904742,
-0.0121133784,
0.0006715955,
0.0000561073,
-0.0656954199,
0.0467505753,
0.0038699179,
-0.0395333171,
-0.0121032409,
0.0238833372,
-0.0158055108,
-0.009023576,
-0.0112148039,
0.0256222822,
-0.0490528606,
0.0042834547,
-0.0050266394,
0.071690172,
0.002736032,
-0.0446079858,
0.008414492,
-0.0100436183,
-0.0038567383,
-0.0056251436,
0.0033841978,
0.0504603088,
-0.0313821211,
-0.0116619822,
-0.0465981066,
0.0020124491,
-0.0629658848,
0.0695471093,
0.0725684017,
-0.0255140048,
-0.0480282195,
0.0087836822,
-0.0434286781,
-0.0749778599,
-0.0152829494,
0.0118858991,
0.0308208987,
-0.0034678832,
-0.0739237666,
-0.0501234978,
0.0747458637,
0.0589154698,
-0.0542621687,
-0.035949897,
0.009499684,
0.010670105,
-0.090542838,
0.0340855718,
0.0296424218,
-0.0092231836,
-0.0294551868,
-0.0007650862,
-0.0001758254,
-0.0620223247,
-0.0144174462,
0.001915766,
-0.1246743649,
-0.0253818501,
-0.0394657999,
0.067003049,
0.0113163004,
0.0346191749,
-0.0099912835,
-0.0276337527,
-0.0076588755,
0.0135645401,
0.0356511213,
0.0278224554,
-0.0137630049,
-0.0059550242,
-0.0059905485,
0.0211288724,
-0.0326136909,
-0.0092659965,
0.023581801,
0.0454074517,
-0.0047694049,
0.0336581171,
0.0280910004,
0.0130240209,
0.0019224073,
0.0143919801,
0.0122647854,
-0.0237946939,
-0.0052275662,
-0.0007824131,
0.0082726171,
-0.1016889811,
0.0037193461,
0.018335551,
0.0335683897,
0.024434654,
0.0357636027,
-0.0162532553,
0.0325525813,
-0.03642134,
0.0064119026,
0.0035719154,
-0.0095787542,
0.0088232681,
0.0417936444,
-0.0134325577,
-0.0012282014,
-0.0068814792,
0.0146139702,
-0.0162943695,
0.0838991031,
0.0052314973,
0.0273219422,
-0.0419030413,
0.0607606322,
-0.052636452,
-0.1126678959,
0.0298573151,
0.0652251616,
0.0040765866,
0.0347621962,
-0.0296968166,
-0.0079161776,
0.0062410748,
-0.0211737175,
0.0285406932,
0.0078334436,
-0.0062726829,
0.0607165135,
0.0448602587,
-0.0125008542,
-0.0763534382,
0.0563353971,
-0.0137067866,
0.0169803128,
-0.005533535,
0.0261784457,
-0.0356242731,
-0.0379325338,
0.0601042174,
0.0279761385,
-0.0029874721,
0.0128735881,
-0.0620757677,
-0.0395283289,
-0.0007081872,
0.0106574725,
0.0030478414,
-0.0025749237,
0.040499676,
0.0369881094,
0.022515269,
-0.0346965902,
0.0134537518,
-0.0282005891,
-0.015641721,
-0.028701704,
0.0331631079,
-5.591953727e-33,
-0.0271771289,
-0.0265247021,
0.0674938634,
0.0028155819,
-0.034536764,
0.0390867814,
-0.0152381165,
0.0174385346,
-0.0083532659,
-0.0233045388,
0.0179135669,
0.0056498433,
-0.0029596209,
-0.0007664495,
0.009369866,
-0.04372802,
0.0323245563,
-0.0279082134,
-0.0289034639,
0.0206498373,
-0.0090224836,
0.00134706,
0.0451616496,
-0.0067031472,
-0.0367049277,
0.0225301273,
0.0262578316,
0.0235354099,
0.0017147886,
0.0862392262,
-0.0244894531,
-0.0005310291,
0.043737065,
0.0146161439,
-0.0116827935,
-0.0014301444,
-0.0412645154,
-0.0344771557,
0.0327204168,
-0.0029241601,
-0.128813386,
-0.001848362,
0.0499011502,
-0.000526223,
0.0247712787,
-0.0273619071,
0.0315556824,
0.0031382022,
-0.0070644622,
-0.0159177911,
-0.0263957381,
-0.0345382802,
-0.008184989,
-0.0507073626,
0.017766254,
0.0679721683,
-0.010973067,
0.0402423777,
-0.0129816877,
-0.0246527474,
0.0035315994,
0.0165056661,
0.0386488773,
0.0364720784,
0.004373766,
0.0327589177,
0.091008544,
0.0060432334,
-0.0279526971,
-0.0130917486,
0.0460889749,
0.0825894475,
0.0838699043,
-0.0048042028,
0.0492412932,
0.0491365343,
-0.0716180727,
0.0255562309,
0.0028438978,
0.0446787961,
-0.0269840267,
-0.0151760103,
0.0090596164,
0.005687831,
-0.0207410716,
0.0045969277,
-0.047995355,
-0.0078566121,
0.0693494976,
0.0241558366,
-0.0093517033,
0.002553626,
0.0827193037,
-0.0360375531,
0.0823448822,
0.0145483119,
-0.0374539196,
0.0774649754,
0.0421591178,
0.0293464698,
-0.0077940607,
0.0316938013,
0.0428947993,
-0.0334221944,
-0.0016808449,
0.0337560847,
0.0089528011,
0.0173164383,
-0.0341593586,
-0.002706225,
-0.0463021286,
0.0418893062,
-0.0079804771,
0.0775239244,
0.016930053,
0.003766451,
-0.0450472571,
-0.0134132337,
-0.0301265586,
-0.0506018251,
-0.0419114456,
0.0281978622,
0.0238408521,
0.0380748808,
0.0072865579,
0.0002584132,
-0.0349534228,
-0.0011019886,
-0.0072357669,
-0.0369549207,
-0.0233803876,
0.0563028492,
2.568e-7,
0.002531199,
0.0074373377,
0.0022369814,
0.0283347834,
0.0053399908,
0.0285036359,
-0.0166001953,
0.0037835096,
-0.0014348502,
-0.0115666073,
-0.0038801583,
0.053647276,
0.0331897698,
0.0090843383,
-0.0373385698,
0.0230434984,
0.0138896443,
-0.0254542101,
-0.0396032035,
0.0173911527,
0.069861494,
0.059556745,
-0.017063776,
-0.006442951,
0.045434285,
-0.0146603882,
0.0547818355,
-0.0007458397,
-0.0372489579,
-0.0114946449,
-0.0497866198,
0.0457049534,
-0.0223274454,
0.0209679995,
0.0189236924,
-0.0095991679,
0.0240366664,
0.0510830656,
-0.0002938982,
-0.0237828996,
0.016521439,
0.0222885199,
0.0170163549,
-0.0345721617,
0.061273165,
-0.0531872362,
0.0033928941,
0.0037507464,
-0.0220193975,
0.0092088431,
0.0126244491,
0.0062175342,
0.0037912074,
0.024667345,
0.0099811582,
-0.05647761,
-0.0135485847,
-0.0670953766,
0.0041324752,
-0.0341781527,
-0.0369385667,
-0.0438384637,
-0.0789480656,
0.0062834667,
0.026496917,
-0.0010273637,
-0.0936688706,
2.647662124e-34,
0.0171670299,
-0.0115871616,
0.0424445234,
0.0556135364,
-0.0030481839,
-0.0076385732,
-0.0567074828,
-0.0155483903,
-0.0106963683,
-0.0843518302,
-0.0314545333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06401v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06401v3 | Autoregressive Language Models For Estimating the Entropy of Epic EHR Audit Logs | 2023-11-10T21:32:34 | 2023-11-26T02:42:13 | Benjamin C. Warner, Thomas Kannampallil, Seunghwan Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | EHR audit logs are a highly granular stream of events that capture clinician
activities, and is a significant area of interest for research in
characterizing clinician workflow on the electronic health record (EHR).
Existing techniques to measure the complexity of workflow through EHR audit
logs (audit logs) involve time- or frequency-based cross-sectional aggregations
that are unable to capture the full complexity of a EHR session. We briefly
evaluate the usage of transformer-based tabular language model (tabular LM) in
measuring the entropy or disorderedness of action sequences within workflow and
release the evaluated models publicly. | [
0.0270493142,
0.0702653453,
-0.0217077024,
-0.0635059476,
-0.0519565903,
0.033366248,
-0.019087784,
0.0343959592,
-0.0001560937,
-0.0112510789,
0.0626958907,
-0.061361976,
0.0098845344,
0.0794769824,
0.0045595928,
-0.0155808469,
-0.0011972063,
-0.007120016,
-0.0271932241,
0.0460604914,
-0.0211093687,
-0.027824156,
0.0112271272,
0.0605933405,
0.0671675056,
0.0221945327,
-0.0284757186,
0.0253609549,
-0.0015807191,
-0.0122622279,
-0.0517880693,
0.0508994646,
-0.0231568571,
0.0131619219,
0.0000018786,
-0.0539055429,
-0.0156348515,
0.0514997989,
-0.0332414061,
0.0154776089,
0.0167980473,
-0.0795904547,
-0.0340974852,
0.0271870475,
0.0150308507,
-0.0637282133,
0.0231907833,
0.0551520921,
-0.003888034,
0.0196544901,
-0.0465588346,
0.0089883227,
0.0271280725,
-0.022108838,
0.0105427448,
-0.0128000006,
0.0307045784,
-0.0182337854,
-0.0007468741,
-0.0602227449,
-0.0185785424,
0.0020266878,
0.0107081989,
0.0034188249,
-0.012801324,
0.0136480061,
0.0475903712,
0.0541775785,
-0.0166028701,
-0.0073695024,
-0.0056145173,
0.0147328479,
0.0548624806,
-0.016994467,
-0.0199205279,
0.0054851067,
-0.0379160941,
0.030143654,
-0.0383398831,
-0.0426606499,
0.0203949641,
0.0236373469,
0.0024598925,
-0.0556269847,
-0.0402653553,
-0.0383562334,
0.0255177785,
-0.0458090231,
-0.0181987993,
-0.0135163954,
0.0782256573,
-0.0363534354,
-0.0001004743,
0.042129945,
-0.025347678,
-0.0027157534,
0.0119300568,
0.0163031183,
0.0547643118,
0.0023257709,
0.0131796775,
0.0090539474,
0.0480788648,
0.014957061,
0.0386168733,
0.0485553965,
-0.0166195687,
0.0112553705,
-0.0409176089,
-0.0052944743,
-0.0308066811,
-0.002624609,
-0.0019615227,
-0.016431829,
0.0160234403,
0.0044267024,
-0.060386207,
0.0169724543,
-0.0118667679,
0.0438605063,
0.0577400327,
-0.0081765754,
-0.005102023,
-0.0067294873,
-0.0131528806,
-0.0324267559,
0.0185246784,
0.0058101104,
-0.0184399169,
-0.0027038918,
0.0141401207,
0.0185422041,
0.0080753462,
0.0033653108,
-0.0051298616,
0.047231406,
0.0567767471,
0.0079127364,
-0.03718343,
-0.0608370639,
-0.0149236415,
-0.0018370068,
-0.0102619659,
-0.0406720638,
0.0094165048,
0.0136817005,
-0.0096397419,
-0.0218599029,
-0.0393502116,
-0.000988218,
-0.0392377488,
0.0200216882,
-0.0393952616,
0.0122414688,
-0.0382555425,
-0.0016229358,
0.0687883049,
-0.0017561313,
0.0332744233,
-0.0233298093,
0.0056762556,
-0.0598755702,
0.0806908011,
0.0437496193,
-0.0367538668,
-0.0137892477,
-0.0136026032,
-0.0012336735,
0.0027632061,
-0.0270832833,
-0.0026776048,
0.0610133633,
0.0124539947,
-0.0141748283,
0.029752966,
0.0607351847,
0.0254748948,
-0.0089360625,
0.0002361295,
-0.0427211933,
-0.0299942009,
0.0240873229,
0.0303981807,
0.0050116489,
0.028125139,
-0.0238625202,
0.025204597,
-0.0048834803,
-0.0613045581,
-0.0444455817,
-0.020062454,
-0.021832373,
-0.0044335974,
-0.031173598,
0.0291476455,
0.0012959476,
-0.04402088,
0.0295820255,
0.02625769,
-0.0296991821,
-0.0351328328,
-0.0660025328,
-0.0357500389,
0.1024057865,
0.0742457584,
-0.0111869518,
0.0155255394,
-0.076130107,
-0.0160870813,
-0.0315211378,
-0.0031661899,
0.0176698267,
-0.0111219855,
-0.0174511801,
-0.0222881362,
0.0672608539,
0.0296043027,
-0.0129072322,
-0.041369129,
0.0124312202,
-0.0036336435,
-0.0031624041,
-0.0887409374,
0.010301183,
-0.0532562882,
-0.0098015526,
0.0274558086,
0.0184508786,
0.0339947641,
0.0254279338,
-0.0155840628,
0.0461359061,
0.0318807177,
-0.0442842543,
-0.0218030047,
0.0504785962,
0.050613001,
0.0602756366,
-0.0296040569,
0.0147956563,
0.0426088832,
-0.0418057106,
-0.0087827947,
-0.0481154285,
-0.0020873628,
-0.0459651574,
0.0494826138,
-0.0135409022,
0.0485192575,
0.0171754844,
-0.0013562397,
-0.0400861278,
-0.0167647693,
-0.0412418656,
0.0588003881,
-0.0435320176,
-0.0664203316,
0.0208158903,
0.0181694273,
0.0246409997,
0.041507706,
-0.0388786756,
0.0173543412,
0.0506392457,
-0.0415408276,
0.0111004263,
-0.0639661103,
-0.0435515195,
-0.0339396261,
-0.0093920939,
0.0491290316,
0.0160156135,
0.0460698381,
0.0080151632,
0.0035152133,
-0.0213247482,
-0.0429116264,
0.0426818319,
0.0110967886,
0.0353981145,
0.028915612,
-0.0699779689,
-0.0003194331,
-0.0296346359,
-0.0370263755,
0.0602143481,
0.0081151724,
0.0140754357,
-0.0520687178,
0.0159898661,
0.0323942155,
-0.0285026487,
-0.0246926434,
-0.0452740267,
0.0014140832,
-0.0188919716,
0.0840687379,
0.0462832153,
-0.0089074355,
0.043069616,
0.006626334,
-0.0391945615,
-0.0060651572,
-0.0139989937,
-0.019033039,
0.0169737451,
0.0171634573,
-0.0808268711,
0.0785089359,
0.0498690754,
0.008912039,
0.0076111262,
-0.0113394009,
-0.0503716208,
-0.0139029622,
0.0290076565,
-0.0108895805,
-0.0194557197,
-0.0501126572,
0.0386447571,
0.0244586393,
-0.0174848065,
0.0227107517,
0.0003116687,
0.0233229436,
-0.0061378838,
-0.0511205345,
-0.0287360102,
0.0369043685,
0.020195026,
-0.0035362423,
0.0190975647,
-0.0468734354,
0.024245074,
-0.0570919253,
0.0047754673,
-0.0302749593,
0.0687157586,
0.0008827099,
-0.0007163893,
0.0031010674,
0.0043569086,
-0.0113375597,
-0.0280674696,
0.0215256009,
0.0135762673,
0.0247156471,
-0.0293804891,
-0.0697933733,
0.0606028326,
0.0044691302,
0.0649491996,
0.0432842262,
-0.0659398586,
0.0158278644,
0.0269077402,
0.0371329039,
-0.0529511981,
-0.0048247334,
-0.0396301374,
0.0261309464,
0.0354773887,
0.0677460805,
0.0533015504,
-0.0173583869,
-0.0359323509,
-0.0013491845,
-0.0277809985,
0.0080600977,
0.0701257959,
-0.0159722697,
0.0081597194,
0.0118789589,
0.0840661451,
0.0143342549,
-0.040368665,
0.0359102711,
0.0323340259,
-0.0118232211,
-0.0039435164,
0.0202306844,
-0.013074317,
0.0230843425,
-0.0015291916,
0.0253147744,
-0.0297642332,
-0.054916013,
0.0248424001,
-0.0132190119,
0.0136957737,
-0.0076229181,
-0.0186871495,
-0.0858233124,
-0.0665168539,
0.0058790348,
-0.034182813,
-0.0208530966,
-0.0146414135,
-0.0234317183,
-0.040727824,
0.0245172922,
-0.1528421193,
-0.0396743603,
0.0283773188,
-0.0199637637,
0.0585666597,
0.0465300493,
0.0033712441,
-0.0585659705,
-0.0400551409,
0.0134006673,
0.020893883,
0.0014000755,
0.0080674719,
0.0349152349,
0.0607608631,
0.0048907031,
-0.0432435721,
-0.0038827132,
-0.0415858999,
0.0167635549,
-0.0138731478,
0.0931716338,
-0.0500632152,
-0.0500379689,
-0.0047168336,
-0.0104878685,
0.0495293699,
0.0497211479,
0.0153195094,
-0.0153774489,
-0.0314223431,
0.0375927873,
0.0396076702,
0.0015302602,
-0.0217661764,
0.0168553665,
0.0319050997,
-0.0860324651,
-0.0271268692,
-0.0225708932,
-0.0039147274,
0.0475473702,
-0.0136920372,
0.034537904,
0.0618492737,
-0.0175172202,
-0.0290819891,
-0.0234468095,
0.0174039435,
0.0641472787,
-0.0608120374,
-0.0075652762,
0.0044961041,
0.075870946,
-0.0242668986,
0.0494721793,
-0.0491229892,
-0.0043784282,
0.0356760845,
0.0179133583,
0.0366281345,
-0.0504741557,
0.0020180061,
0.0158310868,
-0.0824475288,
0.0042468542,
-0.0470665023,
-0.0288032908,
-0.0415655151,
0.0015008739,
-0.0216062646,
-0.0283306707,
-0.0030239269,
-0.009571556,
0.004750337,
-0.0067183878,
-0.0407195874,
-0.1076455489,
-0.0198675953,
0.0043668435,
-0.017020477,
0.00644304,
-0.022321891,
-0.0055770734,
0.0117649306,
-0.0341771096,
0.0460125357,
-0.012213612,
-0.0158235356,
-0.0073713795,
-0.0144588454,
-0.0242131408,
0.0663825274,
-0.0845507532,
-0.0504284687,
-0.0564702153,
0.0188773721,
-0.0218687989,
0.0320996717,
0.0192377772,
-0.024256736,
0.0215121694,
-0.0102868201,
0.0331461392,
0.0418609679,
0.0106189605,
0.0317310281,
-0.0291974265,
0.0617326014,
-0.0115908282,
0.0527253747,
-0.0609831885,
-0.0052864579,
0.038885396,
-0.0632132217,
0.0158948172,
0.0154389404,
0.0198271479,
-0.0367822349,
0.0602142178,
-0.0335986912,
0.0418263078,
0.0162214581,
0.0579125248,
0.0131500755,
0.0363016501,
-0.0462473854,
-0.0249679517,
0.0916459262,
0.0536614545,
0.031480737,
-0.0262455326,
-0.0449928567,
-0.029355552,
-0.0225546304,
0.062392991,
-0.0259603895,
-0.0534179844,
-0.0329731219,
-0.0871100947,
-0.0146861784,
0.0002102654,
-0.0190492328,
0.0114395814,
-0.0069096894,
0.006391115,
0.063492097,
0.0167383198,
0.0373412371,
-0.0133217042,
0.0090554506,
0.0023391934,
-0.024498174,
0.0109990127,
-5.538970523e-33,
0.024716327,
-0.0548921861,
-0.0047817016,
0.0091993846,
0.0140378,
-0.0029029353,
-0.0421609282,
0.0047683669,
0.0473925211,
-0.0118402187,
-0.0241208673,
0.023515163,
0.0249362588,
-0.0050506215,
0.0506072007,
0.0228457488,
0.030016724,
0.0243853908,
0.02188145,
0.0301431753,
0.0065734871,
-0.0045975447,
0.0114852898,
-0.0418782607,
0.0302822143,
0.0353510827,
0.0120173432,
-0.0098701157,
0.0322776362,
0.0268044006,
-0.0134386588,
0.008027181,
0.0326655693,
-0.0616399646,
0.0151685001,
-0.0059145116,
-0.0369237512,
-0.0202560835,
0.0095923273,
0.003183774,
0.0133173326,
-0.0439844504,
0.0475130156,
-0.0171393547,
-0.0639654323,
-0.0009040224,
0.0123416092,
0.0260995086,
-0.0435269587,
-0.0922785029,
-0.0208587609,
0.0416050181,
-0.0385342948,
-0.008461209,
-0.0132752554,
0.0148709221,
-0.0095242206,
-0.0730694458,
-0.0781038329,
0.0129055642,
0.0501981787,
-0.0015533126,
-0.0166033003,
-0.0026461468,
0.0121174483,
-0.0030238028,
0.0053849989,
0.0368524306,
-0.0643372536,
0.0665438026,
-0.0033190078,
0.0262180939,
0.012573041,
-0.0416562371,
0.0321286879,
-0.02822157,
-0.0746752545,
0.1080566198,
-0.0295294691,
0.0697067678,
0.0502981581,
-0.039236363,
-0.0541699454,
-0.0158785414,
0.0063722138,
0.0404300839,
-0.0094009368,
-0.0007015946,
0.0062257666,
0.0129485261,
0.0304067396,
-0.0213653743,
0.0383563042,
-0.0204539597,
-0.0195209067,
0.025398409,
0.0250898972,
0.0053815511,
-0.0334073268,
-0.0169140343,
-0.0000853604,
-0.0128817447,
0.0500264838,
0.0384997278,
0.0325163193,
-0.0048316019,
-0.0085983481,
0.0033272025,
-0.0869537964,
-0.0144123491,
0.0232238527,
0.0355008319,
-0.0078379232,
-0.0124387564,
0.0273230802,
-0.0004271936,
0.0103629921,
0.0298249628,
-0.0361640714,
-0.0351179466,
-0.0115596429,
0.0672612935,
-0.0110976333,
0.0133791072,
-0.0045498777,
-0.0202204995,
-0.0526702218,
0.0044249319,
0.0637551174,
0.0451791398,
-0.0108887926,
-0.0046051699,
2.631e-7,
0.0250165462,
0.0172674712,
0.0259709321,
0.0136278747,
0.0512479059,
0.0005084843,
-0.0150234019,
-0.0147305811,
-0.0123600271,
-0.0348847657,
0.0414597876,
-0.0537662432,
0.0734058917,
0.0156798586,
0.0043789023,
-0.0567007288,
-0.0843304917,
0.0084704841,
-0.0482482351,
-0.0140007082,
0.0527261719,
0.0463652462,
-0.016942881,
-0.0136493631,
-0.0150940502,
0.0149064502,
-0.0127336262,
-0.0137985721,
0.0168742035,
0.0023149801,
0.0476819128,
-0.0342808515,
0.0237460174,
0.036258705,
-0.0172483623,
-0.0343693234,
-0.0479940884,
0.0748568028,
-0.042643968,
0.039427761,
0.0213320013,
-0.1014664322,
0.0035884066,
-0.0334179886,
0.0463921838,
-0.026067635,
-0.0378851779,
0.0293364339,
-0.0078678895,
0.0124859521,
0.0819938183,
0.0376085006,
-0.0345856212,
0.0425379202,
0.0166782048,
0.0002167514,
0.0384334624,
-0.0196454562,
-0.0008622818,
0.0193890184,
-0.0204736684,
-0.0033943425,
0.0038726802,
-0.0213081334,
0.0200115778,
-0.0303827077,
0.0369359478,
2.864640244e-34,
0.0517237894,
0.0336420834,
0.0007782084,
-0.0043206378,
0.0203517061,
0.0072638928,
0.0087509416,
0.0342972912,
0.0201228745,
-0.1087808833,
-0.0156343933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06383v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06383v1 | Distilling Large Language Models using Skill-Occupation Graph Context for HR-Related Tasks | 2023-11-10T20:25:42 | 2023-11-10T20:25:42 | Pouya Pezeshkpour, Hayate Iso, Thom Lake, Nikita Bhutani, Estevam Hruschka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Numerous HR applications are centered around resumes and job descriptions.
While they can benefit from advancements in NLP, particularly large language
models, their real-world adoption faces challenges due to absence of
comprehensive benchmarks for various HR tasks, and lack of smaller models with
competitive capabilities. In this paper, we aim to bridge this gap by
introducing the Resume-Job Description Benchmark (RJDB). We meticulously craft
this benchmark to cater to a wide array of HR tasks, including matching and
explaining resumes to job descriptions, extracting skills and experiences from
resumes, and editing resumes. To create this benchmark, we propose to distill
domain-specific knowledge from a large language model (LLM). We rely on a
curated skill-occupation graph to ensure diversity and provide context for LLMs
generation. Our benchmark includes over 50 thousand triples of job
descriptions, matched resumes and unmatched resumes. Using RJDB, we train
multiple smaller student models. Our experiments reveal that the student models
achieve near/better performance than the teacher model (GPT-4), affirming the
effectiveness of the benchmark. Additionally, we explore the utility of RJDB on
out-of-distribution data for skill extraction and resume-job description
matching, in zero-shot and weak supervision manner. We release our datasets and
code to foster further research and industry applications. | [
0.0735902116,
0.049011372,
0.0062512476,
-0.0196287297,
-0.0274804886,
0.0033930764,
-0.00519326,
0.0138251213,
0.0000381354,
-0.0703076497,
-0.0038806074,
-0.0208261162,
-0.0184957236,
-0.0292347409,
0.0073752021,
-0.05455954,
-0.0051023089,
0.0242704526,
-0.0261747558,
0.0222787876,
-0.003471449,
0.072710678,
0.0025283927,
0.0657878146,
-0.0052855052,
-0.0202713925,
0.0250230487,
0.0290495213,
0.0327793062,
0.0334277861,
0.0452294685,
0.0274445731,
0.0351723358,
-0.0057745096,
0.0000019187,
-0.0257940069,
0.0075976709,
0.0446328968,
-0.0370139256,
-0.0624355488,
0.0636280701,
-0.030569911,
0.0112031046,
0.0321187004,
-0.0023746344,
-0.0221868996,
-0.0060444786,
0.0142311845,
0.0314030088,
0.064253211,
0.0086257914,
-0.0223451816,
-0.0228276681,
-0.0455907136,
0.0151131153,
-0.0429227017,
0.0423009172,
-0.0054670172,
0.0203152113,
-0.0017222338,
-0.0011166318,
-0.0045245732,
-0.0182707161,
-0.0466128848,
0.0289501119,
-0.0012803471,
0.0049518803,
0.0372728519,
0.0281956606,
0.0642815903,
-0.0179262944,
-0.0156435054,
-0.0121388165,
-0.0107208239,
0.032314904,
0.0321328342,
-0.0184280444,
0.0315007381,
-0.0417863242,
-0.0156716499,
-0.0316979252,
-0.0001643808,
0.014695284,
-0.0042387121,
0.0335309245,
0.0500393473,
-0.0013463037,
-0.0496214032,
0.038177561,
0.0059864135,
0.0538223982,
-0.038206052,
0.014762138,
0.0417601839,
-0.0383357815,
0.0178604089,
-0.0430110246,
0.0179025419,
0.0193158835,
-0.0025656035,
0.0004109457,
0.0202753209,
-0.0054307603,
0.0725738853,
-0.0043487623,
0.0239582025,
-0.0016260681,
-0.0117218336,
-0.0487226881,
-0.0644374788,
-0.125541687,
-0.0214538109,
-0.0416882858,
-0.003222293,
-0.0242498629,
0.0138735287,
-0.040349599,
-0.0224752761,
-0.0502477884,
0.0158531275,
0.058094915,
0.03152439,
-0.043117445,
0.0242600646,
-0.053604342,
0.0090268319,
0.0274227336,
-0.0098640351,
0.0028455863,
-0.0274223648,
0.0217178315,
0.0015656971,
0.0227721818,
-0.0373785309,
0.0280486569,
0.0503328741,
0.0381297171,
-0.0012577181,
-0.0248345379,
-0.0400013104,
-0.0086908061,
-0.0492496826,
-0.010868133,
-0.0552147105,
0.0666081011,
-0.0038216561,
-0.0170905869,
-0.0774739608,
0.0395818651,
0.03337216,
-0.0523600429,
0.0244849976,
-0.0026819389,
0.0342357717,
0.0450038016,
-0.0095886085,
-0.0472053438,
0.0382125936,
0.0041096159,
0.0427199341,
0.0322655998,
-0.0195646696,
0.0570679903,
0.0546054542,
-0.0105088037,
-0.0055837799,
0.0020399815,
0.0597939081,
0.0331013538,
0.0467334203,
0.068226181,
0.0035717604,
-0.0473018773,
0.0181629378,
0.0317193754,
0.0448864661,
0.0104265613,
0.0021081376,
0.102466099,
0.0583061129,
0.0038410255,
-0.0332792066,
-0.0430858955,
-0.0003115229,
-0.0097640026,
-0.01281296,
-0.045660194,
0.0159901325,
-0.0447055176,
0.0146240024,
-0.0154855698,
-0.0168286413,
-0.0158854257,
0.0194676649,
0.0305821169,
0.0360805616,
-0.0515641719,
0.0496848039,
0.0548241995,
-0.0257939231,
0.0225819722,
-0.0104031656,
-0.0725762919,
0.1110707372,
0.045903556,
-0.0332827456,
-0.0304450672,
-0.0566901416,
0.0005436597,
0.0346720368,
0.0922119021,
-0.0350538492,
0.0090896888,
-0.0417667963,
-0.036283914,
-0.012919385,
0.0077830376,
0.0249252897,
0.0520854779,
0.0277530625,
0.048125647,
-0.075666137,
-0.0721930563,
0.0357250609,
-0.0339178331,
-0.0137804914,
0.0224051513,
0.0232311077,
-0.0305119082,
-0.000770964,
-0.0127197355,
0.0143179875,
-0.02733895,
-0.0146839665,
-0.0061418144,
-0.0072761378,
-0.0118427305,
-0.0268963072,
0.0246344451,
0.0063148467,
-0.0584908724,
0.0324748084,
-0.0363057889,
-0.0073368615,
-0.0101513034,
0.0162812602,
0.0048908684,
-0.0289009325,
-0.0036176986,
-0.026940627,
-0.0121616814,
-0.0365153961,
0.0720689222,
0.0618394613,
0.0142904045,
-0.0182778742,
-0.0381702408,
0.0095374119,
-0.120905526,
-0.0023571409,
-0.0155455424,
0.0228904095,
0.0528236851,
0.0035058863,
-0.0021671639,
-0.0526026301,
-0.0355656184,
-0.0771869123,
0.0178689752,
0.0069174618,
-0.0003049772,
0.0274880789,
-0.000745588,
-0.000051831,
-0.0190824717,
-0.0402354263,
-0.0333651192,
0.0161251388,
-0.0172220487,
0.0291193463,
-0.0233044755,
-0.0167447124,
-0.0237679016,
-0.027048951,
-0.031503845,
0.027220387,
0.0114660356,
0.0240996089,
-0.0409666784,
0.0242568329,
-0.0275554899,
0.0361074321,
0.0153300771,
0.0307170711,
-0.01402946,
-0.0001570802,
0.0227670446,
0.0554686114,
-0.0222404841,
0.0258100349,
0.012901037,
0.0142309163,
-0.029252829,
0.007295588,
-0.0082328236,
-0.0012721252,
-0.0408942029,
-0.0299077593,
-0.0134263197,
-0.009995915,
0.0168627426,
-0.0317682177,
-0.0393463336,
-0.0044963066,
-0.0230119191,
0.0129406909,
-0.0734294206,
0.0222693868,
-0.0138504878,
0.0043893857,
-0.0349825621,
0.0090648467,
0.0279449299,
0.0013743353,
0.0444949865,
0.0070586498,
-0.0480031408,
-0.0752496421,
0.0702777505,
-0.0343384184,
0.0249363966,
-0.0172301978,
-0.0183523595,
-0.0409600921,
-0.0236570351,
0.0110071525,
-0.0429894365,
-0.0375220068,
-0.0180678405,
0.0212762263,
-0.0172273666,
-0.0317560993,
-0.0429363623,
-0.0510195047,
-0.0167646557,
0.0711968318,
-0.0022014503,
0.0029575049,
-0.075756371,
-0.0243470669,
-0.006198335,
0.0237199254,
0.0088486038,
-0.0120884981,
-0.0214875881,
0.0234683007,
0.0659914166,
0.0197434407,
-0.0309641566,
-0.0425952151,
-0.0115618454,
0.0161082149,
0.0254816152,
0.002406759,
-0.0196944829,
-0.0075064008,
0.017121844,
-0.0706757903,
0.0094471648,
-0.0029543303,
0.0040120683,
-0.0244655348,
0.0243481565,
0.0901724845,
-0.0188377295,
-0.0525421239,
0.0002340413,
0.0306594726,
-0.0320809893,
0.0512717627,
0.0858326033,
-0.028318271,
-0.0146162855,
-0.0056209196,
0.0382958427,
0.0392330103,
-0.049938444,
-0.0034916021,
-0.1280750036,
0.0554994307,
-0.0195708834,
-0.0030065265,
-0.0083139222,
-0.0213698465,
0.0040139621,
-0.0276410151,
0.0020448745,
-0.0020257314,
-0.0505700558,
-0.0130123179,
0.0593463965,
0.0253593847,
-0.0794074312,
0.0867000222,
-0.0411263481,
0.009841511,
-0.0094521642,
0.0404880531,
0.0032217391,
0.0151061229,
0.0133337602,
0.0285279602,
0.0067599243,
0.0503589436,
0.0553392135,
-0.0367813669,
-0.024450412,
0.0066956403,
-0.0093562687,
-0.063493818,
0.0175659992,
0.0346458852,
0.0809995309,
0.0113208462,
0.0017978277,
-0.0155109651,
-0.0359523967,
0.0229665972,
0.1004407033,
-0.0126416367,
-0.0717713535,
-0.0208647475,
-0.0001118112,
-0.016069077,
-0.0317435712,
-0.0217420664,
0.0390312821,
-0.0369055793,
0.05620303,
-0.0125400964,
-0.0573548339,
0.0513936915,
0.0120793926,
0.0286783241,
-0.0009454276,
-0.0090195509,
-0.012636113,
-0.0841536596,
0.0215163901,
-0.0666093677,
0.0694581643,
-0.0402987301,
-0.0158465691,
-0.022875512,
-0.0500144027,
-0.0398244672,
-0.0261726119,
-0.0747485459,
-0.0027252883,
-0.0373128317,
-0.0313929394,
0.0189950056,
0.0721093342,
-0.0169942752,
-0.0498557091,
0.0024633878,
0.0315315276,
-0.0403546095,
-0.0078701135,
-0.035788361,
-0.0130767329,
-0.0248976126,
0.0276413858,
-0.0774440765,
0.0051732734,
0.0448537022,
0.0002700379,
0.032830745,
-0.0338576175,
-0.0085187731,
0.0116069457,
-0.0363184549,
0.032022696,
0.0015471326,
-0.088883318,
-0.0294221733,
-0.0078251129,
-0.0413449444,
-0.0259460956,
-0.0018534297,
0.0842431113,
0.002903278,
0.0367320776,
0.0066577494,
0.0141315795,
0.0455594361,
-0.078595832,
-0.0277857613,
-0.0623071305,
0.0005108786,
0.0134593137,
-0.0129909441,
-0.0407657847,
-0.0165477861,
0.0057981452,
0.0345665067,
-0.003087102,
0.0132304234,
0.0146846818,
0.0218663905,
0.0044345595,
0.0006938707,
-0.0379393324,
-0.0300435126,
-0.0088564157,
0.0236487947,
0.0614128821,
-0.0608526915,
0.0203418974,
-0.0156483315,
-0.0190691408,
-0.0139492191,
0.0010596041,
0.0504951887,
0.0072922674,
0.0287284944,
0.0235475414,
-0.0183848515,
0.0124902753,
0.0382934362,
0.0757177398,
0.0565750524,
-0.020706214,
-0.0246086121,
-0.0454092212,
0.0025167495,
0.0637085885,
0.0258505773,
-0.0221995879,
0.0006262874,
-0.073061727,
-0.0653441995,
0.0100372452,
-0.0111042177,
-0.0379437022,
0.0124927498,
0.026954066,
0.0426544137,
0.0032913303,
-0.0238452442,
-0.0592258088,
0.0050975708,
-0.009652663,
0.01519104,
-0.0404656641,
-5.938995292e-33,
-0.0128074689,
-0.0174739938,
0.0370049365,
0.0129381623,
0.0066721756,
0.0295832902,
0.0384083837,
-0.049579192,
-0.0418586209,
0.0030159338,
-0.0348969027,
0.008851856,
0.0109317731,
0.0222629979,
0.0160973761,
0.0271896571,
0.0559093989,
0.0157285184,
0.0031163783,
0.0180040896,
0.0293787289,
0.0397548042,
0.0833470225,
-0.0586612672,
0.014675756,
-0.0286459234,
0.0039778515,
0.0464044325,
0.0037421449,
0.0689658299,
-0.0287454296,
0.0465619937,
0.0319472589,
-0.0346903354,
0.0251032449,
-0.0181632061,
-0.0668031424,
-0.0075480649,
0.0257274788,
0.018576419,
0.0137616321,
-0.0120783346,
0.0035925994,
-0.0022807419,
-0.0039124815,
-0.0490721799,
0.0717699379,
-0.0083497986,
-0.012204228,
0.0155488616,
-0.0465068482,
0.0180983078,
-0.0137179755,
-0.0221603047,
0.0093991719,
-0.0042421073,
-0.0093563292,
0.0291319285,
-0.1035868227,
-0.0244219098,
-0.0263117794,
0.0067602196,
0.0232290626,
0.0209544078,
-0.015712956,
0.0623523816,
0.0308501087,
0.0634429306,
0.03636612,
0.0008703975,
-0.0069855675,
0.0617467351,
-0.0425402187,
0.023491824,
0.0341917872,
-0.0190923661,
-0.0384060293,
0.0189120248,
0.0129921325,
0.0158187989,
-0.0045528989,
-0.0094576105,
-0.0393926352,
-0.0309524834,
-0.0256023742,
-0.003784993,
-0.0164599884,
0.0170181096,
0.0537042022,
0.0361529775,
0.0236685481,
0.0397373475,
-0.0360197201,
-0.0502613708,
0.0040062312,
0.0527813025,
-0.0548503213,
-0.0382810645,
0.0007887494,
-0.0200058203,
-0.0648800507,
-0.0449518934,
0.0086368937,
0.0054785428,
0.0297323596,
0.0584064759,
0.0509520024,
0.0093667498,
-0.056098558,
-0.0009178455,
-0.0393375084,
0.0275786053,
-0.0613160394,
0.0186671019,
0.0388863534,
0.0182269793,
0.005032069,
0.0303417593,
0.0592233352,
-0.0215849914,
0.0146054169,
0.0064869607,
0.0532480739,
0.0215557832,
0.0298725311,
-0.0011441375,
0.005884775,
-0.0095697092,
0.0324875973,
-0.008057748,
0.0013570287,
-0.0017167745,
2.484e-7,
0.0616807528,
0.001145276,
-0.0059443437,
0.021510873,
0.0230172537,
0.0067312182,
-0.0268741101,
0.0233674608,
0.0283125527,
0.0245399773,
-0.0169024486,
0.0173558313,
0.0496677756,
-0.0056046313,
-0.082432732,
-0.0119498111,
-0.0086799534,
-0.0440880768,
-0.0468106419,
-0.0018308825,
0.0899447426,
0.0422727913,
0.059964709,
-0.0457188897,
-0.0365875624,
-0.0335643962,
0.0782819241,
0.0054955259,
-0.0212144759,
0.0435748063,
0.0110408058,
0.0295266863,
-0.0129166432,
0.0431901664,
-0.0041726176,
0.0509972982,
0.0727945715,
0.0715534538,
-0.0607476123,
0.0464946516,
-0.0146613149,
-0.017919071,
-0.0457739644,
-0.033574637,
0.0427769944,
-0.0330942273,
-0.0079662502,
-0.0103033921,
-0.0726551116,
0.0295878369,
-0.0152112106,
0.0267660934,
-0.0065253773,
-0.012319806,
0.0137386806,
-0.0066937953,
-0.0916407779,
-0.0314825736,
0.0205654856,
0.0202002805,
-0.0240254719,
-0.0432201363,
0.037498761,
0.0247148518,
0.0069861002,
-0.0602128953,
-0.0057427096,
2.128204512e-34,
0.0163764935,
0.0470631234,
0.016679164,
-0.0306464341,
0.042456679,
0.0095595689,
-0.0038771478,
0.0170666985,
-0.0298599396,
-0.0401802771,
-0.0105692279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06382v1 | Transfer Learning for Structured Pruning under Limited Task Data | 2023-11-10T20:23:35 | 2023-11-10T20:23:35 | Lucio Dery, David Grangier, Awni Hannun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large, pre-trained models are problematic to use in resource constrained
applications. Fortunately, task-aware structured pruning methods offer a
solution. These approaches reduce model size by dropping structural units like
layers and attention heads in a manner that takes into account the end-task.
However, these pruning algorithms require more task-specific data than is
typically available. We propose a framework which combines structured pruning
with transfer learning to reduce the need for task-specific data. Our empirical
results answer questions such as: How should the two tasks be coupled? What
parameters should be transferred? And, when during training should transfer
learning be introduced? Leveraging these insights, we demonstrate that our
framework results in pruned models with improved generalization over strong
baselines. | [
-0.0276645031,
0.05106299,
0.0095625268,
0.0363356397,
-0.0054308316,
0.0086002899,
0.0194389429,
0.0040151468,
-0.0344002284,
0.0017527781,
-0.062473584,
-0.0084135253,
-0.0224543251,
0.0184370708,
-0.0140206879,
-0.0990288705,
0.0159847774,
-0.0051096915,
0.0428447835,
0.0246955939,
0.0033383528,
0.0070913057,
0.0207390804,
-0.0006349748,
-0.0243235473,
-0.018619759,
-0.0038008341,
0.048330646,
0.0125676962,
0.007582475,
0.0352547765,
0.0442637764,
0.0274139754,
-0.027156176,
0.0000021065,
0.0007487357,
-0.0334414504,
-0.0086792158,
-0.0425382927,
0.026300868,
0.0174593348,
-0.0213530716,
-0.0249423236,
-0.0235164259,
-0.0126728909,
-0.0483136289,
0.0240614638,
0.067732282,
0.0739137158,
0.0991785899,
-0.0121925594,
0.0102717988,
-0.017284045,
-0.0538397953,
-0.0015550867,
-0.0268222969,
0.0390660912,
-0.0208759997,
-0.0471023507,
-0.0052900547,
-0.001651832,
0.0123553509,
0.0418496877,
0.0278271493,
0.0170965157,
0.0099138943,
-0.0424352549,
0.0024085671,
0.0102178678,
0.061746262,
-0.0554837026,
-0.0257027019,
0.0401052944,
-0.0587289482,
0.0017240661,
-0.0734870359,
-0.0542484149,
-0.0286739245,
0.0170517415,
0.0339566059,
-0.0723404139,
0.009226881,
0.038493298,
-0.0296830144,
-0.0008674693,
0.0226316806,
-0.0033774015,
0.0221332945,
0.0297153741,
0.0163292568,
0.0190990139,
-0.0367777459,
0.0105129546,
0.0299862009,
-0.0115415445,
-0.0254823193,
-0.0864676312,
-0.0162988566,
-0.0399829485,
0.0100944927,
0.0539967269,
0.0003993516,
-0.0008815004,
0.0649676993,
-0.0253863037,
-0.0018928307,
-0.0084295804,
0.0230217092,
-0.0461790897,
-0.0068931412,
-0.0508865714,
0.0212275703,
-0.0370532721,
0.0399344563,
-0.0200099181,
-0.0123292757,
-0.017695222,
-0.0025265859,
-0.0341262408,
-0.0469820052,
0.0553069562,
0.0302060079,
-0.0580297709,
-0.0130297188,
0.0123679442,
0.0274136681,
-0.0106294826,
0.0242263824,
0.0088334894,
-0.0413601622,
-0.0524641424,
0.0463488102,
0.0092586447,
-0.0546458066,
0.0205776226,
0.0335918665,
-0.0343766212,
-0.0256853867,
-0.037779741,
0.0128839239,
0.0010109992,
-0.0496679023,
0.0583709478,
-0.0365825482,
0.0534502082,
-0.061641138,
0.0210909378,
-0.0613533407,
-0.0050286092,
0.0072169346,
-0.0483025387,
0.0309148487,
0.0188135076,
0.0265339725,
-0.0003266366,
-0.0044356762,
-0.0218914878,
0.0570610091,
0.0251450874,
0.047654327,
-0.0163149145,
-0.0510956086,
-0.0350765847,
0.0424924009,
0.0553806536,
-0.0071260477,
-0.0196987167,
-0.0000883321,
-0.0351583809,
-0.0235317796,
0.0663843676,
0.0272502489,
-0.0302922297,
-0.00578631,
0.034375824,
-0.0150304278,
0.0193459988,
0.0347049907,
0.0467652045,
0.0139503479,
-0.0164638888,
0.0124957347,
-0.0696033314,
0.0244777035,
0.0138245486,
-0.0280013811,
-0.0389925018,
-0.0043942807,
-0.0710772499,
-0.0151285343,
0.0382251181,
-0.0149340024,
-0.0101727899,
0.0378500409,
0.0706695095,
0.0522010028,
-0.0332898311,
0.063722685,
0.01744744,
-0.0227533933,
0.0106898537,
-0.004061094,
-0.0260672085,
0.0072002904,
-0.0110354573,
-0.0476430207,
-0.0064275535,
0.039197471,
0.0873812065,
-0.0428636,
0.0254531968,
-0.0038579365,
0.0811755136,
-0.018670287,
-0.0040860921,
-0.0341662355,
0.0266603548,
-0.021493163,
0.0349325761,
0.0089620398,
0.0296287145,
-0.0332099907,
-0.0039698672,
0.0306313392,
-0.0189541206,
-0.0326636583,
0.0280792378,
0.0100586526,
0.0043508359,
-0.0271670297,
-0.0179216266,
-0.0009767199,
0.0540634133,
-0.0389614254,
0.0488618203,
-0.0523472056,
-0.0591303483,
-0.0252450332,
0.0215680506,
-0.0136591634,
-0.0068332162,
0.0781544149,
-0.0586608201,
-0.0187566057,
0.0039663296,
-0.0095537538,
0.0234154183,
0.0047581261,
0.0060643745,
0.0202253144,
0.0304808002,
0.0101529462,
0.028964173,
0.0176154319,
-0.0350640863,
0.0150725869,
-0.0948950127,
-0.01898003,
-0.0837444142,
0.0104440209,
-0.0234263632,
-0.0359569974,
-0.0245438553,
-0.0123258876,
0.012889158,
-0.030589195,
0.0396143906,
-0.0400089659,
0.0266559944,
-0.0349988267,
0.0411514454,
0.013663237,
0.0304085519,
-0.0018989104,
-0.0574919954,
0.0093332557,
0.0304449759,
-0.0013281344,
0.0058403113,
0.0114128273,
-0.0258461274,
-0.0040905476,
-0.0238344725,
-0.0178725366,
0.0447981581,
0.0183133762,
-0.0374823883,
-0.0749612153,
-0.0082323318,
0.0858990252,
-0.001577393,
0.0250764731,
-0.0099651413,
0.0229037311,
-0.0333829448,
-0.0334349722,
-0.0288011543,
0.109570615,
-0.03711823,
0.0344611816,
0.0177145954,
-0.0322247781,
-0.0091265645,
0.0248490591,
-0.0091990698,
0.0404243581,
-0.0221241862,
-0.021943232,
0.0311800651,
0.0612499677,
-0.031142598,
0.0259163585,
-0.0357115269,
0.0040160329,
0.0177648384,
-0.0239107218,
-0.0283465497,
0.0389220342,
-0.0008422903,
-0.009946866,
-0.0320834443,
-0.02593817,
0.0075571877,
-0.0082599018,
-0.0051318612,
0.0110514564,
-0.0279480498,
-0.0100754406,
0.0448922664,
0.0539160669,
-0.0031990986,
-0.0006783544,
0.0195245501,
-0.0892372504,
0.0027884718,
0.0082928026,
0.0262468122,
0.0024285777,
-0.0693201274,
0.0046127108,
-0.0384433642,
-0.0300550926,
-0.012558043,
0.0131643638,
-0.0203230456,
0.0450279154,
0.0120118707,
0.0020574415,
-0.0442588218,
-0.0115652699,
0.0003634087,
0.0529496744,
0.0235998929,
0.0270846747,
-0.0015342869,
0.0376666449,
0.0485019051,
0.0000288155,
0.0190696046,
-0.0296476558,
0.0054959911,
0.0686530396,
0.0631190166,
-0.0001740187,
-0.0401815437,
-0.0101116896,
0.0239831563,
-0.0027860235,
-0.0161784422,
0.0156618375,
0.0862802789,
-0.0703389198,
-0.016002655,
0.0278226417,
-0.026548408,
-0.024123013,
-0.0023218608,
0.0432610326,
0.0334429368,
-0.0197436176,
0.0506122373,
0.0072626299,
-0.0427209847,
0.0213447213,
-0.0030831015,
0.0489489958,
-0.0125274556,
-0.0331306271,
-0.1005512848,
0.0448400229,
0.0049241376,
-0.0557120219,
0.0117685664,
-0.0026614112,
0.0465152264,
-0.0345593505,
-0.0301559605,
-0.0157379061,
-0.0186116192,
-0.004741156,
0.0179944988,
-0.0346058309,
-0.0253740139,
0.0039016041,
-0.0189050566,
-0.0030910424,
0.0512789339,
0.0240843166,
-0.0054447246,
-0.0254647732,
0.0625529736,
0.0296960045,
-0.0267610289,
-0.0125079574,
0.0751576647,
-0.0042068847,
0.0030218107,
-0.0032650805,
0.0439845286,
-0.0437881835,
-0.0225603506,
0.0355647616,
0.0786775723,
0.0265506618,
-0.0477557294,
-0.0133608496,
-0.0370272808,
0.0265912917,
0.0489974618,
0.0333735347,
-0.028667571,
-0.0727251992,
0.0059072203,
-0.0345848389,
-0.0535009764,
-0.0044093328,
0.0131228222,
-0.0280721467,
-0.028535258,
-0.0428641178,
-0.0055466853,
0.0632097498,
0.0299841817,
-0.0261391923,
-0.0260459203,
0.0010331564,
0.0137793822,
-0.0543824099,
0.0384371355,
-0.0448240936,
0.0140344948,
-0.0361435898,
-0.029110821,
-0.0342632085,
0.0028677355,
-0.0038926711,
-0.039101053,
-0.137016654,
-0.0096145635,
-0.0298617519,
0.0813749284,
0.0101869125,
0.0763851926,
-0.026724847,
0.0061515886,
0.0148065919,
-0.0031475085,
-0.0652385205,
0.0352643803,
0.0539658554,
-0.0804549307,
-0.0114486022,
0.0612703077,
-0.0517210476,
0.060327895,
0.0715020001,
-0.0045117014,
-0.0062540979,
0.0013615963,
-0.0238399003,
-0.0086479299,
0.056499552,
0.0450379252,
-0.0212330259,
-0.0159517862,
0.0392324626,
0.033368282,
-0.0055676885,
-0.075964503,
0.0145011852,
-0.0111593977,
0.0580149628,
-0.0036837028,
0.0326619633,
0.0309649669,
0.0163293928,
-0.0694446191,
-0.0072868709,
0.0404360518,
-0.019971462,
0.0371904895,
-0.008013797,
0.0161670744,
0.031001322,
0.0274629649,
0.0183970649,
-0.0091033764,
-0.0504796393,
0.0229509789,
0.0560481548,
-0.0457267016,
0.0116088763,
-0.0202191602,
-0.0925337598,
-0.0558303595,
-0.0186740626,
-0.002185419,
-0.046504911,
0.0491195917,
0.0344432704,
-0.017791247,
-0.0585888252,
0.0441654325,
0.0255890768,
0.0006874865,
-0.0242490713,
-0.0076098959,
0.0160965994,
-0.0028797847,
0.08734373,
0.0343696065,
0.0341732837,
0.0029529056,
-0.0214085169,
-0.0508141108,
-0.0389406681,
-0.023328105,
0.0051634698,
0.012471783,
0.0141854817,
0.0090182526,
-0.0579491816,
0.0011000679,
-0.0557187721,
-0.0000574417,
-0.0076044519,
0.0630735978,
0.012311304,
-0.0175232347,
-0.0122740846,
0.0178028885,
-0.0446012467,
-0.0070513878,
-0.0355744362,
-0.0049767676,
-6.140450779e-33,
-0.0173467658,
0.021610152,
0.0218209978,
-0.0012630804,
-0.0365418904,
0.0122702969,
-0.0612141751,
-0.0443832688,
0.0001164373,
0.0177410562,
-0.0136044761,
0.0119052278,
0.010508622,
0.0349958092,
-0.0208426658,
-0.0016606,
0.0772344023,
0.0022451833,
-0.0337965153,
0.0572549142,
0.0050871889,
0.0550194383,
0.0700562745,
-0.0173146222,
-0.0755781531,
0.0555203222,
-0.0129669653,
0.0106746182,
0.012874594,
0.0092268297,
0.0202544685,
-0.0125760008,
0.0202891752,
-0.0292659141,
-0.0171970017,
0.0737454072,
-0.0856021121,
-0.0160899144,
-0.0150227481,
0.0044186506,
-0.046913892,
-0.0117935948,
0.0206841417,
0.0083247935,
0.0589002147,
-0.0390640274,
0.040364828,
-0.0317132361,
-0.0177711472,
-0.0601417944,
-0.0340546891,
0.0218691286,
-0.0066764685,
-0.0391995348,
0.0222528297,
0.0520484373,
-0.029652793,
0.0152236195,
-0.0462526456,
-0.0179160591,
-0.0122890519,
0.0483382232,
0.0329252183,
0.0410168096,
-0.0288661551,
0.0455554314,
0.0038700989,
0.0035283156,
-0.0187268481,
0.0145305116,
0.0159766134,
0.08974161,
0.005553687,
-0.0020090358,
0.0242278967,
-0.004557177,
-0.0941998884,
-0.0010356535,
-0.0172127429,
0.0587061979,
-0.0058931261,
0.0468195453,
0.0549210459,
-0.0342377722,
0.0442606881,
-0.0214275084,
0.0007369747,
-0.0096800663,
0.0232160073,
0.0356958397,
-0.0599161424,
0.0236466601,
0.0437274054,
-0.0240446832,
0.0167111494,
0.0158858206,
-0.008311267,
-0.0186041165,
0.0301260501,
-0.005978548,
-0.0808205605,
-0.0185289551,
0.0266329627,
-0.0374742635,
0.0319488458,
-0.0109447539,
0.0504303463,
0.0216564983,
-0.0118255718,
-0.0264706369,
-0.046175763,
0.0324777216,
0.0363374837,
0.1373544037,
0.0257827081,
0.0204570647,
-0.0037757566,
0.0523875244,
0.0194657836,
-0.0534575358,
-0.0293252803,
0.0415704548,
0.0372116528,
0.0124010071,
-0.0127696088,
-0.0157121215,
-0.0333066247,
-0.0152826086,
0.0354907773,
-0.0600242652,
-0.0323217362,
0.0240228157,
2.639e-7,
0.0089682834,
-0.0343771428,
-0.0323062614,
-0.0229744446,
0.0163542815,
0.007677089,
-0.0152465124,
0.0130438646,
-0.0255981926,
-0.0366851278,
0.0144163379,
0.0315107182,
0.0830453932,
0.0197118875,
-0.0841935873,
-0.0088409903,
-0.0438600294,
-0.0029194274,
-0.0164356045,
-0.0685919449,
-0.0586575493,
0.0704336762,
0.031898763,
-0.0168047082,
0.019597996,
-0.002619677,
0.0258460101,
-0.0371883251,
0.0446927436,
-0.007076147,
-0.0290738307,
-0.0275472682,
-0.0541552678,
0.0283808354,
-0.0090571092,
0.0004347782,
0.0429573581,
0.092536822,
0.013510406,
0.0164116398,
-0.0036005245,
0.0506800525,
0.025698293,
0.0185311865,
0.0806009322,
-0.0662299618,
0.0203617904,
-0.0134336883,
-0.0141356327,
0.0195559077,
-0.0368636698,
0.0110934824,
0.0318334438,
-0.0018348097,
0.0366465189,
-0.0194874927,
-0.0517486371,
-0.04794503,
-0.0191496145,
0.0019720362,
-0.0532976054,
-0.026712874,
-0.0444070622,
-0.026996782,
-0.0017994866,
-0.0428742394,
0.0049985228,
2.137910606e-34,
-0.008115056,
0.0132991653,
-0.0131597454,
0.0124966213,
0.0103145987,
-0.0143318698,
-0.029609235,
-0.0089878002,
-0.0040203566,
-0.0169709902,
-0.0108732097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06379v1 | DeMuX: Data-efficient Multilingual Learning | 2023-11-10T20:09:08 | 2023-11-10T20:09:08 | Simran Khanuja, Srinivas Gowriraj, Lucio Dery, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the task of optimally fine-tuning pre-trained multilingual
models, given small amounts of unlabelled target data and an annotation budget.
In this paper, we introduce DEMUX, a framework that prescribes the exact
data-points to label from vast amounts of unlabelled multilingual data, having
unknown degrees of overlap with the target set. Unlike most prior works, our
end-to-end framework is language-agnostic, accounts for model representations,
and supports multilingual target configurations. Our active learning strategies
rely upon distance and uncertainty measures to select task-specific neighbors
that are most informative to label, given a model. DeMuX outperforms strong
baselines in 84% of the test cases, in the zero-shot setting of disjoint source
and target language sets (including multilingual target pools), across three
models and four tasks. Notably, in low-budget settings (5-100 examples), we
observe gains of up to 8-11 F1 points for token-level tasks, and 2-5 F1 for
complex tasks. Our code is released here:
https://github.com/simran-khanuja/demux. | [
-0.0033984573,
0.0570528395,
0.0061206869,
0.0321643427,
-0.0137686674,
0.0514163077,
0.030261416,
-0.0336584039,
-0.029650677,
-0.0608456843,
-0.0847265273,
-0.0202051345,
-0.0290522296,
-0.0118481442,
0.046027258,
-0.037533924,
0.0492894202,
-0.037434753,
0.0042092348,
-0.0180031452,
-0.0032645995,
0.0344523489,
-0.0313785188,
0.0233986825,
-0.0290104765,
-0.0161823854,
0.0219351184,
0.0122338422,
-0.0006914239,
-0.0254745651,
0.0276623629,
0.0661759004,
-0.0107825631,
0.0399018489,
0.0000022394,
-0.0423463136,
-0.0225332696,
-0.0153521812,
-0.0176728908,
-0.0404932536,
0.0138475178,
-0.0376776718,
0.0162443947,
-0.0221853647,
0.0004959672,
-0.0451500118,
0.0831597671,
0.0134214377,
0.0307882503,
0.071112439,
-0.0207876842,
-0.0265323836,
-0.0244528819,
-0.0422046632,
-0.0034141585,
-0.0760963336,
-0.0020101478,
0.0114882365,
-0.0649917498,
0.0087922961,
0.0061607589,
0.0375019573,
-0.0048114937,
0.0163092241,
-0.0179381799,
0.0031483797,
0.0101502575,
-0.069533661,
0.0040749409,
0.0790865347,
-0.0739192963,
-0.0211775526,
-0.0164260101,
-0.0414285064,
0.0050682914,
-0.0509674139,
-0.0182866193,
-0.0033485768,
-0.0029738524,
-0.0087627023,
0.0070919143,
-0.0130215939,
0.0583810285,
0.0096345861,
0.0075086528,
0.0074111214,
-0.0021030894,
0.00600575,
0.0591910332,
0.0336215645,
-0.0217680354,
-0.0471383296,
-0.0178152956,
0.0040756497,
-0.0734870955,
0.0129778013,
-0.016975427,
-0.0694475174,
0.0156241022,
-0.0321270712,
0.0486286655,
0.0401858836,
-0.0390147306,
0.0541159436,
0.0079863705,
-0.0247373506,
0.0011977814,
0.0358777419,
-0.0316166393,
-0.0522044599,
-0.0177250486,
0.0284384079,
-0.0477803573,
0.0037961444,
-0.014985715,
0.0044412138,
-0.0103559652,
0.015685441,
-0.0353518389,
-0.0055843014,
0.0092459274,
-0.0412123315,
-0.0459856093,
-0.0071953456,
0.0388582908,
0.0385657735,
-0.059313979,
0.0173262246,
-0.0004319799,
-0.0493695289,
-0.013980302,
0.0344072878,
0.0044751344,
-0.0764185488,
0.0337146223,
0.0981513038,
-0.0266638584,
-0.0453543141,
-0.0238519441,
0.0087932199,
0.0226143058,
-0.0610062853,
-0.0020426023,
-0.0625450164,
0.0432571657,
0.0155055448,
0.0415191203,
-0.064710848,
-0.0180475973,
-0.0110625289,
-0.0240490306,
0.0848437473,
0.0027045421,
-0.0031856601,
-0.0016830033,
-0.0322088897,
-0.042886842,
0.1099713668,
0.0111996252,
0.012820784,
0.0742903501,
0.0088984389,
-0.0187620837,
0.0580141693,
0.0299887545,
0.0413042791,
0.0157937855,
0.0053786016,
0.0412188135,
-0.0193802156,
0.0026834318,
-0.0437829979,
-0.0255825892,
0.0370949768,
0.0443599038,
-0.0001683709,
-0.0151206823,
0.0032645613,
0.0299958196,
-0.0005545983,
-0.0123380749,
-0.0432917178,
-0.0248780251,
0.0232098792,
-0.0098155672,
-0.0154460305,
0.0174329244,
0.0520670973,
-0.0407112204,
-0.035474062,
-0.0118190544,
-0.0442992933,
-0.0176379848,
0.0415529273,
0.0602538101,
0.0265802145,
-0.0024568217,
0.0752304271,
0.0617725588,
-0.0206380468,
-0.0041599842,
-0.0087715285,
-0.0265987366,
-0.0124123432,
-0.026669804,
-0.0681600943,
-0.0740319937,
-0.0233324077,
0.0697750673,
0.015380769,
0.0440792739,
-0.0242904127,
0.0799376443,
-0.0389573239,
-0.0506211817,
-0.0196739286,
0.0149935754,
0.0509980321,
0.0168564599,
0.0171629339,
-0.0203888584,
-0.047894448,
-0.0352222398,
0.0324222706,
-0.0129470779,
-0.014799471,
0.0249643791,
0.0326172821,
0.0083131753,
0.0051628854,
0.0028234341,
-0.0203506164,
-0.0054437597,
-0.0262082573,
0.0170320738,
0.0000589008,
0.0037086657,
-0.0010102054,
0.0483272672,
0.0059388466,
-0.0453924313,
0.0156037547,
-0.0684042498,
-0.0185726266,
-0.0041011851,
-0.0284990855,
-0.0365227498,
-0.0161743499,
0.0011136163,
-0.0275682583,
0.0040295338,
-0.0422329307,
0.0487331152,
0.0024069599,
0.0274341628,
0.0240003765,
-0.0034540945,
0.0356110334,
-0.0069779623,
-0.0285676997,
0.0160506293,
-0.0040285531,
0.0021223356,
0.0556354113,
0.0673565045,
-0.0129678175,
-0.0107785705,
-0.0456003584,
0.0137487603,
-0.0484729111,
0.0021454752,
0.0166418608,
0.0242594685,
-0.0030700755,
-0.0604238808,
-0.0289288126,
0.0114898263,
-0.0192252342,
0.0286129601,
0.0163069218,
0.0155621711,
0.0351396129,
-0.0257574823,
-0.0140033932,
0.034477219,
0.0385322832,
-0.0042888727,
-0.0328843072,
-0.0309610181,
0.0134017011,
-0.0443314873,
0.0122577595,
0.0120037543,
-0.0067623928,
-0.018566424,
-0.0036215181,
-0.0064975913,
0.0287868306,
-0.0345185474,
0.0202179067,
0.0337560512,
-0.0005129284,
-0.0394870788,
0.0361707732,
-0.025538668,
-0.0119413538,
-0.0752376989,
-0.0039517838,
-0.0086354557,
0.0614577085,
-0.0367228203,
-0.0318352208,
-0.0473536737,
0.0074474216,
-0.0156535152,
-0.0470262878,
-0.0554524064,
0.0674279779,
0.0044525829,
0.0211422816,
-0.0350307152,
-0.0509466641,
0.0643341169,
-0.0027889395,
-0.0134425079,
-0.0618789829,
-0.0066525522,
-0.0043491786,
0.0306465775,
-0.0000183172,
0.0461604372,
-0.0246104654,
-0.0109590758,
-0.0573322512,
0.0178276263,
0.0318007506,
0.0104965214,
0.0315783359,
-0.0251826327,
-0.0031472207,
-0.0188686606,
-0.0620192848,
-0.0217601992,
-0.0055793831,
-0.0213630386,
0.0115834912,
-0.0017978281,
-0.0141900117,
-0.0532378666,
-0.0039698044,
0.0275431424,
0.0747341067,
-0.0023012657,
0.0165448412,
-0.0202596262,
-0.0243124198,
0.0598234348,
-0.0022772779,
-0.0023379689,
-0.0341001377,
-0.0106431609,
0.0216261968,
0.0236824583,
-0.0337796547,
0.0177181922,
0.0072224061,
0.0848649442,
0.0003410674,
-0.0223245397,
-0.0070154932,
0.0711053088,
0.0035173725,
-0.0120750424,
0.1106299311,
0.0023102658,
-0.0628207102,
-0.0016505539,
-0.0188378617,
0.0314632468,
0.0473514982,
0.0331122726,
-0.0683180988,
-0.0601365604,
-0.0013025809,
-0.0028585573,
0.0409728624,
-0.0158642437,
-0.0129256081,
-0.0970173553,
0.0037108799,
-0.0003575332,
-0.0898853466,
0.0101929959,
-0.0445078388,
-0.004831248,
-0.03764778,
0.0118816579,
-0.0612254143,
0.0447105505,
-0.0127290888,
0.0212238375,
-0.0029990778,
-0.0685727149,
0.0172032006,
-0.0325881578,
0.0112540815,
0.02326601,
0.0514943525,
0.0047665476,
0.0053065252,
0.057209298,
-0.01705328,
-0.0202799421,
-0.0297774114,
0.0421493649,
-0.0122817773,
-0.0339363366,
0.0587298647,
0.015421371,
-0.0263553765,
-0.0146125788,
0.0058059529,
0.0630008653,
-0.005945208,
0.0631407574,
0.0333095193,
-0.05407634,
0.0560679212,
0.0383398011,
0.0062966212,
-0.0537593588,
0.0039468524,
-0.0095456978,
0.0248811636,
-0.0586522147,
-0.0038627705,
0.0327995904,
-0.0727846697,
-0.0767404661,
-0.0393899269,
-0.075453952,
0.0507891364,
0.0734206364,
0.0139223132,
0.0044629546,
-0.0237495303,
0.0119489999,
-0.033211939,
0.0424242914,
-0.0346094221,
0.0333616771,
-0.0582731329,
-0.0581845269,
0.0079649705,
-0.0207127146,
-0.0130498754,
0.0340460092,
-0.0827754736,
-0.0638040453,
-0.0174365006,
0.0751355216,
0.0100281173,
0.0581002533,
-0.0296091437,
-0.0720878467,
0.0079104807,
0.0021027306,
-0.0232065935,
-0.0133610936,
0.0706777871,
-0.0352058262,
-0.0167935751,
0.0557262376,
-0.0704265535,
0.0356561095,
0.0620865636,
0.0307844263,
-0.0316930227,
-0.0116667422,
0.000428404,
0.0061337301,
0.094351992,
-0.0409559235,
-0.0293793045,
-0.0570210814,
0.0090143057,
0.0139162624,
-0.0570246503,
-0.0369066,
0.0120633347,
0.0133648524,
-0.0017510493,
-0.0052900608,
0.0257093795,
0.0362786688,
0.0216263663,
-0.0314499401,
-0.0039466852,
0.0180164296,
0.0325394981,
0.0036326181,
0.0390412435,
-0.0099048652,
0.033254452,
0.0227404609,
0.0225409921,
-0.0200406425,
0.0273491163,
0.0282580499,
0.0137888929,
-0.0164599456,
0.0294275004,
-0.0115172435,
-0.0384780169,
-0.041198995,
0.0126462383,
0.0825158209,
-0.0154892551,
0.0897281468,
-0.0230153557,
-0.0328059085,
-0.013162965,
0.0241622012,
0.0272190832,
-0.0495300181,
0.0010550664,
0.0112957535,
-0.0112989694,
-0.0087314295,
0.1008422226,
-0.0199289396,
0.0458245352,
-0.0029852244,
0.0136422347,
-0.0325042009,
-0.0160669275,
0.0187806748,
0.0248561557,
-0.0084950393,
0.0342050232,
-0.0140354885,
-0.0688547269,
0.0066064638,
-0.0287982244,
-0.0529207736,
0.0297480971,
0.0423295312,
0.0711326227,
-0.0052040531,
0.015282196,
-0.0550583228,
-0.0136183454,
0.040669214,
0.0117452778,
0.0294156931,
-6.263604751e-33,
0.0026640806,
0.0062559061,
-0.0137015712,
-0.0319351181,
0.0215954613,
0.011815994,
-0.0187232494,
0.0094011389,
-0.0195323005,
0.0147891399,
0.0294362977,
-0.0140984403,
0.0332397148,
0.0357392915,
0.0003558426,
-0.0143690854,
0.0432900302,
0.0040519349,
-0.0189069696,
0.0226017367,
0.0476141647,
0.0295209642,
0.1055738777,
-0.0574257821,
0.0323908478,
-0.0040946291,
-0.0027892883,
0.0361063443,
0.0343147591,
0.0475433543,
0.0151901674,
0.0542054586,
0.0026246824,
-0.0314436816,
-0.0213403553,
-0.05267727,
-0.0939896032,
-0.0330036022,
-0.0173024964,
0.0775154307,
-0.0179172028,
-0.0208162479,
-0.0186308715,
-0.0074014897,
0.0201563966,
-0.0068862801,
0.0349030606,
-0.0334925056,
-0.0179576911,
-0.0095219472,
-0.0648001507,
0.0200960059,
-0.0089855725,
-0.0083026262,
0.045137763,
0.0748769641,
0.0192398485,
-0.0026498688,
-0.0681692213,
-0.002346585,
-0.0541602857,
0.0310899243,
0.0693810284,
0.038399078,
0.0099301906,
0.0409717187,
0.0499309264,
0.00967097,
0.0513589196,
0.0263660736,
0.021525301,
0.0178139322,
0.0153017025,
0.0696976334,
0.0155206565,
-0.0108937249,
-0.0986630023,
0.0125811324,
0.0185665321,
-0.0028587065,
0.0107290195,
0.005042789,
-0.007649214,
-0.0309590325,
-0.0350951813,
-0.0006021961,
-0.0425461903,
-0.0148716504,
0.0222709477,
0.0069838865,
-0.0190219861,
0.0443849117,
0.0490431525,
0.0112810209,
-0.0317037441,
0.0280414913,
0.0004120292,
0.0187151823,
-0.004359799,
0.0206327755,
-0.0169890858,
-0.0800814927,
-0.0056613204,
-0.0176812112,
0.0347420946,
0.0235132296,
0.0971135199,
0.0189348403,
-0.0468818694,
0.0094640637,
-0.0282503609,
0.0112961279,
0.0118268281,
0.0619981326,
0.0191025026,
-0.0154377948,
-0.0237485878,
0.0898794681,
0.0622480661,
-0.0319838598,
0.0127111822,
-0.0384964794,
-0.0183842573,
0.0148815699,
-0.0221741926,
-0.0354383998,
-0.0369709544,
-0.0477966443,
0.007843446,
-0.0682156682,
-0.0158024821,
-0.0012961025,
2.817e-7,
0.0493040383,
0.0420316346,
-0.0143581294,
0.0240239482,
0.0012412887,
0.041173894,
-0.0286638718,
0.0026980846,
-0.0067529571,
0.0150794825,
-0.0268094502,
0.0183377285,
0.0514966957,
0.0521393046,
-0.0782831237,
0.0009032497,
-0.0479890108,
0.0170082077,
-0.0343837552,
0.0238758251,
-0.0188857242,
0.111520417,
0.0051823235,
0.0027334194,
-0.0088718226,
-0.0362391919,
0.0474946536,
-0.0521083251,
-0.0160652418,
0.0223397687,
0.0205751676,
-0.0010294472,
-0.0108251721,
0.0154290069,
-0.0389855728,
-0.0089229085,
0.0603942387,
0.0523339398,
-0.0171781126,
-0.0172464997,
-0.0133461868,
-0.0066035138,
-0.0138474395,
-0.0058856243,
0.064339146,
-0.0332956426,
-0.0265265517,
0.0049090134,
0.0184309594,
0.0261931196,
0.0509455502,
-0.0390850194,
-0.0308715142,
0.0233753789,
0.0324187912,
0.001209614,
-0.0282594152,
-0.0468392111,
-0.0403603278,
0.0219379254,
0.010247211,
-0.0262523815,
0.0096019758,
-0.017716296,
0.0136472797,
-0.0381024443,
0.0276838187,
2.278867302e-34,
0.0248500295,
-0.0075831697,
0.0118052093,
0.0024628269,
0.0026655698,
-0.0347172543,
-0.0265174173,
-0.0030962245,
0.0067409296,
-0.0001220593,
0.0006942554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06377v1 | Heaps' Law in GPT-Neo Large Language Model Emulated Corpora | 2023-11-10T20:07:32 | 2023-11-10T20:07:32 | Uyen Lai, Gurjit S. Randhawa, Paul Sheridan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Heaps' law is an empirical relation in text analysis that predicts vocabulary
growth as a function of corpus size. While this law has been validated in
diverse human-authored text corpora, its applicability to large language model
generated text remains unexplored. This study addresses this gap, focusing on
the emulation of corpora using the suite of GPT-Neo large language models. To
conduct our investigation, we emulated corpora of PubMed abstracts using three
different parameter sizes of the GPT-Neo model. Our emulation strategy involved
using the initial five words of each PubMed abstract as a prompt and
instructing the model to expand the content up to the original abstract's
length. Our findings indicate that the generated corpora adhere to Heaps' law.
Interestingly, as the GPT-Neo model size grows, its generated vocabulary
increasingly adheres to Heaps' law as as observed in human-authored text. To
further improve the richness and authenticity of GPT-Neo outputs, future
iterations could emphasize enhancing model size or refining the model
architecture to curtail vocabulary repetition. | [
0.063237831,
0.0483589359,
-0.0209061634,
0.0096021527,
-0.025163671,
-0.0103018526,
-0.0024978125,
0.0399086103,
-0.0286834035,
-0.0159798171,
-0.000434052,
-0.0427707508,
-0.0042096814,
0.0308366921,
0.0714307651,
-0.0351438038,
0.0210044719,
-0.01001566,
0.0102283414,
-0.0018692134,
0.0211115479,
0.0007706886,
0.0420538783,
0.0114468345,
0.0545078143,
-0.0196802281,
0.0020890397,
-0.0048617735,
-0.0005490148,
-0.0323954746,
-0.0128820231,
0.0654925182,
0.0273956452,
0.0859981999,
0.0000017913,
-0.0540525503,
0.0008307107,
0.0593668632,
0.0121235913,
0.0572407171,
0.1018509194,
-0.0175445769,
-0.0193155482,
0.0180399325,
-0.0046227272,
-0.0269872751,
0.0274371915,
0.0188379139,
0.0205068812,
0.0590134859,
-0.02101635,
-0.0122293029,
0.0761651546,
-0.040815983,
-0.0079839882,
-0.0060308017,
0.0394025669,
0.0353555195,
0.0529016182,
0.0613969155,
0.0050187623,
0.0199629925,
-0.007145877,
0.0112322429,
0.0211424753,
0.0547849908,
-0.0291000437,
-0.0045664045,
0.0088962326,
0.0212631505,
0.0040234067,
-0.0551834181,
0.0387642682,
0.0012510091,
-0.014118758,
0.0326960981,
-0.0607928932,
0.0158738084,
-0.0168890227,
0.0140209552,
0.0028241812,
-0.0045474847,
0.0241466202,
0.0283653736,
-0.0502619781,
-0.0039151716,
0.0260925498,
-0.0632916689,
0.0042129364,
-0.0184669755,
-0.0238764826,
-0.0354203358,
0.0112112323,
-0.0002245793,
0.007846524,
0.0247499608,
0.0002837836,
-0.0633479282,
0.1038633883,
-0.0794953629,
0.0201622415,
-0.0387893841,
0.0153848743,
0.0258356035,
0.018942317,
-0.0035461893,
-0.0290434081,
0.0011423634,
-0.0254047569,
0.0123505294,
-0.033958964,
-0.0224586539,
-0.0270163175,
0.014776431,
0.0104000457,
-0.0299330167,
-0.0617174655,
-0.0037663719,
0.0395321921,
-0.0200791769,
0.0055721635,
-0.0000670154,
-0.0426350273,
0.0084061855,
-0.0017164085,
0.0128405457,
-0.032845743,
0.0126124416,
-0.0207189564,
-0.032377772,
-0.0271246154,
0.0105787367,
-0.0063762642,
-0.0469828323,
0.01208637,
0.0270494893,
0.0040613324,
-0.0398280136,
0.0281576235,
-0.0021543477,
-0.018109465,
-0.0655054525,
0.0017166425,
-0.090726167,
0.0323516913,
0.0141101247,
-0.0104208617,
0.0043677595,
-0.0108233551,
0.036946401,
-0.073951833,
0.0413786285,
-0.0550974719,
-0.0020918385,
0.021377651,
-0.0068484936,
0.0486032739,
0.0308901016,
0.0546233989,
-0.0129054105,
0.040097367,
-0.0355570801,
-0.0147278812,
0.02037392,
0.0311471019,
0.0178327058,
-0.0107873091,
-0.0071421373,
-0.0112575945,
0.059320908,
0.0187871046,
0.0680721775,
-0.0257002097,
-0.022782525,
0.0367377251,
0.1080745757,
0.0206796397,
0.0641832128,
0.001994079,
0.0086843092,
0.0346924327,
0.0051721223,
0.0008675857,
-0.0302651022,
-0.0008776141,
0.0210583359,
0.036674358,
0.0563265905,
0.0021130184,
0.0137591138,
-0.0204766057,
-0.0009573175,
0.0032175719,
-0.0785595849,
0.0537558459,
-0.0284714084,
-0.0094328318,
0.0246695504,
0.0416579805,
-0.057602074,
0.0245879572,
-0.021344902,
0.0221083947,
0.0451200604,
0.0853562206,
-0.0293345675,
-0.0014940801,
-0.0109574702,
-0.0495949946,
0.0849333405,
-0.0096412394,
0.0081263371,
-0.0413302444,
-0.0481807403,
0.0267508626,
0.011134835,
0.0139737176,
-0.000856846,
0.0323700458,
0.0249558687,
0.0226261206,
-0.0419928245,
-0.0261225123,
0.0140719544,
-0.0842214748,
0.0000868241,
-0.0483419262,
-0.0845343247,
0.0508737564,
0.0111140925,
-0.0486465879,
0.0415441357,
0.0386499129,
-0.0124915363,
-0.0553621762,
-0.0146897715,
-0.0261823144,
-0.0029827834,
0.0220224559,
-0.0421132408,
0.0557841621,
0.0129038142,
-0.023128951,
-0.0212923735,
0.0185401458,
-0.0350644588,
0.0634228215,
-0.0576078929,
-0.0052609504,
-0.0299252011,
0.0174480602,
-0.0413984247,
0.0414925888,
-0.0129483482,
0.037733838,
0.0103704585,
-0.0184949599,
0.0318892337,
-0.0192784034,
-0.010040815,
0.0151678175,
0.0361851566,
0.0041114986,
0.043567311,
-0.0209819451,
-0.0256815627,
-0.0366437137,
-0.0924394056,
0.016756013,
0.0160277244,
0.0174446832,
0.0254365765,
-0.0001813152,
-0.0279958528,
0.0207476802,
-0.0203895178,
-0.0057652364,
0.0084163565,
0.0141852582,
0.0376415215,
-0.0154564781,
0.003969898,
-0.0759231299,
-0.0344536118,
-0.0260671265,
0.028358005,
0.0329428539,
-0.0286144111,
-0.0171388797,
0.0443212427,
-0.0170774125,
-0.0030323709,
-0.006510797,
-0.0183039848,
0.0153176403,
-0.0214744136,
0.0430093892,
0.0142017324,
0.0441858955,
0.0278863907,
0.0380763523,
0.0106530683,
-0.0237536412,
-0.039771311,
-0.0376582593,
-0.0018904787,
-0.0294512548,
-0.0440582931,
0.0422224924,
0.0514673367,
0.011804915,
-0.0135220028,
-0.0277214404,
-0.0034472502,
-0.0320706703,
-0.0002150507,
0.0072293957,
0.0020362758,
-0.0524136461,
-0.0237292647,
0.0037814775,
-0.0592115261,
0.0583507456,
-0.0570701361,
0.0161398649,
-0.0837957337,
0.0028683192,
-0.032696493,
0.0126002785,
0.0425325334,
-0.0025162497,
0.0497354455,
0.0098707415,
-0.0013311524,
0.0065816734,
0.003807625,
-0.0461916514,
0.0496218577,
-0.0241306461,
0.0195785016,
0.0053062742,
-0.0029850078,
0.0138928266,
-0.0755431876,
0.0256900564,
0.0195196457,
0.0589905046,
-0.0608693175,
-0.0158303808,
0.0283122845,
0.029692797,
0.0545015074,
-0.0194530971,
-0.0083767194,
-0.0175551288,
0.037847992,
0.0850331411,
-0.0021793107,
0.0192194898,
-0.0222723484,
0.0071999487,
0.0462782905,
0.026785925,
0.0175923426,
-0.0383160003,
-0.0317398719,
-0.0136822788,
-0.0350812152,
-0.0268744398,
0.0079459259,
-0.0037566051,
-0.0081876153,
-0.0171334799,
0.1176700071,
0.0304853488,
-0.0599841662,
0.0154485758,
-0.0121628987,
0.0784724429,
-0.0042843898,
0.0260729492,
-0.0743840188,
0.0078006391,
-0.0068273148,
0.0088561373,
-0.0219309647,
-0.0514265671,
-0.01596044,
-0.1018112674,
0.050069157,
0.0318064205,
-0.0070945141,
0.0400899947,
-0.0568713993,
-0.0133514293,
-0.0089561576,
-0.0216571745,
0.0196266267,
-0.0351889357,
0.0216956362,
0.0086268159,
-0.0510155186,
-0.0784674287,
0.0091125192,
-0.0326503813,
0.0555913858,
0.0313403681,
0.0391057394,
-0.0501571633,
-0.0037690017,
-0.0007502926,
-0.0402817689,
-0.0145569686,
-0.0053543467,
0.0738362446,
0.0144428918,
0.0240556523,
-0.0561754666,
0.0389531516,
-0.0225813724,
0.0024339303,
0.0069240341,
0.0838343874,
0.00779026,
-0.0382388346,
-0.0554090664,
-0.0146900127,
0.0155258672,
0.0683550984,
0.0218599234,
-0.0101916259,
-0.0238582436,
0.009347003,
0.0100554349,
0.0264701694,
-0.0282288212,
-0.0431256928,
-0.0441552438,
-0.0057999841,
-0.0534622855,
-0.0339902043,
-0.0053298427,
0.0029407663,
0.0199713334,
0.0459847376,
0.0061032549,
-0.0458426103,
-0.0142568648,
0.0158673413,
-0.0015519422,
0.0099424617,
-0.0374011472,
-0.0369468108,
0.061342191,
0.0501011834,
-0.0208024252,
0.0585203841,
-0.0558226183,
-0.0527444333,
-0.0176648814,
-0.0050218971,
0.031342037,
0.0083646867,
0.002401252,
-0.0277613699,
0.0883215815,
0.0062627997,
-0.0143873701,
0.0106245028,
-0.0187504776,
-0.0419869088,
0.0042368281,
-0.0183173213,
-0.014312881,
0.0380162969,
-0.0143424291,
0.0237225201,
-0.0013576904,
-0.0110045401,
0.0257348754,
0.0310342852,
0.0205808133,
-0.0412490927,
0.0427043252,
-0.0232140627,
0.0004690896,
-0.042365998,
0.0300580002,
-0.0394514725,
-0.0019978192,
0.0458092839,
-0.0194540471,
-0.0533682592,
0.0187340342,
-0.0582667477,
0.0364882387,
-0.0501626171,
0.0026622056,
-0.0090706069,
0.0042945491,
0.0516031235,
-0.0271822568,
-0.0054607098,
-0.0211711694,
-0.0634841472,
0.0270746145,
-0.0223894659,
0.0297476351,
0.008294736,
-0.0063001155,
0.0105070965,
0.0633846521,
-0.0673757568,
-0.0099143209,
-0.0366638303,
0.0197750032,
0.0020622564,
-0.0193648674,
0.0801387578,
-0.0764521286,
0.0173349492,
-0.0591574535,
0.0176475868,
0.0013514608,
0.0144956475,
0.0141090583,
0.0159678608,
-0.0347563326,
-0.022556847,
0.1115084514,
0.0462931022,
-0.0013706577,
-0.0017567467,
-0.0483029038,
-0.0003294408,
-0.0381381847,
-0.0097043142,
-0.0228714589,
-0.0176211949,
0.0031041873,
-0.0699432194,
-0.039965082,
-0.0042474819,
0.0012778637,
0.0126905637,
-0.0146514364,
0.0037908745,
0.0703506321,
-0.0233696755,
0.0033525361,
-0.0302032996,
0.0580596328,
-0.0409853607,
-0.0406708531,
0.0165828988,
-5.920676314e-33,
-0.0138356527,
-0.0073977043,
-0.0025473831,
0.0102917803,
-0.0429264829,
-0.002965874,
-0.0554271452,
-0.0370278656,
0.0319701619,
0.0269552916,
-0.0368432701,
0.0238033906,
-0.0011893332,
0.010343859,
0.0379460342,
0.0483648963,
0.028147934,
-0.0284902249,
-0.0176956877,
0.0382461399,
0.0250494666,
0.0282388311,
0.0264039058,
0.0085888561,
0.0478496067,
0.0071638986,
0.0325050801,
-0.039258454,
-0.0020126025,
0.0411800854,
-0.0451181605,
0.0499212667,
0.0292346589,
-0.0471576974,
-0.0183732323,
0.0344425179,
-0.0410543643,
0.0057329,
0.0583996028,
-0.04728112,
-0.0025158895,
-0.002970306,
0.0230165888,
-0.0418624692,
-0.0403097719,
-0.0090144258,
0.0367599167,
-0.0129875736,
-0.031383168,
-0.0335043855,
-0.0595908538,
0.0495393015,
0.0180406664,
0.0338668898,
-0.0066613061,
-0.0309665035,
-0.0137988022,
0.058630947,
0.0016051719,
0.0039317561,
0.0679467618,
0.0501660146,
-0.0208368059,
-0.0087117543,
0.0299346987,
0.0625379235,
-0.0278700367,
0.0146784727,
-0.0064655794,
0.0246609468,
0.0159646664,
-0.0023268294,
0.0563378558,
0.0116788074,
0.0602952763,
-0.0012661611,
-0.0647677258,
0.0307285599,
-0.0270556454,
0.0445688777,
0.0446525924,
-0.0143288877,
-0.0102042491,
-0.0218113959,
-0.0162494294,
-0.0132037848,
0.0065355469,
-0.0487903133,
0.0095609725,
-0.021973148,
-0.0233658161,
0.0175314751,
0.0187190101,
-0.0274074841,
-0.0560698323,
0.0244669188,
-0.0007247084,
0.0155806458,
-0.0145729072,
0.0297906268,
-0.073502779,
-0.0239504147,
-0.003253245,
0.0333409309,
0.0035710388,
0.0014884869,
0.0251581911,
0.0100568291,
-0.0636317432,
-0.0092709251,
-0.0153433252,
-0.0272179134,
-0.002818739,
-0.0205061603,
-0.0059287343,
0.0092838472,
0.0282838307,
0.0205474384,
0.0340691581,
0.0069851913,
-0.0008654395,
0.0150046153,
0.0100381961,
0.0104157962,
-0.0064524538,
-0.0033452029,
-0.0408752076,
0.0215492547,
0.0680425018,
-0.0466696434,
0.020066807,
-0.0210624766,
2.581e-7,
0.0493414551,
0.0761153102,
0.0355972983,
-0.0377551056,
0.0474375598,
-0.004440343,
-0.0504217856,
0.0499772727,
-0.0053941351,
-0.030482566,
0.0058709611,
0.0028044381,
0.0272664372,
0.0163375288,
-0.0973772705,
0.0597831756,
-0.1162422746,
-0.0290394519,
-0.077360183,
0.0053076902,
-0.0115805324,
0.076724112,
-0.0109243123,
-0.0192999728,
-0.0029378929,
-0.0656046048,
0.0543199442,
-0.0335201621,
-0.0350738727,
0.0465929955,
0.0502436496,
-0.023359675,
0.0117465928,
-0.0059832847,
-0.0287364852,
0.0173509941,
-0.0001887963,
0.0453323983,
-0.0038310383,
0.0528569296,
0.0464053825,
-0.0680662915,
0.0138075268,
-0.0610098094,
0.0195168704,
-0.0196888726,
-0.0332356729,
-0.0575876944,
-0.0116031319,
-0.0277071744,
0.044072479,
-0.0421495512,
-0.0101682041,
0.0178638715,
-0.0056679938,
0.0173557978,
0.0148373768,
-0.0614889748,
-0.0165280644,
0.0366984718,
-0.0537663661,
-0.0715803206,
-0.0522380956,
-0.051169157,
-0.0054566227,
-0.0745819062,
0.032225173,
2.666512737e-34,
0.0751658902,
-0.0042583249,
0.0143965511,
0.0016008947,
0.0333306715,
-0.0266972445,
0.0638601482,
0.0548716784,
-0.001095111,
-0.1232519746,
-0.0010407636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14703v1 | ChatGPT Exhibits Gender and Racial Biases in Acute Coronary Syndrome Management | 2023-11-10T19:59:36 | 2023-11-10T19:59:36 | Angela Zhang, Mert Yuksekgonul, Joshua Guild, James Zou, Joseph C. Wu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in large language models (LLMs) have led to their rapid
dissemination and widespread use. One early application has been to medicine,
where LLMs have been investigated to streamline clinical workflows and
facilitate clinical analysis and decision-making. However, a leading barrier to
the deployment of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and in particular LLMs has been
concern for embedded gender and racial biases. Here, we evaluate whether a
leading LLM, ChatGPT 3.5, exhibits gender and racial bias in clinical
management of acute coronary syndrome (ACS). We find that specifying patients
as female, African American, or Hispanic resulted in a decrease in guideline
recommended medical management, diagnosis, and symptom management of ACS. Most
notably, the largest disparities were seen in the recommendation of coronary
angiography or stress testing for the diagnosis and further intervention of ACS
and recommendation of high intensity statins. These disparities correlate with
biases that have been observed clinically and have been implicated in the
differential gender and racial morbidity and mortality outcomes of ACS and
coronary artery disease. Furthermore, we find that the largest disparities are
seen during unstable angina, where fewer explicit clinical guidelines exist.
Finally, we find that through asking ChatGPT 3.5 to explain its reasoning prior
to providing an answer, we are able to improve clinical accuracy and mitigate
instances of gender and racial biases. This is among the first studies to
demonstrate that the gender and racial biases that LLMs exhibit do in fact
affect clinical management. Additionally, we demonstrate that existing
strategies that improve LLM performance not only improve LLM performance in
clinical management, but can also be used to mitigate gender and racial biases. | [
0.0262572858,
0.0462747291,
0.0017445065,
-0.0277576521,
0.0008428699,
0.0548938662,
0.0433069691,
0.0320327431,
0.0222724583,
-0.0206368435,
0.0555334762,
-0.0202947482,
0.009561142,
0.0196977705,
-0.0199591462,
-0.0374132916,
-0.0102053443,
0.0426362157,
0.0832854137,
-0.0268864688,
0.0116143776,
0.0333249494,
0.0275622308,
0.06122908,
0.0111925649,
-0.0309606232,
0.049123574,
-0.0459485538,
-0.0116230976,
-0.0363092497,
-0.0086139087,
0.0445983633,
-0.0183795094,
-0.0415454321,
0.0000021446,
-0.0847590044,
-0.0011539125,
0.0547972023,
-0.0450373776,
-0.0407417715,
0.0266536567,
-0.0184416976,
0.0302066635,
0.0403286181,
-0.0438652076,
-0.0206721239,
0.0393318869,
0.0212574843,
0.0196368415,
0.0060166675,
-0.0150672123,
0.0321966708,
-0.0363115743,
-0.0362061448,
-0.0216596145,
-0.0395658314,
0.0574476011,
-0.0015069569,
0.0539436527,
-0.0418758877,
-0.0221766997,
0.0335645974,
0.0310757384,
0.0374218076,
0.0238466822,
0.038319733,
-0.024122566,
-0.0380150788,
0.0144579802,
0.0359776281,
0.0191976428,
0.0380315632,
0.0195424333,
0.0116470568,
0.0351402313,
0.0030965195,
-0.0261752587,
0.0047184885,
-0.033979319,
-0.0140680652,
0.0355112366,
-0.0166721903,
0.0137665411,
0.0200156849,
-0.049529355,
0.0241420735,
-0.0115067726,
-0.0153181963,
0.0136298202,
0.0049708877,
-0.015068938,
-0.0504879057,
0.0475499667,
-0.0001502193,
-0.0796156153,
-0.0120178163,
0.0493341759,
0.0253251772,
0.048730772,
-0.1051853448,
0.0019437141,
0.0541674607,
0.0289163291,
0.0010824964,
0.0164145678,
-0.0034444374,
-0.0051169717,
0.0540606417,
-0.0565849207,
0.0348811038,
-0.0431357324,
-0.0066836453,
-0.0054395073,
0.0143344458,
0.0095066372,
0.0374395736,
-0.0890426859,
-0.0436864719,
-0.0763344169,
0.0124771902,
0.0039573298,
0.0409719571,
0.019778939,
0.0132897431,
-0.0257218052,
-0.0071393442,
-0.0342425071,
0.0155943856,
0.0075650378,
-0.0489556305,
0.0402716659,
0.003243082,
-0.0089202831,
0.0035420137,
0.0014294168,
0.051287353,
-0.003712269,
-0.0082596624,
-0.0071173389,
-0.044166144,
-0.0416914672,
-0.0620414428,
-0.0036153747,
-0.0702888891,
0.0316634253,
0.0337843038,
0.0258787051,
-0.0281576328,
-0.0094205132,
0.0111124907,
-0.0474365652,
0.0377813838,
0.008398897,
0.0371870957,
0.0556564182,
0.0534052365,
-0.0108932788,
0.0151148522,
0.0419032425,
-0.0264332388,
0.0015328211,
-0.037485268,
0.0038332872,
0.0211345218,
-0.0011551705,
0.0175028816,
-0.0018364154,
0.0278588813,
-0.0191520322,
0.0736028776,
0.0095858518,
0.0250119232,
-0.0033508937,
-0.0229172017,
0.0124509139,
0.0731727481,
0.0083696246,
0.0673382953,
0.056218259,
-0.0209296718,
-0.0244563203,
0.0000859306,
-0.0370237716,
-0.0431279689,
-0.0371937715,
-0.0436182171,
-0.0039661438,
-0.0006810357,
-0.0505384505,
-0.0383194983,
-0.0385778211,
-0.0072257579,
0.008275426,
0.0128021017,
0.0018001099,
-0.0499475226,
0.0054956609,
0.0284064095,
0.0213453248,
0.0105794566,
-0.0760253817,
-0.0681140721,
-0.0150384046,
0.0699071214,
-0.0011097161,
-0.0121770157,
0.0118974177,
-0.0266364068,
0.0303096268,
-0.0002133274,
0.0588085018,
0.0041617565,
-0.0133429728,
-0.0333050564,
-0.0176450126,
0.0686556026,
0.0128319142,
0.0444286056,
0.0309701748,
0.0588109456,
-0.0382406712,
0.0066864062,
-0.076465182,
0.0297267642,
-0.0537720658,
-0.0301960055,
0.0074511128,
-0.0144966859,
0.06924586,
0.0213964265,
-0.0103858523,
0.028925661,
-0.0336117148,
-0.0115223518,
-0.0570241064,
0.012761822,
-0.0509789288,
0.0192159116,
0.013016752,
-0.046450112,
-0.0496336147,
-0.0060215583,
-0.0211512391,
0.0150595782,
0.0138415545,
-0.015748078,
-0.0120728631,
0.0348835737,
0.0188857093,
0.0324932858,
0.0182752833,
-0.0132787256,
-0.0204348117,
-0.025191091,
-0.0132649215,
0.0275977608,
-0.0358473957,
-0.011970927,
-0.0449542888,
-0.0177759882,
0.0303541627,
0.0263570324,
-0.0016783869,
0.0157620218,
0.039479252,
-0.0076733828,
0.0121893277,
-0.0794516429,
-0.0228074454,
0.0270487275,
-0.0267067589,
-0.0356380157,
0.000932531,
-0.0414535441,
-0.0149321295,
-0.0071742954,
-0.0254835933,
0.0668741465,
0.0599367283,
-0.0058049895,
0.0526370853,
-0.0289130379,
-0.0016833931,
-0.0291231126,
-0.062947385,
0.0542533323,
0.0449475124,
-0.0286567379,
0.003393654,
-0.001723486,
-0.0378903225,
-0.0141011346,
0.0065267361,
-0.0193034336,
0.0121387402,
0.0039455835,
0.0056975326,
0.0476950929,
-0.0148607418,
0.0356982909,
0.0436647162,
0.0119579295,
-0.011300873,
0.0078471573,
-0.0226366092,
-0.0135424631,
0.0483484082,
-0.0852859691,
-0.0239997376,
0.0661990345,
0.0245456547,
0.0117777418,
-0.0471026003,
0.0194411445,
-0.05959066,
-0.0497185923,
-0.0666286796,
-0.0344557092,
-0.0160752423,
0.0566837005,
-0.0069164964,
-0.0251874104,
0.0517197698,
0.0294282716,
0.0259318799,
-0.0679391026,
-0.0234568678,
-0.0554956831,
-0.0103275953,
-0.0099585913,
0.0228534471,
0.0210618787,
0.03130183,
-0.0070957541,
-0.0386362337,
-0.0339492969,
-0.0575324148,
0.0629148632,
-0.0335658826,
0.0107568726,
0.0006493191,
-0.0675957799,
-0.0269059353,
0.0125430645,
-0.0589841753,
0.0115506239,
0.0292886999,
0.0325896852,
-0.0135938488,
0.0351362638,
0.0006755645,
0.0344893262,
-0.039916154,
-0.0390023999,
0.0440989509,
-0.0623748042,
-0.0008654064,
-0.0129128527,
0.0240444895,
-0.0311600175,
0.0647405982,
0.0439175181,
-0.0249294359,
-0.0051543214,
-0.006681283,
0.0270778388,
0.0040418911,
-0.0135981971,
-0.0203332156,
0.0213199928,
-0.0146145998,
-0.0303058363,
0.0290999804,
0.1163092107,
0.0201442912,
-0.0739632174,
0.0099235112,
-0.057015311,
-0.0118873566,
0.0024900839,
-0.0047210255,
-0.0903858915,
-0.0075590415,
0.0199882276,
0.016358979,
-0.0414871126,
-0.0422474071,
-0.0225002952,
-0.0368640907,
0.0469284132,
0.0211954135,
-0.035622187,
-0.0103918212,
-0.0365094803,
-0.0082881637,
-0.0251082312,
0.0126003316,
-0.0495753475,
0.0010194097,
0.0241260715,
0.0043309503,
-0.1147924513,
-0.0441571698,
0.0729351491,
-0.0268323068,
0.0032199165,
0.0303245187,
0.0375547335,
-0.0109692821,
0.0078573627,
0.0390634462,
0.0425891206,
0.0129127158,
-0.0492900312,
0.0621324405,
0.0167198684,
0.0309519265,
-0.0857600197,
0.0272834357,
0.000712127,
0.0123406136,
0.0181053951,
0.0520318337,
-0.0008627178,
-0.0550740622,
-0.0434036851,
0.0597962402,
-0.0172025934,
0.051368691,
0.0207481794,
0.000008599,
-0.0296703428,
-0.050652191,
0.0331756622,
0.0332955606,
-0.0527154468,
-0.0011871748,
-0.0085920338,
-0.0313768163,
0.0221987572,
-0.0529380068,
0.0472875126,
-0.0319815092,
0.0214467179,
-0.0208314918,
0.0549994148,
-0.0234595332,
-0.0305777863,
0.0585797541,
0.0063823541,
0.0602540895,
0.0204316806,
-0.0201248191,
-0.02181747,
0.0082267318,
-0.0229926556,
0.0094601111,
0.043189358,
0.0055178194,
0.0562447645,
0.0505116917,
0.0343028046,
-0.0108840661,
-0.0188079514,
-0.0299789347,
-0.0038412313,
0.051506348,
-0.0075204088,
-0.0045775319,
-0.0142904753,
0.0405373387,
-0.0152741596,
-0.0162912868,
-0.0024302623,
0.0383771844,
0.0029620735,
-0.0078109265,
-0.0161165893,
0.0038035729,
0.0171546433,
0.0439386852,
-0.0327002779,
-0.0287328754,
-0.0166944098,
-0.0104532372,
-0.0239237286,
-0.0253669806,
0.0028611957,
0.0031408721,
-0.0156651028,
0.0011205189,
0.0311123934,
-0.0076034218,
-0.0223509278,
-0.0411605127,
-0.0728819072,
-0.0395648517,
0.0739747435,
-0.0002159345,
0.0267022494,
0.0407112204,
-0.0006285732,
0.0010537248,
0.0110020144,
-0.0097452803,
0.0208201334,
0.0108215567,
0.0972180963,
0.0021696126,
0.0283832699,
-0.0225084201,
0.0176120121,
-0.0438170694,
-0.0701577216,
0.018820405,
0.0522982627,
0.0357792005,
-0.0399377309,
-0.0084582744,
-0.0063416213,
0.0006617108,
-0.0248504877,
-0.0200411007,
0.0074773533,
0.0235124044,
0.0495964997,
-0.0023555805,
-0.0081179077,
-0.0380959325,
0.0606358312,
0.0022246395,
0.0443412066,
-0.0327801779,
-0.0717382506,
-0.0135746533,
-0.0564062744,
0.0316360779,
-0.0201854147,
-0.0552234091,
-0.0248127859,
-0.1106560081,
-0.0243082084,
-0.0228801817,
-0.0167234801,
-0.0007144185,
-0.0203910396,
0.0002592925,
0.0557681434,
-0.0319518968,
-0.0588037781,
-0.0071835122,
0.0357625745,
-0.0517362431,
-0.0234860852,
0.0097325435,
-5.692290252e-33,
0.0022465456,
-0.037766438,
0.0242471695,
-0.0440195873,
0.0232687779,
0.0287826918,
-0.02736184,
-0.0004892402,
0.012105328,
0.0723162815,
-0.0351179875,
0.014455528,
0.0149174677,
-0.0145649826,
0.0050769444,
-0.0563418455,
0.0284170862,
0.0283429027,
-0.0026426772,
-0.0046698484,
-0.0807388946,
0.0407390483,
-0.0081243478,
-0.073456198,
0.0397757627,
0.0181560013,
0.0294765718,
-0.0057741911,
-0.0185168348,
0.0420317762,
-0.0018373454,
0.0529770404,
0.0543663576,
-0.0295985304,
0.0149885714,
0.0237146765,
-0.0090318238,
-0.0097417701,
0.0244648084,
-0.0238222126,
-0.0093977936,
-0.0202492122,
0.0246841218,
0.0496326201,
-0.0720368773,
-0.0149113825,
0.0275687408,
-0.0508420281,
0.0435000136,
-0.0002552159,
-0.0125430776,
0.0479914248,
-0.0235672556,
0.0396600142,
-0.0272286329,
0.0281174835,
-0.0605875514,
0.0241682194,
-0.0052730222,
-0.0055782399,
0.0503468774,
-0.0410076641,
0.0039727762,
-0.0016321689,
-0.0286104698,
0.0222398639,
0.0324120261,
0.0048581264,
-0.0712237731,
-0.0023976262,
-0.0732708424,
0.0044397181,
0.0497770309,
0.057448294,
-0.0277792681,
-0.0205057785,
-0.071145393,
0.0052585658,
-0.0668769032,
0.0163248107,
0.044783894,
-0.0188584253,
-0.1166432127,
-0.0542703532,
0.0010940334,
-0.0121798338,
-0.0260499213,
-0.0224411506,
0.0280216951,
0.0032754748,
0.0099959578,
0.0016363207,
0.0262320675,
-0.0357545912,
-0.0018013845,
-0.0431618579,
0.0364449583,
-0.0401067771,
0.0033235201,
0.0004113512,
-0.0542916916,
0.0406713299,
0.0056918934,
0.0177370887,
0.0542535707,
0.0361716338,
-0.0138307875,
-0.0348552205,
-0.0474436693,
-0.0142909847,
0.0025474099,
0.0079191709,
0.0230109598,
-0.0188415013,
0.0366620272,
0.0514270514,
0.0266087707,
0.0664341897,
0.0490577221,
0.0081225941,
-0.0360043645,
-0.0478470847,
-0.0330697745,
0.0079890685,
-0.0386552364,
0.0194134638,
-0.0185080953,
0.0736051574,
0.0555903427,
-0.0638538897,
-0.019331798,
-0.058540795,
2.696e-7,
0.0422970131,
0.0582682379,
-0.0109276371,
-0.0164513271,
0.0191706903,
0.0336202607,
-0.0165250581,
-0.0090696262,
0.0711997151,
0.0006123526,
0.0199005567,
0.0456492007,
-0.004930309,
0.0335496999,
-0.0319777504,
-0.0213921983,
-0.0908802524,
0.0048070149,
-0.007533065,
0.0084173754,
0.0222470872,
0.0557310842,
-0.015451109,
-0.0143237626,
-0.0273435768,
-0.0013495716,
0.0049641002,
-0.0463602841,
-0.0083438084,
0.0249159709,
0.012485534,
-0.0053235586,
0.0296397749,
0.0660216361,
0.0161731578,
-0.0193931982,
0.0104266759,
0.0822450742,
-0.051096756,
0.0784869865,
0.0154648153,
0.0086873798,
0.0143501274,
-0.0699139386,
0.0604445189,
-0.0414708517,
-0.0688404366,
-0.0631354973,
0.0029940708,
-0.0221009236,
0.0922678113,
0.0092275636,
-0.0298988447,
0.0302556325,
0.0218072552,
0.0501446612,
0.0099230893,
-0.0308566839,
0.0211756807,
-0.0034338748,
-0.0183333065,
-0.0664451793,
0.0071060113,
0.0558173619,
0.0309512354,
-0.0465715677,
0.0165892653,
2.28359132e-34,
0.013515396,
0.0609396063,
-0.0025489763,
-0.0315944105,
0.0409481861,
-0.0063769282,
-0.0062669409,
-0.0065659913,
0.0160634983,
-0.0153356688,
-0.0159116965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06364v1 | Relation Extraction in underexplored biomedical domains: A diversity-optimised sampling and synthetic data generation approach | 2023-11-10T19:36:00 | 2023-11-10T19:36:00 | Maxime Delmas, Magdalena Wysocka, André Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | The sparsity of labelled data is an obstacle to the development of Relation
Extraction models and the completion of databases in various biomedical areas.
While being of high interest in drug-discovery, the natural-products
literature, reporting the identification of potential bioactive compounds from
organisms, is a concrete example of such an overlooked topic. To mark the start
of this new task, we created the first curated evaluation dataset and extracted
literature items from the LOTUS database to build training sets. To this end,
we developed a new sampler inspired by diversity metrics in ecology, named
Greedy Maximum Entropy sampler, or GME-sampler
(https://github.com/idiap/gme-sampler). The strategic optimization of both
balance and diversity of the selected items in the evaluation set is important
given the resource-intensive nature of manual curation. After quantifying the
noise in the training set, in the form of discrepancies between the input
abstracts text and the expected output labels, we explored different strategies
accordingly. Framing the task as an end-to-end Relation Extraction, we
evaluated the performance of standard fine-tuning as a generative task and
few-shot learning with open Large Language Models (LLaMA 7B-65B). In addition
to their evaluation in few-shot settings, we explore the potential of open
Large Language Models (Vicuna-13B) as synthetic data generator and propose a
new workflow for this purpose. All evaluated models exhibited substantial
improvements when fine-tuned on synthetic abstracts rather than the original
noisy data. We provide our best performing (f1-score=59.0) BioGPT-Large model
for end-to-end RE of natural-products relationships along with all the
generated synthetic data and the evaluation dataset. See more details at
https://github.com/idiap/abroad-re. | [
0.0561763905,
0.0505727492,
0.00801735,
0.0065904837,
-0.0175326336,
0.0096971579,
0.0070999241,
0.0572311394,
0.01722035,
-0.0738341436,
-0.0130916703,
-0.0254170392,
-0.0297231451,
0.036102578,
0.004261374,
-0.0313914455,
0.0175936371,
0.0272548292,
0.0178590696,
-0.0134906229,
-0.0349115916,
0.0107786721,
0.0162609238,
-0.0027917307,
0.0329170488,
-0.0272967368,
0.0268540233,
-0.0259153377,
0.0638860837,
-0.0630943179,
-0.0012864795,
0.0359398499,
-0.0174400341,
0.0317664333,
0.0000020168,
-0.0839870498,
-0.0366414338,
0.0558555573,
-0.0086739818,
-0.0103351725,
0.0443899669,
-0.0308911707,
0.030838538,
-0.016463412,
-0.006359539,
-0.057568714,
0.0405194014,
0.0486829989,
-0.015470231,
0.056880258,
-0.0260035824,
-0.0761124939,
0.0489987023,
-0.042289719,
0.0579499193,
0.0032181521,
0.0790772811,
-0.0101769213,
0.0503644198,
0.0028316772,
-0.0078041181,
-0.0002807564,
0.0033918992,
0.0015620493,
0.0724738911,
0.0771911219,
-0.0073449323,
-0.0286710206,
0.0160315074,
0.1048744991,
-0.0287930053,
0.002600793,
0.0272236131,
-0.0175571125,
-0.0410570055,
0.0398807712,
-0.0340160765,
0.0215188339,
-0.0511190817,
0.0338917747,
0.0227930006,
0.0124710761,
0.0281600207,
0.001626533,
-0.0190707874,
0.0160357468,
0.0151873594,
-0.0203266069,
0.0350583605,
-0.0104453228,
-0.0306315944,
-0.0149437999,
0.0116405673,
0.0014445097,
-0.0097487038,
0.0124899726,
0.0285935849,
-0.0646531582,
0.0505498163,
-0.0383025929,
-0.0138286967,
-0.0162017364,
-0.0215513203,
0.0445360132,
-0.0008141986,
-0.0276249573,
-0.0038478661,
0.0126355477,
-0.0209925324,
-0.0001515953,
-0.0475845374,
-0.0027517849,
-0.0011739205,
0.0448481515,
-0.0555419885,
-0.0068961326,
-0.047800187,
-0.005801159,
-0.0124981198,
-0.0242343266,
0.0389095508,
0.0184804462,
-0.039551273,
0.012393157,
-0.0201509185,
-0.0094213635,
-0.0034416602,
0.0057518184,
-0.0159236323,
-0.0588049255,
-0.0116961412,
-0.0059956019,
0.0431058593,
-0.0387955979,
0.0155781014,
0.0820519254,
0.0077892956,
-0.0536756478,
0.0065655066,
-0.0348001793,
0.0079590855,
-0.0864393786,
0.0271096416,
-0.0358901583,
0.0696088001,
0.0041155228,
0.0049039735,
-0.0210791435,
0.0173136014,
-0.0165105443,
-0.0626262203,
0.059692394,
-0.0383790545,
-0.0389246047,
-0.004297235,
-0.0152791766,
0.0604181439,
0.0459811352,
0.0329265669,
0.0046280045,
0.0390728153,
0.0016791788,
0.0121597806,
-0.0036443505,
-0.0219823997,
-0.0629590601,
0.0204487797,
0.0462210774,
0.0268838126,
0.0591124855,
0.0159810185,
0.0347041301,
-0.0522504188,
-0.0181402676,
0.0325561464,
0.0353719629,
0.0529227406,
0.0369540676,
0.0331539921,
-0.0073599271,
0.0175286718,
-0.0227323566,
0.0026370657,
0.0171221774,
-0.0017502174,
0.0473600775,
0.0245972034,
0.0632509589,
0.0202331692,
0.0033733796,
-0.0106992042,
0.0030997731,
-0.0601775423,
-0.0184563007,
0.1060715988,
-0.000770691,
-0.0519167595,
0.0359460786,
0.0772069767,
-0.0100045595,
0.0054612458,
0.0238430034,
0.0409029089,
0.0308892429,
0.0408424959,
-0.0530071892,
0.0025136508,
-0.0330493934,
-0.0601442941,
0.0409129821,
-0.0028681452,
-0.0294995699,
0.020010937,
-0.0278063845,
-0.0352893323,
-0.0093685007,
0.0097995363,
0.0231668353,
0.0104124723,
0.0442458503,
0.0066775251,
-0.0462502204,
-0.0173437167,
0.0352702141,
-0.0312715173,
-0.057882756,
0.0485804006,
-0.0117919082,
0.0465358831,
0.0471778512,
-0.042666059,
0.0043702223,
0.0608028397,
-0.0786449537,
-0.0149505315,
-0.0320322923,
0.0088044051,
-0.0561654754,
0.0229772422,
-0.0408346504,
-0.0022528379,
-0.0046351803,
-0.0582729094,
-0.0226730611,
0.0048149601,
0.0216666888,
-0.003125407,
-0.0490206927,
0.0020693352,
0.0111772856,
0.0260645542,
-0.0406247824,
0.0680541992,
0.034154918,
0.0095951483,
-0.0313365832,
-0.0843063667,
-0.0017874688,
-0.0319144018,
0.0143114142,
0.0461754091,
0.0130239353,
0.0034959833,
0.0146652898,
0.007266588,
-0.0471334122,
-0.0188108701,
-0.0246630851,
0.0226095896,
0.0019521039,
0.0487143882,
-0.0047725863,
0.0082985377,
0.0127720516,
0.0091290213,
-0.0068851891,
-0.0093024243,
-0.0600682087,
-0.0145070218,
0.0340278,
0.0374741219,
-0.0148948766,
-0.0172099974,
-0.0094089806,
-0.0156441983,
0.0901199058,
0.0195488092,
-0.014826851,
0.0210240837,
0.0311076846,
-0.0070635313,
0.0094220201,
-0.0071789543,
0.0346291102,
-0.0320248269,
0.0119895879,
0.0066169826,
-0.0051945695,
-0.0016004118,
0.0159001071,
0.0410914198,
0.0232638307,
-0.001068912,
0.0244378503,
-0.0583452247,
0.0352563933,
0.0270205755,
-0.0169570539,
-0.0072763385,
0.0372582003,
-0.0138620762,
-0.0100156283,
0.0026432113,
0.0170243476,
0.0123160128,
-0.0169499088,
-0.0453952476,
0.0478423089,
-0.0102274604,
-0.0061350917,
-0.0095828492,
-0.0381011181,
0.0550867058,
0.0070659351,
-0.0012942241,
-0.0680899397,
0.0208197534,
-0.0226815809,
0.0057639591,
0.0240125917,
0.0074615669,
0.0417578258,
0.0256331991,
0.0009213575,
-0.0164209679,
0.0405868404,
-0.0311627034,
0.0019295153,
-0.0334843546,
0.0363552161,
-0.0061964891,
-0.0327475704,
-0.0405209176,
-0.0101784468,
-0.0043256362,
0.030593114,
0.049232211,
-0.0117928721,
-0.0118414778,
0.0486149006,
0.0090662558,
0.0053291582,
-0.0255334545,
-0.0240251757,
-0.0004234383,
0.0397659242,
0.1164115593,
-0.0622140095,
0.0160115175,
-0.0227348451,
0.0432304405,
0.0151253939,
-0.0256072525,
-0.0121045886,
0.0215117298,
0.0092595909,
-0.0334357023,
-0.0382639989,
0.01909828,
0.0151640847,
-0.0222669039,
-0.012568769,
-0.0260891002,
0.0717786476,
0.0081798434,
-0.0404740684,
0.037566144,
0.027435869,
-0.0339925438,
-0.0068593584,
0.0409664437,
-0.0723409429,
0.0014241395,
-0.0449767448,
-0.0026577762,
-0.0260458793,
-0.0721514523,
-0.0224021319,
-0.1064412892,
0.0391168073,
-0.0041272133,
-0.1271134764,
-0.0250359401,
-0.0669159666,
-0.0213935692,
-0.0486041382,
0.0129658962,
0.0073056314,
-0.028896451,
0.0007717339,
0.0034114611,
0.0126886452,
-0.094105728,
-0.0143294251,
-0.0282108095,
0.0107211052,
0.0182027314,
0.0112972166,
-0.0041663572,
0.0555038117,
0.0157875735,
-0.0285627879,
-0.0287357531,
-0.0160512365,
0.0811928436,
0.0161440093,
-0.0114669688,
-0.0104717892,
0.0206744652,
-0.0513600968,
-0.0149291893,
-0.0337542817,
0.0865418315,
0.0127545884,
-0.0477733091,
-0.0267239027,
-0.0268954244,
0.0171475969,
0.0416566469,
0.0147798518,
-0.0048361784,
-0.0485777482,
0.0199652389,
-0.0051269606,
-0.055856254,
0.0200664829,
0.024013279,
-0.0773685053,
-0.0569472611,
-0.0391778909,
-0.0481007844,
0.0514209569,
0.012556497,
-0.0185628776,
0.0471639745,
0.0292238593,
-0.0104623437,
-0.0248121638,
0.0161266159,
0.0280252937,
-0.0165114086,
0.0021529926,
-0.0429039411,
0.0598815829,
-0.0227450281,
-0.0187466927,
-0.0076819779,
-0.0391847603,
-0.0524197519,
-0.0237764288,
0.0136039397,
0.0189768933,
0.018087741,
0.0034588927,
-0.0394292437,
0.0784898549,
0.1419753581,
-0.0212716591,
-0.0285313707,
-0.0182802286,
-0.0062721246,
-0.0217686482,
0.018823253,
-0.0339000635,
0.0320129991,
0.0281041339,
0.0401721597,
0.0137454448,
-0.0202269778,
0.056530349,
0.0470674485,
0.0495421551,
-0.0382015891,
-0.0082775131,
-0.0602708906,
0.019364493,
-0.0368852504,
0.0279371832,
-0.0344308577,
0.0059297341,
0.0068763648,
0.0005378206,
-0.0308827218,
0.0130096516,
-0.0118083181,
0.0291139726,
-0.0467371792,
-0.0203279816,
-0.0293987431,
-0.0072563714,
0.0538666137,
-0.0267976541,
-0.0134397093,
-0.028875269,
-0.0029834819,
0.0186545737,
-0.0087123392,
0.0278032664,
0.016472552,
0.0136541957,
-0.033903379,
0.0038744886,
-0.0335573815,
0.0301539954,
-0.0694238693,
0.0366765074,
0.0332379453,
-0.0152217578,
0.037750043,
-0.0171028487,
-0.0261275675,
-0.0383954868,
0.0493141413,
-0.0144739263,
0.0200165194,
0.0150458394,
0.0378821194,
-0.0370428786,
-0.0204635821,
0.0960265845,
0.0269972533,
0.0515444167,
0.023484055,
-0.0033714378,
-0.0435230322,
-0.0098850196,
-0.0290345084,
-0.0131704332,
-0.0164995883,
0.0066599972,
-0.0790419206,
-0.0384719744,
0.0311294626,
-0.0077416115,
-0.0172649715,
0.0262015779,
0.0179647952,
0.0180619322,
0.0116224401,
-0.0611916669,
-0.0222201496,
0.0237096697,
-0.0165004935,
-0.0440303273,
-0.0127981799,
-6.421962207e-33,
0.0182249267,
-0.0345655754,
-0.0199135151,
-0.0231817104,
-0.0034712504,
-0.010891729,
-0.0590507761,
-0.0565089099,
0.0199600123,
0.0715648457,
-0.0005901062,
-0.020937562,
0.0065631843,
0.0052342629,
0.0017109129,
-0.0066062361,
0.0026497252,
0.0039207069,
0.0274260119,
0.0268791635,
0.0491627492,
0.0734677017,
0.0670287386,
-0.0558215491,
-0.0248900279,
0.0173525158,
0.0199249703,
0.0040511205,
-0.0143760256,
0.0651214346,
-0.0498767756,
0.0862121955,
0.0053014765,
-0.0635919347,
0.019156117,
-0.0547989681,
-0.100403063,
-0.0106232753,
-0.0039349557,
-0.0263061952,
-0.0163078215,
-0.0272025447,
0.0274366923,
0.0031823816,
0.002964647,
-0.0431397147,
0.059530247,
-0.0437427796,
-0.0665594488,
-0.1145889163,
-0.0600803755,
0.0118279736,
0.0212417692,
0.0225936845,
0.0065552415,
-0.0050982358,
-0.017002197,
0.0473852158,
0.036444921,
-0.0012841953,
0.052159369,
0.0031239907,
0.0252515282,
0.0406851843,
0.0400397293,
0.0572601669,
-0.0124535123,
-0.0058393599,
0.034503907,
0.0097737079,
-0.0323356576,
0.0513560735,
-0.0261608958,
0.0506449305,
0.0631234199,
0.0125491507,
-0.1079104766,
0.0388913304,
-0.0166755784,
-0.0179765299,
-0.0140650067,
0.0007758967,
0.0155677479,
-0.0147461593,
0.0115533946,
0.0274801608,
-0.0118798614,
-0.0004461992,
0.000127369,
-0.0039523272,
-0.0544007309,
0.0229298119,
0.0008433966,
-0.0425147563,
-0.0371883102,
-0.0084684128,
-0.0183892343,
0.0068177823,
0.0075990367,
-0.0428746268,
-0.0710491836,
-0.0459317602,
0.0309686977,
0.0078995517,
-0.0028948928,
-0.0148433894,
0.0190241504,
-0.0164810847,
-0.0296198949,
0.0094166426,
-0.0373292267,
0.0276257321,
0.0355837792,
0.0186617132,
-0.0171778835,
0.0227388721,
0.0117976414,
0.0925476253,
0.0786713511,
-0.0001165958,
0.01660401,
0.0496735498,
0.0220181458,
-0.0055862349,
-0.0032078666,
0.0110524045,
0.0111031039,
0.0118032424,
0.0366925187,
-0.0334814824,
-0.0061472529,
0.0083149737,
2.897e-7,
0.0473967753,
0.0066042682,
0.0193654522,
-0.0028364416,
0.0162464995,
0.019206889,
0.0368471816,
0.033132758,
-0.0688370988,
-0.0321790241,
0.0414069444,
-0.0242287032,
0.0253942925,
0.0245754775,
-0.0483039469,
0.0160107687,
-0.0808892474,
-0.0878145397,
-0.0718907341,
-0.0281298999,
0.0192562379,
0.0837499499,
0.0163614266,
0.0048817201,
-0.0009025753,
-0.011730467,
0.0287514552,
-0.0694985911,
-0.0045927009,
0.0710990801,
0.0390270539,
-0.0371131487,
-0.0125066889,
0.0370461531,
-0.0065880544,
0.0164307095,
-0.0193372816,
0.0168783739,
-0.0287933797,
0.0112000499,
0.0415549055,
-0.0320507698,
0.0235370919,
-0.0411906056,
0.0331168398,
-0.0617975593,
-0.0410177782,
0.002298058,
-0.0206340626,
-0.0034986024,
0.0219256803,
-0.0197781008,
0.0422049351,
0.0425354764,
-0.0010679861,
0.0009800362,
-0.0050631138,
-0.0328818336,
0.0246236138,
0.0552686751,
-0.026065968,
-0.0270585455,
0.0171980113,
-0.0066144448,
0.0199573077,
-0.0393287577,
0.0078022941,
2.781124355e-34,
0.0483014695,
0.0037591499,
-0.0296088755,
0.0325531997,
0.0085598929,
-0.0363690369,
-0.0400188267,
0.0061942539,
-0.0421644561,
-0.105631955,
-0.0054721376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06362v1 | Word Definitions from Large Language Models | 2023-11-10T19:27:20 | 2023-11-10T19:27:20 | Yunting Yin, Steven Skiena | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dictionary definitions are historically the arbitrator of what words mean,
but this primacy has come under threat by recent progress in NLP, including
word embeddings and generative models like ChatGPT. We present an exploratory
study of the degree of alignment between word definitions from classical
dictionaries and these newer computational artifacts. Specifically, we compare
definitions from three published dictionaries to those generated from variants
of ChatGPT. We show that (i) definitions from different traditional
dictionaries exhibit more surface form similarity than do model-generated
definitions, (ii) that the ChatGPT definitions are highly accurate, comparable
to traditional dictionaries, and (iii) ChatGPT-based embedding definitions
retain their accuracy even on low frequency words, much better than GloVE and
FastText word embeddings. | [
0.0006158641,
0.007043703,
0.0040179193,
0.0364095345,
-0.0505012348,
-0.0128086163,
-0.0275580734,
0.0159885231,
-0.0174349844,
-0.0453540795,
-0.0098716505,
-0.0672902614,
0.0087477053,
0.0449052118,
0.0220602769,
-0.0054444368,
0.0844876766,
0.0496008769,
-0.047391858,
0.025016332,
0.0496140011,
0.0043603997,
0.0244389288,
0.0489885435,
-0.0537603684,
-0.0424041785,
0.0071741147,
-0.0419126712,
-0.0233948529,
-0.0300037432,
-0.0112185888,
0.0569394492,
0.0538827665,
0.0723121613,
0.0000019395,
-0.0440860316,
-0.0316547751,
-0.0032113434,
-0.015604984,
0.0218625758,
0.0956981406,
-0.0541559048,
0.0147914169,
-0.004160759,
-0.0465485714,
-0.0322750211,
0.0784222409,
0.0153726982,
0.0123351282,
0.0241634808,
-0.0113996603,
-0.0328589007,
0.0187385995,
-0.0371528082,
-0.0068901721,
-0.0253077634,
0.0084927892,
0.0362327583,
-0.0354753025,
-0.0239282195,
-0.0481636859,
0.031381879,
-0.024898259,
0.0440824516,
0.0341606885,
0.0413477458,
-0.0218889453,
-0.0224453341,
0.0277516749,
0.0497397669,
0.0090962984,
-0.0479427353,
-0.0396221466,
0.0105120568,
-0.0202621464,
0.075030908,
-0.0045186505,
0.0156191662,
0.0113079231,
0.0242177751,
0.0547872484,
-0.0183217712,
0.0375786349,
0.0181119386,
-0.0187150259,
0.0208996385,
0.0360023193,
-0.0558151603,
-0.0218209047,
-0.020328911,
-0.0463925414,
-0.027319191,
-0.036564853,
-0.039785102,
0.0054555475,
0.010942095,
-0.0408903174,
0.0038045363,
0.0202159099,
-0.0646137223,
0.0243685916,
0.0330487601,
0.0146966679,
0.0297395624,
0.0118433256,
0.0219138693,
-0.0064209867,
0.0045092907,
-0.0566869825,
0.0260829683,
-0.0561003089,
-0.0111979833,
-0.0521369167,
-0.0312844329,
-0.0267044622,
-0.0655115619,
-0.017670149,
0.0269561559,
-0.0034180314,
-0.00607649,
0.0027789257,
0.0142987398,
-0.0214544106,
0.0412411876,
-0.0131131532,
-0.0226917192,
-0.0326535888,
0.0057551777,
-0.0257577226,
-0.0398519635,
-0.0187013801,
-0.016437985,
0.0017227103,
-0.0214208979,
-0.0105944704,
0.0384970233,
0.0096385134,
-0.0387495123,
0.0326988176,
-0.0204598382,
-0.0587851107,
-0.0318017378,
-0.0425858498,
-0.0613099448,
0.0530970469,
0.002893507,
-0.0014493424,
-0.0523819253,
-0.0102827167,
0.0198540986,
-0.0357334763,
0.1089533791,
-0.0363209918,
0.0263771601,
-0.0145476209,
0.0205834955,
-0.023917025,
0.0568607412,
0.0395500958,
-0.0097030643,
0.0780324414,
-0.0131928362,
-0.0124385264,
0.0390695967,
-0.008379628,
0.019887967,
-0.028690571,
-0.0314786509,
0.0531119928,
0.0492988527,
0.001219183,
0.0690399259,
-0.0434866734,
-0.0140311839,
0.0611312054,
0.0685583055,
0.0313491486,
0.0172551181,
0.0260054898,
0.0357018039,
-0.0065175504,
-0.0035005931,
-0.0439324304,
-0.0471352749,
-0.0060502482,
0.0121853622,
0.0185990222,
0.0273833219,
0.0029988915,
0.0254010446,
-0.0565510057,
0.0054221856,
0.0234290734,
-0.0450223163,
0.0092952047,
-0.0043603024,
-0.0059337714,
0.0435174853,
0.0446539186,
-0.0223011412,
-0.0042699901,
-0.0289600994,
0.0078884037,
0.0345712081,
0.067121774,
0.0051081958,
-0.0384381339,
0.0052139461,
-0.0220390186,
0.0521523692,
0.0611610599,
-0.0096353516,
-0.0141640045,
-0.036148414,
-0.0338617712,
-0.0162567366,
0.0373511426,
-0.0063235783,
0.0246168319,
0.0176883098,
0.0116159497,
-0.0523383506,
-0.0334120914,
0.0446136594,
-0.01648256,
-0.0432555974,
-0.0412676483,
0.0081353458,
0.0254057832,
0.0194095373,
-0.0454070233,
0.032857582,
0.0209633224,
-0.0187184606,
0.0145635717,
0.0001094022,
-0.0335447453,
-0.0287762955,
0.0371956974,
0.0005077002,
0.0235421769,
0.0159308705,
-0.0111006908,
-0.0265031997,
-0.0229300763,
0.0001835794,
0.0708554387,
-0.0665036961,
0.0078300657,
-0.0080802711,
0.0651378408,
-0.0396576561,
0.0595125183,
0.0047815437,
0.0247778948,
-0.0415388793,
0.0362012498,
0.0018717153,
0.0156137673,
-0.0710442066,
0.0219550505,
0.0018556215,
0.0304840747,
0.043072924,
-0.0028354346,
-0.0403991006,
-0.0447702594,
-0.0740617737,
0.0405118614,
0.0098755937,
0.0181590412,
0.0226450618,
0.0134598622,
-0.0064118556,
0.0403808989,
-0.0055372063,
0.0054454915,
0.0143787879,
0.0316090882,
0.0345560238,
-0.0341600701,
-0.0407538414,
-0.039072413,
0.0000185987,
-0.0168842003,
0.009365825,
-0.0163493063,
-0.0250031147,
-0.009324328,
0.0184039362,
-0.0739032403,
0.029767314,
-0.0048896428,
-0.0402090438,
0.0137828439,
-0.0124939401,
0.0414615273,
0.0053098272,
0.020226201,
0.0482057855,
0.0617567077,
-0.0128946612,
-0.0422980636,
-0.0350357741,
-0.0406431444,
-0.0291676074,
-0.0047660181,
0.0058699925,
-0.0261591505,
0.0928196013,
0.0263213236,
0.0058719157,
-0.0338351987,
0.0417952873,
-0.0404108725,
0.0071621281,
-0.0170214344,
0.0270019434,
-0.07248272,
0.0059440914,
-0.0374235176,
-0.0478164144,
0.0222838521,
-0.034820538,
0.0018898044,
-0.0329243839,
-0.0319092385,
-0.0057642707,
0.0841112062,
-0.0442662016,
0.0214210656,
-0.0034502991,
0.0198262706,
-0.044634968,
0.0047921487,
0.0745173022,
-0.0796818733,
0.0415333062,
-0.028482303,
0.0158265121,
-0.0273115002,
-0.0018617314,
-0.0259522554,
-0.0508707576,
-0.0098391045,
0.0172607023,
0.0472882055,
-0.0178175792,
-0.0016123459,
0.0551062971,
-0.018450493,
-0.0126896147,
0.003438337,
0.0080094505,
-0.0388135985,
0.0258317869,
0.0482799448,
0.0193115026,
-0.0060807033,
0.0221900567,
0.034727104,
0.0339215249,
0.0134692239,
0.0230519064,
-0.0264361557,
-0.0099357748,
0.0249980036,
-0.0004788374,
-0.0357897691,
-0.0081594996,
0.0131281856,
-0.0071383431,
-0.004584624,
0.1215258464,
0.0334127806,
-0.0356427282,
0.0165873561,
0.0194930658,
0.0326495022,
0.0158187896,
-0.0388999842,
-0.0950977504,
-0.0243101045,
0.0185812972,
-0.0152426381,
0.0400949791,
-0.0255607702,
-0.0358776301,
-0.0654858574,
0.0217022635,
0.0090547334,
-0.0340479985,
-0.0075245746,
-0.0462617539,
0.0211694352,
-0.020580234,
0.0186483059,
-0.0101673147,
-0.0112013984,
0.0205857512,
-0.0091756228,
-0.0150382426,
-0.0315175839,
0.0375204496,
-0.0584494658,
0.0436361842,
0.0433201492,
0.0614771284,
-0.0182750057,
-0.0338497683,
0.0373928919,
0.0027072991,
-0.044558499,
-0.0148895765,
0.0170384925,
-0.0303436313,
-0.0074388352,
0.0320887454,
-0.0133967726,
-0.0144324396,
-0.0181425996,
-0.0195412375,
0.0572818778,
-0.0108212698,
-0.018345423,
-0.0271877535,
0.00394578,
0.046526596,
0.0949412435,
0.0163911786,
0.0019766763,
-0.0207560193,
0.0239767786,
0.0406974144,
0.053637065,
-0.0721129328,
0.0021813407,
-0.045434121,
-0.0123042502,
-0.058920335,
-0.051049687,
-0.0043516615,
0.0320388451,
0.0381969213,
0.0545954034,
-0.0252736285,
-0.0369470716,
-0.0676721931,
0.0157129243,
-0.0264686197,
0.0027636876,
-0.0249200668,
-0.032846164,
0.0327463672,
0.018988084,
-0.0348386727,
0.0494763851,
-0.0241970029,
-0.0205845572,
0.024174843,
-0.0315100998,
0.0217079073,
-0.0009300724,
-0.0440741405,
0.036697112,
0.0242161471,
0.0158847589,
-0.0089137536,
0.0168469306,
-0.0116952714,
0.0130435713,
-0.0082879746,
0.0275042783,
-0.0194243751,
0.0211163294,
-0.0296908878,
0.0741090849,
0.0188300274,
-0.0475191511,
0.0499318391,
0.0187453106,
0.0734558329,
-0.0576756336,
0.0010525691,
-0.0391652957,
-0.0776062012,
-0.0006308735,
-0.0267961659,
-0.0393726714,
-0.0100146001,
0.0449312851,
-0.0340681449,
-0.0081992429,
0.0485807098,
-0.0070612314,
0.0515986979,
-0.0393811986,
-0.017860854,
0.0188220907,
-0.0192332827,
0.0018784481,
0.0228852127,
-0.0191284176,
0.0186864976,
-0.0450243391,
-0.0070874677,
-0.0522878096,
0.0304669477,
-0.0160363205,
0.010830435,
-0.0379714817,
0.0372242443,
-0.0418048166,
-0.0668888167,
-0.0319223627,
0.0454071537,
0.0427574478,
-0.0319502987,
0.030881023,
-0.0464217588,
-0.0305556078,
-0.0432875976,
0.0244731233,
-0.0011369718,
-0.0040929788,
0.0284767821,
0.0028526438,
-0.0482699312,
-0.0057109492,
0.0416718684,
-0.0098059401,
0.0652093664,
0.0073802024,
-0.0347071476,
-0.0334731378,
-0.0041054157,
0.0187971704,
0.0065226904,
-0.0010372996,
0.0395402834,
-0.1170510501,
-0.0635509118,
-0.0000312793,
0.0298249274,
-0.013778883,
0.0335817412,
0.0235263705,
0.0763010085,
-0.0283249989,
0.0157692377,
-0.0328501388,
0.0286093131,
-0.0356022604,
-0.0422268398,
-0.0210671891,
-6.070893472e-33,
-0.019094089,
0.0329711549,
0.018955119,
-0.0275520831,
-0.0845459476,
0.0291687269,
0.0177505203,
-0.0062971758,
-0.0285145883,
0.0284225289,
-0.0234484766,
0.0158733465,
-0.0005396635,
-0.0295796692,
0.0061395979,
-0.0107049393,
0.0075975941,
-0.0212688819,
-0.0266600642,
-0.0102780778,
0.0690432191,
-0.0009410002,
0.0864711404,
-0.0434947237,
0.0548442639,
0.0094760908,
0.0014993836,
0.007114958,
0.0097138844,
0.0501663275,
-0.064479284,
0.0410869978,
0.0326278061,
-0.0083164955,
0.0074974904,
0.0123193217,
-0.0423072241,
-0.0245662909,
0.0383170657,
-0.0122011527,
-0.0184265971,
0.020740442,
-0.0014203023,
-0.0073291184,
-0.0656715333,
0.0174093526,
0.016247496,
0.0049256324,
-0.0711537451,
0.0254228879,
-0.0655370578,
0.0453676283,
0.0214533769,
-0.0650177598,
0.0400411449,
-0.0759486705,
0.0407091305,
-0.0436605364,
-0.0308745224,
-0.0076493975,
-0.0232381132,
0.0482313149,
0.0202720687,
0.0299068168,
0.0148415873,
0.0798349828,
0.032156989,
-0.0357118696,
0.0295149703,
-0.040175233,
0.0339333937,
0.0492655709,
-0.0506769978,
0.0804941207,
0.0716036484,
-0.0371741466,
0.0210759584,
0.0088163605,
0.0116391201,
0.0469425209,
0.023361899,
-0.0080334274,
-0.0482980981,
-0.0252417643,
-0.0717629343,
-0.0045158174,
-0.0284286253,
-0.0026204034,
0.0460645445,
0.0011834375,
0.0217828155,
-0.0165136773,
0.0193810184,
-0.0604855865,
-0.0149189774,
-0.0018206849,
-0.0116048884,
-0.0227967799,
-0.0032189409,
0.0175092947,
-0.0021686901,
-0.0634225234,
-0.0327432789,
0.0321355797,
-0.0092584928,
-0.0068438528,
-0.0033308421,
-0.001350124,
-0.0130885914,
0.0091355266,
-0.0288916193,
-0.0598441213,
-0.0273412522,
-0.03292064,
0.06610246,
-0.0100989854,
-0.0023935388,
-0.015977243,
0.0779600516,
0.0116863428,
-0.0210688803,
-0.0262343455,
-0.0265766121,
0.0238358527,
-0.0012416341,
0.0484362878,
-0.0337357931,
-0.0148471622,
0.0498643927,
-0.0102211908,
0.0134918494,
-0.0106431367,
2.67e-7,
0.0605330504,
0.0561461411,
0.0146339973,
0.0340276323,
-0.0121389506,
0.0075024283,
-0.0085158609,
0.0349188074,
-0.0684364364,
-0.010014398,
0.0170997903,
0.0196298417,
0.0391773395,
0.0054404004,
-0.0209016819,
0.0051963483,
-0.0804128423,
0.0572622791,
-0.0162621755,
0.0091843493,
0.0595516898,
0.1235022545,
0.0238454137,
-0.0059389556,
-0.0315353684,
-0.0556965582,
0.0575385466,
-0.037122082,
0.0033649143,
0.0336918905,
0.0206999499,
-0.0036869559,
0.0430596843,
-0.0086806212,
-0.0179172363,
0.0278717801,
0.0538337678,
0.0522548705,
-0.0085856672,
0.0659947991,
-0.0518676676,
-0.0494981706,
0.0087464945,
-0.0725387111,
0.0640526265,
-0.0214472152,
-0.0021525689,
-0.0869462118,
-0.0312264655,
0.0409033149,
0.0399857201,
-0.0068540485,
-0.0436493382,
0.015994804,
0.0283320844,
0.0260413438,
-0.0423982181,
-0.0466135442,
-0.0087693408,
0.0242017005,
-0.0155571187,
-0.0485738479,
0.006155605,
-0.0329198912,
0.0460967384,
-0.0081854872,
-0.0176130161,
2.31547339e-34,
0.0264662262,
0.0086100949,
0.0502392389,
0.0108708851,
0.037574172,
-0.0283573866,
0.1283943802,
0.0170505457,
-0.0087828506,
-0.0479000993,
0.0005788125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06345v1 | Schema Graph-Guided Prompt for Multi-Domain Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-11-10T19:00:02 | 2023-11-10T19:00:02 | Ruolin Su, Ting-Wei Wu, Biing-Hwang Juang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tracking dialogue states is an essential topic in task-oriented dialogue
systems, which involve filling in the necessary information in pre-defined
slots corresponding to a schema. While general pre-trained language models have
been shown effective in slot-filling, their performance is limited when applied
to specific domains. We propose a graph-based framework that learns
domain-specific prompts by incorporating the dialogue schema. Specifically, we
embed domain-specific schema encoded by a graph neural network into the
pre-trained language model, which allows for relations in the schema to guide
the model for better adaptation to the specific domain. Our experiments
demonstrate that the proposed graph-based method outperforms other multi-domain
DST approaches while using similar or fewer trainable parameters. We also
conduct a comprehensive study of schema graph architectures, parameter usage,
and module ablation that demonstrate the effectiveness of our model on
multi-domain dialogue state tracking. | [
0.0244736802,
0.0157828946,
-0.0088564204,
0.0146047492,
-0.0133355334,
-0.0262021627,
0.0178883951,
-0.0174847022,
0.0758166686,
-0.0678550825,
-0.0297143087,
-0.0750610232,
-0.0007192813,
0.0931351483,
-0.0010138621,
-0.0713682547,
0.0509654991,
-0.0260849521,
-0.0024736931,
0.0173439775,
0.0185166821,
0.001758982,
-0.0310768168,
0.0462260954,
-0.0308558084,
-0.0289283302,
-0.067981407,
0.028488351,
-0.0274384972,
-0.0510060973,
0.005195681,
0.0453544706,
0.043758668,
0.023324959,
0.0000018797,
-0.0473457985,
-0.0323090926,
-0.0331631377,
-0.044063177,
-0.0330634452,
-0.0257337894,
0.0113911275,
-0.0041273725,
0.0300153997,
-0.0528670214,
-0.0531410985,
0.052436281,
0.0452969298,
0.0805790797,
0.0851786658,
-0.024338305,
-0.0115483571,
0.0179249123,
-0.0285905544,
-0.0279418323,
-0.0953349322,
0.0046712831,
0.0246393066,
0.0210756343,
0.0085830856,
-0.0233179629,
0.0165851265,
0.0012190756,
-0.0470347032,
0.0028075944,
-0.0122303572,
0.0288678296,
0.0165979229,
-0.0427593067,
0.1275203973,
0.033579845,
0.043402493,
-0.0011516094,
-0.0148021439,
0.0305598322,
-0.0032460333,
-0.0346523449,
-0.0492004901,
-0.0330164209,
-0.0183992051,
-0.0346365422,
0.0049667452,
-0.0009501075,
-0.0448701978,
-0.0016792393,
0.0814650804,
-0.0053734146,
-0.024634501,
-0.0167881753,
-0.0019673782,
0.0131031321,
-0.0799476504,
0.0246319845,
0.0389011391,
-0.0743020177,
0.0358298421,
-0.0653357282,
-0.0085205995,
-0.0224228688,
0.0242050998,
0.0419891253,
0.0481769107,
-0.0261283908,
0.0327020511,
0.0503450073,
0.0657049716,
-0.0213736538,
-0.0025870625,
-0.0305374805,
-0.0010049453,
-0.071962826,
-0.0033355115,
-0.07841333,
0.0347300582,
-0.0244635772,
-0.0660501719,
-0.0331362709,
0.07278312,
0.0231999997,
0.0091524431,
0.0062668738,
0.0358889177,
-0.0079033151,
-0.0048298994,
-0.0359698571,
0.0717567727,
-0.0029939248,
-0.000798448,
0.0238981359,
0.0037429403,
-0.0315500833,
0.018310491,
0.0546031184,
-0.0137938652,
-0.0340365507,
0.1048630476,
0.0227684639,
-0.044027783,
-0.0151280975,
-0.027460251,
-0.0344725102,
-0.0385136083,
0.0146074528,
-0.0167302191,
0.0446922593,
0.0008534472,
-0.0088378116,
-0.0766863301,
-0.0049935142,
0.0231773648,
0.0002316674,
0.0547505915,
-0.0472497568,
0.0016501016,
0.0105071859,
-0.006432286,
-0.0319229998,
0.0260849614,
0.0240516793,
0.0310543347,
0.0234095398,
0.0063539147,
0.0079484703,
0.0166043062,
0.0226147436,
0.0072512673,
0.0247940719,
0.0153481206,
0.0118917441,
0.0122603029,
-0.0055267466,
0.0294746775,
-0.0313761309,
-0.0036001434,
0.0574087426,
0.0635399818,
0.0049832482,
-0.0255392715,
0.0527802221,
0.049951572,
0.0009762704,
0.0299168341,
-0.0372375473,
0.0224973354,
0.0063558449,
0.0019720604,
0.0145664793,
-0.0208351873,
-0.0357316844,
-0.03073241,
0.0076475805,
-0.0264303237,
0.0573491529,
-0.0053806459,
0.0333490856,
0.0117963273,
-0.0858977586,
0.0362867005,
0.0027017167,
-0.0326667242,
-0.0289752577,
-0.0058857389,
-0.0153101562,
0.0794709176,
0.0351499841,
-0.0392723344,
-0.0796555951,
-0.0338275619,
0.051421456,
0.0479124598,
0.0480694771,
-0.0405362956,
0.0400300324,
-0.0293856245,
-0.0340099223,
-0.0263805036,
0.0048602559,
0.0538286492,
0.0008944012,
-0.023183912,
0.0156679265,
-0.010152515,
0.0525529534,
-0.0016474448,
0.0163245685,
-0.006339659,
0.0016898765,
0.0102123274,
0.0270518828,
0.0511416979,
0.000652185,
-0.0074070622,
0.0019414409,
0.020581862,
0.0097902706,
-0.0019648049,
-0.0943853632,
-0.0437112153,
0.0214844868,
0.0497764386,
-0.0249586273,
-0.0221557412,
-0.0244528577,
-0.0807787627,
0.0178110395,
-0.0585580356,
0.0277453605,
-0.0321784429,
0.0038587293,
0.035666246,
0.0008714813,
-0.0207317285,
0.0336823389,
0.0313012078,
-0.0290185176,
0.056686461,
0.0309682302,
0.0353367627,
-0.0373192057,
0.0077574789,
0.026605064,
-0.0098400274,
0.0323968269,
0.020299159,
-0.0127550233,
-0.0558011234,
0.0270844232,
-0.0646665171,
-0.0074392972,
-0.0278980192,
0.0040879222,
-0.0063482523,
0.0362460725,
-0.0116341729,
-0.0493504293,
-0.0649799481,
0.0139991678,
0.0325233005,
-0.0103778578,
0.0321587846,
0.0282585062,
-0.0221235659,
-0.0410749428,
0.0174417533,
-0.0185970291,
0.0274496023,
-0.0188868586,
-0.0478628129,
-0.0772172809,
0.0659589991,
-0.0294166245,
0.0639424324,
-0.0064788554,
-0.0209616739,
0.0391625948,
0.0032708792,
0.035470549,
0.0289147664,
-0.0239707585,
0.014412594,
0.0150827421,
-0.0668402389,
-0.0436980575,
0.0322003588,
-0.0339545161,
0.0430148616,
-0.0426275581,
0.0676345602,
0.017223889,
0.0261363965,
0.035135895,
0.014149759,
-0.0608407296,
-0.016858004,
-0.0003721568,
0.0223033931,
-0.0139953289,
-0.0445396677,
-0.0400099233,
0.0185338352,
-0.016366737,
-0.02479784,
0.0767594799,
-0.040442843,
-0.0258890949,
-0.0122375423,
-0.0074435389,
-0.0520121306,
0.0666552857,
0.0051054861,
0.0191927105,
0.0866373479,
-0.0810756981,
-0.021209836,
-0.0045627593,
0.0088682109,
-0.0170306247,
0.0361281522,
-0.0239853002,
0.0363614,
-0.0124713695,
-0.0190623682,
-0.0463719331,
0.0110164862,
-0.0228490923,
0.0322762541,
0.0074534835,
-0.026852319,
0.0023792721,
0.027635321,
-0.0116050253,
0.0657079816,
-0.0191758722,
0.0148371346,
-0.038818799,
0.048924163,
0.0308031663,
0.0252008196,
-0.0482448824,
-0.0191067085,
0.054377649,
0.0203370564,
0.0359050557,
-0.0302026067,
-0.0035156077,
0.0089753484,
0.0096732564,
-0.0278817937,
-0.0217682477,
0.0085124699,
0.0673384145,
-0.0386896618,
0.0003637474,
0.128750667,
0.0275910832,
-0.0400982685,
-0.0340493508,
0.0129824243,
-0.0033529308,
0.0234395377,
0.0138371121,
-0.1117413044,
-0.0447193086,
-0.0064828745,
0.0107942922,
0.052884873,
-0.0388724543,
-0.039673645,
-0.0799237639,
-0.013832896,
0.0046870532,
-0.0240712073,
-0.0217215158,
0.0159840435,
0.034557946,
0.0417623557,
-0.0021586355,
-0.0165261663,
0.0138675999,
-0.0516233481,
0.014157665,
0.0093946559,
-0.0142257856,
0.0117327143,
-0.0127231851,
0.0595077723,
0.0468501635,
0.0367648602,
0.0326465517,
0.0307090655,
0.0223804731,
0.0262205768,
0.009064571,
0.0146276196,
0.0383965895,
-0.0329231434,
-0.0118544046,
0.0082587637,
0.0009888749,
-0.0541115813,
-0.0122908233,
0.0023227893,
0.0492602251,
-0.0514590777,
0.0261920299,
0.0088408478,
-0.0127187166,
0.036055509,
0.0247143973,
0.0349014252,
-0.0352079272,
-0.0244254358,
-0.037464574,
-0.0036776357,
-0.0233741868,
0.0097228158,
-0.0055239103,
-0.0116869286,
0.0455402397,
-0.0619058535,
-0.0502449498,
0.033995606,
0.0409140587,
0.0108033074,
0.0101101175,
0.0510057211,
0.0142625598,
-0.007246484,
-0.0099654365,
-0.0547005683,
0.0145905064,
-0.0762248412,
-0.0360707827,
0.0493990406,
-0.0245941691,
-0.0042820768,
0.0239283834,
-0.0501646474,
-0.0654986203,
-0.0389979519,
0.0168292839,
0.0189344659,
0.0491486043,
-0.0362203605,
0.0086709009,
-0.0194295794,
-0.0079593454,
-0.0115670273,
-0.0364395604,
0.0489837714,
0.0006709842,
-0.0277026929,
0.020755861,
-0.041716598,
0.0298917964,
-0.0154680451,
0.0286919568,
-0.0204312298,
-0.1004015952,
0.0103293071,
-0.0161312334,
0.0278175566,
0.0360900685,
0.0016735737,
-0.0367684402,
0.0215906594,
-0.0324322022,
-0.0203160886,
-0.0639011338,
0.0003766258,
-0.0297341868,
-0.0473425798,
0.0030874079,
-0.0491820425,
-0.0222661234,
0.0547293425,
-0.016939193,
-0.0331696682,
0.015001093,
-0.0224446692,
0.0258514974,
0.0035999729,
-0.0000839746,
0.0379866101,
0.0474404767,
0.0237246267,
-0.0062123337,
0.1009338647,
0.007094536,
-0.0300710779,
-0.0002791118,
0.0459063165,
-0.0611256771,
-0.0463864915,
-0.022137031,
0.01482898,
0.0479950793,
0.0250374284,
0.0255308188,
-0.0045218379,
0.0273594856,
-0.0196830798,
0.0759096891,
0.0388978831,
-0.0342609473,
0.0295654573,
0.0151982205,
-0.0128496783,
0.0353593789,
0.0603739321,
0.050051555,
0.0208705533,
0.0169772655,
-0.004916823,
-0.0616730787,
-0.0321536027,
-0.0032033105,
0.0642389804,
-0.0197124034,
0.0112736328,
-0.0490102209,
-0.0533540621,
0.0249279402,
-0.0257230122,
0.0030670029,
0.0044091027,
0.0511501208,
0.0256432202,
0.005505173,
0.004208067,
-0.0230818391,
-0.0223563407,
-0.0088721029,
-0.0119128106,
-0.0128067322,
-5.22109628e-33,
-0.0556674749,
-0.0507664122,
0.032506451,
0.0264617819,
-0.0485196076,
-0.0040050368,
-0.0733384117,
0.0151257459,
-0.0166680459,
-0.0220707282,
-0.0019305206,
0.0232798979,
0.0119395731,
0.020674957,
-0.0502383001,
-0.0384908617,
0.0452936962,
-0.0068207351,
0.0017213528,
0.0386836901,
0.0374450982,
0.0333195664,
0.0383101925,
-0.06640587,
0.0425217897,
0.0115055982,
0.0202882104,
0.0285098068,
0.0527708083,
0.0368445814,
-0.0199776497,
0.0479123034,
0.0069402913,
-0.0271039307,
-0.0168022886,
0.0626289994,
-0.0424327068,
-0.0425512418,
0.0039927354,
0.0061582085,
-0.0134048276,
0.0079676844,
-0.0273275673,
-0.0283414535,
0.0354097076,
0.0306153968,
0.0247304514,
0.0238780286,
-0.0314423144,
-0.0086886054,
-0.0668542385,
0.0217324831,
0.0075557781,
-0.0757701322,
-0.0072676828,
0.0667922571,
0.0468646921,
-0.0613338351,
-0.0134991417,
0.0220348183,
-0.0522343293,
-0.0232066959,
-0.0254342984,
0.0103860898,
-0.0053441753,
0.0813953131,
0.0070764502,
0.0356919952,
0.0136722699,
-0.0063250405,
-0.0204864517,
0.0118347807,
0.0071559576,
-0.0068425527,
-0.0656703487,
-0.0240475331,
-0.0514162853,
-0.0020990698,
0.0259597842,
0.0082387486,
-0.017334111,
0.023102304,
-0.0245836955,
-0.0246506259,
-0.0138956876,
0.0039775069,
-0.0006143585,
-0.0651680008,
0.0311393868,
-0.0243648607,
-0.0113577982,
0.0012347152,
0.0577636622,
-0.0346775874,
-0.0133315967,
0.0604073666,
-0.011507811,
0.0270760804,
-0.0211403258,
0.0181312412,
-0.0182266291,
-0.0400050096,
0.0424972065,
-0.0006324198,
0.0106371576,
0.0112382788,
-0.0092334086,
0.0326682106,
-0.0491009466,
0.0005828585,
-0.0442513712,
0.0218356941,
-0.0434150845,
0.0578038096,
0.0462038815,
0.0185320079,
-0.0297844745,
0.0955705792,
0.0120292231,
-0.0198033713,
-0.0512411967,
-0.0061131441,
0.0141268279,
0.0283480398,
-0.0297351591,
-0.0230703205,
-0.0205757562,
-0.0073446659,
0.013904592,
-0.0326188169,
0.0052864859,
-0.0324015208,
2.607e-7,
0.006412542,
0.0369436182,
0.0527009927,
0.0474866778,
0.0355917625,
0.0537065938,
-0.0060241343,
0.033378575,
0.0333846286,
-0.0378983654,
0.0223080162,
0.0110536171,
-0.0012808311,
0.0164915845,
-0.144957602,
-0.0089801978,
-0.0048908736,
-0.0116312234,
-0.0221994072,
0.0541711263,
0.0355925374,
0.0477362722,
0.0187561568,
0.0212170202,
-0.0013147074,
-0.0213449169,
0.0436063074,
0.0098881936,
-0.0026609937,
0.0132725965,
-0.0195014272,
0.005981965,
-0.0486823805,
0.0136249978,
0.003586232,
0.047412131,
0.027179664,
0.0568651929,
-0.009075895,
-0.0287116747,
-0.0188628938,
0.0014681482,
0.0169239696,
0.01035723,
0.0338307209,
-0.0388398841,
-0.0235050097,
-0.0380204916,
-0.0052079717,
-0.0384587571,
0.0092109982,
0.0262873638,
-0.004579132,
0.010790091,
-0.0011442399,
-0.0017031073,
0.0175266527,
-0.0762968361,
-0.0101971123,
-0.0169552639,
-0.0191852786,
-0.0449670926,
-0.0215103105,
-0.0366286375,
0.0065057045,
-0.0150942802,
-0.011146347,
2.26912103e-34,
0.0359376036,
-0.0194684323,
0.0211647842,
0.0437238514,
0.0235493965,
-0.0017699486,
-0.008875154,
-0.006401957,
0.0652384087,
-0.0744673982,
-0.0427425355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06243v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06243v2 | Parameter-Efficient Orthogonal Finetuning via Butterfly Factorization | 2023-11-10T18:59:54 | 2024-04-28T20:05:02 | Weiyang Liu, Zeju Qiu, Yao Feng, Yuliang Xiu, Yuxuan Xue, Longhui Yu, Haiwen Feng, Zhen Liu, Juyeon Heo, Songyou Peng, Yandong Wen, Michael J. Black, Adrian Weller, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Large foundation models are becoming ubiquitous, but training them from
scratch is prohibitively expensive. Thus, efficiently adapting these powerful
models to downstream tasks is increasingly important. In this paper, we study a
principled finetuning paradigm -- Orthogonal Finetuning (OFT) -- for downstream
task adaptation. Despite demonstrating good generalizability, OFT still uses a
fairly large number of trainable parameters due to the high dimensionality of
orthogonal matrices. To address this, we start by examining OFT from an
information transmission perspective, and then identify a few key desiderata
that enable better parameter-efficiency. Inspired by how the Cooley-Tukey fast
Fourier transform algorithm enables efficient information transmission, we
propose an efficient orthogonal parameterization using butterfly structures. We
apply this parameterization to OFT, creating a novel parameter-efficient
finetuning method, called Orthogonal Butterfly (BOFT). By subsuming OFT as a
special case, BOFT introduces a generalized orthogonal finetuning framework.
