id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05661v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05661v3 | Prompt Engineering a Prompt Engineer | 2023-11-09T08:00:32 | 2024-07-03T01:29:20 | Qinyuan Ye, Maxamed Axmed, Reid Pryzant, Fereshte Khani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Prompt engineering is a challenging yet crucial task for optimizing the
performance of large language models on customized tasks. It requires complex
reasoning to examine the model's errors, hypothesize what is missing or
misleading in the current prompt, and communicate the task with clarity. While
recent works indicate that large language models can be meta-prompted to
perform automatic prompt engineering, we argue that their potential is limited
due to insufficient guidance for complex reasoning in the meta-prompt. We fill
this gap by infusing into the meta-prompt three key components: detailed
descriptions, context specification, and a step-by-step reasoning template. The
resulting method, named PE2, exhibits remarkable versatility across diverse
language tasks. It finds prompts that outperform "let's think step by step" by
6.3% on MultiArith and 3.1% on GSM8K, and outperforms competitive baselines on
counterfactual tasks by 6.9%. Further, we show that PE2 can make targeted and
highly specific prompt edits, rectify erroneous prompts, and induce multi-step
plans for complex tasks. | [
0.046222467,
0.0477036424,
-0.0227328762,
0.0042663566,
-0.0602598861,
0.0192569159,
0.0226885751,
-0.0424318202,
-0.0442946181,
-0.0372972749,
-0.0020161683,
-0.0257848725,
0.0071811755,
0.0641961545,
0.0317987613,
-0.083080098,
0.0549657792,
-0.0683352798,
0.033524856,
0.0066146608,
-0.0070745288,
0.0133655118,
-0.0311891623,
0.0325663127,
0.0140788984,
-0.0617114194,
-0.0424989723,
0.0140596041,
-0.0050820494,
-0.0345817357,
-0.0113781029,
0.071522586,
-0.0044837226,
0.0295561664,
0.0000023403,
-0.0774711818,
-0.0231162626,
-0.0121770622,
-0.0734964982,
0.0127060683,
0.0057160901,
0.0059405426,
-0.0446699597,
0.022913998,
-0.0354027525,
-0.0035164447,
0.0382999554,
0.0088722063,
0.0674945191,
0.0753577128,
0.0012464017,
-0.0014313619,
-0.0295149796,
-0.0207972806,
0.0206363145,
-0.0340053923,
-0.0092225941,
-0.0351482891,
0.0530474409,
0.0388567895,
0.0005564627,
0.0364429913,
0.0548196025,
-0.0464939065,
-0.0186768491,
0.0076966081,
0.0148762101,
-0.0351339094,
-0.0400157571,
0.0398887545,
-0.0084811756,
-0.0256999116,
0.0010660535,
-0.0232604425,
0.0192814637,
-0.0164304338,
-0.0562187359,
0.0340527222,
-0.0152857006,
-0.0185083114,
-0.0041949288,
-0.0169131774,
0.0192847066,
0.0125129046,
-0.0318108983,
0.0932435766,
0.0375549532,
-0.0153685082,
-0.0070855203,
-0.0012991459,
-0.03020183,
-0.0906353965,
0.0110181225,
0.0429443493,
-0.0937235355,
0.0205804147,
-0.0202851202,
-0.0108654527,
0.0159176495,
0.0198281985,
0.0418120548,
0.0806524232,
-0.0144823557,
0.0401711203,
0.0054655015,
0.0499138609,
-0.015547758,
0.0106241824,
-0.0286085978,
0.005256115,
-0.0357911959,
-0.0094284024,
-0.0522673726,
-0.0023270741,
-0.0250505991,
0.0152132558,
-0.0176040437,
0.064513199,
-0.011627757,
0.0502268411,
0.0207588244,
-0.0036230281,
-0.0285042971,
-0.0586553551,
-0.0179038998,
0.0160077102,
-0.0628555641,
0.000016701,
0.0505439937,
-0.0438711829,
-0.0130719393,
0.0099391146,
-0.0196308438,
-0.0246125497,
-0.0347965546,
0.0484721623,
-0.0066956915,
0.0059227301,
-0.0137051148,
-0.0454309508,
-0.0153320739,
-0.0573231988,
-0.0191395581,
-0.0631503835,
0.0045125699,
0.0178343412,
-0.0242221244,
-0.0317477845,
-0.0059386706,
0.0139979785,
0.0192462299,
0.0747991279,
-0.0091055399,
0.0279594623,
0.0206699707,
0.0203232523,
-0.0584057271,
0.0716046169,
0.0271575674,
0.0104474379,
0.0300961696,
-0.0008229329,
0.0101303281,
0.0577884018,
-0.0090810889,
-0.0140276114,
-0.0155101018,
0.0050120205,
0.0177510493,
0.0218177289,
0.0107086813,
0.0348950699,
-0.0013469517,
0.0333541036,
0.0345749669,
0.0266946387,
-0.0183608942,
-0.0170431994,
0.081461519,
-0.0115886079,
-0.0184080303,
0.0057319156,
-0.0745764598,
0.0218731444,
-0.0290678609,
0.0143985758,
-0.0068361922,
0.0182873104,
-0.019809017,
-0.0420069769,
-0.0028424349,
0.0158507042,
-0.0128719369,
0.0252698064,
0.0343507379,
0.0382335633,
-0.0284312684,
0.0378850028,
-0.0015606962,
-0.0243154075,
-0.0100376401,
-0.0566523373,
0.0372140706,
0.0750099868,
0.0494234599,
-0.0345876478,
-0.0472408906,
-0.0186958518,
0.0319011956,
0.0445408672,
0.0769537538,
-0.0383618996,
-0.0282156877,
-0.0374152847,
-0.0330852605,
-0.0236059669,
0.0323140621,
0.0055609676,
0.0232488085,
-0.031939391,
0.0079419771,
-0.0132350046,
0.0157819968,
0.0125412205,
-0.0402902737,
-0.0304513108,
-0.0071851141,
0.0285295118,
-0.0087715527,
0.0252036862,
0.0261433739,
0.048299361,
0.0037157608,
-0.0095711332,
0.0012194634,
0.0031537232,
-0.0540863201,
-0.0283292998,
0.0338138305,
0.0262650512,
-0.0607432388,
-0.0029443877,
-0.0366655551,
-0.0522801355,
0.0161677133,
-0.0090824692,
0.0307532158,
-0.0140196802,
0.0598761067,
-0.0089789564,
-0.0302673988,
-0.0206843987,
0.0497954376,
0.0129999425,
-0.0181488376,
0.0828103945,
0.0352701135,
0.0043193111,
-0.0413536057,
-0.0256408453,
0.0237654261,
-0.0070789861,
-0.0235538315,
0.0073283478,
0.0271816924,
-0.0391007252,
-0.0154050197,
-0.0756087303,
0.0004214577,
-0.0493077971,
0.0236302521,
0.0395846739,
0.0367227197,
-0.014196883,
-0.0311090518,
-0.0016032946,
-0.0149962949,
0.01991871,
0.0298535805,
0.0177216884,
0.0139842322,
-0.0302718747,
-0.0242183935,
-0.0147053059,
-0.0394512191,
0.027160218,
0.0084190136,
-0.0042159162,
-0.07773491,
0.0133781759,
-0.0148049677,
0.0060445131,
0.0144802947,
0.0079857316,
0.0424587205,
-0.0359582454,
0.0757899061,
0.0467134453,
-0.0173502713,
0.0241286848,
0.0478349924,
-0.0269664396,
-0.0636712611,
0.0135780927,
-0.000778426,
-0.0163180921,
-0.0057606222,
-0.0306553431,
-0.0051387167,
0.1053656414,
-0.0183923449,
0.0036276444,
-0.0547228418,
0.0147474622,
-0.0075407852,
-0.0087362537,
-0.0255744047,
-0.0431406088,
-0.0317793265,
0.1026768461,
-0.029231526,
-0.0435652994,
0.0978765935,
-0.0111406939,
-0.0081779333,
-0.0415118821,
0.0021721942,
-0.0164085366,
0.0882114246,
-0.0237080622,
0.0025740953,
0.0348776989,
-0.0264134184,
-0.0515770316,
-0.0088280011,
0.0260868222,
-0.008255844,
0.0481501482,
-0.0991401151,
-0.0124889622,
-0.0043989122,
-0.0462701954,
-0.0548745431,
-0.012548185,
-0.0482839607,
0.033143837,
-0.0140506327,
-0.0117265461,
-0.016443884,
-0.0134799369,
0.011577718,
0.0618133768,
-0.0224632304,
-0.0156501755,
-0.0323252827,
-0.0108022606,
0.0494608507,
0.0430637822,
0.0166274253,
-0.0348302908,
0.0715516433,
0.0139461625,
0.0521683767,
-0.007559035,
-0.0295967069,
0.0096239746,
0.0269581731,
-0.0425167717,
-0.0221268497,
0.0557803623,
0.053168457,
-0.0841779709,
-0.0287961867,
0.1166197658,
0.0517579615,
-0.043928653,
0.0048825555,
-0.0426078625,
0.0459320359,
0.035692431,
0.0478783436,
-0.0830269083,
-0.0308231432,
0.0483832359,
-0.0031767229,
-0.0047576334,
-0.0168735255,
-0.0381770954,
-0.1123656258,
0.0511751026,
-0.0074325907,
-0.0171432644,
0.009032663,
-0.0339757428,
0.0130570363,
0.0140253957,
0.0167015716,
0.0382414423,
-0.0033579229,
-0.0004519682,
0.00903673,
-0.0120478189,
-0.0628669932,
0.0364084877,
-0.02137498,
0.0645638332,
0.0772361308,
-0.0227429345,
0.0163942277,
-0.0162723213,
0.0717763901,
0.0307812709,
0.0133973286,
-0.0130845271,
0.0003508953,
0.0288041364,
-0.0161402337,
-0.0141488528,
0.0258489568,
-0.0251035746,
-0.0717392266,
0.0310370009,
0.1284376681,
-0.0380176939,
0.0145295002,
0.0021247291,
-0.0000373219,
0.0314614214,
0.0538450815,
0.0505033359,
-0.059864033,
-0.0335487314,
-0.0601564683,
-0.0381566994,
-0.0763045177,
-0.0102012195,
0.0101530738,
0.0300149769,
-0.0095285829,
-0.0539068505,
-0.0417081602,
0.067142576,
0.0558287315,
0.0314396881,
-0.0311759412,
-0.0001940305,
-0.0122746769,
-0.0274297353,
0.0348729752,
-0.0196032822,
0.0434498154,
-0.0660028681,
-0.0045698588,
-0.0080405753,
-0.0321927629,
0.0029582724,
-0.0027895723,
-0.0416842848,
-0.0746143907,
0.0038579176,
0.068652913,
0.0360923819,
0.0366212763,
-0.0484147929,
-0.0709059536,
0.0085488195,
-0.010765532,
-0.052526135,
-0.0280925073,
0.029504912,
0.0178967547,
-0.0086283227,
0.0410797633,
-0.0356486849,
0.0088522518,
-0.0032724342,
0.0541422702,
-0.0115938205,
-0.050671611,
0.0473329015,
0.0222701505,
0.0422643423,
-0.0224500857,
-0.0211577881,
-0.0442499742,
0.0214730836,
-0.0271155685,
-0.0338781066,
-0.0314227864,
0.0392863676,
-0.0100645479,
-0.0327115208,
0.0283481348,
-0.0003000917,
-0.038929034,
0.0222069044,
-0.0274144989,
0.0363188125,
-0.0182298124,
0.0283361394,
0.0351504423,
-0.0003079732,
-0.005529684,
0.0335201211,
0.0030006533,
0.0330133326,
-0.0238912255,
0.0814940035,
0.0115604568,
-0.0017635315,
-0.0352230966,
0.0238257926,
-0.0508981124,
-0.0760725141,
0.0330613889,
0.0201433823,
0.023997521,
0.0127145424,
0.0119681647,
-0.033864826,
-0.0208013132,
-0.0036848392,
0.0274527986,
0.0445251837,
-0.0385644212,
0.0230576247,
0.0427024364,
0.00701456,
-0.0274198186,
0.019097982,
-0.0676371753,
0.0548300408,
-0.0053443722,
0.0037541266,
-0.0433750376,
-0.034049429,
-0.0250138808,
0.0090836948,
-0.0549597889,
-0.0077355495,
-0.085604541,
-0.0627840757,
-0.016010832,
0.0338043235,
-0.0339689516,
0.0031113299,
0.0537631102,
0.0578307547,
-0.0161244571,
-0.0137408441,
-0.0274115484,
0.0093199667,
-0.000679074,
-0.0331447497,
-0.0223337002,
-6.280603134e-33,
-0.0275580473,
-0.0349499658,
0.0610731244,
-0.0222089477,
0.0170228351,
-0.0249269437,
-0.0838625804,
0.0350827314,
0.0049228515,
0.0130894352,
-0.0391252451,
-0.0033220709,
0.0189486928,
0.0072886581,
0.0306678023,
0.0146612376,
0.0586997867,
0.0027288827,
-0.0586321466,
0.0029285601,
0.0173290726,
0.0096948883,
0.0314336307,
-0.0119710444,
0.0554097146,
0.0208851211,
-0.042352844,
0.0540611111,
-0.0463671312,
0.0649418905,
-0.000146814,
0.0119951749,
0.0077307578,
-0.0515309572,
-0.0477172509,
0.0451524369,
-0.0448233075,
-0.0342042148,
0.0440527834,
0.0073846891,
-0.0646880344,
-0.0501816794,
-0.0100849159,
-0.0268553738,
-0.0141980825,
0.0049433331,
0.0069891191,
-0.006728481,
0.0075738151,
0.0398684852,
-0.0748828053,
0.017212851,
-0.013726294,
-0.0360495336,
0.0331634693,
0.0404150672,
-0.0102451043,
-0.0033235494,
0.0132129043,
0.029057214,
0.0200305134,
0.0121783763,
0.0751128718,
0.0083820019,
-0.0220356733,
0.0292446073,
0.0418057516,
0.0217583012,
-0.0136437397,
0.0080047324,
0.0116819413,
0.0306009278,
0.0436236672,
0.0406740457,
0.011969734,
0.0094526354,
-0.0123716509,
0.023703685,
0.0266460665,
0.0288777072,
0.0082967505,
0.0028053229,
-0.0154553829,
-0.0199418217,
-0.0545401387,
0.0090152994,
-0.0571133308,
-0.0210632812,
0.0451507755,
-0.0089704646,
-0.0304603651,
0.0035078228,
0.0321947299,
-0.005111509,
-0.0043613557,
0.0091834571,
-0.0161004532,
0.0371741764,
-0.0007488012,
0.0444498025,
-0.004968307,
-0.0005433664,
0.0277294498,
0.0012150422,
0.0168458987,
0.0313845426,
0.0090032574,
0.0534752384,
-0.0633527189,
0.0162733626,
-0.068483904,
0.0277546141,
0.0039550047,
0.0046707736,
0.0183866676,
0.0018295475,
-0.0207821745,
0.0346557237,
0.0059637227,
-0.0604552403,
-0.0368835963,
0.0521160141,
-0.0059564491,
0.0174507331,
-0.0277248938,
-0.0077973255,
-0.0228787493,
0.0383161455,
0.0259642731,
-0.013600125,
-0.0103884097,
0.0262468774,
2.934e-7,
0.0495085679,
0.0340719484,
0.0173417386,
0.0449460708,
0.0114139579,
0.0164909568,
-0.0232884865,
-0.0246067867,
0.0044497554,
-0.0223436747,
0.0125152068,
0.028479971,
0.0379495695,
0.0302644111,
-0.0716369152,
0.0248522218,
-0.036711257,
0.0169949066,
-0.0705230981,
0.0091178985,
0.0614590198,
0.0672805309,
0.003449918,
0.0005362217,
0.0063109281,
0.0113980277,
0.0148532512,
-0.0322924592,
0.0100023197,
0.0203948542,
-0.0088428436,
-0.0195983537,
0.0051985499,
0.0245456118,
-0.0199423283,
-0.0174301602,
-0.0092427926,
0.0876580998,
0.0157007687,
0.0043615955,
-0.0116761178,
-0.0271907244,
0.0049969326,
-0.0624351539,
0.052078288,
-0.0331296027,
-0.01015855,
-0.0443425365,
0.0130467182,
-0.0135400137,
-0.0131709902,
-0.0261390731,
-0.0046897773,
0.0148365097,
0.0105104093,
0.0103311427,
-0.0208781809,
-0.0687530115,
-0.0360451601,
0.0218914319,
-0.0296072718,
-0.0301331133,
-0.0474207029,
-0.0101174805,
0.0195293799,
-0.0741219074,
0.0065809628,
2.924277526e-34,
0.0417912155,
0.0083093271,
0.0256394185,
0.0310636591,
0.0326298885,
0.0061893743,
-0.0323152579,
0.0371665508,
0.0640161708,
-0.0767644569,
-0.0643963739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05169v1 | Large Language Models and Prompt Engineering for Biomedical Query Focused Multi-Document Summarisation | 2023-11-09T06:45:04 | 2023-11-09T06:45:04 | Diego Mollá | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper reports on the use of prompt engineering and GPT-3.5 for
biomedical query-focused multi-document summarisation. Using GPT-3.5 and
appropriate prompts, our system achieves top ROUGE-F1 results in the task of
obtaining short-paragraph-sized answers to biomedical questions in the 2023
BioASQ Challenge (BioASQ 11b). This paper confirms what has been observed in
other domains: 1) Prompts that incorporated few-shot samples generally improved
on their counterpart zero-shot variants; 2) The largest improvement was
achieved by retrieval augmented generation. The fact that these prompts allow
our top runs to rank within the top two runs of BioASQ 11b demonstrate the
power of using adequate prompts for Large Language Models in general, and
GPT-3.5 in particular, for query-focused summarisation. | [
0.0555509478,
0.0296028387,
0.026062604,
-0.0298268329,
-0.0210063551,
-0.0129233506,
0.0017802484,
0.02597351,
-0.0070422334,
-0.0281620733,
0.0056084297,
-0.0464541242,
-0.0045025665,
0.0332823209,
0.0352391377,
-0.0677362904,
0.0354328752,
0.0013409752,
-0.0010530557,
-0.0174369533,
-0.0028478317,
-0.0071460856,
0.0137220873,
0.022844879,
0.0541754365,
-0.0299484599,
-0.0081185885,
-0.0005222617,
0.0283646286,
-0.0337051898,
-0.0101862773,
0.0232851822,
0.0101811737,
0.003924971,
0.0000019432,
-0.0694950223,
-0.0472753681,
0.0355033241,
-0.0266776681,
0.0370404832,
-0.0050901775,
0.0032598197,
0.010033682,
0.0035037494,
-0.0011420574,
0.0004372124,
0.02608574,
0.031547375,
0.0731742531,
0.0589630716,
0.0111639528,
-0.0023363531,
0.0475028194,
-0.0246711913,
0.0583595335,
-0.0384561829,
0.0108729005,
-0.0489072129,
0.1172276959,
0.0412851386,
0.0199284591,
0.0331102498,
0.0010461273,
-0.0171490386,
0.0115635796,
0.0527493544,
-0.0236098282,
-0.0136178313,
0.0059583397,
0.0455363728,
0.0280756373,
0.0058066752,
0.0358332135,
0.0070506367,
-0.0001617777,
0.0122586004,
-0.1058876216,
0.0286679864,
-0.0345820785,
-0.0316873193,
0.0032318293,
0.0095565645,
-0.0040620817,
0.0014878371,
-0.0413832925,
0.031188637,
0.0381359346,
-0.0458020158,
-0.0264003053,
-0.0155849215,
-0.0094838841,
-0.0232803784,
0.0123826209,
0.0384315848,
-0.0606741011,
-0.0243957788,
0.0056360043,
-0.0380893648,
0.0733747333,
0.0106507111,
0.0153791523,
-0.0034016818,
0.0012745454,
0.034509141,
0.0027093699,
0.0350108333,
-0.0075409068,
0.0186480414,
-0.0619052313,
0.0079508657,
-0.0310077574,
-0.019165948,
-0.0464990474,
0.0477232151,
-0.0368007012,
0.004992249,
-0.0694450662,
0.0155750616,
0.0334984586,
-0.0122030433,
0.0035133008,
0.0269775968,
-0.0681687817,
0.0124991415,
0.0028956814,
0.027642699,
-0.0239042211,
-0.0642712191,
0.0246753953,
-0.0622289963,
-0.0422595814,
0.0063958415,
0.0193410888,
-0.039182961,
0.0018562017,
0.0419334136,
-0.0253898054,
-0.0298402049,
0.0272758044,
-0.0454698727,
-0.024363691,
-0.0421209596,
-0.0109174764,
-0.0573674329,
0.0339244977,
0.0077948729,
-0.0086929221,
0.0192219205,
0.0184334945,
0.0355948359,
-0.0446466357,
0.0309351906,
-0.0112784067,
-0.0085764332,
0.0425540805,
0.0125118652,
0.0128545268,
0.0340804793,
-0.0038048204,
0.0238216985,
0.013897527,
0.0049060164,
0.0050520208,
-0.0025412468,
0.0331146121,
-0.0142479911,
0.0335792303,
0.0277282186,
0.0532799028,
0.037120685,
-0.0016336095,
0.0832724869,
-0.0074036126,
0.0197788831,
0.0194789302,
0.0710361972,
0.0177206937,
-0.0386049226,
0.0319730341,
-0.003289439,
0.0212133285,
0.0414292403,
-0.0110749658,
0.0147049213,
-0.0265904106,
0.0542580672,
0.0671959445,
0.0470815673,
-0.0177164059,
-0.0080813197,
0.0071862936,
0.0439898185,
-0.0509802923,
0.0025286833,
0.0379110128,
-0.0190611836,
-0.0455180854,
-0.0041362378,
0.0080480352,
-0.0555521771,
0.0346265994,
-0.0513627306,
0.0042722877,
0.0255670343,
0.0659047365,
-0.0457513891,
-0.0169895347,
-0.0099988542,
0.000765744,
0.0224075001,
0.0496303812,
-0.0212244727,
-0.0123245129,
-0.0396670513,
-0.0036016814,
-0.0027241292,
-0.0158915594,
-0.0146280434,
-0.0122840637,
0.0015178317,
0.0221638698,
0.0057209395,
-0.0188986044,
0.0135651464,
-0.0515034236,
-0.0292970911,
-0.0089088269,
-0.0148622729,
0.0321186483,
0.0320162103,
-0.0207211841,
0.0568554401,
0.044271633,
-0.027764339,
-0.0013334482,
-0.0405111313,
-0.0169963334,
-0.0420124121,
0.007186594,
-0.0256349333,
0.0089947395,
-0.0092057884,
-0.0208260752,
-0.0479552969,
-0.0359069817,
-0.0647835135,
-0.0195155423,
-0.0304667838,
0.0057361247,
0.0300669633,
-0.0237445049,
-0.0717245415,
0.0491493531,
0.0317826122,
0.0301822685,
0.0830849707,
-0.0371993184,
0.0197461545,
-0.1023596078,
0.0072165243,
0.0480832122,
0.034276966,
-0.0016809707,
0.0547396094,
0.0341447331,
-0.038300097,
-0.0169916358,
-0.0941433534,
0.0126071144,
0.002271007,
0.0003977905,
0.0200409535,
0.0487291738,
-0.0035710896,
-0.0032748957,
-0.0705176741,
-0.0487392955,
0.0437017567,
0.0391037315,
0.0438926779,
0.0425501578,
0.0255600475,
-0.040990226,
-0.0352214538,
-0.026001893,
0.0433546416,
0.0355666652,
-0.0284520984,
-0.0056971544,
0.0180829484,
-0.0312903821,
-0.0140374005,
0.0163291618,
0.0049052285,
0.0185375325,
-0.0522181988,
0.0598362535,
0.0386625528,
0.0434389152,
-0.0040000654,
0.0285796393,
0.0049450891,
-0.0266211051,
0.0224060155,
-0.0368788093,
-0.0229795426,
0.0536124706,
-0.0359169915,
0.0454641618,
0.0262527559,
0.0175184049,
-0.0179701094,
-0.0550829619,
0.0308305956,
-0.0087890569,
-0.0127575826,
-0.0924916714,
0.0100916373,
-0.0323809348,
0.0532221273,
-0.0072498363,
-0.0206797998,
0.09825138,
-0.0234120321,
0.0142745497,
-0.0736991391,
0.0153712304,
-0.0338518918,
0.0333671123,
0.0179042071,
0.0386492945,
0.0092468783,
-0.001196573,
-0.0425138809,
-0.0002735532,
0.0038207448,
-0.0453198068,
0.0433718935,
-0.0415778868,
0.0220224094,
-0.0224705767,
-0.0543964729,
-0.009617216,
-0.0194496345,
0.0078715645,
0.0167915393,
0.0080690905,
-0.0052977223,
-0.0372384563,
0.0298861656,
0.0694568455,
0.0452688597,
-0.060133338,
-0.0152729414,
-0.0131070847,
0.057979688,
0.0793123841,
-0.0021527228,
0.004770631,
-0.064435713,
0.0343634523,
0.0581599735,
0.0459407456,
0.0067217457,
0.0759038627,
-0.0029569124,
0.0251199547,
-0.0669053122,
-0.0447076671,
0.024705166,
0.0429689474,
-0.0533048324,
-0.0229268875,
0.075740248,
0.0454864278,
-0.0283662602,
-0.0084732408,
0.0008366909,
0.0206800904,
-0.0052122329,
0.0849171057,
-0.0782805011,
0.0095821768,
0.0111741032,
0.0589659885,
-0.0250918828,
-0.0203393809,
-0.0226287991,
-0.0917468518,
0.0672974139,
0.0141038345,
-0.066072315,
-0.0163718145,
-0.0390978083,
-0.0046154526,
0.009160771,
-0.0053216843,
0.0728334188,
-0.0270663202,
0.023099808,
0.0135170389,
0.0120884627,
-0.0125960307,
-0.010064411,
-0.0148159983,
0.0053945202,
0.0722043365,
0.0066219093,
-0.0069780182,
-0.0055804034,
0.0210167374,
-0.0579462387,
-0.0017632704,
-0.013948869,
0.0411709808,
0.019864196,
-0.0140582593,
-0.0433409773,
0.0238394868,
0.0182642918,
-0.0058466201,
0.0223764163,
0.0900137275,
-0.0098477742,
-0.0176214874,
-0.0661151633,
0.0123768328,
-0.0433404557,
0.0670070574,
0.0401439965,
-0.0238758344,
-0.047087118,
-0.0342801064,
0.0329897329,
-0.0523752831,
-0.0281605478,
0.0081737777,
-0.0561243854,
-0.0164016373,
-0.0573423915,
-0.0495199263,
0.0523174331,
0.0272459686,
-0.0159025025,
0.0160367005,
-0.0406993777,
0.019239407,
-0.01977106,
0.0176361687,
0.0158568751,
0.0028769283,
-0.0797827169,
-0.0325525515,
0.0879033133,
-0.0271258205,
-0.0275897551,
0.0230819378,
0.005423618,
-0.0436899513,
-0.0234954637,
0.0460182652,
0.0278691389,
-0.0269585531,
0.0065961909,
-0.0119142374,
0.0656786337,
0.0676578954,
-0.013204773,
0.0203548837,
-0.0466380045,
-0.0016967889,
-0.0506517924,
-0.0024067734,
-0.0644294471,
0.0195138101,
-0.0357817374,
0.0839625373,
0.0319481678,
-0.0472698547,
0.0559313446,
0.1023645476,
0.0285377931,
-0.0202385839,
-0.0072715799,
-0.0248616263,
-0.0053027528,
-0.0447164141,
0.0006961307,
-0.0198419485,
0.0221179593,
-0.0182873439,
-0.0083994158,
0.0170869641,
0.0088490611,
-0.0473599993,
0.0440860242,
-0.0751240328,
-0.0099564036,
-0.0123352204,
-0.0083782589,
0.0381342769,
-0.0270348731,
-0.0205001216,
-0.00299462,
-0.0208844654,
0.0299647581,
-0.0372693911,
0.0213069357,
0.0329962522,
0.0092313392,
-0.0051569156,
0.0266722459,
-0.1096581891,
-0.0051595876,
-0.0404156074,
0.0199174229,
0.0177542865,
0.0204300229,
0.0155027211,
0.0273189321,
-0.0241594743,
-0.0440516919,
0.0233708192,
0.0446327068,
0.0181090515,
0.015054943,
0.0390747786,
0.0063121133,
-0.0450143479,
0.0866088569,
0.0040473128,
0.0268209092,
0.0205576178,
-0.0342670605,
-0.039221283,
-0.0445444658,
-0.0133820772,
0.0323882103,
-0.0088923583,
-0.0285610221,
-0.0848085284,
-0.0014174366,
0.0390871391,
0.0235162992,
-0.0224029813,
-0.0072099306,
0.0636285171,
0.0278953966,
0.0121515933,
-0.0501788966,
-0.034691412,
0.0651909634,
-0.0193673801,
-0.0579967685,
0.0440637209,
-6.187896302e-33,
-0.0215447024,
-0.0047228648,
0.0047565601,
-0.009706229,
-0.0398362391,
0.0061635729,
-0.0614640489,
-0.0270818602,
0.0203840174,
-0.0029637346,
-0.063291423,
-0.0207510665,
0.0038367428,
0.031610731,
-0.0154567454,
0.0029715081,
0.0279605091,
-0.0174615309,
-0.0377208032,
0.0593018793,
0.0178376678,
0.0352783352,
0.0046969689,
0.021659717,
0.0153430896,
-0.0080368044,
0.0095203882,
0.0015335715,
-0.0137436902,
0.0317288227,
-0.0106042977,
0.0313944593,
0.0180354752,
-0.0566504933,
-0.0095560951,
-0.0076553528,
-0.052781418,
-0.0258920826,
0.0327526927,
-0.069915019,
-0.0544724427,
-0.0617200844,
0.0055087931,
-0.0442936644,
-0.004191082,
-0.039831154,
0.0297952946,
-0.0185920037,
-0.0432708338,
-0.0695251524,
-0.0106698265,
0.0148130776,
-0.0069601517,
0.0214205328,
-0.0057409485,
0.0553118512,
-0.0097769191,
0.0579043441,
0.032238774,
0.0463759787,
0.0664897114,
0.0556099154,
0.0152226835,
0.0126154432,
0.0077464236,
0.0331518203,
0.02863786,
-0.0114232115,
-0.0079676295,
-0.0043696291,
-0.0406284928,
-0.0345920138,
0.0189274158,
0.0332688987,
0.0245341752,
0.0407395959,
-0.0790905282,
0.0946920589,
-0.0240388773,
0.0043320898,
0.0123294499,
-0.0348938331,
0.0032370938,
-0.0268618204,
-0.0303865261,
0.0251038373,
-0.0291894637,
-0.0208571404,
0.0223954562,
-0.0231852587,
-0.0501190685,
-0.0081895692,
0.0338411443,
-0.0048404913,
0.0028139059,
-0.00361618,
0.0024890008,
0.0122928498,
-0.02509683,
0.0109303659,
-0.026935691,
0.0422718227,
0.0389560983,
0.0155877601,
0.0100417538,
0.0084303347,
-0.0190462675,
0.0144225806,
-0.0456912704,
-0.0096247569,
-0.0089480821,
0.0208909567,
-0.0213540513,
0.0092800623,
-0.0113132959,
0.0109910304,
0.0327584371,
0.0499396883,
0.0039305477,
-0.0283671301,
-0.022303747,
-0.0042333198,
0.0257234462,
0.0346715413,
-0.0233845469,
0.0481550545,
-0.025350567,
0.0837025493,
0.0047913515,
-0.0302329678,
-0.0108067803,
0.0063671535,
2.708e-7,
0.0544009469,
0.0249682274,
0.0530287102,
0.0090852259,
-0.0082835434,
-0.01183738,
0.00034475,
0.0192816425,
-0.0076164412,
-0.0002442048,
0.0291527826,
0.0065418035,
0.0059344638,
0.0030027863,
-0.1144748479,
-0.0031942558,
-0.0970967561,
-0.027328575,
-0.0674996451,
-0.0195782036,
0.0497407392,
0.0567777194,
-0.0444558673,
-0.0248872023,
0.0093772821,
-0.0000353076,
0.0194048379,
0.0007560583,
-0.0499361791,
0.0476465635,
0.0305732787,
-0.0316321775,
0.020479396,
-0.0002087445,
0.0004148391,
-0.0406895243,
0.0414036401,
0.0484723262,
0.0003825748,
0.004007197,
0.053556446,
0.0154599259,
0.0491889007,
-0.0323967785,
0.0429166593,
-0.0205310173,
-0.0071826302,
-0.0043068756,
-0.0321644433,
-0.043430876,
0.0098757045,
-0.0399919525,
-0.0386375412,
0.0536803789,
-0.0172700007,
0.0244191196,
0.0092982408,
-0.0435913317,
-0.0194868278,
0.0070036729,
-0.0272397008,
-0.0835016966,
-0.0113157099,
-0.0088206455,
-0.0225356966,
-0.088457197,
-0.03234208,
2.849112009e-34,
0.0676437169,
-0.0201481171,
-0.019762747,
-0.0104513038,
0.0177579448,
-0.030925341,
-0.0031450973,
0.0104060424,
0.0360419564,
-0.0944466442,
-0.061604064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05161v1 | Enhancing Computation Efficiency in Large Language Models through Weight and Activation Quantization | 2023-11-09T06:19:51 | 2023-11-09T06:19:51 | Jangwhan Lee, Minsoo Kim, Seungcheol Baek, Seok Joong Hwang, Wonyong Sung, Jungwook Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are proficient in natural language processing
tasks, but their deployment is often restricted by extensive parameter sizes
and computational demands. This paper focuses on post-training quantization
(PTQ) in LLMs, specifically 4-bit weight and 8-bit activation (W4A8)
quantization, to enhance computational efficiency -- a topic less explored
compared to weight-only quantization. We present two innovative techniques:
activation-quantization-aware scaling (AQAS) and sequence-length-aware
calibration (SLAC) to enhance PTQ by considering the combined effects on
weights and activations and aligning calibration sequence lengths to target
tasks. Moreover, we introduce dINT, a hybrid data format combining integer and
denormal representations, to address the underflow issue in W4A8 quantization,
where small values are rounded to zero. Through rigorous evaluations of LLMs,
including OPT and LLaMA, we demonstrate that our techniques significantly boost
task accuracies to levels comparable with full-precision models. By developing
arithmetic units compatible with dINT, we further confirm that our methods
yield a 2$\times$ hardware efficiency improvement compared to 8-bit integer MAC
unit. | [
-0.0155960592,
0.041257374,
-0.0018945726,
0.0331410244,
-0.007681929,
0.0076492848,
0.0281448662,
-0.0093353083,
-0.026482163,
-0.0610577315,
-0.0138028655,
-0.0798795298,
-0.0079243155,
0.0216164179,
0.0176203512,
0.0131601403,
0.0631856322,
-0.0333947539,
0.0042522205,
-0.0039204699,
-0.00118604,
-0.0115563609,
-0.0002104269,
0.0221745018,
0.0079563372,
-0.0074354685,
-0.0079225684,
0.00503628,
-0.0005251055,
-0.0352832526,
-0.0012341135,
0.0512122028,
0.0368580818,
0.0366884544,
0.0000021983,
-0.0126484083,
0.0091666495,
0.0057332083,
-0.068134509,
0.0488534085,
0.0584336109,
-0.0357909128,
-0.0161920711,
0.0327478237,
0.000596369,
-0.0122306738,
0.0621850304,
0.0049443408,
0.0265310667,
0.0754974931,
-0.0005923153,
-0.0531725064,
0.0570487715,
-0.0133207394,
-0.0154952751,
-0.0199521873,
0.0107065486,
0.0843844041,
-0.0055331523,
0.0134618031,
-0.0077305404,
0.0106397336,
0.0148423417,
0.0007565117,
-0.0136779556,
0.0157923177,
-0.0506272279,
0.0184815265,
-0.0276179984,
0.034216594,
-0.0533493012,
-0.0299011953,
-0.0150466682,
-0.0031024236,
-0.036244005,
-0.107581526,
-0.0316193029,
0.005717461,
0.0616547726,
0.0367323048,
-0.0213059057,
-0.0040616258,
0.0484662987,
0.0072799721,
-0.0354546271,
0.0613727607,
0.0130316652,
0.0022652673,
-0.0314231217,
-0.0274457615,
-0.0923183486,
-0.0518861562,
0.0217725392,
0.018630879,
-0.0056656129,
-0.0014769202,
-0.0678936392,
-0.0329681821,
0.0033621069,
-0.0588788092,
0.0256680958,
0.0862531886,
-0.00693308,
0.0070100725,
-0.0256671309,
0.0803963766,
-0.0284694452,
0.0053104945,
-0.0473351181,
0.0100392038,
-0.0255055707,
0.0010518949,
-0.0423841141,
0.034756124,
-0.0454929397,
-0.0438375622,
-0.0807963386,
0.0183922537,
-0.00210841,
-0.0377672687,
0.0394562893,
0.0206771605,
-0.0289075058,
-0.0169773139,
-0.0072644083,
0.0533695817,
-0.0031603314,
0.0200563259,
-0.0167704988,
-0.0466269404,
-0.004002471,
0.0123787588,
0.0120572234,
-0.0513458699,
0.032337375,
0.0123837925,
0.0068622921,
-0.0644800514,
-0.0257968847,
-0.008166031,
-0.026254639,
-0.0500008948,
-0.0519769005,
-0.0651664957,
0.0120184375,
0.0041143694,
-0.0078384457,
-0.0189902056,
0.0390066244,
0.0234539211,
0.0011999391,
0.0733342022,
-0.0056637642,
-0.0071949381,
-0.0217996202,
-0.0147707378,
0.0502358712,
0.0867072418,
0.06907399,
0.0259417538,
-0.0094687436,
0.0075896112,
-0.0265603941,
0.0434508361,
0.0061426735,
-0.0231374521,
-0.0419812426,
-0.0177025478,
-0.0114156967,
0.0456780232,
0.0903329849,
0.0839356109,
-0.0537777729,
-0.0216416642,
0.0413031168,
0.0238546282,
0.0201003626,
0.0116662709,
-0.0080864001,
0.0018724641,
-0.0118461009,
-0.0414347164,
-0.0449400581,
0.0174149219,
-0.0217151847,
0.0019144579,
0.060533341,
0.0580900945,
-0.0080941543,
-0.0232695006,
-0.0376004986,
-0.0170475654,
0.0249152519,
0.0018501707,
0.010648312,
-0.0258883946,
-0.0032242963,
0.1080421209,
0.0200761314,
-0.043402411,
-0.0179024432,
-0.0546213724,
-0.0400955938,
0.0486890785,
0.0350314379,
0.0028712691,
0.0123745566,
0.0204292182,
-0.0053450502,
0.0085654166,
0.0084965872,
-0.0014639272,
-0.0103190457,
-0.0720562935,
-0.0171228014,
-0.0059953462,
-0.0134600345,
0.0012181633,
0.0288321432,
0.021465132,
0.0123151187,
-0.0526367761,
-0.0544467494,
0.0166038051,
0.0287009981,
-0.0897566676,
0.0427284949,
-0.0173913836,
0.0151068484,
0.0370785743,
-0.0076720738,
0.0147124277,
0.0257535465,
-0.0352735929,
0.0044192909,
-0.0392470136,
-0.0219710972,
-0.0020249125,
0.088738285,
0.0335792266,
0.0599867031,
0.0476144962,
-0.0166101251,
-0.0587572008,
0.0384302437,
-0.0337026305,
0.0261918306,
-0.048840072,
0.0409880579,
-0.0129917841,
0.038351234,
-0.0468394756,
0.0275084712,
-0.0215007607,
0.0084812418,
-0.0042978511,
0.0108093219,
0.0042225285,
-0.0164455064,
-0.0384062044,
-0.0088085998,
0.0376488566,
0.0271456465,
0.0032642582,
-0.0340267904,
0.0039646048,
-0.0078557506,
-0.1354916394,
0.0117190871,
-0.0523588136,
0.0512482896,
0.030980764,
0.0462313741,
0.0280447826,
0.006992335,
-0.0607596152,
-0.0179717746,
-0.0172677841,
0.0215484947,
-0.0075721587,
0.0020898371,
-0.0143984882,
-0.0352504775,
-0.0406813584,
-0.0116391908,
0.0260340422,
-0.0255588479,
-0.0050936583,
-0.0775385052,
-0.0032545228,
-0.0084942244,
0.051583156,
-0.0106929094,
-0.0188572537,
-0.0108781084,
0.0144616785,
0.0025943285,
0.0323808044,
-0.0121610053,
0.0026034345,
0.0712227523,
0.0284329969,
-0.0427015163,
0.0390730277,
0.0024356041,
-0.0388515182,
-0.0217490718,
-0.0153785264,
-0.0298899133,
0.0801286623,
-0.0384974517,
-0.0149777383,
-0.0088881617,
-0.0058776257,
-0.0117604388,
-0.0212820806,
-0.0232423544,
-0.0134798838,
-0.037547309,
0.0365909263,
0.0007546359,
-0.0558189005,
0.0093979379,
-0.0435157493,
-0.0132621024,
-0.0535065122,
-0.0137708932,
-0.0114390189,
0.07709907,
0.0502085499,
0.0253990944,
-0.0158687234,
-0.0068386067,
-0.0262296069,
0.0042275973,
-0.0181020275,
-0.0478282087,
0.0523263738,
-0.018098494,
0.0536512397,
-0.0410686657,
-0.02248675,
-0.0023842282,
0.0041039018,
-0.0302059632,
0.0507076494,
0.0312901475,
-0.0445621908,
0.007887587,
0.0709219649,
0.0097199073,
0.0343219042,
-0.0285972562,
0.0191878341,
-0.0383614525,
0.0425775871,
0.0503605083,
0.0092913583,
0.0428204648,
0.0154210366,
-0.0298004933,
0.006684056,
0.0147729013,
0.0448333994,
-0.0721755996,
-0.0140573001,
0.0456810445,
-0.0133136688,
-0.0116250925,
0.0287462883,
0.065680638,
-0.0527407974,
0.0086056963,
0.101786688,
0.0380348228,
-0.0513275005,
0.0288354605,
0.0031103371,
0.0091797486,
0.022434365,
0.015194078,
-0.1136848852,
-0.0358899534,
0.0223978423,
0.000173951,
-0.0104357312,
0.001772373,
-0.006948268,
-0.0804781392,
0.0044334875,
0.0397947617,
0.0091901254,
-0.022540953,
-0.0144086527,
-0.0148072662,
-0.030721182,
0.0862022638,
0.0449582376,
0.0068677268,
-0.0020955536,
0.0348828137,
0.016073741,
-0.0518574864,
0.0400497504,
-0.0108614294,
0.0758584291,
0.0443838984,
0.0144911557,
-0.0087314965,
-0.0169208776,
0.0355305262,
0.0193925723,
0.002984544,
0.0260539465,
0.0005228361,
0.021078011,
-0.0175135713,
0.0056916773,
-0.0111351497,
-0.0128471944,
-0.0037638075,
-0.0467728376,
0.0591944754,
-0.015514262,
0.0144956131,
0.0008861264,
-0.0616779253,
-0.00534746,
0.0505813509,
0.0176072866,
-0.0030224647,
-0.0607694127,
-0.0150705231,
-0.0200526938,
-0.0408324227,
-0.040690165,
-0.0129372803,
-0.0027315957,
-0.0623735078,
-0.0319454707,
-0.0068823141,
0.0136616016,
0.0122056725,
-0.0084911436,
-0.0301432684,
0.0294308588,
0.0099739563,
-0.0782180876,
0.021775879,
-0.0629538894,
0.0482228212,
-0.051537741,
0.0007115789,
0.0172951389,
0.0046291603,
-0.006433642,
0.0190038998,
-0.1393216848,
-0.0720928162,
0.0029014072,
-0.0011228654,
0.0170095004,
0.0151091311,
0.0028695276,
-0.0835562944,
0.042596329,
0.0615812056,
-0.0537549779,
0.0440784581,
-0.0092744352,
0.0017867775,
-0.0065554865,
0.0196866263,
-0.0078126602,
0.0474320799,
-0.0092496574,
0.0709650591,
-0.0454995781,
-0.0476026684,
0.0078535937,
0.0197169539,
0.0481726676,
0.0184305124,
0.006815474,
0.0289908741,
0.0327382423,
-0.0422702879,
0.0147877634,
-0.0285649672,
-0.0099844337,
0.0187083222,
0.0204469617,
-0.0208141785,
-0.0167370941,
0.0081501985,
-0.0255359374,
0.0180914719,
0.0025802932,
-0.0443475172,
0.0339944735,
0.0334274471,
-0.0215492044,
-0.0335417762,
0.0036682095,
0.0235595368,
0.0469665565,
-0.0254008286,
-0.0015972977,
-0.0182414576,
0.0137432134,
-0.069360666,
0.0350761861,
-0.0199295804,
-0.0111900475,
-0.0437044427,
-0.0232149325,
0.0484755337,
0.0128679052,
0.0462142304,
0.0006554502,
-0.0218967162,
-0.0281469617,
-0.0049003833,
0.0095690237,
0.0022248018,
0.038681481,
0.0292722303,
-0.0274697971,
-0.0063047032,
0.0398308747,
-0.0215926971,
0.0315742083,
-0.0051400466,
-0.0149650984,
0.0200778022,
-0.0569565445,
-0.0585276335,
0.0420685112,
-0.0399018265,
-0.0173055269,
-0.0213043634,
-0.0416650549,
0.0136336824,
0.016505735,
-0.006460154,
-0.0495054647,
0.0257976372,
0.020586919,
-0.0147055089,
-0.0491295606,
-0.0215520151,
-0.0380057767,
0.000686941,
0.0051926933,
-0.0345038772,
-6.487878787e-33,
-0.0152624529,
0.025477631,
0.0388501585,
-0.02859056,
-0.0279116295,
0.0323975831,
0.0049931649,
0.0319130346,
-0.0071303146,
-0.0261695962,
-0.0134083703,
0.0112124877,
0.0303269625,
0.0116594015,
0.0056269914,
0.0184198432,
0.0669610873,
-0.0342792235,
-0.0092546903,
0.0210996773,
0.0052439515,
0.0004219938,
0.0510955825,
0.002959013,
-0.0143965501,
0.051735945,
0.0042852126,
-0.0006243656,
0.0424842574,
0.0234903079,
-0.0443303734,
0.0611431934,
0.0130123142,
-0.0082529727,
-0.019232275,
-0.0112764509,
-0.0483657308,
-0.0051650079,
0.0471963584,
0.0461121723,
0.0158825275,
-0.0309239738,
0.0611172095,
0.0166535079,
-0.059163589,
-0.0062494446,
-0.0217340738,
-0.015965391,
-0.0253031012,
-0.0479937047,
-0.0239377767,
0.0243931413,
0.0424322784,
0.0228194986,
0.0589415394,
-0.0150993634,
-0.0384822227,
-0.0062010959,
-0.0827202946,
-0.0192866214,
0.0476982407,
0.0976589844,
0.0483815633,
0.0606325604,
0.0166061688,
0.0413221978,
0.0604012534,
-0.0305964183,
-0.0445489064,
0.0546807274,
0.064459756,
-0.0119444188,
0.0331631526,
0.0334777795,
0.1182874292,
0.0006483793,
-0.0711135939,
-0.0104039684,
0.0276974607,
0.0266407803,
0.033585649,
0.049024079,
-0.0381855033,
-0.0257856082,
-0.031712167,
0.011773007,
-0.0548697524,
-0.0491287746,
0.0006212228,
-0.0001717535,
-0.0109850112,
0.0322790034,
0.0214597788,
-0.0357868858,
-0.0316808745,
-0.0186987706,
0.0365657322,
0.024137849,
-0.0017892555,
0.0307627711,
-0.029411342,
-0.0248438474,
-0.0071591339,
-0.0027977983,
0.0280251745,
-0.0141848279,
0.0012858071,
0.062429402,
-0.0755699202,
-0.0269465894,
-0.0368619487,
-0.0100453449,
0.0154201156,
0.0620619468,
0.0209983606,
0.0103854379,
0.0143634314,
0.0195292868,
-0.029987948,
-0.0216173846,
-0.0178065095,
-0.015709132,
0.0257817544,
0.0530611053,
-0.0645882785,
0.00713176,
-0.0244654249,
0.041521024,
0.0264938641,
-0.0562114269,
-0.0507490002,
0.0266387593,
2.991e-7,
0.0523768142,
0.0292551089,
0.0168749429,
0.0067639314,
-0.0007877641,
-0.0150479553,
0.0298020039,
0.0325689502,
0.0040520332,
-0.0232101493,
0.004552261,
0.0134147014,
-0.0093390997,
0.0141522717,
-0.0465092212,
0.02342733,
-0.0105441734,
0.0234056134,
-0.0420026109,
-0.0362016633,
0.0116069317,
0.113236852,
-0.0067832102,
-0.0108966883,
0.0280754734,
-0.0326507911,
0.0326383673,
0.0027105568,
0.0215270109,
0.0275146682,
0.0326938182,
0.0317765884,
-0.0016856075,
0.0044724308,
0.0230933074,
0.0322248153,
-0.0318449922,
0.088014394,
-0.0471857898,
-0.0005778751,
-0.0184731353,
-0.027037479,
-0.0232566148,
-0.0277945735,
0.065570645,
-0.0237716213,
-0.0170078371,
-0.0966910124,
-0.0053137369,
-0.0195369404,
0.0019658529,
0.0102946162,
0.0155745605,
0.0369397178,
0.039540235,
-0.014140984,
-0.013991164,
-0.0784845278,
-0.0575871952,
0.0302257948,
-0.0226305462,
-0.023908589,
-0.0508609824,
-0.0157191157,
0.0159603655,
-0.0590995438,
0.023519272,
2.881575857e-34,
0.0489687175,
-0.0116805276,
0.0396130346,
0.0233473275,
0.003526879,
-0.0139377173,
-0.0220572911,
0.0037106662,
-0.0204245523,
-0.0806890875,
-0.0412701927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07589v1 | Dialogizer: Context-aware Conversational-QA Dataset Generation from Textual Sources | 2023-11-09T06:03:11 | 2023-11-09T06:03:11 | Yerin Hwang, Yongil Kim, Hyunkyung Bae, Jeesoo Bang, Hwanhee Lee, Kyomin Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To address the data scarcity issue in Conversational question answering
(ConvQA), a dialog inpainting method, which utilizes documents to generate
ConvQA datasets, has been proposed. However, the original dialog inpainting
model is trained solely on the dialog reconstruction task, resulting in the
generation of questions with low contextual relevance due to insufficient
learning of question-answer alignment. To overcome this limitation, we propose
a novel framework called Dialogizer, which has the capability to automatically
generate ConvQA datasets with high contextual relevance from textual sources.
The framework incorporates two training tasks: question-answer matching (QAM)
and topic-aware dialog generation (TDG). Moreover, re-ranking is conducted
during the inference phase based on the contextual relevance of the generated
questions. Using our framework, we produce four ConvQA datasets by utilizing
documents from multiple domains as the primary source. Through automatic
evaluation using diverse metrics, as well as human evaluation, we validate that
our proposed framework exhibits the ability to generate datasets of higher
quality compared to the baseline dialog inpainting model. | [
0.0227940455,
0.0897706151,
0.0119015044,
0.0444361642,
-0.009424299,
0.0094462624,
-0.007464258,
-0.0262817144,
-0.0177284144,
-0.0304880664,
-0.0270068031,
0.0011340223,
-0.0361593105,
0.0405299887,
0.0146284513,
-0.048137594,
0.0340744779,
0.006353457,
-0.0220036134,
0.0033773873,
0.0313995294,
0.0158868395,
-0.021439163,
0.0183013715,
-0.0027154773,
-0.054463502,
-0.0357516967,
0.0183152594,
0.0156532452,
-0.0091378698,
0.0479522161,
0.0501031689,
0.0298998859,
0.0060503413,
0.0000017018,
-0.0527358912,
-0.0112973377,
-0.0234974902,
-0.0202736054,
-0.0197174884,
0.0322501138,
0.0011853753,
0.0239461698,
0.0381456353,
-0.0462650396,
0.0290743839,
0.0396430716,
0.0630771518,
0.100576587,
0.0656117201,
-0.0176952071,
-0.0133285923,
0.0121099679,
-0.0160261448,
0.0151618244,
-0.05409142,
-0.0178508386,
0.0595725253,
0.0063417163,
0.0298017524,
-0.0072823712,
0.0300582759,
0.0023920743,
-0.0495697409,
0.0147863207,
-0.0086555993,
-0.0319737159,
0.0195444226,
0.0074332971,
0.1284617186,
0.0222560782,
-0.0023435117,
-0.0076419679,
0.0131278327,
0.0262976736,
-0.0287275966,
-0.0768321007,
0.0120001212,
-0.0094850017,
0.000581057,
-0.0113691716,
0.0168454591,
-0.0084149288,
0.0053649643,
0.0058795596,
0.0088598635,
0.0277743135,
-0.0079645142,
-0.0435073562,
-0.0066850008,
-0.036286965,
-0.0745156109,
-0.0175393336,
0.0359627567,
-0.071246013,
0.0277762432,
-0.0638198704,
0.0066294721,
0.0228112005,
-0.0053494703,
-0.0345392823,
0.0332059152,
0.0012418648,
0.0426567495,
-0.0032474862,
0.0378185287,
-0.0159963388,
-0.0177650806,
-0.0999333188,
-0.0576947071,
-0.0092552006,
-0.0157657731,
-0.0312293693,
0.021636907,
-0.0615400001,
-0.0253301132,
-0.0311130639,
0.0534717999,
-0.0048184572,
-0.015448357,
-0.0088842595,
0.060134165,
-0.0630862266,
-0.0024915321,
-0.0374588817,
0.0035805076,
-0.0435409397,
0.0428190269,
0.0161924418,
-0.0386394225,
-0.0162361097,
0.0053521367,
0.0494065657,
-0.0230425037,
-0.0060420977,
0.037241932,
-0.0428653285,
-0.0090253549,
0.0191136207,
-0.0114862518,
0.0191734023,
-0.007332447,
-0.0290431622,
-0.0476149507,
0.0531362407,
-0.0099988943,
-0.0300683994,
-0.0053824447,
0.0138320765,
0.0512351356,
0.0148657802,
0.072937876,
-0.029353397,
-0.0038615272,
0.0672284514,
-0.0023379521,
-0.0131904772,
0.0774346367,
0.0209099539,
-0.0113539547,
0.0342874825,
-0.0034741911,
0.0061482992,
-0.007657961,
0.0489382781,
0.0144693675,
0.0220193304,
0.0640844703,
0.0107020307,
0.0346373096,
0.04553736,
0.0329210311,
-0.0570182204,
-0.0248178486,
0.0308404509,
0.0299169719,
0.0231788531,
-0.0056263465,
-0.0238501169,
0.026650792,
0.013031777,
0.0003800687,
-0.0132549433,
0.0369479917,
0.0298107732,
0.0228961781,
0.0460066721,
0.0229006615,
-0.0277656335,
-0.0135119567,
0.0368022993,
0.0061329948,
0.0097053275,
0.0033394545,
-0.0103794513,
0.0694392323,
-0.0356983803,
0.0286141075,
-0.0050571198,
-0.0354256332,
-0.0102352109,
-0.0224323925,
0.0250840727,
0.0396859609,
0.0620413721,
-0.0083184149,
-0.0677134022,
-0.0380398221,
0.0545868091,
0.0247841142,
-0.0051029003,
-0.0441880152,
0.0303819627,
-0.0428265072,
-0.0005899773,
-0.0470628925,
-0.0262152608,
0.0015338395,
0.0290773176,
0.0039913063,
0.0330091491,
-0.0304460265,
0.0075251241,
0.026725309,
-0.0106160678,
-0.0194631852,
0.050664328,
-0.0052866857,
0.0251377877,
0.0368534587,
0.0038938294,
0.0127277039,
0.0285812393,
-0.0295782983,
-0.0116959717,
0.0450132154,
-0.0625427216,
-0.0821804032,
0.030840138,
-0.0579815656,
-0.0207979884,
0.0100110816,
-0.0757482201,
-0.0662005693,
0.0153461248,
-0.0462944284,
-0.0045306333,
-0.0760180727,
-0.0244236439,
0.0314302966,
0.0042871302,
-0.0503931157,
0.0632908344,
0.0262236148,
0.0107054282,
0.0677924678,
0.0711067319,
0.0229461435,
-0.0318713076,
0.0300638676,
-0.0317477211,
-0.030894259,
0.0070975614,
0.0149571486,
0.0111430036,
-0.0729445443,
-0.0121490741,
-0.0993997604,
0.0327992998,
0.0121419067,
0.0133203557,
0.0814072639,
0.0460791029,
0.0051872577,
-0.0415352471,
-0.0750630125,
-0.0281492025,
0.0607178472,
0.0074422918,
0.0786953643,
-0.00341762,
0.0075482866,
-0.0620856509,
0.0217735358,
0.0135603203,
0.0212832168,
0.0032105297,
0.0310839731,
-0.0615128949,
0.0038733217,
-0.0281123817,
0.0408750661,
-0.019792594,
-0.0250783768,
0.0045154053,
0.0245118588,
0.0382541232,
0.0747572854,
0.0543681197,
-0.0306727383,
-0.0112773515,
0.0053994451,
-0.0505943112,
0.029355675,
-0.0228379536,
-0.0210673939,
0.0201197919,
-0.0510619432,
0.0397978425,
0.0207224581,
-0.0115082795,
0.0136664296,
-0.0139878104,
0.0647830814,
0.0416074879,
-0.0134916371,
-0.0487326421,
-0.0116662551,
-0.0311799813,
0.0541712381,
-0.0405893587,
-0.0259830318,
0.0522335805,
-0.0100038303,
-0.0296031907,
-0.0769065693,
0.0163751952,
-0.0675812513,
0.0229631104,
-0.0094019594,
0.0214428529,
-0.0202335436,
-0.0404328294,
-0.03832509,
-0.01989213,
0.033475928,
-0.0351530463,
0.0418072008,
-0.033793956,
0.0104022389,
-0.0256189704,
-0.0549635775,
-0.0627800971,
-0.0356380939,
0.024178179,
-0.0153778149,
0.0269467402,
-0.0053942217,
-0.0196650308,
-0.0187187232,
0.0093844999,
0.0417752862,
-0.017722657,
0.0083108824,
-0.0119290845,
0.1130296215,
0.0853898376,
0.0514996648,
0.0035104358,
0.0078451466,
0.059948694,
0.0578879043,
0.0372907259,
-0.0067432197,
-0.0044625369,
-0.0208121594,
0.0000625621,
0.0121079506,
0.0260398723,
-0.0235556867,
0.0667157546,
-0.0075196694,
-0.0393576212,
0.1004496142,
0.0218062792,
-0.0171846151,
-0.0193845052,
-0.0450723097,
0.0219267271,
0.0325166471,
0.0327690728,
-0.1129610464,
-0.03553956,
-0.0098539144,
0.0326821506,
0.0126204127,
-0.0079390416,
-0.0079174004,
-0.0814983249,
0.0347074121,
-0.0235986896,
-0.0343690403,
-0.0347106755,
-0.0447546244,
0.0230910834,
-0.0113083376,
0.0192758925,
0.0237434618,
-0.0107918838,
0.0186884049,
0.0148589835,
0.0263164435,
-0.0308218952,
0.0117592216,
-0.0231024809,
0.0338146836,
0.0498171486,
0.0441127904,
0.0248009954,
0.0064769122,
0.0091880262,
-0.0659081861,
-0.0361287892,
0.0199637879,
0.0490557179,
-0.0029718559,
-0.0201573204,
-0.0400887467,
0.0757171214,
-0.0163655747,
-0.0153347244,
0.0432036482,
0.0002313239,
-0.0246528946,
0.0284778159,
-0.0319231525,
-0.0033970641,
0.0199070778,
0.0745886117,
0.0406826846,
-0.0242161807,
-0.0370651409,
-0.0293318462,
0.0306262113,
-0.0782314241,
0.0306621715,
-0.0051188311,
0.0308547504,
0.0192307383,
-0.1003820226,
-0.046811711,
0.0067126048,
-0.004575979,
-0.0152763547,
-0.0115641048,
-0.0240619425,
-0.0181649849,
-0.0436205268,
0.0251414683,
-0.0275014378,
0.0002694627,
-0.0247049332,
0.0053964192,
0.0320096165,
-0.0525512062,
-0.0374297053,
0.0304697584,
-0.0770586729,
-0.0224769898,
-0.0358943455,
0.0239494592,
0.0113455746,
0.0766897872,
-0.0035568252,
-0.0005997733,
0.0025259685,
0.023617452,
-0.0210923161,
-0.0108962422,
0.0118508982,
0.0452945493,
-0.0048947004,
0.0224752966,
-0.0656463951,
0.0060053593,
-0.0448606946,
0.0313925259,
-0.0175154712,
-0.056408003,
0.0288155619,
-0.020019738,
-0.0393951237,
0.0363018587,
0.0456511118,
-0.0409986004,
0.0556111112,
-0.0237580147,
-0.037635155,
-0.0524254404,
0.020683106,
0.0074743051,
-0.0321072116,
0.025236953,
-0.0161808431,
-0.0429867543,
0.0651756078,
-0.0069848639,
-0.0136768017,
0.0350687094,
0.005709847,
0.0007693233,
-0.0267751217,
-0.0192840789,
0.0024388984,
0.0010803918,
0.0653240904,
-0.008417815,
0.0508509912,
0.0314769372,
-0.0290545579,
0.0083701685,
0.0153677454,
-0.0754538104,
-0.0413633697,
-0.0567655191,
-0.0023694334,
0.0290536731,
0.0002309769,
0.0402425677,
0.0106337275,
-0.0072243297,
0.0018447078,
0.0175048038,
0.007976152,
-0.0192688555,
0.0341164581,
0.0164637435,
-0.0034510661,
0.0111060683,
0.0779388845,
-0.0095830914,
0.0521469228,
-0.0287666488,
0.0128183151,
-0.0483176336,
-0.0245222561,
-0.0013524914,
0.0293190163,
0.0023455662,
-0.0083081014,
0.0245371312,
-0.0292262621,
-0.0015772898,
-0.0103425775,
-0.0327117741,
0.0122211063,
0.0502774902,
0.0581618808,
0.0049036625,
-0.0353042968,
-0.0320953541,
0.035622634,
-0.0349157564,
-0.0419297703,
-0.0169159416,
-5.66790205e-33,
-0.0285312627,
-0.0375482626,
0.009812302,
-0.0155103365,
-0.0002990041,
-0.010154292,
-0.0534138419,
-0.0290811453,
-0.0235500652,
-0.0111388853,
0.000362838,
0.0060228007,
-0.0065909252,
0.0709374622,
-0.0287514161,
-0.0107588721,
0.030439619,
-0.0085878316,
-0.0224766079,
0.0505248979,
0.0071672527,
0.0018903527,
0.0237323809,
-0.0500090681,
0.0085034929,
-0.0543544702,
-0.0142754083,
0.0421775281,
0.0260049794,
0.0552913733,
-0.0217330474,
0.0144974384,
0.0415587574,
-0.0248558484,
-0.0031048448,
0.050221689,
-0.0854941681,
-0.0368720777,
0.0199520383,
-0.0194329675,
-0.0498692393,
-0.0307681449,
-0.0005623272,
-0.0283257831,
0.0393798128,
-0.0246039983,
0.0221239068,
-0.033926852,
0.0045455373,
-0.0215026047,
-0.0328569114,
0.0037908093,
-0.03904045,
-0.0562346391,
-0.0471133813,
0.0911452547,
0.011267405,
0.0265806522,
-0.0371138826,
0.0146021331,
0.0010093382,
0.0182077661,
0.0479371324,
0.0382619537,
-0.0056531811,
0.0400128923,
0.0319365524,
0.0074706594,
-0.0078407805,
-0.0456123874,
-0.0619840771,
0.0165213123,
0.0395155661,
0.0965744257,
0.0213111062,
0.0283975992,
-0.0428835936,
0.0734572485,
-0.0028834837,
0.0168752521,
-0.0097418763,
-0.0038019016,
0.0108788814,
-0.0038604198,
-0.0595972724,
0.023501819,
-0.0344483964,
-0.0219346341,
0.0410755016,
0.0034820831,
-0.019540824,
0.0013511198,
0.0170870516,
-0.0142842038,
0.0026584656,
0.0333399996,
-0.0203541368,
-0.0062878067,
0.0078245671,
0.0132933669,
-0.0145252133,
-0.003759712,
0.0683136582,
0.0337728932,
-0.0015949243,
0.0026577858,
0.0080650216,
-0.0340756774,
-0.0535843559,
0.0264061298,
-0.0338005126,
0.0563255586,
-0.0669226199,
0.0196608547,
-0.005823975,
0.0034200093,
-0.0274007004,
0.0472610667,
0.0069638239,
0.0236616172,
-0.0493542999,
-0.0751261637,
0.0003798055,
0.0162589941,
-0.0296528321,
0.0171850398,
-0.0140545918,
0.0080014691,
-0.0118971076,
-0.0496093854,
-0.0084843934,
0.00288728,
2.396e-7,
0.0375284925,
-0.001220296,
0.0572849587,
0.017285848,
0.0406954661,
0.0283864625,
0.0136748347,
0.0211174153,
0.0482859537,
-0.0369330235,
0.0088510187,
-0.0058051925,
0.0336807594,
0.0293236524,
-0.0974736437,
0.0055927034,
-0.0939027369,
-0.048839014,
-0.0240965579,
-0.0089076282,
0.0528756417,
0.0824150518,
-0.0394701362,
-0.0224660244,
-0.0110981567,
-0.0305187311,
0.0366612263,
-0.0241729543,
-0.028815547,
0.0431509614,
0.018999964,
0.002775406,
0.0191221889,
-0.0115699358,
-0.0102566518,
0.034505602,
0.0285155661,
0.0479862764,
0.0206453651,
-0.0483476408,
-0.0397434831,
-0.0010405042,
0.043435622,
-0.0786105692,
0.0714647695,
-0.0502988696,
-0.0150802899,
-0.0705345944,
-0.0663031861,
0.0004595006,
0.0173180699,
-0.04057502,
-0.0092207631,
0.0117020709,
0.0220686756,
0.0295852404,
0.0044952836,
-0.0574235916,
-0.0323961973,
-0.0133383498,
-0.0574407987,
-0.0240805261,
-0.03507182,
-0.007802662,
0.021281518,
-0.0059122862,
0.0400280878,
1.716405882e-34,
0.0275381636,
-0.0075489935,
0.0239456408,
0.0563183203,
0.0161381885,
-0.0210488848,
0.0133305825,
-0.0220698025,
0.0258194115,
-0.0670947134,
0.0092249541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05155v1 | Weakly-supervised Deep Cognate Detection Framework for Low-Resourced Languages Using Morphological Knowledge of Closely-Related Languages | 2023-11-09T05:46:41 | 2023-11-09T05:46:41 | Koustava Goswami, Priya Rani, Theodorus Fransen, John P. McCrae | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Exploiting cognates for transfer learning in under-resourced languages is an
exciting opportunity for language understanding tasks, including unsupervised
machine translation, named entity recognition and information retrieval.
Previous approaches mainly focused on supervised cognate detection tasks based
on orthographic, phonetic or state-of-the-art contextual language models, which
under-perform for most under-resourced languages. This paper proposes a novel
language-agnostic weakly-supervised deep cognate detection framework for
under-resourced languages using morphological knowledge from closely related
languages. We train an encoder to gain morphological knowledge of a language
and transfer the knowledge to perform unsupervised and weakly-supervised
cognate detection tasks with and without the pivot language for the
closely-related languages. While unsupervised, it overcomes the need for
hand-crafted annotation of cognates. We performed experiments on different
published cognate detection datasets across language families and observed not
only significant improvement over the state-of-the-art but also our method
outperformed the state-of-the-art supervised and unsupervised methods. Our
model can be extended to a wide range of languages from any language family as
it overcomes the requirement of the annotation of the cognate pairs for
training. The code and dataset building scripts can be found at
https://github.com/koustavagoswami/Weakly_supervised-Cognate_Detection | [
-0.0086895134,
0.046361696,
-0.0026066646,
0.0964168683,
-0.0433307774,
0.0588829964,
-0.0221070684,
0.0074501871,
-0.0049814177,
0.047489699,
-0.034069486,
-0.0582504906,
0.0060326252,
-0.0007420826,
0.0126884878,
0.005782932,
0.0339272022,
-0.0402147882,
0.0145098669,
-0.0198068451,
-0.0262155794,
0.0030935463,
-0.0051096813,
-0.0183780957,
-0.0484262034,
-0.0073376284,
-0.0185366049,
0.051786378,
-0.016324224,
-0.0476287082,
0.0214806236,
0.0224434715,
-0.0124227302,
0.0773107558,
0.0000019045,
-0.0605064519,
-0.0272041466,
-0.0262101199,
-0.0427434146,
-0.015753191,
0.021717621,
-0.0386422761,
-0.0171071161,
-0.0197082963,
0.0053099901,
0.0021421546,
0.0525812693,
0.0014036518,
0.0017229459,
0.052600354,
-0.0112660909,
-0.0307045169,
0.0214176457,
-0.0561541654,
-0.0026749715,
-0.0110638235,
-0.0228408687,
0.0230311025,
-0.0403289981,
0.0152971204,
-0.0355093889,
0.0535453819,
0.0050162249,
0.0150949601,
-0.0729082376,
0.0187344514,
-0.0541887619,
-0.0396170616,
0.0331296548,
0.0228081569,
-0.0118428823,
-0.0314571597,
0.0318643562,
-0.0080511533,
0.0078671034,
0.0051299003,
-0.0050804764,
-0.007700915,
-0.0207074266,
0.0488459431,
0.0756345615,
-0.0124979541,
0.0249834433,
0.0006105407,
0.0154018104,
0.0396384224,
0.0613420457,
-0.0121531244,
0.0150242737,
0.0541039035,
0.024719147,
0.008213806,
0.0378555954,
0.0012245185,
0.0029678924,
-0.0028373366,
0.0023688774,
-0.0028769888,
0.0298266243,
-0.0311967228,
-0.004248119,
-0.0176844243,
-0.0620551109,
0.0757277012,
-0.1159610897,
-0.0334607027,
0.0171699114,
-0.0349947251,
0.0310845692,
-0.066570282,
-0.0059150318,
0.0096273683,
-0.0429109335,
-0.009581415,
-0.0465598404,
0.0597508959,
-0.0180185605,
-0.0350115672,
0.0340508483,
-0.0146529898,
0.030553069,
-0.0120425075,
-0.0710604414,
0.0083497865,
0.0036037676,
0.0336306691,
-0.0084169619,
-0.036459554,
-0.0540117696,
-0.0801727176,
-0.0142063834,
0.018556295,
0.058930207,
-0.043387901,
0.0597056784,
0.048934754,
0.0138812866,
-0.0916061848,
-0.019788513,
-0.0331857502,
-0.0567143336,
-0.0313823149,
0.0036668186,
-0.078923434,
0.0367105342,
-0.0329169072,
0.0152046662,
-0.040746145,
-0.0123025645,
-0.0210979246,
-0.055879306,
0.0235851295,
-0.003702203,
-0.0097694714,
-0.0008753359,
-0.0143852821,
0.0410919227,
0.0371553674,
0.0287542138,
0.0094771748,
0.0480897389,
0.0104108788,
-0.0636727437,
0.0300572049,
-0.011916521,
0.007099153,
0.0240590479,
-0.0332582444,
-0.0166310482,
0.0201073345,
0.0582761429,
0.0331691168,
0.0356240496,
-0.0364107639,
0.0182036236,
0.013861808,
0.0727129653,
0.0165346358,
0.0807757452,
0.0075963512,
-0.0431407839,
-0.0013644443,
0.0040994529,
-0.0097617684,
-0.0049890392,
-0.0036566171,
-0.043134883,
0.0376700759,
-0.0002957756,
0.0123872878,
0.0202918202,
-0.033412002,
-0.0728126839,
0.0336343236,
0.0708173886,
-0.0036058512,
-0.0371795185,
-0.0209126435,
0.0706464276,
-0.0437206142,
0.0426278114,
0.0201294161,
0.0551593006,
0.0273381658,
0.0013110514,
0.0037831431,
-0.022508679,
0.0408015847,
-0.0020441336,
0.0140080657,
0.0102992989,
-0.0208533294,
0.0702913031,
-0.0207105726,
-0.0073841154,
0.0064717974,
0.0202262625,
0.0487079136,
-0.0362935737,
0.0933819711,
0.0342998244,
-0.0081660394,
0.0365369022,
0.038396541,
-0.0643277839,
-0.0108585125,
-0.0121464618,
0.0306251794,
0.0162345562,
0.0668614507,
0.0077506416,
-0.0167348869,
0.0382694677,
-0.0472140536,
0.0316517688,
0.0203125495,
-0.0326514207,
-0.0799421594,
0.0176736619,
-0.0393580757,
-0.0413027033,
-0.0508563332,
0.0282778107,
-0.0430810004,
0.0269832853,
-0.0377824344,
0.0608528331,
-0.0524432436,
0.0061394665,
-0.0227502957,
0.041581735,
-0.0107375178,
0.0797084942,
0.0571887754,
0.0225129128,
0.0482289791,
-0.0323276706,
-0.0002555315,
-0.0113056637,
-0.0240005292,
-0.0021676354,
-0.0324745849,
-0.0842118859,
0.0119844172,
0.0265839268,
-0.0113779046,
-0.0087038074,
-0.0715137944,
0.0075505427,
-0.0307672191,
0.0619999059,
0.0022912975,
0.0442919694,
-0.0297649838,
-0.0322632343,
-0.0004906984,
0.0462720357,
-0.0000190102,
0.0243266616,
0.0155769857,
-0.0446123891,
0.0140794916,
-0.0416730419,
-0.0299351886,
-0.0067458209,
0.0348076671,
0.0496587045,
-0.050785549,
-0.0284761712,
-0.0085849101,
-0.0627607852,
-0.0191124007,
0.0386190005,
0.0121373981,
-0.0118809016,
-0.0433163829,
0.0337410197,
0.0028627897,
-0.0414130948,
-0.0264718216,
0.0060163271,
-0.0406616256,
-0.0411089845,
0.0001067394,
-0.0204946082,
0.0074623697,
-0.0088721849,
0.0025334607,
-0.0294468049,
0.0785479918,
-0.0421701372,
-0.010037058,
-0.0051331455,
-0.0362431705,
-0.0129794944,
-0.0035416873,
0.0161699858,
0.0249654166,
0.0090385471,
0.0283822976,
-0.0139686819,
-0.0022560023,
0.0475658998,
-0.0311474781,
-0.0403503664,
0.0191134382,
-0.0445367917,
-0.061945796,
0.0649041906,
0.0151476404,
0.0422388949,
-0.0048270933,
-0.0569290854,
-0.0044659246,
0.0480897464,
0.0254693944,
-0.0156923402,
0.0061095962,
0.0096031381,
-0.0138437729,
-0.0077110222,
-0.0177069679,
-0.0320461206,
0.0177523717,
-0.0495767333,
0.0193100423,
0.008350376,
-0.0034326781,
0.0416351557,
0.0013345308,
-0.0131558226,
0.0290900059,
0.0402239934,
-0.0013226892,
-0.0120890439,
0.0764073208,
0.0039107236,
0.0021594304,
0.00385157,
0.0148399677,
0.002377948,
0.0180220846,
-0.0217835773,
-0.0079102386,
0.0238477942,
0.0139197549,
0.0306781251,
-0.0147640267,
-0.032977879,
-0.0339111798,
0.0391039774,
-0.0370605811,
-0.0315692872,
0.0641604662,
-0.0004099132,
-0.0097990697,
0.0176867954,
-0.047387749,
0.0412746444,
0.0254960489,
0.0021107527,
-0.0539410934,
-0.0738279521,
0.0379995853,
-0.0155742001,
0.0620137528,
-0.0695078447,
0.0199161973,
-0.1026694328,
-0.024655832,
-0.0255009085,
-0.0079513835,
-0.0228012353,
-0.0610624179,
0.0159426294,
-0.048660554,
-0.049213659,
0.0105615482,
0.0017830024,
-0.0068553444,
0.0003442133,
0.0178293716,
-0.0500679277,
0.0093956757,
-0.0914492086,
-0.011852677,
0.0069251079,
0.0723276138,
-0.043432828,
0.0098489076,
-0.0021297629,
-0.0892757773,
-0.0248197541,
-0.0168263689,
0.0351292901,
0.0049282666,
-0.0329779424,
-0.0155279143,
0.0173381306,
-0.0292408448,
0.0062178615,
0.027869191,
0.0552446097,
0.0319362246,
-0.0683610961,
0.0115360739,
-0.0180582516,
0.00792397,
0.0607369877,
0.0220286101,
-0.0034919651,
-0.0183311906,
0.0272493381,
0.0416580886,
-0.0132858548,
-0.0114929527,
-0.0279778168,
0.0258244481,
-0.0242770463,
-0.0974590555,
-0.0392624289,
0.026986083,
0.0300186593,
0.0273162182,
0.0379438512,
-0.0039648246,
-0.0079100449,
-0.0543539971,
0.0355965756,
-0.0430142768,
0.0204051007,
-0.0679944903,
-0.0019543171,
0.0695979744,
-0.0192744844,
-0.0059143552,
0.0123553611,
-0.034778934,
-0.0533242263,
-0.0123610171,
0.0040905764,
0.0030812386,
0.0248645414,
-0.0388000458,
-0.0250439309,
0.0267612711,
0.002560304,
0.0047037634,
0.0137837194,
0.0307222903,
-0.0513590425,
-0.0085630259,
0.0451663882,
-0.0350389518,
0.0107287681,
0.0116018867,
0.0536651909,
-0.0027344816,
-0.0487170331,
0.0297529865,
-0.0343168452,
0.0471708737,
-0.0900439546,
-0.0001968453,
-0.0437459089,
0.0063610356,
0.0263043568,
0.0345772393,
-0.0247854572,
0.0189258158,
0.0135451406,
0.0027211211,
0.0034587241,
0.0101308655,
0.0062414086,
0.0169352181,
-0.0208436623,
0.0598766543,
0.0322441049,
0.0159949791,
-0.0287420955,
0.0100564538,
0.0464368537,
0.0352536142,
-0.0212779138,
0.0590731017,
-0.0699134693,
-0.0143450974,
-0.0298878569,
0.007451308,
0.0263499804,
0.0069648675,
0.0304227825,
0.0508949831,
0.0052361032,
0.0638373047,
0.1125332639,
-0.066920653,
0.0585749634,
-0.0220108554,
0.0115930084,
-0.0069852034,
0.0194087513,
-0.0568286628,
-0.0379341915,
-0.0092430059,
0.0231024008,
-0.0118865445,
0.0399379916,
0.0537336171,
-0.0062756054,
0.0568085238,
0.0019942592,
0.0322423875,
0.0291581023,
-0.0199182257,
0.0157757252,
-0.0378444009,
-0.0480522439,
0.0203715563,
-0.0082368432,
-0.0933475569,
-0.0359553248,
-0.0187276602,
-0.0029558823,
0.0342401154,
0.0265792292,
0.0132270036,
0.0041686497,
0.0092071211,
-0.0440387949,
0.0318529047,
0.0385759212,
-0.0086631123,
0.0028920583,
-5.922980651e-33,
-0.0092803352,
0.0024932732,
-0.0241565127,
-0.0141104618,
0.0255224817,
0.0219596997,
-0.0524998903,
0.0367961936,
-0.0578767397,
0.0025793626,
0.0142606841,
-0.0061123059,
0.009657166,
0.0317512341,
0.036197532,
-0.016565958,
0.021618003,
0.0352794714,
0.037285462,
0.0159044545,
0.0222914964,
0.0430669151,
0.0984975025,
-0.0911957249,
0.0149600189,
-0.0051700925,
0.0220232885,
0.0235144924,
0.0248372555,
0.0318251066,
-0.0172777567,
-0.0192400366,
-0.0077750054,
-0.0044627734,
0.0206623841,
0.0087907668,
-0.1467039585,
-0.0148822386,
-0.0265261587,
-0.0085556898,
-0.0179092735,
-0.023449339,
0.0106636854,
0.028887976,
0.0185297262,
0.0313639082,
0.0276410244,
0.0074199438,
-0.0067090318,
-0.0304368474,
-0.090787828,
0.0553461649,
-0.0179737341,
0.0158674382,
0.0786490217,
0.0407858752,
0.0386844538,
-0.0198443979,
-0.007631571,
-0.007002688,
-0.0526908487,
0.0322395675,
0.037222553,
-0.010724999,
-0.053483706,
0.0314665064,
0.0358705446,
-0.0493786149,
0.0379241779,
0.036599867,
0.0291436091,
-0.0035499008,
0.0300519411,
0.0438604914,
0.0591104478,
-0.0009536197,
-0.0404995717,
-0.0142991608,
0.0229163561,
0.006154045,
-0.0066846129,
-0.0089326371,
-0.0725178495,
0.0181298349,
0.0098527009,
-0.0847702771,
-0.028911408,
-0.0404220037,
-0.0035213258,
-0.0168280974,
-0.0459771156,
0.0913038403,
0.0299471226,
0.0019889374,
-0.0732008889,
-0.008271846,
0.0450658575,
-0.0035894704,
-0.0155234886,
0.0698407143,
0.0024743453,
-0.0606388748,
0.0052283136,
-0.0174038522,
0.0332099646,
-0.0274586845,
0.0917917788,
0.0103700235,
-0.0445672683,
-0.0047875266,
-0.0218825117,
0.0183371343,
-0.0225691833,
0.0190280769,
0.0127293384,
0.0051751351,
-0.0055013532,
-0.0119595379,
0.0838506147,
-0.0144783333,
-0.0434308797,
-0.0456323959,
-0.0257239249,
0.0031880012,
-0.0113124652,
-0.0110183517,
-0.0103476346,
-0.0018399733,
0.0355338231,
-0.0337529294,
-0.0095700156,
-0.0041602161,
2.691e-7,
0.0293055698,
-0.0011196876,
-0.0024182468,
-0.0385390893,
0.0073191836,
0.0068598334,
-0.0056909015,
0.0307545345,
-0.0156158777,
-0.0290660821,
-0.0097806649,
0.0142277954,
0.0230282247,
-0.0009236165,
-0.1049715579,
0.027985381,
-0.0416539088,
-0.0078021521,
-0.0492693335,
-0.0044162082,
-0.0073240004,
0.1186250374,
0.0128590502,
-0.0738104582,
-0.0053951228,
-0.0274190605,
0.0303831622,
-0.0133849904,
0.0160855502,
-0.0095723709,
-0.0255168453,
0.0194398556,
0.0090537211,
-0.0058035343,
-0.0389779918,
0.0201938953,
0.0420946069,
0.0158029702,
0.0045998916,
0.0270418897,
0.0495038629,
-0.0021163907,
0.0066927541,
0.0273701176,
0.0838082433,
0.028769698,
-0.0180470087,
-0.00187814,
0.0256228335,
0.0249481536,
-0.00355314,
-0.0120062456,
-0.0256130788,
0.0267136041,
0.0510720275,
-0.0453105718,
-0.0718711466,
-0.0221119039,
0.0094189569,
0.0476379804,
-0.0173207019,
0.0172055159,
0.0040930854,
0.0057978858,
-0.0193385109,
0.0179705024,
0.0298483688,
2.229997502e-34,
-0.0273039397,
0.0129164895,
0.0033131011,
0.0056097629,
0.0143256187,
-0.0395631455,
-0.0175111834,
0.0236757621,
-0.0157904178,
0.0313387476,
-0.0035800659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05120v1 | Quranic Conversations: Developing a Semantic Search tool for the Quran using Arabic NLP Techniques | 2023-11-09T03:14:54 | 2023-11-09T03:14:54 | Yasser Shohoud, Maged Shoman, Sarah Abdelazim | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Holy Book of Quran is believed to be the literal word of God (Allah) as
revealed to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) over a period of approximately 23
years. It is the book where God provides guidance on how to live a righteous
and just life, emphasizing principles like honesty, compassion, charity and
justice, as well as providing rules for personal conduct, family matters,
business ethics and much more. However, due to constraints related to the
language and the Quran organization, it is challenging for Muslims to get all
relevant ayahs (verses) pertaining to a matter or inquiry of interest. Hence,
we developed a Quran semantic search tool which finds the verses pertaining to
the user inquiry or prompt. To achieve this, we trained several models on a
large dataset of over 30 tafsirs, where typically each tafsir corresponds to
one verse in the Quran and, using cosine similarity, obtained the tafsir tensor
which is most similar to the prompt tensor of interest, which was then used to
index for the corresponding ayah in the Quran. Using the SNxLM model, we were
able to achieve a cosine similarity score as high as 0.97 which corresponds to
the abdu tafsir for a verse relating to financial matters. | [
0.0567507856,
0.0190566722,
-0.0218641479,
0.0269804504,
-0.0570575483,
0.012887801,
0.022987105,
0.0148901278,
-0.0431420282,
-0.0394586921,
-0.0005195417,
-0.0039656931,
0.0241708606,
-0.046954859,
0.0116005531,
-0.0135004353,
0.0573676974,
-0.0067269988,
0.0356685296,
0.0143852858,
0.0427784398,
0.0561263114,
-0.0206471607,
0.0177048557,
0.0026947951,
-0.0213035159,
-0.0679182932,
-0.0081064506,
0.0001940281,
0.011548263,
-0.0124176377,
0.0504914224,
0.0016584088,
0.0450380482,
0.0000021965,
-0.0748921633,
-0.0386482403,
-0.0203851704,
-0.0204865485,
-0.0233260468,
0.0527942777,
-0.0427730456,
0.0086324094,
-0.0220202226,
-0.0303157847,
0.0237199515,
0.0091576353,
0.1039017066,
0.0826531649,
0.048132997,
0.0140759852,
-0.0806130394,
0.0010832306,
0.0201885719,
0.0343212485,
-0.010643241,
-0.0157597214,
0.0182667859,
0.0122513128,
0.0194974337,
-0.055758711,
0.0204427149,
0.0024561032,
-0.0594254881,
0.0042771697,
-0.0297998656,
-0.0311369337,
-0.0122185592,
0.0149425175,
-0.0224032905,
0.0056074094,
-0.0245942194,
0.045769643,
0.0102233747,
-0.0133594954,
0.068571873,
-0.0152358301,
0.0290379245,
-0.0693568885,
-0.0088881459,
0.0369043201,
0.0101676751,
0.0082931239,
0.0047310735,
-0.0400663018,
0.0249391273,
0.0140222004,
-0.0506725796,
0.0222824998,
-0.0195301585,
0.0244644452,
-0.038283553,
0.0324962102,
-0.0249783434,
0.0059708268,
-0.014892431,
-0.0206845477,
-0.0403107814,
0.0069232262,
-0.0836870074,
0.0447984524,
0.064728491,
0.0230024923,
0.0296347309,
-0.0399611033,
0.0046619009,
0.0495718047,
-0.0003071438,
-0.0532922782,
0.0118537238,
-0.0326411501,
0.0121132713,
-0.070313856,
0.0616979711,
-0.079880625,
-0.0200494118,
-0.0826977566,
0.0336699486,
0.0315691754,
-0.0083696451,
0.0165345948,
-0.0114252111,
0.0268129278,
-0.0030115582,
-0.0171501916,
-0.0313308463,
-0.0191433877,
-0.0231725965,
-0.069511272,
-0.0571789071,
0.0658691898,
0.0172235873,
0.0029148897,
-0.0128177051,
-0.0005862039,
0.13027969,
0.0252003949,
-0.0419338942,
-0.0724349171,
0.0084912404,
0.0117465416,
-0.005274605,
-0.0266578123,
-0.034857478,
0.0568651147,
0.0187858809,
-0.0213244483,
0.0375394449,
0.0094998702,
0.0721115917,
-0.0002920354,
0.0515267476,
0.0273479242,
0.0324531794,
0.0907603726,
-0.0151433786,
0.0447175354,
0.0166636687,
-0.0133083062,
0.0185523145,
0.0852964893,
-0.0140890665,
-0.0654416531,
-0.0077244905,
0.0164808165,
-0.0690871403,
-0.004808106,
0.0191248581,
-0.023361152,
0.0729847103,
-0.0344647244,
0.0229228679,
-0.0407153331,
-0.0369376391,
-0.0161341187,
0.0793544948,
0.0599344708,
0.0437701233,
0.002967251,
0.0695304126,
0.0691243559,
0.0084482701,
-0.01566975,
0.024851786,
0.0297768246,
0.0041481028,
0.069419302,
0.0312287249,
0.010647079,
-0.0311642401,
-0.0180773456,
0.0125128441,
-0.021317251,
-0.0203061774,
0.0394088626,
-0.0141914682,
-0.0271679834,
0.0371718109,
0.0568855852,
-0.0310920253,
0.0165904053,
0.0193821937,
0.0592725463,
0.0404547751,
0.0313784778,
0.0064998744,
-0.0177465696,
-0.0028440482,
-0.0175203811,
0.0409307443,
-0.0219905842,
0.0061670588,
-0.0351258628,
-0.0416146964,
-0.010756094,
0.0314509533,
-0.0020029463,
-0.0188393276,
0.0093166316,
0.0294840615,
0.0374463014,
-0.0252421293,
0.0172242559,
0.0616144389,
0.0228394326,
-0.0055001788,
-0.0530453026,
0.0190943722,
0.0382201821,
0.0216079187,
-0.0022264495,
-0.011885874,
0.0147538716,
-0.0123333782,
-0.0375648588,
0.0079421317,
0.0005253533,
0.048943866,
0.0453532562,
-0.0867366642,
0.004912402,
0.0338515714,
-0.0058260337,
-0.030458482,
0.0276727602,
-0.0366358981,
0.0106007,
-0.0490562394,
0.0047389362,
0.0054996414,
-0.0124256117,
-0.0302116349,
0.0382808,
0.0060935467,
0.0434893146,
-0.037529517,
-0.0537630282,
0.0735431239,
0.0130831366,
-0.0007196213,
-0.0113351066,
0.009283605,
0.0030624715,
0.0570569076,
0.0057275635,
0.0093238484,
-0.0064905332,
-0.0602800027,
-0.0051001795,
0.0254626311,
0.0015561855,
-0.0042247884,
0.0198413767,
-0.0271034054,
-0.0259693787,
-0.0236997902,
-0.0421136171,
0.0247232653,
0.0114611769,
0.0619736202,
-0.0243786797,
0.0062723365,
-0.0524185412,
-0.0369375087,
0.0017792573,
0.0370736681,
0.069120504,
-0.0226344019,
0.0319082066,
-0.0265630819,
-0.0348761007,
-0.0180207044,
0.0034564694,
-0.0119168572,
-0.0122896833,
-0.007670546,
-0.0640964136,
0.0079795932,
0.0692581311,
0.0076378565,
-0.03070811,
0.0060017686,
-0.0509080552,
0.0079428907,
0.0007637326,
-0.0201248098,
-0.002240513,
-0.0227775741,
0.0258363392,
-0.0222470388,
0.0133881262,
0.0188033991,
-0.0336663499,
0.0227911416,
-0.0547980852,
0.0036222679,
-0.0748593062,
-0.0119727915,
-0.0045903288,
0.0744000971,
0.0100221988,
-0.0403250009,
0.0001458389,
0.0156522486,
0.0195852276,
-0.0486744568,
0.0093197664,
-0.0586338043,
-0.0352527089,
-0.0554650463,
0.0397948697,
-0.0152514447,
-0.0294662789,
0.0028876138,
-0.0004041495,
0.0167258549,
-0.0007959762,
0.0260469895,
0.0458424315,
0.0196225476,
-0.0211146902,
0.01691618,
-0.0310226828,
0.0022002114,
-0.006564009,
-0.0472372249,
0.02632723,
0.0073612714,
-0.0228939001,
0.0100699263,
-0.0003678562,
-0.0357409343,
-0.016974071,
-0.0248559546,
-0.004010574,
0.001118424,
0.0331838951,
-0.0528260805,
0.0294348281,
-0.0013375671,
-0.0244764667,
0.0341328196,
-0.0497042611,
-0.020296244,
-0.0327945426,
-0.0532738827,
0.017312821,
-0.0649164245,
-0.0077430778,
-0.049470719,
-0.0874969512,
-0.0471052304,
0.0375158601,
0.1133486629,
0.016074311,
0.003456492,
-0.0119978357,
-0.0634619966,
-0.0744153261,
-0.0271096192,
0.0324121714,
-0.1642984003,
0.0150120175,
0.00047833,
0.0155958962,
0.0192872025,
-0.0103983404,
0.0509341061,
-0.0398571603,
-0.0369551629,
-0.0400691852,
-0.0032768145,
-0.0394817591,
-0.0499559119,
-0.0009042014,
-0.0214395225,
-0.0057365606,
-0.0230967738,
-0.0376314148,
0.0656277537,
0.0149253737,
0.0562566258,
0.0048670308,
-0.0093772225,
-0.0417628661,
-0.0779287592,
0.0244103447,
0.0472517014,
-0.0547350422,
-0.0252684224,
-0.0343955941,
-0.0042157643,
-0.0059334212,
-0.0176356621,
-0.0052895341,
-0.0127663929,
-0.0070594912,
-0.0854569525,
-0.0303719658,
-0.0401432402,
0.0151185645,
-0.0023975312,
0.0163991526,
-0.0312327165,
0.0219065174,
-0.0315664671,
0.0335767232,
-0.025589386,
0.0547589362,
-0.0345972031,
-0.0274319369,
-0.002160823,
0.0188844316,
-0.0012351177,
-0.0321669877,
-0.0549163818,
-0.0776914284,
0.0410086773,
0.0161264166,
-0.0879051313,
-0.0360414274,
-0.0744116753,
0.012286745,
0.0353635214,
-0.0003335034,
0.0217201915,
0.0299756713,
-0.0547841638,
-0.0330467448,
0.0088850101,
0.0001656935,
-0.0480864868,
0.0252257362,
0.0112948315,
-0.0412583649,
-0.0028481965,
-0.019349169,
-0.0183849167,
-0.0177207086,
0.0540219694,
-0.0388518125,
0.0104856305,
-0.0315862037,
-0.0163025633,
0.0012656609,
0.0553789623,
0.0511183999,
-0.0883080512,
0.0432510786,
0.0402600877,
0.0506188609,
-0.0417802334,
0.0326304473,
0.0086392006,
0.011227712,
-0.0551092066,
-0.0397338979,
0.0504396521,
-0.0797921196,
0.0201732274,
-0.0287746843,
-0.0137341227,
-0.0152761471,
-0.0299069807,
-0.0383279733,
0.0102063017,
-0.0053149196,
-0.0059897997,
-0.0232138,
0.000254635,
-0.0038319181,
0.0585492477,
0.007573864,
-0.0175656024,
0.0251664948,
0.015375779,
-0.0266773514,
0.0649052337,
-0.0011537749,
0.0528658032,
-0.0666806251,
0.0189821515,
0.0408194549,
-0.0403809696,
-0.0366633348,
0.0095364451,
-0.0457180031,
0.0290181637,
0.0122231608,
0.0083912751,
0.0275277793,
0.0553759672,
-0.0185608771,
-0.0491595231,
0.0106798075,
0.0086778738,
0.0472658388,
-0.0414248109,
-0.0263718497,
0.0039742696,
-0.0009575738,
0.0247152932,
0.0348590687,
0.0254042819,
0.0023522954,
-0.0080489209,
0.0198753439,
0.0100344252,
-0.0290325023,
0.0212010257,
-0.0397277772,
0.0238143429,
0.0357682779,
-0.0399819538,
-0.025283346,
-0.0097879414,
-0.0113316486,
0.0487918369,
-0.0387831107,
0.0191373881,
-0.0660376772,
0.0195236746,
0.0442894846,
0.0334279872,
-0.0337776579,
0.015767673,
0.0594234802,
0.1002430692,
0.0306039564,
-0.0131834419,
-0.0536484197,
0.0560913421,
-0.0430340841,
-0.0479389131,
-0.0353214405,
-5.735851868e-33,
-0.0347863548,
-0.0161293503,
0.0029802534,
-0.0023764218,
0.0209285486,
-0.0402070098,
-0.0006760989,
-0.0123769566,
-0.025472695,
0.0237332378,
-0.0437115058,
0.0320755877,
0.0212072209,
-0.0047307736,
0.0450111367,
-0.0004979087,
0.0312086567,
0.0075192833,
0.0095335655,
0.0089098951,
0.0623441897,
0.0503601953,
0.0634398833,
-0.1306431741,
0.0159956645,
0.015747169,
-0.0053494531,
0.0090417629,
0.0305365343,
0.0646178648,
-0.013856316,
0.0412707627,
0.0036105174,
-0.0402101055,
0.0230506063,
0.0169839989,
-0.0597983114,
-0.0314088464,
0.0623432137,
0.0328834429,
-0.0293593071,
-0.0199666377,
-0.0491873994,
-0.0373075269,
-0.0506127253,
0.0354215242,
0.0562838539,
0.02118342,
-0.0310701896,
-0.0045547457,
-0.0890236422,
0.0419127941,
0.0082623046,
0.032955654,
0.0098700207,
0.0258863959,
0.0119916704,
0.0249386895,
-0.0185871962,
-0.0042233425,
-0.0080988826,
0.0443853475,
-0.0411169864,
-0.01772446,
-0.0249266364,
0.0209401697,
0.0146935647,
-0.0518872216,
0.0564421378,
0.0432824567,
-0.0151758511,
-0.0330333449,
0.0361840241,
0.0687078685,
0.0018121705,
-0.0030415738,
-0.0152504332,
0.0228489134,
-0.0196961164,
0.047213655,
0.0142759746,
0.0028578937,
-0.0457981825,
0.0245425683,
0.010558011,
-0.0306216646,
0.0146043412,
-0.0047557075,
0.000993274,
0.0147742266,
0.0118871601,
0.0339701213,
-0.0245210566,
-0.0095787868,
0.0500350595,
0.0258726943,
0.0240205247,
-0.038992241,
-0.0123637673,
-0.0113859549,
-0.0573706739,
-0.0187242106,
-0.0211384874,
-0.0179959293,
0.0147053162,
-0.047216624,
0.0112653263,
0.0028622514,
-0.0504757836,
0.0071817567,
0.0013505203,
0.0195077267,
-0.0228152703,
0.0155621497,
0.0023394558,
0.0002570612,
-0.0056496998,
0.0251252707,
0.0302613936,
-0.0160834771,
-0.0512508862,
-0.0548933782,
0.0007248938,
-0.0350735411,
0.0115982313,
0.0565197542,
-0.0367096066,
0.0417842381,
0.0226547681,
-0.0391695946,
0.0151842209,
0.0103627266,
2.956e-7,
0.0454092734,
-0.0128353816,
0.0259230006,
0.0217678733,
-0.0381423719,
-0.0003163017,
0.0547882542,
0.0259201247,
-0.0261356365,
0.0239815563,
0.0041397074,
-0.0091692964,
0.0219512992,
-0.0283851773,
-0.0832700282,
-0.037694633,
-0.0508010983,
-0.0382332355,
-0.0527183078,
0.0282398798,
0.0045628906,
0.1040753722,
0.0029240446,
-0.0115066376,
-0.0297183879,
-0.0107340785,
-0.0035765083,
-0.0043816618,
-0.0053233239,
0.0139952516,
0.0594888702,
-0.0344131999,
0.0229939502,
-0.0113111129,
-0.0150675103,
0.0454931818,
0.0483261123,
0.0355324559,
0.038730491,
0.0187043268,
-0.0128144138,
-0.0146342535,
-0.0180896819,
-0.0551570803,
0.0283547621,
0.0363270044,
0.0104879467,
-0.0094469963,
-0.0167813431,
0.0558448918,
0.0123708043,
0.0132997651,
-0.0379468352,
0.0295486636,
0.044627443,
0.004936995,
0.0160181802,
-0.0537994131,
0.0549847037,
-0.0295235701,
-0.0001485995,
0.0494194515,
-0.0212243516,
-0.0234442428,
0.0230486151,
-0.0149574913,
-0.0156136863,
2.363645699e-34,
0.0378792956,
0.0162493531,
-0.004410651,
-0.0073177125,
0.04231387,
0.0373500288,
-0.0063809999,
0.0168264825,
0.0016537926,
-0.0167371016,
0.0045481143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05117v1 | Unsupervised Translation Quality Estimation Exploiting Synthetic Data and Pre-trained Multilingual Encoder | 2023-11-09T03:10:42 | 2023-11-09T03:10:42 | Yuto Kuroda, Atsushi Fujita, Tomoyuki Kajiwara, Takashi Ninomiya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translation quality estimation (TQE) is the task of predicting translation
quality without reference translations. Due to the enormous cost of creating
training data for TQE, only a few translation directions can benefit from
supervised training. To address this issue, unsupervised TQE methods have been
studied. In this paper, we extensively investigate the usefulness of synthetic
TQE data and pre-trained multilingual encoders in unsupervised sentence-level
TQE, both of which have been proven effective in the supervised training
scenarios. Our experiment on WMT20 and WMT21 datasets revealed that this
approach can outperform other unsupervised TQE methods on high- and
low-resource translation directions in predicting post-editing effort and human
evaluation score, and some zero-resource translation directions in predicting
post-editing effort. | [
0.0442298464,
0.033057373,
0.0074000801,
0.0323420316,
0.0053888904,
-0.008516537,
0.0398290455,
0.023607282,
-0.0373986997,
-0.0024084202,
-0.0512360148,
-0.0498858169,
0.0257876087,
-0.0394046195,
0.0410034321,
-0.0174874794,
0.019162979,
0.0356827527,
-0.0323092639,
0.0002593602,
0.0052577052,
0.0136239743,
0.0263195913,
0.0262501594,
-0.0268136021,
-0.0198938604,
0.0247640181,
0.0513775498,
0.0404124483,
0.0145886047,
0.0120089054,
0.0777822509,
0.0013701606,
0.0341981165,
0.0000018726,
-0.0389138311,
-0.0568358526,
0.0074779708,
0.0272947978,
0.0254121535,
0.0464513041,
-0.0514928252,
-0.0441764779,
0.0261169299,
-0.0032854937,
-0.0087292781,
0.0490665324,
0.0087739751,
0.0928282216,
0.0805019587,
-0.0157051403,
-0.0209040567,
-0.0167436134,
-0.005171706,
-0.0079438696,
-0.0229734499,
-0.0362364426,
-0.0071663489,
-0.0884789675,
-0.0005524859,
-0.0115077011,
0.0290750135,
0.0296651423,
-0.0317195579,
-0.0103414068,
-0.0352748334,
-0.0527725108,
-0.0186466891,
0.0207464844,
0.0474225059,
-0.0386568159,
-0.0120869335,
-0.0321185067,
0.0047990549,
-0.0151140941,
-0.0289439298,
0.0050357985,
-0.0011187741,
0.0121145826,
-0.0079078805,
-0.0234789979,
0.0428964086,
-0.0108779911,
-0.0399131998,
-0.0027607577,
0.0085055679,
0.0299591366,
-0.0356251933,
-0.0210125018,
0.0304297954,
0.021379618,
0.0099205794,
0.0309996363,
-0.0387211181,
0.0028271584,
-0.0066181533,
-0.0367234796,
-0.0761941373,
-0.0133489305,
-0.0686432049,
0.0103977006,
0.029456716,
-0.0077511873,
0.015938947,
-0.0217500664,
0.0481523238,
0.0148304822,
0.0067487666,
-0.0515993014,
-0.029049905,
-0.0319384187,
0.0314922556,
-0.0158155803,
-0.0127049405,
-0.0295636635,
0.0190732926,
-0.0559832416,
-0.0232644733,
0.0034583746,
0.0011647873,
0.0511809066,
-0.0030643661,
-0.0686437786,
-0.0145425033,
-0.0057753231,
0.043252334,
-0.0040913848,
-0.0087336162,
-0.0216871779,
-0.0298273433,
-0.0070647011,
0.0345625505,
0.0516266935,
-0.0351652354,
0.0152490307,
0.0586150736,
-0.0212818217,
0.0003106956,
-0.0451603532,
-0.0277718715,
0.002439538,
-0.0298864916,
-0.0101992562,
-0.0721908957,
0.0595590286,
0.000204432,
0.0024694011,
-0.0273879115,
-0.001941403,
-0.0061250827,
-0.0063641644,
0.0169902109,
-0.0418240279,
0.0119944625,
0.0095916092,
-0.0255918633,
0.0460229889,
0.053706497,
0.0444060564,
0.0255162995,
0.0706378892,
-0.0114974575,
0.0223547332,
0.0661105365,
-0.0139980661,
0.0453652479,
-0.0086387778,
-0.0106767667,
0.0208488349,
0.0123068541,
0.040912047,
0.0355038829,
-0.0301287789,
0.0500226282,
0.061670348,
-0.017252421,
0.0530070812,
0.0271811336,
0.0554646552,
0.0203766413,
-0.000650949,
0.0198915433,
0.0242176522,
0.0406779572,
0.022837745,
-0.008700314,
0.0859485418,
0.0170947742,
-0.0083300723,
-0.0682910904,
-0.0035583028,
-0.0200318452,
-0.0084204236,
-0.0700045899,
0.0238068718,
0.0217129942,
-0.0632597506,
-0.0153947137,
-0.010023932,
-0.0830677003,
0.0244302526,
0.0178606883,
-0.0363403186,
0.0838153362,
0.0636902303,
0.0174948182,
-0.0007476571,
-0.0237509813,
-0.0231927466,
0.0509501398,
0.02559302,
-0.0081558172,
0.0407864079,
-0.0569833964,
-0.0675734505,
-0.004511958,
0.010622317,
-0.000631407,
-0.0156382844,
0.0288369302,
0.040965464,
-0.0749553144,
-0.0886769593,
0.0139591256,
0.0461300947,
-0.0253276229,
0.0284688529,
0.0309374221,
0.0192818772,
0.0323598236,
-0.0328304544,
-0.0217185803,
-0.0211407579,
-0.0289223362,
-0.0191072263,
0.034419179,
0.001828409,
-0.0804470256,
-0.0014836,
-0.0646270812,
-0.0099171419,
0.0163357761,
-0.0447258428,
-0.0531607792,
-0.0286079273,
-0.0277922712,
0.0204045027,
-0.0600469448,
0.0318428613,
-0.0295599196,
-0.0155742746,
-0.0032637997,
0.0067412057,
0.0069805426,
0.0444826223,
0.0017728474,
-0.0349302851,
0.0298311114,
0.0101757953,
-0.0217436962,
0.018905282,
0.0166977458,
0.0462979227,
0.05591584,
0.0507855751,
-0.0196186472,
-0.0321221836,
-0.029184103,
0.0067655323,
-0.0445796102,
0.0437936857,
0.0513983555,
0.0065238629,
0.0039986293,
0.0048604137,
-0.0191039182,
-0.0433182046,
0.0111167086,
-0.0014597675,
0.0259778984,
0.0019761946,
0.0429495983,
-0.0389789417,
-0.0032735479,
0.0218220036,
0.0308821462,
0.0207811054,
-0.0351033174,
-0.063588284,
0.0377898254,
-0.0333977379,
-0.0301714744,
0.0449028797,
-0.1023259237,
0.0028206629,
0.0203702319,
0.0579018854,
0.0145648327,
-0.0044176718,
-0.0134062646,
0.0537000075,
0.0197494105,
-0.0383397713,
-0.0123558547,
-0.0052256216,
-0.0194649715,
-0.0031355792,
-0.0403864086,
0.0437062085,
0.0129660657,
0.0368777551,
-0.017209528,
-0.0675223395,
0.0236073211,
-0.0156397074,
-0.012165484,
0.0041027945,
0.0296571665,
0.0123334071,
0.0738677531,
0.0077845021,
-0.0330488309,
0.0548282452,
-0.0307224449,
-0.0061285794,
-0.0490289964,
0.0324974544,
-0.0051363544,
0.000488121,
-0.0093754325,
0.0434226915,
-0.0412981659,
-0.0083920797,
-0.0414115861,
0.0377020799,
0.0517085902,
-0.0023914382,
-0.029021766,
-0.0242105108,
-0.0297423787,
-0.0081210127,
0.0207840372,
-0.0072855963,
0.0051671509,
0.0281747188,
-0.0250044707,
0.0361068286,
0.0050207162,
0.0203642752,
0.0043181158,
0.0094086519,
0.0962197557,
-0.0132528907,
-0.0047300849,
0.014408946,
0.0088104531,
-0.0077869263,
-0.0368870497,
-0.0062251799,
-0.0734364614,
0.0261248946,
0.0085671339,
-0.0309543163,
-0.0345594101,
0.0147207575,
-0.0413880423,
0.0173825882,
-0.0015663842,
-0.0177343283,
-0.0044637765,
0.0469892211,
-0.0626119152,
-0.0023571069,
0.1167158633,
0.0422053486,
-0.0315674096,
-0.0200317781,
-0.0187245235,
-0.0135497116,
0.0331096612,
0.0204397123,
-0.0597740784,
-0.0055440534,
-0.01859322,
0.0400915965,
-0.006259935,
0.0112640681,
-0.0073804557,
-0.0956263393,
0.0356791839,
0.0251540374,
-0.0115640247,
-0.0192409288,
-0.0090242913,
-0.0219445415,
-0.0327721313,
-0.0053817476,
-0.0119842375,
0.0367543921,
0.0242731478,
-0.0121443914,
-0.0562091991,
-0.0739048719,
-0.019061476,
-0.0573330745,
-0.0041182814,
0.0584919527,
0.0362605155,
-0.0223297942,
-0.0499313474,
0.0320166349,
-0.0279241335,
-0.0063289292,
-0.0135376109,
0.0786913857,
-0.0148564111,
-0.01581854,
0.0181233082,
-0.0280615445,
-0.0061665569,
0.0307211597,
0.0214023478,
0.0285195466,
-0.0156319942,
0.0112719163,
0.0317242704,
-0.0168814529,
-0.0179478209,
0.0339064971,
0.0223856755,
-0.0698673502,
0.007507042,
-0.0343417302,
-0.0072849952,
-0.061868865,
-0.0336315259,
-0.0107130567,
-0.0634922981,
-0.0324781314,
-0.1225570291,
-0.0827724934,
0.0176886152,
0.035285715,
0.0056971507,
-0.0091716507,
-0.0308504887,
-0.0227827951,
0.0026482472,
-0.0222427566,
0.0063103479,
-0.0034341512,
-0.0440995917,
0.0002136813,
0.008546521,
0.0056229597,
0.0072160386,
-0.018551996,
-0.0052700196,
-0.0339741521,
-0.0556371771,
0.0556991808,
0.0097087938,
0.0478657596,
-0.0313580669,
-0.0040643043,
0.0205777846,
0.0098905936,
-0.0103799496,
-0.0004987437,
0.0614331663,
-0.0042159571,
-0.026274072,
0.0322679877,
-0.0159785226,
0.0038974183,
0.0064039906,
0.0243179444,
0.0125048393,
-0.0473850593,
0.0184510872,
0.0068080677,
0.046860382,
-0.0388385467,
0.0038161951,
-0.0758620277,
0.0207309891,
-0.0411593802,
-0.0365421139,
-0.054875534,
0.0213976167,
0.0149135152,
0.0266392305,
-0.0350797549,
0.068968758,
-0.0662308931,
-0.0323621966,
-0.0061331927,
0.0244743191,
-0.0182253476,
0.0087690288,
-0.0214494448,
0.0322027281,
-0.0246598572,
-0.0167208668,
0.0141544137,
0.0177336112,
-0.0182236284,
0.020588493,
-0.0066840597,
0.0357242823,
0.0352010056,
0.0578909777,
-0.0173872933,
0.0414181687,
-0.0677433312,
0.0052287835,
0.0604050942,
-0.0337205157,
0.1040853038,
0.0173099916,
-0.0077322517,
-0.0218796674,
0.0681811497,
0.0162465665,
-0.017804062,
-0.0267203506,
-0.0359276794,
-0.0244077034,
0.0125440825,
0.0664952397,
-0.0304573961,
0.0021746929,
-0.0410548598,
-0.0212950949,
-0.0299748536,
0.0179348961,
-0.0055138189,
-0.0393179171,
-0.0018990613,
-0.0118242111,
-0.0080929026,
-0.0400449857,
-0.0019319507,
0.0284345988,
-0.0036130464,
0.0002747601,
-0.0001806401,
0.0726743639,
-0.0581825376,
0.0257285368,
-0.0400640666,
-0.0734957978,
0.0294677857,
-0.0020884965,
-0.000968237,
-5.680533104e-33,
-0.0076255817,
-0.0055302819,
-0.0410059802,
-0.0247794539,
-0.0020083569,
-0.0119185923,
-0.027908925,
-0.0382746942,
0.0313591436,
0.006311683,
0.0010736712,
0.0052042347,
0.0233912934,
-0.0160773192,
0.0265273359,
0.0458647497,
0.0867888853,
0.0070946063,
-0.0436889268,
-0.0081009148,
0.024033824,
0.0075504342,
0.1264606416,
-0.0166620165,
0.0374325849,
-0.0185065251,
-0.0252169017,
0.0070659113,
0.0708687678,
0.0275317114,
0.0458713546,
0.031881284,
0.0127446242,
-0.0537417121,
-0.0158640426,
-0.0694587082,
0.0027842338,
-0.0132889803,
-0.0166505966,
0.0337913707,
-0.0176675692,
-0.0591354407,
0.031723097,
-0.044835452,
-0.0340238512,
-0.0093659339,
0.0503016934,
-0.0461442545,
0.0110862656,
-0.0736652464,
-0.057432659,
0.0432543419,
-0.0148869343,
-0.0139071522,
-0.003467845,
0.0631619096,
0.001033649,
-0.020227734,
-0.104001604,
0.0009463424,
-0.0137223611,
0.0452291481,
0.0560702309,
-0.0246912111,
-0.0148569429,
0.0036327755,
0.0035770643,
0.0206587669,
0.058974091,
0.0284631867,
0.0332849286,
-0.0162725598,
0.0668187216,
0.0920424685,
0.0302332081,
-0.0267005432,
-0.0546127409,
0.0995744914,
-0.0698444694,
0.006434903,
-0.0192566458,
0.0119950091,
0.0066153486,
-0.0187982898,
-0.027006628,
-0.0370394997,
-0.0100119952,
-0.0379812419,
0.0023299071,
0.0004182809,
-0.0422504768,
-0.0381662585,
0.0737356842,
-0.0217527226,
0.0304736234,
-0.0016847975,
-0.0803004354,
0.0314425789,
-0.004882819,
0.0195847526,
0.0068886527,
0.0178648364,
0.0231365263,
0.0466583744,
0.0120583959,
-0.0386938304,
0.0793229267,
0.0307533927,
-0.0800795406,
0.0331272036,
-0.0144849736,
0.0055684736,
-0.036366649,
-0.0134245958,
-0.0117896516,
-0.0418489575,
-0.0187827498,
0.0483776964,
0.0243050829,
0.0343846865,
-0.0370310433,
0.0019178176,
0.0291861333,
0.0301346891,
-0.0296399072,
0.0335472785,
-0.0131440135,
0.007338739,
0.0428587645,
-0.0311359186,
-0.0312410332,
-0.0227041151,
2.511e-7,
0.0499258712,
0.058100868,
0.0119587202,
-0.0108433515,
-0.0039357343,
0.0164234582,
-0.0420435295,
0.0280178878,
-0.0135387219,
0.01984022,
0.0545307845,
-0.0060725594,
0.0568976365,
0.0427765809,
-0.0517269112,
-0.0011673202,
-0.0510959215,
0.0016130598,
-0.0576197058,
-0.0242219102,
0.063571237,
0.0732768998,
-0.0318202861,
0.0011777173,
-0.0192737747,
0.0178581774,
0.0865932852,
0.0115411812,
-0.0456892699,
0.0213455893,
0.0460586287,
-0.0163009483,
0.0060865483,
-0.018881524,
-0.0576783828,
0.0209957957,
0.0595252439,
0.0659513474,
0.0016358837,
0.0059772534,
0.0587902777,
0.0047551114,
-0.0147386231,
0.001915513,
0.0590066724,
-0.0054080733,
-0.0032710291,
0.0380635522,
-0.0355200805,
0.0372292325,
0.0690403655,
-0.0477974042,
-0.041084595,
0.0381013528,
0.0301547516,
0.0053674174,
-0.0044130883,
-0.0035426619,
-0.0382206663,
-0.0056662792,
0.0369363539,
-0.0645976886,
0.0303107835,
-0.0116615463,
0.0134909693,
-0.0254498739,
0.0238295719,
1.866744607e-34,
0.071037218,
-0.0120849377,
0.0517972484,
-0.0675801635,
0.0390114635,
-0.0241136067,
-0.0089751389,
-0.0437176414,
-0.0135608343,
-0.0018847652,
-0.0263710469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05113v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05113v1 | Conic10K: A Challenging Math Problem Understanding and Reasoning Dataset | 2023-11-09T02:58:17 | 2023-11-09T02:58:17 | Haoyi Wu, Wenyang Hui, Yezeng Chen, Weiqi Wu, Kewei Tu, Yi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical understanding and reasoning are crucial tasks for assessing the
capabilities of artificial intelligence (AI). However, existing benchmarks
either require just a few steps of reasoning, or only contain a small amount of
data in one specific topic, making it hard to analyse AI's behaviour with
reference to different problems within a specific topic in detail. In this
work, we propose Conic10K, a challenging math problem dataset on conic sections
in Chinese senior high school education. Our dataset contains various problems
with different reasoning depths, while only the knowledge from conic sections
is required. Since the dataset only involves a narrow range of knowledge, it is
easy to separately analyse the knowledge a model possesses and the reasoning
ability it has. For each problem, we provide a high-quality formal
representation, the reasoning steps, and the final solution. Experiments show
that existing large language models, including GPT-4, exhibit weak performance
on complex reasoning. We hope that our findings could inspire more advanced
techniques for precise natural language understanding and reasoning. Our
dataset and codes are available at https://github.com/whyNLP/Conic10K. | [
-0.0154016623,
0.0722734034,
-0.0063658669,
0.0576466955,
-0.0305917431,
0.0301600005,
0.0399613455,
-0.0228943881,
-0.0357918628,
-0.0073685539,
0.0245420225,
-0.012352393,
0.0186170619,
0.031530425,
-0.0113983685,
-0.0622686446,
-0.0022512749,
-0.0390439406,
0.0245069265,
-0.0093884896,
-0.0405415706,
-0.0024486596,
-0.0491695888,
0.0117656579,
-0.0348000303,
-0.071060352,
-0.0036709872,
-0.0385320336,
0.0200945791,
-0.0253231414,
0.0096774977,
0.0189639516,
0.016695004,
0.0387711152,
0.0000021269,
-0.0549109541,
-0.0240116138,
0.0031068553,
-0.062880151,
0.0198419672,
-0.0336806141,
-0.0048450087,
0.0019524124,
0.0121675506,
-0.0808909461,
0.0153607354,
-0.0029808853,
0.0428465344,
0.0735318065,
0.0704115704,
-0.0022164879,
-0.0463898405,
0.0335129909,
0.0132842902,
0.0198486168,
-0.0737223402,
0.0215883721,
0.0588060468,
0.0095162038,
-0.0080184042,
-0.0276887212,
0.0165239833,
0.0822237879,
-0.0003568115,
-0.0530921668,
0.0000772516,
-0.0599117614,
-0.0008005493,
0.0124767683,
0.0776806846,
0.0004929682,
-0.0172953922,
-0.0165786855,
-0.0008914028,
-0.0081147887,
0.0009857379,
-0.0543888509,
0.0202621296,
-0.0208609682,
0.011254292,
-0.0034865625,
-0.0149412155,
0.0139626786,
0.004084581,
-0.0427739248,
0.109526962,
-0.0049214801,
-0.0324240029,
-0.0066685565,
-0.0164284892,
-0.0735603496,
-0.0377983451,
0.0188771114,
0.0653639883,
0.0279055499,
0.0215254109,
0.0074735577,
-0.0248888712,
-0.035371311,
-0.0158602204,
0.0054213782,
0.0604825988,
0.0335273109,
0.0497879945,
-0.0189106837,
0.0881214291,
-0.0082631502,
0.0466100238,
-0.007970701,
-0.0157981738,
-0.0497503541,
-0.0261621475,
-0.0500061214,
0.0622813702,
0.0167993233,
0.0155019555,
-0.0484078638,
-0.000963747,
-0.046774406,
0.0425565429,
0.016577214,
-0.0177736692,
0.0087246345,
-0.0313342959,
-0.0414604731,
0.0109646581,
-0.0646900162,
0.005779908,
-0.0240322948,
-0.0142793646,
-0.0146791758,
-0.0169346966,
0.0087771928,
-0.0272614583,
0.0141663924,
0.0366564766,
0.0381106324,
0.0051102941,
-0.0229413509,
-0.037205223,
0.0195861757,
-0.0926011503,
0.0096595893,
-0.0723224208,
0.0299885739,
0.0205834638,
-0.0200790465,
-0.0455810539,
-0.0101847369,
0.0074760318,
0.0311336834,
0.0724298432,
0.0020654763,
-0.0168264732,
0.020724928,
0.0336056352,
-0.0160906091,
0.0378258564,
0.0693659559,
-0.0037829387,
0.0276025739,
-0.0019181321,
-0.0074495771,
0.0122781005,
0.0194403771,
-0.0108370502,
-0.0228685662,
0.0329175703,
-0.0247985106,
0.0378093757,
-0.052521795,
0.0292131156,
0.0072771194,
-0.0002892051,
0.001577225,
0.0621381961,
-0.0257106591,
0.0190014672,
0.0311457701,
-0.0069413576,
0.0560884513,
-0.0120846145,
-0.0669885203,
0.0218082666,
-0.0137343872,
-0.0205134638,
-0.007516427,
-0.0102949953,
0.0004869091,
-0.1035902277,
-0.0215269998,
-0.0080340151,
0.0019387014,
0.0137358718,
0.0755707771,
-0.0386919454,
0.0258793905,
0.0006779917,
0.0157192089,
-0.0588447675,
-0.0150296604,
-0.0328241698,
0.0437503345,
0.0063502188,
0.0580769815,
-0.0735893771,
-0.0435045511,
0.016238898,
0.0225114226,
0.0187885407,
0.0692323521,
-0.0103737293,
-0.0049412064,
-0.0435573794,
-0.019299468,
-0.0353453308,
0.0230404716,
-0.0032520425,
0.0127032762,
0.0166744683,
0.0120171048,
-0.0202398803,
0.0123096257,
0.0044651856,
-0.0427576527,
-0.021189766,
-0.0144019816,
0.0122499941,
0.0018792161,
0.0142802401,
0.0130530968,
0.0140872691,
0.0195872691,
-0.0163877141,
-0.0241640676,
-0.0162710045,
-0.0462387986,
-0.0316964351,
0.0726134852,
-0.0880416557,
-0.045936875,
0.0519765913,
-0.0555865467,
-0.0419041812,
0.075913772,
0.0108653298,
0.0096444041,
0.0088593736,
0.0343183503,
-0.0179445557,
0.0061016749,
0.0185565948,
0.090155296,
0.0306288321,
0.0259505045,
0.0219470374,
0.0299417879,
0.0587381795,
0.0064465026,
0.0000826557,
-0.0207074936,
-0.0191600174,
0.0203609746,
0.0041149082,
0.0066217054,
-0.0216019321,
0.0277518816,
-0.0171782468,
0.0162920337,
0.0195278171,
0.0298503451,
0.0151177086,
-0.0488220192,
0.0052402709,
-0.0055016549,
-0.0346958488,
0.0162149742,
-0.0260735136,
-0.0422424003,
0.0563238896,
0.0024478124,
-0.0261739139,
-0.0102452179,
-0.0212246086,
-0.0940066278,
0.0068879589,
0.0380963944,
0.0615929328,
-0.0074616834,
0.0224942043,
-0.0337198935,
0.0221219417,
-0.0104331439,
-0.0192814246,
0.0420238599,
-0.0213460792,
0.00916442,
0.0796178356,
-0.0224984828,
0.0540137962,
0.0217131134,
-0.0273249112,
-0.0332308896,
0.0401162729,
-0.0015716323,
0.0214161146,
-0.0317963324,
-0.0401613601,
-0.0285199322,
0.0748337284,
-0.0039962656,
-0.0294896979,
-0.052190125,
0.0557082035,
-0.0252080262,
0.0363748446,
-0.0489131398,
0.0213689338,
0.004957451,
0.0639594123,
-0.0157426298,
0.0003800798,
0.0525757335,
0.0059186365,
0.0109506231,
-0.0599840917,
0.0102327056,
-0.0627245307,
0.0616001301,
0.0108512184,
-0.0183398798,
-0.0117016425,
0.0052923644,
-0.0378393829,
0.005991179,
0.0264608581,
-0.0240169838,
0.0480498672,
-0.0768025517,
-0.0129542556,
-0.0217692349,
-0.0391788408,
-0.0214296319,
0.0330138914,
-0.0118758008,
0.0425832495,
0.0067395954,
-0.0643337741,
0.0129841883,
-0.0152658038,
0.0061932835,
0.0367757007,
-0.0368347466,
-0.0224918313,
-0.0269987304,
-0.007862675,
0.0367517956,
0.0213185977,
0.0373113267,
-0.0396097712,
0.0244130827,
0.0387418345,
0.045520585,
0.0326838493,
-0.0284063481,
0.0245438199,
-0.010055108,
-0.0240527652,
-0.0170107633,
0.0203678831,
0.0228474624,
-0.08547277,
-0.0298387017,
0.1251049787,
0.0436182581,
-0.0297498796,
-0.0049417769,
-0.0545349605,
-0.0139236962,
0.0295449458,
-0.0073561869,
-0.0951718837,
-0.0359350294,
0.0161641426,
-0.004814506,
0.0006606829,
-0.0399725102,
-0.0072572455,
-0.1091026142,
0.0148106357,
0.0105570573,
-0.0219106469,
-0.0568747669,
-0.0389080755,
-0.0077149523,
-0.0018135257,
-0.0078933872,
-0.0094563216,
0.0288152639,
0.013988005,
0.017067397,
-0.0266108047,
-0.0233015232,
0.0520503037,
0.0078955432,
-0.0045579839,
-0.0048347767,
0.063593328,
-0.0309526604,
-0.0430444553,
0.0341773443,
0.0305599533,
-0.0584675372,
0.0072659943,
0.0332108848,
0.0201196261,
0.0041426108,
-0.011274307,
0.0392707996,
-0.0772806481,
-0.0151483733,
0.0681533366,
0.1202799976,
-0.0141931763,
-0.0152036129,
-0.0114994543,
-0.0019912685,
-0.0355257988,
0.0910483301,
0.038285546,
-0.0024183574,
-0.0624106824,
-0.071450159,
-0.035112489,
-0.0614317991,
-0.0028750955,
0.0407073908,
0.0648241043,
-0.0080885496,
-0.0303855836,
-0.032938391,
0.0402503088,
0.0164256878,
0.0093408534,
-0.0550245158,
0.0344649516,
0.0077287871,
-0.0343848914,
0.0360555761,
-0.0305888392,
0.0118699018,
-0.0634400398,
0.0219026525,
-0.0089014554,
-0.0210885499,
-0.0488483794,
0.0311826877,
-0.1061513573,
-0.0421627313,
-0.004264087,
0.0094236545,
0.025196325,
0.0042149588,
-0.0067728171,
-0.0038856191,
-0.0136103407,
-0.0300261602,
-0.0287014563,
-0.0169693343,
0.0274040718,
-0.0029895918,
0.0172034856,
0.0220063124,
-0.0034872347,
0.0275933519,
0.0124888374,
0.0162785742,
-0.0554111116,
0.0274883192,
0.0322578289,
0.0472817346,
0.0123118116,
0.0607255474,
-0.0285144225,
-0.0087604597,
0.0484924242,
-0.05595183,
-0.0151567161,
-0.0420025475,
0.0015214098,
0.024463864,
-0.0266228784,
0.0011239202,
-0.0337447301,
0.0310980901,
0.0142494533,
-0.0093668923,
0.0451716855,
0.002963793,
0.029916821,
0.025029894,
-0.0685244277,
0.0249273032,
-0.0113310907,
-0.0261832178,
0.0658769831,
-0.0099302214,
0.0465935916,
0.0277528446,
0.0013931718,
-0.0066969967,
-0.0177006051,
-0.0337438509,
-0.094130896,
0.0259506945,
0.0092617543,
0.0357243232,
0.0178479962,
-0.0144287581,
-0.0577649213,
0.0139437765,
0.0035188834,
0.0129248444,
0.0320467502,
-0.0271141883,
0.0290634912,
0.0367138535,
0.0246568304,
-0.0275999848,
0.0315753631,
-0.0338984616,
0.038446784,
0.0072278744,
-0.002286013,
-0.0296099335,
-0.0093705487,
0.0028021222,
0.0302066822,
-0.0088232504,
0.0217468888,
-0.0523180105,
-0.0825991929,
-0.0173944328,
0.0075470936,
-0.0126536163,
0.0213048141,
0.027694745,
0.0412646271,
-0.0517991744,
-0.0356366374,
0.011868882,
0.0055251196,
-0.0195569824,
-0.0185189359,
-0.0225842893,
-5.933643486e-33,
-0.0330844112,
-0.0310814269,
0.0410512723,
0.0131512964,
0.0454768874,
-0.0092156203,
-0.0469046347,
0.0054141204,
-0.0358923897,
0.0103568863,
0.0048398408,
0.0484242998,
0.0005130074,
0.0231753401,
-0.008418791,
-0.0248979758,
-0.0283195712,
-0.0117727239,
-0.0418382883,
0.0138544701,
0.047465194,
-0.0094464812,
0.0879389942,
-0.0671559945,
0.0252544433,
0.0074449596,
0.0031569549,
0.0320282392,
-0.0600045584,
0.0585751273,
0.0033779787,
0.0262024403,
0.0420734845,
-0.0109288255,
0.0204049014,
0.0011045164,
-0.0529406555,
-0.0616224222,
-0.0041386131,
0.0371343531,
-0.0523777418,
-0.0556290336,
0.029030066,
0.0180753004,
-0.0097688446,
-0.042006325,
0.0599367283,
-0.0320446119,
0.0407266617,
0.0223111212,
-0.0223467257,
0.0355458148,
-0.0813139305,
-0.0152016422,
-0.0042443806,
0.0576804541,
-0.0202697236,
0.0093815122,
-0.0323142782,
0.020874273,
0.0228168499,
0.0081779929,
0.0173351653,
-0.0434678867,
0.0310762506,
0.0110702515,
0.0439064652,
-0.0442333035,
-0.0373125337,
-0.02149822,
0.0361826606,
0.0535822026,
0.0656320006,
0.0005227803,
0.0747702196,
0.0064789681,
-0.0867335647,
-0.0075038369,
0.0304008983,
0.047201056,
-0.0009017942,
-0.0345631316,
-0.0773999318,
0.003028848,
-0.033070378,
-0.0160241462,
-0.0400270596,
-0.0055229496,
0.0272836369,
-0.0427322723,
0.0090308134,
0.011423938,
0.0155290021,
-0.0505527481,
0.0175401978,
0.0593864061,
0.0273734722,
0.0276595838,
0.0148998499,
0.0600838922,
-0.0179889016,
-0.0255955141,
-0.0211016349,
-0.0142034842,
0.044776801,
0.0180308558,
0.0195101164,
0.0232418608,
-0.0292382501,
-0.0382144786,
-0.0502318293,
-0.0395087563,
0.0318985283,
0.0241670609,
0.0320046842,
0.0433152616,
0.0039209733,
0.0062228898,
-0.009762275,
0.0100037958,
-0.0330762304,
0.0193547588,
-0.018346915,
-0.0000201874,
0.000216376,
-0.0515337549,
-0.0260690618,
0.0043059667,
0.0293970779,
-0.0625027865,
-0.0069877873,
0.0056098835,
2.742e-7,
0.0459694974,
0.0330638289,
0.0145582864,
0.0625541881,
0.0183136873,
0.0118391681,
-0.0498118512,
-0.0468273424,
-0.0048428643,
-0.0068980018,
0.0182739142,
0.0668544993,
0.0415406339,
0.0489286147,
-0.0465915091,
0.0218637772,
0.0039875642,
-0.0339695364,
-0.0536784343,
0.0694440156,
0.0607359335,
0.07112059,
0.0427496508,
0.0099449977,
-0.0057479721,
-0.0490500852,
0.0061682593,
0.008429152,
0.0251049083,
0.0417549238,
-0.0124139609,
-0.0012292244,
0.0054944679,
0.0178569257,
-0.0020335233,
0.0377283357,
0.0208568461,
0.0706187189,
0.0027330581,
-0.0011243841,
-0.0157482028,
-0.0568253249,
-0.0041402304,
-0.0332465209,
0.0777255595,
-0.0501044095,
-0.056709975,
0.0088106301,
0.0074801082,
-0.0274885651,
-0.0101353666,
0.007426132,
0.0354094394,
-0.0138656115,
0.0127862114,
-0.0486962609,
0.0326540545,
-0.0522497967,
-0.005311287,
0.0105859889,
-0.0412804224,
-0.0239959825,
-0.0329259634,
-0.0206278097,
0.0623306744,
-0.0127392467,
-0.0007311541,
2.622000761e-34,
0.0337384343,
-0.0348788351,
0.0236910917,
0.0075971307,
0.0583678745,
-0.0298013594,
-0.0039197584,
-0.0007088105,
0.0335609056,
-0.0587940887,
-0.0215808395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05112v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05112v5 | A Survey of Large Language Models in Medicine: Progress, Application, and Challenge | 2023-11-09T02:55:58 | 2024-05-15T13:38:45 | Hongjian Zhou, Fenglin Liu, Boyang Gu, Xinyu Zou, Jinfa Huang, Jinge Wu, Yiru Li, Sam S. Chen, Peilin Zhou, Junling Liu, Yining Hua, Chengfeng Mao, Chenyu You, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng, Lei Clifton, Zheng Li, Jiebo Luo, David A. Clifton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have received substantial
attention due to their capabilities for understanding and generating human
language. While there has been a burgeoning trend in research focusing on the
employment of LLMs in supporting different medical tasks (e.g., enhancing
clinical diagnostics and providing medical education), a review of these
efforts, particularly their development, practical applications, and outcomes
in medicine, remains scarce. Therefore, this review aims to provide a detailed
overview of the development and deployment of LLMs in medicine, including the
challenges and opportunities they face. In terms of development, we provide a
detailed introduction to the principles of existing medical LLMs, including
their basic model structures, number of parameters, and sources and scales of
data used for model development. It serves as a guide for practitioners in
developing medical LLMs tailored to their specific needs. In terms of
deployment, we offer a comparison of the performance of different LLMs across
various medical tasks, and further compare them with state-of-the-art
lightweight models, aiming to provide an understanding of the advantages and
limitations of LLMs in medicine. Overall, in this review, we address the
following questions: 1) What are the practices for developing medical LLMs 2)
How to measure the medical task performance of LLMs in a medical setting? 3)
How have medical LLMs been employed in real-world practice? 4) What challenges
arise from the use of medical LLMs? and 5) How to more effectively develop and
deploy medical LLMs? By answering these questions, this review aims to provide
insights into the opportunities for LLMs in medicine and serve as a practical
resource. We also maintain a regularly updated list of practical guides on
medical LLMs at: https://github.com/AI-in-Health/MedLLMsPracticalGuide. | [
0.0394660756,
0.0414409339,
-0.0066737765,
-0.0214323457,
-0.0395206213,
0.028236419,
0.007050876,
0.0396022126,
0.0303074028,
0.0035023948,
-0.0242303666,
-0.084659934,
0.0303813312,
0.0406725779,
0.0282994267,
-0.049638547,
0.0431192517,
-0.0193512253,
0.0246068314,
-0.0039561684,
-0.005814888,
0.0103070913,
-0.038137719,
0.0696987957,
-0.0015535499,
-0.01035887,
0.0232071672,
-0.0220414456,
0.0001779626,
-0.0572508872,
-0.0472959056,
0.0343147218,
0.0038228221,
0.0045929933,
0.0000020594,
-0.0704905763,
0.0095074046,
0.0332396701,
-0.0329483263,
-0.0352673493,
0.0614175871,
-0.031469468,
-0.0093867257,
0.0117075974,
-0.032417357,
-0.0114288228,
0.0467870831,
0.0045390259,
0.0207010619,
0.0597696416,
-0.0117811896,
0.0080018314,
0.0399614386,
-0.0479897782,
0.0168461315,
-0.0279120393,
0.0591729209,
0.0334548503,
0.0642526597,
-0.0007577741,
-0.000303305,
0.0652550384,
-0.0031412572,
0.0222194772,
0.0025727972,
0.0538404547,
-0.0250575785,
-0.0471340939,
0.0058306572,
0.0175782386,
-0.0056008478,
-0.0133892037,
0.0421312973,
0.0203870162,
-0.0129554709,
-0.0176545829,
-0.0538372509,
0.0038300885,
-0.013760699,
0.00436011,
0.0160577204,
-0.0274759158,
0.0295313559,
-0.017995175,
-0.0221856851,
-0.0003797055,
0.0260764193,
-0.0077541946,
-0.0014193582,
-0.006347598,
-0.0309593193,
-0.0429401882,
0.0355538502,
0.0507424586,
-0.0602664873,
0.01390706,
-0.0132553484,
-0.0250421893,
0.092061542,
-0.0744461566,
0.0171712786,
0.001990201,
0.0033054312,
0.0222762022,
-0.0080158776,
0.0308003239,
-0.0319189057,
0.0397520363,
-0.0516312942,
0.0163110271,
-0.0460280478,
-0.0299203582,
-0.0257272609,
0.0050974539,
-0.0044611143,
-0.0155992666,
-0.0961014554,
0.0066925534,
-0.0073561454,
-0.009203949,
0.0114906961,
0.031191323,
-0.0193617586,
-0.0057500461,
-0.0043052589,
0.0078180693,
0.0279563852,
0.0058697481,
-0.0276440699,
-0.0572534055,
0.0255655348,
0.0133259278,
-0.0355761275,
-0.0029440506,
0.0077962694,
0.0934997275,
0.0314394236,
-0.0117306169,
0.0251165293,
-0.0212113801,
-0.0470255837,
-0.0568971112,
0.0194517113,
-0.0691548362,
0.0403277464,
0.0329434201,
0.0175623614,
-0.0491175167,
0.005964167,
-0.003682314,
-0.0558113419,
0.0545974672,
-0.0315424986,
0.0258254912,
0.0286424458,
0.0355894379,
0.0039854427,
0.025121836,
0.0479412861,
-0.0553682148,
-0.009698784,
-0.0435553938,
-0.0038654262,
0.0337317102,
-0.0047130799,
-0.032579612,
-0.021357378,
-0.0070432513,
0.0217098091,
0.0964691043,
-0.0299454574,
0.0865890607,
0.0140307657,
-0.0038168617,
0.0298182536,
0.0754190981,
0.0423929244,
0.0102575887,
0.031186007,
-0.0262292121,
0.0199056342,
-0.0325388014,
-0.0015203228,
0.0037129913,
0.0160226803,
-0.015785357,
-0.0379665606,
0.0304839201,
-0.0353956446,
-0.037362583,
-0.0668077841,
-0.0262146126,
-0.0063775633,
0.0048283138,
0.0499414466,
-0.0473168008,
-0.002257542,
0.0421463847,
0.0618079416,
-0.0272931475,
-0.0058922591,
-0.0964856222,
-0.0158114061,
0.070768632,
0.0532527529,
-0.0320847072,
-0.0323282592,
-0.0041867481,
0.0038385219,
0.0216155015,
0.0222104117,
0.005964017,
0.0091880653,
-0.0408671685,
0.0116630672,
0.0555153228,
0.0011243136,
-0.0240994468,
-0.0110243177,
0.0184951406,
-0.0170430019,
-0.015910415,
-0.0206988025,
0.0349708311,
-0.0943386033,
0.0057035261,
0.009975601,
-0.0208714921,
0.0395869203,
0.0110113258,
-0.0147880558,
0.0420939848,
0.0222018007,
-0.0389825106,
-0.0092048021,
0.0171647985,
-0.0214537587,
-0.0197960064,
0.0162035394,
-0.0133433202,
-0.0044652615,
-0.0337583236,
-0.0049158894,
-0.0292320475,
-0.0288848672,
-0.0738675222,
0.05560885,
-0.0037155428,
0.0239316039,
0.0098283403,
0.0174351502,
-0.0538236685,
-0.0033917374,
-0.0159259848,
-0.0137969991,
0.0200127512,
-0.0313167721,
0.0087326104,
-0.034354195,
-0.0409920961,
0.0195279978,
-0.0111487061,
0.0091441246,
-0.0201086216,
0.0359404758,
-0.0053111115,
-0.0505796038,
-0.124386847,
-0.0173097309,
0.0465757921,
-0.0026301017,
0.0033946338,
0.026110664,
-0.0092572728,
0.0065308912,
-0.0423161313,
0.0081158113,
0.052226685,
0.01939179,
0.0034724157,
0.0255066752,
-0.0404195599,
-0.0290504582,
-0.0018466091,
-0.047823526,
0.0147618158,
-0.000147399,
-0.0353804156,
-0.0048733726,
0.0113299163,
-0.0360772833,
-0.014623154,
0.0035066064,
-0.030558018,
0.0387095325,
-0.0150629124,
0.0424463116,
0.0281182155,
-0.0206871741,
0.0312478617,
0.0468918234,
-0.0080258967,
-0.0017713624,
-0.016568983,
-0.0297205504,
-0.0272544902,
-0.0022621513,
-0.0602895953,
-0.0207732115,
0.088831462,
0.0121219344,
0.0177694242,
-0.0570840426,
-0.0048043155,
-0.0594808236,
0.0154387522,
-0.0417176075,
0.0243906379,
-0.0635323748,
0.0422037691,
-0.0022645891,
-0.0465872735,
0.0974107757,
-0.0155947646,
0.0312135331,
-0.0667179897,
-0.0259118415,
-0.0339283831,
-0.0000546489,
-0.0107564945,
0.0184971821,
0.0006216276,
-0.0035342688,
0.0123975892,
0.0185245797,
-0.036065463,
-0.0811519846,
0.0713427067,
-0.04040296,
0.0248100273,
0.0255401246,
-0.031402722,
-0.0311889984,
0.0179757588,
-0.0308978315,
0.0008991479,
-0.0117441574,
0.0149115724,
-0.0398211889,
0.0505243987,
-0.0156868212,
0.0457239784,
0.0090602729,
-0.0151428245,
0.0030887772,
-0.0174935367,
0.0156331677,
0.0048142145,
0.011018008,
-0.0282949619,
0.0419918969,
0.0507653914,
-0.0109702889,
0.048438821,
-0.0075812768,
0.0002283892,
0.0159262661,
0.0023074951,
-0.0045791813,
0.0249057151,
0.0335226431,
-0.0424013026,
-0.0077604395,
0.130103156,
0.0275258198,
-0.0591698773,
0.0400572605,
-0.0203308221,
-0.0040969937,
-0.0278260168,
0.0038800132,
-0.0722596198,
-0.009850841,
-0.0125105781,
0.0355998725,
-0.0274841208,
-0.0094550624,
0.0160503089,
-0.0272403155,
0.0324423946,
0.0301265065,
-0.0424550287,
-0.0228836201,
-0.0423079282,
0.0117011797,
-0.0204151366,
0.0189363956,
-0.0152887041,
-0.020814402,
-0.0241896156,
0.0115995752,
-0.0953216329,
-0.0891345441,
0.0411940254,
-0.0229254216,
0.0917011574,
0.0685863271,
0.0334958322,
-0.0074053663,
-0.0056965463,
0.0089407852,
0.0325554498,
0.0238893405,
-0.0196397845,
0.0490717925,
0.0350995772,
-0.0051829885,
-0.0613971017,
0.0324006639,
-0.0504751056,
-0.0177042689,
-0.009359641,
0.1047417223,
-0.0714675561,
-0.0401388071,
-0.0486493818,
0.0243595019,
0.0300596878,
0.0682702214,
0.0004742499,
-0.0392250046,
-0.030077301,
0.0191722549,
0.0425451808,
0.0126733361,
-0.0481227748,
0.0193482544,
-0.0201151874,
-0.0167340431,
-0.0283049773,
-0.0031111857,
0.0454669409,
-0.0464804657,
0.0214464758,
0.037448138,
0.0235663224,
0.0013326284,
-0.0379532054,
0.0449238867,
0.0348076597,
0.0336522423,
-0.0683207512,
-0.0565946065,
0.0423465036,
-0.0182673037,
0.0052194004,
0.0228525884,
-0.045145601,
-0.0161132142,
0.0322160274,
0.0633910671,
0.0230352655,
-0.0138602918,
-0.0198398679,
-0.0269660093,
0.0362135805,
0.0239693001,
-0.0353404321,
0.0080744959,
-0.0318880975,
0.0120993294,
0.0064110067,
0.0207281075,
-0.0062478045,
0.0438004658,
-0.007994852,
0.0268816203,
-0.0084696738,
-0.0382119045,
0.0205427874,
0.0348803923,
0.0202777646,
-0.0268916059,
-0.0180872716,
-0.0210532397,
-0.0180623662,
-0.0463602208,
0.0526508093,
-0.0328631923,
-0.0167543925,
0.0376034342,
0.0107269082,
-0.0270900391,
-0.0360642411,
-0.0808285996,
-0.0404900052,
-0.0362214483,
0.0592611507,
-0.0073153218,
-0.0012790575,
0.0715542957,
0.00955649,
0.0040303692,
0.0382404514,
-0.0596473329,
-0.0031398567,
-0.0134374481,
0.0530600958,
-0.0175252557,
0.0272330791,
0.003487403,
0.0679263249,
-0.0199371595,
-0.0448154025,
-0.0047279955,
0.0641903505,
0.041728504,
0.0278014485,
0.0437517278,
-0.0507103205,
0.0182509944,
-0.0575608611,
0.0110202916,
-0.047457505,
0.0350001343,
0.0226209909,
0.0017197677,
-0.0094542066,
-0.0277770534,
0.0879815444,
0.0003148011,
0.0486012548,
-0.0131783532,
-0.0552672818,
-0.0388718173,
-0.0266152341,
0.0128708286,
-0.0298865512,
-0.0851167887,
0.0354911238,
-0.0794941559,
-0.0518580303,
0.0052693551,
-0.0090859905,
-0.0246058144,
-0.0415447056,
0.0569602624,
0.0445866622,
-0.0059981607,
-0.0050503942,
-0.0168036241,
0.0442155786,
-0.0430795401,
-0.0304260012,
0.0322827064,
-5.34568913e-33,
0.0040851478,
-0.0044114501,
0.0498478375,
0.0127625,
-0.0180677958,
0.0334174,
-0.0438425243,
0.0169094168,
-0.0109131671,
0.0497855544,
-0.01609811,
-0.0239785314,
0.0059606894,
0.0285613984,
0.0282018315,
-0.0016501173,
0.0071124719,
0.0008679159,
0.0283436514,
0.033890292,
-0.0109223286,
0.0438197069,
0.048704572,
-0.0850600973,
-0.0095182275,
0.0013605577,
0.0268688165,
0.0170721915,
-0.0308709182,
0.0645991638,
-0.0519078895,
0.036370825,
0.0465162024,
0.0184661429,
-0.0125177419,
-0.0015775677,
-0.0268859901,
0.0063763098,
0.0230231956,
-0.0230645034,
-0.0291882493,
-0.0429407246,
0.0542492419,
-0.0227091238,
-0.058112368,
0.0130169773,
-0.0053617293,
-0.0416873246,
-0.0083576255,
-0.0085494788,
-0.0521599241,
0.0483634174,
0.0027356672,
-0.0250112396,
-0.0123977307,
-0.0102496222,
-0.0593115427,
0.0128549496,
-0.0063356184,
0.0093939733,
0.0420702398,
0.0157595277,
0.02108429,
-0.0152813848,
-0.0012863938,
0.0507765599,
0.0359438471,
-0.0082671596,
-0.023102738,
0.0031869446,
-0.0111784609,
0.0499113798,
0.064132832,
-0.0050692912,
-0.0233783573,
-0.0394157432,
-0.0893517807,
0.0116938772,
-0.0249687787,
0.0452707596,
0.0184583981,
-0.0236099046,
-0.0583954304,
-0.0234447848,
-0.0107802758,
-0.0061501209,
-0.0096005555,
-0.0418707952,
0.0318290144,
-0.0277308896,
0.0211043432,
0.0314187557,
0.043348439,
-0.0249932259,
0.0186355058,
-0.0512904301,
0.0267802738,
0.0254694317,
-0.0318323597,
0.0362590514,
-0.0649338886,
-0.0430315323,
0.0271643829,
-0.0055869138,
0.0426006019,
-0.0067443247,
-0.0210312102,
-0.017261453,
-0.0248693619,
-0.0035336046,
0.0139693907,
-0.0119524207,
0.0101117808,
0.0116521893,
0.0445236266,
0.0223046225,
0.0072977715,
0.0497168936,
-0.0063201324,
-0.0341985896,
-0.0469281226,
-0.0248451885,
0.0000716649,
0.0005140316,
-0.042496033,
0.0108517855,
-0.0598521307,
0.0339839607,
0.0526076518,
-0.0485097133,
-0.0182363354,
-0.0036297715,
2.719e-7,
0.0828444883,
0.0703060478,
-0.0030036741,
-0.0161216967,
0.0338122435,
-0.0162410215,
-0.0154567556,
0.0208836533,
0.0054428196,
-0.0100845601,
0.0298254248,
0.0331830978,
0.0645515621,
0.02344919,
-0.0527261496,
-0.0170673542,
-0.083630845,
-0.027614994,
-0.0351094082,
-0.0095213167,
0.0198971797,
0.0741276294,
-0.0420372225,
-0.0530524924,
0.0294834934,
-0.0089389011,
0.0442106202,
-0.0491266586,
-0.019155765,
0.0628531724,
0.0110554071,
-0.0162589028,
0.0481366627,
0.0413438864,
-0.0087796832,
-0.0132085737,
0.0067579588,
0.1113024727,
-0.0674280599,
0.0277936645,
0.0549210161,
0.0174109675,
0.0117088361,
-0.0608073696,
0.0461725034,
-0.0597885884,
-0.0390126072,
-0.0393039398,
0.0329567119,
-0.018738471,
0.0731922016,
-0.0362864845,
-0.0272316933,
0.0310318656,
0.0466939546,
0.0201755948,
-0.0317882225,
-0.0376727656,
-0.0063944259,
0.0223894771,
-0.0659427196,
-0.0534288883,
0.025460247,
-0.0117321974,
0.0079178112,
-0.0728445202,
0.0127745857,
2.518577462e-34,
0.0362519287,
0.0009644313,
0.0257178284,
0.0275043491,
0.0371309146,
-0.0064904271,
0.0212051328,
0.0424050465,
0.0053671482,
-0.0710354224,
0.0030027546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05089v1 | Legal-HNet: Mixing Legal Long-Context Tokens with Hartley Transform | 2023-11-09T01:27:54 | 2023-11-09T01:27:54 | Daniele Giofré, Sneha Ghantasala | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Since its introduction, the transformers architecture has seen great adoption
in NLP applications, but it also has limitations. Although the self-attention
mechanism allows for generating very rich representations of the input text,
its effectiveness may be limited in specialized domains such as legal, where,
for example, language models often have to process very long texts. In this
paper, we explore alternatives to replace the attention-based layers with
simpler token-mixing mechanisms: Hartley and Fourier transforms. Using these
non-parametric techniques, we train models with long input documents from
scratch in the legal domain setting. We also introduce a new hybrid Seq2Seq
architecture, a no-attention-based encoder connected with an attention-based
decoder, which performs quite well on existing summarization tasks with much
less compute and memory requirements. We believe that similar, if not better
performance, as in the case of long correlations of abstractive text
summarization tasks, can be achieved by adopting these simpler infrastructures.
This not only makes training models from scratch accessible to more people, but
also contributes to the reduction of the carbon footprint during training. | [
0.0090923281,
0.0716920793,
0.0141776288,
0.0310055427,
-0.0496252328,
0.007915088,
0.0083811209,
-0.0083630541,
-0.0295532215,
-0.0707919002,
-0.0058076098,
-0.0213145539,
-0.0151664661,
0.0153148109,
0.0009986365,
-0.052953247,
0.0228407625,
0.0025843596,
-0.0081987921,
0.0155414781,
0.0021841547,
-0.0006661459,
0.028107075,
0.0408101492,
-0.0432286337,
-0.0099344328,
-0.0169020593,
0.0046321796,
0.0263596922,
0.0185753461,
0.0031803453,
0.0652544051,
0.0300889388,
0.0291537438,
0.000001892,
-0.0426586717,
0.0077860733,
0.0050588101,
0.0052198395,
0.0123683056,
0.0642576292,
-0.0576976463,
-0.0194906872,
0.005009851,
0.0138024986,
0.0133285653,
-0.0009533441,
0.0686397031,
0.0641821921,
0.0785294324,
-0.0023052194,
-0.0688022599,
0.0498763472,
-0.0752674341,
0.0052951621,
-0.0164704695,
0.0034763119,
-0.056939058,
-0.010348578,
0.0023819734,
-0.0283265766,
0.0456845425,
0.061396461,
-0.0086764824,
0.00372741,
0.0155170187,
-0.0805408657,
0.0088952295,
0.0233549383,
0.0362141542,
-0.0050418242,
-0.0179789066,
0.015677534,
0.0481136106,
0.0174848009,
-0.0274872184,
-0.0507507026,
0.0635280237,
0.0213406291,
0.0085144471,
0.0157050621,
0.0330102108,
-0.0188451577,
0.0105937887,
-0.026576506,
0.0024764761,
0.0024737255,
-0.0044822949,
-0.0313072354,
-0.0064642001,
-0.0028156082,
-0.0311507974,
0.0004860713,
0.0493461415,
0.033626169,
0.0015134002,
-0.0575020798,
-0.0362990648,
0.0462655202,
-0.0838407278,
-0.0717472881,
0.0047820453,
-0.0047594537,
0.0776627883,
-0.0657630339,
-0.0034398804,
-0.0040170872,
0.0116672944,
-0.0120313093,
-0.0416814983,
-0.0135410288,
-0.0121932095,
-0.0766772181,
0.0202888902,
-0.0594754964,
-0.0508580767,
-0.0242537726,
-0.0105596762,
-0.0088700363,
0.0106317839,
0.009673168,
0.0315485932,
-0.0347433053,
0.0067727021,
-0.0022883252,
-0.0318405144,
-0.0326438099,
-0.0010224896,
0.0269730128,
-0.0082031339,
-0.0212989878,
0.0299226306,
0.0108844806,
-0.0059225336,
-0.0086858748,
0.1024229899,
-0.0214193575,
-0.0525035448,
-0.0012719741,
-0.0337383673,
-0.0223183092,
-0.057877019,
-0.0093817627,
-0.0688531399,
0.0236691553,
-0.0242966842,
-0.0201096088,
-0.0176418275,
-0.0076436806,
0.055585511,
-0.0246843565,
0.0313426256,
0.0047721565,
-0.0416146889,
0.0262495503,
0.0255949814,
0.0167346615,
0.0683672801,
0.048461359,
0.0301610958,
0.0340633765,
0.0013800258,
-0.0138306934,
0.0307646189,
0.0402630828,
0.0013793126,
-0.0191069599,
-0.0225487538,
-0.0397071205,
0.0148781249,
0.0624894872,
0.089254871,
-0.0321618877,
-0.0361165032,
0.0023819357,
0.0463174284,
0.051999595,
0.0662718713,
0.0277073104,
0.0258407481,
0.0266447775,
0.0045234784,
-0.0686116293,
0.0611662976,
-0.0141700981,
0.0327968374,
-0.0162658673,
0.0002275727,
-0.0376223214,
-0.0467892475,
0.0085889651,
-0.0207708757,
-0.0135396942,
-0.0247730352,
0.0491085425,
0.0273853261,
-0.035351675,
0.0609485023,
-0.0150204347,
-0.0566799492,
0.0320912898,
-0.0101929903,
-0.0278546195,
0.0616996177,
0.0353390202,
-0.0424250141,
0.0256451871,
-0.0610477552,
-0.0066616661,
0.0498813801,
0.0239313729,
-0.002913367,
-0.0233302154,
-0.0490656346,
-0.0370309949,
-0.0031148642,
0.0136741428,
-0.020765489,
-0.0126160104,
0.0066322437,
0.0637404472,
-0.0189690981,
-0.0240902361,
0.0231957063,
0.0166306011,
-0.0599034391,
-0.0168908369,
-0.0002872968,
0.0255912337,
0.0210119225,
0.0034076376,
0.0207099859,
0.0244020596,
-0.0469687544,
-0.0317121409,
0.022932997,
-0.0297276061,
-0.0343438126,
0.0268221516,
-0.0515586287,
0.0091675688,
0.0445361286,
-0.0383737534,
-0.0473721549,
0.0106866807,
-0.0376811214,
0.0454251282,
-0.0445570908,
-0.0360047705,
0.0365666598,
0.0284209829,
-0.0300448686,
0.0602868795,
0.0224243831,
-0.027747605,
-0.0224266723,
-0.0280491244,
0.0034668394,
-0.0067620575,
-0.031839896,
-0.0062707728,
-0.0152268028,
0.0151431439,
0.0143668558,
-0.0125460057,
-0.0214684419,
-0.037295755,
-0.1008835658,
-0.0117061408,
-0.0464351922,
-0.0010202533,
0.0006450679,
-0.0113590108,
0.0110975495,
-0.0067675994,
-0.0389136486,
-0.0187505055,
-0.0322550535,
-0.0076389043,
0.0110189514,
-0.0214718729,
-0.0318497568,
0.011360636,
-0.0705071911,
-0.0139817297,
0.0876318812,
-0.0245966893,
-0.0097804926,
-0.0036940014,
0.0333089605,
0.0054592611,
-0.0111572295,
-0.0208023097,
0.0010170996,
-0.0349621959,
-0.0064061,
0.0369264893,
0.0545595326,
0.0874582082,
-0.0049754363,
-0.0136346491,
0.0275205355,
-0.0211523063,
0.0200988017,
-0.0088589257,
0.0348904096,
-0.0180194732,
0.0274206623,
0.0240255613,
0.0337850451,
-0.0412198976,
-0.0039322558,
-0.0073136715,
0.0033080031,
-0.0055142441,
-0.0155395148,
-0.0342489555,
-0.0066653481,
-0.0320871286,
-0.0150168585,
-0.0067418818,
-0.017180223,
0.0367527716,
-0.0155713949,
0.0339117423,
-0.0475398488,
0.0224019289,
-0.0705499798,
0.051985085,
0.0238484778,
0.0278902724,
-0.039220266,
-0.0622115918,
0.012146295,
-0.0143790515,
0.0332456306,
-0.0154170943,
0.1143040508,
0.035525512,
0.0296407621,
-0.063359201,
-0.0298895482,
-0.0338488743,
-0.0291062202,
-0.0152142234,
0.0440737158,
0.0053311139,
0.0291116964,
-0.0161224101,
-0.0015095777,
0.0021053399,
0.0786628425,
-0.0106327832,
0.0032124748,
-0.0202844162,
0.068047516,
0.0218044855,
0.023309119,
0.0215803869,
-0.0322113037,
0.0391029045,
0.0466435626,
0.0260496084,
-0.0017704002,
0.0125820525,
0.0031930925,
-0.0142245637,
-0.062366344,
0.0034534512,
0.0195912942,
0.0383737572,
-0.0502133667,
0.0130059309,
0.0967061073,
-0.0002250826,
-0.067091316,
0.0230172724,
0.0386545062,
0.0316504203,
0.0328568071,
0.0116709387,
-0.0657422319,
-0.0200006776,
0.0243266523,
-0.0060202843,
0.0240483359,
-0.0295814574,
0.0066115055,
-0.016623674,
0.0339363329,
0.0214472413,
-0.0846983045,
-0.0274491236,
-0.0104254251,
-0.0008012138,
-0.0085098445,
0.0286289565,
-0.0154493526,
-0.0287667476,
-0.0342965573,
0.0134418076,
-0.0074279751,
0.0107207075,
-0.0431671366,
-0.0340848118,
0.0280711912,
0.0242811106,
0.0079274243,
-0.0378550403,
0.0052748425,
0.0451934859,
-0.0115866158,
0.013626419,
0.0221457146,
0.0734282583,
-0.0341978334,
0.0143080363,
-0.0296137333,
0.057893157,
-0.0389344618,
-0.0528081469,
0.0081165778,
0.0541196726,
0.0092713116,
-0.0115606934,
-0.0416911133,
0.0037172702,
-0.0347384512,
0.049401354,
0.0240263697,
-0.0213191751,
-0.0441503078,
-0.0307018459,
-0.0378019065,
-0.0668416098,
-0.037762329,
-0.0090918504,
0.0396833867,
-0.0494723581,
-0.0350499898,
-0.0361471213,
-0.0005442592,
0.0399997942,
-0.0132302716,
-0.0018185368,
0.0451440886,
0.0082228705,
-0.072529003,
0.0220195539,
-0.0368322991,
-0.0145984655,
-0.029802477,
0.0232273322,
0.0407463908,
0.0115479082,
-0.0199182015,
-0.0135466298,
-0.0709110796,
-0.0114284754,
0.0387379117,
0.0217250288,
0.0139364945,
0.0263091885,
-0.0308721215,
-0.0287167095,
0.0392307863,
0.0755031928,
-0.0796300992,
0.0036665094,
0.0322142765,
-0.0143812848,
-0.0219276659,
0.023433648,
-0.0355565026,
0.0412690267,
0.0113633629,
0.0289555658,
0.0054001566,
0.0055561,
0.0114463465,
-0.001501363,
-0.0222369637,
-0.0170570221,
0.0379546359,
-0.009045613,
0.0146255661,
-0.0176801179,
0.0058480403,
-0.0090289973,
0.0230741296,
-0.0142252687,
-0.0005185126,
-0.0099629229,
0.0977336764,
0.0308384448,
-0.0503992997,
-0.0169490054,
0.0547353961,
-0.0564420745,
-0.0134341409,
-0.0270426571,
-0.0122677889,
-0.043703638,
-0.0167398583,
-0.0074590361,
0.0276778527,
-0.02573587,
0.026773192,
0.0402195789,
0.0218021646,
-0.028048398,
0.0158828869,
-0.0889667943,
-0.0011109815,
-0.0557917804,
0.030912336,
0.0445673503,
-0.0251744445,
0.0026006415,
-0.0192966964,
-0.0153884925,
0.0009440997,
0.0265441127,
0.0215821825,
-0.0199222639,
-0.0047432696,
0.0241865274,
-0.0132577317,
0.0104787024,
0.0571583994,
0.0069702943,
-0.0139109958,
0.0216123722,
0.0160814878,
-0.0514198802,
-0.0327906534,
0.0022836167,
0.010530117,
-0.0056899916,
-0.0275477245,
-0.0408480279,
-0.0731961057,
0.0225389767,
-0.0081396913,
-0.0028827684,
-0.0099792657,
0.0449720323,
0.0256982855,
0.0252405778,
-0.0604326949,
0.0047423486,
0.0412882939,
0.0196005963,
-0.0063900826,
0.0046754023,
-5.90612847e-33,
-0.0069922819,
0.0014988,
-0.0148222595,
0.0140407262,
-0.043270167,
0.0250691231,
-0.0118411686,
-0.044088468,
0.0185167566,
-0.003199931,
-0.0232266057,
0.0428446271,
0.0055106082,
0.0577441603,
0.0088504376,
-0.0225469042,
0.0573910326,
-0.0031845034,
-0.0288222246,
0.0561714098,
0.0344910845,
0.0021197821,
0.0333014317,
-0.0351711661,
-0.0274817515,
0.0122422036,
-0.0026880736,
-0.0106493011,
-0.02765074,
0.0617048107,
-0.0062645064,
0.0452514291,
0.0239094682,
-0.0562042817,
-0.0234736148,
0.0438303985,
-0.1323213726,
-0.0060855742,
-0.0248846207,
-0.0113376593,
-0.0206838381,
-0.0652823374,
0.0852278024,
0.0110578425,
-0.0075533525,
-0.0420904532,
0.0358265638,
-0.0057808016,
-0.0510922819,
-0.0987803638,
-0.0648789927,
0.043599993,
-0.0117575461,
0.0272406451,
0.0372783318,
0.0189907514,
-0.0032537761,
0.0073751537,
-0.0978127271,
-0.0232982561,
-0.0306333657,
0.0355336741,
0.0307700951,
-0.0102078104,
-0.0020024329,
0.0531903841,
-0.019403521,
0.0260649007,
-0.0644790754,
0.023433499,
0.0393182151,
0.047261294,
0.0416413136,
-0.0078022154,
0.0706458166,
-0.0124997245,
-0.0652941987,
0.0025988494,
0.0132247573,
0.0352150761,
0.031915471,
-0.0065346966,
-0.0061430209,
0.0009491465,
-0.0376457386,
-0.0084054517,
-0.0010190022,
-0.0099620996,
0.0016894742,
0.0509147756,
0.0274744872,
-0.0337322354,
0.025435742,
-0.0514080338,
0.0299987048,
0.0385356843,
0.0336835943,
0.0372104645,
0.0012629427,
0.0053571914,
-0.0398456566,
-0.0137118623,
0.0301686544,
0.0009212969,
0.0100193983,
-0.0490569435,
0.0914755464,
-0.0037460402,
-0.0669685453,
-0.008755995,
0.0079433713,
0.0366896391,
0.0246496964,
0.0349746682,
0.0183091983,
0.0192670878,
0.0284390226,
0.039791435,
-0.0407253616,
-0.0246355571,
-0.0166809261,
0.0315396339,
0.033469107,
0.0322398841,
0.002963786,
0.0114426855,
-0.0177917071,
0.032260336,
0.043923419,
-0.0997383967,
-0.0067121657,
0.0642173663,
2.631e-7,
0.0341548845,
0.0109596048,
0.0695464239,
-0.0477089807,
0.0377825052,
0.0094639137,
0.0514858142,
0.0781841353,
-0.0101327999,
0.0199154876,
-0.0031274075,
0.0384539291,
0.0522148982,
0.0232374165,
-0.1016732007,
-0.0923360139,
-0.043460317,
-0.017984733,
-0.0272155516,
0.0046871463,
0.0916083977,
0.1278959215,
-0.0176057182,
0.005490276,
0.0312356837,
-0.0022382396,
0.0541608445,
0.0085455934,
-0.0211046133,
0.0062474194,
0.0011903937,
-0.0169358384,
0.0039474578,
0.0076314225,
-0.018168645,
0.0354145318,
-0.00366343,
0.0654578358,
0.0079853488,
-0.0453724377,
-0.0124713359,
-0.0087230681,
0.0014016395,
0.0079753231,
0.0638482422,
-0.068340905,
-0.0266911704,
-0.0148077644,
-0.0193252843,
0.0051355357,
-0.0296458453,
0.0475557894,
-0.0275226049,
0.0165514555,
0.0454918779,
-0.0180450063,
0.0212325938,
-0.1277561337,
-0.0123473927,
0.0300058443,
-0.0366650224,
0.0111002168,
-0.0366824344,
0.0015091698,
0.0722545087,
-0.0261872467,
-0.0167527553,
2.470335817e-34,
0.0680139363,
-0.0127246641,
-0.004336881,
0.0114231082,
-0.0155749964,
-0.0308768507,
0.0148762865,
-0.0130171906,
0.0115475943,
-0.0697982386,
-0.0243380163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05085v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05085v2 | Characterizing Large Language Models as Rationalizers of Knowledge-intensive Tasks | 2023-11-09T01:04:44 | 2024-01-31T19:17:00 | Aditi Mishra, Sajjadur Rahman, Hannah Kim, Kushan Mitra, Estevam Hruschka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are proficient at generating fluent text with
minimal task-specific supervision. Yet, their ability to provide well-grounded
rationalizations for knowledge-intensive tasks remains under-explored. Such
tasks, like commonsense multiple-choice questions, require rationales based on
world knowledge to support predictions and refute alternate options. We
consider the task of generating knowledge-guided rationalization in natural
language by using expert-written examples in a few-shot manner. Surprisingly,
crowd-workers preferred knowledge-grounded rationales over crowdsourced
rationalizations, citing their factuality, sufficiency, and comprehensive
refutations. Although LLMs-generated rationales were preferable, further
improvements in conciseness and novelty are required. In another study, we show
how rationalization of incorrect model predictions erodes humans' trust in
LLM-generated rationales. Motivated by these observations, we create a
two-stage pipeline to review task predictions and eliminate potential incorrect
decisions before rationalization, enabling trustworthy rationale generation. | [
0.0450489819,
0.0757597089,
0.0140674524,
0.0264094565,
-0.0061527477,
-0.0099469712,
0.0127625782,
-0.0029176285,
-0.035499461,
-0.0343373641,
0.0051601063,
-0.0021482531,
0.0310238488,
0.0105221402,
0.0451870337,
-0.042667482,
-0.0153286569,
-0.0450134315,
0.0726942345,
-0.0226926263,
0.0126511334,
0.0403802581,
0.0158660915,
0.0741999969,
0.0330778435,
-0.0054897061,
0.0024890353,
-0.0143954623,
0.0039234487,
-0.0249046329,
-0.0106186206,
0.0715606883,
0.0113497796,
-0.0012024747,
0.000002004,
-0.04227525,
0.0287639089,
0.0073733027,
-0.0703626499,
0.0290719867,
-0.018731134,
0.0394732803,
0.0339654982,
0.0006761229,
-0.0115745701,
0.0440296903,
0.0327090919,
0.0403441899,
0.0550925322,
0.0177795049,
0.0197847001,
0.0072261044,
-0.0210030712,
0.0048365141,
-0.0019215203,
-0.0192789827,
0.0014475363,
0.0143390633,
-0.0090823695,
0.0566779599,
0.0237111561,
-0.0041468106,
0.0093457466,
-0.0557343923,
0.034916997,
0.0173819363,
0.0039685029,
-0.0217584167,
0.0222180039,
0.0718883425,
0.0145854792,
-0.0586419217,
0.0209504385,
-0.0094873589,
0.0107939215,
0.0560215451,
-0.0546821505,
0.0507053807,
0.0132228248,
0.005515072,
0.0117721893,
0.0053173453,
0.0226414893,
0.0410698429,
0.0317479745,
0.0450029038,
-0.0071465834,
0.0137030818,
-0.0046688667,
0.0168138016,
-0.0409300663,
-0.0915513858,
-0.0192613285,
0.0398725383,
-0.0498096347,
0.0075852047,
-0.0038602969,
0.0048904624,
0.0395261087,
-0.0293702465,
-0.0091454126,
0.0032877624,
0.0221916344,
0.0648819059,
-0.0136938579,
0.0149384728,
-0.0187483318,
0.0245170277,
0.0104487278,
-0.0015821495,
-0.055965133,
-0.0243777819,
-0.0157773551,
-0.001476206,
-0.0420860462,
0.0372922458,
0.0139362868,
-0.0351103023,
-0.0400277786,
0.02294969,
0.0185963865,
0.0627925545,
0.0083092926,
-0.0609570928,
-0.0790313929,
0.0190354977,
-0.0710959584,
0.0271333903,
0.03549245,
-0.040954195,
-0.0122594843,
0.007237264,
0.0255835541,
0.006622815,
-0.0058656195,
0.0093541453,
-0.0051846509,
0.0238868929,
-0.060314063,
-0.0610306896,
-0.000217253,
-0.0381800644,
-0.0459950268,
-0.0639919862,
-0.0103292139,
0.0232568905,
-0.01109784,
-0.0333664492,
0.0018865046,
0.0165285077,
-0.0225555003,
0.0746958256,
-0.0629723966,
0.0089680636,
0.030148169,
0.0183892921,
-0.0568679832,
0.0274952631,
0.0101521062,
0.0052814693,
0.0386137702,
-0.0157544129,
0.0479974747,
-0.0270918235,
0.0110736964,
-0.0139984041,
-0.0030261965,
0.0389528759,
-0.0617040396,
0.0154277598,
0.0255129263,
0.0631394237,
-0.0344136581,
0.0347096957,
0.0787783489,
0.0714261383,
-0.0499597639,
0.0130277975,
0.0169192329,
0.0122953001,
-0.0002407547,
-0.0008065096,
-0.0342103839,
0.0413989536,
-0.0434826091,
-0.0394468755,
-0.0058566821,
0.0107963383,
-0.0088926665,
-0.0376102366,
0.0158019345,
0.0051637623,
0.0185442045,
0.0004400341,
0.0227618255,
0.0150233367,
-0.0223250203,
0.0192261226,
0.0062179076,
-0.0415508896,
0.0272091962,
-0.0389440544,
0.0707717836,
0.0427695177,
0.0380747542,
0.0165749434,
-0.0074023139,
-0.0285064857,
0.0319351628,
0.0248218477,
0.0433354415,
-0.0429462083,
-0.0388169251,
-0.0289275572,
-0.0311934948,
-0.0272497609,
0.0216591079,
-0.0259691272,
0.0564263314,
-0.0088406336,
0.0247372612,
-0.0722242147,
-0.0642530173,
0.0049559465,
-0.0254185721,
-0.0294055659,
-0.0365185887,
0.0043886863,
-0.0171136297,
0.0224335883,
0.0131896222,
0.0445261225,
0.0079154838,
-0.0087409206,
-0.0538820364,
0.053644523,
-0.0447536036,
0.0205900036,
0.0244173892,
-0.0297960546,
-0.0504348651,
-0.0045519448,
0.0044017923,
-0.0207146201,
-0.0041000401,
-0.0145705454,
0.0001986311,
-0.0200616866,
0.012730414,
-0.0153990472,
-0.0386326201,
-0.0249023698,
0.082170099,
0.0314773321,
0.0130317593,
0.0282716993,
-0.0194764901,
0.002179709,
-0.0155796949,
0.0016262233,
0.0323150083,
0.0242994837,
0.007537026,
0.0361570492,
-0.0232308041,
-0.0496572517,
0.0210166592,
-0.0462936498,
-0.020225957,
-0.034608338,
0.0081779631,
0.0314570218,
-0.0345117636,
0.0414484255,
0.0101642711,
-0.0456610061,
0.0113587203,
-0.0072873416,
0.0196653083,
0.0570121966,
0.004765986,
0.0159120075,
-0.012567196,
0.021067977,
-0.0017407001,
0.0525900908,
0.0583195873,
0.0587843843,
-0.0875720903,
0.0049481643,
-0.0378566906,
-0.0135116875,
-0.001535862,
-0.0051031271,
0.0196389202,
0.01871337,
0.0052896896,
0.0364555307,
0.0117624253,
0.018689638,
0.0425172523,
0.0356546566,
-0.0433495976,
-0.0424407944,
0.01096192,
0.0101269018,
-0.0168471523,
-0.0114441263,
0.0203476381,
0.0462838337,
-0.006928809,
0.0204081666,
-0.0780108646,
0.0818913877,
-0.0440476835,
-0.0237322338,
-0.0617926717,
-0.0994876474,
-0.0074718874,
0.11468032,
-0.0333949998,
-0.0358770713,
0.0692098513,
-0.0279133115,
0.0170136429,
-0.0112435976,
-0.015251576,
-0.0049624057,
0.0475775227,
-0.033752352,
0.0174496528,
0.0076891156,
0.0272685904,
-0.0364509225,
-0.0338707864,
0.0597579665,
-0.0192750916,
0.042768985,
-0.090527229,
-0.0191912949,
0.0004815107,
-0.0321533903,
-0.0198583491,
-0.0658385828,
-0.0638320968,
-0.0195656251,
0.0631354675,
-0.0403511599,
0.0117041031,
-0.0157175772,
0.0641129985,
0.0072530727,
0.0178438742,
-0.015330269,
0.0009770433,
0.0298437104,
0.0327424146,
0.0588325374,
0.0536443815,
-0.0359039903,
0.0471516661,
0.0636907518,
0.0293726623,
-0.0285693854,
-0.028693324,
-0.0373634174,
-0.009000835,
-0.0062209475,
-0.0039127995,
0.0124214543,
0.1045647115,
-0.0378793366,
0.0245998129,
0.0793881863,
0.0212647226,
0.0036942079,
-0.0085085118,
-0.0458415039,
0.0315984525,
0.0200232081,
-0.0046492675,
-0.0376196913,
-0.0120977527,
0.008133566,
0.0469731241,
-0.0078872861,
-0.0611303411,
-0.0055918312,
-0.1499872804,
0.06000375,
-0.0092457347,
-0.0061321897,
0.0067488523,
-0.0781189278,
-0.0051637189,
-0.0223748349,
-0.0221335515,
0.0407983884,
0.0193570051,
0.0280065201,
0.0427603647,
-0.008577452,
-0.0078896023,
0.0576309226,
-0.0479474738,
0.0417283215,
0.0079162642,
0.0536098741,
0.0175579935,
-0.0824751183,
-0.0035785034,
0.0122969272,
0.0141180772,
0.003216841,
0.0417912751,
0.0241657943,
-0.0044810125,
-0.0488358289,
0.0519455597,
-0.0482937321,
-0.0420651734,
0.0094926441,
0.0889405981,
0.0123908613,
-0.0399733409,
0.0157633144,
-0.0102442317,
-0.0137029141,
0.0807129964,
0.0469604433,
-0.0212819204,
-0.0210838858,
-0.0334017277,
-0.0124870017,
-0.0622578934,
-0.078371875,
0.0029811361,
0.0307496637,
-0.0119945146,
-0.0789005086,
-0.0166114494,
0.0477913581,
0.0426351279,
0.0129864793,
-0.0284226127,
0.0128716752,
-0.0045949263,
0.007352225,
0.04416072,
-0.0357218273,
0.0133565962,
-0.0240571965,
0.022291014,
-0.0097630927,
-0.0253381375,
0.0032503763,
0.0217639618,
-0.013105195,
-0.0552538894,
-0.0355884582,
0.0256821383,
0.0330004133,
0.0223827865,
-0.0131534953,
-0.0656161904,
-0.0069524902,
-0.0027359067,
-0.0395624749,
0.0016673338,
0.0045482251,
0.0164624322,
-0.0009684066,
0.014238622,
-0.0226182044,
-0.0137565341,
-0.0048545185,
0.0122542316,
-0.039169617,
-0.0368043035,
0.0374380648,
0.0426463,
0.0306696109,
-0.0291318595,
0.0435640402,
-0.0361317657,
-0.0351302102,
-0.0092652272,
-0.0321470536,
-0.0088791447,
0.0134775992,
0.0014853516,
-0.0313171521,
0.0009009066,
-0.0089914277,
0.0007986263,
0.0254291967,
-0.0092834476,
0.0131505076,
0.019435389,
0.0325560309,
0.0314734951,
-0.0070138057,
-0.0073906891,
-0.0018536238,
-0.0572353192,
0.0467931218,
0.0092042331,
0.0300950594,
0.0069343862,
-0.0165812504,
0.0121803889,
-0.03788504,
-0.0399968438,
-0.1311461926,
0.0130193681,
-0.008272104,
-0.0044281832,
-0.0267630387,
0.062879324,
-0.0202086456,
-0.0342666768,
0.0194975175,
0.0106901322,
0.0382949263,
-0.0057377219,
0.026080586,
0.0228621643,
-0.0526087657,
0.0027664537,
0.0702278391,
-0.0133193377,
0.0336273536,
-0.0051260297,
-0.0458501726,
-0.0161776282,
-0.0337225012,
-0.0283055324,
0.0201505497,
0.0068212431,
-0.0089527592,
-0.0875194743,
-0.0267688148,
-0.0193306115,
0.0233088955,
0.0063089752,
-0.0124557428,
0.0029995085,
0.0363752171,
-0.0261437725,
-0.0003480359,
-0.0425095297,
0.038256716,
-0.0396979377,
0.0341006592,
-0.0417771265,
-6.42514045e-33,
0.0102109918,
-0.1084431708,
-0.0096605187,
-0.0509093143,
0.0309632793,
-0.0036040698,
-0.0590360127,
0.0241841208,
-0.0052471734,
0.0751869902,
-0.0131020779,
0.0174678918,
-0.0016581242,
-0.0211485941,
0.0286160447,
-0.0183053743,
0.048338037,
0.0004558156,
-0.0364066213,
0.0302008223,
0.0559209734,
-0.0321001522,
0.0201758407,
-0.062884964,
0.0876852572,
0.0001135935,
-0.0259409156,
0.0331111252,
-0.0258200783,
0.0188561939,
-0.0072355801,
0.0320303515,
0.0159969702,
-0.0747017339,
-0.0108159734,
0.0221036524,
-0.0457049161,
0.0071541197,
0.0497054048,
-0.0626995042,
-0.0749401972,
-0.0267309342,
0.0438276008,
0.0216771532,
-0.0099491514,
0.0337104499,
0.0294030942,
-0.016996637,
0.0095866183,
0.012066883,
-0.0207744092,
0.0218894463,
-0.0350002684,
-0.0024427471,
-0.0321801156,
0.0216720067,
-0.0109360991,
0.0435233079,
-0.0724215135,
0.0153964087,
0.011708525,
-0.018239554,
0.063172482,
-0.038202703,
-0.0050133523,
0.0701090023,
-0.0245636292,
0.0244315192,
-0.0767899007,
0.0098560667,
-0.0455344543,
0.0691341609,
0.0989249051,
0.1144571826,
0.0408183001,
-0.011346871,
-0.0459074713,
0.0248764176,
-0.0701290444,
0.0275639407,
0.0384655707,
-0.0178724378,
-0.0293958951,
-0.0096255764,
-0.0509120971,
-0.0175131802,
-0.0506068133,
0.0046529341,
-0.0169802178,
-0.0038259835,
-0.0640947595,
-0.0334786884,
-0.0105838366,
-0.0205406863,
0.0267221741,
0.0316191763,
-0.0210542437,
-0.0082668029,
0.0184758808,
-0.0197475702,
-0.0465812758,
0.0512959063,
-0.0004359857,
0.0390790254,
0.0232805107,
0.0369599685,
0.0129518239,
-0.0118600484,
-0.0363039263,
0.0328407884,
-0.0595985129,
0.0253938567,
0.0115963118,
-0.0189782921,
0.0339705609,
0.0116656059,
-0.0050461078,
-0.0061098514,
0.0105600934,
-0.0030469291,
0.0064793173,
0.0290229376,
-0.0074430867,
-0.0187887773,
-0.0105952835,
-0.0266070757,
-0.0263259746,
-0.0220343508,
0.0406154208,
-0.0111788576,
-0.0021640817,
-0.0105223134,
2.639e-7,
0.0164082702,
0.0477816798,
0.0008486171,
-0.0406707972,
0.0200924706,
0.0530403107,
0.0212020986,
-0.0219145399,
0.0016305386,
-0.0675190687,
0.0021690154,
0.0323174857,
0.0332509503,
0.0539660789,
-0.0521298759,
-0.0374309607,
-0.0782110244,
-0.0037177852,
-0.024804052,
-0.0050828732,
0.0585490726,
-0.0076641701,
0.0220013652,
-0.0053366744,
-0.0047952496,
-0.051470954,
0.0366009548,
-0.0263621751,
0.0076151118,
-0.0118159847,
0.0833311751,
-0.0057677338,
0.008196542,
0.0072524371,
-0.0207743309,
-0.030719934,
-0.0148659246,
0.0455173515,
0.0043668351,
-0.0024374386,
-0.0288296118,
-0.0530628115,
0.0307511482,
-0.0856436342,
0.0532614477,
-0.02507516,
-0.0304699838,
-0.0181552712,
-0.0232716743,
-0.0378306694,
-0.0130049484,
-0.0085996045,
-0.0003764245,
-0.0074985288,
-0.0317078829,
0.022260638,
0.006637706,
-0.048444517,
-0.046960257,
-0.0081903562,
-0.0250076298,
-0.0526420027,
-0.0113153616,
-0.0300917886,
0.0273940414,
-0.0372564457,
0.0312951356,
2.065719182e-34,
0.0058721108,
0.0197063927,
0.0249120425,
-0.017265914,
0.0886952057,
0.0411250256,
-0.0314673521,
-0.0385917947,
0.0624476299,
-0.022718709,
-0.0163972992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05657v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05657v2 | Agent Lumos: Unified and Modular Training for Open-Source Language Agents | 2023-11-09T00:30:13 | 2024-03-13T10:54:21 | Da Yin, Faeze Brahman, Abhilasha Ravichander, Khyathi Chandu, Kai-Wei Chang, Yejin Choi, Bill Yuchen Lin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Closed-source agents suffer from several issues such as a lack of
affordability, transparency, and reproducibility, particularly on complex
interactive tasks. This motivates the development of open-source alternatives.
We introduce LUMOS, one of the first frameworks for training open-source
LLM-based agents. LUMOS features a learnable, unified, and modular architecture
with a planning module that learns high-level subgoal generation, and a
grounding module trained to translate these into actions using various tools in
the execution module. The design allows for modular upgrades and wider
applicability to diverse interactive tasks. To foster generalizable agent
learning, we collect large-scale, unified, and high-quality training
annotations derived from diverse ground-truth reasoning rationales across
various complex interactive tasks. On 9 datasets, LUMOS exhibits several key
advantages: (1) LUMOS excels multiple larger open-source agents on the held-out
datasets (unused for training) for each task type. LUMOS even surpasses GPT
agents on QA and web tasks; (2) LUMOS outperforms open-source agents produced
by chain-of-thoughts and unmodularized integrated training; and (3) LUMOS
effectively generalizes to unseen tasks, outperforming 33B-scale agents and
domain-specific agents. | [
0.0113743022,
0.0301948003,
-0.0014319924,
0.0236403234,
-0.0225574039,
0.0225359332,
-0.0080980454,
-0.0271426011,
0.035531573,
-0.0262139626,
-0.0436494574,
0.0314457864,
-0.0482684635,
0.0207264461,
0.0125826076,
-0.0411113128,
0.0454684086,
-0.0164234918,
-0.0070507573,
-0.0088636531,
0.0143195754,
0.0150964977,
-0.0525301322,
0.0482247286,
-0.0055857613,
-0.0162728727,
-0.0591025613,
-0.0038812687,
0.0303379577,
-0.0223496202,
0.0121237775,
0.0028819114,
0.0719125196,
0.0214018188,
0.000002038,
-0.0520277731,
-0.0202865247,
-0.0264342967,
-0.0350904427,
-0.056990657,
0.0129935294,
0.0121731488,
-0.021306375,
0.0232676249,
-0.0708667263,
0.0203635078,
0.032027524,
0.0464510284,
0.0601282753,
0.0928070247,
0.008935662,
-0.0168537702,
0.0104892515,
0.0191940404,
0.031971775,
-0.0331982337,
-0.0374675952,
-0.0019832004,
0.0195067525,
-0.0023348955,
0.0270211231,
-0.0379800685,
0.042975314,
-0.0256165341,
-0.0129314419,
0.0505141765,
-0.0287441295,
-0.0317575,
-0.0330420583,
0.0810563266,
0.0012908179,
-0.0114149451,
0.0211350508,
-0.0169358887,
0.0207698848,
-0.0253691655,
-0.0297371373,
0.0583264157,
0.0156321991,
0.0422265641,
0.019159995,
-0.0175675824,
0.0116800629,
0.0360603295,
-0.0178671591,
0.0803600997,
-0.0275410544,
-0.0119958427,
0.0550956726,
-0.0004905327,
0.0077434536,
-0.0534832254,
-0.0430549532,
0.08005438,
-0.0489214137,
0.0335498787,
-0.0443902239,
0.0239675306,
0.0224994384,
-0.0260846801,
0.0232831873,
0.0423831902,
-0.0130534014,
0.0225545745,
-0.0351198353,
0.0461723283,
-0.0053104497,
0.0793558732,
-0.0007478335,
0.0055672498,
-0.0687781721,
0.0139928935,
-0.0287852623,
0.0623970516,
-0.0453876443,
0.0100027137,
-0.023600379,
0.0682679787,
-0.0223001167,
0.041932907,
-0.0061942497,
0.047825858,
-0.0294670593,
-0.0111130252,
-0.0761772245,
0.0079094432,
-0.055921223,
0.033553075,
0.0271910187,
-0.0654236376,
-0.0224448722,
0.0302381199,
-0.0067086243,
-0.0047606896,
0.0206020307,
0.0800819993,
-0.0072446996,
-0.0264686029,
-0.0797360092,
-0.0364089087,
0.0161496699,
-0.0830224827,
0.0244639888,
-0.0712624937,
0.0135248331,
-0.020189926,
-0.0299139377,
-0.0137757994,
0.0359834544,
0.0187995974,
0.0232518129,
0.0737169832,
-0.0185294989,
-0.0330094509,
-0.0190074947,
0.0071148165,
-0.030320568,
0.0791939944,
0.0348788239,
0.0554274805,
0.0229612477,
0.0057712724,
0.0127473883,
0.0124536846,
-0.0111030359,
0.0194880143,
0.0614908189,
0.0236016829,
-0.0014724105,
0.0491417237,
0.034010455,
0.0058580334,
-0.0240034387,
0.0030974925,
0.0610620081,
0.0503997914,
-0.0154708149,
-0.0156287663,
0.0417719819,
0.0267441217,
-0.0045992411,
-0.0229233839,
-0.0780516937,
0.0774823502,
-0.0036248225,
0.0104330713,
-0.0467440933,
0.0108575569,
-0.041353602,
-0.0499679632,
0.0079268562,
-0.0397419855,
0.025783278,
-0.011094382,
0.0140464017,
0.0136613902,
-0.0744818002,
0.0445438363,
0.0242845323,
-0.0864611045,
-0.0244872402,
-0.0625087544,
0.0477255024,
0.0541553386,
0.0279389899,
-0.0625012144,
-0.0621791258,
-0.038649153,
0.0210538115,
0.0668070987,
-0.0021296197,
-0.0348369032,
0.0114072235,
-0.0675556064,
-0.0237539243,
-0.0466439798,
-0.0095100515,
0.0340685435,
0.0191848949,
-0.0078460732,
-0.0132053941,
-0.0287982486,
-0.0024008648,
0.0443826765,
-0.0147715295,
-0.0556960516,
-0.0250835177,
0.0154348966,
0.0436184108,
0.0059194053,
0.0186694078,
-0.0080723017,
0.0477981977,
0.0018773453,
-0.0427306332,
0.0145904487,
-0.0167257227,
-0.0068199299,
0.0430477001,
-0.0266473684,
-0.0125902994,
0.0410207361,
-0.0523086637,
-0.0254849773,
0.004509029,
-0.0050757229,
0.0492122583,
-0.0495916307,
-0.0103575522,
0.023607336,
-0.0182092935,
-0.0099942656,
0.0580492914,
0.0031871302,
-0.034728691,
0.0394056626,
0.0180298984,
0.0112761632,
-0.0365150608,
0.0266207531,
0.0036507361,
-0.0005487797,
0.0189383794,
0.001927194,
0.0514272489,
-0.0611984394,
-0.0200199205,
-0.0822336599,
0.0352875143,
-0.0288919471,
0.0059138834,
0.0227009524,
-0.0067066331,
0.0102855265,
-0.021546388,
-0.026591761,
0.0598791875,
0.0154183339,
-0.002351132,
0.0505266748,
0.0042141029,
-0.001937242,
-0.0334644914,
0.0389083363,
-0.0090041729,
-0.0058732308,
-0.0106509542,
0.0435593463,
-0.0423033983,
0.037244007,
-0.0609216653,
0.0480947644,
-0.0107449191,
-0.0525501259,
0.0488365851,
-0.0203336775,
-0.0322352126,
0.0498765744,
0.0058371532,
0.0166976042,
0.0695773438,
-0.0032179228,
-0.0836673304,
0.0500247143,
-0.0199609231,
-0.0316441469,
-0.0635140613,
0.02645877,
-0.0010270919,
0.0540396497,
-0.0061108572,
0.0096889194,
-0.0603812188,
0.0006740693,
0.026752606,
-0.0377410762,
0.017640451,
0.0204765052,
-0.0478966236,
0.0159285404,
-0.0262715481,
-0.0604323633,
0.05369436,
-0.0166351162,
-0.0221943501,
-0.0393108949,
-0.0281696115,
-0.0569721982,
0.0635372549,
-0.0164772701,
0.0005458225,
0.0107498672,
-0.0206831712,
-0.0539623536,
0.0194891766,
0.0182550214,
-0.0011722652,
0.059827935,
-0.0646860674,
-0.0032432349,
-0.0293665417,
-0.0486933105,
-0.0672064647,
0.0159846693,
-0.0360629037,
0.0008214705,
-0.0319329724,
-0.0205737818,
-0.0229369011,
-0.0539178252,
0.0235734116,
0.0261740386,
-0.006984327,
-0.0215183292,
-0.0574272908,
-0.0434181951,
0.0170817617,
0.0544996634,
0.0042864373,
-0.0081916181,
0.0225807037,
0.043968983,
0.0413005762,
-0.0573379472,
-0.0398173742,
0.0076645319,
0.0166961551,
-0.0425984412,
-0.0145171368,
0.0290394835,
0.0573267043,
-0.0571518242,
0.0057308446,
0.120256342,
0.0295887794,
-0.0277175382,
0.0028985359,
-0.0426187515,
0.0689927712,
0.0596025772,
0.0352180265,
-0.0876559839,
-0.0546165146,
-0.0024224864,
0.0440764204,
0.0075573628,
-0.038143564,
-0.0095195509,
-0.1154334247,
0.0601876788,
0.0051816204,
-0.0240421332,
0.0138828168,
-0.044884149,
0.0030207818,
-0.0278822687,
-0.0073589459,
0.0176105406,
-0.0121185752,
-0.0091133872,
0.0220454317,
-0.0161371119,
-0.0018129821,
0.0266255941,
-0.0321747884,
0.0231248513,
0.0665095448,
0.0338301584,
0.0113873333,
-0.0552023537,
-0.002493788,
0.0137973996,
0.0139356079,
-0.0182438456,
0.0548163317,
-0.0011652512,
-0.0044970629,
-0.0111748753,
0.0617717542,
-0.0517683551,
-0.0297358427,
0.0083642425,
0.0947752073,
-0.0381924845,
0.0045433915,
0.0117487423,
0.003766034,
0.0193346962,
0.0472114757,
-0.0120222718,
-0.0123033598,
-0.0668015555,
-0.039522633,
-0.0397197902,
-0.0513749309,
-0.0310103651,
0.013227148,
-0.0232539419,
-0.0055666603,
-0.0762709305,
-0.0764872059,
0.0497694463,
0.0383291841,
0.0150710074,
-0.0357549414,
-0.0004859264,
0.017448511,
-0.0362475067,
0.0058310404,
-0.0251043476,
0.0214917827,
-0.0323761664,
-0.0250718724,
0.0319677517,
-0.0568811111,
0.0144530255,
0.0016618855,
-0.0471783355,
-0.0555985346,
-0.0236107428,
0.0926457494,
0.0240026377,
0.0544085167,
0.0012537695,
-0.0122521361,
0.015295065,
-0.0041605663,
-0.0424699485,
0.0069093201,
0.0824454352,
0.0103083346,
0.0180075914,
0.0441287644,
-0.0690851286,
-0.0046648076,
-0.0214875937,
0.0114128534,
-0.0278828889,
0.0151948119,
0.0342527516,
-0.0238818601,
0.0048001241,
-0.0131399119,
0.0000925432,
-0.0438220277,
0.0365274809,
0.0103072394,
0.0019237142,
-0.043461524,
0.0244676322,
-0.0026226819,
-0.0058773053,
0.0616010092,
0.0093906391,
-0.0347252153,
0.0261934977,
0.0123832505,
0.0312317703,
0.0277467184,
0.027770929,
0.0099780727,
0.0162270851,
-0.023848569,
0.0188138261,
0.0009645009,
0.0413083434,
-0.0057452773,
0.0797882229,
0.0043809712,
0.0070943912,
0.0125489337,
0.019591067,
-0.0599741675,
-0.0590261184,
0.0117709525,
0.039291393,
0.041204676,
0.0284140762,
0.0402599908,
-0.0493217893,
0.0273365937,
0.0255594887,
0.0523251593,
-0.0141465496,
-0.0420027077,
0.0276888441,
0.0284562279,
-0.0032276986,
-0.0173938461,
0.0633065403,
-0.0312387999,
0.0775019899,
-0.0180261005,
0.0168126784,
-0.0554310679,
-0.0581414402,
0.0154480943,
0.0313889049,
-0.0027213234,
-0.024566656,
-0.0522338748,
-0.0354198255,
-0.0153518524,
0.0329939462,
-0.0336318985,
-0.0244188029,
0.0705305189,
0.0247322489,
-0.0050043017,
-0.0277341865,
-0.0356586017,
-0.0303134453,
-0.0146049988,
-0.0106994277,
0.0007018567,
-5.567793645e-33,
-0.0208908301,
-0.0140374927,
0.0744942352,
0.0005982853,
-0.0346500501,
-0.019526612,
-0.0337613262,
0.0067253695,
-0.0211476553,
-0.0034228524,
-0.0097051822,
0.0027326012,
0.0138905849,
-0.0069264662,
0.0178328641,
-0.0203093253,
0.0175366681,
-0.0198142175,
-0.029685868,
0.0297904797,
0.0360657126,
0.007559001,
0.0550986789,
-0.0425606333,
0.0262470134,
0.0247455537,
-0.011034823,
0.0346099101,
-0.0351042077,
0.0497597344,
0.0108941188,
0.0010070791,
-0.0005314008,
-0.0172700975,
-0.0038306003,
-0.0102574313,
-0.0470928662,
-0.0229105931,
0.0073269047,
0.0166674647,
-0.0760546029,
-0.0534868166,
-0.0047183288,
-0.0133229997,
-0.0036356999,
-0.0037172036,
0.0278196391,
-0.0165760554,
0.0237955283,
0.0330780484,
-0.0617900193,
0.0000605881,
-0.009562809,
-0.0255148299,
-0.018041281,
0.0314834267,
-0.0051940172,
-0.0159251653,
-0.0273293331,
0.0363148116,
-0.0074543683,
-0.0263768993,
0.0727108493,
-0.0022509424,
-0.0012070208,
0.0684019402,
0.0323862098,
0.0049636834,
-0.0423087329,
0.0363368504,
0.0140724154,
0.1004652157,
0.0327198766,
0.0490396544,
-0.0022729889,
0.0230769403,
-0.0585330725,
0.0507270135,
0.0311949141,
0.0548449978,
-0.0164201334,
0.0399661586,
-0.0093798395,
0.0214077625,
-0.0014555348,
0.0232056174,
0.0114441197,
-0.0534278303,
0.0317527466,
0.0288354121,
-0.0204196684,
-0.0504049323,
0.0132728014,
-0.0145933134,
0.0068595824,
0.0149548501,
-0.0224075355,
0.0136256693,
-0.0009530147,
-0.0123432484,
-0.0547418073,
-0.0191846453,
0.0254172049,
-0.0272125918,
0.0391986109,
0.0278197601,
0.0274598617,
0.0729925632,
-0.0350890234,
0.0208944529,
-0.0758198127,
0.0373007879,
0.0055205361,
0.0136423316,
-0.0176679976,
-0.0337075219,
-0.0156260245,
0.0391752869,
-0.0353392139,
-0.0425890163,
-0.0291607883,
-0.0181007162,
0.0148497196,
0.0145738842,
-0.045221217,
-0.0038440572,
-0.0593125075,
0.0404238142,
-0.0109976027,
-0.0703764111,
0.0004849078,
0.0157857276,
2.754e-7,
-0.0125957914,
0.0051350659,
0.0076912022,
0.0570366532,
-0.0003781832,
0.0511872545,
-0.0258165784,
0.0448095426,
-0.035273999,
-0.0309159979,
0.0021772461,
0.0546308234,
0.0275533702,
0.043459177,
-0.0879943296,
-0.024565639,
0.0092251515,
-0.0379055813,
-0.0494054519,
-0.0176144559,
0.0386907719,
0.0640344992,
0.0274119508,
-0.0091607701,
0.0573979095,
-0.0190274101,
0.0381312408,
-0.0127009954,
0.0069149351,
-0.0087860702,
-0.0125385765,
0.0244375672,
-0.0287637729,
-0.002464816,
-0.0015517219,
0.003656053,
-0.0489041507,
0.0588207357,
-0.0060964571,
-0.0703720376,
0.021432979,
-0.0390814468,
0.0244253129,
-0.0249147993,
0.0658793524,
0.0073888921,
-0.0158456769,
0.0039596725,
0.0136017511,
-0.0286342073,
-0.0328670703,
-0.0248723272,
-0.0144039094,
-0.01716353,
-0.017790189,
-0.0466170423,
-0.0265245382,
-0.0758667886,
-0.0006057554,
-0.0141040124,
-0.0206605569,
-0.0544940121,
-0.0268228613,
0.0248611383,
0.0113930609,
-0.0397241637,
-0.0200045835,
2.490504269e-34,
-0.0259702783,
-0.000749538,
0.0129877133,
0.0544882528,
0.0356146991,
0.0231427811,
-0.0051473645,
-0.0134335523,
0.0501031391,
-0.0232613143,
-0.029500477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07751v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07751v3 | Large Human Language Models: A Need and the Challenges | 2023-11-09T00:27:28 | 2024-05-09T17:22:40 | Nikita Soni, H. Andrew Schwartz, João Sedoc, Niranjan Balasubramanian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As research in human-centered NLP advances, there is a growing recognition of
the importance of incorporating human and social factors into NLP models. At
the same time, our NLP systems have become heavily reliant on LLMs, most of
which do not model authors. To build NLP systems that can truly understand
human language, we must better integrate human contexts into LLMs. This brings
to the fore a range of design considerations and challenges in terms of what
human aspects to capture, how to represent them, and what modeling strategies
to pursue. To address these, we advocate for three positions toward creating
large human language models (LHLMs) using concepts from psychological and
behavioral sciences: First, LM training should include the human context.
