id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02499v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02499v1 | Can Chat GPT solve a Linguistics Exam? | 2023-11-04T20:02:57 | 2023-11-04T20:02:57 | Patricia Ronan, Gerold Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL, J.5; K.3 | The present study asks if ChatGPT4, the version of ChatGPT which uses the
language model GPT4, can successfully solve introductory linguistic exams.
Previous exam questions of an Introduction to Linguistics course at a German
university are used to test this. The exam questions were fed into ChatGPT4
with only minimal preprocessing. The results show that the language model is
very successful in the interpretation even of complex and nested tasks. It
proved surprisingly successful in the task of broad phonetic transcription, but
performed less well in the analysis of morphemes and phrases. In simple cases
it performs sufficiently well, but rarer cases, particularly with missing
one-to-one correspondence, are currently treated with mixed results. The model
is not yet able to deal with visualisations, such as the analysis or generation
of syntax trees. More extensive preprocessing, which translates these tasks
into text data, allow the model to also solve these tasks successfully. | [
0.0378345549,
-0.0021372018,
-0.0410967581,
0.0479458086,
-0.1119830012,
0.0056634238,
-0.0259623025,
0.0012412631,
0.009143468,
-0.0408026502,
0.0126226395,
-0.0428444818,
0.0366882235,
-0.0023667729,
0.0353249125,
-0.0621929169,
0.0574900433,
-0.0105963266,
-0.0046013305,
0.0023538256,
0.029225383,
0.0116449222,
-0.0300549958,
0.0390877351,
-0.0264787097,
-0.0329212621,
-0.0462441817,
-0.0107633648,
-0.0054397057,
0.0046076332,
-0.0206639599,
0.0513908155,
-0.0201183762,
0.0580283292,
0.0000017952,
-0.0658879057,
-0.02233213,
0.0005272352,
-0.0210049599,
-0.0012193685,
0.0473761857,
0.0387261696,
-0.0516247526,
0.0295137316,
-0.0385451391,
-0.0137579106,
0.0707877129,
0.0005967412,
0.0504509993,
0.0794415176,
-0.0224234611,
-0.0561832115,
0.0318315104,
0.0323161371,
-0.0039218864,
-0.0168206226,
0.0219095182,
0.0062726918,
0.0463943221,
-0.0115812644,
-0.0271782633,
0.0186806396,
-0.0149360849,
0.0049901488,
-0.0488698743,
0.0073797577,
-0.0689328387,
-0.0355834886,
0.0054815174,
0.0058477158,
-0.0316880569,
-0.0352706164,
0.0096440921,
0.014060271,
0.0116059147,
-0.0025902949,
-0.0560693592,
-0.0070690992,
-0.0353157371,
0.0200912263,
0.0638766214,
-0.0360820033,
-0.0373415239,
-0.0083362162,
-0.0075611798,
0.0464799888,
0.0454717018,
-0.0363385379,
0.0227634553,
0.0326484665,
-0.0234536622,
-0.0165582374,
0.0106058074,
0.0247142278,
-0.0182580445,
0.0420270525,
0.0178645942,
0.0055642878,
0.0255289115,
-0.0513442308,
-0.0194073599,
0.0524677783,
-0.0041166944,
0.0310096145,
0.0028529943,
0.0567478761,
0.0469842479,
-0.0163035821,
-0.0590165854,
-0.009373528,
-0.068215251,
-0.0155877937,
-0.098996006,
0.0301447269,
0.0151647711,
0.0237209573,
-0.0365711376,
0.0154810352,
0.019301679,
-0.0152481403,
0.0213111471,
-0.0542984605,
-0.0600044541,
0.0528955944,
-0.0271467455,
0.0098140417,
0.0015835098,
-0.0113689229,
-0.0534036495,
-0.0769338533,
0.0083342874,
0.0246953685,
-0.0008859948,
-0.0264071971,
-0.0141614191,
0.0467199348,
-0.0053896382,
-0.0176836271,
0.007124966,
-0.0130278701,
-0.0401444659,
-0.0680809692,
-0.0039377115,
-0.0742987916,
0.0095793167,
0.0092890607,
-0.0086448751,
-0.0015569157,
-0.0104908645,
0.0102250231,
-0.0084124869,
0.0516448244,
0.0179404244,
0.0225199033,
0.0085118273,
-0.009464982,
-0.0190720577,
0.0593667366,
0.0222863387,
-0.0302866269,
-0.0009811718,
-0.080610998,
-0.003499266,
0.0724705383,
-0.0091942269,
-0.0215487052,
-0.0035003352,
-0.0089660352,
0.0137287723,
0.0281029996,
-0.0132003073,
0.096580267,
0.0054734163,
-0.0233183112,
0.0039596185,
0.0751628205,
0.0604270995,
0.0448955595,
0.0105699077,
0.0171778463,
0.0287996791,
0.0785686523,
-0.0078962501,
-0.0462293997,
-0.0558903441,
0.0227338336,
-0.0520186052,
0.0441403314,
0.011778038,
-0.0010720976,
-0.0185145475,
0.0125078764,
0.012132464,
-0.0310287923,
0.0540507101,
-0.0116706798,
-0.0314921886,
0.016170444,
0.0200202484,
-0.0346359573,
0.0041776686,
-0.0571664013,
-0.0095161721,
0.0233947374,
0.0625699013,
-0.0148528889,
-0.0668996423,
0.0094569977,
-0.0331449136,
0.065887399,
0.0492496155,
-0.0111025367,
-0.0162629094,
-0.0364364721,
0.0059980466,
0.0316055715,
0.0058521526,
0.0210912582,
-0.0242235828,
0.01670097,
0.0044131214,
-0.0111056976,
0.0004300308,
-0.0010958057,
-0.014048974,
-0.0053094006,
-0.043673981,
0.0024240008,
0.0520610176,
0.042072624,
-0.0091237845,
0.0418723039,
0.0069872788,
-0.0191968642,
0.0201618727,
0.0178581215,
-0.0364497975,
-0.0661198497,
0.0626338869,
-0.0695453137,
-0.0329616889,
0.0002955687,
0.0012509909,
-0.062543042,
0.0237650014,
-0.0742857009,
0.082943514,
-0.0530250669,
0.0416186824,
-0.012501209,
-0.011046458,
-0.0237547699,
0.0500962175,
0.0728851184,
0.0464713834,
-0.0265199598,
-0.0094525702,
0.0518996753,
-0.0576260798,
-0.0286109094,
0.0182661228,
-0.0097838929,
-0.000654874,
0.0033527168,
0.016254086,
-0.0560960695,
-0.0370145738,
-0.1099772081,
0.0108065689,
-0.0015761512,
0.0631442964,
0.0301488433,
0.0233477969,
-0.0247488618,
-0.0113704568,
-0.0525767244,
0.0071237925,
0.0302017704,
0.0043147188,
0.0046313079,
-0.0100550447,
-0.0346314572,
-0.0380024984,
0.0061628954,
-0.0526858456,
-0.0097620646,
0.0458835661,
-0.0430039093,
0.0022633125,
0.0452557728,
-0.0222164616,
0.0313901491,
0.0394915566,
-0.043497514,
0.0258664675,
-0.031384822,
0.0779514015,
-0.0097767757,
-0.015106434,
-0.0064782081,
-0.0092433309,
-0.0768531263,
-0.0381531827,
-0.0132910088,
-0.0207821839,
-0.0237611383,
-0.0256986339,
-0.0434499271,
-0.0489192978,
0.0759560019,
0.0380987003,
-0.0202960391,
-0.0408250801,
0.0408501849,
-0.0669151172,
0.0525980145,
-0.0416319594,
-0.0030066043,
-0.0347961895,
0.0250489023,
0.004067434,
-0.0074405181,
0.0859184712,
-0.0685767606,
-0.0274373777,
-0.1197417751,
-0.0148144308,
-0.0251846611,
0.0848374516,
0.0074078515,
0.0022107689,
0.0406927355,
-0.0616748407,
-0.0590917505,
0.018076716,
0.0418239571,
-0.034552671,
-0.004408143,
-0.0610867813,
0.0219559819,
-0.0198249891,
-0.0100798467,
-0.0116584208,
-0.0200711004,
0.0174293965,
0.0472614132,
0.0211783126,
0.0324836038,
0.0171367191,
0.0731151029,
-0.0375897326,
0.0022805547,
-0.0147327166,
0.0155510399,
-0.0237756819,
0.0604821071,
0.0240667723,
0.0001829683,
-0.0445911661,
0.0146084754,
0.0206683334,
0.0101055484,
0.0013219328,
0.0324240066,
-0.0055871708,
-0.0016277157,
0.0005753518,
-0.0359919667,
-0.0612524338,
-0.0208185129,
-0.003822261,
-0.0335778482,
-0.0038241812,
0.1190109625,
0.0458739959,
-0.001664841,
-0.0002451975,
-0.0144326771,
0.0158648938,
-0.0034574976,
0.0408852883,
-0.0794694722,
0.0190301258,
0.0217391998,
-0.0083857737,
-0.0287637115,
-0.0025028226,
-0.0048698364,
-0.1101218238,
0.0464289263,
0.0156780891,
-0.0739678144,
0.0122956997,
-0.0135563677,
0.0046737902,
-0.0194595307,
0.0008623796,
0.0294888895,
-0.0013171855,
0.0284406971,
0.0271776058,
-0.0493233874,
-0.0195661131,
0.0390690677,
-0.0197800621,
0.04745977,
0.028096538,
0.0394680649,
-0.0431611612,
-0.015303907,
0.0506781936,
-0.0167751964,
-0.0111981025,
-0.0260384586,
0.0071157226,
0.0518260822,
-0.0212177224,
-0.0470807031,
-0.0050420011,
-0.0147403292,
0.0183080621,
0.0278927386,
0.1129461527,
-0.0280346964,
-0.0093199322,
0.0096691204,
0.0368929766,
-0.0043386021,
0.0597177148,
0.0443765409,
-0.0089100022,
-0.039674826,
-0.0430591404,
0.0145814838,
-0.0036353185,
-0.041530624,
0.0202198736,
-0.0065820622,
-0.0453241579,
-0.0582463518,
-0.0576716438,
0.0423943996,
0.0318626463,
0.0195958707,
0.0005138095,
0.0007770959,
0.00526156,
-0.0141810039,
0.0264845639,
0.0154643618,
0.0194487832,
-0.0768915117,
-0.0357560068,
0.0645915121,
0.0056331339,
-0.0392346606,
0.0132688945,
-0.0207709502,
-0.0628995299,
0.0306996759,
-0.0028012637,
0.0299787764,
0.0129165528,
-0.0503180064,
0.0160531253,
-0.0292388946,
-0.0047276113,
-0.0366596915,
0.0177619625,
0.0058459216,
-0.0203599669,
0.0133747077,
-0.0103190457,
0.0296792239,
0.0423004553,
-0.0218956228,
0.0297451653,
0.0002329769,
-0.0427500233,
0.0494611338,
0.0622642078,
0.0552171357,
0.0259850193,
0.0137468949,
-0.0106814643,
0.00357899,
-0.0143409939,
-0.0012254295,
-0.0163657833,
-0.0455393344,
0.029785471,
-0.0061854082,
-0.0163492765,
-0.067448616,
-0.1001895294,
0.0137751354,
0.0102650244,
0.0234804992,
0.0542574301,
-0.0077412231,
0.0116958069,
-0.0067978818,
-0.0025463616,
0.0071200207,
-0.0105504915,
0.0301596895,
-0.0347076841,
0.0353923328,
-0.0222550537,
0.0076838345,
0.0311223697,
-0.0049454779,
0.0074427412,
-0.0137585402,
-0.013572854,
0.0307932049,
0.0558323227,
0.0062931869,
0.0326547101,
-0.0327808894,
0.0210655406,
-0.0173185654,
0.0204808563,
-0.0138662606,
-0.0028644181,
0.0316452198,
0.0123462752,
-0.004167018,
-0.0451164842,
0.0546805672,
0.0147694843,
0.0236527789,
0.0238700509,
-0.0264167208,
-0.0110170394,
-0.0568766259,
0.0196449477,
-0.0076447395,
-0.011443886,
0.0153872278,
-0.0552929863,
-0.0799913108,
-0.0374159366,
0.0384768881,
0.0305699334,
0.0054276376,
0.0490578748,
0.0398875624,
-0.0149175692,
-0.0244963896,
-0.015777396,
0.0368237048,
0.0134978564,
-0.0395267569,
0.0144006573,
-5.910360617e-33,
-0.0682949722,
-0.0244506039,
0.0285255332,
0.0451938473,
-0.0029727609,
-0.0377967507,
-0.0281461067,
0.0167322587,
-0.0118146623,
-0.0182344764,
-0.011987932,
0.0105822496,
0.0266443919,
-0.0020415981,
0.0221162736,
0.0129317231,
0.0174337942,
-0.0085525624,
0.0252589285,
0.0046043471,
0.0173280779,
0.0198499393,
0.088561438,
-0.0144911772,
0.0238692034,
-0.0019509032,
0.0060217897,
0.0030155517,
-0.0345131308,
0.0439080521,
-0.0142736994,
0.0391344614,
0.0327244997,
-0.0048766993,
-0.0103481747,
0.0215809979,
-0.0456078276,
-0.0696922168,
0.0724987313,
0.0440383963,
0.0069736708,
-0.0126732783,
0.0240840707,
-0.0531861372,
-0.0118507817,
0.0028156654,
0.0281174388,
-0.0098482287,
-0.0025745756,
0.0340952612,
-0.0627651736,
0.0337285623,
-0.0269798264,
-0.0036213452,
0.0419792309,
0.0185108017,
-0.0148606952,
-0.0502416082,
0.0111476639,
0.0344824828,
0.0397323929,
0.0403990932,
0.0335477665,
-0.0375647843,
-0.020886844,
-0.0021697925,
0.0159867443,
-0.0477243289,
0.0314417519,
0.009929833,
0.0504219346,
0.0007335914,
0.0356016494,
-0.0106029166,
0.0155517245,
0.0068899454,
-0.0305870678,
0.0052196123,
0.0707076713,
0.0250683427,
-0.0385459475,
0.0052977926,
-0.0290814694,
-0.0529364683,
-0.0067746714,
-0.0053514717,
-0.0381732732,
-0.0588841625,
0.0377628617,
-0.0891984031,
0.0192719065,
-0.0065629184,
0.0400613099,
-0.0405439623,
0.0060828584,
-0.0525810644,
0.0044561131,
0.0440564603,
-0.0495932959,
0.0767904967,
-0.0127303069,
-0.0411917232,
0.0278680772,
0.0167805888,
0.027720103,
0.020047944,
-0.0073815868,
0.0188219808,
-0.0412108414,
0.0001002475,
-0.0422213152,
0.0031451185,
-0.0328363404,
0.0193474796,
0.0163813438,
0.0144834723,
0.0263810027,
0.0008621144,
0.0503650047,
-0.0132155428,
-0.0561040901,
0.0001765436,
-0.021349011,
-0.0091252606,
-0.02812442,
0.0040727332,
0.0113680223,
0.0168111268,
0.0302840807,
0.0160692446,
-0.000694814,
0.0064411904,
2.721e-7,
0.0734773725,
0.0559408292,
0.0203105751,
0.0148147829,
0.0327876471,
-0.0366255902,
-0.0511129797,
0.0184433535,
0.0250869561,
0.0436842702,
0.0353105217,
-0.0239122678,
0.0385090411,
0.0521633215,
-0.1027828008,
0.0154638411,
-0.0445668139,
-0.0298771076,
-0.0794870555,
0.0740199909,
0.0741185099,
0.0879945382,
-0.003826587,
-0.0047887978,
-0.0453923456,
-0.0269628428,
0.0222103503,
-0.014884267,
-0.0492952988,
0.0228601843,
0.0392096452,
0.0138315838,
0.0322194099,
0.0621969961,
0.0074477075,
0.0149765806,
0.036590647,
0.0378350765,
-0.0358049795,
0.0146310655,
0.0386268608,
-0.0231685303,
-0.0156022748,
-0.076717779,
0.0593015105,
-0.03739959,
-0.0190351717,
-0.0141665349,
-0.0361963399,
-0.0149176307,
-0.014656947,
-0.0130857481,
-0.0214135293,
0.0138926189,
0.0271334164,
-0.0337236747,
-0.0147081809,
0.000375209,
0.0087349769,
0.0451344624,
-0.0174352676,
-0.0676642135,
0.0123306168,
0.0041722548,
0.0143928165,
-0.0319169313,
-0.0059984108,
2.426117714e-34,
0.0348798335,
-0.0076959799,
0.0482369103,
0.0056984611,
0.02695903,
0.0116085177,
0.0511926264,
0.0516936965,
-0.0195337012,
-0.0645984188,
-0.0441278815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02408v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02408v3 | Citance-Contextualized Summarization of Scientific Papers | 2023-11-04T14:08:15 | 2023-11-13T08:40:04 | Shahbaz Syed, Ahmad Dawar Hakimi, Khalid Al-Khatib, Martin Potthast | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current approaches to automatic summarization of scientific papers generate
informative summaries in the form of abstracts. However, abstracts are not
intended to show the relationship between a paper and the references cited in
it. We propose a new contextualized summarization approach that can generate an
informative summary conditioned on a given sentence containing the citation of
a reference (a so-called "citance"). This summary outlines the content of the
cited paper relevant to the citation location. Thus, our approach extracts and
models the citances of a paper, retrieves relevant passages from cited papers,
and generates abstractive summaries tailored to each citance. We evaluate our
approach using $\textbf{Webis-Context-SciSumm-2023}$, a new dataset containing
540K~computer science papers and 4.6M~citances therein. | [
0.0149396583,
0.0026646033,
0.0072453264,
-0.0120412037,
-0.0031115813,
-0.0001538956,
0.0168633498,
-0.0341950022,
0.0032417306,
-0.0495878346,
-0.0033032615,
0.0225243419,
0.0008141407,
0.0122082727,
-0.0177300051,
-0.0666379184,
0.0240647029,
0.0155471191,
0.0362893231,
0.0103798527,
0.0145855583,
-0.0166054592,
-0.0055966466,
0.0096299266,
0.0690374076,
-0.0378010385,
0.0228205193,
-0.0343256705,
0.0692267194,
-0.0432663634,
0.0423414931,
-0.0056700837,
0.0143085802,
-0.0040325033,
0.0000016156,
-0.0715742186,
-0.032445956,
0.0258499235,
0.0299191456,
0.0549513996,
0.0699462667,
-0.028430244,
0.0133205215,
0.0082141887,
-0.0053465134,
0.0242239106,
0.008071362,
0.0241607372,
0.0268109739,
0.0158668626,
-0.0077920561,
-0.0484480597,
0.0336678736,
0.0273199901,
-0.0085232556,
-0.0271606594,
0.0164741557,
0.0327747427,
0.0259157009,
0.03459711,
0.0527254418,
0.0337384306,
-0.0073764711,
-0.0343648307,
0.0345288329,
0.0256648175,
-0.0571676753,
0.0202995706,
0.0142497653,
0.0434373207,
0.0173387751,
-0.0234273281,
0.0692360029,
0.0070138611,
-0.0214065798,
0.0266498998,
-0.0748656094,
0.0534524918,
-0.0055793393,
-0.0294008665,
0.0466023237,
0.0586742088,
-0.0030322657,
0.0204738248,
0.0085693728,
0.0382428765,
-0.0041570943,
-0.0223363154,
-0.0413206704,
-0.0368585475,
0.0151472175,
-0.0177748483,
-0.0040260796,
0.0513818674,
0.0039998917,
-0.031593807,
0.026117051,
-0.0391480476,
0.0600721687,
-0.0211740788,
-0.0277344976,
-0.0302625056,
0.036405798,
0.0411211923,
0.0018685275,
-0.0391971059,
-0.0112175625,
-0.0562751591,
-0.0246085916,
-0.0324014202,
-0.0269562081,
0.0001023752,
-0.0007858503,
0.0451885648,
-0.0142988777,
-0.0144016817,
-0.0443842746,
0.0326353014,
-0.022495361,
0.0054762224,
-0.0302737691,
0.0125588747,
-0.0376808755,
0.0164324827,
0.0142990341,
0.0168456864,
-0.0054983296,
-0.0037287325,
-0.0047112806,
0.0212293305,
-0.0091152964,
0.0323263668,
0.0333501361,
0.0054841116,
-0.0131371953,
0.0101659,
0.0141127901,
-0.0310088992,
0.0119587043,
-0.0601583645,
0.0200734157,
-0.0053001656,
0.0143859284,
-0.0582852215,
0.0057250462,
0.0261307135,
-0.007852518,
-0.0291304104,
-0.0168939922,
0.0228113439,
-0.0284055099,
0.0147426687,
-0.0661760643,
-0.0320618972,
0.0458244309,
0.0207900126,
0.0319687612,
0.0030056944,
0.032569848,
0.006266919,
0.028304901,
0.0045409212,
0.0244208351,
-0.0211148653,
0.0339140408,
0.0213883575,
0.058481738,
-0.0050101699,
-0.0195207074,
-0.0055393954,
0.0016939633,
0.0026710178,
-0.0138376188,
0.0434854627,
-0.0087007219,
0.0468281992,
-0.0057517253,
0.0297532193,
0.011723537,
0.0377630815,
0.0411564298,
0.0062662512,
0.0084370142,
0.0310517233,
-0.0232980009,
0.0797287598,
0.0637508035,
0.018564688,
-0.0069371243,
-0.019880712,
0.0279881116,
0.0285669044,
-0.0264808442,
-0.0255934112,
0.0268185902,
-0.002994494,
0.0025894837,
0.0240265206,
0.0337374508,
-0.0390816703,
0.0109033631,
0.0337406136,
0.0424424633,
-0.0449338965,
0.0430981666,
-0.0766507685,
-0.0170020051,
-0.014264253,
0.0072366972,
0.0416698717,
0.0154360803,
-0.0213282183,
-0.0191732813,
-0.0213485975,
-0.0343852751,
-0.0165428631,
0.0060911826,
-0.0299595315,
-0.007847175,
-0.0377825536,
0.0330647528,
0.0000283869,
-0.0502038002,
0.0069031091,
-0.0221149474,
-0.0054662419,
-0.0099030063,
-0.0619063601,
0.0322314352,
0.0251585189,
-0.0115942424,
0.0378047489,
0.0653587356,
-0.0096707018,
0.0019308762,
0.0454563424,
-0.0047491807,
0.0189020019,
0.0323398747,
-0.0803539455,
0.036746908,
-0.0140665192,
-0.0129955262,
-0.040189568,
0.0595252924,
-0.0151944431,
-0.0110068377,
0.0209326874,
-0.0191119425,
-0.0005936126,
0.00910962,
-0.0099600554,
0.0609960929,
0.0217769574,
0.045037888,
0.083970286,
-0.0364873111,
-0.0009237372,
-0.0178507194,
-0.005919009,
-0.0567704737,
0.0145336278,
-0.021067109,
0.0836194828,
-0.0137213869,
-0.0234000515,
0.0136671802,
-0.0381187759,
0.0225949772,
0.0356844552,
0.003228473,
0.0490185767,
0.0130503494,
0.0092349621,
0.0068680267,
-0.002506692,
-0.0224297997,
-0.0075430027,
-0.0412557125,
0.0750436559,
0.0247543976,
0.0015577254,
-0.0578764118,
-0.0046928031,
-0.0578932725,
0.0183454454,
0.0411667302,
0.0038385384,
-0.0442756712,
0.0654966459,
0.0288095102,
-0.0016760384,
-0.0236113165,
0.0447743386,
-0.0072368211,
-0.0161895435,
0.0106198527,
0.0668262169,
0.0333297811,
0.0222824775,
0.0559031628,
0.0100014545,
-0.0464921854,
-0.0168377347,
-0.0431276299,
0.0247920733,
0.0183644481,
-0.0270496011,
0.0766924396,
0.0319475755,
-0.0114188585,
0.0057697091,
0.0197025966,
0.0144138401,
0.0006971984,
0.0290812422,
-0.0279129948,
-0.0053874087,
0.011573812,
0.0397736393,
0.0380848944,
-0.0029661932,
0.0200384948,
-0.0328787714,
0.0188614707,
-0.0655553043,
-0.0045592072,
-0.0723850131,
0.0075824047,
-0.0009024619,
0.0140588535,
0.0422231294,
0.0106627932,
-0.0186183415,
-0.0168857593,
0.0133429244,
-0.0055089574,
-0.0172692593,
-0.0456785671,
0.0024017778,
-0.0309377443,
0.0095151449,
-0.00113301,
0.0077857659,
-0.0049345861,
0.0573818758,
0.0382465757,
-0.0341858231,
-0.0644441694,
-0.0022335188,
0.0696205646,
0.0389410481,
-0.025706809,
-0.0359552093,
-0.034461949,
0.0575759076,
0.0970052928,
-0.0130457832,
0.0315409154,
0.0287607219,
0.0195647012,
0.0732394308,
0.0104092006,
0.0360410176,
-0.0168786775,
-0.0576276928,
-0.0235575214,
-0.1093746275,
0.0038765357,
-0.0182867534,
0.015803827,
-0.0104747601,
-0.0370615534,
0.0897234082,
0.0501606725,
-0.0791568235,
-0.0419849418,
-0.0159343705,
0.0033497431,
0.0205775406,
-0.0008658945,
-0.0700772107,
0.0194936395,
-0.0126643404,
0.0127278715,
0.0121052945,
-0.016368242,
-0.0018258481,
-0.0434960686,
0.0194247961,
0.0104258414,
-0.0416850485,
-0.0351509079,
-0.0414372496,
0.0070679053,
-0.0198376942,
-0.0326263197,
0.0467035696,
-0.0462130792,
0.0005431498,
0.0246765818,
-0.0589947328,
-0.0198281128,
-0.0151132299,
-0.031136414,
0.0042736055,
-0.0104492931,
0.0448822193,
-0.0194994602,
0.0190908685,
0.0234873053,
-0.1027373821,
-0.0352265388,
-0.0012239699,
0.0323619954,
0.000357142,
0.0200579036,
-0.03103601,
0.0732340887,
0.0049946448,
-0.0301827025,
0.0909998193,
0.0315652415,
-0.0030817492,
0.0044255187,
-0.1215910092,
0.0271979757,
-0.0617676862,
0.060075473,
0.0263120029,
0.0067224014,
-0.0126447696,
-0.0201903228,
-0.007395409,
-0.0383161083,
-0.0410868227,
-0.0593324751,
-0.0465871692,
0.0137391947,
-0.0590372346,
-0.0355116427,
-0.007571327,
-0.0339095592,
0.0166544244,
-0.0003850574,
0.0390076712,
-0.0022499782,
-0.0820138156,
0.0215441454,
-0.0298719481,
-0.002348175,
0.0146543989,
0.0053441329,
0.0922931358,
-0.0243471693,
-0.0439684168,
0.0175876096,
0.0343919583,
-0.0271598715,
-0.0166267268,
0.0121589117,
0.0208393969,
0.0386189707,
-0.017264545,
-0.0061616101,
0.0454879068,
0.0392284021,
0.0241624638,
-0.0158989318,
0.0092355348,
-0.0013481416,
-0.021852158,
-0.0446932167,
-0.0589240603,
0.05963137,
-0.0664285421,
-0.003035268,
-0.0768089741,
-0.0242266841,
0.023289755,
0.0175232422,
0.009666523,
-0.029912563,
-0.0053726113,
0.0194184314,
-0.0222579967,
-0.0094744209,
-0.016280748,
0.014399237,
0.0608446933,
-0.0425617993,
0.002316657,
0.0300921835,
0.0492404066,
-0.0340423398,
-0.014150667,
-0.0134895174,
0.0084071066,
-0.0113749402,
0.0221582782,
-0.0330048837,
-0.0170674697,
-0.0247657876,
-0.0618229881,
-0.0674718916,
0.0226070117,
-0.0041426094,
-0.0007996822,
0.033825092,
-0.0073641618,
-0.0212726314,
0.0272415131,
-0.1443713903,
0.044286821,
-0.031641487,
-0.0118695954,
0.0203492995,
-0.0186714213,
0.0509437732,
-0.0276213083,
-0.023129819,
-0.0105098393,
0.0686652586,
0.0260747559,
0.0216730572,
0.0035349529,
0.0184490923,
-0.0054742591,
-0.0174474716,
0.0784680694,
-0.0103772599,
-0.0159040596,
0.0105625223,
-0.0268912166,
-0.0193764698,
-0.0201006997,
-0.0631556809,
0.0726603493,
0.0006734566,
-0.0683509931,
-0.0319674015,
-0.0051576635,
0.0522768833,
0.0328505039,
0.0229856241,
-0.0265956149,
0.0151020875,
-0.0013151773,
-0.0032768215,
-0.0501503795,
-0.0399426222,
0.07155554,
-0.0370264426,
-0.0399347134,
-0.0355830789,
-5.335344045e-33,
-0.0189947933,
-0.0203325525,
-0.0293285381,
0.0815287232,
-0.0175663531,
0.0188025981,
-0.0918050185,
-0.0460696816,
-0.0149664525,
0.0051373378,
-0.0197256282,
0.0136788879,
-0.0099716047,
0.0218034256,
0.040541511,
0.0558059961,
-0.0088754157,
0.0242853388,
-0.0252601784,
0.0679696724,
0.0229386464,
-0.0255291816,
0.0291598123,
-0.1134311631,
0.0573268086,
-0.027372187,
-0.0109920613,
-0.0304007102,
0.0540347509,
0.0370409302,
-0.029406216,
0.004763525,
0.0120428056,
-0.0285061859,
0.0029511265,
0.0023306364,
-0.0839464888,
0.0023574135,
0.020356914,
-0.0597778782,
-0.0170085318,
-0.0653755143,
0.02451884,
-0.0248852484,
-0.014892282,
-0.042608045,
0.0956412703,
-0.0403479189,
-0.0522730425,
-0.1327833086,
-0.029545363,
0.0179650038,
-0.0618943684,
0.0411167666,
0.0045570051,
0.0511699691,
0.0027902741,
0.0921176076,
-0.0163552351,
0.0554328263,
0.0166803654,
0.0398302488,
0.0049447585,
-0.0383192971,
0.0535774305,
0.0166016594,
-0.0000643342,
-0.0407315828,
0.0243296716,
-0.0138203325,
-0.0125890048,
-0.0185635854,
0.0244298633,
0.0362961963,
0.0290486701,
0.0295331869,
-0.0510431975,
0.0963691399,
0.0060809795,
0.022591589,
0.0342754386,
-0.0101309139,
0.0252518356,
0.0042950171,
0.0261788536,
-0.0303374641,
0.0074232728,
0.0065776561,
-0.0377178602,
-0.0236893762,
-0.0589280985,
0.0258112196,
0.0010074583,
-0.0614496879,
-0.0192430206,
0.0439882725,
0.0131732943,
0.0473821945,
0.0070278062,
-0.0512086637,
-0.0319831111,
-0.0458861217,
-0.014323269,
0.025878692,
0.0180397332,
-0.0033064489,
0.0464378707,
-0.0114241485,
-0.0118924044,
-0.0262606479,
0.0044987211,
-0.0225101113,
-0.0455942452,
-0.0136128347,
-0.0589832328,
0.0574210845,
0.0189087205,
-0.0041916757,
0.0410250351,
0.0489302799,
-0.0011593254,
0.0083491933,
0.005434067,
0.0611771271,
0.0153638469,
-0.008478323,
0.0096965572,
0.0584403649,
0.0211675763,
-0.0192501619,
-0.0084817624,
-0.032575056,
2.33e-7,
0.0581784099,
0.0231237374,
0.0290176682,
0.0069307424,
0.026041057,
0.0202813093,
0.0036265398,
0.0200304221,
0.0265432913,
0.0493826494,
0.0165891722,
-0.0191878509,
-0.0238282233,
0.0044754348,
-0.0980946943,
-0.0559938625,
-0.0562260561,
-0.0849278197,
-0.0257496908,
0.035385862,
0.000730455,
0.0162836704,
-0.0407198444,
0.0159355104,
-0.0133108236,
-0.0234990027,
-0.0066174222,
-0.0439971425,
0.0015048269,
0.0449169427,
-0.0092731267,
-0.0027552266,
-0.0090680821,
-0.0388908051,
-0.0061021354,
0.01026286,
0.0039895969,
0.0246017165,
0.0324570946,
0.0198892206,
0.0363540314,
-0.0503019802,
0.0665723756,
0.002671954,
0.0046025519,
-0.0531033948,
-0.002009429,
-0.067801781,
-0.0720552728,
0.0259134676,
-0.0402118973,
0.0066770748,
-0.0254073199,
0.0272488631,
-0.0578855611,
-0.0267437343,
0.0044294856,
-0.0618164279,
-0.0491825789,
0.0705672801,
0.0177993309,
-0.0122829098,
0.0177269373,
-0.0481318496,
0.0179981235,
-0.0477982126,
0.0344706178,
2.104259095e-34,
0.1030014902,
-0.0176531747,
-0.0407717414,
0.0372951142,
0.0167767126,
-0.0208955575,
-0.0270623453,
0.018817002,
0.0278211031,
-0.0448095016,
-0.0057845283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02355v1 | TreeSwap: Data Augmentation for Machine Translation via Dependency Subtree Swapping | 2023-11-04T09:27:40 | 2023-11-04T09:27:40 | Attila Nagy, Dorina Lakatos, Botond Barta, Judit Ács | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data augmentation methods for neural machine translation are particularly
useful when limited amount of training data is available, which is often the
case when dealing with low-resource languages. We introduce a novel
augmentation method, which generates new sentences by swapping objects and
subjects across bisentences. This is performed simultaneously based on the
dependency parse trees of the source and target sentences. We name this method
TreeSwap. Our results show that TreeSwap achieves consistent improvements over
baseline models in 4 language pairs in both directions on resource-constrained
datasets. We also explore domain-specific corpora, but find that our method
does not make significant improvements on law, medical and IT data. We report
the scores of similar augmentation methods and find that TreeSwap performs
comparably. We also analyze the generated sentences qualitatively and find that
the augmentation produces a correct translation in most cases. Our code is
available on Github. | [
0.0446219444,
0.1093154326,
-0.0033097432,
0.0702009276,
-0.0467783697,
-0.0032531919,
-0.0152035616,
-0.0072353315,
-0.0376247801,
-0.0484069772,
-0.0055870372,
-0.0188442767,
0.0075520491,
0.0116484482,
0.0207743589,
-0.0953538343,
0.0317598358,
0.0197735019,
-0.0263146684,
0.0062357984,
-0.0078352727,
0.0196650606,
-0.0018277182,
0.014988929,
-0.0478340015,
-0.0222606901,
-0.008961482,
0.0590075366,
0.0477921292,
-0.025773799,
0.0151284467,
0.0393166542,
0.0146255931,
0.0563719533,
0.0000020341,
-0.0070141684,
-0.0240605567,
0.0214222893,
-0.0178480186,
-0.0087282164,
0.0515059493,
-0.0818743035,
-0.0096499128,
0.0103259115,
-0.0447516069,
-0.0435835384,
0.0369020887,
0.0131230485,
0.0811661333,
0.1407124847,
-0.0302713253,
-0.0427738726,
0.0366373397,
-0.061612092,
0.007199428,
-0.0341716334,
-0.0250306763,
-0.0115594743,
-0.0215242617,
0.042264685,
-0.007952637,
0.0143982563,
0.0512699075,
0.0000357483,
0.0302332789,
0.0102143753,
-0.0296877287,
-0.0317017213,
-0.0116366791,
0.0958447084,
-0.0137129286,
-0.0055094254,
-0.0267047305,
-0.0287543908,
0.0251482315,
-0.0366908722,
-0.0317537412,
0.0247662719,
0.0316932872,
0.0196537897,
0.0248193834,
0.0291967634,
0.0300326236,
0.0023276829,
-0.0274939816,
0.0383570977,
0.0292461291,
-0.045517873,
-0.0029982701,
0.0246059503,
0.0121574104,
-0.0221603084,
0.0082903178,
-0.0133992452,
-0.0220640507,
0.036481712,
-0.0614633448,
-0.0446671993,
0.00937053,
-0.0429363623,
0.0134493858,
0.0297222491,
-0.0393451713,
0.0345878787,
-0.0283238012,
0.0192479789,
-0.0180610996,
0.0023869998,
-0.0708840117,
-0.0161065329,
-0.0381449834,
0.0142843835,
-0.0404727161,
-0.0112539539,
-0.107812956,
-0.0069011315,
-0.0315038078,
0.0037466111,
-0.0128869843,
-0.0244154446,
0.0220583994,
-0.0020474049,
-0.0778683797,
0.0003188475,
0.0229383577,
0.0513053574,
-0.0177630633,
-0.0002607766,
0.0174030736,
-0.0396098904,
-0.0293071754,
0.034512829,
0.0130512901,
-0.0395476148,
0.0029176599,
0.0828257576,
-0.0162944719,
-0.0362699106,
-0.0212582722,
0.0041585099,
-0.0181946922,
-0.0276583061,
0.0103456117,
-0.0701326579,
0.04472626,
-0.0340362191,
0.0149452901,
-0.0361459926,
0.013956083,
0.0294153709,
-0.0315267481,
0.0587561764,
-0.0476357378,
-0.0031204438,
-0.0385703705,
-0.0231006946,
0.0010557326,
0.0644125491,
0.0587551035,
0.0119284699,
0.0010327435,
0.0045892564,
-0.0083306413,
0.0314113125,
0.0104904715,
0.019644307,
-0.0096861618,
-0.0028596199,
-0.0400770269,
0.0567214452,
0.046921391,
0.028650634,
-0.0378159322,
0.0107084913,
0.0301084891,
0.0267121512,
-0.0192289129,
0.0347090438,
0.0378881097,
-0.0202457421,
-0.0225348789,
-0.001731732,
-0.0426254682,
0.0181711484,
0.0094246818,
-0.0094932783,
-0.0594905727,
0.0462449752,
0.002662549,
-0.0321418755,
0.0130876023,
-0.0313564986,
0.0268305428,
-0.05174594,
0.0092944466,
0.066076681,
-0.0087075625,
0.034857519,
0.0082042972,
-0.0623211935,
-0.0292393547,
-0.0191438068,
-0.0864624828,
0.0696539432,
0.0236074515,
-0.0061605396,
-0.0591969974,
-0.009322755,
0.0051758783,
0.0725403354,
0.0269434042,
0.0221802369,
0.0357819572,
-0.0310834609,
-0.0103761172,
-0.0221982207,
0.0128498962,
0.0304379445,
0.0327696465,
-0.0086907549,
0.0684403032,
-0.0236486848,
-0.0588982292,
0.036391262,
-0.0538071617,
0.0204451755,
0.0724498257,
0.01077592,
0.0352418274,
0.0308973473,
-0.0011636912,
-0.0018494719,
0.0310942046,
-0.0418765545,
-0.0407404192,
0.0658079088,
-0.0326091982,
-0.0781305134,
0.0263293311,
-0.0634082854,
-0.044154983,
0.0407658443,
-0.0684796125,
-0.0530496798,
0.002848404,
-0.0537124611,
0.0198049899,
-0.0329393484,
0.0323250405,
0.0113090239,
0.0082874978,
-0.0398914777,
0.063007012,
-0.0067991465,
-0.0278960373,
-0.0178761631,
-0.0151323527,
0.0270126071,
-0.0109605109,
0.0107198562,
-0.0119938422,
0.0113594634,
0.0255392864,
0.0173904225,
0.046979703,
-0.0412698984,
-0.019559646,
-0.0644306093,
0.0248867292,
-0.0080474941,
0.0333011374,
0.0515081659,
0.068523109,
-0.0013789183,
-0.0457814373,
-0.0329076573,
0.0086811874,
-0.016786417,
0.0076670349,
0.009121784,
-0.0147009389,
0.0250216406,
-0.0062337997,
0.0040290034,
-0.0168485846,
0.0187740773,
-0.0140182488,
-0.0545448288,
-0.0418713428,
0.0252863429,
0.0123794051,
0.0252241734,
0.0203013718,
-0.0338509865,
0.0000298394,
-0.0050565018,
0.0354261622,
0.0505382493,
-0.0138538908,
0.0082578268,
0.0051993607,
0.0155813228,
-0.0535042696,
0.0097991414,
0.0087128729,
0.0119242063,
-0.0236136504,
-0.0613643676,
0.0111755515,
0.0414461717,
-0.0222360231,
-0.0218497459,
-0.0276687015,
-0.0116137275,
-0.0093025221,
-0.0125719095,
0.0190040804,
0.0023464975,
-0.0078785773,
0.0116986688,
-0.0484789126,
-0.0346009769,
0.0871048644,
-0.0345616341,
-0.0131504126,
-0.0807690993,
-0.014575934,
-0.0436089076,
0.0695486665,
0.046407856,
0.0202394836,
-0.0322711468,
-0.0144900018,
-0.0068005398,
0.0583332591,
-0.0158242173,
0.0098625915,
0.003748276,
-0.0519509576,
0.0064487644,
-0.0348713771,
-0.0680820495,
-0.0181057714,
-0.0427378789,
0.0087774163,
-0.0147445593,
-0.004747807,
-0.0487530418,
-0.0367248505,
-0.0303327423,
-0.013030461,
0.0922330394,
-0.0161397122,
0.0089948848,
-0.0280055106,
0.0145543972,
-0.0034600133,
0.0271856282,
-0.0045046289,
-0.0133558325,
0.0079379613,
0.0246914662,
0.0200887751,
-0.0127802724,
-0.0717813596,
-0.0015145132,
0.005442305,
0.0310906749,
-0.0317976773,
-0.0286207926,
0.0396161377,
-0.0384992063,
-0.0077782874,
0.0804481432,
0.0318429768,
-0.0600607693,
0.0219838731,
-0.0142316241,
0.0451798029,
0.0429946631,
0.0455319621,
-0.087608397,
-0.0427309461,
0.0053395643,
0.0294790398,
0.0059642307,
-0.0103838667,
-0.0073408624,
-0.1365842521,
0.0364757925,
0.0292128883,
-0.0505658947,
-0.0195402447,
0.0126242656,
-0.0089853015,
-0.0218196455,
0.0178553108,
-0.0240844134,
0.0105478754,
0.0013009777,
0.0006324793,
0.0029256144,
-0.0612187721,
-0.0367512181,
-0.0329964757,
0.0281985085,
0.082354486,
0.0263046343,
-0.0047595887,
0.0075422907,
0.0255090054,
0.0036638868,
0.0007267764,
0.0097371386,
0.0496817343,
0.0004033932,
-0.0221093874,
0.0166195445,
0.0449851938,
-0.0383083038,
-0.0010310829,
0.0467322245,
0.0626457408,
-0.003483071,
0.0159619842,
0.0068025258,
-0.0269039199,
0.0028982193,
0.0397340134,
0.0407371782,
-0.0244957153,
0.021251535,
-0.0399453864,
-0.0275857281,
-0.0811943859,
0.016738398,
0.0434966013,
-0.0300716981,
-0.0436390415,
-0.0969327763,
-0.0526340678,
0.018063141,
0.0309584942,
0.0076779942,
-0.0061339638,
0.0093035549,
-0.0358034149,
-0.0167629179,
0.0514295511,
-0.0197383687,
0.012462521,
-0.013748738,
-0.0260528643,
0.0317693092,
0.0108520295,
0.010886305,
0.0083335275,
-0.0514415689,
-0.0623074248,
-0.0097313039,
0.0566954687,
0.0198780019,
0.0751411766,
-0.0579622202,
-0.0320138633,
-0.0361476317,
0.0752401054,
-0.0630626008,
-0.0010503659,
0.0193436015,
-0.0453363955,
0.0052550929,
0.0373958871,
-0.0043859044,
0.0201616324,
0.0044306428,
0.0478226244,
-0.0377747603,
0.0082891276,
0.0531262532,
0.0312771797,
0.0411656834,
-0.0129368631,
0.0055123726,
-0.0120391715,
0.0396790467,
-0.0412340835,
-0.0231654588,
-0.0563565753,
-0.0032337606,
0.0525211692,
0.016488526,
0.013142366,
-0.0110406326,
-0.0295737293,
-0.0242682043,
-0.013384453,
-0.0097813439,
0.0361586474,
0.0151099972,
-0.0144877518,
0.020270301,
0.0088712908,
-0.0078082499,
-0.0167074967,
0.0152958268,
-0.0365374088,
-0.002490622,
0.0275419839,
-0.0184247829,
-0.0275638215,
0.0403237343,
-0.0782511681,
0.0006316603,
-0.0129679376,
0.0165614691,
0.05303175,
-0.0007849872,
0.1076459363,
-0.0143180527,
0.00429053,
0.0282562431,
0.052980721,
-0.0045534782,
-0.0457195155,
-0.0171763208,
-0.0147694023,
-0.0023902834,
0.0301262494,
0.0770104378,
0.0124032591,
0.0378494523,
0.0029798918,
0.0028435634,
-0.0284321532,
-0.0397811495,
-0.0055842395,
-0.025072474,
-0.0192678496,
0.0028582867,
-0.013618662,
-0.0647716671,
-0.0145073123,
-0.0026984743,
0.0272698682,
0.0090621449,
0.0198447071,
0.045849856,
-0.0326142423,
-0.0105169797,
-0.0292359013,
0.0317259766,
0.0202010646,
-0.0551037155,
-0.0339637995,
-5.97213909e-33,
-0.0368151255,
0.0160520226,
0.0069339126,
-0.0157155152,
-0.0446830168,
-0.0091075655,
-0.03392905,
-0.0154091744,
0.0071395123,
0.0166276079,
-0.0032210413,
0.0269172657,
0.0270275921,
0.0442698896,
0.0213056169,
0.0129781347,
0.0417671464,
0.0154729141,
-0.0033936889,
0.0122907441,
0.0249620322,
0.0358428918,
0.0980667174,
-0.0675906315,
0.0123327551,
0.0126313362,
-0.0018979448,
0.0299976449,
-0.0256071016,
0.0022979062,
0.0346123204,
0.0246882569,
0.0298064575,
-0.0074152728,
-0.0186155736,
0.0065966458,
-0.0754530355,
0.0217056461,
0.0117067704,
0.05172709,
-0.0594342761,
-0.0575977117,
0.0722158253,
-0.0371102057,
0.0374927931,
0.0028972367,
0.0000363597,
-0.0731258541,
-0.0262658261,
0.0289805476,
-0.0863876492,
0.0072285095,
-0.0130464165,
-0.0040002954,
-0.0085185431,
0.1053704172,
-0.025695987,
-0.0080828546,
-0.0427996889,
0.0038353051,
-0.0097315982,
0.0362582542,
0.0318379775,
-0.0115090171,
-0.0336524509,
0.0530237556,
0.0204606578,
-0.024777228,
0.0248475429,
0.0407861657,
0.0195631236,
0.0445419066,
0.0740930885,
0.0403200909,
0.051970195,
-0.0022738387,
-0.0753329247,
0.0403511487,
0.011559057,
0.016297102,
-0.0006467599,
0.0080097197,
-0.0021561584,
-0.0016166241,
-0.0010363135,
-0.0305592492,
-0.0194381885,
-0.0394343957,
0.0053203348,
0.0227717217,
-0.0264987256,
0.0282698441,
0.0205752961,
-0.0463583358,
0.0214484483,
0.0051307906,
-0.029719431,
0.0220784396,
-0.0225721039,
0.0380389504,
-0.0187196322,
-0.0367752574,
0.0351192504,
0.0404370353,
0.0432229713,
-0.010506602,
0.0963626802,
-0.0162377711,
-0.037668936,
0.0074557168,
-0.0384666584,
0.0175962541,
-0.0503145047,
0.0720353872,
0.0203566924,
0.0255872831,
-0.0174090583,
0.0177161749,
0.0247728713,
0.0056823604,
-0.052306436,
-0.0366808884,
0.0249347631,
0.0084599396,
-0.0284746885,
-0.0060246158,
-0.0133232325,
0.0031405739,
0.0235639922,
-0.0674101412,
-0.0244970899,
0.0138833616,
2.83e-7,
0.0517628603,
0.0490655787,
0.0145966532,
-0.017734088,
0.0160116795,
-0.0001043622,
-0.0448251143,
0.0409767479,
0.004267897,
-0.0000528888,
0.0057913116,
-0.0037369693,
0.0909859985,
0.0203809049,
-0.1275022775,
-0.0188007299,
-0.0625882819,
-0.0141037572,
-0.0497285835,
-0.0080290232,
0.041603677,
0.1070194021,
0.0093864668,
-0.0178043414,
0.0209991559,
0.018468447,
0.0469274297,
-0.002984718,
-0.0483823381,
-0.032510411,
0.0121996496,
0.0392981656,
-0.0151909683,
0.0220923033,
-0.0311858784,
0.0399841107,
0.0202033073,
0.0457495227,
-0.0195577517,
0.0427208245,
-0.0072252196,
0.003493737,
-0.0090032835,
0.0143984156,
0.0411290042,
-0.0629104152,
-0.0164433327,
0.0015296579,
-0.0468730815,
0.0425076261,
0.0090240994,
-0.037220642,
-0.0516863838,
0.0091807228,
0.0567834303,
-0.0340163484,
-0.0374976136,
-0.0384041332,
-0.033008825,
-0.0064923633,
-0.0124674784,
-0.0193144791,
-0.0334478132,
0.044344224,
0.0166348722,
-0.0348301083,
-0.0126436735,
2.624350372e-34,
0.0482429788,
0.0133089339,
0.0129282372,
0.0090640439,
0.0182651114,
-0.0134025132,
0.0002742514,
0.0284027997,
-0.0428960174,
-0.0299890488,
-0.0168486666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02345v1 | Perturbation-based Active Learning for Question Answering | 2023-11-04T08:07:23 | 2023-11-04T08:07:23 | Fan Luo, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Building a question answering (QA) model with less annotation costs can be
achieved by utilizing active learning (AL) training strategy. It selects the
most informative unlabeled training data to update the model effectively.
Acquisition functions for AL are used to determine how informative each
training example is, such as uncertainty or diversity based sampling. In this
work, we propose a perturbation-based active learning acquisition strategy and
demonstrate it is more effective than existing commonly used strategies. | [
0.0281801652,
0.0111434944,
0.0041890531,
-0.0248999503,
0.0249653663,
0.0327721983,
-0.0173281282,
-0.0207928736,
0.0174781308,
-0.0561168678,
-0.0088616591,
-0.0418075509,
-0.0496342294,
-0.0032173167,
0.0233235192,
-0.0179500431,
0.066499047,
-0.0572937466,
0.0063330079,
-0.025510991,
0.0153459664,
-0.0142408153,
-0.054547146,
-0.0160112306,
-0.0291034933,
0.0200889558,
-0.0165895633,
-0.0144893629,
0.0154924588,
-0.0017739529,
0.0397280492,
0.0704940632,
-0.0090313042,
0.0216754191,
0.0000017112,
-0.0277099945,
-0.0319046341,
0.0049547479,
-0.039205227,
0.0299030244,
-0.0366382748,
0.062786378,
0.0415302031,
-0.0007813881,
-0.0638234615,
-0.0374062657,
0.0536429249,
-0.0147674372,
0.0502698161,
0.0195863247,
0.0203357283,
0.0182340331,
-0.0217262097,
-0.0298375227,
0.02681656,
-0.1073377728,
0.0415350534,
0.0336027257,
-0.0072522159,
0.029221449,
0.0047386196,
0.0424515978,
0.0081932694,
-0.0154943829,
0.0322887301,
0.0192258712,
0.0110605685,
0.0130308699,
0.014354609,
0.0759494007,
0.0580510944,
0.0308262836,
-0.0220571104,
-0.0206604637,
0.0328612141,
0.0541010462,
-0.0386887044,
-0.0355879292,
0.0021615257,
0.002013084,
-0.0376449823,
-0.0613397546,
-0.0051345574,
0.0328361131,
0.0056110234,
0.0313925743,
-0.0145883458,
-0.0777113587,
0.0351577736,
0.0108569795,
-0.0538771935,
-0.0159501582,
0.0046329722,
0.0836585537,
-0.0177065022,
0.0199480616,
0.0136784334,
-0.0128515158,
0.0117058437,
-0.0558074303,
-0.0029292291,
-0.016223168,
0.0122372909,
0.0757040083,
0.025726201,
-0.0178003199,
0.0095787942,
0.0164915565,
-0.0821864232,
-0.0073655494,
-0.0645507425,
-0.0341191627,
-0.0559652485,
0.0915057287,
-0.0076600006,
-0.0209125821,
-0.050380975,
0.0039674942,
0.0029438818,
-0.0471189655,
-0.0105418647,
0.0559681728,
-0.0521782339,
0.0423189364,
-0.039039664,
0.0010226673,
-0.0341995507,
0.0214566682,
-0.0224891156,
-0.0345259719,
-0.0016139689,
-0.0157100856,
0.0055237366,
-0.0251091365,
-0.0053725229,
0.0526951477,
-0.027767431,
-0.0454404503,
-0.0122980215,
-0.0125825526,
0.0262007415,
0.0021963827,
-0.0078565935,
-0.0173437521,
0.0020885959,
-0.0280931182,
0.0087998789,
-0.0412645787,
0.0253168195,
0.021810662,
-0.0245089587,
0.0330497399,
-0.0492722578,
-0.0279202256,
0.0592082366,
-0.0210547168,
-0.0069121844,
0.1088465676,
-0.0306974966,
-0.0062921029,
0.0446281582,
0.0135407187,
-0.0259959213,
-0.0173400715,
0.0353906825,
-0.009047512,
0.0328996703,
0.0457709581,
-0.0030924934,
-0.0363974497,
-0.0549931042,
0.0037789706,
-0.0440945663,
0.0075074239,
0.0260679238,
-0.0094909277,
-0.0438513048,
-0.0084652929,
-0.002925691,
0.0075401706,
0.0762170702,
-0.0020398966,
-0.013467934,
0.0182714071,
-0.0443426073,
-0.0049400437,
-0.0111406986,
-0.0086715259,
-0.0405224413,
-0.0479509197,
-0.015998615,
-0.0325869732,
-0.0045779357,
0.068809092,
0.0463995486,
0.012708934,
0.0252033044,
0.077704668,
0.0284832884,
0.0138878832,
0.0055804863,
0.0014289287,
0.0281955563,
-0.0146177392,
-0.0010517985,
-0.0826008841,
-0.0825523064,
-0.016501205,
0.0703917816,
-0.0116770491,
0.0464673713,
-0.0486268625,
0.0293440819,
-0.0454777554,
-0.027927747,
0.0034829329,
0.0151157845,
-0.0003583405,
0.0340196081,
0.0061497376,
0.0179953445,
-0.0184716228,
-0.0176654067,
0.0246135797,
0.0108606108,
-0.0724100545,
0.0251491498,
-0.0348870605,
0.0514090024,
0.0021161542,
-0.0222800747,
0.0053741462,
0.0232599173,
-0.0111718969,
-0.0278176758,
0.0084946882,
0.0254155062,
-0.0009423909,
0.0358339101,
0.0208594482,
-0.0441381447,
0.0380199514,
-0.0323149227,
-0.0189000927,
-0.0434882045,
-0.0742312819,
-0.0653839484,
-0.0650029033,
-0.0102434298,
-0.0185094588,
0.0286191981,
-0.0764846578,
0.064163588,
-0.0084639667,
0.0123364339,
0.0386376828,
-0.0069010826,
0.0333844312,
-0.0479138345,
-0.0209139343,
-0.0329380929,
0.0046895314,
-0.0249152072,
0.0166605469,
-0.0023560403,
-0.0266308356,
0.0068890443,
-0.0225857832,
-0.0093352702,
-0.0058098063,
0.0075022718,
0.0583192147,
0.0399365053,
0.0046333778,
-0.0083686225,
-0.0227499586,
-0.0047286926,
-0.013805598,
0.0370490067,
0.0251759086,
0.040959172,
0.0195867084,
-0.0593157597,
-0.0159661099,
0.0018967645,
0.0251275655,
0.0099567603,
-0.0124794366,
-0.0378852822,
-0.0421915352,
-0.0536095425,
0.032267455,
0.0489499457,
-0.0268934555,
0.0135701727,
-0.0427456908,
-0.0583748892,
0.0568185076,
0.0303357635,
0.0197904576,
-0.007904876,
0.0013814721,
-0.0370408334,
0.038309373,
-0.0448778234,
-0.0115813268,
-0.0048501454,
-0.0294964872,
0.0143691683,
0.00571858,
-0.0182007123,
-0.0257398933,
0.0046565146,
0.0360776819,
-0.040655382,
-0.0787690729,
-0.074562639,
0.0562076122,
-0.0031180547,
0.0411576107,
0.0078551229,
-0.0190525502,
0.0783407465,
0.0224512834,
-0.0262662824,
-0.0825161189,
-0.0057652676,
-0.023290677,
-0.0235403273,
-0.000054103,
0.0197808556,
-0.0381187312,
-0.0050323028,
-0.0273967274,
-0.0839990005,
0.0354352258,
-0.0320334397,
-0.000958648,
-0.0430823751,
0.0326192491,
0.0128640058,
-0.0220865421,
-0.0557329729,
-0.025789652,
0.019472532,
0.0358848087,
0.0184208415,
0.0189564005,
0.0014726769,
0.0494137295,
0.0263243485,
0.001707912,
-0.0308228619,
-0.0141748078,
-0.0200631339,
0.0587646589,
0.080639109,
0.0125506856,
0.0136239836,
-0.0239810385,
0.0173385348,
0.0710325241,
0.0014370137,
-0.006591538,
0.0194464494,
0.0032979124,
0.0173323285,
-0.0609598346,
0.0160500668,
0.0060226945,
0.0295112673,
0.0030016857,
-0.0424905084,
0.0997538939,
0.0670524091,
-0.0385609865,
-0.013599216,
-0.01152879,
-0.0341689065,
0.0342668369,
0.0700385869,
-0.001836824,
-0.0285861772,
-0.0305583049,
0.0774322152,
0.0189413838,
-0.0328083523,
0.0059304661,
-0.0317440592,
-0.0107682403,
-0.0196371078,
-0.0728957579,
-0.0185429994,
-0.0221356992,
0.0313589238,
-0.020408351,
0.0227948483,
0.0044767484,
0.0115319276,
0.0375064984,
0.0715108812,
-0.0248341728,
-0.0237857141,
-0.0393812321,
0.0162586477,
-0.0009130393,
0.0410540327,
-0.0114365686,
-0.0072449213,
0.0118144089,
0.0470795184,
-0.0682896525,
0.0039339499,
-0.0244100746,
0.0513685048,
0.0244231615,
-0.0089811459,
0.0044670035,
0.0178413521,
-0.0175252315,
0.0116093615,
0.0333826728,
0.0174192283,
-0.0206378177,
0.0712490678,
0.0001295133,
0.0057682404,
0.0257501211,
-0.0034579476,
0.0121475374,
-0.0280875769,
-0.0191943981,
0.0105102798,
-0.0048779221,
-0.0085584661,
0.0117137842,
0.0222808756,
-0.024501631,
-0.0220172442,
-0.0804201663,
-0.0330814272,
0.0559052303,
0.1006093025,
0.0204860922,
0.0579903126,
0.0173126459,
0.0248074401,
0.0116137499,
-0.0062138704,
-0.0092865024,
0.0027190067,
0.0212636776,
-0.1054011509,
0.0302277822,
0.0071652518,
-0.0351076424,
-0.0212324914,
-0.0255441945,
-0.030369835,
0.0550339073,
0.063086614,
0.0172463916,
0.0306606982,
-0.0269590542,
-0.0220073909,
0.0019821818,
0.0221010614,
0.0214903932,
0.0265544076,
0.0404376984,
-0.0210900102,
0.0060257912,
0.0095234681,
-0.0693268031,
0.0134757971,
0.0585184433,
0.0555275604,
-0.0724350736,
-0.0531413518,
0.0409201607,
0.0302969497,
-0.001342371,
0.0275182296,
-0.030729793,
0.0051383399,
0.0272843949,
0.0386800393,
-0.0250568055,
-0.0179924164,
0.022288451,
0.0008732309,
-0.0118155321,
-0.010117379,
0.0121228052,
0.0160097703,
0.074533321,
-0.0315251909,
-0.0260014813,
0.0336389728,
-0.0389942452,
-0.0405953638,
0.0018728498,
-0.0292919166,
0.040222805,
0.0049309251,
0.0635296553,
0.0345801041,
0.0431498103,
0.0103384899,
0.0071472586,
-0.0683462396,
0.0202506576,
-0.1023627967,
-0.0589513257,
-0.0287162643,
0.0721057951,
0.0602918305,
-0.0172384139,
0.0160495415,
0.0156008825,
-0.0289818477,
0.0186529271,
-0.0376361907,
0.0480430052,
0.0166704897,
0.0522447675,
0.0465181582,
0.034740895,
0.0388322324,
0.0927380547,
-0.0200853478,
0.0495656431,
-0.0376950689,
-0.0042165979,
-0.0383490063,
-0.007931916,
0.0309118479,
0.0383679271,
-0.0002520921,
0.0392483287,
0.0256826859,
-0.0442251377,
0.0014916203,
-0.048560068,
-0.016952388,
-0.0257589351,
0.0828543007,
0.0384464934,
0.0347312838,
-0.0208192822,
-0.0388035364,
0.020107165,
-0.0030063682,
0.0333060548,
0.0092278207,
-6.108545291e-33,
-0.0346542597,
0.0030587427,
-0.0347946696,
0.0102397976,
-0.0023796964,
0.0211562049,
0.0344157331,
-0.0187156089,
-0.0199843198,
-0.0141899539,
0.0095324293,
0.0034753764,
0.011499661,
0.0072738896,
-0.0008172039,
-0.0593813621,
-0.0285197217,
-0.0084700137,
-0.0008329184,
-0.0120773176,
0.0297410823,
0.0573441833,
0.0063970988,
-0.0587787442,
0.0051720045,
0.0025644547,
-0.0137192765,
0.026562253,
0.003471635,
0.0254757497,
-0.0050652414,
0.0095584514,
-0.0112194167,
-0.0314805284,
0.005908241,
-0.0350724123,
-0.0700216591,
-0.0231056586,
0.0003929608,
0.0458554663,
0.0032099194,
0.0259522796,
-0.0564568713,
-0.012846617,
0.077089034,
0.0122335954,
0.0318202339,
-0.0159508102,
-0.0615436211,
-0.0330855362,
0.0060509103,
0.0030642757,
-0.0729928166,
0.0287337471,
-0.032325916,
0.0481032357,
-0.028627431,
-0.0328648128,
-0.0010347721,
-0.0177091286,
0.0358757786,
0.0460268408,
-0.0122573683,
0.0314483605,
0.018349696,
0.0155628854,
0.0369163044,
-0.0390610956,
-0.0067948424,
0.0246528238,
-0.0715134293,
-0.0322246477,
0.020137988,
0.0081417887,
-0.0149794985,
0.0284077767,
-0.0709060803,
0.0047461987,
0.0823791549,
0.0011055793,
0.0160798673,
-0.0117783817,
-0.0155793279,
-0.0147793433,
-0.0269132107,
0.0492719673,
-0.0146822603,
-0.0586428046,
0.0283897407,
-0.0012940647,
-0.1076694578,
0.0148372184,
-0.0005067364,
-0.0058911941,
-0.0035493004,
-0.0236140974,
0.0275854245,
0.0086291693,
0.010606112,
-0.003329976,
-0.0086886473,
-0.0456591733,
0.0226725359,
-0.0366851091,
-0.0159250051,
0.0357056819,
-0.0023880792,
0.0151652768,
-0.009794943,
-0.0031501947,
-0.0082625709,
0.0189149305,
-0.0065598302,
0.0316509008,
0.0108432742,
-0.001848272,
-0.0191920381,
0.0618720129,
0.0424135849,
0.0230173692,
-0.0077255787,
-0.0517391562,
-0.0006375337,
0.0192290265,
-0.0303428359,
-0.0098269917,
0.008340124,
-0.0217777025,
-0.0728756413,
-0.0848611593,
-0.0034212314,
0.0570051558,
2.438e-7,
0.0661515966,
0.0198060926,
-0.0058270646,
0.0244466253,
0.0265955292,
0.0065241787,
0.0194388982,
-0.0462465659,
0.068943955,
0.0560535528,
0.0149714481,
0.0400730111,
-0.0085199811,
0.0528187826,
-0.110432595,
-0.0863314793,
-0.0318130665,
0.0365504138,
-0.0065103495,
0.0098207379,
0.0091179656,
0.0735172853,
0.0016326762,
-0.0260905847,
-0.0243091751,
-0.0885314196,
0.0356207676,
0.0194486473,
0.0171984136,
0.0211616885,
0.036704801,
-0.0374377482,
-0.0153888045,
0.0443774313,
-0.0273876637,
-0.0120746512,
0.0193337351,
0.0340196565,
-0.0144838262,
-0.0488990881,
0.0020517078,
0.0130353402,
0.0708143786,
0.0073586074,
0.112132594,
-0.0433629528,
-0.0359207578,
0.0092488676,
-0.0580656603,
-0.0366978794,
0.009255439,
0.007449904,
-0.0000380059,
0.0173127111,
-0.0028603533,
0.0115197878,
-0.0400804617,
-0.0606226288,
0.0166630689,
-0.0525857545,
-0.0125685381,
-0.0561627448,
0.0031826245,
0.0170517042,
-0.0237558652,
-0.0049010282,
0.0075797839,
1.717267988e-34,
0.0450169705,
0.0017277545,
0.0218200069,
0.0923217237,
-0.0208515506,
-0.0039930134,
0.0558672138,
-0.0460340232,
0.034648072,
-0.0556365028,
0.0026020966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02344v1 | You Only Forward Once: Prediction and Rationalization in A Single Forward Pass | 2023-11-04T08:04:28 | 2023-11-04T08:04:28 | Han Jiang, Junwen Duan, Zhe Qu, Jianxin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Unsupervised rationale extraction aims to extract concise and contiguous text
snippets to support model predictions without any annotated rationale. Previous
studies have used a two-phase framework known as the Rationalizing Neural
Prediction (RNP) framework, which follows a generate-then-predict paradigm.
They assumed that the extracted explanation, called rationale, should be
sufficient to predict the golden label. However, the assumption above deviates
from the original definition and is too strict to perform well. Furthermore,
these two-phase models suffer from the interlocking problem and spurious
correlations. To solve the above problems, we propose a novel single-phase
framework called You Only Forward Once (YOFO), derived from a relaxed version
of rationale where rationales aim to support model predictions rather than make
predictions. In our framework, A pre-trained language model like BERT is
deployed to simultaneously perform prediction and rationalization with less
impact from interlocking or spurious correlations. Directly choosing the
important tokens in an unsupervised manner is intractable. Instead of directly
choosing the important tokens, YOFO gradually removes unimportant tokens during
forward propagation. Through experiments on the BeerAdvocate and Hotel Review
datasets, we demonstrate that our model is able to extract rationales and make
predictions more accurately compared to RNP-based models. We observe an
improvement of up to 18.4\% in token-level F1 compared to previous
state-of-the-art methods. We also conducted analyses and experiments to explore
the extracted rationales and token decay strategies. The results show that YOFO
can extract precise and important rationales while removing unimportant tokens
in the middle part of the model. | [
0.040293023,
0.1115029976,
0.0117109641,
0.0228556022,
-0.0149524165,
0.0124777388,
0.0059357551,
0.024660999,
-0.0478794575,
-0.0379798114,
0.0082442593,
-0.0038114376,
-0.0027630201,
0.0388773791,
-0.0102588488,
-0.0512163863,
0.0295236465,
-0.018226387,
0.1147246361,
-0.0015890241,
0.0153779276,
0.0316177197,
0.0335478522,
0.0656546205,
-0.0032513684,
-0.0462677255,
-0.0148931406,
-0.0129408231,
0.0025715402,
0.0051440205,
-0.0042752363,
0.0436875746,
0.0056988187,
0.0025695299,
0.0000021714,
-0.0256902073,
-0.0566401407,
-0.0160842612,
-0.0278235488,
0.0080184042,
-0.0343806706,
0.0455068424,
0.0152650299,
-0.0054725348,
-0.0529372059,
0.0453901328,
0.0200445112,
0.1213052496,
0.0475843735,
0.0626684129,
-0.0017179567,
-0.0718595907,
0.002359716,
-0.0206715148,
-0.0506802797,
-0.0321103372,
-0.002931965,
-0.018734416,
-0.0623802356,
0.0178913493,
0.0011719266,
-0.0029728613,
0.0323273577,
-0.0409386121,
0.025577208,
0.0257439781,
0.0039478559,
-0.0465096496,
-0.009473606,
0.073313266,
-0.0444965735,
-0.0547002926,
0.0249811709,
-0.0150133809,
-0.0108860899,
-0.0251565874,
-0.0595474616,
0.0340730771,
0.019832518,
0.0659747645,
0.070698671,
-0.0195326991,
0.0316923223,
0.0279820338,
-0.0273263194,
0.0619367026,
-0.0143863857,
-0.0220266432,
-0.000410314,
0.0011792292,
-0.0230832119,
-0.0747465268,
-0.0075576995,
0.0708128735,
0.0054123392,
0.0240686424,
0.009829822,
0.0125144543,
0.0072156908,
-0.0298911408,
-0.0378889702,
0.0095438296,
-0.0035491909,
0.0453110449,
-0.0407425649,
0.0160738081,
-0.0069195689,
0.0579937324,
-0.0154699506,
0.0025352233,
-0.0593355335,
-0.0361720771,
-0.034753602,
0.0737280846,
-0.0898753554,
-0.0246661007,
-0.0227349512,
-0.0284794755,
-0.013210088,
0.0088106086,
0.0442151241,
0.0584793538,
0.025585698,
-0.0124215409,
-0.0167887565,
0.0125261284,
-0.0746783614,
-0.0083017629,
0.0391588993,
-0.0082116518,
-0.0239156149,
0.0383615382,
0.0153989252,
-0.0083292574,
-0.0096245566,
0.0419819839,
-0.0263511948,
-0.0087086111,
-0.0410043485,
-0.0736772567,
-0.0203730464,
-0.062778227,
-0.0085969726,
-0.0184861384,
-0.0004340161,
-0.0104468642,
-0.0253055021,
-0.0443531387,
0.0096151736,
0.0111357328,
-0.0546171367,
0.0672623813,
-0.0462224446,
-0.011539028,
-0.0204451475,
0.0234971903,
0.0105988411,
0.045100525,
0.0113880849,
0.0262003783,
0.0584385246,
0.0026934578,
-0.0091120135,
-0.0281644557,
0.0416691564,
-0.0320914239,
-0.0403095856,
0.023357382,
-0.0403654315,
-0.0082284436,
0.0223063771,
0.0209987741,
-0.0080393776,
0.000938075,
0.0272762496,
0.0612191148,
0.0176912341,
0.0407845005,
0.0371280238,
0.0137254344,
0.0114163617,
0.0215478837,
-0.0353766084,
0.0295884702,
-0.0201952457,
0.0113123124,
0.0368465967,
0.0059884256,
-0.0132778576,
-0.0606811345,
0.0008914905,
-0.0203007199,
0.0028644167,
-0.02907384,
0.0535303503,
0.0182407741,
-0.0676728636,
0.0277308132,
0.0141098509,
-0.0367337242,
-0.0072740098,
-0.0328929834,
0.0647610649,
0.0736729428,
0.0301870219,
-0.0099140797,
-0.0207331758,
0.002645659,
-0.0001597123,
-0.0030096951,
0.0376097932,
-0.0208960101,
0.0501917563,
-0.0425167754,
-0.044977881,
-0.0345448963,
0.025292974,
-0.0196014307,
0.011869194,
-0.0184779223,
0.0125165433,
-0.0337408409,
-0.0182809774,
0.0309433118,
0.007124335,
-0.0333201587,
-0.0068960269,
0.0223485101,
0.040671993,
0.0458861664,
0.0158296973,
0.0325708799,
0.0231533945,
-0.0216026343,
-0.0276468825,
0.0424297377,
-0.0665579438,
-0.0421452001,
0.0218467955,
0.0198197234,
-0.0297965668,
0.0202006437,
-0.0280739684,
-0.0609057024,
0.0207486488,
0.0167274177,
0.0608367026,
-0.0497934073,
0.0016794722,
0.0219789241,
0.0035172822,
-0.0154229365,
0.0848414451,
0.0072816382,
0.0153568424,
-0.0003070638,
-0.0233321451,
0.023435181,
-0.0213873945,
0.017804496,
0.0231315419,
-0.0398119874,
-0.0173101779,
0.0170737449,
-0.0002926582,
-0.0249931626,
0.01469828,
-0.0437610187,
0.00603372,
-0.0235695355,
-0.0083269682,
0.0366373286,
-0.0158231445,
0.016908953,
-0.0184175093,
-0.0149251726,
-0.0137299895,
-0.0195057783,
0.0127945766,
0.0640331358,
0.0072849072,
0.0037339728,
-0.0439538285,
-0.0022414525,
-0.0414471626,
0.0646535307,
0.0013563974,
0.0278744213,
-0.0337062068,
-0.0272446107,
-0.0169922169,
-0.0072123981,
0.0014987085,
-0.0438440777,
0.0105652474,
-0.019155791,
0.0145832254,
0.0340613797,
0.0297774207,
0.0346098728,
0.0056929882,
-0.0008912972,
-0.0451021455,
0.006192042,
-0.0488597304,
0.0729094446,
-0.0207579006,
-0.0031254787,
0.0349241458,
0.0935786739,
-0.013693166,
0.0196325034,
-0.0659622401,
0.0609790832,
0.0042344616,
-0.0042459695,
-0.0433257446,
-0.0472932123,
-0.0113123879,
0.0655817166,
-0.0218904745,
-0.0326606669,
0.0896767005,
-0.0391441695,
-0.0042296615,
-0.0177022442,
-0.0016567801,
-0.0264635477,
0.0760128573,
-0.0368308164,
0.0061287866,
0.0193772409,
-0.015602977,
-0.0031126109,
-0.0858694389,
-0.0209884141,
-0.0037487887,
0.0573768839,
-0.0447896048,
-0.0239861738,
0.0093279257,
-0.0301957894,
-0.0177282449,
-0.0715767443,
-0.0409223512,
0.0053957808,
-0.0067978688,
-0.0268844198,
0.0060306098,
0.0040629623,
-0.0064647715,
0.0517472327,
-0.0297919083,
0.0195062365,
-0.007071089,
0.0439095274,
0.0517523773,
-0.0046768906,
0.0267701261,
-0.0325463414,
0.0868709609,
0.0324781463,
0.0228605196,
-0.0307244174,
-0.0309713427,
-0.0126976203,
-0.017813243,
-0.0411131009,
-0.0181964226,
-0.0102513433,
0.0763222501,
-0.0425321124,
-0.0030347898,
0.1234863326,
0.0264109671,
0.0068092747,
-0.0036813479,
-0.0146785034,
0.0496280529,
-0.0044459584,
-0.0067417379,
0.0056931903,
-0.0438152961,
0.0167997498,
0.0349916741,
0.0319975279,
-0.0211101845,
-0.0059914715,
-0.0857628733,
0.0403380767,
-0.0412043408,
0.0002561178,
-0.0171294995,
-0.0632235482,
-0.014696491,
-0.0245076343,
-0.0239133146,
0.0248951316,
0.0050333538,
0.0280545112,
0.0174369849,
-0.0753861517,
0.0189424288,
0.0063585988,
-0.0154384365,
0.01040674,
0.0387203507,
0.0749167427,
0.0150009571,
-0.0476021245,
0.0139246257,
-0.0417014398,
0.0307831615,
-0.0388494879,
0.0679041892,
0.0138009079,
-0.0110676894,
-0.0218512323,
0.0318398625,
-0.0314974487,
-0.0414153337,
-0.0063170176,
0.0504955612,
-0.0243643411,
-0.0280860718,
-0.0168145802,
0.0287098717,
-0.0241045859,
0.0957450718,
0.0593871102,
-0.0325304903,
-0.0830365419,
-0.0220806152,
-0.0226193015,
-0.1051822528,
0.0101337628,
-0.0552708656,
0.0076495209,
0.0129972128,
-0.0744621828,
-0.0410616323,
-0.0031491802,
0.0410739705,
-0.0121007683,
0.0197062455,
-0.038566526,
-0.0122974031,
-0.0212228708,
0.0049722809,
-0.0144689288,
-0.0287500862,
0.0053599016,
0.0293502044,
0.0242995862,
-0.042899631,
-0.0348613448,
-0.0267865714,
0.0286337435,
-0.0373848639,
-0.0134058148,
0.0484499633,
0.0250493325,
0.1015264541,
-0.0390363671,
-0.0062781405,
0.0229333155,
-0.0017010398,
-0.0105936248,
-0.0456180312,
0.0626059473,
0.0215605963,
0.0214633271,
0.040874511,
-0.0277897548,
0.0085057234,
0.022557864,
0.0528965108,
-0.019971082,
0.0068507832,
0.0220966265,
0.0051075094,
0.0717489272,
0.0059369914,
0.0222732835,
-0.0502186194,
0.0086004594,
-0.0274392217,
-0.0071524708,
-0.0430831984,
0.0713242963,
0.0008836514,
0.0055386582,
-0.0278706476,
-0.0146020781,
-0.0198160429,
0.0107519533,
0.0214221776,
0.0120393373,
-0.0220286362,
0.044160679,
-0.0172466598,
-0.0126900282,
-0.0080990857,
-0.0012631529,
-0.0149634741,
0.0087973475,
-0.0217813272,
0.0358540528,
0.0421444029,
0.0006148048,
-0.0109105539,
-0.0013143325,
-0.0803987607,
-0.0599921718,
-0.0075649135,
-0.0351363458,
0.0146525884,
-0.0400595926,
0.063422136,
-0.0152896317,
-0.0041883569,
0.0252655521,
0.0627506003,
0.0418269895,
-0.0215191189,
0.0001001104,
0.0192716774,
-0.0499988757,
-0.0127170794,
0.053745836,
-0.0076720687,
0.0062964358,
0.0044083646,
-0.0307607818,
-0.0524431579,
-0.0354058519,
0.0078730751,
0.0447377712,
-0.0160674322,
-0.0148767233,
-0.0251249298,
-0.0367564857,
0.0000368716,
-0.0027980804,
-0.007562587,
0.0057014888,
0.037277516,
0.0615833476,
0.0015787128,
-0.0486694574,
-0.0657950863,
0.0189704187,
0.0270070843,
-0.0138709545,
-0.0155868968,
-6.771297822e-33,
0.0114840437,
-0.025642436,
-0.0045588254,
-0.0169813391,
0.0002348811,
0.0147438031,
-0.0726723745,
-0.0450841226,
-0.0246725343,
0.0422685444,
-0.0330590792,
0.022722058,
0.0243696198,
0.0164712816,
0.0140915662,
-0.0247342959,
0.0636577606,
0.0058882819,
-0.0039996323,
0.0256925356,
0.0572603121,
0.0510738455,
0.0610398389,
-0.0611271523,
0.0366257802,
0.0209795292,
-0.0221932046,
0.0386328474,
0.0226540957,
0.046850156,
-0.0018119977,
-0.0028318299,
0.027366288,
-0.0681050345,
-0.0084777605,
0.042245537,
-0.1091843992,
-0.0306577906,
0.0370337069,
-0.0331664532,
-0.0463532209,
-0.0256047491,
0.0407546163,
0.0069195703,
0.0162055381,
0.0297297295,
0.0544916727,
-0.0040677716,
0.0009887756,
0.0034592461,
-0.0529758707,
0.0324158967,
-0.0309838839,
0.0099919317,
0.0073934896,
0.0271284841,
-0.0074012205,
0.0588040911,
-0.0462462269,
-0.0209123939,
0.0200056862,
0.0330547765,
0.0300436113,
-0.0152627295,
-0.0110129667,
0.0881629884,
-0.0055461987,
-0.0197595395,
-0.0572568811,
0.023711348,
-0.0035125555,
0.0694870651,
0.0655167699,
-0.0065456801,
0.0496459976,
-0.010710001,
-0.0966895968,
0.0116789741,
-0.0166671891,
0.0185803846,
0.0318414792,
0.0060878457,
0.0056292564,
0.0053709745,
-0.0075388355,
-0.0185971223,
-0.0104183136,
-0.0168943033,
0.0038645435,
0.0227133352,
-0.058592651,
0.0063660839,
0.003792715,
-0.0580759868,
0.0219314769,
0.0543445759,
-0.0185289383,
-0.0212216489,
0.0284378976,
-0.002809447,
-0.0704355165,
-0.003801344,
-0.0029637439,
0.0193421487,
0.005731842,
0.0060862177,
0.068984814,
-0.0163506269,
-0.0490069725,
0.0127336122,
-0.0331476331,
0.0029030591,
-0.0255177617,
0.0261529535,
0.0224241037,
0.0147500942,
-0.0215242989,
0.0317697078,
0.0314952731,
0.0380902067,
-0.0114886248,
-0.0006693629,
0.0376766212,
0.0242240187,
-0.0001967053,
-0.0474206135,
-0.0093012536,
-0.0084060933,
0.0124275591,
-0.0670269057,
-0.0175196473,
0.0403517894,
2.795e-7,
0.0467153862,
0.0200137626,
0.0590638667,
-0.0645591095,
0.0125342393,
0.0409787372,
0.0285531953,
-0.0077565117,
-0.0200641137,
-0.0105736163,
0.0120927049,
-0.0013289549,
0.0315337032,
0.0142130852,
-0.0842537358,
-0.0148491459,
-0.0884589851,
-0.0579968914,
-0.0239585638,
-0.015653545,
0.047789827,
0.051158078,
0.042185735,
-0.0192113798,
-0.0147945527,
-0.0036692373,
0.0191702321,
0.0047489717,
0.013522136,
0.0103374328,
0.0369721502,
-0.0117511768,
-0.0138080204,
-0.0346475244,
-0.0335854143,
0.0314406641,
-0.0236334745,
0.0777658671,
-0.0288250241,
-0.0707136989,
0.0032934705,
-0.0318397544,
0.0325853564,
-0.0691965297,
0.0648690015,
-0.0277265273,
-0.0380307324,
-0.0200653784,
-0.0691800267,
0.0035852047,
-0.0146244075,
0.0120544676,
-0.019486554,
0.0466595329,
-0.0342074446,
-0.0065092938,
0.0121087991,
-0.111734204,
-0.0467898361,
-0.0097277919,
-0.0161444265,
0.0134279616,
-0.0194329098,
0.0000482976,
0.0373487584,
-0.0953790918,
-0.0122354124,
2.778958185e-34,
0.0404145904,
-0.015561128,
-0.0084224604,
0.0320982672,
0.0390337817,
0.0204093698,
-0.035071332,
-0.0219730567,
0.0480453111,
-0.0163859762,
-0.0161409955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02341v1 | Enhancing English Writing Proficiency in China's Polytechnic Students An In-Depth Literature Review on the Application of the Input Hypothesis | 2023-11-04T07:41:12 | 2023-11-04T07:41:12 | Wei Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Having good English writing skills is extremely important for students in
polytechnic institutions. However, a lot of students in technical schools have
difficulties in reaching high levels of skill. The Input Hypothesis, created by
Stephen Krashen, suggests that people learn languages well when they receive
information that's a little harder than what they already know but still
understandable. This research paper wants to study how the Input Hypothesis can
help polytechnic students improve their English writing skills. The study will
include real-life observations and experiments from the previous research. We
will look at data from polytechnic students who are receiving special writing
instruction to see if the Input Hypothesis actually helps improve their writing
skills. The paper can better inform polytechnic students, faculty members, and
support staff and even members of the larger community about the attributions,
the processes, and the possible outcomes of second language development for
polytechnic students.
Keywords: English writing skills, Polytechnic students, Input hypothesis,
Comprehensible input | [
0.0278167017,
-0.0532632284,
-0.0113442428,
-0.0204151664,
-0.010289791,
-0.0073995502,
0.0294941049,
-0.0113740079,
0.0271802265,
-0.0563650914,
0.0004184171,
-0.0265275091,
0.0424507633,
-0.0099369353,
0.0460168011,
-0.0158242211,
0.0113949087,
0.0314382352,
-0.003431895,
0.0012611281,
0.0332773402,
0.0109988721,
-0.0057368097,
0.0288400482,
0.0206782464,
-0.0409762263,
0.0073005483,
0.0038258443,
-0.0193053037,
0.0281889513,
0.0241921842,
0.0498039648,
0.0129967602,
0.0461157523,
0.0000022845,
-0.0267198589,
-0.0081438385,
-0.0383137502,
-0.0110876122,
0.0431702249,
0.0327990018,
0.0335754715,
-0.0457430445,
0.0169081371,
0.0132645266,
-0.0133665651,
0.0081147468,
0.0479637273,
0.0265742913,
0.0290665198,
0.0076800166,
-0.0392535776,
0.0440158062,
0.0325725079,
0.0090127364,
0.0785880014,
0.0078509599,
-0.0658980906,
0.0246434454,
0.0125005832,
-0.0473512486,
-0.003642827,
0.0121587785,
-0.0627929196,
-0.0057075373,
0.0459521003,
0.0032115073,
0.009949212,
0.0189537276,
-0.0356961489,
0.0180798937,
-0.0453019403,
-0.020663714,
-0.0122984406,
0.0338933915,
0.0504501723,
-0.0216726735,
-0.0155196898,
-0.0371839702,
0.0075261649,
0.0493924953,
-0.073081173,
-0.0330261514,
0.0312261581,
0.0335883088,
0.0038672069,
-0.0058707129,
-0.0610083118,
-0.0120227858,
0.00626582,
0.0372249074,
-0.0267785843,
-0.0307759009,
0.0402857363,
-0.0087317387,
0.0026497727,
0.0315621756,
-0.0476753339,
-0.012707958,
-0.0462267436,
0.0581833385,
0.0476579592,
0.0257538091,
-0.0343579389,
-0.0198304784,
0.011273548,
0.0275606867,
0.0592467003,
-0.0188652202,
0.0466834046,
-0.0669639111,
-0.0537615605,
-0.0239054561,
0.0074428278,
0.0512161702,
0.0096299313,
0.0024416097,
-0.0353634246,
0.0072039221,
0.008045448,
-0.0885954201,
-0.0335330814,
-0.0605072789,
0.0035712323,
0.0219174791,
0.0761959851,
-0.0160924364,
0.0202374645,
-0.0310818665,
-0.0125541128,
0.0458442234,
0.0175413173,
0.031034492,
0.0141298007,
-0.0018154365,
-0.0515536629,
-0.0473240986,
-0.0002961414,
-0.0361918136,
-0.0047898204,
0.0237402301,
-0.0098357154,
-0.0111053223,
-0.0303793214,
-0.0859426335,
0.0020906853,
0.004401864,
-0.0669338629,
0.0042074108,
0.0134410765,
0.0135570439,
-0.0452967212,
-0.0241664816,
-0.0071845683,
0.0705469474,
0.0155357774,
0.0287154932,
-0.0093351742,
0.0765356198,
0.0305981785,
-0.0269139167,
-0.0264859274,
0.0607004426,
0.0169253293,
-0.0116223814,
-0.0124514224,
0.0016117401,
-0.0440824553,
-0.0329988971,
0.0308191702,
-0.0154148154,
-0.0168218166,
-0.0143077588,
0.1584681123,
0.0211154614,
0.0412613563,
0.0476626903,
-0.0123097915,
-0.017013941,
0.0148261953,
0.0203567427,
0.0534690432,
0.0165557712,
0.0089195203,
0.0154828588,
0.0510940962,
-0.0020431033,
-0.0276680812,
0.0005222355,
-0.0607249029,
-0.0306543242,
0.0326622091,
-0.0101684127,
-0.0063414592,
-0.00874345,
-0.007489122,
-0.0010869983,
0.0128920544,
-0.0159110688,
-0.0637144074,
0.0558483712,
0.0238224808,
0.0378884673,
0.0939608738,
-0.0028564469,
-0.0056382674,
0.0742422044,
-0.0467564687,
0.0233583078,
0.0312656797,
0.0255426094,
-0.0026719135,
-0.0167538449,
0.0092249112,
0.0088333422,
-0.0048289201,
0.0189646296,
-0.0114163673,
-0.0688605085,
0.038904123,
0.0047726668,
0.0684869438,
-0.0754029006,
0.0248264205,
-0.0662867427,
-0.0150546534,
-0.0390274413,
0.015073562,
-0.0469141528,
0.0354589447,
-0.068878755,
0.0139918709,
-0.0369129218,
-0.0019375609,
-0.0161434934,
-0.0041075828,
-0.0061483174,
0.0008512162,
0.0238630772,
-0.0687714517,
-0.0256101377,
-0.0107700331,
0.0084095076,
-0.0439104997,
0.0166728981,
-0.0179060716,
0.0584110916,
-0.0056683221,
-0.0209670458,
-0.0891451165,
-0.0356669351,
-0.0023856182,
-0.0399921872,
0.0016411302,
0.0503539369,
-0.0456728935,
0.0097212102,
0.0131716346,
-0.0129950019,
-0.0358421318,
0.0109466305,
0.0166308712,
0.0489238501,
0.0421889909,
0.0257939715,
-0.0761011392,
-0.0285331756,
-0.0018918754,
-0.030996047,
0.0058996007,
-0.0122540276,
0.0206168555,
-0.0741467774,
-0.0108370315,
0.0200662836,
-0.0218121018,
-0.0510538816,
-0.0075739599,
-0.0223981179,
0.0315167308,
-0.0185281802,
0.0289534703,
0.0003665863,
-0.0075587975,
-0.0314839594,
-0.0162437689,
0.081773825,
-0.0435770378,
-0.036781732,
0.0396800786,
0.0444710068,
-0.0565415584,
0.0192519538,
-0.0953901187,
0.0083387205,
0.0182447731,
0.0498279333,
0.0600351393,
0.0196262337,
-0.0044840402,
0.0271629076,
-0.0009893598,
0.00371191,
-0.0327014029,
0.0251684431,
0.0467206277,
-0.0189178064,
-0.0616433211,
-0.0331653133,
-0.0095611773,
0.0435411669,
-0.0300649032,
0.0043261671,
0.0108240591,
-0.0639245957,
0.0171019286,
-0.0435423926,
-0.0488136783,
-0.0664444268,
0.0279211905,
-0.0075201467,
0.005155636,
0.0222127233,
-0.030777961,
-0.026715219,
-0.0293412637,
0.0258390214,
-0.0009056019,
0.0154915377,
-0.008558074,
0.0197783653,
0.0146497879,
-0.0359684862,
-0.0444792733,
0.0200063996,
0.0683427081,
0.0188632514,
0.0198727045,
0.0241417699,
-0.0395790301,
-0.0020143816,
0.0280815922,
0.023411436,
-0.0050918651,
0.019200068,
0.0191646498,
0.0028927415,
-0.027073415,
0.0508036725,
-0.0321132615,
0.0455133021,
0.059213385,
-0.0192626547,
-0.0002949362,
-0.0180605482,
-0.0541658998,
-0.0106688933,
0.0145196477,
-0.0175327193,
-0.0772254989,
0.0544644445,
0.0292844716,
-0.0164914671,
0.0262567606,
0.0167262554,
-0.0306506269,
0.0002394275,
-0.022413196,
-0.0388824977,
-0.0096284105,
0.0369022004,
-0.0473811515,
-0.0238427855,
0.0659927055,
-0.0254708696,
0.025038287,
-0.0319876075,
0.0055738995,
0.0169721451,
0.0065633985,
0.0394618958,
-0.0187651776,
0.0384953655,
-0.0057523265,
0.0594954602,
-0.0164201315,
0.0126894405,
-0.0159824789,
-0.0375369862,
0.0112800524,
0.0156000983,
0.0074579795,
-0.010452169,
0.0030673619,
-0.0383384079,
0.0745806023,
0.0268676933,
0.006600386,
-0.0182303526,
0.0368769318,
0.0429720022,
-0.0535669439,
-0.0417283177,
-0.0413942859,
0.0050278017,
0.0066549135,
-0.0078921644,
0.0147358365,
-0.0663625821,
0.0083891358,
0.0249641575,
-0.0021178699,
-0.0225694869,
-0.0050613596,
0.0084021119,
-0.0113702929,
0.0319575891,
-0.0280057546,
0.041678004,
-0.0164644923,
-0.0007589544,
0.0429424085,
0.027039066,
0.0482067578,
-0.017590154,
-0.0160424598,
0.0124854241,
0.0020934443,
0.0151676666,
0.0648042634,
-0.0476335324,
0.0145954145,
-0.0582043715,
-0.0284901094,
-0.0258402657,
-0.0336410329,
0.0448733158,
-0.0362740122,
-0.0322058573,
-0.0245299507,
-0.0901098475,
0.0120851751,
0.0599257872,
0.0223405808,
0.0916655064,
0.0071733762,
-0.0389263369,
0.0030217026,
-0.0081262384,
0.0501224436,
0.0070705125,
-0.0611906946,
-0.000138077,
-0.060373649,
-0.0363624319,
-0.0167592447,
-0.0729227066,
-0.0109429872,
-0.0376554318,
0.0500000902,
-0.0038870214,
0.0107504828,
-0.0154234441,
0.0390734337,
-0.0454915389,
0.0167107284,
-0.0479664356,
0.0237295516,
0.0272416864,
0.0174843948,
-0.032679297,
0.0229860805,
0.0018425485,
0.0511169657,
-0.017421579,
0.0212838519,
0.0114546502,
-0.0003093875,
0.0058599268,
0.020589171,
0.0594556257,
0.0254554562,
-0.0426289141,
0.0266488437,
-0.0956701413,
0.0046894085,
0.0102185467,
-0.0454337932,
-0.0186063517,
-0.0314382762,
0.0071611414,
-0.0282330662,
-0.0282054171,
-0.0252206363,
-0.0017335145,
0.030635044,
0.0031697601,
0.0948944539,
0.0051300339,
0.1158205569,
0.0289073084,
0.0058460282,
-0.0138551798,
0.016452251,
-0.0210721362,
0.055034712,
0.0330303088,
0.0373189487,
0.0376464948,
-0.0082025006,
0.0373470038,
-0.0134300068,
-0.0395301953,
-0.0353385061,
-0.0146535328,
-0.0042034755,
-0.0145352818,
-0.0110350875,
0.0468484163,
-0.0259848461,
0.030439822,
-0.0097745284,
0.0431253724,
-0.0022669565,
-0.068410337,
-0.0024591689,
-0.0272047836,
-0.000232762,
-0.0676137358,
0.0121385474,
-0.0248020198,
-0.0329665504,
-0.0238529816,
0.0108610773,
-0.0041596885,
0.0110656591,
0.0170632079,
0.0311725177,
0.0281057563,
0.0508419238,
-0.0514769964,
-0.0435046777,
-0.0517591164,
0.0070927069,
-0.012112516,
-0.0307061803,
-0.0443341658,
0.030808717,
-0.0170589406,
0.0091787186,
-0.0440920815,
0.0300492011,
0.0354470126,
-0.0309603326,
0.0265050624,
-6.290356063e-33,
-0.0227798782,
-0.034422107,
-0.0076781823,
0.0386281274,
0.0188900977,
0.0076906201,
-0.0384852961,
0.0452599339,
-0.0236435309,
0.0199438911,
-0.0353272855,
0.0292305052,
-0.0182572827,
0.0386378467,
0.0612398461,
0.0522056147,
0.0300514325,
0.0314742401,
-0.0329399593,
-0.0624746978,
0.0554006584,
0.003482983,
0.1089553311,
0.0724413618,
0.0971461758,
-0.081465438,
-0.0043391692,
-0.0171150751,
-0.0043315561,
-0.0235960018,
0.0541972294,
0.0488360822,
0.0303639639,
-0.0733120218,
0.0058517107,
0.0357651412,
0.0098972926,
-0.0576600134,
-0.0219593104,
0.0267223474,
0.0281587169,
-0.056352511,
0.0239576548,
-0.0338670798,
0.002821537,
-0.018065555,
0.0305232015,
0.0167065784,
0.0159273464,
0.0555877201,
-0.0703067482,
0.0032687397,
-0.0233749207,
0.0261480547,
-0.0164737143,
0.0269893557,
0.0123831583,
-0.1028676108,
-0.0694261864,
0.0321538486,
0.0367338285,
0.0741907656,
0.0178863462,
-0.0487361439,
-0.0388950221,
-0.0082036965,
0.0074204537,
-0.0004178905,
-0.0017085337,
0.0108170602,
0.0767310187,
-0.0635174438,
0.0071970066,
0.0813153461,
0.0236321744,
-0.0621481426,
0.022792846,
-0.0018222039,
0.0770857558,
-0.0104497559,
-0.0210980717,
-0.0355053023,
-0.0575386547,
-0.1001619324,
-0.0274601448,
0.0252521709,
0.0214673113,
-0.0375609808,
0.024957655,
-0.0402553603,
0.015923908,
-0.0698606893,
-0.0005569593,
0.0042344476,
-0.045084469,
-0.0001612065,
-0.0634554401,
0.034288317,
-0.029448323,
0.059143234,
-0.0615617931,
-0.0100505808,
-0.0213192478,
0.0214537736,
0.0050054574,
0.0583559349,
0.0327672549,
0.0219897535,
-0.0306298155,
-0.0125989523,
-0.0315027833,
-0.0238532256,
0.0336236171,
-0.0258830748,
-0.0138317626,
-0.0019693649,
0.0035326725,
-0.0068491627,
0.0257788822,
-0.0390214026,
-0.0431125388,
0.0137429312,
-0.0200070459,
-0.0061241216,
-0.0125883389,
0.005455337,
-0.0180260576,
0.0063222903,
0.0456747077,
-0.0258468725,
0.0215911716,
-0.0287715998,
2.974e-7,
0.0258686561,
0.0284033585,
-0.0202066675,
-0.0094570015,
-0.0100782132,
0.0165640041,
-0.0306057967,
0.0365294367,
0.0707345828,
0.0715392902,
0.0036287417,
-0.0070180693,
-0.0130180288,
-0.0135636386,
-0.0465872698,
-0.0631347001,
-0.0340480804,
0.0592236258,
-0.0345142186,
0.0591627881,
0.0653715283,
-0.0425024554,
-0.0044199396,
-0.0178832784,
-0.0266827885,
-0.0102856858,
-0.0273259524,
0.0149716297,
0.0377648026,
0.0404534191,
0.0354051143,
0.0025244309,
0.0107262824,
0.0410772488,
-0.0256558433,
-0.0148314256,
-0.0003448763,
0.0114525417,
0.0130796898,
0.0692124665,
0.0492703393,
0.0168832671,
-0.0254704524,
-0.0780689567,
0.0232821181,
-0.0004616222,
0.0109445909,
0.0207492858,
0.0239398554,
-0.0190885998,
-0.0192519855,
0.0333941914,
0.0130532021,
0.0202741921,
-0.0075651533,
-0.0135440808,
0.0640133843,
0.0083495034,
-0.0395010225,
-0.014022124,
0.0364037491,
-0.034492325,
-0.0299657397,
-0.0253829956,
-0.0217992757,
-0.0551308468,
-0.0419711918,
2.297339553e-34,
-0.0096887406,
-0.0297121182,
0.0548231266,
0.0284607597,
0.0102291219,
0.0288314335,
0.0386743359,
-0.00309534,
0.0264962111,
0.0451816209,
-0.0378470607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02321v1 | Identifying Context-Dependent Translations for Evaluation Set Production | 2023-11-04T04:29:08 | 2023-11-04T04:29:08 | Rachel Wicks, Matt Post | cs.CL | cs.CL | A major impediment to the transition to context-aware machine translation is
the absence of good evaluation metrics and test sets. Sentences that require
context to be translated correctly are rare in test sets, reducing the utility
of standard corpus-level metrics such as COMET or BLEU. On the other hand,
datasets that annotate such sentences are also rare, small in scale, and
available for only a few languages. To address this, we modernize, generalize,
and extend previous annotation pipelines to produce CTXPRO, a tool that
identifies subsets of parallel documents containing sentences that require
context to correctly translate five phenomena: gender, formality, and animacy
for pronouns, verb phrase ellipsis, and ambiguous noun inflections. The input
to the pipeline is a set of hand-crafted, per-language, linguistically-informed
rules that select contextual sentence pairs using coreference, part-of-speech,
and morphological features provided by state-of-the-art tools. We apply this
pipeline to seven languages pairs (EN into and out-of DE, ES, FR, IT, PL, PT,
and RU) and two datasets (OpenSubtitles and WMT test sets), and validate its
performance using both overlap with previous work and its ability to
discriminate a contextual MT system from a sentence-based one. We release the
CTXPRO pipeline and data as open source. | [
0.0390982032,
0.0226592384,
-0.0276197698,
0.0694830939,
-0.0424095541,
0.0155399926,
0.0245969072,
-0.0239411741,
-0.0462458543,
-0.0385825261,
-0.039969895,
-0.026534155,
0.0144821461,
-0.0307141505,
0.0171753038,
-0.037388321,
0.0086431289,
0.0121555924,
-0.0152464453,
0.0176617019,
0.0458265543,
0.0397102498,
0.0252299886,
0.0412424169,
-0.0010338291,
0.0055748206,
0.023334058,
0.0758474767,
0.0533969328,
0.0149395242,
0.0292285066,
0.034714561,
-0.0103151305,
0.0413820073,
0.0000018303,
-0.070013456,
-0.0494582653,
-0.0036564372,
0.0121211503,
0.0027604168,
0.0709772184,
-0.033745259,
-0.027236728,
0.008877106,
-0.0077068158,
-0.0057685776,
0.0403223708,
-0.0296908859,
0.0546103008,
0.0644304305,
-0.0321951658,
0.0154110789,
-0.0738264546,
-0.0293243751,
-0.0404877402,
-0.0427351221,
-0.0307534579,
-0.0409418084,
-0.0221774075,
0.0109052891,
0.0105059016,
0.0433635786,
0.0132046379,
-0.0391407013,
-0.036185801,
-0.0146141397,
-0.0644197538,
-0.038712658,
-0.0017833746,
0.0668845624,
0.0106134042,
-0.0281496346,
0.0033361411,
-0.0027011496,
-0.0161000174,
-0.0330252536,
-0.0273682773,
0.0068013626,
-0.0193078313,
0.0054242606,
0.0442284681,
0.0466984436,
0.0074635181,
0.0299940817,
-0.0241917986,
0.0290191341,
0.031455636,
-0.0181505233,
0.01457683,
0.0359687768,
-0.0476818793,
-0.0345350914,
0.0329944901,
-0.0478439182,
-0.0165436156,
0.0168324504,
-0.0376393571,
-0.0663447231,
0.0439065285,
-0.0545661226,
0.0099102091,
0.034547668,
-0.0185210351,
0.0423433706,
-0.010979984,
0.0562997796,
0.0235607438,
0.0014869375,
-0.0839004219,
-0.0584100708,
-0.0105816303,
0.0503602996,
-0.0561227687,
-0.0507234782,
-0.081883505,
0.0213995352,
-0.0379704237,
0.013828123,
-0.0134885879,
0.0268583708,
0.0049520982,
-0.0294986162,
-0.0389957912,
0.0140936049,
0.0199066792,
0.0435308665,
-0.0229977239,
-0.0088830963,
-0.0296932422,
-0.0492502004,
-0.0154723972,
0.0329980999,
0.0177739859,
-0.0375051685,
-0.010452305,
0.0436542183,
-0.0060902494,
-0.048814781,
0.0390003547,
-0.0290218927,
-0.0533157587,
-0.0454699285,
-0.0196989141,
-0.0581952631,
0.0327646285,
0.0190976225,
0.0184543859,
-0.0367691256,
0.0158299711,
0.0181061029,
0.0308159534,
0.0554677546,
0.04033041,
-0.0172981452,
0.0132930307,
-0.0125267366,
-0.0117628342,
0.070485957,
0.0587269627,
0.0117726345,
0.0720481575,
0.0426812097,
-0.0115869241,
0.0856266469,
0.0128064863,
0.0321761481,
-0.0169985071,
0.0312809907,
0.0072870515,
0.0472562946,
0.0229723621,
0.0306340959,
0.0189193711,
0.0146921938,
0.013326061,
0.011181972,
-0.0002959488,
-0.0128858266,
0.0699613914,
0.0033586156,
0.0065767025,
0.0019699235,
-0.0219636057,
-0.0042531011,
0.0116558094,
-0.0262729339,
-0.0279960521,
0.0211922526,
-0.0020540825,
-0.0308542419,
-0.0422416329,
0.0095687192,
0.0200001393,
-0.0210553911,
0.0276154857,
0.0462277569,
-0.0329699479,
0.0196936298,
0.0006486422,
-0.0896067619,
0.0034370599,
0.0002931485,
-0.0370622911,
0.0631071553,
0.0563034303,
-0.0221126974,
-0.0267315656,
-0.0106370691,
0.0088315159,
0.0470881164,
0.0390610546,
-0.0284738,
0.0395139754,
-0.0464364998,
0.002835481,
0.0148108425,
0.019870311,
0.0048043095,
0.0171618033,
0.0232624877,
0.0411654487,
-0.0514765419,
-0.0389091223,
0.0321991816,
-0.0099493926,
-0.0042785779,
0.0540109836,
0.0326187313,
0.0346663222,
0.0309477057,
-0.0022427838,
-0.008240399,
0.0192398671,
-0.0431140698,
0.0078652883,
0.1014586911,
-0.034036845,
-0.041521389,
-0.0116896201,
-0.0431713015,
-0.0553561449,
-0.0193476286,
-0.0439409986,
-0.0483335555,
-0.0075957868,
-0.0380698219,
0.0254927836,
-0.0606986359,
0.0235773139,
0.0059370184,
0.0086207539,
-0.0598042421,
0.0162644107,
0.0044348184,
-0.0064372569,
0.0314899608,
-0.0076453751,
0.0295913201,
-0.032559488,
-0.0224067885,
-0.0067286426,
0.0092681535,
0.0033451458,
0.0429031141,
0.0385455526,
-0.0288564693,
-0.0350949652,
-0.0867089257,
0.0298709963,
-0.0522149764,
0.0497346893,
0.0590627193,
0.0473210774,
-0.0211634897,
-0.0021257799,
0.0318881012,
-0.0055220402,
0.0190874431,
-0.014205182,
0.0518363826,
0.0025412235,
0.0013750859,
-0.0247646924,
0.0166363232,
-0.015648365,
0.040123228,
0.0386175774,
-0.0097195767,
-0.0294436999,
0.0406537578,
0.0215047505,
-0.0270013101,
0.0188198145,
-0.0310470499,
-0.0178563632,
0.0199883468,
0.0131195616,
0.0443118885,
-0.0251782667,
0.0252818037,
0.0187074114,
-0.0143859312,
-0.0345434323,
-0.0068652397,
0.014685425,
-0.0470318124,
-0.0195861422,
-0.0397909284,
0.0373943187,
0.014823705,
-0.0100334454,
-0.015854422,
-0.0329472683,
-0.0146057568,
-0.0459317937,
-0.028522091,
0.0055133644,
-0.0006250893,
0.0029988179,
0.0592429079,
-0.0311402511,
-0.0016883208,
0.0653774366,
-0.0449741073,
-0.0259184204,
-0.0878309309,
-0.0052847476,
-0.0636698157,
0.0715612322,
-0.0212775543,
0.0046973196,
-0.0158299766,
-0.0358783118,
-0.0143628335,
0.0166827776,
0.0244075637,
-0.0028045091,
0.030917719,
-0.0872552246,
0.008884904,
-0.0253763646,
-0.0392221101,
-0.017273834,
0.0055084527,
-0.016633559,
0.0032513847,
0.0114722215,
-0.0067373998,
0.015400474,
-0.0001942123,
-0.0373091921,
0.0887470096,
-0.0061126002,
0.0104556568,
-0.0230729152,
0.0441216305,
-0.022674419,
0.0225292817,
-0.0017951336,
-0.0329698548,
0.0232189652,
0.0322357863,
-0.0075267009,
-0.0075302101,
-0.0085003367,
-0.0173790865,
0.0311430916,
-0.029194016,
-0.0156213958,
-0.0466295741,
0.070838131,
-0.0879915208,
-0.0470808744,
0.1079537943,
0.0465046428,
-0.0610873476,
-0.0145904319,
-0.0132678449,
0.002124999,
0.0221660268,
0.0098878909,
-0.1275395304,
-0.030465262,
0.031323906,
0.0153291617,
-0.0082795564,
-0.0015572523,
-0.012132572,
-0.081554696,
0.0451308563,
0.0108467881,
-0.0868538469,
-0.0045383563,
-0.0173429623,
0.0244198292,
-0.0701832324,
0.0309776757,
-0.0204952452,
0.0076198713,
0.0058405763,
-0.0195350926,
0.025841061,
-0.0607079975,
0.0474272072,
-0.0540781431,
0.0094015198,
0.0335786901,
0.0537307709,
0.0033038601,
0.0082549453,
0.0443916135,
-0.0895071104,
-0.0034546072,
-0.0341778547,
0.0099388966,
-0.0131691182,
-0.0291342959,
-0.0031019663,
0.0554148406,
-0.0044788471,
0.0002630257,
0.0465399325,
0.0213071797,
-0.0257440601,
0.038070526,
0.0003521729,
-0.02582944,
0.0337258764,
0.0796004906,
0.0114170574,
-0.0424272418,
-0.0288045313,
-0.0303477012,
0.0051885643,
-0.0783847421,
0.0101656644,
-0.0235596709,
-0.0145741096,
-0.0206471458,
-0.0827482119,
-0.0461923368,
0.0409138426,
0.0340793841,
0.0301871467,
-0.032823436,
-0.0031961824,
0.0277956687,
-0.0645850599,
0.0241643228,
-0.005352451,
0.0301881023,
-0.0021559461,
0.0229093041,
0.0122136613,
-0.0124560622,
-0.0050072391,
0.0786513984,
-0.0635665953,
-0.0476765931,
0.0065999306,
0.0227905456,
0.016719725,
0.0561324432,
-0.037100438,
-0.0131925615,
0.0032958218,
0.0076708188,
-0.0302892905,
0.0032518047,
0.0606544614,
0.0043818853,
-0.0256928522,
0.0656800121,
-0.010415405,
0.0038717168,
-0.0103026899,
0.0522465147,
-0.005558739,
-0.0690582022,
0.0204657242,
0.0119168665,
-0.0102594653,
-0.0748353973,
-0.0140292598,
-0.0416591018,
0.0306867026,
-0.0228667054,
-0.0179176405,
-0.0351681709,
0.0009096627,
0.0062198979,
0.0092250938,
-0.0006912046,
0.001841425,
-0.0224648826,
0.0064604897,
-0.0306033269,
0.0143763516,
0.0462059006,
0.0336745828,
-0.0364650488,
0.0318179727,
-0.0051199705,
0.0107702175,
-0.0077796183,
0.0334960222,
-0.0454318449,
0.0121421479,
0.0032917866,
-0.0153290592,
0.0046545737,
0.0329974666,
-0.009235098,
0.097001262,
-0.0262548644,
0.0501002558,
0.0761986673,
-0.0393440276,
0.138384521,
-0.0396541245,
-0.0197157636,
0.0154242031,
0.0458382368,
-0.0052393381,
-0.0256792754,
-0.03949669,
-0.0026741032,
0.0056046983,
0.0041999132,
0.0326411575,
-0.0207263306,
0.0246953089,
0.0360025056,
-0.0254574269,
-0.0457279384,
-0.0166634843,
-0.035760507,
-0.0408763848,
-0.0001345217,
-0.020658724,
-0.0483558811,
-0.0273463074,
0.0086700395,
0.0133640626,
-0.0107303606,
-0.0005723184,
0.0113570429,
0.0698694363,
-0.0143582374,
-0.0181191768,
-0.0505306534,
0.004462006,
-0.0027743129,
-0.0131807001,
-0.0376435556,
-5.769585617e-33,
-0.0354357064,
-0.0075372877,
-0.0397452712,
0.0094488766,
-0.0190586597,
0.0326189511,
-0.0518943518,
-0.03995784,
0.0372228697,
0.0140268775,
-0.0053476123,
-0.0047596232,
0.0405149087,
0.0120197367,
0.0292121135,
-0.0021774042,
0.0552357808,
0.0241320506,
-0.0441728346,
0.0086329198,
0.0581272356,
0.0068802666,
0.0765615851,
-0.0927780941,
0.0731660575,
-0.0096062701,
-0.0498372763,
0.0382616743,
0.0039915335,
0.03677487,
0.0240807161,
0.0372607708,
0.0012167661,
-0.0404424071,
-0.0032682756,
0.0232935231,
-0.1216478571,
0.0025293543,
0.0399337895,
0.04508093,
-0.0110982992,
-0.0577812865,
0.0320562907,
-0.035883572,
-0.0199302938,
0.0244423803,
0.0263259374,
-0.0336968303,
0.0538843609,
-0.0007028909,
-0.0611834303,
0.0116404193,
-0.0277295318,
-0.0077100131,
0.0426330864,
0.051898472,
-0.0031061021,
-0.0119791804,
-0.0759142265,
0.0195075627,
-0.0684490651,
0.007540728,
0.0483432189,
-0.022895867,
0.005710966,
0.0190663654,
-0.0093387952,
0.021739101,
0.0283439048,
-0.0186342597,
0.0341207385,
-0.0059537459,
0.0473631397,
0.0861488804,
0.0068493383,
0.0151036363,
-0.0742567852,
0.0156626757,
0.0290126,
0.0204940513,
0.0024844424,
-0.0144985961,
-0.0549629107,
-0.0042743194,
-0.0241146963,
-0.0766593143,
-0.000233496,
-0.0089432951,
0.0090956455,
-0.0063971831,
-0.0506930687,
0.0209289603,
0.0492128767,
-0.012549934,
0.0009611988,
-0.0159186218,
-0.0188520942,
0.0039727432,
0.0064711133,
0.0599104017,
-0.0021504688,
-0.0040643052,
0.0239359476,
0.0451077074,
0.0447068401,
-0.0225342289,
0.0525387563,
0.0132542625,
-0.0303852186,
0.0036999001,
-0.0579894595,
0.0221219435,
-0.116473265,
0.0299271978,
-0.0131126419,
0.0393126309,
0.0087069077,
0.0071116202,
0.0557405241,
0.0350030214,
-0.0382896289,
-0.0226270687,
0.0050459704,
0.0341506489,
-0.0319044441,
0.0179115459,
0.0230500288,
0.0016776565,
0.03465252,
-0.0320647918,
0.0115471324,
-0.0125009827,
2.608e-7,
0.051396843,
0.0566041581,
0.0345993638,
0.0043432666,
0.0183504932,
0.0073889177,
-0.0316462032,
0.0386130698,
0.0390446484,
0.0183242559,
0.0407987833,
-0.0003131941,
0.0705727786,
0.0379152633,
-0.1009259,
-0.0136743197,
-0.0268250164,
0.0014036002,
-0.0326037966,
0.0342197865,
0.0346046463,
0.0618989579,
0.0294454787,
0.0058500296,
-0.0581208095,
-0.0100971973,
0.0356128998,
-0.0357886516,
-0.0114487726,
0.0233029854,
0.0109897275,
0.020414371,
-0.0109699843,
0.0315383375,
-0.0094155064,
0.0255266074,
0.0487422682,
0.0686604083,
0.0255846009,
-0.0145817231,
-0.0125053758,
-0.023162283,
0.0027634718,
-0.0636207387,
0.0601613596,
-0.0245529059,
-0.0024830627,
-0.0455585793,
0.0086350041,
0.0183858648,
0.048522383,
-0.0086345579,
-0.0254924558,
0.0510001332,
0.0401955917,
-0.0182118583,
-0.0495676287,
-0.0532860607,
-0.0675648227,
0.0156436898,
-0.010288123,
-0.0325632021,
0.0089877974,
0.0198929086,
-0.0361326523,
-0.0571581088,
0.0087319789,
2.506599588e-34,
0.0228790268,
-0.0023588929,
-0.0066457354,
-0.0090911696,
0.0012509763,
-0.0178354923,
-0.0109065063,
0.0185227636,
-0.0130047277,
-0.0060335547,
0.0026461021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02310v1 | Narrowing the Gap between Zero- and Few-shot Machine Translation by Matching Styles | 2023-11-04T03:18:45 | 2023-11-04T03:18:45 | Weiting Tan, Haoran Xu, Lingfeng Shen, Shuyue Stella Li, Kenton Murray, Philipp Koehn, Benjamin Van Durme, Yunmo Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models trained primarily in a monolingual setting have
demonstrated their ability to generalize to machine translation using zero- and
few-shot examples with in-context learning. However, even though zero-shot
translations are relatively good, there remains a discernible gap comparing
their performance with the few-shot setting. In this paper, we investigate the
factors contributing to this gap and find that this gap can largely be closed
(for about 70%) by matching the writing styles of the target corpus.