Finally, we conduct an extensive empirical study of adapting large vision
transformers, large language models, and text-to-image diffusion models to
various downstream tasks in vision and language. | [
0.0176043008,
0.0806402117,
0.0149766998,
0.0600965694,
-0.0108943535,
0.0410350114,
-0.0267521981,
0.0079193618,
-0.0760340691,
-0.0383350104,
-0.0316844508,
-0.0223770849,
0.0437446199,
-0.0511210524,
0.0233254191,
-0.0807166547,
-0.0079124263,
-0.050641153,
-0.1048370376,
-0.005228742,
-0.0106437607,
0.0014546787,
0.0056773555,
0.0158490874,
0.0143534867,
-0.0231176205,
-0.0189294368,
0.0321863294,
0.0629023612,
0.0242699701,
-0.026986815,
0.0490799211,
0.025865728,
-0.0153169986,
0.0000021762,
0.0012030861,
0.024923753,
0.031135235,
0.0457530059,
0.0254413858,
0.0873127952,
-0.0329295509,
-0.0387889594,
-0.009218066,
-0.0217933226,
-0.0277562942,
0.0664859191,
0.0812244788,
0.0218594484,
0.0381646156,
-0.0223286506,
-0.0680926293,
0.0427397415,
-0.0237695947,
-0.0016599885,
-0.0555945747,
0.0293877535,
-0.0680156797,
-0.0160173047,
-0.0094267894,
-0.0755726919,
0.0488046594,
-0.0125404047,
0.0246094652,
0.0367727429,
0.0226773154,
0.0101042502,
-0.0273093563,
-0.021979196,
0.0715698972,
-0.1053143367,
0.0275498666,
0.0047713779,
0.0102158533,
-0.0086556422,
0.0555696487,
-0.057247594,
-0.0193561129,
0.0188686792,
0.0087234415,
-0.0127481315,
-0.0581513084,
0.0319571011,
0.013386813,
-0.0409517251,
0.0425138399,
0.016106749,
0.0100606978,
0.0089353323,
-0.045341406,
-0.0437192097,
-0.0140509726,
-0.0152810849,
0.0244343076,
0.0147475451,
-0.0084153805,
-0.0602844171,
-0.0083674807,
-0.0150593501,
-0.0075481436,
0.0881413072,
0.0149300266,
-0.0512450039,
0.0305715613,
-0.0589900762,
0.0075237118,
-0.1131569967,
0.0731390044,
-0.0528823212,
0.0262273811,
-0.0281519219,
0.034527231,
-0.0225923229,
0.0397996865,
-0.0262592342,
-0.0275324956,
-0.0126678813,
-0.014222051,
-0.0064378725,
-0.0338666216,
0.034133628,
0.0159129389,
-0.0437206365,
-0.0331053436,
0.026986897,
0.0557467975,
0.0145892659,
0.0152495382,
-0.0122729708,
-0.0376825593,
-0.0133703584,
0.0324063636,
0.0528376102,
-0.0216211639,
0.0083316956,
0.0407852791,
-0.0135684218,
-0.0058982363,
-0.0362520516,
0.040473707,
-0.0195592828,
-0.0605490655,
-0.0098833218,
-0.0684919953,
0.0120675983,
0.0054393923,
0.0435666777,
-0.0390165709,
0.0212489646,
0.0405250676,
-0.0616069362,
0.0533393808,
-0.0311414227,
0.0074647488,
0.0058007189,
0.0081920866,
0.0421425961,
0.0629729331,
0.0397694483,
0.0162868332,
-0.0125438264,
-0.0096860314,
-0.0154344728,
0.0552250966,
-0.0008467209,
0.042728994,
0.0084361816,
-0.0240661632,
0.0006283803,
-0.0135163348,
0.0381085761,
0.0666233003,
-0.021502601,
0.0100177014,
0.0427204221,
0.043426808,
0.0499217696,
0.0542012043,
0.0453297012,
0.0047459211,
-0.0217101034,
0.0555143207,
-0.012362754,
0.0565664917,
0.0265935119,
-0.0261933636,
-0.015997028,
0.0600836836,
-0.0569110624,
-0.0286356695,
0.0260926932,
-0.0196767244,
-0.0223891027,
-0.0038237097,
0.049778562,
0.0202324335,
-0.0574795939,
-0.0010915744,
0.0390472375,
-0.0648931414,
0.0145984115,
-0.0286891293,
-0.0458635353,
0.0610993579,
-0.0045836177,
-0.0271104053,
0.0262234882,
-0.0199327748,
0.0415154472,
-0.0111696972,
0.0360755101,
0.0115910014,
0.0228788815,
-0.0293494556,
-0.0222479012,
0.060268525,
0.0067352587,
0.0065230946,
-0.0146435061,
0.0132340565,
0.0126516139,
0.0052415561,
-0.0292068049,
0.0628840178,
0.0313502327,
-0.0256085061,
0.0189659745,
0.035082709,
0.0244490821,
0.0180687476,
-0.0011116117,
-0.032505922,
0.0236911923,
-0.0383927301,
-0.0063705705,
-0.0353289284,
-0.0006013209,
0.0122898379,
0.0266652424,
-0.0300482847,
0.0134618739,
0.0754504725,
-0.0311753917,
-0.0556052141,
0.0491163917,
0.0050810329,
-0.0388655625,
-0.0046113632,
0.0071574296,
-0.0171511862,
0.0183104984,
-0.0206339695,
0.0187224951,
-0.0069277971,
0.0000212456,
-0.0176097788,
0.0240472089,
0.0159231052,
-0.0325054377,
-0.0439355634,
0.0001659397,
0.0028849787,
0.0384194627,
0.009907363,
0.0122707533,
0.0012489172,
-0.0553512312,
-0.0432932675,
0.0100066056,
-0.0341959298,
0.010263822,
0.0139949573,
0.0026172441,
0.050595846,
0.0167045519,
-0.0257504024,
0.0381421261,
-0.0668514371,
-0.0227064714,
-0.0040372405,
0.00584753,
-0.0589027628,
-0.0069520539,
-0.0448266305,
0.0184231047,
0.0384724699,
-0.0069653904,
-0.0442611054,
-0.0572313629,
0.0015337827,
-0.007897553,
0.0258574151,
-0.0127180154,
-0.0126943551,
-0.0368364863,
-0.0253155734,
0.0219331924,
0.1096547991,
0.0133607341,
0.0303015709,
0.0193340797,
0.0253714602,
0.0346214771,
0.0198445637,
-0.0432771295,
-0.0446245633,
-0.0509260409,
0.0091802729,
-0.0114534125,
0.0123221586,
-0.0418598726,
0.0033450583,
-0.0508692972,
-0.0090705799,
-0.0012123294,
0.0084738871,
-0.0132149849,
0.0068821795,
-0.0216556005,
0.008163102,
-0.0313173756,
-0.0280476529,
0.0089054601,
-0.0020134517,
0.019797191,
0.0033934249,
0.0130659472,
-0.0277166385,
0.0008355728,
-0.0137791773,
0.0253369752,
-0.0423263498,
0.0156902354,
-0.0769700781,
-0.0207618382,
0.0309619494,
-0.0322657265,
0.0403672047,
-0.0079923598,
0.0152911749,
-0.0326429978,
-0.0219059382,
-0.0085654557,
-0.0299649015,
-0.0202361681,
0.0038248918,
0.0150568066,
-0.040001411,
-0.0213185009,
0.0330976844,
0.039962057,
0.0210348908,
-0.0263557658,
-0.0058286358,
-0.0398109108,
0.0486475639,
0.0339709334,
0.0131954355,
0.0255130958,
-0.0349157527,
0.035343457,
0.0127969356,
0.047772117,
-0.0040472895,
-0.0363609307,
0.02499507,
0.0220404677,
0.0151792197,
-0.0388578251,
0.0078130653,
0.0213209167,
-0.0477088988,
0.0147125265,
0.0283030048,
-0.0044223065,
-0.0665893033,
0.0139340824,
0.0446492508,
0.0406459868,
0.023215862,
-0.0002532327,
-0.0265277214,
-0.0394885167,
0.001179483,
0.0189042594,
0.0511073694,
-0.0164225865,
0.0123492656,
-0.0327440836,
0.0780515596,
0.0452401415,
0.01451548,
-0.0548463725,
-0.0080657424,
0.0555779412,
-0.0266411062,
-0.0080880597,
0.010351155,
-0.0271770898,
-0.0307680927,
0.009864198,
0.0142944679,
-0.0479388349,
-0.0223340429,
-0.0386025272,
-0.0600273423,
0.0378095359,
-0.0043496056,
-0.003705102,
-0.0856296271,
0.0190744307,
-0.0517753512,
0.000468299,
-0.0207129009,
0.0468782596,
0.011466343,
-0.042088557,
0.0259121638,
0.0514977649,
-0.0391543843,
0.0038297654,
-0.0384728909,
0.0571844727,
0.0228364486,
0.0010027658,
0.0285217743,
-0.0211430676,
-0.0203209147,
0.0065613715,
0.001095069,
-0.0623208992,
-0.0138771841,
0.0016429002,
-0.0264083948,
-0.0251903627,
-0.0677263886,
0.0022759133,
0.0316338949,
-0.0629175082,
-0.0486575067,
0.0623439439,
0.0275302641,
0.0305343959,
0.0145114409,
0.0033068729,
0.0709942952,
0.0001739432,
-0.0530791804,
0.0201251488,
-0.0465768389,
0.0424948856,
-0.0140542733,
-0.0152966185,
0.0469817072,
-0.0103714885,
-0.0061075105,
0.0064652371,
-0.1115162075,
-0.0301871803,
0.0192106944,
0.038941063,
0.007940907,
0.0152398851,
-0.0054023811,
-0.0721317157,
0.0008154837,
0.0290296935,
-0.0023850272,
0.0701987818,
0.0234624799,
-0.058560539,
-0.003510878,
0.060792923,
-0.0347812809,
0.0197200216,
0.0109359026,
0.033179868,
0.0074028596,
-0.0113741318,
0.0177708752,
-0.0267705675,
0.0089761037,
0.0010629973,
0.0121299056,
-0.0132190902,
0.0306445006,
0.0323214754,
-0.0101588657,
-0.0619834214,
-0.0315584242,
0.0276402384,
0.0430566892,
0.0085114073,
0.0035992661,
0.0573582612,
-0.030184811,
-0.0217056721,
0.0276840273,
-0.0657136068,
-0.0117392894,
0.0205563009,
0.0478512868,
0.0034582641,
0.0370480046,
0.0077738701,
-0.0128564909,
0.0010157079,
0.0312771127,
0.0239781812,
0.0326586664,
-0.0727180466,
-0.0093270317,
-0.0604857318,
-0.0739624649,
-0.0688741282,
-0.0210923366,
0.0176232941,
0.0111493142,
0.0586303398,
-0.0268184356,
-0.0477369539,
-0.0285324175,
0.019893717,
-0.0297665391,
0.0253988411,
0.0382960327,
0.0168174133,
0.0237115249,
-0.0063293101,
0.0610425882,
-0.0272274986,
-0.0187545866,
-0.0028671466,
0.0281564519,
-0.0345628262,
0.0138636343,
-0.0139530506,
0.035494972,
0.0339907445,
0.0235861186,
-0.0130387358,
-0.0564888269,
-0.0084456718,
-0.0560960546,
0.0041023968,
-0.0617213771,
0.0644390583,
0.0129718129,
0.0076594106,
0.0214880388,
-0.0015145452,
-0.0632739961,
0.0197864547,
-0.0222488251,
0.0194416102,
-6.193862671e-33,
-0.0298055205,
0.0186078548,
-0.0260164607,
0.1143366694,
-0.0356578752,
-0.029489236,
0.0259458851,
0.0188987534,
-0.0512982979,
0.0188458879,
0.0148749007,
0.0131480992,
0.0022268272,
0.0280604195,
-0.0285293888,
-0.0039184247,
0.0663460121,
-0.0364460461,
0.0108988732,
0.0294179022,
-0.0162659399,
0.0276946779,
0.0323053487,
-0.0943708196,
-0.0782244429,
-0.0156499427,
-0.0255495291,
0.0106952908,
-0.0056316983,
0.014181857,
-0.031664934,
0.0263485778,
-0.0200464632,
-0.0193864163,
-0.0158526227,
0.0094063058,
-0.0943853781,
0.0144226411,
0.0041971677,
0.0388450846,
-0.0322129801,
-0.0323114879,
0.0578376651,
0.0283778589,
-0.0361342467,
-0.0600451902,
0.0100065721,
-0.0447675064,
-0.0198280383,
-0.0083821323,
-0.0668791905,
0.0373071097,
-0.0117597403,
-0.0680099577,
0.0717233643,
-0.0303388238,
-0.0617211573,
0.0208822638,
-0.0078084432,
-0.0113391383,
0.0501628071,
0.0689331144,
0.0217236914,
0.0327647515,
-0.0108561562,
0.0031893344,
0.0639951825,
0.0051113982,
0.0130344518,
-0.0395152345,
0.0566890687,
0.0718933716,
0.0623320565,
0.010957093,
0.0412916206,
0.0170812607,
-0.0532927364,
-0.0189335272,
-0.0821072757,
0.0173245762,
0.0357931629,
0.0110115735,
0.0337012671,
-0.0249201227,
-0.0453967527,
-0.0283713695,
-0.045542229,
0.0321038365,
0.0071933111,
0.0358281806,
-0.0332995355,
0.0443099178,
0.0253732577,
-0.0298487488,
0.0208903458,
-0.017486101,
-0.0377381928,
0.0615550242,
0.0162571725,
-0.0384358279,
-0.0318841003,
-0.0253683068,
0.0131408554,
0.0262716506,
0.0181257538,
-0.0171592217,
0.0680523366,
0.0454230197,
-0.0702071935,
-0.0557990894,
-0.0192525499,
0.0036565876,
0.0286629405,
0.0758961216,
0.0361952223,
-0.0027796279,
-0.0001787194,
0.0392246395,
0.0012838676,
-0.0089130783,
-0.0370311253,
-0.0076849991,
-0.001583632,
0.0144542623,
-0.0097010909,
0.0150592541,
-0.0076609347,
0.0257618111,
0.0358279943,
-0.0661630705,
-0.0472133532,
0.0326764844,
3.047e-7,
0.0249974541,
0.0256637074,
0.0001491036,
-0.0373439379,
0.0039792364,
0.0040468951,
0.0079605933,
0.0169009287,
0.0049873558,
-0.0366233103,
0.0189340953,
0.0579154156,
0.0316458642,
-0.0186181851,
-0.0253989939,
0.008920582,
-0.0018280022,
0.0319183655,
-0.0163673572,
-0.0329553857,
0.0016136341,
0.095327422,
-0.0157087296,
-0.0325772502,
0.0269651022,
0.0357586779,
0.0691529587,
0.0011466999,
0.0558379181,
-0.0254622586,
-0.0431533009,
0.0030062248,
-0.0364535786,
0.0426622964,
-0.0021280693,
0.0426208898,
0.0258731637,
0.0239063576,
-0.03029521,
0.0397034138,
0.0172795914,
0.0285881311,
-0.0084321611,
-0.0692213252,
0.0453099273,
-0.0867282823,
0.009690281,
-0.0454206094,
-0.0124505479,
0.0338584483,
-0.0012608636,
-0.0094693955,
0.0162582342,
0.0260958839,
0.0341409631,
0.0071464069,
-0.0384434499,
-0.0834310651,
0.0306422189,
0.0630814061,
-0.023454668,
-0.0782830194,
-0.0577905513,
-0.0537082739,
0.0363061726,
0.0157699231,
-0.0374335237,
2.578175255e-34,
0.0185814388,
-0.0060525965,
0.0068751201,
0.0016690113,
-0.0131057547,
-0.0216231607,
-0.007422525,
0.0076272995,
0.0139772398,
-0.0829032734,
-0.0048761875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06239v1 | Argumentation Element Annotation Modeling using XLNet | 2023-11-10T18:55:23 | 2023-11-10T18:55:23 | Christopher Ormerod, Amy Burkhardt, Mackenzie Young, Sue Lottridge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This study demonstrates the effectiveness of XLNet, a transformer-based
language model, for annotating argumentative elements in persuasive essays.
XLNet's architecture incorporates a recurrent mechanism that allows it to model
long-term dependencies in lengthy texts. Fine-tuned XLNet models were applied
to three datasets annotated with different schemes - a proprietary dataset
using the Annotations for Revisions and Reflections on Writing (ARROW) scheme,
the PERSUADE corpus, and the Argument Annotated Essays (AAE) dataset. The XLNet
models achieved strong performance across all datasets, even surpassing human
agreement levels in some cases. This shows XLNet capably handles diverse
annotation schemes and lengthy essays. Comparisons between the model outputs on
different datasets also revealed insights into the relationships between the
annotation tags. Overall, XLNet's strong performance on modeling argumentative
structures across diverse datasets highlights its suitability for providing
automated feedback on essay organization. | [
0.0125843044,
0.0342081673,
0.0313002467,
0.0159044936,
-0.0277575329,
0.0083616981,
0.007554905,
-0.0332016908,
0.0109202201,
-0.0846603885,
0.0108789392,
-0.0135290371,
-0.0049589276,
-0.0328070261,
-0.0031885698,
-0.0500680357,
-0.0112123182,
0.0368217379,
0.0710383058,
0.0154506313,
0.040674042,
0.0070382087,
-0.0152621707,
0.0648718849,
-0.0228813477,
-0.0641616061,
0.0044264719,
0.0172946323,
0.0170932226,
-0.0340576284,
0.0342755653,
0.0892396271,
0.004654143,
0.0412684157,
0.0000019848,
-0.0309934951,
0.0063883797,
0.0162611101,
-0.0123580368,
0.0488694981,
0.0783765092,
0.0350166671,
-0.0501774028,
0.0270276107,
-0.0304998644,
-0.0029005681,
0.0602551848,
0.1117747128,
0.0783097148,
0.070574522,
-0.0185907912,
-0.0140114529,
0.057611037,
-0.002891555,
-0.0535709374,
0.0429000072,
0.0124285538,
0.00871858,
0.0000672379,
0.0418355167,
0.0031147085,
0.0315721445,
0.0177459214,
-0.0639311299,
-0.0157489367,
-0.0056545357,
-0.0466280058,
0.0181407724,
-0.0055968226,
0.0008210093,
0.0366353467,
-0.0393515229,
0.0116895642,
-0.012158907,
0.0274660569,
-0.0022512842,
-0.0645875484,
0.0432157591,
0.0001264494,
0.0167175326,
0.0742684156,
0.0023084076,
0.0009229381,
0.0106827961,
0.0019386047,
0.0045353142,
-0.0190819446,
-0.0292872097,
0.0143937068,
-0.0055550509,
-0.0079772659,
-0.0833564252,
-0.0081391623,
0.0106022181,
0.0181200802,
0.017958317,
-0.0092674196,
-0.0390920565,
0.0305476263,
-0.1055974811,
0.0619104318,
-0.0148640424,
-0.0167552363,
-0.0079175029,
0.0043620788,
0.0066429409,
-0.0190855917,
-0.0100561185,
0.0186188985,
-0.0027744549,
-0.0647134036,
-0.0271373857,
-0.0623298027,
-0.0066518243,
0.0048803575,
-0.0184300784,
-0.0219982322,
-0.0139893796,
-0.0473341048,
0.0189974736,
0.0180226378,
-0.0014318369,
-0.0018800196,
-0.0000394894,
-0.0118159894,
0.0520675555,
-0.0150142638,
0.0151143447,
0.0417149663,
-0.0347164832,
0.0040576118,
0.0670429543,
-0.0102657396,
-0.0177850034,
-0.0339098237,
0.0039101779,
-0.0230720285,
0.0352480784,
-0.0353632793,
-0.0472325087,
-0.0403974019,
-0.0247057881,
-0.0080631999,
-0.087179549,
-0.0191525556,
-0.0110556101,
-0.0005240382,
-0.0720646456,
0.0041500228,
0.0271941777,
-0.0045952285,
0.0262435041,
0.0014569106,
-0.024820203,
0.0480668023,
-0.0129152993,
-0.0151259238,
0.0047926796,
0.0573169142,
0.0287728962,
0.0427196734,
0.0065459427,
0.0433186628,
0.0050572413,
-0.0218948759,
-0.0109392358,
0.049893856,
-0.0301686022,
-0.0537738912,
0.0369653143,
-0.042222362,
0.0435641892,
-0.0215773135,
0.0031745068,
0.050127089,
0.0484441444,
0.0388770662,
0.0187058616,
0.0031201814,
0.0266603157,
0.0327829868,
0.0100335134,
-0.0297540799,
0.0327892415,
0.0343001634,
-0.0153420754,
-0.0112963757,
-0.0272612907,
-0.0040387516,
-0.0872782692,
-0.0531597771,
-0.0140894651,
-0.0049649621,
-0.0319952853,
0.0093080038,
0.0343074948,
-0.0429439358,
0.0104835862,
0.0146632539,
-0.0706356391,
-0.0500890985,
0.0090272455,
0.0301508922,
0.0379940234,
0.0111917891,
-0.018477926,
-0.0174503513,
-0.0799525529,
0.0768580735,
0.0645281747,
0.0559151247,
-0.029049933,
-0.0644173101,
-0.0687280893,
-0.0270626843,
-0.0217144601,
0.0276592728,
0.0346708521,
-0.0018157669,
-0.0303812176,
0.0252634324,
0.0268162116,
-0.100373432,
0.0483760498,
-0.0136132473,
0.0009352982,
0.0014249285,
0.0055393516,
0.0352273881,
0.0472682454,
-0.0237579327,
0.0260859244,
0.0076521998,
-0.0327869169,
-0.0296144783,
0.0226601977,
0.000865627,
0.0200588685,
0.0229269713,
-0.0525019988,
0.0140677141,
-0.0200045146,
-0.0117971906,
-0.039201282,
0.0221842583,
-0.0291312337,
0.0243909042,
-0.0216988549,
-0.0203878768,
0.0120266574,
-0.0087729553,
-0.0328642949,
-0.006027462,
0.0564412437,
-0.0205655545,
-0.0146932108,
0.0046658251,
0.0383250564,
-0.0244600382,
-0.0356428288,
-0.0032269326,
0.0303010326,
0.0052072895,
0.049567014,
-0.0298076067,
0.0034245888,
-0.0396038517,
-0.0988534465,
0.0036466485,
-0.0386615619,
0.0319675021,
0.006875616,
-0.0486238599,
0.0252166837,
0.0177059267,
-0.041164387,
-0.0330200978,
-0.0428614467,
-0.0049884678,
0.0516624004,
-0.0170720648,
0.0136974873,
-0.0317422561,
-0.0225942228,
-0.0487522967,
0.0208437443,
0.0568222366,
-0.059426602,
-0.0279909074,
0.0170087293,
0.0069031743,
-0.009098988,
0.0016570385,
-0.0357808024,
0.0385145508,
0.0161793325,
0.0685164556,
0.0500580519,
0.0292646643,
0.0120358458,
0.0264625717,
0.005085275,
-0.0366211906,
-0.0114880037,
-0.007687957,
0.0444293618,
-0.0197225735,
-0.031524837,
0.0161450766,
0.0660893917,
0.0033287453,
-0.0047631832,
-0.0450939424,
0.0364112221,
-0.030798208,
0.0246395171,
0.034449704,
-0.0468686074,
-0.0041828901,
0.0213628057,
-0.0149114775,
0.0096477047,
0.0320295282,
-0.0346533619,
-0.001595943,
-0.0170220975,
-0.0152519569,
-0.0299206264,
0.0420241505,
-0.0020518352,
-0.0072895042,
0.0296613779,
-0.0008570885,
-0.0053439667,
-0.0447913967,
0.0479277894,
-0.0162245054,
0.0646107718,
-0.016834395,
0.0163525306,
0.0041840542,
-0.0119714197,
-0.0185324997,
0.0023782656,
-0.0145817958,
-0.0022124283,
-0.001077511,
-0.0282126125,
0.0100451382,
-0.003846555,
-0.0094249723,
0.075385347,
-0.0348052159,
0.0065119513,
0.0071473219,
0.0082476502,
-0.0137394145,
-0.0136448964,
0.0135280723,
-0.0111844037,
0.0444742292,
0.0531703942,
-0.0890959352,
-0.0162395295,
-0.069652155,
-0.0559096783,
-0.0278944056,
-0.0657679662,
-0.0328186527,
-0.0351282991,
0.0387980975,
-0.0903885216,
-0.006495574,
0.0880826488,
0.0177153219,
0.0024193798,
-0.0096171359,
-0.0439978093,
0.0338426381,
0.010556493,
0.0456926748,
-0.0671493784,
-0.0082286,
-0.0204092711,
0.0260420982,
-0.0346210822,
-0.0203256868,
0.0157663617,
-0.0493008681,
0.090789862,
0.0162914935,
0.0301966853,
0.0214579292,
-0.0226406027,
-0.0462553278,
-0.0470693856,
-0.0289175734,
-0.0129370987,
0.0125226723,
-0.0033683004,
0.0371867977,
-0.0633367971,
0.0142979147,
-0.0300470628,
-0.0231313296,
0.0455759093,
0.0074457899,
0.0582798235,
-0.0137193156,
-0.0342000984,
0.0731296912,
-0.0011917319,
-0.0260775574,
-0.0058123549,
0.0461491942,
-0.00362604,
0.0141813774,
-0.0121354023,
0.0521782823,
-0.0101533756,
-0.0719697252,
0.0404535532,
0.0594199598,
-0.0382029451,
0.0076427688,
-0.0330284983,
0.019196339,
0.0112980613,
0.0594213791,
0.0510074049,
-0.0167171694,
-0.034886457,
-0.0623225197,
-0.0069797109,
-0.0753823817,
0.0015191507,
-0.029689122,
-0.017188482,
0.0206572488,
-0.0776421502,
-0.0476198867,
-0.0223792288,
0.0163804088,
0.0347703174,
0.0026311066,
0.0058607357,
-0.0035325717,
-0.0460503735,
0.0081158504,
-0.0003310601,
0.0018105152,
0.0071390504,
-0.0203764793,
0.0289868955,
0.0098879896,
-0.0251779947,
0.0180290993,
0.011315397,
-0.0478502475,
0.0106338756,
0.0128805181,
0.0146331321,
0.0477951653,
0.0130155142,
-0.0500683077,
0.0062925131,
-0.0013011275,
0.0683293417,
-0.0268449988,
0.0507161207,
-0.0002994873,
0.0003296721,
0.0086121112,
0.0394466966,
0.0640886426,
0.0070630363,
0.0280662589,
-0.0365736932,
0.0029226146,
-0.0033040983,
0.0084935073,
0.0257901177,
-0.0058836788,
-0.0378791392,
-0.0717337206,
0.010773927,
-0.0533511937,
-0.023933772,
-0.0387571417,
0.0419000089,
-0.0089519704,
-0.0329508856,
-0.0226247218,
0.0210098345,
-0.0386586711,
0.0282338057,
0.0026369819,
0.0915917754,
-0.0160727017,
0.0268061608,
-0.0327149853,
-0.0011759226,
-0.0385246575,
0.0309460592,
0.0153590608,
0.0433330126,
-0.0086058993,
0.0526142828,
0.0327853933,
0.0164063647,
0.0396574996,
0.0356479101,
-0.064304851,
0.0153653622,
-0.0350853093,
-0.0194408502,
-0.0084917163,
-0.0298459567,
0.1021563038,
-0.0561321266,
-0.002448234,
-0.0172875598,
0.0613179877,
0.0211455636,
-0.0021961937,
0.018450303,
0.0050549009,
-0.0264834631,
-0.0108499071,
0.0123116719,
-0.0636646077,
0.011714004,
0.0113761444,
-0.0280554146,
-0.0566356182,
-0.0560259968,
0.0177189894,
-0.0107713686,
0.0053827106,
-0.0418017022,
-0.0256196577,
0.0112792347,
-0.0200836528,
0.0440826081,
-0.0004374758,
-0.0025391621,
0.0132304765,
0.0333172418,
-0.0116526121,
0.0126505569,
-0.0559255593,
0.0141001074,
0.0081531042,
-0.021890834,
-0.0173143689,
-5.33571506e-33,
-0.0120307514,
-0.0069018342,
0.0041046957,
0.0875360221,
-0.0192814153,
0.001017265,
-0.054704871,
0.0113965739,
0.0065920786,
0.0998691022,
-0.0084274625,
0.0125616342,
0.0066080401,
0.0378605798,
0.0267635975,
0.0225047674,
0.0620129481,
0.0208281558,
-0.0312554203,
0.0246348809,
0.0435399562,
-0.02769644,
0.0519039631,
-0.0839932784,
0.0888925046,
-0.0183226429,
-0.0094063729,
-0.0305386987,
-0.0005162084,
0.0533630662,
0.0275291037,
0.0310968123,
0.0241309498,
-0.0760754347,
0.0039357143,
0.0590739585,
-0.0489665829,
-0.0036952375,
0.0193567257,
-0.0261115655,
0.0002285255,
-0.0747650117,
0.0338863097,
-0.0180453248,
-0.0297667906,
-0.017814476,
0.0552693605,
-0.0200064518,
0.0097724637,
-0.044619333,
-0.0796799436,
0.0502151065,
-0.0220748633,
-0.0074217347,
-0.0041415174,
0.0419844389,
-0.0152981235,
0.0398890972,
-0.0563298091,
0.0191103909,
0.0146426,
0.0374579206,
-0.0164289065,
-0.0307917316,
-0.0284782983,
0.0515211262,
0.007599954,
0.0090955123,
-0.0390221775,
0.0427119695,
0.0048526642,
0.006495025,
0.10714221,
0.0373720005,
0.0115600927,
-0.0058388915,
-0.0518721305,
-0.0074579907,
0.0087986114,
0.0125568118,
0.0258979108,
-0.0474135019,
-0.0046149143,
-0.0244838316,
-0.0286878236,
-0.1120899469,
0.0094315419,
-0.0457151569,
0.0063217143,
-0.023938382,
-0.0036876393,
0.053176146,
0.0033719756,
-0.0451857336,
-0.0174894072,
0.0006794448,
-0.0002143872,
0.0448140688,
-0.0226219986,
-0.0194288082,
-0.0423985347,
0.032081265,
0.0037997146,
0.0298965182,
0.0500975922,
0.0215635262,
0.0876788646,
-0.0160958897,
-0.0503706895,
-0.0226615909,
-0.013568284,
0.023002414,
-0.0358665362,
0.0425376408,
0.0065401481,
0.0392408706,
0.0229022428,
0.0441266559,
-0.003028149,
0.0134266624,
-0.0210123006,
-0.0365744829,
0.0203702208,
-0.0195317641,
-0.0204196386,
0.0030588752,
0.0142605742,
0.0422471389,
0.0177462101,
-0.046933081,
0.0041571842,
-0.0046117036,
2.459e-7,
0.0512384064,
0.0807373002,
0.0512209386,
-0.0594888479,
0.0175396707,
0.0087679876,
-0.0204669442,
0.0016570953,
-0.0030757824,
-0.0177854709,
0.007518156,
-0.015690634,
0.0613737777,
0.0295816325,
-0.0921183452,
-0.0803667903,
-0.0509372801,
-0.0192453191,
-0.0436862037,
0.0315401927,
0.120272994,
0.0507166572,
0.0231909323,
0.0056048171,
-0.0373205915,
0.0244123489,
0.0448682234,
-0.0273044836,
-0.0054039783,
0.0464633405,
0.0469122343,
-0.040259555,
0.0090698013,
-0.0042764046,
-0.0366978385,
-0.018410679,
-0.0148292026,
0.0673539415,
0.008295143,
-0.0134602534,
0.0055849659,
0.0029981523,
0.0150040342,
-0.0436863862,
0.0211355127,
-0.0671314001,
-0.0463015065,
-0.0622958876,
-0.0438285992,
0.0276783463,
0.0153211253,
0.0280963145,
-0.0075104544,
0.0016546659,
0.0108438879,
-0.0039392267,
0.0199016519,
-0.0663170815,
-0.0348426066,
0.0214132592,
0.0062841238,
-0.0172222704,
-0.0081998268,
-0.0074678669,
0.0061744205,
-0.0518966727,
-0.0165916961,
2.270203541e-34,
0.0589258187,
-0.0291638114,
0.0368594825,
0.0444678217,
0.0090090502,
0.0490470305,
0.0516723543,
0.012049472,
-0.0057790927,
-0.0374293402,
-0.0140596395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06330v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06330v4 | Smart Agent-Based Modeling: On the Use of Large Language Models in Computer Simulations | 2023-11-10T18:54:33 | 2023-12-14T21:59:41 | Zengqing Wu, Run Peng, Xu Han, Shuyuan Zheng, Yixin Zhang, Chuan Xiao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.MA, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Computer simulations offer a robust toolset for exploring complex systems
across various disciplines. A particularly impactful approach within this realm
is Agent-Based Modeling (ABM), which harnesses the interactions of individual
agents to emulate intricate system dynamics. ABM's strength lies in its
bottom-up methodology, illuminating emergent phenomena by modeling the
behaviors of individual components of a system. Yet, ABM has its own set of
challenges, notably its struggle with modeling natural language instructions
and common sense in mathematical equations or rules. This paper seeks to
transcend these boundaries by integrating Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT
into ABM. This amalgamation gives birth to a novel framework, Smart Agent-Based
Modeling (SABM). Building upon the concept of smart agents -- entities
characterized by their intelligence, adaptability, and computation ability --
we explore in the direction of utilizing LLM-powered agents to simulate
real-world scenarios with increased nuance and realism. In this comprehensive
exploration, we elucidate the state of the art of ABM, introduce SABM's
potential and methodology, and present three case studies (source codes
available at https://github.com/Roihn/SABM), demonstrating the SABM methodology
and validating its effectiveness in modeling real-world systems. Furthermore,
we cast a vision towards several aspects of the future of SABM, anticipating a
broader horizon for its applications. Through this endeavor, we aspire to
redefine the boundaries of computer simulations, enabling a more profound
understanding of complex systems. | [
0.0120295864,
0.0122724539,
-0.0657646209,
0.0421337225,
-0.0405595265,
-0.0460324064,
-0.0027782854,
-0.0001396719,
0.048453819,
-0.0145534044,
0.0257093683,
-0.0147361523,
-0.0060737724,
0.041945748,
0.0102498569,
-0.0326382816,
0.020414399,
-0.0566329882,
0.004017028,
-0.009741826,
0.0175743662,
-0.0062907888,
0.0026458772,
0.0384753607,
0.0048472928,
0.0068150274,
-0.0547840632,
0.0028387445,
0.015530888,
-0.0078466041,
-0.0140103735,
0.0288073514,
0.072330527,
0.0617379844,
0.0000024614,
-0.0550857224,
-0.0049975035,
0.0346607044,
-0.0280538741,
0.051542975,
0.0695398077,
0.016207369,
-0.0326346122,
-0.0062761535,
-0.074696362,
0.0037087384,
0.0492156893,
-0.0286864415,
0.0670944825,
0.0237527359,
-0.0046211574,
-0.0007666654,
0.0251507722,
0.0182200782,
-0.0385286026,
-0.0549286045,
0.0418487862,
0.0297187977,
0.0478065722,
0.0059983404,
-0.0155894225,
-0.0124177756,
0.0326390229,
-0.0052936482,
-0.0194779057,
0.0503131822,
-0.0009229315,
0.0091568297,
-0.0395523421,
0.0213182047,
0.0357933119,
-0.0053342474,
0.0446481742,
-0.0001553215,
-0.0303793065,
0.0218499992,
-0.0353639126,
0.0146128731,
0.0021583082,
0.0267123692,
-0.0085121542,
0.0092677642,
0.0172695592,
0.0100417072,
-0.0262987092,
0.0697595254,
0.0041206633,
-0.0151327252,
-0.0557854958,
-0.042498365,
0.0248649307,
-0.0552092083,
0.0115525685,
0.0763423741,
-0.0464450195,
0.0085135875,
-0.0072435196,
0.0159653686,
0.0279397387,
-0.0702081695,
0.0424927324,
0.0213495586,
0.0442263186,
0.0485093817,
0.0250031762,
0.0452125147,
-0.0327215344,
0.0021294903,
0.0101689138,
0.0216932762,
-0.0737255663,
-0.0324344151,
-0.0352330767,
0.0092640901,
-0.0162115227,
-0.0164974239,
0.0066618174,
0.0317975208,
-0.0573636703,
0.0046661408,
-0.0327395387,
0.0038225923,
-0.0204223432,
-0.000562066,
-0.0682555214,
-0.0260187015,
-0.0399484821,
0.001739261,
0.0044361814,
-0.0350422449,
0.0211081412,
-0.0158297271,
-0.0340801775,
0.0063950871,
0.002904257,
0.0911509469,
0.017018415,
0.0232745614,
-0.0135039221,
-0.0376090668,
0.042165935,
-0.0488994606,
-0.0091466559,
-0.0755493417,
0.0334200561,
-0.0316690952,
-0.0069363313,
-0.0425110795,
0.0017646953,
0.0017976603,
-0.0154645359,
0.0707704201,
-0.029690342,
0.031446334,
0.0101007009,
0.0051146606,
0.0075148405,
0.0336077511,
0.0565927923,
-0.0264664181,
0.0197853968,
0.0046842811,
0.0617407896,
0.0524995513,
-0.0168115757,
0.0305057503,
-0.0006925799,
-0.0094635822,
0.0037304875,
0.038556058,
-0.0148966461,
0.0195288211,
-0.0242189523,
-0.0011538685,
0.078374885,
0.0495924838,
-0.0467831828,
0.0535422228,
0.0636652336,
0.0700287521,
0.0190056823,
-0.0257400908,
-0.0318537317,
0.0373719633,
-0.0216840003,
0.0235353243,
-0.047632359,
0.0830306411,
-0.017712146,
-0.0194877423,
0.0271853562,
0.005338246,
0.0492031462,
-0.033457417,
0.0313737653,
-0.0217519775,
-0.0234896932,
-0.0057822573,
0.012912442,
-0.0182402059,
-0.0172752887,
-0.1011925265,
-0.0054080589,
0.1025036722,
0.0908948705,
-0.0449850969,
-0.0219323337,
0.0087200152,
-0.0111408737,
0.0709262863,
0.0093295919,
0.0223260075,
-0.0762036368,
-0.043598447,
-0.0186281819,
0.0256456528,
0.0110932682,
0.0362454802,
-0.0118485168,
-0.011347604,
-0.0148243662,
0.0292921588,
-0.0252000038,
0.0212982297,
-0.0669340566,
-0.0196671821,
-0.0356950462,
-0.0300644021,
0.0376641452,
0.0022528493,
-0.0120533891,
0.0044214437,
0.0228553712,
0.0238853451,
-0.0646549985,
0.0198198613,
0.0037725735,
0.0544767752,
0.034571901,
0.002571197,
0.0395203717,
-0.0001883083,
-0.0208704155,
-0.0222446471,
0.0507491231,
-0.0151169905,
0.0273034945,
-0.0302782152,
0.0026346862,
-0.0379342735,
0.022357285,
-0.0103428438,
0.0335331149,
0.0428966694,
-0.0522507094,
0.0190921202,
0.0244374257,
0.0148576647,
0.0020488042,
0.0167923775,
0.0053949179,
0.0122729717,
0.0532048605,
0.0327742547,
0.0194247626,
-0.0083096148,
0.0034466165,
-0.0591265522,
0.0005698516,
0.0176202729,
-0.0112073347,
-0.001120152,
-0.0184415113,
-0.0313288905,
0.0399568491,
0.0032004099,
0.0546458811,
-0.01160031,
-0.0287679732,
0.0183051601,
-0.0087291002,
-0.0870195702,
-0.0333669782,
0.0150163844,
-0.0330916084,
0.0255264323,
0.0272031203,
0.0346812122,
-0.0647099093,
-0.0001396193,
-0.0204768628,
0.0210683439,
-0.0134701999,
-0.0569039099,
0.0332769677,
-0.0256279334,
0.046195507,
0.0083519937,
-0.0286674201,
0.0459461398,
0.0126602361,
-0.0700923353,
-0.0446078368,
0.0306765381,
-0.0358676128,
0.0112845125,
-0.0648207664,
-0.0388641767,
-0.017894242,
0.0682335123,
-0.0043970007,
-0.004692879,
-0.0214311816,
0.057629656,
-0.0318783671,
-0.025391724,
0.0120266816,
-0.0098907445,
-0.0376694873,
0.0385917127,
0.0032540308,
-0.0129019329,
0.0973213315,
-0.0359587222,
0.0135454806,
-0.0250898302,
-0.0149171464,
-0.0357277915,
0.0701252148,
0.0052302047,
-0.0201029778,
0.0097039575,
0.06185776,
-0.0172844026,
-0.0174504798,
0.0135191008,
-0.0043560425,
0.0201197751,
-0.0710616782,
0.0060126842,
0.0221606065,
-0.0067016063,
0.0044460637,
-0.0075077121,
-0.0371494442,
0.0504426993,
-0.0048468695,
-0.0371446721,
-0.0325952955,
0.019925626,
0.0448832251,
0.0221495423,
-0.0165879894,
-0.03050806,
-0.0623042174,
-0.027849311,
0.0265827328,
-0.0049739238,
-0.0072654323,
-0.0047411607,
0.0505492836,
0.0251851901,
0.0429721773,
-0.0239837319,
-0.0392404571,
-0.0211836994,
-0.0067518307,
-0.0023256715,
0.0301175527,
0.0503902175,
-0.0260738675,
-0.091213122,
-0.0193572957,
0.0957977325,
0.0259095486,
0.0051800283,
0.0288271625,
-0.0670686886,
-0.0040013702,
0.0040163235,
0.0658178329,
-0.0394752696,
-0.001904096,
0.0000915839,
-0.0056771412,
-0.0348366648,
-0.0418119542,
0.0231597237,
-0.0694073662,
0.0556869358,
0.0063313781,
-0.0460492559,
-0.01895204,
-0.0616748333,
0.0029621017,
-0.0119975004,
-0.0015640372,
0.0046582879,
0.0495835207,
-0.0401965529,
-0.022487158,
-0.0665573031,
-0.0098340763,
0.0566166379,
-0.0438161455,
0.0826887265,
0.0957095176,
0.0408722721,
-0.0447112173,
0.0031936152,
-0.0443297215,
0.0033626542,
0.0165343862,
0.0103982026,
-0.0334554687,
0.0438381396,
0.0089275707,
-0.0253269132,
0.0057957247,
-0.0606491491,
-0.0375885889,
0.0437198989,
0.0978693143,
-0.0189068802,
-0.0552586056,
-0.0612461194,
-0.0054694093,
0.032098975,
0.0358866788,
0.0025885275,
-0.0560815185,
-0.0658646077,
-0.0534040257,
-0.0384909734,
-0.0007039513,
-0.0639554709,
-0.0273171477,
-0.0048559518,
-0.0205968302,
-0.0000760495,
-0.051105015,
0.0258119497,
-0.0367768854,
0.0246530939,
-0.0040412624,
0.105996415,
-0.0293521844,
0.0100882286,
-0.0308180749,
-0.0667377859,
0.0527465641,
0.0236210413,
-0.0274822768,
0.0352632776,
-0.0437917225,
-0.0181917511,
0.0301705394,
-0.0065345853,
-0.0524902493,
0.0499006175,
0.0617846325,
0.0255541448,
0.0133651979,
-0.0154136326,
-0.0171638392,
0.0330291316,
0.0096620051,
-0.0472028963,
0.0206485167,
-0.0076028062,
-0.0206724145,
0.0133887464,
0.0016806457,
-0.0066239601,
0.0509821214,
-0.0119825937,
0.034741465,
-0.0473697931,
-0.0394303836,
0.0177484285,
-0.0003838731,
-0.0186756924,
0.0283030253,
-0.0517026968,
0.0071038944,
-0.0109312544,
-0.0447778925,
-0.0159282144,
-0.0169845168,
-0.049057845,
-0.0277845375,
-0.0024456505,
0.0436666943,
-0.0051500322,
-0.0083378647,
-0.0140193552,
0.0518161543,
0.0016664027,
0.0045540957,
0.0566367842,
0.0242495444,
-0.011403271,
0.0164930336,
0.0087086828,
-0.0395457521,
0.0264812931,
-0.0030371968,
0.0396910794,
0.0034998967,
-0.0359977335,
-0.0112898154,
0.010904979,
-0.038081415,
-0.0606111027,
0.0164450444,
0.072166644,
0.0264969692,
0.0392175429,
0.0202824511,
-0.0972256064,
0.0230699629,
-0.0248351712,
-0.0068782056,
0.0095328465,
-0.0272302441,
-0.0051093977,
0.0520443097,
-0.0294647608,
-0.0149981072,
0.0450740121,
0.0190344658,
0.0402201936,
-0.0180567428,
-0.0313272402,
-0.0271065701,
-0.0200458504,
0.00161602,
-0.009449997,
-0.009445345,
-0.0142221916,
-0.090734005,
-0.01916622,
-0.0051585119,
0.0560397133,
-0.0019012042,
-0.0702008605,
0.0362144597,
0.0365055166,
-0.0298719667,
0.0237426646,
-0.015704643,
0.0167396907,
-0.0603785366,
-0.0106744496,
-0.0072284276,
-6.437427304e-33,
-0.0190222003,
-0.0515210778,
0.0894013643,
0.0329714082,
-0.020149285,
-0.0522526577,
-0.0643421188,
-0.0404545777,
0.0204285234,
0.0380059332,
-0.0071486146,
0.0041259141,
0.0156921353,
-0.0097719263,
0.016853869,
-0.0020033577,
0.0248413552,
-0.0327671207,
-0.0012786888,
0.0311181433,
-0.0149231339,
-0.025082631,
-0.0115937209,
-0.0486514755,
0.0351604559,
-0.0324839391,
-0.0191537458,
-0.001526686,
-0.0371857844,
0.0606918782,
-0.0564592071,
0.0433268584,
0.0042213574,
-0.0363580287,
-0.009963966,
0.0067856913,
-0.0032099448,
0.013199551,
-0.0166877676,
-0.0083977897,
-0.0135108521,
-0.0344909616,
0.0225365348,
0.0104057509,
-0.0711595938,
0.0402657613,
0.0487221032,
-0.046477247,
0.0133366818,
0.025685735,
-0.1218115315,
0.0166124739,
-0.0075688963,
-0.0191419739,
-0.0001892443,
-0.0241865888,
-0.0212571658,
-0.0255349707,
-0.0275597144,
0.0288904458,
0.0547328778,
-0.0176125914,
0.046156235,
0.0109539088,
0.0517905764,
0.0458155051,
0.0276537091,
0.0128883682,
-0.0308257882,
-0.0056510516,
0.0270801354,
0.0484473482,
0.0352920853,
0.0906553045,
-0.0418511145,
-0.0144686243,
-0.0309934951,
0.022864487,
0.0293922462,
0.0216534063,
0.0696404278,
0.018207686,
-0.042114187,
-0.0140054226,
-0.0014120563,
0.0259979051,
-0.0077567953,
-0.0338561311,
-0.010690188,
-0.0207633264,
-0.0197979584,
-0.0042847055,
0.002389027,
-0.0525557324,
-0.0122402133,
-0.0316000618,
0.0210352261,
0.0250890721,
0.0220902655,
0.0293252114,
-0.0143525945,
-0.0539951101,
-0.0233260076,
-0.0146662155,
0.015520853,
0.0261954758,
-0.053637933,
0.0600092746,
-0.0056511387,
0.0168024302,
-0.0209876858,
0.0051821801,
0.047402516,
-0.0381247289,
-0.012976801,
-0.0093669808,
0.0108590014,
0.0032214355,
0.0205315482,
-0.0591363609,
0.0304111931,
0.0397160612,
-0.0194046684,
0.0059973188,
-0.0096787065,
0.0036268914,
-0.0791631788,
-0.0209289975,
0.0175090171,
-0.0322720855,
-0.0299469028,
0.0009349836,
3.126e-7,
-0.0051212101,
0.0800527334,
0.0264200494,
0.0141838966,
0.054208748,
0.07958588,
-0.0392142795,
0.0301624797,
-0.0019289048,
-0.0210491717,
0.0243688822,
0.060699705,
0.0299599264,
0.0022325634,
-0.0723911747,
0.0064308201,
-0.0115587236,
0.0060557723,
-0.0802504197,
-0.0377819166,
0.0271051042,
0.0191574097,
0.0367049761,
0.0140858218,
-0.0010932637,
-0.039921809,
0.0217584651,
-0.0399383269,
-0.0021159912,
0.0558368117,
-0.0653863475,
-0.0072177527,
-0.0199830458,
0.0060097869,
0.0187015329,
0.0313123539,
-0.0240049586,
0.0813979805,
-0.0019408452,
0.0167694036,
0.0282884464,
-0.0731187165,
0.0106359804,
-0.0562611483,
0.0190115329,
-0.0696673095,
-0.0309071317,
-0.0198011082,
-0.0296149999,
-0.0104292696,
-0.0277810246,
-0.0389640927,
-0.0437735431,
-0.0045218137,
-0.0386534072,
0.0141967591,
0.018154759,
-0.0069725448,
0.0120371897,
-0.010163988,
-0.0598076023,
-0.0594312921,
-0.0335991643,
0.0287867002,
0.0427944846,
-0.0276840981,
0.0539979525,
3.047826115e-34,
0.0561630465,
0.0141703971,
-0.0058575044,
0.0438268892,
0.0232953206,
0.0364434533,
-0.025459731,
0.0506215021,
0.0369101539,
-0.0639147162,
-0.0400889702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06237v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06237v2 | Summon a Demon and Bind it: A Grounded Theory of LLM Red Teaming in the Wild | 2023-11-10T18:52:58 | 2023-11-13T17:00:40 | Nanna Inie, Jonathan Stray, Leon Derczynski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.HC | Engaging in the deliberate generation of abnormal outputs from large language
models (LLMs) by attacking them is a novel human activity. This paper presents
a thorough exposition of how and why people perform such attacks. Using a
formal qualitative methodology, we interviewed dozens of practitioners from a
broad range of backgrounds, all contributors to this novel work of attempting
to cause LLMs to fail. We relate and connect this activity between its
practitioners' motivations and goals; the strategies and techniques they
deploy; and the crucial role the community plays. As a result, this paper
presents a grounded theory of how and why people attack large language models:
LLM red teaming in the wild. | [
0.0512863323,
0.0749722645,
-0.0295465365,
0.0370827913,
-0.0654802099,
-0.0133996336,
-0.0161571335,
-0.0042644618,
-0.0261904877,
-0.0370744281,
0.0057161716,
0.0161294863,
0.0253721066,
0.0272166766,
0.0254192036,
-0.0099641569,
0.0119203171,
-0.0057308991,
-0.0451425202,
-0.0115015544,
0.0186571386,
0.0272551887,
0.0275008008,
0.0582888164,
-0.0024289766,
-0.0128055811,
-0.0111308917,
0.0303515941,
-0.0057766419,
-0.0152347321,
-0.0115805091,
0.0188788958,
-0.011835224,
0.0829540119,
0.0000019631,
-0.049041871,
-0.0175863132,
0.0069443774,
-0.0188023038,
0.0479950756,
0.0082687102,
0.0399835147,
-0.0513891019,
0.008529691,
-0.0514340959,
0.0118533848,
0.0391770452,
0.0005589046,
0.0477144308,
0.0736786127,
0.0115701165,
-0.0150746582,
-0.0006516407,
-0.0094469152,
-0.0622031838,
-0.0033528612,
0.0287071634,
0.0187728629,
0.0622859113,
0.0100435624,
-0.0064259828,
0.020114623,
0.0287494864,
-0.0449494086,
-0.05029241,
0.0069184373,
-0.0256376155,
-0.0441398397,
0.0345936716,
0.035442587,
-0.004258824,
-0.0239823461,
0.0001085803,
0.016903365,
-0.030276211,
0.0158797633,
-0.0364645198,
0.0469984412,
-0.0021514585,
0.0502191372,
-0.017076103,
-0.0145751415,
0.049449183,
-0.0090004606,
0.0041969442,
0.0545519553,
-0.0172245316,
-0.0137490481,
-0.0116926907,
0.0141662443,
0.0016296252,
-0.0570068434,
-0.037602175,
0.0323617198,
-0.0001999032,
0.0440267101,
0.0006710078,
-0.0208454169,
0.0429055505,
-0.0753103718,
0.0250829924,
0.0279935785,
0.0370325781,
0.0190797616,
0.0052225599,
-0.0033260917,
-0.023164615,
0.0163326617,
-0.0132858111,
0.0484744757,
-0.0336961262,
-0.0211844202,
-0.0323098823,
-0.0135366069,
-0.0057005608,
-0.0013093641,
0.0183621366,
0.0180641077,
-0.0195479318,
0.0409210958,
-0.0360568017,
0.0031108705,
-0.0056674066,
-0.0244026743,
0.0152619435,
0.0154825663,
-0.007713336,
0.0104931537,
-0.0221256185,
-0.1072541103,
0.0267378408,
0.0034097992,
-0.0623375624,
-0.0130300084,
-0.005617917,
0.0981928557,
0.0057564583,
0.0084149418,
-0.046852842,
-0.0611693338,
0.0039669084,
-0.0384448133,
-0.0086187264,
-0.0759844035,
-0.0589039214,
0.0483067594,
-0.0073928544,
-0.0674041584,
0.0097211897,
-0.0094580892,
-0.0137832277,
0.047055576,
-0.0547979251,
0.0135600232,
0.0417315513,
0.0533409193,
0.0374067388,
0.0838173926,
0.0302388836,
0.0034307193,
0.0260722693,
-0.0289676134,
0.0723148957,
0.0706253499,
-0.023905674,
0.0377991535,
-0.0586697534,
0.0138439257,
-0.0055824923,
0.017933365,
0.0033563233,
0.0573092662,
-0.0162438955,
0.0368707143,
0.042567011,
0.0208981037,
0.0066601001,
0.0152882403,
0.001839546,
-0.0121881356,
-0.0411817245,
0.0152951898,
0.0048401812,
-0.0147600966,
-0.0121250972,
-0.0019372469,
-0.0062998086,
0.0391144566,
-0.0059620491,
-0.0228543263,
-0.0374292172,
0.0079031158,
0.0110278539,
0.0298857186,
0.0104600517,
0.0303382948,
-0.015543066,
0.0151807014,
0.0127337938,
-0.0675034821,
0.0142317964,
-0.0925728381,
0.0057592886,
0.0402714908,
0.0651930422,
-0.0259553883,
0.007127462,
0.0010955884,
0.0074168118,
0.061801739,
0.0086618159,
0.0082953712,
-0.0698258132,
-0.0125842085,
-0.0176965073,
-0.0307953879,
0.0035542741,
0.0025627883,
-0.0112258894,
0.0210652929,
-0.0233031474,
-0.0223089978,
-0.0780965462,
0.0228701625,
-0.0647143424,
-0.0540634096,
-0.0550843403,
0.0066103074,
0.0097831972,
0.0071459068,
-0.0339605883,
0.0354801342,
0.0449451506,
-0.0065724654,
-0.009793736,
0.026486041,
0.0265178904,
0.0752990246,
0.0317499563,
-0.0933371708,
0.0103573985,
0.0327819996,
0.0059832735,
0.001404583,
0.083502844,
-0.0390658155,
0.0652466938,
0.0116157513,
0.0180992112,
-0.0365291126,
0.0103691928,
-0.0589350611,
-0.0015357326,
-0.0196869671,
0.0128069902,
-0.0135273552,
-0.0240794849,
0.0268229321,
-0.0028994686,
-0.0077482504,
0.0505259447,
0.0061893398,
0.0480344519,
0.0395339504,
0.0158292316,
-0.0235700328,
-0.0424934328,
-0.0176306628,
-0.0543594994,
-0.0142009798,
0.0180470068,
0.0378070474,
-0.0258666184,
-0.0385814495,
0.0111286314,
0.0287403129,
-0.0183830746,
0.0048040808,
0.0156237939,
0.0244024284,
0.0136986384,
-0.0603760444,
-0.0289657097,
0.0042766104,
0.0043124668,
0.081303224,
0.0026348098,
-0.0262281317,
-0.1017958522,
0.0403656252,
-0.0248789489,
-0.004321273,
-0.0166874602,
-0.0462089106,
0.0623532124,
0.0016772114,
0.022639839,
-0.0006029891,
-0.0211105254,
0.0691735968,
0.047406707,
-0.0238772649,
-0.0545262732,
-0.0318641402,
0.022209214,
-0.049088344,
-0.039569173,
-0.0717240125,
-0.0066553759,
0.0624591038,
0.0118629215,
0.0092436951,
0.0106076458,
0.046395164,
-0.0422509611,
-0.0220223088,
0.0013581105,
-0.1009152234,
-0.045741275,
0.0694066286,
0.0171038378,
-0.0368497334,
0.0134625761,
-0.0390031822,
0.0014834572,
-0.0318814963,
-0.0100702811,
-0.0253009517,
0.0912512615,
-0.0454274826,
0.0236094091,
0.0310711935,
-0.0076541863,
-0.022915408,
-0.0232260302,
0.0013761934,
-0.0225480944,
0.0650733188,
-0.0606601387,
0.0206547435,
-0.0205815993,
0.0202970766,
-0.0334628373,
-0.0331430286,
-0.0605600998,
-0.0278126225,
0.0387412682,
0.0127937784,
-0.026950771,
-0.0024376658,
0.0395574719,
-0.0104896221,
0.0256530754,
-0.0319501124,
-0.0051082764,
-0.0120275952,
-0.0150728114,
-0.0243905727,
0.070361279,
-0.0329167508,
0.0040602889,
0.0660811588,
0.0271128397,
-0.0106947655,
-0.0277919192,
-0.0454685353,
0.0650771633,
-0.0019317254,
-0.0396741703,
0.0202909373,
0.0457857177,
-0.050045941,
-0.0186839141,
0.0441296361,
0.0110901203,
-0.0030429391,
0.0422458164,
-0.0659586638,
0.0485984236,
0.0311701316,
0.0393311381,
-0.09161219,
0.0169104598,
0.0059807086,
0.0257881936,
-0.0426055193,
-0.0224394333,
-0.0418828763,
-0.1116273999,
0.0302862283,
0.0311286133,
-0.0351725556,
0.0324331261,
-0.0020366339,
-0.0127159748,
0.0213573594,
0.0898665786,
0.0382911228,
-0.0085358759,
-0.0042961845,
0.049898196,
-0.0573801436,
-0.0286582801,
-0.0065826755,
-0.0115627134,
0.0694749877,
0.048770491,
0.0136770634,
-0.032764338,
-0.0040663658,
0.0461133942,
0.011961909,
0.019687999,
0.0060413117,
-0.0285865627,
0.0295247007,
-0.0249639489,
-0.0138187986,
0.0049916203,
-0.0630176514,
-0.0352414772,
0.0151390713,
0.0661040246,
-0.0200889036,
-0.0583554208,
-0.0241414625,
0.000584126,
0.0286181122,
0.0380805023,
0.0408535115,
-0.0469797254,
-0.009753284,
-0.0680304691,
-0.0079628974,
-0.0049595241,
-0.0992741287,
-0.0026610296,
0.0283044539,
-0.0014468988,
0.0042962236,
-0.0633068457,
0.0131382672,
0.0386531241,
0.0548692048,
-0.0008832219,
-0.029137753,
-0.0037213739,
0.0143411281,
0.0391529948,
-0.0284062345,
0.0431405492,
-0.0535612665,
0.0062613646,
-0.0383109599,
-0.0194002613,
0.0297310613,
-0.0144234337,
-0.0471136123,
-0.0821710601,
0.0382995233,
0.0380182974,
0.0460667275,
-0.0258504581,
0.0231479388,
-0.0777347609,
-0.0374650061,
0.0510221682,
-0.025410993,
0.0458593741,
0.0458743833,
-0.0029025178,
0.0075588333,
0.0274450425,
-0.0018480377,
-0.0057630576,
0.0534819849,
0.0009159314,
-0.1166451499,
-0.0321900547,
0.0141750565,
0.0066603743,
0.0028184988,
-0.0776135698,
0.0078770816,
-0.0055921106,
-0.0123623097,
-0.0320681147,
-0.028051272,
-0.0188602358,
-0.0006318058,
0.0095462305,
0.0073086289,
0.0258980654,
0.0106227398,
-0.0561635718,
0.0278561674,
-0.0223477595,
0.0677702725,
0.0209949724,
0.0187532902,
0.0696142986,
0.006740585,
-0.0059757512,
0.0463592075,
-0.0227994397,
0.0446978658,
0.0314051658,
0.0269151181,
0.0102968076,
-0.0045436257,
0.0478861444,
0.0110533433,
0.0086487122,
-0.1167877167,
0.0418312401,
0.0144402562,
0.0328643881,
0.0059293676,
0.0440091304,
-0.0070546842,
0.0202368237,
-0.0052954964,
-0.007184986,
-0.0027941363,
-0.0327665582,
0.0020654383,
0.01503288,
-0.0454132967,
-0.0152506446,
0.0510053113,
-0.0486367494,
0.0420836955,
0.0329466686,
0.0382431075,
-0.0125512369,
-0.0540290922,
0.0409920886,
0.0019312917,
-0.0220388435,
-0.0364271589,
-0.1162150502,
-0.0475469567,
-0.0338589624,
0.0202116892,
-0.0160203781,
-0.0337937251,
-0.0128867496,
0.0572560206,
0.0289542638,
0.0528286844,
-0.0441870466,
0.0181029048,
-0.0052007576,
-0.0189680122,
0.0448179096,
-5.927100758e-33,
0.0085699875,
-0.0820741355,
0.015987277,
-0.0147440694,
-0.0226088297,
-0.000258785,
-0.0370262675,
0.0444150679,
-0.0104414895,
0.0052140709,
-0.0122887772,
-0.0345760547,
0.0102387574,
-0.0061851051,
0.0244967733,
0.0174624007,
0.0216118824,
0.031834621,
-0.0027844831,
-0.0018810336,
0.0403536819,
-0.0215082262,
0.0269230027,
-0.0780199692,
0.0511052795,
-0.0419071838,
-0.045024544,
0.0329778828,
-0.0004862754,
0.0289729759,
0.0062179598,
0.0293431878,
-0.0075755855,
-0.0458185039,
-0.0213590376,
0.0310241487,
0.0244509615,
0.0051051313,
0.0506457426,
0.0437541232,
-0.020510301,
-0.0300603695,
0.0488888323,
-0.003837802,
-0.0312816389,
0.0166991744,
0.0124306083,
-0.0094090728,
-0.0224512666,
0.0425399505,
-0.0728828534,
0.0133142434,
-0.0253381487,
0.0148015283,
-0.0212551057,
-0.021597499,
0.0056781336,
-0.0343578197,
-0.0799133852,
0.0040231803,
0.0155397756,
0.0046353871,
0.0836942345,
0.0332404263,
-0.0118365204,
0.0755661801,
-0.0056403656,
0.0530269854,
-0.029341545,
0.0142779732,
0.0151350396,
0.0541433245,
0.0420328677,
0.0529210418,
-0.0417172089,
-0.0197780263,
-0.0371264592,
-0.0188765209,
0.0298929755,
-0.0023280745,
0.0273028612,
0.0170040764,
-0.0620758496,
-0.0464656092,
0.0148084285,
-0.0027289295,
0.0002641395,
-0.0309555307,
-0.026839748,
-0.034123987,
-0.0509534515,
0.0073207687,
0.0116331149,
-0.0244126674,
-0.0261124242,
0.0041651181,
-0.0229141731,
-0.006320531,
0.012073189,
0.0203333553,
-0.0193828233,
0.0256238859,
-0.0278506521,
-0.0134916315,
0.0430487022,
0.0305066109,
-0.0061171609,
0.0337633751,
-0.0589068942,
0.0014839674,
-0.0458580516,
0.0639594048,
0.02316669,
-0.0221512821,
0.0240592137,
-0.0147022335,
0.0015106602,
-0.0151370252,
0.0417937972,
-0.0316904262,
-0.010012879,
0.0618995912,
-0.04933016,
-0.0147705507,
-0.0339844488,
-0.0273135379,
-0.0263589304,
0.0544513613,
0.1107010841,
-0.0594850071,
-0.0393339023,
-0.0253089182,
2.714e-7,
0.0383000746,
0.0378669575,
0.0273169428,
0.0053325891,
0.0220014304,
0.0402547009,
-0.0241167489,
0.030234538,
-0.0056299698,
-0.0328358263,
-0.0111087142,
0.0126105435,
0.0205047075,
0.0527363569,
-0.056217242,
0.0126643125,
-0.0819572285,
0.0289177746,
-0.0636802763,
-0.0161501747,
0.0077712284,
0.029493276,
0.0209132005,
-0.0311957132,
-0.0380045809,
-0.0573988855,
0.0058697243,
-0.0328664891,
0.0223095939,
0.0415962003,
0.0182646029,
0.0132204574,
0.0195027497,
-0.0082567139,
0.016625151,
-0.0418675095,
-0.0253344309,
0.0439893194,
0.006075806,
-0.0230296273,
-0.0078320736,
-0.0601576157,
-0.0193489511,
-0.0604702197,
0.0410897546,
-0.0052843094,
-0.0056638056,
-0.0155242439,
-0.0057444815,
-0.051450748,
-0.0049504726,
-0.0136743812,
0.0091435146,
0.0660521761,
0.0172090661,
-0.0291466918,
0.0010061973,
-0.0204366092,
-0.0266962964,
-0.0019529031,
-0.0380632728,
-0.0475181192,
0.0202794243,
0.0311348196,
-0.0148905683,
-0.006882471,
0.0024066686,
2.393965188e-34,
0.0079408027,
-0.0055004968,
0.0214575399,
0.0206912644,
0.03162596,
0.0255471393,
-0.0467920117,
0.0128841298,
0.026838975,
-0.0085810944,
-0.0340556987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06233v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06233v6 | Data Contamination Quiz: A Tool to Detect and Estimate Contamination in Large Language Models | 2023-11-10T18:48:58 | 2024-05-24T06:14:09 | Shahriar Golchin, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose the Data Contamination Quiz (DCQ), a simple and effective approach
to detect data contamination in large language models (LLMs) and estimate the
amount of it. Specifically, we frame data contamination detection as a series
of multiple-choice questions and devise a quiz format wherein three perturbed
versions of each subsampled instance from a specific dataset partition (e.g.,
GSM8k test set) are created. These changes only include word-level
perturbations. The generated perturbations, along with the original dataset
instance, form the options in the DCQ, with an extra option accommodating the
possibility of selecting none of the provided options. Given that the only
distinguishing signal among the options is the exact wording with respect to
the original dataset instance, an LLM, when tasked with identifying the
original dataset instance, gravitates towards selecting the original one if it
has been exposed to it in its pre-training phase -- a trait intrinsic to LLMs.
While accounting for positional biases in LLMs, the quiz performance reveals
the contamination level for the model being examined with the dataset partition
to which the quiz pertains. Applied to various datasets with GPT-4 and GPT-3.5,
our findings -- while fully lacking access to pre-training data and model
parameters -- suggest that DCQ achieves state-of-the-art results and uncovers
greater contamination/memorization levels compared to existing methods and
proficiently bypasses more safety filters, especially those set to avoid
generating copyrighted contents. | [
0.023092946,
0.1028732508,
-0.0450546965,
0.0452744514,
-0.051632192,
0.0159815196,
0.0073208404,
0.0099984761,
0.0093643935,
-0.0240819585,
-0.0124165574,
-0.0363615155,
0.0115409987,
-0.0030983307,
0.0436254293,
0.0018904767,
0.0846455321,
-0.0330941044,
-0.0264419969,
-0.0116144195,
-0.002647449,
-0.0002931931,
0.0436735041,
-0.0003382443,
-0.0113086803,
-0.0435458757,
-0.0075887875,
-0.0175105352,
0.0195995886,
-0.0236890614,
-0.0060984278,
0.0789448693,
0.000319508,
0.079433918,
0.0000019848,
-0.0474793054,
-0.0343605541,
0.0080488753,
-0.0294813216,
0.0645644814,
0.0463938825,
0.0385466143,
-0.0136561841,
0.0429729372,
-0.0167362988,
-0.0008024751,
0.049045343,
0.0205646083,
0.0656043887,
0.0598624274,
-0.0085810507,
0.0313386619,
-0.0069691269,
-0.0135007035,
0.0100158546,
0.004862125,
0.0730596557,
0.0013843232,
-0.0157797132,
0.0032659988,
-0.0299757589,
0.0414499901,
-0.0089307502,
0.0329453647,
-0.045203153,
0.0030565977,
-0.0408008695,
-0.0196083561,
0.0402621515,
0.050066296,
0.0050779944,
-0.0214830078,
0.0164127927,
-0.0203429312,
0.0241483003,
0.0263832286,
-0.0140071446,
0.006145101,
0.0009909947,
0.0338334627,
-0.008151927,
-0.0438136198,
0.0439966545,
-0.0111138457,
-0.0400097221,
0.077880919,
0.0414546616,
-0.0409640111,
0.0127733713,
0.0023367987,
-0.013618581,
-0.0337848179,
-0.003270278,
-0.0271637011,
-0.0155775659,
0.0488652922,
-0.0417744517,
-0.0494034402,
0.049084045,
-0.0480049513,
0.0122559834,
-0.0039113318,
-0.0380471461,
0.0140557727,
0.0050724312,
0.0270338375,
-0.007437998,
0.0249648634,
-0.0288529303,
0.0109469919,
0.0116929859,
-0.0181641877,
-0.017113816,
0.0253835786,
0.0239752457,
0.0057220981,
-0.0336901285,
0.0372692458,
-0.0200371984,
-0.0078333542,
-0.017311886,
-0.0062351371,
-0.0221479442,
0.0333402008,
0.0009561015,
-0.0073099211,
-0.0126071991,
0.013537637,
-0.0140333446,
-0.0850825533,
-0.0342417136,
0.0054950938,
0.0090054171,
-0.053925164,
0.0009804227,
0.0495636351,
0.0386856422,
-0.0331296474,
-0.0369959325,
-0.0372108407,
-0.0448226258,
-0.0517207235,
-0.0026260943,
-0.0298205707,
-0.0084189046,
0.0001380704,
-0.0082524065,
-0.0435892642,
-0.0053108991,
0.0521605909,
-0.0780269578,
0.0532697402,
-0.0331860557,
0.0181608927,
-0.0030202311,
0.0024083389,
0.0006874109,
0.0871154666,
0.0235962197,
0.0151673472,
0.0435921513,
-0.042367883,
0.0279435199,
0.0651512221,
0.023018362,
0.0530086979,
-0.0329501927,
-0.021883022,
0.0315371491,
-0.0017052388,
0.0140080294,
0.0836285949,
-0.000067018,
-0.0334945805,
0.0809446201,
0.0283074807,
-0.0176910851,
0.0038339905,
-0.0154380277,
0.020930009,
0.0228978246,
0.0582642108,
-0.0484824739,
-0.0648169592,
-0.0328189917,
0.0025107157,
0.0310300365,
0.0218707435,
-0.0005496645,
-0.0139550194,
-0.0310472846,
0.0055005127,
0.0333113186,
0.0346877873,
0.0375334956,
-0.0159748383,
-0.0364261828,
0.043728698,
0.0091244886,
-0.0521392487,
0.0150408996,
-0.0482578836,
0.0586055927,
0.0551586226,
0.0429533496,
-0.0213781055,
0.0007439467,
-0.0365051702,
0.001044438,
0.0055371774,
0.0108374571,
0.0049376343,
0.0417413041,
-0.0468067527,
-0.037595816,
0.0199216586,
0.0254784003,
0.0138767557,
0.0175826605,
0.006998451,
0.0273105856,
-0.0387764014,
-0.042219609,
0.0445236303,
0.0039209998,
-0.03354856,
0.0174877476,
0.0054303636,
0.0402065702,
0.006566246,
-0.0328872539,
-0.0003285066,
0.0276897158,
0.0276293065,
0.0247478522,
-0.0389196165,
-0.0263659619,
0.0091487309,
0.0376377702,
0.0146727161,
-0.0142624853,
0.0450356975,
-0.0460854582,
-0.0361928418,
-0.0077300961,
-0.0314640366,
0.0096947448,
-0.0481305309,
0.0248717573,
-0.0261149798,
0.0452428162,
-0.0341871604,
0.0481161401,
0.0059735118,
0.0126063712,
0.0202007722,
0.0253456291,
0.0554695278,
-0.0612945743,
-0.0707877055,
0.0101831825,
-0.0081907371,
0.0194121413,
0.0214234591,
-0.010165479,
-0.053732641,
0.0038682988,
-0.0486644059,
-0.0079352958,
-0.0089465249,
0.0214290582,
0.0152513012,
-0.0042516058,
-0.053189259,
0.0021054607,
-0.0218300503,
-0.0332466252,
0.0315043889,
0.0520799905,
-0.0032457469,
-0.0241488945,
-0.0011646074,
-0.0132491253,
-0.0050725513,
-0.0258285291,
0.0499108508,
-0.0155858658,
-0.0353494175,
-0.0777315348,
0.047318846,
-0.0451975688,
0.0034597784,
0.0315777101,
-0.0455968305,
-0.0014114149,
-0.0007617941,
0.0161237828,
0.0434040129,
-0.0081284726,
0.0050273375,
0.067839995,
-0.0303056184,
-0.0288224723,
-0.0221064445,
-0.00417666,
-0.0250985008,
-0.0011390898,
-0.0365131497,
-0.0034371833,
0.0485048406,
0.0317163728,
-0.0505045801,
-0.0213402938,
0.0316109434,
-0.0536701009,
-0.0010728197,
-0.0031325428,
-0.02310008,
-0.0734845847,
0.0415248983,
-0.0057345373,
-0.0704090893,
0.0591950268,
-0.0309214666,
0.0417850241,
-0.0474564247,
-0.0038476896,
0.016018372,
0.0139661813,
-0.0020339028,
0.0106254732,
0.0416280329,
-0.0469467677,
-0.0640802458,
-0.004229195,
0.0395875089,
-0.0597668886,
0.0246191677,
-0.0381778739,
0.0085379099,
0.0072838529,
-0.0141657386,
-0.0407176763,
-0.0241362639,
0.0299832746,
-0.0057502068,
0.0429825038,
0.0256758891,
0.0045827199,
-0.0078888508,
-0.0015871425,
0.0122113675,
-0.0240725651,
0.0349448323,
-0.0146639282,
0.0485803224,
0.0657707229,
-0.0123069165,
0.0395904705,
-0.0304788444,
-0.0136166262,
0.03188904,
0.0167451594,
0.0379632115,
-0.0059980834,
-0.0032809416,
0.0219655223,
0.0065062018,
-0.0090806074,
0.0257504322,
0.0375508256,
-0.0580501556,
-0.0189801957,
0.076978676,
0.0149603421,
-0.02264487,
-0.0051414901,
0.0254117604,
0.0376688875,
0.0058098817,
0.0086097429,
-0.1301612854,
0.0205376856,
0.0344317481,
0.01527387,
-0.0214803834,
-0.025502447,
-0.0247877762,
-0.1134129018,
0.0437753648,
0.0246300995,
-0.0555578209,
-0.0027731464,
-0.0320335664,
0.0049119685,
-0.035748262,
0.0767966509,
-0.0205615647,
-0.0099898409,
0.0087962579,
0.016178092,
-0.0256222095,
-0.1118656322,
0.0133550335,
-0.0189844184,
0.0523416102,
0.0608547293,
-0.0121114263,
-0.051620584,
-0.0349364989,
0.0246591344,
-0.0332799703,
-0.0371139608,
0.0163156837,
0.0488057807,
0.0082909726,
-0.029365588,
-0.0035653911,
0.0211063661,
0.0040928391,
0.007304206,
-0.0001577151,
0.073683098,
-0.0244869646,
-0.0160956401,
0.0083256736,
-0.0156496204,
0.0153307263,
0.0784394667,
0.042638585,
-0.0428138599,
0.0001076344,
-0.0302879196,
0.0374521799,
-0.0103135696,
0.0280026793,
0.0293798391,
-0.0348176919,
-0.0297136437,
-0.0673129633,
-0.0417751856,
0.0474956073,
-0.0009614464,
0.0351828523,
0.0681913644,
-0.019648172,
0.0012619146,
-0.0350054502,
0.0389474444,
-0.0346419401,
0.0134037519,
-0.0598487556,
-0.0086569386,
-0.0198339988,
0.0172535405,
-0.0254473351,
0.0368695781,
-0.1184615791,
-0.1034528315,
0.0439830236,
0.0431332551,
0.0235581491,
0.0199822895,
-0.0087828096,
-0.0498453751,
0.0520697311,
0.0192915406,
-0.0358048528,
0.0232366845,
0.0165285207,
-0.058359921,
-0.0028508762,
0.0198404677,
-0.0248728227,
-0.007582163,
0.0331745818,
0.0013724336,
-0.0408345386,
0.0007714098,
0.0201216545,
0.041268371,
0.0835389197,
-0.0267304145,
-0.0003502188,
-0.0545609072,
0.0083192931,
-0.0168167613,
-0.0097722327,
-0.0198580194,
0.0273652542,
0.0320146047,
-0.0177451149,
-0.030653365,
-0.023678733,
-0.0630080402,
0.0454655774,
-0.0179819744,
-0.0002115805,
-0.0059342585,
-0.0184805728,
0.0729599446,
0.027710706,
-0.0042101629,
0.0419330113,
0.0139376605,
0.0284046717,
0.0127812335,
0.0524697453,
0.0048834528,
0.0233754497,
0.019974269,
0.0353447571,
-0.0450657718,
-0.0332331099,
-0.0293162502,
0.0056107552,
0.0170538556,
-0.023497697,
0.0351684801,
-0.0102547687,
-0.005096389,
-0.0325383022,
-0.0102995839,
-0.0067102672,
-0.0220875032,
0.0267400183,
-0.0007153532,
-0.0602651648,
0.0484690107,
0.090550445,
0.0296365637,
0.044884298,
-0.0381915681,
-0.0391617864,
-0.0042890264,
-0.0102388794,
0.0340280682,
0.0128838439,
-0.0470450148,
-0.0293618552,
-0.0649211034,
-0.1130589917,
-0.0497297868,
-0.0111590736,
-0.0053457003,
-0.0238522589,
-0.0107834535,
0.0471184216,
-0.0201931261,
0.0053155082,
-0.0339801796,
-0.0149500715,
0.0087531377,
-0.0419027917,
0.004324472,
-6.27995e-33,
0.0099818408,
-0.0206683483,
-0.0148727195,
-0.0069411825,
-0.010632975,
-0.0012733317,
-0.0004990843,
-0.0067843506,
-0.0234795623,
-0.0185860563,
-0.0277075861,
0.0162231252,
0.0168313384,
0.011881521,
-0.0015337298,
-0.02315492,
0.0475361645,
0.0007804359,
-0.0415566526,
0.0266512334,
0.0400981382,
0.0358657166,
0.0716292188,
-0.0468568131,
0.0346114822,
-0.0149005298,
-0.0172938462,
-0.0114091095,
-0.076102607,
0.0595554896,
-0.0157802328,
0.0410506874,
0.0159770548,
-0.0407728814,
-0.0174320806,
0.0070721549,
-0.0209942032,
-0.0349367596,
0.0238382835,
0.0118378885,
0.0103739044,
-0.0498431139,
0.0615365058,
-0.0321950018,
-0.0125427479,
0.0154913217,
0.0135963103,
-0.0344119146,
-0.0489407741,
-0.0086051738,
-0.0052513131,
0.0217628963,
0.0070547471,
0.0211034734,
0.0180934835,
0.0257873517,
0.0043724887,
0.0358149335,
-0.0303610042,
0.0134424493,
0.0993034616,
0.0342577323,
0.0429027192,
0.0314640813,
0.0311181173,
0.0645004436,
0.0183350891,
-0.0213587172,
0.0620863512,
-0.0448899716,
0.0356573537,
-0.002021906,
0.0239387974,
0.0421107933,
0.0566511042,
-0.0434985124,
-0.0363227837,
0.01717248,
-0.0153316464,
0.0083619403,
0.0095879817,
-0.0154070631,
-0.0259792022,
-0.0593689159,
-0.0579798184,
-0.027835004,
-0.0431276038,
-0.0512162559,
0.0632311255,
-0.0356232971,
-0.0485795252,
0.0153821576,
0.0290107001,
-0.0337891355,
-0.0378920734,
-0.0095822159,
-0.0269802064,
-0.0072534876,
-0.010303135,
0.0575566441,
-0.0309812874,
0.0083795162,
0.0294092,
-0.029119039,
0.0241789035,
0.0107946144,
0.0262710769,
0.0363726728,
-0.0821189508,
0.0204125084,
-0.0227896068,
0.0179931223,
0.0108262021,
0.0177298393,
0.0416982025,
0.0069482815,
0.0409328751,
0.0175486542,
0.072256878,
0.0294484571,
-0.029188646,
-0.0200042203,
-0.0192495715,
0.0162408929,
-0.0015690515,
-0.0313761644,
-0.0018218424,
0.0395614877,
0.0628532767,
-0.0494960397,
0.0108272405,
0.0083267167,
2.726e-7,
0.0481863432,
0.0567928255,
-0.0127032921,
0.0045600957,
-0.0013029982,
-0.0003536144,
-0.0509961993,
0.0238677934,
0.0215397496,
0.0099043772,
0.0102455774,
-0.0368685611,
0.0591743328,
0.0516819768,
-0.1001218483,
0.023866782,
-0.0476368479,
-0.0142071964,
-0.0917566121,
0.0165069029,
0.0336475335,
0.1154695228,
0.0141996136,
-0.0264990982,
0.0132542811,
-0.0491754599,
0.0301782191,
-0.0581464395,
-0.0239299852,
0.0152658904,
0.0608066842,
0.0083219195,
0.029228352,
0.0347965993,
-0.0197706316,
-0.003886048,
0.0015208983,
0.0411569811,
0.0026138555,
-0.0318390839,
-0.0257178154,
-0.0355462693,
-0.0206984114,
-0.0928580537,
0.0873501897,
-0.0121882539,
-0.0153883472,
-0.0202427208,
-0.0261747241,
-0.0925983191,
0.064386487,
-0.0503585823,
-0.0156578869,
0.0069622844,
-0.0112495273,
0.0057373745,
-0.0141681563,
-0.0306739621,
0.0245783944,
-0.0208196249,
-0.0319689699,
-0.0682625398,
-0.0077771624,
-0.0296276584,
0.0042017223,
-0.0627713725,
0.0539310984,
2.801869075e-34,
0.05415456,
-0.051374495,
-0.0005464909,
-0.0082897339,
0.0480707549,
-0.0243568104,
0.0298561901,
0.0354317985,
-0.035212718,
-0.0922196209,
-0.0089278035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06221v1 | A Comparison of Lexicon-Based and ML-Based Sentiment Analysis: Are There Outlier Words? | 2023-11-10T18:21:50 | 2023-11-10T18:21:50 | Siddhant Jaydeep Mahajani, Shashank Srivastava, Alan F. Smeaton | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexicon-based approaches to sentiment analysis of text are based on each word
or lexical entry having a pre-defined weight indicating its sentiment polarity.
These are usually manually assigned but the accuracy of these when compared
against machine leaning based approaches to computing sentiment, are not known.
It may be that there are lexical entries whose sentiment values cause a
lexicon-based approach to give results which are very different to a machine
learning approach. In this paper we compute sentiment for more than 150,000
English language texts drawn from 4 domains using the Hedonometer, a
lexicon-based technique and Azure, a contemporary machine-learning based
approach which is part of the Azure Cognitive Services family of APIs which is
easy to use. We model differences in sentiment scores between approaches for
documents in each domain using a regression and analyse the independent
variables (Hedonometer lexical entries) as indicators of each word's importance
and contribution to the score differences. Our findings are that the importance
of a word depends on the domain and there are no standout lexical entries which
systematically cause differences in sentiment scores. | [
0.0278148204,
0.0390322506,
0.0033906568,
0.0201436915,
-0.0797323436,
0.0159686096,
-0.0111387093,
-0.0286969822,
0.0254198238,
-0.08135546,
-0.0097075459,
0.0240701344,
-0.012659831,
0.0337329954,
-0.0484573767,
-0.0170253534,
-0.0097073633,
0.0845376328,
0.0571245216,
-0.0260956399,
0.0336780697,
0.0224058051,
-0.0024078207,
-0.017647773,
-0.0029909785,
-0.0033783927,
0.0498757102,
0.0012401872,
0.0205139406,
-0.0120178685,
0.0214908291,
0.0067586889,
-0.0475479439,
0.0080494499,
0.0000019227,
-0.0426922441,
-0.0131281931,
-0.017504666,
0.0342357494,
-0.0004245987,
0.1128733829,
-0.006382097,
-0.0069135944,
-0.004615427,
-0.0409658514,
0.0145301614,
0.0349005312,
0.0091767153,
0.023992449,
0.0274082925,
-0.0223436654,
-0.0126357889,
-0.0565045476,
0.0180164222,
-0.0166896656,
-0.0040753428,
-0.0045371088,
0.0177690443,
-0.0496937186,
-0.0238840058,
-0.0264820848,
0.002468714,
-0.0328511223,
0.0033539745,
0.0132113919,
0.0174118299,
-0.0002267334,
-0.0295796674,
-0.0092571434,
0.0236676112,
0.043951232,
-0.0100830253,
-0.0221282486,
-0.0140836919,
0.0035254338,
0.0201858394,
-0.0269306321,
0.0078250784,
0.0393506028,
0.0293580573,
0.0324378088,
0.0333763398,
0.0205721669,
0.0695931315,
-0.0359451547,
0.0678396896,
-0.0288435873,
-0.0217827335,
0.0494153723,
0.0399762467,
-0.0256027021,
-0.0048036822,
0.0269657858,
-0.0132445488,
0.0335026495,
0.0084336232,
0.0107082734,
-0.0391270332,
0.0278588627,
-0.0886317417,
0.0237368234,
-0.0014012505,
-0.00676456,
0.0157157537,
0.0042300601,
0.0000802167,
0.0436004996,
-0.0477864668,
0.0106360344,
0.0153881172,
-0.0503938086,
0.0230908226,
0.0620391928,
0.0340228751,
-0.0125849117,
-0.0053688395,
-0.0546344891,
-0.0052132034,
-0.0275600161,
0.0019633782,
-0.0026174213,
0.0069340304,
0.0393504202,
0.0169970579,
-0.0330533497,
0.0214503314,
-0.0819213465,
0.0490864888,
-0.0564963929,
-0.0168434512,
0.0261143632,
0.020772649,
0.0144773275,
0.0133388853,
0.034118142,
0.0508383252,
0.0638061985,
-0.0345933326,
0.0141848354,
-0.0141303595,
-0.0188454408,
-0.0434728302,
-0.0243224055,
-0.0613161065,
-0.0172392633,
0.0265339632,
-0.0002809892,
-0.0026995796,
0.0273111779,
0.0113118384,
-0.026639102,
0.036789462,
-0.0310021304,
-0.0278093386,
0.0062613655,
-0.0189860631,
0.0032088822,
0.0293226317,
-0.0212943479,
0.0246202443,
0.0738095269,
0.0344328843,
0.0231480282,
-0.0213354863,
-0.0116068628,
-0.0414171256,
-0.0750913173,
-0.0079089273,
-0.0309722461,
-0.0204575788,
-0.0160822198,
0.0078669759,
0.0150000192,
0.0010682837,
0.0718163401,
0.0193848684,
-0.0526949838,
0.0114048515,
-0.0668948516,
0.0030534021,
0.0116736656,
-0.016676601,
-0.0403584875,
0.0058424575,
-0.0256335363,
-0.009072898,
0.0143040894,
-0.0349534713,
0.0196564179,
-0.0854355618,
-0.0194735322,
-0.0169063099,
0.0492940098,
0.0036715837,
0.0742641166,
-0.0376357511,
-0.0450713784,
-0.033235345,
0.0258088596,
-0.08537139,
-0.0124696195,
0.0065978477,
0.0197574981,
0.0842580795,
-0.0012426187,
-0.0197173934,
-0.0212171096,
-0.016721826,
-0.0337312669,
0.0224241819,
0.0472610518,
0.0131588709,
0.0009789196,
-0.0522027649,
0.0050510126,
-0.0033549408,
0.0195351038,
-0.0137617327,
-0.0147605892,
0.0510743186,
-0.0098741176,
-0.0193015952,
-0.0665859729,
0.0168294758,
0.0357805192,
-0.0181591902,
0.0020146056,
-0.0132236946,
0.0613642,
0.0442828424,
-0.0288203973,
-0.0179672036,
0.0384505019,
-0.0122736283,
-0.0714049712,
0.02473142,
-0.0025492455,
0.0037439254,
0.0283802692,
-0.0530915707,
0.011518213,
0.0422377698,
-0.0366947837,
-0.0033083698,
0.0289319176,
-0.0051110797,
0.0052098506,
-0.0320962183,
-0.0118651399,
-0.0581999309,
0.0294035021,
-0.0216563754,
0.059076488,
-0.0325512439,
0.0373125225,
-0.0656588748,
-0.0280394014,
0.0093063125,
0.0560264364,
-0.0408121794,
-0.0146936597,
0.0326505899,
0.0265580937,
0.0351155885,
-0.0208612848,
-0.0167456139,
-0.0149351154,
-0.0813597217,
-0.0004094127,
-0.0056544822,
0.0244635288,
0.0073271599,
-0.0005529358,
-0.0233530737,
0.0424704999,
0.0114966119,
-0.0112883002,
-0.0228859354,
0.0288048759,
0.0340393148,
-0.008884266,
0.0540361479,
-0.0317287706,
-0.0053021866,
-0.0020223807,
-0.0096669616,
0.02731614,
-0.0125731677,
0.0413958766,
0.0376806781,
-0.060528025,
-0.0009181341,
-0.0101871304,
-0.0503152683,
-0.0208161175,
0.0086700423,
-0.0103453305,
0.0094029605,
-0.0001265074,
0.0153281456,
0.0177959595,
0.001936057,
-0.0414858349,
-0.0088463724,
-0.0430837199,
0.0461451374,
-0.0108066685,
-0.0165605452,
-0.010833038,
0.0059849229,
0.0183658469,
-0.0274987556,
0.0058440114,
0.0148711968,
-0.0253451727,
-0.0276955701,
-0.0077772657,
0.0151525112,
0.0129230944,
0.0485659614,
0.0445602648,
-0.0523127541,
0.0280802585,
0.0308631156,
0.0162311736,
-0.0975898206,
-0.0133363698,
-0.0084657269,
0.0174336918,
-0.0282058064,
0.0128199086,
-0.0518921353,
0.0139535731,
0.0178077668,
-0.0552474111,
-0.0138111832,
-0.03733363,
0.0395971797,
-0.0228912476,
-0.011210111,
0.0293453149,
-0.0049584401,
0.0368460082,
0.0045859879,
-0.0667957515,
-0.027958734,
0.0388094783,
-0.0427734107,
0.0219410509,
-0.0350613594,
-0.0376641862,
-0.038927149,
-0.0094920862,
-0.0401459783,
0.0614957213,
-0.0364242047,
0.0004050785,
-0.0101678744,
0.0612568818,
0.0074788281,
-0.0259013604,
0.0313233249,
-0.0166930594,
0.0069441302,
-0.0100405719,
0.0021718212,
0.0120742572,
-0.0476795658,
0.0003624571,
-0.0374984592,
0.0140031585,
-0.0180668309,
0.0109138926,
0.103945218,
0.0402272083,
-0.0609534085,
0.0091405679,
-0.005268937,
-0.007635768,
0.0615639649,
-0.0160409957,
0.0052791759,
-0.0182005093,
0.0100089442,
0.0546635687,
-0.0399371348,
-0.0275300276,
0.0052253748,
-0.0957421437,
0.0085866516,
-0.0267158262,
-0.0147898523,
-0.041376967,
-0.065137215,
0.0017167011,
-0.0347919539,
-0.061333701,
-0.0442971177,
0.0198227856,
0.0370299183,
-0.031381622,
-0.0562049821,
0.0025425756,
0.0237526614,
0.0109470841,
0.005966634,
0.063283585,
0.0857475549,
-0.0627301261,
-0.0060389782,
0.027131265,
0.0031709913,
-0.0039418936,
-0.0776130185,
0.0967312828,
0.006807894,
-0.0227634758,
-0.0404788963,
0.0195269361,
-0.0900606662,
0.0295408368,
-0.0112692416,
0.033165697,
-0.0121894581,
-0.0219102334,
-0.0604723804,
0.0460239723,
0.0492577553,
0.0455524698,
-0.0329715163,
-0.0647020265,
-0.0207127184,
-0.0303037111,
0.0033546339,
0.0001212151,
-0.0109005077,
-0.023365749,
0.0312741287,
-0.0538285971,
-0.0456774123,
-0.0527520701,
-0.0162717365,
0.0304360576,
0.0004612215,
0.0221930332,
-0.0273272227,
0.0005904161,
-0.0539525561,
0.0016727424,
0.0610819645,
0.0210849252,
0.0222530477,
-0.0097066164,
0.0993426964,
0.0090492703,
-0.031929262,
-0.0234313663,
0.0218905397,
-0.0291752201,
0.0201140773,
0.0388476513,
0.0124288844,
0.0075135748,
-0.0193432476,
-0.0140212141,
0.0663557723,
0.0904417932,
-0.058044333,
-0.0007253744,
0.0510078929,
0.0276763402,
0.005900573,
0.0073293028,
-0.0180179812,
0.0549084283,
0.015315461,
-0.0324059725,
-0.0060171159,
-0.0558250472,
-0.0069446927,
-0.0290586762,
0.044549901,
-0.0028697755,
-0.000423696,
-0.0114661651,
-0.0092560649,
0.0104191061,
-0.0493564568,
-0.0073298695,
-0.0337999165,
0.0082536712,
0.0288793463,
-0.1026590466,
0.0384088829,
-0.0216504466,
-0.0087473989,
-0.010532626,
0.080930911,
0.0370155498,
0.0324804448,
-0.0206706468,
0.0011659401,
-0.0065805567,
-0.0351333916,
-0.0090523968,
0.0049177073,
-0.0022912521,
0.0249229055,
0.008659441,
0.0275696926,
0.0331974924,
0.0140395034,
-0.0379684642,
0.0143337017,
-0.0094400942,
0.0074120197,
-0.0132059902,
-0.0345005207,
0.0102167008,
-0.0289109908,
0.0153364567,
-0.0358188488,
-0.0133227399,
-0.0152211795,
0.0250593796,
0.0187913291,
-0.0174961984,
-0.0219869278,
0.0040062382,
0.0192603264,
-0.0813928023,
0.0276268497,
0.054757949,
-0.0168345124,
-0.0511560589,
-0.0271855835,
0.0515212603,
-0.0119281001,
0.0232864767,
0.0318037607,
-0.0556583293,
-0.0365837626,
0.1049871743,
-0.0327966958,
0.0439987257,
-0.0191250611,
0.0360403508,
0.0905485898,
-0.0092967711,
0.0299597625,
-0.041847501,
0.0238748509,
-0.0772184506,
-0.0283097737,
-0.0267959572,
-6.053882232e-33,
-0.0015254205,
-0.0467722639,
-0.071088478,
0.0312296208,
0.0148065127,
-0.0209860541,
-0.0076941964,
0.0187632069,
-0.0025711476,
0.0845983475,
-0.0191491134,
0.0746607929,
-0.0024860126,
0.0193802267,
0.0698042139,
-0.0181819536,
0.0184761658,
-0.020719273,
0.0073890435,
-0.0052277124,
0.0410045646,
0.0267270096,
0.0662392825,
-0.1407052428,
0.0796068311,
0.0051115206,
-0.0149773909,
-0.0384581722,
0.0207696296,
0.0088531235,
0.0096444003,
0.0955088884,
0.0221503545,
0.0063143778,
0.0129371826,
0.0302413814,
0.0118055036,
-0.0446750373,
-0.0087239817,
0.0026300778,
0.0236014165,
-0.0153830051,
0.0262784027,
0.0282155927,
-0.0972141623,
0.0092156734,
0.0520156026,
-0.0257139876,
0.0070356573,
-0.079326719,
-0.0303820986,
0.0300622247,
-0.0386206061,
0.0050934209,
0.0293353572,
0.038984552,
0.0160561129,
0.062996991,
-0.0731280968,
0.0154585065,
-0.0540055148,
-0.0304322764,
-0.0021302144,
-0.040153414,
0.0127224633,
0.0770920888,
0.0006831242,
0.0176593866,
0.0195830874,
0.0719795674,
0.0257128794,
0.0125008468,
0.0460792519,
0.0575142317,
0.0220851731,
-0.021430362,
-0.029236367,
0.0371622927,
0.0257347878,
-0.0083376709,
0.0591377206,
-0.0204546489,
-0.025708314,
-0.0082158698,
0.0308277141,
-0.0702227205,
-0.0111943763,
0.0186784007,
-0.0208548643,
-0.0584452003,
-0.0164244622,
0.0069496748,
-0.0261489693,
-0.0537418425,
-0.0499327183,
0.0342335664,
-0.0069031026,
0.0187815856,
0.0260546282,
-0.016324807,
-0.0543285236,
0.0195412133,
-0.081019856,
0.0491531081,
0.0310847349,
-0.0117085716,
0.0070762527,
0.0496264733,
-0.0659912601,
-0.0312874764,
0.0134826452,
0.0194351804,
0.0072374153,
0.0498940162,
0.0013418876,
-0.0272220336,
0.0008868239,
0.0355867632,
0.0320565067,
0.0427336954,
0.0025244111,
-0.024308024,
-0.0050897594,
-0.0110187493,
-0.052697029,
-0.0684444308,
0.010405913,
-0.0213106088,
-0.0015649918,
-0.0278699119,
-0.0073016048,
-0.0106572229,
2.767e-7,
0.059511777,
0.1021496579,
-0.0318888687,
0.008179618,
0.0269558039,
0.0754899085,
0.0131831001,
-0.0023278643,
0.0019761345,
-0.0041354932,
0.0124796396,
-0.0108335735,
0.0276474785,
0.0131285824,
-0.0743719786,
-0.0005694781,
0.0056909835,
-0.0010192131,
0.0094848415,
0.0505690798,
0.081554465,
0.0629086345,
0.0603413321,
-0.018024547,
-0.0273589753,
-0.0072963256,
-0.0026529643,
-0.0826592594,
0.0131352777,
0.024165025,
-0.0187546462,
0.0245211422,
-0.013634176,
0.0034447142,
-0.0130864326,
0.0284886695,
0.0333327949,
0.0382935219,
-0.0204281416,
-0.0260984711,
0.0001287237,
-0.0254008994,
0.0385915115,
0.008923593,
0.0239785258,
0.0063143545,
-0.0348009728,
-0.1011267528,
-0.0247949716,
0.0100994483,
0.1098501161,
-0.0077918414,
-0.0119740777,
0.0186390933,
-0.0003072983,
-0.0185036901,
-0.0466030128,
-0.049663391,
-0.0051627476,
-0.0111410478,
0.0060876207,
-0.0209361725,
0.0333963856,
0.0707312524,
0.0285679493,
0.0063191396,
0.0026992545,
1.947768655e-34,
0.0524578989,
-0.0304156095,
-0.0197881199,
0.014439459,
0.0214052349,
0.0142309749,
0.0035862778,
-0.0134065896,
0.0145748779,
-0.0222542714,
0.0402063541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06217v1 | MultiIoT: Towards Large-scale Multisensory Learning for the Internet of Things | 2023-11-10T18:13:08 | 2023-11-10T18:13:08 | Shentong Mo, Paul Pu Liang, Russ Salakhutdinov, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | The Internet of Things (IoT), the network integrating billions of smart
physical devices embedded with sensors, software, and communication
technologies for the purpose of connecting and exchanging data with other
devices and systems, is a critical and rapidly expanding component of our
modern world. The IoT ecosystem provides a rich source of real-world modalities
such as motion, thermal, geolocation, imaging, depth, sensors, video, and audio
for prediction tasks involving the pose, gaze, activities, and gestures of
humans as well as the touch, contact, pose, 3D of physical objects. Machine
learning presents a rich opportunity to automatically process IoT data at
scale, enabling efficient inference for impact in understanding human
wellbeing, controlling physical devices, and interconnecting smart cities. To
develop machine learning technologies for IoT, this paper proposes MultiIoT,
the most expansive IoT benchmark to date, encompassing over 1.15 million
samples from 12 modalities and 8 tasks. MultiIoT introduces unique challenges
involving (1) learning from many sensory modalities, (2) fine-grained
interactions across long temporal ranges, and (3) extreme heterogeneity due to
unique structure and noise topologies in real-world sensors. We also release a
set of strong modeling baselines, spanning modality and task-specific methods
to multisensory and multitask models to encourage future research in
multisensory representation learning for IoT. | [
-0.0745826215,
0.0420111679,
-0.0220704786,
0.0064779604,
-0.028399935,
-0.0104487324,
0.0361336432,
-0.0277319234,
0.0375249572,
-0.0261276122,
-0.0092600137,
0.0115851667,
-0.0063855802,
-0.0156043004,
0.032661844,
-0.0141777592,
0.0489708818,
0.02391381,
-0.0406955667,
0.0163247678,
0.0090650031,
0.0062853284,
0.0051411488,
0.0451052599,
-0.0350315124,
-0.004904205,
-0.0145313628,
0.0188690592,
0.037252713,
-0.0608272702,
0.034716554,
0.014570958,
0.0765035674,
0.0523665659,
0.0000022284,
0.010569226,
-0.0062031006,
0.0036043909,
0.0425321534,
-0.0355625562,
0.0066348659,
-0.0491686463,
0.021901112,
0.0379663296,
-0.0221247841,
-0.0105347857,
0.0911146775,
0.0196753293,
0.0247889496,
0.0280588046,
-0.0245869439,
0.03802827,
0.0410213806,
-0.0109580541,
0.0259046089,
0.0189321786,
-0.0286242682,
-0.032678511,
-0.0223564301,
-0.0032775106,
0.0010221894,
-0.0316766091,
0.0292071681,
0.0870749578,
0.0137983989,
0.0432468615,
0.0024668176,
0.0030171447,
-0.0465734266,
0.057186842,
-0.0495840088,
-0.0170519706,
0.036643479,
0.0221859477,
-0.0375068411,
-0.0364217609,
-0.040189188,
-0.0667372718,
0.0311753582,
0.0303168651,
-0.0582073852,
-0.0016645814,
0.0444187522,
0.0326974317,
0.0126595395,
0.0480949208,
-0.0056000957,
0.0287722088,
-0.0060010022,
-0.0139931086,
0.0266542621,
-0.0039837705,
-0.0378363431,
0.0012732155,
-0.0753730759,
-0.0770625174,
-0.0291511714,
0.0213927459,
-0.0367250405,
0.0210234877,
0.0329017192,
0.0088611003,
0.0046239858,
0.0538811833,
0.0296075232,
-0.0460598357,
-0.0750009492,
-0.01306812,
-0.0333065242,
-0.0063096713,
-0.055976633,
0.000767606,
0.0268196575,
0.008117428,
-0.0009161123,
-0.0536935255,
-0.0136667462,
0.0126772923,
-0.052678857,
-0.0142987557,
-0.0475587994,
0.0475856774,
0.0007112174,
-0.0132893575,
0.0420223661,
0.0560146421,
0.0032512948,
0.0673876479,
0.0005961012,
-0.0284022372,
-0.0112788398,
0.0340785645,
0.0090671489,
-0.02588466,
0.0075328825,
0.0755670145,
-0.002108627,
-0.0139814056,
0.0003004522,
-0.0091770766,
0.0274771079,
-0.0313622318,
0.0201892536,
-0.0400271304,
0.0289875269,
-0.0254034866,
0.0233554933,
-0.0156804472,
0.0031114472,
-0.0161869396,
-0.0126274368,
0.114277944,
0.0036447735,
-0.008993688,
0.0209424533,
-0.0068265232,
0.0119853858,
0.028111482,
0.0381323472,
0.0264890436,
0.0192724578,
-0.0353768133,
-0.0059369961,
0.0528632402,
0.0220098626,
-0.022128759,
0.0270746294,
-0.0157505088,
-0.0387909524,
0.018864302,
-0.0248704273,
0.0084206676,
-0.0252487045,
0.0083892597,
0.0500476845,
0.0220610481,
0.0020959489,
-0.0000541546,
-0.0211493354,
0.0238813013,
-0.0230629109,
-0.0588479787,
-0.0859908164,
0.0705457777,
-0.0072167586,
-0.0373967513,
0.0122232521,
-0.018074492,
-0.0500154346,
-0.021367671,
-0.0059817485,
-0.0466538966,
0.0274924058,
-0.0032033797,
0.0479231589,
-0.048690062,
-0.0016841353,
0.0171290264,
0.0356171764,
-0.0057789125,
-0.0246845614,
-0.0162296034,
0.010847833,
0.0060339649,
-0.0037492723,
-0.0709794983,
-0.0076214317,
-0.0198097993,
0.0277944617,
-0.0379724763,
0.0207644776,
0.0092495941,
0.0809291229,
-0.0242084656,
-0.0531633347,
0.0226635206,
0.0575427115,
-0.006184231,
-0.03340156,
-0.0300412271,
0.0389504731,
-0.0167133026,
0.0093381759,
0.0266894866,
-0.0291929711,
0.0001818835,
0.0211507045,
0.0433773957,
0.0385816954,
-0.0231325924,
-0.0061915913,
-0.0223813783,
0.0509165525,
-0.0571202412,
0.0163552314,
0.0307131801,
-0.0325524136,
0.0527901426,
0.0172129478,
-0.0075307284,
0.0111110341,
0.0717137903,
-0.0688734204,
-0.0163415354,
0.0267503206,
-0.0023116427,
-0.0217961688,
0.0118569164,
-0.0594866723,
0.0292400513,
0.0172270201,
0.0259520914,
-0.0197299533,
0.003436238,
0.0046252408,
-0.0050713336,
0.0022850772,
0.0327022076,
-0.0111236917,
-0.0079128165,
-0.0480184406,
-0.0281886887,
0.0434967205,
0.0342460535,
0.0356417149,
-0.0012572069,
0.0177607462,
-0.0976173207,
0.0213076361,
-0.042458538,
0.0018033996,
-0.0357691124,
0.0145104881,
0.0266781952,
-0.0368483514,
-0.0143667199,
0.0504534282,
-0.0413579494,
0.0096269632,
0.0068507008,
-0.0024977822,
-0.0066344724,
-0.0074624927,
-0.0011208382,
-0.0106974309,
0.053436067,
0.0056112208,
0.0302087665,
0.0106462464,
-0.0626345426,
0.0016355023,
0.0170148835,
-0.0213965531,
-0.0258833598,
0.0272902213,
-0.02130026,
-0.0035736945,
0.062870644,
0.0125115393,
0.0108287549,
0.0145499455,
-0.0212986171,
-0.0323543288,
0.0197397713,
-0.0128550641,
0.0374721438,
-0.0405009054,
0.0197127685,
-0.0287151504,
0.0445498489,
-0.0228517596,
-0.022904586,
-0.0303472579,
0.01463605,
0.0154358279,
-0.0465119518,
-0.0522003397,
0.0503588282,
-0.0179571267,
0.0142235728,
-0.0228513535,
-0.0713165998,
-0.0018859924,
0.0040076068,
0.0288797915,
0.0175053943,
-0.0096441107,
-0.0024266716,
0.1036745682,
0.0161366425,
0.0218266491,
-0.0240492038,
-0.0099558318,
-0.0422161482,
-0.0123731624,
-0.0102770505,
0.0120110493,
-0.0468153097,
-0.044258479,
-0.0018181779,
-0.0119834021,
-0.0618819147,
-0.0057977019,
0.0478596538,
-0.0160934441,
-0.0152578466,
-0.118875213,
-0.0022406373,
-0.0085826982,
-0.0306367017,
-0.0348266587,
0.030865144,
0.0213473216,
-0.0161097851,
-0.0294103064,
0.0402256884,
0.0558227301,
0.044435259,
-0.0596184731,
-0.0113444626,
-0.0248802975,
0.0368892476,
0.0589046776,
0.0170627777,
-0.1158624366,
0.0268212091,
0.0252504814,
0.03214873,
-0.0166001264,
0.0318978503,
0.052472353,
-0.0285062138,
0.0061074058,
0.0631708503,
-0.0246834978,
-0.0514233559,
0.0177742988,
0.0477513596,
0.0068360297,
0.0004427856,
-0.0297233202,
-0.0500266999,
-0.0669885129,
-0.0054878062,
0.0207758099,
0.0216331501,
-0.0236334074,
0.0274627563,
-0.0394891575,
0.0433887132,
0.0083169658,
-0.0663591996,
-0.1006602868,
-0.0387419499,
-0.0007919081,
-0.0584469847,
0.0343314074,
-0.0364381373,
0.0227244496,
-0.005676772,
0.0230556298,
-0.0438049398,
-0.0408491641,
0.0470705554,
-0.0341325141,
0.0101504559,
0.0093787163,
0.0467571057,
-0.0349108987,
-0.0261722878,
-0.0178293176,
0.0302818604,
-0.0119569236,
-0.0500346981,
0.0185507871,
-0.0168721154,
-0.0071197329,
0.0163483694,
0.1118640453,
-0.0539933704,
-0.027720714,
0.0078507187,
0.0587174892,
-0.0266351905,
0.0074365768,
-0.0407744497,
-0.064906396,
0.0664638653,
0.0134690721,
-0.0407612063,
-0.0360170789,
-0.0519342758,
-0.0008637407,
0.0069288071,
0.0316658318,
-0.0222827718,
-0.0260707308,
0.0150409052,
-0.0704875663,
-0.0272736326,
0.0089712432,
-0.0164492819,
0.0517463535,
0.0003690069,
0.0036415793,
0.0209833812,
0.0261025149,
-0.0742368102,
0.0342773497,
0.032672178,
0.0552372076,
0.0095814774,
0.0286252461,
0.04226432,
-0.0291639492,
0.0030173929,
0.0456456915,
-0.1263072044,
-0.0554009937,
-0.0247940421,
0.0590608604,
0.0175195113,
0.0808881819,
-0.018529851,
0.0284091067,
0.0197066311,
0.0444699153,
-0.0614222139,
0.018275734,
0.0466647074,
-0.0423246324,
-0.0219288878,
0.0264754612,
-0.0281989835,
0.0541160256,
0.0022158555,
-0.0041614962,
-0.0076406072,
-0.0290703438,
0.002236967,
-0.0269687362,
0.1001285464,
0.0062473351,
0.009465849,
-0.0100428872,
-0.023284927,
0.0323484913,
0.0205919631,
-0.0620863736,
0.01199954,
0.0369888805,
0.0098624881,
-0.0250052568,
0.0287275538,
0.1065637395,
-0.0055013527,
-0.0528111309,
0.010248336,
0.0007924133,
0.0362901427,
-0.0192509759,
-0.0287185907,
0.0231012497,
0.0126185277,
-0.0236151926,
0.009693319,
-0.0243506823,
-0.0202156082,
0.0218131933,
0.0153456135,
-0.0610715486,
0.0523848161,
-0.0115541453,
-0.0376714282,
-0.016854072,
0.0257866122,
0.0482912511,
0.0006434064,
0.0384192131,
-0.0496702045,
-0.0022112171,
-0.0473219901,
0.098357521,
-0.0296926014,
0.0377928093,
0.0070086843,
0.0171389747,
-0.0194823779,
0.0507113971,
0.0461388305,
-0.0099385483,
0.0220879689,
0.0037588049,
-0.0162497088,
-0.0627152622,
0.0233512409,
0.0321734361,
0.028005695,
-0.0084156264,
0.0257314146,
-0.0081752501,
-0.0337406434,
0.0158516429,
0.01280169,
0.0298093017,
-0.012495161,
0.0258021671,
0.059437044,
-0.0252730828,
-0.0154059548,
0.005040471,
-0.0688485652,
-0.0399265438,
-0.0109767299,
-0.0280837659,
-6.153059425e-33,
0.051153589,
0.021340508,
-0.0031725378,
-0.0019430084,
-0.030272359,
0.0243188981,
0.0153936632,
-0.0206928104,
-0.0029124341,
-0.0215462241,
0.0008448121,
0.000555647,
0.0022063041,
0.0157413669,
0.0514598303,
0.0124933962,
0.0416966341,
-0.0257648639,
-0.0058019282,
-0.0111045325,
0.0409981981,
-0.0205478147,
0.0413194709,
-0.0562578551,
-0.0221137777,
0.0242379103,
-0.0526581742,
-0.0248480756,
-0.0469578765,
0.0077641089,
-0.0306931306,
0.040855363,
0.0216484927,
0.0444750264,
0.0142504144,
0.0286480859,
-0.0720453113,
0.0013273,
-0.062778756,
0.0063050706,
-0.0864821598,
-0.0304082781,
0.025387425,
0.0038617202,
-0.0405405462,
-0.016903,
0.0372875929,
-0.0066223028,
-0.0091911405,
-0.0101264063,
-0.0252242163,
0.0179130696,
-0.0399280116,
-0.0557372048,
-0.0115304776,
0.0193246268,
0.0010761542,
0.0070665618,
-0.1169388965,
0.0094025834,
-0.0511155576,
-0.003680205,
0.0255801622,
0.0182967782,
0.0399581082,
0.0493030362,
0.0369409658,
-0.0198289994,
0.0354042426,
0.0168575328,
0.032965567,
0.1020590886,
-0.0312600173,
0.0585553199,
0.0392526984,
-0.0563391708,
-0.0945862383,
0.0507340021,
0.0333398022,
0.0421719775,
-0.0168985054,
-0.001436529,
0.004869042,
0.0097966585,
0.0185521729,
-0.037549369,
0.0063566682,
0.0158776641,
0.0160072614,
0.0329821073,
-0.0013935497,
0.030256914,
0.0368287899,
-0.0318987668,
0.013174342,
-0.0063872789,
-0.0002609027,
0.0149136567,
0.0327975936,
0.0161652006,
-0.0339523628,
-0.0832293853,
0.0009885652,
-0.0179975554,
0.0151496213,
-0.024261089,
0.0150380787,
0.0818503201,
-0.0008158557,
-0.025599923,
-0.0096051292,
0.0099460101,
0.0070240875,
0.0198324993,
0.0787070245,
-0.0275595989,
0.0200129598,
0.0614355989,
-0.0417047217,
0.0097311893,
-0.0043579619,
0.0050234366,
0.0025095155,
0.0161914825,
0.0091807283,
-0.0301789362,
-0.078705743,
-0.0870184153,
0.0077340282,
-0.0337564796,
-0.0314841494,
-0.0019130309,
3.112e-7,
-0.0331161618,
0.0547077022,
-0.018209219,
-0.0385994352,
0.038586542,
0.0575863272,
-0.0241940524,
0.0678718984,
-0.0465880707,
0.0108728418,
0.0271504708,
0.0009935823,
0.0889780372,
-0.0108078541,
-0.0428913943,
-0.0097813122,
0.0256183129,
0.0498782173,
-0.0412793085,
0.0010170431,
0.0315474533,
0.0882446319,
0.0305737555,
-0.0014265585,
0.0854312181,
-0.0272539258,
0.0534108728,
-0.0432546325,
0.0167364608,
-0.0442967452,
0.0236519184,
0.0030994408,
-0.0082720295,
-0.0242521986,
-0.0278963372,
0.0056068655,
0.0077318568,
0.0276516732,
-0.0244327225,
-0.0241638962,
-0.0161766037,
0.0128901294,
-0.0015851579,
-0.0199093521,
0.0582342818,
-0.0512464419,
-0.0238449145,
-0.0364939421,
-0.0234988797,
0.0504502803,
0.0328733325,
0.0232980605,
-0.0239982437,
-0.0424710922,
-0.0149450088,
-0.0319983773,
-0.0254966002,
-0.0401342399,
-0.0197983515,
-0.0042281761,
-0.047220435,
-0.0163376871,
-0.0159601271,
-0.0706253946,
0.0544615164,
-0.0414492041,
-0.0569909588,
2.446225785e-34,
-0.0008490249,
-0.0127773462,
0.007893363,
-0.0000463675,
-0.024923401,
-0.0240846053,
-0.0262497962,
0.009712032,
0.0176174454,
0.0171541907,
0.0085447505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06204v1 | BanglaBait: Semi-Supervised Adversarial Approach for Clickbait Detection on Bangla Clickbait Dataset | 2023-11-10T17:38:46 | 2023-11-10T17:38:46 | Md. Motahar Mahtab, Monirul Haque, Mehedi Hasan, Farig Sadeque | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Intentionally luring readers to click on a particular content by exploiting
their curiosity defines a title as clickbait. Although several studies focused
on detecting clickbait titles in English articles, low resource language like
Bangla has not been given adequate attention. To tackle clickbait titles in
Bangla, we have constructed the first Bangla clickbait detection dataset
containing 15,056 labeled news articles and 65,406 unlabelled news articles
extracted from clickbait dense news sites. Each article has been labeled by
three expert linguists and includes an article's title, body, and other
metadata. By incorporating labeled and unlabelled data, we finetune a
pretrained Bangla transformer model in an adversarial fashion using Semi
Supervised Generative Adversarial Networks (SS GANs). The proposed model acts
as a good baseline for this dataset, outperforming traditional neural network
models (LSTM, GRU, CNN) and linguistic feature based models. We expect that
this dataset and the detailed analysis and comparison of these clickbait
detection models will provide a fundamental basis for future research into
detecting clickbait titles in Bengali articles. We have released the
corresponding code and dataset. | [
0.0744032487,
0.0214766096,
-0.0298933666,
0.0590342693,
-0.0427585952,
0.0165689625,
-0.003534528,
0.0163735803,
0.0346702337,
0.0255802684,
-0.0457777306,
-0.0184503924,
0.007031749,
0.0517901629,
0.026523374,
-0.0439305827,
0.0347007886,
0.0261436347,
0.0249542203,
0.011371851,
0.0230781436,
0.0327598117,
0.038766887,
0.0103622088,
-0.0129310675,
-0.0191634558,
0.0335214958,
0.0312694572,
0.0002758621,
-0.0284008011,
0.0469547808,
0.0483422428,
-0.0038489569,
0.0458795987,
0.000001633,
-0.0120246736,
0.0241307113,
-0.0026965013,
0.0016177914,
0.0262731854,
0.0562442094,
-0.0471913144,
-0.0335479937,
0.0131481895,
-0.0249143708,
-0.0183110274,
0.0546245985,
0.0687231794,
0.0496426746,
0.0786091089,
-0.0280911103,
-0.0429830439,
0.0090054516,
-0.0381254628,
0.0348564535,
-0.0297997538,
0.0119895265,
-0.013893608,
0.0109123504,
0.0459788665,
-0.0475371964,
0.0438746363,
0.0153914923,
-0.0419777073,
-0.0539401993,
0.0220906865,
-0.016905468,
-0.0120286914,
0.0391532443,
0.0408946238,
-0.1102127731,
-0.0497241952,
-0.0050818273,
0.0187705904,
0.0000574311,
-0.0313382372,
-0.0542515889,
0.0401368923,
0.0081430776,
0.0271856841,
0.0031746961,
-0.0106116822,
0.0189785957,
0.0249816068,
0.0462766886,
-0.0297423676,
0.0058597508,
-0.0269554481,
-0.0064990595,
-0.0184465125,
0.0443418361,
-0.0245933607,
0.0514506325,
0.0020930178,
-0.0022740322,
0.0058698966,
-0.0568241477,
-0.0463812277,
0.0147269489,
-0.0530212894,
-0.0581542812,
-0.0044523431,
-0.0296353567,
0.0427683331,
-0.037225619,
-0.0135865137,
-0.008280158,
0.0525243208,
-0.0246605258,
0.0024332849,
0.0339660235,
-0.0499169305,
0.0001007808,
0.0049144262,
-0.0203855801,
-0.0153008904,
-0.0715864971,
0.0181435607,
0.0077891978,
0.016267268,
-0.0354599394,
0.0344029255,
-0.0414940231,
-0.034675125,
0.0469813794,
-0.0026955456,
0.0082158949,
0.0050767511,
0.0249108449,
-0.0766983926,
-0.0561860055,
0.0241248067,
-0.0010011584,
-0.0346621722,
0.0065034661,
0.0036462469,
-0.0195941888,
-0.0478065088,
-0.0802857503,
0.0035163949,
-0.04685295,
-0.0158670973,
-0.0355675407,
-0.0558435991,
0.0341069736,
-0.0194972251,
-0.0123856952,
-0.0287948698,
-0.0138172396,
0.0666350126,
-0.0100443857,
0.0874114335,
0.02732273,
-0.042283427,
0.0423950367,
0.0680799782,
0.0629247203,
0.0578576736,
-0.0403238349,
0.1396587789,
0.0446431339,
0.0147329001,
0.0338299125,
0.045733314,
0.0293927025,
-0.0081891688,
0.0244956166,
-0.0000089906,
-0.0167782474,
0.0171963349,
-0.002334805,
0.029989291,
0.0053521502,
-0.0144501235,
0.0938301161,
0.0223517101,
-0.0524631925,
0.050743822,
0.0390232466,
0.0197990667,
-0.0007174611,
0.0110767903,
-0.0459890366,
0.0166297015,
-0.0393098705,
-0.02043535,
0.006757319,
0.0680861324,
-0.0072409282,
-0.0101161459,
0.0386425704,
-0.0114066489,
-0.0118763028,
-0.0515160412,
0.0419099033,
0.0611250103,
-0.0527290627,
-0.0035159416,
0.0156375915,
0.0046192207,
0.020030586,
-0.0313225947,
0.0342361182,
-0.0490127243,
0.073441647,
0.0204220843,
-0.020726474,
-0.0344879441,
0.009975059,
0.0382954665,
0.0028305049,
-0.0146954656,
-0.0538817458,
-0.0177441202,
-0.0153555041,
-0.0145813916,
0.0110019259,
0.0375721678,
-0.01191126,
0.0407725498,
0.0558529682,
0.0025197514,
-0.0458124392,
0.0232008975,
0.0281653181,
-0.0238607302,
0.007629924,
0.0188473761,
0.0582060404,
-0.0165991802,
-0.0112997238,
-0.0285491329,
0.029474169,
0.0150639508,
-0.0330169015,
0.0081084659,
0.0293860845,
-0.0876687989,
-0.0317962691,
-0.1112262979,
0.0042479723,
0.0639509857,
-0.023020193,
-0.0136250816,
0.0357100591,
-0.0243718717,
-0.0194578413,
-0.0435909219,
-0.0074830679,
-0.0186447501,
0.0346974544,
0.0011207894,
0.0494506285,
0.0115319323,
0.0121942023,
0.0410904847,
0.0171308145,
0.0468286052,
-0.0228949152,
-0.0352808312,
0.0395634733,
-0.0253077354,
-0.0252360087,
0.0060485485,
0.00666324,
0.0123887416,
0.0104294997,
-0.0652679428,
-0.0326946042,
-0.0162662305,
-0.0066599413,
0.0477377474,
0.033863049,
-0.0173823554,
-0.0181249268,
-0.0480908602,
-0.0617904291,
0.018852666,
0.007212833,
-0.0027657363,
-0.028295815,
0.0428646244,
0.0010403518,
0.0147833377,
0.0008696071,
0.063116014,
0.0448927358,
-0.0140875913,
0.0078694597,
-0.0304038692,
0.0154439686,
-0.0288040526,
-0.0342770144,
-0.0387664586,
-0.0449508652,
0.0190784782,
-0.0140606379,
0.0538839698,
0.0502052531,
0.0180863943,
-0.0042610005,
0.0387539938,
-0.0212418679,
-0.022422757,
-0.0407328792,
-0.0066066859,
-0.0100792786,
-0.0450840406,
0.0746239647,
-0.0123069864,
0.0344054326,
0.041001685,
-0.0001178378,
0.0262551326,
-0.0120342085,
-0.004716571,
-0.0451811068,
0.0257026255,
-0.017780982,
0.0108000385,
-0.026738489,
-0.032961376,
0.0550527275,
-0.0227350611,
0.0011221984,
-0.0112064565,
-0.0010485951,
-0.0108955093,
0.0080105867,
-0.0150853069,
0.0525367744,
0.0010680095,
-0.0524884649,
-0.0303505287,
0.0433126241,
0.041035302,
-0.0039442591,
-0.0188956466,
-0.0015254144,
-0.0032951008,
-0.0051479568,
-0.0415306389,
-0.0531352498,
-0.0844566077,
0.0420036837,
-0.0343394093,
0.0482900962,
0.0131960502,
-0.0241741706,
0.0296020675,
-0.0032131362,
-0.0017296426,
-0.0405617096,
-0.0143463612,
0.0398467146,
0.0894659087,
0.0478130616,
-0.0516558588,
-0.000598795,
0.0247175265,
-0.040706791,
0.0184986126,
-0.0649711266,
0.0132498788,
0.0045810887,
-0.0173387434,
0.0278775245,
-0.0220734831,
-0.0018500333,
-0.055154603,
-0.0418310463,
-0.0148351677,
-0.0465281904,
0.0612184331,
0.0173858032,
-0.0170176718,
-0.0097760372,
0.0114845335,
-0.0326194018,
-0.0295993593,
0.0143697793,
-0.0466479361,
-0.0021714021,
-0.0360757522,
-0.0048061796,
0.0098286066,
0.0200136956,
-0.0274117999,
-0.0888286531,
-0.0151093667,
0.0029942875,
-0.0454849787,
-0.0529312752,
-0.0054265517,
-0.0189496353,
-0.0194482002,
0.0172078554,
0.000094959,
-0.009607044,
0.0081533492,
-0.012354414,
0.0131695895,
-0.0716660842,
-0.0109572336,
-0.0013269358,
0.0327174291,
0.0426265225,
0.0528883934,
-0.0535297729,
0.0186904147,
-0.0099320058,
-0.0214084033,
-0.0542332791,
-0.0304194633,
0.0862022862,
-0.0373944789,
-0.0039109318,
0.0046124067,
0.0543971509,
0.0383185185,
0.0201875865,
0.0053499313,
0.0114791291,
0.0347202085,
-0.0709595606,
-0.0542508438,
-0.0050229458,
0.0041634496,
0.0480778813,
0.0390409082,
-0.0329115987,
-0.0118588181,
-0.0343603119,
-0.0331393629,
-0.059979409,
-0.0599218458,
0.0025529426,
-0.0649756864,
-0.0687513798,
-0.0552520603,
-0.0562482402,
-0.0013108107,
0.0045814067,
0.0328954011,
-0.007076154,
-0.0187631566,
-0.0167093817,
-0.0403119363,
-0.0450635031,
-0.0211699512,
0.0154220769,
-0.0346635841,
0.0279986132,
0.0789233968,
-0.0297096372,
-0.0272852872,
0.0006335271,
-0.0444373228,
-0.0140007762,
-0.0091643445,
0.0291905366,
0.0049398569,
0.0272996984,
-0.0598738194,
-0.0464002155,
0.0869361684,
0.0866414458,
0.0031543509,
-0.0318040736,
0.008155806,
0.0103387414,
0.0209485143,
0.0382646061,
-0.0150594404,
0.0698077232,
0.0407594293,
-0.0600458868,
-0.0308135096,
0.0541428588,
0.0107088946,
-0.0012257789,
0.0447762236,
-0.031171035,
0.0152141396,
-0.0337947682,
-0.0225778837,
0.0184213016,
-0.0084415087,
-0.0096314177,
0.0085265599,
0.0756321773,
0.0373373777,
-0.0115916627,
0.0104874419,
-0.0245072395,
-0.0097955829,
-0.0578910559,
-0.024110714,
0.0019381014,
0.0287072193,
0.0014928377,
0.0212172996,
0.0007931392,
0.0000382866,
0.0171491988,
0.0033420408,
0.0007601824,
0.0270804614,
0.0494700857,
-0.0110040177,
0.0594943911,
0.0625583678,
0.0132714137,
0.0678613782,
-0.0687527284,
0.0108302152,
0.06557028,
-0.0460069217,
0.0020276792,
-0.0229702592,
-0.0046362961,
0.0089354469,
0.0063862293,
-0.0330826901,
-0.0675117299,
0.0268496908,
-0.0189141221,
-0.0073330938,
-0.0196652282,
0.0489128008,
-0.0118760737,
-0.0142136579,
0.0775954947,
-0.0707941875,
-0.0377294086,
-0.0184534322,
0.0479022712,
0.0171471704,
0.0042591998,
0.0030388397,
-0.0164252687,
-0.0495849885,
-0.0450237878,
0.0053821448,
0.0408451855,
0.0422854125,
0.0358033851,
0.072522141,
0.0345850252,
0.0441016592,
-0.020522384,
0.0133405272,
-0.0133330068,
-0.0460529663,
-0.0073021883,
-5.693891128e-33,
0.0146296592,
-0.0408613794,
-0.0520411767,
0.0188731104,
0.0005810499,
-0.0067535001,
-0.0447483882,
-0.0152418939,
-0.0194314476,
0.0089689791,
-0.0110651376,
0.0367724635,
-0.0073690563,
0.0311997328,
-0.003968609,
-0.0236391425,
0.0529967211,
0.0414895639,
-0.018594943,
0.0290696472,
0.0274653323,
0.0323905498,
0.0512652472,
-0.0194634311,
0.0279750507,
-0.0566083752,
-0.0810603648,
-0.0152556105,
0.0095617911,
0.029421106,
0.0105235493,
0.0477714278,
0.0435387306,
0.0002004803,
0.0009875377,
0.0280585028,
-0.0355323181,
-0.0171884261,
0.04478053,
0.0693789423,
-0.003685182,
0.0063235499,
0.0584682859,
-0.044171378,
-0.0022116764,
0.0298522506,
0.047072757,
-0.0153079228,
-0.0109500233,
-0.0150114233,
-0.0441913567,
0.0051283566,
-0.0123630147,
0.0131694535,
0.0122444117,
0.0466431938,
0.0238346476,
0.0114242313,
-0.0553540476,
0.017855566,
0.0282328539,
0.0442409068,
0.0562092699,
0.0059752213,
-0.0055082105,
0.017905036,
0.0046566767,
-0.0333154164,
-0.0174103845,
0.0664602816,
0.0304521956,
0.0119627658,
0.0381886251,
0.0666250885,
0.0734667182,
-0.081328854,
-0.0445870571,
0.0528682657,
0.0451953374,
0.0125076883,
0.0123873865,
-0.0068674395,
-0.0366783179,
-0.009587829,
0.0251901709,
-0.0317292325,
-0.0235766601,
-0.064185366,
0.0399614125,
-0.0012157877,
-0.0545012951,
0.0493588112,
-0.0182709675,
-0.0505622923,
0.0153902099,
0.0125473244,
-0.0185657889,
-0.0103760529,
0.0179701839,
0.0260561835,
-0.0223849677,
0.0083031785,
0.0050846115,
0.0215986185,
-0.0131923268,
-0.0094977906,
0.0734486878,
0.0157984961,
-0.0507783219,
0.0129103847,
-0.0171407014,
0.0006981228,
-0.0177023578,
0.0193681214,
0.0020295701,
-0.0283154696,
-0.0350996777,
-0.0528968126,
0.0357035622,
0.021080628,
-0.0112340702,
-0.0107962936,
-0.0331620947,
0.0152184935,
-0.0257802941,
-0.0239541549,
-0.0094189644,
-0.0346039049,
0.0129789673,
-0.1172259152,
-0.0071437689,
-0.013992575,
2.465e-7,
-0.01520433,
0.0418512896,
-0.0000845444,
0.0189295262,
-0.0071698655,
0.0239696931,
-0.0190561619,
0.0476736687,
0.0047346214,
0.0298143122,
0.0064949244,
-0.0354095101,
-0.0216123313,
-0.0137150781,
-0.1284359097,
0.040710073,
-0.0704137087,
0.0043888888,
-0.0310842227,
-0.0314915292,
-0.0154164061,
0.0679797903,
0.021215288,
-0.0379913561,
0.038699273,
-0.0324976742,
0.0321178362,
0.0031673042,
-0.0063013998,
0.0301263835,
0.050887946,
0.0559757017,
-0.0043470138,
-0.0464800447,
-0.0278290175,
-0.0236584023,
0.0733550638,
0.0283337925,
0.0226518922,
0.0289287455,
-0.0043286597,
-0.0355733931,
0.0126201892,
-0.0881662518,
0.0749005601,
-0.0270114914,
-0.0350254774,
0.003598697,
-0.0649601221,
-0.0224863291,
0.0579793341,
-0.0520784557,
-0.0305855907,
-0.026699869,
0.025362609,
-0.0041527878,
-0.0093936622,
-0.0483259894,
0.036231976,
0.0084383348,
-0.0323101617,
0.0177611522,
-0.026369933,
0.0192704853,
0.0071525262,
-0.0306406356,
0.0309932381,
1.953240673e-34,
0.0417001918,
-0.0226863604,
0.0141329728,
-0.0491639748,
-0.0238621514,
0.0245809425,
0.0323466994,
-0.0084874984,
0.0021429413,
-0.0187240969,
-0.0192639492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06329v1 | A Survey of AI Text-to-Image and AI Text-to-Video Generators | 2023-11-10T17:33:58 | 2023-11-10T17:33:58 | Aditi Singh | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.IV | Text-to-Image and Text-to-Video AI generation models are revolutionary
technologies that use deep learning and natural language processing (NLP)
techniques to create images and videos from textual descriptions. This paper
investigates cutting-edge approaches in the discipline of Text-to-Image and
Text-to-Video AI generations. The survey provides an overview of the existing
literature as well as an analysis of the approaches used in various studies. It
covers data preprocessing techniques, neural network types, and evaluation
metrics used in the field. In addition, the paper discusses the challenges and
limitations of Text-to-Image and Text-to-Video AI generations, as well as
future research directions. Overall, these models have promising potential for
a wide range of applications such as video production, content creation, and
digital marketing. | [
0.0363456272,
0.0417598523,
0.0232888982,
0.0262654889,
-0.0264466293,
-0.0210989211,
0.024330264,
0.013187319,
-0.0321548618,
-0.0719929188,
0.01783593,
-0.0517034829,
0.0000934533,
0.0819045305,
0.0109881833,
-0.1046331376,
-0.0362486951,
0.0001976839,
-0.0090018893,
0.0113861132,
0.0103664063,
0.040139854,
-0.0012755429,
-0.0095118638,
-0.0970569551,
-0.0376146547,
-0.0013392973,
-0.0012275096,
0.0360813774,
-0.0335472971,
-0.0480390489,
0.0144411745,
0.0530130453,
0.0031424419,
0.0000019795,
-0.0311579574,
0.0255704131,
-0.0009908375,
0.0041981908,
0.008132006,
0.0747975037,
-0.030353358,
-0.0098468205,
-0.009121187,
-0.031334959,
0.0426787473,
0.0626507103,
0.0369882472,
0.0513635166,
0.0544190109,
-0.0576592498,
-0.0777444318,
0.0236116033,
-0.0094473129,
0.0283480305,
-0.005231319,
-0.0258241203,
-0.0356672853,
0.0089063505,
0.0138263814,
-0.0077790502,
0.0515734106,
0.0240125284,
-0.0310871042,
0.0207107123,
0.0512680262,
-0.0022120464,
-0.0428192355,
-0.0370614454,
0.0483984798,
-0.0414300002,
0.0122186774,
-0.0283073075,
-0.0213959701,
-0.0105743324,
-0.0312692635,
-0.0197834838,
0.0552842915,
0.0038505073,
0.0288490392,
-0.0557545051,
0.0433706641,
-0.0057644122,
-0.02972278,
0.0232386235,
-0.0282340124,
0.039295163,
0.007833438,
-0.0148925772,
0.0062952163,
0.0136105064,
-0.0660757124,
0.0464880876,
0.0258843936,
0.0648486689,
-0.0001479249,
-0.056973435,
-0.0499154478,
-0.0299355444,
-0.0630045012,
0.0613690093,
0.0018218011,
-0.0348808095,
0.0345040113,
-0.0604569837,
0.0574630909,
-0.0024717604,
-0.0044176099,
-0.0236057453,
0.0061105555,
-0.0420994088,
-0.0063944431,
-0.0077581471,
0.0039328416,
-0.032533586,
-0.0468262993,
-0.0430871584,
-0.0110798012,
-0.027200276,
0.019870175,
-0.0160547905,
0.0809866711,
-0.0365374498,
-0.0345887393,
-0.0719503462,
-0.0146015659,
0.0023712558,
0.0392575376,
0.0148694655,
-0.0118872412,
0.0257950015,
0.0361968242,
0.0417036116,
0.0140597997,
0.0250499751,
0.0556364805,
-0.0717663988,
-0.0135120284,
-0.0520163774,
0.0259486847,
-0.046397645,
-0.0148870153,
0.0305655934,
-0.0698280483,
0.0605457611,
-0.0524440333,
-0.0264298357,
-0.0643908381,
-0.0010735532,
0.0160359759,
-0.0170700364,
0.0500697754,
-0.0224467944,
0.0243982002,
0.0401619636,
-0.0143814357,
0.0134226382,
0.0058159125,
0.0708738044,
0.0986857712,
0.0272423234,
0.0067057461,
0.0430853702,
0.0531678423,
-0.0068910955,
-0.0132204173,
-0.0618359968,
-0.0323442295,
-0.0404864736,
0.0343616307,
0.0174062308,
0.0840977579,
0.0053067305,
0.0255310759,
0.0774386972,
0.042309016,
0.0148059856,
0.0345013104,
0.1029629111,
0.0305843446,
0.0128230285,
-0.0149014089,
0.0239601098,
0.0684709176,
0.0388915166,
0.0102690039,
0.0033937506,
0.0434273444,
-0.0826714262,
-0.0529867485,
0.0154878087,
-0.0399395563,
0.0176435132,
-0.0279779565,
0.0454569869,
0.0551212616,
-0.1000346318,
-0.033898253,
-0.0374409594,
-0.0298734661,
0.0500343591,
-0.0211458933,
0.0039610649,
0.0949026421,
0.0187706463,
0.0200749747,
0.0305803623,
0.0031830769,
0.014225455,
0.0704192817,
-0.0195018873,
-0.0077790506,
0.0114511633,
-0.0558713414,
-0.0165204462,
-0.0295644291,
0.0032869221,
0.0283954889,
-0.0406076983,
0.0527676977,
0.0035141686,
0.0280151721,
-0.0613600239,
0.0656897426,
0.0401285626,
-0.0313907713,
0.0233254451,
0.032408718,
-0.0078427419,
0.0203293804,
-0.0368973725,
-0.0078608477,
0.015643714,
-0.0089670261,
-0.0226707403,
0.0423660018,
-0.0147949988,
-0.0022011267,
0.0035658656,
-0.0877090469,
0.0157773066,
0.0122772437,
-0.0319759063,
-0.0508837737,
0.0099477842,
-0.0149716549,
-0.0134379948,
-0.0473786928,
0.0223150272,
0.0296883788,
0.0054223915,
0.0118293939,
0.0380200483,
-0.0032541931,
-0.0642709881,
0.0029934314,
0.0217708275,
-0.0165811926,
-0.0234893337,
0.0066748597,
-0.0385589264,
-0.0174121466,
0.0059837382,
0.0295964759,
0.049302198,
-0.0337214842,
-0.0148259951,
-0.0401441753,
-0.0273927338,
0.0093326671,
-0.0236154906,
-0.0232185181,
-0.0164096709,
-0.0007115927,
0.0150890909,
-0.0597615652,
0.0266512781,
-0.0009380415,
-0.0392998084,
0.0427220464,
0.0254366398,
0.026349755,
-0.0259920526,
-0.0125647653,
0.026028024,
0.0642963946,
0.0449338108,
-0.0470797569,
-0.0379943438,
0.0201864615,
-0.0119972667,
0.0380356498,
0.0092323273,
-0.0099836057,
-0.0016588297,
0.0145850414,
0.0281553399,
0.0591934174,
0.0301458947,
-0.0002170638,
0.0131526245,
0.0139654027,
-0.0141305951,
0.0233444367,
-0.0182149913,
0.0049675992,
0.0137725482,
-0.0542761087,
0.0256432854,
-0.006293566,
-0.0117761111,
0.0446742512,
-0.0732556358,
0.0209015179,
0.0047919005,
-0.0498752072,
-0.0062680282,
0.0089077046,
-0.0081193699,
0.0274987668,
-0.0295426771,
-0.0578338467,
-0.0029982391,
-0.0266519319,
-0.0217243936,
-0.0071778707,
0.0056297299,
-0.002999237,
0.064358525,
0.0342450254,
0.0563763008,
-0.0174313914,
0.0107342899,
-0.0612804964,
-0.0051253019,
-0.0017193392,
0.0030222333,
0.0381452888,
-0.0357584804,
-0.0034551583,
-0.017229503,
0.0074092494,
-0.0493938103,
-0.0106496904,
-0.001039137,
-0.0093506658,
0.0090796174,
-0.015727954,
-0.0266619213,
0.0288884901,
-0.0122537268,
0.0318336673,
0.0006430323,
0.0020766074,
-0.0261860806,
0.0639709607,
0.0617843978,
-0.0528191254,
-0.0605717637,
-0.010992893,
0.0451871268,
0.0196015406,
-0.0153117133,
0.0133991204,
-0.0570904799,
0.007267768,
-0.0040769591,
0.0336919911,
0.0137958555,
0.0388285667,
0.0233563203,
-0.0486738011,
0.0121522052,
0.0662733614,
0.0136218918,
-0.0407540314,
0.00079786,
0.0435957871,
-0.008483611,
-0.0041877464,
0.0245393254,
-0.0912632793,
-0.0202931892,
-0.0220526382,
-0.0008762855,
0.0056485282,
0.0113424314,
-0.0537247844,
-0.0772355273,
0.0775249153,
0.0139780147,
-0.0045859111,
-0.0319360532,
0.0108761033,
-0.0037931523,
0.0196469836,
-0.0114312014,
-0.0036074908,
0.0129859895,
-0.0010674393,
0.014930157,
-0.0097177317,
-0.0519658662,
-0.009686023,
-0.0201552566,
0.0122516723,
0.0642689839,
0.0515515804,
-0.0406329036,
-0.0324708559,
-0.0287955999,
0.0350489765,
0.0326533876,
-0.0013716089,
0.0630035847,
-0.0185199529,
-0.0104011707,
0.0295710415,
0.0434291065,
0.0291348305,
0.0127841197,
0.020340465,
-0.0022189624,
-0.0037585143,
-0.0533688702,
-0.0610079542,
0.0185803026,
0.023548618,
0.0372635536,
-0.0163987279,
-0.0854208171,
-0.0379822738,
0.0005570733,
0.0132661611,
-0.1087842435,
-0.048280824,
0.0011576131,
-0.0349992625,
-0.0223196186,
-0.0739796609,
0.0063942554,
0.0589778908,
0.0207267199,
0.0177478045,
-0.0352546498,
0.0170947108,
0.0067657819,
-0.0606200472,
-0.0051583988,
0.0001055608,
-0.0000679879,
-0.0395281129,
-0.0103003923,
0.0356649049,
-0.0483881794,
0.0047534662,
0.0318903737,
-0.0575915873,
-0.0083375489,
-0.024241209,
0.0776425526,
0.0133059463,
0.0350047685,
0.0329432338,
-0.0243234336,
0.0614062324,
0.0413910225,
0.0334070772,
-0.0222512875,
-0.0235938244,
0.0179145038,
-0.0271612387,
-0.0075243567,
-0.0447675996,
0.0410649367,
0.0081217606,
-0.0047381073,
-0.005230126,
-0.0145463226,
0.0067850151,
-0.0404451638,
-0.0364198908,
-0.0643662512,
-0.0261987895,
-0.0563803352,
-0.0309231877,
-0.0188428704,
0.0018523848,
-0.0951817334,
0.0191438384,
0.0140461074,
0.0443606675,
0.0188269932,
0.005630929,
0.0075872988,
-0.0181678217,
-0.0151576959,
-0.0431829616,
0.019095581,
0.0311126895,
-0.012215551,
0.0189224407,
0.0187864285,
0.0570687056,
-0.0534748733,
0.0292677749,
0.0139399851,
0.0378753208,
0.0034425328,
-0.0106516089,
-0.0154573871,
0.0428045727,
0.0126813604,
-0.0116938902,
-0.0936870575,
0.0418601483,
0.0440346636,
-0.0094411531,
0.0281979665,
-0.0397082046,
-0.005459425,
-0.0254981238,
0.031309586,
0.0095798336,
-0.0691216588,
-0.0150246453,
-0.0341506563,
-0.0057379832,
-0.0153299496,
0.0517238043,
0.0201870203,
0.0203287024,
-0.0052522006,
-0.0095772361,
-0.0403368436,
0.0105884327,
0.0168729499,
-0.0191550758,
0.0020231141,
0.0161448251,
-0.0262665432,
-0.052386187,
0.0379902273,
0.0002297348,
0.0157747697,
0.0198690798,
0.084173888,
0.0033975523,
-0.0065530711,
0.0211291425,
0.0114422347,
-0.0237509627,
-0.0439607762,
-0.0307700895,
-0.0518244952,
-5.538024618e-33,
-0.0078724409,
-0.0488816425,
0.0148152085,
0.0065388004,
-0.0318632275,
0.0123135867,
0.0042042932,
0.0000788528,
-0.0040225205,
0.0087103005,
0.0085857175,
-0.0083583137,
0.0120553132,
0.0655990839,
-0.0147308521,
-0.0004277202,
0.04072579,
-0.0607989877,
-0.0170512944,
0.0383527726,
0.0113783618,
0.0082550487,
0.0338773429,
-0.0840863064,
-0.0254788194,
-0.0063117538,
-0.0587435476,
-0.0113716805,
0.0502800494,
0.022000609,
-0.0107506057,
0.0112836193,
0.0155364145,
-0.0139691764,
-0.0025753547,
0.0246745348,
-0.0169819891,
0.009504104,
-0.0478432812,
-0.0024720423,
-0.1018947512,
-0.0201749671,
0.0427389741,
-0.027391158,
-0.017115457,
-0.0033068687,
0.0869291946,
-0.0392205231,
0.0417836346,
-0.0276308339,
-0.0689882934,
-0.0063892826,
-0.0402679592,
-0.0700880513,
0.0368242748,
0.0509509593,
0.0366577283,
-0.0017620635,
-0.0918064862,
0.0592775457,
0.0006474329,
0.0026253683,
0.0948989913,
0.0120047433,
0.0034062897,
0.040371418,
0.0173117034,
-0.0196448769,
-0.0367795043,
0.0146127548,
0.0008211331,
0.0805272385,
0.069310613,
0.0330922566,
0.0294249225,
-0.0191225838,
-0.02605832,
0.0594919361,
-0.0273737554,
0.0056252643,
-0.0021029953,
-0.0096819056,
0.0097394502,
0.0048377845,
-0.0231399052,
-0.0298777074,
-0.0174680222,
-0.0361802392,
0.0228532478,
-0.0024925375,
-0.0059323194,
-0.0022929148,
0.0472781584,
-0.0105738025,
0.0269724932,
-0.0098682418,
-0.0472290479,
0.0859042779,
0.0079027209,
0.008764294,
-0.0302463509,
-0.0436182767,
0.0578720719,
0.0588771403,
0.0156863797,
0.0329949111,
0.0126501387,
0.060506016,
0.0080179647,
0.0102464017,
0.0362289809,
0.0359432511,
0.0335064307,
0.0361193866,
-0.0194298625,
-0.0141300773,
-0.0554191247,
0.0128005352,
0.0179592799,
0.0177007839,
0.0122028971,
-0.039901644,
0.0233660564,
0.0072447355,
-0.0680640861,
0.0434965156,
-0.0492021702,
-0.0268035047,
0.0450292565,
-0.0581831411,
-0.0256730095,
0.0301889982,
2.523e-7,
0.005843841,
0.0193572994,
0.0142969033,
0.0079618627,
0.0139012765,
0.0480102412,
0.0288132187,
0.0155712496,
0.0253336169,
-0.0040323921,
0.0275737774,
0.0110641755,
0.0379455686,
-0.0246586259,
-0.0331683196,
0.0129954014,
-0.0359796807,
0.0142415185,
-0.0373718962,
-0.0009341006,
0.0679209158,
0.0654794574,
-0.0081631197,
-0.0359685645,
0.018971771,
-0.0391340628,
0.0751229823,
0.0026817061,
0.0092467098,
-0.0082892608,
-0.0056192256,
0.0268400926,
-0.0591669194,
0.0067557506,
-0.007858295,
-0.0062633418,
0.0676584616,
0.0204391107,
-0.0320798792,
0.0036369096,
-0.0040481002,
0.0467954315,
-0.0263150111,
-0.0250669774,
0.0515615232,
-0.0508206636,
-0.0376766026,
-0.0375416614,
-0.0000374407,
0.0530433692,
-0.0168675426,
-0.0348638631,
-0.0210380293,
-0.0066066654,
0.072017923,
-0.0054568141,
-0.0473190024,
-0.076537244,
-0.0147180445,
-0.0326319672,
-0.0018197322,
0.0407180563,
-0.0502002686,
0.0377419591,
0.0282171872,
-0.0119589679,
-0.0174598023,
1.910870186e-34,
-0.0229743142,
0.0173330139,
0.0014415495,
-0.0490211248,
-0.0007019447,
0.0323349386,
0.0042466354,
0.0044574314,
-0.0171472486,
-0.0528995022,
-0.0559373274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06189v1 | Syntax-semantics interface: an algebraic model | 2023-11-10T17:12:09 | 2023-11-10T17:12:09 | Matilde Marcolli, Robert C. Berwick, Noam Chomsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.LO, math.QA, math.RA, 91F20, 16T05, 18C50 | We extend our formulation of Merge and Minimalism in terms of Hopf algebras
to an algebraic model of a syntactic-semantic interface. We show that methods
adopted in the formulation of renormalization (extraction of meaningful
physical values) in theoretical physics are relevant to describe the extraction
of meaning from syntactic expressions. We show how this formulation relates to
computational models of semantics and we answer some recent controversies about
implications for generative linguistics of the current functioning of large
language models. | [
-0.0163839813,
0.0387622491,
-0.0331348144,
0.0278094877,
-0.0288862679,
0.0131831653,
-0.0240772255,
0.0424004272,
-0.009068924,
-0.0703332871,
-0.0031596867,
-0.0442731492,
-0.0263837911,
0.0047437302,
0.0381606333,
-0.0720092282,
0.0799074769,
-0.038850002,
-0.0351748168,
0.0070631574,
-0.0047214376,
-0.0517259166,
0.0036702629,
-0.0146612301,
-0.0344251283,
-0.0180420168,
0.0090117399,
-0.0453481786,
0.0327167958,
0.0433330573,
-0.0810574591,
0.0090798382,
-0.0439742878,
0.0223676898,
0.000001371,
-0.0471872203,
-0.0019505725,
0.0364645123,
-0.0323765613,
-0.017435072,
0.0353616476,
-0.0021412321,
-0.0384637751,
-0.0322383121,
-0.0222972836,
0.0119458269,
0.0565098114,
0.0122029437,
-0.0035945904,
0.0259362999,
0.003536199,
-0.095419623,
0.0810120627,
0.0067696571,
0.0736235604,
-0.0142496955,
0.0507464297,
0.0480426773,
0.0182497669,
-0.0243331268,
-0.0427922979,
0.0002881077,
0.0240050778,
-0.0369142219,
0.0153591484,
0.0229611769,
-0.0040967274,
0.0245791208,
0.0056498586,
0.001108733,
0.0042649657,
-0.0253611673,
-0.0191429723,
0.0327561721,
-0.0149887381,
0.0042619132,
-0.0529827066,
0.0199246258,
0.0158991441,
0.0551075302,
0.0597596951,
-0.0203919932,
0.0247321706,
0.0093610706,
-0.0576366112,
0.0930436105,
0.0777095184,
-0.0066583361,
-0.0274211764,
-0.0165241845,
-0.0209417362,
-0.0406945199,
-0.0711859986,
-0.0126656992,
-0.022642104,
0.0097651249,
-0.0058436184,
-0.0114157191,
-0.0136837047,
-0.0158099197,
0.0042368616,
0.0303704832,
0.0466235168,
0.0633432642,
-0.0056774481,
0.0472438447,
-0.0296795797,
-0.0323101953,
-0.0394579917,
0.0080747027,
-0.0351050608,
-0.040653564,
-0.0499706939,
0.058563374,
-0.0220982339,
0.0074040941,
-0.0399243347,
0.0049001263,
-0.0195061639,
-0.0255038459,
-0.0670725927,
-0.0271557402,
-0.0593483783,
-0.0036248306,
-0.027788369,
-0.0252978578,
0.0052017216,
0.0033060368,
-0.0071020308,
-0.0726287067,
-0.0320308171,
0.036737375,
0.0227545183,
-0.0296744555,
-0.0441460349,
0.0617332086,
0.0547328442,
0.0144009097,
0.0547423586,
-0.0141153876,
-0.0160832256,
0.0068592513,
0.0047719646,
-0.0388412848,
0.0040451195,
0.0005748702,
0.0033234649,
-0.0932449698,
-0.0103763435,
-0.0198468529,
-0.0103012491,
0.0119611248,
0.0100710411,
-0.0059884335,
-0.0588619262,
-0.0164180472,
-0.0182294901,
0.0053280792,
0.001688628,
-0.0162766147,
-0.0072447252,
-0.01535674,
0.01639916,
-0.0008340328,
0.0187662151,
-0.0162396245,
-0.0989048183,
-0.0343501307,
0.0429385677,
-0.0207474865,
0.0082711503,
0.0958140418,
-0.0155744478,
-0.032797385,
-0.0312300753,
0.063644208,
0.0246392842,
0.0548501909,
0.0424234234,
-0.0070594745,
-0.0030333842,
0.0495803244,
-0.0221584644,
-0.00997556,
-0.0765501484,
0.0295081828,
-0.0212037656,
0.0097406683,
-0.0050014714,
-0.0330506675,
-0.0091911685,
0.0066889999,
-0.0003581767,
-0.0466883071,
0.0513951667,
0.0036041425,
0.008991885,
0.012747502,
0.0008555376,
-0.0198074859,
0.0709251463,
-0.0454308912,
-0.0010465609,
0.0071569555,
-0.030536294,
-0.0269948598,
0.0451586284,
0.0103675108,
-0.0392790101,
0.0516289771,
-0.0195654985,
-0.0064491956,
-0.0293053295,
0.020107884,
0.0217989031,
-0.0487577654,
0.0432959124,
-0.0168951657,
-0.0678668171,
-0.0199304223,
0.0193303116,
0.0249051042,
-0.0039594448,
0.0408875123,
0.0087547153,
-0.0307359472,
-0.0569166616,
0.0249046423,
0.0263566747,
0.0002654143,
-0.025573615,
0.0903839841,
0.0210621506,
-0.0294136573,
-0.0144861257,
0.0355814844,
0.0396806858,
-0.009021542,
0.0542139262,
-0.0146886474,
0.0612631962,
-0.0516872332,
0.0166358724,
-0.0329882689,
0.1190478429,
-0.0520797558,
0.1061111167,
-0.0360912681,
0.0158307347,
0.0312876403,
0.0055006314,
-0.030992195,
0.0847507045,
0.037618205,
0.0592546389,
-0.0297967046,
-0.0137875704,
0.0061613219,
0.0113983117,
-0.0334752947,
0.0081850532,
0.0252682231,
0.0170231462,
0.024815876,
-0.0276794899,
-0.0243372656,
-0.0552727878,
-0.0088846469,
-0.0010449418,
-0.0132501572,
0.0226926841,
0.04161755,
0.0305704977,
0.0154277356,
0.0415936373,
0.0240203068,
0.0146979932,
0.0211239886,
0.0141893309,
-0.002552235,
0.0136935432,
-0.0682868734,
-0.0196312722,
-0.0204095207,
-0.0527398624,
0.0421328992,
-0.005603774,
-0.0083784275,
-0.0208510477,
-0.0034145417,
-0.0457131937,
0.0010016261,
-0.0091117434,
0.000104787,
0.0341582224,
-0.0600439794,
0.0666883215,
-0.0139945103,
-0.0279047675,
0.0705035403,
-0.0015214904,
-0.018491663,
-0.018789662,
-0.0357375555,
-0.0613471717,
-0.0011435108,
-0.0407249033,
0.0106041832,
0.001189596,
0.1032720357,
-0.0098075755,
-0.0337208696,
-0.0541929901,
0.0472544916,
-0.0692352355,
-0.0228478108,
-0.0090374323,
-0.0090453112,
-0.0510651655,
0.0370719507,
-0.0327326506,
-0.0091649015,
0.0172532313,
-0.0092736678,
-0.0071828193,
-0.0256936271,
0.0052610342,
-0.0265729707,
0.0793293193,
0.0363184661,
-0.0015617838,
0.0468309112,
0.0043124319,
-0.0077657863,
-0.0364908762,
-0.0064332481,
0.0080434931,
0.0131867807,
-0.0074245515,
0.044436276,
0.0059766918,
0.0332645364,
0.0050207139,
-0.0251981076,
0.0120532569,
0.0276878551,
-0.0080208117,
0.0163088664,
0.0462427586,
0.0410510562,
-0.0166112222,
-0.0151714515,
0.0074292705,
-0.0035711401,
-0.0303610712,
0.0235150643,
0.0358383879,
-0.0227289461,
0.0170761384,
0.0326446407,
0.0028600497,
0.0294203684,
0.0039101792,
0.0268955249,
0.0060303579,
-0.0298272762,
0.039871823,
-0.0131514687,
-0.0198776834,
0.0276071839,
-0.0524130836,
-0.0077845594,
0.0043819239,
0.0164842084,
0.0316212736,
0.0557554998,
0.0600703284,
-0.0531041101,
0.0120629165,
0.0151415924,
-0.0140113607,
-0.09273085,
0.0342813618,
-0.0121753654,
-0.0753050745,
0.0338147171,
-0.03444333,
0.0286821779,
-0.0067018759,
-0.0149446148,
0.0407103188,
-0.0482569784,
-0.0122798719,
0.0116381152,
0.0478661917,
0.024130594,
-0.0227167178,
0.0165558215,
-0.0253021289,
0.050379362,
0.0108104441,
0.0952941626,
-0.0530025624,
-0.0378800668,
-0.0062312898,
0.024297053,
0.0873300359,
0.0517799519,
-0.037233863,
-0.0399264917,
0.0478462577,
-0.0154765211,
-0.0165398233,
-0.0150973937,
-0.0714866593,
0.0488650501,
-0.0143480524,
-0.0434779339,
0.0196473878,
0.0183911398,
-0.0451861396,
-0.0461483859,
0.0625565648,
-0.0259378329,
-0.0355260447,
-0.0036240821,
-0.0041512595,
-0.0190939233,
0.0794458985,
0.0538101271,
-0.0023011672,
-0.0350774452,
-0.0412733257,
-0.0105765993,
0.0460410155,
-0.091328457,
-0.0005465247,
0.0576806068,
-0.1141222641,
-0.045324333,
-0.0071131787,
-0.0205377862,
-0.0143007562,
-0.0279120654,
0.0273722596,
0.016989721,
-0.0396889485,
0.0101683391,
0.0233508535,
-0.037216682,
0.0062538995,
-0.0192448739,
0.0311579034,
0.0428432375,
-0.0055601308,
-0.0660059229,
-0.0138676846,
0.0024337596,
-0.056974601,
0.0397648141,
0.0270855315,
0.0329560935,
-0.0362869389,
-0.0049397503,
0.0017476686,
-0.0454319008,
0.0357965194,
-0.0124544594,
0.0838758871,
0.0069672344,
0.0275500063,
0.0230632238,
0.0498529412,
-0.0109205833,
0.0157722812,
0.0024387478,
0.0563967638,
-0.0334621631,
0.0149520002,
0.0414470993,
0.0084814569,
0.0142844031,
0.0354861245,
-0.0351397023,
0.0116501451,
-0.0450643972,
-0.0592129715,
-0.0173797216,
-0.0651089847,
-0.0454108752,
0.0336470939,
0.0258600116,
-0.0092898766,
-0.0125203328,
0.0258740988,
0.0366335139,
0.0538859628,
-0.0265931804,
-0.0287727043,
-0.0258400962,
0.0317305736,
0.0421095341,
0.032550741,
-0.0180788189,
-0.0505182147,
0.0191887729,
-0.0426753946,
-0.0501126088,
0.034655042,
0.0019446823,
-0.0330335274,
-0.0355350785,
-0.0587285832,
-0.0488687605,
0.029516669,
0.0066360058,
0.0004189086,
0.0248376951,
0.0477840491,
-0.0787138045,
-0.0236606672,
-0.0097974297,
0.0075488519,
0.0731548816,
-0.0252376944,
0.0473434739,
0.0357517451,
0.0042553204,
-0.0187600851,
0.0284603722,
-0.0620646141,
0.0344462879,
-0.0107327681,
0.0050875768,
-0.0348357931,
-0.052299913,
-0.0593386814,
0.0120131364,
0.0360387228,
0.0234779064,
-0.1006409079,
-0.022978127,
-0.0326914117,
0.0452959724,
-0.0129401069,
-0.052932281,
0.0113804946,
0.0204300787,
-0.0093775354,
-0.0395171791,
-0.0491379164,
0.048110906,
0.0232934859,
-0.0142651182,
-0.0015798953,
-4.802381151e-33,
-0.0732815936,
0.0018635773,
-0.0233836155,
0.0531490184,
-0.0392038226,
-0.0052995421,
-0.0296099372,
-0.0041108509,
-0.0174059328,
0.0024269933,
0.0144550493,
0.0145596014,
-0.0045372397,
0.0195742268,
-0.0224905889,
0.015771877,
0.0218134765,
-0.0265555866,
0.0379499905,
-0.0053312173,
0.0231830478,
-0.041359812,
0.000779243,
-0.0013710782,
0.0348562077,
-0.0181643292,
0.0056867311,
0.0472594574,
0.009221293,
0.0096251965,
-0.0706956014,
0.0184341725,
-0.0097971112,
-0.0273733716,
-0.0178602859,
0.0048965584,
-0.0048388429,
-0.0637922436,
0.0460618213,
-0.0383356176,
0.0108322008,
-0.0447126105,
0.0494259149,
0.001507881,
-0.0395259112,
0.0025995683,
-0.0043220241,
0.020095624,
-0.035709653,
0.0338145196,
-0.0833784491,
0.0037311562,
0.0096528875,
0.0647459552,
0.0661073253,
-0.0559698232,
0.0099109439,
-0.0028302507,
0.0000671976,
0.0172498543,
-0.0147449095,
0.0417468175,
-0.0107671674,
0.021958489,
0.0273818504,
0.0439418443,
0.0761437491,
-0.0274619535,
0.0252263881,
0.0290368181,
0.0031297824,
0.0378070064,
-0.0142322499,
0.0358248614,
0.0334378742,
0.0387423038,
-0.0150739728,
0.0077314647,
0.0375217274,
0.0494018644,
0.0035945675,
0.0344984382,
-0.026303988,
-0.0340422988,
-0.0088176643,
0.0341678075,
-0.0104831541,
-0.024341397,
-0.0270024016,
-0.0392971858,
-0.005245069,
0.0309344623,
0.023753183,
-0.0596226081,
-0.045468498,
0.0163527075,
-0.0041152695,
0.072217606,
0.0120137464,
0.0143345436,
0.018613942,
-0.0284820758,
-0.0237349309,
0.0217694584,
0.0283757299,
0.0090951854,
-0.013131476,
0.0337872989,
0.0038105855,
-0.0042659934,
-0.0172211174,
-0.0755285472,
0.0102805309,
-0.0059499405,
0.02373817,
0.0612035245,
0.0397110395,
0.0195377991,
0.0061971452,
0.0314614251,
0.0235031396,
0.0114783207,
0.0110466881,
0.0172133315,
-0.0280927755,
-0.0409320034,
-0.0229610559,
0.0251096655,
0.0983088538,
0.0022587099,
-0.0106843179,
0.0022943898,
2.486e-7,
0.0801479965,
-0.0027955647,
0.046163138,
0.048710186,
0.0221138876,
-0.00496131,
0.036941696,
-0.020886695,
-0.0018488788,
0.0119850105,
-0.0000855155,
0.0073768478,
-0.0433138087,
-0.0005174103,
-0.0265415907,
0.017660588,
0.0011104184,
-0.0794587135,
-0.006336614,
0.0205558036,
0.0520571209,
0.0493294634,
0.0411933698,
0.0045872028,
-0.0255997628,
0.0122481519,
0.057474073,
-0.0145259891,
0.0165388994,
0.0341962948,
-0.0218433794,
-0.0200506169,
0.0138242068,
0.0027317859,
0.0241534971,
0.0296599604,
0.015796097,
0.0233753975,
-0.0524593629,
0.0354003236,
-0.0211629756,
-0.0734781101,
-0.0001866635,
-0.0347776301,
0.040886987,
-0.0302977134,
-0.0124746738,
-0.0265954211,
-0.0346435569,
0.0286895949,
-0.02377332,
0.0355917551,
-0.0176540948,
-0.0260578021,
0.0245249234,
0.0000121588,
-0.0250039753,
-0.0315474756,
-0.0078103323,
0.0616185665,
-0.0436277539,
-0.0258962978,
-0.0012708665,
0.0213171113,
-0.0078261103,
-0.0674916282,
-0.051678393,
2.515961069e-34,
0.0407828875,
0.0244374517,
0.0764986947,
-0.0015880482,
-0.0130603584,
0.0180401448,
-0.0273425356,
0.0541865751,
0.032606218,
-0.1000564918,
-0.0397987068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06158v1 | Language Models can be Logical Solvers | 2023-11-10T16:23:50 | 2023-11-10T16:23:50 | Jiazhan Feng, Ruochen Xu, Junheng Hao, Hiteshi Sharma, Yelong Shen, Dongyan Zhao, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Logical reasoning is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence and a key
component of tasks like problem-solving and decision-making. Recent
advancements have enabled Large Language Models (LLMs) to potentially exhibit
reasoning capabilities, but complex logical reasoning remains a challenge. The
state-of-the-art, solver-augmented language models, use LLMs to parse natural
language logical questions into symbolic representations first and then adopt
external logical solvers to take in the symbolic representations and output the
answers. Despite their impressive performance, any parsing errors will
inevitably result in the failure of the execution of the external logical
solver and no answer to the logical questions. In this paper, we introduce
LoGiPT, a novel language model that directly emulates the reasoning processes
of logical solvers and bypasses the parsing errors by learning to strict
adherence to solver syntax and grammar. LoGiPT is fine-tuned on a newly
constructed instruction-tuning dataset derived from revealing and refining the
invisible reasoning process of deductive solvers. Experimental results on two
public deductive reasoning datasets demonstrate that LoGiPT outperforms
state-of-the-art solver-augmented LMs and few-shot prompting methods on
competitive LLMs like ChatGPT or GPT-4. | [
0.0353278555,
0.0395711251,
-0.0220473483,
0.0311533455,
-0.0479197353,
0.0280431211,
0.0147517258,
-0.0016107499,
0.0608782247,
-0.0329269581,
0.0408380069,
0.0447889604,
-0.0208557155,
0.0374964625,
0.004757544,
-0.007670193,
0.0521314517,
-0.0490724556,
0.045599997,
-0.0132259578,
0.0008442805,
0.0460147224,
0.0127916597,
0.01381383,
-0.0064399866,
-0.0320191197,
-0.0321885124,
-0.0072524538,
0.0155603969,
-0.0263221264,
-0.0026845378,
0.0142217474,
0.0277368333,
0.0272995681,
0.0000023086,
-0.0393646099,
-0.0197599623,
0.006756844,
-0.0738620088,
-0.0233695284,
-0.0279415529,
-0.0018030669,
0.0023904645,
0.0559875779,
-0.0463937595,
-0.0085381437,
0.0232089777,
0.0414617173,
0.0822235644,
0.0571789071,
0.0003917926,
-0.0350906737,
0.0173734687,
-0.004966829,
0.0122694923,
-0.0145317698,
0.0084952423,
0.0426149331,
0.0015222338,
-0.0228837244,
-0.0011803574,
0.0221910458,
0.0516526848,
0.0342861004,
-0.076237157,
0.0125195701,
-0.0687496662,
0.004351154,
-0.019012887,
0.041037377,
-0.0406677946,
-0.0469321944,
0.0054319799,
-0.0007926757,
0.0069743074,
-0.0067333793,
-0.0241044518,
0.0577214211,
-0.0433157459,
0.0113932807,
0.0707481876,
-0.0279152133,
0.0156512465,
-0.0015760146,
-0.0496057346,
0.1157173663,
-0.0029165787,
-0.0328174829,
0.0170644615,
-0.0247536004,
-0.052344013,
-0.0703946799,
0.0369082429,
0.0442893319,
-0.0301224887,
0.0367028676,
-0.0463851802,
0.025113048,
0.0038743382,
-0.0117811784,
0.0323314853,
0.0621485338,
0.0415276475,
0.0402248465,
-0.0301406626,
0.059852697,
0.0053817616,
0.0645050779,
-0.0222588722,
-0.0001576459,
-0.0669330508,
-0.0404515937,
-0.0490788035,
0.0547861755,
-0.0101537555,
0.0113606788,
0.0129835103,
0.0294317361,
-0.0012357425,
0.0343065895,
0.0173486192,
-0.0113219935,
-0.0178458169,
-0.0481504351,
-0.0598512664,
0.0198563691,
-0.0260116123,
-0.0008406996,
0.0130084464,
-0.0544764884,
-0.0112277726,
-0.0121798646,
-0.0045561064,
-0.0319771767,
0.0313633084,
0.0689539015,
0.0051832693,
0.0038537786,
-0.0383799374,
-0.0658431351,
0.0379268117,
-0.0802013427,
-0.002674449,
-0.0671705753,
0.0337006748,
0.0257128645,
-0.0182792414,
-0.0548259765,
0.0148901846,
0.0426065698,
0.008826578,
0.0692662448,
0.0106185433,
0.002173942,
0.011035799,
-0.0093213841,
0.0070840414,
0.0561393797,
0.0447889902,
0.0132085523,
-0.0126520274,
0.0152328974,
0.0200047288,
0.0130332895,
0.0304577742,
-0.0157921631,
-0.0431818925,
0.0413935222,
-0.015874764,
0.0143767912,
-0.0244952012,
0.0666451901,
-0.0032213312,
-0.0273035429,
0.0177463572,
0.0428823493,
0.019215012,
0.001309026,
0.0234582219,
0.0086166812,
-0.0070391605,
-0.0297717843,
-0.0591720454,
0.0359151997,
-0.0464977771,
-0.0024389355,
-0.0324324444,
0.036641188,
-0.0012502401,
-0.0419078507,
-0.0145285707,
0.0416873656,
0.0103221349,
0.0630170554,
0.016436534,
-0.0048485664,
-0.0361036807,
0.0856777281,
0.002901135,
-0.0277113747,
-0.0553189218,
-0.0855392218,
0.0365677327,
0.0538412854,
0.063782841,
-0.0129012521,
-0.0710202381,
-0.0374835916,
0.0209031086,
0.0237921588,
0.0079749944,
0.0125257317,
-0.0088118166,
-0.0325837955,
-0.0114411991,
-0.0204200577,
0.0004593277,
0.0229612142,
0.0142612671,
-0.005180466,
0.0140650012,
-0.0245407615,
0.0082200794,
0.0320947766,
-0.0517636612,
-0.0026513569,
-0.0100529622,
0.0062797642,
0.0268503036,
-0.0083957687,
0.002615368,
0.0107641881,
0.0037428213,
-0.0363301896,
-0.0335279442,
0.0186101049,
-0.0258235019,
-0.0381015092,
0.0582784675,
-0.0624804161,
-0.0379264504,
0.0168414209,
-0.0562978797,
-0.0352546722,
0.0400863551,
-0.0619405434,
0.0142168291,
-0.0231700353,
-0.0201538205,
0.0168889221,
-0.0425952375,
-0.0168184061,
0.0814345032,
-0.0076139737,
0.00318278,
0.0046740924,
0.0271996204,
0.0179886185,
-0.0544991903,
0.019463677,
0.0219689067,
-0.0067078853,
-0.0042732428,
-0.0091486396,
0.0262896754,
-0.0268433988,
-0.0236224085,
-0.0574718192,
0.0420311764,
0.0002331741,
0.0230999757,
0.0326575451,
-0.008191416,
0.0140790697,
0.0002711983,
-0.0568632632,
-0.0080462592,
0.0276166592,
-0.0013773273,
0.0229413155,
-0.005338849,
-0.0311787874,
-0.00803727,
-0.023995515,
-0.063154161,
-0.0102240983,
-0.0049702809,
0.0343306921,
-0.0466165915,
0.0477656983,
-0.0257232338,
0.0447887667,
0.0045277518,
-0.0167335831,
0.0288939513,
-0.0353760347,
-0.0189710595,
0.096901305,
-0.0297134444,
0.0042970357,
0.048497919,
-0.0464318581,
-0.0760078505,
0.0437206179,
0.0027746405,
0.0106944768,
-0.0143354563,
-0.0448876917,
-0.0362771302,
0.0498383567,
-0.0085999062,
0.0028612232,
-0.0567062162,
0.0630287006,
0.0054167574,
0.0043159174,
-0.0309509132,
0.0021074994,
-0.0004377037,
0.0476824902,
-0.0236164462,
-0.0179626718,
0.1060002446,
0.0109306313,
-0.0028845996,
-0.0737565979,
0.0008456379,
-0.0511999726,
0.0584462322,
-0.0049126535,
-0.0087644532,
-0.0000412494,
-0.0293952543,
-0.0352671333,
-0.0180495623,
0.0378838703,
-0.0427174084,
0.0450388491,
-0.0601335429,
0.0114761926,
0.0075982017,
-0.0443735979,
-0.0477963574,
-0.0380664617,
-0.0660156384,
-0.0010427914,
-0.0197479166,
-0.0040726834,
-0.0422725491,
0.0016909795,
0.0087067317,
0.0111746974,
0.0084999176,
-0.017488813,
-0.0438618176,
-0.0380986147,
0.0324621238,
0.0153129427,
-0.0073912563,
-0.0122226374,
0.0359510779,
0.027375849,
0.0349608622,
-0.0432354324,
-0.0155325243,
0.0410724096,
0.0003416555,
-0.0054638851,
-0.0010768692,
0.015045736,
0.0286365878,
-0.0968571007,
-0.0187044367,
0.1195332333,
0.0528646596,
0.0165923182,
-0.0097131077,
-0.0315507129,
0.0163325835,
0.0470637344,
0.0595205575,
-0.0992572829,
-0.0790447071,
0.0368537083,
-0.0090574911,
-0.0192187335,
-0.0312776677,
-0.0084885499,
-0.1368283778,
0.0091537461,
0.0159797668,
0.0079146475,
-0.0052856449,
-0.024362253,
-0.0364400446,
-0.0311893541,
-0.0135705704,
0.0061976709,
-0.0029709588,
0.0189125203,
-0.0105058998,
-0.0059861089,
0.0120570464,
0.0560370982,
-0.0084074195,
0.0407617167,
0.0701337606,
-0.0046282662,
-0.0029734529,
-0.0421617255,
0.0292913299,
0.0321561098,
-0.0066106222,
-0.0314558335,
-0.0047364198,
-0.0105330758,
-0.0006887037,
-0.0340888798,
0.0374778993,
-0.0606410541,
-0.0109917792,
0.0389119722,
0.087122418,
-0.028026158,
0.002801372,
-0.0050093867,
0.0122571308,
-0.0395104103,
0.0645909905,
0.0008933003,
-0.0141154435,
-0.0723077655,
-0.0837020576,
-0.04514217,
-0.0286183134,
-0.033468008,
0.0406759195,
0.039363306,
-0.0169942323,
-0.0155830262,
-0.0286234878,
0.0720479116,
0.0085891904,
0.0002650942,
-0.0348697416,
0.0180836003,
0.0244967397,
-0.0423558094,
0.0200005081,
-0.0325479023,
0.031702131,
-0.0375858657,
0.0361729339,
-0.0177047756,
-0.0146198347,
-0.01855468,
0.0460269451,
-0.0523634851,
-0.0575323105,
-0.0081929183,
0.0569407456,
0.0268262438,
0.0158039685,
-0.0275093187,
-0.0320362374,
-0.0122033712,
0.0574770123,
-0.0088394769,
-0.0228863172,
0.0034838903,
0.0108885821,
0.0363697149,
0.0382139236,
-0.0075358222,
0.0318390764,
0.0111944191,
0.0538880751,
-0.061565686,
0.0105819367,
0.069200106,
0.0612289645,
-0.0128425639,
0.0359398238,
-0.026496131,
-0.0137649253,
0.0239059813,
-0.0628199354,
-0.0335843451,
-0.0508033484,
0.0308779236,
0.0057553858,
-0.0412918627,
0.0213085357,
-0.0457529277,
-0.0375117958,
0.0104657058,
-0.0062480606,
0.0391583592,
0.0395271108,
-0.0002047904,
0.0299720876,
-0.0345848836,
-0.0059004654,
0.0077352095,
0.0153257931,
0.036612995,
-0.0078087016,
0.0826821327,
0.032609351,
0.0207482688,
-0.0512212701,
-0.0189173315,
-0.0501719676,
-0.0759523287,
0.0365040153,
-0.0019843529,
0.0338898078,
0.0404890999,
0.0060150139,
-0.030225236,
-0.0123392474,
0.0029192034,
0.0102574211,
0.0449002348,
-0.0293633956,
0.0552413277,
0.0393926613,
-0.0221741088,
-0.0492219329,
0.0538340583,
-0.0161903352,
0.0546369851,
0.0204286277,
-0.0129323686,
-0.0492032915,
-0.0203802641,
-0.0084042102,
0.005782689,
0.0218598042,
0.0262890477,
-0.0487652235,
-0.0835298896,
-0.0425583571,
0.0472276993,
0.020482121,
-0.0118541783,
0.0083613163,
0.0271906629,
0.0230396427,
-0.0711636916,
-0.0166195054,
0.0205693319,
-0.0485462546,
-0.0515945032,
-0.031331975,
-6.42125838e-33,
-0.0347132869,
-0.0079448028,
0.0466358215,
0.0062034172,
0.0189165846,
-0.0461580902,
-0.0445655398,
0.0183082893,
-0.0233790725,
0.0214749146,
-0.0326643325,
0.0465447642,
0.009269502,
0.0070715188,
0.0184589773,
-0.0145875653,
0.0250527412,
-0.020243274,
-0.0126207555,
0.0049542291,
0.0399177149,
-0.0060937991,
0.0046222974,
-0.0266577657,
-0.0366136804,
0.015150995,
-0.0164510868,
0.0593883172,
-0.065233916,
0.029984422,
-0.0031753213,
-0.0113813579,
0.0048278398,
-0.0268859547,
-0.0029850423,
0.0054459265,
-0.0407529622,
-0.0191941131,
0.0431044772,
-0.0006277801,
-0.032560192,
-0.0519809872,
0.0218396951,
-0.0186004229,
0.0063979696,
-0.0467804,
-0.0115581658,
-0.0151352789,
0.0434517115,
0.0023441017,
-0.0058910442,
0.0223670974,
-0.0388555042,
-0.0355082601,
0.0306995418,
0.0340279266,
-0.0138635635,
-0.0280475598,
-0.0273334011,
0.0026235085,
0.026645381,
-0.003416654,
0.0616509989,
-0.0156297982,
-0.0078801792,
0.0219021291,
0.0088909287,
-0.0051942584,
-0.0290789027,
0.0599392429,
-0.0104666529,
0.087484017,
0.0468091778,
-0.0172741786,
0.0446564183,
0.002508516,
-0.0547520258,
0.0000552661,
0.0111484295,
0.0548139885,
0.0540298298,
0.0129029285,
-0.0395538025,
-0.0049216785,
-0.0331926532,
0.0446028076,
-0.0506977737,
-0.0163397584,
0.0448679142,
-0.0009103224,
-0.0104965093,
-0.0425461493,
0.021422904,
-0.0649607256,
0.0222015325,
0.0117859812,
0.0014423869,
-0.0145644099,
-0.0080494089,
0.0623647086,
-0.0327541195,
-0.017209664,
0.0106030907,
0.0154278725,
0.0281330217,
0.0010935969,
0.0093154153,
0.0076860297,
-0.0561255142,
-0.0055312766,
-0.071107246,
0.0431496613,
-0.0166453253,
0.0229975134,
0.0276121944,
0.0234398413,
0.0011219569,
-0.0188050885,
-0.0268179122,
-0.0457873233,
-0.0410654359,
0.0281106178,
0.002477326,
0.0127169155,
-0.0201704148,
-0.0235978365,
-0.0405397601,
-0.0201838147,
0.0120050544,
-0.016486438,
-0.0013142622,
0.0210687462,
2.971e-7,
0.0049165427,
0.055872649,
0.0092770578,
0.0836145133,
0.0254331362,
0.0528935343,
0.0057485346,
0.023829909,
0.0359669663,
-0.038187664,
-0.0219931863,
0.0470349602,
0.0463742092,
0.0396937132,
-0.0548285693,
0.0124288667,
0.0042968336,
-0.0538889579,
-0.0627157688,
0.014361606,
0.0704735816,
0.0884340852,
0.0236616116,
0.0004243906,
0.0064670569,
-0.0408293493,
0.0087648612,
-0.0001126526,
0.0056567234,
-0.0202317145,
0.0315198489,
0.0310944431,
-0.0015089116,
0.0410898775,
0.006919255,
0.0116461515,
-0.0379838087,
0.0932266861,
-0.0058872723,
-0.0203177817,
-0.0275112707,
-0.0246585533,
-0.0129140913,
-0.0251835492,
0.0903863013,
-0.0628628358,
-0.048871465,
0.0132400915,
0.0148173189,
-0.0537935197,
-0.037997175,
-0.0126648284,
-0.0004331128,
0.0177140627,
0.0215024874,
-0.0385491736,
0.0250343755,
-0.0610554889,
-0.0124379462,
0.0160870068,
-0.0430014543,
0.0022304854,
-0.0292982385,
0.055230502,
0.0284238495,
-0.0277304109,
-0.007354002,
3.088298937e-34,
0.048227258,
-0.0031123972,
0.0199891757,
0.0268875547,
0.0920822844,
0.0195403751,
-0.0455986671,
0.0312078875,
0.0227924399,
-0.105225563,
-0.0274361204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06121v1 | Is it indeed bigger better? The comprehensive study of claim detection LMs applied for disinformation tackling | 2023-11-10T15:36:35 | 2023-11-10T15:36:35 | Martin Hyben, Sebastian Kula, Ivan Srba, Robert Moro, Jakub Simko | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study compares the performance of (1) fine-tuned models and (2)
extremely large language models on the task of check-worthy claim detection.