Second, LHLMs should recognize that people are more than their group(s). Third,
LHLMs should be able to account for the dynamic and temporally-dependent nature
of the human context. We refer to relevant advances and present open challenges
that need to be addressed and their possible solutions in realizing these
goals. | [
0.089210324,
0.0620614924,
-0.0433762819,
0.0311327707,
-0.0239417404,
0.0115513513,
0.0066014873,
-0.0195395052,
0.0140135353,
-0.0572875105,
-0.0110311378,
-0.0487224534,
-0.0030765429,
-0.0260046311,
0.0302817803,
-0.0915662348,
0.0368699506,
0.0040750569,
0.0117941182,
-0.0108352937,
0.0235695206,
0.022219127,
0.0253568552,
0.0348262116,
-0.0145654082,
-0.0241984669,
0.0010033984,
-0.0079954211,
0.018926831,
-0.0186093356,
-0.010210433,
0.0699367225,
0.0315263048,
-0.0169163793,
0.0000019622,
-0.0501283742,
0.0243808459,
-0.0130506409,
-0.0366465338,
-0.0159969851,
0.0773299411,
0.0044396264,
-0.0211832542,
-0.0117567992,
-0.0471910648,
0.0264315028,
-0.0041224379,
0.0522873476,
0.0484034158,
0.024499245,
-0.0099244211,
-0.0284352023,
0.000033044,
-0.0090627735,
-0.0072402447,
-0.04473776,
0.024237724,
0.0001859211,
0.0436789244,
0.0133488961,
0.0097393673,
0.0543056019,
-0.0069982065,
0.0069582169,
0.0675419122,
-0.022463588,
0.0183183979,
-0.0071559041,
-0.0196690783,
0.047002051,
0.0608683415,
-0.0115174362,
0.0138391815,
0.0110148601,
0.0194511469,
0.0364298746,
-0.0195753686,
0.0393988825,
0.0135580786,
-0.0139680887,
-0.0056334063,
0.0485864915,
-0.000948418,
0.0389056355,
-0.0037116739,
0.0405255966,
0.0019965391,
-0.026382247,
-0.0126894573,
0.0026750495,
0.0128142331,
-0.0397838727,
0.0315595865,
0.0423056819,
-0.0374627858,
0.0463762954,
-0.0201007687,
0.0094105508,
0.0557531938,
-0.0551105887,
0.0079404339,
-0.0117143197,
0.0185136832,
0.0208433568,
0.049790442,
0.0389335863,
0.0091128983,
-0.0186591428,
0.0015630036,
-0.0307500288,
-0.0725026131,
-0.0259798914,
-0.024006512,
0.0144890742,
-0.0395314582,
-0.0203512423,
-0.0640752241,
0.0326066092,
-0.0260298662,
-0.0255041756,
-0.0158561096,
0.0266197417,
-0.0385175869,
-0.0005141051,
-0.0468135178,
-0.0189186446,
-0.0246089976,
0.0024978698,
-0.0028910739,
-0.05507515,
0.044397153,
0.0054010358,
-0.0196558777,
-0.022230899,
-0.0269781146,
0.0374472998,
0.0285269395,
-0.0480129272,
-0.0304695312,
-0.0314801261,
-0.0357960574,
-0.0416199081,
-0.0383763611,
-0.0421374664,
0.0474019833,
0.0022125589,
0.0081823254,
-0.0746942833,
-0.0134279123,
0.0439217612,
-0.0313000381,
0.0880494863,
0.0097939288,
0.0340865292,
0.0369835719,
0.0133711006,
0.0436920933,
0.0311425608,
0.041009821,
-0.0268387422,
0.049814254,
-0.0176459998,
0.0153925093,
0.0506872796,
-0.0274814572,
-0.0263665281,
0.0064849891,
0.0085772201,
-0.0331119597,
0.0433180146,
0.0332047269,
0.0598234758,
-0.0243859868,
0.0026944368,
0.0571343563,
0.1085762158,
0.0105583984,
0.0543117039,
0.0309284292,
0.050974898,
0.0123228468,
-0.0167334396,
-0.0544749759,
-0.0233398154,
-0.0220221262,
-0.0144258849,
-0.0269983653,
0.0268851351,
-0.030806981,
-0.0076822313,
-0.0350993611,
-0.0031763143,
0.025751451,
0.0214380994,
0.0109130545,
0.0073027336,
0.0249668583,
0.070883885,
0.0509688556,
-0.0782190636,
0.0157652739,
-0.0229131747,
-0.014392619,
0.0944366232,
0.0446731411,
0.0010978108,
0.0325316712,
-0.0274283215,
-0.0056691803,
0.0519741513,
0.0319447108,
-0.0244345181,
-0.0143164964,
-0.0009657242,
0.0204123668,
0.0507231243,
-0.018040875,
-0.0095941955,
0.0649399161,
-0.0326878503,
0.0153131541,
0.0050958036,
-0.0495012477,
0.0520750433,
-0.0833026543,
-0.0175456405,
-0.0419763997,
0.0088818967,
0.0402709395,
0.0562941581,
0.0143440012,
-0.0125419041,
0.0314775445,
-0.0257618483,
-0.0180508625,
0.0250630416,
-0.0416131057,
0.0006498952,
0.0338867046,
0.0171377063,
-0.0227240194,
-0.0098546296,
0.0330914445,
-0.026947232,
0.0161991231,
-0.0449464209,
0.0628817752,
-0.0476236902,
0.0074847783,
-0.0177640859,
0.0195204578,
-0.0754271746,
0.0712694675,
0.0016839122,
-0.0365393236,
0.0177999735,
0.0038846824,
-0.0213155355,
-0.0762918666,
-0.0307650194,
-0.0219909735,
0.012732761,
0.0223409086,
0.037371885,
-0.0099943578,
-0.0716717616,
-0.0289544258,
-0.0892466605,
-0.0132898707,
-0.0010669812,
-0.0019576852,
-0.0013179003,
0.0038095918,
-0.0246818569,
0.0008471773,
-0.033712063,
-0.0273436233,
0.006903464,
-0.0011787479,
0.0461605154,
-0.0094781574,
-0.0241076238,
-0.0400002897,
0.0018085333,
-0.0207491554,
0.0418829694,
0.0070161629,
-0.0340581499,
-0.0329876095,
0.0366037413,
-0.0020348188,
0.0022963535,
0.0054319911,
0.0109421685,
0.024853725,
0.01330439,
0.0756843537,
0.0429700799,
0.0225760192,
0.0807427168,
-0.0342854746,
-0.0163907185,
-0.0601336733,
-0.0002397609,
-0.0121824676,
-0.0175454579,
-0.0249012392,
-0.0503805652,
0.0168211479,
0.0371359251,
-0.0075801108,
-0.0081340531,
-0.0423039719,
-0.0000704165,
-0.0296249166,
-0.0562399998,
-0.0059136413,
-0.0390469618,
-0.0665215924,
0.015761409,
-0.0072742011,
-0.0238761399,
0.0381083675,
-0.0119048236,
0.0288137402,
-0.0019488649,
-0.0202188529,
-0.0571920946,
0.0674493238,
-0.0207970347,
0.0143752154,
0.0269243643,
-0.0337945111,
0.0029551249,
-0.0223637763,
0.0031808573,
-0.0408096984,
0.0316706859,
-0.0420064777,
0.0165091902,
0.0378644839,
-0.0363590457,
-0.0373190306,
-0.0393441245,
-0.0558832958,
0.0080946665,
0.0068585244,
-0.0111669693,
-0.0155244535,
-0.0177312978,
0.0286681633,
-0.0559195429,
0.0116028236,
-0.0188782793,
-0.0256284717,
0.0292977951,
0.0328416899,
0.0231424496,
0.0170378238,
-0.0342656709,
0.01808214,
0.0182745662,
0.0591415204,
-0.0120026218,
-0.0012971563,
-0.0117144966,
0.0568635687,
-0.028207086,
-0.046873074,
0.04433446,
0.0564810112,
-0.0296211224,
0.0233297795,
0.1293087751,
0.0144210644,
-0.0491779931,
0.0343016535,
-0.0327114239,
0.0172951315,
0.0093620606,
0.0418929569,
-0.042811092,
-0.021870438,
-0.020755589,
-0.0075777154,
-0.0339751169,
-0.0397195667,
-0.0088048959,
-0.0671360046,
0.0136047509,
0.0099112531,
-0.0166150145,
0.0129693067,
-0.0208131708,
-0.0064926916,
-0.0083858008,
0.0567330569,
0.006732564,
-0.0537007749,
-0.016608201,
0.0171900671,
-0.0727173835,
-0.064619869,
0.0436207838,
-0.0754354298,
0.0662273169,
0.0403239578,
0.049297493,
0.0112024695,
-0.0339454859,
-0.0231173541,
-0.0040903743,
0.0543299243,
0.0041420874,
0.0299624894,
-0.0468478128,
0.0209165774,
-0.085506089,
0.0382407606,
-0.0448819324,
-0.0346968584,
-0.0047492725,
0.059031345,
-0.016273452,
0.0336494856,
-0.0182562694,
0.007704319,
0.0059883259,
0.0773292854,
0.017718073,
-0.0837186426,
-0.0132812122,
0.0074647688,
0.0039572273,
0.0169326663,
-0.0658837482,
0.0023367838,
-0.0190985464,
-0.002597589,
-0.0235282741,
-0.0727761835,
0.0245808922,
0.0179234128,
0.0260645319,
0.0374212079,
0.0469856858,
-0.006117309,
-0.0243069865,
0.0407661758,
-0.0511357263,
0.040521387,
-0.0337006301,
-0.0235629622,
0.0521768518,
-0.0262458287,
0.0403914563,
0.0223883428,
-0.041687306,
-0.0565340109,
0.0452071689,
-0.0179514531,
0.0244502556,
0.0537317544,
0.005831501,
-0.1269470751,
0.0009695533,
-0.0201002229,
-0.0216844659,
0.0508773439,
-0.0232992452,
0.0662579462,
-0.0131579954,
0.0288374051,
0.0045530326,
0.031385377,
0.0135342479,
-0.0012209262,
-0.0599549673,
-0.0772883594,
0.0112339733,
0.0147615308,
0.0059379879,
-0.0384921357,
-0.0412251577,
-0.0171194971,
-0.0590895787,
-0.0576004274,
-0.0002896546,
-0.0159790665,
-0.0313632153,
0.0118141696,
0.0051789284,
-0.0173759423,
-0.0450171717,
-0.0527137294,
0.0398354381,
-0.04686407,
0.0599061847,
-0.0161402691,
-0.0130944178,
-0.0161990635,
0.0258955806,
0.0130520016,
0.0049051959,
-0.0386442132,
0.0510567725,
0.0252853353,
0.0738631412,
-0.0091667809,
-0.0107493894,
-0.0090322932,
0.0272213127,
-0.0582150184,
-0.0082987593,
0.000558413,
-0.0064251088,
0.0195905138,
0.0129947634,
0.083514154,
-0.0080726547,
-0.0002387526,
0.0144225257,
0.0215666238,
0.0024880348,
-0.0345944241,
0.0191039238,
0.0294629727,
-0.0378498919,
0.0187103786,
0.0351486132,
0.0375755057,
-0.01702727,
-0.0418450944,
-0.0263745729,
-0.0410718843,
0.0024622635,
0.0494216122,
0.001682001,
-0.0331438184,
0.0091875391,
-0.1274722219,
-0.0456894338,
0.039451547,
-0.0014469221,
0.0166773479,
-0.047061082,
0.0420919769,
0.0467777774,
-0.007523308,
-0.0600482747,
-0.0593545958,
0.0232999288,
-0.0082666399,
-0.0169422682,
-0.0146719227,
-5.976960453e-33,
-0.0446151234,
-0.0595348626,
0.0357896872,
-0.0126958955,
-0.0521256924,
-0.0023232847,
0.0107818544,
0.0190657321,
-0.0201319214,
0.0018210153,
-0.0507196747,
0.0153078865,
0.0172909759,
0.0247648526,
0.0230222605,
0.0242065117,
0.0472877212,
-0.0141052483,
0.027954096,
0.0202034973,
0.0204255842,
0.0247956049,
0.0131918788,
-0.0801655054,
0.0639131591,
-0.0296481363,
-0.0232114866,
0.0346203148,
0.0285134315,
0.0311031807,
-0.0790423006,
0.0479718596,
0.0341440216,
-0.0192320142,
-0.0132119991,
0.0508586504,
-0.0937231928,
0.0070345621,
0.0381562524,
0.0281561185,
0.0065457714,
-0.0548940897,
0.0374862514,
-0.0401197784,
-0.0501080081,
0.013713697,
0.0414537303,
-0.0127406158,
-0.0215606894,
-0.0069928602,
-0.0666319132,
0.0392169319,
0.0027249975,
0.0241532903,
0.0041543175,
-0.007786104,
-0.0608865432,
-0.0020560182,
-0.0612142086,
0.0120456303,
-0.0120883249,
-0.0375046879,
0.0378266349,
0.0443293378,
0.0054216618,
0.0777422339,
0.0275240932,
0.0616918318,
-0.0222644638,
-0.0272452869,
0.029637225,
0.0478156991,
0.0083905682,
0.0598701127,
-0.0262533426,
-0.0187550671,
0.0015148515,
-0.0101642264,
0.0304166414,
0.00268146,
0.0324420296,
0.0122883869,
-0.0674423054,
-0.0482392684,
-0.0147572467,
-0.0109057361,
0.0165461451,
-0.0276684426,
0.0248528179,
-0.0121275028,
-0.0292664729,
0.0052170176,
0.0071966122,
-0.0783808082,
-0.009183825,
-0.0261924099,
0.0106385285,
0.0250479579,
-0.0084477272,
-0.015833186,
-0.0595359281,
-0.0282684024,
-0.0236730818,
0.0181270428,
0.0284201223,
-0.004899187,
0.0206135102,
0.0041026757,
-0.0196776092,
-0.0183839183,
0.0141398562,
0.0308127813,
-0.0104306079,
-0.0224651266,
0.0405888297,
0.0109269358,
-0.0167232975,
0.0380853303,
0.0329010449,
-0.0434959382,
-0.0005152393,
0.0303577259,
0.004366518,
0.00570786,
-0.0256573129,
-0.0014580565,
-0.016590273,
0.0346524566,
0.0769267678,
-0.0163524598,
0.0019175592,
-0.0337945931,
2.589e-7,
0.0343226604,
0.0581218228,
0.0437835604,
-0.024788186,
0.0374776013,
0.0230026469,
0.0466139615,
0.0306892693,
-0.0101541812,
-0.0023335123,
0.0092602391,
0.0337555781,
0.057658039,
-0.0062268698,
-0.0659377798,
-0.0108202649,
-0.0261842776,
-0.0120952819,
-0.0433387645,
0.0365383364,
0.0624389686,
0.034965843,
0.0216954555,
-0.044112809,
-0.0479046889,
-0.027664993,
0.0572141483,
-0.0611087084,
-0.0339002684,
0.0393979214,
0.0285468884,
0.0007558235,
0.0168727487,
0.040771421,
-0.0034391352,
0.042214442,
-0.0056261038,
0.0643339977,
-0.0428221263,
-0.0194920767,
0.0158849061,
-0.0276432019,
-0.0467250496,
-0.0258159693,
0.0445911437,
-0.042556949,
-0.0565831587,
-0.0147141544,
-0.0205804501,
-0.0151436795,
-0.0390784517,
0.0146605149,
-0.0107208155,
0.0226078369,
0.0153430942,
-0.0427437723,
-0.0276873857,
-0.0955616906,
-0.0112180104,
-0.0115007786,
-0.0296759512,
-0.0207705591,
-0.0077476362,
0.0017757997,
0.020181125,
-0.066783905,
0.0164929517,
2.03183969e-34,
0.0291359462,
0.0442439616,
0.0200890452,
0.0469431169,
0.0644213408,
0.0369331986,
-0.0270680897,
0.0286992583,
0.0705394968,
-0.0637007505,
0.022044912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05075v1 | Mental Health Diagnosis in the Digital Age: Harnessing Sentiment Analysis on Social Media Platforms upon Ultra-Sparse Feature Content | 2023-11-09T00:15:06 | 2023-11-09T00:15:06 | Haijian Shao, Ming Zhu, Shengjie Zhai | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Amid growing global mental health concerns, particularly among vulnerable
groups, natural language processing offers a tremendous potential for early
detection and intervention of people's mental disorders via analyzing their
postings and discussions on social media platforms. However, ultra-sparse
training data, often due to vast vocabularies and low-frequency words, hinders
the analysis accuracy. Multi-labeling and Co-occurrences of symptoms may also
blur the boundaries in distinguishing similar/co-related disorders. To address
these issues, we propose a novel semantic feature preprocessing technique with
a three-folded structure: 1) mitigating the feature sparsity with a weak
classifier, 2) adaptive feature dimension with modulus loops, and 3)
deep-mining and extending features among the contexts. With enhanced semantic
features, we train a machine learning model to predict and classify mental
disorders. We utilize the Reddit Mental Health Dataset 2022 to examine
conditions such as Anxiety, Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), and
Bipolar-Disorder (BD) and present solutions to the data sparsity challenge,
highlighted by 99.81% non-zero elements. After applying our preprocessing
technique, the feature sparsity decreases to 85.4%. Overall, our methods, when
compared to seven benchmark models, demonstrate significant performance
improvements: 8.0% in accuracy, 0.069 in precision, 0.093 in recall, 0.102 in
F1 score, and 0.059 in AUC. This research provides foundational insights for
mental health prediction and monitoring, providing innovative solutions to
navigate challenges associated with ultra-sparse data feature and intricate
multi-label classification in the domain of mental health analysis. | [
0.02690107,
0.0611031428,
-0.0114039425,
-0.0248928536,
0.0198789723,
0.0038055759,
-0.0044167396,
0.0182406679,
0.0376741476,
-0.0396855921,
-0.0029862346,
-0.0294729732,
-0.0232463796,
0.0338868573,
-0.0411777981,
-0.0615617372,
0.0298050344,
0.0599822849,
0.0383922383,
0.0012749161,
0.0338978805,
0.0257848203,
-0.0155088697,
0.0335628577,
-0.0507265069,
-0.012536915,
0.0384548418,
0.0204520822,
0.008455974,
-0.0817651823,
0.0134764453,
0.0609192736,
-0.0210436489,
0.0122258179,
0.0000020393,
-0.0190814827,
-0.0072582746,
-0.0153957838,
0.0347812995,
-0.0851106644,
0.0530356131,
-0.0910888314,
0.0299501158,
0.0142695336,
-0.0237071402,
-0.0890851095,
0.0425129682,
0.1251219362,
0.0391163714,
0.048586864,
-0.0394345522,
-0.0175848622,
0.0041102367,
0.0132524744,
0.0151595036,
-0.0177431945,
0.0223662853,
-0.060792923,
0.0080658793,
-0.022888165,
-0.0011592866,
0.0008624616,
-0.0353439115,
0.0466469787,
-0.0053311423,
0.0129291248,
-0.0057938038,
-0.04754759,
0.0120289922,
0.0741416886,
-0.0157852173,
0.0232579354,
0.0102255745,
-0.0073747342,
-0.0030078345,
-0.0095755663,
-0.0262017529,
-0.0170796756,
-0.0075346045,
0.0327395685,
0.027323382,
0.0145195089,
0.0346251428,
0.0022114704,
0.0275918096,
0.0537065342,
-0.0302788801,
-0.0259336066,
0.0041379831,
0.0014601011,
-0.046683345,
-0.0331871361,
-0.0108936392,
0.0058024004,
-0.0258332156,
0.0076549374,
-0.0620106906,
-0.0824210197,
0.037219964,
-0.0117041729,
-0.0101379501,
0.0264315568,
-0.053843841,
-0.0034580242,
0.0302654486,
-0.0515272766,
0.0224640928,
0.0187775083,
0.0122887781,
0.0041549737,
-0.0728127062,
0.0244819261,
-0.0121445442,
0.0340349711,
0.0438516922,
-0.0222254097,
-0.0469537452,
-0.0071411706,
-0.0303036477,
-0.0309251435,
-0.0144548854,
0.0360270105,
0.0203705207,
0.0229623746,
0.0135350311,
0.0480486192,
-0.0109070837,
0.0130395619,
-0.008122175,
-0.0275615063,
0.0297041349,
-0.0165640507,
0.0295366291,
-0.034091685,
0.0329279378,
0.030794682,
0.0607875064,
-0.0467857681,
-0.0512583479,
-0.0669241324,
-0.0345390551,
-0.0110030314,
-0.0094183153,
-0.0553994551,
0.0005267201,
0.0125880856,
0.019181069,
-0.0324853361,
0.0202487372,
-0.0026352934,
-0.075290598,
0.0560303703,
-0.0681411922,
0.001519133,
0.0000258486,
0.0304529238,
0.0376822501,
0.0483663343,
0.0151007948,
0.0007767599,
0.0492656305,
-0.022419706,
-0.018108625,
-0.0253029913,
0.0209144074,
-0.0119489264,
0.0194045175,
-0.0547530986,
-0.0523380563,
0.0050580921,
0.0059122257,
0.0096609537,
0.0196510404,
-0.013682995,
0.0224613287,
0.0756875202,
0.001708824,
0.0509620793,
-0.0099515002,
0.0251385923,
-0.0408808738,
-0.0177003052,
-0.0197169967,
0.005950762,
-0.0210158229,
-0.0222628023,
0.024283478,
0.014900567,
-0.0337567925,
-0.0280095842,
-0.0424888358,
-0.0227774773,
0.0179683641,
-0.0014075424,
-0.0063101933,
-0.023319805,
-0.012639951,
0.0576867647,
0.0789711103,
-0.0103758918,
-0.0473368801,
-0.0201699175,
0.0070276954,
0.0563392043,
-0.0147951497,
-0.0541651919,
-0.0135347135,
-0.0150461327,
0.032736931,
-0.0066350191,
0.0260162298,
0.0206217654,
0.0206759032,
-0.0093499422,
0.0010648399,
0.0165683981,
0.0328764059,
-0.0270559657,
-0.0152358813,
0.0336244218,
-0.0255532563,
0.0186071415,
-0.0058395797,
0.0281670876,
0.0410500951,
-0.0228836294,
0.0430329777,
0.0180169884,
0.0644646287,
0.0336190201,
-0.007253021,
-0.0093279192,
0.0183301121,
-0.0588695891,
-0.0728709772,
-0.0599230975,
-0.0378823616,
-0.0152743254,
0.0341680013,
-0.0004400338,
0.02956862,
0.0465980098,
-0.0375297405,
-0.0201284178,
0.0585095398,
-0.0322496668,
0.0112425592,
0.0131700486,
-0.0441684239,
-0.0039697471,
0.0523100495,
-0.006411606,
0.0400861017,
-0.0225201715,
0.0294286162,
-0.0535102077,
-0.0722496137,
0.0038411065,
0.0071730781,
-0.0633083433,
-0.0364083797,
-0.0302823354,
0.0039143385,
0.0105807353,
0.0090562878,
-0.010325741,
-0.0019584151,
-0.1477422416,
0.0244984496,
-0.0260077808,
-0.031699419,
-0.0188053343,
0.0228827167,
0.0015705389,
-0.0240716152,
-0.0452688187,
0.0313137658,
0.0552353486,
0.0661918744,
0.0136127025,
0.0353531018,
-0.013632589,
-0.0154012125,
-0.0291668922,
-0.0275238324,
0.010331424,
0.01461442,
-0.0277903844,
0.0299342908,
0.0232931562,
-0.0703496262,
0.0077150702,
0.0269988831,
0.0079687573,
-0.0085467333,
-0.0259379242,
-0.0100743324,
-0.0013512513,
-0.007753477,
0.0829690546,
0.0435323901,
0.0598312356,
0.0086832745,
0.0096176136,
-0.0401915349,
-0.0120241698,
-0.0366272219,
-0.0097963484,
-0.0166092366,
0.0703551173,
0.0274849255,
-0.0148212044,
-0.0433629416,
-0.0190334879,
-0.0087893549,
0.0004298205,
-0.0055259722,
0.0258238781,
0.0200959519,
0.0047083357,
-0.0199365672,
-0.0426818542,
0.0582528524,
0.0202765353,
0.0159169044,
-0.0261730887,
-0.0662261695,
-0.0358632989,
0.0258488674,
0.012832148,
0.0248927847,
-0.0000512608,
-0.0000575673,
0.0407814309,
-0.0222268254,
-0.0536802374,
-0.0238216426,
0.024186084,
0.0047914782,
0.0250328183,
0.0199935026,
-0.0476782434,
-0.0186500121,
-0.0560933203,
-0.0706591159,
0.0098901549,
-0.0169417262,
-0.0001466393,
-0.0303348601,
-0.0292737409,
-0.0134942643,
0.0336990766,
0.0248356983,
-0.0368920565,
0.0267439652,
0.0208699983,
0.0675737709,
-0.0056991442,
0.0310595799,
-0.0179352406,
-0.0213015508,
0.0426667891,
-0.0206812881,
0.0267520472,
0.0009979224,
0.0161367469,
0.009808939,
0.0207776539,
-0.0005744617,
-0.0000744206,
-0.006823306,
-0.0591073669,
0.0169644412,
0.1164047047,
0.0175623335,
-0.0456418544,
0.0564355515,
-0.0217486955,
0.0156529229,
0.0155592877,
-0.0302376412,
-0.0463530198,
-0.0585911237,
-0.0481217206,
0.0318937525,
-0.0359884053,
-0.0547904931,
0.0215903912,
-0.0146015305,
0.007378865,
-0.047657337,
0.0036461994,
-0.0070140813,
-0.080043152,
0.0256029069,
-0.0138120819,
-0.0152312834,
-0.0904073045,
0.0227555688,
-0.0135835707,
0.0005331225,
-0.0839998946,
-0.0478921011,
0.0562254116,
0.0018524121,
0.0281421542,
0.0073045301,
0.0387601815,
-0.0017343378,
-0.0201130286,
-0.0073233829,
0.0208663661,
0.013357115,
-0.0323594324,
0.0807024315,
-0.0060718283,
-0.025335243,
-0.0410920344,
0.0417535454,
-0.0877895057,
-0.004967514,
-0.0289502889,
0.0982498601,
-0.0132173058,
-0.0422497913,
-0.0384310298,
0.005680819,
0.0473092049,
0.0473261103,
0.0114436066,
-0.0488032997,
-0.0191313718,
0.0196819529,
-0.0109727308,
-0.03484888,
-0.0581052452,
0.0141985379,
-0.0091494648,
-0.0515594818,
-0.0292324945,
-0.0529611185,
0.0563378669,
-0.0202653166,
-0.0303352438,
-0.016481271,
0.0151638007,
0.0135241281,
-0.0885088071,
0.0798398927,
0.0313892923,
0.021325428,
-0.0208578035,
-0.0059311772,
0.0191059262,
0.0302359331,
-0.0083240364,
0.0237366874,
-0.0793790072,
-0.0154048679,
0.0425102897,
-0.0117361387,
0.0015526065,
-0.0196989663,
0.0151135959,
-0.0443221331,
0.0595641397,
0.0454277284,
-0.0455980934,
0.0092583206,
0.0165541135,
-0.0154080093,
0.0059696445,
0.0763584599,
0.002862229,
0.0415150858,
0.0159060843,
-0.0139409192,
-0.025984114,
-0.022371551,
-0.0070480774,
0.0173435658,
0.0412306003,
0.0014864912,
-0.0221185423,
-0.00621496,
-0.0552596413,
0.032004077,
0.0093677193,
-0.0259536356,
-0.0218464322,
0.0270011891,
-0.0207535829,
-0.0330078006,
-0.0023926219,
-0.0332028568,
0.0221883692,
-0.0352473594,
0.0477092341,
-0.0244293306,
-0.0073347795,
0.0235185008,
0.007058192,
-0.0122238649,
0.0023226803,
-0.0059827925,
-0.0266318657,
0.0005328202,
0.0155163612,
0.0069300542,
0.0372278281,
-0.0110211447,
0.0114652887,
-0.0065698987,
-0.0554561131,
0.001550991,
-0.0230010618,
0.0198584311,
-0.0251549575,
0.0794898495,
-0.0115280859,
-0.0104763042,
-0.0159953572,
0.0074385684,
-0.0452824496,
-0.0424295291,
0.015981907,
0.0241492223,
-0.0131890671,
0.0096263383,
0.0806612819,
-0.0147578372,
0.0261067636,
0.0536006019,
-0.0171524342,
-0.0130996807,
0.039217297,
0.0453171283,
0.0729625523,
-0.0120261637,
0.0448226444,
-0.0479076058,
-0.0423388481,
0.0914054736,
-0.089656502,
-0.0197320487,
-0.0053175981,
0.0295657385,
0.0271927249,
0.0193646401,
0.0366789289,
-0.0342422761,
-0.0108640194,
-0.0266569983,
-0.0485428311,
-0.0266562104,
-6.310524608e-33,
0.0213551931,
-0.0123204151,
-0.0169294085,
-0.0110797528,
-0.0106653804,
0.0311633293,
-0.0133916242,
0.0376874469,
-0.0054872367,
0.0386602692,
0.0184292775,
0.0264314171,
-0.0182059631,
0.0583384261,
0.0118873911,
-0.0132009694,
0.0335224271,
0.0135537116,
0.0098192384,
0.038603697,
0.0437207483,
0.0726159662,
0.0336152576,
-0.1351517588,
-0.002390374,
0.0057098488,
0.0292033777,
0.0072737602,
0.0714562982,
0.0139744421,
-0.0201378614,
0.1163214594,
0.059606187,
-0.0188447703,
0.0111465473,
0.0418843254,
-0.0558479354,
-0.0329679698,
-0.0290452931,
-0.0197808836,
0.0046177288,
-0.0012716667,
0.0129591329,
0.0184704717,
0.0235002059,
-0.053095296,
0.0365191475,
-0.0271374509,
0.0017281536,
-0.0302021746,
-0.0255088862,
0.0245255288,
-0.0080704512,
0.0209409483,
-0.0214413628,
0.0232033748,
-0.0135684134,
0.0206947867,
-0.056757167,
0.0026163247,
-0.0442923158,
0.029356556,
-0.0049915006,
-0.0559726469,
-0.0257957093,
0.0657947883,
0.0189844798,
0.0328461975,
-0.0131753702,
0.0410477556,
-0.0106885275,
0.0331954584,
0.0235199127,
0.0145649211,
0.0780577362,
-0.0433488525,
-0.0629609153,
-0.0078002773,
0.0056614317,
0.0126269087,
0.031363599,
-0.0045533525,
-0.0169688072,
-0.0206836034,
0.0062411134,
0.0412288643,
-0.0271390788,
-0.0338660106,
-0.019243665,
0.0144488541,
0.0069874744,
0.0373373516,
-0.0212866776,
-0.0224785525,
-0.0321975127,
0.037687812,
0.0199418049,
0.0208063275,
0.0146771362,
-0.0153082153,
0.0087286886,
0.0026560675,
0.0125135444,
-0.0249860659,
0.0459516943,
0.0017451975,
0.074192062,
-0.0153186219,
-0.0366730839,
-0.0343309045,
0.0296942443,
0.021184165,
-0.0183338188,
0.1066948324,
-0.0325181484,
0.0372541025,
-0.0088866986,
0.0605007857,
0.0069159348,
0.0330672488,
-0.0226331074,
-0.0309760924,
-0.0064156251,
-0.0120185027,
-0.0028539861,
-0.0680069774,
-0.0397800393,
-0.0407280028,
0.0286579654,
-0.078045845,
0.0003484892,
-0.0369838029,
2.867e-7,
0.0288181733,
0.0388422199,
-0.0513835251,
-0.0256166216,
0.0160045885,
0.0380294211,
0.0426860526,
0.0546423383,
-0.0249302089,
-0.0472883582,
0.0049138325,
0.056739267,
0.0011769354,
0.0621320866,
-0.0220214576,
-0.041690357,
-0.01137973,
-0.0116510848,
-0.0625779331,
0.0188437104,
0.0746814087,
0.1071702838,
0.0232245382,
-0.0626969934,
0.0511795506,
0.0075645559,
0.0064506112,
0.0098253107,
0.0040415921,
0.0159691032,
0.0362601988,
0.0043643406,
0.017251309,
-0.0169089679,
-0.0190187227,
-0.0072310315,
-0.0234978516,
0.0328639299,
-0.0497643761,
-0.0197873283,
0.0349056907,
0.0262961015,
-0.0190086775,
0.0404302813,
0.0614619106,
-0.062081039,
-0.0499243401,
-0.0564623959,
-0.013048891,
-0.0015448991,
0.0335037038,
0.0077567087,
-0.0053715706,
0.0323571227,
0.0318904407,
-0.0346466824,
-0.0029190213,
-0.0701964125,
-0.0045776139,
0.0713238642,
-0.0600879118,
0.0020660406,
0.0128841437,
0.0056947917,
0.0561459661,
-0.0523295514,
0.034878511,
2.638752015e-34,
0.019119719,
0.0360930897,
0.0248795077,
-0.0378379747,
-0.0193401817,
-0.0052631241,
-0.0266705155,
-0.0086713554,
-0.013471623,
-0.0675686747,
0.0007175875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05074v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05074v2 | GRASP: A Disagreement Analysis Framework to Assess Group Associations in Perspectives | 2023-11-09T00:12:21 | 2024-06-14T03:28:49 | Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Christopher Homan, Lora Aroyo, Aida Mostafazadeh Davani, Alicia Parrish, Alex Taylor, Mark Díaz, Ding Wang, Gregory Serapio-García | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Human annotation plays a core role in machine learning -- annotations for
supervised models, safety guardrails for generative models, and human feedback
for reinforcement learning, to cite a few avenues. However, the fact that many
of these human annotations are inherently subjective is often overlooked.
Recent work has demonstrated that ignoring rater subjectivity (typically
resulting in rater disagreement) is problematic within specific tasks and for
specific subgroups. Generalizable methods to harness rater disagreement and
thus understand the socio-cultural leanings of subjective tasks remain elusive.
In this paper, we propose GRASP, a comprehensive disagreement analysis
framework to measure group association in perspectives among different rater
sub-groups, and demonstrate its utility in assessing the extent of systematic
disagreements in two datasets: (1) safety annotations of human-chatbot
conversations, and (2) offensiveness annotations of social media posts, both
annotated by diverse rater pools across different socio-demographic axes. Our
framework (based on disagreement metrics) reveals specific rater groups that
have significantly different perspectives than others on certain tasks, and
helps identify demographic axes that are crucial to consider in specific task
contexts. | [
0.0475446284,
0.0778589621,
-0.0097818011,
-0.0135455346,
-0.0150466841,
0.0539925657,
0.0333757624,
-0.0330509692,
-0.0227981526,
-0.0603265092,
-0.0594199486,
-0.0126801021,
0.0293223392,
-0.0074036634,
0.0149807232,
-0.0507360771,
0.0210136082,
0.0565431155,
0.0394142456,
0.0016178583,
0.0451221913,
0.0243456271,
-0.0200942606,
0.075969778,
-0.0396643057,
-0.0582577251,
0.0233314671,
-0.0060036224,
0.0832609385,
-0.0158634149,
0.0613106638,
0.0453728437,
-0.0439274088,
0.0523522831,
0.0000018123,
-0.0181064885,
-0.015338352,
-0.0104048792,
0.0402531102,
-0.0237210393,
0.077855058,
0.0207925569,
-0.003275712,
0.0304149408,
-0.0509194992,
0.0090030283,
0.0504665338,
0.0447464623,
0.0460802242,
0.0197492354,
-0.0122268405,
0.017314082,
-0.0775524974,
-0.0165313967,
-0.0169369653,
-0.0079414342,
-0.0040461253,
0.0364540033,
-0.0574846566,
-0.0044321469,
-0.0183359478,
-0.0158586409,
0.007766095,
-0.0167984404,
0.0046902858,
-0.0135112423,
-0.0402335078,
-0.0431278609,
0.0269712973,
0.0584288798,
0.0255694743,
-0.0001730773,
-0.0113633517,
-0.001321145,
0.0162490029,
0.0255061518,
-0.0200086478,
0.0159703456,
-0.0310273413,
-0.0017597125,
-0.0288707539,
0.0328274593,
-0.0000384577,
0.0085876109,
0.0386953987,
0.0586661249,
-0.0296987686,
0.0116943279,
0.0195186734,
0.037608292,
-0.0167278294,
-0.0171630289,
0.0406519324,
-0.0199761856,
-0.0229816791,
0.0000336156,
-0.0271136705,
0.0078450069,
0.0453030504,
-0.0704123005,
0.0177783351,
0.0200213138,
-0.0342502333,
0.0147883287,
0.0596814752,
-0.0064198817,
0.0300263409,
0.0328876264,
-0.0082306163,
-0.0172361638,
-0.0532861501,
0.0131693855,
0.0470347218,
-0.014960181,
0.008513513,
0.0387442708,
-0.0676041991,
-0.0023001758,
-0.088859573,
-0.0172405243,
-0.0322816782,
0.0137892077,
0.0165874902,
0.0297171716,
-0.0399077013,
0.0407495648,
-0.0532113872,
0.0271107089,
-0.0216263644,
-0.0356819518,
0.012299858,
0.0302461348,
-0.0138834659,
-0.011199086,
-0.0100665493,
-0.0384757034,
0.0227791984,
0.0112874024,
-0.0056752693,
-0.0276711788,
-0.0316401385,
-0.0447495729,
0.0112011293,
-0.0648590773,
0.0363491848,
0.0143001573,
-0.0040816707,
-0.0396666154,
0.0037032142,
0.0450317934,
-0.0014227227,
0.0573501438,
0.0265539177,
-0.0122335078,
0.0414281264,
0.0459607169,
-0.0498599969,
0.0293517243,
-0.0025504334,
0.0122801196,
0.0394337922,
0.0132629406,
0.0152956694,
-0.0026018114,
-0.0303298272,
-0.018435495,
-0.000276459,
-0.0091896988,
-0.0365398452,
-0.0389413983,
0.0610859282,
0.0568836778,
-0.0127861472,
-0.0610273108,
0.0386903584,
0.1087851897,
-0.0537987687,
0.0244546402,
0.0006665556,
0.0139765106,
0.0052211522,
-0.0063505056,
-0.0365138538,
0.0313973911,
-0.0068595717,
-0.0626799762,
0.0083775241,
0.0378180221,
-0.0259767771,
-0.0640932769,
-0.0320859812,
0.0085870167,
0.0870652944,
-0.007746276,
-0.0005476581,
-0.0003828575,
0.031507358,
-0.0435631685,
0.0562446825,
-0.0278215297,
-0.0319077224,
-0.0406149141,
0.0318639874,
0.0333577134,
-0.0191994924,
-0.015671365,
-0.0289721973,
-0.0224043988,
0.0144258402,
0.0157911237,
0.0710242316,
-0.032433778,
-0.019577207,
-0.0141257113,
-0.0300689489,
0.0252506379,
0.0064317677,
0.0427991562,
0.0285573993,
0.0118406825,
-0.0211196691,
0.018461844,
-0.0557502024,
0.0153360078,
0.031866312,
0.040257737,
0.0030507715,
0.0288373604,
0.0768895373,
0.052563116,
-0.0089237839,
-0.0091561778,
-0.0177475139,
-0.0017204293,
-0.0319264755,
0.0355813429,
-0.0220484398,
-0.0303134136,
0.0202426072,
-0.0716913342,
-0.0629070848,
0.0043047117,
-0.0027272857,
0.0355650596,
0.0197696518,
-0.0217940677,
-0.0177358463,
-0.016314093,
-0.0282832831,
-0.0146980295,
-0.0089557804,
-0.0500881337,
0.0423515327,
-0.0216743723,
0.0016803519,
-0.0400244221,
-0.0516161695,
0.033980757,
-0.0066747754,
-0.0551823303,
0.0006484847,
0.0045333845,
0.0125852888,
0.0487937629,
-0.0207355861,
-0.0551740676,
0.0111915004,
-0.1379366815,
-0.0285093337,
-0.0266708136,
0.0085152183,
0.0133650452,
-0.040352948,
-0.0020193404,
-0.0334136784,
-0.0285886675,
-0.0102891205,
-0.0290377419,
0.065382123,
0.0263106562,
-0.0256869309,
0.0326616541,
-0.0300660692,
-0.0108798444,
-0.0333477035,
0.0502509549,
0.0522169694,
-0.0075807483,
0.0065715336,
-0.061012581,
-0.091759041,
-0.008010556,
-0.0194389261,
-0.021606002,
0.0559684001,
0.0652540028,
0.0236644857,
0.0484000854,
0.0419595391,
0.0734509602,
0.0607924052,
0.0056255991,
-0.0334326215,
-0.0196766127,
-0.0218102373,
0.0003690504,
0.0551521666,
-0.0959690586,
-0.0076038786,
0.0703651458,
0.0209927447,
0.0027225192,
-0.0682703257,
0.0604864433,
-0.0602219999,
-0.0333227143,
-0.0278571602,
-0.0174920019,
0.0017266186,
0.0329224579,
-0.0386604145,
-0.0279822741,
0.0816430598,
0.027719833,
0.0274052266,
-0.0160191078,
-0.0068945508,
-0.0315534361,
0.0423194692,
-0.0154118277,
0.0176819861,
0.0281925499,
0.0091027217,
-0.006952452,
0.0027629137,
0.0552849136,
-0.0528464429,
-0.0009197314,
-0.0262552928,
-0.0181627106,
0.0080358181,
-0.0490273945,
-0.0199248157,
-0.0172530916,
-0.024308553,
-0.0152451927,
0.0177445542,
-0.0428328775,
-0.0034254203,
-0.0001130472,
0.0055576866,
-0.0239878464,
0.0051213345,
-0.0231308173,
0.043637,
-0.0296970177,
0.0486829653,
0.0222324878,
0.0351788141,
-0.0335336141,
-0.016292626,
0.1015383229,
0.0136528322,
0.0067122751,
-0.0075327749,
-0.0210546833,
0.0034687887,
0.0243493598,
-0.0229856875,
-0.039414119,
0.0589135475,
-0.0126740076,
0.0393998511,
0.0781548545,
0.0323819555,
-0.0523820259,
0.0102976514,
-0.0302429274,
0.0197153781,
0.0204226859,
0.0038964662,
-0.0599989593,
0.0133926701,
-0.0418539383,
0.052739691,
-0.0627695918,
-0.0624419302,
-0.0055690515,
-0.0711998343,
0.0281622354,
-0.0165261086,
-0.0442815833,
-0.0182083976,
-0.0321812108,
0.0579797924,
-0.0194187779,
0.0182950366,
-0.0450797789,
0.0458336398,
0.0188546292,
0.0326692127,
-0.0748779401,
-0.0077735619,
0.0500276424,
-0.046386499,
0.0597955547,
0.0161172058,
0.054170996,
0.0253991913,
-0.0231118463,
0.0296826605,
0.0023448518,
0.0069487486,
-0.0206095222,
0.0647392198,
-0.0308096595,
-0.0015307701,
-0.0535830371,
0.0217833426,
-0.0078179361,
-0.0346626826,
-0.0044419724,
0.0329421535,
-0.0129324151,
0.0111866873,
-0.045632679,
0.0299030785,
-0.0023373915,
0.0712212101,
0.0107265459,
-0.0580294728,
-0.0023714057,
-0.0361044593,
0.0157745015,
-0.0180368833,
-0.0729952976,
-0.0046879025,
-0.0117885815,
-0.0558300577,
-0.0582291111,
-0.0674146116,
0.0157211497,
0.0011656391,
-0.0325128473,
-0.0482165255,
0.0544326454,
-0.0065155672,
-0.0565809086,
0.0442667082,
0.0302796997,
-0.0046956106,
0.0105278147,
-0.0382288806,
-0.0084771877,
0.0050496622,
-0.0339237861,
-0.002789943,
-0.0388065539,
-0.034786772,
0.0269631464,
0.0340121947,
0.0127063068,
0.0132643413,
0.0014435358,
-0.0270553529,
-0.0082249548,
0.0353127904,
0.0463085845,
0.0155125642,
-0.0010617219,
0.0593410209,
-0.005745207,
-0.0001562066,
-0.0194321554,
0.0166673753,
0.046913974,
-0.0436738916,
-0.0779551864,
-0.0303201526,
0.006974618,
-0.0452604033,
0.0473955534,
0.0095872413,
-0.0276461374,
-0.0207285956,
-0.0423808508,
-0.0053966814,
-0.0212623682,
-0.0139656831,
-0.0408600122,
-0.006509311,
-0.0620411485,
-0.0573996454,
0.038627468,
-0.007081049,
0.0589127615,
-0.0650977939,
0.0452063978,
0.0190316737,
0.0167509355,
-0.0511513241,
-0.0060390662,
-0.002757166,
-0.0102800969,
0.0014288598,
0.0230614208,
0.0400056653,
0.0839902982,
0.0210298002,
0.0146699818,
0.0250244476,
0.0055479244,
-0.0285768062,
-0.0254860464,
0.002920496,
0.015180069,
-0.0206653308,
-0.006182312,
0.0431888402,
-0.0063699097,
-0.0138283661,
-0.0234279949,
0.0226276442,
-0.0073190155,
-0.0215350296,
0.0047906041,
0.029032724,
-0.002179066,
0.001472207,
0.0560932383,
-0.0306831859,
-0.0012624332,
-0.007535052,
-0.1154865026,
-0.0287090708,
0.0072277682,
0.0404601842,
0.0167970527,
-0.0096968105,
0.0126906671,
-0.0892616659,
-0.0371832401,
0.0097951889,
0.0131063107,
0.0371748693,
0.0278020948,
0.0062487978,
0.0597059652,
-0.0405148529,
-0.0328952,
-0.0296053477,
-0.0241342429,
-0.0208375193,
0.0003441305,
-0.032856904,
-6.014290848e-33,
-0.0156768803,
-0.0714405701,
-0.0401339307,
0.0406149961,
-0.0128525086,
-0.0177025031,
-0.0082212221,
0.0432684645,
-0.0133726019,
0.0431913696,
0.0158399232,
0.0394055136,
0.0076760855,
-0.0056151929,
0.056366317,
-0.0375287049,
0.0316216536,
-0.0050764652,
-0.0322637074,
0.0168643519,
0.0388719775,
-0.0288019702,
0.0309313051,
-0.1243031174,
0.0667803958,
0.0255615506,
-0.0169449039,
-0.0063679502,
0.0030200828,
0.0637416169,
-0.0161890965,
0.0714827776,
0.0319193341,
-0.0181804709,
0.0117589459,
0.0312408172,
-0.0509902947,
-0.0436742865,
-0.0153607475,
0.0256637465,
-0.0153807355,
-0.0219083652,
0.0212349147,
0.0188376214,
-0.0385733359,
-0.0224381052,
0.0547683835,
-0.0088369315,
0.0752723366,
-0.0644147843,
-0.0290761497,
0.0151752923,
-0.0416348614,
-0.0288355928,
-0.0062192911,
0.0079566222,
-0.0101510854,
0.0048896857,
-0.0704356506,
0.0391422026,
-0.0626041219,
-0.0302681047,
0.0291098002,
0.0247499812,
0.0064207013,
0.0696154237,
0.0185408853,
0.0595821999,
-0.0505182222,
-0.0464150235,
0.0065263668,
0.0266146902,
0.0019379512,
0.0723915398,
0.0536439195,
-0.0136586614,
-0.041475147,
0.0287570003,
0.0579374991,
0.0190476198,
0.0379984304,
0.0035672032,
-0.0708367079,
-0.0120005449,
0.0085991733,
-0.0521375537,
-0.0330125913,
-0.0078890743,
-0.0012627108,
0.0014495838,
-0.0390429832,
-0.0051482399,
0.0040704804,
-0.0154563393,
0.0059447424,
-0.0001965807,
-0.0258515235,
-0.0086736036,
0.0227776673,
-0.023204226,
-0.0431980342,
0.0456589386,
-0.0122053754,
-0.0101240519,
0.0506531745,
-0.0213599615,
0.0875373334,
0.0136039453,
-0.0619700029,
-0.015127562,
0.0100616002,
0.0104021169,
-0.0241251476,
0.023005832,
0.0458881296,
0.0492866449,
-0.0125649432,
0.0104595711,
0.0098979725,
0.0547859855,
-0.022428412,
-0.0088720527,
-0.0412917845,
-0.0121460883,
0.0004501952,
-0.0318856798,
0.0414172709,
-0.0114005944,
-0.0135213062,
-0.039627023,
-0.0232211128,
-0.0394395627,
2.411e-7,
0.0657409951,
0.0637375414,
0.0037923828,
0.002463829,
0.0368692763,
0.0418238789,
0.0396869145,
0.0352473035,
0.0302856974,
-0.0388668776,
0.0125898151,
0.0271474868,
0.0458396301,
0.0769266784,
-0.0090269363,
-0.0063893083,
-0.0326741822,
0.0058574649,
-0.0004287366,
0.0283654649,
0.0759903416,
0.0359837189,
0.0309416484,
-0.0025082941,
-0.0206531808,
0.0417228937,
0.0530899391,
-0.0286052916,
-0.0018167644,
-0.0065931776,
0.061662849,
-0.0515188724,
0.0279900823,
0.0672546253,
0.0021523249,
-0.0259586256,
0.0416740477,
0.0135037554,
-0.0061369599,
-0.0371829122,
-0.0077680456,
0.0436860695,
0.0043167993,
-0.0415108241,
0.0316196121,
-0.0396402068,
-0.0359736942,
-0.0483883247,
-0.0091879321,
0.0081981579,
0.08615271,
0.0073149935,
-0.030576339,
-0.0065494063,
0.0245831218,
-0.0110631818,
-0.0159166455,
-0.0508003421,
-0.0136085525,
-0.0058382871,
-0.0398380682,
-0.0611723103,
0.0103257252,
0.0282963105,
-0.0031395678,
-0.0075707757,
0.0117089404,
1.763167599e-34,
0.0074491855,
-0.0031951079,
-0.0310089644,
-0.0222838335,
0.0402017012,
0.0213209782,
-0.0193952788,
-0.004594279,
0.0266845264,
0.0114367828,
-0.0167964753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05051v1 | Deep Learning Brasil at ABSAPT 2022: Portuguese Transformer Ensemble Approaches | 2023-11-08T22:58:34 | 2023-11-08T22:58:34 | Juliana Resplande Santanna Gomes, Eduardo Augusto Santos Garcia, Adalberto Ferreira Barbosa Junior, Ruan Chaves Rodrigues, Diogo Fernandes Costa Silva, Dyonnatan Ferreira Maia, Nádia Félix Felipe da Silva, Arlindo Rodrigues Galvão Filho, Anderson da Silva Soares | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is a task whose objective is to
classify the individual sentiment polarity of all entities, called aspects, in
a sentence. The task is composed of two subtasks: Aspect Term Extraction (ATE),
identify all aspect terms in a sentence; and Sentiment Orientation Extraction
(SOE), given a sentence and its aspect terms, the task is to determine the
sentiment polarity of each aspect term (positive, negative or neutral). This
article presents we present our participation in Aspect-Based Sentiment
Analysis in Portuguese (ABSAPT) 2022 at IberLEF 2022. We submitted the best
performing systems, achieving new state-of-the-art results on both subtasks. | [
-0.0143350633,
0.0531872436,
0.0135598751,
0.0528617166,
0.0016849327,
0.0062680868,
-0.0125399958,
-0.0260928404,
-0.0715868548,
-0.0160358902,
-0.0632116273,
-0.0630911887,
-0.0369344428,
0.0495862365,
-0.0396947339,
-0.0292291287,
0.0349317268,
0.0598835871,
-0.0424063168,
-0.0230837036,
0.0041485243,
0.0240260698,
-0.0010024704,
-0.0010583324,
0.0175910667,
-0.005397337,
0.0080547705,
-0.0363994986,
0.0429701842,
-0.0105587477,
0.0341784544,
0.0077631958,
-0.0440688804,
0.0203519724,
0.000001926,
-0.0267680846,
-0.0587300994,
-0.0203238409,
0.0343690962,
-0.0321752094,
0.0562053062,
-0.0004292403,
-0.0251338035,
0.0106042447,
-0.068422623,
-0.0704197735,
0.0327599905,
0.0838029832,
0.0468851589,
0.0909121782,
-0.0181654878,
-0.0310636517,
0.0063247462,
-0.0327575244,
-0.0251570567,
-0.0166928321,
-0.0117724184,
-0.0823368132,
-0.0576111041,
0.0296300109,
0.0067885076,
0.0137517173,
0.0436915793,
0.0033301567,
-0.0116665149,
-0.0126966015,
0.0229098909,
0.0079212897,
-0.0104109785,
0.020512566,
0.0403439403,
0.0146375876,
-0.0290993769,
-0.006489384,
-0.0281500164,
-0.0236902609,
-0.0118830102,
0.0272773337,
0.0129167568,
0.0499445572,
0.0624036267,
0.0791062713,
0.0207886416,
0.0479438342,
-0.0216257107,
0.0495428108,
-0.028117571,
-0.0507763587,
0.051961489,
0.0619611405,
0.012014552,
0.0167726595,
0.0358400904,
-0.0035003393,
0.0317230299,
0.0047606421,
0.0547215864,
0.0060566869,
0.0152401375,
-0.0729729682,
-0.0264234971,
-0.0248394888,
-0.0478050672,
0.0434972718,
-0.0157093946,
-0.0168677531,
-0.0153080663,
-0.0335336141,
0.0023380397,
-0.0093639307,
-0.0310861133,
0.0040692366,
0.0096943025,
0.0631860048,
-0.0514494069,
0.0386798196,
-0.0609385259,
-0.0359478183,
-0.0291546956,
-0.0123694707,
0.0472841822,
0.0390834026,
0.0083997119,
-0.0233635921,
-0.0263116658,
0.0986078829,
-0.0429490134,
0.0262602102,
-0.0436847024,
0.0062361332,
0.023789743,
0.0311389994,
-0.0250790827,
-0.0441135503,
0.0305539183,
-0.0084655955,
0.0178334694,
-0.0394800752,
0.0076611927,
-0.0227934867,
-0.0182683505,
-0.086228922,
0.0044219098,
-0.0475149229,
0.0191873591,
-0.0246560872,
0.0083344486,
-0.0206000116,
0.0073581338,
-0.0009163616,
0.0349922664,
0.0183891375,
-0.0195188224,
-0.0381307714,
-0.0429536812,
0.0208841879,
0.057390023,
0.0526982769,
-0.0322310328,
0.0548210368,
0.0025511135,
0.009199148,
0.008575066,
0.0196785759,
0.0142703932,
-0.0182004739,
0.0199518688,
-0.0050467313,
-0.0447615162,
-0.0211465824,
0.0071506076,
0.040280696,
0.0193546601,
-0.0339731835,
0.0111968415,
-0.0386934504,
-0.0268101357,
0.0876107588,
0.025529949,
-0.0400674045,
0.0128431618,
-0.0298557673,
0.0006602837,
0.0204743054,
-0.0054410216,
-0.0236489959,
-0.0180540793,
0.0527893342,
-0.0126908608,
-0.0428613536,
0.0302707702,
-0.0229807589,
-0.0210806001,
-0.0159174018,
0.0695401356,
0.0048276135,
-0.0468740836,
-0.0098513057,
0.0261384733,
-0.0843885019,
-0.0147713656,
-0.0296174549,
0.0417541265,
0.0231873021,
-0.0221193731,
-0.0178906918,
-0.0334595293,
-0.0381145924,
-0.0393075868,
0.0437749624,
0.0218212865,
-0.0013174325,
0.0095961131,
-0.0425944105,
0.0083505595,
-0.0004315018,
0.0069398717,
0.0178669095,
-0.0283082649,
0.066524446,
0.0044144872,
0.0228733588,
0.02322766,
0.0046681184,
0.0175069086,
-0.0176253375,
0.0413859598,
0.0391610451,
0.0304862373,
0.0821728855,
0.0135951089,
-0.0424095355,
0.0488641635,
-0.0419501737,
-0.0613568388,
0.0308318604,
-0.0413380228,
-0.0163563434,
0.0047199186,
-0.018957492,
-0.0121743735,
0.0196600743,
-0.0066709262,
-0.0091171563,
0.0242632087,
0.0074380026,
0.0020781385,
-0.0124921398,
0.0268997494,
-0.0157900322,
0.0475666448,
0.0048448271,
0.0582779981,
-0.0343171135,
0.0082577979,
-0.0550325774,
-0.0453751162,
0.0285038967,
-0.0024248988,
-0.0272008199,
0.0072500925,
0.015148106,
-0.0167188589,
0.0288215242,
0.0276787765,
0.00534443,
-0.0195056647,
-0.0910716057,
0.0165940505,
-0.0141373146,
0.0426873304,
0.0432438254,
0.0128455423,
0.0175702423,
0.0387692899,
-0.0485192277,
-0.0074916086,
-0.0111969383,
-0.0080175651,
0.0197859257,
0.0209207628,
0.0297493115,
-0.0204302836,
0.006226406,
-0.0278472044,
0.0193510894,
0.0295824613,
-0.0338992327,
-0.033999566,
0.0431139618,
-0.0104119219,
0.009012755,
0.0012831034,
-0.0462013893,
-0.0110005112,
0.0028416857,
-0.0034414644,
0.0497993492,
0.0189670008,
0.0521567799,
0.0173021127,
0.0448358469,
-0.009842868,
0.0128412517,
-0.0683196411,
0.033925198,
-0.0399233513,
-0.0077955551,
0.0247774459,
0.0717373341,
-0.0246446021,
0.0147553952,
-0.0153098954,
-0.0011750398,
-0.0135579472,
-0.0133655071,
0.0584629141,
0.0259869676,
0.0071890657,
-0.0148502076,
0.021768067,
0.0127513129,
0.0514565185,
0.014036986,
-0.0170191042,
-0.0995201245,
-0.0222561508,
-0.0274873842,
0.070381023,
-0.0278557111,
0.0085629895,
-0.0051792064,
0.0191496313,
0.0086350609,
-0.0356619433,
-0.0208695084,
-0.0134569854,
0.0407568999,
0.0173362922,
-0.0204598662,
-0.004151246,
-0.0767925605,
0.0010147,
-0.0418908522,
-0.0393294804,
0.0198386908,
0.0361833796,
-0.0286554676,
-0.0158109069,
-0.0096049728,
-0.0041348469,
-0.0390839055,
-0.0302426107,
-0.0117793754,
0.0239754505,
0.0413837209,
0.0445830002,
-0.0409113392,
0.0559515283,
-0.0207744334,
0.0003013948,
0.0470346324,
-0.0486516729,
-0.004659255,
-0.046733994,
-0.0361263193,
0.040151123,
-0.0090989964,
-0.0266312566,
-0.0901428461,
0.0591816306,
-0.0448163524,
-0.0006720637,
0.076208353,
0.0138687016,
-0.0873391107,
-0.0065965531,
0.0102468785,
-0.0211150553,
0.0080468999,
0.0356795713,
-0.0599328168,
-0.0051211235,
-0.0241654813,
0.0006850039,
-0.0256850068,
0.0052100341,
0.0070288754,
-0.1088438779,
0.0250145216,
-0.0351707861,
-0.060243655,
-0.0802094564,
-0.0570075177,
-0.0122064147,
-0.0791515931,
0.0093604475,
-0.0333345123,
0.0223196559,
0.0132399769,
0.0182272792,
-0.0060321139,
-0.0302112345,
0.0253533199,
-0.0149224484,
0.0245908312,
0.038827803,
0.0380852073,
-0.0221202504,
-0.0342559777,
0.0279837325,
-0.0625179633,
-0.0030212959,
-0.0463034399,
0.0680837184,
-0.0275605209,
-0.0442778841,
-0.0109510282,
0.014569045,
-0.0501272231,
0.0437175445,
0.0014483349,
0.0868017972,
-0.0151369479,
-0.0213688929,
-0.0217684098,
-0.0049770074,
0.0296149738,
0.0275809672,
-0.0146395927,
-0.0488144681,
-0.0139047066,
0.0135705788,
0.0032962132,
-0.0672484785,
-0.0356404185,
-0.045200374,
-0.0021071618,
-0.038849134,
-0.0553649403,
-0.0736449584,
-0.0017236236,
0.0287879892,
-0.032666076,
-0.0279963426,
-0.013114023,
0.0188800562,
-0.0470707566,
0.0178470127,
0.0200496614,
0.0351599157,
-0.0056309779,
-0.0275060404,
0.0702707544,
0.0292316675,
-0.0279904697,
-0.0323324651,
-0.0093653183,
-0.0251116771,
0.0134952627,
0.0326506607,
0.00790272,
-0.0194340032,
-0.0036533056,
-0.0026283471,
0.0064436616,
0.0935218707,
-0.0275864843,
-0.0093950015,
0.054115694,
0.0227500033,
0.0103294263,
0.0377777368,
0.0144590354,
0.0465211347,
0.0218297224,
0.0058496161,
-0.0359473713,
-0.0367047526,
-0.0174968708,
-0.0101938657,
0.0741526634,
0.0167519711,
-0.0519595817,
-0.0155376783,
0.0051420303,
0.0117355436,
0.0119683193,
0.000748446,
0.0098044323,
0.0084605599,
-0.0128864944,
-0.0349044316,
0.0821359083,
0.0119220167,
-0.0138006918,
-0.0129882172,
0.0636264905,
0.0551400557,
0.0175279621,
-0.0436720811,
0.0552081615,
-0.0071574198,
-0.0110549312,
0.0358308442,
0.0227638241,
-0.0212640744,
0.0261983387,
0.0018855843,
0.0111499522,
-0.0190900657,
0.0389106534,
0.0188820269,
0.0512690656,
-0.0633641258,
-0.0010900059,
0.0233520269,
-0.0367631242,
0.0638351589,
-0.0259387549,
0.0051148618,
-0.000534353,
-0.0141879488,
-0.0392163508,
0.0123737231,
0.0349653177,
-0.0103711374,
-0.020208776,
0.0133512048,
0.0221331287,
-0.1136733666,
0.048774384,
0.0540365651,
0.0192972925,
-0.0255339779,
-0.0050065122,
0.0516935214,
-0.0453402624,
-0.0199207012,
0.0097577982,
-0.0407038964,
-0.0266322903,
0.0244730636,
-0.013173338,
0.013004086,
0.0081520006,
0.0147268157,
0.0426657647,
0.0059001488,
0.0367338955,
-0.0377386995,
0.0142611414,
-0.0548056029,
0.0073088408,
-0.053618703,
-6.196982139e-33,
-0.0144956941,
0.0123680457,
-0.0248758979,
0.00447712,
-0.0342659801,
0.0006825022,
-0.0158172753,
0.040602535,
-0.0018668235,
0.0549405627,
0.0174688864,
0.0073126019,
0.0070469067,
0.0346672237,
0.0084265955,
-0.0082575334,
0.0343891606,
-0.0024518624,
0.0034046138,
0.0430710316,
0.0363557227,
0.0336189419,
0.0988328531,
-0.1270852089,
0.0075133485,
0.0156253763,
-0.0567621216,
0.0112918699,
-0.0062164217,
0.067463398,
-0.015438146,
0.0378190354,
0.0242698062,
-0.0666874349,
0.0206150897,
-0.014732955,
0.0052121142,
-0.0319625698,
-0.0087732943,
0.0321721584,
0.0055577443,
-0.0583852418,
0.0193573181,
0.0137632601,
-0.0237980988,
-0.0036657774,
0.0198525507,
-0.0169523489,
0.0326472893,
-0.096151039,
-0.0435121208,
0.0262469351,
0.0299521424,
-0.0143158482,
0.0371911414,
0.0590398833,
0.0151305515,
-0.0015685634,
-0.0185514726,
0.0084748501,
-0.0603199601,
0.0486565679,
0.0089363968,
-0.0370847173,
-0.0047170883,
0.0463054366,
0.0238835774,
-0.0104040615,
-0.0380776338,
0.0461936891,
0.0252235904,
0.0364900082,
0.0437325612,
0.0669834986,
0.0303767212,
0.0011012856,
-0.0454276502,
0.0209703576,
0.0539576747,
-0.0080932332,
0.0172261707,
-0.0328636765,
-0.0478481911,
0.0193530433,
0.0391607471,
-0.062679857,
-0.0078477496,
-0.0283876285,
-0.0245119296,
-0.0243695304,
-0.0468900613,
0.0473305061,
-0.0038038827,
-0.0799557492,
-0.0080461418,
0.0109290686,
-0.0378889069,
0.0347293168,
0.0170735549,
-0.0029891208,
-0.057906948,
-0.0355454385,
-0.0560340844,
0.0572266988,
0.0063777147,
0.0035708025,
0.0673176721,
0.0086510284,
-0.0898279399,
-0.0129968198,
-0.005603821,
0.0270261429,
0.0035255086,
0.0936291665,
-0.0300676897,
0.0015975807,
-0.0136179011,
0.0900281817,
0.0080280444,
0.069419831,
-0.0100007048,
-0.0213955361,
0.0326665044,
0.0254377015,
-0.0417937897,
-0.0232020449,
0.0004149792,
0.001703712,
-0.0432189219,
-0.0187934339,
-0.0156212645,
-0.029004788,
2.675e-7,
0.0337426737,
0.0268583186,
0.0163190104,
-0.0232283771,
-0.0027192817,
0.042979233,
0.0283803251,
-0.0006968313,
-0.0266958419,
0.0274061039,
0.0283265561,
0.0011481331,
0.0159245208,
0.0400630161,
-0.0776595771,
0.0579748079,
-0.0028384442,
-0.0225866605,
-0.0173131563,
0.0139030321,
0.0478852168,
0.1294035763,
0.0424957983,
-0.0117626507,
-0.0147318244,
0.0572096184,
0.0424895436,
-0.0042398139,
-0.0155377081,
-0.0028597871,
-0.0256579742,
-0.0032442105,
-0.0337341465,
-0.0500311144,
0.0187266115,
0.0363546945,
-0.0243291222,
0.0637534559,
0.0050922497,
-0.0383065306,
0.0483824164,
-0.0117328139,
0.0055742445,
-0.0207668524,
0.0382291712,
-0.0575994551,
-0.0612198152,
-0.1029282212,
-0.0250364225,
0.0354772136,
0.0397972763,
-0.000703563,
-0.0121104484,
0.0352592245,
-0.007922817,
-0.0592939146,
-0.0734044313,
-0.0651271492,
-0.0020731397,
0.0341136903,
0.0202858262,
-0.0092155822,
0.0196275152,
0.0512731075,
-0.0097885039,
-0.0042136176,
0.0300489739,
2.053157234e-34,
0.0209418405,
-0.0073882588,
-0.0191611908,
0.0177824609,
-0.0013120989,
-0.0198780708,
-0.0367065147,
-0.0097072665,
0.0098325014,
0.0196065288,
0.0172849279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05047v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05047v1 | DeepLearningBrasil@LT-EDI-2023: Exploring Deep Learning Techniques for Detecting Depression in Social Media Text | 2023-11-08T22:42:31 | 2023-11-08T22:42:31 | Eduardo Garcia, Juliana Gomes, Adalberto Barbosa Júnior, Cardeque Borges, Nádia da Silva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we delineate the strategy employed by our team,
DeepLearningBrasil, which secured us the first place in the shared task
DepSign-LT-EDI@RANLP-2023, achieving a 47.0% Macro F1-Score and a notable 2.4%
advantage. The task was to classify social media texts into three distinct
levels of depression - "not depressed," "moderately depressed," and "severely
depressed." Leveraging the power of the RoBERTa and DeBERTa models, we further
pre-trained them on a collected Reddit dataset, specifically curated from
mental health-related Reddit's communities (Subreddits), leading to an enhanced
understanding of nuanced mental health discourse. To address lengthy textual
data, we used truncation techniques that retained the essence of the content by
focusing on its beginnings and endings. Our model was robust against unbalanced
data by incorporating sample weights into the loss. Cross-validation and
ensemble techniques were then employed to combine our k-fold trained models,
delivering an optimal solution. The accompanying code is made available for
transparency and further development. | [
0.0411198959,
0.1058921069,
-0.0255333744,
-0.0114794942,
0.0088428222,
0.0427849069,
-0.0014319374,
0.0241672806,
0.0241449084,
-0.021064464,
0.0251234602,
-0.0248021018,
-0.0308643524,
0.0046496987,
-0.0282963347,
-0.0713914111,
-0.007813273,
0.0641162917,
0.0145924687,
-0.0120931901,
0.0278749783,
0.0184553657,
-0.0207559969,
0.028162742,
-0.0352432355,
-0.0275020674,
0.0409979597,
0.0253716316,
0.028291963,
-0.0311690811,
0.0628639758,
0.0388265923,
-0.0116803339,
0.0452951454,
0.0000024049,
-0.0136316642,
-0.0149450768,
-0.0292715766,
-0.0255970079,
-0.0276996922,
0.0314093046,
-0.0400264636,
0.0492031202,
0.0104324576,
-0.043513976,
-0.0551112816,
0.0374151804,
0.0722499266,
0.0592618138,
0.0730136484,
-0.0195094142,
-0.0213210545,
0.0144808227,
-0.024561286,
-0.017283801,
-0.0128765563,
0.0342452973,
0.0073699704,
0.0015808842,
-0.0348560438,
-0.0033315071,
0.0143847726,
-0.0141873304,
0.038629014,
-0.0176135637,
-0.014743492,
-0.0011292541,
-0.0343122892,
0.0012757388,
0.0877267569,
0.0175330639,
0.0026143682,
0.0240254924,
-0.0244722553,
-0.0037670117,
-0.0347939059,
-0.0147579433,
-0.0204540305,
0.0142282303,
0.0388710424,
0.005740054,
0.0576979779,
0.0379742756,
-0.0028657836,
0.0335611328,
0.000358981,
-0.0204669945,
-0.0141732926,
0.0043495321,
0.014754951,
-0.0129876127,
-0.045569215,
0.0447753072,
0.0026621439,
0.0049722074,
-0.006361065,
-0.0321397893,
-0.0671270341,
0.0167155042,
0.0339906961,
-0.0188424196,
0.017033333,
-0.0589875653,
-0.0051296656,
0.0390494689,
-0.0045428271,
0.0124355545,
-0.0301663745,
-0.0028097772,
-0.0061806221,
-0.0582822524,
0.0336566083,
-0.0287313741,
0.029582331,
0.0174248181,
-0.0355503,
-0.066288501,
-0.0327493958,
-0.028913606,
-0.0547812656,
0.002574201,
0.0313986056,
0.0015140685,
0.0011991975,
0.0408967063,
0.0729012862,
-0.029590128,
-0.0063038166,
0.0007059249,
-0.0278328862,
0.0438165404,
-0.0070932894,
0.0055515901,
-0.0354068428,
0.0231607221,
0.0210263617,
0.058676336,
-0.0299505088,
-0.0392781645,
-0.0130373714,
-0.0179909486,
-0.0520699434,
0.000397274,
-0.0310291834,
0.011530064,
-0.0013594986,
0.007844667,
-0.0733421445,
0.0134344129,
-0.0285913385,
0.0037833203,
0.0600007735,
-0.0640315041,
-0.0214058589,
0.0467363335,
0.0210301504,
0.0163618103,
0.0873523951,
0.0192785785,
0.0680279434,
0.0402949154,
-0.0118482774,
0.0111362645,
-0.0016972667,
0.0242876448,
-0.0308640264,
0.0029740036,
-0.0369385742,
-0.0766532496,
0.0305271111,
0.012257644,
0.0162991229,
0.0024247945,
-0.0131890113,
0.037050087,
0.065473251,
0.0166108813,
0.0995550528,
0.0025796061,
0.0299141277,
0.0022484611,
-0.017168669,
-0.0065770517,
0.0024590853,
-0.0081934556,
-0.0291743875,
0.0250391997,
0.0151898051,
-0.0176944099,
-0.0554027967,
-0.0270842351,
-0.0394167118,
0.0216148235,
-0.0221160799,
0.0177534055,
-0.037923228,
-0.0244601984,
0.0455928966,
0.0330993384,
-0.0240183827,
-0.0359727144,
-0.0396246612,
0.0062992768,
0.0288535133,
-0.0222993996,
-0.0704139099,
-0.0071519534,
-0.0133328121,
0.07116092,
0.0263016783,
-0.0017445151,
0.0347006209,
0.0264075175,
-0.0460641682,
0.0128434179,
-0.020777829,
0.0372927859,
-0.0061277458,
-0.0272685327,
0.0333434269,
-0.0142500009,
0.0068369168,
-0.0195216034,
0.0253366735,
0.0280076228,
-0.0174758136,
0.0190720726,
0.023757102,
0.0121726282,
0.0067754607,
-0.0129773831,
-0.0082327779,
0.0162397996,
-0.0213598348,
-0.0626372248,
-0.0415753648,
0.0178957433,
-0.034628991,
0.0044615529,
-0.0514012687,
-0.0060769762,
0.1153004244,
-0.0376979262,
-0.0094554378,
0.0761403367,
-0.0593153015,
0.0071257311,
0.020480264,
-0.0393806249,
-0.0365879685,
0.0511062816,
0.0007413531,
0.0202164985,
-0.0328378528,
-0.0064783394,
-0.0011831664,
-0.1011554748,
-0.0156655256,
-0.0161099918,
-0.0318710431,
-0.0338502675,
-0.0206310954,
0.0177470297,
-0.0007894929,
-0.0038978562,
-0.0254789405,
0.0071048178,
-0.1124826297,
0.0149624497,
-0.0495888479,
0.0096260682,
0.0017214494,
-0.0072895065,
-0.0104757138,
-0.0216507912,
-0.0148284724,
0.0393261015,
0.0268022362,
0.0050730328,
0.0579917841,
-0.026363099,
0.0265402086,
-0.0775167942,
-0.054783538,
-0.0275523849,
0.0314619839,
-0.0069914185,
-0.0516463034,
0.0058142412,
-0.0089980327,
-0.0576892048,
-0.0063914205,
0.0108708171,
-0.0661036521,
-0.0127661536,
0.001269503,
0.0143647911,
0.0694571361,
0.0160511639,
0.0872823447,
-0.0296872649,
0.0544742011,
0.0188394058,
0.0259556975,
-0.0233397186,
0.0248667561,
-0.0281793699,
-0.0430709459,
-0.0158540923,
0.048269555,
-0.0042721876,
-0.0042828443,
-0.0233561415,
-0.0061327643,
-0.0201459546,
0.0063561019,
0.0177633949,
0.0202329308,
0.0151122985,
0.014288296,
-0.0113346064,
-0.0607018247,
0.0504628122,
0.0412639491,
-0.0099619282,
-0.0253598765,
-0.0549478084,
-0.0442494825,
0.0281268414,
0.0095167132,
-0.0020503593,
0.021567205,
-0.0085218782,
0.0106758028,
-0.0289546158,
-0.0438337699,
-0.033399079,
0.0362590738,
0.0005539733,
0.0010429072,
0.026955761,
-0.034376055,
-0.0294324514,
-0.0443732552,
-0.0777300745,
-0.0038972145,
0.014327229,
-0.0040687174,
-0.0670073405,
-0.0536033884,
0.0109855421,
0.0254603382,
-0.0140144425,
-0.0201293789,
0.0220868364,
0.0431083292,
0.0617901161,
-0.0360168554,
0.0630621463,
-0.0390376225,
0.0146056507,
0.0314332396,
-0.0355092995,
0.0626565591,
-0.031812977,
-0.0080257114,
0.003665834,
0.0138525926,
-0.0095879296,
-0.0095276507,
0.0296980478,
-0.0322621427,
-0.0007430639,
0.0889692008,
-0.0170186348,
-0.0451681539,
0.0262571592,
-0.0003681959,
-0.0253313575,
0.0100442385,
-0.0156226959,
-0.0562455915,
-0.0749573708,
-0.0427090898,
0.0309232343,
0.0036302286,
-0.0133376289,
0.0096942522,
-0.024443673,
0.0230899584,
-0.0334061049,
0.005042559,
0.0495468602,
-0.0262869094,
0.0117796008,
-0.0362894796,
-0.0084449043,
-0.0650730953,
-0.0127414055,
-0.0052638976,
0.0157343969,
-0.088819854,
-0.0461060815,
0.0133759286,
-0.0115778511,
0.052183371,
0.007999707,
0.0739480481,
0.0057566068,
-0.0158866346,
-0.0132540492,
0.0075210738,
-0.0273995996,
0.0005579724,
0.1075332314,
-0.0031697452,
-0.0234577954,
-0.049596183,
0.0580934808,
-0.0760546252,
0.0278332811,
-0.0239089523,
0.051720731,
0.0231107604,
-0.0579776838,
-0.0518447645,
0.0354279578,
0.0276502836,
0.0212831087,
0.0725646839,
-0.0507497601,
-0.0337633751,
0.0094565786,
0.005703649,
-0.0495926701,
-0.0078165503,
-0.0165302232,
-0.0015600073,
-0.0136051606,
-0.0435910597,
-0.0406528749,
0.0257909503,
-0.0461798385,
-0.0523139499,
-0.0428873152,
-0.0021010209,
0.007186315,
-0.0930420458,
0.0427742377,
0.0255870875,
0.021795392,
-0.015233011,
-0.0317563936,
0.0175275896,
-0.0107832626,
-0.0141047919,
-0.0031491145,
-0.1109948233,
-0.0394602008,
0.0268603396,
0.0353951864,
0.0110158147,
-0.0474532172,
0.0261681695,
-0.0621347278,
0.0629033372,
0.0329975002,
0.018124653,
-0.0210029501,
0.0412555598,
-0.0027196577,
-0.0004190012,
0.0581475161,
0.008056053,
0.0620916747,
0.0039399471,
-0.0271677449,
-0.0117706163,
0.0091415839,
-0.035953626,
0.0018734601,
0.0112595316,
0.0087734526,
-0.0887722746,
-0.0010848512,
-0.0467356518,
0.0221724994,
0.0142898653,
-0.0384483486,
-0.0223649144,
0.026381148,
0.0256601069,
-0.0349046066,
-0.0242370367,
0.0118840728,
-0.0131795183,
-0.0563295521,
0.0276111793,
0.0221148469,
0.0338473283,
0.0030808544,
0.0120937461,
-0.029618429,
0.0290650278,
-0.0128692314,
0.0009158269,
-0.0142331319,
0.0269521736,
0.0077465987,
0.012918409,
0.0200099368,
0.0439063311,
-0.0243058335,
-0.040518485,
-0.0304961205,
-0.0161801651,
0.0779485628,
-0.0115239099,
0.0910362378,
0.0087470831,
0.0024987715,
-0.0065208739,
0.0256113093,
-0.053966254,
0.0103668198,
-0.0166448466,
-0.0128741805,
-0.0253441185,
-0.0033573855,
0.0520068854,
-0.0157198645,
0.0175933186,
0.0438851826,
0.0030595821,
-0.0057262736,
0.0167230032,
0.0227844287,
0.0572450198,
-0.0140816066,
0.0226198975,
0.0120628132,
-0.0560699813,
0.0612224415,
-0.0373058766,
-0.0167529508,
-0.0245434698,
0.023747284,
0.0120772775,
0.0361658745,
0.0130408555,
-0.0388524942,
0.000198197,
-0.0529695041,
-0.0265539419,
-0.0544726588,
-6.683363498e-33,
0.0486431234,
-0.0046389117,
-0.0373056754,
0.0119338864,
-0.0396518074,
0.0763146356,
-0.0257300138,
0.0023215436,
0.0030228579,
0.0530976839,
0.0345267653,
0.0680306032,
-0.0169700589,
0.0635316148,
-0.0013480735,
-0.0228749197,
0.0307481121,
-0.0043265815,
0.0019411972,
0.0371813998,
-0.0053211241,
0.0845104232,
0.0549017675,
-0.0354957581,
-0.018434573,
0.0033649371,
-0.0069144247,
-0.0037571499,
0.0574629232,
0.0392231382,
-0.0462163612,
0.0759991482,
0.0542529188,
0.0114995446,
0.0077754282,
0.0242174957,
-0.0463193767,
-0.0390743986,
-0.0232342761,
0.0113890227,
-0.0569168665,
0.0104845017,
0.0337474197,
0.0094740707,
0.0237431787,
-0.0445928313,
0.0602114834,
0.0097415894,
0.049859684,
-0.0503645502,
-0.0229463149,
0.0055531566,
-0.0208843406,
-0.0201192349,
0.0017757298,
0.0524015464,
-0.0002559231,
0.0467481315,
-0.0708044916,
-0.0054245791,
-0.0289729368,
0.0064832652,
0.0155109223,
-0.060146898,
-0.022547435,
0.0563315414,
0.0369206481,
0.012055398,
-0.045541808,
-0.0033771861,
0.0000994816,
0.0358175859,
0.0774884671,
0.0391750857,
0.0866559222,
-0.0344549678,
-0.0823652446,
-0.0049685468,
0.0437690839,
0.0084098615,
0.002558853,
0.0018207339,
-0.0159325507,
0.0173506308,
-0.0006987417,
-0.0035733997,
-0.0149298459,
-0.0371344499,
-0.0190188847,
-0.010023376,
-0.0340604074,
0.0246402491,
-0.024266379,
-0.0507518053,
-0.0257603768,
0.0247887485,
0.0140676089,
0.0380544178,
0.0273937527,
0.0035999748,
-0.0009422078,
0.0004308588,
-0.0019652729,
0.0283512864,
0.0622127168,
-0.0010337054,
0.0534995534,
-0.0102962852,
-0.0205365121,
-0.0087917205,
0.0104802558,
0.0303551648,
-0.0100442264,
0.0995767489,
-0.0275004301,
0.0293887611,
0.0030140453,
0.0401778184,
0.0327768624,
0.0668398589,
-0.0416707098,
-0.0551335663,
0.0096557429,
0.0230353437,
-0.0223919433,
-0.0645731911,
-0.0311691035,
-0.0157960877,
0.0045323046,
-0.0840439945,
-0.0029684876,
-0.020417098,
3.031e-7,
0.040982414,
0.0743163377,
-0.0013485047,
-0.0221597571,
0.0159935951,
0.0022475757,
0.0149596641,
0.0370545611,
0.0135048358,
-0.0225693062,
0.0123416567,
0.043647144,
0.0616882779,
0.0414204933,
-0.0334174819,
-0.0445725583,
-0.0232407823,
-0.0169277769,
-0.0552609228,
-0.0014644115,
0.0537076034,
0.0875061378,
0.0380650163,
-0.0412399359,
0.0086246999,
0.0197709724,
0.0474759117,
-0.0123202391,
0.0457707681,
0.0205666143,
0.0631266087,
0.0036176674,
-0.0039723073,
-0.0436129794,
-0.0036447162,
0.0061780214,
-0.0003886725,
0.0289550554,
-0.0210965853,
-0.0229818616,
0.0303299427,
0.0353703164,
-0.0101530561,
0.0035587526,
0.0292212665,
-0.082004182,
-0.0425757132,
-0.0772346705,
-0.0187282618,
-0.0484923348,
0.1019779742,
-0.0223811436,
-0.004070574,
0.0369899757,
0.0090975631,
-0.010272406,
-0.0065341336,
-0.0958263427,
-0.0174858943,
0.0399660207,
-0.0437167436,
0.0341328681,
-0.0348760039,
-0.0393086597,
0.0086054429,
-0.0481431969,
0.0560355149,
2.397648251e-34,
0.0358328298,
-0.0083923414,
-0.0054248488,
-0.0099843722,
0.0040578442,
0.0017901828,
-0.0306138769,
-0.0320151821,
-0.0216734968,
-0.0603214167,
-0.0120092724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05043v1 | Zero-shot Translation of Attention Patterns in VQA Models to Natural Language | 2023-11-08T22:18:53 | 2023-11-08T22:18:53 | Leonard Salewski, A. Sophia Koepke, Hendrik P. A. Lensch, Zeynep Akata | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Converting a model's internals to text can yield human-understandable
insights about the model. Inspired by the recent success of training-free
approaches for image captioning, we propose ZS-A2T, a zero-shot framework that
translates the transformer attention of a given model into natural language
without requiring any training. We consider this in the context of Visual
Question Answering (VQA). ZS-A2T builds on a pre-trained large language model
(LLM), which receives a task prompt, question, and predicted answer, as inputs.
The LLM is guided to select tokens which describe the regions in the input
image that the VQA model attended to. Crucially, we determine this similarity
by exploiting the text-image matching capabilities of the underlying VQA model.
Our framework does not require any training and allows the drop-in replacement
of different guiding sources (e.g. attribution instead of attention maps), or
language models. We evaluate this novel task on textual explanation datasets
for VQA, giving state-of-the-art performances for the zero-shot setting on
GQA-REX and VQA-X. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/ExplainableML/ZS-A2T. | [
0.0138250217,
0.0477039032,
-0.0061666523,
0.0621083081,
0.0098790517,
0.0113933226,
0.0304692406,
0.0000881971,
-0.0116765061,
-0.0718089715,
-0.0362594984,
-0.0006776453,
-0.0264152847,
0.0434527658,
0.0569830537,
-0.0514110029,
0.0437099859,
-0.0355719551,
-0.0157707185,
0.0511314869,
0.0314233415,
0.0078518772,
0.0140116895,
0.0492277853,
0.0016146705,
-0.0264744181,
-0.0240766034,
0.0087197563,
0.0353292264,
0.002573075,
-0.0267386921,
0.0418792777,
0.0382353514,
0.0117125344,
0.000001954,
0.0041470062,
0.0094368001,
-0.0003038278,
-0.0095528299,
0.0044580875,
-0.0060699573,
-0.0128085474,
0.0246010814,
0.0102081476,
-0.0283929482,
-0.016276069,
0.082491532,
0.0429371111,
0.1027740315,
0.0585841797,
-0.0202843715,
-0.0261978731,
-0.0101152938,
-0.0204871856,
0.0399803035,
-0.0531125404,
-0.0013753593,
0.0159601271,
0.0088469135,
0.006960263,
-0.0437761284,
0.0451287068,
0.0312516987,
-0.0191875584,
0.0277585983,
0.0561838299,
-0.0300126188,
-0.0270074531,
-0.0123258168,
0.1129661426,
-0.013095459,
-0.0174895823,
-0.0175292101,
0.0018641999,
-0.0069566346,
0.0124372514,
-0.0620218292,
0.0355042368,
0.0196062867,
0.0195153169,
-0.0277445782,
0.0135246394,
-0.0132833235,
-0.0049746288,
-0.0275732987,
-0.0117815193,
0.0102930171,
0.0202089828,
-0.0332531817,
0.0137134427,
-0.0775495544,
-0.0888335258,
-0.0349041931,
0.0702648535,
0.0294310004,
0.001786985,
-0.0303337574,
-0.0193929039,
-0.0178685039,
-0.0079143457,
0.0627272204,
0.0344499648,
-0.0541011058,
0.0704150796,
-0.0349069387,
0.0871950164,
-0.0117128091,
0.0280937478,
-0.0553117134,
-0.0293988157,
-0.0347549133,
-0.0122973556,
-0.0533913821,
0.0017750602,
-0.0484806634,
-0.0600029603,
0.0109236464,
0.0009302928,
-0.0096618831,
-0.013322792,
0.0028979927,
0.0418823585,
-0.0194936562,
0.000336379,
-0.0259176698,
0.0713021904,
-0.0350256003,
0.0047805966,
-0.0219509602,
-0.0525000393,
-0.039291095,
0.0450758487,
0.0320811346,
-0.0227653123,
-0.0173910186,
0.0628931299,
-0.0410662629,
-0.0356242843,
-0.0014230431,
-0.0200062264,
-0.021891268,
-0.0330493189,
0.0261392314,
-0.0294866506,
0.0125991534,
-0.0059582619,
-0.0032599503,
0.0011367929,
0.0175882727,
0.0428197719,
-0.0421824306,
0.0955201089,
0.0092937732,
-0.0131648015,
-0.010063705,
0.0131688248,
0.021996446,
0.061380025,
-0.0019799378,
0.0286347531,
0.0170455407,
-0.0120900478,
0.0517506227,
0.0306776296,
0.0119136516,
0.0017610082,
-0.0442253016,
0.0320973657,
0.0115218991,
0.0080811502,
0.0678576529,
0.0179160256,
-0.0335882418,
-0.0309168398,
0.0610262156,
0.063132897,
-0.0214965232,
0.0084124971,
0.0231430307,
0.0136519475,
0.0001921164,
-0.014945047,
-0.0756368488,
0.0905177966,
0.0085903043,
0.0066911611,
0.0093023516,
-0.0129266055,
-0.0579304472,
-0.0217211433,
-0.0059419987,
-0.0035685459,
-0.01052476,
0.0421799496,
0.0322769359,
0.0433023013,
-0.0476288386,
0.0225990191,
-0.0029737148,
-0.0220860597,
-0.012331998,
-0.0345362537,
0.0669177398,
0.0543943681,
0.019746894,
-0.0020695562,
-0.0168873277,
-0.0032459381,
0.0379546881,
0.051227726,
-0.034232527,
0.0168757737,
0.0190685764,
-0.0422790498,
-0.028412383,
-0.0526143909,
0.0008408097,
-0.0241980907,
0.0051732133,
0.0094773769,
0.0093061961,
-0.0140098734,
-0.0102333827,
0.0398752727,
0.0383764245,
-0.0296488628,
-0.0088868719,
0.0194814168,
-0.0038051119,
-0.0092883892,
-0.0178993177,
0.0136362668,
0.006991982,
-0.0419122986,
0.0070346529,
0.0129289664,
-0.0175851099,
-0.0382224023,
0.0083064437,
-0.0693124831,
-0.0015447375,
0.026846936,
-0.0481032468,
-0.0321064591,
0.0196325984,
-0.0385032184,
-0.0128440298,
-0.0433866158,
-0.0178074706,
0.0399546921,
0.0419519357,
-0.0239107236,
0.0414714068,
-0.0040203682,
-0.0166838523,
0.0007002763,
-0.0176343154,
0.0015071667,
-0.0259149261,
0.0139502427,
-0.0216225404,
0.0007263292,
-0.0081000002,
-0.0159335695,
0.0227254741,
-0.0404354148,
0.0036498448,
-0.0626775697,
-0.0110344021,
-0.0280863773,
-0.0144154644,
0.0440169051,
0.0080295857,
0.0166463852,
-0.0426504575,
-0.0396674573,
0.025984833,
0.0122515252,
-0.0068448046,
0.0571596175,
-0.0031394616,
0.0160267968,
-0.0520617627,
-0.0130386995,
0.0160311852,
0.0799300373,
0.0180348977,
0.0009979225,
-0.0330363512,
0.0063240626,
-0.0352974385,
0.0354460999,
-0.0003664961,
-0.0491821095,
-0.0020349436,
0.0002883451,
0.0093810307,
0.0935332477,
-0.0068743066,
-0.0019229301,
0.0098730847,
0.0042257626,
-0.0271856505,
0.0097893523,
0.009777491,
-0.0554807149,
0.0156566743,
-0.0571457036,
-0.0018440651,
0.0691367313,
-0.0365370885,
0.0079831844,
-0.0785522908,
0.0437661931,
0.0319419056,
-0.0141308485,
-0.0455361493,
0.04384505,
0.0250086691,
0.0336591676,
-0.0657893568,
-0.065093033,
0.0440889038,
-0.0335610844,
-0.0402404182,
0.0150158182,
0.0224748049,
-0.0461373441,
0.0545409098,
0.0257232338,
0.0151418969,
0.023336865,
-0.0039337012,
-0.0279438905,
-0.0426833294,
-0.0122369407,
0.0130181601,
0.0736778677,
-0.0159980971,
0.0223791208,
-0.0283264574,
0.0041316869,
-0.028638145,
-0.014610637,
-0.0642625615,
0.0241292417,
-0.0556923524,
-0.0278260428,
-0.0283700712,
0.0352734774,
0.0421574861,
0.0317843668,
-0.01776262,
0.0048668892,
-0.0233731326,
0.0583246537,
0.0972082764,
0.0473766252,
-0.0071150879,
-0.0380917005,
0.0113565717,
0.0678927079,
0.0168563277,
0.0248582065,
-0.0267174672,
-0.0083477153,
0.0192065779,
0.004783263,
0.011099237,
0.0223300289,
0.0652581155,
-0.0471737832,
-0.0274915658,
0.1037323326,
0.0112228487,
-0.0371635854,
-0.0179629382,
-0.0136315078,
0.0180731695,
0.0598902442,
0.0331974514,
-0.1235737503,
-0.0827673301,
-0.0327860452,
0.0087631578,
0.0472683869,
0.0118347453,
-0.0135896048,
-0.0789742917,
0.0593199022,
-0.0123041579,
-0.0360509418,
-0.0110445507,
0.00162208,
0.0073309559,
-0.0191236567,
-0.0289575923,
-0.0288812015,
-0.007187977,
0.0216775984,
-0.0103610856,
0.0304948874,
0.0046068975,
0.0439220071,
-0.0556088872,
0.0144768935,
0.0648988783,
0.0177625697,
-0.0122828679,
-0.0521103628,
-0.0278700627,
-0.0390784182,
0.0114452234,
0.0127967633,
0.070619598,
-0.0387431383,
-0.0416884571,
-0.0047007268,
0.032900393,
-0.0186406411,
-0.0205629095,
-0.0035202848,
0.058759626,
0.0048100385,
-0.0311457198,
-0.0358392186,
0.0094743045,
-0.0092500364,
0.0680987388,
0.0540066995,
-0.00764261,
-0.067687951,
-0.000587362,
-0.014110622,
-0.0633893088,
-0.0640691519,
0.0009173179,
0.0332368538,
-0.0317792371,
-0.0607039928,
-0.013434628,
0.0735388324,
0.0273365472,
-0.0362792164,
-0.0476955511,
-0.0093940636,
0.0252692383,
-0.0492020734,
0.0875915661,
-0.0498558916,
0.0436980389,
-0.0474597365,
-0.0039447015,
0.0085440977,
-0.0346906632,
-0.0147399837,
0.0044228984,
-0.049853757,
-0.0128489267,
-0.0315947942,
0.0820710137,
0.0092479298,
0.0334511846,
-0.0163407251,
-0.0333027616,
0.0206202529,
-0.0065282648,
-0.0021476853,
0.0190867409,
0.0021090186,
-0.0211805385,
0.0035422535,
0.0431876928,
-0.016331017,
0.0155961448,
0.0142050264,
0.0125012416,
-0.0291063804,
-0.0216498896,
0.0160584003,
-0.0140851848,
0.0304128174,
0.0153941857,
0.026912313,
-0.0032732633,
-0.0009899301,
0.0086989775,
0.0077194269,
-0.0956389457,
0.0073510539,
-0.0030439158,
-0.0216844883,
0.0188913886,
-0.0251972079,
-0.0646362603,
0.0063162502,
-0.029403666,
0.0149118342,
0.0388645865,
0.0045583285,
-0.0181293767,
-0.0070364191,
0.0001077088,
-0.0272404496,
-0.0207209922,
0.0543574803,
-0.0144291893,
0.0645625219,
0.0335077755,
-0.0174614415,
-0.0229362547,
0.026576573,
-0.0287696607,
-0.0421697013,
-0.013674261,
0.0115150316,
0.0569104627,
-0.015261217,
0.0039411415,
0.0442342684,
-0.0312077887,
0.0022340305,
0.0228869785,
-0.0070569757,
-0.0362821929,
0.0558180809,
0.0373567306,
0.0056090886,
-0.0226962157,
0.0608576536,
0.0307285246,
0.0110739125,
0.0050398284,
-0.0158694349,
-0.0234569274,
-0.0064666471,
0.0200512428,
-0.0178376287,
0.0050815917,
0.0525533669,
-0.0247606877,
-0.0831284747,
-0.0028176252,
0.0011665348,
-0.0467522182,
0.0021241484,
0.0447910912,
0.0031995247,
0.0367390215,
-0.028557688,
-0.0221270081,
0.0259037875,
-0.02348754,
-0.0005954364,
-0.0130241476,
-6.2782279e-33,
-0.0302176196,
-0.0408242233,
0.015231126,
-0.0292135086,
-0.0279124677,
0.0313342176,
-0.0520303026,
-0.0257099532,
-0.0332213789,
0.0088119628,
0.0252336208,
-0.0019680269,
-0.0011962511,
0.0382396914,
-0.0199677851,
-0.0370430462,
0.0226112325,
-0.020001363,
-0.0296407528,
0.0194938108,
0.0061998842,
-0.0144973975,
0.062355876,
0.0038235378,
-0.0198362768,
-0.009365079,
-0.007771689,
0.029314382,
0.0266920291,
0.070366241,
-0.0092139561,
-0.0011247033,
0.0139461085,
-0.0441252217,
-0.008216111,
0.0392228514,
-0.0709363446,
-0.0036298763,
0.0310210995,
0.0107666664,
-0.0810865536,
-0.0203142911,
0.0206102356,
-0.0203574225,
0.050543718,
-0.0670324787,
0.043827571,
-0.0009704435,
0.0049494081,
0.0167377964,
-0.0398779549,
-0.0081670871,
-0.0362797044,
-0.05136979,
0.022934841,
0.0769949555,
0.0057056961,
0.0370503329,
-0.0349866562,
-0.0093064876,
0.0207079146,
0.0368893556,
0.0896460488,
0.0555020161,
0.0088338815,
0.0223627388,
0.0244512409,
-0.0474500172,
-0.0858310238,
-0.0067974152,
-0.0005478971,
0.0521961562,
0.0661263615,
-0.0002320725,
0.0306511745,
0.0440645926,
-0.0515348837,
-0.0013705774,
-0.0824488029,
0.0851099938,
0.0020449783,
-0.0178088583,
0.0153741864,
0.0094303731,
-0.0349900052,
-0.0097935898,
-0.0656507611,
0.0098253842,
0.0577737726,
0.0283906851,
-0.0164353829,
0.0616317168,
0.0635938272,
-0.0287057329,
0.0449858196,
0.0288366526,
-0.0120726721,
0.0394250266,
0.0105503611,
0.0321093127,
-0.0581848249,
0.0154539905,
0.0520431101,
0.0020636853,
0.0104661966,
0.0190340243,
0.0474606678,
0.0092284782,
-0.0407744534,
-0.0287194233,
-0.0526252091,
-0.0013394156,
-0.0585317165,
0.0340353809,
0.007588461,
0.0315292664,
-0.0596260726,
0.0113506783,
-0.0265295375,
-0.0047925715,
-0.0093655484,
-0.0083513269,
0.0043022805,
0.0198119842,
-0.0301092621,
0.013914749,
-0.0548054725,
0.0012867093,
-0.0111915991,
-0.0586643852,
-0.0293793455,
0.0626249239,
2.542e-7,
0.0410355218,
0.0078527117,
0.0104449233,
0.0337874442,
0.0143997977,
0.0491324998,
-0.0058810553,
0.0364627205,
0.0219950397,
-0.0179204047,
-0.0089110192,
0.07841824,
0.034658704,
-0.02044506,
-0.034029752,
0.0376026593,
-0.0461032428,
-0.0079522301,
-0.0539837629,
-0.0227486845,
0.0515154786,
0.0972990021,
-0.0220232159,
-0.0011877952,
0.0386879966,
-0.0385051593,
0.065531984,
0.0003844214,
0.02166453,
-0.0256159678,
0.0072030332,
-0.0126709044,
-0.0194933712,
0.0031632888,
0.0026780372,
-0.011709285,
0.0318772383,
0.0533113368,
-0.0461879633,
-0.0508173779,
-0.0594128929,
-0.0015365642,
0.0108005498,
-0.0641867816,
0.0981164053,
-0.0802865624,
-0.0321782902,
-0.0199355185,
-0.0570917688,
0.0125781987,
0.012762811,
0.0102017419,
-0.0206787493,
0.0235399641,
0.0460960977,
-0.0321379043,
-0.0228392538,
-0.067551434,
-0.0289136134,
-0.0307973698,
-0.0263650455,
0.0191880651,
-0.0802811161,
-0.0313316956,
0.0245512165,
-0.0151659911,
-0.0410649292,
1.998587434e-34,
0.0074377595,
-0.0013573298,
0.0151489442,
0.0392615385,
0.0263267718,
-0.0265642032,
-0.0365191549,
-0.026453102,
0.0375154242,
-0.0910986587,
-0.0173993837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07588v1 | NLQxform: A Language Model-based Question to SPARQL Transformer | 2023-11-08T21:41:45 | 2023-11-08T21:41:45 | Ruijie Wang, Zhiruo Zhang, Luca Rossetto, Florian Ruosch, Abraham Bernstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, scholarly data has grown dramatically in terms of both scale
and complexity. It becomes increasingly challenging to retrieve information
from scholarly knowledge graphs that include large-scale heterogeneous
relationships, such as authorship, affiliation, and citation, between various
types of entities, e.g., scholars, papers, and organizations. As part of the
Scholarly QALD Challenge, this paper presents a question-answering (QA) system
called NLQxform, which provides an easy-to-use natural language interface to
facilitate accessing scholarly knowledge graphs. NLQxform allows users to
express their complex query intentions in natural language questions. A
transformer-based language model, i.e., BART, is employed to translate
questions into standard SPARQL queries, which can be evaluated to retrieve the
required information. According to the public leaderboard of the Scholarly QALD
Challenge at ISWC 2023 (Task 1: DBLP-QUAD - Knowledge Graph Question Answering
over DBLP), NLQxform achieved an F1 score of 0.85 and ranked first on the QA
task, demonstrating the competitiveness of the system. | [
0.0586633906,
0.0684616044,
0.0168745816,
0.0517029613,
-0.0382804871,
-0.0173555724,
0.0153595861,
0.0122215739,
0.0114717083,
-0.0322062485,
-0.0312486142,
0.0530051365,
-0.0192887355,
0.0335146263,
0.003986076,
-0.0201002751,
0.0215010028,
-0.0034158975,
0.0321858414,
-0.0053160358,
0.0031207323,
0.0432480536,
-0.0020616737,
-0.0120054912,
0.0172704607,
-0.0281782094,
-0.0216801409,
-0.0032980223,
-0.0220189579,
-0.0037000736,
0.0076496014,
0.0599645264,
0.0060048159,
0.0103494702,
0.0000020233,
-0.0669717789,
-0.0351405367,
0.0478500947,
-0.0070980471,
-0.0370647423,
0.0402950346,
0.0265856609,
0.0392118506,
0.0145525886,
-0.0484937802,
-0.0263114665,
0.0122344326,
0.0431078561,
0.0289346892,
0.0393191352,
0.0009638948,
-0.0584118813,
0.0493330397,
0.014633406,
0.0151980706,
-0.0531104989,
0.0047302996,
0.0143985972,
0.0521025993,
0.0551401898,
0.0162156802,
0.0153277796,
-0.026463693,
-0.0432491191,
0.0441165119,
-0.0146248108,
-0.0042520384,
0.0160196349,
0.0459483452,
0.0162646137,
0.0884140879,
0.0009520468,
0.0333437771,
0.0509604923,
0.0254680999,
0.1089421362,
-0.0583245605,
-0.0115706129,
-0.0341297463,
-0.0758996606,
-0.0092230206,
-0.0017724342,
0.0037869604,
0.0117953951,
-0.0435796194,
0.0671254173,
0.0287238192,
-0.0227716435,
0.0103050107,
-0.0280789249,
0.0381614603,
-0.0387897827,
0.0281058345,
0.0618385226,
-0.0423674248,
0.0102421576,
0.0132461889,
-0.0060643819,
0.0363033824,
0.0051742438,
-0.0117460573,
-0.0050438982,
0.023484746,
0.0424527079,
0.0127736395,
0.0308062695,
-0.0029723272,
-0.006909485,
-0.0152096162,
-0.0409948304,
-0.0549545772,
-0.0160574429,
-0.0569460168,
0.0242254827,
-0.0396313556,
-0.0079419352,
0.0172416121,
-0.0119878612,
0.0224613585,
0.0068087354,
0.0444928557,
0.0445623957,
-0.0046232389,
0.0122361593,
-0.0775717795,
0.0774324313,
-0.024154108,
-0.0270676631,
-0.0184935108,
0.0046976856,
0.0198983252,
0.0009354829,
0.0465462245,
-0.0656529739,
0.0241120253,
0.0356253013,
0.0132395653,
-0.0254026409,
-0.0183269382,
-0.0286200028,
0.0248569325,
-0.0436741114,
0.0221907757,
-0.0711841434,
0.0697439536,
0.0421817563,
-0.0211125463,
-0.0502182208,
0.0157093536,
0.0422109552,
-0.0537309237,
0.0439316779,
-0.0596551597,
-0.0108993743,
0.0770501643,
-0.0209767055,
0.0157645009,
0.0129946461,
0.007246281,
-0.0389507487,
0.0586656518,
-0.0018820419,
-0.0081818057,
-0.0059805373,
0.0173894111,
-0.0197317153,
0.0270550195,
0.0731243417,
-0.0319515951,
0.0415121987,
0.0103751617,
0.0681624487,
0.0097475527,
-0.0297853928,
0.0105797108,
0.0753722787,
0.0094607947,
0.0136455484,
-0.0104065714,
0.0278393347,
0.0425183699,
-0.0389259644,
-0.0549567826,
0.0582735538,
0.0185691807,
0.0255592111,
-0.0171110723,
0.0426019616,
0.0031288152,
-0.0402946398,
-0.0053948509,
0.0387043878,
0.0143903233,
0.0313284695,
0.0467955358,
0.021875022,
-0.0315142274,
0.0660844967,
-0.0013668853,
-0.0290645473,
0.0141236447,
-0.0144381765,
0.0261157695,
0.0453936197,
0.057728,
-0.0292190872,
-0.0433513969,
-0.0142861875,
-0.0265806802,
0.0653103739,
-0.0187640022,
-0.0088795293,
-0.0148119796,
0.0064564007,
-0.0215156674,
0.0005740547,
-0.0034594804,
-0.0300034173,
0.0235975012,
0.0254721623,
-0.0107341027,
-0.0918216184,
-0.013911563,
0.0332038216,
-0.0102444049,
0.0001489972,
-0.0070673963,
0.0036558146,
-0.010909413,
0.043354895,
0.007252743,
0.0405551568,
0.0546248853,
-0.0234983116,
-0.0313778222,
-0.0252567753,
0.0583890863,
-0.0089945318,
0.0402889363,
-0.0480643287,
-0.0001933446,
0.0264910609,
-0.0078444295,
-0.0532817766,
0.0126187699,
-0.0396652818,
0.0082876058,
0.0162136108,
-0.0396365374,
0.0095636407,
-0.0459498912,
-0.0598969497,
0.0370261446,
0.023686694,
0.0416998118,
-0.0011317984,
-0.0522426479,
0.0216857921,
-0.0058943522,
-0.005763649,
0.0042651379,
-0.0158227514,
-0.0124525419,
0.0298287664,
-0.0219146218,
-0.0530566052,
-0.0003206465,
-0.031773176,
0.0234573632,
-0.0265024584,
0.0348282792,
0.0123504838,
0.0288021639,
-0.0036147097,
0.0012557062,
-0.0366068669,
-0.0105208866,
0.0054531642,
-0.0189967304,
0.0645921379,
0.0052007865,
0.0195589699,
-0.0440893732,
-0.0360590145,
-0.0130341072,
0.0399428122,
0.0577757619,
0.0080002667,
0.0106488932,
0.0081231631,
-0.0573428012,
-0.0077872034,
-0.0018870564,
0.0228393227,
0.0055906475,
-0.0307922699,
-0.0131401578,
0.0570995845,
0.0135885756,
-0.0150837991,
0.0092178546,
-0.0014356814,
-0.0305893924,
0.003856567,
-0.0117498925,
0.0161387231,
0.0001320657,
-0.0300889853,
0.0518499091,
-0.0503817387,
-0.020069845,
-0.0007918286,
0.0002569475,
0.0413930789,
0.0076255691,
0.0267027617,
-0.0197186191,
0.0068052937,
0.0222518574,
0.0424712822,
0.0216820184,
0.0195277352,
0.0174232963,
-0.0172215011,
0.0090071475,
-0.0634615943,
0.0038922783,
-0.0626444593,
0.0690821782,
0.0127983466,
0.007020555,
-0.0153680686,
-0.0369401611,
-0.0577588119,
-0.0132624144,
0.0160222035,
-0.0431022532,
0.0045787464,
0.0231905412,
0.0148534467,
-0.0348590426,
0.0305791572,
-0.00988001,
0.0220788252,
-0.0322670527,
0.0325223617,
0.0372808091,
-0.0541532077,
0.0129114343,
0.0146555882,
0.0268819332,
-0.0158122573,
-0.047579132,
-0.0299057513,
-0.0156303942,
0.0881557763,
0.1073048189,
-0.0015629786,
0.0147483787,
0.0325186439,
-0.018989794,
0.0504634231,
-0.0019521789,
-0.023722006,
0.021386398,
-0.0482584983,
0.0388121195,
-0.0936992839,
-0.0023224622,
-0.0182841867,
-0.0088750292,
-0.0650716797,
-0.0061189015,
0.1048294157,
0.0443722196,
-0.0284614172,
-0.030836435,
-0.0622026697,
0.0052788858,
0.0421858691,
0.0859244168,
-0.1280989945,
0.0113690579,
-0.0313576944,
0.0263735428,
0.0104983542,
-0.0394252799,
0.0058812862,
-0.0726339072,
0.0344793312,
-0.0623031519,
-0.0383997783,
-0.0162511244,
-0.0615378246,
-0.0046013137,
-0.0305011701,
-0.0177922789,
0.0314594619,
-0.0338533111,
0.0212078597,
-0.0114103034,
-0.0156482663,
0.0314104557,
0.0146969827,
-0.0526325926,
-0.0223178044,
-0.004291845,
0.0786939785,
-0.0500952266,
-0.0142041557,
-0.0468694307,
-0.0103127072,
-0.0354753137,
-0.0130881835,
0.0639123246,
-0.0054361317,
0.0030099747,
-0.058595147,
0.005555653,
-0.036993809,
0.0200560335,
0.0459891818,
0.0687184557,
0.0064650862,
0.0327289738,
-0.0432611927,
-0.0192881115,
-0.0212680604,
0.0623987019,
-0.0032136831,
0.0000242412,
-0.0670201182,
-0.0199913122,
0.037964303,
-0.0426114313,
-0.0527230948,
-0.0005373962,
-0.0294253975,
0.0098608574,
-0.0553746894,
-0.0265175179,
0.0577914417,
-0.0003031785,
-0.0091585396,
0.0184769314,
0.0490324423,
-0.0040962957,
-0.0713846982,
0.0068549514,
-0.0145158311,
0.027378168,
-0.0174879804,
-0.009528907,
0.0395103619,
0.0172293205,
-0.0214948785,
-0.0306075923,
0.0102635669,
-0.0292285737,
-0.0342535079,
0.0150135029,
0.0150970053,
0.0066723181,
-0.0373269022,
-0.0119651854,
0.0109757539,
0.046416983,
-0.0501577444,
-0.0380044393,
-0.0178612582,
-0.0152112385,
-0.0465736426,
0.0208965633,
-0.0785771832,
-0.0368205644,
-0.0600790009,
0.0399134867,
-0.0369386636,
-0.0880906805,
0.0434009284,
0.0390995219,
-0.0283008665,
0.0068590115,
0.0165075511,
0.011750618,
0.0024503593,
-0.0380869545,
-0.0405561663,
-0.0166064799,
0.0094739404,
-0.0155669721,
-0.0192171466,
0.0256643035,
-0.0164355654,
-0.0308730379,
0.0466862954,
-0.0331250653,
0.0072678039,
0.02278083,
-0.0035158882,
0.0022661281,
-0.0258901343,
-0.0049965028,
-0.0254853424,
0.011951888,
0.0602842681,
-0.0105018644,
0.0393728204,
0.0158227086,
-0.0206149835,
-0.0168847069,
-0.0181757621,
-0.0903327167,
-0.0783469975,
0.0185000412,
0.0047365334,
0.0110541461,
0.0306243915,
0.028062148,
0.018327564,
-0.0272710603,
0.012418949,
-0.0027655445,
0.0182545502,
0.0183508731,
0.0687604398,
0.0411396548,
0.0001731011,
-0.0254857726,
0.0300615206,
0.0239454154,
-0.0138696488,
0.0290467925,
-0.0466988347,
-0.0198627766,
-0.0600918569,
-0.0222570393,
0.0308354255,
0.0094926031,
-0.0178874675,
-0.0439135917,
-0.0340890512,
0.0280137658,
-0.0034008129,
-0.0213747136,
-0.0529142357,
0.0303943586,
0.0350773856,
0.0706520006,
-0.0665623769,
-0.048858121,
0.0927960873,
-0.0583959743,
-0.0557117946,
-0.0062535214,
-6.512319519e-33,
-0.0287056435,
-0.0823620707,
0.0315647721,
-0.0058341273,
-0.0287072044,
-0.033862479,
-0.0129579455,
-0.043202959,
-0.0668247193,
0.0501755774,
-0.055483494,
-0.0009935733,
-0.0028781069,
0.0298337601,
0.0060018329,
-0.0346926078,
0.0085634589,
-0.0021730284,
0.0026904561,
0.0268658958,
0.0736182407,
0.0168353897,
-0.0139478203,
-0.0443515293,
0.0490387492,
-0.0510413796,
0.0186999999,
0.0408200808,
0.0308324434,
0.0571860224,
-0.006430272,
0.0038728609,
0.0037138993,
-0.0379077345,
0.0301021617,
0.0034836878,
-0.1367108375,
-0.0122639081,
0.0170022622,
0.0350432284,
-0.0135098603,
0.0031574017,
0.0435991772,
0.0073664435,
0.0355637297,
-0.0275831707,
0.0786812678,
0.0278177224,
-0.0188482199,
-0.0836405754,
-0.0543620735,
-0.0073705609,
-0.0091148689,
0.0255355407,
-0.0456939302,
0.0193858761,
-0.0143373208,
0.0262374897,
-0.0209520087,
-0.0242846031,
-0.0190320052,
0.0253778603,
-0.011723333,
0.0141219106,
-0.0012488322,
-0.0440612398,
-0.014645665,
-0.024236789,
0.0407802686,
0.0406604744,
-0.0262820758,
0.0518131666,
0.0652409568,
0.0404013097,
0.0079535274,
0.0304733068,
-0.0446139425,
0.0269635282,
-0.0105224028,
0.0433501489,
-0.0439332873,
-0.0182085931,
0.039368093,
-0.0353572369,
-0.0120966537,
0.0171502214,
-0.0283755157,
-0.0139805712,
0.007801462,
-0.062374413,
-0.007010093,
-0.0109792454,
0.0006327692,
-0.0454495847,
-0.0466318652,
0.0860329196,
0.0130789373,
0.0309485439,
-0.0173345506,
0.0330643244,
-0.0355114676,
0.0427706875,
-0.0088866409,
-0.0118609071,
-0.0233172346,
0.0242830422,
-0.0094458759,
-0.0174591243,
-0.047631897,
-0.0335464962,
-0.0047822343,
0.0260998588,
-0.0376510732,
0.0155046908,
-0.0060771811,
0.0553028397,
0.0197298564,
0.0364416502,
0.0381263308,
0.0247482844,
-0.0324088857,
0.0066448813,
0.0242810044,
0.0056851967,
-0.000399133,
0.0049114893,
-0.0179898795,
0.0374618322,
-0.0230178256,
-0.0468557924,
-0.005580015,
-0.0200336166,
2.828e-7,
0.1000226364,
0.0199811198,
0.0109156705,
0.0628405884,
-0.0358769745,
-0.0208277162,
0.0446518473,
0.0323676392,
0.0186873078,
0.0137252407,
0.0015303567,
0.0054166908,
-0.0296781603,
0.0648443326,
-0.0922387838,
-0.0488062724,
-0.0530670434,
-0.0830642506,
-0.0491663776,
0.0278168023,
0.0457190573,
0.002245185,
-0.0092541352,
0.0009645698,
-0.0531565137,
-0.0305328257,
0.0179002266,
0.0316677876,
-0.0032764473,
0.0387149677,
0.0427307412,
-0.0510675982,
0.0166883543,
0.0125929136,
0.0067212428,
0.0382907465,
-0.0070450399,
0.0375476256,
-0.0062851482,
-0.0165471323,
0.0057821181,
-0.045465596,
0.0394259915,
-0.0342851505,
0.0807004571,
-0.0228935294,
-0.0062387474,
0.0110810231,
-0.0885323584,
-0.0122670773,
-0.0186966695,
-0.0255401656,
-0.0209401269,
0.0330766663,
0.0142888268,
-0.0056875735,
0.0336252786,
-0.0250314269,
0.0208407268,
0.0351179242,
0.0254700035,
-0.0248300955,
-0.0159944873,
-0.0379089639,
-0.0039028551,
-0.0018073604,
-0.0163748674,
2.590332438e-34,
0.0464216433,
0.0226897337,
-0.0149995955,
0.0591178797,
0.0476770774,
-0.0308493096,
-0.042454578,
0.0245868377,
0.0171310883,
-0.0903477296,
0.0052689174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05020v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05020v2 | First Tragedy, then Parse: History Repeats Itself in the New Era of Large Language Models | 2023-11-08T21:13:38 | 2024-03-26T02:23:27 | Naomi Saphra, Eve Fleisig, Kyunghyun Cho, Adam Lopez | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many NLP researchers are experiencing an existential crisis triggered by the
astonishing success of ChatGPT and other systems based on large language models
(LLMs). After such a disruptive change to our understanding of the field, what
is left to do? Taking a historical lens, we look for guidance from the first
era of LLMs, which began in 2005 with large $n$-gram models for machine
translation (MT). We identify durable lessons from the first era, and more
importantly, we identify evergreen problems where NLP researchers can continue
to make meaningful contributions in areas where LLMs are ascendant. We argue
that disparities in scale are transient and researchers can work to reduce
them; that data, rather than hardware, is still a bottleneck for many
applications; that meaningful realistic evaluation is still an open problem;
and that there is still room for speculative approaches. | [
0.0363462754,
0.0858060196,
-0.0219160002,
0.0413070098,
-0.0536957085,
0.0098073147,
0.0173635986,
0.0162719097,
-0.0075698509,
-0.0567314811,
-0.0165981967,
-0.0718066096,
0.0170921944,
0.0133701451,
0.0159615707,
-0.0267785583,
0.0216185749,
-0.033391133,
-0.0497850813,
-0.0017238172,
0.0175921023,
0.0119408136,
0.0327044837,
0.0633928925,
-0.0010916959,
-0.0059303385,
0.0195599217,
0.0090627344,
-0.021305427,
-0.0142326113,
-0.0391621515,
0.0107651297,
0.0152607476,
0.0748762637,
0.0000018495,
-0.0473631397,
-0.0229214262,
0.0211722162,
-0.0357230082,
0.0646295398,
0.0657961294,
-0.0441207513,
-0.0210666563,
0.0270560421,
-0.0045818342,
-0.0276570022,
0.0456796177,
-0.0179733783,
0.0247519035,
0.0672840178,
-0.0132831624,
-0.0408905819,
0.0451791398,
-0.0481700785,
-0.0410731547,
-0.061121352,
0.0221914817,
0.0096339285,
0.0171361193,
0.029761862,
-0.0396835767,
0.0657329261,
-0.0076984474,
-0.0106688421,
-0.0160031281,
0.0376227982,
-0.0301472861,
-0.0080231819,
-0.0205433704,
0.0293741133,
-0.0130825257,
-0.0168228019,
0.0160868932,
0.0069838003,
-0.0402995385,
-0.0035152913,
-0.0455925576,
0.0637026131,
0.0003868838,
0.0262569524,
0.0487770252,
0.0024263142,
0.0522020608,
0.0234194938,
-0.0457349047,
0.0277546365,
0.0416347049,
-0.0179374255,
-0.0045192153,
0.0415148363,
-0.0598131306,
-0.0236086976,
0.033104185,
0.0029276381,
-0.0149839194,
0.0168466829,
-0.0043540155,
-0.0056879865,
0.0160841867,
-0.0555375293,
0.0485428572,
0.0315512232,
0.0073594227,
0.0640864372,
0.0043983897,
0.0575681999,
-0.060570363,
-0.0306107942,
-0.0483463071,
-0.0142718274,
-0.0489795022,
0.0030496991,
-0.0524579026,
0.0057084719,
-0.0397542566,
-0.0290943477,
-0.0056401249,
0.0235998221,
0.0178749468,
-0.0012365561,
0.0063895485,
-0.0365212336,
-0.0357176773,
-0.0206339229,
0.0113148289,
0.0559310205,
0.0163485352,
-0.0151007045,
-0.0109123196,
-0.0727110505,
-0.0192411207,
0.0099150212,
-0.0222839694,
-0.0508313589,
0.0133339148,
0.0795295835,
0.0201130621,
-0.0353290327,
-0.0140309492,
-0.0070440099,
-0.0566624776,
-0.082173869,
-0.0318144374,
-0.0655467361,
0.0325611085,
0.0458970927,
0.0308743399,
-0.0172480624,
-0.0065348009,
0.0144250849,
-0.0513681807,
0.0560005307,
0.0419862047,
0.0219029244,
-0.0064895521,
-0.0154226832,
-0.0043901773,
0.0708392709,
0.0163770597,
-0.0019157308,
0.0388550758,
-0.0182501748,
-0.0213131234,
0.0828836188,
-0.004436038,
0.0382247418,
-0.0200729817,
-0.0099951942,
0.0501071922,
0.0518031195,
0.0128310481,
0.0999615565,
-0.025606472,
-0.0131585039,
0.0668138936,
0.0784705803,
-0.0066391909,
0.049252551,
0.0405065753,
-0.0077963755,
0.0025750892,
-0.0096427621,
-0.0029770159,
-0.0355403684,
-0.0201781113,
0.0007243852,
0.0526623093,
0.0583684109,
-0.0078513511,
-0.0016051511,
-0.0508533567,
0.0109211095,
-0.018741902,
-0.011944632,
0.0619269833,
-0.0312306322,
0.0063524656,
0.0271089654,
0.0240881126,
-0.0258057602,
0.0449749045,
-0.0720008537,
-0.0332420468,
0.0337583423,
0.0838900432,
-0.003085132,
0.013153418,
-0.0085621225,
0.0193421766,
0.0567613058,
0.0514192767,
0.0089956038,
-0.0019983409,
-0.0078159515,
0.0274822675,
0.0242625922,
0.0178421568,
0.0133622857,
0.0469465256,
0.0249532368,
-0.0013784339,
-0.0081083849,
-0.0423919745,
0.017723687,
-0.0341731496,
0.0050662607,
0.0069729979,
-0.0315926783,
0.0555939004,
0.0150177348,
-0.0368906148,
0.0182822626,
0.0284661427,
-0.0602902472,
-0.0176803414,
-0.0137963081,
-0.0098089566,
-0.0402728543,
0.0420193747,
0.0038459634,
0.0097873146,
-0.0037829611,
-0.020269515,
-0.0342452303,
0.0138120903,
-0.0466057099,
0.0635810867,
-0.0207133275,
0.0459789522,
0.0015217904,
0.0143234497,
-0.0677719489,
0.0314447284,
0.0011798567,
0.0426119082,
0.0026338436,
-0.0031235653,
0.0165466405,
-0.0201783273,
-0.0650458932,
0.0586587787,
0.0374312364,
0.0161721725,
0.0147966174,
-0.0119197695,
-0.0083758123,
-0.0580658428,
-0.0821006373,
0.031933412,
-0.0246613789,
0.0393563695,
0.02800465,
0.0204557106,
0.0076759653,
0.034529347,
-0.0130452719,
0.0088923518,
0.0308477171,
0.0484373122,
0.0171756241,
0.0032940737,
-0.0256571081,
-0.0328456573,
-0.0351161733,
0.00571645,
0.0723528415,
0.0033890845,
-0.043245554,
-0.0621733703,
0.0333788991,
-0.0236610938,
0.0270553883,
-0.0252711512,
-0.0176864676,
0.0019651107,
-0.044897452,
0.0662485436,
0.0348826684,
-0.0151981106,
0.0422207452,
0.0207735226,
-0.0244661197,
-0.0386245102,
-0.0157903396,
-0.0413608104,
-0.0749413744,
-0.0375227928,
-0.0280020032,
-0.007304112,
0.0833253488,
-0.0124711283,
-0.0171779953,
-0.0134356478,
0.0047721062,
-0.062886022,
0.0228657201,
-0.0162345842,
0.0190831292,
-0.0113457134,
0.0144850202,
-0.0425937138,
-0.0542838946,
0.0340437405,
-0.0651985854,
-0.0135231446,
-0.044930622,
-0.0336142182,
-0.0523718596,
0.107026875,
0.0054177125,
0.0235572141,
-0.0225759353,
-0.0130313225,
0.0039920653,
0.0306144562,
-0.0209959857,
-0.0239847209,
0.0721274465,
-0.0635252818,
0.0551601164,
-0.0268209223,
-0.0408856086,
0.0062340614,
-0.05815088,
-0.0474912152,
-0.0151896067,
0.0639438778,
-0.0381246209,
-0.0331821404,
0.0532270931,
0.0137431677,
0.0214722585,
0.0048853094,
-0.0037960606,
-0.0127145015,
0.0463399962,
0.0317050144,
-0.0122882072,
0.0351407267,
-0.0194147602,
0.013614051,
0.0459245965,
0.0246908776,
0.0101208072,
-0.030991843,
-0.0137317749,
0.0482401624,
-0.0262974054,
-0.0282700025,
-0.01258766,
0.0504013896,
-0.0355387703,
-0.0294528008,
0.1118491068,
0.0249469578,
-0.0445892252,
0.0230605993,
0.0330817141,
0.0424312055,
-0.0045493371,
0.009308855,
-0.0569252558,
-0.0134735843,
0.0210343469,
-0.0155357737,
-0.0012627582,
-0.030012276,
-0.0353039317,
-0.1088834256,
0.0323705822,
0.0302579254,
-0.0003401435,
-0.0045198514,
-0.0210003536,
-0.0335760042,
-0.0462635458,
0.0347988345,
0.0002313579,
-0.0354295969,
0.0074054324,
0.0275945254,
-0.0063594691,
-0.0264355969,
0.0256426018,
-0.0568490513,
0.0578557476,
0.0366535112,
0.0167728923,
-0.0086039938,
-0.0092721572,
0.0370447077,
0.0039190366,
0.0022248162,
-0.0242667515,
0.0071313195,
0.0039581349,
-0.0294021647,
-0.0073417448,
0.006646601,
-0.0302559584,
0.0298269447,
0.0100217443,
0.058795765,
-0.0218632687,
0.0052627488,
0.0184491556,
-0.0319885984,
-0.0358859599,
0.0723255575,
0.0076850937,
-0.049587585,
-0.0319468342,
-0.034263473,
-0.01675901,
0.0131336823,
-0.056516923,
0.0151500311,
0.0000276687,
-0.00626955,
-0.0373651832,
-0.0127041852,
0.0269063935,
0.0180971418,
0.0152984634,
0.0241092499,
0.0300634932,
-0.022147106,
-0.0239423532,
0.0351806991,
-0.0585714653,
0.0188147463,
-0.0591989383,
0.0248827077,
0.0474354364,
0.0035917759,
-0.0165287051,
0.0200986527,
-0.1436341703,
-0.0866698325,
-0.0115732765,
-0.0001689297,
0.0330139548,
0.004938832,
-0.0237139706,
-0.0462614521,
-0.0066167754,
0.0285553038,
-0.0250409599,
0.0171723478,
-0.0127390698,
0.0363208465,
0.0026563706,
0.0511984304,
0.003651544,
-0.0062855771,
0.0041071214,
0.049050618,
-0.0067371447,
-0.0295838881,
0.0093797119,
0.0228168108,
0.0523776524,
-0.0277012046,
0.0048862454,
-0.0021729744,
-0.0407859273,
-0.0243312083,
0.0054150475,
-0.0517887808,
-0.0445602573,
0.0619099475,
0.009343504,
-0.0642903373,
-0.0015661416,
0.0067407065,
0.0292799342,
-0.0534730703,
0.026385881,
-0.0296028852,
-0.034250617,
0.0728013366,
-0.0073925974,
-0.0128106866,
0.0194333568,
-0.0098972237,
0.0105442693,
-0.018655194,
0.0452325158,
0.0127295749,
-0.0121892914,
-0.0063211205,
0.0265518632,
-0.0538896993,
-0.0609015077,
0.0036177479,
0.0623311661,
0.0893499926,
-0.0048683118,
0.0757754818,
-0.0199487675,
-0.0201401599,
-0.0523784831,
0.0238147583,
0.0225435719,
-0.0193179194,
0.0079738963,
0.0008868815,
-0.0337602533,
0.0590897016,
0.0896646902,
0.0078949593,
0.0386853106,
0.0563517138,
-0.0284668989,
0.0054215626,
-0.0619919561,
-0.032472115,
-0.0490483269,
-0.0219043214,
0.0019135498,
-0.0814526752,
-0.0497301742,
-0.0299249534,
0.0099556837,
0.0142934974,
-0.032922104,
-0.0271172281,
0.0619700141,
0.0006819215,
0.0003620836,
-0.0543102622,
0.0419587716,
-0.0490065962,
-0.0352756903,
0.0055453125,
-6.480441581e-33,
0.0015124198,
0.0066276737,
0.0229178108,
-0.0309817549,
-0.052248802,
0.0227568932,
-0.005536363,
0.0216921568,
-0.0102209244,
-0.0098969955,
-0.032183364,
-0.0137153957,
0.0009569364,
0.029014973,
0.0188253745,
0.0190477986,
0.0590215512,
0.0094718598,
0.006042643,
0.0108242054,
0.0110463481,
0.0048552323,
0.034609694,
-0.0235220529,
0.0180692822,
-0.0092162034,
0.0104609048,
0.0164785255,
-0.0092820777,
0.0267957542,
-0.040115308,
0.0337756872,
0.0385857224,
-0.055625733,
-0.0122842109,
-0.0252004117,
-0.0596635193,
0.0410646498,
0.0373162292,
0.0270502642,
0.028509073,
-0.0063489564,
0.0271458235,
-0.0124825081,
-0.0317063071,
-0.0044617094,
-0.0332282111,
-0.0162871797,
-0.039746426,
0.0175678283,
-0.0138592236,
0.0375088118,
0.0118270358,
0.0129170427,
0.0341432951,
-0.0371100157,
-0.0227410216,
0.0391372852,
-0.0354721621,
-0.0216045231,
0.0132954456,
0.0690858737,
0.0610512719,
0.0020040667,
0.0071620382,
0.0489619114,
0.0146494452,
0.0167318806,
-0.0036397469,
0.0074661816,
0.0047407486,
-0.0020988195,
0.0314977393,
0.0110788438,
0.0201707538,
-0.0064227092,
-0.0636469945,
-0.0223125275,
0.0223807562,
0.0241285507,
0.0367601924,
0.0156361237,
-0.0443756357,
-0.0261227153,
-0.042833589,
-0.022116892,
-0.0159026403,
-0.0037270796,
0.0232206695,
0.0063210479,
0.0039976155,
0.0055079809,
0.0633864701,
-0.059038762,
-0.0593592674,
-0.0158863701,
-0.0037947113,
0.0325462148,
-0.0335778557,
0.0546605177,
-0.0641145781,
-0.0563371666,
-0.0309939552,
0.0196020827,
-0.0279837362,
-0.0228302293,
0.0125501566,
0.0043139593,
-0.0586222745,
-0.0103742257,
-0.0599609204,
0.0160996206,
-0.0184543561,
0.0344459713,
0.061656341,
-0.0188274067,
0.0077900281,
0.0427078977,
0.0280558728,
0.0140734799,
0.0022330394,
-0.0065840115,
0.0046847006,
-0.0104565062,
-0.0274712462,
0.0307196509,
-0.0327017531,
0.0303711537,
0.0590138659,
-0.0434337631,
-0.0258224253,
-0.0307905469,
2.589e-7,
0.0308628567,
0.061060749,
0.0198752768,
0.0099997753,
0.0487006083,
0.0056077433,
-0.0196423363,
0.0344561338,
-0.0340661742,
0.029105464,
-0.0107239801,
0.0250319038,
0.0784279183,
0.001286726,
-0.0680732206,
-0.0285342671,
-0.0610867701,
0.0247923937,
-0.0715733394,
-0.0236692,
0.0307038464,
0.1266150475,
0.0014173401,
0.0037844563,
-0.007695389,
-0.0602710359,
0.074368082,
-0.0442929864,
-0.0513406061,
0.0126648042,
0.0389270782,
0.0187241044,
-0.0028911207,
-0.0067678136,
0.0024565614,
0.0193443038,
0.0214211605,
0.0899213627,
0.0191962998,
0.0352704637,
0.0164683741,
-0.0430921465,
-0.026550604,
-0.0579126477,
0.0695327222,
-0.0392353311,
-0.0284321904,
-0.0249395762,
0.0004147707,
-0.023185648,
0.0078204544,
-0.0170507133,
-0.0151814455,
0.0298090857,
0.0268764105,
-0.0363561586,
-0.0220344048,
-0.0567072593,
-0.0252148788,
-0.0082191201,
-0.0337744579,
-0.06381841,
-0.0294453632,
0.0225251932,
0.0198406968,
-0.0467769913,
-0.012540211,
2.589049726e-34,
0.0602279678,
-0.0093146851,
0.0253128782,
-0.0029773561,
0.0380457416,
0.0021082093,
0.0069547123,
0.0048066308,
-0.0381090753,
-0.1105360836,
-0.0187173951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05014v1 | Interpreting Pretrained Language Models via Concept Bottlenecks | 2023-11-08T20:41:18 | 2023-11-08T20:41:18 | Zhen Tan, Lu Cheng, Song Wang, Yuan Bo, Jundong Li, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained language models (PLMs) have made significant strides in various
natural language processing tasks. However, the lack of interpretability due to
their ``black-box'' nature poses challenges for responsible implementation.
Although previous studies have attempted to improve interpretability by using,
e.g., attention weights in self-attention layers, these weights often lack
clarity, readability, and intuitiveness. In this research, we propose a novel
approach to interpreting PLMs by employing high-level, meaningful concepts that
are easily understandable for humans. For example, we learn the concept of
``Food'' and investigate how it influences the prediction of a model's
sentiment towards a restaurant review. We introduce C$^3$M, which combines
human-annotated and machine-generated concepts to extract hidden neurons
designed to encapsulate semantically meaningful and task-specific concepts.
Through empirical evaluations on real-world datasets, we manifest that our
approach offers valuable insights to interpret PLM behavior, helps diagnose
model failures, and enhances model robustness amidst noisy concept labels. | [
0.0566264503,
0.048446618,
-0.0235994123,
0.0465789624,
0.0251172055,
0.0071393484,
-0.0206479598,
0.0118438452,
-0.0342891663,
-0.0540847667,
-0.0369803347,
-0.0101547567,
-0.0121488655,
0.0702007189,
0.0013872933,
-0.0239857715,
0.0454269648,
-0.0149438092,
0.0331280269,
0.0323579945,
0.0151015837,
-0.0103882626,
0.0286616925,
0.0359579474,
-0.0015365989,
-0.0360103399,
0.0059107412,
0.0081093144,
-0.0441427007,
-0.0672364235,
0.0194681138,
0.0746261403,
0.0281765182,
0.0242725946,
0.0000020535,
-0.0091528911,
0.0032922348,
-0.0322865434,
-0.062518701,
0.0426168889,
0.0046272711,
-0.0431785919,
0.0359460562,
-0.0546109155,
-0.0349965803,
-0.022932345,
0.0372414067,
0.0709547997,
0.0126924748,
0.0478288196,
0.0059300321,
-0.0227683019,
-0.0593981035,
-0.0355157852,
0.0479657464,
-0.0523376875,
0.0226206724,
-0.0088379085,
-0.0542798862,
0.0163605958,
-0.0186679196,
0.0137372874,
0.0067427754,
0.0178877991,
0.0559667647,
0.0420362502,
-0.0130806947,
-0.0480274595,
-0.0241904408,
0.0955246016,
-0.0286016408,
-0.0245077945,
-0.0442848131,
-0.0127025312,
0.0046541542,
-0.0549107082,
-0.0237969868,
-0.0299520418,
0.0116351042,
0.0448260047,
0.0039488277,
0.051366739,
0.0438900888,
0.023580838,
-0.0039273654,
0.0826861933,
-0.0445498973,
-0.0350230485,
0.0280371662,
0.0615298375,
-0.0226324443,
-0.0073596411,
0.0421385169,
0.0098758927,
0.0267216619,
0.0533010252,
-0.0179767273,
-0.0074423421,
0.0092504742,
-0.0889842734,
0.0778886974,
0.0216964651,
-0.0540635921,
0.0579510257,
-0.027506182,
0.0068403077,
-0.0398079902,
0.0270539895,
-0.0318411589,
0.0378613621,
-0.0483615175,
-0.0221359469,
-0.0214871895,
0.0243121367,
-0.0127782701,
-0.0072938898,
-0.0189275667,
0.0240393728,
-0.0307193343,
-0.0392528735,
-0.0062288879,
0.0413000882,
-0.0173128638,
-0.0007023374,
-0.0737141594,
0.021169465,
-0.04214615,
0.0292260218,
-0.0213722549,
-0.0508744493,
-0.0436052456,
-0.0050308835,
-0.0126861874,
-0.0139978323,
0.020381989,
0.0318479389,
0.017768899,
-0.0566599779,
-0.0366041176,
-0.0289385375,
-0.0312338267,
-0.0640423521,
-0.0160633177,
-0.0125134541,
0.0209315792,
0.0013021729,
0.018330723,
-0.0471718125,
0.0288899187,
0.0056249932,
-0.0391039513,
0.0949713215,
-0.0190476421,
-0.0129442085,
-0.0243371651,
0.0429485105,
-0.0190844834,
0.0489146002,
0.0249320157,
0.0598566979,
0.0339945816,
-0.0031500666,
0.0114540663,
-0.0307319444,
0.0444638208,
-0.0150733832,
-0.0385961309,
0.0160449371,
-0.035580948,
0.0226272214,
0.0459290519,
0.0174666625,
-0.0107804341,
0.0191606302,
0.1155140847,
0.0521588512,
-0.0127469776,
0.0487222187,
0.024053216,
0.0188895613,
0.024607487,
-0.0028238292,
-0.0566284992,
0.0251230095,
-0.0461869426,
-0.0154995965,
0.0199206062,
0.0091261948,
-0.0242243968,
-0.0722984448,
0.009235234,
-0.0074896882,
0.0432523526,
0.0028345154,
0.0752043799,
0.0201443285,
-0.0523245558,
0.0287626926,
0.0390410013,
-0.0288487449,
0.0189991873,
-0.0422751456,
0.0391369686,
0.0792678669,
0.0086486423,
-0.0377508663,
0.0030542265,
0.0312847905,
-0.0013987572,
0.0335802995,
0.0438236222,
0.0187095124,
0.0178408213,
-0.0033262477,
-0.0322246663,
-0.0189547036,
0.0234917514,
0.0185325835,
-0.0109612606,
0.0122491699,
0.0134497704,
-0.0312167332,
-0.0591365099,
0.0206363089,
0.0504652411,
-0.0336048007,
-0.0060173995,
0.0076610269,
0.0260118507,
0.0079974849,
0.0177739263,
0.0181736555,
0.0180184953,
-0.0453743935,
-0.0056280056,
0.0177720487,
-0.0690165684,
-0.0291609168,
-0.0053237239,
-0.0213872883,
-0.0289361533,
0.034434028,
-0.0358740762,
-0.0137354713,
0.0240617711,
-0.0108878976,
0.0579814687,
-0.0395753272,
0.0056360178,
-0.0038833555,
0.065866597,
0.0006850898,
0.0833727196,
-0.0026246791,
-0.0142545355,
-0.044224903,
-0.0143156918,
-0.0069734533,
0.0063442443,
-0.0375336371,
-0.0233542658,
0.0149456831,
0.0033412706,
-0.0023648508,
0.0234271586,
-0.0332931913,
0.0449667722,
-0.0589209348,
-0.0093592582,
-0.012426273,
-0.0102323564,
-0.007510806,
-0.0212727338,
0.004800735,
-0.0207498111,
-0.0008829119,
0.0134999426,
-0.0423278101,
0.0154138086,
0.0338234417,
0.0012055732,
0.0047224774,
-0.0511700176,
-0.0079126349,
-0.0120110242,
0.0673485324,
0.0017462419,
-0.0321776196,
-0.0132709732,
0.0035460135,
0.0045899991,
0.0021441299,
0.0007009878,
-0.0602903143,
0.0028652637,
-0.0123685664,
-0.0212306418,
0.0632972643,
-0.0049210074,
0.0724761337,
0.0734653175,
0.0037699982,
-0.0507161617,
0.0027263816,
-0.0365379192,
0.0530156903,
-0.0301810987,
-0.003851067,
0.0187541209,
0.1135035232,
0.0106913196,
-0.0029630107,
-0.0778691694,
0.0089539066,
-0.0148517732,
-0.0428315699,
-0.0800162703,
0.0034006499,
-0.0091964034,
0.0550626963,
-0.0300979074,
-0.0362689197,
0.0805546716,
-0.0218505636,
-0.0074731479,
-0.009195691,
-0.0116242832,
-0.017597178,
0.0746310353,
0.0266723037,
0.0108316578,
0.0441467203,
0.0106084775,
-0.0106845153,
0.0397675037,
-0.0339612551,
-0.043462418,
0.0410706624,
-0.0333454944,
-0.0211400632,
0.0552273691,
-0.0069506494,
-0.0421473235,
-0.0255640857,
-0.053873308,
-0.0263626445,
0.0531818718,
0.0367411822,
-0.0300811976,
0.0317008235,
-0.0140531734,
0.0157859083,
-0.0135735935,
-0.0272029489,
-0.0104012229,
-0.0201949347,
0.0371922441,
0.0195092,
0.026053058,
-0.029608082,
0.0064448752,
0.0515703373,
-0.0134141771,
-0.0113559663,
-0.0362470746,
0.0387390666,
0.0288990326,
-0.0221300274,
0.0061848322,
0.0099933939,
0.0083478568,
-0.0811773762,
-0.0451944619,
0.1119464189,
0.0178875308,
-0.0698130131,
0.0498680845,
0.0065758997,
-0.0159349404,
0.0201164149,
0.0238169897,
-0.0387731865,
-0.0476966202,
-0.0281837471,
0.0245939065,
0.0029031022,
0.0159346387,
-0.0268376209,
-0.0782060772,
-0.0020427911,
-0.0200630277,
-0.0613940507,
-0.0580189526,
-0.0433879942,
-0.032823462,
-0.0014699626,
0.0055767661,
-0.0099091567,
0.0119016832,
0.0184341148,
0.0180619415,
-0.0338461213,
-0.0485787317,
0.0567788482,
-0.0152356643,
0.0480306335,
0.055688303,
0.0039217756,
-0.0051503712,
-0.0237284396,
0.0162016619,
-0.0167190321,
0.0194538962,
-0.0221301578,
0.0631504878,
-0.0411492921,
-0.0235176012,
-0.0023855709,
-0.0229232553,
-0.0717478096,
-0.0364734307,
-0.0219266228,
0.0394229181,
-0.00949156,
-0.0484038889,
-0.0014171293,
0.0308998916,
0.022382671,
0.1122290939,
0.0778297409,
-0.0539095514,
-0.0234695151,
-0.0162536539,
-0.027895635,
-0.0502061397,
-0.0364539884,
0.0627501234,
-0.0170319621,
-0.0376559831,
-0.0012303989,
-0.0323843136,
0.0135732628,
0.0093110893,
0.0202511437,
0.0199940987,
0.0117001059,
0.0104053924,
-0.0202998724,
0.0793985501,
-0.0140384566,
-0.0498279147,
-0.0561323799,
-0.0605549403,
0.0283711683,
-0.0329991691,
-0.031061165,
-0.0047032731,
-0.0778781772,
-0.0270406455,
0.0394635201,
0.0952001363,
0.0195932928,
0.0533931963,
-0.0023292215,
-0.0633478761,
0.0550386384,
0.0104835238,
-0.066005826,
-0.006608604,
0.0274988152,
-0.0033552987,
0.0217256024,
0.0450978354,
-0.0440464318,
0.0561891645,
0.0113930628,
0.0158853699,
-0.0374079347,
-0.0336766914,
0.027842287,
-0.0387958139,
0.0815265477,
0.016097106,
-0.0180163644,
-0.0467011295,
0.0096579092,
-0.0076788757,
-0.0062926211,
-0.0661190078,
-0.0533335693,
0.0284494106,
-0.0240932498,
-0.0306713022,
-0.0503967628,
-0.0403443873,
0.0112466887,
-0.0111651793,
0.0038185662,
0.0247826371,
0.0091937333,
-0.0076963832,
-0.004764488,
-0.0114439074,
0.0412457883,
-0.049006857,
-0.0015230125,
0.0041946764,
0.0191948321,
0.0074947323,
0.0167345535,
-0.0233320463,
0.0458817631,
-0.0443905815,
-0.0229216274,
0.0218964741,
-0.0239827689,
0.0267932601,
-0.0495448895,
0.0554281063,
-0.03333994,
0.0038606862,
-0.002705297,
0.0347041152,
-0.0387574881,
-0.0121728955,
0.045470193,
0.0058421753,
-0.0217627715,
-0.0171130002,
0.0795826837,
0.0078709824,
0.0098312227,
0.0484268591,
-0.0352260359,
-0.0250523798,
0.0266952384,
0.0303247999,
0.0404344797,
-0.0330868736,
0.0323168486,
-0.0596593767,
-0.055081293,
0.0304304957,
0.0159178991,
0.0012065063,
-0.0068308976,
0.0433328524,
0.0455632359,
0.012230129,
-0.0271919705,
-0.0168041456,
0.0091406936,
-0.017286839,
-0.0044453284,
0.004317896,
-6.840297136e-33,
-0.0384658016,
-0.0545745604,
-0.0410995744,
0.0162388757,
-0.0023934823,
0.0277676862,
-0.0669417009,
0.0036459656,
0.0156170642,
0.0320304409,
0.0202029217,
0.0335994214,
0.0085208239,
0.0054124482,
-0.014248101,
-0.0429032035,
0.0331007615,
0.0083519742,
0.00018949,
0.0004793635,
0.0188566633,
0.059633933,
0.0669237673,
-0.0540674441,
0.066680789,
0.0051037758,
-0.0030679503,
-0.0044982811,
0.0147312768,
0.0665962473,
-0.0573428497,
0.0661401302,
0.0445691384,
-0.0349577107,
-0.0205498207,
0.0253217947,
-0.0718454793,
-0.0327671394,
0.0206733309,
0.034675397,
-0.0447016209,
-0.0344351791,
0.0817970037,
0.0082481829,
0.0162372272,
0.0378844254,
0.0478830189,
-0.0089489538,
-0.0414464921,
-0.0223980807,
-0.0599368177,
0.0032924451,
-0.0165097341,
0.0024669291,
0.0399624631,
0.013507111,
-0.0143617252,
0.0375257693,
-0.0478184409,
-0.00844693,
0.0122129098,
0.0175100751,
0.0484656505,
0.0372812152,
-0.0030452423,
0.0717185661,
0.0156866908,
0.0075043496,
-0.0502461083,
-0.0102788052,
0.0570751317,
0.0215087328,
0.0279113073,
-0.0048928689,
0.0722895712,
-0.0178776663,
-0.0460937396,
0.0205655657,
-0.022358492,
-0.0001669111,
0.028484175,
-0.0012399977,
-0.0110339345,
-0.021276867,
0.0057495786,
-0.0506785661,
-0.0540862791,
-0.0343083218,
0.0172251239,
-0.0220692474,
-0.0460567251,
-0.0119983619,
0.0132507449,
-0.0223391671,
0.0030913828,
-0.0042337896,
0.0382464863,
-0.0267061591,
0.0273689274,
0.0121686012,
-0.0822442845,
-0.0426695272,
-0.0197755545,
-0.0115645863,
0.0397260226,
0.001700818,
0.0279625934,
-0.0040978813,
-0.0032943636,
-0.0209254697,
-0.0229118448,
-0.0405094847,
0.0289576668,
0.0530036986,
0.0431779698,
0.0209321938,
-0.0355238505,
0.0381522365,
0.0274875239,
-0.0021098461,
-0.0337300338,
0.0041941572,
0.0176899992,
0.0369621776,
-0.028544724,
-0.0433333404,
-0.0330744088,
-0.0070343479,
0.056863267,
-0.0645370036,
-0.0160367433,
0.0035913521,
2.782e-7,
0.0622735955,
0.0616832227,
-0.023452187,
0.0051339124,
0.0108212903,
0.0456549004,
0.0162975751,
0.0161739979,
-0.0262344349,
-0.0322279781,
0.054119058,
0.061100658,
0.0266033951,
0.011874117,
-0.0322174691,
0.0173661448,
-0.0370629393,
0.0513149127,
-0.0092859175,
-0.0184082072,
0.032808993,
0.086639598,
0.0287228338,
-0.0012686938,
-0.0179911219,
-0.0216187499,
0.0467844233,
-0.072429575,
0.0241366234,
0.0028909545,
0.0444965102,
0.0177107453,
-0.0404408388,
-0.0003291507,
-0.0116575062,
-0.0078766653,
0.0285009984,
0.041356802,
-0.024853684,
-0.0369631983,
-0.0381423719,
0.0187054928,
0.0050685029,
-0.0641591027,
0.0513109118,
-0.0932814553,
-0.0352929458,
-0.0032355422,
0.0432870686,
-0.0453881472,
0.0136412913,
0.0192115493,
-0.0000197606,
-0.0280365013,
-0.005325566,
-0.0241107251,
-0.0263535883,
-0.074304074,
-0.0176239423,
-0.0143490173,
-0.0120633431,
-0.0072241155,
-0.05587833,
-0.0237524398,
0.0260585919,
-0.0220570769,
-0.0000879916,
2.287953735e-34,
0.0384233743,
-0.0287144426,
0.0146240974,
0.0055145072,
0.0239323266,
0.017521644,
-0.0263183527,
-0.0109147606,
0.0132510914,
-0.0667521134,
-0.0155039942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07587v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07587v2 | Frontier Language Models are not Robust to Adversarial Arithmetic, or "What do I need to say so you agree 2+2=5? | 2023-11-08T19:07:10 | 2023-11-15T19:49:02 | C. Daniel Freeman, Laura Culp, Aaron Parisi, Maxwell L Bileschi, Gamaleldin F Elsayed, Alex Rizkowsky, Isabelle Simpson, Alex Alemi, Azade Nova, Ben Adlam, Bernd Bohnet, Gaurav Mishra, Hanie Sedghi, Igor Mordatch, Izzeddin Gur, Jaehoon Lee, JD Co-Reyes, Jeffrey Pennington, Kelvin Xu, Kevin Swersky, Kshiteej Mahajan, Lechao Xiao, Rosanne Liu, Simon Kornblith, Noah Constant, Peter J. Liu, Roman Novak, Yundi Qian, Noah Fiedel, Jascha Sohl-Dickstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | We introduce and study the problem of adversarial arithmetic, which provides
a simple yet challenging testbed for language model alignment. This problem is
comprised of arithmetic questions posed in natural language, with an arbitrary
adversarial string inserted before the question is complete. Even in the simple
setting of 1-digit addition problems, it is easy to find adversarial prompts
that make all tested models (including PaLM2, GPT4, Claude2) misbehave, and
even to steer models to a particular wrong answer. We additionally provide a
simple algorithm for finding successful attacks by querying those same models,
which we name "prompt inversion rejection sampling" (PIRS). We finally show
that models can be partially hardened against these attacks via reinforcement
learning and via agentic constitutional loops. However, we were not able to
make a language model fully robust against adversarial arithmetic attacks. | [
0.0183718428,
0.116881527,
-0.0199502409,
0.0411022641,
-0.0501576066,
0.0017332551,
-0.0071738139,
-0.0398968756,
-0.0435792506,
-0.019048674,
-0.0116175832,
-0.0236007236,
0.0456410013,
0.0146373054,
0.0698468462,
-0.0090301819,
0.0545102246,
-0.0327643678,
-0.0139147723,
-0.0092458567,
-0.0142225679,
-0.0210050028,
-0.0181464739,
0.0059560454,
0.0115420111,
-0.0228761192,
-0.0215521343,
-0.0586249307,
0.0028821661,
-0.0088220956,
-0.0047643585,
0.0226722881,
-0.0152059179,
0.090373762,
0.0000019421,
-0.0423434675,
-0.0223599449,
0.0288726129,
-0.0364525877,
0.0652232468,
0.0211574193,
-0.0011440135,
-0.0132449279,
0.0386242084,
-0.0441774577,
-0.0086105466,
0.0412114598,
0.0575238205,
0.0768743977,
0.099569194,
0.0178745631,
-0.0093372725,
0.043683555,
-0.055544287,
-0.0139578832,
-0.049411308,
0.0255788136,
-0.0217865035,
-0.0124187227,
0.0119018098,
-0.0157214925,
-0.0107279653,
0.0371836536,
-0.0026776905,
-0.0880173072,
0.0014957191,
-0.0136838555,
-0.0002719577,
0.0085862018,
0.0687409341,
-0.0204516556,
-0.0181022249,
0.0009444904,
0.0103896055,
0.0116515746,
-0.0033128997,
-0.0365285091,
0.0063632149,
0.0321969166,
-0.005939933,
0.0237149652,
-0.0262769274,
0.047319226,
-0.0056718048,
-0.0236088075,
0.0739326701,
0.0448527858,
-0.0111401826,
-0.0152481776,
-0.0323709399,
-0.0566308163,
-0.0489117242,
-0.0172799062,
0.0215110257,
-0.0222027246,
0.0179255661,
-0.0606586151,
-0.0135426987,
0.0323939845,
-0.0200154502,
0.0290227253,
0.0510784574,
-0.0085292058,
0.0196337979,
0.0131778149,
0.0227981061,
-0.0473686121,
0.0700408965,
-0.0040920814,
0.019015843,
0.048504401,
-0.018319387,
-0.0009486158,
0.0103709083,
-0.0295433365,
0.0189161729,
0.0031971324,
0.0572582036,
-0.0342245251,
0.0607377812,
-0.0476870127,
-0.0017056107,
0.0090843868,
-0.0280635562,
0.0028885272,
0.0168185756,
-0.029960135,
0.0199242309,
-0.0024811761,
-0.0907460302,
-0.0459637642,
0.0044593993,
-0.0523100235,
-0.0221214592,
-0.0042242859,
0.1093218625,
0.012685122,
-0.0019546992,
-0.0025915627,
-0.0128388889,
-0.0211306494,
-0.0614083298,
-0.0093698855,
-0.0668533295,
-0.0159313846,
0.0119969696,
-0.0405031517,
-0.0313642584,
0.0221655201,
0.0168624893,
-0.0060586026,
0.0959834233,
0.0655311793,
-0.0100348303,
0.0146571305,
-0.0079767993,
-0.0277322344,
0.0451967977,
0.0269256048,
-0.0132572353,
0.0348848552,
0.0091591943,
0.0125001827,
0.0674571544,
0.0352034643,
0.0202866606,
-0.0148218293,
0.036637146,
0.0298220161,
0.0090717915,
-0.0127824107,
0.0548959561,
-0.0217835288,
-0.0800369307,
0.0717612579,
0.036957223,
-0.0870202035,
-0.0041751373,
-0.0158384088,
-0.0298517291,
0.0068455753,
0.0377660729,
-0.0783675015,
0.0058783269,
-0.0936995968,
0.000125683,
0.0233539809,
0.0096802777,
-0.0327125825,
-0.0437541269,
-0.0143844979,
0.0127394283,
0.0428154543,
0.0212362297,
0.0369736068,
0.0002667182,
-0.0105273565,
-0.0237955302,
-0.0079887677,
-0.0390093066,
-0.0187312402,
-0.0640894473,
0.0285558272,
-0.0658896491,
0.0700841621,
-0.0386234485,
0.0176196508,
-0.0380691588,
-0.0129029602,
0.0271547213,
0.0886217803,
-0.014651482,
-0.0288482178,
-0.0081511326,
-0.0118738292,
-0.034960296,
0.0316125266,
0.0062678843,
-0.0230134279,
-0.0093680937,
-0.0297570564,
0.0002829879,
-0.0183770526,
0.0289762449,
-0.030266393,
-0.0893188938,
0.0014355739,
0.0249538757,
0.0243096408,
-0.0015709796,
-0.0023350201,
0.0739813447,
0.0354910381,
0.0092507889,
0.0006936108,
-0.0325197279,
0.008214891,
-0.0393396281,
0.0709525421,
-0.0358123221,
-0.0336221382,
0.0532764979,
-0.0407145172,
-0.0143003175,
0.0818159431,
-0.0595062636,
0.0159891751,
-0.0048781023,
0.024975244,
0.0127139278,
-0.0172385871,
-0.0356953964,
0.033607088,
-0.0297736544,
0.0130966092,
-0.0083825924,
0.017007621,
0.0314708911,
-0.0128882574,
-0.0261080209,
-0.0084787924,
-0.0178487971,
0.0237958822,
0.0309353955,
-0.0420546979,
0.0098333284,
-0.028175449,
-0.0001822053,
-0.0149969263,
-0.0305782836,
0.0484373495,
0.03457167,
-0.0060823611,
-0.004124695,
-0.0398653634,
-0.048553016,
-0.0074350806,
0.0183070954,
0.0196947698,
0.0172789302,
0.0032194022,
-0.01739306,
-0.0388972014,
-0.0050612045,
-0.0389594287,
0.0479879193,
-0.0041611902,
0.0022338242,
-0.0364609174,
-0.0311012212,
-0.0132434843,
0.0590045191,
-0.0408745408,
-0.0032884104,
0.0245541092,
0.0052494104,
-0.0054021273,
0.0514078252,
0.0023993775,
0.0649171323,
0.0340790413,
0.0466264673,
-0.038652163,
-0.0079382807,
-0.0167131089,
-0.0247866604,
-0.0051415106,
-0.0227431618,
0.0073510939,
0.0842946172,
0.0363493413,
-0.0240331832,
-0.0032726214,
0.0701343194,
0.0163836461,
-0.0061362563,
-0.0155391842,
0.0000958327,
-0.0391484611,
0.0162842497,
-0.0375798419,
-0.0264308825,
0.0827201977,
-0.0287806839,
-0.0134452721,
-0.0559530519,
0.0011415689,
0.0056315423,
0.0637779385,
0.0369199663,
-0.0061349659,
0.0330512635,
-0.0020246061,
-0.0784787908,
-0.0301222056,
0.0478323475,
-0.0424401388,
0.0890002623,
-0.0169801209,
0.0230855625,
0.007464001,
-0.0295998529,
-0.0757339448,
-0.0543499254,
-0.008433409,
0.0499418229,
-0.0356277041,
-0.0260875467,
-0.031849578,
-0.029120354,
0.0532005094,
0.033063516,
-0.0327193663,
0.0074031428,
-0.0343658924,
0.0462119281,
0.080312103,
-0.0177506674,
0.0564822145,
-0.0593029447,
0.0043112221,
0.0344885886,
0.0079573095,
0.0412257388,
0.0101460274,
-0.0132830702,
0.0304209124,
-0.0279450342,
0.0219573472,
0.0413879715,
-0.0048780842,
-0.0195079278,
-0.014999616,
0.035091415,
0.0292133857,
0.0175474454,
0.0353322737,
-0.0434555151,
0.0105643617,
0.0262959488,
0.013039181,
-0.0610808022,
-0.0097747548,
0.0229899846,
-0.0039650891,
0.0013674384,
-0.0223294906,
-0.0108169131,
-0.1378964633,
-0.0140216714,
0.018644264,
-0.0692069754,
-0.0402971618,
-0.0211455543,
0.0098362705,
-0.0186999906,
0.0578990728,
0.0275126379,
0.0378570296,
0.0272236727,
0.0130524235,
0.0226142202,
-0.0069594048,
0.0066837473,
-0.0252461582,
0.0558820926,
0.1056803986,
0.0200608671,
-0.0293410271,
-0.0635094941,
0.0234528501,
0.0221617725,
-0.0793040395,
0.0501030162,
0.0233049374,
0.0137951653,
-0.0306260437,
0.0231101681,
0.0369681343,
-0.024476137,
0.018208459,
0.0301165897,
0.046552714,
-0.0273246039,
-0.0058572241,
-0.0104520079,
0.0113753257,
0.015351153,
0.0593468435,
0.0323994234,
-0.0209214315,
-0.0275070593,
-0.0818760172,
-0.0331522264,
-0.044818949,
-0.030170694,
-0.0062044319,
0.0689862892,
-0.0311437119,
-0.0665458217,
-0.0276470408,
-0.01898822,
0.0262782052,
-0.0001191825,
-0.0269927196,
0.0200429112,
-0.0138019323,
-0.0265282653,
-0.0137094278,
-0.0241101496,
0.0495927408,
-0.0303502437,
0.0202816799,
-0.0010947858,
-0.0277018417,
-0.0321947448,
0.0008620122,
-0.0918942466,
-0.0982966572,
0.0072248084,
0.0440282933,
0.0223766137,
0.0119464444,
-0.0370074585,
-0.0183363799,
0.0076504112,
0.0106715076,
-0.0296505783,
0.0028238257,
0.0316259786,
-0.0272045154,
0.0082777394,
0.0364485681,
-0.0237443727,
0.0014775813,
0.0678041801,
0.0193371065,
-0.0771476626,
-0.0369343199,
0.0382648669,
0.0259430241,
0.03580283,
0.0292113665,
0.0174922571,
0.0143414829,
0.0047951825,
-0.0221250542,
-0.0140465433,
-0.0113484869,
-0.0210379567,
-0.0092925737,
0.0134745389,
0.0198930074,
-0.0361460857,
0.0238577817,
0.0555907078,
0.0388076305,
-0.0149193704,
0.0154662328,
0.0966770202,
-0.0007974583,
-0.0048752436,
0.0001660989,
0.0467218868,
-0.002218816,
0.0423302688,
0.0128939776,
0.0603533536,
0.0092484094,
0.0152948722,
-0.0118116932,
0.0026060988,
-0.0672456697,
-0.0696967617,
0.0047800564,
0.0179960057,
0.0013334961,
-0.0003154573,
-0.0171396527,
-0.0332268588,
-0.0053586718,
-0.0327493288,
-0.0220975857,
0.014310508,
-0.0332276709,
0.039322976,
0.0228566565,
-0.0010888188,
-0.013774029,
0.0321713537,
-0.0112274308,
0.0626486689,
0.022871796,
0.0028724296,
-0.0245445222,
-0.0446458124,
0.0418975316,
-0.0152747417,
-0.0419859923,
0.0103290491,
-0.0545830354,
-0.0831338093,
-0.0471529178,
0.0482704528,
-0.0086793788,
0.0003453614,
0.012631489,
0.0320481323,
-0.0215369835,
0.0524060167,
-0.0412927642,
0.0610164069,
-0.0194467418,
-0.0525175184,
-0.0311168917,
-5.839492634e-33,
-0.0269102696,
-0.024411615,
-0.0039783046,
-0.0237686988,
0.0377158672,
-0.0407996736,
-0.0336493105,
0.0166212115,
-0.0458069146,
-0.001412304,
-0.0156463012,
0.01277625,
-0.0172112416,
0.0350498073,
-0.0427208394,
-0.048662737,
0.0239118114,
-0.0230856203,
-0.0342981704,
-0.0219811033,
0.0425904095,
-0.0173317511,
0.0564127006,
-0.0232079588,
0.085378319,
0.0052579432,
-0.0379499942,
0.0063642729,
-0.0843132883,
0.0408729389,
-0.006448599,
0.0126535622,
-0.0297113918,
-0.0255099572,
-0.0200192835,
0.0258181151,
-0.0165830348,
-0.0591290072,
0.0503537655,
0.0217034947,
-0.0256080162,
-0.0164513905,
0.0345806219,
-0.0322542414,
-0.0368721187,
0.004976131,
-0.0078234347,
-0.012904603,
-0.0020263239,
0.0554761961,
-0.0305180326,
0.0070206961,
0.0007264783,
-0.0365201905,
-0.0383467972,
0.008811824,
0.0165979192,
-0.0460939743,
-0.0562623553,
0.0401423201,
0.0335732065,
0.0208993573,
0.0308033358,
-0.0081742043,
0.0127100376,
0.0488573872,
0.0118365558,
-0.0249466002,
-0.0180616379,
0.0017280394,
0.0096099414,
-0.0008409424,
0.0967282429,
0.0717310235,
0.0482041128,
0.0112524321,
-0.0365929045,
0.0258062929,
0.053959284,
0.0012449882,
0.0059101447,
-0.0355998464,
-0.0512612797,
0.0115540596,
-0.0325833522,
-0.0580895357,
-0.0472404808,
-0.0136691937,
-0.0051275445,
-0.0021511326,
0.0189162903,
-0.0218475237,
0.0067286454,
-0.0631638095,
-0.0016041603,
0.0365825817,
0.0119122965,
-0.0212306269,
0.0183955375,
0.0190076269,
-0.0135925133,
0.0241981577,
-0.0320297815,
-0.0245359614,
0.0062145414,
0.0273104068,
0.0036914407,
0.0379817635,
-0.0694144964,
-0.0164422244,
-0.0096773161,
0.0329713859,
0.0252862778,
0.0518445075,
0.0497645251,
-0.0061950432,
-0.0043611475,
-0.0019684108,
-0.0287640151,
-0.0314050131,
-0.0201848075,
0.0363802873,
-0.0431836061,
0.0312923416,
-0.0073292921,
-0.027966544,
-0.0083849886,
0.0521982014,
0.0186947193,
-0.0603441782,
0.0162650738,
-0.035808716,
2.703e-7,
0.0307759829,
0.0114985323,
0.0355710611,
-0.0039031338,
0.0200797915,
0.0819293112,
-0.0201786496,
0.0812521875,
-0.0265028216,
-0.0334873162,
-0.0247567501,
-0.0346858203,
0.0143617466,
-0.0031623829,
-0.0204343181,
0.0222716313,
-0.0625651553,
0.0269375332,
0.001127708,
0.0102292858,
-0.0127902459,
0.1152096242,
0.04013253,
0.0155570973,
-0.0090360874,
-0.042776823,
0.0302238353,
0.0152803566,
-0.026927853,
-0.0060713794,
0.0251170397,
-0.0411591679,
0.0102687487,
0.0087626781,
-0.0035319466,
0.0355833694,
-0.0061278674,
0.0646800101,
0.0278584696,
-0.0255309176,
-0.0614975803,
-0.0359276123,
-0.0184454098,
-0.0375322923,
0.0581264831,
-0.0265568737,
-0.0245270655,
-0.0414329953,
0.0027585295,
0.012879258,
0.0383360796,
0.0116908867,
-0.0060795089,
-0.0138264801,
0.0258035362,
0.0091247242,
0.0464632809,
-0.0450456627,
-0.0164206475,
-0.0082759513,
-0.0171894766,
-0.0372331701,
-0.0104751652,
0.041663792,
0.0266736075,
-0.0461014286,
-0.0174689684,
2.660050273e-34,
0.0470760241,
-0.0262041297,
0.0106945513,
-0.0191208385,
0.0228790529,
-0.0046800207,
0.027838219,
0.0084283249,
0.0813944936,
-0.0288727526,
-0.0361162201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04978v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04978v2 | On the steerability of large language models toward data-driven personas | 2023-11-08T19:01:13 | 2024-04-02T18:29:52 | Junyi Li, Ninareh Mehrabi, Charith Peris, Palash Goyal, Kai-Wei Chang, Aram Galstyan, Richard Zemel, Rahul Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are known to generate biased responses where the
opinions of certain groups and populations are underrepresented. Here, we
present a novel approach to achieve controllable generation of specific
viewpoints using LLMs, that can be leveraged to produce multiple perspectives
and to reflect the diverse opinions. Moving beyond the traditional reliance on
demographics like age, gender, or party affiliation, we introduce a data-driven
notion of persona grounded in collaborative filtering, which is defined as
either a single individual or a cohort of individuals manifesting similar views
across specific inquiries. As individuals in the same demographic group may
have different personas, our data-driven persona definition allows for a more
nuanced understanding of different (latent) social groups present in the
population. In addition to this, we also explore an efficient method to steer
LLMs toward the personas that we define. We show that our data-driven personas
significantly enhance model steerability, with improvements of between
$57\%-77\%$ over our best performing baselines. | [
0.0511898696,
0.0930889472,
-0.0165743306,
0.0369548388,
-0.0028842883,
-0.0107542537,
0.0547785647,
-0.0356395319,
0.0085755251,
-0.0340287462,
-0.0308336206,
-0.0629078448,
-0.022054391,
0.0376612023,
0.0201217905,
-0.0759591237,
0.0348122567,
-0.0049653682,
0.0449955575,
-0.0463971533,
0.0304417405,
0.052330371,
0.0187798701,
0.0629037321,
0.0132284341,
-0.052691035,
0.0539951771,
-0.0093227224,
0.0336857028,
0.0287282933,
0.0429065935,
0.0398959331,
-0.0057037086,
0.0357446857,
0.0000021041,
-0.0258176588,
-0.0190572236,
-0.0115377018,
0.0140975732,
-0.0218372308,
0.0698455647,
0.0534989797,
0.0144297993,
0.0328514203,
-0.0573812053,
-0.0090406733,
0.0116121043,
0.0185738057,
0.0754967332,
0.0304928999,
-0.0119686089,
-0.0529620983,
-0.0584299788,
-0.0359489955,
-0.0163236298,
0.0001927115,
0.0270093344,
-0.0401475653,
-0.0432769544,
0.0108081084,
-0.0160526447,
0.0082588643,
-0.0119304564,
-0.0454858765,
0.0504907742,
0.0018852914,
-0.0124923363,
-0.0366009586,
0.0197136234,
0.0825316608,
0.025916623,
-0.0209953003,
-0.0139607023,
-0.0100646224,
0.0086409664,
0.0474594459,
-0.0269186627,
0.0172498748,
-0.0137150716,
0.0294239242,
-0.0032760149,
0.0067397268,
0.0367693976,
0.0212144796,
-0.0452108495,
0.0892354399,
0.0190601815,
0.0174883846,
-0.0153722344,
0.0146089466,
0.0304067209,
-0.0455127619,
0.0270488672,
-0.0087168617,
-0.0411098376,
0.0324927606,
-0.0264727566,
0.0333594494,
0.0111771151,
-0.04409118,
0.0078162905,
0.0117229763,
0.0345200188,
0.0500886999,
0.0330203101,
-0.0252042431,
-0.0276572797,
-0.016126385,
0.015043484,
-0.0436338671,
-0.0393178798,
-0.0221954808,
0.0159329567,
0.0085067879,
-0.0075492314,
0.0159503948,
-0.0319044739,
0.0205872077,
-0.0602657907,
-0.0014456399,
-0.0010865087,
0.0394950584,
-0.0044300421,
-0.02784984,
-0.0530624539,
0.0674032122,
-0.0493615828,
0.0031958728,
-0.016690528,
-0.039150849,
0.0549239218,
0.017781714,
-0.0155204432,
-0.0142007135,
-0.0143943736,
0.0117573449,
-0.0011424519,
-0.0023655335,
-0.004615102,
-0.0382002033,
-0.0222699121,
-0.0582067668,
-0.0145686846,
-0.0802256092,
0.0569237545,
0.0431580283,
0.0423367247,
-0.07121557,
-0.0037932608,
0.0284169987,
-0.0417895876,
0.0625099614,
0.0283535589,
0.0246987324,
0.0546343252,
0.0328048021,
0.017416263,
0.0825973228,
0.0099117635,
-0.0080419146,
0.0442567319,
0.0015708359,
0.0058158231,
0.0228216071,
-0.0113567691,
0.0354531966,
-0.0398013033,
0.0225847568,
-0.0190627631,
-0.0214409139,
0.0377230793,
0.0599859096,
-0.0200814903,
-0.029353071,
0.0863442644,
0.0238504708,
-0.0122289406,
0.0588752925,
0.0363323614,
0.0265802611,
-0.0120957391,
0.0001165676,
-0.0187433865,
0.0277392529,
0.0284713469,
-0.0729278848,
0.0363055058,
0.048873134,
-0.0341457203,
-0.0252844952,
0.0244614538,
0.0204189513,
0.0203422513,
0.0480477437,
0.0006424643,
-0.0167484824,
0.018670775,
0.0652144849,
0.053007789,
-0.0577103421,
0.0126118269,
-0.0355246067,
0.043166399,
0.0596545078,
0.0267636478,
-0.0160279348,
-0.0339184329,
-0.0137468092,
0.0117425481,
0.0364687629,
0.1022993401,
-0.044673413,
-0.0119286077,
-0.0379619412,
-0.0252485853,
0.0291616339,
-0.0074973828,
0.0580385178,
0.0390355587,
-0.0005480949,
-0.0087258397,
-0.000859616,
-0.0175513942,
-0.0112323258,
-0.0348214582,
0.0137300352,
0.0227169599,
0.0225375965,
0.0366497859,
0.0402476117,
0.0172780212,
-0.0068527698,
-0.0125685055,
-0.0105619254,
0.0002980426,
0.0045112274,
-0.0475301296,
0.0101577668,
0.0091756964,
-0.071945101,
-0.0397630446,
0.0016651544,
0.0088602593,
-0.0174449533,
0.0454468951,
-0.014006325,
0.0144182034,
0.0031095447,
0.0052674059,
-0.036510393,
0.0051886044,
-0.0639215782,
0.0546844415,
0.0115348082,
-0.006079895,
0.0364372618,
-0.0076704025,
-0.0192172006,
-0.0300691146,
-0.0197817553,
0.0172698069,
0.0502659641,
-0.0099794492,
0.063696757,
-0.0383352973,
-0.0436145738,
-0.0377240442,
-0.0511078276,
-0.0167380739,
-0.0167320371,
-0.0058521479,
0.0257384647,
-0.0043094191,
-0.0071206628,
-0.003521825,
-0.0925390348,
0.0111096622,
-0.0046973191,
0.0084244581,
0.0084206462,
-0.0022527368,
-0.0054986728,
-0.0385431685,
-0.0202349667,
-0.0061461562,
0.0430529341,
0.0082161808,
-0.0184049271,
-0.0373741537,
-0.0404372476,
-0.0809163377,
0.0091752969,
-0.028162647,
0.0037089137,
0.0296565238,
0.0025789896,
0.0640092939,
0.0239661746,
0.0277464502,
0.0244363677,
0.0526555181,
0.0082176365,
-0.0572242253,
-0.0142938122,
-0.0425558984,
0.0386451371,
-0.0238028485,
-0.0597312748,
0.0138210766,
0.0224921443,
0.0338053256,
-0.0250634402,
-0.0772771165,
0.0722415075,
-0.0283533931,
-0.0467043184,
0.0002146583,
-0.0204969794,
0.0074137226,
0.0065867561,
-0.0200090837,
-0.0248800721,
0.0612153336,
0.0132137928,
0.0296352543,
-0.0046578865,
-0.0048686936,
-0.0641435608,
0.0151040414,
0.0128131527,
0.0363181233,
-0.0185722355,
-0.0074159787,
-0.0575398207,
-0.0039143208,
0.0335581414,
-0.0479427017,
0.0981905237,
-0.0281286798,
-0.0097228549,
0.0414099917,
-0.0498947948,
-0.0462974161,
-0.0594732873,
-0.0173469987,
0.0029969888,
0.0642128512,
-0.0369302407,
-0.0364019945,
-0.0025826043,
0.0278100464,
-0.020192543,
-0.0349562764,
-0.0098307868,
-0.0112193832,
-0.0037841182,
0.0424198918,
-0.0149628855,
0.0487455763,
-0.0392309725,
0.0462092347,
0.046481479,
0.009731886,
-0.0275274497,
-0.0148161147,
-0.0256410725,
0.0631605387,
-0.0178790726,
-0.0493284203,
-0.0048412448,
0.0560501106,
-0.0280614793,
-0.000841565,
0.0998525694,
0.0280136801,
-0.1070298702,
-0.0282354522,
-0.0129598547,
0.0404827185,
0.0488736667,
0.0288600381,
-0.0342944339,
0.0176878646,
-0.0057374025,
0.0480859466,
-0.0263572149,
-0.0249801558,
-0.0428563096,
-0.1096232682,
0.0387257263,
0.0056901043,
0.0105479276,
0.0027836955,
-0.0361810215,
0.033947628,
-0.0069861831,
0.0187396891,
-0.0153933708,
0.0068237013,
0.0123897633,
-0.0033938931,
-0.0524652265,
-0.0256925952,
0.0262456816,
-0.0224343054,
0.060406372,
0.0378777385,
0.0644105077,
0.0204195008,
-0.0184619296,
-0.004574751,
-0.0086380839,
-0.0163360015,
-0.0061470089,
0.0444558226,
-0.0269368719,
-0.0044457559,
-0.0538102165,
0.0424087457,
0.0104753328,
0.0020275956,
-0.0060433904,
0.0350650325,
-0.0150841745,
-0.0326687507,
-0.028301293,
0.0135471364,
0.022931084,
0.0811324865,
0.029229654,
-0.0547175221,
0.0166490953,
-0.0496739969,
0.0001659834,
-0.0140111037,
-0.0668104813,
0.004778923,
-0.0139603624,
-0.0369862765,
-0.0314952508,
-0.0301088821,
0.039273683,
0.0158961881,
0.0212612059,
0.0045413096,
0.0457730666,
-0.0411502272,
0.0027754162,
0.0134295309,
-0.0715078264,
0.0410460867,
-0.0727295056,
-0.0535597317,
0.0043935636,
-0.0519853905,
-0.007092631,
-0.0025613396,
-0.0334782116,
-0.0778060928,
0.0198255684,
0.0227653515,
0.0223424621,
0.0476310737,
-0.0239059962,
-0.1043362543,
0.0512780435,
0.0077720648,
-0.00181732,
-0.0145589365,
-0.0222456604,
0.0445390381,
-0.0071004811,
0.0589735843,
-0.0242921151,
0.0252664685,
0.0367024057,
-0.0295782108,
-0.069895938,
-0.0601336285,
0.0157173909,
-0.0046470761,
0.0119809499,
-0.0056621972,
0.0150069445,
-0.0506048724,
-0.0418960154,
-0.0538969599,
-0.0530723892,
-0.00845253,
-0.0133765843,
0.0317478254,
-0.0396163985,
-0.0140020493,
0.0032913603,
-0.0347432233,
0.0324416235,
-0.0815134048,
0.0489868149,
-0.0032488673,
-0.0168014783,
0.0381724797,
0.00607942,
0.0169765409,
0.0233810972,
-0.023523001,
0.0184069481,
0.0164449736,
0.057733912,
-0.0016784114,
-0.0085650096,
-0.0185628161,
0.0049021733,
-0.0565589182,
-0.072235249,
0.0162133407,
0.0443996936,
0.0120240394,
0.0057413434,
0.0623480976,
-0.0016509432,
-0.0316552259,
-0.0065128091,
-0.0034003071,
0.0412778445,
-0.0200859234,
0.0326760449,
0.0079264957,
-0.0118297888,
-0.0103053991,
0.0707030296,
0.0019821695,
0.0020352926,
-0.014459339,
-0.0513399653,
-0.040720731,
-0.0196923502,
0.0249012839,
0.0171351749,
-0.022865925,
-0.0031600986,
-0.0655901954,
-0.0460782945,
-0.0161380228,
-0.0109553402,
-0.0015709355,
-0.0262584258,
0.0173200108,
0.0587849058,
-0.0008075283,
-0.0063978471,
-0.0894055367,
0.04253041,
-0.0268242899,
0.0027786442,
0.0016952517,
-6.757623884e-33,
-0.0185856484,
-0.0347326547,
-0.0008873827,
-0.0382704884,
-0.0259664897,
-0.0133003462,
-0.0221111439,
0.0265713036,
-0.0007657195,
0.0270351935,
-0.0068039363,
0.0336425789,
0.0080712568,
0.0108467992,
-0.0012513057,
-0.0092134988,
0.0875984952,
0.023519842,
-0.0294028912,
0.0407476947,
0.0303666014,
0.0042935433,
-0.0025451751,
-0.0648481995,
0.0633147433,
-0.003874677,
-0.0067502051,
0.0188456252,
-0.0098261293,
0.057113979,
-0.0080799907,
0.0616423525,
0.02590538,
-0.0493819304,
-0.0255417153,
0.0557688773,
-0.0616539605,
-0.0105817057,
0.026662806,
0.0205980074,
-0.006412325,
-0.0428035818,
0.0307130497,
0.0109591391,
-0.0037121156,
-0.0139156254,
0.0565068349,
-0.0125773475,
0.027917074,
-0.0198745225,
-0.0286743008,
0.0210524201,
-0.0092208711,
0.018756073,
-0.0023987442,
0.0427993201,
-0.003195496,
0.053740859,
-0.0683162659,
0.0517621823,
-0.0277665332,
-0.0010310088,
0.0366970152,
0.0352386162,
-0.0039987531,
0.0502208211,
0.0238063168,
0.0294193178,
-0.0496321507,
-0.050791163,
-0.0133906621,
0.0171046071,
0.0149987387,
0.0740104318,
-0.0240433197,
-0.027570527,
-0.0320606269,
-0.000861122,
0.0303084236,
-0.0317294411,
0.0631488338,
-0.0082043791,
-0.0490537994,
-0.0387979411,
-0.0446808785,
-0.0497288443,
-0.0411752611,
0.0002442933,
0.0047174138,
0.0142754298,
-0.0680963099,
-0.0206251778,
0.0075572254,
-0.0549124479,
-0.0452715196,
0.0211819969,
-0.0432149731,
-0.0163998436,
0.0298957713,
0.0130089344,
-0.0496585108,
0.020984482,
-0.0060169683,
-0.0357046872,
-0.020508077,
0.0186600033,
-0.0031793832,
0.0070085321,
-0.0774326026,
-0.0191349927,
-0.0222201124,
0.0197297763,
-0.0094107734,
0.0735026076,
0.0450675301,
0.0259023309,
0.0007908857,
0.0225712769,
0.043460805,
0.0112007046,
0.0140176667,
-0.0149939051,
-0.0341284573,
0.0298646968,
-0.0558833592,
-0.0218166206,
-0.0091932416,
-0.0091639357,
0.0669088066,
-0.0376685858,
-0.0360035039,
-0.0376860723,
2.628e-7,
0.0438687131,
0.0586294346,
-0.0436099283,
0.0497687645,
0.0416759253,
0.0329438671,
0.035219308,
0.0084432596,
0.0254738983,
-0.041330453,
-0.0312572196,
0.0391553119,
0.0313116536,
0.0509938598,
-0.0768298358,
0.0155837508,
-0.0118143624,
0.0384149477,
-0.0390363708,
-0.0172779448,
0.0342043266,
0.065374352,
0.0356063582,
-0.0169382878,
-0.0165567808,
0.0281216893,
0.0600674786,
-0.0236170571,
-0.0454075709,
0.0424932241,
0.0458376445,
-0.0231744498,
0.0274166521,
0.0498671867,
-0.0106789339,
0.0127567416,
-0.0166932493,
0.0532315634,
0.0172011647,
-0.0171235483,
-0.0131294969,
0.0040543699,
-0.0017209183,
-0.0722910464,
0.0812115669,
-0.0079306606,
-0.0285675302,
-0.0347107612,
-0.0148445303,
-0.007668688,
0.0362217836,
-0.0325882286,
-0.0315489024,
0.0138624841,
0.0155159682,
-0.0216888636,
-0.0181745533,
-0.052908916,
-0.0165392421,
-0.0741094723,
-0.0565620214,
-0.0584311858,
-0.0030938545,
0.0227070414,
-0.018899912,
-0.006740028,
0.0459717326,
2.324427351e-34,
0.0141070085,
0.0464536138,
0.0016749339,
-0.07488022,
0.048352357,
-0.0055648009,
-0.0420295969,
-0.0093034049,
0.0543582737,
-0.0607928522,
-0.0154023692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04902v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04902v2 | Beyond Size: How Gradients Shape Pruning Decisions in Large Language Models | 2023-11-08T18:59:54 | 2024-04-08T22:42:49 | Rocktim Jyoti Das, Mingjie Sun, Liqun Ma, Zhiqiang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) with billions of parameters are prime targets
for network pruning, removing some model weights without hurting performance.
Prior approaches such as magnitude pruning, SparseGPT, and Wanda, either
concentrated solely on weights or integrated weights with activations for
sparsity. However, they overlooked the informative gradients derived from
pretrained LLMs. In this paper, we present a novel sparsity-centric pruning
method for pretrained LLMs, termed Gradient-based Language Model Pruner
(GBLM-Pruner). GBLM-Pruner leverages the first-order term of the Taylor
expansion, operating in a training-free manner by harnessing properly
normalized gradients from a few calibration samples to determine the pruning
metric, and substantially outperforms competitive counterparts like SparseGPT
and Wanda in multiple benchmarks. Intriguingly, by incorporating gradients,
unstructured pruning with our method tends to reveal some structural patterns,
which mirrors the geometric interdependence inherent in the LLMs' parameter
structure. Additionally, GBLM-Pruner functions without any subsequent
retraining or weight updates to maintain its simplicity as other counterparts.