Additionally, we explore potential approaches to enhance zero-shot baselines
without the need for parallel demonstration examples, providing valuable
insights into how these methods contribute to improving translation metrics. | [
-0.0020274976,
0.0631318837,
0.0073461789,
0.0210597254,
-0.0537160933,
0.0147237871,
0.049607031,
0.0249958243,
-0.0749574527,
-0.0468902104,
-0.047856234,
-0.0891530141,
0.0358166471,
-0.0088263126,
0.0648767725,
-0.032887388,
-0.00169931,
0.0247153211,
-0.0289917886,
0.0061322819,
0.0450492762,
0.050241258,
-0.0002546591,
0.0273658726,
0.0165851265,
-0.0329502076,
-0.0084207831,
0.0782213807,
0.0466772392,
-0.0036872844,
0.0148475189,
0.0290298052,
0.0240618307,
0.0674450994,
0.0000015445,
-0.0313897878,
-0.0047729844,
0.0011958946,
0.0148086743,
0.0024865922,
0.0501022115,
-0.06073815,
-0.0153320655,
0.0264147539,
-0.0114837866,
-0.0622196756,
0.0554342642,
0.0113052772,
0.0446967185,
0.1142915562,
-0.0294544846,
-0.0450830236,
-0.0253341291,
-0.0575023182,
0.0180182271,
-0.0299242958,
-0.0107923048,
-0.044186864,
-0.023287721,
0.0131210536,
0.0007716572,
0.0199618358,
-0.0100663565,
-0.0174154285,
-0.0217960849,
0.0030718651,
-0.0989960134,
0.0177934766,
0.0090997051,
0.0739254579,
-0.0324472412,
-0.0495814793,
-0.0127858566,
-0.0174037125,
-0.0052341935,
-0.0348452292,
-0.0448784865,
-0.0053203334,
-0.0084455656,
0.0066051786,
-0.0031827749,
0.028271433,
0.0331257395,
-0.0219987389,
-0.0209288094,
-0.0249449648,
0.0318541415,
-0.0292287562,
-0.0233487561,
0.0050579524,
-0.0119032236,
-0.0292763859,
-0.0005946446,
0.0121176224,
0.0237179883,
-0.0020879309,
-0.0604318455,
-0.0517317839,
0.0124084316,
-0.0339392535,
0.0784942061,
0.0703857169,
0.0300035756,
0.0295575485,
-0.0210030172,
0.043329183,
0.0067260088,
-0.0078111091,
-0.0604008064,
-0.0008073929,
-0.054349497,
0.0289995726,
-0.0569985397,
-0.048249647,
0.0151838306,
-0.0021881566,
-0.0103451861,
0.0219835415,
0.0158256292,
0.002626165,
-0.0116936918,
-0.0327607729,
-0.0688140094,
-0.0289940815,
0.0563669465,
0.0653014928,
0.002570719,
-0.0042821839,
-0.0044823843,
-0.0577817336,
-0.0304388646,
0.0183592122,
0.0304531623,
-0.0394825228,
-0.0040706065,
0.0369226858,
-0.0146263372,
-0.0485613272,
0.0078630261,
0.0100815194,
-0.0188311469,
-0.0647890046,
-0.0174908824,
-0.0597741343,
0.015577428,
0.0105644353,
0.0229751989,
-0.0171965957,
-0.0090572052,
0.0233219787,
-0.0180844292,
0.0595283732,
0.0414419845,
-0.012352244,
0.001882595,
-0.0093327155,
-0.0061132112,
0.0892675892,
0.0287107583,
0.0066405255,
0.0091475891,
0.0085591981,
-0.0015419796,
0.0655345619,
0.0380898379,
0.0710733756,
-0.0444086455,
-0.0198377427,
0.0293232314,
0.0494822524,
0.0534610152,
-0.0006328294,
-0.019125415,
0.0221777856,
0.0836938322,
-0.0029132867,
0.0391078182,
0.0007838211,
0.0620197169,
0.0031099559,
-0.0042539942,
0.0349010192,
-0.001055597,
-0.0016552956,
0.0040561054,
0.027538782,
0.0257404819,
0.0302765053,
-0.0517357811,
0.0111907562,
-0.01288791,
0.0131194778,
-0.0243255235,
-0.0215945616,
0.0091638044,
0.0450295247,
-0.0510528311,
-0.033513464,
-0.0017898022,
-0.049345836,
0.0074750287,
-0.0065826993,
-0.0395617597,
0.0670722127,
0.0626517311,
0.0253096018,
-0.0480965972,
-0.0170371979,
0.016111102,
0.0355675146,
0.0522524565,
-0.0056908568,
0.074481234,
-0.0374891572,
0.0041782786,
-0.0177825093,
0.026794415,
0.0161808841,
-0.0123866042,
0.0378749669,
0.0296726935,
-0.0472131968,
-0.0282636173,
0.0368656963,
-0.0283301156,
-0.051670637,
0.0581341125,
0.0150871631,
-0.0030684266,
-0.011070055,
-0.0526349545,
-0.0064153569,
-0.0123451995,
-0.0509163328,
0.0158287901,
0.0477071144,
-0.0243359506,
-0.0755447298,
-0.0066745616,
-0.0266989339,
-0.0070076426,
-0.0150264073,
-0.0431244709,
-0.0527368225,
-0.026975343,
-0.0034444658,
0.0209967736,
-0.032521423,
0.0312568285,
-0.0077025737,
0.0007717361,
-0.049501095,
0.0043411157,
0.0390876345,
0.0028147358,
-0.0178788472,
-0.0242512077,
0.0113150226,
-0.0241928231,
-0.0284936484,
-0.0060127764,
0.026019156,
0.0294625498,
0.0221920181,
0.0252464637,
-0.0159576964,
-0.0108660804,
-0.086253956,
0.0274836682,
-0.0499982536,
0.0398056693,
0.0618338101,
0.0408136472,
-0.0186382905,
-0.0098489439,
-0.0427860543,
0.0101131778,
-0.0096220812,
0.0184052419,
0.062151216,
0.0023735235,
0.0101314299,
-0.0278173294,
-0.0031117648,
-0.0197456144,
0.0516619459,
-0.013909325,
0.0303151757,
-0.0393088721,
0.04955348,
-0.0021086382,
-0.0244687665,
0.015213836,
-0.0504407994,
0.0034235881,
-0.0274259541,
0.0328458659,
0.0535647795,
0.0010374113,
-0.0213908199,
0.0252800751,
0.0156709161,
-0.0507026128,
-0.0272321049,
-0.0085980324,
-0.00742287,
0.0038054739,
-0.0503193997,
0.0149513315,
0.0235117394,
0.0145832878,
-0.0131094558,
-0.0640338734,
0.0168957803,
0.039528206,
0.0065155136,
-0.0138072679,
0.0274924748,
0.0142675806,
0.0206769984,
-0.0286785085,
-0.0361663327,
0.0574199855,
-0.0401444398,
-0.0104323979,
0.0016563338,
0.0156984348,
-0.0531279258,
0.0332603566,
-0.0054258723,
0.0220321845,
-0.0166160632,
-0.0027743313,
-0.0235928465,
0.0089690397,
0.0304775666,
0.0114561133,
0.029919574,
-0.0417944379,
0.0041750213,
-0.0293593444,
-0.029660454,
-0.0188401248,
-0.052861385,
-0.0048683845,
0.0017735935,
-0.0255907234,
-0.0096414229,
-0.035178449,
0.0006757296,
-0.0043732114,
0.1001418605,
-0.0414124466,
-0.0195677336,
-0.0160728227,
0.0269645844,
0.0086033447,
-0.0562542789,
-0.052960366,
-0.0519329756,
0.0334290564,
0.0044644433,
0.0373811238,
0.0404585972,
-0.0338036194,
-0.0367175788,
0.0468064174,
-0.0304867905,
-0.0303047318,
0.0075113364,
0.0611542389,
-0.0409586467,
-0.0276250746,
0.1137198806,
0.0247101281,
-0.0513519906,
-0.0198134053,
-0.0172626954,
0.0499145985,
0.0171771981,
0.030257931,
-0.0925219953,
-0.0341427624,
0.0001971724,
0.0137397656,
0.0119109405,
0.0295642149,
-0.0465192497,
-0.1007351428,
0.0070590265,
0.0508826524,
-0.0873510614,
-0.0051639485,
-0.0084496858,
0.0112355519,
-0.0393622704,
0.0015768621,
-0.0108530568,
-0.0061244913,
0.0017989294,
0.01123932,
0.0280396212,
-0.0805975497,
-0.0097350851,
-0.0612641834,
0.0101867635,
0.0546267293,
0.0479000174,
0.0094574448,
-0.0037202297,
-0.0077605932,
-0.0268334299,
0.00201262,
0.0051520923,
0.0517880283,
-0.01456038,
-0.0141877905,
0.0252928101,
0.0211744159,
-0.0108168339,
0.0300473459,
0.0021772156,
-0.001538804,
-0.0151851084,
-0.0001230155,
-0.0142364064,
-0.0275150351,
0.031664528,
0.0474188104,
0.0479648784,
-0.0718159899,
-0.0170956906,
-0.0421950035,
-0.0022325257,
-0.0901757926,
-0.0209411345,
-0.0129232565,
-0.0292984974,
-0.0407773852,
-0.0854742825,
-0.0400964357,
-0.0035127811,
0.0854429603,
0.0194465797,
-0.006853316,
-0.0386153944,
-0.0194368828,
-0.0189941861,
-0.015769124,
-0.0262498111,
0.0364243463,
-0.032289587,
0.0301733073,
0.0127899675,
-0.0329363272,
0.0201093368,
0.0014544952,
-0.101869829,
-0.0794198066,
-0.0083999187,
0.0381219462,
0.0143226143,
0.0190590695,
-0.01789991,
-0.0539304614,
0.0422137417,
0.0748266205,
0.0453770868,
0.0033099402,
0.0229881424,
-0.0330884941,
-0.0013057441,
0.056880448,
-0.0014124825,
0.0113999275,
0.0236385763,
0.0438314304,
-0.0207376499,
-0.0081930486,
0.0208202451,
-0.0098701138,
0.0153018236,
-0.0479376428,
-0.0091927089,
0.0169610102,
0.0181684494,
-0.025254691,
-0.0239837673,
-0.0228402745,
-0.0458540283,
0.0409414507,
0.0038292389,
-0.0173890609,
0.0331441239,
-0.0363397859,
0.0463331081,
-0.05715812,
-0.0175091214,
0.0229737032,
0.0426193438,
-0.0130142309,
0.0304106381,
-0.0111750821,
0.0288777687,
-0.0060842549,
0.0245145466,
-0.0395242237,
0.0222233851,
0.0128195649,
0.0537870191,
0.0006926464,
0.0278246347,
-0.060090743,
0.0376161262,
-0.0220786873,
-0.0126292985,
0.0912914947,
-0.0338659324,
0.1001453102,
0.0064038937,
-0.0133964252,
-0.0181916431,
0.0311236028,
-0.0043989397,
-0.0354395323,
-0.0423651338,
0.0156897884,
0.0186115019,
0.0221157093,
0.0825596005,
0.0058235205,
0.034279231,
0.0341774672,
0.0103375921,
-0.0028180941,
0.0178326182,
0.0560674816,
0.0000377043,
0.044390142,
-0.0425000489,
-0.0605002232,
-0.0372898988,
0.0341150761,
-0.0114354007,
0.001708116,
-0.003176146,
0.0015840117,
0.048160173,
-0.0395912305,
0.0235552825,
-0.0676870123,
-0.0009516391,
0.0104194544,
-0.0189526025,
-0.0483529381,
-5.598391395e-33,
-0.0235900227,
-0.0123967966,
-0.0158597827,
-0.0156285614,
-0.0091169076,
-0.0033176902,
-0.0289374664,
-0.0265516099,
-0.009819773,
0.0107956398,
-0.0504781976,
-0.0088688834,
0.0043611526,
0.0063804328,
0.0045632031,
0.0428169742,
0.0665693358,
0.0038789676,
-0.0745756552,
0.0141872279,
0.0390862636,
0.016318161,
0.0881372243,
-0.0166166015,
0.0296144914,
-0.0617908724,
-0.0416033417,
-0.0119483583,
0.0398838297,
0.0075131059,
0.0249712281,
0.0174681749,
0.0224811658,
-0.0114756124,
-0.026276743,
-0.0184959397,
-0.0410564616,
0.0175292213,
0.0257887226,
0.0333171412,
0.0191581212,
-0.0382589959,
0.0360566564,
-0.0435888208,
0.0077766976,
-0.0176706221,
0.0178000964,
-0.0175460521,
-0.0214144904,
-0.0288168825,
-0.0688973665,
0.0114106964,
-0.0083310166,
-0.036135301,
0.0187316742,
0.0579804629,
-0.004651601,
0.0192010254,
-0.0769370422,
0.0275397412,
-0.0540028773,
0.0541956872,
0.0375520177,
-0.005666736,
-0.0200286489,
0.0306991003,
-0.0188801587,
0.0415694825,
0.0052102376,
-0.0120108882,
0.0679482669,
-0.0273289867,
0.0096880822,
0.0855521113,
0.1041217372,
0.0129213147,
-0.0475475751,
0.0471645147,
0.0177280344,
-0.0107254339,
0.0094755944,
0.0104663689,
-0.032056585,
-0.0088011865,
-0.0560930781,
-0.0779288262,
-0.0343758091,
-0.0127271935,
-0.0091185663,
0.0047655473,
-0.012720718,
0.015158847,
0.0739840344,
-0.0107273152,
-0.0157841574,
0.0247167684,
-0.0611492619,
0.0248652119,
-0.0122667309,
0.0239654761,
-0.0171339139,
-0.0316020995,
0.0362519249,
0.0822992027,
0.0203458909,
-0.0028202406,
0.1115361676,
0.0438503474,
-0.0855856463,
-0.0098026991,
-0.0277779475,
-0.0071609453,
-0.028082842,
0.0081078243,
0.0237270985,
0.004414435,
0.0087531814,
0.0410240069,
0.0299282838,
-0.0444211029,
-0.0068409308,
-0.0063173217,
-0.0177459028,
0.0241454579,
-0.0350539796,
0.0069743041,
-0.0006870596,
-0.0099669946,
0.034871649,
-0.0512301177,
-0.0180734936,
-0.0101658851,
2.25e-7,
0.033068236,
0.0428592302,
0.002170796,
0.0444032028,
0.0294403266,
0.0361518934,
-0.0221264381,
0.0647401437,
-0.0097247837,
0.0601359792,
0.0373797491,
0.0153946932,
0.0820938125,
0.0109163877,
-0.0828255564,
0.0118957367,
-0.0449081995,
0.0443993919,
-0.0515032597,
-0.0089730062,
0.0352490954,
0.0757248178,
0.0027777469,
-0.0007225481,
0.043026302,
-0.0336189941,
0.1087990478,
0.0207811669,
-0.0174285099,
0.0201834701,
0.0125310607,
0.0013982994,
-0.0364708677,
-0.0049051954,
-0.0353569947,
0.0172913447,
0.0069505181,
0.0731621608,
-0.0041756169,
0.0075828228,
-0.0014474019,
0.0080412189,
-0.0079802545,
-0.0240152124,
0.0613794439,
-0.024487434,
-0.025353495,
-0.0270810183,
-0.0282102283,
0.039682854,
0.050949201,
0.0010352881,
-0.0448113233,
0.0408809111,
0.0455372296,
-0.0234357752,
-0.0363587365,
-0.0408440754,
-0.060291037,
-0.0160809066,
0.0205988809,
0.0050394163,
-0.003293212,
-0.0036023874,
0.0152135193,
-0.0364196338,
0.0076376391,
2.032468763e-34,
0.0476187356,
-0.0275505483,
0.0091508208,
-0.0035524459,
-0.02340132,
-0.0097647281,
0.0049744458,
0.0030943735,
0.009901749,
-0.0435585193,
-0.0157714393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02294v1 | LLMs grasp morality in concept | 2023-11-04T01:37:41 | 2023-11-04T01:37:41 | Mark Pock, Andre Ye, Jared Moore | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Work in AI ethics and fairness has made much progress in regulating LLMs to
reflect certain values, such as fairness, truth, and diversity. However, it has
taken the problem of how LLMs might 'mean' anything at all for granted. Without
addressing this, it is not clear what imbuing LLMs with such values even means.
In response, we provide a general theory of meaning that extends beyond humans.
We use this theory to explicate the precise nature of LLMs as meaning-agents.
We suggest that the LLM, by virtue of its position as a meaning-agent, already
grasps the constructions of human society (e.g. morality, gender, and race) in
concept. Consequently, under certain ethical frameworks, currently popular
methods for model alignment are limited at best and counterproductive at worst.
Moreover, unaligned models may help us better develop our moral and social
philosophy. | [
0.0212387368,
0.0611361749,
-0.0419799984,
0.0103705544,
-0.069131583,
0.02049339,
-0.0095277559,
-0.0043699415,
0.008231096,
-0.0037557804,
-0.0207287017,
-0.0169001259,
-0.0163295195,
-0.0254445914,
-0.0091181071,
-0.0020293414,
0.0299585517,
0.0114198802,
0.0218885634,
-0.0244398527,
-0.0474354886,
0.0115008084,
0.0602439269,
-0.0238160603,
-0.0032096445,
0.0135814017,
-0.022000473,
0.0179823227,
0.0479902141,
0.0016658498,
-0.0381842703,
-0.0267925784,
0.0585710779,
0.0052536265,
0.0000019348,
-0.0838846639,
0.008265934,
0.0218558926,
-0.0184924938,
-0.0511661172,
0.0456696935,
0.0060130861,
-0.0039462978,
-0.0235511363,
-0.0383235104,
0.1255391389,
0.0239822548,
-0.0007260414,
-0.0056307875,
0.0552365333,
0.0170335956,
0.000857275,
0.0048342627,
-0.0005997968,
0.0244812686,
-0.0297258832,
0.0439347699,
0.0235212464,
-0.0065644132,
-0.0339062065,
-0.0365837291,
0.0128463721,
0.0208900962,
0.0308206528,
0.0020088693,
-0.0501685366,
0.0375840478,
-0.0568243302,
0.0182283409,
0.0202485602,
0.070399709,
0.0341288298,
0.0398137122,
0.0281455442,
0.0372025035,
-0.0137058785,
0.0262143873,
0.0572332665,
-0.0048674918,
0.0213632304,
0.0594496429,
0.0287566036,
0.035820581,
0.0345792137,
-0.01854885,
0.0632182956,
-0.0171024278,
0.0006928508,
-0.0259036552,
0.0054370645,
0.0103949253,
-0.0289997384,
-0.0116058979,
0.0511196069,
-0.0270700827,
0.0299210642,
-0.0140737453,
0.0485880189,
0.0311351717,
-0.0448282287,
0.0224388167,
0.0431038775,
0.010751606,
0.0337224975,
0.0416737907,
0.0257647764,
-0.0030057151,
0.0744388998,
-0.0606948659,
-0.0063672196,
0.0327550694,
0.0056099454,
0.0296864416,
0.0316738822,
0.0104364827,
0.0575704165,
0.0166806206,
0.0392108187,
-0.0840209648,
0.0279133357,
-0.0250762347,
-0.0022574544,
-0.0054980675,
-0.0183833558,
-0.0682972521,
-0.0674252212,
-0.0555737764,
0.0074948431,
-0.0361230783,
-0.0541993715,
0.0032829007,
-0.0224593356,
-0.0295529217,
-0.0006478179,
0.0290858205,
0.1152882352,
0.0502364375,
-0.0408542678,
-0.0148666045,
-0.0186456088,
0.021299459,
-0.0572653748,
0.0039636758,
0.0061827959,
0.0328882262,
0.0005717623,
-0.0128708435,
-0.0765690506,
0.0016228561,
-0.0051932498,
0.0071792635,
0.0439607166,
-0.0007959391,
0.0217440333,
0.0132725723,
0.0427119732,
-0.0427087024,
0.0440269485,
0.0253843833,
0.0280496813,
0.0299236625,
0.0267274342,
0.0145494314,
-0.0155538181,
-0.0302474126,
0.0178663861,
-0.0251887944,
0.0340889506,
-0.052832596,
0.0534318686,
0.0262469165,
0.0041029328,
0.0103465468,
-0.0033456031,
0.013685111,
0.0855867416,
0.0295044687,
0.0289676283,
0.0213523451,
-0.054845769,
-0.0226645526,
0.0298901331,
-0.0955985412,
0.0344855823,
-0.0068487846,
-0.0116569176,
-0.0790101662,
0.0495913848,
-0.0292585418,
-0.0515666306,
0.0003940726,
-0.0224751271,
0.003539941,
0.0221732724,
-0.0062035318,
-0.037966799,
0.0348626487,
-0.0532546751,
0.0079434719,
-0.0149768842,
0.043672353,
-0.1013046354,
0.0644181296,
0.0751309842,
0.0110865338,
-0.0424923152,
-0.0501530804,
-0.0075502708,
-0.0363079309,
0.0162821803,
0.0208408795,
-0.0191945415,
-0.0306716543,
-0.0493444353,
-0.036486797,
-0.0327937566,
0.0029099828,
0.0347682461,
-0.0533013381,
-0.0079082986,
-0.0042359224,
-0.0236263797,
-0.0239275452,
0.0432160161,
-0.0256135184,
0.0153818773,
-0.0506085418,
0.0109616779,
0.0218591429,
0.01082836,
-0.0007596722,
-0.0057775741,
0.0216622297,
0.0133411577,
-0.0082395012,
0.0153915966,
-0.0196331199,
0.0820069537,
0.0168195385,
-0.0870844051,
-0.031205358,
0.0462096184,
0.0125925783,
0.0371330194,
-0.0171583593,
-0.0093187699,
0.0032667271,
-0.0306320302,
0.0177748613,
-0.0527971089,
-0.015568723,
-0.0063195177,
0.0356222801,
-0.0192040149,
-0.0570391305,
0.0008855297,
-0.0198486242,
0.0398717262,
-0.0131081762,
-0.016103195,
0.0156081878,
-0.0017584424,
0.0400759317,
0.0364882722,
0.037889082,
-0.0323041156,
-0.0289705582,
-0.0318523236,
0.00866256,
0.0319831632,
-0.0267659351,
-0.009341917,
-0.0163172521,
-0.0107852342,
0.0275588781,
-0.0313515216,
0.0208046213,
0.0245839469,
-0.0002361038,
0.0424645655,
-0.0270815697,
-0.0380939394,
-0.0145204915,
0.0288005266,
-0.044009801,
-0.0334404297,
0.0113578187,
0.0022928338,
-0.0236606486,
0.0204954408,
-0.0997248814,
-0.0150043471,
-0.0013377373,
-0.0243906043,
0.007241731,
0.0661418065,
-0.0214839149,
0.0803413317,
0.0524040461,
0.0885522664,
0.0607286803,
0.0570369102,
-0.0326503739,
-0.0313107707,
0.0096724797,
0.0030249024,
-0.0163569897,
-0.0645394027,
-0.0392899141,
0.0510929413,
-0.009468128,
0.0209752191,
-0.0297728013,
0.0741618127,
-0.028630143,
-0.0708177388,
0.0042533842,
-0.0510089807,
-0.0151629848,
0.0568237118,
-0.0271480698,
-0.0383640677,
0.0446517915,
0.0631651282,
0.0359420851,
0.0486413315,
-0.0138981212,
-0.0381311923,
0.0411161296,
-0.0116251269,
0.0294519961,
-0.0282301474,
0.0018447276,
-0.0486614369,
-0.0292081516,
0.0135862147,
-0.0630441085,
0.0685290024,
-0.0421720892,
0.0007316606,
-0.0288960319,
-0.0367653221,
-0.0560492314,
0.0106162578,
-0.0224183034,
-0.0073880157,
-0.0360724889,
-0.000086503,
0.0019718255,
-0.0186842829,
0.0320895985,
-0.0684285238,
0.0002015619,
0.0019430107,
-0.023461774,
-0.1084458306,
0.0080683716,
0.0299719218,
0.0811468959,
-0.0092133442,
0.0359499753,
0.0211651307,
-0.0558347553,
-0.0133897578,
0.001684114,
0.0289834924,
0.0154852001,
-0.0213193689,
0.0108075365,
0.0126802474,
0.0319660567,
0.0189369898,
0.0044995537,
0.0822915882,
-0.0241812561,
-0.0257864669,
0.0311180241,
-0.0611470826,
-0.0638369024,
0.0264176279,
-0.0007429791,
-0.0641226098,
0.023855729,
0.0048138699,
0.0080535589,
-0.077140227,
-0.0776795819,
0.0113391122,
-0.0116447387,
0.0243684892,
0.0376601517,
-0.0136764562,
-0.0590904467,
0.023610536,
0.0124042155,
-0.0358635411,
0.0224355627,
0.0172064677,
0.0298346449,
-0.0267959554,
-0.0089601763,
0.0636921674,
0.0213322155,
0.0091764126,
-0.0779333785,
0.0603008009,
0.0793811902,
0.0556416027,
-0.0385856628,
-0.0443949401,
-0.0269487295,
0.0395283885,
0.0142125767,
0.0313790627,
-0.0556240529,
-0.0472017601,
0.0000517354,
-0.0514167994,
-0.0009387437,
0.0146459769,
-0.0124705834,
0.0081109647,
0.0479403958,
-0.0362786874,
-0.049520582,
-0.0355785787,
-0.038770359,
-0.0289352201,
0.06614393,
-0.013102103,
-0.026190998,
0.0273258574,
-0.0368124656,
-0.027431041,
0.0445184112,
-0.0487068892,
0.002805274,
-0.0321644768,
-0.0130143585,
-0.0063886638,
-0.0633593053,
-0.021025965,
0.0094422372,
0.0525927432,
-0.08487501,
-0.0128479805,
-0.0112575814,
-0.0209622793,
-0.0104329316,
-0.0369085148,
0.0005588197,
0.0315091126,
-0.0269835833,
-0.0143116536,
-0.0712464452,
0.0250015073,
-0.0440937579,
0.0242214669,
-0.0122079998,
0.0666328818,
0.0543136969,
0.0313118249,
0.0222452134,
-0.0020546338,
0.0584362447,
0.0350789726,
0.0411520898,
-0.0129273161,
0.0864440873,
0.0193471853,
0.0443654656,
-0.0275693759,
0.009177207,
-0.0475125201,
0.0080504743,
0.011053253,
-0.0092376648,
-0.0528427958,
-0.0439940393,
0.0365755819,
0.0279674381,
-0.0442291535,
-0.009296651,
-0.004582976,
-0.0013803046,
-0.0503479093,
0.018471038,
-0.0213258751,
-0.0001396959,
-0.0454078093,
0.0204401184,
0.0147752166,
-0.0025488378,
0.0072380458,
-0.0137611646,
-0.0221432634,
0.0001134618,
0.0066405851,
-0.0192119479,
0.0268329885,
-0.0450021029,
0.0254598223,
-0.0121210339,
0.0611988232,
-0.037284635,
0.0140161365,
0.0122960862,
0.0025513431,
0.0211201534,
0.0406453684,
0.0033473503,
0.0466022752,
-0.0709864274,
-0.0678282231,
0.0151011795,
0.0024226534,
0.0081960112,
0.0357281975,
-0.0208174642,
-0.0300424863,
0.015064599,
0.0100546274,
0.010903161,
0.0172247197,
0.0100426208,
0.0026655111,
0.0091677746,
0.0126857534,
-0.0410922281,
-0.0195454061,
-0.0758939013,
0.0938229039,
-0.0375201777,
-0.0009163767,
-0.0059998655,
-0.0681753084,
0.0398108102,
-0.069067575,
0.0035326763,
-0.0458635166,
-0.0752774999,
-0.0296055637,
0.0011393178,
0.0458901487,
0.0235063192,
-0.0314331837,
-0.0234265234,
0.0195703432,
-0.0204609092,
-0.0184280258,
-0.0134153133,
-0.021701606,
-0.0291996785,
0.0330479965,
-0.0053699859,
-5.126715104e-33,
-0.0414487049,
-0.0248951335,
0.0199579615,
-0.0061109387,
-0.0601832457,
-0.055682037,
0.02221312,
-0.0144878849,
-0.0596687309,
-0.002229634,
0.0078231581,
0.0170340147,
-0.0020496012,
-0.058938127,
0.0363311693,
-0.0739575103,
-0.0006992786,
-0.000917091,
0.0033754765,
-0.0274587795,
-0.0553838722,
-0.0062536653,
0.0132526029,
-0.0471434928,
0.0547952689,
0.0138565116,
-0.0285949018,
0.017373303,
-0.0358472466,
0.0017638044,
0.0098444019,
0.0182584282,
0.0382676609,
0.0322542749,
0.001471041,
0.0173185728,
0.0198416281,
-0.0265459344,
0.0601170696,
-0.0177667979,
-0.0201418269,
-0.0769729614,
-0.0063822553,
0.0056869723,
-0.0671532303,
-0.0004524938,
0.043982394,
-0.028713055,
0.0470287912,
-0.0079801893,
-0.0443686619,
-0.017825719,
-0.0273731705,
-0.021191733,
-0.0246183891,
-0.030384494,
0.0067555001,
0.046336744,
-0.002718762,
0.0350302644,
-0.0238839649,
-0.0651366338,
0.0450972058,
0.0054120566,
0.0335900374,
0.0603495985,
0.0176387113,
0.0261477828,
-0.0485072955,
-0.0447996967,
-0.0074210251,
0.0464406423,
0.0051379856,
0.0411016047,
-0.0406125635,
0.0003044422,
-0.0129045341,
0.026684111,
0.0098744668,
0.0065576239,
0.0011285249,
0.0098260473,
-0.0328828506,
0.0314020626,
-0.0134336594,
-0.0803918839,
-0.0133880451,
-0.0214275606,
-0.0071442076,
-0.036955934,
-0.0265285913,
-0.0191396531,
-0.003955082,
-0.0740469247,
0.0436097123,
-0.0103548551,
0.0349938497,
-0.0253658611,
0.0224384144,
-0.0068372777,
-0.0004609553,
-0.0509391129,
-0.0262702964,
0.0048002298,
0.0451973081,
0.027138656,
-0.0207052976,
0.0294428654,
0.0276907627,
-0.005681626,
-0.0325043723,
0.0113348085,
0.0375802256,
-0.0795124918,
0.0137776081,
0.0040084911,
0.0130669679,
0.0069633294,
0.021285329,
-0.0056251474,
-0.0387649126,
0.0318303034,
-0.0435877144,
0.0360141546,
-0.0303363707,
-0.0001101338,
-0.00738985,
0.0780899301,
0.0484119318,
-0.0184482932,
-0.0168596357,
-0.0192241613,
2.654e-7,
0.0038149108,
-0.0292304046,
0.0243166145,
0.0579132736,
-0.0268467143,
0.0645892993,
-0.0071869465,
0.0926792622,
0.010481989,
-0.0568266511,
0.0577558428,
0.0251391772,
-0.0014355937,
-0.0408418402,
0.0395295508,
0.0213775299,
0.0048550251,
-0.0018417495,
-0.0014483238,
0.0783903152,
0.0127488011,
0.011762077,
0.0395281501,
-0.0038736397,
0.0072420337,
0.0181746893,
0.002728848,
-0.0632319525,
0.0078043258,
0.0109032029,
0.0172630735,
-0.0104681952,
0.0073061371,
-0.0037909735,
0.0587201975,
0.0160211213,
-0.0126974415,
0.0524473749,
-0.0109132146,
-0.018522216,
-0.0406284817,
-0.0182739645,
-0.0016123076,
-0.0059078243,
0.0538617298,
0.0255459249,
-0.0273613352,
-0.0637978539,
0.0320323706,
-0.0076288744,
0.0036594376,
0.0136290938,
0.0143568963,
0.0016269812,
0.0253053047,
0.0041639735,
0.0248722769,
-0.0335491635,
0.0271371733,
-0.0362841785,
0.014246433,
-0.0755662769,
0.0206254572,
0.0875939354,
0.0407125391,
-0.0591867752,
-0.0184618123,
1.625053097e-34,
-0.0159046184,
-0.0049149324,
0.0090628108,
0.0409653224,
0.0263884738,
0.0432476252,
-0.0529821254,
0.0018778119,
0.0310093872,
0.0174537897,
-0.0160162654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02271v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02271v2 | FaMeSumm: Investigating and Improving Faithfulness of Medical Summarization | 2023-11-03T23:25:53 | 2023-11-08T22:54:33 | Nan Zhang, Yusen Zhang, Wu Guo, Prasenjit Mitra, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Summaries of medical text shall be faithful by being consistent and factual
with source inputs, which is an important but understudied topic for safety and
efficiency in healthcare. In this paper, we investigate and improve
faithfulness in summarization on a broad range of medical summarization tasks.
Our investigation reveals that current summarization models often produce
unfaithful outputs for medical input text. We then introduce FaMeSumm, a
framework to improve faithfulness by fine-tuning pre-trained language models
based on medical knowledge. FaMeSumm performs contrastive learning on designed
sets of faithful and unfaithful summaries, and it incorporates medical terms
and their contexts to encourage faithful generation of medical terms. We
conduct comprehensive experiments on three datasets in two languages: health
question and radiology report summarization datasets in English, and a
patient-doctor dialogue dataset in Chinese. Results demonstrate that FaMeSumm
is flexible and effective by delivering consistent improvements over mainstream
language models such as BART, T5, mT5, and PEGASUS, yielding state-of-the-art
performances on metrics for faithfulness and general quality. Human evaluation
by doctors also shows that FaMeSumm generates more faithful outputs. Our code
is available at https://github.com/psunlpgroup/FaMeSumm . | [
0.0687906444,
0.0635710806,
0.0340328515,
-0.0212674867,
-0.0169486292,
0.0113544473,
-0.0207792036,
0.0100076646,
-0.0191801209,
-0.0123891709,
-0.014323784,
-0.062510781,
0.0482318327,
0.0240476411,
0.0310730506,
-0.0980299935,
0.046005968,
0.0280727539,
-0.0248624161,
0.0016915194,
0.023561094,
0.0045032296,
-0.0127473054,
0.0494654179,
0.0035610981,
0.010285683,
0.0466216095,
0.00267329,
0.0630341396,
-0.0528963618,
0.0242067743,
0.0323800407,
-0.0321599692,
-0.0038716604,
0.0000018406,
-0.0367907956,
-0.0228004549,
0.0183554962,
0.012758242,
-0.0090561444,
0.0529674031,
-0.0932763442,
0.0146781448,
0.0313323997,
-0.0249161236,
-0.0158307236,
0.0188415069,
0.062625967,
0.0920896307,
0.0736994818,
-0.0033512113,
-0.0009933232,
0.0097699454,
-0.0273411218,
-0.01370914,
-0.0177740287,
0.0185289346,
0.0204700418,
0.0136801228,
-0.0092517463,
0.0110192951,
0.0333329029,
-0.008608426,
0.0290160533,
0.007757579,
0.0463108122,
-0.0329160802,
0.0113646202,
0.0251334943,
0.0745014846,
0.0186953992,
-0.0258498229,
0.0305877272,
0.0044849357,
-0.0261884946,
-0.0058466475,
-0.0598606765,
0.0374682285,
-0.0262214933,
0.0157869514,
0.0080464678,
0.019908946,
0.0069552702,
0.0311487857,
-0.0213130992,
-0.0389964506,
0.0094137453,
-0.0257658418,
-0.0422107019,
-0.0059121014,
-0.0350953341,
-0.0509674251,
0.0349767208,
0.0267665759,
-0.0648706406,
0.0008801377,
-0.0571605563,
-0.0509875976,
0.0880401582,
-0.0500141717,
-0.0285079535,
0.005547198,
-0.0183298942,
0.0284513719,
-0.0000389265,
0.0117505128,
0.0045332038,
0.0435709804,
-0.0673125833,
-0.0049359454,
-0.00761879,
-0.0054494007,
-0.0154696349,
0.0229714699,
-0.0083702896,
-0.0096156048,
-0.0887398645,
-0.0190321337,
-0.0071996637,
0.0229550768,
-0.0031970793,
0.0337799527,
-0.0393888876,
-0.0020279903,
0.0009791545,
-0.0009430973,
-0.0236513522,
0.0001525964,
0.0083869444,
-0.0040036025,
-0.0071711596,
0.02423588,
-0.0001571939,
0.0243457966,
0.0073871752,
0.025824517,
-0.0079450551,
0.0059410208,
0.0152085582,
-0.0436102226,
-0.0262752026,
-0.0090613998,
-0.0278457422,
-0.066858612,
0.0263762567,
-0.0061032418,
-0.00515649,
-0.0583383366,
0.0144346654,
0.0366034172,
-0.0732938796,
0.0389317945,
-0.053522855,
0.003885,
0.0100920117,
0.0421747118,
0.0090130921,
-0.0036896092,
0.0459608175,
-0.0236890949,
0.0079973117,
0.0141938748,
0.0099276453,
-0.0168004129,
0.027497625,
-0.0346827582,
0.0033673875,
-0.0010752671,
-0.0080302265,
0.0541357622,
0.001662286,
0.1282096058,
-0.0158284716,
0.0095323734,
0.038215097,
0.0328165032,
0.0036663385,
0.0011173302,
0.0176117532,
-0.0194794796,
0.011831441,
0.0654545501,
-0.0286532585,
0.0146013377,
0.008193884,
0.0536096804,
0.0631761029,
0.003630982,
-0.0258626025,
-0.045211859,
-0.0330765434,
-0.0014045979,
-0.0112748463,
-0.0255457256,
0.0173344817,
0.0091470452,
-0.0381251536,
0.0716532916,
0.0509623736,
-0.0490188934,
0.0111294277,
-0.0362164639,
0.0019399656,
0.0549369305,
0.0732657015,
-0.0362407193,
-0.0501593314,
-0.0114045711,
0.0088070231,
0.0243188255,
0.0477134064,
-0.0224760212,
-0.0026470502,
-0.0400417,
-0.0168446302,
0.0291771833,
0.0235388726,
-0.0307061598,
0.00337932,
0.0054199486,
0.0278636683,
-0.0048299083,
-0.0606503561,
0.0657262951,
-0.0468643159,
0.0020483662,
-0.0035682528,
-0.0326607563,
0.0135800028,
0.0175902452,
-0.0219565425,
0.0447071455,
0.0268173963,
-0.0219014622,
-0.0127528831,
0.0220773276,
-0.0770302564,
-0.04521548,
0.0368767269,
-0.0730140135,
0.019233942,
0.0072354581,
-0.0480516478,
-0.0454614162,
-0.0306207351,
-0.0586213879,
-0.019230755,
-0.0238261744,
0.0331598781,
0.0526245646,
-0.0100362161,
-0.0269909278,
0.0375424139,
-0.0371814296,
0.0110770445,
0.049483519,
-0.0204916187,
-0.0056219264,
-0.0149364267,
-0.0112446928,
-0.0000434497,
0.0221213121,
0.0268051568,
0.0212984215,
0.0309371967,
-0.0272594821,
-0.0416883826,
-0.1189040542,
0.003131777,
-0.0159009453,
-0.0064204745,
0.0596481226,
0.0308001749,
0.0133557944,
-0.0004829799,
-0.0555250421,
-0.0416016392,
0.0528232791,
0.0062211906,
0.0449127294,
0.0398250073,
0.0466624983,
-0.0541499592,
-0.004774244,
-0.0238321703,
0.0109844375,
0.011656085,
-0.0177465957,
-0.0148424748,
0.0081212223,
-0.054770831,
-0.0339815132,
0.0279880092,
-0.01573194,
0.010454135,
0.0151441535,
0.0305488817,
0.0133611308,
0.0652517825,
-0.0206630118,
0.0236935224,
0.0295660067,
-0.0089375181,
-0.0096278461,
-0.0419927947,
-0.0053790072,
0.049617257,
-0.0549250767,
0.0172684658,
0.0622781739,
0.0425866321,
0.0084057646,
-0.0252180621,
0.007739272,
-0.0113267228,
0.0221238807,
-0.0275221523,
0.0059913401,
-0.0488894917,
0.0308942143,
-0.0170323197,
-0.0024505802,
0.1065610498,
-0.0246766917,
0.053030815,
-0.069228217,
-0.0038300208,
-0.0424092487,
-0.0047010924,
-0.0145475939,
0.0319451131,
0.0266654678,
-0.0035619617,
-0.0299265925,
0.0116275502,
0.04549459,
-0.0649835691,
0.0852625892,
-0.0304535609,
0.0154533116,
-0.0035932492,
-0.0416864045,
-0.0545398556,
-0.0421801433,
-0.0052364897,
0.0161118358,
0.0167931914,
0.0237072073,
-0.0550620183,
0.0408710949,
-0.0032193861,
0.0959933773,
0.0075031458,
-0.009120469,
-0.0030331719,
0.0461783186,
0.0501214862,
-0.0007773864,
0.0349356979,
-0.0520500168,
0.0239878707,
0.0768069848,
0.0042512454,
0.0204778221,
0.0292939842,
-0.0219398998,
-0.0203962475,
-0.0455664471,
0.0080846325,
0.0151927201,
0.0391735397,
-0.056689322,
-0.0087422915,
0.0973091349,
0.0228217002,
-0.0195623264,
0.0289050918,
0.0153826987,
0.0059891944,
-0.0261097811,
-0.0075567872,
-0.0672147423,
-0.0257610511,
-0.0060822414,
0.0493477993,
0.0104033314,
-0.0373441763,
0.0142741408,
-0.0375151895,
-0.0030524295,
0.0277834646,
-0.0751992315,
-0.0562734827,
-0.025272619,
0.0016458564,
-0.0187730994,
0.037359979,
0.0210103635,
-0.0277917683,
0.0084060794,
0.0215565003,
-0.0735349953,
-0.0545566715,
-0.0213386901,
-0.0461000055,
0.0291332547,
0.0693465695,
0.0331398472,
-0.0087902192,
0.0065281587,
0.016789237,
-0.0272472929,
-0.0279054604,
0.0058048232,
0.0858568624,
0.0030257383,
-0.0064400635,
-0.0324492119,
0.0378440097,
0.0080861701,
-0.0319869891,
-0.001529804,
0.0034446074,
-0.0092319371,
-0.0294565409,
-0.0663196445,
0.081437476,
-0.0024757695,
0.0778236911,
0.0243569184,
0.0377464034,
-0.0136037869,
0.0012524752,
0.0395441689,
-0.0450298041,
-0.0197818913,
0.0191964731,
-0.0450099781,
-0.0037116348,
-0.1087459549,
-0.0438519269,
0.0189207364,
-0.0314229913,
-0.0058001196,
0.0043036398,
-0.0172447115,
-0.0086952373,
-0.0569087192,
0.0143229477,
-0.0001449398,
-0.0068580289,
-0.0400112197,
-0.0476860665,
0.0718158707,
-0.0102399662,
-0.0090365503,
0.0219306983,
-0.0351438858,
-0.0087514734,
-0.0221968647,
0.0747878179,
0.0170946997,
0.0460694171,
0.0154680759,
0.019359896,
0.0474560149,
0.0490383022,
-0.0256937481,
-0.0023814354,
0.0041304836,
-0.0137311788,
-0.0126682604,
0.0082473801,
-0.0389291234,
0.0180728938,
-0.0127280289,
0.0698027909,
-0.0187042691,
-0.0556144379,
0.0355436467,
0.0347210951,
-0.0033891075,
-0.0396702737,
0.0081029842,
-0.0272937194,
-0.0091663059,
-0.0075974264,
-0.0106736552,
-0.0327195302,
0.0453025289,
-0.0021459446,
0.0227810722,
-0.0208677351,
0.0319086723,
-0.0610130057,
-0.0219535884,
-0.0366053544,
-0.0002238934,
-0.0244801827,
-0.0091309212,
0.0018494899,
-0.0203321241,
-0.0469978712,
-0.0019016148,
-0.0176447835,
0.0160663389,
-0.0057122284,
0.0219441876,
0.0225276668,
0.0339174978,
0.0028505889,
0.0518501326,
-0.0606416017,
-0.0160287786,
-0.077193141,
0.0043113111,
0.0412305482,
-0.0098554119,
0.0283926073,
-0.0349843316,
0.0068015642,
-0.0467545502,
0.0387293063,
-0.0080525354,
0.0272822734,
-0.0177046936,
0.0015039608,
0.0300262831,
-0.004354313,
0.1040869877,
-0.0444773324,
0.0276987199,
0.0188514516,
-0.0523489043,
-0.057199005,
-0.0325997658,
-0.0045424984,
0.027064126,
-0.0448669977,
-0.0128768962,
-0.066980809,
-0.035667643,
0.0502670854,
0.0075089098,
0.0072996402,
-0.0157412533,
0.063097842,
0.0219123084,
0.0006322894,
0.0333187245,
-0.0281519126,
0.0390749089,
-0.0000112498,
0.0093144933,
0.0139648253,
-5.518682226e-33,
-0.0264366306,
-0.022689946,
0.0089476835,
-0.0235520639,
-0.0219283346,
0.0271410495,
-0.0776819885,
-0.0186353084,
0.0093824584,
0.0260860547,
-0.0156796295,
-0.0033673139,
0.0013368609,
0.0477371812,
-0.0062779258,
-0.0213575643,
0.0467524789,
0.0224754661,
-0.0417940281,
0.0410250314,
-0.0231552254,
0.0386541672,
0.0426051468,
-0.0604748465,
0.0185385905,
-0.0300476458,
0.0002820664,
0.002004951,
0.0105038499,
0.0507392064,
-0.0198244285,
0.016591128,
0.0465693846,
-0.0159121826,
-0.0523807406,
-0.0183034651,
-0.0810587779,
-0.0087255957,
0.0253940262,
-0.0525851436,
-0.0783263296,
-0.0358931981,
0.0563275367,
-0.0405026451,
-0.0030672485,
-0.023360718,
0.0292224791,
-0.0520024709,
-0.0090795774,
-0.0568552576,
-0.0263932459,
0.0537253208,
0.0031447778,
-0.041652929,
-0.0252460577,
0.0057442035,
-0.0318071507,
0.0409521423,
-0.0050579119,
0.0139390295,
0.045100309,
0.0375190862,
-0.00197626,
-0.0143834623,
-0.0241097957,
0.0674157143,
0.0142985787,
-0.0206763707,
-0.0161670037,
0.0121560581,
-0.0523759276,
0.0180770978,
0.05552404,
0.0450681448,
0.0322789177,
-0.012404426,
-0.0662519336,
0.075733006,
-0.0694137141,
0.0201765876,
0.0128977308,
-0.0454187691,
-0.0282967724,
-0.004207266,
-0.0094562573,
0.0033423507,
-0.0087756272,
-0.021674592,
0.0112234307,
0.022729652,
-0.0232552718,
0.0122706341,
-0.0088779414,
-0.015126734,
0.046477627,
0.0013489469,
0.0017527888,
-0.0283940937,
-0.051967714,
-0.0033515908,
-0.0440887921,
-0.0061163288,
0.0140204644,
-0.0046989932,
0.0243472531,
0.0381101742,
0.0580144525,
-0.0374412313,
-0.036318209,
0.0148992343,
0.0359903388,
-0.0066900663,
-0.0413251929,
0.0038727026,
0.0129579445,
0.0298006404,
0.0197216459,
0.045783218,
-0.0160566662,
-0.0205461532,
-0.0505882874,
-0.0291892812,
0.0156515874,
0.028446028,
-0.0447461568,
0.0037859222,
-0.0310540013,
0.0407781415,
0.0385434814,
-0.0435805544,
-0.0126254121,
-0.0130072795,
2.476e-7,
0.0822611526,
0.0237293802,
0.0365456417,
-0.0385225527,
0.0039180331,
0.0110817906,
-0.0104421452,
0.0402283929,
-0.0130320517,
0.0044508786,
0.0407678708,
0.0131289307,
0.03748025,
0.027306078,
-0.0750615597,
-0.019311646,
-0.1281383038,
-0.0370415039,
0.0087982761,
-0.041379299,
0.0512124151,
0.0691496879,
-0.0615980849,
-0.020438958,
-0.0088532148,
-0.0104216412,
0.0399290174,
-0.013816054,
-0.040363241,
0.0636748299,
0.0297875199,
0.00166573,
0.0200886559,
0.0034923577,
-0.0190594941,
-0.0355955102,
0.0597254187,
0.0883629695,
-0.0003872295,
0.0064034751,
0.0034667619,
0.0007239011,
0.0453126878,
-0.0122097768,
0.0318686366,
-0.0487731509,
-0.0056119119,
-0.027406482,
-0.0385619886,
-0.0000925687,
0.0479690172,
-0.0245582797,
-0.0722113028,
0.0719816014,
0.0243987851,
0.0425841175,
-0.0426998958,
-0.0712550357,
-0.0712506324,
0.0411814079,
-0.0077069411,
-0.0382707454,
0.0516999178,
-0.0290843733,
-0.0183888488,
-0.0800048336,
-0.0053397887,
2.258320717e-34,
0.0828959048,
-0.0046835109,
-0.0252617076,
0.0189755894,
0.0208056327,
-0.0428930372,
0.0078879083,
0.0088559957,
0.0376053751,
-0.0241017956,
-0.0151646165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02265v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02265v2 | Not all layers are equally as important: Every Layer Counts BERT | 2023-11-03T23:08:50 | 2023-11-07T21:36:11 | Lucas Georges Gabriel Charpentier, David Samuel | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel modification of the transformer architecture,
tailored for the data-efficient pretraining of language models. This aspect is
evaluated by participating in the BabyLM challenge, where our solution won both
the strict and strict-small tracks. Our approach allows each transformer layer
to select which outputs of previous layers to process. The empirical results
verify the potential of this simple modification and show that not all layers
are equally as important. | [
-0.0081104944,
0.0662849918,
-0.0081322296,
0.0576872602,
-0.0068490729,
0.0127482936,
0.0156774297,
-0.0040335576,
-0.0556293763,
-0.0215902664,
-0.0526355207,
-0.0203020256,
-0.0057726889,
-0.0061348476,
0.0300993193,
-0.0700257346,
0.0318124741,
-0.01904382,
-0.0355586298,
-0.0238686968,
-0.0088484213,
-0.0216355603,
-0.0088988636,
0.0470064916,
-0.0053554401,
0.01842211,
-0.0030692946,
-0.0066817594,
0.0215836242,
-0.0042325002,
0.0300071202,
0.0598598868,
-0.0028113353,
0.0517021939,
0.0000019814,
-0.0261604208,
0.0098225456,
0.0044037746,
-0.0271168239,
0.035196621,
-0.0397778377,
0.0115096597,
-0.0382139236,
0.0319470242,
-0.0216600485,
-0.0344063789,
0.0620201342,
0.0573083907,
0.0795059055,
0.0811804831,
-0.0282362513,
-0.0326031037,
0.0209185928,
-0.0209672507,
-0.0080899289,
-0.016281845,
0.0151231783,
-0.071533367,
-0.0190962963,
-0.0540394634,
-0.0333124548,
0.0447075479,
0.028586898,
0.0090197967,
-0.0151360445,
0.0369134769,
-0.0580249168,
-0.0690259933,
-0.0117297834,
0.0685732439,
-0.0477293469,
-0.0146684507,
-0.0123981964,
0.0019175725,
-0.0118680643,
-0.024501564,
-0.0256498046,
0.0403612666,
0.0154450266,
0.0124021452,
-0.0153380958,
0.001751209,
0.0313144028,
-0.0099999057,
-0.0642146245,
0.0478468686,
0.0484192558,
-0.0339383744,
0.0104785413,
0.0481460057,
0.0223054886,
-0.0599467456,
0.0303962436,
0.0065036444,
-0.0108779725,
0.0016022822,
-0.039678514,
-0.0129250288,
-0.0112286145,
-0.0796437263,
0.0607724339,
0.0305686258,
-0.048445981,
0.0235936884,
-0.0403128304,
0.0279509146,
-0.0310845263,
0.0212870128,
-0.0421716236,
-0.0094385613,
0.0049358676,
0.0047097821,
-0.1188234985,
0.0401067808,
-0.0229000021,
-0.0375925638,
-0.0285342485,
0.0378854871,
-0.0026734059,
-0.0437273011,
0.0412585996,
0.0064284108,
-0.0165885426,
0.0013087862,
0.0240995493,
0.0453939624,
-0.0250243675,
0.0105746724,
-0.0293991007,
-0.0658190399,
-0.0169119183,
0.014744008,
0.017053999,
-0.0221818201,
0.0125393262,
0.0193060301,
-0.0133031709,
-0.0575814769,
-0.0296432339,
0.0591479503,
0.015632702,
-0.0326910242,
0.0221677199,
-0.0303468425,
-0.0023212824,
-0.0078478409,
0.0403258614,
0.0113597829,
-0.0219227504,
-0.0146596255,
-0.0068887514,
0.0283926297,
-0.0084127588,
-0.0033265527,
0.0093861409,
0.0197637975,
0.0015504485,
0.071315743,
0.0481205061,
0.0093242088,
0.0165210199,
-0.0507890321,
0.0081503876,
0.0713236928,
0.0292448793,
0.00527946,
-0.0280710142,
-0.0130330389,
-0.0296207294,
-0.0100655537,
0.0182944704,
0.0382624902,
-0.0603023916,
0.0004341081,
0.0646637231,
0.0289734639,
0.0534638502,
0.0665159523,
0.008154247,
-0.0245502144,
0.0450521745,
0.0219724644,
-0.0121781016,
0.0090643065,
-0.0233342424,
-0.0190812778,
-0.0240928382,
0.0490312576,
-0.068463698,
0.0044238511,
0.0027507874,
-0.0120227477,
0.0155999437,
-0.0068105948,
0.025618054,
0.0434421077,
-0.0565012954,
0.1361195147,
0.0058315657,
-0.0671994314,
-0.0081656743,
-0.0762223005,
-0.0288674682,
0.0247251857,
0.0340102464,
-0.0098060844,
-0.0768648684,
0.0223493911,
0.0223824289,
0.0379389785,
0.0494604222,
-0.0022108704,
0.0713437051,
-0.0436553732,
-0.0391430743,
0.0324125476,
0.0124466671,
0.0304814503,
0.0118352817,
-0.023166256,
-0.0085672839,
-0.0064760586,
0.0291514397,
0.0337933525,
-0.0116954288,
-0.0037499683,
0.0079257581,
0.0119778272,
0.0307654981,
-0.0169813242,
-0.0534500442,
-0.0086437697,
0.0494853184,
-0.0195269641,
-0.023273658,
0.0226559862,
-0.0583231933,
-0.0157585945,
0.0071665761,
-0.046611201,
-0.0008592428,
0.0742772669,
-0.033495266,
-0.0346384123,
-0.0010675096,
-0.0743696019,
0.0996666029,
-0.0283742175,
0.0433117971,
-0.0352483355,
-0.0120203793,
-0.0008163669,
0.0179209933,
0.0104467459,
0.0034201331,
0.0134784253,
-0.0021508813,
0.03120354,
-0.0251276772,
-0.065436013,
0.0068787867,
-0.0156403687,
0.0196652841,
0.0361936167,
-0.0035041438,
-0.0253239553,
-0.0555153638,
-0.0942643881,
-0.0188462175,
-0.027537128,
0.0149422362,
0.0193373673,
0.0530450046,
-0.0160624906,
-0.0223456156,
-0.0069697108,
-0.0105126044,
-0.0178437196,
0.0194226466,
0.0122579997,
-0.0153197646,
-0.0473012105,
-0.0256356355,
-0.0344825424,
0.0118582826,
0.053412836,
-0.0056318706,
-0.0034640883,
-0.0352648497,
-0.0624634251,
-0.010032489,
0.0607074127,
0.015522413,
-0.0731470361,
0.0108891362,
-0.0079768607,
0.0265665203,
0.0459742099,
0.0229993388,
0.0613059029,
0.0051456252,
-0.0170824826,
-0.0342139043,
0.0262629837,
-0.0454843156,
-0.0002632666,
-0.0648551732,
0.0130613046,
0.0246539563,
0.1019291207,
-0.0341982692,
-0.0040538646,
-0.0603825226,
-0.0174200963,
-0.0060251616,
-0.0156725049,
0.030596219,
-0.0310198255,
-0.0298852473,
0.0009474219,
-0.0031541558,
-0.0367003754,
0.0457297042,
-0.0507428721,
-0.0291169733,
-0.0590920635,
0.0301780049,
0.0003047296,
0.0398379825,
0.0245493259,
0.0316563025,
-0.0147651462,
-0.0325767137,
-0.0366277583,
0.0253443234,
-0.0032603524,
-0.0243345294,
0.0226900689,
-0.0059242561,
0.0181521624,
0.0015660365,
-0.0782302916,
-0.0488838591,
-0.0278996136,
-0.0281976182,
0.0178201292,
0.03811308,
-0.054462377,
-0.0977003425,
-0.0102826823,
0.0161045883,
0.0712501928,
0.0050555537,
0.0063109961,
-0.0008217025,
0.0579396039,
0.0134452162,
-0.0030617332,
0.0372032933,
-0.0232165568,
0.0275673736,
0.0222813487,
0.0509371459,
0.033340171,
-0.0509785898,
0.0095907673,
0.0658681765,
-0.0426902771,
-0.0193867106,
-0.001126878,
0.0551499315,
-0.0217832066,
-0.0188597012,
0.122003004,
0.0157612115,
-0.0044784439,
0.0130425328,
0.0348732136,
0.0166424289,
-0.0058341562,
0.0252097081,
-0.0698944181,
-0.0211048592,
0.006689365,
0.012729398,
0.0204981659,
-0.0012445417,
0.0086413398,
-0.0639227852,
0.0158238336,
-0.0079937167,
0.0008340824,
0.0100725824,
-0.0425564162,
-0.018005522,
-0.0196482521,
-0.0111252619,
0.0029457847,
-0.0061844452,
-0.0405096412,
0.0368965492,
-0.0021098363,
-0.0332827084,
0.0197618976,
-0.0259523001,
0.0087438338,
0.0589729361,
0.0143654961,
-0.0327247269,
-0.0813217834,
0.0453763865,
-0.007463756,
-0.0189451389,
-0.0057548708,
0.0235047266,
0.0201854315,
-0.039886266,
-0.0216342602,
-0.0124214469,
0.0071283369,
0.0188645236,
-0.0428452566,
0.0518860742,
-0.0148754586,
-0.0473973937,
0.0126024457,
0.0044554076,
-0.0331557058,
0.0627966896,
0.0324317366,
-0.0557793453,
-0.0002794806,
0.0025980519,
0.0100784944,
-0.0672470257,
0.004906395,
0.0430461876,
-0.0361910872,
-0.0731933638,
-0.0494558513,
-0.0114011215,
0.0186723843,
0.0689722672,
0.014162262,
-0.0734113678,
0.0528641529,
0.0129924593,
-0.0231636986,
0.0359169059,
0.0126431473,
-0.003766404,
-0.0826989636,
-0.0423198603,
0.0481098071,
0.0074464157,
-0.0315213278,
-0.0001488232,
-0.0533198565,
-0.0350987799,
0.0639977083,
0.0661219954,
0.0274630524,
0.0251894705,
0.000267088,
-0.0557220355,
0.0816846564,
0.0314249583,
-0.0131165097,
0.0241774041,
0.0667203143,
-0.0899257213,
-0.0068375664,
0.0303888191,
-0.0386154652,
0.0645568222,
0.0355415195,
0.0416416675,
-0.0038099245,
-0.0127669834,
-0.004633435,
-0.0090957778,
0.0795191005,
-0.0172726978,
0.0354485251,
-0.0235563628,
0.0500557907,
0.0157545637,
0.0137177249,
-0.0692830458,
0.0007125802,
0.0237695258,
0.0309433397,
-0.0100286677,
0.0317437276,
0.0007927025,
0.0157066323,
-0.0347722769,
0.0459136665,
0.0450046435,
0.0132038882,
0.0383941717,
0.0020315999,
-0.0101947924,
0.0062593902,
0.0396604054,
0.0043600686,
-0.0223666914,
0.0262081698,
0.0344689451,
0.0334540047,
-0.0426199473,
0.0293541215,
-0.0491719767,
-0.0453261696,
-0.0517821535,
0.0235886406,
0.0470473357,
-0.0035270276,
0.0515956283,
-0.0046659745,
-0.0037979707,
-0.0088140871,
0.0070898999,
-0.014346824,
-0.0393109098,
0.0275944769,
-0.0007473576,
0.000672539,
-0.0449369401,
0.0564023554,
-0.0105503229,
0.0492911153,
-0.0084706368,
0.0081143938,
-0.0251710992,
-0.0443108045,
0.0600640289,
0.0097407596,
-0.0188342333,
-0.004459315,
-0.011715861,
-0.0452903882,
0.0096153477,
0.0036507058,
0.0369700268,
0.0028702279,
0.0510128625,
0.0328489654,
0.003617259,
-0.0298552979,
0.0135029638,
-0.0341421477,
0.0103083011,
-0.0118814465,
0.0317298099,
-6.650787611e-33,
-0.0266576074,
0.0415075272,
0.0099759232,
-0.006601945,
-0.001370054,
0.0436138697,
-0.0363573991,
-0.0090187564,
-0.0186067019,
0.0092873815,
-0.0268322565,
-0.0040192031,
0.0246014334,
0.0491569042,
-0.014846785,
0.002265611,
0.0917783305,
-0.0003902532,
-0.0381215177,
0.0029331925,
-0.0427904613,
0.0453447029,
0.0577554144,
0.01247459,
-0.0453450531,
0.0048923199,
-0.0195789542,
0.0090287561,
0.0216479339,
0.0386411287,
-0.0190687329,
0.0064470144,
-0.0063016936,
-0.0541464612,
-0.0281544887,
0.0424741134,
-0.0948205665,
-0.0486019067,
0.0159981772,
0.073463954,
-0.0206653792,
0.0441293381,
0.0399986878,
-0.0002880179,
-0.0135558434,
0.0032821808,
0.0047318679,
0.0132383648,
-0.0251395684,
-0.0538285673,
-0.0596012548,
0.0115025919,
-0.0032197433,
-0.0459325574,
0.0238252152,
0.0178491678,
-0.0261200164,
-0.0137088848,
-0.0732656941,
-0.0020724575,
0.0414698049,
0.0066875792,
0.0470906645,
0.0429497249,
0.0089365235,
0.0356312022,
0.0404956713,
-0.0121932328,
-0.0205636155,
-0.0109041277,
0.0642604604,
0.0465638191,
0.0334281474,
-0.0634728819,
0.0074720648,
-0.019411074,
-0.0469312109,
0.0045681121,
0.0325332433,
0.0121002859,
0.0053564827,
0.0104727177,
0.0082517806,
-0.0224184729,
-0.035388831,
0.0170795918,
-0.0109330378,
0.0118834423,
-0.0023931093,
0.0140981721,
-0.0150984144,
0.0233801119,
0.0436149277,
-0.0322112553,
0.0052526668,
-0.0003230339,
0.0061914991,
0.0211399253,
-0.0190081876,
0.0330822319,
-0.0370181575,
-0.0549973473,
0.0215238538,
0.0262593403,
0.0087697618,
0.0153945088,
0.0483003333,
0.0597041473,
-0.0824641362,
-0.0112928897,
-0.0448322147,
-0.0194788463,
0.0274373312,
0.0606448762,
0.023784373,
0.0266514551,
0.0004449154,
0.0233642273,
-0.0047849966,
0.0053587002,
-0.0297139622,
0.0298527014,
0.0273011401,
0.0360501669,
-0.0274743345,
-0.03922325,
-0.0614232235,
0.0387851037,
0.0139537435,
-0.0997734964,
-0.0316725373,
-0.0055305432,
2.709e-7,
0.0389208198,
0.0314261205,
0.0383732617,
-0.0230669286,
0.0224740934,
0.0044479794,
-0.008841089,
0.0454551764,
0.000454977,
0.0820759982,
0.0123452581,
-0.0056633349,
0.0254499782,
0.0251145419,
-0.083456099,
-0.0650752932,
-0.1035953388,
0.005952626,
-0.0305787157,
0.0000929572,
0.0049685272,
0.0904282182,
0.0286967326,
-0.0245242342,
-0.0047221039,
-0.0225016866,
0.0459521972,
-0.0108253192,
0.044683706,
0.0319644809,
0.0400439613,
0.0323024504,
-0.0068190387,
-0.0003110234,
-0.0348308384,
0.0389351435,
-0.0162939858,
0.045244243,
-0.0410775766,
-0.0278634373,
0.0312139075,
-0.0033006193,
-0.0237561818,
-0.0457394384,
0.0263408571,
-0.0628381148,
-0.0252085011,
0.0037764704,
-0.0318458639,
-0.0118341148,
0.0024960358,
-0.0335932001,
-0.0107050771,
0.0227496102,
0.04777354,
-0.0318098739,
-0.0129697919,
-0.0817393884,
-0.0078897811,
-0.0131329317,
-0.0314304419,
-0.0587660521,
-0.0381268561,
-0.0366650969,
0.03397635,
-0.0167125389,
0.013725399,
2.200094027e-34,
0.0335566066,
-0.0256979484,
0.0053488254,
0.0282412805,
0.0287798569,
-0.0209218003,
0.0522720702,
-0.0038868242,
-0.0221662298,
-0.0673082471,
-0.0243754108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02262v1 | Tell Your Model Where to Attend: Post-hoc Attention Steering for LLMs | 2023-11-03T22:56:43 | 2023-11-03T22:56:43 | Qingru Zhang, Chandan Singh, Liyuan Liu, Xiaodong Liu, Bin Yu, Jianfeng Gao, Tuo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In human-written articles, we often leverage the subtleties of text style,
such as bold and italics, to guide the attention of readers. These textual
emphases are vital for the readers to grasp the conveyed information. When
interacting with large language models (LLMs), we have a similar need -
steering the model to pay closer attention to user-specified information, e.g.,
an instruction. Existing methods, however, are constrained to process plain
text and do not support such a mechanism. This motivates us to introduce PASTA
- Post-hoc Attention STeering Approach, a method that allows LLMs to read text
with user-specified emphasis marks. To this end, PASTA identifies a small
subset of attention heads and applies precise attention reweighting on them,
directing the model attention to user-specified parts. Like prompting, PASTA is
applied at inference time and does not require changing any model parameters.
Experiments demonstrate that PASTA can substantially enhance an LLM's ability
to follow user instructions or integrate new knowledge from user inputs,
leading to a significant performance improvement on a variety of tasks, e.g.,
an average accuracy improvement of 22% for LLAMA-7B. Our code is publicly
available at https://github.com/QingruZhang/PASTA . | [
0.0203403123,
0.008117958,
0.000148549,
0.0461494997,
-0.0100181662,
0.0033313981,
-0.0427399613,
0.0099672712,
0.0288030673,
-0.0331983194,
-0.0568232015,
-0.0273189545,
-0.0082299467,
-0.0010079721,
0.0498414673,
-0.0571937524,
0.0439727157,
-0.0484238379,
0.0078087267,
0.0255921111,
0.0458844975,
-0.0082914466,
0.000982844,
0.0423620157,
0.0186628457,
-0.0355633348,
-0.0037294847,
0.0331519954,
0.0249646455,
-0.0239914693,
0.0188385211,
0.0460466407,
-0.0104066553,
0.0260237232,
0.0000020988,
-0.0074165449,
0.011315505,
-0.0188282728,
-0.0121609569,
0.0643628165,
0.0354778804,
0.0055163698,
-0.0415825136,
0.034413971,
-0.0193522405,
0.0672501624,
0.0552700609,
0.0608499795,
0.0355129689,
0.0764610171,
0.0019326028,
0.0080638817,
0.0213312469,
-0.0199208725,
0.0241313614,
-0.0127581945,
0.000909012,
-0.022458205,
0.0151047921,
0.0601119064,
-0.0003803353,
0.0838651583,
0.0374652036,
-0.0134578245,
-0.0057882159,
0.05033838,
0.0085412422,
0.0013723677,
-0.0427335389,
0.0728743598,
-0.0100331279,
-0.0420225449,
-0.0095213372,
0.0004775041,
0.0118620638,
-0.0013855108,
-0.0554474071,
0.0025662447,
-0.0131935505,
0.0614550225,
0.0534890071,
-0.0050859521,
0.0247206558,
0.0087524494,
-0.0080962349,
0.0543907098,
0.0119843679,
-0.0249021426,
0.0037618254,
0.0099120708,
-0.0097392919,
-0.0441898033,
0.054360237,
0.051508069,
0.0249345191,
0.0196007211,
-0.0561036319,
-0.0471825078,
0.0298211295,
-0.067795448,
0.0752196014,
0.0513032526,
-0.0788547099,
0.0346028134,
-0.0210218541,
0.002471637,
-0.0549672656,
0.0382738225,
-0.0071632708,
0.0105935754,
0.0083403736,
-0.013584665,
-0.0243741777,
0.0046191425,
-0.0603693649,
-0.0381334089,
-0.0010293832,
0.0451353528,
0.0357011296,
-0.0191274751,
0.0167633202,
-0.0246992838,
-0.034328036,
-0.0082311686,
0.0142187215,
0.0562602393,
-0.0468082465,
0.0061311498,
0.0130291013,
-0.0476381779,
-0.0423342437,
0.0265334453,
-0.0187073424,
-0.017018389,
-0.0038535434,
0.0586885288,
-0.0448141694,
-0.0421203822,
-0.068955943,
0.006342961,
-0.0224671923,
-0.026911037,
0.0063262992,
-0.0387341678,
0.0030451389,
0.0046445597,
0.0047556339,
-0.0236679409,
0.027037194,
0.0525192246,
-0.033546377,
0.0303086396,
-0.0245579667,
-0.008764822,
0.0163231157,
0.0128381299,
-0.0146231102,
0.0647669509,
0.0453591421,
0.0433358513,
0.0120314145,
0.0148266042,
-0.0041795489,
0.0632369071,
0.0180281121,
0.0191541538,
-0.0340141803,
-0.0181357805,
-0.0278584491,
0.0165697932,
0.0640128627,
0.0630876943,
-0.0197583605,
0.0151035311,
0.1000777483,
0.0293005388,
0.016079355,
0.0105595142,
0.0164166801,
-0.0006660805,
0.0254077781,
0.0337889679,
-0.0669254586,
0.0454190448,
-0.0514844917,
0.0150952423,
0.0308875591,
0.0137231154,
-0.0235134978,
-0.0583091639,
-0.0079971682,
-0.0063814241,
-0.0120285237,
0.0085098902,
0.0428557359,
0.0097748283,
-0.0461491495,
-0.0080237221,
0.0546414778,
-0.0359130278,
-0.0003220702,
-0.0445308685,
0.0380811095,
0.0774107799,
0.017464608,
-0.0278030075,
-0.0247392077,
0.0144890416,
0.0430196151,
0.0576678403,
-0.0002614918,
0.0173612144,
-0.0169859771,
-0.0533663593,
0.0108246841,
0.0083046844,
0.0100783333,
0.0068557933,
0.0128523223,
0.006982333,
-0.0119254896,
-0.0105148647,
-0.046095375,
0.0660224259,
0.0078474162,
-0.0371446535,
-0.0403974764,
-0.0171487723,
0.0027577574,
0.0045356983,
0.0099874176,
0.0131532187,
0.0216735825,
-0.0609868541,
0.0076803621,
-0.0218885485,
-0.0117272921,
-0.030244749,
0.0200873613,
-0.0296886172,
-0.0297207888,
-0.0039310614,
-0.0025740091,
-0.0307482742,
0.0037681148,
-0.0404233821,
0.0526662841,
-0.0171790477,
0.0152533511,
0.0356419683,
0.031072231,
-0.0537180379,
0.0266743973,
-0.035596665,
-0.0251443274,
0.0415822603,
-0.0077505056,
-0.028535895,
-0.0356035493,
0.0088039823,
-0.004387863,
0.027892435,
-0.0104260147,
-0.037417125,
0.0522166118,
-0.0261404552,
-0.0494369008,
-0.0750912949,
0.0047060847,
-0.0508098751,
0.057052698,
0.049786482,
0.0081333742,
-0.0328687206,
-0.0186425578,
-0.0222303029,
-0.0171298925,
-0.0697280094,
-0.0064870641,
0.0250449851,
-0.014330226,
0.0191657916,
-0.0645765886,
-0.0167054795,
0.0003042943,
0.0095874891,
0.0296637733,
-0.051673498,
-0.0668789744,
-0.0071944911,
0.018925542,
0.0120876851,
-0.0179628506,
-0.0574780405,
0.0076303924,
-0.0072748233,
0.0759759396,
0.1036071032,
-0.0078380369,
0.0347229056,
0.0638050959,
-0.0059325024,
-0.066179432,
0.0265413783,
0.0113222133,
0.0058318339,
-0.0467702597,
-0.0340667441,
0.0382107273,
0.1064608097,
-0.0050623505,
0.0355309397,
-0.0509408154,
-0.0528064556,
-0.0186838172,
-0.0374868847,
0.0281915963,
0.0193941239,
-0.066656284,
0.0217356533,
-0.0192568135,
-0.0433658697,
0.0765676498,
-0.0540609732,
-0.0439920761,
-0.0261097886,
0.0142490603,
-0.0234913137,
-0.0060629812,
-0.0186569542,
0.0141783776,
-0.0333219841,
-0.0471219383,
-0.0293356813,
0.0166454911,
-0.0219085924,
-0.0091514653,
0.0851270929,
-0.0451090299,
-0.0069927461,
0.0118085993,
-0.000566318,
-0.0233063139,
-0.0181751177,
-0.0448565893,
-0.0157846771,
0.0191142615,
-0.0296407454,
-0.0277264621,
0.0002775773,
0.0484334305,
0.0605966039,
-0.0404907688,
0.0054547871,
-0.0420454443,
0.0060837637,
0.0508888774,
0.0038881097,
0.0140383812,
-0.0590178594,
0.0032243398,
0.0791204423,
0.0071392483,
-0.052047763,
-0.0187354218,
-0.0056956257,
0.0585626811,
-0.0468578748,
-0.0164088812,
0.0251905229,
0.070998922,
-0.074590683,
-0.015671948,
0.1044164747,
0.0381407551,
-0.0566108339,
0.007126648,
-0.0420191213,
0.0760980174,
0.0117812455,
0.0287058931,
-0.0689540207,
-0.0593054518,
0.0216760784,
0.0482587703,
0.0060619786,
0.0107247122,
0.0125809461,
-0.0673370808,
0.0323921591,
0.0196913183,
-0.0179004259,
-0.0110753616,
-0.0202734899,
0.0407068469,
0.0219488144,
0.0343217179,
0.0297777448,
-0.0248801261,
-0.0143243317,
0.019293379,
0.0072684013,
-0.0289286803,
-0.040368095,
-0.0209972188,
0.0379130542,
0.0361758471,
-0.0071822456,
0.0012664137,
-0.0272270255,
0.0398115665,
-0.0207817182,
0.0119688921,
-0.0449485518,
0.0399557836,
-0.025712071,
-0.0058235321,
-0.0223132409,
0.0532067567,
-0.0378521457,
-0.0137415724,
0.0194855612,
0.0599388555,
-0.0231567658,
0.0142082656,
-0.021446621,
-0.0074092173,
0.0232953336,
0.0420058705,
0.0847806558,
-0.0663520321,
-0.0256585348,
-0.0451936014,
-0.04454685,
-0.0335545242,
-0.0466379933,
0.0206571091,
-0.0345920287,
-0.0266027357,
-0.0843905434,
-0.0552314632,
0.0408004634,
0.0252744909,
0.0197224449,
-0.0015097412,
0.0127024706,
-0.0469164737,
-0.003310997,
0.0384562053,
-0.0428375453,
0.0041453545,
-0.1012311727,
-0.0265095066,
0.0174093246,
-0.0351149328,
0.0108402772,
0.0531525612,
-0.0623988584,
-0.0675580576,
0.0272927061,
0.0545019545,
0.0186358113,
0.0399801657,
-0.0368555449,
-0.0779293403,
0.0199849177,
-0.0253322478,
-0.021798864,
0.0361675806,
0.0323778354,
-0.0041964394,
0.0160312504,
0.0433888063,
-0.0097943516,
0.0359024256,
0.0166145824,
0.0476429574,
-0.0474384725,
-0.0425066687,
0.011835116,
0.0116270427,
0.047273133,
-0.0064195534,
0.0059203622,
-0.0489555486,
0.0445723534,
-0.0195240192,
0.0057880539,
-0.0696476698,
0.0099540586,
0.0002659999,
-0.017462153,
-0.0207527615,
-0.0282960944,
-0.038423717,
-0.0128650228,
-0.049309846,
0.0574371219,
-0.0183659345,
0.050163053,
0.0106094312,
0.0106351729,
-0.0221513789,
0.0519971289,
-0.0054545156,
0.047118064,
0.002076593,
0.0486933328,
0.0242098086,
-0.0385881886,
-0.0304179993,
0.0533590317,
-0.0582939312,
0.0202363152,
-0.0039003026,
0.0328397974,
0.0458806679,
-0.000882451,
0.095809333,
-0.0249381214,
-0.0142987305,
0.0035741057,
0.0473088697,
-0.0257711224,
0.0010983715,
0.0219706371,
0.0099276816,
0.0136929145,
-0.0085943406,
0.0576633476,
-0.0092735449,
0.0035637589,
0.0192823689,
0.0102635976,
-0.035749305,
-0.0423065685,
0.0466138422,
-0.0006783989,
-0.0246809553,
-0.0101167951,
-0.044164449,
-0.0494279079,
0.0131950285,
0.0083607128,
-0.0399469286,
-0.0591466948,
0.0303705744,
0.0131682996,
0.0059700287,
-0.0221971311,
-0.0343059078,
0.0044588237,
0.0122209014,
-0.0278696958,
-0.0324376561,
-6.877466268e-33,
-0.0524886176,
-0.0277196206,
0.0067618438,
0.0163483154,
-0.0350785777,
0.0212383699,
-0.0562251657,
-0.0008605311,
0.0179506578,
-0.0052903141,
-0.0441267826,
0.0117271207,
0.0290593784,
0.0020920048,
0.0023929053,
-0.0190842357,
0.0330391675,
-0.0146657433,
-0.0150737585,
0.0234822724,
0.0025862632,
0.0202230662,
0.0510008223,
-0.043536488,
0.0331544019,
-0.0055295364,
-0.0170310419,
0.0000914017,
-0.0330515876,
0.0662494451,
-0.0102719367,
0.0361734889,
0.0072487211,
-0.0094508305,
-0.0415847823,
0.038909927,
-0.0514308102,
-0.0333785638,
0.0325257145,
0.0060499753,
-0.071295619,
-0.0455794036,
0.067376785,
-0.0066091865,
0.0223974381,
0.0024668439,
0.0371319167,
-0.0282688905,
-0.0354003981,
0.0336764045,
-0.0688530728,
0.0292742383,
-0.0071353433,
-0.0101325335,
0.0194920823,
0.0149208512,
-0.0073064738,
0.0106899785,
-0.0327124298,
-0.0094069233,
0.0441899635,
0.0523389354,
0.0565882586,
0.0539735444,
-0.0097162342,
0.0278892312,
-0.017762769,
-0.0172555372,
-0.0182989035,
-0.0028092836,
0.0628099293,
0.0056852917,
0.0288678762,
-0.0062523559,
-0.0000765307,
0.0310645644,
-0.0565167293,
0.0100390753,
0.0233503375,
0.0303738825,
-0.0080806129,
0.0195686277,
-0.0511474907,
-0.013931171,
-0.0013133996,
-0.0271487795,
-0.0189462323,
-0.0223980397,
0.0216368921,
-0.0102175437,
-0.024764318,
-0.0013398409,
0.0305410866,
0.0044967262,
0.0059426646,
-0.0161610562,
-0.001091462,
0.0581021048,
-0.0098990211,
0.0313218832,
-0.0880733654,
-0.0116097657,
-0.000874897,
-0.0098164622,
0.0147906076,
0.0211373195,
0.035226129,
0.006258897,
-0.0737339184,
0.0045349533,
-0.0227784757,
0.0085973507,
0.0236713234,
0.0390729979,
0.0458347462,
-0.047565721,
-0.0061176568,
0.0666611195,
-0.0020805777,
-0.0012713985,
-0.0431572497,
-0.0175530463,
-0.0017758891,
0.0181327108,
-0.0737639293,
0.0166473351,
-0.0036686084,
0.0395525284,
0.0145275965,
-0.0879579112,
-0.0218604039,
0.0246474762,
2.735e-7,
0.0730900839,
0.0527627729,
0.0376321264,
0.0274590775,
-0.009218134,
0.0102524618,
-0.0211624149,
0.037959069,
0.0138141913,
-0.0043361117,
0.0237033051,
0.0481370613,
0.0331021696,
-0.0028287275,
-0.1008386761,
-0.0148988785,
-0.0453214385,
0.0409587212,
-0.0430352166,
-0.0332143381,
0.0349172764,
0.0746048465,
-0.003805089,
0.0009221149,
0.0356919058,
-0.0305940993,
0.0546673611,
-0.0150667289,
-0.0045642499,
0.0171474852,
0.0587835982,
0.0150535349,
-0.0402308628,
-0.0150989993,
-0.0132319815,
-0.0127605293,
0.0022202914,
0.0892340243,
-0.0185146313,
-0.0456797481,
0.0121823829,
-0.0027296764,
0.0016180059,
-0.0482015684,
0.0439446494,
-0.0485047773,
-0.0178576726,
0.0110969637,
0.013344924,
-0.0421620831,
-0.0260997452,
-0.0238111392,
-0.0013047169,
0.0122110387,
0.0112958346,
-0.0311863609,
-0.0427942984,
-0.0704704002,
-0.0791310519,
-0.0297893342,
-0.0253115986,
-0.0177770257,
-0.070012942,
-0.0027602429,
-0.020879589,
-0.0766481906,
-0.0356498472,
2.840836253e-34,
0.0225580111,
-0.0454767011,
0.0210125819,
0.1006386131,
0.0033608528,
0.0120126437,
0.0045497147,
0.0172185767,
0.0303073395,
-0.0889724419,
-0.0209537297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02248v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02248v2 | COSMIC: Data Efficient Instruction-tuning For Speech In-Context Learning | 2023-11-03T21:47:03 | 2024-06-14T17:57:13 | Jing Pan, Jian Wu, Yashesh Gaur, Sunit Sivasankaran, Zhuo Chen, Shujie Liu, Jinyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS | We present a cost-effective method to integrate speech into a large language
model (LLM), resulting in a Contextual Speech Model with
Instruction-following/in-context-learning Capabilities (COSMIC) multi-modal
LLM. Using GPT-3.5, we generate Speech Comprehension Test Question-Answer (SQA)
pairs from speech transcriptions for supervised instruction tuning. With under
30 million trainable parameters and only 450 hours of English speech data,
COSMIC demonstrates emerging capabilities in instruction-following and
in-context learning. Equipped with such capabilities, COSMIC achieves a maximum
33.18 BLEU score in 0-shot EN-to-X speech to text translation (S2TT) and a
significant boost in the 1-shot setting. Additionally, there is an average
25.8\% relative Word Error Rate (WER) reduction for 1-shot cross-domain
adaptation. COSMIC exhibits a significant automatic speech recognition (ASR)
accuracy gain in contextual biasing tasks due to its instruction-following
capability. | [
-0.0161225069,
0.0405893736,
0.0224466138,
0.0281226616,
0.0043901377,
0.0194307119,
0.0429370627,
-0.0511939675,
-0.0258288085,
-0.0597999692,
-0.0865018144,
-0.0150614399,
0.0044522807,
-0.0033451137,
0.030408632,
-0.0002514786,
0.0568959266,
-0.0460528992,
-0.0255083796,
-0.0016170007,
-0.0035698602,
0.031799674,
-0.0449150018,
-0.0060386802,
0.0211682245,
-0.0063638254,
-0.0100294044,
0.0437125377,
0.0210571326,
-0.0343964249,
0.0074827746,
0.0440496765,
0.0627984256,
0.0417887345,
0.0000021173,
-0.046742063,
-0.0412650965,
-0.0007886179,
-0.0366793051,
0.0379763432,
0.0605683476,
-0.0110993562,
-0.0081539517,
0.0592354834,
0.0016723684,
0.0141811268,
0.0461517051,
0.0109244427,
0.0633624196,
0.0807702243,
-0.0117208082,
-0.0384288654,
0.0210199039,
-0.0378217511,
0.0344892852,
-0.0616597496,
-0.0223694686,
-0.0124628963,
0.0042625135,
0.0314854719,
-0.0605582669,
0.0670404211,
0.0192461461,
-0.0020778615,
-0.0215360429,
-0.0094866017,
0.0083911708,
-0.0124098388,
-0.0622763224,
0.0890574828,
0.0231958572,
-0.012881374,
-0.021694975,
0.0005330465,
-0.0340985581,
-0.0247058403,
-0.0380134322,
0.0047507202,
0.0373627506,
-0.0076900483,
0.0115278689,
-0.0143279992,
0.0099074729,
-0.0180599261,
-0.0193400085,
0.0189528614,
0.0324011073,
-0.0288816337,
-0.0149891032,
-0.011561837,
-0.0395721309,
-0.0169715006,
0.0093759755,
0.0316447578,
-0.0895163119,
0.044121664,
-0.0678709894,
-0.0025351204,
-0.0072483928,
0.0080667017,
0.0453524068,
0.0863308012,
-0.0231547076,
0.052226752,
-0.0084618432,
0.0625194386,
0.0059970068,
0.0053894524,
-0.0592895225,
-0.0158818439,
-0.0392198786,
0.030412456,
-0.0251113772,
0.0003373626,
-0.0654282942,
-0.0372725874,
-0.0252215452,
0.0317626856,
0.0164886191,
0.0146584101,
0.0264158081,
-0.0358610526,
-0.0723913014,
-0.0132497484,
0.0054164254,
0.0356460065,
-0.0028659641,
0.0428278968,
-0.0020826058,
-0.0440643951,
-0.0212266091,
0.0175033566,
0.0089502614,
-0.0138795376,
0.0466729365,
0.0855067968,
-0.0233169161,
-0.0515215322,
-0.0164692625,
-0.0052379109,
-0.003290321,
-0.0641397908,
-0.0092148893,
-0.0182925947,
0.0198702831,
0.0003391026,
-0.0060827024,
-0.0034809108,
0.0028689746,
0.0137725873,
-0.010981706,
0.0682054535,
0.0213324372,
-0.0033168737,
0.0359594785,
-0.0020587516,
0.0233864207,
0.0820318013,
0.0325324796,
-0.0425836109,
0.0040010563,
-0.0179283638,
-0.0236911774,
0.0451684855,
0.0292184409,
0.0563349836,
-0.0077153319,
0.0264669918,
0.0320125557,
0.0109411823,
0.0408197455,
0.0221108478,
-0.0348259099,
0.0115215369,
0.0529803336,
0.026381759,
0.0238214526,
-0.0185047369,
0.0334184505,
0.036654111,
-0.0325580314,
-0.0267765429,
-0.0693757311,
0.0215638038,
-0.0320372321,
0.0123276636,
0.0489337146,
0.0026274023,
-0.0475155078,
-0.0166139938,
0.0198517237,
-0.0038436404,
-0.0147508932,
0.0601690039,
0.016036287,
-0.0068694805,
-0.0897678584,
0.0298019461,
0.0275906753,
-0.0446552895,
0.0181488153,
-0.0054066847,
0.0216500573,
0.0487473272,
0.0103932805,
-0.0221039392,
-0.0614439957,
-0.0364250205,
0.0501148663,
0.0570863821,
-0.015708413,
-0.0071321111,
0.0622393042,
-0.0811430141,
-0.0014121308,
0.000321393,
-0.0130304731,
0.0458357371,
-0.0033405924,
0.0178931523,
0.0120994644,
0.0028473032,
0.0236331075,
0.0202706829,
-0.0386761241,
-0.0692150518,
0.0082042245,
0.0079681724,
0.0487779155,
0.0159587413,
-0.0288675427,
-0.0224023294,
0.0140268095,
-0.0325276144,
0.027051311,
0.0245883595,
-0.0931831151,
-0.0704087391,
0.0271472298,
-0.0275314134,
0.0029306926,
-0.0127519192,
-0.0321445912,
-0.0814382732,
-0.0021515011,
-0.02517418,
0.0344494469,
-0.0616187677,
0.0212387815,
0.0185624305,
0.0056049698,
-0.0300916545,
-0.0043103117,
-0.0008241655,
0.0002196154,
0.0605751723,
0.0531351678,
-0.0118450597,
-0.0566457361,
0.0203208271,
0.00487073,
0.0115898512,
0.0152820228,
-0.01300292,
0.0442145243,
-0.0498420373,
-0.0018016142,
-0.0904639587,
0.0501800403,
-0.0224882364,
0.0327464864,
0.0664282292,
0.040088471,
-0.0303684585,
-0.0313194729,
-0.0275409594,
-0.0232944917,
0.0018876329,
-0.0034309314,
-0.0207555443,
0.0050954609,
-0.0366515219,
-0.0309445485,
0.0145697147,
0.002032344,
-0.0220358521,
-0.0179528818,
0.0359517485,
-0.0611898527,
0.06503658,
0.0354365446,
0.0234100726,
-0.0110468687,
-0.0366473645,
-0.0134606911,
-0.0125641935,
0.0305827465,
0.0785550997,
0.0044935592,
-0.0222422685,
0.024261836,
-0.0301082935,
-0.0606212951,
0.0412092991,
0.0058073928,
-0.049611643,
-0.0259222221,
0.0313100405,
0.0020170254,
0.0404736586,
0.0113432519,
0.0209071655,
-0.0588733517,
-0.033117082,
-0.0016122471,
-0.0210329946,
-0.0358338021,
0.0072043575,
-0.0205915663,
-0.0184631124,
-0.0094784293,
-0.011298107,
0.0399707966,
-0.0803740472,
-0.041827213,
-0.098551631,
-0.0279760472,
-0.0258935336,
-0.0302469004,
-0.0068029654,
0.0023242899,
-0.0330906063,
-0.0416506231,
-0.0592449568,
0.0087264962,
0.024952827,
-0.0129873175,
0.0470292717,
-0.041648306,
0.0121005625,
-0.0271556433,
-0.0077880356,
-0.0250141062,
-0.0131381461,
-0.0026944724,
0.0067366916,
-0.0114859696,
-0.0442262329,
-0.0170264393,
-0.0175287239,
0.034608271,
0.0745943561,
-0.0007517773,
-0.0011818601,
-0.0521271899,
0.0398486704,
0.0335170142,
0.0448229723,
-0.0068254643,
-0.0369738527,
0.0381997488,
0.0077753742,
0.0549841337,
-0.0107997218,
0.007242626,
0.0354614221,
0.0408394933,
0.0108057568,
0.0035215323,
0.0499541089,
0.1112798378,
-0.042505376,
-0.0202114377,
0.1313291192,
0.0126519985,
-0.0385698825,
-0.0290588289,
0.0243046191,
0.015516689,
0.0386421755,
0.0179009121,
-0.0807514414,
-0.0773020908,
0.006875759,
0.0203804616,
0.0316182673,
0.0194885023,
-0.0442080013,
-0.1011315957,
0.0280814562,
0.0339042656,
-0.0857486799,
-0.0446655713,
-0.0206471924,
-0.0007315239,
-0.0129316626,
0.0542748831,
0.0084521268,
-0.014242813,
-0.013485522,
0.0248419885,
0.0317849927,
-0.0679784119,
0.0457792655,
-0.0252589751,
0.0698877648,
0.0576644205,
0.0085123098,
-0.0035489351,
-0.0202108733,
0.0275530778,
-0.0305474661,
-0.0067243711,
-0.0221458301,
0.0011866462,
-0.0203015041,
0.0026598605,
0.0162219852,
0.0914577246,
-0.0436927676,
0.0195681639,
0.0379738621,
0.0620314255,
-0.010272664,
0.0415702611,
-0.007584495,
-0.0066177738,
0.0394271053,
0.06320519,
0.0064594182,
-0.0809954554,
-0.0009451787,
-0.018738851,
-0.0292219035,
-0.061699532,
0.0143016372,
0.0044597038,
-0.0315344855,
-0.000368955,
-0.0413096286,
-0.0239403062,
0.0352113545,
0.0447134003,
-0.0033352324,
0.0035910627,
-0.0200979467,
0.0103930635,
-0.024519762,
-0.0084493561,
-0.0169629008,
0.0341318063,
-0.086153917,
-0.0119956313,
0.0453652777,
-0.0245335605,
-0.0122813592,
0.0402022898,
-0.0821419209,
-0.0549872555,
-0.0091348477,
0.0035611819,
0.0115022985,
0.0685811862,
-0.0071636639,
0.0014069222,
0.0856303647,
0.006806138,
-0.0381267481,
0.0253534708,
0.0488732867,
0.0397193767,
-0.0097517539,
0.0209247228,
-0.0203776602,
0.0323641524,
0.010392637,
0.0399713665,
-0.0462153181,
0.0073007694,
0.0117174769,
0.0170167498,
0.0293819848,
-0.0151844248,
0.0014755164,
-0.0295733809,
0.0516138598,
-0.0079445364,
0.0273376405,
-0.0348314904,
-0.0283913296,
0.0249812789,
-0.0455858707,
-0.0027473322,
0.0221210122,
0.0147741009,
-0.019071687,
-0.0095422063,
0.063565582,
0.0161212925,
0.0284525212,
0.0236844644,
0.0038053882,
-0.0074825319,
0.0169382337,
0.0337882861,
0.0505115911,
-0.028973436,
0.0887870342,
-0.0025206911,
0.007919766,
0.0071989796,
0.0294069592,
-0.0413829237,
0.0046524405,
-0.0533528067,
0.0315351002,
0.0354210287,
0.0011211893,
0.0551162884,
-0.0056548053,
-0.0034707023,
-0.0293631963,
0.0460896082,
-0.0198741648,
0.0010105292,
0.0559353605,
0.0171959139,
0.0172703732,
0.036291495,
0.0445978418,
0.0143917222,
0.0347128548,
-0.0001987965,
0.0687108785,
-0.0610677451,
-0.0194146801,
-0.0073607648,
0.022971293,
-0.0109508615,
0.0348324254,
0.0211596284,
-0.0566195771,
-0.0243724585,
-0.0076094521,
-0.0099807903,
-0.0430409871,
0.0195287336,
0.0156753752,
-0.0470197573,
-0.0164291356,
-0.0070290109,
-0.0252121836,
-0.0195053797,
-0.0414521322,
0.0022129428,
-6.85266848e-33,
-0.0601288714,
0.005346078,
0.03862793,
-0.0258738175,
-0.0016632342,
-0.0171988998,
-0.0366603732,
-0.0252302047,
-0.030525092,
-0.0415144712,
0.0062223733,
0.0185513515,
0.0236302372,
0.0550279766,
0.007433698,
-0.0002006099,
0.0607866384,
-0.0158341546,
0.0069569424,
0.0438007601,
0.0291422103,
0.0255213343,
0.032029774,
-0.0540472008,
-0.0174486674,
-0.0048699467,
-0.0176341273,
0.0237319097,
-0.0058897184,
0.0260634776,
-0.0044177165,
0.0139326453,
-0.0232691672,
-0.0502459146,
-0.0192563701,
0.0188245159,
-0.0737571716,
-0.0226408225,
0.0202498604,
0.0144614223,
-0.0116246454,
-0.0371165425,
0.0027862636,
-0.0227356832,
-0.0179075003,
-0.0616172068,
0.0019447702,
-0.0076356581,
-0.0068515027,
-0.0120659014,
-0.062508963,
0.0046699774,
-0.0247168951,
-0.0231572166,
0.0158962142,
0.0429873317,
-0.0030671135,
0.0166214406,
-0.067574136,
0.0231624357,
0.0069351755,
0.0408039764,
0.0588090979,
0.0341250226,
-0.0136521375,
-0.0069393031,
0.0251331534,
-0.0414884053,
0.0398194678,
-0.0105264122,
0.043085169,
0.0136325136,
0.001890806,
0.0458778925,
0.0294195767,
0.0010622842,
-0.0748794749,
0.0067298464,
0.0383990295,
0.0178086385,
0.0169531628,
0.0267357305,
-0.0302662086,
0.0104886154,
-0.0440842882,
-0.0131682279,
-0.0310203712,
-0.0160786044,
0.0622979403,
0.0096079996,
-0.0075737787,
-0.0336064361,
0.0833591521,
-0.0240468569,
0.0080931876,
0.0103109395,
-0.0327068456,
-0.0063993856,
-0.0255481713,
0.0653237626,
-0.0835329518,
-0.0344591886,
0.0359479785,
0.0024189681,
-0.0003019367,
-0.0287928898,
0.0121074878,
0.0432859138,
-0.065294005,
-0.0185339842,
-0.0045916275,
0.0280002281,
-0.0188660566,
0.015423716,
0.0147734871,
-0.0096644554,
-0.0012951205,
0.0580804832,
-0.033790879,
-0.0239249468,
-0.0035497306,
-0.0465022512,
-0.0064150016,
0.0290450323,
-0.0503693148,
0.0159404613,
-0.0063946731,
-0.0554322824,
0.0329946801,
-0.0541912131,
-0.0069571682,
0.0234317277,
2.876e-7,
-0.011280207,
0.0609683469,
-0.0120067988,
0.0001401106,
0.0312773846,
0.0252825283,
-0.026479492,
0.0112491809,
0.0449205749,
0.0104235495,
0.0349732526,
0.0103451042,
0.0760053769,
0.0116117392,
-0.0929561108,
-0.0237650927,
-0.0071885386,
0.0375710651,
-0.0232105143,
0.0305316281,
0.0158752054,
0.098925963,
-0.0425620936,
-0.0061533586,
0.013936054,
-0.0170097109,
0.0330639146,
-0.0233114138,
-0.0125625441,
-0.0017610502,
-0.065660283,
0.0309151653,
-0.0394117236,
0.024954157,
-0.0335266255,
0.0451563671,
-0.0123156179,
0.0980503783,
0.0119120432,
-0.0764012784,
-0.0118135009,
0.026728062,
-0.0169805549,
-0.0011198128,
0.0686914474,
-0.020317452,
-0.0058666747,
-0.0257416219,
-0.0186674707,
-0.0293722041,
0.0018609904,
-0.0126918228,
-0.0137419449,
0.0076691075,
0.0354845226,
-0.033260975,
-0.0207626205,
-0.068899706,
0.0199987441,
0.0554270595,
-0.0416133888,
-0.0229907278,
-0.0353588909,
-0.0067627463,
0.0234128051,
-0.040783409,
-0.0053016231,
2.573334606e-34,
0.0343115479,
-0.0262859296,
0.0662674308,
0.0035102423,
0.0058512627,
0.0024103457,
-0.0310290344,
-0.0107783359,
0.0550588295,
-0.1153347716,
-0.0310018416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02236v1 | Robust Fine-Tuning of Vision-Language Models for Domain Generalization | 2023-11-03T20:50:40 | 2023-11-03T20:50:40 | Kevin Vogt-Lowell, Noah Lee, Theodoros Tsiligkaridis, Marc Vaillant | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transfer learning enables the sharing of common knowledge among models for a
variety of downstream tasks, but traditional methods suffer in limited training
data settings and produce narrow models incapable of effectively generalizing
under distribution shifts. Foundation models have recently demonstrated
impressive zero-shot inference capabilities and robustness under distribution
shifts. However, zero-shot evaluation for these models has been predominantly
confined to benchmarks with simple distribution shifts, limiting our
understanding of their effectiveness under the more realistic shifts found in
practice. Moreover, common fine-tuning methods for these models have yet to be
evaluated against vision models in few-shot scenarios where training data is
limited. To address these gaps, we present a new recipe for few-shot
fine-tuning of the popular vision-language foundation model CLIP and evaluate
its performance on challenging benchmark datasets with realistic distribution
shifts from the WILDS collection. Our experimentation demonstrates that, while
zero-shot CLIP fails to match performance of trained vision models on more
complex benchmarks, few-shot CLIP fine-tuning outperforms its vision-only
counterparts in terms of in-distribution and out-of-distribution accuracy at
all levels of training data availability. This provides a strong incentive for
adoption of foundation models within few-shot learning applications operating
with real-world data. Code is available at
https://github.com/mit-ll/robust-vision-language-finetuning | [
0.0094419299,
0.0658212826,
-0.0030818642,
0.0375747383,
-0.0282291956,
0.0141300652,
0.0049081813,
-0.0181570277,
-0.0609896705,
-0.0391048416,
-0.0447485186,
-0.0272935163,
0.0139381392,
0.0392291844,
0.0337996557,
-0.0644927323,
0.0218377542,
-0.0143808518,
-0.0305721108,
0.0211050864,
-0.0027113634,
0.0002984809,
0.0024144016,
0.0229527112,
0.0254694149,
0.0031926066,
0.03180122,
0.0398367159,
0.0420376062,
0.0093858708,
0.0050533456,
0.0407663696,
0.0373377725,
-0.013747164,
0.0000019301,
-0.0377555601,
0.0109953014,
0.0191305541,
-0.0094292741,
-0.0212231409,
0.0324827768,
-0.0621072426,
-0.0020601479,
-0.0049459548,
-0.0253388043,
-0.039673388,
0.0706152096,
-0.0028152599,
0.0156361535,
0.0532552749,
-0.0239624828,
-0.015174577,
-0.0192764346,
-0.0479508191,
-0.0214927997,
-0.0628261566,
0.0459656864,
-0.0180932004,
-0.0280564837,
-0.029307479,
-0.0576336421,
0.0121762427,
-0.0007174131,
0.025820991,
-0.001639237,
0.0308771655,
-0.0756543726,
-0.036265973,
0.000574709,
0.0684262961,
-0.0366218053,
-0.0153966518,
0.0031797991,
-0.0254395772,
0.0194631238,
0.0120968809,
-0.0502385162,
0.0229236614,
0.0146886678,
0.0228116736,
-0.0660247505,
0.0008273467,
0.0401340574,
0.0224788636,
-0.0415075533,
0.0127847418,
0.0014408444,
0.0443577059,
0.0073186336,
0.0222132895,
-0.0587269217,
-0.0230270904,
-0.0575203933,
-0.0051233312,
0.0206760373,
-0.0045810458,
-0.0899223909,
-0.0037180111,
-0.0314463377,
0.0258839931,
0.0767800733,
0.0299903434,
-0.0699673444,
0.0578815341,
-0.0278931763,
0.025736643,
-0.010562757,
0.0644634515,
-0.0149639742,
-0.0428655185,
-0.0469158143,
0.0328940526,
-0.002921893,
0.0053117676,
-0.0197908115,
-0.0224449169,
-0.040890269,
0.0063149231,
-0.0140022915,
-0.0223029144,
0.0160635933,
0.0095522078,
-0.0471105315,
-0.0423289873,
0.0343975611,
0.0416903831,
-0.0318279043,
0.0477048345,
0.0192127284,
-0.0787846148,
-0.0314605534,
0.0466411225,
0.0091174953,
-0.0224601571,
-0.0021151302,
0.0822144598,
0.008777108,
-0.0447057448,
-0.031935364,
0.0251175929,
-0.0182139836,
-0.0577950142,
0.0122050028,
-0.0602750443,
0.0065550609,
0.0019994332,
0.0194441229,
-0.0735222474,
-0.0030040466,
-0.0153462347,
-0.0348496698,
0.0661184341,
-0.0157972965,
-0.0012755457,
-0.0232048463,
-0.0060134586,
-0.0322172865,
0.1028074697,
0.0148486346,
0.0020810675,
0.0092237964,
-0.0053708116,
0.0154589713,
0.0390109383,
0.0194721408,
0.0394261666,
-0.0552370548,
-0.0083810147,
-0.0161269419,
-0.0110142836,
0.0376288295,
-0.0060737678,
-0.0333304368,
-0.0364060961,
0.056936983,
0.0354092307,
0.0188191608,
-0.026789777,
0.0521440506,
-0.0273464154,
-0.0080744829,
-0.0156175364,
-0.0737905651,
0.0160132721,
-0.0089151766,
-0.0013581186,
-0.0760249421,
0.0366490521,
-0.0368887223,
0.005869417,
0.0041362722,
-0.0066703521,
-0.0128018707,
0.0220138822,
0.0939134061,
0.0353395194,
0.0054860511,
0.0135736568,
0.0417924672,
0.001506615,
0.0040253513,
-0.031778425,
-0.0198360998,
0.0087384069,
-0.0057714782,
0.0003787748,
-0.0149053233,
-0.007607508,
0.0726614073,
0.0196535885,
0.0247600172,
0.005438996,
0.0649022311,
-0.0399055369,
-0.0610256232,
-0.0017524242,
0.0328831002,
-0.003290477,
-0.0002442294,
0.004002145,
0.0311419666,
-0.0816149414,
0.0211502519,
0.0433651693,
-0.0172986817,
0.0129604759,
-0.003518014,
0.0247908644,
-0.0029745167,
-0.0310969409,
-0.02671884,
-0.0056326268,
-0.0065049203,
-0.0225378778,
0.0261545721,
0.0093669975,
-0.0143997073,
0.0216962025,
0.0311059263,
-0.0410425514,
0.0073387325,
0.0364980288,
-0.0698747262,
-0.0093373945,
0.0242248978,
0.0253432933,
-0.0276290663,
-0.0231381338,
0.0151022868,
-0.0244304817,
0.0355935767,
-0.0177431945,
0.0234368928,
0.0089959064,
-0.0299884733,
-0.0058626663,
-0.0034744227,
0.0219975393,
-0.0151087586,
0.0120179048,
-0.0245890636,
-0.0342536494,
0.0155145954,
-0.0017830195,
-0.0063925544,
-0.0236050915,
0.0275514666,
-0.0201312751,
0.0027667319,
-0.0332753882,
0.0161874592,
0.0093147028,
0.0108200004,
-0.0176978726,
-0.0250238348,
0.0122366045,
0.0393620171,
-0.0173485354,
0.0133443139,
0.0119743254,
0.0065023736,
0.0016438852,
-0.0247964747,
0.0000126683,
0.0300570037,
0.0419589877,
-0.0201986767,
-0.0391430818,
-0.0395060144,
0.0425780937,
-0.0146589791,
0.0488304719,
-0.0414300896,
0.0008642073,
-0.025541896,
-0.039705202,
-0.0262059979,
0.0840254575,
-0.0289724339,
0.0136843678,
0.0131545737,
0.0156560279,
-0.0201773439,
-0.0170197804,
-0.0092105577,
-0.0292231422,
-0.0543469563,
0.0237704609,
-0.0181862041,
0.0494091474,
-0.0318609923,
-0.0135514271,
-0.077490665,
0.0497519076,
-0.0107118245,
-0.0236920565,
-0.0381948054,
0.056097094,
0.004203185,
0.0387405343,
-0.0312431715,
-0.052464921,
0.0302428398,
-0.0115540847,
0.0023058362,
0.0099118566,
-0.0169095024,
-0.0166517012,
0.0429749005,
-0.0020623817,
-0.0139986277,
0.0554878153,
-0.0036130212,
-0.1074689776,
-0.0385882966,
0.0247850697,
0.0205013268,
0.0724366978,
-0.0605055429,
0.0265769176,
-0.0529675186,
-0.0386100076,
-0.0259204265,
-0.0337592959,
-0.0477298014,
0.0383844227,
-0.0443723723,
-0.0295407847,
-0.0514708087,
0.0105411215,
0.0047141961,
0.0681082159,
-0.017951576,
-0.0060918382,
-0.0077908789,
0.0090460861,
0.0829886496,
0.0126472265,
-0.0193353631,
-0.034404397,
-0.0242948253,
0.043076396,
0.019608181,
0.0250119399,
-0.055298999,
0.0098002627,
0.0360203795,
0.0285429973,
-0.0117573468,
0.0333239958,
0.0560147874,
-0.0380923972,
-0.0268305521,
0.0570797473,
-0.0136452205,
-0.0189887807,
-0.0053711464,
0.0204813052,
0.0356851257,
0.0530948862,
0.0128868576,
-0.0857197717,
-0.0569947846,
0.0108290557,
0.0338374823,
0.0434557348,
-0.0307733435,
-0.0096656727,
-0.1168191656,
0.0480762497,
0.0163877625,
-0.0482309088,
-0.0384096578,
0.0271069594,
0.0502885804,
-0.0313218981,
-0.0215836298,
-0.0312818438,
-0.0231337827,
-0.0056064795,
0.0193082243,
0.0340673514,
-0.0886493027,
0.0345762596,
-0.0574657395,
0.0117431628,
0.0533097759,
-0.0176241212,
-0.0017655253,
-0.0056720492,
0.0449859314,
-0.0423369035,
-0.004206338,
0.0194547996,
0.072478883,
-0.0229414981,
-0.0359885991,
0.0577908382,
0.0294918083,
-0.0309809279,
-0.0091428189,
-0.0012831005,
0.0267725624,
-0.0088515989,
-0.0382168703,
-0.0200459715,
-0.027622588,
0.004968395,
0.0365306288,
0.0262032486,
-0.0273625217,
-0.0222254358,
-0.0064153858,
-0.0492078476,
-0.0501594581,
-0.0304703172,
0.0096537741,
0.0244876407,
-0.0465353243,
-0.0591529235,
0.0069945343,
0.0454777256,
0.0525702499,
-0.0167841259,
-0.0502070859,
0.0031474591,
-0.00008183,
-0.039851509,
0.042053964,
-0.0562801771,
0.0478308164,
-0.0446281843,
0.0084608616,
0.0579243973,
-0.0353586599,
-0.024777174,
0.0262350626,
-0.1025560573,
-0.0503645092,
-0.0166385397,
0.073466979,
0.0220047515,
0.0444619581,
-0.03573706,
-0.0250780843,
0.0255718455,
0.0767697096,
0.0174140744,
0.0406793021,
0.0426716022,
-0.0850307941,
-0.0108643984,
0.0413086563,
-0.057049863,
0.0328133851,
0.0706760958,
0.0003767299,
0.0042258515,
0.0181034282,
-0.0191769786,
-0.032257583,
0.0825044289,
-0.015321658,
-0.0087396801,
-0.0151248043,
0.0038399377,
0.0152586875,
-0.0126597164,
-0.0691194311,
-0.0213766173,
0.0459641665,
0.0127960676,
0.0192056727,
0.024221044,
0.0064532571,
0.0561933257,
-0.056445621,
-0.0077437102,
0.0349982902,
0.0144761195,
0.0172271729,
0.0177666638,
0.0121818837,
0.0179022122,
0.0041042301,
0.0380203798,
-0.0255065877,
0.0218531806,
0.034698721,
0.0344380401,
-0.0281155705,
0.0127882706,
-0.0353186093,
-0.0392992534,
-0.0320543014,
0.0395246372,
0.0347452462,
-0.023382036,
0.0270029642,
-0.0012211875,
-0.0284515787,
-0.0481399447,
0.0454322249,
0.00916998,
-0.0009552048,
0.0500477329,
0.0216537341,
-0.0172166619,
-0.0109175313,
0.0803907514,
0.0717552826,
0.0537128635,
-0.0137874587,
0.018218264,
-0.0245942045,
-0.0256802123,
0.0238945782,
-0.0201308616,
0.0085707558,
0.0451748148,
-0.0548454784,
-0.0798580796,
0.0091986274,
-0.0420075767,
0.0014281551,
0.0262163803,
0.0380995497,
0.0383137912,
-0.0039383103,
-0.0101087922,
-0.0148286391,
-0.0242550876,
0.0224679001,
0.0175557416,
0.0061633261,
-5.933226921e-33,
-0.0209250245,
0.033118207,
0.0130172754,
-0.014107585,
-0.0042884671,
-0.0283992048,
-0.0230317656,
0.0076878984,
-0.0658111498,
0.0140357008,
0.0088370871,
0.0153829046,
0.0232721623,
0.0443797968,
-0.0146500543,
-0.0102110356,
0.0460138731,
0.0099295052,
-0.0264203642,
-0.0233212877,
0.0063442662,
0.0480544902,
0.0776327774,
-0.0443248749,
-0.0595188253,
0.0107390257,
-0.0305988323,
0.0127721271,
0.0255363081,
0.0464312173,
0.0476634391,
0.0094564836,
0.0124760624,
-0.0099217091,
-0.0484954417,
-0.013256927,
-0.0754718259,
-0.0084800748,
0.0132750617,
0.0172677059,
-0.0151436776,
0.0207604002,
0.0429281481,
-0.0101819998,
0.0264019147,
-0.0766406804,
0.0394552909,
-0.0765171945,
-0.0285660233,
-0.0078256205,
-0.055724524,
0.0311522204,
0.0162851028,
-0.0370384865,
0.0287158713,
0.0262844674,
0.0066256593,
0.0372177362,
-0.011537076,
0.0025433393,
0.0079960385,
0.0297231711,
0.0796693787,
0.0642411634,
-0.0094388891,
0.0430203378,
-0.0177529585,
-0.0091283601,
0.0175692439,
-0.039198149,
0.0691287145,
0.0675239488,
0.0050434759,
0.1056826934,
0.0274282843,
-0.0018347005,
-0.0824022815,
0.0041057975,
-0.0368745998,
0.0534471497,
0.0038186193,
0.0211546607,
-0.0076446533,
-0.0250332952,
-0.02767542,
-0.0234830547,
-0.0244351123,
0.0123160724,
0.0515086688,
0.0212568324,
-0.0334289819,
0.0596358664,
0.059065178,
-0.0571247004,
-0.0087126279,
0.0501770712,
-0.0280894656,
0.0287422705,
-0.0030848463,
-0.0074081309,
-0.0564624332,
-0.0428696238,
0.0261383932,
0.0484056063,
0.0218280964,
0.0020422323,
0.0962816924,
0.0300358441,
-0.0451727808,
-0.0162771642,
-0.0478801019,
0.0073853997,
0.0141120153,
0.0928986967,
0.0194392968,
0.0244264398,
-0.0295898914,
0.0499408431,
-0.0047163782,
-0.059993986,
0.0138292164,
0.0310628787,
0.0174782258,
0.0335266739,
-0.0160202011,
-0.0236143544,
-0.0299731158,
-0.0098172892,
0.048201561,
-0.0278759543,
-0.0228907932,
-0.0025686,
2.623e-7,
0.0636124536,
-0.0113302395,
-0.0093458584,
-0.0046164384,
-0.0154153192,
0.0430401191,
-0.0275026225,
0.0374682918,
0.0110071301,
-0.0439902954,
0.0045822472,
0.0436542332,
0.0556198508,
-0.011578517,
-0.0446342155,
0.0500283688,
-0.0045838887,
0.0002449513,
-0.0043653036,
-0.0323695689,
-0.0071566636,
0.0984789878,
0.0217068028,
-0.0202768482,
0.0577727072,
-0.0555322245,
0.0689241514,
-0.0289598741,
0.0358531326,
-0.0107377358,
-0.0755493119,
0.0507722124,
-0.0171508938,
0.0304912385,
-0.0166823864,
0.0224746466,
0.0341915116,
0.0466564074,
-0.0271599796,
0.0355992168,
-0.0334845372,
0.0053381142,
0.0068269805,
-0.0401708186,
0.0635136664,
-0.1244027913,
-0.0212688576,
-0.0368074514,
-0.0332306698,
0.0094108032,
-0.0042420831,
-0.0088374149,
0.0032310833,
0.0063555376,
0.0387412496,
0.0141317444,
-0.0706907362,
-0.0678027347,
-0.0106864823,
-0.0020384712,
-0.0173577797,
-0.0306092724,
-0.0261029787,
-0.0414959267,
0.029757604,
-0.0394371785,
-0.0211773068,
2.169546786e-34,
0.0192998331,
0.0105434228,
-0.0002909664,
-0.0144663379,
-0.0278097503,
-0.0086360043,
-0.0184180513,
0.006660732,
0.0028393529,
-0.0214168224,
0.0134540796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02216v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02216v1 | Exploring the Numerical Reasoning Capabilities of Language Models: A Comprehensive Analysis on Tabular Data | 2023-11-03T20:05:30 | 2023-11-03T20:05:30 | Mubashara Akhtar, Abhilash Shankarampeta, Vivek Gupta, Arpit Patil, Oana Cocarascu, Elena Simperl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Numbers are crucial for various real-world domains such as finance,
economics, and science. Thus, understanding and reasoning with numbers are
essential skills for language models to solve different tasks. While different
numerical benchmarks have been introduced in recent years, they are limited to
specific numerical aspects mostly. In this paper, we propose a hierarchical
taxonomy for numerical reasoning skills with more than ten reasoning types
across four levels: representation, number sense, manipulation, and complex
reasoning. We conduct a comprehensive evaluation of state-of-the-art models to
identify reasoning challenges specific to them. Henceforth, we develop a
diverse set of numerical probes employing a semi-automated approach. We focus
on the tabular Natural Language Inference (TNLI) task as a case study and
measure models' performance shifts. Our results show that no model consistently
excels across all numerical reasoning types. Among the probed models, FlanT5
(few-/zero-shot) and GPT-3.5 (few-shot) demonstrate strong overall numerical
reasoning skills compared to other models. Label-flipping probes indicate that
models often exploit dataset artifacts to predict the correct labels. | [
0.0108520528,
0.0587645546,
-0.0127741853,
0.0482559428,
-0.049583029,
0.0357635356,
0.015670795,
-0.0150981247,
-0.0126797669,
-0.0381153785,
-0.0187495239,
-0.0474966168,
0.0386064798,
0.0083488123,
0.0454000458,
-0.0075786919,
0.043960575,
-0.0439587384,
0.0384403281,
0.0100848563,
0.0053551425,
0.0003239151,
-0.0238677002,
-0.0052501899,
-0.0017690283,
-0.0095815752,
0.0332295634,
-0.0193693675,
-0.0121495277,
-0.0071213082,
-0.0049038776,
0.0354924165,
0.0473845713,
0.0733280405,
0.0000021907,
-0.0391049832,
-0.0350158364,
0.0074163284,
-0.0556698702,
0.0187223442,
0.0631527752,
-0.0694923177,
0.0144640999,
0.0026399221,
-0.0434637815,
-0.0009346281,
0.0458453931,
0.0025698966,
0.0353318676,
0.0565460585,
-0.0143235233,
-0.061991293,
-0.0044724396,
-0.0082177501,
0.0117444964,
-0.0764340907,
0.0037622151,
0.0602626987,
0.0103709176,
0.013628725,
0.0075690034,
0.0304468013,
0.0507712923,
0.0335497558,
-0.0379888713,
0.0408734679,
-0.0478188135,
-0.0064778337,
0.0050136279,
0.0392710455,
0.0100101149,
0.0014402487,
0.0013926259,
-0.0199025273,
0.0001087362,
-0.0068213055,
-0.0595953986,
0.0180382654,
-0.0104764421,
0.0050150612,
0.0477814525,
0.0169110671,
0.0155871855,
0.0016140462,
-0.0493578799,
0.0815504342,
-0.0161190294,
-0.0171946213,
0.0031850496,
-0.0184516013,
-0.056714654,
-0.0091674831,
-0.0044233873,
0.0290330369,
0.0180774927,
0.0332927071,
-0.0035712854,
-0.0277548023,
0.012882716,
-0.0612610988,
0.0501282215,
0.0734120384,
0.0051298914,
0.053533081,
-0.044714056,
0.031415455,
-0.0168095697,
0.0069582644,
0.0096033048,
-0.0055970866,
-0.0269492585,
-0.0338294916,
-0.0324032828,
0.0086258845,
-0.0386051163,
-0.0036302553,
-0.0398940593,
-0.0163057763,
0.0082045998,
0.0043910388,
0.0131502971,
-0.0183474645,
-0.0052048522,
-0.0249499902,
-0.0517048128,
0.0261743739,
-0.0504152998,
0.0070777731,
-0.02067215,
-0.0784626678,
-0.0298930574,
-0.0094883721,
-0.0043090004,
-0.0574699976,
0.0216103829,
0.0756937861,
-0.0092235524,
0.0118147414,
-0.0442029499,
-0.0340646505,
-0.0160138085,
-0.0739209801,
-0.0093882745,
-0.0590985678,
0.0353610441,
0.0274634343,
-0.0273882803,
-0.0506461784,
0.0105557283,
0.0200394187,
-0.0276364144,
0.0894482955,
-0.0012743651,
0.0006304698,
-0.011700782,
-0.0322125331,
0.0008687552,
0.0623692125,
0.0315834545,
-0.0086072171,
0.015458581,
0.0000171082,
0.01357166,
0.0532014892,
0.0005844176,
-0.0508120954,
-0.0329216383,
0.0297010932,
-0.0199410971,
0.0181624442,
0.0294563975,
0.0154317105,
-0.0273618326,
-0.0346899778,
0.0778424069,
0.0676216036,
-0.0007271739,
0.0123067256,
0.0237761661,
-0.0051407591,
0.0303355809,
-0.02012063,
-0.0298723914,
0.032624092,
-0.0299478434,
0.0121456273,
0.0327196568,
-0.0010965074,
0.000141719,
-0.0794732124,
-0.041592218,
0.0068276902,
0.0098500829,
-0.001050237,
0.0607645474,
-0.0261997394,
-0.0395345502,
0.0249679759,
0.0078845946,
-0.0274379347,
-0.0487276278,
-0.030828692,
0.0194438919,
0.0410056002,
0.0220960099,
-0.0420904644,
-0.0318344161,
-0.0015320532,
-0.0126909884,
0.0201550201,
0.0719433874,
-0.000371619,
-0.0222093463,
-0.0250714086,
0.035070207,
-0.0021325785,
0.0577050261,
0.0095401499,
-0.0048800954,
-0.0158813652,
0.0070510013,
-0.0773715526,
-0.0052519501,
0.0079045435,
-0.0221937075,
-0.0396405347,
-0.0136725809,
-0.0162552875,
-0.0261061918,
-0.0056137103,
0.02696638,
0.0330813527,
-0.0026772474,
-0.0034022236,
0.0089976452,
-0.0024145595,
-0.0075617125,
-0.0443883874,
0.0332933702,
-0.0113500245,
-0.0543027408,
0.0116690854,
-0.0354527757,
0.007177155,
0.0519515239,
-0.0452282466,
-0.0102981394,
-0.0433970056,
0.0145767517,
0.0017711171,
0.0258258246,
0.0096076392,
0.0984647572,
-0.0112294555,
0.0411088429,
0.0072475406,
-0.0365903042,
0.010873273,
-0.0160061549,
0.0168823041,
-0.0234837811,
-0.0085047921,
0.0094785728,
0.0088396184,
-0.038619943,
-0.0274152011,
-0.0009176321,
-0.0454013497,
0.0217276011,
-0.0282234456,
0.0520335734,
0.0508657359,
-0.0329570435,
-0.0201838985,
-0.017767122,
-0.0113622071,
-0.0347059332,
0.007920946,
0.0229933634,
0.1000719219,
-0.0230683722,
-0.0009697526,
-0.0456593558,
-0.002093523,
-0.0815669447,
0.0479341038,
0.0155493245,
0.0089008408,
-0.0287817344,
-0.0149234431,
-0.0311376508,
-0.010947397,
-0.0290910844,
0.013060296,
0.0056091775,
-0.0283050276,
0.0178346634,
0.0497141108,
-0.0266989712,
0.0806014761,
-0.0035490645,
-0.0243969094,
-0.02689052,
0.002992304,
-0.0350995511,
0.00055382,
-0.021895973,
-0.0663553029,
-0.0209141448,
0.0958549306,
-0.0183562543,
0.0000119734,
-0.0285577886,
0.0781957507,
-0.0213555191,
0.0125970449,
-0.0241575763,
0.0931610912,
0.0303285532,
0.0635197163,
-0.023440633,
-0.0105962753,
0.0558342114,
-0.0134767666,
-0.0225804262,
-0.043492008,
0.0035295908,
-0.0552159622,
0.0837740004,
0.0322144106,
-0.036916431,
0.0247467328,
0.0036506327,
-0.0274461359,
0.0025651241,
0.0537865758,
-0.0221023541,
0.0789513886,
-0.0665848255,
0.0169470739,
-0.0156851374,
-0.0032251209,
0.0076783928,
-0.0718115047,
-0.0334515683,
0.0509758331,
-0.0033118397,
-0.0326339155,
-0.0418569632,
0.0058605685,
0.0364040174,
0.046513591,
-0.0298863873,
-0.0196454022,
-0.0454481319,
0.0299401321,
0.030239651,
0.0047690463,
0.0529248603,
-0.0449343957,
0.0039747604,
0.0020535123,
0.0054571372,
0.0559514649,
-0.0165889245,
0.0157911759,
0.0169450045,
-0.027053047,
-0.0439837314,
0.0513005704,
0.0199444387,
-0.0832569674,
-0.0030821639,
0.1076465175,
0.0454731695,
0.0430828594,
-0.0013399182,
-0.039064087,
0.0343741998,
0.016185334,
0.0409536585,
-0.0787403807,
-0.0390693881,
-0.0020259209,
-0.0120078819,
-0.0027060304,
-0.0777457282,
-0.0398857817,
-0.1319286078,
0.0690560713,
-0.0144583145,
-0.0359939486,
-0.0487727709,
-0.0533212349,
0.0189146586,
-0.0339632779,
-0.0046173655,
0.0424963422,
-0.0223834254,
0.0391277,
0.0137303872,
-0.0333422385,
-0.0502326973,
0.0243070908,
-0.0123266103,
0.0218502954,
0.0160735603,
0.0404831134,
-0.0294450093,
-0.0280224308,
-0.0167454388,
0.0176796112,
-0.01494582,
0.0034099719,
0.0426554047,
0.0046301433,
0.0132789565,
0.0036709181,
0.0169339683,
-0.0581693053,
0.0249210373,
-0.03115803,
0.0623825006,
-0.020273393,
-0.0300295558,
0.0316850096,
0.0173778646,
-0.0488354005,
0.0814242214,
0.0493773632,
0.0033410757,
-0.0653386191,
-0.0532285273,
-0.0384745188,
-0.0449871048,
-0.0284150727,
-0.0074099791,
0.0462154858,
-0.0693825036,
-0.0371668376,
-0.0293611884,
0.0376900956,
0.0258448031,
-0.0264931433,
0.0053972546,
0.0307969823,
-0.007607711,
-0.0217910912,
0.0041031493,
-0.0348804295,
0.043523211,
-0.0243798681,
0.0254015457,
0.0392592698,
-0.0279469043,
-0.0554162599,
0.0234495755,
-0.1024385244,
-0.0458046831,
-0.0152183389,
0.0281105377,
0.0316991992,
-0.0012602549,
-0.0016573704,
-0.0121424356,
-0.0522250198,
0.0424576327,
-0.0605062917,
0.0083437059,
0.0319052413,
0.0071121226,
0.0216883719,
0.0348303318,
-0.0007871049,
0.0284280572,
-0.0204891674,
0.0450539924,
-0.071147345,
0.0160763338,
0.0491417386,
0.0060921321,
0.0224772934,
0.0502991751,
-0.0538935587,
0.0083031403,
0.009027997,
-0.036524795,
-0.0534163639,
-0.0163708124,
-0.0119485371,
0.0034466425,
0.0397061035,
-0.0568003245,
-0.0202104449,
0.0313499458,
0.0458705463,
-0.0185889285,
0.0024252569,
0.042173937,
0.0305837244,
-0.0233045593,
-0.0669213831,
0.0067042285,
-0.0139766308,
-0.0265112054,
0.0853918865,
-0.006174284,
0.0504350848,
0.0239216872,
-0.0109683555,
-0.0294734072,
0.0004383074,
-0.0577167906,
-0.0642492622,
0.0182375666,
-0.0012450092,
0.0058006532,
-0.0129148616,
0.0065601659,
-0.0393318757,
0.0055708406,
0.0148688192,
0.0148769831,
0.0359625891,
-0.0158390962,
0.0134802694,
0.0263155755,
-0.018190857,
-0.0468782447,
0.0518971793,
0.0265253913,
0.007323456,
-0.015533084,
-0.0242829826,
0.0022875359,
-0.0143704414,
-0.0060140085,
-0.0009383175,
0.019922277,
0.0116304178,
-0.0870667845,
-0.0685682967,
0.011716879,
0.0330866724,
-0.0152271371,
-0.0090533653,
0.0122717731,
0.0864351466,
-0.0147817312,
0.000851161,
-0.0462263711,
0.0121182911,
-0.0128194792,
0.0006667436,
-0.0840457752,
-6.530569069e-33,
-0.0301334802,
-0.0115744518,
0.0359279811,
-0.0350796953,
0.0330977812,
-0.0318920016,
-0.0576447286,
0.0091345096,
-0.0238151718,
-0.0039618807,
0.00083586,
0.0185456388,
0.0133781089,
0.0043175775,
-0.0014452578,
-0.0499861948,
0.0022495212,
-0.0146345105,
-0.0101516796,
-0.0637385473,
0.0102505023,
0.0357734412,
0.0851672515,
-0.0401864909,
0.0672470704,
0.0048896833,
0.0180506669,
0.0240161587,
0.002357061,
0.026336547,
0.0124284578,
0.013071591,
0.0218818355,
-0.0820039809,
-0.0298094749,
-0.00442761,
-0.0604104102,
-0.0520908274,
0.0534321144,
0.0299097858,
0.0081585422,
-0.0107652312,
0.0242908541,
-0.0187931508,
-0.0270539485,
-0.0230751149,
0.0446297191,
-0.0283676814,
0.0415430926,
0.0105406372,
-0.0373381823,
0.0493990816,
-0.0131495846,
-0.0002971153,
0.0541554578,
0.0811331421,
-0.0153445518,
0.0362132676,
-0.0601699129,
0.0028938784,
0.0251538269,
0.033272814,
0.044313252,
-0.0257410966,
0.0198083315,
0.0332495496,
0.0284106974,
-0.0119455475,
-0.081175223,
-0.0116270082,
0.0405494347,
0.0367146507,
0.0578703769,
0.0174621139,
0.0911183804,
0.0307498742,
-0.0441674516,
-0.0002957394,
0.0434940606,
-0.0086980583,
0.0190917682,
-0.0020861477,
-0.0507926345,
-0.0276104789,
-0.0451922193,
-0.0195781328,
-0.0458186828,
-0.0017528777,
0.0134079671,
-0.0400924683,
0.0462107211,
0.0180354491,
0.0191285871,
-0.0280577838,
-0.0387555622,
0.0026535874,
0.0134115415,
0.0389702134,
0.0145677784,
0.0592172444,
-0.0429186076,
-0.0064658164,
-0.0336741507,
0.0072736712,
0.048458524,
0.01666045,
0.0291988403,
0.0179299582,
-0.0446826257,
-0.0339375362,
-0.0451504067,
0.0003105178,
0.0018670781,
0.0398967154,
0.0158481821,
0.031086145,
-0.0038880105,
0.0120191341,
0.0088751549,
0.0045327805,
-0.0334827863,
0.0307484306,
-0.0409223437,
0.0043418123,
0.0004669283,
-0.0372750647,
-0.0114233093,
0.0259587299,
0.0020128784,
-0.043428991,
0.0040283157,
0.0571564622,
2.886e-7,
0.0861837119,
0.0584361367,
-0.0088877995,
0.0234965514,
0.017354669,
0.0344927944,
-0.0209158864,
-0.0171205904,
0.0073999492,
-0.0466657504,
0.0376079865,
0.0088144066,
0.0521321669,
0.0507891774,
-0.0373758823,
0.0003873233,
-0.0482293293,
0.003947868,
-0.0376437828,
0.0228613373,
0.030644659,
0.0797085837,
0.014007967,
0.0100241331,
-0.0008368617,
-0.0262674913,
0.0425068811,
-0.0241904594,
0.0272468869,
0.0151337357,
0.0185290743,
-0.0068114912,
0.0157745108,
0.048522979,
0.0090894932,
0.0197852589,
0.0217055064,
0.0671688244,
-0.0061874981,
0.0263465773,
-0.0222644303,
-0.0679400042,
-0.0319642611,
-0.0750987157,
0.0874374807,
-0.0749144033,
-0.0378759392,
0.0125744417,
-0.0370133221,
0.0134208566,
0.0199603587,
0.01496494,
-0.0110544367,
0.0138851181,
0.0443915464,
-0.0374158546,
-0.0016119273,
-0.0532355942,
-0.0159931108,
0.0187845938,
-0.0378645062,
-0.0199788641,
-0.0469712615,
-0.0120707909,
0.0330223441,
-0.0495305397,
-0.0079085939,
2.977934481e-34,
0.0559007935,
-0.0089478204,
0.0027512973,
0.0388479978,
0.0884797573,
0.0117418021,
-0.0019526815,
0.0331416801,
0.0377294645,
-0.0656604841,
-0.0055429274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04929v1 | An Interdisciplinary Outlook on Large Language Models for Scientific Research | 2023-11-03T19:41:09 | 2023-11-03T19:41:09 | James Boyko, Joseph Cohen, Nathan Fox, Maria Han Veiga, Jennifer I-Hsiu Li, Jing Liu, Bernardo Modenesi, Andreas H. Rauch, Kenneth N. Reid, Soumi Tribedi, Anastasia Visheratina, Xin Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL, cs.LG | In this paper, we describe the capabilities and constraints of Large Language
Models (LLMs) within disparate academic disciplines, aiming to delineate their
strengths and limitations with precision. We examine how LLMs augment
scientific inquiry, offering concrete examples such as accelerating literature
review by summarizing vast numbers of publications, enhancing code development
through automated syntax correction, and refining the scientific writing
process. Simultaneously, we articulate the challenges LLMs face, including
their reliance on extensive and sometimes biased datasets, and the potential
ethical dilemmas stemming from their use. Our critical discussion extends to
the varying impacts of LLMs across fields, from the natural sciences, where
they help model complex biological sequences, to the social sciences, where
they can parse large-scale qualitative data. We conclude by offering a nuanced
perspective on how LLMs can be both a boon and a boundary to scientific
progress. | [
0.0418977141,
0.1315930337,
-0.0239313971,
0.0164130889,
-0.0431776717,
0.0115393326,
0.0442707725,
0.006782339,
-0.0040906672,
-0.04751518,
0.0163931567,
-0.0377115905,
0.0207077693,
0.0261280369,
0.0076966393,
-0.0251677092,
0.022915177,
-0.0473966897,
0.0521356575,
-0.0196062885,
-0.0188581944,
-0.0077093216,
0.0408672318,
0.030767139,
0.0564769953,
-0.0193832237,
0.0338630714,
-0.0448497906,
-0.0124263968,
-0.0208822489,
-0.0197880045,
0.0503035374,
0.0206421018,
0.0931337997,
0.0000018698,
-0.0523832217,
-0.0047462992,
0.0620200709,
-0.0101483343,
0.0376289561,
0.0529753491,
-0.0360554568,
-0.0004896243,
-0.0254634507,
-0.0011560747,
-0.0271481294,
0.0772034377,
-0.0648923889,
-0.0153085543,
0.0291671697,
0.0155992433,
-0.0465599522,
0.0362859592,
-0.0238163918,
-0.021245053,
0.0399909131,
0.0898094028,
0.038529899,
0.0542971753,
0.0574603491,
-0.0063539487,
0.0658279806,
-0.0014398944,
-0.0358589068,
0.0127696749,
0.0152768977,
-0.0152656836,
-0.03016055,
0.0434863828,
0.0239899643,
0.0312599316,
-0.0382270403,
0.0540002622,
-0.0027071873,
-0.0261601955,
0.0317492709,
-0.0718242899,
0.0741567686,
0.0046303207,
-0.0025007741,
0.0283770785,
-0.0264830031,
0.0422026478,
0.0437437519,
-0.0333247446,
0.0510978065,
0.0206824504,
-0.0298382156,
-0.0441923775,
0.0027343668,
-0.003638319,
-0.0595521592,
-0.0083918311,
0.0000813971,
-0.0046269884,
0.0145906694,
0.0075022662,
-0.0202794597,
0.0822718218,
-0.0035071059,
0.0246437564,
-0.0092788478,
0.0182865616,
0.0245463736,
0.0632803366,
-0.0125160422,
-0.0474157147,
-0.0193712264,
0.0029419076,
0.0051438464,
-0.0489606857,
-0.0457209311,
0.021764962,
-0.0282180216,
-0.0218085069,
0.0468050092,
-0.0207338873,
-0.0076509737,
0.0003626042,
-0.0092687467,
-0.0388329141,
-0.0261419769,
-0.0448222868,
0.0170810986,
0.0090646306,
0.0391919352,
0.0173063055,
0.0317817181,
-0.029085584,
-0.0433338098,
-0.0117190881,
0.006121573,
-0.0015826456,
-0.0253257025,
0.0082127098,
0.044538565,
0.0654681548,
-0.0145751936,
0.0327633396,
-0.0330611095,
-0.0512881279,
-0.0438671485,
0.0045047509,
-0.0725404024,
0.0439668261,
0.0261940341,
-0.0076551288,
-0.0645980239,
-0.0174849574,
-0.010762875,
-0.0548154488,
0.0522070266,
-0.0870340914,
0.0086867614,
0.0110768685,
0.0049598319,
0.0483292788,
0.0262493528,
0.0329798646,
-0.0508651957,
0.0287247803,
-0.0448374227,
0.0110113956,
0.0071730129,
-0.0046350164,
0.023175111,
-0.0426023193,
0.0196639299,
0.0132577131,
0.0305074137,
-0.0024942167,
0.0705181807,
-0.0244105402,
-0.0225715116,
0.0472141728,
0.0899239928,
-0.0283924863,
0.0488323644,
0.0236913115,
-0.0035919398,
0.0078517236,
-0.0175164919,
-0.0062665879,
0.0054577929,
0.0047793523,
0.0055456706,
0.010585703,
0.0419949554,
0.0078387093,
-0.0169144887,
-0.0246819556,
0.0254703145,
-0.0093849124,
0.0053331065,
0.0515146255,
-0.0467833914,
0.044859346,
0.0146516366,
0.0534952134,
-0.0368826017,
0.0284800772,
-0.0160329044,
0.0440123826,
0.0238859076,
0.0497992374,
-0.0411196239,
-0.0085583702,
-0.0356240645,
0.0175993945,
0.059172716,
0.0228484403,
-0.0118758697,
-0.0438301042,
0.0029133321,
-0.0018435898,
-0.0131749399,
-0.0056288582,
-0.0091097942,
-0.0087985462,
0.0059131323,
0.0035126016,
-0.0172539391,
-0.0712738112,
0.015552694,
-0.080950059,
-0.0041462616,
-0.0260971542,
-0.0581498891,
0.0362270698,
-0.0034481371,
-0.0603806712,
0.0326476917,
0.0343376659,
-0.0272380617,
-0.0194044244,
-0.0162893608,
0.0339153111,
0.0404270627,
0.0575292632,
-0.04258845,
0.0056030666,
-0.0078118253,
-0.0052278936,
-0.0165900756,
0.0406746715,
-0.0088195335,
0.0468150191,
-0.0008204719,
0.0113362325,
-0.0819088891,
0.0092981597,
-0.0352843069,
0.0223072991,
0.0023719408,
0.0781929493,
0.0056209401,
-0.0592270754,
0.017659435,
-0.0227586105,
-0.0381277762,
0.0402631573,
0.0336276293,
-0.0053803497,
0.0526386425,
-0.0378537364,
0.0069522671,
-0.0332744606,
-0.0383841321,
-0.0022196805,
0.0214766543,
0.0082149412,
-0.0102989683,
-0.0181065835,
-0.0118438993,
0.0386332311,
0.0090199821,
-0.0551224127,
0.0197414905,
0.0368651897,
0.0379904024,
-0.013335214,
-0.0431903079,
-0.0659005791,
-0.0560228713,
-0.0377826318,
0.0784031153,
0.0359799229,
-0.0052412548,
-0.0563205853,
0.0221332163,
-0.0419221185,
-0.0037864132,
-0.0158251897,
-0.0056801615,
0.0345008522,
-0.0039197295,
0.0209755339,
0.0311709084,
-0.0258533154,
0.0209594946,
0.0822662562,
-0.0104853418,
-0.016637966,
-0.0444360487,
-0.0103345066,
-0.0062018149,
-0.0029407402,
-0.038290333,
-0.0026510968,
0.0372545049,
-0.0192002803,
-0.0516676717,
0.0054581692,
0.0431606881,
-0.0629158542,
-0.0145217516,
0.0177890696,
-0.0393357836,
-0.0150242569,
0.0358302705,
-0.0117778359,
-0.0478705168,
0.0530342162,
-0.0344472714,
0.0108629204,
-0.0544550344,
-0.0084887603,
-0.0293578804,
0.058572378,
0.0075936415,
-0.0111161256,
0.0359357558,
0.0110185808,
-0.0087259458,
-0.0035567463,
-0.0182687249,
-0.022858534,
0.0477310233,
-0.0788965449,
0.0480457582,
-0.0005650264,
-0.0242779125,
0.0115040652,
-0.0347088426,
-0.0451823808,
0.0377147608,
0.044084914,
-0.0300298128,
-0.0372850262,
0.0227591526,
0.0853442177,
0.0111849159,
-0.0198934805,
0.0109459348,
-0.0156383514,
-0.0253371671,
0.0466813557,
-0.0316541679,
0.0480766892,
-0.0269232076,
0.0307259485,
0.0428089909,
-0.0128808515,
0.0536605045,
-0.0233852249,
-0.0106278621,
0.0173143428,
-0.0370057635,
-0.0292707887,
0.0004322972,
0.0242254511,
-0.0582545139,
-0.0132001927,
0.1006414518,
0.0120479558,
-0.0513942242,
0.0106861489,
-0.0384504013,
-0.0129951965,
0.0273927562,
0.0190785918,
-0.0870995298,
0.0255883392,
0.0019748029,
-0.0070967507,
-0.0313119069,
-0.0703418329,
0.0093200579,
-0.0696107075,
0.0436074734,
0.0367206782,
-0.0248374529,
-0.0148732616,
-0.0672206059,
0.0068048085,
-0.0052153012,
0.0074981181,
0.0421409011,
-0.0201089978,
0.0060230405,
0.0253346693,
-0.0163049605,
-0.0641984791,
0.0221754666,
-0.0388496295,
0.0539311841,
0.0329293497,
0.0396458507,
-0.0432180353,
0.0070544025,
-0.014668854,
-0.0080563072,
-0.0357910618,
0.0149351219,
-0.0143199321,
0.0822572857,
-0.0180296823,
-0.0454353578,
0.0317996256,
-0.0382652692,
-0.0183633473,
0.0187541414,
0.0980532989,
-0.0249753967,
-0.0330532864,
-0.0484780557,
-0.0132401893,
-0.0205974877,
0.0703836977,
0.0381638743,
-0.0318058282,
-0.0212205965,
-0.0302347932,
-0.0266548805,
0.0243763383,
-0.0537763163,
0.014089386,
-0.0244003311,
-0.0371139646,
-0.0146487728,
-0.0115210116,
0.0388482958,
-0.0173513386,
0.0497034267,
0.0089126844,
0.0651649833,
-0.0541974455,
-0.025375424,
0.0332758166,
-0.0382658318,
0.0085792672,
-0.0414347649,
-0.0062614162,
0.0529527739,
0.0236175805,
-0.0091184154,
0.0030199829,
-0.0468598232,
-0.0889374018,
-0.0014870081,
0.0205650125,
0.0221450757,
-0.0068361182,
0.0335496515,
-0.0808663741,
0.0110379225,
0.051007662,
-0.0088779796,
0.0196541212,
-0.0493573472,
-0.0097484542,
0.0007185342,
-0.0020395098,
-0.0300344396,
0.0023240147,
0.0044070547,
0.0143054426,
-0.0682623386,
-0.0379534215,
0.0218541827,
0.0335088372,
0.0382242948,
-0.036314372,
-0.022690136,
0.0102225663,
-0.037492428,
-0.0573839098,
-0.0262819398,
-0.0145768533,
0.0028729122,
0.0039323377,
0.0176219363,
-0.0273539703,
0.0321639888,
-0.0416588262,
0.050098069,
-0.0561825261,
0.0865412578,
-0.0096149938,
0.0040148073,
0.0553647839,
-0.009368415,
-0.0201072022,
0.0195609834,
-0.0712650418,
0.0378223248,
0.0045017484,
-0.0165758394,
0.0050250688,
0.0137396799,
-0.0020558559,
-0.0060578608,
-0.0818990469,
-0.0429085419,
0.0118843894,
0.010639145,
0.021057684,
0.0211516749,
0.0343913883,
-0.0291118398,
-0.0264945347,
-0.0598488934,
0.0242860168,
0.0152296629,
-0.019051088,
0.0365589522,
0.0263762698,
-0.0696467236,
-0.0416878685,
0.0692557618,
0.0537199639,
0.0321838483,
0.0011805148,
-0.0346129127,
0.0143407593,
-0.0589262545,
-0.0139018446,
-0.0392173305,
-0.009062212,
-0.0349598378,
-0.0842958167,
-0.0497633144,
0.008802874,
0.027622994,
-0.018591335,
-0.0332322381,
-0.0272633471,
0.0287083331,
0.0029186583,
-0.0273483098,
-0.0422358625,
0.0800402239,
-0.0184149146,
-0.0644405112,
0.0120411851,
-5.871547997e-33,
0.0183138922,
-0.0189851709,
-0.0015279475,
-0.0171434414,
-0.0252933279,
0.0226161648,
-0.046333801,
-0.0107569555,
-0.0028905219,
0.0235229395,
-0.0149527807,
-0.0000112779,
-0.0176733024,
0.004691944,
0.0745465532,
0.034644369,
0.0426609926,
-0.0012789001,
0.025305476,
0.0177199095,
0.0372662619,
-0.0020680486,
0.0275952052,
-0.0464004278,
0.0583831333,
0.0026878007,
0.0276189912,
0.0098834848,
-0.0156082986,
0.0480425544,
-0.0258555654,
0.0273089316,
-0.003622375,
-0.0355347842,
-0.015646141,
-0.02915751,
-0.0183537714,
0.0433046967,
0.0428933129,
-0.00498205,
0.0357916541,
-0.0505625084,
0.0683306232,
-0.0046177614,
-0.0245286077,
-0.0038351424,
0.0290392227,
-0.0585538931,
-0.0478037298,
-0.0530427173,
-0.0522604659,
0.0149512952,
-0.0227547567,
0.0501364991,
0.0167783275,
-0.0237361807,
-0.0054433383,
0.0745880976,
-0.0101653757,
0.0388447419,
0.064196609,
0.0233760551,
0.0455257781,
-0.0032220511,
0.0439815335,
0.0594398193,
-0.0125519382,
-0.0031221143,
0.0152971065,
0.0069588106,
0.0277181715,
0.0203084312,
0.0299917515,
0.065951623,
0.0179864969,
-0.010439463,
-0.0822666734,
-0.0120865526,
-0.0042820871,
0.0101853861,
0.0184943471,
0.0187062267,
0.0189455077,
-0.0349657871,
-0.0412039794,
-0.0149395708,
0.0031692497,
0.0071423659,
-0.0229644999,
-0.0484979488,
-0.0440254845,
0.0420834646,
0.0680189729,
-0.0587650836,
-0.078659974,
0.0246223547,
-0.0076244469,
0.0410216153,
0.0041677253,
0.029896412,
-0.0758183226,
-0.0278501138,
-0.0136259887,
0.0106156794,
0.0338974595,
0.0037674962,
-0.0043856716,
0.0230662674,
-0.0337690264,
-0.0021570181,
-0.0165472869,
-0.0101496102,
0.0359227657,
0.0063822046,
0.0155735491,
0.0303860791,
0.0534656532,
0.0268542543,
0.0515353903,
0.0075564729,
0.0105441194,
0.0498413593,
-0.0316922851,
0.0279865358,
-0.0250182375,
-0.0306433644,
-0.0241540149,
0.0497730672,
0.045133207,
-0.0541634038,
-0.0052541895,
-0.0165717602,
2.687e-7,
0.0663689896,
0.0662917197,
0.0096303448,
0.002612693,
0.0439577661,
0.0072454964,
-0.0081059784,
0.0247622728,
-0.0169784259,
-0.0095284227,
0.0027263113,
-0.0044200793,
0.0352876186,
0.0301174503,
-0.0561178625,
-0.0163317434,
-0.0747019276,
-0.0265689958,
-0.088533096,
-0.0268046949,
-0.0271565747,
0.048496332,
0.0203158464,
0.0193276256,
-0.0155994184,
-0.0450779945,
0.0425247885,
-0.0324244425,
0.0117445644,
0.0674512833,
-0.0104125543,
-0.0126573564,
0.0155717339,
-0.0025693607,
0.0087432442,
0.0052374406,
-0.006967715,
0.059304487,
0.0039042984,
0.0585949086,
0.0367467813,
-0.0341466628,
0.0065555614,
-0.0574572161,
0.0447174571,
-0.0366938896,
-0.0411115848,
-0.0541487597,
-0.0206486341,
-0.0291807838,
0.0141212745,
-0.0233582146,
0.0128481667,
0.0393151455,
-0.0218525082,
-0.0042451406,
-0.0024800228,
-0.0222264603,
-0.0256401058,
0.0309170801,
-0.0681999102,
-0.0612693988,
0.0088783214,
-0.0172812063,
-0.0006226636,
-0.0431020223,
0.0444642045,
2.758047013e-34,
0.0615043417,
-0.0127443774,
-0.0050024181,
0.0105804047,
0.0157634132,
0.0130359037,
-0.0251355525,
0.025153609,
0.0100102294,
-0.0762103349,
-0.0002241223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02205v2 | An Introduction to Natural Language Processing Techniques and Framework for Clinical Implementation in Radiation Oncology | 2023-11-03T19:32:35 | 2023-11-08T11:51:16 | Reza Khanmohammadi, Mohammad M. Ghassemi, Kyle Verdecchia, Ahmed I. Ghanem, Luo Bing, Indrin J. Chetty, Hassan Bagher-Ebadian, Farzan Siddiqui, Mohamed Elshaikh, Benjamin Movsas, Kundan Thind | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Processing (NLP) is a key technique for developing Medical
Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems that leverage Electronic Health Record
(EHR) data to build diagnostic and prognostic models. NLP enables the
conversion of unstructured clinical text into structured data that can be fed
into AI algorithms. The emergence of the transformer architecture and large
language models (LLMs) has led to remarkable advances in NLP for various
healthcare tasks, such as entity recognition, relation extraction, sentence
similarity, text summarization, and question answering. In this article, we
review the major technical innovations that underpin modern NLP models and
present state-of-the-art NLP applications that employ LLMs in radiation
oncology research. However, these LLMs are prone to many errors such as
hallucinations, biases, and ethical violations, which necessitate rigorous
evaluation and validation before clinical deployment. As such, we propose a
comprehensive framework for assessing the NLP models based on their purpose and
clinical fit, technical performance, bias and trust, legal and ethical
implications, and quality assurance, prior to implementation in clinical
radiation oncology. Our article aims to provide guidance and insights for
researchers and clinicians who are interested in developing and using NLP
models in clinical radiation oncology. | [
0.0775925517,
0.0765069574,
0.0238805283,
-0.0195328593,
-0.0191036258,
0.045446001,
0.0018403998,
0.0190789327,
0.0349179506,
-0.0328675956,
0.0182079934,
-0.039587643,
0.0042576944,
0.0293001663,
-0.0068739257,
-0.046579022,
0.0051541287,
0.0162065756,
0.0344975628,
0.0321411081,
-0.0037552924,
0.0264688767,
-0.0142122097,
0.0431779921,
0.0246894844,
0.0345271565,
0.0569835566,
-0.0072326334,
-0.0124718258,
-0.0807418376,
-0.0405087359,
-0.0176427122,
-0.028137397,
0.0125981346,
0.0000018805,
-0.0911899507,
-0.0584566407,
0.0451882184,
-0.016857611,
-0.0648590997,
0.0837308466,
-0.0633714646,
0.0099510094,
0.028791694,
-0.0155213242,
-0.0019391562,
0.0243189987,
0.0813648999,
0.0419982411,
0.080202125,
-0.0375377536,
-0.0448605716,
0.0638061091,
0.0257421248,
-0.0126400487,
-0.0011521762,
0.0344695598,
-0.0143596157,
-0.0018965434,
0.0088979695,
0.0345037654,
0.0691543967,
-0.0156912878,
0.0410146341,
0.0141639989,
0.0569121204,
-0.0166432895,
0.0047290977,
-0.0250349808,
0.0163644217,
0.0176571161,
-0.0020835081,
0.0755203441,
-0.0006046413,
-0.0102610495,
0.0094609736,
-0.0061901226,
0.0175567865,
-0.0243194923,
-0.008609754,
-0.0148484623,
-0.0124914274,
-0.027008675,
-0.0198774282,
-0.0187793765,
0.0170248598,
0.0193477701,
-0.0301399045,
0.0130484253,
-0.0004304317,
0.0196500439,
-0.0421507172,
0.0548332073,
0.0449498259,
-0.0272879004,
0.0488715172,
-0.0361334011,
-0.0063186735,
0.1028855518,
-0.0887401551,
-0.0220841095,
-0.0095342677,
0.0100856433,
0.0457865037,
-0.0359048955,
0.0158429258,
-0.0170592666,
0.0395228304,
-0.0555447824,
0.0019075903,
-0.0367482975,
-0.017979579,
-0.0311762225,
0.0320225917,
-0.0056475364,
-0.0132215871,
-0.0798082277,
-0.0098739266,
0.0332320407,
0.0503987819,
0.0606857277,
0.0327723026,
-0.0103948526,
0.0200166199,
-0.0165898111,
-0.0214850195,
0.0118993241,
-0.0194183607,
-0.0214301217,
-0.0568958856,
0.0347337648,
0.0116869295,
-0.00066463,
-0.0370509699,
0.0052168351,
0.0779752061,
0.0370732322,
-0.0272735618,
0.0297332574,
-0.0318696611,
-0.0439550728,
-0.0377690941,
0.0375567824,
-0.0619220659,
0.0217863657,
0.0304218549,
0.0044861515,
-0.0414192043,
0.0195479915,
0.0139653767,
-0.0767018422,
0.0607481562,
-0.0255358741,
0.0133268638,
0.0327123925,
0.0007311155,
0.0416232236,
-0.0175023433,
0.0416017547,
-0.053370133,
0.0067945807,
-0.0150513016,
-0.0030039081,
-0.0067281811,
-0.005242629,
-0.0570343509,
-0.0101469494,
0.0248962119,
-0.0350855626,
0.0493870638,
-0.0413491391,
0.0923709199,
0.0197668783,
-0.0141379694,
0.0070358682,
0.082749106,
0.0283141602,
0.0535560362,
-0.0153314425,
-0.0001840742,
-0.0161881559,
-0.0143557759,
-0.0187314358,
0.0097055528,
-0.0189760309,
0.0125747854,
-0.022146875,
0.0088725826,
-0.0078484602,
-0.0421904474,
-0.0443166979,
0.0070113521,
0.0188086014,
-0.0141192777,
0.0163535904,
-0.0067290189,
-0.0438264944,
0.0074083894,
0.0602066293,
-0.0145591097,
-0.0269408282,
-0.0453070588,
-0.0812615752,
0.097678557,
0.0445255302,
-0.0587693714,
-0.0153201297,
-0.0440707728,
0.0016126006,
0.0263898727,
-0.003334142,
0.0282798316,
-0.018888345,
0.0050017904,
-0.012776237,
0.0566387884,
-0.0190162305,
-0.0270342249,
-0.0228659846,
0.016597325,
-0.0299152788,
0.0050053578,
-0.050493598,
0.0716798007,
-0.0286178403,
-0.0517771393,
-0.0483450703,
0.0060778004,
0.0082330545,
0.0152772833,
-0.0050323019,
0.0355870202,
0.0269981083,
-0.0258014817,
-0.0706319585,
0.0244023185,
-0.0281060059,
-0.0128443157,
0.0005726519,
-0.0334119275,
-0.0042758118,
-0.042350322,
-0.0177036878,
0.0140258083,
-0.0377130732,
-0.0427668616,
0.0263004024,
0.0209497344,
0.0253670495,
0.0344097801,
0.0027494282,
-0.0644113645,
0.0393915959,
-0.0463165753,
0.0075653228,
-0.0104142614,
-0.1059979573,
0.0108108763,
-0.0327894874,
-0.049844522,
0.0242310073,
-0.0135852257,
0.0021388216,
0.0091690402,
0.0013858631,
-0.017465923,
-0.0079513844,
-0.08370848,
0.0085359039,
0.0244253781,
0.0439430214,
0.0309902281,
0.0113030914,
-0.0116143469,
-0.034021318,
-0.040914055,
-0.0356438607,
0.054341536,
0.0189998746,
0.0568111055,
0.02283209,
0.0014552906,
-0.0392002352,
-0.0377406403,
-0.0561394431,
0.0624009408,
0.0335559025,
-0.0374701507,
-0.0271339733,
0.0672974885,
-0.0188999623,
0.0042493679,
0.0182969049,
-0.0269760024,
0.0319252871,
-0.0152567802,
-0.0279596541,
0.0554776005,
0.024587201,
0.0342232846,
0.0214551762,
-0.0065046451,
-0.0182950217,
-0.015259508,
-0.0551772378,
-0.0385012738,
0.009436639,
-0.0329746827,
0.0357567742,
0.0269413739,
0.021555474,
-0.0014398693,
-0.0177243948,
-0.0178426821,
-0.0451001786,
0.0228150189,
-0.0316377021,
0.0067249537,
-0.0390257202,
-0.0353226736,
0.0104938271,
0.0073120752,
0.1063572913,
-0.0005875427,
0.036614392,
-0.1235480979,
-0.0101796081,
-0.0261580702,
0.0117017133,
0.0235701222,
0.0331911333,
0.0543319546,
-0.0091155162,
0.026267888,
-0.0233215187,
0.0048904065,
-0.0443583764,
0.0550304502,
0.0030490065,
0.0425256304,
0.0131261926,
0.0069580469,
-0.0493217595,
-0.0046105366,
-0.0057554925,
0.0031626113,
0.0060007907,
0.0115013542,
-0.0672430247,
-0.0120423492,
0.0137941483,
0.045472648,
0.0278006271,
-0.0463651232,
-0.0232850797,
0.0446716994,
0.0394683555,
-0.0240952261,
0.0380117334,
0.0227856319,
0.0310720783,
0.0771918744,
0.0030546226,
-0.0027354353,
-0.0055979816,
-0.0095248288,
-0.0055738674,
-0.06676393,
0.0329187997,
0.0283589512,
0.045828566,
-0.0361901671,
0.0169292558,
0.1124148816,
0.0365467444,
-0.0119158076,
0.0189253129,
0.0488523878,
-0.0479503088,
-0.0152785834,
0.0226340126,
-0.0492192656,
0.0059641241,
-0.0359914638,
-0.0011331701,
-0.0457691625,
-0.0490125529,
0.0251030289,
-0.0090621803,
0.0100290431,
-0.0372669399,
-0.0465135276,
-0.0011270273,
-0.039367903,
-0.0069025499,
-0.0003957457,
-0.0210909527,
-0.0128481695,
-0.030724477,
-0.0372708514,
0.0092803594,
-0.0787926167,
-0.051772926,
-0.0099914819,
-0.0554914847,
0.0357712284,
0.0465067588,
0.0676299855,
-0.049856104,
-0.0008984123,
-0.0310619604,
0.0084157269,
0.0088353958,
0.0167227685,
0.0828479081,
0.0181856211,
0.0044986871,
-0.0686954707,
0.0164270755,
-0.0445108861,
-0.0160647128,
-0.0159321353,
0.0576088689,
-0.0520990752,
-0.0326123759,
-0.0279521663,
0.0015598625,
0.0194616523,
0.0356563441,
-0.0307457764,
0.0188790299,
-0.0664996952,
-0.0096886307,
0.066940628,
0.0292221252,
-0.0388869159,
0.0265570264,
-0.0241624489,
-0.0102660488,
-0.1053304076,
-0.0123841017,
0.0250397883,
-0.0435286239,
0.0182749815,
0.0126840444,
0.0094089163,
-0.0131248962,
-0.0336380489,
0.0426509231,
0.0312431082,
0.0055848421,
-0.0234012473,
-0.0463711619,
0.023863595,
-0.0073178257,
-0.0210889727,
0.0033790946,
0.0103874756,
0.001367238,
-0.0038170961,
0.0325935371,
0.0185208376,
-0.0386353508,
0.01044467,
-0.0159602072,
0.0451189093,
0.0383919626,
-0.0571570471,
-0.024590401,
-0.0330340937,
0.0072711576,
-0.0004923751,
-0.0137607027,
-0.0107511608,
0.0376910046,
-0.0107710017,
0.0036929776,
-0.017568985,
-0.0273041092,
0.0478558205,
0.0559371002,
0.0116822459,
0.0004752076,
-0.0038453704,
-0.0050145122,
-0.0244681407,
-0.047149118,
0.0160504971,
-0.0202818364,
-0.0089586368,
-0.0129992962,
0.0479599722,
-0.0200633518,
0.0328833014,
-0.0706514046,
-0.0283688195,
-0.0499619097,
0.0657834262,
0.0592733547,
0.0020467958,
0.0312442277,
-0.0238433741,
0.00760841,
-0.0085349632,
-0.0080168014,
-0.0018967601,
0.0106450832,
0.0090301363,
0.02097499,
0.0075382921,
-0.0192175694,
0.0611944273,
-0.0603894703,
-0.0278329179,
-0.0220983829,
0.0089409892,
0.0148244454,
0.014267955,
0.0310823862,
-0.0429480374,
0.0151732685,
-0.005582823,
0.0000816789,
-0.0145316971,
0.0339236148,
0.0200120304,
0.0209282469,
-0.0050332211,
-0.0476754904,
0.0478019305,
0.0310368445,
0.0313343741,
-0.0251381975,
-0.0614057407,
-0.0424675122,
-0.0469410755,
-0.0118807256,
-0.0325295366,
-0.0546556823,
-0.0258684587,
-0.0378626883,
-0.0096548237,
0.0546710603,
0.0038630003,
-0.0142272366,
-0.0327637568,
0.0573508479,
0.0150806447,
0.0359936096,
-0.0285554454,
-0.0423172005,
0.0377931111,
-0.0024651275,
-0.0092063481,
0.0052687014,
-5.522525725e-33,
0.0289027616,
-0.0462399423,
0.0249841698,
0.0150525495,
-0.0130102662,
0.0213218573,
-0.0371219888,
-0.0157577321,
0.0228186566,
-0.0156886894,
-0.0207975935,
0.0046516419,
0.0056610284,
0.0236826017,
0.0030734311,
-0.0523449816,
0.0347264595,
-0.0167547148,
0.0018084726,
-0.0056057111,
-0.008594417,
0.0683418512,
0.044034604,
-0.0790742114,
0.0338804796,
0.0372925885,
0.0219324958,
-0.0164790433,
-0.0001022221,
0.0462132469,
-0.0522247739,
0.028963197,
0.0304859355,
-0.0220031403,
-0.0011786689,
0.0186127964,
-0.0878607556,
0.0019920256,
-0.0142590739,
-0.0020317789,
-0.030349344,
0.0079850759,
0.1042146459,
-0.0347623006,
-0.0221621785,
0.0107208183,
0.0260325428,
-0.0241047777,
0.0003401715,
-0.0212736987,
-0.0511553958,
0.047062356,
0.005118967,
0.0330270939,
0.0049393848,
-0.0163741093,
-0.0479381792,
0.0710189864,
-0.0579298623,
-0.0286261085,
0.0054526553,
-0.0052083847,
0.013605441,
-0.0491698533,
-0.0000421695,
0.0548503809,
0.0137068452,
-0.0141600072,
-0.0434209555,
0.0093184933,
-0.0299741235,
0.0305570979,
0.0307746995,
0.0127494615,
0.0218465738,
-0.0157833416,
-0.0798836723,
0.0350357667,
-0.0707682371,
0.0644262731,
0.03430463,
-0.0196763258,
-0.0472129844,
0.015104942,
-0.009917181,
0.0171386432,
-0.0136982426,
-0.024531791,
0.0107146883,
-0.0040407125,
0.0065384074,
0.0501996242,
-0.0172852296,
-0.037708547,
-0.0031388728,
-0.0226706844,
0.0651409552,
0.0014656108,
-0.0496163405,
-0.0019099928,
-0.0285373405,
-0.0103370957,
0.0453631878,
-0.0553212427,
0.0380976424,
-0.0258216336,
0.0171152726,
-0.0150668072,
-0.0569846071,
-0.0008013573,
0.0300155226,
0.0179073215,
-0.0068981904,
0.0330711938,
0.0191870965,
0.0449892543,
0.0087829307,
0.0658565387,
0.0157644171,
-0.0179234799,
-0.0436046943,
-0.0134417722,
0.0135528147,
-0.0184518415,
-0.0381031632,
0.005389275,
-0.0252939537,
0.0669880882,
0.0270277206,
-0.0585914291,
-0.0161567982,
0.0131098097,
2.731e-7,
0.1114309952,
0.0705176741,
0.0434045792,
-0.0531759374,
0.0124161644,
-0.0092738606,
0.0116789788,
0.0288262852,
0.0058200271,
-0.0142368646,
0.0465377457,
0.0119163143,
0.0164892189,
0.0317692757,
-0.0504846685,
-0.0424872339,
-0.0674895421,
-0.0575104989,
-0.0373214707,
0.005051407,
0.1254526973,
0.0339255147,
-0.0292469617,
-0.0280547496,
-0.016821513,
0.0117450496,
0.0015687246,
-0.0589429922,
0.0254688282,
0.0127023188,
0.0255275201,
-0.0005168208,
0.0250347611,
0.0633880198,
0.0212577563,
-0.0109814173,
0.0387462303,
0.055447381,
-0.0407879129,
0.0101182843,
0.0342688896,
-0.0272090137,
0.0098513635,
-0.0307343006,
0.0599413738,
-0.0610445738,
-0.036729943,
-0.0117460545,
-0.0198034793,
-0.0101127205,
0.0620422885,
0.0144683495,
-0.0626370311,
0.0222827531,
0.0133858528,
0.0111847231,
-0.013699078,
-0.0635317266,
0.0280372594,
0.0370217748,
-0.0108214635,
-0.0123280017,
0.0248300675,
-0.0167993959,
0.0107074715,
-0.0396347418,
0.0286103934,
2.576070615e-34,
0.0083055263,
0.0235290956,
-0.0134926578,
0.0282289647,
0.02604484,
0.0097613009,
0.0037416271,
0.0183125138,
-0.02311817,
-0.094072856,
0.0159264095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02192v1 | Automating Governing Knowledge Commons and Contextual Integrity (GKC-CI) Privacy Policy Annotations with Large Language Models | 2023-11-03T18:49:05 | 2023-11-03T18:49:05 | Jake Chanenson, Madison Pickering, Noah Apthorpe | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | Identifying contextual integrity (CI) and governing knowledge commons (GKC)
parameters in privacy policy texts can facilitate normative privacy analysis.