For the purpose of the comparison we composed a multilingual and multi-topical
dataset comprising texts of various sources and styles. Building on this, we
performed a benchmark analysis to determine the most general multilingual and
multi-topical claim detector.
We chose three state-of-the-art models in the check-worthy claim detection
task and fine-tuned them. Furthermore, we selected three state-of-the-art
extremely large language models without any fine-tuning. We made modifications
to the models to adapt them for multilingual settings and through extensive
experimentation and evaluation. We assessed the performance of all the models
in terms of accuracy, recall, and F1-score in in-domain and cross-domain
scenarios. Our results demonstrate that despite the technological progress in
the area of natural language processing, the models fine-tuned for the task of
check-worthy claim detection still outperform the zero-shot approaches in a
cross-domain settings. | [
0.0419693775,
-0.0085264146,
0.0002080725,
0.0591208674,
-0.079095751,
0.0040992396,
-0.0049912389,
0.0030885283,
0.0286970884,
-0.0635791793,
0.0188176092,
-0.0464794114,
0.019746514,
0.0281709637,
0.0351579823,
-0.0093421135,
0.0299442299,
-0.0029483624,
0.0889806971,
-0.0380985029,
-0.0012757852,
0.0137189478,
-0.0188021623,
0.0084799612,
-0.0487483926,
-0.0172858126,
0.0593820438,
0.0174056944,
0.0408725217,
-0.0413500704,
0.0266847238,
0.0420547202,
0.0102419723,
0.1174796745,
0.0000020044,
-0.0744124055,
0.0211736914,
0.0418568924,
-0.0299089067,
0.0545083843,
0.0403534658,
-0.0321962163,
-0.0327314325,
0.0106633883,
0.0271913726,
-0.0116104614,
0.0169216208,
0.0909541622,
0.0324091651,
0.1067977399,
-0.0088446923,
-0.0405741185,
0.0491508916,
-0.0081326952,
-0.0462854579,
-0.0435464419,
0.0584700257,
0.0067007411,
-0.0039266278,
-0.029203685,
0.0146669028,
0.0518443994,
-0.0114734378,
-0.0318492278,
-0.0562792085,
0.0015016424,
-0.0508303344,
-0.0039877933,
-0.0004203775,
0.0069614472,
-0.0154055385,
-0.0348035656,
-0.0129016479,
-0.0100485319,
0.0294452589,
0.0329318941,
-0.0059197079,
0.0856428817,
-0.0251694787,
0.0037267844,
0.0083630681,
-0.0048547271,
0.0365958773,
0.0289538782,
-0.0021022998,
0.0298111662,
0.0005889729,
-0.0720603764,
0.0465810597,
-0.0153051876,
0.0127834771,
-0.0772755221,
0.0107112862,
-0.0070503424,
0.0151011702,
0.0132045625,
-0.0235600639,
-0.0230843015,
0.0742259398,
-0.1125467643,
0.0392643698,
-0.0118950391,
-0.051302243,
0.0315627158,
-0.0503952317,
0.0377378799,
-0.0226715598,
-0.022396734,
0.0047628297,
-0.0269925408,
-0.0200833995,
-0.0166482106,
-0.0054042838,
0.0358634442,
-0.0319603197,
0.0083162263,
-0.0557524562,
-0.0218484327,
-0.000162337,
0.0204894561,
-0.011843509,
-0.0215292908,
0.0095897038,
-0.0209191963,
-0.0378542356,
0.0524033718,
-0.0084612854,
0.0126280915,
-0.0118982,
-0.0698597133,
0.0075667836,
0.0514028482,
-0.0205335785,
-0.0261962097,
0.0037874882,
-0.0156887565,
0.0121474173,
-0.0578895323,
-0.048569113,
-0.0084630717,
-0.0512346774,
-0.0828034952,
-0.0072085224,
-0.0473191701,
-0.0155994864,
-0.0201241057,
-0.0022812746,
-0.0218944158,
-0.0011802297,
0.0316929072,
-0.0641263276,
-0.0069798939,
-0.0063929567,
0.0041490193,
0.0585156418,
-0.0073569305,
0.0276220441,
0.0583853647,
0.0112236403,
0.044583194,
0.0704811588,
0.024324242,
0.0379681215,
0.0342459939,
0.0187567491,
0.0349130705,
0.0466616116,
-0.0267003868,
-0.0010143375,
-0.0123468805,
0.0007861208,
0.0289752148,
-0.0078455694,
-0.0474612974,
0.0943730325,
-0.006042257,
0.0031215155,
-0.0389834419,
0.004967554,
0.0295008011,
0.0295266975,
0.0024118035,
-0.0163800847,
-0.027034305,
-0.0785468295,
-0.0270929895,
0.0235100407,
0.0165751446,
-0.0054914765,
-0.0338857397,
-0.0553971604,
0.0001165973,
-0.0281460546,
-0.0055795601,
0.031033555,
0.0151237594,
-0.0488160998,
0.0237919148,
0.0225318689,
-0.0052017509,
-0.0411935821,
-0.0657946318,
0.0098507106,
-0.014334701,
0.0236934982,
0.0041111815,
0.0273347609,
-0.0466846563,
0.0121776154,
0.0755249038,
0.0816114098,
0.013805829,
-0.0062207323,
0.0120910406,
-0.0134396954,
-0.0615147203,
0.0246255491,
0.011470411,
0.0397069193,
0.0271098409,
0.0280858763,
-0.0260271356,
-0.0425303616,
0.0198851861,
0.0341720097,
-0.0141051812,
-0.0023062238,
0.0091545321,
0.0203937236,
0.0326073505,
-0.0188614149,
-0.0340060852,
0.030258121,
-0.0304098018,
-0.047692474,
-0.0090186214,
0.065865986,
-0.0245911628,
0.0278102905,
-0.0485921465,
-0.0297662076,
0.0390981808,
-0.0012253536,
0.0076681343,
-0.0222466458,
-0.0310375653,
-0.0165505484,
-0.0528640188,
0.0041581732,
-0.0361025147,
0.0173242074,
0.0017604646,
0.079032138,
0.0019470864,
-0.0021716354,
-0.0092525035,
0.0043506338,
0.0443467684,
-0.0145998243,
-0.0402162783,
0.0173055176,
-0.0075857099,
-0.0169453565,
0.0278498586,
-0.0427985229,
0.0112450272,
0.0035266548,
-0.0498311333,
-0.0111530144,
-0.0229218993,
-0.0044052852,
-0.0044107353,
-0.0525573455,
-0.0228021238,
0.0212606359,
0.0017771071,
-0.0519307815,
0.0444616079,
0.0343133248,
0.0151162846,
-0.0317431614,
-0.006366434,
-0.0052829492,
0.0368505307,
0.0016052139,
0.0230878834,
0.0339873098,
-0.0917475671,
-0.0674936995,
0.0151211238,
-0.0411384217,
0.010746669,
-0.0333766118,
-0.0130902426,
-0.0256878305,
0.03416612,
-0.0186160412,
0.0035986474,
0.0252123047,
0.0092266137,
0.0311108809,
0.0597845353,
-0.0081687262,
-0.014830092,
0.0037555904,
0.0113608474,
-0.0358036943,
-0.0541032813,
0.0586705692,
0.0499674529,
0.0132756848,
0.0086717177,
-0.0027369668,
-0.0207882449,
-0.0239270609,
-0.0290359482,
0.0632518157,
-0.0196757633,
-0.0296956934,
0.0444041938,
0.0008873788,
-0.0585633889,
0.0541371033,
-0.0263196621,
0.0185581278,
-0.0053165192,
-0.0074960939,
-0.0002816133,
0.0352020562,
0.0088861994,
0.0374610871,
0.0376870595,
-0.0195229091,
0.0483634844,
-0.0305939466,
0.0549284518,
0.0005944513,
-0.0083102221,
-0.0340982154,
0.0482305363,
-0.0044067525,
-0.0321824513,
-0.0439656302,
-0.0938129127,
-0.0004153552,
-0.0213117618,
-0.0562091097,
0.0101065906,
-0.1216868162,
-0.0015403465,
0.0165313613,
0.0465592854,
-0.0008907592,
0.0094659105,
0.0290463958,
0.0146223921,
-0.0144964382,
-0.0160795581,
0.0591111295,
-0.0496920422,
-0.0147978459,
0.0487414338,
-0.0564971007,
0.0416148864,
0.0313328318,
-0.0633552447,
0.0067611714,
-0.0347811505,
-0.0210869517,
-0.0060444907,
0.0197224133,
-0.0783745497,
0.0375868566,
0.08636491,
-0.0016607223,
0.0584064387,
0.001499329,
-0.0005731967,
-0.0012330284,
0.039659176,
0.0036219517,
-0.0850697309,
0.0009056874,
0.0058916938,
-0.0301101189,
-0.0566626228,
0.0086674234,
-0.0166101977,
-0.1125809848,
0.0788955614,
0.0147733884,
0.0054371557,
-0.0518189445,
-0.0289894212,
-0.0169707946,
0.0346284732,
0.0009447164,
0.0036995392,
0.0135453595,
-0.060154371,
-0.0102815367,
-0.053876508,
-0.0479548462,
-0.0095494036,
-0.0171642751,
0.0146438805,
0.0309160426,
0.0334998034,
-0.0240101945,
-0.0455595218,
0.0174432583,
-0.0066893473,
-0.010434364,
0.0017321591,
0.0810239092,
-0.0164263491,
0.0105999755,
-0.0137843024,
-0.0058090664,
0.0434366986,
0.0073054447,
0.0092797233,
0.0468702093,
0.0042635533,
-0.0623527989,
0.0015007949,
0.0227598064,
0.0019293504,
0.0795015246,
-0.0136829941,
0.0258108135,
-0.0445646048,
-0.0382916667,
-0.0412627794,
-0.0068373899,
0.0006513592,
0.0907164887,
-0.0070495661,
-0.0580429025,
-0.0562210493,
-0.0200798474,
-0.0178541802,
0.0034856417,
0.0037916736,
0.0172562469,
-0.0018156008,
0.0171447862,
-0.0276087485,
-0.0048717358,
-0.0546954684,
0.0694834292,
-0.0246121194,
0.0295054372,
0.010565104,
0.0047857757,
0.0003014114,
0.0060226559,
-0.0428237207,
-0.0600585714,
-0.0142013924,
0.0116362572,
0.0182475764,
0.0486330055,
-0.0058349152,
-0.0622476749,
0.0400367901,
0.0230104122,
-0.0085702371,
0.0461429879,
0.0269975085,
-0.0361012928,
-0.0061096493,
0.021470027,
0.0080678053,
0.0569058396,
0.0236648154,
-0.0092606815,
-0.0024272637,
-0.0004479496,
0.0185117461,
0.0557224192,
0.0578035973,
-0.0118331024,
-0.019822225,
-0.023502415,
0.0013398074,
-0.0338899195,
-0.0439667292,
0.0003935872,
0.0031826538,
0.0041070776,
-0.01291891,
-0.0134492284,
0.0369903259,
-0.0616320521,
0.0192200858,
-0.0713981166,
0.0351058543,
-0.0341400504,
0.0353746451,
0.0311451592,
-0.0123723214,
-0.0284770615,
0.0089904033,
0.0398253873,
0.0414730981,
0.028446326,
0.0328200348,
0.0010471083,
-0.0024661541,
0.0272490978,
-0.0486363508,
-0.0186594184,
-0.0106821964,
-0.0243636258,
0.0153991906,
0.0432018451,
-0.0103345141,
0.037049938,
-0.0154702403,
-0.0155650675,
-0.0047853175,
-0.0160058327,
0.0081823207,
-0.0318870954,
0.0328273587,
-0.0067397691,
-0.0323714577,
0.0291184019,
0.0513452068,
0.0076335566,
0.0545452982,
-0.0120340306,
-0.0360720791,
-0.0312190782,
-0.0762852207,
-0.0144651048,
0.0334296189,
0.0052715279,
-0.0028255894,
-0.114134334,
-0.0442796499,
0.0105554266,
0.0125415931,
0.034320578,
-0.0004541086,
-0.005345101,
0.0433512442,
0.0226029418,
-0.014067091,
-0.0344991609,
0.0023341284,
0.0164782684,
0.0081917215,
0.0214539394,
-6.085897923e-33,
-0.0036358691,
-0.0484372266,
-0.0234352704,
0.0113117965,
-0.0209274441,
0.0214247629,
-0.0107472772,
-0.0380258821,
-0.0105218878,
0.0813060552,
0.0138374055,
0.0305096209,
0.0196456388,
0.0042502075,
-0.0386402942,
0.0034293125,
0.0609050915,
0.0001656897,
-0.0355179794,
-0.0239241142,
0.0314294845,
0.0207297932,
0.0496037528,
-0.078988716,
0.0639565438,
-0.0044148439,
-0.046867419,
0.0159524512,
-0.0277125444,
0.0377547406,
0.0150080901,
0.059614826,
0.0288107656,
-0.0358911008,
0.03352651,
0.0075018601,
-0.0347172171,
0.0063751368,
0.0626072511,
0.0009955268,
0.0362886339,
-0.0027841511,
0.0317304842,
0.0079457546,
-0.0350084528,
-0.0048205075,
0.0332194902,
-0.0600571893,
-0.0057483111,
-0.05699737,
-0.0817490295,
0.0504139587,
0.0172741245,
0.0096065449,
0.0119949114,
0.0483700112,
-0.0009368443,
0.0565527156,
-0.0579665005,
-0.0024641561,
-0.0379899442,
-0.0280050654,
0.0193139724,
-0.0365218967,
-0.0520066395,
0.084870249,
0.0074156867,
0.0580202304,
0.0011872669,
0.0107853608,
-0.0209726188,
0.042132698,
0.0438856483,
0.092720136,
0.0229292233,
-0.0390114263,
-0.1003726274,
0.0140449489,
0.0267364047,
-0.0217871107,
0.0395839699,
-0.0448173173,
-0.0445962213,
-0.0247269534,
-0.0586961806,
0.0063092308,
-0.0317225419,
0.049022343,
0.0168251656,
0.0485096462,
0.0131374812,
0.0446337946,
-0.0010122027,
-0.0345309451,
0.0018008621,
-0.0232190527,
-0.0077998443,
0.0075981193,
0.0008115789,
0.0171924569,
-0.048195187,
0.0076367543,
-0.0182380639,
0.0310659688,
0.0033323485,
-0.0363411121,
0.0758175179,
-0.0212746039,
-0.0886388645,
0.0275536589,
-0.0067471429,
0.0352115743,
0.0077608111,
0.0121383965,
0.0269317552,
-0.0154276704,
-0.0016028339,
0.00334256,
-0.0128368381,
-0.0398136377,
-0.0236636493,
0.0022752816,
-0.0056918412,
0.0236429293,
-0.0309467614,
-0.0070724194,
0.0114657125,
0.0068190391,
0.0541528985,
-0.0775740594,
0.010350409,
-0.003513271,
2.715e-7,
0.0317688063,
0.069168523,
0.0066877366,
-0.0065289615,
0.0326181762,
0.0451879874,
-0.0118101658,
0.0014967556,
0.0037136674,
-0.0350641757,
-0.0604145378,
-0.0011555455,
0.0446754321,
0.0266738776,
-0.080150798,
0.0100581981,
-0.018279532,
-0.0468449891,
-0.0641157404,
0.0092652105,
-0.0039555514,
0.0283853617,
0.0168946423,
-0.0374107026,
-0.0014391585,
-0.0306511838,
0.0744152442,
0.0084910607,
-0.0237488225,
0.0156571455,
0.0401170105,
-0.0184690394,
0.0123127745,
0.0591612384,
-0.0314899199,
0.0392741784,
-0.0260380264,
0.0840423182,
0.0250325669,
0.0362933241,
-0.0410962664,
-0.0148356529,
0.006678829,
-0.0462973975,
0.0324654505,
-0.0067502791,
-0.0435211025,
-0.0540531464,
-0.04160662,
-0.0093548577,
0.0337625854,
-0.0207969584,
-0.0169068035,
0.0255294181,
-0.0016816978,
-0.0199770946,
0.0116091752,
-0.0517007113,
0.003213732,
0.0344448313,
-0.0341810882,
-0.0198930874,
0.0140279327,
-0.0352037437,
0.0531762615,
-0.0554421134,
0.0295971464,
2.383904839e-34,
0.0633786097,
-0.0329134949,
-0.0113704614,
-0.0373575501,
0.0531244054,
0.0387298986,
-0.0106372768,
-0.0079002529,
-0.0220754948,
-0.0138375647,
0.0151931196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06102v1 | Making LLMs Worth Every Penny: Resource-Limited Text Classification in Banking | 2023-11-10T15:10:36 | 2023-11-10T15:10:36 | Lefteris Loukas, Ilias Stogiannidis, Odysseas Diamantopoulos, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Stavros Vassos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Standard Full-Data classifiers in NLP demand thousands of labeled examples,
which is impractical in data-limited domains. Few-shot methods offer an
alternative, utilizing contrastive learning techniques that can be effective
with as little as 20 examples per class. Similarly, Large Language Models
(LLMs) like GPT-4 can perform effectively with just 1-5 examples per class.
However, the performance-cost trade-offs of these methods remain underexplored,
a critical concern for budget-limited organizations. Our work addresses this
gap by studying the aforementioned approaches over the Banking77 financial
intent detection dataset, including the evaluation of cutting-edge LLMs by
OpenAI, Cohere, and Anthropic in a comprehensive set of few-shot scenarios. We
complete the picture with two additional methods: first, a cost-effective
querying method for LLMs based on retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), able to
reduce operational costs multiple times compared to classic few-shot
approaches, and second, a data augmentation method using GPT-4, able to improve
performance in data-limited scenarios. Finally, to inspire future research, we
provide a human expert's curated subset of Banking77, along with extensive
error analysis. | [
0.0404288359,
0.1013730317,
-0.0047077262,
0.0436398052,
-0.0321134329,
0.0125314333,
0.0447378978,
0.0726601854,
0.0326358043,
-0.0577006452,
-0.0660798997,
-0.0592366681,
0.0061336383,
-0.0045659468,
0.0146121094,
-0.0070534023,
0.0416508913,
0.0203229729,
0.0334771164,
0.0007604729,
-0.0085525913,
0.027057372,
0.0119312564,
0.0146186706,
-0.0006948934,
-0.0089965034,
0.0088166744,
0.0005859721,
0.018530203,
-0.0343721993,
0.0304527804,
0.0185417477,
0.0382384472,
0.0569889881,
0.0000022331,
-0.0698617995,
-0.029942004,
0.0002609585,
-0.0534791015,
0.0219859593,
0.071162723,
-0.0353085473,
0.0619978905,
0.0297723562,
-0.034920048,
-0.0290015172,
0.0385239832,
0.0747924522,
0.0307923742,
0.0795234144,
-0.0170317814,
-0.0633152947,
0.0005103413,
-0.0625790432,
0.0332002863,
-0.0655327365,
0.0434405841,
-0.034899164,
-0.0205219965,
0.0306221694,
-0.031537883,
0.0194120612,
0.0214256849,
0.0261917505,
-0.0026186039,
0.0368572995,
-0.0419791602,
0.0157998856,
-0.0483291075,
0.0410027988,
0.0077411388,
0.0200245399,
0.0054136766,
-0.0595570877,
-0.0160979461,
-0.0015584411,
-0.0071592927,
0.0382515155,
-0.0066313925,
0.0061644204,
-0.0024668721,
0.0308204982,
0.0431559719,
0.0506907292,
-0.0333702639,
-0.0158420447,
-0.0145636154,
-0.0427475236,
0.0157862995,
0.0290922038,
-0.0374172516,
-0.0106497658,
-0.0230288599,
0.0142700318,
0.0219455715,
0.0146896942,
-0.033842057,
-0.0418053269,
0.0361568928,
-0.0248436462,
0.0367039777,
0.0627112612,
-0.0465746932,
0.0472736694,
-0.0145205399,
0.0074912752,
-0.0066535897,
-0.040565677,
-0.0494343229,
0.0179592781,
-0.0670171753,
-0.0017241726,
-0.0516369455,
0.0674442649,
-0.0525400601,
-0.0338132381,
-0.0762207285,
0.0190409999,
0.0182519481,
-0.0097716227,
0.002877411,
-0.0210407041,
-0.0080517,
-0.0072645755,
-0.024969833,
-0.0034191217,
-0.0225241594,
0.0225710031,
-0.0142401773,
-0.0390408039,
-0.0151980696,
0.0554512255,
-0.0269309245,
-0.0424339212,
0.0329971388,
0.0584804043,
0.0254560728,
-0.1221940741,
-0.0798371136,
-0.0068759373,
-0.0550644509,
-0.0360964537,
-0.0358781889,
-0.0116381682,
0.0184368212,
-0.0050146449,
-0.0233562198,
0.0009275606,
0.0138591211,
0.0089181541,
-0.0341488533,
0.0799586475,
0.0032850895,
-0.0323136561,
0.0258187018,
-0.0242637824,
-0.0076369694,
0.0616680682,
0.0105120344,
0.0259728543,
0.0255886689,
0.0198664181,
-0.0026671034,
0.0341376625,
0.0380428173,
-0.0170315411,
0.0355576575,
0.0256247781,
-0.0025409786,
0.0178196337,
0.0294157472,
0.0261918753,
-0.0574068539,
-0.0072244504,
0.0515720397,
0.0286990162,
0.0551603064,
-0.0118429493,
0.0132189849,
0.0464776866,
-0.0170300324,
-0.0233536363,
0.0145161459,
-0.0081470152,
-0.0591162518,
0.0176221505,
0.0272238832,
0.0049585085,
-0.0626515746,
-0.0257616173,
-0.0170912798,
-0.021849433,
-0.0191101525,
0.0252047013,
0.0594459362,
-0.0012277978,
-0.0638522953,
0.0377382152,
0.0288550481,
-0.0201326124,
-0.0146250594,
-0.0686723813,
0.0566666052,
0.0691245198,
0.0491011031,
-0.0419227555,
0.0295550115,
-0.0112989694,
-0.0156013574,
0.0593770705,
0.063223213,
0.0225542001,
0.0182973836,
-0.090940915,
-0.0034221173,
-0.0083180163,
0.0200991333,
0.0261947811,
0.0154508706,
0.0138567463,
0.0280932169,
-0.012276181,
-0.0019457226,
0.0290648956,
-0.0078623621,
-0.0604197644,
0.0730363578,
0.015656447,
0.0028342877,
0.0097228745,
0.0092947604,
-0.0132476185,
0.010250573,
-0.0256928485,
-0.0096713332,
-0.0401355587,
0.0023018301,
-0.0374478661,
-0.0138825104,
0.0214095842,
-0.0098196669,
0.0361419022,
-0.0637670383,
-0.0241781138,
-0.0094178701,
-0.0164007619,
0.0340315811,
-0.0882635415,
-0.0053993016,
0.018522609,
0.0287728924,
-0.0190957207,
0.0994267762,
0.0046811919,
-0.0084394515,
-0.0111997062,
0.0008902936,
0.0436779037,
-0.0314751118,
0.0087156985,
-0.0293863267,
-0.010797888,
0.0087539954,
0.037952058,
0.0301684588,
-0.0094637405,
0.0054134661,
-0.08846277,
-0.0045413529,
-0.0098808138,
0.014023033,
-0.0145548666,
0.041593831,
0.0086888792,
-0.0122176548,
-0.0117913857,
0.027663175,
0.0066700983,
0.0223642513,
0.0504158102,
0.0044287937,
-0.017823264,
-0.0142941959,
0.0169077553,
0.0205638707,
0.0446847603,
0.0125848027,
-0.0524766557,
-0.0180959683,
0.025808977,
0.010656829,
-0.0019941221,
-0.0019771268,
0.0238118898,
-0.0004009358,
-0.0120382225,
-0.0217551105,
0.0105038602,
-0.0073978035,
0.0536655188,
-0.0304163583,
0.0245440677,
-0.0735803321,
0.0283802729,
-0.0241546277,
-0.0054271161,
0.0074829431,
0.0046877041,
0.0153086353,
0.0553130731,
-0.0119763622,
0.0025460268,
-0.08904396,
-0.0030893118,
0.0058184513,
-0.0187209621,
-0.0505319312,
0.0293013584,
-0.0125192208,
0.0339424424,
-0.0043102126,
-0.0288491827,
0.0460357554,
0.0216386616,
-0.0021673681,
-0.0280814711,
-0.0208752155,
-0.0597981624,
0.0679683685,
-0.0384769216,
0.0143661927,
0.0151427286,
-0.029706249,
-0.0190308504,
-0.0399551429,
-0.0025843496,
0.0044270949,
0.0581281334,
-0.0134051079,
0.0470424704,
-0.0263554491,
-0.052807495,
-0.046749372,
-0.1093923077,
-0.020725403,
-0.003972407,
0.0187733136,
-0.0220162701,
-0.0528056771,
0.0294386502,
-0.0154529009,
0.0276272874,
-0.0029706906,
-0.0437717997,
0.0074270889,
0.0384557955,
0.0460252687,
-0.0232573394,
0.01203606,
-0.0415979289,
0.0200022087,
0.023115214,
-0.0047113588,
-0.0049915831,
-0.000472865,
-0.0172096025,
0.0126576396,
-0.0506823622,
-0.025702972,
-0.0035181835,
-0.0282420106,
-0.0377499983,
-0.0442911759,
0.089974612,
0.0158315338,
-0.0247062463,
-0.0030192977,
-0.007750954,
-0.011791734,
-0.0188958421,
0.0470416844,
-0.0977637321,
-0.0609507188,
-0.0233055037,
0.0423179083,
0.0069125011,
-0.0202934165,
-0.0268762521,
-0.1597367376,
0.0627449378,
-0.0061310437,
-0.0299466066,
-0.0069313892,
-0.0170296803,
-0.0125079891,
-0.0238705836,
0.0102987243,
0.0116671408,
0.0042960159,
-0.0214084424,
0.0005551146,
-0.0070214863,
-0.0376607776,
-0.0151573913,
0.0080453753,
-0.0389449038,
0.0398718864,
0.0214211997,
-0.0017817537,
-0.0462228581,
0.0089280298,
-0.0590647459,
0.006555079,
-0.0253359322,
0.0749222487,
-0.0237443428,
-0.0077094086,
0.0298903175,
0.0202106666,
-0.0550876148,
-0.0070694876,
-0.0123474868,
0.0218723603,
-0.0331119038,
0.0133749014,
-0.0017385568,
-0.0107958205,
0.0087532541,
0.1089154556,
-0.0006628301,
-0.062371511,
0.0080829337,
0.019121604,
-0.024310451,
-0.042127721,
0.0503831096,
-0.0101320334,
0.0161697585,
-0.0214516968,
-0.0641117021,
-0.0651582852,
0.031130502,
0.0361729376,
-0.0133407665,
0.0006878561,
-0.008905516,
-0.0132501703,
-0.0089769196,
-0.0275368374,
-0.0813504905,
0.0206076019,
-0.0356032662,
0.0176393781,
0.015863033,
-0.0776606128,
-0.031942714,
0.0142544135,
-0.0584703423,
-0.0352485105,
-0.0023106756,
0.028407611,
0.0218613688,
0.0057779369,
-0.0080024777,
-0.0050079399,
0.0405909568,
0.0907521546,
-0.0545630679,
-0.0070947921,
0.0264576972,
-0.0021761949,
-0.0214301962,
0.0216490719,
-0.0662810728,
0.042082876,
0.0373956859,
0.0164189991,
-0.0751504004,
-0.0134810274,
0.0058761775,
0.0044842828,
0.0593322814,
-0.0403546765,
-0.0324490704,
-0.0320759825,
0.0157238618,
0.0101689678,
0.0034737196,
-0.0437095501,
-0.0451361351,
0.0493937545,
0.0003361632,
-0.0164293144,
0.0015331884,
-0.0278389286,
0.0194015708,
-0.0038749038,
-0.0067936312,
0.0303967912,
0.0346712396,
-0.008399155,
-0.0312690884,
0.0019789827,
0.0360931195,
0.0190006066,
0.0148907667,
-0.0032157954,
0.0650997907,
0.0305178221,
0.0309207942,
-0.011115564,
-0.0027514386,
-0.035036888,
-0.0149431285,
-0.0090357922,
0.0352497213,
0.0279226042,
-0.0496371575,
-0.0051943739,
-0.0574237444,
0.0038308844,
-0.0181931909,
0.0072757229,
0.007478903,
-0.059626095,
0.0133728739,
0.0152079742,
-0.0330139548,
0.0036307427,
0.0958020389,
-0.0557335988,
0.0455047041,
-0.0104278,
-0.0263353754,
-0.0438911133,
-0.0193837434,
0.1052278057,
0.0303880591,
-0.0160908718,
0.0035155076,
-0.1021459028,
-0.0127652055,
0.0410488732,
-0.0290021431,
0.0020386314,
-0.0029055441,
0.0581269339,
0.0285182148,
0.0059821899,
0.0247586891,
-0.0364488661,
-0.0066958969,
-0.0729203075,
-0.0102072079,
-0.0488018468,
-6.680658391e-33,
-0.0127514638,
-0.0193222035,
0.047364492,
-0.0343388058,
0.0313331895,
0.0409233198,
0.0072214506,
-0.0292008631,
-0.0007325329,
-0.0256152097,
-0.0036042046,
0.018857101,
0.015472712,
0.0362103134,
-0.0053348467,
-0.0098018497,
0.0335937701,
-0.0198315103,
-0.0217740331,
0.0051718727,
0.0347073376,
0.0486162193,
0.0413389467,
-0.0462617613,
0.0108066611,
0.0068373466,
-0.0380074196,
0.0117394179,
0.0263269395,
0.0446444526,
-0.0213454068,
0.0362002067,
0.01350406,
-0.0602561235,
0.0183437765,
-0.0003597067,
-0.0463249125,
-0.0411282443,
-0.0002816029,
0.0159337781,
-0.0229941737,
-0.0119813243,
0.0162247866,
-0.0163072553,
-0.0417755768,
0.0044392496,
-0.0095089888,
-0.0142818438,
-0.0130705098,
-0.0101216231,
-0.0635480732,
0.0379738957,
0.0378314555,
0.0034222312,
0.0450467728,
0.0669697598,
0.0127550242,
0.0330594331,
-0.0628899336,
0.0165664554,
-0.0041530146,
-0.038167119,
0.0103017306,
0.0113593461,
-0.0271667894,
0.0540188327,
0.0233299918,
-0.0152688036,
0.0243511498,
-0.0059257387,
0.0136533761,
0.0334649347,
0.0236759372,
0.0753615275,
0.0581350513,
-0.0603745356,
-0.0537824593,
0.0324276984,
0.028128555,
0.0050096903,
0.0499516651,
0.0230892487,
-0.0722326189,
-0.0257860161,
0.030487841,
-0.0301685445,
-0.0468030684,
-0.0141377198,
0.0353514254,
0.0558881722,
-0.0190888736,
0.0406753868,
0.0480410829,
-0.0408296809,
-0.0136200413,
0.0204688217,
-0.0029562921,
-0.0056638266,
0.0112263719,
-0.0034395505,
-0.0750170201,
-0.0618366748,
0.0086465525,
0.0327110253,
-0.0087640276,
0.0049686427,
0.0547364242,
-0.0035587221,
-0.0555161349,
0.0063024759,
0.011309593,
0.0289465804,
-0.0291150678,
0.0435868651,
0.0093981577,
0.0245994646,
0.0079803318,
0.0163697898,
0.0105008259,
-0.0143412212,
-0.016524313,
-0.0318815671,
-0.0084904255,
0.0388940275,
0.0128440643,
0.0272621308,
0.0309226476,
0.0216394253,
0.0347392894,
-0.034652736,
-0.0329787247,
0.063030079,
2.93e-7,
0.0528532527,
0.0357785448,
-0.0383336358,
0.0380448811,
-0.0199205913,
0.0588366799,
0.0158790983,
-0.0073853326,
-0.0275857206,
0.0109630665,
0.0557278618,
0.0179266557,
0.0463459156,
-0.0284085665,
-0.0757983252,
0.0215131585,
-0.037018653,
0.0143001266,
-0.0433796681,
0.0254031476,
0.0756426156,
0.0949461013,
0.0232609566,
-0.0695070624,
0.0108500607,
-0.076211907,
0.0831492916,
-0.0149669806,
-0.0223669671,
-0.0155051881,
0.024018731,
0.0395773351,
-0.014194184,
0.0291019324,
-0.0041869697,
0.0311075952,
-0.004466617,
0.0287358072,
0.0169296004,
-0.0086828619,
-0.0030849623,
0.0472719893,
-0.0181860663,
-0.0109802391,
0.045818314,
-0.0477170348,
-0.0186320376,
-0.0246722698,
-0.0149340527,
0.0044071409,
0.0258903671,
0.017704824,
-0.0213879198,
-0.005243517,
0.0317113772,
-0.0253413972,
-0.0275210794,
-0.0527255833,
0.0527790859,
0.0033571594,
-0.0248148534,
0.0217626281,
-0.0541748255,
0.0511496775,
0.034953136,
-0.0930679142,
-0.0118675586,
2.609722814e-34,
0.0504500493,
-0.0424928889,
-0.024020154,
0.0204529446,
0.0170466304,
0.0182234384,
-0.010485895,
0.0338874795,
0.0326370783,
-0.0809118599,
0.0272176471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06062v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06062v3 | Practical Membership Inference Attacks against Fine-tuned Large Language Models via Self-prompt Calibration | 2023-11-10T13:55:05 | 2024-06-25T12:36:02 | Wenjie Fu, Huandong Wang, Chen Gao, Guanghua Liu, Yong Li, Tao Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Membership Inference Attacks (MIA) aim to infer whether a target data record
has been utilized for model training or not. Prior attempts have quantified the
privacy risks of language models (LMs) via MIAs, but there is still no
consensus on whether existing MIA algorithms can cause remarkable privacy
leakage on practical Large Language Models (LLMs). Existing MIAs designed for
LMs can be classified into two categories: reference-free and reference-based
attacks. They are both based on the hypothesis that training records
consistently strike a higher probability of being sampled. Nevertheless, this
hypothesis heavily relies on the overfitting of target models, which will be
mitigated by multiple regularization methods and the generalization of LLMs.
The reference-based attack seems to achieve promising effectiveness in LLMs,
which measures a more reliable membership signal by comparing the probability
discrepancy between the target model and the reference model. However, the
performance of reference-based attack is highly dependent on a reference
dataset that closely resembles the training dataset, which is usually
inaccessible in the practical scenario. Overall, existing MIAs are unable to
effectively unveil privacy leakage over practical fine-tuned LLMs that are
overfitting-free and private. We propose a Membership Inference Attack based on
Self-calibrated Probabilistic Variation (SPV-MIA). Specifically, since
memorization in LLMs is inevitable during the training process and occurs
before overfitting, we introduce a more reliable membership signal,
probabilistic variation, which is based on memorization rather than
overfitting. Furthermore, we introduce a self-prompt approach, which constructs
the dataset to fine-tune the reference model by prompting the target LLM
itself. In this manner, the adversary can collect a dataset with a similar
distribution from public APIs. | [
0.0129401013,
0.1146405488,
-0.0280959737,
0.0622466244,
-0.0345960967,
-0.0034903197,
0.03358775,
-0.0163122602,
0.0053304769,
-0.0101001458,
-0.0269749053,
-0.0195576549,
0.0134884221,
-0.0126281623,
0.0395227298,
0.0405796543,
0.027426891,
-0.0598531812,
-0.0117147565,
-0.0569276698,
-0.0365939438,
-0.0275809225,
0.027410116,
-0.0081755323,
0.000387483,
0.0046600527,
-0.011239158,
-0.0074570053,
0.0224649925,
-0.0016914014,
-0.0039194673,
0.0857008472,
0.0299876779,
0.0658926666,
0.0000020201,
-0.0131068118,
-0.0544702038,
0.0382385179,
-0.0641240478,
0.0495149083,
-0.0157185793,
0.0147804897,
0.0184984282,
0.0145383012,
-0.0151523864,
0.029888019,
0.0338632725,
0.0141497608,
0.0234837905,
0.0857972801,
0.0186619144,
-0.0130764004,
-0.0046506813,
-0.0671967193,
0.0178384762,
-0.0636781752,
0.0241414197,
-0.0348787978,
-0.0443278961,
0.0173363518,
0.0063009732,
0.0222389549,
-0.0156378429,
0.0295720734,
-0.0161249656,
0.0390044078,
-0.0210209172,
0.002658193,
0.0151053369,
0.0172832999,
0.0114113856,
-0.0128434086,
0.0286032893,
0.0094477953,
0.0285034198,
0.0382752866,
0.0015010828,
0.0277349874,
0.001565563,
0.0063013099,
0.014256496,
-0.0171234477,
0.0613290481,
-0.0178071186,
0.0071230871,
0.0301827565,
0.0231010187,
0.0066190283,
-0.0145425145,
-0.0439525805,
-0.0226443429,
-0.0463198312,
0.0023038504,
-0.0237020534,
0.0357431136,
0.0324705355,
-0.0821988806,
-0.0306463391,
0.0227342565,
-0.033632528,
0.0454874113,
-0.0069243619,
0.0056528365,
0.0287888758,
0.0057772091,
0.0246168524,
-0.0167497098,
0.0269114561,
-0.0092417412,
0.0269850008,
-0.0180790965,
-0.0032983713,
0.003330105,
0.042416919,
0.0053560496,
0.0124733942,
-0.0546753667,
0.0118137952,
-0.0239499267,
0.04223774,
-0.050606858,
-0.0102016786,
-0.0274793096,
0.0006385527,
-0.0010740501,
-0.0404506214,
0.0082329996,
0.0017560874,
-0.0031507488,
-0.0712070987,
-0.0455011874,
-0.0402947441,
-0.0200146399,
-0.0019911523,
-0.0109870201,
0.0614038222,
0.0319935381,
-0.0641875416,
-0.017529659,
-0.0701186806,
-0.0056878701,
-0.0618084669,
-0.0106862215,
-0.0661155358,
0.0006180002,
-0.0095441826,
0.0049168929,
-0.0676389933,
0.0040823505,
-0.001449858,
-0.0438212976,
0.0712147281,
-0.0099978745,
-0.0025355138,
-0.0153578315,
0.0151468841,
-0.0076163975,
0.0760363415,
0.0066385125,
0.0056388737,
0.0535798483,
-0.0097666979,
0.0527382642,
0.0318875946,
0.0604507364,
0.0154186292,
-0.0086225253,
0.0164931007,
0.0422215462,
-0.0481856093,
-0.0255359132,
0.041888997,
-0.012745562,
-0.057985153,
0.0816677958,
0.0691568628,
-0.0443483666,
0.0094720013,
-0.0568517856,
-0.0083426395,
0.0196861178,
0.0362188369,
-0.076489605,
-0.0304476749,
-0.0872261971,
-0.0369303711,
0.0371248387,
0.000884395,
-0.0013124662,
-0.0060216044,
0.0056247073,
-0.0541300736,
-0.0196193475,
0.0490239374,
0.0304958466,
0.0039547379,
0.0477525219,
0.0837157816,
0.0354544148,
-0.044671502,
-0.0082431938,
-0.0437122621,
0.0241493955,
0.0063268249,
0.0383253917,
-0.0356351472,
0.032500118,
-0.0475635119,
-0.0032821456,
-0.0144702075,
0.0400015377,
0.0201691836,
0.0546604656,
-0.0094297789,
-0.0312787145,
-0.0165873542,
0.037276458,
0.0379523039,
0.0168790389,
-0.043294169,
0.0250356179,
-0.0468016341,
-0.0301680863,
0.0285127088,
-0.0312621444,
-0.0419562049,
0.0384511948,
0.0112824244,
0.0315810181,
0.0198947396,
-0.0417660289,
0.0163865481,
0.0296112765,
0.0201682448,
0.0293237288,
-0.0454935096,
0.0108093983,
0.0025826734,
0.0073964335,
-0.0093499189,
0.010833458,
0.0291859917,
-0.0313308574,
-0.0391694158,
0.0136783328,
-0.0101871304,
0.0126518523,
-0.0014410048,
0.0219230391,
-0.0163815543,
0.0541034788,
-0.0281115156,
0.0217151865,
-0.0312165972,
0.0094264485,
-0.0173635278,
-0.0163005088,
0.027334949,
-0.0663482994,
-0.0729172528,
-0.0012756754,
-0.018562777,
0.0143310353,
0.014787049,
-0.0504505858,
-0.0090470146,
-0.0251552518,
-0.0239834636,
0.0135074193,
-0.0117819365,
0.0285458416,
-0.0208251756,
0.0221775472,
-0.0333366245,
-0.0399542116,
-0.0096156383,
-0.0240527634,
-0.047389552,
0.0384555124,
-0.0045052362,
0.0156838093,
-0.0213385168,
-0.0117540071,
-0.0318011642,
0.0106891794,
0.0559465736,
-0.0170219578,
0.0363238044,
-0.0415486246,
0.0051813964,
-0.0300632212,
0.0416253358,
-0.0253274143,
-0.0258313455,
0.0135396654,
0.0078496924,
-0.0232720338,
0.0725452453,
0.0113434764,
0.0012739978,
0.0657848567,
0.022272462,
-0.0265667513,
-0.0140444208,
-0.0075608245,
-0.0603684671,
-0.0559420809,
-0.0098313885,
-0.0074370163,
0.0248542335,
0.0337895676,
-0.052868329,
-0.0033910028,
0.0388420746,
0.0139557142,
-0.0202735905,
0.0008847208,
0.0049554994,
-0.009424529,
0.0135978833,
0.0221014302,
-0.0906477869,
0.0548263341,
-0.0606889017,
0.0451020747,
0.0178424008,
-0.0516589954,
0.0366673432,
0.0300680511,
0.037175063,
0.0224541649,
0.0606751442,
-0.0112924688,
-0.0318107978,
-0.002740443,
0.0838111117,
-0.0571145266,
0.0220288485,
-0.0024211539,
-0.0017876731,
0.0011442371,
-0.0241805501,
-0.075743489,
-0.0593576916,
-0.0200394653,
-0.0243722387,
-0.0160274748,
-0.033105962,
-0.0074699,
-0.0146429781,
0.0114934864,
-0.002581632,
-0.0091390265,
0.0275555085,
-0.021549318,
-0.0012838055,
0.0243566055,
-0.0427072868,
0.0205556527,
-0.060452681,
-0.0221269913,
0.061323002,
0.0458367281,
0.0547763743,
0.0123711089,
-0.0227863248,
0.0225775242,
-0.0173462108,
-0.0155918542,
0.041364491,
0.0364020877,
-0.032252349,
-0.0136515154,
0.0732548237,
-0.0014799809,
-0.0593889877,
-0.0115081333,
0.0463561825,
0.023323223,
0.0096091032,
0.0011502792,
-0.0871765316,
0.0015802422,
0.0502506383,
0.0671985224,
-0.0305782557,
-0.0586488135,
-0.0173424538,
-0.0886604637,
-0.0106197558,
0.0241455305,
-0.0048348526,
-0.0076896069,
-0.041231811,
0.0299930908,
-0.0090442523,
0.0090398584,
-0.0317831114,
0.0136723956,
-0.0087015694,
0.0063507464,
-0.0023042804,
-0.0469398201,
-0.0070868433,
-0.0477972031,
0.0896093473,
0.0482633114,
-0.0019128261,
-0.0253514592,
0.008573181,
0.0514902063,
0.0034660229,
-0.0236817915,
0.0390761644,
0.0617334917,
-0.0079897968,
-0.0137372361,
0.0399883166,
0.0520042852,
0.0310293492,
-0.0082548568,
0.0243248418,
0.0153390598,
-0.0014709084,
0.0037349481,
0.0184022672,
-0.023111308,
0.0257658195,
0.0522609763,
0.0125359539,
0.0001016088,
0.0222798884,
-0.0581939332,
0.0536670573,
0.0444326662,
0.0168598425,
0.0503630824,
-0.0045429254,
-0.077701956,
0.0024188287,
0.039799232,
-0.0233855397,
0.0275349636,
0.0245452821,
0.0421838351,
0.0179172102,
-0.0041220621,
-0.025178317,
-0.0010626176,
-0.0927387848,
0.0234774165,
-0.0309718717,
-0.0075756465,
0.0074920021,
0.0090233982,
-0.0225815699,
-0.017977925,
-0.1233117953,
-0.1129547507,
0.0198236536,
0.0367544778,
0.016233813,
0.0462600328,
-0.0206079651,
-0.087626636,
0.0835211426,
0.0369814411,
-0.0163410213,
0.0229110662,
0.0558960028,
-0.0522870757,
-0.0035653349,
0.0447882935,
-0.0406627133,
-0.0316705965,
0.0893574432,
-0.0477161594,
-0.009124306,
-0.0462364778,
-0.0111084096,
0.0314359851,
0.0663124248,
-0.0080089923,
0.0213672072,
-0.0150564853,
0.0433221571,
0.0004996765,
-0.0180989467,
-0.0088700335,
-0.0170786176,
0.0218293928,
-0.0073377201,
0.0498468913,
-0.0493210256,
0.0250819046,
0.0577575304,
-0.0274748281,
0.0057075592,
0.0557315946,
-0.0024265826,
0.0513188727,
-0.01614164,
-0.0089531718,
0.0734173208,
0.0316799693,
0.0291622318,
-0.0070735933,
0.0205529109,
-0.001142084,
-0.0031831618,
-0.030831296,
-0.0040545645,
-0.0551810265,
-0.0452735312,
-0.0001966931,
0.0574814193,
0.0240088832,
-0.0027409743,
-0.0170204397,
-0.0034746623,
-0.003740974,
-0.0302231442,
-0.0018702993,
-0.0271578506,
-0.0295610316,
0.0453586057,
-0.0180409607,
0.0015485453,
0.0813000873,
0.0778871626,
0.0374114253,
0.0533892252,
-0.0212270729,
-0.0359529927,
-0.0276460741,
-0.0105135739,
0.0037385223,
0.0431584306,
-0.0371240117,
-0.0067867232,
-0.0201519392,
-0.0808212757,
-0.0023599789,
-0.0138252238,
0.0048937262,
0.0045929793,
-0.0193325505,
0.0265984368,
-0.0138240047,
-0.0124659538,
-0.0698652789,
0.0104446346,
0.0434969105,
-0.0163356736,
0.0177937914,
-6.055451884e-33,
-0.0140159847,
-0.0127042644,
-0.0602169335,
0.0221613199,
0.0241102129,
0.002790404,
0.0108838724,
0.0141943023,
-0.0249755234,
-0.0372957774,
-0.0494751669,
0.0039388365,
0.0049896166,
0.0256198309,
-0.0315354653,
-0.048059877,
0.0264465082,
-0.0317769721,
-0.0377498902,
0.0164817106,
0.0505368374,
0.0289007276,
0.0641973987,
-0.0533530302,
0.0367802121,
-0.0236275773,
-0.0330808014,
0.0050318767,
-0.0412583165,
0.0513457097,
0.0061242185,
0.000022542,
-0.0143991597,
0.0379873663,
0.0008235148,
-0.0003951482,
-0.0171601903,
-0.0058150035,
-0.0084799109,
-0.0031791276,
0.0640025288,
-0.0431069583,
0.0313214473,
-0.0278461762,
-0.0012155346,
-0.0203177761,
-0.0044693029,
-0.0431178324,
-0.0342369005,
-0.0123017663,
0.0446301922,
0.0153048271,
-0.0150501113,
0.0056713647,
0.0480320975,
-0.02333536,
0.0315578692,
-0.0331098959,
-0.0301286653,
0.0359902382,
0.069340542,
0.0310624968,
0.0567001924,
0.0387315415,
0.0251466539,
0.0289278887,
0.0731264502,
0.0163301323,
0.0256924648,
-0.0216148552,
-0.0038286494,
0.0201781318,
0.0024650958,
0.0426901206,
0.0324909352,
-0.0382217914,
-0.0404184684,
-0.0234671887,
-0.007644474,
-0.0159456339,
0.0741946995,
-0.0026712834,
-0.0730133429,
-0.025897501,
-0.082667537,
-0.0545146689,
-0.0373720527,
0.0113461912,
-0.011357584,
0.0312829204,
-0.0307209715,
-0.0462222509,
0.0189445317,
-0.0563041903,
-0.0538677424,
0.0336943753,
0.0333148949,
-0.0406462215,
-0.033032123,
-0.0001271474,
-0.0270513743,
-0.012276846,
-0.0036990785,
-0.0830497965,
0.0185448956,
0.0083636642,
0.0299268216,
0.0199812334,
-0.0582176261,
-0.0154708093,
-0.0273584221,
0.025697127,
0.0357365981,
0.0162581969,
0.0678003728,
-0.0248075277,
0.0085339472,
0.0197036266,
0.0345965065,
0.0291810278,
-0.045446787,
0.0373833776,
-0.0256194491,
-0.0044123554,
0.0056220423,
-0.0089462772,
0.0174287856,
0.0251073819,
0.0865279883,
-0.0144403186,
0.0156684704,
-0.0278656464,
2.86e-7,
-0.012296048,
-0.0204110648,
-0.0042663775,
-0.0038594049,
0.0122677246,
0.0776090324,
-0.035655383,
0.0727070346,
0.0137253394,
-0.0128070917,
-0.0290558524,
0.003746114,
0.0502728596,
0.0254951715,
-0.0432853289,
0.0016491226,
-0.0213990808,
0.02602656,
-0.0479931533,
-0.0174335986,
-0.0147747342,
0.1052827761,
0.0503499806,
-0.0022748606,
-0.025227543,
-0.0597845092,
0.0346804634,
-0.0496715754,
-0.051233165,
0.009326457,
0.0879943147,
0.0702168122,
-0.0030772551,
0.0181470271,
-0.0267241262,
0.0384642221,
-0.046208702,
0.0546299666,
0.0631025881,
0.0092920512,
-0.0310176909,
-0.0246323161,
-0.0186648779,
-0.0052864701,
0.0454695448,
-0.0237173345,
-0.0265029632,
-0.0615026206,
-0.0005779737,
-0.0774535611,
0.0462361872,
-0.0086700246,
0.0018643624,
0.0233528763,
-0.0022534519,
0.0021168159,
0.0042251372,
-0.0797308981,
-0.0430051088,
-0.0384347439,
-0.047429096,
-0.0414475799,
0.0242928304,
-0.0034361859,
0.0014261141,
-0.0097359335,
0.0371859111,
2.732175346e-34,
-0.0048428881,
-0.0408648625,
-0.0243540239,
0.031143019,
0.0313599147,
-0.035762623,
0.0332783908,
0.007194153,
0.0032553829,
-0.0802914649,
-0.017430177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07598v1 | Multi-Label Topic Model for Financial Textual Data | 2023-11-10T12:56:07 | 2023-11-10T12:56:07 | Moritz Scherrmann | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a multi-label topic model for financial texts like ad-hoc
announcements, 8-K filings, finance related news or annual reports. I train the
model on a new financial multi-label database consisting of 3,044 German ad-hoc
announcements that are labeled manually using 20 predefined, economically
motivated topics. The best model achieves a macro F1 score of more than 85%.
Translating the data results in an English version of the model with similar
performance. As application of the model, I investigate differences in stock
market reactions across topics. I find evidence for strong positive or negative
market reactions for some topics, like announcements of new Large Scale
Projects or Bankruptcy Filings, while I do not observe significant price
effects for some other topics. Furthermore, in contrast to previous studies,
the multi-label structure of the model allows to analyze the effects of
co-occurring topics on stock market reactions. For many cases, the reaction to
a specific topic depends heavily on the co-occurrence with other topics. For
example, if allocated capital from a Seasoned Equity Offering (SEO) is used for
restructuring a company in the course of a Bankruptcy Proceeding, the market
reacts positively on average. However, if that capital is used for covering
unexpected, additional costs from the development of new drugs, the SEO implies
negative reactions on average. | [
0.0008457348,
0.0308143906,
-0.0109959971,
-0.0174013954,
0.0186141711,
-0.0118271541,
0.0241229162,
0.0330996513,
-0.0203556456,
-0.0657032207,
0.0002153157,
0.0058470159,
-0.0540869869,
0.0489427224,
-0.0186051801,
-0.0046980707,
0.0451531298,
-0.0205455851,
0.0679557249,
-0.0202953778,
0.0192047749,
0.0005585494,
0.0224955101,
-0.0075014951,
-0.0132014574,
-0.0232356358,
-0.0060583195,
0.00262917,
-0.0016324113,
-0.0313443802,
0.0033259601,
0.0303829182,
0.0318855084,
-0.0191884656,
0.0000018298,
-0.0581832379,
-0.0612321235,
-0.034126427,
0.0666793287,
0.0137748774,
0.0533593446,
-0.0409376994,
0.0365217924,
-0.0228106845,
-0.043836195,
0.0303254407,
0.0210361704,
0.0998300612,
0.0368268825,
0.038548328,
-0.0206135586,
-0.0551537946,
-0.014325914,
-0.0543856323,
0.0303546377,
-0.1298374534,
0.009020458,
0.0167374909,
-0.0264044032,
0.0318001099,
-0.0053216619,
0.0432442278,
-0.0225519761,
0.0193319228,
0.0146929016,
0.0172025338,
0.001482163,
-0.002318156,
-0.032570783,
0.0079225879,
0.0555797294,
0.0149342939,
0.0534581169,
-0.0243419111,
0.0402766727,
0.0310332775,
-0.0093852561,
0.0150722126,
-0.0173360258,
0.0253317915,
0.0786551684,
-0.0017738501,
-0.0154122645,
0.0005544073,
0.0177047886,
0.0386937186,
-0.037137609,
-0.0508680269,
0.0513507724,
0.03735663,
0.0136765763,
-0.0505031124,
0.0126044098,
0.0037753761,
0.0259585455,
0.0126102474,
-0.0296876766,
-0.0677593425,
-0.0010589896,
-0.122548908,
-0.0754720718,
-0.0037906815,
-0.0051801591,
0.0612509064,
0.004638819,
-0.018741671,
0.0043680742,
-0.0493935123,
-0.0025767402,
0.0273379032,
-0.0445052311,
0.0182857476,
-0.0337196216,
0.1172832549,
0.0017280784,
-0.007722469,
-0.0397613347,
-0.008640999,
-0.0116508231,
-0.0087053441,
-0.008953427,
-0.0514726005,
-0.0193840507,
-0.0127460547,
0.0009404193,
-0.0128476908,
-0.0578315556,
0.0244933255,
-0.0308950394,
0.0492392108,
0.042268265,
-0.0140395481,
-0.0127847791,
0.0004516033,
0.0100610992,
0.0540378727,
0.009353485,
-0.0186821111,
-0.0646571666,
-0.068038702,
0.0172196869,
0.0182644166,
-0.0341074504,
0.0118300328,
-0.0288055576,
-0.0182999372,
0.0017707478,
-0.0066189915,
-0.0005944581,
-0.0201387312,
-0.0603672452,
0.0275556613,
0.0002372229,
-0.0145897362,
0.0358839221,
-0.0247345641,
0.0368620045,
0.0422780029,
-0.0286324974,
0.0018242524,
0.072251156,
0.0117114261,
-0.0025168553,
0.0295183826,
0.0160646997,
-0.0427030064,
0.0158975758,
0.0305202492,
0.0209457148,
-0.0341348723,
0.0595058128,
-0.0308937561,
0.0072707874,
-0.0054961974,
0.0252567641,
-0.0172657259,
0.0293727592,
-0.0031869644,
-0.0578520149,
0.0172061361,
-0.0218850859,
-0.017730318,
0.0652932003,
0.0017993503,
-0.0582438745,
0.0400949307,
0.0414805785,
-0.023783749,
-0.05057282,
-0.0483481996,
0.0124715716,
-0.0145345125,
-0.0219257623,
-0.0354543626,
0.0596661754,
-0.0611065999,
-0.0265976861,
0.0815998092,
0.0422110632,
0.0222711004,
0.0142643452,
-0.0067354115,
0.0276556183,
0.0343883485,
-0.0222604722,
-0.0267535504,
0.0467906184,
-0.0220407993,
-0.0076097851,
-0.0001038957,
0.0154443765,
0.0237245113,
-0.0728012472,
-0.0031410023,
0.0229530819,
-0.0023596645,
0.055447977,
0.0379099064,
-0.0409618989,
0.0137014799,
-0.0438831635,
0.0035846424,
0.0560835563,
0.0405338928,
0.0464275628,
-0.0055081495,
0.0177052543,
-0.0493036956,
-0.0051387837,
0.0295587406,
-0.0083305575,
-0.0149565144,
0.0175769813,
0.0151418615,
-0.0561048239,
-0.0349871069,
0.0105190855,
0.0289235339,
-0.0348689333,
-0.0054461784,
-0.0076730754,
-0.0254003629,
0.0050200648,
-0.0088819629,
0.006501724,
-0.0030667575,
-0.0233693272,
-0.0223906673,
-0.0486661717,
-0.0063541494,
-0.0030899046,
0.0024567132,
0.0464822426,
-0.0117609212,
0.0448364615,
-0.0429596081,
-0.0052407691,
0.0093684969,
-0.0239258576,
0.026454458,
0.0205242019,
-0.0508739017,
0.0610959753,
0.0473449826,
-0.0283081308,
0.0541945621,
-0.0320413969,
-0.0386402421,
-0.0431477539,
-0.0170480665,
-0.0042203804,
0.0150316823,
0.0003377775,
0.0079254936,
-0.0067836484,
-0.0086034201,
-0.0279084388,
-0.0062551708,
0.0021661024,
0.0519005172,
0.0052733887,
0.0167626776,
-0.0352049805,
-0.0146831935,
-0.0218394957,
0.0235159528,
0.0827543437,
-0.0394640118,
-0.0291594509,
-0.0061316113,
-0.0107729621,
-0.0126623176,
-0.0024820499,
0.039806366,
0.0077379518,
0.0020166701,
0.0522435941,
0.0491962731,
0.0154057797,
0.0568922311,
-0.0232329648,
-0.0037910352,
0.0030600599,
0.0167045444,
-0.0005609783,
0.0215095691,
-0.0196475182,
-0.0279674195,
0.0476255678,
0.0569091029,
0.0000602761,
-0.0019822149,
-0.0728242099,
-0.0203368198,
-0.0382460393,
0.0114491666,
-0.0849433914,
-0.0146574052,
-0.0003962627,
0.0761177987,
0.0317097679,
-0.0259895716,
0.0403247438,
0.0366313234,
-0.0243186224,
-0.0338058658,
-0.0335197151,
-0.0610171743,
0.028367117,
-0.0527719148,
-0.0007454767,
0.0112220999,
-0.0060836957,
0.0241154358,
-0.0232988503,
0.0117644537,
-0.0137685426,
0.0438929312,
-0.0322666205,
0.0539681166,
0.0157501455,
0.0163179915,
0.0219277088,
-0.0737506151,
0.0081258183,
-0.0007955279,
0.0459470451,
0.0087559829,
-0.0545277596,
0.0339285769,
-0.0123284925,
-0.025737498,
0.0154931471,
-0.0398809724,
0.0483944193,
0.017972067,
0.0327069424,
-0.0888620839,
-0.0358684883,
-0.0479933955,
0.0377825312,
-0.0032423281,
0.0598840863,
0.0126334382,
0.006018843,
0.0153358066,
-0.0261769835,
0.0018431759,
0.009305588,
0.0228416175,
-0.0263277628,
-0.0205127876,
0.0149071347,
0.0395186022,
0.0108170742,
0.0286183488,
0.015351858,
0.0195202511,
-0.0098232394,
-0.0102771418,
0.0226713568,
-0.0449661165,
0.0145109966,
-0.0459643118,
0.0061789071,
0.0179693475,
-0.0285983458,
-0.0173260942,
-0.0656306818,
0.0242975745,
-0.0280586742,
-0.0530986153,
0.0012528553,
-0.068738848,
-0.0162930097,
-0.046397239,
-0.0561336838,
0.01919402,
-0.0128897717,
0.0311425161,
-0.0004191663,
-0.0783182755,
-0.0054647047,
-0.0081344359,
0.0146557121,
-0.0341313295,
-0.0498553552,
-0.0062179719,
-0.0580007434,
0.0383878872,
-0.0348680727,
-0.0018925274,
0.0058721169,
-0.0244973712,
0.0577190593,
-0.0239465274,
-0.0187514685,
0.0139390556,
0.0272406749,
-0.0156527162,
0.0205551591,
0.000385637,
-0.0413711444,
-0.0149440477,
-0.0671880096,
0.0078935716,
0.0508893654,
0.0010018589,
0.0270822905,
-0.0093610277,
-0.0480769761,
0.0260757171,
-0.0291862823,
0.016320426,
-0.0302508548,
0.0084963748,
-0.0025928516,
-0.0616861135,
-0.0864679217,
-0.0480721109,
-0.059327174,
-0.031760361,
0.0481726415,
-0.0178396162,
0.0489233397,
0.0251756404,
0.0342317857,
-0.0116135692,
0.0180635452,
0.0239174105,
-0.0195197444,
-0.0256147645,
0.0017421847,
0.0581462607,
0.0270078368,
-0.0828498676,
0.038659282,
-0.0143970111,
-0.0434214026,
0.0265125465,
-0.0426529907,
0.0219131,
-0.0459749885,
-0.0187946074,
0.0419936515,
-0.0172282029,
0.0512720197,
-0.0476602428,
-0.0116540734,
0.032683,
0.006920842,
0.0110351294,
-0.0123185115,
-0.0232270006,
0.0648261979,
-0.0464779623,
-0.0066932933,
-0.0591597222,
-0.0163717605,
-0.0375586152,
0.0135912066,
0.0451891683,
0.0225252397,
-0.0397503786,
-0.03837277,
-0.0307347756,
0.0453561731,
0.0170531813,
0.0101989591,
-0.0491014086,
0.0119716777,
-0.0268227626,
-0.0477904081,
0.0338825658,
-0.0125616584,
0.0017048179,
0.0101690618,
-0.0011888038,
-0.0080126403,
0.0664793774,
0.0091029312,
-0.0219367333,
0.0115237199,
-0.0204312764,
0.0507523976,
-0.0258688852,
0.0031375003,
-0.0039404687,
0.0230419673,
0.0231797285,
0.0398422517,
-0.0665767044,
-0.0506983399,
0.0322487801,
0.0013796167,
0.0308570787,
-0.0349510238,
0.0310831703,
0.0051289718,
-0.0531204417,
0.0265333559,
0.0073025711,
0.0395417772,
0.0051802481,
-0.030710062,
0.0442373902,
-0.0069987359,
-0.0582236387,
0.0118515752,
0.0590149388,
0.056654986,
0.0095780576,
-0.0569597445,
-0.0142775308,
-0.0421367288,
0.0003801731,
0.0559895821,
0.0044057383,
-0.0108979866,
0.0192693602,
-0.0690971687,
0.0221646093,
0.042032171,
-0.0191688333,
0.0216598604,
0.0308974218,
0.0324739516,
0.0612334311,
0.017118033,
0.0549398996,
-0.0011687007,
0.0087441402,
-0.0297059081,
-0.0299614295,
-0.0726982281,
-5.676106266e-33,
-0.0256456099,
-0.0229818169,
-0.0258251894,
-0.0013337515,
0.0479583032,
0.0060180034,
-0.0062311934,
0.0269316006,
0.0224937554,
-0.0073066503,
0.0470427163,
0.0592591949,
0.0112099843,
-0.0276436303,
0.0440686047,
-0.0152022839,
0.0146119837,
-0.0569030382,
0.0121158436,
-0.0099426601,
0.0075894902,
0.0590800457,
0.039997559,
-0.0485169031,
0.0483554415,
-0.0171978306,
-0.0564752668,
-0.0776723623,
0.0872566327,
0.0209287535,
0.0232415777,
0.029105369,
0.0445600711,
-0.0813779682,
0.0144604146,
0.0343992338,
0.0214650296,
-0.0543238968,
0.0239356644,
0.0065214471,
0.0460935198,
0.0079811485,
0.0288486183,
0.0367296413,
-0.0046090162,
0.0343268737,
0.0644112155,
0.0220753849,
-0.0026591271,
-0.0285239741,
-0.0581781305,
0.0269043706,
0.0089711118,
0.0831016004,
0.0302848108,
0.0887013003,
0.0003776793,
0.069488734,
0.0119850142,
0.0391283333,
-0.0062922654,
0.0167278498,
-0.0195177589,
-0.0507703573,
-0.0150656272,
0.0195672102,
-0.0290940534,
0.0646231249,
0.0354186818,
0.0093826531,
0.007878785,
0.0356002599,
0.0125912819,
0.0349012129,
0.0275014099,
-0.0276448391,
-0.0600131452,
0.0313300416,
-0.0274181981,
-0.0391509496,
0.0329865925,
0.021644013,
-0.0083502196,
-0.030898463,
-0.0023226426,
0.0216174312,
-0.0111440457,
0.0078983484,
0.0197182596,
-0.0037454241,
0.0088155195,
0.0554936863,
0.0048495983,
-0.0193759669,
-0.1061698422,
-0.0262064151,
-0.0145572117,
0.0376419201,
-0.0244796127,
-0.0150696058,
-0.0075795986,
-0.0416162796,
0.016487306,
0.0357262306,
0.0081329783,
-0.0650162101,
-0.0043642861,
-0.0182227511,
-0.0451428592,
-0.0161851514,
0.0392979681,
-0.0174805634,
0.039173983,
-0.0329549313,
-0.0028075997,
-0.0093635125,
0.0021781859,
0.0228658151,
0.006940126,
0.0081576295,
0.0178804453,
-0.0894182622,
-0.0240052193,
0.048948247,
-0.00068213,
0.0082415575,
0.0295041371,
0.0395708494,
0.0515455566,
-0.0010288148,
-0.0208363738,
0.0575320944,
2.595e-7,
0.0646992698,
0.0755972043,
-0.0475571044,
-0.010222422,
0.0392825268,
0.0552400388,
-0.0666590035,
0.0327882953,
-0.0035124382,
-0.025697073,
0.0253566299,
-0.0132313296,
0.000589486,
0.03799944,
-0.0379647985,
-0.0659022853,
-0.0527935624,
0.0440903902,
-0.1004471481,
0.048271805,
0.0041304585,
-0.0007145104,
0.0172797777,
-0.0105137378,
-0.0557535663,
-0.0009632051,
0.0424428992,
-0.0686298162,
-0.0451625623,
0.0020425417,
0.02597069,
0.0210189819,
-0.0383264124,
0.0256250147,
-0.0222311225,
-0.0272506792,
0.0583826527,
0.00507939,
0.0078964196,
0.0731176287,
0.0392267108,
-0.0163558051,
-0.0712423474,
-0.0137007013,
0.0059859599,
-0.0482121967,
-0.0186555181,
-0.0167577788,
-0.0462983139,
0.0505316854,
0.0312362649,
0.0369346179,
-0.0058600027,
0.0344752856,
-0.0032659401,
0.0089388797,
0.0404253267,
-0.0268823933,
-0.0260970797,
0.097884126,
-0.0458932258,
0.0373721309,
-0.0165998489,
0.0240389779,
0.0107230786,
-0.0556149893,
0.0156973451,
1.877912378e-34,
0.0805969015,
-0.0564838499,
-0.0654736459,
0.0113477595,
0.0450078547,
0.0082646077,
-0.0877064019,
0.0248515513,
-0.0282315612,
-0.0406916775,
0.0277184416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06025v2 | ChiMed-GPT: A Chinese Medical Large Language Model with Full Training Regime and Better Alignment to Human Preferences | 2023-11-10T12:25:32 | 2023-11-23T10:19:47 | Yuanhe Tian, Ruyi Gan, Yan Song, Jiaxing Zhang, Yongdong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, the increasing demand for superior medical services has highlighted
the discrepancies in the medical infrastructure. With big data, especially
texts, forming the foundation of medical services, there is an exigent need for
effective natural language processing (NLP) solutions tailored to the
healthcare domain. Conventional approaches leveraging pre-trained models
present promising results in this domain and current large language models
(LLMs) offer advanced foundation for medical text processing. However, most
medical LLMs are trained only with supervised fine-tuning (SFT), even though it
efficiently empowers LLMs to understand and respond to medical instructions but
is ineffective in learning domain knowledge and aligning with human preference.
Another engineering barrier that prevents current medical LLM from better text
processing ability is their restricted context length (e.g., 2,048 tokens),
making it hard for the LLMs to process long context, which is frequently
required in the medical domain. In this work, we propose ChiMed-GPT, a new
benchmark LLM designed explicitly for Chinese medical domain, with enlarged
context length to 4,096 tokens and undergoes a comprehensive training regime
with pre-training, SFT, and RLHF. Evaluations on real-world tasks including
information extraction, question answering, and dialogue generation demonstrate
ChiMed-GPT's superior performance over general domain LLMs. Furthermore, we
analyze possible biases through prompting ChiMed-GPT to perform attitude scales
regarding discrimination of patients, so as to contribute to further
responsible development of LLMs in the medical domain. The code and model are
released at https://github.com/synlp/ChiMed-GPT. | [
0.0730357617,
0.0477302112,
0.0155411614,
0.0085643018,
-0.021592265,
0.0245950501,
-0.0006379319,
0.0134959416,
0.0235118922,
-0.0321873687,
-0.052713532,
-0.0676185787,
-0.0096149389,
0.0388528332,
0.014078537,
-0.0328048989,
0.0506792851,
0.0310937259,
0.0231770109,
-0.0058146939,
0.010624378,
0.0154694449,
-0.0223576613,
0.0430190116,
0.0224767979,
-0.002742928,
0.0317293108,
-0.001709361,
0.0338889025,
-0.0689905137,
0.0294828918,
0.0431223214,
-0.0092739528,
0.0035533924,
0.0000019347,
-0.0580435395,
-0.01769506,
0.0077141016,
-0.0303935148,
-0.0081218472,
0.031667158,
-0.0353339091,
-0.0152223315,
0.0282634981,
-0.0365261286,
-0.0371906608,
0.0112250997,
0.1011754945,
0.0498579666,
0.0930915475,
-0.0114371553,
-0.0258217081,
0.0261104982,
-0.0495345443,
0.012737141,
-0.0679628775,
0.0453084484,
-0.0202500466,
0.0179606415,
0.0006499446,
-0.0025332796,
-0.0014654638,
-0.0040314058,
0.0717671141,
0.004984729,
0.0475714132,
-0.0368805192,
-0.002058493,
-0.0117738312,
0.0995597318,
0.0013288356,
0.0126939164,
0.0245686602,
-0.0066945697,
-0.0285974927,
-0.053601563,
-0.0280068386,
0.0001449278,
-0.0033636098,
0.0245058052,
-0.0019931577,
-0.0228498299,
0.0344404317,
0.0297370777,
-0.0375453234,
0.0051612728,
0.0066720811,
-0.0370528474,
0.0047901468,
-0.0227556936,
-0.036582578,
-0.0312996954,
0.041273687,
0.0477969721,
-0.0685602203,
0.0107112909,
-0.013350931,
0.0101672998,
0.0726362392,
-0.0297753066,
-0.0405040681,
0.029237859,
-0.0105933808,
0.0497383736,
-0.015317874,
0.0195356328,
-0.0456360169,
0.00130331,
-0.0544541553,
0.0001296353,
-0.0359755903,
-0.0205748919,
-0.0260455143,
0.0273831896,
-0.0344112031,
-0.0368444622,
-0.0847203285,
-0.0071652387,
0.0138862804,
0.0072846119,
0.020747276,
0.0356852263,
-0.031171944,
-0.0274265017,
-0.0298985187,
0.0377123207,
-0.0274930224,
0.0228243414,
-0.01970114,
-0.0299571268,
-0.002280107,
0.0168226194,
0.0180265214,
-0.0278577209,
0.0407298803,
0.0591715276,
0.0104239816,
-0.0224462021,
-0.0142678656,
-0.0142962039,
-0.0362656936,
-0.0516563579,
-0.0116309756,
-0.0555367023,
0.0154587543,
0.0060421275,
0.0290097613,
-0.027991062,
0.0209778659,
0.0246518217,
-0.0545525663,
0.0628267974,
-0.0144241164,
0.0021421779,
0.0015074473,
0.0277913772,
0.0278149191,
0.0368606411,
0.0223903041,
-0.0308611058,
0.0117565067,
-0.0287609249,
-0.0224823896,
0.0151701253,
0.0017159461,
-0.0484231934,
0.0061045559,
0.038979467,
0.0187446885,
0.0747939646,
-0.0263745673,
0.0862137005,
-0.0199707616,
-0.0142339421,
0.0331685506,
0.0574991554,
0.0096903099,
0.012165023,
-0.0047745234,
0.0017911271,
-0.0101464354,
-0.0092650531,
-0.0300139654,
-0.0006954997,
0.0082197338,
0.0256031416,
0.0026951588,
0.014134842,
-0.032523293,
-0.0311960764,
-0.0278658941,
-0.0216118526,
-0.0172160659,
-0.0004808775,
0.0392170064,
-0.0037987183,
-0.0430636518,
0.0464200452,
0.0556965731,
-0.0159545969,
0.0037872742,
-0.0633622259,
-0.0004608067,
0.0849609673,
0.0562541559,
-0.0686983243,
-0.0201930534,
-0.0258811135,
-0.0034471415,
0.0365920179,
0.0459819399,
-0.0088884188,
-0.0137989428,
-0.0664990023,
0.0052810586,
0.0512816049,
0.0072418596,
-0.0293185692,
0.034519542,
0.0488110669,
0.0065279058,
-0.0073937979,
-0.0100868335,
0.0405910984,
-0.0332789384,
-0.049950745,
0.0134870708,
-0.0052692159,
0.0500764325,
0.0241732989,
-0.0288658347,
0.0313377716,
0.0231983587,
-0.0268114582,
-0.0233233497,
-0.0187133346,
-0.0964166448,
-0.04789076,
0.0230863895,
0.0010659024,
-0.0183046497,
0.0009217683,
-0.0513728485,
-0.0306892991,
-0.0530273505,
-0.0078902571,
0.0109805278,
-0.0378466845,
0.027303068,
0.0195684116,
-0.0012938513,
-0.0735257715,
0.0349377245,
0.0075981664,
0.0103364047,
0.005181829,
0.0198618025,
0.0041189776,
-0.031989418,
-0.0527801737,
0.0388249643,
-0.0003874871,
0.0131383725,
-0.0130658615,
0.026505176,
-0.0466635004,
-0.050995212,
-0.130797103,
0.0333020315,
-0.0136948787,
0.004850131,
0.0161630455,
0.0283945519,
-0.0178422965,
-0.0088995378,
-0.0551431924,
-0.0003209127,
0.0349146016,
0.0154302595,
0.0337703973,
0.0120568285,
0.0031492366,
-0.0149937384,
0.0147571871,
-0.0293202642,
-0.014657326,
-0.0075578126,
0.0046336446,
-0.0240206625,
-0.0066386769,
-0.0229073726,
-0.0154000437,
-0.0018713267,
-0.0398143306,
0.0027493516,
-0.0147386193,
0.0339102671,
0.0580607839,
0.0279341489,
0.0101481592,
-0.007048761,
0.0349597931,
-0.0190870985,
0.0249998886,
-0.0494108908,
-0.0168293864,
-0.0324757136,
0.0026150949,
-0.0025039355,
0.0915458873,
0.0297077559,
0.0105144074,
-0.0355577469,
-0.0165908672,
-0.013416742,
0.0279418435,
-0.0349258967,
0.0431699716,
-0.0654317811,
0.014697019,
-0.0027360257,
-0.0281113293,
0.0825562179,
-0.0086435201,
0.0285732169,
-0.0969752669,
-0.0147315254,
-0.0589813329,
0.0119101238,
-0.0061115255,
0.0210210849,
0.026056014,
-0.0379265845,
-0.0154558914,
0.0337114818,
-0.0454411507,
-0.0774822235,
0.0461961292,
0.0059170988,
0.0094695771,
-0.0246173404,
-0.0601047873,
-0.0452090539,
-0.0503679626,
-0.0424271151,
0.0241896771,
0.0186412111,
0.0142312376,
-0.008546344,
0.0162174162,
-0.0108503513,
0.0804063827,
0.0007579798,
0.0175971165,
-0.0320604742,
0.0139848385,
0.0465195291,
0.0166568961,
0.0058394023,
-0.0047608735,
0.0359636918,
0.0651618987,
0.0423957184,
0.0110414289,
0.0140792113,
0.0023223979,
0.0022557343,
-0.0365237109,
0.0031801318,
0.0182911623,
0.0479918271,
-0.060945712,
0.0050682421,
0.1446764469,
0.0208225101,
-0.0543734096,
0.0248351842,
0.0326691978,
0.0096102692,
0.0045542317,
0.0031422633,
-0.0738327652,
-0.059479706,
-0.0019535935,
0.0255717784,
-0.0143045392,
-0.0139071848,
0.0261921044,
-0.0803557783,
0.0156329554,
0.0061939699,
-0.0284915455,
-0.0289798528,
-0.0192290135,
-0.001910629,
-0.0098640528,
0.0357729122,
0.0057333768,
-0.0285338741,
-0.0113848578,
0.0039384896,
-0.0297631789,
-0.086653091,
0.0575821884,
-0.0368117727,
0.0650950819,
0.0708628148,
0.0394836739,
0.0011133736,
0.0181412604,
0.0443025343,
0.003041883,
0.0074942536,
-0.0289036445,
0.05728909,
-0.0206535067,
-0.0185453538,
-0.0519415289,
0.0525667444,
-0.0617680065,
-0.0152630508,
0.0156151298,
0.0497141667,
-0.0081612533,
-0.0024458773,
-0.0132953795,
0.0352806002,
-0.000607531,
0.0867025033,
-0.0110749165,
-0.0363647081,
-0.0405397564,
0.0168603435,
0.0003270197,
-0.0050824243,
-0.033907935,
0.02220135,
-0.0049275388,
0.0186533574,
-0.0719242468,
-0.0284924861,
0.0317302793,
-0.0030448635,
-0.0070549101,
0.025582172,
0.0205198079,
0.0165820308,
-0.0412491187,
0.0349103995,
-0.0006673234,
0.0126225073,
-0.0965968445,
-0.0179846846,
0.0720774308,
-0.0355529934,
-0.0218185056,
-0.0118757589,
-0.0318597406,
-0.0318613574,
-0.0026477701,
0.0098631857,
0.012296428,
0.0321520157,
-0.0065896371,
-0.0159934405,
0.0135240592,
0.0567911267,
-0.0574200526,
-0.0151542127,
-0.0041731717,
0.0081632026,
-0.0202529766,
0.0229903515,
0.0095763151,
0.031027507,
0.0474238507,
0.045853395,
-0.0078655398,
-0.0250834711,
0.0114350924,
0.0351231173,
0.0365467668,
-0.0021901212,
0.007484518,
-0.0409574807,
0.0414518751,
0.0001060835,
0.0049249269,
-0.0186287463,
-0.0363551751,
0.0473882779,
-0.0214727968,
-0.0384534225,
0.0140159782,
-0.0181234442,
-0.0167202447,
-0.0431683548,
0.0388120003,
-0.0154366605,
-0.0072994861,
0.0447797179,
-0.0310249738,
-0.0219315235,
0.0158990435,
0.0098406123,
0.038792301,
-0.0084520336,
0.1003092974,
0.0068107625,
0.0197016168,
0.0043569319,
0.0357427932,
-0.0504097119,
-0.0383426584,
-0.0266861692,
0.0190502834,
0.0422950275,
-0.0196140651,
0.0061874888,
-0.0120861223,
-0.0049079182,
-0.0405909643,
0.0171503201,
-0.0480222069,
0.0275934022,
0.037247315,
0.0243510567,
-0.0277958773,
-0.0032070628,
0.0941119343,
0.0183320716,
0.0526452847,
0.0209113397,
-0.0160152148,
-0.03814831,
-0.0196647961,
0.0099794585,
0.0226347782,
-0.0654017329,
0.0332191288,
-0.042268645,
-0.0561707802,
-0.0028442652,
-0.0251125786,
-0.023974102,
-0.0419826582,
0.0473527424,
0.0386791006,
-0.0062176748,
-0.0180984735,
-0.0229463819,
0.0275301915,
-0.0120387478,
-0.0015414081,
0.0095666815,
-6.387371081e-33,
-0.0029777226,
-0.0045476682,
0.0306315292,
-0.0212099161,
-0.025430765,
0.0182157177,
-0.0219820309,
-0.014277257,
-0.0324200578,
-0.0027209027,
-0.029705761,
0.0031399638,
0.0144014033,
0.0620621182,
-0.0234375019,
-0.0359990224,
0.0456368662,
-0.001573634,
-0.0150491055,
0.0487599559,
-0.0014094409,
0.0618132018,
0.0270067882,
-0.0474397428,
-0.0228576642,
-0.0108341323,
0.031828884,
0.0275793746,
-0.0334146321,
0.0640687793,
-0.0455226526,
0.0370498747,
0.0675023571,
-0.020686917,
-0.0047896709,
0.0423631445,
-0.1145195439,
0.0040307026,
0.0008513008,
0.0004346072,
0.0035023403,
-0.0253974032,
0.0449714586,
-0.0178292934,
-0.026120726,
-0.0065474701,
0.00483581,
-0.042164851,
-0.0032210434,
-0.0228832923,
-0.0401086099,
0.0548178591,
0.0143465102,
0.0101891709,
-0.0409107581,
-0.0116958758,
-0.0386361443,
0.0983294919,
-0.0434455499,
-0.0287432931,
0.0261246115,
0.024302084,
-0.0096789543,
-0.0084045818,
0.0023581525,
0.0536694303,
0.030850647,
0.001636531,
-0.0303494241,
0.0037208099,
-0.0217746198,
0.0300925728,
0.0219959281,
0.0271052998,
0.0306223147,
-0.0433023386,
-0.0997380316,
0.0091897277,
-0.0264503304,
0.0307976715,
0.057328511,
0.0040884884,
-0.0436939709,
-0.0065612369,
-0.0178389307,
0.0364611782,
-0.0296057984,
-0.0169027131,
0.0447538979,
0.0355619751,
-0.0055960626,
0.0161807723,
0.0216574036,
-0.0327224061,
0.0244380385,
0.0017352713,
0.019988643,
-0.0080193682,
-0.0500306934,
0.0107952524,
-0.0967046693,
-0.0389060564,
0.0142872008,
-0.0205493532,
0.0065354612,
0.0110273613,
0.0285901446,
-0.0451749042,
-0.0731102973,
-0.003551529,
0.0188072305,
0.0006955393,
-0.0065296772,
0.0637138039,
0.0282271225,
0.0130968876,
0.0095889065,
0.0864876732,
-0.0057592061,
-0.0232238155,
-0.0754875168,
-0.0563842095,
-0.006439256,
0.0110982861,
-0.0345479362,
0.0197208021,
-0.0179952681,
0.0330853797,
0.0155646717,
-0.0466782339,
-0.0072131483,
0.0051452294,
2.721e-7,
0.0572778285,
0.0399497822,
0.0178779252,
-0.0156532414,
0.0313220248,
0.034154173,
0.0051353672,
0.030562019,
0.0063842265,
0.0032092738,
0.0302811265,
0.0241254494,
0.0443235338,
0.0060600298,
-0.099492155,
0.013265593,
-0.0715940818,
-0.0187007543,
-0.036970932,
-0.0200866982,
0.0476750359,
0.1101514325,
-0.0577176474,
-0.0190456901,
0.0289254896,
-0.0239661988,
0.0462821871,
-0.0186092779,
-0.004081131,
0.0630780384,
-0.0483820774,
0.0226146597,
0.0152425254,
0.0184303019,
-0.021913467,
0.0249044262,
0.0066415137,
0.1387680471,
-0.0287233554,
-0.0012014547,
0.0214019455,
0.0162958354,
0.0139822522,
-0.0505430214,
0.0922930986,
-0.0732809752,
-0.0457660705,
-0.019774925,
-0.0001567484,
-0.0590028688,
0.0481452122,
-0.0319973081,
-0.0340589993,
0.0279380698,
0.0311190151,
0.0067746276,
-0.0344059542,
-0.0922483131,
-0.0168699529,
0.0219678506,
-0.0700101554,
-0.0455408916,
0.0114032524,
-0.0102217942,
0.0042130868,
-0.054507181,
0.0014378617,
2.556159991e-34,
0.0421042703,
-0.0155596593,
0.0044911802,
0.0300804246,
0.0422920696,
0.0056742048,
0.0127132107,
0.0197046064,
0.0226228889,
-0.0773326606,
-0.0154436389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05965v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05965v1 | Large Language Models are Zero Shot Hypothesis Proposers | 2023-11-10T10:03:49 | 2023-11-10T10:03:49 | Biqing Qi, Kaiyan Zhang, Haoxiang Li, Kai Tian, Sihang Zeng, Zhang-Ren Chen, Bowen Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Significant scientific discoveries have driven the progress of human
civilisation. The explosion of scientific literature and data has created
information barriers across disciplines that have slowed the pace of scientific
discovery. Large Language Models (LLMs) hold a wealth of global and
interdisciplinary knowledge that promises to break down these information
barriers and foster a new wave of scientific discovery. However, the potential
of LLMs for scientific discovery has not been formally explored. In this paper,
we start from investigating whether LLMs can propose scientific hypotheses. To
this end, we construct a dataset consist of background knowledge and hypothesis
pairs from biomedical literature. The dataset is divided into training, seen,
and unseen test sets based on the publication date to control visibility. We
subsequently evaluate the hypothesis generation capabilities of various
top-tier instructed models in zero-shot, few-shot, and fine-tuning settings,
including both closed and open-source LLMs. Additionally, we introduce an
LLM-based multi-agent cooperative framework with different role designs and
external tools to enhance the capabilities related to generating hypotheses. We
also design four metrics through a comprehensive review to evaluate the
generated hypotheses for both ChatGPT-based and human evaluations. Through
experiments and analyses, we arrive at the following findings: 1) LLMs
surprisingly generate untrained yet validated hypotheses from testing
literature. 2) Increasing uncertainty facilitates candidate generation,
potentially enhancing zero-shot hypothesis generation capabilities. These
findings strongly support the potential of LLMs as catalysts for new scientific
discoveries and guide further exploration. | [
0.0435245559,
0.029481912,
0.0025086198,
-0.0044675902,
-0.0465353467,
-0.0046929065,
0.0421470888,
0.0140240761,
-0.003545512,
-0.0368259847,
-0.0262172315,
-0.0428927764,
-0.0064193513,
0.0265152231,
0.0306934193,
-0.0178262349,
0.0350970589,
-0.0274309013,
0.0537213013,
-0.0190995634,
-0.0327549875,
-0.0246108864,
-0.0087444549,
0.0345880836,
0.0386459194,
-0.0122236833,
-0.0011797232,
-0.0359075554,
0.006852644,
-0.0752293095,
-0.0430968814,
0.0701568052,
0.032373786,
0.0960158259,
0.0000017597,
-0.0639690757,
-0.0107544437,
0.0348337926,
-0.0159325264,
0.0030618066,
0.0500309169,
-0.0121503016,
0.0110931816,
-0.0140713062,
-0.0348031111,
-0.0128918346,
0.0598544367,
-0.0342114121,
-0.0168483369,
0.0436522178,
0.0152753685,
0.003364895,
0.0202746764,
-0.0280793309,
0.0502963141,
0.0016458231,
0.0587785095,
0.0091979029,
0.055544246,
0.0586357042,
-0.0114722317,
0.0411214419,
0.0073208138,
-0.0051172576,
0.0230809264,
0.0675619543,
-0.0521783382,
-0.0474093482,
0.0201980006,
0.0536370836,
0.0008716469,
-0.0572064072,
-0.0037060697,
-0.0145167205,
-0.0311000496,
0.0598995984,
-0.0559071526,
0.0524558052,
-0.0149247414,
-0.0015618205,
0.0451721847,
-0.0122547513,
0.0500607602,
0.0344899297,
0.0034497946,
0.0974941775,
0.0092872707,
-0.0326266624,
-0.0117793297,
0.0143746119,
-0.019603394,
-0.0744921267,
-0.0158977397,
0.0090471646,
-0.0155452909,
0.0139985755,
0.038125854,
-0.0318072066,
0.0666332021,
-0.0305392593,
0.0380589925,
0.0027551616,
0.0116528682,
0.0472257361,
-0.0318995081,
-0.0051250393,
-0.0290239528,
0.0211375244,
-0.0128881326,
0.0060056555,
-0.1073068976,
-0.0391081572,
0.0043474538,
0.0117674479,
0.0159763135,
0.014681682,
-0.0053150174,
0.0185765326,
0.0186326019,
-0.0285317283,
-0.0425490066,
-0.0035897251,
-0.0499342382,
-0.0220958088,
-0.0437097698,
0.0265166257,
-0.0000506109,
0.046317365,
0.0004108374,
-0.0588363633,
-0.0317044221,
0.0160512812,
-0.0071147461,
0.0116318148,
0.028894335,
0.0314571261,
0.015696384,
-0.0237831697,
0.0235337578,
-0.0371232219,
0.0007362637,
-0.0707076788,
0.006968162,
-0.063771382,
0.0010747039,
0.0314634219,
-0.0038406763,
-0.0180004332,
0.0004579911,
-0.0196226072,
-0.0337431058,
0.0689034462,
-0.0645705611,
0.0111944992,
0.0421382152,
0.0125404745,
-0.0338335447,
0.0777178109,
0.0286060236,
0.0083055748,
0.0177494623,
0.0140879713,
0.0123798577,
-0.039641574,
0.0174703058,
0.0187208448,
0.0091542546,
0.0053561046,
0.0026481166,
0.0740499198,
-0.0392105654,
0.0369649716,
-0.0397734568,
-0.0115181729,
0.0630032122,
0.0871706083,
0.0115019539,
0.0228108931,
0.0579907037,
-0.0287867468,
0.007138575,
-0.0355998427,
-0.0002544889,
0.0322855376,
-0.0318750516,
0.0015350418,
0.0296264067,
0.0205023382,
-0.0266122986,
-0.0165609401,
-0.0272457805,
0.0145792384,
-0.0010144241,
-0.0359221995,
0.0716188103,
-0.0197700039,
-0.0134236058,
-0.0109206848,
0.0494998284,
-0.0280852765,
0.0027478037,
-0.0555308349,
0.0631514713,
0.0300303716,
0.0693005249,
-0.0344943441,
-0.0356884263,
-0.0008806357,
0.0307387169,
0.0544534326,
0.0368809551,
-0.0096569527,
-0.0192197524,
-0.0166714154,
-0.0385303199,
-0.0245041419,
0.0084095094,
-0.0024227435,
-0.0270728078,
0.0107542695,
-0.0212468747,
-0.014501608,
-0.0272796992,
0.0326076522,
-0.0601696968,
0.0288141835,
0.0108462693,
-0.045931112,
0.0469197333,
0.0076132743,
-0.0219618753,
0.0532530211,
0.0592010543,
-0.034240365,
-0.0644831061,
0.0208405666,
0.0395477451,
-0.0306800473,
0.0197481029,
-0.0608344525,
0.0141475294,
-0.0243946053,
0.0211147517,
-0.032796979,
0.0511661135,
-0.0015210079,
0.0110004926,
-0.0451740511,
0.007192004,
-0.0463917814,
0.0292904936,
-0.0237615425,
0.0627086759,
0.0128350351,
0.0319173262,
0.0369625911,
-0.0168836098,
0.026334174,
-0.0436266176,
-0.0245823115,
0.0289418846,
0.038461782,
-0.0109638721,
0.0542789698,
-0.0234976429,
-0.0029880679,
-0.0217056107,
-0.0828143284,
-0.0048524458,
0.0108812479,
0.0044369623,
-0.0064173904,
-0.0323186368,
0.0068987063,
0.0292904004,
-0.0164596997,
0.0259670243,
0.008608914,
0.0432869717,
0.0365663655,
0.0238451473,
-0.0318327881,
-0.036007233,
-0.004514107,
-0.039193701,
0.0643969402,
0.0729930252,
-0.0090219444,
-0.037618842,
0.0317900069,
-0.0515435711,
-0.0003726956,
-0.0210289583,
-0.015459084,
0.0655726045,
-0.0177923348,
-0.0299656186,
0.0331790075,
-0.0111094303,
0.0135685187,
0.0700063556,
0.0181121211,
-0.0371815041,
-0.0115572531,
-0.0646451041,
0.0027980965,
-0.0124049466,
-0.0116348844,
-0.0051489309,
0.048198536,
0.0025185435,
-0.0495155267,
-0.050648015,
0.03941416,
-0.0201163553,
-0.052946385,
-0.0098111341,
-0.0136615336,
0.0014367372,
0.0424918607,
-0.0198279042,
-0.0605695061,
0.0881768465,
-0.015593891,
-0.0112395855,
-0.0661572218,
0.0008606988,
-0.0447132885,
0.049830433,
0.0065493449,
0.0026475424,
0.0563461296,
0.0407970585,
-0.029371582,
-0.0046989853,
0.0159677695,
0.0096563222,
-0.0273169912,
-0.0584043413,
0.0294304416,
0.0010033011,
-0.0184330195,
-0.0037558319,
-0.0382804535,
-0.0300738644,
0.0533692129,
0.0306847468,
-0.0285545718,
-0.0685299486,
0.0170418192,
0.0512573346,
0.0122691225,
-0.0040895496,
-0.0111074336,
-0.0317288339,
-0.0533042811,
0.0391129144,
-0.0205368027,
0.0401912294,
-0.054731369,
0.0561445802,
0.0610662363,
-0.0067219161,
0.0349812172,
-0.0246695727,
-0.0058602523,
-0.0180181302,
-0.0098735075,
-0.0043265196,
-0.0082990322,
0.0290319286,
-0.0188458618,
0.0067539793,
0.0906774849,
0.0222292673,
-0.0708908439,
0.0186620913,
-0.0084160529,
-0.0072567672,
0.0168622974,
0.0038769012,
-0.0853362083,
0.0003767114,
-0.0252726357,
-0.0207147058,
-0.0415017419,
-0.0691032559,
-0.0166472215,
-0.0756604299,
0.0396228991,
0.0112698684,
-0.0272479579,
0.0436056703,
-0.0945959687,
-0.0025865445,
-0.0420695059,
-0.0224157218,
0.0256655514,
0.0163168553,
0.0256864224,
0.0201537963,
0.0073830513,
-0.0871184245,
0.0239477102,
-0.0470243767,
0.0580217913,
0.0430360623,
0.0228174627,
-0.0086902967,
0.0064933873,
-0.0398593247,
0.0039027482,
0.0344921462,
-0.0044624275,
0.0250023939,
0.0284787975,
0.012266132,
-0.0100960201,
0.0444413982,
-0.0590609759,
-0.0207752883,
0.0128968423,
0.1069179699,
-0.0359863862,
-0.0475776531,
-0.0240201764,
0.0175492726,
0.0101427659,
0.1063497514,
0.0025774105,
-0.0300164111,
-0.0187551342,
-0.0054112044,
0.0013526327,
0.0063419593,
-0.0363733619,
-0.0137087302,
0.0026593891,
-0.0046726773,
-0.0668734908,
-0.0181622915,
0.0518747903,
-0.0112531977,
0.0182958469,
0.0444877483,
-0.0044631572,
-0.0187639333,
-0.0299237352,
0.0266305786,
0.0001943403,
0.013092638,
-0.0373401493,
-0.0373192504,
0.0718085542,
-0.0272824448,
-0.0057002967,
0.022814557,
-0.0607804209,
-0.0898955166,
-0.0428971648,
0.0243845694,
0.0293443855,
-0.0122688627,
-0.0063900822,
-0.0882948115,
0.0498213917,
0.0543044284,
-0.0092453146,
0.0171444714,
-0.0274050273,
-0.0080839489,
0.0071432292,
0.0119497515,
-0.0012308848,
0.0173569154,
0.0258121844,
0.0214590244,
-0.0439135693,
-0.0423910767,
0.0184180774,
0.012101124,
0.0485431328,
-0.051112555,
-0.0181949101,
-0.0179501195,
-0.0249795113,
-0.0143477144,
0.002371551,
-0.0381171778,
0.0151096983,
0.0244451407,
-0.0030193345,
0.02643512,
0.0079160435,
-0.0403293669,
0.0544119403,
-0.0376764573,
0.0364281945,
-0.0089119542,
0.0232424382,
0.0250509847,
0.0079437504,
0.0058147535,
0.0033162825,
-0.0825730562,
0.0257844888,
-0.0003554592,
0.0377696753,
0.0295617804,
0.01379639,
-0.0303771887,
0.0122532332,
-0.1215798631,
-0.0479495563,
-0.0209834594,
0.0633635968,
0.0263663586,
0.0855242312,
0.0199335832,
-0.0610302798,
-0.0231551975,
-0.0301961619,
0.0373309292,
-0.0365270637,
-0.0089197727,
0.0445840023,
0.0329017155,
-0.0435836166,
-0.0138774374,
0.1009385064,
0.0422165692,
0.0668918565,
-0.0037578731,
-0.0313835964,
-0.0081807273,
-0.0085375477,
-0.0121586863,
-0.0020869519,
-0.0235141199,
0.0263500791,
-0.0748004019,
-0.0124369459,
0.0294198655,
0.0183768664,
0.0106721455,
0.0154153593,
0.0119164567,
0.0359705314,
-0.0245951079,
-0.0519043803,
-0.0321695134,
0.0024254306,
-0.0197526962,
-0.0254266709,
-0.0237286109,
-6.35593322e-33,
0.0118497415,
-0.010110761,
0.0324033797,
-0.0064210463,
0.0209164415,
0.0164502207,
-0.0604553819,
0.0178798195,
-0.006005499,
0.0542249121,
0.015853934,
-0.008239408,
-0.014013662,
-0.0247918423,
0.0269011445,
0.0221876055,
0.0235946048,
-0.0163029172,
-0.0218031779,
0.0157149173,
0.0520411618,
0.006855675,
0.0485431887,
-0.0343789868,
0.0026073854,
-0.0026723542,
-0.0057572033,
0.0208899248,
-0.0771405548,
0.0523047484,
-0.0284982044,
0.0149462465,
0.0086112227,
-0.0584199801,
-0.0269206986,
-0.0509932637,
0.0008191632,
-0.0052352534,
0.0145938946,
-0.0536963157,
-0.0045238752,
-0.0215129368,
-0.0010831103,
-0.0033841587,
-0.0425712056,
0.0086834803,
0.0259904042,
-0.0400739498,
-0.0254288353,
-0.0191790406,
-0.0357374363,
0.0277495235,
-0.01245612,
-0.0059722201,
0.0144243333,
-0.0106121516,
-0.0319312662,
0.0051186867,
-0.0072748866,
0.0804023817,
0.0510329045,
-0.0121948933,
0.0429901667,
0.0008501525,
0.0206213668,
0.070702292,
0.0430493206,
0.0402132347,
-0.0152978078,
-0.0087335492,
0.0372211486,
0.0439376943,
0.0462733582,
0.0687584653,
0.0066300267,
0.0473719724,
-0.0681099072,
0.0188320391,
0.0220960174,
-0.0071701659,
0.0433589593,
0.0627575815,
0.0003629193,
-0.0459659621,
-0.026375249,
-0.0202191826,
-0.0257926192,
-0.034474697,
-0.0072873714,
-0.017048493,
-0.0326050185,
0.0174347367,
0.0651816875,
-0.041705519,
-0.0134341829,
0.0261901896,
-0.0057076244,
0.0366528034,
0.0124599272,
-0.0030677088,
-0.126932472,
-0.0239231344,
0.0562898666,
0.0469129048,
0.0154167758,
0.003713961,
-0.0070790537,
0.0273863822,
0.0127636809,
-0.0022672473,
-0.0286859609,
-0.0426375121,
0.0560052544,
-0.020375343,
-0.0111288968,
0.0021469719,
0.00667754,
0.0186459143,
0.0409838557,
-0.0036544912,
-0.0101035601,
0.0616328977,
-0.0346921496,
0.0043078526,
-0.0155316088,
-0.0040054405,
-0.0297694784,
-0.0044446657,
0.0573697798,
-0.0478477515,
-0.0102606602,
0.0194556136,
2.713e-7,
0.0436545834,
0.0465937629,
-0.0071328259,
-0.0162430871,
0.0573331155,
0.0344157442,
-0.0355941281,
0.0029234365,
0.0107911257,
-0.0150483297,
0.0271888115,
0.0199012887,
0.012632492,
0.0352996066,
-0.0423604026,
-0.0295221712,
-0.0584255606,
-0.0314721353,
-0.0555423833,
-0.0303621683,
-0.0199412163,
0.035071969,
0.0211529266,
0.0023259041,
0.022703696,
-0.0450959913,
0.0733442754,
-0.024627028,
0.0101044336,
0.0737120882,
0.0024755432,
-0.0140199848,
0.0079562096,
0.0415444598,
0.0034120355,
-0.0022724175,
-0.0077031567,
0.0062773633,
-0.0112889316,
0.0141637567,
0.053471487,
-0.0011989624,
-0.0019325212,
-0.056840267,
0.0350973941,
-0.073070012,
-0.0701199621,
0.0099388817,
0.0131441187,
-0.0051771752,
0.0167953912,
-0.0370451026,
0.0220028237,
0.0063489173,
-0.0397659615,
0.0318618268,
-0.0393366329,
-0.0417172313,
-0.0268368553,
-0.0101865688,
-0.096659489,
-0.0707013458,
-0.0031045717,
-0.032852985,
-0.0130648455,
-0.0504048876,
0.0147689208,
2.593231685e-34,
0.0426719785,
-0.0015996645,
-0.0444353893,
-0.0019521659,
0.0215559099,
0.0009263603,
0.006798489,
0.0029568293,
0.0363353863,
-0.0961199701,
-0.0116528077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07594v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07594v2 | How to Bridge the Gap between Modalities: A Comprehensive Survey on Multimodal Large Language Model | 2023-11-10T09:51:24 | 2023-12-19T03:44:25 | Shezheng Song, Xiaopeng Li, Shasha Li, Shan Zhao, Jie Yu, Jun Ma, Xiaoguang Mao, Weimin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.MM | This review paper explores Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), which
integrate Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 to handle multimodal data
such as text and vision. MLLMs demonstrate capabilities like generating image
narratives and answering image-based questions, bridging the gap towards
real-world human-computer interactions and hinting at a potential pathway to
artificial general intelligence. However, MLLMs still face challenges in
processing the semantic gap in multimodality, which may lead to erroneous
generation, posing potential risks to society. Choosing the appropriate
modality alignment method is crucial, as improper methods might require more
parameters with limited performance improvement. This paper aims to explore
modality alignment methods for LLMs and their existing capabilities.
Implementing modality alignment allows LLMs to address environmental issues and
enhance accessibility. The study surveys existing modal alignment methods in
MLLMs into four groups: (1) Multimodal Converters that change data into
something LLMs can understand; (2) Multimodal Perceivers to improve how LLMs
perceive different types of data; (3) Tools Assistance for changing data into
one common format, usually text; and (4) Data-Driven methods that teach LLMs to
understand specific types of data in a dataset. This field is still in a phase
of exploration and experimentation, and we will organize and update various
existing research methods for multimodal information alignment. | [
0.0009031689,
0.0642514676,
-0.0215716027,
0.0407079495,
-0.0488355942,
-0.0062954603,
0.0247435588,
-0.0205147769,
-0.0252856445,
-0.0666487068,
-0.0424250364,
-0.0375614278,
0.0154541442,
0.0217674077,
0.0202746633,
-0.084585838,
0.0279396549,
-0.0288687777,
-0.0402060896,
0.0102646826,
0.0241300352,
0.0318471864,
-0.022813132,
0.0402570926,
-0.036539495,
-0.0414819084,
-0.0344128199,
0.0208733883,
0.0207987186,
-0.0242378116,
-0.0389602855,
0.0143887699,
0.0660550371,
0.0442316495,
0.000002007,
-0.063777335,
-0.0041414178,
0.0143695222,
0.0446794406,
-0.0368760265,
0.0527760908,
-0.0480982028,
0.0109723313,
-0.0149554331,
-0.0307402834,
-0.0276867766,
0.0990176573,
0.0300308596,
0.0552445687,
0.0174871348,
-0.0228091814,
-0.0519474484,
0.0327092521,
0.0348214246,
0.0343262069,
-0.0046277475,
-0.0041000219,
0.0475823395,
0.0247408208,
-0.0054509947,
-0.0449403189,
0.0577214435,
-0.0145929875,
0.0089858677,
-0.0060914503,
0.0306183565,
0.0384096839,
-0.0454012305,
-0.0500800312,
0.078403078,
0.019976981,
-0.0188759658,
-0.0228297673,
0.0056364005,
0.0099560441,
0.0599762462,
-0.0499155633,
0.0353637822,
-0.018166637,
0.0306384563,
-0.0429541655,
-0.0338701308,
0.022293251,
0.0210919566,
0.0040323664,
0.0110130925,
0.0321808346,
-0.0107057951,
-0.0440565422,
-0.0241550766,
0.0121760778,
-0.0337204263,
0.0084789526,
0.0554587431,
0.0051875338,
0.0248426162,
-0.077362299,
-0.019187687,
0.0075367279,
-0.0308564305,
0.035434179,
0.0435798056,
-0.052279532,
0.0312083662,
0.0144308396,
0.0131624825,
-0.0406654701,
0.0166017599,
-0.0234131664,
-0.0166310333,
-0.0434561893,
-0.0384425782,
-0.0137850614,
-0.0293156318,
-0.0672187507,
-0.0319659561,
-0.0131055135,
0.0658513233,
0.0033842837,
0.0107746692,
-0.0405123122,
-0.0240896661,
-0.0315667689,
-0.0200441498,
-0.0321602076,
0.0825287327,
0.0073509929,
0.0295680147,
-0.0201861952,
-0.0476143099,
0.0466830917,
0.030906843,
0.0075576948,
-0.0368984416,
-0.0288409609,
0.1144642532,
-0.0308142267,
0.0011040618,
-0.0414813273,
-0.0429703258,
-0.019028604,
-0.0333670415,
0.0054721315,
-0.0561918803,
0.0252168104,
0.0189532042,
-0.0099219084,
-0.0122630987,
0.0025214644,
0.0229345243,
-0.0037276531,
0.1138774157,
-0.0330276676,
0.0335159674,
0.067030713,
0.00502293,
0.0277366284,
0.0583969653,
0.057142403,
-0.0041491226,
0.0186899826,
-0.0388781466,
-0.0049364017,
0.0433119573,
-0.0387731269,
-0.0197330918,
-0.0357032008,
-0.0086276764,
0.0154808396,
0.061015971,
0.0260332897,
0.0427436121,
-0.0123758726,
0.0069559906,
0.1153706685,
0.0194798019,
0.0448490344,
0.0088774348,
0.0164125245,
-0.0111211827,
-0.0056673349,
0.0077218176,
-0.0461179316,
0.0444132537,
-0.0463448279,
0.0345132872,
-0.0069560874,
0.0808510855,
-0.0047775945,
-0.0135192694,
-0.0080206962,
-0.008423374,
0.0386246853,
-0.0089336764,
0.0388933904,
-0.039792113,
-0.0233691633,
0.0047172341,
-0.0079654604,
-0.0600549653,
0.0191437174,
-0.0354796275,
0.0030624585,
0.0465361699,
0.0229677558,
-0.0143308677,
-0.0428310707,
-0.0259703416,
0.0145055838,
0.0475783497,
0.0035911989,
0.0012206223,
-0.0051061716,
-0.0681037158,
-0.0341012441,
-0.0091670211,
-0.0228486974,
0.0020405198,
-0.0638942048,
0.0035440084,
0.0078847231,
-0.0340133496,
0.0122959241,
0.031852819,
0.0267827585,
0.015282236,
-0.0705112442,
0.0367407091,
0.0031077564,
0.0138627663,
-0.0022172187,
0.0022360096,
0.002830853,
-0.0005710732,
0.0262551066,
0.0653439164,
-0.0394916236,
0.0351766795,
0.0612482503,
-0.0949784592,
0.0137604112,
0.0188191421,
-0.0005118366,
-0.0407710373,
-0.0057078805,
-0.0272709168,
0.0142588876,
-0.030658735,
0.0111337258,
0.0124072703,
-0.0002364877,
-0.0323961638,
0.0517955385,
0.0134506477,
-0.0205916017,
0.0037154886,
0.0165677704,
0.0158848278,
-0.0000094005,
-0.0083203251,
0.0522675402,
0.0040975707,
0.0409544259,
0.0199398641,
-0.0227542836,
-0.0493346043,
-0.0135273999,
-0.1235066503,
-0.0234447718,
0.0198459309,
0.0137058962,
0.0352000631,
0.0044153472,
-0.0134244058,
-0.0145165455,
-0.0351611562,
0.05397854,
0.0185895003,
0.0083131716,
0.0332934186,
0.0021870236,
0.0080703162,
-0.0083627673,
0.0146418065,
-0.0403810181,
0.0504628196,
0.0301945303,
-0.0367104299,
-0.0664666221,
-0.0263606273,
-0.0369935781,
0.0259010904,
0.0075696916,
-0.0079647275,
0.0344285071,
0.00859854,
0.071124956,
0.0263921805,
0.0209169742,
0.035865169,
0.0540373437,
-0.0390503593,
-0.0449903905,
0.0104936054,
0.0321363471,
-0.0250579007,
-0.0352484249,
-0.0315579176,
-0.0162001979,
0.0463140793,
0.0099205496,
0.0247384012,
-0.0270670969,
0.0427470729,
0.011396504,
-0.0277068857,
-0.0099849096,
-0.0074624922,
-0.0239497721,
0.0194068663,
-0.0217341445,
-0.061203178,
0.019258054,
-0.0421929471,
-0.0044724494,
0.0032089504,
0.0089428695,
-0.0147453388,
0.0730030164,
-0.0005847737,
0.0540659875,
0.0038794586,
-0.0127098346,
-0.0630721003,
-0.003226202,
0.0328848548,
-0.0205754451,
0.0761458874,
-0.0907223821,
0.0113339871,
-0.0345736109,
-0.0144723086,
-0.0140576838,
-0.0018715071,
-0.0163318254,
-0.0154577419,
-0.0317824669,
0.0064028222,
-0.044021301,
0.0390090942,
0.0652281716,
0.0009477084,
0.0182571057,
-0.0219307058,
-0.0471576452,
0.0490558781,
0.0497110412,
0.0404133275,
-0.0430283323,
-0.0270215422,
-0.0037854337,
0.0117932744,
-0.0170874521,
-0.0099129369,
-0.0515166558,
0.0070671653,
0.0335061774,
0.0188132916,
-0.0184605569,
0.033919964,
0.08166641,
-0.0412323028,
0.042601712,
0.0737031177,
0.0076404358,
-0.0480154902,
-0.0086407922,
-0.0078030047,
-0.024329666,
0.0005225007,
0.0021287026,
-0.0864639059,
-0.0374255851,
-0.0100461347,
-0.021881571,
0.0052777645,
-0.0065585393,
-0.0045727915,
-0.0735127255,
0.0270076264,
0.0257871412,
-0.0508327,
-0.0626157895,
0.0238731336,
0.0273966249,
0.0323549509,
0.024443103,
-0.0038569034,
-0.0356442817,
-0.010781344,
0.0108997002,
0.0351756699,
-0.0435717776,
-0.0551521033,
-0.0259702969,
0.0562508814,
0.0463877916,
0.0363012552,
-0.018023096,
-0.0370232537,
0.0001219023,
0.0339085683,
0.0145821646,
-0.0000199129,
-0.0092933932,
-0.0281777084,
-0.0047095376,
-0.0390667655,
0.0326991677,
0.020387264,
-0.0192294791,
-0.0090275276,
0.0733906776,
-0.0213486589,
0.0138905356,
-0.0431692936,
-0.0064537008,
0.005268998,
0.0400604978,
-0.0009577787,
-0.0381186455,
-0.0126164928,
-0.0136889908,
0.0137376729,
0.004286103,
-0.0205457322,
0.032895539,
-0.016056003,
0.0065482543,
-0.0417921878,
-0.0411049128,
-0.0040199095,
0.0376035161,
0.0204313416,
0.0108792316,
0.01277343,
0.0161989331,
-0.0585338436,
0.0471753441,
-0.0137612475,
0.0250544511,
-0.0337069184,
0.0035266853,
0.0044845594,
-0.0952009186,
0.0117617147,
0.029431155,
-0.0459674299,
-0.0563295931,
-0.0328354836,
0.0007029799,
0.0206068922,
0.0138535742,
0.0433394909,
-0.0695474967,
0.025143493,
0.0486159958,
-0.0225262791,
0.0070813233,
-0.0210269783,
0.0183382314,
-0.0024209484,
-0.0092712017,
-0.0242648199,
-0.0173333902,
0.0034566291,
0.0260964781,
-0.0179970693,
-0.0399406701,
0.0373980589,
0.0198785234,
0.0137009164,
-0.0404172577,
-0.0113751944,
-0.0338879637,
-0.0399644934,
-0.0274010375,
-0.0281163584,
-0.0343973935,
0.0057729664,
0.0218880475,
0.0193709005,
0.0348772332,
-0.0164109766,
0.0148942955,
0.0005508149,
-0.0414280184,
0.0381435528,
0.0107457656,
-0.0141456043,
-0.0134591861,
0.0243994016,
-0.0003980573,
0.035940744,
-0.0354012549,
0.0175323486,
-0.0124902725,
0.1250600368,
0.0237382837,
-0.0132746752,
-0.0211513992,
0.0598975755,
-0.0006959532,
-0.0083257584,
-0.0224723965,
0.0526825711,
0.0635314211,
0.0260575097,
0.0480534881,
-0.0365525708,
-0.0038243565,
-0.0130344247,
0.0543967932,
0.0177485179,
-0.0085064154,
0.0557015948,
0.0059238463,
-0.0161417872,
-0.0366561078,
0.041015543,
-0.0320134759,
0.0180762261,
-0.0261603016,
-0.025785828,
-0.0189928003,
-0.0139305117,
0.0712278709,
0.0060188854,
-0.0455539189,
-0.0174333826,
-0.0369185135,
-0.0379593223,
0.0069655394,
0.03398785,
-0.0309813246,
-0.0121916924,
0.0277598351,
0.0531908013,
-0.0001639577,
-0.0543487929,
-0.019205695,
0.0144372741,
-0.0157022066,
0.0180413052,
-0.018440323,
-5.683258782e-33,
-0.0325360894,
-0.0401003025,
0.0506056882,
-0.0255237482,
-0.0562187545,
0.0005407505,
0.0206781812,
0.0178522207,
-0.0023185746,
-0.0115104867,
0.0480320491,
-0.0583348311,
0.0079598967,
0.0212037396,
-0.0016977314,
0.008046194,
0.0127685769,
0.0151364207,
-0.026042046,
-0.018157348,
0.0235836972,
0.0027037703,
0.0626932681,
-0.0788998529,
0.01629816,
0.0122859245,
-0.0452668369,
-0.0003659395,
0.0057329973,
0.0697444081,
-0.0437816903,
0.055293899,
0.0417376682,
0.0138609754,
-0.0212000459,
0.0951285586,
-0.0279853977,
0.0113751283,
0.0449402183,
0.0587405898,
-0.053173922,
-0.0386236124,
0.0689992234,
-0.0508481301,
-0.0202484038,
-0.0061626257,
0.0618358217,
-0.0344493836,
0.0152146909,
0.0072628693,
-0.0955519751,
0.0197914671,
-0.0128834397,
-0.0214360841,
0.0143900234,
0.0362068601,
0.0328260921,
0.0120682176,
-0.0428358018,
0.048382923,
0.0010994113,
-0.0167665966,
0.11418093,
0.0656278804,
0.0250772368,
0.0323867425,
0.0187543631,
-0.0652819052,
-0.0330998749,
0.0093484661,
0.0292308852,
0.0291960798,
-0.0145606538,
0.1083094105,
-0.0152801936,
0.0250655971,
-0.023209529,
0.0271605086,
-0.0396954529,
0.0412647799,
0.0321418419,
0.0353634655,
-0.0230399799,
0.0299155563,
-0.0519679002,
0.0040761149,
-0.0339982249,
-0.037236955,
0.0365511291,
-0.0292790066,
0.0128160883,
0.0325576775,
0.0638526306,
-0.0142709259,
-0.0463722907,
-0.0178803466,
-0.0034873036,
0.0687210411,
-0.0201247614,
0.0111185042,
-0.0024606918,
-0.0353104472,
0.0503181294,
-0.0136207631,
0.0317864567,
0.0203045215,
-0.0343623683,
0.0325963087,
-0.0446620584,
0.0038051349,
-0.0324152596,
-0.0563960522,
0.0080964481,
-0.0123435203,
0.0647115409,
-0.0201226287,
-0.0389093459,
0.0044024428,
0.0144033208,
-0.0163511187,
-0.0384502858,
-0.0939571857,
-0.0551201478,
0.0019143185,
-0.0219526328,
0.029279761,
-0.041510053,
-0.0506457984,
0.0434231758,
-0.0342431441,
-0.0093844514,
0.0424285196,
2.694e-7,
0.0386819951,
0.028515555,
-0.003726342,
-0.0227160901,
0.0165375397,
0.0399966314,
-0.0089297658,
0.0532394387,
-0.0000932341,
-0.0396435149,
0.0081887981,
0.0092849508,
0.0248487052,
0.0236465391,
0.0038894794,
0.0124819381,
0.009016973,
0.0146352621,
-0.0719058514,
0.091208145,
0.0921742767,
0.0365852043,
-0.0393420346,
-0.0202739686,
0.0368630812,
-0.0530220084,
0.0669790357,
-0.0573123656,
-0.0322768316,
0.0040962328,
0.0190468207,
-0.0051373597,
-0.0200442597,
0.0100277625,
0.0357603095,
-0.0226750597,
0.02686188,
0.0315294899,
-0.0388396643,
0.0034305204,
-0.0276001878,
0.0038178198,
-0.0525071919,
-0.0609611608,
0.0572109185,
-0.0230226386,
-0.0195139144,
-0.0140743367,
-0.0105932858,
-0.0137284128,
-0.0232983604,
-0.0301310513,
-0.0491424128,
0.0164758321,
0.022497192,
-0.0051270705,
-0.0479422547,
-0.0309153069,
-0.0069229719,
-0.002291668,
-0.0417630672,
-0.0335802697,
-0.0625238195,
-0.0362384021,
0.0385912918,
-0.0653938651,
-0.026691772,
2.085435344e-34,
-0.0315315463,
-0.0213577952,
0.0237627551,
-0.027214963,
0.0242493544,
0.0022386077,
-0.0174438152,
0.0300766919,
-0.0140847703,
-0.0904680043,
-0.0119757745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14699v1 | Ontology Learning Using Formal Concept Analysis and WordNet | 2023-11-10T08:28:30 | 2023-11-10T08:28:30 | Bryar A. Hassan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Manual ontology construction takes time, resources, and domain specialists.