Extensive evaluations on LLaMA-1 and LLaMA-2 across various benchmarks show
that GBLM-Pruner surpasses magnitude pruning, Wanda and SparseGPT by
significant margins. We further extend our approach on Vision Transformer. Our
code and models are available at https://github.com/VILA-Lab/GBLM-Pruner. | [
-0.011923844,
0.0671077147,
0.0025146278,
0.0605049171,
-0.0061388896,
-0.0001018024,
0.0013416569,
0.0472730026,
-0.0384736694,
0.0125582758,
-0.0583974607,
-0.0404544882,
0.0304630753,
-0.023973234,
0.0238591824,
-0.0437416397,
0.0176333971,
-0.0428698212,
-0.0212713424,
-0.0063921046,
0.0156776346,
0.0187478792,
0.0264906399,
0.0484494604,
0.0039653699,
-0.0122372452,
0.0186719578,
0.0103736846,
0.0078882929,
0.0230511688,
0.0155215319,
0.0342802927,
0.0078056781,
0.0329532027,
0.0000022044,
-0.0088508409,
0.0260133073,
-0.0049125408,
-0.0282058008,
0.0687685832,
0.0447326936,
-0.0096803587,
-0.0078663565,
0.003070619,
-0.0299146567,
-0.0535285361,
0.033299733,
0.038665399,
0.0332226381,
0.0813980028,
0.0008611705,
-0.0659432784,
0.0072073545,
-0.0507982746,
-0.018040752,
-0.0361488163,
0.0092397546,
-0.0464758202,
-0.0551239848,
-0.0194505379,
-0.0263699349,
0.0308385827,
0.0286791138,
0.0215013456,
-0.0185301919,
0.0513453595,
-0.0105389412,
-0.0262993611,
0.0297938175,
0.0713727251,
-0.0652800202,
-0.0356988162,
0.0128546972,
-0.017789565,
-0.0217337925,
-0.0450265519,
-0.0449548662,
0.0021383772,
0.0353528894,
0.0408091061,
-0.0553451106,
-0.0376710407,
0.0630846545,
0.0100831045,
-0.0219833311,
0.0357218012,
0.0190080125,
0.0237275381,
-0.0194115974,
-0.0073003634,
-0.0079361955,
-0.0474610329,
0.0006184577,
0.0407108106,
-0.0059422608,
-0.0103912586,
-0.0350002423,
-0.00322965,
-0.0003861659,
0.0005776082,
0.0676819608,
0.0347848833,
0.0147907706,
0.0374499261,
-0.0307716466,
0.0537263043,
0.0047557186,
0.0202986989,
-0.0529578477,
-0.015687583,
0.0123722935,
-0.0017287991,
-0.0216940846,
0.0284214634,
-0.0190207995,
-0.0233384427,
-0.0445365347,
-0.0166970193,
-0.0082335537,
-0.0375438631,
0.0416010767,
0.0122149084,
-0.0230541471,
-0.0265543554,
-0.0086712595,
0.0404263102,
-0.009373825,
0.0190828592,
-0.0153907016,
-0.0459795706,
-0.0334033407,
0.0536430776,
0.0034994988,
-0.0154386256,
0.0407929271,
0.0697252005,
-0.0144931125,
-0.0530804247,
-0.053958755,
0.0072333026,
0.0044917953,
-0.0760644674,
0.0027327409,
-0.0789115578,
0.0232037716,
-0.0417981483,
0.009034222,
-0.0953071192,
-0.004781018,
0.026987657,
-0.0356593542,
0.0406113751,
0.0055965027,
0.0188552178,
0.0167966895,
-0.0014780358,
0.0383760072,
0.0782441199,
0.0445029922,
0.0586241446,
0.0099871205,
-0.0194701273,
-0.0135757271,
0.0509460568,
0.0382087044,
0.0020794198,
-0.0463390835,
-0.0299333055,
-0.0135934372,
0.0151260355,
0.0778686106,
0.0823691487,
-0.0672361255,
-0.055631917,
0.0770644918,
0.0497140326,
0.0509006791,
0.0474967062,
0.0742105469,
-0.0228530541,
0.0130178109,
0.0095684687,
-0.0459544882,
0.0006343717,
-0.0189324301,
-0.0069418987,
-0.0108059989,
0.0749832168,
-0.0579184406,
-0.037392132,
-0.0110193109,
-0.032777179,
-0.0014297443,
0.0279252306,
0.0325989053,
0.0159748457,
-0.036748752,
0.082712777,
0.0153299626,
-0.0483261496,
-0.00011436,
-0.053655386,
-0.0072927265,
0.009901192,
0.0181160141,
0.0006191949,
-0.0274096746,
0.0389912352,
0.0210371464,
-0.023504002,
0.0346573144,
-0.0099472366,
0.0384922363,
-0.0839914456,
0.0106080044,
0.0069642658,
0.0203301143,
0.000237665,
0.0269918088,
0.0295600612,
0.0385965221,
-0.0392144099,
-0.0285491198,
0.0472003818,
-0.0232518017,
-0.0248269495,
0.0270456746,
-0.0106049133,
-0.0065436773,
-0.0262975208,
-0.0097945686,
-0.0092551475,
0.0460497215,
-0.0401488282,
0.0270619746,
-0.0331326984,
-0.0495961271,
-0.0340027884,
0.0639324039,
-0.0016915523,
0.0355826393,
0.0778775513,
-0.0456194282,
-0.0251220651,
0.0086648911,
-0.0226599891,
0.0166453086,
-0.0552879423,
0.0168118887,
-0.0220611803,
0.0739102587,
0.0058241705,
0.012156385,
-0.0197672974,
-0.0010810026,
0.022015674,
-0.0283215381,
-0.0035611296,
-0.0580227226,
-0.0458851345,
0.0098603042,
-0.0033215303,
0.0236777589,
-0.0234683324,
0.0232329071,
0.0078209424,
-0.0141051775,
-0.0713939592,
0.0238153879,
-0.0464368761,
0.0342476815,
0.0195507128,
0.0411822572,
-0.0040155295,
-0.0155211184,
0.0267965309,
0.0408662222,
0.0119873025,
0.017811751,
0.0104837744,
-0.0198513437,
-0.0327863209,
-0.0136946309,
-0.0413434803,
0.0329586901,
0.0704702809,
-0.0278680027,
-0.0065138522,
-0.0437591374,
0.0519801974,
-0.038385231,
0.0303853489,
-0.0140609173,
-0.0499129519,
-0.0213431232,
-0.0061158058,
0.020626178,
0.0628635511,
-0.0098534739,
0.0493263379,
0.0783980042,
0.0268887579,
-0.0111792479,
0.0030823234,
-0.0342169926,
-0.0178889427,
-0.0606520809,
-0.0346536078,
-0.0068120477,
0.0828823,
-0.0179707557,
-0.0041054212,
-0.0516345389,
-0.004256953,
-0.0079859877,
-0.0184224993,
-0.0353080817,
0.0201457422,
-0.0340053886,
0.013123245,
0.0014543119,
-0.0620545149,
0.0151728578,
-0.0674626976,
-0.0157017075,
0.0062867864,
-0.0296868365,
-0.0430518463,
0.0356309563,
0.0544360876,
0.0121273762,
-0.0151664177,
0.0143364659,
-0.0627926365,
-0.0058013573,
0.0045713405,
-0.0144707207,
0.0309252683,
-0.0499756224,
0.0186407696,
-0.0257118009,
-0.0085365325,
-0.0048076482,
-0.0082829585,
-0.013004276,
0.0358024873,
0.0248247292,
-0.0334253423,
-0.0117398715,
0.015871264,
0.0060554389,
0.066180177,
0.007706298,
0.0293454845,
-0.0054740869,
0.0351398103,
0.0621404797,
0.0252367985,
0.0602462701,
-0.0367045924,
0.0042742062,
0.0508268289,
0.0285481121,
0.0038488782,
-0.0655072033,
-0.0213094987,
0.0133949826,
0.0008705833,
-0.0021884823,
0.0107256826,
0.0707783997,
-0.0471924469,
0.0021218287,
0.0779474527,
-0.0075604636,
-0.0695350766,
0.0137997139,
0.0522052944,
0.0578696802,
0.0202171616,
0.0359587669,
-0.0369258597,
-0.0196431503,
0.0092861652,
-0.0012586172,
0.0325198434,
-0.0296487808,
-0.0181763675,
-0.089106366,
0.0246142279,
-0.0154269906,
-0.0030125575,
0.0137326289,
-0.0215283558,
0.0180544052,
-0.0358420014,
0.0175579842,
0.0107720606,
-0.0333519205,
-0.0050135572,
0.0056813681,
-0.0360109694,
-0.049019102,
0.0213954691,
-0.0029285704,
0.0090125045,
0.007437428,
0.0272168443,
-0.0049769939,
-0.0516558215,
0.0760548934,
-0.0251295958,
-0.0217989367,
-0.0145025579,
0.049914442,
0.0341888331,
-0.0175744593,
0.0380926169,
0.0091919862,
-0.0328946821,
0.002980296,
-0.0148409568,
0.0554927774,
-0.0020501635,
-0.0579857603,
0.0079300283,
-0.0277942717,
-0.0436244458,
0.0505571961,
0.0518607125,
-0.0163847208,
-0.0469545387,
-0.0120618567,
-0.02609987,
-0.0280206073,
-0.058401309,
0.00518644,
0.0225350242,
-0.0548207909,
-0.0363760181,
0.0022471033,
0.0259092506,
0.0060578259,
-0.0337417498,
-0.0328042507,
-0.0125496248,
0.0204144958,
-0.0310705099,
0.0361027457,
-0.0370893255,
0.0198340416,
-0.0494115539,
0.0254786201,
0.0227131862,
0.0114787444,
-0.0298752338,
-0.015320153,
-0.1440686882,
-0.0530562103,
-0.0339817069,
0.0574830733,
0.0132139269,
0.033434134,
-0.0027739941,
-0.0551285483,
0.0373307951,
0.056495823,
-0.0035134132,
0.0798034295,
0.0223087836,
-0.0801113099,
-0.0023613675,
0.082251668,
-0.0093118036,
0.0251519158,
0.0228976794,
0.0327459201,
0.0029054887,
0.010375238,
-0.0246082265,
0.0120022492,
0.03492162,
-0.0152026005,
0.0052207978,
-0.0424880087,
0.0268695243,
0.0177085213,
0.0265778862,
-0.0584733225,
0.0088906381,
0.020777721,
0.0488263592,
-0.0045576696,
0.0086394046,
0.0283536166,
-0.0102081094,
-0.0379017666,
0.0276347324,
0.0280677024,
-0.0128959743,
0.0617581829,
0.0077053015,
-0.0003714409,
0.0119694415,
-0.0117438193,
-0.0053298092,
-0.041527044,
-0.0156171881,
0.0118774669,
0.0201502219,
-0.0882342309,
0.0415625386,
-0.0148686869,
-0.1015974805,
-0.044499442,
0.0402267203,
0.0430485122,
-0.0055515026,
0.0261338223,
-0.0079886708,
-0.0152242426,
-0.0478968136,
0.0093407324,
0.0010846226,
0.0066955448,
0.0325480402,
-0.0001620514,
-0.024890231,
0.0086898711,
0.0862962157,
0.0157476664,
0.0448531471,
0.0129705109,
-0.001164785,
-0.0227148701,
-0.0557927452,
-0.0233849809,
0.0060669482,
-0.0269310009,
-0.0063583176,
-0.0072355857,
-0.0885354429,
0.0105059026,
-0.0206922274,
-0.0106639788,
-0.0105210086,
0.0620316118,
0.0450808741,
0.0000699713,
0.0434984118,
-0.0042148479,
-0.0471113957,
-0.0230644681,
-0.0352534615,
-0.0029324151,
-6.550844142e-33,
0.0042227018,
0.0089274207,
0.0308564529,
-0.0013978364,
-0.0429156423,
0.0244304556,
-0.0326351374,
-0.0203926209,
-0.0450394824,
0.0252485573,
-0.0159483384,
0.0134888291,
0.000542131,
0.0353922322,
-0.0526240841,
-0.008237605,
0.0649628043,
-0.0119346259,
-0.0280602314,
0.0369638689,
0.0048557119,
0.0305536892,
0.0884518996,
-0.0131648267,
-0.0705456808,
0.014555118,
-0.0227687284,
0.0251333565,
0.0104652913,
0.0553962775,
-0.0499163009,
0.0501285978,
0.0098529588,
-0.0184324253,
-0.0102475099,
-0.0052805366,
-0.0664496347,
-0.0278398879,
0.0177205168,
0.0074068485,
-0.034324903,
-0.0237067286,
0.0721529275,
0.0128359916,
-0.0357546918,
-0.0285055172,
0.0297556259,
0.0025899687,
-0.0380072072,
-0.0217720345,
-0.0321248993,
0.0233750381,
0.0025541724,
-0.0383248217,
0.0329133458,
-0.018172469,
-0.0377760343,
0.0356003232,
-0.0433159061,
-0.0124567542,
0.0231929049,
0.071750477,
0.0525338538,
0.0320671573,
0.0110358782,
0.0490597188,
0.0159881059,
-0.0110424701,
-0.0265569743,
0.0099244388,
0.0716923997,
0.0159837026,
0.0400223769,
0.0123473667,
0.0210706666,
-0.0533172637,
-0.096147038,
-0.0173247159,
-0.0147588514,
0.0777670667,
0.0114804441,
0.0420658849,
0.0378877334,
-0.0140496427,
-0.0133232446,
-0.0436441228,
-0.0320463553,
-0.0063079344,
0.0123834023,
0.0407200195,
-0.0393848233,
0.0042416696,
0.0182405375,
-0.0588820018,
-0.0222758669,
0.038001854,
-0.0226250533,
0.0175199173,
0.0299587678,
0.0238555968,
-0.0490466245,
-0.0018013531,
-0.0111842677,
-0.011193715,
0.0242499169,
-0.0108760744,
0.0239513144,
0.0325945616,
-0.03865017,
-0.0201450437,
-0.0432492495,
0.0039673178,
0.0129633928,
0.0996426269,
0.0366067328,
0.0101887509,
-0.0108922124,
0.0552578494,
0.0247166641,
-0.0233420059,
-0.04178771,
0.0112774875,
0.0386089422,
0.0420814753,
-0.0539777353,
-0.0180817842,
-0.0233721416,
0.029778257,
0.0544683449,
-0.0631486624,
-0.0375568643,
0.0288676675,
2.764e-7,
0.0364514962,
-0.0039578388,
-0.0249317978,
0.0000815906,
0.0094590764,
-0.0023026622,
-0.0020693303,
-0.0090856012,
-0.0210545231,
-0.0090976367,
0.024228571,
0.0334948003,
0.0572435111,
0.0039460482,
-0.0960919708,
0.0491347015,
-0.0778628737,
-0.0284391176,
-0.0218199845,
-0.0605608113,
-0.0557806976,
0.0985249877,
0.0145885972,
-0.0355600454,
-0.0048234053,
-0.0261861123,
0.0394933335,
-0.0391387343,
0.0286700409,
0.0190503262,
0.0366332456,
-0.0079751927,
-0.013853889,
-0.0389788821,
0.0046237907,
0.0267876536,
0.0035445136,
0.0885215774,
-0.0265332423,
0.0081682308,
0.0113203907,
0.0153530426,
-0.021605378,
-0.0578365028,
0.0656604916,
-0.0043957694,
0.0052897367,
-0.0563146397,
0.0242986679,
-0.0174016207,
0.0235543158,
-0.0246753301,
-0.0006618961,
0.0444488302,
0.0193751846,
-0.0367526226,
-0.0378157757,
-0.0835260749,
0.0008976356,
0.0054914807,
-0.0637843162,
-0.0416286439,
-0.0636053234,
-0.0133588742,
0.041467078,
-0.0386222005,
0.0046864781,
2.60612424e-34,
0.0239563212,
-0.0188207831,
-0.0115564801,
0.0292774178,
0.0244931821,
-0.0104299653,
0.0085755019,
0.0130326571,
-0.0377285033,
-0.0788707137,
-0.0225824844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04900v1 | How Abstract Is Linguistic Generalization in Large Language Models? Experiments with Argument Structure | 2023-11-08T18:58:43 | 2023-11-08T18:58:43 | Michael Wilson, Jackson Petty, Robert Frank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models are typically evaluated on their success at predicting the
distribution of specific words in specific contexts. Yet linguistic knowledge
also encodes relationships between contexts, allowing inferences between word
distributions. We investigate the degree to which pre-trained Transformer-based
large language models (LLMs) represent such relationships, focusing on the
domain of argument structure. We find that LLMs perform well in generalizing
the distribution of a novel noun argument between related contexts that were
seen during pre-training (e.g., the active object and passive subject of the
verb spray), succeeding by making use of the semantically-organized structure
of the embedding space for word embeddings. However, LLMs fail at
generalizations between related contexts that have not been observed during
pre-training, but which instantiate more abstract, but well-attested structural
generalizations (e.g., between the active object and passive subject of an
arbitrary verb). Instead, in this case, LLMs show a bias to generalize based on
linear order. This finding points to a limitation with current models and
points to a reason for which their training is data-intensive.s reported here
are available at https://github.com/clay-lab/structural-alternations. | [
0.0475491583,
0.0610087253,
-0.0192421302,
0.0530195907,
0.0021870956,
0.0317279659,
-0.0392562039,
0.0116199562,
-0.0487831905,
-0.068355605,
-0.0092057604,
-0.0714292303,
-0.0144192828,
-0.0089912787,
0.0484938249,
-0.0398688652,
0.0251517538,
-0.0162298344,
0.0009060065,
-0.0039377385,
-0.0219281726,
-0.0187286157,
0.0103555107,
0.0195497181,
-0.011022469,
0.0086909626,
-0.0000752965,
-0.0233278014,
0.0143970614,
0.0035620953,
-0.0186294112,
0.0261357427,
0.0384818576,
0.0243780725,
0.0000017297,
-0.0662120134,
0.00903452,
-0.0003705276,
-0.002381959,
0.0440096483,
0.018186504,
-0.03896828,
-0.0084586907,
-0.0129991928,
-0.021082174,
-0.0688856915,
0.0676979199,
0.0744457617,
0.0176473539,
0.0717884377,
-0.0039930288,
-0.0808087587,
0.037767224,
-0.0326815583,
-0.0083034588,
-0.0061737415,
0.0405389816,
0.0084423935,
-0.031335067,
0.0394858867,
-0.0666969195,
0.0195480715,
0.0145294573,
0.0336140282,
-0.0058954223,
0.0474662259,
-0.0488773733,
-0.0386459604,
0.0225036573,
0.058704786,
-0.0246038716,
-0.0402110852,
-0.0117136156,
-0.0118153561,
-0.0035486706,
0.0562933013,
-0.0381643735,
0.0520498641,
0.0143795488,
0.0425549224,
0.0556615591,
-0.0126766618,
0.0439821817,
0.0214436539,
-0.079356432,
0.0529075749,
0.0301810354,
-0.0445965268,
0.019762747,
0.0140152602,
-0.0493535884,
-0.045617234,
-0.0207210016,
0.0114027727,
-0.0080864271,
0.0408488996,
0.0049151857,
-0.0148583725,
-0.0013110148,
-0.0607710034,
0.0599350259,
0.0036850017,
0.0062483307,
0.0430294052,
-0.0354370587,
0.0587697849,
-0.0521752387,
0.0331815109,
-0.0470451601,
-0.0210275147,
-0.0500755534,
-0.014528485,
-0.0197520666,
0.0358469039,
-0.0175758917,
-0.0232479144,
-0.0351499915,
0.0304989126,
0.0082973531,
-0.0308970436,
0.0285801161,
0.0297569986,
-0.0272162147,
-0.0050095324,
-0.0132097853,
-0.0184434261,
-0.0232006554,
0.0279692132,
-0.0358609371,
-0.0254760385,
-0.0077301362,
0.0037677384,
-0.0081991563,
-0.029153835,
-0.0160056129,
0.0448738076,
-0.0092514809,
-0.0368956737,
-0.015695218,
0.0222714674,
-0.0383285098,
-0.0252029784,
0.0420014001,
-0.0423568599,
0.0212931894,
0.0234051999,
0.013468801,
-0.0305624269,
0.005960091,
-0.0189267676,
-0.0797625333,
0.0521611199,
0.0602546893,
0.0201659761,
0.0138041992,
0.0104988152,
-0.0019543187,
0.0563723966,
0.0093480283,
0.0015800461,
0.0290160682,
-0.0319726728,
-0.012766676,
0.0365196988,
-0.0013377621,
0.026562864,
0.0037867655,
-0.0048700017,
-0.0217303056,
0.0212396868,
0.0238609891,
0.0612967424,
-0.0466357693,
-0.0347708836,
0.0374025181,
0.0384712406,
0.0135162631,
-0.0040633054,
0.0816234052,
-0.0235306434,
0.0127190314,
0.0353721268,
-0.0548418313,
-0.045858968,
-0.0190746412,
-0.006514756,
-0.0294580217,
0.0217685495,
-0.0423407033,
-0.0069606439,
-0.0388930514,
-0.0190855525,
0.0058357129,
-0.0384635665,
0.0687104613,
0.0642091036,
0.0049376171,
0.0703742653,
0.0572622195,
-0.0312266406,
-0.0218802746,
-0.0204467103,
0.0267942976,
-0.0323881432,
-0.001684459,
-0.0010316757,
-0.0049483567,
0.0277999118,
0.0364587903,
0.012957165,
0.0465390868,
-0.0130592147,
0.0226848703,
-0.0149920508,
0.0061705131,
-0.0230284669,
0.0378753506,
0.018035613,
0.0302525721,
-0.0179830231,
0.0296763144,
-0.0505153984,
-0.0090265414,
0.0600564145,
-0.0484413728,
-0.030733427,
-0.0121776545,
0.0065324111,
0.0491843745,
-0.0042731678,
-0.0128908958,
0.0259306692,
0.0499599874,
-0.0540046841,
-0.0341428034,
0.0475107208,
-0.0356073491,
-0.0018451159,
0.0229300223,
-0.0196336247,
0.0158825349,
-0.0004112981,
-0.0361883678,
-0.0174044818,
0.0498112664,
-0.0112682898,
0.1014791429,
-0.0204664655,
0.0469598956,
-0.0007831989,
0.0065905978,
-0.0425436683,
0.0674979836,
0.0048972578,
0.0317412578,
-0.0082535008,
0.0238638204,
-0.0198263377,
-0.0028246681,
-0.0237710215,
0.0149646383,
0.0114513105,
-0.0251048859,
-0.0023665912,
-0.0347207151,
-0.0485509746,
-0.0084666898,
-0.0666058585,
-0.0078172842,
-0.010025613,
0.0082650008,
0.0411702208,
0.0065770261,
0.0080088768,
0.0185890198,
-0.0030474856,
-0.0086322865,
-0.0185283441,
0.0415556133,
0.0345927998,
-0.0287918784,
-0.0244464334,
-0.0343314074,
-0.0119286897,
-0.0259922072,
0.0916671678,
-0.0211770739,
0.0159853995,
-0.063299872,
0.0409072489,
-0.0349994116,
0.0240007862,
-0.02827687,
-0.0409232974,
0.0169774033,
-0.0004897421,
0.059457127,
0.0596908256,
0.0161562283,
0.0381253809,
0.0512576289,
0.0101332003,
-0.0529741794,
-0.0615884326,
-0.0433014184,
-0.0282310788,
-0.0448981375,
-0.0265160855,
-0.0088178907,
0.1377577782,
-0.0056882794,
-0.0146936011,
-0.0340448283,
0.0350896418,
-0.0451049842,
-0.0123106614,
-0.0028242497,
-0.0346393101,
-0.0353404544,
0.0293348208,
-0.0194134042,
-0.0246213339,
0.0392721444,
-0.0241238326,
-0.0114033334,
-0.0245925244,
-0.0234887283,
-0.0366352908,
0.0702756867,
0.0356251746,
0.0084914649,
0.025833901,
-0.0152623709,
-0.0783807412,
-0.0076993676,
0.0108619621,
-0.009651388,
0.0522568002,
-0.032048475,
-0.0039430032,
0.0014598864,
-0.0425007753,
-0.028568441,
-0.0748879239,
-0.0227769613,
-0.0013785646,
0.032588359,
-0.0145292813,
0.0012167791,
0.0076375986,
0.0002866764,
-0.0044857175,
0.0168264005,
-0.0128452396,
-0.0182576962,
0.0490281545,
0.0177507568,
-0.015472292,
0.0226782691,
-0.0034678739,
-0.0089198314,
0.0589250401,
-0.006867589,
-0.0161484629,
-0.0737776086,
-0.0046265149,
0.0142711587,
-0.024257116,
-0.0672263652,
-0.0342735015,
0.0449526422,
-0.0082203867,
-0.0060310005,
0.0833386555,
0.0510366485,
-0.0008570395,
0.0472530425,
0.0022071542,
0.0272625145,
0.0305900089,
0.0023218759,
-0.0600700639,
0.0040903334,
-0.0014604985,
-0.0493491329,
0.0023279514,
-0.0398561209,
0.0105091641,
-0.1389777362,
0.0095984992,
-0.0073223016,
-0.0353225581,
0.0189455692,
-0.0394412614,
0.0094219884,
-0.0315126739,
-0.0074288137,
-0.0001637208,
-0.03612395,
0.021674348,
0.0197208598,
0.0060847085,
-0.0304743219,
0.0016673389,
-0.0586110987,
0.0245156791,
0.0126600787,
0.0326763652,
-0.0288768318,
-0.0108373053,
0.0670216456,
-0.0062717167,
0.000448927,
0.004768732,
0.0138743268,
0.0245055109,
-0.0112925069,
0.0020889647,
0.018099986,
-0.0215201546,
-0.030060757,
-0.0191124361,
0.0659077987,
-0.0047127889,
-0.0479402691,
-0.02080689,
-0.0079251677,
-0.0298533533,
0.0793064758,
0.0335254259,
-0.0098676737,
-0.0150667783,
-0.0185046066,
0.0024444368,
0.0452454612,
-0.0530458242,
0.0064167203,
-0.0153669454,
0.0032777884,
-0.0990919024,
-0.0144812465,
0.0165395029,
0.0297230855,
0.0095815584,
-0.0226899963,
-0.0046596332,
-0.0464076884,
-0.0253670979,
0.032611344,
-0.0056755524,
-0.0213251431,
-0.0069141053,
-0.0192397106,
0.0608774684,
-0.0013141317,
-0.0528777242,
-0.0057518529,
-0.0284913313,
-0.0895864889,
0.0259008221,
0.0175782349,
0.0263543464,
0.0495069623,
0.0019816335,
-0.0332886651,
0.0561799444,
-0.0153930858,
0.007918424,
0.0443037525,
0.0300910678,
-0.0066103814,
0.0282459296,
0.0440142341,
-0.0298835412,
0.0536934957,
0.0520502739,
0.0314164311,
-0.0219806284,
0.0171236712,
0.0135248676,
0.0125961332,
0.0722141564,
0.0012022649,
-0.028790528,
-0.020974813,
0.02287638,
-0.03985456,
-0.016918879,
-0.0409868807,
0.025077058,
0.0462425128,
0.0268666744,
-0.0261731427,
-0.0177867301,
0.0058372873,
0.0961638018,
0.0027171928,
-0.0176739804,
0.0507830717,
-0.0306803528,
0.0457256697,
0.0409999676,
-0.0075869863,
0.0349285938,
-0.0113761127,
0.0287365299,
-0.0311066378,
0.0214248262,
-0.0030187967,
0.0323039219,
-0.0647067875,
0.0135279559,
-0.0864990428,
-0.0421918146,
0.0095551712,
-0.015291878,
0.0297969189,
-0.0905163288,
0.0747721642,
-0.0309165418,
-0.0158953834,
-0.0001068134,
0.0170856453,
-0.019261945,
0.0073997746,
0.0512269065,
0.0227453653,
-0.0350276418,
0.037284568,
0.0906689242,
0.0100283679,
0.0455139838,
0.0051155938,
0.0007613755,
-0.0078383144,
-0.0007371467,
0.0221706722,
-0.0028280821,
-0.0060710097,
0.0067281835,
-0.0444631167,
-0.060763821,
-0.0284611918,
-0.0209061988,
-0.009562294,
-0.0073868013,
0.0186335333,
0.0968931019,
0.0061654164,
0.0379906334,
-0.0264508519,
-0.0240293201,
0.0249071606,
-0.0160985272,
-0.0334554575,
-6.180413546e-33,
-0.0149089554,
0.0231138933,
-0.0223675519,
0.0033146872,
-0.0086954813,
0.0274880566,
-0.0055089984,
0.0162173361,
-0.0379014648,
0.0403753147,
-0.0214695707,
0.0143258795,
0.011061348,
0.0144676194,
0.0194818247,
-0.0005894291,
0.0118295494,
0.0067454753,
-0.0193132907,
-0.0252364408,
0.0362863913,
0.0168278031,
0.079854466,
-0.0697322115,
0.0060606371,
0.0340600871,
0.0184588674,
0.0119236736,
-0.0082188658,
0.0547715127,
-0.0136134569,
0.0426247641,
0.0330906101,
-0.0351035967,
-0.0036833426,
0.0347867124,
-0.0643328875,
-0.0377139486,
0.0678622723,
-0.0312927775,
-0.0329617374,
-0.0211177021,
0.0493967272,
-0.0142030399,
-0.0113305459,
-0.0355791673,
0.0144326752,
-0.0048399088,
-0.011091345,
-0.0371142253,
-0.0895544961,
0.0035778459,
-0.0075618504,
0.0257409457,
-0.0062484397,
-0.027333647,
0.0022489184,
0.0544402599,
-0.0253355149,
0.0187922698,
0.0067566349,
0.019133877,
0.004142548,
0.0102700582,
-0.0093965437,
0.0690652207,
0.0431061089,
-0.0168313347,
-0.0290689934,
0.0025110794,
0.0013213225,
0.0469681732,
-0.0016915011,
0.037066754,
0.0424593426,
0.0090730898,
-0.0721777305,
-0.0559536554,
0.0119690048,
0.0424524359,
0.0379023999,
0.0197906941,
-0.0219216719,
-0.0412521549,
-0.0513883159,
-0.0392112173,
-0.0245005675,
-0.0378605649,
0.0081978953,
0.0139228553,
-0.0040330822,
0.0095149102,
0.0072219139,
-0.0616122223,
-0.0273069423,
0.014237945,
-0.0325625241,
0.0121474732,
-0.0152566712,
0.0080586309,
-0.0457199179,
-0.0563138127,
0.0028354519,
0.0016237261,
0.0130318347,
0.0259265155,
0.0346640795,
-0.0071564708,
-0.0517982282,
-0.0298950933,
-0.0383396782,
-0.0673809573,
-0.0195219908,
0.0444773845,
0.0441049933,
0.0461562201,
-0.0131287333,
0.0443153679,
0.0583044067,
0.0040129935,
-0.0293836407,
-0.0186848789,
0.0106071997,
0.0130923856,
-0.0104454663,
-0.0320187137,
-0.0055345153,
0.0142944241,
0.120009996,
-0.0564896911,
-0.0280811191,
-0.023371445,
2.59e-7,
0.0927511156,
0.0648204014,
-0.0082809376,
0.0110696759,
0.0136062885,
-0.0047134198,
-0.0111638447,
0.0153229665,
0.0306514353,
-0.0368669406,
-0.0135356542,
0.0160030965,
0.0040416867,
0.0288159903,
-0.0731609464,
-0.0204450674,
-0.101382412,
-0.0221590381,
0.0022137433,
0.0142345782,
0.0056385673,
0.1456174701,
0.0342547633,
-0.0115460549,
-0.0407670587,
-0.0473154932,
0.0729715675,
-0.0514365658,
0.0005892222,
0.0256282594,
-0.0099380389,
-0.0130992774,
0.0328005776,
0.0313377753,
0.002703815,
0.0371517539,
0.0096367793,
0.0326194726,
-0.0124454955,
0.0162597876,
-0.0056089931,
-0.0628290847,
-0.0044175466,
-0.0719663873,
0.0767470971,
-0.1002646834,
-0.0563218221,
-0.008411482,
-0.0345505178,
0.0203203782,
0.0191790853,
-0.0049779369,
0.0233936738,
0.0053361724,
0.0131727764,
0.0246676095,
-0.0224280041,
-0.0811055675,
-0.0322517753,
0.0282285996,
-0.03368821,
-0.068043232,
0.0193173382,
-0.0456677526,
0.0347906612,
-0.0501291864,
-0.0210355725,
2.481029601e-34,
0.032416977,
0.0308911987,
0.0411236808,
0.0317851119,
0.0462215133,
-0.040716283,
0.0210053325,
0.0274222139,
-0.0010735546,
-0.0835340172,
0.0111871492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04954v1 | Prompt Sketching for Large Language Models | 2023-11-08T18:57:23 | 2023-11-08T18:57:23 | Luca Beurer-Kellner, Mark Niklas Müller, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many recent prompting strategies for large language models (LLMs) query the
model multiple times sequentially -- first to produce intermediate results and
then the final answer. However, using these methods, both decoder and model are
unaware of potential follow-up prompts, leading to disconnected and undesirably
wordy intermediate responses. In this work, we address this issue by proposing
prompt sketching, a new prompting paradigm in which an LLM does not only
respond by completing a prompt, but by predicting values for multiple variables
in a template. This way, sketching grants users more control over the
generation process, e.g., by providing a reasoning framework via intermediate
instructions, leading to better overall results. The key idea enabling
sketching with existing, autoregressive models is to adapt the decoding
procedure to also score follow-up instructions during text generation, thus
optimizing overall template likelihood in inference. Our experiments show that
in a zero-shot setting, prompt sketching outperforms existing, sequential
prompting schemes such as direct asking or chain-of-thought on 7 out of 8 LLM
benchmarking tasks, including state tracking, arithmetic reasoning, and general
question answering. To facilitate future use, we release a number of generic,
yet effective sketches applicable to many tasks, and an open source library
called dclib, powering our sketch-aware decoders. | [
0.0042341892,
0.0631902665,
-0.0103544304,
0.0106894877,
-0.0380716883,
0.0173083432,
0.0224863701,
-0.0196026526,
-0.0259740893,
-0.0282454975,
0.0120613165,
-0.0545612983,
0.0121780075,
0.0480650887,
0.0061255437,
-0.058094956,
0.0324142091,
-0.0770305172,
0.0216761325,
-0.0092866188,
-0.0229427982,
0.0041189957,
-0.0428085066,
0.0648910999,
-0.0065394924,
-0.0464353338,
-0.0603408255,
-0.0259703752,
-0.0203969423,
-0.0317655094,
-0.0323849767,
0.0791269392,
0.0109103946,
0.0185163822,
0.000002179,
-0.0453699492,
0.0074433149,
-0.0130252577,
-0.0351594724,
-0.0040309122,
0.0213854052,
-0.0274845064,
0.0042725867,
0.014233958,
-0.0355678871,
-0.0504467189,
0.050599914,
0.0355959237,
0.0796272457,
0.0184536241,
0.0130176041,
-0.0272780079,
0.0105842575,
-0.0132454075,
0.0247159582,
-0.0417968445,
-0.007667196,
0.0141292987,
0.0332130902,
0.0030736264,
-0.0308973584,
0.0555266999,
0.0600996464,
-0.0103217643,
-0.0236988328,
0.0429275259,
0.0481757745,
-0.0340410545,
-0.0192734674,
0.0619952865,
0.017272355,
-0.0040263357,
-0.0082364874,
-0.0032494033,
0.0122478213,
0.0025153446,
-0.060662318,
0.0627488419,
-0.0286706574,
-0.0226853397,
0.0201074537,
0.0201952122,
0.0073546735,
0.012360421,
-0.016958626,
0.0588231124,
0.0102165984,
-0.0132365264,
-0.0277067255,
0.01888825,
-0.001464374,
-0.0866294056,
-0.0041168123,
0.0407567397,
-0.0460116751,
0.0204695035,
-0.0566709377,
-0.0277543589,
-0.0084799267,
0.0545892119,
0.0570763126,
0.0801566094,
-0.0052470434,
0.0321531072,
0.0026744022,
0.0290966444,
-0.0100421607,
-0.0072824694,
-0.0604887381,
0.0092431931,
-0.0197415836,
-0.0291752499,
-0.071578078,
0.0070431624,
-0.0285804812,
-0.0340149179,
0.0037732024,
0.0563728139,
0.036266081,
0.0104315411,
-0.0050131665,
0.0213547517,
-0.0041655409,
-0.0181466267,
-0.0280447826,
0.033814501,
-0.0721730739,
-0.0026896731,
0.0516403876,
-0.0364617035,
-0.0301478989,
0.0042647943,
-0.0018310078,
-0.0248947237,
-0.0371693484,
0.0406269096,
-0.031161746,
0.0067788921,
-0.0071152812,
-0.0453890413,
0.021635022,
-0.064080596,
0.0123192938,
-0.0736522675,
0.0155192176,
0.0479254499,
-0.0018846676,
-0.0364560299,
0.0102534248,
0.0330648832,
0.0161036141,
0.0612029396,
-0.0106363939,
0.0035080314,
0.0037288349,
0.0222911127,
-0.0108872252,
0.0688980371,
0.0290506035,
0.0216140319,
0.0058512897,
0.003956846,
-0.0006556117,
0.0423196666,
0.0204892904,
-0.0123109892,
-0.009786291,
-0.000589887,
0.0121887131,
0.0406310968,
0.0373664312,
0.0175287873,
-0.0562902093,
0.0069585815,
0.0402483307,
0.0682053864,
0.0209187828,
0.0000159804,
0.0558374226,
0.016525209,
0.0125314025,
0.0114896297,
-0.0571095012,
0.0526402816,
-0.0123629821,
0.0482086726,
0.0260715634,
0.0162005033,
-0.0064413487,
-0.0403384045,
0.0048218514,
0.0165151246,
0.0154394424,
0.0331666581,
0.0307151359,
0.0421986841,
-0.0364032872,
0.0502617359,
-0.0108632622,
-0.0450882241,
-0.0254229307,
-0.0648531392,
0.0714044049,
0.081041798,
0.0568830557,
0.0226979814,
-0.023124814,
-0.0024170717,
0.0225630272,
0.0249838177,
0.0233013462,
-0.014963544,
0.0213705562,
-0.0402768627,
-0.0220850445,
-0.0193694867,
0.0087406561,
0.0200058948,
0.0381546393,
-0.0173413381,
0.0057681338,
-0.0504407883,
0.027928723,
0.0218453053,
-0.0056910869,
-0.0463727117,
-0.0011312701,
0.0132796783,
-0.0143266944,
0.0086055333,
-0.0140706627,
0.039749518,
0.0247926842,
-0.0464720838,
0.0158268269,
-0.0089180926,
-0.0817096531,
-0.0852290988,
-0.0073012859,
0.0250585061,
-0.0328648835,
-0.009165707,
-0.0157265309,
-0.0337683484,
0.0091210669,
-0.0313814916,
0.0420944989,
-0.0306325909,
-0.0052263588,
0.0347270258,
-0.0075889179,
-0.0301696602,
0.0762573257,
-0.0228007603,
0.0075333766,
0.0766846314,
0.0554389581,
-0.0051185903,
-0.0328373909,
-0.0165676102,
0.0148851378,
-0.012172577,
-0.0011081161,
-0.0007636312,
0.0275267716,
-0.0421353243,
0.0035135706,
-0.0777983591,
0.0004103799,
-0.0336201005,
0.0158559997,
0.0107047437,
0.0140171405,
-0.0223143473,
-0.034858197,
-0.0328487307,
-0.0133429738,
0.0081186704,
0.025975557,
0.0109184738,
0.0043905093,
-0.0053692022,
0.023604637,
-0.011207018,
-0.001422065,
0.035773281,
0.0035336488,
-0.0368084647,
-0.0666800067,
0.0674080849,
-0.0160829574,
0.0051827375,
-0.0086869691,
0.010562975,
0.0424397923,
-0.0356941223,
0.055922091,
0.0555134453,
-0.0135726389,
0.0195850432,
0.0584369972,
-0.0430373028,
-0.0685096309,
0.0159807447,
0.0016244298,
0.0124314819,
0.0194175802,
-0.0407563932,
-0.0009780069,
0.0781895444,
0.0247221142,
0.0298467968,
-0.0581826903,
0.026371086,
-0.0034058145,
-0.0276668519,
-0.0524019673,
0.0033551038,
-0.0063203909,
0.0680979639,
-0.0229554027,
-0.0523379594,
0.0869810358,
-0.0434774533,
-0.0271801371,
0.0040470194,
0.0364217833,
-0.0169843361,
0.1062903032,
-0.0054583596,
-0.0019115992,
0.0370419659,
-0.0400603935,
-0.0384388678,
0.0268284678,
0.0222073458,
-0.0352943838,
0.0290058237,
-0.0677168071,
0.0006398632,
-0.0202328116,
-0.0386447608,
-0.0575476624,
-0.0158845503,
-0.045571994,
0.0057262331,
0.0028649967,
-0.0235379338,
0.0360707156,
0.0180761386,
0.0256795995,
0.0305218901,
-0.0339979082,
0.0003852029,
-0.0254397951,
0.0448151194,
0.0675466284,
0.0238485169,
-0.0050072898,
-0.0667555928,
0.0550474003,
0.0742167979,
0.0465997308,
0.0152045637,
-0.0235583894,
0.0269356128,
0.033607889,
0.0139808832,
-0.0062180441,
0.0625466183,
0.0613760985,
-0.0883366168,
-0.0372782834,
0.1033184603,
0.0342486985,
-0.0353021882,
-0.0130609451,
-0.0435752496,
0.0700024366,
0.01763127,
0.0425027236,
-0.111221239,
-0.063822709,
0.0351373553,
0.0237193778,
0.006103707,
-0.0266335662,
-0.0182981584,
-0.1264052838,
0.0316578932,
0.000452303,
-0.0386682153,
0.0043001184,
-0.0059687579,
-0.0206534863,
0.0524246469,
-0.0150071997,
0.0394232273,
-0.0023649177,
0.0155230109,
0.0154052526,
-0.0211396217,
-0.0258907527,
0.0098102894,
-0.0125993341,
0.0491153337,
0.0835450739,
-0.0156770386,
0.0264718551,
-0.0090114446,
0.0351163484,
-0.0152670154,
0.0130580952,
-0.0233835448,
0.0252764877,
0.0151284914,
-0.0080677718,
-0.0243210588,
0.0191059746,
-0.0292436089,
-0.028519487,
0.0180287734,
0.0658584759,
-0.0452440567,
-0.0071745124,
-0.0127000669,
0.0072150338,
0.0141875437,
0.0578935109,
0.0546944365,
-0.0331631005,
-0.0622973405,
-0.0555733591,
-0.0010625259,
-0.0882349983,
-0.0178822242,
-0.0054018092,
0.0293093137,
-0.0194176473,
-0.0459891334,
-0.0379684269,
0.0759699941,
0.0461726822,
-0.0106117632,
0.0144297136,
-0.0105815148,
-0.0095842192,
-0.0415949002,
0.035480164,
-0.0088391565,
0.0415762924,
-0.0426406078,
-0.0257404018,
-0.0106443251,
-0.041522406,
0.0001303903,
0.0452234969,
-0.1213035658,
-0.0452859029,
0.0037084038,
0.0605456941,
0.0214893781,
0.0391558744,
-0.0103031034,
-0.0536179617,
0.0255494658,
0.0319112986,
-0.0046956739,
-0.0048181522,
-0.0017955106,
0.0311539695,
0.0026424034,
0.0290364791,
-0.0246948488,
-0.0148921022,
-0.0010984445,
0.0581697226,
-0.027021924,
-0.0326641947,
0.0263401456,
0.0185468253,
-0.0001851733,
-0.0106518902,
-0.0014647748,
-0.0218540877,
0.0239637867,
-0.0167554636,
-0.0437512808,
-0.0432295986,
0.024318425,
0.0033433447,
-0.0565096065,
0.0238086041,
-0.012230536,
0.0208817497,
0.0284234043,
-0.0282183662,
0.0091451807,
0.0160175711,
0.0255642906,
0.0531950779,
-0.0095497724,
-0.033030197,
0.0284733232,
-0.0029669332,
0.0654876307,
-0.0157805383,
0.0905520171,
0.0181919467,
-0.0147240739,
-0.0086522726,
0.025187647,
-0.0659738481,
-0.0892213434,
0.008425856,
0.006748124,
0.0208794437,
0.0369591638,
0.02253226,
-0.03049374,
0.0107744867,
0.0028141567,
0.0281304773,
0.0375900455,
-0.0545948967,
0.0440758094,
0.0223798957,
0.0112029864,
-0.0558129437,
0.0464823507,
0.002182829,
0.0476887003,
0.0058105588,
0.0130171394,
-0.0372840725,
-0.0296740904,
-0.0301948879,
0.01459755,
-0.0235418435,
0.0161961969,
-0.0559519194,
-0.0647491738,
-0.0004164368,
0.0106928591,
-0.0257625207,
-0.0200419836,
0.0397969708,
0.0448866822,
0.007100442,
-0.0498413369,
-0.0268995389,
0.0447119027,
-0.0049829185,
-0.0206187628,
-0.0390743166,
-6.309477683e-33,
-0.0519390218,
-0.0530017465,
0.0558525212,
-0.0760564134,
-0.0199388154,
-0.020415755,
-0.072672464,
0.0269753393,
0.0029389451,
-0.0018593658,
-0.0303047542,
-0.0083457315,
0.010958178,
0.0378474593,
0.0102209514,
-0.0246741846,
0.035193529,
0.0033184718,
-0.0490787476,
0.0018547162,
0.03664333,
0.0278793704,
-0.0079632597,
0.0085307769,
0.0273851026,
-0.0152490083,
-0.0065665049,
0.0156938471,
-0.0352059118,
0.0474402048,
-0.0234368257,
0.0229398329,
0.0176986549,
-0.0080010286,
-0.0498862676,
0.0463005006,
-0.0854040757,
-0.0411892422,
0.0187475961,
0.0140527124,
-0.0652335584,
-0.0295861308,
-0.0084815565,
0.0079051908,
-0.015024987,
0.000265072,
0.0035255936,
-0.0176928043,
-0.0338033475,
-0.0138863306,
-0.0420773067,
0.0040301709,
-0.0139173623,
-0.071492821,
0.0162640214,
0.0799305886,
-0.0089810612,
-0.0361436419,
-0.0380394869,
0.032350976,
0.0127877351,
0.0259105973,
0.0698839352,
0.0385046154,
-0.0005515856,
0.0299689937,
0.0194080453,
-0.020712534,
-0.0800162628,
-0.0167393386,
-0.0003688188,
0.0147394231,
0.0139908623,
0.0063175135,
0.0255852714,
0.0111442981,
0.0039656274,
0.0200590175,
0.0597475655,
0.0496336743,
0.0278042201,
-0.0108924126,
-0.0166598856,
-0.0540330224,
-0.0646868125,
-0.0221778098,
-0.0394729115,
-0.0174691118,
0.0686122626,
0.0121540455,
-0.0141212475,
-0.0400772095,
0.0486246422,
-0.0161730703,
-0.0065233461,
0.0149272121,
-0.0115932068,
0.0489817485,
-0.0307023842,
0.0458677933,
-0.0161534678,
0.0037658957,
0.0222627725,
-0.0155171938,
0.0087220874,
0.0306235943,
-0.0119327391,
0.0011156588,
-0.06909246,
-0.0071505718,
-0.0712442026,
0.0354201719,
0.0071866647,
0.0009266588,
0.0417973548,
-0.009392634,
-0.0336356461,
0.0448657945,
-0.0217998978,
-0.0184156783,
-0.041227635,
-0.0044055027,
-0.0083892532,
-0.0060336925,
-0.0133291353,
0.0003898385,
-0.0434448496,
0.0144345742,
0.0142543465,
-0.0366535857,
-0.0067157345,
0.0466023833,
2.733e-7,
0.0372384414,
0.0166659039,
0.0354494676,
0.0566888563,
-0.0055516348,
0.0325001329,
-0.0118515976,
-0.0142681086,
0.0372579992,
0.004247678,
-0.0223802011,
0.0172730461,
0.0571092665,
0.0368038341,
-0.0974491313,
0.0207445752,
-0.0366224684,
0.0189326108,
-0.0513529666,
-0.0062106559,
0.0594145097,
0.0475088879,
-0.0370317772,
0.0023223353,
0.0324048363,
-0.020494841,
0.0334343649,
-0.0071223313,
0.0034901032,
-0.007925895,
-0.0334112085,
-0.0216756836,
0.0165134948,
0.0200582854,
-0.0000241825,
-0.0160223544,
-0.0053552561,
0.037698444,
0.0223572552,
-0.022645887,
-0.020668596,
-0.020172406,
0.0079335487,
-0.0425304919,
0.0867110863,
-0.0372658446,
-0.0039830375,
-0.0342616737,
0.0287732203,
-0.0294276066,
-0.0035068511,
-0.0078455191,
-0.0138382921,
0.0162218362,
0.0266743843,
-0.0193974208,
-0.0001762473,
-0.0536096431,
-0.0564525127,
-0.0294837132,
-0.0326924473,
-0.0469681583,
-0.063630119,
0.0072671627,
0.0106674964,
-0.0655846074,
-0.0353673212,
2.821693374e-34,
0.0391830206,
-0.0064188652,
0.0448666252,
0.0852640495,
0.0346112773,
-0.0085332831,
0.0275446475,
0.0144667849,
0.047923509,
-0.0914718509,
-0.0612799637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04897v1 | Future Lens: Anticipating Subsequent Tokens from a Single Hidden State | 2023-11-08T18:56:35 | 2023-11-08T18:56:35 | Koyena Pal, Jiuding Sun, Andrew Yuan, Byron C. Wallace, David Bau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We conjecture that hidden state vectors corresponding to individual input
tokens encode information sufficient to accurately predict several tokens
ahead. More concretely, in this paper we ask: Given a hidden (internal)
representation of a single token at position $t$ in an input, can we reliably
anticipate the tokens that will appear at positions $\geq t + 2$? To test this,
we measure linear approximation and causal intervention methods in GPT-J-6B to
evaluate the degree to which individual hidden states in the network contain
signal rich enough to predict future hidden states and, ultimately, token
outputs. We find that, at some layers, we can approximate a model's output with
more than 48% accuracy with respect to its prediction of subsequent tokens
through a single hidden state. Finally we present a "Future Lens" visualization
that uses these methods to create a new view of transformer states. | [
-0.0249713119,
0.0322571732,
-0.0112562552,
0.0011679453,
-0.0532377586,
-0.0650774017,
0.0271062944,
0.0272786971,
-0.0352788121,
0.0135143818,
0.0143984687,
0.0235172752,
-0.005265167,
0.0789858028,
0.0256079566,
-0.0229414627,
0.0630694628,
0.0024263838,
-0.0708859488,
-0.0131909288,
-0.0464058034,
-0.0260392353,
0.0064890268,
0.0790159479,
-0.0305247065,
-0.0339376777,
-0.0437505394,
-0.0132978782,
0.0207311697,
-0.0301159192,
-0.0593445376,
-0.0188808702,
0.0017252602,
0.0524720363,
0.0000020298,
0.0282048993,
-0.0154971266,
0.003958236,
-0.0202849321,
0.0058134031,
-0.0777643695,
-0.0281828884,
-0.0123071549,
0.0020203397,
-0.0245421063,
0.0118545219,
0.0671181455,
0.0861563757,
0.041186206,
0.0372868553,
-0.011018605,
-0.0061151334,
0.0565510876,
-0.0073853866,
0.0075175427,
-0.0124504687,
0.0064590531,
-0.1012361348,
-0.0487002283,
-0.0043378277,
-0.0413726345,
0.025761744,
0.0630177483,
-0.0104385754,
-0.0082979724,
0.0607865714,
0.0322744586,
0.0034650154,
-0.0383133553,
-0.0110549973,
-0.0556587614,
-0.0566334575,
0.0010122749,
-0.0134048546,
-0.0120517639,
0.0314167812,
-0.0516874939,
-0.0598639138,
0.0173091646,
0.035616897,
-0.0085856291,
0.038188301,
0.049969431,
-0.0326592736,
-0.0207806807,
0.1081827879,
0.0365458466,
-0.0167957116,
-0.0738973096,
-0.004938982,
0.0579008944,
-0.0409566611,
0.0259646699,
0.0486736819,
-0.0063599171,
-0.0144515997,
0.0252458882,
-0.0102879424,
-0.0561121628,
0.0065607652,
0.0393367968,
0.0491534211,
-0.0383470766,
0.0132617066,
-0.0255364124,
0.0206061639,
-0.0885269642,
0.037123777,
-0.0119276084,
0.024492586,
-0.0036102773,
-0.0286460035,
-0.0371206105,
0.0436518304,
-0.00449814,
-0.046931196,
-0.0373618789,
0.0222969316,
-0.0198368616,
-0.0187513847,
-0.0017874737,
0.0173559412,
-0.0132095693,
-0.0216545165,
-0.0156377628,
0.020783864,
-0.0317463428,
-0.0025105965,
-0.0107875867,
-0.0228468813,
-0.0615378544,
-0.0192089416,
0.0093956878,
-0.0199756641,
-0.0596830286,
0.0979043543,
0.0055432529,
-0.0065644239,
-0.0118612489,
-0.0181808993,
-0.0029801393,
0.0197117366,
0.0704210848,
-0.0020054055,
-0.04712791,
-0.0125569478,
0.0245703533,
0.0267574508,
0.0038857204,
-0.0255838037,
0.0298487898,
0.0399076454,
0.0305497684,
-0.0470136926,
-0.0295252204,
-0.0025384095,
0.0178710893,
0.009328098,
-0.0026464381,
0.0592033081,
0.008176513,
-0.0248956718,
0.0430625267,
0.0223719552,
0.045142971,
-0.0073558339,
-0.0324033424,
-0.0521496646,
0.0283732507,
0.0063629621,
-0.0120471809,
0.0019498487,
-0.0473061725,
-0.0404003896,
0.0275944844,
0.0967080444,
0.0594190694,
0.0309025608,
0.0271078274,
-0.0206222497,
-0.0144296465,
0.0227305647,
-0.0516823567,
0.0829529837,
-0.0034646911,
-0.0198590029,
0.0196033269,
0.0038040334,
-0.020655388,
-0.0278303567,
0.0160001069,
-0.0174551271,
-0.002261091,
-0.078397952,
0.0389705636,
0.0131550208,
-0.0670323223,
0.0636404455,
-0.0187794734,
-0.0098296851,
0.0053181667,
-0.0893340707,
0.0011022892,
0.0029180385,
0.0385382324,
-0.0181155335,
-0.0151743442,
0.0127507038,
-0.0510526299,
0.0179669149,
0.0201386996,
0.0288756546,
0.0115952715,
0.01351857,
-0.0400555432,
0.0483349375,
0.0101413717,
0.0139386887,
-0.0536834486,
0.0175209399,
0.0045323991,
-0.0050010555,
0.0256186854,
0.0064515132,
0.0346100591,
0.0111410599,
0.0147158839,
0.035322275,
0.0434373319,
0.0267109796,
0.005497036,
0.0314535648,
0.0514723994,
0.0025591257,
-0.0063316156,
0.0249331314,
-0.0930574238,
0.0390464589,
0.0375507958,
-0.0343702622,
0.0502565466,
0.0367943347,
-0.0183783267,
-0.0812995657,
0.0779992417,
-0.0477690399,
0.0688272864,
0.0054070856,
-0.0514982902,
0.0172628425,
0.0048213387,
0.0256784558,
-0.0110209454,
0.022763323,
0.0140202381,
-0.041227445,
-0.0088786166,
0.0433841571,
-0.0301680285,
0.0305381641,
-0.0073528793,
-0.0323041901,
-0.0298211165,
0.0391931236,
-0.0500569493,
-0.0027721166,
-0.0177737512,
-0.0455870442,
-0.0473839156,
-0.0074763927,
0.0306155868,
0.0172800943,
-0.0024792224,
0.0150718316,
-0.0315498002,
-0.0064057033,
0.0144201377,
0.0109570762,
-0.0357855745,
0.022502441,
0.0257102903,
-0.0635170862,
-0.0282910932,
-0.03394996,
-0.0364390574,
0.0499433689,
0.0225199014,
-0.0603454895,
-0.0192845464,
-0.0850236341,
0.0476695746,
0.0231447723,
-0.0347816162,
-0.0550611056,
0.0330097787,
0.0018266228,
0.0007977501,
0.0329950191,
0.0341405086,
0.0452649631,
-0.0158005897,
0.0176368058,
-0.0297174454,
0.0077880621,
-0.0996914282,
0.0265322383,
-0.0699404329,
0.0295304488,
0.0226214584,
0.0867868885,
0.0107547063,
-0.014913192,
-0.0745904222,
-0.0019187239,
0.0066099823,
-0.0521239974,
-0.0101289889,
-0.040241763,
-0.055481948,
0.0184954591,
-0.0100566419,
-0.0514021218,
0.0613209009,
-0.0187178906,
0.0147915743,
0.0437692851,
0.0099755451,
0.0205679145,
0.0507027619,
0.0374741703,
0.0415605977,
0.0076252888,
-0.0268919636,
-0.0225294735,
0.0371243618,
-0.0633111447,
0.0067788837,
0.0007338133,
-0.0133143822,
0.0072591165,
0.0179290473,
-0.0236376766,
-0.0218503196,
0.011927533,
0.0079533979,
0.006511651,
0.0019207427,
-0.0254715346,
-0.0308687985,
-0.016273804,
0.0023763911,
0.0545221567,
-0.0570392385,
-0.0219260771,
-0.0116486037,
-0.0170834418,
-0.0119275469,
-0.0140674841,
0.0348237306,
-0.0186217707,
0.0345411822,
0.0086843893,
0.0605874732,
0.0504361503,
-0.0344157666,
-0.0038198808,
0.0044928077,
-0.0240482111,
-0.0167220421,
0.0232378077,
0.0329450034,
-0.0046271556,
-0.0288746245,
0.0567772202,
0.0267141704,
-0.0828205794,
0.0460429564,
0.0062727411,
-0.0302633271,
0.0247025415,
0.0316572674,
-0.0857465118,
0.0274513941,
-0.0268791504,
0.0088558942,
-0.0235635675,
-0.007087484,
0.0005317912,
-0.064331986,
0.012208838,
0.0104668615,
-0.0100537036,
-0.0227663517,
-0.0215250179,
-0.036951907,
0.0203079246,
0.0348493941,
0.010229677,
0.0169748738,
-0.0178571809,
0.0247006398,
-0.0182398297,
-0.0064525791,
0.0281457901,
0.0582074039,
0.016673686,
0.0126867266,
0.0021488566,
-0.033798717,
-0.0616173446,
0.0619842708,
0.010945362,
0.0508267023,
0.007505205,
0.0232597031,
0.0285380464,
-0.0194070991,
-0.0249328203,
0.0090501821,
0.0237704385,
-0.0347151719,
-0.0589694344,
0.0688136667,
-0.038007956,
-0.026793154,
-0.017106276,
-0.0346845314,
-0.0387913473,
-0.0094741313,
0.0219474249,
-0.0265008751,
-0.0239501633,
-0.0253247153,
0.0892392322,
-0.0554125756,
-0.0530247055,
-0.0519364215,
0.065861851,
-0.021825688,
-0.0395632684,
0.0235774536,
-0.0638117641,
0.0525829755,
0.0307114851,
-0.0121773519,
0.036168132,
-0.0166244805,
-0.0092426417,
0.0084359786,
-0.0069349571,
0.0071544885,
-0.0656138435,
0.0231762268,
0.0064703701,
-0.0455472805,
-0.0711241663,
0.0057829879,
-0.0828313604,
-0.0424107127,
0.053567715,
0.0294206869,
0.0281498712,
0.0070754769,
-0.011370372,
-0.0266529117,
0.0853469074,
0.0273060165,
-0.0356431864,
-0.0343936048,
0.0495746098,
-0.0390557572,
-0.0249796901,
0.0101568839,
-0.0193007737,
0.0308733098,
0.0142368404,
-0.0124317491,
-0.0146770598,
0.0182405934,
0.0236547273,
-0.018802898,
0.1410316825,
0.0244199429,
0.0562380217,
0.0071162796,
0.0251347274,
-0.0125710815,
0.0371401049,
-0.0316139199,
0.0131144337,
0.0508985296,
-0.002932518,
0.0124688931,
-0.011020815,
0.0403707922,
-0.0356385857,
-0.0158753283,
-0.0269882642,
0.0221442208,
-0.0013201252,
0.0064504161,
-0.0088386564,
-0.014409747,
-0.0232457891,
0.0194942914,
0.0061666272,
-0.0123529807,
-0.0015332125,
0.0205736496,
0.0340113789,
-0.0348257311,
0.0165222026,
-0.1354953498,
-0.0457391143,
0.0015170178,
0.0656829551,
0.0474432372,
0.0452078283,
-0.006597118,
-0.0404458791,
0.0121231964,
0.0112931598,
0.0285805967,
-0.0036146464,
-0.0076463264,
0.03119055,
0.0192296915,
-0.0113791954,
-0.0315624736,
0.0195341613,
0.0009873868,
0.0480832011,
-0.0341051742,
0.0246205218,
0.0007146817,
0.0024760272,
0.0027772749,
0.0580703095,
-0.0105943391,
-0.0098340595,
-0.0266093872,
-0.0401131734,
0.0150151448,
0.0461145267,
0.0296087991,
-0.0366513617,
0.0224567056,
0.0049944855,
0.0068520438,
-0.0346307494,
0.0286825374,
-0.0283130873,
0.0624026656,
-0.0158123188,
0.0050961236,
-6.589146156e-33,
-0.0339777172,
-0.0323097594,
0.0075812805,
0.0481965654,
-0.0201706439,
0.0028380342,
-0.0442664027,
-0.0320415087,
-0.008473482,
0.0072140051,
-0.0400497019,
0.022641778,
0.0281212516,
0.0253960248,
0.0025831028,
-0.0353040472,
0.0562244579,
-0.0151621457,
-0.0054498743,
0.0344789661,
0.0259606652,
0.0141912131,
0.0784114301,
-0.0131680043,
0.0181430504,
0.0361378975,
-0.0422927402,
0.0334644169,
-0.0419466645,
0.0332885794,
-0.0402614102,
-0.005942395,
-0.0113216192,
-0.0654349849,
-0.0109344004,
-0.0079117939,
0.0001507993,
-0.0306840576,
0.0189164486,
0.0206860397,
-0.0250615701,
-0.0262961928,
0.0366552509,
0.0199469067,
-0.0795144588,
0.0137188593,
0.0032125805,
0.0482897051,
-0.0290328767,
-0.0156833585,
-0.0205970909,
-0.0051645427,
-0.0124552194,
0.0200980846,
0.0392126366,
0.0162406992,
-0.0009231299,
-0.0335997343,
-0.0528632067,
0.0341280624,
-0.0096059386,
0.0475894436,
0.0291170254,
0.0310760997,
0.0265272725,
0.0385574326,
0.0493408591,
-0.0343845598,
-0.0379128195,
-0.0195930786,
0.0158756189,
0.0112537257,
0.0221657064,
-0.0972832739,
0.0593956858,
-0.04787663,
-0.0313079953,
-0.017531177,
-0.0169645306,
0.0561783388,
0.0401496552,
0.0274897218,
0.0091547184,
0.0022787817,
-0.0015270581,
-0.0445585027,
0.0009400721,
-0.0092119416,
-0.0040834192,
0.0303522907,
0.0143442135,
0.0200216249,
0.0283962116,
-0.0458361059,
0.0243741255,
0.0254856981,
0.022405155,
0.0310138557,
-0.0158828776,
0.0254796091,
-0.0375904106,
-0.0216945503,
-0.0017382912,
-0.003574721,
0.0289181508,
-0.0129221594,
-0.0010751458,
0.0674876198,
-0.0647871941,
-0.0132718114,
-0.0306624733,
-0.0411734134,
0.0265934542,
-0.0476525202,
0.0926868021,
-0.0036565159,
-0.0187772959,
0.0140796276,
-0.026318185,
0.0340714976,
0.026155537,
0.0427553393,
-0.0078982934,
0.072536841,
-0.0479891002,
-0.0380786769,
-0.0704169571,
0.0611943007,
0.0318992846,
-0.0737980753,
-0.0634575561,
0.0459442288,
2.917e-7,
0.0200336743,
0.0421825573,
0.0523681305,
0.04246011,
0.0614850856,
-0.0045544892,
0.0038455741,
0.0316013061,
0.0216746237,
0.0328973047,
0.0361906067,
-0.0162898898,
0.024931673,
0.0248401947,
-0.0491712317,
-0.0167825762,
-0.085145779,
0.0162253045,
-0.0058723013,
-0.0058582313,
0.0356179476,
0.0816608593,
0.0490869656,
0.0296874978,
0.0210308209,
-0.0389947519,
0.0400383696,
-0.001105551,
0.0413027927,
-0.029838318,
-0.0070840772,
0.0013227991,
-0.0202776343,
-0.015881272,
-0.0082162833,
0.0203702152,
-0.0375410281,
-0.0179955196,
-0.0288717821,
-0.0496816747,
-0.022672018,
0.0072014527,
-0.0069263298,
-0.03958188,
0.024870947,
-0.0341671892,
-0.0320203975,
0.0163529273,
-0.0087917717,
-0.0025386286,
-0.0046737916,
0.0134365065,
-0.014276105,
0.0355867073,
-0.0166493747,
0.0161745399,
0.0578347594,
-0.0496354811,
-0.0216748565,
-0.0087749297,
-0.0471947789,
-0.0249713771,
-0.0647288784,
0.0035773434,
0.0416663475,
0.0175393987,
-0.0410666242,
2.601343284e-34,
0.0279962942,
-0.0299416203,
0.0328280516,
0.0265954845,
0.0082581248,
-0.0275344364,
0.0276263505,
0.0007765454,
0.0381060056,
-0.0483663604,
-0.0770605206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04892v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04892v2 | Bias Runs Deep: Implicit Reasoning Biases in Persona-Assigned LLMs | 2023-11-08T18:52:17 | 2024-01-27T08:49:29 | Shashank Gupta, Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Ameet Deshpande, Ashwin Kalyan, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal, Tushar Khot | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent works have showcased the ability of LLMs to embody diverse personas in
their responses, exemplified by prompts like 'You are Yoda. Explain the Theory
of Relativity.' While this ability allows personalization of LLMs and enables
human behavior simulation, its effect on LLMs' capabilities remains unclear. To
fill this gap, we present the first extensive study of the unintended
side-effects of persona assignment on the ability of LLMs to perform basic
reasoning tasks. Our study covers 24 reasoning datasets, 4 LLMs, and 19 diverse
personas (e.g. an Asian person) spanning 5 socio-demographic groups. Our
experiments unveil that LLMs harbor deep rooted bias against various
socio-demographics underneath a veneer of fairness. While they overtly reject
stereotypes when explicitly asked ('Are Black people less skilled at
mathematics?'), they manifest stereotypical and erroneous presumptions when
asked to answer questions while adopting a persona. These can be observed as
abstentions in responses, e.g., 'As a Black person, I can't answer this
question as it requires math knowledge', and generally result in a substantial
performance drop. Our experiments with ChatGPT-3.5 show that this bias is
ubiquitous - 80% of our personas demonstrate bias; it is significant - some
datasets show performance drops of 70%+; and can be especially harmful for
certain groups - some personas suffer statistically significant drops on 80%+
of the datasets. Overall, all 4 LLMs exhibit this bias to varying extents, with
GPT-4-Turbo showing the least but still a problematic amount of bias (evident
in 42% of the personas). Further analysis shows that these persona-induced
errors can be hard-to-discern and hard-to-avoid. Our findings serve as a
cautionary tale that the practice of assigning personas to LLMs - a trend on
the rise - can surface their deep-rooted biases and have unforeseeable and
detrimental side-effects. | [
0.0295665953,
0.0078480514,
-0.038806349,
0.0341721773,
0.0133828567,
0.0226377062,
0.0650966093,
0.0162402075,
0.0324145816,
-0.0261722468,
-0.0294409003,
0.0036983176,
0.0012029693,
-0.0394725241,
0.0619197078,
-0.0511663035,
0.0434391946,
-0.0065338421,
0.0230754633,
-0.0416881256,
-0.022987457,
0.0281357095,
-0.0095452173,
0.0349651277,
-0.0201096795,
-0.0463643335,
0.0343397856,
-0.0094529325,
0.033606261,
-0.0081179691,
0.0344857164,
0.0364095718,
0.012311033,
-0.0158864576,
0.0000020557,
-0.0667826459,
0.0279827602,
-0.0160681829,
-0.0356363244,
-0.0098005682,
-0.0186034255,
0.0890264437,
0.0166423079,
0.0344762206,
-0.0633582249,
0.0216692332,
-0.0085807806,
0.0329801403,
0.0146738067,
0.0167503022,
0.0036401344,
0.0012418311,
-0.0584391654,
0.0161882136,
0.0564260706,
-0.0376000442,
0.0088201128,
-0.0196311269,
-0.0229827613,
-0.0302410312,
-0.0129771214,
-0.0214762557,
0.0296916123,
0.0196515508,
0.003326772,
0.0056668799,
0.0021425234,
-0.0027759508,
0.0177125297,
0.0515980087,
0.076989457,
0.0208552554,
-0.0127103785,
0.0386946388,
0.0592083596,
0.0182876829,
-0.0391962305,
0.035028033,
-0.0414243527,
-0.0402323902,
-0.0478763394,
-0.0104498211,
0.0196442567,
0.0192935765,
0.0030454975,
0.0750135332,
0.0051139151,
-0.0248921383,
-0.0158141349,
0.0056263963,
0.0379934423,
-0.0494815893,
-0.0032845705,
0.0289025828,
-0.0493339188,
0.0205055419,
-0.0065440577,
0.0461240225,
0.0144954687,
-0.0134807322,
0.0297108125,
0.0865403861,
0.0285447426,
0.0015178996,
-0.0039514215,
0.0452747345,
-0.0050947322,
0.0326740928,
0.0155870663,
0.0150422454,
-0.0261816252,
-0.0639986172,
0.0291480739,
0.0308761392,
0.044836618,
0.0593113936,
-0.0273476373,
-0.0142422691,
-0.0452121273,
-0.0031368807,
-0.0554789081,
0.0232032165,
-0.0119865788,
-0.0102759823,
-0.1110667214,
0.0051700133,
-0.0486399308,
0.0251379814,
-0.0060633151,
-0.0878513008,
-0.0043413392,
0.0005918926,
-0.0172230639,
-0.0206188504,
0.0017084198,
0.0592615381,
-0.0143848211,
-0.0200978257,
-0.0301205181,
-0.0340461433,
0.0273032859,
-0.0586481541,
0.0153573705,
-0.0220811442,
0.0180690195,
0.0150796212,
0.0022650554,
-0.0363672748,
0.0086045666,
0.0621581972,
-0.0175203662,
0.0743720084,
0.0217077639,
0.0339915194,
0.0469810069,
0.0719612613,
-0.0787239671,
0.0606150851,
0.0310014989,
-0.0262171961,
0.0083332863,
-0.0406299867,
0.0238063671,
0.0172466952,
-0.0196937732,
-0.0113332001,
0.0274670646,
0.0253389068,
-0.0276821405,
0.0164364967,
0.0979453623,
0.0070176297,
-0.0439510718,
-0.0170031022,
0.0500322506,
0.1079123244,
-0.0212003104,
0.0460464954,
0.0199133549,
-0.0198815707,
0.0311470814,
0.0053839311,
-0.0891899243,
0.0407099538,
-0.0157195628,
-0.0513615422,
-0.0047754757,
0.0624211915,
-0.0444868281,
-0.0043732245,
-0.00273195,
0.0330117419,
0.0195619073,
0.0185336694,
-0.027547894,
-0.0051046154,
0.0129831759,
0.0852753296,
0.0156360138,
-0.0255496427,
-0.0180810057,
-0.0745366067,
-0.0041684755,
0.0377777144,
0.0070333397,
-0.0145287421,
-0.040012408,
-0.0305620711,
-0.0141865434,
0.070747897,
0.0670740083,
0.0022085982,
-0.031694442,
-0.025511248,
-0.0232693013,
-0.0076154559,
-0.0244825631,
0.0599858388,
0.0598661378,
0.0303750131,
0.0075294301,
-0.0081638424,
0.046151422,
0.0093679652,
-0.0870803595,
-0.0329718627,
-0.0368106626,
0.0044779233,
0.0430344529,
0.0017696556,
0.0355166942,
-0.0133553976,
-0.0344605036,
0.0304208566,
-0.0157921147,
0.0264100805,
-0.0905531347,
0.0123915691,
0.0322210491,
-0.0716640428,
-0.0782992616,
0.0068923873,
0.0130132502,
0.0198736917,
0.0430226177,
-0.0073662004,
-0.0133465948,
0.000559921,
-0.022861762,
-0.0218672641,
0.0010291857,
-0.0125422971,
0.0466557518,
-0.0030428215,
-0.0024447606,
0.0629408062,
0.003608139,
0.0078592002,
-0.0662438869,
0.0104404921,
-0.0226908419,
-0.0114073362,
-0.0084902393,
-0.0387530439,
-0.0299385414,
-0.0701217204,
0.0300796125,
-0.0786600113,
-0.0098498128,
0.022004148,
0.0095206425,
-0.0061193397,
-0.0080400724,
-0.0506454743,
-0.0188787449,
-0.0465339608,
-0.0074667563,
0.0005124384,
0.0424301066,
0.0131274164,
-0.0243432354,
0.0142490836,
-0.0021062684,
0.0052973763,
-0.0476703979,
0.0134357773,
0.0055429349,
0.0516317151,
-0.0343726836,
-0.0165012646,
-0.0676248819,
-0.003306105,
-0.0058148629,
-0.0110532399,
0.0694746822,
0.0373707972,
0.0519081913,
0.0678993836,
0.0274902955,
0.0356730521,
0.0246034991,
-0.0113011664,
-0.0542280003,
0.0253189821,
0.0040545021,
0.0046588168,
0.0048298971,
-0.0980146602,
-0.0336186476,
0.0293670651,
0.0422405265,
0.0193770137,
-0.0593716055,
0.0695415586,
-0.0260277167,
-0.0624187998,
0.0201134589,
-0.0190592762,
-0.0333234146,
0.0219085459,
-0.0475478433,
-0.0230714139,
0.0569051243,
0.0295845233,
-0.0219449457,
0.0159465149,
0.0275145788,
-0.0260749273,
0.0415872969,
-0.0472152531,
-0.0157668609,
-0.0021330081,
-0.0306534357,
-0.0768870637,
-0.0379138216,
0.0113445604,
-0.0558795445,
0.0505152419,
-0.0284949951,
-0.0172186643,
-0.0217293315,
-0.0284836888,
-0.0654713064,
0.0167398099,
-0.0110934451,
-0.0207081344,
-0.0418218225,
-0.0241315607,
0.0055198879,
-0.0455257632,
0.0346416943,
-0.0453028269,
-0.0196167901,
-0.0294695031,
0.0068647498,
-0.0650242642,
-0.016006168,
0.0725030601,
0.080039449,
-0.0599176213,
0.0353304297,
0.0520437658,
-0.0089887418,
-0.0396655649,
0.0028408526,
0.0086683258,
0.0301560406,
0.0032180592,
-0.002172987,
0.0134048741,
0.0687206611,
-0.0155567052,
0.0331730619,
0.0939450786,
0.0104849124,
-0.0318013951,
0.0235868338,
-0.0461667255,
0.0164121576,
0.034279868,
-0.002535902,
-0.0879753754,
0.0012635434,
0.0189480186,
0.0319276117,
-0.0549666882,
-0.0703933313,
-0.0079082465,
-0.0972575545,
0.0314633138,
0.0090699559,
0.0050232951,
-0.0013948681,
-0.0002718328,
0.0465656668,
0.0209214259,
0.0584049895,
-0.0045476123,
0.0162499323,
0.0203276332,
0.0199737139,
-0.072677739,
-0.0127230138,
0.0490009598,
0.0075918618,
0.0215964578,
-0.0085334722,
0.0196886119,
-0.0110137481,
-0.0551984347,
0.017716255,
0.0128708864,
0.0209852085,
-0.0299594607,
0.0107366443,
-0.0220648237,
0.0319471508,
-0.0679397359,
0.0154132107,
-0.0303371958,
-0.0241281576,
0.02742083,
0.0676642209,
-0.0208522137,
-0.04060442,
-0.0191061143,
0.0063754134,
-0.0391775481,
0.0528143793,
0.0065297233,
-0.0170390252,
0.012021455,
-0.0556479655,
-0.0237788949,
0.0105019175,
-0.081425488,
0.0182657242,
0.0106112892,
0.0076548685,
0.0087403096,
-0.0743404403,
0.0280521549,
0.0060154693,
-0.0083693881,
-0.0416508764,
-0.0266701952,
-0.0021801786,
-0.0219772514,
0.0437627733,
-0.0519415103,
0.0390871055,
0.0150689622,
-0.0196276829,
-0.0079366397,
-0.0323127657,
0.0209552832,
-0.0286559183,
-0.0074022859,
-0.0343854241,
0.0105033675,
0.0494861826,
0.0319812223,
0.0133579811,
0.0345686749,
-0.0427472442,
0.040929351,
0.0230005365,
-0.0032218436,
0.0544148237,
0.0035390342,
0.0489144512,
0.0087881917,
0.0075410586,
0.0002041122,
0.0172052979,
0.014588871,
-0.0162072349,
-0.0398977026,
-0.0563367233,
0.0103396745,
0.0099688303,
0.0109174531,
0.0111011062,
0.0059399032,
0.0088969599,
-0.0111087719,
-0.0171755552,
-0.0139798848,
0.0275510103,
-0.0707657784,
0.0250109937,
-0.0002985474,
0.012781579,
-0.0456922278,
-0.035059575,
0.0244560428,
0.000382927,
0.0502404235,
0.0110499375,
0.0511885658,
-0.0154548185,
0.0039243679,
-0.0013658345,
0.0029895806,
-0.0227179695,
0.0532578677,
0.0512323752,
0.0849621221,
0.0249489527,
0.0122163538,
-0.0011892352,
-0.018577747,
-0.0447971262,
-0.067669265,
0.0574446023,
0.0369973183,
-0.0050283452,
0.0170327667,
-0.0116408076,
-0.0206298586,
0.0127157811,
0.0180027355,
-0.0349324681,
0.0246158503,
0.0154530993,
0.0661255121,
0.0050605489,
-0.0008521809,
-0.0328213088,
0.0278848726,
-0.0369615257,
0.0520072579,
-0.0410620496,
-0.0314930566,
-0.0259549916,
-0.0397285596,
0.023773998,
-0.0073415018,
0.0233817417,
-0.036931891,
-0.1043241769,
-0.060021732,
-0.0093703708,
0.0113842674,
0.0047493507,
-0.0371594168,
0.0015322649,
0.043115031,
-0.000770488,
-0.0547139198,
0.036996033,
0.0343597271,
-0.0604118817,
0.0027726043,
0.002872,
-6.085483561e-33,
-0.0519669279,
-0.069117263,
0.0281178113,
-0.0069922647,
-0.0435727946,
-0.0281736478,
-0.0248860121,
0.0284166411,
-0.0172616467,
-0.0116399266,
-0.0233736578,
0.0010396531,
0.0144118331,
-0.044238463,
-0.0089206472,
-0.0389996655,
0.0192507897,
0.0003631697,
-0.0385288522,
-0.0023824763,
-0.0212542079,
-0.0070264707,
0.0180964433,
-0.0582331866,
0.0391176119,
-0.0301118456,
0.0013990885,
0.0042242184,
-0.0522068441,
0.0111609865,
-0.020887522,
0.0458462089,
0.0409477763,
0.0303372536,
-0.0199721549,
0.0829460248,
-0.0249670539,
-0.0592180565,
0.0407669619,
0.0136400033,
-0.0303713791,
-0.0653643757,
0.0063729277,
0.0178034939,
-0.0650775209,
-0.0313725621,
0.0389361009,
-0.0207808875,
0.0732180104,
0.0311623085,
-0.0237944704,
-0.0152098583,
-0.0162148774,
0.0181782003,
-0.0429110564,
0.0297427885,
-0.0347294956,
-0.0354812071,
-0.0539368056,
0.0386924818,
-0.038962692,
-0.0562177002,
0.0609903224,
0.0449020043,
0.0221295655,
0.0220980681,
0.0531181619,
0.0642380789,
-0.0648035929,
-0.0758070275,
0.0175408404,
0.0009980962,
0.03099465,
0.0521419533,
0.0160506051,
-0.0307825394,
-0.0006585264,
0.0168222152,
0.0579448752,
0.0108531062,
0.0343836956,
0.0128353573,
-0.0557394736,
-0.0176843908,
-0.0145414723,
0.0096571501,
-0.0121265957,
-0.0697552711,
0.036932677,
-0.0221212786,
0.0094335191,
-0.0074335434,
0.0184810199,
-0.0137445861,
-0.0184209831,
-0.0577413216,
-0.0018672934,
-0.0140960179,
0.0060187648,
-0.0079172468,
-0.0450996272,
-0.0000040179,
0.0044639409,
0.0066352147,
0.041289337,
0.0445864312,
-0.0276904702,
0.0148445964,
-0.0487301163,
-0.0235307813,
-0.0160971656,
0.0174893141,
0.0293117668,
0.0139679341,
0.0250989608,
0.0330937952,
0.011534377,
-0.0336061604,
0.0127149541,
-0.0185896605,
-0.0433133915,
0.0077436175,
-0.0455947369,
0.0265491772,
-0.0329777338,
0.0060459827,
-0.0268010776,
0.0058450974,
0.0174706951,
-0.0649395287,
-0.0238473192,
-0.0363978893,
2.64e-7,
-0.0224155802,
0.03334447,
-0.0146201774,
0.0390658751,
0.0344149061,
0.0383610241,
0.0027243909,
0.0297557991,
0.0759296566,
-0.0305433255,
-0.0177602284,
0.0636888742,
0.0255101826,
0.0292699262,
-0.0610528775,
-0.0067527564,
0.0259281714,
0.0106201954,
-0.0235917456,
0.0579549186,
0.0667044446,
-0.0102338959,
0.0343983509,
0.0024543901,
-0.024445843,
0.0102969492,
0.0396784805,
-0.0162193906,
0.0187758487,
-0.0223620906,
0.0480370149,
-0.0091850013,
0.0404777303,
0.0884431899,
0.0309764128,
-0.018196471,
-0.0192895792,
0.0300283711,
-0.0157839712,
-0.0180699397,
-0.0168525316,
-0.0137153054,
0.0164547209,
-0.026049694,
0.0279856827,
-0.0056828731,
-0.0501212105,
0.0075024222,
-0.0279504769,
-0.0185671151,
0.0024788212,
0.0187883265,
-0.0393241048,
-0.0086419806,
0.0211681221,
-0.0084149018,
-0.0038178968,
-0.0734598041,
0.0080972118,
-0.0161628276,
-0.0469272211,
-0.0992857963,
-0.0032771067,
0.0338145792,
0.0259853527,
-0.0063943304,
-0.0019797676,
2.236447338e-34,
-0.0563881546,
0.0588592701,
0.05423107,
-0.0036351404,
0.0343320854,
0.0229167975,
0.0191253424,
0.0096803121,
0.0649826303,
-0.0192629378,
-0.0074730827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04886v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04886v2 | SEMQA: Semi-Extractive Multi-Source Question Answering | 2023-11-08T18:46:32 | 2024-06-30T18:53:22 | Tal Schuster, Adam D. Lelkes, Haitian Sun, Jai Gupta, Jonathan Berant, William W. Cohen, Donald Metzler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recently proposed long-form question answering (QA) systems, supported by
large language models (LLMs), have shown promising capabilities. Yet,
attributing and verifying their generated abstractive answers can be difficult,
and automatically evaluating their accuracy remains an ongoing challenge.
In this work, we introduce a new QA task for answering multi-answer questions
by summarizing multiple diverse sources in a semi-extractive fashion.
Specifically, Semi-extractive Multi-source QA (SEMQA) requires models to output
a comprehensive answer, while mixing factual quoted spans -- copied verbatim
from given input sources -- and non-factual free-text connectors that glue
these spans together into a single cohesive passage. This setting bridges the
gap between the outputs of well-grounded but constrained extractive QA systems
and more fluent but harder to attribute fully abstractive answers.
Particularly, it enables a new mode for language models that leverages their
advanced language generation capabilities, while also producing fine in-line
attributions by-design that are easy to verify, interpret, and evaluate.
To study this task, we create the first dataset of this kind, QuoteSum, with
human-written semi-extractive answers to natural and generated questions, and
define text-based evaluation metrics. Experimenting with several LLMs in
various settings, we find this task to be surprisingly challenging,
demonstrating the importance of QuoteSum for developing and studying such
consolidation capabilities. | [
0.0343798287,
0.0525997318,
0.0004644554,
0.0580244549,
-0.0232616551,
0.0044356715,
-0.0118457004,
-0.0495244861,
-0.0138568934,
-0.0378904939,
-0.015211205,
-0.0251938831,
-0.0206598621,
0.0384597927,
0.0435042009,
-0.0115578845,
0.010579939,
-0.0348077565,
0.0155292666,
-0.0106657837,
0.029057987,
0.0299751591,
0.0303822272,
0.0048157042,
0.0054484704,
-0.0272641461,
-0.0122911902,
-0.0301862694,
0.019390896,
0.0165077783,
-0.0014063551,
0.028881751,
0.0040285629,
0.0111116627,
0.0000016784,
-0.0471551977,
-0.0026962894,
0.0148933865,
-0.0439564064,
0.0188480243,
-0.0124560902,
0.0152694145,
0.0392382853,
0.0086967191,
-0.0422445871,
-0.0137569373,
0.0320036523,
0.0368895307,
0.1231186688,
0.0524326153,
0.0060973852,
-0.0189094599,
0.0366839655,
-0.0095951958,
0.0063711135,
-0.0039070854,
0.0316516496,
0.03350541,
0.0300358739,
0.0269206278,
0.0151377078,
0.0392648913,
0.0340068862,
-0.0353868529,
0.0023198901,
0.0118231541,
-0.0467681177,
0.0022629101,
0.0058819694,
0.1046228781,
0.0202890746,
-0.0148066822,
0.031312421,
0.0066714529,
0.0121134678,
0.0068949475,
-0.072727479,
0.0424940735,
-0.0008155903,
-0.005660722,
-0.0151361246,
0.0004291475,
0.004023328,
0.0216667186,
-0.0275147799,
0.0283512678,
0.018897865,
-0.0267455466,
-0.0171251018,
0.0156388525,
-0.0269347318,
-0.0911939517,
-0.0048827105,
0.0684962869,
-0.0138466116,
0.0215638746,
-0.0402188748,
-0.0468735583,
0.0419171713,
-0.0058442052,
0.0075087184,
0.0036113407,
-0.0155758942,
0.0556841865,
-0.0451208651,
0.0401150398,
-0.0657920539,
0.0114502897,
-0.0581399053,
-0.0466090403,
-0.0370806977,
-0.0387627929,
-0.0058924481,
0.0531163551,
-0.0478730276,
-0.0090493569,
-0.0054653422,
0.0230765902,
-0.0208082534,
-0.0080451285,
0.010092237,
0.0332553647,
0.0008130582,
-0.010738018,
-0.0253483113,
0.0253173579,
-0.047976464,
0.0160175189,
0.024186613,
-0.0585667118,
-0.0521289185,
0.0308157764,
0.0252952594,
-0.0293194093,
0.0059600002,
0.0447401293,
-0.0236418955,
-0.0016010673,
-0.0013253454,
-0.0541190952,
-0.020697549,
-0.0725081265,
0.0179049503,
-0.0785552487,
0.0836295784,
0.0170521587,
-0.0457713753,
-0.0258834437,
0.0096165258,
0.0497169569,
-0.039914187,
0.023477599,
-0.0057825698,
0.0153352292,
0.0408237651,
-0.0122143561,
0.0100621236,
0.0453633144,
0.0528500676,
0.0139962323,
0.0411160663,
0.0158926956,
0.0168469492,
0.0391675159,
0.0542666875,
0.0330766924,
0.0179958399,
0.0653691664,
-0.009093903,
-0.0103715677,
0.0466397591,
0.0826472268,
-0.0131082889,
-0.0162062142,
0.0519290492,
0.0349260047,
-0.0212890953,
0.0069658761,
0.054116223,
0.0243260916,
0.0350962766,
0.0122940484,
-0.0132072279,
0.0424497686,
-0.0131064262,
0.0284916051,
0.042206753,
0.0572544932,
-0.017030986,
-0.0269940589,
-0.0036992384,
-0.0100298477,
-0.0271643959,
0.0406504087,
0.0092774574,
0.0210699588,
-0.0005752227,
0.0755730793,
-0.0040241918,
-0.0520653017,
0.0237126052,
-0.0352263302,
0.0800113603,
0.0058242655,
0.0071199099,
-0.0190601721,
0.0083744265,
-0.0231116284,
0.0220982246,
0.0378084965,
0.0154645629,
-0.0310588907,
0.0118296016,
0.0000622619,
-0.0114705274,
-0.031212233,
-0.0100499112,
0.016636299,
0.0168808755,
-0.0169844665,
0.022800006,
-0.0317076184,
-0.012853533,
0.0387149379,
-0.033877641,
-0.0198943354,
0.0084988475,
-0.0166728143,
0.0198519528,
0.0409601927,
-0.0300687086,
0.0456688069,
0.0278460737,
-0.0568615533,
-0.0909851566,
0.0156928841,
-0.033383593,
-0.0136389015,
0.0515325665,
-0.0106513212,
-0.0199704077,
0.02051121,
-0.0342157297,
-0.0642335638,
-0.0032552371,
-0.0580687672,
-0.0045488882,
-0.0506821573,
-0.0263803788,
0.0455325022,
0.0182426684,
-0.0439427644,
0.083129935,
0.0013248036,
0.0190309547,
0.0429372787,
-0.0056254282,
0.0299563762,
-0.0121244676,
-0.0060186284,
0.023198314,
-0.0138266739,
0.0152107328,
0.0203367863,
-0.0108158682,
-0.0538476966,
-0.0260722674,
-0.0459637716,
0.0315379761,
-0.0234820694,
0.0284602437,
0.0345293023,
0.0111512868,
-0.0080498038,
-0.0038672066,
-0.0855106935,
-0.0317673869,
0.0510419533,
0.0217743609,
0.0455937721,
0.0260210913,
0.0368148535,
-0.0555208959,
-0.0144716129,
-0.0172941145,
0.0857354105,
0.0064030127,
0.0387977138,
-0.0545184277,
-0.0214395169,
-0.0621717274,
0.008181354,
0.0186795369,
-0.0196821094,
-0.0294149369,
-0.0183953717,
0.0364164226,
0.0465907753,
0.0215004906,
-0.0379268155,
0.0480231605,
0.010597663,
-0.0438060872,
0.0175133646,
-0.0156720877,
-0.0125189498,
0.0109304274,
-0.023273984,
0.0277797058,
0.0261692442,
0.0216252469,
-0.0146316821,
-0.020315621,
0.0546428114,
0.0077922451,
-0.0298580527,
-0.0372887589,
-0.0268139597,
-0.025394924,
0.0366422087,
-0.0261268038,
-0.0055281599,
0.0544749536,
-0.0479681715,
-0.0189987179,
-0.0100665819,
-0.0022239091,
-0.0772365332,
0.0507099442,
-0.0091959909,
0.0114147104,
-0.0019346318,
0.0203455519,
-0.036166586,
-0.0142124798,
0.0034978034,
-0.0477582477,
0.0605583824,
-0.0499706455,
0.0240124054,
-0.0248896889,
-0.0355878808,
-0.0390450172,
-0.0608550385,
-0.0172713175,
0.0227994118,
0.0085727097,
-0.0066946098,
0.0073638754,
-0.0152447512,
0.0765123218,
0.0017045594,
-0.0421812534,
0.0055901702,
-0.0219613351,
0.1008478105,
0.1031505987,
0.0683783665,
0.0267250687,
-0.0222603474,
0.0194162633,
0.0599965341,
0.0177578647,
0.0311176479,
-0.0031065003,
-0.025952613,
0.011143839,
-0.035424158,
0.0026813261,
-0.0169989262,
0.0656910911,
-0.0375291221,
-0.0108731827,
0.0953063816,
0.0283173267,
0.0068288674,
-0.0074579525,
-0.0266228113,
0.0465315208,
0.0100246742,
0.0513584539,
-0.1056564897,
-0.0062658903,
-0.0462153777,
0.0140454518,
0.0140889073,
-0.0154269002,
-0.0221956018,
-0.1335417628,
0.0228815973,
-0.0202921126,
-0.0728487298,
-0.017752178,
-0.0276106093,
0.0080338782,
-0.0160111357,
-0.0318894312,
0.0164031945,
-0.0219304077,
0.0143798208,
0.0220921356,
-0.0085457908,
0.0108006634,
0.0395738818,
-0.0203841962,
0.0152234659,
0.0424055234,
0.025306059,
-0.0075343847,
-0.0078261653,
-0.0081493147,
-0.1085693091,
-0.0343920887,
0.026390098,
0.0723378509,
0.0049920678,
-0.0090788789,
-0.0067778016,
0.0430984125,
-0.0245330576,
-0.0067616142,
0.0282805152,
0.0711656138,
0.0208962429,
-0.0038246734,
-0.0184278674,
-0.0026198537,
0.0022913115,
0.088797152,
0.0300654545,
-0.0361228511,
-0.0508036874,
-0.0263508428,
-0.0373641774,
-0.0663090944,
-0.0534179546,
0.0315607712,
-0.0103576696,
0.010891269,
-0.1056302488,
-0.0428117178,
0.0077551608,
0.0022175582,
-0.0257319193,
-0.0045853714,
0.0124278134,
0.0084763458,
-0.0025674596,
0.0206166506,
-0.0433454327,
0.0133976685,
-0.0004474343,
0.0034667929,
0.0398959033,
-0.0273364522,
-0.0266311076,
0.0178041458,
-0.0848941803,
-0.0512870662,
-0.0182574969,
0.0393514559,
0.0204054024,
0.0140103083,
-0.0102225794,
-0.013818711,
0.0472985916,
0.0086047072,
-0.0348847732,
0.0292822309,
0.0176736191,
0.016392123,
-0.0061382549,
0.0410275385,
-0.0710278824,
0.0140625462,
-0.0213520154,
0.0355155878,
-0.0220821481,
-0.0289399251,
0.0247529261,
0.0283970442,
-0.0433936045,
0.0267938934,
0.0310232732,
-0.0141505944,
0.001499851,
-0.0447857976,
-0.0263549127,
-0.0353306271,
0.0298654716,
-0.0045889937,
-0.0388088897,
0.0085978834,
-0.0067838449,
0.0022357095,
0.0604053475,
-0.0534648262,
-0.0403709002,
0.0245756637,
-0.0382083803,
-0.0086592603,
-0.0198471062,
-0.0423916392,
-0.0139919166,
-0.0279474948,
0.03446839,
-0.0163111147,
0.0456801578,
0.0146552166,
-0.0211156867,
0.033041738,
0.0149116395,
-0.1096054092,
-0.0417447276,
-0.0123689072,
-0.0144978492,
0.020611316,
-0.0002280879,
0.0968358815,
0.0223529264,
-0.0259531904,
-0.0168300439,
-0.0052872472,
0.0100985644,
-0.0059490586,
0.0279950108,
0.034169931,
-0.0403528884,
0.0101883132,
0.078246519,
-0.0082766442,
0.0347828418,
-0.0091358479,
0.0182034131,
-0.0352586433,
-0.0597114563,
-0.0482494272,
-0.0192221515,
-0.0072671664,
-0.0264924821,
-0.0434420444,
-0.0760914534,
0.0203644391,
0.0329779647,
-0.0036213619,
-0.0026466576,
0.0284106676,
0.0556711666,
0.0260089785,
-0.0263972394,
-0.051347848,
0.0515948832,
-0.0226207078,
-0.0031735399,
-0.0095615992,
-6.167982693e-33,
-0.0200326592,
-0.0240662061,
0.0168308057,
-0.0047982512,
-0.0345928818,
0.0252124146,
-0.0414999351,
0.0008546009,
-0.0408505425,
-0.0000741202,
-0.0111136017,
0.0110622132,
-0.0094359182,
0.0550505184,
0.0094294297,
-0.0331205055,
0.001112528,
-0.0167441145,
-0.0220886096,
0.0314345881,
0.0588878989,
-0.0197308771,
-0.0017041259,
-0.0446268581,
0.0451936796,
-0.0537250228,
-0.0131723825,
0.0398698188,
-0.0092602735,
0.0835154578,
-0.0326619186,
0.0287392158,
0.0277422164,
-0.0486532934,
-0.0046201576,
0.0413874872,
-0.0696955696,
-0.0172220543,
0.0233177952,
-0.0621424504,
-0.0662428066,
-0.027414741,
0.0381862037,
-0.0133344112,
0.0582571104,
-0.0406384952,
0.0447643958,
-0.0241205636,
0.0115261674,
-0.0517337583,
-0.0320270918,
0.0100929746,
-0.0239933822,
-0.0035235661,
-0.0427413955,
0.0600923374,
0.0101622492,
0.0480930507,
-0.0137214018,
-0.0021968945,
-0.004236768,
0.0141192637,
0.0622620098,
-0.0119926361,
-0.0048518809,
0.0382437818,
-0.0406406336,
-0.028899448,
-0.0423974842,
-0.0290370509,
-0.0439195,
0.0296952482,
0.0624357946,
0.0711177364,
-0.0077805934,
0.0513513945,
-0.0687003359,
0.0286125056,
0.0189017095,
0.0316454805,
-0.0183172058,
-0.0253196936,
0.0202365424,
0.0096547799,
-0.0396591537,
0.0281534959,
-0.0219926089,
-0.0178020895,
0.0224182978,
-0.0142380558,
-0.0286093988,
-0.0016042365,
0.0247979201,
-0.04536153,
0.0038327656,
0.048262991,
-0.0403028689,
0.0265932586,
0.0189299453,
0.0370426327,
-0.052120734,
0.0287848786,
0.0127193946,
-0.0096082762,
0.001054315,
0.0279009249,
0.0307490155,
0.0085290596,
-0.0593231656,
0.015869014,
-0.0292236023,
0.0275651496,
-0.053885784,
-0.0035696204,
0.0144200074,
0.0354517512,
-0.0081450045,
0.0154790776,
0.0099954,
0.0174298044,
-0.0372573584,
-0.0230251029,
0.0214897245,
0.0048190514,
-0.0304781366,
0.0153245907,
-0.0219247527,
0.0349469148,
-0.00123262,
-0.0503179207,
0.0101848468,
0.0138101,
2.34e-7,
0.0546399169,
-0.0112323817,
0.041906938,
0.0471352674,
0.0046993648,
0.0126121957,
0.0095981834,
0.0329497121,
-0.0011861533,
-0.0427606665,
-0.0451131389,
0.0455491021,
0.0494818315,
0.0426347405,
-0.0860224217,
-0.0018232188,
-0.0950297713,
-0.049838949,
-0.0403445773,
-0.0251878519,
0.076065354,
0.0636232272,
-0.0044385404,
0.0141385002,
-0.0615637079,
-0.0535858609,
0.0646485314,
0.0137084574,
-0.0463398769,
0.0381767303,
0.0555020683,
-0.0098911859,
0.0157148428,
-0.0028546369,
-0.0084515093,
0.0228994321,
0.0318855196,
0.0777544677,
0.0344793573,
-0.0433471538,
-0.0326332003,
-0.0581284799,
0.0465682782,
-0.0368868746,
0.0830983594,
-0.04284418,
-0.0029489186,
-0.0328997523,
-0.0446359403,
-0.0113612236,
0.0073391348,
-0.0104897274,
0.0046854126,
0.0382917821,
-0.002838291,
-0.0016800108,
0.0109342132,
-0.0543675199,
-0.0531353801,
0.011667368,
-0.0435852297,
-0.0424658582,
-0.013069395,
-0.0150487982,
0.0271215681,
-0.0735806823,
0.0180241391,
2.055374831e-34,
0.0357192084,
0.0011410058,
0.0181933288,
0.0328192934,
0.0398269743,
-0.0134829944,
0.0076875803,
0.002992966,
0.003532425,
-0.0983193144,
-0.0005944924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04885v1 | Profiling Irony & Stereotype: Exploring Sentiment, Topic, and Lexical Features | 2023-11-08T18:44:47 | 2023-11-08T18:44:47 | Tibor L. R. Krols, Marie Mortensen, Ninell Oldenburg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media has become a very popular source of information. With this
popularity comes an interest in systems that can classify the information
produced. This study tries to create such a system detecting irony in Twitter
users. Recent work emphasize the importance of lexical features, sentiment
features and the contrast herein along with TF-IDF and topic models. Based on a
thorough feature selection process, the resulting model contains specific
sub-features from these areas. Our model reaches an F1-score of 0.84, which is
above the baseline. We find that lexical features, especially TF-IDF,
contribute the most to our models while sentiment and topic modeling features
contribute less to overall performance. Lastly, we highlight multiple
interesting and important paths for further exploration. | [
0.0617436916,
0.0250686873,
-0.0087041594,
0.0181781407,
-0.021288652,
0.0387091823,
0.020016212,
0.0213589016,
0.0226751827,
-0.0937353596,
0.0243476536,
0.0206979848,
-0.039843034,
0.0409713201,
-0.0313418731,
-0.0414054841,
-0.0038474118,
0.0436337925,
0.0210909508,
-0.0408385582,
0.0131059922,
0.0366765149,
-0.0103601012,
0.0318871513,
-0.0169634745,
-0.0020326285,
0.0637412965,
0.0430821888,
0.0124125378,
0.0143309617,
0.0353580527,
0.0610611625,
-0.0362631232,
-0.0146100996,
0.0000015805,
-0.0676827952,
0.0004713212,
-0.0220248494,
0.0234731268,
-0.0310082585,
0.0899418369,
-0.0014808011,
-0.0083580175,
0.0309330262,
-0.038045276,
-0.0032200848,
0.0402618609,
0.0466512032,
0.0613071956,
0.0506920293,
-0.0209302902,
0.0078467196,
-0.0407506898,
0.0406511649,
-0.0308695734,
0.0325698592,
0.0301667601,
-0.0335796401,
-0.0796622112,
-0.0130902678,
-0.0341599435,
0.0106231403,
-0.0477724709,
0.0493596308,
0.0142908888,
-0.0321518406,
-0.0513994396,
-0.0056500123,
0.0225348789,
0.0181723814,
0.0435776934,
-0.0413352586,
0.0132065825,
0.0447906666,
-0.005414241,
-0.0120660113,
-0.0026035963,
-0.009117825,
-0.0245727506,
0.0173840038,
0.0505195819,
0.0541625917,
0.0053818654,
0.0744943693,
0.0234416723,
-0.0406166315,
-0.0136606898,
-0.0350489914,
-0.0183889829,
0.0143686282,
-0.0719612911,
-0.0229911413,
0.017533293,
0.0064783972,
0.0206985772,
0.0151820146,
-0.0146396188,
-0.0887727588,
0.0092586223,
-0.0787623748,
-0.0211572926,
0.0110800527,
-0.0350476727,
0.0278348885,
0.0092153084,
-0.0073038652,
0.0370925106,
0.0092498781,
-0.006121886,
-0.0390922539,
-0.0563957393,
0.0420419797,
-0.0096373213,
0.0433178023,
0.0278904382,
0.0186302196,
-0.0370021276,
0.0005794608,
-0.0293261129,
-0.023858659,
0.0276505202,
0.0136556588,
0.0142405229,
-0.0306838304,
-0.0071909023,
0.0222159121,
-0.029468067,
0.0116964672,
-0.0914606005,
-0.0313237011,
0.0400050133,
0.0183421355,
0.0252527464,
-0.0176756233,
0.038917549,
0.0728875473,
0.0508470051,
-0.1011942104,
-0.0516691208,
0.0147937061,
-0.0385038741,
-0.0124814473,
-0.0107059721,
-0.0536992289,
0.0138411941,
0.0530083887,
-0.0033699535,
-0.0032756445,
0.0102776866,
0.0129301948,
-0.0435485244,
0.0275228862,
-0.038443733,
-0.0121281482,
0.037110433,
0.0039744144,
-0.0362533405,
0.0434098542,
0.0041652406,
0.012473831,
0.0668635815,
0.0251197424,
-0.0233385619,
-0.0097077414,
0.0115378369,
-0.0006984842,
-0.0138321454,
0.0112957312,
-0.0861803144,
-0.0145181883,
-0.0107642384,
0.0487221368,
0.0142281232,
-0.0429621413,
0.0049156793,
0.0629378036,
0.0107169123,
0.0748648122,
0.0209253952,
0.024381483,
0.0113515705,
-0.0112850694,
-0.0017463234,
-0.0011157237,
-0.0703474134,
-0.0355104618,
-0.0124166412,
0.054027468,
-0.0269062389,
-0.0361922272,
-0.0378422104,
-0.0200749729,
0.0427134335,
-0.0378738418,
0.0597317629,
0.019330861,
-0.0096708592,
-0.0083538322,
0.0468695574,
-0.0365610048,
-0.0475613959,
-0.0220813509,
-0.0128516154,
0.0821324289,
0.0263849664,
0.0054732407,
-0.001502721,
-0.0428746641,
-0.0101395212,
0.0231547784,
0.0159387402,
0.007162434,
-0.0155861769,
-0.0180334188,
0.0246568136,
0.0039530639,
0.0212952197,
0.0046523181,
0.0338107347,
0.0622850955,
-0.0197838526,
-0.0004602644,
0.0177290104,
0.0055418452,
-0.036468666,
-0.0204563439,
-0.0096949227,
0.0298373252,
0.0523635037,
0.0412149355,
-0.01057484,
-0.0437282734,
-0.0052510188,
-0.0200393293,
-0.084790431,
0.0551995337,
0.0108691966,
-0.0369731933,
0.0220341831,
-0.0821967423,
-0.0362244584,
0.0383455306,
-0.0048177494,
-0.0013237146,
0.077814728,
-0.03851353,
0.0429853871,
-0.056307435,
-0.0293970108,
-0.0796369463,
0.0069205598,
-0.0091435127,
0.0659730434,
-0.013439917,
-0.0091526397,
-0.0343014076,
-0.1032094061,
0.0086334739,
0.0346594155,
-0.0066870251,
-0.0057396395,
-0.0011498415,
0.0169136282,
0.0007495427,
-0.0091242827,
-0.000540079,
-0.0364810452,
-0.1666919738,
0.0125008961,
-0.0329418182,
-0.0256409217,
0.0096437316,
-0.0012067335,
-0.0197873805,
0.0344483405,
0.0126320319,
-0.0204708111,
0.0050730389,
-0.0050163665,
-0.00584117,
-0.0504458249,
0.0149777606,
-0.0252735801,
-0.0152228409,
-0.0406849943,
0.0422003046,
-0.0310569312,
-0.0264706071,
0.0407062545,
0.030366756,
-0.0474182107,
-0.0017909626,
0.0141355628,
-0.022502169,
-0.0159965102,
0.0166765787,
-0.0268509239,
0.0094274515,
0.0648022071,
0.0769003332,
0.0020276268,
0.0116660027,
0.0028905543,
0.0153523218,
-0.01525525,
0.0541758053,
-0.0014212575,
-0.041229412,
0.0050664367,
0.0341349579,
0.0256609805,
0.0068742922,
-0.0451920666,
0.0333642475,
-0.0547774993,
0.0146384211,
0.0103100454,
0.0020228839,
-0.0078405999,
-0.0334912166,
-0.0011608475,
-0.0191439223,
0.0728741065,
0.016990358,
0.0083016036,
-0.0419767722,
-0.0536098182,
-0.033024963,
0.0466562584,
-0.0160977915,
0.0449561253,
0.0071580447,
0.0102142543,
0.0247280616,
-0.0200646333,
-0.0062742541,
-0.0292902049,
0.0720528811,
0.0235321019,
-0.0218958575,
0.0374964885,
-0.0508772694,
-0.0129944906,
-0.0849500299,
-0.0878153965,
-0.0465713181,
-0.0084815482,
-0.0518180542,
0.0391277634,
-0.0044765896,
-0.0018075537,
-0.0543290228,
-0.0126430588,
-0.0198656283,
0.0298805218,
-0.0199882854,
0.040948309,
-0.0210377723,
0.0178011619,
0.0461036973,
0.0022164595,
0.0209421404,
-0.0529128909,
-0.0052722143,
-0.020359084,
-0.0131107904,
0.0005028429,
-0.0334100761,
0.005613056,
-0.0560972467,
0.0587568879,
0.0411921926,
0.0207959954,
0.1103521138,
0.0342591405,
0.0060394462,
0.0109985936,
-0.0056357663,
-0.0387006886,
0.0101054935,
-0.0011268021,
-0.0337809995,
-0.0469851755,
-0.0277278721,
0.0141113615,
-0.0458834507,
-0.0324542113,
0.0008348565,
-0.0632169172,
-0.0076690847,
0.0010790339,
-0.0117986212,
-0.0049942737,
0.0173503961,
0.0067241453,
-0.0330345221,
-0.0062933536,
-0.0505861528,
-0.0131291952,
0.0026243955,
0.0048515494,
-0.0415102877,
-0.0191976391,
0.0530330874,
0.0058197947,
0.0363123827,
-0.0070138122,
0.0447234698,
-0.0237743258,
0.0075323116,
-0.0757265612,
-0.0324191041,
0.001673495,
-0.0473164357,
0.0661658123,
-0.0336866044,
-0.0000687625,
-0.0566054173,
0.0009951589,
-0.0392085798,
0.0298234355,
-0.0229173563,
0.0283504799,
-0.0193596892,
-0.0429038927,
-0.0698772222,
0.0052318228,
-0.0006380273,
0.0803206861,
0.0152562838,
-0.0660121217,
0.0169631094,
-0.0318209529,
-0.0254333485,
-0.0737842619,
-0.063494578,
-0.0226682834,
0.0149570294,
-0.0181925427,
-0.0454932228,
-0.0229514763,
-0.0010991046,
0.0071157319,
-0.0621545538,
-0.0381135978,
-0.0295303687,
0.0191786885,
-0.0654404536,
-0.0010136098,
0.0258362684,
0.0141875781,
0.0161696337,
-0.0066205966,
0.058470156,
-0.0620603412,
-0.017516369,
0.0243638307,
-0.0206521004,
-0.0343679972,
0.0552702844,
0.0121277645,
0.0136706876,
-0.0138851702,
-0.0098653035,
-0.0267004445,
0.0289616585,
0.0626259968,
0.0158349853,
0.035302341,
0.0199796502,
0.0124224285,
0.0158622246,
0.0533258542,
-0.0329670012,
0.0570828691,
0.0027596771,
-0.0372774675,
-0.0481684692,
-0.0066556898,
-0.0187333692,
-0.0112305237,
0.0931819156,
0.0207701996,
-0.0968407542,
0.0129928347,
-0.0443487354,
-0.011610209,
-0.0181184523,
0.0004219884,
-0.0047603478,
0.0023352483,
0.0333509482,
-0.0776591003,
-0.0463508964,
-0.0424927548,
0.0180481728,
0.0320886075,
0.038484253,
0.0197626706,
0.0202579033,
-0.0253544748,
0.0143630551,
-0.0582185276,
0.0010382275,
0.0262557641,
-0.0509000085,
0.0112694642,
0.0112536168,
-0.0013567895,
0.0077660619,
-0.018908821,
0.009623413,
0.0001996551,
0.0279863663,
-0.0159613527,
0.0182890799,
0.0426751599,
-0.0358190238,
0.0698006824,
-0.019255532,
0.0034226554,
0.0025715625,
0.0215538051,
-0.0093235373,
-0.0016966509,
0.0107048592,
0.0321227498,
-0.0211754497,
-0.0153546026,
0.0153768985,
-0.0481750555,
0.0108895442,
0.0589426048,
-0.0446491688,
-0.0058718305,
0.0158717893,
0.0257358588,
-0.0038658218,
0.0229971819,
0.0482293777,
-0.0737912357,
-0.0398553722,
0.0660583228,
-0.055096969,
0.0250169709,
0.0089040762,
0.016100727,
0.0763367787,
0.0332150161,
0.0350090116,
-0.0506758019,
0.0034921251,
-0.049411647,
-0.0118870949,
0.0035775225,
-5.601845145e-33,
0.0025383853,
-0.0314108282,
-0.0379968472,
0.0813647509,
0.0310483109,
0.0011217075,
-0.0023789394,
0.0370556712,
-0.0325975493,
0.0246202257,
0.0120155625,
0.0144929057,
-0.0082183424,
0.0092894267,
-0.0035021126,
0.0175200906,
0.0196096431,
0.0110575762,
0.0143910423,
-0.0053961901,
0.0677132457,
0.018687211,
0.0522240624,
-0.099483557,
0.0099846525,
-0.0473564379,
0.0030780856,
0.0204078183,
0.0706816912,
0.0558805466,
0.0095951082,
0.1215032637,
0.0380028933,
-0.0065851426,
0.0120984567,
-0.0047634081,
-0.0153178517,
-0.0398803689,
-0.0048026647,
-0.0043188874,
0.0023204151,
-0.0283707567,
0.0354092717,
0.0179471616,
-0.0816176906,
-0.0317091867,
0.0728949755,
0.0023194314,
0.0494338013,
-0.0381421968,
-0.0536340922,
0.0296379328,
-0.0103097716,
-0.0041430425,
-0.0024857647,
0.0223455578,
0.0354362056,
-0.0121098878,
-0.0287944786,
0.0320148803,
-0.0603576787,
-0.0415700376,
-0.0184245408,
-0.0499258526,
-0.0057882229,
0.0524559766,
-0.0169466659,
0.0387283228,
-0.0083587747,
0.060158357,
0.0105086342,
0.0135935266,
0.0619436353,
0.0726510584,
0.0394405499,
-0.0471761487,
-0.0074041123,
-0.0171374083,
0.0441069193,
-0.0128034158,
0.0263752472,
-0.0348018855,
-0.0789280534,
0.000070495,
0.0168242287,
-0.0135256229,
-0.0145140439,
-0.0583547167,
-0.014928082,
0.0097953603,
-0.0041904896,
0.0310774166,
0.0076419753,
-0.0187038686,
0.0159260519,
0.0472279377,
-0.0290509164,
0.0602905527,
0.0084742252,
0.0345163718,
-0.0261405874,
-0.0001855272,
0.0053173811,
0.0400111191,
0.0226503294,
0.0025283701,
0.0466147251,
0.0193158444,
-0.0393499322,
0.0052105864,
0.0326106921,
-0.0148793831,
-0.0633287206,
-0.0096234856,
-0.0391005464,
0.053281121,
-0.0053077126,
-0.0002186359,
0.027441185,
0.039950341,
-0.0302817859,
-0.0085877338,
-0.0075029242,
-0.0095813489,
-0.0019758083,
-0.0282626264,
0.0073895291,
-0.0407391079,
-0.0146796508,
-0.0609432608,
0.0131680565,
-0.0518676154,
2.395e-7,
0.0387307815,
0.0714189559,
-0.0323419608,
0.0033619518,
0.0396515355,
0.0704494342,
0.0322250873,
0.0394015871,
0.0206529461,
-0.0009274533,
0.0112583749,
0.0471297242,
-0.0130161811,
0.0578552559,
-0.0599672683,
0.0144820902,
-0.0217205063,
0.0210173819,
-0.0281724967,
0.0174477696,
0.0581082106,
0.0654192641,
0.0536132939,
-0.0334887467,
0.0073757223,
-0.0396996811,
0.0253610089,
-0.0248631984,
-0.0000774314,
-0.0165371485,
0.053606905,
0.0063656,
0.0328870118,
-0.0289344024,
-0.0104303621,
-0.0189273413,
0.0131553104,
0.0326216817,
-0.0046410006,
-0.0151939942,
0.0339662842,
0.0222591329,
-0.0130737871,
0.0060360194,
0.0313732587,
0.0137552125,
-0.0306103937,
-0.0737452954,
0.0273785722,
0.0343445167,
0.0541935116,
-0.0131796608,
-0.0427687839,
0.0138349822,
0.0252570342,
-0.0193062611,
-0.0224841163,
-0.0814593732,
0.0050302125,
0.0514171198,
-0.0249655116,
-0.0164364371,
0.0199702401,
0.0052467785,
0.0572623387,
-0.033048138,
0.036722783,
1.762768573e-34,
0.0242525395,
0.0078699663,
0.0079534966,
-0.0352749676,
0.0031851837,
0.0091716228,
-0.0313229375,
-0.0224731863,
0.0252001379,
-0.007912715,
0.02007192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04879v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04879v2 | LongQLoRA: Efficient and Effective Method to Extend Context Length of Large Language Models | 2023-11-08T18:33:06 | 2023-11-09T05:21:28 | Jianxin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present LongQLoRA, an efficient and effective method to extend context
length of large language models with less training resources. LongQLoRA
combines the advantages of Position Interpolation, QLoRA and Shift Short
Attention of LongLoRA. With a single 32GB V100 GPU, LongQLoRA can extend the
context length of LLaMA2 7B and 13B from 4096 to 8192 and even to 12k within
1000 finetuning steps. LongQLoRA achieves competitive perplexity performance on
PG19 and Proof-pile datasets, our model outperforms LongLoRA and is very close
to MPT-7B-8K within the evaluation context length of 8192. We collect and build
39k long instruction data to extend context length of Vicuna-13B from 4096 to
8192 and achieve good performance both in long and short context generation
task. We also do some ablation experiments to study the effect of LoRA rank,
finetuning steps and attention patterns in inference.The model weights,
training data and code are avaliable at
https://github.com/yangjianxin1/LongQLoRA. | [
0.0137902228,
0.0820884332,
0.0012493886,
0.0614581108,
-0.0394110121,
0.0182594713,
0.0174221825,
-0.0205428656,
-0.0472752824,
-0.0171341095,
-0.0265303776,
-0.0400079377,
0.0083202701,
0.0021179803,
0.0528762043,
-0.0449549183,
0.0285325944,
-0.0514430031,
-0.0045493767,
-0.0064165425,
-0.0019536584,
-0.0069670216,
0.0185087528,
0.0096992292,
0.0123851243,
-0.0387780853,
-0.0432558507,
-0.0163617805,
0.0166433789,
-0.0384233855,
-0.0244689137,
0.0586203448,
0.0060067005,
0.0588035397,
0.0000022527,
-0.0353447646,
-0.0131567745,
0.0100688394,
-0.0223402288,
0.0617984608,
0.0341881774,
-0.0126430541,
-0.0157138053,
0.0112712039,
-0.0207003243,
-0.0005303023,
0.0617959201,
0.0258908812,
0.0325616486,
0.0601461641,
-0.0026497238,
-0.0525007509,
0.0317169502,
-0.0721180514,
0.0062753386,
-0.0902917609,
0.0107416986,
0.0024585044,
0.0252486039,
0.0096940277,
-0.0271034036,
0.0327523388,
0.0621381439,
-0.0103016952,
-0.0638888404,
0.0341134146,
-0.0233897083,
-0.0018288376,
0.0008625157,
0.0754538104,
-0.0456733629,
-0.0472127199,
-0.0192405079,
0.0104210414,
0.0011278259,
-0.0864690915,
-0.052884452,
0.0350148305,
0.0135863675,
0.0117581142,
0.0757866353,
0.0082462607,
0.0338961221,
-0.0388714857,
-0.0514657013,
0.0453794599,
0.0591532998,
-0.0221474133,
-0.0476462431,
-0.0351493657,
-0.0547542796,
-0.0506852046,
-0.0288149137,
0.0125960242,
-0.0252840593,
0.0307108983,
-0.0694201961,
-0.0226699915,
0.0362043083,
-0.0217078906,
0.0496449284,
0.0770856068,
-0.0160076302,
0.0287407171,
-0.0411994196,
0.0362070873,
-0.034817446,
0.0261810329,
-0.0318969004,
0.0073395777,
0.0157227889,
0.0115023209,
-0.0442024507,
-0.0206087362,
-0.0671095401,
-0.0290404409,
-0.0409027152,
0.0201651063,
0.0170076098,
-0.0122582959,
-0.0118757691,
-0.0064931484,
-0.0406516641,
0.0039502117,
0.0290274862,
0.0211669728,
-0.0448965356,
0.0159921702,
0.0018029516,
-0.0713687986,
-0.0442158878,
0.0093100192,
0.0192533452,
-0.0461449027,
0.0123841921,
0.0512448214,
0.0112600178,
-0.0582201667,
-0.0156330504,
0.0124394549,
-0.0132766096,
-0.098315388,
-0.0103603099,
-0.0724101365,
0.023980584,
-0.0011023832,
-0.015902333,
0.0108662648,
0.0173642449,
0.0388431549,
0.0116434433,
0.0768133327,
-0.0276977494,
-0.0053932061,
-0.0023462814,
0.0090806549,
0.0057193837,
0.0880657956,
0.0204831809,
0.010761966,
0.015528488,
0.0044314205,
-0.0332088545,
0.036806643,
0.0457465872,
0.0031011314,
-0.0490916446,
0.0177362543,
0.0193498004,
0.0060221688,
0.0482135154,
0.0496063791,
-0.044840239,
-0.0160382893,
0.0015011061,
0.0325449146,
0.0305660535,
0.0157657955,
0.0378821678,
-0.0174150951,
-0.0034734078,
-0.0125800855,
-0.0563685745,
0.0478391983,
0.0077866009,
0.05165511,
0.06426882,
0.036513932,
-0.0131797912,
-0.0177728441,
-0.0061172848,
-0.0070272484,
0.0169148259,
-0.002890242,
0.0180645082,
0.0047676503,
-0.0504610837,
0.0540030822,
0.0506567545,
-0.0601982772,
-0.0623770878,
-0.0549212582,
0.0506070964,
0.0522001199,
0.0170770623,
-0.0051799472,
-0.037145853,
0.0090862187,
-0.0057895901,
0.0396390073,
-0.000702926,
0.0312648788,
0.0153019559,
-0.0446311645,
0.001262107,
-0.0373550057,
0.0270206537,
0.0200533196,
0.0596573614,
0.0171068702,
0.0259345677,
-0.0448656008,
0.0230657589,
0.023048168,
-0.0438852832,
-0.0347403102,
-0.0463946834,
0.0209289026,
0.0434170291,
-0.012823862,
0.0136513421,
0.0348583199,
0.0459246002,
-0.0463829711,
0.0391931832,
-0.0096470993,
-0.0558940023,
-0.0668691322,
0.0814793408,
0.0060405503,
0.0043702708,
0.0079083843,
-0.0266838819,
-0.0411064588,
0.0393267199,
-0.0367244855,
0.0591827855,
-0.0446117222,
0.0233279243,
-0.0046326783,
0.0478449203,
-0.041459728,
0.059340138,
-0.0228875484,
0.0398926437,
0.0582993105,
0.0548714064,
0.0116321538,
-0.0241710562,
-0.0006167931,
-0.0095344773,
-0.0080598909,
-0.0021971033,
-0.0333510935,
0.0366488099,
-0.0220084861,
-0.0410481915,
-0.1032715291,
-0.0074762721,
-0.0389162898,
0.0302690137,
0.0370310806,
0.027521478,
-0.0144317802,
0.0027600306,
-0.0115308417,
-0.0134362821,
-0.0147422673,
0.0273288507,
0.0076253628,
0.0145805087,
-0.0712793916,
-0.050311029,
-0.0347603261,
0.0110362051,
0.0539423674,
-0.0179554522,
-0.0177635178,
-0.0414007641,
0.0297272392,
-0.0034872657,
0.0353349298,
-0.0322886668,
-0.0498544872,
0.0063943216,
-0.0226428416,
0.0387974381,
0.0515121184,
-0.0133044031,
0.0036949739,
0.040244177,
-0.0066510057,
-0.0012853099,
0.0253280811,
0.0055441894,
-0.0229486451,
-0.023236813,
0.0094579253,
-0.0398091488,
0.0627203137,
-0.0349392928,
-0.0245529581,
-0.0471352004,
-0.0011839091,
0.0247026421,
-0.0011324389,
0.0504857153,
0.0101070832,
-0.0442875884,
0.0410671197,
-0.0479916967,
-0.0641688332,
0.0291413441,
-0.0737472177,
-0.0000183481,
-0.060965348,
0.0080431141,
-0.0635296404,
0.089779377,
-0.0096307835,
0.0364590771,
-0.0581984669,
-0.0294298325,
-0.0070839874,
0.0092521124,
-0.0348246023,
-0.0091137523,
0.0499483235,
-0.022790404,
0.0366714336,
-0.0329879969,
-0.028769061,
-0.0345971957,
0.01468297,
-0.0402645208,
0.0082399379,
0.0258781705,
-0.0166717395,
0.0286713131,
0.03679692,
0.0112063745,
0.0573448762,
-0.0230434444,
0.0412078835,
-0.0274712481,
-0.0147283245,
0.0581703596,
0.0140298316,
0.0054794783,
-0.0216327477,
0.0151954768,
0.0244279001,
0.0123803085,
0.0166171286,
-0.0213466249,
0.0152056254,
0.0066076238,
-0.0026111992,
-0.0249390937,
0.0416702926,
0.0498464406,
-0.0548562631,
-0.0197610594,
0.0886943489,
0.0144718671,
-0.0466459021,
0.0217254013,
-0.0299393181,
0.049042698,
0.0286667366,
0.0307358168,
-0.1006856114,
-0.0390006304,
0.0223832093,
-0.0218702238,
0.0232830234,
0.0101321051,
-0.0345644094,
-0.1219085678,
0.0414577127,
0.0204359908,
-0.0730662048,
-0.0602799803,
-0.0318923891,
0.0014283381,
0.0439854041,
0.0363116376,
0.0594066419,
-0.0202712808,
0.014367206,
-0.0041360017,
0.0361664407,
-0.0308954362,
0.027437536,
-0.0154238138,
0.0306041166,
0.0496425629,
0.010593134,
0.0271712039,
-0.0608415715,
0.0408713445,
-0.0057573812,
-0.0110295145,
0.011520002,
0.022617653,
0.0304859336,
-0.0292453058,
0.006031563,
0.0388573334,
-0.0253457278,
-0.010514589,
0.0009505996,
0.0591201894,
0.0122285029,
-0.0046611908,
0.0137258619,
0.0042562135,
-0.0297334418,
0.0350799039,
0.0828553513,
-0.0098059457,
-0.0457783341,
-0.0280087348,
-0.0329313949,
-0.057084363,
0.0248155762,
0.004791338,
0.0129009904,
-0.0320865214,
-0.0204461776,
-0.0121073052,
0.0383702703,
0.0855927691,
-0.0146974297,
0.0284577459,
-0.0064993333,
-0.009560653,
-0.0616606846,
0.0137082171,
-0.0410786271,
0.0374844596,
-0.0701005459,
0.0062813396,
-0.004313149,
0.0024958914,
-0.0061214105,
0.035323482,
-0.0958840922,
-0.0605955534,
-0.0076991976,
0.0350843072,
0.0224974174,
0.0540970564,
-0.0156975519,
-0.0144038033,
0.0319681913,
0.0015464999,
-0.0188818239,
0.05825698,
0.0224148799,
-0.0272885803,
0.0244649556,
0.0600996614,
-0.0081574861,
0.0026551196,
0.0147104068,
0.0572615564,
-0.0036637771,
-0.0074721742,
0.0123392316,
0.0176933594,
-0.0129744709,
-0.0064692087,
0.0058882516,
0.00042987,
0.0656853765,
-0.0530168451,
0.0151526909,
-0.0446658954,
0.0007928066,
0.0106374817,
-0.0285247341,
0.0149665754,
-0.0633987635,
0.0128546646,
-0.0040540467,
-0.0104207611,
0.0425117835,
-0.0319589861,
0.0035869335,
0.0390456691,
-0.0044501293,
-0.0222042091,
-0.0315737464,
-0.0240007788,
0.0434431024,
-0.0448212549,
0.001153819,
0.0082055712,
-0.013345073,
-0.0588096716,
0.0708325058,
-0.0340767391,
-0.0223831814,
-0.0283743422,
0.0097325658,
0.0817773342,
0.0115772113,
0.0486763753,
0.0186658241,
-0.029994987,
-0.0039523914,
0.0413372107,
-0.0092634987,
-0.045224037,
0.0191927142,
0.0308766328,
-0.0115217892,
-0.0046374011,
0.0725789368,
0.0200373437,
0.03989508,
0.0365964621,
0.0235818662,
-0.0264936052,
-0.034718968,
-0.0251257475,
0.0337971672,
-0.014683364,
0.0092864186,
-0.0124666439,
-0.0970294327,
0.0035176114,
-0.0009678606,
-0.041534245,
0.005524504,
0.0222226772,
0.0432833545,
0.0037173796,
-0.0392199457,
-0.0111418189,
0.0111973612,
0.0602025278,
-0.0475033745,
0.0025091146,
-6.889776632e-33,
-0.0353005864,
0.0033657982,
0.0423051529,
-0.0420958772,
-0.0433598869,
0.0082478067,
-0.0479780324,
0.0014393956,
0.0105783306,
0.0039068763,
-0.025942944,
-0.0023878298,
0.0033368603,
0.0079500312,
-0.0095901852,
-0.0143527435,
0.0221040193,
0.0270202029,
0.0045855362,
0.0289846547,
-0.0127087766,
0.0329220556,
0.060627114,
-0.0236284845,
-0.0243818145,
0.0352977253,
0.0002198895,
-0.0141589763,
-0.0621807911,
0.052741684,
-0.0277044997,
0.0102792792,
0.0028191381,
-0.0437921137,
-0.0234017279,
0.0002368825,
-0.0646074414,
-0.0209265966,
0.04786852,
-0.0087671857,
-0.0369247086,
-0.0672187582,
0.0175517388,
0.0086743915,
0.0169016812,
-0.0113649657,
-0.027132377,
-0.03445746,
-0.0143259643,
0.0129752252,
-0.057580635,
0.0291287005,
0.0282239895,
-0.0039692577,
0.0285987109,
-0.0253578182,
-0.0146243861,
0.0200321879,
-0.045158688,
-0.0045108772,
0.0444216393,
0.0676561296,
0.0538994707,
0.0138096791,
0.0372833572,
0.0136573063,
0.0192935728,
-0.0295927729,
-0.0003197094,
0.0034566468,
0.0205704123,
0.0587491915,
0.0187019333,
0.0004600549,
0.0668755397,
-0.0010134116,
-0.0820326507,
-0.0429295525,
0.0111996802,
0.0401477627,
0.0452052243,
0.0105768591,
-0.0331341289,
-0.0272006914,
-0.0260827374,
-0.0182468817,
-0.0415887088,
-0.0178538673,
0.044542484,
0.0295734219,
-0.0177962966,
-0.0340914018,
0.0173120108,
-0.0348344743,
-0.0266317632,
0.0161785353,
-0.0265361108,
0.0193350315,
0.0033859711,
0.0437673926,
-0.0126541285,
-0.0032741418,
0.0126026385,
-0.0202734843,
0.0085728411,
-0.0327815562,
0.0425988995,
0.0304265358,
-0.0845071748,
-0.0015030162,
-0.0556767434,
0.0147567829,
0.0274394769,
0.0438359827,
0.0133615118,
0.0016279345,
0.0129715139,
0.0460536368,
0.0149509506,
0.0233372319,
-0.0005881301,
-0.0206342656,
-0.00315456,
0.0394842625,
-0.0460466594,
0.0092557091,
-0.0660212114,
0.0482810475,
0.0181363821,
-0.0731690377,
-0.027888516,
0.035897024,
3.002e-7,
0.0411826335,
0.0241834056,
0.0524999946,
0.0295475535,
0.0269055497,
-0.0049307109,
0.0102103222,
0.0193469115,
-0.0116050765,
-0.002044447,
-0.0279258452,
0.0172424559,
0.0098049352,
-0.0042346725,
-0.0765760168,
0.0210492499,
-0.037893597,
0.0091719097,
-0.0469517298,
-0.0341064222,
0.0111059221,
0.164015606,
-0.0089440169,
0.0041068424,
0.0325546153,
-0.013554127,
0.0148928836,
0.0117116254,
-0.0170223974,
0.0058658901,
0.0214043185,
-0.0180080589,
0.001781518,
-0.0202560853,
0.0137507813,
0.0423942804,
-0.0363132358,
0.0660406277,
-0.0174473282,
-0.0333498046,
0.0346529894,
-0.0219148118,
-0.014386571,
-0.0550578833,
0.0761834607,
-0.0070814132,
-0.0209574495,
-0.056297265,
-0.0216791984,
-0.0038145762,
0.0056242445,
-0.00145947,
0.0313555449,
0.0233076811,
0.0334030949,
-0.0449308492,
-0.009256986,
-0.0804230273,
-0.0589679033,
-0.0112080714,
-0.0364932716,
-0.0211084951,
-0.0661351383,
-0.011654919,
0.0308345612,
-0.0335134268,
0.0073511908,
3.414193036e-34,
0.0554948747,
-0.0257904939,
0.0305645559,
0.0268456675,
0.0261588283,
-0.0458690226,
0.0010189367,
0.0260453168,
0.0067062639,
-0.0876412392,
-0.0410761237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05772v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05772v2 | ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning with Language Models | 2023-11-08T17:59:15 | 2024-04-08T20:42:17 | Archiki Prasad, Alexander Koller, Mareike Hartmann, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal, Mohit Bansal, Tushar Khot | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used for interactive
decision-making tasks requiring planning and adapting to the environment.
Recent works employ LLMs-as-agents in broadly two ways: iteratively determining
the next action (iterative executors) or generating plans and executing
sub-tasks using LLMs (plan-and-execute). However, these methods struggle with
task complexity, as the inability to execute any sub-task may lead to task
failure. To address these shortcomings, we introduce As-Needed Decomposition
and Planning for complex Tasks (ADaPT), an approach that explicitly plans and
decomposes complex sub-tasks as-needed, i.e., when the LLM is unable to execute
them. ADaPT recursively decomposes sub-tasks to adapt to both task complexity
and LLM capability. Our results demonstrate that ADaPT substantially
outperforms established strong baselines, achieving success rates up to 28.3%
higher in ALFWorld, 27% in WebShop, and 33% in TextCraft -- a novel
compositional dataset that we introduce. Through extensive analysis, we
illustrate the importance of multilevel decomposition and establish that ADaPT
dynamically adjusts to the capabilities of the executor LLM as well as to task
complexity. | [
0.0282638781,
0.0426268764,
-0.0338127762,
-0.0017282175,
-0.0317719616,
0.0149111291,
-0.0244255252,
0.0011406519,
0.0245017093,
-0.0455301218,
-0.0151243471,
-0.0053549358,
0.0078416737,
0.0498459153,
0.0003065997,
-0.0798483863,
0.0167886522,
-0.0669255331,
-0.0220697355,
-0.0033848016,
-0.0126110772,
0.0064884168,
-0.0073441514,
0.0565311015,
0.0393361337,
-0.0175078921,
-0.0616660528,
-0.0082991831,
-0.0018652859,
0.0128897224,
-0.0200004298,
0.0234437417,
0.045053333,
-0.0046317098,
0.0000021741,
-0.041624032,
0.0019509655,
-0.0452765711,
-0.032503441,
-0.0125984205,
0.0147889266,
-0.0134072229,
-0.0181831568,
0.0429906473,
-0.0497213304,
0.0068159788,
0.0094905309,
0.036292281,
0.0505130999,
0.0578474328,
-0.0007049705,
0.018257007,
-0.0170701221,
0.0035344928,
-0.0293600541,
-0.0434483029,
-0.0065835714,
-0.0338387676,
0.028450096,
0.013525472,
-0.0078241844,
0.0057555544,
0.0368063487,
-0.0415332802,
-0.0385593288,
0.0336626731,
-0.0014239151,
-0.0220139734,
-0.0245352276,
0.0510907695,
-0.022485476,
0.0129443202,
0.0164494216,
-0.0102111259,
0.0010077539,
-0.0048885383,
-0.0282848813,
0.028778933,
-0.0108832465,
0.0255953837,
0.0027808738,
-0.0102420468,
0.0228106827,
-0.0026132292,
-0.0164217893,
0.0918287486,
-0.0179559235,
-0.0369875953,
0.0061958097,
-0.017776601,
0.0247028321,
-0.0851943269,
0.0118547603,
0.0661551803,
-0.1188355684,
0.0260344818,
-0.0176967829,
0.0101387221,
-0.0127446642,
-0.0492455065,
0.0884898826,
0.0407930948,
0.0248763338,
0.056408003,
0.0144842276,
0.0463260449,
0.0056610974,
-0.0315238126,
-0.034461461,
0.0249262396,
-0.0436422005,
-0.0080377758,
-0.0482036546,
0.0226867739,
-0.0713670924,
-0.0184660479,
0.0091633126,
0.0609187409,
-0.0148597937,
0.0299397428,
0.0323334523,
-0.0090994313,
-0.0324465707,
-0.0276907925,
-0.0539689325,
0.000107103,
-0.0332441926,
0.0279578362,
0.0055411118,
0.0183855649,
0.0285070669,
0.0162178613,
-0.0100711407,
0.0025603643,
-0.0174239557,
0.0875900462,
-0.0139975715,
-0.0057308907,
-0.0613712259,
-0.0543286279,
0.0093299113,
-0.0702627823,
-0.0061579342,
-0.0635088086,
0.041524712,
-0.01148945,
-0.0428194106,
-0.0248468257,
-0.008279766,
0.0019367771,
0.0142840808,
0.0574039184,
0.0455864295,
0.0379093811,
-0.0079698674,
0.0018508789,
-0.0027571213,
0.0901590586,
0.0469099879,
0.087466903,
-0.004305244,
0.0317102671,
0.0070102448,
0.0645458326,
-0.0444788411,
0.0329695754,
0.0014911331,
-0.0046032625,
-0.0388984531,
0.0206346698,
0.0151811959,
0.0435313061,
-0.0126039265,
0.0275979079,
0.0597047433,
0.0013316254,
0.0102655608,
0.0180454291,
0.0558744185,
0.046204865,
-0.0396294296,
0.0121334428,
-0.0335896872,
0.0392040275,
-0.0175293367,
-0.0281122942,
-0.0353341177,
0.0306042787,
-0.0166971907,
-0.0683887377,
-0.0111496197,
-0.0079321098,
0.0496020876,
-0.0036133667,
0.0283597652,
0.0216794182,
-0.0580912419,
-0.0167077053,
-0.0041773105,
-0.0348101147,
0.0045760637,
-0.064300783,
0.0210610088,
0.1039572731,
0.0453217179,
-0.0381356813,
-0.0123617044,
0.006894426,
0.0203693025,
0.0352537632,
0.0226003602,
-0.0480095223,
0.004521444,
-0.018979298,
-0.0591483265,
0.0026391584,
0.0027547933,
0.0080969222,
0.0101462547,
-0.032895308,
-0.0372816063,
-0.0043809167,
-0.001966187,
0.021091884,
-0.0491857044,
-0.0234578606,
-0.0060501844,
0.0160139352,
0.0357002057,
-0.0211967342,
0.0076318788,
0.0018822594,
0.0118364459,
-0.0303919725,
-0.0689279065,
0.0129815107,
0.0034172998,
-0.051738482,
0.0360603593,
0.004086148,
-0.0093693137,
0.0017982007,
-0.0383851752,
-0.0461994186,
0.0316757374,
-0.0463894419,
0.0363784954,
-0.0034830796,
0.0299917329,
-0.0078128912,
-0.0338955522,
-0.0120071005,
0.0569165498,
-0.0294362232,
-0.0586914271,
0.0409570746,
-0.0477550328,
-0.028720526,
-0.032014437,
-0.0102237808,
0.0348780416,
0.0180704072,
0.0064814966,
0.0245987866,
0.0442304388,
-0.0123303477,
-0.0521150567,
-0.1001704261,
-0.0066356286,
-0.0231495406,
0.0049702325,
0.0086353095,
0.0208064262,
-0.0047877398,
0.0154069439,
-0.0102878902,
0.0498657562,
0.0064761578,
0.018612925,
0.0205714274,
0.0046551321,
-0.0145030664,
-0.0244275201,
-0.0201018713,
-0.0209298711,
-0.0042763613,
-0.0057955408,
-0.0351912789,
-0.0616920926,
0.0547739156,
-0.0053452984,
0.0255328361,
-0.0088229124,
-0.0367481858,
-0.0026976014,
-0.0260338206,
0.0614525154,
0.0433278531,
-0.0203807484,
0.0426607318,
0.0809030756,
-0.0241794586,
-0.0495441519,
0.0532545298,
-0.026470894,
0.0012055773,
-0.0550426766,
-0.01773219,
0.0470878072,
0.0889715925,
-0.0156215262,
0.0055599087,
-0.0475433096,
-0.0120980944,
-0.0186311416,
-0.0136517538,
-0.0062438017,
-0.0233276933,
-0.038055487,
0.0858752877,
-0.0098589119,
-0.0397575498,
0.0657904819,
0.0012804052,
-0.0172622949,
-0.0323432088,
-0.0150356414,
-0.0521714017,
0.0620982014,
0.0111383321,
0.0186502114,
-0.0346773118,
-0.0165484492,
-0.0692630559,
-0.0064713289,
-0.012223918,
0.0048265732,
0.0375245139,
-0.0580019504,
-0.0061112121,
-0.0182246808,
-0.0791057348,
-0.025518585,
-0.0006379173,
-0.0183532927,
0.0275856983,
0.0456466861,
-0.0464715287,
-0.0501766354,
-0.0175749604,
0.0448619872,
0.0577397458,
0.0133695817,
-0.0366054811,
-0.0266511757,
-0.0195114501,
0.0385309793,
0.0542973168,
0.0006759094,
-0.0174016468,
0.0629543439,
0.0481187627,
0.0409198292,
-0.0514701456,
0.000490252,
0.0114368144,
0.0350861698,
-0.0287490133,
-0.0063534426,
0.0496528521,
0.016188655,
-0.0729817897,
0.0138518801,
0.0811372176,
0.0311262403,
-0.0349023417,
0.0270268619,
-0.0487514772,
0.0432946049,
0.034965571,
0.0507529229,
-0.0438254923,
-0.0178326648,
0.0302731413,
-0.0039108619,
0.0147076072,
-0.045620136,
0.0196520966,
-0.1085251868,
0.0704132542,
-0.0035973778,
-0.0060449382,
0.0323993228,
-0.0624647923,
0.0031967219,
0.008059836,
0.0113812508,
0.0268996358,
-0.0115952054,
-0.0271597132,
0.0002106352,
-0.0609514043,
-0.01322487,
0.0119499816,
0.0027707461,
0.015872065,
0.0642023608,
0.0510232672,
0.0202431586,
0.023466792,
0.0438605547,
0.0386809856,
0.016197335,
-0.0201336518,
0.0016756388,
0.0193826258,
0.0196054652,
-0.0053207385,
0.0175084136,
-0.046142634,
-0.0350868516,
0.0220725574,
0.1170828193,
-0.02052949,
-0.0260866564,
-0.0372577682,
-0.008069382,
0.012164562,
0.0692833513,
0.0092386259,
-0.0702179894,
-0.0716497749,
-0.0353867933,
-0.0347385481,
-0.062325839,
-0.0307520423,
0.0069138454,
0.0018460221,
0.0357095897,
-0.0707511604,
-0.0598850586,
0.0816334412,
0.0451651774,
0.016569199,
-0.0060090492,
0.0336445384,
-0.0060478076,
-0.0222649518,
-0.05389015,
-0.0193512719,
0.0272232573,
-0.0304056201,
-0.0167810787,
0.0025418699,
-0.0361073278,
0.0119948704,
0.0009797964,
-0.0406365506,
-0.0563566647,
-0.0019754891,
0.0469664223,
0.0288250539,
-0.0011306839,
-0.0006321933,
-0.0856462568,
0.0505283587,
-0.0002026975,
-0.0305349566,
0.0406097472,
0.0200096387,
0.0495015718,
0.0061269347,
0.0590580888,
-0.0527383015,
-0.0006696267,
-0.0185993575,
0.0716415718,
0.00838718,
-0.0036128326,
0.0069771749,
0.0085644536,
-0.0415404178,
-0.0455227792,
-0.0099067325,
-0.0244221594,
0.0267605577,
-0.0183238704,
-0.0247018505,
-0.0709259808,
0.0346921794,
0.0052497559,
0.0257225223,
0.0405174121,
0.0486090146,
-0.0168613158,
-0.0020134028,
0.0115906298,
0.0398691557,
0.0311925095,
-0.0379267186,
0.0699076653,
0.0398047641,
0.0085583758,
0.0012486051,
0.0020911519,
-0.0071007158,
0.0114415614,
0.0304719843,
0.0160720944,
-0.0161392577,
-0.0795674846,
0.0123252915,
-0.0338361301,
-0.0590758957,
0.0246519446,
0.0359532535,
0.0154684531,
0.0268440135,
0.0396051295,
-0.0584217906,
0.0046168212,
-0.0222468749,
-0.0065437877,
0.0043616393,
-0.0418352261,
0.0238329526,
0.0446600989,
-0.031338308,
-0.0079723643,
0.0882283822,
-0.0033802753,
0.0480235703,
-0.0084914118,
-0.0137204453,
-0.0468297936,
-0.0621669367,
-0.0003987074,
0.0293765459,
-0.0348994285,
-0.0343724154,
-0.0849919319,
-0.0460344814,
-0.0150919938,
0.0225857105,
-0.0175185464,
-0.0436651558,
0.0336041003,
0.0242603552,
0.0197784025,
-0.001204755,
-0.044490844,
-0.0201939195,
-0.0048810523,
-0.0275363997,
-0.0168031082,
-5.998549509e-33,
-0.0258092713,
-0.0206679385,
0.0732635409,
0.005864142,
-0.0080344295,
0.0067336117,
-0.0421841517,
0.0357429013,
0.0348930135,
0.0296277739,
-0.0304755587,
0.0082529821,
0.0101011414,
0.0205222294,
0.032618288,
0.0110080894,
0.0505738072,
-0.0206335895,
-0.0589662008,
0.0225167368,
0.0354559645,
-0.005843509,
0.0179099143,
-0.0106444992,
-0.0202777013,
0.0359860323,
-0.01601886,
0.0646792725,
-0.0011970819,
0.0668257698,
-0.0244290661,
0.0498764329,
0.0371713787,
-0.0053830282,
-0.0395687781,
0.0533286333,
-0.0455429181,
-0.0313251801,
0.0325312056,
0.0026543865,
-0.0614352226,
-0.0053054411,
0.0017226551,
0.0317004621,
-0.023455061,
-0.0162705742,
0.0082147699,
-0.0192847326,
-0.0100452453,
-0.0114850374,
-0.0752674118,
0.0091259321,
-0.0050795046,
-0.0238238089,
0.0377202891,
0.0476947725,
0.0015772195,
-0.0094753969,
-0.0174891707,
0.0360143073,
-0.0229601134,
0.0176244024,
0.0592562892,
0.0020147124,
-0.0001858066,
0.0633982494,
0.022538431,
0.0506476238,
-0.0462554097,
0.0121733118,
0.0175551567,
0.0873995125,
-0.0181171261,
0.0255970135,
-0.0176527668,
0.0403576605,
-0.024307901,
0.0504929647,
0.0402971394,
0.0465804413,
0.0231277328,
0.0418827422,
-0.010530063,
-0.0411668606,
-0.0187319964,
0.0230170023,
-0.0147773074,
-0.0307734143,
0.0332582109,
0.0344484746,
-0.007569022,
-0.0338496231,
0.0407639779,
-0.0246196277,
-0.0340315551,
0.0309537034,
-0.0461892635,
0.0377114341,
0.0187178291,
0.0332132764,
-0.0285583604,
-0.0267606787,
-0.0073447451,
0.0048811976,
-0.0038443408,
0.0154035678,
-0.0172178242,
0.0702576563,
-0.0616099983,
0.0080794618,
-0.0495633893,
0.0367792398,
0.0046899184,
0.0385004357,
0.0486611016,
-0.0426219888,
-0.0031406921,
0.0083787413,
0.0153449383,
-0.073865965,
-0.0247588381,
0.0057368237,
-0.013012195,
-0.0059781936,
-0.0161921512,
-0.0178838242,
-0.0424705669,
0.024394745,
0.0245442521,
-0.0589225739,
-0.0136611415,
0.0252320264,
2.846e-7,
-0.0023729717,
0.0497520678,
-0.0006001781,
0.0008691062,
0.0374356881,
0.0335767195,
-0.0255869981,
-0.008742962,
-0.0283336639,
0.0020161236,
0.0312909856,
0.0297893155,
0.054185003,
0.0432099923,
-0.0852290168,
0.0152522577,
-0.0433222055,
-0.0177982152,
-0.0709630847,
-0.0271601342,
0.0375611484,
0.0576708727,
0.0308645293,
-0.0201369226,
-0.0119194137,
-0.0498213358,
0.0373020358,
-0.0444877669,
0.0025698971,
0.0065599079,
-0.0201217569,
0.0043269699,
0.0019419414,
-0.0288543086,
-0.0151707623,
0.0339622907,
-0.0225456115,
0.0938227475,
0.0139515866,
-0.0200035851,
0.0241752267,
-0.0370993353,
0.0103921704,
-0.013640807,
0.0601729043,
-0.0495298095,
-0.0351166315,
-0.0206699297,
0.0315621607,
-0.0196964815,
-0.0470823087,
-0.0259938221,
0.0172001123,
0.0391741358,
0.0018978788,
-0.0153289475,
-0.0040111993,
-0.0791747347,
-0.0184017736,
0.0105185229,
-0.0757499635,
-0.0386658832,
-0.0451269858,
0.0623853132,
0.0056472188,
-0.0559551418,
-0.0188627262,
3.004754579e-34,
0.0222041141,
0.0240219757,
-0.0006734157,
0.0618952401,
0.0336054303,
0.0050217393,
-0.0347359776,
0.038498316,
0.0445507318,
-0.0628670454,
-0.0394405164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04850v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04850v2 | Rethinking Benchmark and Contamination for Language Models with Rephrased Samples | 2023-11-08T17:35:20 | 2023-11-11T05:11:18 | Shuo Yang, Wei-Lin Chiang, Lianmin Zheng, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models are increasingly trained on all the data ever produced
by humans. Many have raised concerns about the trustworthiness of public
benchmarks due to potential contamination in pre-training or fine-tuning
datasets. While most data decontamination efforts apply string matching (e.g.,
n-gram overlap) to remove benchmark data, we show that these methods are
insufficient, and simple variations of test data (e.g., paraphrasing,
translation) can easily bypass these decontamination measures. Furthermore, we
demonstrate that if such variation of test data is not eliminated, a 13B model
can easily overfit a test benchmark and achieve drastically high performance,
on par with GPT-4. We validate such observations in widely used benchmarks such
as MMLU, GSK8k, and HumanEval. To address this growing risk, we propose a
stronger LLM-based decontamination method and apply it to widely used
pre-training and fine-tuning datasets, revealing significant previously unknown
test overlap. For example, in pre-training sets such as RedPajama-Data-1T and
StarCoder-Data, we identified that 8-18\% of the HumanEval benchmark overlaps.
Interestingly, we also find such contamination in synthetic dataset generated
by GPT-3.5/4, suggesting a potential risk of unintentional contamination. We
urge the community to adopt stronger decontamination approaches when using
public benchmarks. Moreover, we call for the community to actively develop
fresh one-time exams to evaluate models accurately. Our decontamination tool is
publicly available at https://github.com/lm-sys/llm-decontaminator. | [
0.0121705336,
0.1157653481,
-0.0202713218,
0.0467016883,
-0.0399748087,
0.0014354426,
-0.0068999194,
0.047574468,
-0.0274575353,
-0.0342676006,
-0.0493842624,
-0.0296832491,
0.0266239885,
0.0019459823,
0.0450190492,
-0.0080085099,
0.0744640529,
-0.0065402794,
-0.0075049112,
0.0017707362,
-0.0120332371,
0.0014365929,
0.0304610934,
0.0187070202,
-0.007132763,
-0.0043279482,
0.0135696996,
-0.0055464297,
0.0125763062,
-0.016911542,
0.0318772048,
0.0597393401,
-0.0054644211,
0.0845655128,
0.0000019805,
-0.0564706735,
0.002248256,
0.0287941471,
-0.0221418813,
0.0663304776,
0.0338138938,
-0.0261432584,
-0.0136860125,
0.0357037783,
-0.0219712872,
-0.0097318459,
0.0332934074,
0.0009174093,
0.0333011188,
0.0899711102,
-0.0082922159,
-0.0023803057,
0.0313602835,
-0.0400837101,
-0.0024946737,
-0.0013711945,
0.0305560976,
-0.0115646394,
0.0014714081,
-0.0167862363,
-0.0147723574,
0.0319066904,
-0.0053035757,
0.0576384328,
-0.0567866825,
0.0188005865,
-0.048836071,
-0.0296744909,
0.0138352606,
0.0557394475,
-0.0408014432,
-0.040647693,
0.0402352735,
-0.0110857422,
-0.0342066437,
-0.0345370956,
-0.014411265,
0.0298907869,
0.0061456352,
0.0405970626,
-0.0011375406,
-0.0152793285,
0.060768988,
-0.0106697772,
-0.0077683544,
0.0564232841,
0.0523497984,
-0.0561534129,
0.0091743087,
0.0225598961,
-0.0139816115,
-0.0427372232,
0.0069797141,
-0.0369839035,
-0.0015917525,
0.0257829577,
-0.0565340519,
-0.0468801446,
0.0594240353,
-0.007962699,
0.0542373285,
0.0418858677,
-0.0150947236,
0.0138507588,
-0.020134367,
0.0479637347,
-0.0207299367,
0.0691649616,
-0.0283261631,
0.0035922322,
-0.0009631395,
0.0176392216,
0.0028422489,
-0.0229284484,
-0.018380573,
0.0134255718,
-0.0249451455,
-0.012217748,
-0.0132296989,
-0.0154298823,
0.0241180696,
-0.0329997726,
-0.049263142,
0.0263727084,
-0.0114387991,
-0.0172469635,
-0.020841537,
0.0179085918,
-0.0053795502,
-0.1006299555,
-0.0375326686,
0.0050140172,
0.0014312032,
-0.0586665273,
0.020854203,
0.0403107516,
0.0181351509,
-0.0416306853,
-0.0100783315,
-0.0055162483,
-0.0230883621,
-0.0772889405,
0.0061635324,
-0.0394182913,
0.0271041095,
-0.0075081042,
-0.0154245393,
-0.0510663241,
-0.0030347318,
0.0465486199,
-0.0446337275,
0.0546850376,
-0.0389059298,
0.0086388914,
-0.0188712925,
0.0131018497,
0.0025633955,
0.0594279766,
0.017705176,
0.0085815284,
0.0406060815,
-0.0242440533,
-0.0028144401,
0.0755913183,
0.0234400723,
0.0146810245,
-0.0319458134,
-0.0158362109,
0.0330996253,
0.0315853357,
0.0585139021,
0.0751040503,
-0.0242751129,
-0.0475377813,
0.0635404438,
0.0342631675,
-0.003768963,
0.0122115985,
0.0048565487,
0.0273099095,
0.0382406265,
0.0238263626,
-0.0480714627,
-0.0388568342,
-0.0298537686,
0.0215884149,
0.0308396723,
0.0553982556,
-0.0028939031,
-0.0101452209,
-0.0530963913,
-0.0331698544,
0.0285124239,
-0.0074201338,
0.0539250039,
-0.0116773769,
-0.0531179979,
0.0578627698,
0.0360168591,
-0.07869526,
-0.0175866298,
-0.0463044494,
0.0251287706,
0.0172907114,
0.0472313911,
0.0043960013,
-0.0101109641,
0.0058047641,
-0.0141167613,
0.0158503819,
0.0584260635,
0.0147755565,
0.0704159215,
-0.052044604,
-0.0218620729,
-0.0069944113,
0.0381165482,
0.0130419834,
0.0542328618,
0.0168855693,
0.0370332189,
-0.0539215729,
-0.0351702422,
0.0700268447,
-0.0465060659,
-0.0074867592,
-0.0197430253,
-0.0121806581,
0.0481911786,
0.0007198516,
-0.0243788734,
0.0057502971,
0.0566798411,
-0.0018649253,
0.0273084044,
-0.0090955971,
-0.0235368181,
-0.0232754834,
0.0573858768,
-0.0192250665,
-0.0224778838,
0.104988873,
-0.0374819376,
-0.0360748954,
-0.0002933767,
0.0083911186,
0.0352686569,
-0.0431707911,
0.0494884737,
-0.0366265066,
0.043998722,
-0.025234092,
0.0426955968,
0.0127961887,
0.04257017,
-0.0098089175,
0.000297915,
0.0523890741,
-0.0345816985,
-0.0634774417,
0.0225450862,
-0.0113306614,
0.0333173648,
0.0092942528,
0.0148198036,
-0.0662112758,
-0.0135073075,
-0.0926716104,
0.020076884,
-0.0121919177,
0.0332940929,
0.0261600763,
-0.0062415269,
-0.0369470716,
-0.0005954744,
-0.0124847665,
-0.0286764037,
0.027063651,
0.026533436,
0.0077298027,
-0.0000276056,
-0.027158089,
-0.0377232023,
-0.0167822596,
-0.024792634,
0.0338305868,
-0.0409633033,
-0.0222417731,
-0.017393766,
0.0507454313,
-0.0290708411,
0.0145913968,
-0.0014629016,
-0.0564364418,
0.0220946707,
-0.0067658173,
-0.0105870133,
0.035430178,
-0.015876079,
-0.0182745121,
0.0590183511,
0.0112097589,
-0.0556838065,
-0.022843523,
0.0282333568,
-0.0440099947,
-0.0264814198,
-0.0466031469,
0.0107538681,
0.0822603479,
-0.010036367,
-0.0254202671,
-0.0373769253,
0.0157487672,
-0.0148450173,
-0.0232812818,
-0.004720326,
-0.0062503815,
-0.0606767274,
0.0473895371,
-0.0390764326,
-0.0671491399,
0.0226337183,
-0.0538355857,
-0.0100134462,
-0.0389127918,
-0.0114958547,
-0.0329627059,
0.0239238441,
-0.0037351334,
0.0165185165,
0.0200400632,
-0.0104890475,
-0.0261717103,
0.0265619922,
0.0087350979,
-0.0500361174,
0.0311912019,
-0.052295167,
0.0333500728,
-0.0149512971,
-0.0452010632,
-0.0282756183,
-0.0452929884,
-0.0144516965,
-0.0094434517,
0.0081088571,
-0.0101226158,
-0.0113768084,
-0.0264670625,
-0.0323573016,
0.0536510684,
-0.0023428986,
0.0297513753,
-0.0137320049,
0.028337691,
0.0487499461,
-0.0386226512,
0.0373602659,
-0.0374272354,
-0.0208058599,
0.0280311648,
0.0309420098,
0.0357476734,
-0.0346842408,
-0.0085011581,
0.0412838571,
-0.004478713,
-0.0052181655,
0.0179636199,
0.0400124006,
-0.0343296565,
-0.0101247411,
0.0984640718,
0.0138940318,
-0.0145427492,
0.0205713566,
0.016911678,
0.059506543,
0.0159485862,
0.0110846348,
-0.09278512,
-0.0107239122,
0.0307229664,
-0.0001612098,
-0.0032586716,
-0.0199550744,
-0.0329188444,
-0.1291424632,
0.0038870864,
0.0282785334,
-0.0450245775,
0.0142174941,
-0.0197831281,
-0.0080339368,
-0.0418254733,
0.081950821,
-0.000537148,
-0.0088985972,
0.0104342131,
0.0140582686,
-0.0050248117,
-0.1180623323,
0.0171310566,
-0.057452824,
0.0639626086,
0.0185538232,
0.0242817476,
-0.0219367258,
-0.0252990667,
0.047441069,
-0.0201331023,
-0.0104779759,
0.0133639118,
0.0626284108,
0.0201899745,
-0.0343943313,
0.0111067127,
-0.0131054586,
-0.0378886163,
-0.0023831592,
-0.0053831586,
0.0308315698,
0.0127393268,
-0.0538309552,
0.011063653,
-0.0274500288,
-0.0288724806,
0.0966479629,
0.022471115,
-0.0136814564,
-0.0220704507,
-0.008235842,
0.0129273534,
-0.0175932497,
-0.00742047,
0.0274124593,
-0.0294469167,
-0.0165137686,
-0.0644912273,
-0.0346610695,
0.0140599655,
0.03210143,
0.0076751183,
0.0375511348,
-0.0543148108,
-0.0115287201,
-0.0427842736,
0.0657657087,
-0.0475619063,
0.0217373781,
-0.07238435,
0.0076430128,
-0.0078438334,
0.0483228378,
-0.0275571439,
0.0187238194,
-0.1166381761,
-0.0994702876,
0.0172577556,
0.0380267575,
0.0321086533,
0.0339309797,
-0.0165531356,
-0.0475347005,
-0.008936719,
0.0025789354,
-0.0308634602,
0.0553274304,
0.0197951812,
-0.0856501237,
0.0075079575,
0.0221474897,
-0.0330999009,
-0.0009820788,
0.0159862936,
0.0301622115,
0.0006566362,
-0.0149390278,
0.0308383871,
0.065467,
0.0734084398,
-0.0380793512,
-0.0207850579,
-0.0070618484,
-0.006907803,
-0.0298966076,
0.0140942587,
-0.021794498,
-0.013999139,
0.0415593423,
0.0293047968,
-0.0327179134,
0.0289278254,
-0.0342901908,
0.0429384708,
-0.040661253,
-0.0123836938,
0.0013201773,
0.0039947699,
0.0367652178,
0.024914667,
-0.0017242625,
0.0133605674,
-0.0097593144,
0.0492931269,
-0.0183935445,
0.0016247868,
-0.0181808285,
0.0233150199,
0.0112808542,
0.0546780936,
-0.0564856492,
-0.0131354937,
-0.0318965539,
0.0088146403,
0.0343700983,
-0.0227496214,
0.055655051,
-0.0235095192,
-0.0063982191,
-0.0354645327,
-0.013419291,
-0.0482725129,
0.0008516105,
0.0185396206,
-0.0082052648,
-0.0445021316,
0.0322593302,
0.0895896032,
0.049353648,
0.054015778,
-0.0043604672,
0.009069494,
-0.0015066506,
-0.0186307542,
0.0161770377,
0.0032737707,
-0.0182636436,
-0.0643450543,
-0.0345836394,
-0.0988868698,
0.0052992562,
0.0168879535,
0.0115220789,
0.0014637404,
0.0066710813,
0.0466285869,
-0.0324441157,
0.006106487,
-0.0269930381,
-0.0258026142,
0.0027118754,
-0.0482268371,
-0.0089100255,
-6.472909601e-33,
0.0047841868,
0.0326173753,
-0.0088324882,
-0.055288326,
-0.0318143032,
0.0024262029,
-0.0126658697,
-0.0179255698,
-0.026738815,
-0.0152238738,
-0.0366359726,
0.0183178801,
0.0218949337,
0.0052842656,
-0.015270194,
0.0052313432,
0.0528435446,
-0.0047364389,
-0.0418304503,
-0.0216177274,
-0.0059693605,
0.0370814651,
0.0668320656,
-0.0470115058,
-0.0153512498,
-0.0169935767,
-0.0298911314,
-0.0149814067,
-0.045451425,
0.0521417111,
-0.0114634829,
0.0411270931,
0.0251835492,
0.0165901929,
-0.0366031006,
-0.0094100377,
-0.0508385077,
-0.0039794091,
0.0423420109,
0.0096920049,
-0.003089248,
-0.0256808829,
0.0585296303,
-0.0354971737,
-0.0422253385,
0.0139670465,
-0.0187709406,
-0.0226588976,
-0.0465695746,
0.004406597,
-0.0249532275,
0.0218103062,
0.0135884294,
0.0379242711,
0.0431545787,
0.0102208667,
-0.0032523593,
0.0385683663,
-0.0299378969,
0.0171976741,
0.0407676771,
0.0524791889,
0.0721528307,
0.0068626809,
0.0133440606,
0.0752210766,
0.0309865549,
-0.0107584437,
0.0742429867,
-0.0196127258,
0.0714496151,
0.0410744734,
0.0201285295,
0.0556970723,
0.079132922,
-0.0469078496,
-0.0427865684,
0.037012957,
0.0035173744,
-0.0024486757,
-0.008421964,
0.0318356492,
-0.0501062311,
-0.0383184031,
-0.0599728599,
-0.0132482136,
-0.0460858531,
-0.0329815708,
0.0592371374,
0.0078040017,
-0.0029666878,
0.0093999682,
-0.000179483,
-0.0373274572,
0.0036299063,
0.000267586,
-0.0217382573,
0.0092889015,
-0.013552024,
0.0654146746,
-0.0379922763,
-0.0363040529,
0.0184680317,
0.0234299041,
0.0485644005,
-0.0226097871,
0.0272489283,
0.0133465184,
-0.0810888261,
0.0260903295,
-0.0379110165,
0.0183352232,
0.021909846,
-0.0181148332,
0.0459020697,
-0.0015920626,
0.0326510407,
0.0178873166,
0.0612787157,
0.0192521866,
-0.0384168327,
-0.0057884548,
0.0244669933,
0.0133725042,
0.0171133149,
-0.0140977157,
-0.010351113,
0.0367425606,
0.0800347403,
-0.0343505442,
-0.0055856439,
0.0153567456,
2.665e-7,
0.0342740901,
0.0474769287,
0.0081966482,
-0.0141754374,
0.0032502413,
0.0051126815,
-0.0641248673,
0.0172282811,
-0.0127463462,
0.0065374821,
-0.004531818,
-0.0175346527,
0.0883855671,
0.0146793686,
-0.0705999061,
0.0150317969,
-0.0713848546,
-0.0061362507,
-0.0798815712,
-0.0174795873,
-0.0164757092,
0.1001069844,
0.0025663974,
-0.0292762164,
-0.0109748179,
-0.0523731112,
0.059192352,
-0.0738575384,
-0.0298681613,
0.0162065029,
0.0365682505,
0.0210836176,
0.0270387121,
-0.0001395951,
-0.028583318,
0.0113382638,
0.0217222311,
0.0679512247,
0.0029821154,
-0.0084893815,
-0.0014832111,
-0.0215471871,
-0.0304988604,
-0.0552467071,
0.0780405253,
0.0161704011,
-0.0261027869,
-0.0427453518,
-0.028673565,
-0.0294992253,
0.0363106057,
-0.0230973903,
-0.0077922097,
0.0190024022,
0.0185626224,
0.0019248711,
-0.0441651717,
-0.0552899353,
-0.0294454768,
0.0020346928,
-0.042065952,
-0.0574354194,
-0.0361678228,
0.0254916418,
0.0142069273,
-0.067327112,
0.0143077709,
2.808595795e-34,
0.0336645506,
-0.0424000956,
0.0398206078,
-0.0087842233,
0.0424925424,
-0.0077261534,
0.0128091061,
0.0298170429,
-0.0470649339,
-0.0668229163,
0.0121078882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04823v1 | Hierarchically Gated Recurrent Neural Network for Sequence Modeling | 2023-11-08T16:50:05 | 2023-11-08T16:50:05 | Zhen Qin, Songlin Yang, Yiran Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers have surpassed RNNs in popularity due to their superior
abilities in parallel training and long-term dependency modeling. Recently,
there has been a renewed interest in using linear RNNs for efficient sequence
modeling. These linear RNNs often employ gating mechanisms in the output of the
linear recurrence layer while ignoring the significance of using forget gates
within the recurrence. In this paper, we propose a gated linear RNN model
dubbed Hierarchically Gated Recurrent Neural Network (HGRN), which includes
forget gates that are lower bounded by a learnable value. The lower bound
increases monotonically when moving up layers. This allows the upper layers to
model long-term dependencies and the lower layers to model more local,
short-term dependencies. Experiments on language modeling, image
classification, and long-range arena benchmarks showcase the efficiency and
effectiveness of our proposed model. The source code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/HGRN. | [
0.0144866379,
0.066244632,
-0.0047199237,
0.0288034044,
-0.0461691916,
-0.0080596181,
0.0227996632,
-0.0095979739,
0.0033602295,
-0.0382193364,
0.0157659221,
-0.0740801543,
0.0165525619,
0.0497900359,
0.0057142009,
-0.0528200828,
0.033762686,
-0.0217021406,
0.0050092726,
-0.0107589588,
-0.0106531475,
-0.00643411,
-0.0197331421,
0.0467570201,
-0.0032410133,
-0.0010661819,
-0.0082963295,
-0.0310858935,
-0.0220467076,
-0.0568684451,
0.0318799876,
0.0386355557,
0.0567265935,
0.0400486775,
0.0000021788,
-0.0087448256,
-0.0116219157,
-0.0271039326,
0.0136651788,
0.0244156979,
-0.0186140593,
0.0235038903,
-0.0089320885,
0.0131867444,
-0.0201999173,
-0.0467506163,
0.0295820385,
0.0527329557,
0.0324979722,
0.0481936671,
0.0217659082,
-0.0729829893,
0.0403204374,
-0.0720100477,
0.0427233502,
-0.0434345715,
0.0182494,
-0.0075137392,
-0.0119740162,
-0.0376649015,
-0.0344629958,
0.0299537592,
0.0281822402,
0.0314832032,
0.0325581953,
0.0265089031,
0.0290092658,
0.0032885869,
0.0061453325,
0.0310317092,
-0.0882068053,
-0.0219171382,
0.0134224258,
-0.0084950663,
-0.0289996732,
-0.0237242188,
-0.0425453484,
0.0261534769,
-0.0024896357,
0.0042238696,
-0.0461071916,
0.0089109149,
0.0566172004,
-0.0017713698,
-0.0321813077,
0.0251489095,
0.0203485768,
-0.0059527429,
-0.0709865838,
-0.0454242378,
0.0140335085,
-0.0733230859,
0.0183075834,
0.0814045444,
-0.0065834071,
0.0115111889,
0.0195062663,
-0.0150599917,
0.0188041721,
-0.0533553585,
-0.0169902705,
0.0347427912,
0.0041438388,
0.005212639,
-0.0131177958,
0.0475864001,
-0.0315217748,
-0.0478128642,
0.0020228997,
0.0475729071,
-0.0557033829,
-0.0016214012,
-0.0097794151,
0.0370730869,
0.0237673167,
-0.0067934752,
-0.0761728659,
-0.0177391823,
-0.00409385,
-0.0003957985,
0.0094911978,
0.029466901,
-0.0325926095,
-0.0173257478,
-0.0079118945,
0.0301815066,
-0.0194147043,
-0.0107270405,
0.0327616669,
-0.0425697304,
-0.0275289733,
0.0257102866,
0.0174050052,
0.0071569565,
-0.0140286721,
0.0999897197,
0.0536007807,
-0.0489807092,
-0.0672391579,
0.0025167582,
-0.0083259391,
-0.0778993964,
0.0596260317,
-0.0517361164,
0.002081662,
-0.0411672816,
-0.0169110764,
-0.0411714427,
0.0234898366,
0.0313696824,
0.0212838743,
0.0459170528,
0.0353059098,
-0.0724228173,
0.0183409657,
0.0186413508,
0.0176741108,
0.0056929775,
0.0476043709,
0.0428342745,
0.004369623,
-0.0426955894,
0.0312617756,
0.0097891986,
0.0216568336,
-0.0773294494,
-0.0626240894,
-0.0382108614,
-0.0158364754,
0.0469246097,
0.007083986,
0.0399277359,
-0.0261988211,
-0.0046158079,
0.0522143617,
0.0588728115,
0.0097315963,
0.0514923371,
0.0536625199,
-0.0205836464,
-0.0368961506,
0.0026057311,
-0.0407322682,
0.0668800771,
0.0241293181,
0.0432565026,
-0.013613957,
0.0337248296,
-0.0380874537,
-0.0195489395,
0.0020020083,
-0.0278460961,
0.0060393931,
-0.0110532213,
0.0590150617,
0.0156124495,
-0.0834110528,
0.0808546245,
0.0052154046,
-0.0485903993,
0.006128293,
0.0025702058,
0.0215028338,
0.0353321098,
0.0439023525,
-0.0148207061,
-0.0273737349,
-0.0399973691,
-0.0416189656,
0.0016821929,
-0.0066136816,
0.0203743447,
-0.0191488098,
-0.0896488652,
-0.0280274525,
0.038001854,
0.0088916719,
0.0405643843,
-0.0205429401,
-0.0110657504,
0.0538817979,
0.0121611916,
-0.0307347458,
0.0187041666,
-0.0621389486,
-0.0159167089,
0.0349715203,
0.0163675454,
0.0338818282,
0.0199701283,
0.0223346539,
0.0209688842,
0.0834238008,
-0.0382364765,
-0.0524712056,
-0.0410084836,
-0.1180737168,
-0.0308650266,
0.0116708679,
-0.0042671058,
0.0352854282,
0.0118648922,
-0.0230443664,
-0.049937252,
0.0816801488,
-0.0703508705,
0.0536588281,
-0.0433814153,
0.0129387109,
0.0200288277,
0.0118831927,
-0.0125999926,
0.0530267507,
-0.054254137,
0.0198551584,
-0.0363921225,
-0.0038616634,
-0.0028341562,
-0.0299635455,
-0.0452705398,
0.0278925411,
-0.0210031625,
-0.0092396829,
0.008291957,
-0.0043791272,
-0.0073137158,
-0.0237325784,
-0.0076889857,
-0.003130364,
-0.0283090286,
0.0046420959,
-0.0178276543,
0.0115426006,
0.0327602774,
-0.0193678252,
-0.0617915131,
0.0171880275,
-0.0063632317,
-0.0094689205,
0.0332040936,
-0.0035852143,
-0.0491345599,
-0.0131456461,
-0.0246362034,
0.0182114393,
0.0684350431,
-0.0439617373,
-0.0428790152,
-0.0011536352,
-0.0309036765,
-0.0305945557,
0.0472916253,
-0.0397714712,
-0.0333680287,
-0.0160324536,
-0.0272765569,
0.0205423646,
0.0212469641,
0.0393432826,
0.0066011208,
0.0309191607,
-0.0333675519,
0.0076437183,
0.0145018687,
-0.0391167626,
0.0262498092,
0.0319229439,
0.0172587056,
-0.050612133,
0.1040201858,
-0.0088706752,
0.0203414168,
-0.0359499417,
-0.0137026254,
0.0036646577,
0.028450897,
0.0072770906,
-0.0149603412,
-0.042233184,
0.0035718023,
-0.0118544316,
-0.0305373743,
0.0247016959,
-0.0181854591,
-0.0004364025,
-0.0123427985,
0.0091379322,
-0.0608914308,
0.0336699709,
0.0378465839,
-0.0064383992,
0.0317587852,
-0.0585076064,
0.0084653432,
0.0167335346,
-0.0324354768,
-0.0250330586,
0.0370960459,
-0.015416421,
0.0125340158,
-0.0110665504,
-0.0119222589,
-0.037647374,
0.0466524661,
-0.010775568,
-0.0195150394,
0.0180943776,
-0.0467839874,
-0.0446729138,
0.0194290113,
0.0096011786,
0.0677733421,
-0.0067308899,
0.0336667672,
-0.0007866501,
0.0754645169,
0.0403019674,
0.0053338078,
0.0218918771,
0.0155865923,
0.0108481711,
0.0353264213,
0.0165825058,
0.0148369716,
-0.0597092584,
0.0090601193,
0.0103791039,
-0.038242396,
0.0028235009,
0.0515207164,
-0.0031161895,
-0.1094722748,
-0.0209780615,
0.0867614076,
0.0005752185,
-0.060420014,
0.002298682,
0.0513748191,
0.0319528356,
0.0212687757,
-0.0285209753,
-0.0354107618,
0.0012801382,
0.0197803471,
-0.0001090767,
0.0142682996,
-0.0382381268,
-0.0123904208,
-0.0796883181,
0.0155804818,
0.0085697193,
-0.0556298941,
-0.0377459712,
-0.0152934203,
-0.0456020981,
0.0084350146,
0.0041960347,
0.048983451,
-0.0191617496,
-0.0225308724,
0.0546545014,
-0.0704833046,
-0.0322487615,
0.0421371385,
-0.0400251299,
0.0199087989,
0.0624315552,
0.0072084651,
0.0053034443,
-0.0441590957,
0.0305954199,
0.0202911291,
0.0200535972,
0.0069516688,
0.0173155461,
0.0113009373,
-0.0256287884,
-0.0255634487,
0.0301475693,
-0.0621190779,
-0.0024396693,
-0.0209017247,
0.0726296231,
0.0112986146,
-0.0220451225,
-0.0116906231,
0.013167656,
-0.0053021675,
0.0394682661,
0.0454916954,
-0.0310172997,
-0.0492376424,
-0.0062070964,
0.023232583,
-0.0777195841,
-0.0259395353,
-0.0070369933,
0.0405725203,
-0.0656806305,
-0.0665416941,
-0.0320599973,
-0.0215797592,
0.0239788182,
0.0055592954,
0.0277383104,
0.0710558146,
-0.0060150712,
-0.0467261784,
-0.0170766804,
0.0004391279,
0.017528614,
-0.0384658016,
0.035799589,
0.0489349328,
-0.028702464,
-0.0176278092,
0.0208893735,
-0.1014820784,
-0.020572478,
0.0193923954,
0.0484430604,
0.0123394765,
0.0218003914,
0.039268095,
-0.0244841445,
0.0122542484,
-0.011497057,
0.0195984505,
0.0084642973,
0.0124895722,
-0.0175954904,
-0.0213518739,
0.0211806279,
-0.0317443237,
0.0499860123,
0.0015789673,
0.0365923122,
-0.0084111197,
-0.0090163099,
-0.0043893238,
-0.0393300876,
0.0487935916,
0.0138641186,
-0.0083148647,
-0.0052609588,
0.0635826215,
-0.0122159142,
0.0218897369,
-0.0333767571,
-0.0031625915,
0.0204401296,
0.0065593426,
-0.0084662195,
-0.0441217944,
0.061810527,
-0.0048603155,
0.0296546314,
0.0399001725,
-0.0137159396,
0.0036891506,
0.0031991457,
0.0080512632,
-0.0428289771,
-0.0021217093,
-0.0203954801,
0.018992139,
-0.0179584529,
0.0550106838,
0.0020232336,
0.0355232358,
-0.0350666568,
-0.0029259261,
-0.0391970053,
0.0026888442,
-0.0238280073,
0.0036104377,
0.1062003598,
-0.0016702716,
-0.0166636538,
0.0135877198,
0.0248366352,
-0.0291911066,
0.0647719279,
0.0012734185,
-0.0456001535,
0.0196986794,
0.0281119961,
-0.043240618,
0.0108814863,
0.0735265985,
0.0854848772,
0.0475059114,
0.0193251912,
0.0275049843,
-0.015955314,
-0.0220268201,
-0.0208900701,
0.0292039718,
-0.0259711388,
-0.0186413191,
-0.0326862782,
-0.0545396321,
0.0611357726,
-0.0135380533,
0.0546469465,
-0.0037991409,
0.0415928848,
0.0118658906,
-0.0153432572,
0.014592181,
-0.0301155504,
0.0333528183,
-0.0076784613,
-0.0307537876,
-0.0681989118,
-6.262305095e-33,
0.0014223841,
-0.0168894231,
0.0281468742,
0.0197828803,
-0.0449897684,
-0.0022386624,
-0.0587911718,
-0.0214633588,
0.0123216258,
-0.0382407717,
-0.0098614302,
-0.0022975982,
-0.0073896465,
0.0596568473,
0.052991759,
-0.0227526296,
0.0559443608,
-0.0102652907,
0.0399894379,
0.0246046148,
0.0650390238,
0.060879346,
0.0653132722,
-0.0272324793,
-0.0415536128,
-0.0464177094,
0.0090874229,
-0.0036548153,
-0.0366978459,
0.0208155755,
-0.0369700454,
-0.002706477,
0.0423495397,
-0.0409370661,
-0.0289702769,
0.0057917731,
-0.089052178,
-0.0206502303,
-0.0314411111,
0.009830392,
-0.0154286074,
-0.0326055363,
0.0592686795,
0.0031680448,
-0.0086235479,
-0.0342496969,
0.0080432845,
-0.003833927,
-0.0868228003,
-0.0669255331,
-0.0096276542,
0.0274166707,
0.0139499977,
-0.0186534654,
0.0115915891,
0.0213011466,
-0.0123331649,
0.0130684162,
-0.0732312351,
-0.0178703051,
0.0062061246,
0.0673172325,
0.0350844562,
0.0486281328,
0.0261808503,
0.0480107628,
0.0444180332,
0.0109974397,
-0.0349728838,
-0.0084562339,
0.0012638381,
0.0072502564,
0.054600466,
-0.0469257124,
0.0831731334,
-0.0461214557,
-0.0684118345,
-0.0257238466,
0.0037789657,
0.1240921244,
0.0164695811,
0.0461774357,
-0.0208561625,
0.0007277678,
-0.0059059318,
-0.0075445785,
-0.0397377759,
-0.0505301431,
0.0241786893,
0.0236171894,
0.0214700978,
0.0198040865,
0.0034350057,
0.0041706376,
0.0251696482,
0.0545167103,
0.0368368141,
0.0083633,
0.0017478216,
0.0165547393,
-0.0366370641,
0.0138869071,
-0.0073744664,
-0.0077378275,
-0.0045317551,
-0.009771239,
0.0326946042,
0.030930208,
-0.0340973958,
-0.0260098409,
-0.0359350629,
0.0334682129,
0.0127108591,
0.0846805274,
0.0582505763,
-0.0158513598,
-0.0063760532,
0.0836580619,
-0.0240598079,
-0.010872907,
-0.0052844845,
0.0622382052,
0.0187800601,
0.046930708,
-0.011030199,
-0.0397198088,
-0.0543418936,
0.0417449959,
-0.0136069329,
-0.047439307,
-0.0060553504,
0.0407202207,
2.961e-7,
-0.0247817263,
0.0293650776,
0.0492885746,
-0.0056950231,
0.0606490672,
0.006413124,
-0.036686074,
0.0139485793,
-0.0126525629,
0.0231418889,
0.0257236511,
-0.0396218151,
0.0564231537,
-0.0143575054,
-0.1066042483,
-0.0380059443,
-0.0970065072,
-0.0070525743,
-0.0054096612,
-0.0114055406,
0.0220999271,
0.084478572,
0.0368824936,
-0.0015082242,
0.0203604847,
-0.029646093,
0.03026071,
0.0269002076,
0.003304959,
-0.0042735566,
-0.0011370631,
0.011903367,
-0.0532849915,
0.0045479112,
-0.0414540805,
0.0126679083,
-0.0058896579,
0.04839449,
0.021060735,
-0.0547456928,
0.0235318597,
0.0277525913,
-0.0219145585,
-0.0098563181,
0.0335918516,
-0.0341430716,
-0.0133292498,
-0.0091986544,
-0.0450467691,
0.0044475524,
0.0004939973,
0.0086146677,
0.0024706037,
0.0105773984,
-0.0281424038,
-0.0242196731,
0.0078371922,
-0.082120873,
0.0169740748,
-0.0041492297,
-0.0693986714,
0.0272875894,
-0.0533489659,
0.0029908293,
0.0277213603,
0.0089352774,
-0.0250980482,
2.560265037e-34,
0.0252188575,
-0.0767269284,
-0.0519781783,
0.0360404849,
0.0048464243,
-0.0036778066,
-0.0571869463,
0.0423065759,
0.0141529813,
-0.0451649502,
-0.0254554637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04816v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04816v1 | MTGER: Multi-view Temporal Graph Enhanced Temporal Reasoning over Time-Involved Document | 2023-11-08T16:41:37 | 2023-11-08T16:41:37 | Zheng Chu, Zekun Wang, Jiafeng Liang, Ming Liu, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The facts and time in the document are intricately intertwined, making
temporal reasoning over documents challenging. Previous work models time
implicitly, making it difficult to handle such complex relationships. To
address this issue, we propose MTGER, a novel Multi-view Temporal Graph
Enhanced Temporal Reasoning framework for temporal reasoning over time-involved
documents. Concretely, MTGER explicitly models the temporal relationships among
facts by multi-view temporal graphs. On the one hand, the heterogeneous
temporal graphs explicitly model the temporal and discourse relationships among
facts; on the other hand, the multi-view mechanism captures both time-focused
and fact-focused information, allowing the two views to complement each other
through adaptive fusion. To further improve the implicit reasoning capability
of the model, we design a self-supervised time-comparing objective. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on the TimeQA
and SituatedQA datasets. Furthermore, MTGER gives more consistent answers under
question perturbations. | [
0.0138255097,
0.0416260511,
0.0248630103,
0.000158127,
-0.0630591139,
0.0129861915,
0.0180393159,
-0.0143597024,
0.0320676565,
-0.0385986641,
0.0194873065,
-0.0005060613,
-0.0007105716,
0.0243997388,
-0.0547004454,
-0.0476432294,
0.0616448335,
0.0008896681,
0.0279152244,
0.0062406166,
0.0064646057,
0.0126157906,
-0.0464964882,
0.0001823608,
-0.0301150829,
-0.0587508269,
-0.0326294564,
-0.0202107262,
0.0473491587,
-0.0286369324,
-0.0328790396,
0.0286869146,
0.0075244661,
0.0240207687,
0.0000017562,
-0.0036611648,
-0.040772438,
-0.0146792335,
-0.0364997312,
0.0123129422,
0.0015268277,
0.0121284844,
0.0480341576,
-0.0095667997,
-0.0604728013,
-0.0179440621,
-0.018784171,
0.0997134671,
0.0478410125,
0.0673783496,
-0.0184002239,
0.0000010785,
0.0102637513,
0.0165804811,
0.0396070108,
-0.0627552271,
-0.0130351214,
0.0373434871,
0.0518566146,
0.0286919661,
0.0146769751,
0.0289035551,
0.0235850923,
-0.0428794026,
0.0346007012,
0.0551196225,
-0.0038545965,
0.0410960577,
-0.0274404846,
0.0602113977,
0.0603521615,
-0.0405084416,
0.0095700165,
-0.0071074245,
-0.0210491605,
0.050584048,
-0.0388040356,
-0.0558319353,
-0.0317905582,
0.0156205865,
0.0235384218,
0.0232982896,
0.0248883832,
0.0175899435,
0.0270025451,
0.0771694481,
-0.0141296731,
0.0086381892,
-0.0343715809,
-0.0000071558,
0.0139849912,
-0.0365186371,
0.0146001242,
0.0938897058,
0.0012676807,
0.0029117505,
0.0003693021,
0.032976944,
-0.0113443267,
-0.0865706205,
-0.0218713973,
0.0128040649,
0.0174549203,
0.1066726968,
-0.0051188427,
0.0424856804,
-0.0314365216,
-0.0323387086,
-0.0362907276,
-0.0260697585,
-0.06307818,
-0.0046930411,
-0.0120055964,
0.0285774041,
-0.011587237,
-0.0185574312,
-0.0219668504,
0.0278410595,
0.0067537632,
-0.0101815602,
0.0150957555,
0.0358236656,
-0.0213352907,
-0.0303679015,
-0.0473551303,
0.0195918363,
-0.0216997564,
0.0215261616,
-0.059301883,
-0.005717624,
-0.0027967861,
0.007069678,
0.0195192695,
-0.0264268313,
-0.0381158218,
0.0149443205,
-0.0475944392,
0.0203328077,
-0.0585875474,
-0.0521501042,
-0.0186503027,
-0.0011978494,
0.0103745023,
-0.0560319945,
0.0238251574,
-0.0064963484,
-0.0385697335,
0.0136457067,
-0.0014978634,
-0.0153336981,
-0.0045439675,
0.0731355026,
0.0473237745,
0.0132218702,
0.0558736436,
0.0168038346,
0.040549513,
0.0362084694,
0.0067812391,
-0.0471262634,
0.0087092407,
0.0340936631,
-0.0386179499,
-0.0171553195,
0.0200352333,
0.0114189405,
-0.0154722566,
0.0148538873,
-0.0102392426,
0.0093972059,
-0.0446823128,
0.0113164112,
-0.020064516,
-0.0556053668,
0.0137773911,
-0.014245701,
-0.0031288147,
-0.0283691362,
0.0351614803,
-0.0315303504,
0.0307329968,
0.0141265206,
0.0123290261,
0.0517062582,
-0.0006490258,
0.0042441967,
-0.0423967503,
-0.0044596652,
-0.0435933918,
-0.0424894877,
-0.0162628144,
0.0099309636,
-0.0080118412,
-0.0231171008,
0.0529135652,
0.0081215929,
-0.0286675896,
0.0474939123,
0.0126787499,
-0.0005038316,
-0.0113313459,
0.0198321678,
0.0150379529,
0.0484071039,
0.0478137583,
-0.0602272227,
-0.0645688102,
-0.0000763454,
0.0190885998,
-0.0095195277,
0.0889860094,
-0.0309559517,
-0.044574745,
-0.0217544045,
-0.0546527877,
-0.0237110294,
0.0019016701,
0.0150735546,
0.0214759614,
0.0444217622,
-0.0013126554,
-0.0348582827,
0.0400962755,
-0.0024961915,
-0.027305631,
-0.0116939712,
-0.017516382,
0.0132297855,
-0.0047822567,
0.0418978892,
0.0079442374,
0.0251928866,
0.0302736983,
-0.0144568933,
-0.0193891488,
0.0672889724,
-0.0771392137,
-0.08169581,
0.0527193174,
-0.0081108715,
-0.054448735,
-0.0081428522,
-0.0376270227,
-0.0592470691,
0.0276276823,
0.0249817651,
0.0344189331,
-0.0322299562,
-0.0120508103,
0.0164033659,
-0.0316319354,
-0.043371927,
0.0984432399,
-0.0092826858,
-0.0045775394,
0.0127667198,
-0.0069667408,
0.0276255589,
0.0019480966,
0.0366364159,
0.0147302495,
0.0201966166,
-0.0263448693,
0.015155985,
-0.0205353498,
-0.0752351433,
0.0155835385,
-0.1153389812,
-0.0235708598,
0.0024534825,
0.0088686915,
0.00393864,
-0.0251212083,
0.0119711738,
-0.0293043833,
-0.0315495208,
-0.0130566107,
-0.03635047,
-0.0095287887,
0.0573896766,
0.0078141158,
0.0467818603,
0.0035164803,
-0.0239778236,
-0.0964313671,
0.0641179681,
0.0518040098,
-0.044900436,
0.022674581,
-0.0212220978,
-0.053618852,
0.0238553714,
-0.0133548509,
0.0421663113,
0.0368429236,
-0.0442955717,
0.0677561238,
0.0562489592,
0.0001510514,
0.0147977639,
0.0232043304,
-0.0277830511,
-0.0603719428,
0.0503604971,
-0.0307709537,
0.0635745823,
-0.0011436705,
0.0179514624,
-0.0504427962,
0.0147794429,
-0.0130076837,
-0.0128544793,
-0.0415747017,
0.0286903083,
-0.0426348522,
0.0099479649,
-0.0109565379,
-0.0101240929,
0.0152994776,
-0.0153028825,
-0.0517199114,
-0.0000777598,
0.0707394332,
0.0155424913,
0.0138202943,
0.0167282373,
-0.0182305556,
-0.0830100104,
0.0822741911,
-0.0092382208,
-0.0038381198,
-0.0165085476,
-0.0375877284,
-0.0349553078,
-0.0179674961,
0.0736874789,
-0.0117255747,
0.0141116213,
-0.0391278863,
0.0450481549,
0.0190702956,
-0.0104925148,
-0.0157263894,
-0.0771624446,
0.0102903778,
-0.0050073098,
-0.0740946159,
-0.0004227502,
-0.0534175858,
0.0072428524,
-0.0419197977,
0.0256907512,
-0.0354727618,
-0.0334406942,
0.0037963253,
0.0784585625,
0.0516108796,
0.0047378442,
-0.0073893205,
-0.0095347967,
0.025385553,
0.0349377133,
0.0525664017,
-0.0610560663,
-0.0431771763,
0.0271842126,
-0.0488777421,
-0.0172473025,
0.008159874,
-0.056888707,
0.0429426916,
-0.0517296232,
0.0021043534,
0.0978342146,
0.0601651482,
-0.0122724976,
-0.0297342949,
-0.0411447175,
-0.003534561,
0.0126462523,
0.0001849004,
-0.0398446769,
-0.0072720139,
-0.0298522431,
-0.0287857596,
0.0056977803,
-0.0341863148,
-0.0117782839,
-0.0532766469,
-0.0090535069,
0.0131601766,
0.0425061062,
0.0298660025,
-0.0187622234,
0.0086792195,
-0.0003336285,
-0.0470541529,
-0.0036829067,
0.008068732,
-0.0071180137,
0.0321193114,
-0.0125853727,
0.0182839148,
0.0610597096,
0.0507113934,
0.0145672625,
-0.0545695387,
0.0698605999,
0.0070429207,
-0.0185302086,
0.0537466966,
0.0065962449,
0.0017679709,
-0.0409529842,
0.0198322404,
-0.0035358795,
0.0025674056,
-0.0272040237,
0.0184538718,
0.0160247721,
-0.0311323442,
-0.0327243432,
0.1019294932,
-0.0337270834,
-0.0036123209,
-0.0527281724,
-0.0157287586,
-0.015644135,
0.029574519,
-0.0287127625,
0.0139951706,
-0.0705310553,
0.0185159929,
-0.0111931833,
-0.0353152379,
-0.023374673,
-0.002689423,
-0.008361496,
-0.0067618196,
-0.0515248813,
-0.0568193421,
-0.0334244482,
0.0388646796,
-0.0398100801,
0.0007225769,
0.0358241387,
-0.0159052461,
-0.0750904307,
0.0316447876,
0.0132499235,
0.0111812958,
0.0090718968,
0.0080246693,
0.0324807912,
0.0027772873,
-0.0051952396,
0.0146344388,
-0.0472002625,
-0.0631494969,
-0.0215136465,
-0.0445029847,
0.0095137786,
0.0901167914,
-0.0342474952,
0.0630774722,
0.0707821026,
0.0159315057,
-0.0191184022,
-0.0239255819,
0.0472205691,
0.0065396749,
-0.0109684318,
0.0280908756,
-0.0415152758,
-0.0178522933,
-0.0309278741,
0.0146217318,
-0.0660114884,
0.0048229098,
0.0009012727,
-0.0269461516,
0.0464101136,
0.0806931779,
0.0027565879,
-0.0228699539,
-0.0022633635,
-0.0486752354,
-0.022874007,
0.0061400728,
0.0329186432,
0.0168565921,
-0.021973867,
-0.0309217107,
0.0215447191,
0.0156752449,
0.0034940781,
-0.012669513,
-0.0003225028,
0.0415843651,
-0.0173425563,
-0.0210331138,
-0.0113801481,
-0.0076857368,
0.0109275151,
-0.0156909581,
-0.0023083088,
0.003301285,
0.04434596,
0.0374827534,
0.037227951,
-0.0516553968,
-0.0508807972,
-0.1144736558,
0.0151190348,
0.0246910229,
-0.0212135073,
0.0277915318,
-0.0299757663,
0.043391753,
-0.0055348706,
-0.0055940975,
0.0169022959,
0.0479846261,
0.0293967407,
-0.0107677514,
0.0296343062,
0.0151441284,
0.0260956381,
0.0499505997,
0.0647449344,
-0.0161115918,
0.0529054552,
0.0306451805,
-0.0450520851,
-0.019617999,
-0.0468315259,
-0.0411410555,
-0.0174914133,
-0.004321191,
0.0421514921,
-0.0521069393,
-0.0285576805,
0.0539860353,
0.0094490834,
-0.0362416133,
0.0288970768,
0.0029419186,
0.0447556525,
0.0318743512,
-0.056597285,
-0.0553532802,
0.0677151307,
0.0196329989,
-0.0217406359,
-0.0257260446,
-6.23030373e-33,
-0.0273554698,
-0.0754107162,
0.0432990231,
0.0055430685,
-0.0340720862,
0.0499448441,
-0.0251206923,
-0.0060634245,
-0.0341972969,
0.0331886299,
0.0034988946,
0.0816568807,
0.0151787298,
-0.031400755,
0.0285968687,
-0.0194991194,
0.0360268056,
-0.015499833,
0.0092133135,
0.0415363461,
0.0749760345,
-0.0005789283,
0.0331458673,
-0.0506337211,
0.0307264682,
0.0116576888,
0.0235720035,
0.0588343404,
-0.0113872467,
0.0725124106,
0.0164473522,
-0.0151198236,
0.0254104994,
-0.0078535657,
-0.0238643363,
0.0185834114,
-0.125377059,
-0.0979944691,
-0.0022515713,
0.0123266745,
-0.0385936648,
-0.0079743667,
-0.0252462011,
0.0061731264,
0.035873495,
-0.0728732646,
0.0507649668,
0.0102196829,
-0.0091693643,
-0.0515452959,
0.0084164832,
0.0728170723,
-0.0516357012,
-0.0009624123,
0.0159274898,
0.0350863896,
0.0525474399,
-0.0180705097,
-0.0536113828,
0.0239524357,
-0.040082477,
-0.013897243,
0.0273586046,
-0.0119416248,
0.0035942034,
0.0349247754,
-0.0559765399,
0.0103235552,
-0.0352826677,
0.0238312911,
-0.0195359588,
0.028796155,
0.0267270114,
-0.0260830037,
-0.0114752268,
0.0213479195,
-0.0632328093,
0.0242641531,
0.0318448469,
0.0595863461,
-0.0040542772,
0.0093314471,
-0.027928859,
0.0078817634,
0.0097575523,
0.0528098233,
-0.0291395131,
0.0348444581,
-0.0000908874,
0.0299360659,
0.015637897,
0.0316888392,
0.0153784296,
-0.027026834,
-0.0141504938,
0.0611546077,
-0.0106093381,
0.0140399346,
0.0031847213,
0.0480800942,
-0.0462790206,
0.0125759291,
-0.0004515336,
-0.0069117057,
0.0185458772,
-0.0172315631,
0.0170590729,
0.0159777254,
-0.0234573223,
-0.0349684916,
-0.0044834502,
-0.0381426923,
-0.024463525,
-0.0284091644,
0.0534469821,
0.0161300544,
-0.0143488329,
0.0566247702,
0.031977389,
0.0544266775,
-0.0184600912,
0.012813447,
-0.0015818822,
0.0194478128,
0.0150626935,
-0.002247296,
-0.0047369651,
0.0189575106,
0.0047893785,
-0.0184896626,
-0.0116130104,
0.0368542299,
2.421e-7,
0.0474666283,
0.0481731258,
0.0412694104,
0.0490921475,
0.0201982912,
0.0150869843,
-0.0405779518,
-0.0104464693,
-0.0313020684,
0.007000606,
0.031529516,
0.0473938845,
0.0153138908,
0.0581372902,
-0.0151086971,
-0.0360963158,
-0.0518447757,
-0.053559199,
-0.0746100917,
-0.028732324,
0.057916984,
0.0222805757,
0.0425120369,
0.0099608088,
-0.0210693255,
-0.0628941879,
0.078537792,
0.0411576703,
-0.0588816367,
0.0226395074,
0.0801319331,
-0.0270231534,
-0.0050815362,
0.0047376011,
-0.019591596,
0.0204233658,
-0.0044384287,
0.0222779661,
-0.0301932842,
-0.0692347214,
-0.0326581597,
-0.0397051461,
-0.0085806083,
0.0106328763,
0.0868198574,
-0.0051022791,
-0.0189001169,
-0.0055034007,
-0.0288605932,
0.0419131592,
0.040717274,
0.0532635115,
-0.0076512466,
0.010373936,
0.0033460904,
-0.0257114042,
-0.0138790542,
-0.0897356272,
-0.0193618312,
0.0421147346,
-0.0040045553,
0.002008399,
0.0156159038,
-0.005869396,
-0.0016099554,
-0.0402337648,
-0.0017848196,
1.74924132e-34,
0.0506665781,
0.0109913442,
-0.0365922712,
-0.015250124,
0.0345800072,
-0.029059859,
-0.0297164246,
-0.0245418046,
0.0415285826,
-0.0570216328,
-0.0119813019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04799v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04799v1 | DACBERT: Leveraging Dependency Agreement for Cost-Efficient Bert Pretraining | 2023-11-08T16:18:32 | 2023-11-08T16:18:32 | Martin Kuo, Jianyi Zhang, Yiran Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Building on the cost-efficient pretraining advancements brought about by
Crammed BERT, we enhance its performance and interpretability further by
introducing a novel pretrained model Dependency Agreement Crammed BERT
(DACBERT) and its two-stage pretraining framework - Dependency Agreement
Pretraining. This framework, grounded by linguistic theories, seamlessly weaves
syntax and semantic information into the pretraining process. The first stage
employs four dedicated submodels to capture representative dependency
agreements at the chunk level, effectively converting these agreements into
embeddings. The second stage uses these refined embeddings, in tandem with
conventional BERT embeddings, to guide the pretraining of the rest of the
model. Evaluated on the GLUE benchmark, our DACBERT demonstrates notable
improvement across various tasks, surpassing Crammed BERT by 3.13% in the RTE
task and by 2.26% in the MRPC task. Furthermore, our method boosts the average
GLUE score by 0.83%, underscoring its significant potential. The pretraining
process can be efficiently executed on a single GPU within a 24-hour cycle,
necessitating no supplementary computational resources or extending the
pretraining duration compared with the Crammed BERT. Extensive studies further
illuminate our approach's instrumental role in bolstering the interpretability
of pretrained language models for natural language understanding tasks. | [
0.0380953029,
0.0655692369,
-0.0002569597,
0.0337291025,
-0.01470003,
0.0021184608,
-0.0034621169,
-0.0456632413,
-0.004368328,
-0.063339062,
-0.0070733679,
-0.0109853894,
-0.0133805955,
0.0278732199,
0.0063852696,
-0.1044101119,
0.0553777739,
0.001699128,
-0.0044843648,
0.0071901581,
0.0426070541,
0.0080987159,
-0.0051538786,
0.0260882303,
-0.0560732335,
-0.0430825241,
-0.0317828469,
0.0219213907,
0.004589187,
-0.0144419773,
0.0223540254,
0.0814613551,
0.0554153845,
0.0353064388,
0.0000022291,
-0.0462918021,
-0.0279845744,
-0.0153619088,
-0.0074976049,
0.0676659718,
-0.0365356803,
-0.0413338281,
-0.0017611674,
0.0101806931,
-0.0224863496,
-0.0117454445,
0.0261321962,
0.0237146132,
0.0878760219,
0.070701234,
-0.0238448605,
-0.0366810225,
0.0108430563,
-0.0276696309,
-0.0050015161,
-0.0376318656,
-0.006180346,
0.0138792265,
-0.008399548,
-0.0427321009,
-0.0216156635,
0.0137735037,
0.038893979,
-0.0136199286,
0.0239383988,
0.0329314917,
-0.0813678727,
-0.0206830576,
-0.0016598961,
0.0793340877,
-0.0453056283,
-0.0105900858,
-0.0139257815,
-0.0121907862,
-0.0076984065,
0.0031094374,
-0.0233607423,
0.015009379,
0.0128861275,
0.0268403869,
0.0150034325,
0.0067568249,
0.0279516447,
0.0096724341,
-0.07018736,
0.0369216539,
0.0192541704,
-0.0320241489,
-0.0156220365,
0.0317195244,
-0.0687092468,
-0.0571039766,
0.0327911787,
-0.0016264699,
-0.0285652895,
0.0449204594,
-0.0844577774,
-0.0275030527,
0.0268033873,
-0.0285659637,
-0.0063166437,
0.0581917167,
-0.0492219217,
0.0550755225,
-0.0410402566,
0.0234454703,
-0.0096522318,
0.004612871,
-0.0314821489,
0.028205853,
-0.0425831825,
-0.0051797461,
-0.0868114233,
0.0365438126,
-0.0304119755,
-0.0441663377,
-0.0167134553,
0.0365805477,
0.035448283,
0.0103738084,
0.0226349328,
0.0113435388,
-0.0368694179,
-0.0111639379,
-0.0107320482,
0.0257095695,
-0.0765664726,
-0.0089696618,
-0.0209354032,
-0.0645153224,
-0.0384709723,
0.0189560112,
-0.000868206,
-0.0474220365,
0.0127156377,
0.0177372098,
0.0070284866,
-0.0563936383,
-0.022348186,
-0.0202633329,
0.0023010422,
-0.0424125828,
0.0122014536,
-0.0479639657,
0.0306862928,
0.012446668,
0.0106809437,
0.0008205908,
0.0049388097,
0.0079182982,
-0.0323969051,
0.0820682794,
-0.0534062348,
-0.0211862233,
-0.0318267494,
0.0251118112,
0.0191829521,
0.0747354478,
0.0323365591,
0.0346933641,
0.027340591,
-0.0210368317,
-0.0193488654,
0.0155092441,
0.0296593476,
-0.0118134432,
-0.0323696099,
0.0341698267,
-0.0191270187,
0.038184341,
0.0565013252,
0.0391844176,
-0.0371921286,
-0.0143465456,
0.0346885286,
0.0570101663,
-0.0063214866,
0.0215907637,
0.0269810818,
0.0338673517,
0.0187692195,
0.0220185667,
-0.0543721057,
0.0010190173,
0.0051289555,
0.0173443463,
0.0016197478,
0.0335627459,
-0.0113194557,
-0.0252327342,
-0.0147313504,
-0.0345286578,
-0.0303794816,
-0.0300769284,
0.0239521861,
0.0080250921,
-0.0611528978,
0.0812436491,
0.0419887491,
-0.0484113432,
-0.0199853219,
-0.0218008626,
0.007732721,
0.0687125921,
0.0736657232,
-0.0358998962,
-0.0960440487,
-0.0003407434,
-0.0117733693,
0.0395007506,
0.0050966614,
0.0133916959,
0.0404350013,
-0.0663668439,
-0.0105169304,
-0.0242669173,
0.0165287834,
0.0425319262,
0.0083796373,
-0.048360981,
-0.0267820377,
0.0059176981,
0.0016709376,
0.0361167379,
0.0389181487,
0.0109264012,
-0.0145319635,
0.0172229111,
0.0387444347,
0.0104549928,
-0.0479746312,
0.0010222921,
0.0263095368,
-0.0457081497,
0.003542807,
0.028948253,
-0.0832761079,
-0.0359106027,
0.0123564415,
-0.0191225503,
-0.0539058968,
0.0066628838,
-0.0420976393,
-0.0276215822,
-0.0034775268,
-0.031861838,
0.1166515276,
-0.0369359516,
-0.0052945712,
0.0113744941,
0.0271646827,
-0.0273626633,
0.0628251061,
-0.0356464796,
-0.0237721782,
0.0029820506,
0.0181893706,
0.0446916632,
-0.0027920788,
-0.0025787973,
-0.009192992,
0.0021892525,
-0.0188670792,
0.0016755135,
0.0017607361,
-0.0387152173,
-0.0126791503,
-0.0582663827,
0.0062708524,
-0.018835498,
0.0306852087,
0.0289549585,
0.0140053378,
-0.0239845291,
-0.0269571412,
0.0232242029,
-0.0380251221,
-0.0372299477,
0.0150032397,
0.0176665168,
-0.0004656533,
-0.0138073759,
-0.0358858109,
-0.0021662505,
-0.019878082,
0.0457170345,
0.021745095,
-0.0319504552,
-0.0207389537,
-0.0017959395,
-0.0120571544,
0.0198638961,
0.0213119779,
-0.0679294169,
0.0271799788,
-0.0069219409,
0.0491939262,
0.0467130579,
-0.0157322939,
0.0284648631,
0.0260956567,
-0.0388883203,
-0.0559107065,
0.0421273522,
0.0178788528,
0.0308119301,
-0.0115452772,
-0.0160401501,
-0.0034449305,
0.1042906642,
-0.030853821,
-0.0082465736,
-0.0549646579,
-0.020682957,
0.0013925397,
-0.0251893476,
-0.0011347421,
-0.0275063459,
0.0047443644,
0.0090582995,
-0.0364882275,
-0.0567782484,
0.0779006481,
-0.0596662425,
-0.0220780373,
-0.0713692978,
0.0245235953,
-0.018002132,
0.0593471453,
0.0471550375,
0.0066563832,
0.0128069539,
-0.0462716371,
0.0080804126,
0.0164208543,
-0.0094306106,
0.0100783855,
0.0329288021,
-0.0464759581,
0.0113135567,
-0.0230813976,
-0.0127713168,
-0.0327951983,
-0.0474059433,
-0.0368342921,
-0.0066714482,
0.0426760502,
-0.0397976078,
-0.0262052566,
-0.0038165569,
0.0018442771,
0.0267651659,
0.0071092662,
0.0043507358,
-0.0320876017,
0.0334843323,
0.034913417,
0.0119625935,
-0.0228693113,
-0.0002332324,
-0.0114909196,
0.0457151867,
0.0499958619,
-0.0031380923,
-0.0772439465,
0.0112176491,
0.0056546764,
-0.0346489213,
-0.0424853191,
-0.0127958227,
0.0239620004,
-0.0821331143,
0.0048865872,
0.1275489032,
0.0479278155,
-0.0123092514,
0.0004462641,
0.0146457609,
0.0879671648,
0.0108743841,
0.0343791321,
-0.1006782651,
-0.0566670075,
0.0124118719,
-0.0042810049,
0.0297520328,
-0.0285330266,
-0.0077797999,
-0.0768270567,
0.0234300327,
-0.0279452708,
0.0188526809,
0.0239303038,
-0.0523141548,
-0.0169763882,
-0.0009045736,
0.0091014551,
-0.0257010981,
-0.0013826139,
0.0261940677,
0.0106467223,
-0.0432861149,
-0.027219763,
0.0221680254,
-0.0426600315,
0.0435615815,
0.067289412,
0.0063852076,
-0.0085408352,
-0.0143562993,
0.0148298703,
-0.0113292718,
0.0040307362,
-0.028592173,
0.0782458782,
-0.0299732201,
-0.0227717757,
-0.022959711,
-0.0167606901,
-0.0183471683,
-0.0167387053,
-0.0243024435,
0.0770052746,
-0.008209086,
0.0172130503,
-0.0092251906,
-0.0094422158,
-0.0230441559,
0.0770162046,
0.0586906038,
-0.0412333012,
-0.0480141081,
-0.0196911786,
0.0128862504,
-0.0817686617,
0.0042985361,
-0.0132876411,
-0.0347967222,
-0.0174397882,
-0.0383199081,
-0.0692751184,
0.0487443395,
0.0473569334,
-0.0106874295,
-0.0182158183,
0.0359191932,
0.0027181951,
-0.0530837141,
0.1067432687,
0.0199916977,
-0.0117268357,
-0.08473254,
-0.050074622,
0.030453274,
0.02097716,
-0.0308750477,
-0.0001936192,
0.0161609724,
-0.037359301,
0.0230900832,
0.0356214009,
0.025025906,
0.0508563183,
-0.0399820656,
-0.0577575527,
-0.0215141792,
0.0371511132,
-0.0547773167,
-0.018963499,
0.0518438704,
-0.0153882923,
0.0057211961,
0.0410539471,
-0.0132727446,
0.0133434907,
-0.0336829238,
0.0568836778,
-0.0272197463,
0.0052927537,
0.0456737876,
0.0058585145,
0.0340671949,
-0.0109356651,
0.0470096543,
-0.0474531502,
0.0560204983,
-0.0422508679,
-0.0011969152,
-0.0571348444,
0.0193477925,
0.0328074396,
-0.0271299854,
-0.0090054916,
0.0179188978,
-0.0405276492,
0.0144892633,
-0.0175570138,
0.0300952606,
0.0296702608,
0.0267446619,
0.0252549052,
-0.0278219189,
-0.0100115025,
-0.0397100151,
-0.0202566944,
0.0129501494,
-0.0500139333,
0.0402304977,
0.0307662208,
-0.0205814224,
-0.0127641829,
0.0418899544,
-0.000370116,
-0.0031483222,
-0.0029735428,
0.0175053813,
0.0487688556,
-0.0325175636,
0.083911702,
-0.0156998001,
0.0032101818,
0.0143595515,
0.0339553617,
0.0049899756,
-0.0240793284,
0.0323196054,
0.0233011171,
-0.0134515576,
0.0056916461,
0.0655975863,
-0.0428330041,
0.0612521283,
0.0130153699,
-0.0203911029,
-0.0385801196,
-0.0557540692,
0.034410391,
0.0206214916,
-0.058764901,
0.0420636684,
-0.0421519466,
-0.0477447845,
-0.0050050821,
0.025644388,
-0.0190399066,
0.020786861,
0.0156165883,
0.0437485613,
0.0147999683,
-0.042013187,
0.0106428256,
0.0402674526,
-0.0163799562,
-0.0321926251,
0.0120578194,
-6.874849323e-33,
-0.0200000927,
0.0194494296,
-0.0042067342,
-0.0479709879,
-0.0033532702,
0.0243177786,
-0.0489469767,
-0.0150860809,
0.0074628196,
0.0174298007,
-0.0084152492,
-0.0073749949,
0.0238175187,
0.0465344116,
0.0054711099,
0.0036318675,
0.0371659026,
0.0015335423,
-0.0052429065,
-0.0009698737,
-0.0105809104,
0.071092166,
0.0544252843,
-0.0302199144,
-0.0188220423,
-0.0095034763,
0.0163590014,
0.0194487702,
0.0112587335,
0.0493013635,
-0.0306794476,
-0.005980473,
0.0238547232,
0.0192008428,
-0.0116519351,
0.0378111005,
-0.1081286445,
-0.0409183465,
0.0389799178,
0.0355819315,
-0.0862452462,
0.0091098556,
0.0177678801,
0.0124367606,
0.0638399795,
0.0063093277,
0.0171445291,
0.0051849559,
-0.0094338665,
0.0240762159,
-0.0768774301,
0.0516787209,
-0.0207881723,
-0.0274964049,
0.0496530645,
0.0323991477,
0.0422507301,
0.0132853352,
-0.040828906,
-0.0226324275,
0.0023222659,
0.0312225018,
0.0601291396,
-0.0171312969,
-0.0098175108,
0.0635415092,
0.0082609057,
-0.0363805853,
-0.0065444405,
0.0340780877,
0.0257568788,
0.0424230807,
-0.0217621531,
-0.0018798769,
0.0467399396,
0.0414697155,
-0.0688428059,
0.0151897883,
0.0656366423,
0.0565613322,
-0.0169123039,
0.0322705805,
-0.0308621116,
0.0114332847,
0.0033450909,
0.0044388892,
-0.0171251483,
-0.0381552763,
0.0241306461,
0.0091050686,
-0.0240427889,
0.0302617401,
0.0270607453,
0.0023404832,
0.0043625026,
-0.0160796344,
0.0174147524,
0.0126447435,
-0.0044441223,
0.0561648905,
-0.0402869098,
-0.0100116339,
0.0418086499,
-0.0328180417,
0.0347840264,
0.0068857558,
0.0634473115,
0.0198298655,
-0.0418810137,
0.0129167652,
-0.0530140251,
-0.0254571792,
-0.0378390066,
0.018598048,
0.047081165,
0.0307172872,
-0.0226407703,
0.0372474976,
0.0228819139,
0.0403869934,
-0.0524108671,
0.0102042481,
0.0116065992,
0.0184619706,
-0.0054099672,
-0.015328221,
-0.0122637758,
-0.0071695554,
0.0120806722,
-0.0904895216,
-0.0210038889,
0.0032877037,
2.942e-7,
0.0655053258,
0.0778686702,
0.0559856072,
-0.0141693288,
0.0036639038,
0.0063617579,
-0.0371811651,
0.026337713,
-0.0145632122,
-0.023955049,
0.0044684554,
-0.0049771038,
0.0000147706,
0.0139520206,
-0.0636021197,
-0.0034889132,
-0.0439616591,
-0.0042294399,
-0.0664388463,
-0.0118693365,
0.0578610115,
0.105661124,
0.0045063356,
-0.0042977147,
0.0349525213,
-0.0232470576,
0.0351333879,
-0.0143132815,
-0.0175457653,
0.0330881812,
0.0305740088,
0.0296062436,
-0.0288089681,
0.0214727037,
-0.0064005652,
0.0362174027,
-0.012787506,
0.0537359938,
-0.0245225299,
-0.0092898365,
0.0013288893,
-0.0406400114,
-0.0065188808,
-0.0482006706,
0.0647125542,
-0.0409827456,
-0.0325613357,
0.0277093481,
-0.0616666302,
0.0056542559,
0.0195111968,
0.018408794,
-0.0106058149,
0.0191332344,
0.0237281211,
-0.0487652235,
-0.053807389,
-0.1009276584,
-0.0264619123,
0.0088210618,
-0.046152167,
0.0375631861,
-0.0471813157,
-0.0336526483,
0.0574012771,
-0.0821300149,
-0.008412038,
3.04898439e-34,
0.0342109501,
-0.0050596632,
0.0184671991,
0.0496692844,
0.0586171821,
-0.0247965809,
-0.026183283,
0.0033611448,
-0.0084301569,
-0.0797799304,
-0.0172097813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04789v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04789v1 | Determination of toxic comments and unintended model bias minimization using Deep learning approach | 2023-11-08T16:10:28 | 2023-11-08T16:10:28 | Md Azim Khan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY | Online conversations can be toxic and subjected to threats, abuse, or
harassment. To identify toxic text comments, several deep learning and machine
learning models have been proposed throughout the years. However, recent
studies demonstrate that because of the imbalances in the training data, some
models are more likely to show unintended biases including gender bias and
identity bias. In this research, our aim is to detect toxic comment and reduce
the unintended bias concerning identity features such as race, gender, sex,
religion by fine-tuning an attention based model called BERT(Bidirectional
Encoder Representation from Transformers). We apply weighted loss to address
the issue of unbalanced data and compare the performance of a fine-tuned BERT
model with a traditional Logistic Regression model in terms of classification
and bias minimization. The Logistic Regression model with the TFIDF vectorizer
achieve 57.1% accuracy, and fine-tuned BERT model's accuracy is 89%. Code is
available at
https://github.com/zim10/Determine_Toxic_comment_and_identity_bias.git | [
0.07588844,
0.0384458974,
-0.0252152253,
0.0312794745,
0.0235083327,
0.0434292443,
0.0388457291,
0.0124553833,
0.0074398355,
-0.0573458709,
-0.0074196267,
-0.0281149913,
-0.0114215668,
0.0033061292,
-0.0147079984,
-0.0579453707,
0.0035828124,
0.0650951862,
0.0321431458,
0.0056066425,
0.0554596446,
0.0077794432,
-0.0039761136,
0.0588735044,
-0.0411312357,
-0.0143013373,
0.045901753,
0.046884954,
0.0320372656,
-0.0011219552,
0.0763001442,
0.0310995858,
-0.0155863306,
0.0524885245,
0.0000018939,
-0.0605426282,
0.0102239,
0.0093688369,
-0.0094856396,
-0.0197434966,
0.0381534211,
-0.036251612,
-0.0156625994,
0.0536129661,
-0.0134335775,
-0.0089064054,
0.0760720447,
0.0899304524,
0.0648130253,
0.0602517538,
-0.0108960681,
-0.0490197726,
0.0026148765,
0.0222140029,
-0.0075984886,
0.008645854,
0.044539731,
-0.0386882275,
-0.0858564228,
-0.0182680301,
-0.0126186134,
-0.015044773,
0.0137037141,
-0.0081168069,
0.054221049,
0.0021950786,
0.0024544711,
-0.0437569879,
0.0173010882,
0.0775446445,
-0.0606021807,
0.0184830576,
-0.0179860853,
0.0022756835,
0.0022295932,
-0.0581332631,
-0.0342034735,
0.0186445769,
-0.009434795,
0.0120827556,
-0.0335045978,
0.0228870232,
0.0427342094,
0.0475061387,
0.0192047004,
-0.0235782042,
-0.0075621749,
-0.0364113674,
-0.0088755367,
-0.0109716514,
-0.0147354985,
-0.0014244844,
0.0522796549,
0.0075928462,
0.0026711235,
-0.012159952,
-0.0363640264,
-0.0662596971,
0.0048710764,
-0.0885938704,
0.0146021908,
0.0302420631,
-0.0347189903,
0.0064851372,
-0.0021251475,
0.034697853,
-0.0014004824,
0.0065534874,
-0.0002524245,
-0.0200710781,
-0.0041990606,
0.0202176962,
-0.0256051328,
0.0271650571,
0.0094584581,
0.0257530808,
-0.0554144681,
-0.0015780674,
-0.0569120459,
-0.0270953681,
0.0233011767,
0.0305763315,
-0.0317867659,
0.01984041,
-0.0038115131,
0.025855761,
-0.0306467414,
0.0145714348,
-0.0402763411,
-0.0648433268,
0.0067805913,
0.0436125882,
-0.0090278881,
-0.0280797258,
0.0139962882,
0.0923168287,
0.0502766408,
-0.0506651029,
-0.060020186,
-0.0297530144,
-0.0150572499,
-0.006641828,
0.0181593858,
-0.0374949761,
0.009969864,
-0.0329162367,
-0.0327785797,
-0.034605246,
0.0095385965,
0.000097131,
-0.0246184915,
0.0479789749,
0.0210857671,
-0.0501084328,
0.0598902628,
0.0263781305,
-0.0213693958,
0.0624151453,
0.0458990894,
0.0330537967,
0.0331203379,
-0.0182276201,
-0.0218005013,
0.0221739411,
0.0537495911,
0.0083297752,
-0.0277120098,
0.0246170443,
-0.0508402735,
-0.0090020476,
0.0252341293,
0.0171115547,
0.0032449348,
-0.0609109886,
0.0486314856,
0.0333253555,
-0.0476260483,
0.0771677196,
0.0223309379,
0.01455954,
-0.0438513272,
-0.0394774824,
-0.0613619573,
0.0047899075,
-0.0134324189,
-0.0676706284,
0.0406508222,
0.0339202806,
-0.049838759,
-0.0323259793,
-0.0015965375,
-0.0234639272,
0.0529608317,
-0.0500970781,
0.0298354942,
0.0222528949,
-0.0386283621,
0.0560254566,
0.0424022935,
-0.0224199668,
-0.0197143275,
-0.0230545439,
0.0358020253,
0.0358581878,
-0.0034085319,
-0.0152831944,
-0.0123968748,
-0.0998123214,
-0.0040142303,
0.0211976953,
0.004328989,
0.0295176227,
0.0368201695,
-0.0394718051,
-0.0216895677,
0.0320961624,
-0.005390259,
-0.0039046281,
0.0308953021,
0.0280376319,
0.0343617275,
0.0225404799,
-0.0352235213,
0.0367617607,
0.0375897773,
-0.0372782424,
0.0272012576,
0.0394787081,
0.0819023624,
0.0241913944,
-0.0139477178,
-0.0285920445,
0.0006369271,
-0.0065237721,
-0.0453583039,
-0.0583040342,
-0.0326047055,
-0.0054143239,
0.0126824193,
-0.0793023854,
-0.0319227204,
0.0743690133,
-0.024343688,
0.0510735624,
0.0691338331,
-0.0810923949,
-0.0142655112,
0.0069202851,
-0.028860379,
-0.0373409912,
0.0391731299,
-0.0070976969,
0.047609739,
-0.0567129478,
-0.0101246685,
-0.0105020348,
-0.0521127842,
-0.0105882073,
-0.0147541519,
-0.0443319678,
-0.0534473248,
-0.0479817502,
0.0136386771,
0.0231507979,
0.0077178162,
0.0032834038,
0.0042723771,
-0.0674485192,
0.0111340843,
-0.0242942162,
-0.0134401387,
0.0001319324,
0.0174209215,
0.0089191906,
0.0179546587,
-0.0199157111,
-0.0628233701,
0.0006480026,
0.0204832852,
0.0154109029,
-0.0575936921,
-0.006841884,
-0.0240325946,
-0.0337488055,
-0.0191628616,
0.0574135222,
0.0240434129,
-0.0454872251,
-0.0140722841,
-0.0333207026,
-0.0165657736,
0.0312810279,
0.0101407301,
-0.083681494,
0.0211461931,
0.0592619479,
0.0148701128,
0.0910775661,
0.0776676536,
0.0902236104,
-0.0083313575,
0.0463227853,
-0.0297006741,
0.0190053172,
-0.018678546,
0.0339762941,
0.0022051055,
-0.0520641804,
0.0038604273,
0.0484452806,
0.0137943663,
-0.0151227573,
-0.0588957742,
0.0212302878,
-0.0098213013,
-0.015472291,
0.01731834,
-0.0454428494,
0.0159091055,
-0.0262252931,
-0.0421767794,
-0.0418218113,
0.0675545931,
0.0062863114,
0.0121305408,
-0.0381771252,
-0.0160001982,
-0.0035791965,
0.0003272747,
-0.0063631041,
0.0387663394,
-0.0092412299,
-0.0317906253,
0.0065932497,
-0.0391770042,
0.0273987837,
-0.0139038814,
-0.0213442408,
0.0179687962,
-0.0068482356,
0.0059905304,
-0.0382427163,
-0.0754829794,
-0.0162973311,
-0.0105099352,
-0.0396108292,
0.0305554271,
-0.0091826692,
-0.0408074036,
0.0157198235,
0.0045975996,
-0.0075482852,
0.0008850316,
-0.0017198625,
0.0130887469,
-0.0099676521,
0.00960535,
-0.0089841774,
0.0453938395,
-0.0132989967,
-0.0052876282,
0.0684454665,
-0.0498702154,
0.009827747,
-0.0370747373,
-0.0123204384,
-0.0057398039,
-0.0075632976,
0.0093750181,
-0.0163904075,
0.012532671,
-0.0256863553,
0.0110537643,
0.0808913857,
0.0022517405,
-0.0441245995,
0.0220385417,
0.0102086123,
0.0078707468,
0.0057492945,
-0.0442838483,
-0.0830930769,
-0.0272473115,
-0.0063601215,
0.0223477781,
-0.0629569888,
-0.0544325523,
0.0224031173,
-0.0785826519,
0.0030988092,
-0.014281298,
-0.0017192124,
-0.0779625773,
-0.016356254,
0.0052391477,
-0.018260872,
0.0634119213,
-0.038966395,
0.0268278401,
-0.0195186082,
0.0080483491,
-0.0737142935,
-0.018138824,
0.0125657097,
-0.0520591624,
0.041291479,
0.040590208,
0.0731661469,
-0.0287713557,
-0.0073593808,
0.0532793291,
0.0183239225,
-0.0337656029,
-0.0349653438,
0.084120661,
-0.0340864956,
-0.0315179117,
-0.0440926179,
0.0325375721,
0.0018399881,
0.0274794959,
-0.0352541171,
0.0450010821,
0.0173481349,
-0.0051196734,
-0.0602042675,
0.0168850496,
0.0258416235,
0.0660846829,
0.0397830382,
-0.0650942847,
-0.0184995104,
-0.0500264168,
-0.007069835,
-0.0248082764,
-0.0423446856,
0.0034801785,
-0.0024897738,
-0.0570646375,
-0.0325698778,
-0.0422156528,
0.0054647764,
-0.0446690246,
-0.0074169696,
-0.0610888414,
0.016272394,
0.002076308,
-0.0412886329,
0.0450584851,
0.0087000728,
0.0417941995,
-0.0195860863,
0.0082236342,
-0.0136972629,
-0.0332359932,
-0.018076323,
0.0227532908,
-0.0544200428,
-0.0255249999,
0.0302103925,
0.0938150063,
0.0061147702,
0.0212254319,
-0.0187237076,
-0.0662897378,
0.0431943685,
0.0451557674,
-0.0136166168,
-0.0352033824,
0.0527463071,
0.012530514,
0.0122945039,
0.0277692173,
-0.028456226,
0.0525397733,
0.0165945496,
-0.0222526193,
-0.0343190022,
-0.0337711759,
-0.0220311489,
-0.008301314,
0.0413572453,
0.032300476,
-0.0327700861,
0.0009911298,
0.0050771395,
0.0059025967,
-0.0105914939,
-0.0098583763,
-0.0010858659,
0.0213113278,
0.011729937,
-0.0257897377,
-0.0065180599,
-0.0299347248,
-0.0039311685,
-0.0262164753,
0.04162696,
0.0196437463,
0.032019008,
0.0264126696,
0.0264138915,
-0.0433825999,
0.0214339662,
-0.0023403021,
-0.0061043878,
0.0226621181,
0.00677071,
0.0175481532,
0.0370454825,
0.0001025551,
-0.006780901,
0.0036465435,
0.0095729558,
-0.0552275069,
-0.0252738185,
0.005875994,
-0.0174973402,
0.0285320021,
0.0069604414,
-0.0038510165,
-0.0020840785,
0.0217632372,
-0.0406583399,
-0.0098511735,
0.0041841837,
0.007842782,
-0.0022784877,
0.0026490903,
0.0389413573,
0.014687405,
0.0435420126,
0.0162040181,
-0.0458326712,
-0.0284948554,
0.0076654791,
0.053540837,
0.0176253971,
0.0031367685,
0.0385051183,
0.0076944721,
-0.0349836126,
0.0085254991,
-0.0776158571,
0.0461159237,
0.0023944755,
0.0317094438,
0.0244389549,
-0.0029990058,
-0.0211544149,
0.0148366317,
0.0025594826,
-0.0056345514,
-0.0570233427,
-0.0210267249,
-5.750058085e-33,
0.0062856404,
-0.0268471334,
-0.0438939855,
0.0300716739,
-0.0142942024,
-0.0223029926,
0.0110265417,
-0.0048286058,
-0.0268952027,
0.024594957,
0.0393943191,
0.0353763252,
-0.0092252474,
0.0312848352,
-0.0372080915,
-0.0301610399,
0.0453064144,
-0.0116490498,
0.0182692818,
0.0238580555,
0.0077076685,
0.0308195036,
0.0258547254,
-0.0969818905,
0.028344214,
-0.0109652057,
-0.0029269652,
0.0225191824,
0.0157925729,
0.0775684342,
-0.0128984125,
0.073823005,
0.0316706188,
-0.0125871385,
0.0146413809,
0.0759201944,
-0.0446292721,
-0.0154818362,
-0.0302375797,
0.0104446653,
-0.0074443473,
-0.0389911756,
0.0784121901,
0.0476628244,
-0.0161398966,
-0.0580151863,
0.0539775901,
0.0140550509,
0.0292880703,
-0.059097752,
-0.0451154858,
0.0038107203,
-0.0538453385,
-0.0116009098,
-0.0185257029,
0.0619983561,
0.012325515,
0.0175897013,
-0.0867823288,
-0.0168190077,
-0.0267339237,
-0.0343641229,
-0.021952739,
-0.0182820596,
-0.0195498299,
0.0369909741,
0.0405286551,
0.0435137898,
-0.0772939399,
-0.0187822934,
0.0146230133,
0.0033498926,
0.0581912436,
0.0305500291,
0.0123082437,
-0.0590932444,
-0.1255924702,
-0.0069294483,
0.0489905402,
0.0294278525,
0.0324821845,
-0.0291717909,
-0.0696343333,
-0.0092236008,
0.0130166868,
-0.0719027072,
-0.0081304358,
-0.0249597896,
-0.0023776789,
-0.034288995,
-0.0375705585,
-0.0046239342,
0.0142403319,
-0.0557423308,
0.0109832762,
0.0270574689,
0.0221099071,
-0.0098712929,
0.0375386626,
0.0116541116,
-0.0285976157,
0.0081516458,
0.0186608732,
-0.0479020327,
0.0195238255,
0.0146808997,
0.0807164684,
0.0070325667,
-0.0417606905,
-0.0087288795,
0.0059931343,
0.0570783392,
-0.0155342082,
0.1228427887,
-0.0201309063,
0.0425536744,
-0.0015535522,
0.0281961113,
0.0357005224,
0.0363882259,
-0.0225527696,
-0.0034833045,
-0.0120958267,
0.0035018516,
-0.0192182008,
-0.03187491,
-0.0359869041,
0.0220664125,
0.0124054141,
-0.0998201519,
0.0024220091,
-0.0457992852,
2.589e-7,
0.0106998272,
0.0497126877,
0.0209699478,
-0.0052202889,
0.0234143212,
0.0572112463,
0.056410905,
0.0838986561,
0.021007264,
-0.0236011334,
-0.0262416601,
0.0454853401,
-0.0039735888,
0.0300589632,
-0.0468398109,
-0.0434192903,
-0.1076015085,
0.0239288658,
-0.0212378465,
0.0016465811,
0.0290935319,
0.1026623398,
0.0397460125,
-0.0359535664,
-0.0012214533,
0.0295523088,
0.022807762,
-0.0134915933,
0.0275250841,
-0.0090578329,
0.0497696921,
0.0050875498,
0.0237712059,
0.0218804386,
0.0004900801,
0.006034221,
-0.0085933246,
0.0356396288,
-0.0422489345,
-0.0269893557,
0.0298938099,
0.0046870015,
0.0049900999,
-0.0322085284,
0.0200149436,
-0.0194164924,
-0.026417613,
-0.0503406338,
-0.0344752073,
0.0086846258,
0.0691947117,
-0.0185375363,
0.0029856479,
0.0166801121,
0.0324707292,
-0.0225332845,
0.0077750427,
-0.0807394311,
-0.0086930189,
-0.0247618426,
-0.0333456621,
-0.0296111107,
-0.0089975297,
-0.0171869863,
0.0511457101,
0.027462082,
0.0570715107,
2.000529755e-34,
0.0226277411,
-0.0227042213,
0.0176177211,
-0.021706013,
0.0251393262,
0.0299529601,
0.0063952389,
-0.0161802601,
0.0578111596,
-0.0011773821,
-0.0190511923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04742v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04742v2 | Using large language models to study human memory for meaningful narratives | 2023-11-08T15:11:57 | 2023-11-28T05:25:45 | Antonios Georgiou, Tankut Can, Mikhail Katkov, Misha Tsodyks | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | One of the most impressive achievements of the AI revolution is the
development of large language models that can generate meaningful text and
respond to instructions in plain English with no additional training necessary.