However, GKC-CI annotation has heretofore required manual or crowdsourced
effort. This paper demonstrates that high-accuracy GKC-CI parameter annotation
of privacy policies can be performed automatically using large language models.
We fine-tune 18 open-source and proprietary models on 21,588 GKC-CI annotations
from 16 ground truth privacy policies. Our best-performing model (fine-tuned
GPT-3.5 Turbo with prompt engineering) has an accuracy of 86%, exceeding the
performance of prior crowdsourcing approaches despite the complexity of privacy
policy texts and the nuance of the GKC-CI annotation task. We apply our
best-performing model to privacy policies from 164 popular online services,
demonstrating the effectiveness of scaling GKC-CI annotation for data
exploration. We make all annotated policies as well as the training data and
scripts needed to fine-tune our best-performing model publicly available for
future research. | [
0.0471860506,
0.0662534311,
-0.0156806223,
0.0150765162,
-0.0346339904,
-0.0131891146,
0.0185857695,
-0.0175070576,
0.0321126878,
-0.0586022586,
0.0233521629,
-0.0044084755,
-0.0063104955,
0.0467841178,
-0.0236324873,
-0.0323826484,
0.0236187018,
0.0019418513,
0.0464932919,
0.0043302737,
-0.0108266734,
0.0095766159,
0.0284748599,
0.0317139365,
-0.0156948939,
-0.0489069149,
-0.0099219121,
-0.0279860757,
0.0275527798,
-0.0550866872,
0.0004136456,
0.054648459,
0.0132080661,
0.0253298767,
0.0000020287,
-0.0837174729,
-0.0336907841,
0.0592268072,
-0.0157831497,
0.0887700915,
0.0244025476,
0.0087028993,
-0.0234548394,
-0.026037883,
0.0040386515,
0.079906553,
0.0597202741,
0.0193795618,
0.0612572469,
0.0482193641,
-0.0269253831,
-0.0150566539,
0.0062991348,
-0.001632281,
0.0159251802,
-0.0743712783,
0.0560347922,
-0.0051464271,
-0.0221940465,
0.0239535123,
0.0491453707,
0.0398193561,
0.0092772264,
-0.0251703691,
-0.0253283326,
-0.0285524037,
-0.0495577566,
-0.0055804099,
-0.0047773817,
0.0547689386,
0.0872737989,
0.0220017359,
0.0539238267,
-0.0254306551,
0.0394267626,
0.0432582386,
0.0070880288,
0.0649125427,
-0.0177554321,
-0.0014122886,
-0.0022510844,
0.0044686883,
0.0416899882,
-0.0095656663,
0.0047855931,
0.0762042478,
-0.0116527369,
-0.0371674187,
0.0054716119,
-0.0477768928,
-0.0227775164,
-0.0494175367,
0.0227717236,
-0.0254820026,
0.0423854552,
0.0023909693,
-0.0248777196,
0.0007092025,
0.0682552904,
-0.0313573703,
0.0004318789,
0.0074285627,
-0.0220973175,
0.0294331443,
0.03134913,
0.0236067772,
-0.0026717063,
0.0267241094,
0.033722125,
0.0063162455,
-0.0113774212,
-0.0049017919,
0.0020859346,
0.0349692442,
-0.0530129932,
0.0268057659,
-0.0613373257,
0.0098706968,
-0.0460468829,
0.0724713132,
0.0188317951,
-0.0170652661,
0.0148707125,
-0.051234331,
-0.0478654392,
-0.0680877864,
-0.0387863219,
0.0314178616,
-0.0160597488,
-0.0087255854,
0.0322670937,
-0.0138599304,
0.0192415882,
0.0009467399,
-0.0195401963,
0.0497619845,
0.0690316185,
-0.0267404541,
-0.0585140325,
-0.1042842418,
0.0001400009,
-0.0059006079,
-0.0525853299,
-0.0346985124,
-0.0156656541,
-0.0422892608,
-0.0233731642,
-0.051807601,
-0.0059667453,
0.0164930616,
-0.0242293943,
0.0575813018,
-0.0303443596,
-0.0217015631,
-0.0291694421,
0.0118208788,
-0.0142165739,
0.0062895035,
-0.0001950676,
0.0323377624,
0.0463623665,
-0.0022874109,
0.0287936963,
0.0066903154,
0.0141653856,
-0.0058526983,
0.0544155985,
0.0340671167,
0.0003703405,
-0.0311078001,
-0.0276819877,
0.0335021988,
0.0034107675,
-0.0093277693,
0.0558141433,
0.0703282431,
-0.0370785892,
0.0167295039,
-0.018764928,
0.0388756543,
0.0023742535,
-0.0434655547,
-0.0576941073,
0.0045576659,
-0.0348153412,
-0.0249183532,
-0.0462540053,
0.0233604629,
0.0332682431,
-0.0119075002,
-0.0294602551,
-0.0237057265,
0.0280114245,
0.0141569516,
-0.0102716768,
0.0180760063,
-0.0067923507,
0.0228538085,
-0.0112426914,
-0.029870227,
-0.0403339528,
-0.0026978219,
0.0351056755,
0.0860728621,
0.0245352518,
-0.034899611,
-0.0094698044,
-0.0537181273,
-0.0047132317,
0.0133550353,
0.0312638804,
-0.0319061093,
0.0158333872,
-0.0245290436,
-0.0638047457,
0.0008480282,
0.0359731391,
0.0272731464,
0.0195555966,
-0.0383932963,
0.0416266546,
-0.0272766817,
-0.0123741738,
0.0020213977,
0.0215117428,
-0.0428515486,
-0.004393287,
0.0321703665,
0.0315197706,
0.0591544583,
0.0426103957,
0.0028173896,
0.0172787625,
0.026151279,
0.0119562401,
0.0255008545,
0.0082478775,
0.0237251986,
0.0204307213,
-0.0451362245,
-0.0212411955,
0.0159440618,
-0.0325351432,
-0.0009300487,
-0.0387271754,
0.0070879804,
0.0373845957,
-0.0487318076,
-0.0507940836,
-0.0120589677,
-0.0340540968,
-0.0065260008,
0.038584847,
-0.030308282,
-0.0291687325,
0.0051605948,
-0.0726210549,
0.0412141047,
-0.0019609404,
-0.0070967926,
-0.0462408736,
-0.0639361069,
0.0462065823,
0.0399054997,
-0.0046521281,
-0.0279826205,
0.04160849,
-0.0336930715,
0.0187506434,
0.0104457559,
0.0487591513,
-0.0052632657,
-0.0005151698,
-0.0059932605,
-0.0064736074,
-0.0353305116,
-0.049125541,
-0.0529459454,
0.0262920391,
0.0433375835,
0.0352538787,
-0.0400018059,
0.0373037905,
0.0119480835,
-0.0345900431,
-0.016510956,
0.021510927,
0.0049125659,
-0.0078904256,
0.0363525227,
-0.008639303,
-0.0178483035,
0.0080266139,
-0.0200974196,
-0.0035542969,
0.0068284962,
-0.0771334767,
-0.0106999064,
-0.012333896,
0.0353165753,
0.0168769751,
0.0005525807,
-0.0151675986,
-0.0231159534,
0.0104662245,
-0.0329043902,
-0.0125525156,
-0.0077547547,
0.0941095725,
0.0028401674,
0.0098449271,
0.0099571943,
-0.0756127611,
0.0009730925,
-0.0151569638,
-0.0030672424,
-0.0544721074,
-0.0133550074,
-0.0282076299,
0.0701616257,
0.0024406463,
-0.0192945395,
0.0650556833,
0.0088991681,
0.0534963571,
-0.0154324248,
0.0001241231,
-0.0008134884,
0.0573886931,
-0.0346321426,
0.0396118164,
0.0692800134,
-0.0655384958,
0.0223201029,
-0.0000109267,
0.1097826734,
-0.0272092056,
0.0282481275,
-0.0342269763,
-0.0166836958,
0.0180843063,
-0.0390078463,
-0.0072590155,
-0.0669981465,
0.001713976,
0.0047771176,
0.0341868475,
-0.0450623594,
0.0343124047,
-0.0331244655,
-0.0004251481,
0.0436857194,
0.0398395881,
0.0007233056,
-0.0161348172,
-0.0435845852,
-0.024563076,
-0.0225243103,
-0.0159154739,
0.028815994,
-0.0077635194,
0.0471799634,
0.0190909486,
0.0120050386,
0.0258442592,
0.0153111592,
-0.0413464569,
-0.0540460646,
0.0276220944,
0.0423485301,
0.0575138964,
-0.0672697201,
0.0193894319,
0.0476580709,
0.031812381,
-0.0181393344,
-0.0057034255,
0.025814211,
-0.0258098003,
0.0005152508,
-0.0047306679,
-0.1315092444,
0.0035630369,
-0.0154812243,
0.0601360463,
-0.0642405599,
-0.0703092292,
-0.0018470084,
-0.0721375048,
0.0179102793,
0.0264234599,
-0.020244509,
-0.0368436612,
-0.0376665555,
0.0077296635,
-0.0401530601,
-0.002649395,
-0.0614648983,
0.0044319248,
-0.0077255964,
-0.0195258819,
-0.0175990835,
-0.0755070969,
0.0288696662,
-0.0524181165,
0.0458273143,
0.0847672299,
0.0121699469,
-0.0188020896,
-0.0387704,
0.0283345617,
0.0363629684,
-0.0485095493,
0.0284746289,
0.0262476206,
-0.0007433668,
0.0161200687,
-0.0129724508,
0.0817485973,
-0.0372917876,
-0.0438835844,
0.002824204,
0.0472189188,
-0.0042605079,
0.0197116248,
0.0318681113,
-0.0413889028,
0.0508294143,
0.0746444315,
-0.0029793761,
-0.0030225231,
0.0181109868,
-0.069842346,
0.0029182485,
-0.0208329279,
0.0357477069,
0.0121129025,
-0.0094263703,
-0.0020481162,
-0.0830897018,
0.0247836038,
-0.0009978901,
-0.020299891,
0.0515957549,
-0.0201450456,
0.0575358644,
-0.0057130372,
-0.0148156136,
0.0062679308,
-0.0752115548,
0.0140474737,
0.000595055,
0.023199698,
-0.0212826431,
0.06294173,
-0.0162137765,
0.0337026604,
-0.0191944279,
-0.0460244901,
-0.0013954501,
0.0252304152,
0.0159711167,
0.0271116719,
-0.0385987014,
-0.0136674931,
0.0172614399,
0.09797851,
-0.0254551079,
-0.0470089912,
0.0771034658,
0.0070578763,
-0.0259505231,
0.0068862061,
-0.0436209142,
-0.0696816891,
-0.0279131271,
-0.0123173343,
-0.0286578517,
-0.0187400617,
0.0394324847,
0.0664180815,
-0.0312343445,
-0.0023078576,
0.0494381115,
-0.0240236167,
-0.0220803712,
0.0037163843,
-0.0174459238,
-0.0107624,
0.0181629136,
0.0423531942,
-0.0558550693,
0.020943474,
0.0227949433,
-0.0042977459,
-0.0012970294,
-0.0488733798,
0.0272790603,
0.0303329527,
0.0640880987,
0.0489872806,
-0.0467994772,
0.0008941058,
0.0571251363,
0.0047152634,
0.0676967129,
-0.0170174818,
0.0279651824,
0.0150391702,
-0.0206931066,
0.00065572,
0.0092431763,
-0.0119016757,
-0.0363046117,
-0.0100584356,
0.0388076976,
0.0000063803,
0.0186716542,
0.0226123948,
-0.0808701962,
-0.0238801707,
0.0139603373,
0.0101150349,
0.0138224736,
-0.0310728531,
-0.003902033,
-0.0000912331,
-0.0379012637,
0.0122270659,
0.0504799746,
-0.0062607969,
0.0520104431,
-0.0531229489,
-0.0351221263,
-0.0717746317,
0.0092155878,
-0.0159991197,
0.0875030458,
-0.056577526,
-0.0338300206,
-0.0612206496,
-0.0328199714,
-0.0351170599,
0.0057120323,
-0.001355714,
0.0066519813,
-0.0026719724,
0.0155696711,
0.0052811485,
-0.0732597336,
-0.0469545648,
-0.020416528,
-0.0509148575,
-0.0116467336,
-0.0050071753,
-5.554316969e-33,
-0.0053553721,
-0.0343244039,
-0.0338769816,
0.0179295503,
0.0289784856,
-0.0180542972,
-0.0328298919,
-0.0253755283,
0.0044429381,
0.0216896739,
0.0153849907,
0.0092782704,
0.0013488494,
0.0050820103,
0.016699532,
-0.008911741,
0.0352400132,
0.0299981125,
-0.0081466064,
0.0238705743,
0.0384051912,
-0.0073801829,
0.0188962389,
-0.1001558229,
0.0940836966,
0.0266656131,
-0.0689328015,
0.017216064,
-0.0594635196,
0.0597086176,
-0.0065878988,
0.0154816872,
0.004530583,
-0.0314211547,
0.0235464107,
0.0257599391,
-0.0454187877,
-0.0080211191,
0.0146832103,
-0.0247126874,
0.0379289947,
-0.0819686726,
0.0270899013,
-0.0269112773,
-0.008364846,
0.017867459,
0.0036791328,
-0.0129981106,
-0.0112230666,
-0.050980866,
-0.0285426341,
0.0223663338,
-0.0333097093,
0.0319881849,
0.0249890983,
0.0069122757,
0.0196947381,
0.0328251161,
-0.0417688377,
-0.0130261024,
0.0269740783,
-0.0505417287,
0.0509661026,
-0.0141337132,
0.0256693773,
0.0387994312,
-0.0801289603,
0.0183236264,
-0.0036261897,
0.018121969,
-0.0132599734,
0.058618892,
-0.024217071,
0.0907925516,
-0.0129290763,
-0.041952692,
-0.0117264958,
0.0432859175,
-0.0434196405,
-0.0081867632,
0.0192138366,
-0.0224315953,
-0.0454282537,
-0.0074556954,
-0.0493368693,
-0.0671830028,
-0.0192747302,
0.0022127742,
0.0272027552,
-0.0080145113,
-0.0677653775,
0.0458446518,
-0.0324729271,
-0.0689263269,
-0.038352292,
0.0104635339,
0.0271398798,
-0.012321448,
-0.0027411359,
0.000584849,
-0.0462866388,
-0.0094505027,
-0.0008942912,
-0.0192888416,
0.0343635455,
0.0205267612,
0.045286309,
0.0186372213,
-0.0674903169,
0.0076425318,
0.011441621,
0.0252811145,
-0.020751765,
-0.0079519618,
0.0337571241,
0.0076193889,
0.0274398234,
0.0151418922,
0.0338495113,
0.0382020064,
-0.0325668082,
-0.0137554267,
-0.0168816652,
0.0072625317,
0.0272156876,
-0.0127250515,
0.0027323018,
-0.0282916892,
0.0890604556,
0.018703768,
-0.0002666402,
-0.002380067,
2.724e-7,
0.0594549179,
-0.0141858896,
-0.0022310396,
-0.0277585946,
-0.0032925068,
0.0790655985,
0.0382433757,
0.0341239944,
-0.0217391029,
-0.0800697953,
0.0203097016,
-0.0706071854,
0.0291634183,
0.0302424505,
-0.0589376651,
-0.0258787591,
0.0111439703,
-0.007920186,
-0.063860327,
0.0744963586,
0.042597428,
0.0061006155,
0.0456959158,
-0.0292069856,
0.0279076081,
-0.0044593504,
0.0021725551,
-0.0444079638,
-0.0159648098,
-0.0008627306,
0.0270104744,
0.0502187014,
0.0272162929,
-0.0085935164,
-0.0362956971,
0.0216088425,
-0.0785393789,
0.0940522403,
0.0448990911,
0.0135051291,
-0.0221051928,
-0.0662752315,
0.0308839604,
-0.0603517368,
0.0475235507,
0.0085337786,
-0.0231850911,
-0.0457903557,
0.0169253033,
-0.0627008975,
-0.0011193882,
-0.0085034864,
0.0208792724,
-0.011182094,
-0.0267621595,
0.0062806639,
-0.0000046421,
-0.059958633,
0.0138078276,
-0.0087578306,
0.0190831926,
-0.0147461183,
0.0154105416,
-0.0099511733,
0.0032592453,
-0.0356998704,
0.064244166,
2.51102537e-34,
0.0066884696,
-0.0579788573,
0.0206689369,
0.0234034788,
0.0426338278,
0.0484910309,
0.02407136,
0.0128628667,
-0.0022701118,
-0.0282506142,
0.0400546528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03708v1 | Abstraction via exemplars? A representational case study on lexical category inference in BERT | 2023-11-03T18:45:19 | 2023-11-03T18:45:19 | Kanishka Misra, Najoung Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Exemplar based accounts are often considered to be in direct opposition to
pure linguistic abstraction in explaining language learners' ability to
generalize to novel expressions. However, the recent success of neural network
language models on linguistically sensitive tasks suggests that perhaps
abstractions can arise via the encoding of exemplars. We provide empirical
evidence for this claim by adapting an existing experiment that studies how an
LM (BERT) generalizes the usage of novel tokens that belong to lexical
categories such as Noun/Verb/Adjective/Adverb from exposure to only a single
instance of their usage. We analyze the representational behavior of the novel
tokens in these experiments, and find that BERT's capacity to generalize to
unseen expressions involving the use of these novel tokens constitutes the
movement of novel token representations towards regions of known category
exemplars in two-dimensional space. Our results suggest that learners' encoding
of exemplars can indeed give rise to abstraction like behavior. | [
0.0154618844,
0.0275113564,
-0.062528193,
0.0311413538,
-0.0093689011,
0.0065830988,
-0.0185017884,
0.0194703303,
-0.0533493124,
-0.0673089325,
-0.0054862616,
-0.0058064037,
-0.025916921,
0.0005973711,
0.0770214051,
-0.0424943008,
0.0439855531,
-0.0091078738,
0.0182408132,
-0.0237570815,
-0.0351272114,
0.003263585,
-0.0121955508,
0.0516933538,
-0.0275125634,
0.0105329948,
-0.0278657973,
-0.0195645019,
-0.0408961177,
0.0152553506,
-0.0044190376,
-0.0002923798,
0.0463364646,
-0.0010805344,
0.0000015696,
-0.0875167027,
0.0095367422,
-0.0232332516,
0.0165341906,
0.0071784519,
-0.0210344959,
-0.0132583203,
-0.0012146969,
-0.0356144011,
0.0133077716,
-0.0422081165,
0.0563912876,
0.0222468507,
0.0087781884,
0.0145387538,
-0.0094773583,
-0.0164832212,
-0.0168275684,
0.0155911753,
0.024706224,
0.0510894433,
0.0206275154,
-0.0693977028,
-0.005941371,
-0.0319784656,
-0.0568984821,
-0.0059747868,
0.0348001011,
0.0477310829,
0.0123202223,
0.0424783416,
-0.0498726591,
0.0005426725,
0.0009878529,
0.0156680625,
-0.0349444486,
-0.0257583205,
0.0013051071,
0.002444973,
0.0452699214,
0.0357034095,
-0.0250855163,
0.0341806971,
0.0127298338,
0.0490609631,
0.0297442377,
-0.0464150496,
0.0071478696,
0.0383849852,
-0.0324215069,
0.0436907187,
0.014124576,
-0.0298013259,
0.0034580524,
-0.010500147,
-0.0348088443,
-0.0242298413,
0.0069037122,
0.0196187403,
0.035740573,
0.0504752472,
-0.012526188,
-0.0278683994,
0.009243561,
-0.0735472217,
0.0806271434,
0.0398181081,
-0.0344952233,
0.0198057424,
-0.0760482997,
0.0645920336,
-0.0301954206,
0.0584265627,
-0.037982624,
-0.0119429203,
-0.0477561355,
-0.0502102859,
-0.0705677271,
0.0942712799,
0.0107798744,
-0.0009654106,
-0.010569985,
0.023032615,
0.0054218452,
-0.0107639693,
-0.0565998219,
0.0233553704,
-0.0085594812,
0.0321445353,
-0.0673860386,
-0.0450373963,
-0.0721711293,
0.0497189686,
-0.0247829836,
-0.0307737421,
-0.0109862508,
-0.0099454671,
0.0052989,
-0.0289281178,
0.0029768317,
0.1006558761,
0.0019762104,
-0.0338240489,
-0.0114992205,
-0.0042551621,
-0.0057608499,
0.0289579015,
0.0467025302,
-0.0671767369,
-0.0030180807,
0.0449857451,
-0.0215619802,
-0.008545287,
-0.0070928731,
-0.0119594699,
-0.0366700739,
0.0374730974,
-0.0028272173,
0.0163797475,
0.0024551235,
0.002522656,
-0.0434175171,
0.0259668007,
0.0190534685,
-0.0352770574,
0.0000783301,
-0.022407895,
0.0585356839,
0.0418525264,
0.0195723698,
-0.0173079669,
-0.0668494403,
-0.0319343433,
-0.0318820104,
0.0487944484,
0.0252969693,
0.0681308359,
-0.0342448726,
-0.0183656253,
0.0338126607,
0.0886321142,
-0.0283057969,
0.0695406273,
0.0368863493,
-0.0317811593,
0.0305894483,
0.0498585217,
-0.0306377448,
-0.0108468076,
0.0315376148,
-0.0110632908,
-0.033569064,
-0.0105311871,
-0.0498568155,
-0.0157937389,
-0.0508624837,
-0.0023579432,
0.0307627544,
-0.0662378371,
0.0500272736,
0.0680243447,
0.0049450882,
0.0855775997,
0.022102382,
-0.0271750055,
0.0145949228,
-0.0746733099,
0.0183689948,
0.0112532573,
0.01404595,
-0.0223993249,
-0.0073399451,
-0.0024902737,
-0.0216598734,
0.0422057286,
0.0471138135,
-0.0043783672,
0.011640396,
0.0088859079,
0.0248499177,
-0.0488912649,
0.0330243707,
0.0014085631,
-0.0121919522,
-0.0136979427,
-0.0395681448,
-0.0732060671,
-0.0173222478,
0.071109049,
0.0355650224,
-0.061087016,
-0.0376757048,
0.0144037912,
-0.0074915295,
-0.0332446881,
0.0042515178,
0.0312817581,
0.0075643323,
-0.0531617478,
-0.0537380725,
0.0392031074,
-0.0375536978,
-0.0156998634,
0.0133297201,
-0.0527195819,
-0.0151135521,
-0.0052712574,
0.0002041251,
-0.011824321,
0.051364392,
-0.0766118839,
0.1380549371,
-0.0234739855,
0.0157770738,
-0.0389425866,
-0.0097156344,
0.0031623624,
0.0721125528,
-0.0078683654,
0.0436976217,
-0.0138219437,
-0.0115754278,
0.0025204967,
0.0261568986,
-0.0134440316,
-0.0055466336,
-0.0059525496,
0.0124925021,
-0.0079859477,
-0.0330097526,
-0.0702097192,
0.0040127691,
-0.0611729212,
-0.0444980301,
0.0348917022,
0.0205974281,
0.037244197,
-0.0417353064,
-0.0007301166,
0.0252587609,
0.0045253476,
-0.0296696294,
-0.0538461581,
0.0553864874,
0.0692036301,
-0.0092246709,
-0.0366718583,
-0.01112362,
-0.0058546215,
-0.060155876,
0.0740142539,
-0.0271496139,
0.0114054894,
-0.0231507365,
-0.0516486987,
-0.0216427799,
0.0261947326,
-0.0028602558,
-0.0492767319,
0.0376034863,
-0.004979027,
0.0131713282,
0.0160825271,
-0.0145728989,
0.0708613098,
0.0395415239,
0.0035347636,
-0.0740404576,
-0.0048331837,
-0.0378711298,
-0.0008302861,
-0.0160966087,
-0.0002798769,
-0.0040515116,
0.0839431584,
0.0228718463,
-0.0028133402,
-0.0099000558,
0.0606345013,
-0.0220311508,
-0.0248029195,
-0.0321074538,
-0.0837280527,
-0.0665009096,
0.0076237335,
-0.0188149139,
-0.0229410175,
0.0849938765,
0.0195517894,
-0.0247145016,
-0.0368703976,
0.0128936823,
0.0051205121,
0.056580022,
-0.0127536235,
0.0188462995,
0.0124150636,
-0.0515812635,
-0.0674097389,
-0.014796677,
-0.0398186259,
0.0089886049,
0.051270511,
-0.0242278203,
-0.0200921334,
0.0451720916,
-0.0272165015,
-0.0555312186,
-0.0261939149,
0.0220305119,
0.0275639426,
-0.0089649335,
-0.0060945721,
-0.0073388596,
-0.0229711346,
0.0049800463,
0.013794736,
-0.0081873452,
-0.0126712946,
-0.0341829471,
0.0262394641,
-0.0075250799,
-0.0086365249,
-0.0038415352,
-0.0269700512,
-0.0112253586,
0.0280472748,
0.0091795381,
0.0111714834,
-0.0558078773,
0.0432530232,
0.0219968129,
-0.0364693701,
-0.0309496652,
-0.0143815288,
0.0272327308,
-0.0235896371,
-0.0263422634,
0.0520343743,
0.0405021161,
0.0092846453,
0.0692640543,
-0.047418002,
0.0179511271,
0.0365812667,
0.0273158606,
-0.0317146927,
0.0161937363,
0.0186490957,
-0.0357860737,
-0.0276228245,
-0.0140865184,
0.0252365358,
-0.1130806506,
-0.0038377582,
-0.0133265713,
-0.0570046306,
-0.0034584026,
-0.0071973531,
0.0333627462,
0.0547218062,
0.0074114441,
0.0143833319,
-0.03286428,
0.0036158548,
0.0166587606,
0.0252576917,
-0.0034227823,
-0.0036587853,
-0.0532556511,
-0.0013921584,
0.0053042672,
0.0244701188,
-0.0787608698,
-0.0357481353,
0.1039075702,
-0.0483471379,
0.0204546787,
-0.0006151611,
0.0056539937,
0.0188977774,
-0.0054435087,
0.0037160118,
0.0252399612,
-0.0082709547,
-0.0241523422,
-0.0308221057,
0.0850307792,
0.0001024746,
-0.0445566177,
-0.0364811942,
-0.0524310134,
-0.0528488457,
0.0616217628,
0.0840751752,
-0.0630418137,
0.010630521,
-0.0157963801,
-0.0370077826,
0.0359414853,
-0.0026474912,
0.0069587617,
-0.006054542,
-0.0215473603,
-0.0677537099,
-0.0344540551,
0.0378056914,
0.0180410594,
0.0324297808,
-0.0135198571,
-0.0345314592,
-0.037723925,
-0.0327207893,
0.0581384636,
0.0413526408,
-0.0067173978,
0.0403044447,
-0.0385131724,
0.0282014348,
-0.02205454,
-0.0561909974,
0.0016365846,
0.0598924719,
-0.0661407262,
0.0214299131,
0.0149148032,
0.0254374184,
0.0119211292,
0.0151389781,
-0.0330809131,
0.0736876279,
0.0482374839,
0.0295380335,
0.0266782306,
-0.0001842838,
0.0262424201,
0.0337240361,
0.0294670537,
-0.0152299935,
0.0287003126,
0.0165015068,
-0.0024204522,
-0.0001656107,
0.0562398806,
0.0234904289,
-0.015390248,
0.0398860313,
0.0011644703,
-0.0068025268,
-0.0362041965,
-0.0149691189,
0.0080728503,
-0.0170470215,
-0.02020563,
-0.033090923,
0.0004899237,
0.0665034354,
-0.0298947729,
-0.0120038418,
0.0104898596,
0.0525732636,
0.0334368795,
0.0063784858,
0.0349480771,
0.0283894297,
-0.0265361033,
0.0419658273,
-0.0071103727,
0.0021357369,
-0.0317584276,
-0.0007192625,
-0.0399311706,
-0.0020290737,
0.0344894417,
0.0355236754,
-0.0395373292,
-0.0103080422,
-0.0202793833,
-0.0440098867,
-0.0126637593,
0.0146067794,
-0.0002423008,
-0.0587646365,
0.0093979193,
-0.0459325239,
-0.0019182907,
0.0265997015,
-0.0203007441,
-0.0156321079,
-0.0169362128,
0.0729052946,
0.0466131605,
-0.0038385382,
-0.0598612018,
0.007057697,
-0.0501130112,
0.0547019467,
-0.0371487513,
0.0066964338,
-0.0036832665,
0.0175375305,
0.0614991337,
0.0128580984,
0.0202316344,
0.0002070596,
-0.0257714465,
-0.0484877303,
0.0054610199,
0.0356008038,
0.0219333824,
-0.0231469851,
0.0598508753,
0.0798514783,
0.0171068888,
-0.0347055346,
0.0069079199,
-0.0026321639,
0.0166697092,
0.0017970763,
-0.029763924,
-5.57881317e-33,
-0.0184195582,
0.0011354072,
-0.0227053128,
-0.0029548465,
0.0149409231,
0.0171062611,
-0.0397327244,
0.026881272,
-0.0022126841,
0.0169586893,
0.0007713475,
-0.0002520645,
0.0060246466,
-0.0033157722,
0.0470721461,
-0.0025398736,
0.0070185224,
-0.0163657404,
-0.028424697,
-0.0442199148,
0.0134927221,
0.0164861418,
0.085190177,
-0.0330661833,
0.0079103736,
0.0276820716,
0.0155753419,
0.0101303812,
-0.0126116928,
0.0509169139,
-0.0020677142,
0.0686535612,
0.0280842017,
0.0323329978,
-0.0102586253,
0.0231907703,
-0.0459088869,
-0.0789671913,
0.0563526526,
-0.0013149753,
-0.0424097888,
-0.0264069252,
0.1156766564,
-0.0139386905,
-0.054161828,
0.0647576079,
0.0390989855,
-0.0001080565,
0.023488326,
0.0075203069,
-0.0596983992,
-0.0401814096,
0.0099492064,
0.01651223,
0.0105772512,
-0.0063103219,
-0.0196033623,
-0.0194573179,
-0.0332412533,
-0.0009638703,
0.0176109653,
0.0083667636,
0.0195210297,
0.0127308248,
-0.0077575645,
0.0676428005,
0.0613209195,
-0.0119854659,
-0.0061937412,
0.002688878,
0.0749406442,
0.0423324034,
0.008844113,
-0.019428445,
0.0554613732,
-0.0008540932,
0.0018601713,
-0.0155816982,
0.0401793495,
0.0095308078,
0.0530546494,
-0.0125372978,
-0.009744186,
-0.0200729053,
-0.0563733988,
-0.0136771491,
-0.0409608558,
-0.0100974683,
0.0040912484,
-0.0219652113,
0.0329155736,
-0.003446456,
-0.016981015,
-0.0072022835,
-0.0389196947,
-0.0439600088,
-0.0353881866,
0.0259116739,
0.015106746,
0.0096365539,
-0.0276102386,
-0.0879737884,
-0.0268947631,
0.0143768461,
0.0334198214,
0.0605060458,
0.0405032225,
-0.0056630257,
-0.0507407077,
0.007112999,
-0.0506642871,
-0.0688265786,
-0.0036974284,
-0.0136611741,
0.02493212,
0.0401083864,
-0.0106243463,
-0.0154142044,
0.0307452027,
0.01400779,
-0.033439599,
0.0429202802,
-0.0335894115,
0.0423125476,
-0.0209909454,
-0.0442429744,
-0.0292210467,
0.0462514348,
0.060540095,
-0.0679831579,
-0.0121440478,
0.0023125364,
2.512e-7,
0.0626154989,
0.0534642898,
0.0245467778,
0.0105050541,
0.0430740453,
-0.0033059295,
-0.0350483134,
0.0339331366,
0.0036844057,
-0.025851965,
-0.0276367068,
0.014090159,
-0.0318718776,
0.0242321063,
-0.0905639306,
0.0334294029,
-0.0383164175,
0.0568600073,
-0.04540696,
0.0629250482,
0.0541802049,
0.0716096833,
0.0350884981,
-0.0137918051,
-0.0480340235,
-0.0542969629,
0.0541152321,
-0.0352346972,
0.0510017872,
0.0032799318,
-0.0407877788,
0.0864022449,
0.0291988961,
0.0295601338,
0.0216642804,
0.0270155687,
0.0003886287,
-0.0046015144,
-0.012193881,
-0.0241645817,
0.0198137444,
-0.0143538825,
-0.0211286414,
-0.0427882522,
0.0283264387,
-0.0788104013,
-0.0091447802,
0.028656302,
-0.0028181497,
0.0289092232,
0.007763207,
-0.0095503619,
-0.0108230701,
0.0043689781,
0.0151828714,
-0.000688403,
-0.0088730343,
-0.0660031587,
-0.0236187,
0.0060208216,
-0.054931704,
-0.0392474905,
-0.0065676142,
0.0022584868,
-0.0048510223,
-0.0703758746,
0.0011433052,
1.820832599e-34,
-0.0068248203,
0.0045910222,
0.0372770652,
0.0654619262,
0.0125376219,
-0.0356810689,
0.0273764469,
0.0298653021,
0.0290369187,
-0.018334141,
-0.0234216247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04928v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04928v2 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Collective Decision-Making | 2023-11-03T18:27:21 | 2024-01-24T19:38:52 | Marios Papachristou, Longqi Yang, Chin-Chia Hsu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.SI | In various work contexts, such as meeting scheduling, collaborating, and
project planning, collective decision-making is essential but often challenging
due to diverse individual preferences, varying work focuses, and power dynamics
among members. To address this, we propose a system leveraging Large Language
Models (LLMs) to facilitate group decision-making by managing conversations and
balancing preferences among individuals. Our system aims to extract individual
preferences from conversations and suggest options that satisfy the preferences
of the members. We specifically apply this system to corporate meeting
scheduling. We create synthetic employee profiles and simulate conversations at
scale, leveraging LLMs to evaluate the system performance as a novel approach
to conducting a user study. Our results indicate efficient coordination with
reduced interactions between the members and the LLM-based system. The system
refines and improves its proposed options over time, ensuring that many of the
members' individual preferences are satisfied in an equitable way. Finally, we
conduct a survey study involving human participants to assess our system's
ability to aggregate preferences and reasoning about them. Our findings show
that the system exhibits strong performance in both dimensions. | [
0.0685993657,
0.0713526905,
-0.0248843879,
0.0232877955,
-0.0529671945,
-0.021738641,
0.0355741344,
0.0008433347,
0.0096136825,
-0.0160027035,
-0.0019492557,
-0.0324843824,
-0.0063340869,
0.0223289151,
-0.0050105485,
-0.0616393238,
0.0094575863,
-0.0173829738,
0.0180192403,
-0.0186700504,
0.0363620333,
0.0238078218,
-0.013627938,
0.0532283187,
0.0003333745,
0.0084537873,
-0.0038664083,
-0.0224754438,
0.0310389455,
0.0495930165,
0.0058096894,
0.0775495619,
0.004649153,
-0.008026042,
0.0000022569,
-0.0537034608,
-0.0134599879,
-0.0184609462,
-0.0142076723,
-0.0123409154,
0.0626855344,
0.0354270227,
-0.0217437129,
0.0182945281,
-0.0491704531,
0.0562335178,
0.0222564358,
-0.0044193091,
0.0238566939,
0.003300942,
-0.0188678857,
-0.0092189312,
-0.0931046009,
-0.0221822858,
-0.0213230196,
-0.0616880618,
0.0297851637,
-0.0014167558,
0.0176248495,
-0.0221642945,
0.057557378,
-0.0433098525,
-0.0289532896,
-0.0548503101,
0.012137155,
0.0340143219,
-0.0388285443,
-0.0398202911,
0.018503638,
0.072557196,
0.0368551835,
0.0040651741,
0.0096714152,
-0.0269826744,
0.045733951,
0.0394737907,
-0.0216112528,
0.0143258683,
-0.0091527104,
-0.003384016,
-0.0255911779,
0.0490919538,
-0.0049083726,
0.017964555,
-0.0237731673,
0.0782688111,
0.0076577319,
-0.0083945459,
-0.0038043396,
0.0077721206,
0.0111392494,
-0.0731369853,
0.0394916162,
0.0220231768,
-0.101543121,
0.0124154184,
0.0030787443,
0.0280895643,
0.0294798668,
-0.0944411457,
0.0207542628,
0.0187737793,
0.0886161849,
0.0478685871,
0.0668809712,
-0.0088138757,
-0.0074667358,
-0.0357322842,
-0.0263616573,
-0.0223618448,
-0.0501512885,
0.0122159943,
-0.0289374366,
0.0317762718,
-0.0804666951,
-0.0131668383,
-0.0396832265,
0.0457764976,
-0.0306732114,
0.0213969611,
0.0076297401,
0.0316683762,
0.0082487948,
-0.0108500728,
-0.08013805,
0.0233627651,
-0.0115098525,
0.0130195478,
-0.0033094082,
0.0012102795,
0.0572443493,
-0.0036361676,
-0.0116076637,
-0.0008263651,
-0.0184512828,
0.0634022132,
-0.0029892761,
0.048025813,
0.0066231214,
-0.048878707,
-0.0393524803,
-0.0365714729,
-0.0722663999,
-0.0804998055,
0.0298227929,
0.0145212244,
-0.0226658043,
-0.0229143221,
0.0114656771,
0.0208501834,
0.0044570905,
0.0518675484,
0.0279432535,
0.0398251787,
0.0521120168,
0.0192180108,
0.0093832072,
0.0513065383,
0.0294003673,
0.0721206367,
0.0208557881,
-0.0033296908,
0.012631462,
0.0392192006,
-0.0390065014,
0.0023315523,
-0.0032100154,
0.0289504156,
-0.0176509768,
0.0076979739,
-0.0401615687,
0.0746067092,
-0.0445980169,
-0.0100641558,
0.0731312707,
0.0575898215,
0.0118337115,
0.0346937515,
-0.0344701558,
0.0403419062,
-0.035665933,
-0.0494613051,
0.0284291226,
0.0380505398,
-0.0140345702,
-0.0230124407,
0.0383483022,
0.0007222017,
-0.0148640787,
-0.029827714,
0.0226960126,
0.0082541872,
0.0214014836,
0.0363009721,
0.0329844281,
-0.0491611287,
-0.0200122762,
0.0443860553,
0.0236118063,
-0.0362268351,
-0.0140878456,
-0.0086151576,
0.0382472798,
0.1101951897,
0.0438844711,
-0.0156877749,
0.0000846906,
-0.0093664331,
-0.0137649626,
0.0471783802,
0.1003919467,
-0.0211405307,
-0.0456889011,
-0.0373719558,
-0.0245544184,
0.0624084547,
-0.0415251441,
0.0474174805,
-0.0029759887,
-0.0054212995,
-0.0201781858,
0.0041950168,
-0.0418813601,
-0.0074583548,
-0.0127016986,
0.0232564714,
-0.0108686816,
0.045562014,
0.0652838051,
0.0301517621,
-0.0057563893,
0.0220328886,
-0.0003767242,
-0.0380709656,
-0.0357406065,
0.0151975239,
-0.0438601002,
0.0423456542,
0.0135329468,
0.0013527174,
-0.0246199388,
-0.0046971613,
-0.0029270975,
-0.005580592,
0.0421751216,
0.0191684626,
-0.0020101543,
-0.0200724117,
-0.0107401405,
-0.04301323,
-0.0158280917,
-0.0604063161,
0.0405350514,
0.0390432663,
-0.0239296332,
-0.0004069457,
-0.0141198384,
0.0269513298,
-0.0761334524,
0.0036473353,
0.0763012916,
0.052380614,
0.0245967694,
0.0433539003,
-0.0275769439,
-0.0544890277,
-0.0478086434,
-0.11979568,
-0.009832087,
0.0108144069,
-0.0027176689,
-0.0005908888,
0.0075557497,
-0.0005233682,
0.0113109183,
-0.0562722981,
-0.004685476,
0.0129902586,
0.0226689018,
0.0214100629,
0.0249479227,
-0.0088278698,
-0.0579874702,
-0.0182952993,
-0.0205070917,
0.0191518553,
0.0367790498,
-0.0158332121,
-0.0603756309,
0.0203863718,
-0.0544385426,
-0.0144584728,
0.0133794239,
-0.0140361069,
0.0320565663,
-0.0283113029,
0.0673049092,
0.0249824729,
0.0283787362,
0.0186382532,
0.0247334931,
-0.0083298897,
-0.0726638287,
-0.0241112821,
-0.023372544,
0.017916318,
-0.023278527,
-0.0427304991,
0.0086701829,
0.0179794598,
0.0131856184,
0.0054186643,
-0.0432656109,
0.0781673193,
-0.0270601325,
0.0062773773,
-0.0548953973,
-0.0372807421,
-0.0097985966,
0.0697703436,
-0.0014406824,
-0.0022072068,
0.0533501022,
0.0264368299,
0.0083226422,
-0.0234734248,
-0.0432929061,
-0.0603486113,
0.0328139216,
-0.019807674,
0.0205257554,
-0.011837027,
-0.020489987,
-0.0507178381,
-0.045619145,
0.0209353659,
-0.0581217334,
0.0131760491,
-0.0440600701,
0.0026654883,
-0.007804343,
-0.042999018,
-0.0205388237,
-0.0646317005,
-0.04990419,
0.0296538733,
0.0671523809,
-0.0289001781,
-0.0338848867,
0.0218194388,
0.0155672301,
-0.015703097,
0.0516146235,
-0.0139125288,
0.0070067542,
-0.0245830417,
0.0292400829,
0.0506762601,
-0.0049912995,
0.004744722,
0.0208417568,
0.0516951531,
0.0484643094,
-0.0111104148,
-0.0373964459,
-0.038267903,
0.0072204489,
-0.0245320667,
0.0328799859,
0.0037397917,
0.0011735691,
0.0044270288,
0.0438652895,
0.0810898319,
0.0237589348,
-0.0910641104,
-0.0083791278,
-0.0517525934,
0.0285104383,
0.0153559456,
0.0447482392,
-0.0343767703,
-0.0019205918,
-0.0165896602,
0.0196750853,
-0.00496312,
-0.0690975711,
0.0179050639,
-0.0902831033,
0.0373846851,
0.0061092414,
-0.0151859773,
0.0226486195,
-0.0256836843,
0.0244278423,
-0.0446918756,
0.0119492952,
-0.0035711778,
0.0432388783,
-0.0235627275,
0.0335897468,
-0.0444205999,
-0.0289178398,
0.0705052987,
-0.0398195349,
0.0141495503,
0.0790286586,
0.082308501,
0.0320997685,
-0.0202109162,
0.0137859527,
0.0278698374,
-0.0057192254,
0.0074389451,
-0.0099000195,
0.0118855564,
0.0131944427,
-0.0375018045,
0.0270026699,
-0.0130208246,
0.0053176987,
0.0311720781,
0.0553952381,
-0.013955975,
-0.0140152629,
-0.0066713383,
0.0444703959,
0.0536591187,
0.0458106138,
0.0071019721,
-0.0921153799,
-0.0143940682,
-0.040888276,
-0.0080003152,
-0.0306533538,
-0.0883250758,
-0.0034439056,
0.0065503363,
0.0274655689,
-0.0390002728,
-0.0219640601,
0.0506023467,
0.0243659988,
0.0008230835,
0.001794478,
0.0643559024,
-0.0052280831,
0.0026991486,
-0.0112034399,
-0.0142382365,
0.0564069413,
-0.05028392,
-0.0541921183,
-0.017069241,
0.0182546899,
-0.0015209948,
0.0107851457,
-0.0137123661,
-0.0705052614,
-0.0347202979,
0.0158782005,
0.02954676,
-0.0163946021,
0.0059450767,
-0.036996372,
0.0011521863,
0.018796958,
0.0036584858,
-0.0109261768,
-0.0345798619,
0.0551886447,
-0.0065309061,
0.0224853922,
-0.0318942815,
0.0234512929,
0.0114686796,
0.0027099608,
-0.0761452392,
-0.0711748973,
0.0268953424,
0.0142407473,
-0.0720941573,
-0.0008839365,
-0.0276601706,
0.0006717068,
0.0005922384,
-0.0488177314,
-0.0570752472,
-0.0015177645,
-0.0506859906,
-0.0002042681,
-0.0559562333,
0.0636836737,
0.0124982065,
-0.0328891426,
0.0038456989,
0.0127934143,
0.0453099608,
-0.0094296662,
-0.019995261,
0.0722043738,
0.0080191437,
-0.0018978546,
-0.0414658412,
-0.0086497329,
0.0430152081,
0.0156728588,
0.0345255472,
0.0075199227,
-0.0151689546,
-0.0301583223,
0.0086459694,
-0.0084399357,
-0.0881354511,
0.0448890999,
-0.019274693,
-0.0165143721,
-0.0147612458,
-0.0027533462,
-0.0529651195,
-0.004141307,
-0.0321810022,
0.0302517507,
-0.0189565849,
0.0268044956,
0.0113173369,
0.021821931,
-0.0415835828,
-0.0029811498,
0.0515569635,
-0.0095197903,
-0.05088377,
-0.0347225741,
-0.0443864688,
-0.0552393422,
-0.0020396835,
-0.0114303119,
0.0185152199,
-0.0409058221,
-0.0295442399,
-0.0982954949,
-0.0093167014,
-0.0130832521,
0.0129577816,
0.0132423108,
-0.0247591808,
0.003913505,
0.0484962091,
0.002720969,
0.0181190092,
-0.0545891523,
0.0255848169,
-0.0354809463,
0.0151079763,
-0.0629672855,
-6.168731336e-33,
-0.0063568871,
-0.056939546,
0.046670109,
0.0160352327,
0.0199397355,
-0.0410820954,
0.0012801966,
0.037041869,
0.0020230531,
-0.0037717512,
-0.0106780035,
-0.0229796264,
0.0226265751,
-0.0027432346,
0.0266740955,
0.0373194888,
0.0447183289,
-0.001095011,
-0.0240323003,
-0.0021599263,
0.0452776588,
-0.0181270521,
-0.01337732,
-0.056608092,
-0.0076436787,
0.0249762386,
0.0211196691,
0.0095420266,
-0.00374234,
0.0522907004,
0.0136013562,
0.0157390777,
-0.0002658952,
-0.0262895841,
-0.0323684402,
0.0822244659,
-0.0201411955,
0.0061134677,
0.0254698545,
-0.0151948696,
0.0583843142,
-0.0066654943,
-0.0081131915,
0.0132263079,
-0.0081401877,
0.0151497889,
0.0164060015,
-0.0339341834,
-0.0367334001,
0.04184727,
-0.0400701426,
0.0076198746,
-0.0308719482,
0.0239298083,
0.0133739859,
-0.0088306386,
-0.0341147482,
-0.00341607,
-0.0609730482,
0.0572781153,
-0.0092503401,
-0.0269343257,
0.0162669513,
0.0257954206,
0.0098562669,
0.0531152114,
0.0157654602,
0.0765481219,
-0.0435859449,
-0.0210729633,
-0.0331916437,
0.084372595,
0.0048775803,
0.0529680066,
-0.02397421,
-0.0181139279,
-0.0202009305,
0.0195991918,
0.0230969358,
-0.0149912033,
0.0837140381,
0.0735644922,
-0.0341333449,
-0.04316907,
-0.0026048813,
0.0291811619,
-0.0444575511,
-0.0353342071,
0.0007931848,
0.0212864224,
-0.0317887291,
0.0278427489,
0.0408611707,
-0.0262359958,
-0.0372317694,
0.0111538284,
0.0030067505,
-0.0127339745,
-0.0005485703,
-0.057953734,
-0.1117060483,
-0.0040841741,
-0.0316986889,
0.0205720086,
0.0195530057,
0.0352023132,
-0.0365446173,
-0.0543200336,
-0.0182588976,
0.0053887279,
-0.0210788455,
0.0175079331,
-0.0108712502,
-0.0160460472,
0.0311290007,
0.0007301506,
0.0089007486,
0.0044458099,
-0.0049260911,
-0.0319220014,
-0.0133182947,
-0.0102323452,
-0.0040822662,
-0.0026187059,
-0.0227791332,
-0.0311569516,
-0.0287379101,
0.0146143353,
0.0882403105,
0.0580434464,
-0.0150834359,
-0.0668051541,
2.863e-7,
0.0158346612,
0.0502091087,
-0.0278776567,
0.0242452063,
0.0390305035,
0.0556975342,
0.0200122409,
0.003810988,
0.018295465,
0.0115135117,
0.0446753874,
0.0273190923,
0.0673221424,
0.0613212921,
-0.0634524822,
-0.0533460565,
-0.016944427,
-0.0420014784,
-0.0554703251,
-0.0142007498,
0.0380235501,
0.0343701206,
0.0698196292,
0.0075945091,
-0.0206481665,
-0.0075945714,
0.0309853535,
-0.0757870376,
-0.051304616,
0.0262981448,
0.0149016231,
-0.0599265173,
-0.0024929659,
0.0401752554,
-0.0062794643,
-0.0209138952,
-0.0106060458,
0.0334332548,
-0.0337380655,
-0.0181734115,
-0.0126927067,
-0.0439205132,
0.0030493161,
0.0024467518,
-0.0021750252,
-0.0512903109,
-0.0378417857,
-0.0006132683,
0.004365135,
-0.0389969647,
0.0184456147,
0.0084198341,
0.0019174421,
-0.0013404131,
-0.0202768184,
-0.0030730327,
0.008653162,
-0.0377537496,
0.0275372546,
0.0451584347,
-0.0690077469,
-0.076543428,
-0.0024272329,
0.0022855664,
-0.0120937563,
0.0023805278,
0.0339299329,
1.964627815e-34,
0.016779257,
0.0959895104,
-0.0302370377,
0.0331979766,
0.0713035092,
0.0114979837,
-0.0020848429,
0.0141614852,
0.0552863069,
-0.0503637902,
-0.0259490013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02069v1 | Grounded Intuition of GPT-Vision's Abilities with Scientific Images | 2023-11-03T17:53:43 | 2023-11-03T17:53:43 | Alyssa Hwang, Andrew Head, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | GPT-Vision has impressed us on a range of vision-language tasks, but it comes
with the familiar new challenge: we have little idea of its capabilities and
limitations. In our study, we formalize a process that many have instinctively
been trying already to develop "grounded intuition" of this new model. Inspired
by the recent movement away from benchmarking in favor of example-driven
qualitative evaluation, we draw upon grounded theory and thematic analysis in
social science and human-computer interaction to establish a rigorous framework
for qualitative evaluation in natural language processing. We use our technique
to examine alt text generation for scientific figures, finding that GPT-Vision
is particularly sensitive to prompting, counterfactual text in images, and
relative spatial relationships. Our method and analysis aim to help researchers
ramp up their own grounded intuitions of new models while exposing how
GPT-Vision can be applied to make information more accessible. | [
0.0243466534,
0.0408076122,
-0.0070032603,
0.0264493674,
-0.0030627213,
0.0318545401,
-0.0189440548,
0.0141257141,
-0.0133988382,
-0.0247139297,
-0.0267048441,
-0.0249466151,
0.0552430712,
0.0344819762,
0.0178526342,
-0.0728113875,
-0.0206613466,
0.0008845709,
0.0047407467,
0.0132899964,
-0.0049404292,
0.0197342355,
-0.0070916135,
0.0308706239,
0.0027962613,
-0.0285733547,
0.0053737205,
0.0211232677,
0.0324463733,
-0.055751361,
-0.0527304746,
0.0263225082,
0.0493631102,
0.0135470442,
0.0000020295,
-0.0233266484,
0.0181370676,
0.0036833079,
0.0305378065,
-0.0077682794,
0.0118339779,
-0.0136132389,
0.0012369152,
-0.0419854969,
-0.0523678884,
0.0034557483,
0.0917402506,
0.0749647394,
0.0003515035,
-0.009416692,
-0.0131297829,
-0.0382072367,
-0.0182696097,
0.0131740272,
-0.000878423,
0.0491122082,
-0.0303807165,
0.0249896143,
0.0020866299,
0.0852509141,
-0.0082105473,
0.0420734696,
0.0092685623,
0.0067512053,
0.0332509726,
0.0830616802,
-0.0458695069,
-0.0137621965,
-0.0062859277,
0.0617686436,
0.0184789579,
0.0031166081,
0.0073718596,
-0.0263958517,
-0.0335646756,
0.0462404676,
-0.0736027136,
0.0082373945,
-0.0086321263,
0.0360476375,
-0.0364182591,
0.0419589058,
-0.0059622857,
0.0335211456,
0.0205684546,
0.0476234853,
0.0014934908,
0.0013853981,
0.0302216057,
0.0375606157,
-0.0141771305,
-0.035219565,
0.0197719838,
0.0142990788,
0.0469174944,
0.0006796373,
0.0177155752,
0.0267982408,
0.0119829411,
-0.0066153957,
0.028593827,
0.0167936496,
-0.0316926055,
0.0332703963,
0.0004273643,
0.064596653,
-0.0187310167,
-0.0104927151,
0.0348780677,
0.0539889187,
-0.0464445278,
-0.048536744,
-0.0085222041,
-0.0323778093,
-0.067849271,
-0.0256831776,
0.0038836563,
-0.0359444469,
0.0055003199,
0.0006226459,
-0.0091977734,
0.0545594357,
-0.0629162639,
-0.0025702175,
-0.0289087575,
0.0239131618,
-0.0197973587,
0.0124146622,
-0.0187009163,
-0.0595701002,
0.0021845235,
0.0179097876,
0.0149499392,
-0.0077329697,
-0.03722075,
0.0355212279,
0.0109650902,
-0.0268289465,
-0.0125201624,
-0.0662136972,
-0.0139487172,
-0.037293829,
0.0567559637,
-0.0255647935,
-0.0217279941,
0.0237809122,
0.0125281801,
-0.00816759,
0.0139402431,
0.0213136617,
-0.031254191,
0.1058175191,
-0.049030602,
-0.0461665466,
0.0064568333,
0.0473556258,
0.0122850863,
0.0514240675,
0.0318195634,
0.0196379013,
-0.0005541604,
-0.0285092387,
0.0191936586,
-0.0178404003,
0.0005269213,
0.0148460902,
-0.0283913426,
0.0015718946,
-0.0658779144,
0.055001013,
0.0056917425,
0.0297565907,
-0.0358570702,
0.0470567495,
0.075756155,
0.1076977178,
-0.0010839937,
0.008649203,
0.0017315936,
-0.0269978978,
-0.0196926948,
0.0544541776,
-0.0197349079,
0.0741617009,
0.0167819001,
0.0139917666,
-0.0691843927,
0.0524817929,
-0.0184455905,
-0.0217288211,
-0.0179510694,
0.032914903,
0.0178590324,
-0.0705008581,
0.0093694609,
0.019612059,
-0.0267112516,
-0.039857693,
-0.0117728617,
-0.0635549501,
0.003934327,
-0.0147180036,
-0.0158346705,
0.0546619818,
0.054322958,
0.0174551606,
0.0223089643,
-0.01013951,
0.0194131974,
0.0781093389,
-0.03311022,
0.0188783854,
-0.0409733057,
-0.0453927405,
-0.040205963,
-0.0318437666,
0.0052306554,
0.0349476822,
-0.0188087877,
0.0745568052,
0.0163264032,
-0.0590884201,
-0.0210914761,
0.022664953,
-0.0197895654,
-0.031649746,
-0.0465631559,
0.0249797404,
-0.0282072574,
0.0314126089,
-0.0139114708,
0.0330587849,
0.0027438567,
-0.0088553196,
0.016500188,
0.067550391,
-0.0074459892,
0.0205936339,
-0.0055920472,
-0.1637564749,
-0.0048133885,
0.0046086535,
0.0150855128,
-0.0335282348,
0.0359205715,
-0.0361932702,
0.0269648209,
-0.03927375,
-0.0206191167,
-0.0034302452,
-0.0039704842,
-0.0212260969,
0.066903688,
0.0050495914,
0.0209532585,
0.0197106469,
-0.0335047618,
0.0379863121,
-0.0321052484,
0.022792425,
0.036919076,
0.0598355122,
-0.0077532888,
0.0251730941,
0.0110210571,
-0.0551073477,
0.0327357799,
-0.0626952797,
-0.0396806896,
-0.0044843536,
-0.0050197532,
0.0243940447,
-0.0612743869,
0.0039674831,
-0.0078287823,
-0.0171526466,
-0.0117975725,
-0.0339332484,
0.0029090107,
0.0868294165,
-0.0020630644,
0.0210294444,
0.008045298,
0.011842953,
-0.0221237466,
0.0506174862,
0.086033456,
-0.0407229736,
-0.0579496883,
-0.0136347869,
-0.0260531381,
-0.0349318795,
0.0125310738,
-0.0022949583,
0.0890846923,
0.033717826,
0.0301141161,
0.029260179,
-0.017845327,
0.0615523681,
0.0221640375,
-0.0100959344,
-0.0097765997,
-0.0414534919,
-0.0013022841,
0.0408297628,
0.0651588961,
-0.0209251456,
0.0200658701,
0.0189719554,
-0.0162812304,
0.021428261,
-0.0737797767,
0.0821844488,
-0.0279958546,
-0.023224989,
-0.054455366,
-0.0259460341,
-0.0090548163,
0.0699699223,
-0.0026380965,
-0.0401616171,
0.0470619015,
-0.0335911214,
0.0024479502,
-0.0326795094,
0.027543053,
-0.0053793113,
0.09248247,
-0.0173435882,
0.0131902564,
0.0257265065,
-0.0213499423,
-0.0380346738,
-0.0029445253,
-0.0163526293,
0.0081003318,
0.0319309682,
-0.0891394317,
-0.0083494661,
-0.0294136219,
0.0007972002,
0.0000794294,
0.0164272841,
-0.062849924,
0.0037934587,
-0.0417409725,
-0.0334093645,
-0.0148976147,
0.0398535654,
0.0452743694,
0.0299620088,
-0.016509477,
-0.0153900553,
-0.0285757724,
-0.001513095,
0.046027191,
-0.0100049237,
0.0267675649,
0.0134837758,
-0.0111510865,
0.0602645092,
0.0226020906,
0.0076141055,
-0.0379724912,
0.0174391661,
0.01225249,
0.0270794276,
-0.0449505411,
-0.0003209503,
0.0811957642,
-0.0344379731,
-0.0176245589,
0.0696319565,
0.0207901131,
-0.0077343155,
0.0239623357,
0.0157206655,
0.0010995856,
-0.0007292732,
-0.0198447034,
-0.055934865,
-0.0134532526,
-0.0341461599,
-0.0271518528,
-0.0176886376,
-0.0440580696,
-0.0296756998,
-0.0830411837,
0.0803881586,
0.0157218613,
-0.0527507104,
-0.0537210554,
0.0127124945,
0.0140865399,
0.0383544937,
-0.021517111,
-0.0119381044,
0.0127618928,
0.0303593539,
0.0185227394,
0.0348109268,
-0.0352604464,
-0.0171177574,
-0.013835391,
-0.0389370658,
0.0266742948,
0.0699503049,
-0.0191582125,
-0.1139267087,
-0.0302734654,
-0.0030037002,
0.0440547802,
0.0005734788,
0.0106766839,
0.0178516638,
-0.0269147437,
0.0080019748,
0.0451693647,
-0.0550704971,
-0.0290328134,
-0.0272755902,
0.0866753459,
-0.048871588,
-0.0186349452,
-0.0533002354,
-0.011192359,
0.004508947,
0.0269788522,
0.065367803,
-0.0034329607,
-0.0369455107,
-0.0188162643,
0.1003593728,
-0.0007779709,
-0.0772284269,
-0.0024438656,
0.0041106488,
-0.0120968344,
-0.0588524118,
-0.0112605635,
0.0323086046,
0.0445868969,
0.0126609849,
-0.0313623734,
-0.0095747123,
0.0098121315,
-0.0428247973,
0.0937618092,
0.0160740241,
0.025607273,
0.0246731415,
-0.0034423545,
0.0244586859,
-0.0265526921,
-0.0304603335,
0.015824534,
0.0303296931,
-0.0345347933,
-0.0137800751,
-0.0027743299,
0.0301051959,
-0.0210365299,
0.0220670588,
-0.0610939562,
0.0056780209,
0.049906671,
0.0293556191,
0.0073170369,
-0.029444335,
-0.0126906177,
-0.0002555992,
-0.0107934447,
0.0274407268,
-0.0056583937,
-0.008356045,
-0.0256670471,
-0.0312134717,
-0.0010583289,
0.0064322278,
-0.0158614907,
0.0984662473,
-0.0358654223,
0.0310876165,
-0.017176237,
-0.0269151274,
-0.0217663292,
-0.0093209799,
-0.0536737666,
-0.0170428604,
-0.0081128143,
0.0226446576,
-0.0459483787,
-0.0439552888,
-0.0684071034,
0.0474890992,
-0.0440934859,
0.0084908605,
0.0230345577,
-0.0042847237,
-0.0125495177,
-0.0110990079,
-0.0245653056,
-0.005652125,
-0.0649176165,
0.0450508296,
0.0040453989,
0.0334077142,
0.0511853769,
-0.0114889266,
0.0457274653,
0.0252341982,
-0.0654133037,
-0.0230636932,
-0.0261230357,
0.0523520932,
0.0000316751,
-0.026218418,
0.022102695,
-0.0456098318,
-0.0063929348,
0.0308497436,
0.0098230001,
0.0123629775,
-0.0158012453,
0.0541092791,
0.0272664446,
-0.0180200078,
-0.0525695831,
0.0450181104,
-0.0217607897,
0.0053536673,
-0.0049973689,
-0.0356610566,
0.0051009883,
-0.0152671002,
-0.0026850482,
-0.0108174793,
0.0501739085,
0.0498592108,
-0.0944575891,
-0.0417921469,
0.0084677627,
0.019611802,
-0.0204710551,
-0.0236366969,
0.0761361867,
0.0535681881,
-0.0146884946,
-0.0349656232,
0.0309667569,
0.0096156439,
-0.0476991124,
-0.0174032301,
-0.0304574184,
-6.068867948e-33,
-0.0196580682,
-0.096030429,
0.0207461119,
-0.0209895372,
-0.0307738353,
0.0156823378,
-0.0384972729,
-0.0002130387,
0.0131659964,
0.0477907769,
-0.0061306842,
-0.0153497625,
-0.0037469035,
-0.0011597788,
0.0147677688,
0.0330509655,
0.0155324675,
0.0032203863,
-0.0358974449,
0.0124660702,
0.0033870968,
-0.0218277983,
0.0825377107,
-0.1045750156,
0.0260328911,
0.0279729664,
-0.006373697,
-0.0394032039,
0.0259402245,
0.037583828,
-0.0471827239,
0.0110628745,
0.017395094,
-0.051826369,
-0.0087612094,
0.0525473058,
-0.0098835956,
-0.0574060753,
0.0259425323,
0.0425164476,
-0.0518692657,
0.0047466136,
0.0159252957,
-0.0469962135,
-0.0406617746,
-0.0015259902,
0.0467744805,
-0.031727802,
0.0040097618,
0.0020372551,
-0.0539851934,
0.0225247703,
-0.0041429866,
0.034470804,
0.0160275456,
0.0035529935,
-0.0075343726,
0.0635391101,
-0.0318710841,
0.0492713451,
0.0435624197,
-0.0116213281,
0.0438691005,
0.0075332867,
0.0192261226,
0.0791870207,
-0.0143450564,
-0.005917205,
-0.045862671,
-0.0303889215,
0.0098771853,
0.0268241037,
0.084311083,
0.0502853692,
0.0363108926,
0.0305892248,
-0.0348998494,
0.0079298504,
-0.0582600869,
0.0227197483,
-0.0068419739,
0.0045864331,
-0.0372595266,
-0.0038593882,
0.0008023664,
-0.0652709529,
-0.0146464556,
-0.0193933249,
-0.0020403722,
-0.0443314351,
-0.0454279929,
0.0998891443,
-0.0109993825,
-0.0124246366,
-0.0387821384,
-0.0438674167,
-0.0101611214,
0.0312107019,
0.0293096639,
-0.0232702568,
-0.0487239324,
-0.0100103291,
0.0208963957,
0.0730685741,
0.0384920835,
-0.0050850054,
0.0012763911,
-0.0065611517,
-0.0309041124,
-0.018483229,
-0.0148626836,
-0.030719569,
0.009784976,
-0.0443491153,
0.0315882936,
-0.0201631505,
-0.0294332635,
0.0017574747,
0.0252134204,
-0.0195023287,
-0.0050201095,
-0.02184253,
-0.0569193773,
0.0255278889,
-0.0403237827,
-0.0177904423,
0.0158392191,
-0.0339381322,
0.071945399,
-0.0791134387,
-0.0376616195,
0.0005370404,
2.781e-7,
0.0323121063,
0.0346095823,
0.046187602,
-0.0434769243,
0.0278311968,
0.0136631988,
-0.0015613349,
0.0233823527,
-0.0133891087,
-0.0835050493,
0.0003137411,
0.0122935511,
-0.0024064551,
0.0237142295,
-0.0208831038,
0.0314104035,
-0.0292886458,
-0.0206131153,
-0.0662778765,
-0.0070021846,
0.0346648544,
-0.0318035372,
-0.0365002789,
-0.0192594249,
-0.0139790373,
-0.0388261974,
0.0531802848,
-0.0137118455,
0.0604592934,
-0.0656628013,
0.0131610362,
0.0259052608,
-0.0007960276,
0.0302152298,
0.0186370313,
-0.0200727452,
0.0634393767,
-0.0033321893,
-0.0374650098,
0.0156981237,
0.0085496819,
0.0066172816,
0.0053868112,
-0.0597295128,
0.0592301041,
-0.0553138144,
-0.0165711362,
0.0029398389,
-0.0148303807,
-0.0207768381,
0.0435276739,
0.0042328048,
-0.0560965277,
0.0204025954,
-0.0010036587,
0.0022363884,
-0.0355808884,
-0.0408721268,
0.0109712826,
-0.0165659506,
-0.0124014933,
-0.0233693291,
-0.0364639983,
-0.0220796242,
0.0158164743,
-0.0137532214,
-0.0729605183,
2.238590779e-34,
0.0178841688,
0.0181948971,
0.0466891155,
-0.0209366567,
0.017190041,
0.0175370965,
0.0417875201,
0.0055844276,
0.0545545667,
0.005325112,
-0.0181523673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02049v1 | Post Turing: Mapping the landscape of LLM Evaluation | 2023-11-03T17:24:50 | 2023-11-03T17:24:50 | Alexey Tikhonov, Ivan P. Yamshchikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | In the rapidly evolving landscape of Large Language Models (LLMs),
introduction of well-defined and standardized evaluation methodologies remains
a crucial challenge. This paper traces the historical trajectory of LLM
evaluations, from the foundational questions posed by Alan Turing to the modern
era of AI research. We categorize the evolution of LLMs into distinct periods,
each characterized by its unique benchmarks and evaluation criteria. As LLMs
increasingly mimic human-like behaviors, traditional evaluation proxies, such
as the Turing test, have become less reliable. We emphasize the pressing need
for a unified evaluation system, given the broader societal implications of
these models. Through an analysis of common evaluation methodologies, we
advocate for a qualitative shift in assessment approaches, underscoring the
importance of standardization and objective criteria. This work serves as a
call for the AI community to collaboratively address the challenges of LLM
evaluation, ensuring their reliability, fairness, and societal benefit. | [
0.0300693437,
0.0437818691,
-0.0316831209,
0.0125189237,
-0.0691409856,
0.0020301356,
0.0019800498,
0.0148614245,
0.0183654949,
-0.0107401507,
-0.0541710779,
-0.0260483157,
0.021818256,
0.0308532622,
0.0191673581,
-0.0170527343,
0.0384758264,
-0.0571956597,
0.006622761,
0.0189596508,
-0.0139783584,
-0.0359268747,
0.0040688738,
0.0376611315,
0.0406614505,
0.0181880668,
0.0063927481,
-0.0407126732,
0.0062414687,
-0.0063553951,
-0.0673762038,
0.035602361,
-0.0116758635,
0.0358978622,
0.000001932,
-0.0630949512,
0.0519548133,
0.0222715512,
-0.0372263417,
0.0192226209,
0.0377621017,
0.0333420485,
-0.0137922214,
0.0079852697,
-0.0323289707,
0.0236644018,
0.0408253893,
-0.0287377313,
0.0332603082,
0.0458221659,
0.0153931053,
0.0023604124,
0.0778965056,
-0.0004389405,
0.0061097099,
-0.0424960628,
-0.0130395703,
0.0248335693,
0.0564077683,
-0.0160451438,
0.0057856645,
0.0412769541,
0.0673847422,
-0.0223102793,
-0.0055511878,
0.0289892405,
-0.028168695,
-0.0386413001,
-0.0048893876,
0.0520441495,
0.0050946027,
-0.0001879391,
-0.0101199029,
0.0146187749,
-0.001441927,
-0.0038364707,
-0.0187864415,
0.0463031195,
0.0257783905,
-0.0063996515,
0.039598953,
0.0354725011,
0.0530227274,
0.027119277,
-0.0219889786,
0.0801666304,
0.0098016607,
-0.0501856841,
0.0094941696,
0.000373443,
0.0204412602,
-0.0498576835,
-0.0181530267,
0.037001051,
-0.0250030346,
-0.0075922967,
-0.0134255532,
0.0206130166,
0.0321014374,
-0.0450483002,
0.0798184201,
0.0237632357,
0.0111966217,
0.0480029173,
-0.0130687905,
0.1161722466,
-0.0090619475,
0.0139780231,
-0.0327014625,
0.0126860356,
-0.0561814234,
-0.0122199813,
0.0161771011,
0.0371067598,
0.0268171486,
-0.010481094,
-0.0110082943,
0.0381572172,
-0.0463807955,
0.0012411404,
0.0151198721,
-0.0298854839,
0.0388502441,
-0.0078988746,
-0.0208963323,
-0.037192516,
-0.0410114266,
0.0237971377,
-0.0063547837,
-0.0714411438,
0.0226811804,
0.0129966997,
-0.0527110621,
-0.017878063,
0.0356719941,
0.0937851593,
0.0506576113,
-0.0021664633,
-0.0027566364,
-0.0102093406,
0.0010114191,
-0.0724757984,
0.002211818,
-0.0600381829,
0.0070316838,
0.0114197638,
-0.010948943,
-0.0000151696,
-0.0148118967,
0.0103957234,
-0.0020700649,
0.0245412495,
0.0300457198,
0.036987517,
0.017078016,
0.025400877,
-0.0084179426,
0.0399733633,
0.0585586131,
0.0323749818,
0.0118115963,
-0.0069876458,
0.0653611869,
0.0519258417,
-0.0387008712,
-0.0136398347,
-0.0258805119,
0.0434034951,
-0.0130202202,
0.0405452587,
-0.0107835922,
0.110227786,
-0.0039458293,
-0.0049381768,
0.0549656786,
0.0549267195,
0.0062761563,
0.0272187609,
0.0453997441,
-0.0373108909,
0.0394929349,
0.0005070083,
-0.0565419644,
0.0180530604,
-0.0375489295,
0.0127305062,
0.0086391969,
-0.000266526,
-0.0041316492,
-0.0594895296,
-0.0102110375,
0.0163346417,
0.0418778211,
0.0157798864,
0.0401086248,
-0.0304011609,
-0.0323658995,
-0.0237524584,
-0.0430133492,
-0.0609785989,
-0.0017825495,
-0.1293175966,
0.0137130162,
0.0634517744,
0.0553045198,
-0.0025555138,
0.0056509245,
0.035277985,
-0.0209892392,
0.0447004475,
0.0264563058,
-0.0196165796,
-0.0101311887,
-0.0001564025,
-0.0062188539,
-0.00392533,
-0.0037669213,
0.0110126846,
-0.0142634064,
0.0028499635,
-0.0030783538,
-0.0743855163,
-0.0474956594,
0.0329664685,
-0.0054560909,
-0.0160899851,
-0.0581637062,
-0.0079141809,
0.0441052057,
0.0202092398,
-0.0440545492,
0.0560593344,
0.0317589045,
-0.0077413153,
-0.0067451852,
-0.010250451,
-0.0313958898,
0.066116564,
0.0439431034,
-0.0614663959,
-0.0004677387,
0.0871751383,
0.0133752413,
-0.0169314928,
0.023773564,
-0.0476596691,
0.0202761162,
-0.0120163858,
0.0540468767,
-0.0741365775,
-0.0358387977,
-0.0424463637,
0.0517059676,
-0.0293096658,
0.0255165473,
0.0188505184,
-0.0171751697,
0.0310825072,
-0.0303560998,
-0.0760583431,
0.0382385142,
0.0105405999,
0.0425237045,
0.0542059876,
0.0166504905,
-0.0629981756,
-0.0564018004,
-0.1029085442,
-0.0065104202,
-0.0112830782,
0.0366259217,
0.008373796,
-0.0243066903,
0.010169033,
0.0313671082,
-0.0241981186,
-0.0284969117,
0.0221062787,
0.0134325586,
0.0097499844,
-0.0154537782,
-0.066643253,
-0.0539085045,
-0.0267417561,
-0.011312467,
0.0304529835,
0.0059620705,
0.0334473513,
-0.0310292765,
0.0394937098,
-0.0218923353,
-0.0081418129,
-0.0073697069,
-0.0252199769,
0.0649196953,
0.0080418056,
0.0030216197,
0.0599939898,
0.013251123,
0.0117022144,
0.0516966321,
0.0146415578,
-0.0293197427,
-0.029508898,
0.0316193178,
-0.0289347619,
-0.0165024847,
-0.0703407153,
-0.0173884388,
0.0512297451,
-0.0115814777,
0.0263987724,
-0.0287230536,
0.0427382328,
-0.0649025738,
-0.0697889626,
-0.0360672027,
-0.0305770431,
-0.0280370116,
0.030767858,
-0.043644011,
-0.085504733,
0.0541918576,
-0.0438765325,
0.0137426695,
0.0003031349,
-0.0161861926,
-0.02507082,
0.1051659957,
-0.0120128226,
0.000591941,
-0.0287363492,
-0.0017552146,
-0.0392152667,
-0.0109610306,
-0.0161843356,
-0.0526047014,
0.0465435684,
-0.0480813421,
0.0301852021,
0.0052859159,
-0.0105423043,
-0.0265141577,
0.0019420359,
-0.0333784036,
0.0494676679,
0.0267927516,
-0.0355227217,
-0.010998887,
0.0310057178,
0.0430029631,
0.0027756281,
0.024388738,
-0.0020319289,
0.0035718635,
-0.0353954174,
0.0003934489,
0.0056266324,
0.0300540365,
0.0009228461,
0.0445566289,
0.0270067323,
0.0605874732,
0.0296197403,
-0.0397906639,
0.0095249647,
0.0193008315,
-0.0477721095,
-0.0189679377,
0.048771657,
0.0215165317,
-0.0504024886,
-0.0019002954,
0.1308941096,
0.0288409088,
-0.0104912911,
0.0148397358,
-0.0120264795,
-0.0257566851,
0.0144056603,
0.0001041537,
-0.0666307136,
0.0074741249,
0.0071009016,
0.0142496843,
-0.0418833308,
-0.0379701443,
0.0456100814,
-0.1020752341,
0.0090347156,
0.0007642013,
-0.0449252203,
-0.024560269,
-0.0500500761,
-0.0205878727,
-0.0055811461,
0.037769299,
0.0365432911,
0.0140986815,
-0.0132168559,
0.0036739006,
-0.0489268079,
-0.0194762051,
0.0998540595,
-0.043574959,
0.0806430727,
0.0746173114,
0.0316795185,
-0.0451202951,
-0.0458765998,
0.0322204903,
0.005134447,
0.0132704778,
0.0141665479,
-0.0000908602,
0.0078873197,
-0.0162894651,
-0.0469714142,
-0.0328388326,
-0.0261399336,
-0.0039847265,
-0.0045951414,
0.0628646314,
-0.0365890414,
-0.0499230362,
-0.0251943525,
-0.0249615535,
-0.0218106937,
0.0703078732,
0.0392610095,
-0.0478618182,
-0.0438344628,
-0.0173679907,
-0.0155257108,
-0.0379316956,
-0.0903988779,
-0.0025583252,
0.0445600711,
-0.0246437546,
-0.048127301,
-0.0544462726,
-0.004154027,
-0.0198808685,
0.0224768035,
-0.0239117425,
0.0025388536,
-0.0173571277,
-0.0484414361,
-0.0009022123,
-0.0183100998,
0.0387191586,
-0.0732479468,
-0.0057156417,
-0.0017380528,
-0.0240316223,
-0.0141688585,
0.0160494912,
-0.0178449843,
-0.0337977894,
0.0493198074,
0.0428700335,
0.0331923515,
-0.0579839423,
-0.029965831,
-0.0352870189,
0.0396313891,
-0.0130915605,
-0.0026266219,
0.0438694991,
0.0257752091,
-0.0216289759,
0.0070833168,
0.0114714457,
-0.028337473,
0.0094727483,
-0.0065144156,
0.0233787242,
0.0053167725,
-0.0345129892,
0.0171840861,
0.0417218246,
-0.0117137693,
-0.0253931899,
0.0224176925,
0.021931095,
-0.03347449,
-0.0247760266,
-0.0304297861,
-0.0386862792,
-0.018476449,
0.0494932868,
0.0379224047,
0.003406558,
-0.0039706375,
-0.0448963828,
-0.0005303873,
-0.0252088122,
0.0582882911,
0.0000819665,
0.0765078887,
0.0010044549,
0.0081562214,
-0.0211239681,
0.0400597192,
-0.0552953295,
0.0423561186,
0.0083778966,
0.0330299065,
-0.0174990315,
0.0210330077,
0.0049799904,
0.0782319382,
-0.0732165873,
-0.0792163014,
0.0126511883,
0.0386495478,
0.0568718277,
0.0376641229,
0.0372319743,
-0.0067757233,
0.022955535,
-0.04262238,
-0.0186981969,
0.0093104821,
-0.0292917639,
-0.0126265744,
0.0370995179,
-0.0009180111,
-0.0031553407,
0.0346309058,
-0.0309654865,
0.040204525,
-0.0033628754,
0.0049352599,
-0.0062997434,
-0.0599975251,
-0.0501554273,
-0.0402209647,
-0.019997213,
-0.037817385,
-0.0630012527,
-0.0729017556,
-0.0016622662,
0.08933644,
0.0418165289,
-0.0139935669,
0.03148105,
0.061930798,
0.0052728266,
-0.0081393765,
-0.0331201442,
-0.0088478597,
0.0009063357,
0.0017604926,
-0.0362011231,
-5.896590068e-33,
-0.0125737907,
-0.0011225725,
0.0338505208,
-0.042431578,
-0.0334297009,
-0.0024471348,
-0.0426769108,
0.0384373851,
-0.0614146665,
-0.013288944,
-0.0108563229,
-0.0070545515,
-0.0006216486,
-0.0385444611,
0.0024240969,
-0.0328291878,
-0.0040131705,
-0.015623806,
-0.03668648,
0.0014993564,
-0.0280752853,
-0.0531356595,
0.0510452278,
-0.0653242916,
0.0688728318,
-0.0046934159,
-0.0177883189,
-0.0177449398,
-0.0260559842,
0.0662856698,
-0.0105432617,
0.0348746441,
0.0333203264,
-0.0364882089,
0.0061595323,
0.0084636379,
0.0014319082,
0.0032739199,
0.040700715,
-0.0044565578,
-0.0081564831,
-0.0425795093,
0.0386973582,
0.0010642856,
-0.0845290273,
0.0079563586,
-0.0010875786,
-0.0236474425,
0.0274500418,
0.0156558678,
-0.0350943804,
0.0296129882,
-0.0199285727,
-0.0257756896,
-0.008214375,
-0.0244759396,
-0.0383417048,
-0.0237354618,
-0.056875702,
0.0248354673,
0.0112261176,
-0.0002826196,
0.1023682877,
0.0001389338,
0.0012963767,
0.0586378165,
0.0530687496,
0.0428249091,
-0.0051442985,
-0.0175966397,
0.0315537676,
0.0419969298,
0.0692287832,
-0.00423906,
-0.0043996582,
0.0003309703,
-0.0367336161,
0.011236704,
0.024740953,
0.0346648246,
0.0177669227,
0.002694668,
-0.0783759728,
-0.0117029082,
-0.0679973662,
0.0033375085,
-0.0394812189,
-0.0113469651,
0.0459220931,
-0.0266375504,
0.0082719829,
-0.0527565368,
0.0362437293,
-0.0762256905,
0.0080493288,
-0.0078850463,
-0.0136045655,
0.0741161779,
0.0172077753,
0.0158503428,
-0.0338817276,
-0.0171771701,
0.0070577124,
0.0711591095,
0.0442433245,
-0.0201304201,
-0.0474886708,
0.0498125441,
-0.0125973094,
-0.0132456422,
-0.0231064484,
-0.0259199087,
0.0323677696,
-0.0055112033,
0.026633298,
-0.0025376324,
-0.0063920189,
0.0054827826,
-0.0321790464,
-0.0055571818,
-0.0609090775,
0.03301429,
-0.0066387332,
-0.0083421888,
-0.0182611924,
-0.0008767183,
-0.0543851927,
0.0553343743,
0.0281978957,
-0.0063901856,
-0.0030483101,
0.0027409762,
2.715e-7,
0.0286851581,
0.0250658281,
0.0229967553,
0.0418695509,
-0.0114915604,
0.018345451,
-0.035226848,
0.0239217561,
0.0077318959,
0.0125927618,
0.0058766762,
0.0533605739,
0.0286564175,
-0.0123317903,
-0.0240556784,
-0.0333783999,
-0.0731694102,
0.0039127208,
-0.0130925905,
0.0355901159,
0.0159644522,
0.0418225452,
-0.0019164587,
-0.0063890927,
-0.029070491,
-0.0754599422,
0.0021026556,
-0.0529259853,
-0.0006876544,
0.0305582788,
0.0201069266,
0.0437525734,
0.0068874806,
0.0079924492,
0.0349708647,
0.0180753358,
0.0064941528,
0.0602318235,
-0.0034965198,
-0.0095366165,
-0.0043510306,
-0.0356419683,
0.0107865613,
-0.0527662262,
0.0701228902,
0.019455066,
-0.0363063402,
-0.0409159623,
-0.0128308805,
0.0060053286,
0.038494505,
-0.0075222035,
-0.0239719395,
0.0257101748,
0.0233592112,
-0.0217219871,
-0.0122763664,
-0.0261502378,
-0.0356804729,
-0.0124951741,
-0.0293784477,
-0.1078455523,
-0.0563874543,
-0.0068087406,
-0.0014259221,
-0.0651328191,
0.0016739647,
2.163995331e-34,
0.0214971937,
-0.0168462917,
0.0422728993,
0.0148121808,
0.0407832339,
0.0504087918,
-0.0141167743,
-0.0130169392,
-0.0039399951,
-0.0622288398,
-0.0162073839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04927v1 | Contextualizing the Limits of Model & Evaluation Dataset Curation on Semantic Similarity Classification Tasks | 2023-11-03T17:12:07 | 2023-11-03T17:12:07 | Daniel Theron | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper demonstrates how the limitations of pre-trained models and open
evaluation datasets factor into assessing the performance of binary semantic
similarity classification tasks. As (1) end-user-facing documentation around
the curation of these datasets and pre-trained model training regimes is often
not easily accessible and (2) given the lower friction and higher demand to
quickly deploy such systems in real-world contexts, our study reinforces prior
work showing performance disparities across datasets, embedding techniques and
distance metrics, while highlighting the importance of understanding how data
is collected, curated and analyzed in semantic similarity classification. | [
0.0320225731,
0.0472879633,
0.0027485644,
0.0383689366,
-0.044077713,
0.0516581647,
0.0360627659,
0.0030690904,
-0.0291858036,
-0.0601683557,
-0.0407479256,
0.0123461382,
0.0000633868,
-0.0134873232,
-0.0139353406,
-0.0226627178,
0.0359240696,
0.0726837814,
-0.0411111079,
0.0198938288,
0.0051748808,
0.0154735707,
0.0124351112,
0.0502545051,
-0.0069649965,
-0.0051678861,
0.0086566685,
-0.0015039467,
0.0016804829,
-0.0283281151,
-0.0133274253,
0.0238117408,
0.0587490387,
0.0660222918,
0.000001517,
-0.0646028519,
0.0097612301,
0.0020156361,
-0.0382579304,
-0.022676101,
0.04611497,
0.0137473019,
0.0643267483,
-0.0085824216,
-0.0151235666,
-0.0533099063,
0.0740901753,
0.0134331994,
0.0259923469,
0.0077887652,
-0.0317773372,
-0.0167937521,
-0.0070769577,
0.0124906553,
0.0064327912,
0.0056900848,
0.000763067,
0.0317128673,
-0.0421392247,
0.0204199944,
-0.0024649065,
-0.0052987114,
0.0110317376,
0.0861661211,
0.009591816,
0.0475672819,
-0.0392838158,
-0.0313855186,
0.028289251,
0.0757732466,
-0.0215918869,
-0.0515406616,
-0.0110989632,
-0.0091072563,
-0.0364990868,
0.0140936868,
-0.028515093,
0.0066397223,
-0.0017660294,
0.0602524877,
-0.022452049,
0.0488931164,
0.0264690965,
0.0365153663,
-0.0269318093,
0.035983976,
-0.0102341017,
-0.0342968069,
0.0307222363,
0.0280357264,
0.0073335045,
-0.01898757,
-0.0202293582,
-0.0034283558,
0.0281397663,
0.0083593763,
-0.0652152821,
-0.0146672772,
0.056636475,
-0.0338572487,
0.1035685241,
0.0312117804,
-0.045931343,
0.0726028308,
-0.0445692763,
-0.0067835804,
0.0124535896,
0.0866442099,
-0.0296626464,
-0.007484532,
-0.073753193,
0.0183405709,
-0.0219057687,
0.0079369452,
0.0082158297,
-0.0344911478,
-0.003805927,
0.0185750984,
-0.0225674361,
0.0208655838,
0.0053112167,
0.013457343,
0.0100849364,
0.0127105303,
-0.0519811325,
-0.05861843,
-0.0402740054,
0.0616850369,
-0.046240937,
-0.0447100028,
0.0090299416,
0.0156492013,
0.0029246474,
-0.0150947459,
0.0115896082,
0.0208790824,
0.0080615291,
-0.0363167003,
-0.0097136386,
-0.0631719455,
0.0354720429,
-0.0151609108,
-0.0233738255,
-0.0574790463,
0.041284699,
0.0169834476,
-0.0157084614,
-0.0627656728,
-0.0301889051,
0.0147024151,
-0.0100520886,
0.1387039423,
-0.0588996299,
-0.0067678662,
0.0134230061,
0.0082760183,
0.014393555,
0.0322552659,
-0.0201891847,
0.0049917977,
0.0681732595,
0.0229066741,
-0.0298405588,
-0.0333092064,
0.0242056623,
-0.0080251107,
-0.0164363012,
0.0509749316,
0.0406567641,
0.0517751798,
0.0233967826,
0.0081719235,
-0.0380996726,
-0.0547490194,
0.0022305758,
0.0972428247,
0.0584443472,
0.0082306797,
0.0242963098,
0.0141139831,
-0.0408442318,
-0.0298314244,
-0.0265308097,
-0.0181316026,
0.0115486924,
-0.0056805941,
0.0352634229,
0.0241419747,
-0.0453038029,
-0.0084566027,
-0.0216251388,
-0.0286203194,
0.0187158454,
-0.0190039519,
0.0220773872,
0.0072544985,
0.0036188886,
0.0717860535,
0.0437118709,
-0.0418220907,
-0.0464557037,
-0.029629441,
0.0157982036,
0.0574195459,
0.0342746451,
-0.0454238541,
0.0157675501,
0.0079302378,
0.038987536,
-0.0349592417,
0.0395143963,
-0.0162574053,
0.0042380695,
-0.0553370304,
-0.084515743,
-0.0333571099,
0.0016469079,
-0.0007776065,
0.0299830437,
0.021201225,
0.0515748858,
-0.0298013203,
-0.0210109651,
0.0548003837,
0.0101589672,
-0.0078308983,
-0.0023567949,
0.0209562704,
0.0246251784,
0.0131309908,
-0.0047925087,
0.0158659499,
0.0206196029,
-0.0089783473,
-0.0037865264,
-0.0032925175,
-0.0201649498,
0.0132976566,
0.0863649845,
-0.0270737614,
0.0249135774,
0.0626101047,
-0.0626332685,
0.0108162407,
0.0081367884,
0.0066354941,
0.042982325,
-0.0681176558,
0.0069111339,
-0.0385813788,
-0.0087550981,
-0.0139157334,
0.0620134361,
0.0039930227,
0.044186607,
-0.0453700759,
0.0213912744,
0.0886750147,
0.0107751722,
-0.0119449794,
-0.0004329968,
-0.0071573867,
0.0154028935,
-0.0265039541,
-0.0084290607,
-0.040162731,
0.0409455448,
-0.1133977249,
-0.0028408885,
0.0056417948,
0.0048049656,
0.0262897462,
-0.0047807498,
-0.0116618313,
-0.029933,
-0.003059546,
-0.0140386224,
-0.0313260667,
0.0280932151,
0.0346895158,
-0.006692599,
0.0003785513,
-0.0418752991,
-0.0345707759,
0.0076932632,
0.065157041,
-0.0001117026,
0.0254973918,
-0.0220587924,
0.0225276016,
-0.071399264,
-0.0022244232,
0.0216360725,
0.0309924241,
0.0185118429,
0.0111740706,
-0.0057031186,
-0.0102016665,
-0.0222080592,
0.0481479205,
0.0822225884,
0.0441153422,
-0.0616449751,
-0.0313611254,
-0.024681855,
-0.005292166,
-0.0128070144,
0.0049269609,
-0.0052399132,
-0.0037977179,
0.0034797594,
-0.0060841721,
-0.0243167505,
0.0398251191,
-0.012109559,
-0.0110872397,
-0.1084474623,
-0.0017887079,
0.0086915037,
0.0321844816,
-0.0163463727,
-0.0324086286,
0.0830321014,
-0.0192863047,
0.0402013883,
-0.0380952843,
-0.0331130512,
-0.0554352254,
0.0851312429,
-0.0237792563,
0.0117873326,
-0.0389198214,
0.031678386,
-0.0089088976,
0.0067058108,
0.0170154311,
-0.0166331753,
0.0071583022,
-0.0080049373,
0.0066011446,
-0.0100785876,
-0.0283893235,
-0.0005635113,
-0.0607602671,
-0.0537791774,
-0.0157596972,
-0.0065481663,
0.0364848413,
-0.0267047677,
0.0147627741,
-0.0305635855,
0.0562362,
0.0440696515,
-0.0312870108,
-0.0206893273,
0.0144713344,
0.0094060441,
-0.0193755515,
-0.0027840247,
0.0051436084,
-0.0189510491,
0.0097344443,
0.0189238954,
-0.0167098697,
-0.0438748486,
0.0216853917,
-0.0070949546,
-0.0397556052,
-0.0005786936,
-0.0005177529,
0.0162470508,
-0.0024700647,
-0.0073716859,
0.0857768357,
0.0675588548,
-0.02133766,
0.0017256608,
-0.0315716565,
0.0117699606,
0.0365887545,
-0.0436493307,
-0.0632894412,
-0.0438417532,
-0.0202329401,
0.0238147471,
-0.0099680973,
-0.0159339942,
-0.0150213446,
-0.0712462962,
0.0150127541,
-0.0183327086,
-0.0290267877,
-0.0213247836,
-0.0698416233,
0.0037972515,
-0.0256633665,
-0.0273834132,
-0.0661373511,
-0.0082830619,
0.0197319947,
-0.0035723643,
-0.0243495945,
-0.0343250111,
0.022514319,
-0.0494500585,
0.0049961787,
0.0272379369,
0.0175489746,
0.0477392413,
-0.0323933549,
0.0165353622,
-0.0297341496,
0.0086486936,
-0.0166272726,
0.0756153017,
-0.0133546619,
0.0083251344,
-0.0267142281,
0.0031517718,
-0.0509676971,
-0.0187835582,
-0.0075470642,
0.0788697973,
-0.0413704775,
0.0140641378,
-0.0417812392,
-0.006015419,
0.0143687176,
0.0942904726,
0.0374187194,
-0.0024838585,
-0.0260672867,
0.0288754795,
0.0339332484,
0.0264666993,
-0.0005855834,
-0.0095312633,
-0.024045866,
-0.0112536317,
-0.0302953329,
-0.0488659739,
0.03070754,
-0.0047831098,
-0.0230187811,
-0.022102166,
-0.0099940468,
-0.0211881734,
-0.0895509943,
0.0461956114,
-0.0361103192,
0.0354324356,
-0.0122421132,
-0.0253537651,
0.0513439029,
0.0335209519,
-0.050233461,
-0.0166357234,
-0.0633347034,
-0.0031884485,
-0.0299224723,
0.0014592165,
0.0193248168,
0.0308472719,
0.0128169199,
-0.0121422634,
0.0312399119,
0.0247357395,
-0.0453489795,
-0.0224853661,
0.0231623966,
-0.014670142,
0.0088729635,
0.0271552857,
-0.0212628711,
0.0311904773,
0.0133174825,
-0.0367173329,
-0.0223112181,
-0.0401880816,
0.0184144322,
-0.0121632768,
0.0612773821,
0.009158426,
-0.0313510075,
-0.0327606052,
-0.0065170559,
0.0112898787,
0.0003674641,
-0.0230682045,
-0.019057136,
0.0385896228,
0.0257218052,
-0.0107319811,
0.029607093,
-0.0087577598,
0.0578464679,
-0.0695675388,
-0.0005951386,
0.0242713597,
0.0846609697,
-0.0286513697,
0.0050726682,
-0.0669310838,
-0.0202402715,
-0.0527000353,
-0.0222239867,
-0.0270001851,
0.0275535937,
0.0071846773,
0.0586666949,
-0.0393417627,
0.0731504858,
-0.0285085943,
-0.0289738197,
-0.0284406655,
0.0004790481,
0.0080091842,
-0.045176208,
-0.0190488361,
-0.0143539459,
-0.0268542022,
0.0055768257,
-0.0000276833,
-0.0575003512,
-0.0226704981,
0.0277605392,
0.0125275394,
-0.0328244716,
0.013962674,
0.0763757974,
-0.018673962,
0.052402027,
-0.0208535399,
-0.0723114982,
-0.0142413368,
-0.0275158137,
0.0592079908,
0.0458462872,
0.0106692808,
-0.0209055524,
-0.0353946686,
-0.0387487561,
0.0171135534,
-0.0090784729,
-0.030045202,
0.0523298681,
0.0905638859,
0.05262376,
-0.0013836611,
-0.0163930822,
0.0226483513,
-0.0495901108,
-0.0068150363,
-0.0364850871,
-0.0431168899,
-5.137400715e-33,
0.0046530017,
0.0282381549,
0.0072109471,
-0.0339837,
0.0052335933,
-0.0124222953,
0.0255972706,
-0.0169936735,
-0.0437621064,
0.0168308765,
0.033280082,
0.025950525,
0.0054182638,
0.0105527844,
0.0147852907,
-0.0375437066,
0.0390949063,
-0.011196889,
-0.0253701862,
0.0223911144,
0.0508321337,
-0.0031983475,
0.0123826992,
-0.1140041351,
-0.0087363515,
0.0196737405,
0.0404280573,
-0.0141667658,
0.0578226224,
0.0685161054,
-0.0300521459,
0.0770016983,
0.0254182089,
-0.0099132182,
-0.0448407494,
0.0071984455,
-0.0541621298,
-0.0590781234,
0.0124437585,
-0.0289712083,
0.0057762726,
-0.0035468873,
0.0132863922,
0.0072627254,
-0.0371401012,
-0.0482514203,
0.0535674132,
-0.0037595897,
-0.0318863057,
-0.0281355847,
-0.0424880609,
0.0135408975,
-0.0177823249,
-0.0072215809,
0.0470669605,
0.0361247435,
0.0052415081,
0.006466208,
-0.0771130323,
0.031360615,
-0.0087511064,
-0.0343452282,
0.0525133647,
0.0004138774,
0.0274023488,
0.0691317916,
0.0009854481,
-0.0798368156,
-0.0187443718,
0.041720897,
0.0161017291,
0.0540298261,
0.0302014295,
0.035788577,
0.0394680128,
-0.024908049,
-0.033543393,
0.0311452691,
-0.0560239926,
-0.0062077525,
0.0138195213,
0.0365561545,
-0.0383411162,
-0.0304032266,
-0.0234104786,
0.010843358,
-0.0318173282,
-0.0506473035,
0.0530722104,
-0.0226223413,
0.0041901753,
0.0308914036,
-0.014048622,
-0.0556370541,
-0.010947017,
0.0118952654,
0.0179981459,
0.0013440672,
0.0132043781,
-0.0234311298,
-0.0464528166,
-0.0350327678,
0.0372656807,
0.0004624909,
0.0295754187,
-0.0293561462,
0.0595238581,
-0.0021164003,
-0.0464167781,
0.0028004141,
0.0177332405,
-0.058875706,
0.0020918727,
-0.0205430165,
-0.0053997859,
0.0467836112,
0.0090343067,
0.049475275,
0.0379560366,
-0.0084685544,
-0.0367445685,
-0.0574717224,
-0.0022115235,
0.0048128213,
0.0096778637,
-0.0069917813,
-0.0608147383,
-0.037475124,
0.0368579887,
-0.0258649103,
-0.0217357222,
0.0079587167,
2.207e-7,
0.0567009151,
-0.0089085847,
0.0082885902,
-0.008675715,
-0.0220727194,
0.0023027936,
0.0281159692,
0.060025733,
-0.0190755762,
-0.0061788652,
0.0657310039,
0.0213797223,
0.0131171308,
0.0305363368,
0.0034599476,
0.00544204,
-0.104652293,
-0.0281654801,
-0.0991949961,
0.002776738,
0.0813933387,
0.0835298896,
0.0377991535,
0.0017847846,
-0.0048669679,
-0.0388329625,
0.0374012068,
-0.0819859281,
0.0510911308,
-0.0244233701,
0.0568792224,
0.0123049906,
0.027020555,
0.016324088,
0.0120347338,
0.0102107888,
0.0484020002,
-0.0164204426,
-0.020589944,
-0.0246988218,
-0.0520621501,
-0.0408222452,
0.007314276,
-0.0937298983,
0.0823119432,
-0.0349126607,
-0.0018863257,
-0.0027967126,
0.0011813977,
0.0379355252,
0.0790773109,
0.0399162807,
-0.0098415846,
-0.0112270983,
0.0588541627,
-0.0196917336,
-0.0115693975,
-0.0978620797,
0.0101686725,
0.0424743295,
-0.0335158296,
-0.0186692625,
-0.016933633,
0.0024296667,
0.0646399632,
-0.0333420821,
0.020622436,
1.516173162e-34,
-0.0234847441,
0.0340266153,
0.0474144444,
-0.0440112948,
0.0186147988,
-0.0189102143,
0.0284982175,
-0.0036646803,
0.0092107411,
-0.0456532463,
0.0463014469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01623v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01623v4 | VQPy: An Object-Oriented Approach to Modern Video Analytics | 2023-11-03T16:58:10 | 2024-06-03T22:36:36 | Shan Yu, Zhenting Zhu, Yu Chen, Hanchen Xu, Pengzhan Zhao, Yang Wang, Arthi Padmanabhan, Hugo Latapie, Harry Xu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Video analytics is widely used in contemporary systems and services. At the
forefront of video analytics are video queries that users develop to find
objects of particular interest. Building upon the insight that video objects
(e.g., human, animals, cars, etc.), the center of video analytics, are similar
in spirit to objects modeled by traditional object-oriented languages, we
propose to develop an object-oriented approach to video analytics. This
approach, named VQPy, consists of a frontend$\unicode{x2015}$a Python variant
with constructs that make it easy for users to express video objects and their
interactions$\unicode{x2015}$as well as an extensible backend that can
automatically construct and optimize pipelines based on video objects. We have
implemented and open-sourced VQPy, which has been productized in Cisco as part
of its DeepVision framework. | [
-0.0013880007,
0.0842253417,
-0.0063072662,