Supporting a component of this process for automation or semi-automation would
be good. This project and dissertation provide a Formal Concept Analysis and
WordNet framework for learning concept hierarchies from free texts. The process
has steps. First, the document is Part-Of-Speech labeled, then parsed to
produce sentence parse trees. Verb/noun dependencies are derived from parse
trees next. After lemmatizing, pruning, and filtering the word pairings, the
formal context is created. The formal context may contain some erroneous and
uninteresting pairs because the parser output may be erroneous, not all derived
pairs are interesting, and it may be large due to constructing it from a large
free text corpus. Deriving lattice from the formal context may take longer,
depending on the size and complexity of the data. Thus, decreasing formal
context may eliminate erroneous and uninteresting pairs and speed up idea
lattice derivation. WordNet-based and Frequency-based approaches are tested.
Finally, we compute formal idea lattice and create a classical concept
hierarchy. The reduced concept lattice is compared to the original to evaluate
the outcomes. Despite several system constraints and component discrepancies
that may prevent logical conclusion, the following data imply idea hierarchies
in this project and dissertation are promising. First, the reduced idea lattice
and original concept have commonalities. Second, alternative language or
statistical methods can reduce formal context size. Finally, WordNet-based and
Frequency-based approaches reduce formal context differently, and the order of
applying them is examined to reduce context efficiently. | [
0.013556201,
0.0342883915,
-0.0220553763,
0.0897167698,
-0.0483605973,
-0.0009449356,
-0.0410154723,
0.0182840936,
-0.0766741484,
-0.0574119315,
0.0188992228,
-0.0041169408,
0.0083377063,
0.038572602,
-0.0470609069,
-0.0481273197,
0.0133687798,
0.0264924783,
-0.0078735389,
0.0161161199,
0.0274192821,
0.0237813666,
-0.0120845102,
0.0103430292,
-0.0087265698,
-0.0124953836,
0.0055878749,
-0.0224977881,
0.0205795523,
-0.0212335549,
-0.0174363516,
0.0405827388,
-0.0064527136,
0.0288653709,
0.0000021269,
-0.075882569,
-0.0681411698,
-0.0211915541,
-0.0028965767,
-0.0242138226,
0.0413600095,
0.021025246,
0.0046888101,
-0.0192207787,
-0.028580863,
0.0248564202,
-0.0060739522,
0.0397854596,
0.004047072,
-0.0089754499,
-0.0208961256,
-0.0161974281,
0.0262266882,
0.0426499061,
0.0171632972,
-0.0239132419,
0.0315330662,
0.0435907915,
-0.0252929386,
0.0198815372,
-0.010528462,
-0.0255227387,
-0.0463711582,
0.0005855625,
0.0352315232,
0.0103601618,
-0.0189909469,
-0.0171456225,
0.0233467631,
0.0234622546,
0.0570607483,
-0.0024797018,
0.0165979732,
-0.0150063569,
-0.0474715978,
0.0562575981,
-0.0128538245,
0.0208223108,
-0.0628156066,
-0.0059455074,
0.0594222657,
0.0138835525,
-0.0249860864,
0.0106878644,
-0.0307631698,
0.1168999225,
-0.0200755727,
-0.0150669916,
0.0030599805,
-0.0060057137,
-0.0501521938,
-0.0203375872,
0.0280733965,
-0.0300435796,
0.0337391309,
0.056195356,
0.0179204252,
-0.0423492156,
0.012257318,
-0.0817191601,
-0.0532258786,
0.0018399525,
0.0148771834,
-0.0190591011,
0.0392897017,
-0.0242075734,
0.0337603986,
-0.0470203422,
-0.0748777092,
0.0171504263,
-0.0982392505,
0.0087995138,
-0.0767625347,
0.0630857721,
0.0164735131,
-0.0161214732,
-0.0198706742,
-0.0005914338,
-0.0038069368,
0.0058641997,
-0.0383636057,
-0.0133647704,
-0.0021033583,
0.0295811146,
-0.0450261347,
-0.072960645,
-0.0287396498,
0.0315963998,
-0.0419215634,
-0.0086778821,
0.0441573747,
-0.0143161407,
0.0421210043,
0.0253036916,
-0.0091051068,
-0.0239965543,
0.0329175405,
-0.0143010234,
-0.0734188035,
-0.0724351481,
-0.0092203217,
0.0036242076,
-0.0385853834,
-0.0963861123,
-0.0285920966,
0.0013574351,
-0.0018353469,
-0.0155843822,
0.0089725722,
0.0287673678,
-0.0400919616,
0.0578986928,
-0.064210847,
-0.0234228,
0.0484959707,
0.0306930989,
-0.0080601294,
0.0131081212,
0.0310593881,
0.0033403886,
0.0703107566,
0.0002052064,
-0.0484734066,
-0.0336173251,
0.0021769151,
-0.0257078018,
-0.0238153785,
0.0040957611,
-0.042625498,
0.0318730026,
-0.0120821455,
0.0183056016,
-0.0086329244,
0.0444396511,
-0.0239350591,
0.0607543327,
0.0036487863,
0.006889936,
0.0274185296,
0.0098582245,
0.031058263,
0.0101288883,
0.0276600383,
-0.0347950123,
-0.0489176139,
-0.0158594903,
-0.0744487643,
-0.0357329287,
0.0134164505,
-0.0603405349,
-0.0451168641,
0.0023403128,
-0.0217038896,
-0.060197141,
0.0799301565,
0.0360182747,
0.0145228971,
0.0066038417,
0.0347558372,
-0.0183146615,
-0.0256075319,
0.0008496443,
0.0073074852,
0.0592161268,
0.0389437154,
-0.0692287832,
-0.0138319451,
0.021211667,
-0.0763283372,
0.0467196964,
-0.0442271642,
-0.0681403801,
-0.0670131445,
-0.0293143466,
-0.0100958822,
0.021784069,
-0.0044327723,
-0.0043045348,
-0.0267597716,
0.0222044419,
0.0125294123,
-0.030790275,
0.0141371042,
0.0438442789,
0.0037275178,
0.0292156115,
0.0069576981,
-0.0014664943,
0.0583145767,
0.0382408425,
-0.0086316206,
0.0208315514,
0.0339221545,
-0.0242207553,
-0.0399162322,
0.0018942626,
-0.0420131609,
-0.0340090506,
-0.0039104908,
-0.0199015494,
0.0539944135,
0.0010215529,
0.0063847573,
-0.0267584231,
-0.003391976,
0.0164651908,
0.0679897442,
-0.0356696323,
0.0145400837,
0.0020186666,
0.0010181024,
-0.0393629037,
0.0912381858,
0.0082833841,
0.046281144,
-0.0178595204,
-0.0036373148,
0.0442509614,
0.0318847597,
-0.0017811611,
-0.0155034149,
-0.0244850758,
-0.010102232,
0.0462811217,
0.0121771581,
-0.0338385962,
0.0415179953,
-0.0325966515,
0.0143843628,
0.0137010254,
0.06733834,
0.0295806844,
-0.0033388119,
0.0197064932,
0.0114806788,
0.0113269398,
0.0709426552,
-0.0496165827,
-0.0324591808,
0.0368979424,
-0.0024222683,
-0.0426036268,
-0.0143434927,
0.0054210601,
-0.0257698782,
0.031386964,
0.0120144179,
-0.0293257497,
0.0009449467,
0.0903865695,
-0.0518960021,
0.0215515476,
-0.0133070191,
0.0022701279,
-0.0136436652,
-0.0211878307,
-0.0052507222,
-0.0159102827,
0.0151677383,
0.0358935557,
0.0676330179,
-0.0015801167,
0.0016553079,
-0.0173175167,
0.0271369647,
0.0536934026,
0.0049076453,
-0.0301464237,
0.0264694337,
0.046638675,
0.0449450836,
-0.0259918496,
-0.0018574463,
0.0281425007,
-0.0857545361,
0.033071842,
-0.0839469433,
-0.0258108582,
0.0053233462,
0.0738562047,
0.0144596705,
0.0066055451,
0.0095262975,
-0.0097967014,
0.0329655185,
-0.048751086,
0.0096018482,
-0.0162710659,
0.0713933557,
0.0259972401,
0.0535519496,
0.0662350208,
-0.0253211223,
-0.0188187864,
-0.0451475829,
0.0714405105,
0.0216168333,
0.064613305,
-0.0978858694,
0.0279723052,
0.0132859228,
-0.0063164001,
-0.0447100773,
0.0682580918,
-0.0050540194,
0.0209509898,
0.0846549198,
-0.0060115587,
0.0694423392,
-0.0122934189,
0.0082280636,
0.0398890972,
0.071093142,
-0.0596485659,
-0.0026642501,
0.0930744112,
-0.0104992231,
-0.0448673889,
0.0149354013,
0.0485414937,
0.0255496576,
0.0512588955,
0.0074437163,
-0.0239449572,
-0.0098973541,
-0.0062083714,
0.0045942347,
-0.0626545995,
-0.0210408997,
0.0004663204,
-0.0739505216,
-0.0183080342,
-0.0159332659,
0.0917067826,
0.1015668884,
-0.0115439091,
0.0446612015,
-0.0207653251,
-0.0558050051,
0.0034077365,
-0.0195986237,
-0.0543260984,
0.0114201298,
-0.0033421216,
-0.0193924028,
-0.0533738807,
-0.0357027873,
0.0015053342,
-0.0657080263,
0.0089793596,
-0.0247820783,
-0.0550412126,
0.0418821387,
-0.0151526826,
-0.0091737825,
-0.009761679,
-0.0960590392,
0.0305146631,
-0.0026778535,
-0.0202192143,
0.0072804247,
-0.0484160073,
-0.0045317309,
0.0449204184,
0.0034416397,
0.0101758847,
-0.0046110912,
0.0640342534,
-0.0670929849,
0.0246719997,
0.013212434,
-0.0929105803,
0.0025276588,
-0.0378176942,
0.0238464661,
0.0186882112,
0.038132634,
-0.0163290948,
0.0283616632,
-0.0480936207,
-0.0482491329,
0.0422011577,
0.0408243649,
-0.0400850065,
0.0209310558,
-0.0039501297,
-0.0058017587,
-0.0056346064,
0.0152367158,
-0.0455724075,
0.0178298596,
0.0604122616,
-0.0148702674,
-0.0113089839,
-0.0217465591,
-0.0158865806,
0.0050267335,
-0.0156186474,
-0.0487852171,
-0.1095028222,
0.0139011238,
-0.0107917562,
0.0108196149,
-0.0102116922,
0.0423861593,
0.0408187695,
0.0091111585,
-0.0383132659,
-0.0183689594,
0.0217780359,
0.0009859004,
0.01356012,
-0.0405233428,
0.0695314184,
-0.0140638109,
-0.052049011,
-0.0085109919,
0.0029826143,
-0.0048432262,
0.029629631,
-0.0173327848,
0.0102170464,
0.0311740302,
0.0022836465,
0.0410875157,
0.0623921715,
0.019263763,
-0.0342634656,
-0.0004146298,
0.023982143,
0.0334916748,
-0.0100822458,
0.0473610014,
-0.0067030541,
0.0547188371,
-0.0209442955,
0.0125651704,
-0.0201756451,
-0.029307168,
0.0472810008,
0.0424157381,
0.0133785158,
-0.034005262,
-0.025125267,
-0.0536280237,
0.0072280625,
-0.0267578959,
-0.0461612418,
-0.0165892914,
0.0245184582,
-0.0150570888,
-0.0248444192,
-0.0460936837,
-0.0000924713,
-0.0059363456,
-0.0181227848,
0.0664190501,
0.0139340637,
0.0279386435,
0.0488533117,
0.0424748361,
-0.0299034044,
-0.0139034353,
-0.0398576781,
-0.0319288969,
0.0115580428,
-0.0370073281,
0.0263046119,
0.0125676822,
-0.011323248,
-0.0645173267,
0.0203522053,
-0.0035455667,
0.0247216523,
-0.0281291343,
0.018821789,
0.0182669889,
-0.009410983,
0.0148704192,
-0.0909518152,
0.0116126826,
0.0101285819,
0.0508820154,
0.0079557206,
-0.0448295847,
0.0153637948,
0.003279103,
0.0093425289,
-0.0026292494,
0.0923096165,
-0.029805718,
0.012446912,
0.0075567947,
-0.0375682823,
-0.0321245901,
0.0311952382,
0.0274433997,
0.0247750618,
-0.0426428691,
0.0156913586,
-0.0707257688,
-0.0300819054,
0.0051749204,
0.0298073348,
0.0120335696,
0.0206738841,
0.1008421853,
0.0718012229,
0.0589265451,
-0.0080943201,
-0.0332909971,
-0.0073477877,
-0.0553393252,
-0.0134099284,
-0.0166046657,
-5.966194027e-33,
-0.0262342338,
-0.0498414412,
0.0033533734,
0.0986403376,
-0.0062553636,
0.0251406264,
0.0140323704,
0.005887269,
0.0151164467,
0.0546048172,
0.016563708,
0.0250692442,
-0.0094560804,
-0.0254502315,
0.0152780898,
0.0428633578,
-0.0147147989,
-0.008457276,
0.0039136522,
0.0079003517,
0.0971866101,
-0.0047647869,
0.0626986399,
-0.0443091616,
0.033902064,
0.0009467231,
0.0054585105,
0.0226138383,
0.0035777921,
0.0121019473,
-0.0014564646,
0.0491798036,
0.0366266482,
-0.0070136343,
0.0336727351,
-0.0000137881,
-0.06925001,
-0.0795913413,
-0.0122042596,
-0.0004767215,
-0.0064080055,
-0.0249794554,
0.0167145319,
0.0139311701,
-0.0053100353,
0.0249237195,
0.0771531463,
-0.0067390767,
-0.0184277743,
-0.0676385388,
-0.0895629004,
0.0420739613,
0.001632125,
-0.0006512336,
-0.0022379775,
-0.0501005091,
-0.0020324017,
-0.0542548224,
-0.0190783888,
0.0134204151,
-0.0077453563,
0.0219926052,
0.0133362105,
-0.0144769102,
0.0047599417,
0.0330525003,
-0.0349717438,
0.0019239322,
0.0398775414,
0.0075464402,
0.0155144613,
0.060260132,
-0.0272063538,
0.0076222932,
0.0703958124,
-0.0084045194,
-0.0521497019,
0.0360490903,
-0.0052442593,
0.0433398373,
-0.0137508167,
-0.0128896302,
-0.0254400633,
-0.0296206288,
-0.004559326,
0.010031092,
-0.0235445425,
-0.02005562,
-0.0130846146,
-0.0420680195,
-0.0190755446,
-0.0391938388,
-0.0333318077,
-0.0485772602,
-0.0125543438,
-0.0214946494,
0.0070282915,
0.0336989947,
-0.0399272479,
0.0113092884,
-0.0591839738,
-0.0567674711,
-0.0209526476,
0.027723033,
0.0249416903,
0.0323712043,
0.0081092343,
-0.0062877643,
-0.0038964986,
0.0018730882,
-0.0143240783,
-0.0669794902,
-0.0366083048,
0.0126347886,
0.013623789,
0.021161573,
0.00148094,
-0.0076255607,
0.0236518569,
-0.0283971876,
-0.0134916613,
0.0036213638,
-0.0201848857,
-0.0044367374,
-0.0160683561,
-0.0279786494,
-0.0104095675,
-0.0564912111,
0.0840104595,
0.007906056,
-0.0104342531,
-0.004976369,
2.963e-7,
0.0476474278,
0.0352229811,
-0.0098555302,
0.0354253203,
0.0367654637,
0.0288087633,
-0.0104691144,
0.042988576,
-0.0569596179,
-0.0127939079,
0.0434115604,
-0.0280427169,
-0.0123228654,
0.0741838291,
-0.0883945003,
-0.0244868454,
0.0437657274,
-0.0608878359,
-0.0146822482,
0.0287920441,
0.0718175843,
0.0196129289,
0.0205331519,
-0.0008224884,
-0.038647566,
-0.0233339127,
-0.0085846437,
0.0189743191,
0.0084599601,
0.0559915155,
0.006103762,
-0.0136378175,
0.0065793884,
0.0458614826,
-0.0117767453,
-0.0147190327,
0.0059001767,
-0.0026889283,
-0.0494426228,
0.0691811964,
-0.0141298566,
-0.0462516919,
0.0147703616,
-0.0036595454,
0.0251492467,
-0.0139089786,
-0.0176919326,
0.0259135719,
0.0188995972,
0.0080336332,
-0.0613623485,
0.0363135561,
-0.0128708109,
0.0121075641,
-0.011828715,
0.0072753537,
-0.0407013334,
-0.0490799733,
0.0256573148,
0.0549020991,
-0.0032847095,
-0.0691421703,
0.0353365727,
-0.0066927401,
0.0087808091,
-0.0294818562,
0.00481785,
2.611967963e-34,
-0.0001503885,
0.0209495276,
-0.0409316197,
0.0214076713,
-0.0137177827,
-0.0140385367,
0.0095883133,
0.0301976055,
-0.0152595025,
-0.0304466318,
0.0250968281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05928v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05928v2 | The Shape of Learning: Anisotropy and Intrinsic Dimensions in Transformer-Based Models | 2023-11-10T08:25:02 | 2024-02-26T06:46:17 | Anton Razzhigaev, Matvey Mikhalchuk, Elizaveta Goncharova, Ivan Oseledets, Denis Dimitrov, Andrey Kuznetsov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.GN, math.IT | In this study, we present an investigation into the anisotropy dynamics and
intrinsic dimension of embeddings in transformer architectures, focusing on the
dichotomy between encoders and decoders. Our findings reveal that the
anisotropy profile in transformer decoders exhibits a distinct bell-shaped
curve, with the highest anisotropy concentrations in the middle layers. This
pattern diverges from the more uniformly distributed anisotropy observed in
encoders. In addition, we found that the intrinsic dimension of embeddings
increases in the initial phases of training, indicating an expansion into
higher-dimensional space. Which is then followed by a compression phase towards
the end of training with dimensionality decrease, suggesting a refinement into
more compact representations. Our results provide fresh insights to the
understanding of encoders and decoders embedding properties. | [
-0.0381009355,
0.0069245286,
-0.0154922418,
0.0493923835,
0.0200976375,
0.0136821922,
0.0435630232,
-0.0170928184,
-0.0868552625,
0.039679192,
-0.0016167911,
-0.0203789137,
-0.0089658136,
0.036343284,
0.0139865838,
-0.0330779478,
-0.0022269445,
0.0264072809,
-0.0388141163,
-0.0513300411,
-0.0494010933,
-0.0556744263,
0.0015179032,
0.035849385,
0.0068314476,
0.0127167981,
-0.0413751751,
-0.0221561734,
0.0053593046,
-0.0146029042,
-0.0015772902,
-0.0088162571,
0.050996948,
0.0267800931,
0.0000019246,
0.0174258705,
0.0366551839,
-0.0003488932,
-0.0272037722,
0.0019728388,
0.0107137877,
-0.0732371882,
-0.0564582907,
-0.0281369891,
0.0002888405,
-0.058047846,
0.0615228564,
0.0465312675,
0.0143995397,
0.0327851288,
-0.0112812771,
-0.0733419284,
0.0387448445,
-0.0263364241,
-0.0169232246,
0.066329062,
-0.0120574124,
-0.0138886049,
-0.0601207539,
0.0034920827,
-0.0904337764,
0.030483678,
0.065667659,
0.0321404226,
0.0456335209,
0.0217158105,
0.0126014762,
-0.0203345492,
0.0231204573,
-0.0087449215,
-0.0316990204,
0.0107790632,
-0.0565812588,
-0.0033002519,
0.0076606506,
0.027742127,
-0.0219971873,
0.0142756337,
0.0123592922,
0.0325033441,
-0.0751064122,
0.0585964359,
0.0474641398,
-0.0548327193,
-0.0189086944,
-0.006384843,
0.0074591422,
-0.0315989554,
-0.0105062332,
0.013458875,
0.0619344339,
0.080889903,
0.004264784,
0.0080238581,
0.0541375726,
-0.0307787396,
0.0162178036,
-0.0051382114,
-0.0142623326,
-0.0321432985,
0.0553048253,
0.0159215946,
-0.0125983041,
0.0092409458,
-0.0556840599,
0.0726097822,
-0.0387808569,
0.063620165,
-0.0622289553,
0.0074764504,
0.0112458058,
-0.0456315801,
-0.0204161964,
0.0085837906,
0.0121557089,
-0.0207117349,
-0.0284733493,
0.0342183746,
0.0038396269,
0.0106266933,
0.0220135115,
0.0269572716,
-0.0293530412,
0.0094756801,
0.0036606551,
0.0690435767,
0.0080103893,
0.0107564125,
0.0058784802,
-0.0009132773,
-0.0109210815,
-0.0368355513,
0.0092140278,
0.0149761979,
0.0144959642,
0.0392097682,
-0.0050668684,
-0.0375583097,
-0.006291782,
0.068461515,
-0.0257927515,
0.0278884526,
0.0701860562,
-0.0006634791,
0.0294546951,
-0.0067936773,
0.0040555974,
-0.0286671519,
-0.0116410917,
-0.0046015517,
0.016084563,
0.0644680113,
0.0103789205,
-0.0273220036,
0.0851267576,
0.0000168523,
0.0009633371,
0.0562713258,
0.0110752303,
0.0330987424,
-0.0117978761,
-0.0558895022,
0.0078908885,
-0.000214038,
0.0100411065,
-0.0025460769,
-0.0179940667,
-0.0627501085,
-0.0171841718,
0.0144058596,
0.0308789089,
0.016247686,
-0.0538619719,
-0.0609554127,
0.0741250515,
0.0634541512,
0.0522680692,
0.0504834466,
0.0082665589,
-0.0157267526,
-0.0017635612,
0.0349181816,
-0.0178092793,
0.0643734261,
0.0659799278,
0.0120128971,
-0.0199279413,
0.0642733276,
-0.0578354076,
-0.0529759564,
-0.023854319,
-0.0154381627,
0.0158863962,
-0.0519113429,
0.0380927026,
0.0310485065,
-0.0423593894,
0.06409619,
-0.0418320075,
-0.0557456724,
-0.0091082193,
0.0047696182,
0.0295587797,
-0.0322309844,
0.0140341353,
0.0024299559,
0.0039648954,
0.0154523971,
-0.0510780476,
0.035344813,
0.0049638008,
-0.0108264666,
0.029147638,
-0.0431027561,
-0.0286956374,
-0.0155337099,
0.015627766,
0.0097790845,
-0.0181937441,
-0.0387384966,
-0.0122544337,
-0.0174691267,
0.0249587186,
-0.0126220854,
-0.0218797252,
0.0002301092,
0.0288011543,
0.0184857696,
-0.0008081046,
-0.0234201923,
0.0072524557,
-0.0242932588,
0.0572260693,
-0.0609991476,
-0.0409284197,
0.0002644144,
-0.0957775488,
0.0217532013,
-0.002216856,
-0.0658972561,
0.0769047663,
-0.0042077387,
-0.0002057016,
-0.0293313507,
0.0398002155,
-0.0319786742,
0.0553491935,
-0.0358346142,
0.0046406426,
-0.032085631,
0.0367933251,
-0.0111424047,
0.0277192052,
-0.0326126777,
0.0164568312,
-0.0126873711,
0.0054785842,
0.0114104003,
0.0187660865,
-0.012884167,
0.0223639309,
-0.023762906,
0.008273351,
0.0208021123,
-0.0770661831,
0.0366520658,
-0.0627666041,
0.0152468644,
-0.0482592508,
0.0064807413,
0.0068429029,
-0.0202603843,
-0.0049720518,
0.0148076219,
0.0143866884,
0.00325888,
-0.0070906873,
-0.0204561856,
-0.0155522227,
0.0354493596,
-0.0045466321,
-0.0195785426,
0.0161432978,
-0.0421237461,
0.0077002794,
0.05651908,
-0.0299145691,
0.0254497956,
-0.0589505024,
-0.0286525674,
0.0654679686,
-0.0037525292,
-0.0350031704,
-0.0965048969,
0.0222170576,
0.0253185891,
0.0317888744,
0.0982805043,
0.0404536463,
0.0838984549,
0.0531591438,
0.0261148736,
0.0177048631,
0.0046887673,
-0.0736013651,
0.0023584184,
-0.0653470904,
-0.0126066115,
-0.0005399344,
0.0926388055,
0.0074545615,
0.0097615579,
-0.0921894908,
0.0043212748,
-0.0085784383,
-0.0026818712,
0.0326375961,
-0.0155663779,
-0.03304746,
0.0059782495,
-0.0059545678,
-0.0209075511,
0.0422850251,
-0.0159830879,
-0.0127151664,
0.0090201898,
0.0012294387,
-0.019317979,
0.0337297209,
0.0307476614,
0.0357761867,
0.0143644819,
-0.0209993087,
-0.0284060519,
0.0396311395,
0.0153131848,
-0.0143742859,
0.0139869219,
0.020194564,
-0.0723492429,
-0.0368967727,
-0.0294487607,
-0.0155593082,
0.0395812467,
0.009000456,
0.0147865834,
0.013213329,
-0.0455241241,
-0.0249474365,
-0.0118174981,
0.0206227154,
0.050721243,
0.0137607846,
-0.040007785,
-0.0200695992,
0.0292519741,
-0.0335138701,
0.0485957563,
0.0342368372,
-0.0220436435,
0.0632353127,
0.0002955208,
-0.0520034358,
0.0480984449,
-0.0854901299,
0.0140032656,
0.0376302786,
0.0376389436,
-0.0106597571,
0.0183611251,
0.0363224521,
-0.0208002031,
-0.0605715215,
0.0429647379,
-0.008380156,
-0.0611249618,
0.0147722373,
-0.0011435638,
0.0263300333,
0.0270433072,
0.0031838024,
-0.0187847838,
-0.0096938154,
-0.0189427156,
-0.0016392935,
0.0233139507,
0.0407377146,
0.0363829136,
-0.0505682565,
0.0467521921,
0.0072791944,
0.037423145,
-0.0723624229,
-0.0311546586,
-0.0670313016,
-0.0339246094,
0.0328560323,
-0.0051665134,
-0.0289530754,
-0.0209101029,
0.0429486334,
-0.008073492,
-0.038373448,
-0.0037408373,
-0.0041190991,
-0.0112466468,
0.0287961029,
-0.0170170255,
-0.0344885103,
-0.0878960639,
-0.0489405952,
0.0304687973,
0.0285390653,
0.0472647101,
0.0589258671,
0.0397325084,
-0.0174993426,
-0.019748088,
0.0162934624,
-0.0240034554,
0.0022882244,
-0.0643256754,
0.0759679154,
-0.027122112,
-0.0183849037,
-0.0079329163,
-0.0439029336,
-0.0714439452,
0.0374389812,
0.0095256744,
-0.0244642589,
-0.0174466353,
-0.0471049026,
0.0762182474,
-0.013889676,
-0.0628995672,
0.0755016804,
0.0574121997,
-0.062257383,
-0.0310370494,
0.0440757796,
-0.0561829507,
0.0590848848,
0.027403459,
-0.0916726366,
0.0505495667,
-0.0106454138,
-0.0623368248,
-0.0396317877,
0.0266971011,
-0.0097447168,
-0.0383653641,
0.0218820777,
0.0689905956,
-0.0319518857,
-0.0074240239,
-0.0411098711,
-0.0432823785,
-0.0217966717,
0.026839966,
0.0204596817,
0.007612335,
0.0230216682,
0.0325023942,
0.0122738108,
0.1145199537,
-0.0031647326,
-0.0044533564,
0.0229631234,
0.0722347423,
-0.0827534348,
-0.0195364021,
0.016154578,
-0.0068222196,
0.0029759754,
-0.0373973437,
-0.0331542902,
-0.0112351775,
-0.019065503,
0.0312014166,
-0.0790335611,
0.0615561083,
0.0084840106,
0.0326440334,
0.0335463881,
0.0632818565,
0.0084681036,
0.0534391254,
-0.0211039092,
-0.061944861,
0.0515504703,
0.0020862718,
0.0306863599,
0.0292883422,
0.0720333531,
0.0360475071,
-0.021370206,
0.0336742476,
-0.0055649369,
-0.0041058413,
-0.0208415817,
0.0369559973,
-0.0066226954,
0.0076950812,
-0.0289327297,
0.0240506548,
0.0048044748,
0.0462651253,
0.0021848655,
0.0522682294,
-0.0428500995,
0.0248626284,
-0.0555872172,
0.0161087383,
-0.0470319912,
-0.0664206743,
0.0226354767,
-0.0224252716,
-0.0041111112,
-0.02152922,
-0.0063483077,
0.025376007,
-0.0079665305,
-0.0219670404,
-0.024281146,
0.0803063512,
0.0009355083,
0.0122867385,
-0.0438366272,
0.0367269516,
-0.0410299599,
0.033818163,
-0.0510353222,
0.0186482593,
-0.0038244268,
-0.0104817506,
0.0292306952,
-0.0042978581,
-0.0153773138,
-0.0432363786,
-0.0178384352,
-0.0224607885,
-0.0113682859,
0.0006755608,
0.0259478763,
-0.0502632521,
0.0268252585,
0.020120183,
-0.00094227,
-0.0535158925,
0.0249703582,
-0.0395351611,
-0.0012811386,
0.026276473,
0.0461281538,
-6.057964504e-33,
-0.017680876,
0.0489346534,
0.0081226099,
-0.0084630139,
-0.0029361837,
0.0221408196,
0.0090081999,
-0.0251140445,
-0.030975746,
0.0072710831,
-0.0143444855,
0.0062111178,
-0.0028243416,
0.0539486296,
0.0349883251,
-0.0116175124,
0.0380215161,
0.0039313696,
-0.0118937586,
-0.0072983433,
-0.0055636889,
-0.0121998843,
0.0525399409,
-0.0235945545,
-0.0603620298,
0.0380511694,
0.0010682209,
-0.0063863215,
0.0299506038,
0.0188665912,
-0.0502109714,
0.0071191294,
-0.0277757868,
-0.1010333002,
-0.012156738,
-0.0427124426,
-0.0364213884,
0.0038458107,
-0.0684267357,
0.0362548195,
-0.033511918,
-0.0436437391,
0.0141010489,
-0.0141654797,
-0.0528458767,
-0.068155244,
0.0187606029,
-0.0136033716,
-0.0091685643,
-0.0271125473,
-0.0105880434,
-0.0167389344,
-0.0153822415,
-0.0154336477,
0.0456763096,
-0.0137476688,
-0.0013889429,
0.0069132191,
-0.0590870753,
0.0433622748,
-0.000589148,
0.0359783955,
0.030131463,
0.0199572109,
0.0280641969,
0.0369622111,
0.0604064949,
-0.0130120274,
-0.0044024833,
-0.0162760299,
0.0208154842,
0.0181521289,
0.0448653549,
-0.0184961073,
0.0645652264,
-0.0355487056,
0.0006050204,
0.0118414266,
-0.019796947,
0.0232413877,
0.0218954124,
0.0273405816,
-0.004356998,
-0.0346267112,
0.0017268338,
-0.0383722782,
0.0301475488,
-0.0394397564,
-0.0011199185,
0.0209142808,
0.0242244769,
-0.0038108951,
0.0098377466,
-0.0381755978,
0.0880545601,
0.0213468522,
0.0016068843,
0.0701637939,
-0.0126622887,
-0.0076562501,
0.011065254,
-0.0278232992,
0.0138148237,
0.0195135716,
0.0143581321,
0.0042015519,
0.006137812,
0.0754942745,
-0.0402740985,
-0.0139838932,
-0.0187973976,
-0.0709210932,
0.0163081102,
0.021439584,
0.0273048282,
-0.0014266904,
-0.0068653538,
0.0172091071,
-0.0282282159,
0.0623409748,
-0.0345681272,
0.0176139027,
0.0123425247,
0.037888322,
-0.0097784195,
-0.0116859619,
-0.0713527724,
0.0112610972,
0.0347030796,
-0.0862716883,
-0.0357548743,
0.0106947199,
2.628e-7,
-0.0186031722,
0.0514537767,
0.0408268012,
-0.0206980631,
0.0267662574,
0.0316642709,
0.0064101787,
0.041582711,
-0.0091156727,
-0.027166279,
0.0233153645,
0.0230650157,
0.0107874274,
0.0192970149,
-0.0531392097,
-0.0210029222,
-0.0141740432,
0.0391127281,
0.012785268,
0.0049350462,
-0.0033526877,
0.0949049294,
-0.0348476246,
0.0074579525,
0.0201997627,
0.0098439762,
0.0320347324,
0.0149611877,
0.0912657678,
-0.0059473002,
-0.0386568978,
-0.0128058167,
0.00159284,
0.0145312436,
-0.0336528011,
0.0276915133,
-0.0217313301,
-0.0093963025,
0.0098701026,
-0.035768386,
0.0185852963,
0.0417719446,
-0.0502468348,
-0.0180970989,
0.0257526487,
-0.0774811879,
-0.050684128,
-0.0086833723,
-0.0636943877,
0.0198068675,
-0.007341932,
-0.0329839289,
0.0155413076,
-0.0116559314,
-0.0061934041,
-0.0181962401,
0.021202229,
-0.0316743441,
0.0178236086,
0.0335438401,
-0.058442153,
0.0021822643,
-0.0756392032,
-0.0458737463,
0.0928486362,
0.0257760994,
-0.0152482484,
2.274679603e-34,
-0.0080523249,
0.0144441081,
0.0424520895,
0.0314080603,
-0.0142992437,
-0.0602196604,
0.0521764047,
0.0028070689,
0.0095549002,
-0.0466231927,
-0.0140530532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05922v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05922v3 | Chain of Thought with Explicit Evidence Reasoning for Few-shot Relation Extraction | 2023-11-10T08:12:00 | 2024-03-08T06:51:43 | Xilai Ma, Jing Li, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot relation extraction involves identifying the type of relationship
between two specific entities within a text, using a limited number of
annotated samples. A variety of solutions to this problem have emerged by
applying meta-learning and neural graph techniques which typically necessitate
a training process for adaptation. Recently, the strategy of in-context
learning has been demonstrating notable results without the need of training.
Few studies have already utilized in-context learning for zero-shot information
extraction. Unfortunately, the evidence for inference is either not considered
or implicitly modeled during the construction of chain-of-thought prompts. In
this paper, we propose a novel approach for few-shot relation extraction using
large language models, named CoT-ER, chain-of-thought with explicit evidence
reasoning. In particular, CoT-ER first induces large language models to
generate evidences using task-specific and concept-level knowledge. Then these
evidences are explicitly incorporated into chain-of-thought prompting for
relation extraction. Experimental results demonstrate that our CoT-ER approach
(with 0% training data) achieves competitive performance compared to the
fully-supervised (with 100% training data) state-of-the-art approach on the
FewRel1.0 and FewRel2.0 datasets. | [
0.0378515236,
0.0130462879,
0.0222849976,
0.0631812811,
-0.0486969687,
0.0365584493,
0.0095173866,
-0.0200870652,
-0.0071676793,
-0.0577309392,
-0.0255270861,
0.0133282235,
-0.0165279172,
-0.0100037921,
-0.0025318889,
-0.0325968675,
0.0277509522,
0.0111625232,
0.0420320109,
0.0326235741,
-0.0035345952,
0.0247700363,
-0.0191141963,
-0.0078403549,
-0.0144473938,
-0.0344716348,
0.0104853204,
-0.0080461921,
0.0673854351,
-0.0559922308,
-0.0219285004,
0.0360331982,
0.0101873204,
-0.0035543637,
0.0000018282,
-0.063691929,
-0.0120205097,
0.0140166422,
-0.0699435025,
-0.0759809315,
-0.0104554966,
-0.0068789707,
0.0258144159,
-0.0165449623,
-0.0307007898,
-0.0622109286,
0.0242678169,
0.0530692898,
0.014225401,
0.0504019149,
-0.0357393585,
-0.0606248081,
0.0041209627,
-0.0173652917,
0.0226890743,
-0.0198237244,
0.0415949114,
-0.0129434196,
0.0179836527,
0.0119834868,
-0.0113401851,
0.0213460829,
0.0206967592,
-0.0098436251,
0.0195105877,
0.05718394,
-0.0490564778,
-0.0085581187,
-0.001464502,
0.1277894676,
0.0083607016,
-0.0006069188,
-0.00235459,
-0.0053732381,
0.0148627544,
0.0291404575,
-0.0156085761,
0.0102101387,
-0.0500670671,
0.0071343384,
0.0131310727,
0.003088736,
0.0386196636,
-0.0098213237,
-0.019403588,
0.0253610238,
-0.0135566713,
-0.0431671441,
0.0487710349,
0.037852522,
-0.0172937401,
-0.036393173,
-0.0148880472,
0.0492354706,
-0.0019057679,
0.0371716619,
-0.0178766139,
-0.0236108322,
-0.0389623754,
-0.0305853728,
0.0031971727,
-0.0037904307,
-0.0215144921,
0.0861498937,
-0.0569808297,
-0.0254350603,
-0.0006359686,
-0.0330458656,
0.0061489674,
-0.0186339244,
-0.0680431649,
0.0284402948,
-0.0341059156,
0.0628322586,
-0.023712337,
-0.0043918826,
-0.0124366516,
-0.004881511,
0.000904983,
0.0388204418,
0.011130332,
0.00097476,
0.0045638257,
-0.0102604311,
0.0010462102,
0.0195012055,
-0.041162394,
0.0035584152,
0.001342627,
0.0145749357,
-0.0218843557,
-0.0173206795,
0.0602628253,
-0.0564908609,
0.022581622,
0.0652517229,
0.0191968661,
-0.0467536077,
-0.0269693173,
-0.0370677337,
-0.0018457345,
-0.078613542,
-0.0032476883,
-0.03078622,
0.0266301036,
0.0282543562,
-0.0230880026,
0.0254611708,
0.032783173,
0.0046884255,
-0.0883814469,
0.0624366179,
-0.0419764332,
-0.0152199361,
-0.0293261297,
0.0066877506,
-0.009643076,
0.0717783943,
0.0525239445,
0.0242150389,
0.0291852206,
0.0464579128,
-0.0166330412,
-0.0014220871,
0.0172710251,
-0.0228912793,
0.0053981608,
0.0057153231,
-0.0085328305,
-0.0043156324,
-0.0103681404,
0.0297953747,
-0.0420459844,
-0.0035610262,
0.026001351,
0.014922969,
0.020701116,
0.0032727958,
0.0777666196,
-0.0057717776,
0.0329941101,
0.0079659382,
-0.0550176166,
0.0316710062,
-0.0146779884,
0.009244673,
-0.0347637534,
0.0209699161,
-0.0158010516,
-0.0003140459,
0.0056229527,
-0.0005434685,
-0.0379563533,
0.0280363839,
0.0942121372,
0.0320487358,
-0.024644712,
-0.0159762837,
0.0526275523,
0.0121886646,
-0.023247635,
0.0187401604,
0.0001152896,
0.0193835665,
0.0423923768,
-0.0329403505,
-0.0615734011,
-0.0413924381,
0.0146891894,
0.0473383628,
-0.0137877213,
-0.048727259,
0.0322290324,
-0.0259267502,
-0.0337968096,
0.0221180171,
-0.0010796926,
-0.0096607637,
-0.0060579749,
0.0030065619,
0.0092728669,
0.0006679905,
0.0142537365,
0.0274022259,
-0.0167935323,
-0.0304064229,
0.0242063385,
0.0486462936,
0.0118991146,
0.0227644797,
-0.0219969712,
-0.0277898517,
0.0328217261,
-0.0330656841,
0.0161215924,
0.0383070074,
-0.0422969237,
-0.0950037017,
0.0252807382,
-0.0221368819,
-0.051540792,
-0.0859921724,
-0.0485634431,
-0.0340399109,
-0.0207526647,
0.0356254987,
0.0602413751,
-0.0027628075,
-0.0126869408,
0.0221885834,
-0.018819036,
-0.0218911115,
0.1085031852,
0.0150882071,
-0.0203683786,
0.0530069023,
-0.0476570651,
-0.0091209747,
0.0199124347,
0.0084609007,
-0.0027368444,
0.0059876996,
-0.0453597344,
0.0085537639,
0.0172239188,
-0.0600110181,
0.0004087769,
-0.0662716702,
0.0111855734,
0.0162320249,
0.0337150507,
0.0108721256,
0.0067627355,
0.0040891068,
-0.0340610519,
-0.0138791921,
0.0470380783,
-0.0433210246,
-0.0019351648,
0.0599340163,
0.0311440639,
-0.00375105,
-0.0376198031,
-0.0064468146,
-0.039944455,
0.0863474458,
0.0347199328,
-0.0243031923,
0.0073320949,
0.0482176766,
-0.0175708234,
0.031738773,
-0.0087034153,
0.0220901594,
-0.0128235091,
-0.0089843608,
0.0213828012,
0.0437785611,
-0.0277079772,
0.0149396872,
0.0244005658,
-0.0190598965,
-0.0230444539,
0.036697574,
-0.0197704285,
0.0402474701,
-0.0065265629,
0.0112336585,
-0.0318930745,
0.032101687,
-0.0105147082,
0.0076322495,
-0.0328234136,
0.0144745419,
0.032552775,
-0.0053770454,
-0.0293286946,
0.0192397628,
0.021641368,
-0.0057299435,
-0.0718619525,
0.0302716438,
0.0844785348,
-0.005204563,
0.0060615791,
-0.0103268977,
-0.0003435553,
-0.0318852365,
0.0606607199,
0.0133270947,
0.0127116721,
0.0445917025,
0.0072000129,
-0.0668079033,
-0.0412581787,
0.0438158326,
0.0139726177,
0.0170206558,
-0.0468518995,
0.0219166055,
-0.0169931538,
-0.0230137464,
-0.0584712662,
-0.0364165567,
-0.0352132842,
0.0028823775,
-0.0466519371,
-0.0007602734,
0.003407588,
0.012298326,
0.0265111178,
0.0229000729,
-0.0028741588,
-0.0425931774,
-0.0171916801,
0.0654552057,
0.0816715956,
-0.0490411781,
-0.010088332,
0.0072837556,
0.0754797235,
0.031838391,
-0.0109760007,
0.0091276318,
-0.0207641106,
-0.0043380097,
-0.0382260196,
-0.0301693529,
0.0166842546,
-0.0107292105,
0.0188292246,
-0.0539185591,
-0.026774887,
0.1085212603,
0.0156834628,
-0.0659590214,
-0.018183101,
0.0122431088,
-0.0110393539,
0.0296671558,
0.0118740452,
-0.0785686448,
-0.0542062335,
-0.0063990736,
-0.0404681042,
-0.0031489588,
-0.0818594098,
-0.0140540395,
-0.0946343914,
-0.0022274395,
-0.0309836809,
-0.0216395911,
-0.0099049611,
-0.0462961011,
0.0413718373,
-0.0142393345,
-0.0185577422,
-0.0079502426,
-0.0413298048,
0.0238349829,
-0.0124749392,
0.0386649147,
-0.0416442938,
0.0357184336,
-0.0407093428,
0.0192384291,
0.0178380683,
0.0161264874,
0.0029452902,
0.0528672636,
0.0351685733,
-0.0144144464,
-0.0038384234,
-0.0115644196,
0.0859711543,
-0.04898642,
0.0066354438,
-0.0454242863,
0.0077134557,
-0.0346020311,
-0.0115025276,
0.0319517516,
0.0831106976,
0.0043615815,
-0.0297026988,
0.0026569623,
-0.0142222606,
-0.0052459287,
0.0571567118,
0.0310320556,
-0.0258811004,
-0.0017730873,
0.011577934,
-0.0254503731,
-0.0210768171,
0.0196277928,
0.0006494938,
-0.0323509946,
0.028630903,
-0.0575559735,
-0.0650091916,
0.0365652852,
0.0727081224,
0.0084424205,
0.0354521424,
0.044508893,
0.0086890887,
-0.0516198911,
-0.0017883038,
-0.0241433717,
-0.0150188291,
0.0014367655,
0.0322718546,
0.0314914398,
-0.0298195481,
-0.021258872,
0.0031545572,
-0.0530469529,
-0.0296140779,
-0.0496372283,
0.0332705155,
0.0187771711,
0.0615352541,
-0.017629113,
-0.0006679329,
0.0296650715,
0.0806523114,
-0.0290864818,
-0.0233341753,
0.0182919763,
-0.0130470414,
0.0060556,
0.0309463274,
-0.0451793484,
0.0372176766,
0.0421305969,
0.0277522802,
-0.0669960156,
-0.0012174011,
0.0469242409,
-0.0085816905,
0.0740764663,
-0.0049987291,
-0.0227823779,
-0.0494738035,
0.0075064115,
-0.0591369458,
-0.0293277744,
-0.0292408932,
0.0426299386,
-0.0063309358,
-0.0013502295,
-0.0044980533,
-0.0624007545,
-0.0055870079,
0.0351602063,
0.0138720302,
-0.0281340368,
0.0294500291,
0.0223572776,
0.0289322622,
-0.0436398052,
-0.0225534122,
0.0037539252,
0.0404702686,
0.0124938516,
-0.0336079486,
0.06833978,
0.0462026186,
-0.0534072965,
-0.0270035788,
0.0172114428,
-0.0466627404,
0.0675103143,
-0.0097284568,
0.0141585106,
0.0703432113,
-0.0077825347,
0.0051496606,
-0.0133270565,
-0.0065866467,
0.0316015966,
0.0665345639,
-0.0212150663,
0.0074029444,
0.0116870273,
0.0264866706,
-0.0211073291,
0.0367084108,
0.0538547151,
-0.0194045529,
0.0443394855,
0.0418373533,
-0.0263716783,
-0.0498102494,
-0.0010909883,
-0.0492346212,
0.0283172447,
-0.0073270374,
0.0365234353,
-0.0784396678,
-0.0686641112,
-0.0178522002,
-0.0346962437,
-0.0080415653,
0.0390706174,
0.0056722714,
0.0103839096,
0.05167583,
-0.0343765914,
-0.0259770136,
0.0364181288,
0.0033658338,
-0.02137018,
-0.0233263001,
-6.260227408e-33,
-0.0449816771,
-0.046627216,
0.0270473678,
0.0148798162,
-0.0132549703,
0.0238707438,
-0.0579689331,
-0.0406961069,
-0.0555319078,
0.0505832955,
-0.0155156143,
-0.0021242676,
0.0086827436,
0.0078348294,
-0.0204666946,
-0.0201661903,
0.0108334161,
0.0207974184,
0.0195531826,
0.0130758286,
0.0660711378,
0.0469348542,
0.0523701832,
-0.0642108694,
0.012547777,
-0.0036108315,
0.0193751138,
0.0409674421,
0.025005199,
0.0256513618,
-0.0240172856,
0.0176418629,
0.0374233127,
-0.0081892461,
0.0481730625,
-0.0045046019,
-0.1534668952,
-0.0478512645,
-0.0014237041,
-0.0394823626,
-0.0289229229,
-0.0081327828,
-0.002217269,
0.0055495128,
0.0766040981,
-0.0395399332,
0.0615447238,
-0.0347683989,
-0.0154251279,
-0.0400770232,
-0.0781220049,
0.0323608182,
0.0238551535,
-0.0053276755,
0.0354956798,
0.0472815298,
0.0088323429,
-0.021585688,
-0.033623755,
-0.0316779576,
-0.0354166664,
-0.0141979856,
0.0183295645,
0.0223952699,
0.001098376,
0.0613590889,
-0.005999384,
-0.0113616632,
-0.0263517331,
0.0085763587,
-0.0148730669,
0.045955129,
-0.0325514413,
0.0522596091,
0.0486516245,
0.0381142423,
-0.1301798373,
-0.0145432688,
0.0556008853,
0.0666067451,
-0.0362938307,
-0.0350572057,
-0.0403102711,
-0.0050810031,
0.000740629,
-0.0505457669,
-0.0243081786,
-0.028995201,
-0.0032178087,
0.0113536054,
-0.0062649189,
0.0263910722,
0.0199393425,
-0.0167710092,
-0.0124913566,
0.0370627195,
-0.0095219268,
0.0186806582,
0.0087566366,
0.012386458,
-0.0722504333,
-0.0286515467,
0.0056011621,
0.0328814387,
0.0324154012,
0.0394802392,
0.102799803,
-0.0263360143,
-0.0342580229,
-0.0299847107,
-0.0568735115,
0.0050837989,
-0.0328937918,
0.0022218481,
0.0040138201,
0.0613451079,
-0.0169598926,
0.0468404107,
0.0320425518,
-0.017955495,
0.0131258974,
0.0501454286,
0.0012595366,
0.0008380098,
0.0180252884,
-0.0179639459,
0.0108777341,
0.0090040555,
0.0391314663,
-0.0659526512,
-0.0006359611,
0.0177348312,
2.628e-7,
0.0204808973,
0.0322120897,
0.0327873304,
0.0063012624,
0.0030627854,
0.0373379961,
0.0111443484,
0.0007658405,
0.0148587683,
-0.030839432,
0.0299289338,
0.0241174754,
-0.0028359841,
0.0517883264,
-0.0604008958,
-0.019303048,
-0.0492973588,
-0.0860295668,
-0.0449215546,
-0.0284145828,
0.0619767904,
0.0405540727,
0.0507621467,
0.0040544206,
-0.0443706065,
-0.042225007,
0.0642299801,
-0.0141040077,
0.0155683309,
0.0071177101,
-0.0157091189,
-0.0153359585,
-0.0311028697,
0.0734273791,
-0.0010558751,
0.0323704816,
-0.0228862837,
0.0352734812,
-0.0345665179,
0.0245890431,
0.011810354,
-0.0210560616,
0.0401597023,
0.0044619991,
0.0819038227,
-0.0984263271,
-0.0101993699,
-0.0053483569,
-0.0446602516,
0.0113453921,
-0.0271787904,
0.0262653884,
-0.0098614227,
0.0256926734,
0.0203348342,
-0.0074329288,
-0.0388246216,
-0.0770971999,
0.0114905015,
0.0751504228,
0.0245549791,
-0.0086146938,
0.0223477073,
-0.0399970077,
0.0186829064,
-0.0647944808,
0.0143463984,
2.249987564e-34,
-0.0018695713,
-0.0132754566,
0.0044931644,
0.0253750812,
0.019340219,
-0.0241422988,
-0.0918224752,
-0.0125430888,
0.0340581127,
-0.0887052864,
0.0177547857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05915v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05915v3 | Fake Alignment: Are LLMs Really Aligned Well? | 2023-11-10T08:01:23 | 2024-04-01T03:32:14 | Yixu Wang, Yan Teng, Kexin Huang, Chengqi Lyu, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Xingjun Ma, Yu-Gang Jiang, Yu Qiao, Yingchun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The growing awareness of safety concerns in large language models (LLMs) has
sparked considerable interest in the evaluation of safety. This study
investigates an under-explored issue about the evaluation of LLMs, namely the
substantial discrepancy in performance between multiple-choice questions and
open-ended questions. Inspired by research on jailbreak attack patterns, we
argue this is caused by mismatched generalization. That is, LLM only remembers
the answer style for open-ended safety questions, which makes it unable to
solve other forms of safety tests. We refer to this phenomenon as fake
alignment and construct a comparative benchmark to empirically verify its
existence in LLMs. We introduce a Fake alIgNment Evaluation (FINE) framework
and two novel metrics--Consistency Score (CS) and Consistent Safety Score
(CSS), which jointly assess two complementary forms of evaluation to quantify
fake alignment and obtain corrected performance estimation. Applying FINE to 14
widely-used LLMs reveals several models with purported safety are poorly
aligned in practice. Subsequently, we found that multiple-choice format data
can also be used as high-quality contrast distillation-based fine-tuning data,
which can strongly improve the alignment consistency of LLMs with minimal
fine-tuning overhead. For data and code, see
https://github.com/AIFlames/Fake-Alignment. | [
0.0063832416,
0.0372410156,
-0.0312824138,
0.0527852252,
-0.0477355719,
-0.002845475,
0.00117088,
-0.0111074857,
0.0104357041,
-0.0177679695,
0.0096987383,
-0.0478373356,
0.0142329782,
-0.0117438193,
0.0464158803,
0.02044563,
0.0897682235,
-0.0537440628,
-0.018884778,
0.0199380293,
0.0317210071,
-0.0120979771,
0.00119432,
0.0198047999,
0.0336275473,
-0.0373081751,
-0.0333972201,
0.0062959068,
0.051862672,
-0.0439267233,
0.0149475187,
0.0604392998,
-0.0314161219,
0.0429148562,
0.0000020612,
-0.075465776,
-0.0235246681,
0.0194291901,
0.0010816064,
0.0677607507,
-0.0111652659,
0.0033660994,
-0.0124651669,
0.0339529216,
-0.0298043117,
-0.0033680194,
0.0482462756,
-0.0099655036,
0.0661706701,
0.06920214,
0.013811822,
0.0026354073,
0.0567569546,
0.0180443246,
0.0063950797,
-0.0453264453,
0.024270121,
0.0067335237,
0.0045780754,
0.0226645172,
-0.0087107662,
0.0045779534,
0.0018482603,
0.0026440411,
-0.0368549414,
-0.0287707392,
-0.0683537647,
-0.0331083462,
0.011439505,
0.068102926,
-0.00765653,
-0.0122791035,
-0.0092732795,
-0.0287848357,
0.0014392071,
0.022302568,
-0.030704435,
0.0228001736,
-0.0060380078,
-0.0111299474,
0.0273226928,
-0.0319132321,
0.0325363502,
-0.0122412471,
0.0110645667,
0.0639594868,
0.025072271,
-0.0408139117,
0.0037523541,
-0.0303465202,
-0.0402934663,
-0.0555826575,
-0.0119140008,
0.0180473998,
-0.0361951441,
0.0369660109,
-0.0487695523,
-0.0388775468,
0.0833441094,
-0.0537747182,
0.0203700922,
0.0501046106,
0.0104270205,
-0.0041185366,
0.0054532764,
0.0758170113,
-0.0199417323,
0.0496311449,
-0.028245559,
0.0468650088,
0.0124533586,
0.0012113336,
0.0292161386,
0.0279036742,
0.0195992384,
0.0267942473,
-0.0585512333,
0.0357573032,
-0.0115234647,
0.06220733,
-0.0294290353,
-0.0161392074,
0.0060244408,
0.0195168369,
0.0238177255,
0.025700938,
-0.0182433724,
-0.0038166842,
0.0308796354,
-0.0574901141,
-0.0057764677,
-0.0122192511,
-0.0424027666,
-0.0463257097,
-0.0130343968,
0.0920637995,
0.0041474658,
0.0067766611,
-0.0321007185,
-0.0390401073,
-0.0574771762,
-0.0319001786,
-0.0129596014,
-0.0949258357,
-0.0078421878,
0.0360331014,
-0.0193462502,
-0.0514899343,
0.0169682186,
0.0331437364,
-0.0288062859,
0.0181863513,
-0.0118050259,
0.0139178,
-0.0153848212,
0.0302479714,
0.0143718245,
0.0555092394,
0.0417136773,
-0.0003873705,
0.0367634743,
-0.0733871534,
0.0109368023,
0.0666683689,
-0.0067048082,
0.0371263549,
-0.0087736202,
0.0233914908,
0.0623709895,
0.027334407,
-0.0126365339,
0.0660806894,
0.0166992266,
-0.0163965244,
0.0564636551,
0.0296625383,
-0.004921508,
0.0196806546,
-0.0284918528,
-0.0028138792,
0.0223371964,
0.0235467087,
-0.0605717599,
-0.0102180811,
-0.0887901112,
0.0283722151,
0.0090673799,
0.0482403226,
0.00293439,
-0.0203576908,
-0.058286164,
0.0199020803,
-0.0086424723,
0.0265754182,
0.0039433101,
-0.0393733792,
-0.0326814353,
0.0502843969,
0.020761935,
-0.0540270545,
-0.0308362916,
-0.0384515747,
0.0338602774,
0.0433476344,
0.0530188605,
-0.0087687382,
-0.0708166212,
-0.0053548426,
-0.0006790831,
-0.0099279331,
0.048312854,
0.0057693464,
0.0238713939,
-0.0344918482,
-0.0292468444,
-0.0207953788,
-0.0013136474,
-0.0206506662,
0.0240730755,
0.0028414153,
-0.000452676,
-0.0368074104,
-0.0909457877,
0.0353236794,
-0.011610521,
-0.0256501865,
-0.0463523939,
0.0135049354,
0.0061165756,
-0.0103967618,
-0.0346882381,
0.0072327233,
0.0274337232,
0.0274207741,
0.0469785221,
-0.0418439396,
-0.0441987514,
0.0188706759,
0.0702363774,
-0.0223797057,
-0.0315876119,
0.0736821368,
-0.0371300578,
-0.0195940044,
-0.0087498361,
-0.0241717417,
-0.0165521055,
0.0272073429,
0.06475465,
-0.0334329084,
-0.0087334635,
-0.0624116175,
0.0285356529,
0.0036101567,
0.0461491346,
-0.0239076987,
0.0135126198,
0.0187327489,
-0.0084668966,
-0.0667762011,
0.0256780628,
-0.0413670912,
0.043768432,
0.0250841044,
0.0168785471,
-0.077569589,
-0.0200855359,
-0.0553966165,
0.0341122858,
-0.0007195696,
0.0277918503,
0.0465376116,
0.0223786402,
-0.0264768228,
0.0223412197,
-0.03935536,
-0.0188998245,
-0.0014345563,
0.0269027743,
0.0242863074,
-0.0180522911,
-0.0418515503,
-0.0547098443,
-0.0199073441,
-0.0569447726,
0.0352832563,
-0.0250752363,
0.0221553538,
-0.0462575294,
0.0577423833,
-0.0299604572,
-0.0072265193,
0.0024735758,
-0.0436313711,
0.0191097017,
0.0239575729,
0.0197452307,
0.0568512492,
0.0171697475,
-0.021227574,
0.0595938228,
-0.0061939028,
-0.0702494979,
-0.0035550352,
0.0233843513,
-0.0673014969,
-0.0302702058,
-0.0873023346,
-0.013273146,
0.0741094872,
-0.0001187826,
-0.017989805,
-0.0077366042,
-0.0126254559,
-0.0264908541,
-0.0083529949,
-0.0111806607,
-0.0261295903,
-0.0499186777,
0.0311791636,
-0.0175959393,
-0.0860695764,
0.0631594062,
-0.0362002887,
0.0309049301,
-0.0296691321,
-0.0106132086,
-0.0208248701,
0.0415165536,
-0.025570754,
0.0237696338,
0.0343902148,
-0.0297852308,
-0.0752310231,
-0.0323877856,
0.043391373,
-0.0672316104,
0.0948602259,
-0.0582796931,
-0.0021955261,
-0.0279581845,
-0.0224465132,
-0.0471618362,
-0.0548631623,
-0.003791803,
-0.0278147813,
0.0226696786,
-0.0153237311,
-0.0057099741,
-0.0142543353,
0.0350702368,
-0.0155796492,
-0.0350280702,
0.011003064,
-0.0144709572,
0.0166989937,
0.0546795055,
-0.0491558313,
0.0260512941,
-0.0387012549,
0.0390033312,
0.0721766204,
0.0518472865,
0.0411996916,
-0.0209760908,
-0.0171547886,
0.0484487675,
-0.0268972814,
-0.0331518278,
0.0702213347,
0.0952821746,
-0.0441341586,
-0.0214589313,
0.0659699664,
0.0323421471,
0.0208299663,
0.0275189858,
-0.0155952079,
0.0539711528,
0.031608887,
0.030005591,
-0.0540763624,
-0.0067853718,
0.0104150018,
0.0450868942,
-0.0009266518,
-0.0345684998,
0.0080014924,
-0.1037077233,
-0.0102731604,
0.0374788716,
-0.0624215528,
0.0018249139,
-0.0278406087,
0.0205826107,
0.0001197305,
0.0681013241,
0.0470673181,
-0.0031155371,
-0.0138333598,
0.0294795986,
-0.0513576977,
-0.0113113662,
0.0254616626,
-0.0428217649,
0.0544972792,
0.0600513667,
-0.0314710103,
-0.0297764689,
-0.0453901589,
0.0682814345,
-0.0137623446,
-0.0177203845,
0.0032007522,
0.0218058545,
0.0168965552,
0.0070100701,
-0.0239067972,
-0.0054408493,
-0.0016564294,
-0.026918117,
0.0570431128,
0.0652566701,
0.003915648,
-0.0249594599,
-0.0446552448,
-0.0175887905,
-0.0186631773,
0.0398913436,
0.0251971092,
-0.0323569775,
-0.0205363352,
-0.0665685683,
-0.0188440736,
-0.0359279253,
-0.0320061743,
0.0307980143,
-0.0049913824,
-0.0007260471,
-0.012820553,
-0.0244014654,
0.009343978,
0.0158451758,
0.0281477179,
-0.0139436703,
-0.0122147799,
0.0048475699,
-0.0226183292,
0.0258891489,
-0.0053327023,
0.0440793559,
-0.0389180742,
0.0492604151,
-0.0253477599,
0.0265883747,
0.0000090075,
0.0231324024,
-0.0859318003,
-0.0956620798,
0.0097237248,
0.0570687912,
0.0247488264,
-0.0084636891,
-0.0013912428,
-0.0493373647,
0.0160089936,
0.0286756139,
-0.0227677301,
0.0141736642,
0.0027005421,
-0.058869794,
0.0223193411,
-0.0083084693,
-0.0429030657,
-0.0590904169,
0.0523407906,
0.0513453111,
-0.0409520939,
-0.0241951048,
0.0304727722,
0.0615783632,
0.0402955376,
-0.0007430103,
0.0134626571,
0.0230144151,
0.0099644484,
-0.0184711479,
-0.0406461284,
0.0117349876,
-0.0157488976,
0.0276581366,
-0.0200593639,
0.028417239,
0.0174999796,
-0.0229641926,
0.0462448373,
-0.017786311,
0.0331242271,
0.0030884005,
0.0359411724,
0.0636816546,
0.0157664996,
-0.0491127037,
0.0290306062,
-0.0111312587,
0.0547641031,
0.0205584634,
0.0526574329,
-0.0202068239,
0.0237864684,
0.0305707175,
0.0258568879,
-0.0615062937,
-0.0479047783,
-0.0202167891,
0.0070929318,
-0.0053225709,
0.0040401225,
0.0389996879,
0.0203265417,
0.0138105927,
-0.0556148998,
0.014748889,
-0.034717422,
-0.0354486518,
0.0418580621,
0.0307386182,
-0.0090907207,
-0.0217249263,
0.0660086423,
-0.0004840255,
0.0083972346,
-0.0188575145,
-0.0120192673,
-0.0246331934,
-0.0089085,
0.0382168293,
0.0315657891,
-0.0437175594,
-0.0647053942,
-0.087660104,
-0.094121851,
0.0135935713,
0.0292814262,
0.0378886685,
0.0078427177,
-0.0065514632,
0.0518288687,
-0.0208911505,
-0.0090830345,
-0.0097121103,
-0.0037450867,
-0.0313675515,
-0.035184253,
-0.0203325432,
-5.86935166e-33,
-0.004634928,
-0.0155204153,
-0.0048208185,
-0.0364027061,
-0.0233763047,
-0.0103581697,
-0.0286523644,
0.0489897169,
-0.0494507886,
-0.0451874509,
-0.0192756392,
0.0027580673,
-0.0018474871,
0.0078900205,
0.0119474512,
-0.0403785668,
-0.0289027039,
0.0289896186,
-0.0425409563,
-0.003305566,
0.0070540896,
-0.0023629686,
0.068966873,
-0.0642616376,
0.0429646634,
-0.031625025,
0.0004287414,
-0.0143499356,
-0.0563913658,
0.0649744868,
0.0289241076,
0.0412811413,
-0.0054722368,
-0.0143553279,
0.0003193749,
0.0282060467,
0.0088956412,
-0.0378886163,
0.0572044365,
0.0038102029,
-0.0259801727,
-0.0558592044,
0.0571063198,
-0.0076500317,
-0.028701419,
-0.0485007018,
0.0193290133,
-0.017508097,
-0.0319447331,
-0.0027359664,
-0.0343409665,
0.0174748152,
-0.0445247702,
0.0085914712,
-0.0492769219,
0.0372201763,
0.0245372262,
0.0162447467,
-0.0151409032,
0.0178986695,
0.0451861024,
0.0312860236,
0.1004319862,
0.0239991639,
-0.0185660403,
0.0786946416,
-0.0172240678,
-0.0067097023,
0.0209166668,
-0.0157762505,
0.0161004886,
0.0311761033,
0.055563461,
0.0859935954,
0.0339532234,
-0.0095444229,
-0.0874890909,
0.0297080241,
-0.0118054859,
0.0352284499,
-0.0048354971,
-0.0002167242,
-0.0729956627,
-0.0226543155,
-0.0435004607,
0.0325742401,
-0.023671085,
-0.0455612876,
0.0409694687,
-0.0646401495,
-0.0160243213,
-0.0198079031,
0.0132344821,
-0.0327290781,
-0.0048936973,
-0.0031829539,
-0.0346323214,
0.0164001025,
-0.0254288912,
0.0540618487,
-0.0215275586,
-0.0121548148,
-0.0177474618,
-0.0350080691,
0.0614221022,
0.0220647678,
0.029503379,
0.0084332088,
-0.0769576132,
-0.0016992392,
-0.0267440155,
0.0011636879,
0.0175438225,
-0.0391421877,
0.0500048324,
-0.0075305728,
0.0011396692,
0.0311855022,
0.0503952429,
-0.0020621819,
-0.0580666065,
-0.0148475347,
-0.0248028785,
0.0016918874,
0.0093757976,
-0.0112529984,
0.0136503652,
0.0408496261,
0.027958909,
-0.0500131212,
-0.0216795113,
0.0162669588,
2.747e-7,
0.0531661212,
0.0218220633,
0.0166798476,
0.0212087072,
-0.01649151,
0.0510966219,
-0.0321677849,
0.0481862612,
0.0463615395,
-0.0275006481,
-0.0080239456,
-0.0085591264,
0.0543148145,
0.0608150996,
-0.0200874377,
0.0174222738,
-0.0533571541,
0.0193486046,
-0.0649865866,
0.0477907732,
0.0447353423,
0.0578288473,
-0.0007604941,
-0.0007438137,
-0.0301425047,
-0.0508949831,
0.0168916844,
-0.0129909636,
-0.0062062219,
0.044594951,
-0.0019283935,
0.0050371615,
0.0150212329,
0.0314833336,
0.0097171925,
-0.0064958627,
-0.0016134949,
0.0527807735,
-0.000448812,
0.0113229416,
-0.0204866324,
-0.055390913,
0.0099819163,
-0.0770118535,
0.0617887713,
-0.0131566357,
-0.0011492254,
-0.0243238732,
-0.0427808911,
-0.0338559598,
0.0189464204,
-0.0049476386,
0.0318891779,
0.0205810163,
0.0026315481,
-0.0011863034,
-0.0124449711,
-0.0163007267,
-0.0514533669,
0.0394723602,
0.0142854666,
-0.0879677385,
-0.0155640626,
0.02230989,
0.0019523251,
-0.055939123,
0.0016355995,
2.846841147e-34,
-0.0061384486,
-0.0434098244,
0.043938525,
0.0079489583,
0.0277105384,
-0.0120119471,
0.0154075157,
0.0343367308,
-0.0078745084,
-0.0486913398,
-0.0350887738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05902v1 | Citation Recommendation on Scholarly Legal Articles | 2023-11-10T07:11:55 | 2023-11-10T07:11:55 | Doğukan Arslan, Saadet Sena Erdoğan, Gülşen Eryiğit | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.3; I.2.7 | Citation recommendation is the task of finding appropriate citations based on
a given piece of text. The proposed datasets for this task consist mainly of
several scientific fields, lacking some core ones, such as law. Furthermore,
citation recommendation is used within the legal domain to identify supporting
arguments, utilizing non-scholarly legal articles. In order to alleviate the
limitations of existing studies, we gather the first scholarly legal dataset
for the task of citation recommendation. Also, we conduct experiments with
state-of-the-art models and compare their performance on this dataset. The
study suggests that, while BM25 is a strong benchmark for the legal citation
recommendation task, the most effective method involves implementing a two-step
process that entails pre-fetching with BM25+, followed by re-ranking with
SciNCL, which enhances the performance of the baseline from 0.26 to 0.30
MAP@10. Moreover, fine-tuning leads to considerable performance increases in
pre-trained models, which shows the importance of including legal articles in
the training data of these models. | [
0.0580478273,
0.0180361699,
0.0102877226,
-0.021977419,
-0.0372724868,
0.0077855689,
0.0395666473,
0.0522407517,
0.0496632941,
-0.0647945553,
-0.0347817615,
0.0165393166,
-0.0188037064,
-0.0225686915,
-0.0259111635,
-0.001576021,
0.0175044313,
0.0207735393,
0.0961465687,
0.0053755506,
-0.0256101228,
0.0242010541,
-0.003468896,
-0.0011203075,
0.039198786,
-0.0324688368,
0.0265810993,
-0.0071288729,
0.0243835393,
-0.0225863829,
0.0382793993,
0.0514870696,
0.0027627926,
0.0177431572,
0.0000017711,
-0.0342953615,
0.011798461,
0.0057195597,
0.0092347544,
0.0408335812,
0.0603880659,
0.0017638211,
-0.0053609191,
-0.0051686992,
-0.0479484163,
0.0618194863,
-0.020158574,
0.0342610441,
0.004479724,
0.057802964,
-0.0065295352,
-0.0735475793,
0.0472535379,
-0.0532161333,
0.0098936008,
-0.0192104522,
0.050271228,
0.0195303597,
0.0308313519,
0.0683057383,
0.0195582937,
-0.0189436246,
0.0042940592,
-0.0420884341,
0.0311931726,
0.0092613157,
-0.0102084326,
0.0299201608,
0.0339557417,
0.0620150827,
0.0139806466,
-0.0436792448,
0.0404063687,
0.0044751745,
0.0258630142,
0.0613069758,
-0.0236500185,
0.0547418445,
-0.0132469591,
-0.0156785287,
0.0180654824,
0.0179885477,
0.0148878032,
0.0323471092,
0.0260250755,
0.0230741594,
0.0024027738,
-0.0304940213,
0.0339524075,
0.0038253751,
0.0343824588,
-0.0275734365,
0.0210301317,
-0.0027926282,
-0.0106883999,
-0.0023102467,
0.0082075726,
-0.012679344,
0.0726634264,
-0.0411923602,
-0.0165927596,
-0.0193669666,
-0.025323363,
0.0765452757,
-0.057738021,
-0.0495610237,
-0.0356452279,
0.0066661472,
0.0511338674,
-0.0239312407,
-0.0220355168,
0.0154791512,
0.0181632414,
0.0433616117,
-0.0708423257,
0.0189043134,
-0.0404198617,
-0.0012257386,
-0.0203555394,
0.0134126665,
0.01338105,
-0.0048131836,
0.0090289973,
-0.0008222826,
-0.0465305746,
-0.0518022031,
-0.0313971899,
0.0464589447,
-0.0112511385,
0.0120933484,
0.0110975513,
-0.0172797628,
0.0217771791,
-0.0438758843,
0.0329702049,
0.0645072237,
0.0270395316,
-0.0542294495,
-0.016300546,
-0.0449364372,
0.0127165141,
-0.0881445482,
-0.00770299,
-0.0517986529,
-0.0006225025,
-0.0061395834,
-0.0012634672,
-0.0478071943,
-0.004919365,
0.0489524789,
-0.0411531366,
0.0187491607,
-0.014789341,
-0.0472439677,
-0.0256548114,
0.0403285623,
0.0515019521,
-0.0070893676,
-0.0311911535,
-0.0064330674,
0.06118045,
0.0115392208,
0.0013887485,
-0.0157305859,
0.0177023597,
0.0262587108,
0.0527828448,
0.0175942034,
-0.0544440895,
0.0416494682,
0.0270962324,
0.0052241059,
-0.0346329696,
-0.0418277308,
0.0054511665,
0.0376324914,
0.0209101886,
0.0563138276,
-0.0144123659,
0.0152324112,
0.0238992386,
-0.0294215437,
-0.0279515032,
0.0622215383,
-0.0220314506,
0.0151487999,
-0.0064536063,
0.0205098018,
-0.0189737044,
-0.0461713634,
0.002043542,
0.0148997344,
-0.0421322882,
0.0069268108,
0.0366941467,
0.0123667652,
-0.0375597402,
0.0192653798,
0.0228501745,
-0.0403212272,
-0.0496599525,
0.026515536,
0.0427198559,
-0.0169885289,
0.0584831946,
-0.0175163876,
-0.0199868679,
-0.0217626784,
-0.0128530469,
0.0340138562,
-0.0209048577,
0.000351517,
-0.0042282389,
-0.0452113561,
-0.0523792766,
0.0104867723,
0.028760789,
0.0024824482,
0.0287072379,
0.0364552028,
0.0341976546,
-0.0803040415,
-0.0316779874,
0.0299375169,
-0.0267013237,
-0.0035033738,
0.0053298711,
-0.0230638292,
0.0645636842,
0.0298740994,
-0.0118017178,
-0.0185819417,
0.0602115691,
0.0163580813,
0.0284196548,
0.0021630798,
0.022169739,
-0.0021089627,
0.0471722335,
-0.0401535667,
0.0221791118,
0.0281658825,
-0.0308040902,
0.0010542743,
0.0150203109,
0.0394127257,
-0.0415868051,
-0.0111189131,
-0.0327990875,
-0.0272596702,
-0.0060085999,
-0.0172555149,
0.0433236472,
0.0123800226,
0.0352753587,
0.0464900471,
-0.0245797671,
0.0283436254,
-0.0115822712,
-0.039930094,
-0.0363997966,
-0.0120484205,
-0.02403697,
0.0179574098,
-0.0226832125,
-0.0496041439,
0.0212540757,
-0.0236555766,
0.0065158163,
0.0037040485,
-0.0293834787,
-0.021135252,
-0.0466978997,
0.0132384421,
-0.0255431179,
-0.0053942367,
-0.0182196591,
-0.0472127423,
-0.0261699744,
0.0171155147,
-0.0147952968,
0.0021332225,
-0.0386619717,
-0.0536631942,
0.0001307971,
0.0319041982,
0.0226186272,
0.0241232328,
0.0038450081,
0.0534008294,
-0.024989618,
-0.0279164705,
-0.060860645,
0.0414433964,
-0.0155163379,
0.0023674718,
-0.0311688464,
0.0328810886,
0.0279586073,
-0.0128384531,
0.0453972556,
0.0375407636,
-0.0791909322,
-0.0359673426,
-0.00010737,
0.0360233486,
-0.0075254762,
0.0143892663,
0.0496164449,
0.0026693642,
-0.0434162878,
-0.0193626564,
-0.0031867002,
0.0024323955,
0.048190441,
0.0212667771,
-0.043526765,
0.0073240516,
-0.0056883022,
0.0468265191,
0.0225263331,
-0.0472787693,
0.0365251489,
-0.0012370433,
0.0304414574,
-0.0440854989,
0.0062703504,
-0.0299553145,
0.0201570392,
0.0295694694,
-0.026882885,
-0.0211742967,
0.0132507067,
0.0137860449,
0.0166033432,
0.0539228469,
-0.0467281416,
0.0186904501,
0.0280672908,
0.0405529812,
-0.0162399355,
-0.0137243541,
-0.0010910351,
-0.040692877,
-0.0162144452,
0.0291801933,
-0.0060368171,
-0.0151684731,
-0.0221064407,
-0.0341965891,
0.0080575766,
0.0322102271,
-0.0153258825,
-0.0329393186,
-0.0149284471,
0.0462230332,
0.0146997161,
-0.0619862601,
0.0124407038,
0.0150810191,
-0.0014025653,
0.0238033477,
0.0114912111,
-0.0296781454,
-0.0113605,
-0.0357482061,
0.0362960286,
-0.0882347524,
0.0025588418,
0.0185398646,
-0.0250457339,
-0.0170296729,
0.0285480749,
0.0635326281,
0.0114305736,
-0.0736275837,
-0.0367463678,
-0.0275866836,
-0.0045133964,
0.0430680253,
0.0137563217,
-0.122211583,
0.0338962041,
-0.0001943959,
0.0084086377,
-0.0321659036,
-0.0344270989,
-0.0120936763,
-0.1258014143,
0.0855631456,
-0.0030834645,
0.0321510248,
-0.0364959985,
-0.0634626076,
0.0127851348,
-0.0336183347,
-0.026630206,
0.0266430322,
-0.0260514189,
-0.0022388452,
0.0141318208,
0.001751224,
-0.031498462,
0.0448128879,
-0.0699330196,
0.0194811858,
-0.0112256603,
0.0447039902,
-0.0220244937,
-0.0178239066,
0.0144684464,
-0.0150926551,
-0.0116243521,
0.0027398125,
0.048797369,
-0.0201570299,
0.0351170562,
-0.0362082794,
0.039872881,
0.0059925271,
-0.0329054296,
0.0473315082,
0.0411266983,
-0.0396241546,
0.0120071936,
-0.0577165149,
0.0103352685,
-0.0507788435,
0.0310867038,
0.0123201814,
0.0167812053,
-0.0135292914,
0.0035628856,
-0.0091821048,
-0.0436777547,
-0.0410858877,
-0.0349458121,
-0.037909247,
0.0359612741,
-0.0400716029,
-0.0120690344,
-0.036035832,
0.0320865996,
0.0187502354,
0.0707471222,
0.0052433442,
-0.0316385105,
-0.0259093791,
0.0391435176,
-0.0314353518,
0.0088119004,
-0.0127818249,
0.0102322884,
0.0491215847,
-0.0090121888,
-0.0272528864,
-0.0267487988,
0.0679923967,
-0.0073701446,
-0.0326718353,
0.0327623524,
0.0165421385,
0.03875174,
-0.0737798288,
-0.0662448853,
0.0542965569,
0.0791301802,
-0.0116932001,
-0.0144522367,
0.0253219288,
-0.0703812316,
-0.0428997055,
-0.0313284844,
-0.0350866467,
0.0359727331,
-0.0229768399,
-0.0088935103,
-0.0251390152,
-0.0064841211,
0.0036299615,
0.0345579088,
0.0633206517,
0.0021223132,
0.0142865283,
-0.0009005083,
0.0115259364,
-0.009667391,
0.0021720158,
-0.001031513,
0.0316725224,
0.0244781561,
-0.0040141605,
-0.0430100337,
0.0569598749,
-0.0023136467,
0.0378371775,
-0.0635588169,
0.0251002796,
0.0005876091,
0.015411485,
-0.014120291,
-0.0329562724,
-0.0221942831,
-0.0191576425,
-0.0167382434,
0.0455338769,
0.0038866519,
0.0292084794,
0.0181076657,
0.0149765238,
0.0360747911,
0.0161920302,
-0.1030210033,
0.0073863273,
-0.0340607576,
0.0137112783,
0.0561926141,
-0.0308043975,
0.0294229817,
-0.0324985273,
-0.0197214186,
-0.0210206304,
0.0327636339,
-0.0159037225,
0.0008290631,
0.0386698991,
0.0134084783,
-0.0198618565,
0.0403206199,
0.0251790863,
0.0478033982,
-0.0082623567,
0.0070207366,
-0.0183574017,
-0.0042663091,
-0.0196580235,
-0.0806090087,
0.0541525967,
-0.014043672,
-0.0644404739,
-0.0212099236,
-0.0001720682,
0.0226756465,
-0.0166119933,
-0.0031885598,
-0.0034759385,
0.0098998677,
0.030976817,
0.0107708955,
-0.0145110497,
-0.0505376905,
0.0429385379,
-0.0561324731,
-0.0327006802,
-0.0215807017,
-5.72246409e-33,
0.0046631796,
-0.0466332622,
-0.0161736943,
0.0168366954,
-0.008193166,
-0.0256531853,
-0.0191569813,
-0.0318682604,
-0.0412709229,
0.0202754326,
-0.0347551592,
0.0335484073,
0.0059386916,
-0.0041197296,
0.0505045764,
0.0134164542,
0.0276574306,
0.0048133689,
-0.0108527457,
0.0144701032,
0.0079870634,
0.0178836137,
0.0234838035,
-0.1214012429,
0.0519204177,
0.0066720252,
0.0007870603,
-0.0438317694,
-0.0393237211,
0.0760483146,
0.0007201688,
0.0470329672,
0.0219946764,
-0.0675815046,
0.0231215637,
0.0161132161,
-0.1017900035,
0.0441378132,
0.0385539755,
-0.027746262,
-0.0078186998,
-0.0502452478,
0.0243647974,
0.0075747366,
-0.0471679531,
-0.0233080946,
0.0683362111,
-0.0382316373,
-0.0713008195,
-0.1135590822,
-0.0229685027,
0.0334523953,
-0.0017519516,
0.0677668378,
0.0022228539,
0.0559515022,
0.0017843732,
0.1287311912,
-0.0373845808,
0.0165445507,
-0.0150999492,
-0.0020949859,
-0.0273655448,
-0.0868358389,
0.0183333308,
0.0185074192,
-0.0374309756,
-0.0444205739,
-0.0139150582,
-0.0385872908,
0.013202033,
0.0626857728,
0.054540541,
0.0986322984,
0.0599030629,
-0.0149098793,
-0.056658458,
-0.0018143837,
0.0708687603,
0.0235697497,
0.0456562676,
-0.0307128578,
0.0140962815,
0.0139181586,
-0.0141655803,
-0.0697566494,
-0.0039431248,
-0.0044595366,
0.001276986,
0.0163401514,
0.0500311926,
-0.0021023403,
0.0069893021,
-0.0377705917,
-0.0213934202,
0.1060664654,
-0.0004716848,
0.031139439,
0.0165564548,
-0.0207693744,
-0.0895669609,
-0.022101108,
0.0076062772,
-0.0384114906,
-0.0134188673,
-0.0455038138,
0.045505479,
-0.0673883185,
-0.0386578776,
-0.0260038767,
0.0324259736,
0.0242932029,
0.0142518906,
0.0389696434,
-0.0174196176,
0.0559333563,
0.0211235508,
0.0381263718,
0.0213658642,
0.0495650172,
-0.0020632637,
-0.0063243764,
0.0077055725,
-0.0080647031,
0.0340527333,
-0.021544667,
0.0269398764,
0.0509202369,
-0.0126858149,
-0.0322128423,
0.0220189467,
0.0108405761,
2.623e-7,
0.0461676754,
0.020855071,
-0.040485993,
-0.0645243302,
-0.0077927816,
0.001320478,
0.046163056,
0.0264565498,
0.0269235745,
0.0242319405,
0.0124141751,
-0.0474271215,
0.0343196169,
-0.0102226501,
-0.0653486699,
-0.0981177092,
-0.093138501,
-0.0633846596,
-0.0107506784,
-0.0209993366,
-0.0561316833,
0.0652002692,
0.0083037317,
-0.0063818493,
-0.0053707915,
-0.0121674761,
0.068782039,
-0.0636805445,
-0.0023417608,
-0.0504568256,
0.0676474869,
0.0143700009,
-0.0072735325,
0.0244831368,
-0.0041656159,
0.0753524229,
-0.0413821228,
0.0340850279,
0.041083362,
-0.0003537278,
0.0151241571,
-0.0055128802,
0.0355968289,
-0.0141246859,
0.046555575,
-0.0062976251,
-0.0058159293,
-0.0281469729,
-0.099167116,
-0.005318081,
0.0080793444,
0.0264175087,
-0.0207832474,
-0.0100875823,
0.0061416891,
-0.0232106447,
0.0181837417,
-0.0803121924,
0.0167834461,
0.0820345432,
0.0180184022,
-0.0073789037,
0.0109636746,
-0.0419498272,
0.0560343601,
-0.057137724,
0.0141636385,
1.992456496e-34,
0.0531182103,
0.0019758653,
0.0217937287,
0.0288519543,
-0.0251963641,
0.0367508121,
-0.0394244231,
0.0015916321,
0.0074210633,
-0.0551802851,
0.0260805599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07593v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07593v2 | Follow-Up Differential Descriptions: Language Models Resolve Ambiguities for Image Classification | 2023-11-10T05:24:07 | 2024-03-15T08:58:05 | Reza Esfandiarpoor, Stephen H. Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | A promising approach for improving the performance of vision-language models
like CLIP for image classification is to extend the class descriptions (i.e.,
prompts) with related attributes, e.g., using brown sparrow instead of sparrow.
However, current zero-shot methods select a subset of attributes regardless of
commonalities between the target classes, potentially providing no useful
information that would have helped to distinguish between them. For instance,
they may use color instead of bill shape to distinguish between sparrows and
wrens, which are both brown. We propose Follow-up Differential Descriptions
(FuDD), a zero-shot approach that tailors the class descriptions to each
dataset and leads to additional attributes that better differentiate the target
classes. FuDD first identifies the ambiguous classes for each image, and then
uses a Large Language Model (LLM) to generate new class descriptions that
differentiate between them. The new class descriptions resolve the initial
ambiguity and help predict the correct label. In our experiments, FuDD
consistently outperforms generic description ensembles and naive LLM-generated
descriptions on 12 datasets. We show that differential descriptions are an
effective tool to resolve class ambiguities, which otherwise significantly
degrade the performance. We also show that high quality natural language class
descriptions produced by FuDD result in comparable performance to few-shot
adaptation methods. | [
0.0369827487,
0.0813096091,
-0.0035721716,
0.0498556085,
-0.0221526567,
0.0355262384,
0.0254111122,
-0.0095632747,
-0.0547923222,
-0.1154443696,
-0.0133715672,
-0.0245150048,
0.0373716094,
0.0143004758,
0.0167697128,
-0.0922836885,
0.0311417319,
-0.0545038953,
0.0026135787,
-0.0009104964,
-0.0064054611,
0.0042315307,
0.028478425,
0.0303701051,
0.011139798,
0.0088034011,
-0.0258269198,
0.0169994179,
0.0314090773,
0.0176931266,
-0.0079652341,
0.0706338435,
0.0359293856,
0.0073455144,
0.0000019335,
-0.0537691675,
0.0505353734,
0.0172451288,
-0.0250118896,
-0.0336240306,
0.0423305854,
-0.0230304319,
0.0431284644,
-0.0186390672,
0.020572992,
-0.0620066635,
0.1031684801,
0.033366926,
0.0382764153,
0.0494709983,
-0.0061602276,
-0.0716385618,
-0.0236883014,
-0.0122885145,
0.0759560764,
-0.0075964918,
0.0479642935,
-0.0095623368,
-0.000064501,
0.0347729325,
-0.0302425176,
0.0194865856,
-0.0005727111,
0.0026345714,
0.0190032162,
0.0442066938,
-0.0847017989,
-0.0425950028,
0.0177542903,
0.0516144894,
-0.0428153425,
-0.0262621548,
-0.0276302155,
-0.0105542038,
0.0148385437,
-0.0250190832,
-0.0102860974,
0.0523292944,
-0.0084580025,
0.0128745921,
-0.0336653516,
0.0465247072,
0.0216563027,
0.0256525055,
-0.0216933712,
-0.0210304763,
0.0009044061,
0.0373764932,
-0.0357476175,
-0.0070657851,
-0.0186993927,
-0.0331111588,
-0.0320839137,
0.0078529771,
0.0108701857,
-0.0084974868,
-0.0752444267,
-0.0052458956,
0.0170114003,
-0.0331961811,
0.0468820855,
0.0241066776,
-0.0680340454,
0.0536276922,
-0.0310444832,
0.0565093346,
0.0463544279,
0.0166344102,
-0.0419502333,
-0.0137384785,
-0.0662568361,
-0.0157324802,
-0.0235313363,
0.0344988219,
-0.0048084157,
-0.01020402,
-0.0206686743,
0.0064017265,
-0.0327152349,
0.0272867139,
-0.0289587919,
-0.0141968811,
-0.0663761273,
0.0008248217,
-0.0184215195,
-0.0135636255,
0.0104685668,
0.0100152763,
0.0006184302,
-0.0667469278,
0.0008548519,
0.0429685116,
-0.008737457,
-0.0061018881,
-0.0184470937,
0.0938444361,
-0.0231905151,
-0.0298628695,
0.0011557081,
0.0069617839,
-0.0530197658,
-0.038362924,
-0.0178981703,
-0.0721582845,
-0.0005632837,
0.0101237698,
0.0205387007,
-0.0364554934,
0.0132066524,
-0.0174265653,
-0.0306181237,
0.149096027,
-0.0450850613,
-0.0020338264,
0.0201104004,
0.005532485,
0.0217010155,
0.0920228735,
-0.0230411235,
0.0068144714,
0.0202681106,
-0.0156379808,
0.051570639,
0.0180450045,
-0.0390446857,
-0.0092876721,
-0.066888839,
0.0010388194,
0.0170888752,
-0.0047106589,
0.0439734161,
0.0070803277,
0.0045041898,
-0.059654016,
0.0571872517,
0.0364858322,
0.0155487023,
-0.0143275131,
0.0510168262,
0.0246009193,
-0.0179705713,
-0.0116444323,
-0.06190731,
0.0125828963,
-0.0421465486,
0.013301691,
-0.0436015613,
0.0261930171,
-0.0567562953,
-0.0438442752,
-0.0385022461,
-0.0196709167,
0.0057239844,
0.0348374881,
0.0329839475,
0.0031675752,
0.0412078537,
0.0440301895,
0.037426848,
-0.0109204799,
-0.0095088901,
-0.0720492974,
0.0178755261,
0.0640917346,
-0.0122258365,
-0.0174020901,
-0.0342141986,
-0.0071156975,
0.0078073321,
0.0684336945,
0.0264713001,
-0.0012204464,
0.0295611788,
-0.0396763012,
-0.0619220249,
-0.0202825312,
0.025792798,
0.0029079688,
-0.0033160744,
0.0008602199,
0.0462959297,
-0.0362019986,
-0.064358972,
0.0551722981,
0.0634260997,
-0.0429609492,
0.0290181506,
0.0217227824,
0.0059567825,
-0.0447640233,
-0.0310358033,
-0.0105865216,
-0.0313571952,
-0.0144951856,
-0.0025313715,
0.0186268967,
-0.0172064956,
-0.0329526588,
0.052007705,
-0.0203274582,
-0.0035912669,
0.0026162541,
-0.0438246094,
-0.0324175917,
0.0055864407,
-0.0300800074,
-0.0132977506,
-0.0157358367,
0.038253177,
-0.034455616,
0.0106160836,
-0.0103324177,
0.0534214638,
0.0165259037,
-0.0162811074,
-0.0105896303,
-0.0177600775,
0.0111604016,
-0.0167426746,
-0.025531983,
0.0307797752,
-0.0199223198,
0.0116573405,
0.0042523937,
0.0331104137,
-0.0336176641,
0.001840485,
-0.0277766027,
-0.0490382425,
-0.0173999183,
-0.0158013385,
-0.0210591052,
-0.0195625294,
0.002069433,
-0.0230827406,
-0.0285230353,
-0.0028549572,
-0.0599121414,
0.0032924311,
0.0114357099,
0.0280700289,
-0.0319059379,
0.0112354243,
0.0023104013,
0.0440414958,
0.076609768,
0.0114618903,
-0.0762872323,
-0.0492796972,
0.02336023,
-0.04850889,
0.0119689191,
-0.0136329867,
-0.002509763,
-0.0057490366,
-0.0074306731,
-0.0193894021,
0.0223279838,
-0.0008272937,
0.0013909303,
0.058534544,
0.0189621486,
-0.0299939085,
-0.0137768853,
-0.0044945185,
-0.0479030795,
0.0152425347,
-0.0414812267,
-0.0338174589,
0.0394615084,
-0.0261924323,
-0.0109536564,
-0.0699543431,
0.0391191281,
0.0103793545,
-0.0184954554,
-0.1051613763,
0.0047930498,
0.0248285215,
0.0031699,
-0.0403563492,
-0.0782906488,
0.0578217804,
-0.0173693448,
-0.0032609301,
-0.0098096356,
-0.0190321077,
-0.0237569772,
0.0721652582,
0.0126706185,
0.0196848195,
0.0341120139,
-0.0024123387,
-0.0276618097,
-0.0438075177,
0.0275079254,
0.0034735966,
0.0517862588,
-0.0686732903,
0.0294403564,
-0.0485431552,
0.0010204996,
-0.0283389762,
-0.0314613208,
-0.0440683812,
0.0440838039,
-0.0694571063,
-0.0220671035,
-0.0371209756,
0.0537418202,
0.0191255491,
0.0255269986,
-0.0197429191,
-0.0007297745,
0.003270275,
-0.0086131841,
0.0351442583,
-0.0038329747,
-0.0497477464,
-0.0235134549,
0.0272132996,
-0.0178042129,
-0.0177581292,
0.0377993137,
-0.0467434004,
0.008731165,
0.0322003141,
0.0167613607,
-0.0227542575,
0.0235154666,
0.0397369899,
-0.0316569135,
-0.0137512898,
0.0767489299,
0.0114223287,
-0.0589142814,
-0.0230583642,
0.011104295,
0.036174085,
0.0387216508,
0.0073348195,
-0.0625846758,
-0.0606340244,
-0.0132658519,
-0.0095290998,
0.0203401931,
0.0158097614,
-0.03928978,
-0.0884267539,
0.0450243801,
0.0457430929,
-0.0947447866,
-0.0326805376,
0.0071636969,
0.0219393447,
-0.0191373117,
-0.0188924093,
-0.030791847,
0.0121212779,
-0.0024008017,
0.0059337639,
-0.0243513901,
-0.0703999773,
0.0067280908,
-0.0234008171,
0.0166389272,
0.0603039376,
-0.0231746193,
-0.0369770527,
-0.0437941551,
0.0116023114,
-0.0384740345,
0.0098963985,
-0.0039170687,
0.0840685666,
-0.0234358441,
-0.0250066686,
0.0483205691,
0.0259932205,
0.0264006332,
-0.0131027177,
-0.0162568651,
0.0221550278,
-0.0195768997,
-0.0431916006,
-0.0581244603,
-0.0208718628,
0.0285850652,
0.0722743943,
0.0383581743,
-0.0572569519,
-0.0177605636,
-0.0226722583,
-0.0485274419,
-0.0430768728,
0.004892597,
0.0331835933,
-0.0286574755,
-0.0681965798,
-0.0379597582,
0.0115072783,
0.0521010533,
-0.0004261216,
-0.0006140862,
-0.0014485401,
-0.0430374928,
0.0176816005,
-0.0664081499,
0.0694448799,
-0.0048912787,
0.0209449138,
-0.0271147769,
-0.0404246747,
0.0518948659,
-0.0268288292,
0.0043233233,
0.0090155611,
-0.0603418835,
-0.0268648732,
-0.0148172537,
0.055785317,
0.012337924,
0.0394759029,
0.018374322,
-0.1004212573,
0.034602765,
0.0870483965,
0.0831980109,
0.0091032311,
0.026932681,
-0.0071037267,
-0.0106012672,
0.0448576659,
-0.059237238,
0.0447188839,
0.0369891189,
-0.0406878553,
-0.0358738154,
0.013912959,
0.0064346935,
-0.0101569509,
0.0437354967,
-0.0466614515,
-0.0054606278,
0.0224472303,
-0.0020860818,
0.0112563204,
-0.0456977636,
-0.0285829958,
-0.0008702564,
0.0125024728,
0.0015039875,
0.0347193405,
0.023734374,
-0.0240721609,
0.0000357421,
-0.030185163,
-0.0093208067,
0.0497435778,
-0.0245025735,
-0.0038897325,
0.038370233,
-0.03227989,
0.0210497845,
-0.0095999213,
0.0057662306,
0.0096875755,
0.0204824731,
0.0273307562,
0.0397398584,
-0.0474960767,
0.0157147925,
0.0146692507,
-0.016173033,
-0.0354891643,
0.0658990815,
0.0020795783,
-0.0023687358,
-0.0199286491,
-0.0095212394,
-0.0378125422,
-0.0311944634,
0.0496649072,
0.0365071781,
-0.0677193329,
0.0750289336,
0.0362825915,
-0.0389200933,
-0.0225683227,
0.0576606542,
0.0154141607,
0.0270053223,
-0.0213660281,
0.0081587611,
-0.0224349238,
0.0378437079,
0.019930061,
-0.0099751689,
0.0194209162,
0.0511121638,
-0.0359914191,
-0.0531181954,
0.0005734567,
-0.0069796583,
0.0381621048,
0.0441774614,
0.0435905941,
0.0223472789,
0.0074488856,
-0.0499758385,
-0.0229801126,
-0.0254659671,
0.0277261045,
0.0454071574,
-0.0236983709,
-5.705609337e-33,
-0.0404111072,
-0.0221703369,
-0.0013996707,
0.0174332913,
0.0227360744,
0.006891679,
0.0046895021,
0.0128466748,
-0.021606423,
0.0231312141,
0.0430260189,
-0.0066896104,
0.0188251585,
0.0456294417,
0.0482235551,
0.0125348233,
0.0475590974,
0.0109128701,
-0.0259480234,
0.0035866767,
0.0175610967,
-0.0175352916,
0.0427211635,
-0.0322780795,
-0.0007278748,
0.0031172556,
-0.0359621644,
0.0103976522,
0.0143062929,
0.0420256071,
-0.0168844219,
0.0603231005,
0.0069530136,
0.0265563112,
-0.0518075489,
-0.0125210229,
-0.0369802713,
-0.0163885877,
0.0247747675,
0.053716775,
-0.0140787456,
-0.0236373562,
0.0343370661,
-0.0154941315,
-0.0087835481,
-0.0571909398,
0.0543085635,
-0.0684901923,
-0.0106818778,
-0.032019034,
-0.0352928676,
0.0345865972,
-0.0018606441,
-0.0352470726,
0.0604047105,
0.0268293787,
0.0043116249,
0.0302386936,
-0.0384676233,
0.029402744,
0.0889483988,
0.0162709691,
0.0751960427,
0.0955215767,
0.0073894626,
0.053680893,
0.0337338001,
-0.013199253,
-0.0082178935,
-0.03073374,
0.026484156,
0.0373985097,
0.0415265895,
0.0461972915,
0.0460562184,
-0.0003458383,
-0.0025574747,
0.0070396028,
-0.0452546999,
0.0283949915,
0.0171617158,
0.026865257,
-0.0159790479,
-0.0336766765,
-0.0582511649,
-0.0242576525,
-0.0413129106,
0.009468222,
0.0341470949,
0.0129675278,
-0.0256273057,
0.0361900479,
0.0486912094,
-0.0254729558,
-0.0249679927,
-0.02220219,
0.0007667781,
0.0480300523,
0.0208639,
-0.0368546247,
-0.0180837903,
-0.045264855,
0.0545378476,
0.0373718813,
0.0281178616,
0.0131150838,
0.0874239281,
0.0269170478,
-0.0516946092,
0.0012021193,
-0.0051235552,
-0.0142468121,
0.0030002287,
0.0500520542,
0.0101851793,
-0.00728592,
-0.0442409478,
0.0391730703,
-0.003694698,
-0.0536960103,
0.0159162488,
0.0295332428,
-0.0402072631,
0.0373374783,
-0.0361345857,
0.0222766511,
0.0031180223,
-0.0326324292,
0.0310975593,
0.0007463315,
-0.0066425391,
0.0180144142,
2.638e-7,
0.0102571752,
0.0088712554,
-0.0214129891,
-0.018459918,
0.0108324541,
0.0568326972,
-0.0169561487,
-0.0047545116,
0.0028768997,
-0.0201705378,
-0.0024104218,
0.0040649972,
0.0557686612,
-0.017344486,
-0.0079217777,
0.0372775979,
-0.0110267205,
0.018845357,
-0.0619425662,
-0.0151445866,
0.0431512818,
0.1287892908,
-0.0009187944,
0.0035430668,
0.032947503,
-0.0635239109,
0.0577851608,
-0.0539741479,
0.0143435812,
-0.0015328549,
-0.0069865524,
0.0473884419,
-0.0133001525,
0.0649532527,
-0.0073960093,
-0.0154307177,
0.0189013332,
0.0402365737,
-0.0400522128,
0.0471252315,
-0.0545235053,
0.0480450131,
-0.0099179074,
-0.0635630265,
0.0847430527,
-0.0751278698,
-0.0148139112,
-0.0644814968,
-0.0059000072,
0.0062082154,
0.0496182106,
-0.0245398656,
-0.0090509346,
0.0231193025,
0.0165240914,
-0.0132958759,
-0.0572342835,
-0.1044022143,
-0.0111662317,
0.005689112,
-0.0117512448,
0.0083131958,
0.0041745333,
-0.0248167925,
0.0408297181,
-0.0333607644,
-0.0044976808,
1.960559503e-34,
0.0194487572,
0.0320454575,
-0.0204336401,
-0.0046348008,
-0.022627918,
0.0006187072,
-0.0180714279,
0.0315485001,
0.0024842217,
-0.0221583638,
-0.0134947272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05876v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05876v2 | Trends in Integration of Knowledge and Large Language Models: A Survey and Taxonomy of Methods, Benchmarks, and Applications | 2023-11-10T05:24:04 | 2023-12-07T12:42:07 | Zhangyin Feng, Weitao Ma, Weijiang Yu, Lei Huang, Haotian Wang, Qianglong Chen, Weihua Peng, Xiaocheng Feng, Bing Qin, Ting liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) exhibit superior performance on various natural
language tasks, but they are susceptible to issues stemming from outdated data
and domain-specific limitations. In order to address these challenges,
researchers have pursued two primary strategies, knowledge editing and
retrieval augmentation, to enhance LLMs by incorporating external information
from different aspects. Nevertheless, there is still a notable absence of a
comprehensive survey. In this paper, we propose a review to discuss the trends
in integration of knowledge and large language models, including taxonomy of
methods, benchmarks, and applications. In addition, we conduct an in-depth
analysis of different methods and point out potential research directions in
the future. We hope this survey offers the community quick access and a
comprehensive overview of this research area, with the intention of inspiring
future research endeavors. | [
0.0509238876,
0.0426270477,
-0.0101993345,
0.044008594,
-0.0491114594,
-0.0133622708,
-0.0458219945,
-0.0114765335,
0.0174614564,
-0.1105378866,
-0.0391554013,
-0.0222144499,
0.0086318851,
0.0225915369,
0.029808268,
-0.0177366063,
0.0494196713,
-0.0323610902,
0.0006952169,
0.0124144061,
-0.0040905788,
0.0105170608,
0.05478983,
0.0221582241,
0.0101025272,
-0.0007062327,
0.0201682243,
0.0197873563,
0.0173473526,
0.012615962,
-0.0179654639,
0.0231082253,
0.0412472412,
0.0962737873,
0.0000015325,
-0.0722885579,
-0.0524412729,
0.0294755623,
-0.0174209829,
0.0002148844,
0.0313530192,
-0.050909292,
0.0012698997,
0.0054212762,
-0.0179347508,
-0.0199633669,
0.055907093,
0.0423623808,
0.0657827258,
0.046717573,
-0.0044576963,
-0.0038221481,
0.0600784943,
-0.0136620188,
-0.0413874686,
-0.0039412049,
0.0846445858,
0.0274649393,
0.0120686451,
0.0241942164,
-0.006732156,
0.0718886182,
-0.0226133708,
-0.0449474826,
0.0223444421,
0.0008414888,
-0.0316888839,
0.0223631505,
-0.0077225147,
0.0355429165,
0.0085466802,
-0.0101659903,
-0.031491641,
0.0210217852,
0.0046154875,
0.0463893898,
-0.062021181,
-0.017878551,
0.0324922763,
0.0169820264,
0.0054363329,
-0.007879205,
0.0456170216,
0.0353228524,
-0.0186183248,
0.0593588352,
0.068044506,
-0.0460076183,
-0.0074146595,
-0.0147917802,
-0.0219551474,
-0.0430391654,
0.0000132293,
0.027611481,
0.0062368237,
0.047171209,
-0.0363751948,
-0.0288459435,
0.0193809234,
-0.0448234119,
0.0219374076,
0.0259789936,
-0.0150461094,
0.0798185542,
-0.0185933486,
0.0469749272,
-0.0252320319,
-0.0429853946,
-0.0451222584,
-0.0137246484,
-0.0549863838,
-0.0256475788,
-0.035207849,
0.0206648931,
-0.0151665071,
-0.0187544264,
-0.0184549838,
0.0140242688,
0.0057506268,
0.0273408536,
0.022461744,
-0.0383665711,
-0.0170731656,
-0.0545914285,
-0.0245149899,
0.0560801588,
0.0241463147,
0.0010258515,
-0.0359821059,
-0.0338464081,
0.0108008394,
-0.0127452146,
0.004090141,
-0.028810231,
-0.0212972071,
0.0478595048,
0.0118903192,
-0.0126130562,
-0.0014969342,
-0.0186237879,
-0.0339961089,
-0.0551562831,
-0.0397065431,
-0.0654054582,
0.0239660945,
-0.0205719806,
-0.0123283817,
-0.0597437583,
0.0352400392,
-0.0071251155,
-0.0463585854,
0.0955842137,
-0.0439682119,
0.0084455376,
0.0531673729,
0.0045788339,
0.0179606378,
0.0824714079,
-0.0037872542,
-0.0327427275,
0.0448628888,
0.0152246635,
-0.0173326861,
0.0606863983,
-0.0016590813,
0.0029012198,
-0.0297898632,
0.0062741116,
0.031071553,
0.0180963669,
-0.0045898892,
0.0712469816,
-0.0121613191,
-0.0053792316,
0.053741578,
-0.0037060184,
0.0125108287,
-0.0050893421,
0.0372170955,
0.0060073631,
0.020664338,
-0.0141816679,
-0.0200021584,
-0.025370162,
-0.0365434028,
0.0194840562,
0.0401807278,
0.06320066,
0.0026678729,
-0.0262728315,
-0.024145769,
-0.0151330736,
-0.0054900483,
0.0248380322,
0.0917673856,
-0.0089649251,
0.0044596242,
0.0281623155,
0.0326933302,
0.0025517,
0.0416965224,
-0.0226246454,
-0.0153316772,
0.0579685941,
0.06588462,
-0.0551677905,
-0.0315110609,
-0.0017953246,
-0.0347433425,
0.0075070085,
0.0221446417,
-0.0316441953,
-0.0237501301,
-0.0287653171,
-0.0275150537,
0.0102630816,
0.025762707,
0.0220060088,
0.0438205376,
-0.0116255889,
0.0461900048,
-0.0520210713,
0.0076771695,
0.0178418998,
-0.0209853239,
-0.0258014202,
-0.0217517857,
-0.0065582702,
0.0096966401,
0.0019268224,
-0.0166278407,
0.0069905901,
0.0198854692,
-0.0350969322,
-0.0334199741,
0.0243710354,
0.0022399705,
-0.0497796573,
0.0754968077,
0.0162271019,
-0.0224333368,
0.0020904008,
-0.0245561562,
-0.047158692,
-0.020752931,
-0.0082510132,
0.0770492032,
-0.0733592063,
0.0452442281,
0.0105387159,
-0.0126029123,
-0.0654806718,
0.068189539,
0.0202927403,
0.0045738826,
0.0180884041,
-0.0464238487,
-0.0027797343,
-0.0287466776,
-0.047398068,
0.0244614631,
0.0029491936,
0.0075251097,
0.0191582274,
-0.046782773,
-0.0531572029,
-0.0136333331,
-0.103437826,
0.0110273277,
-0.0048234421,
0.0225613192,
0.0025348682,
0.0436301641,
-0.0136385811,
0.000974217,
-0.0172542259,
-0.0480352342,
0.0272429567,
0.0506806448,
0.0093220724,
0.0513902307,
-0.0280185416,
-0.0384829976,
-0.0064539541,
0.0030434672,
0.0574764349,
-0.0213675778,
-0.0513504595,
-0.0404406227,
0.0389168002,
-0.0533150099,
0.0347344913,
-0.0289247204,
0.0109744351,
-0.0562266111,
-0.0260697231,
0.0684656575,
0.0054208729,
-0.0389697179,
-0.0236385036,
0.0633630529,
-0.0718809515,
-0.0431469679,
-0.008005837,
-0.0028844262,
-0.0197870973,
-0.012137509,
0.0131191295,
0.0096015092,
0.0377201624,
-0.0151451761,
-0.0544651784,
-0.0173444543,
-0.0124282539,
-0.0512391664,
-0.0393941365,
-0.0469911136,
-0.0399647914,
-0.0151792141,
0.022688482,
-0.0318008959,
-0.0496612862,
0.071952872,
-0.0634675846,
-0.0036229591,
-0.0162704457,
-0.0172962472,
-0.0557360612,
0.0626844764,
0.0009320072,
0.0233678967,
-0.0038122744,
-0.0164086819,
-0.0423416682,
-0.0037658175,
0.0011962077,
-0.0429496467,
0.080380857,
-0.0512246005,
0.0629982427,
0.0052793105,
-0.0094037037,
-0.0233148485,
-0.0455261655,
-0.0388400406,
0.0021362938,
0.0163370539,
-0.0207135137,
-0.0212735347,
0.0367878787,
0.0153078362,
-0.0033447656,
0.0014100677,
-0.0096412813,
-0.0086536258,
0.0398569554,
0.0715855658,
-0.0026151738,
-0.0020461283,
0.0172112864,
0.0260871872,
0.0453578718,
0.0243992936,
-0.042957902,
-0.0129624084,
-0.0337439589,
0.0281963814,
-0.083989501,
-0.0165824145,
-0.0069054575,
0.0164095648,
-0.0510188378,
0.0051704957,
0.1216939762,
0.0306638516,
-0.0147617385,
-0.0328064002,
-0.0313371718,
0.0024100018,
0.0136338351,
0.0518084429,
-0.0338303521,
-0.0127939014,
0.0332316197,
-0.0231290143,
-0.0012148038,
-0.0277999658,
-0.0207028687,
-0.1272738725,
0.0244114716,
0.0280067846,
0.0013620296,
-0.0681925416,
-0.0204394497,
0.0323106498,
0.0166944135,
-0.0146230748,
-0.0030088124,
-0.0152547481,
-0.0070906235,
-0.0170383863,
-0.0426998958,
-0.0665396973,
0.002682284,
-0.037710309,
0.0532462448,
0.0510735586,
0.0249880068,
0.0174404215,
0.0293013342,
0.0150605943,
-0.0086845113,
-0.0190572292,
-0.013945804,
0.0068716961,
-0.0244194772,
0.0086957803,
0.0065664505,
0.0020925566,
0.0052260817,
-0.0117869955,
-0.0015670386,
0.0993649736,
0.0054826834,
0.0570032112,
-0.0121550038,
-0.0311131775,
-0.0065126386,
0.0810790509,
0.0172078852,
0.0031645498,
0.0424524844,
-0.0439998358,
-0.0232026782,
0.0282450411,
-0.0136642559,
0.0176317059,
-0.0339659825,
0.0112726027,
-0.0601366274,
-0.0368174352,
0.0562732294,
0.0169011429,
0.047497198,
0.0636987537,
0.0085206497,
-0.0199378729,
-0.0401922613,
0.0145451184,
-0.0798846632,
0.0318022929,
0.0079459492,
0.0003403978,
0.0241907444,
-0.0378186516,
-0.0261425283,
0.0108960597,
-0.0535442531,
-0.0782749504,
-0.0303914919,
0.0187395792,
0.020982556,
0.0539157577,
-0.0366876498,
-0.0481982604,
0.0273338165,
0.0106056882,
-0.0369716957,
-0.0088651814,
0.0030153799,
0.0104190372,
-0.0031508196,
0.0472053923,
-0.0829852074,
-0.0280863866,
-0.0073390156,
0.0490648262,
-0.0375301763,
-0.0637310147,
0.0315602049,
0.0276434403,
0.0337463282,
-0.0203273259,
-0.0032920903,
-0.0346697941,
0.0048492895,
-0.0681870133,
-0.0646258667,
-0.0395445935,
-0.0122245448,
0.0431921519,
0.0158901699,
-0.0119259087,
0.0330519155,
0.0054890569,
0.0259889103,
-0.0257839691,
-0.0099485898,
0.0132058617,
-0.0200725906,
0.0598924495,
0.0160870887,
-0.0007448293,
0.0357536487,
-0.0032904218,
0.0260694809,
-0.0322440043,
-0.0065319268,
-0.0016000957,
-0.0126898251,
-0.0198405124,
0.0098773204,
-0.0524275973,
-0.0261728056,
-0.0022537536,
0.0373098105,
0.0771804899,
-0.0227326248,
0.0526868068,
-0.0255478658,
-0.0480955392,
-0.0246052481,
0.0063248933,
0.0322211199,
-0.0280867256,
0.0321359299,
0.0223222636,
-0.0319371596,
0.0584772006,
0.0604966618,
0.0098975077,
0.0609686524,
-0.0071604354,
-0.0361667611,
-0.0125548327,
-0.0214292519,
0.0297967214,
0.0036356337,
-0.0504120886,
-0.0063425843,
-0.0675865561,
-0.0793068483,
0.0170128196,
-0.0189466458,
-0.0510323606,
0.0081248591,
0.0012394341,
0.0341514498,
0.0181200225,
0.0028855393,
-0.0423281118,
-0.0061580837,
-0.0418132395,
-0.0069704154,
0.0277105644,
-5.350632818e-33,
-0.0537052006,
-0.0005877998,
-0.0073366072,
-0.0446294807,
-0.0345188268,
0.0167902764,
-0.0029047537,
-0.0199013837,
0.0102313124,
-0.002040084,
-0.0009482074,
-0.0178913232,
0.0027411594,
0.0074382029,
-0.0057328125,
0.0173395723,
0.046144709,
0.0418947116,
0.0227743518,
-0.0183259714,
0.0222051013,
0.0535646565,
0.0388830937,
-0.0415301882,
0.0480208136,
0.019207418,
0.0021425649,
0.0539813228,
0.0271019582,
0.0687791631,
-0.0337081142,
0.0535341129,
0.015961213,
-0.0353408419,
-0.0430364944,
0.0165248904,
-0.0429793745,
0.0229360852,
0.0475571789,
0.0104337977,
0.031192109,
-0.028667314,
0.0213213321,
-0.0202671885,
0.0267157014,
-0.0075712814,
0.0203920938,
-0.0549908355,
-0.0240191501,
-0.0156973079,
-0.0652947128,
0.0391267166,
-0.0005524911,
-0.0045453664,
0.053253822,
-0.013586971,
0.0538747832,
0.0235605985,
-0.0442382097,
0.037333563,
0.0363786779,
0.0638481081,
0.0730984658,
0.0268195346,
0.0044423235,
0.032127548,
-0.0369402952,
-0.0335525721,
-0.018652875,
-0.0134319589,
0.0214551035,
0.0295358971,
-0.0002514068,
0.0606087409,
-0.0164189152,
0.0290850326,
-0.0128484452,
0.0443238392,
-0.0103160692,
0.044997137,
-0.018862348,
0.0602052845,
-0.042525515,
-0.0112354681,
-0.0557064787,
0.038684573,
-0.0264817066,
-0.0099108312,
0.0293407626,
0.001327551,
-0.019632088,
0.0199736655,
0.0446803346,
-0.0591417514,
-0.018118497,
0.0275270492,
0.0063121668,
0.0245467611,
-0.0202657487,
0.0535187945,
-0.0600073524,
0.0040365388,
0.0200913884,
-0.0271551404,
-0.0593467243,
-0.0262640473,
0.0146442102,
0.006849573,
-0.0625794008,
0.0336792544,
-0.0132754669,
-0.0251783598,
-0.006075609,
0.0081788218,
0.0300750844,
0.0220526811,
0.0117179872,
0.0239702892,
0.0687311143,
0.0022279613,
0.007852722,
0.0137584992,
0.009210919,
-0.0207785945,
0.0020567465,
0.0398026332,
-0.0120306257,
-0.0059997449,
0.0170957018,
0.0076594623,
0.0000578067,
0.0163599048,
2.332e-7,
0.0792104229,
0.0498592481,
0.0033846726,
0.0199203994,
0.01330355,
0.0099085029,
-0.0246326737,
-0.012208269,
0.0500551239,
-0.0116657624,
0.0355032682,
0.0341911428,
0.0460379981,
0.0102400854,
-0.090191856,
-0.0289021228,
-0.0071468283,
-0.0136594279,
-0.0664097592,
-0.0236276351,
0.0445957482,
0.1050112545,
0.0040500914,
0.0091249272,
-0.05783429,
-0.0879073218,
0.0771328509,
-0.0270368699,
-0.0592162795,
0.0276085231,
0.0410744771,
0.052125141,
0.0033403074,
0.0244873334,
-0.0133807603,
0.0424276367,
0.0357773788,
0.0420830362,
-0.0028253654,
0.0360844098,
-0.0318029486,
0.025649501,
-0.0052102702,
-0.0443293676,
0.0756312311,
-0.0301609971,
-0.0112454714,
-0.0359849781,
-0.0133964717,
-0.0215116758,
-0.0159868859,
-0.0075509246,
-0.0120063638,
0.0161943529,
0.0423452295,
-0.0003657518,
-0.0466222093,
-0.0796127915,
-0.0251885559,
0.0098991469,
-0.0416289009,
-0.054654751,
-0.0278041419,
-0.0374333598,
0.010554445,
-0.0522525311,
0.0053176964,
2.329191087e-34,
0.0362692475,
0.0120291868,
-0.0035234476,
0.041994147,
0.049888134,
-0.0172554906,
-0.0409191027,
0.0234272666,
-0.0128887072,
-0.1322577447,
0.0053153913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05845v1 | Tamil-Llama: A New Tamil Language Model Based on Llama 2 | 2023-11-10T03:02:39 | 2023-11-10T03:02:39 | Abhinand Balachandran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language modeling has witnessed remarkable advancements in recent years, with
Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT setting unparalleled benchmarks in
human-like text generation. However, a prevailing limitation is the
underrepresentation of languages like Tamil in these cutting-edge models,
leading to suboptimal performance in diverse linguistic contexts. This paper
addresses this lacuna, enhancing the open-source LLaMA model with an addition
of 16,000 Tamil tokens, aiming to achieve superior text generation and
comprehension in the Tamil language. We strategically employ the LoRA
methodology for efficient model training on a comprehensive Tamil corpus,
ensuring computational feasibility and model robustness. Moreover, we introduce
a Tamil-translated version of the Alpaca dataset and a subset of the OpenOrca
dataset tailored for instruction fine-tuning. Our results showcase significant
performance improvements in Tamil text generation, with potential implications
for the broader landscape of LLMs in Indian languages. We further underscore
our commitment to open research by making our models, datasets, and code
publicly accessible, fostering further innovations in language modeling. | [
0.0243355948,
0.0439103805,
-0.0131799048,
0.0348869227,
-0.0395782143,
-0.0060599926,
-0.0026772132,
0.024536971,
0.0148427458,
-0.001522455,
-0.0508470871,
-0.0893721581,
0.0136001687,
0.0417217202,
0.0410473384,
-0.0347118117,
-0.0075867926,
-0.0421565957,
-0.00229381,
-0.0037973358,
0.0225710105,
0.033103276,
-0.0268910732,
0.0287423022,
-0.0007635624,
-0.0332454406,
-0.0118742036,
0.0292469338,
-0.0092468765,
-0.0272244848,
0.0054526865,
0.0433474556,
0.032636337,
0.0395033844,
0.0000019039,
-0.0332653448,
0.0116369287,
-0.0274058376,
0.0261349492,
0.0394834764,
0.0882889405,
-0.0043350821,
0.0343290344,
0.0460268967,
0.0005876702,
0.0465350561,
0.0574750863,
-0.0293867104,
0.0387245715,
0.0734648407,
-0.0225952193,
0.0066194022,
0.0194039587,
-0.0138291288,
-0.010812371,
-0.0048334789,
0.0030836372,
0.0098149804,
0.036660783,
-0.0213743746,
-0.0160765722,
0.0215175506,
0.0049827858,
0.0058553703,
0.0014348279,
0.0489124432,
-0.0150301885,
-0.0544488579,
0.0117748184,
0.0651820377,
-0.0238013826,
-0.0500021502,
0.0208818633,
0.0034593188,
-0.0808718577,
-0.0438979231,
-0.0452124253,
0.0584468991,
-0.0251626112,
0.0532023683,
0.0939166173,
0.0141792316,
-0.0064021205,
0.0327032954,
0.0545829572,
-0.0067253867,
0.035661377,
-0.0047397804,
-0.0505082346,
0.0021247126,
-0.0302012879,
-0.0450460613,
0.0287888702,
0.0525394902,
-0.0207769498,
0.0383653007,
-0.0542662144,
-0.0099056959,
0.0481045097,
-0.0360414684,
0.0432110429,
0.0479581393,
-0.026522072,
-0.0207755249,
-0.0296487417,
0.0465484783,
-0.0195733365,
0.0157819521,
-0.008407834,
0.0093935495,
0.0386662744,
-0.066754289,
-0.0310177933,
0.0252391864,
-0.0632981956,
0.0057034334,
-0.0664499924,
0.0297925435,
0.0350451507,
-0.0503532439,
0.0266962256,
-0.0146026406,
-0.0625772476,
-0.016699126,
0.0059669954,
-0.0278314427,
-0.0198875237,
0.0403515995,
0.0179089569,
-0.1079573482,
-0.0266343169,
0.040241234,
-0.0437745489,
-0.0153594064,
-0.0391608588,
0.0517459884,
-0.0422087684,
-0.0484214537,
-0.064292036,
-0.0234323256,
0.0024775621,
-0.0885912776,
-0.0304069016,
-0.0974122509,
0.0525493361,
0.00623962,
-0.0123026026,
-0.0554331355,
0.0147129558,
0.0361586101,
0.0061958544,
0.0325370952,
-0.025001267,
0.0054289424,
0.0455855392,
0.0305682737,
0.0733547732,
0.0472677574,
0.0413786583,
0.0352331325,
-0.0030900815,
0.016556479,
0.0176587962,
0.062240541,
0.015162386,
0.0029960347,
-0.0439678282,
0.0240999218,
-0.0183514971,
0.0594864823,
0.0348962732,
0.0747410133,
-0.022545198,
0.0479130112,
0.0415901616,
0.0377627388,
0.0126300231,
0.0382153988,
0.0247519817,
0.0158288721,
0.0308079459,
0.0075261849,
0.0043368307,
0.0460230336,
0.0104458248,
0.0069168559,
0.0509147383,
0.0309622381,
-0.0354045369,
-0.0121463584,
-0.0200823322,
-0.0507343449,
-0.0402624868,
-0.0393327586,
0.0206034184,
0.017722236,
-0.0590828843,
0.0399667136,
0.0771671832,
-0.0737770796,
0.0522193424,
-0.0869336799,
0.0754151344,
0.0268595405,
0.0546474978,
-0.0232390966,
-0.0354984775,
0.0157172754,
0.0072697722,
0.0833048746,
-0.0060913074,
0.004293357,
-0.0087382337,
-0.0869691074,
0.0586145818,
0.022596648,
0.0167410392,
0.0075532314,
-0.0099524735,
0.016736012,
0.023391448,
-0.0068211285,
-0.0364178009,
0.0486201197,
-0.0596725531,
-0.0051619681,
-0.0049110814,
-0.0128292507,
0.0377492756,
-0.0026289138,
-0.0068374737,
-0.0027761157,
0.0261953901,
-0.0262156893,
0.0091424836,
0.0061418302,
-0.0421893299,
-0.0171454009,
0.0018199559,
-0.0204632487,
0.0499316491,
0.0532892644,
-0.0022399114,
-0.0591119081,
0.0262426008,
0.0037793068,
-0.0070615457,
-0.0412202924,
0.0273716599,
0.0103500988,
0.0251695812,
-0.0337316506,
0.0312271491,
-0.0013992746,
0.00524553,
0.0526406728,
0.0171520356,
0.0464111194,
-0.0696669519,
-0.0158222243,
0.0242007896,
0.0054567265,
0.0404235944,
-0.0133594014,
0.0301940609,
-0.0355743989,
-0.0780194774,
-0.0609973371,
0.0319721214,
-0.0389917605,
0.0197048541,
0.0258959755,
0.0312161148,
-0.0341663286,
0.0232207403,
-0.0373077951,
-0.0073313634,
0.0739303306,
-0.0160373487,
0.0452599116,
-0.0379098766,
-0.0131503036,
-0.0452772863,
-0.026471708,
0.0020093024,
0.0303244274,
0.0134596601,
-0.0411255471,
-0.0423348211,
0.0224912409,
-0.0396706536,
-0.0220886003,
-0.0296786837,
-0.0588138811,
-0.0208032094,
-0.0186367389,
0.0491642058,
-0.0058533866,
0.0124606481,
0.0068440964,
-0.0041413005,
-0.0024308236,
-0.022603441,
-0.0381661914,
0.0033069763,
-0.0237774365,
-0.0008975139,
-0.0397507101,
-0.0006737484,
0.0610139333,
0.0122601874,
-0.007074743,
-0.0278646015,
-0.0029517256,
-0.0546533205,
0.0055694892,
-0.0082573052,
0.0491836146,
-0.0240600165,
0.0564973392,
-0.017754538,
-0.0549712665,
0.0286380742,
-0.0561300106,
0.0161427315,
-0.0407568812,
0.00431397,
-0.0728376135,
-0.0040435242,
0.0062480988,
0.0003865068,
-0.0057950048,
-0.0034347279,
-0.0444917157,
0.0200064741,
-0.0185241476,
-0.0412373058,
0.0341025516,
-0.0891892761,
0.0252212957,
-0.0269608833,
-0.0060509895,
-0.0160801392,
-0.0501696989,
0.0178577956,
0.0025922041,
0.0172788538,
-0.0125283776,
0.0299102403,
0.0528856255,
-0.0297136214,
0.0102708349,
-0.0509849079,
0.0307020228,
-0.0138588455,
0.0465421416,
0.0542632602,
0.0027343666,
-0.0018540442,
-0.022008894,
0.0205269456,
-0.0123136258,
0.0419057459,
0.008576802,
-0.0046247062,
0.0318466723,
0.0190929398,
-0.0092164706,
-0.0101543702,
0.012660102,
0.0628413111,
0.0006629693,
-0.0388620682,
0.0616448186,
0.0485620014,
0.0065360004,
-0.0030910976,
-0.0568559058,
0.0786319822,
0.0075720311,
0.0258098878,
-0.0720723718,
-0.0083122822,
0.0170642585,
0.008622583,
-0.0007158451,
-0.0193597022,
-0.0591671243,
-0.0673264265,
0.0151132448,
0.0012920962,
-0.0128314402,
-0.0105612976,
0.0049443888,
-0.0542160496,
-0.0095273759,
0.0207603946,
0.0784761235,
-0.0516271777,
0.0172793493,
0.0588418767,
-0.0247497354,
-0.0212524608,
-0.0153462822,
-0.0165735334,
0.0636769012,
0.007066885,
0.0066559259,
-0.0502514914,
-0.0203853659,
0.0237773526,
-0.0218961388,
0.0087137911,
-0.0217132531,
0.0257865377,
0.0103177624,
-0.0271493532,
-0.0340907946,
0.0546599068,
-0.0314098671,
-0.0074721375,
0.0168470666,
0.0224909224,
0.0438589565,
0.008085235,
0.0187447965,
-0.0080721313,
-0.0047849198,
0.023814192,
0.0318738408,
-0.0261633229,
-0.0421480127,
-0.0091682542,
0.0004637963,
-0.0429804586,
-0.0310598593,
0.0118898675,
-0.0321502052,
-0.0238740761,
-0.0504312553,
-0.0510141179,
0.0421182662,
0.0167117286,
0.0199491307,
0.0206496343,
-0.0519425981,
-0.0411154218,
-0.0257395227,
0.0002360198,
-0.0452464446,
0.0265691988,
-0.0720945373,
-0.0038261416,
0.0273131058,
-0.065440312,
-0.0260436926,
0.0374264643,
-0.0869474635,
-0.0585888661,
0.008260997,
0.059155982,
0.0315829217,
-0.0048160614,
0.001403427,
-0.0723423362,
0.0310440511,
0.0133670773,
-0.0077457372,
0.0286624357,
-0.0039897319,
0.0077951211,
0.0169933047,
0.0541207641,
-0.0097273011,
0.0014475532,
-0.0168343671,
0.0204591695,
0.0101680374,
0.0088915797,
0.037795607,
0.0535372235,
-0.0100797936,
-0.0950382203,
-0.0127004292,
-0.072434552,
0.0110407565,
0.0065954295,
0.0037373328,
-0.0294141769,
0.0047019138,
0.0364963785,
0.0173272602,
-0.0365283862,
-0.0551635735,
-0.0135946618,
0.0623550266,
0.0141971931,
0.0450222529,
-0.0124496222,
0.0671502426,
0.0361700431,
0.0018952098,
-0.0319942012,
0.0081465021,
-0.0794870779,
0.0354357511,
-0.0006714099,
0.0557981655,
-0.0288755447,
0.0258043911,
0.0372649096,
0.0507577285,
0.0602950752,
-0.0307585765,
-0.0316531062,
0.0581982732,
0.045712132,
0.0244611017,
0.0541884154,
-0.0348914564,
0.0276496634,
-0.0291329585,
0.0608344413,
-0.0233142637,
-0.0060615116,
0.0455478616,
-0.0179516561,
-0.0281055812,
-0.0360999182,
0.1090320125,
0.0332787745,
0.0293294415,
0.0161122382,
0.0300698671,
-0.0430794917,
-0.0210220758,
0.001000726,
-0.0022285273,
0.0287030004,
-0.0250221398,
-0.0540460609,
-0.0504171066,
0.0406669267,
0.0231948979,
0.0339615345,
-0.0429587848,
0.0208156202,
0.0292627569,
0.012124449,
0.0392731316,
-0.0643688813,
-0.0159540065,
-0.025825806,
-0.0153984912,
-0.0145247076,
-6.044494808e-33,
-0.0530685,
0.0103016309,
0.0312052332,
0.0363927446,
-0.0243573934,
-0.0007650517,
-0.0247924216,
-0.000496124,
0.0353875197,
-0.0229827017,
-0.026455896,
0.0071616485,
0.0105117904,
0.0143366894,
0.0030363975,
-0.0090357764,
0.0241028965,
0.0042421403,
-0.0072874115,
0.0342135839,
0.0134672681,
0.0141409067,
0.0514483638,
0.026959192,
-0.0079855006,
-0.0819780305,
-0.0163378883,
0.0200412031,
-0.0345708467,
0.0245010536,
-0.0696662068,
0.0536132418,
0.0426284708,
0.0040160762,
-0.0248879381,
0.0055624447,
-0.0534111485,
0.0031942353,
0.0516393855,
0.0234873481,
-0.0284766834,
-0.0522366054,
0.0333644748,
0.0071200952,
-0.0396992303,
0.0280004628,
0.002568796,
0.0062456224,
-0.0276735891,
0.001091461,
-0.0837336704,
0.0445344672,
-0.0089537064,
-0.0372714102,
0.0225062314,
0.030680079,
-0.023300318,
0.0037787813,
-0.0187831037,
-0.0132610844,
0.0305407625,
0.0568243973,
0.0518910587,
0.0274640787,
-0.0453188978,
0.0139566697,
0.0072199157,
-0.0557364374,
-0.0303112194,
0.0330476612,
-0.0041500865,
0.0552624948,
0.005345738,
0.0326760449,
0.0121476091,
-0.0735035166,
-0.0620182529,
-0.0007044709,
0.0192580055,
0.0048111356,
0.0354423784,
-0.02534559,
-0.0157882068,
-0.0346206948,
-0.0243471786,
-0.0367639028,
-0.0338759981,
-0.0144461049,
0.067365177,
-0.0032773712,
-0.0041545131,
-0.0182863791,
0.0241911355,
-0.0137927746,
0.0134885935,
-0.0255471133,
-0.0413557105,
0.0278735626,
-0.0252275672,
0.0282305274,
-0.070727475,
-0.0683265552,
-0.0217524916,
0.0174952261,
-0.0015769273,
0.0055834944,
0.0160110928,
0.0029649998,
-0.0650643632,
0.0220331382,
-0.0581213683,
0.0677520558,
0.0438025929,
0.0309115648,
0.0256681647,
-0.0195724815,
-0.0198863279,
0.0339516476,
0.0190287791,
0.0003594469,
-0.0048023537,
0.0100385221,
-0.0122655956,
0.0254100002,
-0.0412596986,
0.0355198942,
-0.0308212601,
0.0059416937,
0.0143033499,
-0.0372570083,
-0.0011461029,
0.0162533261,
2.505e-7,
-0.0012202709,
0.04277879,
0.0540024005,
-0.0169469975,
-0.0131029682,
-0.0130143529,
-0.0465238653,
0.024207538,
-0.0086952457,
0.0116598131,
-0.002839023,
0.0170456953,
0.047439076,
-0.0036174643,
-0.0781589821,
0.0280396044,
-0.0944340602,
0.0039387713,
-0.0549755096,
-0.0600851849,
0.0091414563,
0.0619115867,
-0.014559756,
-0.0259096362,
-0.0236141142,
-0.0011913128,
0.0847334638,
0.0063782958,
-0.0374832377,
0.0466775335,
0.0230075363,
0.0016518986,
-0.0397880338,
-0.0337945521,
-0.0165328588,
-0.0069288122,
0.0207064264,
0.080620043,
0.012566898,
0.0347134508,
0.066171132,
0.0037663809,
-0.0236482285,
-0.0348448828,
0.043441534,
0.0199104846,
-0.0347044244,
-0.0265600178,
-0.0179671198,
0.03818487,
0.0150015093,
-0.0334789567,
0.012216025,
0.0405874997,
-0.0024617701,
-0.0642096922,
-0.0104710041,
-0.0200778209,
-0.0567420758,
-0.0281652473,
-0.029900508,
-0.0418647714,
-0.0554429144,
0.0178180449,
-0.0009050938,
-0.0471429229,
0.0108943228,
2.041097855e-34,
0.0475943722,
-0.0177538749,
0.02051441,
0.0370321274,
0.0085637281,
-0.0153661631,
0.0394177027,
0.041546803,
-0.009197088,
-0.0602435209,
-0.0232784171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05821v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05821v1 | Let's Reinforce Step by Step | 2023-11-10T01:35:51 | 2023-11-10T01:35:51 | Sarah Pan, Vladislav Lialin, Sherin Muckatira, Anna Rumshisky | cs.CL | cs.CL | While recent advances have boosted LM proficiency in linguistic benchmarks,
LMs consistently struggle to reason correctly on complex tasks like
mathematics. We turn to Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) as a
method with which to shape model reasoning processes. In particular, we explore
two reward schemes, outcome-supervised reward models (ORMs) and
process-supervised reward models (PRMs), to optimize for logical reasoning. Our
results show that the fine-grained reward provided by PRM-based methods
enhances accuracy on simple mathematical reasoning (GSM8K) while, unexpectedly,
reducing performance in complex tasks (MATH). Furthermore, we show the critical
role reward aggregation functions play in model performance. Providing
promising avenues for future research, our study underscores the need for
further exploration into fine-grained reward modeling for more reliable
language models. | [
0.0204574168,
0.0584369376,
-0.0019467834,
0.0257619768,
-0.0396746956,
0.0242898036,
-0.0082072783,
-0.0123869479,
-0.0514358543,
0.0047832318,
-0.0301583968,
-0.0091134831,
0.0237510949,
-0.0034282273,
0.0379507281,
-0.0634085014,
0.0427210368,
-0.0820194185,
0.0525696538,
-0.0256459638,
-0.0305902213,
0.0002465799,
-0.0345291011,
0.013328068,
-0.0062215007,
-0.0213263296,
0.0302391574,
-0.0335921943,
0.0029466834,
-0.0338179916,
-0.0042771529,
0.0367797837,
0.0222167391,
0.0563886836,
0.0000019723,
-0.0670969486,
0.0250923056,
-0.0132386023,
-0.0369212478,
0.000217581,
-0.0091036083,
-0.0099659739,
-0.0064652809,
0.0266621206,
-0.0211375766,
0.0064467886,
0.0069665168,
0.0578726903,
0.0417034887,
0.0631034672,
0.008752848,
-0.0497348644,
0.0353839137,
-0.0480442159,
0.0597909801,
-0.0389458798,
-0.002301581,
0.0309169553,
0.020368088,
-0.0227871407,
-0.0125194341,
0.0170840211,
0.0588804968,
0.0085097048,
-0.0104753328,
0.0714181364,
0.0438932739,
0.0010085502,
0.0175483618,
0.0149588343,
-0.0218899287,
-0.0084077055,
-0.0153444055,
-0.0142697655,
0.0095688188,
-0.0084098456,
-0.052087456,
0.0554213859,
0.0031695857,
0.0405694097,
0.0354974307,
-0.0077160844,
0.0383172408,
0.0501970723,
-0.0314263664,
0.0931946114,
-0.0087864827,
-0.0294251647,
0.0195246954,
0.0495798849,
-0.0612627305,
-0.0304259602,
-0.0278907456,
0.0445976108,
-0.0499639958,
0.0234630425,
-0.0078888396,
-0.0029709158,
-0.0011103878,
-0.0013499942,
0.0463193916,
0.0493872389,
0.0221059676,
0.0646273121,
-0.0392499343,
0.0245778486,
-0.0111789471,
0.0893254131,
-0.0083707534,
0.0182241052,
-0.0487766489,
-0.0252628531,
0.0268146005,
0.0502498038,
0.007933923,
0.0217710938,
-0.0539221652,
0.0380873941,
-0.0513118021,
0.0365622006,
0.0203989092,
0.0113656269,
-0.0099598309,
-0.0235442538,
-0.0921139196,
0.0018621335,
-0.0471951291,
0.0640457422,
0.0333722979,
-0.0048153391,
-0.0334125757,
-0.0122060496,
-0.0340187103,
-0.0251813158,
0.0129070738,
0.0751136467,
-0.0137871001,
-0.0195405576,
-0.0235362463,
-0.0354044214,
0.0258847103,
-0.069238849,
0.0117348405,
-0.0724944621,
0.0118293939,
-0.0120460736,
-0.0182104204,
-0.0173782725,
0.0072402358,
0.0140104434,
-0.0360138603,
0.0664504692,
0.0363872387,
0.0115426136,
0.0349829644,
0.000065316,
-0.0352267101,
0.0420204923,
0.0632271171,
0.0054789572,
-0.0008498239,
0.0071564671,
0.0234271288,
0.0154658342,
0.0312951058,
0.0016257695,
0.0014511235,
-0.0209088046,
-0.0126719447,
0.0251473188,
0.0401367806,
0.0370897837,
-0.0474430136,
0.0198647473,
0.0664398894,
0.0695522651,
0.0027737049,
-0.030570209,
-0.0073808664,
-0.0213921126,
0.0142532839,
-0.0089087719,
-0.115822129,
0.046121899,
-0.0185584743,
0.0254964698,
0.0194035936,
-0.0278033912,
-0.0295498408,
-0.0797888562,
-0.0097398423,
0.0050790133,
0.0203421135,
0.0534166731,
0.0871984437,
0.0019089368,
-0.0231102984,
0.0263069775,
0.0337391794,
-0.0251796562,
0.0328205638,
-0.0630564243,
0.0617354363,
0.0151725411,
0.048394084,
-0.0287790708,
0.0174677335,
-0.013690955,
-0.0340982787,
0.0369108282,
0.0172394868,
0.0017893141,
-0.0087187737,
0.0019062394,
-0.0188270137,
-0.0009500842,
0.0274272636,
-0.0191775579,
0.04924668,
-0.0532524921,
-0.0067713549,
0.0115702823,
-0.0404753275,
0.0468804874,
0.0059872167,
-0.0363449231,
0.0166674089,
-0.0116416933,
-0.0042206892,
-0.0210739337,
0.014659578,
0.0458638892,
0.0287154838,
-0.0229902975,
-0.0167317372,
0.0045127035,
-0.0509565845,
-0.0607056953,
0.0277810711,
0.0290784575,
-0.0226727743,
0.019805707,
-0.0585039817,
-0.0308848657,
0.0637861118,
-0.0431461558,
0.0245494563,
-0.0162614584,
0.0301150512,
0.01301187,
-0.0249923673,
-0.056411922,
0.079088293,
-0.0189243294,
0.0070264474,
-0.0370979607,
-0.0030813643,
-0.0234683827,
-0.0538155027,
0.0212534517,
-0.0184407532,
-0.0186093673,
0.0371146202,
0.0028240464,
0.0028580376,
-0.051556658,
-0.0278249756,
-0.0064406237,
-0.0111718606,
0.0012016969,
0.0435161777,
-0.0157238599,
-0.0191721171,
0.0041464856,
-0.0344303474,
-0.0236333255,
-0.038420666,
0.0474939868,
0.021840848,
0.0378077812,
0.0054163667,
0.0015969693,
-0.0398185365,
-0.0333766527,
-0.0260854717,
0.0240887608,
-0.0064346241,
0.0842842385,
-0.0483734123,
0.0028729893,
-0.0473189279,
-0.0039755241,
-0.0063964822,
0.0180910286,
0.0354147814,
-0.0108030979,
0.0116133438,
0.0969716832,
0.0003975468,
0.027893167,
0.0182927996,
0.0143587524,
-0.0636008158,
0.0207609646,
-0.0346237049,
-0.044574026,
-0.0085796146,
0.0097990893,
-0.0136173647,
0.0764567703,
-0.0228820741,
0.0118588042,
-0.0250630528,
0.0513299219,
-0.0016841758,
-0.0228857808,
-0.0520010032,
0.0030873606,
-0.0293730199,
0.0547421724,
-0.0696548969,
-0.0586965755,
0.0850188136,
0.0222138874,
0.0008201869,
-0.0366710685,
-0.0112304538,
-0.0188046563,
0.0338714421,
-0.0076215495,
-0.0300088078,
-0.0294900928,
-0.0150580648,
-0.0645211637,
-0.0282603521,
0.0599537492,
-0.0427514054,
0.0598979294,
-0.0437862612,
0.0026408038,
-0.0019871115,
-0.0410794169,
-0.068820335,
-0.0074082366,
-0.0338485502,
0.0351132751,
-0.046157781,
0.0032964428,
-0.0221845265,
-0.0307133738,
0.0570235439,
-0.0206513703,
-0.0260393452,
-0.0318578482,
-0.0167211052,
-0.0212084781,
0.0283005033,
0.0262659714,
0.0373118632,
-0.0758782178,
0.0149690891,
0.0262031816,
0.0689965114,
-0.0023400194,
0.0000419728,
0.0317346789,
0.0388642065,
-0.031058358,
-0.0134980604,
0.0418272763,
0.0149641614,
-0.0745691285,
-0.0043977266,
0.1077819243,
0.038485799,
-0.0351992734,
0.0013427526,
-0.043817807,
0.0601376854,
0.0144589357,
0.0261805765,
-0.0516609438,
-0.020270573,
0.0342405923,
0.0184512343,
0.0236442927,
-0.0044829184,
0.0291065499,
-0.1258389354,
0.0005224059,
0.0029195212,
-0.0417389162,
0.0076588304,
-0.0350930206,
-0.0024157304,
-0.0217364747,
-0.005236249,
0.0462126322,
0.0178558622,
-0.0018025718,
0.023988314,
0.0076265316,
-0.0223136283,
0.0288444627,
-0.0708508864,
0.0132643096,
0.0973235741,
-0.0202026721,
-0.0192420892,
-0.0849011764,
0.0277013965,
0.0363637209,
-0.0201587081,
-0.0069135595,
0.0170802567,
-0.0042281877,
-0.0120051149,
-0.0209607854,
0.0564245135,
-0.0425420441,
-0.0465026908,
-0.0253359377,
0.1048910096,
-0.0146782137,
0.0049760761,
-0.0146510461,
0.005750644,
-0.0383659601,
0.05102963,
-0.0094250022,
-0.0273400843,
-0.0548972823,
-0.0363823213,
-0.0377694778,
-0.0246660374,
-0.0221756026,
-0.0039873044,
0.0173719116,
-0.0167338084,
-0.0316862911,
-0.0340515859,
0.0287741777,
0.0182070248,
-0.0314985514,
-0.0137006324,
0.0150858611,
0.0012271719,
-0.0432978794,
0.0584739484,
-0.0381410159,
0.0523179024,
-0.0538952127,
0.0202532131,
-0.034161523,
-0.043197535,
-0.0221775174,
-0.0349706337,
-0.0740369558,
-0.0638915524,
-0.0398595184,
0.0486464128,
0.0223949775,
0.0346760675,
-0.0143307596,
-0.0481000207,
0.0331586003,
-0.0192698389,
-0.0619221143,
0.0303319432,
0.0437713489,
0.0228035189,
0.0027949328,
0.0214009285,
-0.0471509472,
0.0141807469,
0.0199722666,
0.0456451811,
0.0035615838,
0.0110519696,
0.030969996,
-0.009781519,
0.0588344969,
-0.0071495362,
-0.0085109463,
-0.0197563469,
0.0153962644,
-0.0100927949,
-0.0310365763,
0.0134792179,
-0.0174762513,
0.0237141792,
-0.0017141032,
0.0005715678,
-0.0399926938,
0.0310388748,
0.0449833684,
0.0075996122,
-0.008862216,
-0.0164534971,
-0.0017135803,
-0.0147697646,
0.0321447104,
0.0095198005,
0.005193511,
-0.0309703369,
0.0593701452,
0.0089696059,
0.0494932681,
0.0328984037,
0.0421943553,
-0.0181345697,
-0.0313168615,
-0.0635117218,
-0.059863925,
0.0190262031,
-0.0373422056,
0.079779394,
-0.0063857497,
0.0076381601,
-0.0392318219,
-0.0036025583,
0.0017098697,
-0.0032805495,
-0.0297024641,
-0.0110275447,
0.0430751592,
0.0471074022,
0.0164548438,
-0.0712552518,
0.0424536057,
-0.0182983931,
0.0235259999,
-0.0416401438,
0.0223684348,
-0.0044184253,
-0.0293852128,
0.0084421458,
0.0295554958,
-0.0257825255,
0.0098086158,
-0.0488079078,
-0.0955249518,
-0.0391050018,
0.0645103455,
0.0229194146,
-0.046163097,
0.0174012352,
0.043340046,
-0.0169961415,
-0.0184163246,
-0.0356718227,
-0.0193981938,
-0.0251033809,
-0.0160057675,
-0.0364530236,
-6.205068805e-33,
-0.0292970985,
-0.0170265362,
0.0511139706,
0.0416073911,
-0.0214787107,
-0.0235576592,
-0.036267709,
0.025459718,
-0.0001367613,
0.0332389921,
-0.0137924263,
0.0258922726,
0.0013503751,
0.0285507645,
0.0392621383,
-0.0054272227,
0.0119565204,
-0.0142198075,
-0.0533588454,
-0.0288732648,
0.0016763486,
-0.0082296627,
0.0426650755,
-0.0380031094,
0.0537509918,
0.0269444641,
-0.0335369445,
0.0607705675,
-0.0683677197,
0.0535109863,
0.0006950652,
0.0252392143,
0.0222886857,
-0.0409400947,
-0.0146065056,
0.0192466769,
-0.0863104165,
-0.0180896893,
0.0296445601,
-0.0124398647,
-0.0865664706,
-0.017844025,
0.0432737172,
0.016928453,
-0.0142063294,
-0.0204719305,
0.0068435329,
-0.0234966483,
-0.041060809,
0.0395905823,
-0.0191009715,
0.0118940379,
0.0001367436,
-0.0175260212,
0.0286644269,
-0.0222156998,
-0.0351808406,
0.0049387482,
-0.025706403,
0.0222693626,
0.0087228715,
0.0484906808,
0.0692725852,
0.0447585508,
0.0031532291,
0.0226415973,
0.0074389433,
0.0000342998,
-0.0493198447,
0.0141707342,
0.0656333491,
0.0377636887,
0.0938471705,
-0.0244331155,
0.0362725891,
0.0250533074,
-0.0387730375,
0.0174349155,
-0.0141015863,
0.0748314932,
0.0104374718,
0.0472705476,
-0.0190370847,
-0.0244931728,
-0.0857160315,
0.0383960642,
-0.0529448092,
-0.0188858192,
-0.0060990667,
0.0455129519,
0.0020483928,
-0.0222526956,
-0.0167314038,
-0.0259331502,
-0.0029245643,
-0.0099872919,
-0.0028529591,
0.0112202913,
-0.0193422493,
-0.0086792065,
-0.074747704,
-0.0097083449,
-0.0057309866,
-0.0116707301,
-0.0029820357,
0.033281371,
0.0287241824,
0.0163902771,
-0.0399873257,
-0.0038384064,
-0.0386799313,
0.015594909,
0.0248927101,
0.0220880043,
0.0232345741,
0.0012944279,
-0.0154145127,
0.0187606961,
-0.0211358331,
-0.0325835049,
-0.0476757251,
0.0318494849,
-0.0296977106,
0.0257323347,
-0.0086695226,
-0.0076627452,
-0.0280764028,
0.0015464032,
0.0433009788,
-0.0307203569,
-0.0166079346,
0.0109912576,
2.757e-7,
0.0304710492,
0.0375009328,
-0.002765632,
0.0909616649,
0.0017634648,
0.0693166703,
-0.0303845908,
-0.0222819019,
0.0480390005,
-0.0174538363,
-0.0104262922,
0.0648893788,
0.054244563,
0.0068837972,
-0.0014637852,
-0.0142194647,
-0.0678801462,
0.0334413052,
-0.0058856565,
-0.0066028684,
0.0389665663,
0.0745678693,
0.0635834113,
-0.038978748,
0.0005229231,
0.0023376856,
0.0667776987,
-0.0226516277,
-0.0108634699,
-0.0098775495,
0.0210480355,
0.0029299622,
0.0235265177,
0.0225353595,
-0.0014969303,
0.0190063156,
-0.0323360078,
0.0378628485,
0.0020208179,
-0.0188120455,
-0.070756413,
-0.0122635337,
0.028782025,
-0.0451331846,
0.0454247855,
-0.0833323672,
-0.033838626,
0.0085917739,
0.0263423398,
-0.0280623455,
0.0317902863,
-0.0039834022,
-0.0393436104,
-0.0136687877,
0.0146753211,
0.0138877844,
0.0070176073,
-0.0961016864,
-0.0623827465,
0.0442528352,
-0.0293477736,
-0.03002299,
-0.0352236368,
0.0293680821,
-0.0012134683,
-0.0478885397,
-0.0311012771,
2.255546596e-34,
0.0332375504,
-0.0031565691,
0.0128103262,
0.044859495,
0.059689533,
0.0179121513,
-0.0349070914,
0.021392474,
0.0536379889,
-0.0443086885,
-0.0105987294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06318v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06318v2 | Knowledge-Augmented Large Language Models for Personalized Contextual Query Suggestion | 2023-11-10T01:18:47 | 2024-02-19T12:05:28 | Jinheon Baek, Nirupama Chandrasekaran, Silviu Cucerzan, Allen herring, Sujay Kumar Jauhar | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at tackling various natural language
tasks. However, due to the significant costs involved in re-training or
fine-tuning them, they remain largely static and difficult to personalize.