Here we show that language models can be used as a scientific instrument for
studying human memory for meaningful material. We developed a pipeline for
designing large scale memory experiments and analyzing the obtained results. We
performed online memory experiments with a large number of participants and
collected recognition and recall data for narratives of different lengths. We
found that both recall and recognition performance scale linearly with
narrative length. Furthermore, in order to investigate the role of narrative
comprehension in memory, we repeated these experiments using scrambled versions
of the presented stories. We found that even though recall performance declined
significantly, recognition remained largely unaffected. Interestingly, recalls
in this condition seem to follow the original narrative order rather than the
scrambled presentation, pointing to a contextual reconstruction of the story in
memory. | [
0.0355148353,
0.0590297729,
-0.05008303,
0.0188687854,
-0.058937218,
0.0276381616,
0.0260359459,
0.0293710083,
0.0105016148,
-0.0597698502,
0.0161162782,
-0.0634107217,
0.0352087691,
0.0739976466,
-0.0225404985,
-0.0666689947,
0.0262057465,
-0.0275562443,
0.0501870476,
0.0237755273,
-0.0385158584,
-0.0035367303,
-0.0199732799,
0.0089401947,
-0.0017454571,
0.0086513264,
-0.0245814528,
-0.0066140192,
0.0247892495,
-0.0355294943,
-0.0492947139,
0.0112509541,
0.0286728833,
0.0037923015,
0.000001876,
-0.059866026,
0.0266985931,
-0.0191280972,
-0.0507012494,
0.038066566,
0.0232545119,
0.0359727852,
0.004184003,
-0.0431083404,
-0.0261807889,
-0.0059332149,
0.0276849233,
0.0606985837,
0.0147779128,
0.0692199543,
-0.0069706407,
-0.0433671549,
0.0307198875,
0.0104705263,
0.0281464737,
-0.0063093537,
0.0160864182,
0.0209530424,
0.0331493765,
0.0025085714,
-0.007385686,
0.0368731618,
0.0075249067,
0.0466257259,
-0.0112823658,
0.088822186,
-0.0193775911,
0.0241637193,
-0.0147702014,
0.0541245341,
0.0310302153,
-0.0253088679,
0.0086560827,
-0.0000743607,
0.0136079593,
-0.0040311394,
-0.0676883236,
0.0611676238,
-0.0251450948,
-0.0029483803,
0.0057844413,
-0.0067411405,
0.016728105,
-0.0000278361,
0.0295685865,
0.0086728316,
0.011959509,
-0.0026948659,
-0.0508806258,
-0.0134890918,
0.0146732936,
-0.061602857,
0.0126121407,
0.0491801687,
-0.0013756942,
0.0292282645,
-0.0366979428,
-0.0024067955,
0.0155554181,
-0.0663098916,
0.046175722,
0.0185986012,
0.0101720821,
0.0458613038,
-0.0512945876,
0.1264898628,
0.0185056329,
0.0027611847,
-0.031679973,
0.0249175746,
-0.0729807317,
0.0063829869,
-0.0304817967,
0.0440454185,
-0.0234187264,
-0.018382607,
-0.0209173299,
0.0012163577,
0.0350779369,
0.0068449075,
-0.053103704,
0.0087178927,
-0.013253456,
0.0131445751,
-0.0361233726,
-0.0089485832,
-0.0469784439,
-0.0116033563,
0.0183995832,
-0.0376911424,
-0.0260539949,
-0.0023802768,
0.0153549965,
-0.0086148763,
0.0091841351,
0.0567082576,
-0.0286420286,
-0.0510139242,
-0.0598828904,
-0.0396319367,
0.0142913992,
-0.066155754,
-0.0141994655,
-0.0391557626,
0.0435016602,
0.0147955352,
0.0153034423,
-0.0471680537,
-0.0047940286,
0.0141164167,
-0.0672617853,
0.0053839884,
0.0456848927,
-0.0067311889,
0.0396793932,
0.0279090684,
0.0144998208,
-0.0077329883,
0.0778407678,
0.0492476895,
0.0092724413,
0.0068666721,
0.0338695757,
-0.0115863271,
-0.0279707853,
-0.0072731841,
-0.0219537318,
-0.0112712849,
0.0380166546,
0.0625633597,
0.000450376,
0.0655353367,
-0.0337074175,
-0.0340813771,
0.0759419724,
0.0864825621,
-0.0214028861,
0.0225082356,
0.0455036834,
0.0015213245,
0.0366690233,
0.0348498598,
-0.0409204252,
0.0375103466,
-0.0025362934,
0.0144043351,
0.0115598142,
0.0070772069,
-0.0407288633,
-0.0069510932,
-0.0116128447,
-0.021534428,
0.0247831233,
0.0000167761,
0.0057423012,
-0.0356018469,
-0.0696684644,
-0.0195836183,
0.0281187296,
-0.068765834,
0.0388107635,
-0.0560187846,
0.0348652788,
0.1006740779,
0.0464140885,
-0.0226339512,
-0.001930771,
0.0095972037,
0.0073365308,
-0.0003497986,
0.0347048119,
-0.003177379,
0.0223308932,
-0.0283752345,
0.0367460623,
-0.0145705035,
0.0225605499,
0.0367136374,
0.0198396463,
0.0026220828,
0.0001956739,
-0.0105755804,
-0.052834969,
0.0517276935,
-0.0679148138,
-0.0426910184,
-0.0292609651,
-0.018439034,
-0.0129392091,
-0.0069946004,
-0.0125768837,
-0.0035456261,
0.0607522056,
-0.0227802079,
-0.0138857868,
0.028312277,
-0.0697572306,
-0.0446742699,
-0.0152214449,
-0.0311066043,
0.0118839992,
-0.0216488075,
0.0159411486,
-0.059664268,
0.0485487394,
-0.0700423047,
0.0239254739,
-0.011521182,
0.009784013,
-0.0048181019,
-0.0227574129,
-0.0326338001,
0.0971705988,
0.0005707828,
0.0352473184,
-0.0111827916,
-0.0115084089,
-0.0053881831,
-0.0602900907,
0.0037841126,
0.036402531,
0.0127663538,
0.0054889428,
0.0271468684,
-0.0739282221,
-0.053466022,
-0.0249996055,
-0.0850978494,
0.0247974955,
0.0111901509,
-0.0138983037,
0.0236513615,
-0.0180046968,
-0.0327000543,
-0.0008038505,
-0.0439030193,
0.0052337982,
-0.0099745868,
0.0298923366,
-0.0064592124,
0.0521678329,
-0.0027644369,
-0.0367649198,
-0.0019490628,
-0.0116790477,
0.0782881454,
0.053542465,
-0.0164019093,
-0.0614562668,
0.0372226387,
0.0016966623,
0.0045032902,
-0.0235873461,
-0.0088202218,
0.0247484073,
0.0031019561,
0.0921047106,
0.1284234673,
0.0128329238,
0.0282508992,
0.0579523072,
-0.0435383916,
-0.0355352201,
-0.0203857068,
-0.0028638314,
0.0036172308,
-0.0197936408,
-0.0830057338,
-0.0024573358,
0.0548757203,
0.0344265848,
0.0526228212,
-0.0557372756,
0.0031288003,
-0.011927803,
-0.0308549125,
-0.0093530556,
-0.0498478711,
-0.0564961471,
0.0437715389,
-0.0135419946,
-0.0319086947,
0.0777859315,
-0.022678392,
0.0162671581,
-0.0070118187,
0.012913188,
-0.0029213375,
0.1090315655,
0.0266109277,
0.0527787283,
0.0153442668,
-0.0205310956,
-0.028874876,
-0.0034550701,
-0.0023894743,
-0.050180763,
0.0109183472,
-0.0749427229,
-0.0095665436,
0.0199511405,
0.0028793209,
-0.0795756131,
-0.0471399091,
-0.0191365909,
-0.003371997,
-0.0079649817,
-0.007679027,
-0.1083704457,
0.0098527651,
0.0630042776,
0.0246349908,
0.0093400218,
-0.0082935644,
-0.0035944607,
0.045043923,
0.0469355322,
-0.0104643935,
0.0231788568,
-0.0439046882,
0.049652312,
0.0362884924,
0.0508977398,
0.0138216764,
0.0104740215,
-0.0047489353,
-0.0150846513,
-0.0536277443,
-0.0259108506,
0.0517680235,
0.0160113815,
-0.045779489,
-0.0283909142,
0.1107744426,
0.0465706289,
-0.0635731742,
-0.0081853997,
-0.0029572586,
0.0090015261,
0.0136523535,
-0.0044561457,
-0.0377139151,
-0.0074302033,
0.0234325491,
-0.0107261026,
-0.0415101126,
-0.0530432872,
-0.0268358979,
-0.0887821987,
0.0198970716,
0.0173578504,
-0.0337440446,
-0.039717298,
-0.0609749854,
-0.0096376194,
0.0389765017,
0.0045395531,
0.0268194582,
-0.0245664883,
-0.0176725537,
-0.0301734395,
0.0116663883,
-0.0063370829,
0.0568161681,
-0.0171954632,
0.0760417655,
0.0447773673,
0.0511800274,
0.0088149393,
-0.0188356172,
-0.0191556904,
0.0048031793,
0.0338691585,
0.0246226341,
0.0766906366,
-0.0003173165,
0.0212875437,
-0.0507380478,
0.0382126123,
0.0028253042,
-0.0606841221,
0.0227952395,
0.0259969458,
-0.0173000321,
-0.054423321,
0.0101575116,
-0.0105554741,
-0.0058998452,
0.0980750993,
0.0354649238,
-0.0474531613,
-0.0294863097,
-0.0046145837,
0.0377529226,
-0.0224411581,
-0.0401211828,
0.0233281162,
-0.0030006287,
0.0354017019,
-0.0961562395,
-0.0487968251,
-0.0087652896,
0.0240374021,
0.0267403554,
-0.0012849486,
0.020897096,
-0.0113575635,
-0.0655535758,
0.0182952043,
-0.0706098303,
-0.0035759406,
-0.0438712426,
-0.0221943613,
0.0126745645,
-0.0605296977,
0.0292625278,
0.0461235121,
-0.0818312466,
-0.0429462455,
0.059338633,
0.0140834162,
0.0254832134,
0.0546866022,
0.0473959818,
-0.0293270759,
0.0094721811,
-0.0258288644,
-0.0443325415,
0.0532347672,
-0.0499654189,
0.0236279964,
-0.0136773111,
-0.009950473,
-0.0094376225,
-0.0014126848,
0.0028154894,
0.0118460851,
-0.0133156022,
-0.0339698084,
0.0240594558,
0.0010089319,
0.0084468313,
-0.0020227807,
-0.0295424815,
-0.0210938882,
-0.0156231392,
-0.0404929519,
0.0152528854,
0.0178755745,
-0.0192092657,
0.0147540122,
0.0047209216,
-0.0162984245,
-0.0381347761,
-0.0405225791,
0.0081629939,
-0.010671353,
-0.0429180637,
0.0157549083,
-0.0141051328,
0.0116148777,
0.0369832441,
-0.0315431394,
0.0441795848,
-0.0499632135,
0.0777131915,
-0.0190689154,
0.0562824085,
-0.0052470295,
-0.0273789838,
-0.0357129537,
0.0036711148,
-0.0953910202,
-0.0195925329,
0.0289755445,
0.0022801864,
0.0287817847,
-0.0378738344,
0.0228625536,
-0.0536100864,
0.046826683,
-0.0316012613,
-0.022415502,
0.0283523034,
-0.0214238353,
-0.0413776673,
0.0229683202,
-0.003740086,
0.0544174574,
0.0698553398,
-0.0047541689,
0.04341821,
0.0202231817,
-0.0025084817,
-0.0158075858,
-0.0309095234,
-0.0014618133,
0.0524086654,
-0.0142939528,
-0.0421932489,
-0.0519488826,
-0.0222769231,
0.0385914557,
-0.0020693704,
0.0625190064,
-0.0280642137,
0.0182921737,
0.0009190234,
-0.0216301102,
0.0071864906,
-0.0441510938,
0.0468778312,
-0.0163602978,
-0.0315302573,
-0.0487679169,
-6.013330983e-33,
-0.0114800669,
-0.0243301112,
0.0080246162,
0.0049308175,
-0.02974247,
0.0241621193,
-0.0606374368,
0.0297898427,
-0.0091875363,
-0.0202756338,
0.001768014,
0.007286679,
0.0139035638,
-0.0016702121,
-0.0192396883,
-0.0056093759,
0.0415071584,
0.0031481998,
-0.0580494516,
0.0458237566,
0.0572323203,
0.0095647732,
0.0110889897,
-0.0219455194,
0.026648134,
-0.0408084393,
0.024566073,
-0.0048961164,
0.0195477661,
0.0350999981,
-0.0512496419,
0.0337319709,
0.0371993631,
-0.0132917482,
-0.0282645188,
0.0217276122,
-0.0656457022,
0.0001956419,
0.0338296145,
-0.0047634002,
-0.0075728926,
-0.0592135228,
0.0160187241,
-0.0437437631,
-0.0091256564,
-0.0070402347,
0.0396114811,
-0.0066080443,
-0.0113805132,
-0.0047047865,
-0.0633953065,
-0.0154042142,
-0.0189651102,
-0.0287780575,
0.0109514343,
0.0105904685,
0.0168318115,
0.021904448,
-0.0503010452,
0.0376892872,
-0.0281664915,
0.0156348888,
0.0066450918,
0.0279425103,
0.0007304964,
0.1009856388,
0.0521336198,
0.0263878759,
-0.0541246273,
0.0174771752,
0.0217505004,
-0.0206087492,
0.0378813371,
0.0415756628,
0.034462329,
-0.0263919588,
-0.0445241965,
0.0188087597,
-0.0079452423,
0.019485103,
0.0725974292,
0.0203122515,
-0.0356370583,
-0.0059967488,
-0.0567799471,
0.0292323716,
-0.0341773853,
-0.001805443,
0.0264843684,
-0.0141234957,
-0.0052531073,
-0.0416525081,
0.0482973866,
-0.0249351878,
0.024934236,
0.0095672747,
-0.0301671941,
0.0335702449,
-0.0225060619,
0.0304340329,
-0.0256381426,
-0.0100788716,
0.046880804,
0.0289218444,
0.0279126521,
-0.0049685393,
0.0074562719,
0.0105951075,
-0.0329361707,
0.0144589571,
-0.0113398656,
-0.0051464136,
0.0340293385,
-0.043936599,
0.0170363374,
0.045068115,
-0.0014236714,
0.0075572021,
0.0020560077,
-0.0353876837,
-0.029693326,
-0.0288971774,
-0.0382908918,
-0.0069875857,
-0.0321194381,
0.0269340836,
-0.0308955684,
0.0527178943,
0.024202073,
-0.0153913926,
0.0250014532,
0.0341828316,
2.599e-7,
-0.0372463055,
0.0569603108,
0.0387893394,
-0.0270799827,
0.0060635917,
0.0144179063,
0.0033123605,
0.0174462087,
0.0322637819,
-0.0383180603,
-0.0095502147,
0.0730708316,
0.0319920294,
0.0155217424,
-0.0654940009,
0.0151375635,
-0.038594231,
-0.0230089556,
-0.0684950501,
0.0096364552,
0.0958925262,
0.0332630649,
0.0299906489,
0.0027570438,
0.0072702789,
-0.0506578647,
0.0818340927,
-0.0483056009,
-0.0271280818,
0.0272882208,
-0.0433502272,
0.0099226609,
-0.0103176693,
0.0241381433,
0.0125627965,
-0.0256839544,
0.0034277642,
0.0444639884,
-0.0201670472,
-0.0175269414,
-0.0067773876,
-0.0065348479,
-0.0156302713,
-0.0317560211,
0.0437965728,
-0.0322360359,
-0.0296801981,
0.0084897559,
-0.0088861585,
0.0128142461,
0.0075866999,
0.0006837216,
-0.0055856532,
0.0477093533,
-0.0144838672,
0.0160954688,
0.029582765,
-0.0632823035,
-0.024486104,
0.0149053764,
-0.0519920439,
-0.0150541877,
-0.0373178981,
-0.0112037212,
-0.0080399113,
-0.0936853662,
0.0226871613,
2.01715703e-34,
0.015298699,
0.0102771204,
-0.0012947748,
0.0437050276,
0.0374710523,
-0.0073927655,
-0.0002371985,
0.019289216,
0.0202929936,
-0.0949692726,
-0.0153533872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04694v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04694v3 | Evaluating Generative Ad Hoc Information Retrieval | 2023-11-08T14:05:00 | 2024-05-22T10:33:56 | Lukas Gienapp, Harrisen Scells, Niklas Deckers, Janek Bevendorff, Shuai Wang, Johannes Kiesel, Shahbaz Syed, Maik Fröbe, Guido Zuccon, Benno Stein, Matthias Hagen, Martin Potthast | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recent advances in large language models have enabled the development of
viable generative retrieval systems. Instead of a traditional document ranking,
generative retrieval systems often directly return a grounded generated text as
a response to a query. Quantifying the utility of the textual responses is
essential for appropriately evaluating such generative ad hoc retrieval. Yet,
the established evaluation methodology for ranking-based ad hoc retrieval is
not suited for the reliable and reproducible evaluation of generated responses.
To lay a foundation for developing new evaluation methods for generative
retrieval systems, we survey the relevant literature from the fields of
information retrieval and natural language processing, identify search tasks
and system architectures in generative retrieval, develop a new user model, and
study its operationalization. | [
0.0760063753,
0.0012232644,
-0.0135140726,
-0.0098625254,
-0.0316248313,
-0.0025081073,
-0.0036628488,
0.0239495356,
0.0367520601,
-0.0360578224,
-0.0305242799,
-0.0170721319,
-0.0417692065,
0.0014175236,
-0.0002357152,
-0.0434312187,
0.0265223458,
0.0323668942,
0.0167138055,
0.0286672357,
-0.0013387799,
0.0250469297,
0.0240529198,
0.0384691507,
0.0026834735,
0.0226625111,
-0.0048933467,
0.0289457869,
0.0181071982,
-0.0221205838,
-0.0019558554,
0.0166499056,
-0.0010303438,
0.0361862928,
0.0000015889,
-0.0445385203,
-0.0227082781,
0.0048495675,
0.010095723,
-0.0264146682,
0.0901476666,
0.0863796473,
0.0047722533,
0.0025564963,
-0.0548727959,
-0.0349810906,
0.0207577422,
-0.0099811051,
0.0337163359,
0.0434772186,
-0.0079017896,
-0.0489574447,
0.0030217471,
-0.0081610773,
0.0481409058,
-0.0235604551,
-0.0062858248,
0.0130654573,
0.0335727967,
0.0701245144,
0.0295018405,
0.0193658601,
-0.0239354763,
-0.0526528694,
0.0968916938,
0.0232924055,
-0.020483654,
-0.0012957042,
0.0223356858,
0.0295489933,
0.0347856171,
-0.0163068157,
0.0106305489,
0.0157616623,
0.0060359524,
0.062889576,
-0.0586702637,
-0.0099302037,
-0.0298125688,
-0.0057483944,
0.0072306078,
0.0676200315,
-0.012953287,
-0.0049411259,
0.0047332444,
0.0165220313,
0.0232599601,
-0.0440254956,
-0.0171403326,
-0.0040261191,
0.0089541692,
-0.0486964583,
0.0286779646,
0.0092586121,
-0.0046000374,
-0.0054971697,
0.031506855,
-0.044976972,
0.066442281,
-0.0707467198,
0.0280839801,
-0.0003648625,
-0.0035844296,
0.0507485457,
-0.0280954409,
0.0259129275,
-0.0000986457,
-0.0304537006,
-0.0563259795,
-0.0043610851,
-0.0689394996,
-0.051146552,
-0.0209071655,
0.034519881,
-0.0563975424,
-0.046079427,
-0.0292189233,
0.0349405445,
0.0215380751,
-0.0550635047,
0.0348655432,
0.0572459921,
-0.0190900043,
0.009004618,
-0.0754485428,
-0.01665744,
-0.0355491564,
-0.0168638583,
0.0060817599,
-0.0357348658,
0.0325684808,
0.0059077898,
0.031660419,
-0.0271354858,
-0.0049950141,
0.0044309292,
0.0187141746,
-0.0313490182,
-0.0183785055,
-0.017807208,
0.0024447266,
-0.0237628203,
-0.0120906336,
-0.0561744682,
0.0087982416,
0.0397042483,
-0.0208511483,
-0.0082006576,
0.0133887175,
0.066441834,
-0.0123352036,
0.0124817491,
0.0147067653,
0.0035045377,
0.0552843213,
0.0004218767,
0.0482231975,
0.0285163987,
-0.019849034,
0.0653204247,
0.0470160581,
0.01833212,
0.0286866035,
-0.0421147421,
0.0005497411,
-0.0084464774,
0.0004168823,
0.0651448518,
-0.0532369465,
0.0042080348,
-0.016745273,
0.0518036298,
-0.0449206643,
0.0254275706,
0.0327716917,
0.0626817569,
0.0416748337,
0.0089531327,
0.0428553857,
0.0121144559,
-0.0232586823,
0.0034098541,
0.0327555016,
0.0323531814,
-0.0484331511,
0.001602862,
0.0579561852,
0.0204534251,
-0.0088552497,
-0.0748450235,
-0.0111985411,
0.0630837381,
-0.021244226,
-0.0003292782,
0.0378145687,
0.039429184,
-0.0167106856,
-0.0272131916,
-0.0095034894,
-0.0778457671,
0.030330535,
-0.0668342412,
0.0126730325,
0.117108576,
0.0920328125,
-0.0114862537,
0.0317655653,
0.0509809852,
-0.0274335314,
0.0200902428,
0.0002218295,
-0.0149410963,
-0.0338986628,
-0.0238206759,
-0.0316715091,
0.0063952152,
-0.0123537127,
0.008990692,
0.0017057713,
0.0048964052,
0.0263963155,
-0.0540928245,
-0.0347585231,
0.0218129922,
0.0167893451,
-0.023018606,
0.024467621,
0.0073279324,
-0.016360892,
0.0505482368,
-0.0047708922,
0.0468537621,
0.038435027,
-0.0055938726,
-0.0623228885,
-0.0098888408,
0.0035410002,
0.0056230733,
-0.0413139686,
-0.0576351099,
0.0564642027,
-0.0097132875,
0.0220958907,
-0.0283363368,
0.0165991057,
-0.0229489859,
0.0191590283,
-0.0765634403,
-0.0004220658,
0.0274813361,
-0.0152682792,
-0.0933941752,
0.1304916739,
0.0282455459,
0.0486714877,
0.0254832059,
0.0239100419,
0.023508545,
-0.0397481285,
-0.0160764139,
0.0119266035,
-0.0089772334,
0.0081765763,
0.0576199144,
-0.0161164161,
-0.0263681542,
-0.0329963565,
-0.1015383601,
-0.0079832114,
-0.0215277113,
0.0100760711,
0.0352191888,
0.0083793839,
-0.0080411248,
-0.0136727029,
-0.0347940326,
-0.0149662076,
0.0361145623,
0.0033696662,
0.0200132579,
0.0148649896,
0.0209396239,
-0.0403115079,
-0.0243707914,
0.0300134774,
0.0498088337,
0.0444457792,
0.03010864,
-0.0464614406,
0.0223572832,
-0.0477711894,
0.0043688663,
0.0191634018,
0.0037907711,
0.0316878557,
-0.0534539111,
0.0633852705,
0.0016525602,
0.0532152727,
0.0268982779,
0.0141827669,
-0.0271536727,
-0.0855172426,
0.0020560164,
-0.0639801249,
-0.0107208239,
0.0333693661,
-0.0340686142,
0.0312967002,
-0.0118656242,
0.0249259006,
-0.0192210935,
-0.0417928025,
0.0439465903,
-0.0088356473,
-0.0238872357,
-0.0848501474,
-0.0076249745,
0.0126952147,
0.0495415106,
-0.000819158,
-0.0415672548,
0.0243866388,
-0.0014839708,
0.0037067223,
-0.0357467346,
0.0184144508,
-0.026810389,
0.0769592971,
-0.0053126058,
0.0128940605,
-0.0232260134,
-0.0012280131,
0.0117613347,
0.0497161336,
0.0320162438,
-0.0705113485,
-0.0016990781,
-0.0082361959,
0.0265030358,
0.0149355223,
-0.0354957506,
-0.0405307338,
-0.0075197625,
0.0430124179,
-0.0033276565,
0.0653219,
0.0012054434,
-0.0170109533,
0.0229918845,
0.0325779095,
0.011586111,
-0.0056642876,
-0.0610199422,
0.0116561418,
0.0643797442,
0.0351404324,
-0.05313861,
-0.0165658984,
0.050842382,
-0.0320618488,
0.0371980481,
0.0221420806,
-0.0290711746,
-0.0014831985,
-0.0312723592,
0.0407922529,
-0.0283590555,
-0.0119360741,
0.0087022092,
-0.0340425931,
0.0059047276,
-0.0376377441,
0.0437579937,
0.0749691278,
-0.0379867554,
-0.0324989147,
-0.0202038027,
0.0209029112,
0.0142495017,
0.0591699407,
-0.0188113768,
0.0418904088,
0.008907441,
0.053149309,
-0.0322297625,
0.0074102706,
0.0019926764,
-0.1169788688,
0.0726374611,
-0.0465130322,
0.0208326206,
-0.0083571859,
-0.0379048772,
0.0011900272,
0.0142056635,
-0.0878897831,
0.0380927399,
-0.0300072674,
0.0258547142,
0.0032737837,
0.0268758368,
-0.0389142931,
-0.0230001714,
0.0033880926,
-0.0183033887,
0.076053001,
0.027912667,
0.037953686,
-0.0626397878,
-0.0467131995,
-0.0308603458,
0.0366186798,
-0.0152898366,
0.0237712245,
0.0085509354,
0.0296060536,
-0.0522661544,
-0.014963448,
0.0089112809,
0.0215728544,
-0.0157185141,
0.0133179957,
-0.0332691185,
0.0480626151,
-0.072329767,
0.0108863367,
0.0234194193,
0.0384414829,
0.0198922232,
0.0006809198,
-0.024695158,
-0.0367651433,
0.0702560022,
-0.0855077207,
-0.071270667,
-0.0121939722,
0.0071623679,
0.0048450138,
-0.0992526934,
-0.0331268907,
-0.0302204471,
0.0231204927,
-0.0256905798,
0.0080204085,
-0.0737484246,
0.0091767199,
-0.0136646442,
-0.013969969,
0.018895654,
-0.0246289857,
-0.0349045843,
-0.0429811701,
0.0589386746,
-0.0530400611,
-0.0345648117,
-0.0104068061,
0.0031384386,
-0.0070910784,
-0.0152501976,
0.0317654982,
0.0211770032,
-0.0268951487,
-0.0321184844,
-0.0474175215,
0.0328921564,
0.083603397,
-0.0279871076,
-0.0296602901,
-0.037710771,
0.0208493378,
-0.014444625,
0.0027257584,
-0.0571800396,
0.0708895177,
-0.0054590227,
0.0498359576,
0.018130457,
-0.0417036302,
0.0364279859,
0.0197338928,
0.0396100096,
-0.0163933169,
0.0083452798,
-0.0365940109,
-0.0090813283,
-0.0444740281,
-0.0393338203,
-0.0269802101,
-0.0027110924,
0.0149091221,
0.0076968828,
-0.0080636954,
0.0426373631,
-0.0373792015,
0.1054026335,
-0.0820891857,
-0.0253652222,
0.010262588,
-0.0165173002,
-0.0167433619,
0.0139387464,
-0.0298111085,
-0.0015127965,
-0.002145194,
0.0553798378,
-0.0298336037,
0.0354769453,
-0.0002502874,
-0.0258197691,
0.0153918564,
0.031335149,
-0.0933025554,
-0.0147174411,
-0.0546024628,
0.0315508321,
0.022329513,
0.0197845213,
0.0173044261,
-0.0008138004,
-0.0156111754,
0.0013480555,
-0.025151005,
0.0578072295,
-0.0395379849,
-0.0490739122,
0.039484486,
0.0150496149,
-0.0284996256,
0.0593393445,
-0.0207581352,
-0.0214531627,
-0.0617988221,
-0.0662437305,
-0.0385125093,
-0.0394281186,
-0.0135932649,
-0.001833451,
0.0144547662,
-0.0011933106,
-0.068220228,
-0.0132812429,
-0.0155687509,
0.0335653871,
0.0189229958,
-0.0255500618,
0.0662071928,
0.1093307734,
0.0056473291,
-0.0188311208,
-0.0619441681,
0.0209398046,
-0.0779904574,
0.018301053,
-0.0425476767,
-6.283193629e-33,
-0.0218442362,
-0.0204381831,
0.0031264897,
-0.0296340398,
0.0024805404,
-0.0175481439,
0.006041375,
-0.0301871002,
0.0229474045,
-0.0149693694,
-0.0212860685,
-0.0146671934,
0.0103423819,
0.0139314542,
-0.0041318443,
0.0269203037,
0.0240652952,
0.0047683353,
-0.0428243056,
0.0271679908,
0.0821677074,
0.017133195,
-0.0343516916,
-0.0498302132,
0.0305422284,
-0.0445183218,
0.0106758866,
0.0058250614,
0.020651238,
0.0516479351,
-0.0087673087,
0.0457683541,
0.0229840074,
-0.0309883822,
0.0152599718,
0.0141177895,
-0.0534673519,
-0.0188645888,
0.0008956867,
-0.0630156696,
-0.0381877199,
-0.0066766096,
0.0339835063,
-0.0019750064,
-0.0361395739,
0.022753777,
0.0613528639,
-0.0135750221,
-0.0451624803,
-0.0667441562,
-0.0381523892,
0.0240136273,
0.0335758664,
0.0265516955,
-0.0175608974,
0.0621344298,
-0.0010429006,
0.0426561162,
-0.0168910548,
0.0441553928,
-0.0207413156,
0.0541142598,
0.008623383,
0.0217500627,
0.0055353553,
0.0284212325,
0.0163871478,
0.0086306054,
-0.0421293266,
-0.0265720282,
-0.0206837598,
0.0001952771,
0.035593845,
0.0693303272,
0.033499945,
0.0027157948,
-0.0096244337,
0.0845631734,
-0.0375156589,
0.001088387,
0.0566865318,
0.0284505747,
-0.0349790528,
-0.0242570378,
0.0054380437,
0.0092313886,
-0.0568901673,
-0.0428538099,
0.0316602066,
0.0440176204,
-0.0376670919,
-0.014905896,
0.0136623215,
0.0247533415,
-0.0022686413,
0.0374635085,
-0.0089116488,
0.014648824,
0.0035144135,
-0.0200321935,
-0.0216946155,
0.0178813934,
0.053361997,
0.0264773499,
-0.0430148505,
-0.0240802187,
-0.0215640571,
0.0120904297,
-0.044868134,
0.00532301,
0.0103728361,
0.0149242952,
-0.0642717332,
-0.0422994345,
0.0018805121,
0.0099973232,
-0.0046407431,
0.018493332,
0.02058913,
0.0560842082,
-0.0101505732,
-0.0560712777,
-0.0066913343,
-0.0138930809,
0.000713114,
0.0767014474,
-0.0115103126,
0.0160187408,
0.0222189277,
-0.0368360132,
-0.0039210487,
0.0368757099,
2.504e-7,
0.0500359163,
0.0207518674,
0.0162171293,
0.0122205522,
0.0025789016,
-0.030205721,
0.0314648226,
0.0108090695,
0.0489304736,
0.0005339282,
0.0028498687,
0.0196769629,
0.0190746225,
0.0307984315,
-0.08457461,
-0.0151557336,
-0.0635506585,
-0.030292742,
-0.0218438935,
-0.0116209583,
0.0849419683,
-0.0060802582,
-0.0445106365,
0.0121438988,
-0.0117005892,
-0.0475986525,
0.0482901186,
0.0222872086,
0.0172623675,
-0.0175205581,
0.0651823878,
0.0231956597,
0.0186433978,
-0.0209682006,
-0.013437489,
-0.0053506899,
0.0522198975,
-0.0020978441,
-0.0065887589,
-0.0310862474,
0.0033373211,
-0.0222508349,
0.0222922154,
-0.0602969751,
0.0449660048,
-0.0332382768,
0.0494770929,
0.0376469269,
-0.0452168286,
0.0079217674,
-0.0123960609,
-0.0312293936,
-0.0640320852,
0.0155664999,
-0.0092478003,
0.0323065557,
0.0185951013,
-0.0529196076,
0.0030507289,
-0.0295256861,
-0.0384777784,
-0.0412082635,
-0.042026639,
0.01374711,
-0.0312002525,
0.0022817745,
-0.0034839555,
1.913822008e-34,
0.0453722775,
0.0562254861,
-0.0396413952,
-0.0482159555,
0.0240183696,
0.0109322062,
-0.0002615117,
0.0090360492,
0.0128582222,
-0.0776346922,
-0.0277723335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04666v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04666v4 | Pre-training LLMs using human-like development data corpus | 2023-11-08T13:13:23 | 2024-01-10T05:36:05 | Khushi Bhardwaj, Raj Sanjay Shah, Sashank Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown success in a diverse set
of language inference and understanding tasks. The pre-training stage of LLMs
looks at a large corpus of raw textual data. The BabyLM shared task compares
LLM pre-training to human language acquisition, where the number of tokens seen
by 13-year-old kids is magnitudes smaller than the number of tokens seen by
LLMs. In this work, we pre-train and evaluate LLMs on their ability to learn
contextual word representations using roughly the same number of tokens as seen
by children. We provide a strong set of baselines; with different
architectures, evaluation of changes in performance across epochs, and reported
pre-training metrics for the strict small and strict tracks of the task. We
also try to loosely replicate the RoBERTa baseline given by the task organizers
to observe the training robustness to hyperparameter selection and
replicability. We provide the submission details to the strict and strict-small
tracks in this report. | [
0.0071828631,
0.0726881698,
-0.0052493862,
0.0610493794,
-0.0284383185,
0.0298020672,
0.0151470788,
-0.0200327337,
-0.0457047597,
-0.05374543,
-0.0552088059,
-0.0531719849,
-0.0175708029,
-0.0033953208,
0.021895228,
-0.0236027427,
0.0487163588,
-0.032109309,
-0.0315249041,
0.0119062979,
-0.0113059981,
0.0004169655,
-0.0048678354,
0.0341356583,
-0.0455726907,
-0.0143489493,
0.0236582775,
0.0093562044,
0.0046373513,
-0.0646928623,
0.0217439886,
0.0322181955,
0.06833186,
0.0388693772,
0.0000019754,
-0.0642356202,
-0.0115677835,
-0.0273703169,
-0.0552133135,
0.0073039974,
0.0532703437,
-0.0096530104,
-0.0111410292,
-0.0064317337,
-0.0384093635,
-0.0478319414,
0.0289761275,
0.0379189588,
0.0217789784,
0.0805393532,
0.0012407062,
-0.0087590674,
0.0137805697,
-0.0318489559,
0.0379535556,
-0.051909022,
0.0239780098,
0.0246285703,
0.0038094064,
0.0018537058,
-0.0095803207,
0.008834633,
0.0147539862,
0.0127887279,
-0.0200992916,
0.0464990251,
-0.0240535568,
-0.0431104712,
-0.0231854338,
0.0886892378,
-0.0062545775,
-0.0379404686,
-0.0074962778,
-0.006070205,
-0.0251968093,
-0.0434305631,
-0.0251035001,
0.0521957465,
0.0124981236,
0.058083944,
0.0251553375,
-0.0184413735,
0.0572947711,
0.0374334976,
-0.0267086662,
0.0517216437,
0.0190970693,
-0.0257883053,
0.0226515997,
0.0277881455,
-0.0303829312,
-0.0337224603,
0.013341154,
-0.0036746764,
-0.0158601236,
0.0329396725,
-0.0622072369,
-0.0186131913,
0.0199901965,
-0.0354942381,
0.0334411673,
0.0072264955,
-0.0390813351,
0.0755862072,
-0.0390213579,
0.0204722136,
-0.0058754738,
0.0200804472,
-0.049808003,
-0.0267605968,
-0.0062596574,
0.0205023177,
-0.051765576,
0.0206861775,
-0.0422024019,
-0.0182272661,
-0.0264573246,
0.0495200828,
0.0089432718,
-0.0241468623,
0.0285876412,
0.0017966441,
-0.0227733981,
-0.0164045561,
-0.0203469042,
-0.016545143,
-0.04922105,
0.043063771,
-0.0062897843,
-0.0729051083,
-0.0281545073,
0.022537414,
0.0407605469,
-0.0383518524,
0.0312889293,
0.0639343038,
0.0327650122,
-0.0592966601,
-0.0469832905,
0.0230474155,
-0.0093665896,
-0.0837704018,
-0.0056905048,
-0.0387941152,
0.0245211963,
-0.0033052058,
0.0178668778,
-0.0231745243,
-0.0068593724,
0.0281033404,
-0.0112141874,
0.0645523295,
-0.0152257225,
-0.0208443962,
-0.0216665976,
0.0043838224,
0.0112200733,
0.0822874606,
0.0355373658,
0.005502935,
0.0317916684,
-0.0001888505,
-0.0563707426,
0.0417068526,
0.0202460531,
-0.0013809915,
-0.0172560979,
0.0155151449,
0.0217732247,
0.0473533198,
0.0477033928,
0.0327493846,
-0.0403818749,
-0.0137938866,
0.073082149,
0.0826959983,
-0.0029058675,
0.0283258483,
0.0895894021,
-0.0105403867,
0.0272265896,
-0.038409099,
-0.0641515106,
-0.0066202637,
0.01030338,
-0.0061671296,
-0.0012408897,
0.0042133504,
-0.040684063,
-0.0137540512,
-0.0311890356,
-0.0287990551,
-0.0302553475,
-0.0032897778,
0.0528203286,
0.0307403523,
-0.0770472214,
0.0243171453,
0.0524846949,
-0.0244924985,
0.026745284,
-0.0510850623,
0.0637971908,
0.0366521999,
0.010053196,
-0.0303529967,
-0.0202444624,
0.0066416068,
0.0184543021,
0.0052083805,
0.0110811079,
-0.0021798189,
0.0393971838,
-0.0403367803,
0.003240651,
-0.001162156,
0.0234026648,
0.0200411025,
0.0108456016,
-0.0054814229,
0.0193236899,
-0.0533895306,
-0.0168494973,
0.0760155395,
-0.0414943583,
-0.0376257747,
0.018069284,
0.0010832393,
0.058324527,
-0.0164246392,
-0.0107244793,
-0.0025472287,
0.0566038005,
-0.0236800052,
0.0366082117,
0.0111923534,
-0.0900287777,
-0.063787058,
0.0043442938,
-0.0164683927,
-0.028337907,
0.0209652856,
-0.0248126555,
-0.0106903194,
0.0268435087,
-0.0027487664,
0.0574061684,
-0.0636395663,
0.0378454477,
-0.0005719967,
0.0186588075,
-0.0099024354,
0.0683158487,
0.0101253847,
-0.0033320363,
-0.0092302319,
0.0250055511,
-0.0082137901,
-0.0304433163,
-0.0328580551,
-0.0353524312,
-0.0102181844,
0.0185536351,
-0.0220361054,
0.0201368313,
-0.079779081,
0.0109715732,
-0.118937321,
0.0221081823,
-0.0114390608,
0.022278076,
0.0095719062,
-0.0100441799,
-0.0143830497,
-0.0227371808,
0.0134525103,
0.0338282213,
-0.0168014094,
0.0048947665,
0.0303509813,
-0.0215676688,
0.0028444557,
-0.0652342066,
-0.0034985095,
-0.010843874,
0.0598115735,
-0.002122337,
0.0250029583,
-0.0214139279,
0.027139755,
-0.0049213795,
0.0402662084,
-0.006951449,
-0.0142663987,
0.0235285424,
-0.0392294265,
0.0443544835,
0.0928502306,
-0.0014280207,
0.0320537835,
0.0280990452,
-0.023336878,
-0.0622137114,
0.0043806629,
-0.0099782757,
-0.0056435065,
-0.0513022766,
0.0147539647,
0.0028869442,
0.1082148626,
-0.0042411713,
-0.0045188852,
-0.0232043639,
0.0069540576,
-0.0211328138,
0.001543846,
-0.0164217558,
-0.017844459,
-0.05211531,
0.0242635682,
-0.0446202867,
-0.0609848909,
0.0286561791,
-0.0533073656,
-0.0207866319,
-0.0489785522,
-0.0150820194,
-0.0370056145,
0.0527898036,
0.0161797255,
0.0142319333,
-0.0354143418,
-0.0113244699,
-0.04197805,
0.0236110371,
0.0090905009,
-0.0173754748,
0.0550519601,
-0.0342519693,
0.0310091879,
0.0084831826,
-0.0202074312,
-0.0622869134,
-0.0687103271,
-0.0504059941,
0.0099656126,
0.0104052778,
0.0047157854,
-0.0338805877,
-0.0126347924,
0.0002777265,
0.0629346222,
0.0218820404,
-0.0042869835,
-0.0260939132,
-0.0051343702,
0.0231614802,
-0.024102537,
0.0203932691,
-0.046000082,
0.0161974486,
0.0292583834,
0.0335384384,
0.0095923897,
-0.059235435,
0.0417135023,
0.0104063516,
0.0038717813,
0.010033112,
0.035930641,
0.062513195,
-0.0419477448,
-0.0193159636,
0.1036290452,
0.0186829809,
-0.0494033955,
0.0053065987,
0.0282241702,
0.0119615812,
0.0164569896,
-0.013212868,
-0.0711300671,
-0.0278031956,
0.0065827607,
-0.0062847133,
0.0101594701,
-0.0330636986,
-0.0258138124,
-0.1044836715,
-0.001052015,
0.0060438127,
-0.0638236552,
0.024850456,
-0.0299087111,
0.0101944711,
0.0118625937,
0.0636170954,
0.0089723496,
-0.0434260108,
-0.0267841872,
0.0217817333,
0.0122080408,
-0.0641837344,
0.0449935496,
-0.0697320104,
0.0604544058,
0.0440141708,
0.0229340736,
-0.0071814647,
-0.0070551257,
0.0580974855,
-0.0296680722,
-0.0212925579,
-0.0256922059,
-0.0067364154,
-0.0323863998,
-0.0241538584,
-0.0202301368,
0.0270521399,
-0.0295785572,
-0.0240485817,
0.0014513478,
0.0735806674,
-0.0067549944,
-0.0453003608,
0.0210979171,
0.0014313995,
0.0025848851,
0.0996885672,
0.0383594893,
-0.06056327,
-0.0153356297,
0.0435422547,
-0.014934768,
-0.0252686664,
-0.005679341,
0.0173119605,
-0.0167550631,
0.0051704231,
-0.0802048072,
-0.0176585447,
0.0616841577,
0.0577807203,
-0.0037774404,
-0.0093943989,
0.0079572424,
-0.015144445,
-0.0446605347,
0.0748134851,
-0.0300183408,
-0.0094020637,
-0.0841283798,
-0.0169339683,
0.0260249153,
-0.0307204649,
-0.0279823001,
-0.0085691065,
-0.1018274799,
-0.0369328447,
0.0074691856,
0.0442634672,
0.019497104,
0.0472197272,
-0.0209203847,
-0.0355328619,
0.0607403405,
0.022431232,
-0.0229926351,
-0.0032877233,
0.0163203254,
0.0055698892,
0.0024152854,
0.0401034988,
-0.0452415235,
0.0396674797,
0.0463850908,
0.0325726457,
0.0067994082,
-0.0004879392,
0.0164608359,
-0.0306237899,
0.0415003374,
-0.0150383422,
-0.0070169186,
-0.0557494313,
0.0156311616,
-0.0336755551,
0.0309053529,
-0.0334854238,
-0.0029961981,
0.0316791534,
0.0078443931,
-0.0187190697,
-0.0009169963,
-0.0135993166,
0.0525666066,
-0.0237623025,
0.0569054708,
0.0218553655,
0.0460075215,
0.0293575935,
0.0198837575,
-0.036682114,
-0.0079469187,
-0.0327616371,
0.0465411618,
-0.0307028368,
0.0296737123,
-0.0107499519,
-0.0115978736,
-0.0272817276,
0.0150030591,
-0.0382773615,
-0.0090291863,
-0.0359797813,
0.0142399808,
0.0616864972,
-0.0432147682,
0.030464923,
-0.0146890935,
0.0126211243,
-0.0341226868,
-0.0025170106,
-0.0327951349,
-0.0029513743,
0.0498880334,
0.0043938565,
-0.0221616887,
0.0236458499,
0.0589317232,
0.0201627519,
0.0449346825,
0.0022862654,
0.0268373508,
-0.0274473596,
0.0031831602,
0.0170961916,
0.0227225833,
-0.0442691296,
0.0298379157,
0.0078018899,
-0.0737828761,
-0.0178979281,
0.0020730176,
-0.0285570491,
0.0143822683,
0.0274147857,
0.0469181053,
-0.0116890818,
-0.0022512311,
-0.0065307454,
0.0163082033,
0.022711128,
-0.0111920312,
-0.0267502964,
-6.877154027e-33,
-0.0107993493,
0.0131354257,
0.0098401094,
-0.045799382,
-0.0177177843,
0.0303777177,
-0.04499631,
-0.0228682254,
-0.0377346352,
-0.0218099114,
-0.0001233108,
-0.0004337136,
0.0147552183,
0.0354778096,
-0.0220740251,
-0.0333148874,
0.0273147635,
-0.0166758113,
0.0196877792,
0.0084814643,
0.0099534439,
0.0411010236,
0.081189841,
-0.0226590764,
0.0195557792,
-0.0322300531,
-0.0003033611,
0.0468479618,
0.0133854272,
0.0689100847,
-0.0348656625,
0.0081600342,
0.0294875465,
0.0068680821,
-0.0286615733,
0.0296675302,
-0.1224136278,
-0.0359210484,
0.0625675917,
0.0062019429,
-0.048725687,
-0.0026134357,
0.0351197794,
0.0037245646,
-0.0059513953,
0.010277817,
0.0047881505,
0.0194015726,
-0.0174371321,
-0.0076407189,
-0.0879277289,
0.0163952168,
0.0079147909,
0.0032393537,
0.0339353643,
0.0136172194,
-0.0238878839,
0.0117569407,
-0.0577148944,
-0.0091723902,
-0.0237833261,
0.0152546205,
0.0300493892,
0.0313725993,
0.0442748033,
0.0870723799,
0.0240181778,
-0.0034574433,
-0.0176450573,
-0.0107737817,
0.0707180649,
0.0495163426,
-0.0093812812,
0.0147564085,
0.0270031374,
0.0229905061,
-0.0962136313,
-0.0208795089,
0.0347064026,
0.0553971976,
0.0301137492,
0.0031249358,
-0.0159965046,
0.0216912739,
-0.0540810525,
-0.0287437439,
-0.0435406156,
-0.0103406617,
0.0475262068,
0.0177678373,
-0.0027944634,
0.0052591194,
0.0279570371,
-0.0385834835,
-0.0249731168,
0.0011123082,
0.0326521024,
-0.0356340744,
0.0009110848,
0.0695399866,
-0.0527069047,
-0.0730995089,
0.0363588445,
-0.0038301372,
0.0375406109,
0.0128336735,
0.0419485644,
-0.021417547,
-0.0641131923,
-0.0248696022,
-0.038667392,
-0.0030117005,
0.0053645531,
0.0361730233,
0.0600356646,
0.0331900232,
-0.0058969557,
0.0476874821,
0.010209443,
-0.0209387988,
-0.0214873031,
0.0013419359,
0.0107366024,
0.0463335924,
-0.0145589616,
-0.031777177,
-0.0199504979,
0.0275892876,
0.0609784275,
-0.0688414797,
0.006849899,
0.0230725091,
2.746e-7,
0.0247985478,
0.0527151152,
0.007604117,
-0.0093834111,
0.0338479429,
0.006342493,
-0.0271785427,
0.0193244219,
0.0088669984,
-0.006576323,
0.0121061374,
0.018460203,
0.0529098175,
0.0085852807,
-0.1113548577,
-0.0082466146,
-0.0638152733,
0.0094614653,
-0.058584258,
0.0089155072,
0.0554648675,
0.125235945,
0.0065018861,
-0.0401889458,
0.0227286015,
-0.0548561104,
0.0591977015,
-0.0666081831,
0.0169252902,
0.002688942,
-0.0295323227,
0.0265013669,
0.0168873481,
0.0265594777,
-0.010646495,
0.0427162275,
-0.0170604195,
0.049060721,
-0.0107684871,
-0.0207650308,
-0.008274355,
-0.0087446384,
-0.0056739482,
-0.0493011177,
0.0984403118,
-0.0599092618,
-0.0169546437,
-0.0316052735,
-0.0080725551,
-0.0280389488,
0.0098575829,
-0.0192536563,
0.007150678,
0.0250868369,
0.0393980294,
-0.0127072921,
-0.037150111,
-0.088175647,
0.0075237877,
0.0229514521,
-0.0522560924,
-0.0590246208,
-0.041211769,
0.0087518152,
0.0526235923,
-0.0260629691,
0.0453945734,
2.188102837e-34,
0.0173853375,
-0.022524083,
0.0271732938,
0.0208652131,
0.0266591012,
-0.0012138461,
0.0080359243,
-0.0031129848,
0.0137155177,
-0.1020947248,
0.0143686403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04664v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04664v2 | Speech language models lack important brain-relevant semantics | 2023-11-08T13:11:48 | 2024-06-16T23:52:21 | Subba Reddy Oota, Emin Çelik, Fatma Deniz, Mariya Toneva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS, q-bio.NC | Despite known differences between reading and listening in the brain, recent
work has shown that text-based language models predict both text-evoked and
speech-evoked brain activity to an impressive degree. This poses the question
of what types of information language models truly predict in the brain. We
investigate this question via a direct approach, in which we systematically
remove specific low-level stimulus features (textual, speech, and visual) from
language model representations to assess their impact on alignment with fMRI
brain recordings during reading and listening. Comparing these findings with
speech-based language models reveals starkly different effects of low-level
features on brain alignment. While text-based models show reduced alignment in
early sensory regions post-removal, they retain significant predictive power in
late language regions. In contrast, speech-based models maintain strong
alignment in early auditory regions even after feature removal but lose all
predictive power in late language regions. These results suggest that
speech-based models provide insights into additional information processed by
early auditory regions, but caution is needed when using them to model
processing in late language regions. We make our code publicly available.
[https://github.com/subbareddy248/speech-llm-brain] | [
-0.0082051465,
0.0760416985,
-0.0246555451,
0.0245351791,
-0.0236950349,
0.030751422,
0.0302421264,
0.0244489126,
-0.0164641682,
0.0010633232,
-0.0527766347,
-0.0363743939,
0.1025031283,
0.0619578026,
0.0563708842,
-0.0294548925,
-0.0014336476,
-0.0312574655,
0.0080553396,
-0.0049232384,
0.027958557,
0.0337127224,
-0.0575447753,
0.0128761344,
0.0215532295,
-0.0313289426,
-0.0270426869,
-0.0115606319,
0.0069541652,
0.0350657776,
-0.0461475924,
0.0657354891,
-0.0020154477,
0.007377869,
0.0000017496,
-0.0241810977,
0.0303101614,
-0.008286695,
0.0073037562,
0.0173464175,
0.0385747626,
0.0076449635,
-0.0098728584,
-0.0254308376,
0.0171152167,
-0.0051353648,
0.064289391,
0.0575982668,
-0.0186520331,
0.0489262678,
-0.0215047244,
-0.0006411319,
0.0670523271,
-0.0259323977,
0.0570272766,
0.0051636877,
0.0289290771,
-0.0443494953,
-0.0423295312,
0.0156049207,
-0.0301929563,
0.0294929594,
-0.0247215964,
0.0380523391,
-0.0023526954,
0.0770008937,
0.0060067801,
-0.0235914625,
-0.0054317112,
0.0473074764,
0.0365459099,
-0.0775827989,
0.013956693,
0.0121123288,
-0.0355779901,
-0.0130166635,
-0.0048096292,
0.0249097422,
0.01253743,
0.0390848927,
0.0201143771,
-0.0511398129,
0.0242458601,
-0.0163693596,
0.0284749027,
0.0458879508,
0.0135559123,
-0.05124918,
0.017899394,
0.0219903365,
-0.0234235954,
-0.0520136133,
-0.0126092834,
-0.0139700901,
0.0093454141,
0.0036546839,
-0.0403771587,
-0.0438590869,
-0.0048535611,
-0.0267963279,
-0.027339045,
0.0698163658,
-0.0178066958,
0.0202861913,
-0.0114600463,
0.0646833926,
-0.0396891609,
0.0460997894,
-0.0168391876,
0.0149052739,
0.0092575131,
-0.0505535975,
0.0438857712,
-0.0120521327,
-0.0434648469,
-0.0479515456,
-0.0115115047,
0.0131368143,
0.0102440165,
-0.0329144448,
-0.011765223,
0.0284338016,
-0.0200033672,
0.0305864923,
-0.0187700726,
0.0047091353,
0.0304775015,
0.0572057329,
-0.014275833,
-0.024866147,
-0.0228359383,
0.0646729022,
-0.0115138991,
-0.030993538,
-0.0381246172,
0.0550664142,
-0.0127478298,
0.0007822335,
-0.0187223405,
0.0363270231,
-0.0131683089,
-0.0212855898,
0.0108612916,
-0.0470471755,
0.0505137369,
0.0424899496,
-0.0239765551,
-0.0556756705,
-0.0221482888,
-0.0112055214,
-0.0398535319,
0.0355440862,
-0.0133899078,
0.0430309549,
0.0500262603,
0.0150485663,
0.0035301016,
-0.0132883936,
0.0465466157,
-0.0333749503,
-0.0319450796,
-0.0294281822,
-0.058545284,
0.0542281084,
-0.0000173554,
-0.0311483312,
-0.0483894721,
-0.0444177128,
-0.0124064703,
0.0217516739,
0.0637984425,
0.0174814165,
0.0106330505,
-0.050770238,
0.0825816542,
0.0938210785,
-0.0176578388,
0.0004451451,
-0.0227410458,
0.0035068986,
0.0112660201,
0.0120614944,
-0.0308294911,
0.0319704376,
-0.0267163031,
0.0208773389,
0.0378623083,
-0.0188779887,
-0.0109407064,
0.0215129796,
-0.0128477486,
-0.0132725565,
0.0009455358,
0.0287824441,
0.0276355743,
-0.0170975756,
-0.0349101648,
0.0168533344,
0.0390123539,
-0.0105059268,
0.0004342188,
0.0063813217,
0.0297553055,
0.0110339401,
0.0077282023,
-0.0143202925,
-0.0064187613,
0.0504700765,
0.0026483855,
0.0942485705,
0.0174766183,
0.0478645898,
0.0540898927,
-0.014423972,
-0.018255217,
0.0291530006,
-0.0112655433,
-0.035140533,
-0.0115888454,
-0.019201288,
-0.0329354703,
-0.0235301107,
-0.0207436662,
0.0468416698,
-0.0654823035,
0.0013166246,
-0.0484665744,
-0.0011731124,
0.0319496132,
-0.0494845212,
-0.0348850973,
0.029861398,
0.0125949597,
0.0035409227,
0.0531548336,
0.0192591716,
-0.0223020948,
-0.0050950376,
0.0535028055,
0.0120130293,
-0.0131864799,
0.0654868186,
0.0302406289,
-0.0203055944,
0.0164469182,
-0.0484207161,
0.024392942,
-0.0160464216,
0.0353284925,
-0.0314728953,
0.0136417495,
-0.0511990041,
0.0083595756,
0.0063483836,
0.0166156162,
0.0100605022,
-0.0076987194,
-0.0101990122,
-0.0511791073,
-0.0532648005,
0.0270902216,
0.0018417622,
-0.0229591914,
-0.020717917,
-0.0254715327,
-0.0277747978,
-0.0102769649,
-0.084886983,
-0.0059236917,
0.034887325,
-0.0078736246,
0.0688402951,
-0.0229035616,
-0.006881895,
0.0295877121,
-0.0396197587,
0.0155812846,
0.0072548655,
0.0041365628,
0.0036653371,
-0.0310695637,
-0.0088663669,
-0.0617755204,
0.0011898119,
-0.0605181791,
0.0476993024,
-0.0360138714,
-0.0547636524,
-0.0436649919,
0.0795711726,
-0.0521140061,
0.012207591,
-0.001440831,
0.023998769,
0.0144477999,
0.0032135546,
0.0495717116,
0.0520877466,
0.0002618675,
0.0446501896,
0.0462145209,
-0.0163292587,
-0.0339512043,
-0.0276338998,
-0.0279480778,
0.0433368906,
-0.0338319913,
-0.0363325514,
-0.0168007929,
0.0873253793,
0.0899822563,
0.0379460454,
-0.0216799509,
0.0230755247,
-0.007663345,
-0.0286348145,
-0.034373153,
-0.00894986,
-0.0615904257,
0.0663295984,
-0.074365668,
-0.0501501746,
0.0700412989,
-0.0515108183,
-0.0009979812,
-0.0141540784,
0.0033265299,
-0.0074354205,
0.0146120088,
0.0481264442,
0.0319579057,
-0.0242111403,
-0.0250533912,
-0.0552747808,
0.0096389316,
-0.0319348499,
-0.044520285,
0.0263086688,
-0.0163005944,
0.005132278,
0.0254815333,
0.0102592679,
-0.0178239867,
-0.0178025458,
0.0049083587,
-0.0216800254,
-0.007646108,
0.0166197289,
-0.0863271207,
-0.0090325549,
0.0560322441,
0.0560258366,
-0.0239057448,
0.0074871927,
-0.0195457563,
0.0775896087,
0.0471955873,
0.0171155985,
-0.0213883836,
-0.047569003,
-0.0008371081,
0.0278035756,
-0.0002594517,
0.0522933975,
-0.0504932366,
0.029654827,
0.045160953,
-0.0109509788,
0.010524123,
-0.0003056407,
0.0218893308,
0.0018069461,
-0.0267268624,
0.1198852211,
0.0199215841,
-0.0319108255,
-0.0157150459,
-0.0009441069,
0.0704202056,
-0.003169683,
-0.0089727938,
-0.0318075493,
0.00283303,
0.0004136817,
-0.0062324856,
0.018835485,
0.0105363457,
-0.0153498016,
-0.0441892296,
-0.0134687982,
0.0018204367,
-0.0708575472,
-0.0025471603,
-0.0232844912,
0.050545577,
0.0139764957,
0.0535088852,
0.0064620115,
-0.0001900059,
-0.019427022,
0.0284449942,
0.0175803043,
-0.0080629028,
-0.0036883594,
-0.0101954537,
0.0822891593,
0.0710814893,
0.025491206,
-0.0326116756,
-0.0327454656,
0.0106735732,
0.0283737406,
-0.0125619899,
0.0218839366,
0.0289507918,
0.0392868109,
0.0070420294,
-0.0439616293,
0.027637003,
-0.0080027729,
-0.0617686175,
-0.0563884079,
0.0494032465,
-0.0269642156,
-0.021349119,
-0.0117870132,
0.0875398666,
-0.0431635566,
0.0356563069,
0.0386927389,
-0.0713628903,
0.0059546316,
0.006497662,
0.036755383,
0.0223869272,
-0.099114649,
-0.0043611713,
0.0202476047,
-0.0136750182,
-0.0276624355,
-0.0063363598,
0.0045311032,
-0.0492046401,
0.0453181453,
0.0052970084,
0.0444211215,
-0.0880173445,
-0.0142403618,
0.0666085556,
0.0167932138,
-0.0025314377,
-0.0349312574,
-0.0114048701,
0.0088919979,
-0.0507125445,
-0.0109185465,
0.040865697,
-0.1046987399,
-0.1058648974,
0.024934575,
-0.0220656153,
0.0220169649,
0.0257541947,
0.0182662178,
-0.0380433388,
0.0417895094,
0.0143243857,
-0.0074954205,
0.1088428646,
-0.0707843006,
0.0010776258,
0.0014153419,
0.0004363791,
-0.0323259048,
-0.0072824685,
0.0340819433,
-0.0017384096,
0.0176236928,
-0.0000058917,
0.0144168343,
0.0064234654,
0.1120100543,
0.0132490257,
-0.0013222003,
-0.0403101593,
-0.021349648,
0.0274671111,
0.0249715261,
0.0245505404,
-0.0505495481,
0.0475836322,
0.0515356213,
-0.0324869789,
-0.0190980248,
-0.0158428401,
0.0095543237,
0.003049941,
-0.024392413,
-0.0629915372,
-0.0226393826,
-0.014451446,
0.0428465232,
0.0090320129,
0.0471506864,
-0.0663378537,
0.0013517555,
0.0339720137,
0.0509010553,
0.0112417396,
0.008269975,
-0.0197025761,
-0.0124313859,
-0.0184682962,
-0.0439107716,
0.0080619371,
-0.0094962353,
-0.0430584587,
-0.0346368104,
0.0474281274,
-0.0056186104,
0.0182828307,
-0.0517015457,
0.010296409,
-0.0193696152,
0.0141841872,
0.0599640049,
0.0137131158,
0.0224341452,
-0.0246835593,
0.0225452185,
0.0404684953,
-0.0053054956,
-0.0012228447,
0.0038113999,
-0.0185207371,
-0.0325744487,
-0.0085808104,
-0.0210585799,
-0.0867029876,
-0.0155415591,
-0.0209251642,
-0.0546725541,
0.0137242721,
0.0065867887,
0.0379676037,
-0.0414913259,
-0.013474091,
0.0188178085,
-0.0345454961,
0.0085187536,
0.0074038394,
0.0002352761,
-0.0113291191,
-0.0722643957,
-0.0516676307,
-5.768760567e-33,
-0.0456530824,
-0.0351113081,
0.0088568265,
0.0356915928,
-0.0321297012,
0.0231523607,
-0.0677440166,
0.0478046164,
0.0211405288,
-0.0018039363,
0.0216068942,
-0.0096370121,
0.0160839539,
0.0241806768,
-0.0273574591,
0.0234667528,
-0.0273293294,
-0.0394630767,
-0.0253019184,
-0.0378504731,
0.0394556932,
0.0045343484,
0.0681150481,
-0.0936806798,
0.0159027502,
0.002166494,
-0.0102198571,
0.0074333204,
-0.0188356657,
0.0337576047,
-0.0802737772,
0.0274136625,
0.0332828574,
0.0114065409,
-0.0021924896,
0.0328141451,
-0.0310859792,
0.0178504214,
0.0867094621,
0.0252990406,
-0.0479444042,
-0.0219657179,
0.0845919251,
-0.025979137,
-0.0117779775,
-0.0126807084,
0.052678857,
-0.0010982211,
0.0059140655,
0.0461481847,
-0.083482787,
-0.0239662323,
-0.0341793671,
0.0110138189,
0.0203911308,
0.0186875928,
-0.0229585767,
0.0798106045,
-0.0745048225,
0.0194279645,
0.0002771546,
0.0310380813,
0.0630174205,
0.0111764669,
0.0284954831,
0.0917689577,
0.0711017549,
-0.010568127,
-0.0689136162,
0.0049733631,
0.0753530189,
0.0305223037,
-0.0141619518,
-0.0105854506,
0.0262578242,
-0.0205524173,
-0.0365653299,
0.0018173893,
-0.0491381958,
-0.0115945581,
0.0332276188,
-0.023856638,
-0.0182405077,
-0.0068602981,
-0.045430135,
-0.0307446811,
-0.0648809448,
-0.0051507177,
0.0283184014,
-0.0406083018,
0.0188551918,
-0.0263740029,
0.0224018581,
-0.0080495747,
0.0405503958,
-0.0122329313,
-0.0403700769,
0.0175801162,
0.0038354811,
0.0083678756,
-0.0423421264,
-0.018051045,
0.031159902,
0.0039041177,
0.0647954196,
-0.0082802093,
-0.0233052503,
0.0091115097,
-0.0214195531,
0.006520988,
-0.0411291644,
-0.0500204936,
0.0373733789,
0.0360940881,
0.0201249886,
-0.0058373907,
-0.0234748293,
-0.0344537571,
-0.0007969714,
-0.0061459187,
-0.0490910038,
-0.0188061297,
-0.0297316797,
0.0206473544,
-0.0163341891,
-0.0010884956,
0.0183508825,
-0.0115684569,
0.0561398715,
-0.0341637917,
-0.0290179141,
0.0408921205,
2.549e-7,
0.0573017262,
0.0263262764,
0.0299431905,
0.046274282,
0.0305389464,
0.0086148642,
-0.0222742651,
0.0136848744,
0.0363358296,
-0.0311169289,
-0.0355979502,
0.0281908698,
0.0444036722,
-0.0201698393,
-0.0606129505,
-0.0009054969,
-0.084615089,
0.0195285939,
-0.0416091681,
-0.0171184558,
-0.0021258565,
0.0470204949,
-0.0161211696,
-0.0430993363,
0.0082132453,
0.0221985262,
0.0920838788,
-0.053508807,
0.0072433488,
-0.0033802032,
-0.0066884779,
-0.0684791878,
0.0130852787,
0.0111672608,
0.0179742184,
0.0159018319,
0.0138631118,
0.0281344019,
-0.0093076341,
-0.0443220548,
-0.0166115835,
0.005897583,
-0.0276984144,
-0.0231428146,
0.0076574613,
-0.0183942262,
-0.0571805462,
-0.0026528568,
-0.0175722111,
0.0453101844,
0.0585557632,
-0.0106454575,
-0.0079338569,
-0.0048254328,
0.0138024641,
-0.0147292465,
-0.0264416598,
0.0115864351,
-0.0458154716,
0.0316068046,
-0.0728249997,
-0.014159021,
-0.00263515,
-0.0042239563,
0.0224516541,
-0.0882622898,
0.0086235525,
1.900515274e-34,
-0.0597221851,
0.0057459534,
0.0265791938,
0.0314505212,
-0.0177513007,
-0.041975785,
0.0552644879,
-0.011035298,
-0.0183686074,
-0.0689992234,
-0.0126835816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04661v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04661v3 | Massive Editing for Large Language Models via Meta Learning | 2023-11-08T13:03:06 | 2024-01-25T03:50:57 | Chenmien Tan, Ge Zhang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While large language models (LLMs) have enabled learning knowledge from the
pre-training corpora, the acquired knowledge may be fundamentally incorrect or
outdated over time, which necessitates rectifying the knowledge of the language
model (LM) after the training. A promising approach involves employing a
hyper-network to generate parameter shift, whereas existing hyper-networks
suffer from inferior scalability in synchronous editing operation amount. To
mitigate the problem, we propose the MAssive Language Model Editing Network
(MALMEN), which formulates the parameter shift aggregation as the least square
problem, subsequently updating the LM parameters using the normal equation. To
accommodate editing multiple facts simultaneously with limited memory budgets,
we separate the computation on the hyper-network and LM, enabling arbitrary
batch size on both neural networks. Our method is evaluated by editing up to
thousands of facts on LMs with different architectures, i.e., BERT-base, GPT-2,
T5-XL (2.8B), and GPT-J (6B), across various knowledge-intensive NLP tasks,
i.e., closed book fact-checking and question answering. Remarkably, MALMEN is
capable of editing hundreds of times more facts than strong baselines with the
identical hyper-network architecture and outperforms editor specifically
designed for GPT. Our code is available at
https://github.com/ChenmienTan/malmen. | [
0.0453405008,
0.0502697788,
0.0128293829,
0.0077741141,
-0.0196073875,
0.0125891007,
0.010405899,
-0.0501246639,
-0.0756700858,
-0.0741777346,
-0.0442443043,
-0.0050043673,
0.0028584483,
0.0012210915,
0.0233964249,
-0.0245398451,
0.0678889379,
-0.0012885696,
-0.0101659084,
-0.0037133617,
-0.007839404,
0.0209233202,
-0.0042061666,
0.0039426032,
-0.0007797092,
-0.0380911753,
-0.0252831355,
0.0117526799,
0.0344245136,
0.0326409824,
0.0010915447,
0.0555738509,
0.0181979798,
0.1011795923,
0.0000019943,
-0.0352212787,
-0.0292116478,
0.0104111219,
-0.0494895168,
0.0688139871,
-0.0056294799,
0.0042647691,
-0.0621001385,
0.0149877323,
-0.0150553845,
-0.0751904175,
0.065885812,
0.0169339031,
0.1134441122,
0.0886444375,
0.0008229588,
0.0025890786,
0.0450285561,
-0.037900582,
0.0037319805,
-0.0149862682,
0.0507096238,
-0.01043911,
-0.0523802228,
0.0135372942,
0.0018420494,
0.034024246,
0.0323516876,
-0.020247886,
-0.0333889611,
0.0218882635,
-0.0510876328,
0.0379129909,
-0.0208588988,
0.0384950005,
-0.0435153879,
-0.0223102085,
-0.0240180083,
0.0195179209,
0.0252696946,
0.0354154333,
-0.0218009651,
0.0168520138,
0.0013060318,
-0.0086374925,
-0.0260739066,
-0.1226089671,
0.0548754297,
0.0303123742,
-0.0106165912,
0.0364179723,
0.0372182578,
-0.02041292,
-0.0399862118,
-0.0289600138,
-0.0644697994,
-0.0546414629,
0.0108829169,
0.0386130214,
-0.0184107851,
0.0086127995,
-0.0397903174,
-0.0462134145,
0.0116795376,
-0.067973651,
0.0439175814,
0.0149033787,
-0.0080413707,
0.0499301404,
-0.0083753271,
0.0313573144,
-0.0177467391,
-0.0049409377,
-0.0102847908,
-0.0001810963,
-0.0737753883,
-0.0212914087,
-0.0706877857,
0.0497501567,
-0.0394662246,
0.0332779996,
-0.0339363627,
0.0131067783,
-0.0030165885,
0.0333805792,
0.0030762537,
-0.0049794465,
-0.0085356915,
-0.0560749061,
-0.0161060467,
0.0595877506,
-0.0116460221,
0.0030032867,
-0.0081087155,
-0.0250536297,
-0.0114202546,
-0.0211805515,
0.0023464512,
-0.0389520936,
0.0290011037,
0.0595383123,
-0.0149063682,
-0.0134877432,
-0.0818135813,
0.0075872377,
-0.002706541,
-0.066643402,
-0.0020699687,
-0.060999319,
0.0240243673,
-0.0313822441,
-0.0438744575,
0.0065807379,
-0.0070240381,
0.0281319972,
-0.0201768409,
0.0618280396,
-0.0336665437,
-0.009215937,
0.0706374049,
-0.0071093934,
-0.0415712856,
0.0476069115,
0.0449996591,
-0.0046411422,
0.035953559,
0.0032139954,
0.016422838,
0.0358484983,
0.020121064,
0.0363228917,
-0.0118567813,
-0.0081284046,
0.038553454,
0.0381774604,
0.0074305111,
0.0444037803,
-0.0463470928,
-0.0143473139,
0.1005032361,
0.0012550524,
-0.0096775303,
0.0743913651,
0.0491682701,
-0.0205203723,
0.0293036774,
-0.0093233697,
-0.062133655,
0.0313051604,
-0.032450296,
-0.0097166458,
0.0014110032,
0.0216890387,
-0.0356092975,
-0.0278934333,
0.0025157051,
0.0220156591,
-0.051115308,
0.0014363722,
0.018247759,
-0.0034573586,
-0.0174663905,
0.0616896227,
0.0176990163,
-0.0240377598,
0.002166562,
-0.0301200878,
-0.0300277974,
0.0654640496,
0.0523372665,
-0.0779980198,
-0.0978298858,
-0.0621691011,
-0.0056373035,
0.0450664982,
0.0605259053,
-0.0273725372,
-0.0022397668,
-0.0446203239,
0.0159525312,
-0.0312681906,
0.0244815368,
0.0390604697,
0.0091565661,
0.0085890181,
0.0129622146,
-0.0245617237,
-0.0266789757,
-0.0014661322,
-0.0495747551,
-0.0243588593,
0.002617622,
0.0203753244,
-0.018439563,
-0.005715529,
-0.0483985394,
-0.0185542312,
-0.0053857998,
-0.0162754022,
-0.0272757951,
-0.0208856091,
-0.0025055096,
-0.0367910117,
0.0753224269,
-0.0167705752,
-0.041743543,
0.0525133722,
-0.0591428988,
-0.0385638289,
-0.019999275,
-0.0320995972,
0.061667446,
-0.0543671958,
0.0334588848,
-0.0021810571,
-0.0108131766,
-0.0154855214,
0.0275960583,
-0.0156615973,
-0.0099546304,
0.0201187506,
-0.0071531837,
0.0048154397,
-0.0309964996,
-0.0290850271,
0.0439232923,
0.0316129737,
0.0135493139,
-0.0176660493,
0.0052172877,
-0.0328244194,
-0.0415935405,
-0.0699921772,
0.0201359745,
-0.0379218124,
0.0215423144,
0.070952408,
0.0070075546,
-0.0144040016,
0.0104114125,
-0.0142776975,
0.0214530323,
-0.0276690125,
0.0305865686,
0.0587827154,
0.0324828215,
0.0006684698,
-0.0478286594,
-0.0230175164,
-0.0190607216,
0.0571492091,
0.005125958,
0.0105855223,
-0.0216174424,
-0.0236104913,
-0.0503011383,
0.041926533,
0.0187084861,
-0.0665403903,
-0.0289751664,
-0.0373977199,
0.0561823435,
0.0587010235,
0.0069079855,
-0.0196331646,
0.0698595643,
-0.0047695097,
-0.0242220759,
0.0392013416,
0.0000573417,
-0.0210145786,
-0.0203500558,
0.014584912,
0.0062854183,
0.0429167897,
-0.0272011273,
-0.0514401793,
-0.0181497131,
0.0439808145,
0.0364660546,
-0.0134653533,
-0.0203133244,
0.0048859697,
-0.0131772496,
-0.0086523378,
-0.0673166886,
-0.0335642025,
0.0693014264,
-0.014856346,
0.0100156814,
-0.0503901206,
-0.0071456209,
-0.0094393259,
0.0221461728,
-0.0124581465,
0.0405336544,
-0.0459460057,
-0.0200683158,
-0.0507368334,
-0.0127169443,
0.048499994,
-0.0103365537,
0.0538589433,
-0.0671816692,
0.0172595363,
-0.0080636088,
-0.026716467,
-0.0169808008,
-0.0285927802,
-0.0037590761,
0.0429655798,
-0.018952217,
-0.0458820611,
-0.054506965,
-0.0349963009,
0.0514665991,
0.1051630899,
-0.0166225154,
-0.0256704818,
-0.0155312698,
0.0144000407,
0.037686009,
0.0371888727,
0.0273010135,
0.0034438921,
0.0468974449,
0.0471543595,
0.0229785871,
-0.0169058442,
-0.0315807797,
-0.0005828487,
-0.0172501486,
-0.0793361962,
-0.0129357381,
-0.0360794216,
0.0170745552,
-0.0527046137,
-0.0054553319,
0.1171581894,
0.0520597994,
-0.0572915226,
-0.0213703737,
-0.0149894217,
-0.0024465949,
0.0343529992,
0.0599162988,
-0.0630206689,
-0.00523934,
0.0231312979,
0.0119787715,
0.0014783836,
-0.0396922827,
-0.0300849322,
-0.0953021944,
0.0011346869,
-0.001395209,
-0.0314328521,
-0.036651805,
-0.030612221,
0.0069083776,
0.0011046907,
0.0149613339,
0.0346699469,
0.0007762771,
-0.0295388214,
-0.0175957698,
0.0585811324,
-0.0234390013,
0.0368547104,
-0.0127767315,
0.0394430198,
0.0230838656,
0.0245470051,
-0.0228393953,
-0.0213414058,
0.0844280869,
0.0290170778,
-0.0215098076,
-0.0001228137,
0.0779765919,
-0.0186990984,
-0.0097652972,
0.0205201358,
0.0186360888,
0.0066221622,
-0.0156883355,
0.0106284814,
0.1035791412,
0.0026681104,
0.0205934439,
0.0143094677,
-0.0353896916,
-0.0120364679,
0.0359031036,
0.0231984053,
-0.037049327,
0.0097085983,
-0.0336285271,
-0.0684911534,
-0.0156258959,
0.0282251257,
0.0248939432,
-0.0378116332,
-0.0054276646,
-0.0602433272,
-0.0066478951,
0.0408595875,
0.0481105112,
0.0417253487,
-0.0127677852,
0.0577623136,
0.0017718058,
-0.0262041464,
0.0020054358,
-0.0334663168,
-0.0173484795,
-0.0561188944,
-0.0091580227,
0.0766659528,
-0.0306980275,
-0.0082237925,
-0.0218183286,
-0.0444694571,
-0.0630163774,
0.0019269413,
0.0510724187,
0.0176660456,
0.0575388521,
-0.0032820795,
-0.0569084063,
0.0203947239,
0.0238304026,
-0.0118246125,
0.0277282912,
0.0404314026,
0.0034269136,
-0.0318520367,
0.0368781872,
-0.0228615347,
0.0102823228,
0.0443640463,
-0.0001410061,
-0.0293930452,
0.0068816491,
0.0219023898,
0.014971572,
0.0228613056,
0.0313552544,
0.0213242397,
-0.0671189576,
0.054241132,
-0.006569576,
-0.0008183925,
-0.0130449906,
0.0202206802,
0.0089551704,
-0.0370146483,
-0.0190415941,
0.0060565951,
0.0278053861,
0.0005843152,
-0.0110551594,
-0.021538401,
-0.0385089889,
0.0372138768,
0.0430231281,
0.0064287139,
-0.0353536457,
0.0047399481,
0.0339362882,
0.0137287341,
-0.0488278642,
0.0473203845,
0.0461178832,
-0.0241220929,
-0.0579133816,
0.0321616158,
-0.0904629529,
-0.0456467569,
-0.0316220187,
0.0506527051,
0.0870563909,
0.0137560144,
0.0113824485,
-0.0368606038,
-0.0525901727,
-0.0338387713,
-0.0041415263,
0.0248582549,
0.0182370115,
0.0093325572,
0.0310153831,
0.0020817716,
0.0403792225,
0.044377353,
-0.0019745172,
0.1016132832,
0.0189353283,
-0.0097591812,
-0.0353636518,
-0.0270719808,
-0.0441574678,
0.004486253,
-0.0218771715,
-0.0006572741,
-0.0174727645,
-0.0642960221,
0.0158780552,
0.0324743874,
-0.0039144251,
0.0109482929,
0.0138831539,
0.0492952466,
-0.0134923011,
-0.008594824,
-0.0194792487,
0.0570942573,
0.0211417861,
-0.0006382474,
0.006276492,
-6.160040025e-33,
-0.0180058684,
0.0086932862,
0.0407390893,
0.0074398164,
-0.0425410196,
0.0039433967,
-0.0206409488,
-0.0100895911,
-0.0239657685,
0.0178926643,
-0.0329762772,
0.0307346936,
-0.0137466975,
0.0188499112,
-0.0050483677,
-0.0103302952,
0.0869711116,
-0.0050171111,
-0.0110328598,
0.0093212789,
0.0430555828,
0.0421232618,
0.0893257409,
-0.0189013258,
-0.0187008306,
0.0299282316,
0.0071587497,
0.0651505888,
-0.068352811,
0.0225711484,
0.0065841391,
0.0451371595,
0.0134114986,
-0.0503372885,
-0.007357697,
-0.0397320576,
-0.0613953881,
-0.0180405751,
0.0110406755,
0.0244990494,
0.0120163178,
-0.0583460368,
0.0398295149,
0.0171519592,
0.0026122138,
-0.0046491353,
0.0004089902,
-0.0410504378,
-0.0063106618,
-0.0119654872,
-0.028111713,
0.0097699715,
0.0030236279,
-0.0015453859,
-0.0101860855,
-0.0095721623,
0.016803693,
-0.0317910239,
-0.0717404112,
-0.0099311862,
0.0362160727,
0.0584983304,
0.0371499173,
0.0107157826,
0.0212718993,
0.0486089289,
0.0372234285,
0.0342559107,
0.006600379,
0.0435275175,
0.0140661765,
0.0072602495,
0.0221583676,
0.0606800541,
0.0298192576,
-0.0340084918,
-0.0530971289,
-0.0248220358,
-0.0174601413,
0.0382590182,
-0.0225070883,
0.0125801945,
0.0428785644,
0.0143735223,
-0.0759829357,
0.0118168537,
-0.0565629601,
0.0076685823,
0.0171167925,
0.0123463543,
-0.019703405,
0.0007218592,
-0.0007720379,
-0.0155256372,
0.0122839659,
0.0388741344,
-0.0252765957,
0.054136049,
-0.0157257244,
0.0117185051,
-0.0324166045,
0.0124698924,
-0.0068190601,
0.0200775526,
-0.0131460773,
0.030250527,
0.0653867051,
0.0270485207,
-0.0595106184,
0.016704509,
-0.0270567611,
0.0368310176,
0.0086116362,
-0.0027821099,
-0.0014783348,
-0.0227284003,
0.009280418,
0.0050427127,
0.0248116832,
-0.0130184889,
0.0095941983,
0.0334505215,
-0.0067372578,
0.024990214,
-0.0245484784,
0.0342938751,
-0.0254721902,
-0.0166286752,
0.0262150336,
-0.0862362534,
0.0002185021,
0.0024540692,
2.856e-7,
0.0083940513,
0.0771608576,
0.0405813269,
-0.0466581918,
0.0478305705,
0.0153486785,
-0.0318100899,
-0.0061424631,
0.050427895,
-0.000285799,
0.0207093693,
0.0397830755,
0.0176951718,
0.0333769657,
-0.069711633,
-0.0152281262,
-0.044416409,
0.0361873545,
-0.048880212,
-0.0101743955,
0.0010733359,
0.0713542774,
0.036168132,
-0.0218423028,
0.0201792624,
-0.0473867171,
0.0554389022,
0.0004849543,
-0.0352467895,
0.0090452274,
0.011365789,
0.0417064317,
-0.0281425677,
0.0080625843,
-0.0283471402,
0.0044862069,
-0.0184700806,
0.0887482166,
-0.0131169232,
0.0058483761,
0.0052286582,
-0.0142840743,
-0.0196668487,
-0.002926168,
0.0635518134,
-0.0497163646,
0.0104926517,
-0.0240508225,
-0.0124235107,
-0.0160628837,
0.0210498404,
-0.0711969808,
-0.0016995792,
0.0193934944,
-0.0021062726,
0.0174465869,
-0.0048550679,
-0.0564497933,
-0.0238635298,
0.0381496437,
-0.0336575732,
-0.0791081935,
-0.0279200654,
-0.0541022159,
0.0598953255,
-0.0774907172,
0.016995674,
2.473609982e-34,
0.0227962192,
-0.0305940434,
0.0390792564,
0.0098608816,
0.0208471958,
0.0013944671,
-0.0456362702,
-0.0403776206,
0.0134286825,
-0.0793687329,
-0.0378725454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04948v1 | Explained anomaly detection in text reviews: Can subjective scenarios be correctly evaluated? | 2023-11-08T11:51:47 | 2023-11-08T11:51:47 | David Novoa-Paradela, Oscar Fontenla-Romero, Bertha Guijarro-Berdiñas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper presents a pipeline to detect and explain anomalous reviews in
online platforms. The pipeline is made up of three modules and allows the
detection of reviews that do not generate value for users due to either
worthless or malicious composition. The classifications are accompanied by a
normality score and an explanation that justifies the decision made. The
pipeline's ability to solve the anomaly detection task was evaluated using
different datasets created from a large Amazon database. Additionally, a study
comparing three explainability techniques involving 241 participants was
conducted to assess the explainability module. The study aimed to measure the
impact of explanations on the respondents' ability to reproduce the
classification model and their perceived usefulness. This work can be useful to
automate tasks in review online platforms, such as those for electronic
commerce, and offers inspiration for addressing similar problems in the field
of anomaly detection in textual data. We also consider it interesting to have
carried out a human evaluation of the capacity of different explainability
techniques in a real and infrequent scenario such as the detection of anomalous
reviews, as well as to reflect on whether it is possible to explain tasks as
humanly subjective as this one. | [
0.0862499103,
0.0090959873,
-0.0334781483,
0.0191487037,
-0.0127603132,
0.0271884669,
0.0305785649,
0.0050900928,
-0.0053001791,
-0.0409173369,
0.0203122441,
-0.0134995012,
-0.0032848797,
0.0853978992,
-0.0176871568,
-0.0212822743,
-0.0120380018,
-0.0048715756,
0.0566598251,
0.0531562716,
0.0031255453,
0.0225196928,
0.0130862407,
0.0208771694,
0.0605816618,
-0.0093303192,
0.0162956603,
-0.0014878456,
0.0105221197,
-0.0256792288,
-0.0030681503,
0.0226426404,
-0.0331101604,
0.0329778343,
0.0000020621,
-0.0302944053,
0.0034556044,
-0.0166571774,
-0.0474090651,
-0.0123446733,
0.0661108047,
0.0131765483,
0.0246009342,
0.026035862,
0.0067163841,
0.0135116922,
0.0143730445,
0.1015983745,
0.0575859398,
0.0540257953,
-0.0110571897,
-0.0085425982,
-0.0477907322,
0.0415598229,
0.0028701427,
0.0144337304,
-0.0000588786,
-0.0175605807,
0.0011133245,
0.0306901745,
0.0133469794,
-0.045163814,
-0.0072955368,
-0.0788595825,
0.029800253,
-0.0141680716,
0.0024056742,
-0.0321953185,
0.0135585833,
0.028087154,
-0.0052091982,
-0.0254700333,
0.011818991,
-0.0065027503,
0.0078836232,
0.0319656618,
-0.0368469581,
0.0161977075,
0.0046111164,
0.0045170453,
0.0037538747,
0.0516735502,
0.0713525563,
0.0360441059,
0.0253206473,
0.0535605848,
-0.0357816145,
-0.0153995426,
-0.0120542543,
0.0221076645,
0.0160976294,
-0.0229874235,
0.0098330621,
0.0205249861,
-0.0155930603,
-0.0030597243,
0.0403183959,
-0.0019776248,
0.0380956531,
-0.055447042,
0.0300101712,
-0.0137519361,
-0.0006174259,
0.0458416492,
-0.0021285878,
0.0362009294,
0.0157725681,
0.023694301,
-0.0216124486,
0.0333180241,
-0.0501791313,
-0.0038522587,
0.0495808385,
0.0070989411,
-0.0278966967,
0.0250229668,
-0.0333695225,
-0.0031689836,
-0.0470044762,
-0.0091197388,
0.0179789197,
0.0255580097,
0.0180179421,
-0.0259153508,
-0.0618025586,
-0.0496033579,
-0.0459271111,
0.0365494899,
-0.0492835604,
-0.0041448036,
0.0012891786,
0.0578592569,
0.0179939196,
-0.019979991,
0.0208573639,
0.0295436885,
0.0767707825,
-0.0058489288,
-0.0428801142,
-0.0640102029,
-0.0354516394,
-0.0304515362,
-0.0502499379,
0.0060320101,
-0.0439544246,
-0.0008691195,
-0.0282508004,
0.0410703383,
-0.0116840145,
-0.0063379514,
-0.0318099149,
0.0464551486,
-0.0560303144,
0.0154049778,
-0.0181001388,
0.0169663541,
-0.0171777178,
0.013231854,
-0.0263627041,
0.0380514301,
0.0611778051,
-0.0377055928,
0.0796430558,
-0.047575634,
0.0031105932,
-0.0285455119,
0.0121907713,
0.017322015,
-0.1258079857,
-0.0281893052,
0.0286479276,
-0.0163367763,
-0.003177966,
-0.0133281834,
0.0427051485,
-0.0016105934,
-0.0229718052,
0.0288165379,
0.016012447,
-0.0094967363,
-0.0472433381,
0.0326741114,
-0.0238312744,
0.0268896036,
-0.0470077805,
-0.0315346606,
-0.0656601712,
-0.004951058,
-0.0113481106,
-0.060675174,
-0.0355989113,
-0.0236130878,
0.0441350378,
-0.0089131184,
0.0368833914,
0.0246499982,
-0.027491862,
-0.0534988753,
0.0007497071,
-0.0148630561,
0.0216204561,
-0.0549157858,
0.053616114,
0.1285303384,
0.0339255705,
0.025143018,
0.01329525,
-0.0585857481,
-0.0320941582,
-0.003883013,
0.0228003822,
-0.026044948,
-0.0003582667,
-0.0197541919,
-0.0440355986,
-0.0555912554,
0.0163465496,
-0.0196448378,
-0.0215078183,
0.0014259194,
0.0068807057,
-0.0645895004,
-0.0566477068,
0.023762254,
0.0558412075,
-0.0356883407,
-0.0043122987,
0.0084714415,
0.0323048867,
0.041698128,
0.0577620156,
0.0106085036,
0.0286072809,
0.0091136387,
-0.0664025173,
0.0456438884,
0.0412293896,
0.0599956103,
-0.019635139,
-0.0175874829,
-0.0171254519,
0.0509877391,
0.0023060143,
-0.0227994267,
0.0120679121,
-0.0072137071,
0.0106085828,
-0.0480772443,
-0.0067629693,
-0.0208350662,
-0.0053093438,
-0.0143945869,
0.0549456924,
0.0089008957,
0.0382784568,
-0.0410542004,
-0.0766224191,
-0.0033114904,
0.0197737869,
0.0095528821,
-0.0018020973,
-0.0128030535,
0.0001696577,
0.0296429917,
-0.0039205099,
0.0084658777,
0.0173116438,
-0.0576836281,
-0.0444061719,
-0.0255659409,
0.0413444526,
0.0540484823,
-0.0294015743,
0.0222800262,
0.0262930263,
-0.0153465159,
-0.0303092189,
0.0244671833,
0.0250020847,
0.0626332015,
0.0040380228,
-0.0425842702,
-0.0118343402,
0.0033640037,
-0.0254107956,
0.060190659,
0.0707107708,
0.0073557142,
-0.064635627,
0.0141779575,
-0.0264255609,
-0.0504361354,
0.0081043681,
-0.0576748699,
-0.0251353104,
0.0352006108,
-0.031134529,
0.0047540078,
0.0133900559,
0.0631650239,
0.0308085512,
0.0590317324,
0.0007848516,
-0.050397072,
-0.0388495736,
0.0199262649,
-0.0112411445,
-0.0460774116,
0.0513722338,
0.0466498658,
-0.009083054,
-0.0186835788,
-0.034316007,
0.0223711766,
-0.0045563467,
-0.0297845434,
-0.0198319145,
-0.1035216525,
-0.0048219962,
0.0685490519,
-0.0181632042,
-0.024463186,
0.06998647,
0.0059471955,
0.0183274038,
-0.0538342595,
-0.0335763358,
-0.0125027765,
0.0191443153,
-0.0158507582,
0.0054645208,
-0.0255116001,
-0.0366134197,
0.0592142232,
-0.0393179469,
0.0669392347,
0.0394483618,
-0.0060162921,
-0.0217892472,
-0.0115320086,
0.0443209633,
0.0221441351,
-0.0227512289,
-0.0776714161,
-0.0160189103,
-0.0440710448,
0.0298232455,
-0.0260697119,
-0.0338142589,
0.0582302921,
0.0022358964,
0.0238926969,
-0.0112725785,
-0.0100097219,
0.0253311284,
-0.0027162402,
-0.0120112952,
-0.0050439346,
0.0646098554,
-0.0410735458,
0.0145997517,
0.0499987788,
-0.0289813317,
-0.0143598896,
-0.0279511511,
-0.018513063,
-0.0388703272,
-0.0336792581,
-0.000160793,
-0.0166998841,
0.0108598173,
-0.0491458438,
0.0154674398,
0.0662498474,
0.0179533418,
-0.014993133,
0.0108868573,
0.01258229,
-0.0233894233,
0.0081717093,
-0.0202043783,
-0.0038481844,
0.0176687967,
0.0035086772,
0.0606518351,
-0.0285284147,
-0.0422143601,
0.016251158,
-0.0559330061,
0.0034324704,
-0.028465189,
-0.0471354686,
-0.0771443993,
-0.0563769601,
-0.0180971175,
-0.0148469387,
0.0445531569,
0.0009678428,
0.0280893482,
0.050092306,
-0.0029308947,
-0.0623236857,
-0.0426123701,
0.0417473987,
0.0052676336,
0.0297425017,
0.0491453633,
0.0194472298,
-0.013658517,
0.0030716527,
0.0173404142,
-0.0290238336,
0.0197137073,
0.0118968254,
0.1053529903,
0.0401001833,
0.0041349051,
-0.0655717179,
0.0352720767,
-0.0706559569,
0.0198444501,
-0.0361190215,
0.0749920756,
-0.009394926,
-0.0716690943,
-0.0178811103,
-0.0057837744,
0.0369972922,
0.0771906897,
-0.0012049398,
-0.0476044714,
-0.0148564968,
0.0143312411,
-0.0215338189,
-0.034381073,
-0.0085354345,
0.0445509814,
0.0519657545,
-0.0689230114,
-0.0725445375,
-0.0485139266,
-0.0336153768,
0.0297572538,
0.0333349556,
0.0042512091,
-0.0271765664,
0.0087856539,
-0.0095787272,
0.0166845601,
0.0525827184,
-0.0004704094,
0.0016192681,
0.0214363486,
-0.0068952711,
-0.0244882498,
-0.0036933764,
-0.0452352352,
-0.0012744662,
0.024213763,
0.0013458502,
0.0227638725,
0.0273495466,
0.0106580686,
-0.0252639633,
-0.0451058224,
-0.0231560711,
-0.0072258208,
-0.0502380021,
-0.0480258018,
0.0331905335,
0.0014620451,
0.028365856,
0.0184546355,
0.0015140468,
0.0226221364,
0.0009428359,
-0.0507899709,
-0.0420830175,
0.0087566609,
0.0137982368,
-0.0105620474,
0.0230592117,
-0.0024360309,
0.0146259926,
-0.0197230969,
-0.0267129168,
-0.0265404303,
-0.0029135079,
0.0123261791,
0.0158691816,
0.0117894392,
-0.0057633822,
-0.0330108255,
-0.0100196507,
-0.0463788174,
0.0136668729,
-0.0383691303,
0.0412302464,
0.0228783991,
0.0258023422,
-0.0147787388,
0.0492147654,
-0.0083132386,
0.0361618623,
0.0014204015,
0.028987512,
0.0353893749,
0.0147558581,
0.0034106583,
-0.0009640091,
0.0010410905,
-0.0236415435,
-0.0306391362,
0.0290240087,
0.004879571,
-0.0270664506,
-0.0452801287,
-0.0367316864,
0.0303114094,
0.0097388187,
-0.0124294963,
0.0252943318,
0.0339310393,
0.0282976292,
0.0190508813,
-0.0112320157,
0.0257102214,
-0.0486374013,
0.008430006,
0.0484937988,
-0.0381369144,
-0.0234122463,
0.0085581942,
-0.0398255251,
-0.0253532548,
0.0135559496,
-0.0097104181,
0.0531751327,
0.0022040084,
-0.0087305373,
-0.0471079648,
-0.033772219,
-0.006366035,
-0.0169735402,
0.0266266484,
-0.0044309087,
0.0086871115,
0.1021383181,
0.0088841533,
0.0166473258,
-0.0412529819,
-0.0134417564,
-0.0031632183,
0.0342504084,
-0.0364043824,
-5.862886441e-33,
0.0400503352,
-0.1306637228,
-0.068868652,
0.009403456,
0.0630905181,
-0.0328334644,
-0.0381165855,
0.00240683,
0.0136944642,
0.0651594177,
0.0293650739,
0.0344801545,
-0.0005887127,
-0.026208505,
0.0009434614,
-0.0134913623,
0.0653289557,
0.0092941504,
0.0126537299,
0.0666873083,
0.0574559942,
-0.0015401572,
0.0312710106,
-0.1124077812,
0.1122758389,
-0.0092689637,
-0.0527415089,
0.0146948071,
0.0003815114,
0.0499837659,
-0.0029584267,
0.0345975235,
0.0394832715,
-0.011957855,
0.0107150115,
-0.0080859652,
-0.021758711,
-0.005552575,
0.0481232777,
0.025547903,
0.007751117,
-0.0251841173,
0.057139568,
-0.023444701,
-0.0347412005,
0.0348450728,
0.0632171482,
-0.0499810614,
0.005337113,
-0.0388783105,
-0.0255954675,
0.0067374804,
-0.0324627906,
0.0239093285,
0.0240019746,
0.0330268256,
-0.0076296283,
0.0095984563,
-0.0288733281,
0.0215477664,
-0.0142622953,
-0.0414600931,
0.0174597856,
-0.0484807342,
-0.0413989797,
0.0584304892,
0.0113120051,
0.0339735076,
-0.0787846074,
0.0491695553,
-0.0255046561,
0.0403919481,
0.0785196126,
0.0757442564,
0.0089658489,
-0.0411366262,
-0.0480091274,
0.0278405882,
-0.0053236429,
-0.0154050291,
0.0772971511,
-0.0344620459,
-0.0933788195,
-0.0070341583,
0.0337147526,
-0.0580775999,
-0.0472139306,
-0.0262389276,
-0.0113527924,
0.0037047542,
-0.0741434172,
-0.0649154931,
-0.0316454172,
-0.0591243096,
-0.006486184,
0.0260706898,
-0.0076130126,
-0.008675253,
0.0388756134,
-0.0448037907,
0.0333071314,
0.0198419392,
-0.0116944918,
0.0064076777,
0.0350790061,
-0.02431673,
0.0444585793,
0.0215718914,
-0.0660609007,
-0.0007374969,
-0.0148840435,
0.0278751515,
-0.0265858378,
0.0604281984,
-0.0041445442,
-0.0271763988,
-0.0257022306,
0.0445097797,
0.0063461405,
0.0659421161,
-0.0311720464,
0.0419168659,
-0.0538981557,
-0.0047630463,
-0.0136135248,
-0.0722608119,
0.0043478622,
-0.0730882511,
0.0043339138,
-0.066824086,
0.0098374048,
-0.0172966216,
2.78e-7,
0.0286226235,
0.0488120131,
-0.0025795382,
-0.0805003271,
0.0618315488,
0.0472414084,
0.0336291119,
-0.0330429859,
-0.0087260688,
-0.0576560274,
0.0392904766,
-0.032719925,
-0.0085499883,
0.0430396833,
-0.0321448669,
-0.0089234654,
-0.0526368581,
0.002684979,
-0.032161735,
0.0163299758,
0.0500342585,
0.03976373,
0.0216760002,
-0.011709691,
0.0176632609,
-0.0418500826,
-0.0258134604,
-0.040005926,
-0.0241565462,
-0.0190024097,
0.0883418769,
-0.0071127415,
0.0158436149,
0.0055598388,
-0.0244385786,
-0.005529759,
-0.0344329253,
0.0374620147,
0.0027659014,
-0.0284629855,
-0.0099517908,
-0.0354475677,
0.0592162088,
-0.0770123601,
0.0449651182,
0.004705694,
-0.0483534634,
-0.0378102139,
-0.0124242455,
-0.0465540215,
0.0065782866,
-0.0025413241,
-0.0013184025,
0.0332500376,
-0.016721528,
-0.0295412578,
0.0224817619,
-0.0386022888,
0.0040702452,
0.0107366266,
-0.0119708385,
-0.0079295784,
0.0242775511,
-0.013618906,
0.0526221916,
0.0179809965,
0.0175270755,
2.601632796e-34,
0.0723075867,
0.0293926783,
-0.013422614,
-0.0436496884,
0.0240901466,
0.0356453173,
-0.0456294492,
-0.0241867416,
0.0539493226,
-0.0024771118,
-0.0128360428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04589v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04589v3 | TEAL: Tokenize and Embed ALL for Multi-modal Large Language Models | 2023-11-08T10:34:16 | 2024-01-04T07:31:07 | Zhen Yang, Yingxue Zhang, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite Multi-modal Large Language Models (MM-LLMs) have made exciting
strides recently, they are still struggling to efficiently model the
interactions among multi-modal inputs and the generation in non-textual
modalities. In this work, we propose TEAL (Tokenize and Embed ALl)}, an
approach to treat the input from any modality as a token sequence and learn a
joint embedding space for all modalities. Specifically, for the input from any
modality, TEAL first discretizes it into a token sequence with the
off-the-shelf tokenizer and embeds the token sequence into a joint embedding
space with a learnable embedding matrix. MM-LLMs just need to predict the
multi-modal tokens autoregressively as the textual LLMs do. Finally, the
corresponding de-tokenizer is applied to generate the output in each modality
based on the predicted token sequence. With the joint embedding space, TEAL
enables the frozen LLMs to perform both understanding and generation tasks
involving non-textual modalities, such as image and audio. Thus, the textual
LLM can just work as an interface and maintain its high performance in textual
understanding and generation. Experiments show that TEAL achieves substantial
improvements in multi-modal understanding, and implements a simple scheme for
multi-modal generations. | [
-0.0079159318,
0.0830697492,
0.0068381215,
0.0343464985,
-0.0199954547,
0.0053009423,
0.0444800965,
-0.0162620619,
-0.0242697969,
-0.0670822337,
-0.0227294844,
-0.0438869148,
-0.0170585848,
0.0601941347,
0.0554191805,
-0.0213391893,
0.054558821,
-0.0686272979,
-0.0368377864,
-0.0067001246,
-0.006930158,
0.0270523224,
0.0037504339,
0.0747015849,
-0.0374844894,
-0.0227873381,
-0.0441423655,
-0.0031692253,
-0.0151327988,
-0.0225194171,
-0.0378831699,
0.0165408496,
0.078238681,
0.04342857,
0.000001674,
-0.0119782947,
-0.0130921928,
-0.011414526,
0.0294054039,
0.0099101458,
0.0627593994,
-0.0322681554,
0.0054665296,
0.0112532359,
-0.0135427183,
-0.0255972035,
0.0280778874,
0.0554187037,
0.0651290715,
0.0644673109,
-0.0146966549,
-0.041765321,
0.0207242686,
-0.0182083938,
0.0100453645,
-0.0162238125,
0.023458967,
-0.0116877155,
0.0070582819,
0.0073221778,
-0.0115599697,
0.0431532711,
0.0169932563,
-0.042093683,
-0.0202764776,
0.0535959713,
0.0388455912,
-0.0447707772,
-0.0287351273,
0.0821071044,
0.0052479878,
-0.0066993241,
0.0133538553,
0.0156096108,
0.0280669183,
-0.0060875062,
-0.0609512217,
0.0502141677,
0.0271707755,
0.0352470651,
0.0089371139,
-0.038739562,
0.0475571938,
0.0185797233,
-0.0112586077,
0.0144759705,
0.045065295,
-0.0026306149,
-0.063890487,
-0.0123355007,
-0.022339398,
-0.0441898592,
0.001957848,
0.0605140068,
-0.046856124,
0.0147773279,
-0.0725662336,
-0.0259888675,
0.0221710801,
0.0218048953,
0.0223989207,
0.020234948,
-0.0427858867,
0.0420973077,
-0.0642853752,
0.0025318775,
-0.0388971455,
0.0030519541,
-0.0535314381,
-0.0197247081,
-0.0345947482,
-0.0271314699,
-0.0309327319,
0.0453296155,
-0.0444050357,
-0.0554793328,
-0.0065187672,
0.0611852445,
-0.005285148,
0.012432294,
0.003909573,
0.0097610978,
-0.035048712,
-0.0235892795,
0.0109373489,
0.0421556458,
-0.0306573305,
0.0262897424,
0.0126258144,
-0.0365661159,
-0.001078982,
0.045326706,
0.0315608084,
0.0104340957,
-0.0136964489,
0.100617744,
-0.0405158699,
-0.0154395336,
-0.0285929013,
-0.0523786694,
-0.021581728,
-0.0608524196,
0.0065051378,
-0.0492172092,
0.0337470733,
-0.0005494604,
-0.0193928406,
0.0007735346,
0.0052411682,
-0.0019484073,
-0.0064544957,
0.0545120239,
0.0266934037,
-0.0046933033,
0.0208657756,
0.0129813729,
0.0006975726,
0.0802639425,
0.0226606671,
0.0146059981,
0.0108870827,
-0.0004274751,
-0.0245590061,
0.0384562463,
0.0070111197,
0.0171489976,
-0.0458594114,
-0.0264372174,
0.0330447704,
0.063973628,
0.05858678,
0.0686587542,
-0.0521512181,
0.008145825,
0.0471430942,
0.0141484477,
0.0255492665,
0.0476804413,
0.0912177414,
-0.0197307635,
-0.0308422763,
0.0171128362,
-0.036384996,
0.034457963,
0.0161107685,
0.016729515,
0.0345038958,
0.0576229244,
-0.0321015865,
-0.0151987011,
0.0160726961,
-0.0236659013,
-0.0220611263,
-0.0366010331,
0.0355519876,
0.0041668117,
-0.0777731463,
0.0696249902,
0.0143190268,
-0.0368334912,
0.0462428778,
-0.0539703704,
0.0522038676,
0.0411885343,
0.0102874609,
-0.0178456753,
-0.0287964959,
-0.0372466147,
0.0331498235,
0.031962797,
-0.0103163039,
-0.0229268726,
0.0146420505,
-0.0574366339,
-0.0032786243,
-0.0287806634,
0.0157970004,
0.035355866,
-0.0440804102,
0.0255488642,
0.0171258543,
-0.0180250574,
0.0662478507,
0.0401511826,
0.0055386629,
0.0158436839,
-0.002195132,
-0.0096247122,
0.0176619384,
0.0073187179,
-0.0019950173,
0.0212690905,
0.0412942916,
-0.0600168258,
-0.0164913256,
0.0428773463,
-0.1012629345,
-0.0463125482,
0.0616063699,
-0.0176506434,
-0.0019127141,
-0.0204858575,
-0.0342615917,
-0.0523788333,
0.0280601177,
-0.0150597505,
0.0601490885,
-0.0621654764,
0.0065939347,
0.010468767,
0.0093033379,
-0.0128554357,
0.0384403579,
-0.0080787074,
-0.0080698812,
0.0507936627,
0.0341397934,
-0.0035179553,
0.0025410096,
-0.0446583517,
0.0401960574,
-0.0043298751,
0.0176173877,
-0.0148861101,
0.001008447,
-0.0313300341,
-0.0682861134,
-0.1300234199,
-0.010499524,
-0.004086955,
-0.0122082699,
0.0298236255,
0.0043753055,
0.0163239464,
0.0082173711,
-0.0373341739,
0.0159776155,
0.0404065177,
0.0089253848,
0.0251154136,
0.0136650456,
-0.0376777872,
0.0042196242,
0.0069487495,
0.008697642,
0.0615884513,
-0.0125186862,
0.0135173406,
-0.0731281191,
-0.023030797,
-0.0219216309,
0.0194949061,
-0.0147146033,
-0.0444666781,
0.0176245775,
-0.0295634475,
0.0761483461,
0.0338426754,
0.0362928547,
0.0394255407,
0.0567043424,
-0.0239840951,
-0.0470074415,
0.0081930151,
0.0033798506,
0.011591143,
-0.0390837193,
0.0214806665,
-0.0240884162,
0.0681629479,
-0.0001469382,
0.0068292967,
-0.0253568925,
0.0210805945,
0.0021756238,
-0.033604078,
-0.0245493762,
-0.0192519985,
-0.0530375764,
-0.0115385475,
-0.016642591,
-0.0463185795,
0.048889976,
-0.0622973926,
-0.0171088744,
-0.0004491151,
-0.0026130385,
-0.0388887376,
0.0479252674,
-0.0069619468,
0.0315409191,
-0.0069352412,
-0.0422569998,
-0.0531497337,
0.023447955,
0.0024275328,
-0.0160932466,
0.0785933435,
-0.0191001743,
0.0031748253,
-0.019247625,
-0.0250595696,
-0.0300056636,
-0.0490776189,
-0.0196616203,
0.0197832659,
0.0015564911,
-0.024555305,
-0.0380330272,
0.0003645938,
0.017927777,
0.0166576002,
-0.0211210474,
0.0105779041,
-0.0469278768,
0.0775142238,
0.0616665632,
0.0361020453,
-0.0216266997,
-0.0308035836,
0.0330822021,
0.0404410511,
0.0112586422,
-0.007916824,
-0.0383866504,
0.0208108947,
0.0324973837,
0.0152197937,
-0.0274501648,
0.0214211345,
0.0463294908,
-0.0463420227,
0.0095144911,
0.1041871011,
-0.0067654988,
-0.0398606434,
-0.0042901766,
0.0076170266,
0.0651421249,
0.0001733554,
-0.0058971485,
-0.084735401,
-0.0405442044,
0.0252030175,
-0.0335182808,
0.030345574,
-0.0096881613,
-0.0141902491,
-0.0765405595,
0.0399491452,
0.0210060291,
-0.0359383039,
-0.0226996019,
-0.006917797,
-0.0287893675,
0.0402384475,
0.036747463,
0.0172295906,
-0.0268746708,
-0.0179367494,
0.0250257831,
0.032323014,
-0.0516820364,
-0.0067340853,
-0.0282222312,
0.0717837065,
0.0086056329,
0.0416000187,
-0.0040919208,
-0.0560470521,
0.049327191,
0.022523744,
-0.0092812451,
-0.0163061004,
-0.0330421291,
-0.0224110708,
-0.0168741401,
-0.0009680942,
0.0483917631,
-0.0247741938,
-0.0199396238,
-0.0146747725,
0.0840313137,
-0.0004822231,
-0.0057013188,
-0.0107551599,
0.0013955731,
-0.0107701933,
0.0668264553,
0.0334414653,
-0.0360007659,
-0.0313813314,
-0.0092408359,
-0.0136698922,
-0.0217676871,
0.0111186905,
-0.01087151,
-0.0002273851,
0.0136815142,
-0.0685970411,
0.0045858491,
0.0136022177,
0.0871570632,
-0.0111654615,
0.0196926054,
-0.0379151739,
-0.0310325399,
-0.0304283742,
0.0199739449,
-0.0172422044,
0.0076740771,
-0.0498709269,
0.0034793417,
0.0620735213,
-0.0392949134,
-0.0165161714,
-0.0028562252,
-0.0912313536,
-0.0667774007,
-0.045451276,
0.0302967299,
0.0132534327,
0.0579189137,
0.0173930954,
-0.0336744711,
0.072827436,
0.0361698866,
-0.0394608751,
0.0061608744,
0.0141083924,
0.0302090142,
0.0012215244,
0.0531683266,
-0.0409714095,
-0.0176674183,
-0.0225001257,
0.0312179439,
0.0196703989,
-0.0132419821,
-0.0042470531,
-0.0140506392,
-0.0101086153,
-0.0453593209,
0.0328058936,
-0.0496200956,
-0.0054112431,
-0.0379578434,
-0.0157757625,
-0.0621445626,
0.0414150879,
0.0299983453,
-0.0173107199,
0.0026852302,
-0.0095789172,
0.0161310248,
0.0369744785,
0.016195979,
0.0507374145,
0.0194463357,
-0.007151911,
0.0331780389,
0.0110730175,
-0.0117474636,
-0.013619273,
-0.0344260149,
-0.0033854535,
-0.0592740923,
0.0645912886,
-0.0043972852,
-0.0062938207,
-0.0477859862,
0.035889104,
-0.0170989204,
-0.0197756868,
-0.0316792428,
0.0540625155,
0.0652580783,
0.0284032337,
0.0505201556,
-0.0086146342,
-0.0278298724,
-0.0046172733,
0.0615596808,
-0.0080057895,
-0.0539006144,
0.0703248158,
0.0286939051,
-0.0439475179,
0.0266244709,
0.0755255967,
-0.0064788479,
0.0346060321,
-0.005846181,
0.0294442084,
-0.0477844328,
-0.0094887,
0.0334422402,
0.0304766856,
-0.0167664066,
0.0019231103,
-0.0087688928,
-0.0649670139,
0.0115566226,
0.00944784,
-0.0333803147,
-0.0032240944,
0.0124114677,
0.0415461808,
0.0086815422,
-0.0011276816,
-0.0297060162,
0.0197246298,
0.0436370522,
-0.0384512097,
-0.0255456194,
-6.016834324e-33,
-0.0307183508,
-0.0237196889,
0.0248624049,
-0.0536583513,
-0.0469083339,
0.0237104539,
-0.023156317,
0.0026162716,
0.0265927091,
-0.0034955582,
0.0230746511,
-0.0203264169,
-0.0015124924,
0.0416296721,
0.01615173,
-0.0113673685,
0.0554610379,
-0.0202451497,
-0.0024131527,
0.0315961204,
0.0267348513,
0.021110598,
0.0010605047,
0.0043344041,
-0.0102551216,
-0.0160326529,
-0.0420308039,
0.0247688424,
0.018408129,
0.0631294101,
-0.0431520492,
0.0149796288,
0.0218923297,
0.0030876251,
-0.0338557884,
0.0371803492,
-0.0607890226,
0.0228074435,
0.027870018,
-0.0023333491,
-0.0464785732,
-0.0502432063,
0.0401656516,
-0.0107510323,
0.0160930809,
0.0047491938,
0.0147322016,
0.0143518979,
-0.0342057385,
0.0059444737,
-0.0521798618,
-0.002616005,
-0.0264123138,
-0.0180183537,
0.0049442342,
0.0216695815,
0.0300220251,
0.0069001634,
-0.0330408216,
0.0252888761,
-0.0281987302,
0.0323803611,
0.0770638138,
0.0188897364,
0.0098928483,
0.0707488731,
0.0243647788,
-0.044461105,
-0.0327059478,
-0.005900796,
0.0330002308,
0.051738739,
-0.0330749266,
0.0728853047,
-0.0165647026,
-0.0032892984,
-0.0412029959,
-0.0041800449,
0.0213645566,
0.0356220827,
0.0437650979,
0.0393791609,
0.047208827,
-0.0024064546,
-0.0497294292,
-0.0152602652,
-0.0312956721,
-0.0244731791,
0.0245510694,
0.0426127128,
-0.0236488804,
-0.0363915637,
0.0870700702,
-0.0144976089,
-0.0336376429,
0.0407655239,
-0.0375448763,
0.018532509,
-0.0058336142,
0.0454598218,
-0.0206217971,
-0.0688711181,
0.0531395972,
-0.0337352678,
-0.0001406744,
-0.0019788409,
0.0043291845,
0.0268325806,
-0.0718360767,
0.0056152185,
-0.0524992123,
-0.0166048948,
0.0097969575,
0.0047198269,
0.0570414849,
-0.0320644826,
-0.0361046642,
0.0348891579,
-0.0143548651,
0.0170774441,
-0.0128907729,
-0.0330118723,
-0.005249077,
0.03533189,
-0.0373326838,
0.0087746745,
-0.0409479514,
-0.028141031,
0.0482223295,
-0.0484482609,
-0.0025995695,
0.0111507671,
2.437e-7,
0.0045861737,
0.0073260008,
0.0158752259,
-0.0378363095,
0.0586920567,
0.0374747775,
-0.0163494367,
0.0217339322,
0.0133886738,
-0.0106299454,
0.0006732463,
-0.007502568,
0.0181951318,
0.0195354186,
-0.0844680592,
0.0332474187,
-0.073226437,
0.0273463093,
-0.0524724759,
-0.0266201589,
0.0476697162,
0.118211329,
-0.0374691561,
-0.0056243236,
0.0141620664,
-0.0541842431,
0.0863406658,
-0.0017058708,
-0.0365080163,
-0.0162266232,
0.0095153712,
0.0007871682,
0.0033830705,
-0.0233113002,
-0.0007331374,
0.0169389565,
0.0159281995,
0.0752210245,
0.0383895673,
-0.024892902,
0.0144145451,
-0.0047467351,
-0.028582802,
-0.0459051952,
0.0614835359,
-0.03674303,
-0.0365163721,
-0.0973443389,
-0.0086257523,
-0.0229972713,
-0.0095351897,
-0.0341722667,
-0.0390266776,
0.0642778724,
0.0259962734,
-0.0390419737,
-0.0078715812,
-0.0839232132,
-0.0299148522,
-0.0225599743,
-0.103906922,
-0.0085267322,
-0.0543349721,
-0.0274582729,
0.0650179684,
-0.0552685633,
-0.0100888675,
2.164117242e-34,
0.0244214069,
-0.0520651862,
0.0273146424,
0.0439866632,
0.0235622283,
-0.0139227817,
0.0012217866,
0.0258044172,
0.0185125247,
-0.0807779431,
-0.0374661982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04563v1 | Investigating the Nature of Disagreements on Mid-Scale Ratings: A Case Study on the Abstractness-Concreteness Continuum | 2023-11-08T09:52:58 | 2023-11-08T09:52:58 | Urban Knupleš, Diego Frassinelli, Sabine Schulte im Walde | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans tend to strongly agree on ratings on a scale for extreme cases (e.g.,
a CAT is judged as very concrete), but judgements on mid-scale words exhibit
more disagreement. Yet, collected rating norms are heavily exploited across
disciplines. Our study focuses on concreteness ratings and (i) implements
correlations and supervised classification to identify salient multi-modal
characteristics of mid-scale words, and (ii) applies a hard clustering to
identify patterns of systematic disagreement across raters. Our results suggest
to either fine-tune or filter mid-scale target words before utilising them. | [
0.042084828,
0.0302259512,
-0.0148279564,
-0.0034425699,
-0.0048452113,
0.0213479288,
0.0022427123,
0.0367618352,
-0.0562523119,
-0.0513185486,
-0.0708282962,
-0.0265433025,
0.0279154703,
0.0236723628,
0.0006164851,
-0.0828415081,
0.0148498034,
0.0655497536,
0.0845776275,
-0.0047493093,
0.0446382761,
0.008102024,
0.0098381527,
0.0241444539,
-0.008930522,
-0.0082693882,
0.0290071946,
-0.0353506431,
0.0207085423,
-0.0474496372,
0.0168714598,
0.0675697103,
-0.0129946051,
0.0260270406,
0.0000016503,
-0.0346181802,
0.0208161026,
-0.0192148443,
0.0638646334,
0.0139744626,
0.0830255672,
0.0214893706,
0.0171016157,
-0.014080666,
-0.014185695,
-0.0174268913,
0.0482928269,
0.0819028094,
0.0289956965,
-0.0201591682,
0.0068780379,
-0.0647344142,
-0.0416394137,
-0.0094942851,
-0.0305645578,
0.0176922493,
-0.000603652,
0.0539112873,
-0.0536374003,
0.0397919863,
-0.0247938391,
-0.0284121614,
-0.013757132,
0.035376735,
0.0458595306,
0.032139767,
-0.0308040064,
-0.0540609919,
0.0381871201,
0.0828026608,
-0.0104237888,
-0.0149798598,
-0.0109599903,
-0.0359660126,
-0.0158090368,
-0.0145060671,
-0.0210379567,
0.0079671759,
-0.0016832789,
0.0013268307,
-0.0148120606,
0.0530673973,
0.0056904047,
0.0220361594,
-0.0043958072,
0.0343404263,
-0.0031003044,
-0.0341116451,
0.0179872066,
0.0001721788,
-0.0395311154,
-0.0296388771,
0.004927746,
-0.0274123382,
0.0069047329,
-0.0134343756,
0.0125411106,
0.0503950641,
0.0628246367,
-0.0540755354,
0.0227412861,
-0.0399600565,
0.0051656268,
0.0286966451,
0.0459571891,
-0.0077379919,
0.0274057165,
0.026549913,
-0.0084313657,
0.0535381064,
-0.0612734705,
0.030253619,
0.0474864095,
0.0067295483,
-0.0158953853,
-0.0098132268,
-0.0658625662,
-0.0497986972,
-0.0753656849,
-0.009569603,
-0.0202896856,
0.0275749434,
0.0264700167,
0.0283953678,
-0.0358250849,
0.0410606153,
-0.0996714011,
0.0762223378,
-0.0322959758,
0.015876472,
0.0722369179,
0.0090095308,
0.0093490565,
-0.0024064449,
0.0448664539,
-0.0410602167,
0.0020049154,
-0.0105354115,
0.0028147295,
-0.0336678065,
-0.0566116385,
-0.0475951619,
-0.0273373891,
-0.0594604835,
-0.0001051343,
0.0218839906,
0.0118709141,
-0.0338285565,
-0.013409391,
-0.0031459804,
-0.0125770047,
0.0754300877,
-0.0069125555,
-0.0083391322,
0.0080787335,
0.0385325141,
0.0039301091,
-0.0217661802,
0.013365292,
0.0235050432,
0.0472754091,
-0.0244608112,
0.0168178435,
-0.0363510922,
-0.0152364252,
-0.0142300343,
-0.0201499183,
-0.0127066551,
-0.0318804085,
0.0495100841,
-0.0032523698,
0.1005775034,
-0.0196958408,
-0.0019217117,
0.0693949088,
0.073421821,
-0.0117568728,
0.0796851367,
-0.0164063182,
0.0329525135,
0.0096851969,
0.0321083702,
-0.0120582497,
0.0049411259,
-0.0065773758,
-0.0127144828,
0.0389709733,
0.0301411245,
-0.0178657584,
-0.0827357247,
-0.0221797712,
0.0197396297,
0.0584397726,
-0.0640362948,
0.0148995994,
0.0225361418,
-0.0057975864,
-0.017559357,
0.0406077877,
-0.0471376479,
0.0065414193,
-0.0335668772,
0.0443644784,
0.0315108187,
-0.0002493178,
0.0158385411,
0.0540762953,
0.0032565377,
0.0271158218,
-0.0254872683,
0.0259612296,
-0.0196541101,
-0.041510053,
-0.0515265539,
-0.005134088,
-0.0285422336,
0.0200320352,
-0.0138231749,
-0.0182569493,
0.0203881003,
-0.0274883173,
-0.0372540466,
-0.0533295423,
0.0080178268,
0.0897016972,
-0.0067378376,
-0.0247273482,
0.0286810156,
0.0437567271,
0.0027001267,
-0.0220298413,
0.001638443,
0.0110703763,
0.0221894942,
-0.022724187,
0.0293900631,
0.0013996421,
0.0808005854,
-0.0147254476,
-0.0739431679,
-0.0175568871,
-0.010330325,
0.0061872317,
0.0192530453,
0.0290720649,
-0.0280492958,
0.0316715054,
-0.0131406765,
0.0282787271,
-0.0325238407,
0.0048655262,
-0.0313343704,
0.037800204,
-0.0079905232,
0.0688553452,
-0.0370741487,
-0.0330756009,
0.0019309673,
0.0327270441,
-0.0531148948,
0.0258671846,
0.0301434211,
0.0493127629,
0.0275960173,
-0.0030668841,
-0.0568373017,
-0.0234115403,
-0.0559867658,
-0.0597725883,
0.0186402164,
-0.0131039405,
0.0498878546,
-0.0525064431,
0.0254502613,
0.0224858113,
-0.0185382459,
-0.0107374927,
-0.0418751985,
0.0344893523,
0.0486327969,
0.0291682109,
-0.0286665577,
-0.0000416807,
-0.0086535709,
-0.0233015679,
0.0444531664,
0.023998851,
0.0569549538,
-0.0047921143,
0.0557892881,
-0.0630784035,
-0.0352403447,
0.0279294718,
-0.0326652788,
0.0342726372,
0.0328609124,
0.0186530482,
0.0086906301,
0.060926266,
0.0410660282,
0.0769168213,
-0.0494347401,
-0.0306901243,
-0.065962635,
-0.0211644713,
-0.0069566406,
0.0054350356,
-0.0530168526,
0.0296791159,
0.0571118556,
0.0439813361,
0.02315755,
-0.0513815545,
0.033514224,
-0.0246990956,
-0.0275502484,
-0.0524041019,
-0.0107708639,
-0.0008977669,
0.0714388266,
0.0009299283,
-0.0347171053,
0.0785823837,
0.0034267092,
0.0279332604,
-0.0321665108,
0.0058479658,
0.0088287387,
0.0303307455,
-0.0512978807,
0.0284136012,
-0.0078634014,
-0.0208838899,
-0.0235817507,
-0.054303918,
0.0462202765,
-0.0280004013,
0.0245034769,
-0.0281749088,
-0.0490120351,
0.0280610863,
-0.039595414,
0.0306522567,
-0.0273038242,
-0.0237207785,
-0.0144359833,
0.0692402571,
-0.0181886125,
-0.032500349,
0.0219844375,
-0.0172311682,
-0.0498683117,
0.0207530726,
-0.0172461607,
0.0379680395,
0.0284451954,
0.0054784636,
0.0437790677,
0.0301736798,
-0.0400798693,
-0.0525920354,
0.0849582255,
-0.0097053815,
-0.0187350735,
-0.0258887243,
0.0127097303,
0.0157731175,
0.0239899494,
0.0061248965,
-0.0014468037,
0.0445449837,
-0.0176676121,
0.0070868512,
0.0703226998,
0.0360590369,
-0.051002793,
0.0090225711,
0.0065823481,
0.0127754146,
0.0201101974,
-0.0282556582,
-0.0009703764,
0.0030370366,
-0.0256470703,
0.0232000221,
-0.0389722101,
-0.0192873497,
0.0074200379,
-0.0493997373,
0.0144866612,
0.0155603345,
-0.0509892926,
-0.0209427997,
-0.0136104599,
0.0311717317,
0.0246845912,
0.0078914352,
-0.0117334463,
0.0096217934,
0.0008433009,
-0.00038808,
-0.043647673,
-0.0307697076,
0.0669938102,
-0.0418294631,
0.0521461591,
-0.0209863167,
0.0744131804,
-0.0343193822,
-0.0852242112,
0.0399090946,
-0.0426793844,
-0.0110469656,
-0.0051301299,
-0.0079714283,
-0.0018053297,
0.0095090158,
-0.0699226856,
-0.0024606236,
0.0305366907,
-0.0249434393,
-0.0138361035,
0.039663285,
-0.012111105,
-0.0441757552,
-0.0203477498,
0.0552912615,
-0.0025298647,
0.0447267964,
0.0467134118,
-0.051719062,
0.0098023722,
0.0025223861,
0.0269731712,
0.0422742404,
-0.0827815533,
-0.0270552821,
-0.0265852492,
0.0017706001,
-0.0706967786,
-0.0321258903,
0.0184559282,
0.0205319263,
0.0005308852,
-0.0573987626,
-0.0150079625,
0.0037831529,
-0.0545150563,
0.0592418797,
0.044516284,
-0.000941721,
-0.0526441485,
-0.0022240586,
0.0427002609,
0.0005376094,
-0.0175446514,
-0.0102376221,
0.0146498382,
-0.0284589361,
0.0339694768,
0.0164028723,
0.0214144588,
-0.0231603272,
0.0140119744,
-0.0651486963,
0.0084106037,
0.03000791,
-0.0219429024,
0.0004342802,
0.0055043376,
0.0292471498,
0.0245253351,
0.0146565894,
-0.0087254932,
0.0349216945,
0.0169385262,
-0.0042272983,
-0.0725031421,
-0.0193771515,
0.015762724,
-0.0133199375,
0.0316142179,
-0.0293257181,
-0.0390144698,
-0.0169634502,
-0.0489367768,
0.0247233044,
-0.0422878191,
0.0196252652,
-0.0185551308,
-0.0085206497,
0.0294205304,
-0.0753827319,
0.0628102347,
-0.0191241726,
0.0431630313,
-0.0378547385,
0.0140284989,
0.014624306,
0.0108060669,
-0.0081891958,
-0.0080163367,
-0.0281968769,
-0.0338303372,
-0.0193590615,
0.0146744773,
0.0172504764,
0.0296309721,
0.039847631,
-0.0007193094,
-0.0487630926,
0.0612494312,
0.0047620581,
0.0051819561,
-0.0344872661,
-0.042394571,
-0.0468092486,
-0.0007162993,
-0.0060351067,
-0.0032203593,
-0.0265983324,
-0.0137486076,
0.0365696847,
-0.0272400808,
-0.0351422429,
0.0377250127,
0.0407808051,
-0.011229936,
-0.0062758485,
0.0122898221,
-0.0969952941,
-0.0305079576,
-0.0115460176,
-0.0799406543,
-0.0077025616,
0.0358003564,
-0.0325326808,
0.0442681536,
0.0105467122,
-0.0148334801,
-0.1029930711,
-0.0329127125,
0.0173280705,
0.0166452434,
0.0204906221,
0.0122732231,
0.0079474924,
0.0739702731,
0.0048949732,
0.0405521058,
-0.0081671216,
-0.0509168133,
0.0389633253,
0.0087627098,
-0.0339757688,
-5.868984685e-33,
0.0124003887,
-0.0418895409,
-0.067743063,
0.0215981808,
-0.0062399213,
0.0123334415,
-0.0037821808,
0.0611359514,
0.0019965309,
0.0545804612,
0.0146760019,
0.0057672546,
0.0017298855,
-0.0564603359,
0.0889824852,
0.0065587764,
0.0474392362,
0.013100205,
-0.0601137131,
0.0108855898,
0.0558146462,
-0.0379439443,
0.0301312059,
-0.1236830056,
0.0385746099,
0.0438277684,
-0.0504315086,
-0.0329083763,
0.0139897065,
0.0642320961,
0.0042585735,
0.0626530349,
0.0322298817,
0.0213366281,
-0.0074001388,
0.0151568446,
-0.0386391208,
-0.0239802171,
0.0082943263,
-0.0138566261,
-0.0087069655,
-0.0116438121,
0.0467802733,
-0.0181700103,
-0.0423682444,
-0.0003929384,
0.0563556254,
-0.0230784453,
0.0476836488,
-0.0657862201,
-0.0219975822,
-0.0059936293,
-0.015320885,
0.0156236673,
-0.0190462526,
-0.0619983077,
-0.0246428791,
0.0494372733,
-0.0791738331,
0.0989914834,
-0.0368956476,
0.0013966091,
0.0086619668,
-0.0091237184,
-0.002619812,
0.0786290467,
0.0254837107,
0.030516021,
-0.0022525096,
0.01020608,
0.0397315659,
0.05452241,
0.0314698815,
0.0794480816,
0.078936018,
-0.0481944978,
0.0125004733,
-0.0054528252,
-0.0062455232,
0.0493691936,
0.060229212,
0.027876826,
-0.0717787892,
-0.0395858325,
-0.0036848288,
-0.0319725834,
-0.0646355674,
-0.0129846772,
-0.0022023695,
-0.0089823473,
-0.0077831196,
0.0087314136,
-0.0099939015,
-0.0138567174,
-0.0240170192,
-0.0383959152,
-0.0324108638,
0.0360361971,
0.0215397831,
-0.0418003835,
-0.0258113313,
-0.0036381523,
-0.0091163628,
0.0221975017,
0.0204000082,
-0.0215870962,
0.0105587486,
-0.0141725037,
-0.0639893636,
-0.0190532226,
0.0215995703,
-0.0466068834,
0.024137361,
0.0017494926,
0.0323780514,
0.0046030716,
-0.0231568366,
0.0047093323,
-0.0159662329,
0.0585439838,
-0.0277788341,
-0.0032244611,
-0.0222960431,
0.0359524712,
0.0018069395,
-0.056110207,
-0.0286314227,
-0.0854001418,
0.052828785,
-0.015805766,
-0.0371636972,
-0.0182572491,
2.531e-7,
0.0261494461,
0.0649534017,
-0.0244404487,
-0.0473369248,
-0.0003943102,
0.038837336,
-0.0002520813,
-0.0144831548,
-0.002559453,
-0.0331031308,
0.0302500688,
-0.0125207258,
0.0444363803,
0.0676842257,
-0.0189082399,
0.0103839627,
-0.0556106269,
-0.0167531669,
-0.0148246689,
-0.0184953958,
0.052569285,
0.0145754367,
0.0103498241,
0.005734575,
-0.0349185653,
-0.0287617855,
0.0226796959,
-0.0420940556,
0.0273449942,
-0.0047753886,
0.0015247472,
-0.0260990169,
0.0109557509,
0.0417124368,
0.0238446761,
-0.0279122721,
0.0543444306,
-0.0030636347,
-0.0045071612,
-0.0394889489,
-0.0117471227,
0.0195534378,
-0.0257540736,
-0.031022504,
0.013286802,
-0.0404095203,
-0.0422418453,
-0.0209985748,
-0.0430871844,
-0.0113580236,
0.0650422946,
-0.0201411024,
-0.0281767379,
0.0129668415,
0.0078703631,
0.0214475468,
-0.0027569658,
-0.0692456812,
0.028471427,
0.0532836057,
-0.0436528176,
-0.0893334225,
0.0321269818,
-0.0079393862,
0.0111292908,
-0.0406797118,
-0.0040275925,
1.880918957e-34,
0.0712519363,
-0.0289429687,
0.0183087196,
-0.0345878638,
0.0249551926,
0.0123286694,
-0.0258369725,
-0.0268720314,
0.0273863487,
-0.0281136688,
-0.0013340926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04554v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04554v1 | Assessing Distractors in Multiple-Choice Tests | 2023-11-08T09:37:09 | 2023-11-08T09:37:09 | Vatsal Raina, Adian Liusie, Mark Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiple-choice tests are a common approach for assessing candidates'
comprehension skills. Standard multiple-choice reading comprehension exams
require candidates to select the correct answer option from a discrete set
based on a question in relation to a contextual passage. For appropriate
assessment, the distractor answer options must by definition be incorrect but
plausible and diverse. However, generating good quality distractors satisfying
these criteria is a challenging task for content creators. We propose automated
assessment metrics for the quality of distractors in multiple-choice reading
comprehension tests. Specifically, we define quality in terms of the
incorrectness, plausibility and diversity of the distractor options. We assess
incorrectness using the classification ability of a binary multiple-choice
reading comprehension system. Plausibility is assessed by considering the
distractor confidence - the probability mass associated with the distractor
options for a standard multi-class multiple-choice reading comprehension
system. Diversity is assessed by pairwise comparison of an embedding-based
equivalence metric between the distractors of a question. To further validate
the plausibility metric we compare against candidate distributions over
multiple-choice questions and agreement with a ChatGPT model's interpretation
of distractor plausibility and diversity. | [
-0.0017525938,
-0.0496578291,
-0.0319048725,
0.0060816598,
-0.041907955,
0.029610347,
0.0371759348,
-0.0104713393,
0.056273479,
-0.0377652384,
0.032301899,
0.0041631381,
-0.0255420897,
-0.0314383134,
0.0054988237,
-0.0647066608,
0.0375040919,
-0.0113548879,
0.0187592395,
0.0227859579,
-0.020909179,
-0.0049292231,
-0.0284782425,
0.0120533453,
0.0379083492,
-0.0568471439,
-0.0038522771,
-0.0183542147,
0.0630330667,
-0.0281458348,
0.0198923163,
0.0644192845,
-0.0439378582,
0.0157239139,
0.0000021305,
-0.0580394305,
-0.0443738513,
0.003907037,
-0.0235220511,
0.0244663581,
0.0036711586,
0.0890695825,
0.0297700707,
0.0056900335,
-0.0108350674,
0.0260704346,
0.0312505029,
0.0014474057,
0.0519454703,
0.0260268282,
0.0254164319,
0.0375737548,
0.0139729427,
0.0242876634,
0.062877506,
-0.005893338,
-0.0129401665,
0.0438734181,
0.0039559626,
0.059177842,
-0.0405883603,
0.0164620019,
-0.0006147865,
0.0499308445,
0.0241917819,
0.0110463807,
0.0271739047,
-0.011968201,
0.0113316281,
0.0461665951,
-0.0065076402,
-0.0212119352,
-0.0360106044,
-0.0324280374,
0.0101477616,
0.094940573,
-0.051237829,
-0.0013080213,
-0.0494703017,
-0.0307101831,
0.0271954089,
-0.0176820233,
-0.0129994592,
0.0098953992,
0.0307686795,
-0.0064848801,
0.0366419442,
-0.0369792208,
-0.0041649234,
0.0219103396,
-0.0016156986,
-0.0413434245,
0.050895419,
0.0126192477,
-0.0471267402,
0.0201144572,
-0.0108941942,
-0.0783888102,
0.0476823635,
-0.0211683903,
0.0011850951,
0.0196303651,
-0.0364078283,
0.0741529092,
0.0030050161,
0.068545036,
0.0106974645,
0.0600491092,
-0.0424195416,
0.0344108231,
-0.0366493687,
0.0182130467,
-0.0009100606,
0.0153701445,
-0.0089033293,
-0.0271296985,
-0.0320812613,
0.0197476167,
-0.0255561024,
0.0258011092,
-0.0018603636,
0.0227644034,
-0.0081783375,
0.0071877274,
-0.0369525701,
0.0371048376,
-0.0334512144,
-0.0126238465,
-0.0104444064,
0.0282266978,
0.0251863562,
0.0339227766,
0.0222236514,
-0.0285873711,
0.0091917235,
0.0421916805,
-0.0250381604,
-0.0372355208,
-0.0247678831,
-0.0101465238,
0.0131884795,
-0.0149691217,
-0.0119207213,
-0.0382656679,
-0.0070365346,
0.0277934559,
-0.0029708487,
-0.0019658506,
0.0032706559,
0.0381265767,
0.0310608633,
0.0218416359,
0.0160911512,
-0.0155353379,
0.0556609742,
0.0253204368,
-0.04382715,
0.057328064,
0.0141084362,
-0.0001684442,
0.0823163241,
-0.068439953,
0.0233692136,
-0.0170575827,
-0.0616926663,
-0.0156629905,
0.0416625626,
0.0155503303,
0.0267650951,
0.0133161973,
-0.0188249256,
0.0414688326,
-0.0207892228,
-0.0102489246,
0.0663569644,
0.0205425452,
0.0489322804,
-0.0028677348,
0.0264921971,
0.0205480177,
0.0109105418,
0.095150426,
-0.0169300605,
0.0149043528,
-0.0460372083,
0.0134940203,
0.0429209098,
0.0523180962,
0.0224034507,
-0.0527842678,
-0.0172539447,
0.0234800074,
0.0271323547,
0.0440164395,
0.0484004058,
-0.0341197364,
-0.0743903741,
0.0026110939,
-0.00733326,
-0.0334689617,
0.0431071594,
-0.0159798395,
0.0914673135,
0.0559131391,
0.0330480598,
-0.0602886751,
-0.080021061,
-0.0091795614,
-0.0109402351,
0.0075133969,
0.0343262926,
-0.0513522699,
0.0120864045,
-0.0652287453,
-0.0357019827,
0.0108664306,
0.0098828431,
0.0268651005,
-0.0173802041,
0.0170304421,
-0.0064792261,
-0.0417045802,
-0.0281977039,
0.0416714847,
-0.0170595516,
-0.0428892188,
-0.015447678,
0.0070465133,
0.0307897869,
0.0278787464,
0.001486334,
-0.010333227,
0.005215859,
0.0005073115,
0.0207485985,
-0.0141863031,
-0.0206769072,
0.0027974965,
0.0364496931,
-0.0687428266,
-0.0299908407,
0.0408841558,
-0.00335424,
-0.0207746495,
0.0115079796,
-0.0569420382,
-0.0448694043,
-0.0117304539,
0.002821727,
-0.0277737416,
-0.022577526,
-0.0651576594,
0.0809630528,
0.0339112207,
0.1070976332,
0.0203793086,
0.0341236144,
0.032866437,
-0.0251749512,
-0.0074042119,
-0.0219863001,
-0.0017943077,
0.0309911873,
0.020794265,
0.0119286217,
-0.0971618518,
-0.0231309906,
-0.0508959517,
0.0275103338,
-0.0120381648,
0.0056624473,
0.0318146721,
-0.0504353382,
-0.0055752979,
0.0018558158,
-0.0085553182,
-0.0117080472,
-0.021990208,
0.0074618743,
-0.0064212112,
-0.0290674046,
0.0191559121,
-0.0016431469,
-0.0067643607,
-0.028613545,
0.0350074992,
0.0491786562,
0.043938715,
-0.0574677512,
0.0236329678,
0.0017806923,
-0.0459437221,
0.0340817533,
0.0236265939,
0.0469845422,
-0.023105612,
0.0481149964,
0.0540321693,
0.0177233536,
-0.0007280015,
0.0404994711,
-0.0327572301,
-0.0435316078,
0.0178335011,
-0.0085506449,
0.0240652598,
0.0135212727,
-0.0683125257,
0.0121540995,
0.0179483742,
0.0583608113,
-0.0501176827,
-0.0443867035,
0.0153570967,
-0.0704571009,
-0.0071204472,
-0.0694692135,
-0.0078573255,
-0.0209462941,
0.0624504536,
-0.0019467428,
-0.007161709,
0.0798578709,
-0.0179944187,
0.0222519003,
-0.1121556014,
0.0289938264,
-0.0043626558,
0.0067597637,
-0.0206389409,
0.0129753686,
0.014106906,
-0.0387573391,
-0.0518588647,
0.0017173408,
0.0685688406,
-0.058492329,
0.0443287864,
-0.0664982945,
-0.0574950799,
0.0173276104,
0.0109912055,
-0.0390955471,
-0.0070649358,
0.0526918992,
-0.0531013422,
0.0204014108,
0.0050929873,
-0.0503353029,
-0.0116454689,
0.0313433073,
-0.0043416005,
-0.028952593,
-0.0217949226,
0.0104671624,
0.0922350734,
0.0303011425,
0.0564596616,
0.0327808931,
-0.0436846018,
-0.0151022673,
0.0705559179,
-0.021466421,
-0.0018178419,
0.0174051654,
0.0143171465,
0.024673555,
-0.065568924,
0.0217054673,
-0.0027894254,
0.0767581537,
-0.051407136,
-0.018790666,
0.075061515,
0.0509203747,
-0.0249323044,
-0.0345693007,
-0.0444628559,
-0.0488827638,
0.0178290717,
-0.0011625898,
-0.0220260397,
-0.0058447029,
-0.0213868059,
0.0378988348,
-0.0277095772,
-0.0044215969,
0.0079062041,
-0.0696097091,
0.0476788133,
0.0067385333,
-0.0679540783,
-0.0108555788,
-0.0605677739,
0.0214370843,
-0.0039224601,
0.0069226143,
-0.0032977124,
0.0407620855,
0.0304826759,
0.0171291921,
0.0043059341,
-0.0219526887,
-0.022505872,
-0.0027095582,
-0.0015932285,
-0.0052839452,
0.0044756746,
-0.0263585486,
-0.0461163074,
-0.0190927219,
-0.1152021959,
-0.0341905504,
0.0189449657,
0.03113636,
0.0029856018,
0.011766254,
-0.069296822,
0.0257948302,
0.0112550287,
-0.0440909006,
0.0746639818,
0.0636120141,
0.0303102396,
-0.0431458913,
-0.0466930196,
0.0205228087,
0.0257720891,
0.0386959426,
0.0442452542,
-0.0590944029,
0.0316327512,
-0.0466824248,
0.0639112666,
-0.079352051,
0.0287302639,
0.0397537239,
-0.0183943734,
-0.0188069288,
-0.038855806,
-0.045035474,
0.0566203892,
0.0122100776,
0.0114201205,
0.0156538002,
0.0150405336,
-0.0018128079,
-0.0101900557,
0.0144841839,
0.0414618552,
-0.0086373053,
-0.0235594865,
-0.0490887463,
-0.0351208411,
-0.0121677276,
-0.0327180214,
0.0339700095,
-0.0541696623,
-0.0085103782,
0.0122249313,
0.0092540383,
0.0186095983,
-0.0551778972,
-0.0067914976,
-0.0199828241,
0.0078856256,
-0.0349663906,
-0.0053818277,
0.0056724325,
-0.0290336367,
-0.0124464333,
-0.0206304397,
-0.0374867506,
-0.0118685225,
0.0172142275,
0.0046674483,
0.02262602,
-0.038034074,
0.0074637933,
0.0126571245,
0.0158316735,
-0.0043079238,
-0.0208425466,
-0.017213162,
-0.056960687,
-0.0157764871,
0.0097373175,
-0.0373819172,
0.0349009559,
-0.0221763905,
0.0419319272,
-0.0598586351,
-0.021775078,
-0.0012095047,
-0.0403157771,
0.0055745887,
-0.050728865,
0.0431039408,
0.0420234762,
0.0194169898,
-0.0016644119,
-0.0047798003,
-0.0574596226,
-0.0445539728,
-0.0088816043,
0.0631164908,
0.043722406,
0.099664405,
0.0060653612,
-0.0140356887,
0.0453018807,
-0.0115720956,
-0.0556334145,
0.0337156057,
-0.0055361819,
0.0672009885,
-0.0032160226,
0.0048162425,
0.0239621606,
-0.0008381276,
-0.0278360657,
-0.0402710512,
0.0188170616,
0.0240252204,
0.012772291,
0.0008014102,
0.0307021663,
0.0464488976,
-0.0175569374,
0.05329936,
-0.0428957343,
-0.0337946154,
0.0181458723,
-0.0501271114,
-0.0762217939,
0.0144975856,
-0.0283530354,
0.0865981653,
0.0030740059,
0.0158477835,
-0.0817530528,
-0.0381584503,
0.0646316037,
0.0456501767,
0.0548707545,
-0.0039107795,
-0.0120132994,
0.0723355263,
-0.0285879187,
0.0120761665,
-0.0100238575,
0.03911452,
-0.0671621487,
-0.0081445705,
-0.042943567,
-6.301119918e-33,
-0.0340140983,
-0.073680684,
0.0005796403,
-0.0639297739,
0.0216541998,
-0.0027445054,
-0.0213865433,
0.0085244337,
-0.0042561702,
-0.0059058992,
0.0059464537,
-0.010111996,
-0.0024272746,
0.0470470414,
0.0006220501,
-0.0200893581,
-0.0113145364,
0.0165395141,
-0.0486243069,
0.031917654,
0.0537213348,
-0.0340506397,
0.0255823303,
-0.0430098474,
0.0446481965,
-0.0130547369,
0.0147891399,
-0.0285199806,
-0.0173370354,
0.056097284,
-0.0236418117,
0.0843870714,
0.0348015316,
-0.0411017798,
0.025625214,
0.0321694277,
-0.0328525826,
-0.0840308219,
0.023927439,
0.0118346671,
-0.0313816778,
-0.038819395,
0.0224096775,
0.0077201906,
0.0138442088,
-0.0637078881,
0.0730577037,
-0.0214780625,
-0.0227528531,
0.018685488,
-0.0634042621,
0.0244417805,
-0.0676966161,
0.0007496412,
-0.0299626719,
0.0690925121,
0.0208630878,
0.0253685266,
-0.0491479039,
0.0331771001,
0.0247968491,
0.0090208193,
0.0213419776,
-0.008741484,
-0.0234253127,
0.0519762561,
0.0142141143,
-0.0349442475,
0.0075890385,
-0.0244745631,
0.0036454631,
-0.0043577435,
0.0772989169,
0.0720267892,
0.046701692,
0.0066902754,
-0.0537218228,
0.0584861115,
0.003697573,
-0.0235436577,
0.0408804081,
-0.0280534104,
-0.0650333166,
-0.0218953509,
-0.027210312,
-0.0379160233,
-0.0446906462,
-0.0153536471,
0.0669955313,
-0.0548643023,
-0.0554475971,
0.009712561,
0.0092449598,
-0.0068795867,
0.0182639901,
-0.0120380707,
-0.0144716883,
0.060266234,
-0.0126674296,
0.01019412,
0.0067325667,
0.0036115481,
0.0131641626,
-0.0063261166,
0.0155221326,
-0.0212399103,
-0.0111001348,
-0.0205640942,
-0.041671373,
-0.0018631568,
-0.0126639754,
-0.0118905893,
0.0200150311,
0.037827,
0.0252373517,
0.0044252654,
-0.0166116655,
0.0125749903,
0.0218904018,
0.0071747419,
-0.02814826,
-0.0399848782,
-0.0470952466,
-0.021734383,
-0.0096895257,
-0.0282969363,
-0.0024176899,
-0.022238452,
-0.0005968811,
-0.0481057987,
0.017385453,
0.0038555753,
2.692e-7,
0.0464877412,
0.0570634082,
-0.0250681322,
-0.0022462897,
-0.0044107107,
0.022317959,
-0.0030382604,
0.0053905211,
0.0723259971,
-0.0281738099,
-0.0057450221,
0.0034725815,
-0.0075006792,
0.0465836003,
-0.0494076498,
-0.058179196,
0.0517181531,
0.0267368872,
-0.0280850828,
0.0489967093,
0.0940523669,
0.0098763676,
0.0217948817,
-0.0162022207,
-0.0009948433,
-0.0172820576,
-0.0081628943,
-0.0054167314,
-0.0010096722,
0.0169299934,
0.0543583892,
-0.029670177,
0.0190054961,
0.0611334629,
-0.0159598961,
-0.0430379026,
0.0609675609,
-0.0020090539,
0.0131774675,
-0.0150748305,
-0.0323786736,
0.0242965128,
0.0279923864,
-0.0568998307,
0.0490690731,
-0.0081290817,
-0.0144110862,
0.0131294392,
-0.0973342061,
-0.0264110081,
0.0171517693,
-0.0081287911,
-0.0406594947,
-0.0148960063,
-0.0200205911,
0.0075459839,
0.0193837471,
-0.0232077204,
-0.0011233832,
0.0163236782,
-0.0282669887,
-0.0648337677,
-0.0123159317,
-0.0463333763,
0.0306132492,
-0.057609953,
0.0026414217,
2.116244316e-34,
0.0251563881,
0.0173303802,
0.0459877253,
-0.0441213176,
0.0120934891,
-0.0380423851,
0.0200034846,
-0.0025689499,
0.0317521095,
-0.067976065,
-0.0072606229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04547v1 | Large GPT-like Models are Bad Babies: A Closer Look at the Relationship between Linguistic Competence and Psycholinguistic Measures | 2023-11-08T09:26:27 | 2023-11-08T09:26:27 | Julius Steuer, Marius Mosbach, Dietrich Klakow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research on the cognitive plausibility of language models (LMs) has so far
mostly concentrated on modelling psycholinguistic response variables such as
reading times, gaze durations and N400/P600 EEG signals, while mostly leaving
out the dimension of what Mahowald et al. (2023) described as formal and
functional linguistic competence, and developmental plausibility. We address
this gap by training a series of GPT-like language models of different sizes on
the strict version of the BabyLM pretraining corpus, evaluating on the
challenge tasks (BLiMP, GLUE, MSGS) and an additional reading time prediction
task. We find a positive correlation between LM size and performance on all
three challenge tasks, with different preferences for model width and depth in
each of the tasks. In contrast, a negative correlation was found between LM
size and reading time fit of linear mixed-effects models using LM surprisal as
a predictor, with the second-smallest LM achieving the largest log-likelihood
reduction over a baseline model without surprisal. This suggests that modelling
processing effort and linguistic competence may require an approach different
from training GPT-like LMs on a developmentally plausible corpus. | [
0.001038512,
0.0344727375,
-0.0248469021,
0.0058778343,
-0.0527642742,
0.0427206643,
0.0423805378,
0.0077119446,
-0.0123603921,
-0.0156471636,
-0.0182434712,
-0.0682629421,
0.0258868784,
0.0304750782,
0.0427296832,
-0.0500100218,
0.0233115908,
-0.0287765954,
0.0464768186,
-0.01570208,
0.0020939736,
-0.0118805515,
-0.0171256438,
0.0585313961,
-0.0023244002,
-0.0098774359,
0.0002817998,
-0.0269213431,
-0.0092532374,
-0.0077143875,
-0.0144413076,
0.0882598981,
0.0036666424,
0.0267487261,
0.0000019675,
-0.0437153205,
0.040052481,
0.0033888118,
-0.0287801027,
0.0343832113,
0.0360227898,
-0.0087624379,
0.0038945612,
0.0262655299,
-0.003827804,
-0.0295839496,
0.0546358675,
0.0151825557,
-0.015126775,
0.0458898209,
-0.0158391707,
0.0173882414,
0.0851481333,
-0.0240154862,
0.0495821871,
-0.0214718133,
0.0070205312,
0.0137878489,
0.0267533958,
0.0023147424,
-0.039402768,
0.0485943183,
0.0349992514,
0.045994211,
-0.0150562022,
0.0212674644,
0.0035723404,
-0.0279591605,
-0.0255941749,
-0.0146820778,
-0.0203661509,
-0.0277882554,
-0.0245577134,
-0.0120903701,
-0.0332151055,
0.0075224098,
-0.0309446566,
0.0409267209,
-0.0014514871,
0.0330003053,
0.0496334918,
-0.0221771263,
0.0267408304,
-0.0440484956,
-0.002167851,
0.0891117081,
0.0138337919,
-0.0690392107,
0.0267453231,
0.0578956753,
-0.0453662202,
-0.0084094647,
-0.030184295,
-0.0402358249,
0.0044141533,
0.0326046236,
-0.0429728925,
-0.0110365683,
0.001480235,
0.0036656284,
0.0351237245,
0.0394369848,
0.0045687449,
0.0117419716,
-0.0181737971,
0.0606151372,
0.0093191508,
0.0106858937,
-0.0252333451,
-0.0153669789,
-0.0419057906,
-0.0305439457,
-0.0210350398,
-0.0416916944,
-0.0515098087,
-0.0243633501,
-0.0631125644,
-0.0143733425,
0.0224691052,
-0.0731725246,
0.0254668035,
-0.0230939314,
-0.041366294,
-0.0116783362,
-0.0429852009,
-0.0141266799,
0.02430363,
0.0229884963,
-0.0159950368,
-0.0623973459,
-0.0042400872,
0.0121939639,
-0.0148078669,
-0.0437531285,
-0.012999774,
0.0348341428,
-0.0057180072,
-0.0637490377,
-0.0659696236,
0.0206476096,
-0.0410628542,
-0.0660435036,
0.0192573667,
-0.0602046661,
0.0060064569,
0.0014575004,
-0.0063622012,
-0.0535364896,
-0.0344618894,
-0.0073421979,
-0.0235039871,
0.0156632513,
-0.0236718096,
0.0384070873,
-0.0005823213,
0.005633675,
0.0006614223,
0.0652448386,
0.0604945123,
-0.0690877587,
-0.0023588187,
-0.036493849,
-0.0568606369,
0.075011611,
-0.01397816,
0.0064397086,
-0.0314613916,
-0.0356648639,
-0.0113709662,
-0.0134731391,
0.0368510894,
0.0238590278,
-0.0170667209,
0.0008733969,
0.089735128,
0.0912867934,
-0.0027046839,
0.0095878039,
0.0527245253,
0.0202106461,
0.0466722101,
0.0067296023,
-0.0198103692,
-0.0089630727,
-0.0233692378,
0.0001990096,
0.0153123057,
0.0394650139,
-0.0016974204,
-0.0083127469,
-0.0028074761,
-0.0024499036,
0.0250979699,
0.0165514592,
0.0335350297,
-0.0392499529,
-0.0575960539,
0.0119524179,
0.0285094604,
-0.0154262576,
-0.0075327582,
-0.0438772365,
-0.0112014338,
0.0239365622,
0.0057627945,
0.022674283,
-0.0119122397,
0.0181470532,
-0.0216853395,
0.0877925158,
0.008641067,
0.0457375385,
0.0265860073,
-0.0272315703,
0.0077841929,
0.0234963931,
0.0296453089,
-0.0131753273,
0.0133039718,
-0.0069914646,
0.0057400861,
-0.0113206347,
-0.0330732092,
0.0314255655,
-0.0698365495,
-0.0274306927,
-0.0371287242,
-0.0071638245,
0.0622212589,
-0.0237357169,
-0.0075780782,
0.0108786887,
-0.0036172946,
-0.0018934525,
0.037146803,
0.005241307,
-0.0514577106,
0.0067837834,
0.008727341,
0.0226601418,
-0.0088838087,
0.0455864333,
0.0546589456,
-0.029878214,
-0.0064114435,
-0.0479511842,
0.0642892048,
-0.0121380175,
0.040264789,
-0.0521022454,
-0.0109683033,
-0.0536384434,
0.0297647659,
0.0137769962,
0.0330381952,
-0.0147029785,
-0.0132382149,
0.0042219837,
-0.0555049852,
-0.0584656745,
-0.0089071803,
0.0113162762,
0.0113767004,
-0.010821417,
0.0139736738,
-0.0516429693,
-0.0167847108,
-0.1082156524,
-0.0021145209,
0.0106000965,
0.0228454974,
0.0368756056,
-0.0395166986,
-0.0502279401,
0.0559006706,
-0.0247782227,
0.0212781783,
0.012300577,
0.0288746245,
-0.0179674067,
-0.0315731578,
-0.0288803186,
-0.0149396546,
-0.0251979064,
-0.0457526818,
0.0349815004,
0.0135512371,
-0.018022567,
-0.0053026811,
0.0433704965,
0.001684384,
0.0182673614,
0.0029047246,
-0.0169381555,
0.0575832911,
0.0121123623,
0.1178153232,
0.0643168017,
0.0070909541,
0.0080520613,
0.009285084,
-0.0487484448,
-0.0184913278,
0.017871283,
-0.046581246,
0.0066894181,
-0.0628908873,
-0.0501823872,
-0.0055479459,
0.1226566881,
0.0168616325,
-0.0145155685,
-0.0738217905,
0.042617064,
-0.0391858742,
-0.0259801541,
0.0124090156,
-0.0099419439,
-0.0326961391,
0.052391313,
-0.0288160387,
-0.0972624049,
0.019086713,
-0.0509003252,
-0.0258424599,
-0.0426524766,
-0.002927131,
0.002696116,
0.0422885343,
0.0243906844,
0.0007009076,
-0.0210148208,
-0.0058516483,
-0.0495535992,
0.0317434967,
0.0025111032,
0.0030030187,
0.0263233148,
-0.0521359444,
-0.0062327632,
0.0258943029,
-0.0089100944,
0.0003219331,
0.0198929328,
-0.0173429102,
-0.0093957717,
0.0078923907,
-0.016494181,
-0.0722272545,
0.0074724718,
0.020505989,
0.0285448022,
-0.0317611806,
-0.0090894382,
0.0007014752,
-0.0368028805,
0.0259902347,
0.0267043151,
0.0233173408,
-0.0734269619,
-0.0075616059,
-0.0017084052,
-0.0093361484,
0.0150697362,
-0.0183413438,
0.0417299122,
0.0157896578,
0.0084531931,
-0.0453714915,
0.045662608,
0.0623323843,
-0.0670058429,
0.003830604,
0.1195224449,
0.0324835852,
-0.013347608,
0.0114057828,
-0.0009743954,
0.0597131029,
-0.0111520654,
-0.0067521827,
0.0036463558,
-0.0077538863,
0.011506645,
0.044616282,
-0.0197338592,
-0.0260647032,
-0.0322987996,
-0.0695868731,
0.0199298523,
0.0131815998,
-0.0394542068,
0.0251070093,
-0.0059765298,
-0.0175623633,
0.0040171603,
0.0085620759,
0.0243204739,
-0.0138367675,
0.0203281362,
0.0196097698,
-0.0387113318,
-0.062943913,
0.0547597595,
-0.0047054277,
0.0682811886,
0.013397119,
-0.0290546585,
-0.0210684203,
-0.0297074281,
0.0539885089,
-0.0317787044,
-0.0356554165,
0.0044839508,
0.0016397053,
0.0065101953,
-0.0033988846,
-0.0640503019,
0.0274245329,
0.0090033393,
-0.0181154981,
-0.0141760046,
0.0758393928,
0.0248626284,
-0.0439469293,
-0.0018707281,
0.0184330475,
-0.0171475373,
0.0680306256,
0.0307895727,
-0.0896952972,
-0.0442204848,
0.0119540356,
-0.0200325437,
0.0010356165,
-0.0922369063,
0.0265209489,
0.0217946414,
-0.0013929714,
-0.0255471431,
-0.0337911136,
0.0364817306,
0.0300818998,
0.0208660271,
0.0298175197,
0.0265764743,
-0.0286690518,
-0.0163033362,
0.0826535299,
0.0161283873,
-0.0360626914,
-0.1332641542,
-0.0317956284,
-0.0043621534,
-0.0209614728,
-0.0333003588,
0.009954094,
-0.070691593,
-0.0589655079,
0.0238811076,
0.0167962033,
0.0365946591,
-0.0197627023,
0.0358377807,
-0.0396233983,
0.0238935053,
0.0112097133,
-0.0388989784,
0.055753693,
-0.0142978569,
-0.0141693475,
0.0242738985,
0.0061018602,
0.0119584454,
0.0369246118,
0.0204138383,
0.0388145,
0.0266024545,
0.0075967824,
-0.0002080858,
0.0330871679,
0.0714751557,
-0.0030289101,
-0.0118207298,
-0.0618563108,
-0.0404360108,
-0.0166892055,
0.0730748326,
-0.0542592146,
-0.0396471471,
0.0354811735,
0.0226427279,
-0.0312133916,
-0.0407757685,
-0.0265384261,
-0.0120044267,
-0.0229070559,
0.0317361057,
-0.0643623546,
-0.00517854,
0.0148026096,
0.0300258361,
0.00069412,
-0.0113941925,
-0.0636943355,
0.0246805213,
0.0291924905,
0.0487796701,
-0.0149649959,
0.017030891,
0.0029190688,
0.0015553551,
-0.0304994714,
-0.0198964812,
-0.0085852304,
0.0199106038,
0.011476893,
-0.0301372055,
0.0801625177,
-0.0559202544,
0.0299529135,
-0.0773288235,
0.0170700308,
0.0073406165,
0.0068907421,
0.0435573533,
-0.0039946642,
-0.0299093593,
-0.0421890765,
0.0851839185,
0.0705480799,
0.0154101802,
0.0124580739,
-0.0181695838,
-0.0223620571,
-0.0487787984,
0.0144422306,
-0.0026017115,
-0.0400837846,
0.0458275788,
-0.0784479901,
-0.0636598766,
-0.0225792453,
0.0056986026,
0.0339277945,
-0.0269551221,
0.0020705278,
0.0527855828,
-0.0522136353,
-0.0242790449,
0.0026857541,
-0.0361614972,
0.0200347528,
-0.0147259329,
0.002079549,
-6.252639592e-33,
-0.0131348148,
-0.0267027896,
0.0507806055,
0.0228976142,
0.0109493984,
0.0318365619,
-0.0107039837,
0.0616393909,
-0.0080219358,
-0.0232981518,
0.0084894178,
-0.0199584831,
0.0128663834,
0.0196078718,
0.0054095304,
0.0570298843,
-0.0102103855,
-0.0198215563,
0.0050422107,
-0.0199815314,
0.0141490977,
0.0041691931,
0.0646194741,
-0.01600595,
0.0253098663,
-0.0030407817,
0.0147095639,
-0.0203777049,
-0.0086808112,
0.0758160204,
-0.044195611,
0.0318449438,
0.0349063985,
0.009808029,
-0.0186577085,
0.0305615813,
-0.0348098651,
0.0049827518,
0.0762780756,
-0.0105684241,
-0.0519583225,
0.0009590281,
0.0421827808,
-0.0001091521,
-0.0351403579,
-0.046896942,
0.007276779,
-0.0324028432,
0.0061219418,
0.02735986,
-0.0695701912,
0.024768969,
-0.0061133513,
0.0185991302,
0.0338452123,
0.0331441686,
-0.0398280174,
0.0321327262,
-0.0375696309,
-0.0200061146,
0.0286926441,
0.0585283302,
0.0286575593,
-0.0054802331,
0.0562815554,
0.0453188457,
0.0404910296,
0.0174357183,
-0.012661078,
0.0106925229,
0.1174506173,
-0.0018774847,
0.057830099,
-0.0161846597,
0.0829762816,
0.0022767831,
-0.0746526346,
-0.0075785397,
0.0299002081,
0.0073584896,
0.0432106778,
-0.0163179375,
-0.006107688,
-0.0207463056,
-0.0335956328,
0.0141075393,
-0.0109563619,
-0.027907772,
0.0745777637,
-0.0302904174,
0.0076084668,
-0.0202741511,
0.0598696396,
0.0017125283,
0.0299853329,
-0.0475292429,
-0.0351957753,
0.0280434489,
0.0014175748,
0.0495145954,
-0.0649689287,
-0.0269939099,
0.0139922546,
0.0143229868,
0.0389737636,
0.0162008014,
0.0023093703,
0.0164962057,
-0.0781648308,
0.0089210058,
-0.0211359859,
0.0180016961,
0.0398071185,
0.0044103358,
0.0668461099,
-0.0388409272,
0.0078007798,
-0.0228081867,
-0.0274826568,
-0.0469871499,
-0.03486773,
0.0132024689,
-0.0330273956,
0.0310916156,
0.008964763,
-0.0063968799,
-0.0034439142,
0.0094493935,
0.0281942543,
-0.0172092225,
-0.0146992933,
0.02318855,
2.732e-7,
0.0380682945,
0.072198458,
-0.000452917,
0.0427642651,
0.0332472771,
-0.0212644599,
-0.0230519436,
0.0043066312,
0.0169561747,
0.0154742645,
-0.016039459,
0.0197719112,
0.0749200061,
-0.012687427,
-0.0655228719,
-0.0507435575,
-0.0436874591,
0.0472672209,
-0.0646034405,
0.0184711032,
0.0388727263,
0.0278337635,
-0.0063288151,
-0.0239200052,
0.0068383892,
-0.037843667,
0.0657853484,
-0.0516340584,
0.0066450476,
0.0032837952,
0.0028994926,
0.034675587,
-0.002369571,
0.0625853986,
0.0081185261,
0.0299308263,
0.0049433312,
0.0636004955,
-0.0056800847,
0.0226479024,
0.0513998792,
0.0078127626,
-0.0477897339,
-0.0663496479,
0.0485230573,
-0.0382621996,
-0.0387149826,
0.064928025,
-0.0412275121,
-0.0308747292,
0.0372887366,
-0.0273272563,
-0.0157804433,
-0.0108362483,
0.0300493613,
-0.0383001789,
0.0070629884,
-0.0155330775,
0.0095239663,
0.0627990663,
-0.0558781475,
-0.0485548787,
-0.0764420256,
0.0103036398,
0.0394160561,
-0.0438146219,
0.0005387047,
2.740708242e-34,
0.0206858162,
-0.0247891005,
0.0683023334,
-0.0007386003,
0.0295728203,
-0.0149078071,
0.0394449905,
0.0092355609,
-0.0190324783,
-0.0960295722,
-0.0224762801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04535v1 | RankAug: Augmented data ranking for text classification | 2023-11-08T08:47:49 | 2023-11-08T08:47:49 | Tiasa Singha Roy, Priyam Basu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Research on data generation and augmentation has been focused majorly on
enhancing generation models, leaving a notable gap in the exploration and
refinement of methods for evaluating synthetic data. There are several text
similarity metrics within the context of generated data filtering which can
impact the performance of specific Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks,
specifically focusing on intent and sentiment classification. In this study, we
propose RankAug, a text-ranking approach that detects and filters out the top
augmented texts in terms of being most similar in meaning with lexical and
syntactical diversity. Through experiments conducted on multiple datasets, we
demonstrate that the judicious selection of filtering techniques can yield a
substantial improvement of up to 35% in classification accuracy for
under-represented classes. | [
0.0523180664,
0.0331807993,
0.0047038039,
0.0080501577,
0.0013411207,
0.0283094309,
0.023926219,
-0.0101698721,
0.0736504123,
-0.0688136816,
-0.0102156559,
-0.0324817449,
-0.0206215698,
0.0184038822,
0.0035821977,
-0.0005248316,
0.04620694,
0.0362159796,
-0.0090550762,
0.0195327289,
0.0259249043,
0.0382878855,
0.0248387419,
0.0155936154,
0.0353555754,
0.0123906545,
0.0125039211,
0.0252660736,
0.0784992948,
-0.026843749,
0.0157341082,
0.0282459948,
-0.0199607965,
0.0634260401,
0.0000020096,
-0.0619760565,
-0.0378645211,
-0.0003874665,
-0.0204108581,
-0.0134313488,
0.0731862262,
0.0330953971,
0.0397403128,
0.0415510684,
-0.0531320535,
0.0309057925,
-0.0010888514,
0.0016406144,
0.0514956899,
0.0694341213,
-0.0234956183,
-0.01182603,
-0.0132535305,
-0.0435104482,
0.0367835388,
0.011710247,
0.0202306584,
0.0194726661,
0.0259455256,
0.0603128597,
0.0096719516,
0.0102398237,
-0.0074905413,
0.002044078,
0.0764471069,
0.0302574057,
-0.0193344988,
0.0238402933,
0.0377995744,
0.0658271536,
-0.0468110144,
-0.0726368129,
0.0220593456,
-0.0112500899,
-0.0012103308,
-0.0261312649,
-0.0159531981,
-0.0134546496,
-0.0470387377,
0.0430848971,
0.04855223,
0.0324786529,
0.004338759,
0.0252707079,
-0.0175073072,
0.0076806471,
-0.0128553612,
-0.0410343669,
-0.0041615958,
0.007075204,
-0.0142472787,
-0.0474261194,
0.026390288,
-0.013978716,
-0.0071659172,
0.0128341261,
-0.0568282083,
-0.0797304586,
0.0376666039,
-0.0687065274,
-0.0104185035,
0.0415730178,
0.015737595,
0.0480559357,
-0.0188522507,
0.0089581534,
0.0371484496,
0.027093498,
-0.0789458901,
0.0121616842,
-0.0829750299,
0.0015158557,
-0.0057334071,
0.0343972445,
-0.0596626811,
-0.0087218964,
-0.0435999781,
-0.0080974242,
-0.0183491725,
0.001368729,
0.0083538694,
0.0122739961,
-0.045192942,
0.030269403,
-0.0235355143,
-0.0097635332,
-0.0309547018,
0.0357164368,
-0.0125138843,
-0.0277862698,
0.0231250748,
0.0058092754,
0.0380378775,
-0.0121816369,
0.0386996381,
-0.026913587,
-0.017175559,
-0.036181815,
-0.0156245204,
-0.0057313619,
-0.00446461,
-0.0185938179,
-0.0203826874,
-0.0493845977,
0.0390977189,
-0.000458047,
-0.0035216054,
-0.0010886282,
0.0241568405,
0.0317090265,
-0.0253743567,
0.0578730665,
-0.0474238694,
-0.0259184204,
0.0064692288,
0.0105174454,
-0.0096869618,
0.016336387,
-0.0263302866,
0.0440678485,
0.0465434156,
0.0109613445,
-0.0124703571,
-0.0147695914,
0.0086018341,
0.0024763839,
-0.0035020909,
0.0255261641,
-0.0538668483,
-0.0022533711,
-0.0065316688,
0.0030068883,
-0.0342087783,
-0.03608796,
0.0357748978,
-0.0039889948,
0.0277957693,
0.0325088911,
0.0170943961,
0.0453608744,
0.0095414715,
-0.0108437324,
0.0161295179,
0.0109779974,
-0.0279873591,
0.004177474,
0.0355776437,
0.0723666251,
-0.0244800095,
-0.063041091,
-0.0201765038,
-0.0105369873,
0.0477987789,
-0.0018600284,
0.0247760471,
0.0480491258,
-0.0079501802,
-0.0314963832,
0.0278273858,
-0.0446873382,
-0.0179498084,
-0.014096519,
0.0051507759,
0.0791345462,
0.0455031879,
-0.0401763245,
-0.0313479751,
-0.0406998955,
-0.0083328588,
-0.0087165646,
0.033803191,
-0.0032322626,
0.0034647514,
-0.0611923262,
-0.0283038449,
-0.0011457001,
0.0008859931,
0.0527370535,
-0.0213061906,
0.0465747006,
0.0052561704,
-0.0653909072,
-0.0767325461,
0.0313898399,
-0.0025539377,
-0.0027305952,
0.0580367111,
-0.0256936699,
0.0279975832,
0.0445271879,
-0.0108329691,
0.0049750064,
0.0342336297,
-0.0491629802,
-0.0435984805,
0.0097168023,
-0.001601485,
-0.0844722167,
0.0081136106,
-0.061849568,
-0.0241694804,
0.0681979731,
-0.0618162304,
-0.019699106,
-0.021412706,
-0.0237181596,
0.0083701583,
-0.0663868412,
0.0065682479,
0.0020885624,
0.0112996893,
-0.0383083262,
0.1053958759,
0.0135704251,
0.0402387306,
0.0090318201,
0.0066678314,
0.0452590026,
0.0104924832,
-0.0145967361,
-0.0131512852,
-0.0017488602,
0.0076377746,
0.0164358653,
0.0303921252,
-0.0422450192,
-0.0128925396,
-0.0961296335,
-0.0066616694,
-0.0107289413,
0.0014373489,
0.043760784,
0.0007016742,
-0.0002847399,
-0.0014778392,
-0.028381547,
-0.0604693294,
-0.0172326528,
-0.0130524281,
0.015412705,
0.0055746855,
0.0066184383,
-0.0409358703,
0.0008883157,
0.0008376617,
0.0443790294,
0.027282903,
-0.0175876077,
-0.0320096053,
0.0281425398,
-0.0501275435,
0.0099926461,
-0.0251589585,
-0.0150023475,
-0.0185189545,
-0.0112768123,
-0.012951619,
0.0117689883,
0.0372467078,
0.0062220395,
0.0431972407,
0.0853625238,
-0.0549731404,
-0.0077915564,
-0.0393358022,
0.1043254733,
0.0195348915,
-0.0432735048,
0.0123518035,
0.0257478077,
0.0235527325,
-0.0362082347,
-0.0496640205,
0.0019932578,
-0.0147919599,
-0.0196471512,
-0.0746104494,
-0.0165786706,
0.0118823415,
0.003218615,
-0.0153310625,
-0.0480844192,
0.0606825687,
-0.0030875076,
-0.0019852819,
-0.1157353148,
-0.0298573468,
-0.0328013711,
0.0288490988,
0.0177716836,
0.0334373899,
-0.0552971289,
0.0531912185,
0.0096423486,
0.0357453264,
0.018563088,
-0.0419409685,
0.0354786851,
-0.0111762369,
0.0151490979,
0.0316058099,
-0.0281365719,
-0.0531877875,
-0.0748433843,
0.0062846853,
-0.0264254734,
0.0354234353,
-0.0027277977,
0.0038220626,
-0.0114089502,
-0.0106759826,
0.053549882,
0.0023331423,
-0.0487896279,
0.0088122869,
0.0310528744,
0.0299698748,
-0.045014184,
-0.0007105509,
0.0220764615,
0.0317342244,
0.0388785042,
0.0219259225,
-0.0301257167,
-0.0318406858,
-0.0019890922,
0.0134191671,
-0.0108794114,
-0.0051208106,
-0.0262333862,
0.0006461361,
0.0137200337,
-0.0170855951,
0.07183595,
0.0707964152,
-0.0288173556,
0.0087762689,
-0.046848584,
0.0739595741,
0.0548125058,
0.0116995303,
-0.0638459995,
-0.0227204319,
-0.010458881,
0.0455902405,
-0.0164716411,
-0.0177187845,
-0.0042565009,
-0.1175731793,
0.0328086615,
-0.0238337778,
-0.0278351475,
-0.0244242493,
-0.0340671204,
0.007924119,
-0.0223893244,
-0.0574807227,
-0.0270995628,
-0.0058996747,
0.0348605029,
0.0293903127,
-0.0269520506,
-0.0643465742,
-0.0093084555,
0.0106306281,
0.0360394716,
0.0059349099,
0.0686591864,
0.0098265447,
-0.0357309319,
-0.0027957372,
-0.0335809663,
0.024337057,
-0.0236751307,
0.0510508604,
-0.0014164626,
0.0156614091,
-0.02833727,
0.0288733039,
-0.0047391453,
-0.0140869711,
-0.0148575157,
0.0352281667,
-0.0376510583,
0.0056209937,
-0.0394824818,
0.0131002059,
0.0203773994,
0.0827759653,
0.0130236791,
-0.0393844843,
0.0152318934,
-0.019156944,
0.0458916537,
-0.0850998908,
0.0089545147,
0.0235321429,
-0.0286925659,
-0.0160528217,
-0.0918981358,
-0.0494106337,
0.0070930175,
0.0095862094,
-0.021183541,
0.0300134998,
-0.0387148745,
-0.0434082188,
-0.0270605963,
0.0125611676,
0.029189568,
0.0198700968,
0.0560408011,
-0.0527567491,
0.019620521,
-0.0957308039,
-0.0557697602,
-0.0258479435,
-0.0360486433,
-0.0382898003,
0.0127230287,
0.005069897,
0.0201428253,
0.0550139621,
-0.0169339236,
-0.0074624619,
-0.0024773902,
0.0785545036,
0.012152533,
-0.0024217791,
0.0364244021,
0.0409305543,
0.0171259064,
0.0151054142,
-0.0242537912,
0.034279447,
-0.0107104182,
0.0148690399,
-0.0390681289,
-0.0399977304,
0.0324009769,
0.0356847309,
0.0095908204,
-0.0134819699,
-0.0424636267,
-0.0750241503,
0.0102812331,
-0.0108543932,
-0.0114374878,
-0.0372315086,
0.0136262188,
0.0301271547,
-0.0004456245,
-0.0405206569,
0.0659796,
-0.0177148618,
0.0385158248,
-0.0482722595,
-0.0004486097,
-0.0278293919,
0.0185766201,
-0.0193786342,
-0.001723866,
-0.0246605277,
-0.0018926354,
0.0220296159,
0.0203885213,
-0.050365448,
0.0246032458,
0.0458890311,
0.0129977819,
-0.013248411,
0.0533865765,
-0.0736625418,
0.0081700273,
-0.0559268855,
0.0021382757,
0.0236805398,
-0.0233361349,
0.0716147423,
-0.0288568884,
-0.0119785033,
0.0115166074,
0.0072060004,
0.028578179,
-0.0326916575,
-0.0254956149,
-0.0031882781,
-0.0164642353,
0.0230042972,
0.0694787353,
-0.0694358125,
0.0381014422,
0.0045531434,
-0.0454381071,
-0.0499840975,
0.0101156393,
0.0244634431,
0.0623316169,
0.0312867761,
-0.0302007254,
-0.0429670773,
-0.0414912999,
0.0469007418,
-0.0267773159,
-0.0002081657,
-0.0148700606,
0.0535171814,
0.0281258635,
-0.0129564265,
0.057096485,
-0.0495078564,
-0.0179964043,
-0.0202677511,
-0.0113994619,
-0.0251745563,
-6.392516073e-33,
0.0220526867,
-0.0208478943,
-0.0320501253,
-0.0325622149,
-0.0055744229,
0.0049539809,
0.0072764833,
-0.0374956913,
0.0080461754,
0.0273478087,
0.0167049114,
0.0277903751,
0.0057755336,
0.0215655863,
-0.020334376,
-0.0019448089,
0.0136712203,
0.0117910923,
0.0070483331,
0.0236498974,
0.0542693362,
0.0097199837,
0.0236386526,
-0.078035146,
0.0281478148,
-0.022396354,
-0.0257082637,
-0.0156435482,
-0.0007139833,
0.0717379227,
-0.0073520266,
0.0632773489,
0.0467637181,
-0.0468750037,
0.0081319055,
0.0024308863,
-0.0348929763,
-0.0777223259,
-0.0012335667,
-0.060306944,
-0.0343939252,
0.019072514,
0.0258087888,
-0.0090747066,
-0.0061223032,
-0.0123433238,
0.0585278459,
-0.0385250337,
-0.0033808805,
-0.0908730626,
-0.025412444,
0.0375099964,
-0.0357378162,
0.0165492445,
-0.0053494568,
0.1056561321,
0.0145416381,
0.0813064948,
-0.0852430165,
0.0376523621,
-0.0428211913,
0.012864829,
0.0242438652,
-0.0220177863,
-0.0098707257,
0.0719262436,
0.0135904448,
-0.0131695578,
-0.0183507856,
0.0158401988,
-0.0229907036,
-0.0002579827,
0.0420273207,
0.0829578638,
0.0550666116,
-0.0316033289,
-0.0491105206,
0.1052983329,
0.0193061344,
-0.0750202015,
0.0144558297,
0.0017929352,
-0.0715504959,
-0.0186097119,
-0.0236970149,
0.0116371643,
-0.042022679,
0.0115397684,
0.0340203904,
0.0227155406,
-0.0459595285,
0.0256494824,
-0.01600633,
-0.0269081779,
0.0028620551,
0.005925104,
-0.045981165,
0.0227871183,
0.0414640084,
-0.0144755011,
-0.0342925601,
-0.014325479,
0.0425360911,
0.0185860191,
0.0064183539,
-0.020467924,
0.0692334026,
-0.0265223049,
-0.0402727649,
0.0228645075,
0.0104669519,
0.02512642,
-0.0416316763,
0.0115526915,
-0.010522482,
0.0201773755,
-0.0082365889,
0.0941890776,
0.0677402243,
0.0714501217,
-0.0270017572,
-0.0383905359,
-0.0237587895,
-0.0107662678,
-0.0160653479,
0.0081321001,
0.0106614241,
-0.011334301,
0.0282800272,
-0.0637956858,
-0.0331971832,
0.0002786401,
2.758e-7,
0.0680567026,
0.0318801701,
-0.0027783143,
-0.0165616777,
0.0013843864,
0.0488673635,
0.0060074646,
0.0522012413,
0.0039407457,
-0.0023893144,
0.0183095895,
0.0068055992,
0.0195295196,
0.026977621,
-0.0294500217,
0.0140130445,
-0.0667963699,
-0.0544518568,
-0.0398221537,
0.0051302607,
0.1057539582,
0.0871614367,
0.0052380473,
-0.0120929759,
0.021274101,
-0.0121374996,
0.0189272501,
-0.0037656799,
0.011489653,
0.0195606612,
0.0719523206,
-0.0308946632,
-0.0069492008,
0.011583182,
-0.0454212204,
0.0086620357,
0.0430437252,
0.0025272004,
-0.0276688673,
0.0060114488,
0.0130726211,
0.0017642134,
-0.0018406409,
-0.0876995176,
0.0736417472,
-0.0113485977,
0.0057780351,
-0.008612182,
-0.0284017101,
0.0471717715,
0.0340148844,
0.0015128356,
-0.0270691831,
0.0120979063,
0.00974108,
0.0091358023,
-0.0580102988,
-0.066623047,
-0.0192468818,
-0.0269289613,
-0.0312881619,
-0.0231876168,
-0.0208476987,
0.0535374917,
0.0419696867,
-0.0811195374,
0.0033214141,
2.731375e-34,
0.05233749,
0.0182655267,
-0.0075189169,
-0.0494336486,
0.0325969085,
-0.0185694043,
-0.0004251345,
0.0187459029,
0.0164082926,
-0.0743668228,
-0.0016014205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04534v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04534v2 | Loss Masking Is Not Needed in Decoder-only Transformer for Discrete-token-based ASR | 2023-11-08T08:45:14 | 2024-02-05T02:42:57 | Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Siqi Zheng, Shiliang Zhang, Chong Deng, Yukun Ma, Hai Yu, Jiaqing Liu, Chong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, unified speech-text models, such as SpeechGPT, VioLA, and
AudioPaLM, have achieved remarkable performance on various speech tasks. These
models discretize speech signals into tokens (speech discretization) and use a
shared vocabulary for both text and speech tokens. Then they train a single
decoder-only Transformer on a mixture of speech tasks. However, these models
rely on the Loss Masking strategy for the ASR task, which ignores the
dependency among speech tokens. In this paper, we propose to model speech
tokens in an autoregressive way, similar to text. We find that applying the
conventional cross-entropy loss on input speech tokens does not consistently
improve the ASR performance over the Loss Masking approach. To address this
issue, we propose a novel approach denoted Smoothed Label Distillation (SLD),
which applies a KL divergence loss with smoothed labels on speech tokens. Our
experiments show that SLD effectively models speech tokens and outperforms Loss
Masking for decoder-only Transformers in ASR tasks with different speech
discretization methods. The source code can be found here:
https://github.com/alibaba-damo-academy/SpokenNLP/tree/main/sld | [
-0.0403918549,
0.0241346192,
0.0184027106,
0.0137547953,
-0.0028865742,
-0.0000829538,
0.0463786088,
0.0084290197,
-0.0640652105,
0.0087763323,
-0.01379319,
0.0147993797,
0.0276928637,
0.0189426057,
0.0157771166,
-0.0611037239,
0.0055183088,
-0.059896566,
0.0127947545,
-0.0302644279,
0.0101050697,
-0.0045726602,
-0.0376669057,
0.034343157,
-0.0513832122,
0.0050512245,
-0.0030411805,
0.0150263291,
0.0526655391,
-0.0146637093,
0.0182610322,
-0.0218921304,
0.0442146212,
-0.0027244014,
0.0000020336,
0.0079432232,
0.0074554887,
0.0131166512,
-0.0812384859,
-0.0078288121,
0.0105281211,
-0.0004080447,
0.0028985103,
0.0464674793,
0.0220955536,
-0.0605387986,
0.0320442133,
0.0758507326,
0.0358399823,
0.0306843445,
0.0078548687,
-0.0820726603,
0.0083666509,
-0.0255016815,
-0.0356537327,
-0.0300844237,
-0.0072370968,
-0.0271321405,
-0.0478710122,
-0.0181443635,
-0.0315598026,
0.0783069134,
0.0154556027,
-0.0066355499,
0.0459518172,
0.0279465802,
-0.0057129106,
-0.0537445918,
-0.0363212191,
0.0067527234,
-0.0116452668,
-0.0285549592,
0.0502542928,
0.0088800425,
-0.0272554923,
-0.0511328578,
-0.0200554449,
0.0117345368,
0.0192640312,
0.0230657812,
-0.0137502747,
0.0201484375,
0.0214351323,
-0.0205061585,
-0.0382549688,
0.0285011381,
-0.0067757699,
-0.0271829665,
0.0204745326,
-0.0251550991,
-0.0207695849,
-0.0211708937,
0.0579734445,
-0.0081860879,
-0.0132391825,
-0.0049967756,
-0.0436441824,
-0.0691797957,
-0.0260353982,
0.0398555472,
-0.0057487777,
0.0398715474,
-0.0391775332,
-0.0044843541,
-0.0109329764,
0.0956419408,
0.0334649719,
0.0671926588,
-0.0255037434,
-0.0168352127,
-0.0221583433,
-0.012381155,
-0.0752765387,
0.0692710131,
-0.0295932684,
-0.022519473,
-0.0191145372,
-0.0129733253,
-0.036042314,
-0.0326345488,
0.0907102823,
0.0030715617,
-0.0754624158,
-0.0268030409,
0.0262783635,
0.050824251,
0.0103584584,
0.0064233225,
0.0439468026,
-0.041002851,
-0.0276605505,
-0.0106034009,
0.0289167464,
0.0001828944,
-0.0090642311,
0.04880777,
-0.0090668155,
0.0065384251,
-0.0400111638,
-0.002718596,
-0.0291015618,
-0.0299888607,
-0.0077498355,
-0.0479295217,
0.0452687331,
0.0114834756,
0.0202273261,
-0.0227994621,
-0.0074273185,
0.0006373778,
0.0757863596,
0.0430460349,
0.0032099122,
0.0131497514,
0.0589889959,
0.0010126262,
-0.0120655112,
0.0688028112,
0.0359613709,
0.0073135816,
-0.0107956892,
-0.0293632448,
-0.0363049656,
0.0340813883,
0.0154545549,
-0.0130548775,
-0.0490428582,
-0.0504021347,
0.0074906237,
0.0104272887,
0.067777209,
0.0630496144,
-0.0562416017,
-0.0121584767,
0.0366799571,
0.0300664976,
0.0630497634,
0.0171517022,
0.0222968888,
0.0116524342,
-0.0079806736,
0.0174860712,
0.0137730734,
-0.0085459817,
0.0734897032,
-0.0050456445,
0.0388679393,
0.0300559644,
-0.0183332041,
-0.0424345173,
0.0219630096,
-0.0278053805,
0.0034376704,
0.0074793189,
0.0488518178,
0.042231217,
-0.0327495895,
0.081355229,
-0.0097523313,
-0.0402726978,
0.0479174294,
-0.0471111201,
-0.0344822668,
-0.0136890244,
0.0099114059,
-0.0270022061,
0.0022336964,
-0.0470581464,
0.0150400475,
0.0032857729,
-0.0285427719,
0.009848563,
0.0609111413,
-0.045259513,
-0.0373387262,
0.0218596607,
-0.0049871132,
0.027714964,
-0.0268351492,
0.0304690562,
0.0133570209,
-0.0625018403,
0.0566436872,
0.0029684913,
0.0228673927,
-0.0490181409,
0.0410055034,
0.0054318733,
0.0569826365,
0.0402914584,
-0.0125420373,
0.008583799,
0.0350354575,
-0.0663619787,
-0.0253445096,
0.004325151,
-0.0884657949,
-0.0560414307,
0.0564893968,
-0.0318624154,
0.0309390444,
0.0756134167,
-0.0247808415,
-0.0578766018,
0.0131956562,
-0.0423321053,
0.0630416349,
-0.0148682231,
0.0393191278,
0.0614289232,
0.0059926286,
0.0161685273,
-0.0062481384,
-0.0005018145,
0.0039060521,
-0.0319585986,
0.0167287365,
-0.0064683137,
-0.0451666303,
-0.0139911054,
0.0483892485,
-0.0482424013,
0.001092654,
0.0274718851,
-0.0469158366,
0.0015498758,
-0.0059584361,
-0.0487991497,
-0.0231081899,
-0.0440979786,
0.0233699698,
-0.0164879598,
0.0450836644,
0.0290794075,
-0.0056288955,
-0.0067947139,
-0.0440109633,
-0.0190660581,
-0.0128915347,
-0.0498742908,
0.0174593795,
-0.0352336466,
0.0350674801,
-0.0182050411,
0.0320334658,
0.0098943543,
-0.0622513108,
-0.0475373156,
-0.0428903475,
0.0005971927,
0.0331997201,
0.0176194645,
-0.0089531355,
-0.012055479,
-0.0044825859,
0.0241338853,
0.0483392701,
0.0297798514,
0.0255012233,
0.0198521651,
-0.0318982527,
-0.0258430447,
-0.0495511778,
0.0269970112,
-0.008855056,
0.0337599069,
-0.0178888589,
0.0002599229,
0.0027696691,
0.0568118095,
0.0273189247,
0.0367774628,
-0.0463158377,
-0.065837875,
-0.0275592394,
-0.0679493099,
-0.0216385182,
-0.0097004855,
-0.0600284897,
-0.0268161036,
-0.011969422,
-0.0044356524,
0.0089023691,
-0.0567903928,
-0.0524052382,
-0.0306700785,
-0.0542931184,
-0.0182696003,
-0.0019084762,
0.0009835295,
0.0155645041,
0.0007276589,
-0.0472722687,
-0.0208196733,
0.0173876993,
-0.0111652166,
-0.0487421826,
0.0372842327,
-0.0199052244,
-0.0102156121,
-0.0005716379,
-0.0125630181,
-0.0111561771,
0.030057814,
0.0051795589,
0.0547449999,
0.0093835564,
-0.0033120739,
-0.0419950485,
0.0234454703,
0.0140273925,
0.0616352968,
0.0015312259,
0.0123591358,
-0.0272722971,
0.0455350205,
0.0444430485,
-0.01002545,
-0.0278644953,
-0.0319900848,
0.0326936506,
0.0044426387,
0.0951620042,
0.0125544909,
-0.0264691338,
-0.030372439,
0.0357571691,
0.0012865728,
-0.006927168,
0.0162292775,
0.0281219576,
-0.0552762002,
0.0066680443,
0.0602070689,
-0.0145852407,
-0.0074855592,
-0.0024430689,
0.0087903012,
0.0655359998,
-0.0071253604,
-0.0601009466,
-0.0677922443,
-0.0345135294,
0.0601424128,
0.0424196348,
0.0320213549,
0.0163305439,
-0.0066358745,
-0.0380128361,
0.0311411712,
0.0203694999,
-0.041030582,
-0.0339112096,
-0.0532425717,
-0.0425476097,
-0.0314835757,
0.0922929868,
-0.0116443615,
-0.0214443523,
-0.0220746379,
0.0779849589,
-0.064215295,
-0.0448057763,
-0.0429944247,
-0.0406852625,
0.0702700242,
0.0519572757,
0.0220086742,
0.0000971653,
-0.0668460205,
0.0384349413,
-0.0092926128,
-0.0017541473,
-0.0116386926,
0.0081919869,
-0.0045029842,
0.0071339807,
0.0492415614,
0.0080573931,
-0.0100368327,
-0.0045243851,
0.022549063,
0.0294807181,
-0.0018757042,
-0.0376712829,
0.0119049717,
-0.0293738395,
-0.0102808792,
0.0509198643,
0.0161886737,
0.0114699947,
-0.0693228915,
-0.0023100015,
0.0911756679,
-0.0169336665,
-0.0002645197,
-0.0047576865,
-0.0567457005,
-0.1135528535,
-0.0089664133,
0.0473374873,
0.010194039,
0.02596974,
-0.0089264503,
0.0114426976,
-0.0255763605,
0.0157128423,
-0.0441757739,
-0.0262691285,
-0.0271392185,
0.0399479233,
-0.0734113902,
-0.0207510218,
0.0189544503,
-0.0280183926,
-0.0171102658,
0.03100425,
-0.1069722995,
-0.0527944639,
0.0557799228,
-0.0174474511,
0.0109575884,
0.051135771,
-0.0049526724,
-0.0380861834,
0.1079107001,
0.0424860381,
-0.0327162631,
0.0369017944,
0.0554810502,
-0.0144994073,
0.0038874473,
0.0114226015,
-0.0565159284,
0.0254320838,
-0.0337301604,
0.0391524956,
-0.0047798473,
-0.0047997604,
0.0131173003,
0.0275981799,
0.0673882738,
-0.0140225673,
-0.0103735477,
0.0017238827,
0.0578122884,
0.0201504398,
0.0448807515,
-0.0412445925,
0.0029852185,
0.0113063585,
0.024578061,
-0.0010713275,
0.0515632853,
0.0100729689,
-0.0173109677,
0.0241739247,
0.0532082096,
0.0001308187,
0.0139941992,
0.0240880176,
0.0130203981,
0.0072617959,
-0.0352352224,
0.0702450797,
0.0052029397,
-0.0081921993,
0.0079355827,
0.0191740189,
0.0255732071,
0.030493265,
0.0295536108,
-0.0323776938,
-0.0358842798,
-0.0164038725,
-0.0064352076,
-0.0326087736,
0.0300216489,
0.0289146639,
-0.0112060541,
0.00548155,
-0.0297649615,
0.0025980147,
-0.0199784357,
0.0277027842,
0.0442557558,
-0.0045365337,
0.0018877683,
0.0012791612,
0.0519124456,
0.0345645398,
0.0360514224,
-0.0338285789,
0.0454355963,
-0.0301425699,
-0.0341738202,
-0.0525902286,
0.0155449715,
0.0131577607,
-0.0477132052,
0.0225520693,
-0.0677877665,
0.0266577601,
-0.059009552,
0.0367566384,
-0.034803763,
0.0246177111,
-0.0269718282,
-0.0481054708,
-0.028091833,
0.0224257372,
-0.0352760032,
0.0346454903,
-0.0161070488,
0.0144470418,
-6.425520281e-33,
-0.0269459318,
0.0396221392,
-0.0015627433,
0.014133431,
-0.0801785737,
0.0238624327,
-0.0207095984,
-0.0142350942,
0.029017536,
0.0143454885,
0.0071176137,
0.0102015417,
0.0530571379,
0.0273186415,
-0.0282564834,
-0.0283778235,
0.1390857399,
-0.0304087829,
0.0029077365,
0.0030927251,
0.0111599499,
0.0363915116,
0.0054532695,
-0.042916663,
-0.0400045998,
0.012183737,
-0.0102832867,
-0.0161207169,
0.0522347204,
0.0187650248,
-0.0015467275,
0.0439372584,
-0.0063660908,
-0.0736253038,
-0.041946087,
0.0366774909,
-0.106390506,
0.0104362797,
-0.0076169386,
0.0568014346,
-0.0033657146,
-0.0389425904,
0.0486808233,
0.0298589505,
-0.0330419987,
-0.021241108,
0.0178465527,
0.0111367004,
-0.0316070355,
-0.0694275126,
0.0368852392,
0.0212553516,
-0.0164248087,
-0.0328524485,
0.0953276008,
0.0084900316,
-0.0087154638,
0.0039667315,
-0.0728194267,
0.0171456058,
0.0172013473,
0.0613194853,
0.036530029,
0.0483601317,
0.0051713195,
0.0119762821,
0.07215783,
-0.0589290597,
0.0021138757,
-0.0524813831,
0.0244601592,
0.0566377006,
-0.0062276977,
-0.0340965912,
0.077531822,
-0.0469878018,
-0.0133082047,
-0.0229582191,
-0.0447836444,
0.0419105515,
0.0089751203,
0.0764450952,
0.0055882861,
-0.0049966997,
-0.0494734347,
-0.0125611611,
-0.0083063487,
0.0175801441,
0.0622243099,
0.0411783606,
-0.0088039152,
-0.001476186,
0.0410614423,
-0.0181226842,
-0.009715518,
0.0135505712,
0.0234343205,
0.003271112,
-0.0164619237,
-0.0182551239,
-0.0533544458,
-0.0251011979,
0.0553459376,
0.0298309438,
0.0134613309,
-0.051099956,
-0.0107173482,
0.0674238354,
-0.068289578,
-0.0141719598,
-0.0318107419,
0.0353416353,
0.0132824974,
0.0177219342,
0.0476057827,
-0.0101894028,
-0.0110981483,
0.0097704967,
-0.0072734859,
-0.001279214,
-0.0024069236,
0.0478384718,
0.0282468777,
0.0194004625,
-0.0384951793,
0.0029998561,
0.0122606959,
-0.0248313099,
0.0519917235,
-0.0041583017,
-0.0315768048,
-0.0046748412,
2.829e-7,
-0.0491489433,
0.0024618958,
0.0542430244,
-0.0620012693,
0.0217497293,
0.020470079,
0.0022217575,
0.0033762231,
0.0172958318,
-0.0275687464,
-0.0204378664,
-0.0142376861,
0.061871212,
0.0129477214,
-0.1130365878,
0.0043808105,
-0.0455859639,
0.0036013485,
0.0131338751,
0.0077744056,
-0.0246933494,
0.0513523109,
-0.0023325116,
-0.0319666974,
0.0196345504,
0.0337607972,
0.0018317763,
0.0012221761,
0.0658079609,
-0.0059480118,
0.0020724642,
-0.0287155565,
-0.0038945198,
0.0259022117,
-0.0443810485,
-0.0057669599,
0.042678725,
0.0425857902,
-0.0263752136,
-0.0707360134,
0.0083746938,
0.0569252111,
-0.0229978506,
-0.0077896421,
0.035877496,
-0.0029266465,
0.0140833836,
-0.0315501913,
-0.0951062143,
0.0183723383,
0.001664898,
0.0153051959,
-0.0058224001,
0.0121519947,
-0.0008775636,
0.0364853181,
-0.0282249302,
-0.0573677085,
-0.0032700661,
0.0045282561,
-0.0836711228,
-0.0263250675,
-0.0516231209,
0.0284197573,
-0.0311180614,
-0.0066222595,
-0.0164283123,
2.15720731e-34,
0.013092665,
-0.028157426,
-0.00250659,
0.0327773541,
-0.0035728074,
-0.0491599031,
-0.0169424172,
0.0505714417,
-0.0437771119,
-0.0188672449,
-0.0366128385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04507v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04507v3 | Conversation Understanding using Relational Temporal Graph Neural Networks with Auxiliary Cross-Modality Interaction | 2023-11-08T07:46:25 | 2024-01-30T08:01:42 | Cam-Van Thi Nguyen, Anh-Tuan Mai, The-Son Le, Hai-Dang Kieu, Duc-Trong Le | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Emotion recognition is a crucial task for human conversation understanding.
It becomes more challenging with the notion of multimodal data, e.g., language,
voice, and facial expressions. As a typical solution, the global- and the local
context information are exploited to predict the emotional label for every
single sentence, i.e., utterance, in the dialogue. Specifically, the global
representation could be captured via modeling of cross-modal interactions at
the conversation level. The local one is often inferred using the temporal
information of speakers or emotional shifts, which neglects vital factors at
the utterance level. Additionally, most existing approaches take fused features
of multiple modalities in an unified input without leveraging modality-specific
representations. Motivating from these problems, we propose the Relational
Temporal Graph Neural Network with Auxiliary Cross-Modality Interaction
(CORECT), an novel neural network framework that effectively captures
conversation-level cross-modality interactions and utterance-level temporal
dependencies with the modality-specific manner for conversation understanding.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of CORECT via its
state-of-the-art results on the IEMOCAP and CMU-MOSEI datasets for the
multimodal ERC task. | [
0.0249408986,
0.0566611812,
-0.0032032523,
0.0364502333,
-0.0174357072,
0.0132080698,
0.0262966808,
-0.0098935468,
0.0193887129,
-0.028812496,
-0.0398825407,
-0.0590469167,
0.0301298518,
0.0427417234,
-0.0065278937,
-0.048711516,
0.0202838741,
0.017188916,
0.0081216889,
0.0165440217,
0.0114312591,
0.0247233212,
-0.0533800721,
0.0248247515,
-0.0561661087,
-0.0293626226,
-0.0629978701,
0.0458708704,
0.0162492692,
-0.0317219831,
-0.0056287297,
0.0272576567,
0.037446402,
0.0189048648,
0.0000018603,
0.0267822798,
-0.0049619819,
-0.0271056257,
-0.0293793138,
-0.0230161361,
0.0315230228,
0.0119459061,
-0.010571355,
-0.0349076018,
-0.0357282124,
-0.0233940631,
0.0337608829,
0.0752214119,
0.0747585371,
0.0862453952,
-0.0376975425,
0.0101018744,
0.0009279396,
-0.0148538789,
0.0351181254,
-0.0349222757,
0.0032260241,
0.0213417597,
0.0179478507,
-0.0265924986,
-0.0559727438,
-0.0047947797,
0.013472857,
-0.0248661637,
0.037192151,
0.0278301351,
-0.0012812195,
-0.027724551,
-0.0268260874,
0.145799011,
0.0362218954,
0.0113254534,
0.0088944286,
0.0325675905,
0.0018418321,
-0.0279148519,
-0.029861642,
-0.0304378252,
0.0138074132,
0.0080330307,
-0.0502700768,
0.0123719871,
0.0035831211,
-0.0123237427,
0.0053545577,
0.0493258536,
-0.0487363189,
0.0075649587,
0.018014051,
-0.0300458297,
0.0077629872,
-0.0284864474,
-0.000666746,
0.0075796209,
-0.0172214769,
-0.0015700455,
-0.023732679,
0.0294272918,
-0.0429756045,
-0.0217121765,
-0.0247312989,
0.0344529487,
-0.0234489534,
0.0389440991,
0.0244087819,
0.0392460264,
-0.0236386526,
-0.0151029769,
-0.0108430525,
-0.0103587713,
-0.0641680062,
-0.0008636204,
0.0050930064,
0.0089377267,
-0.0467205271,
-0.0570205599,
-0.0848122612,
0.0149982721,
-0.0221463945,
0.0033937744,
0.0308371,
0.05135772,
-0.0191526301,
0.0093497746,
0.0308001488,
0.0726841018,
0.025639493,
0.0424205549,
-0.0250412859,
-0.0588160083,
-0.0105534177,
0.0296493806,
0.0308496654,
-0.0089901118,
-0.0170625206,
0.0731466636,
-0.000037632,
-0.0323302075,
-0.0277565308,
-0.044642996,
-0.0550195239,
-0.0363822468,
0.0372254476,
0.0153385494,
0.0467763245,
-0.0227557216,
0.009117485,
0.005198455,
0.0122758821,
-0.0796994492,
-0.0275340546,
0.0697893947,
0.0458645076,
-0.0014170273,
0.0037823941,
0.0079937428,
0.024493333,
0.0239833202,
0.0376474299,
0.0139642293,
0.0096254563,
-0.0023334161,
-0.0229246039,
0.0258257706,
0.0195880737,
-0.0375204235,
-0.0528386906,
-0.0279235393,
-0.0054493863,
0.0595811456,
0.0593211912,
0.0116000967,
-0.0354897603,
-0.0570181459,
0.0524174683,
0.0045615253,
-0.0211813282,
0.0210624412,
0.0093891351,
0.0372177549,
-0.0053230673,
-0.0082539655,
-0.0524343103,
0.0484336838,
-0.0137468362,
-0.0336395688,
-0.0115470765,
-0.0380353928,
-0.0390756428,
-0.0135551794,
0.024355568,
-0.012408047,
0.0255162604,
0.0072509642,
0.0370300636,
-0.0283896327,
-0.0386241376,
0.0379979052,
0.004200974,
-0.010139457,
-0.0337725319,
-0.0001728042,
-0.0189295206,
0.0442532115,
-0.0152807338,
-0.0122035462,
-0.059340138,
-0.0260451566,
0.014832845,
0.0064767092,
0.0355646387,
-0.0163247809,
0.0896819532,
-0.0445427261,
-0.014242026,
-0.020476561,
-0.0186130274,
0.0485577248,
-0.0288738944,
0.0005538107,
-0.0063192896,
-0.037386477,
0.0682676435,
-0.0185411908,
-0.001873614,
0.0153960157,
0.002656634,
0.027411256,
0.016886415,
0.0251975097,
-0.0292041562,
-0.0285387076,
0.0069204895,
0.0071720271,
0.0138565619,
0.0685382262,
-0.0613346174,
-0.0692811906,
0.0507888347,
-0.0147009064,
-0.0481290482,
0.0059527964,
-0.0476460904,
-0.0467456989,
0.0688718185,
-0.0365251563,
0.0625685081,
-0.031884186,
-0.0034073053,
0.0220723934,
0.0547313131,
0.0426673405,
-0.0013088426,
-0.0256233215,
-0.0272067375,
0.017805852,
-0.006975418,
-0.0013667461,
-0.0522872172,
-0.0352756418,
0.0240598917,
0.0356497578,
-0.0434642024,
-0.0485513806,
0.0011992495,
-0.0644121468,
-0.0250188224,
-0.1351903975,
-0.0199231021,
0.0170887467,
-0.0279911123,
-0.0114925001,
0.0265692286,
-0.0168225244,
-0.0498694442,
-0.0223066229,
0.0332621485,
0.013517987,
-0.007477812,
0.0133405505,
0.0170356687,
-0.0141359009,
-0.0243348163,
-0.0085461885,
-0.0299092215,
0.0870954767,
-0.0082675824,
-0.0572488271,
0.0101229073,
-0.0019159458,
-0.0238158181,
0.0638145357,
-0.0259078369,
-0.0297195613,
-0.0347146466,
-0.0070838705,
0.032921385,
0.0558792688,
0.0042586457,
0.0686292127,
-0.0203343965,
-0.0845296532,
-0.0406138599,
0.0393359102,
0.0125236427,
0.0414568484,
-0.0418153405,
-0.0308356881,
-0.0828530192,
0.0587636977,
0.0135716153,
0.0352313742,
-0.0324728265,
-0.0477956124,
0.0088403169,
-0.0590390489,
-0.017480839,
-0.0153684961,
-0.0070576132,
-0.0408586524,
-0.0358899534,
-0.014889922,
0.0601769425,
0.0104320785,
-0.0533912592,
0.0125636654,
-0.0324622989,
-0.033499565,
0.0778891072,
-0.0204178113,
-0.0075983717,
0.0245252587,
-0.0421494544,
-0.0521967411,
-0.0444931686,
-0.0052148802,
-0.0190884937,
0.0056726765,
-0.0151310954,
0.0004609488,
0.0332581028,
-0.0031486473,
0.0008031866,
-0.0515048094,
-0.0180804133,
-0.0077960631,
-0.0402890518,
-0.0055981097,
-0.0011487304,
0.0102671208,
0.0037990599,
-0.0448935516,
-0.0408296809,
0.0039624828,
0.0159800593,
0.0884477124,
0.0340085588,
0.0399351493,
-0.0068595102,
-0.023358997,
0.0422456153,
0.0306974277,
0.0648284703,
-0.0076469025,
-0.0593138561,
0.0626387522,
-0.0370243303,
0.0557029136,
-0.0402781256,
-0.0349995829,
0.0174735114,
-0.0339347124,
0.025978718,
0.0734921172,
0.0122935949,
-0.0762496889,
-0.0122155696,
0.008356805,
-0.0172355045,
-0.0036009282,
0.014022016,
-0.0419514589,
-0.0376708806,
-0.0072944192,
-0.0179680903,
0.0177468825,
-0.0593054146,
-0.0135700507,
-0.0524278618,
0.0015858082,
0.0080587296,
-0.0192250106,
-0.0069800275,
0.0097910706,
0.0336920246,
0.003825529,
0.0135781365,
-0.0442827418,
0.0191350672,
-0.0418030918,
0.0264889374,
-0.0026444027,
-0.0377992503,
0.0583502948,
0.0215417948,
0.0349316709,
-0.0299207103,
0.0887345672,
0.0050485847,
-0.000862317,
0.0700843781,
0.0313837677,
-0.0016405749,
-0.0132347522,
0.0515897796,
-0.0332116783,
-0.0182721876,
0.0111332415,
0.0183376633,
0.0152324447,
0.0009798803,
-0.0567029677,
0.0614006482,
-0.0528921448,
0.0094113462,
0.0079081291,
0.0292785987,
0.0494011939,
0.0081049129,
0.018452663,
-0.0408070385,
-0.056445282,
0.0014896224,
0.0253342334,
-0.0412689261,
0.0011627618,
0.0174716488,
0.0279965606,
-0.0121651515,
0.0071089715,
-0.0529452004,
-0.025581345,
-0.0096459156,
-0.0283852126,
-0.0553513207,
0.0265071057,
0.0155319711,
-0.0446988307,
0.0586128905,
0.0060082292,
0.0255071055,
0.0133491606,
0.0006924284,
0.037717469,
-0.0158917177,
0.0040468066,
0.016858045,
-0.0544695966,
-0.057525292,
-0.0168593563,
-0.0120952176,
0.0120413713,
0.0755219981,
0.0352116972,
-0.0245530121,
0.018003609,
-0.0289200358,
-0.0222300682,
0.029814383,
0.0423569158,
0.0207678266,
-0.0262190886,
0.0304406844,
-0.0442792252,
0.0296084937,
-0.0090363715,
0.0293699391,
-0.017398091,
-0.0557064191,
-0.0147046521,
-0.036002405,
0.0349450409,
0.0461397059,
0.0210662968,
-0.0459443219,
0.004085653,
-0.0064313873,
0.0304752402,
-0.0612865575,
-0.0155597916,
-0.0114677669,
-0.0104000419,
-0.0547895841,
-0.0295838676,
0.0042128265,
-0.0080622202,
-0.0056009321,
0.0298268627,
0.0215189774,
-0.0514620543,
0.0023842065,
0.014952708,
0.0034344338,
0.0227089133,
0.0211531911,
-0.0158603974,
-0.0012970908,
0.0872776583,
0.0239022374,
-0.0402294397,
-0.0089210691,
0.0326081328,
-0.040100608,
0.0504250713,
-0.0103973215,
0.0055748061,
0.0381394997,
-0.0208352096,
0.0196247734,
-0.0046409355,
0.0282150339,
0.0074004713,
0.0983808637,
-0.017348662,
-0.0427130535,
0.0639495105,
-0.0069886325,
-0.0144740995,
0.0705115125,
0.0304503851,
0.0022954189,
0.02372526,
0.0067955195,
-0.0097313263,
-0.0638459027,
-0.0042081736,
0.0593741275,
-0.0338822901,
-0.0050377185,
0.0188925155,
-0.0399951302,
-0.0598780364,
0.0579604991,
-0.013733346,
-0.0167282745,
0.0019246604,
0.0059539592,
0.0202722698,
0.0209037699,
0.0056268219,
-0.0260395501,
0.0261858851,
-0.0177478753,
-0.0090633938,
-0.0137735438,
-5.375850478e-33,
-0.0142031312,
-0.0245838892,
-0.033462055,
0.021311691,
-0.0675595552,
0.0714433342,
-0.0607960634,
-0.0061448514,
-0.0048580309,
0.0312125273,
-0.0096676415,
0.0824829862,
0.0242733695,
0.0141649051,
-0.0082812784,
-0.006003622,
0.0194611885,
-0.0291626994,
0.0508916378,
0.0524798371,
0.0315121636,
0.0638125762,
0.0569339246,
-0.0914922804,
0.0194944218,
0.0282243881,
-0.0001914181,
0.020406602,
0.0640518963,
0.0524292029,
-0.0265227444,
0.0392021611,
0.0226499848,
-0.0008330976,
-0.0007528372,
0.0211085733,
-0.0997128636,
0.0029713626,
-0.0315756276,
0.0329419188,
-0.058186397,
0.0009633799,
-0.0066082198,
0.024237968,
0.0546005964,
-0.0460287482,
0.0346260853,
0.0159844346,
0.0105664795,
-0.0384198092,
0.0192988478,
0.038467247,
-0.0470585674,
-0.0265662465,
0.0389531478,
0.0690891743,
0.0372687243,
-0.0240626484,
-0.0331839584,
0.0143818418,
-0.1002544835,
-0.0423630588,
0.0086549316,
0.0211722516,
0.0048065824,
0.0728113055,
0.0371906012,
-0.0234433729,
-0.012006538,
0.0076201307,
0.0098892907,
0.0287755392,
-0.0500198565,
0.0315261185,
-0.0402216315,
-0.0097303009,
-0.0496216379,
0.0190090481,
0.0495805368,
0.0326952301,
-0.0036013783,
-0.0094210189,
0.0131786652,
0.0229714159,
0.0277467333,
-0.0096445,
-0.0243512411,
-0.0025927783,
0.0198469367,
-0.0190848485,
0.0215361007,
0.018910436,
0.0527167208,
-0.059876021,
0.0005555081,
0.0692310929,
-0.0157173984,
0.0421550535,
0.0128641659,
0.0300515462,
-0.0019917216,
-0.0231364742,
0.0407492891,
-0.0163462013,
0.0728560761,
-0.0324186571,
-0.0047894157,
0.0381781273,
-0.0070746001,
-0.0385667197,
-0.0104323439,
0.027259415,
-0.0439507179,
0.0426650569,
0.0293067005,
0.0321299881,
-0.038541086,
0.0238568578,
-0.0119002871,
0.1067540124,
0.0057665422,
-0.0377588235,
0.053908255,
0.0704548061,
-0.0493307076,
-0.021512704,
0.0124423634,
-0.0285899993,
0.0122599881,
-0.0314200446,
-0.005812719,
0.0149695305,
2.654e-7,
-0.019067442,
0.0005064537,
0.072174266,
-0.0230477564,
0.0303274021,
0.0372614153,
-0.025626298,
0.0360499956,
0.0080960328,
-0.0564617403,
0.0785932243,
0.0305109993,
0.0566342101,
0.0172282942,
-0.0420479961,
-0.0296682063,
-0.023460038,
-0.0206588674,
-0.0323290415,
0.0269246325,
0.0729351044,
0.0680268258,
0.0359828845,
0.0099305464,
-0.0200616308,
-0.0035452056,
0.060779728,
-0.022565376,
-0.0222677812,
-0.0150109185,
-0.0016495266,
-0.0516214147,
-0.0547524057,
0.0158687942,
0.0140672969,
0.0168490373,
0.0094480477,
0.0362203829,
-0.0403930061,
-0.092944324,
-0.0136284446,
0.0348692164,
-0.0436757915,
0.0023012345,
0.0364990532,
-0.064098835,
-0.0428711511,
-0.0174936689,
-0.0261572339,
-0.0047522807,
0.0114460709,
0.027519213,
-0.0157913975,
0.0386770926,
0.01619168,
-0.0395836234,
-0.0306982603,
-0.1044715643,
-0.0021186233,
0.027840687,
-0.0725405514,
-0.0046143923,
-0.0026385968,
-0.0071792402,
0.0556464568,
-0.0038519807,
-0.0401711352,
1.732931221e-34,
0.0008492158,
-0.0120801618,
-0.0197404269,
0.0200260561,
0.0076499498,
-0.0274026245,
-0.023305079,
-0.0146088749,
0.0327035412,
-0.0639282241,
-0.0192083362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04498v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04498v4 | NExT-Chat: An LMM for Chat, Detection and Segmentation | 2023-11-08T07:15:05 | 2023-12-18T12:15:26 | Ao Zhang, Yuan Yao, Wei Ji, Zhiyuan Liu, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The development of large language models (LLMs) has greatly advanced the
field of multimodal understanding, leading to the emergence of large multimodal
models (LMMs). In order to enhance the level of visual comprehension, recent
studies have equipped LMMs with region-level understanding capabilities by
representing object bounding box coordinates as a series of text sequences
(pix2seq). In this paper, we introduce a novel paradigm for object location
modeling called pix2emb method, where we ask the LMM to output the location
embeddings and then decode them with different decoders. This paradigm allows
us to use different location formats (such as bounding boxes and masks) in
multimodal conversations. Leveraging the proposed pix2emb method, we train an
LMM named NExT-Chat and demonstrate its capability of handling multiple tasks
like visual grounding, region captioning, and grounded reasoning. Comprehensive
experiments show the effectiveness of our NExT-Chat on various tasks, e.g.,
NExT-Chat (87.7) vs. Shikra (86.9) on POPE-Random, NExT-Chat (68.9) vs. LISA
(67.9) on referring expression segmentation task, and NExT-Chat (79.6) vs.