0.0040253582,
0.0015728369,
0.0118681174,
0.0247733537,
0.0347121358,
-0.0132038547,
-0.0640847161,
0.0423499718,
0.0040108631,
-0.0403471291,
0.1063960046,
0.0040800469,
-0.1034377962,
0.0045515168,
0.0008093327,
-0.0348010808,
0.0444072336,
-0.0003568233,
0.0044282977,
-0.0142439911,
0.0170910731,
-0.0718168318,
-0.0229150765,
-0.0404633246,
-0.0128550911,
0.0209821984,
0.0005355345,
-0.0151271736,
0.0305845607,
0.0738028511,
0.0372544192,
0.0000021104,
-0.017331332,
-0.0042084986,
0.0034905854,
0.0334902368,
0.0509713069,
0.0485406145,
-0.0378764831,
0.0042295307,
0.0014880885,
0.0000962669,
0.002262973,
0.0796658546,
-0.0520448275,
0.0361491814,
-0.0050878697,
-0.0416292883,
-0.0440371372,
-0.0122088008,
0.0281654503,
0.0479008295,
0.0024774275,
0.0066819498,
0.0072895102,
0.0569574609,
-0.0306454543,
-0.0169152971,
-0.003894408,
-0.0103137782,
-0.0473995544,
0.0457441621,
0.0179463048,
-0.0124282688,
-0.0779940486,
-0.0316745341,
-0.0285453908,
-0.0327257104,
-0.0001308228,
0.0402773172,
0.0044386568,
-0.0467329547,
-0.0312406551,
-0.0554888137,
0.0192637965,
0.0262746997,
-0.0367905945,
-0.0625241473,
0.0276839659,
-0.0319969915,
-0.0319074504,
0.0174425971,
-0.0588593967,
0.0515602082,
0.0510893911,
-0.0549507849,
0.0282905307,
0.0511044599,
-0.0460138172,
0.0360501185,
0.0151449246,
-0.0245361831,
-0.0357386172,
0.0225217082,
0.0346132182,
-0.029334601,
-0.0396042503,
0.0407090932,
-0.0032805153,
-0.0311358552,
0.0374321453,
0.0337855853,
0.0487722158,
-0.0464574508,
-0.0195401832,
0.0374246463,
0.0002094742,
-0.0506432317,
0.0117548285,
0.0254923161,
-0.0156443194,
-0.0046159965,
0.0102568464,
0.015485609,
0.0923331529,
-0.0730517507,
0.0169699416,
-0.1083696038,
0.0135900313,
0.0494061075,
0.0485687517,
-0.0281531811,
0.023538718,
-0.0352451801,
-0.0270498618,
-0.0046816901,
-0.0441444777,
0.0208311435,
0.0290495791,
0.0253977608,
-0.022706382,
0.0136611806,
0.0228405055,
-0.0157546811,
-0.0042784591,
-0.0004151759,
-0.0222375654,
0.0558319315,
0.0318948142,
0.0124181593,
-0.0453127027,
0.034189783,
-0.0205875486,
0.016110966,
0.0326553509,
-0.0251363982,
0.0048810737,
-0.0196647812,
0.035243459,
0.0188402496,
0.0377327874,
0.0073978053,
0.0167325847,
0.0552253723,
0.0402067006,
-0.0355529562,
-0.0151833976,
0.0330563113,
-0.0403111987,
0.0532409474,
-0.0191842113,
-0.0599102192,
0.0236878917,
-0.0746347159,
0.0359439701,
-0.047291223,
-0.006817318,
-0.0012889911,
-0.0166668203,
-0.0040731668,
-0.0014033166,
0.0003214635,
0.0081705479,
-0.0252920482,
-0.0532007404,
0.0677411258,
0.0157961994,
-0.0097855041,
-0.0102711301,
0.0131891333,
0.1461100876,
0.048962675,
-0.0334717929,
-0.0862034857,
0.0599673204,
-0.0704923943,
-0.0568269044,
-0.0108680269,
-0.000118086,
0.0135408305,
0.0110346926,
0.0582613535,
-0.018914124,
0.0044426741,
-0.0351856835,
-0.020106839,
-0.0392808132,
-0.0064018201,
-0.0370492414,
0.0333084129,
0.0427407697,
0.0164211821,
-0.0382334553,
-0.0436328016,
-0.015332046,
-0.0057543353,
-0.0259771682,
0.068165727,
-0.0368432738,
0.0178099778,
-0.0125552546,
-0.0199633986,
-0.0061750915,
0.041839499,
0.0350022651,
-0.0082163857,
0.008029731,
-0.0129615879,
0.0369880423,
0.0211581923,
0.0702001825,
0.0629096255,
0.0283135734,
-0.0129736364,
0.033375904,
-0.0168972686,
0.000082897,
0.0094145397,
-0.02948373,
0.0462752394,
0.054436747,
0.0578035414,
0.0025046489,
0.0625027195,
0.0871836767,
-0.0086713713,
-0.0386064909,
-0.005262279,
0.0421802849,
-0.0467725992,
-0.0115224821,
0.0337507278,
-0.0040755179,
0.0052534379,
-0.0145015251,
0.0111959884,
-0.0045362888,
0.0029617373,
0.0304185301,
-0.0148645714,
0.0519429445,
-0.0161766913,
-0.0033612016,
-0.0152673507,
0.0463206358,
-0.0219974369,
-0.0016918139,
-0.0158015378,
-0.0306713507,
0.0390981063,
0.0419894084,
0.0011723326,
-0.0208751131,
0.0370656997,
-0.0129011851,
-0.0018358412,
-0.0051093772,
-0.0153659172,
0.0074645742,
0.0493755639,
-0.0135759143,
-0.0230382625,
0.0569737554,
0.0143321753,
-0.0614751428,
0.0115914224,
0.0112056322,
0.0327421054,
-0.0593057536,
0.0108332084,
-0.0364476629,
0.0033282109,
0.0230383985,
0.029376138,
-0.0415644199,
0.0196777266,
-0.0635351315,
-0.0228188448,
0.0148346024,
0.0099434592,
-0.0257902481,
0.021781031,
0.0250123758,
-0.0139366193,
0.0849416628,
-0.0002883464,
0.034738034,
0.0351772122,
0.0001540955,
0.0292135794,
-0.0038722767,
-0.0218205359,
-0.0487876795,
0.0679066032,
0.0077563557,
0.0240801051,
-0.0213048756,
-0.1030722484,
0.0028814599,
-0.0467790589,
0.0372596905,
0.0375876427,
-0.002675429,
-0.028544046,
-0.0092589026,
-0.0038593232,
0.0175295975,
0.0222132895,
-0.0125969257,
0.0053099054,
0.0170888323,
-0.0071308538,
0.0448416509,
-0.0302388333,
-0.0296537243,
0.090637818,
0.0806945488,
0.0184916332,
-0.0658770427,
-0.0362949707,
-0.0379185118,
0.0209837947,
-0.0120004443,
-0.0139216511,
-0.0096140727,
-0.0556944571,
-0.0144461999,
0.0156374201,
0.0143544823,
-0.0189184546,
0.0586189926,
-0.0283655357,
-0.0258815847,
-0.0692040622,
-0.0187763032,
-0.0011762936,
0.0440644324,
-0.0395749398,
0.0425991639,
0.0403518863,
0.0101654101,
-0.0017787375,
-0.0452416316,
0.001458965,
-0.0197110884,
-0.0740802288,
-0.0166945923,
0.0455745049,
0.0536842272,
0.0035383303,
-0.0180596542,
-0.0432676747,
0.0623163246,
0.0056811208,
-0.0008090264,
-0.0363824777,
0.016586706,
0.0261151288,
-0.0728944689,
-0.0136181377,
0.0244053658,
0.0023277884,
-0.0726285726,
0.0157212522,
0.0071634301,
-0.0234637931,
0.0781583264,
0.0551084429,
-0.0762049258,
-0.0186877567,
-0.0115325218,
0.0132050151,
-0.0207834914,
-0.0049067894,
0.0089891795,
-0.0262820292,
0.1109221056,
-0.0091913091,
-0.006590792,
-0.0057962141,
-0.052242659,
0.0657457486,
-0.087577641,
-0.0379392169,
0.0095466133,
-0.0232434366,
0.0076527535,
-0.0263373666,
-0.0233781971,
0.0191440396,
0.0023522053,
-0.0491396822,
-0.0432763211,
0.0532268099,
0.050044626,
-0.0161037687,
-0.033104334,
-0.01795513,
-0.0146330483,
-0.0220196955,
-0.0248062871,
0.0414649062,
-0.045666337,
-0.0483697318,
0.020852806,
0.0069363653,
0.0190112777,
-0.0251750536,
-0.0598964319,
0.0539348163,
-0.037638966,
0.0067738839,
-0.0773623809,
-0.0438237451,
0.0305345878,
0.0362513736,
-0.0271008294,
-0.0020571919,
-0.0448357686,
0.0230523404,
-0.0674036816,
0.0329923742,
-0.0587723814,
-0.0012333308,
-0.033782009,
-0.0987857804,
-0.0212099031,
0.0638306588,
0.0710565448,
-0.010718164,
-0.0627462193,
-0.0560713261,
-0.009952412,
0.0122492407,
-0.0978217497,
0.0169630218,
0.0528092347,
0.0250533205,
-0.0210973769,
-0.035185691,
0.0349706039,
0.0519544259,
-0.0226345044,
0.0257489346,
-0.0182130449,
-0.0198519044,
0.0205218978,
0.0924453959,
0.0215911567,
-0.0103547629,
0.0133999139,
0.036910627,
-0.0706688091,
0.0349124819,
-0.0190279204,
-0.0059301415,
-0.0463018008,
-0.0729600489,
-0.0325386226,
-0.0096602608,
-0.0386903398,
0.0050781881,
-0.0613456331,
-0.0032693788,
-0.054116562,
-0.0147355944,
-0.0368596911,
-0.0507018939,
0.0264320541,
0.0390358567,
-0.0400236361,
0.0090787355,
-0.0168474317,
0.0012608067,
0.0344972201,
-0.0714379922,
0.0048587401,
-0.0411015116,
0.0230348781,
0.0031517546,
0.0553427339,
-0.0132169705,
-0.0244350191,
-0.0493969843,
-0.0097274166,
0.0034127925,
-0.040363092,
0.0029878635,
0.0181845594,
0.067762427,
0.0139741385,
-0.0086874152,
0.0890354365,
-0.0144530078,
-0.0145982839,
-0.0093230437,
0.0502013303,
0.0242363364,
0.0282192118,
-0.0147918267,
-0.0171569642,
-0.0150530571,
0.0342774577,
0.0184698999,
-0.0639461502,
-0.0022952224,
-0.0546923913,
-0.0100707514,
-0.0354093499,
0.0309913233,
-0.015304503,
-0.0224440936,
-0.0226326436,
0.0002899066,
-0.0088253068,
-0.0194738675,
0.0414751284,
0.0213928241,
0.0101827215,
-0.0123177627,
-0.0359275229,
0.0008843148,
0.0369547158,
0.0672528893,
-0.0023903803,
-0.016574448,
-0.0029850788,
-0.0301824491,
-0.0427392349,
-0.0465173535,
-0.0136623019,
0.0061196117,
0.0087190755,
0.0453356393,
0.0161180627,
-0.0028266013,
-0.0101283574,
0.0042668958,
-0.0180420671,
-0.052217707,
-0.0224470384,
0.0364559554,
-5.914016771e-33,
-0.0188963767,
-0.011758035,
0.0112196859,
0.0122862523,
-0.0086755687,
-0.0078429691,
0.0339386351,
-0.0350636095,
-0.020037977,
-0.0140744708,
0.0408259295,
0.0432465076,
-0.0080650225,
-0.0034415608,
0.0340966955,
0.0085897632,
0.0194287412,
-0.0367311798,
0.0042368034,
-0.0059781498,
0.0297391694,
-0.0098768817,
0.0198077578,
-0.0755676106,
-0.0554449745,
0.0353671983,
0.0027091743,
0.0263770856,
0.0212217737,
0.0309060644,
0.0148484381,
-0.06226632,
-0.0211770441,
-0.0027058709,
-0.016726872,
0.0321832635,
-0.0228641089,
0.0294462703,
-0.0306153987,
0.0380243734,
-0.0476692952,
0.017522838,
0.0072463253,
-0.0009525419,
0.0266091134,
-0.0285764672,
0.0035258632,
-0.0145506058,
0.0310954992,
0.0237276107,
-0.0185369831,
0.0006502249,
-0.03821541,
-0.0304461289,
0.074575752,
-0.0696599334,
0.0147302458,
-0.0119079752,
0.0085583031,
0.0236766152,
-0.0349513665,
0.0102065895,
0.0475925989,
0.0211437326,
0.0389110707,
0.01415148,
0.0805630535,
-0.0775532648,
0.0003402277,
0.0293312352,
-0.0029128441,
0.1082942858,
0.0332215987,
-0.0482378826,
0.0041975146,
-0.0187913869,
-0.0528942719,
0.0066126487,
-0.0665792674,
0.0197566189,
-0.05037532,
0.0153718879,
0.0378903523,
0.0266016591,
0.0379230715,
-0.0379405357,
0.0026900666,
0.0028446841,
-0.0147956237,
0.009464304,
-0.0428835526,
0.048801586,
0.021094203,
-0.0140376277,
0.046379786,
-0.0249355193,
-0.0265418049,
0.0525044538,
0.0461845957,
0.0372054726,
0.0039068805,
-0.0053381012,
-0.0113755586,
-0.0041482546,
0.0244886745,
0.003893991,
-0.0078617409,
0.0599992163,
0.0117928246,
0.0085810814,
-0.0168891028,
0.0045658979,
-0.00188984,
0.0487153307,
0.0049517294,
0.025201356,
0.0034602596,
0.0730267689,
0.0081464257,
-0.006852353,
-0.0210183356,
-0.0078171613,
-0.0234023854,
0.0031600131,
-0.0229603536,
-0.0276146848,
-0.0562587008,
-0.063675195,
0.055610504,
0.0024188212,
-0.015808126,
-0.0085545443,
2.766e-7,
-0.0050654481,
0.0243324768,
0.0324362367,
0.0120438533,
-0.0086150141,
0.0414841399,
0.0177726783,
0.0386014804,
0.0220681839,
-0.0616548546,
0.0197208878,
0.0070899511,
0.0151756564,
-0.0257073604,
-0.03021116,
0.0156434178,
0.0134766158,
-0.0048667202,
-0.0766239166,
-0.0196890812,
-0.0314918682,
0.0319894291,
0.0462344848,
0.0004039641,
0.0306445323,
-0.0371457823,
0.0096806632,
0.0030339914,
-0.0132263023,
-0.0124038719,
-0.020699,
0.0654268637,
0.0014560261,
0.0010581301,
-0.0485924706,
-0.0200396422,
0.0163562205,
0.0184032153,
-0.0413307883,
-0.0143663315,
-0.0217144005,
-0.0036542623,
0.0001995488,
0.0028978172,
0.0361249335,
0.0533024408,
0.0338463485,
-0.0345219821,
-0.0100558875,
0.0239345897,
-0.030951649,
0.0282263178,
-0.0081262989,
0.0504813418,
-0.0033736767,
-0.0069628377,
-0.0411935337,
-0.041548837,
0.0647063255,
-0.0289312601,
0.0136653408,
-0.005630211,
-0.012517605,
0.0176005196,
0.0236613918,
0.0499226898,
-0.101290226,
2.356071108e-34,
-0.0116679193,
0.0477961414,
0.0077597671,
-0.0070786076,
-0.0065581826,
0.0190683268,
-0.0140500935,
-0.0086172977,
-0.0049321493,
0.0432376377,
-0.0153523386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02025v1 | Vicinal Risk Minimization for Few-Shot Cross-lingual Transfer in Abusive Language Detection | 2023-11-03T16:51:07 | 2023-11-03T16:51:07 | Gretel Liz De la Peña Sarracén, Paolo Rosso, Robert Litschko, Goran Glavaš, Simone Paolo Ponzetto | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual transfer learning from high-resource to medium and low-resource
languages has shown encouraging results. However, the scarcity of resources in
target languages remains a challenge. In this work, we resort to data
augmentation and continual pre-training for domain adaptation to improve
cross-lingual abusive language detection. For data augmentation, we analyze two
existing techniques based on vicinal risk minimization and propose MIXAG, a
novel data augmentation method which interpolates pairs of instances based on
the angle of their representations. Our experiments involve seven languages
typologically distinct from English and three different domains. The results
reveal that the data augmentation strategies can enhance few-shot cross-lingual
abusive language detection. Specifically, we observe that consistently in all
target languages, MIXAG improves significantly in multidomain and multilingual
environments. Finally, we show through an error analysis how the domain
adaptation can favour the class of abusive texts (reducing false negatives),
but at the same time, declines the precision of the abusive language detection
model. | [
0.0307120495,
0.0118187843,
-0.0220508575,
0.0471663252,
0.0000425275,
0.0455537587,
0.0349441059,
0.0169401839,
-0.007793278,
-0.0621699952,
-0.0590787306,
-0.0559696555,
-0.0369391516,
0.0073831645,
0.0182714518,
-0.060072083,
0.0487062708,
-0.0176968779,
0.0059362352,
-0.004767274,
0.0433502272,
-0.0066400445,
-0.0107908743,
-0.0036279617,
-0.0302314553,
0.0261933431,
0.0506754369,
0.0011670054,
0.0469768234,
-0.0267371926,
0.0402452983,
0.0210862849,
0.0220275652,
0.0465553626,
0.0000019521,
-0.045345068,
-0.0124771623,
0.0052901949,
0.0120000122,
-0.0237159561,
0.0976000652,
-0.0712680146,
-0.0294493958,
0.0037089153,
-0.0175579302,
-0.0595322438,
0.0810002238,
0.0435840972,
0.0863700062,
0.0643354952,
-0.0216243435,
-0.0098353727,
0.0185046643,
-0.0076707811,
-0.0003023207,
-0.0319670551,
0.0641727,
-0.0077242088,
-0.0604975857,
0.0000070276,
-0.0287020486,
0.0393380746,
0.0079494091,
-0.0088001592,
0.000365379,
-0.039525453,
-0.0200981144,
0.0065008006,
0.0114435488,
0.038536042,
-0.0727100074,
-0.0119532179,
-0.0554160513,
-0.0200762171,
-0.0017046954,
-0.0133868288,
-0.0181275271,
-0.0043927049,
0.0181766935,
0.0155492639,
-0.0010385665,
0.0644279122,
0.0197469741,
0.0478013791,
-0.0060149003,
-0.0368942693,
0.005988671,
-0.0345453694,
0.0203595106,
0.0244622324,
0.0034737845,
0.0113486582,
0.0232681874,
-0.0119277416,
-0.0072315284,
-0.0042169299,
-0.0466144532,
-0.0829176679,
0.0058862716,
-0.0646221563,
0.0470366925,
0.0471686311,
-0.0651768222,
0.0020265714,
-0.0195716657,
0.0126210973,
-0.0180918071,
0.0183436498,
-0.0322107784,
-0.0249297172,
-0.0019363484,
0.0340553895,
-0.0061696982,
-0.0114161819,
-0.0213367324,
0.0698636994,
-0.0498215668,
-0.0075395061,
-0.0426623784,
-0.0659591332,
-0.0274704322,
-0.0236464515,
-0.0482854247,
0.0033782755,
-0.0049375761,
0.025274016,
-0.0022640973,
0.041176185,
-0.0455993451,
-0.0498417914,
-0.0183893926,
0.0389034562,
-0.0261575915,
-0.0761751011,
0.0431225486,
0.1035408229,
-0.0027337417,
-0.0354899988,
-0.0445122086,
-0.0090779569,
-0.0099943196,
-0.0277051777,
0.0156049924,
-0.0504023544,
0.0175480377,
-0.0501512997,
-0.01279971,
-0.0518281087,
-0.0104793655,
-0.0267497431,
-0.0866444409,
0.0635864064,
-0.0194164868,
-0.035388492,
0.0137946391,
0.0147456368,
-0.0370538384,
0.0647308379,
0.012619039,
0.0055425107,
0.0245303269,
-0.0182623956,
-0.0115669603,
0.0712167844,
0.0521695428,
0.0584708005,
-0.0166412722,
-0.0045929691,
-0.0020796973,
-0.0460163578,
0.0331040621,
0.0004161758,
-0.0241803955,
-0.0351455249,
0.0444135107,
-0.0002760519,
-0.013104693,
0.0156767424,
0.0529932231,
-0.0071079861,
-0.0539563261,
-0.0145765403,
-0.061283607,
-0.0126053309,
-0.0212815125,
-0.0497376807,
0.012085679,
0.0777553022,
-0.015196763,
-0.0249651019,
0.021367278,
0.0011193265,
0.0258592702,
-0.0185893215,
0.0598700605,
0.0522627793,
0.0267610289,
0.0185475051,
0.0828006044,
-0.0144115547,
0.0096030757,
-0.0082012238,
-0.0024777502,
0.0600285158,
-0.0102759814,
-0.0122386739,
-0.0119611816,
-0.0789194405,
0.032182768,
0.0182375927,
0.0097453315,
0.0096827429,
0.0614525042,
-0.0154488515,
-0.0335935839,
0.0339867398,
-0.0099367965,
0.0484725386,
0.0029586961,
0.0532872342,
0.0114458855,
-0.0042669415,
-0.0464876331,
0.0102863163,
-0.0223542228,
-0.0502701178,
0.0343571305,
0.0340644829,
0.0376258083,
0.0096998056,
-0.0306749344,
-0.0742725059,
0.0049947402,
-0.0339405686,
-0.0069374712,
0.0173866972,
-0.0349353999,
-0.0432935394,
0.0429311022,
-0.0496303141,
-0.0032148496,
-0.0373619571,
-0.017858766,
-0.0011118896,
0.047760535,
-0.010998629,
-0.0139510622,
-0.0383954011,
-0.0066412915,
-0.0389160626,
0.0772666261,
-0.0006078391,
0.0396063775,
0.0105378479,
-0.0154058021,
0.0149333365,
-0.055711288,
0.0349283367,
0.0245985109,
-0.0492174253,
-0.0155513221,
-0.0385355353,
0.011972934,
0.0292846467,
0.0513373353,
-0.0028292595,
0.0254279878,
-0.0337389596,
-0.0046356344,
-0.0163708813,
0.021260852,
0.0194595587,
0.0260691512,
-0.0149101717,
-0.0053836042,
-0.0076239905,
-0.0560222082,
0.0251083691,
0.0407673009,
0.0006852766,
-0.0285300314,
0.0156111373,
-0.0151806679,
0.0007857312,
0.009827273,
0.0229498204,
-0.0149265872,
-0.049650833,
-0.0325205848,
0.008935268,
0.0066333869,
0.0307669509,
-0.0023128563,
-0.0429537557,
-0.0359173566,
0.0330609903,
-0.0120691154,
0.0396009572,
-0.0155763235,
0.0128775639,
0.0630532429,
-0.0298752878,
-0.0311877504,
0.0009222585,
0.0038625048,
-0.0003043308,
-0.0063878442,
-0.0448268019,
-0.0113795074,
0.0368652977,
-0.0138122123,
-0.0180568565,
-0.0321639143,
0.0003625258,
-0.0296278801,
-0.0573519208,
-0.0170243718,
-0.0366835184,
-0.0162862688,
-0.0059506609,
0.0048322366,
-0.0314674415,
0.0838385969,
0.006119756,
0.0244428683,
-0.0294855833,
-0.0478554443,
0.0213540364,
0.0186987184,
0.0095188869,
0.0545389578,
-0.0063250875,
-0.0181900319,
-0.0137198111,
-0.0064297002,
0.0735955015,
0.0110692345,
-0.0066584847,
-0.0103204045,
-0.0223333575,
-0.0076412018,
-0.0402824469,
-0.0367775597,
-0.052795697,
0.0245335642,
-0.0343179926,
-0.0132747367,
-0.0017513088,
-0.0446104929,
-0.0001203619,
0.0446386486,
-0.0157361943,
-0.0063789356,
0.0022751319,
0.0219239816,
-0.0021541792,
0.0151526192,
-0.0290057473,
0.0042708013,
-0.0114775859,
-0.0064475304,
0.0516890958,
-0.0199537743,
-0.0109968586,
0.0106179547,
0.0247205328,
0.0234688967,
0.0514889061,
-0.0120681617,
-0.0442041531,
0.0407908261,
-0.013534639,
-0.0083675021,
0.0320130289,
-0.0207943488,
-0.0170542877,
-0.0048461119,
-0.0328863896,
0.0023545448,
0.0128857289,
0.0375028811,
-0.0843963623,
-0.0202205554,
-0.0158268437,
0.0011753846,
-0.0623344667,
-0.0274617448,
-0.0129189892,
-0.1054315194,
-0.0087953592,
0.0115183722,
-0.0822770298,
-0.0385539755,
0.010736254,
0.0226391423,
-0.0094026439,
0.0678380132,
-0.0468445383,
0.0013741303,
-0.0268629417,
0.0218053795,
0.0218731742,
-0.0563643463,
-0.0100014769,
-0.0339836776,
0.0328227356,
0.0209515691,
0.0231788941,
-0.0519291125,
0.0016455686,
0.0194872674,
0.0046849195,
-0.020675255,
-0.0183127765,
0.0756601766,
0.0050282246,
-0.035938561,
0.0490709245,
0.0078520523,
0.0170904342,
-0.0025568041,
0.0422005169,
0.099168703,
0.0640474409,
0.0249272808,
-0.0245693065,
-0.0120356828,
0.0456238575,
0.0467953458,
0.0037922224,
-0.0332415402,
0.0253358409,
-0.0423920378,
-0.0488545597,
-0.0390891768,
-0.0285274778,
0.0161224809,
-0.0762785673,
-0.0492404141,
-0.0462647676,
-0.0397327021,
-0.0022404324,
0.0157048181,
0.040338818,
-0.0152706886,
-0.023845084,
-0.0170648675,
-0.0238811132,
-0.0100669246,
-0.0154342176,
0.0710277706,
-0.0009116936,
0.0399708301,
-0.0186256077,
-0.0328970328,
-0.0090514896,
0.0068874629,
-0.0277409721,
-0.0686074123,
0.026831653,
0.0830033123,
0.0025291818,
0.0489630848,
-0.0336065181,
-0.0630987361,
0.0616700202,
0.0769525021,
-0.0261548292,
-0.0179468915,
0.0868679732,
-0.0512898825,
0.0104136281,
0.0194952302,
-0.0199381858,
0.0467763506,
0.072038129,
-0.0392853804,
-0.0515940338,
0.0016282522,
-0.0170885213,
0.0044384608,
0.0453368165,
-0.026921846,
-0.0548036881,
-0.0207842123,
0.0048546032,
-0.0075958306,
-0.0106875636,
-0.0241269022,
0.0338159315,
0.0360305607,
-0.0299056545,
-0.0095140934,
0.0250836313,
-0.0152929854,
-0.0158509202,
-0.0393164791,
0.022143513,
0.0192134362,
0.0449092723,
0.015893653,
0.0634917691,
-0.0032037874,
0.003044226,
0.0545872413,
0.0124371732,
-0.0236573741,
0.0027219164,
0.0185132641,
0.0185547359,
0.0462695174,
-0.0068503469,
0.0121105453,
0.0350809805,
-0.0532490201,
-0.0383465178,
0.0118931429,
-0.0329491794,
0.1069078743,
0.028869791,
-0.0030484195,
-0.0022529268,
-0.0275573581,
-0.0387307592,
-0.0310914479,
0.0041974215,
-0.0029947821,
-0.0078612035,
0.0454658642,
0.0548314974,
-0.0135505432,
0.0366525166,
0.0239183903,
-0.033755403,
-0.0229809806,
0.0015698943,
0.0881844535,
0.0177801121,
-0.0156260934,
0.0281691607,
-0.0303072799,
-0.061282564,
-0.0385763645,
-0.0729758963,
0.0022151002,
0.0254833475,
0.0068004872,
0.0484033637,
0.0055024256,
0.0436574481,
-0.0082828067,
-0.0013912371,
0.0520491153,
-0.0328774378,
0.0235646889,
-5.801035969e-33,
-0.0160485078,
-0.0044523799,
-0.0188167095,
-0.0146043915,
0.0004002294,
-0.050882116,
0.0167167615,
0.0106842518,
-0.0291438252,
0.0427262224,
0.0455461182,
-0.0163299367,
0.0119492887,
0.0163477063,
-0.003594904,
-0.0129225543,
0.032156013,
0.0294918567,
-0.0021559121,
0.0280027036,
0.0612681098,
0.0410415679,
0.0962073803,
-0.1177502424,
0.0372966155,
0.0310394503,
-0.0306704398,
0.0300953649,
0.0166812912,
0.0552112386,
-0.0083995573,
0.0651366711,
0.0117815947,
-0.0341074653,
-0.0178717971,
-0.0230009332,
-0.045557797,
-0.0297187921,
0.0189396329,
0.0338769555,
0.0385100432,
-0.0351753235,
0.0282092839,
-0.0101334313,
-0.0037258228,
-0.0470833182,
0.0274769887,
-0.066540435,
0.0058386335,
-0.0438441969,
-0.090758279,
0.0268682856,
-0.0124320854,
-0.0197785944,
0.0351555236,
0.0456934161,
0.0314767621,
-0.0138821946,
-0.0717255399,
0.0050638216,
-0.0260493122,
-0.0014126871,
0.0147682456,
-0.0185913276,
-0.0229621734,
0.0545910858,
0.0160703361,
-0.0199242439,
0.0516179129,
0.0149694094,
0.0188779403,
0.023296373,
0.0017874636,
0.1009869725,
0.0349799991,
-0.0515339263,
-0.0799244493,
0.0055121784,
0.0204232298,
0.0063582365,
-0.0080118245,
-0.0174081884,
-0.0503595583,
-0.0346101932,
0.0003876256,
-0.0476895086,
-0.0122459289,
-0.0677222908,
0.0202002432,
-0.0100897579,
-0.0227818955,
0.0247349497,
0.0472386181,
-0.0584222898,
-0.0200719051,
0.0022188833,
-0.0507973246,
-0.0259735342,
0.0264770258,
0.0474510677,
-0.0219768248,
-0.0335234143,
0.0131073268,
-0.0364643261,
0.0155633483,
-0.0202721842,
0.1579417288,
0.0137439873,
-0.081863232,
0.0146019207,
-0.0116571449,
0.0600280352,
0.0058972598,
0.089599207,
-0.0102791479,
0.0382259078,
-0.0228329934,
0.0321328267,
0.0714817867,
-0.0191992801,
-0.0267192572,
-0.0057467129,
-0.0326340795,
0.00756292,
-0.0143483197,
-0.001884219,
-0.0053440444,
0.006192165,
0.0358684137,
-0.0936327428,
-0.010583966,
-0.03204339,
2.79e-7,
0.0165484659,
0.033678595,
-0.0317439772,
-0.0247898065,
0.0083850333,
0.0624187812,
0.008544717,
0.0479406118,
0.0088974489,
0.0159593485,
-0.0291932411,
0.0160161871,
0.0254052971,
0.0643063262,
-0.0174793638,
0.0034788754,
-0.0510425456,
-0.0008806034,
-0.0212502796,
-0.0102437362,
0.0368465558,
0.0887214616,
0.0517144538,
-0.0658446699,
0.0132110827,
-0.0421858132,
0.033463046,
-0.0244851895,
-0.0377414078,
-0.0182408188,
0.0019295454,
0.0440807939,
0.0111344391,
0.0195642989,
-0.0230429675,
0.0378356315,
0.000151368,
-0.008175537,
0.0007743947,
0.0422586165,
-0.0132280141,
-0.0079948604,
-0.0009839279,
-0.0328384042,
0.0579464659,
-0.0069175847,
-0.0072898902,
-0.0127997454,
-0.0220557563,
0.022948591,
0.0220146645,
-0.0504187271,
-0.0128815742,
0.0036047967,
0.0774967372,
0.0264016446,
-0.0484409146,
-0.0426808111,
0.0153782358,
0.02163551,
0.0184948836,
-0.0200457461,
0.0048620841,
0.012248503,
0.0192955658,
0.0031029377,
0.045579426,
2.029571812e-34,
0.0098965354,
-0.0337964259,
0.0500177257,
-0.0449033156,
-0.0000859104,
0.0231166668,
0.0000988079,
-0.0066283019,
0.0219830871,
0.0211949237,
-0.0038244601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01981v1 | ProSG: Using Prompt Synthetic Gradients to Alleviate Prompt Forgetting of RNN-like Language Models | 2023-11-03T15:34:02 | 2023-11-03T15:34:02 | Haotian Luo, Kunming Wu, Cheng Dai, Sixian Ding, Xinhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | RNN-like language models are getting renewed attention from NLP researchers
in recent years and several models have made significant progress, which
demonstrates performance comparable to traditional transformers. However, due
to the recurrent nature of RNNs, this kind of language model can only store
information in a set of fixed-length state vectors. As a consequence, they
still suffer from forgetfulness though after a lot of improvements and
optimizations, when given complex instructions or prompts. As the prompted
generation is the main and most concerned function of LMs, solving the problem
of forgetting in the process of generation is no wonder of vital importance. In
this paper, focusing on easing the prompt forgetting during generation, we
proposed an architecture to teach the model memorizing prompt during generation
by synthetic gradient. To force the model to memorize the prompt, we derive the
states that encode the prompt, then transform it into model parameter
modification using low-rank gradient approximation, which hard-codes the prompt
into model parameters temporarily. We construct a dataset for experiments, and
the results have demonstrated the effectiveness of our method in solving the
problem of forgetfulness in the process of prompted generation. We will release
all the code upon acceptance. | [
0.021966273,
0.0375276618,
-0.0102972155,
0.0136567093,
-0.0382532924,
-0.0165250804,
0.0148882335,
-0.0161179006,
0.0053307405,
-0.0305491947,
-0.0093426667,
-0.063405931,
0.0099726263,
-0.001692074,
0.0202339552,
-0.0505395979,
0.0635765344,
-0.0397027619,
-0.0030811038,
-0.0260538291,
-0.0041352902,
-0.007673271,
-0.0063732527,
0.0218388774,
0.0061721755,
-0.0396584757,
-0.039819207,
0.0244667344,
-0.0120095992,
-0.0348084122,
0.0425943173,
0.0488048084,
-0.014963449,
0.0277516153,
0.0000019609,
-0.0353874154,
-0.0136919906,
-0.0425920598,
-0.0399280973,
0.0023930208,
0.0048865234,
0.0287604276,
-0.0273825005,
0.0432743728,
-0.0145429922,
-0.0060115773,
0.0379434302,
0.0313316099,
0.0686057881,
0.0804636255,
0.0269167311,
-0.0029067977,
0.0213050935,
-0.053217195,
0.0392115898,
-0.0268202201,
0.0286898818,
-0.0743017122,
-0.0177539866,
0.0050384752,
-0.0309989154,
0.0497868955,
0.0304378849,
0.0049357051,
0.0057081864,
0.0534108877,
0.0463408679,
-0.0200899076,
-0.0528591312,
0.0562699661,
-0.0354020223,
-0.0244887471,
0.0482167043,
-0.0059586288,
0.0071192114,
-0.020696627,
-0.0328856893,
0.0405861177,
0.0042457324,
0.0104642529,
0.006921778,
-0.0094315642,
0.0233879425,
-0.0014281215,
0.0108750286,
0.0242051538,
0.0433684401,
-0.0462118834,
-0.0447586402,
-0.0514700226,
0.0129262125,
-0.0610761307,
0.0128186792,
0.0804026201,
-0.0620285869,
0.0341623239,
-0.0212708618,
-0.0328005217,
0.025571011,
-0.0072000707,
0.0640829653,
0.0418793075,
-0.0274182577,
0.0238134619,
-0.0694429204,
0.0853236616,
-0.0008789666,
0.0008174049,
-0.0098991152,
0.0342527628,
-0.0176577661,
-0.024608383,
-0.0559439622,
0.0218858831,
-0.0221830998,
-0.0006223442,
-0.0257816352,
0.0339134298,
-0.0047271904,
0.0258015823,
0.0240606833,
0.0275461432,
-0.0576752424,
-0.0049694953,
-0.0436739214,
0.0161227454,
-0.0365305729,
-0.0213754214,
0.0524866059,
-0.0680579543,
-0.022970017,
-0.0117597431,
0.0280582439,
-0.003696633,
-0.0125528341,
0.0521308146,
-0.0031926848,
-0.0277893543,
-0.0583633035,
-0.0271523148,
-0.0009604436,
-0.0785508454,
0.024244586,
-0.0522828735,
0.0228429828,
-0.0321983993,
-0.0118601602,
-0.056425795,
0.0149199199,
0.0536991507,
0.0143193277,
0.0301160235,
-0.0157169122,
-0.006527293,
0.0338357724,
-0.0000656684,
0.0122135347,
0.0320313759,
0.0162388925,
0.0513338447,
0.0109023564,
-0.0069881757,
0.0318174586,
0.0175498519,
0.0369533524,
-0.0384333283,
-0.0063201473,
-0.0282793194,
0.0418192297,
0.0544150062,
0.0345871672,
0.0855436474,
0.0052504977,
-0.0037260868,
0.0590916723,
0.0182160437,
0.0151430769,
0.0327151679,
0.0649252236,
-0.0143975783,
-0.0140105691,
0.0185062885,
-0.0345507599,
0.0390181728,
-0.0174933877,
0.0406203344,
0.02060063,
0.0414154828,
-0.0694953054,
-0.0353273377,
0.0120646423,
-0.0186034553,
-0.0206936635,
0.0203698706,
0.0330756009,
0.0434559621,
-0.1003972962,
0.0340739116,
-0.0033550046,
-0.0510815121,
0.0432184637,
-0.0332895555,
0.0632968992,
0.0696819201,
0.0236847829,
-0.0192334913,
-0.002423977,
-0.0253899153,
-0.0098773846,
0.0116328513,
0.0457950048,
-0.0073047783,
-0.0065823747,
-0.075997591,
-0.0047169272,
0.0298207924,
0.0113032497,
0.0513912849,
0.0007922364,
0.0028007203,
0.0249571633,
0.0305035021,
-0.0315354168,
0.0476822108,
-0.0709679574,
-0.0494809225,
0.0166934393,
-0.0068092956,
0.0041785068,
0.0209014025,
0.0356699824,
0.016675856,
0.0495845079,
-0.0418860205,
-0.006950154,
-0.0233948156,
-0.1043849736,
-0.0599847548,
0.0041248333,
0.0200357512,
-0.0004683951,
0.0415472277,
-0.0266588684,
-0.0785446465,
0.0068787076,
-0.0256506857,
0.03529853,
-0.0627211109,
0.0082244221,
0.0270821247,
0.0093928194,
-0.0320542157,
0.0543102734,
-0.0232844111,
0.0443736017,
0.0732004791,
0.0422083102,
-0.0174840018,
-0.0980849713,
-0.0384217687,
0.0145921148,
-0.0235969573,
0.0314848498,
0.0104437657,
0.0200245641,
-0.0545942001,
-0.0228436347,
-0.0452407375,
0.0090341605,
-0.0387515984,
-0.0106125148,
0.0158968884,
0.0214183461,
-0.0161922015,
-0.0189292207,
-0.0580482259,
-0.0190550797,
-0.0086718109,
0.0145662148,
0.0359908789,
0.0201676674,
-0.034127634,
-0.0220829062,
-0.0040848376,
0.0113863153,
0.034814693,
-0.0323641747,
0.0211872887,
-0.0676842332,
0.0293215625,
-0.0076464112,
0.0344404168,
-0.0144502576,
-0.0106491046,
-0.0041033169,
-0.0346929505,
0.128104642,
0.0567385405,
0.020689562,
0.03285449,
0.0498719737,
-0.0086955251,
-0.0565186441,
0.0292435586,
-0.0636850297,
-0.0368151441,
0.0437266231,
-0.0062758727,
0.0282020736,
0.0518650673,
0.0294163618,
0.0011067523,
-0.0397489443,
0.0027310941,
-0.0049918704,
0.0027449648,
-0.044315204,
0.0135101499,
-0.0718899146,
0.0336142257,
-0.0027416574,
-0.0423933007,
0.0546713434,
-0.0402657539,
-0.0111833308,
-0.0147096328,
0.0094017033,
-0.0094616776,
0.0066599213,
-0.0088253804,
0.0095347697,
0.0267634019,
-0.0408353321,
-0.0335123837,
-0.0124852573,
-0.0039524636,
-0.0351295769,
-0.0000777701,
0.0001287119,
-0.0029239755,
-0.0071313847,
-0.0116613302,
-0.0872805789,
-0.0142418193,
-0.0029908407,
0.0092019262,
-0.005716667,
0.0001719616,
0.0539482161,
-0.0110471891,
0.0297969487,
0.0651823729,
-0.0326089747,
-0.0014558828,
-0.0370141491,
0.0322717428,
0.0424610376,
0.0078468081,
0.0012737802,
-0.0282942448,
0.0492674783,
0.0241590459,
0.0428336412,
0.0299982205,
-0.0447007418,
0.0147023145,
0.0205204058,
-0.0231033713,
0.0278036594,
0.0612153932,
0.0364241488,
-0.0566318743,
-0.0423478521,
0.0906573012,
0.0200830586,
-0.0547805093,
-0.0031049643,
-0.0102589624,
0.06087045,
0.021364307,
0.0141285313,
-0.0318851098,
-0.0024176715,
0.034133058,
0.0386985056,
-0.009086784,
-0.0108047985,
-0.0245230496,
-0.0861274824,
0.012985169,
-0.0072976095,
-0.0260210037,
-0.0364467464,
-0.0227103923,
-0.0178195797,
0.0446945503,
0.0496309511,
0.0595284626,
-0.011923926,
-0.0068733562,
0.0392884314,
-0.0333796591,
-0.0599940307,
-0.0133913429,
-0.0242527835,
0.0725329891,
0.0779507831,
0.0131942071,
0.0149418982,
-0.0750328824,
0.0464147031,
-0.024818942,
0.0141835855,
-0.0046143602,
-0.0125730839,
-0.0021508271,
-0.0314794481,
-0.0065756342,
0.0467734151,
-0.0498367213,
-0.0074330582,
0.0057310532,
0.0737688094,
-0.0227768701,
-0.0107504232,
-0.0001652138,
-0.0088708168,
0.0319053084,
0.0720426291,
0.0433725081,
-0.0516118817,
-0.0180542674,
-0.0299543887,
0.0129973572,
-0.0734506026,
-0.0228064265,
-0.0016862663,
-0.0129968897,
-0.0157307163,
-0.0849990174,
-0.0352430381,
0.0174450874,
0.0381542519,
0.0029961022,
-0.0015988193,
0.0126818465,
0.0061674844,
-0.0203812588,
0.008879642,
-0.037333712,
-0.0017504749,
-0.0622429661,
-0.0260808468,
0.02582689,
-0.0476186275,
0.0045622559,
-0.0007776898,
-0.0684101358,
-0.056153331,
0.0300763305,
0.0578745194,
0.0203609057,
0.0350475051,
-0.0056016855,
-0.0284320172,
0.0447248593,
0.0307999831,
-0.0014715836,
0.0014460102,
0.0301801972,
0.0343926959,
-0.0228396002,
0.020379331,
-0.0429004319,
0.0001992032,
0.0423843935,
0.0575914718,
0.0186241977,
0.0019300708,
0.0260958448,
-0.0107113188,
0.0386925824,
-0.0158049967,
-0.0382333882,
-0.0475479253,
0.0054876753,
0.0024962714,
0.0089211995,
-0.0211620815,
0.0443401076,
0.000850587,
-0.0014277403,
0.0083285151,
-0.0460813642,
0.0315550305,
0.0040765684,
-0.0136260781,
-0.0262622163,
0.0031039466,
0.0478009582,
0.0260900017,
0.0049068206,
-0.043746572,
0.0250479933,
-0.0305547193,
0.0049834135,
-0.0032600507,
0.0598037951,
0.0504797101,
0.0009238993,
-0.0504939668,
0.0103146629,
-0.0473696999,
-0.0681805313,
-0.017999718,
0.0252750684,
0.0860703066,
0.0210301504,
-0.033375416,
-0.0146289868,
0.0140700191,
-0.0308881998,
0.0352669023,
0.0441737883,
-0.0567553639,
0.0353686288,
0.0242842119,
-0.0044179829,
0.006583387,
0.0669127852,
-0.005448861,
0.0336196758,
-0.0045770481,
0.0715753809,
-0.0448526479,
0.0048825056,
0.0000140315,
0.0098555451,
-0.0304300562,
-0.0221798941,
-0.0269806031,
-0.0531469546,
0.0259913206,
0.0385671519,
0.011020516,
-0.0148454392,
0.0610409863,
0.0171583258,
-0.0194312874,
0.0169831384,
-0.044405967,
0.02568358,
0.0048355642,
-0.0460800752,
-0.0527624711,
-6.350049136e-33,
-0.0127540762,
-0.0134845218,
0.0180850644,
0.004876364,
-0.025928339,
-0.0061993292,
-0.0666754097,
-0.0129052578,
0.0059651942,
-0.034717422,
-0.0678103939,
-0.0263240449,
0.0125944158,
0.0402940437,
0.0085136099,
-0.0425805785,
0.0622470006,
-0.0198434666,
-0.0227360278,
0.0533396266,
0.0448127277,
0.0640728176,
0.0147760455,
0.0285297148,
0.0389540568,
-0.0402056873,
-0.0317690261,
0.0171664897,
-0.0325204283,
0.0325462259,
-0.0573169254,
0.0408642404,
0.0155680133,
-0.0581096262,
-0.060252998,
0.0688374937,
-0.0690342337,
-0.0352905504,
0.0007395924,
-0.0032783842,
-0.0856127143,
-0.0448192358,
0.0202814415,
-0.0260939114,
-0.0142563162,
0.0366412066,
0.0236930698,
-0.0129121142,
-0.0631464571,
-0.0539093725,
-0.0188562833,
-0.0251120701,
0.0245593488,
-0.0536347143,
-0.0126587329,
0.019128304,
-0.0135148559,
-0.0080947122,
-0.0561324358,
-0.0003177506,
-0.0066310968,
0.0608071946,
0.0141562922,
0.0533358417,
-0.0087070055,
0.0432698131,
0.0438649654,
0.0130466959,
0.0009473703,
0.0405189395,
0.0278234798,
-0.0224636849,
0.046424251,
0.0035559165,
0.04709002,
-0.0443037786,
-0.0027322145,
0.001634752,
0.0369760804,
0.0175261609,
0.060026966,
-0.0028076658,
0.0068931198,
-0.0201938841,
-0.0412658453,
-0.0240296647,
-0.0358862728,
0.0038003873,
0.0426228158,
0.0511309206,
-0.0035283435,
-0.0377223901,
0.0299449433,
-0.0053793527,
0.0139836632,
0.0095416112,
0.0252068583,
0.0052336683,
-0.0061128847,
0.0052449941,
-0.0389944613,
-0.0216667037,
0.0161313489,
-0.0010828496,
-0.0109391073,
0.0297653582,
0.007457104,
0.0406683944,
-0.0575930849,
0.005587141,
-0.0440430529,
0.0658471808,
0.0034175704,
0.0117647266,
0.0171294771,
-0.009841918,
-0.0110778771,
0.0688132569,
-0.0221454557,
-0.0208856296,
-0.0453299992,
0.0358801559,
0.0009539906,
0.0530524664,
-0.0352003835,
-0.0064026229,
-0.031794779,
0.0602792986,
0.0291109663,
-0.0235537589,
0.0138129592,
0.0108606778,
2.645e-7,
-0.0377381779,
-0.0018346668,
0.0518078171,
0.0067441124,
0.0182717051,
0.0082684718,
-0.0194498412,
0.0361362584,
0.015411146,
-0.0125755267,
0.0003965684,
-0.0110446839,
0.0272700116,
-0.0417563617,
-0.1451301724,
-0.0084100123,
-0.0761689171,
0.0138667235,
-0.0411997437,
-0.0006634165,
0.0311085116,
0.0717512295,
0.0080487663,
0.0056937407,
0.009352644,
0.0309019908,
0.0381306037,
-0.0228028558,
0.0116424467,
-0.0053429347,
0.0809598416,
0.013842769,
-0.0141869299,
-0.0354097933,
-0.013072391,
-0.0078254901,
-0.0288040079,
0.0630445778,
0.0408753306,
-0.072106503,
0.0144792357,
0.0307705943,
-0.0198820513,
-0.0179361012,
0.0267443974,
-0.0205408782,
0.0391499028,
-0.0219786279,
-0.0046732994,
0.0037765799,
0.0019976664,
-0.0162186734,
-0.0535239764,
0.0070269192,
0.0011264293,
0.0182532184,
0.0126468223,
-0.0961991623,
-0.0012276126,
-0.0189334471,
-0.0662160143,
-0.0335919335,
-0.0356546268,
0.0072944658,
0.0282669123,
-0.0882119462,
-0.0158110503,
2.286786965e-34,
0.0339682661,
-0.0321128629,
0.0208071768,
0.0587384775,
-0.0067326189,
-0.0145741496,
0.0189262778,
0.028297469,
0.0464377776,
-0.0688689873,
-0.0705944747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01967v1 | The language of prompting: What linguistic properties make a prompt successful? | 2023-11-03T15:03:36 | 2023-11-03T15:03:36 | Alina Leidinger, Robert van Rooij, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The latest generation of LLMs can be prompted to achieve impressive zero-shot
or few-shot performance in many NLP tasks. However, since performance is highly
sensitive to the choice of prompts, considerable effort has been devoted to
crowd-sourcing prompts or designing methods for prompt optimisation. Yet, we
still lack a systematic understanding of how linguistic properties of prompts
correlate with task performance. In this work, we investigate how LLMs of
different sizes, pre-trained and instruction-tuned, perform on prompts that are
semantically equivalent, but vary in linguistic structure. We investigate both
grammatical properties such as mood, tense, aspect and modality, as well as
lexico-semantic variation through the use of synonyms. Our findings contradict
the common assumption that LLMs achieve optimal performance on lower perplexity
prompts that reflect language use in pretraining or instruction-tuning data.
Prompts transfer poorly between datasets or models, and performance cannot
generally be explained by perplexity, word frequency, ambiguity or prompt
length. Based on our results, we put forward a proposal for a more robust and
comprehensive evaluation standard for prompting research. | [
0.0323795415,
0.0044708857,
-0.0105894506,
0.040163137,
-0.0620903149,
0.0126768984,
0.0227886811,
0.0243412443,
-0.0287600383,
-0.0545172729,
-0.0483914092,
-0.0143493628,
-0.0169433039,
-0.0265568309,
0.0017838139,
-0.0352588296,
0.0829677507,
-0.0080866981,
-0.0185694899,
-0.0018000549,
-0.0064993883,
-0.0043753027,
-0.0301134158,
0.0311490726,
-0.02972156,
-0.0029706007,
-0.0220748074,
0.043293763,
-0.0024692472,
-0.0686551407,
0.0067856931,
0.0731925815,
-0.0229656696,
0.0234982166,
0.0000017607,
-0.0885075852,
0.0276400018,
-0.0336306915,
-0.0743010119,
0.0033583371,
0.0417467766,
-0.0185153689,
-0.0021471693,
-0.0099546025,
-0.0278097671,
-0.0167962108,
0.0191530362,
0.0425117612,
0.0315274559,
0.094011724,
0.0133614149,
0.020229511,
-0.0153862536,
-0.0301634166,
0.041903086,
-0.0358475484,
-0.0080046607,
-0.073802866,
0.0298012719,
0.0547560528,
-0.0206570942,
0.039663095,
0.0104352012,
0.0086795222,
-0.0051739616,
0.0144946277,
-0.0056993603,
-0.0342457071,
-0.0671573207,
0.0643324405,
0.0370099433,
0.0339788534,
-0.025903957,
-0.0374664441,
0.0104251849,
0.0159876887,
-0.028423192,
0.0410934761,
0.0242978241,
0.0192067977,
0.0174950138,
0.0398228094,
0.0010319515,
0.0190481395,
0.0359038673,
0.0667333454,
0.0176210497,
-0.0281749163,
0.0035835095,
0.0396002866,
0.020251561,
-0.0916317254,
-0.0360547863,
0.0078022373,
-0.0796735734,
0.0076622069,
-0.0465906076,
-0.0151804592,
0.05168451,
0.0145237651,
0.061539162,
0.0333744437,
-0.0504770316,
0.0450726822,
-0.022139594,
0.0373125449,
0.0120242732,
0.0333812982,
-0.0369886868,
0.0166407712,
-0.0521468148,
0.015032649,
-0.0278067123,
0.0227452796,
-0.0227700304,
-0.0187746529,
-0.0476413146,
0.0222541988,
0.0102340141,
0.0214911178,
0.0141067347,
0.0019131098,
-0.0256136172,
0.0065641827,
-0.0453855209,
0.0108495662,
-0.0731847286,
0.0379737988,
0.0483957119,
-0.0903190598,
-0.0378985032,
0.0199920963,
0.0130900927,
-0.0366543196,
0.0048198127,
0.0439507775,
0.0102272388,
-0.0696089566,
-0.0440322086,
-0.0304155946,
-0.0142017566,
-0.0494291894,
-0.0146572357,
-0.0281170402,
0.0509381406,
-0.0037791636,
0.0097598052,
0.017165035,
-0.0019634899,
0.0321703814,
-0.0073393472,
0.0974059999,
-0.0236795526,
0.0120609272,
-0.0319758728,
0.0003349408,
-0.041004058,
0.0557563975,
-0.0190949626,
0.0167097952,
0.074643001,
-0.0023222286,
0.0009561544,
0.0209412947,
-0.0036544092,
0.0075561185,
0.0148254875,
-0.0019643591,
0.0116044423,
0.0391113013,
0.0318809785,
0.0522748567,
-0.0200519338,
-0.0119734276,
0.0480299518,
0.066512838,
-0.0181205161,
-0.0452783443,
0.0739210621,
0.0199412704,
0.002111021,
0.0325120166,
-0.0733791739,
0.0216231029,
-0.0524922684,
-0.0070413039,
0.0191549119,
0.007581701,
-0.0477658212,
-0.0197281651,
-0.0492353104,
-0.0148485564,
-0.0156390592,
-0.010394969,
-0.0073652947,
0.0351356342,
-0.0395435281,
0.0410604775,
0.0149504011,
-0.039356675,
-0.0095842192,
-0.0357412845,
0.0230943616,
0.0642589629,
0.0352590308,
0.0152089177,
-0.0448151641,
-0.012180049,
0.0378121175,
0.0627044067,
0.0284602363,
0.002119361,
0.024285499,
-0.027342055,
-0.0181548912,
-0.0347264335,
0.0191284623,
-0.0174054801,
0.0379629657,
0.0012019981,
0.0058782827,
-0.0130167827,
0.0072012013,
0.0571819358,
-0.0217012204,
-0.0414706506,
0.0230728257,
0.0138398781,
0.0040719891,
0.0181615297,
0.0055447598,
0.0160290524,
0.012334045,
-0.0246664677,
0.007589262,
0.0023944189,
-0.0668441504,
-0.0763797238,
0.0161890388,
0.0028452722,
-0.0287695583,
0.0007661206,
-0.0506433174,
-0.0273920409,
-0.0269735493,
-0.0171677023,
0.0116899749,
-0.0445327461,
0.0319851674,
0.0412958711,
0.0137915043,
-0.0473680608,
0.0437009893,
0.0101436116,
0.0460093357,
0.0579870604,
0.0327002853,
0.0223511737,
-0.0407456532,
-0.0309942272,
-0.003672027,
-0.0019974613,
-0.0337500945,
0.0148029448,
0.024889376,
-0.0822589695,
-0.027394101,
-0.083094649,
0.011014415,
-0.0173365045,
0.0175836552,
0.0207304731,
0.0155300507,
-0.0304399189,
-0.0222516377,
-0.0282783378,
0.0211608447,
0.0169792753,
0.0600749664,
0.0840179175,
0.0034381275,
0.000161036,
-0.0352836065,
-0.0072104488,
0.0076638483,
0.0151581289,
0.0067117582,
-0.0330958441,
-0.0436569788,
0.0765974075,
-0.0125270467,
-0.0266858786,
-0.0006244171,
-0.0316092521,
0.0271315537,
0.0000274655,
0.0488732047,
0.0496434756,
-0.0034506114,
0.023290107,
0.0065502645,
-0.0119656846,
-0.0621706434,
0.0033065353,
-0.0385033898,
-0.0591132455,
-0.0010248612,
-0.0193452369,
0.036618378,
0.0512792617,
0.0072756894,
-0.0153010748,
-0.0456687585,
0.0034355198,
-0.0200202409,
-0.019052688,
-0.0449200422,
0.0258622151,
-0.0343292616,
0.0536413528,
-0.020587841,
-0.0607150905,
0.0715799257,
-0.0176431257,
-0.025936272,
-0.0137309153,
-0.0089970278,
-0.0441444553,
0.0483387075,
-0.0286659766,
-0.0123447757,
0.0075622406,
-0.0380930752,
-0.0542404316,
-0.0142441047,
0.0089375935,
-0.0099757444,
0.0181619301,
-0.0188220274,
0.0162620936,
-0.0118761016,
-0.0514050983,
-0.0456841961,
-0.0859223455,
-0.0232717488,
0.0035571209,
0.0007840733,
0.0114298984,
0.029344026,
-0.0459187962,
0.0080551431,
0.0017164669,
-0.0027162055,
-0.0172404088,
-0.047672715,
0.0406610928,
0.027941484,
0.0427598134,
0.0135030812,
-0.0120425159,
0.0460866615,
0.0233655795,
0.0102395276,
0.0169261377,
-0.0106270276,
0.0397067517,
0.0381527394,
-0.0376939811,
-0.0234565903,
0.0355972722,
0.0869130194,
-0.0342377499,
0.0035692088,
0.121991083,
0.0351160876,
-0.0449998043,
0.0127705932,
-0.0004060125,
-0.0001837753,
0.0159439575,
0.0125917997,
-0.0990658253,
-0.0569253489,
0.019932691,
0.0097368713,
-0.0088660941,
-0.0150737101,
-0.0337901339,
-0.1439465135,
0.0270247925,
-0.037417382,
0.026343612,
0.0363225006,
-0.0216824505,
0.0152946264,
0.0055543496,
0.0523489974,
-0.0099595133,
-0.0281238835,
0.003129995,
0.0153332958,
0.0315969251,
-0.0647837147,
0.0125059495,
-0.0508994311,
0.0956660435,
0.0647449791,
-0.0144990664,
-0.0062557939,
-0.0738561451,
0.0399777889,
-0.0013734497,
0.0197398961,
-0.0278358776,
0.0456627235,
-0.0165920034,
-0.016906416,
-0.0215267353,
0.0138540147,
-0.015407199,
-0.0295997318,
-0.0082445899,
0.0455888435,
-0.0272904485,
-0.0224334784,
-0.020343408,
0.0261187125,
0.0213560089,
0.1200188845,
0.0427661836,
-0.0382572077,
0.0086410213,
0.0018421542,
-0.0010354379,
-0.0302726049,
-0.0035091599,
0.0348713659,
-0.0314955674,
-0.0057952162,
-0.0635628849,
-0.0771175846,
0.0304468423,
0.0143584972,
0.004515911,
0.004525498,
-0.0510291457,
-0.004436404,
-0.0079838522,
0.0625803992,
0.0040768455,
0.0115261069,
-0.0965753347,
-0.0158082545,
0.0604772717,
0.0106398752,
0.0014177777,
-0.0254358128,
-0.0939991623,
-0.0422835387,
-0.0015191982,
0.0446280688,
0.0167663675,
0.0158596691,
0.0009042801,
-0.0337845571,
0.0085483305,
0.0674380809,
-0.0022041656,
0.0428711101,
0.0122771729,
0.0578185096,
-0.0013076243,
0.042846933,
-0.0229497459,
0.0147158056,
0.0431518443,
0.0520948954,
-0.0004150249,
-0.0747797117,
0.028863892,
0.0615405887,
0.0881606489,
-0.0465753749,
-0.0124603473,
-0.0189991724,
-0.0096588098,
-0.0191503577,
-0.022614697,
-0.0455418825,
-0.017676007,
-0.0020832713,
-0.0029936677,
-0.0364259332,
0.0255727898,
-0.0552856363,
0.0627192706,
-0.0209430587,
-0.0002836729,
0.0149685405,
-0.0384364948,
0.0022749023,
0.0349911451,
-0.0227912068,
0.0486175008,
-0.0001866458,
0.0242831223,
-0.02056765,
0.0574738048,
0.0326525681,
0.0127335377,
-0.0096225655,
0.0638835579,
-0.0297426656,
-0.0186115429,
0.0365840644,
0.05220953,
0.0334636196,
-0.0307474174,
0.0103530912,
-0.0152892228,
0.0090524983,
-0.0018259903,
0.02102644,
0.0232404973,
-0.0109233186,
0.0663871914,
0.0022522977,
-0.0211864021,
0.0142437452,
0.0546944439,
-0.0894076899,
0.0481453352,
0.0095400168,
0.0396449529,
-0.0230246335,
0.0194865745,
0.0314198323,
-0.0018585376,
0.00198341,
0.0343817547,
-0.0743356347,
-0.0302263387,
0.0309992898,
-0.0017368391,
-0.0147764441,
-0.0021985506,
0.047672078,
0.043570891,
0.0035131464,
-0.01500569,
-0.0234180223,
-0.0212935843,
-0.0061944486,
-0.0411862358,
-0.0300767478,
-6.272099901e-33,
-0.0444577113,
-0.0082364818,
0.0047083339,
-0.0205744151,
-0.0118158264,
0.0311909541,
-0.0162529834,
0.0183858983,
-0.0121180471,
0.0109887403,
-0.066017516,
-0.0055842237,
0.0251900777,
0.016338693,
0.0291903745,
-0.0570532084,
0.0273553692,
-0.0283475202,
-0.0346164554,
-0.0337082855,
0.0050449544,
0.0095209172,
0.0348417088,
-0.0012949698,
0.067839779,
0.018458901,
-0.0280747488,
0.0183187518,
0.0161759555,
0.0207270253,
-0.0224177707,
0.0357861705,
0.0318778157,
-0.034656629,
-0.0278156884,
0.0317156613,
-0.042765975,
-0.0891119242,
0.0531355403,
0.0015975214,
-0.0781794116,
-0.0395406932,
0.0047657886,
-0.0518203564,
-0.0628243908,
0.0297425352,
0.0051321983,
0.0192127544,
0.0040774574,
-0.0155631471,
-0.0360088609,
-0.0022752821,
0.0247065723,
-0.0475794338,
0.023116583,
0.0328689963,
-0.0221587047,
0.0408223383,
-0.0245644264,
0.0251280721,
0.0026023758,
0.0465179384,
0.0309115965,
0.0085116196,
-0.0224820003,
0.0725738481,
0.0323149674,
0.009794699,
-0.0102208797,
0.0354239792,
0.008206089,
0.0462240204,
0.0481027775,
0.0680009648,
0.0323345698,
0.028986752,
-0.0113039799,
0.0333497636,
0.0447716601,
-0.0015098887,
-0.0228225626,
-0.0126062622,
-0.0316036753,
-0.0231245905,
-0.0335794091,
-0.0096145663,
-0.0314869992,
-0.0314406902,
0.0532026179,
0.0077575711,
-0.000969425,
-0.0310354121,
0.0228845775,
-0.0119625703,
-0.014859248,
-0.0304823052,
0.0021346202,
0.0255948287,
0.0024225714,
0.0062626805,
-0.0471429229,
-0.0080598099,
0.0265359618,
0.0075501176,
0.0349271484,
0.0024906797,
0.0249551572,
0.0151153328,
-0.0695062727,
0.0085381791,
-0.0106059611,
0.0379385017,
-0.0273349024,
-0.0301436484,
0.022844797,
0.0217632521,
-0.0273985248,
0.0521384068,
0.0219093245,
-0.0275801402,
-0.0049961153,
-0.0119328732,
0.0068248799,
0.0342788175,
-0.0214010943,
0.0076641175,
-0.0218022242,
0.0211043954,
0.0043754866,
-0.0060471925,
-0.0118372245,
0.0048046224,
2.598e-7,
0.0365140922,
0.0514366776,
0.0315654501,
0.0589103103,
-0.0151381437,
0.0210918896,
-0.032725431,
0.0101246061,
-0.0133509589,
-0.0312528498,
-0.0001338436,
0.0042213793,
0.0536277555,
0.0057929968,
-0.1057780981,
0.0046553086,
-0.0361174904,
0.0266396701,
-0.0509502292,
0.0079208314,
0.0963734686,
0.0658278838,
0.0089232083,
-0.0058420086,
-0.012618212,
-0.037432503,
0.0298356712,
-0.0639730915,
-0.0226465967,
0.0036406592,
0.0389463976,
-0.0267334208,
0.0299946088,
0.0119017642,
-0.0033483121,
-0.0067652059,
-0.0085721808,
0.0533538423,
0.0180818997,
-0.0689843372,
-0.0262642689,
-0.0180779323,
-0.0097675761,
-0.0038966006,
0.0782922134,
-0.0363508649,
-0.0168331061,
-0.0307909958,
-0.0107434643,
-0.0153846936,
0.0389731452,
-0.0334602408,
-0.0514417291,
0.0146590946,
0.0515911058,
0.0061384654,
-0.0630566552,
-0.0856973305,
-0.0050507444,
-0.0272156391,
-0.0127155902,
-0.0689225569,
-0.0259116404,
0.0221820436,
0.0226677693,
-0.07613267,
-0.0339445248,
2.17566326e-34,
0.0369463116,
0.0009321532,
0.0597613752,
0.0452188849,
-0.0141032636,
0.0221592374,
-0.0366944894,
0.0028211882,
0.0191448908,
-0.067806527,
-0.0011516412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01964v1 | Don't Make Your LLM an Evaluation Benchmark Cheater | 2023-11-03T14:59:54 | 2023-11-03T14:59:54 | Kun Zhou, Yutao Zhu, Zhipeng Chen, Wentong Chen, Wayne Xin Zhao, Xu Chen, Yankai Lin, Ji-Rong Wen, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models~(LLMs) have greatly advanced the frontiers of
artificial intelligence, attaining remarkable improvement in model capacity. To
assess the model performance, a typical approach is to construct evaluation
benchmarks for measuring the ability level of LLMs in different aspects.
Despite that a number of high-quality benchmarks have been released, the
concerns about the appropriate use of these benchmarks and the fair comparison
of different models are increasingly growing. Considering these concerns, in
this paper, we discuss the potential risk and impact of inappropriately using
evaluation benchmarks and misleadingly interpreting the evaluation results.
Specially, we focus on a special issue that would lead to inappropriate
evaluation, \ie \emph{benchmark leakage}, referring that the data related to
evaluation sets is occasionally used for model training. This phenomenon now
becomes more common since pre-training data is often prepared ahead of model
test. We conduct extensive experiments to study the effect of benchmark
leverage, and find that it can dramatically boost the evaluation results, which
would finally lead to an unreliable assessment of model performance. To improve
the use of existing evaluation benchmarks, we finally present several
guidelines for both LLM developers and benchmark maintainers. We hope this work
can draw attention to appropriate training and evaluation of LLMs. | [
-0.0043151747,
0.060889259,
-0.0227045137,
0.0695039034,
-0.0490223393,
0.0075636916,
-0.0071028778,
0.024004031,
-0.0151008423,
-0.0501391403,
-0.0836556032,
-0.0279642027,
-0.0025837368,
0.0066889785,
0.0337237231,
0.0068382598,
0.0541982204,
-0.0415345058,
-0.0208626911,
0.0042856694,
-0.0298657361,
-0.0327156335,
0.0335590355,
0.0423481986,
0.0038493662,
0.0069855005,
0.0285785794,
0.0103831673,
-0.0196316652,
-0.035425622,
-0.0104959635,
0.0092365397,
-0.0123638306,
0.039363727,
0.0000019729,
-0.0689205974,
-0.0097743459,
0.0344859511,
-0.0403333567,
0.0517783575,
0.0345221795,
-0.0032051054,
-0.0161758196,
0.0209472273,
-0.036797896,
0.0166164003,
0.0049912245,
0.0027103992,
0.0341493934,
0.0997726992,
0.009719423,
-0.0186207481,
0.0525384843,
-0.0141977603,
-0.0111540994,
-0.0767467469,
0.0112658991,
0.0319211669,
0.0294260494,
-0.0273494683,
-0.0048005092,
0.0271141957,
0.041253183,
0.0113158207,
-0.0092356429,
0.0241514388,
-0.0249847267,
0.0169547647,
-0.0226194896,
0.0213267934,
-0.0273820478,
-0.0122966934,
-0.0075014313,
-0.0198825691,
-0.0086613577,
-0.0154049499,
-0.0282559209,
0.0347005092,
0.0222022701,
0.0349969193,
0.0493260995,
-0.0023869779,
0.0717945322,
-0.0062420764,
-0.0054832553,
0.1064664796,
0.0256360974,
-0.038577728,
0.0341321267,
0.0075665009,
0.0007960771,
-0.0577164665,
-0.0257718749,
0.0614943914,
-0.0067962781,
0.0360414125,
-0.0208119135,
0.0008012739,
0.0216594357,
-0.0554920882,
0.0821629539,
0.0261143763,
-0.0020837272,
0.034395121,
-0.047230199,
0.0869315937,
0.0037033313,
0.051420331,
-0.0380890295,
0.0170656685,
-0.0172266793,
0.0026327737,
-0.0029928365,
0.0463430434,
-0.0026686576,
0.0128881168,
-0.0417405032,
0.0148734562,
-0.0115222232,
0.0489090756,
0.0198290311,
-0.0454666428,
0.008795389,
-0.0002523234,
-0.0379181132,
-0.0359001905,
-0.0126325078,
0.0211083405,
-0.0176603459,
-0.0999461636,
0.0144662159,
0.0127815083,
-0.0629871637,
-0.022574231,
0.0198237523,
0.1086281762,
0.006268437,
-0.0275859516,
-0.0464668833,
-0.0131511316,
-0.006243974,
-0.0853114799,
0.008703649,
-0.0775120258,
-0.0065371348,
0.017194042,
-0.0077578151,
-0.048974473,
0.0016271464,
-0.0106479758,
-0.0028909515,
0.0296292361,
-0.0184420366,
0.0173604004,
-0.0027285938,
0.0415353812,
-0.0241863392,
0.0902336165,
0.0442231223,
0.0257888697,
0.0318382941,
-0.0224964842,
0.0078756427,
0.0854792669,
-0.0186208151,
0.0201109778,
-0.0447034091,
0.0343826525,
0.0240781717,
0.0119583579,
-0.0118298437,
0.0595897958,
-0.0122926738,
-0.008974391,
0.0533102863,
0.0387855768,
0.0118238544,
0.02370755,
0.0190411918,
-0.0400694758,
0.0455583557,
0.002481214,
-0.0603761114,
-0.0107317427,
-0.0169804338,
0.0193165652,
-0.0091031045,
0.0178614631,
-0.0080848169,
-0.0644325614,
-0.0613658577,
-0.0055162432,
-0.0196484011,
0.0031308176,
0.05049555,
-0.0076006926,
-0.0486984178,
0.0756845027,
-0.010583668,
-0.0515203886,
-0.0146197239,
-0.0725550652,
-0.0126792174,
0.0184791647,
0.0437106714,
-0.0311798137,
-0.0317071043,
0.0202463716,
-0.0495919213,
0.0244088974,
0.0633727461,
-0.0032147097,
0.0151569759,
-0.0208616722,
-0.0111722779,
-0.0371173285,
0.0208093282,
0.0237580296,
0.0259383246,
0.0106960181,
0.0135667073,
-0.0825018212,
-0.0616892762,
0.0515962094,
-0.0477884188,
-0.0302564409,
-0.0296972618,
-0.0180727895,
0.0352371186,
0.0055920342,
-0.0247394703,
0.0205570962,
0.0586432889,
-0.0167615898,
-0.0045052269,
-0.0037639379,
-0.0229086448,
0.0138879465,
0.04960794,
-0.0230717976,
-0.0121589769,
0.0415582247,
-0.0256822538,
-0.0247173961,
0.0039216713,
-0.0252114087,
0.0588993803,
-0.0150423301,
0.0697586611,
-0.0570090674,
-0.0090371761,
-0.0372542739,
0.0533815026,
-0.0399493724,
0.0378404148,
0.005656952,
0.0287507586,
0.0305237286,
-0.0243238006,
-0.0489305034,
0.0174480584,
-0.0160371158,
0.0240012649,
-0.004908503,
0.0239916574,
-0.0564979538,
-0.0513991043,
-0.0814777836,
0.0145935705,
-0.0280992482,
0.0499886982,
0.0025040742,
-0.0396129973,
-0.0173707921,
0.0159536134,
-0.021961024,
-0.0308808312,
0.0098721758,
0.0166606363,
0.0328686722,
0.0274117161,
-0.0545356236,
-0.0500193685,
-0.0027197183,
-0.0133066587,
0.0563628003,
-0.0296271536,
0.0035217199,
-0.0463511385,
0.079219088,
-0.0105857169,
0.0147312582,
-0.0251919739,
-0.0334004872,
0.0328788273,
0.0115623102,
-0.0070373663,
0.0578616895,
-0.0246905535,
0.0052553718,
0.0717015788,
0.0024140098,
-0.0687858537,
-0.0032200913,
0.0328820907,
-0.0555951558,
-0.0717233866,
-0.0425997265,
0.0167889316,
0.0522478819,
-0.0334509201,
-0.0010474077,
0.003103243,
0.0213530678,
-0.035319712,
-0.0627941117,
-0.0155357467,
-0.0029551291,
-0.0309320446,
0.0375812165,
-0.0237527452,
-0.0914309248,
0.0127041684,
-0.0491757765,
0.0084186411,
0.0090433694,
-0.0105430065,
-0.084905155,
0.0545490868,
0.0063477252,
0.0046594539,
-0.032188721,
-0.0129019571,
-0.0155813945,
-0.0251961481,
0.0015670924,
-0.0466309153,
0.0670567304,
-0.0524129048,
0.0263469536,
-0.019891059,
-0.044536531,
-0.044345621,
0.0023795373,
-0.0444548503,
0.0250962656,
0.0257694852,
-0.0030821953,
-0.0160294231,
0.004102252,
-0.0158140268,
0.0129623814,
0.0067790169,
-0.0044132466,
-0.0033762546,
-0.0126270475,
-0.006751325,
-0.021781059,
0.0451387018,
-0.0438600592,
0.0275697652,
0.0326789394,
0.0399379395,
0.0199451894,
-0.0614861958,
0.0192850959,
0.0333791636,
-0.0421275534,
-0.0182994269,
0.041723039,
0.02585054,
-0.0605554804,
-0.0140199661,
0.1171393096,
0.0264092553,
0.0025653653,
0.0258300658,
-0.0117942756,
0.0229371712,
0.0488217101,
0.0289302785,
-0.070482403,
-0.0022831762,
0.0063658869,
0.0174405947,
-0.0246110801,
-0.0365546159,
-0.0081847468,
-0.1374516338,
0.0170488209,
0.0143822553,
-0.0288372971,
0.0143988002,
-0.039331425,
-0.0234915279,
-0.0435019843,
0.0415099449,
0.0253648963,
-0.0092336293,
-0.0254722722,
0.023280859,
-0.0326723531,
-0.0526787154,
0.0413189083,
-0.0457484201,
0.056897033,
0.0342874266,
0.0242577288,
-0.03679239,
-0.0225440972,
0.0558221936,
0.0114151007,
0.0187370498,
-0.0079600764,
0.0157660116,
0.0023001092,
-0.0084782196,
0.0358536132,
-0.032632377,
-0.0139951529,
0.0129420627,
0.0140183056,
0.048043523,
-0.0013188747,
-0.0448332466,
-0.001445853,
-0.0395281315,
-0.0350968093,
0.0674606338,
0.0242524222,
0.0008597479,
-0.0418880284,
-0.0332351401,
-0.0345083103,
-0.0364569202,
-0.0286186375,
0.0339510255,
-0.0034410704,
0.0247078743,
-0.0291962977,
-0.0288671348,
-0.020594243,
0.0245598983,
0.013562602,
0.0281868596,
-0.0179246701,
-0.0046514878,
-0.0341800861,
0.0184348039,
-0.0330998637,
0.0402954631,
-0.0790215954,
0.0218462721,
0.042184405,
-0.0008398048,
-0.0052080094,
-0.0104646422,
-0.0999699831,
-0.0667791516,
-0.0172688216,
0.0886330307,
0.028204482,
0.0146091105,
0.0050690868,
-0.0566780195,
0.0023835781,
0.0148116359,
-0.0196061786,
0.0406043902,
0.0317656621,
-0.0296276864,
0.0113784587,
0.0122264167,
-0.047239542,
0.0147397248,
0.0512866341,
0.0013455139,
-0.0232908558,
-0.0406691954,
0.0066722482,
0.0677195787,
0.0011023282,
-0.0090208668,
0.0039724847,
0.0323254429,
0.0248623043,
-0.0339153484,
-0.0063727549,
-0.0274759065,
-0.013459011,
0.0232485924,
0.0429799519,
-0.007812608,
0.0218963642,
0.0045399969,
0.0327575617,
-0.0246920567,
0.0582897551,
0.0112859802,
0.0116015188,
0.0179906711,
0.0100973127,
-0.0269913431,
0.0066874917,
-0.021763308,
0.0564426035,
0.0166837703,
0.0169202797,
-0.0069624507,
0.0345373079,
0.0076648467,
0.0401386917,
-0.0584899411,
-0.0482349433,
-0.0111521613,
0.0378894769,
0.0623831563,
0.0021156003,
0.0337202325,
-0.0356916152,
0.0116826948,
-0.039231874,
-0.0236860756,
-0.0370530151,
-0.0232929233,
0.0305807237,
0.0144612137,
-0.0197402518,
0.0176793635,
0.0645075366,
0.047574304,
0.0560352989,
-0.00092539,
0.0175672043,
-0.0307172835,
-0.0202126484,
0.0213908181,
-0.0225021429,
-0.0078364369,
-0.0387329236,
-0.0609882921,
-0.0898104683,
0.0240363684,
0.0480281748,
0.0552215762,
-0.0073666386,
0.0111614838,
0.0658801422,
0.0073485812,
-0.0065766252,
-0.038596198,
-0.0335574299,
-0.0048982119,
-0.0066633038,
-0.0209255088,
-5.883050944e-33,
-0.0188806411,
-0.0214179065,
0.05826509,
-0.0147402016,
-0.0253703035,
0.020578647,
-0.0186620727,
-0.0023260699,
-0.0367244519,
-0.0255427677,
-0.0301840175,
-0.0129511096,
0.0082627367,
-0.019553883,
-0.0104983421,
-0.0130280033,
0.0190424304,
-0.0105670337,
-0.0340193808,
-0.0474722721,
-0.0351746753,
0.0249404907,
0.0631688982,
-0.0593881235,
-0.0008346777,
-0.0107507585,
-0.033470422,
0.0139656076,
-0.0169699546,
0.0674223527,
0.0057439622,
0.0134554533,
0.0173774157,
-0.0342413001,
-0.0151059814,
-0.0446223728,
-0.0010556481,
-0.0302488413,
0.0358392522,
0.0300398245,
0.0071372623,
-0.0370740406,
0.0771470219,
0.0151371798,
-0.0981486663,
0.0077441884,
-0.0095547177,
-0.0413257927,
-0.0409074239,
-0.0076302248,
-0.0520748496,
0.0421833545,
-0.0020584106,
0.0317567028,
0.0370217338,
-0.0121940989,
-0.0249117035,
-0.0043445961,
-0.0270309504,
-0.0047990317,
0.0542732924,
0.0416585505,
0.1104657203,
0.0313262567,
-0.0044267913,
0.059434101,
0.0401811674,
0.033146739,
0.0201328453,
-0.0361151025,
0.0513380393,
0.0732646883,
0.0505104139,
0.0340432785,
0.0433252081,
0.0039639072,
-0.058284428,
0.0316326842,
0.0305305179,
0.0144600226,
0.0134064546,
0.0312709771,
-0.0524628311,
-0.0160300806,
-0.0688023493,
0.0084628146,
-0.0081074219,
-0.0126103181,
0.0496970303,
-0.0080197603,
0.024882881,
-0.0227577239,
0.0099450918,
-0.0601057522,
-0.0083673885,
0.0019647679,
0.0076018642,
0.041326873,
0.0019396361,
0.0364356935,
-0.0542099588,
-0.0298458003,
-0.0149753885,
0.0264264271,
0.0530800633,
-0.0241960455,
0.0078379326,
0.0244766418,
-0.0555578023,
0.0032900691,
-0.0313357711,
-0.0024151576,
0.0303385165,
0.0199805442,
0.0312247127,
-0.0380944423,
-0.004636602,
0.0423676334,
-0.0088451952,
0.0037625739,
-0.0453055315,
0.0205570422,
0.0211895611,
0.0220893305,
0.0061324998,
0.0031087175,
-0.0131920194,
0.0602361858,
0.0457679741,
-0.0228083935,
-0.0150838457,
0.0274977237,
2.698e-7,
0.0454488136,
0.0333980657,
0.0041698399,
0.0464055873,
-0.0133260377,
0.0316732302,
-0.0746316388,
0.0048319297,
0.0023149664,
-0.0006813842,
-0.0090714209,
0.0321580321,
0.0647854358,
0.014279075,
-0.0384926163,
0.000989493,
-0.0579069629,
-0.0117934467,
-0.0492538437,
-0.0119275004,
0.0027215348,
0.0691111982,
-0.0061132344,
-0.0264824815,
-0.037360806,
-0.0600041449,
0.0404261239,
-0.0607467741,
-0.0036909452,
0.0503937081,
0.0386890098,
0.0624606498,
0.010280204,
0.0064969924,
0.0102748713,
0.0358933657,
0.0039392761,
0.0594487041,
0.0073267929,
-0.0243987627,
0.0153635815,
-0.0371924154,
-0.011130441,
-0.0446654633,
0.0623689927,
0.0069871214,
-0.0264515318,
-0.0587900206,
-0.0164455473,
-0.0075134216,
0.0259450804,
-0.0173232164,
0.0152387246,
0.0384915955,
0.0150083005,
-0.0353185497,
-0.027491793,
-0.0427485853,
-0.0450552776,
0.0164519846,
-0.0161816776,
-0.0882528722,
-0.0394255184,
0.0399011672,
-0.0307330638,
-0.0577527732,
-0.008165936,
2.647398556e-34,
0.0192567203,
-0.0492786914,
0.0369217433,
0.0651182085,
0.0457093865,
0.02632902,
-0.0417175815,
0.0099853631,
-0.0383645147,
-0.0532482639,
0.016601963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01955v1 | Too Much Information: Keeping Training Simple for BabyLMs | 2023-11-03T14:50:00 | 2023-11-03T14:50:00 | Lukas Edman, Lisa Bylinina | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper details the work of the University of Groningen for the BabyLM
Challenge. We follow the idea that, like babies, language models should be
introduced to simpler concepts first and build off of that knowledge to
understand more complex concepts. We examine this strategy of
simple-then-complex through a variety of lenses, namely context size,
vocabulary, and overall linguistic complexity of the data. We find that only
one, context size, is truly beneficial to training a language model. However
this simple change to context size gives us improvements of 2 points on average
on (Super)GLUE tasks, 1 point on MSGS tasks, and 12\% on average on BLiMP
tasks. Our context-limited model outperforms the baseline that was trained on
10$\times$ the amount of data. | [
0.0141094392,
0.0466946326,
-0.0245156363,
0.0233541112,
-0.0549248718,
0.0390006453,
-0.0024346656,
0.0024148475,
-0.0602124669,
-0.0428227559,
-0.0152370837,
-0.0471168831,
0.0264579859,
0.0085943257,
0.0513817146,
-0.0891441554,
0.0662467927,
-0.0472837202,
0.0262365006,
-0.01892519,
-0.0209845882,
-0.0064378078,
-0.0228097681,
0.0347295254,
-0.0390275009,
0.0130290817,
-0.0282340795,
0.0202471949,
-0.0065607242,
-0.0172707587,
-0.0052510737,
0.0628145337,
0.0557816923,
0.0316445976,
0.0000018539,
-0.0662953034,
0.0187247545,
-0.021124281,
-0.0528910756,
-0.0238613728,
0.050049562,
-0.054025989,
-0.0100636063,
0.0147269405,
-0.0208318681,
-0.0137574691,
0.0388198905,
0.0384875126,
-0.0029238092,
0.084254548,
0.0107260263,
-0.0260354131,
0.0206677858,
-0.0156926326,
0.0696693063,
-0.0513517633,
0.0047374871,
0.0234584287,
0.0528086871,
-0.0176350996,
-0.0494843088,
0.0515023135,
0.0335161649,
0.0360264964,
-0.0017904665,
0.0649001375,
0.0061504934,
-0.0480090752,
0.0094449688,
0.0457399338,
-0.0491159968,
-0.0275182966,
-0.0138903167,
-0.0285633467,
0.0014077362,
-0.0328603834,
-0.0593160912,
0.0436977074,
0.0138779199,
0.0229587965,
0.0202119462,
-0.0292886887,
0.0520343445,
-0.0001132878,
-0.0123046963,
0.0460199602,
-0.0195521768,
-0.0268448908,
0.0597036779,
0.0264483616,
-0.0098356744,
-0.0459449627,
-0.075864695,
0.0179615635,
-0.022400938,
0.0356829762,
-0.0317833088,
0.0094315847,
0.0156394932,
-0.0425125845,
0.0279750954,
-0.0009357042,
-0.0118481312,
0.0492129177,
-0.0026505201,
0.0263641085,
0.0547945946,
0.0172746126,
-0.0320979059,
-0.0150324833,
-0.0457949713,
0.0148172649,
-0.0480845161,
0.015832657,
-0.0433698446,
-0.0154856993,
-0.0357142277,
-0.0088513624,
-0.0068778261,
-0.0011744394,
-0.0055378466,
-0.0054523009,
-0.0427278355,
-0.011058582,
-0.0134321228,
0.0009804443,
-0.0156395696,
0.0428017676,
0.0206405707,
-0.0592026487,
-0.0110864891,
0.0034442558,
0.0224455576,
-0.019273499,
0.0009857849,
0.0480993092,
-0.0035349857,
-0.0606581755,
-0.0585130602,
0.0201926194,
-0.0216345116,
-0.0997943282,
-0.0109702442,
-0.0807084963,
0.0136667378,
-0.0376590937,
0.0032352209,
-0.0529842526,
-0.0057654562,
-0.0096793827,
-0.0285999011,
0.0647762045,
-0.0366334245,
0.0085609891,
-0.0269657001,
0.0140797729,
0.0008061612,
0.1063418016,
0.0078581711,
-0.022587629,
0.0437999852,
-0.0111878766,
-0.0157943405,
0.0318597071,
0.0104168225,
0.0029998419,
-0.00945313,
-0.0131301386,
-0.0096865864,
0.0021165507,
0.0256144665,
0.0371611118,
-0.0342964306,
0.0074143508,
0.0714191422,
0.0338682234,
0.0017153646,
-0.0094952909,
0.0345730372,
0.0244115703,
0.0280061513,
-0.0150501672,
-0.0659186691,
0.0007961711,
-0.0272551011,
0.0143783735,
-0.0118605895,
0.0339299254,
-0.0536503308,
-0.0271628685,
-0.0408978797,
-0.0302379187,
0.0239852257,
0.0053527355,
0.0430941135,
0.0307036359,
-0.0225015637,
0.0188786276,
0.063722983,
-0.0074233254,
0.0169911571,
-0.0356515087,
-0.0236061029,
0.0253598914,
-0.0066453535,
-0.0171003249,
-0.0558644794,
-0.0142764123,
0.0275221076,
0.0516752526,
0.0342798941,
-0.010408001,
0.0567101873,
-0.0326297842,
-0.0131358868,
0.0338703841,
0.0327905789,
-0.0156914666,
0.029863324,
-0.016518943,
-0.0063030492,
-0.0051017599,
-0.0144270742,
0.042009756,
-0.0512834042,
-0.0158266705,
0.0029244567,
0.0041543315,
0.0402174778,
0.0194473974,
-0.0053774989,
0.0025947867,
0.0254506692,
-0.0380878523,
-0.0116945403,
0.0161001198,
-0.0536564142,
-0.0302918814,
0.0205312539,
0.0064783427,
-0.0279559791,
0.0293780528,
-0.017482264,
-0.0376034267,
0.0138941128,
-0.0415251888,
0.0567811392,
-0.0134696579,
0.0251671392,
-0.0279257093,
-0.0124367252,
-0.0468616299,
0.0715112984,
0.0034077221,
0.0345695466,
-0.01906926,
-0.0172529463,
-0.011297605,
-0.0521081015,
-0.0242597722,
-0.0232940018,
-0.016086055,
0.0352989212,
0.0046352982,
0.027343547,
-0.0475549176,
-0.0087265726,
-0.0771969631,
-0.0170662235,
-0.0185584761,
0.0175056569,
0.025377214,
0.0020377003,
-0.018206019,
-0.0142617607,
-0.0270605367,
0.056062337,
-0.0163229033,
0.0145869488,
0.0244795475,
0.0223304834,
-0.0380193703,
-0.0437123775,
-0.0129980547,
-0.0084822923,
0.0155529622,
0.0088996235,
-0.0356696658,
-0.0108283786,
0.0137864863,
-0.0299819149,
0.0109828925,
-0.0216166489,
-0.0040685763,
0.0264244545,
-0.0384515189,
0.0234217979,
0.0716089755,
0.011434881,
0.0252815057,
0.0165239237,
-0.0144642619,
-0.070472762,
0.0183026958,
-0.0443051457,
0.0055222241,
-0.0627030581,
0.005218606,
-0.0057957489,
0.1050918847,
-0.0433368087,
-0.0075431583,
-0.0499591678,
0.0245032031,
-0.0169016179,
-0.0366553776,
-0.0271440111,
0.0079012318,
-0.0308933407,
0.0425853655,
-0.0258416422,
-0.0714272484,
0.0198505297,
-0.0255304091,
-0.0183826629,
-0.0480094403,
-0.047254242,
-0.006965233,
0.0983460695,
0.0273730438,
0.0285172462,
0.0089617278,
-0.0245933831,
-0.0747496486,
-0.0009727513,
-0.0044863364,
0.0097215846,
0.0613331385,
-0.0583357252,
0.0293778721,
-0.0125666969,
-0.0765074342,
-0.0493130758,
0.0009737969,
-0.0370452851,
-0.0008124281,
-0.0177302174,
-0.0323724523,
-0.0545325167,
-0.0336441845,
0.0387050845,
0.016355969,
0.0033030997,
0.0031416046,
-0.0215102062,
-0.0201952681,
0.0463284478,
0.0343010798,
0.063619189,
-0.0671294332,
-0.0108382618,
0.0387378559,
0.0223699659,
0.0362189934,
-0.0184619389,
0.0114850067,
0.0151977818,
-0.0037635914,
-0.0499884412,
0.034579251,
0.0662228912,
-0.0449631922,
-0.0163416043,
0.1080427617,
0.0146580376,
-0.0138988197,
0.0266620386,
0.0278880391,
0.0720113739,
0.0222575087,
0.0153057398,
-0.0646122769,
-0.0246899612,
0.0270103142,
0.0071955677,
0.0179758873,
-0.0266941413,
-0.0266297515,
-0.0924405977,
0.0013362354,
0.0091681201,
-0.0770106092,
-0.0023471874,
-0.0276238378,
-0.0088393399,
-0.0102273719,
0.0334600545,
0.0152592678,
-0.0449263863,
-0.0108865872,
0.0255156234,
-0.0181412734,
-0.0910719857,
0.0343878604,
-0.0441541225,
0.0872334167,
-0.008830335,
-0.0100896629,
-0.0356307365,
0.0049852114,
0.1176514477,
0.0035819174,
-0.0238559283,
-0.023634363,
0.0119411917,
-0.0012003733,
-0.0094750356,
0.0104594035,
0.0333775617,
-0.0242541991,
-0.0178392772,
-0.0180802587,
0.0386536419,
0.0127253281,
-0.0392174125,
0.0111345826,
0.0169838537,
0.016979482,
0.0749879926,
0.0453369394,
-0.0594866239,
-0.0195561331,
0.0016598656,
-0.0274680704,
-0.0105921254,
-0.036909122,
0.0349948965,
-0.002685101,
-0.0266983397,
-0.0580092184,
-0.0415169038,
0.0544999093,
0.0870313123,
-0.0006765909,
0.0031240426,
0.0030638846,
0.0118131414,
-0.0420434996,
0.0476870425,
-0.0083540259,
0.0125028268,
-0.071345605,
-0.0427517332,
0.0187725704,
0.0134250075,
-0.0202165544,
-0.0206394885,
-0.0943037495,
-0.0529434904,
0.0210143272,
0.0382116474,
0.0406029373,
0.0604305901,
-0.0107963635,
-0.0418960452,
0.0137697989,
0.0502829216,
-0.0355447531,
0.0465792492,
0.0371139348,
-0.0231712963,
0.0341707841,
0.0641242191,
-0.0433112495,
0.0360157415,
0.0297079366,
0.0567552,
-0.0350806117,
0.0207487959,
-0.0115804235,
0.008559593,
0.0335975103,
-0.0101107797,
-0.005775156,
-0.0371632501,
-0.0043394691,
0.0096724508,
0.0274454374,
-0.0528070219,
-0.0222800206,
0.0134830279,
0.0334348083,
0.0148881264,
0.0088118576,
0.0128861126,
0.0220105592,
-0.0146863582,
0.0062520532,
0.0116640255,
0.0175371766,
0.0264305267,
0.0331833251,
-0.020566443,
0.0156466365,
-0.0042380458,
0.0320368782,
-0.0200156383,
-0.000317125,
0.0111100925,
0.0118875215,
-0.0468418971,
0.0033321502,
-0.0513396449,
-0.0309943371,
-0.0120360376,
0.0203839093,
0.0695771948,
-0.0059236656,
0.0396292396,
-0.033306323,
0.0053602513,
-0.042802915,
0.0124511672,
-0.0323830396,
-0.0271397065,
0.0528136976,
0.037966419,
-0.0229826402,
0.0118271969,
0.0760610402,
0.0020678227,
0.0338820964,
0.0197852533,
0.0671946555,
-0.0266925283,
-0.0047213091,
0.0314293168,
0.0543223657,
-0.0207287539,
0.050855957,
-0.064896822,
-0.0841776282,
-0.0229684375,
0.0278740786,
0.0143868607,
0.0086332709,
0.0733123869,
0.0300224852,
-0.0062845345,
-0.0173433144,
-0.0113537293,
-0.0305348653,
0.0171155818,
-0.0162749011,
0.0500266105,
-6.482412738e-33,
-0.0213334523,
0.0137776742,
0.0235958677,
0.0274813101,
-0.0026942312,
0.0409042463,
-0.0053598378,
0.0458041839,
-0.0587707125,
0.0152719859,
0.0005156008,
-0.0080063408,
0.0107987979,
0.0462423079,
0.0027643363,
0.0145050678,
0.0329805911,
0.0041785794,
0.000883382,
-0.0013441552,
0.0023986606,
0.0256619323,
0.0322174206,
-0.0521476977,
-0.0128739737,
0.0276519954,
-0.0127068935,
0.0516739823,
0.0294763185,
0.0662563518,
-0.0112485746,
0.0265910123,
0.0320959762,
0.0002703558,
-0.0538737439,
0.0221930724,
-0.1097786129,
-0.0503965616,
0.0335628465,
0.0193189979,
-0.0578703731,
-0.0055841343,
0.0606475733,
-0.0199094675,
0.001107793,
-0.0310221314,
0.0119138649,
-0.0092740152,
-0.0476409197,
0.0197212398,
-0.0771204531,
0.0169965513,
0.0154754501,
0.0156151177,
0.0435512066,
-0.0008754848,
-0.0352023803,
-0.0145711526,
-0.0300838538,
0.0001882901,
0.03948332,
0.0500628278,
0.0308886394,
0.0058706091,
0.0175880082,
0.0869075283,
0.0397095531,
0.0242664106,
-0.0102483742,
0.021899242,
0.0903260484,
0.0492203645,
0.0148543501,
0.0050494103,
0.043035239,
0.0036799423,
-0.0872946382,
-0.0167521052,
0.043948587,
0.0422824584,
0.0050293244,
-0.0067021269,
-0.039497517,
-0.0161906034,
-0.0609331727,
0.0099551668,
-0.0101645011,
-0.0299196634,
0.0320026726,
0.0419603959,
-0.0049940329,
-0.0161212776,
0.0132427393,
-0.0479936115,
-0.0213476419,
-0.041337207,
0.0281164926,
0.0003609148,
0.0199389365,
0.0059341886,
-0.0860042945,
-0.0503451005,
-0.0089340918,
0.0413113609,
0.0418808535,
0.0203733109,
0.0805432051,
0.0317977257,
-0.0772700161,
-0.0182559341,
-0.0345081128,
0.0093970187,
0.0153932655,
0.018117331,
0.0616489053,
0.0013782785,
-0.0013417487,
0.0343075544,
0.0038019114,
-0.0483622774,
-0.0055363323,
0.0271563064,
-0.0287737977,
0.0317440443,
-0.0186596345,
-0.0410627462,
-0.0319751389,
0.0147698252,
0.0637740642,
-0.047779832,
-0.0081795994,
0.0249469951,
2.625e-7,
0.0115044666,
0.0658878386,
0.0165265705,
0.0160527863,
0.0528813675,
0.0062946444,
-0.0404152945,
0.0064315493,
-0.0369946472,
0.0100560896,
-0.0230602995,
0.0159565769,
0.0581623241,
0.0223604012,
-0.1274573058,
-0.0214726254,
-0.0380053669,
-0.0052956808,
-0.0410729162,
0.016473718,
0.0400285274,
0.1176763326,
0.0127612231,
-0.0334636085,
0.0167191606,
-0.0388866924,
0.030695688,
-0.0536365435,
0.0179967079,
-0.0048633781,
-0.0295670927,
0.0623534806,
0.0240789205,
0.0197840314,
-0.0278077442,
0.024818942,
-0.0376246423,
0.0566588789,
-0.0130091747,
0.0010784608,
0.0237582456,
-0.0056053083,
-0.0283307638,
-0.0454840027,
0.0547307618,
-0.0784811676,
-0.022855686,
0.0091243396,
-0.0046467474,
-0.018949233,
-0.0003929526,
0.0128210876,
-0.0411838144,
0.0125130545,
0.0373285338,
-0.0207648147,
-0.0162605084,
-0.0884449333,
0.0043875063,
0.0566773042,
-0.0172790177,
-0.044299487,
-0.0089198481,
-0.0025125463,
0.0183594748,
-0.0356592536,
-0.0157541353,
2.249406245e-34,
0.0399656408,
-0.0363315009,
0.0241622552,
0.0069951396,
0.0088640768,
-0.0167313647,
-0.0373161249,
0.0049390676,
0.0145313991,
-0.0414652787,
0.0019566119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04926v1 | More Robots are Coming: Large Multimodal Models (ChatGPT) can Solve Visually Diverse Images of Parsons Problems | 2023-11-03T14:47:17 | 2023-11-03T14:47:17 | Irene Hou, Owen Man, Sophie Mettille, Sebastian Gutierrez, Kenneth Angelikas, Stephen MacNeil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of large language models is reshaping computing education. Recent
research has demonstrated that these models can produce better explanations
than students, answer multiple-choice questions at or above the class average,
and generate code that can pass automated tests in introductory courses. These
capabilities have prompted instructors to rapidly adapt their courses and
assessment methods to accommodate changes in learning objectives and the
potential for academic integrity violations. While some scholars have advocated
for the integration of visual problems as a safeguard against the capabilities
of language models, new multimodal language models now have vision and language
capabilities that may allow them to analyze and solve visual problems. In this
paper, we evaluate the performance of two large multimodal models on visual
assignments, with a specific focus on Parsons problems presented across diverse
visual representations. Our results show that GPT-4V solved 96.7\% of these
visual problems, struggling minimally with a single Parsons problem.