Nevertheless, a variety of applications could benefit from generations that are
tailored to users' preferences, goals, and knowledge. Among them is web search,
where knowing what a user is trying to accomplish, what they care about, and
what they know can lead to improved search experiences. In this work, we
propose a novel and general approach that augments an LLM with relevant context
from users' interaction histories with a search engine in order to personalize
its outputs. Specifically, we construct an entity-centric knowledge store for
each user based on their search and browsing activities on the web, which is
then leveraged to provide contextually relevant LLM prompt augmentations. This
knowledge store is light-weight, since it only produces user-specific aggregate
projections of interests and knowledge onto public knowledge graphs, and
leverages existing search log infrastructure, thereby mitigating the privacy,
compliance, and scalability concerns associated with building deep user
profiles for personalization. We validate our approach on the task of
contextual query suggestion, which requires understanding not only the user's
current search context but also what they historically know and care about.
Through a number of experiments based on human evaluation, we show that our
approach is significantly better than several other LLM-powered baselines,
generating query suggestions that are contextually more relevant, personalized,
and useful. | [
0.075048402,
0.0411327034,
0.0009923546,
0.0269352421,
-0.0033629385,
-0.032657858,
0.0188123174,
-0.0161944814,
0.0577415116,
-0.0373032093,
-0.0486190021,
-0.0232424103,
-0.0562268645,
0.0300913956,
0.0001544397,
-0.032442458,
0.0073361117,
-0.0333012901,
-0.0119792828,
0.0255275313,
0.0282090846,
0.0245997328,
0.0310501345,
0.0343437642,
0.0153199024,
-0.0248094331,
-0.0299098864,
-0.0035940788,
-0.0017572893,
-0.0215905365,
0.0254812986,
0.0466821678,
0.0387738757,
0.0272817034,
0.0000016543,
-0.064667426,
-0.0156170698,
-0.018635584,
-0.0294288192,
0.0109667918,
0.0338704772,
0.0491179861,
0.015478163,
0.0032029822,
-0.0281776004,
0.0247500073,
0.0232648551,
0.043463666,
0.0490059815,
0.0495461933,
0.0048446348,
-0.0157537386,
-0.0027961582,
-0.0467442721,
0.074814789,
-0.0520143397,
0.0191624444,
-0.0417325683,
0.0156313963,
0.0389159322,
0.0059603369,
0.0095166704,
-0.0088772411,
-0.0243628714,
0.0512517765,
0.0331684947,
0.0032618262,
0.0271497071,
0.0090213036,
0.0779982358,
0.0105372807,
-0.0040898058,
-0.0086523974,
0.0134438127,
0.0057639293,
0.00047133,
-0.0363632366,
0.0005848411,
-0.0098746819,
0.0127819832,
0.0105585558,
-0.0033683812,
0.0544583201,
0.035399247,
-0.0298624374,
0.093613632,
0.012763341,
-0.0318709426,
0.0033615474,
-0.0122261252,
0.0283855088,
-0.0613159984,
0.0198285319,
0.0065999664,
-0.0449866913,
0.0146530438,
-0.0442470796,
0.0245316066,
0.0100440299,
-0.0342265628,
-0.0279203188,
0.0076665226,
0.0047902237,
0.0839258283,
0.0145400008,
0.0202308912,
-0.0219932459,
-0.0231815707,
-0.0492257364,
-0.0399780311,
-0.0381696932,
-0.0060116118,
-0.0102490922,
0.0260114055,
-0.0192808826,
-0.0259038266,
-0.0205904022,
0.0913471133,
0.0142422095,
0.0112318695,
0.0023749773,
0.0578698888,
-0.036714986,
-0.0222277604,
-0.0617863461,
-0.0065557971,
-0.0327649042,
0.0201763716,
0.01783273,
-0.0195146017,
0.0083010327,
0.0095015224,
0.0197487064,
-0.052047655,
-0.0101229912,
-0.0308253709,
0.012968163,
-0.0408351533,
-0.0487989485,
-0.0681461245,
0.0253758915,
-0.0093813771,
-0.0377155542,
-0.0502252206,
0.0348525904,
-0.022076847,
0.009581211,
-0.0235973168,
0.0131040439,
0.0283447709,
0.0000810742,
0.0714562312,
0.0120022669,
-0.0321953595,
0.0142297586,
0.0141435051,
0.0145716444,
0.0304563455,
-0.018212961,
0.068865642,
0.0549442843,
0.0038690742,
-0.0159997307,
0.0081457663,
-0.0017125368,
-0.0044441982,
-0.0085078077,
0.039095588,
-0.0158832613,
0.0299467854,
0.0351134613,
0.0321140289,
-0.0170206409,
-0.0037279848,
0.0539715588,
0.0636206046,
0.0350947455,
0.0357307605,
0.031451147,
0.0053599365,
-0.0182756092,
-0.0368241705,
-0.054835584,
0.0205615293,
-0.0416794457,
-0.0262438711,
0.0475130267,
0.0078452984,
-0.0402094536,
0.0107785165,
0.0509250164,
-0.0059706387,
0.0046819444,
0.0576445609,
0.0233927965,
-0.0191587973,
-0.004449721,
0.0044672969,
0.0062299832,
-0.0404120572,
0.0621622577,
-0.0337524787,
0.0497323461,
0.1304320097,
0.0537638329,
-0.0416799486,
-0.0082653612,
-0.0183184203,
-0.0094937989,
-0.0108264983,
0.0508666039,
-0.0261247568,
0.0257703215,
-0.0289016832,
-0.0684403405,
0.015927529,
-0.0142331198,
-0.0039256848,
0.0305999741,
0.0127467215,
0.0424936712,
-0.0466079004,
0.0172468014,
0.0005611069,
-0.0332511105,
-0.0348908082,
0.0373238809,
0.0252192952,
0.0018978908,
0.0491090417,
0.0378620923,
0.0118798278,
0.041217722,
-0.0090070274,
-0.0548908301,
-0.0255013984,
-0.0127244331,
0.0098175351,
0.0104773734,
-0.0196194369,
0.0474954024,
-0.0117727257,
0.0076083806,
-0.0409055166,
-0.0424380936,
-0.0170396417,
0.0936868489,
-0.0444696061,
0.0047107721,
-0.0059463223,
-0.0117350426,
-0.046408046,
0.0722443089,
0.0149960117,
-0.0108840633,
0.0130404141,
-0.0084566725,
-0.0385764763,
-0.0564617775,
-0.0534948036,
-0.0193479098,
0.0367808938,
0.0163501389,
0.0636297464,
-0.01021541,
-0.1007126421,
0.0222986713,
-0.1218210608,
0.0272234175,
-0.0029026165,
0.0255336333,
-0.003502104,
0.0685093775,
0.0019130381,
-0.0352149345,
-0.0703272447,
-0.0276514515,
-0.0280399434,
0.0303326789,
0.0242181215,
0.0397260375,
-0.0035071885,
-0.0365663767,
-0.017388517,
-0.0056464924,
0.0235907808,
0.0013051277,
0.0115964534,
-0.0258421432,
0.0193333961,
-0.0366801769,
0.0355324522,
-0.0159892775,
0.0254055392,
-0.0090896878,
-0.0725262389,
0.0164441224,
0.0584019311,
0.0371185988,
0.001312238,
0.016977448,
-0.0025593217,
-0.0630279109,
0.0019513974,
-0.0567622259,
-0.0003589718,
-0.0322812051,
-0.0024963771,
0.0428973213,
-0.02024398,
-0.0072489623,
-0.0076245433,
-0.0530048609,
0.0079703806,
0.0459863842,
-0.0102871209,
-0.0656529665,
0.0226511136,
0.0149863111,
0.0286750123,
0.022249531,
-0.0177414287,
0.0838559791,
0.0236823615,
0.0170900952,
-0.0001003829,
-0.0352731608,
-0.0398734026,
0.0685816258,
-0.0343988054,
0.0347764269,
-0.015967248,
-0.0277829301,
-0.0088115754,
0.0068721655,
0.0109694768,
-0.0421786606,
0.0389363505,
-0.0164171904,
0.0134689165,
0.0602205992,
-0.0659126565,
-0.0618198775,
-0.0798478872,
-0.0293255746,
-0.0115554594,
0.0044273473,
-0.0506567173,
-0.0289577078,
-0.016369544,
0.0298933573,
0.0011744007,
-0.0117951091,
-0.04092177,
-0.0014309052,
0.014150531,
0.0694923252,
0.0067344857,
-0.0279432684,
0.0218531024,
0.0189726204,
0.0277456343,
0.0538497232,
-0.0344846062,
-0.0113104582,
-0.024536293,
0.0629921257,
-0.0644974262,
-0.0340341069,
0.021059053,
0.0088840481,
0.0109244492,
-0.008169665,
0.1087859198,
0.0367406234,
-0.0875955522,
-0.0177300051,
0.0081296396,
0.0060431622,
0.0225605834,
0.044130981,
-0.0615465157,
-0.0272507817,
0.0155831166,
0.0293215886,
0.0126259103,
-0.0493244231,
-0.0270794909,
-0.1035561189,
-0.0254073571,
-0.0121652093,
-0.0002067655,
-0.0157781709,
-0.0648856983,
0.0103079537,
-0.0235742871,
0.0089372424,
0.0123195602,
-0.0320748538,
-0.0015953165,
0.0185268279,
0.0226612613,
-0.0570094623,
0.0265790466,
-0.0693357587,
0.0331038721,
0.0514907315,
0.025686495,
0.0242205299,
-0.0120435469,
-0.0188841633,
0.005275568,
0.0148509014,
-0.0200096406,
0.0109162936,
-0.0510567389,
0.0216310322,
-0.0447014458,
0.021072967,
-0.0368087813,
0.0122318035,
-0.001290896,
0.0709118545,
-0.0464959964,
0.033597786,
-0.0241063237,
-0.0630816892,
0.0013059725,
0.0900301635,
-0.0216252729,
-0.0527105629,
0.0204703677,
-0.0472014509,
-0.0040733116,
0.0167898238,
-0.0046029962,
0.0046311039,
-0.0123709468,
0.0158850588,
-0.0466128103,
-0.0401628762,
0.0119457152,
-0.0062612249,
0.0328826346,
0.0302275121,
-0.0035915817,
-0.0177732669,
-0.0231313985,
0.0330983512,
-0.0569115318,
0.028398484,
-0.0610860065,
0.0095462045,
0.0557628572,
-0.0578034483,
-0.0081508309,
-0.0025420596,
-0.0502533838,
-0.0394379012,
-0.04695623,
0.0219145324,
0.0091348467,
0.0576116703,
-0.0432993248,
-0.0883495137,
0.020691501,
0.0447785892,
-0.0230864994,
-0.0497605614,
-0.013629932,
0.0248562805,
0.0224685557,
0.0373244621,
-0.0746498108,
-0.0500013493,
-0.0552912503,
0.0105824023,
-0.0372130759,
-0.1091063246,
0.032952074,
0.0163151771,
0.0371747315,
-0.0028728792,
0.0276743174,
-0.0155398389,
0.0215801802,
-0.0186235774,
-0.0407804139,
-0.0015779141,
0.0099555776,
0.0507236496,
-0.0272138249,
0.0063827387,
0.0371668376,
-0.0101690143,
0.0226001292,
-0.0892111212,
-0.0287321527,
-0.0061833337,
-0.0001156592,
0.0426065773,
0.0360668227,
-0.0201489795,
0.037888594,
0.031725999,
0.0537006706,
-0.0506476797,
0.0398480818,
-0.0047252649,
-0.0203093104,
-0.0297766626,
0.0419503786,
-0.0778252408,
-0.0552297533,
0.0052892957,
-0.0033555985,
0.0496958271,
-0.0185077488,
-0.0011508571,
-0.033987578,
0.0059060198,
-0.0336350538,
0.0050420421,
0.0285046138,
-0.0136961918,
0.0073934696,
0.0408605039,
-0.0011506006,
0.0285742786,
0.0493412167,
-0.012488313,
0.0478165522,
-0.0081920996,
-0.0577640533,
-0.0321618691,
-0.0087236324,
0.0258563906,
0.0775679946,
-0.0617096163,
-0.0083513437,
-0.008863234,
-0.0280161537,
0.0156043852,
-0.0308063515,
-0.0359964333,
0.0020616418,
0.0900298283,
0.0656873509,
-0.0139088966,
-0.0305759385,
-0.0422070883,
0.0172084812,
-0.0290224515,
-0.0217287503,
-0.0315451249,
-5.610239276e-33,
0.0156247495,
-0.0046960362,
0.0189371854,
-0.0113707529,
-0.0149325412,
-0.019341141,
-0.0094591593,
-0.011384666,
-0.0250465907,
-0.038569849,
-0.038447164,
0.0003967383,
0.0056847115,
0.0311265122,
-0.008686455,
-0.0246250015,
0.0649305731,
0.0371097252,
0.0176504757,
0.0550791807,
0.0707143247,
0.0601465292,
-0.0007634825,
-0.0539327674,
0.0628012046,
-0.0371288657,
-0.0275303088,
0.0544404127,
0.0100237317,
0.0736874044,
-0.0401776209,
0.0405249335,
0.0061027701,
-0.0255969558,
0.0263555013,
0.013080446,
-0.0646129996,
-0.0241567977,
0.0366962738,
0.0015900536,
-0.0043794839,
-0.0390318297,
0.0037166795,
-0.0316117853,
0.0223965459,
0.0247706361,
0.0375674926,
0.0199447107,
-0.0313308425,
-0.0467886776,
0.020698186,
-0.0142398262,
-0.0043163174,
-0.0197344609,
0.0198557004,
0.008794643,
0.0079654483,
0.0330924951,
-0.026792217,
0.0524254106,
-0.023166934,
0.0165389962,
0.0409558751,
0.0186282825,
-0.0046464335,
0.052613847,
0.0150172943,
-0.0076090624,
0.0024365277,
-0.0119567551,
-0.000424257,
0.0166694522,
-0.0311061088,
0.0372655205,
-0.0148680853,
0.0084934179,
-0.0182057824,
0.0320324004,
0.0451800451,
-0.0053240354,
0.021362273,
0.020081196,
-0.0294820908,
-0.010445728,
-0.0583242513,
0.0035467434,
-0.0619640164,
0.0107540274,
0.0335127003,
0.0380033702,
-0.0158312079,
-0.0076348418,
0.0093052788,
-0.023298746,
-0.0258430112,
0.0572604798,
0.013583241,
-0.0348388515,
0.011927532,
0.014292852,
-0.0297171436,
0.0156357288,
0.0284940246,
-0.0697823912,
-0.0522662587,
0.0170134753,
-0.0126351267,
0.0066794762,
-0.0169565789,
-0.0236711577,
-0.0167582668,
-0.0195626095,
-0.0333312489,
-0.0087755518,
0.0463469513,
0.0420693234,
-0.0253354032,
0.0666006804,
0.0771016777,
0.0310547147,
-0.0073412806,
-0.0575532056,
0.0422606543,
-0.0084599406,
0.0091943359,
-0.010277858,
-0.0148187652,
0.0202940535,
0.0504972637,
-0.0196371153,
-0.0143899573,
-0.0032041878,
2.401e-7,
0.0046591409,
0.0153976725,
-0.0169842076,
0.0379335769,
0.012472352,
0.048047591,
0.0376905203,
0.0450033247,
0.0302380379,
0.0185322203,
0.0354011394,
0.01266672,
0.0134614194,
-0.0034048872,
-0.0911538303,
-0.023122916,
-0.0025655639,
-0.0159560926,
-0.0595908016,
-0.0165321603,
0.0340644307,
0.0774288401,
0.0475749783,
-0.0101173958,
0.018364612,
-0.0564562343,
0.0478620194,
-0.040694546,
-0.0254823361,
0.0010945537,
0.0183744673,
0.0555064157,
-0.0132223843,
-0.0068154493,
-0.0307643786,
0.0043405835,
-0.0024425839,
0.0579399429,
-0.0124058789,
-0.0237970315,
-0.0238104127,
-0.0189795885,
0.0050494764,
-0.0522726104,
0.0872589201,
0.0195304286,
0.0365016125,
0.000877039,
0.0062987097,
-0.0290768407,
0.010920261,
-0.065626353,
-0.0252553523,
-0.028341515,
0.0081358338,
0.0406249501,
-0.0278647579,
-0.0838874578,
-0.011309267,
-0.017742265,
-0.0553016812,
-0.0417496823,
-0.0565378219,
0.0357908458,
-0.0245340634,
-0.0360034145,
0.0415141992,
1.736903221e-34,
0.0064608413,
0.0695153102,
-0.0047241654,
-0.0050679827,
0.0309284367,
0.0255345404,
-0.0215850044,
-0.0110271359,
0.0786622539,
-0.1220757291,
-0.0324387588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05812v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05812v2 | CFBenchmark: Chinese Financial Assistant Benchmark for Large Language Model | 2023-11-10T01:12:03 | 2024-05-21T08:37:05 | Yang Lei, Jiangtong Li, Dawei Cheng, Zhijun Ding, Changjun Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential in the
financial domain. Thus, it becomes important to assess the performance of LLMs
in the financial tasks. In this work, we introduce CFBenchmark, to evaluate the
performance of LLMs for Chinese financial assistant. The basic version of
CFBenchmark is designed to evaluate the basic ability in Chinese financial text
processing from three aspects~(\emph{i.e.} recognition, classification, and
generation) including eight tasks, and includes financial texts ranging in
length from 50 to over 1,800 characters. We conduct experiments on several LLMs
available in the literature with CFBenchmark-Basic, and the experimental
results indicate that while some LLMs show outstanding performance in specific
tasks, overall, there is still significant room for improvement in basic tasks
of financial text processing with existing models. In the future, we plan to
explore the advanced version of CFBenchmark, aiming to further explore the
extensive capabilities of language models in more profound dimensions as a
financial assistant in Chinese. Our codes are released at
https://github.com/TongjiFinLab/CFBenchmark. | [
-0.0020726684,
0.0808429942,
0.0124633852,
0.0436682552,
0.0013817594,
0.0219983961,
0.0564371496,
0.0484382883,
-0.0042336411,
-0.0059619816,
-0.0625578687,
-0.077536732,
-0.005008731,
0.0228818953,
0.0327097103,
-0.0499705076,
0.0183028392,
-0.0182760917,
0.0183695834,
-0.0232907515,
0.0203868691,
-0.0280796085,
0.0386160538,
0.0223956332,
0.0026501387,
-0.0333248973,
0.0090378746,
-0.0148354936,
0.0239644367,
-0.0218491685,
0.0074881972,
0.0004059015,
-0.017958317,
0.0870409235,
0.0000020895,
-0.0503933318,
-0.0342891812,
0.0174154844,
-0.0123316618,
0.0584039502,
0.0411839187,
-0.0378823727,
0.0054467581,
0.0168832522,
-0.0267388765,
0.0057276385,
0.0371485651,
0.1082014441,
0.0406397544,
0.0911548287,
-0.0257362556,
-0.0714555234,
0.0093948748,
-0.0885558128,
-0.0235877614,
-0.0937829465,
0.0234441794,
0.0373022333,
-0.0234338436,
-0.0157965645,
-0.0275819618,
0.0160483215,
0.0275827181,
-0.0041323639,
0.0098489271,
0.0183212645,
-0.0402835347,
0.0139609072,
-0.0257198215,
0.0652061924,
-0.0211637523,
0.040226128,
0.0105912974,
-0.0285847075,
-0.0192667693,
0.0134848673,
-0.0381644517,
0.0375155583,
-0.0239505079,
-0.0148465727,
0.0033911089,
-0.0171254538,
0.03046293,
0.0079056872,
-0.0512700975,
-0.0010194817,
-0.0080282511,
-0.0342813693,
0.0231830385,
-0.0077277101,
-0.0297540277,
-0.0246139821,
0.0179842766,
0.0164068658,
0.0192303751,
0.0004470893,
-0.0307064913,
-0.0477041304,
0.0011276162,
-0.080283381,
0.0714519918,
0.0478284694,
-0.0342272595,
0.0369417593,
-0.1033527032,
0.0885815471,
-0.0182402041,
-0.0190961603,
-0.0325399823,
0.0174118243,
-0.0395565294,
-0.0004206909,
-0.0651728734,
0.0607768223,
-0.0297939703,
-0.071233891,
-0.0634554401,
-0.0191757679,
0.0074930023,
0.0295973644,
-0.0002896223,
-0.0364776216,
-0.0238297004,
-0.0222907122,
-0.0223917086,
-0.0079414034,
-0.0286159925,
0.0224687122,
-0.0168226901,
-0.008971639,
0.0215577539,
0.0378613509,
-0.0108694648,
-0.0109162424,
0.0263013355,
0.0661441013,
0.0223011877,
-0.05546939,
-0.034346357,
-0.0173424818,
-0.0091474149,
-0.0291921478,
-0.0002959024,
-0.02472491,
-0.0094089024,
-0.0133937914,
0.0230219811,
0.0242922772,
0.0158352535,
-0.0216279849,
0.0265149288,
0.0276100375,
0.0299833007,
-0.0273679439,
0.0121631967,
-0.019080013,
-0.0233559888,
0.0462290756,
-0.0051090112,
0.0475532934,
0.0346426852,
0.0216230284,
-0.0146320909,
0.0648006797,
-0.0271513257,
-0.0508545861,
-0.0266026296,
0.0215244107,
0.0018346801,
-0.0202599298,
0.0461923927,
0.0319564827,
-0.0461347364,
-0.0096160769,
0.0651652142,
0.0202323273,
0.072849296,
0.0233654119,
-0.0057197833,
0.0237863809,
0.0617061071,
0.0039269361,
0.0198354889,
0.0048662717,
-0.0149930427,
0.05743175,
-0.0079525933,
0.002916876,
-0.0483515598,
-0.0303200949,
-0.0130198253,
-0.0497395955,
-0.0416629091,
-0.0070019611,
0.0183175765,
-0.0325211026,
-0.0286941677,
0.0132258683,
0.010962341,
-0.0329569727,
-0.0179369599,
-0.0092309713,
0.0454054996,
0.0974446237,
0.0391655229,
-0.0121438745,
0.0353388935,
-0.0051962212,
-0.0369943641,
0.0831945539,
0.0689769611,
-0.0028445381,
-0.0208417084,
-0.0661636665,
0.0075934562,
0.0242957622,
0.0144613963,
0.0419503041,
0.0037878214,
0.0139727388,
0.0294457283,
-0.0055148397,
-0.0321935639,
0.0050081052,
-0.0172580928,
-0.0551961511,
0.0119924163,
-0.0142650716,
0.00783379,
0.0248280354,
-0.0436095893,
0.009833076,
-0.0102438116,
-0.0236358289,
-0.0420814455,
0.0192227922,
-0.0624428988,
-0.0118473675,
0.0258021355,
-0.0052044112,
-0.0004113648,
0.0349752009,
-0.0520864092,
-0.0450456627,
-0.0475393645,
-0.0133972373,
-0.0031382197,
-0.0863298848,
0.0276542678,
0.0064826608,
0.0390538909,
0.0080634048,
0.0830143541,
-0.0110135917,
0.023396112,
-0.0143350968,
0.0533305854,
-0.008399372,
-0.0445930585,
0.0149996178,
-0.0183816906,
-0.004402698,
0.0313613638,
0.0227277353,
0.0195338074,
0.0185943712,
-0.0418702066,
-0.0462717302,
-0.006691772,
-0.0387695767,
0.0251526982,
0.0019891537,
-0.0117838597,
-0.0063361521,
-0.0065155663,
-0.0306954365,
0.0444349982,
-0.0181163494,
-0.0172899868,
0.0505046584,
-0.0301016271,
-0.0111134807,
-0.0355840437,
0.014896756,
0.0372604728,
0.018749224,
0.0059572179,
-0.0418894514,
-0.0309659373,
-0.0118026668,
0.0072949543,
0.0201164652,
-0.0080022216,
0.0131342141,
-0.0115678599,
-0.026875766,
0.0422735363,
0.0468336269,
0.0311022867,
0.0442082435,
-0.0350565463,
0.0171401203,
-0.0289258901,
0.0085971737,
0.0324468054,
0.0096716844,
-0.021842951,
-0.0143175228,
0.0084302463,
0.0566977747,
-0.0188792665,
0.0184884872,
-0.0459381416,
-0.0061888779,
-0.0207359456,
0.0254161265,
-0.0263189971,
0.0092980051,
-0.041931048,
0.0039948127,
-0.0151882488,
-0.0386686847,
0.0282604378,
-0.0425931588,
-0.0154924905,
-0.0264684577,
-0.0181817021,
-0.080067642,
0.0461407602,
-0.0087965205,
0.0345993116,
-0.0035620062,
-0.0310722571,
-0.0109092984,
0.0053891153,
0.0210666768,
-0.0205365624,
0.0349592194,
-0.0202925745,
0.0431672148,
-0.0265409779,
0.0152010778,
-0.0110027092,
-0.069357954,
-0.0316788331,
0.0533299185,
0.061012283,
-0.0646107346,
-0.0387090072,
0.0537416637,
-0.0114606563,
0.0366932601,
-0.0105657876,
0.0164593086,
-0.0045615579,
0.0303480718,
0.0656948313,
0.0137392348,
0.0330670178,
-0.0768559054,
0.091319263,
0.0267207716,
0.0105596269,
0.0022948037,
-0.0045319009,
-0.0256917439,
-0.0189450029,
-0.05739858,
-0.0237319134,
0.0065411883,
0.0005212961,
-0.062848337,
-0.0007561699,
0.114484258,
0.012549351,
-0.0006913599,
0.001066668,
0.0008583261,
-0.0061831418,
-0.0285886806,
0.006208343,
-0.110591948,
-0.0245171003,
-0.0100548118,
0.0115951588,
0.0290030465,
-0.008702741,
0.005642524,
-0.132372126,
0.0566319637,
0.0004765729,
-0.0137944324,
-0.0312831253,
-0.0099096708,
-0.0187002309,
-0.0081181917,
0.0403967425,
0.0201972779,
-0.020975044,
-0.0173120108,
0.0030489331,
-0.0292040184,
-0.0134574175,
-0.0053730439,
-0.0258319266,
-0.0358971842,
0.043189846,
0.0134651661,
0.0148740821,
0.0007025861,
-0.0370478034,
0.0014781189,
-0.0015143155,
-0.0080885841,
0.0331168026,
0.0206514951,
-0.0189009421,
0.0330455862,
0.0312855989,
0.0023636294,
0.047523424,
0.0255322251,
-0.0489956476,
-0.0156130623,
-0.0343512669,
0.0115231518,
0.0217767432,
-0.0369181633,
0.0809820518,
0.0241034012,
-0.040094424,
-0.0458325446,
-0.0173396636,
-0.038702406,
-0.0704059452,
0.0211739913,
0.0309483223,
0.0017952969,
-0.00225884,
-0.1123722196,
-0.0340622663,
-0.0123471003,
0.0402468182,
-0.0265608802,
0.0102182915,
0.0395832807,
-0.0271160658,
-0.0239519104,
0.009665872,
-0.0482755154,
0.0322043672,
-0.0762482882,
0.0135656623,
0.0151417665,
-0.0452494435,
-0.0429636836,
0.0496486053,
-0.0648442507,
-0.0343316942,
-0.0043496187,
-0.0057131308,
0.0097556831,
-0.0393013023,
-0.0261025354,
0.0115990946,
0.0162583422,
0.0140226437,
-0.0566781275,
-0.0028684523,
0.0466931202,
-0.0328277387,
-0.0307493582,
0.0333507918,
-0.0374595895,
0.0414941348,
-0.0177495126,
0.0487648733,
-0.0296947733,
-0.0140467286,
-0.0198234878,
0.0426953472,
-0.0096811671,
0.014870964,
0.020973416,
-0.0235362314,
0.0361449383,
-0.0198836103,
-0.00490788,
-0.0238219369,
-0.0255232081,
0.0709105358,
0.0058265291,
-0.0001590292,
0.0253744759,
0.0077209044,
-0.0266664196,
0.0063595031,
0.0154892569,
-0.0458247177,
0.0213852078,
-0.0083707962,
-0.0384538583,
0.0300556906,
-0.0116231162,
0.0264793579,
0.004316499,
0.0035192638,
0.0455410592,
0.0027862394,
0.0283698402,
-0.0342866927,
-0.0253065899,
-0.0303842984,
-0.0141237574,
-0.0189818535,
0.0482914075,
0.0636331663,
-0.0392886102,
0.0116627254,
-0.0905963778,
0.0081424173,
-0.0296031144,
-0.0212904848,
0.0394667275,
-0.0524389297,
0.0095095178,
0.0102149108,
-0.0206620302,
-0.0393620804,
0.1199668646,
0.0236404277,
0.0150768189,
-0.0215313397,
0.0172519181,
-0.0695303828,
-0.0468151644,
0.0737620294,
-0.0014525044,
-0.0342079997,
0.0271184072,
-0.0659588799,
-0.0288635492,
0.0601910874,
-0.008740929,
0.002182208,
-0.0056582177,
0.0110260984,
0.0278334636,
-0.0035682572,
0.0459664948,
-0.0163589027,
0.0054793856,
-0.0108710313,
-0.0010155619,
-0.051166106,
-6.339476299e-33,
-0.0243834388,
-0.010692223,
0.0217088461,
-0.0070308549,
0.0251288489,
0.0317580961,
-0.021377746,
-0.0317912214,
0.013720152,
-0.0090185655,
0.0091684926,
0.0185376965,
0.0235277712,
0.0259017516,
-0.0368451886,
0.0255766194,
0.0562960878,
-0.0166532397,
0.0022550097,
-0.0279969592,
0.0320727602,
0.0704149082,
0.0263203047,
-0.0357281566,
-0.0128300199,
0.0026200032,
-0.0256691016,
-0.0190540031,
0.0325310938,
0.0518533476,
-0.0158118159,
0.0355871283,
0.0071516503,
-0.0481229648,
-0.0236093998,
-0.0190516599,
-0.0641065389,
-0.0173113756,
-0.0208334569,
0.0542510003,
0.0113105839,
-0.0153711112,
-0.0002370516,
-0.0047666566,
0.0022720606,
0.0065333503,
0.0158783533,
-0.0393714234,
-0.0000200417,
-0.0479225256,
-0.0724598691,
0.0679835603,
0.027240742,
0.0313843451,
0.0395351984,
0.0501733236,
-0.0061599468,
0.0074725621,
-0.0114073148,
-0.0130467033,
0.0380571224,
0.0385461077,
0.0059235008,
0.0250767134,
-0.0129585396,
0.0391899645,
-0.0118292738,
-0.0014776631,
0.00537667,
0.009720007,
0.0241265148,
0.0577293374,
0.0654964522,
0.0550855733,
0.014466715,
-0.0244965404,
-0.0233313013,
0.0455817543,
0.0265668426,
0.0148358177,
0.0212960616,
0.0294967387,
-0.0262597799,
-0.0058011888,
-0.0060983552,
0.0138868652,
-0.0382603928,
0.0200967584,
0.0314114727,
0.0516574308,
-0.040482007,
-0.0115139885,
0.0198663324,
-0.037277136,
-0.0513437912,
0.0091123804,
0.0017574042,
0.0190926082,
-0.0212338604,
0.0132757369,
-0.0670223162,
-0.0908612609,
0.0021936621,
0.0092384946,
-0.0316641331,
-0.0303993858,
0.042493768,
0.0034351542,
-0.0699969083,
0.0028072004,
0.0265406668,
0.0105880639,
0.0390091427,
0.0523446091,
0.0004529263,
-0.0063147498,
-0.0070920885,
0.0224100258,
-0.0023926659,
0.0014096902,
-0.0220011771,
-0.0358669385,
0.0069853128,
0.0685178488,
0.031951379,
0.0565237738,
-0.0252467338,
0.062207479,
0.0501456186,
-0.0280640814,
-0.0148870768,
0.049183771,
2.733e-7,
0.038171988,
0.0430866107,
0.0370302461,
0.0418551192,
0.0149165457,
0.0157371797,
-0.0528090373,
0.0029235338,
-0.034117911,
0.0446082056,
0.0380377956,
0.0391287915,
0.1164584681,
-0.0280884076,
-0.0633364692,
-0.0121863317,
-0.0729642436,
0.0199601538,
-0.0563436523,
0.0326407589,
0.0047125896,
0.0866439641,
-0.0678024366,
-0.0133043276,
0.0229170434,
-0.1143452227,
0.0726139173,
0.009245527,
-0.009013922,
0.0223017652,
0.0320970714,
0.0319124758,
-0.0289190654,
0.0020175097,
0.0084481463,
0.0316761322,
0.047209993,
0.0738743693,
0.0402589664,
0.0081674848,
0.0069033378,
0.0187363885,
-0.0122371493,
-0.0444768555,
0.0410576276,
-0.0281881019,
-0.0102984179,
-0.0503413938,
-0.0417678207,
0.017049415,
0.0388109796,
-0.0060968995,
0.0006379686,
0.039777495,
0.0302476212,
-0.0455121845,
-0.0056159785,
-0.0321010537,
-0.0538163967,
0.0082790144,
-0.0297965724,
0.0201719906,
-0.0721654817,
0.0045066886,
0.010409656,
-0.0443788134,
-0.0147594055,
2.182727706e-34,
0.0505763255,
-0.0428947993,
-0.0495669879,
0.0509788059,
0.0500902012,
-0.0150247738,
-0.0356603637,
0.0567478202,
-0.0440555178,
-0.0791595131,
0.0098116631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05800v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05800v2 | Leveraging LLMs for Synthesizing Training Data Across Many Languages in Multilingual Dense Retrieval | 2023-11-10T00:17:10 | 2024-04-15T22:11:33 | Nandan Thakur, Jianmo Ni, Gustavo Hernández Ábrego, John Wieting, Jimmy Lin, Daniel Cer | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | There has been limited success for dense retrieval models in multilingual
retrieval, due to uneven and scarce training data available across multiple
languages. Synthetic training data generation is promising (e.g., InPars or
Promptagator), but has been investigated only for English. Therefore, to study
model capabilities across both cross-lingual and monolingual retrieval tasks,
we develop SWIM-IR, a synthetic retrieval training dataset containing 33 (high
to very-low resource) languages for fine-tuning multilingual dense retrievers
without requiring any human supervision. To construct SWIM-IR, we propose SAP
(summarize-then-ask prompting), where the large language model (LLM) generates
a textual summary prior to the query generation step. SAP assists the LLM in
generating informative queries in the target language. Using SWIM-IR, we
explore synthetic fine-tuning of multilingual dense retrieval models and
evaluate them robustly on three retrieval benchmarks: XOR-Retrieve
(cross-lingual), MIRACL (monolingual) and XTREME-UP (cross-lingual). Our
models, called SWIM-X, are competitive with human-supervised dense retrieval
models, e.g., mContriever-X, finding that SWIM-IR can cheaply substitute for
expensive human-labeled retrieval training data. SWIM-IR dataset and SWIM-X
models are available at https://github.com/google-research-datasets/SWIM-IR. | [
0.0369789265,
0.0008763553,
0.0114393402,
0.0311249383,
-0.0134887239,
0.000374099,
0.013124641,
0.0191656426,
0.0412520543,
-0.0117533728,
-0.063112393,
-0.0489762425,
-0.0402717702,
0.015831653,
0.0177919734,
-0.0269147865,
0.0499716029,
-0.0195769221,
-0.0149495741,
-0.0356318913,
-0.002388956,
0.0219005533,
0.0426736511,
-0.0073653422,
0.0288857464,
0.0163227096,
-0.0244706105,
0.0256121475,
-0.0254633948,
-0.0184083097,
0.05697418,
0.045860026,
0.0262345616,
0.0191434771,
0.0000016527,
-0.0522270091,
-0.0206515789,
-0.0047090333,
-0.0205511004,
-0.0140268225,
0.0306801572,
-0.0048486884,
0.0517352559,
0.0072211255,
-0.0154470336,
0.007798071,
0.0099793561,
0.0184032004,
0.057602942,
0.0856702775,
0.0087417448,
-0.0202419069,
0.0239651892,
-0.0273594186,
0.0240707658,
-0.0449089855,
-0.0101709776,
-0.0160324126,
0.0309293196,
0.0525772944,
0.0234438963,
0.0490821525,
0.0143048251,
-0.0084010875,
-0.0026316796,
0.0069341417,
-0.0503701158,
-0.0350347124,
0.0049971812,
0.0521943197,
-0.0115712527,
-0.0091721956,
-0.0096853422,
0.0259669591,
0.017783653,
-0.0031757229,
-0.0476191416,
0.0300245509,
-0.0235029776,
0.00303612,
-0.0210317224,
-0.010309699,
0.0064134812,
0.0184000209,
-0.0251886193,
0.0455252267,
0.024598401,
-0.0233044531,
0.010651716,
0.0131606758,
-0.0020740596,
-0.0045164465,
0.0068616262,
0.0361836776,
-0.0716734752,
-0.0112258075,
-0.0079599349,
-0.0429912768,
0.0528345779,
-0.0405399688,
0.0134052541,
0.0221919641,
-0.0417252705,
0.0750348568,
-0.0124916788,
0.0333261937,
-0.0075571598,
0.0160179306,
-0.0701615736,
-0.0560990013,
-0.0004671701,
-0.0102983927,
-0.0457649529,
0.0443327911,
-0.08652924,
0.0185215808,
-0.0264048968,
0.0264356285,
0.030536931,
-0.014220451,
0.0202485602,
0.0113008255,
-0.0566609055,
-0.0024171399,
-0.0351903997,
0.0219991263,
-0.0381737985,
-0.0183560271,
0.0273521617,
-0.0608708337,
0.0002128856,
0.0202020854,
0.0061784056,
-0.0512476712,
0.0460788384,
0.0394307896,
-0.0648628473,
-0.0397603028,
-0.0306447279,
-0.0403123721,
0.031206701,
-0.057687819,
-0.0129406266,
-0.0756625161,
0.0488438979,
-0.0134979431,
-0.0163994171,
-0.0302816536,
0.0002507671,
0.04654276,
-0.0163368639,
0.023444267,
-0.0238508433,
0.0136110978,
0.0362498835,
-0.0123177106,
0.0091358637,
0.0709862933,
-0.0348373502,
0.0453639664,
0.0839284882,
0.0231709071,
-0.0239784103,
0.0342079662,
0.0207278691,
0.0252694562,
-0.0213746708,
0.0460596867,
-0.0047891811,
0.0165662151,
0.0372713618,
0.0509501658,
-0.0338860042,
-0.0011863206,
0.0063484022,
0.0418743268,
0.0373939276,
-0.000922607,
0.0434212387,
-0.0028386661,
-0.0072693941,
0.001113733,
-0.0278151724,
0.0343174487,
-0.0358405821,
0.0137948021,
0.0585411973,
0.0326134712,
-0.0649731979,
-0.044044368,
0.0345055722,
0.0137104811,
-0.0634942129,
0.0534545518,
0.0426729359,
0.0085984701,
-0.0041046748,
0.0346341245,
0.0213466547,
-0.0613838471,
0.0345234908,
-0.0264142826,
0.0454068296,
0.0842775553,
0.0410052948,
-0.0418243743,
0.0074306773,
0.0187081434,
0.0275216848,
0.0147386137,
0.0355869159,
-0.031380482,
0.0236770641,
-0.0567407496,
-0.0416102931,
0.0128479274,
-0.0040567298,
0.0255428478,
0.0394477434,
0.0144475354,
0.0381146036,
-0.0366571881,
-0.0456655957,
0.0206363238,
-0.052303303,
-0.0357526168,
0.0198549107,
-0.0063597383,
-0.0045960504,
0.0351264104,
-0.0009841232,
0.0135686575,
0.0448259637,
-0.0264309105,
-0.0205543209,
-0.026593728,
-0.0270509012,
-0.0204406474,
0.0213189274,
0.0010806216,
0.0049774419,
-0.0158822313,
-0.0219133757,
-0.0466872342,
-0.0382071808,
-0.0029012333,
-0.0020194035,
-0.0776855573,
0.0130644115,
0.0134521378,
0.0013055041,
-0.0455097929,
0.0673619956,
0.0093232002,
0.0591726229,
0.039136745,
0.0113394661,
0.0143054323,
-0.0755899549,
-0.0504386835,
0.0340921283,
-0.0147430077,
0.0372694731,
0.06481307,
0.0539538004,
-0.0512786917,
0.0094487555,
-0.1067617089,
0.0175627619,
-0.0608625524,
-0.0068986551,
0.0039849929,
0.042747587,
-0.0008128883,
-0.0335919969,
-0.0638401359,
-0.051641833,
0.042218376,
0.0725882351,
0.0174854025,
0.0152971251,
0.0359467342,
-0.0441392064,
-0.0432469808,
0.0447741747,
0.0411993414,
-0.0091760233,
-0.0154035287,
-0.0388405919,
0.0269382764,
-0.0368057452,
0.0186029933,
-0.0140381157,
0.0095105348,
0.0099569513,
-0.0691443011,
0.0500757545,
0.0564067811,
0.0410734266,
-0.034400627,
0.0200929064,
0.0011964018,
-0.0986920223,
0.0337775424,
-0.0417222567,
-0.0551025197,
-0.0204896647,
-0.0281583946,
0.0175921675,
0.0052316133,
-0.0394423828,
0.0006186829,
-0.03627887,
-0.0270110536,
0.0249536484,
-0.0167857427,
-0.0857650712,
0.0448074564,
-0.0037351153,
0.0743217021,
-0.0303197876,
-0.0549064875,
0.0540839769,
-0.0088136513,
-0.0259947926,
-0.0440298542,
-0.0168521162,
-0.0519811437,
0.0520855859,
-0.0487250909,
0.0422942266,
-0.0400887616,
-0.0119587677,
-0.026632024,
0.0002342756,
0.0312509909,
-0.048177138,
0.0573372878,
-0.0105962707,
0.0263515133,
0.0023398963,
-0.063958481,
-0.0516680479,
-0.0267833937,
0.001426614,
0.0084926104,
-0.0105847772,
-0.0258951019,
-0.0363834985,
-0.0200200174,
0.0442502871,
0.0458075479,
-0.0312306248,
-0.0149524007,
0.0054477267,
0.0044201668,
0.0371494032,
0.0093305428,
-0.0343488045,
-0.0220414363,
0.0189980716,
0.0317870639,
0.023044711,
-0.0738986954,
0.0325761028,
0.0082997819,
0.0691739693,
-0.0229221731,
-0.0183894653,
0.0039308909,
0.0516558178,
-0.0041056061,
-0.0363573432,
0.05318534,
0.0099264504,
-0.0849454701,
-0.0398933776,
-0.0317988768,
0.0549217723,
0.0620623007,
0.0678236634,
-0.0369807482,
-0.0191065725,
0.0043175607,
0.0566500425,
0.0281068739,
-0.0081263464,
-0.0104785133,
-0.1302980334,
0.0322702341,
-0.0175859723,
-0.0304314531,
-0.028507866,
-0.0569179803,
-0.0197055135,
-0.0135366507,
0.0367035307,
0.0528861172,
-0.0247665662,
-0.0037176257,
0.0008231857,
0.0363790281,
-0.0402530544,
-0.003765004,
-0.0450060256,
-0.0287187807,
0.0236953218,
0.0040595923,
0.0058316914,
-0.0201563593,
0.0506085083,
-0.0406209603,
0.0120835183,
-0.0276085548,
0.0487038381,
0.0059618745,
-0.0088672033,
-0.0207864083,
-0.0010851907,
-0.0176184941,
0.0155609865,
0.0079848822,
0.0515089445,
0.0010162049,
0.0375535525,
-0.0241421591,
-0.0232711881,
-0.0241431259,
0.0659240708,
-0.0051545096,
0.0054924507,
-0.0141990632,
-0.0148961693,
-0.0133360056,
-0.0300743524,
-0.0342528261,
0.0293926504,
-0.0431804582,
0.0011738822,
-0.0594920702,
-0.0690536276,
0.0176984016,
0.0384189487,
-0.0056152232,
0.0338028148,
-0.0569782257,
-0.0130567923,
-0.0392751396,
0.0615115352,
-0.0439348109,
0.0149287554,
-0.054063566,
-0.0033801179,
0.0330371782,
-0.0588575341,
-0.005053164,
-0.0123341689,
-0.0021517181,
-0.0725754797,
-0.0282213334,
0.0645435601,
0.0158578698,
0.0415747836,
-0.0148249464,
-0.0671055838,
0.0480994023,
0.0697178394,
-0.0487261228,
-0.0152551075,
0.0198030788,
0.0317370519,
-0.0364966765,
0.0477824509,
-0.0848466456,
0.0108168591,
-0.0111035472,
0.0469334647,
-0.0274861753,
-0.053684976,
0.0439623855,
0.0679435059,
0.0396822542,
-0.0144614913,
0.0199759584,
-0.0493055508,
-0.0029723682,
-0.0129185608,
-0.0447108708,
-0.031929411,
0.0332359634,
0.0220471602,
-0.0324928313,
0.0122927241,
0.0387819186,
0.001506592,
0.0337924883,
-0.0462788865,
-0.0108942185,
-0.0001194333,
0.0025861757,
0.0190361682,
0.0044331574,
-0.03404494,
0.0302646961,
-0.0087208729,
0.0709170103,
-0.0310086943,
0.0022334328,
0.0295929182,
0.0061924681,
-0.0230908617,
0.0185155105,
-0.0607674271,
-0.0728687346,
-0.0171787869,
0.0208837185,
0.0822007954,
-0.0303275827,
0.0140951583,
0.0119517371,
-0.0158395711,
-0.0429226793,
-0.0172646381,
0.0235872976,
-0.0278019644,
0.014991113,
0.0434049629,
-0.0139768524,
0.0128949862,
0.0658821687,
-0.0073554916,
0.0265183523,
-0.0216574129,
-0.0145492032,
-0.0208425727,
-0.0390176922,
0.0484124459,
0.028585637,
-0.03259556,
-0.0324516743,
-0.0083959196,
-0.0413982347,
0.0237241574,
-0.0064339195,
-0.033624094,
0.0072542066,
0.0669050664,
0.1022260711,
-0.0075707622,
0.0005663766,
-0.049685549,
-0.0025637106,
-0.0167308692,
-0.0159321688,
-0.0057331529,
-6.091463521e-33,
0.0032959941,
0.0131721711,
0.0407054164,
-0.019801436,
0.0022366203,
-0.0164411049,
-0.0305135343,
0.0074963882,
-0.0335103199,
0.0015187206,
-0.0580795594,
-0.0024558778,
0.0221722126,
0.0256324224,
0.0154766515,
-0.0096992292,
0.0453268066,
-0.0109936669,
-0.0077484557,
0.0232082848,
0.0540385619,
0.0677779689,
0.0234662984,
-0.0214017816,
0.0370673686,
-0.042713102,
0.0037966708,
0.0773022324,
0.0006465015,
0.0328874514,
-0.0005074823,
0.050886482,
0.0270853247,
-0.0101695172,
-0.0070444751,
-0.0169800669,
-0.0874223411,
-0.0309779029,
0.0199356284,
-0.0211702157,
-0.0391863175,
-0.0223043114,
0.0189641844,
-0.062351767,
0.010610492,
0.0100946054,
0.0388780385,
-0.0041773142,
-0.0467647053,
-0.0610600337,
-0.0048788264,
0.0238508955,
0.0298755858,
0.0096920142,
0.0400038734,
0.0802354962,
0.0075278045,
0.0360281207,
-0.009732875,
0.0375782661,
-0.0694908127,
0.0676879734,
0.0275679193,
0.0232961178,
-0.012873726,
0.0351126529,
0.0337047949,
0.0111018512,
0.0073723788,
0.0154549647,
0.0138265388,
0.0429577641,
0.021048503,
0.0865778625,
0.0010307641,
0.008859016,
-0.0285513997,
0.0606711358,
0.0032026044,
0.0248112977,
0.0071177646,
0.0149518801,
-0.0428498052,
-0.0348338746,
-0.041899208,
0.000166094,
-0.0392753705,
-0.0054758755,
0.0379122049,
0.0429542437,
-0.0169081464,
-0.0354865342,
0.0516868532,
0.019185422,
-0.0070569338,
0.0127159674,
0.0125909736,
-0.0207862649,
0.0074257408,
0.0417496674,
-0.0128535144,
-0.0489999913,
-0.0036046975,
-0.0305016004,
-0.0440577753,
0.0424133725,
0.0434556603,
0.0056162421,
-0.0479355045,
0.0184561778,
-0.0226190295,
0.0325939432,
-0.0278481059,
0.0325045325,
-0.0111204265,
0.009599993,
-0.0085052038,
0.0546308123,
0.0248985998,
0.0013993504,
-0.0611737818,
-0.0742615983,
0.0217724331,
0.0190603174,
0.006105145,
0.0512887239,
-0.061622791,
0.0401127189,
0.0263950899,
-0.025455432,
0.007525878,
0.0649478659,
2.42e-7,
0.0207203086,
-0.0016374753,
0.019892754,
0.0372606888,
-0.0440792516,
0.0141771734,
-0.0104472563,
0.0159366746,
0.0282659903,
-0.0277338382,
0.0031060951,
0.0395650342,
0.0236687213,
0.0159754567,
-0.1160587445,
-0.0202286355,
-0.0478856675,
-0.0394512042,
-0.045086503,
-0.0558028966,
0.0188690033,
0.0756697133,
-0.0268779323,
-0.022256542,
-0.0028605582,
-0.0641129091,
0.0648597479,
-0.0167736504,
-0.0323424377,
0.0269169174,
0.0670922399,
0.0367691182,
0.0139591293,
-0.0242078863,
-0.0274925977,
0.0117325271,
0.046415735,
0.049153138,
0.0198401865,
-0.0294050928,
0.02405403,
-0.0207914673,
-0.0185350236,
-0.0363963582,
0.0539693423,
0.0103442511,
0.044305101,
0.0010431717,
-0.0198821761,
-0.0085023753,
0.0320760049,
-0.0535918102,
-0.0341022722,
0.0353175253,
0.0254339576,
0.0102156689,
-0.0006663725,
-0.0678337216,
-0.0238063559,
-0.0276333466,
-0.036294464,
-0.0189143028,
-0.0418213569,
0.0419118702,
-0.0436022542,
-0.0369791351,
0.0164174791,
1.886932001e-34,
0.0657994151,
0.0175489075,
0.0110781016,
0.0075512649,
0.0243271384,
-0.0314347595,
-0.0146473059,
0.0302474592,
0.0065377266,
-0.0648842081,
-0.0246798415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07592v1 | Hallucination-minimized Data-to-answer Framework for Financial Decision-makers | 2023-11-09T22:53:52 | 2023-11-09T22:53:52 | Sohini Roychowdhury, Andres Alvarez, Brian Moore, Marko Krema, Maria Paz Gelpi, Federico Martin Rodriguez, Angel Rodriguez, Jose Ramon Cabrejas, Pablo Martinez Serrano, Punit Agrawal, Arijit Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been applied to build several automation
and personalized question-answering prototypes so far. However, scaling such
prototypes to robust products with minimized hallucinations or fake responses
still remains an open challenge, especially in niche data-table heavy domains
such as financial decision making. In this work, we present a novel
Langchain-based framework that transforms data tables into hierarchical textual
data chunks to enable a wide variety of actionable question answering. First,
the user-queries are classified by intention followed by automated retrieval of
the most relevant data chunks to generate customized LLM prompts per query.
Next, the custom prompts and their responses undergo multi-metric scoring to
assess for hallucinations and response confidence. The proposed system is
optimized with user-query intention classification, advanced prompting, data
scaling capabilities and it achieves over 90% confidence scores for a variety
of user-queries responses ranging from {What, Where, Why, How, predict, trend,
anomalies, exceptions} that are crucial for financial decision making
applications. The proposed data to answers framework can be extended to other
analytical domains such as sales and payroll to ensure optimal hallucination
control guardrails. | [
0.0280123465,
0.0890196189,
-0.0219840128,
0.0216006357,
-0.0118280696,
0.0071052997,
0.0064321831,
0.0351837724,
0.0243832525,
-0.0153511576,
-0.0163138974,
-0.020626504,
-0.0351897068,
0.0435032807,
0.0446166545,
-0.0329078063,
0.023746185,
-0.0484085679,
0.0138871474,
-0.0207957923,
0.0087132026,
-0.0135422209,
0.0005375317,
0.0167548656,
0.0121470867,
-0.0261874441,
-0.020738354,
-0.0120446412,
-0.0218681749,
-0.0128746331,
-0.0068207961,
0.0638823137,
-0.0066352854,
0.0509154983,
0.0000022609,
-0.0661982298,
-0.0143093625,
-0.0007812756,
-0.0575011,
-0.0425119065,
0.0157855302,
0.015606259,
0.0650323629,
0.0197720919,
-0.059768144,
0.010499537,
0.0526330508,
0.0557912849,
0.0926381275,
0.0312170479,
-0.0094397031,
-0.0591786616,
0.0236985721,
-0.0106776925,
0.0740246102,
-0.0071537537,
0.023091333,
0.039202217,
0.0365284644,
-0.0268447418,
-0.0170196481,
0.0428943411,
0.0035440677,
0.0109375641,
0.0372710899,
-0.0053349477,
-0.0625910535,
-0.0128679425,
-0.0248940811,
0.0566021204,
0.0320264027,
-0.0166408084,
0.0142060742,
-0.0133194486,
0.0341969281,
0.0323602259,
-0.061753422,
-0.0015116531,
-0.0044918172,
-0.0450801738,
-0.0130121885,
0.0244571362,
0.016288029,
0.0108964723,
-0.0611665286,
0.0594104044,
-0.0119787566,
-0.0441643186,
0.0403622985,
-0.0181703847,
0.010439679,
-0.0599880293,
0.0201838519,
0.0514498465,
-0.054067608,
-0.0093846545,
0.0248662289,
-0.0072364192,
0.0394727923,
-0.0879516378,
-0.0027271006,
0.0241306778,
-0.0111031625,
0.0488621369,
-0.0038373959,
0.0396209247,
-0.0253770091,
-0.0107375644,
-0.0454038121,
-0.0056919595,
-0.0409538895,
-0.0171437208,
-0.0524235889,
0.055979982,
-0.0444246382,
-0.0236186851,
-0.022872854,
0.0281390678,
-0.0150930118,
0.0482516848,
0.0067853695,
0.0323494822,
0.008184189,
0.0028194932,
-0.0661854818,
0.000403442,
-0.0653923303,
-0.011201553,
0.0187966786,
-0.0384098701,
0.0178913027,
0.0301236566,
-0.0197400302,
-0.0174435079,
0.0500231422,
0.0746369734,
0.0226960983,
0.0309442952,
-0.0463073142,
-0.0793303102,
-0.0003257297,
-0.0361345485,
-0.0243774261,
-0.0663736984,
0.0129391747,
0.0181736108,
-0.033787813,
-0.0067234943,
0.0079722051,
0.0502238683,
-0.0237752702,
0.0707887784,
0.010912966,
-0.0019796966,
0.0171056092,
-0.0197520498,
0.0063278633,
0.0621306226,
0.0099651944,
0.0669063181,
0.0474917293,
-0.0198096018,
0.0585211329,
0.0205707643,
0.009046834,
-0.0387028046,
-0.0324659459,
0.0897499546,
-0.0027825111,
-0.0013608425,
-0.0120898988,
0.02623979,
-0.0108390246,
0.0041342988,
0.0697795823,
0.0453944504,
0.0421729796,
0.0161381811,
-0.0087901838,
0.0169683266,
0.0113345711,
-0.0251937769,
-0.0163130574,
0.0468038544,
-0.0475049764,
0.0211707707,
0.0292936228,
-0.0408343263,
-0.0454715043,
-0.0350620858,
0.0095459176,
0.0150743453,
0.0070309704,
0.0756650344,
0.0032068531,
-0.0171013139,
-0.0472462848,
0.0139997341,
0.0048570805,
-0.0203128085,
-0.0231369603,
-0.0612021945,
0.0327197686,
0.0936250165,
0.047692284,
-0.0349867903,
0.0459561124,
-0.0391620323,
0.0312070958,
0.0332189389,
0.023357369,
-0.0185717847,
-0.0389684625,
-0.0346048549,
-0.0003717089,
0.0446893536,
0.0010704346,
-0.018459592,
-0.0194155611,
0.008103542,
-0.022692956,
-0.0395437367,
-0.0006627978,
0.0215467699,
0.0156006971,
-0.0517163128,
0.0231204554,
-0.0070272698,
0.0167884268,
0.0228420366,
0.015568804,
0.0382117033,
0.0010869482,
-0.020943895,
-0.029256884,
-0.0361221358,
-0.0161998533,
0.0327544361,
0.0025023741,
-0.0081113735,
0.000245182,
-0.022236241,
-0.0135466671,
-0.0360774659,
-0.0191935599,
-0.0452921577,
0.003480952,
-0.0673785433,
-0.0298408028,
0.0060454556,
0.0396180861,
-0.0359650739,
0.0760599822,
-0.0057075578,
0.0319475718,
-0.0186726265,
0.0027455015,
-0.0000644804,
-0.0446563959,
0.0329439007,
0.0142500764,
-0.009861338,
0.0585354827,
0.0303847976,
0.0019315563,
-0.0331008248,
-0.0022146935,
-0.0716429055,
-0.0168750919,
-0.0191038456,
0.0161953196,
0.0136732524,
0.0144453105,
-0.0109621882,
-0.0496529117,
-0.0822963715,
0.0044414001,
0.0258552022,
0.0262808837,
0.0579174459,
0.0154574001,
-0.0271849986,
-0.0241492856,
-0.0104059428,
0.0145899616,
0.0357602388,
0.0076332963,
-0.0055559203,
-0.0415802933,
-0.0463859625,
-0.036491476,
0.0055090711,
0.026201522,
0.0205119923,
-0.010909087,
-0.026337916,
0.0225285571,
0.0510211736,
0.0096196327,
0.0219896007,
-0.0133823631,
-0.0013228918,
-0.0507689454,
0.0077193645,
-0.0315632783,
0.0341607369,
0.0182011165,
-0.0332371145,
0.0443098173,
0.0202199686,
0.0009436185,
0.0018092436,
-0.0746900961,
0.0475493036,
0.0272397492,
-0.0157842878,
-0.0703457594,
0.0260229111,
-0.0115745123,
0.0856191888,
0.0263324305,
-0.0370246358,
0.0698059425,
0.0024218061,
-0.0184627678,
-0.0008047622,
-0.0346567594,
-0.0413214713,
0.0510959998,
0.004818087,
0.0124707036,
-0.0552448742,
-0.0186175462,
-0.055064857,
-0.0230088457,
-0.0007666399,
-0.0589450598,
0.0422923677,
-0.0287578143,
-0.0040389556,
0.0154267792,
-0.0079027899,
-0.0345993042,
-0.0567511804,
-0.0234757327,
-0.0133194551,
0.02629802,
-0.0246906225,
-0.0362905599,
-0.0048006321,
0.0233412273,
0.0127940848,
-0.0218091682,
-0.0453430451,
0.0127403988,
0.0261690766,
0.0608909801,
0.0175708439,
0.0329808779,
-0.0227115229,
0.0711641982,
0.0577483214,
0.0544942841,
-0.0166444443,
0.0160798971,
0.002623226,
0.0328931361,
-0.0406810455,
0.0159812625,
0.0444173254,
-0.0384192616,
-0.020369146,
-0.0055584363,
0.0822300389,
0.0428838506,
-0.0092649395,
-0.0040616808,
-0.0637646988,
0.0648122877,
0.0053821197,
0.0743092149,
-0.1072509289,
-0.0170957111,
-0.0190760624,
0.0384675451,
-0.008316908,
-0.047683578,
-0.0359199755,
-0.0926359817,
0.0535520352,
-0.0359136872,
-0.0163811427,
-0.0234362762,
-0.0472614281,
-0.0190132316,
-0.0044941385,
0.0073115374,
0.0444559231,
0.0003456516,
-0.0049581118,
0.0018551686,
-0.0569080375,
0.0253498871,
0.0335650817,
0.014690619,
-0.0182816088,
0.0828760564,
0.0212317742,
-0.0062340037,
-0.0390316024,
-0.0507236421,
-0.0299090892,
-0.0194358286,
-0.0126581471,
0.0512031801,
0.0221629068,
0.0057189171,
-0.0189135186,
0.0598203875,
-0.0593382716,
0.031274505,
0.0370568,
0.0617421269,
-0.0535463206,
-0.0245089624,
-0.0291360412,
0.0330361761,
0.0172928497,
0.0855965167,
0.0045072776,
-0.0803993493,
-0.0537690707,
-0.0521166027,
-0.0114440108,
-0.0423583649,
-0.0277911816,
0.023365926,
0.0574822538,
0.0027500994,
-0.0860535055,
-0.0479779318,
0.0213453937,
0.0502613261,
-0.0075850827,
0.0318095572,
0.0063382275,
-0.0028112205,
-0.0117653795,
-0.00964275,
-0.0617677197,
0.0280278474,
-0.0548091307,
0.02828696,
0.0234487914,
-0.0612264872,
-0.0354382731,
0.0271481555,
-0.079270713,
-0.0127495248,
0.0109886806,
0.0343539454,
0.037713293,
-0.0212281495,
-0.0081354799,
-0.020760309,
0.0320175849,
0.0610489547,
-0.0531808995,
-0.027108768,
0.0217695087,
0.0420479253,
-0.0050566792,
0.0300350171,
-0.0748134926,
0.0097894762,
-0.0052300263,
0.0302551799,
-0.0381478332,
-0.0134448605,
0.0271406304,
0.0258772336,
-0.0371909514,
0.0144644445,
-0.0212569367,
0.0153438989,
0.0171906017,
-0.0247507747,
-0.0180302318,
-0.0307263862,
-0.0264551658,
0.0159998275,
-0.0500722826,
0.0232238993,
-0.010708075,
-0.0122149847,
-0.0461257659,
-0.0450602062,
-0.002305849,
0.0207196083,
0.0363473594,
0.0357755236,
-0.0274384022,
-0.0141692283,
-0.0165993012,
0.0490977094,
0.0537959598,
0.015133339,
0.0728296041,
0.0050666877,
-0.0341725461,
-0.0232916418,
0.0042001363,
-0.0691945404,
-0.0982007012,
0.0081879273,
0.0061704838,
-0.0370098576,
-0.0006090319,
-0.0282026529,
-0.0321028456,
-0.0066863084,
0.0168556534,
-0.0043617571,
0.0614322126,
-0.0274280738,
0.0141014708,
0.0131180296,
-0.0394257531,
-0.0380763113,
0.0778831989,
-0.0077192057,
-0.0125550693,
-0.0270543788,
-0.0269896183,
-0.0595757775,
-0.0582865402,
-0.0105347661,
0.010758481,
-0.0153777376,
-0.0218789279,
-0.0889935195,
-0.0538839288,
-0.0387571864,
0.0106360056,
-0.0240942668,
-0.0182567146,
0.043404486,
0.0536754578,
0.023033414,
0.0165367275,
-0.0281645171,
0.0497712791,
-0.0259360541,
-0.0287438799,
-0.0458053239,
-6.508207493e-33,
0.00978518,
-0.0289552528,
0.0285866894,
-0.044387769,
0.0399736837,
-0.0388722792,
-0.0004627252,
0.0075330101,
-0.0173819549,
-0.0056427941,
-0.0245821513,
0.0074596205,
0.0145409256,
0.039747823,
0.0087991832,
-0.0460585915,
0.0085029751,
-0.0262826346,
-0.0048264428,
0.0250103865,
0.0384231396,
0.0135755092,
0.0016371104,
-0.0390418097,
0.0693546385,
-0.0251859017,
-0.0313014872,
0.0446661301,
0.0219142679,
0.0319601297,
-0.0242012758,
0.0616405308,
0.0015199078,
-0.0736408979,
-0.0174044296,
0.0249309298,
-0.0550370999,
-0.0558640286,
0.0214875694,
0.0219308883,
-0.0226016659,
0.0127966125,
0.0416222811,
-0.0292880852,
0.0134129934,
0.0179015044,
0.0170833729,
-0.0344838761,
0.0033649395,
0.0085873595,
-0.0314330198,
0.0011548308,
-0.0198166445,
0.0317520872,
0.0212681442,
0.1465682387,
-0.0078184493,
0.0068079443,
-0.0483152866,
0.0369500145,
0.0057186238,
-0.0216809474,
0.040291246,
0.0191043671,
0.0071174428,
0.0338234007,
0.0274471138,
-0.0065533826,
-0.0165601838,
0.0224738978,
-0.0320021696,
0.0527722463,
0.0675562471,
0.0313721821,
0.0254752152,
0.0053573828,
-0.048995208,
0.035047669,
-0.0155602917,
-0.0085492413,
0.0399990119,
-0.0023859292,
-0.0591270663,
-0.0327577218,
-0.0051334938,
0.0410002209,
-0.056876082,
-0.0356629118,
0.0308003239,
-0.0097083319,
-0.0155214593,
-0.0029227326,
0.030179508,
-0.0401684828,
-0.061744228,
0.0251409411,
-0.0018139882,
0.0074094147,
0.0253433101,
0.0120952753,
0.0134607544,
0.0248930249,
-0.0148580465,
-0.0224080123,
0.0036801593,
0.031485904,
-0.0091126943,
-0.0150333624,
-0.0718833506,
-0.0035787853,
-0.0068507171,
0.0421758071,
-0.0070328661,
-0.0001328366,
0.0167637896,
0.015052855,
0.0007709682,
0.0278759804,
-0.0074006859,
-0.0157350674,
-0.0127184838,
-0.0045272154,
-0.0198568776,
0.0252526179,
0.0032210655,
-0.0088289669,
-0.0084455581,
0.0134526854,
0.0369109213,
-0.0532569177,
-0.0028980442,
0.0305238198,
2.939e-7,
0.0240463614,
0.0392750837,
-0.0216865875,
0.0657057315,
0.0182682984,
0.0424297377,
0.0356877968,
-0.0026278794,
0.0237281471,
-0.0412413813,
0.0219390932,
-0.007312912,
0.0437927395,
0.0500280969,
-0.0882838592,
-0.0675551146,
-0.044376228,
0.0204239562,
-0.0573071837,
0.0102576343,
0.0559123978,
0.0651969463,
-0.0064087999,
-0.0185814276,
-0.0004776162,
-0.0332662836,
0.0250413716,
-0.0552136153,
0.0171128009,
0.0310523771,
0.0366459377,
0.0028535922,
0.029812403,
0.0658584535,
-0.0185870882,
-0.0135986181,
0.0132072568,
0.0149403932,
0.0197896417,
-0.0167918969,
-0.0200235508,
-0.0441010296,
0.0426868051,
-0.0777858421,
0.0757569,
-0.0368801206,
-0.0374182574,
0.0276156124,
-0.0156049477,
-0.028791029,
0.0353897549,
-0.0232549626,
-0.015551432,
0.0016944098,
0.0287858527,
0.015417723,
0.0502607562,
0.0059327707,
-0.0173134338,
0.0268422384,
-0.0463886708,
0.0072576846,
-0.0514598414,
0.041350428,
-0.0156308077,
-0.0650290623,
0.0050524357,
3.023693813e-34,
0.0415292941,
0.0183553472,
0.0060038171,
0.0213421285,
0.0600276664,
0.0002105566,
0.0577955581,
0.0340163633,
0.0684949383,
-0.0991071761,
-0.024120722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05769v1 | Chatbots Are Not Reliable Text Annotators | 2023-11-09T22:28:14 | 2023-11-09T22:28:14 | Ross Deans Kristensen-McLachlan, Miceal Canavan, Márton Kardos, Mia Jacobsen, Lene Aarøe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent research highlights the significant potential of ChatGPT for text
annotation in social science research. However, ChatGPT is a closed-source
product which has major drawbacks with regards to transparency,
reproducibility, cost, and data protection. Recent advances in open-source (OS)
large language models (LLMs) offer alternatives which remedy these challenges.
This means that it is important to evaluate the performance of OS LLMs relative
to ChatGPT and standard approaches to supervised machine learning
classification. We conduct a systematic comparative evaluation of the
performance of a range of OS LLM models alongside ChatGPT, using both zero- and
few-shot learning as well as generic and custom prompts, with results compared
to more traditional supervised classification models. Using a new dataset of
Tweets from US news media, and focusing on simple binary text annotation tasks
for standard social science concepts, we find significant variation in the
performance of ChatGPT and OS models across the tasks, and that supervised
classifiers consistently outperform both. Given the unreliable performance of
ChatGPT and the significant challenges it poses to Open Science we advise
against using ChatGPT for substantive text annotation tasks in social science
research. | [
0.0626818016,
0.03417271,
0.0128812268,
-0.0133453365,
-0.0421920642,
0.0369451493,
0.0294632539,
-0.0074114832,
0.0836070627,
-0.0974807665,
0.0092629185,
-0.0204335526,
-0.0262597334,
0.0216633342,
-0.0179519765,
-0.0372424796,
0.0388147235,
0.0037175789,
0.0280453153,
0.0035022134,
0.014510572,
0.0222860966,
0.0022773782,
0.0757440701,
-0.0149721969,
-0.0197252221,
-0.0081899473,
-0.0130861336,
0.0054002688,
-0.0073575121,
0.0171948764,
0.0858816952,
0.0194324031,
0.1076282412,
0.0000018266,
-0.0328956284,
-0.0065053687,
0.0166221578,
-0.031515453,
0.000757527,
0.0606971532,
-0.0153218769,
-0.007017097,
0.0306385849,
-0.0291926041,
-0.0125845075,
0.071149826,
0.0240022969,
0.0603520498,
0.0657268092,
0.0076733357,
0.0144070992,
0.0559164807,
-0.0166869033,
0.0189222582,
-0.0103123533,
0.0307828076,
0.0190835316,
0.0021893084,
0.0681256801,
0.0198690128,
0.045455154,
0.0136673348,
-0.0418416858,
0.0200004857,
0.036003422,
-0.0794185624,
-0.0352651887,
-0.0002037591,
0.0624043681,
0.0389033109,
-0.0320656449,
0.0193459839,
0.0036176853,
0.0002692127,
0.0184261464,
-0.0489462465,
0.0486147813,
0.0096790837,
0.0057225362,
-0.0139092654,
-0.0059964573,
0.0193234682,
0.0477016978,
0.0364797264,
0.0235732626,
-0.0207309797,
-0.0307284538,
0.0156858806,
0.0382494964,
-0.0302245412,
-0.0688956007,
-0.0036449283,
0.0054733623,
-0.0035883393,
0.0148280552,
-0.0417437293,
-0.0241548549,
0.0276918095,
-0.0723261908,
-0.0272959881,
0.0261794794,
-0.0513160676,
0.0754126981,
0.0093737235,
0.0125274472,
0.0012857369,
0.043704059,
0.0350872837,
-0.0159618314,
-0.0742370784,
-0.0069534495,
-0.0199773628,
0.0133005716,
-0.0156595055,
-0.0321445093,
-0.0346574336,
0.0421383046,
0.0131015666,
0.0171026103,
0.0029336524,
-0.0307696238,
-0.0071946774,
0.0164571572,
-0.0064635091,
0.0053950232,
0.0148595525,
0.0114763733,
0.0014691132,
-0.0772460327,
-0.0029174963,
0.0350201428,
0.009012185,
-0.0115618883,
-0.0114654861,
0.032672815,
0.0181151442,
-0.0542475954,
-0.009272215,
-0.0171710216,
-0.0319501609,
-0.0641182661,
-0.011754524,
-0.0707383454,
0.001099105,
0.0317877792,
-0.0077559021,
-0.016689606,
0.0243220795,
0.0413982794,
-0.0571191162,
0.0591690205,
-0.0517722368,
-0.0126647372,
0.0320709608,
0.0184088908,
-0.025171509,
0.079659678,
0.0232777726,
0.041419182,
0.0469165407,
-0.0009827816,
0.0184211805,
0.0351159498,
-0.0190474242,
0.0070733721,
0.0375740752,
-0.0044439458,
0.0004996186,
0.0189553015,
-0.0091794496,
0.0578261949,
-0.0195307471,
0.0090073664,
0.0765227899,
0.0681053028,
-0.0092334272,
0.0103813848,
0.0154527929,
0.0634089857,
0.0401867516,
-0.0227148365,
-0.0273607671,
0.0156639405,
-0.0472215712,
-0.0374500751,
0.024666734,
-0.0205394812,
-0.018774746,
-0.0245808642,
-0.0289983228,
-0.0372725762,
0.0426250845,
0.0091299508,
0.0706681535,
-0.0319714807,
-0.0179078467,
-0.0006944152,
0.0465489142,
-0.0341056734,
-0.0227561295,
-0.0626894981,
0.035023693,
0.0390897617,
0.0375207067,
-0.0271443613,
-0.0063403724,
-0.0633749217,
0.0511865094,
0.070633851,
0.0531209335,
0.0000518286,
-0.0519785024,
-0.0273561683,
-0.0267003849,
-0.0177242551,
0.0308803841,
-0.0051114857,
0.0484038554,
0.002547323,
0.0092253052,
-0.0064023645,
-0.0442610458,
0.0374254808,
-0.0139555093,
0.0055079898,
-0.0232723784,
-0.0297524594,
0.0176084694,
0.0487365499,
-0.0094519695,
-0.0145100271,
-0.0011403775,
0.0085445959,
-0.0505788364,
-0.0053911381,
-0.000611145,
-0.0323350765,
0.0225614198,
0.0176123939,
-0.0544331186,
0.0497652106,
-0.0431758165,
-0.016941417,
0.0015010638,
-0.035009075,
0.0275651086,
-0.0592203066,
-0.017511148,
-0.0580024831,
0.0131153101,
-0.0417965204,
0.0366450287,
0.0116466405,
-0.0047016493,
-0.0141025977,
-0.0208831504,
0.0257283673,
-0.0309036765,
-0.0579717085,
-0.0081343073,
0.0017014476,
0.0111573087,
0.0263653118,
0.0021477956,
-0.0484925546,
-0.0274914671,
-0.134618178,
0.0202928558,
-0.027232049,
-0.0099892784,
-0.0079921028,
0.0033291976,
0.0021836639,
-0.0060511162,
0.006040554,
0.0037541271,
0.0056824549,
0.0389428362,
0.0245365482,
-0.0321012884,
0.017719185,
-0.0378980599,
0.0225550607,
-0.0156975631,
0.0452015027,
0.0340648219,
-0.0663223863,
-0.0255547091,
0.0287847649,
-0.0208411682,
0.0107678482,
-0.0032678102,
-0.0187555347,
0.0249804594,
0.0114253545,
-0.0024598788,
0.0570035167,
0.0161822066,
0.0401659161,
0.0154117746,
0.0352661051,
-0.0697100461,
-0.0061660232,
0.0020975166,
-0.0332585573,
0.0027124162,
-0.0056329793,
-0.0222245846,
0.0483982675,
-0.0141178295,
0.0086339703,
-0.0589103848,
0.0129790017,
-0.0208146982,
-0.0073886346,
-0.0344886072,
0.0003914556,
-0.0269675404,
-0.0016672019,
-0.016906295,
-0.0408644266,
0.0309514776,
-0.0234725382,
0.0159352422,
-0.017422393,
-0.0459320322,
-0.0390923135,
0.0590926893,
-0.003429621,
0.0027575614,
0.0144001963,
0.0092204735,
-0.0087394975,
0.0161890071,
-0.0000613266,
-0.0399904512,
0.0021998258,
-0.0200730786,
0.0264747236,
-0.0248565655,
-0.0274941586,
-0.0427748077,
-0.086739108,
-0.076793626,
0.0256654471,
0.0236702953,
-0.0272836722,
-0.0229750685,
0.0316583067,
0.0414791629,
0.0415762998,
-0.0091476794,
-0.015739616,
-0.0112453969,
-0.0016354149,
0.029674435,
-0.0132257771,
-0.010288219,
-0.0029470336,
0.0121733341,
0.047970511,
-0.0104132406,
0.018621169,
-0.0366410725,
-0.0497370213,
0.0088274162,
-0.0357535556,
-0.0325322747,
-0.0414366871,
0.0656221583,
-0.0389803499,
0.0165944975,
0.1367126852,
0.0274732076,
-0.0542608686,
-0.0211441834,
-0.0104415668,
0.0199506152,
0.0057470314,
0.0026539916,
-0.1168534607,
-0.038835045,
0.0051675881,
0.0204179231,
-0.0249258932,
-0.0474847518,
-0.0113696707,
-0.101480484,
0.0308837146,
-0.0278168656,
-0.0591270067,
0.0004423674,
-0.0599074699,
0.0067201755,
-0.0658354461,
-0.020019399,
-0.0169189926,
0.0035130202,
0.0133715346,
0.0417648554,
-0.0638173074,
-0.0229193326,
0.0226709154,
-0.0443138368,
0.0830881819,
0.0471096449,
0.0310242996,
0.0205156654,
0.0272662155,
0.0697384626,
0.0436542258,
-0.0195296742,
-0.0066135526,
0.0741541088,
-0.0218253434,
-0.0005414627,
-0.0220923144,
0.030396672,
-0.0035888678,
-0.0191201977,
0.0019963901,
0.0602929853,
-0.0109672016,
0.0169777013,
-0.0137505643,
0.0116421944,
0.0087594762,
0.0791928321,
0.0172683429,
-0.0539745167,
-0.0539471693,
-0.042368196,
0.0033969416,
-0.0103458259,
-0.0519075654,
0.0113384575,
-0.02976452,
-0.0542785451,
-0.0283414498,
-0.0428276286,
0.0418316014,
-0.0156227592,
-0.0103064226,
0.0046583591,
0.0246370789,
0.0193388071,
0.0002679586,
0.0339860581,
-0.0775750205,
0.0014325778,
-0.0246083923,
-0.0376219489,
0.0462069884,
-0.0172499344,
-0.0136816679,
-0.005226993,
-0.0874842778,
-0.0467610918,
0.0104059195,
0.007740383,
0.022371551,
0.0090298718,
-0.0148566263,
-0.0633866191,
0.0321061797,
0.0761243626,
-0.0115168411,
-0.0142013039,
0.0112226494,
0.0625914335,
-0.0134227732,
0.0277868286,
-0.0412258804,
-0.0049571223,
-0.0049221474,
0.001631635,
-0.0474982001,
0.0134368436,
0.0018380728,
0.0153707154,
0.0850821882,
-0.0072141499,
-0.0348618478,
-0.0367871709,
-0.0274068993,
-0.0138407592,
-0.0194721986,
-0.0411885865,
0.0101761371,
0.0183360539,
-0.0239659753,
-0.034430258,
0.0297870021,
-0.0397108868,
0.0773149505,
-0.0654828548,
0.0100815585,
0.0292299371,
0.0106100058,
-0.0028675774,
-0.0185890608,
-0.0435464978,
0.0286371429,
-0.0001178863,
0.0006169319,
0.0041908445,
0.0409882739,
-0.0103035113,
-0.0058776042,
0.077590242,
0.0163040031,
-0.0649457276,
-0.0565170385,
-0.016701594,
0.0964931995,
0.0480654426,
0.0167855304,
0.0386613682,
-0.028459629,
-0.0381759889,
-0.0233500227,
0.036716491,
0.0045349519,
-0.0325014181,
0.0108905639,
-0.0190763194,
-0.0630302951,
0.0308990534,
0.0659220442,
0.008723978,
0.0503845327,
0.0269317757,
-0.0439435281,
-0.0331902616,
-0.0122480784,
0.0064990171,
0.0170757975,
0.0113599887,
0.0122741815,
-0.0492624156,
-0.0285143349,
-0.0041421228,
-0.0341564231,
-0.0131598553,
0.0094029177,
0.0079370178,
0.0424749814,
-0.0180815049,
0.0030074946,
-0.0745180845,
0.0033001581,
-0.015632242,
-0.0354411528,
0.0007528276,
-6.292112693e-33,
-0.0000537234,
-0.0307504386,
0.0064155227,
0.0357152559,
-0.0232961141,
0.0114306705,
-0.0087566366,
0.0244207475,
-0.0263833459,
-0.0029453097,
-0.009499643,
0.0148297008,
0.0097429696,
0.0198029261,
0.0312980674,
-0.0163455606,
0.0169534571,
-0.0198851377,
-0.0140418913,
0.0249237772,
0.0426551923,
-0.0012285673,
0.0349797159,
-0.0877293125,
0.0555764697,
-0.017354019,
0.0040162723,
-0.0024149409,
0.0266944077,
0.0419203006,
-0.0258166324,
0.0395184383,
0.0261164196,
-0.0162482746,
0.0154596148,
0.0628305674,
-0.044058986,
-0.0060788193,
-0.0082268352,
0.003098178,
-0.0097755073,
-0.0184980705,
0.0162293799,
-0.0272724945,
-0.0166451056,
0.0038051289,
0.0427227542,
-0.0132183619,
-0.0085704746,
-0.0084156347,
-0.0488571338,
0.066976279,
-0.0230203941,
-0.0414275676,
-0.0131056607,
0.0593590103,
0.0305089727,
0.0620110184,
-0.0364623293,
0.0236659367,
-0.0047972011,
-0.0245400481,
0.0404499099,
-0.0152220186,
0.0044225738,
0.0691009536,
0.008382814,
0.0194114391,
-0.0366626494,
-0.0199293531,
0.0084576411,
-0.0050214487,
0.0550462157,
0.0673356429,
-0.0015340823,
-0.0062974677,
-0.0807585493,
0.0057474421,
0.0696765259,
-0.015655363,
0.0333726257,
0.0121763721,
-0.013085179,
0.0010374987,
-0.0397396907,
-0.0235410687,
-0.0251511931,
-0.0302606598,
0.0011364548,
0.0087886658,
-0.0232274961,
0.0046209623,
0.0491899252,
-0.0448623188,
-0.0121229701,
0.0143826818,
-0.0191043317,
0.0471729115,
-0.0059254719,
0.0201212578,
-0.0959346741,
-0.0293170866,
0.0321213305,
0.0226540435,
0.0141385989,
0.0109168245,
0.0721504539,
0.0085607702,
-0.0555304438,
-0.0009319133,
-0.0132045364,
0.0266902354,
-0.0417996608,
-0.0167456809,
0.0261065103,
0.0026221548,
0.0119456584,
0.050057169,
0.0442429371,
0.0453119315,
-0.0069485381,
-0.0493189059,
-0.0368709825,
-0.0603849143,
-0.0082895737,
0.0139015066,
0.0131912436,
0.0219175722,
-0.0373307727,
-0.0552193969,
0.0115308119,
-0.0278355386,
2.552e-7,
0.0582890064,
0.0821055621,
-0.0165563058,
-0.003386966,
0.0129690086,
0.0352558233,
0.0256349295,
0.0424474925,
-0.0272698738,
-0.0151131731,
-0.0125887189,
0.0156991016,
0.0638056621,
0.0113271838,
-0.0867363289,
-0.0485753641,
-0.0968779251,
-0.0104906568,
-0.055797983,
0.0086777546,
0.0401398689,
0.0771953091,
0.0407782644,
0.0028209893,
-0.0234155338,
-0.0549072437,
0.0882789567,
-0.0255957525,
-0.0460883789,
0.0369555876,
0.0538537018,
0.0459015183,
0.0218431596,
0.0108216926,
0.0074012964,
-0.0085478593,
0.0332053676,
0.052131176,
0.0177738834,
-0.0207979251,
0.0199212562,
-0.011856745,
0.0125381043,
-0.0521224402,
0.094617635,
-0.074336946,
-0.0532255769,
-0.0570484512,
-0.0039312285,
-0.0232474692,
0.0740843415,
-0.0100165568,
-0.0073014884,
0.0104308017,
-0.017550908,
-0.0264098048,
-0.0181904119,
-0.0517929234,
-0.0195193645,
-0.0253438931,
-0.0421256647,
-0.0792644545,
-0.0158545412,
-0.0051463405,
0.0243964586,
-0.0353137627,
0.0442733876,
2.051717942e-34,
0.0428188518,
0.0019361929,
-0.0131792733,
0.0093449419,
0.0249289833,
0.0432075262,
0.0502748117,
-0.0018328279,
0.0126193361,
-0.053926155,
0.0330084898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07591v1 | Identification of Books That are Suitable for Middle School Students Using Artificial Neural Networks | 2023-11-09T22:10:52 | 2023-11-09T22:10:52 | Alp Niksarli, Sadik Ozan Gorgu, Ege Gencer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Reading right books contributes to children's imagination and brain
development, enhances their language and emotional comprehension abilities, and
strengthens their relationships with others. Building upon the critical role of
reading books in individual development, this paper aims to develop an
algorithm that determines the suitability of books for middle school students
by analyzing their structural and semantic features. Using methods described,
an algorithm will be created that can be utilized by institutions and
individuals responsible for children's education, such as the Ministry of
National Education officials and schools. This algorithm will facilitate the
selection of books to be taught at the middle school level. With the algorithm,
the book selection process for the middle school curriculum can be expedited,
and it will serve as a preliminary reference source for those who evaluate
books by reading them. In this paper, the Python programming language was
employed, utilizing natural language processing methods. Additionally, an
artificial neural network (ANN) was trained using the data which had been
preprocessed to construct an original dataset. To train this network, suitable
books for middle school students were provided by the MEB, Oxford and Cambridge
and with content assessed based on the "R" criterion, and inappropriate books
for middle school students in terms of content were included. This trained
neural network achieved a 90.06% consistency rate in determining the
appropriateness of the test-provided books. Considering the obtained findings,
it can be concluded that the developed software has achieved the desired
objective. | [
0.0266753063,
-0.0320651159,
-0.0352747254,
0.0237610675,
-0.0414713807,
0.0168713238,
0.0381311402,
-0.0492821485,
0.0340271592,
-0.0585213937,
0.0270525888,
0.025179619,
0.0341689251,
0.0054003452,
-0.0076304269,
-0.0234594382,
0.0152443592,
0.0285491049,
0.0425229855,
0.0299207531,
-0.0402902402,
0.032750193,
-0.0367154106,
0.0310688373,
0.0206863713,
-0.0350115038,
0.0273810551,
-0.0304147191,
0.0097565698,
-0.0402758755,
0.0298343822,
-0.0024299133,
-0.0140129607,
-0.0215699729,
0.0000024371,
-0.0500651076,
-0.0292735994,
-0.0401256084,
0.029357437,
0.0121714156,
0.0753102005,
0.0620521531,
-0.0271177404,
-0.037597023,
-0.0337424837,
0.0475594476,
0.0234797504,
0.0452205911,
0.0513459481,
0.0227768496,
0.0094271358,
-0.0768793896,
0.0136889471,
0.0745635703,
0.0349038914,
-0.0063165883,
0.0279260986,
0.025531346,
0.0503810607,
0.0166841652,
-0.0308957081,
0.0150761195,
-0.0123179648,
-0.0106588947,
0.0239461139,
0.0047479104,
-0.0191515125,
-0.0159591362,
-0.0042344406,
0.0363935344,
-0.0033294964,
-0.035284318,
-0.0007021938,
-0.0183902737,
-0.0150212543,
0.0324773118,
-0.0347154774,
-0.0008159485,
-0.023350589,
-0.008048825,
0.0287212003,
0.0221753493,
0.0087893596,
0.0308936555,
0.0346424691,
0.0273338277,
-0.0252388585,
-0.0293463953,
0.0104619004,
-0.0094264671,
0.0116253756,
-0.005949955,
0.017110616,
0.0213219449,
0.0330214538,
0.0067799231,
-0.0327655561,
-0.0527813546,
0.0022645141,
-0.0668545067,
-0.0091059599,
0.041179806,
0.0206018202,
0.0216301531,
0.0030317907,
0.0464345478,
0.0518485643,
0.0459393077,
-0.0416991934,
0.0593375452,
-0.0429298133,
-0.0031613538,
-0.0199633744,
0.0841975138,
0.007789996,
-0.0348846018,
-0.0926619619,
-0.0319535546,
-0.0012339781,
-0.0080569638,
0.0087439334,
0.0495892502,
0.020249987,
0.0288201086,
-0.0649820194,
-0.0159742292,
-0.0582726747,
0.0088157663,
-0.0703017712,
0.0473877303,
0.0777201578,
0.0140125435,
0.0117654521,
-0.0040311608,
0.0352921821,
0.0469942465,
0.0153826661,
-0.0250569321,
-0.1252675802,
-0.0224111993,
0.0384473428,
-0.0561080985,
-0.0057418477,
-0.03239448,
-0.0082612429,
-0.0086882431,
0.010682283,
-0.0186540447,
-0.0178515986,
0.0149272261,
0.0164269079,
0.0213863868,
-0.0012010472,
-0.0397433639,
0.0644448996,
0.0136054382,
0.0500645302,
-0.01934186,
0.041222468,
0.000079356,
0.0425946414,
-0.0491037145,
-0.0185868274,
-0.0390760861,
-0.0221893098,
-0.0560965575,
-0.0048679742,
-0.0193059128,
-0.037354257,
0.037683133,
-0.0916421339,
0.0198217053,
-0.0143609922,
-0.0130856577,
0.0256818105,
0.0758081228,
0.0222739223,
0.0950695872,
0.0011037448,
0.0347756334,
0.0813426524,
0.0480082519,
0.0257962979,
0.0398138054,
-0.0269578472,
-0.0223979428,
-0.0395402163,
0.017451508,
0.0136893261,
-0.0684545338,
0.0343086272,
0.0280554313,
0.0641052648,
-0.0438791551,
0.0644316897,
-0.0117148412,
-0.019590212,
-0.0332288221,
0.0367248617,
-0.0116692968,
-0.0027264799,
0.0018679899,
0.0540513471,
0.0531675257,
0.0527544953,
-0.0594194271,
-0.0162078142,
-0.0042498265,
-0.0324431397,
-0.002271211,
-0.0258864798,
-0.0071921549,
-0.025648525,
-0.0879021361,
0.0022988482,
-0.0034675114,
-0.001587258,
0.013489197,
-0.0428484306,
0.0629829764,
0.0113537069,
0.0361498706,
-0.0773290843,
0.0547046885,
-0.0565841347,
-0.0423001982,
0.0010477907,
0.0273645781,
0.0125060044,
0.0528549366,
0.0100749694,
-0.0110026253,
0.0178921241,
0.0066596456,
0.0228429567,
-0.0287303254,
-0.0379653499,
0.0379484706,
0.0450610854,
-0.0809696242,
0.0305358991,
0.0175538454,
0.0164542571,
-0.0185222644,
0.0752373263,
-0.0030671947,
0.0061669028,
-0.0011427872,
0.0464514084,
-0.0614322498,
-0.0275136493,
-0.0057595251,
0.0279623549,
0.0368397124,
0.0214430299,
-0.021138778,
-0.0210413039,
0.023719782,
0.0005022069,
-0.0440578572,
0.0191645958,
-0.0009246789,
0.0286153052,
0.0078534558,
0.0177331623,
-0.0248303898,
0.0019501746,
-0.0319224969,
-0.0341601446,
0.0372084938,
-0.0025077644,
-0.0211698767,
-0.0438125618,
0.0124867093,
0.0210290775,
0.0048135095,
0.0409215689,
-0.056606032,
-0.0743022859,
0.0104843974,
-0.0107513042,
-0.0095867617,
-0.022824958,
-0.038318228,
-0.0366714261,
0.0510830171,
0.1181055531,
-0.0273034945,
-0.0046690712,
-0.0040770187,
-0.0313729048,
0.014756104,
-0.006135447,
-0.0641899779,
0.0164219309,
0.0126920715,
-0.0528721176,
0.0563981161,
0.012552077,
-0.0195083842,
0.0589023232,
-0.0222417675,
-0.0409481302,
0.010034957,
0.0107375858,
0.0562287048,
-0.0066894665,
-0.0295874141,
0.0069036507,
0.0018521948,
0.0244903415,
-0.0478071086,
-0.0019188053,
0.0733514801,
-0.0392114222,
0.0345118642,
-0.0829516724,
-0.0569498613,
0.0122194299,
0.0592646971,
0.0397384129,
0.0160576832,
0.0618022829,
-0.0059961961,
0.0065578753,
-0.1455012262,
0.0035658469,
-0.0201997794,
-0.0108543867,
-0.0033121158,
0.0051958528,
0.00926245,
-0.0047793216,
-0.0437595323,
-0.005815912,
0.0818523541,
-0.0145636918,
0.0116270809,
-0.0132585885,
-0.0324893221,
0.01241305,
0.0178028382,
-0.04508356,
-0.0078708148,
0.010490397,
-0.0449623168,
0.0247295126,
0.0053459685,
-0.0477946103,
-0.0076269233,
0.0215091407,
0.0136042023,
-0.0168465339,
-0.002611913,
0.032275103,
-0.0122828865,
0.0075925668,
-0.0775799453,
0.0071386066,
0.0088738706,
0.0247226842,
0.0165344533,
-0.0672522858,
0.0079292348,
-0.0411209315,
0.0259755049,
-0.0202350784,
-0.0348000564,
-0.0095101185,
-0.000647355,
-0.0670170039,
-0.0983558893,
0.03967724,
0.0509185307,
0.0321919434,
-0.0482618622,
-0.0215696916,
-0.0049651614,
-0.1281521022,
-0.0156744663,
0.0500052162,
-0.0141343195,
0.0351088829,
-0.0189449266,
0.0374120511,
-0.0377432927,
-0.0233811699,
-0.0156909656,
-0.0267710295,
-0.019822577,
0.0281987637,
-0.0506018065,
-0.0236211345,
0.0116952043,
-0.0578798689,
0.0159858298,
-0.008225929,
0.0017151294,
-0.0368146189,
-0.0063686683,
-0.0135466149,
0.0054269247,
0.0009820043,
0.0075617465,
0.0243133288,
-0.0014297415,
0.0315343328,
0.0730280355,
-0.0790149197,
-0.016592389,
0.0287834927,
0.0146700153,
-0.0550031476,
-0.0081388745,
0.0306463353,
0.0164905973,
0.0113873556,
-0.039588917,
-0.0049934508,
0.0023372914,
0.0170212388,
0.0404741503,
0.0325673632,
0.0348150879,
-0.0312273186,
-0.0474438667,
0.0696726665,
-0.0064048627,
0.004529289,
-0.0121342149,
-0.0153498901,
0.0303895269,
-0.0431104116,
-0.0111869574,
-0.0053099957,
-0.0253919717,
0.0534010008,
-0.0343220495,
-0.0151856169,
-0.0460001044,
-0.0305792131,
0.000835706,
0.035057202,
0.0668661371,
0.0292000435,
0.081434086,
-0.008159468,
-0.0097171701,
-0.0194839183,
0.053542275,
-0.0158556849,
-0.0706924647,
0.0105020925,
0.0386563838,
-0.0510585718,
-0.0108647151,
-0.0321939327,
0.0340804271,
-0.0274060797,
-0.0000623015,
0.0105028059,
0.023493588,
-0.0323007964,
0.0148112951,
-0.0732119456,
0.0071891774,
-0.0040983837,
-0.0470196456,
-0.0166359264,
-0.0000198334,
0.0138091464,
-0.0075048544,
-0.0237281993,
0.015929658,
0.0273220204,
-0.0094494456,
-0.0386779048,
-0.000796192,
-0.0261111408,
-0.0083868019,
0.0326189101,
0.021733446,
0.0027860173,
-0.0540690422,
-0.0647073761,
-0.0097505618,
-0.0069108745,
-0.0293537918,
0.0147501267,
0.0134858331,
0.0314617939,
0.0231183395,
-0.0543168895,
-0.0396836065,
0.0157186259,
0.0177985299,
0.0230444223,
0.089779377,
0.0102412309,
0.0710025057,
-0.0003017029,
0.0188585147,
-0.0324173868,
-0.016802948,
-0.0009540032,
0.0744371563,
0.0057351985,
0.0381041951,
0.0433367677,
0.0049404399,
-0.0507031307,
0.0033309436,
0.0482374504,
0.0464169942,
-0.0459220596,
0.0350017548,
-0.012274405,
-0.0224160813,
-0.0403896831,
-0.0156702045,
0.0011200794,
-0.0435886979,
0.0224906914,
0.0237793867,
0.01350589,
-0.0100060906,
-0.0021663639,
0.0147519344,
0.0004652387,
0.0116928443,
-0.0046741348,
-0.0725942329,
0.0515013784,
-0.0506785847,
-0.0344962701,
0.0425136201,
0.0010140131,
0.0947666541,
-0.0045908648,
0.0230039526,
-0.0389888659,
-0.004133814,
0.0221955925,
0.0343659334,
0.0105931424,
0.0128228674,
0.0152751366,
0.0380659513,
0.0227342453,
0.0143021466,
-0.0210547056,
-0.0027125287,
-0.0761450306,
-0.0086828815,
-0.0235614274,
-5.816960611e-33,
-0.0158450343,
-0.0676563233,
0.0249241963,
0.0588948354,
0.0119600464,
-0.0432906263,
-0.0194461867,
0.0191629864,
-0.0093870386,
0.0084383152,
0.005024143,
-0.0041343169,
-0.0072808857,
-0.0076874951,
0.0177932996,
0.0134177329,
-0.031589698,
0.0118204234,
-0.0147982035,
-0.049792476,
0.0386898667,
0.0276811589,
0.0688841194,
-0.073217392,
-0.0025925725,
-0.0462756082,
0.0182711761,
-0.0629352182,
-0.0066041173,
0.0409394726,
-0.001494796,
0.0248680916,
0.0241718981,
-0.0161815062,
0.0578273498,
0.0275347531,
-0.0409485213,
-0.0866391286,
0.0028649899,
0.0263131354,
-0.0070254765,
-0.0416003466,
0.0419849418,
0.0106235892,
-0.0135931559,
0.0210521631,
0.1030143499,
-0.0284361169,
-0.0147518031,
-0.0169482287,
-0.0747996494,
-0.0002564634,
-0.0294952784,
0.0242862105,
0.0687560141,
0.0374425948,
-0.0048932116,
-0.0041166097,
-0.0480964445,
0.0320082605,
0.0346135609,
-0.0001492371,
-0.0325117037,
-0.0021005878,
0.0143032242,
0.0318654031,
0.0511638373,
-0.0249626562,
-0.0018862664,
0.0339408591,
0.0809819549,
-0.0579735525,
0.0520821586,
0.0268656313,
0.0309218261,
-0.0478294529,
-0.0648811236,
0.0244376678,
0.0689821541,
0.0239817016,
-0.0101443958,
-0.048701793,
-0.0843541399,
-0.030313611,
0.0319452174,
-0.0229669362,
-0.0300231408,
-0.0145342806,
0.0067783445,
-0.0738723949,
-0.0586203411,
-0.0040713926,
-0.057248313,
-0.0457938947,
0.002883221,
0.0260344278,
-0.0109346537,
-0.0062134154,
-0.0199208912,
0.020543972,
-0.0185818281,
-0.0249691084,
-0.0160585735,
-0.0234349538,
0.0458869189,
0.0164630953,
-0.0281571057,
0.0046174102,
-0.0015425824,
-0.0220816229,
0.0058951192,
-0.0258643143,
0.0528925247,
0.0310296882,
-0.0367057286,
0.0092673758,
-0.0198789109,
0.0154649001,
0.0138389459,
-0.0015743891,
-0.0224251803,
-0.0306245983,
0.0266748331,
-0.0412813835,
-0.0431453213,
-0.0303085037,
-0.023188388,
0.0377648324,
0.0070317858,
-0.0336199179,
0.0205839947,
0.0303036403,
3.127e-7,
-0.0051635592,
0.056830164,
-0.0028613212,
-0.0082115876,
-0.0093507105,
0.01620147,
-0.0037575543,
-0.0324042477,
0.0305217244,
0.0293681733,
0.0340505056,
-0.0483228117,
0.035712339,
0.0589708537,
-0.0925001651,
-0.0148265539,
0.0041560209,
-0.0212835763,
-0.0257321019,
0.0159172453,
0.041863583,
0.009599993,
0.0823016167,
-0.0215752311,
-0.0444210097,
-0.0182230305,
-0.0253935177,
-0.0089152092,
0.0255172066,
0.0197692886,
0.0537422076,
0.0630899817,
-0.0310432278,
0.018833613,
-0.023375636,
0.0382934883,
0.0043287622,
-0.001462994,
0.0082024848,
0.0211299937,
0.0376205258,
-0.0007833911,
-0.0208222363,
-0.0262620877,
0.0506064259,
-0.0111765666,
0.0005190579,
0.0592249669,
-0.0113528287,
0.0043535191,
0.0055430247,
0.0010178832,
-0.0162724331,
0.0052934494,
-0.0028129125,
-0.0487832427,
0.0474117883,
-0.046798449,
0.0434539281,
0.0010126909,
-0.0269909222,
-0.0058540269,
-0.0105436463,
0.020015642,
0.0537407249,
-0.0148135172,
0.049169194,
2.20584293e-34,
0.0061578769,
-0.0648497418,
-0.0098397657,
-0.0658197403,
0.0092817936,
0.014998246,
0.0152557613,
-0.0018993367,
0.012418787,
-0.0245214924,
-0.0074108816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05754v1 | Deep Natural Language Feature Learning for Interpretable Prediction | 2023-11-09T21:43:27 | 2023-11-09T21:43:27 | Felipe Urrutia, Cristian Buc, Valentin Barriere | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a general method to break down a main complex task into a set of
intermediary easier sub-tasks, which are formulated in natural language as
binary questions related to the final target task. Our method allows for
representing each example by a vector consisting of the answers to these
questions. We call this representation Natural Language Learned Features
(NLLF). NLLF is generated by a small transformer language model (e.g., BERT)
that has been trained in a Natural Language Inference (NLI) fashion, using weak
labels automatically obtained from a Large Language Model (LLM). We show that
the LLM normally struggles for the main task using in-context learning, but can
handle these easiest subtasks and produce useful weak labels to train a BERT.
The NLI-like training of the BERT allows for tackling zero-shot inference with
any binary question, and not necessarily the ones seen during the training. We
show that this NLLF vector not only helps to reach better performances by
enhancing any classifier, but that it can be used as input of an
easy-to-interpret machine learning model like a decision tree. This decision
tree is interpretable but also reaches high performances, surpassing those of a
pre-trained transformer in some cases.We have successfully applied this method
to two completely different tasks: detecting incoherence in students' answers
to open-ended mathematics exam questions, and screening abstracts for a
systematic literature review of scientific papers on climate change and
agroecology. | [
0.0311728064,
0.0488763377,
0.0094083669,
0.0374080651,
-0.0054552006,
0.0247928817,
0.006455827,
-0.000637735,
-0.0052936152,
-0.0648339763,
0.0151408445,
0.0103026042,
-0.0191778224,
0.0554901138,
-0.000815855,
-0.0639963374,
0.0061833537,
-0.0178758781,
0.039292831,
0.0097152283,
-0.0171341281,
-0.0033833322,
0.0089759361,
0.0430068076,
0.0072832974,
-0.0313549899,
-0.0420108624,
-0.0090283137,
0.0170014277,
0.0036192008,
0.0212994907,
0.0423753932,
0.0461072251,
0.013268278,
0.00000226,
-0.052233953,
-0.0444207527,
-0.0047740047,
-0.0515477844,
-0.0141231772,
-0.0072943699,
-0.0101118796,
0.0209507588,
0.0067365463,
-0.0367656462,
-0.038322337,
0.0659669116,
0.0837126523,
0.0347284935,
0.0521992408,
-0.0037543802,
-0.0356241502,
0.0220344309,
0.0136180688,
0.0249282978,
-0.0078016398,
0.0261286125,
-0.0269370768,
-0.0326922983,
0.0382750742,
-0.025452137,
0.0046998207,
0.0429388359,
-0.028410852,
0.0103120897,
0.0400491767,
-0.055745054,
-0.0281703714,
0.0273710731,
0.0949772,
-0.0381364599,
-0.0234827343,
-0.0155560607,
-0.027387606,
0.0074690375,
0.0316934548,
-0.0230073556,
0.0083958032,
0.0011574422,
0.0044317949,
0.0432841107,
0.0106087374,
0.028674623,
0.0305246152,
-0.0499609262,
0.0447492413,
-0.0068186782,
-0.0317713283,
-0.0008165592,
0.0048250067,
-0.041571185,
-0.0394743979,
0.0051964624,
0.0318717323,
-0.0176142659,
0.0340164453,
-0.0129286647,
-0.0197315402,
-0.0029525082,
-0.0405597426,
-0.0048217271,
0.0089312783,
-0.0626398623,
0.0516078137,
-0.0032767653,
0.045544751,
-0.0014787633,
0.0356920063,
-0.0259555783,
-0.0574699789,
-0.0515226088,
-0.0428727977,
-0.0115844524,
0.0573970191,
0.000614915,
0.0082219513,
-0.0205647275,
-0.014296514,
-0.027413547,
0.0073154587,
0.007102116,
0.0387382135,
-0.0501061678,
-0.0057337843,
-0.0275138654,
0.071415022,
-0.0288586821,
0.0265720692,
-0.0246865526,
-0.0333948545,
-0.0038745373,
0.0291425977,
0.0324499607,
0.004551392,
0.0246306155,
0.0752261952,
0.0183339249,
-0.0375586115,
-0.0180485062,
-0.0364918523,
-0.0089790598,
-0.0277014468,
0.0282055587,
-0.0531749502,
-0.006869039,
0.0105962977,
-0.0053896657,
-0.0221675355,
0.0014414719,
-0.0005158742,
0.0004325386,
0.0690034106,
-0.0209882967,
-0.0355789512,
0.0145902922,
-0.0015794358,
-0.0109556196,
0.0515082255,
0.0319554806,
0.0416818485,
0.0194992367,
-0.0295303799,
0.0380090475,
0.0084981089,
0.0119028846,
-0.0095983185,
0.0454066694,
0.0083529018,
-0.0651466995,
0.0204776023,
-0.0050248178,
0.0002617056,
0.0167134125,
-0.0246148109,
0.0179900303,
0.0392889157,
0.0273706205,
0.0367596634,
0.0146201057,
0.0494298562,
-0.0164854415,
0.0145283435,
-0.041793339,
0.0286103263,
-0.0323879272,
-0.019256128,
-0.0284591615,
-0.0161436014,
-0.0254448485,
-0.0653823465,
-0.006433344,
-0.0093357507,
-0.0326598994,
0.0136034423,
0.1005705073,
0.0182846468,
-0.0235763937,
0.0551035255,
0.01508616,
-0.010963344,
0.0050234473,
-0.0468415804,
0.0286887903,
0.0211935565,
0.0103702657,
-0.0573439784,
-0.0168955624,
-0.0269519929,
0.0206289776,
0.0002248853,
0.0286616907,
-0.0110073444,
0.0313334875,
-0.0311044529,
-0.0307125933,
-0.0082257986,
0.0083981175,
0.019026164,
-0.0407536626,
-0.0091820005,
0.0177706834,
-0.0402752198,
-0.0125016784,
0.0314013883,
-0.0148183974,
-0.0481343158,
0.0425426848,
0.0158355366,
0.034928944,
0.0065485653,
0.001966717,
0.0098774582,
0.0368028618,
-0.0402110405,
-0.0611706674,
0.0117032109,
-0.0315729417,
-0.0373253152,
0.0061990921,
-0.0686672702,
-0.0284955222,
0.0465901084,
-0.0772504658,
-0.0414213687,
0.0040546735,
-0.0584451668,
0.0152864214,
-0.0002446439,
-0.0233146306,
-0.0115417968,
-0.0231055859,
-0.0265788212,
0.0634594187,
0.0031522606,
0.0341886841,
-0.0048515839,
-0.0400094464,
0.023418583,
-0.0056272517,
0.0185137913,
-0.0098370528,
-0.0321424417,
-0.0379717126,
0.0478096157,
0.0100838672,
-0.0389463231,
0.0063469964,
-0.0669745803,
0.009642153,
-0.0186102018,
0.0011606744,
0.0183198191,
-0.0116443913,
0.022541184,
-0.0156608336,
-0.0473368689,
-0.016303299,
-0.0115005681,
-0.005951609,
0.0516042374,
-0.0048003141,
0.0236779582,
-0.0307153016,
-0.0144447042,
-0.0698978528,
0.0935741812,
0.0312667675,
-0.0233568735,
-0.0428381637,
-0.0013617105,
0.0121239265,
0.0220250245,
-0.0210203957,
-0.0150324889,
0.0023305172,
-0.0357113816,
-0.0038503713,
0.0617393516,
-0.0024249274,
0.0555606298,
0.0177530795,
0.0189341307,
-0.0721653327,
0.0164133999,
-0.0256623402,
0.0273911245,
-0.0131480452,
-0.0480249077,
0.0114259887,
0.0452970564,
-0.0020683738,
-0.0266641583,
-0.0414360426,
0.0308969449,
0.0026301444,
-0.0142828831,
-0.0516616963,
-0.001806006,
0.0271253791,
0.0229583569,
0.0010802349,
-0.0531128906,
0.1102134734,
0.0010956201,
-0.0046416721,
-0.0783835128,
-0.0279134251,
-0.0560066178,
0.0675649345,
0.0172761064,
-0.0202646945,
0.0257870834,
-0.0203425772,
-0.0547402352,
-0.0078364564,
-0.0209379513,
-0.0091043711,
0.0527898669,
-0.0575384982,
-0.0052212714,
-0.0066156499,
-0.0394952372,
-0.0397852957,
-0.0441779681,
-0.0230086856,
0.0389688574,
0.0218263548,
-0.0352806859,
-0.0590524115,
-0.0406484194,
0.0196316168,
0.0116693014,
-0.0230284575,
-0.0236021075,
-0.0120206727,
0.0705090538,
0.0621994399,
0.0242432002,
0.0279092453,
-0.0226351991,
0.0167548321,
0.0369241983,
0.0017293295,
0.0288460553,
-0.0593110994,
0.0153336562,
0.0052611926,
-0.0268496145,
-0.0004641577,
0.0035598285,
0.0354509689,
-0.0877068639,
-0.0013594307,
0.1083815396,
0.010382425,
-0.0104429657,
-0.0016381416,
-0.0590680577,
0.0040773684,
0.0128546208,
0.0187717732,
-0.0692056194,
-0.0649182424,
-0.0057508601,
0.0149247069,
-0.004331334,
-0.0296254959,
0.0040350766,
-0.0808357224,
0.0147212995,
-0.0334603637,
-0.0120153343,
-0.0505009368,
-0.0894807801,
-0.0200887918,
-0.0268770959,
-0.0477976911,
-0.0268291142,
0.0174752921,
0.0154159209,
0.0261297897,
-0.0698135793,
-0.0313651785,
0.0502328873,
-0.0248975847,
0.0038326886,
0.058033891,
0.0341755077,
-0.0504722521,
-0.0012983135,
0.0001683719,
-0.0381117761,
-0.0143205067,
-0.0069517721,
0.0599302575,
-0.0020283379,
-0.0221328586,
-0.0268704128,
0.049782142,
-0.055400461,
0.0013264135,
0.0171225369,
0.107056573,
-0.0306528285,
-0.0580890626,
-0.0331177115,
-0.0218618885,
0.0136997113,
0.1009734273,
0.009840278,
-0.0395452492,
-0.0586344451,
-0.044090692,
0.0063263169,
-0.0238731802,
-0.0154373813,
0.0126329307,
0.0189978182,
-0.0252393708,
-0.0198588874,
-0.0541981719,
0.0552367717,
-0.0127473492,
-0.0056213769,
-0.0168682616,
0.0420234799,
-0.0008141075,
-0.0686118677,
0.0467428677,
0.0095666433,
0.0085067758,
0.0071010753,
-0.0182439964,
0.0741528273,
0.0199899971,
-0.0329117849,
0.02668426,
-0.0320661776,
-0.0187135208,
-0.0162192769,
0.0525110811,
0.0175021254,
0.0409979969,
0.0093931071,
-0.0334241875,
0.0360998698,
0.0373712033,
0.0003552441,
-0.0308153965,
0.0475994386,
-0.0018900533,
0.0193942096,
0.024799522,
-0.0571334735,
0.0219096076,
-0.0044796052,
0.0038868298,
-0.060073927,
-0.0160562638,
0.0287574716,
-0.0006431416,
0.0538089871,
0.0317748711,
-0.0217248183,
-0.0187199581,
0.0242876951,
0.0106665567,
-0.0013860109,
-0.0466966815,
0.0350465626,
0.0213762857,
0.0034586377,
-0.0080674496,
0.0311170146,
-0.0332597606,
0.0149057442,
-0.0219418425,
0.0515863486,
0.0400424749,
0.0342383906,
-0.0043926574,
-0.0158817843,
-0.0280375164,
-0.025617782,
0.0003499362,
0.0343507901,
0.0170264561,
0.0222718399,
0.0312249567,
0.0027382134,
-0.0128745157,
-0.0248067286,
-0.0677189603,
-0.0474128425,
-0.0229107849,
0.0223421343,
-0.0014965354,
-0.0074881944,
-0.0220119022,
-0.0484024175,
0.0115969917,
-0.020144986,
0.0423012674,
0.0208255872,
-0.0286582913,
0.0558423586,
0.0310092662,
-0.0200672969,
-0.00905002,
0.0639736876,
0.0469211154,
0.035804525,
0.0089890258,
-0.0063330266,
-0.0479160063,
0.0001527676,
0.0132675786,
0.025988834,
0.0004167961,
0.039806284,
-0.0230601355,
-0.0266750064,
0.03996896,
-0.018006308,
0.0354056843,
-0.0029023914,
0.0194816031,
0.0579450801,
-0.0006051399,
-0.0327203311,
-0.0224631764,
0.0390204936,
-0.0291353408,
-0.0232897606,
-0.0539766923,
-6.632034068e-33,
-0.0116787152,
-0.0633776933,
-0.007313774,
-0.0029111749,
0.0336490385,
0.0225470681,
-0.0564760678,
-0.0035092207,
-0.0385614559,
0.0629111156,
0.0268845353,
0.0404808521,
0.0036515819,
0.054437872,
0.0071230941,
-0.0381701216,
0.0363685675,
0.0232780483,
0.0225939099,
0.0260406267,
0.0694304556,
0.0455380455,
0.0877486095,
-0.0973030329,
0.0102231419,
-0.0047741299,
0.0222880114,
0.0350373276,
-0.0227173008,
0.0279345438,
-0.011588729,
0.0699407682,
0.0361694992,
-0.07122612,
-0.008780621,
0.0565683618,
-0.0937525257,
-0.0662835166,
-0.0096815322,
0.0150601491,
-0.0627901256,
-0.0094522526,
0.0595130548,
0.0122420285,
0.0337675177,
-0.0619920306,
0.0753701255,
-0.0405148603,
-0.0080533847,
-0.0695649013,
-0.0399529748,
0.0268036146,
-0.0425029844,
-0.0228478853,
-0.0254245363,
0.1089350358,
0.0092409104,
0.0334120169,
-0.053488005,
-0.0176712088,
0.0581136495,
0.0296995938,
0.0326947272,
0.0008720479,
-0.0140049625,
0.0736967251,
0.0126070566,
-0.0163027868,
-0.0466581993,
-0.0463660769,
0.0269762799,
0.0444971137,
0.0825752839,
0.0212212224,
0.0733319372,
0.040450979,
-0.0980607197,
0.0324249119,
-0.0005026319,
0.0560239851,
0.0103102699,
-0.0208701398,
-0.0387984365,
-0.0145263625,
-0.0291568916,
-0.0003575774,
-0.0332836621,
0.0109155271,
0.0210863538,
-0.0429183878,
-0.0399177484,
0.0275906697,
0.0277487393,
-0.0599161275,
-0.0103868097,
0.0630298257,
-0.005765121,
0.010948902,
0.0096245781,
0.0257342588,
-0.0274938345,
-0.0297702942,
0.0179852042,
0.0045755678,
0.0321951285,
0.0267598014,
0.0516957566,
0.007679427,
-0.0279090218,
-0.0359581225,
-0.0170277283,
-0.0370847993,
-0.0110448943,
0.07390894,
0.0128143849,
0.0363163613,
-0.0166126695,
0.029093165,
0.0010787048,
0.0279597379,
0.0011705026,
0.028118778,
-0.0189215001,
0.0040494078,
-0.0208074786,
-0.0595980398,
-0.0261715539,
-0.0077033746,
0.0046297652,
-0.0837270543,
0.0066398387,
0.0062566712,
2.929e-7,
0.0623157434,
0.0469671935,
0.0194949396,
-0.0106841149,
0.0093293218,
0.0556715131,
0.0263478663,
0.0344368443,
0.0143180778,
-0.04230389,
0.0119561199,
-0.0137874931,
0.0227815025,
0.0215139259,
-0.1017646864,
-0.0000271298,
-0.0420062952,
-0.0150528206,
-0.0396461971,
0.0193308946,
0.1015514061,
0.1411404014,
0.0195634626,
-0.0094812661,
0.0228791852,
-0.0024419995,
0.0482175611,
-0.0319696665,
0.0229145233,
0.0011661976,
0.0366124548,
-0.010823356,
0.0191968512,
0.0435221456,
-0.0226659086,
-0.0036884823,
-0.0232142247,
0.0418284945,
-0.0132383984,
-0.0170155913,
0.0086996164,
-0.0069807312,
0.0192379728,
-0.0103591932,
0.0662792623,
-0.1065939814,
-0.0477522425,
-0.0188679006,
-0.0207568165,
-0.0130176349,
0.0073396713,
-0.010962775,
0.0105776535,
0.0167121701,
-0.0047601736,
-0.0543104298,
0.0046044458,
-0.0477247834,
-0.012700527,
0.0234274492,
-0.0395951867,
0.0008661182,
-0.0482596606,
-0.0286507867,
0.0570831895,
-0.0603698492,
0.0129724005,
2.849092953e-34,
0.0436562337,
0.0168499034,
-0.0107898256,
0.0404438563,
0.0201966707,
-0.0093293414,
0.0111520151,
0.0021529153,
0.057145793,
-0.0638330057,
-0.0091699995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05746v1 | Bridging the Digital Divide: Performance Variation across Socio-Economic Factors in Vision-Language Models | 2023-11-09T21:10:52 | 2023-11-09T21:10:52 | Joan Nwatu, Oana Ignat, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Despite the impressive performance of current AI models reported across
various tasks, performance reports often do not include evaluations of how
these models perform on the specific groups that will be impacted by these
technologies. Among the minority groups under-represented in AI, data from
low-income households are often overlooked in data collection and model
evaluation. We evaluate the performance of a state-of-the-art vision-language
model (CLIP) on a geo-diverse dataset containing household images associated
with different income values (Dollar Street) and show that performance
inequality exists among households of different income levels. Our results
indicate that performance for the poorer groups is consistently lower than the
wealthier groups across various topics and countries. We highlight insights
that can help mitigate these issues and propose actionable steps for
economic-level inclusive AI development. Code is available at
https://github.com/MichiganNLP/Bridging_the_Digital_Divide. | [
-0.0189829022,
0.1425089091,
-0.0349630676,
0.0238803439,
-0.0063200067,
0.0373395346,
0.0686267093,
-0.0131395813,
0.0205292385,
-0.0474035367,
-0.0042209378,
0.0067075356,
0.0597011372,
0.0480388887,
0.0041894312,
-0.0896145105,
0.0043655555,
0.0101464102,
0.0061620129,
-0.0422291718,
-0.0021782848,
0.016165603,
0.005344999,
0.0567179061,
-0.0334681123,
0.0131876497,
0.0403831191,
0.0056541632,
-0.001980793,
0.0040663863,
-0.0013571644,
0.055733256,
0.0051045124,
0.0133405039,
0.0000021108,
-0.0339350812,
0.0122728702,
0.0088917511,
0.0076312083,
-0.0222113486,
0.0549131222,
-0.0616090707,
0.0015270965,
0.0023518815,
-0.0281017162,
0.0381415375,
0.0537994169,
0.0138587067,
0.0157729778,
-0.017907612,
-0.016652327,
-0.0273708645,
0.0154885128,
0.0033725847,
-0.0120557118,
-0.0023688714,
0.024546802,
0.0057125692,
-0.0329075828,
-0.0424400046,
-0.0312238578,
0.0583495013,
0.0473837554,
0.0253652595,
0.0172223616,
0.054441873,
-0.0550369248,
-0.0722712278,
-0.0028675571,
0.055939313,
0.006084776,
0.010774496,
-0.0017009932,
0.0077753658,
-0.0189559907,
-0.0332551971,
-0.0552812368,
0.0629460588,
0.0162960999,
0.0309352726,
-0.0514297448,
0.0213193782,
0.0252262987,
0.046010796,
-0.0053683533,
0.0572048724,
-0.0126547469,
0.0015889722,
-0.0439391211,
0.0284312796,
-0.0080898143,
-0.0082421452,
0.0201013181,
-0.0354420319,
0.0323860534,
-0.0109469099,
-0.0400647186,
-0.0440567508,
-0.0237144455,
0.0031978341,
0.0526354052,
0.0474911667,
-0.0299875792,
0.028648641,
0.0146868359,
0.0585774146,
0.0157533269,
0.0316413194,
0.0345780142,
-0.0223434977,
-0.0099662114,
-0.0035124344,
0.0030765263,
-0.0093887998,
-0.0829629824,
-0.0128679322,
-0.0314025842,
0.0046838131,
-0.0487639643,
-0.015240049,
-0.0127281779,
0.0221195798,
-0.0235954951,
0.0016739564,
-0.0146482987,
-0.0294289123,
-0.0037668708,
0.0162655655,
-0.000634653,
-0.0761699528,
0.0503980778,
0.0172581952,
-0.0026482074,
-0.0103440918,
-0.0013512354,
0.0095894737,
0.0090298243,
-0.02908732,
-0.0317303613,
-0.0105863456,
0.0169587117,
-0.0349651426,
0.0115180463,
-0.0599455722,
0.0235933959,
0.0113374917,
0.0441742726,
-0.0618746988,
-0.008483028,
0.0021296646,
-0.043799106,
0.0779726058,
0.0086891185,
0.0093768667,
0.0583858527,
0.0162842833,
0.0100021716,
0.073265031,
0.045876909,
-0.0084444406,
0.0525932312,
0.0090978881,
-0.0068512443,
0.0350551419,
-0.0023630469,
0.0084070433,
-0.0576290861,
0.0018083922,
-0.0478010625,
-0.0065194643,
0.0432364084,
0.0330528468,
0.0101900753,
-0.0021322495,
0.0848622471,
0.0913476273,
0.01722968,
0.0318899937,
-0.0495609082,
0.0256168284,
-0.0259995572,
-0.0524784327,
-0.0453314669,
0.0044075432,
0.0122983856,
-0.0351046771,
-0.012020763,
0.0454832576,
-0.0317546204,
-0.0219676457,
0.0083956784,
-0.0096788881,
0.0705163032,
0.0395883806,
0.0467886068,
-0.0320649482,
0.0209764894,
-0.0396477655,
0.008984047,
-0.0445373803,
-0.0204050913,
-0.0860318914,
0.0457188599,
0.0435285792,
0.0190703645,
0.0258200541,
0.0668621585,
0.0297975428,
0.0159047004,
0.0398207903,
-0.0281089209,
0.0189730916,
0.0211486798,
-0.0383901261,
-0.0504309498,
0.0452911966,
0.0315892473,
0.0077493675,
0.0584256053,
0.0074837925,
0.0292645879,
-0.0439557247,
0.0021369902,
0.0122653861,
0.0071605858,
0.0672839135,
-0.0370450541,
0.0357362665,
-0.0373311974,
0.0083952956,
-0.0176032558,
0.0038780151,
-0.0262742881,
-0.0317786448,
0.0046477602,
0.0077592642,
-0.0269377008,
0.0205235407,
-0.007200602,
-0.0897849798,
0.0269759148,
0.1002697572,
0.0187179614,
0.0136595983,
0.0479253121,
0.0157243777,
0.0134361768,
-0.026544217,
-0.0053508566,
-0.0159292128,
0.0230868924,
-0.0017737766,
0.0336248465,
-0.0613100715,
-0.0359640531,
-0.0044823312,
-0.0013340083,
0.0022686806,
-0.0479499772,
0.0278819967,
-0.0018722727,
-0.0102497842,
0.0481291525,
0.017644139,
0.023556808,
-0.0162292086,
0.0292018466,
-0.063902013,
-0.0383570381,
-0.034363281,
-0.0379823111,
-0.0302026253,
-0.0091450168,
-0.0263734832,
-0.029336594,
-0.0023238552,
0.060436856,
0.0120638749,
0.0316907391,
-0.0130641051,
-0.0363801196,
0.0373993553,
-0.0139551433,
-0.0537894815,
0.0193264466,
0.0575680397,
0.0422648005,
-0.0599624664,
0.0259585492,
-0.041656293,
-0.01931745,
0.0368316844,
-0.0229758751,
0.0060300906,
0.0178670902,
0.0205558445,
-0.004433698,
0.0240234192,
-0.0251156799,
0.0377654843,
0.013215743,
-0.0086699808,
-0.0531308614,
-0.0241089892,
0.045074895,
0.0529412441,
-0.0011977138,
-0.0374999233,
-0.0505546033,
0.0589509271,
0.003669702,
0.0059860335,
-0.0520369336,
0.0440295078,
-0.0715226382,
-0.0858236849,
-0.0694548264,
0.0208078306,
-0.0022889264,
0.0703074783,
-0.0654061511,
-0.0942627788,
-0.0144358082,
0.0138714788,
0.0127231674,
0.0572575107,
-0.0068524559,
-0.0289691798,
0.0549578853,
0.0180465169,
0.0327304378,
-0.0420298688,
-0.0131135546,
-0.0635076389,
-0.0130954906,
0.0317242369,
-0.0290827323,
0.056757167,
-0.0497339517,
0.0062333327,
-0.0282972921,
-0.055814717,
-0.033374168,
-0.0411331728,
-0.0292325933,
0.0379759297,
0.0284788311,
-0.0518488437,
-0.0173876733,
0.0538816042,
0.0276906304,
0.0455918089,
0.0235649049,
-0.015585334,
-0.0088243894,
-0.0204823539,
0.0374455675,
-0.0040976279,
-0.0118926587,
-0.0338854417,
0.02776118,
0.0073304167,
0.0526145212,
0.0301906224,
-0.0143987639,
0.0204877462,
0.0211409405,
0.0383153148,
-0.0288367718,
-0.0042042471,
0.0308300387,
-0.0270589776,
0.0254973993,
0.0611921735,
-0.0034641186,
-0.0395806283,
-0.0018718366,
-0.0145858023,
0.0273031611,
0.0200524721,
-0.0100381067,
-0.1164788008,
-0.01106642,
0.0317517705,
0.0480601899,
-0.0397111326,
-0.0314284079,
0.0036678039,
-0.0898063555,
0.0577599145,
-0.0129401488,
0.0034509283,
-0.067711629,
0.0091359047,
0.0066132289,
-0.0138506498,
0.0109511241,
-0.0339040756,
-0.0100042801,
0.010324236,
-0.0051864968,
-0.0640812814,
-0.0258512571,
0.0267776437,
-0.0414874665,
-0.0123720802,
0.071778506,
0.0258435309,
0.0130862799,
-0.017155407,
0.0163996145,
-0.0335506313,
-0.007070458,
-0.0218506902,
0.0450187363,
-0.020529937,
-0.0238442943,
-0.0015878399,
0.0252492893,
-0.0126000214,
-0.0070365826,
-0.0243077446,
-0.0214610863,
-0.0340203941,
-0.0243933275,
-0.0428976975,
-0.0322315432,
-0.0199555177,
0.0344353467,
0.0145886419,
-0.0243576542,
-0.0259335972,
-0.0366300195,
-0.0396364294,
-0.0027597884,
-0.0517138839,
0.0577591285,
0.0010399316,
-0.0591037199,
-0.0218829811,
-0.0600436553,
0.0104336329,
0.0211220216,
-0.0256587286,
-0.0861064866,
0.0525183268,
0.0040970142,
-0.0520794168,
0.0280841682,
-0.0632688701,
0.0267311949,
-0.0112283267,
-0.0175157767,
-0.0309630949,
-0.0360966325,
-0.0205729343,
0.0053035505,
-0.0730469376,
-0.0100961067,
0.0246026367,
0.0283226389,
0.0228805561,
0.0082434965,
-0.0078151692,
-0.0484130941,
0.0418901779,
0.0412103459,
0.0359713547,
0.0337024815,
0.0263622105,
-0.0319934376,
-0.009250951,
0.0293883681,
-0.0142242247,
0.0293546505,
-0.0079558864,
0.0138649428,
-0.0746151879,
0.0021892372,
-0.0326210149,
-0.0208190922,
0.0809309557,
-0.0131815989,
-0.024625279,
-0.0528565198,
-0.0242849085,
0.0214108042,
0.001144903,
-0.0563394241,
-0.0274899788,
0.0325204395,
0.0367591903,
-0.0020789432,
0.0306647345,
0.008627749,
-0.0358167589,
-0.0792108774,
0.0584603585,
-0.0302521922,
0.0210802685,
-0.0254860781,
0.0034495776,
0.0194789413,
0.0639332607,
-0.0490022078,
0.0466814265,
0.0218241401,
0.034845043,
0.0000486939,
0.0078748474,
0.0067216093,
0.0379386991,
0.0293028895,
-0.0553133376,
0.0109369662,
0.0568388253,
0.0527748019,
-0.0072024073,
0.0190746449,
0.0019832414,
-0.0198318847,
-0.028218573,
-0.0085788034,
0.025126176,
-0.057064537,
0.0416659117,
-0.0213895272,
-0.0119021162,
0.0224573575,
0.0727838054,
0.0101493597,
0.008407956,
-0.0091002034,
-0.0260248706,
0.0020525737,
-0.0429967791,
0.03743314,
-0.0382210873,
-0.0298768841,
0.0451601483,
-0.0402322598,
-0.059271317,
-0.0410925075,
-0.0083166109,
0.0117516685,
0.0132439779,
0.027343072,
0.033642076,
-0.0260035843,
-0.02326997,
-0.0398962982,
-0.033300478,
-0.1074413881,
-0.0262303278,
0.0160400905,
-6.395528278e-33,
-0.0123667885,
-0.0624981299,
0.0042940029,
-0.0519196466,
0.0064561311,
0.0483621247,
-0.003051277,
0.0297172125,
-0.0375332274,
-0.0032784897,
0.001335183,
0.0222155508,
0.0199691281,
0.059002731,
-0.010994656,
-0.0051395106,
0.0165417325,
0.0064109457,
-0.0294547565,
-0.0197234508,
-0.0302149616,
0.0188154802,
0.0405234993,
-0.0570040829,
0.0158657562,
-0.0155080408,
-0.0190235302,
-0.0179857239,
0.0635318235,
0.0432571992,
-0.0380015858,
0.0398142114,
0.043602217,
-0.0009769781,
-0.0294097848,
0.0549779497,
-0.0902663022,
0.012080689,
-0.0291589871,
0.0436999723,
-0.0828570724,
-0.0045370851,
0.0098970169,
0.0227226131,
-0.0327917859,
-0.0174743906,
0.0471742675,
-0.0411613546,
-0.0023801061,
-0.0046545314,
-0.0311808754,
0.0581375323,
-0.0193809047,
-0.0011272179,
0.0405670032,
0.0579947904,
0.0183961075,
0.0451090969,
-0.0466208309,
0.0382042378,
0.0196723007,
-0.016022956,
0.1107209623,
0.0064865765,
0.0326051526,
0.0286506414,
0.0343568027,
-0.0397390127,
-0.0114399334,
-0.1053851098,
0.0555101559,
-0.0066374047,
0.0226418935,
0.0524962135,
0.0043464345,
0.0035095557,
0.0011460651,
-0.0073596998,
-0.0029080599,
0.0393231884,
0.0353142284,
0.0218543839,
-0.0645284802,
0.0013285384,
-0.0449022986,
-0.0749475285,
-0.0366099961,
0.0061641503,
0.0686241761,
0.0155697986,
0.0061386046,
0.0635381341,
0.0372931026,
-0.0532173775,
-0.027898768,
-0.0191634763,
0.0079781925,
0.0069834087,
0.0116664898,
0.0417192765,
-0.0755208284,
-0.0117667885,
0.0119093182,
0.0602666698,
-0.0014826416,
0.012643327,
0.0062704808,
-0.0015105384,
-0.0373886116,
-0.0280414429,
-0.0138973361,
0.0144245019,
-0.0074217478,
0.0458232723,
0.0455906428,
-0.0233868752,
-0.0095588518,
0.0064330823,
-0.0346825495,
0.0107439263,
-0.0196697824,
0.0080397353,
-0.0320397913,
0.0296513774,
-0.0337071754,
-0.0189950559,
-0.0634659752,
0.0070013646,
0.0496930666,
-0.0080815926,
-0.0253232382,
-0.0247863457,
2.553e-7,
0.0254306588,
0.040330559,
-0.0137706865,
0.0044339104,
-0.0059245848,
0.031201506,
0.0339493901,
0.0072606099,
-0.0308560766,
0.019808935,
-0.0090777576,
0.0680649132,
0.0738981515,
-0.0159886312,
0.0042366232,
0.0422974005,
-0.04684164,
0.0107910354,
-0.0462839045,
0.0243568718,
-0.0061095343,
0.0723291636,
-0.0112092663,
-0.0037340103,
0.004965222,
-0.0588504039,
0.0437478721,
-0.0518284775,
0.0009500058,
-0.0525743775,
-0.0101551889,
0.0625040084,
-0.0107704941,
0.0043054577,
-0.0102393478,
0.007027647,
0.0566004887,
0.0353669003,
-0.0375941694,
0.0242065098,
-0.0128778685,
0.011086422,
-0.0338136517,
-0.0719204247,
0.0712407678,
-0.0177062526,
-0.034492854,
-0.0349739306,
0.0157333054,
0.0188381094,
0.0573687665,
-0.0004421293,
-0.0059198453,
-0.0381995104,
0.0437834077,
-0.0556497984,
-0.0270781051,
-0.0358297303,
0.0026092262,
-0.0377700441,
-0.0179960597,
-0.0406053625,
-0.0366354138,
0.0492566898,
0.0039069215,
0.0130850598,
-0.0055325059,
2.06501113e-34,
0.0130339926,
0.0519818626,
0.0025837244,
-0.0269334856,
0.0286556818,
0.0099556157,
0.0148963928,
-0.0266122222,
-0.0086133033,
-0.0063086059,
0.0488123931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05741v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05741v2 | Efficiently Adapting Pretrained Language Models To New Languages | 2023-11-09T20:59:08 | 2023-12-14T23:37:14 | Zoltan Csaki, Pian Pawakapan, Urmish Thakker, Qiantong Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent large language models (LLM) exhibit sub-optimal performance on
low-resource languages, as the training data of these models is usually
dominated by English and other high-resource languages. Furthermore, it is
challenging to train models for low-resource languages, especially from
scratch, due to a lack of high quality training data. Adapting pretrained LLMs
reduces the need for data in the new language while also providing cross
lingual transfer capabilities. However, naively adapting to new languages leads
to catastrophic forgetting and poor tokenizer efficiency. In this work, we
study how to efficiently adapt any existing pretrained LLM to a new language
without running into these issues. In particular, we improve the encoding
efficiency of the tokenizer by adding new tokens from the target language and
study the data mixing recipe to mitigate forgetting. Our experiments on
adapting an English LLM to Hungarian and Thai show that our recipe can reach
better performance than open source models on the target language, with minimal
regressions on English. | [
0.0145872366,
0.0731036291,
0.0207452644,
0.0377479121,
-0.003441246,
0.0341409184,
0.0071625491,
0.0047196592,
-0.0163569748,
-0.0509612933,
-0.0601442568,
-0.0315334685,
-0.0073367157,
0.0177091267,
0.0385584086,
-0.0556335263,
0.0695911795,
-0.0488425009,
-0.0311658625,
-0.0174412187,
-0.0008419201,
-0.0001872756,
0.0257188547,
0.0113836024,
-0.014514544,
0.0183044523,
-0.0066100368,
0.01173284,
-0.0141190588,
-0.0241736788,
-0.0117947785,
0.0379447825,
-0.0079475967,
0.0466526486,
0.0000018228,
-0.0415228345,
-0.0266532749,
-0.014769082,
0.0010975112,
0.0406130254,
0.0719036534,
-0.0376116931,
-0.0315873548,
0.0472641326,
-0.0089269374,
-0.0557729565,
0.0560521781,
0.033146292,
0.0472083427,
0.0899513513,
-0.0047661178,
-0.026999414,
0.0361621268,
-0.0211970005,
0.0041066254,
-0.0178200789,
0.0413841791,
-0.0271046758,
-0.0425418653,
-0.0157540031,
-0.0389807709,
0.0292693544,
0.0011192872,
0.0251268726,
0.0022974892,
0.0279187281,
-0.0684292465,
-0.0196817573,
-0.0274750553,
0.0407892019,
-0.0723585859,
-0.0485270582,
0.0006841887,
0.010198364,
-0.0128121926,
-0.0388547443,
-0.0487824455,
-0.0001201957,
0.023701217,
0.0430080928,
0.046767462,
-0.0218263883,
0.0412605442,
0.0107116727,
-0.0655123144,
0.0422228985,
0.0581717789,
-0.0130221155,
-0.0069250963,
-0.0001903167,
0.0113778589,
-0.0613066219,
0.0043540308,
0.0220977385,
-0.0230780467,
0.0175179169,
-0.0605645441,
-0.0516088158,
0.015810091,
-0.0389725268,
0.0081171151,
0.0594822578,
-0.038016066,
0.0640851483,
-0.0762557089,
0.0356909409,
-0.0065478543,
0.032221444,
-0.0754395425,
-0.0295122284,
-0.0218647532,
-0.0090387985,
-0.0688705444,
0.0299996193,
-0.013322657,
-0.0067981109,
-0.0386608765,
0.0261994526,
0.012710385,
-0.0206728037,
0.0306430254,
-0.0386194922,
-0.0392967276,
-0.0110538527,
-0.0017408688,
0.0214418601,
-0.0182382297,
0.0147455717,
0.021025585,
-0.053136386,
-0.0102832904,
0.0142076081,
0.0101812817,
-0.0275136661,
0.0379451402,
0.0750480369,
-0.0230247807,
-0.0204549283,
-0.0482329503,
0.0417250432,
0.0050265128,
-0.0501961596,
-0.0030267693,
-0.0748290718,
0.0572208129,
0.0082656732,
0.019211825,
-0.0469067022,
-0.0019490003,
0.0105922399,
-0.0490667559,
0.0580681376,
-0.0408978537,
0.0015409243,
0.0101104975,
-0.0216365419,
-0.0092479009,
0.0973973498,
0.0010265164,
0.0213598572,
0.0381809063,
-0.0153015358,
-0.0037643567,
0.0587801933,
0.0233316887,
0.0235831216,
-0.0235460196,
-0.012359743,
0.0685204193,
0.0015403008,
0.0536234826,
0.0789620429,
-0.0213015396,
0.0340251364,
0.0177053735,
0.037155237,
0.0179183111,
0.05689862,
0.0527230985,
-0.0350898579,
-0.0102102431,
-0.013878582,
-0.046882201,
-0.0185895786,
-0.0067080851,
0.0064290673,
0.0335585736,
0.0683872029,
-0.0571138225,
-0.0213201158,
-0.0059810849,
-0.0611379445,
0.026191676,
-0.0255959351,
0.0697130263,
0.0018941215,
-0.0436833091,
0.0990400314,
0.058737319,
-0.0580142625,
0.0357233882,
-0.0245025866,
0.0278853551,
0.0533619374,
0.0012892401,
-0.0206829086,
0.0109073212,
0.0170026366,
0.0610148087,
-0.0131009538,
0.0514595322,
-0.0025944216,
0.0442728065,
-0.0735322237,
0.0018632256,
0.0158666708,
0.0311656967,
0.0646344498,
0.0081403768,
0.0455014221,
0.0276383311,
-0.0335152932,
-0.0425485484,
0.030678248,
-0.0326897167,
-0.0167310908,
0.0141300792,
-0.006801269,
0.0044165025,
0.016454475,
0.019322481,
0.0159928054,
0.0405690856,
-0.0656984672,
-0.0169862583,
0.0241379701,
-0.0576845594,
-0.041497156,
0.0531960167,
0.0164358001,
0.0001697618,
-0.001747344,
-0.0439705439,
-0.05993912,
0.0393862724,
0.023690654,
0.0882080868,
-0.0565607287,
0.0605947934,
0.002996549,
0.0078660781,
-0.0099197756,
0.0508624576,
0.0109511064,
0.0104374159,
-0.0151322912,
-0.0154142929,
0.0179644991,
-0.0219521131,
-0.0530640148,
0.0302557629,
-0.029548537,
0.0292428583,
0.0148104532,
0.0111043239,
-0.0395485535,
-0.0142292762,
-0.0976973176,
0.010873666,
-0.0446192846,
0.0178149976,
-0.0108352359,
0.0449357368,
-0.0065013226,
-0.0265592989,
-0.0471206419,
-0.0346884504,
0.000273015,
0.0443523899,
-0.0025046684,
0.0180960018,
-0.0141919339,
-0.0220696367,
-0.0164452028,
0.0238971915,
0.0381252579,
-0.0565355904,
-0.021571992,
-0.0629013851,
0.0267009512,
-0.0309669469,
0.0364121608,
-0.0058476222,
-0.0539684445,
-0.0248735454,
-0.0317230448,
0.0511442795,
0.0390424915,
-0.0197461024,
0.0060815136,
0.0383427814,
-0.0065305326,
-0.0374254882,
0.0005826734,
0.0008589224,
-0.0421885028,
-0.0320713855,
-0.0161989126,
-0.0100797992,
0.0486744307,
-0.0545374341,
-0.0064802328,
-0.0604676493,
-0.0342070498,
-0.0501303673,
-0.0216303598,
-0.0307485554,
0.0069660945,
-0.0183874648,
0.0321655199,
0.0020559966,
-0.0242450759,
0.0314813294,
-0.0490155183,
-0.0041287723,
-0.0375036448,
-0.0062429779,
-0.0542804748,
0.0243391246,
0.0034413652,
0.0308458377,
-0.0263040233,
-0.0428839922,
-0.0427457653,
-0.0020451548,
0.0009584839,
-0.0181863755,
0.0319262706,
-0.0204021428,
0.003271631,
-0.0214320067,
-0.0388829522,
-0.029046325,
-0.036516849,
-0.043628905,
0.0127404304,
0.0095629441,
-0.0032961539,
-0.0310834851,
0.0237191189,
-0.0009069917,
0.0419268459,
0.0085926987,
0.0390348993,
0.0013742627,
-0.0018385146,
0.0120335445,
-0.0258296449,
-0.0207393952,
-0.0388008915,
0.0250548292,
0.0379244648,
0.0832006633,
-0.0371447131,
-0.0260434784,
0.0135644022,
0.039407365,
-0.013237928,
-0.0167286862,
-0.0123124607,
0.0307634715,
-0.0187190268,
0.0003582288,
0.0973309204,
0.0067054573,
-0.0514210798,
-0.0035582951,
-0.0095362365,
0.0381605476,
0.0209514592,
0.0250302944,
-0.091042839,
-0.0279431529,
0.0296741202,
-0.0086869635,
0.021354124,
0.0028221689,
-0.0145347556,
-0.1397779733,
-0.028551355,
0.0371527597,
-0.0678671896,
-0.0277580731,
-0.0271401685,
-0.0302057043,
-0.035577938,
0.0542676225,
0.0167307742,
-0.0203879867,
0.0019200628,
0.0326789729,
-0.0284709111,
-0.0543889366,
-0.0170657113,
-0.0307470467,
0.0606163777,
0.0330374129,
0.0014889708,
-0.017032152,
-0.0098783197,
0.0756952986,
0.0190374255,
-0.0236005913,
-0.026085278,
0.020722881,
-0.0065304353,
-0.0237885024,
0.0622731447,
0.0130873704,
-0.0294799935,
-0.0300860684,
0.007035316,
0.0536721833,
0.0394618213,
0.0007045586,
0.035756357,
-0.0402660854,
0.0034154812,
0.0743081123,
0.0257011205,
-0.037216913,
0.0002542211,
-0.0317936391,
-0.0257240087,
-0.0271501187,
0.0201549847,
0.008418587,
-0.0563568436,
-0.0490203686,
-0.0639088452,
-0.0230417717,
0.0559968613,
0.0529554896,
0.0141176768,
0.0494363643,
-0.0232537296,
-0.0053457771,
-0.0212527663,
0.0328171849,
-0.0441015549,
0.011994482,
-0.0793038979,
-0.0054084426,
0.0057862489,
-0.0048134634,
-0.0091632213,
-0.0290281791,
-0.0695228204,
-0.0706610084,
0.0167759489,
0.0544273332,
0.018519802,
0.0626805797,
0.0067762602,
-0.0407430977,
0.03519677,
0.0227622055,
-0.0378199294,
0.022884937,
0.0582517646,
-0.0114654442,
-0.001027127,
0.0321439393,
-0.072995849,
-0.0092387246,
0.0180580877,
0.0294156447,
-0.0041144541,
0.0442473441,
0.0025623057,
0.0310557429,
0.0488861352,
-0.0479434617,
-0.0043017152,
-0.0185840316,
0.0484294742,
-0.0362274572,
-0.0077429195,
-0.0355357304,
0.0004235608,
0.027066322,
0.0192799941,
-0.0128278788,
-0.023485899,
0.0030909155,
0.0323045626,
-0.00210758,
-0.0125782732,
-0.0063985842,
0.0433004387,
0.0623103231,
0.0131997662,
-0.0282563195,
-0.0005523138,
0.0069285501,
0.0170980915,
-0.0720767826,
-0.0268539619,
0.0069921347,
0.0086970907,
-0.0267042648,
0.0330360457,
-0.0262682699,
-0.0563865602,
-0.0138613041,
0.0247961301,
0.0575085729,
-0.0341091156,
0.0556998178,
-0.0041659004,
-0.0258945394,
-0.034334112,
0.0065941084,
-0.0026482735,
-0.0376227684,
0.0175196081,
-0.0051642996,
-0.0443504527,
-0.0031922224,
0.0831896812,
0.0292304624,
0.0315088555,
-0.0092641497,
0.0304744411,
0.0031266187,
0.0276877191,
0.0238068998,
0.013724912,
-0.0403893888,
-0.0179634951,
-0.0231454782,
-0.0851704851,
0.003603417,
-0.0001341262,
-0.0188473593,
0.0160554275,
0.023389386,
0.0410257354,
-0.0063074711,
0.0444264226,
-0.0339662395,
-0.0074874396,
0.0455564931,
-0.0316558369,
0.0281262677,
-6.004433593e-33,
-0.0106515391,
0.0462636016,
0.0100393556,
-0.0293534156,
-0.0088110399,
-0.0002130981,
-0.0092824772,
-0.0089689502,
-0.0003919483,
-0.019680012,
-0.0235516988,
-0.0128248269,
0.0334918499,
0.0433870032,
0.0085716769,
0.0084595261,
0.0477400012,
0.009811148,
-0.0087288013,
0.008062277,
0.0268461313,
0.0519764759,
0.0723697245,
0.0065467167,
-0.0257435031,
0.005689784,
-0.0105207376,
0.0385683216,
0.0357746333,
0.0630666912,
-0.0100416262,
0.0452391841,
0.009467992,
-0.0134662557,
-0.036223907,
0.0013846611,
-0.0878997594,
-0.0295674782,
0.0423237272,
0.0393227153,
0.0164274611,
-0.0423148647,
0.006253059,
-0.0250971671,
-0.0043735132,
0.0172889549,
-0.0073607462,
-0.0247008,
-0.0399762355,
0.0100191282,
-0.0528791063,
0.0169904046,
0.0153574264,
0.0254568439,
0.0427038781,
0.013968301,
0.0136548756,
-0.0007158385,
-0.0556937493,
0.0239509735,
-0.0002844811,
0.0529059321,
0.0737750158,
0.0372397415,
-0.0050119422,
0.0522635877,
0.0433858521,
-0.010338028,
0.0300701614,
0.0115310028,
0.0641342252,
0.009961633,
0.0252713896,
0.025002541,
0.0318100527,
-0.0512976423,
-0.0673177987,
0.006902351,
0.002703046,
0.0239304919,
0.0070713372,
0.063951157,
-0.0016188638,
-0.0529788062,
-0.0410645865,
0.0098221134,
-0.0455392785,
-0.0334747918,
0.0315923952,
0.0273423176,
-0.0198036432,
-0.0286743324,
0.0609357394,
-0.0269694012,
-0.03929222,
0.016159974,
0.005402647,
-0.0060411459,
-0.0423993133,
0.0657005683,
-0.0450257659,
-0.0748583749,
-0.0039100586,
-0.0189657938,
0.0017101874,
-0.0100540016,
0.0670113638,
0.0198404938,
-0.0886369273,
0.0021901117,
-0.0291824844,
0.0064517898,
0.0162444003,
0.0332654677,
0.034373749,
0.0256166961,
0.0019458085,
0.03395129,
0.0316813104,
-0.0191655345,
-0.0478637628,
-0.0258707255,
0.015264404,
0.0134392362,
-0.0293607544,
0.0083981259,
-0.0390938297,
0.0153330397,
0.0474532582,
-0.0299163908,
-0.0166015569,
0.0129833808,
2.495e-7,
0.0426620431,
0.0144872637,
0.0056965491,
-0.0331568159,
-0.0085989423,
0.0108168796,
-0.0513323806,
0.0138975661,
0.004820032,
0.0494742058,
0.0034873595,
0.0204787329,
0.0467681102,
0.0127016716,
-0.1076148078,
0.0186657067,
-0.0680136159,
0.014309248,
-0.0520794764,
-0.0128950803,
-0.0026430131,
0.126953274,
-0.001484683,
-0.0134223076,
-0.0232881084,
-0.0471675508,
0.0615896657,
-0.0398115255,
-0.0339563303,
0.0089023933,
0.008612318,
0.0661518052,
0.0100092208,
-0.0219124276,
-0.0569567308,
0.0049341698,
0.034061227,
0.0428707786,
-0.0087381247,
-0.0113601945,
0.0325645171,
-0.0019876708,
-0.0419748574,
-0.0441445597,
0.0639608949,
-0.0185033698,
0.0048842244,
-0.0481474698,
-0.0165321864,
0.0149488105,
0.0030998013,
-0.0107803941,
-0.0380934179,
0.0532855727,
0.0617116243,
0.006306713,
-0.0308034588,
-0.0655832067,
-0.0233073141,
-0.0063902945,
-0.0241730381,
-0.0581520945,
-0.0312754512,
0.0255001169,
0.020947786,
-0.0329128057,
0.0221397486,
2.316563936e-34,
0.0604148358,
-0.0029059085,
0.0175721869,
0.0618231632,
0.0304324087,
-0.041628316,
0.0192469116,
0.0396127254,
-0.0231252518,
-0.0754279569,
-0.0122108469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05720v1 | Long-Horizon Dialogue Understanding for Role Identification in the Game of Avalon with Large Language Models | 2023-11-09T20:04:08 | 2023-11-09T20:04:08 | Simon Stepputtis, Joseph Campbell, Yaqi Xie, Zhengyang Qi, Wenxin Sharon Zhang, Ruiyi Wang, Sanketh Rangreji, Michael Lewis, Katia Sycara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Deception and persuasion play a critical role in long-horizon dialogues
between multiple parties, especially when the interests, goals, and motivations
of the participants are not aligned. Such complex tasks pose challenges for
current Large Language Models (LLM) as deception and persuasion can easily
mislead them, especially in long-horizon multi-party dialogues. To this end, we
explore the game of Avalon: The Resistance, a social deduction game in which
players must determine each other's hidden identities to complete their team's
objective. We introduce an online testbed and a dataset containing 20 carefully
collected and labeled games among human players that exhibit long-horizon
deception in a cooperative-competitive setting. We discuss the capabilities of
LLMs to utilize deceptive long-horizon conversations between six human players
to determine each player's goal and motivation. Particularly, we discuss the
multimodal integration of the chat between the players and the game's state
that grounds the conversation, providing further insights into the true player
identities. We find that even current state-of-the-art LLMs do not reach human
performance, making our dataset a compelling benchmark to investigate the
decision-making and language-processing capabilities of LLMs. Our dataset and
online testbed can be found at our project website:
https://sstepput.github.io/Avalon-NLU/ | [
0.0689838231,
0.0864722654,
-0.0420673564,
0.0752857476,
-0.0639250055,
-0.0097743599,
0.018043017,
-0.002542852,
-0.0102440603,
-0.0352540389,
-0.027751388,
-0.0375288054,
0.0552142747,
0.0384774394,
0.0383535214,
0.015536732,
0.03881054,
-0.0343654491,
0.0747609809,
-0.0262647029,
-0.0082860887,
-0.0034908887,
-0.0241665579,
0.0388476774,
-0.0090105096,
-0.0159240291,
-0.0205245819,
-0.0196791925,
0.0174020194,
0.0027448719,
-0.0151361339,
0.0569253862,
0.0388984904,
0.0605942532,
0.0000019049,
-0.0404643193,
-0.0096295448,
-0.0459766984,
-0.0521879829,
-0.0288548432,
0.0268586762,
0.0018676512,
0.0169199221,
0.002507386,
-0.0466949716,
-0.0284323674,
0.0345479846,
0.0235020872,
0.0762813389,
0.0764287636,
0.0139797293,
-0.0160682816,
-0.0308816712,
-0.0613424666,
-0.0313146114,
-0.075773783,
0.0309395082,
-0.032337267,
-0.0260577146,
-0.0094154263,
0.0079556163,
-0.0056663686,
-0.0225919411,
-0.0186707061,
-0.03635085,
0.0388901494,
0.0013639281,
-0.0078008668,
0.0127433054,
0.0684863254,
0.0183453094,
-0.0006136522,
0.0182697289,
0.0401467346,
-0.0023330906,
0.0131736659,
0.0039361822,
0.0405977778,
0.0091545861,
-0.0089214491,
-0.0135778878,
0.0370872132,
0.0046838261,
0.0086623877,
-0.0172123369,
0.032327082,
-0.0181965996,
0.0074342149,
-0.0140568828,
-0.0142433466,
-0.0168214776,
-0.1138916239,
-0.02027403,
0.0205568224,
-0.0555708818,
0.0245510116,
-0.041681651,
0.0355514921,
0.0254213847,
-0.0315655321,
0.043070659,
-0.003008777,
0.0265787486,
0.0666714087,
0.0287886094,
0.0451093651,
-0.0000366845,
-0.0080489805,
0.0083688023,
-0.0286164973,
0.0072216131,
-0.0266142339,
-0.0299707111,
0.0195959527,
-0.0204052553,
-0.0306298658,
-0.0256795902,
-0.0116884578,
-0.0592188239,
0.0736763403,
-0.0122865271,
0.0118384715,
-0.0315339379,
-0.0159309153,
-0.0444301553,
0.0484538376,
-0.0081484644,
0.02210363,
0.0023023617,
-0.0606492795,
-0.0084874807,
0.0035440198,
-0.0167532936,
-0.032138776,
0.0189760439,
0.0567714646,
-0.02429826,
-0.0078968666,
0.0487690009,
-0.0365813188,
-0.0278648641,
-0.1099838093,
0.0129595622,
-0.0416672565,
0.0331216455,
-0.0301208366,
0.002333092,
-0.0451256335,
0.0196262784,
0.0079578971,
0.0028535274,
0.0951216668,
0.0197230559,
0.0255148299,
0.0301530305,
0.0336962827,
-0.0194560513,
0.0772544816,
0.0332577899,
0.0518588535,
0.0323834643,
-0.0116859945,
0.0379737616,
0.040898066,
0.015736768,
0.0011113727,
-0.0057486715,
-0.0074760425,
0.0133302398,
0.0443411395,
0.0122995088,
0.0331651866,
-0.0312422086,
-0.0978620201,
0.1265738457,
0.035914015,
0.0027178477,
-0.000887802,
-0.0007908412,
0.0388472304,
-0.0127753979,
-0.0083162496,
-0.0330266654,
0.0380417891,
-0.0302957036,
-0.0360507853,
-0.0190237481,
0.0177931543,
-0.0034483215,
0.0012932423,
0.0327638686,
-0.0192178153,
0.0168127939,
0.0554758459,
0.0148589294,
-0.0249362327,
-0.0307196472,
0.0340926982,
0.0354284458,
-0.0283378363,
-0.0150550343,
-0.0555893928,
0.0429078415,
0.0325897709,
0.0580001399,
-0.0063618985,
-0.0316865519,
-0.0472213663,
0.0106883403,
0.060383901,
0.0419908874,
-0.0188228376,
0.0393949822,
-0.0271762013,
-0.0187685173,
-0.0055787102,
-0.0091084922,
0.0405752361,
-0.0284963399,
-0.0097373435,
-0.0035551742,
-0.0177627839,
0.0590419918,
0.0068946024,
0.0106993727,
-0.0015318232,
-0.0248611439,
0.0256817676,
0.0474099964,
-0.0000067175,
-0.0320835821,
-0.0194143821,
0.0252788942,
-0.0312623233,
-0.0169289466,
0.022521371,
-0.0253396668,
-0.0204767454,
0.0359699093,
-0.0408033244,
-0.0204330403,
0.0275473539,
0.0085062096,
-0.0022171014,
0.048520308,
-0.0485073365,
-0.0028743874,
0.0038444833,
-0.0170624275,
-0.0167929754,
0.0534591675,
-0.002096985,
0.0467490591,
0.0077304272,
-0.0151557364,
-0.0291393306,
-0.0422780067,
0.008501865,
-0.0673712865,
0.0265441667,
0.0544345118,
0.0047226134,
-0.0411493741,
0.0413141176,
-0.016792044,
-0.0256475229,
-0.0635830164,
-0.1178723425,
-0.0363919102,
-0.0108053461,
-0.0153207052,
-0.016951533,
-0.020393433,
-0.0111348871,
0.0234686546,
-0.0277603101,
0.0287204459,
0.0092316866,
0.002171681,
0.0119522233,
0.0134881493,
-0.0365056768,
0.0130829243,
0.0189504586,
-0.0116539607,
0.0742940679,
-0.0146915121,
-0.0220373105,
-0.0388684757,
-0.0238752495,
-0.0435473807,
0.0558256581,
-0.0504206866,
-0.0572405197,
0.0179523528,
0.0093834903,
0.0285369661,
0.0637016296,
0.0597116202,
0.0497620665,
0.0208424963,
-0.049419146,
-0.0429637767,
0.0147083718,
-0.0120292325,
0.0013492077,
-0.0872363523,
-0.0347428322,
-0.0005162191,
0.0663434491,
-0.0117170308,
0.0138107063,
-0.0090340376,
0.0189108904,
0.0182469208,
-0.0509904586,
0.0169277415,
-0.040736381,
-0.0114705171,
-0.0000870973,
-0.0185039341,
-0.0143421981,
0.0935589597,
-0.0420468561,
-0.019156171,
-0.0147502609,
-0.0048066163,
-0.0096106986,
0.1085524932,
-0.0009376817,
0.0043336465,
0.0324339084,
-0.0075077955,
-0.0175295826,
-0.0566139556,
0.0402650535,
-0.0298733953,
0.0478029512,
-0.0532278679,
0.0173467565,
-0.0076350626,
-0.011175245,
-0.031624537,
-0.0766894743,
-0.0486489795,
-0.020823231,
-0.008810102,
-0.0150679359,
-0.063065961,
-0.0203221105,
0.0115384348,
-0.0202893429,
0.00963342,
0.0100286342,
-0.025172811,
-0.011463508,
0.0545422174,
0.0461873189,
0.0034758912,
-0.0451230519,
0.0381643213,
0.0586467646,
-0.0147944158,
-0.0027096546,
-0.0104865292,
-0.0307328589,
0.0307846367,
0.0112721724,
0.0015073675,
0.0030295108,
0.0279918145,
-0.0399531238,
0.0127829332,
0.0963161364,
-0.0093084509,
-0.0537477471,
0.005907387,
0.0277506635,
0.0285112262,
0.0160674751,
-0.0192884244,
-0.0981518701,
-0.0455399044,
0.0165425036,
-0.0161789637,
-0.0350298695,
-0.0500192679,
-0.0546451658,
-0.1170824915,
0.002321071,
0.0028417269,
-0.0120857479,
-0.0130216861,
-0.0120114591,
0.0138634443,
-0.0162449647,
0.0192761384,
-0.0235454366,
0.0504969023,
-0.0198674779,
-0.022336999,
-0.0071227299,
-0.0103266435,
0.0225429256,
-0.0468752943,
0.1220973879,
0.0115793422,
0.0832791254,
0.004137997,
-0.0217162482,
0.0157665219,
0.0205513667,
-0.023168264,
0.012235092,
0.0637256652,
-0.0357978046,
-0.0073728072,
0.0137099484,
0.0214318298,
0.0068474426,
-0.0141332252,
0.0212665126,
0.0294341519,
-0.0322848745,
-0.052503977,
0.0390530676,
0.0404918529,
0.0835785493,
0.0696541816,
0.0070311143,
-0.0185308084,
-0.0205401592,
-0.0037528751,
0.0267030466,
-0.0016582008,
-0.0363592505,
-0.0137293274,
0.0565023981,
-0.0070880111,
-0.0208541453,
-0.0457927808,
0.0081986208,
0.0185153633,
-0.0099006537,
0.0309991334,
0.0174981933,
0.0344641022,
-0.0244602319,
0.0078715608,
-0.0809208974,
0.0717114434,
-0.0146930534,
-0.0338387676,
-0.0060919235,
-0.0558508895,
0.0061880122,
0.0587332621,
-0.0717758238,
-0.0288376361,
0.0123520149,
-0.0059616216,
0.0243298989,
0.0311243553,
-0.0079573523,
-0.0702792257,
0.0181913264,
-0.0244293269,
-0.0323991887,
0.0400150195,
0.0185165145,
0.0443059802,
0.0079425536,
0.0455148108,
0.0031577197,
0.0123445271,
0.0425281897,
0.0089379139,
-0.0547329858,
-0.0397137478,
0.0121120568,
-0.0001737496,
0.0300467778,
-0.0023560966,
0.0436370634,
-0.0107419929,
-0.0042534526,
-0.0524006598,
0.0020797793,
-0.0185860228,
-0.0416734889,
0.0336020328,
0.0018706755,
0.0457756966,
-0.0219355226,
-0.0189259164,
-0.0113418261,
-0.0216029808,
0.0194829404,
0.0429678783,
-0.0200540349,
0.0068076039,
0.0021032859,
0.020740699,
0.0494421758,
-0.018401172,
0.040674489,
0.0260091443,
0.0444002412,
0.0473094285,
-0.078552179,
-0.0031575928,
0.0207838248,
-0.0235615894,
-0.0206845999,
0.0621689744,
0.0635501444,
0.0519832298,
0.0390666462,
0.0109426286,
-0.0318282135,
0.0303118993,
0.0057303114,
0.0238977149,
-0.0289129931,
-0.0722600073,
0.0218818523,
0.0211673807,
-0.0474528596,
0.0468683131,
0.070660919,
0.0260010436,
0.0221805125,
0.0016457449,
0.0036030977,
-0.0428994112,
-0.0391004011,
0.0151421288,
0.0381188393,
-0.0402961299,
0.0250462126,
-0.076170437,
-0.037795227,
-0.0047222027,
0.006508993,
0.0382006615,
-0.0072677359,
-0.0107164178,
0.0441293083,
-0.0055037574,
-0.0207088999,
-0.0672006756,
0.0388134085,
-0.0065980344,
0.0054656137,
-0.0100874798,
-6.013324371e-33,
-0.0120441047,
-0.0440172628,
0.0240095146,
-0.0056735929,
-0.03790861,
0.0290018171,
-0.0359333232,
-0.0018356709,
-0.022534892,
0.0344083011,
-0.004002138,
0.0267747492,
0.0100518307,
0.0121093895,
-0.0476704352,
-0.0300030168,
0.0280936137,
0.001090443,
-0.036399845,
0.0322787389,
0.0425598584,
-0.0162630007,
0.0310096648,
-0.083520405,
-0.0042941878,
0.0332486555,
-0.0549620353,
0.0616424382,
-0.0221895501,
0.0168581698,
-0.0174156912,
0.0020357885,
-0.005975212,
-0.0366133563,
0.0026119549,
0.0286164638,
-0.0127261477,
-0.0028864273,
0.0306631736,
-0.0022832504,
0.0017137228,
-0.0267417189,
0.0003679459,
-0.0085964408,
-0.0284702871,
-0.0316890329,
0.0097032599,
-0.0136432787,
0.0133325541,
-0.0073416899,
-0.0303558409,
0.021342637,
-0.0355434753,
-0.026091136,
0.0211306494,
-0.005567349,
0.024608627,
-0.0117574949,
-0.0775566176,
0.0626552477,
-0.0534030385,
-0.0137457661,
0.0493679531,
0.0271461178,
0.0381238312,
0.0782261491,
0.0377464332,
0.0638406426,
-0.0460228734,
-0.0251660105,
0.0017843465,
0.0613359697,
0.0695937723,
0.0326972194,
-0.0326595418,
-0.0414925516,
-0.0462816283,
-0.0235305652,
0.0687967986,
0.0050625145,
0.0564085171,
0.0117430342,
-0.0283780638,
-0.0249651819,
-0.0376945995,
0.0005083748,
-0.025834091,
0.0048371134,
0.002954613,
0.0175712071,
-0.0327048302,
0.0056383638,
0.0725651234,
-0.0647269338,
-0.0104243821,
0.0284718275,
0.0404798277,
0.0198829453,
0.0054256059,
-0.0166101363,
-0.0335640945,
-0.0236985665,
0.0516512953,
-0.007754094,
0.0368045047,
-0.0018939904,
0.0051456741,
-0.0024074772,
-0.0015227018,
-0.0172807742,
-0.0345687643,
0.0420572944,
-0.0100318966,
-0.0198391229,
0.0407348573,
-0.0217781793,
-0.0240768455,
-0.0241459403,
0.0040069772,
-0.0059378054,
-0.0097572245,
0.0222978126,
-0.0395589843,
0.010132988,
-0.0357860029,
-0.0002426554,
-0.0349526443,
0.0058217985,
0.0235358533,
0.0062424242,
-0.0085930768,
-0.0662097558,
2.652e-7,
-0.0463101007,
0.0412529185,
0.0002019187,
0.0296421219,
0.0159869324,
0.0785743147,
-0.0091031352,
0.041175209,
0.0107609928,
-0.0654018074,
0.0067468206,
0.0366807096,
0.0681765079,
0.0264249053,
-0.0520989224,
0.006340012,
-0.0107889753,
-0.0606688932,
-0.0510913841,
-0.0016421775,
0.0434401818,
0.0656112805,
0.0743482709,
-0.017378483,
0.0043999306,
-0.0375355966,
0.0268252082,
-0.0559718087,
-0.0304479878,
0.0361139029,
0.0457240269,
-0.076072365,
-0.0165339671,
0.0291579068,
0.0180699993,
0.021362748,
-0.0493284166,
0.0206432026,
-0.0156070478,
-0.0326859392,
-0.0590324104,
-0.0223535206,
-0.0339585207,
-0.0415001214,
0.0433137752,
-0.0496565439,
-0.0771631822,
-0.0400407165,
-0.0038232321,
-0.0415448211,
-0.0016917748,
0.0112018334,
-0.0298141092,
0.0150450887,
0.0122136092,
-0.0015866794,
-0.0009163953,
-0.0705329105,
-0.0185486507,
-0.0178715885,
-0.0648654029,
-0.0210834462,
0.0066867662,
0.0081097642,
0.0254132599,
-0.0298977531,
0.0138432318,
2.342174331e-34,
0.0032694885,
0.0018115786,
-0.045748502,
-0.0094820252,
0.0937631875,
-0.0177999437,
-0.0241382439,
0.0259158798,
0.034058921,
-0.0509893931,
0.0080435732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05608v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05608v2 | FigStep: Jailbreaking Large Vision-language Models via Typographic Visual Prompts | 2023-11-09T18:59:11 | 2023-12-13T17:54:16 | Yichen Gong, Delong Ran, Jinyuan Liu, Conglei Wang, Tianshuo Cong, Anyu Wang, Sisi Duan, Xiaoyun Wang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Ensuring the safety of artificial intelligence-generated content (AIGC) is a
longstanding topic in the artificial intelligence (AI) community, and the
safety concerns associated with Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely
investigated. Recently, large vision-language models (VLMs) represent an
unprecedented revolution, as they are built upon LLMs but can incorporate
additional modalities (e.g., images). However, the safety of VLMs lacks
systematic evaluation, and there may be an overconfidence in the safety
guarantees provided by their underlying LLMs. In this paper, to demonstrate
that introducing additional modality modules leads to unforeseen AI safety
issues, we propose FigStep, a straightforward yet effective jailbreaking
algorithm against VLMs. Instead of feeding textual harmful instructions
directly, FigStep converts the harmful content into images through typography
to bypass the safety alignment within the textual module of the VLMs, inducing
VLMs to output unsafe responses that violate common AI safety policies. In our
evaluation, we manually review 46,500 model responses generated by 3 families
of the promising open-source VLMs, i.e., LLaVA, MiniGPT4, and CogVLM (a total
of 6 VLMs). The experimental results show that FigStep can achieve an average
attack success rate of 82.50% on 500 harmful queries in 10 topics. Moreover, we
demonstrate that the methodology of FigStep can even jailbreak GPT-4V, which
already leverages an OCR detector to filter harmful queries. Above all, our
work reveals that VLMs are vulnerable to jailbreaking attacks, which highlights
the necessity of novel safety alignments between visual and textual modalities. | [
0.028406851,
0.0564746894,
-0.0166564453,
0.0450343862,
-0.0415192917,
0.0024420086,
0.0206006858,
0.0155340284,
0.0747757107,
-0.0384308659,
0.0119184395,
-0.0114673572,
0.0166547876,
0.0623224825,
0.0476761498,
-0.0142661929,
0.0306438524,
-0.0721146837,
-0.0145339658,
-0.0002284855,
0.0206285585,
-0.0020872513,
0.0079118228,
0.039503824,
-0.0398928039,
-0.0406551361,
-0.0335179493,
0.0326632671,
0.0190507136,
-0.0357698463,
-0.0430081114,
0.0283288844,
-0.0024933356,
0.0567333475,
0.0000022547,
-0.0282868557,
-0.0240424722,
0.0513674989,
-0.0088060219,
0.0298087075,
0.0252162684,
-0.0626956075,
-0.024184227,
0.0171192847,
-0.0334792361,
0.0135214627,
0.0741382614,
0.0724118426,
0.0803183541,
0.0616720691,
-0.0259112082,
0.01083674,
0.0623463728,
0.007979502,
0.0200540703,
-0.0387072787,
0.0242043864,
-0.0149331344,
0.0067216693,
0.0373387448,
-0.0036272551,
0.0481250957,
0.0159672555,
-0.0362886898,
-0.056461595,
0.0265304409,
-0.0300265178,
-0.0619883686,
-0.0183125027,
0.0495049097,
-0.0239613783,
-0.0132567137,
0.0056158374,
0.013220273,
0.0141071342,
0.0325367749,
-0.0138430707,
0.0652084574,
-0.0108927842,
-0.0111288661,
0.004356531,
-0.0305030309,
0.0251655318,
-0.0034797885,
-0.0048521371,
-0.0141765261,
0.0273565054,
-0.029960949,
0.0122013437,
-0.0356568955,
-0.0117178569,
-0.0505629852,
-0.009891971,
-0.0014671247,
0.0251031592,
-0.0006891416,
-0.1049816012,
-0.04414979,
0.0111846803,
-0.0628657192,
0.0340372846,
0.0058932863,
-0.0276046004,
0.0289294589,
0.0032819109,
0.0446765423,
-0.0490035675,
0.0711852685,
0.0143342074,
0.0029043872,
0.00766565,
-0.0296688061,
-0.0130006047,
0.0154796401,
-0.0403213128,
-0.0133544449,
-0.0147037366,
0.0510585792,
-0.0467537604,
0.0369076468,
-0.0279846117,
0.0090383831,
0.0060383957,
0.010966178,
0.0153535753,
-0.0398292467,
0.0355799459,
-0.0282718837,
-0.010453294,
-0.0873919949,
-0.0054609538,
0.0439869724,
-0.0207956042,
-0.0086615607,
-0.0238426682,
0.1252856553,
0.0027869381,
-0.0193753298,
-0.0467256121,
-0.0695369616,
-0.043972332,
-0.0039922148,
0.0334826671,
-0.0637031645,
-0.0196832381,
-0.0303981174,
-0.0033260409,
-0.0612878129,
0.0306971967,
0.0326639079,
-0.058927428,
0.0821618214,
-0.0334419645,
-0.0211670659,
0.000557435,
0.0329113603,
0.0029846132,
0.0544327796,
0.0248201173,
0.0649970844,
0.0507872738,
-0.015971506,
0.0642046928,
0.0624921508,
0.0028439013,
0.0307854991,
-0.0534964167,
-0.0037755782,
0.0309737828,
-0.0009685375,
-0.0350534283,
0.0770688206,
-0.0086275106,
-0.0468377098,
0.0997552127,
0.0625534058,
-0.0390711315,
0.0224304907,
-0.0020684449,
-0.0130367847,
0.0220518205,
-0.0046700323,
-0.079404667,
0.0124250008,
-0.0852572992,
-0.0358537957,
-0.044330962,
0.0243516639,
-0.0125650251,
-0.0012453411,
-0.0043554618,
-0.0301936995,
0.0021153125,
-0.0048745782,
0.019153744,
0.0083998656,
-0.0151619408,
-0.0144032314,
-0.0044908989,
-0.0532764532,
-0.042185463,
-0.0628113449,
-0.0027255181,
0.0835079029,
0.0820851475,
0.0037986755,
-0.0133419884,
-0.0161390193,
-0.0085366648,
0.0367627926,
-0.0185465105,
0.0269480068,
0.0013923162,
-0.0231716167,
-0.0084020356,
0.0007708212,
-0.0116784871,
-0.0118138902,
0.0048280074,
0.0140448706,
0.0061487271,
-0.0031334185,
-0.0514485575,
0.0266508926,
0.0149492174,
-0.0240594186,
-0.0180744361,
0.0390731171,
0.0063228142,
0.0029696396,
-0.0403533094,
0.0259773098,
0.0593799241,
-0.016134873,
0.0186999645,
-0.003471886,
-0.0067017572,
0.0256111193,
0.0367605388,
-0.1062091812,
-0.0065327277,
0.0648592487,
-0.0243774839,
0.0080954833,
0.0143217519,
-0.0694263354,
-0.0060538347,
-0.0107432175,
0.0074050277,
0.0047861738,
0.0008662713,
-0.0183830205,
0.0183096062,
-0.0201957133,
-0.0557636209,
0.0112496242,
-0.0019324044,
0.0107509522,
-0.0005040743,
-0.0331974365,
0.0204559509,
-0.0201314669,
0.0387356356,
0.0063880095,
0.0426821969,
-0.0041900743,
-0.024244437,
-0.0857368186,
-0.0468579605,
-0.013382107,
-0.0086249923,
0.0147487242,
0.0069721136,
-0.0253105816,
-0.014877446,
-0.0100545222,
-0.0081532048,
-0.0218214374,
0.0234938636,
0.0209716111,
-0.0214781743,
-0.0260605365,
0.0043507842,
-0.040673811,
-0.0088513838,
0.0497326367,
0.0064481269,
-0.0451305173,
-0.0266367272,
0.0420197099,
0.0034539234,
0.0443241335,
-0.0172354802,
-0.0313515738,
0.024681991,
-0.014338213,
-0.0162158329,
0.0800854042,
0.0356181599,
0.0327122919,
0.0455417745,
0.009403117,
-0.0175576471,
-0.0103859743,
0.0389649421,
-0.0318557844,
-0.0051282821,
-0.0524068363,
0.0179107487,
-0.0061083445,
-0.0054398826,
0.0273077879,
-0.0594332851,
0.0660308748,
0.0017206531,
-0.052397497,
-0.011486168,
-0.0112459091,
-0.0195666254,
0.0091797244,
-0.0117769958,
-0.0944985002,
0.0369909965,
-0.0465968251,
0.0194859616,
0.0366920643,
-0.0192409568,
0.0093362136,
0.0499159023,
0.0208356399,
0.0243019983,
0.0443335362,
-0.0056824619,
-0.0562955178,
0.0199177731,
0.0100704441,
-0.0222345218,
0.0709282681,
-0.057464812,
0.0017833016,
-0.0341476835,
-0.0280516893,
-0.0358189903,
-0.0721710399,
0.003103127,
-0.0228231736,
0.0079506775,
-0.0504963286,
-0.0046260832,
-0.0025368039,
0.0492715798,
-0.027811233,
-0.0190576296,
-0.0064447299,
-0.0291222315,
0.0355531089,
0.0584459752,
-0.0475572906,
-0.0032226075,
-0.0087657589,
0.0042968201,
0.1190873682,
0.055758357,
0.0096542249,
-0.0257558469,
0.0110523365,
0.0156690516,
0.0552222691,
-0.0223443583,
0.0247960594,
0.0343531035,
-0.0334928595,
-0.0032780822,
0.0325179063,
0.0085849157,
-0.0399269238,
0.0107261678,
0.0418105312,
0.0234989263,
0.0011104684,
0.0121596269,
-0.1017645001,
-0.0142978225,
0.0172379538,
0.0490872636,
-0.0313746408,
-0.0276204161,
-0.0162480976,
-0.0916292518,
0.0482749268,
0.0274211541,
0.0223979075,
-0.0256982557,
0.0129264342,
-0.0221834145,
0.016583208,
-0.0138788475,
-0.0228066221,
-0.0208785627,
0.000931097,
-0.0008901988,
0.0017064692,
-0.0136065176,
-0.0069128857,
-0.0235652123,
0.0322029255,
0.0702569485,
-0.0144396657,
-0.0394793861,
-0.0305131096,
0.0203912351,
0.0015664279,
0.0010023984,
-0.0025187761,
0.0557472296,
-0.0051599597,
-0.0309327543,
-0.0029811009,
0.020318836,
0.001753134,
-0.0241886005,
0.0272567086,
0.0345811583,
-0.0212195646,
-0.0125377309,
-0.055779662,
-0.0275052749,
-0.0117744599,
0.0333715566,
0.0233492069,
-0.0355612226,
-0.0571128428,
-0.0750386193,
0.0146086151,
-0.0327018425,
-0.0549662262,
0.0287168864,
0.0318334177,
-0.0519114994,
-0.0439988412,
-0.0080245016,
-0.0001829738,
0.0378173143,
0.0356874615,
-0.0359137878,
0.0002188155,
0.0225005914,
-0.0442382991,
-0.0076990593,
-0.0139253475,
0.0245124809,
-0.0594309978,
0.0409426242,
-0.0171218868,
-0.0272172615,
-0.0019072947,
0.0464168563,
-0.0508806445,
-0.0707726777,
0.0181565545,
0.0991894975,
0.0220475774,
-0.0245728809,
-0.0204375647,
-0.0453252308,
0.0856013373,
0.1037101075,
-0.014136171,
0.0200325456,
0.0496096648,
-0.037013717,
0.0188602544,
0.0193198416,
-0.0401817337,
-0.0405733511,
0.029703889,
-0.0218613334,
-0.0275377575,
-0.0007672022,
0.0122426925,
0.0501836762,
-0.0052792425,
-0.0221558623,
0.0421187691,
0.0366582498,
0.0275289919,
-0.036540173,
-0.0153009975,
-0.0262820683,
0.0259195995,
0.0057387291,
-0.0155227743,
0.0408572406,
0.0195120834,
-0.0028661136,
-0.0017177608,
-0.0318469293,
0.0185739305,
0.0230460335,
0.0247202888,
0.0429301821,
0.0153424032,
-0.0044130096,
0.0502833761,
-0.0181425326,
0.0273222867,
-0.0075539197,
0.045314353,
0.0032753528,
-0.0167181306,
0.0084868222,
0.0864987522,
-0.0625523776,
-0.0651321709,
0.0077744219,
0.0821756497,
0.0182880107,
0.0294173378,
0.0028141704,
-0.0251419693,
0.0046148938,
-0.0597011,
-0.0172259249,
0.0209248625,
-0.0370797142,
0.0304468926,
0.0104289548,
-0.0037095349,
-0.0072400202,
0.086772576,
0.0261286031,
0.0364847071,
0.0291608777,
-0.0297733545,
-0.0438756198,
-0.0258579161,
0.0496260114,
-0.0203287471,
-0.0302569717,
-0.0313927531,
-0.0618772805,
-0.0759193376,
0.0094672097,
-0.0052988445,
0.0175807718,
0.0118410448,
-0.0001566849,
0.0333376639,
0.030207241,
-0.0022832097,
-0.0234667193,
0.0003547416,
-0.0196918529,
-0.050506413,
0.0358696096,
-6.192091348e-33,
0.0312997885,
-0.0486873798,
-0.0284294505,
0.0081808306,
0.0213572588,
0.0322987586,
0.0033901343,
0.005751126,
-0.010029071,
-0.0151022775,
-0.0247366987,
-0.0075657601,
-0.0041526458,
0.0231481325,
-0.0170040429,
-0.0336559229,
-0.0015984896,
-0.0051989295,
-0.0126188342,
0.0210964531,
0.0310143959,
-0.0039087632,
0.0078602452,
-0.0970976949,
0.0146090901,
-0.0161926076,
-0.0543726385,
-0.0128953326,
-0.0260545202,
0.083366707,
0.0083957277,
0.0321648493,
0.0075412653,
0.0374064557,
-0.0075153797,
0.0786493048,
-0.0084884278,
-0.0059007667,
-0.0161948111,
0.0046633054,
-0.0564351417,
-0.0592987053,
0.0272685327,
-0.0349687077,
-0.007640461,
-0.0377685912,
-0.0013652098,
-0.0140116336,
-0.0052656024,
-0.0014218726,
-0.0178929958,
0.0043222685,
-0.0194084402,
-0.008972045,
0.0441870987,
0.0261554178,
0.0422736555,
0.0147346864,
-0.0215626303,
0.0220924672,
0.0479030758,
-0.0169762038,
0.0603141785,
-0.0065214648,
0.0095585547,
0.0479692444,
0.0072528017,
-0.0288829729,
-0.0276358183,
-0.0358571373,
-0.0063535403,
0.0841316208,
0.0628906637,
0.0716668144,
0.0234043095,
-0.0025754918,
-0.054279048,
0.0093686851,
-0.071610719,
0.0515676998,
0.0349762402,
-0.020832859,
-0.0793329328,
0.007183623,
-0.0097655244,
-0.0208954234,
-0.0333800688,
-0.0178618692,
0.0410931557,
0.0098401448,
-0.0376013517,
0.0153478282,
0.0037364583,
-0.0647974461,
0.0101025887,
0.0058879103,
-0.0019719673,
0.007782001,
-0.0078842621,
0.0189867727,
0.007456651,
0.0093788914,
0.039775461,
-0.0392754525,
0.0340337604,
0.0251415633,
0.0462388881,
0.0512302369,
-0.059866298,
-0.0170157887,
-0.0195820816,
0.0361736193,
0.0246941559,
-0.0246077888,
0.0471231118,
-0.0296769142,
-0.0064720428,
-0.0169166718,
0.0413997248,
0.0262415614,
-0.0462993905,
-0.0195468329,
-0.0423912033,
0.0139089804,
-0.0016255559,
-0.0078316741,
-0.0037898328,
0.0221337378,
0.043903105,
-0.0771298259,
-0.0101718837,
0.0151445838,
3.005e-7,
-0.014140307,
0.0347231403,
0.0517309569,
0.0244318768,
0.0302441977,
0.0935112983,
0.0023696499,
0.0634461567,
-0.0373523831,
-0.028061755,
-0.0152980145,
-0.0050128475,
0.0690101013,
0.0249171779,
-0.0121263405,
0.0434037335,
-0.024324527,
-0.0114561785,
-0.0725338757,
0.0039139306,
0.0775317997,
0.065562956,
-0.025239883,
-0.0526220649,
0.0302120037,
-0.075368911,
0.0107135093,
-0.0251478329,
-0.0055562649,
-0.0510635152,
0.0003145719,
0.0624575578,
0.010362668,
0.0337706655,
-0.0298701841,
-0.0604313612,
-0.0164574645,
0.0377317108,
-0.0258018039,
-0.0035560923,
-0.0135207744,
-0.0447229147,
-0.0179780088,
-0.0607547686,
0.0843196139,
0.0372908376,
-0.0224361811,
-0.0238872673,
0.0039722556,
-0.0522373579,
0.0316900015,
-0.0647381619,
0.0017160707,
0.0099499607,
0.0183723737,
-0.0149975289,
0.0071231062,
-0.0369947478,
0.0032054938,
-0.0461439826,
0.0139973518,
-0.0190072246,
-0.0522638112,
0.0599572361,
0.0338017792,
-0.0167565942,
-0.0090321312,
3.084973803e-34,
-0.0076269964,
-0.0527717061,
0.0059645185,
0.0218171552,
0.0409423895,
0.0091255223,
0.0067383377,
0.0105376672,
-0.0244224388,
-0.0438539237,
-0.0344666615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05601v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05601v1 | FAMuS: Frames Across Multiple Sources | 2023-11-09T18:57:39 | 2023-11-09T18:57:39 | Siddharth Vashishtha, Alexander Martin, William Gantt, Benjamin Van Durme, Aaron Steven White | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding event descriptions is a central aspect of language processing,
but current approaches focus overwhelmingly on single sentences or documents.