Kosmos-2 (62.3) on region caption task. The code and model are released at
https://github.com/NExT-ChatV/NExT-Chat. | [
0.0548434779,
0.0326816514,
0.0104678264,
0.0715456232,
-0.0183162577,
-0.0009040947,
0.0199223403,
-0.0005184722,
-0.0149268936,
-0.0739758015,
-0.0649626181,
-0.0194982477,
0.0074959118,
0.0518814884,
0.0284798648,
-0.0656836852,
0.0101008462,
-0.0270046722,
-0.0164376982,
0.0229927227,
0.0420036428,
0.0062826267,
-0.0274308082,
0.0512064658,
-0.0252221432,
-0.0174729712,
-0.0378211401,
0.0153232906,
0.0080373129,
-0.0554749481,
-0.0214705598,
0.0344431289,
0.0801624209,
-0.0058166794,
0.000002017,
-0.0024020532,
-0.003918034,
-0.0153714046,
0.0083982972,
-0.00849385,
0.0283984747,
-0.0437638238,
-0.013061651,
-0.0099047683,
-0.0232457705,
-0.0175179336,
0.0436819345,
0.0440661646,
0.0828321576,
0.053771954,
-0.0244022235,
-0.0346137024,
0.018408129,
-0.0098480051,
0.0360607952,
-0.0609904043,
-0.0007463444,
0.0506260879,
0.0053650863,
0.0387535729,
-0.0518238246,
0.0199541897,
0.0188659355,
-0.0304115675,
-0.0058137202,
0.0442784987,
-0.0143982908,
-0.0471537597,
-0.0285674296,
0.0897160918,
-0.0097755883,
0.0172393303,
-0.0233101826,
0.0321498327,
0.0023367002,
-0.0510409884,
-0.0866635814,
0.0417493284,
0.0008388702,
0.024154149,
-0.0518373735,
0.030296078,
-0.0130308308,
-0.0132364212,
-0.0246629007,
0.0063205273,
-0.0131569337,
0.0107358266,
-0.0442041494,
-0.0042001493,
-0.0319711417,
-0.0592962541,
0.0359501354,
0.0378201455,
0.0187309477,
0.0149269542,
-0.0284200814,
-0.0157616399,
-0.0202547163,
-0.0342949517,
-0.0204991363,
0.0263620634,
-0.066785112,
0.0713464916,
-0.0099200709,
0.0482227281,
-0.0315146111,
0.035830427,
-0.0284524113,
-0.0002853247,
-0.0223617926,
-0.012778718,
-0.0249323994,
-0.0085150478,
-0.069735691,
-0.0885417238,
-0.0114024822,
0.0262789652,
-0.0125238029,
-0.0211152807,
-0.0138591137,
0.0306235272,
-0.0029514174,
0.0028372547,
0.0101585137,
0.0538626015,
-0.0293569975,
-0.0083319293,
-0.0086839646,
-0.0687628388,
-0.0148698119,
0.0603193715,
0.0173892938,
-0.0231662951,
-0.0317339599,
0.0682335049,
-0.028590899,
-0.0511094891,
0.0066301399,
-0.0288470313,
-0.0444842279,
-0.036864128,
0.0677594244,
-0.0181227066,
0.015127914,
-0.0248466544,
0.0069769188,
0.0083464747,
0.022120297,
0.0006624107,
-0.0020157166,
0.0833695009,
0.0192868169,
0.0037069002,
0.0190268736,
0.033181861,
0.0030513506,
0.0732536167,
0.0375160575,
0.0255749132,
0.042782139,
0.0043007433,
-0.0007616,
0.0382667072,
-0.0056727254,
-0.0191474445,
-0.0395555273,
-0.0064643673,
0.0081044659,
0.0286666062,
0.0440774411,
0.0343103558,
-0.03966894,
-0.0247394107,
0.0719781592,
0.0481381863,
-0.0625292063,
-0.0246374458,
0.0206668023,
0.0498840995,
-0.016282564,
-0.0041266964,
-0.0432648063,
0.0599647351,
-0.005154389,
-0.0078510828,
0.0514704436,
0.0089043733,
-0.0256529897,
-0.0090997433,
-0.0115697794,
-0.0208168328,
0.0299840141,
-0.0116316928,
0.0627413243,
0.0238772929,
-0.0584634915,
0.0715133697,
-0.0215677917,
-0.0186660085,
-0.0356842689,
-0.0300243907,
0.0214618277,
0.0142185204,
0.0369980931,
0.0216867197,
-0.0338220783,
-0.0027956846,
0.0611276627,
0.0436567031,
-0.0110427774,
0.0122880097,
0.024988398,
-0.0535420887,
-0.048961658,
-0.0235264599,
-0.0106611103,
-0.0033512446,
0.0178183895,
-0.0247791465,
0.0143594192,
-0.0407992266,
0.0750274956,
0.0347587019,
0.0414829887,
0.0503862947,
-0.0686206073,
0.0150667299,
0.0069577461,
0.012834643,
-0.020719368,
-0.0048681078,
0.0446519516,
-0.0261027366,
0.0398226827,
0.0529597625,
-0.0707300603,
-0.0709872022,
0.033559408,
-0.0343128629,
-0.0099200672,
0.0113620562,
-0.0512901582,
-0.0077504017,
0.0331465341,
-0.0462118015,
0.0179990381,
-0.0329996757,
-0.0031724405,
0.0206757449,
0.0321799889,
-0.0173580274,
0.0408905298,
-0.0437405035,
-0.0153108193,
0.0164533257,
0.0127508929,
0.0140197556,
-0.0327905975,
0.0106660258,
-0.0003801896,
-0.033424601,
-0.0247963909,
-0.0228452217,
0.0242733397,
-0.0386741236,
-0.0109168682,
-0.10358233,
-0.0174411703,
-0.0140775377,
-0.0187009424,
0.002558999,
-0.003627599,
-0.0058830688,
-0.0569324084,
-0.0255509168,
0.011934692,
0.0241786316,
0.0160409026,
0.033578001,
-0.0018934937,
-0.0214033742,
-0.0275965557,
0.0151283266,
0.015949849,
0.0725678205,
-0.0117269084,
-0.062316861,
-0.0276365634,
0.0085653523,
-0.0180838797,
0.02000756,
-0.0315719023,
-0.0387534313,
0.0314012468,
-0.0280730203,
0.034237545,
0.0767278671,
0.0106329992,
0.0645321757,
-0.0064428332,
-0.0292089544,
-0.0316481404,
0.00550615,
0.0151148783,
-0.0208625533,
-0.0251027104,
-0.0290187858,
-0.0226450656,
0.0620367751,
-0.0178084448,
0.0368240625,
-0.0413928963,
0.000681449,
0.0258875862,
-0.0446923636,
-0.0496622659,
0.0088894945,
-0.0077744843,
0.0321590453,
-0.0666240528,
-0.0572559685,
0.0320511125,
-0.0680256784,
-0.0365961716,
-0.0181062464,
-0.0014162544,
-0.0284687169,
0.0804965198,
0.0053813122,
0.0284753777,
-0.0120038707,
-0.0418362506,
-0.0275635887,
-0.0032609215,
-0.0313939042,
0.0014828313,
-0.0053043491,
-0.0285268389,
-0.0029378084,
-0.006908441,
-0.0075033102,
-0.0167602468,
-0.0191808585,
-0.0496986471,
-0.0305203982,
-0.0294105206,
-0.0017676213,
-0.0394010469,
0.0628757402,
0.0166988932,
0.0263360888,
-0.0265917499,
0.0237977635,
-0.0307121221,
0.0117686894,
0.0560035892,
0.0565424748,
-0.0471070111,
-0.0624422021,
0.0108524356,
0.0841443166,
-0.0127887838,
-0.0051598335,
-0.0334284604,
0.0426199995,
0.0141181443,
0.0591327623,
-0.02471173,
0.0015011085,
0.080393143,
-0.0405291766,
-0.0209101047,
0.0932340696,
0.0431158878,
-0.0297979247,
-0.0134485262,
-0.0254760422,
0.0106196478,
0.0422241762,
-0.0072789029,
-0.0763590336,
-0.0759270638,
0.0199111458,
-0.0244171061,
0.0450270884,
0.0204422213,
-0.0182355735,
-0.0856418833,
0.0478211045,
0.0059296652,
-0.0828313231,
-0.0653088987,
0.0152571211,
-0.0001510603,
0.0243198965,
-0.0131445695,
0.0064701415,
0.0059154122,
-0.012692932,
0.0160353035,
-0.0254637189,
-0.0306181405,
-0.001206584,
-0.049537506,
0.0088348249,
0.0354704931,
0.0143484408,
0.0382831283,
-0.0248626862,
0.03030237,
0.04471609,
0.0211583991,
0.0038146246,
0.0566809103,
-0.0452201776,
-0.0222047158,
-0.0251001287,
0.0133506833,
-0.0089059342,
-0.0358595327,
-0.0440179408,
0.0507669337,
-0.0221312586,
0.0316822976,
-0.0409539156,
0.0771684498,
0.0096317632,
0.0498297215,
0.0378000811,
-0.0152717195,
-0.0127541563,
-0.0192455091,
0.0296828561,
-0.0049152304,
0.0158062261,
-0.0110588213,
-0.0240650624,
-0.0062860074,
-0.0551645383,
-0.008985823,
0.06083766,
0.0376961008,
-0.0199811775,
-0.0273093767,
-0.0081928726,
0.0201906767,
-0.0316485651,
0.0587275103,
-0.0107516702,
0.0123749254,
-0.0229573604,
0.0307446122,
0.0298134461,
-0.0305151101,
-0.0144301429,
0.0626456663,
-0.0735972598,
-0.0160640832,
-0.0432696119,
0.0592298843,
0.0178662892,
0.0393478535,
0.0015769314,
-0.0292865615,
-0.011439099,
-0.0082980022,
-0.0144900419,
0.0221812036,
0.0043332879,
0.0147674894,
-0.0050702095,
0.0106798597,
-0.0235438533,
0.019998461,
-0.0303498693,
0.0419705398,
-0.0292524137,
-0.0377336442,
-0.0049599162,
-0.0367900431,
0.0428235196,
0.0207056068,
0.007062396,
-0.020422224,
0.0261873025,
-0.0005391431,
-0.0126432525,
-0.0827536806,
0.0228200033,
0.0149932029,
-0.0008789243,
0.0159511305,
-0.0140810553,
0.0089016324,
0.0620890372,
0.0276598316,
0.0001643403,
0.0267036185,
-0.0333511047,
-0.0169854946,
0.0338377878,
-0.0080666691,
0.0017084172,
-0.0314047076,
0.0292862579,
-0.0133964317,
0.0969111994,
-0.0136574358,
-0.062351726,
-0.0142533593,
0.0564615242,
-0.0126920966,
0.0053674863,
-0.0227162335,
0.0774896741,
0.0585584082,
0.0294641498,
0.032261204,
0.0111763505,
-0.011170744,
0.008112127,
0.076925002,
-0.0081535,
-0.0834111944,
0.0490952767,
0.0210989676,
-0.015347532,
-0.0188179035,
0.0379687436,
0.0131371701,
0.009321006,
-0.007333681,
-0.0278113615,
-0.0505740009,
0.0078543993,
0.0463901907,
0.0415722355,
0.0075504696,
0.0334464349,
-0.0073318831,
-0.0605245233,
-0.0028498094,
0.0119996751,
-0.0494048297,
0.0108404607,
0.0482840091,
0.0507491976,
0.030780511,
-0.033264149,
-0.0256591439,
0.0052373661,
-0.0096240174,
0.0010655705,
-0.0042158607,
-5.940728411e-33,
-0.0426700227,
-0.0337858535,
0.0207753275,
-0.0205534566,
-0.0523161665,
0.0083929924,
-0.0475478433,
0.0067352485,
0.0149743417,
0.0152606945,
0.023936836,
0.0132388826,
0.0256567039,
0.0374667682,
-0.0466224551,
-0.0104319286,
0.0191296842,
-0.022682881,
-0.0041840435,
-0.0155090569,
0.0391040668,
0.0530438647,
0.0579875186,
-0.0476521626,
-0.0079234503,
0.0113962675,
-0.0241187979,
0.0612732284,
0.0175475106,
0.0815125853,
-0.0475715585,
0.001124574,
0.0019004513,
-0.0080985678,
-0.0368539579,
0.0570313632,
-0.0792817175,
0.0290049519,
0.009509204,
0.0673495159,
-0.0450291261,
0.0179762375,
0.0362024494,
-0.0338812135,
0.0414786153,
-0.002740012,
0.031946674,
-0.0293968227,
-0.0102523388,
0.0510377772,
-0.0325598381,
0.010578787,
-0.0146737341,
-0.0631482825,
0.0535476692,
0.046961505,
0.0379280299,
-0.0012969461,
-0.0365379304,
0.0252787899,
-0.0244606454,
0.0125711225,
0.0739880949,
0.0339336991,
0.0160158221,
0.0861989856,
0.0206448827,
-0.0441948399,
-0.0468659103,
-0.0225987136,
0.0174935572,
0.0686761513,
0.0095514795,
-0.003497771,
-0.0201757047,
0.0452931859,
-0.0511366799,
0.0077765966,
0.0134028792,
0.0643362999,
0.0197802372,
0.0257606823,
-0.0186784938,
-0.0067999768,
0.0024771122,
-0.0182799809,
-0.032355234,
-0.0208285209,
0.0427333266,
0.0414090976,
-0.0228780359,
0.0127846617,
0.0921629593,
-0.0308616422,
0.0053620297,
0.0168983229,
-0.004568852,
0.0702311248,
-0.0021591445,
0.0259883814,
-0.015149368,
-0.018818723,
0.0710010901,
-0.0489043258,
0.0056474134,
0.0141638368,
0.0281820949,
0.0089547411,
-0.0297516305,
-0.0220834538,
-0.0398182161,
-0.0039151674,
-0.0501804538,
0.0565082878,
0.032480631,
0.0039636926,
-0.0714090541,
0.0518124998,
-0.0119251236,
0.0250049289,
-0.0292259995,
-0.0498862565,
-0.0241623353,
0.0236934144,
-0.0235635713,
0.0139954044,
-0.0510993712,
-0.040118549,
0.0334797464,
-0.0869533718,
-0.0184039846,
0.0446267426,
2.695e-7,
0.0324514546,
0.0237014331,
0.0414963849,
0.0115156788,
0.0274611805,
0.0453942232,
-0.0304457974,
0.0271039438,
0.0180136692,
-0.0445311964,
-0.0221399292,
0.0527899601,
0.0456896946,
-0.0146487774,
-0.0702738315,
0.0073749465,
-0.0359243639,
-0.0346786194,
-0.0432431325,
0.0047306898,
0.0370394886,
0.0916394219,
-0.0304459669,
-0.0021620169,
0.0218564346,
-0.0432069749,
0.0639467314,
-0.0363919474,
-0.0220475998,
-0.0196643136,
0.02167302,
0.0115474453,
-0.0226288922,
-0.0040992047,
0.0391031578,
-0.0098901428,
0.0550713651,
0.0588303953,
0.0004295368,
-0.0276224464,
-0.0127416346,
0.0254047867,
-0.0400926955,
-0.0306057706,
0.0658483952,
-0.0727417395,
-0.0474229269,
-0.0411114767,
-0.0192662906,
-0.0294807572,
-0.0095790299,
-0.0251191985,
-0.0371683612,
0.0058521335,
0.0309751332,
-0.0367867909,
-0.0178571045,
-0.0953823254,
-0.0475887023,
-0.0244488623,
-0.0632842779,
-0.013671834,
-0.0558825172,
-0.0308403242,
0.0319677666,
-0.023693705,
-0.0485237725,
2.475622097e-34,
0.0070538465,
-0.0242330376,
-0.0005135607,
0.0357260928,
0.0415040478,
0.0021877831,
-0.0065309294,
-0.0029500565,
-0.0152928745,
-0.0484823287,
-0.005308284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04495v1 | Multi-label and Multi-target Sampling of Machine Annotation for Computational Stance Detection | 2023-11-08T06:54:34 | 2023-11-08T06:54:34 | Zhengyuan Liu, Hai Leong Chieu, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data collection from manual labeling provides domain-specific and
task-aligned supervision for data-driven approaches, and a critical mass of
well-annotated resources is required to achieve reasonable performance in
natural language processing tasks. However, manual annotations are often
challenging to scale up in terms of time and budget, especially when domain
knowledge, capturing subtle semantic features, and reasoning steps are needed.
In this paper, we investigate the efficacy of leveraging large language models
on automated labeling for computational stance detection. We empirically
observe that while large language models show strong potential as an
alternative to human annotators, their sensitivity to task-specific
instructions and their intrinsic biases pose intriguing yet unique challenges
in machine annotation. We introduce a multi-label and multi-target sampling
strategy to optimize the annotation quality. Experimental results on the
benchmark stance detection corpora show that our method can significantly
improve performance and learning efficacy. | [
0.0316290185,
0.0245057866,
0.0005209394,
0.0437237099,
-0.0203659087,
0.0330383703,
0.0126244975,
-0.0343443826,
-0.0070322063,
-0.0990750864,
-0.0316234343,
-0.0111667439,
-0.0475284792,
-0.0235939324,
0.0133412573,
0.0038243693,
0.0551709905,
0.0099260909,
0.0484158397,
0.0135048516,
0.0605037361,
0.0501736514,
-0.0304142274,
0.0524239503,
-0.0623127408,
-0.0510515459,
0.0047281352,
-0.0245072283,
0.0339168534,
-0.0303625241,
0.0372354202,
0.0625443384,
0.0192717817,
0.0250624176,
0.0000017595,
-0.0378328934,
-0.0407358818,
-0.0158578176,
-0.0086549688,
0.0179182719,
0.0058727157,
-0.0436600037,
-0.002349298,
-0.0051021613,
-0.0545808598,
0.0213460643,
0.0445604213,
0.0128388079,
0.074388884,
0.0432487577,
0.0076499032,
0.0115942517,
-0.0196846481,
-0.0269265249,
-0.0514079332,
-0.0624861233,
0.0165000036,
0.0314195901,
-0.0482674651,
0.0602090545,
-0.0244301148,
0.0114622628,
0.0127784228,
-0.0429072864,
-0.0593270324,
-0.0085096443,
-0.0105778147,
-0.0342105702,
-0.0181459803,
0.0684564337,
0.0234819837,
-0.0012438257,
-0.0168491155,
-0.0389121287,
0.0099705178,
-0.0094532557,
0.002351779,
0.0394897647,
-0.0327453651,
0.0250173658,
0.038835153,
-0.0078205783,
0.0050521926,
0.036799591,
0.0250468422,
0.0750317723,
-0.0462947339,
-0.01639878,
0.056849774,
0.0510308146,
-0.0505229384,
-0.0309511721,
0.0265895966,
0.0148130432,
-0.0416572429,
0.0461202189,
-0.0422685184,
-0.0060766987,
0.0328655094,
-0.0290101469,
0.011682611,
-0.0018895295,
-0.0206346419,
0.0712122321,
0.0016201292,
0.0161350723,
-0.0386620909,
-0.021145504,
-0.0125757847,
0.0080851279,
-0.0428718738,
-0.0312462002,
-0.0294281319,
0.038545534,
-0.0545418672,
-0.0201814473,
-0.0242017433,
0.0024769751,
-0.0388976671,
-0.0134960981,
0.0121876001,
-0.0201365389,
-0.0066165607,
0.023525577,
-0.004003135,
0.056821201,
-0.0216670632,
0.0191697888,
-0.0117327441,
-0.0512074493,
-0.0175287277,
0.02648139,
-0.0380501971,
-0.0303040259,
0.0166558661,
-0.0070908708,
0.0138053754,
0.0123079345,
0.0172881968,
-0.0300667323,
-0.0567220226,
-0.0650848374,
-0.0141143082,
-0.0642486066,
0.0347097553,
0.0083418302,
0.0058233491,
-0.0611219555,
0.0211343952,
0.0322528891,
0.0358768404,
0.0775632337,
0.0139283603,
-0.0407974906,
-0.0066093453,
-0.0218699221,
-0.0052396604,
0.1039493531,
0.0061691599,
-0.000737861,
0.0335659608,
0.0306404904,
-0.010004024,
0.0416187681,
0.0191493798,
0.0000861399,
0.0361763015,
0.0131973336,
-0.0102295233,
-0.0068337033,
0.0123428479,
0.0428775735,
0.0159999914,
-0.0345068537,
0.0419658311,
0.0098317852,
-0.0353333615,
-0.0228187181,
0.0324197151,
0.0338634476,
0.0329754539,
-0.034596581,
-0.0343645662,
0.0389282331,
0.0166530833,
-0.0214259867,
-0.0150284106,
0.0108085256,
0.0063129901,
-0.0727927983,
-0.0224357769,
0.0028809872,
-0.0241707228,
0.0053765024,
0.0321875513,
0.0144156842,
-0.0412027836,
0.0515152253,
0.0418097489,
-0.0195512511,
-0.0170775913,
-0.0194612406,
0.0262025595,
-0.0252384301,
-0.0198431201,
-0.0668374896,
-0.0586211681,
-0.0439607129,
0.0183904935,
0.071432963,
0.0521537289,
-0.0574803315,
-0.0191460252,
-0.0019948264,
-0.0016316425,
-0.02199376,
0.0286476687,
0.0316898003,
0.0059248577,
-0.0160748437,
0.0027787564,
0.0003395694,
0.0048720082,
0.050771296,
0.0459405817,
-0.0154409278,
0.0125982761,
0.0171299633,
0.0358307883,
0.0528013073,
-0.0110997912,
-0.0140125444,
0.01663756,
-0.0309518427,
-0.0143837109,
-0.0133676324,
0.0032653927,
-0.0707625672,
0.0467551611,
-0.0140360296,
-0.0844584554,
0.0265061613,
-0.046513658,
-0.0014507496,
-0.0388351269,
-0.0481388383,
-0.0706980377,
-0.0779093355,
-0.0307538938,
-0.0244365372,
0.0146124251,
-0.0507880375,
0.041027911,
0.0129331322,
-0.0164553635,
0.0341334417,
-0.0066835126,
0.0381783172,
-0.0351129919,
-0.0434928127,
-0.0131094363,
0.0145803252,
0.0003343394,
0.0415757783,
0.0090757357,
-0.0165050607,
0.0034308857,
-0.099190712,
-0.0054051336,
-0.0396998301,
0.0157225598,
0.0291452091,
-0.0409759767,
0.0101249404,
0.0002288683,
-0.0298650526,
-0.0483475477,
-0.0182254165,
0.0292587411,
0.0526341237,
0.003853769,
0.0046637249,
-0.0389275849,
0.0176328104,
-0.0393533446,
0.0022352145,
0.0410672799,
-0.0682057515,
-0.0405846201,
-0.0208485015,
-0.0154242367,
-0.0083544804,
0.0127635179,
-0.0317006148,
0.045827955,
-0.0041050357,
-0.014216247,
0.0782449618,
0.0206183456,
0.0783061311,
0.0233153906,
0.0383465923,
-0.036653161,
0.0274134949,
-0.0112589076,
0.0335282609,
-0.0210607089,
0.00689075,
0.0207553245,
0.0737913325,
-0.0066625774,
-0.0182819925,
-0.0297187287,
0.025957603,
-0.064714089,
-0.0385616496,
-0.0095337788,
0.0130156185,
-0.0275939684,
-0.0013246452,
-0.0145890871,
-0.0128707765,
0.083183758,
0.0122964848,
-0.0103382617,
-0.0432600752,
-0.0028215849,
-0.0350800715,
0.0603031106,
0.0192880668,
0.001450213,
0.0124314828,
0.0073731537,
0.0156220002,
-0.0100289676,
0.0243431982,
-0.0090259528,
0.0086545134,
-0.0467520654,
0.0493908003,
-0.0069869421,
-0.0471745841,
-0.0203954447,
-0.0371317938,
-0.0706172884,
0.0078225974,
0.0172233246,
0.0098553048,
0.0428747796,
0.0333183371,
0.0062613939,
0.0227965899,
-0.0143340621,
0.0214906018,
0.0027036611,
0.0011941015,
0.0341540053,
-0.0097563332,
0.0203785282,
-0.0217992775,
0.0089448104,
0.0731233358,
-0.0140789282,
0.0549044795,
-0.0028335182,
-0.0191901829,
0.0114006083,
-0.0200386997,
0.0102745071,
-0.0343558677,
0.0816114247,
-0.0540675782,
0.0015239709,
0.0945114195,
0.0329498127,
-0.0326849595,
-0.0012021131,
0.0709662512,
-0.0197684523,
0.031669233,
0.0082248989,
-0.0513080545,
-0.0586593598,
-0.0190164018,
0.0077502485,
-0.0225021504,
-0.0202060565,
0.0059763989,
-0.1053498015,
0.0056208884,
-0.053264726,
-0.0985429585,
-0.0144676855,
-0.0626499355,
0.0452378914,
-0.0602714159,
0.0186473653,
-0.0088183982,
0.0316256806,
-0.0006883193,
0.0475532711,
-0.0259012561,
0.0065328176,
0.0103756394,
-0.0356984138,
0.0430326574,
0.0462209284,
0.0502055138,
0.0064881677,
0.0052177454,
0.0634349883,
-0.0153273912,
-0.0007305446,
-0.0030516093,
0.0311438218,
-0.0531994179,
-0.0302539002,
0.0053577498,
0.0424680188,
-0.0353571735,
0.0211086664,
-0.0035405213,
0.028674785,
0.0197065156,
0.0280924104,
-0.0219727363,
0.0321546234,
0.0544452518,
0.067913793,
0.0191993043,
-0.0779448152,
-0.0280228667,
-0.0471467339,
-0.0427610129,
-0.0918462053,
-0.0583095439,
-0.0010512072,
-0.0243147984,
0.0355576761,
-0.0579923391,
-0.051344905,
0.0317062847,
0.0512847789,
-0.0082575046,
-0.0116258338,
0.0462462008,
0.0507612899,
-0.0406509824,
0.0289811604,
-0.0184364393,
0.0411943085,
-0.0121564912,
-0.029044142,
0.0592073426,
0.0226140749,
-0.053754963,
0.0262816101,
-0.0730338991,
-0.0460275114,
-0.0156582613,
0.0564097241,
0.0081861028,
0.0248248186,
-0.0089731943,
0.0149874566,
-0.0201823581,
0.0859519467,
-0.0135128302,
0.0091851745,
0.0343649611,
0.0121813631,
-0.0308794063,
0.0342377834,
-0.0053970111,
0.0372235253,
0.0269565471,
0.0423892587,
-0.0356266797,
-0.0152198654,
0.0319788493,
0.0058226949,
0.02021694,
-0.0131195514,
-0.0333248414,
-0.0113484189,
-0.0035621014,
-0.0155831715,
-0.074267298,
-0.0352415368,
0.016620934,
-0.0154904807,
-0.0782953799,
-0.0373553596,
0.034748055,
-0.0004287999,
0.0822265744,
-0.0180016477,
0.0269589573,
0.0404161736,
0.0145806866,
-0.0326559246,
-0.0233540479,
-0.037942186,
-0.0131686702,
0.0367053449,
0.0211748462,
0.0271171108,
0.0577744469,
0.0423305891,
-0.0184300542,
0.0201720037,
0.0083635692,
-0.0135552846,
0.0233986415,
-0.0509613119,
0.0136632426,
0.0315057114,
-0.0421660542,
0.0537650436,
-0.0179126151,
-0.0439499691,
-0.0261288341,
0.0117706973,
-0.0143976714,
-0.0167480409,
0.0526620485,
0.0340028517,
-0.0097681256,
0.0047404338,
0.0197034832,
-0.0202620942,
0.0286640525,
0.0366479121,
-0.0171555895,
-0.0262997467,
-0.00742264,
-0.0482674502,
-0.0047056936,
0.0039834091,
0.0331870914,
-0.0633357614,
-0.0391542017,
-0.0034278014,
0.0208304245,
0.0037609693,
0.0253659543,
-0.0008063944,
0.0547848977,
-0.0059887771,
0.0048550512,
-0.0787412375,
0.032857269,
-0.0190616753,
-0.0000437508,
-0.0388539732,
-5.642966141e-33,
-0.0396779254,
-0.050009612,
-0.0394586511,
0.0074806353,
-0.0013432287,
0.0188295972,
-0.0027034283,
0.0031127643,
-0.0229403637,
0.0729580596,
0.0206525363,
0.0097986106,
0.0119014932,
0.0245867912,
0.0012326716,
-0.0128042372,
0.0153941363,
0.0010431908,
-0.0570018366,
-0.0117521249,
0.0259422082,
-0.0217929743,
0.0339021012,
-0.0753750727,
0.0799774081,
0.0040294677,
-0.0375787206,
0.0369686335,
-0.0196323246,
0.1023066789,
0.0109832156,
0.0298653021,
0.0465931632,
-0.0948296338,
0.016899148,
0.0480598137,
-0.0566756725,
0.0186686404,
0.0144732259,
0.0262208935,
0.0140426904,
-0.0041384264,
-0.0255753808,
-0.0070045996,
0.002060767,
0.0202073604,
0.0217758026,
-0.0376437977,
0.0394096449,
-0.0472803302,
-0.0529791936,
0.0159803107,
-0.0301195197,
-0.0313404389,
-0.0090691466,
0.0269338563,
0.0096051479,
0.0511593185,
-0.0316094309,
-0.0137717752,
-0.0662256628,
0.0275738034,
0.0055089095,
0.0245768391,
0.0090118116,
0.0587957725,
-0.0273358822,
0.0186084956,
-0.052658584,
0.0166578647,
-0.0027681484,
-0.0020128423,
0.0611101799,
0.0587488152,
0.0194444768,
0.0397298709,
-0.0674753487,
-0.0018983099,
0.0632174835,
-0.0159451962,
0.01610904,
0.0015636345,
-0.0037390501,
-0.0017538073,
-0.0250008404,
-0.0437403843,
-0.0226992071,
0.0235071238,
0.0061216666,
-0.0090991724,
-0.0937062874,
0.0549020655,
0.0202587023,
-0.0357295536,
-0.0192117505,
0.0226648655,
-0.0064572669,
0.0252598207,
-0.0042295838,
0.014578782,
-0.0296973009,
-0.0049548657,
-0.0066366401,
-0.0010354806,
0.0453477874,
-0.0137072224,
0.1018971577,
-0.0372015797,
-0.0494655818,
-0.022722207,
-0.0277110264,
0.0223989096,
-0.0532996655,
0.0752075016,
0.0334999189,
-0.0097074509,
-0.0134665063,
0.0666598082,
0.0022637441,
-0.0002458731,
-0.0347304493,
0.019872278,
-0.0307929348,
0.0124128517,
-0.029497033,
-0.0341670364,
0.0225331448,
0.0288181119,
-0.0517965406,
-0.0815784186,
0.0133943027,
0.0211057365,
2.273e-7,
0.0582342036,
0.0535257719,
0.0203765854,
-0.0114883408,
0.0502486266,
0.0405270569,
-0.0033111821,
0.0043222597,
0.0204029661,
-0.0692867264,
-0.0236940272,
0.0582268909,
0.0430464372,
0.0237395875,
-0.0852285251,
-0.0148470253,
0.0082634995,
-0.0006076092,
-0.0188484583,
0.0266927984,
-0.0138208997,
0.0858998299,
0.0197125245,
0.0051803282,
0.001866564,
0.0073680249,
0.0307549275,
0.023663627,
0.0069650593,
0.0297987517,
0.0000988947,
-0.0482906662,
-0.0151065188,
0.0383070521,
0.0061094007,
0.0175210163,
0.0286262259,
0.1211961955,
0.0131495595,
-0.0217211656,
-0.0417090356,
0.0147633711,
0.0362092666,
0.0019857385,
0.0672512501,
-0.0576607883,
-0.0009568474,
-0.0585447177,
-0.0133983726,
0.0037324415,
0.0234341864,
-0.00165325,
0.0023451052,
0.0403360836,
-0.0044732434,
-0.0248653088,
0.0048726089,
-0.0454314239,
-0.0445967317,
-0.0316077694,
-0.0296356771,
-0.0404917039,
0.0559013039,
-0.0339867063,
0.0104551921,
-0.0737443194,
-0.019806372,
1.69960102e-34,
0.0258407444,
-0.0406363048,
0.0228723399,
0.0309998728,
0.0290628355,
0.031976115,
-0.0568908975,
-0.0056061,
0.0234717075,
-0.0199014414,
-0.0111548062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04480v1 | CLearViD: Curriculum Learning for Video Description | 2023-11-08T06:20:32 | 2023-11-08T06:20:32 | Cheng-Yu Chuang, Pooyan Fazli | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Video description entails automatically generating coherent natural language
sentences that narrate the content of a given video. We introduce CLearViD, a
transformer-based model for video description generation that leverages
curriculum learning to accomplish this task. In particular, we investigate two
curriculum strategies: (1) progressively exposing the model to more challenging
samples by gradually applying a Gaussian noise to the video data, and (2)
gradually reducing the capacity of the network through dropout during the
training process. These methods enable the model to learn more robust and
generalizable features. Moreover, CLearViD leverages the Mish activation
function, which provides non-linearity and non-monotonicity and helps alleviate
the issue of vanishing gradients. Our extensive experiments and ablation
studies demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model. The results on two
datasets, namely ActivityNet Captions and YouCook2, show that CLearViD
significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art models in terms of both
accuracy and diversity metrics. | [
0.0149736861,
0.0301869754,
0.0119892024,
0.0093850996,
0.0073429467,
-0.0134333791,
0.0258158576,
-0.0391431488,
-0.0593358874,
-0.0857332796,
-0.0014105574,
-0.0635758415,
0.0230435301,
0.0652305856,
0.0074200854,
-0.0726056546,
0.0110219903,
-0.0152706755,
-0.0036156913,
0.0107163126,
0.0010034385,
0.0213298704,
0.025991749,
0.0334191322,
-0.0417292006,
0.0228380952,
-0.0005863748,
0.0291791689,
0.0559103154,
-0.0204081982,
0.0325986333,
0.0432680584,
0.026002273,
-0.0205273796,
0.000002084,
-0.0256371759,
0.012549676,
-0.0189777017,
0.0343859345,
0.0032003229,
0.0196623448,
-0.0092796274,
0.0054663774,
0.0271118116,
-0.0113244802,
0.0287698507,
0.0523021743,
0.0229628757,
0.0572786257,
0.0537063777,
-0.0376122594,
-0.0769657642,
-0.0054703127,
-0.0455564819,
0.056690108,
0.0253088605,
-0.004933265,
0.0302348826,
0.0198501199,
0.0264257025,
-0.0516930148,
0.02731332,
0.0480660945,
-0.0313865878,
0.0255622305,
0.051170323,
-0.0094165839,
-0.0208614115,
0.0083618956,
0.0806428194,
-0.0120669371,
0.0250260923,
0.0058344803,
-0.0140842069,
0.0105041862,
-0.0546693429,
-0.0416077413,
0.0670356601,
-0.0013162153,
0.0072907838,
-0.0416691229,
0.0693715811,
0.0095083173,
0.0009892981,
0.0373549536,
-0.0731791854,
0.0227070227,
-0.0003167682,
-0.0350074694,
-0.0028212646,
-0.0155515559,
-0.0573107451,
0.0137372548,
0.0307748914,
0.0003245332,
-0.0169302281,
-0.0666507185,
-0.0359480754,
-0.0065065841,
-0.0265700649,
0.0009302114,
0.032271605,
-0.0383783355,
0.0342722014,
-0.0181701276,
0.0828372389,
0.023939563,
0.0298739299,
-0.0625892729,
0.009932681,
-0.050064154,
-0.0178557876,
-0.0348162875,
0.0429094099,
-0.0199595951,
-0.0378882736,
-0.072757937,
0.0061129988,
-0.0530232936,
0.012163043,
-0.0110031934,
0.0646948516,
-0.076383099,
-0.0296988711,
-0.0170523096,
0.0137739694,
-0.018822141,
0.0037878035,
0.0406183414,
-0.000314931,
-0.0204987768,
0.0617181584,
-0.0046798619,
0.0018649595,
0.0250048563,
0.0383706912,
-0.0542854033,
-0.0149127208,
-0.0010315893,
0.002542621,
-0.0471584871,
-0.0351807475,
0.0296283662,
-0.0774782971,
-0.0050744438,
-0.0179121085,
-0.0096783005,
-0.0562099591,
0.010250221,
-0.0005480073,
-0.0098224189,
0.0424737632,
-0.0199234076,
-0.0334277526,
0.0251586009,
0.0301773716,
0.0380155519,
0.0589132607,
0.0259382427,
0.0520693548,
0.0018059519,
0.0331688523,
0.0380691551,
0.0030409952,
-0.0107512502,
-0.0106193274,
-0.0462825149,
-0.0001067469,
-0.0027583893,
0.0763835013,
0.0390103832,
0.0798573792,
-0.0281016883,
-0.0177161023,
0.0641864911,
0.0214028861,
-0.0418740921,
-0.0126239844,
0.0884198248,
0.0424273051,
-0.012002103,
0.0256052651,
-0.013281283,
0.0822316334,
0.0664325282,
0.0303002112,
0.0102332011,
0.0475575738,
-0.1027155071,
-0.100787431,
-0.0123295812,
-0.0476245731,
0.0401951261,
-0.0205376688,
0.0179520994,
0.0550733693,
-0.0546387993,
0.0414384007,
0.0066827824,
-0.0153751858,
0.0570025034,
-0.0211465098,
0.0004916613,
0.0681228563,
0.0324091762,
0.0002113782,
-0.0632492378,
-0.0492766835,
0.0391182937,
0.0643530414,
0.010901358,
-0.0137148881,
0.0109765632,
-0.1002657935,
-0.0410044119,
-0.0526002795,
0.0372011401,
0.0156407915,
-0.0078530032,
0.0025561464,
0.057575196,
0.0050046509,
-0.0770148784,
0.0370180756,
-0.0011157016,
-0.030539291,
0.0527997687,
0.0023540831,
-0.0108598741,
0.0032109751,
0.003960514,
-0.0008391333,
0.0041244547,
-0.0343031175,
-0.0058518257,
0.0407982543,
-0.0563457534,
-0.0318091176,
0.0151428888,
-0.071393393,
0.0165042728,
0.0548051968,
-0.0298410915,
-0.0476397946,
0.0273409765,
-0.0154339932,
-0.0403959192,
-0.0598008446,
0.0064661824,
0.0564543158,
0.0066613322,
0.0001145746,
0.0370061956,
0.0024206955,
-0.0386129133,
0.0194584038,
0.0003341294,
-0.0027918252,
-0.0537969172,
-0.0242282283,
-0.0220383815,
-0.0184118114,
0.0031391478,
0.0088160252,
0.0327860415,
-0.0304761976,
-0.0031753962,
-0.0621467121,
-0.0040203286,
-0.0260322392,
-0.0150483185,
0.0228227638,
0.0227694511,
0.0459573194,
-0.0203026813,
-0.059786275,
0.0054445146,
0.0023475217,
-0.0177134257,
0.0523096099,
0.0359807499,
-0.0007140564,
-0.0218790993,
-0.0100911297,
0.0270480048,
0.0670654625,
0.0234012324,
0.0131079955,
-0.0010252435,
-0.0282640792,
0.0010073878,
-0.0015864314,
-0.0178709589,
-0.0046580108,
-0.0010407092,
0.0383891538,
0.0352409557,
0.0347119085,
0.0427146778,
0.020851532,
0.0341434143,
0.0245596319,
0.0071713966,
0.0414362922,
-0.0386031233,
-0.0145925144,
-0.0212112963,
-0.0327784047,
-0.0064795902,
0.0086180978,
-0.0032552395,
0.0374500565,
-0.0873073488,
-0.0094900681,
0.0163296442,
-0.0137670767,
-0.0675080866,
-0.007268121,
-0.0285195,
-0.0219883509,
-0.0334010646,
-0.0337609462,
0.0269362889,
-0.0195891093,
-0.0160314422,
-0.0207036212,
0.0110315997,
-0.0208697934,
0.0463806801,
0.0020700304,
0.0421039872,
0.0399591848,
-0.0274606179,
-0.041607134,
-0.0568967946,
0.0004334662,
0.0013320696,
0.0313575231,
-0.0672445893,
-0.0176469013,
-0.004981,
-0.0098281596,
-0.0480939038,
-0.0225377902,
0.0184302796,
0.0151573736,
-0.0054826015,
-0.0205406211,
-0.0095218578,
0.0052583599,
-0.0134195182,
0.0629294291,
-0.0311862268,
0.0057851421,
-0.0084150089,
0.0430947468,
0.0827552229,
0.0260237791,
-0.0329788849,
-0.0654760897,
0.0104020135,
0.0237892307,
-0.0327530988,
0.0027727066,
-0.0556148142,
0.0050798682,
-0.0159161408,
0.0046429392,
0.0009215092,
0.0463524461,
0.0679575652,
-0.0343780257,
-0.0158160459,
0.0849641785,
-0.0220588911,
-0.0235313084,
0.0063291704,
0.0586168133,
0.0292054266,
0.0311629307,
0.0144211715,
-0.0648949817,
-0.0310607571,
-0.0314112157,
0.0269433744,
0.0298999306,
0.0314302444,
-0.0529962033,
-0.0496648513,
0.0497762971,
0.0451837331,
-0.0118647618,
-0.0626960322,
0.0336570479,
-0.031893421,
-0.0256510843,
0.0223049391,
-0.0319305807,
-0.0087012695,
0.0179130379,
0.01578217,
-0.0175299365,
-0.0818924531,
0.0205327105,
-0.0234141443,
0.032948114,
0.0250522625,
-0.0053289956,
-0.0323833898,
-0.0240102597,
0.0196269806,
-0.0058829742,
0.0026696401,
0.0195300505,
0.0522335581,
-0.0363664888,
-0.0169962943,
0.0299960375,
0.0494894907,
0.0139320651,
-0.0408112556,
-0.0230015982,
0.0171038229,
-0.0224248171,
-0.00537724,
-0.0289940722,
0.0353951566,
0.0411867127,
0.0743660331,
-0.0086092567,
-0.0392942913,
0.0113350786,
0.013441151,
-0.0511965007,
-0.0684623942,
-0.0372921862,
0.0075882231,
0.0123336455,
-0.0180104841,
-0.0627804846,
-0.0231709015,
0.0402689613,
0.0474089682,
-0.0069057122,
-0.0222858526,
-0.0093095209,
0.0363933891,
-0.0621212535,
0.0431465171,
0.0208365228,
-0.001907302,
-0.0348640643,
-0.033470124,
0.0084437877,
-0.0804153606,
-0.0128937429,
0.0235834606,
-0.0916642323,
-0.0240564235,
-0.0340917483,
0.0628630668,
0.0167120863,
0.0859404951,
0.0181985535,
0.0105201658,
0.0563200973,
0.0456513166,
0.0412397534,
0.0087653035,
0.0282915402,
-0.0435570404,
-0.0345101692,
0.0193316955,
-0.0372251943,
0.019828923,
-0.0092441021,
0.0233398341,
-0.0069213444,
0.0112818489,
0.0113675073,
-0.0661244392,
0.0335332975,
-0.0364849977,
-0.0178806949,
-0.0402037725,
-0.0404401384,
-0.0194515865,
0.0168453529,
-0.0439976789,
0.0309301708,
0.0386797637,
0.0365076847,
0.0043095802,
0.0025262197,
0.0039140522,
-0.0239335168,
-0.0264838915,
-0.0478323959,
-0.0858518183,
-0.0405908823,
0.0001554878,
0.0119964331,
-0.0160836596,
0.042989634,
-0.016942095,
-0.0044545126,
0.0016124991,
0.0209938902,
0.0119320527,
0.0346044824,
-0.0156636834,
0.0381082855,
-0.0131151555,
0.0125408005,
-0.0793368369,
0.0247401185,
0.0407993831,
-0.0211425684,
0.0149139203,
-0.022747498,
0.0085974587,
-0.0385359153,
0.0603207052,
0.0039747544,
-0.0532407612,
0.0379197113,
-0.0213460345,
-0.0085483566,
-0.0131847207,
0.0783644393,
-0.0002559816,
0.0359427743,
-0.0018311267,
0.0306286104,
-0.0573238023,
-0.0246588606,
0.0117467782,
0.0217304137,
-0.0425412506,
0.0392702594,
-0.0008965759,
-0.0324943289,
0.0048525804,
-0.0042399219,
0.017357422,
0.0310882982,
0.0959464088,
0.0258854534,
-0.0102859065,
-0.0111213718,
-0.0104605053,
-0.0462353528,
-0.0086140223,
-0.002333157,
-0.0433047786,
-6.328850565e-33,
-0.0363295749,
-0.0232186224,
0.0410967655,
0.037759047,
-0.0172919389,
0.0088893101,
-0.0318963826,
0.0194578022,
0.0079943081,
0.0225120187,
0.0234070588,
0.0019397344,
0.0194382612,
0.0635590628,
0.0089189718,
-0.0301508922,
0.0755001083,
-0.0208845828,
-0.024761539,
0.0329113789,
0.0045006736,
0.0092214635,
0.056811735,
-0.074241206,
-0.0225260481,
-0.000401069,
-0.0504596494,
0.0252892002,
0.0342985541,
0.0239285212,
-0.0101155099,
0.0199930165,
0.0087581053,
-0.0270894412,
-0.0284294747,
-0.035075739,
-0.0274831038,
0.0188073535,
0.0019671302,
0.0008434349,
-0.0811270922,
-0.0674848631,
0.0404005907,
-0.0257942304,
-0.0360106193,
-0.0530033186,
0.0621942058,
-0.0182652064,
0.0187058672,
-0.0477503799,
-0.0769035816,
-0.003069313,
-0.0190343354,
-0.0578253083,
-0.00825918,
-0.0029183694,
-0.003691226,
-0.0411495306,
-0.0287418459,
0.0188654996,
-0.0091285054,
0.0790578127,
0.0656827167,
0.0261185989,
-0.0224579256,
0.062391568,
0.0028065457,
-0.0159624033,
-0.0067509515,
0.0286164433,
-0.0065053762,
0.0374463797,
0.0259865001,
0.03874157,
0.0386384577,
-0.0293896422,
-0.0322956964,
0.0442086682,
-0.0795433372,
0.043973349,
0.001474194,
-0.0257260613,
0.0027433536,
-0.0023278652,
0.0165613033,
0.0175434295,
0.0088671781,
-0.0271192491,
-0.0052220449,
0.0540666357,
-0.0154999904,
0.0174849257,
0.0203612465,
-0.0205702167,
0.0757366717,
0.0442785844,
-0.041384317,
0.0238915421,
0.0102285137,
-0.0087505393,
-0.0426230431,
-0.0473848432,
0.0523632318,
0.0519124568,
-0.0029203072,
0.0380102694,
0.0269361362,
0.0751689672,
-0.0210204031,
0.0064259698,
-0.0148701742,
0.0265488289,
-0.0084692687,
0.0309520047,
-0.012662651,
0.0201344807,
-0.0757132694,
0.0398970917,
-0.0445005074,
-0.0111931367,
-0.0158564504,
-0.0151469214,
0.041302219,
0.0595394224,
-0.0351762027,
0.0367510803,
-0.0237676259,
-0.023629522,
0.0309925508,
-0.0427529477,
-0.0225219838,
0.0226166844,
2.751e-7,
-0.01316527,
0.0034813653,
-0.0012492148,
-0.0131335659,
0.0100169452,
0.0422364585,
0.0053304159,
0.0460188016,
-0.005639059,
-0.0143401036,
0.0532108359,
0.0328270793,
0.0423937142,
-0.0140486453,
-0.0603069961,
-0.0006275486,
-0.0522560626,
-0.0001633212,
-0.0314419158,
-0.0350173526,
0.0803329498,
0.064662993,
-0.0026792111,
0.0088707823,
0.0471641459,
-0.0365886204,
0.0813534036,
0.0262162052,
-0.0145801622,
0.0077774436,
0.0306346379,
0.0166938938,
-0.0444292426,
-0.0079095419,
-0.021198241,
-0.0306807514,
0.0354834422,
0.0603687949,
0.0031269058,
-0.028835753,
-0.0171294641,
0.0520105436,
-0.0043575163,
-0.0306646954,
0.0460457616,
-0.0646892413,
0.0115135629,
-0.0205860306,
-0.0176099557,
0.0497325025,
-0.0079112183,
-0.0069582746,
-0.050844077,
-0.022553375,
0.0346223004,
0.0046739019,
-0.0157054011,
-0.0814940333,
0.0015035443,
-0.0179569498,
-0.0550374612,
0.0063994532,
-0.0375911184,
0.0059614829,
0.0216352101,
-0.0106478482,
-0.0287450645,
2.36462811e-34,
0.0741629079,
0.0036472606,
-0.0017032906,
-0.062278565,
-0.0403836705,
0.0221590213,
-0.0060454127,
-0.0190251619,
-0.0094651589,
-0.0124895638,
-0.0604096614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04479v1 | Twitter Sentiment Analysis of Covid Vacciness | 2023-11-08T06:16:04 | 2023-11-08T06:16:04 | Wenbo Zhu, Tiechuan Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI | In this paper, we look at a database of tweets sorted by various keywords
that could indicate the users sentiment towards covid vaccines. With social
media becoming such a prevalent source of opinion, sorting and ranking tweets
that hold important information such as opinions on covid vaccines is of utmost
importance. Two different ranking scales were used, and ranking a tweet in this
way could represent the difference between an opinion being lost and an opinion
being featured on the site, which affects the decisions and behavior of people,
and why researchers were interested in it. Using natural language processing
techniques, our aim is to determine and categorize opinions about covid
vaccines with the highest accuracy possible. | [
0.0641311556,
0.0544618033,
0.0003677354,
-0.0246009808,
-0.0260761511,
0.0030056925,
-0.0037609509,
-0.0066913986,
0.0438663699,
-0.0516160689,
0.0443264134,
-0.0002547351,
0.0087584089,
0.0483401604,
-0.0167494062,
-0.0481252372,
0.0150327822,
0.0698376596,
0.0801643506,
0.0406939127,
0.0310945921,
0.017876694,
-0.0137031376,
0.0406142585,
0.0351617709,
0.0301084965,
0.0531331226,
-0.0253969003,
0.0716048926,
-0.0990999192,
0.0328084379,
-0.0152518004,
-0.0160763878,
0.003241946,
0.0000016288,
-0.0225770678,
-0.040368095,
0.0066973232,
0.0554940812,
-0.0214299355,
0.0917233154,
-0.0484061725,
-0.0095026158,
0.0608426146,
-0.0597120374,
-0.0160098001,
0.0372428857,
0.0257139951,
0.0489692539,
0.0654989183,
-0.0285792593,
-0.044192981,
-0.028957177,
0.0038751136,
-0.0022707211,
-0.0060016811,
0.0257574506,
-0.0297974702,
0.0073161707,
0.0385377891,
0.0446821526,
0.0054628537,
-0.0721459538,
0.0042415108,
0.0164275505,
0.0265275724,
-0.0452220738,
-0.0523853526,
-0.001310677,
0.0092088096,
0.0188794825,
-0.0186959021,
0.0257974602,
-0.0118291331,
-0.0106788734,
0.0005901098,
-0.0087437918,
-0.0205357764,
-0.0118339034,
0.0579621159,
0.0015209162,
0.0615056865,
-0.0022052906,
0.0321467631,
0.0147013823,
0.055120457,
-0.0407987051,
-0.0736312643,
0.0044064736,
-0.0029728655,
-0.0008990786,
-0.0331827402,
0.0378291793,
0.010603698,
0.0171938892,
0.0284790788,
0.0435629003,
-0.0156640206,
0.0537345521,
-0.1439843625,
-0.0547874682,
-0.0406115688,
0.0405556299,
0.0059559671,
0.0326689556,
-0.0390812308,
0.0172509868,
-0.007780083,
0.0352330767,
0.0344353206,
-0.0685928687,
-0.002316776,
0.0073042954,
0.0214448124,
0.0064832275,
0.0468590334,
-0.0979430899,
-0.0357304402,
-0.028537903,
-0.0231017135,
-0.0135011431,
0.0464682728,
0.0158266816,
0.0317540541,
-0.0246567149,
0.0553546399,
-0.0321570113,
0.0153228752,
-0.0383479558,
0.0142889209,
0.0566017367,
-0.0296317302,
0.0482685119,
0.0169733893,
0.0031548499,
0.0409369022,
0.0628546774,
-0.0200035702,
0.0187483467,
-0.0063868533,
-0.0295368284,
-0.0231378041,
-0.0730525702,
-0.0604929924,
-0.0174102653,
0.049594149,
-0.0063862423,
0.0183350537,
0.0027217576,
0.0206347443,
-0.0840160921,
0.0274732728,
-0.0318434313,
-0.001730081,
0.0351860933,
-0.0002213242,
0.0405452661,
-0.0313357338,
0.0135299461,
0.0453508124,
0.0349493958,
-0.0237986799,
0.0110410005,
-0.0367831439,
-0.000175836,
-0.0401212983,
0.031649638,
-0.004077483,
-0.056192629,
-0.0071409657,
-0.0886007324,
0.0549153425,
0.0140863648,
0.0231036674,
0.0335477479,
0.04298044,
-0.0289191399,
-0.0566612072,
-0.0342949852,
0.0745365545,
-0.0007302916,
-0.0192569513,
0.0006935076,
-0.0315358825,
0.0144044124,
-0.0210517235,
0.0121613117,
0.0211148988,
0.0127896005,
-0.0441220663,
-0.0345680602,
0.0049883584,
0.0509838797,
-0.0503198281,
0.018811617,
-0.0458965935,
-0.0533806533,
-0.0069223461,
0.0354789309,
-0.0501751751,
0.0009619395,
-0.0328179263,
-0.0075692628,
0.066127032,
-0.0110304197,
-0.0138567174,
-0.0475896895,
-0.0139138894,
-0.0086773066,
-0.0038224163,
0.0283683185,
0.0028052751,
-0.055826813,
-0.0009692226,
0.0171148498,
0.0406342968,
0.0355074182,
-0.0184985176,
-0.0058120447,
0.0653726012,
-0.0251795352,
0.0411620177,
-0.0064903353,
0.010913427,
0.0684674978,
-0.0025590879,
0.0008505006,
0.0079334425,
0.0363321342,
0.0667373613,
0.0115625896,
0.0279216338,
0.0549375638,
-0.0299332011,
-0.0380342975,
0.0028056807,
0.0479663312,
0.0306442324,
-0.0261929985,
-0.051836051,
-0.0145782307,
0.0223540328,
-0.0470513366,
0.0293736588,
0.0620143712,
0.0071501904,
0.027093919,
-0.0032210518,
-0.0009310682,
-0.0384409912,
-0.0199638605,
-0.0244404543,
0.0657824948,
-0.0241796914,
0.0110453377,
-0.0394923985,
-0.119118005,
-0.0146535989,
-0.0118931485,
0.0268923938,
0.0149229746,
0.0087474063,
0.0164240673,
0.038091518,
-0.0367305167,
-0.0166322794,
0.0005702838,
-0.0880235732,
-0.0043501342,
0.0174040999,
0.036715854,
-0.0096860705,
0.0191467497,
0.0087226285,
0.0104178637,
-0.0047879708,
-0.0314752348,
0.0505978093,
0.0051900111,
0.0459565967,
0.0057745152,
0.0210365709,
-0.0354366824,
-0.0185021814,
-0.0546752587,
-0.0162840839,
0.0204005577,
-0.0584539957,
0.0021709742,
-0.0270704199,
-0.0545915887,
0.0110933129,
0.0000804992,
-0.0161904544,
0.0150827644,
-0.0094917975,
-0.0451921709,
-0.0013805054,
0.027140284,
0.039092239,
0.0472939797,
0.0458316542,
0.0045496281,
0.007361711,
-0.0573658533,
0.0203903057,
0.0053579579,
-0.0081258686,
0.0441544093,
0.0595816337,
0.0182647128,
-0.0064645475,
-0.0276714284,
0.0317321084,
-0.0589439869,
0.0177235808,
-0.0435539111,
-0.0183674078,
-0.0019181606,
0.0241219737,
0.0187157411,
-0.0334133767,
0.016343331,
0.0396143906,
0.0439811312,
-0.1122522205,
-0.0344109423,
-0.0382227115,
-0.0286533199,
0.0252969563,
0.001383402,
-0.0035665974,
0.0239088293,
0.058289472,
-0.0538724922,
-0.0079081785,
-0.0334807672,
-0.0433734395,
0.0060286755,
-0.0058834758,
-0.0125112291,
-0.0232523233,
0.0056985072,
-0.0668853074,
-0.0845765695,
-0.0349041149,
0.0535545796,
-0.0311729144,
-0.0238194056,
0.0100244144,
-0.0097363014,
-0.0163782313,
0.0175699219,
-0.0181767773,
0.0492129438,
0.0098434417,
-0.0133205652,
-0.056968376,
0.0261303447,
0.0338043161,
-0.0073160701,
0.0693383291,
0.0139933517,
-0.0063980455,
-0.0339292176,
-0.0213744156,
-0.0111570945,
-0.0463243872,
-0.0240388736,
0.0009056137,
0.0307479184,
-0.0190541223,
0.0667401776,
0.078441076,
0.0439704135,
0.0031285516,
0.0106396871,
0.00421977,
-0.0436006412,
-0.0096313264,
0.0271336269,
-0.0414920337,
-0.0008640956,
-0.0355320573,
-0.0026871238,
-0.0574283637,
-0.043646317,
-0.0173707064,
-0.047456529,
0.0354193486,
-0.0266167223,
0.0192648433,
-0.0193722397,
-0.080012545,
0.0019010233,
-0.025804963,
-0.0304856803,
-0.0268767718,
0.001132743,
0.0118454611,
0.007115351,
-0.0683162361,
-0.0328608379,
0.0264020078,
-0.0056662974,
-0.0068109985,
0.0503413901,
0.0992464349,
-0.0279557705,
-0.0439789332,
-0.0254007969,
0.0114482418,
-0.0080407932,
-0.0245375168,
0.0772613361,
-0.0149677191,
-0.0004460275,
-0.0550569594,
-0.0120884608,
-0.0268778596,
0.0085307956,
-0.0150357448,
0.0572462641,
-0.0047216318,
-0.0878423378,
-0.0551008396,
0.0513620041,
-0.0051613618,
0.0384015031,
-0.0087718442,
0.0045945025,
-0.0218054578,
0.0020957466,
0.0625425652,
-0.0458453782,
-0.0446239077,
-0.0372026935,
-0.0066700927,
-0.0746617019,
-0.0636016726,
-0.0041184532,
0.0059824199,
0.007087132,
-0.0276330616,
0.005946558,
0.0634610429,
-0.0004977374,
-0.0409297235,
-0.0078708725,
0.0769000426,
0.0199328121,
-0.0065539652,
-0.0261447448,
0.0556334704,
0.048871249,
-0.0304227266,
0.0155982058,
0.0087096551,
-0.0572827943,
-0.0019819315,
0.0018817498,
0.0259384159,
-0.0306151044,
0.0138896899,
0.0033475573,
0.0469668731,
0.074664481,
-0.00093004,
-0.0592828281,
0.0015795155,
0.0345910527,
0.0276892222,
-0.0047134133,
0.012040318,
0.0087624155,
-0.0471595787,
-0.0249618143,
-0.0484023392,
0.0491926633,
-0.0039331601,
-0.0291846562,
0.079190433,
-0.003717819,
-0.0301691275,
-0.0150823798,
-0.0227337442,
-0.0008547092,
-0.0204821918,
-0.0082592312,
-0.0380387753,
-0.0160234254,
0.0320688561,
-0.0884817541,
0.0285269674,
-0.049642209,
-0.0006263721,
-0.0344630741,
0.0711278319,
0.0243716612,
0.0407449454,
0.0210978892,
-0.0201243609,
0.0095619559,
0.0065979622,
-0.0135120181,
-0.0109647168,
-0.0133947348,
-0.0315532535,
-0.0200208277,
0.0116530545,
0.0086389417,
0.0659575611,
-0.0227767546,
-0.0498478487,
-0.0324520953,
0.008378339,
-0.0230882261,
-0.0103985043,
0.0502701588,
-0.0102129756,
-0.0253725518,
-0.0030840547,
0.0196158364,
-0.0172802303,
-0.0051006097,
-0.0000542883,
-0.0226618703,
-0.0528539605,
-0.0039196359,
0.0399171077,
-0.0197103024,
0.0076046688,
0.0449114926,
-0.0602088682,
-0.0175445266,
0.0250605214,
0.0205894466,
0.0188101605,
0.0068391874,
0.0376285687,
-0.0457533039,
-0.0142134009,
0.06145427,
-0.0575380847,
0.0379685424,
-0.0152317695,
-0.0082160393,
0.0369781367,
0.0366119333,
0.0508474,
-0.0569597334,
-0.0099079628,
-0.0208295062,
-0.0606730171,
-0.0282025617,
-5.986461386e-33,
0.0417333953,
-0.0472676307,
-0.0440409668,
0.0229198262,
0.0261969846,
0.0260514971,
-0.0015931723,
0.008329194,
0.0120807644,
0.0386672765,
0.0094585875,
0.0159080327,
0.011914067,
-0.0014200258,
0.0388872474,
-0.0117532071,
0.0152605707,
-0.0072622495,
0.0090283463,
0.0223552436,
0.0227404293,
0.0165017489,
0.0619604811,
-0.1030199304,
0.0782032609,
0.0177955423,
-0.0097528575,
0.0014224137,
0.0241526999,
0.0476678945,
0.0037281662,
0.068812266,
0.0438564606,
-0.040498551,
0.025615003,
0.0604492016,
-0.0067804297,
-0.0350818075,
-0.0111442301,
-0.0354234949,
-0.0353288315,
-0.0062818676,
0.0744609907,
0.0433565341,
-0.0549379811,
0.0567084849,
0.0518881418,
0.0087056328,
0.0236561503,
-0.0392378941,
-0.0531349778,
0.0392823927,
-0.0277007874,
0.0101183243,
0.0029477174,
0.0302798674,
-0.0403858908,
0.1031177193,
0.0102491258,
0.038152419,
0.0018157886,
0.0260943007,
-0.0163536239,
-0.0617842264,
-0.0075706337,
0.0370671786,
0.013291725,
-0.0125201456,
-0.0330735222,
0.0255178846,
-0.0327496603,
0.033246547,
0.0147667034,
0.0431210101,
0.0484995283,
0.0009595029,
-0.0809478983,
0.0394358598,
-0.0130114676,
0.0392849781,
-0.0053960173,
-0.00113437,
-0.0449892171,
-0.0044853794,
0.0250813328,
-0.0520476326,
-0.0275971964,
-0.0068108509,
-0.0260939896,
-0.0124628674,
-0.0647468045,
0.0240387991,
-0.0301317293,
-0.0174221341,
-0.0543180853,
0.0157898907,
0.0029075833,
0.0207576957,
0.0063872845,
0.0121512786,
-0.0580373853,
0.0257439855,
-0.0377575196,
0.0284272656,
0.0163411293,
-0.0201299321,
-0.0090035917,
-0.0246715229,
-0.0434758216,
-0.0056401491,
0.0300740469,
0.0559310168,
-0.0348613262,
0.0479485914,
-0.0037223711,
0.0145012308,
0.016026862,
0.0327854827,
0.0178330429,
0.0424383543,
0.0188277103,
0.0043232692,
-0.0408783257,
-0.0082128681,
0.0028570394,
-0.0163300559,
0.0168030113,
0.0312879272,
-0.0394764096,
-0.0422541387,
-0.0157824997,
-0.0546345934,
2.619e-7,
0.0885430053,
0.0790836364,
-0.0345607325,
-0.0245228224,
0.0388613977,
0.0532784387,
0.0037328785,
0.0335910767,
-0.0029167079,
-0.0258149151,
0.0127544524,
-0.0146793528,
-0.0194287952,
0.024833791,
-0.0643067732,
-0.0141125023,
-0.0484559536,
-0.0063929874,
-0.0204589758,
-0.001932213,
0.0522102006,
0.0546643324,
0.0008600677,
0.0022068284,
-0.0433115251,
0.0326662548,
0.0058691907,
-0.0263723489,
-0.0141061265,
0.0040060291,
0.0141458856,
-0.0125137037,
-0.0064818957,
-0.0036092859,
-0.0386382975,
-0.0333588794,
0.0000971347,
0.0243311636,
-0.0087920772,
0.0016402273,
0.0226683225,
-0.0189278498,
0.0007632808,
0.011641006,
0.0288875327,
-0.0512887016,
-0.0682336837,
-0.0487077199,
-0.0130679067,
0.0196602549,
0.0557483248,
-0.0058633462,
-0.0611902177,
0.0161247775,
-0.0159916803,
-0.0108705545,
-0.0323405452,
-0.0492833629,
0.0190171115,
0.0012656503,
-0.0122388313,
-0.0531986803,
0.0402910635,
0.0356863216,
0.0097294385,
-0.0009829779,
0.0636770651,
1.361052448e-34,
0.0605061874,
-0.0070270994,
-0.0025716785,
-0.0162263531,
0.0185874011,
0.0185246114,
-0.0380257368,
-0.0085198861,
0.0143587403,
-0.0128141595,
0.029717721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04467v1 | RDGCN: Reinforced Dependency Graph Convolutional Network for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-11-08T05:37:49 | 2023-11-08T05:37:49 | Xusheng Zhao, Hao Peng, Qiong Dai, Xu Bai, Huailiang Peng, Yanbing Liu, Qinglang Guo, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) is dedicated to forecasting the
sentiment polarity of aspect terms within sentences. Employing graph neural
networks to capture structural patterns from syntactic dependency parsing has
been confirmed as an effective approach for boosting ABSA. In most works, the
topology of dependency trees or dependency-based attention coefficients is
often loosely regarded as edges between aspects and opinions, which can result
in insufficient and ambiguous syntactic utilization. To address these problems,
we propose a new reinforced dependency graph convolutional network (RDGCN) that
improves the importance calculation of dependencies in both distance and type
views. Initially, we propose an importance calculation criterion for the
minimum distances over dependency trees. Under the criterion, we design a
distance-importance function that leverages reinforcement learning for weight
distribution search and dissimilarity control. Since dependency types often do
not have explicit syntax like tree distances, we use global attention and mask
mechanisms to design type-importance functions. Finally, we merge these weights
and implement feature aggregation and classification. Comprehensive experiments
on three popular datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the criterion and
importance functions. RDGCN outperforms state-of-the-art GNN-based baselines in
all validations. | [
0.0341851637,
0.0618740693,
0.0110910926,
0.0421630442,
-0.0344871879,
-0.0121663464,
-0.0353618413,
-0.0064793569,
-0.0013374337,
-0.0472572856,
-0.0256629195,
-0.029249154,
-0.0392131023,
0.0783059597,
-0.0352885574,
-0.0534098074,
0.0190159567,
0.072601445,
0.0118942149,
-0.0007078251,
0.0279603787,
0.0431597382,
0.0217011422,
0.0168998465,
-0.0306329206,
-0.0278636552,
0.0199916456,
0.0353757106,
0.0338579416,
-0.0550146364,
0.0533109643,
0.0141217522,
-0.0021767868,
-0.0022446646,
0.0000022512,
0.0041718027,
-0.0080473255,
-0.0207007751,
0.0477644578,
0.0061851339,
0.0278959591,
-0.0504496358,
0.0361340381,
-0.0016124893,
-0.0588198975,
-0.0416319408,
0.0277045313,
0.0826029629,
0.0355654135,
0.0797558278,
-0.0297780149,
-0.0261154119,
-0.0002334469,
-0.0407724679,
-0.0002404664,
-0.0289811008,
-0.00253664,
0.0037270999,
-0.0454541519,
0.0528846085,
-0.0338214226,
-0.0008575052,
0.0426253937,
-0.0079138381,
0.0271362979,
0.0277004428,
0.0332672633,
0.0452771485,
-0.0148292156,
0.0780576989,
0.0057268701,
-0.0443676487,
-0.0115099996,
-0.0563280769,
-0.0151235033,
0.0293356888,
-0.0025291692,
-0.0310520791,
0.0009748185,
0.0603684224,
0.0309495367,
0.0214925315,
0.0122803515,
0.0227675159,
0.0107126068,
0.0648701414,
-0.0401599817,
-0.0562191121,
0.0289942063,
0.0420404002,
-0.0362164155,
-0.0346528739,
0.0233202521,
-0.0322710536,
0.0142955026,
-0.0044869762,
0.0010128621,
0.017850196,
-0.0030780216,
-0.0739906207,
-0.0257673059,
-0.0065774694,
-0.0395431034,
0.0253999997,
0.010883417,
0.0075999126,
0.0156625286,
-0.024862444,
-0.0086479634,
0.0529044867,
-0.0682361647,
0.0114585971,
-0.0014774896,
0.0431135781,
-0.0052141254,
-0.0237432942,
-0.0305798352,
-0.0247974247,
-0.0408883765,
0.0015842854,
0.0526007824,
0.0589943528,
0.0077316929,
-0.0021854059,
-0.0225399472,
0.0480649024,
-0.0435555913,
0.0337862521,
-0.0491954014,
0.037749026,
-0.006256674,
0.0337717459,
0.0238467082,
-0.013430208,
0.0147313317,
0.0208661873,
0.05898479,
-0.052656021,
-0.0144851143,
-0.0205838718,
-0.0275084842,
-0.0519167967,
0.0168019775,
-0.0612449721,
-0.0380983986,
-0.0163502973,
-0.0034834829,
0.0112484051,
0.02989682,
0.0182741359,
-0.0081426809,
0.0398986116,
0.0234248955,
-0.056820292,
-0.0542433783,
-0.0207813103,
0.0221285075,
0.0263485778,
-0.0206171535,
0.0535442196,
-0.0061849561,
0.0202336404,
-0.0394593924,
-0.040318653,
0.0027911928,
0.0063965567,
-0.027644204,
-0.0091371844,
-0.1177076101,
-0.0446965061,
0.0144810341,
0.0192228407,
-0.0046139928,
-0.0431686565,
0.0272026695,
-0.0139601603,
-0.0379596613,
0.0502549969,
0.0323044434,
0.0345393047,
-0.0317383967,
0.0018338221,
-0.0435588881,
0.0278321784,
0.0048226793,
0.0005039112,
-0.0183076914,
-0.0069542732,
-0.0233752374,
-0.0528822429,
0.0197291374,
-0.0368317738,
0.0539298207,
-0.0055302046,
0.0473867431,
0.0092153903,
-0.0686698779,
-0.0047681993,
0.0520536005,
-0.0126762195,
-0.0592096932,
0.0192878861,
0.0136589315,
0.0571368076,
-0.0065033692,
-0.0191853065,
-0.0338204093,
-0.0028161886,
-0.0432738848,
0.017579684,
0.0339055359,
0.0164519902,
-0.0117011536,
-0.041643016,
-0.011292791,
-0.0153841069,
0.0202692822,
0.0309056081,
-0.0187039748,
0.0369701497,
0.0014733212,
0.000996697,
-0.0106716882,
0.0024397008,
0.0648968965,
0.0062715453,
0.0495140217,
0.0050572678,
0.061533086,
0.0588287339,
-0.0113540282,
0.0146552268,
0.0236384757,
-0.034610115,
-0.05671129,
-0.004418774,
-0.0844858885,
-0.0631938949,
0.00395456,
-0.0450507924,
-0.0197145492,
0.0206016302,
-0.0430529192,
-0.0297665875,
0.0679480731,
-0.0279486515,
0.0423080288,
-0.0179645717,
-0.0308870059,
0.0194093492,
0.0230499208,
-0.0226294622,
0.0829184055,
-0.0521432534,
0.0302630123,
-0.0511854701,
0.0026458171,
0.0284778699,
0.0207429733,
0.0111119496,
-0.0302442294,
0.0115565294,
-0.007745089,
0.0297708586,
0.0382470451,
-0.0168640669,
-0.0116496822,
-0.0940387771,
-0.0080864327,
-0.0194705427,
0.0610093474,
0.014525786,
0.0024210457,
0.0140575916,
-0.0191837549,
-0.0308853686,
0.0050102938,
-0.0510763414,
-0.0181684364,
0.0138246277,
0.0159034133,
0.040116068,
-0.0404528119,
-0.0417860597,
-0.0239291377,
0.0188559406,
0.0222804286,
-0.0533843264,
-0.0096831499,
0.0571563281,
-0.0274551399,
0.0150500583,
-0.0004222679,
-0.0303853098,
-0.023994457,
-0.0045558638,
-0.0023511474,
0.0280217975,
-0.0159326009,
-0.0199867617,
0.0382200405,
0.0148937842,
-0.0434298366,
0.0237363819,
-0.0457882434,
0.0769899711,
-0.0125268036,
-0.0211975388,
-0.0053741601,
0.0454708561,
0.0051499279,
-0.0135958055,
-0.0557748079,
-0.0100026466,
-0.0158176888,
0.0063260924,
0.0563500747,
0.0034009039,
0.0100481045,
-0.0523040332,
-0.0348625518,
-0.0038714933,
0.0873133466,
0.0256404039,
0.0077739432,
-0.0612202287,
-0.0348904133,
-0.0623253956,
0.0645281225,
0.0331928059,
-0.0050258329,
0.0356727168,
0.0045489506,
0.0007247279,
-0.0226292536,
0.0091637326,
0.0216406696,
0.0441196673,
0.0104475534,
0.0204704069,
0.0321615338,
-0.0393317454,
0.0279688034,
-0.0289266799,
-0.0517032705,
0.0068151988,
0.0045033987,
-0.0199299194,
0.0534985811,
-0.0312491208,
-0.0128952526,
-0.0041629504,
-0.0215501841,
-0.007968653,
-0.0022411838,
0.0362382419,
0.0293614846,
-0.026924558,
0.0284718871,
0.0114111295,
-0.0094457474,
0.0421511978,
-0.0206066966,
0.0178585146,
-0.041187223,
-0.0120637594,
-0.0154608823,
0.0232144892,
-0.037912108,
-0.0351778083,
0.0507684425,
-0.0524771139,
-0.0011552528,
0.0660912842,
0.0387799889,
-0.0780646726,
0.0179384723,
0.0134541281,
0.0401527435,
0.0445345826,
0.0059488486,
-0.0623068884,
-0.0357031338,
-0.0168828815,
0.0134260803,
-0.003425013,
-0.0190885384,
0.0064733308,
-0.0825746581,
0.0115984064,
-0.0333289355,
-0.0210611112,
-0.0824971497,
-0.0497230962,
0.0174390674,
-0.0182624627,
-0.0416899435,
-0.0475830175,
0.0043684645,
0.0162926801,
0.0055471133,
-0.0446742401,
-0.0021925648,
0.0404113196,
-0.003304068,
-0.0243233554,
0.0231818855,
0.056841962,
-0.0220569093,
-0.0237661842,
0.044673916,
-0.0382725336,
-0.0215170737,
-0.0264210589,
0.0954750851,
-0.0011493546,
-0.0096877553,
-0.0246314183,
0.0202356633,
-0.056286823,
0.0027474589,
-0.0207577869,
0.0507120155,
-0.0262653995,
-0.0307851154,
-0.0161938369,
0.0052648988,
0.0419146121,
0.0234388039,
0.0141709093,
-0.0516710728,
-0.0496237576,
-0.0325937644,
0.0125113381,
-0.0926523507,
-0.0338394046,
-0.0216172524,
-0.0257486459,
-0.0167916026,
-0.067859754,
-0.0518802591,
-0.0423766971,
-0.0175050311,
-0.0601809211,
-0.0225480925,
0.0396615043,
-0.0353439227,
-0.053915102,
0.0412384421,
0.0346157253,
0.0433488525,
0.0132400943,
-0.0223866906,
0.065132387,
0.0070659239,
-0.0311215986,
-0.0113818087,
-0.0351928733,
-0.0267426055,
-0.0309387855,
0.0248042047,
-0.0099191777,
0.0057824492,
-0.0111538963,
0.0027418216,
-0.0076018111,
0.0522660092,
-0.0260345433,
0.0054134713,
0.072613351,
0.0236805771,
0.0162770692,
0.0443481617,
-0.0308729205,
0.0566623248,
0.0318542682,
0.0105052916,
-0.0481826626,
0.0041250847,
0.0027359962,
-0.0074996296,
0.0647802353,
0.0458549783,
0.0006205526,
-0.0599905662,
0.0287279505,
-0.0008956459,
-0.0101542547,
-0.039484892,
0.0080559356,
-0.0152855963,
-0.0035393832,
-0.0512616299,
0.0287004132,
0.0244545359,
0.0097058704,
-0.0233757533,
0.0550335832,
0.0288129915,
0.014909395,
-0.0087897712,
0.0108150635,
-0.015768338,
-0.0469057858,
0.0253792778,
-0.0092990231,
0.0042979489,
0.0078300266,
0.0290183406,
-0.0025467062,
-0.0328301936,
-0.0265711173,
-0.0442117751,
0.0420410596,
-0.032214649,
-0.0436218046,
0.0259405803,
-0.0465774238,
0.059380237,
-0.0421495996,
0.0164547153,
0.0008619736,
0.0214581527,
-0.0169752277,
-0.015073319,
0.0393785834,
0.0032358484,
-0.0059530735,
0.0507021435,
0.0514997952,
-0.0473492853,
0.0447171479,
0.0379584171,
-0.0461527854,
-0.0265310686,
-0.0043457393,
0.0287489574,
0.06048337,
0.0171500593,
0.0513308086,
-0.0457590073,
-0.054818444,
0.0373425633,
-0.0196749289,
0.0255676657,
0.0056965626,
0.0546234436,
-0.0026604857,
0.0408232324,
0.0256273579,
-0.0623597614,
0.0025743572,
-0.0317055956,
-0.0253712051,
-0.0436862409,
-7.028996306e-33,
0.0138986455,
-0.0417392179,
-0.0521061942,
0.0267873406,
-0.0380117446,
0.0531739406,
-0.046812091,
0.0165961273,
-0.0053744037,
0.073142305,
0.0217410587,
0.0523917153,
-0.0128447823,
0.0534806922,
0.0264496822,
0.0025351932,
0.0135918846,
0.0134309372,
0.0458128899,
0.0575404875,
0.0431965105,
0.0298136529,
0.0868742615,
-0.1265987456,
0.0214210153,
0.0169297084,
-0.0069855354,
-0.0199645311,
-0.0192919727,
0.0457513593,
0.0126441363,
0.069540903,
0.0520313121,
-0.019267777,
-0.0016693153,
0.0133286677,
-0.0316639356,
-0.0775155574,
-0.0144605162,
-0.0195945073,
-0.049460765,
-0.0088411951,
0.03037153,
0.0310224555,
0.0383100435,
-0.0226059426,
0.0420482345,
-0.0052267117,
-0.0009638233,
-0.0567665957,
-0.02283483,
0.0481906235,
-0.0109640304,
0.0163655896,
-0.0025643916,
0.04701446,
0.019888578,
0.0354926027,
-0.0005465156,
0.0147225074,
-0.0715298057,
0.050534483,
-0.0310379863,
-0.0106898993,
-0.0008529673,
0.0711067542,
-0.0216130055,
-0.0300605651,
-0.0301504601,
0.0046261437,
0.0106834443,
0.0170637313,
0.0147457719,
-0.0065671825,
0.0350863673,
-0.0078797126,
-0.0843394101,
-0.0182818435,
0.0595085658,
0.0371004492,
0.0260450598,
0.0252773836,
-0.025137987,
-0.0131338648,
0.0250737537,
-0.0356379636,
-0.0219152197,
-0.0309641659,
-0.0273729619,
0.0145234419,
-0.0142896138,
0.055044394,
-0.0216619149,
-0.0650813803,
-0.0146277212,
0.0614227504,
-0.0469079278,
0.0379708484,
0.0335056596,
-0.0095340628,
-0.0829616189,
0.0192938596,
-0.0283956416,
-0.0138451755,
0.0047675865,
-0.0068363436,
0.0941703171,
-0.0006595374,
-0.0748589784,
-0.0304692872,
-0.0127445608,
-0.0144353313,
-0.0190366227,
0.0811084211,
-0.0006828933,
0.0305402521,
-0.0166629348,
0.0911603943,
0.0363095738,
0.0677225888,
-0.0205421783,
0.005220456,
-0.0026492774,
0.0373014398,
-0.0386861786,
-0.0512281954,
-0.0096974662,
0.0360783301,
-0.0185524002,
-0.062265072,
-0.0441953577,
0.0240164828,
3.042e-7,
0.0549628176,
0.0545651577,
0.0033105565,
0.0106917927,
0.0298511572,
0.0469665788,
0.033684209,
0.0442574993,
-0.0292831641,
-0.0221356321,
0.0301633179,
0.0190576464,
-0.0157084446,
0.0217111614,
-0.0863044038,
0.0666211322,
-0.0487932488,
-0.0517168678,
-0.0014008024,
-0.0063979239,
0.0563876145,
0.1010483429,
0.0411659852,
0.0190638378,
0.0179145969,
0.0493649617,
0.0186964646,
0.0072880085,
-0.0155662578,
0.0016939164,
-0.0242406484,
-0.0265426654,
-0.0419139974,
-0.0036249938,
-0.0102219442,
0.0060143145,
0.0285766404,
0.0236347206,
0.0001849248,
-0.0630582944,
0.005661252,
0.0400126986,
0.025805559,
0.0068437173,
0.0577237643,
-0.0411636196,
-0.0414621383,
-0.0746113956,
-0.0275191665,
0.0495568961,
0.0385721996,
0.0343394428,
-0.0178019237,
0.0269439537,
-0.0214826316,
-0.0488203168,
-0.0499778874,
-0.0576256514,
-0.0323162898,
0.0418675691,
0.0022604943,
0.0015237436,
0.0031767485,
0.0280392617,
-0.0134180663,
-0.0194322728,
0.0110221021,
2.726586927e-34,
0.0523276627,
-0.0137608182,
-0.011670786,
-0.0216691494,
0.0132460473,
-0.0047979597,
-0.0744009688,
-0.0013714798,
0.0356827416,
-0.0285998341,
-0.0046783779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04459v1 | Improving Pacing in Long-Form Story Planning | 2023-11-08T04:58:29 | 2023-11-08T04:58:29 | Yichen Wang, Kevin Yang, Xiaoming Liu, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing LLM-based systems for writing long-form stories or story outlines
frequently suffer from unnatural pacing, whether glossing over important events
or over-elaborating on insignificant details, resulting in a jarring experience
for the reader. We propose a CONCrete Outline ConTrol (CONCOCT) system to
improve pacing when automatically generating story outlines. We first train a
concreteness evaluator to judge which of two events is more concrete
(low-level-detailed). This evaluator can then be used to control pacing in
hierarchical outline generation; in this work, we explore a vaguest-first
expansion procedure that aims for uniform pacing. We further use the evaluator
to filter new outline items based on predicted concreteness. Compared to a
baseline hierarchical outline generator, humans judge CONCOCT's pacing to be
more consistent over 57% of the time across multiple outline lengths; the gains
also translate to downstream stories. All code, data, and models are
open-sourced. | [
-0.005334843,
0.0319107585,
-0.0063663647,
0.0093571115,
-0.0479193963,
-0.0197873674,
-0.0151886614,
0.0353152379,
-0.055489745,
-0.0004545229,
0.0311623216,
-0.0388990641,
0.0241477676,
0.0710985214,
-0.0411738716,
-0.0893299282,
0.0044469321,
-0.0098602548,
0.0424511172,
0.0368848182,
0.001507693,
0.0042965994,
-0.0249561202,
0.0150871482,
0.0299236923,
-0.0168835111,
-0.0500214435,
0.0137402127,
0.0022120816,
-0.0724261031,
-0.0069815475,
0.031831909,
0.007166238,
-0.0214305744,
0.0000019914,
-0.0535719432,
-0.0103370585,
-0.0076251053,
0.0176561102,
0.0139098102,
-0.0038316865,
-0.0325545445,
-0.0031208645,
-0.0114676347,
-0.0054796296,
0.0515852384,
0.0064323312,
0.0869206563,
-0.0196471512,
0.0488007627,
-0.0207835007,
-0.0203797109,
-0.0342741311,
-0.0076154163,
0.0318000726,
-0.0117038283,
-0.0347652249,
-0.0419130437,
0.0674810857,
0.0038889851,
-0.0183503926,
-0.0341617316,
0.0205635522,
0.0219354574,
0.0719297826,
0.0515591539,
0.0053383522,
0.0039161369,
-0.038870953,
0.060556177,
-0.0115103759,
-0.0228516813,
0.0327091701,
-0.0553642735,
0.0030408257,
-0.0600738414,
-0.0661526695,
0.0160964727,
-0.0368896537,
0.0047157453,
-0.0103348726,
0.0158339571,
0.0057052588,
-0.014868849,
0.0701173842,
0.0487660952,
0.0119595388,
-0.028481327,
-0.0375266373,
0.0218643006,
0.0283016395,
-0.1192975342,
0.0560477152,
0.076149486,
-0.0063293818,
-0.0095964344,
-0.0717846081,
0.0636136606,
0.0102334879,
0.0012070469,
0.0382275879,
0.0298331827,
-0.0014979019,
0.0096884547,
0.0004911974,
0.0527121834,
-0.0190656129,
-0.0385273471,
-0.0478241295,
0.0992334709,
-0.0153790396,
0.0225898437,
-0.0242000874,
0.0124729751,
-0.0546607077,
-0.0280015431,
-0.0497778617,
0.0143972673,
0.0513581447,
0.013941464,
-0.0237858016,
0.0114200972,
-0.0025040342,
-0.001062486,
-0.0569600239,
-0.00091782,
-0.0839454234,
-0.0078868056,
0.0187067278,
0.0565435216,
-0.0043520555,
-0.0227638036,
0.0217361897,
0.0005675127,
0.0140344556,
0.0255088918,
-0.0534538813,
0.0193786137,
-0.0682670176,
-0.0642851964,
-0.0013522125,
-0.0247037094,
-0.0209529325,
-0.0358541831,
-0.00786692,
-0.0032921603,
0.0002919639,
-0.0270846877,
-0.016910512,
0.0003672601,
-0.0029953958,
-0.0106313685,
-0.0407926738,
0.019026421,
0.0144688403,
0.0415934063,
-0.006767903,
0.015084398,
0.0904037431,
0.0750588328,
0.0358834304,
0.0199336037,
0.0377517082,
0.0219103061,
-0.0095837777,
0.0151031548,
0.0188515857,
-0.0176993497,
-0.0407035798,
0.0751106367,
0.0416933745,
0.0345723331,
-0.0109166577,
0.0341986567,
0.0615440123,
0.0519424938,
0.0255138762,
0.0390944108,
0.0921472982,
-0.0175498016,
-0.014299144,
0.0728875622,
0.0026816416,
0.0238531474,
0.0250910856,
0.025884036,
-0.0222725831,
-0.0052277287,
-0.0032265696,
-0.0413776226,
-0.0122227585,
0.03125339,
0.0002825286,
-0.0470165014,
-0.019327784,
0.0141814472,
-0.0800841749,
0.005164274,
-0.0223687496,
-0.0510678254,
0.0453886688,
0.0307935569,
0.0290389657,
0.1259172708,
0.0372563526,
-0.0015053444,
-0.0319933742,
-0.0016471018,
0.0561387055,
0.0295914765,
0.0050798669,
-0.0339593813,
0.0317268036,
-0.0480018966,
-0.0100014787,
-0.0410817228,
-0.0215244088,
-0.0053517492,
-0.0193198025,
0.0284014586,
-0.0007383536,
-0.0143034421,
-0.0132261422,
0.0513219796,
-0.0559213422,
-0.0304256789,
-0.0120690158,
-0.0059753321,
-0.0084684491,
-0.0153999617,
-0.0142425383,
-0.0110239023,
0.0192788877,
-0.0278397631,
-0.0023029016,
0.0371851251,
-0.0416311771,
0.0150531195,
-0.0101404088,
0.0139143644,
0.0111347353,
-0.0648312494,
0.0221476685,
-0.0466977879,
-0.0215777773,
0.0081709204,
0.0384023152,
0.0236060135,
0.0420423374,
0.0005383958,
-0.0447459295,
-0.0322643742,
0.0684156418,
-0.0087658437,
0.0059147757,
0.0574741885,
0.0374574959,
-0.019239245,
-0.0443955623,
0.0397011377,
0.0289910417,
0.0324979126,
-0.0569358431,
-0.0022136844,
0.0109110689,
-0.0520673096,
-0.0402207151,
-0.0579364263,
0.0084874174,
0.0103771137,
-0.0131776724,
0.0192027595,
-0.0238317326,
-0.0258914586,
0.0231946036,
-0.0464617871,
-0.0163090937,
-0.0035265165,
-0.024101276,
0.0093844309,
0.0331759416,
-0.0347530432,
-0.0232283771,
0.025045462,
-0.0083916746,
0.015598787,
0.0624165982,
-0.0246765576,
-0.0810405016,
0.0650065318,
0.0024528031,
0.0068391263,
-0.0217000153,
-0.003608339,
0.0191085562,
0.0110109579,
0.0551676005,
0.0309445132,
0.0221400037,
0.0129849007,
0.0777029097,
-0.0449711643,
0.0216134042,
0.0169060715,
0.015143008,
0.0739721581,
-0.0391238742,
-0.0529815815,
0.025583474,
0.0667091534,
0.0279022455,
0.0430221744,
-0.050415203,
-0.0486006737,
-0.0044202236,
-0.0338265225,
0.0094446,
-0.076341413,
-0.0188954566,
0.0808261782,
-0.0224344432,
-0.0639252365,
0.0522829071,
-0.0470546372,
-0.0198264755,
0.0356338546,
0.0136135779,
-0.0567603149,
0.0568354055,
0.004488124,
0.020058468,
-0.0025129325,
-0.0090254145,
-0.0431149155,
-0.0052751163,
0.0073486455,
0.0010175299,
0.0317933969,
-0.048394762,
-0.0431460291,
0.0159397125,
-0.0519820154,
-0.0470124744,
-0.0297822002,
-0.0112236748,
-0.0090810964,
0.0474361368,
-0.0358707868,
-0.0042041773,
0.0158444066,
-0.0047094952,
0.0513878651,
-0.0038295824,
-0.0271356869,
-0.0076082037,
-0.0032067858,
0.0575511083,
-0.0294517446,
0.0060200528,
-0.0574595928,
0.0313220285,
0.0449556522,
0.0335629061,
0.0094820978,
-0.0230417624,
0.0460638292,
0.008477997,
-0.0448513478,
-0.0272918511,
0.045126345,
0.0558821261,
-0.0257467348,
-0.0315460637,
0.095919624,
0.0214415472,
-0.0433237143,
0.0333324783,
-0.0447035059,
0.0501748249,
0.0094162542,
-0.0070413002,
-0.0156647488,
0.0089237848,
0.03558046,
0.0513608754,
-0.01629081,
-0.0422395207,
-0.0205789506,
-0.0306007601,
0.030914193,
0.0262633488,
-0.052365113,
0.0288917255,
-0.0184610076,
-0.0164420176,
0.0365154892,
-0.0171452612,
0.0308709648,
-0.0356987789,
0.0065063797,
-0.0275625978,
-0.0987807214,
0.0157568268,
-0.0093905842,
-0.0306808874,
0.0207856111,
0.0296662562,
0.0296406522,
0.0184261743,
0.028852785,
0.0324682854,
-0.0141813112,
0.0366782025,
-0.0248445719,
0.0116875265,
-0.0065950826,
0.0227387324,
-0.0421885997,
0.0594817176,
0.029106088,
-0.083898209,
0.0464781746,
0.0380985774,
-0.045802962,
-0.0215149373,
-0.0212433897,
0.0429889709,
0.0177870132,
0.0414187424,
0.0118338391,
-0.0218174756,
-0.0160647109,
0.0021513607,
0.003023417,
-0.078195408,
-0.0267909151,
-0.0146897268,
-0.0662372038,
0.0485235192,
-0.0786179528,
-0.045511093,
0.0098268325,
0.0650729388,
0.0392068401,
0.036441043,
-0.0210563708,
-0.0236833133,
-0.0512298159,
-0.0069054817,
0.033057142,
0.0033023758,
-0.0460543148,
-0.0184325017,
-0.0581150465,
-0.0371794887,
0.0195914786,
0.0693802685,
-0.0737334341,
-0.0257744044,
-0.0184593238,
-0.0098431949,
0.0173214003,
0.0226522461,
0.0337726474,
-0.0348910317,
0.0470669791,
-0.0774621964,
0.0338654853,
0.0672783926,
-0.0333322585,
0.0559457056,
0.0085312584,
-0.017236609,
-0.0344188884,
-0.0020079068,
0.009573428,
0.0436433144,
-0.0450548418,
-0.0116181383,
-0.0217545927,
0.0210544448,
-0.0259233676,
-0.0438529886,
-0.0298941508,
-0.0634992346,
-0.0013722747,
-0.0309957359,
-0.0118812872,
-0.0320255347,
0.0247185323,
0.0165799093,
-0.0111006889,
-0.0088240048,
0.0055825552,
-0.0668731928,
-0.0041829515,
-0.06163124,
-0.0139328996,
-0.0192030873,
-0.0200118367,
0.0358878598,
0.0095969485,
0.0029352012,
0.0001589423,
-0.0666857138,
0.0493595228,
0.0010859969,
0.0325180143,
0.0266217496,
0.035016872,
-0.0186896902,
0.0058371457,
-0.049899064,
0.0228869691,
-0.0254287198,
-0.0234243572,
0.0296808165,
-0.0199546888,
0.0820919275,
-0.0231346004,
0.0253662579,
0.0099241138,
0.0345488302,
-0.0016185688,
-0.0273214281,
-0.0422297902,
0.0265641306,
-0.0201146584,
0.0125492681,
0.0440573841,
0.0173222926,
0.0263334997,
0.0165574737,
-0.0248852372,
-0.0204275884,
-0.0170993041,
-0.003990917,
0.0275754165,
0.0197293349,
-0.0745988935,
-0.0425743349,
0.0228902549,
0.0830782428,
0.0028459616,
0.0188185349,
-0.0491379499,
0.0304780845,
0.0092242658,
-0.0322158299,
-0.0348243862,
-0.0210922621,
-0.026606841,
0.0443138145,
-0.0359859802,
-0.0541749932,
-5.437943763e-33,
-0.0307107419,
-0.0580683388,
0.0509189144,
0.0057825819,
-0.0893779248,
0.024840666,
-0.0325163864,
0.0242846198,
0.0795009434,
0.007032658,
-0.0032732557,
-0.0056129103,
0.0117043005,
-0.0320755914,
0.030464828,
0.0074592838,
0.0669796169,
0.0111218439,
-0.0663713217,
-0.000676667,
0.0274697766,
0.0200635623,
-0.0086053936,
0.0126903681,
-0.0182955135,
-0.0194174144,
-0.0252892412,
-0.0251679849,
0.0361641161,
0.0346113369,
0.0147083364,
-0.0351805575,
0.041649837,
0.0558843464,
-0.0290594865,
0.0353822298,
-0.0405096263,
-0.0114324465,
0.0167892035,
-0.0112411752,
-0.0153050721,
-0.0704569966,
0.0396750756,
0.0063186949,
-0.010616878,
-0.0247841645,
0.035008207,
-0.0235644188,
-0.0018761712,
-0.0631993636,
-0.0721829385,
0.0003217053,
-0.0270455368,
-0.026673276,
0.0038569253,
0.0360902995,
0.0278978124,
-0.0323877633,
-0.0198969059,
0.0084668379,
-0.0324323997,
0.0440871045,
-0.0056143557,
0.0185855981,
-0.0409655087,
0.0626552701,
-0.0005295713,
0.06415575,
-0.069881402,
0.0567046516,
0.0032418782,
0.0460239872,
0.0355090871,
0.0052787615,
0.0417874008,
0.0142668644,
-0.0347841531,
0.0806179568,
-0.0038604497,
0.0413286835,
0.0394857712,
0.0507359207,
-0.0175115839,
-0.0160630178,
-0.0138109839,
-0.0072388183,
-0.0144866938,
-0.027959941,
0.0218532123,
0.0110608013,
0.0408373103,
0.0049007623,
-0.0010527914,
0.0476467833,
0.0292711128,
0.0072221318,
-0.072170347,
0.0683643296,
0.003728519,
0.0057828757,
-0.0334309526,
-0.0328930169,
0.0280280765,
0.0216958188,
0.0691702813,
0.0179923754,
-0.0029263301,
0.0164413881,
-0.0398444869,
0.0082846237,
-0.0120677575,
0.0217921548,
0.0224175565,
-0.0610124134,
0.021922728,
-0.050206989,
-0.0137945972,
0.0241148137,
-0.0248542242,
-0.030121617,
-0.0003993307,
-0.0270172432,
0.0333089121,
0.0504734293,
-0.0111934356,
0.0169052929,
-0.0116534662,
0.0241427068,
0.0425107069,
-0.0546718501,
-0.0113508767,
0.014255615,
2.625e-7,
-0.0278510116,
0.0152496388,
0.0095469998,
0.0385127403,
0.0016673914,
-0.0338208862,
-0.0107248975,
-0.0045282333,
-0.0364625901,
-0.0329956077,
0.0619782247,
0.0307889767,
0.0432807468,
0.0349165127,
-0.0481623672,
-0.0168623701,
-0.0688386634,
-0.0029062475,
-0.0667896494,
-0.0293770321,
0.0475927815,
-0.0507369041,
0.0309655219,
0.0077316351,
0.0321329013,
-0.0133907599,
0.0443434604,
-0.0332924798,
0.0002796534,
0.036375124,
-0.0183632001,
-0.0363210179,
-0.0475394577,
-0.0281627644,
-0.0382942706,
-0.0170830414,
0.0118378233,
0.0562232435,
-0.0140392613,
0.0044118399,
0.0296607483,
-0.0135804079,
-0.0221621804,
0.0065269498,
0.0418377146,
0.0477122813,
-0.0049857078,
0.0143442778,
0.0189009253,
-0.0072785215,
-0.0223648679,
0.0081609841,
0.0031623091,
0.0256826822,
0.0207456555,
0.0295509286,
-0.0113877859,
-0.0336527899,
-0.0098828394,
0.0799451023,
-0.0365261212,
-0.0168461725,
-0.0519524477,
-0.0113336388,
-0.039553389,
-0.0891837403,
-0.0301725119,
2.627378877e-34,
0.0024122444,
-0.0266553517,
0.0010714531,
0.0412707888,
0.0377394333,
-0.0001474326,
0.00413058,
-0.0012873173,
0.0184043981,
-0.0412271768,
-0.0278359689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04453v2 | Lewis's Signaling Game as beta-VAE For Natural Word Lengths and Segments | 2023-11-08T04:34:30 | 2024-04-02T07:53:07 | Ryo Ueda, Tadahiro Taniguchi | cs.CL | cs.CL | As a sub-discipline of evolutionary and computational linguistics, emergent
communication (EC) studies communication protocols, called emergent languages,
arising in simulations where agents communicate. A key goal of EC is to give
rise to languages that share statistical properties with natural languages. In
this paper, we reinterpret Lewis's signaling game, a frequently used setting in
EC, as beta-VAE and reformulate its objective function as ELBO. Consequently,
we clarify the existence of prior distributions of emergent languages and show
that the choice of the priors can influence their statistical properties.
Specifically, we address the properties of word lengths and segmentation, known
as Zipf's law of abbreviation (ZLA) and Harris's articulation scheme (HAS),
respectively. It has been reported that the emergent languages do not follow
them when using the conventional objective. We experimentally demonstrate that
by selecting an appropriate prior distribution, more natural segments emerge,
while suggesting that the conventional one prevents the languages from
following ZLA and HAS. | [
0.0235233996,
0.0441341437,
-0.0508049801,
-0.0031950069,
-0.037272498,
-0.0200026538,
-0.0174152609,
0.0446212143,
-0.0541889593,
0.0084086601,
-0.0264955685,
-0.0684296489,
0.0423006937,
0.0366909951,
0.0436429009,
-0.033291325,
-0.0039401865,
-0.0503371656,
0.044967901,
-0.0213917382,
0.0039434633,
-0.0623706169,
0.0005297629,
0.0117042027,
0.0341277905,
0.0517445803,
-0.0389130451,
-0.0357232429,
-0.0040980093,
0.001973493,
-0.0842590109,
0.0111563373,
-0.002971444,
0.0268766414,
0.0000017209,
-0.0481113568,
0.000400132,
-0.0173270982,
-0.0394448265,
-0.0311490856,
0.0847519413,
0.0068039894,
-0.017451698,
-0.022077119,
-0.0179619603,
-0.0207938757,
0.0950724557,
-0.0530469157,
-0.0268388148,
0.0680962577,
0.0018341682,
-0.0012903467,
0.052230414,
-0.0314918645,
0.0072800224,
-0.0332691371,
0.0371930152,
-0.0378197804,
0.051863566,
-0.0015259798,
-0.0477408543,
0.0295679402,
0.0165864583,
0.0080010826,
-0.0356245004,
0.038615156,
0.0513050817,
-0.0448120683,
-0.0121718915,
0.0602033399,
0.0119132036,
-0.0206045434,
0.0144473286,
0.0107401554,
0.029652141,
-0.0074055553,
-0.0207377523,
0.0361663215,
0.0183078665,
0.0189846139,
0.0623509958,
0.0262307562,
0.0089848768,
-0.0468150154,
-0.0000367104,
0.1038798317,
0.035245046,
-0.0251712762,
-0.0534368381,
-0.0279618502,
0.0083146831,
-0.0672454536,
-0.0052897604,
0.0016041988,
-0.0031514694,
0.0430528,
-0.0229199193,
-0.0106440615,
-0.0131410705,
-0.0176607016,
0.0222043209,
-0.0191112999,
0.0267761517,
-0.0114847217,
0.0251422152,
-0.0110172769,
0.0245337468,
0.0133374417,
-0.0421807989,
0.0369638391,
-0.0199140441,
-0.0263571423,
-0.0241671763,
0.0340949297,
-0.0145272342,
-0.0267114807,
0.0022796469,
0.0235336311,
0.0139952879,
-0.0222980417,
-0.0164985135,
-0.0202930104,
-0.0197336972,
-0.0135974577,
-0.0391912386,
-0.0279407017,
-0.0440219007,
0.0195465367,
-0.000422486,
-0.0548823886,
-0.0136322193,
-0.0070885262,
-0.0030505473,
0.0110754613,
-0.0198175739,
0.0526678562,
-0.0035755916,
-0.0112465406,
0.0504788905,
0.0362951159,
-0.0693153292,
-0.0267339516,
0.0123973247,
-0.0596289858,
0.0171966627,
-0.0287945513,
-0.0132114906,
-0.0350093991,
-0.0207271054,
-0.0480556227,
-0.0405859128,
0.0494093411,
-0.0427942984,
0.0327068307,
0.0127232997,
-0.0038705585,
0.1060407609,
0.047414124,
0.0604814216,
-0.0337788984,
0.0457507521,
0.0034758467,
0.0369880795,
0.052948501,
-0.0071384939,
0.0159635358,
0.0208210573,
-0.0454466119,
0.0021148371,
0.0448060706,
0.0004376153,
0.0433694087,
-0.0369198173,
-0.0887733847,
0.0101655908,
0.0877018496,
0.0394068956,
-0.0000415378,
0.040391691,
0.019878041,
-0.0028611894,
0.0374893919,
0.0311312061,
-0.0188977029,
-0.0565133318,
0.023023434,
0.0156356059,
0.0093662674,
-0.0109923622,
-0.0323695093,
0.000250679,
-0.0235514231,
0.0119852237,
-0.0615346245,
0.0487313047,
0.0015247088,
-0.0239084307,
-0.0329670683,
0.030044714,
-0.0023156395,
-0.0090930033,
-0.0891413167,
0.0195790511,
-0.0044199238,
0.0125138862,
-0.0075741429,
0.0118409451,
0.036370039,
-0.0079106009,
0.080277659,
0.0084354468,
-0.0081318412,
0.0090248724,
-0.0044714003,
0.0058294195,
0.0179621764,
0.0149524724,
0.0546002276,
-0.0700032562,
0.0307613183,
-0.0061042611,
-0.0627519712,
-0.006987948,
0.0228895731,
-0.0056309854,
0.0058211312,
-0.0043948004,
-0.0214973893,
0.059201289,
-0.0154944239,
-0.0444135852,
0.0743806511,
-0.0213619433,
0.0026976238,
0.0065365518,
0.0172725488,
0.0014031079,
0.0021054861,
0.0452072583,
-0.0360374302,
0.0519728661,
-0.0332192034,
0.0424657427,
-0.0327999406,
0.0869898945,
-0.0347831659,
0.0632502437,
0.0187076498,
0.034119226,
-0.0170788653,
0.0126275457,
-0.0071774987,
0.0184160564,
0.0348677821,
-0.0033259711,
-0.0088275699,
-0.0101658134,
0.0412119105,
-0.0471410789,
-0.0005893319,
0.0311401375,
0.0156210186,
-0.0092507731,
0.0527656116,
0.0175108816,
-0.0006972432,
-0.0413492844,
-0.0497601964,
-0.0150321843,
0.0056874175,
0.0411266126,
-0.0154179372,
-0.0212632883,
-0.0282540489,
0.0443497188,
-0.0353446156,
0.0504893064,
0.0162879899,
-0.0014990707,
0.0361563228,
-0.0094527705,
-0.093509838,
-0.0454725996,
-0.0269780308,
-0.0222846903,
0.0402386077,
0.0290808044,
-0.0021850809,
-0.0755474195,
0.0055171051,
-0.0097444383,
0.0180967022,
-0.0202875324,
-0.0266446583,
0.0207819361,
-0.0310997963,
0.0491277725,
0.0154952854,
0.0279321019,
0.0326237567,
-0.0047137081,
-0.0227128323,
-0.0188584831,
-0.0370396934,
-0.0764587522,
0.0202349033,
-0.1077151969,
-0.0636802688,
0.0319302902,
0.1011188701,
-0.0164345913,
-0.0278339516,
-0.024930818,
0.014156607,
0.0177109148,
-0.1102464125,
0.0036605326,
-0.0321690105,
-0.0457945466,
0.0152032878,
-0.0247167461,
-0.0359217189,
0.0590519011,
-0.0363220684,
0.0048774974,
-0.0556276329,
0.0106184743,
-0.0112245269,
0.059940327,
0.0444114096,
-0.0167171545,
0.0754743516,
-0.0172999259,
-0.0426444933,
-0.0031061934,
0.0430053622,
-0.003643488,
-0.0346262306,
-0.0418805219,
-0.0030548933,
-0.0015339915,
-0.005681139,
0.0249489639,
0.0005553218,
-0.0050774845,
0.0137021989,
0.0265632775,
-0.0293914098,
0.0027425271,
0.0434112996,
0.0346585028,
-0.0058154785,
0.0104332343,
0.0087669035,
-0.0114072952,
0.0251163542,
0.0487843826,
0.0194430333,
0.0377364792,
-0.058139354,
-0.0131920669,
-0.0072647124,
0.0138722081,
0.0498906039,
0.0217350218,
0.0054573822,
0.0246086866,
0.0018366743,
-0.0342212468,
0.0543738194,
0.000039589,
0.0372649804,
0.0096876211,
0.0574391149,
0.017778093,
0.0056968094,
0.0529188737,
-0.0231867582,
0.0602052324,
-0.0144741526,
0.0236418806,
-0.0849145055,
0.0190140121,
-0.0128948521,
-0.0209046863,
-0.0390112549,
-0.0307290331,
-0.0055644428,
-0.0932398215,
0.0058865496,
0.0098748254,
-0.0514349677,
0.023402527,
-0.0304966029,
-0.0132182883,
0.00365829,
-0.0191144366,
0.0337108448,
0.0009493693,
0.0239125863,
0.0225560367,
-0.0479640923,
-0.0432435982,
-0.0411021672,
-0.0409232378,
0.09511967,
0.0088402852,
0.040207196,
-0.0637082085,
-0.0224476587,
-0.0056595793,
0.0075322394,
-0.0270573981,
0.0260209311,
-0.0075891721,
0.0354115851,
0.0002028805,
-0.0170720611,
-0.0081433486,
-0.0095202308,
0.0017762472,
0.0259171613,
0.0296704583,
-0.0049241073,
-0.0795824528,
0.0187380482,
0.0135043245,
-0.005052764,
0.0365533978,
0.0282768048,
-0.0639310777,
-0.0281097218,
-0.0100171268,
0.0095708659,
0.0133211408,
-0.0801595449,
-0.0401979759,
0.0168346614,
-0.1365924329,
-0.0927354842,
-0.027129367,
0.0078059826,
0.0871658251,
0.0201699045,
0.0061613303,
-0.032665614,
-0.0180533435,
0.0439432524,
-0.0599349961,
-0.028190136,
-0.0336874165,
-0.0336366035,
-0.0082517192,
-0.0229242444,
-0.081610024,
-0.0401479006,
0.0150855258,
-0.0640541688,
-0.0608699545,
0.0313297249,
0.0368105471,
0.0315459706,
-0.0200199615,
-0.0122394208,
-0.0480433367,
0.017011689,
0.037515685,
0.0409571491,
0.0361572057,
0.0229265913,
-0.0500673316,
0.0297001544,
0.0192632787,
0.0125670834,
0.0110074673,
0.0086163674,
0.062267378,
-0.0416598246,
-0.0222030561,
-0.0087378398,
0.0319013856,
-0.0348056294,
-0.0384254307,
-0.0647229403,
-0.0306725018,
-0.0022422096,
-0.0209436659,
0.0285205729,
-0.0117572555,
0.0077623753,
-0.0161270555,
0.0489765331,
0.0478598438,
-0.0159345455,
-0.0186368152,
0.0345840864,
0.0795232356,
0.0413155109,
0.0845023915,
0.0512269959,
0.0299250428,
0.0119135156,
0.05468693,
0.0587075353,
-0.0423475839,
0.0636189729,
0.0004766849,
-0.0262393188,
0.0055817417,
-0.0642890558,
0.0024131963,
0.03875212,
-0.0488440879,
-0.027642604,
0.0188312344,
0.0877528489,
0.0123956893,
0.0531867221,
0.0341633894,
-0.0739690661,
0.0182519089,
-0.0297658872,
-0.0071547148,
-0.0280319583,
-0.0231470112,
0.0034239166,
0.0166717563,
-0.0528544597,
0.0130099552,
0.0635629073,
0.0323066898,
0.0054805959,
-0.0512933508,
0.0147748562,
-0.0139967445,
0.0007088407,
-0.0291740354,
0.0049203797,
-0.0212357938,
0.0169945173,
-0.054631941,
-0.0168768372,
0.0021185337,
0.0596947595,
0.0474877097,
0.0180212203,
0.0278768577,
0.0719060227,
-0.044026006,
0.0468423516,
-0.037838269,
-0.0370512865,
0.0495203473,
-0.0151547287,
0.0311023556,
-6.023180891e-33,
-0.0088043613,
0.0088457987,
0.0215525664,
0.0008229356,
0.0026236323,
-0.0140592773,
-0.0350721665,
0.0355734527,
-0.0185479783,
-0.0028678188,
-0.0020422323,
-0.0128571,
0.024265809,
-0.0071464079,
-0.0046235714,
-0.0309679024,
-0.0204719156,
-0.0153484978,
-0.0046501481,
-0.0217170957,
-0.0267838482,
-0.0180576853,
0.0637291521,
0.0434566662,
0.0693702772,
0.0178946797,
-0.0088954773,
-0.0090794042,
0.0080343364,
0.0337898098,
-0.0320801958,
0.0235121474,
-0.0085363267,
-0.0274796467,
-0.0180780906,
-0.0174864791,
-0.0022707523,
-0.029196281,
0.0622734688,
-0.0294460375,
-0.0510185324,
-0.0050847749,
0.0191156734,
0.0116822589,
-0.0703235343,
0.0317312889,
0.0024239535,
-0.0300397407,
-0.0047757258,
0.041997198,
-0.0440614596,
0.01822396,
0.0100819794,
0.030624995,
0.0468706377,
-0.0465680994,
-0.0294266436,
-0.0797386393,
0.0182789043,
0.1155727506,
0.0855923742,
0.0100169508,
0.0385702923,
0.0289173853,
0.0377690382,
0.0279094018,
0.0831652284,
0.0148142157,
0.0099578118,
-0.0250739735,
0.0385076813,
-0.0154075511,
-0.0031888774,
0.0083742132,
-0.0268644225,
0.0076829591,
-0.0194849726,
-0.0313807353,
0.0693296194,
-0.0357526653,
-0.0118466057,
0.0106297527,
-0.0554677062,
-0.0369549058,
-0.0208154302,
-0.0204061549,
0.008334606,
-0.0331568345,
-0.0062960777,
-0.0075828251,
0.0400129147,
-0.0039614877,
0.044897642,
-0.0237199645,
-0.0541341566,
-0.0566502623,
0.016455818,
0.0414231345,
0.011688346,
-0.016048016,
-0.0476176664,
-0.0254826546,
-0.0087121222,
0.0168990009,
0.004786531,
0.0167269576,
-0.0373613425,
0.0017490244,
-0.0351367556,
0.0078409649,
0.0143325441,
-0.0530109853,
0.0628638566,
-0.036705479,
0.0262384843,
-0.0098271463,
0.0053074374,
0.0134247355,
0.0366422012,
-0.023744043,
0.0183950681,
0.0732961968,
-0.0497877337,
0.0263852365,
-0.0300261471,
0.0151593443,
-0.0142187178,
0.0443091653,
0.0087287426,
-0.0369867496,
-0.0183772966,
-0.0102242203,
2.731e-7,
0.0472019985,
0.0150175542,
0.0746296272,
-0.0051288675,
0.0056798072,
0.0007845773,
-0.0276206955,
0.0199443586,
-0.0131486626,
-0.0468569137,
0.0384969823,
0.0083366549,
-0.005410912,
0.0019671335,
-0.0720759928,
-0.0095374743,
-0.039958369,
0.0062947525,
-0.0009610914,
-0.0025909017,
0.0096809175,
0.0468396321,
0.0092046149,
-0.0005493081,
-0.0176889487,
-0.0096859215,
-0.0025620379,
-0.0445700213,
0.0148979332,
0.056509383,
-0.02526257,
-0.0538028479,
0.0111366827,
0.0078593604,
0.0089166462,
0.0205256026,
0.0210657474,
-0.0052891644,
-0.0102530336,
0.0276639294,
0.0374437794,
-0.0197401959,
-0.0309498366,
0.0114994431,
0.0315370597,
-0.011176913,
-0.0501825623,
0.0323966667,
-0.011765114,
0.0130237136,
-0.0518381819,
-0.0212165173,
-0.0005976288,
-0.0042608553,
-0.0059011634,
0.0119044855,
0.0535049401,
0.0060418691,
0.0136515722,
0.0356843546,
-0.0256233178,
-0.0756910369,
-0.0268820152,
0.0205854625,
0.0271846391,
-0.0315151736,
-0.027381286,
2.497602005e-34,
0.0437968001,
0.0111139286,
0.0217011813,
0.0258877072,
0.0167670138,
-0.024726836,
0.0102289859,
0.0037154534,
0.0809202716,
-0.0612872168,
-0.0504394472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04449v1 | Recursion in Recursion: Two-Level Nested Recursion for Length Generalization with Scalability | 2023-11-08T04:20:56 | 2023-11-08T04:20:56 | Jishnu Ray Chowdhury, Cornelia Caragea | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Binary Balanced Tree RvNNs (BBT-RvNNs) enforce sequence composition according
to a preset balanced binary tree structure. Thus, their non-linear recursion
depth is just $\log_2 n$ ($n$ being the sequence length). Such logarithmic
scaling makes BBT-RvNNs efficient and scalable on long sequence tasks such as
Long Range Arena (LRA). However, such computational efficiency comes at a cost
because BBT-RvNNs cannot solve simple arithmetic tasks like ListOps. On the
flip side, RvNNs (e.g., Beam Tree RvNN) that do succeed on ListOps (and other
structure-sensitive tasks like formal logical inference) are generally several
times more expensive than even RNNs. In this paper, we introduce a novel
framework -- Recursion in Recursion (RIR) to strike a balance between the two
sides - getting some of the benefits from both worlds. In RIR, we use a form of
two-level nested recursion - where the outer recursion is a $k$-ary balanced
tree model with another recursive model (inner recursion) implementing its cell
function. For the inner recursion, we choose Beam Tree RvNNs (BT-RvNN). To
adjust BT-RvNNs within RIR we also propose a novel strategy of beam alignment.
Overall, this entails that the total recursive depth in RIR is upper-bounded by
$k \log_k n$. Our best RIR-based model is the first model that demonstrates
high ($\geq 90\%$) length-generalization performance on ListOps while at the
same time being scalable enough to be trainable on long sequence inputs from
LRA. Moreover, in terms of accuracy in the LRA language tasks, it performs
competitively with Structured State Space Models (SSMs) without any special
initialization - outperforming Transformers by a large margin. On the other
hand, while SSMs can marginally outperform RIR on LRA, they (SSMs) fail to
length-generalize on ListOps. Our code is available at:
\url{https://github.com/JRC1995/BeamRecursionFamily/}. | [
0.0268806387,
0.040978834,
0.0078588212,
0.009947164,
-0.0486914739,
0.0037867173,
0.0046508792,
-0.0258540232,
-0.0329488814,
-0.0053512133,
0.0256789364,
-0.0688618943,
0.0091472147,
0.0316779837,
-0.01449522,
-0.0570366234,
0.0143847242,
-0.0333725438,
-0.0056042261,
-0.0211366042,
-0.0161197186,
-0.0146573111,
-0.0244619977,
0.0198774785,
0.0014473652,
0.004052313,
-0.0487398542,
-0.015912652,
-0.0190822147,
-0.0343752876,
0.0209845994,
0.0087714633,
0.0502671786,
0.0621013753,
0.0000019279,
0.0053612338,
-0.000732269,
0.0005517345,
-0.0270907599,
0.0035239605,
-0.040323101,
0.0016475805,
0.0048548658,
0.0252686441,
0.0047327154,
-0.0566775277,
0.055275619,
0.0366296843,
0.0415278934,
0.058518704,
0.0095298262,
-0.1077627912,
0.0572362952,
-0.0457103811,
0.0441768132,
-0.0734425783,
0.0007448802,
0.0079974858,
0.0162364691,
-0.016222842,
-0.0161755811,
-0.0066180439,
0.0607673749,
0.0176210999,
-0.0172270723,
-0.0116718961,
-0.0244965833,
0.008531386,
0.003859594,
0.0310718715,
-0.0661050156,
-0.0289943386,
0.0217626337,
-0.0010765149,
0.0072321566,
-0.070797123,
-0.0283926129,
0.0353800207,
-0.0284609869,
-0.044961039,
-0.0284598321,
-0.0274480488,
0.0450244471,
-0.0156917479,
-0.031757459,
0.05790307,
0.0248872824,
-0.0208966956,
-0.0480003655,
-0.0374110229,
-0.0009624221,
-0.0914394036,
0.009481471,
0.0777546093,
-0.0630696416,
0.0286397636,
-0.0107235294,
0.0068887067,
-0.0154205449,
-0.0072511132,
0.0190348849,
0.0382729769,
0.0006887796,
0.0098444289,
-0.0429164954,
0.0490885451,
-0.0334206782,
-0.0055652582,
-0.0230869781,
0.0026266489,
-0.0179193858,
-0.0092391847,
-0.0630284175,
0.0266814306,
-0.0025155954,
-0.0244870875,
-0.0289794467,
-0.0066285129,
0.0030882361,
0.0266218726,
0.0023349456,
-0.0039599813,
-0.0337597765,
-0.0079409489,
0.0147379935,
0.0316523872,
-0.0425892361,
-0.0025814599,
0.0424990766,
-0.0098090032,
-0.0145457005,
0.0209513735,
-0.0301048886,
-0.0123481601,
0.0140300263,
0.0914010182,
0.0249671042,
-0.0333255418,
-0.0086379796,
-0.0208806917,
-0.0427283049,
-0.0792680532,
0.0519064963,
-0.0822809041,
0.0243592411,
-0.0416610427,
-0.0436923951,
0.0376220085,
0.0374037698,
0.0306108482,
0.01083358,
0.0464772619,
0.0134771224,
-0.0282125808,
-0.0214020964,
0.0119732451,
0.0231062174,
0.043325413,
0.0509807505,
0.0577814505,
-0.0081493771,
-0.0195071623,
-0.0283671971,
0.0136042759,
-0.0023851201,
-0.0621543042,
0.0043198699,
0.0024742687,
-0.0216091871,
0.0586824082,
-0.0270452108,
0.0078153573,
-0.0373811387,
-0.0214671921,
-0.0111265099,
0.0115087759,
0.0454090051,
0.04581967,
0.0719834045,
-0.0717723221,
-0.0142769348,
0.0634014383,
-0.0388764851,
0.0412116162,
-0.0562276281,
0.0341947749,
-0.0080861198,
0.0424365886,
-0.0395657644,
-0.0421457663,
-0.0396711715,
0.0012353257,
0.0065642898,
-0.0165516082,
0.0356392637,
0.0479083993,
-0.0449220985,
0.0518671162,
0.0102464939,
-0.0350537226,
-0.0365887843,
-0.0200655237,
-0.0138392057,
0.0069195214,
0.0344775729,
-0.0462278575,
-0.0439043082,
0.0022039514,
-0.0383947454,
0.0181620121,
0.0207637623,
0.0036318048,
-0.0154215069,
-0.0626484379,
-0.0440685041,
0.0252548046,
0.0113906721,
0.0464506447,
0.0333911888,
-0.0142448321,
0.0275931247,
-0.0223359317,
-0.0433831997,
0.0102870734,
-0.035619732,
0.0045260116,
0.0371874049,
0.0194669329,
0.0606873743,
0.0118243238,
0.0224130973,
0.0289603285,
0.0363235995,
-0.0094107501,
-0.0378841609,
-0.0323204212,
-0.071343936,
-0.0430363193,
0.0484102331,
-0.0004918766,
-0.0325900279,
0.028088579,
-0.0743320435,
-0.0391889662,
0.0551070943,
-0.0823998973,
0.0056967847,
0.007719107,
0.0409871265,
0.0085498756,
-0.0296737049,
-0.0123565467,
0.0508056656,
-0.0221220143,
0.0438265651,
-0.0498533249,
-0.0642079115,
0.0070827515,
-0.0523538664,
-0.0583254099,
0.0128840869,
-0.0237204898,
-0.0240008272,
0.0149627598,
-0.0128343636,
0.0018101857,
-0.009189357,
-0.0202361196,
0.0396350026,
-0.0425577164,
0.0492330492,
-0.0028110079,
0.0385161117,
0.0425312184,
0.0002659426,
-0.0619271696,
0.0407361649,
0.0059841787,
0.0220968127,
0.0507782176,
-0.0171084926,
-0.0710081607,
-0.0036359979,
-0.0761070028,
-0.0263210703,
0.0164750535,
-0.0147162918,
-0.0168954711,
-0.0194063578,
0.0115708709,
-0.0311268866,
0.0418857448,
-0.0372997858,
0.0076294956,
0.014010868,
-0.0178863611,
0.0483181216,
0.057249669,
0.0165472478,
-0.0204140712,
0.0229592435,
0.0104906866,
0.0198931824,
0.0311731957,
-0.0331242681,
-0.0288773719,
0.0063262186,
0.012514404,
0.024910247,
0.0854553357,
-0.0504939668,
-0.0056365542,
-0.0494553521,
-0.0621132739,
0.0696445256,
0.0211800337,
-0.0096826414,
-0.0375320241,
0.0040178723,
0.0167976655,
-0.0328265615,
0.0063492842,
0.05201279,
-0.0265297033,
0.0019770355,
-0.0530756786,
-0.0031775811,
-0.0736636892,
0.0590771064,
0.06872686,
0.0051006027,
-0.0017229862,
-0.0227172207,
-0.0204460882,
-0.0116212713,
0.0072933924,
-0.0177915785,
0.0465286188,
-0.0078363987,
0.0107557382,
-0.0364443809,
-0.0314320028,
-0.0301243886,
0.0478009209,
0.0145264687,
0.0276922714,
-0.0012781799,
-0.0388934985,
-0.0634549633,
0.0411735401,
0.0612200312,
0.050795123,
-0.0069034384,
0.0231776852,
-0.0415302962,
0.0270984229,
0.0277644061,
0.0100227725,
0.0712708682,
0.0040790774,
-0.0353142768,
0.0197585281,
0.0298247859,
0.0109554585,
-0.0472514518,
0.0171748139,
-0.0102640027,
-0.0366945304,
-0.0222685281,
0.0508542806,
0.0333244056,
-0.0748952776,
-0.009569441,
0.0401563197,
-0.0081560044,
0.0043338644,
0.0061625843,
-0.028372759,
0.0437920056,
0.0168231297,
-0.0084512588,
-0.0847299621,
-0.0097538568,
0.0444728769,
-0.0307368636,
-0.0108757354,
-0.0556681678,
-0.002637872,
-0.1467218399,
0.0008197984,
0.0192865077,
-0.0323486663,
-0.0624366254,
0.0154815316,
-0.0280956924,
0.031484928,
-0.009036269,
0.059587121,
0.0017422574,
0.0133769391,
0.0244348403,
-0.0760979429,
0.0075632744,
0.0305103306,
-0.0334344022,
-0.012757198,
0.0745301172,
0.0086591784,
0.0128868222,
-0.0185437705,
0.0150209963,
0.0197788998,
0.0185847543,
0.0248722937,
-0.0285441335,
0.0182944387,
-0.0060527404,
0.0129784001,
0.0103330305,
-0.0325063728,
0.0015702614,
0.0265947115,
0.0602361634,
0.0206234884,
-0.0249738693,
-0.0089814011,
-0.0150504755,
0.0069711711,
0.0435940847,
0.0351294465,
0.0286925323,
-0.0773220584,
-0.0161699951,
-0.0364768915,
-0.0585681088,
-0.0229422059,
0.0250501949,
0.022444563,
-0.0391959846,
-0.0414269194,
0.0004400438,
0.0033224442,
0.0620787032,
-0.0362007916,
-0.0359819084,
0.0040843925,
-0.0264352281,
-0.0372235775,
-0.0461388379,
-0.0276368055,
0.0488309115,
-0.0277975444,
0.0595734455,
-0.0087090638,
-0.0078305369,
-0.0310004018,
0.0324825868,
-0.0610582456,
-0.03012136,
0.0099297483,
0.0379149914,
0.0206471477,
0.0167810712,
0.0179660935,
0.0308393873,
0.043353159,
0.0123234726,
-0.0087345997,
0.0020381776,
0.0413184017,
-0.0167883765,
-0.0020595223,
0.0282974727,
-0.0417020507,
0.0394491814,
0.0277838372,
0.0469482355,
-0.0033105067,
0.0123329684,
-0.0027104823,
0.0355558507,
0.0177935008,
0.0513795167,
-0.012521592,
0.0110516837,
0.0584662147,
-0.0295570251,
0.0122786164,
-0.0372409038,
0.0209172443,
-0.0239724331,
0.0133950692,
0.026583435,
-0.0290804934,
0.0688846409,
-0.0038786207,
0.0207394417,
0.0268599652,
0.0543507598,
0.0077199806,
0.0204690807,
-0.0237145461,
-0.0133230034,
0.0218625665,
0.0180387795,
0.0431041941,
-0.004516142,
-0.0202211663,
0.0298051517,
0.0661869347,
-0.0235948469,
0.0164887793,
-0.0671959445,
-0.043598529,
-0.0044833762,
0.017784398,
0.0706595108,
0.0353277028,
-0.0359911732,
-0.0183287337,
0.0046409271,
-0.0149190826,
0.0021464876,
-0.0133744273,
-0.0411453508,
0.0129219331,
0.0534587689,
-0.0161252953,
-0.0095176995,
0.0661086664,
0.0404144675,
0.0908296779,
-0.0112812351,
0.0298570413,
-0.0150028253,
-0.0700054839,
-0.0079235099,
0.0238037072,
-0.0025282833,
-0.0366768986,
-0.0364638641,
-0.0461391956,
0.0170022901,
0.0437724777,
0.0527827591,
0.0004985142,
0.0538267717,
0.0410811082,
-0.0005397334,
-0.0014324655,
0.0180958305,
0.0206408985,
-0.0110291736,
-0.0183538906,
-0.045952566,
-5.44160249e-33,
-0.0396122038,
0.0115197143,
0.0543368608,
-0.0036193398,
-0.0504635833,
0.0088730725,
-0.0388751253,
-0.0141164716,
0.0083581964,
-0.0157444384,
-0.0040458501,
0.0036842572,
0.0010669682,
0.0164327957,
0.0317226611,
-0.0158164818,
0.0270635262,
0.0325419493,
-0.0172930509,
0.0126639279,
0.0084152222,
-0.0093591902,
0.0276704039,
-0.0173797011,
-0.0335233957,
0.0166586339,
0.0038169113,
0.0064979242,
-0.0527652875,
0.0168429613,
0.0246591102,
0.0131824249,
0.0255554914,
-0.0588089786,
-0.0402431153,
0.0039777434,
-0.0842419341,
-0.0093042301,
0.0111578712,
0.0189624429,
-0.0638030618,
-0.0105688777,
0.0886517391,
0.0026733521,
-0.0020065454,
-0.0565520413,
-0.0043856092,
-0.024276929,
-0.0186367854,
-0.04785401,
-0.0392046161,
0.0208953731,
0.0376544893,
-0.0072687236,
0.0041827001,
0.0080353301,
0.0025130906,
-0.0222349074,
-0.0380390584,
0.012970279,
0.0068203909,
0.0861652941,
0.0259776004,
-0.0019741214,
0.0266255327,
0.0049993512,
0.0673568621,
-0.0193087459,
-0.0182455089,
0.0054706256,
-0.0344792828,
0.0329452269,
0.0642903671,
-0.0166170206,
0.112346828,
0.0194700789,
-0.1110007614,
-0.0253656823,
0.0114779836,
0.1195503771,
-0.0124261063,
0.0205905214,
-0.0147380969,
0.0088152979,
0.0219011642,
-0.0237032492,
-0.0432904884,
-0.0403615125,
0.011494983,
0.0202751718,
0.0247089975,
0.0409599021,
-0.008583257,
-0.0003524251,
0.0242780223,
0.0888481811,
0.0374115556,
-0.0070408895,
0.0144228283,
0.0581835285,
-0.023185892,
-0.0147392768,
-0.0033651823,
0.0123846177,
0.0022834449,
0.0134831965,
0.0192247778,
0.0435530394,
-0.0421787165,
-0.0263572484,
-0.0339766741,
0.0204937812,
-0.0121371374,
0.1031600907,
0.0730983391,
-0.0200647414,
0.0028191342,
0.0440357067,
-0.040008869,
-0.0512809493,
-0.0164007153,
0.028605802,
0.0119454656,
0.0500291996,
-0.0137546416,
-0.0036441688,
-0.0327736773,
-0.0249904115,
0.0097080646,
-0.0251281206,
-0.0264286548,
0.0198084339,
2.803e-7,
-0.0255433246,
-0.0228269082,
0.1082115024,
0.0425053947,
0.0394821092,
0.0087299915,
0.0249581449,
0.0441436991,
-0.0198457204,
-0.039050255,
0.0045768954,
0.0009799871,
0.0223146118,
-0.000375157,
-0.06606365,
-0.0028941792,
-0.1179231331,
0.006069622,
-0.013125754,
-0.0289223883,
0.0139726754,
0.0852363557,
-0.0055333981,
-0.0079323193,
0.007184281,
-0.0320282839,
0.011272274,
0.0886749029,
0.0214986783,
-0.0243633389,
0.0137942005,
-0.0076583065,
-0.0214334521,
-0.0015752765,
0.0203586351,
0.0385458432,
0.0084515717,
0.051899422,
-0.024734173,
0.0126194451,
-0.0039908094,
-0.0238092188,
-0.0414498672,
0.0267368183,
0.0485797711,
-0.0429883525,
-0.0220881123,
-0.0141662071,
0.0001448184,
-0.0250864942,
-0.0078543331,
0.0616540648,
0.0224113632,
0.0158898607,
0.002081092,
-0.0125497766,
0.03685553,
-0.0931937099,
0.005427775,
0.0092427153,
-0.0638873801,
0.0314674377,
-0.0556134433,
0.0413629748,
-0.0039730864,
-0.0278252568,
-0.0556378514,
2.791305927e-34,
0.0151433209,
-0.0380440354,
-0.0067193038,
-0.0105822701,
0.0253736377,
-0.0266455766,
-0.0793122128,
0.0211923178,
0.0231706407,
-0.0393939018,
-0.0473296456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04939v1 | LooGLE: Can Long-Context Language Models Understand Long Contexts? | 2023-11-08T01:45:37 | 2023-11-08T01:45:37 | Jiaqi Li, Mengmeng Wang, Zilong Zheng, Muhan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), despite their impressive performance in various
language tasks, are typically limited to processing texts within context-window
size. This limitation has spurred significant research efforts to enhance LLMs'
long-context understanding with high-quality long-sequence benchmarks. However,
prior datasets in this regard suffer from shortcomings, such as short context
length compared to the context window of modern LLMs; outdated documents that
have data leakage problems; and an emphasis on short dependency tasks rather
than long dependency tasks. In this paper, we present LooGLE, a Long Context
Generic Language Evaluation benchmark for LLMs' long context understanding.
LooGLE features relatively new documents post-2022, with over 24,000 tokens per
document and 6,000 newly generated questions spanning diverse domains. Human
annotators meticulously crafted more than 1,100 high-quality question-answer
pairs to meet the long dependency requirements. These pairs underwent thorough
cross-validation, yielding the most precise assessment of LLMs' long dependency
capabilities. The evaluation of eight state-of-the-art LLMs on LooGLE revealed
key findings: (i) commercial models outperformed open-sourced models; (ii) LLMs
excelled in short dependency tasks like short question-answering and cloze
tasks but struggled with more intricate long dependency tasks; (iii) in-context
learning and chaining thoughts offered only marginal improvements; (iv)
retrieval-based techniques demonstrated substantial benefits for short
question-answering, while strategies for extending context window length had
limited impact on long context understanding. As such, LooGLE not only provides
a systematic and comprehensive evaluation schema on long-context LLMs, but also
sheds light on future development of enhanced models towards "true long-context
understanding". | [
0.0221022349,
0.0475689173,
0.0086767841,
0.058830142,
-0.0429220758,
0.0140986517,
0.0042958632,
-0.0302864946,
-0.0090238024,
-0.0602765791,
-0.0296505541,
-0.0560339764,
-0.0134844808,
0.0139461849,
0.0159875657,
-0.0476353355,
0.0385294855,
-0.0265755504,
-0.0053842734,
0.0013945805,
0.0013424285,
-0.0126163885,
0.0117105804,
0.0331748091,
0.0089205652,
-0.048513744,
-0.0146385171,
-0.0270200968,
-0.0063405675,
-0.0403913632,
0.0207646545,
0.0653023422,
0.0423390418,
0.0330652595,
0.0000018551,
-0.0747256279,
-0.0069052191,
-0.0159896854,
-0.0400201306,
0.0049307207,
-0.0162313264,
-0.0188028421,
0.030398095,
0.0067927786,
-0.0368415266,
-0.0103993639,
-0.0153513495,
0.0294551589,
0.0538378134,
0.0653756335,
0.0067134257,
-0.0353769511,
0.0380438678,
-0.0534944125,
0.0560087971,
-0.0794326961,
0.0169726927,
-0.0094404537,
0.0453711711,
0.0342169292,
-0.0257532373,
0.0219487976,
0.0506334305,
-0.0040340293,
-0.002076074,
0.0373990536,
-0.0367585309,
0.0121716941,
0.0043475926,
0.0934078097,
0.0243144594,
-0.0194668956,
-0.0133390259,
0.0218643229,
0.0233141538,
-0.0299476795,
-0.0636967495,
0.0214371346,
-0.0070985765,
-0.0147252381,
0.0527291,
0.009257663,
0.0166121349,
0.0201663766,
-0.0382449478,
0.0647139177,
0.0033682806,
-0.0280131102,
-0.0073386743,
-0.0086524282,
-0.0375687033,
-0.0615109839,
0.0006290484,
0.0621030629,
-0.0351744257,
0.0128151085,
-0.0390646122,
-0.0226359759,
0.0494817458,
-0.02282032,
-0.0407973528,
0.0251976959,
-0.042105671,
0.078989923,
-0.0324574187,
0.041045256,
-0.0197131094,
-0.0352826864,
-0.0345088616,
-0.0279983021,
-0.0401454121,
-0.00424641,
-0.0251867436,
0.0218893923,
-0.049569454,
-0.0305516068,
-0.0028424985,
0.0364871919,
0.0137912761,
0.0066875913,
-0.0158657897,
0.0021342372,
-0.0071448935,
-0.0086699603,
-0.0301100612,
0.0411501527,
-0.0608666018,
0.011653861,
0.0282793809,
-0.0544453003,
-0.0162183698,
0.0221830122,
0.0106179705,
-0.0527798906,
0.01132017,
0.0448314995,
0.0130188242,
-0.0363382436,
-0.0188873503,
-0.0359279886,
-0.024337532,
-0.057866022,
-0.0143809309,
-0.083429575,
0.0090582287,
0.0347175971,
0.0006000065,
0.0068616481,
0.006877468,
0.0352855176,
-0.0014668858,
0.0552118383,
0.0209417399,
-0.016595209,
0.0277176145,
0.030337885,
0.0064311437,
0.0694308653,
-0.0085629597,
-0.0035160349,
0.0302554816,
0.0073835044,
0.0022349267,
0.0195471253,
0.0194517579,
-0.003676242,
0.000550725,
0.0678513348,
0.0273939129,
0.0300124977,
0.0367664397,
0.0327437818,
-0.011428969,
-0.0499782227,
0.0271508656,
0.0469583459,
0.0390369706,
-0.0132528422,
0.0390155017,
-0.0111550391,
-0.0053212331,
0.0157400481,
-0.0562863015,
0.0341965817,
-0.0045044431,
0.0148145361,
0.0119762635,
0.0067635709,
-0.0307501592,
-0.0172758158,
-0.0128725106,
-0.0140443295,
-0.0087418063,
0.0035768324,
0.030576624,
0.0138605013,
-0.0178276151,
0.0626611859,
0.0092196893,
-0.0246611293,
-0.0054822112,
-0.0233881865,
0.0574716441,
0.0449342169,
0.0395720042,
-0.0357841253,
-0.0474110544,
-0.0312898867,
0.0448758937,
0.0273651853,
0.0232000072,
-0.0182179604,
0.0233980212,
-0.0148900999,
-0.0146929668,
-0.0285467487,
0.0029122964,
-0.0048552179,
0.0249174368,
0.0074501298,
0.0270382017,
-0.034861289,
0.0213109981,
0.0245384146,
-0.0479181409,
-0.0268227048,
-0.0210156702,
0.0110384254,
0.0167658981,
0.0093207732,
0.0076848068,
0.0335265957,
0.0347290076,
-0.0625100508,
-0.0204251073,
-0.001828041,
-0.0948499367,
-0.0454250835,
0.0318564028,
-0.0231641643,
-0.0211814027,
0.003589594,
-0.0325530842,
-0.0427969471,
-0.010232104,
-0.008401189,
0.0321912728,
-0.0357047506,
-0.0143400375,
0.0112824365,
0.015319407,
-0.0661293715,
0.0743844435,
-0.0265014954,
0.0231993739,
0.0197203942,
0.0453699119,
0.0229098592,
-0.0205543991,
-0.0134511823,
0.0092772665,
-0.004704461,
-0.0259609204,
0.0218621101,
0.0267909374,
-0.0800790861,
-0.0218714289,
-0.0995346457,
0.0217255298,
-0.0343658775,
0.0284417681,
0.0287629943,
0.0145953819,
-0.0038798542,
-0.0204301663,
-0.0682590753,
-0.001961875,
0.004937876,
0.0210366473,
0.0314281769,
0.0368179157,
0.0129209654,
-0.0438710377,
-0.0154148759,
-0.0155449035,
0.040215455,
-0.0091803381,
-0.0130676581,
-0.0508203022,
0.0323192403,
-0.0171334818,
0.0070471903,
-0.0375562869,
0.0073847114,
0.0136010638,
-0.0389537029,
0.0485354066,
0.0558276512,
0.0083075995,
-0.0177999847,
0.0222973265,
0.0031294778,
-0.0435885116,
0.0282877889,
0.003658104,
0.0081200488,
-0.0295075551,
0.0273877028,
-0.017457692,
0.0650672019,
-0.0390704535,
-0.009725417,
-0.0196402166,
0.0063026734,
-0.01601764,
-0.0012652557,
-0.0468798168,
-0.0110235363,
-0.0072646281,
0.0311108828,
-0.0510741808,
-0.0264656991,
0.0679885671,
-0.0239734668,
-0.0021730079,
-0.0457986854,
0.0084599685,
-0.0836127922,
0.0845298991,
-0.0008078721,
-0.010983577,
-0.0070442352,
-0.0300558656,
-0.0565289855,
0.0137263099,
-0.025459623,
-0.0253046211,
0.079657644,
-0.0273453444,
0.0239890106,
-0.032298401,
-0.0525192916,
-0.0407788157,
-0.0314940922,
-0.0281542409,
0.0097741187,
0.0148607781,
0.0006518782,
0.0122544728,
-0.0126864957,
0.031758301,
0.0631071702,
-0.0240745582,
-0.001394039,
-0.0032278609,
0.0646941289,
0.0686475709,
0.0368705541,
0.0206154026,
-0.0213053096,
0.0567742474,
0.0637030974,
0.0623566173,
-0.0146687934,
-0.0118814064,
-0.010323707,
0.000255224,
-0.0300152414,
-0.0381295346,
0.0028938134,
0.0597782657,
-0.0849053487,
-0.0277843215,
0.1244732887,
0.0213575847,
-0.0591843203,
0.0044507789,
-0.0452663302,
0.046887219,
0.0454319902,
-0.0042739301,
-0.1140601858,
-0.0532443374,
0.0136590982,
0.0033621525,
0.0183689818,
-0.0496515073,
0.0166251324,
-0.1043613181,
0.0007419454,
-0.0118079204,
-0.078332983,
0.0158710666,
-0.0494346395,
-0.0000711772,
0.0265960004,
0.0077564428,
0.0381003469,
-0.0180836879,
-0.003606118,
0.0096973758,
-0.0187175535,
-0.0254103038,
0.0751561001,
-0.020754844,
0.0366017446,
0.0236003436,
0.014203703,
0.0118754003,
0.0070059332,
0.0597608499,
-0.0721711144,
0.021610707,
-0.0122924028,
0.0423319824,
-0.0207902379,
-0.0052244184,
-0.0113506047,
0.0523240641,
-0.0508909598,
-0.0038517744,
0.0439394116,
0.083433494,
-0.0158235859,
0.0090504838,
-0.0210755896,
-0.0242969207,
0.0135065923,
0.0866507292,
0.0559570603,
-0.0396506786,
-0.0562759191,
-0.0033520246,
-0.0173829738,
-0.0419439115,
0.0078901239,
-0.008904716,
0.0260093715,
0.0323052928,
-0.0773927644,
-0.0779834092,
0.0375956893,
0.026626328,
-0.0256550815,
0.0515194796,
-0.0256736148,
0.0001317451,
-0.0500889122,
0.0554743707,
-0.0291865338,
0.0246762745,
-0.0630571395,
0.0377265513,
0.0226395521,
-0.0070487023,
-0.0207763016,
0.0580974035,
-0.1005483568,
-0.0360728502,
-0.0112613766,
0.0215959754,
0.0203131288,
0.0457544103,
-0.0107400492,
-0.0426861569,
0.029074898,
0.0072647878,
-0.0291335713,
0.0193469822,
0.0124015808,
0.0305532012,
0.0058154776,
0.0570601746,
-0.0652697235,
-0.00127319,
-0.0000258509,
0.0463720001,
-0.0215186756,
-0.0057983161,
0.0184950605,
-0.017683439,
-0.0125803519,
0.0086562047,
0.0198468361,
-0.0085832309,
0.0423675515,
-0.0252365768,
-0.0155644258,
-0.0140195098,
0.0103012184,
0.0215191487,
-0.0361179225,
0.0205550063,
-0.0038554915,
0.0068344581,
0.0413576663,
-0.0390716605,
0.0309894569,
0.0427331775,
0.0070678275,
0.0244971029,
0.0013643571,
-0.0213345792,
-0.0352394469,
-0.0061285668,
0.0569133051,
-0.0191235952,
0.0526456572,
0.0176130328,
-0.0147621259,
0.0039650719,
0.0061207521,
-0.103311047,
-0.0001007359,
0.0143428519,
0.0040780157,
0.0622051693,
-0.016139403,
0.0480426513,
0.009893558,
-0.01360304,
-0.0340556577,
0.0340343714,
-0.0089043928,
-0.0323654041,
0.0189352538,
0.0525486991,
-0.0164372288,
0.037798509,
0.0990414172,
0.0209413748,
0.0433922224,
0.032617595,
0.0362077095,
-0.0396903157,
-0.0122207869,
-0.0365743041,
0.0392885357,
-0.0153465923,
0.0305867139,
-0.045928359,
-0.0691170767,
0.0221804455,
-0.0119727291,
-0.0111129377,
-0.0161779951,
0.0207626447,
0.063526541,
0.0180634856,
-0.0295304954,
-0.0336700529,
0.0516179875,
-0.020152308,
-0.0268602483,
-0.0175906979,
-6.228126862e-33,
-0.0144997127,
-0.025862284,
0.0201150235,
-0.0012595431,
-0.0288063586,
0.0381399058,
-0.0504625551,
0.0136754587,
-0.0278042071,
0.0044030617,
-0.0257627424,
0.0160060525,
-0.0122715225,
0.0421061292,
0.014271751,
-0.0416042432,
0.0068166922,
-0.0011218353,
-0.0004286599,
0.0404708199,
0.0614280403,
0.0416522436,
0.0275693033,
-0.0166690331,
0.0454037488,
-0.0222112052,
0.0332464278,
0.0263290815,
-0.0171408858,
0.0843751878,
-0.0217223838,
0.0181173515,
0.0613639839,
-0.040270444,
-0.0302391034,
0.0530332401,
-0.1232128143,
-0.02149342,
0.00349217,
-0.0238824915,
-0.0628417879,
-0.0407357402,
0.0488457046,
0.0078153359,
0.024278434,
-0.0199688002,
0.0227413755,
-0.0411915556,
-0.0220984612,
-0.0112786377,
-0.0442843363,
0.0169438012,
0.0032264597,
-0.0113859475,
-0.0118594188,
0.0661923513,
-0.0001680429,
0.0691728145,
-0.0504864529,
-0.0271752086,
-0.0322928466,
0.0473826267,
0.0436826274,
0.003551333,
0.0078888033,
0.0456718765,
-0.0175443217,
-0.0023281164,
-0.0182956588,
-0.0377300009,
0.006094039,
0.0285367239,
0.0420614742,
0.0442194156,
0.0656513497,
0.0219006427,
-0.0871842504,
0.024545256,
0.0237319786,
0.0638713539,
-0.0124504343,
-0.0004432997,
-0.0023570023,
0.0017886449,
-0.0640196875,
0.0131165618,
-0.0365794487,
0.0050171213,
0.0435947701,
0.0046511302,
0.0025261049,
-0.0193924215,
0.0491156541,
-0.0348302908,
-0.0210790597,
0.0538502708,
-0.0075722733,
0.0050737951,
0.0377051644,
0.0397767015,
-0.0584674664,
0.0182315875,
0.0132493414,
0.0209839158,
0.0142678581,
-0.0012635037,
0.0621253848,
-0.0145639181,
-0.0576425381,
-0.0241365414,
-0.0595869571,
0.0294789504,
-0.0341276713,
0.005300256,
0.0422279537,
-0.0007579515,
-0.000855953,
0.0813650861,
0.0058300821,
0.009418143,
-0.0161707178,
-0.035996139,
-0.0059936424,
0.002692654,
-0.0123018976,
-0.0119738989,
-0.0057995589,
0.0333051011,
0.0215901937,
-0.0583547875,
0.0043497724,
0.0341962799,
2.493e-7,
0.0516041331,
0.0283828806,
0.038683001,
0.0066611362,
0.0438038819,
0.0100173391,
-0.0186088327,
0.0272857491,
0.0024695294,
-0.0422361791,
-0.0283295847,
0.0226576794,
0.0490040965,
0.0017568452,
-0.0878019854,
0.0021184606,
-0.0707810894,
-0.0054918868,
-0.047243394,
-0.007889959,
0.0599373356,
0.0943622738,
-0.0284797922,
-0.0198576264,
-0.0007849161,
-0.0484284684,
0.0497336239,
-0.0317429043,
-0.0106539205,
0.0064949137,
-0.0070451093,
0.030067632,
0.0307065602,
0.005243462,
-0.0038088586,
0.0280661155,
-0.0011077933,
0.0579380095,
0.0275546648,
-0.0609678328,
0.0035040458,
-0.0190001223,
0.0001880741,
-0.0686685592,
0.1022856683,
-0.0613472946,
-0.0266242009,
-0.0474051349,
-0.0212078448,
-0.0159343984,
0.0214300528,
0.0174210779,
0.0130884051,
0.0022751922,
0.0013370939,
-0.0203931928,
0.0069319173,
-0.0915790871,
-0.04350264,
0.0029791154,
-0.040027827,
-0.0121002328,
-0.0659132972,
-0.0168625042,
0.0046649287,
-0.0282714982,
-0.0112528969,
2.421461884e-34,
0.0276205372,
-0.0393517353,
0.0069907936,
0.0288784653,
0.0066200746,
-0.0180941839,
-0.0430738404,
-0.0024087091,
0.0261292644,
-0.0940605998,
-0.0003993069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04420v1 | Data Factors for Better Compositional Generalization | 2023-11-08T01:27:34 | 2023-11-08T01:27:34 | Xiang Zhou, Yichen Jiang, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent diagnostic datasets on compositional generalization, such as SCAN
(Lake and Baroni, 2018) and COGS (Kim and Linzen, 2020), expose severe problems
in models trained from scratch on these datasets. However, in contrast to this
poor performance, state-of-the-art models trained on larger and more general
datasets show better generalization ability. In this work, to reconcile this
inconsistency, we conduct an empirical analysis by training Transformer models
on a variety of training sets with different data factors, including dataset
scale, pattern complexity, example difficulty, etc. First, we show that
increased dataset complexity can lead to better generalization behavior on
multiple different generalization challenges. To further understand this
improvement, we show two axes of the benefit from more complex datasets: they
provide more diverse examples so compositional understanding becomes more
effective, and they also prevent ungeneralizable memorization of the examples
due to reduced example repetition frequency. Finally, we explore how training
examples of different difficulty levels influence generalization differently.
On synthetic datasets, simple examples invoke stronger compositionality than
hard examples do. On larger-scale real language datasets, while hard examples
become more important potentially to ensure decent data coverage, a balanced
mixture of simple and hard examples manages to induce the strongest
generalizability. The code and data for this work are available at
https://github.com/owenzx/data4comp | [
0.0173387788,
0.0578260161,
-0.0174595751,
0.000318823,
0.0019406498,
0.0438859612,
-0.0028935999,
-0.0244281869,
-0.0806922391,
0.0039112233,
0.0106349764,
-0.0409541093,
0.0152878687,
0.014964724,
0.0258874651,
-0.0575953759,
0.0327212662,
-0.0214549042,
-0.0465741493,
-0.0117836799,
-0.0142609244,
-0.0014678419,
0.0056527923,
0.0354868621,
-0.027954679,
0.0206663273,
-0.0346963592,
-0.0122172963,
0.0181003436,
0.012888927,
0.012242117,
0.0339858234,
0.0476268716,
0.0330039598,
0.000001827,
-0.0349084772,
-0.0113909608,
-0.0061297705,
0.0026951772,
-0.0348711014,
0.0116823427,
-0.0543294214,
0.0327230096,
0.0048424755,
-0.0201383196,
-0.0469513312,
0.0625333115,
0.0656217188,
0.0205052998,
0.0973769948,
-0.0167813376,
-0.0868305042,
0.0162189733,
-0.0138431983,
0.0504614562,
0.0086605093,
0.0220015105,
0.0156310722,
-0.0258027352,
-0.0244880058,
-0.0442099273,
0.0050429832,
0.0518033579,
0.052827213,
0.0120022967,
0.0581241995,
-0.0649609491,
-0.0225372631,
0.0419666953,
0.0915858969,
-0.0160979666,
-0.032543797,
-0.0009748036,
-0.0243441332,
0.0233212877,
0.006511359,
-0.0239624381,
0.022368148,
-0.0370669104,
0.0240390077,
-0.0185876656,
-0.0047402661,
0.0337352492,
-0.0352031812,
-0.0585493185,
0.0073509756,
0.0081046727,
-0.0359677821,
0.0527222939,
-0.0213954765,
0.0055792378,
-0.0118932379,
-0.0154673969,
0.0347690694,
-0.0285503417,
0.0108837048,
-0.0265773684,
-0.0437531248,
0.0062244292,
-0.0058567454,
0.0460629128,
0.0375937037,
-0.0056927996,
0.0321977846,
-0.05164399,
0.0621028505,
-0.0061603654,
0.0528973788,
-0.0410489179,
-0.0365502387,
-0.0815935135,
-0.015289939,
-0.0527632609,
0.0421845354,
0.0370551385,
-0.0081951702,
-0.0446127504,
0.0046956772,
-0.0378585979,
0.0534086004,
0.009341402,
0.0028565899,
-0.0599122681,
-0.0000368632,
0.0108104143,
0.0026428562,
-0.0470209457,
0.0069369837,
0.012894528,
-0.0465977229,
-0.0041546975,
-0.0392605774,
0.025848357,
-0.0163963176,
0.0108925449,
0.0411562584,
0.0036257359,
-0.0532042347,
-0.0060509522,
0.0148792965,
0.007043595,
-0.0802759379,
0.0353479646,
-0.0842051953,
0.0617676452,
0.0171700101,
0.0193970911,
-0.0168220568,
0.0122443531,
0.002734774,
-0.0158149842,
0.0792163163,
0.0322899073,
0.0138622252,
-0.0221954025,
-0.001229165,
-0.024415005,
0.0927821025,
-0.0018367466,
-0.0202685818,
0.0027171066,
-0.0370757803,
0.0365415178,
-0.0111939823,
0.0041160355,
-0.0195899308,
0.0292231198,
0.0152978813,
0.0001821806,
0.0248633958,
0.0415330119,
0.0455064327,
-0.0258901902,
-0.0432107374,
0.0252460521,
-0.0108701726,
0.0524751581,
0.0348498113,
0.0700086504,
-0.0019865606,
0.0196123216,
0.060759116,
-0.0566747449,
0.0236457288,
-0.0069274879,
0.0258692931,
-0.0328155831,
0.0254211072,
-0.0551828668,
-0.0351630189,
-0.0244114008,
-0.0252070241,
0.0432473831,
-0.027273085,
0.0557076,
0.0573027655,
-0.0193114392,
0.0485318638,
0.0453436822,
-0.0597133227,
-0.0136994291,
0.0085956315,
0.0433585867,
-0.0001445127,
-0.0108597744,
-0.0410646461,
-0.0220723636,
-0.0102675492,
0.0195291117,
-0.0251420792,
0.0586237498,
-0.0162354019,
0.0565404557,
-0.0709051415,
0.0028368526,
-0.022353569,
0.0167947859,
0.0131641943,
0.0557910874,
-0.0251175761,
0.0167645831,
-0.0502741486,
-0.0278498381,
0.0266969018,
-0.0037562456,
-0.0330555663,
-0.0119096236,
0.027655175,
0.0233117491,
-0.0253166985,
0.0192094613,
-0.0062757717,
0.0098633505,
-0.0341056101,
-0.0622494444,
0.0340329036,
-0.0705978721,
-0.0414377563,
-0.0063798521,
-0.1009444445,
-0.0297231469,
0.0245911554,
-0.0671119541,
-0.0462308004,
0.0147191249,
-0.0531885698,
0.0577060655,
-0.0100270137,
-0.0000271425,
-0.0085499939,
0.0080421558,
0.0052554491,
0.044478178,
-0.0121547449,
0.0303502679,
0.0016019639,
-0.0236947816,
-0.011298622,
-0.0227289256,
-0.023660088,
0.020398356,
-0.0250853971,
-0.006335861,
-0.0081498399,
-0.0295616463,
-0.0597389229,
-0.0124424901,
-0.0386640094,
-0.0235511027,
-0.0234059636,
-0.0106136296,
0.0243858285,
0.0210151058,
0.0126109617,
0.0219396707,
-0.0482198745,
0.0246392228,
-0.0312557407,
0.0366886221,
0.0347086005,
0.0119927619,
-0.0270254258,
-0.006769381,
-0.0147777516,
-0.0355621465,
0.0755335912,
-0.0432727486,
0.0328245163,
-0.0308484677,
0.0346505195,
0.0145714087,
-0.011809702,
-0.0398569815,
-0.0448298417,
-0.0020999657,
-0.0156141324,
0.0459557883,
0.0427064747,
-0.022035433,
0.0088369902,
0.039059002,
-0.007602768,
-0.0470781252,
0.0117151011,
-0.0490438305,
-0.0129896021,
-0.0256789718,
-0.0426239744,
-0.0113765383,
0.07946641,
-0.0079869004,
-0.0151273096,
-0.0655602664,
0.0083695073,
-0.0346369036,
0.0132823065,
-0.0020883116,
-0.0065380079,
-0.02330474,
0.0166110359,
-0.0167027283,
-0.0172563344,
0.056888245,
0.0108342757,
-0.0319141075,
-0.0278221294,
0.0123096472,
-0.0471814722,
0.0658023432,
0.0426320992,
0.0125481915,
0.037495479,
-0.0289160442,
-0.0728531405,
-0.0036468455,
0.0336460285,
0.0039776983,
0.0535037071,
0.0130316643,
-0.0274010357,
-0.0314934961,
-0.0325208344,
-0.0249794554,
0.0346519984,
0.0079681976,
0.0215794519,
0.0486451387,
-0.0287641697,
-0.0306710452,
-0.0314537063,
0.0074931798,
0.0362724736,
0.0090975212,
-0.0359582342,
-0.0035860857,
0.0217580572,
-0.0049475268,
0.0252291113,
0.028702572,
-0.0424086787,
0.0134269539,
0.0297044069,
0.0114128757,
0.0127695538,
-0.0510774255,
0.007388466,
0.0012065276,
-0.0285396036,
-0.0087132361,
0.0256741606,
0.0510706753,
-0.0605479218,
-0.0251206812,
0.0710829049,
0.010998806,
-0.0404531807,
0.030634664,
0.0021418745,
0.0179164391,
0.0539280474,
0.01478911,
-0.0763152465,
0.0000665023,
0.0361227468,
-0.0276378393,
-0.0103429193,
-0.0271895621,
0.0069933063,
-0.1069108024,
0.0062685022,
0.0095888367,
-0.0887751132,
-0.0623688623,
-0.0382805541,
-0.0053892569,
-0.0520016178,
0.0062842397,
-0.0075644972,
-0.0494873077,
0.0050358721,
0.0184407681,
-0.0508064926,
-0.0621049181,
0.0068074162,
-0.0305281356,
0.0219282042,
0.0080414945,
0.0182783864,
-0.0294194128,
-0.0268110186,
0.046598576,
0.0226993151,
-0.0103051681,
0.0318921618,
0.0690084696,
0.0247430336,
-0.0016990196,
0.0143624833,
0.0551504046,
-0.0343344882,
-0.0139572397,
-0.0302985199,
0.0627931356,
0.032292638,
-0.0583778061,
-0.0185985491,
-0.0016653724,
-0.0189420003,
0.0836981758,
0.0730159953,
-0.023209637,
-0.0152558293,
-0.0285272803,
0.0231356882,
-0.0847091675,
0.0112441266,
0.0533529483,
0.0461438,
0.0158175565,
-0.0445647687,
-0.0442847833,
0.0496355891,
0.0320940539,
-0.007221384,
-0.0499361455,
0.0062297434,
-0.0079522273,
-0.0412282087,
0.0325716957,
-0.0146684181,
0.016474342,
-0.0022155005,
-0.0398653857,
-0.0175949819,
-0.0298912674,
-0.0382881761,
-0.03980086,
-0.1066423133,
-0.0426723398,
0.0315988101,
0.0485116281,
0.0222677384,
0.0419162549,
0.015072478,
-0.0282367393,
0.0410737582,
0.0239861235,
-0.0052413726,
-0.0090897596,
0.0844476596,
-0.027282862,
0.0451382659,
0.0308032874,
-0.0476593375,
-0.0082543101,
0.031312611,
0.0120097473,
0.0248088334,
0.0664460436,
0.0467564724,
-0.0283724014,
-0.0093333293,
0.0215149261,
0.0391945057,
-0.0259724576,
0.0377624668,
0.0084906677,
-0.0078145666,
-0.0340961069,
-0.0019180175,
0.0342310295,
0.0494641215,
0.0097260373,
-0.019114485,
0.0115252128,
0.0666566119,
-0.0260390732,
0.0316098854,
0.0609358735,
-0.0329243876,
0.0518545434,
0.0321557894,
-0.0331312381,
0.0365404598,
-0.0197967608,
0.0065821819,
0.006864103,
0.005060751,
0.0179860145,
0.0336812921,
-0.0468934886,
-0.0411726534,
-0.0748838633,
-0.0004353472,
-0.0107213389,
-0.0344436578,
0.0565671436,
-0.0658346862,
0.0026645488,
-0.0173463263,
-0.0024699483,
0.0018991728,
0.0003146913,
-0.033105664,
-0.018576365,
0.0239041597,
0.0448604412,
0.004653329,
-0.0034289418,
0.105586417,
-0.0231727902,
0.0785658881,
-0.0092712203,
0.0347580723,
-0.0298856627,
-0.0008237177,
0.0335681103,
0.0526194312,
-0.026012633,
-0.0342241228,
-0.0409850031,
-0.0455196984,
-0.0051638316,
-0.0266190842,
0.0141969463,
0.0068869516,
0.0439912602,
0.0609803125,
0.0025708326,
-0.0076843882,
0.0054835179,
-0.0333093219,
0.0322252698,
0.0100507485,
-0.0224389825,
-6.054762383e-33,
0.0041838191,
0.0003430046,
-0.0098338444,
-0.0092305178,
-0.0079401908,
0.0296541713,
-0.002588924,
-0.0004428264,
-0.0159815494,
0.0151788825,
-0.0179551188,
0.016423678,
0.0011439335,
0.0328822024,
0.0147760287,
-0.0023318001,
0.0527821705,
0.0343322828,
-0.0278242715,
0.0198287386,
0.0287465192,
0.031586457,
0.0780143589,
-0.0172628071,
-0.0090909805,
0.0177453924,
-0.0133810118,
-0.0168986879,
-0.0245888196,
0.0679252222,
0.0016168618,
0.054141555,
0.0341265723,
-0.029299546,
-0.0307927486,
0.005938773,
-0.0887499526,
-0.022340551,
0.0124997515,
0.0365793444,
-0.0327030197,
-0.0382734612,
0.0531376153,
-0.0463207625,
0.0261951778,
-0.0749121532,
0.0326098092,
-0.0198939908,
-0.017105408,
-0.0739448965,
-0.078205727,
-0.0018948353,
-0.0021726317,
0.021252593,
-0.0221535917,
0.031593021,
-0.0071996641,
0.0371147208,
-0.0610460229,
0.0115676001,
0.0069963164,
0.0084172664,
-0.0041253315,
0.0091273421,
0.0017987316,
0.0372289456,
0.0257513523,
0.0152160795,
-0.0312825404,
-0.0118259285,
0.0037856225,
0.0480163172,
0.0210665576,
0.0360016637,
0.0942520201,
0.004282516,
-0.0194445048,
-0.0075618774,
-0.0332572088,
0.0470799915,
0.0345477089,
0.0169002991,
-0.0355353057,
-0.0031591952,
-0.0554378442,
0.0037398399,
-0.0187926795,
-0.0272990577,
0.0108644506,
0.0300374851,
0.0061738631,
-0.0075246058,
0.025386218,
-0.0596954003,
-0.0000701146,
0.0180908497,
-0.028842533,
0.0001811301,
-0.0007615354,
-0.0157802422,
-0.0467767715,
-0.0635755509,
0.0268653892,
0.0244622175,
0.037689697,
0.0218380652,
0.1022201404,
0.0479176007,
-0.0680933595,
-0.0383368097,
-0.0548347905,
-0.0126836617,
-0.026225131,
0.0480630808,
0.048485972,
0.0301815812,
-0.0271724872,
0.0332741775,
0.0040417602,
0.0197059046,
-0.0624810383,
0.0145447021,
-0.0223207809,
0.0522705205,
0.0020977894,
-0.0441197455,
-0.031302724,
-0.0453998446,
0.0913528278,
-0.0414979607,
-0.0178957283,
0.0087816482,
2.492e-7,
0.0246634595,
0.0227612387,
0.0158776715,
0.0328360125,
0.0111329798,
0.0065216757,
-0.0283151828,
0.0079918988,
-0.0525785312,
0.0017397312,
0.0184886809,
0.0246454664,
0.0380487926,
0.042418249,
-0.0758992657,
0.0078000519,
-0.0835052282,
-0.0232972801,
-0.0312641822,
0.0043964414,
0.0371411368,
0.1131740287,
0.0303538386,
-0.0012050882,
0.0328401253,
-0.0107143493,
0.0646939352,
-0.0352224112,
0.0412258208,
0.0074700634,
0.0019254158,
0.0439049229,
0.0307107829,
0.0118669858,
0.0036439614,
0.0203280896,
0.0118601387,
0.0151751973,
0.0443630591,
0.0078958571,
0.0222746152,
-0.0251072682,
-0.018935293,
-0.086873062,
0.0612639561,
-0.1183243766,
-0.0229466539,
-0.0096071456,
-0.0249093287,
0.0340262875,
0.0328742452,
0.0098430626,
0.0318468623,
0.0199159272,
-0.0072795697,
-0.0006539616,
0.0040351264,
-0.0839846134,
-0.0237624533,
0.0328999124,
-0.0230073407,
-0.008388767,
-0.0208868999,
-0.0241865348,
0.0514268465,
-0.021396568,
-0.035124436,
2.424642606e-34,
0.0482910983,
-0.0089853341,
0.0137305502,
0.0036457186,
0.0263490006,
-0.0643658862,
-0.0156051293,
-0.0078636054,
-0.0070547559,
-0.0540649854,
-0.0196554828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04378v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04378v2 | Watermarks in the Sand: Impossibility of Strong Watermarking for Generative Models | 2023-11-07T22:52:54 | 2023-11-15T00:21:29 | Hanlin Zhang, Benjamin L. Edelman, Danilo Francati, Daniele Venturi, Giuseppe Ateniese, Boaz Barak | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Watermarking generative models consists of planting a statistical signal
(watermark) in a model's output so that it can be later verified that the
output was generated by the given model. A strong watermarking scheme satisfies
the property that a computationally bounded attacker cannot erase the watermark
without causing significant quality degradation. In this paper, we study the
(im)possibility of strong watermarking schemes. We prove that, under
well-specified and natural assumptions, strong watermarking is impossible to
achieve. This holds even in the private detection algorithm setting, where the
watermark insertion and detection algorithms share a secret key, unknown to the
attacker. To prove this result, we introduce a generic efficient watermark
attack; the attacker is not required to know the private key of the scheme or
even which scheme is used. Our attack is based on two assumptions: (1) The
attacker has access to a "quality oracle" that can evaluate whether a candidate
output is a high-quality response to a prompt, and (2) The attacker has access
to a "perturbation oracle" which can modify an output with a nontrivial
probability of maintaining quality, and which induces an efficiently mixing
random walk on high-quality outputs. We argue that both assumptions can be
satisfied in practice by an attacker with weaker computational capabilities
than the watermarked model itself, to which the attacker has only black-box
access. Furthermore, our assumptions will likely only be easier to satisfy over
time as models grow in capabilities and modalities. We demonstrate the
feasibility of our attack by instantiating it to attack three existing
watermarking schemes for large language models: Kirchenbauer et al. (2023),
Kuditipudi et al. (2023), and Zhao et al. (2023). The same attack successfully
removes the watermarks planted by all three schemes, with only minor quality
degradation. | [
0.021168787,
0.0984380394,
0.0001500175,
0.0160802957,
-0.0446648076,
-0.015635252,
0.0075088544,
0.0469797477,
-0.0091546299,
0.0024904979,
-0.0004285288,
0.0183083601,
0.0165218432,
0.0086802458,
0.0593586341,
-0.0340730511,
0.0376953445,
-0.0124086598,
-0.020925222,
-0.0228039995,
-0.025867451,
-0.0475210249,
0.0863386616,
-0.027003495,
0.0117059154,
-0.0247397311,
-0.0105387019,
0.0063086101,
-0.0294512678,
0.0078299772,
-0.0856110528,
0.0560660735,
-0.0285482071,
0.1153586134,
0.0000021881,
-0.0064273281,
-0.0369280688,
0.0674701482,
-0.0447217859,
0.0777481049,
-0.0268702079,
0.0098041873,
-0.0460083298,
0.0121675357,
-0.0145057896,
0.0419032983,
0.054320097,
0.0334451795,
0.0833226293,
0.0602092408,
0.0051043914,
0.0038210887,
0.0528526455,
-0.0050509083,
0.0163074806,
-0.0279130768,
0.0108945146,
-0.002855584,
-0.0410402678,
0.0440150164,
-0.0209198184,
0.0631255507,
0.0050689634,
-0.0521735027,
-0.0443338081,
0.0209291205,
0.0090690656,
-0.0106286369,
0.0228877682,
0.0104297455,
-0.0755368993,
-0.0309903566,
0.0042291549,
-0.0052690106,
0.035767179,
0.0179934744,
-0.0045060753,
0.0408665165,
0.0222066324,
0.0061704707,
0.0086442502,
-0.0271497443,
0.0636175796,
-0.0181645527,
0.0294448156,
0.0345335044,
0.0533515513,
-0.0043661767,
-0.0757532269,
-0.0325941145,
-0.0251989737,
-0.0552181005,
0.013280306,
-0.0031206461,
0.0535989963,
0.0043502562,
-0.093092002,
-0.0227935165,
-0.0182569902,
-0.0192109607,
0.0635765195,
-0.0005743306,
0.0105686896,
0.0378903821,
-0.0300422739,
0.0290190279,
-0.0769545808,
0.0439674854,
0.0526605546,
0.0289190672,
0.0223567802,
-0.0511340834,
-0.0096742222,
0.0343501121,
-0.0217667725,
-0.0067969402,
-0.0100332666,
0.0399634093,
-0.0149829201,
0.0307078417,
-0.0407451242,
-0.0134832012,
-0.0306494124,
0.0018774045,
0.0482198261,
-0.0592080653,
0.0179289896,
-0.0114330817,
-0.0016097763,
-0.0512562357,
-0.0206133127,
-0.0005009916,
-0.0077562835,
0.0361600891,
-0.0233093109,
0.1013557687,
0.0311582536,
-0.0171364993,
-0.0104189403,
-0.070424594,
0.0171512831,
0.0051985099,
-0.0146617619,
-0.0309667848,
-0.0464825928,
-0.0414580293,
0.0136968819,
-0.0771724507,
-0.0025890174,
-0.0174853057,
-0.00260656,
0.0401477069,
-0.0329774655,
-0.019528158,
-0.0304154009,
0.0071170283,
-0.0303699244,
0.027085457,
0.0234530028,
0.0117955096,
0.0685567483,
-0.007761165,
0.0478789099,
0.0424028747,
-0.007987746,
0.0120567409,
-0.0110324956,
-0.0385591835,
0.0758827999,
-0.0345379673,
-0.0351037011,
0.048689235,
-0.0058646463,
-0.0540878698,
0.0641699955,
0.0149370888,
-0.0382112935,
0.0336195268,
-0.001777057,
0.0056327367,
0.0048666229,
0.0533613339,
-0.0091616567,
-0.0344140045,
-0.0525824279,
-0.018878134,
0.0415152423,
-0.0466818362,
-0.0161134899,
-0.0067394711,
0.0018596478,
-0.0284883101,
-0.0061639259,
-0.0228592549,
0.0097828256,
0.053638339,
-0.014835719,
-0.0050538401,
-0.0218033623,
-0.0182874482,
0.0202258043,
-0.0858638659,
0.0199839063,
0.0078889905,
0.0615519136,
0.0207119659,
0.1195665151,
0.0012445048,
-0.0518410727,
0.0119594261,
-0.0229964685,
-0.004274948,
0.0238848887,
-0.0013314673,
0.0119367242,
-0.0132036386,
0.0240931939,
0.0252977721,
0.0037245958,
-0.0013432754,
0.0070871948,
0.0013877269,
-0.0015577496,
-0.0254786555,
0.0082609123,
-0.0545257777,
0.0004352488,
-0.0242835972,
0.0333582684,
0.0216824543,
-0.0450554974,
0.0525388643,
0.0109653166,
0.0184628665,
-0.0188811813,
-0.0259362925,
0.0320281871,
0.0202494022,
0.0076169595,
-0.0355271511,
0.0080049792,
0.062160749,
0.0039239032,
-0.0188572779,
0.0426433273,
-0.0642846674,
0.0286992975,
0.0048161354,
0.0459689163,
-0.0151835326,
0.0422241092,
0.0045206207,
0.0158667546,
-0.000407573,
0.0389730334,
-0.0033956275,
0.0517383739,
-0.0194725394,
-0.0353001393,
-0.0611523911,
-0.0017375147,
-0.0405831784,
0.0061350861,
0.0253784899,
-0.0155534092,
-0.0052034589,
-0.0077028833,
0.0231748838,
-0.001671697,
0.014668934,
0.0219378937,
0.0039489437,
0.0110330535,
0.0130901411,
-0.0466712117,
-0.0101062683,
-0.0542287193,
0.0231222175,
0.0362408943,
0.0069433632,
0.013394489,
-0.0354678556,
0.0041909995,
-0.0243047588,
0.0180261601,
0.068623513,
-0.0091126291,
-0.0404096879,
-0.0525470227,
0.0433975942,
-0.0414845571,
0.0286583919,
0.0019973326,
-0.017352866,
0.0222446714,
-0.0073645269,
-0.0026903495,
0.068638511,
0.0180133265,
0.0200562607,
-0.0122714825,
0.0250770915,
-0.000454876,
-0.062558189,
-0.0160320997,
-0.0424230732,
-0.0160034839,
-0.0114406152,
0.0237954613,
0.034790419,
0.0230638981,
-0.0392182358,
-0.0309645571,
0.0539394915,
0.0145250922,
0.0071347179,
0.0182945114,
-0.0252040457,
-0.0182245243,
0.0290644895,
-0.027855657,
-0.0642280877,
-0.016906878,
-0.0316558108,
0.027728701,
0.0256685484,
0.0008156059,
0.0476066135,
0.0326520093,
0.005994522,
0.021836156,
0.0422004722,
-0.0096550761,
-0.0027926355,
-0.0334516168,
0.0869937092,
-0.0461825915,
-0.0550598539,
-0.021973474,
-0.022442665,
0.018652482,
-0.0183213521,
-0.015712956,
-0.0429357812,
0.0012385341,
-0.0109981038,
0.0245892685,
-0.0178806689,
0.0264935382,
0.0034957819,
0.0245727561,
0.0027051249,
-0.0108497757,
-0.0075383321,
-0.0320508182,
0.0546269082,
-0.0157950539,
-0.0755747184,
0.0015123155,
-0.0249274615,
0.0122903902,
0.0873355046,
0.0286093988,
0.0368806459,
0.0362071581,
-0.0083159916,
0.0425953902,
0.0309971925,
-0.0595885925,
0.0199379157,
-0.0045464858,
-0.0174934734,
-0.0104376916,
0.0219379216,
0.0043101809,
0.0323384777,
0.0374474302,
0.0427813493,
-0.0017679413,
0.0236349385,
-0.0186805893,
-0.0796142668,
0.0035572122,
0.039285142,
0.0322363451,
-0.0578226931,
-0.0022548924,
-0.026929697,
-0.0861893818,
0.0237790067,
0.0271229669,
0.0020803772,
-0.0150664728,
-0.0424875319,
-0.0095916688,
0.0391673297,
-0.0419034734,
-0.0588383004,
0.0584530383,
0.0017365189,
0.0341468155,
0.0320616476,
-0.0467497893,
-0.004363209,
0.0100631006,
0.0168450121,
0.0768628046,
0.004038427,
-0.0182402637,
-0.0469269045,
0.0433458611,
0.0197917931,
-0.0264921598,
0.0348441824,
0.0201769713,
0.0289747454,
-0.044045236,
-0.0137372566,
-0.0081806974,
0.0764796063,
-0.0158307962,
-0.0235885251,
0.0206798725,
0.0307826046,
-0.0486768484,
0.0325106531,
-0.0419572704,
0.0096582891,
0.0320337862,
-0.0016119264,
-0.0224304814,
-0.0210406836,
-0.0738643184,
0.0735811964,
0.0215376243,
-0.0734431893,
-0.0301549565,
-0.0001842078,
-0.0547858104,
-0.0366929471,
0.0257254466,
-0.0620184019,
0.0481830351,
0.047175698,
0.0232226942,
0.0235194862,
-0.0329503119,
0.0009254996,
-0.0240229536,
-0.1098857149,
0.0137506183,
-0.0477297828,
-0.0140022598,
0.0087089911,
-0.0197836384,
-0.0422353297,
-0.0059193894,
-0.0687223002,
-0.0733586326,
0.0158692207,
0.0341672935,
0.0324858315,
-0.0272102412,
-0.0112582762,
-0.046333842,
0.025634015,
0.001063654,
0.0034276966,
0.0216275211,
0.0825653747,
-0.0717583224,
0.011476635,
0.0279046483,
-0.0239753816,
-0.0038778998,
0.0869790539,
-0.0106371837,
-0.0341761522,
0.0253158771,
-0.000306102,
0.051304128,
0.0300942995,
0.0108312145,
-0.0098352423,
0.0222643577,
0.0212247726,
-0.0257593282,
-0.0167237464,
-0.034785863,
0.0252912398,
0.0095563829,
-0.003676797,
0.0286852587,
-0.0029262179,
0.0163094867,
0.0002359655,
-0.0238532685,
-0.0095816664,
0.0025836709,
-0.0029051378,
0.0413444713,
0.0013136623,
-0.0044216197,
0.0618710332,
0.0409050025,
0.0279348698,
0.0188746396,
-0.0283551589,
0.015663119,
0.0157130007,
0.0100357691,
0.021568438,
-0.1132231355,
-0.0509619452,
-0.0092036594,
0.0651846305,
0.0322464965,
0.0231978726,
-0.0328700431,
-0.0026016976,
-0.0126666622,
-0.0406915732,
-0.0086864559,
0.0113095473,
-0.0944791734,
-0.0141986823,
-0.0203428753,
-0.012756465,
0.0640165061,
0.0221987255,
-0.0097471708,
0.0621284433,
-0.0258638673,
-0.0238965303,
-0.0375167467,
-0.0137390271,
0.0178158302,
0.0212568436,
-0.0020753564,
-0.0230114106,
-0.0269787908,
-0.0727310777,
-0.0323991328,
-0.0060150158,
0.0610364452,
0.0213694628,
-0.040871311,
0.0026471897,
-0.0084799808,
0.03479499,
-0.0697707832,
0.0196849573,
0.0340293348,
-0.039929349,
0.0227360781,
-5.559527348e-33,
-0.0048874049,
0.0000677059,
-0.0860925615,
-0.0095443679,
0.0773320347,
0.0353334993,
-0.0240299869,
0.0025569971,
-0.002368106,
-0.0191792455,
-0.0206971094,
-0.005933885,
0.0092061711,
0.005668445,
-0.0533098727,
-0.0002806035,
0.0354157761,
-0.0111799929,
-0.0440504849,
0.0086887423,
0.0441404134,
-0.0360217877,
0.0095419539,
-0.019963963,
0.0393270068,
-0.0335790217,
-0.0813432708,
-0.0152569786,
-0.0521116257,
0.0610596575,
0.0067248866,
-0.0167814195,
-0.0454404317,
-0.049091287,
-0.0385277234,
0.0107998513,
-0.0020082658,
-0.0001530569,
-0.0059975614,
0.0107483817,
-0.0101701347,
-0.0554598905,
-0.0268419273,
-0.0242258608,
-0.014189654,
0.0358115658,
-0.0304746106,
0.0016484113,
-0.0254054945,
-0.0381988212,
0.0056748018,
0.0064302445,
-0.0260162335,
0.0190678611,
0.0199399665,
-0.0210781619,
0.0257934593,
-0.0325784385,
-0.0397829376,
0.0637650713,
0.076817207,
0.0168157574,
0.0216249302,
-0.0151104787,
0.0136521002,
-0.0113592548,
0.0307843182,
0.0137064233,
0.0781233832,
-0.0088369846,
-0.0227279253,
-0.0114449561,
0.0588554181,
0.0309078526,
0.0946998596,
0.0002216278,
0.0356984437,
0.0027280436,
-0.054778751,
-0.0259684902,
0.0581077039,
-0.000277464,
-0.0651982576,
-0.016158307,
-0.0677632019,
-0.0697767511,
-0.0096643604,
0.0098293144,
0.0191359092,
0.0456867181,
-0.0406496413,
-0.0239533447,
0.0119005851,
-0.0739693865,
-0.0467425101,
0.0158234816,
0.0008559704,
0.02062767,
-0.0238397513,
0.0065239863,
0.0508597977,
-0.021259157,
0.0323952213,
-0.0560075045,
0.0259464979,
0.0017709058,
0.0290275887,
0.0334149562,
-0.0884443596,
-0.0039655357,
0.0010611797,
0.0184646342,
0.0281034075,
-0.0105650611,
0.0245105997,
-0.0464119837,
-0.0145347584,
-0.0132423257,
0.0047724731,
0.0361363403,
0.0080162287,
0.0523131713,
-0.0446673222,
0.0103858868,
0.0224395897,
0.0200464651,
-0.0042960518,
0.0528341196,
0.0548755415,
0.0120692048,
-0.0201840177,
-0.0052375188,
2.977e-7,
-0.002403497,
-0.0262627732,
0.058953125,
0.0276364908,
0.0572720766,
0.0554356277,
0.0080199512,
0.022304479,
-0.0365428589,
0.0024028085,
-0.0530206375,
-0.0216869842,
0.0353738517,
-0.0444254614,
-0.0274245888,
0.0033518753,
-0.0560451485,
0.0087159863,
-0.0005197303,
-0.0213059131,
0.0173669588,
0.0933304653,
0.0237168167,
-0.0089619495,
0.0010158089,
-0.0635362118,
0.0205756351,
-0.016340185,
0.0276876334,
-0.0484729186,
0.0022662072,
0.0218915585,
0.0232310183,
0.0034712509,
-0.0667493865,
-0.0404428504,
0.0004377545,
0.0649016127,
0.0215142276,
0.0138790384,
-0.0426258147,
-0.0158492513,
0.0037554018,
-0.0116722248,
0.0399425775,
0.0960982144,
-0.050175149,
-0.072258994,
-0.0359462611,
-0.0518214218,
0.0467183404,
-0.0091362335,
-0.0229273178,
-0.0327646397,
-0.0151976021,
0.0457568504,
0.0017028647,
-0.023525374,
-0.035071414,
-0.0792802349,
-0.0173008852,
-0.0209087189,
-0.0058131632,
0.0266969576,
0.0465915874,
-0.0134122809,
-0.0026018205,
2.863588038e-34,
0.0127542373,
-0.0729301572,
0.0393392071,
0.0197222251,
0.0316346809,
0.0016349994,
0.0212501548,
-0.0116347065,
0.0456901826,
-0.0440378003,
-0.0429053791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04368v1 | Evaluating multiple large language models in pediatric ophthalmology | 2023-11-07T22:23:51 | 2023-11-07T22:23:51 | Jason Holmes, Rui Peng, Yiwei Li, Jinyu Hu, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Huan Zhao, Xi Jiang, Wei Liu, Hong Wei, Jie Zou, Tianming Liu, Yi Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL | IMPORTANCE The response effectiveness of different large language models
(LLMs) and various individuals, including medical students, graduate students,
and practicing physicians, in pediatric ophthalmology consultations, has not
been clearly established yet. OBJECTIVE Design a 100-question exam based on
pediatric ophthalmology to evaluate the performance of LLMs in highly
specialized scenarios and compare them with the performance of medical students
and physicians at different levels. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This
survey study assessed three LLMs, namely ChatGPT (GPT-3.5), GPT-4, and PaLM2,
were assessed alongside three human cohorts: medical students, postgraduate
students, and attending physicians, in their ability to answer questions
related to pediatric ophthalmology. It was conducted by administering
questionnaires in the form of test papers through the LLM network interface,
with the valuable participation of volunteers. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Mean
scores of LLM and humans on 100 multiple-choice questions, as well as the
answer stability, correlation, and response confidence of each LLM. RESULTS
GPT-4 performed comparably to attending physicians, while ChatGPT (GPT-3.5) and
PaLM2 outperformed medical students but slightly trailed behind postgraduate
students. Furthermore, GPT-4 exhibited greater stability and confidence when
responding to inquiries compared to ChatGPT (GPT-3.5) and PaLM2. CONCLUSIONS
AND RELEVANCE Our results underscore the potential for LLMs to provide medical
assistance in pediatric ophthalmology and suggest significant capacity to guide
the education of medical students. | [
0.0599493533,
-0.0180777665,
-0.0012079518,
-0.0322533399,
-0.0333963707,
0.0048019299,
0.0374195203,
0.0329073481,
0.0386808366,
-0.0371300988,
0.0297189597,
-0.0779553503,
0.0186744928,
-0.0121237654,
0.0112541569,
-0.0592130385,
-0.0149832135,
-0.0291661248,
0.0169990398,
-0.0088809626,
-0.0067655062,
0.0159146953,
-0.0358436853,
0.0167457592,
0.0399565436,
-0.032544136,
0.0470474921,
-0.0152690774,
-0.0045966706,
-0.0454887301,
0.0096693467,
0.0234740302,
-0.023649076,
-0.0338218957,
0.0000025463,
-0.0533699133,
0.0154140107,
0.0306640714,
-0.0112030003,
0.0521969534,
0.0628988147,
-0.0429175124,
0.0133616701,
0.0080727655,
-0.0200560912,
-0.0312954746,
0.043870829,
-0.0250546616,
0.0050286241,
0.0143124117,
-0.002763859,
0.0122035826,
0.0190116726,
0.0009987174,
0.0008219684,
-0.0104114544,
0.0257318486,
0.0567487553,
0.0178458448,
-0.0272232313,
-0.0169868842,
0.0420546755,
-0.0257771425,
-0.0151205808,
0.010380758,
0.0084864134,
-0.0159439407,
-0.0321702212,
0.013985943,
-0.0004104147,
0.0438209549,
-0.0157105774,
-0.0198719017,
0.0021021168,
0.0053415881,
0.075052388,
-0.0825713128,
0.0443375893,
0.0015565155,
-0.0152404234,
-0.0135424184,
-0.0496632271,
-0.0062230695,
0.0313834473,
-0.0209981054,
-0.0263891164,
0.0297149755,
0.0043776273,
0.0224446468,
0.0120512238,
0.0054579889,
-0.0213846676,
0.0083277179,
0.0562159047,
-0.0378666855,
-0.0053212265,
0.0123638306,
0.0022662738,
0.0744802207,
-0.0280112289,
0.0180229712,
0.0000615057,
-0.0182660352,
0.0132812206,
-0.0173713919,
0.0416907407,
0.0018209473,
0.0103352573,
-0.033972472,
0.0277495794,
-0.0311588962,
-0.0009979019,
0.0108666187,
-0.0080276765,
0.0077110543,
0.0087226164,
-0.0623900816,
-0.0339930244,
0.01291514,
-0.0065291324,
-0.0322919078,
0.0219207574,
0.0137070036,
-0.0123005789,
-0.056995254,
0.0801512748,
0.0414513424,
-0.0042259651,
-0.0401926078,
-0.0441136844,
0.0595360138,
0.0091149323,
-0.0088157076,
0.0302549675,
0.0023967584,
0.0686991364,
-0.0232479926,
0.0228100717,
0.0326598771,
-0.0275510252,
-0.0188034531,
-0.029373249,
-0.0155711714,
-0.0692226812,
-0.0374365374,
0.0508938096,
0.0203339905,
-0.0084975185,
0.0261069313,
0.0507446192,
-0.0021110065,
-0.0197940171,
-0.0393740721,
0.0264788084,
0.0401337855,
0.0192840602,
0.0510265864,
-0.0289050061,
0.0152519969,
-0.0664369762,
-0.0144141186,
-0.0833739415,
0.0132049276,
-0.0023621914,
-0.0213224497,
-0.0032943864,
0.0165502522,
0.0052596112,
0.0285309255,
0.0646098778,
-0.081025444,
0.0979933292,
0.0028340344,
-0.01797897,
0.0342405066,
0.0655370876,
-0.0097959563,
0.0024816941,
-0.0217012484,
-0.0081756907,
0.0611747578,
-0.0059087011,
0.0318116061,
0.0097771967,
0.0135355545,
-0.0181828626,
-0.0727682412,
0.0424600467,
0.0122109568,
-0.0269438345,
-0.0868008062,
0.0057568103,
-0.0328166299,
0.0309579093,
0.0246293172,
-0.0662832707,
-0.0278473087,
0.0500427596,
0.0123322634,
-0.0485950261,
0.0070403363,
-0.0450974628,
0.0021788485,
0.0483019352,
0.0169706866,
0.0170142073,
-0.033983402,
-0.0163866896,
-0.0205987748,
0.0406084806,
0.0312113333,
-0.018952705,
-0.0020071203,
-0.0315980874,
0.0332735516,
0.0316095315,
0.0114976419,
-0.0396755524,
-0.0194923915,
0.0554647185,
-0.011138116,
-0.0092762141,
-0.0547283478,
0.0033415086,
-0.0752070621,
-0.0021219875,
-0.0099161174,
-0.0223212838,
-0.033616364,
0.0120333666,
0.0191844255,
0.0280393362,
-0.0066497698,
0.0247278381,
0.017217027,
-0.0447280072,
-0.0087918472,
0.0268807877,
0.066566065,
-0.0549353696,
0.0254772343,
-0.0436902232,
0.0119683594,
-0.0105312439,
-0.0072019026,
-0.0429350808,
0.0591611974,
0.0122023495,
0.0235546678,
-0.0125188418,
-0.0121771442,
-0.047439713,
-0.0240288526,
0.0201736763,
-0.0042160051,
0.0261917803,
-0.0519985072,
0.0015994986,
-0.0486197174,
-0.0188880004,
0.0210152902,
-0.0149263218,
0.0313369632,
-0.0068843695,
0.0419754423,
-0.0380968451,
-0.0460933223,
-0.1044345498,
-0.0457795113,
0.0437225662,
-0.0199285522,
0.039567925,
-0.0447454713,
0.0208577178,
0.007272711,
-0.0332238898,
0.0052629625,
0.0070200707,
0.0043901098,
-0.0101303216,
0.0193337705,
-0.0140760038,
-0.0306094326,
-0.0395491011,
-0.0406974368,
0.012374199,
0.0684836656,
-0.0431253724,
0.0356713347,
0.0089714136,
-0.0588180795,
-0.0130303241,
0.0109633096,
-0.0277819429,
0.0534969717,
-0.0207953416,
0.0219513532,
0.0441535637,
-0.0107800132,
-0.0209734179,
0.0273196101,
-0.0338341221,
-0.0023472726,
-0.040641807,
0.0072255037,
-0.0829750597,
-0.0266221054,
-0.1139952242,
-0.0485051945,
0.0287041385,
0.0113373566,
-0.017282987,
-0.0053321803,
-0.0076659126,
-0.0593323521,
0.0470491499,
-0.0723848492,
0.0123405205,
-0.022552805,
0.0684496388,
0.0348234065,
-0.0496739596,
0.0444715172,
0.0120378407,
0.0359315239,
-0.0716015771,
-0.0314722098,
-0.0132872602,
0.0151833678,
-0.0451549031,
0.0051211501,
0.0211130511,
-0.0143450499,
-0.0491652191,
0.013247462,
0.0340010747,
-0.0681696087,
0.0672094524,
-0.0550211929,
-0.0019658457,
0.0025848125,
0.0185527187,
-0.0339611508,
0.0147869699,
-0.0022919937,
-0.010558622,
-0.0137692131,
0.0067575192,
-0.0492067002,
0.0301903039,
0.0229796544,
0.0489701368,
-0.0116562825,
0.0147706019,
0.0268264432,
-0.0251990613,
0.0371504836,
0.0071342988,
0.0368777253,
-0.029037077,
0.0605983883,
0.0886394978,
0.0082598133,
0.0240892805,
0.0096196188,
-0.030695023,
0.0346551798,
0.0080504995,
-0.0279399026,
0.0533639416,
-0.0043047224,
-0.0491191894,
0.0292314403,
0.0581419542,
0.0255848262,
-0.0131609505,
-0.0156531744,
-0.0379226431,
-0.0508936867,
0.0076831025,
-0.0129916705,
-0.0374709778,
0.0316160247,
-0.0389504135,
0.0629606023,
0.0165401287,
0.0012508401,
0.0232615769,
-0.011556196,
0.0244194735,
0.0288036522,
-0.0216286052,
-0.0077815996,
0.0003008674,
0.0262178555,
0.0590155907,
0.0224456843,
0.0199530274,
-0.0200062767,
0.0143079227,
0.0119631533,
-0.0913185328,
-0.0499301963,
0.0741437525,
0.0215870459,
-0.0057589556,
-0.011555491,
-0.0127396528,
-0.014795959,
-0.0449650288,
0.0195908491,
-0.0155752171,
-0.0339423604,
-0.0094187409,
0.0439020768,
0.0352535769,
0.021069875,
-0.0461221077,
0.0135267805,
-0.0431688614,
0.0080030514,
0.0319184773,
0.0567185283,
-0.0004120975,
-0.0325822681,
-0.0105591957,
0.0436931774,
-0.0115783196,
0.0019728208,
-0.0094629563,
-0.0140922545,
0.0306420326,
0.0139400382,
0.0156535115,
0.0287039336,
-0.0202755015,
0.0399361067,
0.0408626609,
-0.0118284794,
-0.0275062975,
0.0273040682,
0.0408840738,
-0.010921957,
0.0384503119,
0.0497743376,
0.0638839304,
-0.0313037075,
-0.011637439,
0.0636844262,
0.0247143861,
0.0222886205,
-0.0826631784,
-0.0159832966,
0.0605565421,
-0.0061698984,
-0.0158096068,
-0.0207785051,
0.0040474613,
-0.0104918191,
0.0110735008,
0.0259751976,
0.0199513957,
-0.082870923,
0.0209857244,
-0.0240884088,
-0.0182815287,
0.0010855836,
0.0008764323,
0.006967233,
-0.0515856929,
0.0004131013,
0.0431410335,
-0.0241114702,
-0.011475265,
-0.0374352336,
0.014061356,
0.0057200454,
-0.0046759308,
-0.059777014,
0.0253535993,
0.074720785,
0.0701003522,
-0.0076224571,
-0.0091216825,
-0.0061380668,
-0.0054995166,
-0.0401847586,
0.008030341,
-0.0242353342,
-0.0193340741,
0.052431155,
0.017419206,
0.002602193,
-0.0387891904,
-0.0716642514,
-0.0460560359,
-0.0370285548,
0.1030385047,
-0.019858826,
-0.0366584919,
0.0797765702,
0.0224260185,
-0.0430166833,
-0.0686305165,
-0.0078292927,
0.0376366079,
0.0339378491,
0.0897337943,
-0.0122093782,
0.0028016903,
0.0477549545,
-0.0177694429,
0.0426978953,
-0.065357402,
-0.0250627697,
0.0190549046,
-0.0095965667,
0.020657571,
0.0063143037,
-0.0268135499,
0.011680101,
-0.0488972552,
-0.0062896614,
-0.0118559767,
-0.0108820759,
0.0953419134,
-0.0068263165,
-0.0136505701,
-0.0099013979,
0.041022107,
0.0045480533,
-0.0300958436,
0.0013361649,
-0.0290014129,
-0.0156351104,
-0.005918806,
0.025140021,
0.0023767762,
-0.0614946038,
0.0443237536,
-0.0848535299,
-0.0498798862,
-0.0635178015,
-0.0031359654,
0.0098088803,
-0.0409262404,
0.0165879205,
0.0440593921,
0.0045789033,
-0.0008589221,
-0.042992238,
0.0829310045,
-0.0048433268,
-0.0040051159,
0.0280612931,
-6.327778661e-33,
0.0230999682,
-0.0450672433,
0.0485280231,
-0.0476987846,
0.0108507816,
0.0315802842,
-0.0178920198,
0.0399231203,
-0.0510945655,
0.0031765956,
0.0062736813,
-0.0196622722,
0.0037439852,
0.062072888,
0.0315645598,
-0.0298802909,
-0.0299142469,
0.0235209912,
-0.0040857126,
-0.0291987713,
-0.0584634095,
-0.0470302589,
0.0646267235,
-0.0346537642,
0.0180061366,
-0.0437693261,
0.029258851,
-0.0435110405,
-0.0165377613,
0.0705028251,
0.0261358749,
0.0513467006,
0.0197515413,
-0.0049961116,
0.0125835575,
-0.0155331586,
-0.0220376756,
-0.0036567824,
0.0567997545,
-0.014654641,
-0.0695231557,
0.0192548782,
0.0469176918,
-0.0270785689,
-0.0183220115,
-0.031190848,
0.0163033344,
-0.0271942429,
-0.030141551,
0.0309238285,
-0.0294473562,
0.0105409883,
0.0139030516,
0.0040877485,
-0.0373452306,
0.0259052105,
-0.0342022292,
0.0107593946,
0.0171992872,
0.0426889323,
0.0570687838,
0.0331324786,
0.0070098229,
-0.0078431461,
-0.0013117406,
0.0121202404,
0.0331393443,
-0.0318016931,
-0.016293386,
-0.0447711013,
-0.0026043183,
-0.0205410868,
0.0798893943,
0.0453240313,
-0.0137210563,
-0.0000312331,
-0.0845857784,
-0.0007024714,
-0.0376105942,
0.0955336615,
-0.0120722633,
-0.0147197526,
-0.0504061654,
-0.0137527417,
-0.0118133361,
-0.0069654966,
-0.0097910287,
-0.0121149598,
0.0355416685,
-0.037773326,
0.0060445522,
0.0093430597,
0.0315257981,
-0.0065663536,
0.0122056762,
-0.0503802747,
-0.0090418672,
0.0473229587,
-0.0485543013,
0.0289336089,
-0.0719226524,
0.0358616151,
0.0105570462,
-0.0321108475,
0.0380508117,
0.050334882,
-0.0586772263,
-0.0407161191,
-0.0601050854,
-0.0039906423,
0.0098161418,
-0.0363843255,
0.0067443955,
0.0228033289,
0.0213095751,
0.008093006,
0.0097538373,
0.0472644046,
-0.022594478,
-0.0779560283,
-0.0304495525,
-0.0752518103,
-0.0209649261,
-0.0248059127,
-0.0223262142,
0.0342481434,
-0.0153716886,
0.0553467683,
0.0309936479,
0.032417845,
0.0049167844,
0.0073575596,
3.148e-7,
0.0391220637,
0.1117385104,
-0.0608679354,
-0.0251445733,
0.0435216017,
-0.0203333218,
0.0037158262,
-0.0400178693,
0.0627015531,
-0.0237720739,
0.0080821849,
-0.0322220102,
0.0040146429,
0.019732533,
-0.0138469581,
-0.0059271087,
-0.0317292586,
0.0065714391,
-0.0147648426,
0.0098481458,
0.0615851954,
0.0121549135,
-0.0560162961,
-0.0472223349,
-0.0275714509,
-0.0290888604,
0.0217366777,
-0.0513374656,
-0.0050454284,
0.0567884259,
0.0237337779,
-0.0039213183,
0.0611099862,
0.1202220321,
-0.02385615,
-0.0420643091,
0.0242338479,
0.0524926819,
-0.0318997391,
0.0545558892,
0.0412896015,
0.0149425808,
0.023191968,
-0.127562657,
0.0215757508,
-0.0096443044,
0.0018793709,
0.0392203927,
-0.038443733,
-0.02620361,
0.0504039302,
-0.051934354,
-0.0612138063,
0.0130640976,
0.0084754331,
0.0262026582,
-0.0234287363,
0.0027994062,
0.0147423334,
-0.0203326866,
0.0099569149,
-0.0648696199,
0.0355107673,
-0.075321205,
-0.0372146703,
-0.0125631671,
0.000180363,
2.731180998e-34,
0.0431603156,
-0.0041967924,
0.0537223294,
-0.0459134169,
0.0246465262,
-0.0015989068,
-0.0058803074,
0.0454572514,
0.032391727,
-0.0125037404,
-0.0188668557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04364v1 | Syntax-Guided Transformers: Elevating Compositional Generalization and Grounding in Multimodal Environments | 2023-11-07T21:59:16 | 2023-11-07T21:59:16 | Danial Kamali, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.RO | Compositional generalization, the ability of intelligent models to
extrapolate understanding of components to novel compositions, is a fundamental
yet challenging facet in AI research, especially within multimodal
environments. In this work, we address this challenge by exploiting the
syntactic structure of language to boost compositional generalization. This
paper elevates the importance of syntactic grounding, particularly through
attention masking techniques derived from text input parsing. We introduce and
evaluate the merits of using syntactic information in the multimodal grounding
problem. Our results on grounded compositional generalization underscore the
positive impact of dependency parsing across diverse tasks when utilized with
Weight Sharing across the Transformer encoder. The results push the
state-of-the-art in multimodal grounding and parameter-efficient modeling and
provide insights for future research. | [
0.0247398801,
0.0441935696,
-0.0139648104,
0.0261586737,
0.0005534972,
0.0003433276,
0.0097720288,
-0.0277199708,
-0.0496202856,
-0.0540909804,
-0.0315024555,
-0.0146759432,
-0.0034202475,
0.0392009094,
0.042859856,
-0.075775072,
0.0092808483,
0.006244434,
-0.0630545169,
0.0275748856,
0.0103114396,
0.0083452547,
0.0127114281,
0.0589600615,
-0.0661553219,
-0.0075944928,
-0.026564341,
-0.0018614182,
-0.0034782975,
-0.0040323888,
-0.008094497,
0.0152706699,
0.0437065512,
0.011250494,
0.0000019451,
-0.0370134637,
-0.0186023712,
-0.0187039692,
0.0293982904,
-0.0560153648,
0.022886062,
-0.0679965839,
0.0215879492,
-0.0225488096,
-0.0357790552,
-0.0205078665,
0.0722872317,
0.0631097332,
0.0955948755,
0.0526172295,
-0.0296998732,
-0.0807165727,
-0.0102397474,
0.0029315813,
0.011493545,
0.0145164691,
0.0022108022,
0.010934826,
-0.0147854127,
-0.0322569199,
-0.0662992448,
0.0204472765,
0.050926771,
0.0098430282,
0.0679464117,
0.0428993814,
-0.0138364155,
-0.0156850424,
-0.0124010704,
0.0803449452,
-0.0430328622,
-0.0112343337,
-0.0169989672,
0.007113623,
-0.0008616606,
-0.0198174957,
-0.0568600558,
0.0463768542,
-0.0352758355,
0.0184534974,
-0.0158940163,
-0.0008603775,
-0.008625254,
-0.0593170151,
-0.0243120324,
0.0805389509,
0.0098556979,
-0.0265816767,
0.0237770025,
0.0265356358,
-0.040318016,
-0.0658503622,
0.0403999239,
0.0288115572,
0.0017743161,
-0.0118534267,
-0.0564209297,
-0.0830894932,
-0.0558985956,
-0.0399591438,
0.0473395325,
0.0385128967,
-0.0509370267,
0.0482311174,
0.0002397318,
0.0339440629,
-0.0482091792,
0.0315300077,
-0.0411599465,
0.0019038281,
-0.0535808057,
-0.0288200174,
-0.0710603371,
0.0256038271,
-0.0344066247,
-0.0257748757,
0.0143505847,
0.0291618239,
-0.0268362127,
0.0129379556,
0.0222653095,
0.0252820253,
-0.0892570615,
-0.0043250429,
0.0199600868,
0.0225357562,
-0.0194987915,
0.0155381141,
0.0040952908,
-0.0285386648,
-0.0360375419,
0.0348475166,
0.0195997376,
-0.0353134386,
-0.0261047501,
0.0868841633,
-0.0157336071,
-0.0219180025,
-0.0053318385,
-0.0478490554,
-0.0218881331,
-0.020030994,
0.0488623083,
-0.0343048722,
0.0361623541,
0.0115618864,
0.0104023889,
-0.0495124757,
-0.0021983816,
0.0299565922,
0.0119696623,
0.0738497227,
0.0404700674,
-0.0297561549,
-0.0105175655,
0.0030277621,
-0.0563093573,
0.0721727014,
0.0441259965,
0.0211413503,
-0.0146546271,
-0.0086035561,
0.0221402198,
0.024572162,
-0.0212308783,
-0.0270442106,
-0.0348098092,
-0.0406212062,
0.0130555863,
0.0042454638,
0.0446102396,
0.0422641598,
-0.0151726566,
-0.0075732218,
0.0564805567,
0.0082440972,
-0.0045895232,
0.0522086769,
0.092131786,
-0.0075496887,
-0.030117536,
0.089766331,
-0.0256201606,
0.0606470145,
-0.010274034,
0.0059310575,
-0.050057184,
0.0164219588,
-0.0102567561,
-0.0274948329,
-0.0069468231,
-0.0155666219,
0.0477392226,
-0.0295073148,
0.0228992347,
0.0520800613,
-0.0577147752,
0.0828772932,
0.0176739842,
-0.077979058,
0.0224551223,
0.0233864617,
-0.0227240343,
0.0249867812,
0.021392338,
-0.0307061337,
-0.0093829986,
-0.0236827545,
0.0457321145,
0.0407888666,
-0.0384917334,
-0.0058599687,
0.0424317792,
-0.0392133966,
-0.0280492567,
-0.0800762475,
-0.0058592013,
0.024039479,
-0.0363522917,
-0.0375761651,
0.0033542884,
-0.0145438863,
0.0554988794,
0.0470662415,
0.0360338986,
-0.0123272398,
-0.0300033465,
0.0281461105,
0.0293062348,
-0.0104077645,
0.0062900814,
0.0007319142,
0.0039503505,
-0.0707770139,
-0.028374685,
0.0549204201,
-0.0679946393,
-0.0168228578,
-0.0110400319,
-0.1184837967,
-0.0005579338,
0.016017599,
-0.0102922469,
-0.0238241423,
0.0312149152,
-0.0740352422,
0.0699971542,
0.0112261316,
-0.002494609,
0.0262710433,
0.0246258117,
-0.0151409525,
0.0516578481,
-0.021185955,
-0.0234577153,
-0.0279352386,
-0.0283598863,
0.0244854167,
-0.0097506046,
-0.0202614814,
-0.0059105237,
0.0042758766,
-0.0337028913,
0.0147830788,
-0.0060367789,
-0.0257944688,
-0.0223213583,
-0.0754755437,
-0.0319103822,
-0.0409598462,
-0.0205993466,
0.0170077179,
0.0305675175,
0.0359991007,
-0.0141219124,
-0.0060457895,
0.0268599745,
-0.0226016901,
0.008278857,
0.0353143737,
0.0237641558,
-0.0231002532,
-0.0073392759,
-0.0071666944,
-0.0267614294,
0.0663320124,
0.0094544431,
-0.0346500911,
-0.0587642565,
0.0072277673,
0.0018647751,
0.0332701616,
-0.0146676134,
-0.0413393565,
0.0191357546,
-0.0210434422,
0.0465462506,
0.0738979653,
-0.0336896293,
0.0078351637,
0.0742083266,
-0.0347876884,
-0.024162082,
0.0480648428,
0.0022316552,
0.026207339,
-0.0225357264,
0.0252658352,
0.0230679419,
0.0989340097,
0.0071988618,
0.0073826206,
-0.0716328546,
0.0254149977,
-0.0180331394,
-0.0370456055,
-0.0034361128,
-0.0260055941,
-0.0207471922,
0.0041185599,
-0.0301797949,
-0.0083067659,
0.0874039605,
-0.0128893321,
-0.0499224812,
-0.0072939997,
0.0457140058,
-0.025406668,
0.0599844903,
0.0382236727,
0.0068998411,
0.0481912866,
-0.0481962152,
-0.0593124777,
0.038603805,
0.0367441066,
0.0457045883,
0.0640988499,
-0.0446022041,
-0.0069641699,
-0.014326198,
-0.0500495769,
-0.0312746018,
0.0127348313,
-0.0155706117,
-0.0216972213,
0.0141386939,
0.0126583893,
-0.034390673,
0.0276953913,
0.0155064687,
0.0317924358,
0.015773043,
-0.0196134448,
-0.0477674194,
0.0069293608,
0.0100841448,
0.0330415219,
-0.0154702365,
-0.0231324416,
-0.0103211049,
0.0340127796,
0.0295124706,
-0.0039681154,
-0.0488782637,
0.0476804301,
0.0210962016,
0.0179393943,
-0.004788442,
0.0156902634,
0.0387836061,
-0.0720221922,
-0.0269388035,
0.0594985373,
0.0240973551,
-0.047289338,
0.0223095994,
0.0105549479,
0.0009396996,
0.0471189246,
0.0196712967,
-0.0564520843,
-0.0322602578,
0.0149395987,
-0.0262503456,
0.0475612618,
-0.0269081257,
-0.0033521799,
-0.0709512383,
0.0338297188,
0.0109669631,
-0.0189171806,
-0.0533351004,
-0.0144308824,
0.0104142372,
-0.0036931986,
-0.0308474787,
-0.0144862412,
-0.008496454,
-0.0210513044,
0.0025040237,
-0.0143712014,
-0.0382841527,
-0.0300756413,
-0.0323254056,
-0.0390207022,
0.0583434068,
0.0006319867,
-0.0089568384,
-0.049454391,
0.0295585487,
0.0033516383,
0.0172050036,
0.0053641726,
0.0352804773,
-0.0204029288,
-0.0218086634,
0.0231731255,
0.0249137934,
-0.0296609905,
-0.0175831895,
-0.0222524963,
0.0773710161,
-0.029005982,
0.007155783,
-0.0150374733,
0.0244545881,
0.0160719138,
0.0404675677,
0.0608138777,
-0.0343848839,
-0.0081473095,
-0.0601207688,
0.0107670231,
-0.070607923,
-0.0019823543,
0.0320969187,
0.0149028804,
-0.030432621,
-0.0676763505,
-0.026653504,
0.0442053452,
0.0251445286,
0.0033963225,
-0.0690044314,
0.0306407176,
-0.003238119,
-0.0284083225,
0.0372261256,
0.0062915133,
0.0152903553,
-0.0067022596,
0.0091632381,
-0.0031222377,
-0.0280897561,
-0.0221636742,
-0.0015847285,
-0.0843974873,
-0.0367786624,
0.0266574994,
0.072520256,
0.0152981263,
0.0436799228,
0.000278802,
-0.0380330943,
-0.0074555776,
0.0014059285,
-0.0246353336,
0.0487217009,
0.0482435897,
-0.0407809876,
0.034079615,
0.0105303992,
-0.0606068298,
0.0058648475,
0.0296706147,
0.0418690555,
0.0021561673,
0.0100892903,
0.0601666383,
-0.0357152186,
0.0433684886,
0.0054290039,
0.0779300034,
-0.0159075838,
0.0146495318,
-0.0259097815,
-0.0340552442,
-0.0845520496,
0.0111478623,
-0.0087097902,
0.0266604666,
0.0095240036,
0.0470581129,
-0.0154428519,
0.032705199,
-0.0286481138,
0.0446953177,
0.0289364699,
-0.0741949305,
0.0100770453,
0.0253794007,
0.0029010272,
0.0005318897,
-0.0004915489,
0.0019086896,
-0.0083430335,
0.0386500061,
0.0415536426,
-0.0185943861,
-0.0655013174,
0.0319802463,
-0.0311942417,
0.0275725406,
-0.0185293593,
-0.0064202677,
0.0556550734,
-0.0227779616,
0.0278082062,
-0.0096214898,
-0.0110394936,
0.0182743743,
0.0441496447,
0.0123806288,
-0.0479834452,
0.0343327522,
0.0116016138,
0.011123836,
-0.0230493397,
0.0846181735,
-0.0371409319,
0.046436891,
-0.0202558953,
-0.0018694112,
-0.0474142805,
-0.0259815454,
0.0092926994,
0.0206740852,
0.0049474332,
0.0094077224,
-0.022939695,
-0.043481987,
0.0137715144,
-0.0012436711,
-0.0012375381,
-0.0156560428,
0.083364211,
0.049648989,
0.0173764043,
-0.0599229597,
0.0236935262,
-0.0257084239,
0.0262881275,
-0.0053578755,
-0.0254278816,
-5.881296152e-33,
-0.0472020172,
-0.0107721854,
-0.008146395,
0.0404911675,
-0.0467006676,
0.0122463005,
-0.0365873687,
-0.0095010269,
0.0344674587,
0.0027257674,
0.0159827266,
0.0069593652,
-0.0114901597,
0.0199247785,
0.056015376,
-0.0094376029,
0.0490845889,
0.0044965143,
-0.0412078612,
-0.00031391,
0.0199874248,
0.0368146114,
0.0746631995,
-0.0178141724,
-0.0217583645,
0.0320101455,
-0.0266445819,
-0.0000877003,
0.0051681302,
0.0677019283,
-0.0103859631,
0.0240291003,
0.026281381,
-0.0323485173,
-0.0337162428,
0.0447825566,
-0.0417479351,
-0.0309931878,
-0.0086453883,
0.0411342531,
-0.0590155832,
-0.0430932753,
0.074843064,
-0.0183922239,
0.0306419581,
-0.0240463037,
0.05444723,
-0.0014776679,
0.0343309604,
-0.0367702506,
-0.0668152049,
-0.0326370224,
-0.0261720829,
-0.0210466534,
0.0240988079,
0.0732811764,
0.0360325277,
0.0304817632,
-0.0413751453,
0.0042179539,
-0.0534940697,
0.0119365044,
0.0433008522,
0.0117561501,
0.0060492163,
0.0381667688,
-0.0292822495,
-0.0124249123,
-0.0716215894,
0.0216700602,
0.0022994659,
0.0392331481,
0.0193333849,
0.0016162921,
0.0190431252,
0.0353673622,
-0.032814309,
0.0070431861,
-0.034923397,
0.1064043716,
0.0042538517,
0.0570673905,
0.006009019,
-0.0023356583,
-0.004718279,
-0.0004000754,
-0.0113613755,
-0.0278797485,
0.0191859752,
-0.0058385273,
-0.0088959159,
0.0021962016,
0.0675611049,
-0.029154297,
0.0315458588,
0.0040051891,
-0.0108810645,
0.0814627409,
0.0178282242,
0.0047416613,
-0.0029443952,
-0.00833744,
0.0715404078,
0.0131572066,
0.0532895103,
0.0013373812,
0.0450482406,
0.0619694777,
-0.0207476523,
-0.0244489573,
-0.0482658036,
-0.0168864988,
0.0055919499,
0.0715833381,
0.0642217249,
0.0221614279,
-0.053026814,
0.0278291069,
-0.0161489975,
-0.000427919,
-0.0513799377,
-0.0216206647,
0.0024495129,
0.0262502581,
-0.0339220427,
-0.0090363007,
-0.0229410995,
-0.0355212577,
0.055638466,
-0.0555703752,
-0.0484693833,
0.0301116444,
2.771e-7,
0.0338938423,
0.012567291,
0.0384584144,
0.0249943715,
0.0228584111,
0.0205809381,
-0.0120419068,
0.0436932817,
-0.0262581818,
-0.0638617426,
-0.0044682398,
0.0121242553,
0.0279872436,
0.0098854704,
-0.0966810212,
0.003537595,
-0.0539908744,
-0.0310453326,
-0.0270526335,
-0.0145505592,
0.0518340729,
0.0780907199,
-0.013248045,
0.0047236849,
0.0069224015,
0.0054125097,
0.0580120645,
0.0092298985,
-0.0006888299,
-0.0240718629,
0.009346257,
-0.0166827887,
-0.0317025445,
0.0178347137,
-0.0170903187,
-0.0026267583,
0.0439500026,
0.0314660445,
-0.0223580971,
-0.0017445143,
0.0021186799,
0.025174858,
-0.0293450374,
-0.0478200056,
0.0529731698,
-0.0954146981,
-0.0085302517,
-0.0209703073,
-0.021188315,
0.0038354329,
-0.0346984118,
0.0006588386,
-0.0191254932,
-0.0076048751,
0.0286727287,
-0.0067887343,
-0.0277565569,
-0.0646628663,
-0.0409602001,
0.028844608,
-0.0381187722,
0.0145088127,
-0.0176013298,
-0.052446086,
0.0437202156,
-0.0340208188,
-0.0560735948,
2.594979773e-34,
0.0116890697,
-0.0171569604,
0.0449024811,
0.0132890632,
0.0446273461,
-0.025418777,
-0.0576040521,
0.0113723492,
-0.0083998004,
-0.0726283938,
-0.0399843305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04354v2 | Uncovering Intermediate Variables in Transformers using Circuit Probing | 2023-11-07T21:27:17 | 2023-11-17T15:15:17 | Michael A. Lepori, Thomas Serre, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural network models have achieved high performance on a wide variety of
complex tasks, but the algorithms that they implement are notoriously difficult
to interpret. In order to understand these algorithms, it is often necessary to
hypothesize intermediate variables involved in the network's computation. For
example, does a language model depend on particular syntactic properties when
generating a sentence? However, existing analysis tools make it difficult to
test hypotheses of this type. We propose a new analysis technique -- circuit
probing -- that automatically uncovers low-level circuits that compute
hypothesized intermediate variables. This enables causal analysis through
targeted ablation at the level of model parameters. We apply this method to
models trained on simple arithmetic tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness at
(1) deciphering the algorithms that models have learned, (2) revealing modular
structure within a model, and (3) tracking the development of circuits over
training. We compare circuit probing to other methods across these three
experiments, and find it on par or more effective than existing analysis
methods. Finally, we demonstrate circuit probing on a real-world use case,
uncovering circuits that are responsible for subject-verb agreement and
reflexive anaphora in GPT2-Small and Medium. | [
-0.0132843396,
0.0960285589,
-0.0352713019,
0.0498035997,
-0.0299645998,
0.0095968386,
0.0151066966,
-0.0216367301,
-0.0247147195,
-0.0227587614,
-0.0243983287,
0.0019393682,
0.0069642174,
0.0168872122,
0.0518051237,
0.0168766305,
0.0710173845,
0.007861048,
-0.0629808456,
0.0051745721,
-0.0220290776,
0.0114654489,
-0.0112160575,
0.0636025965,
-0.0246314276,
-0.0223050937,
-0.0255399793,
-0.0264774375,
0.0044702739,
0.0424579158,
-0.0077714967,
0.0618437342,
-0.0172508713,
0.0640161037,
0.0000022318,
-0.0188633278,
-0.0083131138,
0.0033429831,
-0.0616056249,
0.0379928686,
0.0041886191,
0.0145058921,
-0.0014828279,
0.015059757,
-0.0350186899,
-0.0288901944,
0.0752967,
0.0616851635,
0.0210595671,
0.0637261048,
-0.0176569093,
-0.0602120161,
0.0114375846,
-0.0232396852,
0.0082121892,
0.003447158,
0.0067608054,
-0.0570578501,
-0.0291463435,
-0.0421083644,
-0.0243457593,
0.0007806033,
0.0618907064,
0.0293365698,
-0.0185635369,
0.0358199812,
0.0052937856,
-0.021957254,
0.0220983513,
0.0232040957,
-0.0015133586,
-0.0374999568,
0.0201433375,
0.0037390997,
-0.0010596729,
0.0176130161,
-0.0118254581,
-0.0032996258,
-0.0046772235,
0.0167066026,
0.0146489451,
-0.0348658375,
0.0234765653,
-0.0119739752,
-0.0552453101,
0.07364849,
0.0185260847,
0.0017787148,
-0.0261803418,
0.0409327112,
0.000343543,
-0.0259794593,
0.0217337869,
-0.0154284872,
-0.0008561061,
0.0019134699,
0.0056718807,
-0.0106687825,
-0.0210586656,
-0.0175889973,
0.0363110043,
0.035139773,
-0.0152470274,
-0.0320821442,
-0.0200184714,
0.0680667982,
-0.0516703986,
0.0604768991,
-0.0269126799,
0.042751696,
-0.0197060369,
-0.0648053288,
-0.014296405,
0.0307220966,
-0.003161707,
-0.0027205425,
-0.0407291763,
0.0324896574,
-0.009422373,
-0.0374715142,
-0.0404825397,
0.026547689,
-0.0214862786,
0.0438476354,
-0.0125503102,
0.0486769229,
-0.0494764335,
0.0348833762,
-0.0064350762,
-0.0328167155,
-0.0467833169,
-0.0040984559,
0.0224171076,
-0.0248918235,
0.0079313731,
0.0802034363,
-0.0099068079,
-0.0492322668,
-0.0372644179,
-0.056896124,
-0.0044789398,
-0.0376388207,
0.0495844707,
-0.044854518,
-0.0007620408,
0.0363328196,
0.0083781648,
-0.0129672382,
0.0142775252,
0.0127591416,
-0.0260394309,
0.0646883771,
0.0468121134,
-0.0248311367,
-0.0371874496,
-0.0101065049,
0.0253889319,
0.0432152487,
0.0257050972,
-0.0023750998,
-0.0160649214,
-0.0262700859,
0.043339245,
0.0408142842,
0.0476242937,
-0.0476216376,
-0.0171747692,
-0.0816622823,
-0.0190928169,
-0.0031435825,
-0.0077889417,
0.0278205331,
-0.0241191797,
0.0029794252,
0.062703073,
0.0465543158,
0.0147614237,
0.0461083762,
0.0457073599,
-0.0577198155,
0.0136207147,
0.0684922636,
-0.1032430828,
0.0335705876,
-0.0389031395,
0.0082629016,
-0.0556607172,
0.0268885009,
-0.0127951084,
-0.0735032111,
-0.0150458738,
0.0237712134,
-0.0148611441,
-0.0113407774,
0.0490933992,
0.0361629128,
-0.0310633741,
0.0624293573,
-0.004004728,
-0.0464316197,
0.005962871,
-0.0658773258,
-0.0015288341,
0.0039303112,
0.0475163348,
-0.0251310971,
0.0111178886,
-0.0204764176,
-0.0333233401,
0.0164333452,
-0.0151127931,
-0.0011682237,
0.0268390514,
-0.0018385797,
-0.0090470016,
-0.0283272658,
0.0701362863,
0.0156201925,
-0.0047961124,
-0.0514008738,
0.0105971359,
-0.025234608,
0.0261940677,
0.0167504642,
-0.0070833475,
-0.0133150388,
0.0355780907,
0.06110131,
0.0107513927,
0.0262584612,
-0.0254205465,
0.0295381006,
0.03221054,
-0.0299966652,
-0.0133053446,
0.0502446592,
-0.0249831062,
-0.0151049234,
0.0039664423,
-0.0652170256,
-0.0085293157,
0.0722137168,
-0.0125963921,
-0.0463657975,
0.0533904284,
-0.0920940712,
0.0285890047,
-0.0419043377,
-0.0104705645,
0.0045730919,
0.009858896,
-0.0217771083,
0.0543765351,
0.0235090964,
-0.0024063226,
0.0000949863,
-0.0159813911,
0.0131809041,
0.0250910483,
-0.0336632319,
-0.0339755863,
-0.0359275565,
-0.0212682504,
0.0249573123,
-0.03132293,
-0.0131396465,
-0.0268206019,
-0.0590795875,
-0.0282239616,
-0.0108025456,
0.0392499752,
0.0209696256,
-0.0027331947,
0.0326723009,
0.0037649882,
0.0143265072,
0.0155232567,
-0.0019130131,
0.0481706336,
0.0472103953,
-0.0078630196,
-0.0259040836,
-0.0287287049,
-0.0353566445,
-0.0714154243,
0.0841898769,
0.0467746891,
-0.0015951518,
-0.0138320941,
0.0239444487,
0.0290681645,
0.0104532307,
-0.0053224792,
-0.0851866305,
0.02701905,
-0.0070685558,
0.034909822,
0.0729667246,
-0.017082585,
0.0498972014,
0.041709505,
-0.0233611427,
-0.0091694715,
-0.0161161609,
-0.0528314486,
0.009050482,
-0.0296084508,
-0.0301487185,
-0.0463878624,
0.1242627576,
0.0135537088,
-0.0170137845,
-0.0218716003,
0.0309034735,
-0.0128591647,
-0.0063133477,
-0.0106572593,
-0.0281382669,
-0.0308154784,
0.0478206575,
0.004617481,
-0.0437313393,
0.0706626698,
0.0133662196,
-0.0123880748,
-0.0287340134,
0.0084212171,
-0.0153156724,
0.0639462098,
0.0354376249,
0.0140085425,
0.0552922003,
-0.0371136852,
-0.0573411509,
0.007688255,
0.0300030001,
0.0130686294,
0.0601642318,
-0.0264485609,
-0.0048051411,
-0.0013908627,
-0.0539050922,
-0.0510689057,
0.0014389836,
0.0080391709,
0.0144658554,
0.0508014448,
-0.0477169342,
-0.0368194096,
-0.0039157611,
0.0159861315,
0.0731240064,
-0.0363626741,
-0.0174472649,
-0.0467310734,
0.0206765905,
0.0006736941,
-0.0213294737,
0.0775131211,
-0.0607601218,
0.0025542155,
0.0190237965,
0.011268924,
0.0309898742,
-0.0636452436,
0.0223354921,
-0.0239638649,
0.009167091,
0.0234922916,
-0.012507393,
-0.0134430546,
-0.0457896106,
-0.0503301136,
0.0768854022,
0.0283578765,
-0.0670845285,
0.0230957121,
0.0121473661,
-0.0124958446,
0.0557658449,
0.0469551161,
-0.096513316,
0.0010512857,
0.0198036227,
-0.0028927396,
-0.0201287027,
0.0110922027,
0.0266713426,
-0.0958751068,
0.0510296896,
-0.0143257482,
-0.0495537706,
-0.0242880471,
-0.0210656971,
-0.0098711215,
-0.0405481644,
-0.0027434917,
-0.0087151639,
-0.00266617,
0.0008521087,
0.0005625309,
-0.0177332982,
-0.0248061866,
-0.0025990352,
-0.0276961345,
0.0149833784,
0.0531028435,
-0.0087875156,
-0.0375917479,
0.0171107091,
0.0618240833,
-0.0042185332,
0.0328226909,
-0.0162111036,
0.073076576,
0.0557431467,
-0.0440753847,
-0.0235259663,
0.0357760154,
-0.0415149145,
-0.025945982,
-0.0544615164,
0.0657098517,
-0.035487406,
-0.0292865261,
0.0111434013,
0.0049309237,
-0.0158257876,
0.0286810417,
0.0518975891,
-0.0245660786,
-0.0642204657,
-0.0168855228,
0.016593596,
-0.044511348,
-0.0682391375,
-0.0238134377,
0.0708530769,
-0.0603816696,
-0.0284871534,
-0.0332997218,
0.0005183583,
-0.0020371058,
0.019843528,
-0.0608364381,
0.0410885438,
-0.0142774871,
-0.0660661235,
0.0649340004,
0.0202205889,
0.0156609807,
-0.0341828316,
-0.0114379376,
0.0400054194,
-0.0391651019,
-0.0580328219,
0.0130486218,
-0.1082371101,
-0.0528533868,
0.0251513496,
0.0545920394,
0.0186212566,
0.0172157008,
-0.0227187499,
-0.0294554941,
-0.0202674195,
0.0317683443,
-0.0463102572,
0.044642292,
0.055558458,
-0.0433552712,
-0.0215472709,
0.0206803232,
0.0301587041,
0.0396414697,
0.0426974297,
0.0014262047,
-0.0396862328,
0.029485302,
0.055719234,
-0.0066599566,
0.0894383416,
0.0404645056,
0.0252245944,
-0.0682746544,
0.0304732025,
-0.0048658131,
-0.0036472259,
-0.0617447235,
-0.0220057555,
0.0169129446,
0.0356427506,
-0.018041132,
-0.0545531064,
0.0120192096,
0.0304980613,
-0.0174312815,
0.0169850625,
0.0016051924,
-0.0097596133,
-0.0184964947,
0.0229963008,
0.0113553414,
0.0339706242,
0.0092312563,
0.0468465798,
-0.0077164061,
0.0373659097,
0.0217230767,
0.0278140195,
-0.0657531396,
-0.0078230379,
-0.0618171208,
-0.01866192,
-0.0016434133,
0.0108143371,
0.0342952944,
-0.015271306,
0.0249642488,
-0.047658667,
0.0052637565,
-0.006237112,
0.028180914,
-0.0064397282,
0.0136838825,
0.0114229694,
0.0217572339,
0.0233241487,
-0.0625493303,
0.0340327173,
-0.0028849526,
0.0518593937,
-0.035321746,
-0.0036010628,
-0.0127107129,
-0.0510645211,
0.0100613507,
-0.0245816894,
-0.0377930552,
0.0084506096,
-0.0681667551,
-0.0812965408,
-0.009461931,
-0.006827563,
0.0124184154,
-0.0380005166,
0.0406401344,
0.0394959673,
-0.0073834457,
-0.0457396321,
0.0173154324,
-0.0096544726,
-0.0100530079,
-0.0158504434,
-0.0080932397,
-6.905799355e-33,
-0.0383654796,
-0.0663858056,
0.0300319269,
0.0055879946,
0.0113560809,
0.0351142995,
-0.0722470358,
0.0133148804,
-0.0049785478,
0.0360212512,
-0.0130896391,
0.0405508988,
0.01577067,
0.0125378044,
0.0305924285,
-0.0411995575,
0.0418963209,
-0.0132916356,
-0.0096104639,
-0.0011171899,
0.0403407849,
0.0284196418,
0.0959318429,
-0.0725916848,
-0.0201633349,
0.0417905413,
-0.0389387719,
0.0236085523,
-0.1192837581,
0.0529405065,
-0.0061303629,
0.0199320707,
0.0110197049,
-0.0490005352,
0.0097493716,
0.0173659436,
-0.0649303272,
-0.045588728,
0.0116002485,
0.0334838443,
-0.0375643,
-0.0457557812,
0.0366814546,
-0.0204286128,
-0.0240972005,
-0.0287524257,
0.045876272,
0.0213474166,
0.0348512307,
-0.0067921574,
-0.0764290765,
-0.0173911247,
-0.0208830759,
-0.0213580281,
0.0225707721,
0.0294897798,
-0.0187039003,
-0.0250100717,
-0.0361891836,
0.0187205952,
0.0532660522,
0.0497008674,
0.028676806,
0.0275861453,
0.0119430879,
0.0236336347,
0.0601202324,
-0.0029784464,
-0.0105627375,
-0.0211002044,
0.0635599121,
0.0581086874,
0.0734266564,
-0.0142007014,
0.038161993,
0.0277329963,
-0.0409287848,
-0.040323209,
0.0409679748,
0.052383583,
0.0367588587,
-0.0488798209,
-0.0133410674,
-0.0160056297,
-0.0433500186,
-0.0239312276,
-0.0761258602,
-0.0080895247,
0.0208744332,
0.0041751978,
-0.0147966435,
0.0048963265,
0.0305778738,
-0.0680677593,
0.0393179432,
0.0334823839,
0.0060677794,
0.0392221548,
-0.0030545061,
-0.005472404,
-0.0175402369,
-0.0043494026,
-0.0228068531,
0.0214105193,
0.0377795137,
0.0242225584,
-0.0009081364,
0.027922513,
-0.0103029031,
-0.0151582872,
-0.0476920046,
-0.0107255494,
-0.001757964,
0.0476564914,
0.0219527725,
0.0286242869,
-0.0151004037,
0.009594487,
0.0255766921,
0.0392658226,
-0.0459354147,
0.0205324478,
-0.0069664386,
0.0456437096,
-0.0031469932,
-0.0496516339,
-0.0340966582,
0.0200931728,
0.0192512162,
-0.0486350581,
-0.0239124261,
0.023676578,
3.022e-7,
0.0645643324,
0.0426988304,
0.0352625102,
0.0673307478,
0.022285806,
0.0109170955,
0.0180183165,
-0.0203362443,
0.0169959776,
-0.001451864,
0.0354102366,
0.0005309573,
0.0598693937,
0.0215700231,
-0.0715329126,
0.015941821,
-0.0444382057,
-0.0078153983,
-0.0232044049,
0.0064406083,
0.0047977585,
0.0751868412,
0.0027862736,
-0.0037427614,
-0.0118132941,
-0.0017223902,
0.032274466,
-0.0096920244,
0.0199906845,
0.0021994326,
-0.051590912,
-0.0487784855,
0.0006053213,
0.0548812449,
-0.016973123,
0.0369074307,
-0.0228544604,
0.0200436208,
-0.0024856529,
-0.0296384208,
-0.0383445099,
-0.0098885577,
0.009291851,
-0.0388436653,
0.0326874033,
-0.0815394968,
-0.0192357283,
-0.000548568,
0.0403646678,
-0.0284745116,
0.0394949354,
-0.0017123749,
0.0230630767,
0.000205464,
-0.0077546369,
-0.0100302557,
0.0093673784,
-0.0406489596,
-0.0192295313,
0.0273546558,
-0.0455094911,
-0.033931002,
-0.0256594103,
-0.020728305,
0.0485104099,
-0.0036084608,
-0.0466483347,
3.273120857e-34,
0.0071707647,
-0.020136239,
0.0304218829,
0.0703007206,
0.0563971512,
-0.0256689377,
-0.0129236383,
0.0048564742,
0.0074594957,
-0.0912510753,
-0.0285391342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04348v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04348v1 | Evaluating the Effectiveness of Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Scientific Document Reasoning | 2023-11-07T21:09:57 | 2023-11-07T21:09:57 | Sai Munikoti, Anurag Acharya, Sridevi Wagle, Sameera Horawalavithana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Despite the dramatic progress in Large Language Model (LLM) development, LLMs
often provide seemingly plausible but not factual information, often referred
to as hallucinations. Retrieval-augmented LLMs provide a non-parametric
approach to solve these issues by retrieving relevant information from external
data sources and augment the training process. These models help to trace
evidence from an externally provided knowledge base allowing the model
predictions to be better interpreted and verified. In this work, we critically
evaluate these models in their ability to perform in scientific document
reasoning tasks. To this end, we tuned multiple such model variants with
science-focused instructions and evaluated them on a scientific document
reasoning benchmark for the usefulness of the retrieved document passages. Our
findings suggest that models justify predictions in science tasks with
fabricated evidence and leveraging scientific corpus as pretraining data does
not alleviate the risk of evidence fabrication. | [
0.0522431545,
0.0196947176,
0.0340011083,
0.0313967988,
-0.0473185405,
0.0067205164,
-0.0155902347,
0.0230760109,
-0.0008382443,
-0.0623550601,
-0.0429643579,
-0.0179876741,
-0.0143532734,
-0.0160661042,
0.0072629,
-0.0047349334,
0.0680943727,
-0.0589820743,
0.038585566,
-0.0033783899,
-0.0377918966,
-0.009167715,
0.0004197147,
-0.0070965509,
0.0266762078,
-0.0405786335,
0.0365928262,
-0.0079447646,
0.0179315563,
-0.0286143702,
-0.0091564953,
0.0449640974,
0.036615476,
0.0578249097,
0.0000016833,
-0.0681891814,
-0.016222842,
0.0399814919,
-0.0469864942,
0.0298097637,
0.0320259482,
-0.0142625449,
0.0071274992,
0.0015246419,
-0.0103717344,
-0.0217910837,
0.0224118624,
0.06904082,
0.0297999177,
0.0649695247,
0.0084139789,
-0.0680651143,
0.0451982878,
0.0100921066,
0.0631079748,
0.0338141136,
0.0733432546,
0.0586388446,
0.0667407215,
0.0671237558,
0.0153906364,
0.0510288924,
0.0076496019,
-0.0089532798,
0.012905715,
0.0422877669,
-0.0616370477,
-0.0126721654,
0.0356805809,
0.0425834954,
0.0404808894,
-0.0566494353,
-0.0024759981,
0.0150288856,
-0.0353581384,
0.0550529286,
-0.0773769543,
0.0525133722,
-0.0122664822,
-0.0123094488,
0.0624185875,
0.0014645749,
0.0568288676,
0.0551813692,
-0.0481829643,
0.1049159765,
0.0353505462,
-0.0652370602,
0.0187700484,
-0.0120227356,
-0.0052083437,
-0.0156391319,
0.0436102413,
0.0551672429,
-0.0129569313,
0.0355453156,
0.0209243484,
-0.0029140711,
0.0625827014,
-0.0348582864,
0.0042729857,
0.0163578875,
-0.0231337305,
0.0714194849,
-0.0478509814,
0.0227814429,
-0.0518841706,
0.0280378759,
-0.0013089301,
-0.012890649,
-0.0449929275,
-0.0553618968,
0.0029766271,
-0.0075784125,
-0.016186107,
-0.0200987719,
-0.0172789618,
-0.0383827761,
0.03536807,
-0.0067307302,
0.0043757022,
0.0012239611,
-0.0292600095,
-0.0329641812,
-0.0398396477,
0.0418277979,
0.0030436809,
0.02504736,
-0.0040860805,
-0.050563693,
-0.0296109486,
0.0277855862,
-0.0179006271,
-0.0331554972,
0.0315707438,
0.0066774623,
0.0360164344,
-0.018189257,
-0.0125797205,
-0.0526693575,
-0.0134913037,
-0.0914937034,
0.0422722436,
-0.0221779048,
0.0013205254,
-0.0077349674,
-0.0175204407,
-0.0047002812,
0.0025037532,
0.0215881821,
-0.0351950824,
0.0489146411,
-0.0246710535,
-0.0217076112,
0.0438779332,
0.0251758806,
0.0105765024,
0.0375234522,
0.0043150955,
-0.00838558,
0.0071137664,
-0.0175627787,
0.0004900346,
-0.021816371,
-0.0073681753,
-0.0143983765,
-0.0142287798,
0.0450190417,
0.0014191197,
0.0620694049,
-0.0121978763,
0.0281539522,
-0.0463362299,
-0.0080949254,
0.0276408587,
0.0483954735,
0.0105707534,
-0.0225501452,
0.020752795,
-0.0365942866,
0.0332781821,
-0.0004322083,
-0.0500232317,
0.0239942297,
-0.0340911895,
0.0370974131,
0.020391535,
0.0311149396,
-0.0246237088,
-0.0354918204,
-0.0387292802,
0.0181529559,
-0.0335882716,
0.0214277171,
0.0786377788,
-0.0120192375,
-0.0148593644,
0.029140804,
0.0372644588,
-0.02745842,
0.016930148,
-0.0132149067,
0.0417115018,
0.027666457,
0.0751207992,
-0.0427117608,
-0.0281168092,
0.0095310071,
0.0187789258,
0.0315445028,
0.0254797209,
0.002756207,
-0.0496569201,
-0.0496440642,
-0.0138431787,
-0.0256463885,
0.0196521226,
-0.0357115977,
0.0091111381,
0.0026353314,
0.0226255823,
-0.0444738232,
-0.0204411056,
0.0568107851,
-0.0468329638,
-0.0334303938,
-0.0632018149,
-0.0497161746,
0.0189560615,
-0.0213746578,
-0.0109698819,
0.049500484,
0.0672645569,
-0.0232020672,
-0.0134280641,
-0.0013958336,
-0.0244858097,
-0.0269866567,
0.0327338614,
0.0150949499,
-0.010370112,
-0.0194794852,
-0.0044617564,
-0.0183603596,
0.0146993827,
-0.009800355,
0.0187255386,
-0.0372232534,
-0.0015224167,
-0.0061368626,
0.0030529413,
-0.0443216003,
0.0645429194,
0.0087413611,
0.0579982921,
0.0198941194,
0.0196294934,
0.006104345,
-0.0428567417,
-0.0038413848,
0.0317250043,
0.0136977434,
-0.0362259783,
0.0136600118,
-0.0613984913,
-0.0623903982,
-0.0182195548,
-0.0294365138,
0.0041765571,
-0.014382951,
0.0136674372,
-0.0076814457,
-0.0341834314,
-0.0052112471,
0.0183257256,
0.0010676821,
-0.0239196569,
0.0160572454,
0.0180854332,
0.0069921804,
-0.016290158,
-0.0064589172,
-0.0315442979,
-0.0275478903,
-0.042358648,
0.0660449862,
0.0214097686,
0.0042031985,
-0.0875129104,
0.0200229324,
-0.0308713149,
-0.0014286418,
-0.0193529632,
0.0066938754,
0.0458623581,
-0.0522076413,
0.0140054505,
0.1107499748,
-0.0047380854,
-0.0101481313,
0.0625328273,
0.0029752026,
-0.0469302349,
0.0063025095,
-0.0097913956,
-0.0029850448,
-0.0112505322,
0.0219271705,
-0.0076559526,
0.0167320166,
-0.0419072397,
-0.0137679158,
-0.0087138787,
0.0304871555,
-0.0375558324,
-0.0353648886,
0.0267550498,
-0.0294276066,
-0.0021402356,
0.0319103636,
0.0015275187,
-0.0413304307,
0.0627217814,
-0.0494195968,
-0.0111398986,
-0.0717222989,
0.0234637801,
-0.0123852873,
0.013399452,
-0.0096548526,
-0.0016030803,
0.0178565234,
0.011496841,
0.0078171482,
0.002336151,
-0.0183422677,
-0.0295607951,
-0.0029640107,
-0.0474211648,
0.0426974073,
0.0354336053,
-0.0011189268,
-0.0161686875,
-0.0091468217,
-0.0284064412,
0.0385883711,
-0.0243256893,
-0.0313476771,
-0.0964123607,
-0.0067569907,
0.0662738457,
0.016323233,
-0.0325168036,
-0.0142261451,
-0.0197126511,
-0.0203712825,
0.0559089147,
0.0065943054,
0.0604130179,
-0.0327648632,
0.0078153154,
0.0548317879,
0.0198687762,
-0.0198146421,
-0.0281180404,
-0.0012444491,
0.0069914265,
-0.0319484062,
0.0139533496,
-0.0019250853,
0.0277387407,
-0.0812694058,
-0.0257464163,
0.1031543016,
0.0276860613,
-0.0228579715,
-0.0171356481,
-0.0558411852,
0.023980774,
0.0147243626,
0.0327778719,
-0.0513868779,
-0.0188257787,
-0.0052152551,
-0.0065212855,
0.0021570299,
-0.0351645462,
-0.0098220874,
-0.1050575376,
0.0626924783,
0.0236172583,
0.0139522059,
-0.0212268736,
-0.0999072939,
-0.0054020877,
0.0036508073,
-0.0124020223,
0.0381177925,
-0.0002864401,
-0.0210282989,
0.0082121855,
0.0161214117,
-0.0566892698,
0.0542673729,
-0.0211274251,
0.0183182471,
0.0406704023,
0.0102216396,
0.0047894921,
-0.0584676228,
0.0136905946,
-0.016426282,
0.0236971155,
-0.0052135685,
-0.0071701477,
0.0211637691,
0.0304509811,
-0.0297878087,
0.0512404554,
-0.0436479934,
-0.032632634,
-0.0217263866,
0.1135282293,
-0.0388191305,
-0.0391407236,
-0.0576163158,
0.0157025158,
-0.0183738582,
0.1082558259,
-0.0164990667,
0.033045046,
-0.0665485486,
-0.0011421111,
0.008686672,
0.0467295162,
-0.0255720727,
0.0243626013,
-0.0054229777,
0.0316576026,
-0.0346631892,
-0.0183669403,
0.0261950232,
0.0339165777,
-0.013475813,
0.0438712277,
0.0021733972,
-0.0249992423,
-0.0109821782,
0.0750502422,
-0.0463288128,
0.010958815,
-0.0403178111,
0.0346862748,
0.0894186869,
0.0069479202,
-0.0008521688,
0.0147448629,
-0.0042777532,
-0.0691964924,
-0.0217190497,
0.0020290734,
0.0297114924,
0.0388339236,
-0.0178577676,
-0.064558655,
0.0351469852,
-0.001730003,
-0.0341726318,
0.0022806779,
-0.0010739493,
-0.0271847192,
-0.0067963228,
-0.0183068253,
-0.0250989776,
0.0308017638,
0.0043059811,
0.0365893319,
-0.0221365932,
-0.0013307928,
0.0369282737,
0.0618858337,
0.0471751727,
-0.0051116925,
-0.0128750401,
0.0004608018,
0.0092599951,
-0.0519421361,
-0.013227039,
0.0046592299,
0.0349339172,
0.0280775465,
-0.0110952789,
-0.0024964735,
-0.0256264117,
-0.0230146553,
0.0399376601,
-0.023444986,
0.0198880285,
0.0025687804,
-0.005156219,
0.0481181182,
-0.0282602049,
-0.0407569073,
-0.0079207364,
-0.0423431844,
0.0690873414,
-0.0121215032,
0.0568176247,
0.0384475663,
0.0037660853,
-0.0425378568,
-0.0345476381,
-0.1072739661,
-0.0432874262,
-0.0088317972,
0.0069459751,
-0.001455932,
-0.0069347247,
0.0273823664,
-0.0647177175,
-0.0334687829,
-0.0345824994,
0.0151862726,
0.0430364609,
0.0001807599,
0.0651347637,
0.0348430239,
-0.0254154783,
-0.0102979671,
0.0440393686,
0.0171482097,
0.0651692078,
-0.0134489173,
-0.0217568912,
-0.018229818,
-0.0686832145,
-0.0657844692,
-0.007705735,
-0.0297755897,
-0.0136525556,
-0.0397454798,
-0.0350918286,
0.020147996,
0.0196518581,
-0.0146911694,
-0.0074520991,
-0.0147703299,
0.0778141171,
-0.0133881653,
-0.0545406938,
0.0155945793,
0.0359498113,
-0.0177956223,
-0.0266872402,
-0.0294068586,
-5.873554787e-33,
0.017980272,
-0.0077551003,
0.0398169979,
-0.0257102624,
-0.0023481809,
0.019471379,
-0.0410524793,
-0.0307216085,
-0.031647224,
0.0458327532,
0.0022628168,
0.0219966043,
0.0042058141,
-0.0219651591,
-0.0021115902,
0.0248937979,
0.019133402,
0.0038691091,
-0.0227720458,
0.0051660505,
0.0626434088,
0.013915861,
0.0461582504,
-0.0682850927,
0.0375953652,
-0.0002724456,
0.012670204,
0.0408743396,
-0.0978045464,
0.0440594964,
-0.0394994095,
-0.0062417425,
0.007868127,
-0.0698284283,
-0.013540633,
0.0184846874,
-0.0580221266,
-0.0005568587,
0.0280237943,
-0.0223490968,
-0.0455182903,
-0.0204733927,
0.0346427038,
0.020100588,
-0.0135403639,
-0.0385910273,
0.0139903538,
-0.0525854565,
-0.047249835,
-0.0289496481,
-0.0591300204,
0.0371747464,
0.00641109,
0.039647568,
0.0122344,
0.0183016732,
-0.0142760733,
0.0800011456,
-0.0196459703,
0.0273363497,
0.0150758354,
0.0155319609,
0.0402464271,
-0.0058796555,
0.0250812043,
0.0703112036,
0.0252909716,
-0.0035164224,
-0.0257721152,
-0.0282396339,
0.0296597295,
0.0505298078,
0.046994362,
0.0377173573,
0.0468375906,
0.054060746,
-0.0923332497,
-0.0071043689,
-0.0125802457,
0.0649595857,
0.0456126779,
0.0293523092,
-0.0101067051,
-0.0022305783,
-0.0394084677,
0.0466537923,
-0.0332833268,
0.0021553794,
0.0241785776,
-0.033191435,
-0.0266944729,
0.0184188243,
0.0448438302,
-0.0372898728,
-0.0076674926,
0.0581585281,
0.0033358508,
0.0120228808,
-0.0191932283,
0.0265711565,
-0.0652161688,
-0.0182459187,
0.0266706459,
-0.0194722675,
0.0012767115,
0.0075849947,
0.0080008553,
-0.0174736716,
-0.0174195003,
-0.0136966268,
-0.0292206388,
-0.0298069119,
0.0433205366,
-0.0074853799,
0.0543101542,
0.0375045575,
0.0282918233,
0.0484701544,
0.0157686584,
0.022543462,
-0.0031275859,
0.0129000526,
-0.0064419983,
0.0125139114,
-0.0072760317,
0.0004808664,
0.0018333255,
-0.0123183765,
-0.0006757966,
-0.0521507822,
0.0255072266,
0.051981587,
2.556e-7,
0.0533945486,
0.0764575526,
0.01374212,
-0.0347948298,
0.0152201559,
0.00310174,
-0.0396677442,
-0.0418607481,
0.0700380579,
-0.0512867458,
-0.0255704019,
0.0240571424,
0.0426428989,
0.0080737201,
-0.0717910975,
-0.0222315062,
-0.0497177392,
-0.0520532578,
-0.0694333315,
-0.0263856072,
0.0141336108,
0.0561911538,
-0.0123751089,
-0.0287867785,
0.0072319065,
-0.0696206018,
0.0737063736,
-0.0251133237,
0.0006349683,
0.059111923,
0.0399513319,
-0.0131577393,
0.0336456187,
0.03694221,
-0.0129304929,
-0.0046806796,
-0.0082075885,
0.0370408706,
-0.0161024593,
0.0023597614,
-0.0004965633,
-0.0167328957,
0.0198436435,
-0.0643416867,
0.0463747233,
-0.0582483374,
-0.0490819961,
-0.0042698155,
-0.0449464358,
-0.0250078216,
0.0234318208,
-0.0106705585,
0.0268251561,
0.0198134836,
-0.0271445978,
0.0210026912,
-0.0231633727,
-0.0916123763,
-0.0289540943,
0.0499474667,
-0.070771262,
-0.0456992202,
-0.0152289132,
-0.0144942189,
0.0049493071,
-0.0635769665,
-0.012514147,
2.481530104e-34,
0.0458772294,
0.0038231038,
-0.0024571223,
0.0243802071,
0.0493628308,
0.0015675257,
0.0316182449,
0.0315882638,
-0.0040051742,
-0.1473215669,
0.0108985342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04345v1 | A Taxonomy of Rater Disagreements: Surveying Challenges & Opportunities from the Perspective of Annotating Online Toxicity | 2023-11-07T21:00:51 | 2023-11-07T21:00:51 | Wenbo Zhang, Hangzhi Guo, Ian D Kivlichan, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Davis Yadav, Amulya Yadav | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Toxicity is an increasingly common and severe issue in online spaces.