Conversely, Bard performed poorly by only solving 69.2\% of problems,
struggling with common issues like hallucinations and refusals. These findings
suggest that merely transitioning to visual programming problems might not be a
panacea to issues of academic integrity in the generative AI era. | [
0.0079492815,
0.0720907077,
-0.0700846091,
0.0110757705,
-0.0525632463,
0.0203134473,
0.056275256,
-0.004041926,
-0.0057342509,
-0.0592172742,
0.0329275653,
0.0008648356,
-0.0214406978,
0.024973277,
0.0403985828,
-0.0855436772,
0.0098018702,
-0.0320535935,
-0.0130503718,
0.0012861198,
-0.0052255848,
-0.0035498154,
-0.0680070743,
0.0559749529,
-0.0686609074,
-0.0667554066,
-0.0370701775,
-0.0131347869,
-0.0091214757,
-0.0091757886,
-0.0288451724,
0.028068997,
0.0445442982,
0.0240684785,
0.0000022839,
-0.0522826687,
0.0026313351,
0.0129523966,
0.0141479215,
0.0272649303,
0.0227304362,
0.0225216672,
0.0186349116,
-0.0004719912,
-0.0466258228,
-0.0005597656,
0.0724593475,
0.017018212,
0.0634697378,
0.0169950929,
-0.0027773497,
-0.0219350886,
0.0352379419,
0.0319348425,
0.0417834148,
0.0063782795,
0.0092105335,
0.0595263056,
0.0477612279,
-0.0197633896,
-0.0692313612,
0.0471969359,
0.0362522788,
-0.019790737,
0.001237605,
0.0313861445,
-0.0369202718,
-0.0360628888,
-0.0071547395,
0.0086872317,
-0.0302452613,
0.0222840011,
-0.0170070045,
0.0199710038,
0.0148646459,
0.0384837501,
-0.0582072698,
0.071489796,
-0.0431016535,
-0.0352419466,
-0.0639283806,
-0.0677927285,
-0.0204118639,
0.017887596,
0.0164430905,
-0.0450537354,
0.0329735428,
0.0126739228,
-0.0136377458,
0.0419459417,
-0.0213085078,
-0.0005318553,
0.0092693251,
0.0632771328,
-0.0048081805,
0.0064920685,
-0.0178735275,
-0.0211332664,
-0.0034185217,
-0.0120728528,
0.05876901,
0.0272619016,
-0.0212275386,
0.0234925076,
-0.0211609025,
0.0938179046,
-0.0355011113,
0.0733826458,
-0.0117774168,
0.0346983671,
-0.0649311543,
-0.0222516265,
-0.0547203086,
-0.0020126768,
0.0068463092,
-0.0003358584,
-0.0042259698,
0.0346448682,
-0.0374106504,
0.0253076404,
-0.0719552413,
0.0335350186,
-0.0074631055,
0.007022772,
-0.0416430943,
0.0198707301,
0.0069350717,
-0.000564881,
-0.003203793,
-0.0464635231,
0.0218092147,
0.0154251773,
-0.0154766692,
-0.0131777674,
-0.0016661446,
0.0983820409,
0.0024238087,
0.007600008,
-0.0080282269,
-0.0199195836,
-0.00668584,
-0.0450352915,
0.0591662824,
-0.0493525863,
-0.0225268453,
-0.0007086992,
0.0120746,
-0.0339230485,
0.0122521697,
0.0387078188,
0.0432480536,
0.0772894844,
0.0313477293,
-0.0032489204,
0.0452052616,
0.0206717867,
-0.0563016832,
0.0161331538,
0.0348047875,
0.0096488772,
-0.0075536589,
-0.0738674924,
0.0814364478,
0.0102076288,
-0.0490363091,
-0.0029890104,
-0.0103509752,
-0.0288296249,
0.0613232441,
0.0334859528,
-0.0260884576,
0.0527281649,
0.0009867877,
0.0092059486,
0.0538690202,
0.0169575512,
-0.0171483811,
0.0155534903,
0.0256701708,
-0.0118782725,
0.0438166521,
0.0145246517,
-0.0379457623,
0.0548301898,
-0.0141531136,
-0.0125426846,
-0.0293952748,
0.0494073965,
0.0131197404,
-0.0761644319,
-0.0136682391,
0.013626215,
-0.0110716363,
0.0153930746,
0.0464088023,
-0.0123099163,
-0.0266250931,
-0.0830673873,
-0.0172043927,
-0.0523359142,
-0.0079482496,
-0.0672149062,
0.029229423,
0.067954883,
0.0798038915,
-0.0237717256,
-0.0104797343,
-0.0360921398,
0.0318399444,
0.0177492779,
0.0577181876,
0.006551804,
-0.0001385433,
-0.0182097666,
-0.0110653499,
-0.02909429,
0.0100201443,
0.0210941397,
-0.0146752028,
-0.0237236246,
-0.0319702625,
-0.005146422,
-0.0405306593,
0.0327819213,
-0.0059477785,
-0.0241649412,
-0.051068671,
0.0204948001,
-0.0023424902,
-0.0184001625,
-0.0165876113,
0.0078210849,
0.0041647102,
-0.0123265004,
0.0298951641,
-0.0424357913,
-0.0308478065,
0.0303767249,
0.0463559218,
-0.1229042932,
-0.0423669294,
0.0448074378,
0.0021752864,
0.0038635144,
0.0820198879,
-0.0595431924,
-0.0040823077,
-0.0094404202,
0.0135457804,
-0.0136978533,
0.0098200301,
-0.0255296323,
0.0204600692,
0.0295271501,
0.0269606262,
0.0212721825,
0.0031886317,
0.0294916779,
-0.0019445143,
-0.0462236293,
0.0338817239,
-0.0054234625,
0.0348201022,
0.0081085637,
-0.0066077593,
-0.0436744206,
0.0039834874,
-0.0424072705,
-0.0323908441,
0.0274985135,
-0.0488377772,
-0.0262113847,
-0.0810853541,
0.0007292813,
-0.0106773907,
-0.0209527537,
0.0181188993,
-0.0045608021,
0.0116586778,
-0.0018422347,
0.010810094,
-0.0442393124,
-0.0119962404,
-0.0182393398,
-0.0681302175,
0.0226506125,
0.0786160529,
0.0178193375,
-0.0270646084,
0.0551389381,
-0.0049880724,
0.0236948002,
-0.0051840851,
-0.0150626916,
0.0581048988,
-0.0548188388,
0.0405817442,
0.0806440935,
-0.0007778813,
0.0599138103,
0.0727318823,
-0.0327519216,
-0.0286313519,
0.0274868738,
0.0373475216,
-0.0171360467,
0.0181977618,
-0.0587566383,
-0.0229359288,
-0.0007122775,
0.0033856214,
-0.0126967644,
-0.0236909576,
0.0764314756,
-0.0158008914,
-0.0310723111,
-0.0227497295,
-0.0331440344,
-0.0069462894,
0.0119301407,
-0.0231894702,
-0.0577361807,
0.0747742504,
-0.0199869182,
-0.0128196087,
0.0181236621,
0.0200226344,
0.007208664,
0.0921059549,
0.0450701341,
0.0231561754,
-0.0079245474,
-0.0020126293,
-0.0560121648,
0.0557065681,
0.0291797854,
-0.0313725173,
0.0258545578,
-0.0870554149,
-0.0309228841,
-0.007534957,
-0.0195553489,
-0.0479560494,
0.0492524765,
0.026274493,
-0.0198075157,
0.0042179236,
-0.0098635163,
-0.0174894352,
-0.0231940877,
0.0404575653,
-0.0426928513,
0.0068782317,
-0.0328666903,
-0.0251533557,
-0.0024573167,
0.0291644447,
0.0153320925,
-0.0454124212,
-0.0561344288,
0.0256824587,
0.0280845091,
0.0364073999,
0.0071713296,
-0.0615284108,
0.0399076082,
0.025309423,
0.0243812539,
0.0046130265,
0.0124031333,
0.02855069,
-0.0411854982,
-0.0060110744,
0.0312115997,
0.0109268418,
-0.058005739,
-0.0068637789,
-0.0044586458,
-0.02980824,
0.0353203639,
0.0440130755,
-0.0924065858,
-0.0052512521,
-0.01054521,
-0.0042522238,
-0.0243518967,
-0.0425047278,
-0.0027843732,
-0.0898608118,
0.0644278526,
0.0081634112,
-0.0117917014,
-0.0437190607,
-0.0058849147,
-0.0051079369,
-0.0075138872,
-0.0006642144,
-0.0087265046,
0.0088568134,
0.0197665207,
0.0577216335,
0.0585703105,
0.019442942,
0.0162019692,
0.0221141502,
-0.0070159975,
0.0354744494,
-0.0168577675,
-0.0457336977,
-0.0622849464,
0.0139797488,
0.0641734675,
0.0264469571,
0.0179083217,
0.0520170741,
-0.0143293003,
-0.0392603986,
-0.0330938958,
-0.0178126767,
-0.0046401983,
-0.0248543117,
0.0323447771,
0.0594625287,
-0.0188670829,
-0.0303310826,
-0.0534972101,
-0.0198563561,
-0.0384953879,
0.001941339,
0.0398167968,
-0.0286703743,
-0.044364702,
-0.0823749527,
0.0370680057,
-0.0444870181,
-0.0154000567,
0.0139701562,
0.0281767175,
-0.0083671072,
-0.020674983,
-0.0239716806,
0.0722006187,
0.0462747291,
0.0131583149,
-0.078029342,
-0.0040120459,
0.0483412594,
-0.0619869307,
0.0334965326,
0.0050955983,
0.0173719358,
-0.0318203159,
-0.027161099,
-0.0407951064,
-0.0524361283,
-0.0343629234,
0.0311468169,
-0.0108052455,
-0.0384567827,
0.03711126,
0.0882058144,
0.0271132234,
-0.037214011,
0.0186976977,
-0.003992266,
-0.0507978722,
0.0362285972,
0.0383754559,
0.0198535584,
-0.0027301935,
-0.0366585441,
0.0166427065,
-0.043926809,
-0.0109199407,
0.0128042167,
-0.0187362116,
0.0085989069,
-0.0035905251,
0.0047013164,
0.0326073393,
0.0596961677,
0.0227021649,
0.003164229,
0.0065718419,
-0.0148616666,
-0.0150599824,
-0.0278716777,
-0.0070693386,
-0.0336446874,
-0.0319694653,
0.0251387227,
0.0076197255,
0.0562254712,
0.0250514876,
0.0141006876,
0.0080783824,
-0.0126973679,
0.037787661,
0.0065711667,
0.0178921539,
0.0155541897,
0.0222097468,
-0.0022452537,
0.0242193732,
-0.0019787322,
0.0652636439,
0.0191578418,
0.1177103892,
0.0066871545,
0.0158215854,
-0.0023146956,
0.020961456,
-0.0416594669,
-0.0730822086,
-0.0037744783,
0.0355494395,
0.0258421954,
0.0264990907,
-0.0205155555,
-0.0460063107,
0.0286512226,
-0.0168879442,
0.0380656347,
0.0163555983,
-0.0473472811,
0.030529825,
0.0317793712,
0.0575463995,
-0.0345368721,
0.0518522188,
-0.0490813404,
0.0368007384,
-0.0445630178,
-0.0144028589,
-0.0147429658,
-0.0138749098,
0.0644932911,
0.0196990781,
0.0552374981,
-0.0071877018,
-0.0309597682,
-0.0727173984,
-0.052937258,
0.0450330861,
0.0133046852,
-0.038114775,
0.0420818888,
0.0405507684,
-0.0041849548,
-0.0255515836,
-0.0089741517,
0.032684695,
0.0062407111,
-0.0007643458,
0.017878361,
-5.815349816e-33,
-0.0074763168,
-0.0549431443,
0.0547410399,
0.0076340754,
-0.0015409782,
-0.0131488955,
-0.0260628667,
0.0475582071,
-0.0427855738,
-0.0055539752,
0.0245222766,
-0.0184004884,
-0.0160212796,
0.0297759175,
0.0495182872,
0.0104256896,
0.0249174908,
0.0267730001,
-0.0110082151,
0.026299471,
-0.0103477808,
-0.0172604658,
0.0235034674,
-0.050210122,
0.0153095536,
0.0107514337,
-0.0229076594,
-0.0438851044,
-0.0535095483,
0.0280379374,
-0.0488831326,
0.060018301,
0.0134340422,
-0.0188120548,
-0.0246401113,
0.0149272839,
-0.0214881636,
-0.0375478603,
-0.0191753563,
0.0374018587,
-0.0569120906,
-0.0521705449,
0.0467709191,
-0.0109545169,
-0.0514871292,
-0.0168516077,
0.066308029,
-0.025719963,
0.0145866862,
0.05280919,
-0.0546846241,
-0.0203698445,
-0.0669275597,
-0.0435732715,
0.003087057,
0.020864822,
0.0150946612,
0.0425429866,
0.0164879747,
0.0717075616,
0.0008642152,
-0.0105937142,
0.0947057083,
-0.0360406004,
0.0109356046,
0.0531576201,
0.0705597103,
-0.0226500481,
-0.0019413233,
-0.0357535332,
0.0090419631,
0.0520863608,
0.0448157415,
0.0379489698,
0.0079667429,
-0.0045137773,
-0.0259599667,
0.0140783219,
-0.0280717481,
0.0315550826,
-0.0132099083,
-0.0215996299,
-0.0708058625,
-0.0128126554,
0.0059251171,
-0.0497302264,
-0.0358472466,
-0.0159229394,
0.0497015491,
-0.0458997414,
0.0022707155,
0.0124003673,
0.0183689632,
-0.0617546551,
-0.0056541651,
-0.0071698544,
-0.0268917885,
0.0738711283,
-0.0251390226,
0.0148472507,
0.0015282009,
-0.0115005095,
0.0415184647,
0.0025935539,
0.0538882539,
0.0071264659,
0.0000147633,
0.038371738,
-0.0189748704,
-0.0088950871,
-0.058229804,
-0.0298120938,
0.0638999045,
-0.0098151872,
0.0336271599,
0.0051748781,
-0.0203637723,
-0.0058538201,
-0.0116573516,
-0.0129351439,
-0.0456467383,
-0.0818807036,
-0.0513360687,
-0.0246319864,
-0.026625257,
-0.0429992713,
-0.0727521256,
-0.0098255584,
0.0142195765,
-0.0761792958,
-0.0254874118,
0.0049136407,
2.973e-7,
0.0187931545,
0.0323765688,
0.0440244041,
-0.0037715246,
-0.0025496101,
0.0314435326,
-0.0084669804,
0.0133643085,
0.0390676521,
0.0049018506,
-0.0353168286,
0.0393202007,
0.0091866758,
0.0234884284,
0.013064798,
-0.0347260945,
0.0464814119,
-0.021813456,
-0.0685744584,
0.0813099742,
0.1271255314,
0.002272937,
0.0153686684,
-0.0275019147,
0.0157870576,
-0.0706366152,
0.02257853,
-0.0009055746,
0.0100380816,
-0.0321685858,
-0.0142503651,
0.0161760021,
0.0050483402,
0.0362893865,
0.0051174597,
-0.0635479763,
0.0161772966,
0.0090244776,
-0.0108333109,
0.0025474012,
0.0184958111,
0.0279341135,
-0.0230059288,
-0.0125450389,
0.045184426,
0.0016973988,
0.0045779869,
0.0103173107,
-0.0510093383,
-0.0411680304,
0.0109379096,
-0.0306423083,
-0.0090906844,
-0.0012389603,
-0.0226224046,
-0.0266789347,
-0.0050517288,
-0.0048324298,
0.0305584557,
-0.0287147611,
-0.0392911881,
-0.0097337831,
-0.009437466,
-0.0318868384,
0.0638975129,
-0.0178168323,
-0.0372421928,
2.237887089e-34,
0.0136922151,
-0.0206998829,
0.0756342411,
0.0176041014,
0.0144910933,
0.0129922088,
-0.0409047715,
-0.022924887,
0.0031191029,
-0.0283936542,
-0.0544043705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01949v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01949v2 | Hint-enhanced In-Context Learning wakes Large Language Models up for knowledge-intensive tasks | 2023-11-03T14:39:20 | 2024-04-18T15:08:44 | Yifan Wang, Qingyan Guo, Xinzhe Ni, Chufan Shi, Lemao Liu, Haiyun Jiang, Yujiu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) ability has emerged with the increasing scale of
large language models (LLMs), enabling them to learn input-label mappings from
demonstrations and perform well on downstream tasks. However, under the
standard ICL setting, LLMs may sometimes neglect query-related information in
demonstrations, leading to incorrect predictions. To address this limitation,
we propose a new paradigm called Hint-enhanced In-Context Learning (HICL) to
explore the power of ICL in open-domain question answering, an important form
in knowledge-intensive tasks. HICL leverages LLMs' reasoning ability to extract
query-related knowledge from demonstrations, then concatenates the knowledge to
prompt LLMs in a more explicit way. Furthermore, we track the source of this
knowledge to identify specific examples, and introduce a Hint-related Example
Retriever (HER) to select informative examples for enhanced demonstrations. We
evaluate HICL with HER on 3 open-domain QA benchmarks, and observe average
performance gains of 2.89 EM score and 2.52 F1 score on gpt-3.5-turbo, 7.62 EM
score and 7.27 F1 score on LLaMA-2-Chat-7B compared with standard setting. | [
0.02836865,
0.0171896946,
0.0224588495,
0.0547434986,
-0.0099931723,
0.0072858166,
0.0054818601,
-0.0006189918,
0.0187837873,
-0.0459376946,
-0.0350824483,
-0.0286374725,
-0.0576371364,
-0.0009352416,
0.0534024239,
-0.0113604674,
0.036102239,
-0.0593988672,
-0.0296708047,
0.0120891696,
-0.0169254038,
0.0133435549,
-0.0135131851,
0.0187643394,
0.0070333066,
-0.050780952,
-0.0285500363,
-0.0109947398,
-0.0114499712,
-0.0312604383,
0.026315527,
0.0216618031,
0.0646027774,
0.0093208514,
0.0000019684,
-0.0539848283,
-0.0003461539,
0.0170348808,
-0.0509484373,
0.0269100405,
-0.0116442321,
0.0311812311,
0.0160886683,
0.0253730677,
-0.0577146411,
0.0144642433,
0.0065239691,
0.0409753397,
0.0308222044,
0.0592947118,
0.0246625412,
0.0181827918,
-0.0000679455,
-0.0291010421,
0.039365869,
-0.0508102104,
0.0209001768,
-0.0118699325,
0.0428755358,
0.0211198218,
-0.0112536373,
0.0458176769,
0.0478771329,
-0.0026574209,
-0.0374399498,
0.0540034659,
-0.0379998013,
0.0532739311,
0.0121372389,
0.0641752407,
-0.0111400355,
0.0108222282,
-0.0131579209,
0.0053289002,
0.008887805,
0.000424529,
-0.0702361092,
-0.0045724204,
0.0007694286,
-0.0110266292,
0.0276949592,
-0.0077346233,
0.028871974,
0.0237248987,
0.0004313795,
0.0714526176,
-0.0040967087,
-0.0572790429,
0.0333582461,
-0.0102309156,
-0.0520130508,
-0.0519036874,
-0.0142223211,
0.0625802279,
-0.0569370538,
0.0376166515,
0.0006430968,
-0.0263325907,
0.0287263487,
-0.0393851735,
0.0292552207,
0.0339870006,
-0.0142050525,
0.0634365007,
-0.0172339864,
0.0399589874,
-0.0187891498,
0.0385413803,
-0.0605545975,
-0.0353728533,
-0.028086789,
-0.0197172314,
-0.0508201458,
0.0414468013,
-0.0468378291,
-0.0213144738,
0.0186396912,
0.070494011,
0.0005638788,
-0.0182133541,
0.0046466589,
0.0293552317,
-0.0132179158,
-0.0245175678,
-0.0461213849,
0.0225523468,
-0.0469233431,
0.0320567489,
0.0294220876,
-0.0565708503,
-0.0512989424,
-0.0116713783,
-0.0051525598,
-0.0351795629,
0.0162933469,
0.0480151474,
-0.0225332882,
-0.0557157546,
-0.03007943,
-0.0182419252,
0.0349397771,
-0.0459661931,
0.0077018109,
-0.0575540699,
0.0354198106,
0.0036113553,
-0.0131876748,
-0.0209525358,
0.0209296197,
0.0646600649,
0.0117659895,
0.0391461328,
-0.0077882009,
-0.006902412,
0.0288946722,
0.0298070349,
-0.0481938981,
0.0899116918,
-0.0003524233,
-0.0144364452,
0.0408346429,
0.0235828664,
0.0289686378,
0.0278112814,
0.0696434006,
0.0233667176,
0.0010602811,
0.0799363256,
0.0500611663,
0.046694316,
0.0395565368,
0.0307012331,
-0.0199386999,
-0.0158244763,
0.0374050066,
0.0426498204,
0.0161744505,
-0.01740494,
0.0135097448,
-0.0058691814,
0.0239773542,
-0.0438922644,
-0.0364088118,
0.015807474,
-0.0265901573,
0.0148347151,
0.0314145125,
0.022083465,
-0.0461342186,
-0.0047085253,
0.0017749313,
0.0163803045,
-0.0413782857,
0.0629448071,
0.0388811119,
0.0249990784,
-0.0571107715,
0.0316033997,
0.0297273602,
0.0147601692,
-0.0057463273,
-0.0583882555,
0.0564584062,
0.0025694997,
0.032372091,
-0.0476560555,
-0.0268195178,
-0.0224968344,
0.0646997616,
0.0148137454,
-0.0045639658,
-0.0549904443,
0.0092260055,
-0.0132728666,
0.0032532935,
-0.0542149581,
-0.006113064,
-0.0075308364,
0.0570953339,
0.0337191597,
0.0025298547,
-0.0776118413,
0.031769067,
0.0153418807,
-0.0321414471,
-0.0579777658,
0.0140422489,
-0.0087834159,
0.0035120277,
-0.0011019917,
0.0022800516,
0.0130757028,
0.0485907458,
-0.0372021571,
-0.0009125483,
-0.0277198832,
-0.041896183,
-0.1120982319,
0.021030901,
0.0242796801,
-0.0302677359,
-0.0028028707,
-0.0406843387,
-0.0097948015,
-0.0330192707,
-0.0271283686,
0.0822766125,
-0.0464404412,
-0.0391977429,
0.0351396166,
-0.0150492005,
-0.0486799441,
0.0763634667,
-0.0119192041,
0.0206135586,
0.0502205603,
0.0110366819,
-0.0206628926,
-0.0538676046,
0.0055111363,
0.0000520678,
0.0204548612,
0.0162347034,
-0.0378506593,
0.0177922752,
-0.0616045445,
-0.0101586543,
-0.0973956808,
0.0350752659,
-0.0333841443,
0.0397645347,
0.0045910124,
0.0136184357,
-0.0139502725,
-0.0305531118,
-0.0402415544,
-0.0423331894,
0.0017770085,
0.0228688102,
0.0196202472,
0.0707058161,
0.002486157,
0.0094204713,
0.0075300843,
0.0034366727,
0.0778629035,
-0.0255422536,
0.0542996079,
-0.0368473083,
0.0011878785,
-0.0068064923,
0.0287277643,
-0.0223129876,
0.0143948467,
0.0079011582,
-0.0175048038,
0.0137753915,
0.0744422972,
-0.0026360697,
0.0087494915,
0.0186325535,
-0.0104713403,
-0.0576231778,
0.0463497117,
-0.0074967146,
-0.0167095568,
-0.0189728662,
0.0387778915,
0.0193995479,
0.0273729824,
-0.0076171691,
-0.0132489046,
-0.0253080912,
0.0173687246,
-0.0083368523,
-0.0204170085,
-0.0800892562,
0.0248618498,
-0.0289320629,
-0.0058236276,
-0.0121627208,
-0.025037853,
0.0765389502,
0.0044826809,
-0.0223667976,
-0.0549715087,
-0.005408403,
-0.049251724,
0.0214829519,
-0.0425999686,
-0.0069360002,
-0.0040079034,
-0.0248715095,
-0.0328894034,
0.0010805333,
-0.0458565578,
-0.0382906534,
0.0310863759,
-0.0373787694,
0.0192270186,
0.0167135298,
-0.0662566498,
-0.0671419352,
-0.0344771482,
-0.0232991111,
0.0386534221,
-0.041671887,
0.0205491763,
0.0175286718,
-0.0289787631,
0.0442060269,
0.0130210109,
-0.0194342956,
-0.0078561427,
-0.0122950478,
0.037006028,
0.0673261285,
0.0490237847,
0.0065650367,
-0.0310143884,
0.0106083974,
0.0547981784,
0.065114893,
-0.0465636253,
-0.0106830727,
-0.0027466437,
0.0148857124,
-0.0367584415,
-0.0022319928,
0.0423380136,
0.0471093617,
-0.0811085701,
-0.0190450083,
0.0900557712,
0.0211210288,
-0.0180306472,
0.0020708353,
0.0018785688,
0.0131979054,
0.0188098736,
0.0695776194,
-0.0793464333,
-0.0450349376,
-0.0004613333,
0.0440964103,
0.0042692204,
-0.0026542619,
-0.0043380512,
-0.1491733342,
0.0273615662,
-0.0131919868,
-0.0701559857,
-0.0252564754,
-0.0355058163,
0.0244254116,
0.0257863868,
0.0296055693,
0.0395665914,
-0.0245049912,
0.0084205586,
0.0343027972,
0.0382030457,
-0.0678241402,
0.0309486818,
-0.0522035249,
0.0327210724,
0.0260122735,
0.0004804993,
0.0204338823,
-0.0448145084,
0.0287479665,
-0.0428372957,
0.0258289371,
-0.0272498596,
0.0235802177,
-0.0267814826,
-0.0306816269,
-0.0147977974,
0.0495845042,
-0.0467622541,
-0.0340199247,
0.0070463084,
0.1085392833,
-0.0108952271,
0.0290022884,
-0.0184459705,
-0.0354222842,
0.029760411,
0.0594104715,
0.0244767331,
-0.0331789367,
-0.0146596907,
-0.0158383511,
-0.0249766968,
-0.0010144674,
0.0139393527,
0.0107193189,
0.0090896096,
0.0356428064,
-0.047222279,
-0.0413303562,
0.0585088506,
0.0649283156,
-0.0346966647,
0.0287469234,
-0.0546590984,
0.0132927429,
-0.0195564628,
0.0541586913,
-0.0419051796,
0.0191656351,
-0.0596467815,
-0.004558885,
0.0362416692,
-0.026233919,
-0.0364327356,
0.0031064244,
-0.063217923,
-0.0438310951,
-0.0191407558,
0.0346898958,
0.0060620988,
0.0362865068,
-0.0027037302,
-0.0479159355,
0.0471657403,
0.0494768023,
-0.0046282317,
0.0374934897,
0.0243627224,
-0.0013156816,
0.0016414474,
0.0337503403,
-0.0626793951,
-0.0477291085,
0.0013588475,
0.053632021,
-0.0260003433,
-0.0098549249,
0.0286066756,
-0.0282621346,
0.0113013694,
0.0269738492,
-0.0160780903,
-0.0286389589,
0.0635533854,
-0.0060262987,
-0.0224212557,
-0.0443080962,
0.000973522,
-0.0118666124,
-0.0388647169,
-0.0066639939,
0.0105494,
0.003090827,
0.0427218005,
-0.0563840158,
-0.0090172971,
0.0509692989,
-0.0157693457,
0.0225222986,
0.0164538436,
-0.0167279765,
-0.0078869108,
0.0041663884,
0.065374434,
-0.0073131993,
0.0484468155,
0.0642748848,
-0.0160372332,
-0.0087416898,
0.0051085632,
-0.0579394065,
-0.0392667316,
-0.0452918038,
0.0440227166,
0.0459546335,
-0.0001731309,
-0.0091598667,
-0.006156561,
-0.0292391665,
0.0060133357,
-0.029847214,
-0.0257742945,
-0.0256302692,
0.0782466382,
0.0391330719,
0.0179313477,
0.0194268469,
0.0750436261,
0.0008972344,
0.0658090189,
0.02659191,
0.012361967,
-0.0091797654,
0.0073948051,
0.0587761849,
0.0344216041,
0.0127165299,
0.0252152868,
-0.0269343648,
-0.0533543676,
0.0151401842,
0.0041398196,
-0.0839397907,
-0.023600325,
0.0656683743,
0.0539972521,
0.0227663629,
-0.0829246715,
-0.0266531929,
-0.0037533529,
-0.0195875075,
-0.0381924585,
0.0118173528,
-6.53657511e-33,
-0.0221697669,
-0.0014339966,
0.038618654,
0.0153885596,
-0.0283057988,
-0.0001273069,
-0.0256764106,
-0.0253104027,
-0.0422842801,
0.0219910424,
-0.0406044498,
0.004656848,
-0.0046080612,
0.0273357145,
-0.0006619223,
-0.0651236027,
-0.0096448278,
-0.0025649136,
-0.0140542518,
0.0130159222,
0.0049559763,
0.0473986156,
0.0553948283,
-0.0458111092,
0.0126780672,
-0.0264110025,
-0.0070330924,
0.0529417656,
-0.0352158025,
0.0562433191,
-0.0274550151,
0.0360532477,
0.0165899526,
-0.0520698391,
-0.0090422602,
0.0228679422,
-0.0699603707,
-0.0304314233,
0.0183291119,
-0.0050493949,
-0.0471296422,
-0.0218298417,
0.0136772068,
0.0100929709,
0.0236151572,
-0.0091104452,
-0.0143284593,
-0.0133724809,
-0.007685795,
-0.056971211,
0.003699681,
0.0064675375,
0.0050638951,
-0.0519070439,
-0.0140200472,
0.0068496373,
0.009111031,
-0.0085112555,
-0.0258669276,
-0.0146002211,
0.0471009128,
0.0255597942,
0.0441603474,
0.0114022484,
0.0037381717,
0.0343959518,
-0.0167764556,
-0.022137152,
0.0161311068,
-0.0417761765,
0.0022851045,
0.0285174735,
0.0133890342,
0.0360640958,
0.0449982807,
0.059740562,
-0.0572426431,
0.0341412202,
0.0161206033,
0.009528474,
0.0108168367,
0.0064864303,
-0.0472221263,
-0.0254443511,
-0.0494360253,
0.0696862563,
-0.037277855,
-0.0263588857,
0.0691475943,
0.0174298584,
-0.0115667116,
0.0301653296,
0.0327051878,
-0.0502249114,
-0.0049785278,
0.0221236236,
-0.0185730439,
0.0110885426,
-0.009165653,
0.011158213,
-0.0848607719,
-0.020384904,
0.0129903648,
-0.0134440344,
-0.0290300362,
0.0095536662,
-0.028258875,
0.0278970972,
-0.0649502799,
-0.0048550917,
-0.0330548175,
0.0149178002,
0.0104452847,
-0.034569867,
0.0306978561,
0.0186759941,
-0.0120956562,
0.0842315629,
-0.0008849962,
-0.0320886821,
-0.0178195201,
-0.0081468774,
-0.0111727333,
-0.0141166607,
-0.0234834347,
0.0151515789,
-0.0061064083,
0.0203368068,
-0.0149261551,
-0.0498894341,
-0.0137874996,
0.0573027991,
2.714e-7,
0.0491278991,
0.0230939891,
-0.0029494176,
0.0724653751,
0.0037994685,
0.0280028619,
-0.0193473902,
0.0214999523,
0.056642022,
-0.0191833358,
0.0044986056,
0.0265812818,
0.0151220206,
0.0490884706,
-0.1157202348,
-0.0244702566,
-0.0382940061,
-0.0379463434,
-0.0569829531,
-0.046543207,
0.0061885626,
0.0992141366,
0.0032543268,
-0.0101162214,
-0.0059013627,
-0.0689927787,
0.0806938186,
0.000216275,
-0.0151501009,
0.004400142,
-0.0046050614,
0.0056490023,
0.0155677134,
0.0454002209,
-0.0140600754,
0.0345799848,
0.0167120099,
0.0476393923,
0.0166036803,
-0.0515856333,
-0.0036405351,
-0.0267877672,
0.0208019912,
-0.0591816381,
0.0907741114,
-0.0557481796,
-0.0111574559,
0.0018299082,
0.0156915896,
-0.0669900551,
0.0058667483,
-0.0208967179,
-0.0008627033,
-0.0008801009,
-0.0023678159,
-0.0007906872,
-0.0099935727,
-0.0780836642,
-0.014560434,
0.0147877587,
-0.0402201079,
-0.0299778655,
-0.0235172622,
0.0071851127,
-0.0092680538,
-0.0621597171,
0.0049051871,
2.460427685e-34,
0.0165571179,
-0.0030942832,
0.0021687928,
0.1160736829,
0.0063577723,
0.0039411467,
0.0363165997,
-0.0111454064,
0.0467868522,
-0.0805979371,
-0.0196144301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14685v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14685v1 | Comprehensive Assessment of Toxicity in ChatGPT | 2023-11-03T14:37:53 | 2023-11-03T14:37:53 | Boyang Zhang, Xinyue Shen, Wai Man Si, Zeyang Sha, Zeyuan Chen, Ahmed Salem, Yun Shen, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Moderating offensive, hateful, and toxic language has always been an
important but challenging topic in the domain of safe use in NLP. The emerging
large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, can potentially further
accentuate this threat. Previous works have discovered that ChatGPT can
generate toxic responses using carefully crafted inputs. However, limited
research has been done to systematically examine when ChatGPT generates toxic
responses. In this paper, we comprehensively evaluate the toxicity in ChatGPT
by utilizing instruction-tuning datasets that closely align with real-world
scenarios. Our results show that ChatGPT's toxicity varies based on different
properties and settings of the prompts, including tasks, domains, length, and
languages. Notably, prompts in creative writing tasks can be 2x more likely
than others to elicit toxic responses. Prompting in German and Portuguese can
also double the response toxicity. Additionally, we discover that certain
deliberately toxic prompts, designed in earlier studies, no longer yield
harmful responses. We hope our discoveries can guide model developers to better
regulate these AI systems and the users to avoid undesirable outputs. | [
0.0589709692,
0.0060220775,
-0.0374847241,
0.0303539075,
-0.0153388139,
0.0205792952,
0.0222458914,
0.0297272094,
0.056357231,
-0.0355195366,
-0.0484131724,
-0.0143383183,
-0.0265916288,
0.0368769951,
0.0115985582,
-0.0269752871,
0.0352940224,
0.0101967892,
0.0202815644,
-0.0075018355,
0.0483478718,
0.0182266459,
0.0000048244,
0.089141503,
-0.0449152552,
-0.0412661508,
0.0312810577,
0.0187023338,
0.0005406378,
-0.0173711516,
0.0494067557,
0.0499256477,
-0.0268128719,
0.034461014,
0.000001853,
-0.0310675446,
0.0280420203,
-0.0127922427,
-0.0209684111,
-0.0151909702,
0.0899984539,
0.0347709879,
-0.0341385193,
0.0485344417,
-0.035294272,
0.0132061876,
0.0792956501,
0.0480286889,
0.0838563591,
0.061368227,
-0.0110256076,
0.0336637795,
0.0017600447,
0.0070335707,
0.0148261851,
0.0016731084,
0.0367819965,
-0.0279768333,
-0.0136870397,
0.0068174903,
-0.0112808431,
0.0226339716,
0.0110302968,
-0.0175335072,
-0.0257486496,
-0.0127092246,
-0.0135585712,
-0.0522366092,
-0.0089655798,
0.0669823289,
-0.0407323427,
-0.0169991292,
-0.0088569252,
-0.0011260253,
0.0067771543,
-0.0312168635,
-0.0299874134,
0.0321452841,
-0.0142990407,
-0.0180006437,
0.0092682261,
0.0114328582,
0.0198400412,
0.039950002,
0.0815494359,
0.0311157033,
0.0074830186,
-0.0343531035,
0.0299968924,
-0.0133787105,
-0.0225194469,
-0.0359416753,
0.0157156903,
-0.0127350409,
-0.0583924316,
0.0276148356,
-0.062160559,
-0.0237732325,
0.0401304737,
-0.0728725791,
0.047941491,
0.0347281918,
-0.0261465292,
0.0175017305,
0.0225620233,
0.0295590814,
0.008202807,
0.0274919365,
-0.0132336346,
0.0246529933,
-0.0109737972,
-0.0281455815,
-0.0297785383,
-0.0203728154,
-0.0053951293,
0.0344505087,
-0.0362746902,
0.0230300631,
-0.0676784739,
-0.0205589216,
0.0277138948,
0.0329782963,
-0.0195025988,
0.0207270291,
-0.0262120441,
-0.0181044657,
-0.0531229824,
0.0044543594,
-0.0014321354,
-0.0678441226,
0.0082331048,
0.014930591,
-0.0521412939,
-0.0380639657,
0.0173261445,
0.1166234314,
0.0254465844,
-0.0096479934,
-0.0180451609,
-0.0388599634,
-0.0483305417,
-0.0479556546,
-0.0071344902,
-0.0393968076,
0.0300691705,
-0.0206666663,
-0.0442814864,
-0.0869332552,
0.0085036671,
0.0487395935,
-0.0581840239,
0.060212791,
-0.0104439324,
-0.0130084949,
0.0249534454,
0.0384347513,
-0.0666332245,
0.0584154986,
0.0214043539,
0.0242270529,
0.0393256657,
-0.0293442458,
0.018322533,
0.0557343103,
0.0110709378,
0.0238051154,
-0.0083728852,
0.0047085457,
-0.0085119428,
-0.0135219898,
-0.003746229,
0.0920443758,
-0.0174897723,
-0.0510174818,
0.0693042502,
0.047502473,
-0.0596060529,
0.0378380977,
0.059808936,
0.0174701139,
-0.0196392629,
0.0084349969,
-0.0765512884,
-0.0069856397,
-0.032046672,
-0.047759302,
0.0207127891,
0.0447076932,
-0.0043734191,
-0.0573843233,
-0.016383402,
0.0060725221,
0.056638591,
-0.0175030213,
-0.0053018038,
0.0218400117,
-0.0432951003,
-0.0106328083,
0.0607247166,
-0.0532462187,
-0.00406759,
-0.0445049256,
0.0118470183,
0.0911669657,
0.0730583817,
-0.0135446759,
-0.0181600861,
-0.0605800487,
0.0051579271,
0.0392751284,
0.027110178,
-0.0026788998,
-0.0059998683,
-0.0275360942,
-0.0163164381,
0.0348044373,
0.0056248796,
-0.0093271537,
0.0503382832,
0.0025499011,
-0.0225818064,
0.0230402574,
-0.06388399,
0.0336479843,
-0.0089377277,
-0.0808796063,
0.0004915029,
0.0138172479,
0.0438530035,
-0.0087058414,
-0.0232925843,
-0.0329257362,
-0.0002656064,
0.0145474756,
-0.026085861,
-0.0007068843,
-0.0603559949,
-0.0134005565,
0.0228176676,
-0.0169497449,
-0.025964627,
0.0404837728,
-0.0036864313,
0.0214194544,
0.0136466408,
-0.0418606773,
-0.0076809796,
-0.0132922707,
0.00111683,
-0.0361506343,
0.0154478075,
-0.047965318,
0.0262249149,
-0.0055743861,
0.0131452717,
0.0112169664,
-0.0155089861,
-0.0160610005,
-0.0022779377,
-0.0666181445,
-0.0072828196,
-0.0208593868,
0.0319159441,
0.0325577855,
0.0401767679,
-0.0350131169,
-0.0100192092,
-0.057744287,
-0.0079890611,
-0.0040448057,
-0.0077294549,
0.0257626083,
-0.0116169006,
-0.0342135765,
0.0326050296,
-0.0325861499,
-0.0382764153,
0.0221853498,
0.0575705916,
0.009951124,
-0.0427916236,
-0.0199551117,
-0.0453977846,
0.0031719937,
-0.033397425,
0.0217177868,
-0.0044962601,
-0.0199147332,
0.0198491234,
0.0510929748,
-0.0201010983,
0.0214323048,
0.0021418806,
-0.076304704,
0.038666971,
0.0265672021,
0.0309418086,
0.0916906819,
0.0314892679,
0.0810403973,
0.041838523,
-0.0102062421,
-0.0485625751,
0.0217511281,
-0.0213920418,
-0.0325172879,
0.0048917108,
-0.0547944792,
0.0144473417,
0.0569076501,
0.0442532264,
0.0025196115,
-0.0876794457,
0.0534961894,
-0.0618612096,
-0.0444162339,
-0.0118177254,
-0.0713829249,
-0.0380480625,
-0.0138777597,
-0.0206979178,
-0.0665382594,
0.0660998896,
0.0027480931,
0.0014123784,
-0.0253207609,
-0.013682588,
0.0295999832,
0.0437037274,
-0.0018286271,
0.0319679156,
0.0443107039,
0.0030478046,
-0.0274422579,
-0.0150066111,
0.0389315747,
-0.0288874432,
0.0045784907,
-0.0309343971,
-0.0233327448,
0.0208337661,
-0.0618300065,
-0.0668829679,
-0.0404041931,
0.0014407024,
-0.0347148664,
0.0486377217,
-0.0007530887,
0.0040656026,
-0.000033069,
0.0213002879,
-0.0414248034,
-0.0338716432,
-0.0093219038,
0.0082552573,
-0.0324669704,
0.0628476441,
-0.0334605612,
0.0210657977,
0.0125283804,
0.0303719491,
0.0860605612,
-0.0280860607,
-0.0032862674,
0.0053949077,
0.01646729,
0.0095043108,
0.009633936,
0.00142775,
0.0313259363,
0.042249836,
-0.0424607173,
-0.0201748684,
0.0678218231,
0.0217866153,
-0.0363461785,
0.0217078663,
0.001757584,
0.039866142,
0.0103149116,
0.0049934671,
-0.07861837,
-0.0233765785,
0.0026257737,
0.0270409882,
-0.0706290826,
-0.0283626113,
-0.0102058407,
-0.1100131497,
0.0223442987,
-0.0013130271,
-0.0271090027,
-0.0063288002,
-0.0008689946,
0.0009485247,
-0.0224860404,
0.0593540967,
-0.0286141243,
0.0027294613,
-0.0091967518,
0.0216410067,
-0.0357320122,
-0.0125756469,
0.0336305164,
-0.0220831931,
0.0779756308,
0.0464440919,
0.0274156462,
-0.018270066,
0.0012492385,
0.0613672808,
0.020611573,
-0.0250014029,
-0.0218114872,
0.0609963275,
-0.0023244366,
-0.006009555,
-0.0373947322,
0.0280534253,
-0.020158371,
0.0059558856,
0.0343601145,
0.0615892783,
0.0122516965,
-0.006943468,
-0.0486771688,
0.035900645,
0.0471063703,
0.0950492695,
0.0259116944,
-0.0946782753,
-0.0084717944,
-0.0711812377,
-0.0057207332,
-0.0335450284,
-0.0869627967,
-0.0212192088,
-0.0288803633,
-0.0277875774,
-0.06986662,
-0.0597962365,
0.0291335955,
-0.0116909845,
0.029810138,
-0.0363676734,
-0.0336905941,
0.0154633606,
0.0153887039,
0.0202407055,
0.0056364299,
0.0201540012,
-0.057011418,
0.0163172614,
-0.0303475913,
-0.0095153432,
-0.0078869751,
0.041081436,
-0.0504012667,
-0.0792947784,
0.0505289659,
0.1004850045,
0.019371843,
-0.0028396889,
-0.0119345896,
-0.0372352488,
0.0157320201,
0.0640485063,
-0.0217400305,
-0.0076621994,
0.040869385,
0.0234125722,
0.0225998983,
0.0115290107,
-0.0204593688,
0.0306239203,
0.0491107479,
0.0033950149,
-0.0309313554,
-0.016080467,
0.0085741272,
0.0301009603,
0.0255289897,
-0.0243055597,
-0.0326003879,
-0.0171941631,
-0.0253636613,
-0.0091096917,
-0.0324002355,
-0.0077864593,
0.0069446922,
-0.0134394486,
-0.0171654243,
-0.0294094793,
-0.0396825783,
-0.0551319048,
0.0348481201,
-0.0351909287,
0.0237303395,
0.0302853528,
0.0149034197,
0.0330662765,
0.0338382386,
-0.0346600525,
0.0479492061,
0.0050160345,
-0.0005355215,
0.000318227,
0.04692626,
0.0075196368,
0.0079495776,
0.0433347784,
0.0437549464,
0.0037696315,
-0.0170548633,
-0.0158955082,
0.011700172,
0.0177484676,
-0.027515538,
0.0524671152,
-0.0156473089,
-0.0006867905,
-0.0330152251,
-0.0059966897,
0.008935607,
-0.0497224629,
0.0031456728,
0.007336773,
-0.0188163258,
-0.0269297808,
0.0679836869,
-0.0300636347,
0.0586008467,
0.0414077789,
-0.025404105,
-0.0181192271,
-0.0088976119,
0.0259178169,
0.0022182227,
0.0064082816,
0.021541575,
-0.0605096444,
-0.0667899251,
-0.0375205837,
-0.0103940545,
0.0376962312,
-0.0262103435,
0.0265549719,
0.0418003388,
0.0059526283,
0.0084519908,
-0.0056822584,
-0.0000025381,
-0.0204163473,
-0.0428323857,
-0.0408901088,
-5.534866211e-33,
0.004765966,
-0.044420138,
-0.0048173759,
0.0507795177,
0.0015764141,
-0.0193609428,
0.0082626995,
0.0304871853,
-0.0204118807,
0.0112822391,
-0.0165997911,
-0.0118675539,
-0.0058210683,
-0.0079748221,
-0.0001486031,
-0.0368328989,
0.025067348,
-0.0322422013,
-0.0404032134,
0.0344059989,
0.0490732826,
-0.0044414434,
0.0174230803,
-0.0790773109,
0.0458645448,
-0.0061803651,
-0.0428798497,
0.0003100596,
-0.0220385808,
0.0738667548,
0.0033065574,
0.1034848243,
0.0193873197,
-0.0090331091,
0.0052450011,
0.0517634489,
-0.0066602663,
-0.0383108966,
0.0213044509,
-0.0066403113,
-0.015792029,
-0.0414611027,
0.0425689407,
-0.0135752475,
-0.0509015843,
-0.0215357672,
0.0245327409,
-0.0028522748,
0.0169723183,
-0.0274939239,
-0.0637047514,
0.0022758378,
-0.0272099283,
-0.0577815399,
-0.0278148651,
0.0628630295,
0.003869195,
-0.0333173983,
-0.0342153981,
0.017567344,
-0.0061444654,
0.0056595784,
0.013824407,
-0.0212706141,
0.0122256018,
0.063074328,
0.0085288975,
0.0717424899,
-0.0207029041,
0.0043895752,
0.0142306825,
0.0239105504,
0.0403663926,
0.0277174469,
0.0049995063,
-0.0613701865,
-0.0228655394,
0.0149974218,
0.047721535,
0.0336666927,
0.0181886982,
-0.0342461802,
-0.0749749169,
-0.0501203425,
-0.0049505532,
-0.0282091834,
-0.0218798388,
-0.0588889606,
0.0546653271,
-0.0360944457,
-0.0107842796,
-0.0711173713,
0.0010188017,
-0.0392537229,
0.0324057154,
0.0101273591,
-0.0080626728,
-0.006705937,
0.018396847,
0.0164833553,
-0.0229374096,
0.0087528061,
0.0055134739,
-0.0443655998,
0.0372067243,
0.0170243196,
0.0565065704,
0.0290339105,
-0.0656951815,
0.0104230409,
-0.0267797839,
0.0853434652,
0.0111932158,
0.0493419804,
0.0028577284,
0.0210205875,
-0.0094112009,
-0.0101171453,
0.0578655005,
0.0038917414,
-0.0541641787,
-0.0136877745,
-0.0349259451,
-0.0087106815,
-0.0371549353,
0.0064202505,
-0.0229006,
0.0132595375,
0.0220573619,
-0.0842465535,
-0.0099929124,
-0.0549565032,
2.489e-7,
0.0164085459,
0.0761192515,
0.0117611205,
0.0676424056,
0.013243922,
0.047476612,
0.0207237843,
0.0407278351,
0.0229395907,
0.0079174712,
-0.0182155445,
0.01164879,
0.0370164253,
0.0604830086,
-0.0535853244,
-0.011587088,
-0.0959475935,
0.0250318423,
-0.0537248328,
0.0048702601,
0.0682225227,
0.0700741708,
0.0304637477,
-0.0280930903,
-0.016830394,
-0.0336519331,
0.0177842546,
-0.0540170297,
-0.0003125973,
-0.0042900699,
0.0521659404,
-0.0148696015,
0.0280020349,
0.0117337415,
-0.0006187522,
-0.0353120342,
0.0003902742,
0.0578956865,
0.0008068092,
-0.0236931834,
0.0352784991,
-0.018652916,
-0.0175148919,
-0.0440602601,
0.0553754643,
0.0038593591,
0.0073701777,
-0.0465404578,
0.0058734776,
-0.0306661408,
0.0557711869,
-0.0585684925,
-0.0443606377,
-0.0095382622,
0.0283315219,
0.0070072971,
0.0161561258,
-0.0404391848,
-0.0225790143,
-0.0143513121,
-0.0136228064,
-0.0720331743,
-0.0112603176,
0.0220268331,
-0.007521159,
-0.0226227604,
0.0276964009,
2.286938953e-34,
0.0128695741,
-0.0413871072,
0.053970851,
-0.0229262412,
0.0564799719,
0.0599521436,
0.0355245583,
0.0187120959,
0.0143937264,
-0.0247702245,
-0.0308650676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01928v1 | Constructing Temporal Dynamic Knowledge Graphs from Interactive Text-based Games | 2023-11-03T14:09:31 | 2023-11-03T14:09:31 | Keunwoo Peter Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In natural language processing, interactive text-based games serve as a test
bed for interactive AI systems. Prior work has proposed to play text-based
games by acting based on discrete knowledge graphs constructed by the Discrete
Graph Updater (DGU) to represent the game state from the natural language
description. While DGU has shown promising results with high interpretability,
it suffers from lower knowledge graph accuracy due to its lack of temporality
and limited generalizability to complex environments with objects with the same
label. In order to address DGU's weaknesses while preserving its high
interpretability, we propose the Temporal Discrete Graph Updater (TDGU), a
novel neural network model that represents dynamic knowledge graphs as a
sequence of timestamped graph events and models them using a temporal point
based graph neural network. Through experiments on the dataset collected from a
text-based game TextWorld, we show that TDGU outperforms the baseline DGU. We
further show the importance of temporal information for TDGU's performance
through an ablation study and demonstrate that TDGU has the ability to
generalize to more complex environments with objects with the same label. All
the relevant code can be found at
\url{https://github.com/yukw777/temporal-discrete-graph-updater}. | [
0.0282819699,
-0.0088577215,
-0.0330222584,
0.0440476872,
-0.0307663437,
-0.0116703771,
-0.0139349811,
0.0008988497,
0.068031691,
-0.0108506372,
0.0312144831,
-0.0071332832,
0.0426932871,
0.0899364129,
0.0016371382,
-0.0389911048,
0.0418326929,
-0.0275494494,
0.0344831422,
-0.0042612175,
-0.0292652734,
0.0096832542,
-0.0664717481,
0.0270033646,
0.0051548993,
-0.0432692058,
-0.0707058311,
-0.0187950227,
0.0151739195,
-0.0822004974,
-0.0507156067,
-0.0185631812,
0.0191661827,
-0.00581674,
0.0000020377,
-0.0035051343,
0.0172440074,
-0.0178815518,
-0.0188234337,
-0.014496306,
-0.005214063,
0.0326544046,
0.0257009044,
-0.0344638601,
-0.0673613474,
-0.0210675374,
0.0559152812,
0.0228171144,
0.0641560778,
0.0707555711,
-0.0061257468,
-0.0011511903,
0.0250502266,
0.0128378253,
0.0208428558,
-0.0646443814,
0.0188830849,
0.0309461541,
0.0618305206,
-0.0227866787,
-0.0320225172,
0.0208591744,
0.0073828502,
-0.0173450261,
0.0359920077,
0.0533026755,
0.0227947664,
0.0578772128,
-0.0141937584,
0.0866846293,
0.0057540783,
-0.006005344,
0.0332978778,
0.0102317948,
0.0112915458,
-0.0130824558,
-0.0152831739,
-0.0231436379,
-0.0155193051,
0.0135701168,
-0.0253121909,
0.024087647,
0.0412039161,
-0.0076932763,
0.004236564,
0.0966160968,
-0.0337093957,
-0.0107814614,
-0.046714019,
-0.0288207158,
-0.0216933247,
-0.0730739087,
0.0077640852,
0.0657628626,
-0.0357808135,
0.0419093445,
-0.0299011637,
0.0190874059,
-0.0249386616,
-0.0493496135,
0.0205628499,
0.0178457405,
0.0323519744,
0.0707767308,
0.0120498985,
0.058472909,
0.0193776432,
0.0073916074,
-0.0057868883,
0.0173035972,
-0.0843163058,
-0.0132923471,
-0.0153184207,
0.072597459,
0.0072402451,
-0.0312341563,
-0.0357714258,
0.0424183458,
-0.0302691087,
0.0567153133,
0.0102544576,
0.0309276823,
-0.001603735,
0.0078059849,
-0.0672297776,
0.0118137049,
-0.0318509638,
-0.0001927169,
-0.0336969234,
-0.0149266059,
0.0062309508,
-0.0372397304,
0.0696947202,
0.0098470049,
-0.0268817861,
0.0734898746,
0.0022828917,
-0.0341288634,
-0.0443559289,
-0.0516396388,
-0.0151549214,
-0.0326851197,
-0.0140963895,
-0.0655946583,
0.0778486505,
-0.0252358019,
-0.0073712431,
-0.0434417501,
0.0043484336,
0.0122567676,
-0.030128831,
0.0729450211,
-0.030690778,
0.0220133942,
-0.0007936669,
-0.0191137753,
0.0167633891,
0.0158808995,
0.0967994034,
-0.0017828572,
0.0217359457,
0.0326229334,
-0.0220027268,
0.0457953177,
0.014214485,
-0.0299731251,
-0.0090393675,
-0.0326014087,
-0.0547791906,
0.0697754249,
-0.0303952657,
0.018126158,
-0.04683391,
-0.0295872446,
0.0689188391,
0.029524928,
-0.003677319,
0.0148360617,
0.0741684586,
0.0393449143,
-0.0038226612,
-0.0037517743,
-0.0201180726,
0.0240902212,
-0.0039751106,
-0.0039110631,
-0.0775459334,
-0.0117241414,
0.010996623,
-0.0749288276,
0.0342929624,
0.0057897791,
0.0938812122,
0.0033328529,
0.0683149099,
0.0065329904,
-0.0532091223,
0.030846037,
0.0130392043,
0.0135256043,
0.0005650769,
-0.022287339,
0.0070818956,
0.1038273498,
0.058190465,
-0.0688900501,
-0.0686655417,
-0.0123181045,
-0.0306754429,
0.0191851687,
0.0293962378,
-0.0310141686,
0.0287077446,
-0.0091739716,
-0.0346144363,
-0.0427057333,
-0.0076039061,
0.0598994456,
0.0146975452,
0.0367408022,
-0.0356736407,
-0.049208276,
-0.0018440289,
0.0130530735,
0.0202940982,
-0.022069253,
0.0145422239,
-0.0033170311,
-0.002124453,
0.0266233012,
0.0030805976,
-0.0207102317,
0.014294073,
-0.0093182186,
-0.0166042298,
0.0298334602,
-0.0284960829,
-0.0649834424,
0.0674811155,
0.0111606335,
-0.0413138457,
0.001349333,
-0.039764192,
-0.0108398786,
0.0557318777,
-0.0327582099,
0.0344179273,
0.027273953,
0.0014570353,
-0.0040771351,
-0.0124055343,
0.0059373071,
0.0745930076,
-0.0176175237,
-0.037827976,
-0.0121754734,
-0.0188430604,
0.0112457825,
-0.0622325018,
0.0161158275,
0.0173958484,
-0.0115620624,
-0.0329746008,
0.016896585,
-0.0041178465,
-0.0373705551,
0.0124014271,
-0.0819953978,
-0.0318878219,
0.0133235129,
-0.0008824763,
0.0131090861,
-0.0117798001,
0.013376019,
-0.0168335941,
-0.0184787437,
0.0146798184,
-0.0086982576,
-0.0100962128,
0.0538485013,
0.0586250015,
-0.0075048669,
-0.0057028504,
-0.023685921,
-0.0579044893,
0.05940127,
0.0272358973,
-0.074643895,
-0.0517582558,
0.0313771814,
-0.0534235984,
0.0403588675,
-0.0242966376,
0.0024421492,
0.0316756591,
-0.0179840643,
0.0107229017,
0.0358094983,
-0.0290522687,
0.0295221675,
0.0769033805,
-0.0714563131,
-0.0400775075,
0.0500630252,
-0.0264956411,
0.0329648219,
-0.0704776645,
-0.0335195549,
0.030714646,
0.0403347015,
0.0357637294,
-0.0072944872,
-0.0739853531,
0.000666537,
-0.0173909012,
-0.0350102521,
-0.0574490726,
-0.0576040447,
-0.0231721029,
-0.0553808548,
-0.0593777336,
0.031428542,
0.0702199265,
-0.0071393014,
0.0141980899,
0.0117561826,
0.0010808321,
-0.0190065429,
0.093879886,
0.0528612733,
0.0207277443,
0.0290108118,
-0.0355678201,
-0.046589423,
-0.0166768301,
0.0431398824,
-0.0135307498,
-0.0063922768,
-0.0854201764,
0.0230200756,
0.0590449646,
0.0041200831,
0.0020463765,
0.0021959301,
-0.0043083881,
-0.0243484341,
-0.0230088774,
-0.0084716137,
-0.0084637906,
-0.0146157332,
0.0079204254,
0.0133819925,
0.0034027561,
-0.0228955355,
-0.0294906925,
0.0529211126,
0.0685847849,
0.0312013458,
-0.0372425914,
0.005819798,
0.0298763067,
0.0359208286,
-0.0084230993,
-0.0437237062,
-0.0559919067,
0.0241756923,
-0.0184668209,
-0.044819504,
-0.0200761631,
0.0309716295,
-0.0061054295,
-0.0747528076,
-0.0108141974,
0.0766672119,
0.0376183651,
0.0036002528,
0.0140594002,
0.0401247926,
-0.025631452,
0.0139447441,
0.0100473184,
-0.0887606442,
-0.0082075708,
-0.0311924722,
-0.0123517988,
-0.0118788956,
-0.0831536278,
-0.0344538651,
-0.0778999254,
-0.0430616103,
0.0099683749,
-0.0060252412,
0.0020033456,
-0.0029359716,
-0.0161370523,
0.0055768061,
-0.0473875664,
-0.0262821317,
0.0507349893,
0.0120601859,
-0.0109074311,
-0.043222975,
-0.0171492398,
0.0369216837,
0.0059877951,
0.05909862,
0.0194454268,
0.0965614989,
-0.0211340543,
0.0032458962,
0.0131720472,
0.0636316165,
0.0012389096,
-0.0045134816,
0.0480433591,
0.0232629012,
0.0098405667,
0.0114271566,
-0.0351318903,
0.0009776708,
-0.0281025935,
-0.0098510757,
0.1104259565,
0.0144252451,
-0.025293285,
0.0099108992,
-0.0101297516,
0.0333101973,
0.0135885812,
-0.0121842045,
0.0019393176,
-0.0267117806,
-0.0128934095,
-0.0136204287,
-0.0637456328,
-0.0369345024,
-0.016526483,
0.0010006698,
0.0293435678,
-0.0828836262,
-0.0358845331,
-0.0243914705,
-0.0027475758,
0.0036782138,
0.0211132448,
0.0750457346,
0.0146889174,
-0.0279944167,
-0.0122794295,
-0.0124453511,
0.0043522539,
0.0071185096,
-0.0448069572,
0.0031910189,
-0.0047993483,
-0.0079772053,
0.0519252568,
-0.0502671301,
-0.0575163513,
-0.0028319522,
0.0125475163,
0.0068121939,
0.0582301803,
-0.0147319073,
-0.022919545,
0.0546654351,
0.002513804,
-0.0183466356,
0.0143962102,
-0.0168423988,
0.0392427184,
0.0081150811,
0.0139362114,
-0.0689709485,
-0.0193296708,
-0.016806934,
0.0598828532,
-0.0621307679,
-0.0051293476,
0.0015525742,
0.0055640172,
0.0243592653,
0.0316968225,
-0.0225236882,
-0.0265037324,
0.0143744349,
-0.0422668979,
-0.0035048132,
-0.0308824386,
0.0055638049,
-0.0082164761,
-0.0025393877,
-0.015553589,
-0.0143432096,
0.0355457664,
-0.0225564577,
-0.0025962582,
-0.0382917933,
0.0624117106,
-0.0118891355,
0.0305943862,
0.03702759,
-0.0089928936,
0.0431834199,
-0.0180658828,
0.0041782404,
-0.0021293845,
0.0186719745,
0.0391825624,
-0.0564753674,
-0.0619100258,
-0.0037833299,
-0.0293543879,
0.0146538736,
0.0311471,
0.010421657,
0.0562432148,
0.0553556494,
0.0208342895,
-0.0282136034,
0.0242256969,
0.0049462891,
0.0152468635,
0.0311137773,
-0.0909657031,
0.0104684932,
0.0366908833,
0.0122312941,
0.0316677392,
0.0524299368,
0.0139491875,
0.0452249199,
0.015769057,
-0.0520347357,
-0.0335512348,
-0.0174029693,
-0.0393429957,
0.0524154603,
-0.0212615598,
0.0128805889,
-0.0399648771,
-0.0112508051,
0.0646798685,
0.0480754338,
0.0286278278,
0.0024926797,
0.0284857918,
-0.0117388247,
0.032356713,
-0.0266067237,
-0.0491189808,
0.0636162013,
-0.0038984471,
-0.0478372797,
-0.0410342887,
-5.260616032e-33,
-0.0409103967,
-0.0758745149,
0.044259835,
0.0105618797,
-0.0576530471,
0.0039610928,
-0.07271716,
-0.0048395339,
-0.0036697888,
0.0379220732,
-0.0045398488,
0.0420223027,
0.008846839,
-0.0100808796,
-0.0062573981,
-0.0477060415,
0.026784936,
-0.0062549761,
-0.002093185,
0.0399286859,
0.0476737209,
0.0238206089,
0.0492157936,
-0.0756165609,
0.0301729478,
0.009214418,
0.0057432665,
0.0177835971,
0.027808845,
0.0098494953,
-0.019361509,
0.0498503335,
0.0286052153,
0.0069870003,
0.0090742428,
-0.0232472233,
-0.1105791926,
-0.0559742637,
-0.0407312103,
0.0306170676,
-0.0450823754,
-0.0267584976,
0.0272812918,
0.0072823032,
0.0318551362,
-0.0192829277,
0.0805218816,
-0.0136500821,
-0.037224669,
-0.0462071933,
-0.0141817816,
0.032131765,
-0.0404736586,
0.0045884186,
0.002645921,
0.0101985848,
0.0342056789,
-0.0443281829,
-0.0762905851,
0.0435910672,
-0.0098465094,
-0.0118596153,
0.0007222903,
-0.0098753767,
0.0578802675,
0.0360019878,
0.0013809962,
0.0247098692,
-0.0426444151,
0.053907048,
0.0201363415,
0.017366223,
0.0035227134,
0.021476768,
-0.004961432,
-0.0038598592,
-0.0626187772,
-0.0095824506,
0.0249752812,
0.0499621406,
-0.0162712242,
-0.0024543607,
-0.0416807905,
-0.004190878,
-0.0025193696,
0.0176070519,
-0.0039148913,
-0.02883563,
0.0020537484,
-0.015940154,
0.0041227876,
-0.0128242327,
-0.013268061,
-0.0462376438,
-0.0321585685,
0.0554459803,
0.0091534304,
0.0459972955,
0.0002658961,
0.0003220587,
0.008343922,
-0.0056992453,
0.0017434336,
-0.0281730797,
0.0429283194,
0.0143626845,
-0.005148768,
0.0737848356,
-0.0037097249,
-0.0016755114,
-0.0059473594,
-0.0006076538,
0.0217497591,
-0.01716814,
0.0221126229,
-0.0341086388,
-0.0303093605,
0.0238586068,
0.0377380475,
0.021062227,
0.0196999833,
0.0361177474,
-0.0012104729,
0.0194969587,
-0.0282062571,
-0.0204106197,
-0.0385139547,
0.0736686587,
-0.0110143162,
-0.0298050568,
-0.012388723,
0.0036232758,
2.845e-7,
-0.015497908,
0.0415773019,
0.0131826615,
0.0337003469,
0.0181861911,
0.0117654884,
-0.0243837237,
-0.0005137436,
-0.0242730509,
-0.0030324194,
0.0667409152,
0.0441807285,
-0.0291439015,
0.0315191709,
-0.0879969075,
0.0027766831,
-0.0182195101,
-0.0112484517,
-0.0386462286,
0.0140012633,
0.0533916168,
-0.0098184133,
0.0887989923,
0.0382756144,
0.0029469237,
-0.0869824961,
0.0242450871,
0.0127485143,
0.0203894712,
0.0218159053,
0.0318592079,
-0.0263753086,
-0.0513620488,
-0.0184123367,
-0.0177855939,
0.0424713977,
-0.0244518574,
0.0016786586,
-0.0399504788,
-0.0083305882,
-0.0302019194,
-0.0410450548,
-0.0058708629,
-0.016497232,
0.0720398799,
-0.0579219609,
-0.0379637629,
0.0135192312,
-0.0020470058,
-0.0434553586,
-0.0508222468,
0.0062431418,
-0.023455156,
-0.0168878008,
0.001285752,
-0.0115139075,
0.0018532505,
-0.080796577,
-0.0138123874,
0.0062562418,
-0.0229842253,
0.006288189,
-0.0432887152,
0.0067301812,
-0.0011313431,
-0.044456616,
0.0189517625,
2.248706918e-34,
-0.0075828782,
-0.0051492448,
-0.0289359353,
-0.0239866134,
0.0528217144,
-0.0035589151,
-0.0042870212,
0.0181886181,
0.062801145,
-0.0677871704,
-0.036556337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01927v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01927v2 | GateLoop: Fully Data-Controlled Linear Recurrence for Sequence Modeling | 2023-11-03T14:08:39 | 2024-01-27T14:52:52 | Tobias Katsch | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DS | Linear Recurrence has proven to be a powerful tool for modeling long
sequences efficiently. In this work, we show that existing models fail to take
full advantage of its potential. Motivated by this finding, we develop
GateLoop, a foundational sequence model that generalizes linear recurrent
models such as S4, S5, LRU and RetNet, by employing data-controlled state
transitions. Utilizing this theoretical advance, GateLoop empirically
outperforms existing models for auto-regressive language modeling. Our method
comes with a low-cost $O(l)$ recurrent mode and an efficient $O(l \log_{2} l)$
parallel mode making use of highly optimized associative scan implementations.
Furthermore, we derive an $O(l^2)$ surrogate attention mode, revealing
remarkable implications for Transformer and recently proposed architectures.
Specifically, we prove that our approach can be interpreted as providing
data-controlled relative-positional information to Attention. While many
existing models solely rely on data-controlled cumulative sums for context
aggregation, our findings suggest that incorporating data-controlled complex
cumulative products may be a crucial step towards more powerful sequence
models. | [
-0.0142633282,
0.0739869475,
-0.0026080534,
0.0391084887,
-0.0363363735,
-0.0038126605,
0.0119755222,
-0.0432702228,
-0.0395988561,
-0.0321617834,
0.003402428,
-0.0795607492,
0.0300240014,
0.0409020856,
0.0345731936,
-0.0206709169,
0.0329171307,
-0.0224782005,
-0.0085626682,
0.0007736336,
-0.0074744211,
-0.0047668531,
0.0088120652,
0.0282862987,
0.0431716293,
-0.0019680252,
-0.0104023907,
-0.0336606689,
-0.0011930626,
-0.0406694375,
0.0058439444,
0.0583046265,
0.031370692,
0.0347247645,
0.0000020264,
-0.0224616807,
-0.0023198712,
-0.0124282222,
0.0127985394,
0.0333410613,
-0.0046230396,
-0.0088474574,
-0.015985636,
0.0035624544,
-0.0171195008,
-0.0519897901,
0.066431649,
-0.0145786246,
0.04980978,
0.0831608996,
-0.0096562728,
-0.05987674,
0.0321773589,
-0.0834948346,
0.0109226704,
-0.0141850784,
0.0200103261,
-0.0094653992,
0.0209463816,
-0.0136982594,
-0.0476643853,
0.0520102717,
0.0390872285,
0.0083496291,
0.0015528523,
0.0233004447,
0.0182447042,
-0.0172277484,
-0.0294420905,
0.0471784808,
-0.0970106125,
-0.040913716,
0.0282918271,
-0.0066079637,
0.0092216674,
-0.0489990637,
-0.0484736077,
0.0455281399,
0.0170219261,
-0.004800465,
0.0147711169,
-0.0116771469,
0.0482922234,
-0.012781282,
-0.0533191897,
0.0009770753,
0.0267351959,
-0.0172431748,
-0.0612510666,
-0.0207906626,
-0.0095408512,
-0.0643210411,
0.0061420258,
0.0993574932,
-0.0070477254,
0.0210238975,
-0.0149108237,
-0.0429033563,
0.000292575,
-0.0151510434,
0.0311968252,
0.0473979637,
-0.0032950204,
0.0308178049,
-0.0023426667,
0.050532341,
-0.0388334133,
-0.0252930541,
-0.0217182357,
0.0304426327,
0.0091086524,
0.0331077352,
-0.0513047725,
0.0093257157,
-0.0209263079,
-0.0197251122,
-0.0324231647,
0.0461047404,
0.0242766123,
-0.0351848193,
-0.0007454881,
0.0010676851,
-0.023861479,
0.0114999563,
0.0449858457,
0.0338189453,
0.0014233675,
-0.0269210879,
0.0162444338,
-0.0481717698,
-0.0546245761,
0.0284027718,
0.0214427561,
-0.0268522929,
-0.0405093692,
0.0464260727,
0.0026646079,
-0.059334714,
-0.0146932779,
-0.0080079492,
-0.0534308963,
-0.0541899614,
0.0237142202,
-0.0753606334,
0.0059799887,
0.0005638939,
-0.0093412278,
-0.0185812023,
0.021434091,
0.0425118469,
0.0131221563,
0.0454177447,
0.0186287761,
-0.0474818833,
-0.0430208296,
0.0166335478,
0.0304167755,
0.0151834665,
0.0540471599,
0.0274710525,
-0.0327229425,
-0.0125114052,
0.0057845036,
0.0453445017,
0.0367331058,
-0.0160263386,
-0.0329799615,
-0.0101941917,
-0.0143813295,
0.0273163803,
0.018356679,
0.052421622,
-0.017722385,
-0.0247803368,
0.0460712239,
0.0324146599,
0.0165298749,
0.0850033388,
0.0329821073,
-0.0042464263,
-0.0161176771,
0.0069487663,
-0.0327682607,
0.0764018223,
0.0000132964,
0.0505788215,
0.059501972,
0.0403682776,
-0.0268534888,
-0.0192368645,
-0.0203394908,
-0.0074791973,
0.0286557488,
0.008805926,
0.0210735109,
0.0228759255,
-0.0722530782,
0.0182638131,
-0.0083181057,
-0.0660406202,
-0.0197483487,
-0.0244498681,
0.0152266202,
0.0324160457,
0.0627908185,
-0.0383910947,
-0.0216981154,
-0.0444068313,
0.0115977013,
0.0295044631,
0.0345287435,
0.0272155236,
-0.0098925019,
-0.069574222,
-0.0284938551,
0.0290031955,
-0.0292139854,
0.0626128018,
0.0065137837,
-0.0050258236,
0.0222139135,
0.0290580429,
-0.0085846018,
0.0065524322,
-0.0160578378,
-0.0334428027,
-0.0062827794,
-0.0117177693,
0.0362854563,
-0.0098894686,
0.0119485231,
0.0494063012,
0.0690525472,
-0.0337340757,
-0.0204752907,
0.0064198556,
-0.0938647613,
-0.0331448391,
0.03954757,
-0.0062492997,
-0.0012344174,
0.0293915458,
-0.0154360048,
-0.0780142322,
0.0699992552,
-0.1040144041,
0.0660378784,
-0.0383382812,
0.0086292494,
0.0312261526,
0.0752900764,
-0.0287319534,
0.0537548624,
-0.0595087744,
0.0116025051,
0.0290709194,
-0.0070262598,
-0.0409803912,
-0.0350093357,
-0.0450510085,
0.0045727552,
-0.0016217072,
0.0148026049,
0.0249517858,
-0.0109329401,
0.0152383987,
-0.0125839505,
-0.0299766585,
0.0135594746,
-0.0534516647,
0.0239394456,
0.0182205401,
0.0404091403,
0.0245460607,
-0.005023181,
-0.0489302762,
-0.0031461215,
0.0127182212,
0.0227911156,
0.0349373184,
-0.0166085828,
-0.0668135434,
-0.0563706718,
-0.0519126616,
0.0067932159,
0.031214118,
-0.0275984015,
-0.0376377814,
-0.0168791786,
-0.0207736082,
0.0028027,
0.0396403596,
-0.0339225866,
-0.0105396388,
-0.0182167422,
-0.0412276238,
0.0346649773,
0.0270809922,
0.0140669802,
0.0352067426,
0.0262777023,
-0.0281103123,
0.0167524051,
0.0306912232,
-0.0318972804,
0.0058601988,
0.0100967772,
0.0084751621,
-0.0141718769,
0.118530944,
-0.0162781347,
-0.005191104,
-0.0486597531,
-0.031531129,
0.0397821777,
-0.0157530513,
0.0081321262,
0.0018590796,
-0.0338010825,
0.0147000458,
-0.0406782664,
-0.0373422615,
0.0487855524,
-0.0375352614,
-0.02055596,
-0.0296668913,
0.0251084045,
-0.041733887,
0.0388752222,
0.0351101719,
0.0043012709,
0.0052174539,
-0.0048581972,
-0.0066328216,
0.0301691927,
-0.0253476873,
-0.0434443615,
0.1057336554,
-0.0234209895,
0.0155227939,
-0.0006244388,
-0.0099095795,
-0.032460846,
0.0031759259,
-0.0043218569,
0.0154430075,
0.0397854447,
-0.0523800887,
-0.0461807549,
0.0387948044,
0.0464558452,
0.0753687024,
0.0093597565,
0.0205659978,
-0.0214238726,
0.0401603468,
0.0584468171,
-0.0083157197,
0.0402005352,
-0.017635921,
-0.0144268572,
0.0448000059,
0.0397926867,
0.027966965,
-0.0533439144,
0.0098172063,
0.0263054073,
-0.0397088639,
-0.0177475661,
0.0491957851,
-0.0003036638,
-0.0763019174,
-0.0382472798,
0.1150091812,
-0.0045896326,
-0.0719303787,
0.0153781977,
0.0370581299,
0.02984244,
0.0306222774,
-0.0030740339,
-0.0578322299,
-0.0294483621,
-0.020096492,
-0.0223101303,
0.0402750038,
-0.0267269351,
-0.0187623817,
-0.0646052361,
0.0038518545,
0.0229058526,
-0.0646785572,
-0.0472609326,
-0.0172426067,
-0.0064566256,
0.0098910825,
-0.0137624769,
0.0477469042,
-0.0239142254,
-0.0166325085,
0.0176715106,
-0.0026623437,
0.0067238952,
0.0234296676,
0.0129076242,
0.0251324736,
0.0872205794,
0.0165244788,
0.0197187867,
-0.0429909416,
0.0299862325,
-0.013047508,
0.0030910843,
0.0108620264,
-0.0263464134,
-0.0130084958,
-0.0212593488,
0.0130208852,
0.0286102407,
-0.0753841251,
0.0084975557,
-0.035753645,
0.0850605369,
0.0180059839,
-0.0273796655,
-0.022378847,
-0.0046236939,
0.0100064958,
0.0494130105,
0.0636211485,
-0.0325035267,
-0.0642814487,
0.0090887602,
-0.0103915613,
-0.0474103503,
-0.0182313323,
-0.0237783678,
0.0412669554,
-0.0567231923,
-0.0558947325,
-0.0381126031,
-0.0064567309,
0.0145383216,
-0.0086542694,
-0.0275024083,
0.0471560024,
-0.0415539257,
-0.0855596587,
-0.0097782444,
-0.0436355434,
0.0420071818,
-0.0357097723,
0.0126404762,
0.0035498925,
-0.0114907315,
-0.0083753215,
0.0341287144,
-0.1394449919,
-0.0755884349,
0.0196341462,
0.0671821907,
0.0187831707,
0.019868901,
0.0053480389,
-0.0267302338,
0.034477707,
-0.0090988483,
0.0081170686,
0.0366594531,
0.0189307481,
-0.0079024779,
0.001351061,
0.0346955582,
-0.0188881569,
0.0335697979,
0.0323634818,
0.0417218134,
-0.0230299924,
-0.0578351691,
-0.0066232351,
-0.0461223461,
0.030861564,
0.0090414248,
0.0254797563,
0.0286702886,
0.027803706,
0.0032793831,
0.0282126907,
-0.0485256687,
0.003260297,
0.0114456965,
-0.0131915528,
0.0042887894,
-0.0165165812,
0.0123392595,
-0.0269915331,
-0.021360727,
0.0360179991,
-0.032894101,
-0.0129294191,
0.0164065026,
-0.011241504,
-0.0137290228,
0.0146397548,
-0.0111508705,
0.0429903641,
0.0027324334,
0.0382217467,
0.0058917026,
0.0450306349,
-0.011151839,
0.0318829902,
-0.0826651827,
0.0122076543,
-0.02982351,
-0.0035878923,
0.0925407708,
-0.0271246042,
0.0581638813,
0.0131546874,
0.0252669621,
-0.0525586382,
0.0376239643,
-0.0072727124,
-0.0359402373,
0.0056167692,
0.0465633906,
-0.0117410058,
0.012706764,
0.0847049132,
0.0245067775,
0.02517532,
0.0204045046,
0.0159824751,
-0.0103964843,
-0.0509277359,
-0.0213547163,
0.0169274919,
-0.0368772522,
-0.0335417129,
-0.0416316949,
-0.0845804662,
0.0368944854,
0.0028036074,
0.0307890307,
-0.0154984184,
0.0386128128,
0.0109477453,
-0.0021506576,
0.01199657,
0.0019394406,
0.0337255113,
-0.0060002604,
-0.0542125814,
-0.0363467075,
-6.437377346e-33,
-0.0130409934,
-0.0116547607,
0.0135700461,
-0.0066939299,
-0.0228623003,
0.0259100292,
-0.088094078,
-0.005866657,
0.0080293296,
-0.0335490033,
-0.0036677639,
0.0135767302,
-0.0071690767,
0.0546867177,
0.0088934302,
-0.0080022933,
0.0408418812,
0.022773793,
-0.0091169886,
0.0425051004,
0.0046668141,
0.034774337,
0.0527477674,
0.0067032203,
-0.0085840309,
-0.0381717011,
0.0161215477,
-0.0185033381,
-0.0193443615,
0.02988787,
-0.0116034225,
0.0205049571,
0.0295910928,
-0.0498547703,
-0.0642920285,
0.0343818292,
-0.0821473598,
-0.0030706003,
0.0073295278,
-0.0125745814,
-0.0238181502,
-0.0192719083,
0.0426283404,
0.002599,
0.0327377506,
-0.024449436,
0.0068730633,
-0.0009652615,
-0.0813086033,
-0.0374745429,
-0.0366916135,
0.0118328929,
-0.0134738442,
-0.0190214235,
0.0367440619,
0.0197032262,
-0.0195872653,
0.0071637235,
-0.0445374437,
-0.0091114212,
0.0056230235,
0.0997915268,
0.0671890527,
0.0495993383,
0.0388104245,
0.0046780449,
0.0438208021,
-0.0122029521,
-0.0562762395,
0.0161617287,
0.0181946885,
-0.0006750528,
0.0361114815,
-0.0269930679,
0.0526561476,
-0.0132806813,
-0.0432969294,
-0.0417575426,
0.0269894432,
0.0707308501,
0.0374569632,
0.0476034582,
-0.0179768652,
-0.0089534959,
-0.0132532828,
-0.0134614082,
-0.0393353365,
-0.0054593068,
0.0124394847,
0.0387243293,
0.0160490945,
0.027170917,
0.0327617601,
-0.0144230053,
0.0243566483,
0.031372495,
0.0300012026,
0.0080715669,
-0.0010357592,
0.032864701,
-0.059158206,
0.0064091445,
-0.0024654192,
0.0054675718,
-0.025781339,
0.0028152557,
0.0248727296,
0.0419481285,
-0.0547414832,
-0.0346553884,
-0.0803809911,
0.0271009933,
-0.0153375408,
0.0417531393,
0.0543090478,
-0.0020366127,
0.0016672243,
0.0698615462,
-0.0273746792,
-0.0146230236,
-0.0093496842,
0.0019863613,
-0.0053682346,
0.0187680349,
-0.0275809225,
-0.0345311277,
-0.0535946935,
0.0493634641,
0.0371581465,
-0.0653569102,
-0.0287104752,
0.0301265214,
2.779e-7,
0.01639417,
0.0188071672,
0.0822017193,
0.0325507335,
0.052879449,
-0.0008989903,
0.0249024406,
0.0447801091,
0.0063455645,
-0.0125377597,
0.0165924281,
0.0156049142,
0.0462993309,
-0.0310897324,
-0.0792795643,
-0.0322094932,
-0.0889202878,
0.041187305,
-0.028236201,
-0.040492937,
0.0029157915,
0.093779169,
0.0045392122,
0.0066389511,
0.0214045569,
0.0027552641,
0.0343903564,
0.0198054686,
0.0121786222,
-0.0203584936,
0.0288000815,
0.021398047,
-0.0388359763,
-0.0351301059,
-0.028384814,
0.0365568101,
-0.011749668,
0.0654893965,
-0.0049381312,
-0.0552579425,
0.0373064578,
-0.0214049332,
-0.0441579781,
-0.006672746,
0.0411830284,
-0.031025786,
0.0287508033,
-0.0355856195,
-0.0175378695,
0.0249000881,
-0.0247302018,
-0.0057670297,
0.0027723585,
0.0283962954,
0.0223607738,
-0.0294135045,
0.0032615666,
-0.085781917,
-0.0414921753,
-0.0111152278,
-0.0529428236,
0.0381102785,
-0.0911605954,
-0.0257286709,
0.0251986496,
-0.0156980231,
-0.0356224328,
2.59495383e-34,
0.0468917936,
-0.0468419939,
0.0053647165,
0.0158829428,
0.0196449012,
-0.0328144766,
-0.0398279615,
0.0390747897,
0.0267505255,
-0.0686586201,
-0.0742532685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04925v1 | Investigating Deep-Learning NLP for Automating the Extraction of Oncology Efficacy Endpoints from Scientific Literature | 2023-11-03T14:01:54 | 2023-11-03T14:01:54 | Aline Gendrin-Brokmann, Eden Harrison, Julianne Noveras, Leonidas Souliotis, Harris Vince, Ines Smit, Francisco Costa, David Milward, Sashka Dimitrievska, Paul Metcalfe, Emilie Louvet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Benchmarking drug efficacy is a critical step in clinical trial design and
planning. The challenge is that much of the data on efficacy endpoints is
stored in scientific papers in free text form, so extraction of such data is
currently a largely manual task. Our objective is to automate this task as much
as possible. In this study we have developed and optimised a framework to
extract efficacy endpoints from text in scientific papers, using a machine
learning approach. Our machine learning model predicts 25 classes associated
with efficacy endpoints and leads to high F1 scores (harmonic mean of precision
and recall) of 96.4% on the test set, and 93.9% and 93.7% on two case studies.
These methods were evaluated against - and showed strong agreement with -
subject matter experts and show significant promise in the future of automating
the extraction of clinical endpoints from free text. Clinical information
extraction from text data is currently a laborious manual task which scales
poorly and is prone to human error. Demonstrating the ability to extract
efficacy endpoints automatically shows great promise for accelerating clinical
trial design moving forwards. | [
0.0521769039,
0.0518412925,
0.0109566711,
-0.0317247063,
-0.0237211492,
0.0025230506,
0.0094657913,
-0.0310089681,
-0.0083136102,
-0.0198417455,
-0.0053320318,
-0.0172341969,
-0.0102234799,
0.0634323135,
-0.012110305,
-0.001963615,
0.0062315748,
0.036109373,
0.0476033837,
0.0111362282,
-0.0035754757,
0.0248620883,
-0.0316322707,
0.0267328117,
0.0137171624,
0.0078395503,
0.0641529188,
-0.0187228043,
0.0018813324,
-0.0771880671,
0.0282465573,
0.0183243137,
-0.0363767482,
0.0693237707,
0.0000017772,
-0.0684686303,
-0.0346039981,
0.0175189003,
-0.0210471507,
-0.0071684332,
0.0824816525,
-0.0595215373,
0.0151928943,
0.0010160751,
-0.0133564146,
0.0152918678,
0.0068112165,
0.0597221591,
-0.004912388,
0.0741000921,
-0.0143294828,
-0.0098358635,
0.0775299445,
-0.0156127829,
-0.0061285123,
-0.0447679982,
0.044410944,
-0.005922731,
0.0074921413,
-0.0006269463,
0.0530670136,
0.0650277361,
-0.0006757939,
-0.0079465602,
0.0438866876,
0.0386021696,
-0.0300393142,
-0.0096049225,
-0.0028614069,
0.0740063116,
-0.0056880717,
-0.0112604601,
0.0209522732,
-0.0407649465,
0.0002151179,
0.0114125917,
-0.0352084674,
0.0106458291,
-0.0064213309,
-0.0006481466,
-0.0111072036,
0.0242924672,
0.027469134,
0.0045987037,
-0.001180202,
0.014047456,
-0.023473708,
-0.0221917015,
0.0559915379,
0.0029483656,
-0.0118493745,
-0.003298881,
0.03735267,
0.0128152985,
-0.0152447335,
0.035570886,
0.0211202614,
-0.0632636994,
0.0830828846,
-0.0681117326,
0.0306714922,
-0.0412822999,
-0.0201548636,
0.030269511,
-0.0484510958,
-0.0181768127,
0.0044335453,
0.055600509,
0.0082772691,
0.0310982931,
-0.0110966014,
-0.0183821395,
0.0064252433,
0.0378758237,
0.0265892819,
-0.0194309,
-0.0807281658,
-0.0352286696,
-0.0171016976,
0.0096083563,
0.0400744639,
0.0657194033,
-0.0385067426,
-0.0030741973,
0.0168624669,
0.0375435427,
0.0028311827,
0.0103588412,
-0.0110121928,
-0.0670387372,
0.0505330749,
-0.0262232162,
0.0255484805,
-0.0153773325,
0.0553576462,
0.0507281348,
0.0067893607,
-0.0213793013,
0.0160232931,
-0.0554262437,
-0.0147861559,
-0.0489656441,
0.0091909878,
-0.0619478561,
0.0438027568,
-0.0034301169,
0.0109099448,
-0.0547727756,
-0.0117223542,
-0.0011354277,
-0.0293059498,
0.0554221161,
-0.042449493,
-0.0144784087,
0.0757453814,
-0.0024986442,
-0.0079658283,
0.0150140934,
0.0478433445,
0.0197469089,
0.02729748,
-0.0030892717,
0.0040539876,
-0.0198305771,
0.0258880239,
-0.0589951947,
0.0328134373,
-0.0033282528,
-0.0254277717,
0.0830167308,
-0.0545463786,
0.0289991871,
0.0158319809,
-0.0209290721,
0.0224943738,
0.0566011257,
0.0436873734,
0.0073519861,
0.001308652,
0.0083476435,
0.0206030607,
-0.0405375808,
-0.029078858,
0.0141071165,
-0.0071401591,
0.0325987078,
0.0004111026,
-0.0136451041,
0.002275344,
-0.0580409802,
-0.0385512561,
-0.003877982,
-0.0259245448,
-0.0221754313,
0.0508006401,
-0.0045314101,
-0.0498783663,
-0.0361028351,
0.0329600684,
0.000715895,
0.0082711047,
-0.0199308004,
-0.0387290828,
0.0002441264,
0.0296813324,
-0.0591828562,
-0.0027029633,
-0.0203140434,
-0.0071116802,
-0.018373888,
-0.0040161931,
0.0016618686,
0.0079905773,
-0.0109914625,
-0.0064027286,
-0.0260230303,
-0.0031137667,
-0.0242862999,
0.0108972145,
0.0054980852,
-0.0156618208,
-0.0526159555,
-0.0744449869,
0.0691190809,
-0.0124989739,
-0.0606116243,
-0.0060552368,
-0.0008920273,
0.0094395997,
0.0106675709,
-0.0213520434,
0.0292716753,
0.0458917283,
-0.03280681,
-0.0684923306,
-0.02117032,
0.0205906872,
0.0187359173,
-0.0069750152,
-0.0492402948,
-0.0203549005,
0.0345652439,
-0.0576202944,
0.0381621383,
-0.016977407,
0.0089777661,
-0.0235020462,
0.0381983854,
0.0010653307,
0.0207823776,
0.0175130516,
-0.0565182418,
0.0087939138,
0.0098152729,
0.0140061621,
0.0156894531,
-0.0786885321,
0.0105920518,
0.0051581813,
-0.0139823817,
-0.0017900384,
-0.0363248251,
-0.0004225705,
-0.0007613248,
0.0060196067,
-0.0331991948,
0.0038936511,
-0.0868492424,
0.0169726629,
0.0252668113,
0.0179048218,
0.0363925509,
-0.0114495121,
0.0053827185,
-0.0233206861,
-0.0443281643,
-0.0405782163,
-0.0177226346,
0.011212864,
0.0634422675,
0.050604023,
-0.0027955838,
-0.0486780666,
-0.0172802731,
-0.0463258214,
0.0498665459,
0.0409356467,
-0.0141692115,
0.0520570204,
0.0236577839,
0.0081245806,
0.0158440098,
0.0174693428,
-0.0071996069,
0.0165499169,
0.0017368783,
-0.0497583412,
0.0844988301,
0.0239301007,
0.0346068665,
0.021855833,
0.0420958884,
-0.0389251895,
-0.0143867945,
-0.0762828887,
-0.0237196926,
0.0540198423,
-0.0272465516,
0.0293615758,
0.0574209727,
0.0161546376,
0.0253621507,
-0.0090059154,
-0.023344012,
-0.0088474518,
-0.0228980668,
-0.0622874349,
0.0676859617,
-0.0167984813,
0.0199240558,
0.0129933264,
-0.0398335941,
0.1209516972,
0.0237556901,
0.0376475863,
-0.0494125523,
0.0401813164,
-0.0145893265,
-0.0176871475,
0.018866431,
-0.0024784056,
0.0127894683,
0.0046800771,
0.0231243465,
0.0011051017,
0.0105098085,
-0.0262775738,
0.0509056859,
-0.0474522039,
0.0352125093,
0.0064064725,
-0.0110369055,
-0.0188394096,
-0.00559902,
-0.0100679072,
0.0265536029,
-0.0047068321,
-0.0051916149,
-0.0569448434,
-0.0240988154,
-0.0041231974,
0.0535382368,
-0.034015175,
-0.0144195752,
0.0013921757,
-0.0004902066,
0.0803286433,
-0.0603896677,
0.011247295,
-0.000925587,
0.0368234329,
0.0758135766,
-0.0123036541,
0.047013402,
-0.0261711329,
-0.0133244377,
-0.0227593277,
-0.0700251013,
0.0348529294,
0.038577579,
0.0196315236,
-0.0549901426,
0.0036800611,
0.0947370157,
0.0114381863,
-0.0210372191,
0.002430758,
0.0212863311,
-0.0457155891,
-0.0356255732,
0.0189487152,
-0.0610594302,
-0.0213900097,
-0.0472735949,
0.0477511548,
-0.0438883156,
-0.0336890854,
0.0086895376,
-0.0328173675,
0.0026828956,
-0.0156969558,
-0.0563662946,
-0.0047368864,
-0.0802411363,
-0.0157238785,
-0.056794066,
-0.0193737186,
-0.0092364633,
0.0193962306,
-0.0310341623,
0.0146318944,
-0.0985276699,
-0.0916442946,
0.0134282541,
-0.046256382,
0.0208740756,
0.037273623,
0.0260734931,
-0.0200441107,
0.0102163479,
0.0014571636,
-0.0295700207,
-0.038709946,
-0.001422176,
0.1136280522,
-0.0028004122,
0.0178136844,
-0.0135091515,
0.0629294366,
-0.0669781566,
-0.0018610085,
-0.0270274878,
0.0592326447,
-0.0103563946,
-0.0520667359,
-0.0554064512,
0.0262960158,
0.0031246135,
0.0591736436,
-0.0155643458,
-0.0209363457,
-0.037452627,
-0.0132011371,
0.0277620219,
-0.0844070539,
-0.0330014117,
0.0106218951,
-0.0263083391,
0.0266276039,
-0.0639249384,
-0.0528844781,
0.0668810904,
-0.0499044582,
0.0205088612,
0.0165083874,
-0.0430460982,
0.0051578945,
-0.0433377586,
0.0420600697,
0.0443263389,
0.0328508466,
-0.0463826321,
-0.0328207128,
0.0725922212,
0.0054158154,
-0.0176438875,
0.043045707,
-0.0043910886,
-0.024123216,
-0.0346854813,
0.0214189421,
0.0160592031,
-0.0058403169,
0.0153238308,
-0.0488111265,
0.0748271793,
0.0325334854,
-0.0010982372,
-0.0885515362,
-0.0105103487,
-0.0153329736,
-0.0120740635,
-0.0257278048,
-0.0394708663,
0.0470618419,
-0.010575748,
0.0089646997,
0.0062817242,
-0.0205676835,
0.0692625418,
0.0534225628,
0.0632866919,
-0.0202947613,
-0.0479709618,
-0.033158835,
-0.0190088227,
0.0017463579,
0.0275301244,
0.0000565468,
0.0435515419,
0.0125794234,
0.0339078307,
-0.0425909311,
0.0465610065,
-0.0433090068,
-0.0157501232,
-0.0784782842,
0.0172747858,
0.0000993738,
0.035201855,
0.0491890274,
-0.0246361718,
-0.0240152534,
-0.0155202793,
-0.033575777,
0.0135909254,
-0.0143050607,
-0.0105232242,
-0.0032720545,
0.049373161,
-0.0061529451,
0.0618775599,
-0.0628488362,
0.0072653568,
-0.0733931363,
-0.0138876447,
0.0329761356,
-0.0158622619,
0.0489843898,
-0.048830092,
-0.0081392433,
-0.0568950586,
0.0298849307,
-0.0145401973,
0.0296489466,
0.0365423895,
0.0205305219,
-0.0057135164,
-0.0576494522,
0.0357026756,
0.0254642051,
0.032027889,
-0.0005838195,
-0.0462462232,
-0.0444399156,
-0.0195227265,
0.0114354091,
0.0261158347,
-0.0474723168,
-0.0201273151,
-0.0151878102,
-0.0080896877,
0.0602332242,
0.0329909734,
0.0137825673,
-0.0076474231,
-0.001971439,
0.0422348641,
-0.0040659606,
-0.0202449504,
-0.0708665624,
0.0322045349,
0.0294807032,
-0.0345776565,
-0.0274192858,
-5.421801287e-33,
0.0559285022,
-0.0163926706,
-0.0172944404,
0.0139300255,
0.0292947367,
0.0301586017,
-0.0659365356,
-0.0266522951,
0.0093699712,
0.0611565188,
-0.0120586948,
-0.0281860456,
0.0006402048,
0.0089851841,
0.0070453514,
0.0060458141,
0.0080233645,
-0.0375996977,
0.0064732246,
0.0117900157,
0.0102892295,
0.0660668835,
0.051883366,
-0.0574723929,
0.0295199007,
0.0425928533,
-0.0042174831,
-0.0302786548,
-0.0110273669,
0.062293984,
-0.0334547162,
0.0457741134,
0.0239068028,
-0.0511692166,
0.0064386134,
-0.0264173653,
-0.049491901,
0.0129700433,
-0.0244809594,
-0.0007269838,
-0.0594765842,
0.0182870235,
0.0822689682,
-0.0203634407,
-0.0106343543,
-0.0257467404,
0.0702245831,
0.0004351847,
-0.0393644646,
-0.0708117634,
-0.0780840665,
0.0357429199,
0.0013587817,
0.0053574326,
0.0051055602,
0.0305124838,
-0.0197806843,
0.0394887812,
-0.0203708224,
-0.0070553487,
-0.0009415948,
0.0264081955,
0.0297033861,
-0.0281629469,
-0.0243510269,
0.0595900938,
-0.0191148706,
0.0120573929,
0.021926526,
-0.0186901465,
0.0379557312,
0.0263483115,
0.0429987237,
0.0224417336,
0.061045941,
0.0056509702,
-0.0980484635,
0.0517008267,
-0.0581742041,
-0.0067194509,
0.0076868054,
-0.0202391464,
-0.0165178981,
0.0027167511,
-0.0012299415,
-0.0044966158,
-0.0142112961,
-0.0094712358,
0.022362927,
-0.0141827725,
-0.0352938958,
0.0548033081,
0.0017906179,
-0.0270923879,
-0.0117616449,
0.002540445,
0.0315231979,
0.0619665347,
-0.0272027012,
-0.0407385081,
-0.0457968973,
-0.0070198262,
0.0064758318,
-0.0296883602,
0.0465911813,
-0.0052242409,
0.038036786,
-0.0495101549,
-0.0135870278,
-0.0183330178,
-0.0299988985,
0.007629618,
0.0328883044,
0.0473145172,
0.001584881,
0.0318648927,
-0.0042773755,
0.085741587,
0.0044738133,
-0.0097339274,
-0.0076709981,
0.0112084216,
0.0503240563,
0.0071117096,
-0.0660289377,
-0.016302906,
-0.0199748855,
0.0136825023,
-0.0199099518,
-0.0440114774,
-0.0204060264,
-0.0091011198,
2.562e-7,
0.116692178,
0.0316918604,
0.0312099997,
-0.0227685124,
0.0054717287,
0.017504774,
-0.0072074849,
0.0065561389,
-0.0041441577,
-0.0326738358,
0.0854371414,
-0.0216754731,
0.0547581501,
0.0045199348,
-0.0715502575,
-0.0609760508,
-0.0446265861,
-0.041282475,
-0.0257509481,
-0.0147527447,
0.045290228,
0.0210726131,
-0.0151071446,
-0.0207011402,
-0.0105105396,
0.0052803373,
0.0019107087,
-0.0373975858,
0.0430653989,
0.0689469948,
0.0361119024,
-0.0214583687,
0.0068386807,
0.0551981479,
-0.0370394886,
-0.0107934512,
-0.005447547,
0.0447395444,
-0.019393459,
-0.019118838,
0.0428202637,
-0.0142527539,
0.0670966431,
-0.0390646383,
0.0179385431,
-0.0899736062,
-0.0496619977,
-0.0291134696,
-0.0126306927,
0.0002628136,
0.0934754014,
-0.0386068821,
-0.0100226086,
0.0379328616,
0.0037582132,
0.0174339954,
-0.0362928659,
-0.0480824523,
-0.0058076084,
0.0647481307,
-0.0302276183,
0.0013749449,
0.0179519877,
-0.01765991,
-0.0014960389,
-0.0445923172,
0.0148891127,
2.084983973e-34,
0.0481551215,
0.0125897666,
0.0265125819,
0.0365318097,
0.0289998278,
0.0114839943,
0.0377047062,
0.0099691125,
-0.0287005771,
-0.0663304329,
0.0084729791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01918v1 | Large Language Models Illuminate a Progressive Pathway to Artificial Healthcare Assistant: A Review | 2023-11-03T13:51:36 | 2023-11-03T13:51:36 | Mingze Yuan, Peng Bao, Jiajia Yuan, Yunhao Shen, Zifan Chen, Yi Xie, Jie Zhao, Yang Chen, Li Zhang, Lin Shen, Bin Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the rapid development of artificial intelligence, large language models
(LLMs) have shown promising capabilities in mimicking human-level language
comprehension and reasoning. This has sparked significant interest in applying
LLMs to enhance various aspects of healthcare, ranging from medical education
to clinical decision support. However, medicine involves multifaceted data
modalities and nuanced reasoning skills, presenting challenges for integrating
LLMs. This paper provides a comprehensive review on the applications and
implications of LLMs in medicine. It begins by examining the fundamental
applications of general-purpose and specialized LLMs, demonstrating their
utilities in knowledge retrieval, research support, clinical workflow
automation, and diagnostic assistance. Recognizing the inherent multimodality
of medicine, the review then focuses on multimodal LLMs, investigating their
ability to process diverse data types like medical imaging and EHRs to augment
diagnostic accuracy. To address LLMs' limitations regarding personalization and
complex clinical reasoning, the paper explores the emerging development of
LLM-powered autonomous agents for healthcare. Furthermore, it summarizes the
evaluation methodologies for assessing LLMs' reliability and safety in medical
contexts. Overall, this review offers an extensive analysis on the
transformative potential of LLMs in modern medicine. It also highlights the
pivotal need for continuous optimizations and ethical oversight before these
models can be effectively integrated into clinical practice. Visit
https://github.com/mingze-yuan/Awesome-LLM-Healthcare for an accompanying
GitHub repository containing latest papers. | [
0.0426961519,
0.0501357205,
-0.0154334186,
-0.0024016669,
-0.0469125025,
0.0263654999,
0.0214585941,
0.0418502651,
0.052752085,
-0.0008220182,
0.0149889309,
-0.0456578992,
-0.0271366276,
0.0408810675,
0.0002776014,
-0.0363724977,
0.0193274561,
-0.0063329125,
0.0519554876,
-0.0018745752,
-0.0408999771,
-0.0010732807,
-0.0280109029,
0.0648441389,
0.0117480503,
0.0018316414,
0.0184811484,
-0.0314344652,
0.0200623777,
-0.067485027,
-0.0444212332,
0.0115008997,
0.0056689512,
-0.0033310752,
0.000002392,
-0.0803110525,
-0.0234206188,
0.0335140303,
-0.0481194742,
-0.0831277147,
0.0467773229,
-0.0304956399,
0.0023484181,
-0.0004166447,
-0.0375853702,
-0.0032223987,
0.0289106052,
0.0188944954,
0.0346066095,
0.0621659942,
-0.0089210672,
-0.0035413809,
0.047318209,
-0.002345341,
0.0210868567,
-0.0607783385,
0.0645214319,
0.0101703247,
0.0650754198,
0.0032549314,
0.0182496663,
0.0648797154,
-0.0089490144,
0.0225343928,
-0.0105001628,
0.0355624221,
0.0192625597,
-0.0441219434,
-0.0036252481,
0.0307089686,
-0.0013509846,
0.009490435,
0.0252070054,
0.0114517249,
-0.0337094665,
-0.0071001407,
-0.0379494503,
0.0247167572,
-0.0367058069,
-0.0136467824,
0.0034797676,
-0.0220581405,
0.0444795005,
0.0177250281,
-0.0459147915,
0.0270814225,
0.003937765,
-0.0059649604,
0.0282567628,
-0.0267934091,
-0.0246596411,
-0.0256322511,
0.0368793197,
0.0962309837,
-0.0579638779,
0.0177230071,
-0.0007210195,
-0.0217506438,
0.1038979515,
-0.0715963468,
0.018874472,
0.0011221039,
-0.0061273007,
0.035423439,
-0.0013048293,
-0.0049455157,
-0.0645325705,
0.0656225309,
-0.0523364022,
0.0006314833,
-0.0390447155,
-0.0181911681,
-0.0038177411,
0.0328788683,
-0.0056728399,
-0.0107296752,
-0.0733262077,
-0.0007750866,
-0.021365948,
0.0293381494,
-0.0053447811,
0.0398374051,
0.0003542311,
-0.0060823062,
-0.0533615537,
-0.0022481391,
-0.0008312098,
0.0189746786,
-0.0238127951,
-0.0210568625,
0.0462303981,
0.0117492843,
-0.010450271,
-0.0240189526,
0.0350904241,
0.1032435596,
0.023075588,
-0.0423740484,
-0.0038215138,
-0.0514361449,
-0.0267541632,
-0.0560914204,
0.0345042013,
-0.0557768159,
0.0365472883,
0.0288150143,
-0.0080210855,
-0.0550206527,
0.0222092289,
0.0139201796,
-0.0514631458,
0.0726342648,
-0.0347036459,
0.0236826614,
0.0261031035,
0.023360379,
0.0013784886,
0.0041990913,
0.0374588296,
-0.0396645367,
0.0176466163,
-0.0272810478,
0.015801765,
-0.0158776809,
-0.0094129276,
-0.0472266674,
-0.0059864987,
0.0131052202,
-0.0052651255,
0.0778699592,
-0.0584376827,
0.0624255687,
0.0366743915,
-0.0167685114,
0.0397124998,
0.0804408342,
0.0255967267,
0.0028889768,
0.0398284867,
-0.0446165912,
0.0016290778,
-0.0403013453,
0.0083191041,
0.0087753115,
-0.0203797203,
-0.0193379987,
-0.0307976436,
0.0105530387,
-0.0175218582,
-0.0621294379,
-0.0717806518,
-0.0238378104,
0.0015514806,
0.0164912157,
0.0525968224,
-0.0610822104,
-0.004131279,
0.0273584649,
0.0500224791,
-0.0220771302,
-0.0393062867,
-0.1010847911,
0.0013085877,
0.09601558,
0.0393706597,
-0.048776038,
-0.0313072205,
-0.0129589885,
-0.009930782,
-0.0091313915,
-0.0014315852,
-0.001346958,
0.0026821904,
-0.0422401838,
-0.0032279736,
0.0529573672,
-0.000118315,
-0.0091647543,
-0.0413710363,
0.032185249,
-0.0364938527,
-0.0187249798,
-0.0032777109,
0.0313275494,
-0.0736286044,
-0.0133541813,
-0.0053868559,
0.0318705291,
0.0307940636,
0.0170498751,
0.0026361134,
0.0377708375,
0.0379792415,
-0.0438699685,
-0.0415488072,
0.0105357412,
-0.0118153514,
0.0139711369,
0.0046165399,
-0.0108450707,
0.0034800018,
-0.0313379914,
-0.01580563,
-0.0179061759,
-0.0281476025,
-0.0442193635,
0.003396512,
-0.0055463873,
0.0175854191,
0.0244678855,
0.0030326603,
-0.0538394786,
0.0362544507,
-0.0213715974,
-0.0064983866,
0.0191358645,
-0.0211379267,
0.0189845562,
-0.0201086793,
-0.0332325064,
0.0102625256,
-0.0050200904,
0.0258225352,
-0.0101845181,
0.0017767908,
-0.0013352047,
-0.0322192945,
-0.0842367634,
-0.011655177,
0.0410812683,
-0.0226990785,
-0.0065523987,
-0.0006580455,
0.0049664294,
-0.0076116202,
-0.0028472557,
0.0206482019,
0.0557620898,
0.0115794493,
0.0335294791,
0.0527434647,
-0.0295116995,
-0.0130614983,
-0.0011931194,
-0.055550199,
0.019191632,
0.0046877316,
0.0109644495,
-0.0085543925,
-0.0225218497,
-0.0442433059,
0.0108558917,
-0.0065640057,
-0.02760645,
0.0205691643,
-0.0451489575,
-0.0329367481,
0.0874156356,
-0.0193997305,
0.0320596062,
0.0548841022,
-0.0034645959,
-0.0005975472,
0.02534144,
-0.0374886356,
-0.0397710875,
0.0102530066,
-0.0351056792,
-0.015009569,
0.0667752102,
0.023521712,
0.0076112882,
-0.0328307226,
0.0110792574,
-0.0276241936,
0.008283034,
-0.0469213463,
0.0058064093,
-0.0389238298,
0.0707297176,
0.0006381217,
-0.0281933695,
0.1241965145,
0.0124144834,
0.049452614,
-0.0516469516,
-0.0381931067,
-0.0548663326,
0.0244193785,
-0.0073546455,
0.0416352339,
-0.0065605328,
0.0112061789,
0.0092281392,
-0.0065947929,
-0.0355932638,
-0.081509307,
0.0796078444,
-0.0275932364,
0.0303327367,
0.0150988987,
-0.0391399376,
-0.0461463407,
0.0187484603,
-0.0321689211,
-0.005998713,
-0.0262238905,
0.0428614095,
-0.0506169014,
0.0285604559,
0.0120535754,
0.0353272744,
0.0298816022,
-0.0233044885,
-0.0128158173,
-0.0184491873,
-0.0135351196,
-0.000613858,
0.0034839713,
-0.0000495937,
0.0579194389,
0.0503778309,
-0.0120951822,
0.0157096963,
-0.0090087345,
0.0291104503,
-0.0053485697,
-0.0120223435,
0.0082291793,
0.0215038508,
0.0226549748,
-0.0651040822,
0.0036508965,
0.0979964957,
0.032368876,
-0.0482754894,
0.0290497113,
-0.028947236,
-0.0780821368,
-0.0145141026,
0.0081758555,
-0.0628678128,
-0.0280393045,
-0.0244843252,
0.0339567922,
-0.0470246114,
-0.0374374241,
0.0271641072,
-0.0169980545,
0.055560261,
0.001237161,
-0.0283687059,
-0.0461627878,
-0.0378930047,
0.0170899406,
0.0025286551,
0.0094970157,
-0.0046288432,
-0.0061380095,
-0.048189763,
-0.0026379237,
-0.038981352,
-0.0729092285,
0.0473751277,
-0.0215412639,
0.0318063349,
0.0570038781,
0.0520172678,
-0.0240296032,
-0.054361172,
-0.0406746492,
0.03249567,
0.0361525118,
-0.0138835767,
0.050895527,
0.0209294539,
-0.0020555665,
-0.0659584925,
0.0296223667,
-0.0247837435,
-0.026589321,
-0.0160309039,
0.108755067,
-0.0687616989,
-0.0279942434,
-0.080481112,
0.0080803959,
0.0178143103,
0.0484370589,
-0.0237404127,
-0.0206503943,
-0.0270897057,
0.0198257808,
0.0380056165,
0.0241915677,
-0.0362876356,
0.053366635,
-0.0292820614,
-0.0134746833,
-0.0314008705,
-0.0173688978,
0.0304835979,
-0.0140833687,
0.0279490538,
0.0178952832,
0.041065298,
-0.001758498,
-0.0554227196,
0.0254338142,
0.0439368635,
0.0393585153,
-0.0484825596,
-0.0174231119,
0.0451223142,
-0.029199712,
-0.0070801699,
-0.0007831929,
-0.011258428,
0.0006895656,
0.0184677038,
0.06169888,
0.0218947884,
-0.0201813672,
-0.0199621804,
-0.0154924747,
0.0306204222,
0.0276354495,
-0.0449196771,
-0.012659858,
-0.0083555728,
0.0208282676,
-0.0114756906,
0.0131743094,
-0.0253933761,
0.0436513089,
-0.0194820073,
0.0216038171,
-0.0159101319,
-0.0392871611,
0.0396401435,
0.0612808801,
0.0175775941,
0.0041174022,
-0.0064434181,
0.0067647174,
0.014659863,
-0.0336052552,
0.0022120723,
-0.0142961666,
-0.0026776886,
-0.0033814316,
-0.0043014688,
-0.0025637003,
-0.0232988093,
-0.0508001745,
-0.0594573617,
-0.029642215,
0.0707003698,
-0.0004310445,
0.0097128116,
0.0418981053,
0.0061230138,
-0.0017748771,
0.0294124261,
-0.0261481591,
0.0239354167,
-0.0060817925,
0.083378844,
-0.0214118008,
0.0071943561,
-0.0480659604,
0.05519142,
-0.0344746672,
-0.0792114437,
0.0313266106,
0.0364301503,
0.0483256802,
0.0112040276,
-0.000744312,
-0.0623362921,
0.0138108302,
-0.019765459,
0.000466573,
-0.0140481303,
0.0116105294,
0.0544364601,
0.0134999733,
0.0095876474,
-0.0354457647,
0.0609352514,
-0.0292440485,
0.059417937,
-0.0360638164,
-0.0666615814,
-0.0390081853,
-0.0233245362,
0.0254019238,
-0.0002951705,
-0.0690184236,
0.0009339246,
-0.0749715045,
-0.0430240817,
0.0158791523,
-0.0022025486,
-0.0374718718,
-0.036312595,
0.031812951,
0.0608585924,
0.020146301,
-0.0373135805,
-0.0308669843,
0.0506790653,
-0.0565858707,
0.0160575733,
0.0403730273,
-6.430573438e-33,
0.0379397757,
-0.0365357436,
0.044485122,
-0.0476199724,
0.0228815265,
0.0237770285,
-0.0447456464,
-0.0020430172,
-0.0054721208,
0.0306140576,
-0.0264840797,
-0.0215998292,
0.0032678836,
0.0283921771,
0.0301183648,
-0.0169060882,
-0.0053406116,
0.0276548527,
0.0154273892,
0.012459862,
0.003057339,
0.0266664382,
0.0232614093,
-0.0797755718,
0.0031453299,
0.0229012202,
0.0324021988,
0.0389279164,
-0.054738909,
0.0621845685,
-0.0300629865,
0.0412860923,
0.0385432541,
0.0249750596,
0.0030883988,
0.0126329474,
-0.0422125533,
-0.0072967098,
-0.002054539,
-0.0165990815,
-0.0516549312,
-0.0471728444,
0.083133623,
-0.0166544244,
-0.0368388928,
0.0199384112,
0.0116148796,
-0.0613958873,
0.0094065247,
-0.0246419944,
-0.0455614217,
0.0421616212,
-0.0016748984,
-0.0147975041,
-0.0111115891,
-0.0215270091,
-0.0405338183,
0.0369742997,
-0.0253336467,
0.0079698162,
0.0215728823,
-0.0419620313,
0.0243464913,
-0.0407113843,
-0.016011145,
0.0627484545,
0.0181343332,
-0.0157015864,
-0.0511228852,
0.0240016803,
-0.0384787843,
0.0838907585,
0.0489989817,
0.0205020271,
-0.0250834152,
-0.0178526975,
-0.095993802,
0.0402523354,
-0.0511604585,
0.0899153501,
0.0547780506,
-0.0204652324,
-0.0607657768,
0.0076520876,
-0.024563875,
-0.0015510654,
-0.0434732996,
-0.0305393562,
0.0287472196,
-0.0212879274,
-0.0038249055,
0.0201176759,
0.0260929558,
-0.0304023456,
0.0143392105,
-0.0350816995,
0.0554973334,
0.0114836693,
-0.0380390473,
0.0160347875,
-0.0413977429,
-0.0284805577,
0.0004233134,
-0.0267869122,
0.0525795221,
0.0168583263,
-0.0363374911,
-0.0093007097,
-0.0181833692,
-0.0040904917,
0.0092311436,
-0.0158879366,
0.0108480928,
0.0028663746,
0.0566104725,
0.0414096117,
-0.0035268872,
0.072446838,
0.005577771,
-0.0096524311,
-0.0561077446,
-0.0288777109,
-0.0122659719,
0.0144279627,
-0.047704041,
-0.0111466469,
-0.0777698308,
0.0359770842,
0.0289682429,
-0.0637312531,
0.0011486302,
0.0160006955,
3.258e-7,
0.082665436,
0.065743342,
-0.0188158061,
0.001472213,
0.0125979409,
0.0330603756,
-0.0375923775,
-0.0005381689,
-0.0130622229,
-0.0209810529,
0.0377173424,
0.0265290178,
0.0145774521,
0.0397935547,
-0.0291560292,
-0.0171902385,
-0.0313493423,
-0.0161689632,
-0.0527452081,
-0.0022284596,
0.0665882006,
0.0512089208,
-0.0347432494,
-0.0608251765,
0.0293314569,
-0.0101174423,
0.0259082858,
-0.0298585929,
0.0147082219,
0.0331198312,
0.0205003973,
0.0031178889,
0.0442496613,
0.068105571,
0.0158952326,
-0.0059760003,
-0.0096481796,
0.1108644679,
-0.0706273839,
0.0006795282,
0.0184480008,
-0.0156865343,
0.029140098,
-0.0510682985,
0.0727886185,
-0.0338472277,
-0.0555804372,
-0.0176047999,
0.013680066,
-0.0073052589,
0.0586160049,
-0.0249388441,
-0.0332334228,
0.0361507162,
0.0131506631,
0.0162255429,
-0.0044681793,
-0.0773158669,
0.0167860687,
0.0244617127,
-0.0261603538,
-0.0368168168,
0.0304910578,
-0.0104558421,
0.0229760651,
-0.0853512958,
0.0124635082,
2.971891476e-34,
0.0207752082,
0.0063552042,
-0.0007920915,
0.0149860233,
0.0219585821,
0.0198998526,
-0.0118357912,
0.0273504853,
0.005018502,
-0.0722053573,
-0.0040300358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01907v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01907v2 | BoschAI @ PLABA 2023: Leveraging Edit Operations in End-to-End Neural Sentence Simplification | 2023-11-03T13:34:08 | 2023-12-06T08:49:40 | Valentin Knappich, Simon Razniewski, Annemarie Friedrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic simplification can help laypeople to comprehend complex scientific
text. Language models are frequently applied to this task by translating from
complex to simple language. In this paper, we describe our system based on
Llama 2, which ranked first in the PLABA shared task addressing the
simplification of biomedical text. We find that the large portion of shared
tokens between input and output leads to weak training signals and
conservatively editing models. To mitigate these issues, we propose
sentence-level and token-level loss weights. They give higher weight to
modified tokens, indicated by edit distance and edit operations, respectively.
We conduct an empirical evaluation on the PLABA dataset and find that both
approaches lead to simplifications closer to those created by human annotators
(+1.8% / +3.5% SARI), simpler language (-1 / -1.1 FKGL) and more edits (1.6x /
1.8x edit distance) compared to the same model fine-tuned with standard cross
entropy. We furthermore show that the hyperparameter $\lambda$ in token-level
loss weights can be used to control the edit distance and the simplicity level
(FKGL). | [
0.032786034,
0.0071662841,
0.0107909003,
-0.0056471676,
-0.0195732247,
0.0063339812,
-0.0110192038,
0.0378764831,
-0.0274556149,
-0.0163490735,
-0.0421928503,
0.0330912247,
0.063598074,
-0.018845275,
0.062366344,
-0.0865124837,
0.0357295088,
0.0126567334,
0.0279506966,
0.0089888265,
0.0099098757,
-0.0297885668,
0.0047492329,
0.0565513298,
0.0174595695,
-0.0335533395,
0.0233410913,
0.01156992,
0.0288361236,
0.00519804,
0.0228630938,
0.0582007691,
-0.0166368652,
0.0016208565,
0.0000019685,
-0.0191346984,
0.0098474286,
0.0125799375,
0.0012575078,
0.0812130123,
0.0642952994,
-0.0449592993,
-0.0105787255,
0.0053276583,
0.0053368406,
0.0008128392,
0.066272065,
0.0541667491,
0.0627840534,
0.0805787668,
-0.0121999122,
-0.045270402,
0.0135303866,
-0.067731671,
0.0039687101,
0.0007529316,
0.028459657,
-0.0299866833,
-0.0247222912,
-0.0093482435,
-0.0177482907,
0.0500941724,
0.0313895307,
-0.0419610925,
0.0132674277,
0.0251673218,
-0.0318701454,
-0.0108498735,
0.0256394409,
0.070075646,
-0.0631219521,
-0.0440060794,
0.0127252946,
-0.0037077412,
0.0167145915,
-0.0525733754,
-0.0688976794,
-0.0184656046,
0.0281050038,
0.0369406454,
-0.0012678296,
-0.0538847744,
0.048952166,
0.0045806728,
0.0166633353,
0.0082378546,
0.0250579622,
-0.0146605512,
-0.0326452516,
-0.0279593952,
-0.0119823245,
-0.0675424114,
0.061438594,
0.0531698912,
-0.019930033,
-0.0117193311,
-0.0448396429,
-0.0870576426,
0.0273281708,
-0.0385098718,
0.0276037976,
0.0493143834,
-0.0069249319,
0.0057199225,
-0.0319079347,
0.0371666029,
0.003025881,
0.0744225308,
-0.0202391595,
0.0011012325,
0.0002989698,
-0.000913671,
-0.039529752,
0.0459650457,
-0.0559155904,
-0.0137813305,
-0.0759053081,
-0.006009989,
0.0045206938,
-0.0390914008,
0.0114678238,
-0.0149839846,
-0.0374723077,
-0.0197365601,
0.0217221864,
0.0640292838,
-0.0187291149,
0.0536980405,
0.0250600297,
-0.0393532813,
-0.0454964004,
0.0132275959,
0.0213302821,
-0.0005625072,
0.0042246408,
0.0257241409,
-0.0261648651,
-0.0219705682,
-0.0434376746,
-0.010051379,
0.0356696397,
-0.0391703136,
-0.0161026437,
-0.058379259,
0.0482248738,
-0.0260203853,
-0.0165664349,
-0.0702719241,
0.0014338756,
0.0091672353,
-0.034356337,
0.0607103333,
-0.0623099357,
-0.0016358873,
0.049030982,
0.0245989393,
0.0082412679,
0.0352228433,
0.0533853695,
0.0132887457,
0.0102017829,
0.0151658179,
0.014670698,
0.0271841586,
0.0396836512,
-0.01832458,
0.022771094,
-0.0329861529,
-0.0692292079,
0.0556869172,
0.0638693869,
0.0671472996,
-0.0698946938,
-0.0033218444,
0.0527516492,
0.0409882069,
0.0256168582,
0.023773985,
0.052707132,
-0.0146994218,
0.0504886843,
0.0230909642,
-0.0333017446,
0.028613152,
0.0042701648,
0.026833551,
0.0736301914,
-0.0314860754,
-0.031098092,
-0.0582278334,
0.0301104151,
-0.0300677754,
-0.0036090293,
-0.0509049743,
0.0102418363,
0.0134774409,
-0.0465924628,
0.0498055294,
0.0320912711,
-0.0594642088,
0.0105475774,
-0.0275923591,
-0.0118813124,
0.0509778112,
0.0116937691,
-0.0214184877,
-0.0481063575,
-0.0028625282,
0.001993038,
0.0231598001,
0.0512949526,
-0.0134702688,
0.0345743559,
-0.0596330352,
0.0175518934,
-0.0209900886,
0.0363192335,
-0.0238101557,
0.0220425837,
-0.0168780945,
0.0288864989,
-0.0515252389,
-0.0223802701,
0.0542674065,
-0.0101193553,
0.0117865261,
-0.0030535776,
0.0167088602,
0.0170594044,
-0.0112878298,
0.0064582382,
0.0487588979,
0.0088862814,
-0.0720039085,
-0.0314876735,
0.0001405281,
-0.0030341975,
-0.0674759522,
0.0440103039,
-0.0542287864,
-0.0085778795,
0.0564941429,
-0.0548238829,
-0.038995415,
-0.006326512,
-0.0738506317,
0.0262492746,
-0.0249056835,
0.037206389,
0.0208943132,
0.0253278092,
-0.028153019,
0.0095683197,
-0.0206476189,
0.0157242659,
0.0382174887,
-0.0359211862,
0.0130187152,
-0.0467459671,
0.0129845906,
-0.0390182287,
-0.0071038296,
-0.0164917074,
-0.0109477025,
0.0197019894,
-0.0125386128,
-0.0239348486,
-0.0824134648,
-0.0071817627,
-0.0120376172,
0.0233834386,
0.0687064677,
0.0399491154,
-0.0069778063,
-0.0195245817,
-0.0088533582,
0.0242708586,
-0.0402350612,
0.0198499449,
0.0877674073,
0.0066060582,
-0.0243101735,
-0.0582891665,
-0.0123862755,
-0.0179650187,
0.0281815007,
0.0048556537,
-0.0530922897,
-0.0312857889,
0.0199329313,
-0.0102489255,
-0.0183834825,
0.0321475677,
-0.062121138,
-0.0179308467,
0.008880971,
0.0489708483,
0.099206984,
0.0032621901,
0.0168586373,
0.0327536762,
0.0325387642,
-0.0192820784,
0.0097576221,
-0.0100006107,
0.0399267934,
-0.0183043424,
-0.0421910435,
0.0303171612,
0.0742051601,
-0.0126392087,
0.0006032754,
-0.0579141565,
-0.0096089104,
0.0170134362,
-0.0159218758,
0.0057324539,
-0.0193700735,
-0.0423308872,
0.0205746144,
-0.0301269926,
-0.0378515162,
0.0526605472,
-0.0129692564,
0.0240377001,
-0.0524547137,
0.0071983174,
-0.0340803303,
-0.0161540657,
-0.0054646828,
0.0223466959,
-0.0060411347,
-0.0141288303,
-0.0469670631,
-0.0027451492,
-0.0174352396,
0.0048799566,
0.0119741941,
-0.070383206,
-0.0083477199,
-0.0300419573,
-0.0551574752,
0.0256274715,
-0.002221646,
-0.0156722106,
0.0211147163,
0.0424985997,
-0.0332343094,
-0.0327943265,
-0.0495300256,
0.0126785971,
0.1016791686,
-0.0347078927,
-0.0079764919,
-0.0207791738,
0.0156305153,
0.0426299833,
0.0050865649,
0.0422573797,
-0.0575730056,
0.0116083352,
0.0373688303,
-0.0139518734,
-0.0128915031,
-0.0091135362,
-0.0174443647,
-0.0141536444,
-0.04933374,
-0.0030024634,
0.012723323,
0.0603817217,
-0.0539810099,
0.0115825729,
0.090239428,
-0.0056983558,
-0.0382873863,
0.035646338,
-0.0131850122,
0.0180802979,
-0.0072279489,
0.0211091824,
-0.0621258467,
-0.0349891372,
0.021802811,
0.0277645476,
0.0216472037,
-0.0085861729,
-0.0131912082,
-0.016825825,
0.022556236,
0.0133820269,
-0.0824038982,
-0.0411205254,
-0.0354426913,
0.0177124459,
-0.0037218973,
0.0224633459,
0.0181679931,
-0.027056586,
0.0097706178,
-0.004522041,
-0.0271585826,
-0.0462438092,
-0.0358583815,
-0.0229203161,
0.036459893,
0.005103962,
0.0361681841,
0.0113953585,
-0.0109132538,
0.0852390379,
0.045876123,
-0.0310539249,
-0.0211475734,
0.0333839804,
0.0471778661,
-0.0002251361,
-0.004457314,
0.0578314625,
-0.0022305243,
-0.0182659291,
-0.0220894739,
0.0404019281,
0.0104345707,
-0.0285129603,
-0.0202597659,
0.0006059051,
-0.0563159846,
0.0542407744,
0.0989891887,
-0.0044040922,
-0.0665276051,
-0.016460197,
-0.0046131215,
-0.0621578172,
-0.0249583796,
-0.0165538881,
-0.0298649333,
-0.0450545438,
-0.0790929943,
-0.0373303108,
0.0265623722,
-0.0022956564,
0.0120916851,
0.0168425459,
0.0008418772,
-0.0326288827,
-0.029816458,
0.0158728492,
-0.0141739668,
0.005218863,
-0.062191017,
0.0127088828,
0.0100038964,
0.0188139211,
-0.0132661778,
0.0065786992,
-0.0876513347,
-0.0733972937,
-0.0075934827,
0.0678526461,
0.0219792053,
0.0396382175,
0.0149246873,
-0.068018496,
0.0227331817,
0.0338604525,
-0.0417753793,
0.0658058077,
0.0265746489,
0.0089809578,
0.0085647907,
0.0600649677,
-0.0181434434,
-0.0141177485,
0.0126199555,
0.0502306186,
0.0020717953,
-0.0215796866,
0.0165692344,
0.0458159521,
0.0110804522,
-0.0012753487,
-0.0103904735,
-0.0134762237,
0.0465741828,
-0.0362885073,
0.0515501723,
-0.0361022577,
0.0074391388,
0.0038786882,
0.038847141,
-0.0254780017,
0.0221731905,
-0.0186373796,
-0.0179372709,
0.0053894874,
0.015097389,
-0.0360807367,
-0.0062345611,
0.0180035848,
-0.0154423229,
-0.0161860995,
-0.0225049891,
-0.0134306466,
0.0035096211,
-0.0319273472,
-0.0145819578,
0.0336359777,
0.0356754176,
-0.0611903369,
0.0609819293,
-0.0327258669,
-0.0152336871,
-0.0139044849,
0.0383238308,
0.0247521587,
0.0355029702,
0.0694830343,
-0.0171844773,
-0.0353962146,
-0.0268074311,
0.0524864309,
-0.0161879174,
0.0105508957,
0.0443767682,
-0.0121045699,
0.0129219722,
-0.0009073324,
0.0890143067,
-0.0106888898,
0.0796667859,
-0.0119293761,
0.0115782591,
-0.0296286326,
-0.0357785076,
-0.0230933428,
0.0170504507,
-0.0318563506,
-0.0427342281,
-0.030499626,
-0.0577185303,
0.0142815802,
-0.0061292769,
-0.0307108071,
-0.0105270185,
0.0264239497,
-0.0012823147,
-0.0251459833,
-0.047041595,
-0.0057063061,
0.0131413341,
0.043358501,
-0.0656961277,
-0.0126098022,
-6.221822539e-33,
-0.0178512912,
0.0132398112,
0.0127332211,
0.0053938222,
-0.0473616682,
0.0147148743,
-0.1040737405,
-0.0050140107,
-0.0182764083,
0.0432578772,
-0.0238570869,
0.0218204614,
0.0064086518,
0.0003727914,
-0.0198160894,
0.03474015,
0.0778844878,
0.0018261243,
-0.0244589001,
0.00614144,
-0.0082567809,
0.0350647196,
0.0418811701,
-0.04211092,
-0.0009556618,
0.0299303569,
-0.041289974,
0.0113305748,
-0.0155825913,
0.014816653,
-0.0372467302,
0.0154382996,
0.0102470256,
-0.028417334,
-0.0379041694,
-0.0061458279,
-0.096369423,
-0.0188744869,
0.0292843282,
0.0043630833,
-0.0650764927,
-0.1022053435,
0.1051838398,
-0.00341265,
-0.011846615,
-0.0271766726,
0.0122756548,
-0.0391069315,
0.0011008488,
-0.0366584472,
-0.0549098626,
0.0213853046,
-0.0236131679,
-0.0260315426,
-0.0073773647,
-0.0036608102,
-0.0494338609,
0.0062279725,
-0.0308604576,
0.0021093043,
0.0558957085,
0.0741978288,
0.0128565235,
-0.0454250984,
0.0129540432,
0.0098628774,
0.0481056161,
-0.0055304198,
-0.0192262903,
0.007709973,
0.0231093969,
-0.0042323894,
0.0648945943,
0.0043177209,
0.0294734556,
0.0005546114,
-0.1052063257,
0.0308545101,
-0.0251527168,
0.0555014871,
-0.0432528593,
0.0354562886,
0.0286104102,
-0.0108617283,
-0.0138788242,
0.0002056488,
-0.0200627465,
-0.0143055674,
0.0097877579,
0.0261677448,
-0.0052656992,
-0.0244955178,
-0.0129313599,
-0.0157384016,
0.0075064781,
0.018462155,
0.0143868709,
0.0480386652,
0.0225828327,
-0.0436872505,
-0.0345544852,
0.0360942818,
0.0410848819,
0.0266562011,
0.0516821668,
-0.003934145,
0.0775308833,
0.0301834792,
-0.0513334945,
-0.0048260405,
-0.0006788756,
-0.0115349432,
0.0396423414,
0.0195036214,
0.0072087985,
-0.0006524674,
0.0098043475,
0.0175863579,
0.0150882071,
0.0083011147,
-0.0074878982,
0.0517348833,
0.0460392311,
0.0535214096,
-0.0392175987,
0.0048454143,
-0.0148214214,
0.0454152375,
0.0089699579,
-0.0719228089,
-0.0404956639,
-0.00434202,
2.696e-7,
0.0932784155,
0.0590734333,
0.0585118122,
-0.0374327935,
0.0089268005,
0.0102551263,
0.0050839819,
-0.0005362024,
-0.0337251611,
0.0346421748,
0.0377188288,
-0.0255594421,
0.0214823708,
-0.0228731781,
-0.1013337374,
0.0347517431,
-0.0614879355,
-0.0281872526,
-0.0389147438,
-0.0552463792,
0.0051494655,
0.0745476633,
-0.0067881281,
-0.0083604502,
0.0083026374,
0.012101179,
0.0521299131,
-0.0268717278,
0.0272146072,
0.0451663695,
0.0280537941,
-0.0069752079,
0.0209298711,
-0.0079004057,
-0.0469116941,
-0.0265108086,
0.0151734147,
0.1060969979,
-0.0395756736,
0.0178629588,
0.0393457711,
-0.0327913687,
-0.0007875104,
-0.0367430225,
0.0472476743,
-0.0622011907,
-0.005687159,
-0.0186713897,
0.0113360779,
0.0290324092,
0.0431743935,
-0.0278542526,
-0.0150829405,
0.044223424,
0.0082757771,
0.0193066262,
-0.0187493116,
-0.0629134551,
-0.068203263,
-0.0165427532,
-0.0080841556,
0.0082836403,
-0.0681400523,
0.0318685099,
0.021693673,
-0.0556446351,
-0.0024894685,
2.568295592e-34,
0.0332704335,
-0.0413019918,
0.0114567652,
0.0382707566,
0.0080332961,
-0.0344980992,
-0.0120793618,
0.0191457793,
-0.0025879024,
-0.051889535,
-0.0162141435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01882v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01882v1 | Indicative Summarization of Long Discussions | 2023-11-03T12:44:59 | 2023-11-03T12:44:59 | Shahbaz Syed, Dominik Schwabe, Khalid Al-Khatib, Martin Potthast | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online forums encourage the exchange and discussion of different stances on
many topics. Not only do they provide an opportunity to present one's own
arguments, but may also gather a broad cross-section of others' arguments.