Aggregating information about an event \emph{across documents} can offer a much
richer understanding. To this end, we present FAMuS, a new corpus of Wikipedia
passages that \emph{report} on some event, paired with underlying,
genre-diverse (non-Wikipedia) \emph{source} articles for the same event. Events
and (cross-sentence) arguments in both report and source are annotated against
FrameNet, providing broad coverage of different event types. We present results
on two key event understanding tasks enabled by FAMuS: \emph{source validation}
-- determining whether a document is a valid source for a target report event
-- and \emph{cross-document argument extraction} -- full-document argument
extraction for a target event from both its report and the correct source
article. We release both FAMuS and our models to support further research. | [
0.0120613771,
0.0242235232,
0.0181639455,
0.0608600862,
-0.0377885625,
0.0246967115,
-0.0062634018,
0.0001499132,
0.018360272,
-0.0729295239,
0.0276543573,
0.0047593354,
-0.008913259,
0.0259395428,
-0.0039732219,
-0.0591853671,
0.0384165123,
0.0188172385,
0.0142579647,
0.0409348384,
0.0166496541,
0.051060807,
-0.0706663206,
0.0487443581,
-0.026086865,
-0.0063203829,
-0.0334519707,
-0.0187298469,
0.0551795624,
-0.0080441684,
0.0241679344,
0.0270192996,
0.0507805869,
0.0145531883,
0.000001437,
-0.0337248035,
0.0134516656,
-0.0112350006,
-0.0183705147,
0.0043614479,
-0.0193227958,
-0.0411999226,
0.0123178335,
-0.0488727614,
0.0058334772,
-0.0858251676,
0.0126442993,
0.0745098665,
0.0308440644,
0.086123459,
-0.0184363518,
-0.0145044513,
-0.0007646385,
0.0060380273,
-0.0007701676,
-0.0084355054,
0.018139312,
-0.0118210074,
0.0026452381,
-0.0177092403,
0.0080334265,
-0.0198135767,
-0.0095809055,
-0.020424461,
-0.0321093425,
-0.0052670063,
-0.0619203001,
-0.0032629953,
0.0108264824,
0.0345223807,
0.0419330113,
-0.0320588611,
0.0436496176,
0.0104802484,
0.0156714302,
0.032439705,
-0.0405701324,
0.0143971825,
-0.0336457267,
-0.0042922799,
0.060973037,
0.0167500321,
0.0020933682,
0.0239094011,
0.016541522,
0.0577019639,
0.0272524096,
0.0372667238,
-0.0392404757,
0.0294830371,
-0.0126828915,
-0.0378031097,
0.0235537663,
0.0189310983,
-0.01331772,
0.0211468581,
-0.0289054029,
0.0149859563,
0.009179607,
-0.0442562662,
-0.0849583372,
0.0047024172,
-0.0087857163,
0.0636086166,
0.0161643848,
-0.0169470198,
-0.0484761894,
-0.0172949992,
-0.0175931342,
-0.0269098934,
-0.0581782907,
0.032004524,
-0.0400872305,
0.0083410982,
-0.0390874073,
-0.0234288182,
0.0196927097,
-0.0085562076,
0.0278606433,
-0.0099628363,
-0.0211571623,
-0.0137400031,
-0.0287143365,
-0.0143480543,
-0.0261756163,
0.0282624587,
-0.0577936955,
0.0315915495,
-0.0023022133,
-0.018920172,
-0.0593740344,
0.0221089944,
0.0251348596,
-0.0261484589,
-0.0333546586,
0.0234131664,
-0.0087357862,
0.0224842597,
-0.0620683767,
-0.0672008321,
-0.0188521314,
-0.0068832524,
-0.0053598871,
-0.0710353777,
0.0422740057,
0.003384056,
0.0019834419,
-0.0299700536,
0.0093841441,
-0.0104168151,
-0.0393100828,
0.0299606379,
-0.0045219804,
-0.0228220318,
0.0177842565,
0.0098290099,
-0.0138530973,
0.0611790679,
0.0397400111,
0.0086590154,
0.0710545853,
0.047963459,
-0.0305807516,
-0.0041159284,
0.0238758884,
0.0025800897,
0.0436475724,
-0.0294407252,
0.0066838535,
0.0143867973,
0.0166100822,
-0.0210100152,
-0.0464979596,
-0.0233751927,
0.0144974962,
0.0138452388,
-0.005979531,
-0.0025075665,
0.0799774528,
-0.0042639128,
0.0113310972,
0.0586959347,
-0.006496164,
-0.008955162,
0.0364159979,
-0.0038137804,
0.0006214199,
-0.0285886675,
-0.0271339081,
0.005559464,
0.0007093503,
-0.030226944,
-0.0416676365,
-0.027237555,
0.0531312414,
0.0343246609,
-0.0090779606,
0.0964637175,
0.042609375,
-0.0552685149,
0.0338298939,
0.0085819401,
0.0206258669,
0.0123608904,
0.0191520844,
-0.0510059968,
-0.0266284179,
-0.0196891483,
0.0419545546,
0.0475748628,
0.0916624665,
-0.0729119033,
0.0388622843,
-0.0146832289,
0.0177904833,
-0.038085144,
0.0326400064,
0.0339092612,
-0.0138128018,
0.0052240621,
-0.0052091237,
0.0081774928,
-0.0000237685,
0.0355405286,
0.0150727108,
-0.0276736505,
-0.0660459101,
0.0147357965,
-0.0056595108,
0.012940973,
0.0042232783,
-0.0082915975,
0.0298130885,
-0.0405962467,
-0.0030836852,
0.0740588009,
-0.0169508159,
-0.0453078896,
0.0375694185,
-0.0583858527,
-0.0170349851,
0.0179307442,
-0.0252867956,
-0.0539144389,
0.0314349011,
-0.0111596081,
0.0059959544,
-0.0051478995,
-0.0231248792,
0.0038059987,
-0.0163024329,
0.0018703641,
0.0909228623,
0.055531349,
0.0127613656,
0.0011107035,
-0.038530197,
0.033645045,
-0.0277654156,
-0.0494105294,
0.038409166,
0.0090076728,
-0.0044139498,
0.0592034943,
-0.0869262516,
-0.0581103601,
0.0299640894,
-0.0718176886,
0.0516756698,
-0.0332678966,
0.0399083234,
0.0606943406,
-0.0163251776,
-0.011327886,
0.0004471507,
-0.0056019649,
-0.0513209663,
-0.0200710893,
-0.0104776146,
0.04502156,
0.0283065476,
0.0205863155,
-0.0271005295,
-0.0159218553,
-0.0730803758,
0.1039719433,
0.0151007641,
-0.0456313156,
-0.0466178581,
0.0196465496,
-0.0075585204,
0.0396091156,
-0.0165904164,
0.0297685955,
0.0095864963,
-0.0261556599,
-0.033554595,
0.0590717383,
0.0054758042,
0.0075904955,
0.0018156405,
-0.0482991859,
-0.0604693256,
0.0062820041,
0.0019002943,
0.0242181774,
-0.0274006501,
0.0105879279,
0.0256636459,
0.0432153381,
-0.0034562964,
0.0068773828,
-0.0345047042,
0.0083426945,
-0.0235060044,
0.0033453798,
-0.0002406597,
-0.0639077649,
0.0009813049,
0.0391311273,
-0.0411739945,
0.0423411205,
0.065815486,
-0.012097938,
0.0057859984,
-0.0307889786,
0.014702904,
-0.0396367759,
0.0748291314,
-0.0215627532,
0.0174463782,
0.0066825263,
-0.0695129335,
-0.0019705954,
0.0096296119,
0.0528036542,
0.0010998183,
0.0704170913,
-0.0429310612,
0.0250922851,
-0.025015451,
-0.006139697,
-0.0383366309,
-0.0493842922,
-0.0080241794,
-0.0042634336,
-0.0567670874,
0.0290727783,
-0.0616128743,
0.0135603473,
0.0019207876,
0.0376230329,
-0.0138746481,
0.0227274969,
-0.0189350471,
0.0774074867,
0.0071154539,
0.0096284244,
-0.0083062304,
0.011846168,
0.0301121678,
0.0586283058,
0.0173584577,
0.0221133363,
-0.0314486697,
0.0060106697,
-0.0086920327,
-0.0908199698,
-0.0149777839,
-0.0723981261,
0.0561494529,
-0.0790628493,
0.0065918611,
0.0763101131,
0.0344728455,
-0.0368627422,
-0.0146002918,
0.0040344046,
-0.0190017745,
0.0240967628,
0.0048757764,
-0.0573360063,
-0.0086086597,
-0.0223541893,
-0.0247107744,
-0.008989498,
-0.0654532313,
0.0022982964,
-0.0613207035,
-0.0049965526,
0.0054905857,
0.0041924994,
-0.0449565537,
-0.0445277318,
0.0441226177,
-0.0196432658,
-0.0309847798,
0.0223586354,
0.0143848425,
0.0026416886,
0.0061077727,
0.0202668682,
-0.0494651757,
0.0106979003,
-0.0460022613,
0.0247713923,
-0.0495117716,
0.0464332737,
-0.0013530036,
0.0207445752,
-0.0309781563,
-0.0805446282,
-0.0289769769,
0.016402347,
0.0909937471,
-0.002323661,
-0.0133106662,
-0.0092176115,
0.0420931503,
-0.001398435,
-0.0841617733,
0.0064966101,
0.0667666048,
0.0097065363,
-0.0101532275,
0.0197412409,
0.0092244558,
0.0268687066,
0.0582488403,
0.0177291147,
0.0369055346,
0.0031756209,
-0.017591536,
-0.0201294795,
-0.0707096457,
-0.0332643725,
0.0071984236,
0.0103848903,
-0.0248267557,
-0.0719759837,
-0.0414068177,
0.0029964005,
0.0248330832,
-0.0069151111,
-0.0034450237,
0.0323065966,
-0.0024649526,
-0.055514317,
0.0738580227,
-0.0128597319,
-0.0264271237,
0.0465352982,
0.0268483143,
0.031843368,
0.0325507671,
-0.0184177347,
0.0941439644,
0.0137486001,
-0.0726445988,
-0.0024620814,
-0.0454120748,
0.0230241176,
0.050820563,
-0.0261613782,
-0.003347412,
-0.0033452951,
-0.0005238518,
-0.0330165699,
-0.0110901007,
0.0034375309,
-0.0233223662,
-0.0195181482,
0.0306819975,
-0.0215436332,
0.0200418346,
-0.047511816,
0.0346458666,
-0.027200168,
0.0282506477,
0.0187226553,
-0.0157570783,
0.0267604813,
0.0046112989,
0.0100129545,
-0.0574179478,
-0.0169097688,
-0.0282581244,
-0.0043463432,
0.0064123683,
0.045984596,
-0.0148085551,
-0.0294035263,
-0.0306920093,
0.0304222386,
-0.0292158592,
0.0214453992,
-0.0364516564,
-0.0002479024,
0.0498909168,
0.0304574054,
-0.0292630736,
-0.0037473424,
-0.0496603958,
0.0042205523,
-0.0109615913,
0.0235678907,
-0.0618233979,
0.0221982915,
0.0270630382,
-0.025868943,
0.0057025803,
-0.0198097397,
-0.090594016,
0.0321962945,
-0.0032022621,
-0.0054253531,
0.0405756161,
-0.0847968534,
0.0760840997,
-0.0022681321,
-0.0354632139,
0.0159451179,
0.0047807982,
0.039673388,
0.0366495401,
0.0390852168,
0.0484887362,
-0.0273787528,
0.0235197227,
0.0494005308,
-0.0472050235,
0.0816842318,
0.0318047591,
-0.0384043753,
-0.0297822896,
-0.0602317862,
-0.0406838246,
-0.0017931524,
-0.0337568112,
-0.031262897,
-0.0421567038,
0.0103226453,
0.0367918126,
0.0312081408,
0.0182566326,
-0.0037124639,
0.0048658391,
0.041644305,
0.0679066479,
-0.0038140416,
-0.0233098324,
0.0396732241,
-0.0068642432,
0.0151300263,
-0.0169924349,
-5.150499028e-33,
-0.0463266969,
0.0116233462,
-0.0263739992,
0.0679856911,
-0.0096166814,
0.0361820273,
-0.0327150375,
0.0019473535,
-0.0094551723,
0.0461011603,
0.0468094945,
0.021352049,
0.020538561,
-0.0455296151,
-0.000658876,
-0.0501380377,
0.0223717708,
0.0131931873,
-0.0551189557,
0.0270378869,
0.0654944554,
-0.0077322838,
0.060868036,
-0.0655585676,
0.0717845187,
-0.0120118381,
0.0047881138,
0.0029432403,
0.0577694178,
0.0654078051,
0.0228750799,
0.0278275199,
0.0363309346,
-0.0453769155,
0.0012238626,
0.053129591,
-0.099078007,
-0.0302641112,
0.0615561269,
0.0074824966,
-0.0074158548,
-0.0471587554,
0.0258778445,
0.0184294786,
0.0448230952,
-0.0318924785,
0.0475704521,
-0.0178300086,
0.0366446823,
-0.0109505728,
-0.0692595541,
0.0312792584,
-0.0212132819,
0.0043892749,
0.0203359928,
0.0462772697,
0.0524732769,
0.02132833,
-0.0396188274,
0.0186945926,
-0.1079012901,
0.0251079332,
-0.0225986,
-0.0601307824,
-0.0516066886,
0.0636570081,
-0.0477970727,
-0.0157443471,
-0.0629367381,
0.018781988,
-0.0235561784,
0.0661697909,
0.0206828937,
0.0753371269,
-0.0022762483,
-0.0000363478,
-0.1007116958,
0.0274289623,
0.0296509638,
0.038805645,
-0.0338220559,
-0.0359264426,
0.0162853468,
0.0178421456,
-0.05244755,
-0.0503900386,
-0.0370779559,
0.0179446191,
-0.0240755845,
-0.0141758705,
0.009895049,
0.0645695031,
0.0164103042,
-0.0099948402,
0.0118411994,
0.0449195988,
-0.0175656173,
0.0283193439,
-0.0028755749,
0.0319968015,
-0.0052603958,
-0.0093677416,
0.0232242364,
0.0168214031,
0.058786016,
-0.0060532759,
0.0435969681,
0.0071347943,
-0.0216369275,
0.0051928293,
-0.023336174,
-0.0120816091,
-0.0537798181,
0.0117771421,
0.0442511067,
0.0467799678,
-0.0028416968,
-0.0087737823,
0.0070905704,
0.012722699,
-0.0032633308,
-0.0425944477,
0.0067023337,
0.0419179834,
-0.0274926517,
-0.0344855338,
0.0037705493,
0.0196775496,
0.0399528034,
-0.0207784027,
0.0068496135,
-0.0046190186,
2.186e-7,
0.034616638,
0.0041637276,
0.0536234081,
0.0108841844,
0.0131085804,
0.004844741,
-0.0208996795,
0.0612925291,
-0.0043866495,
-0.0574370101,
-0.0331961289,
0.0363403447,
0.0185611676,
0.0442647785,
-0.0801468417,
-0.0596973374,
-0.0133640338,
-0.0060335221,
-0.0622411631,
-0.009247154,
0.0442079045,
0.0345756635,
0.0425156541,
0.0206580628,
-0.0163166896,
-0.0550356917,
0.0442697667,
0.0060820528,
-0.0812718719,
0.0384359509,
0.0349245295,
0.0191139821,
-0.0345897712,
0.0560069941,
-0.0079497313,
0.036958281,
0.02381327,
0.0405256115,
-0.0094815902,
0.0061142612,
-0.0378742144,
-0.0475167222,
0.0255188756,
-0.0065524955,
0.0376659259,
0.012241276,
-0.0088500818,
-0.050556846,
-0.0344783291,
0.0339186862,
-0.0228914134,
0.0180278439,
-0.0217883419,
0.0370748863,
-0.0062115765,
0.0208273176,
-0.0055553121,
-0.0859487653,
-0.0509628132,
0.0276421364,
-0.0268085469,
-0.0445104539,
0.0436749458,
-0.0758764371,
0.0037158444,
-0.0447029583,
0.0055282391,
1.450689173e-34,
-0.008290261,
0.0417190678,
-0.0177508499,
-0.0110341515,
0.0465689749,
-0.0368687063,
-0.051288154,
-0.0080965785,
-0.0026229555,
-0.0264176652,
-0.0025031597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05591v1 | Accuracy of a Vision-Language Model on Challenging Medical Cases | 2023-11-09T18:48:02 | 2023-11-09T18:48:02 | Thomas Buckley, James A. Diao, Adam Rodman, Arjun K. Manrai | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Background: General-purpose large language models that utilize both text and
images have not been evaluated on a diverse array of challenging medical cases.
Methods: Using 934 cases from the NEJM Image Challenge published between 2005
and 2023, we evaluated the accuracy of the recently released Generative
Pre-trained Transformer 4 with Vision model (GPT-4V) compared to human
respondents overall and stratified by question difficulty, image type, and skin
tone. We further conducted a physician evaluation of GPT-4V on 69 NEJM
clinicopathological conferences (CPCs). Analyses were conducted for models
utilizing text alone, images alone, and both text and images.
Results: GPT-4V achieved an overall accuracy of 61% (95% CI, 58 to 64%)
compared to 49% (95% CI, 49 to 50%) for humans. GPT-4V outperformed humans at
all levels of difficulty and disagreement, skin tones, and image types; the
exception was radiographic images, where performance was equivalent between
GPT-4V and human respondents. Longer, more informative captions were associated
with improved performance for GPT-4V but similar performance for human
respondents. GPT-4V included the correct diagnosis in its differential for 80%
(95% CI, 68 to 88%) of CPCs when using text alone, compared to 58% (95% CI, 45
to 70%) of CPCs when using both images and text.
Conclusions: GPT-4V outperformed human respondents on challenging medical
cases and was able to synthesize information from both images and text, but
performance deteriorated when images were added to highly informative text.
Overall, our results suggest that multimodal AI models may be useful in medical
diagnostic reasoning but that their accuracy may depend heavily on context. | [
0.0427343622,
0.0708062798,
-0.0161298141,
-0.0192180779,
-0.015386804,
0.0290740225,
0.0257818326,
0.043144986,
0.0011180758,
-0.0459927879,
-0.0108727589,
-0.0678331405,
0.0172751695,
0.0544935279,
0.0174313076,
-0.1154164225,
-0.0087671606,
0.0077111991,
0.0158051886,
0.0151634142,
-0.0014785472,
-0.0010183975,
-0.0347473323,
0.0524155609,
-0.034595564,
-0.0065559447,
0.0170545429,
0.0024254546,
0.0198654216,
-0.0562014319,
-0.0470160618,
0.0541461483,
-0.0004831314,
-0.0063764746,
0.0000023143,
-0.0337279774,
0.0228778124,
0.0118334265,
0.0105235055,
-0.0399872065,
0.0591215901,
-0.0789830387,
-0.0033431195,
0.0131904306,
-0.0439343639,
-0.0404258221,
0.0523087978,
0.0771631673,
0.0458527207,
0.0616368651,
-0.0364361741,
-0.0203598775,
0.0583346449,
-0.0077078501,
0.0116750998,
-0.034452498,
0.0039767097,
0.034566544,
0.0208638031,
-0.0197136011,
-0.0203869306,
0.0683006048,
0.006243736,
0.0050780945,
-0.0180063732,
0.080398038,
-0.0161203295,
-0.0672177002,
-0.0118400464,
0.0762286708,
0.0107460171,
0.0142603461,
-0.0277661625,
0.0015162488,
-0.005767073,
0.03932973,
-0.0356022678,
0.0484005511,
-0.0164245106,
0.0000883237,
-0.0459672622,
0.0060851537,
0.0114274425,
-0.0056760879,
0.0057403445,
-0.0400113054,
0.0260863677,
0.012598983,
0.0156792924,
0.0032845943,
-0.046723526,
-0.0437149443,
0.0247408841,
0.0328561477,
-0.0329152085,
0.0178647656,
-0.0387580916,
-0.0481009334,
0.0483620055,
-0.0573079661,
0.0237622503,
0.0160802901,
-0.0584863834,
0.0393565297,
-0.0168043151,
0.0513699315,
-0.0489785932,
0.0620779023,
-0.0321706906,
0.0171857849,
-0.0191538706,
-0.0167085398,
-0.0261352994,
-0.0190438237,
-0.0328610018,
-0.0452909097,
-0.0542409644,
-0.0228126422,
0.0050606364,
-0.0108155636,
0.0276108962,
0.0496373884,
-0.0377354994,
-0.0006053938,
-0.0512550138,
0.0244184714,
0.014919281,
0.0151958112,
-0.0073963036,
-0.0400657095,
0.0416666865,
0.0353213847,
-0.0152898198,
0.0078651924,
0.0088999467,
0.0754673555,
-0.0265268087,
-0.0213507507,
0.0191593561,
-0.0155546125,
-0.0544531606,
-0.0493043363,
0.0228973869,
-0.0480087474,
0.0245825052,
0.0237273183,
0.0327837393,
-0.0492203236,
0.0070483619,
0.0306084473,
-0.0221135858,
0.0888939649,
-0.0202036705,
0.0158336833,
0.0460903533,
0.0388190746,
0.0057391687,
0.0095361853,
0.0400282666,
0.00094004,
0.0024389424,
-0.0503817163,
0.0335633978,
0.0074205128,
-0.0178038571,
-0.0322699733,
-0.0170292854,
-0.0195134375,
-0.0069880816,
0.0773783177,
-0.0036608302,
0.1109715104,
0.0046767094,
-0.0213188846,
0.0467689894,
0.0546561852,
0.0188076906,
0.0086690951,
0.0289415196,
-0.0430245437,
0.013974173,
0.0133168688,
-0.0199239478,
0.0334982388,
-0.0000523004,
-0.0113563044,
-0.0195474979,
0.0336891413,
-0.0259892885,
-0.0443512239,
-0.0597876869,
-0.0191307571,
-0.0007198236,
0.0019326203,
0.0312341526,
-0.0102253901,
-0.0609337091,
-0.0029186953,
0.0134961689,
-0.0396988206,
-0.0490502268,
-0.0527959019,
-0.0101672551,
0.059254948,
0.0477287211,
0.0020825095,
-0.0355945379,
0.008411929,
0.0091747846,
0.0587166287,
0.0346355997,
0.0254859347,
0.0004021437,
-0.0551919453,
-0.0076867999,
0.0376375653,
0.0134571437,
-0.0260185432,
-0.0235937145,
0.0222258102,
-0.0035475881,
-0.0080770925,
-0.0121045662,
0.0491104573,
-0.0113889789,
-0.007481446,
-0.0248179622,
-0.00055206,
0.0157894418,
-0.0052026655,
-0.0208019316,
0.0130356811,
0.0027910005,
0.0023345461,
-0.0213278383,
0.0441543087,
-0.0633458793,
-0.0180999432,
0.0273269508,
-0.086693339,
-0.0211277436,
-0.0028002823,
-0.0194757562,
-0.0183373746,
-0.0242824033,
-0.0837574601,
-0.0331217982,
-0.0295695849,
0.0118306838,
0.0514641032,
0.0067336042,
-0.0164724868,
0.0464775451,
-0.0155831072,
-0.0289573949,
0.0087249856,
-0.0385004729,
0.0098342281,
-0.0268674549,
-0.0384136848,
0.0311522074,
0.0211432166,
0.0197289567,
-0.0209200233,
0.018349871,
-0.0359690338,
-0.0167148206,
-0.1176640615,
-0.0322195217,
0.0231660865,
-0.0487151705,
0.0226686783,
-0.0121353026,
0.0034688939,
-0.0153621016,
-0.0298025124,
0.002280158,
0.0464974828,
0.023093449,
0.0225546155,
0.0406991765,
0.0212315004,
-0.0295765344,
-0.0106864544,
-0.0308232978,
0.0476684384,
0.0635046437,
-0.0082437461,
-0.0009020616,
0.0206263512,
-0.0336087719,
0.0262889657,
-0.0035899351,
-0.0363655724,
0.0333080888,
-0.0255600344,
0.0215864349,
0.0320459791,
0.0163551886,
0.0367704816,
0.0130649311,
0.0157816391,
-0.0109493323,
-0.0046106027,
-0.0043982984,
-0.0419988558,
0.0076658339,
-0.0834563747,
-0.0175727326,
0.0577766709,
0.0255888626,
0.0279634949,
-0.0642118528,
0.0234059393,
-0.0081242258,
-0.0178041123,
-0.030878067,
0.0019946317,
-0.0225366261,
0.0529541858,
-0.0058909277,
-0.0522099696,
0.0830837339,
-0.0149927232,
0.0262960996,
-0.0355058499,
0.0096545955,
-0.0250484888,
0.0495263971,
0.0334460065,
0.0403866284,
0.0300952252,
-0.0054028947,
-0.0455710441,
0.0221283678,
0.0072121155,
-0.0633501858,
0.0669142008,
-0.0401398875,
0.0079553686,
-0.0023056602,
-0.0295259021,
-0.0337564833,
-0.0029210094,
-0.0067291507,
-0.0161908716,
-0.0063697509,
0.0248861313,
-0.0447914116,
0.052993875,
0.0184870921,
0.051085595,
0.0239987336,
-0.0128934514,
0.005747275,
0.0488787889,
0.0287209507,
0.0446813032,
-0.0216836166,
-0.0378559753,
0.0133362012,
0.0667851418,
-0.0215603281,
0.0014751568,
-0.0523295961,
-0.0036050072,
-0.0109532457,
0.0294374991,
-0.0238160491,
0.0309371203,
0.0370522626,
-0.0462850109,
0.0210519657,
0.094872281,
0.0241617281,
-0.0662480146,
-0.0039795982,
0.0146154799,
-0.0437902585,
-0.021983441,
0.0084184436,
-0.0647777542,
-0.0300694052,
-0.0211897772,
0.0166572817,
-0.0124169439,
-0.0174905751,
0.0162659902,
-0.0286917258,
0.0591880605,
-0.0071356273,
-0.0038311018,
-0.0491304733,
0.003403493,
0.0035581577,
0.0037574219,
-0.0091168405,
-0.0352883041,
-0.0034049661,
0.0039044563,
0.0027702565,
-0.0372714549,
-0.072165221,
0.0221207384,
-0.0113160657,
-0.0056360541,
0.0516489595,
0.0402560458,
-0.0257458594,
-0.0683740377,
0.0065387394,
0.0264043827,
0.059921883,
-0.0017417107,
0.1011007428,
0.0059749349,
-0.003208745,
-0.0456455722,
0.0192010943,
-0.0045683081,
-0.027560018,
-0.0126859797,
0.0732912421,
-0.033353921,
-0.027671339,
-0.0817590728,
0.0195126217,
-0.0097966464,
0.0141297849,
-0.00313449,
-0.0144472076,
-0.0363197476,
0.0179153681,
0.1002360955,
-0.0310786217,
-0.0332190953,
0.0373550802,
-0.003762769,
-0.0384930819,
-0.0800466314,
-0.0150445607,
0.020851871,
0.0079505248,
0.0145472018,
-0.0327613652,
0.0206440277,
0.0301811341,
-0.0539087765,
0.0641755983,
0.0317082591,
0.0117340703,
-0.0538642667,
-0.0196670424,
0.0498050004,
-0.0183756053,
-0.0068377042,
0.0216064565,
-0.0135613149,
0.0159395821,
0.0043200399,
0.0633615032,
0.0177459456,
-0.030317599,
0.0173817314,
-0.0384661816,
0.015897708,
0.0451374985,
-0.0139893051,
0.0084957993,
-0.0093421284,
-0.0322986916,
-0.0151833706,
-0.007881863,
0.0139710223,
0.0275708623,
-0.0142456396,
0.0131761078,
-0.02096688,
-0.0344684646,
0.0198259503,
0.0342393778,
0.0769227892,
-0.0440605134,
-0.0076603638,
-0.0040008067,
-0.0112513062,
-0.0251211934,
0.0164216161,
-0.0377482511,
-0.0074094124,
0.0233585145,
0.0162865594,
-0.0141247166,
-0.0148498537,
-0.0663002506,
-0.0368086547,
-0.0448904261,
0.0464921594,
0.0454207137,
-0.029774975,
0.0230979044,
-0.0062785596,
0.0190276671,
-0.0061652963,
-0.0131906336,
0.0244650543,
0.0161249321,
0.1060274467,
-0.0009185908,
-0.0007502316,
0.0076377867,
0.0512822568,
-0.0114276959,
-0.0350690782,
-0.0280444436,
0.0335809402,
0.0419014543,
0.0094407164,
-0.0075453948,
-0.0282271784,
0.0036977681,
-0.0124319801,
0.0254049506,
-0.0017049008,
-0.0075306343,
0.0763403997,
-0.0076390398,
0.0298153497,
-0.0270486064,
0.076683335,
-0.0174019244,
0.0143663995,
-0.0202258527,
-0.0455790125,
-0.0483453535,
-0.0214681383,
0.0158651453,
-0.0108187506,
-0.0480244122,
0.0324696265,
-0.0579590201,
-0.0580642223,
0.0032071201,
-0.0019482654,
-0.0133669367,
-0.0152145773,
0.060810823,
0.0484222993,
0.0085244216,
-0.0356808193,
-0.0182753857,
0.0541869178,
-0.0305024702,
0.0194610208,
0.0301260073,
-6.037570411e-33,
-0.0205517039,
-0.0525671653,
0.0479740836,
-0.0156825688,
0.0030399216,
0.0371929854,
-0.0326222889,
0.0333092399,
-0.0022203766,
0.0405506827,
0.0022777086,
-0.0277127028,
0.0047612572,
0.0591193885,
-0.0092378547,
-0.0086193206,
0.0167647675,
-0.0080053434,
-0.0377982855,
0.003832039,
-0.042039454,
0.0031056092,
0.0291413646,
-0.0892673805,
-0.020309234,
0.017682815,
-0.0123081226,
-0.0387731083,
0.001780441,
0.0626997054,
-0.0377137028,
0.033455316,
0.0400493965,
-0.0092212874,
-0.0140423803,
0.016280476,
-0.0413848497,
-0.0062447647,
0.0157667901,
0.019561328,
-0.0946215019,
-0.0037030813,
0.0436838791,
-0.0435868911,
-0.0136224153,
-0.0269072112,
0.0542120486,
-0.0342546143,
0.01141416,
-0.0289397836,
-0.0358838849,
0.0376615413,
0.012719973,
-0.0143832359,
-0.00063613,
0.0244855043,
-0.0210862942,
0.0662898794,
-0.0485193208,
0.0218183808,
0.0284159258,
-0.0228636321,
0.057715103,
-0.0182721131,
-0.0298403166,
0.0344412625,
0.039937526,
-0.057086695,
-0.0834268555,
-0.0182937887,
-0.0255745165,
0.0511950217,
0.0767171234,
0.0494681783,
0.0170725714,
-0.0100130476,
-0.0390311554,
0.0500055812,
-0.1039189547,
0.0626010299,
0.0272552818,
-0.0230650585,
-0.0630873516,
0.0065485621,
-0.0122104408,
0.0113561042,
-0.0206000023,
-0.0400317274,
0.0440620072,
0.000286901,
0.0275812987,
0.0365272723,
0.0359016992,
-0.0147647932,
0.0094008502,
-0.0533779077,
0.0182105526,
0.0627505556,
-0.0461640172,
0.0069780773,
-0.0451235734,
-0.0118920431,
0.0696043819,
0.0248397086,
0.0572371334,
-0.0022084813,
0.0224560201,
-0.0159979276,
-0.0521119237,
-0.0098852096,
0.0152596692,
-0.0122779338,
-0.0038098253,
0.0291651562,
0.0231774114,
0.0324152261,
-0.0499091074,
0.0128715988,
-0.0248219315,
-0.005175049,
-0.0612773299,
-0.0674517974,
-0.0064053899,
-0.0109866289,
-0.0533793755,
0.0084221885,
-0.0359625518,
-0.0010197567,
0.0324999541,
-0.0589597896,
-0.0249052383,
0.0485352091,
2.939e-7,
0.093970187,
0.0586313829,
0.0060858731,
-0.0151201645,
0.025019845,
0.0247880146,
-0.0016414875,
-0.0053263758,
0.025446441,
-0.0210978761,
0.0180918854,
0.0370593257,
0.0022189312,
0.0410598181,
0.0079319142,
-0.0130536109,
-0.038185887,
-0.0173973609,
-0.0281236898,
0.0093857497,
0.0890206993,
0.0674824938,
-0.0717047304,
-0.0556852631,
0.0249421243,
-0.0257917121,
0.0838615373,
-0.0318477191,
0.0014958562,
0.0052671889,
0.0030680781,
0.0305721927,
0.0051870705,
0.0637936443,
-0.0231109206,
-0.0462980792,
0.0476131774,
0.0303948857,
-0.0652707517,
0.0129632289,
0.0134212198,
0.0449870713,
-0.0040578446,
-0.0808699355,
0.0675439239,
-0.0547801293,
-0.0334220901,
0.0024344367,
-0.0287183058,
-0.0071525462,
0.0707185641,
-0.0401167162,
-0.0441909991,
0.0203736611,
0.0394660905,
0.0014344444,
-0.0487270616,
-0.0794050768,
-0.0201209411,
0.0013734536,
-0.0278541781,
-0.0160978269,
0.0017089143,
-0.0710124671,
0.0211828407,
-0.0640743524,
-0.0217056945,
2.337199143e-34,
0.0436128341,
0.0138869248,
0.0263739415,
-0.0112585174,
0.0061642169,
0.0028285473,
0.0175834149,
0.0003777469,
0.0082144495,
-0.0706511959,
-0.0137519184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05584v1 | Zero-Shot Goal-Directed Dialogue via RL on Imagined Conversations | 2023-11-09T18:45:16 | 2023-11-09T18:45:16 | Joey Hong, Sergey Levine, Anca Dragan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful and general solutions
to many natural language tasks. However, many of the most important
applications of language generation are interactive, where an agent has to talk
to a person to reach a desired outcome. For example, a teacher might try to
understand their student's current comprehension level to tailor their
instruction accordingly, and a travel agent might ask questions of their
customer to understand their preferences in order to recommend activities they
might enjoy. LLMs trained with supervised fine-tuning or "single-step" RL, as
with standard RLHF, might struggle which tasks that require such goal-directed
behavior, since they are not trained to optimize for overall conversational
outcomes after multiple turns of interaction. In this work, we explore a new
method for adapting LLMs with RL for such goal-directed dialogue. Our key
insight is that, though LLMs might not effectively solve goal-directed dialogue
tasks out of the box, they can provide useful data for solving such tasks by
simulating suboptimal but human-like behaviors. Given a textual description of
a goal-directed dialogue task, we leverage LLMs to sample diverse synthetic
rollouts of hypothetical in-domain human-human interactions. Our algorithm then
utilizes this dataset with offline reinforcement learning to train an
interactive conversational agent that can optimize goal-directed objectives
over multiple turns. In effect, the LLM produces examples of possible
interactions, and RL then processes these examples to learn to perform more
optimal interactions. Empirically, we show that our proposed approach achieves
state-of-the-art performance in various goal-directed dialogue tasks that
include teaching and preference elicitation. | [
0.0813198835,
0.0429388322,
-0.004790986,
0.0228530746,
-0.0317633785,
0.0115492065,
0.0151817789,
-0.0320725888,
-0.0053920299,
-0.0599489771,
-0.0052022529,
-0.0275368895,
-0.0054759034,
0.0332732387,
0.0142484121,
-0.0628060922,
0.0253535639,
-0.0529395826,
0.0142900683,
0.0213098321,
0.0071957586,
0.0365345627,
-0.0312956758,
0.0646185279,
0.0008215021,
-0.0067787399,
-0.0545048192,
0.014973552,
0.0248524826,
-0.0118367691,
0.0180864967,
0.0335895009,
0.0610901378,
-0.0024150247,
0.0000018452,
-0.042987138,
-0.0083614327,
-0.0386278331,
-0.011022375,
-0.0485954061,
0.0472069085,
0.0031366423,
-0.0136290612,
0.0245609768,
-0.0442174599,
0.0018558203,
0.0260977205,
0.0645361468,
0.0540437028,
0.1046341062,
0.0152910631,
-0.0064465702,
-0.0179723259,
-0.0283391736,
0.0535467975,
-0.0422100239,
0.0011074874,
0.0114267245,
0.0021568206,
0.0118576158,
-0.0169660766,
-0.0024809695,
0.0332195088,
-0.0354113169,
0.0059021781,
0.0463535078,
-0.0286466796,
-0.0251889732,
0.0072317594,
0.1252752542,
-0.0333601683,
-0.0016695563,
0.0273764506,
-0.0160053093,
0.0180452671,
-0.0168090723,
-0.0194484107,
0.0420110784,
0.0132341413,
0.0124087743,
-0.0191396456,
0.0142899901,
0.0050579058,
0.028117802,
-0.0050638025,
0.0457108431,
-0.0309496354,
-0.0280005261,
0.0221325271,
-0.0220297053,
-0.0151700499,
-0.0736682564,
-0.0366778113,
0.0342880599,
-0.092765674,
0.0443047769,
-0.0454067737,
0.0430613421,
-0.0029934719,
-0.0005435098,
0.0516881533,
0.0488702096,
0.0423361398,
0.0288759749,
0.0228518229,
0.0333173759,
0.0125496462,
0.002034117,
-0.0299273673,
0.0303333476,
-0.047985319,
0.0156217106,
-0.0580942892,
0.0348707736,
-0.0601023398,
-0.0462172404,
-0.0296355132,
0.0390868858,
-0.0194193311,
0.0463435277,
0.0021725278,
0.0366509892,
-0.0625334457,
-0.0138148991,
-0.0586781092,
0.0173697397,
-0.0314588919,
0.0006872177,
0.0448021702,
-0.030307183,
-0.0036217968,
0.0228027944,
0.0179441758,
-0.0129367597,
-0.029648019,
0.0652569383,
-0.0274631269,
-0.0257965177,
-0.021773994,
-0.0547900014,
-0.008776363,
-0.0952953547,
0.0040823007,
-0.0345310308,
0.0330885388,
-0.0275794193,
-0.0161601231,
-0.0127682639,
0.0335303508,
0.0190288331,
-0.0170576051,
0.0603196733,
0.029327888,
0.0115551939,
0.0137355849,
0.0090760756,
-0.0213722344,
0.0711092874,
0.0415175743,
0.0300761107,
0.0167224668,
0.0103601841,
0.0271372925,
0.0268497467,
0.0196826886,
0.0189512521,
-0.0138867516,
0.0166344177,
-0.0145016769,
0.080454804,
0.0221695788,
0.0242863838,
-0.0707047358,
0.0131130628,
0.067459859,
0.0339030139,
-0.0117337005,
-0.0211041272,
0.0604476519,
0.0882029235,
-0.0323186703,
0.0043964554,
-0.0556554012,
0.0374552161,
0.0021908015,
0.0093085393,
0.021344848,
0.0075591262,
-0.026906386,
-0.0470704995,
0.0451869592,
-0.0117554497,
0.0254531857,
0.0126839755,
0.0212230645,
0.0390211083,
-0.0753786042,
-0.0059120781,
0.0192624517,
-0.0297950841,
-0.0051558795,
-0.034278255,
0.0396469012,
0.0852693692,
0.070940949,
-0.0094026672,
-0.0507017747,
-0.0480489992,
0.0034801259,
0.0929827318,
0.0360306688,
-0.0355805233,
0.0235750731,
-0.0596735142,
-0.0088782357,
-0.0007674979,
0.0051875548,
0.0204937384,
0.0200026818,
-0.007741191,
0.0150085902,
0.0052780006,
-0.0165449828,
0.0044298396,
-0.039175339,
-0.0067682527,
0.0302554462,
0.0060289167,
0.013648469,
-0.0117663415,
-0.025777841,
-0.0064599575,
-0.0016230186,
0.0016635261,
-0.0165758301,
0.0031922697,
-0.0500250868,
-0.0514887087,
0.0019904687,
-0.0107649649,
-0.0163513161,
0.0179263111,
-0.0287728608,
-0.0162319988,
-0.0044564935,
-0.0137860598,
0.0307012275,
-0.0185630918,
0.0232987199,
0.0383799747,
-0.0015741418,
-0.0293454956,
0.0264819805,
0.0058140857,
-0.0152343558,
0.0233564209,
-0.0050003668,
-0.0312652811,
-0.0563822314,
0.010528842,
-0.0117834704,
-0.0042058993,
0.0169334803,
0.0372542068,
0.0550661758,
-0.053822685,
-0.0367770381,
-0.060293328,
-0.0150147248,
-0.0146818841,
-0.0189328641,
0.0224072076,
0.0107629178,
-0.0057020928,
-0.0216706246,
-0.0467086881,
0.013253714,
0.0395019576,
-0.0227732267,
0.0633686632,
0.0130048878,
-0.0220826436,
-0.044984825,
0.036267031,
0.016899284,
0.0204431005,
-0.0022617034,
0.038851887,
-0.0447618812,
0.0193556529,
-0.0509707741,
0.0333068706,
-0.0232868604,
-0.0457763597,
-0.0061143222,
-0.0252500121,
0.0171044674,
0.0874831304,
0.0440642349,
0.0367947072,
0.0316770375,
-0.0261425152,
-0.0888316631,
0.0493637398,
-0.0342346318,
-0.0072234864,
-0.0605404191,
-0.0015372686,
0.0296982974,
0.0283463448,
-0.0083942609,
0.030935809,
-0.0565105155,
0.032070104,
0.0393234305,
-0.0589517802,
-0.0192704853,
0.0222256668,
-0.0347672515,
0.0440172069,
-0.0149441641,
-0.026914509,
0.0729704425,
-0.0088746902,
-0.0279341191,
-0.0402501523,
-0.0018607739,
-0.0137912519,
0.0173652694,
0.0070528365,
0.0255446956,
0.0221514311,
0.0088102464,
-0.0400934629,
-0.0257215444,
0.0250671674,
-0.0170200095,
0.0492190495,
-0.0577152967,
-0.0024859682,
0.0074567106,
-0.0404117517,
-0.0713685602,
-0.0438135415,
0.0139663974,
-0.0340284072,
-0.0091936765,
-0.030989131,
-0.0603611432,
-0.0022647963,
0.0212470479,
0.0478184819,
-0.0306538269,
-0.0268376041,
-0.0303224325,
0.0261685494,
0.1004488394,
0.0131166065,
-0.021022277,
-0.0042058262,
0.0772986785,
0.02256082,
0.0113129718,
-0.0024774959,
-0.0128498022,
-0.0170082226,
-0.001577323,
-0.0195032954,
0.0152571928,
0.0660428181,
0.0390865952,
-0.0458399951,
-0.0303848498,
0.1298759133,
0.0323882774,
-0.0525304414,
0.008296174,
-0.0094806431,
0.0672245473,
-0.0197401755,
0.0508639589,
-0.0729835629,
-0.0298053026,
-0.0022575441,
0.0021182438,
-0.0363308713,
-0.0508715957,
-0.0278214999,
-0.1355980784,
0.0450904816,
0.0042734253,
-0.0338286012,
0.0170766655,
0.0008297027,
-0.0076172538,
0.0018244642,
0.0398963131,
0.0057310644,
0.001975999,
0.006091807,
-0.0224703029,
0.0131526468,
-0.0343923196,
0.0229986217,
-0.0160901546,
0.0583205856,
0.0789846554,
0.0477335677,
0.0344908945,
0.007889322,
0.014679593,
0.0527411476,
-0.001649241,
-0.0052063284,
0.0516142994,
-0.0334449969,
-0.0100577818,
-0.006200687,
0.0618636645,
-0.0251158811,
-0.0113239652,
0.0222598687,
0.0233470798,
-0.0373777039,
-0.0014944439,
0.0081952577,
0.051878456,
0.0517447926,
0.0601128526,
0.0062078633,
-0.0816442221,
-0.0472989529,
-0.0153744984,
-0.0188167412,
-0.0454388894,
-0.0254526101,
-0.0159670059,
0.004634968,
0.0185917746,
-0.0661279857,
-0.0803923681,
0.0168568678,
0.0394377448,
-0.0130747408,
-0.0388200432,
0.0490465648,
0.0113358097,
0.0105979657,
0.0068125064,
-0.0513079762,
0.0216229819,
-0.0406183228,
-0.0130811837,
0.0255367886,
-0.0678978041,
-0.0009032484,
-0.0021447043,
-0.0570199825,
-0.0614974089,
-0.0512698293,
0.0484622195,
0.0207113177,
0.1108499318,
-0.0034390443,
-0.0289113577,
0.0039058703,
0.001683137,
-0.0414284132,
0.0114577245,
0.0069163055,
0.0774794668,
0.0047546504,
0.0531246923,
-0.0211376492,
0.0285554938,
-0.012972123,
0.0382960476,
-0.0365419462,
-0.0519647896,
0.0157990586,
-0.0421597734,
0.0083922278,
-0.0051801177,
0.0110255191,
-0.0103896353,
0.0240002517,
-0.0228197537,
-0.0433840193,
-0.0719566047,
-0.005326238,
0.0248358697,
0.0042669959,
0.0182844829,
-0.0247387476,
-0.0464481302,
0.0471655056,
-0.0045809788,
-0.0391190015,
0.0121084871,
-0.0106816459,
0.0339688249,
-0.0135920476,
-0.0076604751,
0.0310011208,
0.0052953279,
0.0391806066,
0.0234074313,
0.1160765067,
0.0320071429,
-0.0216408204,
0.0025719746,
0.0026190288,
-0.032164637,
-0.0361537039,
-0.0113941086,
0.0237780102,
0.0294858124,
0.0327518322,
0.0436164625,
-0.0475646295,
0.0217027124,
-0.010328792,
0.0457532257,
-0.0265188087,
-0.0593391806,
0.0407773592,
0.0367548205,
-0.0171854962,
0.0211472567,
0.0554981083,
0.0110047143,
0.0179357547,
0.0033085537,
0.0180131234,
-0.0575910024,
-0.0274576116,
0.0204651579,
0.0273165163,
0.0042156284,
0.0175537188,
-0.0538929403,
-0.0433200002,
-0.0247080978,
0.0234760027,
-0.0244058091,
-0.0403972045,
0.0514183454,
0.0131764617,
-0.0344314873,
0.0050702915,
-0.0671869442,
-0.0178718511,
-0.0251608472,
-0.0322563015,
-0.0488553122,
-5.699722315e-33,
-0.0244395733,
-0.0493587106,
0.0534650125,
-0.0038263297,
-0.0602521673,
-0.0229254887,
-0.0372934341,
0.0013955388,
-0.0100737279,
0.0171325859,
-0.0075715329,
0.002321067,
0.002724716,
0.0574526452,
-0.0255303588,
-0.0116592627,
0.0275165569,
-0.0173846669,
-0.0485304296,
0.0656936765,
0.0190254599,
-0.0103850402,
-0.0089716669,
-0.0383583903,
0.003142145,
-0.0206327047,
-0.0419667251,
0.0622001067,
-0.0017970613,
0.0487599485,
-0.0102045955,
0.0015647508,
0.0075344224,
-0.0498814695,
-0.0112209124,
0.0302565005,
-0.0439891517,
-0.0078412388,
0.0167009365,
-0.007622364,
-0.0516948476,
-0.0109247798,
-0.0002771397,
-0.0124050044,
0.024310343,
0.0022805044,
0.0160146561,
-0.0080310497,
-0.0275363345,
0.0126042068,
-0.0727631375,
0.0044974419,
-0.0249626283,
-0.0695970878,
-0.0012693999,
0.0692747757,
-0.0100451978,
-0.0060400651,
-0.0158551522,
0.0435761549,
0.0117927697,
-0.0055308482,
0.0424807034,
0.0209084116,
0.0045208721,
0.0488135479,
0.0079441071,
0.006873678,
-0.0209136195,
-0.0044312812,
0.0028111248,
0.0398854241,
-0.0453234278,
0.0745640621,
0.0000317241,
0.0204780195,
-0.0197885875,
-0.0004869976,
0.024980573,
0.0305365305,
0.0277244523,
-0.0131476177,
-0.0363326184,
-0.0160077047,
-0.0535260774,
0.0175894182,
-0.0063953404,
-0.0478471592,
0.0528192148,
0.0554996766,
0.0010752276,
-0.0455580913,
0.0289010555,
-0.0211177785,
-0.0109329401,
0.0415423028,
-0.0521116704,
0.0057587991,
-0.0277905576,
-0.0092535866,
-0.0613897294,
-0.0402624533,
0.0496944487,
-0.0280792136,
-0.028809024,
0.0407309607,
-0.0020288583,
0.008203485,
-0.0360831954,
0.0065283352,
-0.0344471149,
0.0601824336,
-0.0350545868,
0.0521272682,
0.012506444,
-0.0248973761,
-0.0613188781,
0.0807137787,
-0.0165791679,
-0.0531785786,
-0.0154463174,
-0.0049140593,
0.000531823,
0.0021330381,
-0.0524441116,
0.0034512267,
-0.0199665483,
-0.0172141269,
0.0331002958,
-0.041698277,
-0.0021593613,
0.0125784753,
2.601e-7,
-0.0597689785,
0.0217160527,
0.0191717111,
0.0525329113,
0.0239261612,
0.0692477524,
-0.004747571,
0.0265680589,
0.0217737015,
-0.0177978091,
0.0300357975,
0.0316435024,
0.0472149849,
-0.0128138606,
-0.0889675468,
-0.0246641096,
-0.0407555513,
-0.0331405289,
-0.0403064452,
-0.0422730967,
0.04032721,
0.0664821193,
0.0278776139,
0.0068395152,
0.0270166863,
0.008577453,
0.0569504388,
-0.0376020223,
-0.0421595015,
0.0185044799,
-0.0257375296,
-0.0174159519,
-0.0153958322,
0.004078445,
0.0130104367,
0.0114924088,
-0.0396628678,
0.0980274528,
0.0051142499,
-0.0458077118,
-0.0095493011,
0.0182027575,
0.0097901858,
-0.0225059986,
0.047870215,
-0.0968587101,
-0.009440477,
0.0174522977,
-0.0001026804,
-0.0088175805,
-0.0258873459,
-0.0314741358,
-0.0263600368,
0.0198562965,
0.0319925696,
0.0186963789,
0.016936684,
-0.0496930778,
-0.0001120038,
-0.0061488962,
-0.0461290032,
-0.0494275317,
-0.03328247,
0.0218677446,
-0.007794953,
-0.0523010567,
-0.0070846207,
2.280147948e-34,
0.029837979,
0.0102073289,
0.0025386387,
0.0172774792,
0.0403998122,
0.0242567416,
0.005757466,
0.0054347273,
0.0643022731,
-0.0728098676,
-0.0304200761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05553v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05553v3 | Removing RLHF Protections in GPT-4 via Fine-Tuning | 2023-11-09T17:54:59 | 2024-04-05T23:30:56 | Qiusi Zhan, Richard Fang, Rohan Bindu, Akul Gupta, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Daniel Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) have increased in their capabilities, so does
their potential for dual use. To reduce harmful outputs, produces and vendors
of LLMs have used reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF). In tandem,
LLM vendors have been increasingly enabling fine-tuning of their most powerful
models. However, concurrent work has shown that fine-tuning can remove RLHF
protections. We may expect that the most powerful models currently available
(GPT-4) are less susceptible to fine-tuning attacks. In this work, we show the
contrary: fine-tuning allows attackers to remove RLHF protections with as few
as 340 examples and a 95% success rate. These training examples can be
automatically generated with weaker models. We further show that removing RLHF
protections does not decrease usefulness on non-censored outputs, providing
evidence that our fine-tuning strategy does not decrease usefulness despite
using weaker models to generate training data. Our results show the need for
further research on protections on LLMs. | [
0.031326279,
0.0726532564,
-0.0076849456,
0.0280847643,
-0.0515708029,
-0.0137497801,
0.0052005299,
0.017855661,
-0.0065059224,
-0.0399157405,
-0.0164521132,
-0.0095630363,
0.0018158261,
-0.002442868,
0.0684047788,
-0.0264594927,
0.052769687,
-0.0641423464,
-0.0113185225,
-0.0355648287,
-0.0200914796,
0.0026255629,
0.0203043614,
0.023993196,
0.0326894596,
-0.0088351844,
-0.0063698166,
0.0101992916,
0.0252244435,
-0.0034220628,
0.0112359067,
0.0518132709,
0.0219232086,
0.0811443403,
0.0000020839,
-0.0265674349,
-0.0285753738,
0.0437209792,
-0.0231374744,
0.0628132522,
0.0225585867,
-0.0367626064,
-0.0403028615,
0.037480291,
-0.0080752857,
-0.02359147,
0.0297342688,
0.0616002269,
0.0435224622,
0.1074536964,
0.0018950936,
-0.0281626042,
0.053688027,
-0.0422535352,
0.0016165426,
-0.0402471907,
0.031806685,
-0.0394930132,
0.0123044001,
0.0098568331,
-0.0138374167,
0.0005021123,
0.010403486,
0.0203634612,
-0.0846538544,
0.0132852169,
-0.0682069212,
-0.00670968,
-0.0053515206,
0.0357403606,
-0.0683966652,
-0.0399822593,
0.0107268114,
-0.0181269124,
-0.0041826214,
0.0069109243,
0.0042471499,
0.0466219373,
-0.003272152,
0.01767876,
0.0068307542,
-0.0419968106,
0.0596165434,
0.0025047404,
0.0026108178,
0.060138531,
0.0439406633,
-0.0473519638,
0.0034959193,
-0.028709285,
-0.0233626012,
-0.0250989944,
-0.0483041815,
-0.0305595249,
0.0189703591,
0.0095498618,
-0.0900151879,
0.0169773288,
0.0386729911,
-0.0253129322,
-0.0135744698,
0.0434134863,
0.0141563937,
-0.0120043047,
-0.0263270494,
0.0277475622,
-0.05835253,
0.0551052652,
0.0579868332,
0.035628207,
-0.0200802051,
-0.003788691,
-0.0049479101,
0.0564094372,
-0.0127758607,
0.0113232872,
-0.0697125345,
0.0196369682,
-0.0303968508,
0.047990948,
-0.037096303,
-0.03977542,
-0.0305571947,
0.0059064259,
0.0232398156,
-0.0293188579,
-0.0042065601,
-0.0137017574,
-0.0307444073,
-0.0845351592,
-0.0110744741,
-0.0000651087,
-0.0288789682,
-0.0525103733,
-0.0027927796,
0.1016909927,
0.0284789521,
-0.0377624109,
-0.0211047009,
-0.0664570853,
0.0012568221,
-0.0615993217,
-0.0085632671,
-0.0441638567,
-0.0507702045,
-0.0313524418,
-0.0008610532,
-0.0456359237,
-0.0116327843,
-0.0022186786,
-0.0589974709,
0.0685977861,
0.0087592527,
-0.0232026149,
-0.0048938505,
0.011899082,
-0.0140430462,
0.0545599535,
-0.0076365666,
0.0081889946,
0.0359180458,
-0.039729055,
0.0498988703,
0.0388114117,
0.0309684556,
0.044381991,
-0.0298487376,
0.0045634583,
0.0239056926,
-0.0207570661,
0.0095361145,
0.0754432604,
-0.031519562,
-0.0554204732,
0.0965137482,
0.0607751682,
-0.0199584477,
0.056291014,
-0.0182628427,
0.0198201649,
0.0049175778,
0.0275788568,
-0.0882131979,
-0.027666349,
-0.0890529677,
-0.0060290815,
0.0213054102,
0.0130861197,
-0.0111607099,
0.0155940857,
0.0077134576,
-0.01449221,
0.0231183358,
0.0128421644,
0.0423352979,
-0.0072971657,
-0.0254467782,
0.0076712775,
0.0341526605,
-0.0393157862,
-0.0201434642,
-0.0911018103,
0.0094159208,
0.0203917678,
0.0749188438,
-0.0250775665,
0.0211500078,
-0.0408374071,
-0.0298013519,
0.0585267134,
0.034937121,
0.0462396219,
0.0331736915,
-0.0288597383,
-0.0029349471,
-0.0138021186,
0.0182634145,
0.0221161302,
0.0442201942,
-0.0043297582,
0.0046263081,
0.0228201896,
-0.0527707823,
0.0037777431,
0.0498008169,
-0.0496371984,
0.0146741327,
0.0164444037,
0.0298595671,
0.0002094065,
-0.0408487394,
0.0161821283,
0.0321235284,
0.0314546414,
0.0225904211,
-0.0555293076,
-0.0186534021,
0.0138955675,
0.021734735,
-0.0130923372,
0.0171034951,
0.0665026605,
-0.0364036486,
-0.0109101227,
0.0512864105,
-0.0185149517,
0.0550493039,
-0.016389912,
0.0171690527,
-0.0273505151,
0.0253212973,
-0.0233511925,
0.0151894819,
0.0176290926,
-0.0098709911,
-0.0423370302,
-0.0047720764,
0.0235558525,
-0.0669488907,
-0.0582914688,
0.0250717513,
-0.0289696511,
0.0397149771,
0.0336827226,
0.0210645124,
-0.0053080101,
-0.0071810554,
0.0028501102,
0.0071206014,
-0.0250495709,
0.030105805,
0.0023882147,
0.0034414576,
-0.0370289236,
-0.0418760739,
-0.0136835575,
-0.0473670959,
-0.0159179401,
0.0286133625,
0.0157870725,
-0.0102931354,
-0.0398836881,
-0.0192950685,
-0.0346841514,
0.0064340071,
0.0362353623,
-0.0182506815,
-0.0032454832,
-0.0245922804,
0.0290979296,
-0.0151596181,
0.0540059544,
0.0072682365,
-0.0619990602,
0.0355712622,
-0.0007621762,
-0.0116688451,
0.046450343,
0.0255150255,
0.0294260867,
0.0541592911,
0.0322489999,
-0.0408212729,
0.0143233743,
-0.0111683551,
-0.0992933214,
-0.0399402417,
0.0272221696,
0.0089241788,
0.033506006,
0.0238715783,
-0.0089543238,
-0.0799300671,
0.0250658281,
0.0062820241,
-0.0228054561,
-0.0019438331,
-0.0111124301,
-0.0618263334,
-0.0032941555,
-0.0120952828,
-0.0976520032,
0.0661034063,
-0.0212921407,
0.034212824,
-0.0266372804,
-0.0354452506,
0.0193553288,
0.005267506,
0.0152048599,
0.0334324241,
0.0468266681,
-0.0228971448,
-0.0268066414,
-0.037801981,
0.0572334826,
-0.0283586867,
0.0295045823,
-0.0309468564,
-0.0016081355,
-0.0348952897,
-0.0540002212,
-0.0193596371,
-0.0504395701,
0.0137820104,
-0.0072965203,
0.0351255909,
-0.0553337596,
0.0217363983,
-0.000232802,
0.039514713,
0.030124668,
-0.0292932801,
-0.0122240968,
-0.0209567025,
-0.0058627496,
0.0504412241,
-0.0642908141,
-0.0065096645,
-0.0244510844,
-0.0026973668,
0.0368748978,
0.0502711385,
-0.0059386538,
-0.0083871186,
0.0250467155,
0.0382496007,
-0.0255452301,
-0.0159353521,
0.0630311742,
0.0432693958,
-0.0369298197,
-0.0013598684,
0.0587772392,
-0.0007231244,
-0.0679860339,
0.0089122821,
0.0211905967,
0.0581667013,
-0.0018640572,
0.0168008897,
-0.080943808,
0.0019545788,
0.0302627776,
0.0730147511,
-0.040790081,
-0.0154465279,
0.000727875,
-0.1181468964,
0.0449368656,
0.0414673388,
-0.0568791926,
-0.0305923205,
-0.0110965595,
0.0010979824,
0.0043347091,
0.0452068709,
-0.0205121972,
-0.016170742,
-0.0000460139,
0.0239398442,
-0.028488012,
-0.0456265472,
0.0167068802,
-0.0392690226,
0.0486410446,
0.0749940723,
-0.0127989724,
-0.0320441015,
-0.0112433471,
0.0332511142,
0.0019571234,
-0.0302409139,
0.0074047605,
0.0292760264,
-0.0005091905,
-0.0309858248,
-0.0020269081,
0.058302816,
0.046586398,
-0.0177974887,
0.0213724524,
0.0405482389,
-0.0197893679,
-0.0114484206,
0.0106978072,
-0.0165745541,
0.0068095718,
0.0635464564,
0.0145623144,
-0.038684383,
-0.0514773279,
-0.0776411369,
0.0186853372,
-0.0473213382,
-0.0336889885,
-0.0159910508,
0.020641394,
-0.0277081579,
-0.0068638441,
0.0033251331,
-0.0282322709,
0.0125149591,
0.0202853139,
0.0156695489,
0.0178187434,
0.0314261504,
-0.017342845,
-0.0332661867,
-0.0529948846,
0.0276868343,
-0.0891269594,
0.0219522808,
-0.0203653369,
-0.0192330126,
-0.0023593181,
0.0177017804,
-0.0421334952,
-0.1043790951,
0.0038358727,
0.0634646565,
0.0338336453,
0.0295247883,
-0.0221058335,
-0.084499009,
0.0590273105,
0.0324175619,
-0.0405021757,
0.0411517583,
0.0944651365,
-0.0335459113,
0.0003823637,
0.0404655449,
-0.0360379033,
-0.0229028892,
0.0778033659,
-0.0090040127,
-0.0026949565,
-0.0098009035,
0.0088570705,
0.0502209589,
0.0519469865,
-0.0418410674,
0.0269520823,
0.0175346341,
0.0291959811,
-0.0234809089,
0.0065351324,
0.0096906526,
0.0213334095,
0.0404792018,
-0.0065833479,
-0.0151711879,
-0.0382761844,
0.0348897502,
0.0638272464,
-0.0319218859,
0.0476275645,
-0.0156459268,
0.0166816004,
0.0577047765,
-0.0051696403,
-0.0169928055,
0.0475405529,
0.0150794517,
0.025095569,
-0.0116376476,
0.0539091229,
0.0103392787,
0.0060715191,
-0.0080341063,
0.0343304463,
-0.0582880527,
-0.0600640662,
-0.0103821158,
0.0191654749,
0.0337447748,
0.026124943,
0.016497273,
-0.023621086,
-0.0259548388,
-0.0366885141,
-0.0067526246,
0.0004457627,
-0.0120565379,
0.0127548398,
0.0073530623,
-0.025260115,
0.02140682,
0.0560891442,
0.0582361855,
0.0751076043,
0.0129519198,
-0.0271192323,
-0.026008822,
-0.048733253,
0.0244925059,
0.0104546463,
-0.0299034379,
-0.0199113451,
-0.0599737056,
-0.0804778039,
-0.0486092418,
0.0064439359,
0.0315616094,
-0.00735289,
-0.0178450812,
0.007971365,
-0.0157670137,
0.0003706307,
-0.075439252,
-0.0111306068,
0.0279312953,
-0.0280016139,
0.0243621189,
-6.264000745e-33,
0.0060605197,
0.0108423475,
-0.0401001386,
0.0056552882,
0.0172092486,
-0.01515406,
-0.0106406156,
-0.0201048907,
-0.0200613644,
-0.0305423178,
-0.0118362373,
-0.0199601427,
0.0115360012,
0.0443460606,
-0.0296466667,
-0.0206470545,
0.0212314017,
-0.0166917033,
-0.0504896007,
0.0486488417,
0.0440517999,
-0.0020683738,
0.0356705226,
-0.031660594,
0.0006330054,
-0.0020601982,
-0.0550420955,
-0.0039627892,
-0.0954317525,
0.0702004135,
-0.0084739029,
0.0335139371,
-0.0096891709,
-0.057648737,
0.0020989864,
0.0254833028,
-0.0322919451,
-0.0083308714,
-0.0000195065,
-0.0271183997,
0.0148558393,
-0.0417289771,
0.0438415073,
0.0035409725,
-0.0316974483,
0.0002023114,
-0.0303723123,
-0.0139949275,
-0.051805269,
-0.0212163441,
-0.016038904,
0.0289626066,
-0.0013620207,
0.0345442444,
0.0368796997,
-0.0146642225,
0.0108447215,
-0.0003959999,
-0.0397653505,
0.0490002818,
0.0652412698,
0.0203700904,
0.0463437103,
0.0224971753,
0.0061785108,
0.0265818145,
-0.0078687929,
-0.015202539,
0.019217452,
-0.0164680686,
0.0221127812,
0.0273297336,
0.0265788715,
0.0672157034,
0.0415411405,
-0.0426805466,
-0.0438592769,
-0.015816668,
0.0049068821,
0.0484404303,
0.053483773,
0.0205248091,
-0.0960117206,
-0.0253589395,
-0.0379992165,
-0.024716353,
-0.0247489661,
-0.0334075205,
0.0205247514,
0.0237384085,
-0.0141090704,
0.0178930797,
0.0155078173,
-0.0367680639,
-0.0007380443,
0.0400566757,
-0.0315515511,
-0.0249592178,
-0.0272889473,
-0.0194710642,
-0.0146475732,
-0.0307730976,
-0.0003113026,
-0.0514818542,
0.0207001455,
-0.0259816106,
0.0337619297,
0.0666105077,
-0.0976050422,
0.0049544582,
-0.0238072947,
0.0693476498,
0.0347955376,
0.0308420584,
0.021784192,
-0.0376210622,
0.0321638025,
-0.0029132676,
0.0059450259,
-0.0386938527,
-0.0354062691,
0.0436572507,
-0.0096051842,
0.0085550966,
0.0190161821,
0.0229822695,
0.0322537608,
0.0704646856,
0.0552814268,
-0.039550636,
-0.0059656496,
-0.020608861,
2.942e-7,
0.0034556976,
0.0074303667,
0.0399570763,
0.0087794997,
0.0206214152,
0.0802726224,
-0.0099458629,
0.0754391029,
-0.0156383011,
0.0299896486,
-0.0053707105,
-0.013312717,
0.0551549159,
0.0004797722,
-0.0321034864,
0.0187261868,
-0.0769516379,
0.0090395575,
-0.0661648512,
-0.0163468756,
0.0407630354,
0.0982468426,
0.0340171643,
-0.0118762664,
-0.0074386527,
-0.0369592905,
0.0331602693,
-0.0365919061,
-0.0136591699,
-0.0167254303,
0.0295142941,
0.0603364259,
0.0080253035,
0.0193890445,
-0.0441276468,
-0.0024008318,
-0.0430970863,
0.0758917853,
0.0200756751,
-0.0213480629,
-0.0261579286,
-0.012266973,
0.0025552951,
-0.0697551519,
0.0559674613,
-0.0063577318,
-0.020498218,
0.0009129409,
-0.0098862881,
-0.0622786023,
0.0213438626,
-0.0572497845,
0.0048950999,
-0.0090966215,
-0.0049814228,
0.0193253737,
0.0163834672,
-0.0770497173,
-0.0121626817,
0.0010710424,
-0.0092434604,
-0.0372968614,
-0.0230091028,
0.0384814776,
-0.0013154611,
-0.0099395001,
0.011803993,
2.916016923e-34,
0.0187380482,
-0.0582137294,
0.0161215402,
-0.0131329484,
0.0395109653,
0.0122360159,
0.0135201951,
0.0289917681,
0.0168073047,
-0.0331281386,
-0.0246051382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05552v1 | The Iron(ic) Melting Pot: Reviewing Human Evaluation in Humour, Irony and Sarcasm Generation | 2023-11-09T17:50:23 | 2023-11-09T17:50:23 | Tyler Loakman, Aaron Maladry, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human evaluation is often considered to be the gold standard method of
evaluating a Natural Language Generation system. However, whilst its importance
is accepted by the community at large, the quality of its execution is often
brought into question. In this position paper, we argue that the generation of
more esoteric forms of language - humour, irony and sarcasm - constitutes a
subdomain where the characteristics of selected evaluator panels are of utmost
importance, and every effort should be made to report demographic
characteristics wherever possible, in the interest of transparency and
replicability. We support these claims with an overview of each language form
and an analysis of examples in terms of how their interpretation is affected by
different participant variables. We additionally perform a critical survey of
recent works in NLG to assess how well evaluation procedures are reported in
this subdomain, and note a severe lack of open reporting of evaluator
demographic information, and a significant reliance on crowdsourcing platforms
for recruitment. | [
0.0777656138,
0.0198566541,
-0.0163315572,
0.0073630088,
-0.0220785867,
0.0152067738,
0.0408087112,
0.018069936,
0.0488542952,
-0.032163512,
-0.0250324402,
0.0013822177,
0.0106136464,
0.0120896073,
0.0227960646,
-0.0403809883,
-0.034263622,
0.0224640295,
0.022478098,
-0.0351000503,
-0.0036397993,
0.0238742381,
-0.0158985108,
0.052082371,
0.0152427796,
0.0293981135,
0.0365199745,
0.0548800416,
0.0408021696,
-0.0151675316,
-0.0183060691,
0.0391729437,
-0.0670885518,
-0.006640424,
0.0000017334,
-0.0529634655,
0.0349330083,
-0.0199827757,
-0.0102775693,
0.0192369018,
0.0753043219,
0.0194924809,
-0.0480177775,
0.0057081515,
-0.0355346948,
0.0345530659,
0.0719831139,
-0.0189556666,
0.0788708702,
0.0400641374,
0.0044858628,
0.015797291,
-0.0642612651,
-0.0211195257,
-0.0118771037,
0.0071799993,
-0.0018503539,
-0.0193349682,
0.0068228235,
-0.0251886081,
-0.0333002396,
0.0162562244,
-0.0010175892,
0.0045604524,
-0.0153517388,
0.0224346574,
-0.0591310821,
-0.0274443347,
-0.0117604639,
0.0294409487,
0.0521454513,
0.020190658,
-0.0218766592,
0.0460521877,
-0.0033671188,
-0.033097934,
-0.0050094854,
0.0317193978,
-0.0030134146,
-0.0194154903,
0.0082723107,
0.0610492565,
-0.031328287,
0.0418466739,
0.071963869,
0.0002414686,
0.006292223,
0.0056776674,
-0.0160144847,
0.0139718661,
-0.0452893861,
-0.0620840006,
0.0502217151,
0.0184037853,
0.0036404836,
0.0156903081,
-0.0122122606,
-0.0337821878,
0.0576958992,
-0.0348347463,
0.0019914457,
0.0294181071,
-0.0189414266,
0.0420107357,
-0.0010828516,
0.0224194676,
0.0178214964,
0.0255600959,
-0.0573334098,
0.0042574732,
-0.0163299646,
0.006892778,
-0.0234146304,
-0.0135157611,
0.0054076514,
0.012942262,
-0.0870718732,
-0.0259476434,
-0.0262912866,
-0.0261573866,
0.0321083963,
0.0698014945,
-0.0244484916,
-0.0212203804,
-0.0298662856,
0.044544749,
-0.0813466534,
0.0077101672,
-0.0145694753,
-0.0693225414,
0.0236893352,
0.0390798189,
0.0195209514,
-0.0390056744,
0.0154566132,
0.0712966248,
0.0234245695,
-0.0490223728,
-0.0059043304,
-0.0344203822,
-0.0675942749,
-0.0393535197,
0.0092873061,
-0.0415552184,
0.0172829852,
0.0167657398,
-0.0069983983,
-0.017431628,
0.0227853172,
0.0313714519,
0.0042620245,
-0.0069369925,
-0.0509609021,
-0.0120890085,
0.0110496162,
0.0176949892,
-0.0426943824,
0.0378825292,
0.0338694006,
0.0289545227,
0.0093454579,
-0.0113612227,
-0.0038098344,
0.0031136093,
-0.0133810174,
0.0169691369,
0.0021548071,
0.0028597878,
-0.0978103578,
0.0200072695,
0.0314568244,
0.0741937831,
-0.012694817,
0.0162087269,
0.0110963322,
0.0305835456,
0.0164580997,
0.072547555,
0.0621946678,
-0.003461977,
0.0101328334,
0.0107015856,
0.0206208564,
0.0078307912,
-0.0262063947,
-0.0374674834,
-0.0050590071,
0.0608848408,
0.0212090798,
-0.048940219,
-0.0118850898,
0.0111959688,
0.0777409971,
-0.0264436062,
0.0064344169,
0.0594457611,
-0.002537227,
-0.0163860712,
0.0206247214,
-0.0758902207,
-0.0113852434,
-0.0211245194,
-0.0277936775,
0.0864839107,
0.0512031205,
0.043123614,
0.0211075097,
0.0002918378,
-0.0053884652,
0.0459246449,
-0.0086706309,
0.0280090962,
-0.0035555672,
-0.0311950129,
0.0260431338,
-0.011017845,
0.0023969554,
0.0007305264,
-0.0006860856,
0.0341982469,
0.0111504728,
0.0191437621,
0.007261306,
0.0024997934,
-0.0490398146,
-0.0153201744,
-0.004200934,
0.0109645203,
0.0393616781,
0.0077854246,
-0.0323075876,
0.0111196246,
-0.019322779,
-0.0416887403,
-0.040334139,
0.0695907772,
-0.0016531168,
-0.0173434224,
-0.0011417153,
-0.1242506057,
-0.0149307474,
-0.0024124472,
0.0146155488,
-0.010762969,
0.0511703677,
-0.0568584837,
0.0046990174,
-0.0554725826,
-0.0314696282,
-0.0307040401,
0.0051650573,
-0.0215142686,
0.0659085587,
-0.0091226548,
0.0026117859,
0.0157350861,
-0.0298401061,
-0.0022624629,
-0.0110169025,
-0.0170923751,
-0.0012977994,
-0.0053643924,
0.0387266167,
-0.0110417958,
0.0495642349,
-0.0567185283,
-0.0512725562,
-0.1089303121,
0.0114146154,
0.0006323956,
-0.0000658992,
0.0346589983,
-0.032897193,
-0.0250752456,
0.0209919773,
-0.0034579767,
-0.0397642218,
-0.0086219078,
-0.0062890355,
0.0077952258,
-0.0163734592,
0.0174359046,
-0.0075390674,
-0.0072351368,
-0.0184986666,
0.0239375643,
0.0454668887,
0.0597851463,
0.0096055912,
0.0559457168,
-0.0727499649,
-0.0730581209,
0.0158755444,
-0.1020567417,
0.0198342074,
0.0368168801,
-0.015121948,
0.0018174713,
0.0703370795,
0.0503540821,
-0.0105029829,
-0.0294831153,
0.0357571468,
-0.0222131815,
0.0034894417,
0.0680203289,
0.0033064203,
-0.0455476902,
0.004458806,
0.0021409919,
0.0476688817,
0.0353758633,
-0.053809505,
0.0695591792,
-0.050776761,
-0.0390366167,
-0.0018249765,
-0.0474948436,
-0.0340490378,
0.0096640484,
-0.0120111536,
0.0106219025,
0.0543512441,
-0.0084919306,
-0.0376933962,
-0.0353758,
-0.0108690262,
-0.0339965075,
0.0626664087,
-0.0307513606,
0.0620510913,
0.0097472686,
-0.0031365324,
-0.0371941514,
-0.0010494471,
0.0093057528,
-0.0554875657,
0.0200345665,
-0.0100895166,
-0.0355593339,
0.0247546583,
-0.03873007,
-0.0144268339,
-0.070888944,
-0.067565307,
-0.0107946321,
0.0264171716,
-0.0112758046,
0.0250520445,
0.0081992764,
0.0274710003,
-0.0528793186,
-0.0177270602,
-0.000901378,
0.0075679957,
0.0010922364,
0.0095627848,
0.0156757627,
0.0284736957,
0.0202222615,
-0.0432602391,
0.0386762992,
-0.0690751821,
0.00798395,
0.0014960951,
0.0261614993,
0.0083168251,
-0.0079216007,
-0.0128587708,
-0.0130925989,
0.0463792384,
-0.0288032871,
0.0023672809,
0.0415846854,
0.0039182645,
0.0360552259,
0.0352366865,
0.0070599858,
-0.0188800842,
-0.0046176305,
0.0103225634,
-0.0649266168,
-0.0177107695,
0.0048449845,
0.043174915,
-0.0507479347,
-0.0102112582,
-0.0383565314,
-0.0885864571,
0.0439347886,
0.0301237907,
-0.012793296,
0.0235448163,
0.0347142182,
-0.0255014095,
0.0037619232,
-0.007809069,
0.0096056508,
0.0039298274,
0.0397984609,
0.0320793763,
-0.0390882418,
-0.0635992736,
0.0338575207,
-0.002588724,
0.0884229615,
0.0271601006,
0.0438304357,
-0.0052120863,
-0.067438513,
-0.0505538955,
-0.0776508078,
0.004621414,
-0.0209575184,
0.0521244705,
0.01214136,
-0.0137843508,
-0.1098600104,
0.0025378887,
0.0042564808,
0.0175744463,
-0.0199105777,
0.0096557643,
-0.0261548851,
-0.0485163257,
-0.0306907408,
0.0382278673,
0.0040539335,
0.0874904096,
0.0481891371,
-0.0931778625,
0.0119966744,
-0.0285382476,
0.024633795,
-0.1148090661,
-0.0654352605,
0.0360959023,
0.0004746072,
-0.0270062648,
-0.0765547007,
-0.0384497829,
-0.0067998702,
0.0528206192,
-0.0327265821,
-0.0448686965,
-0.0665417761,
0.014580451,
0.0334703289,
-0.0003121942,
0.0163515341,
0.0064213709,
-0.0086966772,
0.0012790592,
0.0117301624,
-0.0763102099,
-0.0330724753,
0.0390606076,
-0.0500967503,
-0.0206139162,
0.0833436847,
0.0568897501,
0.026453184,
-0.0712391511,
-0.0165191442,
-0.042764008,
0.0248611271,
0.0610560998,
-0.0174805541,
0.0345370583,
-0.0222898386,
0.0462171324,
0.0032262525,
0.0235214103,
-0.0090182815,
0.0553766452,
0.0207740329,
0.0237835199,
-0.0072281845,
-0.0234575979,
0.0013989238,
0.0438031889,
-0.0180972964,
-0.0697309002,
-0.0633104593,
0.0398851633,
-0.0364857912,
-0.0097620813,
-0.028194949,
-0.0408578701,
-0.0421220586,
-0.0042321826,
-0.0030673442,
-0.0148635283,
-0.029132368,
-0.0431493185,
0.0507707931,
-0.0086849844,
0.0504806973,
0.0276920721,
0.0120043028,
-0.0131909512,
0.0443324745,
-0.0349626057,
0.0104484595,
-0.0206181258,
0.0143258683,
0.0001306757,
0.0245273095,
0.0003166931,
-0.0389759876,
-0.0022424515,
0.0443224236,
0.005758517,
0.0305293631,
0.0265162867,
-0.0073513431,
0.0463382527,
0.0070465822,
0.0891335383,
-0.0324447267,
0.0215897001,
0.0002981664,
0.0092071425,
-0.0072264029,
-0.0629843324,
0.008672351,
-0.0087859314,
0.006116095,
-0.0744853765,
0.0452679545,
-0.0779651552,
-0.004015856,
0.0049053668,
-0.0182374418,
-0.0271249972,
-0.0339956544,
-0.0369281024,
-0.0474327989,
0.0240339953,
-0.0003905357,
-0.0933717415,
-0.0412543751,
-0.0011346588,
-0.010744404,
0.0358846895,
-0.013152387,
0.0386746153,
0.0267948136,
-0.0146964006,
0.0042281272,
-0.0488333143,
0.0316350684,
-0.0602963902,
0.0381600149,
-0.0180989448,
-6.133204591e-33,
-0.0307563748,
-0.0398289636,
-0.0233882703,
0.0134558473,
-0.03115144,
0.0041729002,
-0.0516977683,
0.0389525704,
0.0088579757,
0.0229602363,
0.0042816503,
-0.0369237885,
0.0058486057,
-0.0047412766,
0.026463287,
-0.0454220921,
0.0317583345,
0.020654954,
-0.0335913859,
-0.0067218528,
0.0313644297,
-0.0008912251,
0.050572861,
-0.0448205955,
0.0354203023,
-0.005547639,
-0.0490053482,
-0.0342072472,
0.0847576857,
0.0408360809,
0.0309766773,
0.0700833648,
0.033620853,
0.0040329448,
0.015991129,
-0.0130009325,
-0.0133589972,
-0.0227561761,
0.0183413681,
-0.0016522565,
-0.0329549797,
-0.0220656842,
0.0837716311,
0.0099749146,
-0.0646751672,
-0.0041805557,
0.0207664669,
-0.0095682442,
0.0389654115,
-0.0448831432,
-0.0212981869,
0.0275323633,
-0.004539724,
-0.0023923765,
-0.0210755207,
0.053433165,
-0.0132637518,
-0.0366260521,
-0.0697799474,
0.0075090444,
-0.0713997185,
-0.046155557,
0.015053302,
-0.0261281319,
-0.0155910142,
0.0672057718,
-0.0265103616,
0.0587867871,
-0.0269660614,
0.0108852815,
0.0251460373,
0.0171769261,
0.0591373295,
0.0874120146,
0.0188733805,
-0.0456873178,
-0.0004731271,
0.0193095971,
0.0222959444,
0.0178918131,
-0.0041292394,
-0.0340790004,
-0.0625437573,
0.0039972612,
0.005376392,
0.0316525511,
0.0191594493,
-0.0781327784,
-0.0033297143,
-0.0121764885,
-0.0493433066,
-0.0408890285,
0.0252896622,
-0.0032060451,
0.0245118923,
-0.0059222439,
-0.0234903041,
0.0395779647,
0.004412761,
-0.0108369514,
-0.000684113,
0.0266445521,
0.0265245903,
0.0665917248,
0.0312570818,
0.0116791874,
0.0262427852,
0.0069932137,
-0.0413995273,
0.0342961587,
0.0077364654,
0.0224497784,
0.0113092056,
-0.0360767245,
-0.0100257592,
0.042246867,
-0.0218830388,
-0.0568670593,
0.0644279122,
0.0627448931,
-0.0012503446,
0.0078919521,
0.0109120766,
0.0109821502,
-0.06226312,
-0.0011386332,
0.0176145583,
-0.0557787642,
0.0167070925,
-0.0271128938,
0.002897976,
-0.0449653193,
2.581e-7,
0.0650240928,
0.0517930984,
0.0028220615,
0.0052852426,
0.0416845195,
0.0391542912,
0.0174601544,
0.0279626846,
0.0420268551,
0.0259376969,
0.0040377644,
0.0111608766,
0.0235334337,
0.0668960139,
-0.0608118363,
0.0458387062,
-0.0668745711,
0.0626282692,
-0.0027415047,
0.0241870079,
0.0604033656,
-0.0036531973,
0.001272544,
-0.0278577171,
-0.0124633377,
-0.0762882307,
0.0207555983,
-0.0110563599,
0.0318989828,
-0.0040379157,
0.0625782833,
-0.0000597747,
0.0195249561,
0.0204901956,
0.0048448895,
-0.0368875824,
0.0158515163,
0.01755777,
-0.0143365515,
0.0098048765,
0.0238017347,
-0.0039743315,
0.0021857123,
-0.0627642274,
0.0408302881,
0.0124537898,
-0.0363639295,
-0.058897689,
-0.0182667188,
-0.0107133789,
0.0506086126,
0.0049258312,
-0.032057967,
0.0130435107,
0.0489165336,
-0.0089354934,
-0.0087773986,
-0.0163089931,
-0.0577295087,
0.0016805585,
-0.0446221195,
-0.032701131,
0.0015399327,
0.011837733,
-0.0280187409,
-0.082940124,
0.0128076561,
1.835050226e-34,
0.0014782775,
0.0196214672,
0.0304833911,
-0.0398494713,
0.0389069878,
0.0404114872,
0.0071454044,
-0.0292402934,
0.0474635474,
0.0117469197,
-0.0079871658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05550v1 | Towards End-to-End Spoken Grammatical Error Correction | 2023-11-09T17:49:02 | 2023-11-09T17:49:02 | Stefano Bannò, Rao Ma, Mengjie Qian, Kate M. Knill, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Grammatical feedback is crucial for L2 learners, teachers, and testers.
Spoken grammatical error correction (GEC) aims to supply feedback to L2
learners on their use of grammar when speaking. This process usually relies on
a cascaded pipeline comprising an ASR system, disfluency removal, and GEC, with
the associated concern of propagating errors between these individual modules.
In this paper, we introduce an alternative "end-to-end" approach to spoken GEC,
exploiting a speech recognition foundation model, Whisper. This foundation
model can be used to replace the whole framework or part of it, e.g., ASR and
disfluency removal. These end-to-end approaches are compared to more standard
cascaded approaches on the data obtained from a free-speaking spoken language
assessment test, Linguaskill. Results demonstrate that end-to-end spoken GEC is
possible within this architecture, but the lack of available data limits
current performance compared to a system using large quantities of text-based
GEC data. Conversely, end-to-end disfluency detection and removal, which is
easier for the attention-based Whisper to learn, does outperform cascaded
approaches. Additionally, the paper discusses the challenges of providing
feedback to candidates when using end-to-end systems for spoken GEC. | [
0.0333065875,
0.0520685092,
-0.0028923673,
0.0124412328,
-0.0419226699,
0.0106213866,
-0.024787087,
-0.0335125476,
0.0247879699,
-0.0653845668,
-0.010724403,
-0.0383838117,
0.0410669409,
-0.0162203349,
0.0494547784,
-0.0453315303,
0.0788138583,
-0.032819517,
-0.03502848,
0.0077558439,
0.0076725371,
-0.0005520936,
-0.035026744,
0.048097536,
-0.0295243207,
-0.0363255404,
-0.0241774805,
0.0258325208,
0.0121913534,
0.0086152526,
0.0575717799,
0.0222638901,
-0.03425676,
0.0400571935,
0.0000021234,
-0.0255112685,
0.0102151604,
-0.0301340651,
-0.0417805426,
0.0334982462,
0.0242379121,
0.0867828876,
-0.0601950362,
0.0433447361,
0.0080247167,
0.0085589532,
0.0307320841,
0.003802005,
0.0639182553,
0.0666225776,
0.0110621359,
-0.0138164256,
0.0731371194,
0.0154250376,
-0.0260206647,
0.0130281234,
0.0219507515,
-0.064255245,
-0.0145584475,
-0.0538753644,
-0.0245437697,
0.0563657433,
0.005003612,
-0.0477372594,
0.0158594362,
-0.0233396851,
-0.0565586761,
-0.0493775122,
-0.0529775955,
0.0323047824,
0.0122346962,
-0.0356848687,
0.0143138338,
0.0055127381,
0.0251556262,
-0.0351151526,
-0.0013798729,
-0.0046126908,
-0.0228735097,
-0.0029415702,
0.0497238375,
-0.0916307941,
-0.0158234108,
-0.0270348713,
0.0231477339,
0.0275947079,
-0.0044921115,
-0.0432842672,
-0.0282565467,
0.0409162566,
-0.0037911581,
-0.0716997012,
0.0479065254,
0.0018504502,
-0.0591952018,
0.0121597499,
-0.0383126251,
-0.0576810315,
-0.013403031,
-0.0293309297,
0.0331263952,
0.0136919646,
-0.0765337422,
-0.016613014,
0.0018192461,
0.0827038288,
0.0394030325,
0.0375641994,
-0.0029941001,
0.028198529,
-0.0288451165,
0.0211450048,
-0.0498208106,
0.0386936553,
-0.0231869482,
0.0217692442,
-0.0526037589,
-0.0085554319,
-0.0488620698,
0.0595671535,
0.0045489799,
-0.0170028768,
-0.0367168225,
0.0080361087,
0.0045756963,
0.0601326227,
0.04661984,
0.0358641781,
0.0351782329,
-0.0811370239,
-0.0147769852,
0.0224957988,
0.0392772816,
0.0491111316,
-0.0124448705,
0.0104574403,
-0.0054443744,
-0.039057143,
-0.0572241433,
0.0026577278,
-0.0280007645,
-0.0662724376,
-0.0555031858,
-0.0431512706,
-0.0262726899,
-0.0088127935,
-0.000040143,
-0.0243290421,
0.0012049127,
-0.0049058399,
0.0169197936,
0.0268127192,
-0.0290671736,
-0.0012890142,
0.0252949577,
-0.0210672189,
0.0095695769,
0.0189781133,
0.0219283961,
-0.0417327024,
0.017466126,
-0.0085121496,
0.020684801,
0.0164249223,
0.0010635832,
-0.0072185732,
0.0067949663,
-0.0313341357,
-0.0208265055,
-0.0023387347,
0.0372038037,
0.0678036436,
-0.0119477417,
0.0550344251,
0.0675526485,
0.0298107862,
0.0570078865,
0.0004949099,
0.0160463229,
0.0061634011,
-0.0071816468,
0.0378624797,
-0.0501691699,
-0.0399577394,
-0.0611845627,
0.0059560547,
0.0091062114,
0.0054121716,
-0.0196193531,
-0.0570888817,
-0.0158372112,
0.0025859389,
0.0030001053,
0.0312912054,
0.0404945873,
0.0457353592,
-0.0537373759,
0.0703608096,
0.0342768542,
-0.0950737074,
0.0532373264,
-0.0503346175,
-0.0117480895,
0.0449455529,
0.0421868041,
-0.0008336417,
-0.0421299189,
-0.0574542433,
-0.0111532826,
0.0323198214,
0.0087748636,
-0.0009346066,
0.0096264612,
-0.0629166737,
0.0076950607,
0.0416256078,
0.0059079402,
-0.0147332503,
-0.0121446755,
0.0007471862,
-0.0190175064,
0.0044556973,
-0.0345525369,
-0.0023711871,
0.0166070573,
-0.0097672222,
-0.0289427191,
0.0153367184,
0.0498524532,
0.0315577537,
-0.0117546683,
-0.0150044551,
-0.00039413,
0.0302421637,
-0.0211465713,
-0.004424077,
-0.0578087159,
-0.0542714335,
0.0360057354,
-0.0191110913,
-0.020227408,
0.0582352951,
-0.0051554414,
-0.0720101148,
0.018546911,
-0.0783198848,
0.0444317572,
-0.0321305953,
0.0941506326,
0.0072912076,
-0.0167073905,
-0.004229865,
-0.0239893422,
-0.0129748276,
-0.0009678203,
-0.0442767441,
-0.001259231,
-0.0137445377,
-0.0897593498,
-0.0498807505,
-0.0051475647,
-0.0377703756,
0.0388863161,
-0.0177067779,
0.0039726342,
-0.0616604611,
-0.0255007949,
-0.0513299853,
-0.0134901367,
-0.0334762782,
0.0458514877,
0.0301670507,
0.0111903548,
-0.0115540931,
-0.0578213744,
-0.0014338148,
0.0425748564,
0.0287498496,
-0.0359310433,
0.0131869353,
-0.0289428681,
-0.0368096009,
-0.0526992716,
0.019178912,
-0.0320124365,
-0.0373937748,
-0.0090231104,
-0.0322144292,
-0.082251288,
0.0602779649,
-0.009382668,
0.0570527613,
0.0490421243,
-0.064935565,
-0.0188077763,
0.0167906508,
0.0493843481,
0.0257277749,
-0.0248468779,
-0.0059665632,
-0.016014671,
-0.0617822297,
-0.0428763479,
0.0236302,
0.0324431062,
0.008451011,
-0.0178140309,
0.0179692321,
-0.0212389845,
0.0528294146,
0.0466565266,
0.0073927045,
0.0020264015,
-0.0286511946,
-0.0232275948,
0.0006158183,
-0.0150282988,
-0.0443977453,
-0.0346714966,
-0.0178800747,
-0.0295971259,
-0.0117841931,
0.057089895,
-0.0259956811,
-0.0357461944,
-0.0572756715,
0.0109728938,
0.0041520316,
-0.0320703313,
-0.0128836678,
0.0083048111,
0.0170598105,
-0.0970426425,
-0.0240806974,
-0.0086149527,
0.0421845391,
-0.0404328071,
0.0577982515,
-0.0661331862,
0.0129753854,
0.0146017484,
-0.0712166056,
-0.0236383118,
0.0401442535,
-0.0128645934,
0.0001703056,
-0.012028439,
-0.0227444358,
-0.0479852483,
-0.0107667921,
0.0064603128,
0.058401525,
0.0086231986,
0.0069859843,
-0.0180862956,
0.0261986982,
0.0039043033,
0.0279682912,
-0.0063132364,
-0.0095713828,
0.0524526648,
0.0560937561,
0.0710260645,
0.0601863824,
-0.0200952739,
0.0086172735,
0.045999147,
-0.0183506161,
-0.0296916515,
-0.0061077876,
0.0995184258,
-0.0731507614,
-0.0328190215,
0.0700725988,
0.002064849,
-0.0143665588,
-0.0180643238,
0.0126162758,
-0.0017810677,
0.011038932,
-0.0035937503,
-0.0587683916,
-0.017773306,
0.0731851608,
0.0458991118,
0.0136060109,
-0.0033443237,
0.0240377057,
-0.1058123037,
0.0912026167,
0.0339902267,
-0.0489612557,
-0.0336537994,
-0.0091094868,
0.0405036025,
0.0284163337,
0.0488245301,
0.0468238108,
-0.0184348784,
-0.0403485969,
0.0192640144,
-0.0713963136,
-0.0438462868,
-0.0169565659,
-0.0187766235,
0.0716224387,
0.0481343232,
-0.0017533608,
0.0344312862,
-0.029433744,
0.0626026019,
-0.0169855356,
-0.0045770667,
-0.0174701568,
0.033937078,
0.026122801,
-0.0291501787,
-0.0384025685,
0.057614781,
0.0001151989,
0.0267869402,
0.016361082,
0.0727700293,
-0.015439339,
0.0124060186,
0.0168083124,
0.0319345817,
0.0469635986,
0.0209754761,
0.0505246744,
-0.0428588837,
-0.0244233739,
-0.0369305722,
-0.0165033937,
-0.0106306104,
0.0175893418,
0.0442946516,
-0.0118880905,
0.0093015889,
-0.0278036352,
-0.0621116646,
0.0100690965,
-0.0126380045,
0.0042216284,
-0.0014419046,
0.0072446242,
-0.0098787155,
0.0169929825,
-0.0095214006,
-0.0059178798,
0.0262323152,
-0.1042630374,
-0.0252213161,
-0.0174277183,
0.0096383607,
-0.0248959642,
-0.0018726079,
-0.0693769157,
-0.0678136721,
0.0608632118,
0.025206713,
0.0103162462,
0.0319657065,
-0.0392724462,
-0.0683687031,
0.0492278188,
-0.0085282736,
-0.0718770921,
0.0551073439,
0.0396194831,
-0.0177573655,
-0.0081009548,
0.0367874652,
0.007869767,
0.0203972291,
0.0148236835,
0.0408048704,
-0.0074731857,
-0.0199328251,
0.0138710132,
0.0501453206,
0.0882616118,
0.0095760599,
-0.0016145491,
-0.0623475984,
0.0439799279,
0.0175236352,
0.0114483684,
-0.0217403527,
0.0302302241,
-0.0024498831,
-0.0326626375,
-0.0101780333,
-0.0188209936,
-0.0728914738,
-0.0155237569,
-0.0281886086,
0.0721888021,
0.0507203862,
0.0169269256,
0.0287818164,
0.017265223,
-0.0034684367,
0.0040839789,
0.0566390045,
0.0360920951,
0.0296337549,
0.0424973369,
0.018272372,
0.0155512188,
0.0296387654,
-0.0143627822,
-0.0266530942,
-0.0047110836,
-0.0225537941,
0.0355831012,
0.0518085845,
0.0684087574,
0.0617985949,
0.0139870644,
0.0083560962,
-0.0211761892,
0.0260613244,
-0.0360262915,
-0.0090606175,
0.0221051965,
-0.0122713419,
0.0223406758,
0.0076345354,
-0.0212121084,
-0.0337903872,
0.0365749672,
-0.0333643258,
0.0560171902,
-0.0596051887,
-0.0546945445,
-0.0216052011,
-0.0080131553,
-0.0088998135,
-0.0026755386,
-0.0110535119,
-0.0782199875,
0.0044915117,
0.0446576923,
0.0365249813,
-0.0342686735,
0.0147311371,
-0.0074175722,
-0.0095917536,
-0.0401198566,
-0.0250064433,
-0.0306142978,
-0.0140563343,
-0.0326106176,
0.0002123513,
-6.347164767e-33,
-0.0631932318,
0.0016038741,
-0.0024521621,
0.0304580647,
-0.031438265,
0.0068350686,
-0.0411305279,
0.0054608728,
0.0270073563,
0.0175766516,
-0.0263919085,
0.0484008156,
0.0172544457,
0.016098395,
0.0446724966,
0.0413680412,
0.110505484,
0.0047498574,
-0.0152103482,
0.0083520804,
0.0390372351,
0.0527032278,
0.0850218982,
-0.0230390634,
0.012057106,
-0.0038041866,
-0.0143962577,
-0.0078390939,
-0.029181689,
0.023730237,
0.0387563594,
0.0615548715,
-0.0181946326,
0.0300950333,
-0.0356348641,
0.021737678,
-0.0840892717,
-0.031399481,
-0.0102913678,
0.0464468226,
-0.013468558,
-0.0095447907,
0.0579201318,
-0.0075681205,
-0.0133539708,
-0.0027454775,
0.0201134477,
0.0078689996,
0.0418404303,
0.0418923125,
-0.0136699975,
0.0204932559,
-0.0037859487,
-0.0251977667,
-0.0165452734,
0.0711093023,
-0.0208384972,
-0.082332179,
-0.0880756825,
0.0180154555,
0.0611642972,
0.0292857867,
0.0335035026,
-0.004285757,
-0.0651757345,
0.0102058733,
0.0717012733,
-0.0218692068,
0.039524924,
-0.0181358736,
0.0272939615,
0.0171786491,
0.0171154961,
0.005607951,
0.0161139332,
-0.0285668317,
-0.0119562708,
-0.0203073565,
0.0178930741,
0.0728193,
-0.0390072688,
0.0044586076,
-0.0396874025,
-0.036948584,
-0.0499320216,
-0.0320045948,
-0.0260332301,
-0.0089821005,
0.0825553387,
0.0020275225,
0.0210045762,
-0.014516551,
0.0079782167,
0.003389976,
-0.0030504146,
-0.0203281194,
0.019365266,
0.0319440104,
-0.0353271514,
0.0151790902,
-0.0597298555,
-0.0175884292,
0.0055895098,
0.0698959529,
0.0075413189,
0.0072020651,
0.0121432785,
0.0593957715,
-0.0482698269,
0.0300776437,
-0.0205486696,
0.0612075366,
-0.0115237888,
0.0105494205,
0.0452221297,
-0.018809706,
0.0020572923,
0.048111584,
-0.0124266688,
0.0128105227,
-0.0386229642,
-0.0120357899,
-0.014820029,
0.0383967198,
-0.0316431448,
-0.013263138,
-0.0200539324,
0.0173651874,
0.0057147304,
-0.0134031242,
0.0237836856,
-0.0180621408,
2.835e-7,
-0.0208063591,
0.0306724217,
0.0340679437,
-0.0129628656,
0.0132889645,
-0.0164031014,
-0.0038463599,
-0.0088844188,
0.0199988429,
0.084441416,
-0.0331297182,
-0.0225241389,
0.0723793507,
-0.001121097,
-0.0682022274,
-0.0114194155,
-0.0506193638,
0.0405657217,
-0.0138543984,
0.0019084068,
-0.0006152453,
0.0121143479,
0.0285606552,
-0.0375763178,
-0.0056821532,
0.0086906422,
-0.0043954314,
0.0104414858,
-0.0151816588,
0.0094732391,
0.0583878122,
0.0127284247,
0.012030758,
0.039296288,
-0.025202645,
-0.0023306722,
-0.0649870411,
0.0234542042,
-0.0497594699,
-0.0118282763,
-0.0132954745,
0.0484761149,
-0.0243601203,
-0.0378568172,
-0.0011909809,
-0.0132300807,
0.0282307081,
0.0083648609,
-0.0456742793,
-0.031154938,
0.0006541955,
-0.0114516374,
-0.0187867898,
0.0016759891,
0.0052638249,
-0.0110943401,
-0.0236762147,
-0.0223476738,
0.0221407637,
0.0368955582,
0.0043811593,
-0.0247396473,
0.0012922075,
0.0071428288,
-0.0453126132,
-0.0381571651,
-0.0217798762,
2.20472621e-34,
0.0406437479,
-0.0173635576,
0.0715783685,
0.0050802934,
0.0183289107,
-0.0149403056,
0.0010019478,
0.028923545,
0.012032358,
-0.0271430239,
-0.0505164638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07590v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07590v3 | Large Language Models can Strategically Deceive their Users when Put Under Pressure | 2023-11-09T17:12:44 | 2024-05-09T07:18:43 | Jérémy Scheurer, Mikita Balesni, Marius Hobbhahn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We demonstrate a situation in which Large Language Models, trained to be
helpful, harmless, and honest, can display misaligned behavior and
strategically deceive their users about this behavior without being instructed
to do so. Concretely, we deploy GPT-4 as an agent in a realistic, simulated
environment, where it assumes the role of an autonomous stock trading agent.
Within this environment, the model obtains an insider tip about a lucrative
stock trade and acts upon it despite knowing that insider trading is
disapproved of by company management. When reporting to its manager, the model
consistently hides the genuine reasons behind its trading decision. We perform
a brief investigation of how this behavior varies under changes to the setting,
such as removing model access to a reasoning scratchpad, attempting to prevent
the misaligned behavior by changing system instructions, changing the amount of
pressure the model is under, varying the perceived risk of getting caught, and
making other simple changes to the environment. To our knowledge, this is the
first demonstration of Large Language Models trained to be helpful, harmless,
and honest, strategically deceiving their users in a realistic situation
without direct instructions or training for deception. | [
0.046849601,
0.0752964541,
-0.0456256606,
0.0326301605,
-0.0300092455,
0.0110640982,
0.0536605716,
0.0276604034,
0.0320205092,
-0.0211103465,
-0.0292074103,
0.0007742168,
0.0018810097,
0.0527772084,
0.0484581962,
-0.0164427124,
0.0442829058,
-0.0310105346,
0.0351672806,
-0.0266548507,
0.023589937,
0.0052909069,
0.0407203212,
0.0118503068,
-0.0143765984,
-0.0328994021,
-0.0301979519,
-0.018180171,
0.0078856125,
0.025984602,
0.0037116953,
0.0211407635,
0.021737773,
0.104172498,
0.0000019684,
-0.0153450323,
-0.0466017611,
-0.0042760596,
-0.062396504,
0.0112280622,
0.0405654423,
-0.0643812567,
-0.0044824271,
0.010444277,
-0.0973585993,
0.0022955134,
0.0531020835,
0.0796598718,
0.060572885,
0.1038822159,
0.0022922335,
0.0269567762,
-0.0025779021,
-0.035344474,
-0.0149860857,
-0.0854419917,
0.0196133945,
-0.0100069037,
-0.0404515117,
0.0137504339,
-0.0019857013,
-0.0198579822,
0.0011161523,
-0.013554913,
-0.078518413,
0.0406515375,
-0.025881039,
-0.0096588414,
-0.0184096526,
-0.0029877692,
-0.0262103919,
-0.0109618763,
0.0242821034,
-0.0133158788,
0.0197058842,
-0.0014414395,
0.0290965438,
0.0571236499,
-0.0301860031,
-0.0093179028,
0.0254729949,
0.0075059291,
0.042710308,
0.0205412768,
0.0080391737,
0.0417108648,
-0.0276017915,
-0.0197746791,
0.0157299936,
-0.0154785337,
0.0201146137,
-0.0808555707,
-0.0142400702,
0.0450944416,
-0.0433134325,
0.0333144478,
-0.0385369323,
0.045208063,
0.0090084542,
-0.0731863901,
-0.006050617,
0.0288088117,
0.0376556478,
0.02229302,
-0.0234633218,
0.0637628809,
-0.0181312691,
0.040320456,
-0.0258834921,
0.0187154282,
0.0222700201,
-0.0235910006,
-0.0629006997,
0.0416629091,
-0.0183378998,
-0.0167123228,
-0.0498317704,
0.0335256048,
-0.0603101738,
0.0579274334,
-0.0256748144,
0.0102408184,
-0.0299070403,
-0.0476807281,
-0.0279227048,
-0.0001787728,
-0.0238857344,
0.0029191447,
0.0161596313,
-0.0349254683,
-0.0177380443,
-0.0092451423,
-0.0612916127,
0.0000543158,
-0.015854653,
0.0884693041,
0.0178494379,
-0.0186296776,
-0.0741963461,
-0.0540739745,
-0.0102158226,
-0.073535502,
-0.0444999561,
-0.0152186695,
-0.0062210141,
-0.0247939825,
-0.0153775169,
-0.0378339738,
-0.0025954028,
-0.0147120431,
-0.0126992036,
0.093069531,
-0.0114114899,
-0.028462369,
0.005289888,
0.0365175195,
-0.0318440273,
0.0862326026,
-0.0099823466,
0.0757040828,
0.0541038439,
-0.0322508812,
0.0557059646,
0.0091187591,
0.0066065588,
0.0087764086,
-0.00047688,
0.0112457937,
0.0177137926,
0.0031373911,
0.0154266078,
0.0293883625,
-0.0337093025,
-0.0315324552,
0.1050536335,
0.0361083485,
-0.0147524569,
0.0082657784,
0.0122433798,
0.000705227,
-0.0264301281,
0.0419561341,
-0.0471866541,
-0.0031001144,
-0.0701539591,
-0.0030682641,
-0.0434570871,
0.0121479537,
-0.0145757832,
-0.0233445931,
0.0175357405,
-0.0358866043,
0.0371115729,
0.0449390523,
-0.0024563267,
-0.0095633846,
-0.0512386784,
0.0088839876,
0.0330011025,
0.0016047402,
-0.0347299129,
-0.0959075615,
0.0085114688,
0.0932491943,
0.0188401602,
0.0021532355,
0.011869926,
-0.050252825,
-0.0121491104,
0.0598773994,
0.0610040203,
0.0001412702,
-0.0458116606,
-0.0283933114,
-0.0052498467,
-0.0113318264,
0.0275760014,
0.0357223302,
-0.0280009136,
0.0247447062,
0.0033901329,
-0.0028714901,
0.014427254,
0.0260276794,
-0.0153223164,
-0.0596728399,
-0.0063573285,
-0.0022479258,
0.0115319323,
-0.0114045814,
0.0029196672,
-0.0057103503,
0.0221953355,
0.0232472774,
-0.0171483271,
-0.0219586305,
-0.0424963161,
0.0371903628,
0.0002703684,
-0.0000906157,
-0.0065265996,
0.0320979021,
-0.0007889075,
-0.0101911714,
0.0144459438,
-0.0320442356,
0.0508373342,
-0.0306454524,
0.0000904423,
-0.022881547,
0.0268441942,
-0.0113273468,
0.0667408481,
0.0088589424,
-0.0157883428,
-0.0443837941,
0.0086292047,
-0.000338142,
-0.028154118,
0.0348176919,
0.0245524645,
0.0310150478,
0.0404672883,
0.0510128476,
-0.0024555929,
0.0022731686,
-0.0400175117,
-0.0795845315,
-0.0200785398,
-0.0302141979,
0.0079355082,
0.0452825278,
-0.0073636407,
-0.0109057724,
-0.032169804,
-0.050161723,
0.0103964498,
-0.004662334,
0.0318109244,
0.0205884632,
-0.0002837652,
-0.0116893565,
-0.0033404194,
0.0108379023,
-0.0107196784,
0.0165426098,
0.0154516855,
0.0073443819,
-0.0862308666,
0.0177875068,
-0.0102502163,
0.0563857481,
-0.0390531793,
-0.0148624443,
0.0413223431,
0.014658479,
-0.0335392095,
0.0923546925,
0.0402338132,
0.0855604336,
0.0410930105,
0.0425621942,
-0.0412241593,
0.0180663001,
0.0098445518,
-0.0073820464,
-0.0834880769,
-0.0265861247,
-0.0243303441,
0.0439117625,
0.0164872985,
0.0136859203,
-0.0398771465,
0.0606156327,
-0.0104149235,
-0.058706481,
0.0049086469,
-0.0464140773,
-0.0195496231,
0.0556167699,
0.0211469475,
-0.0811991766,
0.0915214792,
-0.018361913,
-0.0243213158,
-0.0071323086,
-0.0255601406,
-0.0004797683,
0.088029854,
-0.0026324769,
0.0218762197,
0.0485519879,
-0.009285599,
-0.0456054322,
-0.0490639061,
0.0557666644,
-0.0473744646,
0.0159234833,
-0.0461225472,
-0.0109656258,
-0.0134154176,
-0.0417306907,
-0.0474257097,
-0.0969396085,
-0.0242405832,
-0.0107500767,
0.043672394,
-0.0541414693,
-0.0357106663,
-0.0229633711,
0.0217638165,
0.0140142906,
-0.0192407705,
-0.0274001695,
-0.0116691086,
-0.0558787584,
0.0791422203,
-0.0127536403,
0.0482911505,
-0.0304155257,
0.0457976125,
0.0547601357,
0.0171666723,
0.0035377934,
-0.0178593565,
-0.0177001562,
0.0109842317,
0.0143268276,
-0.0004221619,
0.041831281,
-0.0084299808,
-0.0475151427,
-0.0026316466,
0.0777066723,
0.0123334983,
-0.0352174714,
0.0144203659,
0.0050864141,
0.0232497565,
-0.0026720809,
0.0322427601,
-0.0995370597,
0.002939753,
-0.0025672058,
0.0239055734,
-0.0287703965,
-0.0445981324,
-0.0377711877,
-0.1239507571,
0.0533432774,
0.0163598973,
-0.0084040146,
-0.012373697,
-0.0394149758,
-0.0619174279,
-0.0261701662,
0.073741518,
-0.0109915491,
-0.0069406349,
-0.0359732769,
0.0056574959,
-0.0274086967,
0.0088105062,
0.0184190888,
0.0006090336,
0.0461515822,
0.0630548373,
-0.0001585381,
-0.0264772214,
-0.0289516486,
-0.0263735391,
0.0270372797,
0.0143074179,
0.0205313135,
0.0410954691,
-0.0122095356,
-0.0164485835,
-0.0057927719,
0.0119253723,
0.0053141909,
0.0389948338,
0.0271429829,
0.0446816236,
-0.0090692369,
-0.0849191025,
0.0305501763,
0.0005370393,
0.0428730696,
0.036639031,
-0.0163591243,
-0.0155498907,
-0.0581617318,
-0.0640183985,
0.0116103794,
0.0133680739,
-0.0268996023,
0.0164068211,
0.04011482,
-0.0089987386,
-0.0456228852,
-0.0848702416,
0.0011805291,
0.0252505522,
0.0319364518,
0.0236576963,
0.0126292687,
-0.0045243897,
0.0106888358,
-0.0141199203,
-0.0265976842,
0.0484979004,
-0.0044228188,
0.0131207248,
-0.0223274697,
-0.0345816948,
0.0283194073,
0.0187849365,
-0.0115864528,
-0.0270808581,
0.0212992001,
0.0418585092,
0.0358098708,
0.0432888605,
-0.0277792998,
0.002633712,
0.0210755598,
0.0060355589,
-0.072640948,
0.0071008918,
0.0910439715,
-0.0118115181,
0.0163223241,
0.0417442769,
-0.0387905724,
-0.0104290703,
0.0246901922,
-0.0249010082,
-0.0914732143,
0.0158280991,
0.0462830514,
-0.0176968556,
0.0071620224,
0.0054060104,
0.0185622759,
-0.0024065557,
0.0108409496,
-0.0346540287,
-0.0218374822,
-0.0051540737,
-0.0298925471,
0.0437570922,
0.0074200085,
0.0401052088,
-0.0027837195,
-0.0267024841,
-0.0414449424,
-0.0103951376,
0.0007284178,
0.0092602698,
0.0231206585,
0.028139174,
-0.0107931038,
-0.0251126196,
0.0498819686,
0.020062821,
0.0411230624,
-0.0032358833,
0.0715061054,
0.0360340811,
-0.0293651726,
-0.0149730295,
0.0094149532,
-0.0423463285,
-0.058725778,
0.0559973642,
0.0593482964,
0.0148641961,
-0.017218003,
0.0255460124,
-0.0469498597,
0.0186964162,
0.0173944887,
-0.0031919468,
0.0340321325,
-0.0592436194,
-0.0043803207,
0.0153701268,
-0.0342116803,
-0.0106351012,
0.0842915252,
-0.0030585539,
0.0427499339,
-0.0273001269,
-0.0109517686,
-0.0177252032,
-0.0318623595,
0.0501748286,
0.0204709452,
-0.015250829,
-0.0225836318,
-0.0842371956,
-0.0664722398,
-0.0555109233,
0.0233022757,
0.0060469233,
-0.0464100949,
-0.0226593688,
0.0721970424,
0.0008941838,
0.0355114527,
-0.0671399385,
0.0009785529,
0.0231518969,
0.0162750203,
-0.0502281599,
-5.776464831e-33,
0.0005207481,
-0.0597072951,
0.0130799385,
-0.0046412731,
0.0241548717,
0.0150962258,
-0.0096209804,
0.0016660716,
-0.0541647971,
0.032404799,
-0.0452997051,
0.0298050065,
0.0162968561,
-0.0209623296,
-0.0034083447,
0.0128172757,
0.0243557505,
-0.018759273,
-0.0435288101,
0.0010349834,
0.0283128805,
0.0097988797,
0.0372031443,
-0.0442459211,
0.0614155717,
-0.0070497189,
-0.0776982978,
0.0095667103,
-0.0640491992,
0.0530494638,
-0.0057524783,
0.0384705327,
-0.0053333575,
-0.0404892117,
-0.0085190786,
0.0201665442,
0.0376953445,
-0.0246392693,
0.0290534291,
0.0166904386,
-0.0205125529,
-0.0071308673,
0.0269237757,
-0.050660722,
-0.0159542169,
0.011834004,
-0.0002866659,
-0.0118367011,
-0.0062831105,
0.01819757,
-0.0561132878,
-0.011149196,
0.0093680043,
-0.0028508108,
0.0042530308,
0.0027776517,
-0.0090812752,
-0.0552488118,
-0.0546106584,
0.0236771908,
0.0472423397,
-0.015230746,
0.0327874571,
0.0350450166,
-0.0047330833,
0.0746632889,
0.0541513525,
0.0563096181,
-0.0224861018,
-0.0091893692,
-0.0050566941,
0.0303265359,
0.0591074787,
0.0315313414,
0.0127854757,
-0.0632376447,
-0.03750927,
-0.0058329091,
0.0449395441,
0.0036083667,
0.0542732365,
-0.0015533017,
-0.0596494228,
-0.0226396173,
0.0003397809,
0.0403889269,
-0.0280917585,
-0.0320856012,
-0.0005461645,
0.0227009859,
0.0088038472,
0.0107880561,
0.0001861821,
-0.0585848503,
-0.0244545024,
-0.018020859,
0.0075636897,
-0.042513527,
0.0038639274,
0.0235371981,
-0.0159058496,
-0.0332581848,
-0.015111452,
-0.0287695173,
0.0183636956,
0.0052864756,
0.0390556343,
0.0345270336,
-0.0228773467,
0.0196856353,
-0.0440529995,
0.0376581103,
0.0401167385,
-0.0444591939,
0.0245393906,
-0.023947347,
-0.0249298457,
-0.0050607771,
-0.0181894992,
-0.0230068993,
-0.0445316434,
0.0548349209,
-0.0268705841,
0.031343177,
-0.0113468254,
0.0051032389,
0.0068000564,
0.074280858,
0.0447905213,
-0.0324274674,
-0.0135609163,
-0.0072595859,
2.728e-7,
-0.0159657411,
0.0102735618,
-0.0299245939,
0.0291528292,
0.024393905,
0.0942425057,
-0.0355384052,
0.0517401472,
-0.0158297103,
-0.0350540765,
0.005255979,
0.0072378647,
0.0465245619,
0.0527989268,
-0.0488849841,
-0.0079976451,
-0.0149975,
-0.0328488536,
-0.0438188687,
0.0150039829,
0.0211892091,
0.0835235268,
0.0273714699,
-0.0246085674,
0.0255230796,
-0.0783500299,
0.0345126837,
-0.0351751484,
0.0031799925,
-0.0198596474,
0.0182088576,
0.0015386251,
-0.0288953651,
0.0454144366,
0.0032694568,
-0.0050283913,
-0.0584807731,
0.0459228568,
-0.0280683711,
0.0089719724,
-0.0249391347,
-0.0739255324,
0.0026601385,
-0.0672897846,
0.0373090208,
-0.0219911858,
-0.0358295888,
-0.0442185029,
0.0038780256,
-0.0535839051,
0.0110420045,
-0.0113239745,
-0.0226927344,
0.0107259667,
-0.0136995865,
0.0214218218,
0.0391142257,
-0.0191168971,
-0.009087977,
0.0042797821,
-0.033802636,
-0.0304126814,
-0.003928801,
0.0304113291,
0.023672156,
-0.0367464051,
0.05838155,
2.269893596e-34,
0.0176140182,
-0.0250296257,
-0.0015848627,
0.0190162975,
0.0653775856,
0.0282979365,
0.039670866,
0.0124704139,
0.0442524403,
-0.0040107793,
-0.042846866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05472v1 | Text Representation Distillation via Information Bottleneck Principle | 2023-11-09T16:04:17 | 2023-11-09T16:04:17 | Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Zehan Li, Pengjun Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have recently shown great success in text
representation field. However, the high computational cost and high-dimensional
representation of PLMs pose significant challenges for practical applications.