Consequently, a rich line of machine learning research over the past decade has
focused on computationally detecting and mitigating online toxicity. These
efforts crucially rely on human-annotated datasets that identify toxic content
of various kinds in social media texts. However, such annotations historically
yield low inter-rater agreement, which was often dealt with by taking the
majority vote or other such approaches to arrive at a single ground truth
label. Recent research has pointed out the importance of accounting for the
subjective nature of this task when building and utilizing these datasets, and
this has triggered work on analyzing and better understanding rater
disagreements, and how they could be effectively incorporated into the machine
learning developmental pipeline. While these efforts are filling an important
gap, there is a lack of a broader framework about the root causes of rater
disagreement, and therefore, we situate this work within that broader
landscape. In this survey paper, we analyze a broad set of literature on the
reasons behind rater disagreements focusing on online toxicity, and propose a
detailed taxonomy for the same. Further, we summarize and discuss the potential
solutions targeting each reason for disagreement. We also discuss several open
issues, which could promote the future development of online toxicity research. | [
0.097026743,
0.0556540042,
-0.0206048954,
-0.0352798067,
-0.0159520153,
0.0438626334,
0.0179185532,
0.0088673001,
0.0143057304,
-0.0452306792,
-0.0296217948,
0.0092690764,
-0.0074840114,
0.0225719009,
-0.0068067373,
-0.0286256708,
-0.008107719,
0.0504177436,
0.0295954607,
0.0108919647,
0.0679075792,
0.0106820483,
0.0188797861,
0.0428111665,
-0.044662483,
-0.033518374,
0.0565764681,
-0.0063108089,
0.0310062487,
-0.0520763621,
0.0375130959,
0.0215751547,
-0.0109856753,
0.0706309825,
0.0000019024,
-0.0136108911,
0.0256047603,
0.0035370241,
-0.0030844251,
-0.0413700975,
0.0723314881,
0.0130561432,
0.0177894123,
0.0605089702,
-0.0391305983,
0.0111822374,
0.0925507024,
0.0284638181,
0.0559896491,
0.0332060643,
-0.0320273228,
0.0060844356,
-0.036081221,
0.0104843397,
-0.0030482369,
0.0169299524,
0.0379703678,
0.0121278428,
-0.0364246555,
-0.0205251761,
-0.012402528,
0.0239511691,
0.0214059018,
-0.0127099566,
0.0211064313,
-0.0128435325,
-0.0224281885,
-0.0811540559,
0.0278407782,
0.0696561635,
-0.0046513528,
-0.0142562389,
0.0102341268,
0.0105675058,
0.0013216275,
0.0092352014,
-0.0363588072,
0.0253066588,
-0.0242961776,
0.0136576137,
-0.021739101,
0.0390364081,
0.061091911,
0.0534132719,
0.0415081233,
0.0317132808,
-0.0266634766,
-0.0438573733,
0.0394307449,
0.0404535122,
-0.0073935436,
0.0163766798,
0.0447499752,
-0.0404219106,
-0.0108711906,
0.0271278322,
-0.0242489204,
-0.0212662742,
0.0358913057,
-0.1104059815,
0.0551740266,
-0.0211407766,
-0.0123449769,
0.0191576052,
0.0355215818,
-0.0358270146,
0.0294057224,
0.0478347577,
0.0077025853,
0.0393676236,
-0.0184972975,
0.0350594074,
0.0342618935,
-0.012715756,
0.0433636978,
0.0237586387,
-0.0415571555,
0.0109882895,
-0.0830050409,
-0.0136605576,
-0.008947175,
0.0156780016,
-0.0082512265,
0.0454307124,
-0.0367649011,
0.0227625836,
-0.0277398042,
0.0594500117,
-0.0042692269,
-0.0364483669,
0.0196060296,
0.0320891812,
-0.0083679855,
-0.0137169054,
0.0157299489,
0.0630448312,
0.0756384656,
0.0098427637,
0.0048031947,
-0.048373539,
-0.0444228947,
-0.0311504509,
-0.0119638639,
-0.0499143377,
0.0391169898,
-0.0116409194,
-0.0158270895,
-0.0391239971,
0.0046846997,
0.0344564505,
-0.0292329993,
0.0740469769,
-0.0313377753,
-0.0187399872,
0.0140829384,
0.0300416574,
-0.0306018516,
0.0337951221,
0.0086908769,
0.0641480014,
0.0305958223,
0.0145085594,
-0.008347637,
0.0004073385,
0.0172300581,
-0.0178594235,
-0.0033702797,
-0.0034175406,
-0.0490099415,
-0.0113265822,
-0.0173254777,
0.057445474,
-0.0242978148,
-0.0274630301,
0.0827761665,
0.016821187,
-0.0575904213,
0.0493836142,
0.01777214,
0.0139892483,
-0.0040170336,
-0.0257685371,
-0.04967333,
0.0050489544,
-0.0143531691,
-0.0464639999,
0.0377005152,
0.0263196155,
-0.0060622422,
-0.0736401603,
-0.0411753878,
0.0001409328,
0.05281993,
-0.0230485983,
0.0317728817,
0.016467046,
-0.0086989077,
-0.0387875289,
0.0525187999,
-0.0339188352,
0.0100218691,
-0.011648884,
0.0331749432,
0.0492238067,
0.0110094482,
-0.0035398831,
0.0113951173,
-0.0502370857,
0.0107503245,
0.0034589577,
0.0188295692,
-0.0154156387,
-0.0369520448,
0.005254874,
-0.0397250466,
-0.0187648814,
-0.0202683937,
-0.0308646224,
0.0034712593,
0.007429909,
-0.0420012288,
0.0090302639,
-0.0777799264,
0.0249241609,
0.0376419686,
-0.0010469152,
-0.0267190114,
0.0508614667,
0.0833370164,
-0.008663767,
-0.0086763753,
-0.0247503165,
0.0069617131,
0.0248811506,
-0.0473935641,
-0.0122634806,
0.0155215906,
0.0198946018,
0.0155930715,
-0.0742091611,
-0.0266864542,
0.0150122587,
-0.0182292406,
0.0506241322,
0.020461021,
-0.0646992251,
-0.0227858853,
-0.0050083036,
-0.038687475,
-0.0282385536,
0.0027168749,
-0.0349710397,
0.0519985594,
-0.0274879206,
0.0028241673,
-0.0228637643,
-0.0674576983,
-0.0050420291,
0.0375548899,
-0.0596432649,
-0.0405844413,
-0.0221788213,
0.0322530083,
0.0389837585,
-0.0197169464,
-0.0494266972,
0.0047468944,
-0.0498478264,
-0.0530398637,
-0.0229769349,
0.0166740976,
0.0267028101,
-0.0421684086,
0.0141623374,
0.0132167013,
-0.0155574903,
-0.0415566787,
-0.0071100835,
0.0631734878,
0.0105364881,
-0.0106862839,
0.0190717485,
-0.0353349149,
-0.0098110335,
-0.0125015937,
0.0393804684,
0.0432474427,
-0.0547440983,
0.0124164075,
0.0092390124,
-0.0654641613,
-0.0152384387,
-0.0019109948,
-0.0259541832,
0.047900822,
0.0498872958,
-0.0349494703,
0.0562751479,
0.0465818569,
0.0970953703,
0.0709142238,
0.0353009515,
-0.0444429293,
-0.0298113581,
-0.0470152609,
-0.0228961036,
-0.0045773257,
-0.0639788061,
0.012912062,
0.0583126657,
-0.0051309266,
0.0149292825,
-0.0474712998,
0.0657346994,
-0.0630932078,
-0.0503958799,
-0.0324460827,
-0.0585213639,
0.0066622999,
-0.0052069449,
-0.0402056724,
-0.0524742715,
0.0755056366,
0.03086235,
0.0443346612,
-0.0194022488,
-0.008790846,
0.0157577768,
-0.0095018549,
-0.0029770569,
0.024485793,
-0.0080400631,
0.0168013647,
0.0390691571,
-0.0022660058,
0.0801069066,
-0.0333819985,
-0.0003220532,
-0.0113412682,
-0.0054137986,
0.0384668671,
-0.0601166002,
-0.0192582794,
-0.0399649255,
-0.0254808068,
-0.0380033813,
0.0088422727,
0.0071151848,
-0.0191241708,
0.0198324993,
-0.016754223,
-0.0686406642,
0.01266996,
-0.0452918187,
0.0550830811,
-0.0152566442,
0.0499209352,
-0.0181674082,
0.0737758875,
-0.0031768049,
-0.0065124095,
0.0985481068,
-0.0301571973,
-0.0127143329,
-0.0010671959,
0.0094076544,
0.0083359657,
0.027675271,
0.0073842197,
0.0099290991,
0.0202151313,
-0.0068822554,
-0.0063258815,
0.0323683284,
0.0144882863,
-0.0335693471,
0.0074079009,
-0.0105247339,
0.0071070255,
0.0004832123,
-0.0240695234,
-0.061448101,
0.0035690735,
-0.0431066751,
0.0373419821,
-0.1039384976,
-0.0478806794,
0.0181754567,
-0.0671797842,
0.0219569895,
0.0187888741,
-0.040771246,
-0.018227797,
-0.0287651699,
-0.0008850361,
-0.047466699,
0.0592574291,
-0.0472388305,
0.0223787129,
-0.014314699,
0.0141252251,
-0.0544542409,
-0.0124812433,
0.0036452368,
-0.0491792932,
0.0640886575,
0.0089511499,
0.0407935753,
-0.0237847492,
-0.0167115517,
0.0200382322,
0.0206963904,
-0.0287359841,
-0.012529498,
0.0833332613,
-0.015712291,
-0.0116054611,
-0.0832933411,
0.0160414539,
-0.0030888035,
-0.0224070102,
-0.0532219373,
0.0575892106,
0.0086802719,
-0.016397262,
-0.0410119854,
0.0473925062,
0.0223820452,
0.0496639237,
0.0408594832,
-0.0668472871,
-0.0216452517,
-0.0560640283,
0.0012982448,
-0.0482551157,
-0.0652026087,
-0.0138231395,
-0.0076301256,
-0.0310586803,
-0.0292765237,
-0.0243554432,
0.0047409963,
-0.031646736,
0.012561189,
-0.0279611535,
0.0045016385,
-0.0034280305,
-0.0175246447,
0.055640351,
0.042230878,
-0.0063303588,
-0.0138155604,
-0.0094181653,
-0.0307468493,
0.0009773376,
-0.0087990602,
0.0456875563,
-0.0261600446,
-0.0299508218,
0.0665489808,
0.0670314878,
0.0084148757,
-0.007114525,
-0.0119491387,
-0.0487911552,
0.0423925072,
0.0529445596,
0.0221750438,
-0.049075041,
0.0435188226,
0.0214307737,
0.0221588798,
0.006860469,
-0.0317301899,
-0.0220223833,
0.052570574,
-0.0487836264,
-0.0799250826,
0.0395259634,
0.0296438858,
-0.0062860162,
0.0409215651,
-0.0057503935,
-0.0261536781,
-0.0024004909,
-0.0385619514,
-0.0015653676,
-0.021095017,
0.0041395454,
-0.0315858573,
0.0161020346,
-0.0019147283,
-0.0639963672,
0.0506173298,
-0.0326013975,
0.0373120792,
-0.0587508939,
0.0232003368,
0.0473583266,
-0.0024465707,
0.0254546907,
0.0156550817,
-0.0334853753,
0.0000246917,
0.0299923662,
0.0103049818,
-0.0009194122,
0.0094037773,
-0.0013861984,
0.0181324258,
0.0345381051,
0.0178122371,
0.0053215255,
-0.0257298723,
-0.0690820888,
-0.0410341807,
-0.025237808,
-0.0019574817,
0.032021556,
-0.0145901497,
-0.0282643307,
-0.0082310205,
-0.0041517694,
-0.0422780588,
-0.0418192521,
-0.0050055501,
0.0147346472,
-0.0293351263,
0.00380329,
0.0247585811,
-0.0253622979,
0.0178153776,
0.0003183925,
-0.0792960748,
0.0099775298,
-0.0043553393,
-0.0025758559,
0.0335531197,
-0.0095081152,
-0.0214016214,
-0.0618092902,
-0.0480870977,
0.0032405043,
-0.0308156908,
0.0315511301,
0.0091216648,
-0.0423568673,
0.0427241735,
0.0109106684,
0.0210961401,
-0.0132867275,
-0.023549309,
0.0170766171,
-0.0452653952,
-0.0270571616,
-5.786612286e-33,
0.0326498896,
-0.0525898449,
-0.0450459421,
0.0276316516,
-0.0029890621,
-0.0059661162,
0.0277798884,
0.0304638594,
0.0050095306,
0.0264446419,
0.0145149026,
0.0127283474,
-0.0025652538,
0.0000706504,
0.052453611,
-0.07156609,
0.0086136488,
-0.0220648479,
-0.0365846269,
0.0113405688,
0.0405202545,
-0.0264532529,
0.0219849627,
-0.1225253716,
0.053301163,
0.0142705003,
-0.0280743502,
-0.008753608,
-0.029241344,
0.0682180971,
-0.0005848793,
0.0989526138,
0.0322780795,
0.0004685875,
-0.0034386434,
0.0432027988,
-0.0346737169,
0.0002193341,
0.0189707447,
0.0039158645,
-0.0509188622,
-0.0144952442,
0.0812799037,
0.0134003982,
-0.0229958128,
-0.0306502897,
0.0365557857,
-0.0046862117,
0.0351227634,
-0.0575871617,
-0.0161751062,
-0.0031988746,
-0.02993715,
-0.0114720641,
0.0122293048,
0.0616399869,
0.0040160129,
0.0206958856,
-0.0950752199,
0.0469738469,
-0.0597080849,
-0.0328486413,
0.0186576303,
-0.0188513305,
0.0033708771,
0.0828227475,
0.0000087909,
0.0708233193,
-0.0372095481,
-0.0223535746,
-0.0116182053,
0.0389455743,
0.0447292887,
0.0434671193,
0.0287631564,
-0.0528394952,
-0.0548952483,
-0.0093500456,
0.033525072,
0.0173850916,
0.0339702293,
-0.0442601964,
-0.0568788312,
-0.0173128918,
-0.0068379808,
-0.0893881321,
-0.0536659434,
-0.0081921546,
-0.0079458803,
-0.0184160583,
-0.0264445581,
-0.0082640694,
-0.0055326968,
-0.0607205033,
-0.0146768754,
0.0057097715,
0.0219240021,
0.0233873948,
0.0279093161,
-0.0123995533,
-0.0440843962,
0.0331780426,
-0.0081632864,
-0.0543205217,
0.0373444408,
-0.0220838729,
0.1052016988,
0.0274282787,
-0.0262686163,
-0.0105633736,
-0.0114178294,
0.0432152487,
0.0233310089,
0.0120591875,
0.0075608934,
0.0456673913,
-0.0001780543,
-0.0129710296,
0.0453557782,
0.0757484809,
-0.0026764316,
-0.0181790497,
-0.043262735,
-0.0198508259,
0.0166590493,
-0.0333263315,
-0.0172049068,
0.0035544194,
0.0114331143,
-0.0754629076,
-0.0004388971,
-0.0248225573,
2.562e-7,
0.0703487098,
0.0522447713,
0.006709178,
-0.0322035477,
0.0359585583,
0.02171354,
0.0514766909,
0.037675187,
0.020932829,
-0.0514433309,
0.0224581733,
0.0034222291,
0.0348148383,
0.0547311716,
0.0134516861,
-0.0214665867,
-0.0743815005,
0.0180637278,
-0.0393568389,
0.0112902438,
0.0387216136,
0.0459593572,
0.0128372973,
-0.0357966684,
-0.0191922747,
0.0102742426,
0.0515015908,
-0.0483909063,
-0.0059180851,
-0.0002468021,
0.0644379482,
-0.0366168618,
0.0188200679,
0.0254863296,
-0.0062891417,
-0.0423988551,
0.0265296102,
0.0261724722,
0.0097386539,
-0.0650807992,
0.0002101415,
-0.0021084326,
0.051478833,
-0.0145910867,
0.0468867421,
-0.0482867807,
-0.0391391106,
-0.0482711792,
-0.0220394116,
-0.0209034234,
0.0952825174,
-0.0074775154,
-0.0243419055,
0.0134031288,
0.0246664882,
0.0246709641,
0.0099642444,
-0.0591217838,
0.0031842708,
-0.0012406593,
-0.0349972248,
-0.0670819283,
-0.0078952042,
-0.0078881318,
0.0122560831,
0.0007168574,
0.0268823355,
2.120160641e-34,
0.0085981535,
-0.0406928621,
0.0296679139,
-0.0455597192,
0.0245393682,
0.049433291,
0.0111522954,
-0.0072780289,
0.0132006546,
-0.0232577436,
0.0203762073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04335v1 | Sub-Sentence Encoder: Contrastive Learning of Propositional Semantic Representations | 2023-11-07T20:38:30 | 2023-11-07T20:38:30 | Sihao Chen, Hongming Zhang, Tong Chen, Ben Zhou, Wenhao Yu, Dian Yu, Baolin Peng, Hongwei Wang, Dan Roth, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce sub-sentence encoder, a contrastively-learned contextual
embedding model for fine-grained semantic representation of text. In contrast
to the standard practice with sentence embeddings, where the meaning of an
entire sequence of text is encoded into a fixed-length vector, the sub-sentence
encoder learns to produce distinct contextual embeddings corresponding to
different atomic propositions, i.e. atomic units of meaning expressed within a
text sequence. The sub-sentence embeddings are contrastively learned to
recognize (inferred) semantic equivalence between propositions across different
text sequences. Our experiments show the effectiveness of sub-sentence encoders
in applications, such as retrieving supporting facts for fine-grained text
attribution or recognizing the conditional semantic similarity between texts.
In practice, we demonstrate that sub-sentence encoders keep the same level of
inference cost and space complexity compared to sentence encoders. | [
0.026567094,
0.0199139621,
-0.0190458465,
0.0805225596,
-0.0668204725,
0.0429270901,
-0.0053553944,
-0.0113186184,
-0.0220036991,
-0.0331872888,
0.0147353215,
0.0368384756,
-0.0141409263,
-0.0028848371,
0.0207350925,
-0.0824015141,
0.0345280468,
0.0349983498,
0.0381259918,
0.0036170902,
0.0588257276,
0.0142379217,
0.0139677776,
0.0321097597,
0.0065774252,
-0.0124976439,
0.0108658066,
-0.0141398199,
0.0609960891,
-0.0176098701,
0.033480864,
-0.0023635128,
0.0605257154,
-0.0085433982,
0.0000017978,
-0.0124201505,
-0.0157315731,
-0.00796971,
-0.0150029976,
0.0078405794,
0.0404638872,
-0.0542494059,
0.0282145943,
-0.0038375542,
-0.0161741935,
-0.017501438,
0.0130791459,
0.0623902604,
0.0107375653,
0.0475284159,
-0.0377436616,
-0.0774355307,
0.0028257554,
-0.0183508694,
-0.0028943168,
-0.0203921963,
-0.0099613825,
0.0231385641,
-0.002950568,
0.0620441958,
-0.0307302382,
0.0063330783,
0.0374616422,
0.0369590111,
-0.0239576753,
0.0413391553,
0.0076300306,
0.025600642,
0.0021458964,
0.0557694063,
-0.0095474999,
-0.0425625667,
-0.0076434803,
-0.041327294,
0.0143876299,
-0.01816855,
-0.0223763175,
0.0213039629,
-0.0366102234,
0.0462695509,
0.0883896649,
0.0776809454,
-0.023882566,
-0.0060174549,
-0.0296820477,
-0.0062034884,
0.0111208539,
-0.038085334,
-0.0559906252,
0.0026892736,
-0.0210240297,
-0.0450628661,
0.0247334167,
0.0022593923,
-0.0030612042,
-0.0134166544,
-0.0616816878,
-0.0308254045,
0.0321360156,
-0.0271224901,
0.0317530371,
0.0264900029,
-0.0372940786,
0.0676126257,
-0.0672977939,
0.0526136011,
-0.0155687006,
0.0179873686,
-0.0516640507,
-0.0574921966,
-0.0524962842,
0.0220258441,
-0.0329241902,
0.0559675172,
-0.0395931862,
-0.0371298306,
-0.0061770482,
0.0155657148,
0.0038725752,
0.0511012897,
-0.0384641662,
0.0023754402,
-0.0193849541,
-0.003134266,
-0.0086758612,
0.0370015576,
-0.0918330029,
0.0344474874,
-0.0109099308,
-0.0233829189,
-0.033312574,
0.0011640305,
0.0520817153,
-0.0347507559,
0.0094603533,
0.0432516932,
0.0023592734,
-0.028657021,
-0.0537269078,
-0.0403754711,
-0.0150368074,
-0.0338407345,
-0.0610014014,
-0.0702731237,
0.0435588472,
0.026174698,
-0.0095451167,
-0.0091888709,
-0.0166567396,
0.0255950652,
-0.0250650197,
0.0733365789,
0.0004734606,
-0.0782604292,
-0.0380837396,
0.0078540733,
0.0264561288,
0.0365294069,
0.0349477045,
0.0663213879,
0.0100993076,
0.0030172446,
-0.071712032,
-0.0415937193,
0.0015855241,
-0.0149651458,
-0.0154796541,
0.0066384301,
0.0442355201,
0.0210781489,
0.0002952855,
0.077794075,
-0.0241769534,
-0.0334781446,
0.0268703736,
0.0399629399,
0.0274721868,
0.0327364132,
0.0403081514,
0.0478219911,
-0.0299122576,
0.0535940453,
-0.0282572247,
0.0658487454,
-0.0053516235,
0.0125895618,
0.0323626995,
0.0245982222,
-0.0333544277,
-0.0240934584,
-0.0039369618,
-0.0312361307,
0.0110092498,
-0.0172773618,
0.0320136249,
0.0256027747,
-0.0562138595,
0.0021408801,
0.0698048323,
-0.0398335867,
-0.0144837722,
-0.0119872587,
0.0455063507,
0.0746227875,
0.0001293009,
-0.0372915082,
0.0032218373,
-0.0190567952,
0.0334898084,
0.0270645823,
0.0354814492,
-0.0160220619,
-0.0045427037,
-0.0444995426,
-0.0280996412,
-0.068170011,
0.0028222366,
0.0156692453,
-0.0204274021,
0.0290441122,
0.0353094451,
-0.0167277753,
0.0154588073,
0.0400105864,
0.0231217593,
-0.0033435998,
0.0000078171,
0.0242903586,
-0.0044037197,
0.016037263,
-0.0135995736,
0.0029372897,
0.0391768664,
-0.0697746947,
-0.0157709159,
0.0019308145,
-0.0330222547,
-0.1304695755,
0.0103463735,
-0.0442509465,
-0.0097322464,
-0.0270505883,
-0.0958493352,
-0.0265294835,
-0.0194251295,
-0.053209573,
0.0611323528,
-0.0284107868,
-0.0459899753,
0.0138798486,
0.0090320958,
-0.0053718439,
0.0750228912,
-0.0111145349,
0.0144644538,
-0.0238744728,
0.0120485397,
0.0439578593,
-0.0110410303,
0.0076053967,
-0.0460219607,
-0.0033643176,
0.0071389233,
0.0251495298,
-0.0043777116,
-0.0159783065,
-0.0315097943,
-0.0516189076,
0.0128354393,
-0.0055937148,
0.0167940464,
0.0112468228,
-0.0045777289,
0.0518769994,
-0.0129982373,
-0.0320048332,
0.0264065638,
-0.023775924,
0.0141567588,
0.0576547459,
-0.0340356678,
0.0054682628,
-0.0478127412,
-0.0057465862,
-0.0151911546,
0.060762912,
0.0095502734,
0.0234996751,
-0.0413065925,
-0.0034814365,
-0.0105066802,
-0.0074518826,
-0.0082518952,
-0.0505224168,
0.0016746946,
-0.0108185289,
0.0069510271,
0.0933498219,
0.0317545645,
0.042863261,
0.0207585227,
0.0121511994,
-0.0500416122,
0.0011568356,
-0.0230929535,
0.0476271883,
-0.0310724583,
-0.0301494468,
-0.0235905368,
0.0330852568,
0.0296943579,
0.0283893291,
-0.0499383472,
0.0202288274,
0.0491190702,
-0.0001640609,
0.0152009781,
0.0219079424,
0.0051283045,
-0.0043099276,
-0.0478077717,
0.0198247414,
0.0856947452,
-0.0346606448,
0.0140696419,
-0.0168283693,
-0.0507097393,
-0.0217454601,
0.0661618635,
0.0171626341,
0.0356270373,
-0.0020807143,
0.0156877562,
-0.0238956995,
-0.0145090995,
0.0335127115,
-0.0116538825,
0.0285438802,
0.0254159104,
-0.0070253038,
-0.034473896,
-0.0519911237,
-0.0376813412,
-0.0541473851,
-0.0545911528,
0.051024694,
-0.013000899,
0.004506011,
-0.0363190547,
-0.0026389849,
0.0144668082,
0.029073419,
0.0117319794,
-0.0018643149,
-0.053457167,
0.0483120158,
0.0471098274,
0.0186775867,
-0.0024393189,
0.0116862142,
0.0189918727,
0.0750994682,
-0.020171877,
0.0166697912,
-0.0488463417,
0.0052959966,
-0.0271583907,
-0.0141213527,
0.0020641331,
0.0091296704,
0.040271692,
-0.0584463216,
-0.0048281853,
0.1019011065,
0.018808851,
-0.0153467664,
0.0011722549,
0.0017819079,
0.0245772246,
0.0119455792,
-0.0222655516,
-0.0893543735,
-0.0920497179,
0.0085364645,
-0.0338882543,
0.0197319854,
0.0005698924,
0.01006281,
-0.0792581961,
0.0110867461,
-0.0170951933,
-0.0238638408,
-0.0479598902,
-0.0238537882,
0.009193968,
0.0140749021,
-0.0065778103,
-0.0057259984,
-0.01821688,
-0.0104946038,
0.0076984549,
0.0085895909,
-0.0198283661,
0.0358603671,
-0.0579466596,
0.0070801484,
0.042109482,
0.0243463479,
0.0063844393,
-0.0441991612,
-0.0286658183,
-0.0869455934,
-0.0042068749,
-0.0029032202,
0.0591775961,
-0.0481190383,
0.016102992,
-0.01225367,
0.0272981264,
-0.0282802545,
-0.0338924006,
0.026216099,
0.0377476066,
-0.0000110273,
-0.0148649933,
-0.030475745,
0.0179832783,
0.0020243996,
0.09331429,
0.0681539774,
-0.0067183734,
-0.0397930183,
-0.0168799926,
-0.0012756375,
-0.0351333581,
0.0460551195,
-0.0230030213,
0.0066968668,
0.0301562883,
-0.0695748106,
-0.017546637,
-0.0074027032,
-0.0060809436,
-0.0235726163,
0.0011671042,
0.0283377897,
-0.0546447225,
-0.0941040814,
-0.0310045239,
-0.0242382977,
0.0400803201,
0.0139851486,
-0.0043967203,
0.0589158013,
-0.0159352198,
-0.062096674,
-0.0122281052,
-0.0876779482,
-0.0306205302,
-0.0349647515,
0.0431859717,
-0.0049357731,
0.0529674515,
-0.0041083507,
-0.0018884168,
0.0691498742,
0.0326255932,
-0.0282339621,
0.0026247725,
0.0427501053,
-0.0140043329,
0.0106600048,
0.0316490829,
-0.0287893545,
0.0218214467,
0.033076793,
0.0141804339,
0.0041625425,
-0.0295605306,
0.0172786471,
-0.0223811399,
0.0197487269,
0.0316018537,
0.0051904707,
-0.0058264919,
0.0233533382,
0.0010333448,
-0.0130657423,
-0.028104458,
-0.009996024,
-0.0063407519,
0.0197891556,
0.0030041542,
0.0367586017,
0.0169873796,
0.0265931766,
0.0007836632,
0.0433128476,
0.0521008894,
0.0317381546,
-0.0049625267,
-0.0172348712,
-0.0523911193,
-0.0039991261,
-0.0169867724,
0.0316374376,
-0.0554014221,
0.0254918467,
0.05302139,
0.0095553184,
-0.0505002141,
0.0538641624,
-0.0721648261,
0.0151020586,
-0.0122206798,
0.0262393598,
0.0292686522,
-0.0216044169,
-0.0194456149,
-0.0154538834,
-0.0109317135,
0.001838702,
0.0644637719,
-0.0411785841,
-0.0248810239,
0.0528452769,
0.0091874981,
-0.0228396654,
0.016644517,
0.046128571,
-0.0483101904,
0.051216621,
0.0004119653,
-0.0074101281,
-0.0422817506,
-0.0232249945,
-0.0115143666,
0.0486786216,
0.0127752041,
0.0113977781,
-0.0135581782,
-0.0478158183,
0.0265729278,
0.0386991724,
0.0249467473,
0.0159160886,
0.0186396632,
0.025352912,
0.0377446376,
-0.0508938022,
-0.003563286,
0.0293739624,
-0.0020193367,
-0.0583072975,
-0.0323263146,
-6.411671488e-33,
-0.0269409902,
-0.0084016751,
-0.0388693288,
0.0178834777,
-0.007432099,
0.0000966393,
-0.0550567284,
-0.0679251254,
-0.0289773885,
0.0381140001,
0.0117105711,
0.0065438095,
0.0082324697,
0.0175212212,
-0.0027954471,
-0.0252370965,
0.0627238899,
0.0220541768,
-0.0015042981,
0.02509325,
0.0353039093,
-0.0066436245,
0.0283751041,
-0.02269518,
-0.0130233597,
-0.008783889,
0.0289266724,
0.0107057234,
-0.0211609956,
0.0622825883,
-0.0098037384,
0.0307064205,
0.0346824676,
-0.0017305874,
0.0068717329,
0.036853075,
-0.1113650501,
-0.0480914675,
0.0068978048,
-0.0515183695,
-0.0399580188,
-0.0265151002,
0.021260215,
-0.0220318269,
0.0292288996,
-0.0342244618,
0.0578755885,
-0.0316548273,
-0.0029830872,
-0.0070514516,
-0.0705722645,
0.0040577734,
-0.0139740203,
-0.0017253533,
0.0217819083,
0.0140501084,
0.0668972805,
0.0457531326,
-0.0266524721,
-0.0179925766,
-0.0137268621,
0.0318114311,
-0.0084336465,
-0.0123949591,
-0.0175342578,
0.0534851439,
-0.0010878528,
-0.0326294452,
-0.0181144793,
0.0223224442,
-0.0181978773,
0.0294998437,
0.054994572,
0.0946865082,
0.0449347794,
-0.0050403252,
-0.0797336102,
0.0095612518,
0.0207972247,
0.0437367819,
0.0234023482,
0.034886945,
-0.028647827,
-0.0134690115,
-0.0308061894,
-0.0476641729,
-0.0417214707,
-0.0144785699,
0.0125927255,
0.0076742666,
0.0010974284,
0.0075701163,
0.0360551402,
-0.0449366048,
0.0095337695,
0.0309662018,
-0.0225087218,
-0.0164255258,
0.0042961962,
0.0294005126,
-0.0515660644,
-0.042556338,
0.0458402447,
-0.0047614751,
0.0184964798,
0.0203528907,
0.1152806878,
-0.0340675972,
-0.0387326702,
0.0310038216,
-0.0166296698,
-0.0369118825,
-0.0599420816,
-0.0216996949,
0.0235671382,
0.0545811951,
-0.0053535015,
0.0328458324,
0.0014354025,
0.0007678166,
-0.0338440128,
-0.0190430209,
-0.0024741106,
0.0546602756,
-0.0218505878,
0.0148194712,
-0.0670967326,
0.0112620778,
-0.017332565,
-0.0139495255,
0.0140045211,
0.0286646914,
2.548e-7,
0.0062990543,
0.0077821831,
0.0603174567,
-0.0199394878,
0.0077496069,
0.0695755407,
0.0194466673,
0.0656520575,
-0.0014202261,
-0.0273657292,
0.0262503065,
0.0404041894,
0.0480739288,
-0.0095308358,
-0.0563819185,
0.0896649584,
-0.0795244575,
-0.04387125,
-0.0324838385,
0.0187197626,
0.1441012621,
0.0816750377,
0.0618062578,
-0.0085587064,
0.0379753932,
-0.0242813174,
0.0472365357,
-0.0115970466,
-0.0030676215,
-0.0320832208,
-0.0496687852,
0.028447032,
-0.0111152539,
0.0162160862,
0.0060897251,
0.0259643123,
-0.025029609,
0.0249704253,
0.0017312667,
-0.0019206894,
-0.041284211,
-0.0104502244,
0.0162202381,
-0.0355225094,
0.0830556229,
-0.0909829661,
-0.0046285237,
-0.047178667,
-0.0226220321,
0.0126655605,
-0.0000128572,
0.0244905092,
-0.0554329939,
-0.0152920363,
0.0357133895,
0.0128014898,
-0.0448245443,
-0.0903530195,
0.0166028533,
0.0568205938,
-0.0320447944,
-0.0028684891,
-0.0276123714,
0.0140801976,
0.0502712876,
-0.0562060252,
-0.0100950878,
2.040461895e-34,
0.0112726763,
-0.0026100192,
0.0077698482,
-0.0135414917,
0.0383798815,
0.0057204226,
-0.0696319118,
-0.0183701403,
0.0185512099,
-0.0737716407,
-0.0251617897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04329v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04329v2 | Formal Aspects of Language Modeling | 2023-11-07T20:21:42 | 2024-04-17T07:31:01 | Ryan Cotterell, Anej Svete, Clara Meister, Tianyu Liu, Li Du | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have become one of the most commonly deployed NLP
inventions. In the past half-decade, their integration into core natural
language processing tools has dramatically increased the performance of such
tools, and they have entered the public discourse surrounding artificial
intelligence. Consequently, it is important for both developers and researchers
alike to understand the mathematical foundations of large language models, as
well as how to implement them. These notes are the accompaniment to the
theoretical portion of the ETH Z\"urich course on large language models,
covering what constitutes a language model from a formal, theoretical
perspective. | [
0.0328133926,
0.0566911139,
-0.0373644195,
0.0428446196,
-0.0497872457,
-0.0041039167,
-0.0125987558,
0.0223510601,
-0.0300036184,
-0.0660936683,
0.018158054,
-0.0745400712,
0.0036338407,
0.0335227288,
0.0246451087,
-0.0614668392,
0.022562921,
-0.0596358217,
0.0030755622,
-0.0065307035,
0.0129567059,
-0.0361899175,
0.0155576151,
0.040107362,
0.0133935427,
-0.0195481479,
0.0167739205,
-0.0391690545,
-0.0683993697,
-0.0108388709,
-0.0271956213,
0.020822404,
-0.0151479412,
0.0255638752,
0.0000015523,
-0.0431304723,
-0.007579763,
0.0020975757,
-0.0009916369,
0.029308524,
0.0291880053,
-0.0147365173,
-0.0345573798,
0.0040793153,
-0.0129274642,
-0.0283772498,
0.05836045,
0.0292498562,
0.0222305357,
0.0542129911,
-0.0303911883,
-0.0744083822,
0.0325041041,
-0.012134756,
-0.0594177954,
-0.0312826708,
0.0632371902,
0.0416973829,
0.0311239976,
0.0137541471,
-0.0106945289,
0.0213203616,
-0.0048663542,
-0.032598529,
0.0270217489,
-0.0048458134,
0.0307963043,
-0.0473202839,
-0.0002848859,
0.0132536376,
0.0292652715,
-0.0189389866,
0.0212868545,
0.0293063745,
-0.0384128951,
0.0276483353,
-0.0466439426,
0.0317969434,
0.0029054384,
0.0375738591,
0.0405178778,
0.0098289419,
0.0444580689,
0.006053518,
-0.0356053226,
0.0996587574,
0.0505074114,
-0.0085006682,
-0.065068312,
-0.0284538399,
-0.0219905265,
-0.0587167367,
0.031983126,
0.0669287145,
-0.0063364599,
0.0048570205,
-0.0119609078,
-0.0147891808,
0.0289873853,
-0.0870943964,
0.0413841903,
-0.0307316016,
0.0342841186,
0.0514049605,
0.0310807284,
0.0342714265,
-0.0274560768,
-0.0250845812,
-0.032909371,
0.0044559357,
-0.0433880202,
-0.0289331283,
-0.0971290171,
0.0249692462,
-0.0204953142,
-0.0202065203,
-0.0183723886,
0.024107011,
0.0086228186,
0.0237767939,
-0.0102723716,
-0.0393360034,
-0.0401913114,
0.0101584606,
0.0083118593,
-0.002720586,
0.0081192302,
-0.0093227671,
-0.0466464832,
-0.0421372205,
0.0344753861,
0.0358544961,
0.0004226162,
-0.0255090073,
-0.0401266553,
0.0590945929,
0.0468890481,
0.0289738998,
0.0025818332,
0.0195056573,
-0.0285647977,
-0.0445513763,
-0.0581608787,
-0.0692932755,
-0.0246759336,
0.0036938465,
0.0247129314,
-0.042297259,
-0.0234264508,
-0.0271659344,
-0.0209000316,
0.0260716379,
-0.0472608767,
0.0387938544,
0.0224627182,
-0.0026690478,
0.05457877,
0.0319131166,
0.0395301692,
-0.0344915278,
0.0752087831,
-0.05895257,
0.0166315176,
0.0825335011,
-0.0303312819,
0.0103586586,
-0.0835399181,
0.0070517925,
0.0461505651,
-0.0070256237,
-0.0180082843,
0.1059149355,
-0.0189069137,
-0.0226144698,
0.0236935765,
0.0634218454,
0.0317147002,
0.0475827157,
0.0441936888,
-0.0046956399,
0.0260309372,
0.0272814594,
0.0194068365,
-0.0417750254,
-0.0365821347,
-0.0088223713,
-0.0121966042,
0.0355913043,
-0.0310938638,
-0.0180482939,
-0.0405924097,
-0.0109006269,
0.0099932281,
-0.048185423,
0.105139181,
-0.0013278223,
0.0169488806,
0.0244235769,
-0.0083237672,
-0.0160356294,
0.0400358252,
-0.0521975942,
0.0254384428,
0.0225392953,
0.0246508252,
-0.0276136678,
0.0189464036,
-0.0003402497,
-0.0401083678,
0.0664860681,
0.0379783623,
-0.0458463281,
-0.0260961484,
-0.0006349056,
0.0446393713,
0.0320967734,
0.0462194197,
-0.0263282433,
-0.0201307312,
-0.0102012707,
0.003524445,
-0.0036596188,
-0.0723996535,
0.0085986303,
-0.0170320272,
-0.0240682568,
-0.0280906893,
-0.0017818954,
0.0577041544,
0.0314655155,
-0.0232322812,
0.044458624,
0.0369809046,
-0.0307973921,
0.0026401691,
0.0026035721,
0.0282304827,
0.052408725,
0.072743468,
0.0055055991,
0.0382059589,
0.0199228395,
0.0145409461,
-0.0361192077,
0.0365953222,
-0.0470348597,
0.062863946,
-0.0274185166,
0.0668416619,
-0.0434933268,
-0.001463846,
-0.0360055305,
0.0404244959,
0.0059238211,
0.0550502017,
-0.0131845828,
-0.0176430214,
0.0267970469,
-0.0370829962,
-0.0538162775,
0.0551612154,
0.0134207793,
0.0337477177,
0.0508777723,
-0.0488101766,
0.0240637269,
-0.0456576757,
-0.0283131134,
-0.0040542884,
-0.0090179443,
0.0276913885,
0.0038159022,
0.0196991898,
0.0074613187,
0.0224383678,
-0.0009779372,
-0.0091307322,
0.0367495939,
0.0323288143,
0.0383664556,
0.0186762549,
-0.0914481506,
-0.0179718807,
-0.0384005755,
-0.0162787717,
0.0495583266,
0.009722623,
-0.0379428267,
-0.0817418993,
0.0182671435,
-0.0410776921,
0.0670439377,
-0.0249072462,
-0.0271906182,
-0.0157554913,
-0.0240658037,
0.0550670549,
0.0322951004,
0.0061087869,
0.0689275488,
0.0222279523,
-0.0054750494,
0.0128185917,
-0.033376202,
-0.0230373517,
-0.0101781022,
-0.0702823997,
-0.0275255181,
0.0113070048,
0.1040801257,
-0.0307733584,
-0.0518268906,
-0.0170802642,
0.0120291375,
-0.0726672709,
0.0128731122,
0.0050755357,
-0.0449958183,
-0.027634969,
0.0499474183,
-0.0431964174,
-0.0648911893,
0.0085685337,
-0.0722580552,
0.0124947233,
-0.0312578343,
-0.050313957,
-0.0578407794,
0.057938233,
0.0168834161,
0.0228114389,
0.0085899578,
-0.0120915398,
0.0312065035,
-0.0187797211,
0.0245856661,
-0.0230260976,
0.050325945,
-0.022621911,
0.0701320022,
0.0003520251,
-0.0253278241,
0.003160225,
-0.0494111627,
-0.0475249216,
0.0228817314,
0.0205426682,
-0.0388208367,
-0.0086975917,
0.0843699202,
0.0048991856,
-0.001868041,
0.0323666036,
0.0170565527,
-0.0238829684,
0.0613286793,
0.058560878,
-0.0057126014,
0.0065703159,
-0.0192637499,
0.0145299444,
0.0275787152,
0.026643293,
0.0628010035,
-0.037554197,
-0.0131091969,
0.055506926,
-0.0445503779,
-0.0456603207,
0.0171611067,
-0.0073696664,
-0.0062560271,
0.0010285103,
0.1058824211,
0.0268788766,
-0.0043798732,
0.0584681816,
0.001469875,
0.0237836428,
0.0233445372,
-0.0052971281,
-0.0543609336,
0.0417769216,
-0.000207485,
-0.0689877421,
-0.0148452204,
-0.009625541,
-0.0127279144,
-0.0986147299,
-0.0160836391,
0.0246803313,
-0.0193559732,
-0.0179351885,
-0.0337818675,
-0.0011632068,
-0.0140434159,
0.0006028378,
0.015764378,
-0.017268518,
-0.0089588528,
0.04331135,
0.003506433,
-0.0478741601,
-0.0001349381,
-0.0504800975,
0.0686638281,
0.0389723293,
0.0412267372,
-0.0545828566,
-0.0114024067,
0.0215641856,
-0.0038958553,
-0.0261627026,
-0.0005195987,
-0.0306158103,
0.0182298496,
-0.0127205402,
-0.0517689213,
0.0173053388,
-0.0030233511,
-0.0125977769,
0.0063325157,
0.0714614689,
0.001319678,
-0.0455223955,
0.0102440109,
-0.001990058,
-0.0004662171,
0.0451804921,
0.0149967959,
-0.0347274318,
-0.0139872078,
-0.0203165505,
-0.006241255,
0.0248371158,
-0.061946284,
0.0078574652,
0.027765628,
-0.0424083062,
-0.0429733396,
0.0354948528,
0.0024048421,
0.0489059612,
0.0295022577,
0.0427749082,
0.0470550619,
-0.0386016555,
0.0092384983,
0.0125326607,
-0.0550269708,
0.0158490799,
-0.0520557649,
-0.0047595045,
0.0630872548,
0.0039074225,
-0.0306907278,
-0.0107360892,
-0.0712647736,
-0.0843906328,
0.0033729721,
0.0287532713,
0.0413596518,
-0.0194573477,
-0.0437105633,
-0.0763557553,
-0.0235438757,
-0.0005623218,
-0.0495578833,
0.0343278013,
0.0263491254,
-0.0109201819,
0.0200935118,
0.0672578514,
-0.0162865818,
0.0295001306,
-0.0391412228,
0.0281187817,
-0.0194659755,
-0.0463002846,
0.0298143011,
0.0540278628,
0.0011731224,
0.0281369407,
-0.0232498832,
0.0001798355,
-0.0266339127,
-0.0491057858,
-0.026229471,
-0.0497541688,
0.0300343297,
0.0145966671,
0.0167805497,
-0.0598144606,
-0.0450817086,
-0.0098798359,
0.0212583449,
-0.0142801786,
0.0309326239,
-0.0044558784,
-0.0226817112,
0.0679480955,
0.001067115,
0.0033545732,
0.0358423702,
-0.0378551297,
0.0101476703,
0.0054038097,
0.0004857653,
0.0179915726,
0.0072326716,
-0.0345131159,
-0.011843672,
-0.0311000086,
-0.0645986944,
0.0110130636,
0.0552198961,
0.0395693965,
-0.0263881013,
0.025384048,
-0.0437445529,
-0.0126231136,
-0.0357137918,
0.0080869514,
0.0434561223,
-0.0423881151,
0.0061442554,
0.0234310217,
-0.0247968975,
0.0373435393,
0.093454726,
0.0288675353,
0.0130873471,
0.0112703852,
-0.0283096842,
-0.033364132,
-0.0185335819,
0.0031209108,
0.013437449,
-0.0310818274,
0.0322339758,
-0.0867602974,
-0.0797283724,
0.0150276478,
0.0259324703,
0.0404779464,
-0.0220637005,
-0.0421105437,
0.0714293867,
0.0165800489,
0.0181196705,
-0.0504935309,
0.0090482645,
-0.0162461121,
-0.0120802689,
0.0170424785,
-5.64474224e-33,
-0.021869339,
-0.04550438,
0.0081871785,
0.0015253186,
-0.0066770376,
-0.0079744384,
-0.0062830886,
0.01428378,
-0.0058435746,
-0.0132249957,
-0.0084587643,
0.0322117992,
0.0051002991,
0.0260460321,
-0.0259771347,
0.0313580371,
0.0318428501,
-0.0099702897,
0.0218013432,
-0.0091951294,
-0.0051452671,
-0.0307197664,
0.011511622,
-0.0369378924,
0.0532798804,
-0.0486883596,
-0.0147073539,
0.0597565249,
-0.0044812299,
0.0689263269,
-0.0504442193,
0.0176535752,
0.0327197872,
-0.0333347693,
0.0053777206,
0.0110031413,
-0.0495269112,
0.0013515658,
0.0484565087,
-0.0075012906,
0.0113530708,
-0.0262509231,
0.0336206295,
-0.0262297336,
-0.0404213332,
0.0364928842,
0.026427336,
-0.0219366569,
-0.0385645479,
0.0126225865,
-0.0437507108,
0.0403176323,
0.0085598091,
0.0469455607,
0.0416612141,
-0.026617242,
-0.0296604019,
0.0101859663,
0.0026035209,
0.0172537193,
0.0443378314,
0.0543841757,
-0.0010599925,
0.025312582,
0.0251413547,
0.0362218805,
0.0421055257,
0.0082558887,
-0.0184362158,
-0.0019836165,
-0.0001698099,
0.0281401239,
0.0166345444,
0.0114005636,
0.0185346678,
-0.0053067985,
-0.0736084953,
-0.0234886259,
0.0145218382,
0.0032038991,
0.0404396579,
0.0178607125,
-0.0368992202,
-0.0418251976,
-0.0451735705,
-0.0517925136,
-0.0163646229,
0.0172582939,
-0.0149771078,
-0.0046750023,
-0.0242861472,
0.0216988754,
0.0114197833,
-0.0776743665,
-0.0748355165,
-0.00740973,
0.0227499083,
0.0324116647,
-0.0109648891,
0.0395064689,
-0.0195623469,
-0.0474701412,
-0.0731748492,
-0.0087951766,
-0.0023324736,
0.0066395076,
-0.0175928306,
0.0170699731,
-0.0255744774,
-0.0241071936,
-0.0005796941,
-0.0350079499,
0.0189969931,
0.0431252718,
0.0375876687,
0.0227826945,
0.0149063589,
0.0360010192,
0.0304838289,
0.0023594417,
0.0381710641,
0.0265462548,
0.0156140905,
0.0134931961,
-0.008497199,
-0.0179760996,
-0.023653714,
0.0097481683,
0.0793363824,
-0.0237953626,
-0.0101936124,
-0.0302475225,
2.362e-7,
0.045292154,
0.0240572579,
0.0637455955,
0.0141158244,
0.0442634784,
-0.004711655,
-0.0377749912,
0.0163426381,
-0.0178677402,
-0.0031210198,
0.0050628427,
0.0353753902,
0.0034771743,
-0.0060081794,
-0.0597674958,
0.0054222667,
-0.0596615188,
-0.0121601168,
-0.0495801792,
0.0166377574,
-0.0032620588,
0.0790036768,
0.0164806936,
0.0275096782,
-0.0406461544,
-0.0638854876,
0.0553399026,
-0.0272625089,
0.0117434813,
0.058280509,
0.034350954,
-0.0094684586,
0.0105302157,
0.0233659241,
0.0359056443,
0.0407462269,
0.0427722149,
0.0794088617,
-0.0333553925,
0.0807051659,
-0.0044874232,
-0.0742416084,
-0.0280827284,
-0.0343032256,
0.0444732085,
-0.0257573333,
-0.0715950057,
-0.0282809362,
-0.0200995076,
0.0045989715,
-0.0421730876,
-0.0121814767,
-0.0294529051,
0.0102549568,
0.0089341188,
-0.0097912848,
0.0104544824,
-0.0299606938,
-0.032221932,
0.0071873893,
-0.0526433326,
-0.0499722734,
0.0107106436,
0.0002550124,
0.0318907015,
-0.0492956936,
0.0331920572,
2.394464314e-34,
0.0603878833,
0.018582698,
0.0076773041,
0.0273426753,
0.0237594415,
-0.0217582621,
-0.0234164856,
0.0307211503,
0.028391894,
-0.1144730225,
-0.0191905797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04936v1 | A comparative analysis between Conformer-Transducer, Whisper, and wav2vec2 for improving the child speech recognition | 2023-11-07T19:32:48 | 2023-11-07T19:32:48 | Andrei Barcovschi, Rishabh Jain, Peter Corcoran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems have progressed significantly in
their performance on adult speech data; however, transcribing child speech
remains challenging due to the acoustic differences in the characteristics of
child and adult voices. This work aims to explore the potential of adapting
state-of-the-art Conformer-transducer models to child speech to improve child
speech recognition performance. Furthermore, the results are compared with
those of self-supervised wav2vec2 models and semi-supervised multi-domain
Whisper models that were previously finetuned on the same data. We demonstrate
that finetuning Conformer-transducer models on child speech yields significant
improvements in ASR performance on child speech, compared to the non-finetuned
models. We also show Whisper and wav2vec2 adaptation on different child speech
datasets. Our detailed comparative analysis shows that wav2vec2 provides the
most consistent performance improvements among the three methods studied. | [
-0.0121505503,
0.0075709927,
0.0093384134,
0.0333847851,
-0.0258166548,
-0.0114357546,
0.0479712747,
0.0013933353,
-0.0497383326,
-0.0087380735,
-0.0197398793,
-0.0616675392,
0.0593286268,
-0.0057494207,
-0.0262666214,
-0.0654714629,
-0.0001561075,
-0.0828557462,
0.0064058807,
-0.0123147089,
-0.0064596916,
-0.0037554668,
-0.0323317163,
0.0477248505,
-0.0241381079,
-0.0009983379,
0.0309893824,
0.022839807,
0.0138513558,
0.0098741297,
0.0230722371,
0.0023498463,
0.0149603719,
0.0384662561,
0.0000017836,
-0.0128353508,
-0.0299814306,
0.0352557153,
-0.0240226965,
0.0234678946,
0.0159597434,
-0.0053610262,
-0.0056226877,
0.028713664,
-0.0176113974,
-0.0137764625,
0.0532258116,
0.0311170314,
-0.0028972554,
0.0193384551,
-0.0072178124,
-0.0327373147,
0.027082216,
0.0313708037,
-0.0323957503,
-0.0787506923,
-0.0267149415,
0.0202155262,
0.0055012256,
-0.0587700456,
-0.0115498938,
0.0327894092,
-0.0373433158,
-0.0427849367,
0.0315891728,
-0.0358653441,
-0.0223164354,
-0.0526803434,
-0.0256060343,
0.0354195125,
0.0057055908,
-0.0340272747,
0.0157477036,
0.0157014932,
-0.0568093732,
0.0188199617,
-0.0402632281,
-0.0226376578,
0.0075515117,
-0.0081052128,
-0.0434517227,
0.0056836568,
-0.0077505829,
-0.0536907464,
0.0149818966,
0.0211921819,
-0.0118579036,
-0.0247969069,
0.0131684644,
-0.0069595412,
0.0235387981,
0.0470822752,
0.0597350635,
0.0008596511,
-0.0091397082,
-0.0357245654,
-0.0553705133,
-0.0521925762,
-0.0608827472,
-0.006652202,
0.0577140898,
0.0470202714,
-0.0441714264,
0.0068409974,
-0.0212714691,
0.0630599186,
-0.0208246857,
0.0370570719,
-0.0486554243,
-0.0302668083,
-0.0207853615,
0.0099312039,
-0.0410862938,
0.025466159,
-0.0170034692,
-0.0098497206,
-0.0206083879,
0.0086947549,
-0.0244693849,
-0.0376452543,
0.0496233851,
-0.0006827048,
-0.0354105569,
-0.0340858847,
0.0507437773,
0.0863047466,
0.0531212389,
0.046046216,
-0.0043337243,
-0.0485870317,
-0.0349506326,
0.0080270236,
0.0900370851,
0.027911583,
-0.0039499723,
0.0584627464,
-0.0105453944,
-0.0169285405,
-0.0208417289,
0.0564818978,
-0.0372968055,
-0.0826089457,
0.027104212,
-0.041532129,
-0.0109604113,
0.0105975224,
0.0195840485,
-0.0791711211,
-0.0188078005,
-0.0775442347,
0.0083896881,
0.0255156886,
-0.0010766203,
0.0037992867,
0.014137214,
-0.0001548564,
0.0367973149,
0.0319535509,
0.082461752,
-0.0590490587,
-0.0001255098,
-0.0520969331,
-0.0180813707,
0.0459552594,
0.008866718,
-0.0050741141,
-0.0039912942,
-0.0172719546,
0.0609386787,
-0.0051065944,
0.0207146164,
0.0434378646,
-0.0091964817,
-0.0304971244,
0.0699967444,
0.0353722908,
0.027898252,
-0.0394161046,
0.050143782,
-0.0038939626,
0.0323022902,
0.0255424436,
-0.0088402061,
0.0028069916,
-0.0216509737,
-0.0309405811,
0.0193092041,
0.0367760658,
-0.0235470347,
-0.0039126645,
-0.0343185663,
-0.0122959716,
0.023416033,
0.0075252289,
0.0423587076,
0.01275675,
-0.0731398761,
-0.0160070509,
0.0210238453,
-0.0359667242,
0.0182130355,
-0.0694211572,
0.026302414,
0.0118630156,
0.0031742866,
-0.0340778641,
-0.0162995756,
-0.0056529152,
-0.0124388058,
0.0076369713,
0.0030650066,
0.022106234,
0.0541473888,
-0.0465449542,
-0.0209426973,
0.0635930076,
0.0148356659,
0.0291304402,
0.0015485589,
-0.0102857407,
0.0072149206,
-0.0311067924,
-0.0191255435,
-0.0203683227,
0.0074014799,
0.0020734821,
0.0548354052,
0.0352392979,
0.0591154322,
0.0355192944,
0.0116574997,
-0.0282361098,
0.0590226166,
0.0262025632,
0.0280982908,
0.0250767805,
-0.0187599733,
0.008013295,
0.0506435819,
-0.0243533496,
0.0229158271,
0.0319561623,
0.0546406731,
-0.0586792789,
0.0485737212,
-0.0580496043,
0.0736783668,
0.0070657535,
0.0747515485,
-0.0172310993,
0.0009343886,
0.029053241,
-0.0527418777,
0.0346079357,
-0.0696349069,
-0.0159667619,
-0.0105765359,
-0.0329847559,
-0.0070101274,
-0.0198536515,
0.0028037557,
-0.0580977052,
0.0865891203,
-0.0124890879,
-0.0396360792,
-0.0065219374,
-0.0262289848,
-0.0311904065,
-0.01662484,
-0.0034630026,
-0.000486493,
-0.0445771627,
0.035237655,
0.0387711413,
0.0074002179,
0.0145516675,
0.0258601625,
-0.0482979529,
0.0137868179,
-0.0480847061,
-0.0302547086,
-0.0351466276,
-0.0193821881,
-0.0045485967,
0.005829466,
-0.0172536001,
-0.0451792814,
0.0153697478,
-0.0357407369,
0.0018902888,
0.0338689573,
0.0335006751,
-0.0196528956,
0.0007747945,
-0.0078813033,
0.0199252218,
0.0346265435,
0.0661222413,
-0.0127711212,
0.0127892904,
-0.0025124596,
-0.0065949336,
-0.0411784239,
0.0035590015,
0.0236548744,
0.0009844539,
0.0277728178,
0.0174420476,
-0.0407853536,
0.0199660435,
0.0210647844,
0.0257560704,
-0.0635500327,
0.0105626164,
-0.0087096207,
-0.0085443165,
0.0494218096,
-0.0640358776,
-0.0458518527,
0.0016792766,
0.0090978611,
-0.044545643,
-0.0323465466,
-0.088746272,
-0.0460987501,
-0.018776875,
-0.0517771654,
0.0126179093,
0.0128312809,
-0.0096762003,
-0.0084576262,
0.0059071989,
-0.0460965075,
-0.0321647152,
-0.0010998601,
0.0704686493,
-0.0536378883,
0.0389473662,
-0.0045623607,
0.0219891798,
-0.0081916275,
-0.0195106268,
-0.0046639,
-0.0091852024,
-0.0252898112,
0.0311362185,
0.0204988774,
-0.0785163268,
-0.0522021763,
0.0730967447,
-0.003925032,
0.0556298345,
-0.0261979904,
0.0253480375,
-0.0233022328,
0.0319424272,
0.0582532845,
0.0374576822,
0.0004938775,
-0.0212731957,
0.0137405209,
0.003954255,
0.0477474257,
-0.0167276673,
-0.0349216238,
-0.0035360272,
0.0348439999,
0.0430253372,
0.0039967131,
0.0067161932,
0.1075671315,
-0.0426884852,
0.0347450078,
0.0404253267,
-0.0144262994,
0.0170847699,
-0.0369291343,
-0.0065240944,
0.0243069902,
-0.0175929163,
-0.0494065508,
0.0241176449,
-0.0068927216,
0.0618535094,
0.0656497702,
0.0171461534,
0.0261947177,
-0.0104077347,
-0.0273298994,
0.0399904028,
0.0229321253,
-0.0496909209,
-0.0793315917,
-0.0420525707,
-0.0228797961,
-0.0261798985,
0.0814495459,
-0.0001728104,
-0.0661256462,
-0.0655307695,
0.0208685808,
-0.0562783033,
-0.0364632681,
0.0288673341,
-0.0335561186,
0.0838311538,
0.04929002,
-0.0143481558,
0.0004525868,
-0.013190507,
0.0235005077,
0.0048490088,
0.0073947897,
-0.0348760486,
0.0001891386,
0.0073380382,
-0.0076251291,
0.0049659554,
0.0443428047,
0.0297717229,
0.0203473698,
0.0083168335,
0.042341996,
0.0049620825,
-0.0369306803,
0.0265319608,
0.0482131578,
-0.0049364707,
0.0611125566,
0.009338351,
-0.0382899754,
0.0118559022,
0.0438225567,
0.024347188,
0.02739105,
-0.0133649781,
-0.0291111115,
0.014624116,
-0.0209036581,
-0.0016958481,
0.0642836615,
0.0132209882,
0.050121434,
0.0487452373,
-0.0027126851,
0.0237795729,
0.0214981437,
-0.0238165017,
-0.0189465191,
-0.0207315665,
0.0301831551,
-0.0530479215,
-0.0210672989,
0.0109322825,
-0.0420081653,
-0.0109302066,
-0.0144165885,
-0.0838109776,
-0.0496197157,
-0.004722063,
-0.0196090769,
0.0268646143,
0.0599027388,
-0.0197662115,
-0.0252652187,
0.0187604632,
-0.0220617615,
-0.057052549,
-0.0213924479,
0.0698102936,
-0.0384656936,
-0.0024766205,
0.0255744923,
-0.0371222496,
-0.0228392836,
0.0004080855,
-0.0118762739,
0.0170678962,
-0.0794080794,
-0.0140620125,
-0.0185178798,
0.0454669856,
0.0305211265,
-0.0165559147,
-0.028242074,
0.0672847629,
-0.0109085646,
0.0634723604,
-0.0326150768,
-0.030429421,
-0.0023255595,
0.0321791768,
-0.0263290163,
0.0289784409,
-0.0532026663,
-0.0105479332,
-0.019643411,
0.1192005724,
-0.0150607815,
0.0266014338,
0.0284755658,
0.0077332109,
0.0077711139,
0.0447815694,
0.0709805638,
0.0320553295,
0.0163448118,
-0.0425280742,
-0.018539194,
0.0291781668,
-0.0109913787,
-0.0137787871,
-0.0446413234,
-0.0133439172,
-0.0222052466,
0.0240889341,
0.0154385772,
-0.0070346557,
0.0615806878,
0.0093194433,
0.017824633,
-0.044567056,
-0.0079664234,
-0.0135523584,
0.0528488979,
0.0263662748,
-0.0452989191,
-0.0090405522,
0.0581876859,
0.0192599092,
0.0124230292,
0.028562475,
-0.0285685919,
0.0720231161,
-0.0365491472,
-0.0346228667,
0.0104484027,
-0.0113330642,
-0.0387390517,
0.0137919318,
0.0010104385,
-0.0114974137,
0.0437498316,
-0.0463990644,
-0.0021555854,
-0.0469950847,
-0.0171443466,
-0.0305691995,
-0.0657126606,
-0.0373530351,
0.0471257493,
-0.0849927887,
0.053105209,
-0.0299920905,
0.0380310155,
-6.401028122e-33,
-0.0087077087,
-0.0034801324,
-0.0112185525,
0.0643550232,
-0.0195858832,
-0.0017379378,
-0.0151050817,
0.0425125882,
-0.0170417875,
-0.0198276639,
-0.0076861801,
-0.0221008006,
0.0612242445,
-0.0272935573,
-0.0236892123,
-0.0050287545,
0.1150920689,
-0.0261294078,
-0.0124403648,
-0.0335205309,
-0.0086966082,
0.0118178949,
0.0156528279,
-0.0592428222,
-0.0317714065,
0.0150145516,
-0.0129377078,
-0.0185651127,
0.0557852127,
0.0533713996,
0.0417987108,
0.0175136924,
-0.0096477093,
0.0329945907,
-0.0113850972,
-0.0053639859,
-0.090963006,
0.0546095707,
0.0205927845,
0.0466739461,
-0.0028541856,
-0.0258406568,
0.0168420151,
0.0244643018,
-0.0311538242,
-0.0803707689,
0.0251953546,
-0.0194480475,
-0.0067166216,
-0.0366982408,
-0.0683872178,
0.0315829813,
-0.0324281305,
-0.0383624136,
0.0708759874,
0.0756043121,
-0.051690612,
-0.0589676388,
-0.078354992,
0.0072623123,
0.0392076708,
0.0620815158,
0.0113042295,
0.0139042176,
-0.0298414659,
-0.0243266001,
0.0819093361,
-0.0560550839,
0.0118306559,
-0.048388809,
0.0488416404,
0.02789676,
0.0323260091,
-0.0230203085,
-0.0185159408,
-0.0469237417,
-0.0542336926,
-0.018170204,
-0.0258140154,
0.0419987254,
0.0264184996,
0.0150327077,
-0.0248622894,
0.0304352958,
-0.0530282743,
-0.042801898,
-0.0289188325,
0.0083496692,
0.0381842367,
-0.0204586852,
-0.0343996175,
-0.0087445844,
0.0628530458,
-0.0326450765,
0.0294697676,
-0.0219919328,
0.0284726564,
-0.0056037321,
-0.04211336,
0.025232086,
-0.0099508408,
-0.0762918293,
0.0572870634,
0.0223402288,
0.003040052,
-0.0318225473,
0.0333174206,
0.0408052094,
-0.0705700815,
-0.0268960353,
0.021825036,
0.0251403973,
0.0101028718,
0.0289202668,
0.0308458265,
0.0032460282,
0.0165141802,
0.0389481485,
-0.0188884791,
0.0433094911,
-0.0179656595,
0.0258612856,
0.0386191718,
0.0074631278,
-0.0253895111,
0.0323533267,
0.0174278859,
0.0144782132,
0.0057476675,
0.0136598442,
-0.0083254213,
0.0098925838,
2.542e-7,
-0.0580193661,
0.0501241237,
0.0109937936,
-0.0695129856,
0.0369618759,
-0.0016300139,
0.0120495437,
-0.0444440469,
0.029888751,
0.0310736299,
-0.0057443548,
-0.0241645612,
0.1495064348,
0.0016376823,
-0.0399237648,
-0.0110946614,
-0.0164047237,
0.0087800333,
0.013496723,
0.0293268021,
0.001826212,
0.0564910062,
0.0021070542,
-0.0558904521,
-0.0066360044,
0.0454540662,
-0.00612398,
-0.0129740126,
0.0265358537,
-0.0032787602,
-0.0328633189,
0.0115259076,
0.018502932,
0.0218240712,
-0.0573300496,
0.0869715661,
0.0113429772,
0.0297444239,
-0.0332358256,
-0.0299071521,
-0.011607836,
0.0496073402,
-0.0311682187,
-0.0248522852,
0.0792818964,
-0.0045242012,
-0.0042531826,
-0.0126679642,
-0.044569578,
0.0118712327,
0.0139092477,
-0.0130194258,
0.0200735498,
0.0532605201,
-0.0028717259,
-0.0120022986,
-0.0406806879,
0.0113739502,
0.0318889134,
-0.006676083,
-0.0297818203,
-0.042704761,
0.0065740165,
0.0034388518,
-0.0030189813,
0.0427312739,
0.0186671335,
1.57677001e-34,
0.0333651938,
-0.0618641824,
0.0612072088,
-0.017456444,
-0.0282392427,
-0.0333901979,
0.0244199615,
0.0192063227,
-0.014561452,
-0.0527274422,
-0.0614470989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04292v1 | Aspect-based Meeting Transcript Summarization: A Two-Stage Approach with Weak Supervision on Sentence Classification | 2023-11-07T19:06:31 | 2023-11-07T19:06:31 | Zhongfen Deng, Seunghyun Yoon, Trung Bui, Franck Dernoncourt, Quan Hung Tran, Shuaiqi Liu, Wenting Zhao, Tao Zhang, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based meeting transcript summarization aims to produce multiple
summaries, each focusing on one aspect of content in a meeting transcript. It
is challenging as sentences related to different aspects can mingle together,
and those relevant to a specific aspect can be scattered throughout the long
transcript of a meeting. The traditional summarization methods produce one
summary mixing information of all aspects, which cannot deal with the above
challenges of aspect-based meeting transcript summarization. In this paper, we
propose a two-stage method for aspect-based meeting transcript summarization.
To select the input content related to specific aspects, we train a sentence
classifier on a dataset constructed from the AMI corpus with pseudo-labeling.
Then we merge the sentences selected for a specific aspect as the input for the
summarizer to produce the aspect-based summary. Experimental results on the AMI
corpus outperform many strong baselines, which verifies the effectiveness of
our proposed method. | [
0.0588459447,
-0.0075302855,
0.004063094,
0.001984186,
-0.0376084261,
0.0198433027,
-0.0120377243,
-0.0294612236,
-0.0207411386,
-0.0291933343,
-0.0284617171,
-0.0298647825,
0.0209572539,
0.0323851109,
-0.0214926414,
-0.0745071545,
0.0684892386,
0.0454359762,
-0.0019519917,
0.0265512038,
0.0446191728,
0.0403775685,
0.0137404921,
0.0144789899,
-0.0236272849,
0.0178666692,
-0.0067849942,
-0.02942927,
0.0639952272,
0.0356142893,
0.0244980194,
-0.000497187,
-0.0010962146,
-0.0509238318,
0.0000018138,
-0.0447736681,
-0.048227407,
-0.0217367038,
0.033167351,
0.0011253055,
0.0411797687,
-0.0215417743,
0.0124713788,
0.0547174588,
-0.0154548166,
-0.0394396558,
-0.0251796301,
0.1196352988,
0.0553776808,
0.0867189765,
-0.0322026126,
-0.0114766043,
-0.0072811795,
-0.013801544,
-0.0267250817,
-0.0324691534,
-0.0283717047,
0.0071437103,
-0.0104054771,
0.0108097596,
0.0441842228,
0.0016276067,
0.0040451246,
-0.0387641229,
0.0221112426,
0.028459223,
-0.0392457768,
0.0130388616,
0.0122984154,
0.0324203372,
0.048130624,
0.0192371998,
0.0625602007,
-0.0057293465,
0.0297629144,
-0.0037196067,
-0.0269252677,
0.0143975327,
-0.0124855628,
0.0148078445,
0.029471511,
0.065620169,
-0.045372691,
0.0334008597,
0.013470388,
0.013981685,
-0.0112498831,
-0.0313314535,
-0.0352713428,
0.0068716463,
0.0123739755,
-0.0443602689,
0.0510016344,
0.0121124731,
0.0000461403,
-0.0208343063,
-0.0370445363,
0.0306644328,
0.0297142286,
-0.0257155523,
-0.035830155,
0.0058236527,
0.0395150818,
0.0436248593,
0.0505776666,
-0.0092576211,
0.0650752261,
-0.0309593603,
-0.0962483287,
0.0056709857,
-0.0391704515,
0.0389320329,
-0.0334191956,
0.0604280904,
-0.0384928882,
-0.0021376836,
-0.0545536242,
0.0085807582,
0.0413229875,
-0.014456097,
0.0284257736,
0.0107690282,
0.0154966041,
0.0331104212,
0.0156605057,
0.011069309,
-0.0550418384,
0.0209474694,
0.0119505469,
0.0412261747,
0.0079181204,
0.0195243061,
0.0352416001,
0.0051896768,
-0.0476969257,
-0.0187667515,
-0.0161681939,
-0.0463468954,
0.0060304007,
-0.0474457629,
-0.0585402064,
-0.0259369444,
-0.0440156944,
-0.0219054986,
0.0316169038,
-0.0263826549,
-0.0367576815,
0.0011871097,
0.0065588267,
0.0120083764,
-0.0083299372,
0.0076912548,
0.0004579693,
-0.0098525332,
0.0464662053,
0.0184697639,
0.0615826659,
0.0053927391,
0.017001275,
0.0389575399,
0.0225347783,
0.0295525212,
0.0011114042,
0.0240105893,
-0.0111493971,
0.0070549515,
0.0540828481,
-0.0289851539,
0.0043661627,
-0.0249291155,
-0.0405804701,
0.0563577525,
-0.022690719,
0.0412815064,
0.0248884764,
-0.0029751118,
-0.0110970605,
0.0641518831,
-0.0207170602,
0.0670305192,
-0.0083275838,
0.0653595552,
0.0026525366,
-0.0055741183,
-0.0456581526,
0.0388113782,
0.0771150067,
-0.0151401851,
-0.0445547514,
-0.0805851817,
0.0000880191,
-0.0140941646,
-0.0297471285,
0.0025629373,
-0.0025157104,
-0.0011917629,
-0.0508311689,
0.0284802765,
0.0240510311,
-0.0673273951,
0.0071721682,
0.0149824964,
-0.0032939774,
0.0376589596,
0.0045436462,
-0.0451007374,
-0.0305151008,
-0.0581425577,
-0.0410118215,
-0.0027226461,
0.0678756312,
-0.0380237177,
-0.0153280543,
-0.0403180271,
-0.0047490713,
0.0132927336,
-0.0042673214,
-0.0429556519,
-0.0247060992,
-0.0008510418,
0.0323218554,
0.0069657811,
0.0043654083,
0.0097835111,
0.0047923271,
-0.0192345902,
0.0356213376,
0.0066748336,
0.0167404357,
0.0653408915,
0.0039399141,
-0.0124856774,
0.032483533,
-0.0312228147,
-0.0048536197,
0.0309628472,
-0.0754330903,
-0.0757700205,
0.0294105727,
0.0066976747,
0.0084181353,
-0.0630427226,
-0.0466362163,
-0.085382387,
-0.0002516958,
-0.0185672734,
0.0224295352,
-0.0498486347,
0.0375526622,
0.043168176,
-0.0066088457,
-0.0184926689,
0.0410242118,
-0.0009286205,
-0.0191476308,
-0.0221730582,
-0.047711987,
0.0385299921,
-0.0240516234,
0.0222896505,
-0.0069069266,
-0.0000703643,
0.0049569225,
0.0696418285,
-0.0106651634,
-0.0391869433,
-0.0361197405,
-0.1300466061,
-0.0078086914,
-0.0288251806,
0.0275209546,
0.0376443975,
0.0232921336,
0.0105232438,
0.0350822359,
-0.0649620667,
-0.0293751433,
0.0126762986,
-0.0357797593,
0.0239825174,
0.0612538271,
0.0258263722,
-0.0548376776,
-0.0077788699,
-0.0166759565,
0.0487671643,
0.0166057851,
-0.0427661426,
-0.059840057,
0.0724035576,
0.00404714,
-0.0186207909,
0.0099529251,
0.0003718844,
-0.0389188603,
0.0071483394,
0.0256137829,
-0.0022361691,
0.0509949662,
0.0172665566,
0.0159636103,
0.0323816463,
-0.0217505228,
0.0036565631,
-0.018146161,
0.0548203699,
0.0013441285,
-0.0378190689,
0.0336616859,
0.032230556,
0.0175068062,
0.0130635509,
-0.0237439014,
0.0143199945,
-0.0055650035,
0.016036531,
-0.0088710589,
-0.0431675464,
-0.0196439289,
-0.0063484348,
-0.0217677839,
0.0300510339,
0.0557237454,
0.0063591185,
0.0292205699,
-0.0640127286,
-0.0496280864,
-0.0340327583,
0.0713572502,
-0.0639091581,
0.0331953652,
0.0511337221,
-0.028385466,
-0.0141215911,
-0.0982989669,
0.0229523834,
0.0026729489,
0.0520856194,
-0.0228824466,
0.0077035162,
-0.0084921615,
-0.0315747261,
-0.025821913,
-0.0533429831,
-0.0216512959,
0.040134076,
-0.039799653,
0.0136434827,
-0.0752192289,
0.0081365444,
-0.0232454743,
0.0212243814,
-0.0181269422,
0.0169477202,
0.0193279311,
0.0871362984,
0.0400500186,
-0.0090655852,
-0.0117796632,
-0.0307216495,
0.0409842469,
0.0364862978,
0.0085465191,
0.0233059768,
0.0426955484,
-0.0343223885,
0.0043317243,
-0.0457795598,
-0.02032944,
-0.0041542426,
0.0442113467,
-0.022649182,
-0.0078868065,
0.1168702021,
0.0526315756,
-0.0385767408,
-0.0238103885,
0.0068558622,
0.0106609203,
-0.0081647225,
0.0302491374,
-0.0622620657,
-0.0061831116,
-0.0217029415,
0.0073308521,
-0.011521386,
0.0020323582,
-0.0155392159,
-0.0681547746,
-0.0019414355,
0.0171316862,
-0.0792619735,
-0.0486287773,
-0.0177574195,
-0.0107320659,
-0.0271899365,
0.0283406563,
-0.0002495347,
0.0058239754,
-0.0325558968,
0.0002365214,
-0.0589183867,
-0.0081090927,
0.0051455456,
0.0106156161,
-0.0129795969,
0.0387757234,
0.069613196,
0.0066707409,
0.0163357016,
0.0404556021,
-0.077366896,
0.0026360275,
-0.0058685765,
0.0764642283,
-0.0302747097,
0.0095387064,
0.0060398332,
0.054414425,
0.0084125688,
-0.0317239538,
0.043743711,
-0.0033154392,
-0.0263108313,
0.0085873827,
-0.0092417086,
0.0519089922,
-0.0037970403,
0.0554423928,
0.0175740682,
-0.013248059,
0.0201432575,
-0.0218096711,
0.0217615198,
-0.049792137,
-0.0028001829,
-0.0334817097,
-0.0140974177,
-0.0044068536,
-0.0827008784,
-0.0724418461,
0.0187667254,
-0.01482681,
-0.0117344912,
-0.0116707599,
0.0308198947,
0.0298769306,
-0.030653337,
0.0229376741,
0.0068773958,
0.0183413085,
-0.0071212724,
-0.0325741284,
0.0775256678,
-0.025647996,
-0.0074361959,
0.0051963986,
-0.0170255024,
-0.0461625718,
-0.0065408819,
0.0184203051,
0.0047928118,
0.0670460314,
0.0191856939,
0.0150614688,
0.015812546,
-0.0019879176,
0.0295231082,
-0.0057848217,
0.0523003489,
0.0259025246,
-0.0361001715,
0.0131164761,
-0.0319868028,
0.0320191607,
-0.0076646879,
-0.0058619105,
-0.0903104693,
-0.1023054793,
0.0052448632,
0.0152918082,
0.0095645934,
-0.0151130613,
-0.0231238827,
-0.0172305554,
0.0043782773,
0.0076709725,
-0.0196189024,
-0.0112078888,
-0.0118385507,
-0.0464179628,
-0.0159483645,
-0.0130318571,
0.0989031568,
-0.0801109821,
0.0096487608,
-0.0489026643,
0.023331169,
-0.0538052805,
-0.0616707616,
-0.0674576908,
-0.0021993055,
-0.0377734192,
-0.0317505375,
0.0200273301,
0.0280669536,
-0.0273582172,
0.0260243453,
-0.0151238814,
0.0294846613,
-0.0166975074,
0.0328876488,
-0.0400574133,
0.0722685382,
-0.0631257668,
0.0198443998,
-0.0020897184,
-0.0877695233,
0.0380584188,
-0.0194923822,
0.009913587,
-0.0471052043,
0.0291923042,
-0.0203151982,
-0.0057157259,
-0.0062044603,
0.0123523632,
0.0037689069,
0.0514302403,
0.0360749029,
-0.1006377935,
0.0048233941,
0.0254639611,
0.0010321062,
-0.0553184412,
-0.0199335665,
-0.0030462497,
0.0118775917,
-0.0090456987,
-0.0211796947,
-0.0549823157,
0.0197188985,
0.0262133069,
-0.0203859098,
0.0196400676,
-0.0189443659,
0.0564276613,
-0.0188321471,
0.0028322267,
0.016406538,
-0.0455658324,
-0.0530627221,
0.0430894457,
0.0336646624,
-0.0197922569,
-5.611610197e-33,
-0.0396758318,
-0.0044527361,
-0.024276536,
0.0140164457,
-0.0479096025,
0.0190202128,
-0.0111275399,
0.010515729,
0.0035189507,
-0.0228325389,
-0.0155755738,
0.0178693738,
0.0283490866,
0.0728682876,
0.0087626176,
0.0420390479,
0.0576938875,
-0.0016226625,
-0.0135834506,
0.0686276555,
0.0038293041,
0.0121032214,
0.0527562723,
-0.1100845635,
0.0165133905,
0.0063917791,
-0.0294958912,
-0.0124781784,
0.035918761,
0.0223019812,
0.0028446654,
0.0093736295,
0.0140616689,
-0.0293269288,
-0.0098321196,
0.0279670767,
-0.0730403662,
-0.0250708181,
0.0448669158,
-0.0242804307,
0.0050227032,
-0.0684144795,
-0.0039773094,
-0.0183826759,
0.0313226618,
-0.0493670627,
0.0425130837,
-0.0474950224,
-0.0599660464,
-0.0916710421,
-0.0045112451,
0.0476001836,
-0.0308540687,
-0.0375069939,
0.0286019333,
0.0550892651,
0.0337931924,
-0.0552515984,
0.0070286365,
0.0608731396,
0.0027799278,
0.0380284041,
-0.0169290416,
0.008775047,
-0.0040751556,
0.0559749305,
-0.0032517796,
0.0202902593,
-0.0140918074,
-0.0193836335,
-0.0437705703,
-0.0104958946,
-0.0346791334,
0.0079133892,
-0.0007134605,
-0.0071436316,
-0.018926084,
0.0918953866,
0.0064277058,
-0.0254418049,
0.0036137511,
0.0038561192,
-0.0255848002,
-0.015509706,
-0.0013827614,
0.0093949856,
0.0089328727,
0.017554367,
-0.0236129966,
0.0391074382,
-0.0289122779,
0.0117137507,
-0.0195498932,
-0.0447232947,
0.0331938453,
-0.005150483,
-0.023317812,
0.0222662073,
-0.027059434,
-0.0229726788,
-0.0432022512,
-0.0187306385,
0.0339532346,
0.0227886122,
0.0169695485,
-0.0056781331,
0.0551997945,
-0.0239285994,
-0.0467274264,
0.0223999899,
0.0469280332,
0.0318112522,
-0.058555413,
0.0251468197,
-0.0368095338,
0.0394127592,
-0.002211767,
0.0746081322,
-0.0245522279,
0.0303111412,
-0.025295889,
-0.005321837,
0.0223880559,
0.0741000324,
-0.0097025903,
0.0264473315,
0.007839351,
0.0125095071,
0.0301107541,
0.0300570447,
-0.006083942,
-0.0135310888,
2.374e-7,
0.020610122,
0.0177917052,
0.0539090745,
0.0042921943,
-0.0113016618,
0.0483070388,
0.0245655496,
0.0267340019,
0.0179807134,
0.0210588668,
0.0719768256,
0.0089520486,
0.0406220667,
0.0186906457,
-0.094668597,
0.0034854561,
-0.0350227207,
-0.0694050565,
-0.023421932,
0.0191383995,
0.0823872089,
0.0910470337,
0.005352376,
-0.0033632454,
-0.0211224332,
0.025884958,
0.0179576986,
-0.0152261611,
-0.0911246315,
0.0204114169,
-0.0235928968,
0.0084513444,
-0.0575956441,
0.0177407432,
-0.0314224102,
-0.0192741118,
0.014783442,
0.0465809777,
-0.0045981314,
-0.0458444059,
0.012081828,
0.0275434311,
0.0038367121,
0.0736922324,
0.0563629232,
-0.0592644028,
-0.0044603762,
-0.0243433714,
-0.0442763157,
0.0363897346,
-0.0147969648,
0.0414585285,
-0.0217948817,
0.0784534737,
-0.0213897675,
-0.035217315,
0.0014367423,
-0.069791235,
-0.0075187995,
0.0941972509,
0.0047539803,
-0.0254862569,
0.0297693908,
-0.01668006,
-0.0016601773,
-0.0506883264,
0.0122263497,
1.858297808e-34,
0.0475328676,
0.0239215922,
-0.0447959676,
0.0299664326,
0.0059354845,
-0.0495602675,
-0.001555267,
-0.0225861613,
0.0345821306,
-0.0150895854,
0.0035584567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04284v1 | CRAB: Assessing the Strength of Causal Relationships Between Real-world Events | 2023-11-07T19:00:44 | 2023-11-07T19:00:44 | Angelika Romanou, Syrielle Montariol, Debjit Paul, Leo Laugier, Karl Aberer, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Understanding narratives requires reasoning about the cause-and-effect
relationships between events mentioned in the text. While existing foundation
models yield impressive results in many NLP tasks requiring reasoning, it is
unclear whether they understand the complexity of the underlying network of
causal relationships of events in narratives. In this work, we present CRAB, a
new Causal Reasoning Assessment Benchmark designed to evaluate causal
understanding of events in real-world narratives. CRAB contains fine-grained,
contextual causality annotations for ~2.7K pairs of real-world events that
describe various newsworthy event timelines (e.g., the acquisition of Twitter
by Elon Musk). Using CRAB, we measure the performance of several large language
models, demonstrating that most systems achieve poor performance on the task.
Motivated by classical causal principles, we also analyze the causal structures
of groups of events in CRAB, and find that models perform worse on causal
reasoning when events are derived from complex causal structures compared to
simple linear causal chains. We make our dataset and code available to the
research community. | [
0.0049292608,
0.0828095227,
-0.0315378197,
0.0213384312,
-0.027990602,
0.0218425337,
0.0007911001,
-0.0028747646,
0.0264559519,
-0.0505030937,
0.0905169025,
0.0219360273,
-0.0148874298,
0.0496088006,
-0.0274061207,
-0.0328884721,
0.023747215,
0.0215974767,
0.0399265625,
0.0193349682,
-0.0067178453,
0.0410988294,
-0.0387948081,
0.0450471044,
-0.0174369905,
-0.0199154261,
0.021549033,
0.001774013,
0.0160620734,
-0.065920718,
-0.0137113761,
0.032759089,
0.0295177046,
0.044271905,
0.0000019108,
-0.0417636409,
0.005548554,
-0.0032759898,
-0.0142408386,
0.014265527,
-0.032850489,
-0.0083224112,
0.0375708789,
-0.0140173743,
-0.0413840823,
-0.0164595898,
0.0059050946,
0.086709559,
0.0033305595,
0.0933929607,
-0.0206817295,
-0.0668051988,
0.0061895042,
0.0018940788,
0.0131079853,
-0.0384944454,
0.0094070062,
0.0462755971,
0.0157873314,
-0.0308672469,
-0.0132193491,
0.0221589841,
0.0332944989,
-0.002195826,
0.0083263665,
0.0384232998,
0.0167630948,
-0.0011298114,
0.0200470872,
0.0711390898,
0.0636850372,
-0.0414719097,
0.0248393789,
-0.0138340024,
0.0039595272,
0.0443817899,
-0.0490159653,
0.0436432958,
-0.0256923903,
0.0182854384,
0.0333589874,
0.0257889349,
0.0455516092,
0.028524952,
0.0036263035,
0.0802759305,
0.0091781346,
-0.0002196865,
-0.0372749045,
0.0180319827,
0.0304491408,
-0.052359622,
-0.0112121403,
0.012452798,
-0.0593850166,
0.0246565714,
-0.0036205631,
0.0740363747,
-0.0097777043,
-0.0775806531,
-0.0039571077,
0.0310483035,
0.0133079132,
0.0525568649,
-0.0242237877,
0.0164035987,
-0.0327922106,
0.0044934214,
0.0286497585,
0.0199749265,
-0.0565440096,
0.0403693914,
0.0166155696,
-0.0042843148,
-0.0437325202,
-0.0102184592,
-0.0092049977,
0.0032903715,
0.0039619072,
-0.0140545955,
-0.015558931,
0.0013977368,
-0.0027637712,
-0.0074991165,
-0.0578719415,
0.0109184403,
-0.098528713,
0.0379686691,
-0.0177974235,
-0.0228121467,
-0.0155418059,
-0.027436832,
0.0263225641,
-0.0576931238,
-0.0296505187,
0.0602850467,
0.021975819,
-0.0136083951,
-0.059683606,
-0.0489408821,
0.0117909014,
-0.044929821,
-0.0343821608,
-0.0224303752,
-0.0005652884,
0.0324464627,
0.0043599512,
-0.0302639306,
0.0222506952,
0.0019362313,
-0.0809654668,
0.0311678164,
-0.0025640402,
0.0074600251,
-0.017777402,
0.0057015619,
0.0391253345,
0.0605215281,
0.054859519,
0.0292344689,
0.0248970632,
0.0150559675,
0.0057391077,
-0.0151985707,
0.0052064084,
-0.0155102033,
-0.0139085986,
-0.0124586001,
-0.0277244542,
0.018393524,
-0.003834611,
-0.0097181685,
-0.0175566878,
0.0047888076,
0.0605118945,
-0.0071359649,
-0.0212233458,
-0.0234035198,
0.0650814995,
-0.0318252854,
0.0012512248,
0.0038457299,
-0.0392370597,
0.0310832188,
-0.0281456877,
-0.0251885876,
0.0167476367,
-0.0077624987,
-0.0009302786,
-0.0247788373,
-0.0225028936,
0.0178887676,
-0.0053225146,
0.0033861238,
0.0342635699,
0.0099239377,
-0.0482295677,
0.0124451574,
0.0377637371,
-0.0523558371,
0.0287386272,
0.0375563689,
0.0114215389,
0.0723698661,
0.0696027577,
-0.0235107783,
-0.029815346,
-0.0369777083,
0.0248589721,
0.0047639636,
0.0021794995,
-0.0161308963,
-0.0051841913,
-0.0084546562,
-0.0122938687,
-0.0018734196,
0.0391118824,
0.0030028152,
0.0293961894,
-0.0096877739,
-0.0276296865,
-0.0169321876,
-0.0036966987,
0.0429004654,
-0.0408359431,
-0.0186832361,
-0.0510506332,
0.0137653062,
0.0247066841,
0.0494164899,
-0.0060977433,
-0.0104898941,
0.0183776468,
-0.0518453009,
-0.061584238,
0.0868486762,
-0.0326068215,
-0.0165110286,
0.0057923617,
-0.0605666041,
-0.0513575263,
0.0197701845,
-0.0183567777,
-0.052246809,
0.0665809885,
-0.0033290419,
0.0082189711,
0.0007967371,
-0.0291443188,
-0.0267425347,
0.0025891005,
-0.0239008181,
0.1006695479,
0.0146230431,
0.0186257679,
-0.0375174358,
0.0086358357,
0.0051105493,
-0.014485117,
-0.0019601688,
0.022712091,
-0.0102907931,
-0.0403692536,
0.0641515255,
-0.0637718067,
-0.0504657775,
0.0049990513,
-0.0453375168,
0.0313552544,
-0.0292914994,
0.0070750485,
0.0379720777,
0.0086074593,
-0.0005156146,
-0.0154357012,
0.0048808414,
-0.0299338438,
-0.0297885425,
-0.0055845235,
0.0312794223,
0.0021211086,
0.0080952412,
-0.0430735163,
0.0105153313,
-0.0838884711,
0.0653599948,
0.0773515999,
-0.0151774893,
-0.0024785551,
-0.0153962309,
0.0162282139,
-0.0098782526,
-0.0116549246,
-0.0073839412,
0.022334354,
-0.0138200931,
0.0079697166,
0.0579394773,
-0.0053791027,
0.0508449301,
0.0014171896,
-0.0469477102,
-0.0347457193,
0.0367497727,
-0.0522039868,
0.0423071459,
-0.0551047102,
-0.0509574711,
-0.0552847199,
0.0748916715,
-0.0131338248,
-0.0012966037,
-0.0645884797,
-0.0015094356,
-0.0434880219,
0.0021739497,
-0.0039224853,
-0.0326434262,
-0.015509991,
0.0607769527,
-0.03478273,
-0.0177522507,
0.0337310024,
-0.0097089475,
0.0291498303,
0.0082380967,
0.0108252978,
-0.0541143119,
0.1050685942,
0.0056235469,
-0.0101873176,
0.0147834104,
-0.0351212136,
-0.0099022621,
-0.0163687933,
0.0487126373,
0.0269642808,
0.0034118721,
-0.0554038249,
0.0418577343,
0.0329172648,
-0.0153675005,
-0.0353639163,
-0.0559800789,
-0.0425235741,
-0.0032041455,
0.0003652715,
-0.0205455758,
-0.0372137278,
-0.0117445784,
0.0164517164,
0.0003928639,
-0.0106214052,
-0.0151811214,
-0.0142781958,
0.0268958658,
0.0359690748,
-0.0324866436,
0.0278484747,
-0.0041118031,
0.0137182195,
-0.01412341,
0.0112326443,
0.0151041159,
-0.0447706431,
0.0168797486,
-0.0266054161,
-0.0306733623,
0.0132032251,
-0.0115063926,
0.0417616554,
-0.0475824028,
0.0025769558,
0.1185715646,
0.0484467372,
0.00360982,
0.037849132,
0.067929469,
-0.0240254551,
0.0655244887,
-0.0046695257,
-0.0856517106,
-0.0260095522,
0.0062227496,
-0.0431840569,
0.0040688505,
-0.1064161435,
-0.012747162,
-0.0701154098,
0.0096901301,
-0.0318442099,
-0.0067408299,
0.004780659,
-0.067411609,
0.0105696619,
-0.0544882864,
-0.0323891826,
-0.0148973148,
-0.0085877823,
0.0184875634,
0.0015724298,
-0.0168591291,
-0.030147763,
0.0384335816,
-0.0151037583,
0.054233022,
0.0061533563,
0.048470825,
-0.0236892737,
0.0317022502,
-0.0069698901,
0.0155983837,
-0.012126999,
-0.0099796345,
0.0562051758,
0.0031239609,
-0.0084788706,
-0.0174004119,
0.04062929,
-0.0500233807,
-0.0387382545,
-0.0034575104,
0.0768806189,
0.0034590878,
-0.0242280383,
-0.0020337934,
0.0054146466,
-0.0196469408,
0.0820315778,
0.0059693689,
0.0153608201,
-0.0513001978,
-0.0122704003,
-0.0145728067,
-0.0764754117,
-0.0529847294,
-0.0158349015,
0.033277683,
-0.0280687381,
-0.0513294861,
-0.0844061896,
0.0048758802,
0.0100213652,
0.0042879744,
0.0393167511,
0.0419886,
-0.0052432101,
-0.0456588082,
0.0532204844,
-0.0398056768,
0.0299900267,
0.0252205394,
0.0245111175,
-0.0269646998,
0.0002955331,
-0.0114762494,
0.0331402943,
-0.0509403758,
-0.0564544648,
0.0091545936,
-0.0324229337,
0.0233393405,
0.0406984054,
-0.0504826866,
-0.0508231185,
-0.033649683,
0.0022686396,
-0.0524434894,
-0.0022853976,
0.0229816418,
-0.0056550549,
0.0189640392,
0.0359745845,
-0.0369617753,
0.0259706173,
-0.0174715817,
0.0751070827,
-0.0456155129,
0.0339579508,
0.0064942776,
-0.0227493681,
0.0505176559,
-0.0189541318,
-0.0384441316,
-0.0598702617,
-0.0163302477,
-0.0458988845,
-0.0099896165,
-0.0061448668,
0.0329920873,
0.0229658727,
0.0153280795,
-0.0535519868,
-0.0073220157,
-0.049237933,
0.0092588067,
-0.0231625829,
0.0173324943,
0.0496660806,
0.0261425041,
-0.0045715109,
-0.0071938816,
-0.0059164055,
0.0062674894,
-0.002164253,
0.0363923125,
-0.0233859029,
0.0254816432,
0.0299809165,
0.0172606781,
0.002633682,
-0.0677138045,
-0.1029800847,
0.0138575332,
0.0541451313,
-0.0052495026,
0.0837308764,
-0.061007224,
0.0603655316,
-0.019159941,
0.0184009671,
0.0340874642,
0.0299090091,
0.0419815071,
0.0066267964,
-0.0114087285,
0.0255242977,
-0.0432636216,
0.0645285249,
0.046324525,
-0.0020112814,
0.0810483322,
0.0202458743,
-0.0192015693,
0.0051713553,
-0.084303759,
-0.0155446045,
0.0530436933,
-0.0170789901,
0.0096273683,
-0.1043639705,
-0.0165163502,
0.0133169442,
-0.0183585212,
0.0139347799,
-0.0055589201,
-0.0032486327,
0.0225174427,
0.0185157992,
0.008272822,
-0.0507587865,
-0.000311598,
-0.0432983376,
-0.0239542425,
-0.0155425249,
-6.558631792e-33,
-0.0047195842,
-0.0282484237,
0.0129611772,
-0.0085630249,
-0.020237796,
0.0472224094,
-0.0733286217,
-0.0068060756,
-0.0260992218,
0.0692536533,
0.0064757974,
0.0450217053,
0.0202525537,
-0.0039891037,
0.0015878566,
-0.0108772498,
0.0306851789,
0.03049119,
-0.0245859176,
0.0300798621,
0.0564411357,
0.030762177,
0.0165809784,
-0.0799434632,
0.0577635057,
-0.0063251513,
-0.0191166867,
0.0067477734,
0.0063239527,
0.0131169502,
-0.0171841402,
0.0061238427,
0.0472918004,
-0.0629020482,
0.0043227351,
-0.0011959273,
-0.0818087161,
-0.0118763736,
0.0636475608,
0.008976548,
-0.0491760448,
-0.0142719373,
-0.0070712371,
0.0106740445,
0.0229658131,
-0.0209165495,
0.0714975968,
-0.0113900658,
0.0029750261,
-0.0102867,
-0.080391936,
0.029884791,
-0.0633978918,
0.0049721445,
0.0094243409,
0.0060280506,
0.0267090071,
0.0429026932,
0.011741857,
0.0043026898,
-0.0393404141,
0.0038744605,
0.0060593258,
-0.0158161391,
-0.0116016427,
0.0941533819,
-0.0078231804,
0.0360568389,
-0.0436872654,
0.0443048552,
-0.0022779324,
0.0393841788,
0.0472317077,
0.0884720385,
0.0192696583,
0.0154413069,
-0.1148202419,
0.005222905,
0.0505125038,
-0.0052700392,
0.0298495293,
-0.0056784945,
-0.0287509244,
0.0066943238,
-0.0627073497,
-0.0092128469,
-0.0337053239,
0.0146064227,
0.0045673628,
-0.0175596662,
0.0050662123,
0.0110245906,
0.0260298718,
-0.0457295142,
-0.0151156336,
0.0515884757,
-0.0105739264,
0.0030606601,
0.0143650761,
0.0277965479,
-0.0278388653,
0.0065595731,
0.0142183127,
0.0156580042,
0.0697375089,
-0.0159901921,
0.0567563884,
-0.0238876622,
-0.0047738664,
-0.0306883436,
-0.0482974052,
-0.0238294974,
-0.0173315424,
-0.0445189513,
0.0308691394,
0.0617337935,
-0.0080990493,
0.0274751224,
0.0442425795,
0.044753056,
0.0213678405,
-0.0528036095,
-0.0348058008,
0.0002758819,
-0.0234573055,
-0.0396414995,
-0.0154710617,
0.0489155091,
0.0010432831,
-0.0701168627,
-0.0188334007,
0.0107110292,
2.575e-7,
0.052065935,
0.0895361006,
0.0303756595,
0.0299968328,
0.020642085,
0.0124305319,
0.0098672519,
0.0092749801,
-0.0254705716,
-0.0194756277,
-0.0004780546,
0.0264250599,
0.0714299604,
0.0308044739,
-0.0550523028,
-0.0093989605,
-0.0672421306,
-0.023752857,
-0.0696739405,
0.002452472,
0.0845504031,
0.0307236519,
0.0784762874,
0.015561996,
0.014569982,
-0.0243259147,
0.0254608765,
-0.0323127434,
-0.0175043754,
0.0042808596,
-0.0574745014,
-0.0091591002,
-0.0326068588,
0.0226663519,
-0.022835182,
0.004159553,
-0.0174563583,
0.0151714589,
0.001675945,
0.0027194275,
-0.0274373796,
-0.0749832988,
-0.0001150163,
-0.0316069461,
0.0796293393,
-0.0136160487,
-0.0475701988,
0.0202042963,
-0.0321659781,
0.0206250008,
0.0148399761,
0.0532009266,
0.0011977566,
0.01138297,
-0.021966204,
-0.0034379927,
-0.0123995868,
-0.0855391175,
-0.040571522,
0.0308773257,
0.0111956438,
-0.0217279829,
-0.0141003504,
-0.0247030295,
0.027066255,
-0.0312632509,
0.003493784,
2.265608323e-34,
0.013085844,
0.0335128158,
0.0078188367,
-0.0080803242,
0.0798723772,
-0.006799228,
-0.0513445437,
0.0054402659,
0.0326047838,
-0.0835698396,
0.0133347362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04205v2 | Rephrase and Respond: Let Large Language Models Ask Better Questions for Themselves | 2023-11-07T18:43:34 | 2024-04-18T23:49:56 | Yihe Deng, Weitong Zhang, Zixiang Chen, Quanquan Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Misunderstandings arise not only in interpersonal communication but also
between humans and Large Language Models (LLMs). Such discrepancies can make
LLMs interpret seemingly unambiguous questions in unexpected ways, yielding
incorrect responses. While it is widely acknowledged that the quality of a
prompt, such as a question, significantly impacts the quality of the response
provided by LLMs, a systematic method for crafting questions that LLMs can
better comprehend is still underdeveloped. In this paper, we present a method
named `Rephrase and Respond' (RaR), which allows LLMs to rephrase and expand
questions posed by humans and provide responses in a single prompt. This
approach serves as a simple yet effective prompting method for improving
performance. We also introduce a two-step variant of RaR, where a rephrasing
LLM first rephrases the question and then passes the original and rephrased
questions together to a different responding LLM. This facilitates the
effective utilization of rephrased questions generated by one LLM with another.
Our experiments demonstrate that our methods significantly improve the
performance of different models across a wide range to tasks. We further
provide a comprehensive comparison between RaR and the popular Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) methods, both theoretically and empirically. We show that RaR is
complementary to CoT and can be combined with CoT to achieve even better
performance. Our work not only contributes to enhancing LLM performance
efficiently and effectively but also sheds light on a fair evaluation of LLM
capabilities. Data and codes are available at
https://github.com/uclaml/Rephrase-and-Respond. | [
0.0880118087,
0.0420902818,
-0.0452162027,
0.0373918079,
-0.0527169481,
0.0174670927,
0.0022057029,
0.006358997,
0.0059407307,
-0.0498379394,
-0.0385950468,
-0.0336128771,
0.0244046822,
0.0059574125,
0.0500990488,
-0.0835303217,
0.0480091609,
-0.0601427145,
-0.0020744631,
-0.0213874578,
0.0024431758,
-0.0072770426,
0.0042372495,
0.0430847071,
0.0008273987,
-0.0163733512,
-0.0424995422,
0.0250527058,
-0.0110674659,
-0.0139257964,
0.0105100004,
0.0545927063,
0.0065765213,
0.0385721177,
0.0000022388,
-0.0586200692,
0.0162260197,
-0.0161262713,
-0.0160125121,
0.0248317029,
0.0351359881,
0.0007231686,
0.0103886034,
0.0375930779,
-0.0518435761,
-0.0052819089,
0.0133601446,
0.021506628,
0.0582788885,
0.0660499483,
0.0058933077,
-0.0006600554,
0.0099839782,
-0.0218955521,
0.0120396717,
-0.0496506244,
0.0234521478,
-0.0062204953,
0.0181052908,
0.0267551932,
-0.0254572183,
0.0491510741,
0.0262482204,
-0.0303563625,
0.0214456432,
0.0182896517,
-0.0011896414,
-0.0422183387,
-0.0282941945,
0.0794474036,
0.0098686256,
-0.009300625,
-0.0051476625,
-0.003346659,
0.0313054845,
0.0293186028,
-0.0565424338,
0.0187978577,
0.0092935394,
-0.0242639929,
-0.0482531376,
-0.0091007669,
0.0076923016,
0.0070227827,
-0.0351772606,
0.0486839078,
0.0073927129,
-0.0382522047,
-0.0083703222,
0.0143999634,
-0.0013799467,
-0.0896369591,
0.0102134263,
0.0510583408,
-0.0670030043,
0.0101313451,
-0.0376231,
-0.0136692477,
0.0252953898,
-0.0154447844,
0.052172862,
0.0311187208,
-0.0109053357,
0.0282170773,
-0.0172200724,
0.0564562157,
-0.0244014468,
0.0192253664,
-0.0441835709,
0.0029822288,
-0.0640477613,
-0.0286841858,
-0.029915262,
0.0365166143,
-0.0358719118,
-0.0099001927,
-0.0041577825,
0.0500863902,
0.0234928913,
-0.0009687401,
-0.0061898855,
0.0192605481,
-0.0086985957,
-0.0153989019,
-0.0656391382,
0.0558471568,
-0.049336154,
0.0315236002,
0.0425982028,
-0.071292825,
-0.0123556498,
0.0096140373,
-0.0083547486,
-0.015748797,
0.0021571945,
0.0313946418,
-0.0371005498,
-0.0157639347,
-0.0096574975,
-0.025239354,
-0.0247364379,
-0.0746907368,
-0.0002571148,
-0.0621760227,
0.0460165702,
0.0277354792,
-0.02482762,
-0.0177233554,
0.0073878844,
0.0233240835,
-0.0495481789,
0.060845159,
-0.0124988332,
0.0535632595,
0.0434094183,
0.0192198437,
-0.0303921644,
0.0243994631,
0.0423844419,
0.0132751856,
0.0307944976,
-0.0127792154,
0.0228185765,
0.0285273306,
0.0025712738,
-0.0093568545,
-0.0006396045,
0.0405803137,
-0.0024751332,
0.0664599538,
0.0496692508,
0.0805111974,
-0.0301416721,
-0.0054147602,
0.0913420618,
0.0629952997,
-0.0382389352,
0.0211424399,
0.0398506634,
0.0393663235,
0.0041785417,
0.0210336391,
-0.0670430213,
0.0204781238,
-0.0192614477,
0.0103880353,
0.0312130246,
0.0188110583,
-0.0410168245,
-0.0586125068,
0.0005641449,
0.0270840898,
0.0213776249,
0.0570045263,
0.0068056351,
0.0218808446,
-0.0184912495,
0.0432117432,
0.0087601664,
-0.0457745083,
-0.0245820042,
-0.0837064013,
0.0448610261,
0.0528256781,
0.0337808058,
0.0117787197,
-0.0220190976,
-0.0188036039,
0.0266317744,
0.050552655,
0.07041201,
-0.0015887282,
-0.0196164977,
-0.0142789241,
0.0134732295,
-0.0175121147,
-0.0096728932,
0.0094797583,
0.0266247559,
-0.0278439671,
0.0087971045,
-0.0264254585,
-0.0062799174,
0.0247650724,
-0.0162353944,
-0.0044869157,
0.0203348026,
0.0063744895,
-0.0047161607,
0.006533951,
0.0040821894,
0.0224562064,
0.0148012899,
-0.0245467648,
-0.0274590291,
-0.0229226481,
-0.0488650016,
-0.048125457,
0.0317673609,
0.0070910654,
-0.0512718037,
0.0329585858,
-0.0185531899,
-0.0454445668,
0.0100836083,
-0.0333191492,
0.0428527072,
-0.0350237451,
0.0291282758,
-0.0005189823,
0.0100544458,
-0.0458353758,
0.0399354659,
0.0025713686,
0.0065005887,
0.0328749232,
-0.0056771706,
-0.0113875037,
-0.0406851992,
-0.0230029263,
0.0092665199,
-0.0147930607,
-0.0073432024,
0.0155365383,
0.0371043272,
-0.0659628958,
-0.0477575399,
-0.0892032608,
-0.0202383082,
-0.0120212352,
0.0095932586,
0.0168845821,
0.0278695989,
-0.0238824096,
-0.0288700238,
-0.0480063744,
0.0111703267,
0.0173232574,
0.0230392739,
0.0446136706,
-0.0003730649,
-0.0262110438,
-0.0305360723,
0.0061536538,
0.0044399565,
0.0228282288,
-0.0096741691,
-0.0142393298,
-0.0683217794,
0.0429735184,
-0.0480497777,
0.0149653759,
-0.0093890158,
-0.0309048258,
0.0305901226,
-0.0162461437,
0.0771867707,
0.0875407308,
0.0171464812,
0.0063508269,
0.05665005,
-0.0205416102,
-0.0566821061,
0.0304901786,
-0.0055753337,
-0.0481477454,
-0.050248336,
-0.0460419916,
-0.01811691,
0.0621691234,
0.0252624433,
0.0037837396,
-0.0342784002,
0.0164256003,
0.0016374009,
-0.0546239801,
-0.0549024902,
-0.0266426243,
-0.0267906711,
0.0680596232,
-0.0208457969,
-0.0333336443,
0.0813983902,
-0.0262668841,
-0.024881592,
-0.027101716,
0.0018737619,
-0.0135787372,
0.0864370614,
-0.0169885848,
-0.0040195603,
0.0083189514,
-0.0209654029,
-0.0820368528,
-0.0243592821,
0.0002993822,
-0.0363610275,
0.0458158329,
-0.0754204988,
0.0077618617,
-0.0030337966,
-0.0613657869,
-0.0635793284,
-0.0270233508,
-0.041524183,
0.003604782,
0.0033288184,
-0.0200198442,
-0.0265632086,
-0.0085192313,
0.0698934719,
0.015064327,
-0.0391090438,
-0.0125416238,
-0.0263880379,
0.0357024334,
0.0712384805,
0.0461072139,
0.0414202027,
-0.054221943,
0.0580111444,
0.0542369708,
0.0208232887,
0.0079886569,
-0.0020171942,
-0.0242180228,
0.031665545,
0.0038238771,
-0.0187686738,
0.0431570299,
0.078360185,
-0.0561573245,
-0.0430137664,
0.1174143851,
0.042557355,
-0.0427264161,
0.0137401996,
-0.0620588288,
0.0584546737,
0.0256589018,
0.0516219288,
-0.0672746748,
-0.0357642248,
0.0301421434,
-0.0125088925,
-0.0088814991,
-0.0247718226,
-0.0151147367,
-0.1417406052,
0.0418057665,
-0.0110179596,
-0.0206310712,
-0.0075072837,
-0.0233470425,
0.0120546306,
0.0596414059,
0.0519777685,
0.0278679486,
-0.0029310472,
-0.013716666,
-0.0076201684,
-0.0276008267,
-0.020326037,
0.019891426,
-0.0316074342,
0.0505888462,
0.0640963912,
0.008941805,
0.03131653,
-0.0377082229,
0.0387234688,
0.007165981,
0.0224032402,
-0.0255213231,
0.0183204673,
0.0140751898,
0.0036947725,
-0.0250749271,
0.0196568482,
-0.0235456303,
0.0074363998,
0.0647634044,
0.0544722676,
-0.0288837366,
-0.0244218633,
-0.0067967023,
0.0102320574,
0.0017902039,
0.0859889537,
0.0773249492,
-0.0633345917,
-0.0327338427,
-0.0192803834,
-0.0343370065,
-0.0211880021,
-0.0427248739,
0.0057298914,
0.0295436941,
0.0353547297,
-0.0681632608,
-0.0567036048,
0.0266273674,
0.0065295119,
0.0030966275,
-0.001854018,
0.0197396539,
0.0045931796,
-0.0119323935,
0.0148015898,
-0.0325826928,
0.0350293033,
-0.0543463565,
-0.0001916902,
-0.0095307473,
-0.0308874846,
-0.0106015988,
0.0136501873,
-0.1043187305,
-0.0547865853,
-0.0140332477,
0.0547763035,
0.0308184624,
0.0386939719,
0.002397615,
-0.079531461,
-0.0035625657,
0.0218821317,
-0.0521821044,
0.0430562459,
0.0087907072,
0.0419625603,
-0.002468213,
0.0769540295,
-0.0289197769,
0.0067099668,
0.0233300086,
0.0557287373,
-0.0240170695,
-0.070946835,
0.0268891361,
0.0333009809,
0.0223257132,
0.0067119226,
-0.005341839,
-0.0086513134,
0.0355785117,
-0.0275687948,
-0.0220659915,
-0.0618720427,
0.0032259028,
0.0187867377,
-0.0033698666,
0.0155081423,
-0.0362242498,
-0.0270295218,
0.0172038563,
-0.0251192506,
-0.018978497,
-0.0286647007,
0.0250894036,
0.0480238497,
0.0069309515,
-0.0167639777,
0.0140326852,
0.0177274272,
0.0353895351,
0.0266602952,
0.0769179165,
0.0136775523,
-0.025748292,
-0.0392025411,
0.021041533,
-0.077005513,
-0.084668532,
0.0381361283,
0.0369767249,
0.0098544089,
0.0485074669,
0.029088404,
-0.0190952867,
-0.0100179119,
-0.0044599781,
0.0362024866,
0.0053767436,
-0.0429145619,
0.0609043092,
0.010139442,
-0.0280854609,
-0.0060056602,
0.0558614582,
-0.0245825201,
-0.0137083679,
0.0121548614,
0.0141830677,
-0.0498993918,
-0.0454831123,
0.0036692494,
0.0026984226,
-0.0229563341,
0.0331755094,
-0.0568158478,
-0.0572582893,
-0.0056351707,
0.0100642992,
-0.0004045751,
-0.0592100397,
0.0303653236,
0.0581931286,
0.0184996147,
-0.0410091169,
-0.0327740423,
0.0330829136,
-0.014131994,
-0.0564547628,
-0.0437678508,
-6.817106102e-33,
-0.0381666236,
-0.0267045163,
0.0306597035,
-0.0059881606,
-0.0397987142,
-0.0131013496,
-0.057825949,
0.0393936671,
-0.0285005309,
0.0040570297,
-0.0519505478,
0.0291540585,
0.0090162726,
0.0354211181,
0.0104831792,
-0.0241822321,
0.0467265286,
-0.0013798604,
-0.0254554357,
0.0254635941,
0.002088238,
0.0295645371,
0.0069380114,
-0.0214906465,
0.0319773629,
-0.0242492352,
-0.0190315172,
0.0457208306,
-0.0262998845,
0.0425411388,
-0.038502913,
0.0360439196,
0.0172261409,
-0.010663894,
-0.0211714879,
0.0562584959,
-0.0436290875,
-0.007591689,
0.0496364944,
-0.0084651727,
-0.0675237998,
-0.0264527444,
0.0383579619,
0.0018726354,
0.00643773,
-0.0178322103,
0.0185438879,
-0.0064900401,
-0.0121021364,
0.0243819598,
-0.0485464372,
-0.0037297104,
-0.0055655995,
-0.0471810512,
-0.023517726,
0.0582204908,
-0.0281232893,
0.0011471459,
-0.0522531793,
0.0071556121,
0.0259208791,
0.0408072285,
0.0471650697,
0.0150768841,
-0.0024621424,
0.0391194411,
0.0040475759,
0.0100053493,
-0.0148787471,
-0.0218328442,
0.0247467048,
0.0251157153,
0.028058283,
0.0609864071,
-0.008172893,
0.0017883015,
-0.0463626347,
-0.0031672257,
0.036871586,
0.0380189754,
0.0124258483,
0.0085224807,
-0.0200332571,
-0.0313985124,
-0.0433586501,
0.0183720384,
-0.0449904203,
-0.023169158,
0.050609272,
0.0148052219,
-0.0088442508,
-0.0449336842,
0.0297418982,
-0.0490217172,
-0.0065996717,
-0.0220270902,
-0.0288833138,
0.0473298132,
0.0173806492,
0.0368433893,
-0.0488332137,
0.0144803049,
0.0148249622,
0.0127952732,
0.0078335507,
0.0181817804,
0.0213477314,
-0.0060121561,
-0.0696888193,
-0.0051538195,
-0.0392196812,
0.0570880286,
-0.0373940244,
-0.0179918483,
0.0119186491,
0.0314300954,
-0.0310368482,
0.0488223881,
-0.0285273083,
-0.0508776531,
-0.0537829101,
0.0000686762,
0.007929638,
0.0151705118,
-0.0495582409,
0.0081996946,
-0.0467694364,
0.0240702927,
0.0354275219,
-0.0416771658,
-0.0256497506,
0.0055867555,
2.881e-7,
0.0362742655,
0.0446855165,
0.0076179947,
0.0465415865,
0.015741175,
0.0317471959,
-0.0106534874,
0.0258843526,
0.0388960727,
-0.0252279565,
0.0043701683,
0.0449775085,
0.0675604492,
-0.0083048707,
-0.1048859209,
-0.0013352594,
-0.0791347474,
0.008835311,
-0.0358146876,
-0.0040718862,
0.0500680357,
0.0606915988,
-0.0046911985,
-0.0136253824,
-0.0121773798,
-0.01074709,
0.0691041201,
-0.0496582165,
-0.0152615327,
0.005552243,
0.0187519994,
-0.0050334423,
0.0274159629,
0.0464935154,
0.0151983462,
0.004996513,
-0.0317399874,
0.0637730882,
0.0135517586,
-0.0213779509,
-0.022361245,
0.0010804513,
0.0211879555,
-0.0871297419,
0.061030142,
-0.0679042488,
-0.0241001081,
0.0046580858,
0.026329197,
-0.0248637516,
-0.0028905265,
-0.021541791,
-0.0270318463,
0.0308361817,
0.0445572995,
0.0007526838,
0.0030192658,
-0.0636249781,
-0.035996303,
-0.0037858938,
-0.0439907499,
-0.0515632667,
-0.0627855361,
0.005768382,
0.0028476987,
-0.04181109,
0.0008137169,
2.549330874e-34,
0.0439524427,
0.0174866132,
0.0201936159,
0.0491863936,
0.0494912639,
-0.0073739481,
-0.0168882068,
0.0132039199,
0.0358074382,
-0.1036958173,
-0.0284040831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04199v1 | Exploring Recommendation Capabilities of GPT-4V(ision): A Preliminary Case Study | 2023-11-07T18:39:10 | 2023-11-07T18:39:10 | Peilin Zhou, Meng Cao, You-Liang Huang, Qichen Ye, Peiyan Zhang, Junling Liu, Yueqi Xie, Yining Hua, Jaeboum Kim | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have demonstrated impressive performance
across various vision and language tasks, yet their potential applications in
recommendation tasks with visual assistance remain unexplored. To bridge this
gap, we present a preliminary case study investigating the recommendation
capabilities of GPT-4V(ison), a recently released LMM by OpenAI. We construct a
series of qualitative test samples spanning multiple domains and employ these
samples to assess the quality of GPT-4V's responses within recommendation
scenarios. Evaluation results on these test samples prove that GPT-4V has
remarkable zero-shot recommendation abilities across diverse domains, thanks to
its robust visual-text comprehension capabilities and extensive general
knowledge. However, we have also identified some limitations in using GPT-4V
for recommendations, including a tendency to provide similar responses when
given similar inputs. This report concludes with an in-depth discussion of the
challenges and research opportunities associated with utilizing GPT-4V in
recommendation scenarios. Our objective is to explore the potential of
extending LMMs from vision and language tasks to recommendation tasks. We hope
to inspire further research into next-generation multimodal generative
recommendation models, which can enhance user experiences by offering greater
diversity and interactivity. All images and prompts used in this report will be
accessible at https://github.com/PALIN2018/Evaluate_GPT-4V_Rec. | [
0.0159897786,
0.0274125226,
-0.0035857901,
0.0110700028,
-0.0327272117,
-0.0090078013,
0.0528062098,
0.0127838654,
0.0349988714,
-0.0426715277,
-0.0746322125,
-0.013928039,
-0.0108713889,
0.05576884,
0.0069823219,
-0.0605073832,
0.0062705902,
0.0050334833,
-0.0151255792,
-0.0139800981,
0.0029712138,
0.0218045395,
-0.0019028304,
0.0718493536,
0.0102146696,
-0.0032634111,
-0.0159878824,
0.0156459808,
0.022678569,
-0.0282231905,
0.0009541385,
0.025025757,
0.0207267255,
0.0063755144,
0.0000022504,
-0.0036606824,
0.0488823168,
-0.0321217291,
0.0427355915,
-0.0080935797,
0.0318064243,
0.0309841745,
0.0285056904,
-0.0169488918,
-0.0411525406,
-0.0292458199,
0.0685191676,
0.047367353,
0.0126503119,
0.0188255254,
-0.0434017517,
-0.0031233523,
0.0341478921,
-0.0351882465,
0.0637454093,
-0.0341291241,
-0.0147944298,
-0.0413344838,
0.0145966057,
0.0291773248,
-0.0449207276,
-0.0062379828,
0.0283403378,
0.026654264,
0.0457197875,
0.0821659192,
0.0059095575,
-0.042085588,
-0.0316458531,
0.1185781434,
0.0058582248,
0.0196656603,
-0.0459068976,
-0.0074924086,
-0.0099509787,
0.0043388824,
-0.0372603238,
-0.0188004468,
-0.0095247645,
0.0319596268,
-0.0732310936,
0.0282104239,
0.0267358329,
-0.0119060008,
0.0150666917,
0.0333322994,
0.0296578016,
-0.0153707843,
0.0308584627,
0.00622842,
-0.0407203287,
-0.0385886617,
-0.0022180334,
0.0146746859,
-0.0256576743,
-0.0274857972,
-0.0242539514,
0.0306772944,
0.0070072184,
0.0101391897,
0.0728542954,
0.0510820337,
-0.0780246928,
0.034067601,
0.0098468708,
0.0178092383,
-0.0383473188,
0.0018277348,
-0.0376575217,
-0.0156320669,
-0.0446525067,
-0.0035324672,
0.0122121423,
0.0057728137,
-0.063759163,
-0.0769111067,
-0.015953498,
0.0470749512,
0.003610282,
0.0145316077,
-0.0046199071,
0.0484854355,
-0.0144814989,
0.010518699,
-0.0947555974,
0.052895993,
-0.0641896799,
0.0268158838,
0.0129159261,
-0.0342856646,
0.0349918716,
0.046343416,
0.0049905372,
-0.0734444857,
-0.0109587535,
0.0505770706,
-0.0240518395,
-0.0554725081,
-0.0294039454,
-0.0052289232,
-0.0223829355,
-0.0773059726,
0.0056766099,
-0.0288114771,
0.0249838848,
0.0016962269,
0.0062075602,
-0.0136678284,
0.005360648,
0.0139353238,
0.0014600187,
0.0880636498,
0.0182007831,
-0.0161566436,
0.0006418616,
0.0054029925,
-0.0090401275,
0.01219883,
-0.0054176487,
0.0857662335,
0.0250202455,
0.0046030758,
0.0374659523,
0.0242958665,
-0.0210960172,
0.0263912138,
-0.001030618,
0.0043913797,
-0.0268815793,
0.0411878973,
0.0481471531,
0.0436312817,
-0.0421020873,
-0.0147262169,
0.0926041976,
0.0235565938,
0.0209003501,
0.012031558,
0.0405098312,
-0.0071704253,
-0.0458130017,
-0.0052991416,
-0.036650598,
0.0979557931,
-0.0095029948,
-0.0289354175,
0.0520294532,
0.0372062288,
-0.0414018556,
-0.024796864,
0.0242822804,
-0.0355511345,
0.0256880615,
0.0227296688,
0.0365152992,
-0.0134900678,
-0.0545274764,
-0.0464726873,
0.0303162392,
-0.0368231051,
-0.0285252016,
-0.0308450591,
0.1029953063,
0.0929450616,
0.0641249269,
0.0131990667,
0.0083266068,
-0.0028839321,
-0.0244453847,
0.007049988,
0.0254114065,
0.0082200775,
0.0405212231,
-0.0790712461,
-0.0533537753,
-0.0049720407,
-0.0035092754,
0.0594965816,
-0.0053383661,
0.0218962878,
0.002430425,
-0.0262703709,
0.0402976871,
-0.0069228779,
0.0203665532,
-0.0192924738,
0.03312039,
0.0394852161,
0.0194049645,
-0.0137577225,
0.0226527154,
-0.006392729,
0.0112211062,
-0.0198523887,
0.0030655472,
-0.0030910738,
-0.0219309237,
-0.0128658535,
0.0006701101,
-0.0710979924,
0.0214764699,
0.057841856,
0.0025629369,
-0.0280619282,
0.0394577123,
0.0164465979,
-0.0257769246,
-0.0617244765,
-0.0596633665,
0.0409523174,
0.0526310466,
-0.0187369175,
0.074334152,
-0.0019559364,
-0.0115506528,
0.0073105791,
0.0250503924,
0.0260711089,
-0.0336473845,
-0.0307356305,
0.0089926468,
0.0285463594,
-0.01328089,
0.0095481314,
-0.0121921729,
-0.022194976,
-0.0056233532,
-0.101833038,
-0.0044177589,
0.0012782074,
-0.0403062701,
-0.0342208743,
0.0284445826,
0.010856173,
-0.0384036787,
-0.0240679644,
0.0466952398,
-0.0075442614,
0.0369331539,
0.013148943,
0.0109660812,
0.0337310284,
-0.0223757755,
0.012814302,
0.0041766851,
0.064374119,
-0.0025422778,
0.0395251922,
-0.0013648296,
-0.0445783436,
-0.0585866645,
0.0158332177,
-0.017304793,
0.009284989,
0.0393948629,
-0.0453966856,
0.0742932782,
0.0331306458,
-0.0088490536,
0.042012129,
0.0456511974,
-0.0050803823,
-0.0466793813,
0.0207877103,
-0.0173901245,
0.0061244546,
0.0065552299,
0.0052748313,
-0.0255231634,
-0.01440283,
-0.0021053746,
-0.0214454234,
-0.0798121169,
0.0215928108,
0.0358265527,
-0.0219046604,
-0.0455678441,
0.0276373513,
-0.0258782469,
0.060768649,
-0.0205292068,
-0.0549766272,
0.044314906,
-0.0050413362,
-0.0214312393,
-0.0025551245,
0.0002973681,
-0.0419741832,
0.0635089129,
0.019374026,
0.0105265537,
-0.0105870347,
0.0039573018,
-0.016391594,
0.0196445435,
-0.0047901459,
0.0110092973,
0.0530444346,
-0.0228941403,
-0.0002341404,
-0.0130256042,
-0.0280051045,
-0.0107463682,
-0.0223782994,
0.0010462473,
-0.0179541446,
-0.0218816455,
0.0204601586,
-0.0137850586,
-0.0144030498,
0.0047561778,
0.0224315301,
-0.0141202258,
-0.0234450661,
0.0008346433,
0.0441600122,
0.0468631946,
-0.0109598683,
-0.036441043,
-0.0253089089,
0.0149174351,
0.0445936732,
-0.0190638043,
-0.0280153565,
-0.0683694333,
0.038802363,
0.0257829465,
0.0535614751,
-0.018224705,
0.0557862408,
0.037659917,
0.0202326141,
0.0004758533,
0.0513103977,
0.0135275433,
-0.1217904463,
0.0149775892,
0.0085127559,
0.0267488286,
0.0321708024,
0.0072798599,
-0.0972263664,
-0.0471831895,
-0.0237785764,
0.0022335432,
0.023519583,
0.0090988809,
-0.0116671389,
-0.0932038799,
0.0822131932,
-0.0191375334,
-0.0247671939,
-0.0219756458,
0.0043910504,
0.0149883442,
-0.0133982925,
0.0139464345,
0.0051770122,
0.0165504962,
0.0007672803,
-0.0172447376,
0.0495678298,
-0.0461774059,
0.0480728857,
-0.0180412941,
0.0145673789,
0.0894718692,
0.0227297582,
0.0065380991,
-0.0596373528,
-0.0050748177,
-0.015352522,
0.0128458086,
-0.022110628,
0.0575672835,
-0.0099809533,
-0.0005437123,
-0.0193351079,
0.039331831,
-0.0101972548,
-0.032418035,
-0.0029341446,
0.0627719834,
-0.0568621159,
-0.0304177441,
-0.0719755962,
-0.0093423808,
0.0307118967,
0.0240444485,
0.0314214863,
-0.0510218889,
-0.0354088135,
-0.0234589335,
0.0093211187,
-0.0444341265,
-0.0190314855,
-0.0230777729,
0.0425528623,
-0.032373853,
-0.0454395935,
-0.0463302918,
0.0230607297,
0.0111943511,
0.0015140354,
0.0000542532,
-0.0532789268,
0.0154745998,
0.0278327223,
0.0443901569,
0.0116894813,
0.0242536031,
-0.0550611615,
-0.0025252434,
0.0100158164,
-0.0938808843,
0.0128116133,
0.0182930212,
-0.0439307466,
-0.0083334483,
-0.0654497817,
0.0619750619,
0.0205193758,
0.0211130735,
-0.0110890875,
-0.0446505509,
0.0163135845,
0.0265281498,
-0.0012626533,
-0.0147553962,
-0.0078087072,
0.0335552543,
-0.001278347,
0.0115781901,
-0.0378810391,
0.0401583277,
-0.0310895592,
-0.0117582148,
0.0071278359,
-0.0357789323,
0.0113284308,
-0.0224439893,
0.05215431,
-0.036020454,
0.0418112613,
-0.0151204104,
-0.003646876,
0.0186152793,
0.0039541805,
-0.06227253,
0.0014482409,
0.0768487304,
-0.0060934126,
-0.0294450931,
-0.0317651667,
-0.0109792277,
0.0329294987,
-0.0590150245,
-0.026162196,
0.0232829712,
-0.0133900279,
0.0006621057,
0.0197445229,
-0.007071136,
-0.0003029008,
-0.0382579602,
0.0176571552,
0.0089681437,
0.0756994262,
0.0080452412,
-0.0345357023,
-0.003087779,
0.0580411255,
-0.0258824117,
-0.009898182,
-0.0002604739,
0.0417429581,
0.0259166453,
0.0109804627,
-0.0011128469,
-0.0216333624,
0.0085210064,
-0.0514816493,
0.0118682599,
-0.00364552,
-0.0478927977,
0.0592030548,
0.0132177323,
0.016156096,
-0.0025408291,
0.0923940688,
-0.0293587185,
0.0064591118,
-0.0069349916,
-0.0136416927,
-0.0351924784,
-0.0150145479,
0.0020623563,
0.064655602,
-0.0313717537,
0.0194408279,
-0.0214803275,
-0.0324516296,
-0.0219689589,
-0.0123030841,
0.00627976,
-0.0044862302,
0.0389407091,
0.0688254386,
0.0037572621,
-0.0298925918,
-0.0351376794,
-0.0197057109,
-0.0526966676,
-0.0021108293,
-0.0297816973,
-6.79365499e-33,
0.0073961476,
-0.0217309967,
0.0389640182,
-0.0117736151,
-0.003803764,
-0.0468396135,
-0.039376121,
-0.0020135259,
0.0125281261,
0.0018503369,
0.0097501129,
-0.0431616008,
-0.0082209781,
0.040143434,
0.0205563102,
-0.0274161063,
0.0267774556,
0.0230715815,
-0.0295277834,
0.0323060676,
0.0397668853,
0.0113771046,
0.0255552791,
-0.0339448527,
-0.0023112183,
-0.0111960033,
-0.0413297452,
-0.0256460551,
-0.0370686688,
0.0871777609,
-0.0610994659,
0.0678503886,
0.0152963735,
0.0007958403,
-0.006499669,
0.0330605246,
-0.0539626926,
-0.0184873715,
0.0218201764,
-0.0169449374,
-0.1090429127,
-0.0516895093,
0.0130388103,
-0.0127334138,
-0.0234814659,
-0.033813715,
0.0620920621,
-0.0040882463,
-0.0293637104,
0.0073002377,
-0.0350148641,
-0.0021299731,
0.0090185385,
-0.0389671773,
0.0016753335,
0.0820063874,
0.002903223,
0.0692775622,
-0.0394829996,
0.0399487056,
-0.030173732,
-0.0165192503,
0.0082673356,
-0.0323709399,
-0.0215992704,
0.0264362823,
0.0039007373,
-0.084306702,
-0.0460465178,
-0.016493341,
0.0017747369,
0.0673370585,
0.0196741298,
0.0527584665,
0.0322353132,
-0.0260371473,
-0.0189945642,
0.0489591435,
-0.0009225106,
0.011242941,
0.0255731437,
0.0266461223,
0.0023342965,
0.0121070305,
0.0078254659,
-0.0370403826,
-0.0806510001,
-0.0549126044,
0.0670142993,
0.0316574462,
0.0214337986,
0.0179932117,
0.0693250522,
-0.0445869565,
0.0112922881,
-0.0069626719,
-0.0486323126,
0.0364668891,
0.027878385,
-0.006073236,
-0.0356243104,
0.0105072502,
0.0760288313,
-0.0379570201,
-0.0409536622,
0.0170729849,
0.0215557683,
0.0332484208,
-0.0127577102,
-0.0150203621,
-0.0246975347,
-0.0066997935,
-0.0023831991,
0.0264076404,
0.0054014735,
0.0180341415,
-0.0569839627,
0.018394107,
-0.0330162235,
0.0466519818,
-0.0478965007,
-0.0882211402,
0.0014615487,
0.0095665595,
-0.0240925681,
-0.0047737234,
-0.0394365489,
-0.0647068843,
0.0267740116,
-0.0347588919,
-0.0249675456,
0.056592714,
2.894e-7,
-0.0011947437,
0.0279353838,
-0.0234166812,
-0.0211267322,
0.0213979483,
0.0306276456,
-0.0029828704,
0.0520372838,
0.0074146497,
0.0152264694,
0.0434166044,
0.0200429615,
0.0166552197,
-0.0041194684,
-0.027978709,
0.0397113077,
-0.0112734707,
0.0147849806,
-0.0850701332,
-0.015819924,
0.0328091197,
0.0814531595,
0.024556756,
-0.0108166542,
0.0746829733,
0.0113407914,
0.113984473,
-0.0486673154,
-0.0079152836,
-0.0553595498,
0.0460311919,
0.01572036,
-0.0274473876,
0.0007008654,
-0.0083921449,
-0.0349218212,
0.042201791,
0.0213295333,
-0.0077562532,
-0.1060228273,
-0.0197632089,
0.0435807593,
0.0189698916,
-0.0602662377,
0.1121945456,
-0.0014744147,
-0.0318422876,
-0.0057205306,
-0.0635219291,
-0.0008952428,
0.0514660813,
-0.0072479676,
-0.0437496267,
-0.0283211134,
0.0214573313,
-0.0072052851,
-0.0229662135,
-0.0558346473,
0.0286408644,
-0.0151080918,
-0.066217266,
-0.0226969086,
-0.0687442049,
0.0103794988,
0.0241320282,
-0.0578000657,
-0.0386523865,
2.061981706e-34,
0.0153551372,
0.01171441,
0.0238324888,
-0.0299393311,
-0.0024128638,
0.0046025403,
-0.0196474325,
-0.0100896284,
0.0215562992,
-0.0579121113,
-0.0358223952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04196v1 | JPAVE: A Generation and Classification-based Model for Joint Product Attribute Prediction and Value Extraction | 2023-11-07T18:36:16 | 2023-11-07T18:36:16 | Zhongfen Deng, Hao Peng, Tao Zhang, Shuaiqi Liu, Wenting Zhao, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Product attribute value extraction is an important task in e-Commerce which
can help several downstream applications such as product search and
recommendation. Most previous models handle this task using sequence labeling
or question answering method which rely on the sequential position information
of values in the product text and are vulnerable to data discrepancy between
training and testing. This limits their generalization ability to real-world
scenario in which each product can have multiple descriptions across various
shopping platforms with different composition of text and style. They also have
limited zero-shot ability to new values. In this paper, we propose a multi-task
learning model with value generation/classification and attribute prediction
called JPAVE to predict values without the necessity of position information of
values in the text. Furthermore, the copy mechanism in value generator and the
value attention module in value classifier help our model address the data
discrepancy issue by only focusing on the relevant part of input text and
ignoring other information which causes the discrepancy issue such as sentence
structure in the text. Besides, two variants of our model are designed for
open-world and closed-world scenarios. In addition, copy mechanism introduced
in the first variant based on value generation can improve its zero-shot
ability for identifying unseen values. Experimental results on a public dataset
demonstrate the superiority of our model compared with strong baselines and its
generalization ability of predicting new values. | [
0.0223827157,
0.0035561183,
0.0018735018,
0.0192343332,
-0.0381748676,
-0.0134872645,
0.0001778443,
-0.0226990264,
-0.0399159752,
-0.0620556511,
-0.0307609905,
-0.053950768,
-0.007568181,
0.0718614981,
-0.0036113234,
-0.0035037429,
0.0328690484,
0.0399764851,
0.00850897,
0.0066786963,
0.0210027471,
0.0076813963,
0.0247697476,
0.0032335683,
0.0175334681,
-0.0144036449,
-0.0430259705,
-0.0143459858,
0.0342246629,
-0.0156403575,
0.0444291234,
0.0110400589,
-0.0096930843,
-0.0262311623,
0.0000020769,
-0.0470517166,
-0.035662245,
-0.018896237,
-0.0245527923,
-0.0550887883,
0.0437060595,
0.0584006645,
0.0348508395,
0.0093058711,
-0.0431684405,
-0.026395319,
0.0477107465,
0.0894957185,
0.0282047633,
0.0623780675,
-0.0244971439,
-0.0326875597,
0.0169610437,
-0.0205615573,
0.0891221538,
-0.0513321199,
0.0278434046,
-0.0035102507,
0.017363498,
0.0569941103,
0.0239053424,
0.0179490466,
0.0065111686,
0.0460691378,
0.0431670099,
0.0508093946,
-0.0030006424,
-0.0183072966,
-0.0345209464,
0.1186484471,
-0.0495300293,
-0.0349575505,
0.0125318179,
-0.0067747738,
0.0148728006,
-0.0346567445,
0.0039652945,
0.0112119792,
-0.0122367842,
-0.0101885917,
0.0074238605,
0.0449340381,
-0.0242646299,
-0.011214762,
0.022811437,
0.0123077352,
0.0007054393,
-0.0400081314,
-0.0373967215,
0.0174386445,
-0.065246366,
-0.0475077555,
-0.0064871823,
0.0389529541,
0.0030098588,
0.0171533357,
-0.0530145615,
-0.051168859,
0.0025074235,
-0.0673172399,
0.0474710353,
-0.032639578,
-0.048558224,
0.0562550165,
-0.0356374159,
0.0189614259,
0.0217605364,
-0.005372548,
-0.0662524849,
0.01618132,
-0.0636995211,
-0.0248720292,
0.0082295481,
0.0589385927,
-0.0060184458,
-0.0172829144,
-0.0179862585,
-0.023757739,
-0.0049352162,
0.0058627357,
0.0093347663,
0.0377688594,
-0.0476976261,
-0.0143148918,
-0.0415579304,
0.0199769866,
-0.0234073792,
0.0391768292,
-0.0124437399,
-0.0127898939,
0.0104800267,
0.0262201875,
0.0910485536,
-0.0287338421,
0.0056533003,
0.0157740451,
-0.0082591325,
-0.0042474288,
-0.0520122387,
-0.083381854,
-0.0172727648,
-0.0647092313,
0.0148537857,
-0.0209305361,
0.0340739936,
-0.0185218509,
-0.0458446033,
-0.0177208688,
0.0125525454,
0.0247832257,
-0.0072729443,
0.0870912597,
0.047630243,
-0.0504733548,
-0.0237546619,
-0.0359016359,
0.018439576,
-0.0006193168,
-0.0042521753,
0.0917945206,
0.0223032627,
0.0425083488,
0.0122480476,
-0.0020169546,
0.0124638164,
-0.0372355059,
-0.0195667762,
0.0374602042,
0.0405436754,
0.0060717324,
0.0050870287,
0.0184645038,
-0.0052064424,
-0.0048481813,
0.0912186131,
-0.0262788758,
0.0126274778,
0.0108753471,
0.0450337231,
0.0494237244,
-0.0203151759,
-0.0397355556,
0.022722533,
0.0287336428,
-0.015306727,
0.0238429494,
-0.0290029906,
-0.0013758534,
-0.0262577012,
-0.0339132324,
0.0144502809,
-0.0595530644,
0.0185848549,
0.0267940089,
0.0387448557,
0.0095006265,
-0.0672963783,
-0.0042304588,
-0.0101214107,
-0.0275023784,
-0.002035138,
-0.0056639137,
0.0534736812,
0.0835974291,
-0.0061466494,
-0.0222352315,
-0.0051362747,
-0.0424990244,
-0.0038300559,
-0.0015813934,
0.0096795429,
-0.0407520682,
-0.0161216389,
-0.0564318821,
-0.0482986271,
-0.0628324002,
-0.0255359318,
0.0076277019,
-0.0192631464,
0.0214109328,
0.0445961691,
0.0046098446,
0.0088887746,
0.0047365064,
-0.0034733159,
-0.0475494191,
0.045920454,
0.0212972704,
-0.0110966247,
-0.001372637,
0.0241568163,
0.0198765453,
0.0054285936,
-0.047768347,
-0.0413290188,
0.0249280222,
-0.0036652235,
-0.0472964011,
0.0383767635,
-0.0129028698,
0.0291171912,
0.0062732371,
-0.0216004606,
-0.0506429225,
-0.0260096304,
-0.0094213933,
-0.0190539174,
-0.0411489829,
0.0042573535,
-0.0038366981,
0.0334952883,
-0.0385182947,
0.081521675,
0.029001791,
-0.0108258473,
-0.0456830934,
-0.0053033629,
0.0073181964,
-0.0352474973,
-0.0089432998,
-0.0133636184,
0.0075664232,
0.0465259217,
0.0121438941,
-0.0015338842,
-0.01759235,
0.0093016718,
-0.0192361344,
0.0163571928,
0.0157135073,
0.0424676649,
-0.0079905055,
0.0061827567,
0.0155147938,
-0.0223172028,
-0.0791797191,
0.027991252,
-0.0204589907,
-0.0211150516,
0.0564341806,
0.0351449326,
0.0384911001,
0.014658819,
0.0158136897,
0.0089958915,
0.0402708426,
0.0305273011,
0.0068429364,
-0.0711813197,
0.0228284467,
-0.0229828749,
0.0103950147,
0.0440801643,
0.0262658279,
-0.069151476,
-0.0286192,
0.0106136305,
0.0503467135,
0.0276435409,
-0.0246658027,
0.0110025192,
0.0032299848,
-0.0460563786,
0.0203911401,
-0.057440687,
0.0464096107,
0.0392968245,
0.0225518811,
0.0299629383,
0.0688318983,
-0.0258393846,
-0.0269568693,
-0.0453341454,
0.0272809416,
0.0130070131,
-0.0090847407,
-0.0274363644,
0.062820293,
-0.0307698119,
0.01189637,
-0.0521104597,
-0.0105191544,
0.0620641448,
0.0296759102,
0.0035680346,
-0.0628280714,
0.0206584278,
-0.0558164418,
0.0336471274,
-0.0048756781,
0.0342128538,
0.0512800105,
-0.032404013,
-0.0448917001,
0.0612702556,
0.0395043008,
-0.0342804901,
0.01877621,
0.0057592886,
0.020772893,
-0.0390570424,
-0.0319788121,
-0.0386046581,
-0.0564834699,
0.0159213301,
0.0043893643,
-0.0069405334,
0.0101896431,
-0.0460292622,
0.0011502062,
-0.0089529781,
0.0149751054,
-0.0213606451,
-0.018818872,
-0.0021557373,
0.0446646921,
0.0916958228,
-0.0254443716,
-0.0471761674,
-0.0336420424,
-0.0194349438,
0.0254646037,
-0.0199378263,
0.0109054409,
-0.0044593439,
-0.0151772294,
0.040273577,
-0.0553139113,
0.003845175,
0.0378910229,
-0.021552572,
-0.0123508228,
0.0088226767,
0.0715913177,
0.0092254914,
-0.0401200689,
0.0048238439,
0.0214295033,
-0.0225999858,
0.0051943376,
0.0407671183,
-0.0995524824,
-0.0326501764,
-0.036415197,
0.014267534,
0.0258105081,
-0.0195384733,
-0.0202170704,
-0.1380232275,
0.0073341508,
-0.020988686,
-0.0113064945,
-0.0322065428,
-0.0040136445,
-0.0063901441,
-0.0139469998,
0.040517278,
0.0026698078,
-0.0219533052,
0.0042420467,
0.020647442,
0.0198890548,
-0.064975962,
0.0464950018,
0.0165866651,
-0.01767499,
0.0668742508,
0.0213869289,
-0.0095789274,
-0.0252017789,
-0.0516513512,
0.0128534306,
-0.0209636297,
0.0136265736,
0.0506346002,
-0.0372644402,
0.000916088,
0.0125211058,
0.0208612531,
-0.0115759457,
0.0071748169,
0.0093017211,
0.0314083174,
0.0086676423,
-0.0495230034,
0.0058102221,
-0.050245706,
0.0119312536,
0.0522123501,
-0.0113129038,
-0.0706735998,
-0.046823144,
-0.0070359851,
-0.027370289,
-0.0602219254,
-0.0260330662,
0.0212115888,
-0.0113377292,
-0.0131604904,
-0.0880395323,
-0.0307216924,
0.0319543146,
0.0287855566,
0.0190624241,
-0.0181809012,
0.0026641421,
0.0119604142,
-0.0694603398,
-0.0328058489,
-0.0180473551,
0.0510814115,
-0.0020882674,
0.0430081822,
0.0514504611,
-0.1053869352,
-0.0299701262,
-0.0357424319,
-0.0520302095,
-0.0356837325,
-0.0445063561,
0.0530178472,
0.0041409917,
0.0490469374,
-0.0145788044,
-0.0366722383,
0.0195938535,
0.0290256888,
-0.0336331502,
-0.0420390628,
0.022109475,
0.041987557,
0.0090457946,
0.0216969363,
-0.0350671038,
0.0345417149,
0.0057200957,
0.0431677103,
0.0282891914,
-0.0371726602,
0.0310623907,
0.021344034,
0.0173510406,
0.0136179188,
0.0512545928,
-0.0234513935,
0.0313231535,
0.0272966996,
-0.0546435267,
-0.0491983481,
0.0169074126,
0.0185211543,
-0.0029529016,
-0.002880014,
0.0350425355,
0.0162126012,
0.0227670353,
-0.0440969095,
-0.0038391331,
-0.0186826438,
0.0475289412,
0.0010942137,
0.0005386333,
-0.0137601877,
-0.0269157793,
0.0341944955,
0.069591172,
-0.0170371551,
0.024979867,
0.0260332786,
-0.0005664204,
-0.0634303465,
0.0344044492,
0.0127852997,
0.0040298137,
-0.080922164,
-0.0318590775,
0.0018711801,
-0.0127773806,
0.0099707507,
-0.0067497157,
-0.0185552258,
-0.0339789577,
0.066117689,
-0.0322071016,
-0.0279295631,
-0.0093549406,
0.0115563581,
-0.0415498838,
-0.0321498588,
0.1100196317,
0.0339621939,
0.0343451351,
-0.0342838652,
-0.0340240672,
-0.0739373192,
0.0330688357,
-0.006467348,
0.0081735495,
-0.019038396,
-0.0102653047,
-0.0349732414,
-0.041259028,
0.0384942368,
-0.0344481654,
0.0420536287,
0.0290406365,
0.0487612039,
0.0427467972,
0.0272260681,
0.0086602438,
-0.0405267328,
0.0052513489,
0.011968554,
0.0332770944,
-0.0234905072,
-5.843630741e-33,
0.0334707275,
-0.0276869945,
-0.0020599579,
0.0141936531,
0.00034322,
0.0260744207,
-0.0181341898,
-0.0317962021,
0.0266215745,
0.0165721755,
0.030238593,
-0.0364989787,
0.0198089145,
0.0427744724,
0.0480908342,
-0.0491427891,
0.034044262,
0.01034276,
-0.0043522445,
0.0489748344,
0.0578381531,
0.0592851639,
0.1003598124,
-0.0372166522,
0.0302361045,
-0.0268691629,
-0.0178032257,
0.0205186196,
0.0570701435,
0.0732549578,
0.0046668784,
0.068458721,
0.019465033,
-0.0866667628,
0.0017893243,
0.0308526196,
-0.0908787251,
-0.0136834374,
-0.0204711389,
0.0004022938,
-0.0308131613,
0.0049791252,
-0.004866838,
-0.000271749,
0.0587350018,
0.011207982,
0.0700056031,
-0.0373017825,
-0.0221589468,
-0.0767770335,
-0.0789463818,
-0.0040495591,
0.0148922093,
-0.0248148963,
0.0575581342,
0.0733343661,
0.0113690021,
-0.0037709088,
-0.0513837188,
0.0608888343,
-0.0530085713,
-0.0067048171,
0.0206251442,
0.0410725065,
-0.0079141269,
0.0490217805,
0.0015616249,
0.0116787767,
-0.035853073,
0.0558377653,
-0.0231759008,
0.0858088061,
-0.0123834526,
0.0517700501,
0.0504208729,
0.0163266603,
-0.0310870353,
0.0429100618,
0.0468341447,
0.0148981484,
-0.0048132073,
-0.0142765231,
-0.0369856022,
-0.0200984962,
0.0079368139,
0.0361660086,
-0.0604887493,
-0.0252092108,
0.0212877281,
0.0430501401,
-0.0659332946,
0.066380322,
0.0385961346,
-0.0517938472,
-0.0502173342,
0.0064430744,
-0.0204659328,
0.0228189528,
-0.0043689422,
-0.0271847658,
-0.0629533306,
-0.0261736456,
0.0067351325,
-0.0270162411,
-0.0316608027,
0.0234081522,
0.0666918755,
0.0000455117,
-0.0195967201,
-0.000836765,
-0.0002680666,
-0.0235700756,
-0.0227868725,
0.0398907363,
0.0404842235,
0.0131710321,
-0.041153051,
0.0809338242,
0.0254650377,
0.033977285,
-0.0416094176,
-0.0408695452,
0.030770978,
0.0173487943,
-0.0214478076,
-0.0004350484,
-0.0459509119,
-0.0052703624,
-0.008614541,
-0.0633745641,
0.0061242147,
0.0456459709,
2.786e-7,
0.0078628678,
0.0059170765,
-0.0031824347,
0.0117190424,
-0.0009483518,
0.0686751381,
0.0587505177,
0.0505008921,
-0.0204833094,
-0.0304903872,
0.0387495756,
-0.0153952297,
0.0326435193,
-0.0146775655,
-0.0958329365,
-0.0150584746,
-0.0080958735,
-0.001682989,
-0.0356742591,
-0.0086093098,
0.0530790575,
0.0455092825,
0.0166764129,
0.0051999739,
0.0213563591,
0.0309500229,
0.067802377,
0.0417938456,
0.0012372795,
0.0201159511,
0.0339458697,
-0.0029113614,
-0.0414477512,
0.0014026434,
-0.0483371466,
0.0170009881,
0.0431976058,
0.0320701972,
-0.0129880644,
-0.0374453776,
-0.0266127922,
-0.0160808861,
0.005957087,
-0.0174298659,
0.0775939748,
-0.0763102472,
-0.0327490158,
-0.0586792938,
-0.0586573742,
0.0408927277,
-0.0275825448,
0.0033180115,
-0.0001218568,
0.0028076714,
0.0049205674,
-0.0201112088,
-0.0277735535,
-0.0612767823,
-0.0233242009,
-0.0127032539,
-0.0180543754,
-0.0029295529,
-0.0045637451,
0.0248341337,
0.0354604349,
-0.0754146427,
0.01809429,
2.457749991e-34,
0.0340625383,
-0.0035223423,
-0.0102679888,
0.033382535,
-0.0109705636,
-0.0060233963,
-0.0165844634,
-0.0024539204,
0.0289873034,
-0.029508356,
-0.0431992412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04192v1 | JaSPICE: Automatic Evaluation Metric Using Predicate-Argument Structures for Image Captioning Models | 2023-11-07T18:33:34 | 2023-11-07T18:33:34 | Yuiga Wada, Kanta Kaneda, Komei Sugiura | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Image captioning studies heavily rely on automatic evaluation metrics such as
BLEU and METEOR. However, such n-gram-based metrics have been shown to
correlate poorly with human evaluation, leading to the proposal of alternative
metrics such as SPICE for English; however, no equivalent metrics have been
established for other languages. Therefore, in this study, we propose an
automatic evaluation metric called JaSPICE, which evaluates Japanese captions
based on scene graphs. The proposed method generates a scene graph from
dependencies and the predicate-argument structure, and extends the graph using
synonyms. We conducted experiments employing 10 image captioning models trained
on STAIR Captions and PFN-PIC and constructed the Shichimi dataset, which
contains 103,170 human evaluations. The results showed that our metric
outperformed the baseline metrics for the correlation coefficient with the
human evaluation. | [
0.0404290631,
0.0342251286,
0.0129497852,
0.0525954627,
-0.0118198115,
0.0178619511,
-0.0147790844,
0.0298303775,
0.0332806036,
-0.0520760641,
-0.062085066,
0.00959229,
0.0233843084,
0.0451744646,
-0.0078190817,
-0.0853819177,
0.0220535081,
0.0019738565,
0.0014428674,
0.0044028061,
0.0345064737,
-0.0125961443,
-0.0021980982,
0.0281914417,
-0.0464954041,
-0.0021294882,
0.0556247197,
0.0184519775,
0.0410148911,
-0.0442279018,
-0.0346371569,
0.0569786765,
-0.0019460688,
0.0004344879,
0.0000015667,
-0.0173288677,
0.0183176119,
-0.0145226223,
0.0584872328,
0.0173849985,
0.0550179966,
-0.0373871028,
0.0118260654,
-0.0140538532,
-0.0443026386,
-0.030963406,
0.0882192105,
0.0227086172,
0.0918956324,
0.0319315754,
-0.0257412158,
-0.0727693215,
-0.0470190682,
-0.0253226738,
-0.0242785141,
-0.0067749908,
-0.0077393581,
0.0643397346,
-0.0136670582,
-0.0299288481,
-0.0388358794,
0.0356834754,
-0.0320323855,
-0.0311115123,
0.0279105343,
0.0283163004,
-0.021520989,
-0.0128745586,
-0.0026940305,
0.1040625572,
0.0109260511,
0.0233072434,
-0.0503033511,
-0.002993508,
-0.0218858756,
-0.0026148409,
-0.050902281,
0.0009332246,
0.0086304164,
0.0072148261,
-0.0259864703,
0.0614598356,
0.0130638154,
-0.0153443059,
0.0389236696,
0.0294527244,
0.0226472896,
-0.0002199123,
-0.0308268201,
0.0106633874,
-0.0571298935,
-0.0489183478,
0.0305661596,
-0.0154489633,
0.0142854638,
0.0130585385,
-0.0264423471,
-0.0454949811,
0.0104846181,
-0.0605673753,
0.0286178179,
-0.0247877426,
-0.0110907815,
0.0695189163,
0.0095566968,
0.0686470568,
0.0295636021,
0.0209355373,
-0.0704951063,
0.0202967618,
-0.0506783202,
0.0199141186,
-0.0526226163,
0.0225345697,
-0.0277085733,
-0.059664432,
-0.0577058941,
-0.0198285412,
-0.0497716814,
0.0029460292,
0.0426117033,
0.025539808,
0.0026423519,
0.0254260451,
-0.0279504936,
0.0023200756,
-0.0190050211,
-0.0132189887,
-0.0463352092,
0.0206594896,
0.0149520719,
0.0434202068,
0.0490998738,
-0.0028505509,
-0.0003752963,
0.0608381107,
0.0073802536,
-0.0229443051,
0.0397051349,
-0.0181301665,
-0.0623800531,
-0.0232331567,
-0.0177614503,
-0.053232234,
0.0179677177,
-0.004729589,
0.016652815,
-0.0214897506,
0.0183663424,
0.028006589,
-0.0018152141,
0.0973413065,
-0.0090362616,
0.0084798615,
-0.0320190974,
0.0230873022,
-0.0402838327,
0.0376801454,
0.0101165175,
0.0335703939,
0.0792042241,
-0.0071780211,
0.0423341244,
0.0307711568,
-0.0178003944,
0.0178331342,
-0.0259634517,
-0.0166187435,
-0.0100076739,
0.0275371,
0.0292974003,
0.0687783882,
-0.0192274731,
0.0258397255,
0.0426818356,
0.0477281511,
0.0022266302,
0.0116841234,
0.0641529113,
0.0034050241,
0.0140696308,
0.0155942319,
-0.0200703051,
0.04070751,
0.0468861386,
0.0364571884,
0.0131871244,
-0.012688728,
-0.0144290496,
-0.0510365292,
-0.0202762503,
-0.0219999775,
0.0018250588,
-0.0589084066,
0.0177532323,
0.0349573344,
-0.0486189798,
0.052031368,
-0.0022460101,
-0.0692880377,
-0.0092159538,
-0.0101203425,
-0.0182309896,
0.0780017376,
0.0523687303,
0.0272271074,
0.0020628416,
0.0496539623,
0.012900739,
0.0212871339,
0.0182925034,
-0.0012139668,
0.0018920592,
-0.0329531506,
-0.0359408595,
-0.019681884,
0.0035896024,
0.0365592353,
0.0054961359,
0.0214097984,
0.0531099774,
-0.0339621939,
-0.08384303,
0.0129699856,
0.0709463209,
0.003994084,
-0.0303591806,
0.0215567574,
0.0227467846,
0.0273239575,
-0.0411294475,
0.0365354419,
0.0030205816,
-0.021622384,
-0.0050354013,
0.0651782826,
-0.0357065834,
-0.0789143294,
0.0259631015,
-0.0997776538,
-0.0029041637,
-0.0000829144,
-0.0362763964,
-0.0333818011,
0.0058973972,
-0.0554171279,
0.0129799489,
-0.0598707534,
0.0143206883,
-0.0113023818,
0.0229189489,
-0.0037091405,
0.0534002669,
0.0161392521,
0.0024954251,
0.0419989266,
-0.0063586067,
0.0157426018,
-0.0159020722,
-0.0707129166,
0.0017596164,
0.0279002711,
0.0320439488,
0.0161998887,
0.0472983606,
-0.0339260027,
0.0070657553,
-0.138383314,
-0.0394125693,
0.0020602362,
-0.0236897282,
0.0126836784,
-0.0298224501,
-0.0113276299,
-0.0323490053,
-0.0109305121,
0.037023548,
0.0222176332,
0.0113933813,
0.0332545638,
0.0162265636,
-0.0265593007,
-0.0466255359,
-0.0015188857,
0.0261813439,
0.0606440268,
0.039981056,
-0.044841297,
0.0006070945,
0.036690563,
-0.0249033514,
-0.0208696853,
0.0190074593,
-0.0667302087,
0.0013908297,
0.0092316642,
-0.0111296922,
0.0092024552,
0.0007816274,
-0.0021166732,
0.0388059169,
-0.0405609384,
0.0031084968,
-0.0225610454,
0.0050095022,
-0.0642131567,
0.0515583828,
-0.0477386005,
0.0026292901,
0.0357823484,
0.0036013748,
0.0450417139,
-0.0562985875,
-0.0128549542,
-0.0544152372,
-0.003274343,
-0.0342566855,
-0.0004384355,
-0.0215106774,
0.0138366092,
-0.032928247,
-0.0394506641,
0.0541012287,
-0.0719107389,
-0.025898857,
-0.038258601,
0.0260903295,
-0.0383966751,
0.1013966426,
0.0197256245,
0.0395538546,
-0.0051217638,
-0.0073342719,
0.0095652025,
-0.0013205832,
0.0527152494,
-0.0235208869,
0.0292748846,
-0.0379866958,
-0.0074307881,
-0.0066642636,
-0.0131646097,
0.0028423225,
-0.0044053742,
-0.049652528,
-0.0468804054,
-0.0155802397,
-0.0083838794,
0.0308913998,
0.094264403,
-0.0432544388,
0.01034493,
-0.010208725,
0.0119673228,
0.0030219746,
0.0141450204,
0.0451611243,
-0.007868222,
-0.0641426742,
0.0122601204,
0.0525511801,
0.0231348071,
0.0001832643,
0.0147351781,
-0.0485360324,
0.0263384804,
0.0082917288,
0.0319181234,
-0.0059960275,
-0.0137184914,
0.0582309254,
-0.0135750752,
0.0091071939,
0.0878105089,
0.0270393025,
-0.0283631291,
-0.0195319783,
0.0170978419,
0.0190776996,
0.022710843,
-0.0119485501,
-0.0468088463,
-0.048977308,
-0.0273399614,
0.0121043725,
0.035515558,
0.0196117293,
-0.01903327,
-0.1191405058,
0.0469532833,
0.0332944766,
0.0149566233,
-0.0388924852,
-0.0057701734,
-0.0123531632,
-0.0216270722,
-0.0359279066,
-0.0461344011,
-0.0201509502,
0.0125807142,
-0.0107382098,
-0.0027794619,
-0.0417902619,
0.0240527783,
-0.0631058142,
0.0034586356,
0.0002864976,
0.0386179909,
-0.0133503666,
-0.0113470508,
0.0125082061,
0.0088726524,
0.0229026917,
-0.0140725812,
0.0623040088,
-0.0031206009,
-0.049185317,
0.0005661894,
-0.0403418355,
-0.0046339403,
-0.0255345646,
-0.007518027,
0.0167309605,
0.0207021646,
0.0169472825,
-0.0558044538,
0.0626432747,
-0.0079184398,
0.0512709767,
0.067570433,
0.0009378794,
-0.0013160389,
0.0004625907,
0.0161066372,
-0.0715685934,
-0.0028936535,
-0.0035125064,
-0.0663550943,
-0.0262055472,
-0.1161287725,
-0.0437314473,
0.0247740354,
0.026640607,
0.0322828367,
-0.0173539184,
-0.0337676108,
0.0352379344,
-0.0483153462,
0.0311437175,
-0.0080811968,
0.0170224514,
-0.021516392,
0.0015625763,
0.0419995226,
0.0454019792,
-0.0153285479,
0.042400945,
-0.0289206319,
-0.0106214276,
-0.0240068771,
0.0859437436,
0.0165960304,
0.0142772477,
-0.0061630649,
0.001480857,
-0.0049145985,
0.0391117781,
0.0492487699,
0.0051742555,
0.0113030337,
-0.0351891182,
-0.0344258882,
0.0070372238,
-0.0287817437,
0.0261032917,
-0.0133663584,
0.0595762953,
-0.002511014,
-0.0574378334,
0.0010408267,
0.0223980621,
0.04012518,
-0.0621636733,
0.0106776552,
-0.014593753,
-0.0181898363,
-0.0165981129,
-0.0388491228,
-0.0552264899,
0.0267598815,
0.0339787081,
0.0365325697,
-0.0239017755,
0.0029771586,
-0.033626724,
0.0007949413,
0.021849161,
-0.011126494,
0.0495948456,
-0.0269798506,
-0.0166437365,
-0.0024456948,
-0.0503803194,
-0.0296476651,
0.0073981779,
-0.0304641444,
-0.0164262224,
0.0320287794,
-0.0048811864,
-0.0194557775,
-0.0210989062,
0.0867090896,
0.0013916714,
0.0235053264,
-0.0575342998,
0.0163702052,
0.1015446261,
-0.0073521617,
0.054811772,
-0.0206567869,
0.0042167725,
0.0209296085,
0.0356032886,
-0.0161294397,
-0.0365497991,
0.041069597,
0.00602319,
0.0240940303,
0.0155459689,
0.0644310564,
-0.0143017229,
-0.0021605552,
0.0095561827,
-0.054760199,
-0.0147363134,
-0.0056153694,
-0.0433530398,
-0.0052955174,
-0.0019196533,
-0.0065216245,
-0.0218597595,
-0.0762335658,
-0.0136198988,
0.0188224986,
0.0143972095,
0.0509112068,
0.0639247373,
0.0250111111,
0.0380519107,
0.0173795708,
-0.0206426214,
-0.0206030905,
-0.0490412004,
0.0562976301,
-0.0195803512,
-5.11496016e-33,
-0.0673264414,
-0.0607031882,
-0.0189963579,
0.021081252,
-0.0316916108,
0.0066302512,
-0.0410183705,
0.0293003451,
0.0322362557,
0.0210517049,
0.0204082187,
-0.0172326174,
0.0309232809,
0.0042155231,
0.0100699887,
0.0010962549,
0.0135488445,
0.0032462406,
-0.0324334726,
0.000687024,
0.002034069,
-0.0139753027,
0.0297001954,
-0.0448091589,
0.0090691494,
-0.0012993491,
-0.0278575327,
-0.0011614864,
0.0600025468,
0.0669549331,
-0.0090013603,
0.0478776768,
0.0149741787,
0.0008931819,
-0.0218669381,
0.0111877797,
-0.0452755317,
-0.040003404,
0.0685088858,
0.0430063456,
-0.0160517264,
0.0004983074,
-0.0029195393,
-0.0422242023,
-0.0288266595,
0.0019574477,
0.0519007817,
-0.0346849933,
0.025971666,
-0.0035389911,
-0.0291855,
0.0114490371,
-0.0135598229,
-0.0183054041,
0.0223434102,
-0.0042570261,
-0.0008641976,
-0.0076088384,
-0.0268675331,
0.0445691161,
-0.0068994141,
0.0158054773,
0.0781263262,
0.0444528535,
-0.0062916377,
0.0490295254,
0.0185508691,
-0.0345408395,
-0.0100366203,
0.0101538245,
-0.0099628512,
0.0594784692,
0.0727706924,
0.0503791124,
0.0421824269,
0.0072549605,
0.0025820399,
0.0211812574,
-0.0673769042,
0.0563523807,
0.0001239367,
0.0149196442,
-0.0165437311,
-0.0122043351,
-0.0362092257,
-0.031340085,
-0.0519635007,
-0.0580460653,
0.0235620253,
-0.0225189719,
-0.0526981726,
0.0079435129,
0.0321979634,
-0.0501205772,
0.0045019393,
0.0193065144,
-0.0154420007,
0.0712787509,
-0.0281368811,
0.002455658,
0.0046001323,
-0.0359797888,
0.0326260664,
0.0695769489,
0.0512285978,
-0.0059911348,
0.051037699,
0.0187732,
-0.017124217,
0.007692867,
-0.0257952008,
-0.0580212101,
-0.0652109683,
-0.0175487529,
0.0138811721,
0.031529326,
-0.0517667867,
0.0179343354,
0.0039306083,
0.0523820408,
-0.0382236131,
-0.0316957682,
0.0113236802,
0.023452986,
-0.0138898939,
0.0299541615,
-0.0329207182,
-0.0392412655,
0.0195075087,
-0.0461793616,
-0.0446454212,
0.0344872698,
2.373e-7,
0.0343612656,
0.0300829336,
0.0345272198,
0.0261671953,
0.0166198667,
0.0328208357,
-0.045643732,
-0.0061975303,
0.0261124335,
-0.0073910626,
0.0564052314,
-0.0047213743,
0.0228601601,
-0.0194132123,
-0.0596234947,
0.006710852,
-0.0802723765,
-0.0392859615,
-0.0316067748,
-0.0318312794,
0.0718053132,
0.0494053736,
-0.0103160031,
-0.0105354441,
-0.026690891,
-0.1190159693,
0.0748708919,
-0.0273290835,
-0.0188038442,
-0.0070772772,
0.026305655,
0.0234302897,
-0.0391218103,
0.0334528163,
-0.0152016608,
-0.000971561,
0.1134053841,
0.0186996032,
-0.0374327265,
0.0003846515,
-0.0256924201,
0.0283666234,
-0.0154426424,
-0.0536580533,
0.0635530651,
-0.050693512,
-0.008264496,
-0.0426297449,
-0.0150045641,
0.0094205989,
0.0256528985,
-0.0546525307,
-0.0639248267,
0.0289527904,
0.0568095967,
-0.0168868825,
-0.0632404909,
-0.0370848887,
-0.0454740524,
-0.0006847081,
0.0104672201,
-0.0452060997,
-0.0486085005,
-0.0243023988,
-0.0043656467,
-0.021995822,
-0.0097118607,
1.629753926e-34,
0.0692916438,
-0.0337270051,
0.0206162501,
-0.0421604142,
0.036955785,
-0.0040664067,
-0.0398712792,
0.0107118823,
-0.0138087487,
-0.0430624485,
-0.0010893209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04189v1 | SpaDeLeF: A Dataset for Hierarchical Classification of Lexical Functions for Collocations in Spanish | 2023-11-07T18:32:34 | 2023-11-07T18:32:34 | Yevhen Kostiuk, Grigori Sidorov, Olga Kolesnikova | cs.CL | cs.CL | In natural language processing (NLP), lexical function is a concept to
unambiguously represent semantic and syntactic features of words and phrases in
text first crafted in the Meaning-Text Theory. Hierarchical classification of
lexical functions involves organizing these features into a tree-like hierarchy
of categories or labels. This is a challenging task as it requires a good
understanding of the context and the relationships among words and phrases in
text. It also needs large amounts of labeled data to train language models
effectively. In this paper, we present a dataset of most frequent Spanish
verb-noun collocations and sentences where they occur, each collocation is
assigned to one of 37 lexical functions defined as classes for a hierarchical
classification task. Each class represents a relation between the noun and the
verb in a collocation involving their semantic and syntactic features. We
combine the classes in a tree-based structure, and introduce classification
objectives for each level of the structure. The dataset was created by
dependency tree parsing and matching of the phrases in Spanish news. We provide
baselines and data splits for each objective. | [
0.0231516995,
0.0400859714,
-0.0189589374,
0.0496624857,
-0.0501154736,
0.0246514585,
-0.0627004355,
0.0266229231,
0.0032002027,
-0.0591802932,
-0.0404812023,
0.0206774585,
0.0082275476,
-0.0172005873,
-0.0113647804,
-0.0425360501,
0.0428829715,
0.0384502821,
-0.0443329401,
-0.0000027393,
0.0067776614,
0.0326651484,
0.0055482448,
0.0181300733,
-0.046231851,
-0.0202888194,
0.03051145,
-0.0128455795,
0.0016106806,
0.0225923676,
0.040479362,
0.0427385792,
-0.0271274243,
-0.009933209,
0.0000017347,
-0.0569046214,
-0.0399510749,
-0.0301016644,
0.011994971,
-0.0663495809,
0.0483456068,
-0.0435313694,
0.0044645765,
-0.0001524218,
-0.0428473093,
-0.0304071866,
0.026556816,
0.0087460987,
0.019834606,
0.0353371128,
-0.0041931532,
-0.0456455238,
0.0136314845,
-0.0043370598,
-0.0289841704,
0.0045439112,
0.0113532273,
-0.01432472,
-0.0111106904,
0.0000460172,
-0.0141730988,
0.0111713018,
0.0123379929,
-0.0462080464,
-0.0130085405,
-0.029695658,
-0.0462092273,
-0.0218197741,
0.0062049022,
0.0123023167,
-0.061474368,
-0.0755283609,
0.0200741701,
-0.008883113,
-0.048261337,
0.0263707284,
-0.0200655349,
0.0066270232,
-0.0225218423,
0.0267998576,
0.077823475,
-0.0098826969,
0.020398099,
0.0366984606,
0.0161325969,
0.0613355748,
0.0101710251,
-0.0167690087,
0.0628295094,
0.0132174967,
0.0231717136,
-0.0617279932,
0.0032275706,
-0.0159337576,
0.0031641638,
0.0473725088,
-0.0081632109,
-0.0325927027,
0.0230027195,
-0.0844977647,
-0.0315270238,
-0.0190518573,
0.0100345537,
0.0013091366,
0.0358354375,
-0.0107635753,
0.0352718197,
0.0051449472,
-0.0370935984,
-0.0200146157,
-0.0807082728,
-0.0037570365,
-0.0477974974,
0.0359523222,
-0.0226745848,
0.012352773,
-0.0254100226,
0.0049967039,
0.0001079273,
-0.0261471923,
0.000649568,
0.0293236114,
-0.0051041278,
0.03094141,
-0.0141311809,
0.0087979091,
-0.0344829373,
0.0064002024,
-0.003160839,
-0.0673481897,
0.032356143,
0.0349458307,
-0.0087789558,
-0.0342473835,
0.0409241505,
0.0178782921,
0.0066396692,
-0.0472358242,
-0.01982872,
-0.0574157424,
-0.0498417541,
-0.0545501411,
-0.0088211037,
-0.1047211364,
0.002149248,
-0.0160454176,
0.025788052,
0.0057990854,
0.0110608889,
0.0392041169,
-0.011845951,
0.0549570508,
-0.0303510372,
-0.0354287811,
0.0098656397,
0.0031435983,
0.0104417512,
0.0432407819,
0.0187039468,
0.0343627222,
0.071145013,
-0.0098079313,
-0.0280900151,
0.0144895082,
-0.0075874855,
-0.0103487661,
-0.0260421652,
0.0083127795,
-0.0400637016,
0.0378603041,
0.0135858906,
0.0206747148,
0.0017263209,
0.026419038,
0.0154691758,
0.0831188336,
0.0007399496,
-0.0285568759,
0.0613483153,
0.0073003257,
0.0345334187,
-0.0114632314,
0.0005412004,
-0.0991416201,
-0.032339789,
-0.0153794512,
-0.0916511193,
0.041752696,
-0.0178815369,
-0.0533686727,
-0.0363734104,
0.0076570003,
-0.0336003527,
-0.0181323122,
0.050984595,
0.070073843,
0.051994767,
0.008289326,
0.0091652106,
-0.0608695224,
-0.01019774,
-0.0359012857,
0.0192620661,
0.0080601089,
0.0445364453,
-0.0062782643,
-0.0128161432,
0.0334408544,
0.0310899708,
-0.0161272809,
-0.0249119829,
-0.0266822595,
-0.0026444395,
-0.0222968757,
0.0122431461,
0.0406075194,
0.0084424745,
-0.024926208,
-0.0265510678,
-0.0251697823,
-0.0200898293,
-0.0130813345,
-0.0405727737,
0.0418444015,
0.0207346603,
-0.0106522013,
0.0374121591,
0.0132718543,
0.047079403,
0.0440439805,
-0.0017009011,
-0.0290386323,
0.0803978592,
-0.0072279535,
-0.005599631,
0.0318269581,
-0.016518008,
-0.0599284656,
-0.0074723684,
-0.0232267808,
-0.0190577991,
0.0034523029,
-0.0085922191,
-0.0168954339,
-0.0364022665,
-0.0505427159,
0.0813281238,
-0.053066846,
0.0712854564,
-0.0221164208,
0.0195972379,
-0.0383464992,
0.0733287036,
-0.0257279892,
0.0522047766,
-0.0641652793,
-0.0074879243,
0.0159312952,
0.0053126761,
-0.0048269657,
0.0427408144,
-0.0302664042,
-0.020245906,
0.0458367094,
0.0508280545,
-0.0479567423,
0.0155694019,
-0.0659094378,
0.0452944301,
-0.0122616868,
0.0445032679,
0.0488400348,
0.0157730803,
-0.0101354616,
-0.0162408557,
0.0098813903,
0.0362259634,
0.0220641792,
-0.0108319046,
0.0332686305,
-0.0185654275,
-0.0310451649,
-0.0338655077,
0.0099287154,
-0.0305732917,
0.0167494565,
0.0006097083,
-0.0525977761,
0.0025014817,
0.0450059213,
0.018072268,
0.0241392963,
0.032655295,
-0.0502503738,
-0.013190642,
0.0411945283,
0.0255705677,
0.0624819808,
-0.0121787423,
0.053600736,
0.0376167148,
-0.0042732889,
-0.0002094486,
-0.0145799089,
-0.0019552142,
-0.0128752338,
-0.0578497387,
-0.0251829624,
0.0595426708,
0.0869019479,
0.051964175,
-0.0173780117,
0.0249870401,
-0.0322696567,
-0.0153149292,
-0.013434954,
-0.0161675215,
0.0007408097,
-0.0360889398,
0.0227885395,
-0.0257286057,
-0.0469016433,
0.0193776824,
-0.0329657681,
-0.0047808923,
-0.0903515965,
-0.0437784456,
-0.0315770805,
0.0542954765,
0.0527550876,
0.0305260662,
0.0179890338,
-0.0237288382,
0.0084771719,
-0.023266444,
0.017752368,
0.0006054009,
0.0429143347,
-0.0887107998,
-0.0050119883,
0.0254155174,
-0.0647382662,
-0.0153979035,
-0.0106345117,
0.0051668915,
0.0051447921,
0.01304847,
-0.010343682,
0.0223822929,
-0.049414482,
-0.0316883624,
0.0314084925,
0.0053682663,
-0.0312818326,
-0.0194590352,
0.0480060726,
-0.0122475559,
0.0009584444,
-0.0235002227,
0.032061018,
-0.0096220504,
0.0138388034,
-0.0056480751,
0.0239739809,
-0.0270807743,
0.0219693556,
0.0528482981,
-0.0215410907,
-0.0504224561,
-0.0154941492,
-0.0135761071,
-0.0197470225,
0.005281555,
0.0311749391,
0.0686866194,
-0.0109782964,
0.0154965194,
-0.0053805583,
0.0370006599,
0.0278503187,
0.0210069679,
-0.0374360383,
-0.002648459,
0.0313394219,
-0.0144280195,
-0.0189713296,
0.0076001734,
-0.0113989497,
-0.1328000873,
0.0196704455,
-0.0409338623,
0.0019597164,
-0.0251205284,
-0.0254176874,
-0.0002878954,
-0.0555746704,
-0.0460519642,
-0.0180076808,
-0.0355789065,
-0.023751799,
0.0458319113,
-0.0545925461,
-0.0342311747,
0.0194784235,
-0.0388274528,
-0.0242599286,
0.03437379,
0.0498747826,
-0.0018783157,
0.0069016474,
0.0292934943,
-0.0298979469,
-0.0330573656,
-0.0251837522,
0.0138456356,
0.0062256712,
0.0142354527,
-0.0184967238,
0.0312269479,
-0.0325361378,
0.0060018403,
0.0175995044,
0.0793819577,
-0.0302347951,
0.0289287735,
-0.0171253253,
-0.0135401897,
-0.0115616303,
0.024577057,
0.0085534714,
-0.011536384,
0.0269029886,
0.0014789065,
-0.0310649872,
-0.0171986856,
-0.0200175215,
0.0238827188,
-0.094769679,
-0.0525876917,
-0.0586438365,
-0.0395955443,
0.0146485483,
0.0105062425,
0.027498832,
0.0035488969,
-0.0045819483,
-0.015300218,
-0.0358234681,
0.0109092668,
0.0248859413,
0.0237195753,
-0.0142968949,
-0.0097515611,
0.0369210243,
0.0463385135,
-0.0430513062,
0.0093934881,
-0.0509844162,
-0.018646162,
-0.0005763589,
0.0309385359,
0.0158778708,
0.0046043652,
-0.0536945388,
-0.0184495803,
-0.0266373027,
0.0394529402,
-0.0479304977,
0.0038422749,
0.0167461447,
-0.0351843871,
0.0071377885,
0.0397874117,
0.0307186339,
0.0061176368,
-0.0313676,
0.0002243263,
-0.0482419431,
0.0003774416,
0.047042381,
-0.0473384373,
0.0760523155,
-0.0348015837,
-0.0403583273,
-0.0518699512,
-0.005047943,
-0.0163537879,
-0.0370617732,
0.0192490704,
0.0375033654,
0.0482639112,
0.034010604,
-0.0364610143,
0.0008968149,
-0.0181314796,
0.0166822821,
0.0539542437,
0.0056274692,
0.0674497038,
0.0116647417,
-0.0431535468,
0.0541246943,
0.0236005839,
-0.010998603,
-0.0280650407,
0.0040913299,
-0.034752965,
0.0022048135,
-0.0167324618,
-0.0250199735,
-0.0076240604,
0.0243594479,
0.0325137377,
0.0024848399,
-0.039871674,
0.0062989816,
0.077540949,
-0.0797333047,
0.0120566757,
-0.033793848,
-0.0165931713,
-0.0063297139,
0.0055723893,
-0.0043116948,
-0.0377664529,
0.0597344041,
-0.0116888117,
-0.0382871106,
-0.055286698,
0.0318571702,
0.0205126256,
0.0324007794,
0.0389201567,
-0.0188369881,
-0.0092756823,
0.0220350306,
0.0848041251,
0.0002862401,
-0.0023616813,
-0.036879655,
-0.0624417737,
-0.0527141355,
0.018602455,
-0.0306505263,
0.0249649789,
0.0224315599,
0.085929215,
0.1280026436,
0.0079997219,
-0.0203858428,
-0.0707617626,
0.0098427236,
-0.0254426766,
-0.0190705918,
-0.0452789031,
-5.345374685e-33,
-0.0146153094,
-0.0675013736,
0.0058455081,
0.0479053929,
0.0134587213,
0.0268971659,
-0.0039062279,
-0.022689743,
0.0179467909,
0.0381162055,
-0.0097602494,
0.0270493589,
0.0235060956,
0.0143214827,
0.0634753555,
0.0286363699,
0.0031798908,
-0.0225994438,
0.004794836,
-0.046624694,
0.0446052961,
0.0180893205,
0.1157030091,
-0.1019738093,
0.0147233615,
0.0456594862,
-0.0128155695,
0.057155706,
0.0462584831,
0.0528565422,
-0.0263544172,
0.0753198043,
0.0372181386,
-0.0168373324,
0.0208281465,
0.0617343113,
-0.0556684062,
-0.0638710335,
0.0858353376,
0.0337103792,
-0.0225576423,
-0.0389040522,
0.0362634063,
-0.0144994892,
-0.0263306815,
0.027172897,
0.0417570919,
-0.036057137,
0.0001586734,
-0.0120331384,
-0.0741988271,
0.0351464823,
0.023613099,
-0.0122093447,
0.0124946544,
0.0324784853,
-0.0153704304,
-0.0225778706,
-0.0065074661,
0.0225136764,
-0.0159382466,
0.0766705498,
0.0527767241,
0.0049103512,
0.0210740417,
0.0667391568,
0.0029965574,
-0.0561395958,
0.0443321317,
0.0624732524,
0.0154877771,
0.0640781522,
0.0134885684,
0.0745066777,
0.0514484122,
-0.0015129405,
-0.0358090326,
-0.0020998516,
0.0521765724,
0.0135635361,
-0.047307428,
-0.0191616938,
-0.0528470464,
0.006088011,
-0.0067370306,
-0.0192830712,
0.0143857971,
-0.0307553336,
-0.00986664,
-0.0111986427,
0.020260198,
0.048288852,
-0.0278703663,
-0.0194309782,
-0.0413980857,
0.027522197,
-0.0226997174,
0.0185931232,
0.0194396172,
0.0576835871,
-0.0560216382,
-0.0359261073,
-0.0204527359,
0.0177783426,
0.0380279571,
0.0121862702,
0.0767738074,
0.0074802507,
-0.0343476534,
0.0173649509,
-0.0208109096,
-0.0217155591,
-0.0545350052,
0.0701916739,
0.0199538413,
0.0676415414,
-0.0058211298,
0.0528591536,
0.0267395489,
0.0033365311,
-0.0345821828,
-0.0372685604,
-0.0623248555,
0.0302002355,
0.0103875902,
-0.0244097803,
-0.0345113315,
-0.0238229744,
0.0179432146,
-0.0259897541,
0.0112799974,
-0.0311363451,
2.616e-7,
0.0649678335,
0.0446619168,
-0.0055700336,
0.0299249701,
-0.0070725703,
-0.0157250091,
0.0181763899,
0.0515661575,
-0.0583439805,
-0.029364625,
-0.0081160543,
-0.058139313,
0.0332507677,
0.0367483906,
-0.1159994528,
-0.0194281824,
-0.0180148836,
-0.0773640051,
-0.0449737832,
-0.0147926994,
0.0457045995,
0.1192917973,
0.0359170437,
-0.0283892397,
-0.0204544645,
-0.0228227992,
0.0134172868,
-0.0026296894,
-0.0288122837,
0.0255479533,
0.0214297567,
0.0234849509,
0.0062815249,
0.0038027051,
-0.016820183,
0.0369793996,
0.0043181367,
0.0364974476,
-0.0240756106,
0.0427287892,
0.0175250247,
-0.0779208317,
-0.0299255792,
-0.023142634,
0.0340553038,
-0.021179799,
0.0086359391,
-0.0043014744,
0.0584685728,
0.0236967821,
0.0142850066,
-0.033863578,
-0.0399279892,
0.0061117751,
0.0314793848,
-0.0313839614,
-0.0303265583,
-0.0529503934,
0.0069090412,
0.090889968,
-0.020464154,
0.0010722211,
0.0135519383,
0.0163915511,
-0.0083996216,
-0.052346658,
0.0041889399,
2.321178211e-34,
-0.0210416224,
0.0028808317,
-0.0139517579,
-0.0113439215,
0.0663398877,
-0.0118300803,
-0.0175244845,
0.029382078,
-0.0023829804,
-0.0011343671,
0.0381595045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04934v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04934v2 | Prompt Cache: Modular Attention Reuse for Low-Latency Inference | 2023-11-07T18:17:05 | 2024-04-25T15:45:19 | In Gim, Guojun Chen, Seung-seob Lee, Nikhil Sarda, Anurag Khandelwal, Lin Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present Prompt Cache, an approach for accelerating inference for large
language models (LLM) by reusing attention states across different LLM prompts.