However, the resulting long discussions are difficult to overview. This paper
presents a novel unsupervised approach using large language models (LLMs) to
generating indicative summaries for long discussions that basically serve as
tables of contents. Our approach first clusters argument sentences, generates
cluster labels as abstractive summaries, and classifies the generated cluster
labels into argumentation frames resulting in a two-level summary. Based on an
extensively optimized prompt engineering approach, we evaluate 19~LLMs for
generative cluster labeling and frame classification. To evaluate the
usefulness of our indicative summaries, we conduct a purpose-driven user study
via a new visual interface called Discussion Explorer: It shows that our
proposed indicative summaries serve as a convenient navigation tool to explore
long discussions. | [
0.0332713351,
-0.0055919746,
-0.0003007725,
0.0311331414,
-0.0227792282,
0.005037406,
0.0250555482,
-0.0140467919,
0.0399885364,
-0.0491884165,
0.0033882067,
-0.0527530685,
-0.0182754546,
0.0069473363,
-0.0193362441,
-0.1351606846,
0.0285948683,
-0.0095244274,
0.0604271628,
0.003877684,
0.0421928726,
0.0099909073,
-0.0311345197,
0.0282059219,
-0.0077758515,
-0.0307065565,
-0.0162234344,
-0.0360591002,
0.0429960229,
-0.0213538893,
-0.0158738624,
0.0465895943,
0.0125591904,
0.0399382114,
0.0000017702,
-0.0474616922,
-0.0000691327,
-0.0316547714,
-0.0145169692,
0.0503947623,
0.0707986355,
0.0327064767,
0.0248309337,
0.0201295614,
-0.0187346525,
-0.0362405367,
-0.0003731044,
0.0711739063,
0.090012759,
0.0484520085,
-0.0161712021,
-0.0298686847,
-0.0055215368,
-0.015839519,
-0.0353857875,
-0.0104445238,
0.005757316,
0.0443665236,
0.002123856,
0.0497661233,
0.0338177569,
0.00030967,
-0.0138062267,
-0.079337351,
-0.000927663,
0.0210598335,
-0.0413337685,
-0.0296538621,
0.0165223386,
0.0686809942,
0.0561466515,
0.0045897118,
0.0379670747,
0.0034281348,
0.0129751852,
0.027911989,
-0.083987318,
0.0706460327,
-0.0158035792,
0.0040037595,
0.0489090532,
0.0618797392,
-0.0021983527,
-0.006193263,
0.0017559372,
0.0066423072,
0.0048923325,
-0.0035107417,
-0.0334853381,
-0.0159511957,
-0.0209701173,
-0.0754217207,
0.0011194431,
0.0364619419,
-0.0358037166,
0.0236566029,
-0.0027414949,
-0.0080361376,
0.016875837,
-0.0538289212,
-0.0185799226,
-0.0273610409,
0.0310017727,
0.0667877346,
-0.0136413826,
-0.0493003689,
-0.0054615461,
-0.0389726944,
-0.0130118839,
-0.0132548939,
-0.0605441704,
-0.0051627001,
-0.0621224977,
0.0333306752,
-0.0662377998,
-0.0466443114,
-0.0109672844,
0.0270298235,
-0.0140575357,
0.0182282757,
0.0020961442,
-0.0078455405,
0.04098849,
-0.0158606172,
-0.0115514612,
0.0023308659,
-0.0841434225,
-0.0089173522,
0.0395383798,
-0.0218010172,
0.0145386169,
0.0589863025,
0.0184214655,
0.0086870352,
-0.0619575083,
0.0411972515,
-0.0209969282,
0.0332312845,
-0.0270065311,
-0.067835696,
-0.0547050834,
0.0010877434,
-0.0417522825,
-0.080547139,
0.0285692737,
0.0050874995,
-0.0059977863,
-0.0113443099,
0.0164588634,
0.0193316415,
-0.0137220193,
-0.0076604276,
-0.0172011834,
0.0160656814,
0.1018163413,
0.0357802659,
-0.0295668449,
0.0191345215,
-0.0132877612,
0.0498525016,
0.0656343699,
-0.0056637423,
0.0140291508,
0.0186249781,
-0.0163505431,
0.0059879203,
0.0277133211,
-0.0010366791,
0.0185735729,
-0.0127166733,
-0.0529635809,
0.055593349,
-0.0357727744,
0.0120761795,
0.0239470731,
0.0574253872,
-0.0114981197,
0.0274663307,
-0.0026771489,
0.0467902757,
0.0340344161,
0.000379489,
0.0462621301,
0.000897819,
-0.0237432718,
-0.0090139061,
0.1062414572,
-0.0160274841,
-0.0283020791,
-0.0499269888,
-0.0096627781,
0.019625308,
0.0003447503,
-0.0100241397,
0.034383554,
0.0142370146,
0.0012832915,
0.05224007,
0.0350497924,
-0.0477383249,
0.0127074718,
-0.0075864792,
0.0569285378,
0.023420874,
-0.0099816825,
-0.0231340807,
-0.0232923385,
-0.019136183,
0.0555654839,
0.0512846187,
0.0863960236,
-0.0376587063,
-0.0566607825,
-0.0356993861,
-0.0151985185,
-0.0106270397,
0.0095578926,
0.01238898,
-0.0055122222,
-0.0300194584,
0.0313930623,
0.0262409579,
-0.0633774698,
0.0195344482,
0.0344503447,
0.0274931788,
0.0199233778,
-0.0024224599,
0.0361846611,
0.0656507835,
-0.0152590498,
0.000396665,
0.0325808674,
-0.0242577307,
-0.0233844258,
0.012091958,
-0.0649496913,
-0.0152216153,
0.0228215121,
-0.0479773618,
-0.0113989152,
-0.0691438317,
-0.0233810451,
-0.061456725,
0.0379668698,
-0.0651569366,
-0.0172121506,
0.012121438,
0.0032057846,
-0.0039324327,
-0.0385257751,
-0.0575653128,
0.0836187601,
0.0506960973,
0.0008783067,
0.0416628271,
-0.0107333325,
0.0146556348,
-0.0528893359,
-0.0172676947,
0.0084963795,
0.0135806892,
-0.0060363743,
0.0835436285,
-0.0467293337,
-0.0444711894,
-0.0281289816,
-0.1397794187,
-0.0031949042,
-0.0273587946,
0.0214073285,
0.0510751605,
-0.0188353471,
-0.0132331615,
0.0106668603,
-0.0574035533,
-0.0198749993,
0.0098512694,
-0.0060775965,
0.0239708647,
0.0323576108,
0.0146640716,
-0.0373817459,
-0.0129369302,
-0.0121043781,
0.0521835238,
0.0440156199,
-0.0343053713,
-0.0634906217,
0.0104130153,
-0.004212311,
-0.039426811,
-0.0187089704,
0.0292324554,
0.0178362746,
-0.0004026888,
0.0489079505,
0.0165156983,
0.0723691285,
0.0382068194,
0.0198338665,
0.0083548035,
-0.0423575602,
-0.0285955891,
-0.0366031416,
0.0410356708,
-0.0254139975,
-0.024257049,
0.0741623119,
0.0710479617,
0.0316971168,
0.0263295136,
-0.0414781757,
0.0207812693,
-0.0256818682,
0.0284580253,
-0.0535633415,
-0.0448554754,
0.0205321833,
0.0408886187,
-0.0162388496,
-0.0016815908,
0.0365182199,
-0.0325455777,
0.0352845117,
-0.0268638395,
-0.0424840935,
-0.0580464341,
0.0260630287,
-0.0074522896,
0.0391959213,
0.017497696,
-0.0215659235,
0.0125841005,
-0.0228761081,
0.0395505168,
-0.0095495414,
0.0539576225,
-0.0504815429,
-0.0029421668,
-0.0095990105,
-0.0155337509,
-0.0269329995,
-0.0498983338,
-0.0146983154,
0.0040607397,
0.0228545442,
0.0169599466,
-0.0427698679,
0.0313164294,
0.0286784116,
-0.0037381218,
-0.0041020396,
0.0001288111,
0.0071442868,
0.0772841349,
0.0233452395,
-0.0191575103,
0.0040178085,
-0.0320229717,
0.0440408662,
0.0828619674,
-0.0372868218,
0.0003889768,
-0.0224575549,
-0.0678361282,
-0.0025728876,
-0.0567844659,
-0.0133656785,
-0.0127736637,
0.05326543,
-0.0354968049,
0.0342615545,
0.1280716211,
0.0598530285,
-0.0491946414,
-0.0269197058,
-0.0278460272,
0.031646587,
-0.0058310875,
-0.0007668092,
-0.0414192304,
0.0037134271,
-0.0312193595,
0.0059278156,
-0.0264049973,
-0.0458083674,
0.030628141,
-0.0907897875,
0.031600032,
0.0226552356,
-0.0199302882,
0.0339320935,
-0.0627332553,
0.0129070375,
-0.0051553301,
-0.040021807,
0.0308650006,
0.0076443329,
-0.0136073036,
0.0428496599,
-0.0706272125,
0.0450836532,
-0.0064391065,
-0.0109483302,
0.028988611,
-0.0095546423,
0.0293755326,
-0.0104613053,
0.0131702265,
0.0387228169,
-0.0439301282,
-0.001493744,
0.0058715059,
0.023936918,
0.0004843986,
0.0070784949,
-0.0441566333,
0.0491143428,
0.0307846852,
-0.0537755862,
0.0797715411,
0.0323565304,
-0.0193263572,
-0.0105044525,
-0.0165114515,
0.0269979294,
-0.0084871594,
0.0559397563,
0.036933884,
-0.0080472892,
-0.0097077508,
-0.0573380888,
0.0070933332,
-0.0087329755,
-0.0141213108,
-0.0521991327,
0.0093196156,
0.0399311855,
-0.0757405534,
-0.018770054,
0.0203099735,
0.0111711621,
-0.0053900424,
-0.014212219,
0.021140933,
0.019847149,
-0.0350642353,
0.0254583471,
-0.0416200943,
-0.0150193889,
-0.0516602509,
-0.0252435971,
0.0398034751,
-0.0071566049,
-0.0173108932,
0.0196754783,
0.0138762584,
-0.0771507993,
-0.0269804113,
0.0114267329,
0.0159916934,
0.0303304456,
-0.0062644123,
-0.0318532474,
0.0570791923,
-0.008178723,
0.0252858419,
-0.0385512151,
-0.0122054908,
0.0536642931,
-0.0065062474,
-0.0198885649,
-0.0142039023,
0.0501072742,
-0.0360568389,
0.0096283974,
-0.0781743899,
-0.0381219983,
0.001652105,
0.0344592221,
0.029204309,
0.0144836903,
-0.0339183211,
-0.0204593576,
-0.0115393568,
-0.0589436702,
-0.0302006099,
0.0232474636,
0.0301666912,
0.0095874192,
-0.0465177894,
0.0214758962,
0.072166346,
-0.0099425381,
0.0316750929,
-0.0173905957,
0.0279900115,
-0.010600185,
-0.0226008985,
-0.0266756844,
0.0015884137,
-0.0539756864,
-0.0073201614,
-0.0137127247,
0.0234152861,
-0.011540575,
0.0639012381,
-0.0016924453,
-0.0353885964,
0.0171833951,
0.0449116789,
-0.048767712,
-0.0365581773,
-0.0239321124,
0.0404904559,
-0.0068199132,
-0.0220006872,
0.0471464694,
-0.0129281282,
-0.0232281405,
-0.0359491855,
0.0526854843,
0.0259087179,
-0.0285461787,
0.0106116654,
0.0493455529,
-0.0315969698,
-0.0028839889,
0.0483874939,
-0.0723006651,
-0.0197135415,
0.0490639247,
-0.047797136,
-0.060123004,
-0.0061345785,
-0.0045010671,
0.0145492926,
-0.0025152199,
-0.029876167,
-0.0292595178,
0.0210114811,
0.0114838872,
0.0136438571,
0.0344102941,
0.025688583,
0.0508390404,
0.0298140924,
0.010594259,
0.0300820917,
-0.0783900991,
0.0194397047,
-0.0163911525,
0.009832399,
-0.0251633301,
-5.704665636e-33,
-0.0244281851,
-0.0614156947,
-0.0249766596,
0.0347832181,
-0.0169270039,
-0.0207655597,
-0.0497987717,
0.0540330634,
0.0220339503,
0.0185157154,
0.0432856493,
-0.0007731025,
0.0122649428,
0.0488888137,
-0.0108728381,
0.0078730341,
0.031554956,
0.0150276711,
-0.0272918101,
0.0832434148,
0.0445666313,
-0.041581016,
-0.0354277082,
-0.0300341658,
0.0442915298,
-0.0194344744,
0.0286888145,
0.0045400201,
0.0293177068,
0.0520732477,
-0.0202890355,
0.0407412574,
0.039156083,
-0.0247447565,
-0.013246702,
0.0811349601,
-0.0311013199,
-0.0070184199,
0.0169919785,
-0.0733945742,
-0.0173341017,
-0.0529814363,
0.0079932436,
0.0163633693,
-0.0040037148,
-0.0084237205,
0.0548376143,
-0.0175997242,
-0.0192546491,
-0.0320402272,
-0.0297915507,
0.0543816239,
-0.0620881952,
-0.0021609634,
0.0036567601,
0.038467411,
0.0276977718,
0.0550674498,
-0.0312767439,
0.0505214036,
-0.016355373,
0.0161107369,
0.0175672155,
-0.000981015,
0.0241702721,
0.0419721641,
-0.0099945348,
0.0424627885,
-0.0567275174,
0.022008229,
-0.0503817648,
0.0337823518,
0.0428296067,
0.04208735,
-0.0023979051,
0.0058014677,
-0.0590413772,
0.0425605662,
0.0021602563,
0.0130533669,
0.0400862806,
-0.0019935712,
0.0061102556,
0.0035624178,
-0.061589174,
-0.034442421,
-0.008517039,
-0.0124475192,
-0.0302960537,
-0.0026758637,
-0.0515357777,
-0.0571610108,
0.0026976927,
-0.0011192504,
0.0054039173,
0.0001683751,
0.0006617459,
0.0373183526,
-0.0017187832,
-0.0073369103,
-0.0221802983,
-0.01016137,
0.0262077842,
-0.0066119125,
-0.0023443173,
-0.0049242801,
0.0110112,
-0.0593960099,
-0.0486682616,
0.0224682186,
0.0016878106,
0.0162477829,
-0.0496445335,
0.017446503,
0.0237833653,
0.0253309179,
-0.0008319787,
0.0694229901,
-0.0157790016,
0.0045835525,
0.0107139442,
-0.0176629759,
-0.0113014653,
-0.0225255396,
-0.0080992319,
0.0095409136,
0.0019397219,
0.0502427444,
0.040594358,
-0.031254068,
-0.0041096136,
-0.0163744427,
2.376e-7,
0.0276445672,
0.0632427484,
0.0398655348,
-0.0211167634,
0.0356776081,
0.0256821532,
0.0237310193,
0.0207762029,
0.0192350317,
-0.044237785,
-0.0030519143,
0.0306722596,
0.0418267176,
0.0467125624,
-0.0755601153,
-0.0435758382,
-0.0666950718,
-0.0559752285,
-0.0436266251,
0.0283704735,
0.0883058608,
0.0448989458,
-0.0337543748,
0.0440359786,
-0.0261186529,
-0.0322063789,
0.0454237796,
-0.0321337171,
-0.0619730614,
0.0493067168,
0.0505320281,
-0.0365910679,
0.0045400765,
0.0080342302,
0.0157700479,
-0.0093043353,
0.0135560837,
0.0556228235,
0.0315806307,
-0.0260062423,
0.0008855159,
-0.0086914795,
0.0265761074,
-0.0232008807,
0.021773031,
-0.1023264676,
-0.0159384049,
-0.0331608392,
-0.0589324608,
-0.022460442,
0.0023524717,
-0.0171950888,
0.0144192632,
0.0348424278,
-0.0252892338,
-0.0164001901,
0.0192394871,
-0.0640104488,
-0.0212091655,
0.0137010319,
-0.0560007654,
-0.0512228496,
0.0143467477,
-0.0264056027,
-0.0090728346,
-0.0045463736,
0.0308219735,
1.762621407e-34,
0.0439277664,
0.0130091794,
-0.0345002413,
-0.0126081211,
0.0455155857,
-0.0004489296,
-0.0465281717,
-0.0109471856,
0.024732491,
-0.0978622735,
0.0122167869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01876v1 | Sentiment Analysis through LLM Negotiations | 2023-11-03T12:35:29 | 2023-11-03T12:35:29 | Xiaofei Sun, Xiaoya Li, Shengyu Zhang, Shuhe Wang, Fei Wu, Jiwei Li, Tianwei Zhang, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | A standard paradigm for sentiment analysis is to rely on a singular LLM and
makes the decision in a single round under the framework of in-context
learning. This framework suffers the key disadvantage that the single-turn
output generated by a single LLM might not deliver the perfect decision, just
as humans sometimes need multiple attempts to get things right. This is
especially true for the task of sentiment analysis where deep reasoning is
required to address the complex linguistic phenomenon (e.g., clause
composition, irony, etc) in the input.
To address this issue, this paper introduces a multi-LLM negotiation
framework for sentiment analysis. The framework consists of a reasoning-infused
generator to provide decision along with rationale, a explanation-deriving
discriminator to evaluate the credibility of the generator. The generator and
the discriminator iterate until a consensus is reached. The proposed framework
naturally addressed the aforementioned challenge, as we are able to take the
complementary abilities of two LLMs, have them use rationale to persuade each
other for correction.
Experiments on a wide range of sentiment analysis benchmarks (SST-2, Movie
Review, Twitter, yelp, amazon, IMDB) demonstrate the effectiveness of proposed
approach: it consistently yields better performances than the ICL baseline
across all benchmarks, and even superior performances to supervised baselines
on the Twitter and movie review datasets. | [
0.0205213185,
0.0951048434,
0.0308334548,
0.0523254983,
-0.0401090756,
0.0285193417,
-0.0002417639,
0.0076999874,
0.0021606777,
-0.0304497555,
-0.0183632057,
-0.0253722183,
-0.0321978889,
0.0002368627,
-0.0237966608,
-0.018573191,
0.002221314,
0.0432514139,
0.053739354,
-0.0217719506,
0.0142000979,
0.0179728176,
-0.0043244492,
0.0192320179,
-0.0289915167,
-0.0207077507,
0.0036258632,
0.0180253498,
0.0129477317,
-0.0290322434,
0.022765493,
0.0189025849,
0.0161633436,
0.0246814936,
0.0000019515,
-0.0462404899,
-0.0267954189,
-0.0276293717,
-0.0089610601,
-0.0381377339,
0.0452886187,
-0.0201224778,
-0.0025372216,
-0.0002510728,
-0.0674944222,
0.0331356339,
0.0218556039,
0.0922111273,
0.0682510883,
0.1130222231,
-0.0100923385,
-0.0580231063,
-0.0183620397,
-0.0209282506,
-0.0292147398,
-0.0381762385,
0.0097656576,
-0.0301351789,
-0.0281416718,
0.0046563116,
-0.0148988562,
0.0186893903,
0.0107219834,
-0.0379318744,
-0.0208316725,
-0.0042474363,
0.0065518175,
-0.0096971896,
-0.0054679499,
0.0647125095,
0.0124791805,
-0.0110869249,
0.0130560249,
-0.0122980466,
0.0018792455,
-0.0471405424,
-0.0378018394,
0.0284958333,
-0.0016287458,
0.059813261,
0.0249384362,
0.006252089,
0.0599939376,
-0.0026316808,
-0.0079859812,
0.042599909,
-0.0401073471,
-0.0321022421,
0.0359450988,
0.0424013324,
0.0122138718,
-0.0343214683,
-0.0088369092,
0.0413567312,
-0.0496436208,
0.0369352214,
-0.0007217928,
0.01878375,
-0.0044516362,
-0.0634110197,
-0.0067594205,
-0.0027357941,
-0.0105131427,
0.0669240877,
-0.0054087834,
-0.0297268275,
-0.0294529218,
0.0346058123,
0.0167945065,
-0.0058333823,
-0.0523763448,
0.0090423618,
0.0308020432,
0.0534521788,
-0.0291858818,
0.010752352,
-0.0568065457,
0.0180301294,
-0.0658524111,
0.0364782214,
0.0255622566,
0.0374828577,
0.0357403941,
0.0048308792,
-0.0564334914,
0.0277177412,
-0.0364587791,
0.0379240029,
0.003560432,
-0.0536867119,
-0.0044736387,
0.0578988343,
-0.0012685768,
0.0018979178,
0.0426553525,
0.0844794959,
0.0072246394,
0.0001226403,
-0.0448381975,
-0.027410049,
0.0091284933,
-0.0771197081,
-0.0027607218,
-0.0611420125,
0.0373686813,
-0.0383601934,
-0.0195883568,
-0.0447298996,
0.0033743961,
0.003798557,
-0.0025944484,
0.0813583881,
-0.0161054526,
-0.0432090089,
-0.0060749128,
0.0403210521,
-0.0394251719,
0.0706527308,
0.0337469541,
0.0528998412,
0.0427873395,
0.0021741698,
0.0141087519,
-0.0136370715,
0.0012437848,
-0.0119398236,
-0.0126308734,
-0.0058343587,
-0.0867276862,
0.0082843574,
-0.0145946909,
0.0464945324,
-0.0232989248,
-0.0429565571,
0.0211037435,
0.0182952862,
0.0501229912,
0.0729909614,
-0.0011486744,
0.0002781197,
-0.0092514502,
0.0010384764,
-0.0100922734,
0.0692003816,
-0.0174305309,
-0.0201435424,
0.0128482124,
-0.006811128,
-0.0319124758,
-0.0566754863,
0.0159362797,
-0.0326986276,
0.0343446098,
0.0074243094,
0.0506070964,
-0.0170612223,
-0.0819871128,
0.0004463031,
0.0222705733,
-0.0320656747,
-0.0245490875,
-0.040977817,
0.0391230658,
0.0521305092,
0.001998279,
-0.0154582122,
-0.0130052716,
-0.0344239622,
-0.000586255,
0.0726240352,
0.0296192225,
-0.0152070848,
0.0172061417,
-0.0412102938,
-0.0068771983,
-0.0350210853,
0.0042915819,
0.0303697921,
-0.0091986274,
0.0275135133,
-0.0195411332,
0.0038655573,
0.0306900386,
0.0023685973,
0.0212890729,
-0.0180662815,
0.0217912178,
0.0151125761,
0.0681470409,
0.0408413634,
0.0007544953,
-0.0204515047,
0.0283831023,
-0.0171387717,
-0.0869546309,
0.0350076817,
-0.0270552114,
-0.056067355,
0.0317022838,
-0.0330867693,
-0.0351507403,
-0.006869318,
-0.0687201843,
-0.0118983379,
0.0257298145,
0.0099165756,
0.0067890193,
-0.0566700548,
-0.0274066888,
-0.0052753529,
0.0094479732,
-0.0049128123,
0.0744121,
-0.014887169,
-0.0461136475,
-0.0071154344,
-0.0170245189,
0.0046368237,
-0.0171177518,
-0.0113935964,
0.0182804652,
0.0188190825,
0.03015038,
0.030720992,
0.0160042401,
-0.0275697969,
-0.0645088106,
-0.0719660595,
0.0154613312,
-0.0141210109,
0.0085477978,
-0.0064665591,
-0.0353611223,
0.0296431184,
0.0303825326,
-0.0391772948,
-0.0087115308,
0.013359461,
0.0048802304,
0.0825529546,
-0.0077659786,
-0.0024575898,
-0.0194692984,
0.0195443742,
-0.018192308,
0.0147716831,
0.000844474,
-0.0161507372,
-0.0335727967,
0.0127609754,
-0.0534366146,
0.0094383219,
-0.0210910626,
-0.0129619678,
0.0341558568,
-0.0058512357,
-0.0474517159,
0.0402613282,
0.0177814234,
0.072982043,
-0.0012753063,
0.0149346516,
-0.056852024,
0.0438222103,
-0.0318307281,
0.044701755,
-0.0676298887,
0.0131974062,
-0.0202782545,
0.0514974259,
-0.0251222048,
0.0111119663,
-0.0452086031,
0.0486322902,
0.0476451144,
-0.0010359673,
0.0112868557,
-0.0055923527,
-0.0098343184,
0.039520245,
0.0096357958,
-0.0229892544,
0.096906729,
0.010085715,
-0.0053224214,
-0.0465900078,
-0.0296661165,
-0.0625212863,
0.0421757251,
-0.0856470168,
-0.0158194192,
-0.0150130596,
0.0239616632,
0.0004855024,
-0.0683583245,
0.003449369,
-0.0254460499,
0.0792961642,
-0.0227410123,
0.0219420623,
0.0115319546,
-0.0383358449,
-0.0231345948,
-0.0235437565,
-0.0601433143,
-0.0075514875,
-0.0062405411,
-0.0284147821,
0.0104221599,
-0.0530958623,
-0.0299744569,
-0.0306323115,
0.0402972177,
-0.0143356062,
0.0076355701,
-0.0096730934,
0.0226247963,
0.0230866056,
0.0409873538,
0.001382395,
0.0488467924,
0.0540632084,
-0.0385971665,
-0.0201842096,
-0.0558560155,
-0.0046078428,
0.0026452173,
0.0026431743,
0.0083367154,
-0.0369286425,
0.038656313,
-0.047000315,
0.0673977062,
0.10953632,
-0.0134179164,
-0.0476189703,
-0.0004865674,
-0.0012028936,
-0.0037927157,
0.0079267258,
-0.0185942426,
-0.0839865208,
-0.0448693894,
-0.0150615126,
0.016138969,
-0.0009344033,
-0.0354930833,
-0.0258714035,
-0.0827454478,
0.0433744155,
-0.0144493859,
0.0243377537,
0.0019863669,
-0.0434010923,
-0.0051987376,
-0.0215422567,
-0.009529734,
-0.0353999361,
0.0371589176,
-0.0144639974,
-0.0277663991,
-0.0171505418,
-0.0354420356,
0.0563647337,
-0.0212329533,
0.0124220755,
0.0184246358,
0.0626706779,
0.0070330324,
-0.0232755318,
0.0331770256,
-0.0102363108,
0.0057003344,
-0.0521318205,
0.0273335539,
-0.020416595,
-0.0301436633,
-0.01278341,
0.0232793652,
-0.0658853054,
0.0123038692,
-0.0062173395,
0.0591422878,
-0.0201002974,
-0.0565682389,
-0.0143570993,
0.0356584042,
0.008455039,
0.0668749809,
0.0110084554,
-0.0369301625,
-0.0520945638,
-0.0359868221,
-0.0563309938,
-0.0803273767,
0.0067976797,
-0.0258031022,
0.0122365896,
0.022245314,
-0.0469794497,
-0.0263666362,
-0.0198919903,
0.0560085401,
-0.0453690179,
0.0097920839,
-0.0089214398,
-0.003641387,
-0.0168479402,
0.005393561,
-0.0118003702,
0.0013529356,
0.0194035098,
-0.0015291986,
0.0452827737,
-0.0024281337,
-0.0083926199,
-0.0003473145,
-0.038547419,
-0.0675169751,
-0.0558463074,
0.0392344147,
0.0266465191,
0.0618065,
0.0095159439,
-0.0243047457,
0.0263242759,
0.068057701,
0.0196680631,
0.0078138383,
0.0698730722,
0.0738059729,
0.0134109762,
0.0346639827,
-0.0252576079,
0.0276728589,
0.0269341506,
0.0223253053,
-0.0600264668,
-0.0281862114,
0.0033289618,
-0.0109331869,
0.0179486498,
0.0195752233,
-0.0191382319,
-0.0068208342,
0.0013081875,
-0.0040273638,
-0.0155229801,
-0.0485243015,
-0.0004053387,
-0.0024265111,
-0.0308413059,
-0.0595178828,
-0.0059622861,
-0.0062164129,
0.0270351339,
0.0159079805,
0.0656629875,
0.0300399456,
-0.0273556206,
-0.0090409145,
0.0303591657,
-0.0115569122,
0.01914417,
0.0269998051,
0.006394513,
0.0134619568,
0.0227158628,
0.0489174873,
0.0203670822,
0.0017878071,
-0.0157203488,
-0.0303589068,
-0.0246611629,
0.0127996914,
0.0177189223,
0.0360270515,
0.0091187637,
0.0302265119,
-0.0214030799,
-0.0019242679,
0.0085770329,
0.0145047093,
-0.0275095589,
-0.0283067506,
0.0505980738,
0.0165949799,
-0.0244321078,
-0.0043940349,
0.0306295324,
-0.0728739426,
0.035651166,
0.013630013,
0.0160263404,
-0.057150986,
-0.0425991602,
0.0035243635,
-0.0027700241,
0.0410007276,
0.0107752457,
-0.0201044697,
-0.0569310337,
0.0759047046,
-0.0436099432,
0.01734096,
0.0003679439,
-0.0025929359,
0.0583681092,
0.0293849092,
0.0470798872,
-0.0328227617,
-0.0153322387,
0.003449206,
-0.0611022301,
-0.0097469073,
-6.239047204e-33,
0.0143208271,
-0.0455341972,
-0.0023662634,
0.0346612632,
-0.021653818,
-0.0227235164,
-0.045870278,
-0.0022739316,
-0.0330892801,
0.0738724768,
-0.0116767846,
0.0244952012,
0.0042695203,
0.0203722976,
-0.0059741354,
-0.052357126,
0.0213408638,
0.0180720259,
-0.0038224284,
0.0004212912,
0.0378281698,
0.0233597159,
0.0616781712,
-0.1052450389,
0.0397833399,
-0.0132057676,
-0.046834968,
0.0480864719,
-0.0069357399,
0.0406705551,
-0.0088701015,
0.054240793,
0.044157628,
-0.0351328254,
0.0195871219,
0.0275754854,
-0.0347470753,
-0.015736321,
0.0120598553,
-0.0219443049,
-0.0278820079,
-0.0387938023,
0.0380263925,
0.0213362146,
-0.018804241,
-0.0120243719,
0.0050561903,
-0.0081890114,
0.0325629152,
-0.0625484139,
-0.033201687,
0.0164465029,
-0.0386031196,
0.0047841771,
0.0205702409,
0.0135178966,
-0.0008434468,
0.0738431513,
-0.0850582644,
0.0034567814,
-0.0479894616,
-0.013940569,
0.0261435527,
-0.070561856,
-0.0254160427,
0.0952290744,
-0.003153271,
-0.0129045583,
-0.063575305,
0.0140350563,
-0.0005965347,
0.0556567237,
0.0505432338,
0.1021397561,
0.008613741,
-0.0312624089,
-0.1044187173,
0.0017124874,
0.067861259,
-0.0017155269,
0.044395376,
0.0254798736,
-0.0051514502,
-0.0148538612,
0.0170655511,
-0.0404325649,
-0.0347525738,
-0.0453747213,
-0.0027378604,
0.0274522584,
0.0037367423,
0.0026973125,
0.0053439722,
-0.0830852091,
-0.006483438,
0.0449600145,
-0.0126689412,
0.0148387253,
0.0409883484,
-0.0103295455,
-0.0222298168,
-0.0293877404,
-0.025392361,
0.0350203477,
0.0171272717,
0.0015867407,
0.0566944368,
0.0093590897,
-0.0570117198,
-0.0010844955,
-0.0296219643,
0.0449913964,
-0.0391833186,
0.026136836,
-0.0316479951,
0.0207162071,
-0.0182604324,
0.07561519,
0.0052630343,
0.0550310202,
-0.0014520517,
0.0123295104,
-0.0020572043,
0.0096627828,
-0.0306313597,
-0.0446564592,
0.0449324809,
-0.027507795,
-0.0094779786,
-0.067223452,
-0.0006695107,
-0.0163204707,
2.731e-7,
0.0350396968,
0.0418668315,
0.0139771979,
-0.002480224,
0.0485992581,
0.0559849143,
0.0028219523,
0.0276439358,
-0.0116980942,
-0.0666033998,
0.0299979318,
0.0426686928,
0.0119108325,
0.0310067665,
-0.0926193297,
0.0433122441,
-0.0445419885,
-0.0358217806,
0.0068307449,
0.0233783256,
0.0866853073,
0.0646366477,
0.0312608555,
-0.0347828679,
-0.0195042547,
-0.0027279428,
0.0629529282,
-0.0382409655,
-0.0063261064,
0.0351612046,
0.0378273018,
-0.0369957164,
0.0088978298,
-0.0048748758,
0.0150593854,
0.024942236,
-0.0499292389,
0.0796606317,
0.0061944164,
-0.0991731361,
0.0119013619,
-0.0030314031,
0.0372027755,
-0.0234859828,
0.0363194644,
-0.0484489277,
-0.0661279857,
-0.0887328312,
-0.0250005554,
-0.0263520107,
0.0360995941,
-0.0107663944,
0.0030050592,
0.0180688836,
-0.0102216518,
-0.0107437419,
-0.01982015,
-0.0997333527,
0.0069985916,
0.0011007867,
-0.0444905646,
-0.0045951102,
0.0379620418,
0.0267054327,
0.0561642684,
-0.033260826,
0.0144167505,
2.107208392e-34,
0.0880567357,
-0.0203125048,
0.0122041292,
0.0561232939,
0.0209130254,
0.030608343,
-0.0511630364,
-0.0166302193,
0.0442805849,
-0.0047301524,
-0.0038902974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01873v1 | Efficient Black-Box Adversarial Attacks on Neural Text Detectors | 2023-11-03T12:29:32 | 2023-11-03T12:29:32 | Vitalii Fishchuk, Daniel Braun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural text detectors are models trained to detect whether a given text was
generated by a language model or written by a human. In this paper, we
investigate three simple and resource-efficient strategies (parameter tweaking,
prompt engineering, and character-level mutations) to alter texts generated by
GPT-3.5 that are unsuspicious or unnoticeable for humans but cause
misclassification by neural text detectors. The results show that especially
parameter tweaking and character-level mutations are effective strategies. | [
0.0283854827,
0.05391993,
-0.0212260894,
0.0758454651,
-0.0328419991,
0.0214958042,
0.0056047556,
0.0421360135,
0.0197880957,
-0.0510419607,
-0.014808462,
0.000638148,
0.0236353762,
0.0579559319,
0.0657897368,
0.0008080247,
0.0496226251,
0.0163865723,
-0.0357666686,
0.0122873308,
0.0103909755,
0.0065711425,
0.028363714,
0.0130380001,
0.0095902858,
-0.0234034713,
-0.0058634127,
0.0129225245,
0.0080106715,
-0.0094502801,
0.0241075195,
0.0393714756,
-0.0147736762,
0.1342923492,
0.0000019005,
0.0106784441,
-0.0627184734,
0.0021693462,
-0.0146783907,
0.0501963235,
0.0497615039,
-0.0197072588,
-0.0494214334,
0.0309730656,
-0.0248210467,
-0.0075305207,
0.0293374881,
0.0714346021,
0.0450084209,
0.1091710776,
-0.0260777436,
-0.0013841219,
0.0572122,
-0.0460041016,
0.0377673991,
-0.0352628306,
0.0108669531,
-0.0482558161,
-0.0336237177,
0.0465245247,
0.002764513,
0.0280080475,
0.0503574535,
-0.000801134,
-0.0450953357,
0.0207498427,
-0.0077160723,
-0.0001025964,
-0.013990541,
0.038417697,
-0.0532394126,
-0.0305477977,
-0.0107803326,
-0.0026903297,
0.034649808,
-0.0164425932,
0.0485221744,
-0.0293416064,
-0.0193746407,
0.0230284482,
-0.0195861496,
-0.0435692146,
0.0258434042,
0.0026469962,
0.028844431,
0.0568395033,
0.0304738283,
-0.0219128374,
-0.0157744624,
-0.0059696846,
-0.0123886829,
-0.0420707501,
0.0346566476,
-0.0174284838,
0.0183655601,
-0.0008820601,
-0.0784329996,
-0.0519871041,
0.0124801416,
-0.0606252067,
0.021524556,
0.0094748726,
-0.0345399454,
0.0111808227,
-0.0834658891,
0.0507401004,
-0.0512939319,
0.0624085143,
-0.0075879698,
0.0329780802,
-0.0070840321,
-0.0157444477,
-0.0489441678,
-0.052779153,
0.0000728996,
0.0161247421,
-0.0271559022,
0.0237065274,
0.0320110321,
0.0049788514,
-0.055402413,
0.0113710724,
-0.0434713401,
-0.021095328,
0.0245681182,
-0.0350645781,
-0.0078465352,
-0.0446526147,
-0.0347192325,
-0.0865638927,
-0.0429430678,
0.0224514399,
-0.0078247134,
-0.0278116707,
-0.0018332818,
0.0555538274,
-0.0326483697,
-0.0312084015,
-0.0609640554,
-0.0348312519,
-0.027209023,
0.0008483216,
-0.0004463565,
-0.0190558899,
-0.0459069684,
-0.0496995077,
-0.02903465,
-0.0815971419,
0.0030681791,
0.0153402491,
0.0078920675,
0.0792385265,
-0.0032601971,
-0.074192293,
0.0485480689,
0.0116232848,
-0.0128505528,
0.0533553325,
0.0243712664,
0.0802837238,
0.0173560716,
-0.01073719,
0.0084626582,
0.0328238979,
0.0276930388,
0.0298918989,
0.001370154,
-0.0122233611,
0.0530451462,
0.0081407838,
0.0148179214,
0.0358729027,
-0.0082559101,
-0.0898946598,
0.0792115405,
0.0209301747,
-0.032158386,
0.0543473922,
0.037053261,
0.0006218851,
-0.0276566111,
0.0357993506,
-0.0318405032,
-0.0216088891,
-0.063301295,
-0.0359784216,
-0.0463269316,
0.0266757347,
0.003911024,
-0.0277899336,
0.0194223356,
-0.0161177032,
0.0377667174,
-0.060896907,
0.0252031498,
0.0028457043,
-0.0730006695,
-0.0156901348,
-0.0100149056,
-0.0226183645,
-0.0144354654,
-0.0721046478,
0.0055092042,
0.0295461398,
0.0584915429,
-0.0222469177,
0.0410187952,
-0.0439581349,
-0.0224533211,
0.0577475913,
0.0193982236,
0.0265607033,
0.0065496047,
-0.0462809727,
-0.0155356862,
-0.0413605049,
0.0212310739,
0.0926338509,
0.0411013477,
0.0284853298,
0.0447068028,
0.0051499391,
-0.0318296105,
0.0450683273,
0.002944167,
-0.1015054435,
-0.0055881334,
-0.0003719802,
0.0372568034,
-0.0158810113,
-0.0194104817,
0.0034746728,
0.0083297314,
-0.0288201682,
-0.0373293795,
0.001961604,
0.0093862424,
-0.0240182132,
-0.0022980617,
-0.0253683086,
-0.014579922,
0.065591462,
-0.0322359949,
-0.0018859351,
0.0056490698,
-0.0780421793,
0.0270620082,
-0.0364525244,
0.0116461068,
-0.0282912683,
0.0469903499,
-0.0267116912,
0.0401029401,
-0.0147307832,
-0.0388305672,
0.0052578733,
0.0140489535,
0.0436484851,
-0.0439764448,
-0.0250545405,
0.0156601164,
0.0228039753,
-0.0021112855,
0.0178204887,
0.0189417042,
-0.0037696802,
-0.0155970678,
-0.027202718,
-0.0064185387,
-0.0366994739,
0.0136041334,
0.06542743,
-0.0003695888,
-0.0040489445,
-0.0221837349,
-0.0391020253,
0.0101491958,
-0.035979338,
0.0072500836,
0.0311441105,
-0.0300056916,
0.0244073234,
-0.001166206,
-0.0173015967,
-0.0216791015,
0.0438881181,
0.0301903151,
-0.03738885,
-0.0863351077,
0.0077088326,
0.0116028618,
0.0687222257,
0.0058729853,
-0.070573695,
0.00412319,
0.0193366688,
0.0072986227,
0.1151038781,
0.0231696814,
0.0422140807,
0.010967222,
0.0716125816,
0.0088227708,
0.0185192022,
0.039862033,
-0.0121495333,
-0.0284929201,
-0.0696641728,
0.0464717448,
0.0420298539,
0.0298963841,
-0.0090868073,
-0.051954329,
0.0561309904,
-0.0123408977,
-0.0571972169,
0.0017508295,
-0.0235495158,
-0.0407204889,
-0.0224110149,
-0.0409278274,
-0.0740779266,
0.0640499592,
-0.0503498279,
-0.0057561244,
-0.0476616062,
-0.0303618647,
0.0115667405,
0.0246876217,
0.0372742191,
0.0267869104,
0.0256079398,
-0.0018928997,
-0.0331948139,
0.0049609188,
0.0431866236,
0.008419456,
-0.0161992628,
0.0043023368,
-0.0116510577,
-0.0077997372,
-0.0319397822,
-0.038263116,
-0.0586807802,
0.0026626019,
0.0069438736,
0.0306001846,
-0.0394406803,
-0.0317342542,
-0.0084865596,
-0.0073521165,
0.0816565081,
-0.0356228985,
0.0012355348,
-0.0518604107,
0.0234130025,
0.0248561576,
-0.0522212163,
0.0148016335,
-0.0310610849,
-0.0035839402,
0.0632821694,
-0.0161243454,
0.0048866356,
-0.0140115898,
-0.015860267,
-0.0029191005,
-0.0008552756,
-0.0236019101,
0.0049504796,
0.0112487692,
-0.0516003184,
-0.0232841056,
0.0670389012,
0.0088729318,
-0.0327708758,
0.0183349717,
0.0098738633,
0.0482003838,
-0.0289518181,
0.0064229635,
-0.0601281188,
-0.0371457413,
0.0281246807,
0.0302257277,
-0.0491957478,
0.0099056968,
-0.0285579301,
-0.0726232752,
-0.0179691985,
0.0428278223,
-0.0229058582,
0.0023829087,
0.0425689183,
-0.0148669481,
-0.0042907358,
0.0259505268,
0.0160702672,
0.0399338417,
0.0049820361,
-0.0283710938,
0.0243625008,
-0.0335169658,
-0.0177760199,
0.0099644847,
-0.0023186088,
0.0831445903,
0.0127083845,
-0.023070436,
-0.0348445401,
0.0368293189,
-0.0056024105,
0.0006440554,
0.0196177773,
0.0787324905,
-0.008481089,
-0.0264428742,
0.0103788758,
0.0517118387,
-0.0214797277,
0.0153634986,
-0.000034546,
0.0121773425,
0.0025352642,
-0.0420091003,
-0.0109866718,
-0.0294945501,
0.0178346541,
0.042306561,
0.0127784302,
-0.0445712246,
-0.055451449,
-0.061920099,
0.0444294661,
-0.0848418325,
-0.0516923591,
-0.0023409876,
0.0060284408,
-0.0786409304,
-0.064961113,
-0.0243128985,
-0.032678578,
0.0118621588,
0.0052899136,
0.0001591001,
-0.0107390406,
-0.0113326441,
-0.018905038,
-0.0013284816,
0.00252087,
0.0067672888,
-0.0464870036,
-0.0266596116,
0.0111062266,
-0.0202646498,
-0.0187193491,
0.0410961434,
-0.0808804706,
-0.0636130348,
0.0183375422,
0.0098859929,
0.0153216459,
0.0299475901,
-0.0502529405,
-0.0660154745,
0.0469543971,
0.0328114741,
0.0178391077,
0.02899299,
0.0361843184,
-0.021772638,
-0.0169904213,
0.0227016732,
-0.0008683269,
0.0005134904,
0.0604072139,
-0.0625039712,
-0.0384549946,
0.0380093977,
0.0336743481,
0.0167984162,
0.0320317149,
-0.0260620508,
0.0253882166,
0.0157228671,
0.0283114854,
-0.0212047528,
0.038099248,
-0.0308907572,
0.0107338103,
0.0277665555,
-0.006164304,
-0.0076022767,
-0.0268799067,
-0.0019833629,
0.0202931743,
-0.0348072909,
0.001149292,
0.032646466,
0.0607766323,
0.0270364657,
0.0006962437,
0.0096247913,
0.0863004923,
-0.0068046208,
0.0299057122,
-0.0062967255,
0.0515002497,
0.0216983408,
-0.0200127717,
-0.0069920444,
0.0498311408,
-0.0752000883,
-0.003740622,
-0.0629700422,
0.039021194,
0.0317798294,
0.024524197,
0.0064016907,
-0.0345685296,
-0.0311284401,
0.0099658528,
-0.010254791,
0.0060553285,
0.0016122474,
-0.0148279369,
-0.0045567458,
-0.0027650686,
-0.0106575219,
0.0593288988,
0.0665097088,
0.0708740652,
0.0076084817,
-0.0401533432,
-0.0327025615,
-0.0048572915,
0.0174337886,
-0.0244571101,
-0.0154408235,
0.0200913139,
-0.0164176021,
-0.0528295636,
0.0031344849,
0.0233283825,
0.0378286354,
0.0063989772,
-0.0075807543,
0.0339252278,
-0.0420636721,
-0.0086609591,
-0.0105877239,
0.0383352377,
0.0129277147,
-0.0523367077,
-0.0060741864,
-5.903909357e-33,
-0.0103355655,
-0.0436250903,
-0.064038597,
-0.025442481,
0.0233255103,
0.0002289455,
-0.0065484154,
-0.0273248274,
0.0170611981,
-0.0039066165,
-0.0037003136,
0.043812871,
-0.0045834295,
0.0076588318,
-0.0511536077,
-0.0336799212,
0.0731207654,
-0.0216623545,
-0.0354003198,
0.0150252655,
0.047964111,
0.0324501656,
0.0462772474,
-0.0409330316,
0.0477101728,
-0.0097825387,
-0.0482631549,
-0.0049902298,
-0.0740943849,
0.0268451981,
-0.0062413504,
0.0259582121,
0.0168790631,
-0.003056267,
-0.0072526825,
0.0379222929,
-0.0009080822,
0.0001893574,
-0.0248646196,
0.0380481333,
-0.018122863,
-0.0798062682,
0.0395735949,
-0.04444113,
0.0003440929,
0.0119680287,
0.0106446324,
-0.0065118857,
0.0385791473,
0.0152998837,
-0.0501300655,
0.0243702047,
-0.000418377,
0.0125865489,
0.005039773,
0.0157850198,
0.0156909153,
-0.0072955578,
-0.043910604,
-0.0402351245,
0.0717976019,
0.0101313572,
-0.0188853741,
0.029190246,
-0.000661417,
0.0405761302,
0.0612701662,
0.0307333972,
-0.0221179817,
-0.0313049108,
0.0204801466,
-0.0236445516,
0.1212175116,
0.0811090842,
0.0531162433,
-0.0289207883,
-0.0609426387,
0.0119294887,
0.0086733019,
-0.0072684307,
0.0152867073,
0.0134889167,
-0.0332166143,
-0.006749541,
-0.0162795205,
-0.111954011,
-0.0190011859,
-0.020903483,
0.0211964697,
0.0028150708,
-0.0160008594,
-0.0203028284,
0.0053428835,
-0.0451030061,
0.0374677069,
0.0146412849,
-0.0412776545,
-0.0126266582,
0.0119663039,
0.0422512703,
0.0259733517,
0.0062357984,
0.0486637093,
0.0122136613,
0.0402714945,
-0.0058554644,
0.0466500483,
0.034760166,
-0.043410942,
0.0130006159,
-0.0282838345,
0.024321802,
0.040272627,
0.0403067768,
0.0162180495,
-0.040487431,
0.0080106361,
-0.0268238187,
0.0341250934,
-0.0028678305,
-0.0304536689,
0.018218454,
-0.013557422,
0.0176502392,
-0.0371311679,
0.0083427448,
0.0465134606,
0.0400531814,
0.0471510477,
-0.0757920519,
0.0222285595,
-0.026096452,
2.686e-7,
0.0259787012,
0.0287891626,
0.0229308922,
-0.0299753025,
0.0644605383,
0.0681203008,
0.0039395937,
0.059927173,
-0.0030420243,
0.0100313583,
0.0025970389,
-0.0102928197,
0.0655877292,
-0.0011639491,
-0.0612511709,
0.0219365284,
-0.089267455,
0.0516917855,
-0.0447288714,
0.0142962914,
0.055703491,
0.0597345605,
0.0234637279,
-0.031627126,
0.0421665534,
-0.0789721534,
0.0257316232,
-0.0460415818,
0.0271987505,
-0.007743008,
0.0342212468,
0.0379708745,
0.0067514242,
0.0123579251,
-0.0225213133,
-0.0404808335,
-0.0059679803,
0.0521979071,
-0.0351975895,
0.031443201,
-0.0228304733,
-0.0002659571,
-0.0074701747,
-0.0358532667,
0.0659379587,
0.0291242842,
-0.0167946573,
-0.0044868542,
0.0176976081,
-0.0579090007,
0.0460874364,
-0.0445672125,
-0.0370118506,
0.0060266042,
-0.000225853,
0.012494511,
0.0132330293,
-0.0438241363,
-0.0154115856,
-0.0293271579,
-0.0295343678,
-0.0228449851,
-0.0829130411,
0.0285195895,
0.0356307663,
-0.0207611471,
0.0105821341,
2.327007928e-34,
0.0064555276,
-0.0302907508,
0.0095844008,
-0.0055950815,
0.0438129306,
0.0033433859,
0.0471442379,
-0.0273280758,
0.0164236668,
-0.0459709875,
-0.0362535864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01870v1 | Multi-EuP: The Multilingual European Parliament Dataset for Analysis of Bias in Information Retrieval | 2023-11-03T12:29:11 | 2023-11-03T12:29:11 | Jinrui Yang, Timothy Baldwin, Trevor Cohn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | We present Multi-EuP, a new multilingual benchmark dataset, comprising 22K
multi-lingual documents collected from the European Parliament, spanning 24
languages. This dataset is designed to investigate fairness in a multilingual
information retrieval (IR) context to analyze both language and demographic
bias in a ranking context. It boasts an authentic multilingual corpus,
featuring topics translated into all 24 languages, as well as cross-lingual
relevance judgments. Furthermore, it offers rich demographic information
associated with its documents, facilitating the study of demographic bias. We
report the effectiveness of Multi-EuP for benchmarking both monolingual and
multilingual IR. We also conduct a preliminary experiment on language bias
caused by the choice of tokenization strategy. | [
0.0405757725,
0.06614279,
-0.0261861384,
0.0459971689,
-0.0102859158,
0.012197108,
0.0370810293,
0.0107571278,
0.0074571203,
-0.0250833873,
-0.024328934,
-0.0143323876,
0.0041491338,
-0.029319657,
-0.0098658483,
-0.0367491543,
0.0513627529,
0.0380148403,
0.0303774569,
-0.0548407249,
0.0167907849,
0.0166459363,
0.0401988663,
0.0491758771,
0.0132370042,
0.0629904345,
0.0443251394,
0.0143010681,
0.0131803676,
0.0047497228,
0.017019514,
0.02672421,
-0.0232500862,
0.0635121316,
0.0000014586,
-0.0494237132,
-0.0372902527,
0.015485541,
0.0065927948,
-0.0129479188,
0.0869624391,
-0.0131798862,
-0.0026175634,
0.0043558259,
-0.0192054324,
0.0200178977,
0.0121253608,
-0.0340580381,
0.0336101465,
-0.001609702,
0.0184115469,
-0.0030530042,
-0.0751946196,
-0.0417696983,
0.0107171405,
-0.0039501577,
0.0185560603,
-0.033122167,
-0.0519152284,
0.005542885,
-0.0121794436,
-0.0012819663,
-0.0271431487,
-0.0072298232,
0.0040066559,
-0.0010179746,
-0.0827468708,
-0.0384555757,
0.0418333821,
0.0204285793,
0.0398348607,
0.0068065999,
-0.0012880981,
0.0191731472,
0.0257863812,
0.0477533825,
-0.045854304,
0.0338533334,
-0.0212660916,
0.012508763,
0.0297967214,
0.0389360003,
0.0026378501,
0.0542462431,
-0.0154658258,
0.0758507103,
0.0269143339,
-0.0472095422,
0.0427501388,
0.0247476343,
0.0465894938,
-0.0075148088,
0.0298267547,
-0.0244400706,
-0.0137532707,
-0.0101617612,
0.0482296124,
-0.0251573063,
0.0757351071,
-0.0886463374,
-0.0685964301,
0.0065970137,
-0.030491557,
0.0535242185,
0.0269212853,
0.0287371259,
0.009234136,
0.0153917223,
-0.0359281152,
-0.0604364946,
0.0129861645,
0.0143859079,
0.0339735597,
-0.0083822198,
-0.0273295082,
0.0692329109,
-0.0799987912,
-0.0018069615,
-0.0346918367,
-0.0093235895,
0.0145876668,
0.0073778913,
-0.0359067321,
0.0048063179,
-0.0716483891,
0.0276464578,
-0.0394429192,
-0.0008706982,
-0.0822975785,
-0.0372514799,
0.0235867109,
0.0071587469,
-0.0104284175,
-0.0607196502,
0.0483336523,
0.0256328266,
0.0090324236,
0.0034296657,
0.0128470957,
-0.0150072444,
0.0442332514,
-0.0218478069,
0.0113544036,
-0.0571071506,
0.0525775328,
0.001394877,
0.029166922,
-0.0146996127,
-0.0285254158,
0.0190933943,
-0.0771709383,
0.0435589813,
0.0344597735,
-0.0203786362,
0.0556568913,
0.0015110406,
-0.0109394239,
0.0753932744,
-0.0407004207,
-0.0022975614,
0.08313521,
0.0392158367,
-0.0474206842,
0.0204127282,
0.0155529715,
0.0455086567,
0.0039393762,
0.0604579449,
-0.0350122266,
-0.0120277097,
0.0616935678,
0.0132523039,
-0.0145076234,
-0.0346221104,
-0.0170162003,
0.0450713076,
0.0278299134,
-0.0169356894,
-0.0593492873,
-0.0070991525,
-0.0476285592,
0.0089525199,
-0.029892901,
0.007594184,
0.0282929335,
-0.0403995253,
0.0559049211,
0.045126427,
-0.0236326866,
-0.0257361289,
0.0249955058,
0.0672205687,
0.0333363302,
-0.004535662,
0.029823618,
-0.0157541893,
0.0211403687,
0.0691710562,
0.0334182046,
-0.0474118181,
0.0270082634,
-0.0388038084,
-0.0097727394,
0.0298822466,
0.0056808763,
-0.0613103919,
0.0125047965,
-0.00015348,
0.0200373735,
0.0363439545,
0.0259972643,
-0.0266005397,
0.0186302532,
-0.0158566106,
-0.0451774821,
0.0414771028,
0.0126742637,
0.0315037742,
0.0043929131,
0.0659126863,
0.0007052195,
-0.0849984959,
0.0023116078,
0.0498077162,
0.0225492846,
0.0156180477,
0.0148904081,
0.0082806442,
-0.0041032913,
0.0078820251,
-0.0228482857,
-0.0181060247,
0.0113082295,
-0.0044689728,
0.0432873927,
-0.0285849329,
0.0071484493,
0.0204963535,
0.045904249,
-0.084707208,
-0.0029049374,
0.0328808278,
-0.0334067605,
0.0006778244,
0.0316989943,
0.0336509906,
-0.0081512826,
-0.0075106709,
0.0116651384,
-0.0460043252,
0.0141203338,
-0.0618696064,
0.0576220974,
-0.014242813,
0.0662051365,
0.0452842079,
-0.0332115702,
0.0358446874,
-0.0490105487,
-0.0397850201,
0.0468125008,
-0.0002633077,
0.0041761049,
0.0687274784,
0.0148951625,
-0.0062928302,
0.0113487458,
-0.0781455487,
0.0011083602,
-0.0498806834,
0.0410921387,
-0.010218163,
-0.0010980261,
-0.0044572977,
-0.0216194615,
-0.0291760229,
-0.081280224,
-0.0283320118,
0.0374122933,
0.0155748455,
-0.0094108609,
0.0382996239,
-0.0318635292,
-0.0687283203,
0.010198174,
0.0538206175,
0.0331998058,
0.00441491,
-0.0131736575,
-0.0206312258,
-0.0688195005,
0.0165877081,
-0.055442173,
0.0202481765,
0.0106604397,
0.0255857334,
0.0159685276,
0.0405781902,
0.0403918438,
-0.0083706463,
0.0664410442,
-0.014815188,
-0.0661375895,
-0.0154651143,
0.005583459,
0.0569150485,
-0.0049360399,
-0.0687162727,
0.0552590303,
-0.0441007949,
-0.0149861956,
-0.0087516159,
-0.0332481302,
0.0250402987,
-0.0525994189,
-0.0228121299,
-0.1037767828,
0.0106521407,
0.0104067689,
0.0413859561,
-0.0075180675,
-0.0377944559,
0.0026780753,
0.0241700616,
0.0557105877,
-0.0312272422,
0.0081350673,
-0.0570384227,
0.0282313302,
-0.0320683271,
0.0266539399,
-0.0634903759,
-0.011029385,
-0.0263063256,
0.0029878963,
0.0865605772,
-0.0520471856,
0.0484044328,
-0.002983764,
-0.0028478322,
-0.0589252785,
-0.0708679929,
-0.0225519463,
-0.0587719679,
0.0347041376,
-0.0037670622,
0.0254483148,
-0.0250370782,
-0.0835155845,
-0.002602075,
0.0295731109,
0.0245187134,
-0.0054802154,
-0.0077536339,
0.0367212072,
0.0155732669,
-0.0043635392,
-0.0245143492,
0.0134009654,
-0.0146074025,
-0.0347281136,
0.0000179141,
0.0327036493,
-0.016381925,
0.0590211861,
-0.0107501736,
0.0429867692,
-0.0757874027,
-0.0458617583,
-0.0551771671,
-0.0008433186,
-0.0216205548,
0.0226723757,
0.0556512699,
0.0243164711,
-0.0940819383,
-0.031340953,
-0.0649406761,
0.0072391173,
0.0364834331,
0.0185948219,
-0.0807167068,
0.0375305191,
0.0358498245,
0.035305839,
-0.0469319895,
-0.029605709,
-0.0145017877,
-0.0528425351,
0.0363530442,
-0.0182245821,
-0.039104905,
-0.0375026688,
-0.0524710603,
-0.007812317,
-0.0618122108,
0.0247730501,
0.0135687375,
0.0029081916,
0.0182635728,
-0.007753456,
-0.045255512,
-0.0440116674,
0.0275838654,
-0.0480962954,
-0.0021214332,
0.0005255833,
0.0853712931,
-0.0602522455,
-0.0092517119,
0.025499681,
-0.0370877646,
-0.0486612022,
-0.0418659151,
0.0439776331,
-0.0335547142,
-0.0054788832,
-0.0399455316,
-0.0204021521,
0.0620174296,
0.0468186326,
0.0215275418,
-0.009362123,
-0.0025929727,
0.0262161605,
-0.0369772948,
-0.0437306799,
-0.0017374007,
0.0371822417,
-0.0302678868,
0.0073960465,
0.0212808996,
-0.0878546461,
0.0169219375,
-0.0241225138,
-0.0305334721,
0.0470079295,
-0.0304397065,
-0.0406867899,
-0.0085642477,
-0.0509679727,
-0.0258643515,
-0.0193722248,
-0.0037886999,
-0.0063690669,
-0.0356780812,
-0.018961627,
-0.0359895602,
0.0202376228,
-0.0092456583,
0.0238005072,
-0.0152759356,
-0.0089635942,
-0.0180294812,
0.0075940299,
-0.0614108257,
-0.0369723365,
0.0164195951,
-0.0189517438,
0.0159132462,
0.0064169113,
0.0131395375,
0.0461578742,
-0.0113187172,
-0.0395966619,
0.0652736649,
0.055658754,
0.0066905082,
-0.027873069,
0.0070524593,
-0.0069988021,
-0.0180719346,
0.0173438415,
-0.0788825303,
0.0299929157,
-0.000017464,
0.0002681264,
-0.0039552343,
0.0098788515,
0.0148543818,
0.0488906503,
0.0208880827,
-0.0412414186,
-0.0086780479,
-0.0644928068,
-0.0136196529,
-0.0100168856,
-0.0360699631,
0.0129097961,
0.0040739337,
0.0288453493,
-0.0063222991,
-0.0141083812,
0.0472083576,
-0.0141553953,
0.0046554059,
-0.0614522472,
0.0520202331,
-0.006053884,
0.0391961634,
0.0092688799,
-0.0048214863,
-0.0220372304,
0.0211636834,
-0.0060513639,
0.0468883626,
-0.0321703292,
-0.035416808,
0.0179469679,
0.0103851845,
0.005320101,
0.009258192,
-0.0541104414,
0.0173122007,
-0.0006562053,
-0.0496900976,
0.0517319813,
0.002682873,
0.0355328582,
0.0278903581,
-0.0129364636,
0.0265022907,
-0.0456925221,
0.0392456874,
0.0031497837,
0.0360623933,
-0.0134899337,
-0.0012447429,
0.0541079789,
0.0720747039,
0.0148411961,
-0.0035659638,
-0.0419078767,
-0.0519286394,
0.0065222005,
-0.0234072413,
0.0310625471,
0.0043840148,
-0.0438627303,
-0.0734951645,
-0.0524363071,
-0.0065624565,
-0.0175470468,
0.0004070221,
0.0129726743,
-0.0143541489,
0.0065358891,
0.0849187523,
0.0102776662,
-0.0000551099,
-0.0500310697,
-0.0351932384,
-0.0529760793,
-0.0009055231,
-0.0166004263,
-5.519175566e-33,
-0.0048911371,
0.0108757429,
-0.016458841,
-0.0485131145,
0.0157368127,
0.000507329,
0.0303360112,
-0.0407072939,
-0.0554523915,
0.0068032634,
-0.0258468743,
0.0410144106,
0.0226667691,
-0.012799493,
0.036543157,
-0.0014746301,
0.0417391174,
0.0423674062,
-0.0265061259,
0.0012949727,
0.0218006931,
0.005223895,
0.0561436862,
-0.0453669876,
0.1159020886,
0.0391772464,
-0.0049387161,
0.0182171892,
0.0313694701,
0.0432261601,
0.0128923114,
0.0798436254,
0.0468327403,
-0.0317111015,
0.0023315125,
0.0283226166,
-0.0484677441,
-0.0264394935,
0.0212012939,
0.0414537042,
0.028314542,
0.0007583289,
0.0406220332,
0.0483730212,
-0.048762355,
0.0022061944,
0.0848341733,
0.0289602224,
-0.0142923379,
-0.018201828,
0.0114795268,
0.0315783173,
-0.0434520915,
0.0859651342,
0.0224789493,
0.0673272237,
0.0152980983,
0.0838643983,
-0.0594493039,
0.0356684513,
-0.0685025379,
0.0153049463,
0.020753704,
-0.0131135471,
-0.0006556181,
0.0468383022,
0.0139983753,
0.0532158278,
0.0074167228,
-0.0567416102,
0.0202363227,
-0.0356826484,
0.0032119788,
0.0784325898,
0.057099171,
-0.0354390927,
-0.0896312445,
0.0498398989,
0.0352628641,
0.0300074033,
0.0079822363,
-0.0046204012,
-0.0385510735,
-0.0171584785,
-0.0135130724,
-0.0225839429,
-0.020534426,
-0.0110580688,
0.0218990128,
0.0229679327,
0.0017471395,
-0.0021793654,
0.0130984476,
-0.0299169496,
-0.0376390219,
0.0397875085,
-0.0220977478,
-0.0487436689,
0.0263113454,
0.0265088845,
-0.0399226658,
-0.0170728862,
-0.0013988353,
0.0260796063,
0.0029586449,
-0.0140662538,
-0.0077117532,
-0.0095939627,
-0.0657569915,
0.0014415133,
-0.0045157149,
-0.0100937299,
-0.0148333656,
0.033344239,
-0.0042072488,
0.0061625289,
0.008388781,
-0.0104720499,
0.0541292727,
0.0341523029,
-0.0215562768,
-0.0496276654,
-0.0307842828,
0.0239916481,
-0.0136339609,
-0.0096812006,
-0.0210238006,
0.0135436449,
0.0355787911,
-0.0250771083,
-0.013521553,
-0.0196856838,
2.266e-7,
0.0507644005,
0.0448860005,
-0.0410023183,
0.0015687902,
0.0010365832,
-0.0006641335,
-0.000381354,
0.0774423853,
-0.0118329376,
0.0274599157,
-0.0030042266,
-0.0160707161,
-0.0004274557,
0.0587104484,
-0.0762751475,
-0.0223470051,
-0.0759471655,
-0.0006576497,
-0.0406169668,
0.0028895824,
-0.0418808274,
0.0667698681,
-0.0051074447,
-0.0058866912,
-0.0259498395,
-0.0381340533,
0.0049454295,
-0.0329852775,
-0.0425329506,
0.0024858927,
0.0617450848,
0.005414749,
0.0239341166,
0.0295861084,
-0.006786956,
0.0235280227,
0.0380664244,
-0.0092923697,
-0.0204117019,
0.0426755175,
-0.0013047783,
-0.0379530899,
-0.0134190889,
-0.0429716744,
0.0464285985,
0.0618316531,
-0.00950843,
-0.0326793976,
-0.0373324007,
0.02472152,
0.0963776484,
-0.0079393219,
-0.0477359816,
0.007881335,
0.018524738,
0.0182259213,
0.0078927623,
-0.0416478254,
0.0075683855,
-0.043378666,
-0.0157105699,
-0.0523067266,
0.0079402281,
0.0314082466,
-0.0276673734,
0.0087540373,
0.0368960463,
1.602842452e-34,
0.0435821228,
0.0066144993,
-0.0108346427,
-0.0621627644,
0.0190172885,
-0.0027922669,
-0.01001467,
-0.0201988388,
-0.0159063414,
-0.0091661122,
0.0155001627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01866v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01866v1 | Towards Concept-Aware Large Language Models | 2023-11-03T12:19:22 | 2023-11-03T12:19:22 | Chen Shani, Jilles Vreeken, Dafna Shahaf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Concepts play a pivotal role in various human cognitive functions, including
learning, reasoning and communication. However, there is very little work on
endowing machines with the ability to form and reason with concepts. In
particular, state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) work at the level of
tokens, not concepts.
In this work, we analyze how well contemporary LLMs capture human concepts
and their structure. We then discuss ways to develop concept-aware LLMs, taking
place at different stages of the pipeline. We sketch a method for pretraining
LLMs using concepts, and also explore the simpler approach that uses the output
of existing LLMs. Despite its simplicity, our proof-of-concept is shown to
better match human intuition, as well as improve the robustness of predictions.
These preliminary results underscore the promise of concept-aware LLMs. | [
0.0264442507,
0.060988944,
-0.0313232392,
0.0647493154,
-0.0133771943,
0.0161761139,
-0.0311777648,
0.0055837124,
-0.0481001064,
-0.0619779527,
-0.0276844259,
-0.0380668268,
0.0005366115,
0.083277218,
0.0461170599,
-0.0533576272,
0.0227033272,
-0.0573262535,
-0.0002285239,
0.0229578689,
-0.0029654133,
0.0219077878,
0.0198340379,
0.0504866503,
-0.0131089333,
-0.0320177861,
-0.0079775248,
-0.01463803,
-0.0151833249,
-0.0291991848,
-0.0251554698,
0.0363643654,
0.0553146489,
0.0275228564,
0.0000022232,
-0.0507299863,
0.0114999395,
-0.0378206261,
-0.0121781593,
0.0187328402,
0.0158451721,
-0.0143735092,
-0.0005521382,
-0.0107914014,
-0.0340872407,
-0.0145303523,
0.0250507481,
0.0715014562,
0.0422236994,
0.0518205874,
-0.017379418,
-0.0283664875,
0.0310341287,
-0.0208016653,
0.0215618592,
-0.0160713792,
0.0453581028,
-0.0196626522,
-0.0009793674,
0.0041565336,
-0.0065870611,
0.0023636711,
0.000844886,
0.0040142955,
0.0259461869,
0.0546559095,
0.0005966825,
-0.0428830087,
0.0078035397,
0.0808028281,
-0.0025943355,
-0.0267673116,
0.0052849255,
-0.0134780305,
-0.0126186041,
-0.0226417538,
-0.0354113877,
0.021806458,
0.0186430421,
0.0289091468,
0.0224292297,
-0.0058398722,
0.0543307848,
0.0721342042,
-0.07550776,
0.0641104355,
-0.0000060453,
-0.0161348283,
0.0011003154,
0.0050097159,
-0.0613781735,
-0.0705775321,
-0.0248074029,
0.0299311318,
-0.014859261,
0.0168766528,
-0.0389600992,
-0.0041265916,
0.0089132851,
-0.0358605012,
0.0234522726,
0.0260048211,
-0.0179336667,
0.0756769404,
-0.0410921127,
0.0677934438,
-0.0251114033,
0.0104663968,
-0.0429560617,
-0.0130610773,
-0.0375569426,
-0.0025569221,
-0.0237247478,
0.0375685766,
-0.0059250607,
-0.0268714856,
-0.0138951438,
0.0730200633,
0.0032889841,
0.0165472683,
-0.0227793567,
-0.0165247731,
-0.0012823399,
-0.0528713837,
-0.0443443693,
0.0040433253,
-0.0250760764,
0.0254233219,
0.0056881383,
-0.0748610869,
-0.0087827723,
0.0065778955,
-0.0214231387,
-0.0105907805,
0.0173712112,
0.0357585326,
0.0090202717,
-0.0222573336,
-0.0296637584,
-0.0300927293,
-0.0076403422,
-0.0639280677,
-0.0228302237,
-0.0504080243,
0.013431848,
0.0163830016,
0.0105702812,
-0.0421475209,
0.013909244,
0.0229428057,
-0.036674194,
0.1086483076,
-0.0204287563,
0.0317629166,
0.0191182066,
0.0017453985,
-0.0480334759,
0.0557983927,
0.0472544581,
0.0319618657,
0.0235872883,
-0.0071925675,
-0.036365483,
0.038187474,
0.013958347,
-0.0359325893,
-0.0368928574,
0.0061817099,
0.0140944282,
0.0563816428,
0.023012206,
0.0607077032,
-0.0160391834,
0.0431036726,
0.0778562501,
0.0804658756,
-0.0171186738,
0.0379109643,
0.0557632744,
0.0099703828,
-0.0071764262,
-0.0376982354,
-0.083059974,
0.000463419,
-0.0207905974,
0.0144745009,
0.0253214352,
0.0300969444,
-0.0401536562,
-0.0208357181,
-0.0301133897,
-0.0108129568,
-0.0021743192,
-0.0021465376,
0.060742408,
-0.0021714792,
-0.01952786,
0.0366484784,
0.045383092,
-0.0196393076,
0.02045363,
-0.0858962908,
0.0734139904,
0.0649779364,
0.0459549017,
-0.0010542917,
0.0046464493,
0.0191455856,
0.0180596188,
0.0349853784,
0.0340871066,
-0.0105667477,
-0.0159645826,
-0.0467910208,
0.0117134452,
-0.0018733343,
-0.0076292125,
0.0010813291,
0.0303940997,
-0.0044526225,
0.0117791286,
-0.0608880334,
-0.0050588003,
0.0523164719,
0.0215243045,
-0.0021435393,
0.006017521,
0.0155912237,
0.035059005,
0.00516561,
0.0144097647,
0.034981966,
0.0435582437,
-0.0423397608,
-0.0265534185,
0.0028744186,
-0.0758943781,
-0.0155997863,
0.0139757888,
0.0267391652,
-0.0017735352,
-0.0095603364,
-0.0300960261,
-0.01715816,
0.0166703537,
-0.0171880759,
0.0641153678,
-0.0560916364,
0.0329698995,
0.0260069445,
0.0067124609,
-0.0104015144,
0.0793610066,
0.0008751542,
-0.0019764113,
-0.0174705647,
0.0104188826,
-0.0288434848,
-0.0186675936,
-0.044723548,
0.0103071025,
-0.0057179467,
-0.0049635833,
0.0150324265,
-0.0078859078,
-0.0397766158,
-0.0226270854,
-0.07696601,
-0.0294726565,
0.0024335426,
-0.0159098785,
-0.0059719062,
-0.0111040641,
-0.0013435838,
-0.012697719,
-0.0056849821,
0.0202288888,
0.0126069076,
0.0246313848,
0.0308650602,
0.0003332966,
-0.0405703001,
-0.0197785608,
0.0041723624,
-0.0096731801,
0.0635467321,
-0.0061238375,
-0.0254770424,
-0.0445559584,
0.0274931751,
-0.0283582639,
0.0100194691,
-0.0072131027,
-0.0260530449,
0.0240118597,
-0.0440846905,
0.0343625471,
0.0656732619,
0.0407879576,
0.029874431,
0.0596022494,
-0.0062679704,
-0.0582116768,
0.0107385935,
-0.0187223759,
-0.0170656275,
-0.0227792915,
0.0032289573,
0.0031843637,
0.0835465491,
-0.0187380407,
0.0222107414,
-0.0686799511,
0.0396347232,
-0.0210355148,
-0.0289940238,
-0.0702262148,
-0.0204504449,
-0.0120432898,
0.0015988488,
-0.0363935232,
-0.0314973406,
0.0839804783,
-0.0394816436,
-0.0031462885,
0.0168899447,
-0.0170343388,
-0.0264111534,
0.0789055228,
0.001165896,
0.0050121471,
0.026207814,
0.0024994789,
-0.0378671326,
0.0015867043,
-0.0148385363,
-0.0210602731,
0.0694713965,
-0.0642269701,
0.0189089999,
0.0211806968,
-0.0460524298,
-0.0759661868,
0.0256192647,
-0.0701465309,
0.0208021961,
0.0211638659,
-0.0108254496,
-0.0389866829,
0.0267640315,
0.0187189747,
0.0132284546,
0.0130660739,
0.001924857,
-0.0280759484,
0.000778996,
0.056287542,
0.0022733822,
0.0108793611,
-0.0418533087,
0.0556215644,
0.0534907393,
0.013810928,
-0.0346904919,
-0.019719718,
0.010752283,
0.0245046224,
-0.0170827955,
-0.0162595976,
0.0363463089,
0.0202309638,
-0.0506637953,
-0.0389140919,
0.1554198563,
0.0338089503,
-0.0431696214,
0.0077653909,
-0.0146107618,
0.0392073169,
0.0171885584,
0.0071314145,
-0.0651519373,
-0.0657104477,
0.0229398813,
-0.0124673648,
0.0127502037,
-0.0252666529,
-0.0208333135,
-0.0957960263,
0.0186470486,
0.0074708243,
-0.06538371,
-0.0540760681,
-0.0376463123,
-0.0077992664,
-0.0138004264,
0.0045565614,
0.0268462207,
0.0044167554,
-0.0050285016,
0.0115987305,
-0.042018611,
-0.0363510214,
0.0579319187,
-0.0444118045,
0.031281013,
0.0568901822,
0.0413931645,
0.0186558552,
-0.0458943732,
0.0107301222,
-0.0571391359,
0.0200690273,
-0.0118829673,
0.0085934736,
-0.0487604588,
-0.0025986657,
0.0017792417,
0.0510718152,
-0.0483192094,
-0.0650447682,
-0.0074766604,
0.0711228624,
-0.0310168862,
-0.037267141,
-0.000561645,
-0.0235200226,
-0.0011166834,
0.1216919124,
0.0433905013,
-0.0585373417,
-0.0154782319,
0.0060699331,
-0.0245896857,
0.0101815797,
-0.0197301321,
-0.0526229218,
0.0155803086,
0.0149112241,
-0.0780555755,
-0.00024406,
0.0355246924,
0.0138458544,
-0.0011941426,
-0.0114855515,
0.0048307669,
0.0199581161,
-0.053335499,
0.062591657,
-0.0263614021,
0.0093728844,
-0.1070864126,
-0.0313546881,
0.0371448845,
-0.0359351784,
-0.0333888344,
0.0235446729,
-0.0740872845,
-0.0651746988,
0.0085725086,
0.0197264999,
0.0157267507,
0.0484650023,
-0.0118053788,
-0.0569083095,
0.1051966697,
0.0316129699,
-0.0646926314,
0.0105960416,
0.0079618897,
0.0215805992,
0.0109645212,
0.0683599859,
-0.0457935072,
0.0366709605,
0.0154539999,
0.0325725973,
-0.0312141497,
-0.0099290702,
0.0201264564,
0.0141312564,
0.0679484755,
-0.0276436936,
-0.0290008765,
-0.0420947559,
0.0002687692,
-0.0108303865,
-0.0261664279,
-0.0521511547,
0.0035616523,
0.0155436713,
0.003671949,
-0.0133763878,
-0.0393866375,
0.0071801427,
0.0318604037,
0.0409287326,
-0.0299523994,
0.0144737046,
0.0350029618,
0.0522476509,
-0.0071080304,
-0.0105245914,
0.0264516026,
-0.0538903885,
0.0209895615,
-0.0426240265,
0.0651535615,
0.0280202366,
-0.0089482656,
-0.0326216184,
0.0236912388,
-0.0374377556,
-0.100925751,
-0.0276084244,
0.0302633177,
0.0433481298,
0.0064495211,
0.0013546258,
-0.040619079,
-0.0130997328,
-0.0200168733,
0.0364468321,
-0.0105782328,
-0.0426574685,
0.0460146442,
0.0327768773,
-0.0248143692,
-0.0150267538,
0.0523149595,
-0.0277954414,
0.0205913968,
0.0057424279,
0.0023097913,
-0.012555629,
0.0058254027,
0.019452041,
0.0219969321,
-0.0363331661,
0.0593713038,
-0.0491144024,
-0.0662992448,
0.0264786631,
0.007878121,
-0.0079670232,
0.018003013,
0.048772309,
0.0645998642,
-0.0089069065,
-0.0254693702,
-0.0232967176,
-0.0038958748,
-0.0068564089,
-0.013660999,
-0.0270113461,
-6.743282118e-33,
-0.0306898151,
0.0006005013,
0.0029242279,
0.0123612834,
-0.0065784017,
0.0052565094,
-0.0417525209,
-0.0059892056,
-0.0071011032,
0.023102317,
-0.00641223,
-0.0019957295,
0.0025246046,
0.0110505121,
0.005857843,
-0.008787659,
0.0393154696,
-0.0054252367,
-0.0151806558,
0.0240141377,
0.0480248854,
0.018209435,
0.0224866122,
0.0002929479,
-0.0011262046,
-0.0061669718,
-0.0147834281,
0.0369277038,
0.0110784248,
0.0610022768,
-0.0552297011,
0.0187220145,
0.0215597469,
-0.0141012156,
-0.0216794349,
0.0514094979,
-0.0555573031,
-0.0152142746,
0.0406700782,
-0.0015427992,
-0.0133198043,
-0.0271119047,
0.0381950922,
-0.0155232046,
-0.0088904025,
0.0073796907,
0.0337356478,
-0.0103149526,
-0.0045346692,
-0.0033142958,
-0.0429375544,
0.0177736096,
0.0028376144,
-0.0149647929,
0.0090965815,
-0.0285092946,
-0.0118849473,
0.0007552126,
-0.0593915246,
0.0575339049,
0.0202966966,
0.0344927162,
0.0549646467,
0.0242273156,
-0.0010721423,
0.0858419165,
-0.002079447,
-0.0260047186,
-0.0378404781,
0.0121348519,
0.0483676977,
0.0555512384,
0.0192992613,
0.0205805395,
0.0245853178,
-0.0007708811,
-0.0502405688,
-0.0156803839,
0.0063739372,
0.0864567682,
0.0474480949,
0.0224241558,
-0.0402834155,
-0.0060475487,
-0.0535807647,
-0.007663874,
-0.0540869869,
-0.0161529481,
0.0295390785,
0.0148320794,
-0.013029187,
-0.0356094912,
0.0292782057,
-0.0520271398,
0.0034090057,
0.0156749599,
-0.0114620943,
-0.0065793567,
-0.0115753766,
0.0211187024,
-0.0882890373,
-0.056462042,
0.0490120053,
-0.0282923989,
-0.0083293281,
0.0210414138,
0.0095650721,
0.0055832793,
-0.0343721323,
-0.0206998046,
-0.0299597532,
-0.0360205807,
-0.0270528402,
-0.0311977249,
0.0461102277,
0.0457865857,
-0.0160709098,
0.0192867275,
-0.0104481848,
-0.0280722957,
-0.0213315617,
-0.0205960255,
0.016816074,
0.0514380671,
-0.0368756875,
-0.0116060842,
-0.027896706,
-0.0278433468,
0.0551565401,
-0.0162447579,
-0.0172873195,
0.0039476668,
2.889e-7,
0.0140723353,
0.0508073084,
-0.0132758319,
0.0312368236,
0.0246284567,
0.0456588753,
-0.0061725904,
0.0071958345,
0.0207485594,
-0.0190854389,
0.0251880493,
0.082839638,
0.0210052263,
0.0029474958,
-0.1191667914,
0.0072417548,
-0.0327357911,
0.0029740143,
-0.0575932041,
-0.0184891578,
0.0378847346,
0.1048835069,
0.0367497094,
-0.0213719439,
0.0067123002,
-0.0407387391,
0.0569612347,
-0.0690513253,
-0.0017328133,
0.027240742,
0.0265553929,
0.0126706827,
-0.0101666618,
0.047060702,
-0.0026134439,
0.027092671,
0.019469019,
0.0507132709,
-0.0217120983,
0.0042291023,
-0.052290339,
0.0113704903,
0.0039616446,
-0.0710477829,
0.0646798164,
-0.0769988373,
-0.0170137435,
-0.0115418062,
0.0005071806,
-0.0390574634,
-0.0216135941,
0.0004482619,
-0.0199805144,
0.0116815055,
0.0229872447,
0.002274215,
-0.0125715639,
-0.1056173667,
-0.0086513096,
0.0101509849,
-0.0538931414,
-0.0622516535,
-0.0572680719,
-0.019098483,
0.0279529765,
-0.0528703444,
0.0020815919,
2.50455487e-34,
0.0283709262,
0.0162579771,
-0.0259427335,
0.0452715419,
0.0587919727,
-0.0029933308,
-0.0080710044,
0.0100233452,
0.0178402029,
-0.1130149066,
0.0119619677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01864v1 | SortNet: Learning To Rank By a Neural-Based Sorting Algorithm | 2023-11-03T12:14:26 | 2023-11-03T12:14:26 | Leonardo Rigutini, Tiziano Papini, Marco Maggini, Franco Scarselli | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | The problem of relevance ranking consists of sorting a set of objects with
respect to a given criterion. Since users may prefer different relevance
criteria, the ranking algorithms should be adaptable to the user needs. Two
main approaches exist in literature for the task of learning to rank: 1) a
score function, learned by examples, which evaluates the properties of each
object yielding an absolute relevance value that can be used to order the
objects or 2) a pairwise approach, where a "preference function" is learned
using pairs of objects to define which one has to be ranked first. In this
paper, we present SortNet, an adaptive ranking algorithm which orders objects
using a neural network as a comparator. The neural network training set
provides examples of the desired ordering between pairs of items and it is
constructed by an iterative procedure which, at each iteration, adds the most
informative training examples. Moreover, the comparator adopts a connectionist
architecture that is particularly suited for implementing a preference
function. We also prove that such an architecture has the universal
approximation property and can implement a wide class of functions. Finally,
the proposed algorithm is evaluated on the LETOR dataset showing promising
performances in comparison with other state of the art algorithms. | [
0.0068855411,
0.0452841483,
0.0132179298,
0.025065776,
0.0520206168,
0.0079389652,
0.0043526008,
-0.0282291286,
0.0220169779,
-0.0410210714,
-0.0420156121,
0.0136596523,
0.0028002411,
-0.0008896007,
-0.0007227,
-0.0317104869,
0.0012860611,
0.0462885275,
-0.0040538693,
-0.0013636848,
-0.0186229777,
-0.0249904636,
-0.0261072703,
0.0085560856,
0.0496948101,
0.0439445041,
-0.0182988998,
0.0316312946,
0.0623469874,
-0.0287853125,
0.0228275694,
0.0037022333,
0.0001538354,
0.0123738293,
0.0000021207,
-0.0261112675,
-0.0305394195,
-0.0171038769,
0.0149350762,
-0.0139060132,
0.0214815848,
0.0537700132,
0.0107234884,
-0.0033619197,
-0.0662874654,
-0.0032343359,
0.0463412441,
0.0307924785,
0.0807927027,
0.0069843116,
0.0063338722,
-0.0033459549,
0.0389852151,
-0.0550905764,
0.0088269841,
-0.021130925,
0.0092734415,
-0.0166155975,
0.0101085333,
0.04117845,
0.0057241409,
0.0265886933,
0.0214600414,
0.0131712807,
0.0406904705,
0.0346702449,
-0.0496760234,
0.0152023761,
0.0131439883,
0.0871664807,
-0.0493570566,
0.0015845237,
-0.0019723715,
-0.0085475501,
0.0022444578,
0.0053771092,
-0.028162146,
-0.02920991,
0.0100724064,
-0.0135163432,
-0.0236449372,
0.0819698051,
-0.0265237018,
0.0085312566,
0.014291239,
0.054667592,
-0.0107816765,
-0.0141560035,
0.0121098207,
-0.0141517948,
-0.012584744,
0.0140118524,
0.0439552031,
-0.0012001101,
-0.027848253,
-0.0238460749,
0.035247229,
0.0088978475,
-0.0131908637,
-0.1081350446,
0.0165256243,
-0.008751723,
-0.0014966233,
0.0219160616,
-0.0511216335,
0.0966781825,
-0.0146724153,
-0.0063584237,
-0.0327685401,
0.0344215818,
-0.0251643844,
0.0002783198,
0.0246887598,
0.0474980138,
0.0028971459,
-0.0022500788,
-0.0763515458,
-0.0073356316,
0.0001441333,
0.003647414,
0.0314238667,
0.0575784184,
-0.031502448,
0.0311150067,
-0.0804504231,
-0.0440176576,
-0.035915114,
-0.0313121006,
-0.0289729573,
0.0230583344,
0.0251968484,
-0.0144788427,
0.0029493356,
0.0011466481,
0.0044452287,
0.029737547,
-0.0002458931,
0.0324527994,
-0.0217969548,
0.0111072427,
0.0408826135,
0.0394888744,
0.0132039636,
-0.0429933518,
-0.0013101088,
-0.0034129717,
0.0104744248,
-0.0448963381,
-0.0125616295,
0.0198435653,
-0.0399705544,
0.0643763617,
0.015041003,
-0.0492405631,
0.0486566871,
-0.0100194002,
-0.014764783,
-0.0316626579,
0.0109787639,
0.041535221,
0.0068411147,
0.0052464278,
-0.0241428148,
-0.0169403628,
-0.0261029918,
-0.0527262762,
-0.057914272,
-0.0129962973,
-0.0888339728,
0.0386904851,
-0.0019012559,
-0.0134055428,
-0.0426997691,
-0.0312116165,
0.0159149226,
0.001372254,
0.0655355603,
0.0216848329,
0.0108540608,
0.0027638709,
-0.0323175453,
0.0031658453,
-0.030965304,
0.0891364217,
0.013677258,
-0.0338031165,
0.002939157,
0.0020337219,
-0.0363547094,
-0.0607065,
0.0880522802,
0.0216405671,
-0.0020201274,
-0.0001541341,
0.0106038656,
0.0140595166,
-0.0033494199,
-0.0220482089,
0.008265228,
-0.0004211691,
-0.0443082415,
-0.0570247099,
0.0022317951,
0.0843937621,
0.0451664738,
-0.0683509782,
-0.0200904347,
0.0309528355,
-0.0093901278,
-0.0281604696,
0.0273772608,
-0.0336648375,
-0.0211983342,
-0.0461704805,
-0.0168450065,
-0.0000626395,
-0.0126971528,
0.0612130575,
-0.0220997334,
0.0501773208,
0.0411152132,
0.0095442794,
-0.0217301454,
0.023294678,
0.0165431146,
-0.0147946691,
0.0364128575,
0.0006449009,
0.0264187381,
0.0181305408,
0.0197907127,
0.0227194987,
0.0481933393,
-0.0121246176,
-0.0024937361,
-0.0388764776,
-0.0273560788,
0.0140464697,
0.0126658129,
-0.0189737454,
0.0686329529,
0.0932026729,
-0.0465052724,
-0.0185707454,
0.0145801632,
0.0448491387,
-0.0014460186,
-0.0017859009,
-0.0088105006,
0.0029223701,
0.0105811963,
-0.0488907956,
0.0927032605,
-0.0016460415,
0.0564917177,
0.0475453325,
-0.0022208448,
-0.0341574997,
-0.0342988931,
-0.0350239836,
0.0351888277,
0.0043639475,
0.004328283,
0.0150724892,
0.0127108414,
0.006391122,
0.0306369383,
-0.0346458219,
0.0118992319,
0.0279244445,
-0.0062138163,
0.0103447782,
0.001976161,
0.0400615335,
-0.0637823716,
-0.0189628117,
0.0484114923,
-0.0435962565,
-0.0345310643,
0.0312255174,
0.0114518637,
-0.0108562568,
-0.0498231165,
-0.0849007964,
-0.0177282002,
0.0394438542,
0.0238677226,
0.0203890279,
-0.0300971176,
0.0344077498,
-0.0764711723,
0.0477787554,
-0.0247271601,
-0.0187952761,
0.0012235183,
-0.0497772805,
-0.0495324172,
0.1116327196,
0.0218488425,
-0.0040379078,
0.0365478881,
0.0099996049,
-0.082361415,
-0.0021813146,
-0.0213535056,
0.0626148283,
0.0394534804,
-0.022331316,
-0.0418206491,
-0.0194310416,
-0.028758442,
-0.0095362766,
-0.0028614525,
0.0708192438,
-0.0173766967,
-0.0582187027,
-0.0847719461,
0.0160327945,
0.0233217068,
0.0092668058,
-0.0089377407,
0.0213742461,
0.0335680954,
0.0337722749,
0.0200326424,
0.0016392815,
-0.0129983071,
-0.0590125844,
0.0104493834,
0.0597479679,
0.0227606632,
-0.075935699,
0.0098492708,
-0.0613734908,
0.0044654384,
0.0276882239,
-0.0502822958,
0.0119258389,
-0.0118639944,
-0.0033269573,
-0.020784229,
-0.0601390004,
-0.0456268862,
-0.0490276292,
0.040505711,
-0.000702245,
-0.0259769708,
-0.0039575417,
-0.0590297654,
0.0216186307,
0.0389391929,
0.1056238264,
-0.0243631694,
-0.039656125,
0.0121723777,
0.0550230853,
-0.0125296349,
0.0004368689,
0.0203214791,
0.0383781455,
0.0516486466,
0.0349594727,
0.0101649538,
-0.0465190522,
-0.0723765716,
0.0226573162,
0.0249957945,
-0.0392428301,
-0.033602085,
-0.0078819683,
-0.0552932657,
-0.0082154674,
0.0033882724,
0.0715441331,
0.0601352341,
-0.0596521236,
-0.01755202,
-0.0077676405,
-0.0095747644,
0.0448179543,
0.0729909837,
0.0226789173,
0.0332608446,
0.0038922995,
0.036812298,
-0.0037208789,
-0.0438780263,
-0.0114104915,
-0.0677208602,
0.0182586722,
-0.0014578305,
-0.0709974617,
0.0055047688,
-0.0075659342,
-0.0221493803,
-0.048790317,
-0.0563980825,
0.0378566831,
-0.004301725,
-0.0086512091,
0.0041155899,
0.0373522304,
0.0103653511,
-0.0019070348,
-0.029981453,
0.0159566104,
0.0567968972,
0.0670037568,
-0.0245750472,
-0.0036837508,
-0.0004621564,
-0.0214263909,
0.0199803282,
-0.012891653,
0.0164683759,
-0.0126445424,
-0.0049576913,
-0.0176414717,
-0.020207528,
-0.0192021858,
0.0325854644,
-0.0044793426,
0.0206186939,
-0.0442001931,
0.0364237018,
-0.0612749718,
-0.0408788733,
-0.0537846684,
-0.0417609513,
0.000471083,
-0.0309898518,
0.0365730077,
-0.0822232813,
0.0442951024,
0.0035598006,
-0.0314361416,
-0.000164504,
0.0226727016,
-0.0490601659,
-0.0944704264,
0.0114369616,
-0.0205703173,
-0.0224265382,
0.0242180321,
-0.0573347099,
-0.0170090683,
-0.0248612761,
-0.0609889776,
-0.0157421529,
0.0760662779,
-0.0155969569,
-0.0440358371,
0.0373381488,
0.114275597,
-0.0763167143,
-0.0578273237,
-0.0355468392,
0.0530826598,
0.0110722147,
-0.0210520681,
0.0887989476,
0.0108720325,
0.0044818777,
-0.0275115333,
-0.0801025033,
0.0094096642,
0.0676005334,
-0.0095222369,
-0.0574537851,
-0.0067163105,
-0.0348428115,
-0.0125943087,
-0.0086738812,
-0.0648611113,
0.0665429533,
-0.0485836267,
-0.0170540791,
-0.0273609292,
-0.0163792055,
0.0251593515,
0.0270341597,
0.0258365441,
0.0250103734,
-0.0333458632,
-0.058735542,
0.0526374578,
0.0008231441,
-0.0237192418,
-0.0124801798,
0.0423635058,
0.0172671136,
0.0642980412,
-0.0402776785,
-0.0280396249,
0.0483751632,
-0.0049672541,
-0.0585743934,
-0.0026053784,
0.0209788755,
0.0153850513,
-0.0263127573,
0.043693345,
-0.0265803281,
0.0125173926,
0.0375516638,
0.0740773007,
-0.0543528497,
0.0099153491,
0.0202886499,
0.0158533677,
-0.0473909751,
0.1191365123,
-0.0912372842,
-0.0027520745,
-0.053430073,
0.0214211065,
0.0521160848,
0.0003843517,
0.0135282837,
0.0168583505,
0.0107729258,
-0.0042730821,
-0.0261955876,
0.0136298416,
-0.0039853682,
-0.0245735142,
0.0716020018,
0.0514422469,
0.0315089189,
0.0500593819,
-0.0254665259,
-0.0739945769,
-0.0036019625,
-0.0093250517,
-0.0306435861,
0.0228078831,
-0.0010894735,
0.0494077094,
-0.0311042219,
-0.0205622949,
0.0181655381,
-0.0192556735,
0.0028917273,
0.0406345874,
0.0395434648,
-0.0335337482,
0.0663003102,
0.0312282834,
0.0136860907,
0.0170386806,
-0.0244978704,
-0.0607624389,
-0.0748751611,
-0.0146556059,
-0.0501651205,
-5.762037842e-33,
-0.0307208747,
-0.0277760979,
-0.0082216728,
0.0149310306,
-0.0044146148,
0.0176754985,
0.0189081319,
-0.0521750525,
-0.0279541165,
-0.0101118684,
-0.04482539,
0.026138762,
-0.0037747698,
-0.0398090221,
0.0346752964,
-0.0252575763,
0.0381780304,
-0.0020535339,
0.0030903646,
0.0179558787,
0.0126456777,
0.0417240113,
0.0123562338,
-0.0536369868,
-0.002404969,
0.0083441967,
0.0145983631,
0.0055215885,
-0.0107208062,
0.0653893054,
0.0179760233,
0.0130224284,
0.0404557101,
-0.0465081558,
0.0344165899,
-0.0004738916,
-0.0710044503,
-0.0540910922,
-0.0660303459,
-0.0031368702,
-0.01253579,
0.0191475991,
0.0412686393,
0.0052918578,
-0.0136493444,
0.0162782911,
0.0773736611,
-0.0073311836,
-0.0290117804,
-0.00911179,
0.0334250033,
0.0099191256,
-0.0263281539,
-0.0142838908,
0.0326682255,
0.045835942,
-0.0285893381,
0.050113257,
-0.038722638,
0.0533553772,
-0.0670342743,
0.0661136135,
0.004278447,
0.0212624967,
-0.0306747369,
0.0440295674,
0.0403332077,
-0.0204704385,
0.0640520304,
-0.0495052189,
-0.0213802513,
0.0321647078,
0.0544899181,
-0.0056623449,
0.0365162455,
-0.0185034815,
-0.0454372726,
0.0625369251,
0.0322223008,
0.028189538,
0.0108862594,
0.0035655326,
-0.0380044132,
-0.0163149536,
0.0123989992,
-0.0263746902,
-0.0710264742,
-0.037008673,
0.0293526519,
-0.0292395093,
-0.0600347184,
0.0122481333,
-0.029114563,
-0.046947103,
-0.0000193702,
0.0125638545,
-0.0085148429,
0.0281015784,
0.0291950218,
0.0120581044,
-0.0461309403,
0.0038652949,
-0.0170229003,
-0.0230520573,
0.0188351795,
0.0091020716,
0.0023094977,
0.011765955,
0.0094732717,
-0.0075659584,
0.021375915,
-0.0318529941,
-0.0405142903,
0.0205220543,
-0.0235202312,
-0.009326593,
-0.0088070072,
0.0548874252,
0.0086849537,
-0.0105843358,
-0.0106185051,
-0.0157702714,
0.0320410207,
0.000664308,
-0.023918746,
-0.0160360504,
-0.0045565809,
0.0656219199,
-0.0043990375,
-0.0765664577,
-0.0451172665,
0.0420414768,
2.858e-7,
0.0062415879,
0.0188981257,
-0.0225976352,
0.0174267087,
0.0368425511,
-0.0207999367,
-0.0018011208,
0.0503833443,
0.0357026868,
0.0512982085,
0.0598070361,
-0.0111448653,
0.0120008029,
0.0029040894,
-0.0746575743,
-0.0771453232,
-0.0259119272,
-0.0112280026,
-0.0103915073,
-0.0467752852,
0.0565520301,
0.0641794428,
-0.008331473,
0.0121269664,
-0.0208258666,
-0.027598761,
0.0069372328,
-0.0151150282,
0.039942082,
-0.0512055159,
0.0163253844,
0.0260974746,
-0.05376973,
0.0382665806,
-0.0013802872,
0.0401527546,
0.083499454,
-0.0204023886,
-0.0273520947,
-0.0323283821,
0.0371024497,
0.0206518546,
0.0170250498,
-0.0410434939,
0.0329639651,
-0.0289430954,
0.0030708392,
0.0422867872,
-0.0290693622,
0.0245287269,
0.0230345055,
-0.0113563258,
-0.0341230184,
-0.0193352886,
0.0163124893,
-0.0178318825,
-0.0101055726,
-0.0175405797,
-0.0133128185,
0.0037108238,
0.0003196941,
-0.0391746238,
0.004496194,
-0.0012812795,
-0.0053423294,
0.022427937,
-0.0276299398,
2.017173331e-34,
0.0299765039,
0.0484606251,
0.0030544298,
0.0014582297,
-0.0162828416,
0.0397016071,
-0.0360943303,
0.0139833381,
0.0132610081,
-0.0113545079,
-0.0423632152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01862v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01862v2 | $R^3$-NL2GQL: A Model Coordination and Knowledge Graph Alignment Approach for NL2GQL | 2023-11-03T12:11:12 | 2024-07-01T14:59:58 | Yuhang Zhou, Yu He, Siyu Tian, Yuchen Ni, Zhangyue Yin, Xiang Liu, Chuanjun Ji, Sen Liu, Xipeng Qiu, Guangnan Ye, Hongfeng Chai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB | While current tasks of converting natural language to SQL (NL2SQL) using
Foundation Models have shown impressive achievements, adapting these approaches
for converting natural language to Graph Query Language (NL2GQL) encounters
hurdles due to the distinct nature of GQL compared to SQL, alongside the
diverse forms of GQL. Moving away from traditional rule-based and slot-filling
methodologies, we introduce a novel approach, $R^3$-NL2GQL, integrating both
small and large Foundation Models for ranking, rewriting, and refining tasks.
This method leverages the interpretative strengths of smaller models for
initial ranking and rewriting stages, while capitalizing on the superior
generalization and query generation prowess of larger models for the final
transformation of natural language queries into GQL formats. Addressing the
scarcity of datasets in this emerging field, we have developed a bilingual
dataset, sourced from graph database manuals and selected open-source Knowledge
Graphs (KGs). Our evaluation of this methodology on this dataset demonstrates
its promising efficacy and robustness. | [
0.0512642637,
0.0860716179,
0.00340436,
0.0292748082,
-0.0343457609,
0.019465303,
-0.0696947128,
-0.0192936547,
0.0367145315,
-0.0390979387,
0.0035130926,
-0.0003134822,
-0.0021087741,
0.0278946348,
0.0040499447,
-0.0007434549,
0.020352615,
0.0164146069,
-0.0117316386,
0.0408109576,
-0.0002024863,
0.0939948037,
-0.0100195333,
-0.0071390895,
0.0259982217,
0.0159993824,
-0.012152493,
0.0387908481,
-0.0203138776,
0.0173141491,
-0.0007395851,
0.0633919612,
0.0019473449,
0.0363713317,
0.0000018219,
-0.0485255271,
-0.0600563847,
0.048760023,
-0.0028982118,
-0.0428950191,
0.0507921055,
-0.0266833827,
0.0429088175,
0.0311374683,
-0.0560834035,
-0.0093384385,
0.0497830287,
0.0325997882,
0.0157959908,
0.060830161,
-0.0183714237,
-0.0538250878,
-0.0229257327,
-0.0162621327,
-0.0069279061,
-0.0535592549,
0.0016066571,
0.0627511069,
0.0300814919,
-0.012284982,
-0.0160729494,
0.020785803,
-0.0312862433,
-0.0527672097,
0.0267300103,
-0.034165699,
-0.0648693517,
0.0295531861,
0.0201484188,
0.0388094187,
-0.004062172,
-0.0028124165,
0.0396932065,
0.0311147198,
-0.0057121366,
0.0398776755,
-0.0302614253,
-0.0219592322,
-0.0382037461,
0.0108321244,
-0.0216674525,
-0.0605296195,
0.0419363417,
-0.0149992518,
-0.035879273,
0.1216803715,
0.0118519608,
0.0231523775,
0.0307891518,
-0.0164951067,
-0.0006627023,
-0.0089984573,
0.0099545661,
0.0028648782,
-0.0514137931,
0.0419850089,
-0.008282451,
0.0651105493,
0.0080262255,
-0.0421391763,
0.0268166047,
0.0211724825,
0.052424781,
0.0501925275,
-0.0133179203,
0.0373438112,
0.0116082765,
0.0495465435,
-0.0653066188,
-0.0502816141,
-0.0971084312,
0.007287004,
-0.0404691584,
0.0071761156,
-0.066325441,
0.0034245783,
-0.0385985859,
0.0522186868,
0.0286279675,
0.0073620281,
0.0732307509,
0.0285278559,
0.0155961467,
-0.0087255817,
-0.0568556711,
0.0429220758,
0.0667216182,
-0.0217680056,
-0.019161256,
-0.0423122533,
0.0199495908,
-0.0143664097,
0.0071210144,
-0.0408503152,
-0.0240660962,
0.0599787794,
0.0034625393,
0.013113508,
-0.0120469602,
-0.0273462348,
0.0309499335,
-0.0292471219,
-0.001238685,
-0.0628429875,
0.0845714882,
0.0243214499,
-0.0154846776,
-0.0466729738,
0.0072399899,
0.0126465242,
-0.0470406488,
0.0333854295,
-0.0440691635,
0.0386303887,
-0.0063930568,
-0.0125270132,
-0.0172733888,
0.0614685081,
-0.0003928245,
-0.0344097055,
0.0371548682,
-0.036586076,
-0.0498357639,
0.0080881231,
0.0052679074,
0.0266481526,
0.0082289902,
0.0463165976,
-0.0058335573,
0.0312801749,
0.0107711675,
0.036126487,
-0.0048150667,
-0.0133730192,
0.0227817632,
0.0043698112,
0.0367405862,
-0.0108533315,
0.0245212913,
0.0267201886,
-0.0052295029,
-0.0189703051,
-0.055460766,
-0.0055636754,
-0.0294855237,
0.0212884638,
-0.0312641598,
0.0097902669,
0.0040064827,
-0.0416330956,
0.0057449164,
0.0287644174,
0.0511479005,
-0.0020797772,
0.0503700785,
-0.0171330962,
-0.0314371958,
0.0544895269,
0.000331503,
-0.0399303399,
0.0233131014,
-0.0054323636,
-0.0552484691,
0.0572830029,
0.0157999583,
-0.0405078754,
-0.0468870439,
0.0134762051,
-0.0051670615,
-0.0172344726,
0.0156115238,
-0.0289110281,
0.0033286249,
-0.0375083387,
-0.0550765395,
0.0121328654,
0.0025486236,
0.0012676802,
0.0166330468,
0.0192917604,
-0.015814472,
-0.0756191537,
-0.0745317042,
-0.0050644041,
-0.0182590876,
0.0266846232,
-0.0076692076,
-0.0114261089,
0.0202504788,
0.0413898639,
0.0166441202,
0.0415003598,
0.0407277755,
0.0082750786,
-0.0685521737,
0.0112046404,
0.042333886,
-0.0324811935,
0.0419200212,
-0.0170436148,
0.0034634629,
-0.0128901536,
-0.087034829,
-0.0298839211,
0.0145333949,
-0.0114086485,
0.0378631651,
-0.00124738,
0.0227350742,
0.0002805286,
-0.0667125583,
-0.0458298475,
0.0157555826,
-0.0059646321,
0.0109655624,
0.0104523208,
-0.0684278756,
0.035267923,
-0.0459496938,
0.0138357319,
0.00627869,
0.0021765106,
0.0414621942,
0.0288509242,
0.0277292375,
-0.0776759535,
0.0384606384,
-0.0796539187,
0.0295465067,
0.012370686,
0.0458174646,
0.0236751512,
0.0058152671,
0.0056021037,
0.0008010009,
-0.0453832261,
-0.0264565051,
0.0083720218,
-0.0024719364,
0.0048240586,
-0.0017814825,
-0.0144676855,
-0.0153119806,
-0.024566751,
-0.0342666954,
0.0682205558,
-0.0103390804,
-0.0295052677,
0.0046886164,
0.0452403538,
-0.0777637735,
0.0259261653,
-0.0148879699,
0.0238004439,
-0.0225342456,
-0.0199350659,
-0.0082291234,
0.0056830174,
-0.0383114107,
-0.0245813448,
0.0119369589,
-0.0164376553,
-0.000009628,
-0.0118059479,
-0.0201775581,
-0.0068466533,
-0.0266154204,
-0.0724229738,
0.0216719992,
-0.02839805,
0.0331352018,
-0.0186197814,
-0.0324880406,
0.0108139245,
-0.0122691048,
0.0243124645,
-0.0656817481,
0.0191345457,
0.0560434312,
0.0318344198,
-0.0504469573,
-0.0142429871,
0.0412412621,
0.0058602989,
0.0430912562,
-0.0483607277,
-0.0086505329,
-0.0674917102,
0.0562505126,
0.0205826238,
0.0477994196,
-0.0378316492,
-0.0331473649,
-0.0393722802,
-0.0325885825,
0.0512341,
-0.0506909639,
0.0448319539,
-0.0380041786,
0.0349293463,
0.0023342683,
-0.0054777963,
-0.0142795192,
0.0612582415,
-0.0317928866,
0.0363611132,
0.0321044065,
-0.0153462719,
-0.0228485912,
0.0241033938,
-0.0192452278,
-0.0077806152,
-0.003600406,
-0.0034817951,
0.0108922655,
0.0295579676,
0.0443382151,
0.0126514724,
-0.0524591543,
0.0210421141,
0.0084072193,
0.0368584692,
-0.0090596937,
-0.0421486981,
0.0183287039,
0.0015918115,
0.0178640671,
-0.0229816698,
-0.0028504226,
-0.01445645,
-0.011077838,
-0.0365462452,
0.0216007605,
0.0561697371,
0.0107806781,
0.0212930627,
-0.0052842363,
0.0143453581,
-0.0082403487,
0.0493448153,
0.0446407683,
-0.1164076552,
-0.0122037195,
-0.0256330818,
0.0145861562,
0.0368135497,
-0.0524421521,
-0.0270862021,
-0.1181469336,
0.0302047692,
-0.0076429304,
-0.0599178746,
-0.0361637846,
-0.0472419597,
0.0010700393,
-0.0682389587,
-0.0532450564,
0.0273236837,
-0.0271869842,
-0.0120182959,
-0.0018118871,
-0.0122174248,
-0.0407917276,
-0.0177287962,
-0.0472926311,
-0.0237938724,
-0.0062401341,
0.0567521229,
0.0055880933,
0.0008626936,
-0.0124464212,
0.03278834,
-0.0113296527,
-0.0465818346,
0.0336886011,
0.0153401606,
0.0003789981,
-0.037287049,
-0.0048050391,
-0.0415050387,
0.0442158766,
-0.0140413577,
0.1163760126,
-0.0001617884,
0.0075729373,
-0.02798374,
-0.0343854241,
0.0234870017,
0.0560140461,
-0.0029226455,
0.0356784798,
-0.0262588598,
-0.0336770341,
-0.018950548,
-0.0445566885,
-0.0549367629,
0.0559843034,
-0.027685985,
0.0101830503,
-0.0189852379,
-0.0236206651,
0.0393321849,
-0.0207753498,
0.0209881607,
0.0816095099,
0.0552772544,
-0.0419173762,
-0.1069460586,
0.0039738412,
-0.0312337913,
0.0361204483,
-0.0272639468,
-0.0127859358,
-0.011806014,
0.0041709868,
-0.0463637188,
-0.0246048737,
-0.0286475737,
-0.0601712726,
-0.0327150486,
0.0215205289,
0.0169345792,
0.0127607323,
-0.0236696154,
-0.00281341,
-0.0156644024,
0.0654064044,
-0.0292830039,
-0.0398244262,
-0.0007069161,
-0.0098458854,
-0.0441745371,
0.0469140075,
-0.0444488376,
-0.0252549872,
-0.0286547821,
0.0546601079,
-0.0094387298,
-0.0254898854,
0.0463933162,
0.0681819096,
-0.0060491469,
0.0392986946,
0.0059798295,
-0.0515521653,
0.0004592768,
-0.0698561817,
-0.0271168631,
-0.0381823443,
0.0173232518,
0.0268177688,
-0.0023240924,
0.0151330121,
-0.0175557788,
0.0017422891,
0.0253687203,
-0.0547957569,
-0.0208575781,
0.0276757497,
-0.0051292367,
0.057782378,
-0.0017159604,
-0.0038068427,
0.0329341106,
0.0192122478,
0.0103177503,
-0.047982011,
-0.0079540508,
0.0292339511,
0.0048762956,
-0.0324899182,
0.0215682127,
-0.0036257715,
-0.0808956698,
0.0035978945,
-0.021204235,
0.0759298876,
0.0054343967,
0.0839746222,
0.0237200893,
-0.0321518891,
-0.0238230154,
0.0526097938,
0.0318658985,
0.0003414362,
0.0315627642,
0.0247802008,
0.0041508367,
0.0124279857,
0.0516939275,
0.0419700779,
0.0243541095,
-0.0002321697,
-0.0946682543,
-0.0097251004,
-0.0429916009,
0.0399425402,
-0.0185398385,
-0.025708802,
-0.0356946811,
-0.0586469956,
-0.0624548122,
-0.0040824055,
0.0147602716,
-0.0121862078,
-0.0261631273,
0.0612582043,
0.0487775393,
0.0588630736,
-0.0250156317,
-0.0352734439,
0.0068741515,
-0.0970032737,
-0.0343464352,
0.0263625402,
-5.61856545e-33,
-0.0040450171,
-0.0693534687,
0.0459666476,
-0.027891688,
-0.0264630783,
-0.0238377042,
-0.0125914533,
-0.0390588492,
-0.0193335302,
0.0198059045,
-0.0054522492,
0.0200539175,
0.0176498648,
-0.0055057541,
-0.002365794,
-0.0069941822,
0.0194563884,
0.0121859424,
0.0264282562,
0.0102183642,
0.0609513149,
0.0560632721,
0.0772995353,
-0.0665456802,
0.0128666656,
0.0102378335,
0.007928065,
0.0399721451,
-0.0049729017,
0.0542914271,
0.0113035357,
0.0509154275,
0.0294638649,
-0.0195005201,
-0.0098962337,
-0.0602690317,
-0.0631550699,
-0.018133346,
0.0447296873,
0.0379747711,
-0.0307199527,
0.0142136738,
0.0551347435,
-0.0051417551,
0.0117914062,
-0.0295623746,
0.0354465544,
-0.0072540403,
-0.0344489105,
-0.0290532243,
-0.0492828749,
0.0188577641,
0.0103170238,
0.0059218337,
-0.0213999301,
0.0196747724,
-0.0117919836,
-0.0018908196,
-0.0434876382,
-0.0042104619,
-0.0330248661,
0.0261426661,
0.0352813378,
0.0163701084,
-0.002203881,
0.0022389051,
-0.0350700393,
0.0149038341,
0.0157700088,
0.0462558791,
-0.006729343,
0.0996243283,
0.0213436764,
0.0092191668,
0.0006952173,
0.0192648973,
-0.1236450374,
0.0299402326,
-0.0405635014,
0.0265065469,
-0.0261978582,
0.018395327,
-0.0234529562,
-0.0657143146,
-0.0432912298,
-0.024087837,
-0.0326484665,
-0.0201961137,
0.0416548885,
-0.0282644499,
-0.0067562507,
0.0060618976,
-0.0038341749,
-0.0489282869,
-0.0468796156,
0.0741729364,
-0.0219078027,
-0.0214693043,
-0.0189452935,
0.0529948808,
-0.0398815833,
0.0019335567,
-0.0088210795,
-0.0124981552,
0.0218004733,
0.0261786152,
0.0100488644,
0.0314018838,
-0.0141417235,
0.0213804301,
-0.0502680764,
-0.0104819238,
-0.0410924219,
0.0335323028,
0.0101111336,
0.0365371518,
0.030845942,
0.0649470091,
0.0555436462,
0.0039387955,
-0.0095506283,
0.0035678118,
0.0319022983,
0.0090480223,
0.0321546495,
0.0149014415,
-0.0256176777,
0.0073344759,
0.0178820714,
-0.01759395,
-0.0400010534,
0.0158868171,
2.725e-7,
0.0707344189,
-0.0093747498,
0.0217771865,
0.0754979327,
-0.030080691,
-0.0050219987,
-0.0144225247,
0.0233843029,
0.0348356701,
0.015830975,
0.0038867714,
0.0250052884,
-0.0004472276,
0.0467831008,
-0.0764322728,
0.0133885266,
-0.0487908423,
-0.0688491538,
-0.0294463001,
0.032221701,
0.0645318404,
0.0463180691,
0.0113062225,
0.0079566902,
-0.049638208,
-0.040012043,
0.0109247416,
-0.0017087583,
-0.0206171237,
0.0428258404,
0.0735172257,
-0.0068772887,
-0.0084932745,
0.0229025781,
0.0027868014,
0.0032759253,
0.0080089495,
0.0393755138,
-0.0385778435,
0.0565411188,
0.0031627014,
-0.0648427308,
0.0214364789,
-0.0381593928,
0.0454109907,
-0.0226859786,
-0.0146419089,
0.0696179047,
-0.0383727476,
-0.033672478,
0.0006970729,
-0.0048431256,
-0.0176602826,
-0.0058659515,
0.0398861468,
0.0011604308,
-0.012071874,
0.0104219671,
0.0123790205,
0.0546584167,
0.0259535927,
-0.0173707269,
0.0151936114,
0.0230731256,
-0.0240277909,
-0.0133627066,
0.0283207893,
2.515376765e-34,
0.0556727499,
0.0356874764,
0.0236742646,
-0.034744624,
0.1010184363,
-0.0287863445,
-0.0185494367,
-0.0101743713,
-0.0236490071,
-0.0929758772,
-0.0283894949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01860v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01860v1 | FAME: Flexible, Scalable Analogy Mappings Engine | 2023-11-03T12:08:02 | 2023-11-03T12:08:02 | Shahar Jacob, Chen Shani, Dafna Shahaf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Analogy is one of the core capacities of human cognition; when faced with new
situations, we often transfer prior experience from other domains. Most work on
computational analogy relies heavily on complex, manually crafted input. In
this work, we relax the input requirements, requiring only names of entities to
be mapped. We automatically extract commonsense representations and use them to
identify a mapping between the entities. Unlike previous works, our framework
can handle partial analogies and suggest new entities to be added. Moreover,
our method's output is easily interpretable, allowing for users to understand
why a specific mapping was chosen.