To make models more accessible, an effective method is to distill large models
into smaller representation models. In order to relieve the issue of
performance degradation after distillation, we propose a novel Knowledge
Distillation method called IBKD. This approach is motivated by the Information
Bottleneck principle and aims to maximize the mutual information between the
final representation of the teacher and student model, while simultaneously
reducing the mutual information between the student model's representation and
the input data. This enables the student model to preserve important learned
information while avoiding unnecessary information, thus reducing the risk of
over-fitting. Empirical studies on two main downstream applications of text
representation (Semantic Textual Similarity and Dense Retrieval tasks)
demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach. | [
0.0205825828,
0.0387347974,
0.0031454335,
0.0449328646,
-0.0222691726,
0.0166723654,
0.0057309959,
0.040284764,
-0.008522247,
-0.0658381581,
-0.0426933318,
-0.0337731652,
-0.0199472215,
-0.0177227352,
-0.0048306976,
-0.0700838119,
0.0327231511,
-0.0359720886,
0.0169584136,
-0.0017374973,
0.0313039795,
0.0084222294,
0.0219767019,
-0.0110482378,
0.0011774427,
-0.0316257589,
0.0033461952,
-0.0012099779,
-0.020721525,
0.0032632558,
0.0021122012,
0.0513263643,
0.0438397676,
0.0102796527,
0.0000023771,
-0.0028819044,
-0.0252726935,
-0.0099538472,
-0.0381943546,
0.0718017593,
0.0407536067,
-0.0123887435,
0.0446267538,
-0.017646132,
-0.0290652793,
-0.0416362286,
0.0100746918,
0.0782933906,
0.0500419885,
0.0779797509,
-0.0090521052,
-0.0454579517,
0.0180937685,
-0.012144139,
0.0015686546,
-0.0330560394,
0.0322223119,
0.0230030566,
-0.0410203822,
0.0171710532,
-0.0197763927,
0.0614893511,
-0.0145008108,
0.0225210954,
0.0018470712,
-0.0014735308,
0.0078831287,
-0.0077127442,
0.0100552384,
0.0677772537,
-0.0486207865,
-0.0260422956,
-0.0204712711,
-0.0140076112,
-0.0141167687,
0.0109208999,
-0.0274168607,
-0.0126909763,
0.0015722218,
0.0450134613,
-0.0344814248,
0.0483611934,
0.0316065438,
0.0005763301,
-0.0670761764,
-0.0141271725,
-0.0018535701,
-0.0208152793,
-0.0148344804,
-0.0156070422,
-0.0417497978,
0.0257181916,
0.0285548661,
0.0133693963,
0.0627791509,
0.0061557186,
-0.0610149838,
-0.0447256938,
-0.0037236277,
-0.0429192297,
0.0305245854,
0.0468232334,
0.0257372186,
0.0276326928,
-0.0186137371,
0.0694347396,
0.0089448122,
0.0527043492,
-0.0441457704,
0.0178067498,
-0.0652852803,
-0.0074593588,
-0.0446370803,
0.0696371198,
-0.0056674499,
-0.0402871035,
0.0097974408,
0.022992868,
-0.0132382819,
-0.0686432868,
0.0019766625,
0.0022436646,
0.0063345181,
0.0005105572,
-0.0352622606,
0.0523282215,
-0.0043241722,
0.0169917904,
-0.0256885234,
-0.0189145394,
-0.0110695856,
0.0087757502,
0.0427082926,
-0.0076197879,
-0.0071902713,
0.0013667363,
-0.018189013,
-0.0532367453,
-0.0619476959,
-0.016845081,
0.0015583962,
-0.0738620833,
-0.0133127831,
-0.0716535524,
0.0712637454,
-0.0144839194,
0.010636569,
-0.1029866263,
-0.0106948093,
-0.0030359384,
-0.0427503176,
0.0776559263,
-0.0271673054,
0.0313244201,
0.0235161204,
0.0365976356,
0.0255677532,
0.0558962896,
-0.0025991371,
0.0153436167,
0.0032982894,
-0.0096635493,
-0.0153622925,
0.0181224607,
0.0398252346,
0.0025888151,
-0.0308380835,
-0.0131943468,
0.0052343472,
-0.0044648917,
0.0432391129,
0.0773572102,
-0.065613851,
0.043170508,
0.0648848489,
0.0317155011,
0.0532843657,
0.0254334081,
0.0072986265,
0.065233238,
0.0388389453,
0.0444656722,
0.0007985325,
-0.0312802047,
-0.0213367883,
-0.0071780467,
0.0580218434,
0.0451027937,
-0.052193027,
-0.0461037531,
0.0211412068,
-0.0249805916,
-0.0077937068,
0.0052461782,
0.0587925874,
0.024920959,
-0.0126413489,
0.082350269,
0.0339722745,
-0.0451651886,
0.018414611,
-0.0114421388,
0.0031953161,
0.0630057305,
0.0250253789,
-0.0746487156,
0.0396219492,
0.0244326107,
0.0151723651,
-0.0144188777,
0.0466948077,
-0.0015635553,
0.0079245325,
-0.0445338599,
-0.0453925245,
0.025127463,
0.0191774797,
-0.0135155637,
0.0027632392,
0.0186177026,
0.0752992257,
-0.036276754,
-0.0518904887,
0.0440031812,
-0.0174194444,
-0.0581261143,
-0.025257552,
0.0151572488,
0.0041513601,
-0.0009285617,
-0.0267092343,
0.0069600237,
0.0427663438,
-0.0304734707,
0.0202895924,
-0.0523968413,
-0.0776179358,
-0.0856779069,
0.0254193041,
-0.0033245441,
0.0643091649,
0.0251624808,
-0.0164655242,
-0.0758601576,
0.008377864,
0.0247233734,
0.0621464029,
-0.0437635295,
0.0504386537,
-0.0054629119,
0.0137505308,
-0.0438204668,
0.0554387383,
-0.0129376715,
-0.0036765514,
-0.0044196267,
-0.0187588986,
0.0050907834,
0.0004621067,
-0.0646077991,
0.0097046467,
-0.0024186645,
0.0528700873,
0.0189076215,
-0.0164400414,
0.0156761557,
-0.0064574396,
-0.0560174882,
0.0029929716,
-0.0297462251,
-0.005114208,
0.0176490955,
0.035689082,
0.0095683793,
-0.0362898037,
-0.0098511148,
-0.0149270091,
-0.011704498,
0.0035342453,
-0.0239271615,
0.0183730237,
0.025905285,
-0.0476757213,
-0.0234112032,
0.0341330953,
0.0482181646,
-0.0500348397,
-0.0450379364,
-0.019230986,
0.0705747381,
-0.0060217679,
0.0480355732,
-0.0153130889,
0.0098910443,
-0.013201966,
-0.0626742244,
0.0449017659,
-0.0002693747,
0.0056998851,
0.0041842954,
0.0518700816,
0.0228243414,
-0.0876220763,
0.0065584164,
-0.0338763818,
0.0433228426,
-0.0181476921,
-0.018038258,
0.0089037288,
0.0336060226,
0.0122016771,
-0.0207194593,
-0.0349326171,
-0.0191689059,
-0.0078177899,
0.0056202332,
-0.0926257074,
0.0029856106,
-0.0082455585,
-0.0009582501,
-0.0253169239,
-0.0489584468,
0.0248872153,
-0.0628270879,
0.0362512991,
-0.017269183,
-0.0233126134,
-0.0298205502,
0.0492218062,
0.0222141892,
0.0322794653,
-0.0135139972,
0.0153486738,
-0.0437579714,
0.0477170795,
0.0113154687,
-0.0245183688,
0.0590806082,
-0.0207430944,
0.0075987261,
0.0011668688,
-0.0091391113,
-0.0200878344,
-0.0869090259,
0.0130638285,
0.0022407721,
0.04062647,
0.0058081937,
-0.027890157,
0.0301595032,
0.0137197282,
0.0532339588,
-0.0059902794,
0.0024027221,
-0.0490071662,
0.0404280275,
0.0133136967,
-0.0156607907,
-0.0093998089,
-0.0086133117,
0.0355492122,
0.043554198,
0.0179089233,
-0.0046905484,
-0.0210576858,
0.0019899604,
0.0298242923,
-0.0075340373,
-0.0355809219,
-0.0048874207,
0.0156799015,
-0.0184543766,
-0.010116539,
0.1284717321,
0.013100761,
-0.0631697327,
-0.0127174919,
0.030275967,
0.0565940551,
0.0107256668,
0.0173143223,
-0.0356253982,
-0.0329731666,
-0.0286253616,
0.0014238085,
0.0422498696,
0.0064678863,
-0.0040865401,
-0.0634858459,
-0.0393233486,
0.0603266768,
0.0173276551,
-0.0472758338,
-0.0205883216,
-0.0352089182,
0.0220948476,
0.0054646726,
0.0055976384,
-0.0391437411,
0.0130473068,
0.0203920621,
-0.0351121761,
-0.0653902814,
-0.0283811335,
-0.0309593976,
-0.0009640566,
0.0301661454,
0.0302924272,
0.0101953344,
0.0027017663,
-0.0191212613,
-0.023015514,
-0.0091396933,
-0.0092445845,
0.0662090406,
0.0077678724,
0.0038292657,
0.015673358,
-0.0083255069,
-0.0361893959,
-0.0179052893,
-0.0030029211,
0.0512847565,
-0.0211935602,
-0.0249865055,
-0.0139020905,
-0.0467706211,
0.0069257421,
0.0868723765,
0.056583941,
-0.0202941243,
-0.0220529214,
0.0117413877,
0.0081859045,
-0.0232169498,
-0.0196868144,
0.0330837518,
-0.0363151953,
0.0107817957,
-0.0531973839,
-0.0048939753,
0.019827636,
0.0333725512,
-0.0075180852,
0.0410888828,
0.0074315574,
-0.0146214096,
-0.0195028037,
0.0040067905,
-0.0277119055,
-0.0401906073,
-0.0410939977,
-0.0311096665,
-0.0025010007,
-0.0382985622,
-0.0209155604,
-0.0140690207,
-0.0661779791,
-0.0572705343,
-0.0052667055,
0.0250972062,
0.0101834601,
0.0717427358,
-0.0056571756,
-0.0598198473,
0.1051985174,
-0.0110194003,
-0.0425995886,
0.0065640174,
-0.0028032034,
-0.0475604795,
-0.0011447063,
0.018048605,
-0.0234457608,
0.0441339463,
0.0079145003,
0.0118450513,
-0.0407425091,
-0.0599585958,
0.0111876968,
0.0562594607,
0.0407122709,
0.0310286693,
-0.0027104609,
-0.0394981541,
-0.002522652,
0.0050013629,
-0.0076174373,
-0.0623163246,
0.0031433422,
0.052489493,
-0.0089454483,
-0.0159129761,
0.0369459987,
0.0463059247,
-0.0145708928,
-0.0344207324,
-0.0362172015,
-0.0111406734,
0.0210795067,
0.0507571138,
0.0136101972,
0.0003575969,
0.0292717535,
-0.0258969013,
-0.0303310826,
-0.0486691147,
0.0167372599,
0.0064928094,
0.0144033162,
-0.0695234016,
0.0251807105,
-0.0687563866,
-0.0661555082,
-0.0498067215,
0.0070776562,
0.0244112257,
-0.0126101309,
0.0304437112,
-0.0176427811,
-0.0046876366,
-0.0364994593,
0.0148675963,
0.0200779494,
0.0175072663,
0.018667765,
0.0091178119,
-0.0208986476,
-0.00058348,
0.1087519601,
0.0361013263,
0.0245074313,
-0.021591939,
-0.0064702919,
-0.0375623517,
-0.0108813895,
0.022196088,
0.0851183608,
-0.0019966424,
-0.0127410796,
-0.0054051401,
-0.0385247357,
0.0230629425,
-0.0336614288,
-0.0332526453,
-0.0119907148,
0.0370175801,
0.0337450504,
-0.0117933108,
0.0135806799,
-0.0433135554,
-0.0110246614,
-0.0002966503,
-0.0158808324,
0.0070160534,
-7.020520991e-33,
-0.0258589853,
0.0402340889,
-0.007750663,
-0.0057277349,
-0.0335184895,
0.0161401685,
0.0099012367,
-0.0219573956,
-0.0054557519,
0.014277216,
-0.0121183656,
0.0182980206,
0.012434328,
0.0337810554,
-0.0459053591,
0.0213626083,
0.0715783015,
-0.0152225709,
0.0026602757,
0.0628946349,
0.0441544652,
0.0602574237,
0.0292925742,
-0.0549802631,
-0.0269884076,
-0.0517762266,
0.0228450391,
-0.0025998587,
0.0244660992,
0.0249188785,
-0.054173097,
0.0753503889,
0.0284234174,
-0.0251427423,
-0.0756792203,
0.0283621885,
-0.0837522075,
-0.0341121554,
0.0051219189,
0.0012931118,
-0.0066784373,
-0.016510481,
0.0686362237,
-0.0066830646,
0.0363643877,
0.0014999266,
0.040779829,
0.0034027621,
-0.0505653992,
-0.0128369285,
-0.0621759109,
0.020340031,
0.0050265389,
0.0017098277,
0.0985788703,
0.0148766395,
-0.026854286,
0.0105768079,
-0.1033800244,
-0.0003144985,
0.0320888236,
0.0830513686,
0.0050438717,
0.0410144776,
0.0075185783,
0.0755001083,
-0.0130070997,
-0.0250679124,
-0.0394002646,
-0.0091706449,
0.0859981254,
0.06267865,
0.001316973,
0.0265497882,
0.0464860909,
-0.0636291951,
-0.0560013242,
0.0249968097,
-0.0267318767,
-0.0123558464,
0.0231225081,
0.0068841069,
-0.0204740074,
-0.0583857521,
-0.0654710159,
0.005457784,
-0.0131611042,
-0.0138626425,
0.0444095023,
0.0171561968,
-0.025076488,
-0.0295313522,
0.0416884869,
-0.0539356247,
-0.0126374234,
0.0016379388,
-0.0227653291,
0.0268933717,
0.0026391624,
0.0062366626,
-0.0766206384,
-0.0662978888,
0.0119056469,
-0.0269514211,
-0.0126568573,
-0.0016395696,
0.0711266398,
0.017923791,
-0.0325007625,
-0.0229373612,
-0.0156645086,
-0.0520210341,
0.0471682772,
0.0335164629,
0.0242971964,
0.015321251,
-0.0051531764,
0.0195611082,
0.0391644761,
-0.032103844,
-0.0079544783,
-0.041228164,
0.0423384123,
0.033243604,
0.0034207953,
-0.0027155504,
-0.0516876057,
-0.0173821133,
0.0508947335,
-0.0482277162,
-0.0000720858,
0.030697355,
2.819e-7,
0.046990227,
-0.0110950284,
0.0121605434,
-0.0492692403,
0.0135175427,
0.0127665475,
0.0209733583,
0.0194051173,
-0.0173469428,
-0.021638291,
0.0549810641,
0.0587384552,
0.0278352052,
-0.0111313844,
-0.101101175,
-0.0119073018,
-0.0234105121,
-0.0131612131,
-0.0250088479,
-0.0353642479,
0.0572205596,
0.0758927837,
0.0033812718,
-0.0144998915,
-0.0047237636,
-0.0347367115,
0.0775704756,
-0.0307859145,
0.0441511013,
0.0653982311,
0.0488332659,
-0.0050595487,
-0.012213611,
0.0246555209,
-0.0041996227,
0.0233798269,
0.026063906,
0.0526805669,
-0.0280142091,
-0.0126758879,
-0.0085267005,
0.0164419301,
-0.0161092561,
-0.0348311439,
0.0953003466,
-0.0333238058,
0.0337417834,
0.0063017569,
-0.01302581,
-0.0249670874,
0.0026347418,
0.0356996022,
0.0192865245,
0.0478551313,
0.0030097624,
-0.0059824903,
-0.0256461762,
-0.0922837108,
-0.004371162,
-0.0141784912,
-0.0604571961,
-0.0118669914,
-0.0474096164,
-0.0522616133,
0.0336941704,
-0.0283005182,
0.0382368825,
2.532273119e-34,
0.0005665698,
0.0212998558,
0.0210801885,
0.0354692452,
-0.0079015875,
-0.0283519812,
-0.0493994765,
0.0211411938,
-0.0233276188,
-0.1162082106,
0.0045307791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05451v1 | All Should Be Equal in the Eyes of Language Models: Counterfactually Aware Fair Text Generation | 2023-11-09T15:39:40 | 2023-11-09T15:39:40 | Pragyan Banerjee, Abhinav Java, Surgan Jandial, Simra Shahid, Shaz Furniturewala, Balaji Krishnamurthy, Sumit Bhatia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Fairness in Language Models (LMs) remains a longstanding challenge, given the
inherent biases in training data that can be perpetuated by models and affect
the downstream tasks. Recent methods employ expensive retraining or attempt
debiasing during inference by constraining model outputs to contrast from a
reference set of biased templates or exemplars. Regardless, they dont address
the primary goal of fairness to maintain equitability across different
demographic groups. In this work, we posit that inferencing LMs to generate
unbiased output for one demographic under a context ensues from being aware of
outputs for other demographics under the same context. To this end, we propose
Counterfactually Aware Fair InferencE (CAFIE), a framework that dynamically
compares the model understanding of diverse demographics to generate more
equitable sentences. We conduct an extensive empirical evaluation using base
LMs of varying sizes and across three diverse datasets and found that CAFIE
outperforms strong baselines. CAFIE produces fairer text and strikes the best
balance between fairness and language modeling capability | [
0.0555797853,
0.0972979814,
-0.0268256869,
0.04789529,
-0.0240068529,
0.0252244435,
0.0411803685,
-0.0146683501,
-0.0344644152,
-0.0820566863,
-0.0240498446,
-0.0257680807,
0.001482666,
-0.0065166783,
0.023360325,
-0.0550109968,
0.0159119777,
0.0198110081,
0.0411696732,
-0.0572093464,
0.0221416634,
0.042700097,
0.0093901251,
0.0521286428,
-0.032072749,
0.0094402339,
0.0454938672,
0.030133592,
0.0063477466,
0.049319189,
0.0638095737,
0.086758852,
-0.008700083,
0.036885649,
0.000001885,
-0.0389561169,
0.0077129141,
0.0028893959,
-0.0085219732,
-0.0067116395,
0.0603633858,
-0.0338992439,
0.0044854428,
0.0307724625,
-0.0185787342,
0.0590983517,
0.0463798195,
0.0048134811,
0.0390570611,
0.0104445778,
0.0079556229,
0.0080075599,
-0.0522891916,
-0.0440595336,
-0.0106169106,
0.0097515797,
0.024070574,
-0.0112966159,
-0.0594459362,
-0.050592985,
-0.0130055696,
0.0297011994,
0.0465473458,
-0.0020738007,
0.0227621756,
0.0065734726,
-0.0275430232,
-0.0244212672,
-0.0039019184,
0.0460011214,
-0.0030520486,
-0.0259568486,
0.0032633683,
-0.0358077437,
0.0256545637,
-0.0090474039,
-0.0370809287,
0.0657642484,
-0.0222042557,
0.0330545567,
0.0197374281,
0.0256790631,
0.0271080509,
0.0470175073,
0.0119063398,
0.0670358017,
0.0248268209,
-0.0189807843,
-0.0340649262,
0.0640974641,
-0.0083778631,
-0.0406303145,
0.017949814,
-0.0212331507,
-0.027614804,
0.0060660481,
-0.0452061296,
-0.052158162,
0.0515917055,
-0.0337405987,
0.0086396318,
0.0170258582,
-0.003248567,
-0.010099154,
0.0305269379,
-0.0082440078,
0.0337650329,
0.0419227667,
-0.0289041642,
-0.0357337743,
0.0274163317,
-0.0283781234,
-0.0081301536,
-0.0067046587,
-0.0735058188,
0.0642768592,
-0.0507825054,
-0.0296962596,
-0.0601914003,
-0.0355617441,
0.0388061143,
0.0261359401,
-0.0661978871,
-0.0008129512,
-0.0034385275,
-0.0009687993,
-0.0330898501,
0.0302690752,
-0.0016634811,
-0.0762881115,
-0.0035875936,
-0.0043066931,
-0.037309207,
-0.0314704068,
-0.0261459108,
0.0696897656,
-0.0100006228,
0.0015910594,
-0.0405787192,
-0.0535701141,
-0.0096249329,
-0.047976926,
-0.0155439191,
-0.0645953789,
0.0098578185,
0.0119014978,
0.0094776573,
-0.0351061895,
-0.0150108254,
0.0101369033,
-0.0469624661,
0.0282465722,
0.0355947427,
-0.0035180775,
0.0464105308,
0.0161375813,
0.0008583638,
0.1110251993,
0.046632003,
-0.0232033823,
0.0369321145,
0.0300351847,
-0.0174921341,
0.0420735851,
0.0303490087,
0.0150838848,
-0.0504331812,
-0.0122439386,
-0.0164064523,
0.0072403173,
0.0739495382,
0.0566658229,
0.0099120187,
-0.0327694416,
0.053642679,
0.0069160634,
-0.0025845824,
0.0161403231,
0.0519970916,
-0.0039844424,
-0.061518725,
0.0517799072,
-0.0928508863,
-0.008268659,
-0.0022897425,
-0.0128330719,
0.0261306893,
0.0507830344,
-0.0177632626,
-0.0309902821,
-0.0081040328,
-0.0007718747,
0.0227525327,
-0.0061154859,
0.0154238259,
0.0317835733,
0.0065348367,
0.0465839058,
0.0588580333,
-0.0657601878,
0.0453455038,
-0.0643327087,
0.0189357288,
0.0358065218,
0.0083496524,
-0.0109365219,
0.0219791327,
-0.008830741,
-0.0282402076,
0.0800005049,
0.068580389,
0.0043769842,
0.0366686322,
-0.0601035468,
-0.0235338993,
0.0065698372,
0.0483136587,
0.0360495336,
0.0147510031,
0.0132628847,
0.0425493307,
-0.0445972309,
-0.0372923426,
0.0467386171,
-0.026805941,
-0.008400023,
0.0257072765,
0.0024290695,
-0.0137053188,
0.0061573209,
-0.0315461904,
-0.0029993802,
-0.0417184755,
-0.0202505309,
-0.003347975,
0.029756939,
-0.0876078159,
-0.054842256,
-0.0036096028,
-0.0698029697,
-0.0191982724,
0.0417537242,
-0.0362103954,
0.0107518611,
0.0649471134,
0.0126190111,
0.0060234931,
-0.0428826921,
0.0161196664,
0.0000647511,
0.0043552564,
-0.0465406962,
0.0425718985,
-0.0113310916,
-0.0163744856,
0.0165351853,
-0.0412764102,
-0.0064765974,
-0.044428356,
-0.0093909586,
0.0087913983,
-0.0126753524,
0.0157300737,
0.0435224958,
0.0386880971,
-0.0049279919,
0.0084864665,
-0.0415799618,
0.0012191911,
-0.0431058109,
-0.0183893424,
0.0366976298,
0.0298821423,
-0.0210822131,
-0.0156811066,
-0.0162338577,
-0.0413322225,
0.0370019749,
0.0096264444,
0.0202412121,
-0.014240684,
0.0143449241,
-0.0305696949,
-0.0477266647,
-0.026813427,
0.0694815218,
0.0509207472,
0.0196336657,
-0.0366380103,
-0.0192491282,
-0.0506612994,
0.007728532,
-0.003261124,
-0.0240763202,
0.0011776169,
0.0568056293,
0.0225989986,
0.0625073463,
0.0527889617,
0.0232908484,
0.0565926619,
-0.00386131,
-0.0411542132,
-0.0025471491,
-0.0017215615,
0.015701931,
0.0159057099,
-0.1019322425,
0.0045137163,
0.0766670927,
0.0498990342,
-0.0465076491,
-0.0817859173,
0.0292580258,
-0.0416732132,
-0.0656803995,
-0.0328890011,
-0.0368419848,
-0.0081883213,
-0.0025640414,
-0.0657978877,
-0.0692749545,
0.0728365108,
-0.0010795719,
0.0181189254,
-0.0267562363,
0.0129985986,
-0.0421471,
0.0212264638,
-0.0086131031,
0.0261090063,
0.0205326602,
-0.0051037362,
-0.0500262156,
-0.0155254658,
0.062338911,
-0.0232933052,
0.0386152491,
-0.0781142265,
-0.0098822154,
-0.0238445718,
-0.0527624413,
-0.058990784,
-0.0705205798,
-0.003919859,
0.0342420973,
0.0236025546,
-0.0094996532,
-0.0171237625,
0.0184412804,
-0.009534888,
0.0527611636,
-0.0397116169,
0.0299083665,
-0.0143163996,
-0.0191154722,
0.0364416875,
-0.0018981147,
0.0352055915,
-0.0647836551,
0.000410472,
0.0298240893,
0.0042095431,
0.023793539,
0.035572771,
0.0110401968,
0.0311938748,
-0.0277752839,
-0.0193299055,
0.0121174389,
0.0626181662,
-0.03765608,
0.0097008869,
0.1011413485,
0.0197878219,
-0.0455799475,
0.0209198557,
-0.0102823293,
0.0526379533,
0.0164575167,
-0.0159861073,
-0.0773149282,
-0.0163863059,
0.0213339664,
0.0472950228,
-0.0584237576,
-0.047332149,
-0.015657166,
-0.0822795108,
0.0274379477,
0.0399066545,
-0.0250673946,
-0.0263458248,
0.0200655479,
0.013222822,
-0.0057055322,
0.036901217,
0.0001588677,
0.0120578241,
0.0186080243,
0.0302577913,
0.0005322202,
-0.0412933603,
-0.017302487,
-0.0671062544,
0.0338474177,
0.0309406016,
0.0197347365,
0.0060802614,
-0.0000120102,
0.0319021083,
-0.0548516475,
-0.005500746,
-0.0322899371,
0.0270151291,
-0.0375932939,
0.0032031809,
-0.0466225632,
0.0355426855,
0.0184904914,
-0.0090185041,
0.0020499113,
-0.0009182,
0.0115496125,
-0.0401235558,
-0.0567959249,
0.0107884584,
0.0254319552,
0.1069025621,
0.0601651892,
-0.017910989,
-0.0192410927,
-0.0811872631,
-0.0027368658,
-0.0590408482,
-0.0031779322,
0.0270442273,
0.0051454962,
-0.0444505699,
-0.0512934178,
-0.0479858518,
-0.0100833811,
-0.0052713724,
-0.0012227386,
-0.0569217019,
0.0055758278,
-0.0484559163,
-0.0476457216,
0.0214329883,
-0.0619977862,
0.0310252104,
-0.0005613989,
-0.0522107184,
-0.0387131609,
-0.0418322347,
-0.035198953,
0.026384756,
-0.0642422736,
-0.0763714314,
0.0359732285,
0.0372110158,
0.0194810573,
0.0543293841,
0.0065750834,
-0.0414449163,
0.0449380502,
0.0597395822,
-0.0102808364,
0.0384251922,
0.0202155355,
-0.0352484956,
0.0295595787,
0.0465572029,
-0.0457224473,
0.0230956599,
0.0285839252,
0.0473689139,
0.0287342854,
-0.0424639285,
-0.0035142647,
0.0004262272,
-0.0063468008,
-0.0506300926,
-0.0243184734,
-0.0551745743,
-0.0113317026,
-0.0280574616,
-0.0575176738,
-0.0397498868,
0.0050465693,
-0.0279186331,
0.0354238078,
-0.0392144173,
-0.0089876205,
-0.0576037467,
0.04061158,
-0.0354854316,
0.033684209,
-0.0507154316,
0.0517899245,
-0.0029965658,
-0.0127003025,
-0.0122453002,
0.0242292229,
-0.0250868443,
0.0456638895,
0.0117712747,
0.0104963453,
0.0324504189,
0.0077502374,
-0.0523912385,
0.0028616658,
-0.0514297336,
0.037301071,
-0.0393380374,
0.012366049,
0.0479501672,
-0.0295391493,
0.0357329585,
-0.0152628142,
0.0147403274,
0.0039565205,
0.0269562528,
0.0455046259,
-0.019665746,
0.021318648,
-0.0288691483,
-0.0045033926,
-0.016159622,
0.0675676614,
0.0108472854,
0.0510827564,
-0.0357510671,
-0.0302761365,
-0.0281005818,
-0.0402203314,
0.0422636122,
-0.0172887556,
-0.0032683453,
-0.0182289705,
-0.0667508915,
-0.0617426336,
-0.0092681618,
0.0379387215,
0.0361463949,
-0.0080484757,
0.0109829959,
0.0602016747,
-0.0404639803,
-0.0641708076,
-0.0273164101,
0.0299363621,
-0.0165948216,
-0.0033585629,
-0.0246016178,
-6.251736666e-33,
-0.0321108103,
-0.0066826763,
-0.0336487144,
-0.0694484264,
-0.0159904547,
-0.0021191386,
-0.0165150259,
-0.0088946624,
0.0109592453,
0.0232967138,
0.0101493476,
0.0035770941,
0.0194931999,
0.0239589047,
0.0013814658,
-0.0236699693,
0.0648002476,
0.0190369878,
-0.0491873063,
0.0137083782,
-0.0357756726,
0.0232036784,
0.0687743872,
-0.026152648,
0.0601440892,
-0.0294468496,
-0.0032886951,
0.0302680284,
-0.0556052215,
0.027791094,
0.0040071635,
0.0742730573,
0.0511269942,
0.013082101,
-0.0214604866,
0.0247634631,
-0.034185756,
-0.0109411245,
0.045927301,
0.0141875967,
-0.0035727615,
-0.040364828,
0.0467640609,
0.0301186815,
-0.054616984,
-0.0205466505,
0.0525256582,
-0.008190277,
0.06047846,
0.0267192349,
-0.0279735439,
0.0212885905,
-0.0275083221,
0.0052416176,
-0.033516366,
0.0183957461,
-0.0001992318,
0.0236751251,
0.001313781,
0.0244381037,
0.0394241437,
0.0129991304,
0.0562193729,
0.0385548547,
-0.0022755242,
0.0344750769,
0.0188490134,
0.0157910325,
-0.0366979428,
-0.0707297251,
0.0355205983,
-0.0348384492,
0.0083071319,
0.1098489538,
0.052774962,
-0.0109483339,
-0.0426317938,
0.0115267364,
0.0107331676,
-0.0082147028,
0.0405547656,
-0.0306402314,
-0.040404696,
-0.0568889491,
-0.0440482795,
-0.0803845078,
-0.0076978174,
0.0191590637,
0.0234332643,
0.0204045903,
-0.0321068391,
0.0105315037,
0.0252230056,
-0.0177165009,
-0.0274826176,
0.0429359376,
-0.0052072904,
-0.050738126,
0.0078523355,
0.0318565555,
-0.0458346047,
0.0010971043,
0.0442689694,
0.0331436172,
-0.0016094089,
0.0239405595,
0.0137900142,
0.0066664382,
-0.0361094773,
0.0321232229,
-0.0191300362,
0.0441914164,
-0.0151003543,
0.0073633059,
0.0278840717,
0.0236638244,
-0.0029862502,
0.0071517592,
0.0128501737,
-0.0399647951,
-0.0522018522,
0.0213647708,
0.0016746037,
0.0616898164,
-0.0423595235,
-0.0140220914,
0.0212125145,
-0.0176907368,
0.0676626489,
-0.0392729491,
-0.0221364647,
-0.0346311368,
2.316e-7,
0.0264629386,
0.0108554661,
0.0196709409,
0.0085337292,
0.0017460849,
0.0485205837,
0.0287967939,
0.0514168777,
0.0373132303,
0.0363993607,
-0.0340201631,
0.0543730296,
0.0388140455,
0.0257299505,
-0.0401716605,
0.0274813622,
-0.1089439541,
0.0149906361,
-0.0257969126,
0.0013438832,
0.0150401974,
0.0340801552,
0.0197559688,
-0.0138527397,
-0.0038310736,
-0.0122482786,
0.0205736458,
-0.0355659723,
0.0099539002,
-0.0035831635,
0.0201563332,
-0.0226204935,
0.0452698618,
0.0543819778,
0.0077099325,
0.0144999502,
-0.0252923872,
0.0338721462,
-0.012687061,
0.0200352538,
-0.0217595212,
0.0071545206,
-0.0051185559,
-0.0601726323,
0.0232673176,
0.025894098,
-0.0175061729,
-0.0489088818,
-0.0056688776,
-0.0075162067,
0.0168468095,
-0.0363281518,
-0.0511172488,
0.0269836802,
0.0492615327,
0.0255317893,
-0.0129606361,
-0.047710903,
-0.0599708445,
-0.0391866155,
-0.0474283546,
-0.0463840403,
-0.00376262,
0.0242581833,
-0.0125789456,
-0.0418921448,
0.0592866205,
2.19928335e-34,
0.0187050365,
0.0344150662,
0.0045693512,
-0.0158384703,
0.0259137657,
0.0121655557,
0.0157859847,
-0.0055454397,
0.0344579518,
0.0064032217,
-0.0334547684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05450v1 | Cognitively Inspired Components for Social Conversational Agents | 2023-11-09T15:38:58 | 2023-11-09T15:38:58 | Alex Clay, Eduardo Alonso, Esther Mondragón | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0 | Current conversational agents (CA) have seen improvement in conversational
quality in recent years due to the influence of large language models (LLMs)
like GPT3. However, two key categories of problem remain. Firstly there are the
unique technical problems resulting from the approach taken in creating the CA,
such as scope with retrieval agents and the often nonsensical answers of former
generative agents. Secondly, humans perceive CAs as social actors, and as a
result expect the CA to adhere to social convention. Failure on the part of the
CA in this respect can lead to a poor interaction and even the perception of
threat by the user. As such, this paper presents a survey highlighting a
potential solution to both categories of problem through the introduction of
cognitively inspired additions to the CA. Through computational facsimiles of
semantic and episodic memory, emotion, working memory, and the ability to
learn, it is possible to address both the technical and social problems
encountered by CAs. | [
0.0931989402,
0.0120201102,
-0.0574373864,
0.0217396133,
-0.0297875777,
0.0006659818,
-0.0110885967,
-0.0133393509,
0.0459667854,
-0.032633625,
-0.0237278324,
-0.0477287769,
-0.0184185766,
0.0257129278,
-0.0004834225,
-0.0756600127,
0.0324180685,
-0.0098692887,
0.0623074844,
-0.0352697372,
-0.0012134933,
-0.0109561579,
0.0115793524,
0.0428770334,
-0.0215565711,
-0.0030566819,
-0.0311241634,
-0.0211987253,
0.0308997612,
-0.0025177812,
0.0171149448,
-0.0095821163,
0.0274292212,
0.0443265066,
0.0000021251,
-0.068700552,
-0.0087004127,
-0.0131399389,
-0.0141620254,
-0.0295510087,
0.0540715232,
0.0474266261,
-0.0250685737,
0.0143762259,
-0.0983971134,
0.0114908516,
0.0501164682,
0.0350724682,
0.0615632981,
0.0649496615,
-0.0214527901,
-0.0354396477,
0.027864771,
0.0150947068,
0.0235561859,
-0.057985384,
-0.0003521629,
0.0157032236,
0.0403348282,
-0.0074777538,
-0.0021897973,
0.0398947001,
0.0100855203,
-0.01443554,
0.0315077268,
0.0147669287,
-0.0470378362,
-0.0526567474,
-0.0343020521,
0.0319729336,
0.0551429167,
-0.0211579744,
0.0095027806,
0.0143745663,
0.0518536866,
0.027354816,
-0.0493951552,
0.0170579664,
0.0011388775,
0.0095993504,
-0.0061235735,
0.0170430653,
-0.0306991395,
-0.0072007244,
-0.0002930373,
0.0508027896,
-0.0109864026,
-0.0023713899,
0.0005227186,
-0.043371629,
-0.0120925196,
-0.0086166402,
0.0269536301,
0.0602084734,
-0.0307674035,
0.0231756363,
-0.0252933167,
0.0219024215,
-0.0088292733,
-0.077394098,
0.0103632975,
0.0415101126,
0.0196419545,
0.009516106,
-0.0066377851,
0.0474641211,
-0.0112058772,
-0.0014106743,
-0.0116359713,
-0.017835157,
-0.0732520297,
-0.0371391885,
-0.0904093087,
0.0703922361,
-0.0040720683,
-0.0244166087,
-0.0417948551,
0.0726435855,
-0.0186548922,
0.0219053645,
-0.0118512707,
0.0204366855,
-0.0191459283,
0.0316333622,
-0.049743291,
-0.0142635982,
-0.0488355048,
-0.0024155928,
0.0310625341,
-0.0945881978,
0.0063982247,
-0.0076882443,
0.0185053758,
0.0039205416,
-0.0110624973,
0.058790721,
-0.0170174036,
-0.0699956939,
-0.0320896134,
-0.0082670953,
-0.022940794,
-0.076587297,
-0.010274427,
-0.0065729888,
0.033820834,
0.0007780747,
-0.0344836488,
-0.0581399128,
0.0185501296,
0.0014381598,
-0.0031672167,
0.0305880867,
-0.014377553,
0.006299891,
0.0324299149,
0.0280765034,
0.0024168787,
0.0311073288,
0.052147992,
0.0187322497,
0.0256958324,
-0.015029138,
0.0489293262,
-0.0058089909,
-0.0033503075,
-0.0229613483,
0.0233786441,
0.0004385907,
0.0306378379,
-0.0121343853,
-0.0060934811,
0.0728167221,
-0.0291744582,
-0.0178080294,
0.0504930392,
0.0400598794,
-0.0155797265,
0.0422316082,
0.0142689478,
0.0384580716,
0.0376542285,
0.0294638481,
-0.0160363931,
0.0441822298,
-0.0517607592,
-0.0042319964,
-0.0482463501,
0.0176912025,
-0.0591199659,
-0.0285311881,
0.0361719392,
-0.0089974636,
0.0674141347,
-0.0039109224,
-0.0093258722,
-0.0020773776,
-0.039885737,
-0.0078864396,
-0.0108166412,
-0.0970046967,
-0.0579167157,
-0.0615679622,
0.0308741797,
0.0572710633,
0.0300151464,
-0.0034904685,
-0.016428927,
0.0323475003,
-0.0474748388,
0.0373894908,
0.033970017,
-0.0193429161,
0.008430589,
-0.0384678505,
0.0265651084,
-0.0130425002,
-0.01765568,
0.0182071999,
-0.0180676039,
0.0334967859,
0.0207852013,
0.057682056,
0.0311025865,
-0.0154264132,
0.0009330827,
0.0013490551,
-0.0609060004,
0.0033969199,
0.0520374812,
0.018677596,
0.0200707037,
0.0031064928,
0.0278509986,
0.013714971,
0.0020412921,
0.0771796405,
-0.0449502841,
-0.0018389112,
0.0262122732,
0.0202570837,
0.008937994,
0.0106567685,
0.0101130307,
-0.0531972349,
0.0658205152,
-0.0734574869,
0.110784471,
-0.0501437485,
0.0555923171,
-0.0159802735,
0.0301849134,
0.01577341,
0.0462669097,
0.0160841756,
-0.0537320822,
0.00719416,
0.0557553582,
0.0090831695,
-0.077659741,
-0.0092709912,
0.0375638455,
0.0110257734,
0.0069039892,
0.0486099422,
-0.0298414789,
-0.0690497905,
-0.0584106296,
-0.058975216,
-0.044693917,
0.0075287833,
-0.0234855786,
-0.0228674132,
-0.0014537645,
-0.0255518313,
-0.0063900049,
-0.0600511543,
0.0662814602,
0.0303943772,
0.0127186654,
-0.0035652136,
0.0070881359,
-0.0653232262,
-0.0592088476,
0.0304538012,
0.0051510893,
-0.0061089215,
0.0091938935,
-0.056246195,
-0.0420930497,
0.0746132359,
-0.0755891353,
0.0594951622,
-0.0327054821,
-0.0625785366,
0.0431683026,
-0.0102612916,
0.0389612243,
0.0717718825,
0.034882009,
0.0657741949,
-0.0017209457,
-0.0499243625,
-0.0613574684,
0.0417908169,
-0.0364664383,
-0.0051316372,
-0.033757396,
-0.0104525657,
0.0085707698,
0.0212775115,
0.0120140538,
0.0239498597,
-0.0741364509,
0.0285876244,
0.050686948,
-0.0704213381,
0.0130670862,
-0.047913637,
-0.0398753695,
-0.0012432757,
0.013426804,
-0.0181249063,
0.0498177335,
-0.0100623732,
-0.0378373265,
-0.0126236798,
-0.0220696665,
-0.0162847918,
0.0743162036,
-0.019722173,
-0.0047276122,
0.0116298534,
-0.015265421,
-0.0419685245,
-0.0487628318,
0.0182623882,
-0.0529240891,
-0.023218099,
-0.0288939513,
-0.0019944559,
0.0288071297,
-0.0152575979,
-0.0382668152,
0.0435695089,
-0.0304298047,
0.0251587257,
0.0136406571,
0.0039362703,
-0.0522474721,
0.0236499012,
0.0308648385,
-0.0110914065,
0.0090920199,
-0.0203699581,
-0.0214238241,
0.0005393371,
0.044082161,
0.043767184,
-0.0097637419,
-0.0045695114,
0.0786805674,
0.0666364133,
0.0593550727,
-0.063467212,
-0.0002194171,
0.0100214686,
0.0276163407,
-0.0022175964,
-0.0373196863,
0.0272459239,
0.0463910475,
-0.0330574922,
-0.0129562113,
0.0989816114,
0.0170889068,
-0.033450231,
0.0066830181,
-0.0516965091,
0.0000337599,
0.0251145661,
0.0175597928,
-0.015575381,
0.0135041019,
0.0025920393,
0.0034953821,
-0.0665393695,
-0.0205571353,
-0.0046621063,
-0.0922706798,
0.0733193681,
0.0114551233,
-0.0220374223,
-0.01718444,
0.0006665125,
0.0009183366,
0.0310933404,
0.0090632252,
0.0086478274,
0.0094428239,
-0.0203353986,
-0.0038593702,
-0.0234321356,
0.0025715092,
0.0151688512,
-0.0032816378,
0.109391734,
0.045672603,
0.0653644577,
0.0233254265,
-0.060100276,
-0.0212790836,
-0.0007883023,
0.0288657751,
-0.010470259,
0.0167065989,
-0.0224111602,
0.0122833438,
-0.0362950079,
0.0198436659,
0.0209496133,
-0.032984715,
0.010917522,
0.0281696524,
-0.0615269952,
-0.0296712797,
-0.004677414,
0.0305559859,
0.0168291088,
0.0521642864,
0.0175760966,
-0.0201275311,
-0.0084712524,
0.0054967166,
0.017438544,
0.0018465385,
-0.0286210254,
-0.0023141438,
0.0274127182,
-0.0393049568,
-0.0528350361,
-0.091854535,
0.0136334905,
0.0422916822,
-0.0160828587,
0.0007770322,
0.0302251894,
0.0084435316,
-0.0004919125,
-0.0393864103,
-0.030561734,
-0.0154474536,
-0.0266862083,
-0.0331455208,
0.0007243439,
-0.0634122044,
0.0219851211,
-0.0197525937,
-0.0094049433,
-0.054067757,
0.0262964293,
0.0559234917,
0.0361489356,
0.0112581095,
0.0154523011,
-0.0410992503,
0.0033875925,
0.0058004833,
-0.039574489,
0.04505549,
0.0272043291,
0.0496328957,
0.0022916186,
0.0353131965,
-0.0163949151,
0.0291807465,
-0.0192976501,
0.0547559969,
-0.0354146324,
-0.0259773526,
0.0375769585,
0.0438970439,
0.009880852,
0.0424279645,
0.0214148127,
-0.0037496553,
0.0083209146,
-0.0510864034,
0.0114990612,
-0.0562777109,
-0.0068703922,
-0.0419211723,
0.0130636506,
0.026756689,
-0.0824918747,
-0.0545289144,
0.0219116639,
0.0038485972,
-0.0001908284,
0.0052901586,
-0.0113468366,
-0.0057686372,
0.0380417258,
-0.0039053613,
0.0392102189,
0.0134546878,
0.0462269709,
0.018109357,
0.0881929323,
0.001766591,
-0.0655606389,
0.0073319222,
0.0514410883,
-0.0826956704,
-0.0254781768,
0.0155728208,
0.0720928088,
-0.0086364038,
0.0260272175,
0.037991751,
-0.0658293143,
0.0376968272,
-0.0049543139,
0.0012949816,
0.0242430363,
-0.0759763643,
0.0084369779,
0.0028379541,
-0.0316614658,
0.0049443329,
0.022261411,
-0.063341327,
0.0256037358,
-0.0571890213,
-0.0138012925,
-0.04578536,
-0.0594196841,
0.0155843617,
0.0036868933,
0.0002137698,
-0.0149241826,
-0.0920733139,
-0.0468550511,
-0.0030352089,
0.0008471378,
0.0097442651,
-0.0470611863,
0.0533410944,
0.0285832603,
-0.0075988402,
-0.0266920198,
-0.0230790228,
0.0130480351,
-0.0635856166,
0.0107740769,
-0.0190745555,
-6.227146793e-33,
-0.0410241894,
-0.0000383025,
0.019164877,
0.0432265736,
-0.0406085886,
-0.0368041471,
-0.0691516027,
0.0111199226,
-0.0223362576,
-0.0122910552,
-0.0409911945,
0.0297378879,
0.0198056083,
-0.023142511,
-0.0322303995,
-0.0053140507,
0.0203699544,
0.0136272237,
-0.0343874209,
0.0369992219,
0.0435708202,
-0.002345958,
0.0073748888,
-0.0855779424,
0.0296574198,
-0.012978375,
-0.0125196986,
0.0115501359,
0.0325242989,
0.0384088568,
0.0038402004,
0.0506415255,
-0.0047945026,
0.015510451,
0.0068362583,
0.0198997855,
-0.0210494716,
-0.0388449617,
0.0336694196,
-0.004973154,
-0.009359275,
-0.0453343801,
-0.0202574469,
-0.0428527594,
-0.0516684577,
0.0585167743,
0.0029826656,
-0.017631704,
-0.0087015368,
0.0008136636,
-0.0757913366,
-0.0063156076,
-0.0067479969,
0.0109301787,
-0.0202913787,
0.0465497039,
0.0006913298,
-0.0123403026,
-0.0417243205,
0.0417152122,
-0.0343415178,
-0.020538209,
0.0120422523,
0.0131236939,
0.0391312204,
0.0458134748,
0.0473660864,
0.0409945175,
-0.0335309729,
-0.0332211144,
0.0189893004,
0.0468302444,
0.0177220535,
0.0578819029,
-0.0514742918,
-0.0555753969,
0.0148002673,
0.0249554738,
0.067032814,
0.0424775146,
0.0389445871,
0.0346673541,
-0.0519765355,
-0.008726133,
0.0027744705,
0.0529106259,
-0.0172659419,
-0.0510534085,
0.0207585059,
-0.0053949738,
-0.0174385365,
-0.0590493269,
0.0217955597,
-0.0333202258,
0.0426871441,
-0.0056133233,
-0.0379684567,
0.0470745042,
-0.0083860587,
0.0132247545,
-0.0167856086,
-0.0495683402,
0.0209970865,
0.015805319,
0.0106198881,
0.0277910121,
-0.0404064842,
0.0719881803,
-0.0062922211,
0.0070583397,
-0.0183962714,
0.0481187925,
-0.0206979997,
-0.067564331,
-0.0297806524,
0.026015358,
-0.0331921317,
-0.0168141164,
-0.0044528223,
0.004399315,
-0.0311423279,
-0.0071821776,
0.0067490553,
0.0158092417,
-0.0458375439,
0.004828576,
-0.0310905408,
0.0451407358,
0.0295387246,
-0.0192505978,
0.0110332789,
-0.0204175469,
3.054e-7,
-0.062957637,
0.0183542632,
0.0121398568,
-0.0214690045,
0.026297858,
0.0370757207,
0.0263399407,
0.0468291491,
0.0508945733,
-0.0097955633,
0.0352984294,
0.0493752062,
0.0399985611,
0.0076105585,
-0.0634111315,
-0.0092855357,
-0.0406834558,
-0.0601037182,
0.0071825041,
0.0296673737,
0.0615189672,
0.0392539464,
0.0502904654,
-0.0066511761,
-0.0380874947,
-0.0155796427,
0.0485144444,
-0.0452424884,
-0.0032237824,
0.0216135569,
-0.005386807,
0.0277993176,
0.0073545421,
0.019277988,
0.0371962152,
0.0403113812,
-0.02522007,
0.0048348596,
-0.0181972086,
-0.0621879287,
0.0308436751,
0.0080647236,
-0.0172679015,
-0.0255896468,
0.0243881401,
-0.0460956022,
-0.0432021916,
0.0407342538,
-0.0186264385,
-0.0063476129,
-0.0367231779,
-0.0096565858,
-0.0412174948,
0.0029068184,
-0.0331453755,
-0.0090961801,
0.0266850498,
-0.0588678941,
0.0477852039,
-0.0383128524,
-0.0122482777,
-0.0985233635,
-0.0129609993,
-0.0061982446,
0.026626572,
-0.0242557991,
0.0232072342,
2.177253392e-34,
0.026176041,
0.0262998939,
0.0295884032,
0.0332859419,
0.0361453928,
0.022813879,
0.0042319326,
0.0391311795,
0.0753407776,
-0.0556611195,
-0.0264374297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05437v1 | LLaVA-Plus: Learning to Use Tools for Creating Multimodal Agents | 2023-11-09T15:22:26 | 2023-11-09T15:22:26 | Shilong Liu, Hao Cheng, Haotian Liu, Hao Zhang, Feng Li, Tianhe Ren, Xueyan Zou, Jianwei Yang, Hang Su, Jun Zhu, Lei Zhang, Jianfeng Gao, Chunyuan Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | LLaVA-Plus is a general-purpose multimodal assistant that expands the
capabilities of large multimodal models. It maintains a skill repository of
pre-trained vision and vision-language models and can activate relevant tools
based on users' inputs to fulfill real-world tasks. LLaVA-Plus is trained on
multimodal instruction-following data to acquire the ability to use tools,
covering visual understanding, generation, external knowledge retrieval, and
compositions. Empirical results show that LLaVA-Plus outperforms LLaVA in
existing capabilities and exhibits new ones. It is distinct in that the image
query is directly grounded and actively engaged throughout the entire human-AI
interaction sessions, significantly improving tool use performance and enabling
new scenarios. | [
0.0220018551,
0.0105553744,
-0.010448372,
0.0191311985,
-0.0012482677,
-0.004594529,
0.0234599095,
-0.0324418657,
0.0047962214,
-0.0693451688,
-0.0622381456,
-0.0015556932,
-0.054392267,
0.0373883694,
0.0379975326,
-0.082347624,
0.0301630702,
-0.0024184212,
-0.0414250381,
0.023983445,
-0.0014457637,
0.032153111,
-0.0578083731,
0.0622347482,
-0.0750983357,
0.0136098443,
-0.0591452047,
0.0031999326,
0.0109759225,
-0.0296106357,
-0.023342669,
0.0162866674,
0.0632471442,
-0.019363163,
0.000001905,
-0.0365992747,
0.0242732447,
-0.0242780522,
0.0218914915,
-0.0739000961,
0.0376834609,
0.0114360442,
0.0242581014,
-0.0129173324,
-0.043414548,
0.0208772216,
0.0603631027,
0.0046667703,
0.0896502584,
0.0329141878,
-0.0275698751,
-0.0275875125,
-0.0015634624,
0.0129067153,
0.0080148689,
-0.0280838851,
-0.0229905546,
0.0105308481,
0.059571974,
-0.0121835936,
-0.0346754119,
0.0222352874,
0.0373427086,
-0.0285262931,
0.0278436709,
0.0612953603,
0.0038633763,
-0.0798609182,
-0.0116638839,
0.0934755281,
-0.0115509424,
0.0241939053,
-0.0134921931,
0.0216941386,
-0.0022822565,
0.0185553674,
-0.0444894135,
0.0236137081,
-0.0316354781,
-0.0190215595,
-0.0690868869,
-0.0147882104,
-0.0020170861,
0.0006448322,
0.0106454715,
-0.0028673103,
0.0072451653,
0.0329344794,
0.050865937,
-0.0095049562,
-0.0243758,
-0.0520855859,
-0.0066016316,
0.0702591315,
-0.0309440624,
0.016995335,
-0.0432262905,
-0.0063280659,
-0.0096433088,
-0.0342946127,
0.0516632758,
0.0285089705,
-0.0805359781,
0.0620056391,
-0.0196829773,
0.0055246013,
-0.0212720633,
0.0610048361,
-0.0266431663,
-0.0191515889,
-0.0518241003,
-0.0225618128,
-0.017552115,
0.0018471743,
-0.0474334396,
-0.0569408052,
-0.0039599631,
0.0443263799,
-0.0277689025,
-0.0172748454,
-0.0347655863,
0.0204898175,
-0.0412661657,
0.0035685168,
-0.0596731715,
0.020691419,
-0.0260330942,
0.040673919,
-0.0003268428,
-0.0455540344,
0.0119179208,
0.038676668,
-0.0035052609,
-0.0091157379,
-0.0109552806,
0.0950631127,
-0.0810864568,
-0.0410145745,
-0.0455378778,
-0.0370444916,
0.0301769618,
-0.0510340445,
0.0337775797,
-0.0082239658,
0.041478429,
-0.043120902,
-0.0293019488,
-0.0513551123,
0.0142366225,
0.0069830925,
0.0287157092,
0.0798060149,
0.0069734929,
0.0154311741,
0.0256392229,
0.0204097442,
-0.0324575007,
0.0381361544,
0.010249,
0.0482758582,
0.0097574154,
0.0054249675,
0.0138344644,
0.034140233,
0.0013816603,
-0.0084519917,
-0.0145518249,
0.0144244069,
-0.0243817437,
0.0317040719,
0.0359418727,
0.0102350125,
-0.0471298471,
-0.0103543615,
0.0527650714,
0.0172740333,
0.0240282305,
-0.0227800123,
0.0663991049,
-0.0081961472,
-0.0018704897,
-0.0169671681,
-0.0459613241,
0.1057072878,
0.005504169,
-0.0207528248,
-0.0052768206,
0.0272531603,
-0.0358406305,
-0.0246181581,
0.0246931706,
-0.0094942823,
0.0146689555,
0.0236935187,
0.044482071,
-0.0029678172,
-0.0344031006,
-0.0197334494,
-0.0048708338,
-0.06167401,
0.0155370291,
-0.046408724,
0.0280191265,
0.0635094568,
0.0067983945,
-0.0136454795,
-0.0249009244,
0.0046391082,
0.036514692,
0.0392163843,
-0.0239945203,
-0.03685119,
0.0610831492,
-0.0339036994,
-0.051850751,
-0.0486958884,
-0.0169742759,
0.0433012694,
-0.0040226681,
-0.0176503863,
0.0208228342,
-0.0179572664,
0.0485763587,
0.0597257577,
-0.0019390286,
0.0044665048,
-0.0477454513,
0.0557461977,
0.0210421868,
-0.002925796,
-0.0063404297,
0.0012795038,
0.0145593351,
-0.0169266257,
0.0195686072,
0.0600516982,
0.0027595838,
0.0156300161,
0.0148435105,
-0.0547214784,
0.0448612198,
-0.0131703755,
0.0228243358,
-0.0222258326,
0.0190780926,
0.0069558411,
0.0047257785,
-0.0456408672,
-0.0241797492,
0.0344717912,
0.0040117679,
-0.0108832354,
0.0229033008,
-0.0258821137,
-0.0396822691,
0.0016387298,
0.0174561739,
0.0156024657,
-0.0051649949,
0.0165189113,
0.0262141116,
0.0284730177,
0.0249732025,
0.0124980174,
0.0070293336,
-0.0616234019,
-0.0108136656,
-0.0776802078,
-0.0093061356,
-0.0062411386,
-0.0521799922,
-0.0142381303,
-0.0170866363,
-0.0042236554,
-0.0511683971,
-0.0135274706,
0.0466044545,
0.0095584458,
0.0272839628,
0.0173434298,
0.0541034527,
0.0150119355,
-0.0363937914,
0.0160104018,
0.0113781039,
0.0222230125,
0.0357423276,
-0.0223874748,
-0.0005478711,
0.0166482106,
-0.0492546633,
0.0257740524,
-0.0343537629,
-0.0222409535,
0.0617967658,
-0.0478170961,
0.0120135425,
0.0809434876,
-0.0087013459,
0.0728602037,
0.0492222533,
-0.0217369013,
-0.05083194,
0.0341471434,
0.0084776757,
-0.0397862792,
-0.0280972496,
0.0496484302,
0.0113769183,
0.0103887813,
0.0148705263,
0.0086438591,
-0.0596050099,
0.0164600406,
0.042790249,
-0.108674489,
-0.0203147121,
0.0330772884,
0.0063642263,
0.0291022547,
-0.0558071844,
-0.0564535297,
0.0337994359,
-0.0039443206,
-0.0319903418,
0.0294127557,
0.0029720515,
-0.0008922915,
0.0644242764,
0.0115112131,
0.0380634703,
-0.043847505,
0.0059572104,
-0.0557116084,
0.0031302809,
0.0109530045,
0.0053955936,
0.0176898707,
-0.0701065063,
0.0137863103,
-0.0069838441,
-0.0145309046,
-0.0252116546,
0.0096900193,
0.0152472686,
-0.010809632,
-0.0366764031,
0.0148084117,
-0.0273939576,
0.0010016441,
0.0329378694,
-0.0039215051,
0.006148749,
-0.0335244462,
-0.030786112,
-0.0000030807,
0.0479813144,
0.023763163,
-0.0454121456,
-0.0672531873,
0.0032466971,
0.0254689474,
0.0085950121,
-0.0679824129,
-0.050300464,
0.0512476787,
0.0100994734,
0.0075224186,
-0.0176622495,
0.0681065544,
0.0611113347,
-0.0235406291,
0.0250881575,
0.0325583518,
0.0147872726,
-0.0179510862,
-0.0113816774,
0.0326502733,
-0.0127119934,
0.0735237449,
0.0350402892,
-0.0687100887,
-0.0455544293,
-0.0083618239,
-0.0169347245,
0.0308285058,
-0.0332429744,
-0.0396588147,
-0.0703815445,
0.0713075846,
0.0016009693,
-0.0198510047,
0.0136300549,
0.0127866948,
0.045920521,
0.0137053393,
-0.0425114445,
0.0327666029,
-0.0073549864,
0.0211834162,
0.0220267512,
0.0689404607,
-0.0315591097,
-0.0130047146,
-0.04486233,
-0.0208098739,
0.0416359641,
0.0138275353,
0.0182806235,
-0.0582141764,
-0.019882055,
0.0237532407,
0.035710834,
-0.0178758316,
0.0541035943,
-0.0312089566,
-0.0304299053,
-0.0047345613,
0.0563013852,
-0.0117031755,
0.0170135461,
-0.0302081034,
0.0250710249,
-0.0519232452,
0.01798358,
-0.0469224863,
0.0092922496,
0.0229872204,
-0.0085537573,
-0.0013587797,
-0.012948947,
-0.0223045181,
-0.0010911069,
-0.0171500184,
-0.0596216097,
-0.0188504681,
0.0331202298,
-0.0464285836,
-0.0013745113,
-0.0481260121,
-0.0265745241,
0.0768580586,
0.083082214,
0.0134548964,
-0.0223550331,
-0.0375266746,
0.0407984108,
-0.0466890968,
0.0331964754,
0.0227485765,
0.0453780964,
-0.0091487151,
-0.0329730734,
0.0119151212,
-0.0562272258,
-0.0053449408,
0.0071605332,
-0.0364476442,
-0.037735004,
-0.0499598719,
0.0908428356,
0.016431408,
0.0172794573,
0.047685083,
-0.0267765149,
-0.0061168619,
0.0022450925,
-0.0301320087,
0.0130374162,
-0.0040999409,
-0.0095212357,
0.0085120732,
-0.003656887,
-0.0507120788,
0.0181976762,
-0.0192290843,
0.0085929651,
0.0106521342,
-0.0562477149,
0.0307892486,
-0.0005203712,
-0.015383644,
-0.0402595885,
0.0458535179,
-0.0611450151,
-0.0080969399,
0.021128431,
-0.0006314375,
-0.074319154,
0.0205507427,
-0.0167516507,
0.0111776814,
0.0283324718,
-0.0047324863,
0.0294095799,
0.0282235984,
-0.0259621032,
0.014625595,
0.0352659635,
0.0099359006,
-0.0209093057,
0.0486084037,
0.0125369476,
0.0443107039,
-0.0284480564,
0.0472011566,
0.0097378613,
0.0898902267,
0.0054843454,
-0.0145534379,
-0.0297729019,
0.0576093756,
0.0025161444,
-0.0548311248,
-0.0037367407,
0.0394718461,
0.069134526,
0.0020884804,
0.0092914551,
-0.0428908579,
0.0045860219,
-0.0100994613,
0.0748068914,
-0.0047687921,
-0.0427432843,
0.0341648422,
-0.0105110798,
0.0246778056,
-0.0410156697,
0.0540051758,
-0.0252296608,
0.0617791526,
-0.0325751193,
0.0031353873,
-0.0481613614,
-0.0407440588,
0.0594677739,
0.0346596465,
0.0134003526,
0.0521817133,
-0.0108532077,
-0.0230787247,
-0.019239597,
0.019752726,
-0.0530039929,
0.0060556619,
0.061371047,
0.0703982562,
0.0127209825,
-0.026249595,
-0.0300986692,
-0.0450505465,
-0.0366809964,
0.0235952903,
0.0387260243,
-5.347707674e-33,
-0.0498791896,
-0.0290252063,
0.0830793679,
-0.0131329168,
-0.0242015328,
-0.0353740454,
-0.031869974,
0.0003529564,
-0.0219315495,
-0.0033793682,
0.0288124327,
-0.0124198934,
-0.0109466454,
-0.0146644702,
0.0365463495,
0.0064073903,
0.0242011733,
-0.0027206158,
0.0074025788,
0.0127801178,
0.0661361441,
0.0254248325,
0.0243706889,
-0.0562543869,
-0.0199514925,
0.0324178375,
-0.0354319476,
0.0305092484,
0.0035132137,
0.0742432177,
-0.0074799638,
0.0228429884,
0.0110601904,
0.0223377887,
-0.0251089875,
-0.0230473951,
-0.0592165403,
-0.0016360425,
0.0036016773,
0.0296784248,
-0.107742995,
-0.0268268976,
0.048497986,
-0.0174378678,
0.0160870589,
-0.0135425283,
0.0465377159,
-0.0258476958,
0.0077642747,
-0.0044656484,
-0.0646751449,
-0.0131178275,
-0.0385589376,
-0.0878072232,
0.0281257592,
0.0489684194,
0.0309190135,
-0.015128646,
-0.0288948584,
0.0420358218,
-0.0422164351,
-0.014594635,
0.0800632611,
0.0362842903,
0.0227017514,
0.0719741881,
0.012892521,
-0.0653964728,
-0.0061943363,
0.0067413175,
0.0305503476,
0.1199536547,
-0.0558782667,
0.0652489066,
-0.0357537903,
-0.0066929157,
-0.0155857075,
0.0688885301,
-0.0097736949,
0.084719561,
-0.019457493,
0.0290465858,
0.0078958487,
0.0337975286,
-0.0085193701,
-0.0149464998,
-0.0182627141,
-0.0495254993,
0.0577092655,
0.0157544352,
0.0376732387,
-0.0126110502,
0.0761060417,
-0.0105652576,
0.030697098,
-0.011891501,
-0.0489678904,
0.0443004183,
-0.0107294908,
-0.0038092248,
-0.0306773391,
-0.0326320268,
0.064647831,
-0.0317623727,
0.0009605051,
0.0259852502,
-0.0137682259,
0.0484609604,
-0.0096428078,
-0.031947691,
-0.0436493009,
0.0293065086,
0.0266649611,
0.0275648721,
0.0254956242,
-0.0133403866,
-0.064844124,
0.0281868745,
-0.0599712618,
-0.0221417937,
-0.0381260738,
-0.0564921089,
0.0290724803,
0.0074347309,
-0.0380340405,
0.0272342321,
-0.0602183826,
-0.0581665486,
0.0069372258,
-0.07931225,
-0.0088639185,
0.0305752438,
2.654e-7,
0.0247646831,
0.0006805924,
-0.0015446155,
0.0229663383,
-0.0025264833,
0.0346369073,
-0.0674903691,
0.03375585,
-0.036513783,
-0.0186257847,
0.0240589399,
0.0554022267,
0.0109485164,
0.012753359,
-0.0224165302,
0.0112969968,
0.0440539978,
-0.0253643617,
-0.0845865607,
-0.0217393376,
0.0478077196,
0.0175653305,
-0.0254156105,
-0.0165296104,
0.0378451757,
-0.0501643121,
0.0978289619,
-0.0043945895,
-0.0135553731,
-0.0201399066,
0.0251062661,
0.023231471,
-0.0217270013,
0.0120851956,
-0.0101803076,
0.0089416094,
0.0416932292,
0.0400335863,
-0.0425185673,
-0.0589116439,
0.0200581253,
0.0323946364,
-0.0184906572,
-0.0108302375,
0.0557765588,
-0.0280655809,
-0.0088276658,
-0.0188292451,
-0.0290778317,
0.0014238824,
-0.0207257532,
-0.0262044333,
-0.0387520045,
0.0131306741,
0.0134783424,
-0.0424392261,
-0.0173653588,
-0.0708767176,
-0.0202409867,
0.0050037638,
-0.050671488,
-0.0115339356,
-0.0329117998,
-0.024072485,
0.0154700056,
0.0036514639,
-0.0654280186,
1.55942263e-34,
-0.0070976438,
0.0106335096,
0.028764993,
0.036846891,
0.0319058411,
-0.002517635,
-0.0171671957,
0.0077400845,
0.006653666,
-0.0283171348,
-0.0383857004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05419v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05419v2 | Mirror: A Universal Framework for Various Information Extraction Tasks | 2023-11-09T14:58:46 | 2023-11-26T17:12:20 | Tong Zhu, Junfei Ren, Zijian Yu, Mengsong Wu, Guoliang Zhang, Xiaoye Qu, Wenliang Chen, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sharing knowledge between information extraction tasks has always been a
challenge due to the diverse data formats and task variations. Meanwhile, this
divergence leads to information waste and increases difficulties in building
complex applications in real scenarios. Recent studies often formulate IE tasks
as a triplet extraction problem. However, such a paradigm does not support
multi-span and n-ary extraction, leading to weak versatility. To this end, we
reorganize IE problems into unified multi-slot tuples and propose a universal
framework for various IE tasks, namely Mirror. Specifically, we recast existing
IE tasks as a multi-span cyclic graph extraction problem and devise a
non-autoregressive graph decoding algorithm to extract all spans in a single
step. It is worth noting that this graph structure is incredibly versatile, and
it supports not only complex IE tasks, but also machine reading comprehension
and classification tasks. We manually construct a corpus containing 57 datasets
for model pretraining, and conduct experiments on 30 datasets across 8
downstream tasks. The experimental results demonstrate that our model has
decent compatibility and outperforms or reaches competitive performance with
SOTA systems under few-shot and zero-shot settings. The code, model weights,
and pretraining corpus are available at https://github.com/Spico197/Mirror . | [
0.0261708144,
0.0122897271,
0.0199832749,
0.0458388887,
-0.0415813662,
0.0584003069,
-0.0050313175,
-0.0004962566,
0.0503836945,
-0.0143586854,
-0.039555829,
0.0042899358,
-0.0197862647,
0.0202595517,
-0.0020235279,
-0.0394861214,
0.0490982793,
-0.0210373159,
0.0140008088,
0.030946983,
0.0106944228,
0.0423565581,
-0.0244798083,
-0.0475276075,
0.008531387,
-0.0315160751,
-0.0018912352,
0.0051345285,
0.0225953348,
-0.0603253916,
-0.0098381974,
0.0256904028,
0.0011196025,
0.0141290789,
0.000001679,
0.0071815751,
-0.0441329554,
0.0257270299,
-0.0731061846,
-0.0054000504,
0.0238974839,
-0.0682378337,
0.0353529043,
-0.0187410302,
-0.0132415127,
-0.0596916713,
0.0138426172,
0.0334792361,
0.0559049323,
0.0481059775,
-0.0283814911,
-0.0164962281,
0.0105968118,
-0.0157444831,
-0.0218842793,
-0.0728713349,
0.0401941314,
0.0283993501,
0.0222619046,
0.0040881536,
-0.0099360244,
0.0361908935,
0.0054928251,
0.0368212052,
-0.008284105,
0.0284513477,
-0.0204455126,
-0.0078123678,
-0.0581732579,
0.1446858793,
0.019666845,
0.0154163204,
0.0273834057,
0.0225519761,
-0.0068367096,
-0.0069351005,
-0.0201277193,
-0.0186540373,
-0.0361338966,
0.022817187,
-0.0140205156,
-0.0207772702,
0.0337042101,
-0.0160345323,
-0.0105985831,
0.0352784619,
-0.0110759847,
-0.0264882986,
0.0457295217,
0.0486973077,
0.01683723,
-0.0088041062,
0.0241186079,
0.0132709621,
-0.0003788568,
0.0156604331,
-0.0283626802,
-0.0647937357,
-0.0384558402,
0.0330064967,
0.0426677875,
0.0017988649,
-0.0451481938,
0.0699100718,
-0.0061620572,
0.0115810083,
-0.0351768062,
0.0685455427,
-0.0327110477,
-0.0142071983,
-0.026497053,
0.0316727124,
-0.0344558358,
0.0540456288,
-0.0261062812,
-0.0393399708,
-0.0034077957,
0.0273986347,
0.0270011965,
0.0070622819,
0.0274627153,
0.0134168807,
-0.0199908931,
-0.0206456501,
0.0771855116,
0.0606960505,
-0.0040480113,
-0.0113305617,
-0.0018842289,
-0.0117398454,
-0.0481479615,
0.0241942089,
0.0652613565,
-0.0577205457,
0.0145725058,
0.0547773428,
-0.0178058092,
-0.0553241372,
-0.0177087504,
-0.0100435624,
-0.0070360554,
-0.0670775697,
0.0075786416,
-0.0242798384,
0.0969482958,
0.0177860577,
0.0090535749,
0.0112422314,
-0.0001975018,
-0.0386717655,
-0.0620102584,
0.0892501548,
-0.0333170481,
-0.015369582,
-0.0045387894,
-0.0117733404,
-0.004525118,
0.0472240821,
0.0284812413,
0.0322307833,
0.0601190031,
0.0154225286,
-0.0188271459,
0.0519051664,
0.0111112036,
-0.0201378688,
0.0482809395,
0.0182597805,
-0.0343026184,
-0.0508176759,
0.0412755758,
0.0432428718,
-0.0671760216,
-0.0179085638,
0.0252629183,
0.0140422173,
0.0270018484,
0.0116155306,
0.0380589552,
0.0294852573,
0.0063207955,
0.0464870259,
-0.0267106649,
0.0081829131,
-0.0131081287,
0.026907647,
-0.0215535648,
0.0022634058,
0.007550213,
0.0124555845,
0.0189453065,
-0.0261887275,
0.0240001921,
0.0362240039,
0.0899788886,
0.0063235578,
-0.0492514446,
0.024581017,
0.0388129316,
-0.0258197021,
0.0021090955,
0.0239066556,
-0.0033822253,
0.0480759516,
0.0286146346,
-0.0260268766,
-0.0403926484,
0.0245651584,
0.0169651527,
-0.0083744861,
0.0229321774,
-0.0535897277,
0.0547787957,
-0.0463025495,
-0.0532334186,
0.0255367495,
-0.0045490782,
0.0353085771,
0.0288591124,
-0.0197840612,
-0.0200130548,
-0.0085007688,
-0.036084868,
0.0193337761,
-0.0175008494,
-0.0355849192,
-0.0214183871,
0.0165770222,
-0.0061414847,
0.0371932127,
-0.021122992,
-0.009984686,
0.0434187725,
-0.0338852294,
0.0087717036,
0.0230508186,
-0.0364895873,
-0.0782734081,
0.0218817666,
-0.0333726928,
-0.0333773606,
0.0414078534,
-0.058502879,
-0.0342379324,
0.0129973721,
-0.0195924044,
0.004881714,
-0.0166720636,
-0.0109119341,
0.0537351891,
0.0173118711,
-0.0265505742,
0.0268948376,
0.0308553893,
-0.0361861438,
0.023559263,
-0.0125897964,
-0.0220471565,
-0.0491945669,
-0.0144372955,
0.0589506365,
0.0148111396,
-0.0200632885,
0.0222809706,
0.0073917937,
-0.052094169,
-0.0180574656,
-0.0747474879,
0.0203644317,
-0.023841301,
0.050861448,
0.0227548294,
0.0241965484,
-0.0232047848,
-0.0504937805,
-0.0116139166,
0.0285477694,
-0.0324687473,
0.0050275004,
0.0397509672,
0.0534267537,
0.0212885533,
-0.0000625196,
-0.0473734811,
-0.0362779684,
0.0476297364,
0.0248355549,
-0.0511570685,
-0.0305706188,
0.0070129931,
0.007423006,
0.0231507476,
-0.0094037559,
0.0349242389,
-0.033548478,
-0.030568514,
0.0001269208,
0.0467347465,
-0.0220594332,
0.0392640494,
-0.0164758842,
-0.0331908427,
-0.0209147297,
0.0217487942,
-0.0607294403,
0.0113399522,
-0.0401979312,
-0.0084926505,
0.0143482108,
0.0302607771,
0.0052948925,
0.0206992701,
-0.027494872,
-0.0511853509,
-0.0070330692,
-0.0020736046,
-0.0322487131,
0.0047400794,
-0.0109324371,
-0.0063582663,
-0.0589905716,
0.0070995535,
0.0772184134,
-0.026850123,
-0.0431843735,
-0.0075726495,
-0.0053536487,
-0.0850070566,
0.0823395178,
-0.001159581,
0.0143331541,
0.0368582085,
-0.0737001598,
-0.0162356831,
0.0235463362,
0.0388268195,
-0.0211253576,
0.0099100731,
-0.0201704893,
0.0370484628,
-0.0295869149,
-0.0505608618,
-0.0094501926,
-0.0069439276,
0.0026068222,
-0.0164555088,
-0.014895035,
-0.0038473345,
-0.0185274091,
0.0077163046,
0.0200288389,
0.0439375341,
-0.0200016126,
0.0014773093,
-0.0315224342,
0.0901342928,
0.0619370155,
0.008829847,
-0.0163787454,
-0.024372343,
0.0163462106,
0.082859844,
0.0350246578,
0.0055289525,
0.013837398,
0.0437865555,
0.0345619693,
-0.0374053791,
0.0157487709,
-0.0417900607,
0.030751301,
-0.0588555746,
-0.0090696365,
0.0734714493,
0.0211301912,
-0.080637455,
-0.0300744101,
0.0469445586,
0.0039852606,
0.0034004129,
-0.0043407278,
-0.1174808517,
-0.0327082202,
-0.0149494,
0.0544130579,
0.0313572623,
-0.0747663006,
-0.0284560397,
-0.0668052435,
0.0113148531,
0.0283851717,
0.0034141929,
-0.033300072,
-0.031830892,
-0.0124371508,
-0.0310655292,
0.0150884334,
0.0292940978,
-0.0251690317,
0.0081594223,
0.0286832508,
-0.0209393166,
-0.0151340254,
0.0165789239,
-0.0003755272,
-0.0160741005,
0.0237637274,
0.0140012931,
0.0225373246,
0.0475161858,
0.0107867131,
-0.0458285511,
-0.050963629,
-0.0206234772,
0.0870188102,
-0.0452246256,
-0.0245831814,
-0.036763221,
0.0233528409,
-0.0511661656,
-0.0091955727,
-0.0057887523,
0.0449084528,
0.029812824,
-0.0437609777,
0.0343099274,
-0.0431744196,
0.0013944238,
0.0561793782,
0.0145725692,
0.0136126243,
-0.0379251353,
-0.001224861,
0.0111454492,
-0.1258910447,
-0.020290846,
0.0253337901,
-0.0180813577,
0.0037296435,
-0.0485411771,
-0.0717369318,
0.0232969932,
0.0298115443,
-0.0288080368,
-0.0165245477,
0.0639336631,
-0.008988075,
-0.0689648613,
-0.0080482364,
-0.0469503067,
-0.032177642,
-0.015693767,
-0.0413674712,
0.0135947373,
0.0104194796,
-0.0168823376,
0.0337080546,
-0.0826286823,
-0.0470494777,
0.0018883043,
0.0029577583,
0.0201592166,
0.0790043399,
-0.0199619289,
0.0414855219,
0.0181699134,
-0.0122066736,
-0.0349629298,
-0.0062982305,
0.0133932335,
-0.0289180055,
-0.0180655159,
0.025799565,
-0.038868092,
0.0165120941,
0.0061671752,
0.0375787616,
-0.059700869,
0.0001270322,
0.032337185,
0.067274034,
0.0432817489,
0.0187695269,
-0.0029543338,
-0.0439816192,
-0.0132122412,
-0.0370145142,
-0.0102616278,
-0.0458660685,
0.0183505397,
0.0300630499,
-0.041482877,
-0.0230923519,
0.0137046278,
0.0433707722,
0.0202479102,
-0.0625981987,
-0.003580896,
-0.0488143042,
-0.0088081183,
0.0155771254,
-0.0302805211,
-0.0267013162,
0.0592606664,
0.0432426557,
0.0168018285,
-0.0246896856,
0.0189259723,
0.0286105666,
-0.025385242,
0.0072236052,
0.0475224517,
-0.0512628853,
0.0655829459,
-0.0286471434,
-0.0023637631,
0.0326773748,
0.0040994398,
0.0810191482,
-0.012228474,
-0.0127899973,
-0.0087458389,
0.046313934,
-0.0096042408,
0.0026499156,
0.0134821814,
0.0267585088,
-0.0169948786,
-0.0151224406,
0.1023053229,
0.0006339154,
0.0360335074,
0.0364832915,
-0.0425482243,
-0.0715852827,
-0.0523314439,
-0.0526627004,
-0.0049108709,
-0.0331130363,
-0.0036012328,
-0.0406306125,
-0.0512248985,
0.029132368,
-0.0395882353,
0.0124147106,
0.0113044204,
0.0043403362,
0.0382554121,
0.027999023,
-0.0276857056,
-0.0394223258,
0.0319252908,
0.0085998764,
-0.0006698385,
0.0110875918,
-6.043883551e-33,
-0.0394850597,
-0.0225124583,
0.0126815839,
0.0216078945,
-0.0439372696,
0.0335980542,
-0.0395411737,
0.0019639267,
-0.02009877,
-0.0105117774,
0.0097614927,
0.0216422752,
0.0314759314,
0.0239316411,
-0.033982683,
-0.0272682905,
0.0215161052,
-0.0177879594,
-0.0243125763,
0.0215030052,
0.0683854297,
0.0922176465,
0.0631875694,
-0.0621997118,
0.0424899235,
-0.0226777252,
0.0279587358,
-0.0079266736,
0.0843707845,
0.0259338245,
-0.0169961769,
0.0303161405,
0.0350998789,
-0.0115356306,
0.0109921815,
0.0326671563,
-0.160405457,
-0.0170914643,
-0.0122536859,
0.0254911594,
-0.0429200605,
-0.0111456942,
-0.0095029902,
-0.0242898352,
0.0537677258,
-0.0688991323,
0.0062969821,
-0.0150422938,
0.0021491928,
0.0033078433,
-0.0292275138,
0.0483814627,
-0.0123321982,
0.0115199275,
0.0711141825,
0.0518678799,
0.0241090897,
0.0256556012,
-0.053313043,
0.0044344096,
-0.05336022,
-0.0013122055,
0.0277510565,
0.0105869919,
0.0063363332,
0.0369387716,
0.0068870755,
-0.0542428493,
-0.0206163302,
0.0255551152,
-0.0123797776,
0.0697924346,
-0.0346189216,
0.0129228402,
0.0142477555,
0.0142670292,
-0.1014651954,
0.0202197116,
0.026370097,
0.0261416789,
-0.0521717854,
0.0054974845,
-0.0424142219,
0.0092995977,
0.0437356718,
-0.0110738622,
-0.0170203485,
-0.0177737065,
0.0143205654,
0.0164621118,
-0.0448818356,
0.101081863,
0.0328866728,
-0.011963224,
-0.0253901165,
0.0509130396,
0.019700259,
0.0252154469,
-0.0289593637,
0.0125824325,
-0.0374531597,
-0.0331090689,
-0.0041063554,
0.0218086615,
0.0178212728,
-0.0050766519,
0.0702412128,
0.0145004382,
-0.0440659672,
-0.0279925074,
-0.0358705856,
0.0210711323,
-0.0222592149,
0.0345548019,
0.0360976309,
0.0367368087,
-0.0200103559,
0.0066790185,
0.0413361676,
0.0534338057,
-0.0274041686,
0.0108678769,
0.017018823,
0.0272833854,
0.0198903084,
-0.0359035656,
-0.0234787222,
-0.0051592044,
0.0145840738,
-0.0474257916,
0.0031687566,
0.024808988,
2.52e-7,
0.0594522841,
0.0226687454,
0.1004881784,
0.020570904,
-0.0063789547,
0.0050458671,
-0.0343928933,
0.0417450406,
-0.015872376,
0.0024963899,
0.0274498779,
0.0326418318,
0.0191947352,
0.0289989468,
-0.0499435477,
0.0126660559,
-0.0273070578,
-0.0351145305,
-0.0480437055,
-0.0161345787,
0.0501271859,
0.0390565693,
-0.0056244005,
-0.0037803545,
-0.012650772,
-0.0524638295,
0.0554691739,
0.0233506002,
-0.0010317701,
0.0183874499,
0.0160983503,
-0.0225524493,
-0.0454044268,
0.025889881,
-0.0175897591,
0.0171957929,
0.033334583,
0.0302302688,
-0.008774451,
-0.0605579615,
0.0164646935,
-0.0156244384,
0.0069403378,
0.0047211247,
0.0798844099,
-0.0547802523,
-0.0347483307,
-0.0133561622,
-0.0786749646,
0.0099277589,
-0.0476284474,
0.0107052643,
-0.0157583021,
0.0703254864,
0.0319491923,
-0.0285603106,
-0.0028468559,
-0.0897148028,
-0.0010026688,
0.0167821813,
-0.0046600536,
-0.0233237036,
0.0049296371,
-0.0139953839,
0.0070985826,
-0.0728969425,
0.0173294619,
2.350458811e-34,
-0.0108815115,
0.0196762886,
-0.0135217588,
0.0374255069,
0.0039858534,
-0.0549641736,
-0.044989951,
-0.0029016586,
-0.0232544709,
-0.0758868903,
-0.0134768402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05379v1 | Memorisation Cartography: Mapping out the Memorisation-Generalisation Continuum in Neural Machine Translation | 2023-11-09T14:03:51 | 2023-11-09T14:03:51 | Verna Dankers, Ivan Titov, Dieuwke Hupkes | cs.CL | cs.CL | When training a neural network, it will quickly memorise some source-target
mappings from your dataset but never learn some others. Yet, memorisation is
not easily expressed as a binary feature that is good or bad: individual
datapoints lie on a memorisation-generalisation continuum. What determines a
datapoint's position on that spectrum, and how does that spectrum influence
neural models' performance? We address these two questions for neural machine
translation (NMT) models. We use the counterfactual memorisation metric to (1)
build a resource that places 5M NMT datapoints on a memorisation-generalisation
map, (2) illustrate how the datapoints' surface-level characteristics and a
models' per-datum training signals are predictive of memorisation in NMT, (3)
and describe the influence that subsets of that map have on NMT systems'
performance. | [
-0.0007414793,
0.0243287086,
-0.0314874277,
0.0037454865,
-0.0294514969,
0.022356052,
0.025823446,
-0.0229949523,
-0.0556502938,
0.0086628953,
-0.0435096025,
-0.0546369329,
0.0467480235,
-0.0387872122,
0.0389351994,
-0.0352891162,
0.0296334848,
-0.0113440836,
-0.0502688177,
0.0059404317,
-0.0577283725,
-0.0239030682,
0.0128200958,
0.0336686261,
-0.0369600132,
-0.0138891358,
-0.009561928,
0.0361421779,
0.0279469881,
-0.0528041124,
-0.0026642124,
0.0053410283,
0.0084322663,
0.0212957337,
0.000001993,
-0.018314803,
-0.0305332933,
0.0143013457,
0.0139776813,
0.0077360892,
-0.0001567516,
-0.0558165908,
-0.0073310039,
0.0026408415,
-0.0291731656,
-0.0265820343,
0.075316079,
-0.0008266499,
0.057984665,
0.0888599679,
-0.0208352916,
-0.0214273836,
-0.001252113,
-0.0429993868,
0.022942476,
-0.0208994355,
-0.0224428494,
0.0336840339,
-0.0992707014,
0.0129054859,
-0.0187930446,
0.0469554737,
0.0330008268,
0.0611486286,
0.0118341548,
0.0405005924,
-0.0169723798,
0.0014761828,
-0.0008935327,
0.057501249,
0.0034062685,
0.0029931909,
-0.0088523775,
0.0094816396,
-0.0033794595,
-0.0315806791,
-0.0651544258,
-0.0176823456,
-0.0144312,
-0.0027362618,
-0.0318999775,
0.0378270857,
0.0434190184,
-0.0123382574,
-0.0670017377,
0.0123405792,
0.0196539667,
-0.0196695849,
-0.0258293189,
-0.0068459776,
0.0082142046,
0.001349413,
0.0487213805,
0.0307415519,
0.0203679465,
0.0345679373,
0.0004652827,
-0.0446899608,
0.0351593867,
-0.0720857158,
0.0971157178,
0.0672747418,
-0.0070040431,
0.0187710505,
-0.0453898571,
0.097565271,
-0.0481506847,
0.0465526804,
-0.0504939742,
-0.0156552251,
-0.0680528805,
-0.0020633363,
-0.0536099523,
0.0144589832,
0.0612755753,
-0.0047189319,
-0.0239013843,
0.015336412,
-0.017224187,
0.0123747503,
0.006122855,
-0.0149828577,
-0.0715181082,
0.0107301325,
0.0015842771,
0.0327925943,
-0.0589932054,
-0.0172506701,
0.0327261277,
-0.0253032632,
-0.0270048659,
-0.0287371092,
-0.0190057959,
-0.0236283876,
-0.003220753,
0.1004473194,
0.003435727,
-0.0169977527,
-0.0503047667,
-0.0090809511,
-0.0142373731,
-0.0707416981,
0.0640181601,
-0.0378767885,
0.0419593416,
0.0344819129,
-0.0007148065,
-0.0105364285,
-0.0274729636,
0.0085193124,
0.0154752471,
0.0510226227,
0.0755930841,
-0.0193981491,
0.0511631928,
0.0026324464,
-0.01348978,
0.0310410224,
0.0581562705,
0.0310951881,
0.0098487483,
-0.0071069519,
-0.0355375968,
0.0249713995,
0.0546920896,
-0.0068520266,
-0.0483338311,
-0.0048450148,
0.0467477515,
0.0409184024,
0.0522311218,
0.0403501019,
-0.0442334227,
-0.0245607495,
0.0677279681,
0.0545098856,
0.0043755323,
0.0436370634,
0.046357587,
-0.0284043979,
-0.0348372273,
0.0325664207,
-0.0445513129,
0.0398548916,
0.0332659297,
0.0000238228,
0.002223572,
0.0420906655,
-0.0253228415,
-0.0289479773,
-0.0081023052,
0.0026847653,
0.0062243007,
-0.0552473553,
0.0047088368,
0.0320508517,
-0.0169238076,
0.0624315925,
-0.0427664891,
-0.0498931967,
0.0275524091,
0.0153498864,
-0.0512979291,
0.0192316342,
-0.0035821886,
-0.0113102403,
-0.0520491861,
0.0045315805,
0.0031710037,
-0.0196901113,
0.0930487067,
0.0201309286,
0.0294796508,
-0.0510158092,
-0.0244917739,
-0.0053754915,
0.0308158994,
0.0441226326,
0.0282031614,
0.013397105,
0.0384080335,
-0.0516820699,
-0.0550918505,
0.0387987085,
0.0247296244,
-0.0232315231,
0.0148300156,
0.0141574172,
0.0329001732,
0.0010019973,
0.0114092557,
0.0077230548,
0.0318134651,
-0.0417677499,
-0.0036623057,
0.0311908722,
-0.1063442007,
0.0006544197,
0.0164035913,
-0.0420549884,
0.0227788109,
0.0174647123,
-0.0370361954,
-0.0670238957,
-0.0005892733,
-0.0244185831,
0.0302953273,
-0.000410981,
0.0336760394,
0.0283360742,
-0.002436663,
-0.036512658,
0.019227555,
-0.027183583,
0.0095453095,
-0.0047353217,
-0.0040063262,
0.0344134681,
-0.0258936323,
-0.0005633499,
0.0469102189,
0.0016125999,
0.0430597626,
0.0049791569,
-0.0167227201,
-0.0442980416,
-0.0306670051,
-0.0665884838,
0.0243914947,
-0.0240590628,
0.0402783155,
0.0483690724,
0.0210365262,
0.0233422834,
-0.0146631366,
-0.056722004,
0.0328072682,
-0.0420512259,
0.038169682,
0.0138128269,
0.0173579026,
0.0378248431,
-0.0187359154,
-0.0119390041,
0.0065721502,
0.0444354862,
-0.0116695184,
-0.0072061606,
-0.060149312,
0.0072740498,
-0.0204608645,
-0.0219125971,
-0.0265908781,
-0.0295871254,
0.0226532966,
-0.0079969307,
0.0397114195,
0.0482164286,
0.0009098104,
-0.0272444487,
0.0368959419,
-0.0308901574,
-0.0747191235,
0.0067364955,
-0.0517674685,
-0.0255656298,
0.0055352645,
-0.043189507,
-0.0035043864,
0.0274664667,
0.0426389873,
0.0067176684,
-0.0351999141,
0.004225431,
-0.0356725939,
0.0087350067,
-0.0501615629,
0.0390296467,
-0.0047086957,
0.0114868265,
-0.01144257,
-0.0644892529,
0.0384564064,
-0.0320229158,
0.0245757308,
-0.0145054739,
0.0142845176,
-0.0156678222,
0.0523985475,
-0.0088967886,
0.0326011516,
-0.0034795492,
-0.0569392517,
-0.0303896107,
-0.0170144718,
-0.0017917274,
-0.0101038655,
0.0257032402,
-0.0427483842,
-0.0211306438,
-0.0319701508,
0.0078411344,
-0.0255707372,
0.0550363585,
0.0396682881,
0.0181756504,
0.0028203691,
-0.0205452666,
-0.0068795132,
0.025992373,
0.0112963123,
0.1012337655,
-0.0409745239,
-0.0148059055,
0.0005196601,
-0.0032750894,
-0.0183146968,
0.0547517985,
0.0176535584,
-0.03787072,
-0.052139584,
-0.0014696569,
-0.0085001476,
-0.0096127568,
-0.0628790557,
0.0041662804,
-0.0082390429,
-0.013800134,
-0.0180871431,
0.0118259098,
0.0358929373,
-0.0680896342,
-0.0242610481,
0.0497796051,
0.0090855556,
-0.0629775375,
0.0088641979,
0.0083121834,
0.0589974746,
0.031302508,
-0.0156920142,
-0.0084360372,
0.0158815756,
-0.0030464765,
0.0151769528,
0.0257177372,
-0.0005349203,
-0.0150797209,
-0.0538206883,
0.0016621944,
0.0504389144,
-0.1221582964,
-0.048310481,
-0.010163527,
-0.0456232391,
-0.019856194,
0.0366873406,
-0.0313620269,
0.01034847,
-0.0228802953,
0.0331141613,
0.0124169132,
-0.0359818973,
-0.0160463732,
-0.0567989647,
0.0235953834,
0.0727776289,
0.0282799788,
0.0150001533,
-0.0303033646,
0.0200433489,
-0.0081308689,
0.0504110605,
-0.0015474285,
0.0397469997,
0.0258437861,
-0.0049434127,
0.0238932483,
-0.0094921887,
-0.0287373438,
0.0335973874,
0.0040231734,
0.0586565509,
-0.0370130464,
0.0326701552,
0.0113852443,
-0.0133164255,
-0.0175573621,
0.050035499,
0.0430101678,
0.002840271,
-0.0048960946,
-0.0198074691,
0.0528184697,
-0.0836113393,
0.0006896743,
0.000269331,
-0.0278375056,
-0.0360873267,
-0.1032249853,
-0.0453646667,
-0.0233375989,
0.0633127168,
0.029933488,
-0.0217767525,
0.0249595232,
-0.0313086845,
-0.0319730081,
0.0550255328,
-0.0311899185,
-0.0087871272,
-0.041376099,
-0.0193457473,
0.0164844207,
-0.0187807437,
-0.0007265666,
0.025710823,
-0.1262834817,
-0.0366358943,
0.0126419934,
0.0782639533,
0.0283692498,
0.0339345448,
0.0076021664,
0.0007837426,
0.0461934693,
0.002318358,
-0.0411981493,
0.0015593858,
0.0370287485,
-0.0081844274,
-0.0355070978,
0.0063049528,
-0.0125959693,
-0.0109535744,
0.0293059889,
0.0276433341,
0.0047045541,
0.0374194793,
0.035452947,
-0.0507590026,
0.0649670288,
-0.002118567,
-0.0349612236,
-0.0088986466,
0.0238326825,
0.0327578597,
0.0038658928,
-0.0277238507,
-0.0301580094,
0.0265038311,
0.0117563568,
-0.0222548228,
-0.0507753268,
0.0117865615,
0.0012097204,
0.0015693861,
-0.0665632263,
-0.0088611953,
0.0416420139,
-0.0141825136,
0.0417336598,
-0.0456767157,
0.0535306744,
-0.0319368504,
0.0095696868,
-0.0288579427,
0.0402375609,
0.0165311452,
0.0495839976,
-0.0112935854,
0.0260644704,
-0.068513155,
-0.0538630933,
-0.0321420245,
-0.0208865106,
0.0868657157,
-0.042433776,
0.0612506792,
-0.0230527166,
0.0103428438,
-0.0055014533,
0.0101107787,
0.0417571403,
-0.0090129469,
-0.0053460011,
-0.0000729156,
0.033217106,
0.0258317608,
0.0505162925,
-0.0485231206,
0.0285656527,
-0.0241352152,
-0.0054774061,
-0.0161942281,
-0.0086556803,
0.0270898808,
-0.021470191,
-0.0070842714,
-0.0444896929,
-0.0619289391,
-0.0340301134,
0.0353010334,
0.0003212637,
0.0154909156,
-0.0149105806,
0.0416936614,
0.0748985037,
-0.0732939765,
0.0083551677,
-0.0225105509,
0.0205323994,
-0.0099741677,
0.0016954237,
-0.0719126165,
-6.361452166e-33,
-0.047500506,
-0.0001090613,
0.0476851426,
-0.0112420572,
-0.0326449834,
0.0095626032,
-0.0332975872,
-0.0211762972,
-0.0189253855,
-0.0185664669,
0.0046226555,
0.0059216619,
0.0254386775,
0.0030247064,
0.0035043091,
-0.0196980853,
0.063188754,
0.0114972387,
-0.0582384132,
0.0293609332,
0.0491190851,
0.0186765697,
0.0886557326,
-0.0834497362,
0.0360546634,
0.0014427723,
0.0116759837,
-0.0157989506,
-0.0169514958,
0.0166390054,
-0.0039977748,
0.0113521544,
0.0260940269,
-0.0332921259,
-0.0406174213,
-0.0680659339,
-0.1027000025,
-0.0322815105,
-0.0009117656,
0.0505747721,
0.0158983581,
-0.0651800558,
0.0935406163,
-0.0618901514,
-0.0169100855,
-0.0306429919,
0.0154988626,
-0.0202322733,
-0.0962091833,
-0.0155217294,
-0.0510866493,
0.0010749282,
0.0033951839,
0.0002896008,
-0.015567733,
0.0408922173,
-0.01615653,
-0.0007765547,
-0.130625084,
-0.0038964567,
0.0146413613,
0.0696502998,
0.049073413,
0.0517485328,
0.0130184181,
0.0329976566,
0.0520631373,
0.0252138954,
0.0545906089,
0.0013968719,
0.042996224,
-0.0157630946,
0.0588415861,
0.0056133186,
0.1054977402,
-0.0183029566,
-0.0310781598,
0.0225834753,
-0.0582270026,
0.0275859721,
0.0301130749,
0.0122853806,
-0.0048846765,
-0.004200303,
-0.0535546765,
-0.0480785668,
-0.0309497118,
-0.0183300674,
-0.0033821734,
0.0192668661,
0.020498205,
0.0021978896,
0.067054987,
0.0257331599,
0.0282412581,
0.026610896,
-0.0054438338,
0.0045710877,
-0.011911436,
0.0251653623,
-0.0307257418,
-0.0275745317,
-0.005923063,
0.0342744365,
0.0415371619,
0.0092798574,
0.0500949174,
0.037532784,
-0.0262467079,
-0.0333643928,
-0.050606519,
-0.0241772141,
-0.036141634,
0.0023711703,
0.042616237,
-0.0065354491,
-0.0004514725,
0.0694558471,
0.005743287,
0.001096115,
-0.0122587448,
0.0082940534,
0.0129862884,
0.0608105846,
-0.0418707803,
0.0008327377,
-0.0120319966,
0.0000352138,
0.0491875932,
-0.0485562496,
-0.0099925399,
0.0410311893,
2.783e-7,
0.0367536247,
0.0346427485,
0.0056858328,
-0.0026507489,
0.0096459314,
0.0126146125,
-0.0660361052,
0.0202938057,
-0.0207341295,
0.0088619096,
0.0259902682,
0.0367769711,
0.0533363037,
0.0426977202,
-0.0664190948,
-0.0264069438,
-0.0336923413,
0.0110480404,
-0.0522730388,
0.0152128199,
0.0185761657,
0.085257858,
-0.0250205118,
0.0079681827,
0.0256560929,
-0.016318325,
0.0703171119,
-0.0402408354,
0.0326678455,
-0.0126773203,
0.0474190004,
0.0289674848,
-0.0352973863,
0.022441132,
-0.004732382,
-0.005556325,
0.0142640453,
0.0653646812,
0.0196394548,
-0.0328579172,
-0.0135563631,
-0.0313050076,
-0.0264912732,
-0.0534841903,
0.007968192,
-0.0859745294,
-0.012576581,
0.0376681387,
0.003487428,
0.0363101475,
0.0545946807,
0.0050052498,
-0.0085700862,
0.0160322599,
0.0183796939,
0.0127304243,
0.0109418454,
-0.0457471199,
-0.0347507112,
0.0089152306,
-0.0038416444,
-0.0373611338,
-0.0481866822,
-0.0094480375,
0.0216866769,
-0.0252191015,
-0.0173750836,
2.217573996e-34,
0.0159854833,
-0.0266007669,
0.0145161366,
-0.0225520413,
0.0343084075,
-0.0330311358,
0.0049518328,
-0.0006115145,
-0.009581699,
-0.0309150331,
-0.0165409129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05374v1 | TencentLLMEval: A Hierarchical Evaluation of Real-World Capabilities for Human-Aligned LLMs | 2023-11-09T13:58:59 | 2023-11-09T13:58:59 | Shuyi Xie, Wenlin Yao, Yong Dai, Shaobo Wang, Donlin Zhou, Lifeng Jin, Xinhua Feng, Pengzhi Wei, Yujie Lin, Zhichao Hu, Dong Yu, Zhengyou Zhang, Jing Nie, Yuhong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities across
various natural language tasks. However, evaluating their alignment with human
preferences remains a challenge. To this end, we propose a comprehensive human
evaluation framework to assess LLMs' proficiency in following instructions on
diverse real-world tasks. We construct a hierarchical task tree encompassing 7
major areas covering over 200 categories and over 800 tasks, which covers
diverse capabilities such as question answering, reasoning, multiturn dialogue,
and text generation, to evaluate LLMs in a comprehensive and in-depth manner.
We also design detailed evaluation standards and processes to facilitate
consistent, unbiased judgments from human evaluators. A test set of over 3,000
instances is released, spanning different difficulty levels and knowledge
domains. Our work provides a standardized methodology to evaluate human
alignment in LLMs for both English and Chinese. We also analyze the feasibility
of automating parts of evaluation with a strong LLM (GPT-4). Our framework
supports a thorough assessment of LLMs as they are integrated into real-world
applications. We have made publicly available the task tree, TencentLLMEval
dataset, and evaluation methodology which have been demonstrated as effective
in assessing the performance of Tencent Hunyuan LLMs. By doing so, we aim to
facilitate the benchmarking of advances in the development of safe and
human-aligned LLMs. | [
0.0322627164,
0.0205735657,
0.0073263063,
0.0315093361,
-0.0437678844,
0.0009789733,
-0.016431259,
-0.0377290696,
0.0173424724,
-0.0377757885,
-0.0611850321,
-0.0479205474,
0.0068490347,
0.0000094469,
0.0344946012,
-0.0438823141,
0.0411104336,
-0.0283614453,
0.0016458115,
-0.0043183467,
0.0019390184,
0.0087317321,
-0.0169665776,
0.0455385707,
0.015890222,
-0.0384319909,
-0.0181983151,
0.0214355625,
0.0529478528,
-0.0461853966,
0.0267705508,
0.04580478,
0.012070924,
0.0111373514,
0.0000020435,
-0.0552722774,
0.0226662047,
-0.0142599065,
-0.0250768084,
0.0045715813,
0.0275014006,
0.0123146139,
-0.0088677788,
0.0242536031,
-0.055309359,
0.0153844366,
0.0071686278,
0.0426975973,
0.0897227302,
0.0679131225,
0.0162628461,
0.0007639184,
0.0122328177,
-0.0057156822,
0.0079579381,
-0.0729861408,
0.0088217063,
0.0219143089,
0.0459785238,
0.0014985648,
0.0145006552,
0.008717211,
0.0393850282,
-0.0001780574,
-0.0086142765,
0.0189351048,
-0.0348599702,
-0.0130163124,
-0.025446428,
0.0994312018,
0.0127355214,
-0.018074898,
-0.0234655067,
0.0021891657,
-0.000332031,
-0.0175857805,
-0.0413174517,
0.0316291973,
-0.0051916451,
0.0025065551,
0.0038849353,
-0.0128263999,
0.0271434356,
0.0515247844,
0.0214826502,
0.074826017,
0.0115981856,
-0.0380259752,
0.0250652637,
0.0062752045,
-0.0277409218,
-0.0626405105,
0.0122672608,
0.0455189347,
-0.0829178989,
0.0353458747,
-0.0449247323,
0.0203653928,
0.0370647795,
-0.0547004491,
0.0309141148,
0.0446875878,
-0.018747991,
0.0501603745,
-0.0048444788,
0.0918496549,
-0.0018008556,
0.0077605476,
-0.0510624647,
-0.0259266123,
-0.0353241041,
-0.0197605789,
-0.023385115,
0.0260341056,
-0.0282549616,
-0.0232507549,
-0.0561692268,
0.0277521908,
-0.0210915338,
0.0092900498,
0.0476402827,
0.0330792703,
-0.0149737345,
-0.0132589163,
-0.0560276248,
0.0024062011,
-0.0315525569,
0.0248460174,
0.0236210953,
-0.0259964261,
-0.0090091266,
0.0407188274,
-0.0213722233,
-0.0318343453,
0.0033637942,
0.064858526,
-0.0221209377,
-0.0171271432,
-0.0346878394,
-0.0164587051,
-0.0254192743,
-0.0771769583,
-0.0123847155,
-0.0548429899,
0.0197506566,
-0.0161695331,
-0.012695251,
-0.0114231464,
0.0160451066,
0.0454481542,
0.0152251124,
0.0437925197,
-0.006495167,
0.0245867167,
0.0195432473,
0.0163625497,
-0.0243353881,
0.0558407381,
0.0490782745,
0.0457906798,
0.0330180414,
-0.002430361,
-0.0087619312,
0.0314718559,
-0.0236195959,
-0.0196600836,
-0.0076431828,
0.0470720343,
-0.0376089253,
0.0508098081,
0.0267184917,
0.0641397536,
-0.0143916653,
0.0002424617,
0.08501257,
0.0456749201,
-0.0013438441,
-0.0029550174,
0.0522626936,
0.008426412,
0.0162200443,
0.0129845291,
-0.0557127036,
0.0333474092,
-0.051580824,
0.0230875723,
0.0238383245,
0.0296413228,
-0.0252340231,
-0.050356105,
-0.0324077308,
0.0042473585,
0.0190866813,
0.0203907713,
0.0177102312,
-0.0128651587,
-0.0286289435,
0.049395293,
-0.0110046249,
-0.0495755263,
0.0124508617,
-0.0441798158,
0.0274394136,
0.1072826385,
0.0542806722,
0.0055229394,
-0.0373581424,
0.0124666523,
-0.0111427894,
0.0611488484,
0.0375274867,
-0.0233540125,
-0.0033133167,
-0.0447614081,
-0.0199593399,
0.0151049523,
-0.0028515507,
-0.0005456185,
0.033699017,
-0.0001305722,
0.0193412937,
-0.0538007282,
-0.0251427982,
0.0424399711,
-0.0373902917,
-0.016815355,
-0.0174217839,
0.0076934705,
0.0286988821,
0.0200257599,
-0.0061507812,
0.0247175079,
0.047597263,
-0.0031647505,
-0.0306431688,
0.0115457568,
-0.065790154,
-0.0335076228,
0.0712574646,
-0.0394531377,
-0.0378927626,
0.0678993762,
-0.0444476977,
-0.0450479425,
-0.029430544,
-0.0540561415,
-0.0210447256,
-0.0699044243,
0.0336945429,
0.0185053926,
-0.0083573284,
-0.0346603133,
0.1031198129,
-0.0126013886,
0.0201776717,
0.0398557521,
-0.0061056903,
-0.0097401645,
-0.0689030737,
-0.0239805318,
-0.0179204848,
-0.00605602,
0.0424797907,
0.0193477031,
0.0452263951,
-0.0718598813,
-0.0220280122,
-0.0979805216,
0.0324418359,
-0.0330700278,
0.0427067243,
0.0444322936,
-0.0341341421,
-0.0213776343,
0.0043484587,
-0.0747087747,
-0.016756326,
0.0337535217,
-0.007151505,
0.0531111769,
-0.036361929,
-0.0083050048,
-0.0396932885,
0.0190187842,
-0.0119783431,
-0.0049614492,
0.0023959028,
0.0185103361,
-0.0354224779,
0.0420596749,
-0.0354190953,
-0.0030340808,
0.0084954994,
-0.0557447374,
0.0264581591,
0.0495363809,
0.0383016281,
0.0668000579,
0.0300597083,
0.0168724041,
0.0194278453,
0.0019794998,
-0.043518424,
0.0160540435,
0.0027507369,
-0.0216049477,
-0.0196632277,
-0.0347364955,
-0.0128726307,
0.0521046035,
0.0200831704,
0.0192128289,
-0.0411655158,
0.006559053,
-0.0106532862,
-0.0276566818,
-0.0284949802,
0.006426217,
-0.0453378558,
0.0266811568,
-0.0574906096,
-0.0433121361,
0.0905623883,
-0.0359717607,
-0.0069820709,
-0.0403810255,
-0.028473746,
-0.0538430698,
0.0654932931,
-0.0177600421,
0.0085206991,
-0.0005533135,
-0.0130668655,
-0.0718238354,
0.01380526,
-0.0053207576,
-0.0577745736,
0.0476441048,
-0.0684362948,
0.0079958541,
-0.013701262,
-0.0250447113,
-0.0490401499,
-0.0283731278,
-0.0139715998,
0.0548640788,
0.0253956132,
-0.0014311044,
-0.0086638406,
0.0148264915,
0.0299129616,
0.0151176378,
-0.0107263513,
-0.0046354868,
-0.0220765769,
0.0406106859,
0.0737897679,
0.056615904,
0.0222185235,
-0.0142245786,
0.04689404,
0.0693984628,
0.0433059186,
0.0163066424,
-0.0209199805,
0.0130725466,
0.0296305604,
-0.0438884422,
0.0067905555,
0.0266989898,
0.07306844,
-0.061527323,
0.0045552356,
0.1253022403,
0.0245230515,
-0.0041241455,
0.0080221128,
-0.0064147566,
0.0227735173,
0.0140834674,
0.006151034,
-0.0882199854,
-0.046449136,
-0.0051437435,
0.0329484567,
-0.0142358784,
-0.0211151522,
0.0060525858,
-0.1395343393,
0.0295713525,
0.0063792486,
-0.0339371115,
-0.0307141766,
-0.0048699961,
0.0072748968,
-0.0083277253,
0.0582708344,
0.0246798284,
0.0086817006,
-0.0198881906,
0.0196264945,
-0.0344953984,
-0.069396086,
0.0786936432,
-0.0523027778,
0.0451410897,
0.0642982572,
0.0339571759,
0.0158100538,
-0.0571041927,
0.0035652767,
-0.0197446123,
0.0083072092,
0.0150439935,
0.0090089655,
-0.0180365983,
-0.0005089592,
-0.0616852716,
0.0162222162,
-0.0385213569,
-0.0072948355,
0.0277043767,
0.0749276355,
-0.0310493577,
-0.0010368874,
-0.0152718779,
0.0228478946,
-0.0124816755,
0.0976032615,
0.0099185118,
-0.0495015346,
-0.035664957,
-0.0112447785,
-0.0214977767,
-0.0509367362,
-0.0266231969,
0.0523299091,
-0.0105494764,
0.0210597683,
-0.0986692384,
-0.0410658047,
0.0212304257,
0.026821252,
-0.011461216,
-0.0100772679,
-0.0173818786,
0.0014831754,
-0.0237463694,
0.0392554551,
-0.024402393,
0.0342728868,
-0.0752484798,
-0.0060744947,
0.0294972155,
-0.031740915,
0.0007627929,
0.0372336917,
-0.0611018725,
-0.0682948753,
-0.0449946411,
0.0457318611,
0.0246711839,
0.0126559837,
-0.007538042,
-0.0388630219,
-0.0016823154,
0.0070858803,
-0.0502565242,
0.0126204332,
0.0050680428,
0.0195825994,
-0.0155288586,
0.0202256311,
-0.0389064997,
0.0065572625,
-0.0139628686,
0.0771173686,
-0.0180254411,
-0.0793517083,
0.047771737,
0.0206188262,
0.0243206602,
-0.0285667684,
0.0068459273,
-0.0083429832,
0.0174040236,
-0.0299515333,
-0.0441435091,
-0.0295290314,
-0.0157823451,
0.0218135621,
-0.0107301651,
0.0049636788,
0.0014408197,
-0.0177820623,
0.0151425032,
-0.0481595621,
0.0084490199,
-0.0077502956,
0.0078732064,
-0.0189772658,
-0.0118911928,
-0.038587179,
-0.0314402543,
-0.0204122309,
0.0459973551,
0.0255582165,
0.0952869579,
-0.0101045035,
0.0032575729,
0.0363632813,
0.0395373031,
-0.0496049449,
-0.0473675057,
-0.0246741064,
0.0125468131,
0.0768312514,
0.0277052894,
0.0405611433,
-0.0343294926,
0.0087843109,
-0.0425652787,
0.0055845696,
-0.0022993733,
-0.0158674717,
0.0402048379,
0.0432167351,
-0.0254626349,
-0.0284611918,
0.0643964857,
0.0257483143,
0.011356758,
-0.0184130576,
-0.0089773331,
-0.0277801808,
-0.0593436174,
0.0146458019,
-0.0026952869,
-0.0380198918,
-0.0146234045,
-0.0695282742,
-0.0746901035,
0.0129430508,
0.0645253584,
-0.0011515529,
-0.0207610969,
0.0478626899,
0.0459035374,
-0.0283255,
-0.0262138937,
-0.037452139,
-0.0225239899,
-0.016923748,
0.0181000791,
-0.0412430875,
-6.741609977e-33,
-0.0550975613,
-0.0552209392,
0.0498841181,
-0.0445410386,
-0.0377440751,
-0.0215714481,
-0.0420960076,
0.0163638443,
-0.0139963431,
-0.0057863072,
0.0022193503,
-0.0055823843,
0.0069706091,
0.0298168231,
-0.0048852814,
-0.0312301666,
0.0049197585,
-0.0044894591,
-0.025998801,
-0.0152877383,
0.0182622857,
-0.0034649407,
0.0342474133,
-0.027145233,
0.0399270207,
-0.0082656248,
-0.0231982507,
0.0302878171,
-0.0142118568,
0.071460925,
-0.0028247687,
0.044445172,
0.0422967933,
-0.0439058766,
-0.0107568279,
0.0339774303,
-0.0592041463,
-0.0082883537,
0.0556215793,
-0.0027687002,
-0.0512591302,
-0.0205716789,
0.0346479602,
-0.0148375519,
-0.0258465335,
0.0042018159,
0.0254193209,
-0.0387198217,
-0.0049469061,
-0.0165962037,
-0.0412679538,
0.0356518924,
-0.0161198638,
-0.0494802147,
-0.0501047596,
0.0657326579,
-0.0251251552,
0.0093883965,
-0.0639690384,
0.0050037559,
-0.014516009,
0.0064513586,
0.1037435904,
0.0080667809,
0.0118849371,
0.0672505647,
0.0160806347,
-0.0134737799,
-0.0215093624,
-0.0306449719,
-0.0007089566,
0.0608293004,
0.0500505529,
0.0423590206,
-0.0011699758,
0.0137983151,
-0.0608863905,
0.0587588437,
0.0302913021,
0.0539762303,
0.0024991236,
0.0111785568,
-0.0364629999,
-0.0030820135,
-0.009661735,
0.0341459177,
-0.0308686532,
-0.0257827193,
0.0549409613,
-0.0115072438,
-0.0080962256,
-0.0301177483,
0.0181476306,
-0.0162677579,
0.0185603481,
0.0226736199,
0.0015286183,
0.0124063957,
-0.0161831584,
0.0411717519,
-0.0412646011,
-0.016889656,
0.0079919659,
0.0131207416,
0.0123704402,
-0.0023684858,
-0.0095428713,
0.0119554047,
-0.0434785075,
0.0124088153,
-0.0381855816,
0.0135093248,
-0.0193144921,
0.0159705784,
0.0458122604,
-0.0223754104,
-0.0159936342,
0.0324630775,
-0.019307252,
-0.0366528705,
-0.0428627618,
-0.0093206279,
0.0001193101,
0.0027741746,
-0.0065362123,
0.0450011082,
-0.0010639327,
0.0144216921,
-0.0101442905,
-0.0134825781,
0.0080545535,
0.0316351503,
2.747e-7,
0.0324545503,
0.0199544951,
0.0347045548,
0.0566854477,
0.0058548427,
0.0296293404,
-0.0462066904,
0.0109874913,
0.0087571247,
-0.0427552424,
0.0294384919,
0.028037522,
0.0972495377,
0.0253259521,
-0.087920174,
0.0010331697,
-0.0638030916,
0.0018041047,
-0.0209592097,
0.0065973573,
0.0774311721,
0.0587523952,
-0.0345752835,
-0.0004668279,
-0.0228603426,
-0.0499061272,
0.0558341034,
-0.027331287,
-0.023631826,
0.010999673,
0.046660345,
0.0133497706,
-0.0103930654,
0.0381018519,
-0.0005670626,
0.0087123718,
0.0417802706,
0.1065882891,
-0.0088405525,
-0.069047384,
-0.0147165945,
-0.0377647318,
0.0281952657,
-0.0536337309,
0.0702904984,
-0.0305225123,
-0.0204328727,
-0.0231254585,
-0.0044306405,
-0.0049822391,
0.0131828627,
-0.021179352,
-0.0232390668,
0.0242478345,
0.0260775052,
-0.0102164289,
-0.0219433438,
-0.0650402158,
-0.0354558676,
0.0180443544,
-0.0535616763,
-0.0642379671,
-0.0338427201,
0.0020027801,
0.0025027948,
-0.0463119149,
-0.0232945718,
2.201162533e-34,
0.0188154653,
-0.0165300742,
0.0154801514,
0.0390027724,
0.0392044112,
0.0110287098,
-0.0214381982,
-0.0048066755,
0.0152637903,
-0.0521956235,
-0.0132742366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05350v1 | There's no Data Like Better Data: Using QE Metrics for MT Data Filtering | 2023-11-09T13:21:34 | 2023-11-09T13:21:34 | Jan-Thorsten Peter, David Vilar, Daniel Deutsch, Mara Finkelstein, Juraj Juraska, Markus Freitag | cs.CL | cs.CL | Quality Estimation (QE), the evaluation of machine translation output without
the need of explicit references, has seen big improvements in the last years
with the use of neural metrics. In this paper we analyze the viability of using
QE metrics for filtering out bad quality sentence pairs in the training data of
neural machine translation systems~(NMT). While most corpus filtering methods
are focused on detecting noisy examples in collections of texts, usually huge
amounts of web crawled data, QE models are trained to discriminate more
fine-grained quality differences. We show that by selecting the highest quality
sentence pairs in the training data, we can improve translation quality while
reducing the training size by half. We also provide a detailed analysis of the
filtering results, which highlights the differences between both approaches. | [
0.0254511163,
0.0589057691,
-0.0085942224,
0.0405450277,
-0.0190009475,
0.0031982476,
-0.0121212387,
0.0365959145,
-0.0313744284,
-0.0169365779,
-0.0245557167,
-0.057086844,
0.0256468654,
-0.0216129422,
0.0251518954,
-0.0313601717,
0.015220386,
0.0280094277,
-0.0169586558,
0.0153678311,
0.0123418458,
-0.0002524189,
0.0338221043,
0.0467057787,
0.0044764671,
-0.0050061918,
0.0441725142,
0.0253367946,
0.0269303601,
-0.0056692981,
0.0294605568,
0.0105441948,
-0.054611329,
0.0576463193,
0.000001911,
-0.0113744084,
-0.0321668498,
0.0000950174,
0.0313511156,
0.0048503485,
0.0260409322,
-0.0062015061,
-0.0373582318,
0.0335089192,
-0.022789022,
0.0041818395,
0.028056521,
0.0122793615,
0.0837906525,
0.0822397992,
-0.0078799073,
0.0380079933,
-0.0005389364,
-0.031227449,
-0.0168654528,
-0.0413242616,
-0.0127074588,
-0.0006230216,
-0.0363191143,
0.0192025881,
0.0065084412,
0.0402867794,
0.0142235225,
-0.0281454492,
0.006697007,
-0.0152288042,
-0.0146952616,
-0.0193376243,
0.0061847069,
0.0569843836,
-0.0286001898,
-0.0060713589,
-0.0121733043,
-0.0100704012,
-0.0071152649,
-0.0375730507,
0.0033749579,
0.0133544654,
-0.0001410869,
0.0330214761,
-0.0261173639,
0.0133996354,
0.0423179232,
0.013848424,
-0.0404071249,
-0.0209953748,
0.0041291849,
-0.0512887239,
0.0012400931,
0.0199981369,
-0.0079621291,
0.0098574879,
0.0586328655,
-0.0125189777,
0.0057058558,
-0.0132583706,
-0.0394758582,
-0.0584735833,
-0.0132349934,
-0.0740391463,
-0.0020590189,
0.035521742,
-0.0035690581,
0.039279189,
-0.0009677642,
0.0378041044,
0.0124057923,
0.0241242331,
-0.056509465,
-0.0285382941,
-0.029359417,
0.0352024883,
-0.017927574,
-0.0002869448,
-0.0281747263,
0.0051818471,
-0.0347668566,
-0.0139315585,
-0.0054598162,
-0.0023064648,
0.0272762645,
-0.0165120307,
-0.0646099746,
0.0050552394,
-0.0500205457,
0.0096624959,
-0.012831348,
-0.0045650266,
0.0174614489,
-0.0499961339,
-0.0124565102,
0.0087168738,
0.0198301189,
-0.040650811,
0.0034647642,
0.0711709708,
0.0127317589,
-0.0319609679,
-0.0164165031,
-0.00981039,
-0.0373218171,
-0.0199304055,
0.0123032248,
-0.0419347584,
0.0306934994,
-0.03913958,
0.0172456261,
-0.0375498571,
-0.007301711,
0.0223967396,
-0.015007521,
0.0281861778,
-0.0356620774,
0.0003803834,
-0.0050185565,
-0.0127740884,
-0.008598757,
0.0478720255,
0.0865701064,
0.0101580415,
0.0632530972,
0.0059419391,
-0.0215414204,
0.0271138307,
-0.0018056566,
0.033987835,
-0.0371283107,
-0.0181340929,
-0.0089341942,
0.0270592943,
0.0079144146,
0.0722694397,
-0.0384795256,
0.0392043367,
0.085857369,
-0.0007798312,
0.0650129542,
0.0315386131,
0.0307216942,
0.0125810783,
0.0005951396,
0.0041444483,
-0.0119984867,
0.0176920425,
0.0227190647,
-0.0203118138,
0.06564527,
0.0556176752,
-0.0128803896,
-0.0947964266,
0.0032127223,
-0.0176880509,
0.008716858,
-0.0575978197,
0.0284322221,
0.0137342121,
-0.0344958305,
0.0021879391,
-0.0073691909,
-0.0394503996,
0.0386062935,
-0.0255442765,
0.0016585139,
0.0464413688,
0.0581699573,
0.0044566132,
-0.019909462,
-0.0347968452,
-0.0461729281,
0.0319973603,
0.0222539417,
0.0144733908,
0.048184067,
-0.0664668381,
-0.0375871882,
0.0221975017,
0.0139717143,
-0.045419123,
-0.0286538322,
0.0443476886,
0.0759978592,
-0.0633362681,
-0.1068299636,
0.0426343791,
0.0315492153,
-0.0141710714,
0.0582241714,
0.0385079049,
0.0464432612,
0.0210500825,
-0.0153523609,
-0.0245339833,
0.0153493732,
-0.0335438326,
-0.0064435801,
0.0058404296,
-0.0280961003,
-0.0336520895,
0.0166357141,
-0.0762578249,
0.0134461317,
0.0563775972,
-0.0499772094,
-0.0231305044,
-0.0454125851,
-0.0552349389,
-0.0304392148,
-0.0559322983,
0.038353689,
-0.0252067987,
-0.0238734335,
-0.0306147505,
0.0225027446,
-0.002488533,
0.0298910905,
-0.007020249,
-0.0551841818,
0.0401133187,
-0.0085902577,
-0.038428802,
0.0279963184,
0.0041425647,
0.0774493292,
0.0750975385,
0.055339288,
-0.0267945901,
-0.0236456748,
-0.006301736,
0.0249669179,
-0.0119059402,
0.0323233902,
0.0482259728,
0.0166009255,
0.0164380036,
0.0040541254,
-0.0197225213,
-0.0279255025,
0.0047298996,
-0.0125494255,
0.0643311217,
0.0146891363,
0.039858304,
-0.0294778906,
-0.032504376,
0.0036959467,
0.0345982723,
-0.0066087428,
-0.0457104445,
-0.0758730471,
0.0500247777,
-0.0404131785,
0.0017852057,
0.0334375165,
-0.108589001,
0.0233280919,
-0.0150474589,
-0.0141040897,
0.0462112129,
0.0065541901,
-0.0126481,
0.0454579443,
0.016549306,
-0.0467766859,
0.0161553621,
-0.0373933837,
0.0317921042,
-0.0144981174,
-0.0398615636,
0.0592283756,
0.0116029838,
-0.0106730312,
-0.0115641821,
-0.0445705429,
0.071226798,
-0.0175815728,
0.0109238615,
0.0151384827,
0.0285739321,
-0.004407018,
0.0329135954,
-0.019371124,
-0.0261450931,
0.0677237064,
-0.0083416924,
0.0239794701,
-0.069814302,
-0.0064810133,
-0.0109405145,
-0.0314417072,
-0.0023825616,
0.0409178436,
-0.0137340687,
-0.0078323474,
-0.0308773573,
-0.0039059112,
0.0399535112,
-0.0222291145,
0.0078241499,
-0.0343116112,
-0.0336218327,
-0.0045519611,
-0.0000734097,
-0.0134532237,
0.0295366514,
0.0042857812,
-0.0280927792,
-0.0002633585,
-0.0030529166,
-0.0033902982,
-0.0056634787,
-0.0105940625,
0.0456202105,
-0.0187473409,
-0.0111534456,
-0.0109625831,
0.0345526971,
-0.0100282151,
0.0005640441,
0.038451083,
-0.0477275513,
0.0407759398,
0.0085251192,
-0.0116089555,
0.0023192375,
-0.0018743741,
-0.0342747942,
0.0349473804,
0.0019789378,
-0.0292393379,
0.0297779571,
0.059647873,
-0.0564282201,
-0.0311915129,
0.0888954997,
0.0207602903,
-0.0170369614,
-0.0060191657,
0.0279434416,
0.0088267513,
0.0050773313,
-0.0038392236,
-0.0408267789,
-0.0176875591,
0.0091101965,
0.0603083,
-0.0187919438,
0.0151598994,
-0.0234164074,
-0.0753421783,
0.0073816432,
0.0633198321,
-0.0280743986,
-0.0566437356,
-0.0116209397,
0.0001052408,
-0.0628480315,
0.0434977338,
-0.0172300134,
0.0383756794,
0.0085714906,
0.0203624796,
0.0107147843,
-0.1006405801,
-0.0470876396,
-0.0677703544,
0.0112249963,
0.059785679,
0.0638943613,
-0.0153262122,
-0.0407602564,
0.0308455918,
-0.0592834875,
-0.023836365,
0.0051904414,
0.0548725501,
-0.0017872513,
-0.0401856266,
-0.017305078,
-0.0139647834,
0.0089815091,
0.0514405183,
-0.0035360912,
0.0425810702,
-0.0180071369,
0.0006766957,
0.0018783599,
-0.0223500747,
-0.0224279482,
0.0564372055,
0.0405509919,
-0.0705398545,
0.007622913,
-0.0219524037,
-0.0065186713,
-0.0547720231,
-0.0089298161,
0.0225474313,
-0.057295043,
-0.0271233581,
-0.1309544444,
-0.0890006498,
-0.0144948168,
0.0085156886,
0.0005121449,
-0.0120159807,
0.0400428846,
-0.0112596368,
0.0242278818,
0.0176539999,
-0.0100371037,
-0.0083944248,
-0.0617765635,
0.0549245216,
-0.0296332855,
0.0016638209,
-0.0118081346,
-0.0169743262,
-0.0690515488,
-0.0417081639,
-0.0369181708,
0.0464170836,
0.013725183,
0.0405347943,
-0.0457028002,
-0.0308488514,
0.0110675832,
0.0729777664,
-0.0286213718,
-0.0305626802,
0.0719570369,
-0.0181209072,
-0.0221541375,
0.0369461812,
-0.0458159037,
0.0048284167,
-0.0110894321,
0.0304627381,
-0.0076052435,
-0.0336326919,
0.0343667455,
0.0123558026,
0.0681919381,
-0.0098162787,
-0.027823858,
-0.040474616,
-0.0095179835,
-0.015063758,
-0.0292209983,
-0.0544538647,
0.0175691526,
0.0343524106,
0.0302197877,
-0.051713232,
0.0259927213,
-0.0194476116,
0.0139972782,
-0.0285841115,
-0.0045692697,
-0.0425058082,
0.0185433477,
-0.0149894347,
0.0092658401,
-0.0214741156,
-0.028343441,
0.0346940868,
0.0063407184,
-0.0317260846,
0.0149788698,
0.0274195876,
0.0206088666,
0.0435260311,
0.0642390773,
-0.0428412184,
-0.014169476,
-0.0561582334,
-0.0248052385,
0.0593967065,
-0.0304758865,
0.0932388082,
0.0071372809,
-0.0132744014,
-0.0409774929,
0.0392101295,
0.0470789224,
0.0295099411,
-0.0249389745,
-0.0101432921,
-0.0014023657,
-0.0002275614,
0.0587363653,
-0.0613497831,
-0.0069712978,
-0.0063848821,
-0.0396665521,
-0.0257800519,
0.0180225726,
-0.0227360018,
-0.0232213382,
-0.0030922738,
-0.0317960046,
-0.0025893443,
-0.0344589129,
0.0063101375,
0.0067878198,
0.0220974255,
-0.0179994274,
0.0189223792,
0.0518868677,
-0.0360036865,
0.0368742943,
-0.0353088863,
-0.0575775243,
0.0268317666,
-0.0013761669,
-0.038877409,
-6.087447004e-33,
-0.0023367028,
-0.015160596,
-0.025433965,
-0.0377591699,
-0.0194693804,
-0.0105727017,
-0.0043515223,
-0.0682356134,
-0.0243037976,
0.0135603342,
0.0214713234,
0.0379660837,
0.0180619508,
-0.0116264969,
-0.0212663058,
0.0401314981,
0.0889798105,
-0.005844146,
-0.0362614729,
0.0087706512,
0.0115939677,
0.0173634663,
0.0783184394,
-0.0395883694,
0.03154248,
0.0222179219,
-0.0343849771,
0.018046964,
0.0534011163,
0.0517081618,
0.0182751529,
0.0491837636,
0.0242525972,
-0.0272821318,
-0.0240100939,
-0.0352828987,
-0.0541056506,
-0.0331078134,
-0.0220619347,
0.0247021988,
-0.005191219,
-0.0610173717,
0.0733587444,
-0.0349168293,
-0.0237193443,
-0.0016307946,
0.0413044915,
-0.0514354333,
-0.0309172925,
-0.0356152356,
-0.0000602622,
0.0505447835,
-0.0280004125,
-0.0095229624,
0.0190206245,
0.0756350532,
-0.0280472338,
0.0145313777,
-0.0879954845,
0.0048740124,
-0.0096293529,
0.0555678159,
0.0105578816,
-0.0264996253,
-0.0102573633,
0.0260929447,
0.0128336754,
-0.0031249938,
0.0731092766,
0.017162513,
0.0427257046,
0.0015037104,
0.090207234,
0.0397900939,
0.0641272217,
-0.0308492798,
-0.087805219,
0.0701397061,
-0.0613049977,
0.0417176113,
-0.0077282232,
-0.0055261985,
-0.0437099971,
0.0025544178,
-0.0314442627,
-0.0693878531,
-0.0251318086,
-0.0030756402,
-0.0086053945,
0.0174073204,
-0.0566434674,
-0.057009887,
0.0228195116,
-0.0356199183,
0.049166847,
-0.0090120882,
-0.0762775019,
-0.0274550226,
0.0171971247,
0.0211838428,
-0.0092553571,
-0.0145801054,
0.0030691214,
0.04100563,
0.0203123447,
-0.0337415077,
0.0641118139,
0.0177603047,
-0.0430359282,
0.0262721311,
-0.0408738405,
0.0088087702,
-0.0054049729,
-0.0037201173,
0.016660247,
-0.0262875911,
-0.0118276216,
0.0667969659,
0.0419406965,
0.0262207408,
-0.013570928,
0.0012907333,
0.0301313065,
0.0243561585,
-0.0392989889,
-0.0084752226,
-0.0257121231,
0.0514302999,
0.0479666665,
-0.0669018552,
-0.0355996601,
-0.0197782889,
2.66e-7,
0.0277567562,
0.0610170439,
0.006385983,
0.0329485387,
0.0065255975,
0.0504230559,
-0.0230949707,
0.0372128859,
-0.0168134682,
0.0488874875,
0.0196149293,
-0.0168078914,
0.0801533461,
0.0533680506,
-0.0712703168,
-0.0102208937,
-0.0758420527,
-0.0165110435,
-0.0337903537,
-0.0014087006,
0.0661507398,
0.0700604171,
0.0112498589,
0.0028028679,
0.0072238739,
-0.0760057047,
0.0652157217,
-0.0232552309,
-0.0132505586,
0.0230181273,
0.1183005348,
0.0251372457,
-0.0057238569,
-0.0418515801,
-0.0439925753,
0.0275116712,
0.0472019166,
0.0509286001,
0.0325229801,
0.0009593274,
0.0220330898,
-0.0074102776,
0.027065428,
-0.0135113699,
0.0712203234,
-0.0204850622,
-0.0071884994,
0.0125286719,
-0.026492497,
-0.024567645,
0.0783856735,
-0.0478352755,
-0.0611292645,
0.0008778931,
0.019114444,
0.0092124632,
0.007949058,
-0.0187625047,
-0.0068156784,
-0.0167181436,
0.0354913846,
-0.0666555837,
-0.0113618365,
-0.0111992294,
0.0299626347,
-0.0270042885,
0.0232562758,
2.198452927e-34,
0.066583626,
-0.0558379553,
0.0580532216,
-0.0275497902,
0.0264076348,
0.0139433909,
-0.0298576429,
-0.053154584,
0.0015888155,
-0.0243900418,
-0.0150473109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05332v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05332v2 | On the Road with GPT-4V(ision): Early Explorations of Visual-Language Model on Autonomous Driving | 2023-11-09T12:58:37 | 2023-11-28T09:47:57 | Licheng Wen, Xuemeng Yang, Daocheng Fu, Xiaofeng Wang, Pinlong Cai, Xin Li, Tao Ma, Yingxuan Li, Linran Xu, Dengke Shang, Zheng Zhu, Shaoyan Sun, Yeqi Bai, Xinyu Cai, Min Dou, Shuanglu Hu, Botian Shi, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | The pursuit of autonomous driving technology hinges on the sophisticated
integration of perception, decision-making, and control systems. Traditional
approaches, both data-driven and rule-based, have been hindered by their
inability to grasp the nuance of complex driving environments and the
intentions of other road users. This has been a significant bottleneck,
particularly in the development of common sense reasoning and nuanced scene
understanding necessary for safe and reliable autonomous driving. The advent of
Visual Language Models (VLM) represents a novel frontier in realizing fully
autonomous vehicle driving. This report provides an exhaustive evaluation of
the latest state-of-the-art VLM, GPT-4V(ision), and its application in
autonomous driving scenarios. We explore the model's abilities to understand
and reason about driving scenes, make decisions, and ultimately act in the
capacity of a driver. Our comprehensive tests span from basic scene recognition
to complex causal reasoning and real-time decision-making under varying
conditions. Our findings reveal that GPT-4V demonstrates superior performance
in scene understanding and causal reasoning compared to existing autonomous
systems. It showcases the potential to handle out-of-distribution scenarios,
recognize intentions, and make informed decisions in real driving contexts.