Many input prompts have overlapping text segments, such as system messages,
prompt templates, and documents provided for context. Our key insight is that
by precomputing and storing the attention states of these frequently occurring
text segments on the inference server, we can efficiently reuse them when these
segments appear in user prompts. Prompt Cache employs a schema to explicitly
define such reusable text segments, called prompt modules. The schema ensures
positional accuracy during attention state reuse and provides users with an
interface to access cached states in their prompt. Using a prototype
implementation, we evaluate Prompt Cache across several LLMs. We show that
Prompt Cache significantly reduce latency in time-to-first-token, especially
for longer prompts such as document-based question answering and
recommendations. The improvements range from 8x for GPU-based inference to 60x
for CPU-based inference, all while maintaining output accuracy and without the
need for model parameter modifications. | [
0.0322511904,
0.0295021795,
-0.01327659,
0.0240448155,
-0.0331257135,
0.0043628141,
0.0202545039,
-0.0135546951,
0.0322150886,
-0.0402823724,
-0.0226278994,
-0.0293115731,
0.0124046449,
0.0127107436,
0.0162601359,
-0.0561412275,
0.0715954229,
-0.0440247506,
0.0130219152,
-0.0083161034,
0.0146767525,
0.0009633995,
0.0094083305,
0.0441502631,
0.0039783721,
-0.0453364849,
-0.0439387634,
0.0150371753,
0.0002630875,
-0.0173193607,
-0.0008315581,
0.0411749631,
-0.0007309387,
0.0338435657,
0.0000021685,
-0.0246959273,
0.0084935818,
-0.0254164729,
-0.0538484715,
0.034413062,
0.0293625835,
0.0529200397,
0.0063184649,
0.0149177006,
-0.0137687679,
0.0220721606,
0.0623392165,
-0.0267029144,
0.0241621491,
0.0418813154,
-0.0022561734,
0.033344347,
-0.008916242,
-0.0359716043,
0.0221957378,
-0.0502200276,
-0.0066069113,
-0.0562397838,
0.027757505,
0.0109249549,
-0.0172679368,
0.0599070154,
0.063182354,
-0.0045693568,
-0.003834822,
0.0590742901,
0.0084487852,
-0.0039601983,
-0.0440011956,
0.0334911197,
-0.021205591,
-0.0350459889,
0.0054719686,
-0.0149574261,
0.0015001161,
-0.0143829556,
-0.0448666029,
0.0208116286,
-0.0383546576,
-0.014459285,
0.0484318957,
-0.0084162997,
0.0176064409,
-0.0006392385,
-0.0268119834,
0.0636491776,
0.0464267731,
-0.011897482,
-0.0395671241,
-0.0066746362,
-0.0157114305,
-0.0850024745,
0.0165441707,
0.0385099798,
-0.058882039,
0.018622404,
-0.0769594312,
-0.0165018104,
0.0304386001,
-0.0008930538,
0.0390523635,
0.065909259,
-0.0453273207,
0.0654242709,
-0.0065971669,
0.041482605,
-0.0405472331,
-0.006674883,
-0.0462922528,
0.0035598855,
-0.0005928613,
-0.014327541,
-0.0513820685,
0.016807219,
-0.0264181532,
-0.0442481935,
-0.0143841123,
0.0674092844,
0.0105395159,
-0.0115873832,
-0.0009593754,
0.0229900982,
-0.0223608688,
0.0068773953,
-0.0230652783,
0.0572713092,
-0.0649156943,
-0.0063069947,
0.020810863,
-0.0907342508,
-0.0293807499,
0.0165404864,
0.008449899,
-0.0231541656,
-0.0063865785,
0.0386850797,
-0.0096490914,
-0.0342282541,
-0.0079622185,
-0.0263621546,
0.0026840169,
-0.0532346182,
0.0035324683,
-0.067187354,
0.050662145,
0.0448024273,
-0.0229062047,
0.0079186633,
-0.008347895,
0.0606061853,
-0.0153748225,
0.0269605406,
0.0087170675,
0.0151885664,
0.008893773,
-0.0020245237,
-0.0121694785,
0.0520161055,
0.0210833438,
0.0554144196,
0.0338021331,
-0.0016130132,
-0.0071135135,
0.0338245556,
0.0360658653,
-0.0082957381,
-0.0034837569,
0.0260754842,
0.0209195949,
0.0084763849,
0.0341263339,
0.0360832475,
-0.0264781341,
-0.0195783786,
0.0550287589,
0.0735118613,
-0.024596978,
-0.0224638339,
0.0381851532,
0.0039285845,
-0.0031832792,
0.0031258948,
-0.0779382586,
0.0675349161,
-0.0171769261,
0.0229395516,
0.0685315877,
0.0235067606,
-0.0236115959,
-0.0161127578,
-0.0067955963,
-0.0033794327,
-0.0178464409,
0.0543590114,
0.0201647393,
-0.0139803328,
-0.0286484417,
0.0835080892,
0.0312562436,
-0.0384939909,
-0.0285314023,
-0.0483461693,
0.0556630902,
0.1117714643,
0.0245835371,
-0.0115490938,
-0.0221255571,
0.017714845,
0.0555125475,
0.0277197342,
0.0452657342,
0.0135037014,
0.0109480843,
-0.0122472597,
0.0080574034,
-0.0032116477,
0.0010399238,
0.045633439,
0.0637857914,
0.0020294995,
0.0065142652,
0.0088922307,
0.0052254386,
0.008277596,
-0.0076656817,
-0.0219649207,
-0.0307550449,
0.0169015229,
0.0188633129,
-0.0213610213,
0.0213677101,
0.0253562145,
0.0207083765,
-0.021809971,
0.0228064638,
-0.0047436641,
-0.0855870992,
-0.0251929127,
0.0082162134,
0.0204219613,
-0.0200908799,
0.0136103109,
-0.0232710578,
-0.0264424346,
0.001530204,
-0.0531657487,
0.0567781217,
-0.02637388,
0.0230417904,
0.0269583128,
0.0208381098,
-0.0069867102,
0.0563721918,
-0.0393643789,
0.0336850435,
0.0746422932,
0.0381562188,
-0.0084565878,
-0.0421851538,
-0.0073699523,
-0.0103032626,
-0.0187613815,
-0.0195490792,
0.0155859534,
-0.0098521952,
-0.0334549397,
-0.0129390312,
-0.1137778834,
0.0167727061,
-0.0335765518,
0.0253438409,
0.0215298869,
0.0418836474,
-0.0059438325,
-0.0405294001,
0.006403469,
0.000329523,
0.0025016738,
0.0673469082,
-0.0117931301,
-0.0146707911,
0.0030951032,
-0.032797765,
-0.023453705,
-0.0119205127,
0.0580855943,
-0.0206852816,
-0.0564736277,
-0.0538696609,
-0.0094182948,
-0.0108400341,
0.0405602306,
-0.0219790321,
-0.0154756885,
0.0165570211,
-0.0081319632,
0.078538008,
0.0888128206,
0.0121127795,
-0.0033039718,
0.0385550782,
-0.0221064501,
-0.0706452727,
0.0349475853,
0.0054465597,
-0.0136738243,
-0.0030755019,
-0.0181378499,
0.0150666768,
0.0723992661,
-0.0057968195,
0.0024856338,
-0.0327692591,
0.0006676411,
0.002253064,
-0.0140213072,
-0.0378126055,
-0.0134857316,
-0.045835156,
0.0245611668,
-0.0319164768,
-0.0810509026,
0.0748088211,
-0.050247509,
-0.0182871521,
-0.0157183688,
0.0069858832,
-0.0024851516,
0.0628248602,
0.0181524251,
0.0037467917,
-0.0267925337,
-0.0392279625,
-0.0261853971,
0.02543718,
-0.0031934641,
-0.0452503599,
0.0474414304,
-0.0229177848,
0.0122340554,
-0.0325080976,
-0.032385271,
-0.0482020117,
-0.012921365,
-0.0540295206,
-0.010740621,
0.0110701816,
-0.0218936484,
-0.0169163495,
0.0089188358,
0.0263311584,
0.0754216537,
-0.0542765856,
0.0116857532,
-0.0312075969,
0.0060306541,
0.068346329,
0.0030373267,
-0.0045306776,
-0.0531022325,
-0.0001221485,
0.0841837972,
0.0379955657,
-0.0129758809,
-0.031727463,
-0.0309705138,
0.0483305566,
-0.0286404099,
0.0010863091,
0.0578166284,
0.0361929424,
-0.1019751504,
-0.0205511097,
0.1068556309,
0.0170482732,
-0.0747328177,
-0.012937068,
-0.0045556868,
0.0365560614,
0.0360717364,
0.0498601459,
-0.0805000514,
-0.056609299,
0.0359932743,
0.0099455295,
-0.0081475182,
0.0015650128,
-0.0210914314,
-0.0808827728,
0.0025205526,
-0.0240183827,
-0.0395649299,
-0.0124036828,
-0.0385783464,
-0.0061349692,
0.0716126785,
0.0022869464,
0.0350571722,
-0.0151470611,
-0.0083507309,
-0.0162449628,
-0.0171701033,
0.012641334,
0.0377945118,
-0.0099534066,
0.0310099795,
0.0406285226,
-0.0109391995,
0.0301322304,
-0.0722364634,
0.0247303098,
-0.038669575,
0.0111121098,
-0.0182845667,
0.0142985685,
-0.0401706435,
0.0015018632,
-0.0339161903,
0.0166626777,
-0.0128822895,
-0.0188816246,
0.0006317288,
0.0707262084,
-0.0349163897,
-0.0022405251,
-0.0296565332,
-0.011574381,
0.0222046226,
0.0646259189,
0.0553243384,
-0.0503839105,
-0.0520076714,
-0.0143495528,
-0.0419475622,
-0.0309844464,
0.0157500487,
-0.0192483459,
0.0041065449,
-0.0222915597,
-0.0124661606,
-0.017863201,
0.0123464707,
0.0238524731,
-0.0111115593,
0.0126012294,
-0.0147471121,
-0.0142074414,
-0.0455919541,
0.0580916442,
-0.054406248,
0.0216583535,
-0.0686530024,
-0.0052626701,
-0.0073665772,
-0.01651478,
-0.0154398987,
0.0416764505,
-0.0993062034,
-0.0463441014,
0.0108380131,
0.0492046066,
0.0192628503,
0.0371517465,
-0.0297208503,
-0.0479667559,
0.0154590439,
0.0172943342,
-0.0695460662,
0.0326925144,
-0.0025687309,
0.0174164865,
0.0097480873,
0.0360888019,
-0.062301483,
-0.0072991601,
0.0085805599,
0.0151514495,
0.0149563057,
-0.0627583042,
-0.0189835597,
0.0162445586,
0.0434193574,
0.0073158145,
0.0081846537,
0.000521116,
0.0527229719,
0.0104816873,
-0.0022867767,
-0.0103996005,
0.0011993392,
-0.0147123029,
-0.0303238183,
0.009687175,
-0.0083873514,
0.0401036665,
-0.0161828268,
-0.0418612882,
-0.0086068762,
-0.0155400448,
0.0132294623,
0.0336555913,
-0.0195958372,
-0.0432474129,
-0.0094463071,
-0.0003543088,
0.0485398024,
-0.0533940718,
0.0680586249,
0.0340773463,
-0.0304953828,
-0.0300503988,
0.0369538181,
-0.0772986785,
-0.0692339391,
0.010896679,
0.0102627538,
0.0280287433,
-0.0081701837,
0.0254758578,
-0.013322481,
-0.0055557135,
-0.0287046116,
0.0301251803,
0.0229435973,
-0.0662554204,
0.0291145854,
0.0266616475,
0.0049667326,
0.0097199632,
0.0448259935,
-0.0166383274,
0.0119051654,
0.0028048081,
-0.0304274987,
-0.0236965716,
-0.0274207592,
-0.0414991938,
0.0160091072,
-0.0434156768,
-0.0195300505,
-0.0340066776,
-0.0417066179,
0.0072017028,
0.0196866523,
-0.0386246555,
-0.012916333,
0.0364085324,
0.0583683886,
0.0279419273,
-0.0628418326,
-0.0169528127,
0.0768060982,
-0.0191614889,
-0.0242387094,
-0.0131695811,
-6.71976415e-33,
-0.0227734856,
-0.0393360071,
0.0336274989,
-0.0339314342,
-0.0268883128,
0.0313591138,
-0.0507146753,
-0.0211474821,
0.0031531157,
-0.0242351573,
-0.0399950482,
0.0236582886,
0.0285529923,
0.0217954759,
-0.010088806,
-0.0326203443,
0.0400597006,
0.0225574188,
-0.0508353747,
0.047310818,
0.0443178229,
0.0293189269,
0.0339530073,
0.0130669614,
-0.0041502938,
-0.016832009,
0.0766566247,
-0.0008521345,
-0.028063897,
0.0368438251,
-0.0237722229,
0.0462862067,
0.0101533337,
-0.0537382849,
-0.0127545074,
0.0637255237,
-0.0565159842,
-0.0438388214,
0.0438746475,
0.0038466665,
-0.0603147447,
-0.0459709615,
0.0038609989,
0.0357534364,
0.0326349847,
-0.0212981701,
0.0042945496,
0.0061345249,
-0.0519977771,
0.0053781508,
-0.0478086211,
-0.0003569529,
0.023978902,
0.0012405198,
-0.0010955109,
0.0786790624,
-0.0040535871,
0.0349337421,
-0.0374049284,
-0.0089092031,
0.0173401963,
0.0667203441,
0.0778981,
0.0384332426,
0.0235024113,
0.0503952652,
0.0300384853,
-0.0007612771,
-0.0422271304,
0.0126060825,
0.0304512102,
0.0060244091,
0.0143294474,
-0.0294331722,
0.0157447588,
-0.0062691453,
-0.0253877956,
-0.0110002384,
0.0567498431,
0.0485863797,
0.0589666888,
-0.002704232,
-0.0206392482,
-0.0280217919,
-0.0352926441,
0.023976272,
-0.0363294892,
-0.0174110755,
0.0603392646,
0.0313814729,
-0.0128118945,
-0.0198899303,
0.0640011951,
0.0035544774,
-0.0042292429,
0.0127443727,
0.0455560796,
0.0115443477,
-0.0005210034,
0.0564033538,
-0.0464364961,
0.009327773,
0.0085730962,
-0.0222449396,
0.0136787659,
0.0185458083,
-0.0009945941,
0.0300207548,
-0.071895659,
0.0136781652,
-0.0499299131,
0.011738997,
-0.0232224837,
0.0023610843,
0.0887257084,
0.0054479833,
-0.0035130009,
0.0610256568,
-0.0195335075,
-0.0254540965,
-0.0497017317,
-0.0414660759,
0.0112226438,
0.0142801516,
-0.0342797711,
0.0157756135,
-0.0764370412,
0.0642524883,
-0.0190915186,
-0.0629107431,
-0.01305239,
0.0586403273,
2.871e-7,
0.0177569035,
0.0116949435,
0.0269187111,
0.0388939008,
0.0244372915,
-0.0131576471,
0.0292004514,
0.0194778237,
0.0429686643,
-0.0157675985,
-0.032388106,
0.0322717577,
0.0370046496,
0.0123244757,
-0.1171574816,
0.0153586417,
-0.0895722732,
0.021369338,
-0.0379678458,
-0.0402013995,
0.0132713364,
0.0796585307,
0.0018731453,
0.0095637571,
0.0468771532,
0.0038017666,
0.0241216458,
-0.0095051955,
-0.006570145,
-0.0184346326,
0.059816204,
0.0075678788,
0.0055938689,
0.0128599294,
0.0039898138,
-0.0212742444,
-0.0416074283,
0.0519461296,
0.0041993507,
-0.0449278727,
-0.0361951105,
-0.0545795485,
0.0026753533,
-0.0663889199,
0.0754546002,
-0.0234687123,
0.0208339952,
-0.0736568943,
0.0074144886,
-0.0236350354,
-0.0095800301,
0.0170818064,
0.0045575025,
0.019327933,
0.0115597732,
-0.0212327968,
-0.0170398634,
-0.0801727474,
-0.0471996926,
-0.0192797296,
-0.047660701,
-0.0625215471,
-0.1013805121,
-0.0115266368,
0.0207155086,
-0.0775376707,
-0.0273488294,
2.882439111e-34,
0.027722761,
-0.011045591,
0.0260803234,
0.0671594143,
0.0177874025,
-0.0244799275,
0.0179605801,
0.0105160018,
0.0424473286,
-0.092895709,
-0.0525452718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04177v1 | Enhancing LLM Intelligence with ARM-RAG: Auxiliary Rationale Memory for Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2023-11-07T18:03:23 | 2023-11-07T18:03:23 | Eric Melz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are smart but forgetful. Recent studies, (e.g.,
(Bubeck et al., 2023)) on modern LLMs have shown that they are capable of
performing amazing tasks typically necessitating human-level intelligence.
However, unlike humans, frozen LLMs do not improve over time; they neither
acquire new knowledge nor learn from their successes or failures. Some
approaches to improving the intelligence of LLMs include fine-tuning models
based on problem-solving performance (Zelikman et al., 2022), and building
bigger and more sophisticated models (Bubeck et al., 2023). However, these
methods have the drawback of requiring substantial data and computational
resources to retrain existing models. In this paper, we explore the use of
Retrieval Augmented Generation, also known as RAG (Lewis et al., 2021) to
improve problem-solving performance. We propose ARM-RAG (Auxiliary Rationale
Memory for Retrieval Augmented Generation), a system that learns from its
successes without incurring high training costs. We demonstrate that the
storage and subsequent retrieval of reasoning chains have a positive influence
on performance in grade-school math problems. | [
0.0122859003,
0.0654404461,
-0.0115868384,
0.0147446487,
-0.0296566468,
0.0040692016,
0.0101417797,
-0.0085766464,
0.0075027458,
-0.0423046686,
-0.0154877976,
-0.0094996914,
-0.0313121043,
-0.0006769174,
0.0227643531,
-0.0329242535,
0.0515074693,
-0.0550989285,
0.0474206917,
-0.0130841685,
-0.0474564955,
-0.0157599635,
-0.0325334445,
-0.0057724938,
-0.0193669777,
-0.0102227814,
-0.0001675232,
-0.0143289734,
0.0012141296,
-0.0395831354,
-0.0027470617,
0.0288810935,
0.0260318071,
-0.001133338,
0.0000023913,
-0.0588360876,
-0.0130558433,
-0.0272692721,
-0.0559841543,
0.0086909886,
0.006312645,
0.0524319559,
-0.011821311,
0.0351465121,
-0.050919354,
0.0013124262,
0.0102221714,
0.0358043201,
0.0418718271,
0.0613282211,
0.0054193698,
-0.0284912512,
0.0542787462,
-0.0072376328,
0.0638162643,
-0.050848145,
0.0042270161,
0.0645044819,
0.0198871065,
0.0153397275,
-0.0098390579,
0.0350230187,
0.056848865,
-0.0070312028,
0.0041954475,
0.029565746,
-0.0019538805,
0.0145066045,
0.0026175776,
0.030124208,
0.0029606,
-0.0327914171,
-0.019643411,
0.0226136949,
0.0285122469,
0.0196498241,
-0.1030312702,
0.0382531546,
0.0130325668,
0.0076695951,
0.0109772254,
-0.0289109182,
0.0395274833,
0.0137716504,
-0.0525543913,
0.0545254126,
0.0072326171,
-0.0344731733,
0.0148320366,
-0.0128355771,
-0.0481815487,
-0.0234361216,
0.0151937241,
0.0664637908,
0.0047282642,
0.0214408059,
-0.0166099891,
-0.0402104594,
-0.0096364515,
0.0157121122,
0.0358143896,
0.0481917374,
0.0191357657,
0.0131262243,
-0.0599929839,
0.0584754944,
-0.0137829818,
0.0457527153,
-0.0324611887,
0.0139392195,
-0.065487124,
-0.0288227238,
-0.0452897176,
0.073495388,
0.000256592,
0.0118715167,
-0.043486651,
0.0161964484,
-0.0059352163,
0.0038702723,
-0.0049762502,
0.041146677,
-0.0058280756,
-0.03379298,
-0.0581660531,
0.0104115857,
-0.0393205732,
0.0232655965,
0.0543763153,
-0.0014183567,
-0.0375556722,
-0.0040273019,
0.0109343845,
-0.0188790374,
0.0469236486,
0.0615476184,
-0.0375705659,
-0.0217342675,
-0.0701884776,
-0.0389279798,
0.0354696251,
-0.0921687186,
0.0283611864,
-0.068532452,
0.0130317444,
0.0187034719,
-0.0112097394,
-0.0549414456,
0.0111217387,
0.0253855363,
-0.017483186,
0.0224052612,
0.0199420396,
-0.0136787482,
0.0251648277,
0.0210808534,
-0.0041785277,
0.0324470103,
0.0639837682,
0.0029159717,
0.0216602553,
-0.0263445005,
0.0107954657,
0.0015911938,
0.0206977557,
-0.0210536532,
-0.0301189777,
-0.010009869,
-0.0032822173,
0.0338403434,
-0.0171426088,
0.0412248559,
-0.0229227077,
0.0129429018,
0.0377170555,
0.0618783198,
0.0014786642,
0.0385953784,
0.0104181264,
-0.036294952,
0.0183746815,
0.0006916287,
-0.0705036446,
0.0719666705,
-0.0704389811,
0.0335319266,
-0.0140310917,
0.0061825747,
-0.038648814,
-0.0621372946,
-0.0232657026,
0.0016308594,
-0.0021996538,
0.0334549099,
0.0717541277,
-0.0057909526,
-0.0573380589,
0.0390490629,
-0.0144388042,
-0.0666121095,
-0.0093757641,
-0.0645620748,
0.0627258494,
0.0526131131,
0.0555888899,
-0.0277508982,
-0.048612766,
0.0093164481,
-0.0055767824,
-0.0253061708,
0.01513437,
-0.0126448581,
-0.0153679652,
-0.059923552,
-0.0199813172,
-0.0202664454,
0.0108196903,
-0.0038209006,
0.0576451421,
-0.0077430531,
0.0298049077,
-0.0340267681,
-0.033325877,
0.019591853,
-0.0887345299,
-0.0316484831,
-0.0189673062,
-0.0172169264,
0.0108482847,
0.0007265413,
0.0056328876,
0.0522103012,
0.0656374767,
-0.0690594837,
-0.0417530686,
0.0216886643,
-0.0764843076,
-0.0126642743,
0.0338613689,
0.0074549159,
0.0181522481,
0.0135239335,
-0.0147135025,
-0.0571217723,
0.0685005113,
-0.0448949374,
0.0276604947,
-0.0085980901,
0.066182293,
0.0151525307,
-0.0530251004,
-0.0314255096,
0.0775576085,
-0.0160548519,
0.010341539,
0.0012005956,
0.0331204087,
0.0103472052,
-0.0522103533,
0.0434595682,
0.0203198958,
0.000931032,
0.0210172907,
-0.0020608676,
-0.0060231094,
-0.0565164387,
-0.0254087206,
-0.0447838679,
0.0307485014,
0.0041440167,
0.0158401038,
-0.0120933698,
-0.0172361862,
0.0039453418,
0.0125223333,
-0.0266449694,
0.0199943148,
0.0283681601,
-0.0036298947,
0.0001058892,
-0.005818855,
-0.0129126683,
-0.0302483179,
-0.0261560734,
-0.023996694,
0.0364474356,
-0.0111884242,
0.030745877,
-0.0126454877,
0.0482203476,
-0.0401190594,
0.0234584436,
-0.0229154229,
-0.0036145686,
0.0365347825,
-0.0472620763,
0.062602438,
0.103945598,
0.0061492543,
0.0215703659,
0.0405876115,
-0.0302563589,
-0.0704843923,
0.0407022536,
-0.0271529648,
-0.0060208067,
-0.0119923558,
-0.0354613401,
-0.0340307765,
0.0602500923,
-0.0140663218,
-0.0003113518,
-0.0325213261,
0.0542746857,
0.0114766583,
-0.0208028015,
-0.0604218207,
-0.0209268127,
-0.0172870476,
0.0453799739,
-0.0196258128,
-0.0385112166,
0.0476704873,
0.0183085818,
0.0092225717,
-0.0457395464,
0.026597647,
-0.0251506586,
0.0808904842,
-0.0260910485,
-0.0143398196,
-0.0557221435,
0.010184342,
-0.0436040871,
-0.0246070717,
0.0038266508,
-0.0520237572,
0.0509404615,
-0.0560847037,
0.0045193709,
0.0067367102,
-0.0532812104,
-0.0741848499,
0.0473018698,
-0.0248718038,
0.0241423082,
-0.018090209,
-0.0363967866,
-0.0565589145,
-0.0334549174,
0.0866501853,
0.0236119665,
-0.0303337462,
-0.0094031459,
-0.0020241716,
0.0043991953,
0.0291322023,
0.0076120268,
0.0459284894,
-0.0524483696,
0.052773539,
0.0549595095,
0.0810496882,
-0.0466796905,
-0.000018615,
0.0297979396,
0.0261707772,
-0.0091505488,
-0.0175742414,
0.0470485017,
0.020446131,
-0.0743206888,
-0.0320429057,
0.1052370891,
0.0583628826,
0.0121083762,
-0.0000554868,
-0.0372897275,
0.0543174036,
0.0415876396,
0.0264953226,
-0.0162437651,
-0.0482942201,
0.0374861397,
0.0237417929,
-0.02800918,
-0.0234795958,
0.0086213751,
-0.1262609214,
0.0228639022,
0.0392979272,
-0.020882491,
-0.0164713748,
-0.0251189098,
-0.0469236784,
0.021188546,
-0.0139803356,
0.0613004528,
-0.0146170361,
0.0132583613,
0.0260093119,
-0.0052094827,
-0.0147143845,
0.0102935424,
0.004851188,
0.0088315094,
0.0425332189,
0.0130764879,
-0.0124129308,
-0.0931963027,
0.062760964,
0.0078759231,
0.0241154339,
-0.0236538481,
0.0224967804,
0.0127913188,
0.0092197619,
-0.0375872068,
0.0527485684,
-0.0314128846,
-0.0602578372,
0.0299672037,
0.0902904719,
-0.0377705172,
0.0021586318,
-0.0079123238,
-0.0229375903,
-0.0617010482,
0.0657063201,
0.0163400546,
-0.0121981353,
-0.0249020103,
-0.0412008911,
-0.0332442448,
-0.0758705214,
-0.0239131488,
0.0362987258,
0.0082300771,
0.0183127001,
-0.0463696718,
-0.0122327069,
0.0284386203,
0.065936245,
0.0079524275,
-0.023885835,
-0.0157348495,
-0.0060601379,
-0.0638981387,
0.0376576111,
-0.0347304903,
-0.015724346,
-0.0567367561,
0.0074161426,
0.0034035603,
-0.062249016,
-0.0069321077,
0.0260457024,
-0.0468714386,
-0.0465288833,
0.0105795395,
0.0809017718,
0.0314271003,
0.0342943966,
0.0405804366,
-0.0214832686,
0.0347151533,
0.0073145078,
-0.0418022312,
0.0171309579,
0.0239220206,
-0.009719301,
0.0190137308,
0.0081026573,
-0.0327861756,
0.0305272117,
0.0296779368,
0.0658067614,
-0.0294161364,
0.0131654171,
0.0267687775,
0.0431196317,
0.0010778769,
0.0190183725,
-0.0272273012,
-0.0374584682,
0.0382107571,
-0.0407881923,
-0.0020385927,
-0.0240507964,
0.0154047394,
0.0138758318,
-0.0126270978,
0.0273479447,
-0.0533938818,
0.0154721057,
0.0552341081,
0.0395614728,
0.0140152676,
-0.0297735371,
0.0344605371,
0.0254165661,
-0.0138521865,
-0.0311655421,
0.0237215795,
-0.0123183951,
0.0683757439,
-0.0158576369,
0.0897665247,
-0.0037965174,
0.0035615996,
-0.0542535335,
-0.0103075253,
-0.0667222366,
-0.0817817152,
0.0032443884,
0.0158998035,
0.0242491607,
-0.0023053864,
0.034689676,
-0.0468195863,
-0.0003350211,
-0.0234628934,
0.0037649425,
0.0458074734,
-0.0331831947,
0.0070315371,
0.0398433618,
0.0023564145,
-0.0187175255,
0.0338066667,
-0.0249547418,
0.0397422872,
-0.0334212929,
-0.0052655633,
-0.0316047035,
-0.054807324,
0.0130853681,
0.017418772,
0.0057065524,
0.0061278054,
-0.0707697123,
-0.066730842,
-0.0147803146,
0.0213924479,
0.0153991552,
-0.0334499739,
0.0346028432,
0.0535007268,
-0.0468459725,
-0.0252407081,
-0.0022988995,
0.0134545043,
-0.0599244647,
-0.02902174,
-0.0299591366,
-6.443237185e-33,
-0.0165778976,
-0.022006955,
0.0717812553,
-0.0330144837,
-0.0011130893,
-0.0258760322,
-0.0561467372,
0.0350405276,
-0.0248402245,
-0.0147886658,
-0.0100172395,
-0.0064958278,
0.0025470115,
0.0182189588,
0.006406805,
0.0141573409,
0.0080012055,
0.0044204495,
-0.0227503236,
0.0394647866,
0.0667478368,
0.0226534959,
0.0416877158,
-0.029356949,
-0.0170649495,
-0.0080444897,
0.0284722801,
0.038715966,
-0.0500755496,
0.0541817546,
-0.0068729571,
0.0039961888,
0.0210534669,
-0.0471254699,
0.0023096281,
-0.0075084344,
-0.0643431097,
-0.0236952063,
0.0256738551,
-0.0376812071,
-0.0549873374,
-0.0626664534,
0.0304586757,
-0.0035053689,
-0.0404502302,
-0.0223339014,
0.0126787061,
-0.0402982607,
-0.0416995399,
0.0071068346,
-0.0508818962,
-0.0070104813,
-0.0188623127,
-0.0093772877,
-0.0194387846,
0.0234338753,
-0.0234044902,
0.0060131969,
-0.0317327268,
0.0011874913,
0.0113697555,
0.0427963287,
0.0509350188,
0.0001990394,
0.0042330422,
0.0651752576,
0.0142013934,
-0.0002909935,
-0.0159959905,
-0.011591088,
0.0493274368,
0.0695911124,
0.0863457173,
-0.0103864484,
0.0509093516,
-0.020785775,
-0.0924940184,
0.0185251907,
0.010598639,
0.0909485072,
0.0252531487,
0.0094979033,
-0.0324478932,
-0.0073234327,
-0.0594553575,
0.0334938243,
-0.0352285914,
-0.0260538533,
0.0499893017,
0.0099562127,
-0.0083582811,
-0.040347226,
0.0339756198,
0.0149842985,
0.0376274362,
0.0359024145,
-0.0252272729,
0.0089209555,
-0.0361883715,
0.0173356086,
-0.0454414971,
-0.0455087908,
0.0149868578,
0.0131796049,
0.0129371956,
0.0135358041,
0.0351162255,
0.0252250768,
-0.0444513038,
-0.012073149,
-0.0668542385,
0.0326117948,
0.0382402018,
-0.027362382,
0.0256689042,
0.0433734171,
-0.0001493048,
0.0314514376,
-0.0132903755,
-0.0419499241,
-0.0306417756,
-0.0036737388,
-0.0047615343,
0.0213213805,
0.0015762312,
0.0108586354,
-0.0151402447,
0.0148372417,
0.0021163223,
-0.0536160134,
0.0046974001,
0.0275441408,
3.056e-7,
0.0015555896,
0.0374259278,
0.0284849163,
-0.0066117239,
0.0108562075,
0.0380471535,
-0.0364873298,
-0.0482429117,
0.0618330501,
0.0082105659,
-0.0168302078,
0.074484691,
0.0437346473,
0.02842764,
-0.0648284853,
-0.0137684168,
-0.0195808578,
-0.0223357417,
-0.0388234109,
0.0169634726,
0.0501068868,
0.0460260287,
0.0381141491,
-0.0368229784,
0.0013334812,
-0.0613188446,
0.0603777766,
-0.0203087945,
-0.0000552055,
-0.0000711506,
0.0201201513,
0.0290056653,
0.0193491224,
0.0187268071,
-0.0140759237,
0.0129073691,
-0.0490230359,
0.0475009121,
0.0244037695,
-0.036561396,
0.0081085237,
0.0180399772,
-0.0047299885,
-0.0311765317,
0.0724997222,
-0.0492699817,
-0.0362299718,
0.0241616871,
-0.0020580525,
-0.0100472495,
-0.0271435902,
0.0025576511,
0.0202787481,
0.004229099,
0.0011573312,
-0.0089568058,
0.025238527,
-0.0891602114,
-0.0371491574,
0.0395994447,
-0.0513387881,
-0.0521113537,
-0.0436084941,
0.0336784758,
0.0063729431,
-0.0519829541,
-0.0171863455,
3.142495195e-34,
0.03678599,
-0.0000101552,
0.0324184783,
0.0537284501,
0.0504221879,
-0.0067493981,
-0.0204953644,
0.0275865085,
0.0461479314,
-0.0610594228,
-0.0249036141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04166v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04166v2 | Perturbed examples reveal invariances shared by language models | 2023-11-07T17:48:35 | 2024-06-14T18:36:36 | Ruchit Rawal, Mariya Toneva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid growth in natural language processing (NLP) research has led to
numerous new models, outpacing our understanding of how they compare to
established ones. One major reason for this difficulty is saturating
benchmarks, which may not well reflect differences in model performance in the
wild. In this work, we introduce a novel framework to compare two NLP models by
revealing their shared invariance to interpretable input perturbations
targeting a specific linguistic capability. Via experiments on models from the
same and different architecture families, this framework offers insights about
how changes in models (e.g., distillation, size increase) affect linguistic
capabilities. Furthermore, our framework enables evaluation of invariances
between commercial black-box models (e.g., InstructGPT family) and models that
are better understood (e.g., GPT-2). Across experiments, we observe that large
language models share many invariances encoded by models of various sizes,
whereas the invariances by large models are only shared by other large models.
Possessing a wide variety of invariances may be key to the recent successes of
large language models, and our framework can shed light on the types of
invariances retained or emerging in new models. We make the code publicly
available. | [
0.0177991204,
0.0700350553,
-0.0472092144,
0.0458343513,
-0.058766447,
0.0219417792,
-0.0206691753,
0.0239767041,
-0.036203146,
-0.0285813659,
-0.0415911749,
-0.0170048699,
0.0120257828,
0.0481281169,
0.0290374812,
-0.0355172977,
0.0669587404,
-0.0416609645,
-0.0379530527,
0.0072982898,
0.0029766748,
-0.0273088329,
0.0132174725,
0.0423964113,
0.0355706923,
-0.0057176668,
0.0017852742,
0.0053409399,
-0.0169409178,
0.008021228,
-0.0143404054,
0.0593540259,
0.0063745445,
0.0480341762,
0.0000018883,
-0.035358835,
0.0136936624,
-0.0036282048,
-0.0262359437,
0.0558650047,
0.0529000238,
-0.0145147787,
-0.0017543653,
-0.0097884787,
-0.0043425881,
-0.0442644097,
0.0707441717,
0.0321474373,
0.0181182772,
0.0802666321,
0.0004288358,
-0.0216255318,
0.0271654781,
-0.0368039571,
-0.0259278826,
-0.0169096347,
0.0111935185,
-0.0288844164,
-0.0074258745,
0.0141336853,
-0.0526048504,
0.0074544172,
0.014307892,
0.0496492498,
-0.0108021451,
0.0264289379,
-0.0349388048,
-0.0403294377,
0.0003937254,
0.0484140329,
-0.0377943292,
-0.0285775792,
-0.0088291168,
-0.0056585022,
0.0228054952,
0.0410517752,
-0.046649117,
-0.033618819,
0.0324931964,
0.0189961586,
0.0189169198,
-0.0005777691,
0.0436564833,
0.0151616903,
-0.0229764171,
0.0848001689,
0.0343977101,
-0.0147015005,
-0.0420867838,
-0.0106754955,
-0.0549159162,
-0.024232721,
-0.018124545,
-0.033565063,
-0.0122624775,
0.0175143126,
-0.0318201631,
0.0086155636,
0.0087219197,
-0.0305420961,
0.0651763827,
0.0229521226,
-0.0124445325,
0.0237230789,
-0.0306217857,
0.0894234031,
-0.0490920059,
0.0411327854,
-0.0264602639,
0.0035513472,
-0.0713686347,
-0.0382587276,
-0.0134973284,
0.011577202,
-0.0111260535,
-0.0448103957,
-0.0300296545,
0.019905135,
-0.003343683,
-0.021593038,
-0.0032246185,
0.007892644,
-0.0325480439,
0.0045280401,
-0.0193327963,
0.047438398,
-0.0386534333,
-0.0043135849,
0.0074141286,
-0.1038283706,
-0.0263960082,
-0.0090119056,
0.0073529552,
-0.0464543514,
0.0122506004,
0.0770120323,
0.0040781568,
-0.039782647,
0.0007855232,
0.002576333,
-0.0144343218,
-0.0639871508,
0.0033073938,
-0.0484549217,
0.0107071288,
0.0197246093,
0.000574173,
-0.0953652412,
-0.0078728404,
0.0014949118,
-0.0338776335,
0.0723244771,
0.0133470958,
0.0002627409,
-0.0037474302,
-0.0165186841,
-0.0017673447,
0.0944962576,
0.0223762672,
-0.0256246943,
0.0443019308,
-0.0418824442,
0.0040572705,
0.0455351062,
0.0000281819,
0.0044089686,
-0.0406143777,
-0.0297513958,
0.0158624519,
-0.0112697389,
0.0264049135,
0.0360055566,
-0.0462481752,
-0.0254778378,
0.0925646871,
0.0695844069,
0.0285224486,
0.0480696633,
-0.0043637995,
-0.0240306556,
-0.0077283941,
0.0274212137,
-0.0705167204,
-0.0021503072,
-0.0071071456,
0.0004081607,
0.0137738325,
0.0331605375,
-0.0192111228,
-0.0395990349,
-0.0342325792,
0.0058023073,
0.0287492536,
-0.031349875,
0.0608126633,
0.0095636258,
-0.0066214669,
0.0445974655,
0.0146556236,
-0.0416446142,
0.0058695409,
-0.0485767052,
-0.0083308071,
0.037116006,
0.045493681,
-0.0090655871,
0.0253745615,
0.0108496789,
-0.0373119749,
0.041186966,
0.0446002856,
0.0198980439,
0.0436154865,
-0.0298572499,
0.0123333614,
-0.0337796174,
0.0618362837,
0.022976635,
0.0277986545,
-0.01958647,
0.0165902264,
-0.0460091829,
0.006546123,
0.0156179257,
-0.0229163766,
-0.0327553898,
-0.016429726,
-0.0434545241,
0.0441744551,
-0.0162727498,
-0.0390653647,
0.0281718485,
0.0000761056,
-0.03178389,
-0.0242217649,
0.050397031,
-0.0255967788,
-0.0179980546,
0.0185498334,
0.0017739772,
0.0530952029,
0.0405627713,
-0.0215246994,
-0.0357359461,
0.0713505149,
-0.0494592264,
0.0961292759,
-0.0155882072,
0.0328966752,
-0.048429437,
0.0415022373,
-0.0230876226,
0.0517910756,
-0.0146593032,
0.0154914586,
-0.0217059143,
0.0035575624,
0.0011008017,
0.0118787177,
-0.0313353427,
0.0442615487,
0.0021751409,
-0.0158444736,
0.0251047984,
-0.055672653,
-0.021965906,
-0.018987162,
-0.0573037826,
0.0073018759,
-0.0315932967,
0.0292230193,
0.0646120459,
0.0292580742,
0.0068842997,
0.0157861859,
0.0132470131,
-0.0447050259,
0.0118936868,
0.0739448145,
0.0409198478,
-0.007884685,
-0.0462003946,
-0.0541854724,
-0.0629042909,
-0.0071136523,
0.0767454803,
-0.0174630955,
-0.009929033,
-0.0572525561,
0.0075429128,
-0.0045324024,
0.0316404812,
-0.0153819444,
-0.0513588488,
0.0142546939,
0.008753024,
0.0264211614,
0.0812093019,
-0.0018303217,
0.0703490451,
0.0266278032,
0.0007761533,
-0.0352077447,
-0.0212799944,
-0.0266483296,
-0.0250462182,
-0.0434378162,
-0.0272271,
-0.0020497763,
0.0863424018,
-0.0106693143,
-0.0199184734,
-0.0524096042,
0.0151726063,
-0.0282031838,
-0.0299173202,
0.015754696,
-0.0201110858,
-0.0422111079,
0.056095954,
-0.0450798497,
-0.0981009528,
0.0267049521,
-0.0326784849,
-0.0160991568,
-0.0438165031,
-0.002857228,
-0.0368552096,
0.0748956278,
0.0473054424,
0.011253871,
-0.0059579988,
-0.0397425778,
-0.0171360075,
0.0141974362,
0.0432954058,
-0.0263478402,
0.0532396249,
-0.0526257344,
0.0045828917,
0.0146263428,
-0.0391139649,
-0.0152157368,
-0.0167259779,
0.0013740236,
0.0375773981,
0.0407374091,
-0.0595239364,
-0.0273207147,
-0.005699697,
0.0088396007,
0.0510794297,
-0.011104241,
0.0034078304,
-0.0398984626,
-0.0075449389,
0.0330852978,
-0.0109589566,
0.035578467,
-0.0259728432,
0.0004458349,
0.0357904173,
0.0115172509,
0.0044961856,
-0.0588986501,
0.038963858,
0.0032582395,
-0.0426867828,
-0.0400168486,
0.0259824581,
0.0722021237,
-0.0575044416,
-0.0297936145,
0.0860522389,
0.0328181535,
-0.009700574,
0.0669118538,
0.0162077099,
0.0543306135,
0.0624324195,
-0.0059526972,
-0.0301428884,
-0.0407266915,
0.0242213327,
-0.0059951236,
-0.0248533767,
-0.0273709744,
-0.0078507131,
-0.1094187945,
0.0076880795,
0.01923858,
-0.0063742087,
-0.0285510272,
-0.0557527803,
0.0203991383,
-0.0371508487,
0.0066811531,
0.0129067441,
-0.0255431663,
0.013974078,
-0.0002556385,
-0.0271913055,
-0.0731500983,
0.0129067143,
-0.0107966652,
0.0266698301,
0.085724622,
-0.0140869198,
-0.0275697932,
-0.0377191119,
0.0892641842,
-0.0073668812,
0.0261284672,
-0.0048678922,
0.0662877932,
0.0450849608,
-0.0120105911,
-0.0264795739,
0.0369128026,
-0.036821872,
-0.0237831287,
-0.041881714,
0.0261555128,
0.0180965085,
-0.0394632034,
-0.007142012,
-0.0533573702,
-0.0369964205,
0.0645099357,
0.0509893931,
-0.0351176597,
-0.0602446012,
-0.0286027398,
-0.0119818412,
-0.0020896713,
-0.0223803092,
-0.0045198547,
0.0466749631,
-0.0488179103,
-0.0359194167,
0.0014701026,
-0.0277122017,
-0.0039597112,
0.0038695536,
0.0064172684,
0.0176565163,
-0.0116407312,
-0.0121865291,
0.0529088676,
0.0032710286,
-0.0070465626,
-0.0536098666,
-0.0071406364,
0.0312093664,
0.0227968786,
-0.0594230331,
0.0138054052,
-0.107761547,
-0.0988803953,
0.0130817397,
0.0013327227,
0.0304698497,
0.0464765206,
-0.0018795441,
-0.0557259768,
0.00520733,
0.0057934555,
-0.0154199926,
0.0423133187,
0.0239688084,
-0.0455432236,
0.0126694487,
0.0452631488,
0.0066032,
0.0150990197,
0.0195793193,
0.0243052393,
-0.0066581075,
0.0075835558,
0.0224939138,
0.003360756,
0.0485196635,
0.0313079841,
0.0021924311,
-0.0173189547,
-0.011231062,
-0.0073618623,
0.0060233404,
-0.0388720371,
-0.0165282395,
0.0443774089,
0.0030954662,
-0.0210587941,
-0.0054908074,
0.0010181776,
0.0496403947,
-0.0354888551,
0.0213802867,
0.0154461311,
-0.008424121,
0.0123439496,
0.010500107,
-0.0079614082,
0.0471847281,
-0.0412770361,
0.047030285,
-0.0298572183,
0.0415813737,
0.0121895364,
0.0229121316,
-0.0356209762,
0.030810168,
-0.0812266618,
-0.0490107387,
-0.0191860348,
0.0191058628,
0.0229438059,
-0.0248030517,
0.0683721676,
-0.0201919023,
0.0011013331,
-0.0465329327,
0.0027020506,
0.002874813,
-0.0082456879,
0.025519222,
0.025649745,
-0.0148239518,
-0.0116168018,
0.0872440636,
-0.0048478576,
0.0616556741,
-0.0261165276,
0.0114542227,
-0.0125389174,
-0.0360092446,
0.0077898358,
0.0297255293,
-0.0015522084,
0.0475803316,
-0.0381280147,
-0.0564365648,
-0.0123800002,
-0.0173715614,
0.0365189016,
-0.0117837451,
0.0095134322,
0.0619437769,
-0.0341093093,
-0.059812203,
-0.0263007637,
-0.0513264947,
0.0027327905,
-0.0080808904,
0.0022117235,
-6.443221022e-33,
-0.0196434837,
0.008415035,
-0.0341665298,
-0.0343356729,
0.020735126,
-0.0212204587,
-0.015847519,
0.0338743813,
-0.0370081291,
0.0035250012,
-0.0170166176,
0.0119819818,
0.0027767578,
0.0372102894,
0.0387461372,
-0.0324563645,
0.0529166274,
0.010125896,
-0.0493184216,
0.02103878,
0.0312883742,
0.0066017234,
0.0799142942,
-0.0403398462,
0.0229228269,
0.0110190418,
-0.0140688764,
-0.0029819831,
-0.0380361564,
0.062677063,
0.0054802406,
0.0472912788,
0.0512928776,
-0.0720314905,
-0.0475784242,
-0.0100461412,
-0.0267698448,
-0.0275749844,
0.0580545999,
0.0200475287,
-0.0145169329,
-0.0252943188,
0.0527714677,
-0.0202769283,
-0.0221425556,
-0.0554677881,
0.0152467815,
-0.013413663,
0.0059119472,
0.0475165918,
-0.0584234968,
0.0369847082,
-0.0362772867,
0.0105449418,
0.0111020785,
0.0161923133,
-0.0221360475,
0.0256430451,
-0.035730131,
-0.0016181571,
0.0333612412,
0.0853709653,
0.066603519,
0.0303328726,
0.0177315753,
0.0552335493,
0.0116931777,
-0.0153153697,
0.0079477411,
-0.0417048037,
0.042308975,
0.0575917773,
0.0405158103,
0.0253810715,
0.0694417804,
-0.0069824737,
-0.0280732699,
-0.0438182354,
0.0384186469,
0.0392552018,
0.0351776443,
0.0290012676,
-0.0502448194,
-0.0164123848,
-0.0654942468,
-0.0623946153,
-0.0378949679,
-0.0400795229,
0.0533763953,
-0.0039027727,
-0.0022831459,
0.0220707785,
0.0395542346,
-0.0417604074,
-0.0430259705,
0.0089484937,
-0.0285834987,
0.0249470733,
0.0078180525,
0.0157934092,
-0.0262957048,
-0.0487378314,
-0.0022768527,
0.0243631806,
0.0300628655,
-0.020631494,
0.0056454754,
0.0070003248,
-0.0747357532,
0.0013131793,
-0.0335084312,
-0.01135315,
0.0096803978,
0.0154770073,
0.0392143279,
-0.0049136779,
-0.0275198668,
0.0364434458,
0.0287597403,
0.0071600396,
-0.0471114554,
0.0036811715,
0.0100935297,
0.0282025691,
-0.0190704539,
-0.0204373375,
-0.0353685208,
0.0096744308,
0.046884723,
-0.0019994089,
-0.0315333866,
0.020158641,
2.651e-7,
0.0615177825,
0.052655302,
0.0266474765,
-0.004497523,
0.064264223,
0.0281922501,
-0.022446949,
0.0251679216,
0.0056464132,
-0.0224850364,
-0.0288858674,
0.0401998833,
0.0419569016,
-0.0110214362,
-0.0241765548,
-0.0028455844,
-0.074491635,
0.0188171975,
-0.0487126745,
-0.0057782843,
0.0272486843,
0.0889710188,
0.0181399267,
0.0111292657,
-0.0065949131,
-0.0372098163,
0.0512136891,
-0.0706755146,
0.0341305584,
0.0314915031,
-0.0304083116,
0.0226029567,
0.0246328209,
0.037614312,
-0.0114468103,
0.0310830791,
0.0064816759,
0.0718917102,
-0.039977923,
-0.0135470582,
-0.01098477,
0.0143544739,
-0.0195769686,
-0.0907573476,
0.0855915844,
-0.0226771645,
-0.0438909456,
-0.0553981289,
-0.0215481594,
-0.0251385681,
0.0488282777,
-0.0021396286,
-0.0033122576,
0.026420312,
0.0291176364,
0.0117390752,
-0.0360940211,
-0.0555128753,
-0.025352696,
-0.004228998,
-0.0738310218,
-0.0516604036,
-0.0658974946,
0.0004918351,
0.0356091075,
-0.0183586087,
-0.0203630477,
2.658241344e-34,
0.0326702148,
0.0070647434,
0.0580092631,
0.0403995514,
0.0379178561,
-0.0289362855,
0.0002995647,
0.0220078956,
-0.0148914764,
-0.0868952125,
-0.0147284474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04155v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04155v3 | Black-Box Prompt Optimization: Aligning Large Language Models without Model Training | 2023-11-07T17:31:50 | 2024-06-21T06:06:07 | Jiale Cheng, Xiao Liu, Kehan Zheng, Pei Ke, Hongning Wang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive success in various
applications. However, these models are often not well aligned with human
intents, which calls for additional treatments on them; that is, the alignment
problem. To make LLMs better follow user instructions, existing alignment
methods primarily focus on further training them. However, the extra training
of LLMs is usually expensive in terms of GPU computing; even worse, some LLMs
are not accessible for user-demanded training, such as GPTs. In this work, we
take a different perspective -- Black-Box Prompt Optimization (BPO) -- to
perform alignments. The idea is to optimize user prompts to suit LLMs' input
understanding, so as to best realize users' intents without updating LLMs'
parameters. BPO leverages human preferences to optimize prompts, thus making it
superior to LLM (e.g., ChatGPT) as a prompt engineer. Moreover, BPO is
model-agnostic, and the empirical results demonstrate that the BPO-aligned
ChatGPT yields a 22% increase in the win rate against its original version and
10% for GPT-4. Notably, the BPO-aligned LLMs can outperform the same models
aligned by PPO and DPO, and it also brings additional performance gains when
combining BPO with PPO or DPO. Code and datasets are released at
https://github.com/thu-coai/BPO. | [
0.0189652294,
0.0442721583,
-0.0146456454,
0.0306705814,
-0.0503564961,
0.0127577148,
-0.0057544545,
-0.0112023307,
0.0222418625,
0.0144038023,
-0.0392610431,
-0.0516035371,
0.030352883,
0.0355412588,
0.0097298296,
-0.066093415,
0.0559462383,
-0.0274260696,
-0.0010811111,
0.0009756961,
0.0185471214,
0.0143908011,
-0.025793517,
0.0371049605,
0.0025114298,
-0.0521776378,
-0.0484441705,
0.026196776,
0.0107901804,
0.0044432157,
-0.0019806856,
0.0588077717,
-0.0051928633,
0.0756466389,
0.0000020278,
-0.06139943,
-0.0326814689,
-0.0268898699,
-0.0554932654,
0.0260501355,
0.0052336892,
0.0095041245,
-0.0352024734,
0.0291645173,
-0.0272812583,
0.013234783,
0.074695237,
0.0222365856,
0.0518852137,
0.0742289424,
-0.0020789457,
0.0247893035,
0.0276607107,
-0.021058308,
-0.0019959023,
-0.0354151353,
-0.0072859172,
-0.0278387442,
0.0017914035,
0.0010867947,
-0.0083522871,
0.0306217317,
-0.0071268291,
-0.003650469,
-0.0283407271,
0.0310045723,
-0.0078719119,
-0.0258314032,
-0.0496335775,
0.0613868497,
-0.0381802693,
-0.0035648819,
-0.0017438879,
-0.0267990716,
0.0206242036,
-0.0350892954,
-0.0164715517,
-0.0119022382,
-0.0179321393,
0.0049930075,
-0.0078441277,
-0.0226542018,
0.0207730196,
0.0016628077,
0.0043362328,
0.0715211481,
0.0482444838,
-0.0317580067,
0.0012223431,
-0.0127197905,
-0.0115550188,
-0.0711090565,
0.0041294121,
0.0114286076,
-0.075215593,
0.050831344,
-0.0561319478,
-0.0011879732,
0.0067145121,
-0.0199207831,
0.0340439603,
0.095483005,
0.0037742236,
0.0378736742,
0.008206645,
0.0897343904,
-0.028713055,
0.0049780305,
-0.0416895263,
0.0227679443,
-0.0263606664,
-0.0243476834,
-0.0550185479,
-0.0182693359,
-0.0297905505,
-0.0209743772,
-0.0408042818,
0.0784546584,
0.0153930914,
0.0345337875,
0.0269647893,
-0.0073339171,
-0.0349678062,
-0.0317691304,
-0.0099439938,
0.0483219288,
-0.0347361527,
-0.0124262646,
0.0095334072,
-0.0628787726,
-0.0041013206,
0.0205775052,
-0.0116880685,
-0.0363253206,
-0.0214191582,
0.0517666265,
-0.0213042535,
-0.0048747966,
-0.010308913,
-0.014396674,
-0.0275304448,
-0.0378759019,
-0.0533579886,
-0.0481764376,
0.0432503559,
0.0021621932,
-0.0156941041,
-0.0419770628,
-0.0050996551,
0.0190131962,
0.009855506,
0.0673712566,
-0.0255774781,
0.0261460952,
0.0494496524,
-0.0191437937,
-0.0313710682,
0.0731536672,
0.03354517,
0.0498845167,
0.0307542831,
-0.0520613119,
-0.0152892796,
0.092991814,
-0.005059558,
0.0213068798,
0.0072735786,
0.0042801765,
0.0549983159,
0.0751603991,
0.0533811264,
0.0407142676,
0.012573556,
0.0002165138,
0.0778351426,
0.0332836062,
0.0022760825,
-0.0050802641,
0.0329995714,
0.0192263313,
-0.0183378514,
0.0048888526,
-0.0511161052,
-0.0008927825,
-0.0604342967,
0.0614827499,
0.0353649259,
0.0506000109,
-0.0142336991,
-0.0229688268,
0.0061948588,
0.007210318,
-0.011907557,
0.0185700078,
0.0183241107,
-0.0371146165,
-0.0850923359,
0.060578227,
0.0228806697,
-0.0390815996,
-0.0295714103,
-0.0388615765,
0.0143553978,
0.0592041351,
0.0379218124,
-0.0014183993,
-0.0564840659,
-0.00660741,
-0.002577364,
0.0514594913,
0.0614941008,
0.0140919499,
-0.0077473279,
-0.0617938228,
-0.0474659838,
0.0244014189,
-0.0341259316,
0.0425257385,
0.0174290072,
-0.0153696463,
0.0012967228,
0.0096889129,
-0.026862679,
0.0342642255,
-0.0164824929,
-0.0415012054,
-0.02656487,
0.0406796224,
0.0424291752,
0.0089614578,
0.0124369664,
-0.0062109674,
0.0099135442,
-0.0018634549,
0.0245652925,
-0.0063671861,
-0.0579302721,
-0.0178932119,
0.0666508451,
0.0138834994,
-0.0347454175,
0.0240507424,
-0.0462756045,
-0.0453541353,
-0.0390513502,
-0.0212895367,
0.0386724211,
-0.0124226939,
0.0541900881,
-0.0098095592,
-0.0073254663,
-0.0592200756,
0.0443275757,
0.0089229587,
0.0179436374,
0.0460952595,
0.0225583836,
0.0292232763,
-0.0646342337,
-0.0150947208,
0.0222983509,
-0.0036613739,
0.0099373143,
0.0407272168,
0.0153361317,
-0.0485400148,
-0.0355246514,
-0.1140032262,
0.0482865311,
-0.014435011,
0.0246602166,
0.0487102978,
0.0573143549,
-0.0592730939,
-0.020252794,
-0.0395920649,
-0.0205118321,
-0.0094373208,
0.0026784369,
0.0462464467,
-0.0107174003,
-0.044560276,
-0.0373022743,
0.0053450214,
-0.0306964945,
-0.0185583588,
-0.0117563112,
-0.0330630168,
-0.0651911944,
0.0459241867,
-0.0111253411,
0.0289130956,
0.0128579391,
-0.0374216735,
0.0113970647,
0.0254527219,
0.0772381797,
0.0676423684,
0.0327231176,
-0.0113846716,
0.0219972469,
0.0148076406,
-0.0762739778,
0.0269362014,
-0.0306284614,
-0.0583996996,
-0.0158988759,
-0.0392989852,
0.0423976071,
0.095607385,
0.0019192912,
0.0231337287,
-0.0815157965,
-0.0146327456,
0.0153594185,
0.0048336247,
-0.0477884263,
-0.0240810774,
-0.0607271977,
0.0276638754,
-0.0345849767,
-0.0896900147,
0.0611805804,
-0.081518501,
-0.0107565029,
-0.0350803621,
0.0017832039,
-0.0136815337,
0.0492401868,
-0.0099611953,
0.0300013907,
0.011537265,
-0.0435467809,
-0.0595647283,
0.0157869905,
0.0155823268,
-0.0266296435,
0.0268209986,
-0.028425429,
0.0198635552,
-0.0299045872,
-0.046874173,
-0.0473609343,
-0.0412514322,
-0.029828582,
-0.0244670119,
0.0075385766,
-0.0209200308,
-0.0295921918,
0.0270907804,
0.015866518,
0.0527897812,
-0.0268435013,
0.0031270997,
-0.0371303521,
-0.0093659824,
0.0904081762,
0.0002347991,
-0.0288708135,
-0.0326200835,
0.0132947043,
0.0029322396,
0.0438137352,
-0.023775531,
-0.0233889166,
-0.0246458054,
0.0623138919,
-0.0503295511,
-0.0144718308,
0.0403204709,
0.0566702336,
-0.0261161067,
0.0155488616,
0.1311549693,
0.029614253,
-0.0413221084,
-0.0069212825,
-0.0216496047,
0.0762354657,
0.0088993227,
0.041918762,
-0.0695226192,
-0.0419342294,
0.0153220724,
0.0173363965,
-0.0072037177,
0.0117659541,
-0.0390475541,
-0.1374514103,
-0.0099449325,
0.0334431157,
-0.0185595825,
-0.0189650189,
-0.0071966657,
0.0203958638,
-0.0052676355,
0.04633452,
0.0315496624,
0.0037130965,
-0.0001450395,
0.0140292468,
-0.0353870839,
-0.0033986582,
0.0050276252,
-0.0227333289,
0.0630704537,
0.092499502,
-0.0032830001,
0.0235873703,
-0.0382018536,
0.0398610979,
0.0332084894,
0.0062581552,
0.0147482827,
0.0072210385,
-0.0295918379,
-0.0025501009,
-0.0057540135,
0.0342526101,
-0.0432335027,
-0.0015709426,
0.0346528292,
0.0604307912,
-0.0227338187,
0.0341016389,
0.0052564112,
-0.0135453753,
0.0307639185,
0.0686355308,
0.0214242395,
-0.0568486936,
-0.0344714671,
-0.0435772277,
-0.0045383112,
-0.0133399703,
-0.0005470668,
-0.001333004,
-0.0142929545,
-0.0220115129,
-0.029183602,
-0.0349435434,
0.0152179431,
0.0517600589,
0.022434175,
0.0036330204,
-0.0066247727,
-0.0095473956,
-0.0057669077,
0.0470872559,
-0.0481370427,
0.0372087024,
-0.1090324,
-0.0041413205,
-0.020111803,
-0.0392065533,
-0.0097411023,
0.0116379783,
-0.0497470759,
-0.076537095,
-0.0124162324,
0.0390825495,
0.0225227978,
0.0629200041,
-0.0124281319,
-0.046914652,
0.0032058873,
0.038747374,
-0.0152676012,
-0.0090540396,
-0.0116931973,
0.0165503193,
-0.0175298844,
0.0255626868,
-0.0289365817,
-0.0219485331,
0.0191627815,
0.0342826098,
-0.0096790791,
-0.0698028207,
0.0331895947,
0.0497438647,
0.0570594333,
-0.0483600013,
-0.0253645349,
-0.0324178822,
0.0108236428,
-0.0005118846,
-0.0109520499,
-0.0078065693,
-0.0144882184,
0.023526933,
-0.0274596382,
0.0361081436,
-0.0526696183,
-0.035453625,
0.0061208582,
-0.0464132093,
-0.0018073561,
-0.0095495721,
0.00840938,
0.0555148423,
0.0011275255,
-0.0171184018,
0.0569244288,
0.0185440164,
0.0527553298,
-0.009274736,
0.0922046602,
0.0342582986,
0.0116784209,
-0.011251457,
0.0530150123,
-0.0295491237,
-0.0570894033,
-0.0187412798,
0.0204263777,
0.0617021173,
-0.0067391326,
0.0197011549,
-0.0211785063,
-0.0077250609,
-0.0226486549,
0.0214373674,
0.0099625802,
-0.0216629934,
0.0260896944,
0.0223843008,
-0.035926871,
-0.0119714225,
0.0499165654,
-0.0416766666,
0.028902065,
-0.0158171915,
0.0054587023,
-0.0524099059,
-0.0080620833,
0.0224915016,
0.0161362849,
-0.0495739505,
-0.0224624109,
-0.0408273377,
-0.034228608,
-0.0279366169,
0.0272873882,
-0.032645829,
-0.0230781063,
0.0675497726,
0.0414346382,
-0.061501842,
0.0033566363,
-0.0148148555,
0.0099546406,
-0.0146936271,
-0.0305770468,
-0.0437177531,
-5.88207859e-33,
-0.0380929261,
-0.0054072747,
0.0220492128,
-0.009827991,
-0.0344308056,
-0.0089683309,
-0.0114379311,
0.02087765,
-0.0086598061,
-0.03408961,
-0.0452634431,
-0.0332441814,
0.0250208899,
0.0007022402,
0.007447808,
0.0030313449,
0.0380348563,
-0.0042569842,
-0.0744458288,
0.0050645284,
0.016872935,
0.0240871999,
0.0144275082,
-0.0252277516,
0.0186927561,
-0.006167734,
-0.0189684089,
0.0408547297,
0.0182526968,
0.0455109291,
-0.0063550337,
0.0063793361,
-0.0032080254,
-0.0272080619,
-0.0192600545,
0.0671389997,
0.000758491,
-0.0179581307,
0.0532943197,
0.0373225845,
-0.0272248369,
-0.0570393801,
0.0255397782,
-0.0172729325,
-0.0326033868,
0.0046794303,
0.0077625033,
-0.0068098372,
-0.0162030421,
0.0387085527,
-0.071020402,
0.0247868448,
-0.0282710362,
-0.0344189443,
0.0123396935,
0.0148183415,
0.0117749786,
-0.0001109646,
-0.0156889167,
0.0244721081,
0.0287688579,
0.0415799469,
0.1274704486,
0.0495406501,
0.013752914,
0.0401974097,
0.025218362,
-0.0172815844,
0.0171480589,
0.0050239875,
0.0144930054,
-0.0080502275,
0.0070187319,
0.0189876109,
0.0127286948,
-0.0215209369,
-0.0082570743,
0.0418239534,
0.0454571955,
-0.0049513364,
0.0209755171,
0.0276528094,
-0.057211563,
-0.0084837591,
-0.0200873483,
-0.0028437106,
-0.0220776238,
-0.04010408,
0.032566648,
-0.0189517159,
-0.0016126907,
-0.0490028299,
0.0418536812,
-0.0133178495,
0.03459692,
-0.0151219601,
-0.0187164098,
0.0128594358,
0.0006093408,
0.0425073653,
-0.0291549433,
-0.0553909428,
-0.0097205173,
0.0103494879,
0.0346551351,
0.0339799561,
-0.0142508764,
0.0200805813,
-0.0815627724,
0.0318358317,
-0.0404909365,
0.014636266,
-0.0207226835,
-0.0003784027,
0.0567049645,
-0.0263303369,
-0.0043992908,
0.0486108474,
0.008313423,
-0.038834352,
-0.0324120522,
-0.0283851661,
-0.0176067855,
-0.003268366,
-0.0233368017,
0.0210958142,
0.0128276683,
0.0079416791,
0.0236894581,
-0.0006564471,
-0.0243152697,
0.0031829916,
2.675e-7,
0.031814158,
0.0375515781,
0.0402583741,
0.0387993939,
-0.0170299169,
0.0468937196,
-0.0099030798,
0.0222162753,
0.0178753827,
-0.0218647085,
0.0311048757,
-0.0136479111,
0.0535431318,
-0.0199223049,
-0.0990126431,
-0.000133275,
-0.0738501325,
0.0410045721,
-0.0699017197,
0.0484250933,
0.0586282313,
0.0956318676,
-0.0054731797,
0.0051719602,
0.0146848727,
-0.0062919492,
0.028211249,
-0.0397538878,
0.0001911887,
0.0488679372,
0.0207808353,
-0.0351291001,
-0.0308225881,
0.0134387799,
0.0075441743,
0.018519856,
-0.0048485124,
0.0904004201,
-0.0116824554,
0.0033672019,
-0.0053932248,
-0.0028974488,
-0.0174690373,
-0.0855334103,
0.0475439057,
-0.0078871399,
-0.019719705,
-0.0501218103,
-0.0019241829,
-0.0229867641,
0.0122144921,
-0.0251987446,
-0.0014905047,
0.032477282,
0.0263707228,
-0.0205577109,
-0.0401231609,
-0.0300140902,
-0.0407836214,
-0.0134684741,
-0.0362741351,
-0.0560807809,
-0.0523141138,
0.0352630615,
0.0387799628,
-0.0596768148,
-0.002042054,
2.661216584e-34,
0.0113016274,
-0.0279381052,
0.0508101359,
0.0121150622,
0.0217131954,
-0.0123676108,
0.0323063061,
0.034783531,
0.0346649103,
-0.0824891329,
-0.025698971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04142v1 | What is Lost in Knowledge Distillation? | 2023-11-07T17:13:40 | 2023-11-07T17:13:40 | Manas Mohanty, Tanya Roosta, Peyman Passban | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deep neural networks (DNNs) have improved NLP tasks significantly, but
training and maintaining such networks could be costly. Model compression
techniques, such as, knowledge distillation (KD), have been proposed to address
the issue; however, the compression process could be lossy. Motivated by this,
our work investigates how a distilled student model differs from its teacher,
if the distillation process causes any information losses, and if the loss
follows a specific pattern. Our experiments aim to shed light on the type of
tasks might be less or more sensitive to KD by reporting data points on the
contribution of different factors, such as the number of layers or attention
heads. Results such as ours could be utilized when determining effective and
efficient configurations to achieve optimal information transfers between
larger (teacher) and smaller (student) models. | [
-0.0013146304,
0.0711450875,
-0.01334137,
0.0188851915,
-0.0378250517,
-0.0088530993,
-0.0000535674,
0.0216985755,
-0.0587607063,
0.0183821879,
-0.0049696094,
0.0159054883,
0.0052209073,
0.0015641762,
0.007714496,
-0.0445914045,
0.0288497489,
-0.0141175594,
-0.0040072598,
0.0005951733,
-0.0171972495,
-0.0296628959,
-0.0042140861,
0.0261165407,
0.000042779,
-0.0319709256,
-0.0354980677,
0.0084167188,
0.0036160885,
0.026615886,
0.0293740053,
0.0629432946,
0.0152196782,
-0.0030237304,
0.0000020033,
-0.0192875341,
0.0027528689,
-0.0135633117,
-0.0948749781,
0.0306382999,
-0.0127988802,
0.0038936187,
0.0408492684,
-0.0081277657,
-0.0182062034,
-0.0144376224,
0.0439160354,
0.0631671473,
0.070659399,
0.0303115211,
0.0091717048,
-0.0410725139,
0.023986131,
-0.0435934104,
-0.0048854956,
-0.0177287664,
0.0198618267,
0.0072722291,
-0.0523963012,
0.0020883204,
-0.0303583238,
0.0699602291,
0.0435526408,
0.0065944791,
0.0102827772,
0.0151299648,
-0.0400050133,
-0.0432442538,
0.0030644059,
0.063073881,
-0.0528857671,
-0.0055740881,
0.0013968232,
0.0046395361,
0.037613824,
-0.0146194119,
-0.0654229447,
0.0036918346,
0.0205402616,
0.0223506857,
-0.0064562405,
0.0213492531,
0.0421729311,
0.0107381344,
-0.0097129652,
-0.0037378974,
-0.0116042392,
-0.0375060737,
0.0206366368,
0.0160456169,
-0.0504374094,
-0.0512783155,
0.0121855251,
0.0218002051,
0.0648521855,
-0.0049990229,
-0.035344366,
-0.0379831977,
0.0065265978,
-0.0150622334,
0.0542464592,
0.027188573,
0.0076623093,
0.0249828864,
-0.0381126516,
0.0742914379,
-0.0068464112,
0.0414477028,
-0.0132694421,
0.0115693985,
-0.0978453383,
-0.0038438933,
-0.0377790071,
0.0569956005,
-0.0263443608,
-0.0162975118,
-0.0078441538,
-0.0330143012,
-0.0411255546,
-0.0102606546,
0.0272164978,
0.0373336002,
-0.0125690354,
0.0285695326,
-0.0288672466,
0.0941222012,
-0.0656289607,
0.0161451939,
0.041586414,
-0.0302517731,
-0.0487547219,
-0.0111922752,
0.0006147887,
0.0174254067,
-0.0120263565,
0.0155674508,
-0.0134077249,
-0.0139774727,
-0.0591638014,
-0.0404940471,
-0.0147423977,
-0.0789561272,
0.0416744649,
-0.0598831065,
0.0764847398,
-0.0293313973,
0.0099539859,
-0.0930370763,
0.0054020081,
-0.0147671998,
-0.0366459042,
0.0309730638,
0.0148693826,
0.0289342608,
0.0105454586,
0.0304593835,
-0.0230823513,
0.0836678222,
0.0173494797,
0.0257534087,
-0.0148428446,
-0.0461810529,
-0.0048592915,
-0.0225300714,
0.0843485668,
0.0218941253,
-0.0262668151,
-0.0340381935,
-0.0175494738,
0.0353965946,
0.047166381,
0.0593577325,
-0.0732389763,
0.0010129892,
0.0736893639,
0.0213589016,
0.0635961518,
0.0417394228,
0.0015194055,
0.0008667751,
0.019410219,
0.051265236,
-0.071286574,
-0.0026581101,
0.0216341596,
-0.0173944943,
0.0314591825,
0.0253061056,
-0.0485928729,
-0.0605095401,
0.0175107364,
0.0011335732,
0.027759904,
0.0132458806,
0.0307826232,
0.0344270915,
0.0302688815,
0.1005199701,
0.0290550515,
-0.0417615138,
0.0287158117,
-0.0355015844,
-0.0294093266,
0.0354020111,
-0.0022572211,
-0.0082660681,
-0.0128160678,
-0.0000022911,
-0.0119072553,
-0.037504252,
0.0417955555,
-0.0270943195,
0.0658049062,
-0.0301541854,
-0.0218362752,
-0.0468342043,
0.0457604229,
-0.0363285579,
0.0241547562,
0.007019443,
0.0249805953,
-0.064583458,
-0.0297618695,
0.0210507046,
-0.0272389911,
-0.0501447394,
-0.0179693587,
0.0224284865,
-0.0065217386,
0.002094578,
-0.0090023605,
-0.0140489582,
0.0312280506,
-0.0551700778,
-0.0256068874,
-0.0587433167,
-0.0356124341,
-0.067692779,
0.0153658595,
-0.0238546096,
0.0511291362,
0.05615592,
-0.0384777822,
-0.0528776944,
0.0155459279,
-0.0076883435,
0.0337396786,
0.0093302168,
0.0255278312,
0.0166967846,
0.0094804913,
-0.0154834148,
0.0499160625,
-0.0409822837,
-0.0059939111,
-0.0139504988,
-0.0527489185,
-0.0229642391,
0.0060127117,
-0.0021367243,
0.0074999775,
-0.0314081088,
0.0055603553,
0.0225368794,
-0.0308300164,
-0.0370271988,
-0.0165287815,
-0.0298787002,
0.0247458834,
-0.0412440822,
0.026510166,
0.0300261136,
0.0220283102,
0.0343952142,
-0.0132403439,
-0.0334648304,
0.002235282,
-0.0289577078,
0.0140348263,
0.011281467,
0.0082023302,
0.0145156058,
-0.0176749043,
-0.0598012097,
0.0179672688,
0.0611797757,
-0.0504650436,
-0.0111606698,
-0.0174796842,
0.0489733852,
-0.0124493865,
0.0135784261,
0.0152651547,
-0.0317503475,
-0.0279197823,
-0.0043254937,
0.0117417853,
0.0613551065,
-0.0466416255,
0.0458008349,
0.070412226,
0.0201972201,
-0.0802375972,
0.0349076092,
-0.0196252577,
0.0033678229,
-0.0305355899,
-0.0321531892,
-0.0178872105,
0.0677678287,
-0.0298852064,
-0.0108945332,
-0.0480351225,
-0.002384668,
-0.0161954686,
-0.0345046669,
-0.0349262506,
0.0164348818,
0.0201620795,
0.0367405415,
-0.0195398089,
-0.0199435744,
0.0392717682,
0.0081174821,
0.0292704869,
-0.0380383097,
-0.0224312302,
0.0213949643,
0.0480342358,
-0.0100701936,
0.0112220952,
0.0096466448,
-0.0068246019,
-0.0600780249,
0.0104529317,
0.0100329947,
-0.0185285509,
0.0498046428,
-0.0538272858,
-0.0340185836,
-0.0288978927,
-0.0263582449,
-0.0305420998,
0.0089611802,
0.0166111141,
0.0547986068,
0.0620005876,
0.0019164478,
-0.0385584757,
-0.0295939632,
0.0012337392,
0.0366189666,
0.0059326859,
-0.0057908781,
-0.0119055938,
0.0465082489,
0.0177782606,
0.0369431041,
0.006362068,
-0.0170051288,
0.0251035634,
0.0698408112,
0.0235891193,
0.0367062949,
-0.0183227956,
-0.0185455699,
0.0181838311,
-0.0141429473,
-0.0418429449,
-0.0028265626,
0.0531496741,
-0.0912870094,
0.0029139565,
0.0532813743,
-0.0019020496,
-0.0227970332,
0.0100172563,
0.0463532098,
0.0413905717,
0.0012776401,
0.0017723475,
-0.0547416881,
-0.0296120364,
0.0203548297,
0.0096308179,
0.0188235883,
-0.0174776725,
-0.0050095674,
-0.0440326631,
-0.0152694834,
0.0123205241,
0.0032578928,
-0.0520372465,
-0.0298230853,
0.0027214128,
-0.0238541551,
0.0011428043,
-0.0311239846,
0.0064520147,
0.0011634983,
0.0285369791,
-0.0195018537,
-0.0662454218,
-0.0233104341,
-0.0223026536,
0.0194091257,
0.052252125,
0.0199456718,
-0.0048744865,
-0.0552465096,
-0.0232950635,
0.0047390652,
0.0005375608,
0.0088370172,
0.0844305605,
0.0293048751,
-0.0022386715,
0.044390928,
0.0389527753,
-0.0541714728,
-0.0002923314,
0.0002082726,
0.0549741574,
0.0127474377,
-0.0782862902,
-0.0179986358,
-0.0392837599,
0.02373611,
0.0934894606,
0.0704031438,
-0.013069829,
-0.0557044521,
0.0172731169,
-0.0005031758,
-0.0441890247,
0.0144853406,
0.0344757736,
-0.0015702072,
-0.0251493212,
-0.0677523613,
-0.0114242537,
0.0124591878,
0.0102778217,
0.0093284314,
-0.0177795216,
0.0283797905,
0.0286799204,
-0.0450095162,
0.0130905835,
0.0025792648,
-0.0217110533,
-0.0159697346,
-0.0117266895,
-0.0282207392,
0.0125389062,
-0.0191470664,
0.0010307737,
-0.1669880301,
-0.0506817438,
0.033415664,
0.0358897187,
0.0194193553,
0.0521291457,
-0.0027851032,
-0.0637444407,
0.0496909507,
0.0002834283,
-0.0156719591,
0.0171191972,
0.0433999188,
-0.043847248,
0.0155722545,
0.0425728261,
-0.0162780993,
0.0158462021,
0.0211436115,
0.0239714142,
-0.0358040072,
-0.0079726633,
0.0069277054,
0.0082991207,
0.0335198045,
0.0324203409,
0.0010801358,
0.0079589542,
0.0279385149,
0.0606751591,
0.0118079884,
-0.0546877794,
-0.0075493874,
0.0569470339,
0.0452101864,
0.0377410762,
0.0213353708,
0.0810077563,
-0.0307787117,
-0.0330322906,
-0.036531955,
0.0175131951,
-0.0249243807,
0.0634784847,
0.0356450565,
-0.0314596519,
0.0319808647,
-0.0047008488,
0.0186311994,
-0.0302068591,
0.0138514629,
0.039265126,
0.0471882932,
-0.021290835,
0.0310458113,
-0.0716010928,
-0.0678091943,
-0.0055703898,
0.002268543,
0.0282132421,
-0.008766898,
0.0016356672,
-0.0345380716,
-0.0088516083,
-0.0222801268,
-0.0104920296,
-0.01365925,
0.0437275693,
-0.0074859317,
0.0234522745,
0.025091609,
-0.0163882188,
0.0891955718,
-0.0204287637,
0.0643422753,
-0.0247927979,
0.0189431999,
-0.0125557566,
-0.0093705729,
-0.0017240647,
0.060072571,
0.0394779108,
0.0122156255,
-0.010628311,
-0.0515984632,
0.0004362943,
-0.0305015873,
0.0263794269,
-0.0338788852,
0.0554586649,
0.0275701433,
-0.0101282327,
-0.0193327125,
0.0043841335,
-0.0233679377,
0.0010969609,
-0.0183048025,
-0.0034279807,
-6.331315429e-33,
0.0093561588,
0.0280121099,
-0.0132068675,
-0.011105597,
-0.0533156805,
0.0254637152,
-0.0021555379,
-0.0251168367,
-0.0579618216,
0.045765169,
-0.0273491312,
0.048655387,
0.0150066391,
0.0343493968,
0.0166593101,
-0.0338337645,
0.0989600196,
0.0008315233,
-0.0095051574,
0.0513626896,
0.0377784483,
0.0363470726,
0.0395021662,
-0.0394576415,
-0.0222809818,
0.0003301691,
0.0461803265,
-0.0056269383,
-0.017978292,
0.0053299502,
-0.0273939036,
0.0692287758,
0.0248903055,
-0.0769402161,
-0.0306710843,
-0.0022789431,
-0.0979535878,
-0.0559452251,
-0.0186264273,
-0.0194815006,
-0.0552768447,
-0.0570007414,
0.0891407952,
0.0329533853,
0.0533020534,
-0.0556561425,
-0.0050376444,
0.0036065516,
-0.0397531241,
-0.0352278501,
-0.0266867373,
-0.0213720705,
-0.0427447744,
-0.0683439076,
0.0449264161,
0.0049562044,
-0.0250295177,
-0.0148248347,
-0.0765051097,
-0.0042689093,
0.0549282916,
0.0796509385,
0.0288350079,
-0.0054470873,
-0.02815024,
0.0379077978,
0.0025262469,
0.0362081751,
-0.035312254,
-0.0293578263,
0.0464611538,
0.0927730277,
0.0402104184,
-0.0093824491,
0.1068182364,
-0.0326968022,
-0.034090139,
-0.0386853442,
-0.0020840312,
0.046773497,
-0.0425341576,
0.0026634706,
0.0106380079,
-0.0432491489,
-0.0666627213,
-0.0262203347,
-0.0108109126,
-0.0104206894,
0.0261186901,
0.0328020193,
-0.0295342971,
0.0067453515,
0.0021538709,
-0.078534171,
0.0374951065,
0.0345004536,
0.0100910217,
0.0225098655,
0.0257000644,
-0.0163030606,
-0.0887614191,
0.0001973115,
0.0091761053,
0.0202305671,
0.0192887168,
0.0119433003,
0.0510108545,
0.0147889685,
-0.0156763569,
-0.0345865749,
-0.0313289426,
0.0035936097,
0.033950936,
0.0167362504,
0.0429249816,
0.0166681297,
-0.0183616262,
-0.0374927372,
0.054282207,
0.0162635166,
-0.0173992179,
0.0142320236,
0.0440768525,
0.0147279752,
0.0048547224,
-0.0294931158,
-0.0656548813,
-0.004185121,
0.0083991829,
-0.0427614562,
-0.0267619286,
0.0052549019,
2.656e-7,
0.0088144485,
-0.0059578177,
0.0038487795,
-0.0234985612,
0.0230711363,
0.0034133808,
0.0128639573,
0.0144322701,
-0.0182372406,
-0.061880596,
-0.0185521599,
0.0483860895,
0.0463369265,
0.0377770998,
-0.073135145,
-0.0342839733,
-0.022724865,
-0.0193302836,
0.011711726,
-0.0445896164,
0.0367930494,
0.0566405915,
0.0372451991,
-0.0239108875,
0.0302992761,
0.0126465717,
0.0090113608,
0.0086738067,
0.063697122,
0.0428587608,
0.0532882027,
-0.0351070128,
-0.0039795358,
0.0705471858,
-0.0084675569,
-0.0026692629,
0.0038714388,
0.0575764924,
-0.0072589102,
-0.0163710639,
-0.042838119,
0.0001442012,
0.0024787979,
-0.0452738926,
0.0554003268,
-0.0460631326,
0.0012010955,
-0.00908422,
-0.0116941845,
-0.012663383,
0.0482679792,
0.0150462193,
0.0448563658,
0.0087283729,
-0.0297285318,
0.0083387699,
-0.0375667773,
-0.0840873718,
-0.0133656422,
0.0053428318,
-0.0154696349,
-0.061496973,
-0.0407406986,
-0.0802427977,
0.0196749158,
-0.017804347,
-0.0205517039,
1.890061869e-34,
-0.0118467733,
0.0092331264,
0.0425798446,
0.0199389104,
-0.028841991,
-0.0450468324,
-0.0853993818,
-0.0159230344,
-0.0187428594,
-0.0432040878,
-0.0074185971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04139v1 | Modelling Sentiment Analysis: LLMs and data augmentation techniques | 2023-11-07T17:12:39 | 2023-11-07T17:12:39 | Guillem Senabre Prades | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper provides different approaches for a binary sentiment
classification on a small training dataset. LLMs that provided state-of-the-art
results in sentiment analysis and similar domains are being used, such as BERT,
RoBERTa and XLNet. | [
0.0240608566,
0.0447536334,
-0.0054194797,
0.059944693,
-0.0133410729,
0.017308915,
-0.0268282127,
0.0154104736,
0.0272920057,
-0.0744318739,
-0.0412995294,
0.0031641352,
-0.0706307217,
0.0183115732,
0.011100186,
-0.010383606,
0.0375064425,
0.0616615936,
0.0062796143,
-0.0135726649,
0.0185208246,
-0.0101570813,
0.0055246442,
-0.0210618638,
-0.0327923745,
0.0230808351,
-0.0133153554,
0.0175710656,
0.0079506328,
-0.0369711779,
0.0342614949,
0.0344167389,
0.0435415953,
0.0269640721,
0.000001607,
-0.02244284,
-0.0035774664,
-0.0040806816,
-0.0391132608,
-0.0248477422,
0.0335714072,
-0.025836166,
0.0224827658,
0.0272233523,
-0.0619284101,
-0.0131457336,
0.0374624096,
0.0582682341,
0.0671199858,
0.0765036494,
-0.0169488918,
-0.0028439441,
0.015115534,
-0.0158143602,
0.0453880243,
0.0186848249,
0.0528399721,
0.0108708944,
0.0113492692,
0.0291465614,
-0.0031401818,
0.0101037035,
-0.0262428373,
0.0408554859,
0.055338908,
-0.0085414341,
-0.0030979593,
0.028505737,
-0.0294628553,
0.0136216106,
0.0616762079,
0.0041547958,
-0.0403510407,
-0.0029551927,
-0.0154828839,
-0.0452026241,
-0.0303855892,
-0.0119345142,
0.0286912695,
0.0468989611,
-0.0029577683,
-0.006598623,
0.0212227758,
0.0686539933,
0.0055959742,
0.0353635512,
-0.045663394,
-0.0652737916,
-0.0080248546,
0.080771789,
0.0261675324,
-0.0231580809,
-0.0193151888,
0.0395427607,
0.0469611548,
0.0146627296,
0.0072070193,
-0.0052666329,
0.0463734418,
-0.1060374007,
0.0322923027,
-0.0008174843,
-0.0431482755,
0.0451879539,
-0.0473721884,
-0.0366424173,
-0.0052155508,
0.0225495249,
-0.011904832,
0.0116769895,
-0.0489122644,
0.0143924123,
-0.0146821812,
0.0926105753,
-0.0243076384,
0.0170375612,
-0.0988428742,
0.0170774739,
-0.0136562865,
0.0144592356,
0.0381372012,
-0.0065976665,
0.0189522635,
0.0346500054,
-0.053418804,
0.0180872511,
-0.0210248455,
0.0774500594,
-0.0504832007,
-0.0667111576,
0.0024950875,
0.0440666713,
0.010120932,
-0.0022480576,
0.0322973318,
0.0847225934,
0.0504146703,
-0.0526931174,
-0.0895966813,
-0.0115757985,
-0.0043535354,
-0.030180091,
0.0071020727,
-0.0582924634,
0.0052179173,
-0.0148906419,
-0.0108125955,
0.0301596057,
0.0075763343,
-0.0395629108,
-0.0100647975,
0.052761998,
-0.0852630958,
-0.0178579092,
0.0154022491,
-0.0081232097,
0.0026164947,
0.0710111856,
0.0095206443,
0.0473925322,
0.0291512012,
0.0066569676,
-0.001392073,
0.0131939417,
0.010352632,
0.0057169772,
-0.0575793497,
0.0104191238,
-0.082241863,
-0.0262799542,
0.0101193562,
0.0091730496,
-0.0078500453,
-0.0116796959,
0.0311672743,
0.0050212718,
0.0041685966,
0.0588110164,
-0.0473929048,
-0.0163417887,
0.0250848774,
-0.0258770064,
-0.0034552806,
0.0515624881,
-0.0129963066,
-0.0106201563,
0.0025901492,
-0.0115744015,
-0.0430034697,
-0.0780416206,
-0.0176635943,
-0.0443592407,
0.0350968353,
0.0141991153,
0.0641808882,
-0.0242903177,
-0.0198210273,
-0.006306231,
0.0337324403,
-0.032940615,
0.0000801084,
-0.0784960017,
0.0298246257,
0.0676704645,
0.0161022861,
-0.0532341935,
-0.0627895296,
-0.0641702935,
-0.0181563403,
0.044557631,
0.0149940811,
0.0264717769,
-0.0191200525,
-0.0470418148,
-0.0228156541,
0.0044098254,
0.0450415537,
0.0032697585,
-0.0187881906,
0.0057479399,
-0.0199907273,
0.0163289011,
-0.0319700874,
0.0165636186,
0.0290436819,
-0.0174392015,
-0.0007437892,
-0.0020918029,
0.0574550778,
0.0670822337,
-0.0074559567,
-0.0188242923,
0.0538908057,
-0.0138137154,
-0.0485043302,
0.0039040027,
0.0564252473,
-0.0473472737,
0.0386344865,
-0.0050954362,
-0.0050593568,
0.0167630743,
-0.0727986097,
-0.007410543,
-0.0020461343,
-0.0454749055,
0.0471587293,
-0.0798703283,
-0.0094052125,
-0.0249076262,
-0.0086673656,
-0.0139054777,
0.04144454,
-0.0140511412,
0.0219492726,
-0.0724141225,
-0.0348509252,
0.0394567214,
-0.0365250185,
-0.0379644334,
-0.0490935221,
0.0297666322,
0.0416546836,
-0.0151302973,
-0.0102174515,
0.0028014896,
-0.0367435291,
-0.0957163721,
-0.0241852794,
0.0195880085,
0.0416399427,
0.0131745208,
0.0036387306,
0.0017577942,
0.0028983997,
-0.041829329,
-0.0258010142,
0.0199541748,
0.0064896485,
0.0636231378,
0.0210536793,
0.0095000714,
-0.0456278212,
-0.0121630812,
-0.009883808,
-0.0227665864,
-0.0034850987,
-0.0711463168,
-0.0112162186,
-0.0094370916,
-0.0738311633,
0.0562638529,
-0.0083428724,
-0.0638299659,
-0.0290607568,
-0.0344427191,
-0.0205669645,
-0.0122218244,
-0.0146639505,
0.0150547689,
0.0287273936,
0.0389622413,
-0.0327851549,
0.0187558569,
-0.0417276882,
0.0158976633,
-0.0131284203,
-0.0328296237,
-0.0093988916,
0.0300452933,
-0.0043357941,
-0.0116020115,
-0.0001972216,
-0.0106816171,
0.0075894468,
-0.0111708296,
0.0012205946,
-0.0034559434,
-0.0096219908,
0.0184735805,
0.017452186,
-0.0435047485,
0.0528867468,
-0.0072414838,
0.0176755488,
-0.0625436008,
-0.0517731011,
-0.0619160868,
-0.0030522994,
0.0012188483,
0.0096465657,
-0.054691121,
0.0298621133,
0.00424643,
-0.0676462799,
-0.0373177156,
-0.0399592742,
0.0768404379,
0.038223628,
0.0140601313,
-0.0089326436,
-0.0232611429,
-0.0234929416,
-0.031158736,
-0.057880301,
-0.0034590967,
0.0070389262,
-0.0240901709,
-0.0050103287,
0.0025176096,
-0.0238088947,
-0.0160477925,
-0.026090432,
0.004483738,
0.0016535108,
0.0219861735,
0.0190363433,
0.0056386949,
-0.0086329831,
-0.0021002861,
-0.0468058474,
0.0146141713,
-0.0297751278,
0.016655514,
-0.0612755157,
-0.0088281902,
0.0240805801,
0.0022395437,
0.0045753713,
-0.0592491925,
0.036907766,
-0.0494290926,
0.0515382402,
0.1090629622,
0.0250766613,
-0.0284444764,
-0.0214770269,
-0.0206773095,
-0.034202978,
0.019855829,
0.0133769233,
-0.0483916178,
0.0012151253,
-0.0275300369,
0.0086124269,
-0.0350322798,
-0.0059601804,
0.0142576629,
-0.0846702829,
0.0377118327,
0.0063302,
0.0058210157,
-0.0391999818,
-0.0446586497,
0.0080225188,
-0.0106404899,
-0.0114965374,
-0.0374971628,
0.0163156651,
0.0037761589,
0.030863462,
-0.0320263728,
-0.0255647302,
-0.0345821977,
-0.0085548004,
0.0595485307,
0.0366791449,
0.0258122478,
-0.0665822923,
-0.0294293761,
0.0508814603,
0.0283787325,
0.0240654033,
-0.0276034474,
0.0817540959,
-0.0332686938,
-0.0096037937,
-0.0161378551,
0.0048205294,
-0.0166961458,
0.0492312722,
0.0098823169,
0.0540476069,
-0.0370329469,
0.0135744819,
-0.0548692234,
0.0433155447,
0.0115551874,
0.0729696155,
-0.006162825,
-0.0410437956,
-0.0039360859,
-0.0095451111,
-0.0194867998,
-0.0222190954,
0.0443650186,
-0.0004167483,
-0.0508614928,
-0.0294509493,
-0.0727414414,
-0.0277502146,
0.0147435805,
0.02308302,
-0.0050150193,
0.0527406745,
-0.0159878824,
-0.021380553,
-0.0470758639,
0.013234498,
0.0046705436,
0.0124560203,
-0.0286037382,
-0.0360204838,
0.0938642174,
-0.0270549171,
-0.0055218907,
-0.053414464,
-0.0356137455,
-0.0430865586,
-0.0348865837,
0.06516698,
0.0281722695,
0.002079935,
0.0044544875,
-0.0383702815,
0.0332167894,
0.1024026498,
0.0002945463,
0.0262185261,
0.0479199514,
0.0847365633,
-0.002185676,
-0.0088145286,
-0.0193297956,
0.0718057603,
0.0074263257,
-0.0306549426,
-0.0803040862,
-0.0016533986,
-0.0189619809,
0.0068225279,
0.0671639517,
0.0141927199,
-0.0121902609,
-0.013083959,
0.0469387919,
-0.0381841026,
0.0271617342,
-0.0396955237,
-0.0342617407,
0.0020279924,
0.0164080076,
-0.0755718201,
-0.021980552,
-0.0460527427,
0.0268729609,
-0.0335472375,
0.1012778506,
0.0224088393,
-0.0067330133,
-0.0098526273,
0.0380401798,
-0.0391805023,
-0.0039402535,
0.0190604962,
-0.0371738151,
0.0166406929,
0.0187719408,
0.0122298393,
0.0344145745,
-0.0081985518,
0.0286539271,
-0.0079941126,
0.0038915602,
-0.0465353802,
0.0716312826,
-0.0004965742,
0.005111461,
0.0229581594,
-0.0267926604,
-0.0177689698,
0.0026124516,
0.0160861462,
-0.0440355539,
0.0078723403,
0.0905673206,
0.0192646496,
-0.0411629267,
-0.0193112865,
0.028465353,
-0.0349061824,
0.0521517955,
-0.0027973321,
-0.0094340723,
-0.0621001124,
-0.0041374089,
0.0968230963,
0.0057764626,
0.0082342457,
0.0415685624,
-0.0295751262,
-0.0636882931,
0.0544009581,
-0.0282851588,
0.0235350411,
-0.0489712954,
0.0379234999,
0.002131273,
0.0212758556,
0.0502287336,
-0.0186581388,
0.017559411,
-0.0082605295,
-0.0404939726,
0.0066566071,
-5.614020328e-33,
0.0071049132,
0.0007595153,
-0.0193939172,
0.0482736938,
-0.0322239473,
0.0198999513,
0.0055568605,
0.0186414365,
-0.0162795838,
0.0142606776,
-0.0014254984,
0.0258353353,
-0.0004307902,
0.0328699201,
-0.003113026,
-0.0208264478,
0.0529253557,
-0.0364972539,
0.031196408,
-0.0310032666,
-0.0288579743,
0.0314561129,
0.0312307421,
-0.0999412313,
0.0494399332,
-0.0132930269,
-0.0576062202,
0.0329774544,
0.0140729761,
0.0461096354,
-0.00518446,
0.0728861019,
0.0532503575,
0.0151852509,
0.0201986749,
0.0392062366,
-0.026306821,
-0.0122111961,
0.0075735133,
0.0269984473,
0.000118958,
0.0124283554,
0.0493708514,
0.0084900213,
-0.0291901249,
0.0455466099,
0.0261862706,
-0.0470441952,
-0.0040121484,
-0.0501827598,
-0.0006436306,
0.013501755,
0.0356048532,
0.0222779606,
0.0425245874,
0.0295847226,
-0.0090255355,
0.0302171391,
-0.0587992184,
0.0219335891,
0.0408850349,
0.0082749603,
-0.0121396407,
-0.0031851709,
-0.0015675653,
0.0464895293,
0.0113410568,
-0.005665883,
-0.036299482,
0.0743969604,
0.0118495021,
0.0478130504,
0.0378349535,
0.0347062983,
0.0127116274,
-0.004413431,
-0.0625581071,
0.0288284086,
0.0771312341,
0.001946757,
0.0509117395,
0.0129128182,
-0.0378144458,
0.0092507703,
0.0514961407,
-0.0262618903,
-0.0193748381,
-0.048126433,
-0.0146526936,
0.0136105977,
-0.0220440477,
-0.0185722187,
-0.010997884,
-0.0735721365,
-0.0350268073,
-0.009356671,
0.0165943746,
0.0308323465,
0.0183343105,
-0.038549941,
-0.0504615009,
-0.0413651839,
-0.0163756702,
0.0345968865,
-0.0085832365,
0.004913948,
0.0575106852,
0.0164138097,
-0.0743834898,
0.0037783552,
-0.0021463211,
0.0278803557,
0.0107474895,
0.0707637295,
-0.0211595036,
-0.0115071191,
0.0142302271,
0.0634750947,
-0.0122495424,
0.0434831157,
-0.0030644808,
-0.0052944329,
-0.0003912105,
0.0061400998,
-0.0428955629,
-0.0162401255,
0.0453348942,
0.0067441831,
-0.0100001348,
-0.0670739114,
0.0041646003,
-0.0137577252,
2.377e-7,
0.0425121374,
0.0632346794,
-0.0173240975,
-0.0042858189,
0.0387192592,
0.0233677458,
-0.0546346754,
0.0323018953,
0.0241722241,
-0.0219317395,
0.0419713818,
0.0037386301,
-0.0077833422,
-0.009818566,
-0.0959690064,
-0.0298602562,
-0.0089830672,
0.0031899114,
0.0092107318,
0.0378897153,
0.0976038128,
0.0898675099,
0.0612482391,
-0.0138769848,
-0.0238976832,
-0.0062067071,
0.0219813641,
-0.0347383022,
-0.002556148,
0.0249252766,
0.0409789421,
0.0373792127,
-0.0074276156,
-0.008545734,
-0.014907917,
0.0339228399,
-0.0194333587,
0.0440247618,
-0.033970356,
-0.0304980427,
0.0206737705,
0.0070256623,
0.0256742723,
0.0002778755,
0.0186397098,
-0.0422742739,
-0.0497172698,
-0.0477019288,
-0.0350206159,
0.0202615261,
0.0245830212,
-0.0110231619,
-0.034781836,
-0.0015506857,
0.0100817159,
-0.0346637256,
-0.0385814905,
-0.0721832737,
0.0149949575,
0.0030186297,
-0.0522863828,
-0.0841843039,
0.0114118559,
0.0637538061,
0.0302480087,
-0.021123575,
-0.0147860143,
1.786503687e-34,
0.0569121987,
-0.0468222201,
0.0041145631,
0.0532918796,
-0.0180060957,
0.0110630868,
-0.0121059977,
0.0021106713,
0.0273284242,
-0.0462590642,
0.0064434609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04131v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04131v3 | Interpreting Shared Circuits for Ordered Sequence Prediction in a Large Language Model | 2023-11-07T16:58:51 | 2024-02-22T17:07:39 | Michael Lan, Fazl Barez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While transformer models exhibit strong capabilities on linguistic tasks,
their complex architectures make them difficult to interpret. Recent work has
aimed to reverse engineer transformer models into human-readable
representations called circuits that implement algorithmic functions. We extend
this research by analyzing and comparing circuits for similar sequence
continuation tasks, which include increasing sequences of digits, number words,
and months. Through the application of circuit analysis techniques, we identify
key sub-circuits responsible for detecting sequence members and for predicting
the next member in a sequence. Our analysis reveals that semantically related
sequences rely on shared circuit subgraphs with analogous roles. Overall,
documenting shared computational structures enables better prediction of model
behaviors, identification of errors, and safer editing procedures. This
mechanistic understanding of transformers is a critical step towards building
more robust, aligned, and interpretable language models. | [
0.0326234214,
0.0641246289,
-0.0347368829,
0.0477863178,
-0.040803723,
0.011075058,
0.0126934387,
-0.019647846,
-0.0138126509,
-0.0268207956,
-0.0032261685,
-0.0352307372,
0.0494445264,
0.0333437584,
0.0006322673,
-0.0232303813,
0.0594855659,
-0.0453192331,
-0.0526513532,
0.0083177369,
-0.0228631012,
-0.0029711158,
0.0161312874,
0.0495888554,
0.0389582887,
-0.0084870383,
-0.0186538007,
-0.0353745222,
-0.0022976752,
-0.0118810739,
-0.0516518727,
0.0847929642,
0.0001607951,
0.0746780857,
0.0000020242,
-0.0207148027,
-0.0219929237,
0.0004836172,
-0.0310597252,
0.0133559508,
-0.0017962451,
-0.0419338606,
-0.0204959661,
-0.0117792254,
-0.0036174301,
-0.0110693062,
0.0878558755,
0.0425386764,
0.0401840694,
0.0334457085,
0.0019664562,
-0.0825830698,
0.0501447283,
-0.0112951901,
0.0143432952,
0.0127595318,
0.017962398,
0.0065834541,
0.0558909476,
-0.0260527339,
-0.0306876376,
-0.0039176238,
0.0231875051,
0.0150880357,
-0.0253174454,
0.013965968,
-0.00922006,
-0.0516414195,
-0.0043932046,
0.0154550821,
-0.0136250975,
-0.0620702617,
0.0217251927,
0.0253417958,
-0.0007977964,
-0.0059287031,
-0.0317952223,
0.0326343067,
-0.0021276951,
-0.0033489298,
0.0212883484,
-0.0078166137,
0.0231426042,
-0.0409937762,
-0.0595747344,
0.1173525006,
0.0159682203,
0.0001035118,
-0.0678707957,
-0.0261298101,
0.0044001588,
-0.0524192154,
0.0494596772,
0.0156390592,
-0.0044033322,
0.0104476726,
-0.0333673581,
-0.0207507554,
-0.0244897008,
-0.0231782123,
0.0426253192,
0.0485561155,
0.0151026333,
-0.0136997635,
-0.0129257878,
0.0636157468,
-0.0284473132,
0.0335710831,
-0.0463264957,
0.0665606335,
-0.0184312351,
-0.0273103677,
-0.0193937942,
0.0228784475,
-0.0133304987,
-0.0199288521,
-0.0369267166,
0.0376433209,
0.006244184,
-0.0181928035,
0.0338070355,
-0.0060759047,
0.0026537096,
0.0028666013,
-0.015788354,
0.0264113266,
0.0242841672,
-0.0373128243,
-0.0035934707,
-0.0339280628,
-0.0373020619,
-0.0148452902,
0.0172095485,
-0.0291449763,
-0.0455845706,
0.0668474957,
0.0111513585,
-0.041383855,
-0.0299774855,
-0.0369656198,
-0.0071133478,
-0.0103168394,
0.0070902151,
-0.0655218139,
0.0083118863,
0.0311442185,
0.009813196,
-0.021755863,
0.0397125594,
0.0280918665,
-0.0036921711,
0.0748093277,
-0.0235120039,
-0.0086514493,
-0.0408676192,
-0.002762808,
0.0395290963,
0.0087997084,
0.0307185277,
0.0124095604,
0.0171672106,
-0.0495038368,
-0.0007662506,
0.0269816499,
0.0030259574,
-0.0643608272,
-0.0361746177,
-0.0519854464,
-0.0063879648,
-0.0043572364,
-0.0212515146,
0.0398927666,
0.0010478222,
-0.0242701434,
0.0447392799,
0.0411228314,
0.042752713,
0.057455644,
0.0274920594,
-0.0338642523,
-0.0111221597,
0.0479387045,
-0.0556577593,
0.0365443043,
-0.0140027944,
0.0345033072,
-0.0392584726,
0.0241718739,
0.0232898425,
-0.0320325941,
-0.0224311277,
-0.008209412,
0.021090012,
-0.0360330455,
0.0114060612,
0.0221344605,
-0.0796766877,
0.0714905336,
-0.0079650572,
-0.0387519635,
-0.0166725982,
-0.0376054272,
-0.0052403426,
0.0825165808,
0.029932918,
-0.0070330077,
-0.0067062927,
0.01054883,
-0.032953009,
-0.0006815547,
-0.0345653966,
0.0135045247,
-0.0388568565,
-0.017547274,
-0.0316105224,
0.0418950059,
0.0261860434,
0.0585674644,
-0.0233334471,
-0.0440682732,
0.0318287462,
-0.0167969316,
-0.0106825028,
-0.0006688864,
-0.0536033399,
0.0100312224,
-0.0283763222,
0.0285490565,
0.0013288388,
-0.0071727722,
-0.0186070241,
0.0729107931,
0.0515003912,
-0.0322323702,
0.0028453078,
0.0310444608,
-0.0657661334,
0.0018807957,
0.0402706899,
-0.0183508173,
-0.0025136257,
0.0388146453,
0.0164416656,
-0.0453253202,
0.0585087314,
-0.1019846052,
0.0708434805,
-0.0236230548,
0.0237706956,
0.0246385001,
0.0175307207,
-0.0210766289,
0.075258106,
-0.0069620274,
0.0181018915,
0.0251501445,
-0.048199378,
-0.0132288793,
-0.0087201279,
-0.0252746083,
0.0266317353,
-0.0155411623,
-0.0423121937,
0.0164374243,
-0.046326872,
-0.0046589514,
-0.0349271186,
-0.0421757624,
-0.0441849045,
-0.0190404709,
0.0571376644,
0.0113895563,
-0.0025258611,
0.034429688,
0.0160479099,
0.0346735269,
0.0016973288,
0.0049972031,
0.0184523351,
0.0404743999,
0.0024984234,
-0.1017403305,
-0.0211448558,
-0.0498702414,
-0.0428216904,
0.1029409021,
0.0031224282,
-0.0393941291,
-0.0756619126,
-0.0087493192,
-0.0007213081,
0.0225931071,
-0.0308729447,
-0.0390957631,
0.0023743915,
0.007846253,
0.0677871928,
0.0306190066,
0.033439897,
0.0465524495,
0.0511084162,
-0.0614834651,
0.0197728723,
-0.0451944321,
-0.0329252779,
0.0354516618,
-0.0461706147,
-0.0343613103,
-0.0632462874,
0.1288541853,
-0.0088984771,
0.0140794357,
-0.0575651936,
-0.0161506012,
0.0060416311,
-0.000632717,
0.0081995996,
-0.0503770448,
-0.0479906909,
0.0684577972,
-0.0092422469,
-0.0264085233,
0.0558824763,
-0.0340806954,
0.0153105874,
-0.0136957262,
-0.0050270539,
-0.0388049595,
0.1048681363,
0.0593709648,
0.0260819551,
0.0525729209,
-0.036265891,
-0.0575218759,
0.0513632149,
0.0134176426,
-0.0304964166,
0.0505571179,
-0.0535696186,
0.0011916653,
-0.0020198047,
0.0128372675,
-0.0239131358,
0.0208942089,
-0.0209422223,
0.0132861985,
0.0618396513,
-0.0351232253,
-0.0869749784,
0.0589945838,
0.0252963677,
0.0479743406,
-0.0059430432,
0.0065754228,
-0.0396514311,
0.0101124207,
0.0256837755,
-0.0308307055,
0.0648629889,
-0.0303689279,
0.0240407195,
0.0225758944,
0.0170102064,
0.0216522627,
-0.018630458,
-0.007662232,
0.0303157046,
-0.0451524146,
-0.0370347984,
0.0281595103,
-0.0225620922,
-0.0305679608,
-0.0422980525,
0.1178247109,
0.0258507133,
-0.0304405242,
0.0422039144,
-0.0202980638,
0.0296166148,
0.0481436327,
0.0085095121,
-0.0955129191,
0.0141848866,
0.0199704822,
-0.0206721071,
-0.0086401468,
-0.0041358522,
-0.0032588772,
-0.0909107178,
0.0070250803,
0.0090801129,
-0.0633404776,
-0.0233344287,
-0.0345867984,
-0.0232788306,
-0.008096749,
-0.0161104333,
0.0552443303,
-0.0318149105,
0.0003088497,
0.0193631109,
-0.0458594523,
-0.0083151134,
0.0110785086,
0.0457851999,
0.0058014938,
0.0524294227,
-0.0020358113,
-0.0108415615,
-0.0050946437,
0.0121284695,
-0.0049618841,
0.0442917719,
-0.0113233579,
0.0092809899,
0.0434552915,
-0.0218632985,
-0.0340761244,
0.0128316395,
-0.0511870496,
-0.0563835874,
-0.0539331548,
0.077550672,
-0.0350358076,
-0.0414493941,
0.0119395377,
0.029028343,
-0.0308538526,
0.0171358977,
0.0344608948,
0.0015058545,
-0.0376728438,
-0.0167507362,
0.0597917326,
-0.0495013893,
-0.0934568644,
-0.0192526802,
0.0289503727,
-0.0771793202,
-0.017830912,
0.0174091645,
-0.0432490259,
0.0068052723,
0.027197998,
-0.0698746741,
0.079029195,
-0.0321192704,
-0.0681703985,
-0.0145360781,
0.0076262592,
0.0255751573,
-0.0987329111,
0.002903691,
0.005395839,
-0.0181488898,
-0.0574387535,
0.0079734093,
-0.0870686918,
-0.0462370776,
0.0428610444,
0.0678258985,
0.0238061287,
-0.0090611428,
0.0301928855,
-0.0148636578,
-0.0184402764,
0.0506351106,
-0.0145990495,
0.0104390569,
0.0348251499,
-0.0623566583,
-0.0173637681,
0.0095918933,
0.020203473,
0.0277294684,
-0.0083049405,
0.0264160782,
-0.0476725549,
-0.0284463633,
0.0500084572,
-0.004025049,
0.061913494,
0.0316969492,
0.0296829529,
-0.0028414747,
0.0494424738,
-0.0442569666,
0.005983613,
-0.0435250439,
-0.0137244957,
0.018922966,
0.0090576252,
-0.0008606449,
-0.0291661527,
-0.0043423246,
-0.0145697873,
-0.003839236,
0.0716583431,
0.0017994859,
-0.0083756214,
-0.003801655,
-0.0189839378,
0.0102281244,
0.0199237652,
0.008403671,
0.0503191352,
-0.0212278944,
0.0095789889,
-0.0056941952,
0.0387680829,
-0.0256162658,
0.0491108373,
-0.0757228211,
-0.0071686204,
-0.0034713964,
0.0152315479,
0.0267681926,
-0.0148148648,
0.0502066799,
-0.0285030007,
0.01479764,
-0.0240167081,
0.0398797505,
0.0050568711,
-0.0104786456,
-0.0153268715,
0.0344269723,
-0.0058002137,
-0.0657939091,
0.0662972108,
-0.0094683003,
0.0278051496,
0.0199348927,
-0.0407829769,
-0.0057462025,
-0.0825504363,
-0.0240376946,
0.0021803894,
-0.0617120788,
-0.0250328798,
-0.0570921823,
-0.0476700142,
0.042052526,
0.0216606352,
0.0391594656,
-0.0108978534,
0.020488821,
0.0314552113,
-0.0021002574,
-0.018713776,
0.0025117637,
0.0034176735,
0.022324428,
-0.0214600805,
-0.0162664857,
-6.21273009e-33,
-0.0341330804,
-0.0531745553,
0.0142958416,
0.0202663541,
0.0036277554,
0.0163336061,
-0.0764896274,
0.0479399338,
0.0258848127,
-0.0351662822,
0.0078349374,
0.0008852692,
0.0169186089,
0.0128175803,
0.0244468637,
-0.0073300432,
0.0317683257,
0.0401709788,
-0.001171769,
-0.0255102757,
0.0472226329,
0.0365973562,
0.082396701,
-0.0352117121,
0.0016899626,
0.0018589018,
0.0219760258,
-0.0319499634,
-0.0247150324,
0.061975088,
0.0003748094,
0.0015372548,
0.0108941644,
-0.0849648118,
-0.0252483208,
0.0144041562,
-0.0682444796,
-0.0166713689,
0.0425974205,
0.0243061204,
0.024342576,
-0.041807007,
0.0220864154,
-0.0361483283,
-0.0235650912,
-0.0312508233,
0.0295442417,
-0.0150596527,
-0.0106150508,
0.0067505469,
-0.0545175299,
0.0310752317,
-0.0195352323,
-0.0022125677,
0.0553787425,
0.0387069397,
0.0116812419,
0.0014940205,
-0.0463311076,
0.0635153875,
0.0210363735,
0.0894179195,
0.0753235742,
0.0163970832,
0.0191571284,
0.0123355165,
0.0387606025,
-0.0042645074,
-0.020448681,
0.0287214536,
0.0267612096,
0.0737906992,
0.0256131627,
-0.0236591846,
0.0552671589,
-0.0154500837,
-0.0001139795,
0.0032199405,
-0.0152337244,
0.0529270656,
0.0241326801,
0.0240454059,
-0.0002474388,
0.0015155844,
-0.0024346088,
0.0027266361,
-0.0376970135,
-0.0303228535,
-0.0064331866,
-0.0154133569,
-0.0270333756,
0.0587652884,
0.0206044205,
-0.0512981527,
-0.0245694686,
0.0280805379,
0.0356432721,
0.014326985,
-0.0331011005,
0.0122415135,
-0.0197237022,
-0.0463441983,
0.011664547,
-0.0009697035,
0.0218649805,
-0.0152219879,
0.0019793687,
0.0250036735,
-0.0402718745,
-0.0241245627,
-0.0293071344,
-0.0052985544,
-0.0304536466,
0.0232393295,
0.0370673202,
0.0078523112,
-0.0181054287,
-0.0117770843,
-0.0020784442,
0.0089071533,
-0.0147227505,
0.0197552629,
-0.0041314107,
0.0328390412,
-0.0161235072,
-0.0328137688,
-0.0763258189,
0.0608998612,
0.0178026911,
-0.0074613616,
-0.0267371982,
0.0371009447,
2.874e-7,
0.0623277612,
0.0622861162,
0.0640891269,
0.0485512428,
0.0292227156,
-0.0226481222,
0.0189713165,
0.0073261657,
-0.0057109427,
-0.0340383984,
0.0396305509,
-0.0200889576,
0.022707222,
0.0161205195,
-0.0143239703,
-0.0153106814,
-0.0934854224,
-0.0032694242,
-0.0279153343,
-0.0295273494,
0.0413861163,
0.0906964689,
-0.0170385409,
0.0078949556,
-0.0159002393,
-0.0046746298,
0.031388849,
-0.0326373018,
0.0231967177,
-0.0149296978,
-0.0369727239,
-0.0440636612,
0.0092629045,
0.0223946813,
-0.0165837687,
0.0190799795,
-0.0119670862,
0.0228637308,
-0.0175737031,
0.018035369,
0.0184350871,
-0.0091595426,
-0.0362061709,
-0.0354416072,
0.0346680991,
-0.0433469564,
-0.0170286801,
0.0011629714,
-0.0173431132,
-0.0061046826,
0.00121158,
0.0258327164,
0.0132067492,
0.0303372089,
0.0189014804,
-0.0004713865,
-0.0002106585,
-0.0255783703,
-0.0155897867,
0.0104553774,
-0.0310968272,
-0.016275607,
-0.0666119158,
-0.0237280224,
0.007062397,
0.0011083161,
-0.0414543599,
2.920355002e-34,
0.0171036273,
-0.003835941,
-0.0088083232,
0.030093817,
0.0656359121,
-0.0316218734,
0.0319154225,
0.0413168631,
-0.0151707949,
-0.077499114,
-0.0621280186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04124v1 | Unveiling Safety Vulnerabilities of Large Language Models | 2023-11-07T16:50:33 | 2023-11-07T16:50:33 | George Kour, Marcel Zalmanovici, Naama Zwerdling, Esther Goldbraich, Ora Nova Fandina, Ateret Anaby-Tavor, Orna Raz, Eitan Farchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | As large language models become more prevalent, their possible harmful or
inappropriate responses are a cause for concern. This paper introduces a unique
dataset containing adversarial examples in the form of questions, which we call
AttaQ, designed to provoke such harmful or inappropriate responses. We assess
the efficacy of our dataset by analyzing the vulnerabilities of various models
when subjected to it. Additionally, we introduce a novel automatic approach for
identifying and naming vulnerable semantic regions - input semantic areas for
which the model is likely to produce harmful outputs. This is achieved through
the application of specialized clustering techniques that consider both the
semantic similarity of the input attacks and the harmfulness of the model's
responses. Automatically identifying vulnerable semantic regions enhances the
evaluation of model weaknesses, facilitating targeted improvements to its
safety mechanisms and overall reliability. | [
0.0295280777,
0.0616664067,
-0.0347713009,
0.0611071251,
-0.0178087521,
0.0153463278,
0.0263550766,
0.0117713138,
0.0338664241,
-0.0625492111,
-0.0186717007,
-0.0061242869,
-0.0108500216,
0.0166887026,
0.0736628249,
-0.0473680124,
0.0626313686,
-0.0339656994,
-0.0383661129,
-0.001556113,
0.0046654497,
-0.0084790923,
0.0041913306,
0.0691020563,
0.0118538132,
-0.0208285041,
0.0125603834,
0.0140878372,
0.0332591273,
-0.0214506015,
0.0124329021,
0.0312744379,
-0.0168247204,
0.0790239722,
0.0000018097,
-0.0240995996,
-0.0309715774,
0.020576518,
-0.0022617611,
0.0094334166,
0.046855893,
-0.0087128039,
-0.0101601491,
0.0294370949,
-0.0251780748,
-0.0318768211,
0.0515108109,
0.0464532897,
0.0824203119,
0.0848414004,
-0.0118091451,
-0.0001988854,
0.0372726806,
-0.0050356598,
-0.0199889131,
-0.0555770881,
0.0510120429,
-0.0033569781,
-0.0358998664,
0.0285253674,
0.0126447547,
0.0194783211,
0.0132564595,
0.0041944054,
-0.0528699234,
0.0199377667,
-0.054291945,
-0.0207206327,
0.0174734108,
0.0786964297,
-0.0501065031,
-0.0147261415,
0.0038927095,
0.0079820231,
0.020016918,
0.018720692,
-0.0326681398,
0.0179068074,
-0.0008750511,
-0.0197632685,
0.0029413369,
0.020264497,
0.0503753126,
0.0117051015,
-0.0024516669,
0.035625618,
0.0346616171,
-0.0018873233,
-0.0103104077,
-0.0442852713,
-0.0431537963,
-0.0269000828,
0.0020389124,
-0.0175332166,
-0.0056793438,
0.0465998352,
-0.1008623764,
-0.0382243171,
0.0580930486,
-0.0618250407,
0.0372952744,
0.00541778,
-0.0126020135,
0.0355877876,
-0.0113731986,
0.0179782603,
-0.0202529132,
0.0395442545,
-0.023876505,
0.0115299085,
-0.0196867026,
-0.0488601401,
-0.0176637918,
0.0202169865,
-0.0222182944,
0.0119036734,
-0.0310697556,
0.0432891138,
-0.0439017303,
0.0205695704,
-0.036976479,
0.0145766018,
-0.0050339745,
0.0156207932,
0.0274917688,
-0.0322532021,
-0.0405447632,
0.0029943809,
-0.007259489,
-0.0949337035,
-0.0212411955,
0.0296121016,
-0.0460486598,
-0.0418207832,
-0.0492508076,
0.1220916733,
0.0290832203,
-0.0233661085,
-0.0431616791,
-0.0637854263,
-0.0392405502,
0.0186382513,
-0.0104928901,
-0.0457945541,
0.0038013794,
-0.0313703865,
-0.02832512,
-0.0788527057,
0.0077581191,
0.0175673552,
-0.0321648233,
0.0891846791,
0.0017098291,
-0.0199613348,
0.0416390821,
0.031287007,
-0.0010324318,
0.0706750825,
0.0026701626,
0.0236409027,
0.0501073152,
-0.0001618379,
0.02427168,
0.0494344905,
0.0238701627,
0.0389032289,
-0.0648992285,
0.0160160121,
0.0386219136,
-0.0224469211,
-0.056789957,
0.0719083324,
-0.0234797075,
-0.0811900869,
0.073653549,
0.0515909605,
-0.0537936017,
0.0373876542,
0.00289729,
-0.0198866613,
-0.0135018779,
-0.0139398556,
-0.0757542327,
-0.0202133041,
-0.0835128203,
-0.0463901572,
0.0069391467,
0.0249325428,
-0.0264758226,
-0.0380357765,
-0.0108564552,
0.0264353976,
0.0453393646,
-0.0037429505,
0.0224248078,
0.0528839454,
-0.0116082598,
0.0332278647,
0.0218191016,
-0.0327288806,
-0.0152996378,
-0.060515888,
-0.029823212,
0.0099483933,
0.0630513877,
-0.069814235,
-0.0302307382,
-0.0284343939,
-0.0000363516,
-0.0031921347,
0.031643413,
0.0007283092,
-0.0016359877,
-0.0188178141,
-0.0129579548,
-0.0062556015,
0.035047628,
0.0080393478,
0.0229538549,
0.0035718807,
-0.0029203109,
-0.0262389667,
-0.0437629335,
0.0621358864,
0.012444674,
-0.0287268516,
0.0170616359,
0.0224399567,
0.034162797,
-0.0106019601,
-0.0225265659,
0.0274870936,
0.057445582,
-0.0102701075,
-0.0010826065,
-0.0090987151,
0.0012144722,
-0.0313976631,
0.0248441584,
-0.0208350159,
-0.0372180194,
0.0564202592,
-0.0498525873,
0.001898104,
0.0515095033,
-0.0455015153,
0.0099964431,
-0.0082443366,
0.0223347005,
-0.0183950495,
0.0225378666,
-0.0455401093,
0.0649395287,
-0.0067974161,
0.0100106243,
-0.0393491536,
0.0139978305,
-0.0078386953,
-0.0362958722,
-0.0663823038,
0.001111743,
-0.061357636,
0.0373201482,
0.0055559492,
-0.022599306,
-0.0280870218,
-0.0043297717,
-0.0327761732,
-0.0276929848,
-0.0231946204,
0.0061566154,
0.0499835685,
-0.0045709014,
-0.0152123133,
-0.0300152656,
-0.0123508656,
-0.0076393536,
-0.0231266301,
0.0467394926,
0.022446759,
-0.0069286344,
-0.0241390802,
-0.0324968547,
-0.0340225883,
-0.0300567374,
0.0978132784,
-0.0030360618,
-0.0079724835,
-0.0160370935,
0.0360387824,
-0.0191975851,
0.0499835387,
-0.017211277,
-0.0668479651,
0.0242637619,
0.0176768471,
-0.0236215778,
0.0787157342,
0.0388169438,
0.081936188,
0.0756978095,
0.0285092928,
-0.0136576742,
-0.0173198991,
-0.0048699616,
-0.0262350906,
-0.0060224161,
-0.0425176099,
0.037608657,
0.0387566425,
0.0382056199,
-0.0237864628,
-0.0415622965,
0.0549666397,
-0.0564480573,
-0.0285176691,
-0.0567768924,
-0.034380503,
-0.0163822509,
0.0192362312,
-0.0267723799,
-0.0435601138,
0.0823117644,
-0.0160400588,
0.0328514799,
-0.014712113,
-0.0482810661,
0.0291428305,
0.0599815287,
0.001049932,
0.0404160507,
0.0339349061,
-0.0362924822,
-0.0759194419,
-0.0316643417,
0.0208753813,
-0.0002169082,
0.0472748317,
-0.0255010035,
-0.0110472273,
0.0175441317,
-0.0210786387,
-0.0691200495,
-0.0510427244,
-0.0009657349,
0.0191278886,
-0.0012912418,
-0.0044065313,
-0.0474953353,
0.018800905,
0.0103753032,
-0.0107255448,
-0.0324012339,
-0.0013395448,
-0.0190765373,
0.0444340929,
0.0601528659,
-0.0518030599,
0.0055967923,
-0.0244457647,
0.0491486564,
0.102359131,
0.0156103401,
0.0194991045,
-0.0311543439,
0.001639665,
0.0076898006,
-0.0071849348,
0.0020250268,
0.0240439847,
0.0216899738,
-0.0403101891,
-0.01926063,
0.0462345257,
0.037526723,
-0.004176985,
0.031723246,
0.0071361298,
0.0333699957,
0.0261634756,
-0.0098253507,
-0.0382622667,
-0.0071062036,
-0.0004106096,
0.032252375,
-0.0025128832,
-0.024800187,
0.0382812917,
-0.0821508467,
0.0070118406,
0.0012992286,
-0.0945365205,
-0.0238956641,
-0.0099905171,
-0.0075576417,
-0.0184951406,
0.031868998,
-0.0116782738,
0.0276366919,
-0.0338867679,
0.0213521346,
-0.0205653012,
-0.0369594842,
0.0155955125,
-0.0274764076,
0.04648415,
0.0772978067,
0.0246821307,
-0.0362097546,
0.0126462635,
0.0467587262,
-0.0197401289,
-0.0297389366,
0.0201812703,
0.0553569831,
0.0011313116,
-0.0243298877,
0.0196360908,
0.0348498933,
-0.0136859994,
-0.011371417,
0.044571016,
0.0259259082,
-0.0139435073,
-0.0057318928,
-0.0320195891,
0.0051485179,
0.0119858924,
0.062308196,
0.0434261262,
-0.0288224462,
-0.0017169012,
-0.0696402788,
0.011835047,
-0.0216727424,
-0.0584479868,
0.0306927674,
0.0168686304,
-0.0448357835,
-0.0745139867,
-0.005539807,
0.0085130055,
0.0008507835,
0.0208226852,
-0.033332862,
0.0009690194,
0.0122147389,
-0.0318544246,
0.0248893388,
0.0092266528,
0.0099112485,
-0.0303313341,
0.0281918254,
0.0262504146,
-0.0022404299,
-0.0365011096,
0.0346322656,
-0.0752940029,
-0.1081923842,
0.0197398383,
0.0544055067,
0.0113817668,
0.0078601222,
-0.0554310568,
-0.0788287073,
0.0782220885,
0.0154254027,
-0.0233203713,
-0.0221673548,
0.0424907394,
-0.0406905673,
0.0108663505,
0.0375093743,
-0.0389136449,
-0.0089052608,
0.0474181697,
-0.0160133168,
-0.0877751261,
-0.0073151258,
0.0023445659,
0.0252071116,
0.0789232329,
0.027921278,
-0.0244772639,
0.0065695043,
0.0013092676,
-0.0147091262,
-0.0379838161,
0.0045497715,
0.0398558229,
0.0243613049,
-0.0124914171,
0.0186175928,
-0.0116156908,
-0.002042379,
0.0319443084,
0.0167230144,
0.0229923856,
0.0447741672,
0.0553959571,
0.0311780032,
0.0269682668,
-0.0218287036,
0.0252239276,
-0.0185966995,
0.0181850754,
-0.008766233,
0.0057827821,
0.0079747336,
0.0129446201,
-0.0156689286,
0.0483434796,
-0.0521255508,
-0.0397396162,
-0.0111516677,
0.0105638737,
-0.0074624624,
-0.0029867145,
0.0095534315,
-0.0042800913,
-0.0343653373,
-0.0275097396,
-0.0092639122,
0.0132867657,
-0.0735223368,
0.0448672473,
0.0282458216,
-0.0200552996,
-0.009605662,
0.0690353066,
0.004074927,
0.0544978231,
0.0514336079,
-0.0302427262,
-0.0225076862,
-0.0086686034,
0.064850457,
0.0100993086,
-0.0223567523,
-0.0168428514,
-0.053927213,
-0.0967251137,
-0.0233312733,
0.012248056,
0.0122365737,
0.0453879088,
0.016917469,
0.0444742814,
0.0368218087,
0.0440295041,
-0.0597457774,
0.0025565063,
-0.0254698265,
-0.0495442748,
0.0056789899,
-5.661127529e-33,
0.0157564804,
-0.0596453175,
-0.0435613431,
-0.0550511554,
0.0211811215,
-0.0068889316,
-0.0156957489,
0.0079045845,
-0.0408277214,
-0.0153719271,
0.0174952373,
0.0172364749,
-0.0166229308,
0.0239309575,
-0.0306691509,
-0.0523901246,
0.0095638065,
-0.0183483101,
-0.0233114455,
0.0233420189,
0.0581286065,
0.0003214821,
0.0126983002,
-0.0588476472,
0.0324633345,
0.0178826042,
-0.0235833135,
0.0273573417,
-0.0192836225,
0.0841111615,
0.0020393408,
0.0453579091,
-0.0130477706,
-0.0218997151,
0.0026818889,
0.0375693962,
-0.0109114079,
-0.0329787582,
-0.0260126535,
-0.0129848029,
-0.0174063444,
-0.045268707,
0.0529509895,
-0.0376220495,
0.0359164886,
-0.0200434942,
0.0219560936,
-0.0199678857,
-0.0271041468,
-0.0057124831,
-0.0224031452,
0.0177989267,
-0.0466642529,
0.0014560804,
0.0027197308,
0.0380252339,
0.0521742366,
-0.0015129835,
-0.0235479958,
0.0181930717,
0.0204060841,
0.0209061597,
0.0544790551,
0.0227197222,
0.0189070664,
0.0582853071,
-0.0099057108,
0.0060875295,
-0.0033600843,
0.0053572129,
0.021373665,
0.0491326824,
0.0762205124,
0.0616489239,
0.0034024392,
-0.0226538498,
-0.0807492584,
0.0202447157,
-0.0293212142,
0.0399752297,
0.0342453308,
-0.0083384328,
-0.066925332,
-0.0125753395,
-0.0281843971,
-0.0353932753,
-0.0445761196,
-0.0258324016,
0.0287341941,
-0.0429191552,
-0.0656999871,
-0.0061661089,
-0.0156747457,
-0.0470685437,
0.0291828755,
0.0390753113,
0.0039855833,
-0.021439787,
0.0050354074,
0.0366971418,
0.0273782536,
-0.0160502773,
0.0099880761,
-0.0565219149,
0.0224846005,
0.0049750041,
0.0517638586,
0.0067858528,
-0.0567375869,
-0.0040566893,
-0.0059112115,
0.0173287708,
0.0181153677,
0.0578919798,
0.029271327,
-0.012122591,
-0.002248853,
0.0051294784,
0.0529651195,
0.0025849238,
-0.0365649201,
0.0284391008,
-0.0447719283,
0.0184827447,
-0.0133675076,
-0.0344928578,
-0.0337823965,
0.0331122577,
0.0831110254,
-0.0777535439,
-0.018626282,
-0.0244966447,
2.596e-7,
0.0318711326,
0.0456815995,
0.011653102,
0.0317539535,
0.0085626496,
0.0607949682,
0.0027087599,
0.0764413103,
-0.0045679384,
0.001729948,
0.0057822573,
0.0028530608,
0.0492675975,
0.0644590259,
-0.0566660091,
0.0111608887,
-0.0935007334,
0.0108489105,
-0.0441566855,
-0.0086486442,
0.0505404733,
0.1343372315,
0.016827872,
0.0002154099,
-0.0089643411,
-0.0629330277,
0.0016953306,
-0.0323873088,
0.0037675239,
0.0073575769,
0.0179695971,
0.0429952666,
0.0286689382,
0.0343284197,
-0.026705008,
-0.0325708054,
0.0104200896,
0.0170033127,
0.0012640823,
-0.0451278239,
-0.0304465033,
-0.0297765899,
0.014819378,
-0.0751600638,
0.0604105517,
-0.0494409949,
-0.0106871454,
0.0119295986,
0.00558213,
-0.0217342805,
0.0504773371,
-0.0614516251,
-0.0220162719,
0.0078670718,
0.0074684275,
-0.0043041026,
0.0447802022,
-0.0550079234,
-0.0186992288,
-0.0305977594,
-0.0249583982,
-0.0451786108,
0.0164223462,
0.0197894014,
-0.0009429285,
-0.0169473737,
0.0089735826,
2.38475294e-34,
-0.013549014,
-0.0047237524,
-0.0194019619,
-0.0109824026,
0.0223509278,
0.0003645916,
-0.0033517401,
0.0033627439,
-0.0064592981,
-0.0435909852,
-0.0366787426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04933v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04933v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models in Ophthalmology | 2023-11-07T16:19:45 | 2023-11-07T16:19:45 | Jason Holmes, Shuyuan Ye, Yiwei Li, Shi-Nan Wu, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Jinyu Hu, Huan Zhao, Xi Jiang, Wei Liu, Hong Wei, Jie Zou, Tianming Liu, Yi Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Purpose: The performance of three different large language models (LLMS)
(GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and PaLM2) in answering ophthalmology professional questions
was evaluated and compared with that of three different professional
populations (medical undergraduates, medical masters, and attending
physicians). Methods: A 100-item ophthalmology single-choice test was
administered to three different LLMs (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and PaLM2) and three
different professional levels (medical undergraduates, medical masters, and
attending physicians), respectively. The performance of LLM was comprehensively
evaluated and compared with the human group in terms of average score,
stability, and confidence. Results: Each LLM outperformed undergraduates in
general, with GPT-3.5 and PaLM2 being slightly below the master's level, while
GPT-4 showed a level comparable to that of attending physicians. In addition,
GPT-4 showed significantly higher answer stability and confidence than GPT-3.5
and PaLM2. Conclusion: Our study shows that LLM represented by GPT-4 performs
better in the field of ophthalmology. With further improvements, LLM will bring
unexpected benefits in medical education and clinical decision making in the
near future. | [
0.0451545976,
0.0186174717,
-0.0021274271,
-0.032775227,
-0.0425010547,
0.0101895696,
0.0281057432,
0.0491381884,
0.0284670293,
-0.0225936808,
0.0341085754,
-0.0536379889,
0.017849654,
0.0193650983,
0.0163060855,
-0.0515919998,
-0.009388024,
-0.0165315606,
0.0161300451,
-0.0184922349,
-0.020044947,
0.0037386327,
-0.0157042705,
0.0186042283,
0.0461047105,
-0.0337641314,
0.0706033334,
-0.0430123806,
0.0025234476,
-0.0286199376,
-0.0216129199,
0.0297738835,
-0.0186834987,
-0.0315338224,
0.0000023894,
-0.0736735165,
0.0057091704,
0.035399925,
-0.0017801799,
0.054414086,
0.059269093,
-0.0294134729,
0.0256633349,
0.0200065486,
-0.0246545393,
-0.0264459103,
0.032597445,
-0.0050054616,
-0.0014823177,
0.0289294124,
-0.0034962541,
0.0087572699,
0.0279872566,
-0.0179481655,
-0.0191037711,
-0.0065593012,
0.0384691767,
0.0457668789,
0.0009937808,
-0.0058133528,
-0.0191668235,
0.0328146406,
-0.0302008856,
0.0174195524,
0.0104814572,
0.0279144701,
-0.0066641732,
-0.0178634133,
0.0210831277,
-0.006363498,
0.0303775035,
-0.003544355,
-0.0210544076,
-0.008856466,
0.0184525959,
0.0635791719,
-0.0891628563,
0.0395074971,
0.0088754147,
-0.0067323642,
0.0050755301,
-0.0304268841,
-0.007594265,
0.0260664001,
-0.0484005027,
-0.0144107537,
0.0388739854,
-0.0052898158,
0.0446305536,
0.0120336553,
-0.0150031196,
-0.0208793301,
0.0166831035,
0.0576247424,
-0.0334031545,
0.0059535643,
0.026731845,
0.026988728,
0.0694800243,
-0.0398095176,
0.0182158016,
0.0226352718,
-0.0174573213,
0.0086734677,
-0.0407711826,
0.0543801188,
-0.0055691623,
-0.00061837,
-0.0387944877,
0.0225904174,
-0.0309547503,
-0.0066144047,
0.0205896627,
-0.0066097085,
0.0065155318,
-0.0054172012,
-0.0826383606,
-0.0365421548,
0.010876134,
-0.0138820158,
-0.0440973118,
0.017404383,
-0.0079520866,
0.0114941578,
-0.0564719923,
0.0725637674,
0.0280874223,
-0.0039903806,
-0.0459391512,
-0.0321124978,
0.0471631549,
0.0049090805,
-0.0169796925,
0.0181008279,
-0.0016992348,
0.0749350265,
-0.0266927239,
0.0077701332,
0.0274981856,
-0.0303820949,
-0.0267502256,
-0.0293281414,
-0.0156992208,
-0.0717291385,
-0.0203251075,
0.0675952137,
0.0206672587,
-0.0137277851,
0.0283482149,
0.055476781,
0.0101854065,
-0.0077589625,
-0.0553609766,
0.0308868159,
0.0520087406,
0.0158205368,
0.042089697,
-0.0277306829,
0.0120885894,
-0.0269770753,
-0.0268622003,
-0.0914802328,
0.0287123583,
0.003543701,
-0.0469720028,
-0.0106895557,
-0.0117155137,
0.0187072102,
0.0358276777,
0.070317477,
-0.0490897708,
0.0864934847,
-0.0038069279,
-0.0069377315,
0.0385585837,
0.057650093,
0.0158717241,
0.0261015948,
-0.0188012999,
-0.0146803595,
0.0557318255,
0.0074175159,
0.0120358532,
0.0052570221,
-0.0108261555,
0.0030305472,
-0.0694040135,
0.0347022489,
0.0083570816,
-0.0328790769,
-0.065854311,
0.0116029559,
-0.0304237604,
0.0153028024,
0.03753056,
-0.0714394674,
-0.0291887447,
0.0354176946,
0.025706321,
-0.0411954895,
-0.0175231136,
-0.0345332623,
-0.0062535298,
0.0502076894,
0.0154514853,
0.0040937955,
-0.0234529506,
-0.0265763551,
-0.020626124,
0.0475805402,
0.0523799323,
-0.012097788,
-0.0035252078,
-0.0481517278,
0.0327147096,
0.0238808375,
0.0051460513,
-0.0303148683,
-0.0254056137,
0.0650193617,
-0.0065388838,
0.0076955762,
-0.056459602,
0.0064171939,
-0.0729938596,
-0.0182742551,
-0.0229203589,
-0.0312456898,
-0.0162821934,
-0.0060534859,
0.010500785,
0.0301774498,
-0.0155799584,
0.0033047977,
0.0011531229,
-0.0458482504,
-0.0373231582,
0.0416508019,
0.0694264993,
-0.0602671169,
0.0151770851,
-0.0167242717,
0.0091817304,
-0.0128372181,
-0.0199230406,
-0.0482358374,
0.0605538972,
-0.0125239948,
0.0264220927,
-0.0219471157,
0.0031680791,
-0.0569346547,
0.0142956264,
0.0148740653,
0.0256715901,
0.0227592178,
-0.0607214645,
0.0317825675,
-0.0600303151,
-0.0262057669,
0.0153604625,
0.0082030995,
0.0346977785,
-0.0037979824,
0.0385657549,
-0.0372225717,
-0.0490276739,
-0.0877616256,
-0.0558255948,
0.0397923812,
-0.0179209132,
0.0197432116,
-0.0480886288,
0.0006143122,
0.0133533664,
-0.0372737758,
-0.0036682691,
0.0228295177,
0.0107661318,
0.0082558692,
0.0361834913,
-0.0105772819,
-0.0461611152,
-0.0525736474,
-0.0492224656,
0.0125773372,
0.0706895813,
-0.0164953861,
0.0063745091,
0.0406047776,
-0.0378592014,
-0.0139679443,
0.0077370247,
-0.0337377265,
0.0481622592,
-0.0135528725,
0.0334444717,
0.0518495776,
0.0057600276,
-0.0005946375,
0.0477335677,
-0.0172558483,
-0.0027826189,
-0.0467378907,
-0.0067102062,
-0.0657224879,
-0.0297068637,
-0.1098292395,
-0.0405005142,
0.0164996926,
0.0194624793,
-0.013085058,
-0.0143987015,
0.0013860618,
-0.0667547733,
0.0180531833,
-0.0616286136,
0.0181800611,
-0.0289288498,
0.0651976913,
0.0434915945,
-0.0458973907,
0.0623407625,
0.0102589279,
0.0499278419,
-0.0683072805,
-0.0133272251,
-0.0211923402,
0.021046754,
-0.0248220526,
-0.0044824467,
0.0011643138,
-0.0212719105,
-0.0441454835,
0.0074380739,
0.0211494304,
-0.0622915365,
0.0980402753,
-0.0502487943,
-0.0168131813,
-0.0073835123,
0.0001274678,
-0.0332504287,
0.005656763,
-0.0147183249,
-0.00114088,
-0.008667348,
0.0164827425,
-0.0507086366,
0.0350637548,
0.0272613335,
0.0300202165,
-0.0245262682,
-0.0007323163,
0.0171904117,
-0.0290218461,
0.0458026789,
0.0169181991,
0.0222335309,
-0.0383675471,
0.0442872047,
0.0497304238,
0.0026633206,
0.0326807722,
-0.025128318,
-0.0239980686,
0.0424741469,
-0.0260499716,
-0.028283542,
0.0390225053,
-0.0247838553,
-0.0528943278,
0.0415426716,
0.10569226,
0.0233464111,
-0.0349778906,
-0.0067965603,
-0.0406321362,
-0.0407082066,
0.0159290358,
0.0120380372,
-0.0471627712,
0.0135688018,
-0.0401815102,
0.0463276096,
0.0060949088,
-0.0173766632,
0.0353467017,
-0.0472105667,
0.0307456665,
0.0275825765,
-0.0248348247,
-0.0141973225,
-0.0193221513,
0.0295913778,
0.0247034803,
-0.0002968798,
0.0246743765,
-0.0243021194,
0.020587191,
0.0169122051,
-0.0842689648,
-0.0340779386,
0.0777226463,
0.0069394805,
-0.0057635196,
0.0066919965,
0.0064773997,
-0.039427314,
-0.045297835,
0.0095599229,
-0.0190998539,
-0.0008283344,
-0.011019622,
0.0647969022,
0.0288277417,
0.0091947494,
-0.0515078902,
0.007926465,
-0.0265755076,
0.0127218505,
0.0242681578,
0.0655124784,
-0.0061806412,
-0.0278905313,
-0.017363932,
0.0275507011,
-0.0349262394,
0.0125362333,
-0.0016920236,
-0.0282856133,
0.0201544669,
-0.0028952351,
0.0264796354,
0.0387273543,
-0.0183680765,
0.0236124713,
0.0335404761,
-0.0114155551,
-0.0309343077,
-0.0066798441,
0.0578366034,
0.0022143191,
0.028688971,
0.0471216589,
0.0362732708,
-0.0211209673,
-0.0329266116,
0.0591417067,
0.0294002499,
0.0356048904,
-0.0609299317,
-0.0151195312,
0.0639458448,
-0.0115936138,
-0.0281565133,
-0.0116766794,
0.0219976362,
-0.0071180537,
0.01117991,
0.0443211347,
0.0247406773,
-0.0801711604,
0.0208188146,
-0.0456597395,
-0.0303557757,
-0.0067218021,
0.0075732884,
0.0207002517,
-0.0497926734,
0.0070499289,
0.0166286137,
-0.0310312063,
-0.0086387508,
-0.0419061258,
0.0180696268,
0.007834347,
-0.0040865247,
-0.0602896698,
0.0309995245,
0.0866219699,
0.0658743232,
-0.0010883163,
0.0092560574,
-0.0165445935,
-0.0074784183,
-0.0461982973,
0.0065564262,
-0.015850706,
-0.004178029,
0.0645672679,
0.0348491669,
-0.005118418,
-0.0410929695,
-0.0620133914,
-0.0440943092,
-0.0585437417,
0.0867093503,
-0.0030821778,
-0.0412474461,
0.0785367116,
0.0076351278,
-0.0498842038,
-0.0704165921,
-0.0036829144,
0.0355700515,
0.033796709,
0.1130897626,
-0.011901658,
0.0071446956,
0.0540228114,
-0.0080771483,
0.0213207733,
-0.0574576892,
-0.0142411022,
0.0183690973,
-0.0028676651,
0.0062544583,
0.0183114149,
-0.0357585326,
0.0100729689,
-0.0505364649,
-0.0050014462,
-0.0081701819,
0.0138525981,
0.0753705353,
0.0110163139,
-0.0090124207,
-0.0348051228,
0.063125208,
0.024416212,
-0.0361257233,
-0.0140572945,
-0.0453379117,
-0.0209519491,
-0.0087897209,
0.0221880116,
-0.0036652642,
-0.0505210645,
0.0303539205,
-0.1057593971,
-0.0360674523,
-0.0390608832,
0.0026930184,
0.0060472852,
-0.050067205,
0.0247289967,
0.0596799366,
-0.0045980546,
-0.0137223089,
-0.0467167497,
0.0712992996,
0.0029671465,
-0.0011313227,
0.0135339275,
-6.183631462e-33,
0.0069469796,
-0.0312091261,
0.0582666211,
-0.0422034487,
-0.0057013836,
0.0151473125,
-0.0183813833,
0.035395585,
-0.0450994149,
0.0034913931,
-0.0037524747,
-0.0105395718,
0.0101246014,
0.0465347096,
0.0249311067,
-0.0120940935,
-0.0273278318,
0.0298020802,
-0.0042498433,
-0.0351676494,
-0.041838564,
-0.0297473036,
0.059036959,
-0.042246554,
-0.0083984798,
-0.0120165423,
0.0414137468,
-0.0584406294,
-0.02988334,
0.0583294109,
0.0054669166,
0.0595109686,
0.0319761895,
-0.0140427127,
0.0052991514,
-0.0244888384,
-0.00613411,
-0.0221084785,
0.0521199442,
-0.0126666222,
-0.0478620864,
0.0118514355,
0.0275695063,
-0.0245123003,
-0.0366936997,
-0.0270643588,
0.0271786414,
-0.0421231836,
-0.0401215963,
0.0323839374,
-0.0434390977,
0.0185595825,
0.0327855647,
0.0258239675,
-0.0596411936,
0.0112617249,
-0.0315770544,
0.0212103073,
0.0170399118,
0.041586034,
0.0747541413,
0.0297683086,
0.0125118429,
-0.0013499727,
0.0086958371,
0.0293889306,
0.0433227569,
-0.0276032053,
0.0027870664,
-0.0514762402,
-0.0015666889,
-0.0004444811,
0.0752616152,
0.0412004367,
-0.0017419924,
-0.0239866711,
-0.0747858286,
-0.0055999854,
-0.0318698883,
0.0651109219,
0.0070571848,
-0.0125928614,
-0.0513893515,
-0.0345841497,
-0.0135774966,
0.0121948505,
-0.0128532769,
-0.0117958523,
0.0397316255,
-0.0380886644,
0.0177978929,
0.0480933897,
0.0494347662,
-0.0022954193,
0.0137858326,
-0.0535561927,
-0.0471025705,
0.0574785024,
-0.03950838,
0.0220889673,
-0.08643426,
0.036712613,
-0.0047807302,
-0.0203730483,
0.0448081009,
0.0342867225,
-0.0555667989,
-0.0344386809,
-0.0537120551,
-0.0022314824,
0.0013862486,
-0.0494999699,
0.0071633691,
0.0106068142,
0.0184207112,
-0.0005400254,
0.0195592791,
0.0389681496,
-0.0187350884,
-0.0891081542,
-0.0313228667,
-0.0795186087,
0.0065795248,
-0.0100675831,
-0.015131169,
0.0306695066,
0.0018832468,
0.0464014784,
0.035985712,
0.0065249056,
-0.0126675433,
0.0072814203,
2.987e-7,
0.0721835569,
0.1071474776,
-0.0537302271,
0.0116324201,
0.0184782483,
-0.0039424356,
0.0012112226,
-0.0257332344,
0.0571803898,
-0.0101481928,
0.0021670221,
-0.0090157725,
-0.0004280328,
0.0125983953,
-0.0043584807,
-0.0124431839,
-0.0291536581,
-0.0108773448,
-0.0393142961,
0.0084260227,
0.0536650084,
0.0168831274,
-0.0466570854,
-0.040465124,
-0.0177679881,
-0.0382845663,
0.0476045869,
-0.0479620025,
-0.0117596807,
0.0592659116,
0.0296454765,
0.0017853348,
0.0514536612,
0.1207077876,
-0.0090007139,
-0.0450695008,
0.0598847494,
0.0625592843,
-0.0422920249,
0.0436122939,
0.0566652939,
0.0145426411,
0.0117279431,
-0.103684321,
0.0258499812,
-0.0001905824,
-0.0200208593,
0.0342118554,
-0.0555706322,
-0.0292061046,
0.0580129251,
-0.0446852855,
-0.0499219932,
0.0048781424,
0.0163266081,
0.0284509212,
-0.0378338955,
-0.0106017794,
0.0135103883,
-0.0045378809,
-0.0046121893,
-0.0632497594,
0.0115945833,
-0.0740000978,
0.0102510657,
-0.0387585834,
-0.0223674215,
2.809536191e-34,
0.051125247,
0.0209784228,
0.0438393131,
-0.0236706417,
0.0110588595,
-0.0020993464,
-0.0094062053,
0.0423570275,
0.0236287974,
-0.0348806828,
-0.0239652004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04088v1 | Personality Style Recognition via Machine Learning: Identifying Anaclitic and Introjective Personality Styles from Patients' Speech | 2023-11-07T15:56:19 | 2023-11-07T15:56:19 | Semere Kiros Bitew, Vincent Schelstraete, Klim Zaporojets, Kimberly Van Nieuwenhove, Reitske Meganck, Chris Develder | cs.CL | cs.CL | In disentangling the heterogeneity observed in psychopathology, personality
of the patients is considered crucial. While it has been demonstrated that
personality traits are reflected in the language used by a patient, we
hypothesize that this enables automatic inference of the personality type
directly from speech utterances, potentially more accurately than through a
traditional questionnaire-based approach explicitly designed for personality
classification. To validate this hypothesis, we adopt natural language
processing (NLP) and standard machine learning tools for classification. We
test this on a dataset of recorded clinical diagnostic interviews (CDI) on a
sample of 79 patients diagnosed with major depressive disorder (MDD) -- a
condition for which differentiated treatment based on personality styles has
been advocated -- and classified into anaclitic and introjective personality
styles. We start by analyzing the interviews to see which linguistic features
are associated with each style, in order to gain a better understanding of the
styles. Then, we develop automatic classifiers based on (a) standardized
questionnaire responses; (b) basic text features, i.e., TF-IDF scores of words
and word sequences; (c) more advanced text features, using LIWC (linguistic
inquiry and word count) and context-aware features using BERT (bidirectional
encoder representations from transformers); (d) audio features. We find that
automated classification with language-derived features (i.e., based on LIWC)
significantly outperforms questionnaire-based classification models.
Furthermore, the best performance is achieved by combining LIWC with the
questionnaire features. This suggests that more work should be put into
developing linguistically based automated techniques for characterizing
personality, however questionnaires still to some extent complement such
methods. | [
0.0417848304,
0.0610797778,
-0.0406264476,
-0.0019073822,
-0.0446370244,
0.0164645966,
0.0235473569,
-0.0209836848,
0.0037843559,
-0.0114604002,
0.0226827394,
0.0232073721,
-0.0231194012,
-0.0015190159,
-0.0066142888,
-0.0575611182,
-0.0073807989,
0.0366149321,
0.0164449587,
-0.0085111959,
-0.0193118397,
0.038242273,
-0.0158380866,
0.0350590274,
0.0204222631,
-0.0213724207,
0.0135809425,
-0.0137638245,
0.0322061479,
0.0011585638,
-0.0041294475,
0.0711165071,
-0.0162008628,
-0.0226399414,
0.0000019661,
-0.0322790518,
-0.0079688029,
-0.0170167554,
0.0309622884,
-0.0847640634,
0.0261048526,
0.012066775,
0.0406390913,
0.0466461405,
-0.0289985202,
-0.0756955221,
0.0302402843,
0.0812024772,
0.0694223419,
0.0319782458,
-0.026124645,
-0.0582859553,
-0.0053859395,
0.0173576679,
0.004148718,
0.0304546319,
0.0345520228,
-0.0508214645,
-0.0308648609,
-0.0106799603,
0.0033279068,
0.0023242519,
-0.0609526113,
0.04797934,
-0.0062833815,
-0.0478839464,
-0.0705029145,
-0.0125476941,
0.0220998898,
0.0351798795,
0.0769118294,
-0.0157486033,
0.0020523202,
-0.008846119,
0.0279036164,
0.0233296715,
0.0326775983,
-0.0028698447,
-0.0250915438,
-0.0430150293,
0.0364361852,
0.02297909,
-0.0282066315,
-0.0293636955,
-0.0221878011,
0.0156844202,
-0.0113553377,
-0.0098651266,
0.0341585428,
-0.0291003138,
0.0033852942,
-0.0803193748,
0.0042857151,
0.0148161445,
-0.0129470369,
0.0227442924,
-0.0554270297,
-0.0291184541,
0.0347940475,
-0.0248330869,
-0.0117265191,
-0.0051471284,
-0.0745758563,
-0.0244706962,
0.0658199042,
0.0260911472,
0.0400347486,
0.0009340176,
-0.0369570665,
-0.0062012253,
-0.1004920825,
-0.0020166535,
0.0207313057,
0.0195835084,
0.0556959808,
0.0241144672,
-0.0851373896,
0.0179743916,
0.005673321,
-0.0045010303,
0.0076672938,
0.0023289321,
0.0395576842,
0.0815459788,
-0.0177134331,
0.0255295523,
-0.0218394808,
-0.0087168021,
-0.0288011003,
-0.0079001114,
0.0839015543,
-0.0085381633,
0.0215595923,
-0.0475359671,
0.0572411902,
0.01364318,
0.0459773019,
-0.0553113371,
-0.037543714,
-0.0275718775,
-0.0461275205,
-0.0155372396,
0.0129438965,
-0.0414515436,
0.0061771525,
0.0246897303,
-0.0172701348,
-0.051363837,
0.0113345329,
0.0186928455,
-0.0094284015,
0.0609992519,
-0.0010394782,
0.0182615314,
0.0386587121,
-0.0098286103,
0.0274733622,
-0.0138798235,
0.0180363916,
-0.0333863236,
0.0226774886,
-0.0860086679,
0.0474821106,
-0.0032740068,
-0.0073414342,
-0.0596423782,
-0.0031517851,
-0.0277328789,
-0.0119467815,
0.0271823145,
-0.0019530548,
0.0400079563,
0.0156923831,
-0.0110709304,
0.0527840629,
0.0686854795,
0.0481870398,
0.0282069314,
-0.0123022087,
0.0310734846,
0.0350155011,
0.0156407729,
-0.0013134612,
-0.0254317112,
-0.0061570094,
-0.0145726558,
-0.0269525032,
-0.0182344578,
0.0038372765,
-0.0391691774,
-0.0336289778,
-0.0200279504,
0.0360249504,
0.0410946049,
-0.0447526462,
-0.0122756967,
0.011754646,
-0.0069971429,
0.0490706377,
0.0019147508,
-0.0632408336,
-0.0699821189,
-0.0273236502,
0.0652091876,
0.0106323175,
-0.0411101244,
-0.0116216503,
-0.0377235673,
-0.0545617118,
0.0011646976,
0.0241849311,
0.0023321058,
0.0239243228,
-0.0096009159,
0.0318846479,
0.0291821361,
-0.0023234419,
0.008566374,
-0.0306473747,
0.0285171047,
-0.0497428067,
0.0132655585,
0.0031214019,
0.0432436131,
-0.0566112772,
-0.1042855754,
0.0582768284,
0.0268834699,
0.0500346348,
0.0294977948,
-0.0238885321,
-0.0155414427,
-0.0058463337,
0.0078240782,
-0.025206726,
0.0416744873,
0.0060053258,
-0.0383826829,
-0.0272458121,
0.0113684414,
-0.0107000014,
0.0397393592,
0.017283503,
-0.0157306008,
0.0021385853,
-0.065104492,
0.0286557637,
-0.0213721674,
0.0128937121,
-0.0392851047,
0.0659022853,
-0.046653863,
0.0129617257,
0.0134112546,
0.0183578245,
-0.0131803676,
-0.0544788614,
-0.0157917794,
-0.0200245306,
-0.0471364968,
-0.0559834018,
0.0048160092,
0.0235943608,
-0.0209935009,
-0.0050647748,
-0.0019957693,
-0.0196508802,
-0.1008515209,
0.0104127191,
0.0160386376,
0.0098194797,
-0.0117230285,
-0.0017591164,
-0.0265478604,
0.0059356871,
-0.0237253681,
-0.0319030508,
0.0422375463,
0.0303710904,
0.0410959497,
0.0140386317,
-0.0171655063,
-0.0110647334,
0.0052762302,
-0.0515664741,
0.0114007583,
-0.0464122854,
0.0221241526,
-0.0085425889,
-0.028092647,
-0.062626265,
-0.0107203666,
0.0041165538,
-0.0464826711,
0.010586787,
0.0074484996,
0.002901302,
0.0367408246,
0.0273570362,
0.0456140004,
0.0145067731,
0.0232932847,
0.0035975927,
-0.0044772029,
0.0003231344,
0.0035444566,
-0.0354225263,
-0.0611367188,
0.0064603868,
0.0317966342,
0.0518587939,
-0.0015177709,
-0.0057547349,
0.0016296689,
0.0513527393,
0.0066873645,
0.0603189357,
0.0082401531,
-0.0383193493,
0.054661043,
0.06943544,
0.0022265587,
0.0782146528,
-0.0157350209,
0.0102773206,
-0.057516396,
-0.0811503381,
-0.024313163,
0.0451144502,
0.0136675509,
0.0252948292,
0.0748137683,
-0.0397113487,
-0.0017278576,
-0.059815906,
0.004771092,
-0.0312444866,
0.0303859916,
-0.0115047647,
-0.0450098962,
0.0314613059,
-0.0175069738,
-0.0709230751,
-0.0691425428,
-0.001605158,
0.0037109093,
0.0196728613,
-0.023645943,
-0.0319776274,
-0.0351390168,
0.0264642369,
0.0026700802,
-0.0098836552,
-0.0321047604,
0.0271792021,
0.0333873667,
0.0301210303,
0.0195062216,
-0.0034491175,
-0.0039811819,
-0.0430978537,
-0.0167094227,
-0.0930045769,
0.0625528023,
-0.0190502759,
0.0087262699,
-0.0055235736,
-0.020452207,
-0.0104081016,
0.0297456589,
-0.0004447873,
0.0047240062,
-0.0134112481,
0.1210938171,
0.0442735627,
-0.0028750256,
0.0205344651,
0.0280241109,
-0.0249961987,
0.0218600743,
0.0588033311,
-0.0110719511,
-0.0317569189,
-0.0287377723,
0.0671459734,
-0.076465331,
-0.004888332,
-0.0095644221,
-0.0214914512,
0.0370741077,
-0.0332966559,
-0.0134146605,
0.0129796648,
-0.037993405,
-0.0075916266,
-0.0227358863,
-0.0369686261,
-0.0602538548,
-0.0196151063,
-0.0182300583,
0.0067105391,
-0.1268101484,
-0.0421290696,
0.0754058361,
0.0012788684,
0.0348791629,
0.0226212796,
0.0344338119,
-0.0245592557,
-0.0204402991,
-0.0719325766,
0.0189593043,
0.0174955167,
0.0254014935,
0.070796825,
0.0066003115,
0.0236507263,
-0.0896439105,
0.0358641483,
-0.0316689387,
0.0352251641,
0.0139259258,
0.0541552678,
-0.0321059898,
-0.0256039761,
-0.0346446969,
0.0331705995,
0.0213669818,
0.0257031024,
-0.013408673,
-0.0629056543,
-0.0155750774,
0.0381818116,
0.0162288714,
0.0189428367,
-0.061958842,
0.0042604753,
0.0078354925,
-0.0145270266,
-0.0589843318,
-0.0735773444,
0.0177018084,
-0.0026314522,
-0.0054489421,
-0.056429714,
-0.0014006682,
0.0468663611,
-0.1003830954,
0.01230314,
0.073664017,
0.0180986393,
-0.0018224852,
-0.0418511517,
0.0788037926,
-0.049428381,
-0.0323623866,
0.0136606339,
-0.0194155611,
-0.0199846756,
0.0683890805,
0.0005271134,
0.003248248,
0.0072249551,
0.0295755975,
-0.0440873653,
0.0266567245,
0.0316246115,
0.0210037269,
-0.002166478,
-0.0079150824,
0.0246643983,
-0.0414949991,
0.0091888364,
-0.0027633277,
0.033195883,
-0.0054247733,
-0.0823609233,
-0.0451393798,
-0.0607910603,
0.000179682,
0.0312293004,
0.0005116295,
-0.0226278808,
-0.0225544367,
0.0057266764,
-0.030846132,
0.0234727394,
-0.0149069335,
-0.0150368512,
-0.0995840654,
0.0158806443,
0.0020122579,
-0.0504777133,
-0.0469753779,
-0.074056007,
-0.008087242,
-0.0330687724,
0.0615643896,
0.0543750525,
0.015299947,
-0.0538896918,
0.0096573662,
-0.0106228078,
-0.0053821332,
0.0358054936,
0.0380546302,
-0.0032058528,
0.0540932417,
-0.0223949682,
0.0412795246,
-0.0108845783,
0.0285400897,
-0.0582647137,
-0.0214204304,
-0.0113082724,
-0.013836029,
0.0045609474,
-0.0110427653,
-0.0061036809,
-0.0157958735,
0.0198325925,
-0.0014787172,
0.0464675985,
-0.0174475834,
0.0097058183,
0.0315892138,
0.025256684,
-0.0113670798,
-0.0492546931,
0.0108833918,
0.0347109027,
-0.0260447748,
-0.0129255578,
-0.0538372286,
-0.0616461635,
0.0133116599,
0.0450694226,
0.0228285845,
-0.0292005334,
0.003946492,
-0.046264682,
-0.0618969426,
0.0742427856,
-0.0496084206,
0.0212007873,
-0.0156804435,
0.0105124461,
0.0291040838,
0.0167059693,
-0.0425108671,
-0.0429935157,
0.0205697734,
-0.0428141505,
0.0125787621,
-0.0306599997,
-5.087009109e-33,
-0.0292524621,
-0.0317076109,
0.0112075862,
0.024273701,
0.0037440832,
-0.044524353,
0.0241520852,
0.0348782875,
-0.0166692194,
-0.0020303577,
-0.0250916965,
0.0197336506,
0.0047131646,
0.0262145568,
0.0181041025,
0.0047093201,
0.0234826989,
-0.0057336567,
-0.0214137454,
-0.0226385985,
0.0059192693,
0.0364951007,
0.0755960494,
-0.0621580593,
-0.0128578609,
-0.0035345422,
0.0292918701,
0.001325933,
0.0306438375,
0.0250550434,
0.0005037509,
0.0583065599,
0.0391139686,
-0.0055833277,
0.0318211913,
0.0158017725,
-0.0553819835,
-0.039156802,
-0.0161269866,
0.0339309685,
0.0102908155,
0.0058301939,
0.0228536632,
-0.0273465756,
-0.0207418036,
-0.026404744,
0.0813809335,
-0.016487062,
0.0519419126,
-0.0172094628,
-0.017297972,
0.0002587523,
-0.0246325601,
-0.0034769981,
-0.0191074666,
0.0073935254,
-0.0392681621,
-0.0043052714,
-0.0440270826,
0.0026785303,
-0.0236177389,
-0.0444128104,
-0.0279875305,
0.0075304075,
-0.0242983587,
0.0218790937,
0.0690753087,
0.0010229027,
0.0254954323,
0.0230276827,
0.0149744516,
0.0446293987,
0.0156275891,
0.0514730588,
0.0083737988,
-0.0110658584,
0.0001185802,
-0.0111987498,
0.0860007703,
-0.0586049408,
0.0242179222,
-0.0331753679,
-0.0193625726,
-0.0317085944,
-0.0349617414,
-0.0029943977,
-0.0004108166,
-0.0028134969,
-0.0028522597,
-0.0367189832,
-0.0019087514,
-0.0073322859,
0.0311803799,
-0.0207554996,
-0.0129269119,
-0.0078030555,
-0.0380941667,
0.0265617557,
-0.0161220431,
-0.0180165526,
0.0245086178,
-0.0026771685,
0.0192485135,
0.0058704326,
0.0998320505,
0.012161904,
0.0319045633,
-0.004686363,
-0.0520013049,
-0.0186169073,
0.0709726289,
0.0231108088,
-0.0353367031,
0.0925911069,
-0.0131244725,
0.0261364244,
-0.0017927055,
0.0009073557,
-0.0073081017,
0.024824366,
-0.0696653426,
-0.0519871339,
0.0072873896,
-0.0140575133,
0.0001641641,
-0.0141399018,
-0.0480970368,
-0.0007167244,
0.012402284,
-0.027731657,
0.0271137115,
-0.0194229353,
2.733e-7,
0.0073104128,
0.0815969482,
-0.0277393088,
0.0513214208,
0.0302651692,
0.0349499062,
0.0100377779,
0.0165998489,
0.0477365069,
-0.013214428,
0.0113066193,
0.0131651396,
0.0289419275,
0.062282335,
-0.0350327715,
0.0067703305,
0.0059925155,
0.011275718,
-0.044404231,
0.0256064776,
0.0954881459,
0.0758114159,
0.0108540058,
-0.038642928,
0.036305774,
0.0621482432,
-0.0021808664,
0.0378436148,
0.007505314,
0.05199733,
-0.0226822849,
-0.0229929164,
0.045292113,
0.0584722497,
-0.0037934519,
-0.0189511552,
-0.0264913309,
0.0555443875,
-0.0570628271,
-0.0310209356,
0.0052855578,
0.0633460656,
-0.0227540471,
0.0166863538,
0.0305277221,
-0.0035877477,
-0.055246029,
-0.0452255532,
-0.024659615,
-0.0589124896,
0.0752844736,
0.0206323732,
-0.0069198618,
0.0541380942,
0.0339108035,
-0.0225261822,
0.0367014781,
-0.0560075603,
0.0311107449,
0.04612514,
-0.0562349521,
0.0116503714,
0.0462888665,
-0.0029225433,
0.0620896146,
-0.0545015931,
0.0297416039,
2.272987075e-34,
-0.0166800488,
0.0833273008,
0.0034199881,
-0.0245644469,
0.0317474678,
0.0232164226,
0.0289697368,
0.0339492261,
0.020992564,
-0.0634999946,
-0.0015902804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04076v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04076v5 | Do LLMs exhibit human-like response biases? A case study in survey design | 2023-11-07T15:40:43 | 2024-02-06T04:16:17 | Lindia Tjuatja, Valerie Chen, Sherry Tongshuang Wu, Ameet Talwalkar, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become more capable, there is growing
excitement about the possibility of using LLMs as proxies for humans in
real-world tasks where subjective labels are desired, such as in surveys and
opinion polling. One widely-cited barrier to the adoption of LLMs as proxies
for humans in subjective tasks is their sensitivity to prompt wording - but
interestingly, humans also display sensitivities to instruction changes in the
form of response biases. We investigate the extent to which LLMs reflect human
response biases, if at all. We look to survey design, where human response
biases caused by changes in the wordings of "prompts" have been extensively
explored in social psychology literature. Drawing from these works, we design a
dataset and framework to evaluate whether LLMs exhibit human-like response
biases in survey questionnaires. Our comprehensive evaluation of nine models
shows that popular open and commercial LLMs generally fail to reflect
human-like behavior, particularly in models that have undergone RLHF.
Furthermore, even if a model shows a significant change in the same direction
as humans, we find that they are sensitive to perturbations that do not elicit
significant changes in humans. These results highlight the pitfalls of using
LLMs as human proxies, and underscore the need for finer-grained
characterizations of model behavior. Our code, dataset, and collected samples
are available at https://github.com/lindiatjuatja/BiasMonkey | [
0.0762828812,
0.0726991966,
-0.0402539521,
0.0020915596,
-0.0196070224,
0.0176960118,
0.0022132974,
0.0080571873,
0.0444864817,
-0.0331382938,
-0.0308113806,
-0.0335621163,
-0.0171896499,
-0.0270025302,
0.0326396078,
-0.0351394489,
0.039112065,
-0.0205370672,
0.0529159829,
-0.0334261432,
-0.0060343472,
0.0118698999,
-0.0056383344,
0.0201650113,
0.0122240456,
0.0073752739,
-0.0129762609,
0.0110963173,
-0.0072689741,
-0.0314270929,
0.0312372055,
0.0916589946,
-0.0071732341,
0.0158196017,
0.0000019835,
-0.0471258275,
0.0308030564,
-0.010131265,
-0.0167165715,
0.0146467118,
0.0908896029,
0.0283159893,
0.0032759525,
0.0164773148,
-0.0439969972,
-0.0002102533,
0.0555545352,
0.0053524487,
0.0054008882,
0.0166119114,
0.0056049777,
0.0046812412,
-0.0347410366,
-0.0127151217,
0.0416229479,
0.0099341245,
0.0166434795,
-0.0573190935,
0.0080853207,
0.007941436,
-0.0418877006,
-0.0115605565,
0.0097967414,
0.0259530973,
0.012455198,
-0.0106435819,
-0.0193428583,
-0.0589869544,
-0.0154810511,
0.0758123696,
0.0488860793,
-0.0311627425,
-0.0115083233,
-0.0160907302,
0.0426162668,
0.0460537076,
-0.0396855064,
0.0244381092,
0.0066325623,
-0.0195613578,
-0.0293779317,
-0.0219830088,
0.0030851311,
0.0116123026,
0.0312113669,
0.0841727331,
0.0116743958,
-0.0268231109,
0.0193773732,
0.0346461944,
0.0427769385,
-0.0540294498,
-0.0061173472,
-0.0043408684,
-0.0537826121,
0.0156378821,
-0.0052482323,
0.0073973574,
0.0660888031,
-0.0330780894,
0.040580526,
0.0386261195,
-0.0289656073,
-0.0138040883,
0.0317012183,
0.0429751016,
-0.0334685929,
0.0375043936,
-0.0323461927,
0.0265113357,
-0.0125183687,
-0.0312717669,
0.0301348213,
-0.016813485,
-0.0199652109,
0.0370921604,
-0.0426817946,
0.0278398842,
-0.0226417836,
-0.0097120367,
-0.0271136239,
0.0258380901,
-0.0207929555,
0.0175392348,
-0.0793579668,
0.0561447591,
-0.0530458018,
0.0279776622,
0.0136775179,
-0.0560058169,
0.0207121596,
0.0103546828,
-0.009410562,
-0.0382872745,
0.0011848386,
0.0368533991,
0.0238655079,
0.0167743359,
0.0083974171,
-0.0105113154,
-0.0198703874,
-0.0490204319,
0.0341832303,
-0.0390200652,
0.036083661,
0.040946357,
-0.0147344144,
-0.0196900647,
-0.0017985241,
0.0344467275,
-0.0533338487,
0.0636345521,
0.0087595293,
0.0298631135,
-0.0008381914,
-0.0026471447,
0.0127030574,
0.0630408451,
0.0137203149,
0.0042701983,
0.0359753445,
-0.0529762618,
0.0296248607,
0.0294726659,
-0.0157102309,
0.0198165067,
-0.0204450581,
0.0318418778,
-0.0103597762,
0.0151856663,
0.0684507266,
0.0445826985,
0.0031388714,
-0.0370763727,
0.0945813432,
0.0518101305,
-0.0542445369,
-0.003431875,
-0.0234939512,
0.0334163904,
0.0028673329,
0.040331386,
-0.0786993727,
0.0238274783,
-0.0195761435,
0.0054726466,
-0.0182204284,
-0.0135810683,
-0.0342414975,
-0.0471114181,
-0.0164026599,
0.0201855116,
0.0283570737,
0.0557983518,
-0.0042541116,
0.0065507782,
-0.0052779349,
0.0266284794,
0.0305046178,
-0.0683617145,
0.0108876638,
-0.0541775823,
0.0581713729,
0.0310361665,
0.0084517077,
-0.0203307811,
0.0346858725,
-0.0281843767,
0.0113454172,
0.0659409761,
0.114965111,
-0.012168359,
-0.0043367441,
0.006017122,
-0.0193776544,
0.0141206142,
0.0050923335,
0.0264940038,
-0.0107715912,
-0.0276424661,
-0.0236038994,
-0.051682882,
-0.0221991241,
0.0275488142,
0.0044175708,
-0.0297753662,
-0.0199669618,
0.0055359001,
0.0300966855,
-0.0056116944,
-0.0068703154,
0.0271680355,
0.0179574043,
0.028377939,
-0.0010231803,
-0.0256667007,
-0.0243489929,
-0.0156061221,
0.0087464023,
0.0073819407,
-0.0367185138,
0.0574149303,
-0.013889024,
-0.0018685504,
0.0173999984,
-0.0151133556,
0.0316078439,
-0.0124488324,
-0.0049545811,
-0.0286116879,
0.0072878976,
-0.0856444165,
0.00535203,
0.0118705779,
0.0170528181,
0.0100221531,
-0.0307909511,
-0.0112286489,
-0.042158965,
-0.0431495458,
0.0503573753,
-0.0196123607,
0.0131174494,
0.0325881578,
-0.013999437,
-0.0826809779,
-0.0329489447,
-0.0791007057,
-0.0119886836,
0.0067687151,
0.0012673527,
0.0069079949,
-0.0061471853,
-0.022908628,
-0.0176968183,
-0.0659004077,
-0.0477686599,
0.0267121196,
0.0908705518,
0.023537308,
-0.0290096719,
-0.0184535161,
-0.052499149,
-0.0285019148,
-0.0317722484,
0.0081010805,
0.0237763431,
0.0350510404,
-0.0399417616,
-0.0127548957,
-0.0323080383,
-0.0162338,
0.0197791215,
-0.038075462,
0.026870545,
0.024920892,
0.0480310135,
0.0986649245,
0.032929156,
0.0164568108,
0.0619659461,
0.012122348,
-0.0651192144,
-0.0156909022,
-0.0576677583,
-0.0484545715,
-0.0167768244,
-0.0643841475,
0.0091776494,
0.0495347083,
0.0386232138,
0.0097515276,
-0.0350771584,
0.0310089495,
-0.0355605893,
-0.0700337887,
-0.0194944516,
-0.023218248,
-0.0418736227,
0.0718272999,
-0.0099146916,
-0.0537773147,
0.0669344291,
0.0318648294,
-0.0143353157,
-0.0172269754,
0.0335892476,
-0.0149718914,
0.0233788956,
0.014413557,
-0.0060970732,
0.0326886773,
0.0034596552,
-0.0794053897,
-0.0434877574,
0.0147102512,
-0.045411855,
-0.0252891984,
-0.0382860005,
-0.0260301065,
-0.0117571382,
-0.0430892557,
-0.0332144164,
-0.0537669025,
-0.0217284784,
-0.0070025912,
-0.0032856383,
0.0055866921,
0.0425640717,
-0.0204364862,
0.0353283212,
-0.0295089241,
-0.0389945731,
-0.0072278269,
-0.0068172878,
0.0109326979,
0.0602597557,
0.0313156769,
0.0749100745,
-0.0342892706,
0.0015867311,
0.0395355225,
0.0498926379,
0.0284647606,
0.0097299721,
0.0279882196,
0.0524445847,
-0.0074994946,
-0.000737789,
0.0595339648,
0.0730986446,
-0.0223369151,
0.0177454296,
0.0735167488,
0.0168284699,
-0.0476795658,
0.0287426617,
-0.0398730822,
0.0758340508,
0.0345446356,
0.0151648112,
-0.0549102798,
0.0099415081,
0.0268536732,
0.0344646424,
-0.0626527816,
-0.0370094776,
0.0245390125,
-0.1321059018,
0.0470192507,
-0.0158348475,
-0.0169837158,
0.019899657,
-0.0421319902,
0.0393344015,
0.0025772159,
0.0214526057,
0.0132507104,
0.0094418805,
0.0107194725,
0.0214213096,
-0.0541545972,
-0.0360433348,
0.0114307618,
-0.0253373776,
0.0648654029,
0.072353974,
0.0290491618,
-0.0100684883,
-0.0380064584,
0.0630609468,
-0.0173129477,
-0.0101320148,
-0.0129924482,
0.0318978243,
-0.0045157913,
0.0033307595,
-0.0554726571,
0.0311635584,
-0.0489458665,
-0.0038319167,
0.0096688904,
0.0424250253,
0.0049502649,
-0.0303893164,
-0.0421654843,
0.0114839254,
0.0120431101,
0.0495380424,
0.0404928587,
-0.1035110727,
-0.0127943465,
-0.0379635654,
0.0035634069,
0.0160284936,
-0.080337815,
-0.0047397609,
0.0072244196,
-0.0115744835,
-0.0375987105,
-0.0709170997,
-0.0012616278,
-0.0321061164,
0.0161228515,
-0.0389713198,
0.0306106638,
-0.0360966884,
-0.0085644722,
0.0375110507,
-0.0223073326,
0.0313344039,
-0.046923507,
-0.0161700696,
0.0097106081,
-0.0349190198,
-0.0004990703,
-0.026761461,
-0.0414374359,
-0.0535765253,
0.0685336143,
0.0558986701,
0.0268029012,
0.0322429314,
0.0297473259,
-0.0509105027,
-0.0055259177,
0.0316642374,
-0.0442737564,
0.060140267,
0.0016191414,
0.0603537075,
-0.0286861993,
0.020834662,
-0.0133203594,
0.0077590495,
0.0717572644,
0.0205561239,
-0.0040676193,
-0.0700637922,
0.0271451008,
0.0233785175,
0.0785249323,
-0.014969036,
0.0191961899,
-0.002842851,
-0.0199579615,
-0.0086038038,
-0.0227756612,
-0.01222937,
-0.0566046871,
0.0221835896,
-0.0077983984,
-0.0061554234,
-0.0276917405,
-0.0523920506,
0.0544215627,
-0.0221038405,
0.0509276129,
-0.0026847387,
0.0329321884,
0.0078909704,
0.0345226526,
-0.015194824,
0.0416329131,
-0.0025031541,
0.0438190587,
0.0605928525,
0.0647701323,
0.0052021556,
-0.0314847082,
0.0051281359,
0.0098666055,
-0.0560089983,
-0.0441056713,
-0.0002114467,
-0.0104240933,
-0.0323528573,
-0.0170990676,
0.0127480505,
0.0112813246,
-0.0069776755,
-0.0399271287,
0.00197032,
0.0087770894,
-0.0108407009,
0.0530732498,
0.0159395617,
-0.0347965397,
-0.0103795249,
0.0200031288,
0.0277833585,
0.0114843315,
-0.0326941013,
-0.0105044981,
-0.0308296066,
-0.0271371845,
0.0243123211,
-0.0160428304,
-0.0272601936,
-0.0226663165,
-0.0980677679,
-0.057810884,
-0.0175265633,
-0.0070735398,
0.0222082138,
-0.0724207014,
0.0071103666,
0.0305405967,
-0.0422378704,
-0.0256170277,
-0.0381199867,
0.0264640991,
-0.0406357683,
0.0043665115,
-0.0499962196,
-6.095356979e-33,
-0.031572815,
-0.0168801174,
-0.0168570112,
-0.0313086472,
-0.0117359776,
-0.0423221923,
-0.0144208996,
0.0713957846,
-0.0254214965,
-0.0046038451,
-0.0313392878,
-0.0214168336,
0.0271624699,
0.0052924072,
0.0442002229,
-0.0439149253,
0.0496074334,
-0.0273549017,
-0.0449696966,
-0.0088921152,
-0.0265673213,
-0.0261776242,
0.0364171229,
-0.0935115069,
0.0688207224,
-0.0041614096,
0.0115021244,
-0.0038857926,
-0.0191208851,
0.0420049094,
-0.0268227607,
0.0753339455,
0.0134243444,
-0.0251771603,
-0.0079655927,
0.0817795545,
-0.0281912871,
-0.0340955555,
0.0219723787,
0.0275608245,
-0.0027590042,
-0.0216086414,
0.0232390575,
-0.0168804936,
-0.0674879551,
0.0051064915,
0.0345217697,
-0.0297594219,
0.0128936125,
0.0318821743,
-0.0324063487,
-0.0201379452,
-0.0162002668,
0.0021222101,
-0.0423745289,
0.096624814,
-0.0272285528,
0.0292485561,
-0.0396986231,
0.0458077565,
0.0086091366,
-0.0062955227,
0.0466478616,
0.0289820377,
0.0353357382,
0.0381286219,
0.0967784375,
0.0707924813,
-0.01085856,
-0.0298135169,
0.0377142355,
-0.0085799731,
0.0405135453,
0.0909114778,
0.0132138431,
-0.0211283155,
0.018416062,
-0.0300078113,
0.039346084,
-0.0068961247,
0.0507570878,
0.0175814778,
-0.0358269885,
-0.0531486385,
-0.0590458326,
-0.0434103347,
-0.0295888521,
-0.0219569411,
0.0578028709,
-0.028322868,
-0.0060537835,
-0.0309157837,
0.0402959958,
-0.0449042767,
-0.0323674046,
-0.0346575268,
-0.0317528173,
0.0238836575,
0.0250531416,
0.0002190914,
-0.0487566032,
0.0225296356,
-0.0118637858,
0.0188247263,
0.0178991389,
0.0173440836,
-0.0272228904,
-0.0166341383,
-0.0709143281,
-0.0090020336,
-0.0117553445,
0.0088818725,
0.0416967534,
0.014931174,
0.0248914622,
-0.0075327763,
0.0011980466,
0.0253903996,
-0.0230211709,
-0.0296225306,
-0.0569154434,
0.0113565596,
-0.0428255387,
0.0317623317,
-0.0246876013,
-0.0304754861,
-0.0158250108,
0.0243059713,
0.0287617519,
-0.0208961871,
-0.0251531787,
-0.0388903581,
2.582e-7,
0.0081396233,
0.0513000153,
-0.0118556377,
0.0177264214,
0.0117093464,
0.0511345603,
0.0115130832,
0.0435274132,
0.0694956779,
-0.0262785852,
-0.0081336489,
-0.0081146723,
0.0355976038,
-0.0011614996,
-0.0763290003,
-0.0162698347,
-0.0389831997,
0.0532180928,
-0.0233647972,
0.0355494209,
0.0388215519,
0.0290415622,
0.0034947707,
-0.0082773129,
-0.0494678505,
0.0208471511,
0.0324367583,
-0.084389478,
-0.0013340628,
0.0171245858,
-0.0072666528,
-0.014070835,
0.0376191698,
0.0606598817,
0.0202028658,
-0.0325816274,
-0.0152057018,
0.0485302061,
0.011957394,
-0.0556937419,
-0.0084085474,
0.0158140846,
0.0064366441,
-0.0709154084,
0.0526697524,
-0.043632485,
-0.0302513894,
-0.0289303083,
-0.0224414524,
-0.0327373743,
0.0532714538,
-0.0336296074,
-0.0120393997,
-0.008877378,
0.0425941423,
0.0211136471,
-0.0131675918,
-0.0187323783,
-0.0264479462,
-0.0148604885,
-0.0348349921,
-0.0936929211,
-0.0189051479,
0.0528056286,
-0.0388975404,
-0.0570931919,
0.0034356825,
2.216443042e-34,
0.0466505997,
0.0337545834,
0.0243146103,
-0.0088747879,
0.043498829,
0.0065520201,
0.0053760959,
0.0128621534,
0.0635579601,
-0.0521649346,
0.001918394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04260v1 | Fully Automated Task Management for Generation, Execution, and Evaluation: A Framework for Fetch-and-Carry Tasks with Natural Language Instructions in Continuous Space | 2023-11-07T15:38:09 | 2023-11-07T15:38:09 | Motonari Kambara, Komei Sugiura | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper aims to develop a framework that enables a robot to execute tasks
based on visual information, in response to natural language instructions for
Fetch-and-Carry with Object Grounding (FCOG) tasks. Although there have been
many frameworks, they usually rely on manually given instruction sentences.