Experiments show that our model correctly maps 81.2% of classical 2x2 analogy
problems (guess level=50%). On larger problems, it achieves 77.8% accuracy
(mean guess level=13.1%). In another experiment, we show our algorithm
outperforms human performance, and the automatic suggestions of new entities
resemble those suggested by humans. We hope this work will advance
computational analogy by paving the way to more flexible, realistic input
requirements, with broader applicability. | [
0.0365345031,
0.0428141169,
-0.0235002171,
0.0263493154,
-0.0036699236,
0.022084225,
-0.0032208429,
-0.0155970426,
0.0431392305,
-0.0541917644,
0.0041771978,
-0.000763029,
-0.0015091294,
-0.0195622239,
0.0147773242,
-0.1065945178,
0.0068995897,
0.0193343181,
-0.0408769734,
0.0074565848,
-0.0397113338,
0.0323569626,
-0.0325338542,
0.0438711159,
0.0008616792,
0.005634198,
0.0078358324,
-0.0085275797,
0.0763593093,
-0.0330511071,
-0.0466636382,
-0.0061980677,
0.0258993842,
-0.0258380584,
0.000002396,
-0.0574445836,
-0.0050408677,
-0.0045858496,
0.0579544902,
-0.0215599015,
0.0240034368,
0.016159486,
0.0115872035,
-0.0091877924,
-0.0300791468,
0.0040914849,
0.0894509256,
0.0090270843,
0.0304196067,
-0.0069933385,
-0.0149676073,
-0.0562052019,
-0.0200855974,
0.0142598795,
0.0542163029,
-0.0080209868,
0.0232673772,
0.0265603811,
0.0487016812,
-0.0409770645,
-0.0107993754,
0.0001085575,
-0.0017389373,
0.0165955704,
0.0350422002,
0.0668187812,
0.035488911,
0.0223312825,
0.0079303524,
0.0828504562,
-0.0116465017,
-0.0175045654,
0.0346190073,
-0.0213875417,
0.0102387685,
0.0621729754,
-0.0280852858,
-0.0199999027,
-0.0083675683,
0.0258707404,
0.0257497616,
0.017188454,
-0.0073898388,
0.0316206291,
-0.0098894993,
-0.029800225,
0.0109054055,
0.0250344966,
0.0165002849,
-0.0003603595,
-0.0233811475,
-0.0348587036,
0.0250273626,
0.0425572172,
-0.0259190761,
0.0148821725,
-0.0489768572,
-0.0069676773,
-0.0065195695,
-0.0946765691,
0.0949305594,
0.0623222031,
0.0148448292,
0.0722710192,
-0.0556756854,
0.0084235538,
-0.0255500972,
0.0540543161,
-0.0603862144,
-0.0179390293,
-0.077670984,
0.0131023005,
-0.0414820015,
0.0286719352,
0.0266612824,
-0.0223979633,
-0.0119634029,
-0.0042629316,
-0.0516104214,
-0.01353346,
-0.0099917715,
0.0477111191,
-0.0009645326,
0.0029891455,
-0.0896328092,
-0.0233841315,
-0.1139594615,
0.0413496718,
-0.0164442565,
0.0001828305,
-0.0045432234,
-0.0240536239,
0.0296374969,
-0.0163958147,
0.016480349,
0.0805133954,
-0.0168316849,
0.0172441565,
-0.0454370715,
-0.0140801547,
0.0735477805,
-0.0190633833,
0.0026947209,
-0.0609571859,
0.0409061573,
-0.0063213776,
0.013178722,
-0.0475141816,
0.0084144725,
0.0255462397,
-0.0847556069,
0.1060128957,
-0.0240052082,
0.0075926348,
-0.0113730123,
0.0187503342,
-0.054498259,
0.0010718665,
0.0275503248,
-0.0328336172,
0.0012671207,
-0.0060212458,
0.0117570115,
-0.0165068228,
-0.0061079636,
-0.0327155404,
-0.0137544563,
0.0180310812,
-0.0165518671,
0.078211695,
0.0388005264,
0.0029993558,
-0.0158689339,
-0.020157082,
0.0248878598,
0.0810959786,
0.0032815966,
0.0751892701,
0.0329592712,
0.0090285484,
-0.0188658535,
-0.0183908828,
-0.0568708293,
0.0867255181,
0.030987313,
-0.0105456831,
-0.0162315425,
0.0545416363,
-0.013743504,
0.0231879372,
0.0142876273,
0.0150084319,
0.0050333967,
-0.0485893153,
-0.0317736156,
0.023624653,
-0.0045170528,
0.0456504487,
0.0317684598,
-0.0053573526,
-0.0019332777,
0.0074889478,
-0.0146413017,
0.0735008046,
0.0387819558,
-0.0127790729,
0.0037981186,
-0.0099744741,
0.0018189264,
0.0306855794,
0.0443175659,
0.0055106445,
-0.0288162492,
-0.0551152639,
-0.0118514076,
0.0275182985,
-0.0034524538,
0.0403418764,
-0.0039774287,
0.016679218,
-0.0017827564,
-0.0352022462,
0.0310075358,
0.0267467164,
-0.0374945067,
0.0107310982,
-0.0027877365,
0.0294646118,
0.0205486249,
0.0127139343,
0.0272120833,
0.0259198379,
0.0141865378,
-0.0407771915,
-0.0215505846,
0.0608046912,
-0.0387258604,
0.015896868,
0.0392846912,
-0.10515479,
-0.0188034531,
0.0164385252,
-0.0043204925,
-0.003399781,
0.035375759,
-0.0170295779,
0.0880506635,
0.0082735904,
0.0047552893,
-0.0043705087,
-0.011985288,
0.0242828485,
0.0751175135,
0.0076228804,
0.0008599368,
-0.0091039268,
-0.010470272,
-0.0118380357,
0.0198852755,
0.0159666315,
-0.041185528,
-0.0037784167,
-0.0108104656,
-0.0421012118,
-0.0250437912,
-0.0294555631,
0.0177977327,
-0.0456693098,
0.0013838717,
0.0563618615,
-0.0112445448,
0.0181056727,
-0.0228361934,
-0.0070032077,
-0.0226325095,
-0.0194961652,
0.0483431555,
-0.0597874671,
0.0206233971,
0.0412975848,
-0.015637923,
-0.0341803953,
-0.0130436895,
0.0314472169,
-0.0519770607,
0.0495453328,
0.0391833819,
0.0338277668,
-0.0080249021,
0.0005692477,
-0.040322043,
0.0038746658,
-0.0005625999,
-0.0188515,
0.022144001,
0.0048952578,
0.0335012376,
0.0021221712,
0.0253989007,
-0.0118098063,
0.0477546155,
-0.03422435,
-0.0545851327,
0.0046527144,
-0.0068194931,
0.0226437133,
0.0087610958,
-0.0350886062,
-0.0438329987,
0.0579099357,
0.0121489186,
0.0139219537,
-0.0345963836,
0.0737231001,
0.0347209312,
0.0188762657,
-0.0370375924,
-0.0033810413,
0.001972307,
0.0041954867,
-0.0144372452,
0.012266499,
0.1019440964,
0.0201510731,
0.0472235121,
0.005668995,
0.0334241278,
-0.0029640736,
0.0780721009,
-0.0340842791,
0.0242773499,
0.0025066531,
0.0232201368,
-0.0249913838,
0.0011038289,
0.0321794115,
-0.0128160324,
0.0392249823,
-0.034488041,
0.0118253445,
0.0109464228,
-0.0398090221,
-0.0211127307,
0.0285178274,
-0.0332022235,
-0.0024218762,
0.0146155916,
-0.026127724,
-0.0855584219,
0.0148560815,
-0.0009631227,
0.0203371514,
0.0259116013,
-0.033769194,
-0.003923784,
0.0068506207,
0.0543364473,
0.0606290363,
0.0264555216,
0.0345880985,
0.017064875,
0.0232569259,
0.006349918,
-0.0321279541,
-0.0134493029,
0.0504124537,
-0.0238795616,
-0.0660510212,
0.0336506851,
0.02973531,
0.0109283263,
-0.0282785855,
-0.0233988315,
0.0490586795,
0.0475811958,
-0.0415455475,
0.0397266112,
-0.0119337477,
-0.0245483704,
0.0342527367,
0.0168838222,
-0.0889451727,
-0.0525405146,
-0.0000575581,
-0.0128237018,
-0.0074939914,
-0.1024181917,
0.0161347706,
-0.0935285017,
0.0093503743,
-0.0024491339,
-0.0861424133,
-0.0476191565,
-0.0288298856,
0.0383407287,
-0.0217672605,
-0.084400259,
-0.0445972867,
-0.0250294562,
0.0190757792,
-0.0048059598,
0.0614551902,
-0.0178721715,
0.0180204231,
-0.0764153376,
0.0598000847,
0.0063923965,
0.0435372852,
0.0318561979,
-0.0383530147,
-0.0418356732,
-0.0053114062,
-0.0144190174,
-0.0110582951,
0.012417349,
-0.0124486135,
-0.0077751195,
-0.0560346805,
0.0413215905,
-0.0343805291,
-0.0378554091,
0.0461572483,
0.0694813058,
-0.0093283905,
-0.013886584,
-0.0592424199,
0.0171281248,
0.0061111678,
0.1033488885,
0.0527615994,
-0.0130301164,
0.0161747541,
-0.0190746207,
0.0147726685,
-0.0464012027,
-0.0539922863,
-0.0284828097,
-0.0217279345,
0.0284912139,
-0.0714430213,
-0.0295450892,
0.0176564064,
0.0120346416,
0.0344785973,
-0.0501361117,
0.0148714688,
-0.0277970713,
-0.0580510907,
0.0212921035,
-0.0191763602,
0.0322660878,
0.033797916,
-0.0400558598,
0.041604612,
-0.0107162539,
-0.0485268608,
0.0336657539,
-0.0538265593,
-0.0034231453,
-0.0043596262,
0.0418807529,
0.0168666001,
0.0132844429,
0.001939625,
0.0000548894,
0.0456695929,
0.0475552678,
-0.0159256663,
-0.0117033813,
-0.0462096222,
0.0309393499,
0.0248250701,
0.0220155958,
0.0012974154,
0.0108945044,
0.0017028679,
0.0499567688,
-0.0449374914,
-0.0014197398,
0.010304098,
-0.0251948666,
-0.00686904,
0.0146955959,
-0.0276529454,
-0.0183345471,
0.0037641528,
0.0064188684,
-0.0279866233,
-0.0334176756,
-0.0156847406,
0.0082321642,
0.0334874727,
-0.0133190788,
-0.0589321963,
-0.0081256432,
0.0391800292,
0.0126390029,
-0.0183690246,
0.0330944806,
0.0388398506,
-0.0127696386,
-0.0175067168,
-0.0259183459,
-0.0012509181,
0.0078069167,
0.0581321493,
-0.0379114337,
0.0434170924,
0.0263032634,
-0.0268969182,
-0.0220933389,
0.0114413407,
-0.0143634053,
-0.0653009191,
-0.047581777,
0.0554892942,
0.0051015918,
-0.0156971216,
0.0019953586,
-0.024429651,
0.0195954684,
0.0513563603,
0.0049782759,
-0.0198791008,
-0.0229815375,
0.0432293192,
0.0243897587,
0.0495240539,
-0.0348930992,
0.0044064298,
-0.1007476524,
0.0583915673,
-0.0268492159,
-0.0392822027,
-0.0197654236,
-0.0206395146,
0.0166831892,
0.0369098075,
0.0045280429,
-0.0011920364,
-0.0673361272,
-0.0133413421,
-0.0379385203,
-0.0036751567,
-0.022068616,
0.0213318896,
0.0664959028,
-0.0044918139,
0.0225586463,
-0.0215020534,
0.0139267901,
0.0185851753,
-0.1064763963,
-0.0381689183,
-0.0347357094,
-6.935580504e-33,
-0.0482762866,
-0.0085700061,
0.0134690367,
-0.0573092774,
-0.0125589501,
-0.0343885645,
-0.0382100977,
-0.005848153,
-0.0383892134,
0.0156821255,
0.0268948488,
-0.0363825224,
0.0007053763,
-0.0274894871,
0.0117908511,
-0.0176120773,
-0.0043215589,
0.0435085371,
-0.0344730429,
-0.0173377823,
0.0059750113,
-0.0139196124,
0.0319566168,
-0.0622305609,
-0.027985597,
0.0162410885,
-0.0092098322,
-0.0122429607,
0.0207554307,
0.0508897267,
-0.0144594135,
0.0269118063,
0.0136160143,
0.006809629,
-0.0026638436,
0.0055243773,
-0.074724704,
-0.0516424738,
0.0138072912,
-0.0347510912,
0.0308184642,
-0.0187164061,
0.029286461,
0.0174287874,
0.0205676071,
-0.0386522971,
0.0767708868,
-0.037941169,
0.0291552134,
0.0468336791,
-0.0377238691,
-0.0265485588,
-0.0243550986,
-0.0277483724,
-0.0266024172,
0.0343707316,
-0.0066015297,
0.0296737589,
-0.0811271071,
0.0349299014,
0.0166585632,
-0.0062164869,
0.0394906476,
-0.0167122483,
0.0205134656,
0.0744141936,
-0.0292905308,
-0.0593775697,
-0.0388511233,
-0.0017797236,
0.012279015,
0.0498783328,
0.0171108991,
0.0540289357,
0.076808691,
-0.0047933143,
0.0103307683,
0.061070431,
-0.0043060379,
0.0287555978,
0.0205502901,
0.0152026732,
-0.0191750247,
0.0035117851,
-0.0122668706,
-0.0324162133,
-0.0425394252,
-0.0682661459,
0.016511431,
-0.0438665077,
-0.0481046252,
0.0823436752,
-0.011032166,
-0.0062254854,
-0.0232646819,
-0.0483495779,
0.0222206209,
-0.0059553832,
-0.0218825433,
-0.0473913699,
-0.0534648895,
-0.0679069608,
0.032024812,
0.0083815409,
0.063814491,
0.0283216368,
-0.0205409117,
-0.0239380598,
-0.076072298,
-0.0260295775,
-0.0362059511,
-0.0502321422,
-0.0301508754,
-0.060037002,
0.0102247503,
0.0085485112,
0.0029466371,
-0.0074350615,
0.0112538394,
-0.0046985382,
-0.0099800304,
0.016564846,
-0.027341282,
0.0223173536,
0.0035254403,
0.0185034927,
-0.0647581667,
-0.068693392,
0.0289440621,
-0.0913548768,
-0.030222876,
0.0146472584,
3.03e-7,
0.0123857167,
0.0141136814,
0.0159325972,
-0.0248642918,
-0.0315970518,
0.0594575591,
0.036636997,
0.0491893515,
-0.0045570452,
0.0029664352,
0.0237493124,
0.04003435,
0.0179152731,
0.0461243577,
-0.0736950487,
-0.0027092225,
-0.0868108198,
-0.0236027613,
-0.0400957502,
-0.0171494018,
0.0661425367,
0.0289766788,
0.0791611895,
0.0080147358,
0.0232002586,
-0.0416949727,
0.0115150437,
-0.0623699203,
0.0447519161,
-0.0128851673,
-0.0433124863,
-0.0143638682,
-0.0247142091,
0.0463284031,
-0.0012586906,
0.0120913023,
0.0287053157,
-0.0190761276,
0.0030856137,
0.0235857032,
-0.0181761682,
-0.0392392017,
0.0354870185,
-0.0808030963,
0.0233835038,
-0.0956085473,
0.0097431038,
0.0178418215,
-0.0313881226,
0.03862812,
0.0142576313,
0.0012521073,
-0.0484992452,
-0.0105925603,
0.0375884138,
0.0207235608,
-0.0012970463,
-0.0539474264,
0.0120189907,
0.0015825641,
-0.0150348181,
-0.0132653601,
-0.022174092,
-0.0372253582,
0.020821739,
-0.0471260436,
-0.009165071,
2.303817858e-34,
-0.0265677851,
0.0360942036,
0.0009581162,
0.0296524186,
0.0682303607,
0.0137296924,
0.0254697967,
0.0114687989,
0.0250407308,
-0.0469923839,
-0.0138932718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01825v2 | Large Language Models to the Rescue: Reducing the Complexity in Scientific Workflow Development Using ChatGPT | 2023-11-03T10:28:53 | 2023-11-06T11:43:33 | Mario Sänger, Ninon De Mecquenem, Katarzyna Ewa Lewińska, Vasilis Bountris, Fabian Lehmann, Ulf Leser, Thomas Kosch | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.HC | Scientific workflow systems are increasingly popular for expressing and
executing complex data analysis pipelines over large datasets, as they offer
reproducibility, dependability, and scalability of analyses by automatic
parallelization on large compute clusters. However, implementing workflows is
difficult due to the involvement of many black-box tools and the deep
infrastructure stack necessary for their execution. Simultaneously,
user-supporting tools are rare, and the number of available examples is much
lower than in classical programming languages. To address these challenges, we
investigate the efficiency of Large Language Models (LLMs), specifically
ChatGPT, to support users when dealing with scientific workflows. We performed
three user studies in two scientific domains to evaluate ChatGPT for
comprehending, adapting, and extending workflows. Our results indicate that
LLMs efficiently interpret workflows but achieve lower performance for
exchanging components or purposeful workflow extensions. We characterize their
limitations in these challenging scenarios and suggest future research
directions. | [
0.0024637862,
0.0493683852,
-0.0282493979,
-0.0013349997,
-0.0692051351,
0.0000617235,
0.0183911789,
0.0190603938,
0.0412885025,
0.027319137,
-0.002633705,
0.0016932938,
-0.0184185039,
0.0755876303,
-0.046682734,
-0.0597393885,
0.037420176,
-0.0507183783,
-0.0121692605,
-0.0014805744,
-0.0281077866,
0.0022988569,
0.0067902114,
0.0386188775,
0.0448964499,
-0.0148535864,
0.004755103,
0.0294245556,
0.0007670997,
0.0255466625,
0.0010825001,
0.0700826645,
0.0062042968,
0.0783715993,
0.0000022136,
-0.0501514226,
0.0337845571,
0.0884592608,
-0.0364312567,
0.0413414873,
0.0489497483,
0.0050238571,
-0.0058872905,
0.0289374813,
0.0408853181,
-0.0285220537,
0.0878318325,
-0.0446799137,
0.0622610189,
-0.033244893,
-0.0140247056,
0.0092532663,
0.0012715382,
0.0078917323,
0.0239691772,
-0.0057677939,
0.0280908793,
0.02633458,
0.0778219551,
0.0293577332,
0.0452242903,
0.0139158173,
0.0193976127,
-0.0413901024,
-0.0061952285,
0.030414043,
-0.0006011771,
-0.024385538,
-0.0241815411,
0.0313889161,
-0.0099943327,
-0.0056680581,
0.0120779052,
0.0166771691,
-0.0543917343,
0.0214905608,
-0.0717856064,
0.0267719086,
0.0006493889,
-0.0849202648,
-0.0189668313,
-0.0307020359,
-0.0073681362,
-0.0073288749,
-0.0275039319,
0.0512841865,
0.03077586,
0.0230446849,
-0.0421377085,
-0.004627414,
0.0413920246,
-0.0665011033,
0.0565822944,
0.0418405272,
-0.0559880845,
-0.0220646374,
0.009957416,
-0.0256702527,
0.0536941476,
-0.0294337198,
0.0142961871,
0.0180322286,
-0.0211807825,
0.0534436405,
0.0157568902,
0.0115013961,
-0.0554476753,
-0.0261428319,
0.0598064773,
-0.0353181362,
-0.0510618985,
-0.0249052215,
-0.0156416073,
-0.0307481531,
-0.0474039465,
-0.0009628889,
-0.013685449,
0.0632484183,
-0.0136651797,
0.0373419747,
0.0132781286,
-0.0361114517,
-0.0298480336,
0.0133342408,
-0.0022184362,
0.0347493179,
-0.023376517,
-0.0080001689,
-0.0049953288,
-0.0342492685,
0.0044523692,
0.0155768329,
-0.0103184935,
-0.0246517863,
0.0495843142,
0.0361435264,
0.0529260226,
0.0658170953,
0.0078066452,
-0.0691888332,
0.0453310795,
-0.0500809886,
-0.026481919,
-0.0783599764,
0.0398426764,
0.0664415285,
0.0114452736,
0.0043925494,
-0.062615037,
-0.0009062247,
-0.0302417446,
0.0307510905,
-0.0216556229,
0.013945342,
0.0209234878,
0.0472889133,
0.0101633575,
0.0104456954,
-0.0263968389,
-0.014003667,
-0.0183140468,
-0.0665228814,
0.0268190932,
0.0171417445,
-0.0669926107,
0.0230905376,
-0.0378418826,
0.0799030587,
0.0031099643,
0.0089424662,
-0.0043885452,
0.0256746877,
-0.013314412,
0.0177765563,
0.0288748425,
0.049150683,
0.000300509,
0.0108594969,
0.02125315,
0.03195934,
0.0230198,
-0.0650318861,
-0.0412061103,
0.0828095898,
0.0102900499,
-0.0372986272,
-0.0416088067,
0.0548718348,
-0.0406145491,
-0.0104703698,
-0.0069252611,
-0.0008234291,
-0.0233087465,
-0.0190321151,
0.0551024675,
-0.0086393952,
-0.0013318048,
0.0096918792,
0.0082805846,
-0.061118219,
-0.046942275,
-0.0303892605,
0.0093615623,
0.0694594756,
0.0614509471,
-0.0457438864,
-0.0261934772,
-0.0187174045,
0.0290121529,
0.0069273552,
0.0392779857,
0.0097091105,
-0.0552663691,
-0.0196400061,
-0.0255467221,
0.0121107763,
-0.0010383714,
0.0246272646,
0.0297502447,
-0.0275224783,
-0.0093675144,
-0.0000453559,
-0.069867827,
-0.0209991485,
-0.0339154452,
0.0022397824,
0.0096355546,
-0.0229874942,
0.0412822291,
-0.0176189598,
-0.0127209891,
-0.0022102243,
0.0392639749,
0.0251476914,
-0.0404401794,
0.0286275838,
0.0375584736,
0.0642034337,
-0.0482185408,
0.0211117472,
0.021324357,
-0.0090815881,
-0.0492536575,
-0.0262589753,
0.0340036303,
0.0148776006,
0.0080121616,
0.039081227,
0.0141276345,
-0.03803223,
-0.008339907,
-0.033140175,
-0.0011918551,
0.0449981168,
0.0065048309,
-0.0291684028,
0.0265228786,
0.0163677316,
0.0201784279,
-0.0039562895,
0.0237668138,
0.01046935,
0.0155015038,
0.0310662203,
-0.0225402061,
-0.0162439682,
-0.0053108735,
-0.0457011908,
0.0356789567,
0.0196224339,
0.0544948503,
0.0164963529,
0.0299849063,
-0.0111710103,
0.0059818211,
0.0132069681,
0.0622384138,
-0.0046109669,
0.033461228,
0.0276801959,
0.0069785062,
-0.0645347685,
0.005007783,
-0.0381323434,
-0.0109763192,
0.0474981666,
0.026226351,
-0.0083098058,
-0.052084785,
0.0220337342,
-0.0068299328,
-0.0350181386,
-0.0038523779,
0.0086648539,
0.0022360922,
-0.007705193,
0.036882665,
0.0256286226,
-0.0637016892,
-0.0002286593,
0.0414251797,
-0.0117814709,
-0.0101936534,
-0.0017042013,
0.0016884211,
-0.0360668786,
0.0183932669,
0.0072926693,
-0.0083375499,
0.0331425481,
-0.0518587865,
-0.0245581474,
0.0200650804,
-0.0013858725,
-0.0052501909,
0.0237665921,
0.0262360945,
-0.0285745002,
-0.004039614,
0.0178667624,
-0.0043550674,
-0.0739500597,
0.0415535904,
-0.0235739406,
-0.0397076048,
-0.0523251817,
-0.045429673,
-0.0637132078,
0.0531702898,
-0.0155339418,
-0.0027827248,
-0.0572228208,
-0.002550646,
0.0045917556,
0.0056915767,
-0.0344176255,
-0.0016826493,
0.0232277531,
-0.0360375382,
0.0084223244,
-0.0030497841,
-0.0079124309,
-0.0050668125,
0.051450666,
-0.0400208756,
0.0108192451,
0.024653757,
-0.0722821355,
-0.0345612764,
0.0357223973,
0.0586317927,
0.0605833977,
0.0004102049,
-0.0395438336,
-0.0229003374,
-0.0677856058,
-0.0317199267,
-0.0612278357,
-0.0153501658,
0.011180724,
0.0164154116,
0.0694208145,
0.0181312729,
-0.0243218429,
-0.0525980853,
-0.0601761378,
0.0172184911,
-0.0300716702,
-0.0191739071,
0.0214671027,
0.0342007726,
-0.0567394383,
-0.0268416107,
0.0408954695,
0.0248049367,
-0.0594236702,
0.0298294406,
-0.0109470002,
0.0464819856,
0.0363424681,
0.0615064502,
-0.0743309632,
-0.0039173272,
0.0316913016,
-0.0134053864,
-0.008341643,
-0.0277032163,
0.0033970627,
-0.0391401649,
0.0909860581,
-0.0054495642,
-0.0666166097,
0.0263219457,
-0.1220635995,
0.0205082744,
-0.0051249759,
0.0050316118,
0.0258420818,
0.012141373,
-0.0317953601,
-0.0097692097,
-0.0464561731,
-0.0625868887,
0.0659695268,
-0.0026261657,
0.00224595,
0.0159256011,
-0.0049427357,
-0.0504405014,
0.0056979181,
0.0475407094,
0.0769103393,
0.0078785764,
-0.0475876592,
0.0098463809,
0.0638454854,
-0.0336692333,
-0.0384049378,
0.0185643118,
-0.0694380403,
-0.0096849343,
0.0392076112,
0.1187337711,
-0.0511738136,
-0.0273649003,
-0.0474529788,
-0.0439370535,
0.0412561782,
0.0751686245,
-0.0048778662,
-0.0504229441,
-0.031192679,
-0.0226694718,
-0.0377312303,
0.0155957229,
-0.0176050048,
-0.0340550952,
-0.0029822548,
-0.0115388157,
0.0223617218,
0.0057045203,
0.0855012909,
0.0179429241,
0.0209403317,
-0.010442473,
0.0048571615,
-0.0014041275,
-0.0355203189,
0.0321722068,
-0.0269632526,
0.0736693367,
-0.0381034166,
-0.0332634486,
0.0041927281,
0.0626175851,
-0.0218287855,
0.0288797915,
-0.0870540887,
-0.0249260161,
0.0005154763,
0.0715940595,
0.0357089154,
-0.0399405807,
0.0171958879,
-0.0487771034,
-0.0506827272,
0.0407214798,
-0.040635176,
-0.0094611086,
-0.0515742786,
-0.0136489552,
-0.0078357533,
-0.071557954,
-0.0232173465,
0.0240310319,
0.0076883622,
-0.0028000677,
-0.0032228138,
-0.0585296191,
-0.017052127,
0.0758987591,
-0.021123752,
0.0271263942,
-0.0313387886,
0.0084819347,
0.0134489192,
-0.0053738211,
0.005682373,
-0.0320929363,
0.0101322131,
-0.0330379903,
-0.0244064219,
0.0452541485,
0.0383023471,
-0.0189029612,
-0.019724533,
-0.047087606,
0.0524795502,
-0.0017762636,
0.0069955788,
0.0794985443,
-0.0008749642,
-0.0272146873,
-0.0345169343,
0.0029806565,
0.0366096087,
-0.007889539,
0.0129019804,
-0.0028438459,
0.0339951217,
-0.0274736267,
0.0221728701,
-0.055127766,
-0.0732708722,
0.0346256793,
0.0258497857,
0.0004625919,
0.0343416966,
0.0077782823,
-0.0775572211,
-0.012267204,
-0.0744749308,
0.0283997208,
-0.0154450377,
0.0255305674,
0.0042783516,
0.0098289857,
-0.0303917378,
-0.0691531226,
0.0535377711,
0.0002276143,
0.0388217233,
-0.0077919629,
-0.0826729983,
-0.037700329,
-0.046923656,
0.0108350031,
-0.0154515365,
-0.0410568081,
-0.072462298,
-0.0586134009,
-0.0297469012,
-0.0358168483,
-0.0302587561,
-0.014237741,
-0.03202115,
0.0113418931,
0.08522553,
0.0255109146,
-0.008288038,
0.0411563925,
-0.0038106104,
-0.0257806703,
-0.0434006974,
0.0025064207,
-6.025784244e-33,
0.0481054448,
-0.0239808913,
0.0440976806,
0.0305724014,
0.0308193974,
0.0069127432,
-0.0470954217,
-0.0192003269,
0.0451030098,
0.0373699181,
0.0017110521,
-0.0111805601,
0.0183479376,
-0.0506108589,
0.048121836,
0.0551984385,
0.0486244261,
0.0564112924,
-0.0143434294,
0.0510369092,
0.0735220909,
0.0013396682,
0.0149736386,
-0.0614470951,
-0.0045022555,
0.0211555958,
0.0322234519,
0.0048893895,
-0.036351949,
0.0349113718,
0.004800634,
0.0352436081,
-0.019627016,
-0.0278966278,
-0.0353549421,
0.0078431973,
-0.0099287368,
0.0207755733,
0.0310962982,
-0.0062283492,
-0.0343365744,
-0.0091713229,
-0.0025476762,
0.0143896565,
-0.0212495551,
0.0075513953,
-0.0220119711,
0.0040815463,
-0.0234087892,
0.0147107635,
-0.0468513928,
0.0089351293,
-0.0002169172,
0.0276782196,
0.0078173308,
0.002287905,
-0.0320866778,
-0.0040340987,
-0.0183449443,
0.0340010524,
0.0447761044,
-0.0240263846,
0.0379837863,
0.0319809914,
0.0337259695,
-0.0193120651,
0.0112792356,
0.033563111,
0.0058563761,
0.0421895348,
0.0110178133,
0.0550639667,
0.0423681103,
-0.0228335932,
0.0167215895,
-0.000440497,
-0.0655413643,
0.0254328009,
-0.0069531882,
0.0358693637,
0.0121400077,
0.0086203879,
0.0109497905,
-0.0292252004,
-0.0162463877,
0.045306839,
-0.0369672701,
0.002620531,
0.0027581968,
-0.0281819496,
-0.0160180349,
0.0368925035,
0.0556639507,
-0.0057914914,
-0.0493238568,
0.0224349387,
-0.0002374183,
0.0132031599,
0.0203872807,
0.0217477363,
-0.0153560396,
-0.0297006164,
-0.0425617509,
0.0005739284,
0.0579368025,
0.0170006547,
0.0161870979,
0.0158150122,
-0.0596391521,
0.0160034709,
-0.0646904185,
0.0084479898,
-0.0119158998,
0.0319226719,
0.0078889001,
0.0004215517,
0.0610923804,
0.0399365798,
0.0073876758,
-0.0221517533,
-0.0188243799,
0.0703443438,
-0.0177488588,
-0.0369292237,
-0.0028137525,
-0.0389511585,
-0.0552968234,
-0.0330282412,
0.0681002289,
-0.0092031956,
-0.0177539531,
-0.0000154205,
2.998e-7,
0.0280828848,
0.0463215448,
-0.0015384707,
0.0517594665,
0.0857328847,
-0.006957286,
-0.0315584727,
-0.0284589492,
0.0019152011,
0.0255489014,
0.0135842068,
-0.0094678914,
0.0742823482,
0.0106983529,
-0.0256426763,
-0.0751316696,
-0.0620349199,
-0.0045931544,
-0.0786835179,
-0.032987617,
0.0059899013,
0.0036997749,
0.0419574678,
-0.0212702435,
0.01755156,
-0.0115318121,
0.0013051997,
-0.0312135126,
0.0598037206,
0.0497180857,
-0.0273876246,
0.0036904952,
0.0470764488,
0.0479834899,
-0.0082254782,
-0.0743371025,
-0.0577094592,
0.0948011428,
-0.0267912801,
0.0664106682,
0.0304478575,
-0.0383804739,
0.0086353999,
-0.0676332489,
-0.0005780279,
-0.0651818141,
-0.0567869693,
-0.0284554884,
0.0097158747,
-0.0544329733,
0.0345364958,
-0.004910762,
0.0322127156,
0.0258890893,
-0.0146948323,
-0.0081074797,
-0.0213234089,
0.0020721918,
-0.0136776157,
0.017020775,
-0.0521916524,
-0.0390022509,
-0.0635026619,
-0.0022775366,
0.0170318522,
0.0114320703,
0.0224628206,
3.447548607e-34,
0.03548887,
0.0350739248,
0.0316483267,
0.0132058449,
-0.0097561879,
0.0142912734,
0.0076416708,
0.033962328,
-0.0007759269,
-0.0308010299,
-0.0111406846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01820v1 | Minimalist Grammar: Construction without Overgeneration | 2023-11-03T10:02:00 | 2023-11-03T10:02:00 | Isidor Konrad Maier, Johannes Kuhn, Jesse Beisegel, Markus Huber-Liebl, Matthias Wolff | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we give instructions on how to write a minimalist grammar (MG).
In order to present the instructions as an algorithm, we use a variant of
context free grammars (CFG) as an input format. We can exclude overgeneration,
if the CFG has no recursion, i.e. no non-terminal can (indirectly) derive to a
right-hand side containing itself. The constructed MGs utilize licensors/-ees
as a special way of exception handling. A CFG format for a derivation
$A\_eats\_B\mapsto^* peter\_eats\_apples$, where $A$ and $B$ generate noun
phrases, normally leads to overgeneration, e.\,g., $i\_eats\_apples$. In order
to avoid overgeneration, a CFG would need many non-terminal symbols and rules,
that mainly produce the same word, just to handle exceptions. In our MGs
however, we can summarize CFG rules that produce the same word in one item and
handle exceptions by a proper distribution of licensees/-ors. The difficulty
with this technique is that in most generations the majority of licensees/-ors
is not needed, but still has to be triggered somehow. We solve this problem
with $\epsilon$-items called \emph{adapters}. | [
0.0229870155,
0.0280007701,
-0.0202556551,
0.0375707075,
-0.0180582646,
-0.0225316025,
-0.0536926948,
0.0155289955,
-0.0396318249,
-0.0218711309,
0.0373347104,
-0.0078060008,
-0.017491119,
-0.042254474,
-0.0126475403,
-0.013494052,
0.0540503636,
-0.0086796843,
-0.0195247959,
-0.0038555802,
-0.0212523583,
0.012566763,
0.0164538212,
0.0067613889,
-0.0185215473,
-0.0052629989,
-0.0187742822,
0.0125911981,
0.022820022,
-0.000109971,
-0.0090506924,
-0.034566097,
-0.0391466618,
0.035846144,
0.000001872,
-0.0456682518,
-0.0445206426,
0.0073264311,
-0.0492516048,
0.0219821762,
0.0480833575,
0.0080296854,
-0.042668052,
0.0097203478,
-0.0112229055,
-0.0064389631,
0.0319957063,
0.0187881328,
0.063777186,
0.0650138855,
-0.0002164152,
-0.0977276266,
-0.0032983364,
0.0051996619,
0.0184359681,
-0.0148549266,
0.0242962781,
-0.0343365185,
0.0442433022,
-0.0379804261,
0.0154771768,
0.0111050056,
0.0006250999,
-0.025692936,
-0.0226352606,
0.0076558692,
-0.0116723953,
-0.0352169313,
-0.023221707,
0.0008023363,
0.0116178533,
-0.0536674969,
0.0172006469,
0.0124054244,
0.027565036,
-0.0600619651,
-0.0318198614,
0.0730410293,
-0.0084331436,
0.0364277288,
0.087410748,
-0.0466708243,
-0.0261035729,
-0.040202558,
-0.0055080708,
0.0353425369,
0.0491437353,
-0.0377802365,
-0.0322811492,
0.0024460957,
-0.0389284566,
-0.0780743584,
0.0152788153,
0.0372269675,
-0.0146891018,
0.0247997306,
-0.059917897,
-0.0298075546,
0.0043493067,
-0.0433899648,
0.0188821051,
0.0113804527,
0.0378311761,
0.030245645,
-0.0334625877,
-0.0101024732,
-0.0092520239,
-0.022150239,
-0.0281660482,
0.0155726764,
-0.0085525755,
-0.0106567042,
-0.1162446439,
0.0861906409,
-0.0715221614,
0.0244025607,
-0.0255920384,
0.0351403318,
-0.0055407509,
0.0170842353,
-0.0083851255,
-0.0009295144,
-0.0183788091,
0.0480553769,
0.0264003649,
0.0051385318,
-0.0267243888,
-0.0433597304,
0.023313703,
-0.0076676868,
-0.0160691291,
0.0316763967,
0.0471910909,
0.0160490032,
-0.037665315,
0.0577836148,
0.027136866,
0.0146546541,
-0.0796990171,
-0.0413173027,
-0.0012615934,
0.0135175856,
-0.0153465541,
-0.0488510467,
-0.0304752085,
-0.0112518556,
-0.010633002,
-0.051209569,
-0.0183360204,
0.0028514352,
-0.0204288792,
-0.0164292585,
-0.0231436156,
0.0042030686,
-0.0398533605,
0.0117898593,
0.0390041582,
0.0043900092,
0.0158302989,
-0.0145705463,
0.0416671485,
0.0074033663,
0.0064137797,
0.0229926519,
-0.0214430727,
-0.0092052743,
-0.0206304938,
-0.0330157802,
-0.0204973184,
-0.0118298717,
0.0024201705,
0.1053830832,
-0.0008188136,
0.0005347753,
-0.0138269635,
0.0024541181,
0.0581738837,
0.0399539769,
0.0546489432,
0.0097087501,
-0.0019104502,
0.0219471604,
0.0018948892,
-0.0264219884,
-0.0732289553,
-0.0196427442,
-0.1046257764,
0.0303656645,
0.0182046015,
-0.0405283831,
-0.0093683144,
-0.0005342174,
-0.0156474002,
-0.0773174316,
0.0208513867,
0.0487150624,
-0.0112907356,
0.0365350097,
0.0171374436,
-0.0968923718,
-0.0146351047,
-0.0202007443,
0.0747111514,
-0.0088692615,
0.0206777994,
-0.0004264433,
-0.0065480787,
0.0374399126,
0.0076506701,
0.0371525064,
0.0196028743,
-0.0381981283,
0.013668091,
0.0024827744,
0.0059811203,
0.0293183122,
0.0475389436,
0.0286767669,
-0.042502068,
-0.0392289609,
0.0230897889,
0.0164776761,
0.0183307584,
0.0220078137,
0.0349288136,
-0.0147697283,
0.0009754928,
0.0077243387,
0.0219922122,
0.0188730843,
0.0155360531,
0.0492999107,
0.0712236017,
0.0028944069,
-0.015187039,
0.0458105616,
-0.0002049441,
-0.0230692923,
0.0539063774,
-0.0217348356,
0.0322058499,
-0.0361203551,
0.0000919945,
-0.0425972044,
0.0478689335,
-0.0476841554,
0.1507099867,
-0.0100799361,
0.0853497088,
0.0173553582,
-0.0470043868,
-0.0189258866,
0.0699532554,
0.0300286394,
-0.0091211954,
0.0119016087,
-0.0407351069,
0.0504872017,
-0.0014205116,
-0.0053699012,
-0.0199641213,
-0.0404850021,
0.004109045,
0.0145555865,
0.0755923614,
-0.0389567614,
-0.0311126839,
-0.0104771079,
0.0083174938,
-0.0156357344,
0.0534439757,
0.0371140987,
0.0579381995,
-0.0000285917,
0.0185495578,
0.0024083443,
0.0651336759,
0.0337149017,
-0.0118303988,
0.0123372991,
0.0083154803,
-0.0842177495,
0.0021655215,
0.0135424575,
-0.0314661488,
-0.0039490294,
-0.0065801949,
-0.0119724814,
-0.0320051685,
0.0071582589,
-0.0500630178,
0.0439090393,
0.0029782611,
0.0028439879,
0.0165651422,
-0.0267789811,
0.0034542971,
0.016112892,
-0.0183933899,
0.0035326625,
0.0113295624,
-0.0129536837,
-0.0142203253,
-0.0174980685,
0.0156114148,
-0.0346407369,
-0.0187202413,
0.0168713015,
0.0209821835,
0.0426697508,
0.0082854461,
-0.0155275101,
-0.0305741206,
0.0489982255,
-0.0083466517,
-0.009414902,
0.0267733745,
-0.0514670573,
-0.0445704013,
-0.0002920289,
-0.0079928851,
-0.0119697452,
0.0104231639,
-0.0167390369,
0.0088330321,
-0.0042320006,
0.0144806551,
-0.0554125831,
0.0357056782,
0.0202363636,
0.0498666428,
0.0718404725,
-0.0328989811,
-0.0283707976,
0.0541645512,
0.0540630557,
0.0115649868,
0.0750012249,
-0.0856304392,
-0.0035958039,
-0.0048400392,
-0.0301587731,
-0.0516634174,
-0.0285638049,
0.0339863598,
0.0069550835,
-0.0070933104,
0.0253981054,
-0.0289467759,
-0.0119469436,
-0.0170881543,
-0.0086140344,
0.041568093,
-0.0113431569,
-0.0111134145,
0.0369856879,
-0.0144474488,
-0.0000837302,
-0.0368177667,
0.0396192074,
-0.0135235433,
0.0599277839,
0.0076438575,
0.0304995459,
0.0024849344,
0.0188194569,
0.0450158715,
-0.0268302336,
-0.0812019482,
0.0169499125,
0.0251537226,
-0.0041867942,
-0.0309709758,
0.0670130327,
0.0355082601,
0.0055505382,
0.0772142559,
-0.0302431807,
0.0185724217,
0.0218506511,
0.041908402,
-0.0839002356,
0.003600437,
-0.0139680915,
0.0192368049,
-0.0139146941,
0.0140693448,
0.0000123095,
-0.0532588065,
0.0412498489,
0.0337777175,
-0.0394190773,
-0.0084773125,
-0.0021148052,
-0.007932174,
-0.0064822705,
-0.0444672182,
0.058558438,
-0.0605197251,
0.0000743405,
0.0369554125,
0.0235769153,
0.007857007,
-0.0437261052,
-0.0274603497,
0.0468105152,
0.0675967857,
-0.0046239938,
-0.0042726598,
-0.0277746432,
0.0486896187,
-0.0855129957,
-0.0201137736,
-0.0445169695,
-0.0852111802,
0.0103195496,
0.026214784,
-0.0256626233,
0.0266593117,
0.0004298538,
-0.0282257088,
0.0349401347,
0.0633438453,
0.0138240559,
-0.056501288,
-0.0101518342,
-0.0238917023,
-0.0131149646,
0.0435652547,
0.0180951785,
0.0397648029,
-0.0105988216,
-0.0756581575,
-0.07296592,
-0.0335552059,
0.0036318181,
-0.0095259985,
-0.0367304757,
-0.0825713053,
-0.06139623,
0.0468657129,
0.0135362353,
0.0475729108,
-0.0014750907,
-0.0217132289,
-0.0215741657,
-0.0385250896,
0.0056283241,
-0.0613742359,
-0.05310864,
-0.0001919324,
-0.0529600605,
0.008312338,
0.0214454886,
0.0535510443,
-0.0394896567,
-0.0231499616,
-0.0030804188,
-0.0787922665,
0.0420236364,
0.0814556703,
0.0301684253,
-0.0032246273,
-0.0289312545,
-0.0081054429,
0.0226650238,
0.0926031098,
0.0311944,
0.0820048973,
0.0192861743,
-0.0383207537,
0.0068250732,
0.0227463935,
-0.0233724713,
0.0154827805,
0.0316143781,
0.0570487007,
-0.0330963917,
0.0380533561,
0.0552277714,
0.0963106379,
-0.0690497234,
-0.0386303663,
-0.0175413787,
0.0174486917,
-0.011447479,
-0.035587512,
-0.0219341274,
-0.0229023956,
0.0118732546,
-0.0361638069,
-0.029047763,
0.0184243266,
-0.0649907514,
-0.0390030742,
0.0326414444,
-0.0262802672,
0.0370300151,
0.0318706483,
-0.0163469817,
-0.0028855538,
0.0143918945,
0.0130058993,
-0.0103111351,
0.0013280018,
0.005311803,
-0.065414533,
-0.0055799363,
0.0268267058,
0.0212559551,
-0.0832699388,
0.0037729472,
0.0133029176,
0.0885139853,
0.0004137785,
0.0357531421,
0.0636326373,
-0.0018286817,
0.0705590323,
-0.0385800749,
0.0116170747,
-0.0199744478,
0.0589988008,
-0.012274866,
-0.0625936985,
-0.0153826969,
0.0368153378,
0.0114519522,
-0.0559599474,
0.0755459368,
-0.0490183868,
0.0143401036,
0.0016543855,
0.0255779419,
-0.0500961654,
-0.0016484753,
-0.0096689137,
0.0000135264,
0.0041185631,
-0.0022963709,
-0.0649552643,
-0.0209510028,
-0.0225045532,
0.0592304468,
0.0807378069,
0.0032565007,
0.0347282998,
0.0101618702,
0.0406336971,
-0.0769516081,
-0.0174326543,
0.0084313927,
-0.0375425592,
-0.0281142723,
-0.0070671574,
-5.532503835e-33,
-0.0468603149,
0.0089731803,
-0.0095841251,
0.0197874531,
-0.0102487756,
-0.0063365526,
-0.0460805036,
0.004927821,
0.0399869047,
-0.0370033458,
-0.0080129532,
0.0015743622,
0.0102158012,
-0.0175804459,
0.034132883,
0.003842467,
0.0070631672,
0.0251791086,
-0.0512504168,
-0.0413994789,
-0.0081884488,
-0.0259406082,
0.0257628858,
0.0075607211,
0.0260731578,
-0.0375085622,
-0.0060316199,
0.0270744897,
-0.0346307456,
0.047210671,
0.0434247144,
0.0238283668,
0.0006451901,
0.0468185842,
-0.0147362743,
-0.0130283572,
-0.0874089375,
-0.0497802794,
0.034987051,
-0.0278029703,
0.0159843825,
-0.0367439054,
0.0338333808,
0.0024058267,
-0.0128395306,
0.0646499619,
-0.0108169634,
0.0217103604,
-0.029775694,
0.0505897328,
-0.0281309541,
-0.0032418962,
-0.0062086638,
0.0490142107,
-0.0162896905,
-0.0126432264,
0.0071490291,
-0.034147732,
0.0162715055,
0.0323459469,
0.0371262729,
-0.0237074941,
0.0411446281,
-0.0459963158,
-0.0095246937,
-0.0287801549,
-0.0150381075,
-0.0080959192,
-0.018599255,
0.0063899918,
-0.0457288213,
0.0621541888,
-0.0167578794,
-0.0123765552,
0.0260892436,
-0.0047595399,
-0.0361426137,
0.0489570946,
0.024907073,
0.054494448,
-0.0635383129,
0.0304545909,
-0.039231997,
-0.0362715833,
0.0064041158,
-0.0387187973,
0.0149004124,
-0.0257025361,
0.0025214676,
-0.0058412799,
-0.0480989106,
-0.0194741637,
0.0053676735,
-0.0119861364,
-0.0127210775,
-0.0398171693,
0.0306683853,
0.0151351849,
-0.0463723354,
0.0024204378,
0.010303882,
-0.0628947094,
-0.0029630393,
-0.0363080055,
0.0365740024,
0.0218622703,
0.0141026657,
0.0086558722,
-0.0360153541,
-0.0008062873,
-0.0249612741,
-0.0040011164,
-0.0331699401,
-0.0268036779,
-0.0026111975,
0.0337365605,
0.0512216724,
-0.0563045964,
0.0319546983,
-0.036262162,
-0.0260003563,
0.0194239821,
0.0378715061,
-0.0148212835,
-0.0086709121,
-0.0100681046,
0.0289263297,
0.0921132341,
0.0837037414,
-0.0033681502,
-0.0376988836,
-0.0283973925,
2.823e-7,
0.0423162095,
-0.0048223641,
0.0744781867,
0.044428166,
-0.0072742193,
-0.0110179903,
0.0291056782,
0.0146188512,
-0.0641433895,
0.0462276787,
0.0109420037,
-0.0327399112,
-0.0360722318,
0.002527765,
-0.043845322,
0.04145623,
0.003783067,
-0.0149762407,
0.0016465711,
0.0036522755,
0.0519785248,
0.0054605277,
0.0360742062,
-0.0040062149,
-0.0628879443,
-0.019650409,
-0.0031579777,
0.0281212833,
0.038490437,
0.0099276397,
0.0221075956,
0.0005513564,
0.0501791574,
-0.0285016261,
0.0101220496,
-0.0049758386,
-0.0418010578,
0.0227775648,
-0.066711247,
0.0552269779,
0.0627963394,
-0.0378451012,
0.0092687402,
0.0229441989,
0.0127235055,
0.0090052821,
0.0278479718,
0.0363470316,
-0.0673205778,
0.0258292072,
-0.1243979707,
0.0260163229,
-0.0399620794,
-0.0330762044,
0.0123130633,
0.0003855062,
-0.0485237502,
-0.0489371009,
-0.0012843873,
0.030391071,
0.0196767133,
-0.0692771152,
0.0537568666,
0.059581358,
-0.0123284105,
-0.0403099656,
-0.0374999903,
2.659355767e-34,
0.0182381608,
-0.0148753924,
0.0279384498,
0.0363508649,
0.0073417518,
0.0016006354,
0.0108935861,
0.0290597156,
-0.0152397556,
-0.0415256135,
-0.0455141999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01817v1 | Mitigating Framing Bias with Polarity Minimization Loss | 2023-11-03T09:50:23 | 2023-11-03T09:50:23 | Yejin Bang, Nayeon Lee, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Framing bias plays a significant role in exacerbating political polarization
by distorting the perception of actual events. Media outlets with divergent
political stances often use polarized language in their reporting of the same
event. We propose a new loss function that encourages the model to minimize the
polarity difference between the polarized input articles to reduce framing
bias. Specifically, our loss is designed to jointly optimize the model to map
polarity ends bidirectionally. Our experimental results demonstrate that
incorporating the proposed polarity minimization loss leads to a substantial
reduction in framing bias when compared to a BART-based multi-document
summarization model. Notably, we find that the effectiveness of this approach
is most pronounced when the model is trained to minimize the polarity loss
associated with informational framing bias (i.e., skewed selection of
information to report). | [
-0.0149958599,
0.0079762395,
0.0367652886,
0.0040991399,
-0.0130918315,
0.0108787101,
0.002943584,
-0.0264839623,
-0.0218529701,
-0.0633640215,
-0.0114399511,
-0.0074146381,
-0.0031962341,
0.0110557517,
-0.0379280671,
-0.081864424,
0.065988183,
0.0312265158,
0.0126339747,
-0.0237427745,
0.0205095559,
0.0312477052,
-0.0143364752,
0.0257535297,
-0.0201192349,
0.0185158551,
0.0076461253,
-0.0038390218,
0.0708303824,
-0.0135102486,
-0.0056132814,
0.0215166006,
0.006550625,
-0.0181743074,
0.0000016441,
0.0045630285,
-0.031096831,
-0.0119926818,
0.0333996415,
0.0046999347,
0.086089626,
-0.0595811829,
0.0256798193,
0.0287071299,
-0.0165476408,
-0.0087784557,
0.0412087254,
0.0614454225,
0.0869719535,
0.0508391336,
0.0050785029,
-0.019653935,
-0.0339661241,
-0.0363720804,
-0.0216610748,
-0.0392971076,
0.0313525312,
0.0095576784,
-0.1005632728,
0.0152663197,
-0.0183027256,
0.0075484184,
0.0125253843,
0.0197377373,
-0.0649277121,
0.0233493466,
0.0188703388,
-0.0106097097,
0.0174126457,
0.0544905998,
0.0366391614,
-0.0289066434,
0.0396368057,
-0.0317954384,
0.0184394084,
0.0109799122,
-0.0272356011,
0.0427407846,
-0.016396014,
0.0464296825,
0.0165768564,
0.0327121057,
0.0029395211,
0.0548703708,
-0.0010075744,
-0.0077311629,
-0.0103680175,
0.0105723515,
-0.0348721296,
0.0208243318,
0.0211205985,
-0.0130079696,
0.0254632141,
0.0022789305,
0.0256875586,
-0.0084876856,
-0.035114564,
-0.0472648367,
0.0227758456,
-0.0686626583,
-0.0593515709,
-0.0014560751,
0.0140704606,
0.0787667483,
0.0214940347,
-0.0500481464,
-0.0047247251,
0.0208517723,
-0.0103759244,
-0.022186419,
-0.0086410902,
0.020831544,
0.0068802391,
0.0418095067,
-0.0530390218,
-0.0171539932,
-0.0114613045,
-0.0271043684,
-0.0290689599,
-0.0385905765,
-0.0207684729,
0.0410766564,
-0.0079201516,
-0.0455254018,
-0.0079623424,
0.0917547867,
-0.0354239009,
0.0125550805,
-0.0143049201,
0.047060553,
-0.0108684115,
0.0587045029,
-0.0236202087,
0.0014614523,
-0.0066584894,
0.0112894345,
-0.04554414,
0.0177220423,
-0.0225665104,
-0.0192360878,
-0.032677222,
-0.0503055863,
0.0509485081,
-0.0620046444,
0.0390078761,
-0.0081346938,
-0.0037501887,
-0.0427276418,
-0.0122140376,
-0.0132303629,
-0.0453437604,
0.0484765768,
0.0412123203,
-0.0360014699,
0.1049987376,
0.0376895592,
0.0040353485,
0.1251784712,
-0.0075371652,
0.0218835957,
0.0343437307,
0.0128912907,
-0.0296163112,
-0.0058098347,
0.0465970896,
0.0497323722,
0.0191054884,
-0.0202809889,
-0.0321576372,
-0.0275635924,
0.0946968645,
0.0228528548,
-0.0250157211,
-0.0248717852,
0.0498504154,
0.0056984816,
-0.0378270112,
-0.0113365734,
0.0054604257,
0.0335008465,
-0.019315226,
0.0644385144,
-0.0129708266,
0.0634946823,
-0.0302431341,
0.0023132223,
0.0514618196,
0.0338408723,
-0.0541604757,
-0.0219543334,
0.0218748953,
-0.0257150438,
0.0264526382,
-0.0322942659,
0.0185315367,
0.0158281066,
-0.0489206053,
0.1194022521,
0.0200870521,
-0.0434809662,
0.0619162805,
-0.0176541079,
0.0036120042,
-0.0385432541,
0.0012976604,
-0.033778742,
-0.0043531763,
-0.0422923043,
0.0241487417,
0.0512267463,
0.0706656873,
-0.012730265,
-0.004452318,
-0.0249883588,
-0.0456009582,
0.0059981011,
0.0293513723,
0.0335418396,
-0.0152331563,
0.0161293559,
0.0325089358,
0.0147822974,
-0.0130871926,
0.0252969954,
0.0079397503,
-0.0150652211,
-0.0166167673,
0.0186018255,
0.0365968607,
0.0383577012,
-0.0240593869,
-0.0108392658,
0.0325484388,
0.0037302473,
-0.0660595149,
0.0082041584,
-0.0736378878,
-0.0076346714,
0.0054614311,
-0.0937094614,
-0.0048831268,
-0.0033095181,
-0.037971288,
-0.0357791632,
0.0624818355,
-0.0106445625,
-0.063941732,
-0.0104958024,
-0.0148154562,
-0.0034004028,
-0.0245822351,
-0.0387900323,
0.0764534175,
-0.016418511,
0.0102448631,
0.027783893,
-0.0682408661,
-0.0242119674,
-0.0102362111,
-0.0117572304,
0.0310960002,
0.0076557002,
0.032324262,
0.0499689281,
-0.042738121,
-0.012412196,
-0.0355110653,
-0.0542082377,
0.0225746259,
-0.0100068515,
0.0280192774,
0.0710320175,
-0.0140800569,
-0.0016967201,
-0.0039600083,
-0.006609018,
-0.0748446062,
-0.009835477,
0.001146153,
0.0170569383,
0.0279493723,
0.0417543277,
-0.0152309351,
-0.0149382083,
-0.0201549046,
0.0315333195,
-0.0269794352,
-0.0311830789,
-0.0369155295,
0.028623702,
-0.0091092363,
-0.0178300496,
-0.0379396901,
-0.0061094258,
-0.0212533139,
0.0075142416,
-0.0069444114,
0.0791677386,
0.0689722076,
0.0185320042,
0.0499635823,
0.0258033499,
-0.0505187623,
-0.0145696159,
-0.0536077581,
0.0556739941,
-0.0144550921,
-0.0745957792,
0.0487007909,
0.0274733994,
0.0226064976,
0.0441948585,
-0.0033079574,
0.0406795926,
-0.0304673016,
-0.0186006259,
0.0150902122,
-0.0246815514,
0.0022853189,
0.0136431884,
-0.0321342014,
0.0154924421,
0.0516457483,
0.0008917555,
0.0558110662,
-0.0606139898,
0.0308184456,
-0.0525339246,
0.0241734628,
-0.0105920704,
0.0162391048,
-0.0356120989,
-0.0161000993,
-0.0643394217,
-0.0931948647,
0.0908603072,
-0.0036065669,
0.0809393674,
-0.0234140959,
0.0042437552,
-0.025038965,
-0.0227978881,
0.0002947984,
-0.0341679156,
0.0033252244,
0.0263833012,
0.0380356424,
0.0322708338,
-0.0600566603,
0.0325253904,
0.051473286,
0.0117904162,
-0.0358831137,
0.020589238,
0.0078695836,
0.0655132383,
0.0140127363,
-0.0263419729,
0.028632829,
-0.0195807517,
0.0030390222,
0.0357389338,
-0.0002062152,
0.0393646806,
0.0087147178,
-0.046901986,
-0.0210414529,
-0.0725351125,
-0.0243653879,
-0.0575378686,
0.0535129495,
-0.0150479013,
0.0450415201,
0.0824182704,
0.0355756991,
-0.0713299066,
-0.0527727753,
0.0223428179,
-0.0224310271,
0.0096480967,
-0.0039776089,
-0.0673327744,
-0.0021388794,
0.0086636655,
0.0378160961,
0.0143816173,
-0.0184529647,
-0.0083429972,
-0.0807088539,
-0.0265428796,
0.0203043949,
-0.032201346,
-0.0509067848,
-0.0589330159,
0.0110662263,
-0.0512306467,
0.0024301244,
0.0096464055,
-0.0057341484,
-0.0001110287,
0.0294088144,
-0.0748852938,
-0.0059787803,
-0.0544830263,
-0.0268499982,
-0.0013060865,
0.0001485476,
0.0301227085,
-0.0213528574,
0.0482125245,
0.0229053311,
-0.0201744549,
-0.0289345682,
-0.0305958204,
0.0991463736,
-0.0401958562,
0.0136016663,
0.0089663789,
0.0574624427,
0.0582140908,
0.0037896319,
0.0011904844,
-0.0039356276,
0.0141218947,
-0.0222741272,
-0.0049183853,
0.060169287,
0.0327446908,
0.0606568865,
0.0200829376,
0.0088262279,
-0.0180544946,
-0.0154076582,
0.0276869647,
-0.0600881055,
-0.0033435095,
-0.016758211,
-0.0193423964,
0.0074332035,
-0.0552141294,
-0.0556491837,
-0.0285299066,
-0.0191939957,
-0.0144187873,
-0.0044880179,
0.008204788,
0.0030353046,
-0.0259421729,
0.0057921973,
0.0136013739,
-0.0150319021,
-0.0006140819,
-0.0006486182,
0.0358254425,
-0.0232661813,
-0.0520100854,
0.04775884,
-0.0302620362,
-0.0610464178,
-0.0009239103,
0.0373304114,
0.0159855951,
0.0574887395,
0.0175912064,
-0.0178853665,
0.0216883142,
0.0933821127,
-0.0105408505,
0.0113931838,
0.0535962433,
0.0485569984,
-0.0091321366,
0.0160740819,
-0.018150311,
0.0428834148,
-0.0054649864,
-0.016635837,
-0.0240330435,
-0.0116460826,
-0.0163063556,
-0.0088610025,
0.0043933131,
-0.018793622,
0.0068162507,
-0.0744509324,
-0.0266962703,
-0.0079183057,
-0.0321645886,
0.0263463706,
0.0387264565,
-0.0060750502,
-0.0367296189,
-0.0291314106,
0.0971273407,
0.0076631699,
0.0315780416,
-0.0048838085,
0.0271824449,
-0.017210789,
-0.0067026443,
-0.0582645722,
0.0192899723,
-0.0575837828,
-0.0008183009,
-0.0014362413,
-0.0012409575,
-0.0185888074,
0.0137196751,
0.02933589,
0.0406139344,
-0.0077076214,
-0.0105608506,
-0.0470640585,
0.020689588,
-0.0386731178,
0.0536649488,
0.0250274744,
-0.0217026081,
0.0555312932,
0.0138734719,
-0.0316132903,
-0.0139085781,
0.0060464456,
0.0386075713,
0.0179935694,
0.0454997383,
0.0162680317,
-0.007477724,
0.0092856493,
0.0785811767,
-0.0352705382,
0.0454818308,
0.0148663586,
-0.0562686846,
-0.0344331823,
-0.0341449678,
0.0271486454,
0.0236924645,
-0.0089198155,
-0.0337410606,
-0.0554309115,
-0.0232644361,
0.0362468511,
0.0003703659,
0.0095403912,
-0.0134050557,
0.0180632733,
0.0425543562,
0.0164649803,
-0.0082616862,
-0.0342193507,
0.0247777756,
-0.0450512767,
-0.0028245717,
-0.001884909,
-5.599124243e-33,
-0.055345878,
-0.0121182296,
-0.0372654237,
0.0263988506,
-0.0129520632,
0.0400393121,
-0.0247944128,
0.0052807853,
-0.0414093845,
0.0154131306,
0.0369586274,
0.0429789722,
0.0176404249,
0.0056503098,
-0.0172959566,
0.0146691948,
0.0506535284,
-0.0158835445,
-0.0571288243,
0.032714162,
0.0229762997,
-0.0278096832,
0.0263279676,
-0.0412570238,
-0.0028234434,
-0.0129948631,
-0.0534851849,
-0.0407155864,
0.0516412072,
0.0226370376,
-0.0062429905,
-0.0251630172,
0.0484458469,
-0.0528470315,
-0.0306068305,
0.0455752388,
-0.0682057515,
-0.0449226275,
0.0313748755,
-0.0246817246,
-0.0143052731,
-0.0210128408,
0.0324562192,
0.0203914586,
-0.0112116095,
-0.0465241745,
0.0628800392,
-0.0043854043,
-0.0178041328,
-0.0144943614,
-0.0194828622,
0.0357052088,
-0.0134019246,
-0.0095628062,
-0.0061287293,
0.00021473,
0.0375749953,
0.0323005058,
-0.0917577296,
0.0048983386,
-0.0504475012,
0.0458485112,
0.0428882167,
-0.0075230128,
-0.0237952154,
0.0784323514,
0.0247297976,
0.0169717427,
-0.0558353253,
-0.0524611361,
0.002024774,
-0.0253543798,
0.043965809,
0.0661695302,
0.009863086,
-0.0291126259,
-0.0827195048,
0.0485198088,
0.0310199391,
0.0140318563,
0.0234394111,
-0.0144345136,
0.0353161246,
-0.0137594268,
-0.0546242669,
-0.0713692382,
-0.0156482588,
-0.0017244061,
-0.0276905298,
0.0603541508,
-0.063832894,
0.0068250699,
0.0347099602,
-0.0290442742,
0.0266982038,
0.0593108311,
-0.020417681,
-0.010573592,
0.0195571966,
-0.020410331,
-0.0538394935,
0.0129426699,
0.0048629348,
0.0273537617,
0.0002501011,
-0.0436814688,
0.080789797,
-0.0249851681,
-0.0564605258,
0.0065253587,
0.0028560343,
0.0246870462,
-0.0175302476,
0.0629216433,
0.0221288223,
0.0144179408,
-0.0014389901,
0.0113532878,
0.0347575322,
0.0226220023,
0.0185231231,
-0.0375755616,
-0.0365598202,
0.0393660702,
-0.0455957614,
0.0008522649,
0.005441892,
0.0134211853,
0.0163431913,
-0.0486384034,
-0.0413252451,
-0.0129722115,
2.376e-7,
0.0690959692,
0.0369847491,
0.0279476102,
0.0108457692,
0.0157889482,
0.0574955456,
0.0251998119,
0.038420368,
-0.0331582502,
-0.0352848284,
0.0154003277,
0.0333429724,
0.013430696,
0.0373049378,
-0.055309739,
0.0155968014,
-0.0339471251,
0.0142081026,
0.0003737118,
-0.0398610979,
0.0095986826,
0.0045829006,
-0.005486561,
-0.0048057269,
-0.0119803967,
-0.024922058,
0.073142767,
0.0067936741,
-0.0326367058,
0.0236310251,
0.0022378394,
-0.0313157588,
-0.0054397616,
-0.0035145599,
-0.0187929757,
-0.0087154433,
0.0009475687,
0.0227376353,
0.023992274,
-0.0538881049,
-0.0132667366,
0.0198246706,
-0.004245481,
-0.0175534673,
0.0639694482,
-0.0853793025,
-0.0050246995,
-0.0927369073,
-0.0889559165,
0.0300552826,
0.0371553414,
0.0231299289,
-0.0232489333,
0.0667761788,
-0.038625855,
0.0284190867,
0.0073977178,
-0.0613994375,
-0.0277349241,
-0.0346621461,
-0.0265739635,
-0.0225957148,
0.0247420836,
0.0139987441,
0.0045925505,
-0.0266924538,
0.0144453524,
1.787882597e-34,
0.0794932768,
-0.0050004125,
-0.0606249943,
-0.0473502763,
0.0117563801,
0.0050767637,
-0.0649658665,
-0.0304746833,
-0.0092688845,
-0.016840104,
-0.0216634274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04924v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04924v2 | Tuning-less Object Naming with a Foundation Model | 2023-11-03T09:11:49 | 2024-02-26T13:08:43 | Andrej Lucny, Pavel Petrovic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.9 | We implement a real-time object naming system that enables learning a set of
named entities never seen. Our approach employs an existing foundation model
that we consider ready to see anything before starting. It turns seen images
into relatively small feature vectors that we associate with index to a
gradually built vocabulary without any training of fine-tuning of the model.
Our contribution is using the association mechanism known from transformers as
attention. It has features that support generalization from irrelevant
information for distinguishing the entities and potentially enable associating
with much more than indices to vocabulary. As a result, the system can work in
a one-shot manner and correctly name objects named in different contents. We
also outline implementation details of the system modules integrated by a
blackboard architecture. Finally, we investigate the system's quality, mainly
how many objects it can handle in this way. | [
0.0510709956,
0.028130753,
0.0084733637,
0.0196845233,
0.0227896329,
0.0316047668,
0.049109228,
-0.0129336538,
-0.0294750761,
-0.0219833814,
0.0086432844,
-0.0127070183,
-0.0383916572,
0.0514221527,
0.0080681704,
-0.0853623152,
0.0444645137,
0.0142638553,
-0.0340965912,
0.0229298566,
-0.010610925,
-0.0243778992,
-0.0103863031,
0.0088345706,
-0.0488907322,
0.0155854626,
-0.0706162974,
-0.0065705213,
0.0230828524,
-0.0469653197,
-0.0456641987,
0.0616303533,
0.0012394434,
0.0623811781,
0.0000020515,
-0.048556786,
-0.0152992224,
-0.0077641304,
-0.0132084982,
-0.0488290265,
-0.0023630469,
-0.0014719107,
-0.0141445557,
-0.0314960293,
-0.0119408518,
-0.0352003202,
0.1226604953,
0.0294649173,
0.0211616531,
-0.0014497312,
-0.0088642277,
-0.0726778731,
0.0285838209,
-0.0131094372,
0.0230810456,
-0.0001927313,
0.0043619927,
-0.0160228871,
0.0128011154,
0.004391978,
-0.0250878092,
0.0280330032,
0.0325092785,
0.0040673008,
0.087274693,
0.0808039978,
-0.042603679,
-0.0455650464,
-0.0166271403,
0.0917211398,
-0.0654714033,
-0.0296212696,
0.0363565125,
-0.0172018614,
-0.0118948407,
-0.0201906301,
-0.0385794863,
0.0205818601,
-0.0374250822,
-0.0332184881,
-0.02041981,
0.0037599634,
0.0006186993,
0.0015702369,
0.0212424491,
-0.0439231358,
0.0244983844,
0.0206457265,
-0.0387318023,
-0.0001057905,
-0.0012201483,
-0.1046006531,
0.0003953701,
0.0616117232,
0.0096354578,
0.0463587418,
-0.0711487308,
-0.007527947,
-0.012269807,
-0.0616995431,
-0.0108000943,
0.0146871954,
-0.0272391438,
0.081343919,
-0.0526234768,
0.0479668826,
-0.0308164377,
0.0372071117,
-0.0220168643,
0.0046034069,
-0.0622038655,
-0.0047433306,
-0.0873155519,
0.0681249276,
-0.0284696054,
-0.0459489971,
-0.0042038257,
0.020658575,
0.0082279146,
-0.0025737151,
-0.0072082379,
0.0251746606,
-0.044706177,
-0.0177974142,
-0.0423582457,
-0.0357418619,
-0.0137914354,
-0.0225297529,
-0.0169881936,
-0.0427698977,
-0.0086008022,
-0.0358541161,
0.0127792228,
0.0189721528,
0.0220267717,
0.0805424526,
-0.0112008564,
-0.0969008207,
-0.0152743878,
-0.0031604823,
0.0387795083,
0.0042840508,
0.0340754315,
-0.0581078827,
-0.0227078386,
-0.0053112572,
0.0037245906,
-0.0467842072,
0.0388072394,
0.0125389807,
-0.0332662053,
0.0779515356,
-0.0148576777,
-0.0018056483,
0.0240578819,
0.0016999802,
0.0216625873,
0.0334772393,
0.035052076,
0.0395546146,
-0.0195645187,
0.0102026118,
0.0526814014,
0.0326135084,
-0.0113120945,
-0.0049447929,
-0.0176092237,
-0.0194731932,
-0.0323057137,
0.0387661718,
-0.0279881023,
-0.015125677,
-0.0020088414,
-0.031032607,
0.0149686756,
0.0369726084,
-0.0211918261,
0.0685312301,
0.0428147651,
-0.0247460883,
-0.0067890999,
-0.0339327604,
-0.0496470034,
0.0652934015,
-0.0223222617,
-0.0248634778,
-0.076132901,
0.017550936,
-0.0414919704,
-0.0090313219,
0.0502437279,
-0.0205450673,
-0.0193573013,
-0.018924376,
0.0720254183,
0.0501564108,
-0.057647597,
0.0586228929,
0.0247867387,
-0.0270519517,
-0.0284121837,
-0.0433568098,
0.0356554501,
0.0577291772,
0.0387325101,
-0.0022574107,
-0.0476344451,
0.0116081377,
0.0418912433,
0.0516948439,
-0.0192005597,
-0.0073201414,
0.0080343252,
-0.0119462442,
-0.015422686,
0.052952189,
0.0071078455,
0.0953646451,
0.0001207771,
-0.0347058289,
0.0130157247,
0.0115969628,
-0.026516242,
0.0692378357,
0.0024605002,
-0.0256154742,
-0.0175499171,
0.0295719467,
-0.0136474026,
-0.003112558,
-0.0189276878,
-0.0114674289,
0.0475892015,
-0.0157938637,
0.0271824263,
0.0177456979,
-0.0262423735,
0.0338434465,
0.0093543688,
-0.0192523897,
0.0041975426,
0.0235712528,
0.0042397128,
-0.0608732551,
-0.0059413793,
-0.0223342832,
0.0418860316,
0.0122178635,
0.0333580039,
-0.0294398945,
0.014982339,
-0.0335449502,
0.058578182,
-0.0113385068,
0.0254787561,
-0.0033375621,
0.0487468392,
-0.0180253517,
-0.0743396506,
-0.0108603491,
0.0141657768,
0.0055358154,
-0.0285593625,
-0.0142067038,
-0.0111199822,
-0.0299199857,
0.0152217187,
-0.0449531563,
-0.003664036,
0.0086171785,
-0.0349313021,
0.0236799121,
0.0079091843,
0.0059818975,
-0.0567403436,
0.0427746288,
0.0760678574,
-0.023346696,
-0.0123887854,
0.0097038671,
-0.0041378993,
-0.0872246772,
0.0103676049,
-0.0193098579,
0.0089154989,
0.0306180622,
0.0828431249,
-0.0483991019,
-0.0322045311,
0.0385322832,
-0.0153958537,
0.0319907367,
-0.0018563636,
-0.0336807258,
-0.000221846,
-0.0039609806,
-0.0174228959,
0.0929735675,
0.0035304646,
0.0221895892,
-0.0015036324,
-0.0255194679,
-0.016456902,
0.0002037207,
-0.017567331,
-0.0082887914,
0.0210487265,
-0.0125842467,
0.0163266901,
0.0883362517,
-0.0744404867,
0.0355450213,
-0.0760209188,
0.0428520255,
0.0168267377,
-0.0423644818,
-0.0243512448,
-0.0171412006,
-0.0149495304,
-0.0079871733,
-0.0519899167,
-0.0534187555,
0.0461524762,
-0.0141670192,
-0.0164416675,
0.0304367151,
0.0383327305,
0.0029318228,
0.0688443184,
0.0597184598,
0.0217395946,
0.0271717496,
-0.0452532396,
-0.0245417599,
0.0296156053,
0.0084267529,
-0.0119953174,
0.0406925753,
-0.0552662984,
0.0234340169,
-0.0285814721,
0.0094100647,
-0.0632912889,
0.0145843634,
-0.0594228171,
0.009178428,
-0.0408258289,
-0.0239312276,
-0.0716350749,
0.0674349815,
0.0278479755,
0.0244923253,
0.0368341245,
0.0013115258,
-0.0411712974,
0.0035603864,
0.0380326882,
-0.0027880943,
-0.0103104087,
-0.0040823156,
0.0274197683,
0.0053112824,
0.0437530354,
0.0024376747,
-0.0503160469,
0.0161668602,
-0.0116910124,
0.0014045447,
-0.0100242617,
0.0073855305,
-0.0193055551,
-0.0480885319,
-0.0379096381,
0.0687947869,
0.0194747578,
-0.0317170322,
-0.0249381624,
0.0172140989,
-0.02735563,
0.0333747603,
0.0073945443,
-0.0146760065,
-0.0395334028,
0.0130918752,
-0.0131215686,
0.0073276409,
-0.0663091913,
-0.02217515,
-0.0798126161,
-0.0083086547,
0.006678916,
-0.0735115856,
0.0009088262,
-0.0078193499,
0.0238582436,
-0.0177278295,
-0.0726915672,
0.0194506645,
0.0022659197,
-0.0172555409,
0.0263090506,
0.031450469,
0.0024121217,
-0.0089539643,
-0.038798634,
0.0085622212,
0.0515575744,
0.0162394792,
-0.0139350761,
-0.0381077714,
-0.0331501663,
0.0078835739,
0.0010651832,
-0.0203708243,
0.02292604,
-0.0235197693,
-0.0257385019,
-0.0068624481,
-0.0134380162,
0.0255692936,
-0.0344221517,
-0.0119445529,
0.0323855504,
0.0163590368,
0.0496576354,
-0.0390034579,
-0.0505570062,
0.0107439989,
0.0290337428,
-0.0007393672,
-0.0235275365,
0.0085547362,
0.0080532143,
-0.0006652668,
-0.02513141,
-0.0491983779,
-0.0082304003,
-0.0921953246,
-0.068386361,
-0.0444157049,
0.006276702,
0.0127829285,
0.0854950696,
0.0433266945,
-0.0432239138,
0.0433408171,
0.0497133993,
-0.0813044235,
0.0407123081,
-0.0101799471,
-0.0041057016,
-0.0939688534,
-0.0343712345,
0.0814178735,
-0.0545294285,
-0.02444846,
0.0359573141,
-0.0157555006,
-0.0375562906,
0.0386646912,
0.0613274463,
0.0208117533,
-0.006899687,
-0.0112772146,
-0.0584024042,
0.0189169329,
0.0141923595,
0.0220443886,
0.0189167541,
-0.0142033836,
-0.0634695143,
0.007824827,
0.0044829012,
-0.0440032296,
0.0724185556,
0.0311191622,
-0.0085426755,
-0.075825125,
0.021503672,
0.0167712756,
-0.0159415882,
0.0594059639,
-0.0184456464,
-0.0008881164,
-0.0168282855,
0.0431617349,
0.0374262035,
0.0200718995,
-0.0382982232,
0.0145658581,
0.0132979071,
0.0199651364,
0.0192277711,
0.0433409996,
-0.0050925054,
0.012755841,
0.0304700825,
-0.0294805709,
-0.0351468511,
0.0198899414,
0.0168091282,
0.0015892163,
0.0173616372,
0.0055103232,
0.0024771516,
0.0782755464,
0.0011082272,
0.0198586434,
0.030314479,
0.0023428737,
-0.0524845757,
0.0108527718,
-0.007717303,
-0.0308704022,
-0.0525157638,
0.0668051839,
0.0307340007,
-0.0177651476,
0.0272315703,
-0.017512938,
0.0032232217,
-0.0054990877,
0.0099033387,
-0.0246434286,
-0.0733809993,
0.0136950286,
0.0373580493,
0.0295561217,
-0.0354226008,
0.0372618921,
-0.0080104843,
0.0188386831,
-0.0078512626,
0.0108349184,
-0.0371666253,
0.034209799,
0.0136528006,
-0.0035142619,
0.0024260643,
0.0459789038,
-0.0232435931,
-0.020163646,
0.0245074034,
0.0023078243,
0.0401427262,
0.0048789312,
0.0779606029,
0.0228674933,
0.0045525138,
0.0002191746,
0.0016328113,
0.0154464087,
-0.0538433529,
-0.033685118,
-0.0062038363,
-5.52616939e-33,
-0.0876604319,
-0.0625190213,
0.0293398388,
-0.0066071255,
-0.0099742543,
0.0257852692,
-0.0171493273,
0.0330696255,
0.0062368652,
-0.019266976,
-0.0241029672,
-0.0032027478,
0.0186207294,
0.0216526072,
0.0018492604,
-0.018080214,
0.0443375744,
0.0245820004,
-0.0313406251,
0.0225399025,
0.0143505,
0.0408144258,
0.0577818714,
-0.047320094,
-0.0725727528,
0.012853724,
0.0300565418,
0.0163935907,
0.0322328545,
0.0609853715,
-0.0204996224,
-0.0347009301,
0.001946134,
-0.0244784057,
-0.0106621888,
0.0442984588,
-0.1258734614,
0.0056881635,
-0.0146261835,
0.0615676641,
-0.0184774697,
-0.0030145925,
0.0571720563,
-0.0008501931,
0.0076385061,
0.0251165275,
0.0411934629,
-0.0680498704,
-0.0477814004,
0.0233481377,
-0.0386499055,
0.0199913345,
0.0231231172,
-0.0471605174,
0.0567383915,
-0.0635263398,
0.0255533811,
-0.0275875777,
-0.0162065569,
0.0056553506,
0.0401137918,
0.0076099457,
0.0659571886,
0.0919127166,
0.0229432173,
0.0472958237,
0.0543250851,
-0.0357375778,
-0.0100109661,
-0.0114928391,
0.0001606909,
0.0485672429,
0.0439687781,
0.0288306158,
0.0443547964,
0.0032956728,
-0.0407374501,
-0.0025148117,
-0.0294639505,
0.0766960829,
0.015119846,
-0.0016588659,
-0.0189472064,
0.0480459407,
-0.0125547862,
0.0181353427,
-0.027941227,
-0.0195199698,
0.040204566,
0.0322731808,
-0.0676514432,
0.022682881,
0.0249649175,
0.0089194151,
-0.0175288077,
0.0031601724,
0.0710359961,
0.0436682515,
-0.0139106624,
-0.0159773249,
-0.0454092957,
-0.0391141623,
0.0337681361,
0.0057421555,
-0.0048834104,
0.0038946993,
0.0280069336,
0.0130476383,
-0.0370160937,
-0.009677873,
-0.024391206,
0.0066547338,
0.0237241387,
0.0241387654,
0.0357692055,
-0.0171090923,
-0.0178692769,
0.0208119228,
-0.0015041115,
-0.0630109683,
-0.0463932566,
0.001102122,
-0.0145593612,
0.0663798675,
-0.0468854196,
-0.0016690617,
-0.0388619602,
0.0067805909,
0.0631162971,
-0.0670583248,
-0.0051009031,
0.0454943404,
2.841e-7,
-0.0381712988,
0.0183229633,
0.0141633702,
0.013385443,
-0.0026437766,
0.014230229,
0.0218674559,
0.0770987868,
-0.0112140169,
-0.0315283611,
0.0026900533,
0.0065876152,
-0.0028973294,
-0.0325220861,
-0.0839702338,
-0.0206767712,
0.0010254332,
0.0477128476,
-0.0613891371,
-0.0067039272,
-0.0262697134,
0.0879499391,
0.0288192425,
-0.000060789,
0.0076948884,
-0.030585533,
0.038727697,
-0.0035694975,
0.0488110147,
-0.0131070698,
0.0071753683,
0.0648058131,
-0.0656314865,
0.0208869334,
-0.0012742846,
0.0294279717,
0.0277971942,
-0.0261509046,
-0.0798272565,
0.0337514989,
-0.0115186069,
-0.0310812574,
-0.0006919271,
0.0143723879,
0.0545032322,
-0.0546903871,
0.0047848979,
0.0107398182,
-0.0104087228,
0.0057981033,
-0.0467232056,
0.022350302,
-0.0400543623,
-0.0004050557,
0.0172008667,
-0.0274462365,
0.0030628231,
-0.0540000834,
0.0275895875,
0.0018523792,
-0.0211375374,
-0.0250543468,
-0.0509108827,
-0.0774761587,
-0.0148507021,
0.001877415,
-0.0373784117,
2.046142838e-34,
-0.0305026527,
0.0234935824,
-0.0219237544,
0.0442444161,
0.0012366973,
-0.0135371611,
0.0282525346,
0.0283582583,
0.0090063727,
-0.0224960744,
-0.011488854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01792v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01792v1 | AFPQ: Asymmetric Floating Point Quantization for LLMs | 2023-11-03T09:07:09 | 2023-11-03T09:07:09 | Yijia Zhang, Sicheng Zhang, Shijie Cao, Dayou Du, Jianyu Wei, Ting Cao, Ningyi Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) show great performance in various tasks, but
face deployment challenges from limited memory capacity and bandwidth. Low-bit
weight quantization can save memory and accelerate inference. Although
floating-point (FP) formats show good performance in LLM quantization, they
tend to perform poorly with small group sizes or sub-4 bits. We find the reason
is that the absence of asymmetry in previous FP quantization makes it
unsuitable for handling asymmetric value distribution of LLM weight tensors. In
this work, we propose asymmetric FP quantization (AFPQ), which sets separate
scales for positive and negative values. Our method leads to large accuracy
improvements and can be easily plugged into other quantization methods,
including GPTQ and AWQ, for better performance. Besides, no additional storage
is needed compared with asymmetric integer (INT) quantization. The code is
available at https://github.com/zhangsichengsjtu/AFPQ. | [
-0.0669289306,
0.0426218547,
-0.00435712,
0.0378160141,
-0.0268466827,
0.0079848114,
0.0151894474,
0.0311625134,
-0.0307248179,
-0.0430529602,
-0.0181808844,
-0.0741979033,
0.005889623,
0.0235292222,
0.01810381,
-0.0452609435,
0.0078486437,
-0.0467887372,
-0.0047262423,
-0.0349751711,
-0.0112480493,
0.0139688225,
0.0031289582,
-0.0167097524,
0.0183178484,
-0.001217162,
0.0064386735,
0.0037584701,
0.028294811,
-0.0170658119,
-0.0083557945,
0.0369387195,
0.0433560126,
0.0106663425,
0.0000021522,
-0.0057234922,
-0.0094756791,
0.0133319208,
-0.0114827529,
0.0391940363,
0.0511967093,
-0.0446219258,
-0.0467287488,
0.0129223904,
-0.0136684673,
0.0111936098,
0.0406157486,
0.0118108289,
0.0463665538,
0.0352773555,
-0.015378206,
-0.0589225218,
-0.006795398,
-0.0072550266,
-0.0136206197,
-0.034966331,
0.0012099179,
0.0280045643,
-0.0147110624,
0.010389572,
-0.0032147244,
-0.0042439713,
0.0124644432,
0.0194464698,
-0.0198835079,
0.0403621867,
-0.0570796579,
-0.0071214489,
-0.0196308736,
0.0607785471,
-0.0438412987,
-0.0436843373,
0.0094395252,
-0.0136225177,
-0.0355744474,
-0.078495577,
-0.0323041268,
0.0715608746,
0.0304537639,
0.0584229454,
0.0284842905,
-0.0119041046,
0.0324205458,
0.0134374406,
-0.0546545014,
0.0577673987,
0.0423944965,
0.0083505586,
-0.0522520356,
-0.0160386153,
-0.1119005382,
-0.0223564468,
0.0299640559,
-0.0006731012,
0.030536063,
-0.0443122573,
-0.0518508367,
-0.0518969223,
0.0184056945,
-0.0741081536,
0.0328814872,
0.070351541,
-0.0261836052,
0.0343472101,
-0.0300630331,
0.0526656695,
0.0143501088,
0.0078949714,
-0.0269005876,
0.0266774166,
0.0288552828,
0.0059424727,
-0.0462035425,
0.0070596864,
-0.0455430336,
0.0056666583,
-0.0461515598,
0.0125731733,
-0.0372792818,
-0.0358755141,
0.0469818786,
-0.000031601,
-0.0012290688,
-0.0036187833,
0.0268746931,
0.0356056131,
-0.01145491,
0.0047073024,
-0.0501924977,
-0.0280293245,
-0.0005056009,
0.0531635061,
-0.0097446693,
-0.0305411667,
0.0464984365,
0.03000273,
0.0309518799,
-0.0350032076,
0.0107233319,
0.0212193932,
-0.0031250964,
-0.0629962608,
-0.0056009372,
-0.0612302795,
-0.003850566,
0.0152987288,
-0.0107807182,
-0.0074831741,
0.0018003832,
-0.0041112066,
0.0085705798,
0.0541545264,
0.0044673486,
0.0100641875,
0.0086359568,
0.005494561,
0.0274216589,
0.0966674536,
0.0596359037,
0.001999333,
0.008973253,
0.0124230031,
-0.0381649546,
0.0316596739,
0.0221250486,
0.0120471753,
-0.0668132156,
-0.0424125232,
-0.0260085054,
0.0483852327,
0.0857022852,
0.1116520837,
-0.0710493177,
-0.057371866,
0.0134347081,
0.0357873775,
0.0213655252,
-0.0185960028,
-0.0175086074,
0.0103506707,
-0.020923648,
-0.023622185,
-0.04721798,
0.0422516726,
0.0334880948,
0.0060046264,
0.0638291687,
0.0679392293,
-0.0310847517,
-0.0062455921,
-0.0537606329,
-0.014197317,
0.0209141206,
-0.0214669369,
0.0461306833,
-0.01395234,
-0.0004072649,
0.0782081336,
0.0079434346,
-0.07315512,
-0.0098758303,
-0.0513024181,
0.0125412485,
0.0148091605,
0.0242286082,
-0.0214895848,
-0.0078452164,
0.0283410754,
-0.0493642651,
0.0153339393,
0.003254561,
0.0354993194,
0.0283768196,
-0.0786265507,
-0.0143164331,
0.0316561908,
0.0132968631,
-0.0266618356,
0.0142937768,
0.0298843794,
0.0013946556,
-0.0694390684,
-0.00444355,
0.0098157041,
0.0169845019,
-0.0284715369,
0.0463048071,
-0.0058187288,
0.027630901,
0.0374042764,
0.0020721601,
-0.0130304089,
0.063749373,
-0.0552755408,
0.0060414271,
-0.0296806358,
-0.0057671592,
-0.0092385039,
0.0946623236,
-0.0068343286,
0.028698137,
0.0153156938,
-0.0617010109,
-0.0381227657,
0.0764859095,
0.0216705557,
0.0201379992,
-0.0493701994,
0.01976116,
0.0166765712,
0.0393777229,
-0.0494244695,
-0.0093494374,
-0.0240853988,
0.0231865756,
-0.0205458552,
-0.0212850384,
0.0060831993,
-0.0278249793,
-0.0442683399,
0.0220981538,
0.041252546,
0.0336971432,
-0.0134301484,
0.0018348475,
0.0331837647,
0.0035692963,
-0.1267300695,
0.001671546,
-0.0377586633,
0.0391133726,
0.0420179255,
0.0303210001,
-0.0045211138,
-0.0031734796,
-0.0522410758,
-0.030568894,
0.0113260085,
-0.0023745652,
0.0211896822,
-0.0197529849,
0.0043048342,
-0.0046059391,
-0.0360270366,
-0.0096988827,
0.0169170555,
-0.0512461625,
-0.0138799129,
-0.0781274885,
0.0093910517,
-0.0471314043,
0.0544699319,
-0.008387303,
-0.0398437716,
0.0016211468,
-0.0366079584,
0.0475066416,
0.0350935608,
0.0102042938,
-0.0290874597,
0.0835948735,
0.0347072221,
-0.018418083,
0.0060959719,
-0.0033411586,
-0.0036347676,
0.0229630545,
-0.048202537,
-0.0467022434,
0.0623752214,
-0.0345754474,
-0.0212545414,
-0.0197608024,
-0.0047765984,
-0.0258515738,
0.0138263376,
-0.0280847438,
0.0246810913,
-0.0236759186,
0.0401720442,
0.0283064339,
-0.0601192862,
0.0220984053,
-0.0242404249,
-0.0249814801,
-0.0212267712,
-0.016755661,
-0.0645810813,
0.0643281713,
0.0144069325,
0.0376712307,
-0.0511182658,
0.0048562014,
-0.0372533388,
-0.0221249405,
0.0131237172,
-0.0483546741,
0.030749321,
-0.0384951271,
0.0299047288,
-0.0556204282,
-0.0072711995,
0.0205587987,
0.007203538,
-0.0091483016,
0.0339964665,
-0.036682386,
-0.0735392496,
0.0410574041,
0.0731211752,
-0.0300090704,
0.038552694,
-0.0458222926,
0.037945345,
-0.0044604419,
0.0207139552,
0.024202479,
0.0120660933,
0.034078408,
-0.010952103,
-0.0435479507,
0.0377953276,
0.025666412,
0.0593592301,
-0.0499972813,
-0.0208839644,
0.0594718866,
-0.0018630871,
-0.0279371683,
-0.0052791364,
0.0554063357,
-0.0099096978,
0.0271453019,
0.0898728594,
0.0220217369,
-0.043925263,
0.0116039049,
-0.000337947,
0.0568528101,
0.0105693107,
-0.0075213113,
-0.1305851638,
-0.004487962,
0.0163846463,
0.0175348204,
0.0241008047,
0.0018669992,
0.0105384868,
-0.071631901,
0.0088920295,
0.0509109944,
0.0228554867,
-0.059768457,
-0.0295327716,
-0.0176054966,
-0.0294807032,
0.0788093433,
0.0408926904,
-0.011569364,
0.0101897568,
0.0337062366,
0.0002891253,
-0.0334696472,
0.0168626867,
-0.0299028866,
0.0714140832,
0.0231574178,
0.0359619856,
-0.0328809395,
-0.0455988757,
0.012570736,
0.0017056296,
-0.0528409146,
-0.0113544092,
-0.0119009949,
0.0386966579,
-0.0016256234,
0.0048179729,
0.0165224373,
-0.028464051,
-0.0095704244,
-0.0441925302,
0.0508967154,
-0.0308618415,
-0.0621278696,
-0.0074959565,
-0.0206085294,
-0.0177387707,
0.066583313,
-0.0251682606,
0.0052327462,
-0.0617218129,
-0.0128793297,
0.0137290591,
0.0027265856,
-0.045370955,
-0.020087745,
-0.0007009801,
-0.0303737279,
-0.0377919376,
0.0590834618,
0.0093157981,
0.008338728,
-0.0329474024,
-0.0320716351,
-0.036125496,
-0.017401265,
-0.0890923291,
0.0073226816,
-0.0232145451,
0.0516100563,
-0.0442428254,
-0.0032865552,
0.024767451,
-0.0109961024,
-0.0201739967,
0.0110085336,
-0.1310711652,
-0.0648903996,
0.0090593938,
0.006777836,
0.0177814793,
0.0040872707,
0.0033659292,
-0.0505390242,
0.0450668447,
0.0764626861,
-0.0475304462,
0.0835322216,
0.0076157101,
-0.0002621242,
-0.0034723058,
0.0246811938,
-0.0054467493,
0.0244144816,
-0.0356736109,
0.049003128,
-0.0688089803,
-0.0470922105,
-0.0344532132,
0.0243661609,
0.0468579009,
-0.0116478978,
0.013174694,
0.003238983,
0.0108836424,
-0.008546642,
0.0293464698,
-0.0402870066,
0.0316394605,
0.0096116764,
0.0004280817,
-0.0376511328,
-0.0234417245,
0.0133977225,
-0.0216058455,
0.0387510881,
0.0366140679,
-0.0366837494,
0.0103486544,
0.0464172103,
-0.0200827997,
-0.0019713533,
0.003577766,
-0.0128939096,
0.0526657291,
-0.030016033,
0.02270527,
-0.0037809808,
0.0133790523,
-0.0190103706,
0.0522676371,
-0.0164708402,
-0.0548958145,
-0.0297475178,
-0.0062646787,
0.04357462,
0.0631498024,
0.0389348604,
-0.0225579329,
-0.0105080158,
-0.0295051895,
0.0324788168,
-0.0051242504,
0.0149525898,
0.0595158525,
0.0026385093,
-0.0330783725,
0.0251812041,
0.0351566821,
0.0061661713,
0.0119165117,
0.0017271083,
0.0269462261,
0.0079285642,
-0.0524905398,
-0.0768131539,
0.0142923407,
-0.0136239827,
0.0038744134,
-0.0270810071,
-0.0524992235,
-0.0019743082,
0.0400714949,
-0.0125619443,
-0.052364327,
0.0175687,
0.0230463315,
-0.0264506247,
-0.0340048298,
-0.0283608623,
-0.01064933,
0.0123327421,
-0.0204942171,
-0.0367459729,
-6.375511813e-33,
-0.0188431796,
0.0348167717,
0.0193430893,
-0.0218361337,
-0.020700762,
0.0120979333,
0.0204758979,
-0.0172914099,
0.0123434374,
-0.0242129844,
0.0164032411,
0.0282655116,
0.0141719142,
-0.012990335,
-0.0096247997,
0.0128405029,
0.0625393167,
-0.0102073299,
-0.0021227845,
0.042466566,
0.0025320237,
-0.0061516352,
0.0803333744,
-0.0232018158,
-0.0252766758,
0.014335514,
0.0075126574,
0.0259384438,
0.0252650362,
0.0214535818,
-0.0214686207,
0.0017477005,
0.0047910577,
0.027669102,
-0.0155727947,
-0.0657382607,
-0.0359954238,
-0.0179294758,
0.023838453,
0.0377826616,
0.0043400866,
-0.0239528716,
0.0331545807,
0.0144533534,
-0.0548680909,
-0.0265720487,
-0.0245320797,
0.0188431162,
-0.0262480211,
-0.0469003208,
0.0217780024,
0.0596820936,
0.0551727675,
0.0531360768,
0.0673520342,
-0.0339625143,
-0.0351623259,
-0.0167962816,
-0.0673593581,
0.0074266782,
0.0177902188,
0.0815134048,
0.0299492218,
0.0337646268,
0.032554362,
0.0279205758,
0.0325682126,
-0.0201774612,
-0.0393031314,
0.028777102,
0.054388307,
-0.0171818342,
0.0359678864,
0.0340203606,
0.119273603,
-0.0033192239,
-0.0448367,
0.0016176943,
0.0127500473,
0.0103564234,
0.0283041988,
0.0566472411,
-0.0044507608,
-0.0377458036,
-0.0226231851,
-0.045492325,
-0.0344531573,
-0.0281767435,
-0.0233678594,
-0.0024197455,
-0.0493051782,
-0.0047022817,
0.0214957297,
-0.0342156775,
-0.0301118717,
0.008347597,
-0.0051935245,
0.0279464815,
0.0313133746,
0.0196331274,
-0.0229550842,
-0.0214331187,
0.0142050274,
-0.0081710396,
0.0092854034,
0.0003127064,
0.0092073195,
0.0682295412,
-0.071546644,
-0.0169215966,
-0.023734469,
0.002716315,
0.0031961179,
0.0579168834,
0.0081374943,
0.0115176151,
0.0207714476,
0.0394671746,
-0.0045371968,
0.0208343435,
-0.0370754637,
0.0157009736,
0.0165778287,
0.057826899,
-0.0562338717,
0.0018029852,
-0.0223770477,
0.0326365456,
0.0692307502,
-0.0771689489,
-0.0530182496,
0.0005813712,
2.877e-7,
0.0487541892,
0.0097670741,
0.0248799883,
0.029219659,
-0.005535814,
0.0090287859,
0.010524312,
0.0272740964,
0.0285247322,
-0.0029984149,
-0.0082482379,
0.0556815043,
-0.0206267014,
0.0274200011,
-0.0495895259,
0.0295299664,
-0.0334168151,
-0.0158265065,
-0.0109360721,
-0.0292006042,
0.0058530122,
0.1046430022,
0.0226217099,
-0.0143499142,
0.0444258489,
-0.0110903792,
0.0309898034,
-0.0250542909,
0.0393055864,
-0.0015891358,
0.0012367736,
-0.0297014751,
0.0140979644,
-0.0200606734,
0.0270400811,
-0.0101546627,
-0.047368478,
0.0813713223,
-0.0360649601,
-0.0040306421,
-0.0222523436,
-0.0279749911,
-0.0310264025,
-0.0483086929,
0.0724939331,
0.0206889361,
0.0006879011,
-0.1388241053,
-0.0309468098,
-0.0153702637,
0.0176155642,
0.0105768917,
0.0107748322,
0.0817822441,
0.0330599621,
-0.015719654,
0.0106199281,
-0.0849673674,
-0.0569856986,
0.0107899373,
-0.0167455487,
-0.0237734951,
-0.019191632,
0.0340136215,
-0.0038349109,
-0.0328110605,
-0.0021916737,
2.810372812e-34,
0.0545429625,
-0.0059373942,
0.004969642,
0.052868478,
-0.0105706584,
-0.027410049,
-0.0163361449,
0.015583789,
-0.0298410691,
-0.0272627752,
-0.0187577903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04923v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04923v3 | Is one brick enough to break the wall of spoken dialogue state tracking? | 2023-11-03T08:59:51 | 2024-07-01T07:15:33 | Lucas Druart, Valentin Vielzeuf, Yannick Estève | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS, eess.SP | In Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems, correctly updating the system's
understanding of the user's requests (\textit{a.k.a} dialogue state tracking)
is key to a smooth interaction. Traditionally, TOD systems perform this update
in three steps: transcription of the user's utterance, semantic extraction of
the key concepts, and contextualization with the previously identified
concepts. Such cascade approaches suffer from cascading errors and separate
optimization. End-to-End approaches have been proven helpful up to the
turn-level semantic extraction step. This paper goes one step further and
provides (1) a novel approach for completely neural spoken DST, (2) an in depth
comparison with a state of the art cascade approach and (3) avenues towards
better context propagation. Our study highlights that jointly-optimized
approaches are also competitive for contextually dependent tasks, such as
Dialogue State Tracking (DST), especially in audio native settings. Context
propagation in DST systems could benefit from training procedures accounting
for the previous' context inherent uncertainty. | [
0.0020120589,
0.0382756069,
0.0066764881,
0.0488034971,
-0.0144068291,
-0.0166124217,
-0.0200662706,
-0.0190388672,
-0.0156378541,
-0.0339585319,
-0.0503832586,
-0.0588458702,
0.0226183049,
0.0568611771,
-0.0017073101,
-0.0702969134,
0.0681781694,
-0.0238751881,
-0.0392999835,
0.0192271136,
0.0084075881,
-0.0064827586,
-0.0673080608,
0.0302586686,
-0.0278542433,
-0.0155567555,
-0.0560349636,
0.0140357763,
0.0136946356,
-0.011317295,
0.0031834943,
-0.0038406868,
0.0475940704,
0.0328148939,
0.0000017537,
-0.0138716185,
-0.0007454565,
-0.0196064413,
-0.0513130501,
-0.0454466306,
-0.0456802472,
0.0072155907,
-0.0347434729,
0.0270654391,
-0.011049212,
-0.009250788,
0.0198718403,
0.0460909121,
0.0676975548,
0.0606084466,
-0.0091873892,
-0.0169151351,
0.0469127148,
-0.029669337,
0.0096451892,
-0.0959813371,
-0.0005319837,
-0.0005247541,
-0.0026852605,
0.0098138331,
0.0048078233,
0.0310532749,
0.0200489331,
-0.0298579726,
-0.0336624384,
-0.0024571584,
0.0105702784,
-0.0162766725,
-0.0421242826,
0.0968056545,
0.0589314327,
0.0594572835,
0.020778412,
0.0123969112,
-0.0269331485,
-0.0870136768,
-0.0339543037,
-0.0297750495,
-0.0420242697,
0.0058745644,
-0.0184184983,
0.0262141433,
0.0008619071,
-0.0088701639,
-0.0202769283,
0.0469061583,
-0.0261192173,
-0.0391999148,
-0.0219057705,
-0.0007916846,
0.038278874,
-0.0724431276,
0.0617553592,
0.0137189552,
-0.056206882,
0.0347614735,
-0.0332848951,
0.0046953745,
-0.0447198451,
-0.0320703499,
-0.0332240053,
0.0574594811,
-0.0695028454,
0.0465476736,
0.0413810648,
0.0581333786,
-0.0250098966,
-0.0344098471,
-0.0082228882,
-0.0031508377,
-0.044992283,
0.0235887673,
-0.0565427691,
0.0197149105,
-0.0605349205,
-0.0208232999,
-0.0257209372,
0.0423539244,
-0.0048898282,
0.016118072,
0.0074448353,
0.0142778875,
-0.0585719794,
0.0113209132,
0.011465067,
0.0455612577,
0.0003901985,
0.0327640697,
0.0338045694,
-0.0099191302,
-0.0431827046,
0.015784055,
0.0671136603,
0.0007190615,
-0.0382210091,
0.0590728335,
-0.0060656215,
-0.0302950237,
-0.0229945276,
0.0041153822,
-0.0350004137,
-0.0448716655,
-0.0301872827,
0.0035189136,
0.0429916382,
-0.0380548239,
0.006443948,
-0.0214947797,
-0.0108273989,
-0.0043708859,
0.0140304826,
0.0461049154,
-0.0322004035,
-0.0063288533,
0.0149931936,
0.030134242,
-0.0242841989,
0.0351057835,
0.0589240864,
0.0400285348,
0.0198303703,
-0.0077115544,
-0.0104152886,
0.0408003367,
0.0059151119,
0.0165843107,
-0.0167036336,
0.0157530811,
-0.0126045533,
0.0216540508,
0.028357625,
0.0469593555,
-0.0536982715,
0.0223625936,
0.0793553591,
0.0285318457,
0.0154976817,
-0.0135258613,
0.0566281863,
0.0261306036,
0.0042257821,
0.0147176273,
-0.0292458069,
-0.0042347498,
0.0066990396,
-0.0020416763,
0.045804482,
-0.0154529335,
-0.0357328877,
-0.0265002437,
0.0113945529,
-0.0050166803,
-0.0078712376,
0.0139151355,
0.0517962202,
-0.0022384971,
-0.0591508932,
0.0082350336,
-0.0046623084,
-0.0521335825,
0.0110959085,
-0.0168346874,
0.0051345634,
0.0557054803,
0.0243974365,
-0.0403675884,
-0.0760223791,
-0.042107597,
-0.0018021062,
0.0505964905,
-0.0010855404,
-0.041221112,
0.1084420159,
-0.0555300973,
-0.0139400316,
0.0176450815,
0.0059488104,
0.0342083499,
-0.0093188407,
-0.0060049286,
0.016664261,
0.0222721752,
0.0846755058,
-0.0106675569,
0.0094219251,
-0.0177251082,
0.004004186,
0.0055142147,
0.0790949315,
0.0506706908,
-0.017443547,
-0.0378492586,
0.0140545508,
-0.0107749309,
0.0052976799,
0.0419356003,
-0.0864975899,
-0.0685920045,
0.0160592459,
0.0568275936,
-0.0103352806,
0.0176320411,
-0.0193966012,
-0.087487638,
0.0278590173,
-0.0343423709,
0.0169322435,
-0.0360651202,
0.0194264352,
0.0632828251,
-0.0082266396,
0.0022608305,
0.0241959896,
0.0017403883,
-0.0335039385,
0.0436023697,
0.0157352965,
0.0213521142,
-0.0415334217,
0.0242512301,
0.0315607823,
-0.0205568187,
0.004260743,
-0.0177599005,
0.0042456831,
-0.035582453,
-0.0004409668,
-0.0586587228,
0.0203560125,
-0.0473548062,
0.0262510609,
0.0183638036,
0.045496121,
-0.0108493716,
-0.0476928093,
-0.0116503257,
0.0060977302,
0.0236753803,
-0.0427393429,
-0.0160300508,
0.0460576378,
-0.0352755971,
-0.0662576705,
0.045267079,
0.0039671496,
-0.026308272,
-0.0510306619,
-0.0598253533,
-0.0794243515,
0.0654172897,
-0.0235208701,
0.0808312818,
-0.0421312414,
-0.0101799406,
0.0202077087,
0.0002604761,
0.0219308585,
0.0294766482,
-0.008717238,
0.0420854501,
-0.0274466313,
-0.0816146731,
-0.0578963272,
0.0654936433,
0.0205113497,
0.0277755074,
-0.0388199985,
0.0314131193,
0.0107046934,
0.0469789915,
0.0313857868,
0.0393475853,
-0.069235757,
-0.0535516962,
-0.0243856236,
-0.0357594751,
-0.0238519907,
-0.0226636752,
-0.0690192431,
0.0355859362,
-0.0053453431,
-0.0264157411,
0.0481816009,
-0.0538273752,
-0.044394359,
-0.0582938604,
-0.0535683259,
-0.017435709,
0.0473392718,
-0.0296074916,
-0.0054765297,
0.0252271779,
-0.0690297708,
-0.0198878217,
-0.0131118894,
0.0069487025,
-0.0317539945,
0.0600213222,
-0.0423903205,
0.0140387788,
-0.0338375978,
-0.049000401,
-0.0544804856,
0.0021143609,
-0.0199202541,
0.0215185266,
0.0249113571,
-0.038154915,
0.0339946523,
0.0216199607,
0.0277817808,
0.0934762582,
-0.0008187278,
0.0067056399,
-0.0313741639,
0.0497628562,
0.0354524553,
-0.005849103,
-0.0323349722,
-0.002741677,
0.0758796558,
0.0197862387,
0.1040130854,
-0.0134895938,
-0.0290456954,
-0.0112077501,
0.0335591696,
-0.0174953025,
-0.0424110852,
0.0172124524,
0.0719727948,
-0.03695824,
-0.0266081467,
0.0911569521,
0.0062268153,
-0.0549205504,
-0.0401556827,
0.0085700657,
-0.0172078926,
0.0028356893,
-0.001185126,
-0.0884582698,
-0.0352890939,
0.0365192182,
0.0434201993,
0.0300491378,
-0.01457443,
-0.0405043066,
-0.0312822051,
0.0174062364,
-0.0155158434,
-0.0756336078,
-0.0129244579,
-0.0026151272,
0.0471165851,
0.0075098206,
0.0587827526,
0.0029271382,
0.0215883348,
-0.0317183845,
0.0268580858,
0.0041866419,
-0.0100688478,
0.0295788161,
-0.0051451041,
0.0613438673,
0.073009409,
0.0500359461,
0.0172443129,
0.0188427325,
0.0448000841,
-0.018716434,
0.0069031417,
0.0106080938,
0.0043744985,
-0.0343171544,
-0.0154048353,
-0.0078259343,
0.0185989216,
-0.0137738055,
0.0055240323,
0.031561356,
0.0213047005,
-0.061857868,
0.0476138555,
0.0206958316,
0.0266375896,
0.0380452983,
0.0302058775,
0.0273132995,
-0.0491693206,
0.00935941,
0.0088868504,
0.0018816334,
-0.0399900675,
0.0510447286,
-0.0225326065,
-0.0163317714,
0.0164637975,
-0.0616656318,
-0.0361476988,
0.0102005107,
0.0650999323,
-0.0075734928,
-0.0020759117,
0.0059640831,
0.0119243013,
0.0146998018,
0.0044733402,
-0.0035522361,
0.0096743917,
-0.0449289978,
-0.0053112456,
0.0634550899,
-0.0217325743,
0.0102984309,
0.0382015742,
-0.0568354093,
-0.0593621917,
-0.0039481982,
0.0249737985,
0.020400146,
0.054314401,
-0.0276647042,
0.0012550475,
-0.0260738116,
-0.0100546964,
-0.0167725794,
-0.0053301412,
0.0509574078,
0.0583964251,
-0.0461594127,
0.0351121724,
-0.0586108342,
0.0328258462,
-0.0327651165,
0.0391308665,
-0.0627350882,
-0.0693274289,
0.0007353541,
-0.0335403942,
0.0840842426,
0.0192102659,
0.0092926249,
-0.029129792,
0.0474593155,
-0.0185482912,
0.0079823667,
-0.0728474706,
0.0132298954,
-0.0264342241,
0.0060882946,
-0.0266376212,
0.0102125732,
-0.0079055689,
0.0030115191,
-0.0365672782,
-0.0165883731,
0.0135312174,
-0.0137163335,
0.0072577726,
-0.0110638859,
-0.007419073,
0.0226540994,
0.0558547191,
0.0358687304,
-0.001547492,
0.104098849,
0.0135425674,
-0.0359112471,
0.0273085199,
0.0459774882,
-0.073873207,
-0.0244967118,
0.008118921,
0.0155022098,
0.0592478998,
0.0312443506,
0.0232330207,
0.0175150055,
0.0316857249,
-0.0040807468,
0.0805132166,
-0.0113424771,
-0.0018169393,
0.0086375186,
0.0175681151,
0.0190343335,
0.0337639041,
0.0254480019,
-0.0217895713,
0.0380775444,
-0.0080917729,
0.0294536352,
-0.0435147621,
-0.0161086451,
-0.027204819,
0.0603215955,
-0.0263292119,
-0.0001535818,
-0.0085592279,
-0.0488333441,
0.0124184918,
-0.002799103,
0.0161290299,
-0.0162948109,
0.0374339595,
-0.0054522981,
-0.0274195746,
-0.0208306946,
-0.0055868309,
-0.0621583909,
-0.0226979982,
-0.0078142388,
0.0099545075,
-5.470544997e-33,
-0.054069858,
0.0108942939,
0.0344646461,
0.0209458917,
-0.0732860565,
-0.0055218809,
-0.0602206253,
-0.0060073631,
0.0057800552,
-0.0177329872,
-0.0270885527,
0.0408492088,
0.0256713796,
0.0179671962,
-0.0446688347,
-0.0325570442,
0.0607338287,
-0.0113939168,
-0.0015474127,
0.0116541926,
0.0578260198,
0.0311860852,
0.0606787354,
-0.0843482539,
0.0370541066,
0.0318002254,
0.0193617437,
0.0323935375,
0.015536461,
0.0036759553,
0.0098000485,
0.0042489343,
-0.0092814751,
-0.0498071611,
-0.0209651031,
0.0059714084,
-0.056676615,
-0.0252595954,
0.0071026701,
0.0299776997,
-0.040121451,
0.030827973,
0.0053050793,
0.0056836586,
0.024907371,
0.0202547479,
-0.0113106007,
0.0204540044,
-0.0266422909,
-0.023735011,
-0.029456906,
0.0403215028,
-0.0118281133,
-0.0679916218,
0.0079770386,
0.0668022335,
0.0282751489,
-0.0715638176,
-0.0354614966,
-0.0173398983,
-0.0443601869,
-0.0299228299,
0.0318542868,
0.0469597913,
-0.0035151537,
0.0583862253,
0.0689189807,
-0.0118507072,
-0.0314422026,
-0.0744876936,
-0.0211757664,
0.0165939685,
0.0120065641,
-0.0024955552,
-0.0367860608,
0.013455268,
-0.0558642298,
0.0089865066,
0.0415163189,
0.0280294251,
-0.040713232,
0.0504635051,
-0.0433059186,
0.0150020691,
-0.0146690197,
-0.004594842,
0.0115498314,
-0.015168638,
0.0326565355,
0.0277337637,
0.0210140627,
-0.0005161476,
0.0730362162,
0.0078056678,
0.0436655283,
0.000890219,
-0.0207452625,
0.0013517552,
-0.025599936,
0.0248587709,
-0.0526397787,
-0.0266224407,
0.0292677935,
0.0520514511,
0.0217486937,
-0.0095911017,
-0.0221904796,
0.0181428436,
-0.0210515223,
0.0096613578,
-0.0264203437,
0.0827894509,
-0.0487585478,
0.0491959192,
0.0592455938,
-0.0248552021,
-0.0185796693,
0.0901953429,
0.0239801109,
-0.0064405287,
-0.0186606515,
-0.0112068336,
0.016166715,
0.000816906,
-0.0268777534,
-0.0204895642,
0.0162434429,
-0.0152938636,
0.0022350035,
-0.023981303,
-0.0014932455,
0.0011516991,
2.553e-7,
-0.0284447186,
-0.0096090501,
0.0596847981,
-0.0068885977,
0.0431282148,
0.0412680134,
-0.0330276117,
0.0026198551,
0.0023433967,
0.0039375527,
0.0251584128,
-0.0159619004,
0.0602171682,
0.0208972394,
-0.1313022077,
-0.0771173686,
-0.034731552,
0.0021335469,
-0.0020473055,
0.0184590742,
0.0215643216,
0.0255488101,
-0.004627327,
0.005636977,
0.0310374368,
-0.001787356,
0.02401096,
-0.0007938241,
0.0285241697,
-0.0020343363,
0.0045736865,
-0.0152171459,
-0.0332422256,
-0.0022878076,
-0.0147646796,
0.0602271967,
-0.0024227682,
0.0861584321,
-0.0212213472,
-0.0528757498,
-0.0405355357,
0.0342491269,
0.0179071985,
-0.0171153583,
0.0324740075,
-0.0178304594,
-0.020200735,
-0.0394168906,
-0.0167909656,
-0.0069006919,
-0.0177937206,
0.0452043638,
0.0121646971,
0.0014335545,
-0.0218084697,
0.0017706405,
-0.0326092914,
-0.1127920896,
0.0263355002,
0.0063799224,
-0.0629818216,
-0.0298446827,
-0.0237019956,
0.009754857,
-0.0102379285,
-0.0086834822,
-0.0191478897,
1.686489551e-34,
0.0090367356,
-0.0297656115,
0.0260862187,
0.0296776816,
-0.0020415769,
-0.0096270991,
-0.015467966,
0.0024081639,
0.059461955,
-0.0244449787,
-0.019454537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01786v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01786v1 | TCM-GPT: Efficient Pre-training of Large Language Models for Domain Adaptation in Traditional Chinese Medicine | 2023-11-03T08:54:50 | 2023-11-03T08:54:50 | Guoxing Yang, Jianyu Shi, Zan Wang, Xiaohong Liu, Guangyu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-training and fine-tuning have emerged as a promising paradigm across
various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. The effectiveness of
pretrained large language models (LLM) has witnessed further enhancement,
holding potential for applications in the field of medicine, particularly in
the context of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). However, the application of
these general models to specific domains often yields suboptimal results,
primarily due to challenges like lack of domain knowledge, unique objectives,
and computational efficiency. Furthermore, their effectiveness in specialized
domains, such as Traditional Chinese Medicine, requires comprehensive
evaluation. To address the above issues, we propose a novel domain specific
TCMDA (TCM Domain Adaptation) approach, efficient pre-training with
domain-specific corpus. Specifically, we first construct a large TCM-specific
corpus, TCM-Corpus-1B, by identifying domain keywords and retreving from
general corpus. Then, our TCMDA leverages the LoRA which freezes the pretrained
model's weights and uses rank decomposition matrices to efficiently train
specific dense layers for pre-training and fine-tuning, efficiently aligning
the model with TCM-related tasks, namely TCM-GPT-7B. We further conducted
extensive experiments on two TCM tasks, including TCM examination and TCM
diagnosis. TCM-GPT-7B archived the best performance across both datasets,
outperforming other models by relative increments of 17% and 12% in accuracy,
respectively. To the best of our knowledge, our study represents the pioneering
validation of domain adaptation of a large language model with 7 billion
parameters in TCM domain. We will release both TCMCorpus-1B and TCM-GPT-7B
model once accepted to facilitate interdisciplinary development in TCM and NLP,
serving as the foundation for further study. | [
0.0573388673,
0.0444225222,
-0.0036320258,
0.0021415697,
0.0272357836,
0.0386651345,
0.0017833262,
0.0469481796,
0.005502196,
-0.0481311306,
-0.0871096626,
-0.0608876832,
-0.0109467441,
0.0122899478,
-0.0104670161,
-0.0413811505,
0.0409669541,
0.0152708543,
-0.0059101181,
0.0143446336,
-0.0208888277,
0.0061934739,
-0.0121526439,
0.0207978282,
0.0460654013,
-0.049550198,
0.0308571104,
-0.0275515914,
0.0409617797,
-0.069041416,
-0.0121079059,
0.0526529625,
0.00980407,
0.0009366642,
0.0000021441,
-0.0516199321,
-0.0431873314,
0.0052992743,
-0.0206167959,
0.0102939252,
0.04797405,
-0.0268629584,
-0.0021338048,
0.0186959971,
-0.0631373152,
-0.0534507558,
0.0303586628,
0.0773117915,
0.0279475395,
0.1065337583,
-0.014635236,
-0.0318372026,
0.0173590258,
-0.0476237424,
-0.0405098051,
-0.0912791938,
0.0587018169,
0.0020043501,
-0.0172009226,
-0.0013043783,
-0.0358213075,
0.0118484534,
-0.050670255,
0.0328161493,
-0.0083187129,
0.0275329668,
-0.0195469353,
-0.0155193834,
0.0003803762,
0.055920478,
-0.0358136483,
-0.0063390695,
0.0182143245,
0.0126187336,
-0.0244629178,
-0.0166962054,
-0.033885859,
-0.0254343711,
0.0091915904,
0.0352326296,
0.013919468,
-0.0188065264,
0.0313122533,
0.0276279468,
-0.0403896347,
-0.0215304364,
0.0224118903,
-0.0053808251,
0.0177227706,
0.0023646306,
-0.0352375396,
-0.0080617089,
0.0276966244,
0.0295959767,
-0.0455135107,
0.0092139049,
-0.0191941857,
-0.0227167644,
0.0441952497,
-0.0558021627,
0.0396808833,
0.0114274966,
-0.0379559137,
0.0383761376,
-0.0294024274,
0.0053395247,
-0.0378553271,
0.0162882097,
-0.042330496,
0.005448618,
-0.0550113395,
-0.008107936,
-0.0134443687,
0.0029238705,
-0.020961266,
-0.0062291753,
-0.0978062302,
-0.0032341701,
0.0068451627,
-0.0641808733,
0.036676541,
0.0276006535,
-0.0134859644,
-0.0255046356,
-0.0038502223,
0.0618911721,
0.0227930862,
0.0603953563,
-0.0592162274,
-0.031542331,
-0.0128903892,
0.0192350596,
0.0025275415,
-0.0205004662,
0.0522197559,
0.0412641652,
-0.0071013886,
-0.0539705753,
-0.0281543192,
0.0294648986,
-0.0282713342,
-0.0380025655,
0.0319681093,
-0.0324579291,
0.0146378977,
-0.0117307836,
0.0785321966,
-0.0618207119,
-0.0013057558,
0.002743081,
-0.0576773323,
0.061820671,
-0.0038327442,
0.0034886904,
0.0316879451,
0.0250961203,
0.0186554138,
0.0186330825,
0.0315067172,
-0.0312804431,
0.0010691509,
-0.0374316126,
-0.0008298438,
-0.0031695566,
-0.0086969594,
-0.0141179301,
0.0064386134,
0.0259502884,
0.0179923438,
0.0407992676,
-0.0123260673,
0.0203018785,
0.0073387213,
0.0019060666,
0.0232892632,
0.0553059541,
0.0353476368,
0.0114772515,
0.0102088833,
-0.0501337349,
0.0061580418,
-0.0202939641,
-0.0253375657,
-0.010395675,
-0.0309036616,
-0.010519959,
0.0020122835,
0.0138214054,
-0.0295884088,
-0.0237250328,
-0.0150747243,
0.0107665816,
-0.0238436665,
-0.0239942912,
0.0507250875,
0.0078983428,
-0.0136928381,
0.0376878269,
0.0603876635,
-0.01277899,
-0.0139980279,
-0.0498027429,
-0.0435145646,
0.0269802585,
0.0282509308,
-0.0526235662,
-0.0111464756,
0.0252021346,
0.0269507375,
0.018729208,
0.0104972925,
-0.005256067,
0.0146462061,
-0.0624015443,
0.0068439404,
0.0305811819,
0.0303074066,
-0.0115399193,
0.0175800212,
0.0708337426,
0.009861636,
-0.0318023488,
-0.0060709212,
0.0543153137,
-0.0697719976,
-0.0619903691,
0.0399564877,
-0.0146540999,
0.0410405099,
0.0182308741,
-0.0264348891,
0.0033842158,
0.0180321671,
-0.0520616025,
-0.0341819078,
0.0017801822,
-0.0271792244,
-0.024004234,
0.0412229039,
-0.0052769938,
-0.0049541364,
0.01969992,
-0.0659985393,
-0.0425055102,
0.0078111761,
0.0184220299,
0.0024170456,
-0.0229796171,
0.0442552455,
0.0100177033,
0.0380217619,
-0.0330705754,
0.0306565203,
0.0385141559,
-0.0255252924,
0.0118392315,
-0.0442875065,
0.0048443205,
0.0025172788,
-0.0368754938,
0.0069373576,
0.0039490405,
0.0371789373,
-0.0204380862,
0.0332543328,
-0.0036144035,
-0.0022697998,
-0.1030684635,
0.0216865297,
-0.0158434864,
0.011907571,
0.0147051029,
0.022581758,
-0.0131714875,
-0.0348882675,
-0.0469382815,
0.0022798427,
-0.0064707538,
0.0123346979,
0.0075724078,
-0.0015895491,
0.0317351706,
-0.0421035402,
0.009452574,
-0.0138023375,
0.0282914527,
-0.0184907652,
-0.0414362401,
0.0129543729,
0.0163594093,
0.005705677,
0.0262616314,
0.009718311,
-0.0124031901,
-0.0333965421,
0.006564368,
-0.0075482544,
0.0230664909,
0.0086141331,
-0.0090729566,
0.0700197816,
0.0416355096,
0.0030559488,
0.0011461223,
-0.033365801,
-0.0538560487,
-0.0247914158,
-0.0269080829,
0.0040132892,
0.0944645181,
0.0078608412,
-0.0139481798,
-0.036595244,
-0.0357652754,
-0.0342613012,
0.0300985426,
-0.0209994372,
0.0403017066,
-0.0389976129,
0.005737179,
0.0071270815,
-0.0192537643,
0.0815940276,
0.0008876484,
0.0192731321,
-0.1023946777,
-0.018292604,
-0.052456446,
0.0101983389,
-0.0144879976,
0.010792383,
0.0252510402,
-0.0117599061,
-0.0193323288,
0.0510497466,
0.0028810161,
-0.0640215874,
0.0247205347,
-0.000317055,
0.0204397403,
-0.0224253256,
-0.0232441798,
-0.032443244,
-0.0168357939,
-0.0250251256,
0.0033061956,
0.0006305202,
0.0437371135,
-0.03092115,
0.0461247601,
-0.0343869925,
0.0730804652,
0.0238159653,
0.0061370404,
-0.0085493457,
0.0248427913,
0.0420686305,
0.0313628353,
-0.0060408358,
0.0141688017,
0.0635421574,
0.0646137223,
-0.0044598826,
-0.0039515393,
0.0171811879,
0.0210032761,
0.0173461437,
-0.0289818812,
0.0118900333,
0.0163790304,
-0.0157081448,
-0.0406238139,
0.0069170105,
0.1142336875,
0.0358204804,
-0.053918656,
0.0158776902,
-0.0001702929,
-0.0607056022,
0.0071095116,
0.013212679,
-0.0900584683,
-0.0352228507,
-0.0226713419,
0.0081256935,
0.0099399444,
-0.0132294213,
0.0249192324,
-0.0729698688,
0.0004262126,
0.0097897127,
-0.0212178025,
-0.0144270966,
-0.0671354234,
0.0015501854,
-0.020034289,
0.0283645391,
-0.0215764362,
-0.0335612111,
-0.0269148163,
0.0210928936,
-0.0380247794,
-0.0959607735,
0.0502925664,
-0.0242548697,
0.0238058772,
0.0651006177,
0.0157089476,
0.0049368455,
0.0095757712,
0.0367717519,
-0.0056105275,
0.0057197758,
-0.0107808253,
0.0619890988,
0.0173584055,
-0.010246167,
0.0158182774,
0.0173693188,
-0.0832252204,
-0.0271780919,
0.0087668756,
0.0581413768,
-0.0082783531,
-0.0409031436,
-0.0170026068,
0.0300508831,
-0.0140868118,
0.0459657721,
-0.0201317184,
-0.0203926973,
-0.0053995894,
0.0327657983,
-0.0006237322,
0.0078767287,
-0.0632686019,
0.0539452098,
-0.0751406327,
0.0019546081,
-0.0804869384,
0.0105506033,
0.0310015436,
-0.0065975692,
0.0237177629,
0.0355309956,
0.003516281,
0.005210625,
-0.0490250811,
0.0697669908,
0.0127515942,
-0.0113503765,
-0.0822613686,
-0.0225525051,
0.0948949009,
-0.003310062,
-0.0114733251,
0.0139617082,
-0.0192934107,
-0.0398729518,
-0.0142061468,
0.0156057784,
0.0066999537,
0.0130969295,
0.0014880252,
-0.0357458629,
0.0572441705,
0.0083622523,
-0.0368668661,
0.0202592127,
0.0071948073,
-0.0763282478,
-0.0243755206,
0.0084558055,
-0.0226935036,
0.0619757473,
0.0528442152,
0.0384056121,
0.0115020107,
-0.0026381537,
0.0286052637,
0.0264533348,
0.0771383122,
-0.017599361,
0.012232,
-0.037152838,
0.0539129376,
-0.0009541076,
0.0132877575,
-0.0213769395,
-0.0428112447,
0.0594964474,
-0.0020562795,
-0.044557225,
0.0195740629,
-0.034635216,
-0.0305380132,
-0.0563588291,
0.0221860446,
0.0106320595,
0.0043979553,
0.0456451885,
0.006549147,
0.0068301703,
0.0049361968,
0.0135575738,
0.0042216377,
-0.0232486948,
0.0551490299,
-0.0265281349,
0.0468432643,
-0.0279083494,
0.0489008762,
-0.0237463582,
-0.0429605022,
-0.0361035913,
0.0065526562,
0.0782331377,
-0.0376499332,
0.0583612621,
0.003174772,
0.0006119335,
-0.0365979485,
-0.002877203,
-0.0118572665,
0.0406987742,
0.026836101,
-0.0052273604,
-0.0159056894,
0.0054825237,
0.1005729064,
0.0375374928,
0.0478815213,
0.0236046836,
-0.0405313931,
-0.0133817373,
-0.0007692938,
0.0232575946,
0.0037525343,
-0.0603814796,
0.025661109,
-0.023446301,
-0.0616812892,
0.0335917138,
-0.0646690875,
-0.0106808934,
-0.0080771996,
0.0185306258,
0.031671755,
0.0114737041,
-0.0082137706,
-0.032261923,
0.0026546763,
0.0209288318,
-0.0147860404,
0.0268059745,
-6.275744669e-33,
0.0012831328,
0.0191256292,
0.0280229226,
-0.016021885,
0.0274933465,
0.0160080027,
-0.0339238644,
0.0030764365,
-0.0132028824,
0.0271026902,
-0.0269740224,
-0.0067788423,
0.023680754,
0.0316554233,
0.0017976498,
0.0137051111,
0.0300203357,
0.018532047,
-0.0055241068,
0.0024538264,
-0.0041963374,
0.0707675666,
0.0803149864,
-0.0748005435,
-0.0193287358,
0.0378202833,
0.0372399874,
-0.0210048277,
-0.0007043096,
0.0578222424,
-0.0709182099,
0.0425433517,
0.0474348553,
-0.0453477539,
-0.0087005282,
-0.0344489813,
-0.0985166878,
0.0123519851,
0.0026997938,
0.0095270043,
-0.0043981038,
0.0049587688,
0.012713952,
0.0068037314,
0.0010813082,
-0.0086677372,
0.011290051,
-0.0781598091,
-0.0000989969,
-0.0735662654,
-0.055070933,
0.050059665,
0.0200752504,
0.0006664667,
0.0041370275,
-0.0087834736,
-0.0455796048,
0.0558570176,
-0.0525749922,
-0.0312201511,
0.0580819473,
0.0577886365,
-0.0008393963,
-0.0072503295,
-0.0467890985,
0.0371267311,
-0.0273707528,
-0.0199397821,
0.0154258171,
-0.0002709403,
-0.0034066231,
0.0161417034,
0.0176301058,
0.0242857132,
0.0281703211,
-0.0345937721,
-0.1175649539,
0.036444243,
-0.0712098554,
0.0162771903,
0.0014903616,
-0.003157676,
0.0152533082,
-0.0038453615,
-0.0152336694,
0.0487782732,
-0.0448374674,
-0.001976935,
0.014296012,
0.0272378754,
-0.0217746403,
0.0223634746,
0.0146670835,
-0.0643462464,
0.0084304204,
-0.0267965719,
-0.0094346916,
-0.0100132525,
-0.0212978404,
0.0193274077,
-0.0413738564,
-0.0543044955,
0.0161413457,
-0.0560273081,
0.0137809189,
-0.021453077,
0.0175208934,
-0.0255974028,
-0.0660050809,
0.0030512977,
0.0374562293,
-0.0412777588,
0.044125393,
0.1013589203,
-0.0008439718,
0.029256925,
0.0128385974,
0.0692047253,
0.0452012084,
-0.0383908078,
-0.0214115828,
-0.0206809063,
0.045184508,
-0.0000048916,
-0.0408615731,
-0.0086142374,
0.0017433614,
0.0309608206,
0.0566932298,
-0.0716632158,
-0.0193812214,
-0.0468271039,
2.975e-7,
0.0903452635,
0.0354291499,
-0.040937297,
-0.0362057202,
0.0030967854,
0.002249833,
-0.0217454396,
0.0603464767,
-0.0151015557,
-0.006686246,
0.0588198788,
0.0039017838,
0.0331454128,
0.0152438404,
-0.0577815063,
-0.0213891473,
-0.0617209934,
-0.0168515313,
-0.0280148871,
-0.0233265646,
-0.0360815376,
0.1332469732,
-0.0340718366,
-0.0414678119,
0.0178983361,
-0.020683255,
0.0721625835,
-0.0315273814,
0.0158617273,
0.0689759254,
0.0174112897,
0.0016625463,
-0.0211757477,
0.0134618757,
-0.0356240124,
0.057245411,
0.0203871783,
0.1086883098,
-0.0531870127,
0.0391173214,
0.0269403178,
0.0303396378,
0.0352394097,
-0.0299549084,
0.0474096946,
-0.0459269173,
-0.0450516418,
-0.0175149441,
-0.0153679997,
-0.0086285882,
0.0605796091,
-0.0226780828,
0.0177666191,
0.0428204648,
0.0255317464,
0.0367158689,
-0.0493510701,
-0.0961596742,
-0.0148147326,
0.0118239662,
-0.0369213186,
-0.0154377129,
0.0262084901,
-0.0611257926,
0.0156101827,
-0.0542103685,
0.0337301902,
2.625389491e-34,
0.0192888901,
-0.0070734415,
0.0037626559,
0.0270894412,
0.0195676703,
-0.020010272,
0.0274270289,
0.0155859133,
-0.0127659254,
-0.1132047474,
0.0043210606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04922v1 | Are cascade dialogue state tracking models speaking out of turn in spoken dialogues? | 2023-11-03T08:45:22 | 2023-11-03T08:45:22 | Lucas Druart, Léo Jacqmin, Benoît Favre, Lina Maria Rojas-Barahona, Valentin Vielzeuf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS, eess.SP | In Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems, correctly updating the system's
understanding of the user's needs is key to a smooth interaction. Traditionally
TOD systems are composed of several modules that interact with one another.