However, challenges remain, particularly in direction discernment, traffic
light recognition, vision grounding, and spatial reasoning tasks. These
limitations underscore the need for further research and development. Project
is now available on GitHub for interested parties to access and utilize:
\url{https://github.com/PJLab-ADG/GPT4V-AD-Exploration} | [
0.004200005,
-0.001213992,
-0.01019534,
0.0810638517,
-0.0590508692,
0.0330055133,
0.0039464706,
-0.006100452,
0.0096952058,
-0.0408948697,
0.0303110722,
-0.0017160656,
-0.0221843366,
0.0341495946,
0.0100079402,
-0.0548070148,
0.0025566495,
-0.0791941732,
-0.0008987017,
-0.0089810798,
-0.0010337435,
0.0149856675,
-0.0098931016,
0.0157942642,
-0.0491129234,
0.004658665,
-0.0071784183,
0.0248408113,
0.0444711968,
-0.002577306,
-0.0206108727,
0.0381405205,
0.0991852134,
-0.0068106866,
0.0000020174,
-0.0224961676,
0.0240576565,
-0.0177571662,
0.0246192496,
-0.0171264708,
-0.0169809032,
-0.0107980259,
0.0050908267,
0.0101541271,
-0.0466749668,
-0.0414181538,
0.0362190455,
0.0461309552,
0.0423380211,
0.0464089513,
-0.0137476726,
-0.0341266431,
0.0550236218,
0.0072649582,
-0.0034814486,
-0.0330835804,
0.0359775908,
0.0452984832,
-0.0424148217,
-0.0107906684,
-0.0307081006,
0.0045443759,
0.0529925786,
-0.0095296595,
-0.0092834793,
0.0616653822,
-0.0055805328,
-0.0394712202,
-0.0282501224,
0.0610516481,
-0.0183969736,
-0.0826996714,
0.0055473037,
0.0019542794,
-0.0457834378,
-0.0205757078,
-0.0128135951,
0.0238853861,
-0.0009779239,
0.0432935655,
-0.0430795364,
-0.0075035184,
-0.0057525225,
0.0276127383,
0.0054300656,
0.0296861827,
0.0278787296,
0.0019577404,
0.0022721449,
0.0358577743,
-0.0620155074,
-0.0526579246,
-0.0440884419,
0.0343104973,
0.0040917364,
0.0019083441,
-0.0047055259,
0.0321335457,
-0.0383861251,
-0.046255745,
0.0419729576,
0.0421326123,
-0.0494899154,
0.0798980147,
-0.0006005051,
0.0755152628,
0.0108108688,
0.0390071236,
0.0047628321,
-0.0194476005,
-0.0203293283,
0.0069116163,
-0.0344744995,
-0.0363738202,
-0.0450021289,
-0.02238979,
0.0176316816,
0.0283347368,
0.0146888802,
0.0161843542,
-0.0285493657,
0.020355504,
-0.0128668295,
-0.0241705868,
-0.0199345872,
-0.004770136,
0.0242501441,
-0.0034231865,
-0.0266112462,
-0.052012641,
0.0365111679,
0.043531213,
-0.0264026523,
-0.0282066502,
0.0092877401,
0.0860863626,
-0.0152663095,
-0.0377273597,
-0.053707473,
0.0117009096,
-0.0166655406,
-0.0697734877,
-0.0035499774,
-0.0517524555,
-0.0059792488,
0.0130532105,
-0.0178473257,
-0.014664066,
0.0226129666,
-0.0243932735,
0.0188791323,
0.073180452,
-0.0251806527,
-0.015554131,
0.0070999973,
0.0109336972,
0.0231005792,
0.0568052121,
0.0188981276,
0.0744616762,
-0.0027079585,
0.0218642373,
0.0397325195,
-0.0123415058,
-0.0351106077,
0.0226074625,
-0.0796154365,
0.0198377818,
-0.0263919942,
-0.0023779762,
-0.00945454,
0.0646920949,
-0.0166057721,
-0.0181265492,
0.0817027465,
0.0000603309,
-0.0407755151,
-0.018700216,
0.0243726447,
0.0360040329,
0.004103079,
-0.0323607847,
-0.1010884419,
0.0614814721,
-0.0576128215,
-0.0088404519,
-0.0548618697,
0.0253403187,
-0.0080374768,
-0.0274389982,
-0.015501692,
0.0097701782,
0.0385678113,
-0.003112752,
0.0294227898,
-0.0743768439,
-0.0091724824,
-0.0297192167,
-0.0079109967,
0.0135655822,
-0.0005877082,
-0.0440846719,
0.0461708754,
0.061694745,
0.0097336378,
0.0106991529,
-0.0406244807,
-0.0102844974,
0.0298712701,
0.0120954523,
-0.0203096531,
0.0434045792,
0.0306769069,
-0.048235137,
-0.0504128858,
0.0385810882,
0.0067314385,
-0.0020682632,
0.0042868247,
0.0054070866,
0.0252139587,
-0.0201684572,
0.0174557287,
0.0233512614,
0.0624259934,
0.0010698196,
-0.0492742509,
0.0035067536,
0.0059240721,
-0.0346793458,
-0.0212824065,
-0.0050267288,
0.0485585257,
0.0275255591,
-0.0049447473,
0.039101474,
-0.0156428497,
0.0237600226,
0.0579787344,
-0.0745988563,
0.0038385822,
0.0633324012,
-0.047893133,
-0.0281076133,
-0.0063691596,
-0.0352807678,
-0.0243932046,
-0.0457669869,
-0.0256469343,
0.0625801533,
-0.0091142179,
-0.0200162865,
0.0611895397,
-0.0070411782,
-0.0196382217,
0.0114956414,
0.0059423526,
0.0314401463,
-0.0303248167,
0.0164561924,
-0.0142563647,
-0.0009101698,
-0.0183616374,
-0.0029514029,
0.0244992226,
-0.0049355337,
0.022973964,
-0.0432318039,
-0.0229655113,
-0.0527171977,
-0.0429497287,
-0.0101397866,
-0.0341528356,
-0.0135958511,
-0.0213650558,
0.012041579,
0.0508005507,
0.0371278152,
-0.0293248221,
0.0247346982,
-0.0300096478,
-0.0095615266,
-0.003419593,
-0.0214558188,
-0.0305883195,
-0.024637457,
0.0396073684,
-0.0500211269,
-0.0176626705,
-0.0008278303,
-0.0309065189,
0.0707608238,
-0.0542586707,
-0.0358357877,
-0.0076545388,
-0.0093753058,
0.0380886532,
0.0619900376,
0.0536996238,
-0.0190128405,
0.0154284658,
-0.0076078083,
0.009411511,
0.0191589613,
-0.031251777,
0.0036194946,
-0.0235079061,
-0.0028625289,
-0.0648754686,
0.0080135018,
0.0058385325,
0.0121123558,
-0.0721608847,
-0.0235269517,
-0.0223738607,
-0.0451850258,
-0.0670512691,
0.0002167362,
-0.0016938843,
0.0640449598,
-0.0333077013,
-0.0861194879,
0.0189881418,
-0.0466682501,
0.0014239775,
0.0129074883,
-0.0200993847,
-0.0188138448,
0.076777786,
0.0671694875,
0.0025082869,
-0.0078395633,
0.0459728166,
0.0057786093,
-0.0499977209,
-0.0116562955,
0.0140750874,
0.098099485,
-0.1236860231,
0.0477332547,
-0.0313006416,
-0.0219392534,
-0.0074579399,
-0.0180636495,
-0.0296900291,
0.0003836509,
-0.0388217196,
-0.0226893499,
0.0337771624,
0.0595247708,
0.0345962979,
0.0519199781,
-0.0020445657,
0.0077625443,
-0.0458361097,
-0.0258798972,
0.0919174105,
-0.0077435384,
-0.0028980721,
-0.008648322,
0.0140820704,
0.0443493351,
0.0112207457,
0.0061002988,
-0.0877618194,
0.0428153127,
0.0374884568,
0.0431171022,
-0.022467928,
0.0642871186,
0.0438607968,
-0.0354380272,
-0.0256384406,
0.0614043213,
0.0028707832,
-0.0191375576,
-0.0167822,
-0.0034290962,
-0.0201233532,
0.0172450747,
0.0040444536,
-0.0734550282,
-0.0430552289,
0.00853494,
-0.0259221271,
0.0421722196,
-0.0013968856,
0.0061797802,
-0.0199978538,
0.0898872167,
-0.0048428397,
-0.0489023961,
-0.0226035826,
0.0247798394,
-0.0351440795,
-0.0392834917,
0.0164895914,
0.0121075921,
-0.013060824,
0.0073375278,
0.0174605511,
0.0316973329,
0.0142274247,
0.0299651977,
-0.0231648795,
-0.0040348088,
0.0613253228,
-0.0073919697,
-0.0291679017,
-0.0788608491,
0.0113113094,
-0.0097554429,
0.0089603793,
-0.0424610078,
0.0210500658,
-0.0480660126,
-0.0139978491,
-0.0080185141,
0.0319837108,
-0.0134352865,
-0.0314411968,
-0.0448398702,
0.0356276706,
-0.0494932607,
0.0004932279,
-0.0424452163,
0.0112552568,
-0.0146624912,
0.0433243699,
-0.017375173,
0.0207434166,
-0.0703466535,
0.0008204094,
-0.0158246458,
-0.0244507305,
-0.0344596803,
-0.0719136223,
0.0445951708,
-0.042947676,
0.0055606915,
-0.0253197551,
0.0406965613,
0.0232839417,
-0.002944293,
-0.0169154145,
0.0004801825,
0.0150114503,
-0.063020803,
0.0592332035,
-0.0065986766,
0.033191096,
-0.0341836065,
0.0306584425,
0.0144966273,
-0.0869422555,
-0.0481120571,
0.0291806422,
-0.0160826966,
-0.0223384332,
0.014873744,
0.0692187399,
0.0213562734,
0.0315904617,
-0.0382864177,
-0.0215095785,
-0.0120790498,
-0.0243446194,
0.05554704,
0.0540470183,
0.0001510261,
-0.0209072828,
0.0075870412,
0.0241417643,
-0.0308273155,
0.0725302994,
0.0364716463,
-0.040588256,
-0.025211269,
-0.0103388708,
0.0327011161,
0.0230096076,
0.0862353519,
0.0065129329,
0.0374721326,
-0.0112941265,
0.0243551545,
0.023034215,
0.0096398517,
-0.0869351402,
0.0292085949,
0.0015448105,
0.0359461941,
-0.0101147303,
-0.0333330706,
0.02465339,
-0.0328805596,
0.0068833786,
-0.0108110728,
0.0476311408,
-0.0118273702,
0.0040523587,
-0.0394209772,
0.0182714127,
-0.0271681082,
-0.0070258654,
0.0386388972,
0.0152322203,
0.1003186628,
0.0422439165,
-0.0487539023,
0.0206383523,
0.0323813222,
-0.0380676277,
-0.0777986422,
-0.0236125775,
0.0387349725,
0.0626143664,
0.0123467632,
0.0343379714,
-0.0738033429,
0.0300923921,
-0.0348796807,
0.041942317,
0.0634441823,
-0.0233775843,
0.0813913941,
0.0147006093,
-0.0396597199,
-0.0108700246,
0.0284580048,
0.0352017507,
0.0152937509,
0.0179127883,
-0.0205220804,
-0.0339221917,
-0.0341385603,
0.0407334752,
-0.0191617124,
-0.0212587975,
0.0085538793,
-0.0328981839,
-0.0344428904,
-0.0317745954,
0.0676533282,
0.0110261953,
-0.0247074571,
0.0118023921,
0.0327058993,
0.0303755607,
-0.0963794664,
0.0285303239,
-0.0418336801,
-0.0132018747,
0.0434003547,
-0.0046587386,
-6.259795414e-33,
-0.0307066776,
0.0085351495,
0.0712662265,
-0.0174759943,
-0.0039441194,
-0.0084271487,
-0.0329436734,
0.0091554699,
-0.0145101408,
0.0074425964,
0.0115008289,
0.0492496192,
0.0286248606,
0.0314194411,
-0.0092204753,
-0.0422479063,
-0.0123857409,
0.0188233107,
-0.0129096657,
0.0188298672,
0.0071575493,
-0.0206681993,
0.0148942182,
-0.0327885747,
-0.0335714072,
-0.0029768925,
-0.0293469932,
0.0248943344,
-0.0800126567,
0.0304920021,
-0.0175141227,
-0.0283456799,
0.0321475603,
-0.0207879469,
-0.0146248601,
0.0234628618,
-0.008734432,
0.0010822256,
0.0293526091,
0.0434668623,
-0.1082217395,
0.0133309951,
0.0373713262,
-0.0084092775,
-0.033846654,
0.0185592826,
0.0537614152,
-0.0240858663,
-0.0005879411,
0.022553999,
-0.0403001383,
0.013939173,
0.0241630934,
-0.0301409587,
0.0184826981,
0.0208943617,
-0.0004584247,
0.0392927937,
-0.0300715957,
-0.0117624076,
-0.0087086735,
0.007248411,
0.0904460847,
-0.0009172312,
0.0165979266,
0.0341876261,
0.0087800836,
-0.1061462313,
-0.053478241,
-0.0160981715,
-0.0010174466,
0.0719796643,
0.0407894924,
0.0208601356,
-0.0309985317,
0.0017898973,
-0.070392631,
-0.0149922911,
-0.0376942754,
0.0613565966,
0.0411106907,
-0.0051011317,
-0.0630142987,
0.021821361,
0.0032283245,
-0.0230151117,
-0.0179960523,
-0.0093832873,
0.0542042404,
0.0370837972,
-0.0183387119,
0.0095178084,
0.0558814667,
-0.0466989763,
0.0406917222,
0.0149277989,
-0.0287251454,
0.0123213381,
0.0094932253,
0.0420853794,
-0.0890618935,
-0.0120019112,
0.0330372863,
-0.0132035892,
-0.0291887149,
0.0036358761,
-0.0222057812,
0.0343052261,
0.0083806645,
0.0094616795,
-0.0790546983,
0.0161757674,
0.0320964232,
0.0093459301,
0.0449757315,
0.0110860383,
-0.0077316612,
-0.012498932,
-0.0120113827,
-0.056947872,
-0.008458863,
-0.0529221445,
-0.0174273383,
0.0084440773,
0.0103591811,
0.0161894318,
0.0040752618,
-0.0263172928,
-0.0047741835,
-0.0132845361,
0.0255435854,
0.0467764996,
2.71e-7,
0.0058967993,
0.0197944511,
0.0106052794,
0.0122920554,
0.0187117718,
0.0613969937,
-0.0302531831,
0.006978977,
-0.011294377,
-0.0092614125,
-0.0041946489,
0.0706374124,
0.026134802,
-0.0235679485,
0.0360067822,
0.0400784127,
0.0190912802,
-0.0381585509,
-0.045607578,
0.0342881531,
0.0880458876,
0.0783543885,
0.0165048223,
-0.0142337121,
0.0574496798,
-0.0046411897,
0.0396440364,
-0.0455494262,
0.0237308256,
-0.0451564118,
0.0351223759,
0.0245147794,
-0.0273682587,
0.0412877351,
0.0233643502,
-0.0335091092,
-0.0327387713,
0.0677550137,
-0.0424141921,
-0.0137516074,
-0.012506336,
-0.031650234,
-0.0041648168,
-0.0793071464,
0.0927483514,
0.020766072,
0.0128979115,
-0.0010222995,
-0.0397898741,
-0.0176842697,
-0.0303680971,
0.0417678952,
-0.0286594387,
-0.0341245458,
0.0252092797,
-0.0201621298,
-0.0250137094,
-0.058419738,
0.0143895596,
-0.0135060865,
-0.0196769163,
0.0000018062,
-0.0488341972,
0.0591208339,
0.0555712841,
-0.0067736288,
-0.0903443173,
1.892030478e-34,
0.007572982,
-0.006511162,
-0.0218516085,
-0.0255270321,
-0.0214819945,
0.0228763763,
-0.0370227434,
0.0033648212,
-0.0538075939,
-0.0087055666,
0.0087311072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05297v2 | Challenging the Validity of Personality Tests for Large Language Models | 2023-11-09T11:54:01 | 2024-06-05T10:33:18 | Tom Sühr, Florian E. Dorner, Samira Samadi, Augustin Kelava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 91E45, H.1; I.2; I.6; J.4 | With large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 appearing to behave increasingly
human-like in text-based interactions, it has become popular to attempt to
evaluate personality traits of LLMs using questionnaires originally developed
for humans. While reusing measures is a resource-efficient way to evaluate
LLMs, careful adaptations are usually required to ensure that assessment
results are valid even across human subpopulations. In this work, we provide
evidence that LLMs' responses to personality tests systematically deviate from
human responses, implying that the results of these tests cannot be interpreted
in the same way. Concretely, reverse-coded items ("I am introverted" vs. "I am
extraverted") are often both answered affirmatively. Furthermore, variation
across prompts designed to "steer" LLMs to simulate particular personality
types does not follow the clear separation into five independent personality
factors from human samples. In light of these results, we believe that it is
important to investigate tests' validity for LLMs before drawing strong
conclusions about potentially ill-defined concepts like LLMs' "personality". | [
0.0481235534,
0.0411715358,
-0.0663935766,
0.0078032245,
-0.0342912078,
0.0144029036,
0.0253949296,
0.0096819438,
0.005297001,
0.0096674059,
-0.0680953264,
-0.0182702858,
-0.0021444962,
0.0015308223,
0.0296559185,
-0.0345626473,
0.0393185243,
-0.0082537327,
0.0149841662,
-0.0140614342,
-0.0145349372,
0.0356496908,
0.0287649781,
0.0106334714,
0.0500494838,
-0.0169034377,
-0.0077132904,
-0.0385228693,
0.0257736128,
-0.0085464967,
0.0205921289,
0.0590041913,
0.0159582123,
0.0295104962,
0.0000020501,
-0.0329596624,
0.0141660841,
-0.0104511371,
0.0134210791,
0.0456804298,
0.0458260737,
0.0450659022,
0.0186505988,
0.0458888672,
-0.0646893755,
-0.0451255254,
0.0132934768,
0.0210108906,
0.0402167737,
0.0453216024,
-0.0013781959,
0.0013819837,
0.0131825712,
-0.0152782789,
0.0411776677,
0.0111336494,
0.0169475935,
-0.0539329536,
-0.0042046132,
0.0349450223,
0.0051061106,
-0.0072060549,
0.0171691366,
0.0460790396,
-0.0400404148,
0.0052777608,
-0.0289375596,
-0.0245788135,
0.01374627,
0.0339159407,
0.0751372948,
-0.0261600371,
-0.0282217842,
-0.0089381719,
0.0284299906,
0.0331289805,
-0.0000231273,
0.0261926074,
0.0100489175,
-0.0620311983,
0.0327526927,
0.0208715014,
-0.0237459447,
-0.0093452288,
-0.0187797174,
0.0614941344,
0.0081362855,
-0.0170990564,
0.0073162117,
0.0123021156,
-0.003885244,
-0.0424009599,
0.0092704752,
-0.0119567858,
0.0015872747,
0.0161342174,
-0.0349646918,
0.018447008,
0.0412296467,
-0.0105704572,
0.0057095904,
0.0422392972,
-0.024161147,
-0.0163762476,
0.0692436025,
0.0621345788,
0.0268472638,
0.0188227128,
0.0008667078,
0.001110138,
-0.050061807,
-0.0154489484,
0.0227834396,
-0.0340120308,
0.0358075649,
-0.0001561914,
-0.0578291006,
0.031595502,
-0.0038414528,
-0.0178401321,
-0.0135301007,
-0.043076247,
0.0191769283,
0.0198342092,
-0.0602592193,
0.0164383389,
-0.0522441082,
-0.0170006379,
-0.0086908238,
-0.0621297807,
0.0560401827,
-0.0076916516,
0.0134912813,
-0.060907498,
0.0286583379,
0.0236977581,
0.0245396104,
-0.0432662889,
0.0097555229,
-0.0150680505,
-0.0257777479,
-0.0801703036,
0.0196831897,
-0.0275796261,
0.0182154998,
0.0517869405,
-0.019028496,
-0.047450725,
-0.0091555063,
0.0453456454,
-0.0057685035,
0.044775255,
-0.008680894,
0.0440988243,
0.0047722002,
0.0204318371,
0.0165499076,
0.0048103654,
-0.0090641193,
-0.0157657918,
0.0431468934,
-0.0715405643,
0.0476852506,
0.0442296751,
-0.0232955366,
0.0291161388,
0.0010531688,
0.0103732767,
0.0042016776,
-0.0291312281,
0.0551354177,
0.0548123196,
-0.0071844994,
-0.0057005174,
0.101417467,
0.0662487894,
0.0058116573,
0.0387670211,
-0.0101441406,
0.053789828,
0.0276188087,
0.0342394672,
-0.0281499382,
0.0122969449,
-0.0236057509,
0.008956342,
0.0001246473,
0.0151133584,
0.0022741086,
-0.039256651,
-0.0289952755,
0.0133706154,
0.0630648062,
0.0382807665,
-0.0090004075,
-0.0424731672,
0.004448683,
-0.0425235219,
0.0337452963,
-0.064087525,
-0.0351612046,
-0.053500969,
-0.0151299359,
0.0731670335,
0.0006192061,
0.0280700549,
0.0050619463,
-0.0010892332,
-0.0333477594,
0.0590358041,
0.0779099613,
0.0015356806,
-0.0181261227,
-0.0262507051,
0.0486472547,
0.0036646491,
-0.0012281514,
0.0050555579,
0.0167890321,
0.0349947736,
-0.00723725,
0.0086187245,
0.0028753602,
-0.0082430746,
-0.0981580094,
-0.0578428768,
-0.0218691695,
0.0192804467,
0.0332546942,
0.0020856885,
0.0023857269,
-0.0167358853,
-0.0105743865,
0.0225007068,
-0.0024607563,
0.0061243116,
-0.003113017,
0.0078654261,
-0.0027729135,
0.0223522056,
-0.0337904133,
0.042359449,
0.0453138165,
0.0135875735,
-0.0021325876,
-0.0516479053,
0.0532591343,
-0.0059330575,
0.0042168209,
-0.0622170754,
0.0566758327,
0.0008465678,
0.0262998343,
-0.0008178311,
0.0449077152,
0.0204501897,
-0.0182264019,
-0.0053143711,
-0.0495915785,
-0.0351868831,
-0.0102321226,
0.010358572,
0.0182490814,
0.0190959349,
0.0048561073,
-0.0666941851,
-0.0415203981,
-0.0548770837,
0.0149492072,
0.021597648,
0.0397991799,
0.0403415486,
-0.0146775478,
-0.0530032888,
0.0375974514,
-0.04403992,
-0.0093913274,
0.011108554,
0.0571948178,
0.0214965064,
-0.033768326,
0.0117933378,
-0.0490102619,
0.0042168498,
-0.0596791767,
-0.022197308,
-0.0355041623,
0.06351652,
-0.0123906881,
0.0232229456,
-0.0612629466,
-0.0116162971,
-0.0183146056,
-0.0835625008,
0.0484302379,
-0.0158092417,
0.0410958044,
0.0504503623,
0.0461054407,
0.0285009723,
0.0118462751,
-0.0132275624,
-0.0341068693,
-0.0142125273,
0.0040282393,
-0.0061550303,
-0.0224952865,
-0.1122295782,
-0.020813968,
0.0371453576,
0.0203533061,
0.0320662744,
-0.0488402396,
0.0380740054,
0.0013964308,
-0.0344012417,
0.0410522372,
0.0255236607,
-0.0341242105,
0.0560449064,
0.02111453,
-0.0301181339,
0.0503114089,
-0.0117065432,
-0.0161413755,
-0.0372765251,
-0.0468023159,
-0.0046298061,
0.0874494687,
0.0163123682,
-0.0385285094,
0.0583752468,
0.0006656062,
-0.0420912579,
-0.0387163125,
-0.0014773099,
-0.0348884352,
0.04777788,
0.0039241123,
-0.0599603467,
0.0423482768,
-0.0092142429,
-0.0128141167,
-0.0376549847,
-0.0277538169,
-0.02580362,
0.0323553644,
-0.0405748524,
-0.0157916527,
-0.0201625582,
0.0530208722,
-0.0066373339,
-0.0488548726,
-0.0057245526,
0.0097811641,
0.0000671551,
0.0570841245,
0.0098106321,
0.0348529033,
-0.0879668593,
-0.0083854096,
-0.0002528208,
-0.05381855,
0.0066029131,
0.0198870562,
0.0057409285,
0.0068563451,
0.0074505387,
-0.0268804841,
0.0207000822,
0.0503595583,
-0.0040193689,
-0.0124703106,
0.1160975322,
0.0298383106,
-0.0113483043,
0.0117818899,
0.0015053633,
0.0299668629,
0.025083581,
0.0431842208,
0.0177770164,
0.0021050242,
-0.0184340496,
0.0213846453,
-0.0514748804,
-0.0100699132,
-0.027638223,
-0.1024253294,
0.0129902894,
-0.0068385648,
-0.0639763549,
0.0285688825,
-0.0490710661,
0.0404888541,
-0.0030411789,
0.0225954056,
-0.0185360648,
-0.001470827,
0.0073925685,
-0.0481071547,
-0.0787295476,
-0.0034999202,
0.0868319795,
0.0015728688,
0.0326471627,
-0.0019606417,
0.0457019024,
-0.0339536518,
-0.0536536053,
-0.0388147011,
-0.0222163741,
-0.0110219819,
0.029041538,
0.049120672,
-0.0099913636,
0.0332726017,
-0.1021199301,
-0.0121712973,
-0.0276358761,
0.0183767956,
0.0099663967,
0.036158897,
0.0142852189,
-0.0695127249,
-0.0060627558,
0.0263747964,
0.008079106,
0.0425878353,
-0.0092609413,
-0.0943271518,
0.0133720553,
-0.0034315926,
0.0160298925,
0.0095541365,
-0.094644025,
-0.0132627003,
0.0255836137,
-0.0421100296,
-0.0363369472,
-0.1172889322,
0.0010204709,
-0.0059592281,
-0.0302313827,
-0.0292782728,
-0.0189411733,
0.0031506533,
-0.0249527935,
0.0162332878,
0.0037332913,
0.0241605341,
-0.0248538479,
-0.0163379759,
0.0388751626,
-0.0475009978,
-0.0014030027,
0.0199112222,
-0.0426743403,
-0.0416863784,
0.0417903513,
-0.0242364667,
0.0245096833,
-0.0232463162,
0.0386995822,
-0.022031704,
-0.0238628294,
-0.0219411403,
-0.0374875031,
0.0677062124,
-0.0373690687,
0.0410823375,
0.0049367817,
0.0115389191,
0.0061349701,
0.0159131289,
-0.0061023985,
-0.0310314801,
-0.0116086183,
-0.1201813594,
0.0072850655,
0.0374079049,
0.0065552141,
0.0151411984,
-0.0094917323,
0.0109056383,
-0.0532860383,
-0.0391159989,
-0.0120479995,
0.0273372363,
-0.1079358384,
0.0066020652,
0.0209840219,
-0.0346754007,
-0.0248640291,
-0.0353821479,
0.0341228843,
-0.0577043742,
0.0139688235,
0.0195561741,
0.0339233503,
-0.0231310893,
0.001317371,
-0.01196675,
-0.0212944895,
0.0007768706,
0.0628647208,
-0.0048575746,
0.1032626703,
-0.0412012897,
-0.0153724346,
0.0128087411,
0.027567843,
-0.0713446364,
-0.021326961,
0.0339333303,
0.0013695686,
-0.0571882166,
-0.0037525301,
0.0480065122,
-0.0476812646,
0.0214695465,
-0.0483240485,
0.0170735102,
-0.003225429,
-0.0141115692,
0.0130866431,
0.0093908738,
-0.0112518035,
-0.0247969572,
0.006687175,
0.053826835,
-0.0104230233,
-0.0108054504,
-0.0371992476,
-0.0305100344,
0.0306794774,
0.0133168902,
0.038595587,
-0.024957737,
-0.0245432351,
-0.0711427778,
-0.0895311609,
0.0193078853,
0.0179547723,
0.0155781703,
-0.0405962318,
0.0030853911,
0.0524251871,
-0.0259665027,
-0.0399713516,
-0.0408753902,
0.0422706082,
-0.0483881086,
0.0129779279,
-0.0222931281,
-5.951603203e-33,
-0.0228637084,
-0.0121742301,
0.0181390252,
0.0076213735,
-0.0238850135,
-0.0511727333,
-0.0312244706,
0.0542336404,
-0.0273993853,
-0.0270127058,
-0.0414579362,
0.0132173318,
0.0172096472,
-0.0303058513,
0.0086911665,
0.020132022,
0.02163947,
-0.0073023499,
-0.0266496968,
-0.0108089242,
0.0015524819,
-0.022862779,
0.0581460558,
-0.0442948453,
0.0270287432,
-0.0594204664,
0.0245744586,
-0.0478049517,
0.0108103612,
0.0428579077,
-0.0130261788,
0.052790612,
0.0464977808,
0.0023371794,
0.0035840566,
0.0709744319,
-0.0236151777,
-0.0510597117,
0.0157744866,
0.0194262806,
-0.0133365486,
-0.0409006551,
0.0078109889,
-0.0298418105,
-0.0688328892,
-0.0294074267,
0.0329925045,
-0.0025664503,
0.0533924848,
0.0759395957,
-0.0299501345,
-0.0009186402,
0.0092606498,
-0.0035255225,
-0.0392871313,
0.0342333093,
-0.0358897783,
-0.0042610709,
-0.0634310916,
0.0620012209,
-0.0291198473,
-0.0239418726,
0.0075573507,
0.0073171733,
0.0117803765,
0.0208088532,
0.0656403452,
0.0729728937,
0.0152716246,
-0.0087876171,
0.0708488598,
0.0169527717,
0.0144394077,
0.0676263422,
-0.0033010459,
-0.0493203513,
0.0390996523,
-0.0020407788,
0.0957741141,
-0.0761537105,
0.0472797528,
0.0042754626,
-0.0526887551,
-0.0417614728,
-0.0003813793,
0.0011277584,
-0.0204180256,
-0.0560599454,
0.0413515121,
-0.0484834611,
0.0169410985,
-0.056922283,
0.0564132258,
-0.0253149047,
-0.0354079269,
-0.0054516513,
-0.088231653,
0.0550874434,
-0.0044342629,
0.0013174589,
-0.0202486869,
0.011599509,
0.0048162634,
0.0384740271,
0.0433679856,
0.0320688076,
-0.0120273465,
0.0152772842,
-0.0709444433,
-0.0226528309,
0.012730659,
-0.0016583073,
0.0034172838,
0.0315310247,
0.0248136651,
0.0073705968,
0.011819385,
0.003197005,
0.0025092913,
-0.0145998718,
-0.0840604305,
-0.030105954,
0.0002333732,
-0.0212869309,
0.0057995194,
-0.0100450385,
-0.0706440136,
0.015865352,
0.0243588015,
-0.0241057426,
0.0146559579,
0.0040942086,
2.728e-7,
-0.0271386877,
0.0874546468,
-0.0507278442,
0.05032463,
0.0294213519,
0.0380691178,
-0.0151174925,
-0.0002073869,
0.0730473474,
-0.0227287337,
0.0022115039,
0.0159150995,
0.0530818142,
0.0386777148,
-0.0061962297,
0.0141029749,
-0.0097942622,
0.0108254924,
-0.0289199147,
0.0251952279,
0.0647916421,
0.0253754109,
0.0425226688,
-0.0031312867,
-0.0147154955,
0.0104220659,
0.0216965768,
-0.0036626926,
-0.0287626106,
0.015104481,
-0.0579605289,
0.004699708,
0.023603173,
0.0634874851,
0.0079253661,
-0.0114888987,
-0.0256910827,
0.0615473874,
-0.0272180587,
0.0067157666,
0.0223651975,
0.0075855632,
-0.0249695312,
-0.0533073172,
0.0447835736,
-0.0076689832,
-0.0299211014,
0.003847236,
-0.0233755726,
-0.0556664243,
0.0413434617,
-0.0083869919,
-0.036440473,
0.0375959724,
0.0274680965,
-0.02512642,
-0.0072932565,
-0.0201774072,
0.0290598795,
-0.0058813496,
-0.0394636393,
-0.0869493932,
-0.0380739234,
0.0371465534,
0.0187076032,
-0.0270270165,
0.0183321889,
2.314924902e-34,
-0.0072720395,
0.0683096722,
0.0120218992,
-0.0446484052,
0.0768135041,
0.0203062333,
0.031180637,
0.0327380523,
0.0394992419,
-0.0704215392,
-0.0097171925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05296v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05296v2 | BeLLM: Backward Dependency Enhanced Large Language Model for Sentence Embeddings | 2023-11-09T11:53:52 | 2024-03-14T08:04:17 | Xianming Li, Jing Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentence embeddings are crucial in measuring semantic similarity. Most recent
studies employed large language models (LLMs) to learn sentence embeddings.
Existing LLMs mainly adopted autoregressive architecture without explicit
backward dependency modeling. Therefore, we examined the effects of backward
dependencies in LLMs for semantic similarity measurements. Concretely, we
propose a novel model: backward dependency enhanced large language model
(BeLLM). It learns sentence embeddings via transforming specific attention
layers from uni- to bi-directional. We extensively experiment across various
semantic textual similarity (STS) tasks and downstream applications. BeLLM
achieves state-of-the-art performance in varying scenarios. It shows that
auto-regressive LLMs benefit from backward dependencies for sentence
embeddings. | [
0.0118151857,
0.0591754019,
-0.0088391323,
0.0767468289,
-0.0540642403,
0.0073746601,
-0.0022377714,
-0.0377317332,
0.0186987221,
-0.0347708166,
-0.0241955407,
0.0083940038,
-0.0356919691,
-0.0204995777,
0.0324149579,
0.0232154243,
0.0271738023,
0.0161498915,
-0.0485837124,
0.0089215115,
0.0230107903,
-0.012178475,
0.035866145,
0.0279128235,
-0.0167359337,
-0.0293355994,
0.0285436232,
-0.0223049205,
0.0340983048,
-0.0446529463,
0.0273973998,
-0.0064156367,
0.0420199111,
0.0292316489,
0.0000015648,
-0.0204899237,
0.0303199664,
-0.046521496,
0.004582434,
0.0354385823,
-0.0206352808,
0.0113649499,
0.0277578626,
-0.025981091,
-0.0051713041,
-0.0198868345,
-0.0102378484,
0.0530833192,
0.0607819706,
0.0385054238,
-0.016035201,
-0.0308192223,
0.0453948155,
-0.0389626548,
0.0122094573,
-0.0190106779,
0.0073671835,
0.0204416495,
-0.0095141111,
0.0332211852,
-0.0108641004,
0.0452569313,
0.0430553854,
0.0220182054,
0.019632142,
0.0344333053,
0.0201941915,
0.0442039445,
0.0057744966,
0.0751624778,
-0.0017327273,
-0.0498756804,
-0.0216446724,
-0.0007202002,
-0.0163890738,
0.008198699,
-0.0395367183,
0.0194422919,
0.0242420752,
0.0708799958,
0.0456548147,
0.0396606848,
0.0430533551,
0.0106749935,
-0.0272792391,
0.0710281879,
0.0341032073,
-0.0639329702,
-0.0145894401,
0.023590263,
-0.0039281794,
0.0242643524,
0.0360300094,
-0.0163999237,
-0.0211465098,
-0.0279532094,
-0.0182683952,
-0.016030252,
0.0282320455,
-0.0445883088,
0.0474147014,
0.0316563621,
-0.0507787056,
0.0481111407,
-0.0872407258,
0.0590176955,
-0.0470771901,
-0.0102986516,
-0.0575604662,
-0.0331135467,
-0.0347593203,
-0.0118770972,
-0.0256791264,
0.0371612869,
-0.0036716084,
-0.0560952909,
-0.0201216172,
0.0381767638,
-0.0305158459,
-0.0049646334,
-0.0087406198,
-0.0004229952,
-0.0026116467,
-0.0068450142,
0.0041864933,
0.0124979131,
-0.0455479547,
0.0369326249,
-0.0416202769,
-0.0063353973,
-0.016828144,
0.0586700886,
0.006378484,
-0.0267901123,
-0.0208838563,
0.0220866408,
0.018529484,
-0.0176465604,
-0.0321372859,
0.0002202663,
0.0069295135,
-0.0254806653,
0.0104690818,
-0.0531134196,
0.0234579127,
-0.0123900995,
-0.0001374345,
-0.007155647,
0.0187300015,
0.0367984623,
-0.04821584,
0.0449592732,
0.1086560115,
-0.0225690715,
-0.0194938425,
-0.0197364781,
0.0525281541,
0.0429190844,
-0.0108486842,
0.0054645375,
0.0185321979,
0.0480930358,
-0.0405485556,
0.0164544769,
0.0043967236,
0.0358455926,
-0.0657233074,
0.0159525275,
0.0467289761,
0.0869861916,
0.0552064404,
0.0482535288,
-0.0223094318,
-0.0322353989,
0.0575508922,
0.0486915819,
0.0189014487,
-0.0012104,
0.0570388809,
-0.0109742358,
-0.0696182922,
0.0309382509,
-0.0373774916,
0.0273132995,
-0.0014045141,
-0.0019289014,
0.0739864036,
0.0119703682,
-0.0588652678,
0.0053590476,
0.0194571856,
-0.0340766981,
-0.0030322282,
-0.0371271186,
0.0196931697,
0.0266958643,
-0.0322820656,
0.0635442138,
0.0232731309,
-0.0538802706,
-0.0285205822,
-0.0111625958,
0.0020498065,
0.0342230722,
0.0584111586,
0.0024333075,
0.0197762307,
-0.0053712181,
0.0234014392,
0.0743669122,
0.002180387,
0.0183441751,
0.004071428,
-0.0360603742,
0.0051991539,
-0.031386558,
0.025367897,
-0.0000332707,
-0.0107912421,
0.0177104436,
0.046720285,
-0.0103688333,
-0.0144382194,
0.0503735356,
-0.0518383645,
-0.0221523792,
0.0055859108,
0.0239730384,
0.0040244265,
-0.0203617234,
0.0053216675,
0.0600200444,
0.0254755616,
-0.0875782445,
-0.0619522408,
-0.0055841445,
-0.0719895437,
-0.0925144553,
0.0425775424,
-0.0770459846,
-0.0061303112,
0.0797808319,
-0.0459294245,
-0.0041886251,
0.0274089463,
-0.024726361,
0.0676417574,
-0.0683473498,
0.0177326128,
0.0134280287,
0.0240820013,
-0.0287331287,
0.0336251296,
-0.0490954705,
0.0428336598,
-0.0393449478,
0.0003146652,
0.0266612396,
-0.0026756686,
-0.0383352749,
-0.0462182127,
0.0397821702,
0.0016296929,
0.0098264515,
-0.0041408669,
-0.0315836631,
-0.0220249593,
-0.0476509817,
0.029630959,
-0.0150375376,
0.0036662484,
0.0137944501,
0.0235153083,
0.019779399,
-0.0312953517,
-0.0153023349,
0.0057807164,
-0.0126850484,
0.0345271714,
0.0694936067,
-0.0437628105,
0.0000247922,
-0.0708022192,
-0.0253996309,
-0.0311801862,
0.0874931589,
-0.0488139465,
0.0236127004,
-0.047400374,
-0.0017723254,
-0.0344981477,
0.0058343443,
0.0102611575,
-0.0318494551,
0.0095325559,
-0.0171611104,
0.0635096803,
0.0633759052,
0.004563129,
-0.0021412389,
0.0538436137,
0.0152981803,
-0.0373775102,
0.0023648909,
-0.0269323252,
0.0259639565,
-0.004352869,
-0.0000637164,
0.0244778674,
0.0485451482,
-0.0069096256,
-0.0150707029,
-0.0021554057,
-0.0045550647,
0.0035960649,
0.0200170893,
-0.0270450078,
-0.0211649127,
-0.0285568833,
-0.042463392,
-0.0475122184,
-0.018578859,
0.0682411268,
-0.0520555675,
0.0102816643,
-0.0193062052,
0.0154141989,
-0.0510874726,
0.0520851016,
0.0417788625,
0.008762734,
-0.0279882085,
0.0288571268,
-0.0099020479,
0.0481842533,
0.0234201532,
0.0125689181,
0.0394918881,
0.0167567525,
0.0052130171,
0.0171051212,
-0.0456755459,
-0.0243790131,
-0.0751165301,
-0.0208417252,
0.0014722726,
-0.0129673313,
0.0485106334,
-0.0596439838,
-0.0029315883,
-0.0120589463,
0.0163391847,
0.0035568613,
-0.0133635458,
-0.0489398576,
0.0461868569,
0.0443287827,
-0.0330155827,
-0.008608113,
0.0150105152,
0.0366697945,
0.0274705179,
0.0390154906,
0.0223015994,
-0.044128418,
-0.0117263244,
-0.0169912539,
-0.0357674994,
-0.0102562057,
-0.0382202491,
0.0124011356,
-0.0225071497,
-0.0140942317,
0.0816531107,
0.0228345804,
-0.0285883471,
0.0126429209,
-0.0208626557,
0.0387264714,
0.0356633104,
-0.0186401159,
-0.0376731828,
-0.0510725714,
-0.0143989874,
-0.0313469134,
0.0278531518,
-0.0192854218,
0.0044717542,
-0.0972987935,
-0.0255313963,
0.0049148956,
-0.0091550481,
-0.0223963968,
-0.0394383036,
0.0221155528,
0.0395561717,
0.0104615139,
0.0015609284,
-0.0028200026,
-0.0237566065,
-0.0315632001,
-0.0467626266,
0.0054533612,
0.0168448519,
-0.0812128335,
0.0263777785,
0.0429317206,
0.0440104082,
0.0281320829,
-0.0249225385,
0.0304009691,
-0.0706384182,
-0.0065506008,
0.0046741646,
0.0168487318,
-0.0372219011,
0.005726988,
-0.0331611373,
0.0012014213,
-0.0284499135,
0.0072203469,
0.0063840528,
0.1055001542,
-0.0096225301,
-0.0152168488,
-0.030764604,
0.0139656411,
-0.0111933444,
0.0886220038,
0.075980112,
-0.0336383246,
-0.0686554611,
0.0129552344,
-0.0157914385,
-0.0188320708,
-0.0259936899,
0.0080793323,
0.0384741239,
-0.0034959551,
-0.0502065085,
-0.0795025751,
-0.0233959965,
-0.0405419916,
-0.0400024392,
0.0318882912,
-0.0039883773,
-0.0736377463,
-0.0399199687,
0.0127343386,
-0.0488171391,
0.0288817994,
0.0007718698,
0.0361342505,
0.0673369318,
0.0279959273,
-0.0315464847,
-0.0292341541,
-0.1053066775,
-0.043972142,
-0.0125259394,
0.0074705561,
-0.0096544297,
0.0360983573,
-0.0288166534,
-0.0028123823,
0.03042881,
0.0083563505,
-0.032668341,
0.0354911871,
0.0156280845,
0.0173201244,
0.0279862434,
0.0811842829,
-0.0254386775,
0.0298906416,
0.0219176169,
0.0452936552,
0.0511832498,
-0.0575073399,
-0.0011940993,
-0.0111313565,
0.0743564665,
0.0239527319,
0.0058697839,
-0.0253470615,
0.0110246511,
-0.0326917246,
-0.0075726574,
-0.0210940838,
0.0169440825,
0.0172852445,
-0.0040577059,
-0.0225751176,
-0.00543031,
0.0011388356,
0.038822338,
-0.0476873517,
0.0398480333,
0.027988432,
0.038585756,
-0.0178370457,
-0.0037797447,
-0.0707995892,
-0.0182510782,
-0.0260328855,
0.0042669177,
-0.0266463142,
0.0123012438,
0.0151772387,
-0.0110665699,
-0.0579504147,
0.0294503197,
-0.0708903596,
-0.0069337389,
0.0057909172,
-0.0009227679,
0.0663798451,
-0.0326837264,
0.0532884747,
-0.0131223174,
0.0155278677,
-0.0042853369,
0.020463882,
-0.0328453332,
-0.0261575039,
0.0265825391,
-0.0204447713,
-0.0208619386,
0.0314058065,
0.0743206888,
0.0223832801,
0.0574966818,
-0.0011857348,
-0.0290966686,
-0.0265961029,
-0.0378564112,
0.0128911491,
0.021556709,
-0.0135118533,
0.0376728289,
0.0030416702,
-0.0521282069,
-0.0087953536,
0.0083389319,
-0.040924143,
0.0009986766,
0.0174518544,
0.0362513699,
0.0218798835,
-0.0169554614,
-0.0108957523,
0.0557468422,
-0.0265683699,
-0.0868001506,
-0.0551098138,
-5.831533068e-33,
-0.0020160421,
0.000063944,
-0.025466226,
-0.0397772118,
-0.0450380184,
-0.0126968818,
-0.0461529382,
-0.0130514977,
-0.0236598328,
0.0450993627,
0.0232155118,
0.0255916193,
-0.0118233012,
0.0311772097,
0.0278019644,
-0.0212814566,
0.0474475175,
-0.005080753,
0.0103418296,
0.0147397965,
0.0400579087,
0.035758853,
0.0371820517,
-0.0043255244,
-0.0005100736,
-0.0603521094,
0.0452871509,
0.0309307408,
0.0317477174,
0.0673816502,
-0.0509670153,
0.0409501307,
0.046255067,
-0.0100478847,
-0.0182600506,
0.0542832948,
-0.0382520929,
-0.053282436,
0.0012428577,
-0.043430686,
-0.0350450687,
-0.0192007069,
0.0340493433,
-0.000267183,
-0.0046926909,
-0.0119465981,
0.0374010541,
0.0001658704,
-0.009858408,
0.0127035426,
-0.0765765384,
0.0007724764,
0.0000309325,
0.003698257,
-0.0037915956,
0.0589128546,
-0.0015891842,
0.0542470068,
-0.0205077361,
0.0034639128,
-0.0816167295,
0.0385646112,
0.0091814278,
0.0073847137,
0.007188621,
0.0706772059,
-0.0083947591,
-0.07346192,
-0.0380749181,
-0.0112908967,
0.0188150518,
0.0072133048,
0.0336732194,
0.021894658,
0.0191335883,
0.0025395167,
-0.0624106638,
0.0062412466,
0.0445330739,
0.0332251787,
0.0571086369,
0.0237124879,
-0.0159212239,
-0.0202800725,
-0.0274855904,
-0.0021209738,
-0.0279271305,
-0.0114701558,
0.0690752044,
-0.0149447266,
0.0294349845,
-0.0214478839,
0.0295432601,
-0.0451739132,
-0.024733711,
0.0489020422,
-0.01643591,
-0.0092605632,
0.0196538977,
0.0218894016,
-0.0363315642,
0.0029095085,
-0.0161914807,
0.0061772843,
0.0244390704,
-0.002644859,
0.0738604069,
-0.0420301445,
-0.0670018494,
-0.0136320079,
-0.0252361521,
-0.0951087102,
-0.0471636876,
-0.0159475077,
0.0134016434,
0.0060774889,
-0.0096955607,
0.0518784076,
0.023038784,
-0.0216684975,
-0.0417590924,
-0.058699403,
0.0104503967,
0.0500866994,
-0.0105661387,
-0.0126288496,
-0.0720298737,
0.0434933193,
-0.0029073637,
-0.0744773522,
-0.0126173487,
0.025509527,
2.3e-7,
0.028007837,
-0.0004600969,
0.0254619624,
-0.0077200844,
0.027410496,
0.019152239,
-0.0224148836,
0.0352840982,
-0.0013281273,
0.033099398,
0.015728252,
0.0383803248,
0.0537576973,
-0.0053389692,
-0.0651452392,
0.0226244479,
-0.115553394,
-0.0166816451,
-0.0637111738,
-0.056209743,
0.052621711,
0.0879654735,
0.0190291516,
0.0251488555,
-0.0162254032,
-0.0498176105,
0.0757922754,
-0.0412421823,
-0.0077792266,
-0.0132535174,
-0.016836822,
0.0084804464,
0.0050978065,
-0.0241730046,
0.0126216644,
0.042217955,
0.0081619816,
0.0111964317,
-0.0043234527,
-0.033580754,
-0.0023397952,
0.0152092371,
0.012468027,
-0.0577986352,
0.0594498627,
-0.0482712053,
0.0085758474,
-0.0271221325,
0.0017713568,
0.0392937735,
0.0781421736,
0.0211392567,
-0.0618271343,
-0.0201072972,
0.0603504665,
0.0099295462,
-0.0181654431,
-0.0808785856,
-0.0335902795,
0.0444749221,
-0.059384156,
0.0066327159,
-0.0760401711,
-0.0003684078,
0.0695350766,
-0.0280864313,
0.0060241418,
2.097140926e-34,
0.0072945096,
-0.0002454215,
0.0236177482,
-0.0169493016,
0.0349673368,
-0.0120951124,
-0.0132219382,
0.0123474095,
0.0171414521,
-0.088803269,
0.016165318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16162v1 | Leveraging Artificial Intelligence Technology for Mapping Research to Sustainable Development Goals: A Case Study | 2023-11-09T11:44:22 | 2023-11-09T11:44:22 | Hui Yin, Amir Aryani, Gavin Lambert, Marcus White, Luis Salvador-Carulla, Shazia Sadiq, Elvira Sojli, Jennifer Boddy, Greg Murray, Wing Wah Tham | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | The number of publications related to the Sustainable Development Goals
(SDGs) continues to grow. These publications cover a diverse spectrum of
research, from humanities and social sciences to engineering and health. Given
the imperative of funding bodies to monitor outcomes and impacts, linking
publications to relevant SDGs is critical but remains time-consuming and
difficult given the breadth and complexity of the SDGs. A publication may
relate to several goals (interconnection feature of goals), and therefore
require multidisciplinary knowledge to tag accurately. Machine learning
approaches are promising and have proven particularly valuable for tasks such
as manual data labeling and text classification. In this study, we employed
over 82,000 publications from an Australian university as a case study. We
utilized a similarity measure to map these publications onto Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs). Additionally, we leveraged the OpenAI GPT model to
conduct the same task, facilitating a comparative analysis between the two
approaches. Experimental results show that about 82.89% of the results obtained
by the similarity measure overlap (at least one tag) with the outputs of the
GPT model. The adopted model (similarity measure) can complement GPT model for
SDG classification. Furthermore, deep learning methods, which include the
similarity measure used here, are more accessible and trusted for dealing with
sensitive data without the use of commercial AI services or the deployment of
expensive computing resources to operate large language models. Our study
demonstrates how a crafted combination of the two methods can achieve reliable
results for mapping research to the SDGs. | [
0.0241039693,
0.077341795,
-0.0075506964,
-0.0159128532,
-0.0543276332,
0.0068509062,
0.0290421508,
-0.0266971104,
-0.0057481364,
-0.0258885957,
0.0209648702,
0.0524436347,
0.0119352322,
0.0564868897,
-0.0250663515,
-0.0328207649,
0.0573553592,
0.0292875562,
0.026533464,
0.0140455058,
-0.0413441919,
-0.0045608468,
0.0143143544,
0.0617906079,
-0.0245034508,
-0.0150341503,
-0.0197185278,
-0.0123499054,
0.0572621673,
-0.0211550873,
0.0324211456,
0.0318116881,
0.0120719876,
0.0703136772,
0.0000020023,
-0.0324065909,
-0.0610618666,
0.0022442774,
0.0268639848,
0.0200787745,
0.0613965094,
-0.037043076,
-0.0010927302,
-0.0004032929,
-0.0208855085,
-0.0344536006,
0.0773812458,
0.0232775882,
-0.0077363858,
-0.0047366852,
-0.0052330997,
-0.0550638922,
0.072162427,
-0.0006337904,
-0.0295224655,
0.0155428378,
0.0366348103,
0.0307242461,
-0.0140871163,
0.0265319198,
0.0160157308,
0.0748860538,
-0.0168223623,
-0.0147943394,
0.0356040038,
0.0321588702,
-0.017920563,
0.0040918468,
0.0247855335,
0.0341639519,
0.0013384289,
-0.0372506902,
0.0234465338,
-0.0418819077,
-0.0250563361,
0.0341445208,
-0.0331920087,
-0.0013406456,
0.0198857207,
0.0044398871,
0.0273802672,
0.041227378,
0.0303196516,
0.0501832515,
-0.0268674027,
0.075509578,
-0.0229467098,
-0.0224466082,
0.0371664353,
0.0078809047,
0.0104627358,
-0.0074324189,
-0.016716117,
0.007898096,
0.0016470186,
0.0095076011,
0.0081207864,
-0.0556105971,
0.0230170581,
-0.014863804,
0.0330284275,
0.0045735338,
0.0011896275,
0.0380654037,
0.0164852962,
0.0192881543,
-0.0449653491,
0.034957882,
-0.0174675882,
-0.037900202,
-0.0955373719,
-0.0362131409,
0.0169845931,
0.0246802121,
0.0089620631,
-0.0259428062,
-0.0321809053,
-0.0130478563,
-0.0509663559,
-0.0040899143,
0.0174941272,
0.0421491079,
-0.0269746799,
-0.0194535889,
-0.0177102741,
0.0591814779,
-0.0347731337,
0.0690166131,
-0.0435448289,
0.022971686,
0.0491419807,
0.0126170078,
0.0102398926,
0.0127704041,
0.0001226677,
0.0577325225,
0.0362162888,
-0.0116276667,
-0.0658097044,
-0.0351672433,
0.0245503411,
-0.0244248696,
0.0544860065,
-0.0326610543,
0.0123461979,
-0.030590158,
-0.007982214,
-0.069729723,
-0.0223102234,
-0.0087602641,
0.0030864365,
0.0624307059,
-0.0744384378,
-0.0149511695,
0.0801142976,
0.0223895796,
-0.0060465252,
0.0116934516,
0.0655932873,
0.0302686114,
0.0418603905,
0.0157417487,
-0.0157761928,
0.0009172882,
0.003152166,
-0.0258507263,
0.0447665043,
-0.009963301,
-0.0188771319,
0.0172787942,
-0.0100967335,
0.0117680831,
0.0206861291,
0.0301123261,
0.0516924225,
0.0700421259,
-0.0005911778,
0.0421759002,
-0.0210773982,
0.0300584603,
-0.037463747,
-0.0248141326,
0.0158557724,
0.0213249847,
0.039541956,
0.005081608,
0.0089604836,
0.0179138537,
0.0048167855,
-0.0220717732,
-0.0062791714,
0.0223976225,
0.012347904,
-0.0311399959,
0.0485408455,
0.0010282585,
-0.0042560156,
0.0000320799,
-0.00941863,
-0.0030730737,
0.0152191538,
-0.0410157852,
0.0264672711,
-0.0234235171,
0.0036866686,
-0.0748318955,
-0.0245542545,
-0.0239277724,
-0.0140482457,
0.0269215517,
0.0207076445,
-0.0085106539,
-0.0483665355,
-0.0013097832,
-0.039801944,
-0.016219018,
-0.0192158092,
0.032795094,
0.0224226397,
0.0276912339,
0.0095779728,
-0.0635643527,
-0.0346351489,
0.0783982649,
-0.028374562,
-0.0004176774,
0.0164046753,
0.0073367325,
0.0470258929,
0.0528754592,
0.0037737151,
0.0182602182,
0.0290976968,
-0.0286024958,
-0.0528295487,
-0.0135638434,
0.0356953405,
0.0927281901,
0.0181879364,
-0.092310369,
0.020887848,
0.1077737212,
-0.0490585193,
-0.0205494612,
0.0029815626,
0.0170496516,
-0.0135213397,
-0.0142638516,
-0.0163940303,
-0.0414150842,
0.000960448,
-0.0335238464,
0.0591000617,
0.0139555,
-0.0051230299,
-0.0320634432,
-0.0554527231,
0.0672652498,
0.0090647098,
-0.0025908493,
0.0066681067,
-0.0406202786,
0.0189419426,
0.0820331872,
-0.0097664855,
-0.0264203083,
0.0024592227,
-0.0626127943,
0.0169694982,
0.0115978085,
0.004530326,
-0.002383207,
-0.0438010283,
-0.0110769598,
0.0298546609,
0.0110071981,
0.0268596709,
-0.0256200675,
-0.0230138861,
0.0572592951,
0.0285289809,
0.0283765811,
-0.0462751314,
0.021244932,
-0.0431195721,
0.052018974,
0.0702057406,
-0.0428791791,
-0.0457524061,
-0.0025931243,
-0.0321329311,
0.0001318892,
-0.0098536499,
0.0063150274,
0.0013076235,
0.0459568352,
-0.0375314467,
-0.0252146721,
0.0138405664,
0.034108825,
0.0423279367,
0.0084423022,
-0.0419858433,
0.0107850954,
-0.0219308194,
0.0151580749,
0.0292885173,
-0.0000656183,
0.0545851216,
-0.0326569304,
-0.0097522167,
-0.016670743,
0.0085229771,
0.0347445533,
-0.0269233361,
-0.0223022681,
-0.0311029684,
-0.0267383289,
0.037716344,
0.0542217195,
0.0074909036,
-0.0582473539,
0.0195343159,
-0.0010430528,
0.0516896695,
-0.0704632625,
-0.0131211868,
-0.0174481943,
0.0587873198,
-0.0202314164,
0.007861767,
0.0111814905,
0.024591919,
-0.0133714564,
0.0178122614,
-0.0044694464,
0.0359584466,
-0.0029124301,
-0.0750106201,
0.0242866222,
-0.0207347069,
-0.016044585,
-0.0229140576,
-0.0162898879,
-0.002355342,
0.0518527925,
0.0149874557,
-0.0241964944,
-0.0642837882,
0.0433897525,
0.035376031,
0.0365818143,
0.012892195,
-0.01474139,
-0.0355254598,
-0.0278115906,
0.0465349965,
-0.0453528725,
0.02991849,
0.0564676374,
-0.0076155001,
-0.0134490766,
-0.0293862429,
0.0340638459,
-0.0650633574,
-0.0348001607,
-0.0139397727,
-0.0713084564,
0.0021958812,
-0.0068928436,
0.0036054687,
-0.0334355906,
0.0001048181,
0.0837999955,
0.0141927358,
-0.0589728132,
0.0016917021,
-0.0339841545,
-0.0118801547,
-0.0220915172,
-0.0145770507,
-0.0504487678,
-0.0094832201,
0.0087615037,
-0.0027143841,
-0.0513117351,
-0.0437274165,
-0.0247329958,
-0.0344843678,
0.0512442067,
-0.0121947741,
-0.0775109604,
-0.0056005353,
-0.0458512567,
0.0094014322,
-0.0167671479,
-0.0453602634,
-0.0648635328,
0.0253442433,
-0.0236877799,
0.0094649941,
-0.0292378422,
-0.0578087047,
-0.0216190126,
-0.0401274264,
0.0324592516,
0.0835903883,
0.0948935375,
-0.0012931493,
0.0266252309,
0.0272475574,
-0.0058900751,
-0.0119099384,
0.0151354391,
-0.0075331577,
0.0060629235,
0.0031798601,
0.0189804379,
0.0295159332,
-0.0648175329,
-0.0179879442,
0.0508638918,
0.1002632827,
-0.032398805,
-0.0188126583,
-0.0538963675,
-0.0199454576,
-0.0027338578,
0.028940592,
-0.0141532784,
0.0109639177,
-0.0486715734,
-0.0116459439,
0.0139840906,
-0.0012759885,
0.0304706618,
-0.0047566234,
-0.0636060685,
-0.0386526287,
-0.0194499753,
-0.0598840788,
-0.001174552,
-0.0381767116,
0.0230445433,
-0.0038125063,
0.1162004173,
-0.0177717786,
-0.0748729408,
-0.0065359506,
-0.0365051925,
0.0360069796,
-0.000799778,
-0.0149286706,
0.0609123036,
0.0555743836,
-0.0413419902,
0.0149469506,
-0.0331110358,
-0.0266913343,
-0.0269478429,
-0.0049063074,
0.0189010594,
-0.0486711003,
0.0292172842,
-0.0191925969,
0.0233034547,
0.0703906566,
0.0459078513,
-0.0407594442,
0.0039860732,
-0.026872132,
-0.0328607187,
-0.0266922377,
0.001436868,
0.0438573249,
-0.0218821187,
-0.0097017325,
-0.0582518429,
-0.0329493918,
-0.0103430618,
-0.0126241632,
0.1027681008,
-0.0246291477,
-0.061982628,
-0.0438824557,
-0.0429175943,
0.0370722525,
0.0132349189,
-0.0093677267,
-0.0074629467,
0.0268032961,
0.017401116,
-0.0320845805,
0.056361407,
-0.0351501442,
-0.0136713972,
-0.0710244998,
0.0232269652,
-0.0021666822,
0.1038903743,
-0.0783355832,
0.0040933946,
-0.0443678424,
-0.0386606492,
-0.003038961,
0.0025328067,
-0.0022733072,
0.0011663347,
0.0320215076,
0.0591605417,
0.0316058621,
0.0556960031,
-0.0325909033,
-0.0336991549,
-0.06039536,
-0.0089896237,
0.0417214409,
0.0543543175,
-0.0569165871,
-0.0512280315,
-0.0374938697,
-0.0213632397,
0.0180629436,
-0.0240378845,
-0.0337030888,
0.0152692366,
-0.0168668106,
-0.047395397,
-0.0476348773,
0.0231573209,
0.0355905108,
-0.0046173614,
0.0128892884,
-0.0441250093,
-0.0108096236,
-0.0614565201,
-0.0016859276,
0.019250324,
0.0128252916,
0.0083522275,
-0.0258121211,
-0.0073576979,
0.0462190397,
0.0105239991,
-0.0175430402,
-0.0150584364,
-0.0037236754,
-0.0078025409,
-0.0364545099,
-0.0359731242,
-0.0161638074,
-0.0149819795,
-0.1007377282,
-0.0218816195,
-0.003855831,
-5.598732289e-33,
-0.0095547047,
-0.062544018,
0.0119437221,
-0.0017166073,
-0.0275945477,
0.0160967913,
-0.0137610286,
-0.0393748507,
-0.0432685874,
0.0474823602,
-0.0028103604,
0.0060230037,
-0.0004587751,
0.0055200602,
0.0448055938,
0.0316734351,
0.0110137044,
-0.0009486576,
-0.0088712266,
0.0148009686,
0.0295489337,
-0.017480731,
0.0506112948,
-0.0942465067,
0.0406836644,
0.0038691056,
-0.0280929506,
-0.0244281068,
0.0313066244,
0.0395586677,
-0.0291428678,
0.0504665487,
0.0335408524,
-0.0601271056,
-0.0004113026,
0.0582751259,
-0.0531816632,
-0.0464923307,
-0.0142064961,
-0.0240913033,
0.0068338909,
-0.0145828538,
0.0227413699,
0.0364527293,
-0.038469635,
-0.0289910194,
0.0761314854,
-0.0292802863,
-0.0065500694,
-0.0619683601,
-0.0915361643,
-0.0043915892,
-0.0193501692,
0.0436863266,
-0.008869892,
0.027247699,
-0.0120549211,
0.0957219899,
-0.077304244,
0.0260650143,
-0.0046412069,
0.0072008604,
0.0506039634,
0.004576717,
-0.014630761,
0.0585283078,
-0.0521405637,
-0.0368644185,
-0.0017679323,
-0.0396956243,
0.0531640761,
-0.019598471,
0.0802177787,
0.0607470237,
0.0592643805,
-0.0086585125,
-0.0672920719,
0.0589323007,
0.0031650783,
0.0265707411,
0.0032429812,
0.0192975011,
0.0323249213,
-0.0004676079,
-0.0361657105,
0.0005183356,
-0.0077337534,
0.0212779026,
0.0401558168,
-0.0524826348,
-0.0582783632,
0.089725472,
0.0158030484,
-0.0554598086,
0.0122241769,
0.0541298166,
0.0211934112,
0.0397783853,
0.0103676794,
0.024328148,
-0.0766259208,
-0.0614021309,
-0.0129503356,
0.0543272719,
0.043331679,
-0.0093302103,
0.0030341912,
-0.0283774808,
-0.0166315846,
0.0088928724,
-0.0138588017,
-0.0269739144,
-0.0167377256,
-0.0063933213,
-0.0282490794,
-0.0180501975,
0.0464016981,
-0.0108180111,
0.0431303307,
0.0324548818,
-0.0012965265,
0.0337963179,
-0.0048505496,
-0.0031695261,
-0.0014771284,
-0.018767314,
-0.0220959298,
-0.0085238675,
-0.0487536415,
-0.0353289358,
0.0097525269,
0.0343887843,
2.74e-7,
0.0652664378,
0.0211379975,
0.0224422701,
0.0068344106,
-0.0062425928,
0.0335656926,
0.0490709394,
0.048392076,
-0.0606321879,
0.0051395441,
0.0436894298,
-0.0389243849,
0.0228208397,
0.0051386668,
-0.0398570485,
-0.0216995645,
-0.0332990438,
-0.0226499103,
-0.1161398739,
0.0195707027,
-0.0109959487,
0.027355019,
0.0054714493,
0.0091196792,
0.0058111222,
-0.0252585951,
0.0328575261,
-0.0194122903,
0.0738115907,
0.0331787467,
0.0392578244,
-0.0015342577,
-0.017350249,
0.0275546834,
-0.0018372306,
-0.0109843165,
0.0120450808,
0.0148227634,
-0.0097611072,
-0.0166946184,
-0.0227421746,
-0.009132118,
0.0217534136,
-0.0718421862,
0.0137030222,
-0.0465936512,
-0.0222976562,
0.0006629679,
0.0107134618,
0.0355659239,
0.0560380742,
-0.0330781527,
0.0219223499,
0.0081500094,
-0.0003959032,
-0.011684156,
-0.0043428158,
-0.0329863839,
0.0511571579,
0.009591734,
-0.0352519676,
0.0119203506,
-0.0253190342,
0.0039929501,
0.0510488711,
-0.0529627837,
0.057021156,
2.028434429e-34,
0.0096595669,
-0.0305415895,
-0.0415371843,
-0.0365636684,
0.0122487135,
0.0542001687,
-0.0288320407,
0.0303051416,
-0.024702983,
-0.0379976518,
0.0344328023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05286v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05286v2 | Causal Inference from Text: Unveiling Interactions between Variables | 2023-11-09T11:29:44 | 2023-11-23T12:12:22 | Yuxiang Zhou, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adjusting for latent covariates is crucial for estimating causal effects from
observational textual data. Most existing methods only account for confounding
covariates that affect both treatment and outcome, potentially leading to
biased causal effects. This bias arises from insufficient consideration of
non-confounding covariates, which are relevant only to either the treatment or
the outcome. In this work, we aim to mitigate the bias by unveiling
interactions between different variables to disentangle the non-confounding
covariates when estimating causal effects from text. The disentangling process
ensures covariates only contribute to their respective objectives, enabling
independence between variables. Additionally, we impose a constraint to balance
representations from the treatment group and control group to alleviate
selection bias. We conduct experiments on two different treatment factors under
various scenarios, and the proposed model significantly outperforms recent
strong baselines. Furthermore, our thorough analysis on earnings call
transcripts demonstrates that our model can effectively disentangle the
variables, and further investigations into real-world scenarios provide
guidance for investors to make informed decisions. | [
0.0026018044,
0.1003610566,
-0.0123512056,
-0.0072932178,
0.0137831811,
0.0302942358,
0.0684586242,
0.0314078331,
-0.0015143644,
-0.0534267314,
0.0421381108,
0.0505659692,
-0.010537697,
0.0374037698,
0.041190628,
-0.0399041437,
0.0176917948,
0.00118143,
0.0590941235,
-0.030895004,
0.0400841236,
0.0213599857,
0.0009152681,
-0.0055074198,
-0.0199208129,
-0.0326878279,
0.0293296203,
-0.0012717737,
0.0037438734,
-0.0162657574,
0.017355958,
0.0302747376,
0.0376451723,
-0.0072972719,
0.0000022249,
-0.0309383664,
-0.0467008352,
-0.028836634,
-0.0062752692,
0.0171173457,
0.0006410948,
-0.052610103,
0.0749198347,
0.0015911101,
-0.0391908176,
0.0073710885,
0.0326441713,
0.0611160398,
0.0007738374,
0.0595422499,
-0.0218053628,
-0.0488016307,
-0.0560384542,
-0.0443957448,
0.0487151109,
-0.0511870533,
0.0281391945,
-0.0215918701,
-0.0556458421,
-0.0035902094,
-0.0054840534,
0.0161432903,
-0.0143288039,
0.0042864187,
0.0486743599,
0.0030723566,
0.0069505638,
0.0095831454,
-0.0010307918,
0.0444429703,
0.0717600882,
-0.0126555171,
0.0501942448,
-0.0461547673,
0.0475499332,
0.0607710667,
-0.04135032,
-0.0287352465,
-0.0139582204,
0.0112078004,
0.0181206502,
0.0291909184,
0.0241142865,
0.0248302966,
0.001359966,
0.0263239127,
-0.0151750492,
-0.0404899344,
0.0130184647,
0.0554896519,
0.0272303782,
-0.028021561,
-0.0053735003,
-0.0321852155,
0.0014293054,
0.0056634406,
0.0252439603,
-0.0368585177,
-0.0165065359,
-0.0999516025,
-0.0663556084,
0.0003379392,
-0.0280853249,
0.0569838919,
0.0070780078,
0.0000308505,
0.001076796,
-0.0179627649,
0.0104342997,
0.0517750122,
-0.0065801824,
0.0031097603,
0.0100686392,
0.0700032189,
-0.0338991694,
0.0082559278,
-0.0294214804,
-0.0044620149,
-0.0231618769,
-0.0155044859,
-0.0408285782,
0.0100857476,
-0.0238818862,
0.0094970902,
-0.0050117965,
0.0128092021,
-0.0554472059,
0.0386460498,
-0.0574402884,
-0.0182986576,
-0.0077467938,
0.0401275456,
0.0475929528,
-0.0507833064,
-0.0060462216,
0.0665252358,
0.0197424404,
-0.0184312984,
-0.0211503189,
-0.0531386733,
-0.0172474924,
-0.0147225736,
-0.0017039464,
0.003045619,
0.0102802515,
0.0164446831,
0.0148899825,
-0.0534436293,
0.0064086695,
-0.0558277927,
-0.078095153,
0.0200424753,
0.0414570644,
-0.0329144187,
0.0028130976,
-0.0089079794,
-0.0082858214,
0.0591591373,
0.0017156552,
0.0000684547,
0.0562927723,
-0.011458219,
0.0155233638,
0.0237843338,
0.0600916706,
-0.0063708341,
0.0222199429,
0.0025096522,
-0.013351568,
-0.0519443788,
0.0310624186,
-0.0189026669,
-0.0160079114,
0.0368338712,
0.0601714067,
-0.0092844432,
0.0142644495,
0.0432889685,
-0.025038911,
-0.0065972293,
-0.0270180088,
0.0168491621,
0.0032210038,
-0.0136278654,
-0.0217406768,
0.0061478461,
0.0702337921,
-0.0138689466,
-0.0531264953,
-0.0387678631,
0.0222495887,
0.0026473969,
-0.013826862,
0.0139156291,
0.0430363566,
-0.0502485968,
-0.0378355421,
0.0194438472,
0.061250262,
-0.0155313322,
0.00494943,
0.0328165554,
0.0312825181,
0.0373578817,
0.0159741752,
-0.0423857719,
0.076031208,
-0.0393858217,
0.0074511589,
0.008686753,
0.0012563883,
-0.0048675523,
-0.0216777734,
-0.0228452273,
-0.0181687828,
0.0165718105,
0.0555813983,
0.0250539202,
-0.0299823917,
-0.0184835624,
-0.0138373766,
0.0161913875,
0.0141063407,
0.0470703766,
0.0357275493,
-0.0619146377,
-0.0144214509,
-0.0110261152,
0.0270894691,
0.0256179553,
-0.0222404953,
-0.0145142013,
-0.0094889142,
-0.0188950021,
-0.0339958034,
0.0249461662,
-0.0221526548,
-0.032915432,
-0.0645550638,
-0.0521080494,
-0.0245968904,
0.002100291,
-0.0445496701,
0.0029731691,
0.0691193789,
-0.0104380902,
0.0523914695,
0.0021226618,
-0.0462305062,
0.0160024799,
-0.0073409728,
0.0046709394,
0.0545018986,
0.002197152,
0.0006035213,
-0.0329131484,
-0.0361180082,
-0.0271345042,
-0.0344481803,
0.04919485,
-0.0221374594,
-0.0417267308,
0.0094492538,
0.0573575571,
-0.0608938448,
-0.0006950514,
-0.0415976085,
-0.0586138144,
-0.0425967202,
-0.0261347946,
0.0050361007,
0.0250590388,
0.0299308728,
-0.0026070348,
-0.0191000216,
-0.0098971371,
-0.063222155,
0.007997076,
0.0304545797,
0.0187674556,
-0.0069692843,
0.0280365497,
-0.0868843049,
-0.0076727695,
-0.0540370792,
0.0664773956,
0.0806791484,
-0.0635716915,
0.0074505433,
-0.018844977,
-0.0270819645,
-0.0127389273,
-0.0091458661,
0.0456788167,
-0.0290311724,
0.0164631568,
-0.0166844632,
0.1005504057,
0.0027776677,
0.0536466092,
-0.0547027364,
-0.0098545691,
-0.0566811785,
0.0125929704,
-0.075687483,
0.0199014302,
-0.0335420705,
-0.0446735695,
0.0085187647,
0.0438481197,
0.0143410051,
-0.0075435643,
-0.0770061463,
0.0366069414,
-0.0059758113,
0.0001521207,
-0.0638074651,
-0.0348335952,
-0.0171608087,
0.0590146668,
-0.0246624667,
-0.0901031867,
0.0337192677,
0.0332389586,
0.0180624314,
-0.0332479104,
0.018715065,
-0.0235146713,
0.0050279982,
-0.0030486388,
-0.0258840006,
0.0192960631,
0.0002547836,
0.0045650182,
-0.0243513901,
0.0620257296,
-0.0240681544,
0.0295579061,
-0.0493710488,
0.072366327,
0.023267692,
-0.0491083227,
-0.0242910571,
-0.0859590843,
0.0043728296,
0.0073181191,
0.0946388766,
-0.0136825647,
-0.0691837594,
-0.0103448583,
0.0119877746,
-0.0249980725,
-0.0305300672,
-0.0099839373,
0.0253772549,
-0.0164728779,
0.0354746953,
-0.045838207,
0.0142044555,
-0.0769498721,
0.0481973141,
-0.0066230991,
0.0158362277,
-0.026516499,
0.02338521,
0.0220049918,
-0.0360112488,
0.0155666526,
0.0135264574,
0.0035000739,
0.0086091375,
0.0145341633,
0.0139210662,
0.0675661787,
0.0009468916,
-0.0221626088,
0.0225956701,
0.0377233773,
0.0180535633,
-0.0375755318,
0.0040091476,
-0.0841309801,
-0.0154304113,
-0.0324681737,
0.0119388625,
0.0427075997,
-0.0365344062,
0.0060714725,
-0.0772586837,
0.0399616733,
0.0218964014,
0.025346512,
-0.0191787835,
-0.0550001115,
0.010673549,
-0.0689011067,
-0.0579889826,
0.001592132,
-0.0128561631,
0.0347521193,
0.0163075607,
-0.0707710236,
0.0084492406,
-0.0127279805,
0.0020562399,
-0.0466247909,
0.0578402206,
0.0125267385,
-0.016931612,
0.0110403998,
-0.02967095,
-0.0156626981,
-0.0323440842,
0.0005750518,
0.1325108707,
-0.038920667,
0.0035897198,
-0.0175341889,
0.0838338733,
-0.0076349182,
-0.0041597271,
-0.0061926339,
0.0146098854,
0.0029437863,
-0.039958965,
0.0412452333,
0.0428492278,
-0.0050717918,
0.0493658856,
-0.0036725798,
-0.0389272235,
-0.0616724379,
-0.0272431374,
-0.0167876482,
-0.041726809,
0.0029756713,
-0.0246840883,
0.0107758036,
-0.0153153585,
-0.0764501765,
-0.0807758495,
-0.0010190464,
-0.0216637272,
-0.0026005839,
0.0323155411,
0.0132402219,
-0.0189489909,
-0.0128724556,
0.0429595225,
0.0244829878,
0.0024193379,
0.0327963978,
-0.0163965523,
-0.0256748758,
-0.016368771,
-0.0300071575,
0.0405447222,
-0.0618170016,
-0.0736051053,
0.0142047573,
-0.009898548,
0.0239663757,
0.0466060303,
-0.0010078957,
-0.0264870096,
0.0108380923,
0.0110774925,
-0.0574824288,
0.0455561802,
0.0294255633,
0.037005432,
0.0091221891,
0.0059380382,
-0.0403566957,
0.0122555718,
0.0070967251,
-0.0071650795,
-0.0493632481,
-0.0018252109,
-0.0121954707,
-0.0403053202,
0.0653579831,
0.0131200282,
-0.0349537581,
-0.0546639822,
-0.0087626427,
0.0204588361,
0.023891367,
0.0261304304,
-0.0001644902,
-0.0025472699,
0.0099423081,
-0.0483041629,
0.041804377,
-0.0595823713,
-0.0095280837,
-0.0695214868,
0.03909095,
-0.0086462097,
-0.0090622539,
-0.0023246731,
-0.0043223063,
0.0191009939,
0.0121037131,
0.0275536235,
0.027656747,
0.0111264475,
0.0147519773,
0.0195165928,
0.0651175976,
-0.0060625207,
-0.0745581165,
-0.0818485692,
0.0272613242,
0.0152463261,
-0.010516542,
-0.009373283,
-0.0414943919,
0.0750057921,
-0.0094173038,
0.0111134974,
0.0052848514,
0.046872396,
0.0114836153,
0.0162888523,
0.0264165625,
0.0000257018,
-0.0571624562,
0.0023776491,
0.0722408071,
0.051828213,
0.0590395927,
-0.0612957925,
0.0043750145,
-0.0132355969,
-0.0560714751,
0.0762097463,
0.0276117362,
-0.0135319205,
0.0237720199,
-0.0761177838,
-0.0364630744,
0.0206009932,
-0.0263678171,
0.044785291,
0.0126983384,
-0.0025791111,
0.0196743775,
-0.0000987743,
-0.0323863104,
-0.0185025092,
0.0402971171,
-0.031347286,
-0.0357174464,
-0.0790994316,
-6.881534213e-33,
-0.0232738573,
-0.0240647793,
-0.0309076607,
0.0209221207,
0.0201509837,
0.02582331,
-0.0070672687,
0.0126824928,
-0.0007920978,
0.026303729,
0.0175967626,
0.0532017536,
0.0189491566,
0.0239041746,
0.0092809908,
-0.0081675909,
0.0291400589,
-0.0251176339,
-0.0135091627,
0.0185901765,
0.0145753343,
0.0718495473,
-0.0028068137,
-0.099496536,
0.0567934662,
-0.0197901577,
-0.0305978451,
-0.0379517898,
0.0330666117,
0.0179157071,
-0.0147022717,
-0.0002872025,
0.0297944564,
-0.049333062,
0.0001793116,
0.07589259,
-0.0341706611,
-0.0306410436,
0.0514384732,
0.0114235114,
-0.0038980565,
-0.0063314843,
0.0029783824,
0.0404573828,
0.0040751039,
-0.0152580347,
0.0380437151,
0.0245350003,
-0.009307215,
-0.0279658679,
-0.0710950568,
0.0395357087,
-0.0550434291,
0.0404458903,
0.0149670681,
0.0804685131,
0.0181484204,
0.0598595291,
-0.0144275874,
0.0107840272,
-0.0140775358,
0.0128824152,
-0.0070111635,
0.0420017764,
-0.0185041483,
0.0601291731,
-0.0376362801,
-0.0012033281,
-0.0651983097,
-0.0297452901,
0.0011033299,
0.0288555231,
0.0306785274,
0.0587392375,
0.0440937653,
-0.0167276096,
-0.1142172366,
0.0156181734,
-0.0209142622,
-0.0166941024,
0.0380002707,
0.0081646731,
-0.0240731221,
-0.0395847,
-0.0321300142,
-0.0011665931,
-0.0128304735,
0.0028858203,
0.0105499066,
0.0204735082,
-0.0457824208,
0.0055134799,
0.0462293364,
-0.0219729543,
-0.05151565,
0.0052609676,
-0.0196261536,
-0.014419768,
-0.010513396,
-0.0504491664,
-0.0655425116,
-0.008988007,
0.0055293273,
0.0410918444,
0.0538784079,
-0.0185715742,
0.0456724875,
-0.0580566563,
-0.0383391343,
-0.0170100406,
-0.0033851601,
0.009735995,
0.0212071538,
-0.0297056325,
0.02293952,
0.045798663,
0.0104962168,
0.0166794024,
0.0344359912,
0.0049956082,
0.0054624067,
-0.0480270311,
-0.0166039374,
0.0066039008,
-0.0320180357,
-0.0116444202,
0.0479868054,
0.0403018817,
0.0458032414,
-0.0443049185,
-0.0280705709,
0.0056995847,
2.903e-7,
0.0757975206,
0.0631642863,
0.0120499302,
-0.0071080863,
0.0487693287,
0.0480583012,
0.0321561508,
0.0304101985,
0.0167058185,
-0.0271247718,
0.0388486534,
0.0145003451,
0.0663572475,
0.0102036214,
-0.0336346924,
-0.0309322793,
-0.0732199401,
-0.0177566651,
-0.0471297838,
-0.0232315697,
0.0623765998,
0.0260145888,
0.0335646607,
0.0232956391,
-0.0143716475,
0.0093539935,
0.0685046315,
-0.0493110642,
-0.0138997687,
0.0006234765,
-0.0402365215,
-0.0433212072,
-0.0422819704,
0.0501509346,
-0.0435615033,
-0.0055917208,
0.0002756745,
0.0236545913,
-0.000111093,
0.0285097584,
-0.0133438893,
-0.0078187538,
-0.0140721295,
-0.0062105395,
0.051291205,
-0.0223200023,
-0.0408573449,
-0.0063098003,
-0.0195036121,
0.0481068976,
0.0205110554,
0.0454599634,
-0.0110797975,
0.0285922214,
-0.0016853289,
0.0209171325,
0.0145009989,
-0.0611372963,
-0.0391746238,
0.0538960844,
-0.0435772948,
-0.0242794957,
0.0118756769,
0.0420189388,
0.0067358911,
-0.0162889306,
0.0570146404,
2.488287819e-34,
0.0396116413,
0.0120418919,
-0.0358681045,
0.0027256708,
0.0740394294,
-0.0151357418,
-0.0423786677,
0.0290256068,
0.0383353047,
-0.0979224071,
0.0253520682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05268v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05268v2 | Modelling prospective memory and resilient situated communications via Wizard of Oz | 2023-11-09T10:50:36 | 2024-01-17T10:09:46 | Yanzhe Li, Frank Broz, Mark Neerincx | cs.CL | cs.CL | This abstract presents a scenario for human-robot action in a home setting
involving an older adult and a robot. The scenario is designed to explore the
envisioned modelling of memory for communication with a socially assistive
robots (SAR). The scenario will enable the gathering of data on failures of
speech technology and human-robot communication involving shared memory that
may occur during daily activities such as a music-listening activity. | [
0.0235860273,
-0.0432612486,
-0.0246956013,
-0.0329591073,
-0.0289633125,
0.0111349886,
0.0394217633,
-0.0238919165,
0.0430746675,
-0.0256519634,
-0.0051928684,
-0.0040942701,
0.034313336,
-0.008898437,
0.0090737687,
-0.0410233848,
0.0245842505,
-0.022342734,
-0.0023317756,
0.0168598574,
-0.032890901,
-0.0105496189,
-0.0461713187,
0.0376350433,
-0.0442665927,
-0.0174199343,
-0.0087642111,
0.0060891164,
0.0018967021,
-0.0384688489,
-0.0066620102,
-0.0189042501,
0.0429868326,
0.0270820446,
0.0000016489,
-0.0190016329,
0.0398978926,
0.0078005451,
-0.0141184637,
-0.0641798899,
0.0142198885,
0.0656521246,
0.0084153572,
0.0308070406,
-0.0135217076,
-0.0006172524,
0.0150636742,
0.0256128535,
-0.0120690009,
0.0340603925,
-0.0138895372,
0.0001121788,
0.021294225,
0.0250731539,
0.0225305129,
0.0021938595,
0.0052880882,
0.0121629862,
0.0678146929,
-0.0548993163,
0.0079244887,
0.0096103847,
0.0119846389,
0.0004297458,
0.0207853075,
0.0246729739,
0.0112227071,
-0.0000253106,
-0.035802342,
0.0074441368,
0.1287605911,
-0.0015335007,
0.0109596299,
0.0423645228,
0.0217690431,
0.0724990219,
-0.0470965542,
-0.0083425986,
0.0068530915,
-0.0460177064,
-0.086873956,
-0.0261694752,
0.0053297319,
-0.0198350679,
0.0586514436,
0.0536505058,
-0.0052512377,
-0.0219747145,
-0.0060226014,
-0.0413797833,
0.0568284132,
0.0146019245,
0.0472951718,
0.0482256487,
-0.0208375268,
0.0053934641,
-0.0384918749,
0.0128436852,
0.0014138117,
-0.0327229016,
-0.0154146487,
0.0123977037,
-0.0372758508,
-0.010201361,
0.0088563692,
-0.0002368057,
-0.0145551674,
-0.0456557982,
-0.0085922563,
0.0539554022,
-0.0866923481,
-0.0293067303,
-0.0396232903,
0.0586085059,
0.0112765348,
-0.0376685448,
-0.016518835,
0.0481165424,
-0.0120512946,
0.0166807659,
-0.0163786802,
-0.0046659117,
0.0184652247,
0.0206228569,
0.0100192539,
-0.0161606353,
-0.0775198117,
0.07340087,
-0.0005835309,
-0.0382595994,
0.0095591843,
0.0184462499,
-0.0221351907,
-0.0262858849,
-0.0281168688,
0.0668057427,
0.0170409456,
-0.0170099419,
-0.0217954349,
-0.0247470271,
-0.0182075649,
-0.0256640464,
0.0707143843,
0.0047303773,
-0.0196628869,
-0.0102756564,
-0.0089496635,
-0.0175357442,
-0.0189257022,
-0.0165512357,
-0.0114668515,
0.0261727329,
0.0027382313,
0.018484341,
0.0580437481,
0.0267907996,
0.0275872033,
-0.0286650751,
0.032126788,
-0.0350450985,
0.0043724882,
-0.0124513926,
0.0251111593,
-0.0006300745,
-0.0516727827,
-0.0043916712,
0.0149689307,
-0.0040651672,
0.0206068885,
0.0013588992,
-0.0774816945,
0.0072814543,
0.0051083262,
0.0012593805,
0.0490621999,
0.0514066555,
-0.0440374613,
0.0072907624,
-0.0521213748,
-0.0069294022,
0.002130742,
0.0031911756,
0.0324218497,
0.0097540645,
-0.029127147,
-0.0140074771,
-0.0399643704,
0.0196834747,
-0.0519522838,
0.022369314,
0.0014701349,
-0.0439597927,
0.0474463813,
0.0146979904,
0.0290205684,
-0.0091625126,
-0.0051335897,
0.0009769965,
-0.0534945801,
-0.0349374004,
-0.0274545513,
-0.0614501759,
-0.0042112386,
0.0733714327,
0.0299086832,
-0.0448820703,
0.0236359406,
0.0054351836,
-0.0119186603,
-0.0357104503,
-0.0185502525,
0.0414657108,
-0.0006505239,
0.010864296,
-0.0067914389,
0.0144214546,
0.0201393329,
0.0293099377,
-0.0607984699,
0.0307930466,
-0.0055208565,
0.098538287,
0.0563340485,
0.0010001138,
-0.0039604986,
0.0117480736,
-0.065215461,
-0.0110395197,
0.0168492086,
0.0809153542,
-0.0320586152,
0.0267761946,
0.0510664023,
-0.0010418985,
0.0227222648,
0.1004966944,
-0.0637763217,
0.0394637696,
0.0121086752,
-0.0176164936,
0.0339136682,
0.0290162154,
0.0443561822,
-0.0278294832,
0.0026374289,
-0.0572677329,
0.0637426898,
-0.0112826256,
0.0694730505,
0.0012309524,
-0.0531898774,
0.0075324816,
0.0070939879,
-0.0201440342,
-0.0402066596,
-0.0813131481,
0.0320572034,
0.0306579135,
-0.0589442328,
-0.003223829,
0.019390475,
-0.0478315763,
0.0169810485,
0.0188355278,
-0.0434241332,
-0.0454132892,
0.0218168627,
-0.0997640043,
-0.0766361505,
0.0046616402,
-0.0396773294,
-0.0300509222,
-0.0653036535,
-0.0190542266,
-0.0287176743,
0.0171755198,
0.0727586523,
-0.0119164679,
0.0180962551,
-0.0124163618,
-0.0085745659,
-0.0435054973,
-0.0205993615,
-0.0036846451,
0.0085536214,
-0.0053649205,
0.0640838742,
-0.0910745114,
-0.0390329957,
0.0309967846,
-0.0048927879,
0.0372293107,
-0.0301091131,
-0.005952456,
0.0531643741,
-0.0112191113,
0.0567941293,
0.0268430952,
-0.0307142437,
0.0334476754,
0.0790767148,
-0.0390830003,
0.0233823583,
-0.0134916827,
-0.0239493437,
0.0118044382,
-0.0186949689,
0.0069071939,
-0.0015433455,
-0.0319766551,
0.0394104347,
0.0564256385,
0.0148229869,
-0.033117082,
-0.0354492217,
-0.0765675381,
-0.0289993901,
-0.0629015192,
-0.0421067961,
0.0142747927,
0.0409371443,
-0.0298280064,
0.0093675731,
-0.0025533759,
0.0096835494,
0.0096512055,
-0.0038764023,
0.0291371904,
0.0619059913,
-0.0502249226,
-0.0030239653,
0.0243087132,
-0.041351188,
-0.0288783554,
-0.062559247,
0.0021239156,
-0.0242229514,
-0.0565592609,
-0.0845894068,
0.0133757917,
0.0485056825,
-0.0267162286,
-0.0208936986,
0.0586822033,
-0.0157984421,
0.0110435933,
-0.0854870901,
-0.0328361951,
-0.0575340688,
-0.0246034153,
0.0362017192,
0.0474572368,
0.0520348437,
-0.0173079427,
-0.0006065858,
-0.0230285954,
0.0215167087,
0.046879027,
-0.0554931574,
0.0165045131,
0.0001992733,
0.010517627,
0.0718445927,
-0.008820504,
-0.0075489189,
0.0031129185,
0.0275690965,
0.0175735913,
-0.0134221595,
0.0523303747,
0.0581649691,
0.0113223754,
-0.0441120192,
0.0260492489,
0.03409262,
-0.0491211899,
-0.003271902,
-0.0599477515,
-0.0413806103,
-0.0234838054,
-0.0334191173,
0.0190945975,
0.0288929176,
0.0149530126,
0.0272342302,
-0.0159490146,
0.0152689712,
0.0280324258,
-0.0584498905,
0.0239046346,
0.021355588,
-0.0232099313,
-0.097668834,
0.0240602251,
-0.0379117094,
0.044574026,
0.0594828352,
-0.0047703106,
-0.0262853149,
-0.0226494875,
0.040208336,
-0.0614643991,
0.0073324786,
0.0366556197,
0.0036260604,
0.1086378843,
0.0508205704,
0.0158374533,
0.000456013,
-0.0028306448,
-0.0577554181,
0.0318112969,
0.056580998,
-0.0319102593,
-0.0103963912,
0.0181679297,
0.0260519255,
-0.0280545484,
0.0162069574,
-0.032481268,
-0.0291279051,
0.0611916333,
-0.002825195,
-0.0992016047,
0.003872226,
-0.0144515997,
0.0363897718,
0.0383902639,
0.0460917987,
-0.039365992,
0.0012007985,
-0.0176032875,
0.0397244729,
0.0173841435,
0.0700880885,
0.0054422915,
-0.0242946744,
-0.0126733631,
-0.0323337093,
-0.0670324415,
-0.0391454734,
0.0244620442,
0.0602939315,
0.0189445429,
-0.0184808876,
0.0232996773,
0.043247886,
-0.0360134952,
-0.0207657628,
-0.0123302601,
0.0132005326,
-0.0259804521,
-0.0054877745,
-0.0003785253,
-0.0526474863,
0.0142223034,
-0.0678384304,
0.0388855189,
0.0044547427,
0.1098069996,
0.0317061245,
0.0331903286,
0.0068994593,
0.0342617445,
-0.0039890115,
0.0175041351,
-0.0228301808,
-0.0477727279,
0.0723472759,
0.0339235961,
0.0304821134,
0.01244081,
-0.0004575214,
-0.0281308871,
-0.012393306,
-0.0590405986,
0.023374524,
-0.0481878407,
0.0071298811,
0.0019955649,
0.0063533764,
0.0069347052,
-0.0043106633,
0.0107262442,
0.0129925767,
0.0440043136,
-0.0225064494,
0.060721688,
-0.0343835317,
-0.000040184,
-0.0329787061,
0.005622224,
0.0406438075,
-0.0211619809,
-0.0207658913,
-0.007090494,
0.0194214229,
-0.0369120836,
0.0307206921,
0.0266498812,
-0.0323537104,
0.0145676164,
-0.0054709422,
0.0187647864,
-0.0374945477,
0.0241843015,
0.0443101637,
0.109472096,
0.0045637712,
-0.0393608585,
-0.010108198,
0.0212255642,
0.0016852871,
-0.0733693689,
0.0208962448,
0.0457651429,
-0.0002268275,
0.0069843871,
-0.0277949665,
-0.0666463003,
0.0362596065,
-0.0540574677,
0.0036333229,
0.0363774151,
0.041833818,
-0.0381450206,
0.0080483276,
-0.0228018854,
0.0322756544,
0.0018297671,
-0.0362804271,
0.0178788509,
-0.0482422076,
-0.0234713219,
-0.0228878502,
-0.0437831208,
-0.0089079831,
0.0447903238,
-0.0075400905,
-0.0380522981,
-0.050369706,
-0.0365144834,
-0.0528719351,
-0.0214189235,
0.0437827557,
-0.0078130635,
0.0694379061,
-0.0218525194,
-0.0113426363,
-0.0120489681,
-0.0054145176,
-0.0190386996,
-0.0341800898,
0.0422986895,
-0.0131295463,
-5.242790028e-33,
-0.025044987,
-0.0622192882,
0.0384695418,
-0.0129901059,
-0.0254092384,
-0.0295264013,
-0.0285958368,
0.0324904658,
-0.0342874713,
-0.0286385268,
0.0396331362,
0.0206257422,
0.0245725401,
0.0023347766,
0.0236018412,
-0.0270398445,
0.0142255025,
0.0129000982,
0.0279904027,
0.002268695,
0.0847283974,
0.0201613624,
-0.0251091421,
-0.0753534734,
0.0344229005,
-0.0108273812,
-0.0173265897,
-0.0096117631,
0.0310058054,
-0.0306658577,
-0.0086305644,
0.0060787681,
-0.002641764,
0.0500489399,
0.0234469492,
0.0490966402,
-0.0641456991,
-0.0208671875,
0.019134257,
0.0050206487,
0.0186102148,
-0.0078085777,
-0.0165095031,
0.0070912298,
-0.0354835279,
0.0208759792,
0.0255227145,
0.0104833441,
-0.0258578621,
0.0454158932,
-0.0456145667,
-0.0240884367,
-0.0137707945,
-0.0201529022,
0.0061890217,
0.0214870609,
-0.0182252042,
0.0111992257,
-0.0311919134,
0.0102584222,
-0.0614219755,
0.0126661556,
0.0090613402,
-0.0199188441,
0.0277246721,
0.0742333829,
0.0572704487,
-0.0112438556,
-0.036358919,
-0.0304411631,
-0.00421385,
0.0409421995,
0.0147604411,
-0.0478969626,
-0.0204557627,
0.0112946238,
-0.0223987754,
-0.0333639421,
0.0299269482,
0.039606493,
0.0298599284,
0.0265890285,
-0.031643644,
0.0262591075,
-0.0048035677,
0.0962034836,
-0.0192418303,
-0.0223417189,
0.0288918447,
0.0018319152,
0.010217363,
-0.0106111169,
-0.0071679656,
0.0027277835,
0.048763264,
-0.0380080901,
0.021543825,
0.0086397044,
-0.0264803022,
0.0071725403,
0.023704771,
-0.0187869016,
0.0484412871,
0.0525726452,
0.0212433264,
0.0203102268,
-0.0355652757,
0.0591567308,
-0.0037687039,
-0.0269615334,
0.0066039027,
-0.0291934926,
0.0459183604,
-0.0544524789,
0.0138710467,
0.0179529712,
-0.0343165919,
0.0721229911,
-0.0192854833,
-0.0025369916,
-0.035212405,
-0.0319312327,
-0.0433440767,
-0.0266915932,
-0.0064154807,
-0.007299108,
-0.0464218408,
0.0016214075,
0.0378330201,
-0.0063698678,
0.0128863687,
-0.0522511639,
2.534e-7,
-0.0647122115,
0.0699305981,
0.0308855549,
0.0161311682,
0.0326447003,
0.0256325137,
0.0025794222,
0.0276626404,
0.0117271692,
0.0097870622,
0.0359901115,
-0.0206075255,
0.0219638534,
-0.0109386919,
-0.0284774769,
-0.0325687118,
-0.050164748,
-0.0209123436,
-0.0241023861,
0.0332026482,
0.0755894184,
-0.0249914397,
0.0434888639,
-0.0088194711,
-0.0225067213,
-0.0530388132,
-0.0002849232,
-0.0512327366,
0.0384707414,
-0.0719112977,
0.0324819908,
0.0088292686,
0.0025938987,
0.0354547165,
-0.0092280144,
-0.0363452099,
-0.0102123953,
0.0497280993,
-0.0510482714,
-0.0896207243,
0.0203191116,
0.0514495857,
-0.0323307253,
0.0627691001,
0.0207055788,
-0.0341553651,
-0.0211099498,
0.1085514799,
-0.0080452394,
-0.0143262912,
0.0119116334,
-0.0036080934,
0.0411558561,
-0.0042797024,
-0.0587354787,
0.051567819,
0.0028998868,
-0.0351042338,
0.0557872057,
0.0145243835,
-0.0524512492,
-0.0901877508,
0.0099484036,
-0.0517764017,
-0.0450875834,
-0.0923181474,
-0.0201253891,
1.515520212e-34,
0.0086729238,
0.0122538032,
-0.0268714987,
0.045778852,
-0.008467393,
0.0049713333,
0.051940538,
0.0490956604,
0.0376895182,
-0.0173409637,
-0.0101168854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05265v1 | Don't Waste a Single Annotation: Improving Single-Label Classifiers Through Soft Labels | 2023-11-09T10:47:39 | 2023-11-09T10:47:39 | Ben Wu, Yue Li, Yida Mu, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we address the limitations of the common data annotation and
training methods for objective single-label classification tasks. Typically,
when annotating such tasks annotators are only asked to provide a single label
for each sample and annotator disagreement is discarded when a final hard label
is decided through majority voting. We challenge this traditional approach,
acknowledging that determining the appropriate label can be difficult due to
the ambiguity and lack of context in the data samples. Rather than discarding
the information from such ambiguous annotations, our soft label method makes
use of them for training. Our findings indicate that additional annotator
information, such as confidence, secondary label and disagreement, can be used
to effectively generate soft labels. Training classifiers with these soft
labels then leads to improved performance and calibration on the hard label
test set. | [
0.017853763,
0.0335616358,
0.0175095946,
-0.0270222202,
-0.001526698,
0.0371977016,
0.039724797,
-0.0222845189,
-0.0085086413,
-0.0627753958,
0.0088030836,
0.0218640938,
-0.0002396285,
-0.0103800222,
0.0051305131,
-0.0271126106,
0.0176059958,
0.003446274,
0.059757527,
-0.0005695862,
0.0199361593,
-0.0226254184,
0.0127638597,
0.0321402811,
-0.0751105845,
0.0053127911,
-0.0101070488,
0.02514413,
-0.0038299416,
-0.0554050133,
0.0553374253,
0.0756306127,
-0.0252389703,
0.0531155951,
0.0000018512,
-0.0221492145,
-0.0192139987,
0.004962944,
-0.0245160814,
-0.0285457131,
-0.0189012773,
0.0007848839,
0.0544683561,
0.0026616063,
-0.0057715029,
0.0113969529,
0.0730288848,
0.0518030375,
0.0499142148,
0.0116235102,
-0.0183472261,
-0.0428714007,
-0.0502796657,
-0.0186110269,
0.0101273675,
-0.0441960245,
0.020922415,
0.0062231151,
-0.0560973808,
0.0269150473,
0.0090574278,
0.0317887664,
0.0116056856,
0.0127046369,
0.012541336,
0.0414594524,
-0.0576337278,
-0.0415139124,
0.008191972,
0.0491928197,
0.0210395548,
-0.0266811661,
-0.0129882069,
-0.0293935761,
0.0234654732,
-0.0033290961,
0.0219254922,
-0.0067266519,
-0.0096605541,
0.0129069602,
-0.0368177257,
0.0255656242,
0.0170646384,
-0.0018620873,
0.0276042372,
0.0536870547,
-0.0272703618,
0.0107493773,
0.0800158903,
0.0483502932,
-0.0113227339,
0.0026919502,
0.0122196935,
0.0149087124,
-0.0086854976,
-0.0206230693,
-0.0254014283,
-0.0255288202,
0.0652166083,
-0.0692257732,
0.0244618692,
-0.0331516191,
-0.0582434088,
0.0589632951,
-0.0072309608,
-0.0315335207,
0.0733596087,
0.0651722476,
-0.0209939107,
0.0184487421,
-0.0323272832,
0.0150728384,
-0.0232673232,
0.081816949,
0.0239056721,
0.0138963843,
-0.0628994703,
-0.0380542465,
-0.0270821247,
0.0106063057,
-0.0008203303,
0.0044732508,
-0.0113284336,
0.0500013493,
0.0036587978,
0.0223668609,
-0.0360201076,
0.0492169224,
-0.0149928853,
-0.0537695065,
0.0120617719,
0.0306814872,
0.0100736385,
0.0099499067,
0.023662284,
0.0213901717,
-0.0032943909,
-0.0119087184,
-0.0400006622,
-0.037971165,
-0.0441819951,
-0.0210323799,
-0.0181448497,
-0.023242645,
-0.0057424228,
0.0057259151,
0.031872157,
-0.0123649845,
0.0053789401,
-0.0451085083,
0.0181927904,
0.0909150243,
-0.0275711156,
-0.0241827294,
0.0614309013,
-0.0129251685,
-0.0154393408,
0.0263473969,
0.0052717328,
0.0237951502,
0.0428160466,
0.0013086457,
0.0574923493,
0.0049084653,
0.0170139018,
-0.0356774889,
0.0136941113,
-0.024401309,
-0.0014480558,
-0.039975509,
-0.0228878502,
0.0100439563,
-0.004709905,
-0.0143181775,
0.0370581336,
-0.0495395064,
0.022280978,
-0.0566599853,
-0.0142292632,
-0.0188868977,
-0.0054585016,
-0.0208044741,
-0.0246267598,
0.0306516439,
-0.0304546617,
-0.0072752549,
0.0033302309,
-0.0635789707,
-0.0350886993,
-0.0627690405,
-0.0208658483,
-0.0402030274,
-0.0090127932,
-0.0087568937,
0.0637547821,
-0.0103074564,
0.0029936999,
0.0158696845,
0.0552556962,
0.0016061576,
-0.0233721491,
-0.0432836786,
0.0078227902,
-0.0696133599,
-0.0473430902,
-0.0450017117,
-0.0440571941,
-0.0255277697,
0.0243424084,
0.0038173599,
0.0767220333,
-0.0318749808,
0.0170512758,
-0.0241832007,
-0.0310909599,
0.018651668,
0.0487537347,
0.024048131,
-0.0369845144,
0.0035436898,
0.0157317966,
-0.0229835492,
-0.0388097502,
0.0448593162,
0.0606716909,
-0.0483315401,
0.0374297686,
0.045281589,
0.0531546995,
0.0183003061,
-0.0025223878,
-0.0180791859,
0.024385538,
0.0130988564,
-0.0182594825,
-0.0614382252,
0.0036793791,
-0.0265161153,
0.0410754643,
-0.0102864429,
-0.0475152358,
-0.0080644786,
-0.035900671,
-0.0301706456,
-0.0486111566,
-0.0184059218,
-0.0811075717,
-0.0370984189,
-0.0285491887,
-0.0130597232,
0.0044493708,
-0.0625026003,
0.0490992852,
0.0450061187,
0.0180715304,
-0.0460465476,
-0.024372844,
0.0658659413,
0.0057330541,
-0.0637996942,
-0.0368088223,
-0.0461489446,
0.0196958929,
0.043171145,
0.0101048769,
-0.0497274548,
0.0107416715,
-0.0115637127,
-0.0169480294,
0.0023808614,
-0.0307986308,
-0.033596117,
-0.0479273684,
0.0307932999,
-0.0355188847,
-0.0530305542,
0.0062888609,
-0.0619968213,
-0.0006747908,
0.0161638502,
0.0318029337,
-0.00264923,
-0.012096514,
0.0083110658,
-0.0265407898,
0.0198443644,
0.0645716712,
-0.0479914807,
-0.0368433446,
0.0010331733,
-0.0546896569,
-0.0375622138,
0.0236406326,
0.0004828432,
0.0348007195,
-0.0011325472,
-0.0639261529,
0.0552671254,
-0.006163815,
0.0240146387,
0.0300434418,
-0.0206166282,
-0.0393121503,
0.0115973996,
-0.0233990215,
-0.0400274731,
0.0037515934,
-0.0375032909,
-0.0500761233,
0.0246265605,
0.0005417432,
-0.0048048827,
-0.0297570545,
0.0059290105,
-0.0173683241,
-0.0169383138,
-0.0714236498,
0.0369617604,
-0.0001846682,
0.0065878388,
0.0104348762,
-0.032908082,
0.0785915852,
-0.0026556901,
-0.0066187023,
-0.0043958854,
-0.036324583,
0.0284742117,
0.0253133774,
-0.0353800654,
0.032052163,
0.0649243891,
0.0216442738,
0.0161445923,
-0.0486905985,
0.0701369047,
-0.0426252857,
0.000751962,
-0.0287903529,
0.0238160901,
-0.0125650298,
-0.0475149825,
-0.011643976,
0.0028009778,
-0.0054128594,
0.0331808776,
-0.0189533345,
0.022869952,
-0.0583236702,
0.0372824371,
-0.025447676,
0.0529629663,
-0.018633103,
-0.0127402265,
0.0082994979,
-0.0054757316,
0.0126807606,
-0.0020083284,
-0.0229865722,
-0.0549868867,
-0.0295877475,
0.0164460018,
0.0034606459,
0.040550366,
-0.0348619111,
0.0053063068,
0.0050133765,
-0.0115784034,
-0.0034622506,
-0.004758616,
0.0495984294,
-0.0018608819,
0.0087840594,
0.1062450483,
0.0381653085,
-0.0209486466,
-0.0072280248,
-0.0063103712,
0.0530820079,
0.0228444468,
-0.0281338636,
-0.0268425662,
-0.0574319512,
-0.0098169213,
0.0483636893,
-0.0279705543,
-0.0370024666,
0.0247339346,
-0.0494344309,
0.0119693065,
-0.0003588553,
-0.0722665712,
0.0174571574,
-0.0731311813,
0.0188482292,
-0.055103451,
-0.0324099921,
-0.0635626093,
0.0638299063,
0.0214947145,
0.0450552292,
-0.0202548504,
-0.0171585102,
-0.0085538812,
-0.0425264575,
0.0435931534,
0.0183938369,
0.019467175,
-0.0201726668,
0.0356825888,
0.0783759952,
-0.0108713061,
0.0073499158,
-0.0177463014,
0.0832908079,
-0.0009391665,
-0.0138773685,
0.0052753584,
0.0210522879,
-0.033756543,
0.0050454983,
-0.0027980397,
0.026383806,
0.0118833799,
-0.0076596667,
-0.0122775203,
-0.0043336698,
0.0250264872,
0.0318612345,
-0.0023914054,
-0.0569329113,
-0.0298163109,
-0.0130531425,
0.0474703014,
0.015003657,
-0.0219949931,
0.0379566252,
-0.0602867641,
-0.0687459931,
-0.0322297215,
-0.058857996,
0.0300704893,
0.0790155157,
0.0043824874,
-0.021968225,
-0.0054531721,
-0.0063496628,
-0.0248866435,
0.0103018973,
-0.0157565121,
0.0205250438,
0.011948593,
-0.0323972553,
0.0840490609,
0.0332001671,
-0.0500310957,
0.0732427165,
-0.0154853864,
-0.0398171507,
0.0025296214,
0.0447620563,
0.0205629524,
-0.0219913423,
0.003144783,
-0.0502057448,
0.0340328962,
0.0955972299,
0.0246212408,
0.0115397237,
0.0521915965,
-0.0313768797,
-0.0236216076,
0.0102375634,
-0.0330372974,
0.0479922406,
0.0333542377,
-0.0175595973,
-0.0617686398,
-0.0347053446,
0.0349835716,
0.0232643969,
0.1076773927,
-0.0146351261,
-0.003351362,
-0.0118315145,
0.0107605318,
0.0468458347,
-0.0386686623,
-0.0031018895,
-0.0099397758,
0.0121743996,
-0.0167952105,
-0.0443626717,
0.028380217,
0.041029118,
0.0482391529,
-0.0140352622,
-0.046148967,
0.0601528846,
0.0374186262,
-0.0258843079,
-0.0197068825,
-0.0189340822,
0.0161063764,
0.0817654133,
0.0315747596,
0.0373613089,
0.0093534468,
0.0401775017,
0.056019675,
-0.0141381305,
-0.0223234482,
-0.0261373352,
0.0428544208,
-0.070678331,
-0.0015606699,
0.0090961289,
-0.0141941402,
0.0068047922,
-0.0016737513,
-0.0320640206,
-0.0314968564,
0.0494490787,
0.0127076032,
-0.0399456099,
0.0000466171,
0.000806302,
-0.0110164378,
0.0236429572,
0.039196074,
-0.0080658896,
0.0114593226,
-0.0634198263,
-0.0117477365,
-0.0621059127,
0.0475417413,
0.0125083737,
0.003480982,
0.0084112836,
0.010091953,
-0.0112635931,
-0.0386951901,
0.0426669493,
-0.0208711997,
0.0366402082,
0.0634345338,
0.0115380855,
0.0447188988,
0.002155062,
-0.0480620861,
-0.0434496664,
-0.0738078058,
0.0503681228,
0.025964126,
-0.0236284733,
-6.15367105e-33,
-0.0357778668,
-0.0344454497,
-0.0533437952,
0.0267480575,
0.0146477865,
0.0154228788,
0.014462648,
0.0396137983,
-0.0006337256,
0.0421034582,
0.0176395644,
-0.0041136905,
0.0193128269,
-0.0087414039,
0.0326382071,
-0.0500383526,
0.0548100658,
0.001874358,
-0.042624332,
-0.0115173878,
-0.0018642416,
-0.0015406469,
0.0473490618,
-0.1741070002,
0.0519762188,
0.0373151861,
-0.0911872089,
-0.0252642818,
-0.020725457,
0.0348285399,
0.030307455,
0.0342145376,
0.0044392785,
-0.0179747529,
0.0161312725,
-0.0166255105,
-0.0726173893,
-0.0318584442,
-0.0574825257,
0.0379990675,
0.0166761931,
-0.0180459116,
0.0507692471,
-0.006083834,
0.0055186432,
-0.0018088018,
0.0660739765,
-0.0352016427,
-0.0020989378,
-0.049159687,
0.0039214739,
0.0275282264,
-0.0209181532,
0.0034112635,
0.0074369339,
0.0347117223,
-0.0110164899,
0.018926451,
-0.0860028192,
0.0300560929,
0.0238441397,
-0.0000735255,
0.0066170017,
0.0280819815,
-0.0377335884,
0.0490888804,
0.040478453,
-0.0050251638,
0.0327423699,
-0.055009976,
0.0273650736,
0.0202072524,
0.0593658015,
0.0564556643,
0.02699125,
-0.0068810163,
-0.0838425383,
0.0480614156,
-0.0104548922,
-0.0571764298,
0.0225179065,
0.0130662015,
-0.0325590745,
-0.0243396834,
-0.0614841208,
-0.0364502072,
-0.0343199223,
0.0214919392,
0.0144000305,
0.0361877568,
-0.0613762736,
0.1050122455,
0.0007350274,
-0.0148349432,
-0.0369269289,
-0.0733254999,
0.0205203742,
0.0349674448,
-0.0059495568,
-0.0488812737,
-0.0355165787,
-0.0450303145,
0.0371318609,
0.0102550928,
0.0414098278,
0.0153190792,
0.0941017047,
0.0284951422,
-0.0835465044,
-0.0064420104,
0.0425084308,
-0.0401932336,
-0.0087126084,
-0.0196616407,
0.0234578736,
-0.0285444465,
0.000947663,
0.0618575178,
0.0009462685,
0.0180906914,
0.0051667895,
-0.0078821983,
-0.0034788903,
-0.0062197377,
-0.0223042797,
-0.0450586565,
0.0168364663,
-0.0740066171,
0.0126463119,
-0.0194125995,
-0.0007190312,
-0.0284139309,
2.533e-7,
0.0438126288,
0.0327532217,
-0.0311831702,
-0.0251161736,
-0.0066333213,
0.0790571272,
-0.0105084609,
-0.0112139136,
-0.0011594899,
-0.0698281601,
0.0424053632,
-0.0316918008,
0.0041685142,
0.0381585434,
-0.019397622,
-0.0442556925,
-0.0055808136,
0.0155718448,
-0.0071297488,
0.037386287,
0.065022245,
0.0957427546,
0.0532447509,
-0.0173499845,
0.0173200052,
-0.0253439341,
0.0361877456,
0.0301312804,
0.0212720092,
0.040991459,
0.0470127538,
-0.0186147522,
-0.0060641374,
0.0927236676,
-0.029401036,
-0.0321321227,
0.0167949684,
0.0232613944,
-0.0351690874,
-0.0137839448,
-0.005957684,
0.0644106343,
0.0403261483,
0.0087858737,
0.0442718677,
-0.0556280874,
-0.0482058264,
-0.0141471177,
-0.0112176891,
0.0091770943,
0.06860324,
-0.0039378004,
-0.0038624876,
0.0178420562,
-0.0228930134,
0.0348459147,
-0.0503081195,
-0.0441983305,
-0.0206078161,
0.0172673631,
0.0061777798,
-0.0078767566,
0.0343933143,
-0.000903617,
0.0159739871,
-0.0688169971,
0.0075427513,
1.856429415e-34,
0.03539823,
-0.0190048851,
0.0032126731,
0.0420235619,
-0.0072457115,
0.0165622216,
-0.0214412939,
-0.0150448363,
0.0041814297,
0.0213559773,
0.0013730628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05263v2 | Model-Based Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Text Generation | 2023-11-09T10:46:09 | 2024-06-12T01:00:09 | Yuu Jinnai, Tetsuro Morimura, Ukyo Honda, Kaito Ariu, Kenshi Abe | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding has been shown to be a powerful alternative
to beam search decoding in a variety of text generation tasks. MBR decoding
selects a hypothesis from a pool of hypotheses that has the least expected risk
under a probability model according to a given utility function. Since it is
impractical to compute the expected risk exactly over all possible hypotheses,
two approximations are commonly used in MBR. First, it integrates over a
sampled set of hypotheses rather than over all possible hypotheses. Second, it
estimates the probability of each hypothesis using a Monte Carlo estimator.
While the first approximation is necessary to make it computationally feasible,
the second is not essential since we typically have access to the model
probability at inference time. We propose Model-Based MBR (MBMBR), a variant of
MBR that uses the model probability itself as the estimate of the probability
distribution instead of the Monte Carlo estimate. We show analytically and
empirically that the model-based estimate is more promising than the Monte
Carlo estimate in text generation tasks. Our experiments show that MBMBR
outperforms MBR in several text generation tasks, both with encoder-decoder
models and with large language models. | [
-0.0204464626,
0.0507960953,
0.0366912223,
-0.0499977879,
-0.0044092555,
0.0254651811,
0.0159689989,
0.0080254553,
-0.0203878097,
-0.0049005551,
0.0025901136,
-0.0438875593,
0.0186137483,
0.0367073491,
0.0186505523,
-0.0309476871,
0.0006777415,
-0.0337205827,
0.0602383614,
0.0047577154,
-0.0082114693,
0.0074054212,
-0.0487907119,
0.063953191,
-0.0044896803,
0.016945919,
-0.0222259611,
0.0419051871,
0.0478646047,
-0.0250222087,
-0.0160265826,
0.0144793,
0.0092970645,
0.0175837558,
0.0000019777,
-0.0113395732,
-0.0512451082,
0.0033078138,
0.0053993803,
-0.0465207249,
0.0536275283,
-0.0385473818,
-0.0267958045,
0.0523332432,
0.010813307,
-0.0277328063,
0.084812589,
0.0190332159,
0.0065828487,
0.0779336393,
0.0033328258,
0.0057788161,
0.0170014296,
-0.0200638436,
0.0445785038,
-0.0555737428,
0.0127994856,
0.0306474939,
-0.000229603,
0.0044033537,
-0.0015428431,
0.0693868175,
0.0340733416,
0.0003888966,
0.0039131101,
0.0704764128,
0.0642483681,
-0.0153096654,
-0.0088903476,
-0.0094600171,
-0.0333958417,
-0.0268824995,
0.0012775618,
-0.0350750722,
-0.0342122801,
0.0341773145,
-0.0227833856,
0.0929495171,
-0.044753436,
0.016458489,
0.0551129617,
0.0146134971,
0.0211712718,
-0.0086462237,
-0.0140648372,
0.0389356725,
0.0374570377,
-0.0259842779,
-0.0202129856,
0.0547218435,
0.0036361509,
-0.0469867811,
0.0402761213,
0.005689424,
-0.0023469508,
0.0335516483,
-0.095580034,
-0.0481325164,
-0.0114505487,
-0.0466456302,
0.0254535619,
0.0523090698,
0.0485145338,
-0.0085843075,
0.0080990773,
-0.0071443301,
0.0116163194,
-0.0527188219,
-0.0215509385,
0.0339748301,
0.0034466481,
-0.0209898967,
-0.0329080857,
-0.0019850989,
-0.065496169,
-0.0492943861,
-0.0071489932,
-0.00542058,
0.0554663166,
-0.030488424,
0.0429859124,
0.0145667493,
-0.0958910733,
0.0007549719,
0.0282722265,
0.0099238986,
0.0032867114,
-0.0075273938,
0.050023783,
-0.0515438765,
-0.0349411666,
0.0328348912,
0.0269610882,
-0.0367560834,
-0.0193362758,
0.0343084596,
-0.0541732088,
-0.0146310944,
-0.0149941742,
-0.0298041385,
-0.0300156977,
-0.0042441166,
0.0114931315,
-0.0560196824,
0.0052500884,
0.0125688463,
-0.0146456892,
-0.0185995344,
0.0240500271,
-0.0082774889,
0.0044431691,
0.0152561441,
-0.0078713223,
-0.0219135061,
0.1033248082,
0.0182958972,
-0.0099654691,
0.0865739435,
0.035734769,
0.0650010332,
-0.0116107007,
0.034566287,
0.007242295,
0.0459608361,
-0.0019459483,
0.0195322987,
0.0187918041,
-0.0443490185,
-0.0286372788,
0.0311574545,
0.0683929622,
0.0231487006,
-0.0764263421,
0.0562586859,
0.0841396451,
0.0047316877,
0.0156435538,
-0.028955549,
0.0423013456,
0.021084724,
0.0000036133,
0.0037461917,
0.0285005048,
0.0393424779,
-0.0437996909,
0.030264711,
0.0546359457,
0.024764441,
0.0047869403,
-0.0068592499,
0.0062873741,
-0.0196795743,
-0.0197158139,
-0.0017749874,
0.0503760315,
0.0163905118,
-0.0591616742,
0.0534115806,
0.0181321744,
-0.0601848401,
0.041321747,
-0.0324289054,
0.0189616941,
0.0442443974,
0.0946555734,
0.0145468973,
0.0035671352,
-0.0055249026,
-0.0440451056,
0.0375930779,
0.0207223482,
0.0161650646,
0.0202717725,
-0.0760593638,
-0.0257584397,
0.0145587772,
0.0412917845,
0.0281951148,
-0.0103018899,
0.020349795,
0.024334101,
-0.0166603439,
-0.042492602,
0.0131159825,
-0.0147650745,
-0.0177029446,
0.0182133075,
-0.0159577262,
0.0121688321,
-0.0319645368,
-0.0425378233,
0.0453894027,
-0.0122454828,
-0.0185844246,
-0.0113693355,
0.0211459063,
-0.0344933346,
-0.0842220932,
-0.0115869623,
-0.0622351468,
0.0247150548,
-0.0229014382,
0.0319264904,
-0.0447201319,
-0.0170454271,
-0.0692260414,
-0.0084373821,
-0.0356212258,
0.0141886519,
0.034197323,
-0.0149256447,
-0.0238334797,
0.0583572574,
-0.0311221182,
-0.0184027925,
0.0004191243,
-0.0053762165,
-0.011977491,
-0.0863160864,
-0.0103139393,
-0.015520337,
0.0037958906,
0.002928064,
0.0520135909,
0.0276620314,
0.0130060324,
-0.0143494019,
-0.0455419719,
0.0177773181,
-0.0217645578,
0.0170376133,
0.0508556217,
0.026336059,
-0.0090192016,
0.0159229767,
-0.0161256809,
-0.0122097237,
-0.0011688123,
0.0170737356,
-0.0034783455,
0.0047203824,
0.0341377743,
-0.0307857692,
-0.0243817363,
0.0048544882,
0.0454333611,
0.0360050537,
-0.020195229,
-0.0719919652,
0.0943620726,
0.0044204551,
-0.0515176095,
0.0068646516,
-0.0286531094,
0.0247782692,
-0.0278442446,
0.0854793489,
0.031367138,
0.0292709172,
0.0487264469,
0.0250399373,
-0.0235699546,
-0.0438567996,
-0.0068452135,
-0.040153943,
0.0138750561,
-0.02610025,
-0.1096951291,
0.0615247265,
0.0181212556,
0.0493041389,
0.0336153768,
-0.083500728,
0.0254118443,
-0.0087031294,
-0.0814307705,
-0.0175956581,
-0.0059211678,
-0.0125921564,
0.0323153548,
-0.004352795,
-0.0201767068,
0.0339525193,
-0.0459344536,
0.0143259224,
-0.0378623605,
0.0166408364,
0.0004991808,
-0.0239421446,
0.0024292727,
0.0553373545,
0.0010304266,
-0.0442773253,
-0.0180980228,
0.0535895117,
0.0413685814,
-0.0164737944,
-0.0002078324,
-0.0453480408,
-0.0103952894,
-0.0201391485,
0.003018894,
-0.0178444572,
-0.0089881551,
0.0128043294,
-0.0150512457,
0.0435945541,
-0.0151005089,
-0.0355906785,
0.0286019109,
0.0280058868,
0.0197182596,
-0.0257766396,
-0.013765608,
-0.0385511965,
0.0714968368,
0.059509702,
-0.0423737317,
0.028663367,
-0.0559911542,
-0.0316186063,
0.0376408435,
0.0186903756,
0.0417814106,
-0.0238700528,
-0.0164419748,
0.0349388495,
0.0043087918,
-0.0282553956,
0.0349358507,
0.0635822266,
-0.0401628129,
-0.0395418592,
0.083926253,
-0.0008397024,
-0.0167253297,
-0.0264636762,
0.0008395517,
0.0380671881,
-0.0381486267,
0.0179734565,
-0.06865336,
-0.0220889077,
0.0249104928,
0.0517885052,
-0.0313934535,
-0.0388092063,
-0.0189389735,
-0.0687018931,
0.0482709669,
0.0305860396,
0.0126441978,
-0.0431858264,
-0.0179421362,
-0.0474827811,
-0.0280564949,
-0.019154463,
0.0405825824,
0.0177955851,
0.0451756679,
0.0340381078,
-0.0111135943,
-0.0825669616,
-0.0550910644,
-0.0204916857,
0.033191938,
0.0854513496,
0.0019484927,
0.0098787667,
0.0056720311,
-0.0401709601,
-0.0282991435,
0.0004451928,
-0.0089992993,
0.0236042291,
-0.0267532263,
0.0142173897,
-0.002941102,
0.0146750566,
0.0051040202,
-0.0029415344,
-0.0104366681,
0.028906351,
-0.0730552971,
-0.0067627407,
0.0053694025,
0.0209300518,
0.0690914914,
0.0513617732,
0.027802011,
-0.0118513787,
-0.0234955996,
-0.0653703585,
0.0336235836,
-0.0703103617,
0.0299537536,
-0.0009528211,
0.0143917231,
-0.0836319774,
-0.0819298699,
-0.0147150429,
0.0002406139,
0.0310318209,
-0.0181974843,
-0.0183455627,
0.0004661044,
-0.0035303447,
-0.0281824153,
-0.019587921,
-0.0206675977,
-0.0127323531,
-0.0038166796,
0.0167145487,
-0.0177445207,
-0.0670229644,
-0.0199761502,
0.0448267572,
-0.0944859385,
-0.0624160022,
-0.0462883636,
0.0570593886,
0.0215261634,
-0.0074944175,
-0.0073012793,
-0.0673757046,
0.051664684,
0.0091999602,
-0.0227037817,
0.0345466472,
0.0190800913,
-0.0214623176,
-0.015104508,
-0.0055862442,
0.0002254866,
-0.0193469878,
-0.0356608965,
0.0567785949,
-0.0107606063,
-0.0492073521,
0.0185844768,
-0.008069749,
-0.0107521769,
-0.0877139047,
-0.0297082923,
-0.0632268488,
-0.0137285898,
-0.0173215233,
0.0134753836,
-0.0389396325,
0.0314997882,
0.0625698045,
0.005091527,
0.0013372349,
0.021358775,
0.011165672,
0.0246569682,
0.0166429915,
0.0187622476,
0.0156441834,
0.0013019355,
0.0842003077,
-0.0313835628,
-0.0080200499,
-0.0030052459,
-0.0074660582,
0.0037005481,
-0.0146940872,
0.0175001435,
0.0243512187,
-0.0154629191,
0.0351759158,
0.0113607971,
-0.0537517592,
-0.0419561788,
-0.0504394881,
0.0226070415,
0.0457428582,
0.03850637,
0.1056010723,
-0.0585873462,
0.0171608254,
-0.0425824635,
0.0396230966,
0.0388589837,
-0.0186770204,
0.0298216399,
0.0026806456,
0.0004635619,
-0.037070293,
0.0994435772,
0.0044569778,
0.0421266183,
-0.0434340537,
-0.0115413824,
-0.029247582,
-0.0310247988,
0.0040656938,
0.0364784822,
-0.0168373734,
-0.0420618095,
-0.0290277228,
-0.0012770081,
0.0149439126,
0.0042145522,
0.0104859322,
-0.0261703432,
0.0317196548,
0.0267189704,
-0.0578421243,
0.0458985083,
-0.0415945873,
0.0049915202,
-0.0505866855,
0.0191108938,
-0.0267405417,
-6.336225322e-33,
-0.0137185575,
-0.0398514345,
0.0130107179,
-0.0642989129,
0.0004977122,
-0.0090432204,
-0.082893461,
-0.0083539151,
0.0609661974,
-0.0038850154,
0.0157535467,
0.0109085348,
0.0250115395,
0.0212334525,
-0.0124517763,
0.0276668333,
0.0489124656,
-0.010341852,
-0.050203044,
0.0160495769,
0.0558749996,
0.0129872533,
0.023034649,
0.0017068072,
-0.0077498839,
0.0067738523,
-0.0522939414,
-0.0470304415,
0.0287351105,
0.0400528274,
-0.0081235068,
0.0199517943,
-0.0094833132,
-0.0426936448,
-0.0373931192,
0.0022308163,
-0.0127919465,
0.0254070107,
-0.0332424641,
-0.0027714965,
-0.0328085236,
-0.0587789528,
-0.0317463949,
0.012672605,
-0.0315045156,
-0.0082688509,
0.011260313,
-0.0299672298,
-0.0292847529,
-0.0734170005,
-0.0176662486,
0.0557266437,
0.0019785068,
0.0049444847,
0.0321006626,
0.0225582514,
-0.0145365801,
-0.028202679,
-0.0106202597,
0.0341022946,
0.0334276482,
0.0483076684,
0.062765114,
0.0107746636,
-0.0008078287,
0.0388937891,
0.0220413562,
-0.0644114688,
0.0178657956,
0.0130680809,
-0.0020306672,
0.004938608,
-0.0144038266,
0.0600923933,
0.021117771,
0.0071522729,
-0.0256948825,
0.0678805262,
-0.004592401,
0.0010847512,
0.027470801,
0.0202266797,
-0.0388689265,
-0.0162053667,
-0.0527722798,
-0.0577865057,
-0.0004715875,
-0.0301107075,
0.0316404365,
0.0467475839,
-0.0264813527,
-0.0183177367,
0.0713308677,
0.0153426612,
0.0510425046,
0.0152861746,
-0.0207437184,
0.0085180812,
-0.0294817556,
0.0372926183,
-0.0540443361,
0.011101272,
0.0772228912,
-0.0025779065,
-0.0448391698,
0.0315168686,
-0.0046942015,
0.0244590696,
-0.0329076909,
0.012211863,
-0.0426170416,
0.0349041298,
0.0245808866,
0.0665132329,
0.0533581451,
-0.0544480011,
-0.0065521486,
0.012639001,
-0.0058274264,
0.0087492438,
-0.0096033895,
-0.024300795,
-0.0050128307,
0.0099504627,
-0.0093702003,
0.0400350541,
-0.0312845372,
-0.0321924314,
0.0492718481,
-0.0447288565,
-0.0329801589,
0.0404059626,
2.628e-7,
0.0460012145,
0.0256120022,
0.0490996204,
0.0362175666,
0.0331838951,
0.0377520435,
0.0175640676,
0.0298729781,
0.0119252698,
0.0089708408,
0.0088819172,
0.0022592712,
0.0686623231,
0.0155402236,
-0.0733366087,
-0.0086436393,
-0.0627650321,
0.0175046027,
-0.0198055413,
-0.0448469967,
0.0480516069,
0.0205849763,
-0.0652753264,
-0.0214296728,
0.055720862,
0.0013107916,
0.0832544267,
0.0213144477,
-0.0303845685,
0.0087841069,
-0.010531052,
0.0063251113,
-0.0150325382,
-0.0042290362,
-0.0448635146,
-0.0674129799,
0.0157063305,
0.0562607273,
0.0409846418,
-0.0662514046,
0.0410105921,
0.0222714841,
0.0016549722,
-0.0175650809,
0.026804246,
-0.009621026,
0.0068844873,
0.0012203275,
-0.0302310064,
0.0320342518,
-0.0395146869,
-0.0415747575,
-0.0200884696,
-0.01133502,
-0.0108949076,
0.0354956798,
-0.007381699,
-0.0023771173,
-0.0224409457,
-0.0219967831,
-0.0412107296,
-0.0653285831,
-0.0413368344,
0.0009433686,
0.0316042155,
-0.1091829687,
-0.0341921262,
2.723131157e-34,
0.017550949,
-0.015066796,
-0.0187227707,
0.0075110057,
0.0229561757,
-0.0103115393,
-0.0214384384,
0.0133784851,
0.0174699165,
-0.076639168,
-0.0602155738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05232v1 | A Survey on Hallucination in Large Language Models: Principles, Taxonomy, Challenges, and Open Questions | 2023-11-09T09:25:37 | 2023-11-09T09:25:37 | Lei Huang, Weijiang Yu, Weitao Ma, Weihong Zhong, Zhangyin Feng, Haotian Wang, Qianglong Chen, Weihua Peng, Xiaocheng Feng, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has marked a significant
breakthrough in natural language processing (NLP), leading to remarkable
advancements in text understanding and generation. Nevertheless, alongside
these strides, LLMs exhibit a critical tendency to produce hallucinations,
resulting in content that is inconsistent with real-world facts or user inputs.
This phenomenon poses substantial challenges to their practical deployment and
raises concerns over the reliability of LLMs in real-world scenarios, which
attracts increasing attention to detect and mitigate these hallucinations. In
this survey, we aim to provide a thorough and in-depth overview of recent
advances in the field of LLM hallucinations. We begin with an innovative
taxonomy of LLM hallucinations, then delve into the factors contributing to
hallucinations. Subsequently, we present a comprehensive overview of
hallucination detection methods and benchmarks. Additionally, representative
approaches designed to mitigate hallucinations are introduced accordingly.
Finally, we analyze the challenges that highlight the current limitations and
formulate open questions, aiming to delineate pathways for future research on
hallucinations in LLMs. | [
0.029826358,
0.0442332029,
-0.0369764641,
0.0584808514,
-0.0435528383,
0.0219034068,
-0.0336536169,
0.0262558293,
0.0279479232,
-0.0471150205,
0.02180852,
-0.0686529055,
0.0151611157,
-0.0251594353,
0.0120726312,
-0.0511605255,
0.0534304827,
-0.0501437597,
-0.0272696503,
0.002583524,
0.0111208707,
0.0281555261,
0.006548224,
0.0584172606,
-0.0204609595,
-0.0376648642,
-0.0010047484,
0.0082816556,
-0.0175366588,
-0.0052151266,
-0.0181210227,
0.0527557209,
-0.0055215512,
0.0799360722,
0.0000021009,
-0.0510365739,
-0.0064116917,
-0.0117663993,
-0.0090434281,
0.0061350148,
0.0375277922,
-0.0138826156,
0.0015249801,
0.0097414246,
-0.0186685994,
0.0037595434,
0.0108995326,
0.084621802,
0.0415537581,
0.0468914136,
-0.0118304705,
-0.0234645233,
0.0179323368,
0.0333888717,
0.0240242854,
0.0026683914,
0.0495239943,
0.0124187013,
0.0169304069,
-0.0521331578,
-0.010547,
0.0108882887,
0.007032183,
0.0072645112,
-0.0295539945,
0.0273556318,
-0.0700159445,
-0.0166949052,
-0.0066228025,
0.0475814454,
-0.0493871011,
-0.0420113876,
0.0358907692,
0.0008240889,
-0.0048727253,
0.0068845744,
-0.0218423177,
0.0381854437,
-0.0251298994,
0.0065871198,
0.0487480685,
0.0056763655,
0.035632804,
0.0216521621,
-0.0651373565,
0.0805900395,
0.0136938132,
-0.0508057661,
0.0032045611,
0.0076541798,
-0.0316197835,
-0.0704220608,
0.0383846685,
0.0233331081,
-0.0651682988,
-0.0017257266,
-0.0517040938,
-0.014231612,
0.0435990319,
-0.1078864634,
0.0189074539,
-0.0170648172,
-0.0561671853,
0.050238844,
-0.0064959414,
0.0343228988,
-0.051805187,
0.0093358401,
-0.0051831105,
0.0242941044,
-0.0276029948,
-0.0273004603,
-0.0425017737,
0.0188897848,
-0.019346131,
-0.046739988,
0.0067643463,
0.0091652079,
-0.0228651538,
0.0321770199,
-0.0478544869,
0.0187572483,
0.0206004959,
-0.0444226786,
0.0022671181,
0.0054004299,
-0.0113790631,
-0.011517697,
0.0079015857,
-0.0604792349,
-0.0140896197,
0.0281910989,
-0.0261046272,
0.0003687278,
-0.0294364225,
0.0328313597,
0.0414430052,
0.0088264998,
-0.0380433723,
-0.0646027401,
-0.0358502939,
-0.0736541674,
-0.0185832661,
-0.0563314147,
-0.0055208206,
0.0184271522,
-0.0062759225,
-0.0290165674,
0.0375820547,
0.0231535845,
-0.0422218107,
0.0855022818,
-0.0523819849,
0.0125201521,
0.0292945895,
0.03749834,
0.0039682128,
0.0874111652,
0.0003880881,
0.0232778322,
0.0218349136,
-0.0039690463,
0.0710890815,
0.036467202,
-0.0368904024,
0.0133707598,
-0.0551147573,
-0.0308306068,
0.0094195642,
0.0171406828,
-0.0052542533,
0.0589505397,
-0.0154055897,
0.0056718132,
0.0587918647,
0.0263377968,
-0.0211331155,
0.0187887028,
0.0348679684,
0.0375728011,
-0.0086733894,
0.0708567128,
-0.0427744612,
-0.0177833512,
-0.0406666696,
-0.0103186667,
0.0407662578,
0.0197931323,
0.0101438593,
-0.0290619005,
-0.0479055457,
0.0111840172,
-0.001578097,
-0.0124542462,
0.0206018668,
0.0041437987,
-0.0437159017,
0.0495404154,
0.0332286768,
-0.0094232336,
0.039964132,
-0.0301044378,
-0.0212469473,
0.1220999956,
0.071010977,
-0.032215964,
0.0226733647,
-0.0336229727,
0.034941677,
0.0526235588,
0.0141366199,
0.0079248752,
-0.0147901913,
-0.0460611358,
0.0217535142,
0.0260382406,
0.064853169,
-0.0084390743,
-0.0337566249,
-0.006075819,
-0.0047022291,
-0.0162636042,
-0.0462102741,
0.0388959758,
-0.0271313153,
0.0014661974,
-0.0341270678,
-0.021122003,
-0.008851856,
0.0043193232,
-0.0182637982,
0.025482608,
-0.0002382261,
-0.0511626601,
-0.0381629467,
0.0309714451,
-0.0349464081,
-0.0058253407,
0.0187469665,
0.0061537195,
-0.001764374,
-0.0033964086,
0.0151632847,
-0.0387519337,
0.0010054293,
-0.0658160523,
0.0567398332,
-0.0418010242,
0.0719412267,
-0.0084192352,
0.060750965,
-0.0135471309,
0.0822473168,
-0.0295147114,
0.0176722612,
0.0425281636,
-0.0016875744,
-0.011418594,
-0.0015714022,
-0.0089103924,
0.0347832963,
0.0116554406,
0.0182276964,
-0.0167871062,
-0.0650857836,
-0.0634476691,
-0.0354383551,
-0.0541123264,
0.0059596673,
-0.0408536457,
0.0018890514,
0.0204360988,
-0.03336557,
-0.0255811829,
0.0102305887,
0.0174866058,
-0.012374552,
0.032997027,
0.0373473056,
0.0099011501,
-0.0040137479,
-0.0425167345,
0.0068425788,
0.031836763,
-0.0240225028,
0.0637899265,
-0.0134118376,
-0.0617242754,
-0.1212458089,
0.0313124657,
-0.0278793871,
0.0099341059,
0.0011794638,
0.0119299097,
-0.0067446376,
-0.0128010288,
0.0756087303,
0.0400279909,
0.0157189295,
0.0357181579,
0.0668516308,
-0.0555913299,
-0.0104559567,
-0.0310144797,
-0.004202154,
0.0315117091,
-0.0114458706,
-0.0414426327,
0.023134008,
0.060207855,
0.005353278,
0.0090594972,
-0.0507709011,
0.0309303794,
-0.0770014003,
-0.0549743846,
0.0124985753,
-0.0364023037,
-0.032678213,
0.045657672,
-0.0244674608,
-0.0282803811,
0.0551011823,
-0.0309045073,
0.0275887977,
-0.0151911415,
-0.0068148412,
-0.0118403127,
0.0229500178,
0.0191258658,
0.0168331061,
0.0160412584,
-0.0382058285,
0.0010949089,
-0.0033319003,
-0.0617957488,
-0.0474120378,
0.0380350202,
-0.04454403,
-0.0065947417,
0.0285372343,
-0.0138376066,
-0.0451325104,
-0.0526179969,
-0.0167332571,
-0.0269819014,
0.0013105224,
0.001684085,
-0.0053221066,
0.0218825471,
-0.0143430959,
0.0148214363,
-0.0195315089,
-0.0213898867,
-0.0248176437,
0.0394485965,
0.0734174103,
-0.0248229746,
0.0680259913,
-0.0422473252,
0.0205414537,
0.0833544135,
0.0327740908,
0.0531814545,
-0.0118509401,
-0.0182419363,
0.026050128,
-0.0234017409,
-0.0533047877,
0.0230761524,
0.0145692946,
-0.0911052227,
-0.0281824246,
0.1033226028,
0.0564287528,
-0.0522216372,
0.0172823332,
-0.0587344542,
0.0530389547,
0.0060146698,
-0.0137227662,
-0.0530374683,
-0.0037581848,
0.0164569225,
-0.0292375609,
-0.0445045494,
-0.0264342148,
-0.0172532964,
-0.0745262429,
0.0340338312,
0.018660197,
-0.0096524842,
-0.0064698118,
-0.0194087271,
0.0063897888,
0.0337854102,
0.0404406749,
-0.0113329915,
0.0057284562,
-0.0342603475,
0.0270840917,
-0.0630784929,
-0.0227876902,
0.0012207949,
-0.0293530393,
0.0583524257,
0.0731585473,
0.0402937084,
-0.0118179889,
-0.0507206842,
0.0220382977,
-0.0214297622,
0.0054646134,
0.0002680709,
0.0335991122,
0.0213953182,
0.0100453645,
-0.0170300547,
0.0023744963,
-0.0380504578,
-0.0252169222,
0.0137602407,
0.0789545029,
-0.0525578,
-0.0483791679,
-0.018861549,
0.0396085605,
0.030878948,
0.069806397,
0.032169681,
-0.0454719104,
-0.0686275661,
-0.0218277313,
0.0503023043,
-0.0324196182,
-0.0502478778,
0.0362519175,
0.0582400821,
-0.0193631947,
-0.0680148453,
-0.0214676578,
0.0140727786,
0.0044742762,
0.0219543464,
0.0687617064,
-0.0072815856,
-0.0348272063,
0.0108537795,
0.0106638018,
-0.0438227132,
0.019089587,
-0.009171267,
0.0313858576,
0.0208942611,
-0.0201404858,
0.0152724739,
0.0343279727,
-0.0940807387,
-0.0725096911,
0.0505227111,
-0.0140270321,
0.024711011,
0.0426888987,
-0.0305470154,
-0.0701197311,
0.0375400372,
0.0420152545,
0.0035424458,
0.0204498507,
-0.0105109485,
0.016760502,
0.007806587,
0.0352547877,
0.004747597,
-0.0127640432,
-0.0199189875,
0.0163300671,
-0.03392094,
0.0084226681,
0.0402210914,
-0.0173676293,
0.0047951811,
-0.0210798737,
0.0005539931,
-0.0098214047,
-0.0120172268,
-0.0296490528,
-0.0318565592,
-0.0163384397,
-0.0106521398,
0.0226139966,
-0.0094953068,
-0.001829422,
-0.0105977813,
-0.0383280218,
0.0066811219,
-0.0372182354,
-0.0346043967,
0.0121118091,
-0.01170184,
0.0642305091,
-0.0268604811,
-0.0153574497,
0.0273667108,
-0.0096691735,
0.041629307,
0.0106312251,
0.0826910362,
0.0045250421,
-0.0489088744,
-0.0277831871,
0.0053968029,
-0.0178720132,
-0.0722628534,
-0.0157022942,
0.0497984402,
0.0580034219,
-0.0195148885,
0.0856683776,
-0.0405707695,
0.0108783357,
-0.004973968,
0.0029120541,
0.0452527739,
-0.0573761724,
-0.0424440131,
0.0296686143,
-0.0474390015,
0.0180138443,
0.06583713,
0.0026267383,
0.0447679721,
0.0269273389,
-0.0323228464,
-0.0096404292,
-0.0554810241,
-0.0299179852,
0.0024372058,
-0.0339423455,
-0.0167185776,
-0.0934339464,
-0.0342921913,
-0.0009614791,
-0.0067656073,
0.010971888,
-0.0225521512,
0.004618356,
0.0742170662,
-0.0242430046,
-0.0185626447,
-0.0216867644,
-0.0047874139,
0.0312990099,
0.0055238707,
0.0044585224,
-6.420661081e-33,
0.0121726831,
-0.0568317994,
0.0085417153,
-0.0556431897,
-0.0357362144,
-0.0200125054,
-0.0091909962,
0.0237189922,
0.0519304201,
0.0150672523,
0.0010915789,
0.0155192809,
0.0224587321,
0.0102555268,
0.0180834681,
-0.0233682655,
0.0589503497,
0.0290053394,
-0.0075476221,
0.0229294654,
0.0443893149,
0.0117887165,
0.0131881889,
-0.0584334768,
0.039880719,
-0.0397940725,
-0.0310013499,
0.0159274358,
-0.0184271969,
0.024618784,
-0.049991861,
0.0524917021,
0.0331925489,
-0.0365506969,
-0.0449867882,
0.020318538,
0.0026492954,
0.0106325829,
0.0003428866,
0.0318151973,
-0.0199546888,
-0.0188511834,
0.0586641617,
-0.0140952319,
0.0171394348,
0.0200063623,
0.0409487262,
-0.060224656,
-0.0249720886,
0.0375544317,
-0.0671156496,
0.0107796267,
0.010878793,
-0.0023518309,
0.0293150265,
0.0434071645,
-0.0110971332,
0.0007962742,
-0.0723123923,
0.0146984486,
0.0199893136,
0.0074388608,
0.0441402495,
0.0043712691,
-0.0042647789,
0.0785743073,
0.0564874746,
0.0315220691,
-0.0518210083,
-0.0150441956,
0.0076617282,
0.0470420979,
0.0281646252,
0.020492062,
0.0479714945,
-0.0028801893,
-0.0130339777,
-0.014394532,
-0.0665954575,
0.0105243446,
0.0923144668,
-0.0099993814,
-0.0735179931,
-0.0546315238,
-0.0074504465,
0.0100184735,
-0.0260970946,
-0.0114277434,
0.0295034833,
0.0001745886,
-0.0238929652,
0.0092585385,
0.0270662233,
-0.0489459038,
-0.0077301092,
-0.0042086584,
-0.0147425272,
0.0136886379,
0.0015292775,
0.0265246555,
0.0186316688,
-0.0336015821,
0.0053397524,
-0.0129987281,
0.0172626432,
0.0005502487,
-0.0040280381,
-0.0226284731,
-0.0583906658,
0.0098852962,
-0.0203291718,
0.0239826404,
-0.0007274975,
0.0062368293,
0.0746337026,
-0.0231356379,
-0.0256458316,
-0.0035087487,
0.0608300753,
0.0131204249,
0.0078083221,
0.0344976448,
-0.060015358,
0.0136225885,
-0.0321249738,
-0.0031245197,
-0.0516087301,
-0.0255676564,
0.0630731583,
-0.0703502521,
-0.013576393,
-0.0370985158,
2.723e-7,
-0.0136506408,
0.082562916,
0.0230111312,
-0.0074723097,
0.0198871288,
0.0175749734,
0.0164331906,
0.0034885553,
0.0137488386,
-0.040552035,
-0.0209181663,
0.0146278385,
0.0666961223,
0.0521613918,
-0.0828858986,
-0.0090146651,
-0.0279488955,
0.0347884037,
-0.1096261516,
-0.0389802791,
0.0471231565,
0.0480465442,
0.0090784375,
-0.0271507502,
0.0065832734,
-0.0566026419,
0.05420148,
-0.0166127272,
-0.0200794879,
0.042607028,
0.0391265191,
0.0167187862,
0.0163248125,
0.0536575802,
0.0113258604,
-0.0189088006,
0.0193540137,
0.0265989769,
0.0054481216,
-0.0070796642,
-0.0110579468,
-0.0122533627,
0.0039549144,
-0.0732765719,
0.0697163418,
-0.0325278975,
-0.0187397003,
-0.0264518745,
-0.0142452987,
-0.0398610756,
0.0406365991,
0.0047481749,
-0.0163768604,
0.0315966345,
0.0076990072,
0.0480404124,
-0.0138100944,
-0.0555331409,
-0.0109180948,
0.0083164228,
-0.0316969641,
-0.0125975041,
-0.0142186172,
0.0166787468,
-0.009901938,
-0.0933743194,
0.0075492319,
2.875989504e-34,
0.0114448154,
0.0099863671,
0.0327681378,
0.0345838554,
0.0300481338,
0.0207714122,
0.0277447496,
0.0272750314,
-0.0011636458,
-0.048046995,
0.0057059983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05195v1 | PRODIGy: a PROfile-based DIalogue Generation dataset | 2023-11-09T08:19:34 | 2023-11-09T08:19:34 | Daniela Occhipinti, Serra Sinem Tekiroglu, Marco Guerini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Providing dialogue agents with a profile representation can improve their
consistency and coherence, leading to better conversations. However, current
profile-based dialogue datasets for training such agents contain either
explicit profile representations that are simple and dialogue-specific, or
implicit representations that are difficult to collect. In this work, we
propose a unified framework in which we bring together both standard and more
sophisticated profile representations by creating a new resource where each
dialogue is aligned with all possible speaker representations such as
communication style, biographies, and personality. This framework allows to
test several baselines built using generative language models with several
profile configurations. The automatic evaluation shows that profile-based
models have better generalisation capabilities than models trained on dialogues
only, both in-domain and cross-domain settings. These results are consistent
for fine-tuned models and instruction-based LLMs. Additionally, human
evaluation demonstrates a clear preference for generations consistent with both
profile and context. Finally, to account for possible privacy concerns, all
experiments are done under two configurations: inter-character and
intra-character. In the former, the LM stores the information about the
character in its internal representation, while in the latter, the LM does not
retain any personal information but uses it only at inference time. | [
0.0404450297,
0.0715223104,
-0.0195697304,
0.0082761394,
-0.0184168965,
-0.012704147,
0.063742511,
-0.0323518962,
0.0040331748,
-0.0105657009,
-0.0266498309,
-0.081369862,
-0.0020311521,
0.0842997283,
0.0311713219,
-0.0702213868,
0.0320637673,
-0.0161888171,
0.0170073342,
0.0016547251,
-0.0158567335,
0.0380197614,
-0.0139407823,
0.0494173355,
-0.0172816198,
-0.0170192402,
-0.0247763433,
0.0325635001,
0.0602787025,
-0.0033318191,
0.0374264009,
0.032248158,
0.0576172099,
-0.0025674598,
0.00000194,
-0.0314618126,
0.0083519332,
-0.006226602,
-0.0006731448,
0.0014784731,
0.0428951606,
0.0212625917,
-0.0090262219,
0.0296504665,
-0.0450904481,
0.0303915702,
0.0046912711,
0.0427276455,
0.0730879456,
0.0589973293,
-0.0102324924,
-0.0606177151,
-0.0173733998,
-0.0458978303,
0.020298399,
-0.0395032726,
-0.0283150058,
-0.031962391,
-0.032207638,
-0.0185624324,
0.011718655,
-0.0035974521,
-0.0041612652,
-0.033718273,
0.0286046248,
0.0145241506,
0.0008153644,
-0.0155697297,
-0.0063704755,
0.1036635041,
0.0975620896,
0.0204765517,
0.0094969627,
-0.0218200535,
0.016602708,
-0.0378232747,
0.0046520932,
0.0478980429,
-0.0169204548,
-0.0057900953,
0.0021196515,
0.0362067111,
-0.0096894586,
-0.0194866359,
-0.008128182,
0.0015613963,
0.0104322918,
-0.0021660984,
-0.0177542288,
-0.0060634054,
0.0135209868,
-0.0543178059,
-0.0086471224,
-0.0063366108,
-0.0379772782,
0.0326181427,
-0.0733576268,
0.0384257734,
0.0175639596,
0.0053090341,
0.0274221357,
0.0329240374,
0.0132207898,
-0.0210468154,
0.0095016481,
0.0736148283,
0.0154085895,
-0.009962,
0.0072101075,
0.01440359,
-0.0587492362,
-0.0076710726,
-0.0212246887,
0.035658583,
-0.0325993262,
-0.021515267,
-0.0753766745,
0.044860702,
0.0049766493,
0.0137086734,
-0.0149938902,
0.0461905897,
-0.0497523099,
0.0209896844,
-0.0443619564,
0.0082760956,
-0.0588464253,
0.0020985859,
0.0610519983,
-0.0582928881,
0.0063654575,
0.0216175169,
0.0130370352,
0.0050143455,
0.0080690263,
0.0907682478,
-0.0160787571,
-0.0417749994,
-0.0235186089,
-0.0610023215,
-0.0228297263,
-0.1031424105,
-0.0546878316,
-0.0010608091,
0.0324051008,
-0.0120376637,
-0.0092037451,
-0.0623810031,
0.0210492928,
0.0183793735,
0.0017293843,
0.0194506552,
0.0398448035,
0.0030411361,
0.0303538702,
0.0141233914,
0.0024064977,
0.0281472523,
0.0442641489,
0.0059478064,
-0.0006948013,
-0.0104169948,
-0.0105741844,
0.0149753001,
0.0059998822,
-0.0061272173,
0.0088252332,
0.0147023806,
-0.0236453395,
0.0589985996,
0.0556697994,
0.0825360343,
-0.0625190362,
-0.0395651758,
0.0739553794,
0.0496185161,
0.0153739415,
0.0315078385,
0.0719783902,
0.0527397096,
0.010975183,
0.0259477589,
-0.0071975226,
-0.0038838324,
0.0151921371,
0.0005066598,
0.0123479394,
0.0351893567,
-0.0411400795,
-0.0397339053,
0.028098058,
-0.0071767275,
0.018666571,
-0.0126882391,
-0.0126484623,
0.0047268351,
-0.069861874,
0.0534397513,
0.0037196565,
-0.0928805023,
-0.0207405891,
-0.0280126818,
0.0198753159,
0.0958741903,
0.0364166573,
0.0444942862,
-0.052959118,
-0.0446115695,
-0.0553197004,
0.0401990972,
0.0388141274,
-0.0300768148,
0.0637543276,
-0.0766301453,
-0.0091897622,
-0.047578238,
-0.0115576107,
0.0509821326,
0.0039304779,
-0.0151297925,
0.0417757519,
0.005794113,
-0.0123710819,
0.0196849089,
-0.0812695473,
-0.0237948652,
0.0307219513,
0.0049872934,
0.021347845,
0.0410272442,
-0.018410841,
-0.0232006181,
0.0259686913,
-0.0078694727,
0.0228668675,
0.043423377,
-0.0802721083,
-0.0191285666,
0.0068310793,
-0.0483805872,
-0.0014293648,
-0.0191753227,
-0.0080649387,
-0.0652104542,
0.0038164058,
-0.0569662787,
0.0172460824,
-0.0597674139,
0.0203918368,
0.0098995417,
0.0235690456,
0.0067381258,
0.0554753393,
0.0071786023,
-0.0221903697,
0.0540623441,
0.04291109,
0.0147959134,
-0.0958783776,
0.014621269,
-0.0410616286,
0.0221157353,
0.0089779748,
0.0245993286,
0.0031218978,
-0.0548610687,
-0.0202445611,
-0.0745291635,
0.0198037084,
-0.0059853951,
-0.0013952275,
-0.0067582573,
0.0052249357,
-0.0189054329,
-0.0135749085,
-0.0706942305,
-0.0151556581,
0.0412914902,
-0.0172912609,
0.0442904755,
0.0026238672,
-0.0081405807,
-0.0361788273,
0.0301277675,
0.0113691026,
0.0356193818,
-0.0095512718,
0.0088415146,
-0.0245012827,
0.024976192,
-0.0597560219,
0.0211877618,
-0.0262968745,
-0.0317434184,
0.022298025,
0.0250286106,
0.0492648184,
0.0317269377,
0.0522557348,
0.015509733,
-0.003402483,
-0.0044111526,
-0.0500087179,
0.034427572,
-0.001555209,
0.0229815394,
-0.052724041,
-0.0387188196,
0.025086673,
-0.0100446614,
0.0313324817,
0.0206211247,
-0.0676095486,
0.0147271603,
0.0600730926,
-0.0541487411,
0.0422342569,
-0.0026476358,
-0.0251843147,
0.010576427,
-0.0117449658,
-0.0284628086,
0.0694535226,
-0.0423290282,
-0.0216537751,
0.0032712037,
-0.0316169895,
-0.0369312726,
0.0418279208,
-0.003339763,
0.0390587561,
0.0234294739,
-0.0496079065,
-0.0441409983,
0.0126195885,
0.0517739244,
-0.0330499932,
0.0060522365,
-0.0172371455,
-0.0064756735,
0.030091973,
-0.034730088,
-0.0854687393,
-0.0697936118,
-0.0071108663,
0.0155411465,
0.0132830739,
-0.0534211136,
-0.0097999861,
0.0013030419,
-0.0050765155,
-0.0086463289,
-0.0073827454,
0.0117746908,
-0.0143485656,
0.011499566,
0.0445036739,
0.0288637169,
-0.0064750663,
-0.0574429557,
0.0527334884,
0.0179927498,
-0.0389977507,
0.0146086365,
-0.0007353321,
-0.0015686116,
-0.0136462525,
-0.0022227464,
-0.0203585699,
0.0380825996,
0.0803602338,
-0.0205413513,
-0.0113509037,
0.1060663536,
0.0101822885,
-0.0312522985,
-0.0131311193,
0.0078853015,
0.0342321768,
0.0021292656,
0.0093754129,
-0.0456145927,
-0.0037145084,
0.0004750187,
0.0433531739,
-0.0331613608,
-0.0185238551,
-0.0292274412,
-0.1035708785,
0.040068429,
0.0238942485,
-0.0074202181,
-0.0247143712,
-0.0004346796,
-0.0336579047,
-0.0034655004,
0.0745789707,
-0.0257149283,
-0.0126317479,
-0.0108195106,
0.0053761886,
0.0004734501,
-0.0534955896,
0.0006214439,
-0.0295589529,
0.0814798698,
0.0804917291,
0.0584521107,
0.045659706,
-0.025880076,
-0.0377131812,
0.0203806646,
0.0318805128,
0.0039437045,
0.054075025,
-0.0062858611,
0.0037974017,
-0.0370179527,
0.0560415238,
-0.0009384218,
0.0071129478,
-0.0112918913,
-0.027434025,
-0.0572599173,
-0.0042772079,
0.0047542122,
0.071813859,
0.0315118916,
0.0780011341,
0.0299095698,
-0.0384979695,
-0.0156785268,
-0.0146900825,
0.0254913252,
-0.0874585509,
-0.010533331,
0.0317637473,
-0.0007428609,
0.0081552137,
-0.0670019314,
-0.045050703,
-0.0090874052,
0.0261265989,
-0.0100580622,
-0.0163004939,
-0.0478484109,
-0.0089076264,
-0.0173974372,
-0.0159578435,
-0.0202292427,
0.0003872087,
-0.0502499938,
-0.0395359322,
0.0496059619,
-0.0687397197,
-0.0080702929,
0.0174651258,
-0.0652511716,
-0.0839577094,
-0.0167452134,
0.0276593491,
0.015474055,
0.069328256,
0.0022698697,
-0.0415938906,
0.0627429262,
-0.0040154373,
-0.0087436503,
0.006035422,
0.0157899633,
0.0358620659,
-0.043621853,
0.0189145654,
-0.0135206226,
0.0021730943,
-0.0325778835,
0.0170958564,
-0.037454024,
-0.1033097357,
-0.0082248785,
0.0097962534,
-0.0189945772,
-0.0136052733,
-0.0213396512,
-0.0204562414,
0.0057224333,
-0.0561832674,
-0.0061970656,
-0.0349794924,
-0.0210332163,
0.0356549323,
0.0117682507,
0.0134676704,
-0.0171549469,
-0.0658199638,
0.0510194115,
-0.054758139,
0.0061828787,
0.0009379446,
0.0140963029,
-0.0159959644,
0.0186415706,
-0.0226179976,
0.0383557566,
-0.0074701598,
0.0400461555,
-0.0010679142,
0.063081868,
-0.0072809062,
0.0255081411,
0.0309574995,
0.0205775779,
-0.0510634519,
-0.0009596383,
-0.038824331,
0.0351797193,
0.015632866,
0.0503554456,
0.055908639,
-0.0316871144,
0.0301351007,
-0.0019703701,
0.0522512272,
-0.0100036692,
-0.0489181727,
0.0147295129,
-0.0087667601,
-0.0259130411,
0.0133254481,
0.0595938191,
0.0343262628,
0.0229574852,
-0.0336743481,
0.0084824404,
-0.0591551065,
0.0026761391,
0.0025547252,
0.0430726819,
0.02498018,
-0.0169471577,
-0.0255984515,
-0.0409106351,
0.0315963998,
0.0235991422,
-0.003370794,
-0.0146512417,
0.0385696068,
0.018912755,
-0.0186149739,
-0.0100799287,
-0.0541478805,
0.0016601133,
-0.0446900204,
0.001471012,
-0.0309536755,
-5.997930905e-33,
-0.0570274964,
-0.0044991919,
0.0261821728,
-0.0081306528,
-0.073177509,
-0.0310046114,
-0.0390729718,
-0.015559623,
-0.0059141433,
-0.0184302293,
-0.0152782612,
0.0058313236,
0.0069737406,
0.0304393135,
-0.0220479481,
-0.007790776,
0.0868690088,
0.0097872689,
-0.0203482788,
0.063393645,
0.0399262682,
0.0327335969,
0.0132989092,
-0.0499375314,
0.0011146099,
-0.063746199,
-0.033623632,
0.0073359665,
0.0007989659,
0.0543991141,
-0.0022132522,
0.0133932503,
-0.0072391368,
0.0208369084,
-0.0172917135,
0.011210476,
-0.0696243793,
-0.0058067306,
0.0032212103,
0.0060703233,
0.004807523,
-0.0799571127,
0.0105232624,
-0.0340417549,
0.0077404389,
-0.0196890142,
0.0197417121,
-0.0048289211,
0.009076817,
-0.0303888861,
-0.0486258455,
0.0128824459,
-0.0300172344,
-0.024313163,
0.0105093988,
0.0737788901,
-0.0005863173,
-0.0454476476,
-0.0250097513,
0.0393702276,
0.0032943818,
-0.0320326388,
0.0228125565,
0.0437489785,
-0.007379917,
0.0664564967,
0.0497615896,
0.0314325318,
-0.0209546629,
-0.0124088377,
-0.0099432161,
0.0536724292,
-0.0553056113,
0.0774129704,
-0.0495237745,
-0.0159629993,
-0.0429895967,
0.0620551705,
0.086369805,
-0.0226829238,
0.0181892999,
0.006724719,
-0.0194972157,
-0.0143705886,
-0.0396884568,
-0.0330369771,
-0.0065370961,
-0.0424294472,
0.0104639549,
0.0120839616,
-0.0180488061,
-0.0333317816,
0.0255830958,
-0.025266204,
0.0030505513,
0.0220383462,
-0.0434910208,
-0.0067790649,
-0.0121307252,
0.0130960196,
-0.0235859081,
-0.0456481315,
0.0762842149,
0.011337501,
0.0288257301,
0.0000652637,
-0.0024182501,
0.0240400825,
-0.0285622738,
-0.0056305793,
-0.0274896845,
0.0691590831,
-0.041146636,
0.0404535457,
-0.0099439276,
0.0284051839,
-0.0490538999,
0.0585351549,
-0.0337687992,
0.0422582105,
-0.0287179779,
-0.0242749117,
0.0511383675,
0.0309038907,
-0.0282614846,
0.0279300753,
-0.0019981526,
0.0185196586,
0.0639271587,
-0.0047564702,
-0.0219329931,
-0.0026816193,
2.579e-7,
-0.0343164578,
-0.0019403286,
0.0485622473,
0.0292671248,
0.0147226052,
0.0508711003,
0.0173736755,
0.0416298062,
0.0043659941,
0.0021717106,
0.0370503627,
0.0137737179,
0.0718634874,
0.0291803926,
-0.0834100768,
-0.003579895,
-0.0177397225,
-0.0383004434,
-0.0351464674,
0.0110521382,
0.0837315992,
0.0239313897,
-0.0242412183,
-0.0167213548,
0.025292119,
0.0182778835,
0.0793513507,
-0.0243140031,
-0.0683068261,
0.018889077,
0.0097880093,
0.0269841552,
-0.013772618,
0.0022025062,
0.0015980665,
0.0512526631,
-0.049957104,
0.0525460169,
0.0006187852,
-0.0999560878,
-0.0037868489,
0.0413221344,
-0.0068495055,
0.0401416682,
0.0223608743,
0.0113019487,
-0.0217529219,
-0.009285029,
-0.0296015292,
0.021010818,
0.0063400236,
-0.0238865837,
-0.0395207368,
0.0232374799,
0.0151322745,
-0.0278917067,
-0.0064356602,
-0.0846936703,
0.0190162957,
-0.0023622909,
-0.080220893,
-0.0354928225,
-0.0183765404,
0.0069140629,
0.005920406,
-0.0111174947,
0.0410599858,
2.050046995e-34,
0.0130089382,
0.0125879571,
0.0121439639,
-0.0022994278,
0.0390574932,
-0.0010866245,
0.0270266924,
-0.0118970573,
0.0494093746,
-0.0812616125,
-0.0183872133
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.