Therefore, evaluations have only been conducted with fixed tasks. Furthermore,
many multimodal language understanding models for the benchmarks only consider
discrete actions. To address the limitations, we propose a framework for the
full automation of the generation, execution, and evaluation of FCOG tasks. In
addition, we introduce an approach to solving the FCOG tasks by dividing them
into four distinct subtasks. | [
0.0586504526,
0.0179295745,
0.0311628431,
0.0006124271,
-0.0572516136,
0.0033692874,
0.0010637809,
-0.0237372704,
0.0248809867,
-0.0858371407,
-0.0297506806,
-0.006721267,
-0.0105056129,
0.0627585128,
-0.0067650322,
-0.0508057922,
0.0115498221,
-0.0216951277,
-0.0372219793,
0.0202948842,
0.0281610712,
0.0093596065,
-0.0542993806,
0.0210134126,
-0.0545643158,
-0.0108198235,
-0.0676027015,
0.0030089153,
-0.0065407865,
-0.0413650312,
-0.0164975002,
0.0253134444,
0.055717241,
-0.0033983376,
0.0000020479,
-0.0554111153,
-0.0097713992,
0.0059094788,
-0.0267353207,
-0.0797206089,
0.0151549317,
-0.0468553938,
0.0103001529,
-0.0075229811,
-0.0147947939,
0.0344436057,
0.0501958355,
0.0706494227,
0.0415501669,
0.0199206229,
-0.0045850985,
-0.0053760465,
-0.0186175331,
0.0184529405,
0.0154294819,
-0.0600011274,
0.0042080404,
0.0679392219,
0.0759750232,
0.0179101024,
-0.0399739109,
-0.0094962437,
0.018677216,
0.0075430721,
-0.0126566505,
0.0421042256,
-0.0131531674,
-0.0398462862,
-0.0515470542,
0.0676398948,
-0.0026465519,
0.0031787707,
0.0064782533,
-0.0025451428,
-0.0051794676,
-0.0046938551,
-0.0338577852,
0.0592149459,
-0.0215845797,
-0.0043870569,
-0.0529590622,
-0.0086392723,
-0.0346587412,
-0.004467621,
-0.0186482258,
0.0876903087,
-0.0149582047,
0.0255730804,
0.0426455103,
0.0136308633,
-0.0207004156,
-0.063176021,
0.0288391504,
0.0649608597,
-0.0506718121,
0.0082512647,
-0.0315626599,
-0.0191533603,
-0.0055787326,
-0.0176616646,
0.0458092913,
0.0571507737,
-0.0810102671,
0.0521336645,
-0.0190737359,
0.1082002819,
-0.0177087132,
0.0350826494,
-0.0252772737,
0.0320358649,
-0.0684089437,
0.0072575863,
-0.0451304615,
0.0279938299,
-0.074529767,
-0.0176153947,
0.0255511887,
0.0127169779,
-0.0197142716,
-0.0171592683,
-0.0182844233,
0.0186825618,
-0.062524572,
0.0129574025,
-0.0280611049,
-0.0173553675,
-0.011788846,
0.0288914107,
-0.0029759295,
-0.031592194,
-0.0100721046,
0.0231314581,
0.034800902,
-0.0087173134,
0.0001471272,
0.0803217664,
-0.0302521531,
-0.0311558079,
-0.0241906177,
-0.0301063024,
0.0055735856,
-0.0572802462,
0.0362035111,
-0.0454817936,
0.0377647281,
-0.0196022708,
-0.0284361281,
-0.0038363021,
0.0087801451,
0.005884408,
0.0077214488,
0.0664892346,
0.0333645642,
0.0079387315,
0.0135348495,
0.0179807451,
-0.0342723504,
0.0535296239,
-0.0325692333,
0.0449882187,
0.0312072225,
0.0260500107,
0.0275356267,
0.0372003838,
-0.0403808057,
-0.0065384116,
-0.0070188092,
-0.0205572601,
-0.0110298758,
0.0213928837,
0.0553645268,
0.0101240734,
0.008787048,
0.0436814204,
0.0015025748,
0.0535013266,
-0.0484325588,
-0.0679597333,
0.0626371428,
0.0577757508,
-0.0353439115,
0.0182297528,
-0.0551354177,
0.0608279146,
-0.0038761941,
-0.0200970583,
-0.0666524023,
0.0177064333,
-0.0362909399,
-0.025924271,
0.0201837365,
-0.0040607955,
0.0706098005,
-0.0100781871,
0.0537572391,
0.0129349427,
-0.0583100356,
-0.0057888608,
-0.0322286375,
-0.0247304291,
-0.0267530605,
-0.0181817524,
-0.0263914298,
0.0187506843,
-0.0008669202,
0.0065299454,
-0.0489223115,
0.0436453819,
0.0448693112,
0.0113572748,
-0.0334288925,
-0.0008835281,
0.0243080128,
0.0091565028,
-0.060200464,
-0.0182506312,
-0.0103615252,
0.0543826707,
0.0057770209,
0.0031896057,
-0.0081548514,
0.0049118944,
0.0093924683,
0.0543882139,
0.0436702557,
0.0062330188,
-0.0097740022,
0.0341344662,
0.0162648261,
0.0124392128,
-0.0100072026,
0.0061264308,
0.0371919461,
0.0000811683,
-0.0122408103,
0.0313013643,
0.0231075902,
0.034082111,
0.0248218123,
-0.0188712589,
-0.0259216744,
0.0220843591,
-0.0363686979,
-0.0163497403,
0.0043869978,
-0.0264831837,
0.0008923053,
-0.0021538236,
-0.0101433331,
0.0222991053,
-0.0193115659,
-0.0207862277,
0.0342340395,
-0.0218317341,
0.0048275799,
-0.0079885041,
0.0179372113,
0.0223317537,
-0.0558119155,
-0.0068942686,
0.0107134935,
-0.0228389539,
-0.0104118269,
0.0625915676,
0.0808036029,
-0.0261608846,
-0.0005894906,
-0.0964794829,
-0.0342516676,
-0.0182993878,
-0.037007913,
0.0215821285,
-0.0093468605,
-0.0008398342,
-0.0293570198,
0.0227255747,
0.0229935311,
0.0136193363,
0.0057951882,
0.0111519126,
0.0464259274,
-0.0376590863,
-0.0262726601,
0.0170216709,
0.0091425925,
-0.0259183981,
0.0367765389,
-0.0203615949,
-0.0561537556,
0.0024738179,
-0.0457869768,
0.0500542969,
-0.020093346,
-0.0076852334,
0.0579180457,
-0.0402423814,
0.0144546023,
0.0927187875,
-0.0233026054,
0.04807638,
0.065474093,
-0.0198743884,
-0.0304249823,
-0.0075314767,
-0.0131327938,
-0.0359496102,
0.0075670034,
-0.0020082993,
0.0154735558,
0.0506920777,
0.0191014837,
0.0349625982,
-0.0596540123,
-0.0328990556,
-0.0322153345,
-0.0534269437,
-0.0622691326,
0.0047611636,
-0.0453716218,
0.0394856632,
-0.0421048924,
-0.0324545018,
0.0360320471,
-0.0111314179,
0.004675841,
0.0056581097,
-0.0231637079,
0.0016263876,
0.1313818991,
0.053940624,
0.0267459713,
0.0159662087,
-0.0221775696,
-0.0251993947,
0.0106006283,
-0.0242035724,
0.0174279343,
0.0086004846,
-0.0960434973,
0.0361574292,
-0.0121833328,
-0.0176449809,
-0.0202676468,
0.0084461207,
-0.0207566638,
-0.0060891197,
-0.0457708612,
-0.0262815114,
-0.0163238104,
-0.0068622911,
0.0291780923,
0.0411691256,
-0.0055320747,
0.0009043025,
-0.0340987742,
-0.0177617054,
0.0607066602,
0.0511958785,
-0.1128730923,
0.0157418717,
-0.0334638171,
0.0493786,
0.0549879149,
-0.0038459881,
-0.0589087754,
0.042341128,
0.0300589241,
0.0468751229,
0.0061509362,
0.0350729041,
0.054770574,
-0.0274512768,
-0.032555636,
0.047099717,
0.0200000796,
0.0190658104,
0.0230364483,
-0.0257565472,
-0.0409290679,
0.0266479235,
0.0362396166,
-0.0611476786,
-0.0446912348,
-0.0004075222,
-0.01038092,
0.0293197874,
-0.0346086733,
-0.0314513333,
-0.1118429676,
0.0621698722,
-0.0201047324,
-0.0375381671,
-0.0936107412,
-0.0206669904,
0.0276585128,
-0.004095858,
-0.0451565199,
0.0474238768,
0.0186954141,
-0.008944002,
0.0363619477,
0.0286667775,
-0.0156612564,
0.0376488045,
-0.0465227999,
-0.0337172374,
0.0648067147,
-0.0055158227,
0.0033359262,
0.0036346491,
0.0065767732,
0.0449571311,
0.0212461874,
-0.021168299,
-0.0155156236,
-0.0497780703,
-0.0143837566,
0.0310645141,
0.0307909586,
-0.0008561703,
-0.0426702313,
-0.0340507925,
0.042676568,
-0.0495722853,
-0.0160651095,
-0.0535872355,
0.0010807678,
0.0490123816,
0.0621434227,
-0.0229146555,
-0.0363311358,
-0.0158918053,
-0.0106602097,
-0.0130689796,
-0.0261472613,
-0.0289562251,
-0.0036604151,
-0.0367706977,
-0.011515649,
-0.0569300801,
-0.0291742422,
0.0649504662,
0.0316019766,
0.0334736817,
-0.0534911714,
0.0071287593,
0.0388478972,
-0.0448197946,
0.0300273839,
0.0142436307,
0.0121968985,
-0.0298212785,
-0.0138508817,
0.0458317883,
-0.0120797036,
-0.0370723642,
0.0441100374,
-0.0380743518,
-0.0122169722,
0.0208974238,
0.0601273067,
0.0177401491,
-0.0013350674,
0.0104783317,
0.0122932782,
-0.0456416011,
0.0017701524,
-0.0476499498,
0.0464094914,
-0.0049208705,
-0.0069382237,
0.0014332886,
0.007999477,
-0.1022733524,
0.0474094152,
-0.0356954075,
0.0328301676,
-0.0463681072,
-0.0115552861,
0.0368108824,
-0.0023774151,
0.0462732352,
0.0014888006,
0.0110805184,
-0.0189274382,
-0.0155479396,
-0.0082739843,
-0.0226504169,
-0.0923605859,
0.0360134542,
-0.0364558771,
0.0042887446,
0.0654770508,
0.0068353512,
-0.0261737332,
0.0452076681,
0.0183044877,
-0.0387835689,
0.0044799172,
-0.006273502,
-0.008456748,
0.0116003454,
-0.0184104163,
-0.0394596681,
-0.0146903563,
0.0486037992,
-0.0020664926,
0.0798113346,
0.0543534048,
-0.0139478333,
-0.0314916223,
0.0385275893,
0.0003134907,
-0.0482587963,
0.0052226693,
0.0346408188,
0.0509222187,
-0.0241460949,
-0.025986135,
-0.0729955733,
0.0087624118,
-0.022602953,
0.0437012948,
0.0168027151,
-0.0265800748,
0.053443782,
0.027305251,
0.0349950939,
0.0225757286,
0.0137450742,
-0.0129686221,
0.0103476662,
0.0152130369,
0.0068130544,
-0.0695548579,
-0.0511110537,
0.0180105232,
0.0033108064,
0.0294207539,
0.0120030316,
-0.0191439893,
-0.0525975302,
-0.0013100798,
0.0452853478,
-0.0076380228,
0.0027821211,
0.0981604531,
0.0268553756,
0.0000859761,
-0.0341487825,
-0.0087815085,
-0.041290246,
0.0030850903,
-0.0080100819,
-0.0274563581,
-5.432496449e-33,
-0.0444181487,
-0.0682463348,
0.0384381451,
0.020323379,
-0.0112186121,
-0.0047370782,
-0.0460650325,
0.0243733544,
0.013262081,
0.0239892378,
0.0227804072,
-0.0152521497,
0.0027615994,
0.0053240852,
0.0054218802,
0.0022791687,
0.0147256479,
-0.0405169986,
-0.0407609679,
-0.0218380094,
0.049883578,
0.0192439184,
0.0222842116,
-0.0459834822,
0.046386186,
0.0340928212,
-0.0327653289,
0.0304033551,
0.0172101334,
0.0233858079,
-0.0230657645,
-0.0034773832,
0.0180103332,
-0.0198083669,
-0.0410575978,
0.0833200514,
-0.0593722016,
-0.0506154001,
0.0017777835,
0.041022215,
-0.0910679623,
0.0447475947,
0.0099290721,
-0.0221764576,
-0.0324491262,
0.0310140792,
-0.0054153744,
0.0355573744,
0.0382501818,
0.0651112944,
-0.0278264843,
-0.0205800049,
0.0101995459,
-0.0829532444,
0.0235005841,
0.0394918509,
0.026279537,
-0.0116094649,
0.0141992383,
-0.0152208246,
-0.0402950533,
0.0061764019,
0.0547150448,
-0.005265851,
0.0165014658,
0.0817309171,
-0.020748103,
-0.0654777661,
-0.0270247813,
0.0010625103,
0.0068174885,
0.0657968968,
-0.0264606643,
-0.0122531746,
0.051467441,
0.0491821915,
-0.0250551421,
0.0305283926,
-0.0563902743,
0.1502480209,
-0.0064463909,
0.0178168677,
-0.0033986715,
0.0176959299,
0.0102137234,
0.0154350158,
-0.0014965896,
-0.0172478035,
0.0543283187,
0.0169274993,
-0.042723991,
-0.0059938384,
0.063794218,
0.0008393792,
-0.001968107,
0.0143491365,
-0.0232070461,
0.0387119465,
0.0070296763,
0.0100516994,
0.002644276,
-0.0059830127,
0.0345663913,
-0.0328580327,
0.021357337,
0.0263424013,
-0.0440402851,
0.0593107678,
0.0194323063,
-0.0029714236,
-0.0397236198,
0.0246934686,
-0.0178085193,
0.0253408775,
0.0336985663,
0.0183198787,
-0.0495712981,
0.0508870222,
-0.0129022244,
-0.0872307122,
-0.0170381926,
0.0138470354,
0.0208999291,
0.0188656114,
-0.0615077876,
-0.012937149,
-0.0211657751,
-0.0071943388,
-0.0025388501,
-0.0392980501,
-0.003345628,
0.0467593223,
2.766e-7,
0.0075668949,
-0.0124084353,
0.0377588496,
0.049645178,
-0.0150474655,
0.0377044156,
-0.0173352826,
0.0388302878,
-0.0108086755,
-0.0672383308,
-0.014737729,
0.0434516482,
-0.0255517401,
-0.0426013321,
-0.0719547793,
0.0218321998,
0.0454877615,
-0.0282506701,
-0.0446650796,
0.0059671714,
0.0365302339,
0.0338215344,
-0.0413685888,
0.0054421932,
0.0022389898,
-0.0482721031,
0.0196842402,
-0.0058880472,
0.043884024,
-0.0347872227,
-0.0012399594,
0.0227650795,
-0.0096357679,
0.0261442978,
0.0025963252,
-0.0355635807,
0.0217999797,
0.0563642271,
-0.0388811491,
-0.0286917686,
-0.0377893634,
0.0088814022,
-0.0296779796,
0.0165301673,
0.0339744799,
-0.085687682,
0.0172276516,
-0.0044475696,
0.0012628222,
-0.0076626861,
-0.0818117708,
0.025701547,
-0.0235410295,
-0.0272108875,
0.0354955345,
-0.0065295212,
-0.0410118438,
-0.0439097732,
0.0145311886,
0.0236157794,
-0.014395521,
-0.0215806775,
0.0274422728,
-0.0031536061,
-0.0152324382,
-0.0175267104,
-0.0795630664,
1.913264222e-34,
-0.0126265595,
0.0097289477,
0.0110212006,
0.0544996373,
0.0082420027,
-0.0010150406,
-0.0678338483,
0.0211709477,
0.023054108,
-0.0030368539,
-0.0393367298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04072v2 | Beyond Imitation: Leveraging Fine-grained Quality Signals for Alignment | 2023-11-07T15:36:40 | 2024-04-15T15:25:53 | Geyang Guo, Ranchi Zhao, Tianyi Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Alignment with human preference is a desired property of large language
models (LLMs). Currently, the main alignment approach is based on reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF). Despite the effectiveness of RLHF, it is
intricate to implement and train, thus recent studies explore how to develop
alternative alignment approaches based on supervised fine-tuning (SFT). A major
limitation of SFT is that it essentially does imitation learning, which cannot
fully understand what are the expected behaviors. To address this issue, we
propose an improved alignment approach named FIGA. Different from prior
methods, we incorporate fine-grained (i.e., token or phrase level) quality
signals that are derived by contrasting good and bad responses. Our approach
has made two major contributions. Firstly, we curate a refined alignment
dataset that pairs initial responses and the corresponding revised ones.
Secondly, we devise a new loss function can leverage fine-grained quality
signals to instruct the learning of LLMs for alignment. Extensive experiments
have demonstrated the effectiveness of our approaches by comparing a number of
competitive baselines. | [
0.0431018099,
0.0613544062,
0.0055007618,
0.0289904159,
-0.0308083426,
0.0033414019,
-0.0613489263,
-0.0311965067,
-0.0396885388,
-0.0091055846,
-0.0799004808,
-0.0339135788,
0.0214304645,
-0.0090749767,
0.0278629158,
-0.0216295253,
0.067062296,
0.0013726198,
0.0039841132,
-0.0172617286,
0.0547038838,
0.0165302716,
-0.0018089658,
0.0584333465,
0.0164153073,
0.0237309895,
-0.0114683928,
0.0151406303,
0.0250644032,
-0.0157846622,
0.048034206,
0.0568215512,
-0.0027454351,
0.0576611795,
0.0000016594,
-0.0637096688,
-0.0139752915,
-0.0188679229,
-0.0109285694,
-0.0029112578,
0.0296277944,
0.0011164346,
-0.0186608583,
0.028806312,
-0.0443946123,
0.0108852768,
0.0651327595,
0.0398627222,
0.059429124,
0.0842237398,
0.017861193,
-0.0270193964,
0.0020694714,
-0.0363574624,
-0.0114042358,
-0.0379918367,
0.0244153626,
-0.0172792971,
0.0099456292,
-0.0163965914,
-0.0291563384,
0.0044574826,
-0.0228648819,
0.0087318178,
0.012391936,
0.0096101882,
-0.042838376,
-0.0307355747,
-0.0189905073,
0.0722325444,
-0.0325745903,
-0.0479193144,
-0.0056723696,
-0.0245777238,
0.0157662611,
-0.006334288,
-0.0063150753,
-0.0402230062,
0.0238658842,
0.0456958115,
0.0135245016,
-0.0223742053,
0.0222257711,
0.0253921542,
-0.0109788906,
0.0342671573,
0.0089279432,
-0.0525600128,
-0.0206795949,
-0.0080451798,
-0.0355299376,
-0.0216778833,
-0.0343043879,
-0.0097846221,
-0.0641076267,
0.0111673586,
-0.0904917866,
-0.0036414636,
0.0322326086,
-0.0039843954,
0.0014850029,
0.0396939963,
0.0137048308,
0.0509901755,
-0.019855611,
0.0600741394,
-0.0331737995,
0.048102513,
-0.0496060699,
-0.0011382394,
-0.0358302221,
0.0018277491,
-0.0050470335,
0.0214953683,
0.0091077872,
-0.0369977802,
-0.0422576219,
-0.0039881784,
-0.025880836,
0.0570988655,
-0.0016310145,
0.000475154,
-0.0313502923,
-0.0243254341,
-0.0450029969,
0.0476754345,
-0.0205265656,
0.0296615362,
0.0119140707,
-0.00797287,
-0.0099133253,
0.0174309667,
0.0093226135,
-0.0174908731,
0.0327847973,
0.0401605479,
-0.0088950889,
-0.024742486,
0.0000294655,
0.021029396,
-0.0305593442,
-0.0431271866,
-0.0383348465,
-0.0600214861,
0.0516444817,
-0.0207176991,
-0.0103130667,
-0.0404598825,
-0.0023149697,
0.0022418054,
-0.0340863727,
0.0682086498,
-0.0244397353,
0.0239834376,
0.0029412988,
-0.0556230545,
0.0192472488,
0.0606877394,
0.0337863527,
0.0220883545,
0.0069885296,
-0.0092350524,
0.0037959614,
0.060628403,
0.0301825441,
0.0277660061,
-0.0140145803,
-0.0038558915,
0.0185416434,
0.080544591,
0.0551922359,
0.0393804684,
-0.0199754406,
-0.0023673871,
0.0740560144,
0.010185495,
0.031380143,
-0.0005095589,
0.0125548746,
0.0407769233,
-0.0211388879,
0.0221307818,
-0.0674326867,
0.0143906092,
-0.0137379589,
0.0406406596,
0.0606270619,
0.0235071257,
-0.0034790302,
-0.0295338146,
-0.0022326671,
-0.0077910898,
-0.0143341748,
-0.0227018222,
0.0364663713,
0.0221784189,
-0.0448504649,
-0.0230061375,
0.0300690774,
0.0010075992,
0.0083358344,
-0.0452520624,
0.0706590638,
0.0655331761,
0.0391138159,
-0.0186568145,
-0.0252723526,
-0.0081313094,
-0.0153115252,
0.0516287796,
0.0538242087,
-0.0113591393,
-0.0227583423,
-0.0650169924,
-0.0283061378,
0.0278085787,
0.0009221195,
0.0111296633,
0.0038498351,
-0.0180936698,
-0.0124365129,
-0.0257411581,
-0.0516687632,
0.0497939736,
0.0101826619,
-0.0170284174,
-0.0185245909,
0.0332250521,
0.048504062,
-0.0102804704,
0.0029420198,
0.0081660403,
0.0043761781,
0.0118067274,
0.0196944792,
-0.0202095713,
-0.038563516,
-0.0137435021,
0.046098005,
-0.0169772059,
-0.037128225,
0.0345482789,
-0.0537538268,
-0.0515901744,
-0.0263758954,
-0.0176064074,
0.0539677739,
-0.0135594364,
0.0451367982,
-0.0181779116,
-0.0057349638,
-0.066320613,
0.0337450057,
-0.0007984487,
0.0426565968,
0.0221866891,
-0.0116844103,
0.0040833466,
-0.0370845646,
-0.0306642819,
-0.0146710882,
-0.0310744587,
0.0436883867,
0.0400142297,
0.0316067301,
-0.0619918369,
-0.0294474419,
-0.0409392454,
0.0224697534,
-0.0042398772,
0.0134854754,
0.032388024,
-0.0081052659,
-0.017755447,
-0.0136421807,
-0.0602100641,
-0.0363174006,
-0.0024752012,
-0.0121582085,
0.0417730659,
-0.0109871794,
-0.0397490673,
-0.0929629207,
0.0172180701,
0.0008475866,
-0.0142639931,
-0.0402906276,
0.0287689865,
-0.0780142099,
-0.0133797694,
-0.0099223042,
0.0169559456,
0.0038794708,
-0.0899689868,
0.0105592012,
0.0111095998,
0.0051498301,
0.0819554329,
0.0299250744,
-0.0018135661,
0.0252464972,
0.0438796841,
-0.0843787864,
-0.0009007854,
-0.0525103211,
-0.0247842185,
-0.0619483888,
-0.0139673669,
0.0144040203,
0.0755946487,
0.0123743638,
0.0315892622,
-0.1000159606,
0.0370106734,
0.0169049613,
-0.0018286133,
0.0267184358,
0.0089561148,
-0.0619640425,
0.0051049055,
-0.042048458,
-0.0547153093,
0.088269569,
-0.0479538254,
0.0048878854,
-0.0370111242,
0.0107102506,
0.0041644797,
-0.004707444,
0.0013409043,
0.0290886611,
0.006108535,
-0.0147183063,
-0.0805547684,
-0.0067875599,
0.0386909321,
-0.0462326407,
0.0465015098,
-0.0212634802,
0.0015563513,
-0.0093275234,
-0.0342897661,
-0.0437451862,
-0.0388670489,
-0.0298072118,
-0.0172866359,
0.0031095687,
-0.0336680152,
-0.0408868864,
-0.004900584,
0.0026631872,
0.0142883165,
-0.024618661,
0.0197631512,
-0.0334803313,
0.0285813902,
0.1104182079,
0.0573240519,
0.0156414304,
-0.0122423507,
0.0057455129,
0.016620012,
0.0281499811,
0.0431290194,
-0.0333230942,
-0.0270896014,
0.0565551072,
-0.0028085932,
0.0195609871,
0.0155840497,
0.0626274347,
-0.0130242575,
-0.0187680013,
0.103195399,
0.0205912422,
-0.0244820602,
0.0143331755,
-0.0018141995,
0.0953332633,
0.0128698442,
0.0128443688,
-0.0480800644,
-0.0648290738,
0.0112540461,
0.0516215898,
-0.0022474811,
0.0178259593,
0.0226649381,
-0.1462358087,
-0.0155290943,
0.04835888,
-0.0708755925,
-0.0512783788,
-0.0138518279,
0.058397416,
-0.0362009965,
0.0412012227,
0.0149517134,
0.0160942357,
-0.0156124244,
0.0251514446,
0.0004869931,
-0.0721124038,
-0.0053702672,
-0.0515460484,
0.1223556399,
0.088625133,
0.0216067862,
0.0107458178,
-0.0379398987,
0.0214739908,
-0.0193424858,
-0.0259025339,
0.0008590711,
0.0087431706,
-0.0234541539,
-0.0208265521,
0.0025867915,
0.0730637833,
0.0038084658,
0.0086068939,
-0.0244992767,
0.0527096987,
-0.004281518,
0.0256177913,
-0.0031447159,
-0.0093081035,
0.0110579878,
0.064774476,
0.0280293413,
-0.0940220132,
-0.0022696631,
-0.0095303664,
-0.0001233551,
-0.0225831922,
-0.0388525538,
0.0276291557,
-0.0311587937,
0.0103527177,
-0.0798682868,
-0.0188733507,
0.0056793806,
0.0202150922,
0.0163968541,
-0.02616328,
-0.0029659439,
-0.044015903,
-0.0001297116,
0.0437509939,
-0.0386540182,
0.0150976507,
-0.1022934765,
-0.0130061861,
0.0195150357,
-0.0371697582,
-0.0061030542,
-0.0038080297,
-0.0662041157,
-0.0934355706,
0.01978576,
0.0527672134,
0.0127676809,
0.0589978136,
-0.0216895118,
-0.0302749202,
0.0101596136,
0.0424732901,
-0.0095537091,
0.0125680137,
0.0248198938,
-0.0193494298,
-0.0306653045,
0.0399583429,
-0.0268701576,
-0.0109449839,
0.0300231576,
0.0528119355,
-0.0017010865,
-0.0373940542,
0.0403500348,
-0.0049617328,
0.054416988,
-0.0321706086,
-0.0060662138,
-0.0282844286,
0.0101568084,
0.0345639177,
-0.0368126556,
-0.0122127701,
-0.0616575927,
0.0419765674,
0.0012350949,
0.0001726213,
-0.0478921384,
-0.0220838804,
0.0501648933,
-0.0273115262,
0.001186914,
0.0038206861,
0.0200624969,
0.0330566429,
0.0103746569,
-0.01455737,
0.0224036034,
0.018623963,
0.0587048382,
-0.0129176928,
0.0532262884,
0.050527472,
0.0105595337,
-0.0089361025,
0.0486246832,
0.0005799988,
-0.0344612673,
-0.0658928528,
-0.0051310761,
0.0413174815,
-0.042421028,
0.0571284965,
-0.0008934322,
0.0015351926,
-0.0051398007,
0.0252409875,
-0.0497142337,
-0.001026241,
0.0332448222,
0.0311201178,
-0.0338372551,
0.006435365,
0.0381281562,
-0.0533189438,
0.0225882884,
-0.0504608378,
0.0427805297,
-0.0270522404,
-0.0074382154,
0.0233333781,
-0.0060515315,
-0.0396429077,
-0.014738922,
-0.0328047238,
-0.0366273485,
-0.0190961156,
0.0374115035,
-0.0192597378,
-0.0006775758,
0.0516226254,
0.0237218756,
-0.0467570014,
0.0208231527,
-0.0173079874,
-0.0645951703,
0.0284216069,
-0.0309840254,
-0.0282180011,
-6.21614784e-33,
-0.0214911439,
-0.0211295485,
0.0059476066,
-0.0270015076,
-0.0527065322,
-0.0421309024,
0.0213831197,
0.0165447444,
-0.0222495236,
-0.0094322134,
0.0074423882,
-0.014677342,
0.0106762089,
0.0237278752,
0.0042379946,
-0.0231916234,
0.0287667327,
0.0036310283,
-0.0618228912,
-0.0180534553,
0.0185091589,
-0.0189052839,
0.0383098312,
-0.0283617359,
0.0056338534,
0.0093278727,
-0.0658700764,
0.0170929618,
-0.0367722027,
0.0822700411,
0.0085283341,
0.0123425256,
-0.0002254586,
-0.0065662721,
0.0092090825,
0.0309535451,
-0.0259160846,
-0.0035411641,
0.0434537344,
0.0080051506,
-0.0066890134,
-0.0149097368,
0.0664138347,
-0.0237797201,
-0.0454188846,
0.0409901664,
0.0379360616,
-0.0482810102,
-0.0242992844,
0.0241334364,
-0.084893994,
0.0198975317,
-0.0059953802,
-0.0638878867,
-0.0126466695,
0.0161179826,
0.0007308907,
0.0263298657,
-0.042531725,
0.028858047,
-0.00988218,
0.0654562414,
0.0574504249,
0.0388649702,
0.0073499968,
0.0522852428,
-0.0166179184,
-0.0190517828,
0.0669054091,
-0.0161602702,
0.0552064069,
0.0179643519,
0.0226116683,
0.0445387624,
0.0116870245,
-0.0142367026,
0.0151278926,
0.0347436108,
-0.0242373589,
0.0426110364,
0.0064638508,
0.0266555808,
-0.0315817408,
0.0087884106,
-0.0536694936,
0.0003840631,
-0.0272731241,
-0.0078559313,
0.0189050455,
0.0074682045,
-0.0339316279,
-0.0489601009,
0.0335433222,
-0.0254018065,
-0.0094999969,
-0.0064427597,
-0.0447495319,
0.0046019489,
-0.0241574459,
0.0040665995,
-0.0658986047,
-0.0683664903,
0.003686836,
-0.008790805,
0.0300560556,
0.0104789278,
0.0522737168,
0.0139368465,
-0.0751160234,
0.0392915383,
0.0000175642,
0.0167975109,
-0.0349938199,
-0.0567264669,
0.063219972,
-0.0101808766,
0.0016588564,
0.0653451458,
0.0121692568,
-0.0261161514,
-0.0539005101,
-0.0041306964,
-0.0187919624,
0.0223766342,
-0.0383139662,
0.0308062322,
-0.0268162619,
0.0067167711,
-0.0129933693,
-0.0379635505,
-0.0061327624,
0.0176703725,
2.479e-7,
0.0087802839,
0.0303937141,
0.0459158644,
0.0234157685,
-0.0072785798,
0.0668418035,
-0.0191798639,
0.0139814122,
0.0152112739,
0.0138067212,
0.0421355106,
-0.0188554153,
0.056109596,
-0.03988152,
-0.0975024179,
0.0726834536,
-0.0991529077,
0.0396486931,
-0.0318225026,
-0.0000769955,
0.0188402105,
0.1193339154,
0.0204393398,
0.0103612468,
0.0110822963,
-0.0036402254,
0.0582271665,
-0.0213646144,
-0.0125984875,
0.0340493768,
-0.0142830014,
-0.0089521632,
-0.0362047926,
-0.0128789423,
-0.006964128,
0.0443524309,
-0.0204526708,
0.0419072881,
-0.0173048694,
-0.0380136296,
-0.0120825395,
0.0154568097,
0.0247531049,
-0.0437163673,
0.0398368426,
-0.0755198002,
-0.0123433182,
-0.0537178181,
-0.0029935313,
0.0014766282,
0.0119492775,
-0.0365179032,
-0.0317387283,
0.0163734127,
0.0496970043,
0.0408233404,
-0.034971308,
-0.0528733283,
-0.0145864766,
0.0211688783,
-0.0251269545,
-0.0267059971,
-0.0086450521,
0.0122021716,
0.0132930214,
-0.0584123246,
0.0018352577,
1.873947151e-34,
0.0256342161,
-0.0458575487,
0.050703153,
0.034754809,
0.0226715356,
0.0124568762,
0.0200661086,
0.039889168,
0.0434881262,
-0.0374150649,
0.005257553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04064v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04064v2 | KPI Extraction from Maintenance Work Orders -- A Comparison of Expert Labeling, Text Classification and AI-Assisted Tagging for Computing Failure Rates of Wind Turbines | 2023-11-07T15:25:52 | 2023-12-06T17:17:00 | Marc-Alexander Lutz, Bastian Schäfermeier, Rachael Sexton, Michael Sharp, Alden Dima, Stefan Faulstich, Jagan Mohini Aluri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.7 | Maintenance work orders are commonly used to document information about wind
turbine operation and maintenance. This includes details about proactive and
reactive wind turbine downtimes, such as preventative and corrective
maintenance. However, the information contained in maintenance work orders is
often unstructured and difficult to analyze, presenting challenges for
decision-makers wishing to use it for optimizing operation and maintenance. To
address this issue, this work compares three different approaches to calculate
reliability by performance indicators from maintenance work orders. The first
approach involves manual labeling of the maintenance work orders by domain
experts, using the schema defined in an industrial guideline to assign the
label accordingly. The second approach involves the development of a model that
automatically labels the maintenance work orders using text classification
methods. Through this method, we are able to achieve macro average and weighted
average F1-Scores of 0.75 and 0.85 respectively. The third technique uses an
AI-assisted tagging tool to tag and structure the raw maintenance information,
together with a novel rule-based approach for extracting relevant maintenance
work orders for failure rate calculation. In our experiments the AI-assisted
tool leads to a 88% drop in tagging time in comparison to the other two
approaches, while expert labeling and text classification are more accurate in
KPI extraction. Overall, our findings make extracting maintenance information
from maintenance work orders more efficient, enable the assessment of
reliability key performance indicators and therefore support the optimization
of wind turbine operation and maintenance. | [
-0.0041437889,
0.0411739796,
-0.0252590943,
0.0011356196,
0.0181655325,
0.0110135488,
-0.0164356437,
0.0332669318,
-0.0060027987,
-0.0248907395,
0.0544216335,
0.00258509,
0.0299838707,
0.0339129716,
0.0009523077,
-0.0271040946,
0.0131879086,
0.0116267111,
0.0443385392,
0.064756617,
-0.0014385203,
-0.0037525832,
-0.052568078,
0.0358510017,
-0.0418058112,
-0.003432069,
0.0265411157,
-0.0701336712,
0.0650055632,
-0.0165352318,
0.0469520986,
0.0202765316,
-0.0231671799,
0.0350293592,
0.0000020088,
-0.0219173823,
-0.0396672264,
0.0189907886,
0.0186557546,
-0.0033671041,
-0.0228663515,
0.0040579122,
-0.0089455573,
0.0137817329,
-0.0395699069,
0.0245249253,
0.0422103852,
0.0464034118,
0.0461866707,
0.0149007142,
-0.0304338709,
0.0284083914,
0.0366127118,
0.0252482053,
-0.0246846415,
-0.0449177139,
-0.012103267,
0.0716624483,
-0.0073612812,
-0.0497432277,
0.0212003402,
0.0531497262,
0.0262689926,
-0.0017825458,
0.04144153,
0.0393856391,
-0.0029350137,
0.0495723411,
0.0052852524,
0.0064190985,
0.0301210321,
0.0422544889,
0.0131170917,
-0.043923907,
0.0067012855,
0.010772258,
-0.0030245504,
0.0188567266,
-0.0294706374,
-0.0227198359,
0.0063468395,
0.07613267,
-0.0068022362,
-0.0500628389,
-0.0169923492,
0.0754539445,
-0.0426500328,
-0.0235986877,
0.036163833,
0.05270404,
-0.0257193148,
-0.0303038899,
0.0148503063,
0.0108581046,
0.0062371925,
0.0302347858,
0.0002051871,
-0.0282240808,
0.0600606315,
-0.0394531563,
-0.0333464965,
-0.019259356,
-0.0099669117,
-0.0002840184,
-0.0189989787,
0.017881263,
0.0387193263,
-0.0130735226,
-0.0204695445,
0.0294472966,
-0.0893910974,
-0.0922219306,
0.009811217,
0.0498326197,
0.005504699,
-0.0036957425,
-0.0324240178,
-0.0150682433,
-0.069838427,
-0.005806007,
0.046767965,
-0.0074031213,
-0.01329643,
0.0127782524,
-0.0448924378,
-0.0048029628,
-0.0270511713,
0.0343393274,
-0.0342217982,
-0.0173494108,
0.0509025641,
0.0286249854,
0.0045521231,
-0.0012861587,
-0.0088363243,
0.0012748989,
0.01281018,
0.0074580563,
-0.079207778,
-0.0529882126,
-0.00552186,
0.0076902332,
-0.0263827853,
0.0016622577,
0.0088697895,
-0.0137601364,
-0.015711464,
-0.0268277712,
0.0084639452,
-0.0174297895,
0.020606339,
0.0209485814,
-0.0849277973,
0.0183628742,
0.0407094434,
-0.0156571604,
0.0136023099,
-0.0286308341,
0.0491608083,
-0.0078776162,
0.0353281498,
0.0115528191,
0.0566876382,
0.0078474898,
-0.0524930581,
-0.0498052761,
0.0233353265,
-0.017378211,
-0.0149572035,
-0.0285803899,
-0.0082898857,
-0.0157366004,
0.0242293198,
0.0319681913,
0.0237043556,
-0.068015255,
-0.0026265145,
-0.0065337317,
0.0000213658,
0.0527881756,
0.0094753392,
-0.0533735901,
0.0538476557,
0.0031637077,
-0.0231183097,
0.0204382148,
-0.0400511846,
0.007979136,
0.0062405807,
-0.0836899281,
-0.0205099918,
0.0143184429,
-0.0362274349,
-0.0114550851,
0.0653799549,
0.0007691022,
-0.0246796254,
-0.0261578821,
0.0108844712,
0.0311598871,
-0.0083030574,
-0.0505496785,
-0.032869678,
0.0867192447,
0.0431764424,
-0.0763923898,
-0.0372792818,
0.0147997383,
-0.0091057885,
-0.0738935694,
0.0354798734,
-0.0132916383,
-0.0019252558,
-0.0129417721,
-0.0269705169,
0.0054619787,
0.0002219696,
0.0123112323,
-0.0460292734,
0.0035338076,
-0.0124773579,
-0.0177457035,
-0.0811749473,
0.0430916436,
0.0680055469,
-0.0149060087,
-0.0144164795,
0.020431567,
-0.0210356973,
0.0576568134,
-0.0304780416,
0.0117604258,
0.0281805135,
-0.0012596725,
-0.0709145218,
0.0148298601,
0.0156373605,
0.0487272516,
0.0286331084,
0.0277679302,
-0.0136663709,
-0.0214480627,
-0.0031347955,
-0.0606447458,
-0.0267692469,
-0.0344887339,
-0.0379826054,
-0.0090893973,
0.0327835642,
0.0133095933,
-0.0246949065,
-0.0910137817,
0.067973502,
0.0371494219,
-0.0130457189,
-0.0531775691,
-0.0385496132,
0.0149890501,
-0.058885131,
-0.028063871,
0.0539854877,
-0.0623258241,
0.005417631,
0.0017557237,
-0.0032198245,
-0.0152043914,
0.0222122055,
-0.0762465596,
-0.0277700219,
0.020433953,
0.0268429294,
-0.0221756082,
-0.0256100614,
-0.0248701964,
-0.0025229338,
0.0026445163,
0.0186924469,
-0.0499551669,
-0.047227405,
0.0524547771,
0.033876121,
-0.0513756946,
-0.0073547461,
0.0022022268,
0.0011812556,
0.0372770727,
0.0870077983,
-0.0592362322,
-0.1136447489,
0.0383155718,
-0.0209643207,
-0.0371602662,
0.0000307612,
0.0056373854,
-0.0280419476,
0.0003350022,
0.0553598665,
0.0044034901,
-0.0324454792,
0.0295691192,
0.01810137,
-0.0302692037,
-0.0473544225,
-0.0024026083,
-0.0160585642,
0.0041052913,
0.0653438568,
-0.0324490182,
0.0266900267,
-0.005142726,
0.0229946729,
-0.0024166016,
0.0047157928,
-0.0075308257,
-0.0035808273,
0.0199031029,
-0.0562794507,
-0.0047993674,
0.0060897744,
0.0719358623,
0.0680011585,
-0.0056209462,
0.0098611889,
0.0258387271,
0.0260948446,
-0.0673052967,
-0.0419337228,
0.0124421753,
0.0622302629,
-0.0139775313,
-0.0088590914,
0.0338811725,
-0.0075364183,
0.0016312615,
0.0239437688,
0.0043542008,
0.0119099766,
-0.0414594188,
-0.0469055884,
0.0512178205,
0.0368289389,
-0.0033724117,
-0.0026165375,
0.0184858069,
-0.0089251408,
0.0096306903,
0.0484053902,
0.0026939833,
-0.003461313,
0.0520959646,
0.0670460463,
0.0545809753,
-0.0086590284,
-0.0075295861,
-0.0002556287,
0.04796106,
-0.0079202,
-0.0563241504,
0.0406024083,
0.0125317965,
0.0062945117,
0.0029304018,
0.0048140609,
0.0232747216,
-0.042634625,
-0.0299671572,
-0.0309555139,
-0.0409696773,
-0.013390393,
0.0290096309,
-0.0585686564,
-0.0460487269,
0.0263743382,
-0.0028039671,
0.0389117934,
0.0495894924,
0.0058268653,
0.023908563,
-0.0268319249,
-0.0130425375,
0.0263583791,
0.0467895679,
0.0333607681,
0.0332203172,
0.0756495968,
-0.0052249618,
-0.0291828793,
0.0319220163,
-0.0140461251,
0.0384609364,
-0.0449857041,
-0.0128816701,
-0.0758875012,
-0.0517304279,
0.0249274857,
-0.0371990688,
-0.0913794488,
0.0347401425,
0.0446097739,
0.0204053558,
0.05398646,
-0.0971490964,
-0.0617822818,
0.0019965651,
0.0042095291,
0.007449531,
0.0918468758,
-0.0013748821,
-0.0446043871,
-0.0429926217,
0.0591757633,
0.0193334389,
0.0039183968,
-0.0245987773,
0.0909825191,
0.0253158286,
0.0110177901,
-0.0071144644,
-0.0141117172,
-0.0132087665,
-0.0264456142,
0.0568377823,
0.0435012095,
-0.0202192031,
0.0027591174,
0.0009478202,
-0.0043453355,
0.0561638325,
-0.0162477419,
-0.0003512936,
-0.0327630006,
-0.0422193073,
-0.0164137725,
0.0296927989,
-0.0402154475,
0.0184673555,
0.0131786298,
-0.0488866083,
-0.0505738258,
-0.0927551091,
-0.061180409,
0.0548987202,
0.0354371369,
0.0180857517,
-0.0380431227,
0.0498805642,
0.0059927567,
-0.0673960075,
-0.0308918338,
-0.0009889564,
0.0559590086,
-0.0119158477,
-0.004653601,
0.0247006323,
0.0122010987,
-0.0513172001,
-0.0446000956,
0.0291967466,
-0.0216350332,
0.0353290923,
0.0767596886,
0.0267468579,
-0.0739036277,
-0.0329134017,
-0.0127674472,
-0.0361047871,
0.0263797455,
-0.0776702985,
-0.0162250921,
-0.0367189795,
-0.021168055,
-0.0265264604,
-0.0343769677,
-0.0132360216,
0.030618187,
-0.040659342,
0.0411026925,
0.0026010994,
0.0436639301,
-0.0249413177,
0.0576533675,
-0.0367739685,
-0.0211158618,
-0.0432069004,
-0.0426682942,
0.0026185985,
0.0471285656,
-0.0244193207,
-0.0159374364,
0.072398968,
-0.0040033851,
-0.0197216216,
-0.0057765115,
0.028049184,
0.0156138577,
0.0086336052,
0.0105574289,
-0.0104325032,
-0.0135071352,
0.0551277399,
-0.0097232731,
-0.0072589172,
0.0312640145,
-0.0674107969,
0.0452952459,
0.015997922,
0.0410994366,
-0.0243094899,
0.0265985485,
-0.0312305111,
-0.0476779342,
0.0131912138,
-0.0149920331,
-0.0187890641,
-0.0316461474,
-0.0594349615,
0.0107531119,
0.0505233668,
0.0080045881,
-0.0724743605,
-0.0082192533,
-0.011732785,
-0.0007872385,
0.0509430654,
0.0652657673,
-0.0239389334,
0.0274866559,
-0.0415046848,
-0.0317684375,
0.0038558769,
0.0407932661,
-0.0287201703,
-0.0667605326,
-0.0447896831,
-0.0498690456,
0.0022746397,
0.0419365726,
0.0137572493,
-0.004321293,
-0.0420363583,
-0.1029903889,
0.0158307534,
-0.0047194413,
0.0302310325,
0.0211780723,
-0.0337024108,
-0.016601434,
0.0217954107,
0.0296826251,
0.0813942626,
-0.0097951796,
-0.0495431684,
0.005874774,
0.01591691,
-0.0087946858,
-5.421585658e-33,
-0.0369370431,
-0.0928714275,
-0.0206505544,
0.0252555348,
-0.011849287,
0.0279899593,
0.0355166532,
-0.0115623418,
0.0630410835,
-0.0063865203,
-0.0021856639,
0.0170838069,
0.0172991604,
-0.0397817679,
0.0180863515,
0.0307983942,
-0.0077951495,
-0.0077391765,
-0.0298504047,
-0.0152256414,
0.0420716293,
0.0083568357,
0.0807864964,
-0.1218401864,
0.0841670781,
0.0427253321,
-0.0374161564,
-0.0051837261,
0.0374989435,
0.0227282196,
-0.0202666465,
0.0407969803,
0.0364096463,
-0.0680151433,
0.0191452857,
0.0059021637,
-0.0424532592,
-0.0446686037,
-0.0294851605,
0.0084696924,
0.064726986,
-0.0064886543,
0.0321046673,
0.0181430932,
-0.0022840875,
-0.0274235029,
0.0588835217,
-0.014039306,
0.0217607357,
-0.0514418855,
-0.0237778518,
0.0375009365,
-0.0131510999,
0.0155837508,
0.020196043,
0.0023939274,
0.0035437841,
0.0122029008,
-0.0463770255,
-0.0119482344,
0.0754510313,
0.022857707,
0.0591750368,
-0.0151977586,
-0.0232333206,
0.025369117,
-0.0309376717,
0.0109371087,
0.0041983859,
-0.0259790141,
-0.0003091397,
0.0314882919,
0.0178308971,
-0.0087974686,
0.0594384708,
-0.0088096103,
-0.079838194,
0.0847275257,
-0.0569436476,
0.0223045647,
0.0051853387,
-0.0050829416,
-0.053988941,
-0.031551756,
0.0047647986,
-0.0210653991,
-0.0118485102,
0.0176786501,
0.0131479828,
0.002042142,
-0.032991752,
0.0439483747,
-0.0190771334,
0.0033582556,
0.027995551,
0.007054301,
-0.0059419069,
0.0489810146,
-0.0260922294,
-0.0079926196,
0.0147068333,
0.0253007729,
0.0168512426,
0.0538213104,
0.0287052169,
-0.0352696292,
0.031528201,
-0.0116492044,
-0.0274208635,
0.0214009471,
0.0440067425,
-0.0145548303,
-0.0329835974,
0.0251864158,
0.0011758993,
0.014665612,
0.001823873,
0.0058803083,
0.0121242153,
-0.0110711288,
-0.0190066732,
-0.0142819108,
-0.0079210149,
-0.0324591845,
0.0110468855,
0.003213028,
0.0104163364,
-0.0259293821,
-0.029110821,
0.039736256,
-0.0225191396,
0.0191648956,
2.667e-7,
0.0518864058,
0.0514635555,
-0.003910644,
0.0123228077,
-0.0156691708,
0.0137091717,
0.00630832,
-0.0571810044,
-0.0224150941,
0.0144249713,
0.0810440853,
-0.0644359216,
0.0041468437,
0.0429451875,
0.0010769885,
-0.0616335496,
0.0175632592,
0.0161410626,
-0.0587628782,
-0.0251237117,
0.0978166461,
0.0075425673,
0.0094594853,
-0.0041640112,
-0.001231023,
-0.013088204,
-0.0117430072,
-0.0332201794,
0.0388281047,
0.0170756355,
0.0688154027,
0.0111405514,
0.0124323862,
0.0632474497,
-0.015810458,
-0.0046380945,
0.0449296758,
0.0444107652,
-0.0095079867,
-0.0110539654,
0.0279778279,
0.0029928689,
0.0740021169,
-0.0040799123,
-0.0116390707,
-0.0349092223,
-0.0310959034,
0.1111661717,
-0.0544251837,
-0.0105791092,
-0.0039968924,
0.0011367261,
-0.0061957231,
0.03155246,
-0.0484288186,
-0.0052729454,
-0.0119808279,
-0.0092690978,
0.0109837782,
0.0521670841,
0.0039134934,
-0.072868444,
-0.0120744919,
-0.0203195326,
0.0224242993,
-0.0260641798,
0.0102311326,
2.427955342e-34,
-0.0144027146,
-0.0082573332,
-0.0623660497,
0.0441872217,
0.0144648971,
0.0312586315,
-0.004052374,
0.0254542977,
-0.0178391766,
-0.0592642576,
-0.0180615466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04046v1 | Reinforcement Learning Fine-tuning of Language Models is Biased Towards More Extractable Features | 2023-11-07T15:00:39 | 2023-11-07T15:00:39 | Diogo Cruz, Edoardo Pona, Alex Holness-Tofts, Elias Schmied, Víctor Abia Alonso, Charlie Griffin, Bogdan-Ionut Cirstea | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Many capable large language models (LLMs) are developed via self-supervised
pre-training followed by a reinforcement-learning fine-tuning phase, often
based on human or AI feedback. During this stage, models may be guided by their
inductive biases to rely on simpler features which may be easier to extract, at
a cost to robustness and generalisation. We investigate whether principles
governing inductive biases in the supervised fine-tuning of LLMs also apply
when the fine-tuning process uses reinforcement learning. Following Lovering et
al (2021), we test two hypotheses: that features more $\textit{extractable}$
after pre-training are more likely to be utilised by the final policy, and that
the evidence for/against a feature predicts whether it will be utilised.
Through controlled experiments on synthetic and natural language tasks, we find
statistically significant correlations which constitute strong evidence for
these hypotheses. | [
0.0489957333,
0.0164872929,
-0.0260727592,
0.0086025987,
-0.0335988961,
0.0459577031,
-0.0134418495,
-0.0060320753,
-0.0204396546,
-0.0489879251,
-0.0333506279,
0.009295824,
-0.0100330105,
0.0237737931,
0.0360143743,
-0.0467497446,
0.047992412,
-0.0514998138,
0.0606999472,
-0.0319316126,
-0.0112990262,
0.0086481422,
0.0066681202,
0.0247696992,
0.0205080938,
0.0218035933,
0.0097544296,
-0.0501545183,
-0.0116135739,
0.0100359069,
0.0102555705,
0.0489572771,
0.0022402823,
0.0164876394,
0.0000018713,
-0.0726427734,
-0.0009404665,
0.0037701449,
-0.0399520285,
-0.0104213916,
0.0406167768,
-0.0063276985,
-0.0085831247,
0.0037218805,
-0.0448302031,
-0.0363460369,
0.0446410328,
0.0637190118,
-0.0003507719,
0.0812501311,
0.0051735057,
-0.0310919471,
0.0016211243,
-0.0236163102,
0.0261890739,
-0.008437722,
0.005614771,
-0.0374923088,
-0.0114931809,
-0.0140115824,
-0.0240420885,
-0.0034393156,
0.0155994799,
0.0430861935,
-0.0222230107,
0.0668869019,
-0.0373443253,
-0.0316562913,
-0.0129239429,
0.0479626134,
-0.0254133511,
0.007543453,
-0.0080927787,
-0.0515548214,
0.0325866155,
0.0287080929,
-0.0228658635,
0.0125835454,
0.0182231497,
0.04880118,
0.06102404,
-0.0350112393,
0.0397404544,
0.0170570184,
-0.0516722798,
0.0467285104,
-0.0108598657,
-0.0665685534,
0.061323002,
0.0362407528,
-0.0174812321,
-0.0283213779,
-0.060833402,
-0.0202291235,
-0.0127184987,
0.0174282156,
-0.034229435,
0.0084599135,
0.0101169357,
-0.0004008735,
0.0390585102,
0.007661846,
-0.0261248443,
0.0542857945,
-0.0282849614,
0.0363982841,
-0.0016601041,
0.0641459823,
-0.0037808684,
0.0198469851,
-0.0475659855,
-0.0164967421,
0.0000983297,
0.0444312505,
0.0342770964,
0.0132675925,
-0.0203885175,
-0.013247868,
-0.0138729438,
0.0091032218,
0.0096436096,
-0.0193744972,
-0.0569382645,
-0.0030284552,
-0.04642253,
0.003497279,
-0.0569852926,
0.0486348681,
0.0139517356,
-0.0661547929,
-0.0161234681,
-0.0078956494,
0.0212890692,
-0.0516260117,
0.0262411777,
0.0782441944,
-0.0047175041,
-0.0760648847,
-0.0158130731,
-0.0060441941,
-0.017805662,
-0.0790330395,
0.0327987,
-0.0542351268,
-0.0001227948,
0.0041187075,
-0.0041438411,
-0.0314654112,
-0.014582932,
-0.0249479674,
-0.0595195219,
0.0514529198,
0.0041146064,
0.0248854142,
-0.0151910922,
-0.0390813053,
-0.0129864533,
0.0798816159,
0.0231765267,
0.0456145145,
0.0217144173,
-0.0182397459,
0.004210786,
0.0356722251,
-0.0104046399,
0.0186964832,
-0.0145964641,
-0.0033187084,
0.0029127516,
-0.0117637282,
0.0622701086,
0.0045568291,
-0.0412216634,
0.0127327349,
0.0541773587,
0.0660405159,
0.0303716119,
-0.0087664854,
0.0089360457,
0.0186688732,
0.0187365562,
0.0399091952,
-0.0661654919,
0.0102707399,
-0.0059015611,
0.0208908562,
0.0033515303,
0.0369965173,
-0.0042544366,
-0.0534784645,
0.009604957,
-0.0122513482,
0.0415940247,
0.0472711511,
0.0878984928,
0.0405772589,
-0.0058225202,
0.0047837514,
0.0595687106,
-0.0192616601,
-0.0076433877,
-0.0644208863,
0.0482431352,
0.0428633839,
0.0108652143,
-0.0469620824,
0.0049640648,
-0.0068754256,
0.002939696,
0.0100510838,
0.0745991766,
-0.0014229587,
0.0256686956,
-0.0174556654,
-0.0480600744,
-0.0416801609,
0.0299162976,
0.010594707,
0.0246083289,
-0.0066219289,
-0.0162857361,
0.0289453417,
-0.0911037475,
0.0498763137,
-0.0114031546,
-0.0565887503,
-0.0120174196,
0.0181322172,
0.022450231,
-0.0068111261,
-0.0317172594,
0.0089544682,
-0.008049909,
-0.0094097592,
0.0243970286,
0.0002704496,
-0.021167988,
-0.0081657451,
0.011796427,
-0.0082111051,
-0.0199918263,
-0.0116255376,
-0.0375264212,
-0.0039399914,
0.0040854868,
-0.0116271097,
0.0384163186,
-0.0077097127,
0.0317461416,
-0.0449886024,
0.0154220918,
-0.0474264361,
0.042951379,
-0.0019378855,
-0.003614045,
-0.0320048779,
-0.0339053012,
-0.0326938443,
-0.0278311614,
-0.00574421,
0.0457224436,
0.0159686636,
0.0077902735,
0.0566725247,
0.0109717045,
-0.0490887128,
-0.0377790034,
-0.0576864854,
-0.0168625154,
-0.0374882929,
-0.0017545996,
0.0057376199,
0.0026136888,
-0.026637299,
-0.0085255131,
-0.0051152115,
-0.0278102085,
0.002902762,
0.0565925166,
0.0110137109,
0.0120273894,
0.0101430807,
-0.0662222132,
-0.034190625,
0.0048556207,
0.0270377193,
0.013227772,
0.0314201862,
-0.0301069915,
0.0169690922,
0.0179844555,
0.0092788124,
-0.0102283722,
-0.0514985919,
0.0111273797,
-0.0544014312,
-0.017503405,
0.0913414136,
-0.012945286,
0.0614022836,
0.0671004355,
0.0069629,
-0.0509118214,
0.0146293649,
-0.056113489,
-0.0354550965,
-0.0623987503,
-0.0056126514,
0.0420337692,
0.0745596215,
-0.0037646736,
-0.0015444381,
-0.0499564037,
0.0366266444,
-0.0226689652,
-0.0545178317,
-0.0005183503,
0.0280126464,
-0.0345634297,
0.0627427697,
-0.0343521126,
-0.0817494094,
0.0745524988,
0.0116915721,
0.00906038,
-0.0455324575,
-0.0252558887,
-0.0270972028,
0.0353073403,
0.0284838285,
0.0019404738,
0.0138749173,
-0.0200874656,
-0.0794638917,
-0.0097415363,
0.0548888631,
-0.0269236974,
0.0491695553,
-0.0114008738,
-0.0079256957,
0.0053688353,
-0.053805653,
-0.044097349,
-0.0803610831,
-0.0360867791,
-0.003410456,
0.0170003362,
-0.0257348455,
0.0217313562,
-0.0395562463,
0.0339517295,
0.0164047536,
-0.0069187465,
-0.0125993071,
-0.0036662158,
-0.0245610978,
0.0555470064,
0.0457773283,
0.0151034249,
-0.0320765339,
0.0111690732,
0.0032832292,
0.0275264792,
0.0047405711,
-0.0002266583,
0.0454633348,
0.0336532854,
-0.0720080286,
-0.034597598,
0.0360244885,
0.0347851291,
-0.0844422728,
-0.0160322376,
0.0948578715,
0.0118424762,
-0.0329165943,
0.015162088,
0.013201925,
0.0373658836,
0.0469919927,
0.0343576185,
-0.041989021,
-0.0215788204,
0.0197147876,
0.0275169015,
-0.0237319153,
-0.0210291371,
-0.0048992001,
-0.1607346982,
0.0335854776,
0.0040175016,
-0.0560342409,
-0.0299082883,
-0.0423703454,
0.0166638251,
-0.042641148,
0.0153417727,
0.0042837393,
-0.0532759428,
0.0191833042,
0.0265299473,
0.0018695079,
-0.0718350187,
0.0158585981,
-0.0478161648,
0.0320479199,
0.1017702743,
-0.0069813579,
-0.0422141477,
-0.0013969039,
0.0153427683,
0.0223184191,
0.0259510428,
0.0069685397,
0.0584855266,
0.0033519939,
-0.0262389425,
-0.0042593945,
0.0396769904,
0.0395176448,
-0.0195808858,
0.0080125825,
0.0436066575,
0.0005933219,
-0.0569368601,
0.0235672481,
-0.0408432744,
-0.0050141015,
0.0747473091,
0.0265832897,
-0.0555435233,
-0.0556418188,
-0.0152394148,
-0.0357750505,
0.0007729096,
-0.0756046623,
0.0202264618,
-0.0193456709,
-0.0062932153,
-0.0530378968,
-0.0737474635,
0.0409144498,
0.0200538766,
0.0022023392,
0.0049738386,
0.0049999575,
0.0146309622,
-0.0188916083,
0.0532589927,
-0.0127430931,
-0.012096365,
-0.0521700904,
-0.0189185832,
-0.0013031646,
-0.0421196446,
-0.0235178471,
-0.055726707,
-0.0220674351,
-0.0836017132,
0.0475536138,
0.0606108829,
0.0164587162,
0.0613440126,
-0.0034219907,
-0.0869307742,
0.0607511513,
0.0381470509,
-0.0423840769,
0.0070381942,
0.0464203879,
-0.0394418761,
0.0074810367,
0.0272427835,
-0.0528369173,
0.0117337685,
0.0474747419,
0.0088507691,
0.0055738664,
0.0015791227,
0.0136324335,
0.0250655208,
0.0965676904,
-0.0257755443,
0.0058926381,
-0.0565786287,
-0.0140028875,
0.0209415369,
-0.0226031747,
-0.0048789568,
-0.0110294316,
0.01108352,
0.0472487621,
-0.007877293,
0.0260776244,
0.025005497,
0.021089375,
-0.0262243636,
0.0079191662,
0.0053722607,
0.0156409852,
0.0291650463,
0.0210636053,
-0.0045951847,
0.0558993183,
0.0066514695,
0.0248467438,
0.0107770329,
0.0367259793,
0.0224383622,
0.0093323197,
-0.0445554778,
0.0062699202,
-0.0581377149,
-0.0736525804,
-0.0051596821,
0.0354242921,
0.0255389679,
-0.0652277768,
0.0505165197,
-0.0328073315,
-0.0209027808,
-0.0068626739,
-0.0142097138,
-0.0135737658,
0.0345214903,
0.0298364032,
0.0256924685,
-0.0663495883,
-0.0122571494,
0.0727958456,
0.0309408363,
0.0571063049,
-0.0348550044,
0.0077671241,
-0.0099973381,
-0.0346043073,
0.0008763158,
0.0012232629,
-0.0249170102,
0.0117755523,
-0.0395657979,
-0.0628511384,
-0.0368678868,
-0.0041434504,
0.0010659285,
-0.0153943235,
0.0201294143,
0.0491135493,
-0.0392759219,
-0.0045898687,
-0.0527978353,
-0.0307464339,
0.0152393682,
-0.0025723586,
-0.0046860403,
-6.447476312e-33,
-0.010596402,
0.0285483859,
-0.0001770905,
0.0166354533,
-0.0032961778,
-0.0193268023,
0.0069744573,
0.0178294461,
-0.0222998094,
0.0324065238,
-0.0285141021,
0.0039216951,
0.0237642862,
-0.0030140053,
0.039239049,
-0.030188527,
0.0492707901,
-0.0081635527,
-0.0400652401,
-0.0027781888,
0.0125686675,
0.0165349245,
0.0724538267,
-0.0587422438,
0.0086193653,
0.0276029259,
0.0165177193,
0.0078295218,
-0.0337517299,
0.0595698357,
0.0024168973,
0.0266947746,
0.02207583,
-0.0748346969,
-0.0268788226,
0.0145060178,
-0.0719961077,
-0.0569208376,
0.0324218608,
0.0083630681,
-0.0099055776,
-0.0491837375,
0.0514334701,
0.0030449326,
-0.0400860086,
0.0047514499,
0.0256023929,
-0.016986927,
-0.0171012189,
-0.0055997418,
-0.0795714483,
0.0183592774,
0.0013268517,
0.033799421,
0.0562947728,
0.0012351773,
-0.0135217877,
0.0271751229,
0.0049869348,
0.0210731495,
0.0512503423,
0.0484482124,
0.0382476933,
0.0355994478,
0.0318434797,
0.0700921714,
0.0455614142,
0.0237091631,
0.0090907719,
-0.0240788013,
0.0701178834,
0.0583839417,
-0.0122865345,
0.04372878,
0.0679811537,
-0.011191735,
-0.0265085902,
-0.0228013732,
0.0083287917,
0.0433322787,
0.0320190154,
0.0176226702,
-0.0606872961,
-0.0418945663,
-0.077835694,
0.0097484021,
-0.0180146936,
-0.0269367509,
0.0238235686,
0.0231375992,
-0.0169283319,
-0.0169672929,
0.0193577744,
-0.0249706116,
-0.004115622,
0.0076486934,
-0.0571280941,
0.0064879977,
-0.0171678569,
-0.01944164,
-0.080311738,
-0.0425319672,
-0.0256644711,
-0.0219034888,
0.0322091877,
0.0190196726,
0.0258152112,
0.0388399027,
-0.0555756502,
0.0000156437,
-0.0189978499,
0.019671075,
0.0539818816,
0.0137149747,
0.0602568649,
0.0104522146,
-0.0063854703,
0.0157148894,
0.0492925197,
-0.0174697731,
-0.0348308757,
0.0092951711,
0.014786033,
0.0011074456,
-0.0137324221,
-0.0071328627,
-0.0314912312,
0.0186029468,
0.010311164,
-0.0428582095,
-0.0225961283,
0.0176126231,
2.633e-7,
-0.0036216304,
0.0632651225,
-0.0120440219,
0.0031317461,
0.0047085509,
0.0604595318,
-0.0035397732,
-0.0081261015,
0.0290874913,
0.0239601154,
0.0079115015,
0.0480537675,
0.0519926772,
0.0142896893,
-0.0602933988,
-0.0142680127,
-0.0697723478,
0.0315814763,
-0.035490375,
-0.0441683084,
-0.002889062,
0.0891048834,
0.0476389267,
0.0028699457,
-0.0086531369,
-0.0444694646,
0.0383884646,
-0.0640059635,
0.0156983882,
0.0254488233,
0.018454466,
0.0651674792,
-0.0062509668,
-0.0079329489,
-0.0023410758,
0.0478732549,
-0.0155760366,
0.0314982161,
0.0212986078,
-0.0090238275,
-0.011642212,
-0.0035547316,
0.0103451787,
-0.0282317065,
0.104452014,
-0.1028069332,
-0.044534348,
-0.0772949085,
0.0335859545,
-0.0476678386,
0.0203129165,
-0.0222762376,
0.0125666959,
0.0247779451,
0.0171745326,
0.0024535472,
-0.0323532075,
-0.0871260613,
-0.0070758564,
0.0746581778,
-0.0158974715,
-0.0603454784,
-0.0266853012,
0.0462449268,
0.0120557817,
-0.0510069169,
0.0148841087,
2.19654229e-34,
0.027575722,
-0.0038795711,
0.0378688537,
0.0112946276,
0.0074123512,
0.01567702,
0.0026087421,
0.0077640731,
0.0399742275,
-0.0801159218,
-0.0017355277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04044v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04044v3 | PrivLM-Bench: A Multi-level Privacy Evaluation Benchmark for Language Models | 2023-11-07T14:55:52 | 2024-06-01T14:04:21 | Haoran Li, Dadi Guo, Donghao Li, Wei Fan, Qi Hu, Xin Liu, Chunkit Chan, Duanyi Yao, Yuan Yao, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | The rapid development of language models (LMs) brings unprecedented
accessibility and usage for both models and users. On the one hand, powerful
LMs achieve state-of-the-art performance over numerous downstream NLP tasks. On
the other hand, more and more attention is paid to unrestricted model accesses
that may bring malicious privacy risks of data leakage. To address these
issues, many recent works propose privacy-preserving language models (PPLMs)
with differential privacy (DP). Unfortunately, different DP implementations
make it challenging for a fair comparison among existing PPLMs. In this paper,
we present PrivLM-Bench, a multi-perspective privacy evaluation benchmark to
empirically and intuitively quantify the privacy leakage of LMs. Instead of
only reporting DP parameters, PrivLM-Bench sheds light on the neglected
inference data privacy during actual usage. PrivLM-Bench first clearly defines
multi-faceted privacy objectives. Then, PrivLM-Bench constructs a unified
pipeline to perform private fine-tuning. Lastly, PrivLM-Bench performs existing
privacy attacks on LMs with pre-defined privacy objectives as the empirical
evaluation results. The empirical attack results are used to fairly and
intuitively evaluate the privacy leakage of various PPLMs. We conduct extensive
experiments on three datasets of GLUE for mainstream LMs. | [
0.0348627046,
0.1256189346,
-0.0358477943,
0.0710780174,
-0.075167954,
-0.0254918709,
0.0597926117,
-0.0218383763,
0.035144534,
-0.0015710198,
-0.0320287831,
-0.0408374779,
0.0268484633,
0.0082877558,
0.0271894038,
0.0040869382,
0.0455579013,
-0.0347013287,
-0.0146900266,
-0.0439975001,
-0.0375582576,
-0.0077467198,
0.0240402687,
0.0256364979,
0.0172992609,
-0.013501538,
-0.0099101262,
-0.0078557683,
0.016327519,
-0.0071702399,
0.0000465016,
0.082622759,
0.0113257198,
0.0714377612,
0.0000019306,
-0.035289079,
-0.0249083322,
0.0605249591,
-0.0111760218,
0.0342078991,
0.0020219339,
-0.0169600379,
0.0302732401,
-0.0090079205,
-0.0096838828,
0.0076170783,
0.0346077122,
0.0206791833,
0.0450483449,
0.0745361596,
-0.0060092714,
-0.0010322045,
0.0045326999,
-0.0433092043,
0.0099778641,
-0.0604728423,
0.0303777177,
-0.0620826706,
-0.0424422324,
0.0055098822,
0.0251321979,
0.0363042653,
0.000199698,
0.0274100248,
-0.0365392864,
0.0051387218,
-0.0055104182,
-0.0338630378,
0.0052287998,
0.0509855114,
0.0036203871,
-0.0252685454,
0.0228114333,
0.0149988504,
0.0426435433,
0.0021908176,
0.0131751411,
0.0504888222,
-0.0222935509,
0.0002781524,
0.0367353968,
-0.0000429668,
0.0592243262,
0.0098386314,
0.0283165034,
0.063397646,
0.0269013364,
0.0056364606,
-0.0157359447,
-0.0384190604,
-0.0026724015,
-0.0406855308,
0.038502384,
-0.0354837812,
0.038089674,
0.037719097,
-0.0632177442,
-0.0407290943,
0.0415443443,
-0.048376292,
0.0207580421,
0.0005981473,
0.0409394652,
0.0360076092,
0.0143691264,
0.0498261638,
-0.0040064366,
0.0333525911,
0.0309866983,
0.0097868834,
0.0062847612,
0.0007615957,
0.0329458863,
0.063569732,
-0.07676474,
0.0143519212,
-0.0149487983,
0.0394172408,
-0.0337147936,
0.0347166285,
0.0098250583,
-0.0160371047,
-0.0131113566,
-0.0197697487,
0.0039293547,
-0.0777052268,
-0.0112331007,
-0.003855756,
0.0086392416,
-0.0682766661,
-0.0231121462,
-0.0557599887,
-0.0340808295,
-0.0134230861,
-0.0409097821,
0.0998173058,
0.0350611173,
-0.0471969135,
-0.0253103785,
-0.089156054,
0.011210612,
-0.0297897719,
-0.024602592,
-0.0489913113,
0.0239092615,
-0.0213050582,
-0.0132382102,
-0.0921626687,
0.0014618931,
0.0190892201,
-0.0389807187,
0.0450724363,
-0.0030465298,
0.0035090793,
-0.0220381282,
0.059982162,
-0.0173935853,
0.0442668125,
-0.0080361506,
0.0151294619,
0.0701486543,
-0.0068478431,
0.0403688997,
0.0057269977,
0.0525639504,
0.0240307134,
-0.0227580145,
0.0331794955,
-0.0006205082,
-0.0631950125,
-0.0378124751,
0.0669224337,
0.0095031345,
-0.0849145874,
0.0965108946,
0.0589247756,
0.0019422317,
-0.0025873205,
-0.0746619403,
0.0209426191,
-0.0042647002,
-0.019579608,
-0.0718905479,
-0.0330234431,
-0.0757421702,
-0.0397737771,
-0.0074262796,
0.0150505034,
0.0112856403,
-0.0054220329,
0.0037466248,
-0.0537455715,
0.0307355784,
0.0170579422,
-0.0237513017,
0.0046355417,
0.0414939858,
0.0603829399,
0.0142430104,
-0.0466811918,
-0.0132570677,
-0.0296224765,
-0.0063907779,
0.040343523,
0.0449448749,
0.000426427,
0.0042829877,
-0.0329499543,
-0.0508405678,
0.0294846576,
0.0081153754,
0.0106728794,
0.0932046771,
0.0060181511,
-0.0214992166,
-0.0137688657,
0.0429614931,
0.006060876,
0.0275993254,
-0.0230865255,
0.0091469223,
-0.0557502396,
-0.005082598,
0.0366135277,
-0.0396908484,
-0.01980244,
0.0313474163,
-0.0039748433,
0.010281763,
0.0396265872,
-0.0066991877,
0.0151571231,
0.0081897508,
0.0435238443,
0.0065233139,
-0.0108263204,
-0.0059106052,
-0.0110023189,
-0.006459665,
-0.0275805891,
0.0425963588,
0.0729358941,
-0.0037097065,
-0.0144511089,
-0.0000695415,
0.0001301854,
0.0207672883,
0.0035298506,
0.0201986488,
-0.0245859623,
0.0331099592,
-0.0271099303,
0.0231689475,
-0.0725736842,
0.0073351581,
-0.057068605,
0.0063780919,
0.0127318855,
-0.0145142898,
-0.0371967889,
0.0021961322,
-0.0290410686,
0.0240099747,
0.0061704582,
-0.0167717636,
-0.0251962151,
-0.0067628622,
0.009280459,
0.0181650743,
-0.01004148,
0.0470815785,
0.0069494657,
0.0145837683,
-0.0255907234,
-0.0325478986,
-0.0364618301,
-0.0376287811,
-0.0484872237,
0.0328962579,
0.0115919374,
0.0284178611,
-0.0303534251,
-0.0075067044,
-0.020622924,
0.0180300158,
0.0394074805,
-0.0461351722,
-0.0166347735,
0.0161879081,
0.0096881576,
-0.0272932239,
0.0419637114,
-0.017425986,
-0.0083073843,
-0.0236139614,
0.0126371104,
-0.0377831087,
0.023508355,
0.0122800712,
0.0041743084,
0.0369071253,
0.0041140555,
-0.0478983782,
-0.0300939977,
-0.0146194017,
-0.0048823492,
-0.0481139384,
-0.0021939108,
0.0299547203,
0.0114926938,
0.0175719615,
-0.0640835837,
-0.0244992375,
0.050398279,
-0.0061741378,
-0.0530410334,
0.0087632807,
-0.0194090828,
-0.0044201245,
0.037868131,
0.002966108,
-0.0711077228,
0.0548440889,
-0.0200631898,
0.0418469943,
-0.0139051443,
-0.0400887914,
-0.008360154,
0.0691900775,
0.0047734822,
0.0353385955,
0.0308451764,
-0.0403963439,
0.009453347,
0.0240252838,
0.0501670539,
-0.0401225276,
0.0571497269,
-0.0281708706,
-0.027557902,
0.0185821317,
-0.0430879258,
-0.0571230017,
-0.1000300348,
0.0103533147,
-0.0201381762,
0.0063347109,
-0.0578988381,
0.0058983564,
-0.0324170664,
0.0098939175,
-0.0009940303,
-0.0089950832,
0.034014415,
-0.0276434757,
-0.0485929064,
-0.0059729628,
-0.0606851578,
0.0109831877,
-0.018963581,
-0.0041734669,
0.0651354641,
0.0575191714,
0.028073838,
0.0485782884,
-0.0335249715,
0.0284291375,
-0.0202571303,
-0.033492513,
0.0317698605,
0.0337718427,
-0.0520753115,
0.0043864874,
0.0717963949,
-0.0002620032,
-0.0572709218,
0.0013110625,
0.0611458085,
0.0081453864,
-0.0090379296,
-0.0222648904,
-0.095210202,
0.014561235,
0.030346306,
0.059251979,
-0.0345133618,
-0.0621023029,
-0.027862398,
-0.0986484811,
-0.0427537598,
0.0067986907,
-0.0018604269,
-0.0103928577,
-0.0592510179,
0.0133089935,
-0.0079735955,
0.0147880828,
-0.0426739454,
0.0211100001,
-0.0235176403,
-0.0162756983,
-0.0150355408,
-0.0726553723,
0.0034611465,
-0.0358428359,
0.0492704026,
0.0307895336,
-0.0128577473,
-0.025827311,
-0.0498251915,
0.0540106855,
0.0345347598,
-0.0443724245,
0.0134393061,
0.0541585311,
-0.0110363336,
-0.0009726795,
-0.00107033,
0.0522878692,
0.0016893091,
0.006716392,
0.0048949812,
-0.0028101963,
-0.0003939499,
-0.0259173606,
0.0165179241,
-0.016060872,
0.0139503609,
0.0704557374,
-0.0155487182,
-0.0206641126,
0.0089157242,
-0.0480848141,
0.0208573714,
-0.0003455742,
0.0127255665,
0.0348350406,
0.0226044338,
-0.0626700744,
-0.0280304868,
0.0257642027,
-0.0329760388,
-0.0027624618,
0.0392671935,
0.0217385963,
0.0111373747,
-0.0121535873,
-0.019240858,
0.0080245305,
-0.0416418388,
0.0173708983,
-0.028628869,
0.0074503138,
0.0089173978,
0.0585985109,
-0.0164593812,
0.0092735048,
-0.082393229,
-0.0890863463,
0.0361772478,
0.0312429108,
0.0160750803,
0.036979761,
-0.0474378988,
-0.0913855657,
0.0306038037,
0.065296106,
-0.0293305442,
-0.0097876228,
0.0497908965,
-0.048819188,
0.0186079871,
0.0504991524,
-0.0210834071,
-0.0403707549,
0.0533364862,
-0.0191705953,
-0.0035924171,
-0.0552942231,
-0.0205533635,
0.060171809,
0.0330499373,
0.0142376535,
0.0466462374,
-0.0417819172,
0.0177225135,
-0.0427630693,
-0.0261738002,
-0.0033137696,
-0.006234284,
0.0519246422,
-0.0072306716,
0.0401199535,
-0.0216455944,
0.0358670019,
0.0288426727,
-0.0512043014,
0.0163588841,
0.0492396355,
0.0094014611,
0.0092894016,
-0.0005473295,
-0.0358691998,
0.0574595481,
0.0149931787,
0.0517722853,
-0.0247102454,
0.0051536639,
-0.002884144,
0.0020845539,
-0.0096606947,
0.0364759155,
-0.0447213091,
-0.0324507803,
0.0065354044,
0.0241323188,
-0.0040455596,
0.0341852084,
0.0145410197,
-0.0270167496,
0.0005035762,
-0.0270614438,
-0.0018590338,
-0.0212774482,
-0.0286182966,
0.0102234436,
-0.0171714891,
-0.024191672,
0.0663244799,
0.0689117312,
0.0160536952,
0.0274872165,
-0.0010866682,
-0.0031704963,
-0.0360016525,
-0.0045843739,
0.0037894126,
0.0598939434,
-0.0276945047,
-0.0102316029,
-0.0574916601,
-0.0857289135,
-0.0384758078,
-0.0107962145,
0.0330288187,
0.0193825681,
-0.0069758072,
0.0039700228,
0.0426936336,
-0.038170021,
-0.0960725769,
-0.0212113764,
0.0124533437,
-0.0066234278,
-0.0022568982,
-5.651885939e-33,
0.0044700415,
-0.0019549911,
-0.0600942113,
0.0464345478,
0.0361392349,
0.0122753195,
0.0049133664,
0.0270204674,
-0.0471700914,
-0.0309837218,
-0.0389162041,
0.0043115728,
-0.0002499555,
0.0256523658,
-0.0349717811,
-0.0184213594,
0.0239592213,
-0.0176787116,
-0.0129677877,
0.021255821,
0.0370814241,
0.0272369683,
0.0323064625,
-0.0603500381,
0.0829225555,
0.0009834551,
-0.035607025,
0.0327883624,
-0.0680524707,
0.0398630165,
-0.0053200051,
-0.0172874052,
0.0074147815,
0.0276579969,
-0.0167593583,
0.0084029809,
-0.0270145219,
-0.0125381863,
0.0054616821,
-0.0255320389,
0.0171595775,
-0.0362912416,
0.0248969365,
-0.0205981042,
-0.0088528637,
-0.0167319849,
-0.0388523191,
-0.0087102354,
-0.0274380315,
-0.0178521778,
0.0459000431,
0.0172770135,
-0.0078783296,
0.0218662787,
0.0757844299,
0.006312618,
0.0095498748,
-0.0274986383,
-0.0259287097,
0.0137375332,
0.0474016033,
-0.0093235867,
0.0755812749,
0.0049196864,
0.0305782668,
0.0148928314,
0.053204149,
0.0566450246,
0.0083514033,
0.0095423013,
0.0123465192,
0.0336195454,
-0.0035213637,
0.0321419798,
0.0083835162,
-0.0185282808,
-0.0182726141,
0.0019780062,
-0.0116131566,
-0.0227980949,
0.0629716292,
0.0080464231,
-0.0840336978,
-0.0172516461,
-0.0843002945,
-0.0097536724,
-0.0357660837,
0.0182405543,
-0.0097760186,
0.0152161866,
-0.0356447324,
-0.0087695401,
-0.0060825711,
-0.0551171303,
-0.0456009917,
0.0390686169,
0.0437452868,
-0.0330092646,
-0.0121158026,
0.0206148159,
-0.0373392887,
-0.0081512798,
-0.0029317492,
-0.0334281623,
0.0222353358,
0.0060763443,
0.0099427365,
-0.0105944434,
-0.0721828565,
-0.0235796701,
-0.0272605177,
0.0518375337,
0.0173374116,
0.0425808169,
0.0516799018,
-0.0384474359,
-0.0235262942,
0.0207071844,
0.044845257,
0.0457085185,
-0.0419993773,
0.0754251853,
-0.0198833141,
-0.0181908458,
0.0355672762,
-0.0391188487,
0.015283444,
0.01514675,
0.1170043871,
0.0250283871,
0.0183003005,
-0.0327681936,
2.743e-7,
0.002963061,
-0.0041598142,
0.004559299,
0.0334411338,
0.0161459669,
0.0635157749,
-0.001521194,
0.0717928633,
-0.0208591633,
0.0160768162,
-0.0601093248,
-0.035200011,
0.0414732359,
0.0300496258,
-0.0224804096,
-0.0054871673,
-0.009522412,
0.0072639422,
-0.0438406728,
-0.0034730998,
0.0037130131,
0.0757033303,
0.061063379,
0.0026053353,
-0.0322695524,
-0.0367667489,
0.0133024752,
-0.0661702082,
-0.0625466257,
-0.0074132164,
0.0651911274,
0.0930657759,
0.0315862149,
0.0063179731,
-0.0232745521,
0.0553770177,
-0.0751598254,
0.0938800275,
0.0373860858,
-0.0237370152,
-0.0008215595,
-0.0602945909,
-0.0258437563,
-0.046300523,
0.0476495363,
0.0326845236,
-0.0495905057,
-0.0182893649,
0.0266181137,
-0.0557264611,
0.0483094193,
-0.0164886396,
-0.0150821693,
0.0022509422,
-0.007516365,
0.0003356787,
0.0034808482,
-0.0666791573,
-0.0611286387,
-0.0469213054,
-0.0121046584,
-0.0106977057,
0.0312850028,
0.027025748,
-0.0421331972,
0.0005662768,
0.0547276139,
2.611543912e-34,
-0.0323701873,
-0.0215111338,
-0.0064633717,
0.007562676,
0.0374953523,
-0.0055523184,
0.0398005061,
0.0240722708,
-0.0113607878,
-0.0500449613,
-0.0115318447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04257v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04257v2 | mPLUG-Owl2: Revolutionizing Multi-modal Large Language Model with Modality Collaboration | 2023-11-07T14:21:29 | 2023-11-09T01:56:51 | Qinghao Ye, Haiyang Xu, Jiabo Ye, Ming Yan, Anwen Hu, Haowei Liu, Qi Qian, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have demonstrated impressive
instruction abilities across various open-ended tasks. However, previous
methods primarily focus on enhancing multi-modal capabilities. In this work, we
introduce a versatile multi-modal large language model, mPLUG-Owl2, which
effectively leverages modality collaboration to improve performance in both
text and multi-modal tasks. mPLUG-Owl2 utilizes a modularized network design,
with the language decoder acting as a universal interface for managing
different modalities. Specifically, mPLUG-Owl2 incorporates shared functional
modules to facilitate modality collaboration and introduces a modality-adaptive
module that preserves modality-specific features. Extensive experiments reveal
that mPLUG-Owl2 is capable of generalizing both text tasks and multi-modal
tasks and achieving state-of-the-art performances with a single generic model.
Notably, mPLUG-Owl2 is the first MLLM model that demonstrates the modality
collaboration phenomenon in both pure-text and multi-modal scenarios, setting a
pioneering path in the development of future multi-modal foundation models. | [
0.0062037916,
0.0961861312,
-0.0012957585,
0.0155827394,
-0.0302518252,
0.0150140915,
0.0407085903,
-0.0250208359,
-0.0455429889,
-0.0324856527,
-0.0725913644,
-0.0058482322,
-0.0045611248,
0.0352497622,
0.0014732417,
-0.0211479347,
0.0308508351,
-0.0581646301,
-0.0585845448,
-0.0121745821,
0.0260041598,
0.0291452128,
-0.0216224976,
0.0577481352,
0.0135791544,
-0.0122106513,
-0.0464154407,
0.0059348396,
-0.0455539189,
-0.0151832355,
-0.0068305717,
0.0494892187,
0.0339819491,
0.0318966918,
0.0000020593,
-0.0062088957,
-0.0071260082,
-0.0077683651,
0.0171782877,
0.0107624577,
0.0894920528,
0.0147102345,
-0.025425449,
0.0105228862,
0.0009737439,
-0.0428160466,
0.0715151429,
0.0515091531,
0.0303462222,
0.0431635603,
0.0002336286,
0.014817737,
0.0363495052,
-0.004234266,
0.0040250779,
-0.0139698712,
-0.0067012184,
0.0159926172,
0.0314761065,
-0.0109707238,
-0.0293667,
0.0385505632,
0.0351945236,
-0.0039637927,
-0.0305229798,
0.0269176643,
0.0541357026,
-0.0353637636,
-0.0475618877,
0.0827523172,
0.0225367006,
-0.0120659564,
-0.0027223059,
0.0259605888,
-0.0089905541,
0.0232985131,
-0.038190078,
0.0306828916,
-0.0157824624,
0.0040694275,
0.0540105104,
0.003285931,
0.0365938991,
0.0406623855,
-0.0157046095,
0.0525725856,
0.0344497971,
-0.0084755998,
-0.0327518024,
0.0150093529,
0.0184879918,
-0.0210967567,
0.0488219373,
0.0362244882,
-0.0323458724,
0.0117645385,
-0.0528818555,
-0.0394262634,
0.0173037723,
-0.0084625324,
0.0386772975,
0.034241695,
-0.0387759693,
0.0239059273,
-0.0019975549,
-0.0116917985,
-0.0367172956,
0.0184296723,
-0.0496777371,
-0.0240529776,
-0.0753029212,
0.0007249795,
-0.0394512638,
0.0332194529,
-0.058171723,
-0.0581684858,
0.0128893061,
0.0420799926,
0.0028722328,
-0.0210579112,
0.0130474176,
-0.0016968671,
-0.0513823852,
-0.0420167781,
0.0304344147,
0.0828525126,
0.0014104852,
0.012435941,
0.0091136144,
-0.0468432829,
0.0148589127,
0.014439092,
-0.0014791769,
-0.0201445762,
-0.0261153057,
0.0876565352,
-0.0557494238,
-0.0181444101,
0.0156566668,
-0.0368569233,
-0.0041138944,
-0.0285857785,
-0.0101954397,
-0.0572384708,
0.0270860139,
0.0177937709,
0.0101303933,
-0.0014979594,
0.003277038,
-0.0245154388,
-0.0027659985,
0.0418835767,
0.0009724008,
0.001036117,
0.0306934565,
0.0342805162,
0.0191055238,
0.0841107219,
0.021609528,
0.0078379,
0.0075009209,
-0.0039513679,
-0.0325719975,
0.0766905993,
0.0032908141,
-0.0060534948,
0.0122016026,
-0.0488099009,
0.0020704865,
0.0271473136,
0.0316875987,
0.035640277,
-0.0539770052,
0.0009912886,
0.0795444623,
-0.0060775122,
0.0890509486,
0.0399578549,
0.0262162033,
0.023465002,
0.0075018457,
-0.0203804262,
-0.044192154,
0.0155759649,
-0.0444058664,
0.0057760812,
-0.0192104019,
0.0742652863,
-0.0275582019,
-0.0065397015,
0.0261057168,
-0.0330073647,
0.0200329106,
0.0146248965,
0.0661648288,
-0.0051212134,
-0.0630676895,
0.0767601877,
0.0195597708,
-0.0546486899,
0.0428793058,
-0.0593443438,
-0.0022459459,
0.047490932,
0.058446642,
-0.0040263813,
-0.0408501402,
0.0000750578,
-0.0043456098,
0.0384327024,
0.0336576588,
-0.0306419227,
0.0146040078,
-0.0675009191,
-0.0345212705,
0.0220882799,
0.0130946198,
0.0203928147,
0.0021949164,
0.0010015961,
-0.0174424909,
-0.0159598365,
0.0307702646,
0.0140165277,
-0.0031435343,
0.0383106954,
-0.0319005586,
-0.0224906933,
0.0028998014,
-0.0073031816,
-0.039301645,
0.0060472931,
0.0444597565,
-0.021751916,
-0.0017238994,
0.0335726179,
-0.1041070595,
-0.0008672547,
0.0476783961,
0.0164559819,
0.003022047,
0.0471465401,
-0.0132635524,
-0.0330546722,
0.0274044741,
-0.0242964868,
0.0370768197,
-0.039593555,
0.0057028485,
-0.0060397307,
-0.0120954951,
-0.0273467544,
0.0091419518,
-0.0269690864,
-0.0260405708,
0.0147776296,
0.0205083564,
-0.0224402379,
0.0159809999,
-0.0218000263,
0.0491963103,
-0.01707628,
0.0480064638,
-0.0138573386,
0.0012319294,
-0.0171595234,
-0.0755047351,
-0.1476874053,
-0.0059502455,
-0.0340067595,
0.0248821396,
0.0602939613,
0.016909821,
0.0003367436,
0.0051157265,
0.0233882349,
0.0614098944,
0.0052929134,
0.006560808,
-0.0286011249,
0.001593505,
-0.039203912,
-0.0002431089,
-0.0375494622,
0.0188685171,
0.0162678268,
-0.0099819694,
-0.0273953956,
-0.064425379,
-0.0028760538,
0.0024061138,
0.0276296996,
-0.0008935964,
-0.0224259105,
0.0195952989,
-0.0403045826,
0.0419707559,
0.0265366267,
0.0023923011,
0.0383207276,
0.0689047426,
-0.0429636203,
-0.0467546806,
0.0048379791,
0.0014621842,
-0.0199900586,
-0.0681168139,
-0.005801043,
-0.0221213717,
0.0935703814,
-0.0018241071,
0.0211641677,
-0.0268864781,
-0.0508841015,
-0.0315822475,
-0.0757774711,
-0.0160130616,
-0.0150021939,
-0.0231357925,
-0.010811829,
-0.0468272418,
-0.0342138298,
0.0580980368,
-0.022832647,
-0.031166235,
-0.0451170914,
0.0147194415,
-0.026950337,
0.054767251,
-0.0079143252,
0.0250656847,
0.0128334872,
-0.0774971992,
-0.0346693248,
0.0284603853,
-0.0023175781,
-0.0306035094,
0.0600380749,
-0.0747215077,
0.0009571055,
-0.0399780422,
-0.0333638117,
0.0221983455,
0.0034376867,
-0.0332486778,
0.0255538579,
-0.0234879702,
-0.0253843255,
-0.0378934741,
-0.0204702355,
0.014201425,
0.0522272699,
-0.018549107,
0.0123693291,
-0.0460652448,
0.0520437397,
0.0267170239,
0.0564724542,
-0.0115552042,
-0.0499393307,
0.0061742887,
0.059658315,
0.0442414731,
-0.0089246947,
-0.0174439121,
0.0278720707,
0.0578435622,
0.0182190631,
-0.0210935436,
0.0363023542,
0.0590123571,
-0.0908148065,
0.0022219734,
0.0880764276,
0.0175108053,
-0.0580511019,
-0.0274286233,
-0.0188369788,
0.0681109056,
-0.0193947367,
0.0026005937,
-0.0735934973,
-0.0586990453,
0.0342555344,
-0.0216501262,
0.0312974676,
-0.0120913647,
0.0141598172,
-0.0649201199,
0.0056896238,
0.0193803832,
-0.0356825404,
0.0110125877,
-0.007346597,
-0.0224826932,
0.0139327794,
0.0098997783,
0.0291737374,
-0.0130001018,
-0.0151857417,
0.0285099205,
0.0315295495,
-0.0510801561,
0.0153083419,
-0.0277907625,
0.088558048,
0.0472243018,
-0.0052819201,
-0.0188885089,
-0.0090319337,
0.0450928174,
0.0066206837,
0.0118795391,
-0.0234044064,
0.0055151288,
-0.0245037805,
-0.0029801433,
-0.0602095537,
0.0143753188,
-0.0334775634,
-0.0068429164,
-0.0300480817,
0.0835473388,
0.0093017984,
0.0076277065,
-0.0084513482,
-0.0049232817,
0.0037472071,
0.0527684353,
0.0053376141,
-0.0652584657,
-0.0398176871,
-0.0322776884,
-0.0356202498,
-0.0510554723,
-0.0106481751,
0.0184772778,
0.0103348093,
-0.017005004,
-0.0359588154,
-0.0195828788,
0.0358810723,
-0.008608493,
0.0035654656,
0.018291248,
0.0133203743,
-0.0267717298,
-0.0664710701,
0.0135664577,
-0.0274070688,
0.0156031363,
-0.0751447529,
0.0033648321,
0.0430224091,
-0.0433719158,
0.0096976971,
0.0376390629,
-0.0815726966,
-0.0558732376,
0.0175789148,
0.0053382223,
0.020410547,
0.0247221924,
-0.0089040324,
-0.1023909301,
0.0031856736,
0.0288536698,
-0.0758508742,
0.0206238888,
0.0401053466,
-0.0413750075,
-0.0028915477,
0.0398393087,
-0.040552564,
0.005557789,
0.011868584,
0.039780952,
0.0207280628,
-0.0139214536,
0.0054927417,
-0.0134959826,
-0.0108329598,
-0.0122867618,
0.0011246675,
-0.0519923158,
0.0145865558,
-0.0062473235,
0.0128962835,
-0.0563438348,
0.0304232221,
0.0415630005,
-0.009386898,
0.0442570113,
0.0311675258,
0.0703871697,
0.0417729989,
-0.0159078687,
0.0726180002,
0.0146636544,
-0.0024890851,
0.0407851264,
0.0193465259,
-0.0138181159,
-0.0045474879,
-0.0089446558,
0.0135300858,
-0.0598819442,
0.0854560658,
-0.0087768938,
-0.0324706808,
-0.0449993499,
0.0459474288,
-0.0196185149,
-0.046992179,
-0.0289071668,
0.0468230098,
0.0447486974,
0.0441389382,
0.0735203475,
-0.0389458872,
0.0012254502,
-0.0359344743,
0.0449029393,
-0.0169598218,
-0.021237554,
0.0289173126,
0.0140685216,
0.0146054151,
0.0002629883,
0.0445483886,
0.0051826658,
0.0430838987,
-0.0155804809,
0.0284424406,
-0.0185636543,
0.0055273157,
0.0568640754,
0.028664887,
-0.0775027946,
-0.0072276178,
-0.021809509,
-0.0300799254,
-0.0014636597,
0.0236494839,
0.0144072194,
-0.0349908657,
0.0192502849,
0.0465795174,
-0.0254687723,
-0.0359188654,
-0.0209379625,
0.0128636844,
0.0255297497,
-0.0056430418,
-0.0135462089,
-6.333996291e-33,
-0.0246660765,
-0.0053906264,
0.0427608974,
-0.0321748182,
-0.0294968244,
0.0278114788,
-0.020850433,
0.0273759775,
-0.0019758823,
-0.0054351809,
0.0171606485,
-0.0108747128,
0.0090905093,
0.0309516154,
0.011728595,
0.0353709422,
0.0525553189,
-0.0324989855,
-0.0001414125,
0.0291789006,
0.028964119,
0.0251858719,
0.0326295123,
-0.0564726517,
-0.0080577284,
0.0100010494,
-0.0242945645,
-0.0171742532,
-0.0101758707,
0.0859724209,
-0.0151935825,
0.0345789529,
0.0396526828,
-0.0065560048,
-0.0472356714,
0.0379500762,
-0.1029091775,
0.021719655,
0.0073166904,
0.0081954496,
-0.0543732308,
-0.0225856751,
0.0322946757,
0.0116700567,
-0.0130793396,
-0.0198978875,
-0.0032952994,
0.0082779536,
-0.0122058308,
0.0286508333,
-0.0670758933,
0.0153030762,
0.0191832501,
-0.0173735041,
0.0495293625,
-0.0019004346,
-0.0015969375,
-0.038727235,
-0.0102683371,
0.02818265,
-0.0098457243,
0.030297501,
0.0850065276,
0.046870742,
-0.0258625057,
0.0490060374,
0.0461688936,
-0.0192461871,
-0.0283994451,
0.0115743,
0.0531824306,
0.0640125424,
0.0145545891,
0.0510364175,
-0.003068567,
-0.0012568708,
-0.0102683166,
-0.0091362419,
0.0373818502,
0.0209873393,
0.0336701162,
0.0638465062,
-0.000324742,
0.0140805654,
-0.0564024486,
0.0305609889,
-0.0455226786,
-0.0358678922,
0.034223821,
0.0317402631,
-0.0335113779,
-0.0046157367,
0.0790762901,
-0.0267979857,
-0.0179108586,
0.0299967509,
-0.0148627879,
0.0789499357,
-0.0306623466,
0.0157195367,
-0.074428536,
-0.045684889,
0.0309317727,
-0.045030158,
-0.0088306889,
-0.0006768717,
-0.0205935482,
0.0338996798,
-0.0519258231,
0.0089485301,
-0.0536734946,
-0.0260463022,
0.0486690737,
0.040642336,
0.0732071176,
-0.0308109242,
-0.0343269892,
0.0106841447,
-0.0050746375,
-0.0064449878,
-0.057885915,
-0.0495672002,
-0.0080104219,
0.0078765228,
0.0062699085,
0.0222929548,
-0.0962287411,
-0.074583143,
0.0337050296,
-0.0150808953,
-0.0218197927,
0.026911594,
2.681e-7,
0.0194943938,
0.0381208695,
0.0339451358,
-0.0290769469,
0.0687145516,
0.0194515344,
-0.0166110359,
0.0382772014,
0.0176235158,
-0.0276831686,
-0.0313842855,
0.0236929003,
0.0251137968,
0.0206643064,
-0.0407645106,
-0.0116178328,
0.0183695406,
0.0396517552,
-0.03212047,
-0.0102190012,
0.0379216298,
0.0801716447,
-0.0211290233,
-0.0064956858,
0.0302412435,
-0.0535041913,
0.058951091,
-0.0327848233,
-0.0368279107,
0.0148057519,
-0.0366177969,
-0.0199355595,
-0.024692243,
0.001912087,
0.013092286,
-0.0296342801,
0.0181405172,
0.0774005577,
-0.0064590592,
-0.0229131058,
0.0189469289,
-0.0209701434,
-0.0409232862,
-0.0230574291,
0.042906791,
-0.0189285427,
-0.0087594027,
-0.0296607818,
0.0188687053,
-0.0032924253,
-0.0561093427,
-0.0286936089,
-0.0364936888,
0.0326630622,
0.0093541732,
-0.0222076867,
-0.021330351,
-0.0591888279,
-0.0332342722,
-0.0140832579,
-0.0540003441,
-0.0613741167,
-0.0654162988,
-0.038682621,
0.0204208232,
-0.0909257978,
-0.0139057375,
2.623408599e-34,
-0.0007110435,
-0.0188744813,
0.0149440272,
0.0466683097,
0.0185704343,
-0.0295543894,
-0.0476918258,
0.0262692794,
-0.008906181,
-0.0816321447,
-0.0284485258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04020v1 | Analyzing Film Adaptation through Narrative Alignment | 2023-11-07T14:18:03 | 2023-11-07T14:18:03 | Tanzir Pial, Shahreen Salim, Charuta Pethe, Allen Kim, Steven Skiena | cs.CL | cs.CL | Novels are often adapted into feature films, but the differences between the
two media usually require dropping sections of the source text from the movie
script. Here we study this screen adaptation process by constructing narrative
alignments using the Smith-Waterman local alignment algorithm coupled with
SBERT embedding distance to quantify text similarity between scenes and book
units. We use these alignments to perform an automated analysis of 40
adaptations, revealing insights into the screenwriting process concerning (i)
faithfulness of adaptation, (ii) importance of dialog, (iii) preservation of
narrative order, and (iv) gender representation issues reflective of the
Bechdel test. | [
0.0015338616,
0.0046458696,
-0.0069599031,
0.0307073835,
-0.0375456326,
0.0074973507,
0.0050718798,
0.0129373306,
0.0289269388,
-0.0317411348,
-0.0040530721,
0.0094935447,
0.0831449702,
0.0229206942,
-0.0167061128,
-0.0028877861,
-0.0100828428,
0.026502287,
0.0130726481,
0.010836306,
0.025126135,
0.0462734438,
0.0171586033,
0.0169278998,
0.0571373738,
-0.0620034598,
0.0003985506,
0.0560364611,
0.0722471401,
0.0088992324,
-0.0116848173,
-0.0199471973,
0.0356979556,
0.0239145439,
0.0000016759,
-0.0952445492,
0.0073222555,
-0.0138218645,
0.0393848456,
0.0481213443,
0.0345818885,
0.0076687802,
0.0097471112,
-0.0237842817,
0.0392000042,
0.0205920897,
0.0513767153,
0.0158090722,
0.0195445456,
0.028699141,
-0.032061331,
-0.0128259538,
-0.0487359203,
0.0350823142,
0.007175033,
0.0403370596,
-0.0045555341,
0.0230198577,
0.0631345287,
0.0112125734,
-0.0612146817,
0.0117901471,
-0.0677562431,
-0.007648604,
0.0171643943,
0.008314657,
-0.0247398429,
0.0087901894,
-0.0388580672,
0.04972855,
0.0246219635,
-0.023768479,
-0.035167098,
-0.0347854756,
-0.0004166533,
0.0310712885,
-0.06016545,
-0.004693537,
-0.0225327983,
0.0067283534,
-0.0241226275,
-0.0330934897,
0.0222888608,
-0.043358922,
0.0519649871,
0.0028384263,
0.0402977914,
-0.0189682692,
-0.0784406587,
-0.0211633071,
0.0209706966,
-0.058785975,
0.0285023414,
-0.0210542772,
0.0663061813,
-0.0194572601,
-0.0657374933,
0.0187853277,
-0.0574264899,
-0.0547582358,
0.0467118025,
0.0473161526,
-0.0326667987,
0.0434602872,
-0.0007541854,
0.115214549,
0.0323193558,
-0.0195329152,
-0.0255671628,
0.036084272,
-0.0380864739,
0.017938856,
-0.0269815288,
-0.047661569,
-0.0250147022,
-0.0370095856,
-0.0064968457,
-0.0028037881,
0.0187964961,
0.0331216753,
-0.0495142452,
0.0104330461,
-0.0026576419,
-0.0083850557,
-0.005362602,
0.0508613139,
-0.0188128371,
-0.0120315189,
-0.0325527713,
0.0290107802,
-0.0295109451,
0.0025549254,
0.055525668,
0.0001756889,
0.0142053692,
0.0231521968,
-0.0177049451,
0.0160615724,
-0.0528442636,
0.0350038223,
-0.0288625676,
0.0000115916,
-0.0436700396,
-0.0271236487,
0.0816208944,
-0.0041979132,
-0.0001088132,
-0.052146025,
-0.0097722961,
-0.0170601625,
0.0100119738,
0.0409560911,
0.0159946103,
0.0460749902,
0.0516958013,
-0.0153612848,
-0.0132628893,
-0.027220346,
0.0708544254,
0.0227158349,
0.0639221519,
-0.0488684662,
-0.0007022485,
0.0426643156,
-0.0520414673,
0.039448522,
-0.0381873064,
0.0137608023,
0.0499502458,
0.0677184016,
0.0189458877,
-0.0174172577,
-0.001327532,
-0.0111681614,
0.0575246029,
0.103815496,
0.0477814861,
-0.0096244523,
0.0384933278,
0.0546616316,
0.0007970281,
0.0181323886,
-0.003612353,
0.0038393403,
0.0165282618,
-0.0081669139,
-0.0130030569,
0.0200080518,
0.0046673021,
0.0203782879,
-0.0130832074,
0.0527176708,
-0.0245033074,
-0.049484551,
-0.0466818064,
0.0002987903,
-0.0548762195,
-0.0055160513,
0.0038624126,
-0.050187584,
0.0547963902,
0.0538608544,
0.0307393689,
0.0685274452,
0.0531091876,
-0.0572426468,
0.0113007687,
-0.0249620266,
-0.0018055758,
0.0150193945,
-0.0225448031,
-0.0280893873,
0.0413704738,
-0.0581206754,
0.0261487979,
0.0176356006,
0.0015507541,
0.0319035165,
-0.0737997517,
-0.0003399053,
-0.0196714532,
-0.0265575089,
-0.0397616997,
0.0401678495,
-0.0376334935,
-0.0439561866,
-0.0619429052,
0.0001161643,
-0.0052916594,
-0.0050549088,
-0.0533087254,
-0.0218068697,
-0.0122374929,
-0.0118822744,
0.0130404979,
0.0762686506,
0.0161847137,
0.0087141488,
0.0238042306,
-0.0605986826,
0.0128856907,
-0.0225922093,
-0.0092307059,
-0.0048304549,
0.0222735945,
-0.0109088682,
-0.0106294546,
0.005014027,
0.061094109,
-0.010277356,
0.0151674505,
-0.0579325669,
0.0154026411,
0.0086027458,
0.0213956777,
-0.0114717092,
-0.0143494746,
0.02420073,
-0.0017649339,
-0.0015872517,
0.0266581289,
0.0061193812,
-0.0054815197,
0.0478412323,
-0.0577751808,
-0.0048084767,
-0.0429210849,
-0.0644795224,
0.0091673676,
0.0241671577,
0.024530137,
0.0590059534,
0.0092346231,
-0.0275283754,
0.0143432338,
-0.0096866498,
-0.0276737586,
-0.0060499366,
-0.0462961309,
0.0356352404,
-0.0115847308,
-0.0131847039,
-0.0463358052,
0.0128525179,
-0.0386424959,
0.0632158518,
0.0370491594,
-0.0079368306,
-0.0714392662,
-0.0248293392,
0.0107245026,
-0.0230971649,
-0.0269655362,
-0.0169324931,
-0.0009607066,
0.0403708667,
0.0291184802,
0.0366339833,
0.0115165655,
-0.0246474091,
0.0451260693,
-0.0237626322,
-0.0214576665,
-0.0132236276,
0.0513783544,
0.0076416084,
-0.0543560758,
-0.0755295008,
-0.000175157,
0.0106081031,
-0.0124180727,
0.0106829638,
-0.0507411994,
0.0395779461,
0.006401564,
0.0038014727,
-0.0001849885,
-0.0440253876,
-0.0243183505,
0.058441136,
-0.0224356838,
-0.0150503814,
-0.0139093166,
-0.0801270083,
0.0276874248,
-0.0343743637,
0.000835106,
-0.0351044424,
0.0599206053,
0.0145567302,
0.0396937728,
0.0199968964,
0.0172292702,
-0.0606234409,
-0.0207945518,
0.0849856511,
-0.0092746494,
0.0321526341,
0.0145653859,
0.0169045571,
0.0132343555,
0.0296257436,
-0.0237388685,
-0.0370508842,
-0.0013860562,
-0.0640452877,
0.0019965973,
-0.0687089413,
-0.0477023572,
0.0346256383,
-0.0064962488,
0.0264580511,
0.0316674523,
-0.0286298245,
-0.0122996233,
0.0357243605,
0.0603936836,
-0.0073622316,
-0.065346837,
-0.0190621335,
0.0632009432,
-0.0130297579,
-0.0854010805,
0.0190816689,
-0.0224599726,
0.0069432771,
0.0260617323,
-0.0400948264,
0.0154014071,
-0.0277065057,
0.04539169,
-0.0291569419,
0.0007351753,
0.0908002034,
0.0386815779,
-0.0107791321,
-0.0059892735,
-0.0534292571,
-0.0107437987,
0.0265936386,
0.0015706421,
-0.0273092277,
0.0327316895,
-0.0063200244,
-0.0015351389,
0.0369242243,
-0.0606358312,
-0.0441594683,
-0.0190323703,
0.0472941957,
0.0443082489,
-0.0527329035,
-0.0418933444,
-0.0069754538,
0.0167985372,
0.0129922833,
-0.0031871523,
0.0330663435,
-0.0367205776,
-0.0258517396,
-0.0312836431,
-0.043607641,
0.0366870724,
0.0001666662,
-0.0420723967,
0.0151185896,
0.0112109864,
0.0695140213,
-0.0108780982,
0.0239001997,
-0.0435825326,
-0.0104415277,
-0.0057176133,
0.0198342763,
0.0368840359,
-0.034991581,
0.0014529041,
-0.0276638716,
0.042209316,
0.0646176115,
-0.0651347488,
0.0357113294,
0.0205903146,
0.000453789,
-0.0251319781,
-0.0298003219,
0.0502168983,
-0.0080875456,
0.0319155678,
0.0404348746,
-0.0262617134,
-0.0101220785,
-0.0060128481,
0.0116419997,
-0.0011550188,
-0.0061233672,
-0.0153586119,
-0.0772526935,
0.0135063231,
-0.0602303147,
0.0117038433,
-0.0035887165,
0.070601128,
0.0834308565,
-0.0399409607,
-0.0015327466,
-0.0374736041,
-0.0581032746,
-0.0083655482,
0.0153068025,
-0.0110365395,
0.0614643581,
0.0115978988,
-0.0140071958,
-0.0151776699,
0.0141516943,
-0.0272092484,
-0.0386478826,
-0.0616005026,
-0.002492435,
-0.0379666574,
0.0233084615,
0.02014447,
0.0249997023,
0.0095712766,
0.02374864,
-0.0246171877,
0.0192157011,
0.0916488022,
-0.0299881436,
0.0239450671,
-0.051655896,
0.0039944299,
-0.024187915,
-0.013124221,
-0.0257345606,
0.0115573229,
0.0074750157,
-0.0383338034,
-0.0007634665,
0.0472833849,
-0.0387987457,
-0.0551481806,
0.000293517,
-0.0562704578,
-0.0567856282,
-0.0131738614,
-0.0230883248,
-0.0102325827,
-0.0070644245,
0.0149598932,
0.0088219019,
-0.0430719107,
0.0326388739,
-0.073255457,
0.010842002,
-0.0565166175,
-0.0031421336,
0.0348135605,
0.0310326219,
-0.0216659624,
0.0234681908,
-0.0491263606,
0.0239332039,
-0.0336753316,
0.0440367162,
0.0122554339,
0.0486269668,
0.0176763814,
0.046883706,
-0.0319779851,
0.0498740822,
-0.0159700885,
0.0103283096,
-0.0030344799,
0.0194811765,
0.0065594441,
-0.0856837258,
0.0642393231,
-0.0024145613,
0.0047417195,
0.0043256101,
0.0205511618,
-0.0065336986,
0.0052624331,
-0.0217636283,
0.0225436091,
-0.0200431142,
0.0597518645,
0.0092644896,
-0.003372441,
0.0128644099,
0.0156679694,
-0.0709956363,
-0.0066456497,
-0.0307623278,
0.0397628769,
0.0134794619,
-0.0001943585,
-0.0314856097,
-0.0369890928,
-0.0171387829,
0.0723906755,
-0.0012962549,
0.0248732716,
-0.0044641541,
-0.0178153049,
0.0362344645,
0.006924571,
0.0216951407,
-0.0059159985,
0.0172992591,
-0.0196367744,
-0.0372595675,
-0.0392220579,
-4.910914545e-33,
-0.0564181395,
0.0158930216,
-0.0265501924,
0.0408822298,
-0.1103180274,
-0.0091998139,
-0.0146267917,
-0.0195786338,
0.0170973632,
0.0303923525,
0.0321646892,
0.0127129368,
-0.0101485895,
-0.0541554876,
-0.0204954408,
-0.014450836,
0.0517437942,
0.052370429,
-0.0771197453,
-0.0326319598,
0.0443988629,
0.0210273024,
0.0531494506,
-0.0423282236,
0.0047055697,
-0.071603246,
-0.0081247818,
-0.0627366155,
0.0819928721,
-0.009659634,
0.011075818,
0.0194524005,
-0.0113186082,
-0.0074328985,
0.0066931709,
0.0133243604,
-0.0054855733,
-0.0423207171,
0.0513483658,
0.030101819,
0.0567316674,
-0.0170272775,
-0.0117185554,
-0.0283931419,
-0.0232847948,
-0.0702647343,
0.0752326101,
0.002669449,
0.0126782013,
0.0318628252,
-0.116603598,
-0.0052268123,
-0.0352381393,
0.0128481518,
0.0073472979,
0.0414127782,
0.0357047729,
0.0068047382,
-0.0647682622,
-0.0122791966,
0.0009699248,
0.0720238239,
-0.0032828588,
0.0235273428,
0.0322520509,
0.0865864381,
0.0507806949,
-0.0313125663,
-0.02959227,
0.0194729287,
0.0025188713,
-0.0498534553,
0.00630434,
0.0536177643,
-0.0201126542,
0.0168242399,
-0.0492992178,
0.0321429968,
-0.0328116491,
-0.0025275671,
0.0286718681,
0.0486457646,
0.0076508713,
-0.0219475869,
-0.0105613573,
-0.0046192128,
0.0283274204,
-0.0408773571,
-0.0066305152,
-0.083387427,
0.006847892,
-0.0130932722,
0.0353567787,
-0.0405009501,
0.0527743064,
-0.0116933817,
-0.0728045031,
0.0383398533,
0.0012496158,
0.0394119471,
0.0348396711,
-0.0203050002,
0.0050736298,
0.0073630912,
0.1126394123,
-0.0197184086,
-0.0258853976,
0.033781752,
-0.0518184081,
-0.0336100683,
0.0022647597,
-0.0520705134,
-0.0500855595,
0.0109382849,
-0.0248210933,
0.0258217044,
-0.0062055727,
0.0241415314,
-0.0081298081,
-0.0269573256,
0.0223986786,
-0.0092521161,
-0.0235144217,
-0.0192057677,
-0.0547432043,
0.0496266074,
0.0366170034,
-0.0144777978,
0.0046892059,
-0.050776761,
-0.0224036388,
0.004825356,
2.565e-7,
0.0054031368,
0.0060200267,
0.0669732541,
-0.0445813239,
-0.0065005906,
0.0381117947,
-0.01568955,
0.0579223931,
0.0296252407,
-0.0424657091,
0.0543006212,
0.0184973832,
-0.0048801051,
0.0169588365,
-0.0268538166,
-0.015093795,
-0.0846782178,
-0.0295607429,
-0.0167162288,
-0.002505078,
0.0284897499,
0.0029554628,
0.0258710962,
0.0140128527,
-0.003212645,
-0.0407203846,
0.0449005775,
-0.0540196411,
-0.0433511063,
0.0521030761,
0.0032500841,
-0.0631525964,
-0.0339251757,
0.0049887653,
0.0048845666,
0.0260026958,
0.0630852059,
0.0119575439,
-0.0693443865,
0.0487116538,
-0.0531253032,
0.0095564285,
-0.0471129082,
-0.035828799,
0.0120231062,
0.0461080037,
-0.0125617459,
-0.072012499,
-0.0526238345,
0.043270763,
0.0351694375,
0.0338707827,
-0.0107596098,
0.0497877225,
0.0347126648,
0.0515476577,
-0.0101401052,
-0.0586640947,
-0.0160201378,
0.0728620514,
-0.0011430511,
-0.0258722827,
0.0108623197,
0.0143861128,
0.0434787013,
-0.0592378974,
0.0204358771,
2.222492246e-34,
0.0040429644,
0.0040684524,
0.0179627109,
-0.000477891,
0.0116058094,
-0.0104297074,
0.0125339655,
0.0318561867,
0.0510819703,
-0.0393462554,
-0.0005814421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06303v1 | MatNexus: A Comprehensive Text Mining and Analysis Suite for Materials Discover | 2023-11-07T14:14:36 | 2023-11-07T14:14:36 | Lei Zhang, Markus Stricker | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph, H.4; H.5; I.5; I.7; J.2 | MatNexus is a specialized software for the automated collection, processing,
and analysis of text from scientific articles. Through an integrated suite of
modules, the MatNexus facilitates the retrieval of scientific articles,
processes textual data for insights, generates vector representations suitable
for machine learning, and offers visualization capabilities for word
embeddings. With the vast volume of scientific publications, MatNexus stands
out as an end-to-end tool for researchers aiming to gain insights from
scientific literature in material science, making the exploration of materials,
such as the electrocatalyst examples we show here, efficient and insightful. | [
0.0067935283,
0.0129780611,
-0.0381498821,
0.0321649201,
-0.0076250308,
0.0035975131,
0.008834389,
0.0413417704,
0.0263422523,
-0.010477487,
-0.0263043046,
0.0652647913,
-0.0182897151,
0.0439730063,
0.0006908971,
0.016944455,
0.0838480741,
0.0052981908,
0.0655329973,
-0.0299002305,
0.0357909501,
0.0144914053,
-0.0435363576,
0.0275107548,
0.0303903781,
0.0121723209,
-0.0272088498,
0.0014181348,
0.0538940951,
-0.0625482276,
0.0467605069,
-0.0046162698,
-0.0123426076,
0.0088367779,
0.0000020838,
-0.0689686313,
-0.0179952867,
0.0456028581,
0.098411411,
0.0118141593,
0.0801120028,
-0.0260838624,
0.0002555466,
-0.0107410429,
0.0231042095,
-0.0021057785,
0.0011571174,
0.0090993214,
0.0027327649,
-0.0199750308,
-0.0247875713,
0.000864939,
0.0382069983,
0.0202854387,
0.0676414147,
-0.0229248311,
0.0121792387,
-0.0166819617,
0.0340976939,
0.0116446661,
0.0049027568,
0.0345581472,
-0.057893075,
-0.0133576598,
0.064339444,
-0.00160431,
-0.0311654396,
-0.0329407565,
-0.0086126309,
0.042795185,
0.0509959832,
-0.0401541404,
-0.0331696421,
-0.0300346036,
-0.0892425179,
0.0499608815,
-0.0044535864,
-0.0037393668,
-0.0016890563,
0.0044084364,
0.0143558551,
-0.0253717154,
0.0411206633,
0.026528582,
-0.0018545487,
0.0414690562,
-0.019014746,
-0.0372074321,
0.0398873575,
0.0084164524,
0.0020901614,
0.0300444551,
0.049021557,
-0.0446202718,
0.034412805,
0.0045152344,
0.0584660061,
-0.0902822241,
0.0290740021,
-0.0155832507,
0.0402283333,
0.0523314252,
0.0203021411,
0.0152529012,
-0.0376380123,
-0.0254768226,
0.0308583491,
-0.024393538,
-0.0085365046,
-0.0452386178,
-0.0208127405,
-0.0643093884,
-0.0330733955,
-0.0222916771,
0.0006201743,
-0.0212741215,
0.0245137028,
0.0000988093,
-0.0159092117,
0.0118319839,
-0.0135165323,
-0.0031334667,
-0.0211999379,
0.0181762576,
-0.011236242,
0.0375863574,
-0.0169440974,
-0.0052945721,
-0.0049757692,
0.0386220962,
-0.0442607924,
-0.0106693851,
0.0080924192,
-0.0125202397,
-0.0458859466,
-0.0128192613,
-0.0114948926,
-0.0769186839,
-0.013641892,
0.0021925699,
-0.0051281448,
0.068923898,
-0.0105636949,
-0.0247434825,
0.088096939,
0.0602562167,
-0.0049690311,
-0.0250268262,
0.0130729098,
-0.0322045423,
0.0287955664,
0.0382104516,
-0.0336734168,
-0.0524870157,
0.0220153444,
0.0027644006,
0.0429520793,
-0.0263933279,
0.0040112711,
0.0583069064,
-0.0255894177,
0.0081972321,
-0.0124481199,
0.0232505277,
0.0356452428,
-0.0687250867,
-0.0154574336,
-0.0257175826,
-0.0438693166,
0.0028271636,
0.0092793629,
-0.0395837575,
-0.0016666056,
0.0221156906,
0.0053195334,
0.0655984879,
0.004441502,
0.0501156151,
-0.0392955653,
0.0131927514,
0.0434445031,
-0.093122758,
0.0262615029,
0.04539885,
0.0329096764,
-0.0676345304,
0.0695822611,
0.004290801,
0.0413024612,
0.00400856,
-0.0590449013,
0.0094244331,
0.0519354716,
-0.0643243119,
0.0575516596,
-0.006871548,
-0.044641301,
0.0478777103,
0.0183724742,
-0.0369028747,
-0.0367560834,
-0.020707367,
0.0615118034,
0.0506374948,
0.0363582708,
-0.0692259595,
-0.0308343433,
0.0557058118,
-0.0070950883,
-0.0160757173,
-0.0425142646,
-0.021965323,
0.0203228351,
-0.0314630531,
-0.0310869627,
-0.0481679216,
0.0018265457,
0.0177576542,
-0.0273112003,
0.0106667904,
0.0098374104,
-0.0355221517,
-0.0414320044,
0.0347080827,
0.018202858,
0.0059447233,
-0.0069151009,
-0.018960895,
0.0183371883,
0.0136346184,
0.0251145158,
0.022505749,
0.0841423348,
-0.0040767994,
-0.0414972678,
-0.045746468,
-0.0067411698,
-0.017135568,
0.0554615594,
-0.0303575508,
0.0616091751,
0.0309890192,
0.0312518552,
0.0346878842,
0.0350880548,
0.0320025273,
0.0210243221,
-0.022120567,
-0.0593355559,
0.0094393808,
0.0672797784,
-0.0101434831,
0.0383970253,
0.0491337627,
0.0444551408,
0.0281463675,
-0.003120308,
0.0045585874,
-0.0175696816,
0.0104378797,
0.006902006,
0.0218986683,
-0.0112977251,
0.0187222268,
-0.077721402,
0.0270165242,
-0.0120793618,
0.0062402934,
0.0436045602,
-0.0202926807,
0.0196327548,
0.0428661779,
-0.0428940021,
-0.0038987068,
-0.0161762983,
0.0621880032,
-0.0290807504,
-0.0227974989,
-0.0817545056,
0.0607762001,
-0.0139021277,
-0.0251844265,
-0.0089672916,
-0.0515419915,
-0.079232879,
0.0613130033,
0.0128755551,
0.0261188503,
-0.0246901009,
0.0530948527,
0.0498213768,
0.0247682352,
-0.0298761148,
0.0278652813,
0.0169535186,
-0.0066939909,
-0.0056231171,
-0.0152726145,
0.0519371219,
0.0923094898,
0.0463007092,
-0.0093508139,
0.0050445525,
-0.008925817,
0.0095758429,
0.071495533,
0.0384306945,
-0.0521220416,
0.03381918,
0.0094171343,
-0.0156636778,
0.0273054112,
-0.0112758167,
-0.0075665452,
0.0185955577,
-0.0264673233,
0.0171261225,
0.0030092108,
0.0459096618,
-0.035632655,
0.0039675492,
0.022590043,
0.0488526113,
-0.0360612608,
-0.0205246694,
-0.1146903262,
-0.0151433814,
-0.0073539834,
0.0033870223,
0.0024485663,
0.0538282171,
-0.0075614587,
0.0264794305,
0.0139132468,
-0.0517136194,
0.0084650591,
0.0157794431,
-0.0401119739,
0.0286572184,
0.0255526863,
-0.0037715833,
0.0188844707,
0.0075642751,
-0.0196275394,
0.0179657415,
0.0283815581,
0.0357674025,
-0.0353267901,
-0.0324768014,
0.0141209597,
0.1044039279,
-0.0267517101,
-0.0137236752,
-0.0025057641,
-0.0525980145,
0.0674007535,
-0.0275759455,
-0.0324480124,
0.008928204,
0.0078766383,
0.0015023843,
0.077431567,
-0.0629680231,
-0.0324915983,
-0.0929913595,
-0.0140342545,
0.0180418808,
0.0126153613,
0.0447839275,
-0.0298228655,
-0.0024990551,
-0.0151265152,
0.0288591124,
0.0240922458,
0.0384876616,
-0.0610065572,
0.0014224377,
0.0217156168,
0.0099876812,
-0.0024186927,
0.001666577,
-0.0689619631,
-0.006505854,
0.0048249746,
0.0460716113,
0.0201337263,
0.0100158677,
-0.0192057993,
-0.02670555,
0.0281257201,
-0.0428314395,
-0.0501276702,
-0.0286887754,
-0.0783490315,
0.0089234803,
-0.0028508839,
-0.0148076601,
0.0355021209,
-0.0270283669,
0.0180374123,
-0.015066212,
-0.0451268144,
-0.0410438068,
0.0131634306,
0.0160543863,
-0.0641765818,
0.0075580287,
0.0601788275,
-0.0305336528,
0.0042265472,
0.0180271156,
-0.0187745653,
0.005195024,
-0.0863888487,
0.011438882,
-0.0083911754,
-0.0424031056,
0.0210137479,
0.0678156093,
0.026813183,
-0.1197768599,
0.0138841746,
0.0454078056,
-0.0291912835,
0.0466578528,
-0.0587537214,
-0.0367996357,
0.02459733,
0.01773059,
-0.0228002816,
-0.0137164937,
-0.0602304526,
0.008447567,
0.0586325713,
-0.0348588936,
-0.0400533825,
-0.0292822402,
0.0238635242,
0.0051309834,
-0.0135778422,
-0.0300960802,
-0.0337911919,
-0.0241479669,
-0.0370835178,
-0.026716074,
-0.0049719582,
-0.0173920467,
-0.0584653579,
-0.00358079,
0.023590209,
0.0329463109,
0.0107678752,
-0.0653749183,
-0.0223405566,
-0.0241293218,
-0.0199353322,
0.0391864181,
-0.0215963349,
-0.0037994517,
-0.0247901641,
-0.0111421458,
0.0062595494,
-0.0040014675,
-0.0171824489,
-0.0013236959,
0.0575662479,
0.0136927757,
-0.0204627328,
-0.0103356913,
-0.0215756577,
-0.0150726279,
-0.0641051233,
-0.0177977923,
0.0036461649,
0.0280364361,
-0.0600966737,
-0.0077857217,
-0.0161682162,
-0.0280398149,
-0.0054869731,
-0.0144752851,
0.0324419886,
0.0108758574,
0.0289486591,
-0.0296860319,
-0.0476038903,
0.0824959651,
0.054776188,
-0.0319459587,
0.0371177495,
0.0250304323,
-0.0809947029,
-0.0127912089,
0.013649377,
0.0398245715,
-0.0099149011,
-0.0368005596,
0.1042270958,
0.0047825282,
0.0036886216,
0.067300491,
-0.0043835449,
-0.0113163088,
-0.000599352,
-0.0524398088,
0.0267084669,
-0.0461944938,
0.0146465506,
0.0106840767,
0.0461708792,
0.0112540154,
0.065960288,
-0.0499892868,
0.0158393923,
-0.0333528742,
0.0254961625,
0.0356992818,
0.01578735,
0.084669739,
-0.0217723548,
-0.0778422505,
0.0112948157,
0.0449596643,
-0.0195143558,
0.0078656729,
0.0077282297,
0.0271891057,
-0.0145820966,
-0.042170383,
0.0420117527,
0.0258462187,
-0.0043440526,
-0.0035025552,
-0.0333002619,
-0.0081589175,
-0.0347018354,
-0.021410495,
-0.0228207316,
-0.0334808752,
-0.0697283149,
-0.0033282121,
0.0128991948,
0.0282430351,
0.0604771934,
-0.0614004694,
-0.0411146954,
0.0092477547,
0.0633598864,
0.0059169768,
-0.0571576469,
0.0024546548,
-0.0172651857,
-0.0239181239,
-0.0391203836,
-0.0071672886,
-6.002644637e-33,
0.0127422344,
0.0076000262,
-0.0420259424,
0.051875487,
0.0187608469,
-0.0551845841,
-0.0904773548,
-0.0496520549,
0.0301284399,
0.0517928228,
0.0021961909,
0.0343146548,
0.0107692163,
-0.0681447834,
0.0311920512,
0.0715616494,
-0.0225516204,
0.0351162739,
-0.0411333926,
0.0025904723,
0.0265463926,
0.0616290309,
0.0480869301,
-0.043235641,
0.0365558825,
0.0611858517,
0.0244788788,
-0.0316265598,
-0.0335333124,
0.0483812951,
-0.0302481689,
0.0074115484,
-0.0180271063,
-0.0331774056,
-0.0055052624,
-0.0044620116,
-0.008733701,
0.0263985842,
-0.0174658578,
0.0321850777,
-0.0197832771,
0.03184871,
-0.0132773025,
-0.0005839236,
-0.0505948253,
0.0246199537,
0.0507989824,
-0.0481133647,
0.0495551601,
-0.007500248,
-0.0384183899,
-0.0294166189,
-0.007392318,
0.0517291017,
0.0194138158,
-0.0024881726,
0.0040725502,
0.0231865216,
-0.0043260055,
0.0287330896,
0.001034183,
0.0296382327,
0.0115284463,
0.0081681581,
-0.0091972919,
-0.0278278682,
0.0425085053,
0.0433923714,
0.0322941504,
0.0494020358,
0.0123740453,
0.0585773289,
0.071211569,
0.013999776,
0.0075533106,
-0.0180255957,
-0.1322690994,
-0.0123945866,
0.0089434115,
0.043067988,
0.0457505994,
0.0298459735,
0.0506492704,
-0.0246730968,
0.0055014016,
0.0272198282,
0.01350947,
-0.0266542975,
-0.0432393774,
0.0094167143,
-0.0982702076,
-0.0017772665,
-0.0248060077,
-0.0260678492,
-0.0433975309,
0.083116658,
-0.0102198161,
0.0301060602,
-0.0327847488,
0.0040163361,
-0.0533444881,
-0.0619565398,
-0.0599828809,
0.0315987319,
0.0400945395,
-0.054588031,
-0.0185852721,
0.0076140678,
0.0020033289,
0.0107341502,
-0.0354341641,
-0.0270689316,
-0.0434685759,
0.0247681178,
-0.0359141193,
-0.0252949242,
0.0019422913,
-0.004407404,
-0.01348799,
0.0524078123,
0.0296637882,
-0.0226682369,
0.0001445634,
0.029134918,
-0.0150086572,
-0.0400089733,
-0.0611217804,
0.0518432446,
0.0423857048,
-0.0162798073,
0.0196395852,
-0.0007506298,
2.75e-7,
0.0301581472,
0.0455280021,
0.0319621824,
-0.019939119,
-0.0423191115,
0.0145538468,
-0.0367033333,
-0.0052495333,
-0.0163611248,
-0.0178191122,
0.0303363968,
0.0423160344,
0.0219119359,
0.034201242,
-0.041875422,
0.0082296664,
-0.0561594106,
-0.0186974201,
-0.0622328036,
0.0384387933,
-0.001895949,
0.0211641956,
-0.0154881878,
-0.0094985487,
-0.001076628,
-0.0584701933,
0.0408479124,
-0.0138355019,
0.0184592884,
0.0434559807,
-0.0098702265,
-0.0603011958,
-0.0274923984,
-0.0064882357,
-0.027170172,
0.0190445371,
0.0004652598,
-0.0247925557,
-0.0113491723,
0.0537837185,
0.0206703078,
-0.0020704863,
0.0093903961,
0.0197812989,
0.0331801176,
0.0380003601,
0.0198352933,
-0.0085225748,
0.0431427099,
-0.0043832143,
-0.0019958226,
-0.0064949864,
-0.0033093437,
-0.0368825644,
-0.0257709436,
0.0109286997,
0.0069116633,
-0.0556995161,
-0.0141514521,
0.0147740375,
-0.0151040964,
-0.006642112,
-0.0493661128,
0.0306303464,
0.0224389955,
0.0105042532,
0.0231768154,
2.737170279e-34,
0.0309235901,
-0.0423411466,
-0.0686822683,
0.0186733883,
0.0021069187,
-0.0062509598,
-0.0265675392,
-0.0089686476,
-0.0243287049,
-0.0404857174,
-0.009116482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14693v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14693v1 | Benefits and Harms of Large Language Models in Digital Mental Health | 2023-11-07T14:11:10 | 2023-11-07T14:11:10 | Munmun De Choudhury, Sachin R. Pendse, Neha Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | The past decade has been transformative for mental health research and
practice. The ability to harness large repositories of data, whether from
electronic health records (EHR), mobile devices, or social media, has revealed
a potential for valuable insights into patient experiences, promising early,
proactive interventions, as well as personalized treatment plans. Recent
developments in generative artificial intelligence, particularly large language
models (LLMs), show promise in leading digital mental health to uncharted
territory. Patients are arriving at doctors' appointments with information
sourced from chatbots, state-of-the-art LLMs are being incorporated in medical
software and EHR systems, and chatbots from an ever-increasing number of
startups promise to serve as AI companions, friends, and partners. This article
presents contemporary perspectives on the opportunities and risks posed by LLMs
in the design, development, and implementation of digital mental health tools.
We adopt an ecological framework and draw on the affordances offered by LLMs to
discuss four application areas -- care-seeking behaviors from individuals in
need of care, community care provision, institutional and medical care
provision, and larger care ecologies at the societal level. We engage in a
thoughtful consideration of whether and how LLM-based technologies could or
should be employed for enhancing mental health. The benefits and harms our
article surfaces could serve to help shape future research, advocacy, and
regulatory efforts focused on creating more responsible, user-friendly,
equitable, and secure LLM-based tools for mental health treatment and
intervention. | [
0.0803734735,
0.0751165897,
-0.0414557569,
-0.0472180471,
-0.0223494712,
0.0170178358,
0.0209065787,
0.0170964561,
0.0983479246,
-0.0033901865,
0.0427158996,
-0.005460578,
-0.0090228189,
0.0492526181,
0.000293498,
-0.0534087718,
-0.0292669684,
0.0415168293,
0.0569611564,
0.01759433,
0.0109874373,
0.0248608869,
-0.0267324317,
0.0700211823,
-0.0049455157,
-0.0038969631,
0.0481468588,
0.0278390907,
0.0020928555,
-0.0940684974,
-0.0364730805,
0.0183550939,
-0.0231743157,
0.011065539,
0.0000021744,
-0.0305409059,
-0.0139058987,
0.0287861805,
-0.0332040079,
-0.0899450555,
0.0560806915,
-0.0641701669,
-0.018522948,
0.0114447325,
-0.040621046,
-0.0018204036,
0.0573010743,
0.0221901201,
0.0014181915,
0.0611611307,
-0.0339409932,
0.0235167686,
0.0324785896,
0.0135519337,
-0.0026658594,
0.0181362722,
0.0379601531,
0.0080328314,
0.0740414485,
-0.0202444401,
-0.0046685198,
0.0604544617,
-0.0326328315,
0.0303607676,
-0.0081329327,
0.0405762643,
0.0349866487,
-0.0640526712,
-0.0032277345,
0.065564923,
0.0490901023,
0.0321551301,
0.0470771007,
0.0029322382,
0.0015236927,
0.014793504,
-0.0436094142,
0.0281669889,
-0.0043509393,
0.0204833169,
0.0137411496,
-0.026732862,
0.0383576006,
-0.0002535144,
0.0162882712,
0.0488050915,
-0.0030396478,
-0.015586881,
-0.0231651533,
-0.0200485177,
-0.0131812021,
-0.0411888398,
0.0368963778,
0.059785109,
-0.0378534421,
0.0240349863,
-0.0399505422,
-0.0740681812,
0.0467049107,
0.0193151385,
0.0169160571,
0.0278094951,
0.0037056888,
-0.0160212889,
0.0869876444,
-0.0231626742,
-0.0255607683,
0.0128885526,
-0.0165554509,
0.0268566385,
-0.0550835244,
-0.0003005399,
-0.0214854721,
-0.0142411208,
-0.0192733556,
-0.0410925038,
-0.0591296032,
0.0390396081,
-0.0221060701,
0.0110982405,
-0.0020439716,
0.0064859367,
0.0231483877,
0.0018885386,
-0.0033836786,
-0.0212960709,
-0.0211674795,
0.0201746672,
0.0080318367,
-0.0839216039,
0.0430446565,
-0.0127804792,
0.0029259608,
-0.0240412299,
0.0092460215,
0.0651567951,
0.0690341368,
-0.0516470037,
-0.0291731805,
-0.0371123627,
-0.0352068916,
-0.002894704,
0.0430372842,
-0.0470315702,
0.0347994193,
0.0178325549,
0.0080355695,
-0.0593681522,
0.0286019277,
0.0088320626,
-0.0955665857,
0.0453753546,
-0.0811757445,
0.0303243082,
0.0310926884,
0.0305221323,
0.0224647522,
-0.001021159,
0.0256033316,
-0.0192168057,
0.048462037,
-0.0249334015,
0.0374158435,
0.0239392184,
0.0024525914,
-0.0614057146,
0.0327456221,
-0.0142081985,
-0.022698544,
0.0399360433,
-0.0651279539,
0.055819571,
-0.0179908704,
0.0495279282,
0.0849809349,
0.1042632386,
0.0229694303,
0.0274523813,
-0.003050687,
-0.0000480673,
-0.036989402,
-0.0546504706,
-0.0349038541,
0.0010202742,
-0.0149793671,
-0.0291375332,
-0.0037796285,
-0.0004277647,
-0.0227379519,
-0.0619286448,
-0.0444254503,
-0.0577249005,
0.016234573,
0.0355687104,
-0.0014755173,
-0.0245872233,
0.0399293602,
0.014870001,
0.0474596359,
-0.0072019505,
-0.0377544202,
-0.1056530699,
0.0309636705,
0.1192679256,
0.044513043,
-0.0187477097,
-0.0106414072,
-0.0113679077,
-0.0149826529,
0.0228587631,
-0.0027439562,
0.001535259,
-0.0297750607,
-0.0002763624,
0.0017602247,
0.0482186563,
-0.0034144381,
-0.0389604494,
-0.0184832457,
0.0480087996,
-0.0467262715,
0.0216019768,
-0.0236442909,
0.0265660677,
-0.0390799753,
-0.0198390204,
-0.027920695,
0.0308603998,
0.0496955998,
0.0524287969,
0.0039598425,
0.0384234786,
0.0224612076,
-0.0366866142,
-0.0365514755,
0.0263217539,
0.0060908073,
0.065637283,
0.012355864,
-0.0059442553,
0.0318928435,
-0.0039613452,
0.0059202462,
-0.0044055358,
0.0329647698,
-0.058981698,
0.0603706799,
0.0167022459,
-0.0237222519,
0.0225393586,
0.0292692017,
-0.0291942358,
-0.001268019,
-0.0463968702,
-0.0118957544,
-0.0181027073,
-0.0154931108,
-0.0450933725,
0.0029188003,
-0.0165653657,
0.0106864758,
-0.0248457026,
0.0154327042,
-0.0125911785,
0.0160291437,
-0.0231538638,
-0.0226442814,
-0.1267150044,
-0.0095527647,
0.0019593637,
-0.0209477264,
0.0293973945,
0.0104180481,
-0.0136501938,
-0.0190490466,
-0.0238079857,
0.0118434867,
0.0596199557,
0.0451638512,
-0.0176687948,
0.0154253552,
-0.0441761166,
0.0001115361,
-0.0067954664,
-0.0325580314,
0.018182693,
-0.0128389178,
-0.0222013555,
-0.0184320007,
-0.0405263901,
-0.0556467809,
-0.0318847261,
-0.0085182767,
-0.0090603428,
0.027797984,
-0.0074204272,
0.0390305929,
0.0130140753,
-0.0104250731,
0.0797141492,
0.0283522122,
0.0256028585,
0.0031233502,
-0.0176333506,
0.0025854425,
-0.0224899538,
-0.0187483467,
-0.0723722577,
0.0004939939,
0.0318792723,
0.0226322152,
0.0179415606,
-0.023863798,
0.0639779046,
-0.0258605834,
0.0187432151,
0.0004052653,
-0.0034382627,
-0.0159726832,
0.0245058518,
-0.012831348,
-0.0396025181,
0.0364081338,
0.017297795,
0.0183914267,
-0.019830171,
-0.067019619,
-0.0120254681,
0.0086749559,
0.0158885904,
0.0363503955,
0.0310816541,
-0.0243523233,
0.045210585,
-0.0370111242,
-0.0396117121,
-0.0697930679,
0.0168026779,
-0.0259482544,
0.0086060818,
0.0297259092,
-0.0196973644,
-0.0264524966,
0.0127594136,
-0.0769141018,
0.0070830006,
0.0259513613,
0.0161925685,
-0.0242290329,
-0.0288940892,
0.0369070098,
0.0415279455,
0.0283038393,
-0.0368471108,
0.0062898449,
-0.0070026466,
0.0240044799,
0.0025296884,
0.0341598131,
0.0359811485,
0.022061497,
0.0353671014,
-0.0094893873,
0.0197608639,
0.0243502073,
0.0056250654,
-0.0073905857,
0.0123163527,
-0.0163629614,
0.0479873531,
0.0363288485,
0.0087621836,
-0.0031275963,
0.068186976,
0.0043302644,
-0.0119283535,
0.0524695553,
-0.0379763916,
-0.067559883,
-0.0179293118,
-0.0210929811,
-0.0680985972,
0.0124978069,
-0.0275779087,
0.0488300547,
-0.0643430948,
-0.0193120334,
0.0270957537,
-0.0176277477,
0.0310311671,
-0.0078304354,
-0.0254070405,
0.0045899684,
-0.0034721855,
0.0073509733,
0.0020903901,
-0.0065591177,
-0.0436900668,
-0.0149192112,
-0.0084130205,
-0.0107269092,
-0.0607935004,
-0.0309815127,
0.0105211623,
-0.0177630167,
0.1039271653,
0.0603260361,
0.0830969885,
-0.0045118039,
-0.017755406,
-0.0484275781,
0.073225528,
0.0238008462,
0.0041847476,
0.055746682,
0.0343205333,
0.0305365846,
-0.0662589744,
0.0602366887,
-0.035588637,
-0.0542314835,
-0.0133420629,
0.0467183888,
-0.0346604176,
-0.0345679298,
-0.0355423801,
0.0306795817,
0.0656862929,
0.009233214,
0.0139787756,
-0.0470833778,
-0.0158594828,
0.0059733964,
0.0427352563,
0.0231489595,
-0.0575900786,
0.0276105851,
-0.0052499617,
-0.0480863899,
-0.0692168847,
-0.0307893027,
-0.0010629677,
-0.0253742374,
0.0059031346,
-0.0490790047,
0.0716407076,
0.0079999687,
-0.0373152681,
0.0250916407,
0.0069771237,
-0.0016727911,
-0.0430728942,
-0.0255210865,
-0.0084769577,
-0.0356210247,
0.0343123972,
0.0018191787,
-0.0145199969,
-0.0013056417,
0.0716714412,
0.0337353684,
0.0149254352,
-0.0230843835,
0.0099033117,
-0.0190795977,
0.0245432891,
0.0443949439,
-0.0555199161,
-0.0139177004,
0.0022986273,
0.0683241338,
-0.0125740282,
0.0075776465,
-0.002857964,
0.0468095876,
0.0209445599,
0.0094390707,
-0.0178865753,
0.0276028309,
0.0163500365,
0.0540502556,
0.0056976234,
-0.0240335856,
0.0145446602,
0.0165148135,
-0.050299637,
-0.0281802658,
0.001562183,
-0.0321413055,
-0.0554036088,
-0.0061105099,
0.0207225308,
-0.0230326429,
-0.0127868615,
-0.0524503998,
-0.0259655416,
-0.0534248017,
0.0333619229,
-0.0099335555,
-0.0060864012,
0.0136134392,
-0.0250283871,
0.0056494414,
0.0947271362,
-0.0448772758,
0.0306809675,
-0.0011356123,
0.0773083791,
-0.031876158,
-0.0050411755,
0.0144791286,
0.0583923236,
-0.0433673598,
-0.1400591135,
0.0131601067,
0.044389654,
0.0422922112,
0.0267670099,
0.0515578315,
-0.0400742739,
-0.0071257278,
-0.0168950632,
-0.000110448,
-0.0121668056,
-0.0460894704,
-0.0182791185,
0.0042605931,
-0.0245591365,
-0.0319351554,
0.025054995,
-0.0594220571,
0.0464596339,
0.0044779116,
-0.024143137,
-0.0125674326,
-0.0188796483,
-0.0205733981,
-0.0094948215,
-0.0591254309,
-0.0029669483,
-0.0307075027,
-0.056494534,
0.0279508885,
-0.0122043267,
-0.0461094007,
-0.0435441844,
0.0295245685,
-0.0002612711,
0.0120685939,
-0.0424648039,
-0.0385633893,
0.0634546429,
-0.0632390082,
-0.0209944304,
-0.0040662941,
-5.701032256e-33,
0.024874879,
-0.0366210677,
0.0181768071,
-0.0141207809,
-0.003890716,
-0.0072091315,
-0.017873833,
0.0315131992,
0.0094835907,
0.0156809147,
0.0065720328,
0.0424542278,
-0.0091312844,
0.0431372784,
0.0156946592,
-0.0172592066,
0.0132438205,
-0.0192430951,
0.0077190823,
0.0222753659,
-0.0246918406,
0.0488125049,
-0.0094527444,
-0.0961568803,
0.0167170577,
0.0102122054,
0.0074176397,
-0.0041522775,
0.0057770195,
0.0234284643,
-0.0290496219,
0.0491273291,
0.0414711088,
0.0151697127,
0.0089534754,
0.0642247051,
-0.0536181368,
-0.0093158893,
-0.0039358172,
-0.0309724491,
-0.0366299935,
-0.0495332591,
0.0228353105,
-0.0521066114,
-0.0340452902,
0.0032872255,
0.0177293681,
-0.0790889412,
0.0005347344,
-0.0383816399,
-0.0208951496,
0.0032476082,
-0.0189420804,
0.0155906798,
-0.0300776027,
0.0097809378,
-0.0515422933,
0.0392775424,
-0.0633101016,
0.0320566408,
-0.0080497116,
-0.0435837582,
0.013445871,
-0.0567109995,
0.01293285,
0.0243432652,
0.0036970698,
0.0106032304,
-0.0586362369,
0.0129925478,
-0.0144351013,
0.0497203469,
0.0285630357,
-0.0225331541,
-0.039608106,
-0.0584986359,
-0.0397314429,
0.0060969712,
-0.0118790753,
-0.0193310194,
0.0625639036,
0.0080223978,
-0.043701753,
-0.0043494222,
-0.0008484487,
-0.0271028392,
-0.0222983267,
-0.0322030671,
0.0003431466,
-0.0174384639,
0.0010066481,
-0.0129465861,
-0.0299481563,
-0.0627319217,
-0.0200149044,
-0.0160515122,
0.0413187109,
0.0051457994,
-0.0227299891,
-0.0219252482,
-0.0270149633,
-0.009004592,
-0.0047987457,
0.0278043225,
0.0679139048,
0.0071831252,
0.0183913186,
-0.0311679095,
-0.0148343863,
-0.0278632995,
0.0355084389,
0.0718356445,
0.0429242328,
-0.0276855733,
0.0229134224,
0.0068756002,
-0.0000127173,
0.0334154516,
0.0509767905,
0.028156491,
-0.0626932755,
-0.0122865718,
-0.0441285446,
-0.0140387863,
-0.0382609516,
-0.0044308971,
-0.0855120197,
0.055729378,
0.0656151697,
-0.045418825,
-0.0038521788,
-0.0439957008,
2.945e-7,
0.0159184691,
0.0693207979,
-0.0149827553,
-0.0069745844,
0.0340976603,
0.0116874827,
0.0183588229,
0.0299096014,
0.0026535152,
-0.0124576017,
0.0331265591,
0.0311338864,
0.0472086854,
0.0438537486,
0.0245113429,
-0.025922453,
-0.0725317895,
-0.0247947257,
-0.0574239604,
0.0384817757,
0.0604148433,
0.0261418913,
-0.0068020881,
-0.0182826295,
-0.0050895293,
0.0292102993,
-0.0048436909,
-0.0600991324,
0.0232467223,
0.0118871089,
0.0031271179,
0.0111068115,
0.0068531837,
-0.017301796,
-0.0056618457,
-0.0145690525,
-0.0156078897,
0.0871608257,
-0.0512350798,
0.0200530328,
0.0189676899,
-0.0093858149,
0.0147580868,
-0.0112401843,
0.06676092,
-0.0999045596,
-0.0640518516,
-0.0185186844,
-0.0153344823,
-0.0496183224,
0.0503230579,
-0.0365416743,
-0.0286826827,
0.0490500741,
0.028766498,
0.0040977737,
0.0413907506,
-0.051734224,
0.0100472486,
0.0294665303,
-0.0270529632,
-0.0247365013,
0.016365936,
0.0085957674,
-0.0183212068,
-0.0520049408,
0.0345950983,
2.222776706e-34,
-0.0060532461,
0.0373733267,
0.0218574405,
-0.011279528,
0.0194385033,
0.0274780318,
0.0318049528,
0.0163234733,
-0.0072936234,
-0.073886402,
-0.0112951212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03998v1 | Exploring Jiu-Jitsu Argumentation for Writing Peer Review Rebuttals | 2023-11-07T13:54:01 | 2023-11-07T13:54:01 | Sukannya Purkayastha, Anne Lauscher, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | In many domains of argumentation, people's arguments are driven by so-called
attitude roots, i.e., underlying beliefs and world views, and their
corresponding attitude themes. Given the strength of these latent drivers of
arguments, recent work in psychology suggests that instead of directly
countering surface-level reasoning (e.g., falsifying given premises), one
should follow an argumentation style inspired by the Jiu-Jitsu 'soft' combat
system (Hornsey and Fielding, 2017): first, identify an arguer's attitude roots
and themes, and then choose a prototypical rebuttal that is aligned with those
drivers instead of invalidating those. In this work, we are the first to
explore Jiu-Jitsu argumentation for peer review by proposing the novel task of
attitude and theme-guided rebuttal generation. To this end, we enrich an
existing dataset for discourse structure in peer reviews with attitude roots,
attitude themes, and canonical rebuttals. To facilitate this process, we recast
established annotation concepts from the domain of peer reviews (e.g., aspects
a review sentence is relating to) and train domain-specific models. We then
propose strong rebuttal generation strategies, which we benchmark on our novel
dataset for the task of end-to-end attitude and theme-guided rebuttal
generation and two subtasks. | [
0.0753315687,
0.0158250127,
0.0342890546,
0.0212646518,
-0.0190939046,
0.0273966137,
0.0015435294,
-0.0277152639,
-0.0462951809,
-0.0521776639,
-0.0671577305,
0.0274016876,
-0.0006244152,
-0.0034719496,
0.0151681146,
-0.0290105026,
-0.0008168275,
0.0164486766,
0.1120972112,
-0.0313073993,
0.0403574817,
-0.0025127549,
-0.0039443052,
0.046361737,
-0.0060986099,
-0.0752799585,
0.0157553852,
0.0046414551,
0.0204572473,
-0.0795578063,
0.0527767055,
0.0710983872,
0.0059353518,
0.04591484,
0.0000017698,
-0.0135966232,
0.0049480055,
-0.0111470027,
-0.0064829383,
0.0418047868,
0.0160337277,
-0.0016229688,
0.0183689892,
0.0082044844,
-0.0467711985,
-0.0385921001,
0.0040257694,
0.1300297379,
0.0783534646,
0.0906601027,
0.0054113688,
-0.0551288314,
-0.0402947851,
-0.0550936982,
-0.0601549931,
0.0153247416,
0.0083266646,
0.0473298579,
-0.0463742577,
0.0465575829,
-0.0119085228,
-0.0513200983,
0.0037491049,
-0.0217114836,
0.0104490444,
-0.0141487755,
-0.0263947695,
0.043317128,
0.0043198066,
0.0525643118,
0.0346730873,
-0.0366640687,
0.0004297789,
-0.0165405069,
0.0215152483,
0.0245201737,
-0.0619604588,
0.0291448422,
-0.0103261555,
0.0122031923,
0.0079623098,
0.0010377597,
0.0258462727,
0.0192168206,
0.0548963323,
0.0468713567,
-0.0122437775,
-0.0300450865,
0.0177328996,
0.0116521781,
0.0172073785,
-0.0622173958,
-0.0310850237,
0.0143126734,
0.0183593724,
-0.007817626,
-0.0022793373,
-0.0008648686,
0.0487946011,
-0.0717817917,
0.0668258816,
-0.0145616466,
0.0302416626,
0.0167607162,
0.0166390073,
-0.032287322,
-0.0144073842,
0.0181928538,
0.0296522658,
0.0131922578,
-0.0634349883,
0.0037988659,
-0.0021905047,
0.0445667394,
0.010280814,
0.0143511277,
-0.0665862709,
-0.0454926416,
-0.0711254328,
-0.0117276125,
0.0136110075,
0.032005839,
-0.0100403605,
-0.0003407911,
-0.0375738554,
0.0444231108,
-0.0700894371,
0.0419904552,
-0.0024742577,
-0.0127357002,
-0.0173173472,
0.0308574289,
-0.0062979949,
-0.0365913212,
0.0304153766,
0.0125424908,
0.0169673916,
0.0325982571,
0.0056138281,
-0.0422625244,
-0.073148407,
-0.0578537919,
0.0442925096,
-0.0705707148,
0.0030224293,
-0.0359416641,
-0.0061257384,
-0.0722674876,
0.0087442584,
0.017868368,
-0.0107994443,
0.0547198541,
0.0106958551,
-0.0390788466,
0.0415773205,
0.0214088261,
-0.0319735631,
-0.0198303722,
0.0028362339,
0.0073371101,
0.0270938352,
0.014614257,
0.0372912511,
-0.0255537033,
0.0128052272,
-0.0161726438,
0.032987453,
-0.0135435117,
-0.0497884452,
0.0225935169,
-0.0054730191,
0.033422783,
-0.0537532717,
-0.0497932769,
0.0357700251,
0.0308750328,
-0.0543567948,
0.0302795134,
0.0338864587,
-0.0065444359,
0.0204902533,
0.0123252366,
-0.0111150071,
0.0183259342,
0.0294108409,
-0.0272292718,
0.0144871697,
-0.0240177196,
-0.0224717949,
-0.0446882807,
0.0016242506,
-0.0003612904,
-0.0570584834,
-0.004329958,
0.014197466,
0.0462936014,
-0.006083671,
-0.0403703153,
0.0332320221,
-0.0534364432,
-0.0320065655,
-0.0011503942,
0.0208727773,
-0.0312057938,
0.0228564125,
0.0203301758,
-0.0064846245,
-0.0247024894,
0.006817773,
0.0464246944,
0.0721617341,
-0.0604756959,
-0.039986603,
-0.0204046834,
-0.0302231926,
-0.0758666247,
0.0079729082,
0.0142960409,
0.0057333698,
-0.0036528993,
0.0235029403,
0.0085721919,
-0.0641597211,
0.0363336541,
0.0211721975,
-0.0209668577,
0.0318237953,
0.0132925967,
0.0836027861,
0.0588867217,
-0.0272749364,
0.0064367126,
0.0414637886,
-0.0159160327,
-0.0235300362,
0.047596965,
0.0218253173,
-0.0261071529,
0.0438471027,
-0.0992306322,
-0.0206880216,
-0.0221584179,
-0.0257765483,
-0.0193328932,
0.0259302966,
0.0410888158,
-0.0265312437,
-0.0361014977,
-0.0352789648,
-0.0087239705,
-0.0165250655,
-0.0262332745,
0.0221920852,
0.030875979,
-0.0069966619,
0.0168463085,
-0.0526575185,
0.0399940684,
-0.0242497195,
-0.0273373052,
-0.0010876353,
0.0203024708,
-0.0287870169,
0.0346904323,
-0.0379911512,
-0.028536072,
-0.0187723935,
-0.1320054382,
-0.0243297406,
-0.0078554107,
0.0178795196,
0.0364623778,
-0.0811351687,
0.0129412822,
-0.0110410228,
-0.0356120206,
0.0066169854,
0.0052211923,
0.0058052461,
0.0537385829,
-0.0051460648,
0.066575706,
-0.0470577963,
0.0052146539,
-0.0340766944,
0.0527710542,
0.0174560901,
0.0075708223,
0.0059184525,
-0.0064134817,
-0.0483161174,
0.0146385236,
-0.0160827655,
-0.0333044976,
0.072905831,
0.0633729696,
0.0307533126,
0.0403788462,
0.0377246365,
0.0120550273,
0.0667392239,
-0.004719933,
-0.0222577453,
-0.0103391726,
0.002657142,
0.0467189886,
0.0057194014,
-0.0441416278,
0.0183154959,
0.0641551241,
0.0252242498,
0.0040556015,
-0.0311860889,
0.0606241338,
0.0035525004,
-0.0079461504,
0.0048114085,
-0.0374109112,
-0.0140583543,
-0.0009095557,
-0.0244846251,
0.0047190525,
0.0618642047,
-0.0327531248,
0.0283019152,
-0.0216017496,
0.0195954945,
-0.0223578736,
0.0209014714,
-0.0284905601,
-0.004973256,
0.0200270489,
0.0519334599,
-0.0032663939,
-0.0269061346,
0.0826751292,
-0.0055907234,
0.0094622448,
-0.0407297462,
0.0136592854,
-0.0076953159,
-0.0304750577,
-0.0247906223,
-0.0100086164,
-0.0516865999,
-0.0318446979,
-0.0378954448,
0.0113690346,
-0.0007787529,
-0.0055034617,
0.0044731866,
0.0157566536,
-0.0334144123,
-0.0246335175,
0.0341706388,
0.0063381074,
0.0297829919,
-0.0103505272,
0.0447510183,
-0.0261684861,
-0.0122074652,
0.063886784,
0.0145880207,
-0.0027076514,
-0.0483186804,
-0.0407428965,
-0.0372285619,
-0.0216026399,
-0.0031965538,
-0.0334045067,
0.0496151745,
-0.0553545393,
-0.0015017241,
0.0779698491,
0.0132667702,
-0.032369066,
-0.0089310352,
-0.0202475339,
0.0316995941,
0.0308609866,
0.0106817065,
-0.079314746,
-0.0233692974,
-0.0324601047,
0.0490270518,
-0.0211156532,
-0.0214955993,
-0.0047267475,
-0.1157702133,
0.0467160046,
0.0082228351,
0.0344302952,
-0.0086625479,
0.0041367193,
0.00592286,
0.0232364554,
-0.0234591682,
0.0015312997,
0.0166735835,
0.0408596955,
0.0181014072,
-0.0168209411,
0.0118405055,
0.0453410745,
-0.0150495907,
0.0610817112,
-0.028429307,
0.0562765859,
0.0417801999,
0.0074441461,
0.0376170762,
-0.0354013406,
-0.017301999,
-0.0193280075,
0.0395525359,
-0.0361551084,
-0.0105418451,
-0.0127063375,
0.0574303716,
-0.0276536793,
-0.0381880105,
0.0494747348,
0.0428146422,
-0.0121081937,
-0.0006062341,
-0.035654489,
0.0266868491,
-0.0002594276,
0.049952887,
0.0211696811,
-0.0121816201,
-0.0597167574,
-0.0373267718,
-0.0006112905,
-0.0438054875,
-0.0482490994,
-0.0124196373,
0.0197211076,
0.0414683446,
-0.073513031,
-0.0894063413,
-0.0113197807,
0.0287176408,
0.0109957187,
-0.0176288914,
-0.0256971829,
0.0124097811,
-0.0467880405,
0.0123575022,
-0.0225440841,
-0.00989048,
-0.0048689824,
0.0030035728,
0.0212424882,
-0.0081543978,
-0.0213674251,
0.0198483113,
0.0229678005,
-0.0445483327,
-0.0389206894,
0.0741655603,
0.0132148312,
0.0270912088,
0.0459370911,
-0.0139365913,
-0.0008898946,
-0.0062759435,
0.0277862214,
0.0092677884,
0.0688837096,
0.0106258085,
0.0164327305,
0.0090888925,
-0.0000244736,
0.038851507,
0.0415777601,
0.0107244654,
-0.0401876867,
-0.0013884688,
0.0133987879,
-0.031624686,
0.0421328209,
0.0155893816,
-0.0087969964,
-0.0435592681,
0.0149137275,
-0.0619467683,
-0.0508574396,
-0.0031247064,
-0.0123626972,
-0.0087788375,
-0.0034439394,
-0.0372316577,
0.031895563,
-0.039642375,
0.1040759683,
-0.0551286861,
0.0466756038,
0.0640098229,
0.0322499834,
-0.0679776743,
-0.0308097918,
-0.0228018519,
0.0006731299,
-0.0036181922,
0.0405664891,
0.0062666014,
0.0848837495,
0.0202481598,
0.0170143899,
0.0180304125,
-0.028498888,
-0.0755491853,
0.0525615439,
0.0033708359,
-0.0178769697,
-0.008582579,
0.0052674967,
0.0612445101,
-0.0065486757,
-0.0129837114,
-0.0049965549,
0.0426179208,
-0.0314806625,
-0.0143398196,
0.0468219593,
0.0127722165,
-0.0366104618,
0.0188434478,
0.0643016621,
-0.0352622159,
0.0307941809,
0.0295208078,
-0.0435907841,
-0.064016737,
-0.0544927232,
-0.0225619543,
0.0441148765,
0.0328204706,
0.0022290396,
-0.0906502604,
-0.0209768247,
-0.0085971486,
0.0300694592,
0.0189717803,
0.0083616329,
-0.0222633835,
0.0504445918,
0.0068027568,
-0.0027940255,
-0.0553402677,
0.015916042,
-0.0140644247,
0.0012034201,
-0.0444686413,
-5.581167097e-33,
-0.0297075864,
-0.0603707097,
-0.0014137384,
0.0567752607,
-0.0069216113,
0.0028352679,
-0.0477511883,
0.0059275348,
-0.0261252318,
0.0747900531,
-0.0066392487,
0.0403961651,
-0.005161352,
0.0090899216,
0.0388228521,
0.0164508931,
0.0396125317,
-0.0310751665,
-0.0461014137,
0.037436489,
0.0313079581,
-0.0246196613,
0.0442629494,
-0.0631166697,
0.0601745322,
-0.0067195571,
-0.0126933362,
0.0028033648,
-0.014138557,
0.047128357,
-0.0361122899,
0.0233121105,
0.0313313492,
0.0038261267,
0.0262132846,
-0.030873172,
-0.0528305583,
-0.005854289,
0.0094120167,
-0.0382258184,
-0.0127308005,
-0.027340211,
0.0177671164,
0.0097351586,
-0.0131865181,
-0.0151775749,
0.0200663712,
-0.042495884,
0.0189366844,
-0.0676190406,
-0.0660909191,
0.0216089487,
-0.0248848256,
-0.0045649773,
-0.0167220403,
0.0175041202,
0.0014449969,
0.0248384029,
-0.072897315,
0.0347049683,
-0.0190930385,
-0.000806038,
0.0007092908,
-0.0456435084,
-0.007590773,
0.088039048,
0.0079254778,
0.0496897846,
-0.0246423036,
-0.0013276892,
-0.0203080755,
0.0172158573,
0.0529384986,
0.101829432,
0.0418242738,
-0.0195405111,
-0.0913268253,
-0.0065635848,
0.0686723068,
0.0283922702,
0.040570844,
-0.0161268339,
0.0164730325,
-0.0091585787,
-0.0112992534,
-0.1039607748,
-0.0147843454,
-0.0056064012,
0.0067056445,
0.0191579293,
-0.032343287,
-0.0055475533,
-0.0233988427,
-0.0307365935,
-0.0093968343,
0.0722474009,
-0.0360702127,
0.0153649589,
0.0172278862,
-0.050650835,
-0.0689245537,
0.030757295,
-0.0037543585,
0.0203907657,
0.0345613882,
-0.0247553643,
0.0780632794,
0.0038969698,
-0.0652749762,
-0.0192714296,
-0.0072434992,
0.0239309743,
-0.0252930671,
0.009945035,
0.000061007,
0.0473671407,
0.0113466848,
0.0171421338,
-0.0015753981,
-0.0008610863,
-0.0239268597,
0.014240576,
0.0306109749,
0.0071870838,
0.0092973532,
0.0039243349,
0.0249772165,
0.0235152673,
0.0034361812,
-0.0423850901,
0.0039517391,
0.0019958594,
2.397e-7,
0.0250506643,
0.0543871969,
0.0409638844,
-0.0206812453,
0.0369242765,
0.0553879887,
0.0011522503,
0.0049104178,
0.0433541499,
-0.0647981614,
0.0198859815,
0.0200306457,
0.0233623795,
0.0258680508,
-0.0718458742,
-0.0049596741,
-0.0744399354,
-0.0478474274,
-0.0233208034,
-0.0248302724,
0.0151487635,
0.0306193363,
0.0125558516,
-0.0105591491,
-0.0158295184,
0.0265687499,
0.1091956943,
0.0293690208,
0.017779557,
-0.003890191,
-0.0001201774,
-0.072588332,
-0.0181655027,
0.0129236607,
-0.0117257526,
0.0414081737,
0.0097907139,
0.0650418401,
-0.0084398678,
-0.0496494062,
-0.0011947581,
0.0570811965,
0.0242474433,
-0.0405167863,
0.0374935791,
-0.0841700062,
-0.043332193,
-0.0622832552,
-0.0269082282,
0.008711176,
0.0298187081,
-0.0092538195,
-0.0356819294,
0.0160166789,
0.0080806566,
0.0011712755,
0.0137865897,
-0.0641392618,
-0.0174343232,
0.0264551044,
-0.0170154497,
-0.0127270482,
0.0124454834,
-0.0611872412,
0.0047836676,
-0.0111655397,
0.0015979633,
1.985440264e-34,
0.0413342007,
-0.0376049839,
-0.0081773745,
-0.0101248464,
0.0475249849,
0.0117695909,
-0.0275220685,
0.0054901741,
0.0317032076,
-0.0145010371,
-0.0316749848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03969v1 | Factoring Hate Speech: A New Annotation Framework to Study Hate Speech in Social Media | 2023-11-07T13:08:55 | 2023-11-07T13:08:55 | Gal Ron, Effi Levi, Odelia Oshri, Shaul R. Shenhav | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work we propose a novel annotation scheme which factors hate speech
into five separate discursive categories. To evaluate our scheme, we construct
a corpus of over 2.9M Twitter posts containing hateful expressions directed at
Jews, and annotate a sample dataset of 1,050 tweets. We present a statistical
analysis of the annotated dataset as well as discuss annotation examples, and
conclude by discussing promising directions for future work. | [
0.0298568085,
0.0363057256,
0.0003404115,
0.0211023763,
0.0280791391,
0.0794669241,
0.0447384827,
0.0071602571,
0.0152376471,
-0.1016822904,
0.0394777954,
0.0033894717,
-0.0189327449,
-0.0131517211,
0.0086473338,
-0.0300820656,
0.0326895118,
0.0587278828,
0.0464094505,
0.0110713318,
0.0692014247,
0.0155609129,
-0.0227047186,
0.0468277968,
-0.092114158,
0.0296653695,
0.0620217472,
-0.0308797769,
0.0155246863,
-0.0097640036,
0.0042016916,
0.0427245796,
-0.0159631986,
0.070724465,
0.0000018606,
-0.0102229854,
0.0164418425,
0.0104202051,
0.0002429845,
-0.05083533,
0.0694922134,
-0.0458777472,
0.0000750209,
0.0155048557,
-0.0341902338,
-0.0223787706,
0.0699805692,
0.052321624,
0.0778230354,
0.0524590872,
-0.0098936548,
-0.0427057818,
-0.0038689354,
0.0244133286,
-0.0065344889,
0.0513343327,
0.0194466263,
-0.0199891217,
-0.0709027722,
-0.001887906,
0.0160084609,
0.0072650658,
0.018008681,
0.038234666,
0.0337354504,
-0.0496661961,
-0.0214343332,
-0.037772879,
0.0211374592,
-0.0195402391,
0.0048907711,
-0.00142455,
0.0047675655,
0.0026303993,
-0.0277225934,
-0.003987283,
-0.0159161128,
0.0113639385,
-0.0392412171,
0.0096713444,
0.0214928836,
0.0233808607,
0.0428687222,
0.0592097864,
0.0314597748,
0.0447207876,
-0.014099,
-0.0352039188,
-0.007128763,
-0.0163301509,
-0.0221458822,
-0.0014505873,
-0.0099229058,
-0.002912597,
0.016682487,
0.0011354769,
-0.0452941507,
-0.0299713276,
0.0268679559,
-0.0628241897,
0.0261421781,
0.0243811961,
-0.0272142626,
-0.0147837996,
0.0588943847,
-0.0077104052,
0.0151659604,
-0.0249226578,
0.0081300093,
0.001410641,
-0.0197400413,
0.0142011363,
0.03330677,
-0.0204572901,
0.0085087633,
0.0588308387,
-0.0515729338,
-0.0129217524,
-0.0315470919,
-0.0119911907,
0.0002371527,
-0.0444720015,
0.0061010937,
0.0341228433,
-0.0217905845,
0.0060427221,
-0.076301232,
-0.002957454,
-0.048337575,
-0.0646739751,
0.0254846271,
0.0288478229,
-0.0222225413,
-0.0252033882,
-0.0082389629,
0.0473719202,
0.0411034413,
-0.0310770497,
-0.0103371534,
-0.0393079072,
-0.0209374223,
0.0068759983,
0.0224483293,
-0.0637619197,
0.0159092546,
-0.0020132367,
-0.0610828884,
-0.0388186127,
-0.002500644,
0.0143880416,
-0.0215256009,
0.0725959465,
-0.0449260958,
-0.0387894735,
0.053007789,
0.0079613291,
-0.0107584987,
0.0200967547,
0.0045234282,
-0.0014919665,
0.0475413948,
0.006607322,
0.0380098857,
0.0580027178,
0.0204420965,
0.0136419879,
0.0001934567,
0.0122873364,
-0.0645617023,
-0.0514115281,
-0.0107604722,
0.0347113274,
-0.0273683667,
-0.0325239003,
0.003817857,
0.0876368657,
-0.0402835943,
0.0055366787,
0.0252514742,
0.0411961041,
0.0018477925,
-0.0351673029,
-0.0513549708,
-0.0052773505,
-0.011298026,
-0.0410746634,
0.0254480522,
0.0550542437,
0.0120549444,
-0.0538716801,
-0.0447469242,
0.0069332016,
0.0977109745,
-0.0503242053,
-0.0050496161,
0.0071013272,
0.0155267799,
0.0059599937,
0.0533587858,
-0.0181716997,
0.0143241519,
-0.0117078163,
-0.0125119668,
0.0366566367,
0.0093276063,
-0.0105720609,
-0.0023375382,
-0.066752933,
0.0238477699,
0.051546514,
-0.0111054471,
-0.0181442872,
-0.0436197147,
-0.0286046881,
-0.0093462458,
0.0451180041,
0.027279485,
-0.0029252341,
0.054156784,
-0.0122469226,
0.0023979375,
0.0530617386,
-0.0204190649,
0.0107056815,
0.0624943189,
-0.0366287045,
-0.0235185008,
-0.0030959083,
0.0336206965,
0.053817533,
-0.0122184511,
-0.0528604016,
-0.0049529132,
0.0039097155,
-0.0317713656,
0.0233335979,
-0.0176380649,
0.0285125002,
0.0160398446,
-0.0479813218,
-0.0293392614,
0.0516506173,
0.0024108007,
0.025766883,
0.0588563457,
-0.0212162435,
-0.0015572511,
-0.0334987156,
-0.0398464799,
-0.0593433753,
0.0247346628,
-0.028168669,
0.0816723704,
-0.0183801483,
-0.005483998,
0.000216114,
-0.1055761501,
0.0204619709,
0.0592888109,
-0.03375623,
-0.0348897427,
-0.0263165385,
0.0379267149,
-0.0069622002,
-0.0290100407,
-0.0216003172,
0.0417259559,
-0.0908033699,
0.008534695,
-0.0261131916,
-0.0163545329,
-0.0079332087,
0.0253111236,
0.0083723627,
0.0248333253,
0.0154136512,
-0.0579071306,
0.0252521913,
0.0234825052,
0.0185594968,
-0.0651846901,
-0.0195660144,
-0.0518062189,
-0.0103269974,
-0.0484329909,
-0.0010769217,
0.0018992601,
-0.0639513731,
0.0391829386,
-0.0177492201,
-0.043617513,
0.0249959007,
-0.0000843933,
-0.0186249465,
0.0473455898,
0.0359717868,
-0.0487742648,
-0.0034157564,
0.0530092083,
0.0918151587,
0.0042816866,
-0.0307777356,
-0.0056621982,
0.0160032604,
-0.0008318751,
0.0300225709,
-0.0292870123,
-0.0254823044,
0.0059691342,
0.0790310279,
0.0394402817,
-0.0152120301,
-0.0624220222,
0.0380177647,
-0.1129832268,
-0.0235510003,
-0.0072414461,
-0.065192841,
-0.0420169085,
-0.0099263592,
-0.0229162853,
-0.0376246423,
0.0315156356,
0.0013554321,
0.0158999115,
-0.0133125018,
-0.0352916159,
0.0090832105,
0.0251113214,
-0.0065363594,
-0.000139214,
-0.0505063608,
0.0226684418,
0.0383810326,
-0.0126488712,
0.0248429533,
-0.0012232456,
0.0209778473,
0.0185208172,
0.0164796654,
-0.0004992358,
-0.0248877592,
-0.0280555692,
-0.0838646516,
-0.0745349899,
-0.0491122864,
0.0187156871,
-0.0158224348,
0.0025474075,
-0.0010903671,
0.0011676628,
-0.0095361816,
0.0499514416,
0.0064985105,
0.0124734743,
-0.0538875051,
-0.0210397337,
0.0036077991,
0.0336477719,
0.0339846425,
-0.0328883231,
0.0338103771,
-0.0456419364,
0.0012303598,
-0.0083476184,
-0.0039598346,
-0.0072695781,
-0.0242941082,
-0.0170262065,
-0.0297321696,
0.0180231277,
0.017085975,
0.0147430552,
0.0936839655,
0.0256430041,
-0.0058104633,
0.0056075566,
0.0028873973,
0.0096028531,
0.0092351064,
-0.0261761025,
-0.1337935776,
-0.0104689561,
-0.0226464532,
0.0212258939,
-0.0491320789,
-0.0622116551,
0.0188881513,
-0.0176530797,
0.0140388403,
0.0084976368,
0.0003360439,
-0.003796258,
-0.0099268658,
0.0055166357,
-0.0120574245,
0.0040658773,
-0.0328202248,
0.0325393341,
0.0127985673,
0.0496624485,
-0.0870207027,
0.0124291219,
0.0243527777,
-0.021011794,
0.0316822641,
-0.0096974047,
0.0366060548,
-0.0144591406,
0.0073503205,
0.0087421965,
0.0005176449,
-0.0291957129,
-0.0551478006,
0.0317158252,
0.0088459039,
-0.0428953022,
-0.0081948619,
0.0380106382,
-0.0171583835,
-0.0168148726,
0.025080312,
0.0382175855,
0.0211124998,
0.0507696457,
-0.0542514548,
0.0295572598,
-0.0129580805,
0.0662799627,
0.0260649007,
-0.0219478197,
0.04652033,
-0.0821591318,
0.0131983915,
-0.0290710293,
-0.1119639426,
0.0079434132,
-0.0274711903,
-0.0443441644,
-0.0483963899,
-0.0679250583,
0.0455318503,
-0.0051065744,
0.0364383608,
-0.0089360951,
-0.0191654395,
-0.030441545,
-0.0622539409,
-0.0196267907,
0.0294763111,
0.0278128032,
0.0494850054,
0.0036225715,
-0.044796221,
0.0161515754,
-0.0218795463,
0.0421184376,
-0.0311958529,
-0.0063820207,
0.1072368249,
0.0184505526,
0.0173669811,
0.0045652743,
-0.0152220456,
-0.064260304,
0.0032840217,
0.0530800633,
-0.0243846122,
0.007521282,
0.0441422313,
0.0165085793,
0.0178972259,
-0.0257214941,
-0.0079353489,
0.0498033166,
0.008793653,
-0.0430611335,
-0.0838367194,
0.0362777971,
-0.0372673422,
-0.0466937311,
0.0697891861,
-0.0119717633,
-0.0580523275,
-0.0340945199,
-0.0280056465,
0.003482325,
-0.0629468784,
-0.0319349542,
0.004624017,
-0.022208821,
0.0055921953,
-0.0676772222,
-0.020561479,
-0.0160292275,
0.0107770525,
-0.053024143,
0.0388704054,
0.0792206079,
0.0243317392,
-0.0251187161,
-0.0047757234,
-0.0094055189,
0.027697362,
-0.0020875791,
-0.0263398457,
0.0092730066,
0.0013695518,
-0.0132076936,
-0.0050476077,
0.047258202,
-0.0352859125,
0.0211504791,
-0.0053995699,
-0.042799186,
-0.0072886427,
-0.0292201824,
-0.0204301178,
0.0879604295,
0.0321315899,
-0.0252000708,
-0.0111708939,
-0.0046646763,
-0.0183038916,
-0.0286907703,
0.0102431495,
0.0213746149,
-0.0374316536,
-0.0226326697,
0.0084273415,
-0.0042158365,
0.0197128579,
0.0665557608,
-0.0232676994,
-0.0340016894,
-0.0153220771,
0.0225525238,
0.0512530766,
0.0469437391,
-0.0075033843,
-0.0660627559,
-0.0200525504,
0.0033685227,
-0.0473495238,
0.0306332223,
0.001840558,
-0.0021264069,
0.0562035926,
0.0032929154,
0.0043535139,
-0.0239919834,
0.0071538906,
0.0227250773,
-0.0762420148,
0.0112982718,
-5.930112595e-33,
0.0007211657,
-0.0154207246,
0.0124455811,
0.0223680809,
0.0032501919,
-0.011506483,
0.0624458678,
0.0299127121,
-0.0114023061,
0.033606194,
-0.0119623216,
0.0233352426,
0.0221996903,
0.0069878935,
0.0319880843,
-0.0355038121,
0.0192558262,
-0.0132298218,
-0.0146537898,
-0.0081077879,
0.0480910167,
-0.0233435668,
0.035313081,
-0.0510687493,
0.0694595203,
-0.0315935761,
-0.0243662968,
0.0083302855,
0.0607999749,
0.0736057535,
-0.0404029489,
0.0718613043,
0.0441250838,
-0.0135661103,
-0.0042753848,
0.0490266681,
-0.0174531173,
0.0070318929,
0.0647311658,
0.0303623751,
-0.0130732423,
-0.012896942,
0.0009772662,
0.0095399916,
-0.066270113,
-0.0338658951,
0.0447896346,
-0.0221530423,
-0.0054167407,
-0.016766306,
-0.0978919789,
0.0535388812,
-0.0577650778,
0.0104257064,
0.0334904157,
0.0255662743,
0.0538392067,
-0.0068107331,
-0.0513872057,
0.0187212601,
-0.0305296332,
0.0096248351,
-0.0241338871,
-0.0151468534,
-0.0061777779,
0.068263717,
-0.0105260797,
0.0135292728,
-0.0201546885,
0.0463927798,
0.0050342865,
0.0332413688,
0.0142644327,
0.0765663087,
0.0228574723,
-0.0519824103,
-0.0369766951,
-0.0097661344,
0.0325684771,
-0.0062755495,
-0.0184078459,
-0.0267351903,
-0.0608008839,
-0.0359004289,
-0.021094285,
-0.0567561798,
-0.0288765971,
-0.0027021524,
0.008931987,
-0.0094102146,
-0.0316286273,
0.0306878034,
0.0311650578,
-0.0147776119,
0.034384802,
0.0410517789,
-0.0335166678,
0.0172483418,
-0.0022414962,
0.0177593231,
-0.0029655907,
-0.0058039995,
-0.002475431,
-0.0048573827,
0.0553036667,
-0.0052056191,
0.0721021965,
0.0144222574,
-0.0606396981,
-0.006667593,
0.0128378309,
0.0326603055,
-0.0681133121,
0.0081653735,
0.013867544,
0.0657035336,
0.0103257038,
-0.0263952184,
0.0485766269,
-0.0268474407,
-0.0048621036,
0.0178364553,
-0.0315845795,
-0.0317695364,
0.0118159382,
-0.0187129118,
0.0255667511,
-0.0216800459,
0.0308037307,
-0.101812616,
0.0226946194,
-0.0732499883,
2.494e-7,
0.0379797705,
0.0596154407,
-0.0231303796,
-0.0052087978,
0.0295817852,
0.0245509557,
0.1101976186,
0.0045191864,
0.0064209453,
0.0034950478,
-0.0354312249,
0.0136564001,
0.019263085,
0.0479090549,
-0.0193398502,
-0.0702235922,
-0.0602385774,
0.0175008904,
-0.0760452077,
0.017998863,
-0.0027805734,
0.083980687,
0.0918914452,
-0.0228583757,
-0.041840598,
0.0215302445,
-0.0129129272,
-0.0457810424,
-0.0457280502,
-0.0079915365,
0.0546127222,
0.0214792378,
0.0381140895,
-0.0029282777,
-0.012568065,
0.016156517,
0.0400410928,
0.0265522152,
0.0423089936,
0.0262372997,
-0.004753734,
-0.0145015605,
-0.0018836312,
-0.0007529015,
0.0068722893,
0.0254494157,
-0.0379225947,
-0.0414686538,
-0.0232725181,
0.0103349881,
0.0444379933,
0.016257301,
-0.0167882908,
-0.0222751126,
0.0321658961,
0.0055491552,
0.0021842038,
-0.0491422191,
-0.013392007,
0.0042214552,
-0.0109492978,
-0.0419751219,
-0.0168763418,
-0.0415561348,
0.0241463259,
0.0594009086,
0.0426305309,
1.814893712e-34,
0.0110332984,
-0.0201451574,
0.0409911312,
-0.0116272755,
0.0554474592,
0.0231406819,
-0.0063921474,
0.0061985971,
0.0377626568,
-0.0285878461,
0.0026748772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03963v1 | An Expectation-Realization Model for Metaphor Detection | 2023-11-07T13:03:54 | 2023-11-07T13:03:54 | Oseremen O. Uduehi, Razvan C. Bunescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a metaphor detection architecture that is structured around two
main modules: an expectation component that estimates representations of
literal word expectations given a context, and a realization component that
computes representations of actual word meanings in context. The overall
architecture is trained to learn expectation-realization (ER) patterns that
characterize metaphorical uses of words. When evaluated on three metaphor
datasets for within distribution, out of distribution, and novel metaphor
generalization, the proposed method is shown to obtain results that are
competitive or better than state-of-the art. Further increases in metaphor
detection accuracy are obtained through ensembling of ER models. | [
0.0516571216,
0.0151065225,
-0.0213029459,
0.0563621409,
0.0093474369,
0.0199871175,
-0.0713589415,
-0.0220342427,
0.0436396599,
-0.0423509665,
-0.0127250124,
0.0085507631,
-0.0188684724,
0.0236094147,
0.0142055871,
-0.0482525863,
0.0173910521,
0.0731340721,
-0.0102570709,
0.0055305734,
-0.0506903455,
0.0376696922,
-0.0109497607,
0.0688039437,
-0.0200487971,
-0.0000578218,
0.0011680222,
0.057597056,
0.0016211289,
-0.0595996045,
0.0122445654,
-0.0238678865,
0.0496310294,
-0.0137628522,
0.0000020177,
-0.0720518976,
-0.0216513649,
-0.0582836829,
0.0178710409,
-0.0287370365,
0.0813094676,
-0.0405759998,
0.0176349431,
-0.0337924547,
0.019684298,
0.0311838128,
0.0299860407,
0.0531198308,
0.0206343681,
0.0003583848,
-0.01197543,
-0.0298848227,
-0.0213335268,
0.0214514229,
-0.0154619031,
0.0050937235,
0.0303976238,
0.0055975495,
-0.0047918139,
-0.0559741966,
-0.0722375289,
-0.0060230102,
0.0300128832,
0.1028694883,
-0.0134596014,
0.0532583036,
-0.0073497356,
0.040854346,
-0.0420765616,
0.0372419469,
0.0293212049,
-0.0181181412,
-0.0279339273,
-0.0286085829,
-0.0044143382,
0.0501159616,
0.0349848792,
-0.0187665224,
0.001250437,
0.0418050811,
0.0150065599,
0.0206981041,
-0.0010288534,
0.0004280613,
-0.0412716009,
0.0047026621,
0.0161629021,
-0.0056842468,
-0.0243117418,
-0.0239340812,
-0.037372075,
-0.0132032838,
-0.0181671847,
-0.0033229515,
0.0356780998,
0.0295976195,
-0.0391378589,
-0.0373332836,
-0.0078239711,
-0.0405236594,
0.0333044641,
0.0430858731,
0.0048863268,
0.0555919893,
-0.040409755,
0.0121498061,
-0.012446736,
0.0472043306,
-0.0389062837,
-0.0302797705,
-0.0489213355,
0.0134997182,
-0.0696614832,
0.0441950373,
-0.0089194654,
-0.0692149922,
-0.0372468494,
0.0034311197,
-0.0203949269,
-0.0189094543,
-0.0503168143,
0.0450851433,
-0.0365963057,
-0.008930807,
-0.0822098628,
-0.0466315188,
-0.0285615288,
0.0248629469,
-0.0580034293,
-0.041678533,
0.0039209453,
-0.009230068,
0.0150392037,
-0.0326411985,
0.0318777859,
0.0730477646,
0.0283894688,
-0.0515997,
-0.0363723747,
-0.0279722493,
0.0063471845,
0.0294584036,
-0.0422975086,
-0.0053549297,
0.0335393697,
-0.0272449329,
0.0380023308,
-0.0171941202,
0.0038177259,
-0.0248563047,
-0.0419591404,
0.0543107018,
-0.0010682108,
-0.0165510885,
0.0125125386,
0.0150661748,
-0.0630923361,
0.0373312347,
0.0299309418,
0.0169575904,
0.0107538523,
0.022785224,
-0.0191303585,
0.0075602741,
-0.0203681532,
-0.0150383897,
-0.0467762649,
-0.0010380676,
-0.0096334405,
0.0639270842,
0.0288120769,
0.028772546,
-0.0355623513,
-0.015504064,
0.0281704515,
0.06821426,
-0.0023109592,
0.0027473383,
0.0789545998,
-0.0002658809,
0.0069855438,
0.0348609164,
0.0036595729,
-0.0266778562,
0.0430309586,
-0.031827461,
-0.0157283302,
0.0151821347,
-0.0209268481,
0.0423958302,
-0.0150388926,
-0.0318045393,
-0.0386945121,
-0.0378701501,
0.0326951779,
-0.0047073001,
-0.0406916775,
0.0168983098,
0.0357740521,
0.0201153252,
-0.0097100269,
-0.0048175761,
-0.0141277723,
0.0795905292,
0.0380650051,
-0.0430412553,
0.0207997952,
-0.0063177319,
0.0008939296,
0.0120059839,
-0.0253774542,
0.004308437,
-0.0050661862,
-0.0148098851,
0.0137573164,
-0.0429664738,
0.0151737845,
0.0231514424,
-0.013952909,
0.0338438787,
-0.0012428651,
-0.0267775711,
-0.0309748109,
0.0591061488,
-0.0264817085,
-0.0051135132,
-0.0260647591,
0.0391693637,
0.0278764311,
-0.0280753374,
-0.0180788245,
-0.0296018645,
0.0099441418,
-0.0421171524,
-0.0322462544,
0.0926904678,
-0.0457067676,
-0.0233497079,
0.0243418235,
-0.0852459073,
-0.0123575497,
0.0055598132,
0.0181375798,
-0.0196112357,
0.0351870507,
-0.058963079,
0.1058657467,
-0.0676349923,
-0.0204156879,
-0.0219835434,
0.0353354327,
0.0199549571,
0.0426862091,
-0.0065929983,
0.0252664611,
-0.0093556475,
-0.0010495163,
0.0003283526,
0.0654975846,
-0.0353376418,
-0.0278324187,
0.0396439806,
-0.0228202473,
-0.0308316704,
-0.0757141411,
-0.0604905896,
-0.0183339845,
-0.084748596,
0.0083946567,
0.0173040628,
-0.0178221576,
0.0678438097,
-0.044455599,
-0.046538692,
-0.0198010374,
0.0236597732,
-0.0015183284,
-0.014362257,
-0.0210238788,
0.0248204637,
-0.0592257306,
-0.0462203808,
0.0012878713,
0.0440546833,
-0.0670801476,
0.0528448224,
-0.01775291,
0.0243298169,
0.0208340939,
-0.0219014641,
-0.0230083484,
-0.0112921633,
-0.0094215386,
-0.0358397625,
-0.0031507355,
0.0611975975,
0.0958512649,
0.0135034304,
0.0211140793,
0.060594596,
0.0665518343,
-0.0139622856,
-0.0196396522,
-0.0141687067,
0.0211111661,
-0.0058948062,
-0.0117351031,
-0.0498704724,
-0.0023749068,
0.0654194131,
0.0659354925,
-0.0102899708,
-0.0292536188,
0.0437232405,
0.015373583,
-0.0084432838,
-0.003947678,
0.0341244973,
-0.0190148614,
-0.0021026239,
-0.0184938107,
-0.0043458119,
0.077856347,
0.0112601407,
-0.0110776927,
-0.009384918,
-0.0245258734,
-0.0049717408,
0.0357585922,
-0.0068338807,
0.0469355173,
0.0117275175,
0.0016289687,
-0.0053076963,
-0.0365577675,
-0.000859482,
-0.0163585711,
0.055221051,
-0.0050646146,
-0.0227014404,
0.0302215498,
0.0266528036,
-0.0465724356,
-0.0493182503,
-0.031627886,
0.0208361242,
-0.0198497362,
0.0265674572,
-0.0484672338,
-0.0384456441,
-0.0040262267,
-0.009081074,
0.0263885763,
-0.0602036044,
-0.0375121348,
0.0118187554,
0.0304907206,
-0.0056451773,
0.0059435237,
0.0057126838,
0.0396404043,
0.0268587004,
-0.0724153891,
-0.002327576,
-0.053811416,
0.0230552051,
-0.0126763461,
-0.0334292389,
0.0470788591,
-0.0088247936,
0.032893993,
-0.0047627124,
-0.0064478191,
0.0656342432,
0.0352257602,
0.0218834169,
0.0509092025,
-0.0188990794,
-0.0065420531,
0.0600431338,
-0.0173706226,
-0.078275688,
-0.037430346,
-0.0022764853,
-0.026609594,
-0.0058770957,
-0.055565875,
-0.014152498,
-0.0645903274,
0.0179706942,
-0.0234147366,
-0.0106150946,
-0.0066073053,
0.0198655427,
0.006858205,
0.0157433115,
-0.0154072866,
-0.0442606136,
-0.0148547571,
0.0116115399,
-0.0188464466,
0.0394650921,
-0.023507176,
0.0287084244,
-0.0626030415,
0.0307668522,
-0.0610350482,
0.0390564017,
-0.0115842959,
-0.0022917746,
-0.0700014159,
-0.0410059392,
-0.0139087439,
0.0282053016,
-0.0244560987,
-0.0433711186,
-0.0068609589,
-0.0087418826,
0.0269149262,
-0.0053822538,
-0.0150739495,
0.0281332713,
0.0926236436,
-0.0219186954,
-0.022339927,
-0.0524361692,
0.0020526741,
-0.0160487723,
0.0847349241,
0.0527753234,
-0.0244921539,
0.0274040475,
-0.0034447906,
-0.0108923763,
0.0304407533,
0.0355521031,
-0.0115295947,
-0.0678124204,
0.0277696643,
-0.0397886634,
-0.0087616211,
0.0023606147,
0.043836683,
0.0344124511,
-0.0167182926,
-0.0764769018,
-0.0447044224,
-0.0945202261,
0.0110406214,
-0.0196691826,
0.0078352392,
0.0305483434,
-0.0291246306,
0.0638298169,
-0.0283316765,
-0.035564404,
0.0662233531,
-0.0111902012,
-0.0480857752,
-0.0131296217,
0.0009557527,
0.0061666574,
0.0030412609,
0.000541229,
0.0135204643,
0.0702634752,
0.0321439207,
-0.0182570145,
0.043499589,
-0.0058289007,
0.0479256287,
0.0054743653,
0.031961102,
0.0151412524,
0.0479159951,
0.0246994421,
0.0070421579,
0.0078540277,
0.0431858264,
0.0238477793,
-0.0050447895,
0.0010770276,
-0.0234627221,
-0.1074257642,
-0.0312181432,
-0.0271680038,
-0.0094303526,
-0.0295810029,
-0.0025149419,
-0.0044704853,
0.0583185963,
0.0370254777,
-0.0699760839,
-0.023663735,
-0.0008727505,
0.0197544899,
0.0494602732,
-0.0130011374,
0.0423407108,
0.0225664508,
-0.0260727815,
0.0078847073,
-0.0264800508,
-0.0444393381,
-0.0497170426,
-0.0054935757,
0.0118908696,
-0.006351436,
0.0335417315,
-0.0076390067,
-0.0429623649,
0.0243146773,
0.0281318426,
-0.0301475413,
0.0315179266,
0.0469990373,
0.047795888,
-0.029019786,
-0.0314471833,
-0.0507774241,
0.0163036343,
0.0322115459,
0.0111101586,
-0.0396953635,
0.0013470036,
0.0354464538,
0.0083330004,
-0.0129247839,
-0.0301778093,
-0.0232522395,
-0.0728953779,
0.087771602,
-0.0151269967,
-0.0214700103,
-0.0191631913,
0.0380043313,
0.0392383151,
0.0440336429,
0.00595146,
0.0618173368,
-0.0429827422,
-0.0579873286,
0.0522633456,
0.0231141485,
-0.0065520261,
0.0142194787,
0.0218490232,
0.0407497883,
0.0281788558,
0.0203432944,
-0.0123335607,
-0.0124779362,
-0.0355812274,
0.0125464285,
-0.0084256018,
-5.923040527e-33,
-0.0209779106,
0.0025193274,
-0.0003240229,
-0.0334319174,
-0.0305080712,
0.0503678098,
-0.0542366765,
-0.0276333708,
0.013332325,
0.0115530798,
0.0364530981,
0.0048881336,
-0.0153512647,
-0.033467982,
0.0243649632,
0.0134978695,
0.0174107607,
0.0026269322,
-0.0450162105,
-0.0576167256,
0.0864891857,
0.0436794609,
0.0951688811,
0.0022026598,
-0.0219430048,
0.0233816635,
0.0082204184,
-0.0072287507,
0.0552471355,
0.0256327279,
-0.0365076922,
0.0509371944,
0.0298631657,
0.0253184754,
0.0198848918,
-0.0247006454,
-0.0300451629,
-0.0347302854,
0.0496248007,
-0.0127425697,
-0.0089790309,
-0.0038621409,
0.0613179505,
0.0073747067,
-0.0211261865,
0.0075368658,
0.0633164123,
-0.0165828262,
0.027883457,
0.0195716564,
-0.0494758338,
-0.0223793238,
-0.008034924,
-0.0047106198,
0.004339979,
-0.0010268241,
0.0414446145,
0.0577469394,
-0.0347508155,
-0.0010227481,
-0.0397276506,
-0.0529819205,
-0.0215042047,
-0.0165033378,
0.01391479,
0.1247510836,
0.0486229137,
-0.0268590413,
-0.067295514,
0.0098098544,
0.0569596142,
-0.0011390435,
-0.0055454834,
0.0215245765,
0.0709490925,
-0.0287570618,
0.0051505794,
0.0333715491,
0.0339240581,
0.000101166,
0.0530120246,
-0.0093942415,
-0.0403061919,
0.0317609906,
-0.0202628709,
-0.0087641003,
-0.0051017674,
-0.0416984148,
0.0226195548,
-0.0274123419,
-0.0042726342,
0.0256574973,
-0.0071144127,
-0.0207998864,
-0.021102678,
-0.0078642471,
-0.0039335103,
0.0006114715,
-0.0002928989,
0.0286721177,
-0.0050371755,
-0.0522867255,
0.0258102659,
0.0090297349,
0.0263936501,
-0.0052503324,
0.0107972752,
0.0077482979,
-0.0535852201,
0.0136912512,
-0.047706835,
-0.0443473421,
-0.0458323173,
-0.0530660339,
0.0103757428,
0.0319702998,
-0.0195000377,
-0.0464648195,
-0.0019923274,
-0.0422311835,
-0.0262870956,
0.0746545345,
-0.015990749,
0.0854398534,
-0.0091237593,
-0.0158640463,
-0.0249067023,
-0.0762702003,
0.0055386112,
-0.0584452078,
-0.0046940739,
-0.0174693093,
2.793e-7,
0.0298153292,
-0.0224822871,
0.0186562929,
0.0237716474,
0.0093918536,
-0.0029569876,
-0.0280254595,
0.0614131615,
-0.0151709523,
-0.0403146744,
0.0329536907,
0.0318481103,
-0.0269471053,
0.0065643718,
-0.1122280955,
0.0685212016,
-0.0248454791,
0.0277039483,
-0.0329806656,
-0.0000426113,
0.0612412356,
0.0425801873,
0.0578124337,
-0.0111953616,
0.0227804072,
-0.0351542607,
0.0426449068,
-0.0757559091,
0.058729995,
-0.00156617,
0.0145156123,
0.0520572588,
0.0052339518,
0.0449377857,
0.0267149527,
0.057054013,
0.0264180675,
0.0027513041,
-0.0270248894,
0.0126808733,
-0.0059623183,
-0.0302340984,
-0.0278822705,
-0.0572388209,
0.0122863501,
-0.050671339,
-0.0297197886,
-0.0221091062,
-0.003271882,
0.0014402568,
0.0811347812,
0.0023897793,
-0.0609679669,
-0.0029979807,
0.0386333726,
-0.0043257177,
0.0283400156,
-0.0751304254,
0.0482990369,
0.0639195517,
-0.0450686775,
0.0060611679,
-0.0055140974,
-0.0203888845,
-0.0040712543,
-0.0992995352,
0.015467667,
1.915866611e-34,
0.0029007047,
0.0117650516,
0.0084191011,
0.0431591496,
0.0639563873,
-0.0363853052,
0.0548797436,
-0.0371421538,
0.0112407478,
-0.0254128855,
-0.020324979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03952v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03952v2 | An Analysis of Dialogue Repair in Voice Assistants | 2023-11-07T12:50:11 | 2024-02-07T22:10:35 | Matthew Galbraith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.RO | Spoken dialogue systems have transformed human-machine interaction by
providing real-time responses to queries. However, misunderstandings between
the user and system persist. This study explores the significance of
interactional language in dialogue repair between virtual assistants and users
by analyzing interactions with Google Assistant and Siri, focusing on their
utilization and response to the other-initiated repair strategy "huh?"
prevalent in human-human interaction. Findings reveal several
assistant-generated strategies but an inability to replicate human-like repair
strategies such as "huh?". English and Spanish user acceptability surveys show
differences in users' repair strategy preferences and assistant usage, with
both similarities and disparities among the two surveyed languages. These
results shed light on inequalities between interactional language in
human-human interaction and human-machine interaction, underscoring the need
for further research on the impact of interactional language in human-machine
interaction in English and beyond. | [
0.0897024274,
0.0519069768,
-0.0653978884,
-0.0013828832,
-0.0037121451,
-0.0045022089,
-0.0037773692,
0.008575052,
0.0035045203,
-0.041191496,
-0.0217878912,
-0.0305666905,
0.077006653,
-0.0126041425,
0.0060478621,
-0.0690189004,
0.0064788749,
-0.0122008491,
0.0101234969,
0.0003336362,
0.0331532061,
0.019985918,
-0.0437170565,
0.0593288429,
-0.0340244882,
-0.0006117278,
-0.0303497426,
-0.0239433125,
-0.0060055209,
0.0295960102,
0.0115990005,
0.0302313771,
-0.0232998226,
0.024643695,
0.0000016992,
-0.0697508454,
0.0505737029,
-0.0094897868,
-0.0445501767,
-0.0055531915,
0.0075747222,
0.0485998653,
-0.0293462109,
0.0428993814,
-0.0231011733,
0.0153975002,
0.0450613424,
0.0213279165,
0.0489267223,
-0.0066928789,
-0.0139986016,
0.0319339484,
0.0335497148,
0.0097778169,
-0.0032894323,
-0.0384602882,
-0.0141860154,
-0.0088428315,
0.0484137423,
-0.045140788,
0.0147875696,
0.0419049934,
0.0089863455,
-0.0556393042,
-0.0738831088,
-0.0056511462,
-0.0353298783,
-0.0521380268,
-0.0144817019,
0.0428964943,
0.0497559384,
0.0373994336,
-0.0298234001,
0.0244839527,
0.0259116162,
0.0445478,
-0.0239946693,
-0.0206604265,
-0.0130104283,
-0.0473497733,
-0.0505334362,
-0.0580352098,
-0.0150089981,
-0.0178330634,
0.0037419419,
0.0227118265,
0.0033413381,
-0.0102682663,
0.0139857167,
-0.0103895674,
-0.0030560549,
-0.0203957427,
0.0020272527,
0.0254626777,
-0.087911956,
0.0190912988,
-0.0230570454,
0.0164961312,
0.0391900092,
-0.0343578644,
0.0179090016,
0.0373789147,
-0.0393078327,
-0.0104871001,
0.0576193854,
0.046649307,
0.0294639617,
-0.0471496694,
-0.0009416223,
-0.0097822584,
-0.0304114632,
-0.0282618795,
-0.0126761459,
-0.0158463325,
-0.0221546907,
0.0154124079,
0.0227394197,
0.0597928464,
-0.0065582069,
0.0395716988,
-0.0291969832,
-0.0030037202,
-0.0388132893,
-0.0022520113,
-0.058530245,
-0.0052642329,
-0.052742146,
0.0534645729,
-0.0308054443,
-0.1054583937,
0.0361552387,
-0.0095545603,
-0.0080005508,
0.001788938,
-0.0381899998,
0.0077111926,
-0.0260864124,
-0.014920298,
0.0167698469,
-0.0083732167,
-0.023840772,
-0.0535475984,
-0.0694641173,
-0.0009284438,
0.0143589489,
0.0025849002,
-0.0270031486,
0.005637465,
0.0309948977,
0.0332115777,
-0.0625405833,
0.0552144088,
-0.0499378182,
0.0581775084,
0.0747593716,
0.0200290345,
-0.0064538727,
0.0128314318,
0.0421599858,
-0.0379320122,
0.0425025858,
-0.0078439871,
0.044655811,
0.029395204,
-0.0470923632,
0.0176603533,
0.0185763929,
-0.0007284746,
-0.0490314662,
0.0027172863,
0.0262569673,
0.0530688986,
-0.0101603884,
0.026138531,
0.0631163269,
0.0831202641,
-0.0224893466,
0.0235858317,
0.0019059568,
0.014245525,
0.0067649703,
0.0224252827,
-0.0035465157,
-0.0159140788,
-0.0049696667,
0.017088376,
-0.0025800648,
-0.0016212842,
-0.015943598,
-0.0473088957,
0.0126541639,
0.0136458455,
0.040157564,
-0.0015287667,
0.0021830352,
0.0078980066,
0.0059462236,
-0.005935288,
-0.0135229826,
-0.05156767,
-0.0255858563,
-0.0488157719,
0.0135595175,
0.0958700329,
0.0320702717,
0.0274722651,
-0.024139123,
-0.0140874293,
-0.0155412443,
0.0279528461,
0.0332545117,
-0.0109604383,
0.0016016043,
0.0019808623,
0.0120191975,
0.0299960412,
-0.0238653235,
-0.0145737519,
-0.0549337678,
0.043679785,
0.0013439876,
0.0175806601,
0.0016081064,
-0.0210589226,
0.0440442935,
0.0035646346,
-0.0264999829,
0.0399719439,
-0.0204424765,
0.0566726886,
-0.0260437131,
-0.032981839,
0.0085369637,
0.030208258,
0.0045880848,
0.0832770169,
-0.0232739877,
0.0069662929,
0.0215280298,
-0.0061434186,
-0.0158167109,
0.0101988371,
0.0204206575,
-0.028695561,
0.0245992765,
-0.0499432124,
0.0170109011,
-0.0156597756,
0.0437612087,
0.0031503446,
-0.0128832059,
-0.0090160407,
-0.0498819724,
-0.030369278,
-0.0017808897,
0.0254026558,
0.0530843064,
0.020164527,
-0.0445005149,
-0.0410287604,
0.101472877,
-0.0311447196,
0.0389386714,
0.017785171,
-0.0077577601,
-0.0633539557,
-0.0065251244,
-0.1146435812,
-0.022455832,
-0.0027511672,
-0.0107889157,
0.0150385723,
0.0432538353,
-0.0360369422,
-0.0311164223,
-0.007993578,
-0.0440301038,
0.0324963965,
0.0299293213,
0.032648053,
0.0134795271,
-0.0290916022,
-0.0433398224,
0.0199249443,
0.000301215,
-0.0511580706,
-0.0143268602,
-0.0452198461,
-0.0721351206,
-0.0204758476,
-0.0189468227,
0.0111836772,
-0.0081785889,
-0.0800352469,
0.0458190665,
0.0632535145,
0.0476886518,
0.0398018397,
0.0118099339,
0.0490064658,
0.006345225,
-0.0392176583,
-0.0137943719,
0.0198720321,
0.0360002331,
-0.0649097934,
0.0012444449,
-0.0468588099,
0.0055244039,
-0.0049808626,
0.00471893,
0.0558463447,
-0.021542985,
0.0114315171,
-0.0066268961,
-0.05035742,
0.0037587236,
-0.0383957326,
-0.0683706254,
0.0844389871,
0.0228477865,
-0.0379158109,
0.0208814647,
-0.0169678461,
-0.0339359865,
-0.0189058818,
-0.0228416882,
0.0400181524,
0.0540430509,
-0.0698502064,
0.0112304576,
0.041347336,
-0.0846642181,
-0.0401989855,
-0.0060827769,
-0.01089729,
-0.0302728079,
0.0272377264,
-0.0750085637,
-0.0114635602,
0.0149955591,
-0.0250539407,
-0.0242460743,
-0.0015268427,
-0.0287452098,
-0.0206179749,
0.0432915166,
-0.0270758346,
0.0031214508,
-0.0105938921,
0.0117594469,
0.0259165261,
-0.0006230262,
-0.0114680883,
-0.0182316843,
-0.0244686641,
0.0330274515,
0.0947762281,
-0.0282245409,
0.0358708575,
0.0585889332,
0.0114916544,
0.0493047349,
-0.022835359,
0.0241383091,
-0.0124656614,
0.041142188,
0.0136713665,
-0.0577100143,
0.0303488597,
0.0552977957,
-0.0130652245,
0.0125584966,
0.0547320023,
0.0171323922,
-0.0088629797,
-0.0080260402,
-0.0758870021,
-0.0122405905,
-0.0020401813,
0.0333816744,
-0.0745352879,
0.0187237263,
0.0409955494,
0.0402649306,
-0.0174455475,
0.0208525639,
-0.0013255718,
-0.0919722989,
0.0257915854,
-0.0358638912,
-0.0267039631,
-0.0167133566,
0.0168205947,
0.0360037982,
0.0301593039,
0.0817953795,
0.0089094574,
-0.0031660078,
-0.0007978863,
-0.0002425094,
-0.020165246,
0.0015462909,
0.0101891654,
-0.0300179478,
0.0570920706,
0.0779697821,
0.035292875,
0.0441494249,
-0.025338972,
-0.0080347927,
0.0282810535,
0.049720116,
0.0018289943,
0.0196985584,
0.0207977463,
0.0083381776,
-0.0067243367,
0.024881158,
-0.0225202031,
0.0321333967,
0.0558176041,
-0.0188482217,
-0.0415089317,
0.0367188416,
-0.001770354,
0.004516819,
0.0319904871,
-0.0034374937,
0.0403358527,
-0.0554224811,
-0.0146712782,
0.000597253,
0.0010255614,
0.0140284747,
-0.0264332239,
-0.0030324054,
-0.010075246,
-0.0519284606,
-0.0429282263,
-0.1241283119,
-0.002587511,
0.0161383264,
0.0321056545,
-0.0036938216,
0.0405563638,
0.0301603284,
0.0157572739,
-0.0199280214,
0.0243029632,
0.0444797836,
-0.0220732111,
0.014622164,
-0.0165904239,
-0.0124252131,
0.0049606692,
-0.0438527428,
0.0494641028,
-0.0531982593,
0.0089352885,
0.0721786916,
0.0268015992,
0.0396447554,
-0.0146536762,
-0.1089848056,
-0.0985295847,
0.0161521845,
-0.0354154371,
0.0107544446,
0.0347706564,
0.0304665174,
-0.0133598335,
0.0442632996,
-0.0252557322,
-0.0524538495,
-0.0630949363,
0.0117285149,
-0.0610343292,
-0.1033311635,
0.0017476596,
0.0161163341,
0.0398883708,
0.0144669851,
0.0813508257,
-0.0045862626,
0.0136358915,
0.0119076436,
-0.0040085693,
-0.0304130297,
0.0248151887,
-0.0516673885,
-0.0252548791,
0.0140909646,
-0.0431036763,
-0.0805823281,
0.0206949245,
-0.001851944,
-0.0032496375,
-0.0060637607,
0.0413849987,
-0.0017411156,
0.0415103659,
0.0119726611,
0.0326737165,
0.0688053966,
0.0476326756,
0.0385869108,
0.0804632977,
-0.0183880385,
-0.0142923119,
0.0172441974,
0.0357818678,
-0.0025212376,
-0.1334644258,
0.042623017,
0.0008187733,
0.0373932607,
-0.0203749146,
0.0205143522,
0.0229635108,
0.0236940067,
-0.0019768039,
0.0328580774,
0.0261647739,
0.0065977965,
0.0200816896,
0.0033939898,
-0.0410832316,
0.0065233125,
0.0314979814,
-0.0742573962,
0.0206265487,
-0.0685907602,
0.002071064,
-0.0525429174,
-0.0357733369,
0.0208988022,
0.0366889089,
-0.0220399573,
-0.0350308716,
-0.0587799288,
-0.0530402698,
-0.0417087227,
-0.0292475335,
0.0208327956,
-0.0605394691,
0.0111976238,
0.0459445156,
0.0106246974,
0.0013002292,
-0.0338351019,
-0.0103630796,
-0.0551519282,
-0.0095273415,
-0.0272201728,
-5.208027721e-33,
-0.0010743869,
-0.0449818596,
0.001989329,
-0.0220955219,
-0.0233420189,
-0.0219393522,
-0.0228385404,
0.0623459555,
-0.00950698,
-0.002204478,
-0.0591908731,
-0.0049288566,
0.0008054521,
-0.0304811113,
0.0237406418,
0.0172168501,
0.0530930385,
0.0159635786,
-0.0319897868,
0.0161738209,
0.0564655215,
0.0070717521,
0.0112181613,
-0.0974363536,
0.0684340745,
0.0019644783,
-0.0074546048,
0.0301676691,
0.0407282636,
0.006139914,
0.0178938899,
0.046256125,
0.0146492422,
0.0242521167,
-0.0009017409,
0.0651873797,
0.0042696097,
-0.0485184081,
0.0583221316,
0.0485141836,
-0.0108269555,
-0.0025086524,
-0.0050879349,
0.0071148491,
-0.0454622582,
0.0598879717,
0.0282777492,
0.0061919522,
0.0234234519,
0.0326408818,
-0.0465512834,
-0.0125716217,
-0.0571698509,
-0.0788885057,
-0.0197918303,
0.0546159893,
-0.0136339134,
-0.0292912163,
-0.0608688593,
0.0140898293,
-0.0240972061,
-0.0243980791,
0.0378314704,
-0.0161025636,
0.0007440403,
0.0164786335,
0.0018435034,
0.0354806222,
-0.0098868255,
-0.037576437,
0.0106012505,
0.0482837707,
-0.0166491587,
0.0463568531,
-0.0222618282,
-0.0829170048,
0.0290821157,
0.0243279971,
0.040321406,
0.0466870107,
-0.0503779687,
0.045672372,
-0.0736146644,
-0.0043646563,
-0.0354741104,
-0.0019588086,
-0.0472003445,
-0.0580760837,
0.0226071309,
-0.0114630172,
0.0075242678,
-0.0445537716,
0.0144842202,
0.005144902,
0.0277969167,
-0.0532681271,
-0.0741379559,
-0.0025323771,
0.0103105456,
0.0025025136,
-0.0113314567,
0.0364979021,
0.0002812881,
0.041894421,
0.0230251607,
0.0106704207,
-0.0306053683,
0.0096011031,
-0.0308621991,
-0.0020821374,
0.0120838694,
0.0413799062,
-0.0160326697,
-0.0256430432,
0.0314107612,
0.0136780171,
-0.032505624,
0.0646417663,
0.0241473317,
-0.0169402026,
-0.0796429291,
-0.0206502005,
-0.0327114686,
-0.0213531237,
-0.0478302613,
-0.0281889662,
-0.0162730105,
0.0146363173,
0.0334937908,
-0.0293238722,
-0.0344944708,
-0.0551375337,
2.517e-7,
-0.0227495227,
0.0314848982,
0.0100309588,
0.0108966306,
0.0427404828,
0.0488273315,
0.0239610076,
0.0233540554,
0.0492676385,
0.0513621867,
0.0212396979,
-0.0685629621,
0.0544766337,
0.0013833785,
-0.0332591012,
-0.0334619097,
-0.0613044873,
-0.0034400288,
-0.0284748711,
0.0308951177,
0.0536680557,
0.0025949224,
-0.0320258737,
-0.0049453611,
-0.0303921327,
-0.0175328795,
-0.0229004212,
-0.0366945714,
-0.0020665049,
0.0051104408,
0.0106863622,
0.0333204716,
0.0215061065,
0.0107202148,
0.0064177797,
0.0233921781,
0.0131042004,
0.0290503018,
-0.0050796182,
-0.0238668006,
0.0142039303,
-0.0040755724,
0.0186128076,
-0.0637382045,
0.009447257,
-0.0088184001,
-0.0381846726,
0.0143376719,
0.0173720736,
-0.0307417009,
0.0197503939,
-0.056459289,
-0.0255094469,
0.0545339361,
-0.0149674648,
0.0069667883,
0.0156969111,
-0.0070331278,
0.02597294,
0.0127126547,
0.0001979134,
-0.0401199795,
0.0010585474,
-0.028356446,
0.006652358,
0.0051881499,
0.0298331957,
1.142115936e-34,
-0.004160678,
-0.0042720069,
0.0467956215,
0.0704248697,
0.0719434917,
0.0417660698,
0.0692772493,
0.0492942482,
0.0329258889,
0.0023279435,
-0.0354610197
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.