While each of these components is the focus of active research communities,
their behavior in interaction can be overlooked. This paper proposes a
comprehensive analysis of the errors of state of the art systems in complex
settings such as Dialogue State Tracking which highly depends on the dialogue
context. Based on spoken MultiWoz, we identify that errors on non-categorical
slots' values are essential to address in order to bridge the gap between
spoken and chat-based dialogue systems. We explore potential solutions to
improve transcriptions and help dialogue state tracking generative models
correct such errors. | [
0.0371689014,
0.0563310049,
-0.0069764,
0.0141688874,
-0.0081778942,
-0.0071175112,
0.0072377441,
-0.0105983354,
0.0029020428,
-0.0291898735,
-0.0309557132,
-0.0704538599,
0.0237314329,
0.0657091364,
0.0064276177,
-0.0741662607,
0.0595595427,
-0.0328535102,
-0.0139502324,
0.0183620341,
0.0216332879,
0.0050174622,
-0.0860819966,
0.0678567961,
-0.03185739,
-0.0368061624,
-0.0620359816,
0.0157704018,
-0.0246240739,
0.0262728892,
-0.0156236794,
0.0400763489,
0.0123762786,
0.0249241404,
0.0000016088,
-0.0395300537,
-0.0030138588,
-0.0141137671,
-0.0375330709,
-0.0364852063,
-0.043049071,
0.0149897411,
-0.0319904163,
0.0442856811,
-0.0096435677,
-0.0272651184,
0.0289226323,
0.0265300106,
0.0469257869,
0.051890146,
-0.0082197143,
0.0222130846,
0.0220438223,
0.0015143484,
0.0177147649,
-0.0803913251,
0.0112570776,
0.0274904817,
0.0126762027,
-0.0206813738,
-0.0088132415,
-0.0045360504,
-0.0086346688,
-0.0783447847,
-0.0151937641,
-0.0129420524,
-0.0023798202,
-0.0405666083,
-0.0504449792,
0.0670779422,
0.0494727492,
0.0505743697,
0.0085471664,
-0.0003531865,
0.0041799136,
-0.0417834297,
-0.035981372,
-0.0304563176,
-0.0502026491,
-0.0209688451,
-0.0098518766,
0.034734834,
-0.029681962,
-0.0127140488,
-0.0170499347,
0.0344177298,
0.0081818718,
-0.0332700945,
-0.0417826027,
0.0047222991,
0.047004886,
-0.0655297711,
0.0337038785,
0.0074587194,
-0.0820009857,
0.0262246132,
-0.0477456264,
0.0235873926,
-0.0349148139,
-0.037254706,
0.0095847398,
0.0701723173,
-0.05355132,
0.0226902105,
0.0711647794,
0.0808553174,
-0.0019040423,
-0.0561422184,
-0.0145628471,
-0.0317641497,
-0.0463962965,
0.0074389619,
-0.0553542376,
0.0093187205,
-0.0372171029,
-0.0288975295,
-0.0259630885,
0.0563050844,
-0.0139622577,
0.0329523496,
0.0020180517,
0.0063413102,
-0.0209415331,
0.0049479455,
-0.0181659907,
0.0611455068,
0.0123095736,
0.0271280333,
0.0208765902,
-0.0505773686,
-0.006961775,
0.0241179727,
0.0462621115,
-0.0075680241,
-0.0399458706,
0.0393079333,
-0.0142455092,
-0.007968002,
0.0339886285,
-0.0117281359,
-0.0615449734,
-0.0456001237,
-0.04733916,
-0.0132522676,
0.0364647582,
0.003653181,
-0.0044769691,
-0.0170186218,
0.0095349578,
0.0070484318,
-0.0132008716,
0.0289715119,
-0.0020883754,
0.016802622,
-0.0019323276,
0.0098578651,
-0.0071888156,
0.0399284177,
0.0504986905,
-0.0195949282,
0.0391332246,
-0.0157762729,
0.0144491764,
0.0322276056,
-0.0167883933,
-0.0059166835,
0.0217980798,
0.0239625182,
-0.0158499647,
0.0167970899,
0.0364380069,
0.0665065944,
-0.0464649051,
0.0273762401,
0.0651027784,
0.0468674488,
0.0303347185,
0.0009110001,
0.0332999229,
-0.0006383419,
-0.0004667819,
0.0588978827,
0.0155926328,
-0.0130879255,
0.0110620102,
-0.0193620324,
0.0605315641,
-0.0006330653,
-0.0358708203,
-0.0386750102,
-0.0173667017,
0.000887626,
0.016879525,
-0.0405914262,
0.0534250066,
0.0104839616,
-0.0644317865,
0.0017996519,
-0.0326759033,
-0.0505023636,
-0.0108671086,
-0.0343090855,
-0.0344287269,
0.0942434669,
0.0376396105,
-0.0074302731,
-0.0745367929,
-0.0423801988,
-0.0191955846,
0.0354616009,
0.0412144214,
-0.0466445461,
0.0742627457,
-0.0239820573,
-0.0046972437,
0.0460424162,
0.0107621253,
-0.0117371483,
-0.026893096,
-0.0228281505,
0.0053200214,
0.0467881039,
0.0551849008,
-0.0153495511,
0.0151403006,
0.0146439578,
-0.0186260007,
-0.005951338,
0.0628911853,
0.0468511842,
-0.0082988087,
-0.0147678787,
0.0025982046,
0.0087086139,
0.0027861018,
0.0619264469,
-0.0791590065,
-0.0569589399,
0.0318874121,
0.0321007557,
-0.0141264508,
0.009877814,
-0.0088089062,
-0.0718963072,
0.0075776996,
-0.0550144091,
0.0245179106,
-0.0627727509,
0.0255267676,
0.0472629257,
0.0066195568,
0.0115544703,
-0.0240102168,
-0.0081337988,
0.0097392248,
0.0356568247,
-0.0230737254,
0.0144511238,
-0.0458286516,
0.0368697047,
0.0389745757,
-0.0282149725,
0.0251092482,
-0.0155766746,
-0.019040918,
-0.0480309725,
-0.0122769522,
-0.0753482133,
0.0088175414,
-0.0223011468,
0.0145613998,
-0.0002924014,
0.0246230122,
-0.0161035787,
-0.0108930534,
-0.0272398554,
-0.032744877,
0.0736767873,
-0.0302227456,
0.0042870259,
0.0154684503,
-0.0391417556,
-0.0479945093,
0.0492691137,
-0.0259950552,
0.0054553137,
-0.0510921963,
-0.043695651,
-0.0804288387,
0.0062778271,
-0.0220778678,
0.0443524271,
-0.0162821058,
-0.0063833334,
0.0229657684,
0.0340861157,
0.0475647226,
-0.00141279,
-0.0105479909,
0.0765777752,
-0.0435851626,
-0.0795724168,
-0.060878545,
0.0411832519,
0.0046071252,
0.0155413942,
-0.0405505486,
-0.0017694195,
-0.0049109417,
0.0476445705,
0.0294883214,
0.0378560312,
-0.053457994,
-0.027192127,
-0.014248102,
-0.0356375761,
0.006276255,
-0.0406719334,
-0.0589706078,
0.0327062979,
0.0021352232,
-0.0177882463,
0.0354597978,
-0.0573323295,
-0.061302565,
-0.0334506333,
-0.0139887026,
-0.0317073427,
0.0515583679,
-0.0362205543,
0.0119796563,
0.080137901,
-0.0579008907,
-0.0299836285,
0.0084844539,
0.0029052531,
-0.047460366,
0.0427518599,
-0.0327961519,
0.0065722698,
-0.0185865741,
-0.0548182763,
-0.0351091474,
0.0061687543,
0.0021328747,
0.0205503125,
0.0352213793,
-0.0316087492,
0.0136322817,
0.0680944622,
0.0208031964,
0.028081201,
0.0112008126,
0.0024300797,
-0.0302484855,
0.0502488352,
0.0536012352,
0.0088350698,
-0.0401789024,
-0.0178439878,
0.0658991113,
0.0351852737,
0.0486944951,
-0.0076852026,
0.0255187117,
-0.0203397293,
0.047644265,
-0.0053071892,
-0.0310725756,
0.0000143114,
0.0720843449,
-0.0215913486,
-0.0031021121,
0.1010790467,
0.0206373446,
-0.0219518393,
-0.0146336081,
-0.0368181281,
0.0171756167,
-0.012158148,
0.0105305845,
-0.0793567672,
-0.0035477551,
0.0340033472,
0.0239911824,
-0.0267030504,
-0.0241915304,
-0.0098573202,
-0.0802357122,
0.0301894527,
0.0035529321,
-0.0424184725,
-0.0317257196,
0.0045844074,
0.0433122441,
0.0305803232,
0.0429544859,
0.030731773,
0.011831928,
-0.0453148708,
0.0536449812,
-0.0285461638,
0.0004120647,
0.0201211292,
0.0002030592,
0.1001015529,
0.0546117648,
0.0508029759,
0.0248501617,
0.0252069775,
-0.0050574089,
0.0190325342,
-0.01746241,
0.0095394468,
-0.0203656796,
-0.0281599779,
-0.0012018445,
-0.0415903404,
0.0446559638,
0.0045801373,
0.0017801241,
-0.0250796098,
0.0125689693,
-0.0650840849,
0.0271376576,
0.002946178,
0.0344169959,
0.0374722555,
0.0443728119,
0.0378822349,
-0.0780602768,
0.0042935559,
-0.0171283949,
-0.0059076352,
-0.0171013176,
0.0072945496,
-0.0148519929,
0.0106140058,
-0.0310584921,
-0.064222604,
-0.0524978265,
0.0144148497,
0.0624600649,
-0.0355519019,
0.0174482763,
0.0106739495,
0.0090930397,
0.0430194847,
-0.0245886985,
-0.008315363,
0.0167034008,
-0.0470264405,
-0.0289651938,
0.0253091864,
-0.0195607617,
-0.0078660157,
0.0314288996,
-0.0662753657,
-0.0558574386,
-0.0227994639,
0.0543580726,
0.0308857262,
0.0207485706,
-0.0081961369,
-0.0006118423,
-0.0801518559,
-0.0057244254,
0.0021265801,
0.0004359989,
0.0489853993,
0.0579573289,
-0.0208973289,
0.0387532189,
-0.0266730729,
0.0128546478,
-0.0737592354,
0.0569695123,
-0.0592221357,
-0.1162182987,
-0.0217025634,
-0.0435699075,
0.0558800884,
0.0255967714,
-0.0124769155,
-0.0161352288,
0.0683250651,
-0.0312726311,
-0.010381015,
-0.0507876799,
0.002041887,
-0.03645714,
0.0182012785,
-0.0145681053,
-0.0142894806,
-0.0387153774,
0.0256379452,
-0.0055688187,
-0.010960889,
0.0161122847,
-0.0228696112,
0.0055051846,
-0.0172939356,
-0.016257152,
0.0284302067,
0.0413805693,
0.0251559243,
0.0146045275,
0.0900212899,
-0.0101117631,
-0.0320492797,
0.0374854468,
0.0185659155,
-0.0499809496,
-0.0303846113,
-0.0063023553,
0.0134717664,
0.0642505512,
0.0426872671,
0.0631723702,
0.01246823,
0.0421700999,
-0.0194938947,
0.0761677176,
-0.0038585947,
-0.0170303714,
-0.0133651663,
0.0118534695,
-0.0066315662,
0.0148432786,
0.0706488341,
0.0432594903,
0.0320452452,
-0.0153166978,
0.0019062355,
-0.0407961719,
-0.0240179505,
-0.010280652,
0.0423820615,
-0.0209405553,
-0.0159067977,
-0.0652500018,
-0.0389966592,
0.0242791511,
0.0127823893,
0.0439952165,
-0.0302520804,
0.0239220057,
-0.0035507868,
-0.0240627415,
-0.0025167479,
-0.0278223306,
-0.0734170303,
-0.0152423065,
-0.0000484787,
-0.0061131963,
-5.324628679e-33,
-0.0376014486,
-0.0299692303,
0.0293006282,
0.03376773,
-0.0428154245,
-0.034833774,
-0.0384872518,
0.0215357933,
-0.001598631,
-0.0244930368,
-0.0219660141,
0.014284106,
0.0239419118,
0.0140979029,
-0.0024454608,
0.0187579319,
0.0544704311,
0.0082453908,
-0.0278126951,
0.0030836265,
0.0539099015,
0.0135172503,
0.0554082543,
-0.0656684712,
0.0493275486,
0.0058184857,
-0.0174638033,
0.0230707452,
0.0294567291,
0.0267239567,
0.0090947766,
0.0174874011,
-0.0069852169,
-0.0237925909,
-0.0233335774,
0.0233083759,
-0.0226959288,
-0.008857891,
0.0565256141,
0.0429101437,
0.0152142169,
0.0311860684,
-0.0166021418,
0.018852178,
-0.004713024,
0.0180538222,
-0.0087417439,
-0.006973281,
-0.0152332615,
-0.0032306402,
-0.0546709299,
0.0186268203,
-0.0224569254,
-0.08938016,
-0.0215576459,
0.0892765597,
0.0337202102,
-0.0850448757,
-0.0403351039,
0.0110384095,
-0.0434008054,
-0.0238422584,
0.0577580594,
0.0392477587,
0.0041465424,
0.0658823922,
0.060558904,
0.0264951363,
-0.0299118236,
-0.0680425018,
-0.0400817357,
0.0336414389,
0.0114704529,
-0.0161367729,
-0.0174372476,
0.0097624362,
-0.0327079706,
0.0256259367,
0.040595077,
0.0238944311,
-0.0023350874,
0.0558257438,
-0.0541344881,
-0.0025014479,
-0.0030438777,
-0.0066863182,
0.0047026062,
-0.0438052453,
0.0108117368,
0.0131106004,
0.0364572741,
0.0075788512,
0.0795130804,
-0.0125939809,
-0.0155755673,
-0.0038515157,
-0.028063722,
0.0267286245,
-0.0526762083,
-0.001271394,
-0.0508299246,
-0.0455292426,
0.0507397614,
0.0517663136,
0.0476127602,
0.0150588611,
-0.0180489607,
0.0155415386,
-0.0507639535,
0.0019469182,
-0.0431721732,
0.0533570759,
-0.0505661108,
0.0603097454,
0.0595093556,
-0.0204932969,
-0.0289055873,
0.0898201168,
0.0102835726,
-0.0045839273,
-0.0490119718,
0.0038869421,
0.0096615274,
-0.005762951,
-0.0099315317,
-0.0265087951,
0.0019842123,
-0.0084081553,
0.0119816419,
0.0060798065,
-0.0050457297,
-0.0105723748,
2.457e-7,
-0.0002593719,
0.0318595432,
0.0516863614,
-0.0034333982,
0.0450863764,
0.0423309729,
-0.0273585934,
0.032232739,
0.0193554368,
0.0098890839,
0.0277814753,
-0.028205853,
0.0758472234,
0.0311426427,
-0.1157315448,
-0.0843397528,
-0.0347675681,
-0.0129133221,
-0.020240264,
0.0241112765,
0.0572066419,
0.0426726602,
0.0191449486,
0.022213174,
0.0391293131,
-0.0052299751,
0.0354372561,
-0.0073359953,
0.0056185066,
0.0225143377,
0.0291011371,
-0.0071437219,
-0.0040158639,
-0.0062858635,
0.0142129762,
0.0409115814,
0.0144503303,
0.0784417987,
-0.024772143,
-0.0515396409,
-0.0527788289,
0.0362249985,
-0.0063296361,
-0.0279569086,
0.0052001858,
-0.0081589669,
-0.0007024615,
-0.0366129838,
0.0037696618,
0.0116627701,
0.006732442,
0.0230792053,
-0.0069270851,
0.0211291593,
-0.0124552976,
-0.0030233387,
-0.0187102538,
-0.0787772983,
-0.0014705724,
-0.0328539498,
-0.0478033461,
-0.079738006,
-0.00105062,
-0.0345793515,
-0.0093021616,
0.0013849857,
-0.0429091863,
1.90982969e-34,
0.0300556868,
-0.013584625,
0.0234378353,
0.0529635437,
0.0279480107,
-0.0231235754,
-0.0036151065,
0.0177717619,
0.0527207851,
-0.0205284059,
-0.0232487079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01775v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01775v2 | UP4LS: User Profile Constructed by Multiple Attributes for Enhancing Linguistic Steganalysis | 2023-11-03T08:20:48 | 2024-06-03T07:42:15 | Yihao Wang, Ruiqi Song, Lingxiao Li, Yifan Tang, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Linguistic steganalysis (LS) tasks aim to detect whether a text contains
secret information. Existing LS methods focus on the deep-learning model design
and they achieve excellent results in ideal data. However, they overlook the
unique user characteristics, leading to weak performance in social networks.
And a few stegos here that further complicate detection. We propose the UP4LS,
a framework with the User Profile for enhancing LS in realistic scenarios.
Three kinds of user attributes like writing habits are explored to build the
profile. For each attribute, the specific feature extraction module is
designed. The extracted features are mapped to high-dimensional user features
via the deep-learning model of the method to be improved. The content feature
is extracted by the language model. Then user and content features are
integrated. Existing methods can improve LS results by adding the UP4LS
framework without changing their deep-learning models. Experiments show that
UP4LS can significantly enhance the performance of LS-task baselines in
realistic scenarios, with the overall Acc increased by 25%, F1 increased by
51%, and SOTA results. The improvement is especially pronounced in fewer
stegos. Additionally, UP4LS also sets the stage for the related-task SOTA
methods to efficient LS. | [
0.0482852645,
0.0695234463,
-0.017047273,
0.0501811132,
-0.0627695173,
0.014627533,
0.0537949055,
0.0309982784,
0.0249642059,
-0.0447468683,
-0.0138210701,
-0.0264059976,
-0.0256187804,
0.0953729451,
0.0071387966,
0.0511431322,
0.0281300619,
0.0007718959,
0.0185120627,
-0.0052230167,
0.0157052055,
0.0331909321,
0.0412369519,
-0.0012128856,
-0.022807762,
-0.0396123342,
0.0016369389,
-0.0319294445,
0.0361841731,
0.007509232,
0.0199550521,
0.0442283489,
-0.0158698689,
0.1080638841,
0.0000022425,
-0.018242985,
-0.0563468486,
-0.0057258727,
-0.0427847207,
0.0019724441,
0.0605648495,
0.0103940284,
-0.0368866622,
0.0191656221,
-0.0797516704,
0.0180197135,
0.0143595571,
0.0568082966,
0.0309622493,
0.0770768151,
-0.0279712919,
-0.0280581936,
0.0222684741,
-0.0166938156,
-0.0192027576,
-0.0239675958,
0.043414291,
-0.0475323349,
-0.0343807153,
0.0338423662,
0.0224998221,
0.0615947396,
0.0191269368,
-0.0310701728,
0.0109748552,
-0.0134020858,
-0.0040744594,
0.0083136857,
0.0367625505,
0.0600550584,
-0.0743905753,
-0.0014225702,
0.0240905415,
-0.0205886774,
-0.0004337789,
0.0344188958,
0.0412006527,
0.0081859306,
-0.0485270545,
-0.010761627,
0.0378212221,
-0.0072926381,
0.0233802479,
0.0226545334,
0.0128572825,
0.0168683883,
-0.0194088016,
-0.0043441472,
-0.0108004324,
-0.042811323,
-0.0051854425,
-0.0590439476,
0.0733263791,
0.0085703796,
0.0205100924,
-0.0109799337,
-0.0420030057,
-0.0855604336,
0.0115258079,
-0.0518187061,
0.0187650677,
-0.0270723235,
-0.0478038192,
0.0407670699,
-0.0520609543,
0.0418937765,
-0.0303196386,
0.0017233584,
-0.0017994177,
-0.0045783632,
0.006943604,
-0.0442121215,
-0.0057564834,
0.0844112486,
-0.0234760121,
-0.0437983312,
-0.062920697,
-0.0042340937,
-0.0231686626,
0.0081631532,
-0.029063493,
0.0265532043,
-0.0326150022,
0.0161054824,
0.0136216041,
-0.0257657412,
-0.0067425352,
0.0263595283,
0.0070406087,
-0.0115972394,
-0.0011503299,
0.0274384711,
0.0611117855,
-0.0095388843,
0.0214697234,
0.0732747316,
-0.003282005,
-0.0386816375,
-0.03699122,
-0.071602799,
-0.0566538572,
-0.0187289454,
0.0021148892,
-0.0674882382,
-0.009995983,
-0.0259165131,
-0.0440500453,
-0.0758402795,
-0.0172826089,
0.0283923857,
-0.0061592259,
0.0336692967,
-0.0051639127,
-0.0397244059,
0.0242311396,
0.0305158067,
-0.0126353186,
0.0218309499,
-0.0125541249,
0.1340584904,
0.0497377254,
-0.0093829418,
0.0166279301,
0.0339724571,
0.0094747907,
-0.0089131184,
0.0240920354,
-0.0262918826,
0.0401334018,
-0.0345067456,
0.022198623,
0.0236251485,
-0.0045597991,
-0.0532153994,
0.0582914166,
0.0686706081,
0.0243937057,
0.0183528829,
0.0074775843,
0.0262390375,
-0.0122498842,
0.0261194464,
-0.0065219258,
0.0045601013,
-0.0692422912,
-0.0471223593,
-0.0126194172,
0.0251642186,
0.0034129957,
-0.017788494,
0.0226865057,
-0.0581843145,
0.0536779165,
0.0084456261,
0.020792732,
0.0335321687,
-0.0172122046,
0.0009610985,
0.0170805734,
-0.0236882642,
0.000059684,
-0.0262623969,
0.0432470478,
0.0782463923,
0.0090805525,
-0.0159923024,
0.0236837119,
-0.0373335592,
0.016032923,
0.0093126325,
-0.0206278693,
0.010680805,
0.0271040723,
-0.0458848998,
-0.0381064452,
-0.0500384234,
-0.0047504436,
0.039274741,
0.0250892323,
0.0550818667,
0.0495518111,
0.0201875884,
-0.0175894536,
0.0172262117,
-0.037041679,
-0.0108161848,
0.0350389741,
0.0263327789,
0.0358397178,
0.0446982309,
0.010908274,
-0.0068286001,
0.0143040475,
-0.076478444,
-0.0317875333,
-0.0636964068,
-0.0167638697,
0.0010389352,
0.0149852103,
-0.0332124643,
0.0105069866,
0.0531783253,
-0.0072147441,
-0.0112767424,
0.0304650944,
-0.0338466465,
-0.0331891626,
-0.0399771184,
-0.0020361957,
-0.002498911,
0.0654316172,
-0.0026575534,
0.0641822815,
-0.0129746161,
-0.0166900009,
-0.0293589234,
-0.031841699,
-0.0007340091,
-0.0264101978,
0.013751029,
-0.0425812565,
-0.0282459427,
-0.0040699402,
0.0415160432,
0.0424401872,
-0.0175484177,
-0.0517862067,
-0.0262790415,
-0.0092542171,
-0.0427474529,
0.0353684574,
0.0050155688,
-0.0009604835,
0.0093166614,
-0.0169695728,
-0.0633459687,
-0.0254029538,
-0.0138292005,
0.0132789845,
0.0433043763,
0.0081358049,
-0.0124510601,
-0.033625029,
-0.0044092247,
-0.0143390326,
0.0310387742,
-0.0339168198,
-0.0547364131,
-0.0070767212,
0.0169704203,
-0.0000201375,
0.0115424767,
-0.0157998707,
-0.0376000367,
-0.0011120384,
-0.0091231074,
-0.0134852938,
0.0547434837,
0.0295385011,
0.0233967882,
0.0003796436,
0.0031348546,
-0.005109041,
-0.026221253,
-0.0098951515,
0.0656732172,
0.0089137116,
-0.008043142,
0.0217434093,
-0.0171177294,
0.0263780691,
0.0003427581,
-0.0155107034,
0.0745381042,
0.0019418197,
-0.0255360007,
-0.0042323577,
-0.0309569761,
0.0164942034,
0.0016830307,
-0.0334728286,
-0.0244983397,
0.0725681111,
-0.0174023174,
0.0349099226,
-0.0257131048,
-0.0775666088,
-0.006041531,
0.0508438423,
0.021623997,
0.0479375198,
-0.0030170036,
-0.0534382723,
0.0035687538,
0.0096679507,
0.0247644894,
-0.0422953591,
-0.0058732769,
0.0092672203,
-0.0089313909,
-0.000691465,
-0.034947969,
-0.0523735061,
-0.1070536003,
-0.00637308,
-0.0113247065,
0.016843887,
-0.0844946057,
-0.0109948907,
-0.0308053512,
0.0003251064,
0.0301351454,
-0.0224520136,
0.0086344713,
-0.033862967,
0.0382551402,
0.0379379727,
-0.0596988536,
0.0158984046,
-0.0060496987,
0.0213589258,
0.0859441236,
-0.0503862686,
0.0090625836,
0.0065209377,
-0.0064918431,
-0.0178647749,
0.0069859736,
-0.0495033227,
0.0004564126,
0.0382223725,
-0.0374578163,
0.0177959856,
0.0823740363,
0.0060356581,
-0.0001835814,
-0.0061632162,
0.0129412618,
-0.0012807834,
-0.028972676,
0.0107203657,
-0.1150148064,
-0.0385808572,
0.0056461738,
0.0193283763,
-0.0265548341,
-0.0306837689,
-0.0274302736,
-0.0439663939,
0.0082211243,
0.001724897,
-0.0664709955,
-0.0430339426,
-0.0313742533,
-0.0416181535,
0.0257408749,
0.0351158492,
-0.0409056954,
0.0117859738,
-0.0314688534,
-0.0170004666,
-0.0638906062,
-0.0350907035,
0.0070238099,
-0.0326511711,
0.0260227229,
0.0281536076,
0.024293866,
-0.0135979317,
-0.0397209004,
-0.0478808656,
0.0499784276,
-0.0010916928,
-0.0206669215,
0.0920510814,
-0.0162657443,
-0.0217510965,
-0.0343260095,
0.0711234212,
-0.0606297813,
0.0013983817,
0.0146717327,
0.0185925309,
-0.0236407686,
-0.0522070639,
0.0109796282,
0.0103354398,
0.0459335707,
0.0611278526,
0.0252647419,
-0.0436227508,
-0.0132212583,
-0.0309888478,
-0.0166469906,
-0.0629422814,
-0.0218798947,
-0.0148894843,
0.0044998918,
-0.0086150356,
-0.052018296,
-0.0367900915,
-0.0049967244,
-0.0373359658,
0.0009656393,
0.0533881858,
0.0175841991,
-0.0408908725,
-0.080414556,
0.0022103237,
-0.0325132124,
0.0650033355,
-0.0126124881,
0.0041306051,
0.0283790492,
-0.0355770811,
0.0045145238,
0.0327347741,
-0.0512176864,
-0.0434066653,
0.0466895364,
-0.0144289723,
0.0007902424,
0.0138528002,
-0.0572643168,
-0.0751038566,
0.0611519814,
0.0403269939,
-0.0519494079,
-0.0227619465,
0.0569464862,
-0.0352946632,
-0.0072560715,
0.0237380322,
-0.0178690534,
0.0052368864,
0.0351838507,
-0.0863985196,
-0.0722373053,
-0.0208452158,
-0.0194493439,
0.0268055778,
0.0316349193,
0.0204346459,
0.0012997014,
-0.0314972103,
-0.0030920887,
-0.0227037836,
-0.0243256912,
-0.0029426024,
-0.0014373158,
0.0269652791,
-0.0184668377,
0.0244430955,
0.043896284,
0.0080920206,
0.0175461881,
-0.0253590662,
0.0406873487,
-0.0247357227,
0.0662765577,
0.0114409328,
0.0278290454,
-0.0113258427,
0.0597891659,
-0.0057370239,
0.0543599464,
-0.0419171453,
-0.0155743547,
0.0071966262,
-0.0097376807,
-0.0127893602,
0.0556629598,
-0.0203255229,
0.0237393118,
-0.0191785172,
-0.0195996668,
0.0285258573,
-0.0274629351,
0.0428690501,
-0.0256243721,
-0.0003675392,
-0.032486096,
0.0207608715,
-0.0194908623,
-0.0114624258,
-0.0340400152,
-0.0048190109,
-0.0341924019,
0.0317810401,
0.0679124594,
0.0133297723,
0.010642767,
0.0145994574,
-0.0436279997,
-0.0353860334,
0.0073297578,
0.0358813927,
0.1020823568,
-0.0341186039,
-0.0131377177,
-0.0088416114,
-0.0451967791,
0.0321209952,
-0.0430404134,
-0.0139913699,
0.0634866506,
0.0156781729,
0.0493424162,
-0.021927502,
-0.0075315917,
-0.0726782754,
0.0072143269,
0.0305649694,
-0.0369306393,
0.0369384438,
-6.419622973e-33,
0.020914929,
-0.0891081169,
-0.0163158067,
0.0573480874,
0.0407555215,
0.0563980825,
0.0176224355,
0.0015306839,
-0.0398324244,
0.0216614511,
-0.0059610861,
0.0245023575,
0.0042560548,
0.0189379659,
-0.0382471047,
0.0048170383,
0.0516573191,
0.0207374673,
0.0100709451,
0.0284674913,
0.0873150676,
0.046738483,
0.0574372597,
-0.1252507716,
0.0075692185,
-0.0094416961,
-0.0171261635,
-0.0042806976,
-0.0126725985,
0.0493091755,
-0.0295279454,
0.0432447977,
0.0145484824,
-0.0061332602,
0.0002736051,
0.0635214373,
-0.052177079,
-0.041827783,
-0.0317754485,
0.0235689059,
0.0025211039,
-0.1221560314,
0.0439271294,
-0.021268297,
0.0180922449,
0.0046229032,
0.0324896537,
0.0096865036,
0.0025049623,
-0.0282278042,
-0.0187431891,
0.0478828326,
0.0226378236,
0.0269856751,
0.0268506072,
0.0144268898,
0.0323796608,
-0.0358846933,
-0.1163472235,
0.0142363282,
-0.0146536129,
0.0217906609,
0.0146666728,
0.0335205682,
-0.0409936346,
0.0665077418,
0.0225211978,
-0.0074822633,
-0.0041419137,
0.0386072844,
0.0321596228,
0.0235642176,
0.0768733993,
0.0429199524,
0.0339753851,
-0.0435615107,
-0.0811620727,
0.0144443121,
0.0348718315,
-0.0413765758,
0.0497647449,
-0.005408017,
-0.0807778239,
-0.0255705323,
-0.0111789024,
0.0420418978,
-0.0348397382,
-0.0274744183,
0.0078606978,
-0.0015695199,
-0.0574622601,
0.0026871457,
0.0162944831,
-0.0578107163,
0.0069773355,
0.0459886529,
-0.033365503,
-0.000326189,
0.0136391437,
0.0261221919,
-0.0274256282,
-0.0200716089,
0.0218445268,
-0.0041367821,
0.0138094248,
-0.009327515,
0.0724606067,
0.0392955467,
-0.0518618152,
-0.0059284107,
0.0316796117,
0.0369046219,
0.0247900505,
0.0070082028,
-0.0155402729,
-0.0142560545,
-0.0099154552,
0.046014674,
0.0589261167,
0.0452212468,
-0.0336924605,
-0.008083147,
0.0127389953,
-0.0177052803,
-0.0099350391,
-0.01858606,
0.0018971906,
0.0450400859,
0.0731398836,
-0.0230338536,
0.0151531659,
-0.0112537164,
3.068e-7,
0.0363718905,
-0.0019342107,
0.0116398986,
-0.0182327293,
0.001910146,
0.0655919984,
0.0686942786,
0.0229747929,
-0.0367938131,
0.0089683738,
-0.0195461046,
0.0538909659,
0.0414981544,
0.0354819745,
-0.0506741516,
0.0236563291,
-0.0321168713,
-0.0158341751,
-0.0681525841,
0.0016980086,
0.0156846605,
0.0641494915,
0.0294176694,
-0.0571647771,
-0.0053085545,
-0.0270236731,
0.0020924446,
0.0161127932,
-0.0415641516,
-0.0156166246,
0.0519500934,
0.0438862555,
-0.0061845225,
0.0227132868,
-0.0288219266,
0.0154944286,
0.000424814,
0.0279603228,
-0.0012682207,
-0.0396458358,
-0.0199873354,
-0.038806621,
-0.0222163461,
0.0046354989,
0.0681567341,
0.0231371131,
-0.0555341542,
-0.0493985638,
0.0175415352,
-0.0215580799,
0.0261437465,
-0.0287398268,
-0.0009701638,
0.034565337,
0.0349164568,
-0.0184600465,
-0.0130711393,
-0.0631794706,
0.0024765877,
0.0055856556,
-0.009961023,
0.00860509,
-0.057437174,
0.0095143532,
0.0519708358,
-0.050322514,
0.0454131737,
2.858410583e-34,
-0.0046780994,
0.0056531429,
-0.0049765971,
-0.0256870221,
0.0332854316,
0.0199385993,
-0.0113241225,
0.0026889192,
0.0230053626,
-0.03222505,
-0.0080791349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01767v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01767v2 | PPTC Benchmark: Evaluating Large Language Models for PowerPoint Task Completion | 2023-11-03T08:06:35 | 2023-11-07T10:13:34 | Yiduo Guo, Zekai Zhang, Yaobo Liang, Dongyan Zhao, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent evaluations of Large Language Models (LLMs) have centered around
testing their zero-shot/few-shot capabilities for basic natural language tasks
and their ability to translate instructions into tool APIs. However, the
evaluation of LLMs utilizing complex tools to finish multi-turn, multi-modal
instructions in a complex multi-modal environment has not been investigated. To
address this gap, we introduce the PowerPoint Task Completion (PPTC) benchmark
to assess LLMs' ability to create and edit PPT files based on user
instructions. It contains 279 multi-turn sessions covering diverse topics and
hundreds of instructions involving multi-modal operations. We also propose the
PPTX-Match Evaluation System that evaluates if LLMs finish the instruction
based on the prediction file rather than the label API sequence, thus it
supports various LLM-generated API sequences. We measure 3 closed LLMs and 6
open-source LLMs. The results show that GPT-4 outperforms other LLMs with
75.1\% accuracy in single-turn dialogue testing but faces challenges in
completing entire sessions, achieving just 6\% session accuracy. We find three
main error causes in our benchmark: error accumulation in the multi-turn
session, long PPT template processing, and multi-modality perception. These
pose great challenges for future LLM and agent systems. We release the data,
code, and evaluation system of PPTC at \url{https://github.com/gydpku/PPTC}. | [
0.010839886,
0.0196665768,
-0.0100551145,
0.026685264,
-0.0585985929,
-0.0087704398,
-0.0030067698,
0.0039673829,
-0.0086009298,
-0.0382579863,
-0.0467139781,
-0.0384862795,
0.0124290567,
0.0144235529,
0.0093013076,
-0.1061821058,
0.0554089807,
-0.0204766206,
-0.0113953361,
0.0281401128,
-0.0057594688,
-0.0025991884,
-0.0449846871,
0.0857276469,
0.0055369558,
-0.0346885771,
-0.0385626405,
0.0004635,
-0.0076714768,
-0.0235801749,
-0.0382602923,
0.0578736067,
0.0148190036,
0.0585145243,
0.0000020485,
-0.0426270589,
0.0146151818,
0.0048793927,
-0.013685992,
0.0082995119,
0.0227075294,
0.0339546092,
-0.0124789709,
0.0144479796,
-0.0026736069,
-0.0281351507,
0.0215764269,
0.0545621552,
0.0515039936,
0.0673162937,
0.0009583135,
0.030730553,
0.0407161824,
-0.0290367641,
0.0271395575,
-0.0693555549,
-0.0030270766,
-0.0146039557,
0.061694473,
-0.0085061342,
0.008265934,
0.0207971409,
0.0243996102,
-0.023107931,
-0.0676027387,
0.0394502617,
-0.0214870721,
-0.0318501927,
-0.0331685282,
0.0791146606,
-0.0123392306,
0.0453608222,
0.0073827142,
-0.0244166534,
0.0035695741,
-0.0270451605,
-0.0608082972,
0.0000512132,
-0.0327324122,
-0.0240648426,
-0.0177208763,
-0.0145185227,
0.021634113,
-0.0069097765,
0.0133821229,
0.0683597252,
0.033583466,
-0.0316844359,
0.0104725966,
-0.011141046,
-0.0214727875,
-0.0595172867,
0.0192787163,
0.0221047569,
-0.0750019774,
0.0188466534,
-0.0606155358,
0.0124103567,
0.0061066835,
-0.035099525,
0.0334163532,
0.0676159188,
-0.0166422278,
0.0625507012,
0.0099499989,
0.0925567672,
-0.0371344984,
0.0090446938,
-0.0298628602,
-0.0160388257,
-0.0604974665,
0.0210702904,
-0.0557123832,
0.0158095285,
-0.0481071137,
-0.0441876538,
-0.0247658268,
0.0498048142,
-0.0021627506,
0.0571817122,
0.0229354072,
-0.0267411694,
-0.0302301589,
-0.0332097635,
-0.0365002565,
0.0698758215,
-0.00981542,
-0.0030602571,
-0.0015551085,
-0.0506947376,
-0.0107520754,
0.0282873455,
0.001917611,
-0.0200967658,
-0.009807338,
0.0907504484,
-0.0335008651,
-0.0323711783,
-0.0165023506,
-0.0464943983,
-0.0106793027,
-0.0800624043,
-0.0380837508,
-0.0522846729,
0.0442573503,
0.0215774942,
-0.02548532,
-0.0192218795,
0.0283990782,
0.0260313246,
-0.008467067,
0.0505499728,
0.025929397,
0.0314934254,
0.0210715998,
0.0256796647,
-0.1027454138,
0.0529785939,
0.0385889485,
0.0545337088,
0.0288450979,
-0.0230476148,
0.0370230153,
0.090798147,
-0.0450139567,
-0.0251291934,
0.0468538254,
0.0075109988,
0.0464387499,
0.0182800572,
0.0149937999,
0.0502526574,
-0.0286161043,
0.0231538676,
0.0724475682,
0.018212311,
0.0023989708,
-0.0041327961,
0.0444523096,
0.0310190748,
0.0005240427,
0.0072720316,
-0.0652181804,
0.0057668327,
-0.0234640893,
0.007836706,
0.0488696247,
-0.0133423945,
-0.0351707563,
-0.0104766283,
0.0016022562,
-0.0056815278,
-0.0198501013,
-0.0254303012,
0.0498344824,
-0.0240819454,
-0.1147681251,
0.0495501682,
0.0041831913,
-0.0435622819,
-0.0203574952,
-0.0382745937,
-0.0128226718,
0.0848081335,
0.054824125,
-0.0159821026,
-0.0292946789,
-0.0182694588,
-0.0097873947,
0.043366041,
0.0548598506,
0.0037601825,
0.025949521,
-0.0435878187,
-0.0394407213,
-0.0065651718,
-0.0098770009,
0.0476667173,
0.0169535279,
0.0049621579,
0.0098172855,
-0.0266972817,
0.0463750251,
0.0124337077,
-0.0062954566,
-0.0486363657,
-0.0093383761,
-0.0031643801,
0.0594199896,
0.0064679538,
-0.0240652096,
-0.0056883716,
0.0140404934,
-0.0040067062,
0.000317941,
0.0230766106,
-0.0680109486,
-0.000586339,
0.0412376747,
0.0005289792,
-0.021301588,
0.002616484,
-0.0108482139,
-0.0540068597,
-0.0045932946,
-0.0449900404,
0.0296826754,
-0.0173390154,
0.0574637689,
0.0172691327,
-0.0061036833,
0.0093844142,
0.0470222645,
-0.007858322,
0.0175458789,
0.0425267294,
0.0201896764,
0.0221602619,
-0.076760821,
-0.0247869287,
0.0340827852,
-0.0100582549,
-0.032430701,
0.0007504134,
0.0051835105,
-0.0491178632,
-0.0520830937,
-0.1348970979,
0.0248619877,
-0.0172691736,
0.0184007548,
0.0001415758,
0.0103874635,
-0.0259514526,
-0.0116992947,
-0.0004710025,
-0.0133530218,
0.014621079,
0.0187125579,
-0.0059698122,
0.022074569,
-0.027069943,
-0.0517316721,
0.0075198864,
-0.0043967306,
-0.0040046363,
-0.006558348,
-0.0278228242,
-0.0553930104,
0.068365328,
0.0159858912,
0.0402356982,
-0.0137015106,
-0.0068873889,
0.0396996699,
-0.0248827823,
0.0854443833,
0.0326303765,
-0.0161700379,
-0.0087397778,
0.0220643673,
-0.0646105111,
-0.0637806132,
0.0512332655,
0.003303854,
-0.0161928087,
-0.0179619361,
-0.0079710968,
0.0075945281,
0.0620509982,
0.0146776102,
0.0623594187,
-0.0479780994,
-0.0539028645,
-0.0083723012,
-0.0290684793,
0.023106277,
-0.0280156843,
-0.0433833301,
-0.0133100227,
-0.0387229286,
-0.0556214415,
0.0316697955,
-0.0798895136,
-0.0295835901,
0.0022842844,
0.0081825741,
0.0029123949,
0.0881383866,
0.050114017,
-0.0125996852,
-0.0437677056,
-0.0433770902,
-0.0335473791,
-0.0079733329,
-0.0005920992,
-0.0236336067,
0.0270718839,
-0.0932844728,
0.0031265568,
-0.040836446,
-0.033370439,
-0.0298761539,
-0.0338204429,
-0.0294422023,
0.0085235005,
0.0240547657,
-0.0293063987,
-0.0427639037,
0.0256784223,
0.0593566783,
0.0572441518,
0.0053110938,
-0.0117899692,
-0.0482734069,
0.0077630025,
0.0256512482,
0.0201633479,
-0.0378041938,
-0.0382275172,
0.0201434363,
0.033853367,
0.0609516501,
-0.0092375232,
-0.0267700776,
-0.0106739569,
0.0120385084,
-0.0372112878,
-0.0588329956,
0.0335993879,
0.0612794049,
-0.0667133331,
0.0336075798,
0.1146525368,
0.0363857858,
-0.0562017113,
-0.0328101143,
-0.0056974445,
0.0000911543,
0.0154144466,
0.029501114,
-0.0816867128,
-0.0478967205,
0.0223430935,
0.0229251273,
0.0159129929,
-0.0259312335,
-0.0108864252,
-0.1182129905,
0.0520699434,
-0.0052037928,
-0.0132953105,
-0.027401669,
-0.0215011798,
0.0274100192,
0.014455054,
0.0189710818,
0.015956128,
0.0170663632,
-0.0260920636,
0.0121698678,
-0.0313566998,
-0.0240890663,
0.0584184304,
-0.0310826544,
0.027666064,
0.089510791,
0.0176754836,
0.0095253214,
-0.0281980038,
0.0242122039,
0.0349980071,
0.0038561057,
-0.0008213732,
0.0304831006,
0.0049305204,
0.0054644323,
0.0059825899,
0.0233649742,
-0.0116308238,
-0.0306269266,
0.0281360224,
0.0679903552,
-0.0465089753,
-0.0078798216,
0.0035066311,
0.0031682861,
0.0047033965,
0.0661069378,
0.0115109552,
-0.0327797942,
-0.0402522758,
-0.0234379862,
-0.0015732223,
-0.0575588197,
0.0110934442,
-0.0144835468,
0.0050145844,
0.0248959288,
-0.0325204432,
-0.0430714898,
0.0683073625,
0.032769464,
-0.0171013512,
-0.0035911866,
-0.0054408736,
0.0360046253,
-0.0197171513,
0.0218963809,
-0.0120655447,
0.0235804264,
-0.0986726061,
-0.0460048877,
0.0312555507,
-0.0007173516,
-0.0007555818,
0.0492638312,
-0.0735146031,
-0.0452927537,
0.009939705,
0.0419090837,
0.0235194732,
0.0211985931,
-0.0057318662,
-0.0328856222,
0.0101512522,
0.0321538821,
-0.0411390737,
0.0102893719,
0.0136324102,
0.0316869132,
-0.0140049895,
0.0249223039,
-0.0579891019,
-0.0180475749,
-0.0187076759,
0.0500288047,
0.0018996781,
-0.0702162087,
-0.008566333,
0.0367199741,
0.0192609765,
0.0002175664,
0.0035746014,
-0.0095514618,
0.0308045428,
-0.0282080192,
0.0005110102,
-0.0610222742,
-0.018417215,
-0.0067845755,
-0.0213788375,
0.0263248328,
0.0112767881,
-0.0295040756,
-0.0057178428,
-0.0281698629,
-0.0142964646,
0.0136286076,
-0.0183855221,
0.0233878046,
0.0001653348,
-0.0133197578,
0.0059392964,
0.007353296,
0.0281163082,
-0.0224443134,
0.1124428436,
-0.0109317154,
-0.0042445762,
0.0006102301,
0.0414814912,
-0.0494591035,
-0.0528929457,
-0.024462698,
0.0497247837,
0.0539709367,
0.0046747797,
0.0450232066,
-0.0648433939,
0.0013945173,
-0.0310129747,
0.0459526964,
0.0162784029,
-0.0370506011,
0.0211940017,
0.0330147892,
0.0020582983,
0.0107930526,
0.0766140297,
-0.040015582,
0.0463229567,
0.0029530146,
-0.0073776534,
-0.0575787947,
-0.0334415771,
0.0175215434,
-0.001811531,
-0.0257009044,
-0.0094209807,
-0.057611201,
-0.0133625967,
-0.0016818615,
0.0251159631,
-0.0223040283,
-0.0240182616,
0.0575591885,
0.0573464036,
-0.0048998138,
-0.0372990966,
-0.0191159081,
-0.0046198154,
0.0279510114,
-0.0086193839,
-0.0378559381,
-5.66522927e-33,
-0.0654431283,
-0.0235250425,
0.0445449837,
0.0291931201,
-0.0056265402,
-0.0306884702,
-0.0457770638,
0.0367324054,
0.0272056852,
-0.0251215734,
-0.0174754132,
-0.0232288726,
0.027214326,
0.0229515899,
-0.0047788816,
0.0110586407,
0.0615545288,
-0.0241925139,
-0.0333855003,
0.0332775228,
0.0069380603,
-0.0158873163,
0.0217108894,
-0.0869993046,
0.0073978165,
0.0198273305,
-0.0130725913,
0.0004433881,
-0.0050945212,
0.0654433519,
0.0035530771,
0.0203908477,
0.0061614136,
-0.0300099459,
-0.0356859677,
0.0286769997,
-0.0150322737,
-0.0212434568,
0.003938314,
0.034407828,
-0.0391643904,
-0.0187266842,
0.0280128438,
-0.002920395,
-0.0114128916,
0.0197596923,
0.0126856631,
0.0084248213,
-0.0236585755,
0.0356077068,
-0.0429560468,
0.0256408881,
0.0074074608,
-0.0624236092,
0.0015062897,
0.0199280754,
0.0207662154,
-0.010038198,
-0.0599124283,
-0.0001862905,
0.0222697929,
0.0348759182,
0.0799692944,
0.0056643127,
0.0159958825,
0.0310677867,
0.0420897305,
0.0166818984,
0.003732984,
-0.0107496809,
0.0072638188,
0.0639444217,
0.014572897,
0.011640748,
-0.0009382297,
0.0434746146,
0.0204294231,
0.0614867881,
0.0494729318,
0.0447985083,
0.0310726073,
0.016140474,
-0.0250467882,
0.0219405107,
-0.0435641594,
0.0001161203,
-0.0250893701,
-0.0335313529,
0.0456883349,
0.0217891764,
0.0722113028,
-0.0069047813,
0.0811683238,
0.007530326,
-0.0112709077,
-0.0150395026,
-0.0508556962,
0.0556985289,
0.0043396447,
0.0097418465,
-0.0431805514,
-0.0242915191,
0.0371061601,
0.0150417322,
0.0174939223,
0.0091126608,
-0.0564879067,
0.0584462583,
-0.0835097209,
0.0160625204,
-0.0386029519,
0.0166384727,
-0.0193623211,
0.0051284414,
0.0473891497,
-0.0329953656,
-0.036236763,
0.0413993299,
-0.026678782,
-0.0274876654,
-0.0308734681,
-0.0435578749,
0.002254179,
-0.0065207821,
-0.0262342244,
0.0235292707,
-0.0278269332,
-0.0127725899,
0.0041925227,
0.0060896152,
0.0049499664,
0.0030322552,
2.783e-7,
0.0088378908,
0.0412234701,
0.0132188378,
0.0548082404,
0.0108530531,
0.0377516635,
-0.0377395675,
0.0238430481,
0.0001593161,
-0.0035520596,
0.0258125663,
-0.0006481046,
0.0493059047,
0.0516597405,
-0.0969736576,
-0.0119353691,
-0.011135865,
0.0261227563,
-0.072970815,
0.0020122849,
0.0663131922,
0.0884363279,
-0.0012528527,
0.0091856597,
0.0253041517,
-0.0558794923,
0.0758798718,
-0.0332811587,
-0.0262780525,
0.0028879391,
0.0163862426,
0.023190761,
-0.0139547829,
0.0197591595,
-0.0023483431,
0.0041569113,
0.0192515124,
0.0890637115,
0.0017855453,
-0.048661489,
0.0050147637,
-0.0185796879,
-0.0095977644,
-0.0224613696,
0.0459789038,
-0.0413372964,
-0.0120342579,
0.0133050494,
-0.0322396345,
-0.0207639281,
-0.0135236569,
0.007470442,
-0.0181166753,
0.0248644724,
0.0073096612,
-0.0265327282,
-0.0394547209,
-0.0401185937,
-0.0170840379,
-0.0247352943,
-0.0539278351,
-0.0460792445,
-0.0610433705,
-0.0449736752,
-0.0053842296,
-0.035998065,
-0.0232097749,
2.65200755e-34,
0.0131383101,
-0.018547127,
0.0228279792,
0.0133678028,
0.0447920486,
0.0290127229,
0.0081101265,
0.0314797647,
0.0161968768,
-0.0762290135,
-0.0305958837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01766v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01766v4 | Support or Refute: Analyzing the Stance of Evidence to Detect Out-of-Context Mis- and Disinformation | 2023-11-03T08:05:54 | 2023-12-09T16:34:35 | Xin Yuan, Jie Guo, Weidong Qiu, Zheng Huang, Shujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Mis- and disinformation online have become a major societal problem as major
sources of online harms of different kinds. One common form of mis- and
disinformation is out-of-context (OOC) information, where different pieces of
information are falsely associated, e.g., a real image combined with a false
textual caption or a misleading textual description. Although some past studies
have attempted to defend against OOC mis- and disinformation through external
evidence, they tend to disregard the role of different pieces of evidence with
different stances. Motivated by the intuition that the stance of evidence
represents a bias towards different detection results, we propose a stance
extraction network (SEN) that can extract the stances of different pieces of
multi-modal evidence in a unified framework. Moreover, we introduce a
support-refutation score calculated based on the co-occurrence relations of
named entities into the textual SEN. Extensive experiments on a public
large-scale dataset demonstrated that our proposed method outperformed the
state-of-the-art baselines, with the best model achieving a performance gain of
3.2% in accuracy. | [
0.0209499206,
0.0216979161,
0.0075276457,
0.0528194346,
-0.0564347096,
0.0326064862,
0.0045989696,
-0.0005503999,
-0.0184368417,
-0.0536155067,
0.001088956,
-0.0184489358,
0.0094283838,
0.0623410232,
-0.0061384295,
-0.0260110162,
0.05335024,
0.0760352835,
0.0828858912,
0.0036382754,
0.0465680584,
0.0410705768,
-0.0453703962,
0.0386527777,
-0.0221183263,
-0.0544024743,
0.0441564955,
-0.0164987743,
0.0859657601,
-0.0602032505,
0.0118974932,
0.0114971539,
0.0319784805,
0.0577149652,
0.0000016557,
-0.0300749149,
-0.0001702086,
0.0044354512,
-0.0280733388,
-0.0165783409,
0.0079085464,
-0.0002702378,
-0.003935019,
0.0133233937,
-0.0341615193,
0.0273232665,
0.0554216988,
0.0847546533,
0.06199947,
0.0856648088,
-0.0089249704,
-0.013890014,
0.013788959,
0.002334343,
-0.0094320849,
0.0255110469,
0.0292941909,
-0.0142175462,
-0.0671095103,
0.0659230947,
0.0091917785,
0.0130724106,
0.0158262718,
0.0211458504,
-0.0587931573,
0.0401959084,
-0.0255996715,
-0.0437476523,
0.0017702717,
0.0754122287,
0.0235648844,
-0.0197885782,
0.0163462348,
-0.0274438635,
0.0199694205,
0.070047237,
-0.015624783,
0.0329266377,
-0.0379818827,
0.0298922602,
-0.0065878355,
0.0015871376,
0.0317937732,
0.0391667224,
0.0262558125,
0.0180454552,
-0.0270468146,
-0.0148720415,
0.0176576003,
-0.000977298,
-0.0197655242,
-0.0200590435,
0.0167212654,
-0.0204907227,
0.0185507406,
0.0323475376,
-0.0299396869,
-0.0161363501,
0.0464568436,
-0.0877818689,
-0.0209254064,
-0.0313308872,
-0.0422905013,
0.0583830811,
0.0023034823,
-0.0350699909,
-0.0310905129,
-0.0207688585,
0.034589842,
0.0180017911,
-0.0365408994,
0.0293318126,
0.0284205973,
0.0175821111,
-0.036629945,
-0.0133293597,
-0.0422201008,
-0.029656481,
-0.0557663217,
0.0125061329,
-0.0184982847,
0.0073979809,
0.0050292099,
-0.0220132209,
-0.0271550938,
0.065438211,
-0.0043165246,
0.046584405,
-0.0060205664,
-0.0215664189,
0.0066366345,
0.0431052521,
-0.0075929998,
-0.0164586697,
0.0160213038,
0.0182488989,
0.0416053496,
0.0013233385,
0.0037483971,
-0.0656518936,
-0.0739989057,
-0.0506164655,
-0.0071615013,
-0.0672566593,
-0.0055667325,
-0.0239233281,
-0.0118531156,
-0.0350165032,
-0.00146363,
0.0324889719,
-0.0513801873,
0.0292397346,
-0.0273745283,
-0.0565587059,
0.0378731601,
0.0416441448,
0.0142025296,
0.0571275614,
-0.0137745058,
0.0607775003,
0.0521060489,
0.0498566628,
-0.0323650911,
-0.0156653207,
0.0715539828,
0.009757271,
0.0231574439,
0.0144803105,
-0.0154280942,
-0.0352250636,
-0.0220685434,
0.026959233,
-0.0316661745,
-0.0754787177,
0.0518515147,
-0.0408247188,
-0.0132189672,
-0.0144452732,
0.009049871,
0.0028421956,
0.011315885,
-0.0270462837,
-0.05563711,
0.0247478317,
-0.0223179255,
-0.0254297331,
-0.0097765671,
0.0798239782,
0.006893334,
-0.023598019,
-0.0011091493,
-0.0046179332,
-0.0118966261,
-0.0037324084,
0.0020243581,
0.0161552634,
-0.0448246151,
0.016132297,
0.0507894158,
-0.0079706507,
-0.0169559941,
-0.0175879784,
0.0193897653,
-0.0066174474,
0.026252294,
-0.0287991092,
-0.0280316491,
-0.0409741849,
0.0052334876,
0.0216827542,
0.0022321453,
-0.0206535794,
0.0000932406,
0.0020827542,
-0.0347042456,
-0.036664512,
0.0121723479,
0.0031129434,
0.0086897258,
0.0302875098,
0.0190167353,
0.016499998,
0.0199489444,
0.0264937375,
0.0590618216,
0.0229761526,
-0.0181243885,
0.0297178607,
0.0686282292,
0.053537745,
-0.0251159277,
-0.0249745995,
0.0726839155,
-0.004539879,
-0.0268475711,
0.0081658345,
-0.0405676924,
-0.0468259566,
0.055334013,
-0.0762028769,
-0.0658806935,
0.0020569253,
-0.0249888748,
0.0292053055,
0.0081877355,
-0.0287473965,
-0.0195371341,
-0.0433950946,
-0.0521694496,
-0.0256731398,
0.0285845231,
0.0085950084,
0.0932253152,
-0.0380193852,
-0.0190591104,
0.0144166034,
-0.0303955022,
0.0218434408,
-0.0024990623,
-0.0037226914,
-0.01636618,
-0.0082583651,
-0.0138631063,
0.0231329277,
-0.0320507362,
-0.0418211967,
0.0301042926,
-0.0678714663,
-0.007879938,
-0.0068606595,
0.0286355913,
0.056681551,
-0.0311068352,
0.0057022381,
-0.0070812074,
-0.020101564,
0.0020808859,
-0.0135346577,
0.034028627,
0.0165525544,
-0.0129562197,
-0.0194721725,
-0.0074594533,
0.0024004567,
-0.0177338347,
0.0306390543,
0.0404639356,
-0.0574316308,
-0.0390985273,
-0.0157037787,
-0.0509084985,
-0.0068861498,
-0.0297684614,
0.0166325849,
0.0357523486,
0.0375432074,
-0.0151436087,
0.0066583268,
0.0390923321,
0.0369122364,
0.0371008925,
0.0216185637,
-0.0371603742,
-0.0446368717,
-0.0468168408,
0.0785962492,
0.0100363819,
-0.0312502384,
0.0348012298,
0.022073986,
0.0388624668,
0.0135164699,
-0.0036277492,
0.0018651723,
-0.0000816584,
-0.0426582955,
-0.0091325594,
-0.0457526296,
-0.0168531667,
0.008911239,
-0.0288491286,
-0.020840738,
0.0851448625,
-0.0153663512,
0.0522410274,
-0.0330677107,
-0.001412264,
0.0088925855,
-0.0008712829,
0.0093438225,
0.0278880205,
0.0539894626,
0.0024809097,
0.0257686563,
-0.0192389302,
0.0384679399,
-0.026562782,
-0.0022550831,
-0.0220416915,
0.0121052861,
0.0156513825,
-0.0298762731,
-0.0213422645,
-0.0839735493,
-0.0090038544,
-0.0257705096,
-0.0371595062,
0.0055048079,
-0.0490072817,
-0.0300381165,
0.0233137831,
-0.0166759938,
0.0145713529,
0.0002305719,
0.0198096745,
0.0186621714,
0.0205307398,
-0.0238686837,
0.0539387576,
-0.0074063786,
-0.0190962013,
0.1012446806,
-0.0540108457,
-0.0018375602,
-0.0192386787,
-0.0391086489,
-0.045569554,
0.0105671417,
0.0171025414,
0.0021705127,
0.0606199801,
-0.014396769,
0.0049112039,
0.0625930578,
0.0123388106,
-0.0399949253,
-0.0334876329,
0.0354758427,
-0.0300718248,
0.0144302035,
-0.065544121,
-0.0861011073,
-0.030599311,
-0.0210976731,
-0.0006990352,
-0.0463247746,
-0.0235385131,
0.0016032604,
-0.0733717605,
0.0238042232,
-0.0202555191,
-0.011224892,
-0.0527962372,
-0.092372179,
0.0379327238,
-0.0045644031,
0.0223328769,
-0.0192534849,
0.0442193113,
-0.0016578744,
-0.0116610238,
-0.0026490388,
-0.0342882015,
0.0101078385,
-0.0359033234,
0.0302181169,
0.0050157285,
0.0531422533,
-0.0057254126,
-0.0258173663,
0.0022831419,
-0.0455652885,
-0.0120401271,
-0.0188206267,
0.0883494541,
-0.0391143709,
-0.0024846809,
-0.059801802,
0.0378809385,
-0.0272810087,
-0.0377498679,
-0.0034328513,
0.0831579193,
0.0143950097,
-0.0091724284,
-0.059100505,
0.0297309719,
0.0529735759,
0.0489904433,
-0.0070398003,
0.0229410604,
-0.0021293312,
-0.0054858588,
-0.0100158593,
0.0170437042,
0.005953561,
0.0200156942,
0.0026140292,
0.0142698446,
-0.0490691774,
0.0007048348,
-0.0288368724,
0.0176204871,
-0.0127673438,
-0.0226468146,
0.0369669795,
0.020009147,
-0.0482502095,
0.0112514291,
0.0000056272,
0.0581200942,
-0.0142774796,
0.0344343707,
-0.0029470173,
0.0078267464,
-0.0092234649,
0.0215952862,
-0.0155673409,
-0.0545310229,
0.0083819693,
0.0123629728,
0.0126175815,
0.0315355994,
-0.0014261726,
0.0069236415,
0.0459535643,
0.0832173228,
-0.0145152295,
-0.0166721549,
0.020642994,
-0.0122556537,
0.0112492386,
-0.0017101122,
0.0155528756,
0.0327677913,
0.0302942432,
-0.028864637,
-0.0560055524,
0.0188790411,
0.0285259541,
0.0115086306,
0.0700895712,
-0.0221172851,
-0.02234089,
-0.0606705882,
-0.0408680663,
-0.031617295,
-0.0352024473,
0.0291621275,
0.0558767542,
0.0147029739,
-0.049256932,
-0.0115212509,
0.1062968969,
-0.0325935669,
0.0160974097,
-0.0461263619,
0.0205311254,
0.0722737908,
0.0440168828,
-0.005207296,
-0.0456431359,
-0.0215078201,
-0.0159780346,
0.0021324975,
-0.0013054692,
-0.0045323758,
0.0388665795,
0.0107386839,
-0.018115256,
0.0142677426,
-0.0101135252,
-0.0308691915,
0.0498375893,
-0.0382792503,
0.0211359691,
-0.0026280293,
-0.0048803687,
0.025881717,
0.0080811847,
-0.0286110099,
0.0038189059,
-0.0106253838,
-0.045544941,
-0.0049593179,
0.0358116403,
0.019185802,
-0.0459264703,
0.0448587388,
0.0234178659,
-0.0633307323,
0.0378390364,
0.0300221127,
-0.0778253376,
-0.027422579,
-0.0117470007,
-0.0394912735,
0.0560325868,
-0.0272303503,
-0.0016677049,
-0.063563183,
-0.0391826294,
0.0021282511,
0.0261645317,
0.0275190659,
0.0539138876,
-0.0321826115,
0.0624766164,
0.042857334,
-0.010846436,
-0.0054759574,
0.0333108269,
-0.0140011273,
-0.0241909381,
-0.0267736763,
-5.933125901e-33,
0.0067508947,
-0.0567655489,
-0.0505871326,
0.0093089705,
0.0138960816,
0.050724607,
0.0062416177,
-0.0015329523,
-0.0337572582,
0.077889502,
0.056248758,
0.0594606139,
-0.0046507609,
-0.0143360244,
-0.0400723778,
0.0180293042,
0.0182014368,
-0.0263269059,
-0.0471263826,
0.0230042394,
0.0844160393,
-0.0263325721,
0.037792556,
-0.1268222183,
0.0780463293,
0.0051591201,
-0.0354617648,
0.0055031311,
0.0133986538,
0.0502175391,
-0.0120513784,
0.0442249738,
0.0627661347,
-0.0309782829,
0.0082071591,
0.0520092361,
-0.0754042566,
-0.0211467575,
0.0258887447,
-0.0338257402,
-0.0137757175,
0.0076981005,
0.0212610923,
0.0187566448,
-0.0236829836,
-0.0236469153,
0.0363753773,
-0.0056767631,
0.0220358986,
-0.0266043507,
-0.0682276487,
0.036498744,
-0.0086552789,
-0.0088961869,
-0.0508426428,
0.0459323451,
0.0370422974,
0.0279184896,
-0.0692170113,
0.0140140727,
-0.0614585541,
-0.0505137108,
-0.0037031577,
-0.0345938616,
-0.023148492,
0.0976252928,
-0.0057447357,
0.0150638353,
-0.0637758449,
-0.0063506518,
-0.0080776587,
0.0454854853,
0.0592571981,
0.1048075184,
0.0528058484,
-0.0231795944,
-0.1222539619,
0.0094083026,
0.0203875545,
0.0040375809,
0.0155426599,
-0.0293295346,
-0.0314487852,
0.0125232786,
0.0011095173,
-0.0548930913,
-0.0269371197,
0.0061375801,
-0.0234458391,
0.0260285251,
-0.0319598913,
0.0551473536,
0.0033636286,
-0.0343695916,
0.0095275864,
0.054017324,
0.0052596796,
-0.0164654162,
0.0421871096,
0.0266188346,
-0.0757363215,
0.0003357499,
0.0312496051,
0.0007395565,
0.0164804664,
-0.0373293124,
0.1167092249,
-0.0288382303,
-0.0488033518,
-0.0259672757,
-0.0238850061,
0.0098107699,
-0.0104426323,
0.0021947196,
0.0449482128,
0.0292000417,
-0.033290647,
0.0114807971,
0.0141316252,
0.0485419817,
-0.0260211509,
0.0038288189,
-0.0251983851,
0.0165482014,
-0.0249084532,
-0.0352869779,
-0.0019694599,
-0.0079528475,
-0.0007442419,
-0.0884938166,
0.0027475026,
0.0198522955,
2.534e-7,
0.0332424976,
0.0241207667,
0.0235438868,
-0.0479874089,
0.0641616732,
0.0514353476,
0.0260630697,
0.0115315644,
0.0006046448,
-0.0936588123,
-0.0179873854,
0.0279907361,
-0.0158327166,
0.0480562933,
0.0090614697,
-0.0002233391,
-0.0261428617,
-0.053235054,
-0.0394714065,
0.0070007103,
0.0101191429,
0.0423546545,
0.022061849,
-0.021958204,
-0.0140011618,
0.0073649264,
0.0544669256,
0.0092500169,
-0.0041162227,
-0.0434961915,
0.0135288248,
-0.0365162641,
0.006462309,
0.00598206,
0.0035944574,
0.0176787972,
-0.006783281,
0.032794863,
0.0077097504,
-0.0187180825,
-0.0265629422,
0.0017660656,
0.0351818465,
-0.0243285038,
0.0550124049,
-0.0472718365,
-0.0549911484,
-0.091087319,
-0.058846198,
0.0268754326,
0.0560566448,
0.0186912585,
-0.0305745732,
0.0315509848,
-0.0096250651,
0.0108534032,
-0.0281382632,
-0.0669816583,
0.0120924003,
0.0153217176,
-0.0457904302,
-0.0283951331,
0.0363603234,
-0.0497360677,
0.0439745672,
-0.0391597375,
0.026838094,
1.893154315e-34,
0.0230916589,
-0.0386801735,
0.0016949713,
-0.058964137,
0.0341177545,
-0.000331419,
-0.0500801019,
-0.0308368057,
0.0108989896,
-0.0310408212,
0.0005309972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.05640v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.05640v1 | FinGPT: Large Generative Models for a Small Language | 2023-11-03T08:05:04 | 2023-11-03T08:05:04 | Risto Luukkonen, Ville Komulainen, Jouni Luoma, Anni Eskelinen, Jenna Kanerva, Hanna-Mari Kupari, Filip Ginter, Veronika Laippala, Niklas Muennighoff, Aleksandra Piktus, Thomas Wang, Nouamane Tazi, Teven Le Scao, Thomas Wolf, Osma Suominen, Samuli Sairanen, Mikko Merioksa, Jyrki Heinonen, Aija Vahtola, Samuel Antao, Sampo Pyysalo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) excel in many tasks in NLP and beyond, but most
open models have very limited coverage of smaller languages and LLM work tends
to focus on languages where nearly unlimited data is available for pretraining.
In this work, we study the challenges of creating LLMs for Finnish, a language
spoken by less than 0.1% of the world population. We compile an extensive
dataset of Finnish combining web crawls, news, social media and eBooks. We
pursue two approaches to pretrain models: 1) we train seven monolingual models
from scratch (186M to 13B parameters) dubbed FinGPT, 2) we continue the
pretraining of the multilingual BLOOM model on a mix of its original training
data and Finnish, resulting in a 176 billion parameter model we call BLUUMI.
For model evaluation, we introduce FIN-bench, a version of BIG-bench with
Finnish tasks. We also assess other model qualities such as toxicity and bias.
Our models and tools are openly available at https://turkunlp.org/gpt3-finnish. | [
0.0323878415,
0.0851548612,
-0.0092294049,
0.027758887,
-0.0136204734,
0.0161228869,
0.0382721126,
0.0068503669,
0.0293014199,
-0.0314158052,
-0.0038351333,
-0.0651194826,
-0.0091414396,
0.0577506907,
0.0317446366,
-0.0367953852,
0.0489229672,
-0.0381315723,
-0.0400321148,
-0.0290580224,
0.0297878068,
0.0490249656,
0.0280388407,
0.0279560573,
-0.0161931328,
-0.0057562422,
0.0167673249,
0.018305555,
-0.0022299001,
0.0059816521,
-0.0121949129,
0.0371024534,
-0.0058244085,
0.069360137,
0.0000016445,
-0.0282696374,
-0.0025255133,
-0.0058059175,
0.0325280279,
0.0591965094,
0.0517310016,
-0.0302736461,
-0.0171403885,
0.0423294157,
-0.0122686205,
-0.0087867193,
0.0464324281,
0.0425915755,
0.0453032553,
0.0843231305,
-0.0133565767,
-0.0307538826,
0.0424223505,
-0.0503246747,
0.0017864144,
-0.0106467856,
0.0431159809,
-0.0260300748,
-0.0186973792,
0.0023565749,
-0.0333132669,
0.0565031841,
0.0233909972,
0.0110702487,
-0.0272909533,
0.0470468104,
-0.0004117858,
-0.0332915634,
0.0176133867,
0.0625800416,
-0.0671075359,
-0.0391940698,
0.0087194806,
-0.0098569971,
-0.0244917758,
-0.0192701928,
-0.0294125117,
0.0142407464,
0.009901952,
0.0382948965,
0.0509075969,
-0.0260368492,
0.0491424203,
0.0187331308,
0.0048372857,
0.0118828285,
0.0380448811,
-0.0018501405,
0.0023069892,
0.0149627421,
0.0146583477,
-0.024577409,
0.010451559,
-0.0132155977,
-0.0260845069,
0.0128634498,
-0.0303056668,
-0.0585094653,
0.0663535148,
-0.0782606304,
0.0055971034,
-0.0177330822,
-0.015043024,
0.0474654064,
-0.0399614945,
-0.0220924336,
-0.0296107903,
-0.0267249979,
-0.0376362391,
-0.0365533531,
-0.0019544328,
0.0090477588,
-0.0500818603,
-0.0254891049,
-0.0451321788,
0.0083421944,
-0.0385413021,
-0.009484278,
0.0030878822,
-0.0147103621,
0.0310563557,
-0.0269848164,
-0.0430830158,
0.008989918,
0.0243785083,
0.0074640326,
-0.0675593317,
0.0134685645,
-0.0229034722,
-0.0807472616,
0.0034695913,
0.0224905647,
0.0192114897,
-0.0508360788,
0.0200574547,
0.0202811919,
-0.0130765662,
-0.0369048715,
-0.0600406192,
-0.0182735007,
0.009622056,
-0.0531442128,
-0.0310800821,
-0.0868715942,
0.0341694355,
-0.0153974202,
0.0373693034,
-0.0464808755,
0.0010558314,
0.0090881819,
-0.0293025691,
0.0468428582,
0.0216295756,
0.0148784313,
-0.0072330702,
-0.0133225424,
0.0381153971,
0.0990203619,
-0.0187190045,
0.0399129689,
0.0731372908,
-0.0140544958,
0.0425921306,
0.0917456299,
0.0231082626,
0.0456555933,
0.0392961763,
0.0039842571,
0.0041149775,
0.0116575621,
0.0592461936,
0.0478777438,
-0.020745283,
-0.0157071035,
0.0591823757,
0.0252338909,
0.0202723425,
0.0631319657,
0.0643773526,
-0.0066439388,
-0.0070310468,
-0.0419739299,
0.0042699012,
-0.0166347325,
-0.0333884656,
0.0103363125,
0.0801550671,
0.0509203151,
-0.0286807772,
-0.0312340558,
0.009830785,
0.0130911469,
-0.0291716401,
0.0027897924,
0.0550884008,
-0.0087164519,
-0.0362173431,
0.0142239863,
0.0386122055,
-0.0341384038,
0.0653187037,
-0.0258974675,
0.0218920652,
0.0451027043,
0.0582497194,
-0.0116353864,
0.0298108626,
-0.0288563129,
0.0009440347,
0.0288605262,
0.0340893157,
-0.0326849893,
0.0240470711,
-0.0391113646,
0.0143035948,
0.0043134484,
0.0123712225,
0.0406075157,
0.0442316867,
0.0273611397,
0.008492073,
-0.058563482,
-0.0461833812,
0.0140139014,
-0.0523363203,
-0.008229346,
-0.0017026366,
-0.0051994515,
0.0316542871,
0.0163186938,
-0.0354430154,
0.0021673371,
0.0255200285,
-0.0705250204,
-0.010945078,
-0.0112141818,
0.0271920208,
-0.0174092576,
0.0476065688,
-0.033995524,
-0.0141453138,
0.0387686677,
-0.0562299378,
-0.0386294387,
0.0437856577,
0.0023858224,
0.0385459587,
-0.0357107446,
-0.0163016487,
0.0004405557,
0.0597282834,
-0.0050475141,
0.0348864272,
-0.0034568179,
0.0307684354,
-0.0381369106,
-0.0211305451,
0.0224816184,
-0.0644886717,
-0.0645918101,
0.0587205254,
-0.0155996336,
0.0332547687,
0.0100681437,
-0.0034768127,
-0.0261529125,
0.013426587,
-0.0998764262,
0.0272376798,
-0.0442446135,
0.0081995567,
0.0148644466,
0.0162585787,
-0.018222006,
-0.0134978751,
-0.0499890149,
-0.0064447345,
0.0183603689,
0.0442891642,
-0.0043627252,
-0.0220368616,
0.0076672318,
-0.0422281027,
-0.061175324,
0.0117237121,
0.0682095066,
-0.0012892556,
-0.0514144264,
-0.0250963625,
0.015517639,
-0.0372855105,
0.0144333802,
-0.0225227494,
-0.0396788195,
-0.0067370776,
-0.0591026284,
0.0857247934,
0.0362132862,
-0.0047307527,
-0.0090855658,
0.0225851778,
-0.0166839324,
-0.038330663,
-0.0106843775,
-0.0309205987,
-0.023883909,
-0.0419423133,
-0.0345712565,
0.0105695911,
0.0347742178,
-0.0347768217,
-0.040380422,
-0.0392112322,
-0.0054367301,
-0.0476777479,
-0.0269183032,
-0.0447905101,
0.0445660912,
0.0132997772,
0.0454202592,
-0.0026651861,
-0.0372987166,
0.0360285453,
-0.0175391342,
0.0233536568,
-0.0476055443,
-0.0065460699,
-0.0447743945,
0.0633092672,
0.011295408,
0.0406682342,
-0.0319779776,
-0.0084052654,
-0.0185031891,
0.0406924002,
0.0342602767,
-0.0208171085,
0.0441428795,
0.004839933,
0.0165601354,
-0.0186687447,
-0.0442385487,
-0.0279011298,
-0.0732696578,
-0.0278953034,
-0.0055181631,
0.0326228403,
-0.0187557079,
-0.0751876906,
-0.0041265422,
0.0100328568,
0.0169182774,
0.0121640535,
-0.0022525131,
0.0008141389,
0.0395645499,
0.0614003725,
-0.0485744327,
0.021206744,
-0.0155673185,
-0.0048543392,
0.0485762767,
0.0108517697,
0.0180607531,
-0.0098477593,
0.0003817279,
0.050504759,
-0.0297618937,
-0.0125629054,
-0.0198900588,
0.0378073789,
0.0003101374,
-0.0127613014,
0.0702667534,
0.0118731316,
-0.0128041403,
0.0094001815,
0.010746005,
0.048718337,
0.0210112203,
0.0357596241,
-0.0833687633,
0.0005095646,
0.0032082151,
0.0173149686,
-0.0100175384,
-0.0163963269,
-0.0159214083,
-0.1365467012,
0.0019794353,
0.0271971934,
-0.0242286548,
-0.0194968022,
-0.0754256696,
-0.018660957,
-0.0689888448,
-0.0107915327,
-0.0127574475,
-0.0174266212,
0.0258218497,
-0.0174556896,
0.0177733917,
-0.0768510476,
0.0127031235,
-0.0361665674,
0.0376958735,
0.0170766208,
0.0064425073,
-0.0127338106,
0.0222096648,
0.0354764871,
-0.0052450965,
-0.0468824953,
-0.0131014539,
0.0366818793,
0.0089474386,
-0.0074228076,
-0.006054596,
0.0224959776,
-0.0236153621,
-0.0174592845,
-0.0047006626,
0.0559821986,
0.0625637844,
-0.0432992391,
-0.0043605971,
-0.0109250974,
0.0022454665,
0.0575830936,
0.0319652744,
-0.0197047964,
-0.0337789319,
-0.0386768319,
-0.0214170255,
-0.0498180874,
-0.0497218482,
0.0086677251,
-0.0049869609,
-0.0265103746,
-0.0882963389,
-0.0140278907,
0.031960804,
0.0335777774,
0.0032658011,
0.0034380918,
-0.0284125376,
-0.0210671034,
-0.0297353752,
0.0425032787,
-0.0262896251,
0.0217137728,
-0.0786797106,
-0.0084963758,
0.0684943274,
-0.0314512849,
-0.0232759248,
0.0661613271,
-0.0815050825,
-0.0700432137,
-0.0066129295,
0.0461079106,
0.0236280654,
0.0204225797,
-0.0250181705,
-0.0865056217,
0.0536809601,
0.0637081861,
0.0061371392,
0.0106307091,
0.0287029594,
-0.0261569824,
0.004034115,
0.0424677357,
-0.0349918418,
0.0439321175,
0.0076523782,
0.0359153673,
-0.0150537034,
0.0289491881,
0.0053717047,
0.0305628777,
0.0372111648,
-0.0656345636,
-0.004392569,
-0.108502686,
-0.0327884033,
0.01029664,
-0.0189699437,
-0.0187557321,
0.002197647,
0.0754546896,
0.0105109736,
-0.0502804294,
0.0399382114,
-0.0056632725,
0.0425898731,
-0.055319421,
-0.0130964452,
0.0317155644,
-0.0164201055,
0.0351658538,
0.0033569389,
-0.0021277668,
0.030868683,
-0.0072892234,
0.0296585131,
-0.0357190147,
0.0011913658,
-0.0022113244,
0.0035613948,
-0.0124691892,
0.0115713123,
-0.0501258038,
-0.0209106226,
-0.0411027782,
0.0130143473,
0.0824543536,
-0.0162781104,
0.0796124637,
-0.0294968728,
-0.0253875982,
-0.0319919586,
0.0382888019,
-0.0056720991,
-0.0392371789,
0.0010481107,
0.016540423,
-0.0469349362,
0.0385737456,
0.0944364294,
0.0182225257,
0.0466013104,
0.0152527168,
0.0084195733,
-0.0230767522,
-0.0177691933,
-0.0226687901,
0.0184595678,
-0.0251310337,
-0.0053832126,
-0.0494849011,
-0.0707249716,
0.0041829194,
0.0236676242,
0.0131308408,
0.0394242145,
0.0166795086,
0.0451101176,
0.0152994692,
0.0510697253,
-0.0742785856,
0.0144520467,
-0.0262398813,
-0.045251485,
-0.0323593467,
-6.087886712e-33,
0.018850131,
0.0193925016,
-0.0251993891,
-0.0209813248,
-0.0018106215,
0.0087356362,
-0.013345425,
-0.002066324,
-0.0188870598,
-0.0091085378,
-0.0150548816,
0.0017899602,
0.0079935146,
0.0279788654,
-0.0249112379,
-0.0034666364,
0.0699406788,
0.0068885372,
-0.0042033591,
0.0499431901,
0.0385602824,
0.0147153568,
0.0459763706,
-0.0384509116,
0.000018626,
-0.0284849238,
-0.0380757824,
0.0029668687,
0.0068094572,
0.0621258467,
-0.0358539782,
0.079448618,
0.007701104,
-0.0268197954,
-0.0062851459,
-0.0097941747,
-0.0855934545,
-0.0028976258,
0.0159272905,
0.0099087013,
0.0029580682,
-0.018757835,
0.0169408675,
-0.0170189682,
0.0171877388,
0.0033805617,
0.0412651971,
-0.0016979092,
-0.0136131607,
-0.0606372766,
-0.0474559627,
0.0279183332,
-0.0008182859,
0.0264330674,
0.0236471929,
0.0426667035,
0.0234823041,
0.0343258344,
-0.0324120931,
0.0322913527,
0.0213704407,
0.0236853454,
0.0527164191,
-0.0054215016,
0.0135961743,
0.0644642711,
0.0130507043,
0.0129991351,
-0.0052807885,
0.0026914675,
0.0296522286,
0.0164303947,
0.0337827913,
0.0951330364,
0.0224489104,
-0.0277495943,
-0.0783946887,
0.020490272,
0.0563290939,
0.0009882213,
0.0136637902,
-0.0053260494,
-0.0132702906,
-0.0145812761,
-0.0532524474,
-0.0706473365,
-0.0276115835,
-0.0031964551,
0.0234627686,
0.023342127,
-0.0141070066,
0.0088008437,
0.0403117575,
-0.0383762158,
-0.0353840515,
0.0277444646,
0.0035628853,
0.0307954513,
-0.0086138044,
0.0307796169,
-0.0353525244,
-0.0515645146,
0.0115694618,
-0.0486304127,
0.0186967421,
-0.0202462915,
0.0562379733,
0.010848484,
-0.0532406531,
0.0175045114,
-0.0354282223,
0.0451520048,
0.0071893232,
0.0377444923,
0.0405419581,
0.0183021463,
-0.008208734,
0.0124370782,
0.0661938488,
0.0224267934,
-0.0037556558,
-0.0424440354,
-0.0155772017,
0.0308706108,
-0.0301376376,
-0.0043930789,
-0.0545103475,
-0.0136188688,
0.0577956662,
-0.0614416488,
-0.0067088227,
0.0065492177,
2.433e-7,
0.0217404459,
0.0340089798,
-0.0078242654,
-0.0004502844,
0.0253736358,
0.0024987955,
-0.0095999483,
0.0395033509,
-0.0172090046,
0.0141767878,
-0.0033585608,
0.009122489,
0.0518316738,
0.0267302711,
-0.0765839219,
0.0180189144,
-0.077772297,
0.0226694811,
-0.0695505142,
-0.0462371185,
-0.0045562284,
0.1386926621,
0.0289975069,
-0.002155907,
0.021752907,
-0.0485398583,
0.0956172869,
-0.0361615866,
-0.0306546185,
0.0092467386,
0.0233854707,
0.051393766,
0.0290837903,
-0.037493322,
-0.0412545763,
0.0044356608,
0.028509371,
0.0525808185,
0.0248127598,
-0.0219539683,
0.0256836265,
-0.0227393173,
-0.0296445079,
-0.0657833591,
0.081379734,
0.0262337308,
-0.0303863361,
-0.0439920798,
-0.0379639119,
0.013134174,
0.0377705097,
-0.0510888994,
-0.0532915778,
0.0503761992,
0.0227400847,
-0.021250328,
-0.0219265949,
-0.0443838313,
-0.0291040689,
-0.0242033992,
-0.0397838391,
-0.0455986746,
-0.0438247398,
0.0306883734,
0.0092243282,
-0.0242222082,
0.0235816371,
2.028074205e-34,
0.0664383098,
-0.0195610058,
-0.0150372311,
-0.0299875233,
0.0201134011,
-0.0188036207,
-0.0129608335,
0.0142293163,
-0.0074431468,
-0.0576150306,
-0.0171237346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01757v1 | Indo LEGO-ABSA: A Multitask Generative Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis for Indonesian Language | 2023-11-03T07:28:12 | 2023-11-03T07:28:12 | Randy Zakya Suchrady, Ayu Purwarianti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Aspect-based sentiment analysis is a method in natural language processing
aimed at identifying and understanding sentiments related to specific aspects
of an entity. Aspects are words or phrases that represent an aspect or
attribute of a particular entity. Previous research has utilized generative
pre-trained language models to perform aspect-based sentiment analysis.
LEGO-ABSA is one framework that has successfully employed generative
pre-trained language models in aspect-based sentiment analysis, particularly in
English. LEGO-ABSA uses a multitask learning and prompting approach to enhance
model performance. However, the application of this approach has not been done
in the context of Bahasa Indonesia. Therefore, this research aims to implement
the multitask learning and prompting approach in aspect-based sentiment
analysis for Bahasa Indonesia using generative pre-trained language models. In
this study, the Indo LEGO-ABSA model is developed, which is an aspect-based
sentiment analysis model utilizing generative pre-trained language models and
trained with multitask learning and prompting. Indo LEGO-ABSA is trained with a
hotel domain dataset in the Indonesian language. The obtained results include
an f1-score of 79.55% for the Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction task, 86.09%
for Unified Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis, 79.85% for Aspect Opinion Pair
Extraction, 87.45% for Aspect Term Extraction, and 88.09% for Opinion Term
Extraction. Indo LEGO-ABSA adopts the LEGO-ABSA framework that employs the T5
model, specifically mT5, by applying multitask learning to train all tasks
within aspect-based sentiment analysis. | [
0.0539181158,
0.0509319603,
-0.00730264,
0.0266395975,
-0.0457716025,
0.0483665131,
0.0177373495,
-0.0064731855,
-0.0271529946,
-0.048355408,
-0.082818687,
-0.0638228953,
-0.0365790576,
0.0256529655,
-0.027383836,
-0.0168026313,
0.0616202466,
0.0417495482,
0.0382797495,
-0.0058423304,
0.0074499622,
0.0362362973,
-0.0244426634,
0.0073701893,
-0.0301890075,
-0.02331529,
0.0215548277,
-0.0274434686,
0.0327127874,
-0.0335107744,
0.0319564901,
0.041688174,
-0.0293265823,
-0.0350445695,
0.0000022153,
-0.0285354666,
-0.0225085858,
-0.0294835661,
0.0482117012,
-0.0413829871,
0.1145146713,
0.0135061378,
-0.0094277039,
0.0060210456,
-0.0543860272,
-0.0651335046,
0.0265099481,
0.1311176419,
0.0394556411,
0.0853650868,
-0.0285440311,
-0.0623647235,
-0.0157655105,
-0.0264366977,
-0.0174284987,
-0.027056098,
0.0050369864,
-0.009063947,
-0.0371919349,
0.0307047833,
0.0243899357,
-0.0017240659,
-0.0076825162,
0.0202207472,
-0.0170410387,
-0.0116974711,
0.0390629955,
-0.019942617,
0.0047503086,
0.0215045884,
0.0152538065,
-0.0086003952,
-0.0069856429,
-0.018279599,
-0.0182464905,
0.0431669615,
-0.0134914732,
0.0086503588,
-0.008014936,
0.0477461889,
0.0733211637,
0.0495297164,
-0.0185939614,
0.0114999739,
0.0244919267,
0.0257780589,
-0.0142932851,
-0.0328359567,
0.0039587733,
0.0807603151,
-0.0065981639,
-0.0053934697,
0.005569296,
-0.013754786,
0.0193713959,
0.0342891254,
0.012108339,
-0.0064791981,
0.0326931104,
-0.0813918635,
-0.007203273,
0.0167551097,
-0.03836032,
0.0052590873,
-0.00635857,
-0.0425730757,
0.0222769566,
-0.0100770164,
-0.0441924594,
0.014616264,
-0.0742690563,
0.0098258117,
0.0057667103,
0.058064986,
-0.0428138599,
0.0118438154,
-0.068882063,
0.0030454621,
0.0031875605,
-0.0224178787,
0.0627653599,
-0.0061478913,
-0.0071506044,
0.0069159763,
-0.0076180217,
0.0257108491,
-0.0626418591,
0.0570452809,
-0.0446669869,
-0.0050805416,
0.0327746235,
0.0147476187,
0.0127383024,
-0.027298782,
0.0075080772,
0.00403838,
0.019828584,
-0.027582394,
-0.0628492609,
0.003470307,
-0.0017794871,
-0.0710261837,
-0.0210074317,
-0.0510877408,
0.0551882572,
0.0039257593,
-0.0108699165,
0.0076714493,
0.0249594226,
0.0166854188,
-0.001231514,
0.0453214385,
-0.0219466072,
-0.0191590469,
-0.0254051052,
0.0175193157,
0.1004044563,
0.0621575974,
-0.0203851573,
0.033585988,
0.0223918818,
0.0041059977,
-0.0202373844,
-0.0004502466,
-0.0063600154,
-0.0167220458,
0.0176577643,
0.0009411403,
-0.0254782513,
-0.0636521131,
-0.0344250575,
0.0252213106,
0.0111467652,
0.0374938734,
0.0102863237,
-0.0377334617,
-0.0045632999,
0.0927257091,
0.0185622759,
-0.0019532226,
-0.0011504225,
0.0034985817,
0.0118213743,
0.0151941972,
-0.0216642134,
0.0025346277,
-0.0096286973,
0.0286466349,
-0.0277845562,
-0.0670073926,
-0.0015669263,
-0.0280538555,
-0.0113822147,
-0.0065168426,
0.0735781416,
0.0047781318,
-0.0752828792,
-0.0334787741,
0.0653735995,
-0.0762024745,
-0.0213208161,
-0.0341221467,
0.0487089008,
0.070630528,
-0.016636664,
-0.0163795147,
-0.0134062385,
-0.0342832319,
-0.0555271097,
0.0130055826,
0.0153336665,
-0.0250810999,
-0.0253289174,
-0.040136002,
0.0177251361,
0.000270662,
0.037352711,
0.0146358842,
-0.0173822027,
0.0711962581,
-0.0002296243,
0.0285809133,
0.0087748254,
0.008221902,
-0.0035106509,
-0.0102013173,
0.0012648597,
0.021846395,
0.0139266048,
0.0713846013,
-0.0097200433,
-0.0347284675,
0.0321463719,
-0.0493030772,
-0.0211125966,
0.0442280844,
-0.0456821993,
-0.0674312413,
0.0060483185,
0.0222764872,
-0.0090994984,
-0.0050404128,
-0.0231920127,
-0.0225920882,
0.0048844838,
0.0647992715,
0.0180073455,
-0.0607615039,
0.0050223763,
-0.0260393359,
0.0186221283,
-0.0114036743,
0.0828293115,
-0.0157346856,
0.0023333677,
-0.0491268672,
-0.0002768092,
0.0447272286,
0.0330906659,
-0.024584366,
-0.004401207,
0.0150802555,
0.0202532914,
0.0101909591,
0.0441164039,
-0.0212445688,
-0.0379352868,
-0.134329766,
-0.0023520833,
-0.005173956,
0.0485858731,
0.0145739298,
0.0110841254,
-0.0254653096,
0.035879977,
-0.0037573117,
-0.0021166506,
-0.0024540611,
-0.0017678895,
0.0094327517,
0.0333085917,
0.0517525747,
-0.0576019138,
0.0107691046,
-0.0119698886,
-0.0159983616,
0.0374206267,
-0.0658191368,
-0.0172314607,
0.0394343957,
0.0095584588,
-0.0203119256,
0.0123486556,
-0.0312612653,
-0.010501517,
-0.0147854686,
0.0184930135,
-0.0137328459,
0.0181191228,
0.0374276824,
0.015646439,
0.0014329688,
-0.0107543645,
0.0338195339,
-0.0623566769,
0.0379494168,
-0.0047866171,
-0.0056567928,
0.0140217198,
0.0632577166,
0.017179532,
-0.0258699525,
-0.0460749343,
0.0062097129,
-0.0467224568,
-0.0064868764,
0.0391247757,
0.0149668604,
-0.0202838164,
0.0186967999,
0.0368890837,
0.0168311279,
0.0376032852,
0.0223118998,
0.0092785414,
-0.0983292609,
0.0107275611,
-0.0379222855,
0.0467782095,
-0.0674246773,
0.0191698838,
0.0401779972,
-0.0021587594,
0.0188134238,
-0.024816351,
-0.0251249298,
-0.0094568506,
0.0360662378,
0.0108059281,
0.0078071672,
0.017918678,
-0.0298473109,
-0.0151890209,
-0.0269470289,
-0.0398165248,
-0.0077497396,
0.0172661003,
0.0198931899,
0.0129491612,
0.0003315535,
-0.0381072089,
-0.0820391029,
-0.0050416267,
-0.0002945502,
0.0292432792,
0.0378362127,
0.0560688823,
-0.0741560161,
-0.0061037824,
-0.0065520257,
-0.0104911076,
0.0197085496,
-0.0322710238,
-0.0072186538,
-0.0043448582,
-0.0092528304,
0.0313924253,
-0.009853472,
-0.012000245,
-0.0660265312,
0.0407043062,
-0.016531691,
-0.0029912605,
0.1080043092,
0.0345858335,
-0.0418828316,
-0.0139082791,
-0.0329080671,
-0.0174906477,
-0.0043141432,
0.0517026633,
-0.0423989408,
-0.0197827462,
-0.0301348381,
-0.0132823531,
-0.0136551317,
0.0110808136,
0.012449678,
-0.1094181836,
0.0261614732,
-0.0300063267,
-0.0167358629,
-0.0357560702,
-0.0168533288,
-0.0023825471,
-0.0364831612,
0.0147930318,
-0.0467566215,
0.0034918343,
0.0106412005,
0.0412396863,
0.0173850544,
-0.0544742867,
0.0389671214,
0.019619368,
0.0313393362,
0.0394864157,
0.0460507274,
-0.032171119,
-0.0275007188,
0.0305966064,
-0.0516770855,
0.0220913384,
-0.0535839349,
0.0318858624,
-0.0336956717,
-0.0394055508,
-0.0080560902,
-0.0186601058,
-0.0494910777,
0.0169917587,
0.003423884,
0.0432944186,
-0.0095956903,
-0.0013356927,
-0.0257895757,
0.0265703108,
0.0540396571,
0.0405914709,
-0.0107855173,
-0.0762939602,
0.0102865985,
-0.0087286578,
-0.0199056733,
-0.0605220497,
-0.0333256572,
-0.0450979508,
-0.0234932993,
-0.0308028273,
-0.0878314823,
-0.0571050085,
0.0123772463,
0.0536693297,
0.0024696849,
0.0291147996,
-0.0000232826,
0.0230975561,
-0.0209870767,
-0.0292879641,
0.0155710867,
0.009200559,
-0.0134671684,
-0.0260058213,
0.1010456085,
-0.0170228891,
-0.01994274,
-0.0229314435,
-0.0236462839,
-0.0299687795,
0.0082543865,
0.0461837687,
0.0015135475,
-0.0095201721,
-0.0189008322,
0.0134077026,
-0.0198669657,
0.045554135,
-0.037498828,
-0.030846905,
0.0688910931,
0.0299719889,
0.0202607438,
0.0278940015,
-0.003404927,
0.0761727542,
0.0246101264,
0.0098377345,
-0.0194091294,
-0.0334822014,
0.0026155938,
0.0014946588,
0.0273493156,
-0.0061751138,
-0.0043316958,
-0.0490421653,
-0.0124241877,
0.0035668625,
-0.0137209976,
-0.0318220109,
0.0143303862,
0.0294920541,
-0.01325176,
-0.0540560447,
0.038718313,
-0.0417170115,
0.0015812406,
-0.0099553466,
0.0880704224,
0.0070040082,
0.0505868942,
-0.0407302044,
0.0260445606,
-0.0230483003,
-0.0591058508,
0.028104987,
-0.0261210538,
-0.0306240916,
0.0640528053,
-0.0086707557,
-0.0004841897,
-0.0385740884,
0.043975316,
0.0373718403,
0.0584505163,
-0.0355573595,
0.0232983325,
0.016910661,
-0.0530993864,
0.0430058949,
-0.0408651307,
0.0174222123,
0.0040716804,
0.0270431787,
-0.0276492424,
0.0066982321,
0.0505173728,
-0.009982774,
-0.0199026223,
-0.0174059942,
0.0364684612,
-0.0967633352,
0.0322486274,
0.0307278931,
0.0152518712,
-0.029488476,
-0.0023253087,
0.0109942164,
0.0158425551,
-0.0094190231,
0.0457369052,
-0.0501376688,
-0.0358991362,
-0.0114461249,
-0.0233311877,
0.0076873517,
0.0026321316,
0.0083553502,
0.0517061427,
0.0293872412,
0.0504978672,
-0.0799095333,
-0.0289737266,
-0.0010876869,
0.0042907139,
0.0039576585,
-6.767368732e-33,
-0.0489669703,
0.0243052635,
-0.0136723937,
0.0183175299,
-0.0333823673,
-0.0528065786,
0.0026813825,
0.0320743397,
-0.0215390939,
0.0307665765,
-0.0205747224,
-0.0122389402,
0.0140994536,
0.0226329137,
0.0454573482,
0.0024275293,
0.0232716072,
-0.0078763003,
0.027108252,
0.032599289,
0.0482319333,
0.0384665616,
0.0890277177,
-0.1293533593,
0.0298378561,
-0.0107666459,
-0.0481096804,
-0.0001273645,
0.012486686,
0.0345673524,
-0.0429004505,
0.0414553061,
0.0297066122,
-0.0683816671,
0.0138423508,
0.0038815776,
-0.0523552261,
-0.0441731662,
0.0557574593,
0.0126057686,
0.0118414294,
-0.046276208,
-0.0271118917,
-0.0012628769,
-0.0108489897,
0.0238403603,
0.0145892454,
-0.0369075947,
0.0192170125,
-0.0676615238,
-0.0786190778,
0.0212082379,
0.0207532831,
0.0034569609,
0.0511937402,
0.0574895181,
0.0102339592,
-0.0145286797,
-0.0108177727,
0.0096109901,
-0.0223740265,
0.0069345962,
-0.0135110961,
-0.0349349678,
0.0114600547,
0.0606897138,
-0.020947108,
0.0029645062,
-0.0049134726,
0.0651218519,
0.0006340581,
0.0576040484,
-0.0284436941,
0.0479088388,
-0.0019393691,
-0.052075915,
-0.0513663441,
0.0206231046,
0.0354005583,
-0.0114621408,
0.067909047,
-0.0191969555,
-0.0475880876,
-0.0176102631,
0.0414673202,
-0.0522161424,
-0.0220005699,
-0.0571524054,
0.0030779648,
0.0185063835,
-0.0517699458,
0.0284182355,
0.0007110093,
-0.0624914169,
-0.0125800865,
0.0242042094,
-0.0553478785,
0.030498039,
-0.019767629,
-0.0027284457,
-0.0629827976,
-0.0307547189,
-0.0449304879,
0.0468741357,
-0.0099477852,
-0.0118827699,
0.0786660463,
-0.0159875937,
-0.0846799314,
0.0022010359,
-0.000915118,
0.0470052622,
0.0101583591,
0.0486747362,
-0.0197247751,
0.0177693944,
-0.0140312668,
0.1077077985,
0.0304030608,
0.0244613029,
-0.0195376985,
0.0012852527,
0.0152277984,
0.0295610279,
-0.0309963692,
-0.0128171286,
0.0009052675,
-0.0160072856,
0.0057884227,
-0.0195321497,
-0.0266009439,
0.0022822516,
2.878e-7,
0.0459713638,
0.0494513847,
-0.0209922306,
-0.0142643685,
-0.0142314266,
0.0591077916,
0.0030115987,
0.0056878771,
0.0284782276,
0.0610721782,
0.0265251528,
-0.0111532342,
0.0056014657,
0.0225717984,
-0.0751683041,
0.0724542215,
0.0195014458,
-0.0090089198,
-0.0104947351,
0.0446474291,
0.0572828427,
0.0760673508,
0.0162839349,
-0.0118214069,
-0.0316767693,
0.036440488,
0.0610974245,
-0.0353441983,
-0.0528862365,
0.0378089771,
-0.0509388335,
0.0412170067,
0.005076847,
-0.0537166893,
-0.0215862077,
0.0174118113,
0.0258814543,
0.0693640634,
0.0239642151,
-0.0349937454,
0.072912164,
0.015519768,
0.0165469274,
-0.0243933946,
0.0676908791,
-0.0327327885,
-0.0326966569,
-0.0822389349,
0.0019733887,
0.0447313897,
-0.0120989373,
0.0058058309,
-0.0230630338,
0.0307427794,
-0.0001883861,
-0.0461640134,
-0.0608345009,
-0.038399972,
0.0093045412,
0.0403725691,
0.0087691983,
0.0105039906,
0.034616787,
0.012795547,
-0.0089077158,
-0.0324307755,
0.0149082514,
2.302688741e-34,
0.0476338789,
-0.0026249434,
0.0012327823,
0.0429398827,
0.0013070056,
-0.0027395524,
-0.0472616516,
-0.0208494198,
0.0213727336,
-0.0155262928,
0.0152499918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01751v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01751v1 | EmojiLM: Modeling the New Emoji Language | 2023-11-03T07:06:51 | 2023-11-03T07:06:51 | Letian Peng, Zilong Wang, Hang Liu, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid development of the internet, online social media welcomes
people with different backgrounds through its diverse content. The increasing
usage of emoji becomes a noticeable trend thanks to emoji's rich information
beyond cultural or linguistic borders. However, the current study on emojis is
limited to single emoji prediction and there are limited data resources
available for further study of the interesting linguistic phenomenon. To this
end, we synthesize a large text-emoji parallel corpus, Text2Emoji, from a large
language model. Based on the parallel corpus, we distill a sequence-to-sequence
model, EmojiLM, which is specialized in the text-emoji bidirectional
translation. Extensive experiments on public benchmarks and human evaluation
demonstrate that our proposed model outperforms strong baselines and the
parallel corpus benefits emoji-related downstream tasks. | [
0.0366937779,
0.074614428,
-0.0334968753,
0.0140406201,
-0.0226533022,
0.0499977656,
0.0077882991,
0.0194887239,
0.0258003715,
-0.0324156992,
0.0020161893,
-0.0559253767,
-0.0064702448,
0.0133766001,
0.0471743718,
-0.0348173305,
0.0198281016,
0.0143879931,
0.0121510206,
-0.0351754017,
0.05381383,
0.0525178872,
0.0205799285,
0.0763276741,
-0.0545830205,
-0.0210175607,
-0.0027937235,
0.0117129358,
-0.0231140852,
-0.0386567712,
0.0141583895,
0.0558286272,
-0.0045472216,
0.0609187521,
0.0000017909,
-0.0023728227,
-0.0171552543,
-0.0047185649,
0.0105713317,
-0.0069973795,
0.0551086068,
-0.0647776201,
-0.0284701493,
0.0428047031,
-0.0014219763,
-0.0354891494,
0.0728776231,
-0.02476478,
0.0140440576,
0.0444965661,
-0.0318374112,
-0.0209602248,
0.0183986239,
-0.0314599648,
-0.017869046,
0.0107051516,
0.0137864612,
-0.0641734973,
-0.0210747384,
-0.0020362907,
0.0037660038,
0.0703443587,
0.0296828914,
-0.0052327192,
-0.042772118,
0.0100904712,
0.034623608,
-0.0734667853,
0.0084404126,
0.0739338472,
-0.0569157302,
-0.0365247838,
0.01907482,
0.0045945556,
0.0080468291,
0.0202066489,
-0.0372682475,
-0.0070279539,
0.0354552232,
0.0223885458,
0.0172844641,
0.0101839248,
0.0546864793,
0.0222785696,
-0.0366919711,
-0.0277517047,
0.0323504694,
-0.0346821807,
-0.0198722351,
0.0004785742,
-0.0409034714,
-0.029231349,
0.0700442344,
0.005963387,
-0.0175838973,
0.0613505244,
-0.0454676524,
-0.1089041829,
0.0397037603,
-0.067031011,
0.0142710451,
0.0347412527,
0.0165436789,
0.0150628695,
-0.0161057711,
0.0328290202,
0.0048446399,
0.0247340873,
-0.0203841496,
-0.0554399565,
-0.0188924447,
0.01149463,
-0.0048012878,
0.0216663759,
-0.0148794875,
-0.0171740968,
-0.0415953472,
0.063440457,
0.0181837156,
-0.0277764313,
0.0269254241,
-0.0108950371,
-0.0237801187,
0.0086303791,
0.0119415959,
0.0338224918,
-0.0351181775,
0.0008897403,
-0.0087277889,
-0.0045342571,
0.0257093031,
0.0269280858,
0.0229878239,
-0.0380447954,
-0.0057565086,
0.0478425846,
0.0149937412,
-0.0546424538,
-0.0065791635,
-0.0013634402,
-0.029659722,
-0.0322657563,
0.0218603518,
-0.0801393762,
0.0526346639,
0.0223352872,
0.027450772,
-0.0045376238,
0.0178947076,
0.0356172882,
-0.0680693835,
0.0559649467,
-0.0201001912,
0.0024245384,
0.0065809796,
0.0099974517,
0.0136503642,
0.0404285342,
0.0415166467,
0.0311484486,
0.040605206,
-0.0370531902,
-0.02710329,
0.0879383162,
0.018146215,
0.0424471162,
-0.050853204,
0.0181667339,
-0.0119609516,
0.0247768015,
-0.0453694426,
0.0719282776,
0.0148099391,
-0.0307658631,
0.0656137168,
0.0845988989,
0.022254549,
0.0457092114,
0.021775743,
0.0106790792,
-0.0262488294,
-0.0325160921,
-0.0189716574,
0.0222421419,
0.0048284908,
-0.004191312,
0.0467001088,
0.0281281397,
-0.0459287576,
-0.0080891764,
0.0105966479,
-0.0545783974,
0.0323239416,
-0.0304046031,
0.0022122669,
0.0005171373,
-0.0826082081,
0.0159187019,
0.0232500602,
-0.0779979825,
-0.0110020749,
0.0112402067,
0.0190963726,
0.0444993787,
0.0410043895,
0.0348248631,
-0.0107167931,
-0.0032949075,
-0.0091795642,
0.0878508687,
-0.0110313129,
0.0163090266,
-0.0020445378,
-0.0433752723,
0.0033632799,
0.0592237227,
-0.0184937399,
-0.0075937179,
0.0082261041,
0.0761828125,
-0.0077193403,
0.0301308092,
-0.0328276232,
0.0272950195,
-0.0520859659,
0.0071299765,
0.0152179571,
0.0106473481,
0.0038436281,
0.011699249,
-0.0065710517,
0.0123065338,
0.0229879376,
-0.0446922928,
-0.0509052277,
0.0367958173,
-0.0356151946,
-0.0504736304,
0.0766806453,
-0.0299365278,
0.0189609006,
0.0486447141,
-0.0541087687,
-0.0244473368,
0.0702006072,
-0.0338969529,
0.0409016497,
-0.0302460343,
0.012132653,
-0.0300546438,
0.0422879532,
0.0334304906,
0.0061122002,
-0.0565755516,
-0.0034876841,
-0.0079430621,
-0.0069274115,
0.0125790341,
0.0409837998,
-0.0299157519,
0.0675109178,
-0.0238914639,
0.0225571785,
0.0372521244,
0.0198098123,
-0.0186502282,
-0.0473003946,
-0.116420418,
0.0080036037,
-0.0071571469,
0.0306153297,
0.0190343596,
0.0363166444,
0.002601454,
-0.021711925,
-0.0364783891,
0.0163458176,
0.0265560169,
0.0318560861,
0.0165337231,
-0.0256026555,
-0.0119804181,
-0.0324569643,
-0.0252316352,
0.0051097898,
0.0561551824,
-0.000169654,
-0.0463953316,
0.0028625329,
0.0020330017,
-0.0212518796,
0.0030312052,
0.0365090705,
-0.0722083077,
0.0201662257,
0.0043996847,
0.0355118886,
-0.0170575846,
0.044063434,
0.0370372385,
-0.0352471285,
-0.0157198384,
-0.0765183866,
-0.0081648426,
-0.0411517918,
-0.0161869172,
-0.0077649476,
-0.042258583,
0.0019806065,
0.0652002469,
-0.0068689222,
0.0007286611,
-0.0915332586,
0.0025246067,
-0.0277070981,
-0.0316843465,
-0.0171110854,
-0.0102222441,
-0.035066843,
-0.0391473435,
-0.0498405807,
-0.0487337299,
0.0362092964,
-0.0131765651,
0.0042370344,
-0.0348225534,
0.0049743038,
-0.002010477,
0.0695258975,
-0.0250025485,
0.0160372313,
-0.0154016465,
-0.0130230524,
-0.01628411,
0.0540833995,
-0.060313262,
-0.0610302798,
-0.0130335409,
0.013799035,
0.0350173861,
0.0346212387,
-0.0088546192,
-0.0168991759,
-0.0651058927,
-0.0211988464,
-0.0088216709,
0.0399389975,
-0.0612526014,
-0.0053999946,
0.0391910933,
-0.0438129455,
-0.0095751686,
-0.0284360778,
0.0070720883,
-0.0075996551,
-0.0080437679,
0.023222791,
-0.0312110446,
0.0117003461,
-0.0306179523,
0.032305751,
0.0756664649,
0.0395192243,
-0.0522139259,
-0.0286779832,
-0.0398181453,
0.0417256914,
-0.0142259952,
-0.0193172339,
-0.0179806147,
0.0317302942,
-0.0062514837,
0.0328601226,
0.1017019525,
0.0115151564,
-0.0649021119,
0.0403506346,
0.0477408171,
0.0244346485,
0.0031203988,
0.0191661306,
-0.1126846373,
-0.0446984805,
0.008112072,
0.031306114,
0.0028109711,
-0.0008968402,
-0.0098666912,
-0.1144185439,
-0.0053786431,
0.0171542503,
-0.0282462239,
-0.0021970628,
0.0201100931,
-0.0003069128,
0.0224626306,
0.0075089931,
-0.0044410988,
0.0084831817,
0.0060713189,
0.0303065088,
0.0215348601,
-0.0199547168,
0.018136302,
-0.0551718101,
0.0138910441,
0.0261013974,
0.04505077,
0.0249506366,
-0.0158990137,
0.0099330181,
-0.0262317751,
0.0062952028,
-0.0183347501,
0.0344303809,
-0.0141312433,
-0.0227398574,
-0.0441746376,
0.0047541237,
-0.0998627692,
0.0160737429,
-0.0003477986,
0.0554845221,
0.0161416549,
-0.0288293697,
-0.0325372964,
-0.027188044,
0.0119530708,
0.0343455821,
0.0167399999,
-0.0936655253,
-0.0134786181,
-0.0089345332,
0.0093255006,
-0.0537943169,
-0.0339028426,
-0.0648559183,
-0.0263401009,
-0.0520941839,
-0.0884519294,
-0.056310311,
0.0111489939,
0.0185054783,
-0.0003066393,
-0.0136599056,
0.0004235499,
-0.0550573282,
-0.0017908304,
0.0231703352,
0.0046619363,
0.0461088121,
-0.0325840227,
0.0325140543,
-0.0151620712,
-0.0014185952,
0.0275300015,
0.0331822783,
-0.1020874903,
-0.0651854575,
-0.0045210291,
0.0927987322,
0.0054852022,
-0.0005811389,
-0.0447785743,
-0.0646689013,
0.0166732203,
0.0498471856,
-0.0530904941,
-0.0167822149,
0.010924953,
-0.0266486946,
-0.0027917279,
0.0479209535,
-0.008048336,
-0.0018197282,
-0.0326516107,
0.0264830869,
-0.0494062752,
-0.0267463885,
0.0210330244,
0.0289969351,
-0.0059145852,
-0.0448774584,
-0.0427508391,
0.0088781128,
0.0085531473,
-0.0037533233,
0.0022460609,
-0.0468888916,
-0.0043606805,
0.0368434526,
0.0019914275,
-0.0101060634,
-0.0475757271,
0.0344291627,
-0.016963277,
-0.0059626717,
0.0242623501,
-0.0117778005,
0.0680053532,
0.0153013235,
0.0511815995,
-0.0052134497,
0.0280271582,
0.0028148293,
0.0003406036,
-0.0371759087,
0.0044115051,
-0.0445300974,
0.0015071335,
0.0261066649,
0.0338877663,
0.01410338,
-0.0335246101,
-0.0174997058,
0.0246853922,
0.0576953292,
-0.0043435008,
0.0837827101,
-0.0008807333,
0.0228767227,
-0.0257237907,
0.0348403826,
-0.0463832058,
-0.0217294563,
-0.0031683908,
-0.0249748789,
-0.016748162,
-0.0222091097,
0.0870439336,
-0.0445926823,
0.0500328876,
0.0484578274,
-0.0069491132,
-0.0198520329,
0.0172567237,
0.0307100993,
0.0402338542,
-0.0475328974,
0.0010177236,
-0.0291330684,
-0.0948654935,
-0.0100860894,
-0.0149818426,
0.0328112021,
0.0342810154,
-0.0076226974,
0.0454392508,
0.0015673781,
0.0529064909,
-0.0598241128,
0.0415272079,
-0.0659588128,
-0.0394032747,
0.0116379689,
-6.241019096e-33,
0.0365394987,
-0.0180873517,
-0.0230641812,
-0.0666984171,
0.0001576177,
-0.015017706,
-0.0240426827,
0.0400865413,
0.0416515768,
-0.0148608563,
-0.0170964617,
-0.0044712392,
0.0037520528,
0.0188099593,
0.0419371575,
0.0050995392,
0.0124396738,
-0.0134418476,
0.0023686662,
0.0290349163,
0.0522373803,
0.0491317809,
0.0554761142,
-0.0676580444,
0.051885251,
-0.0534188114,
-0.0006221283,
-0.0202385392,
0.0310955234,
0.0514312796,
-0.0322178341,
0.0557174161,
0.0137212966,
-0.0046683094,
-0.0399585888,
0.02505254,
-0.0489574336,
-0.0042733569,
0.0440859124,
0.0329657905,
-0.0677879676,
-0.0281691309,
0.0473931059,
-0.0205430556,
-0.0095438352,
-0.0007318571,
-0.0065437118,
0.0083884001,
0.0087469593,
0.0357222073,
-0.0535757951,
0.0238656793,
-0.0200796202,
-0.0223913435,
0.0524108037,
0.0565911904,
0.0243846644,
0.0291183628,
-0.0507925153,
0.0178883206,
-0.0500466675,
-0.0200435352,
0.0724888891,
0.0142374653,
0.0096220504,
0.0473708212,
-0.0042531411,
-0.0110416729,
0.0019583197,
0.0011089977,
0.0153355421,
0.0272695553,
0.0451620482,
0.0427630469,
0.0748292208,
-0.0681404099,
-0.0369915552,
0.0059615509,
0.0595351495,
0.0091263251,
0.0185869094,
0.0346970223,
-0.0191534273,
-0.0095908586,
-0.0206017774,
-0.0108479699,
-0.0195168797,
-0.0717447475,
-0.0074606882,
-0.0035964435,
-0.0455214418,
0.0038101855,
0.0377026647,
-0.037565928,
-0.0516171902,
-0.0113315592,
-0.0385871083,
0.0128448624,
-0.0153186088,
0.0589277484,
-0.0329765975,
0.0002283489,
-0.0153725455,
-0.0360282473,
-0.0105545176,
0.0456091613,
0.0169754121,
0.0023139331,
-0.042010814,
-0.01352794,
-0.0210595001,
0.0138405878,
-0.0151057038,
0.0023262959,
0.0386029258,
0.0168799963,
-0.0069407593,
0.0063774884,
0.0318493731,
0.0488641225,
0.0022039961,
-0.0042271167,
-0.0115643432,
-0.0045220354,
-0.0148149375,
-0.0220497344,
-0.0500961617,
0.0010312542,
0.0276647341,
-0.0668407381,
-0.0080995932,
0.0140303178,
2.515e-7,
0.0747271627,
0.0272214673,
0.0228070728,
0.0282802228,
0.0219140686,
0.0429022275,
-0.0111171883,
0.0065308991,
0.0217239801,
0.0425348058,
-0.0239608884,
0.0081479717,
0.0642803311,
-0.0113492496,
-0.0512703843,
-0.0156962741,
-0.0825390369,
0.0652448684,
-0.0519311018,
0.0132230483,
0.0014197163,
0.1043628678,
0.0312506743,
-0.0159645341,
-0.0398175865,
-0.0280069411,
0.0727308318,
-0.031343244,
-0.020273421,
-0.0151088694,
-0.0167860463,
-0.0205017626,
-0.0037593716,
-0.0002075258,
-0.0097366637,
-0.0112439208,
0.0511244461,
0.0022620452,
0.0123795401,
0.0350771099,
0.0468494482,
-0.013899588,
-0.0167526882,
-0.046985615,
0.0547756813,
-0.04234837,
-0.0400676653,
-0.0534211546,
-0.0139996959,
0.0649314076,
0.0522156097,
-0.0320320092,
-0.0202935245,
0.0402864106,
0.0317942724,
-0.0054155095,
-0.0016731919,
-0.0437441617,
-0.0316094868,
-0.0261748247,
-0.0225111134,
0.0130941402,
-0.0810559392,
0.0400967039,
-0.0298825465,
-0.0210672393,
0.0111818695,
1.825325306e-34,
0.00542178,
-0.0154736526,
-0.0080111027,
0.0233058948,
0.0134713752,
-0.0440945514,
0.0385369696,
0.0329102725,
0.0195106808,
-0.0349848866,
-0.0171245281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01740v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01740v2 | SAC3: Reliable Hallucination Detection in Black-Box Language Models via Semantic-aware Cross-check Consistency | 2023-11-03T06:32:43 | 2024-02-18T06:13:47 | Jiaxin Zhang, Zhuohang Li, Kamalika Das, Bradley A. Malin, Sricharan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucination detection is a critical step toward understanding the
trustworthiness of modern language models (LMs). To achieve this goal, we
re-examine existing detection approaches based on the self-consistency of LMs
and uncover two types of hallucinations resulting from 1) question-level and 2)
model-level, which cannot be effectively identified through self-consistency
check alone. Building upon this discovery, we propose a novel sampling-based
method, i.e., semantic-aware cross-check consistency (SAC3) that expands on the
principle of self-consistency checking. Our SAC3 approach incorporates
additional mechanisms to detect both question-level and model-level
hallucinations by leveraging advances including semantically equivalent
question perturbation and cross-model response consistency checking. Through
extensive and systematic empirical analysis, we demonstrate that SAC3
outperforms the state of the art in detecting both non-factual and factual
statements across multiple question-answering and open-domain generation
benchmarks. | [
0.0261757206,
0.0546067171,
-0.0050198599,
0.0560664348,
-0.0431601629,
0.0074649169,
-0.0145067526,
0.0018715129,
0.008370026,
-0.0407269411,
-0.0142025538,
-0.0489037335,
0.0017482335,
-0.0026500244,
0.0327025726,
0.0249870811,
0.0879261121,
-0.0447592847,
-0.0236630347,
-0.0271003582,
0.0108297952,
0.0202388242,
0.001323697,
0.0322403722,
-0.0097392071,
-0.0528315268,
-0.0071868929,
0.0109699704,
-0.0050845519,
0.0056069903,
0.0108910371,
0.0879127532,
-0.0194578022,
0.0992141366,
0.0000020985,
-0.0588767752,
-0.051933255,
-0.0095893592,
-0.0311647449,
0.0283234324,
-0.0139639145,
0.0068360572,
-0.0022140588,
0.0340879485,
-0.0292590912,
0.0059475307,
0.0175968632,
0.0481071845,
0.0811944604,
0.0543794669,
0.0059185587,
0.0403435379,
0.042321872,
-0.004373997,
0.0302392729,
0.005035331,
0.0198339708,
0.0457092784,
-0.0357890949,
-0.0071952892,
-0.0154078566,
0.0326143689,
0.0414020978,
-0.0054043322,
-0.0518700853,
0.0150606502,
-0.0772655979,
-0.0110804746,
-0.0137264971,
0.0528506488,
-0.005781787,
-0.0461474098,
0.0000751166,
0.0091420179,
0.0180159621,
0.0169001482,
-0.0166619755,
0.0111802183,
-0.0067384415,
-0.021244606,
0.037615601,
-0.0132331979,
0.0353120267,
0.008741485,
-0.0156309977,
0.1211530119,
0.0309710782,
-0.0436095111,
0.0006691884,
0.011744502,
-0.0119556524,
-0.0652747154,
0.0025377094,
-0.0014032089,
-0.0561079569,
0.0156790707,
-0.0743130445,
0.0093663502,
0.0512313806,
-0.0095823985,
0.0069673113,
0.0029399926,
-0.0550244637,
0.0458763056,
-0.0141348597,
0.0503438301,
-0.0290472042,
0.0682235733,
-0.0069347583,
0.0038157138,
-0.0053550033,
-0.0272311363,
-0.0466788523,
0.0279640071,
0.0005847989,
-0.0088785961,
-0.0161937065,
0.0104862051,
-0.0265207645,
0.0308353696,
-0.0167632569,
-0.0010308934,
-0.0052135009,
-0.0170638841,
-0.0109697506,
0.0233692341,
-0.0129903778,
-0.0110727148,
0.0312298667,
-0.113460198,
-0.0452851392,
0.0184768029,
-0.0263623558,
-0.0086546065,
-0.0121066384,
0.0134125147,
0.025606079,
-0.000497675,
-0.0295669008,
-0.0886421874,
-0.060897477,
-0.0738600194,
0.0008367347,
-0.082840465,
0.0037801256,
-0.0205660164,
-0.0144050298,
-0.025788296,
0.0241952501,
0.0195943881,
-0.0085318629,
0.0452992693,
-0.0262219831,
-0.0150991352,
-0.0015248744,
0.019215038,
0.0024555963,
0.0742498413,
0.0121907368,
0.0087319082,
0.065960981,
0.014391928,
0.0268364064,
0.033111129,
0.0345836058,
0.0192957092,
-0.0310876071,
-0.006646663,
0.0223430153,
-0.0147038493,
-0.0075654238,
0.0662939176,
-0.0239615329,
-0.0587900281,
0.0616722405,
-0.0002985405,
-0.0225922372,
-0.0106364554,
0.0350846983,
-0.0043408684,
-0.0013388012,
0.0863190144,
-0.051371336,
0.0066968617,
-0.0412523896,
0.0105669172,
0.0544532277,
0.0119813671,
-0.0182286482,
-0.0529887453,
-0.0171231795,
0.0134517625,
-0.0132085076,
0.0004786417,
0.0074729593,
0.0279222298,
-0.0365124308,
0.0921901092,
0.0206128731,
-0.049101226,
0.0173678584,
-0.0609846525,
0.0442980528,
0.0306909829,
0.0857672021,
-0.00223282,
-0.019932339,
-0.0276716892,
0.0455560572,
0.0680018067,
0.0479611233,
0.0174534507,
0.0156533364,
-0.0258784778,
-0.0084950775,
-0.0105718141,
0.0560758747,
-0.0161608905,
0.0162726007,
0.0061510564,
0.0107722534,
-0.0593657754,
-0.0173263699,
0.0341503732,
-0.0284341834,
0.0034942101,
-0.0178510863,
-0.024640806,
-0.0007866425,
-0.005474613,
-0.0147384694,
0.0322347768,
0.0046035899,
-0.0227515455,
-0.0246383511,
0.0087814638,
-0.0424642451,
-0.0450600907,
0.042803362,
0.0108346175,
-0.0168926734,
0.0703165904,
-0.0215045847,
-0.0253891181,
0.0198095646,
-0.0498134829,
0.0179116745,
-0.0710511729,
0.0596735924,
-0.0156653877,
0.0672288537,
-0.0033194143,
0.0438144803,
-0.0479333326,
0.0195644777,
0.0000190978,
0.0386191197,
0.0132107781,
-0.015927054,
-0.0355490521,
0.014137988,
-0.0295983739,
0.0244957507,
0.0159134381,
-0.0246235542,
-0.0751625821,
-0.010645004,
-0.0356241725,
0.008573533,
-0.0415859856,
0.0144793531,
0.0422485098,
-0.0001168057,
-0.0106829051,
-0.0106114056,
-0.0205898751,
-0.0014147105,
0.0457871966,
0.01717503,
0.0240070391,
-0.0233247615,
-0.008385255,
-0.0175875481,
0.0143417818,
-0.0301588308,
0.0456790552,
-0.0178901721,
0.0057029426,
-0.0905490741,
0.0097696055,
-0.0812302828,
0.0164821856,
0.0120604923,
-0.0090586431,
0.0242832098,
0.0026808388,
0.0281230286,
0.044472672,
0.0300311577,
-0.0125594446,
0.0621057861,
-0.0201224424,
-0.0473291092,
-0.008656566,
0.0052423687,
-0.0070089712,
0.0133259622,
-0.0443373062,
0.0386547036,
0.061405953,
0.0322334729,
-0.0145541104,
-0.0323844962,
0.0281572584,
-0.0393700562,
-0.0460174233,
0.0230266284,
-0.0102765653,
-0.0264275204,
0.0391147733,
-0.0375120714,
-0.0461932458,
0.0826451108,
-0.0707724243,
0.0113825183,
-0.0142997503,
0.0166247394,
-0.0004498777,
0.0240935199,
-0.0084552728,
0.0092336191,
0.037137568,
-0.0097558321,
-0.0407310426,
-0.0285107214,
0.0025173191,
-0.0548425131,
0.0067114122,
-0.0402254052,
0.0037052298,
0.0202432703,
-0.0226777755,
-0.076067403,
-0.0442439243,
-0.0179692172,
-0.0246509742,
-0.0539444573,
0.0044046198,
-0.0101147378,
0.00308703,
-0.0127477888,
0.0430030748,
-0.0563621186,
-0.0134344948,
-0.0279007927,
0.0621268936,
0.1078892499,
-0.0092430459,
0.0658783019,
-0.0394354761,
0.0129496455,
0.1007816792,
0.0282357521,
0.0675173029,
-0.0065751038,
-0.0209823735,
0.0199237242,
-0.0037218239,
-0.0153609356,
0.0125951236,
0.0319711752,
-0.0570547953,
-0.0614115745,
0.1083102748,
0.0452554934,
-0.0057027917,
0.0104718376,
-0.0676383972,
0.0694128573,
-0.0034652464,
-0.005033799,
-0.0800563395,
-0.0314533152,
-0.0068130209,
-0.0009332084,
-0.0286710951,
-0.0176259726,
-0.0197271761,
-0.1024046317,
0.0289217215,
0.0053099906,
-0.0440899879,
-0.0012235295,
-0.018502716,
0.0184407849,
0.0326961987,
0.0513157286,
0.0218607206,
0.0277673397,
-0.0360021703,
-0.0003128685,
-0.0191655234,
-0.0074241124,
0.0289467797,
-0.0378401764,
0.0373892002,
0.0789217874,
0.0123583991,
0.0082582375,
-0.0817111433,
0.0396578833,
-0.010663989,
-0.029152995,
-0.0061760005,
0.0524053462,
0.0007464092,
-0.0038332357,
0.0089141689,
0.0017935274,
-0.023885835,
0.0087716486,
0.0014846508,
0.0711624995,
-0.0205248445,
-0.0619680136,
-0.0295697898,
0.0469615757,
0.0042940793,
0.0836587995,
0.0208359547,
-0.0286685266,
-0.0506589152,
-0.0129491845,
0.0291382093,
-0.0367398113,
-0.0166965034,
0.0518057607,
0.0598073043,
-0.0214956217,
-0.0808898062,
-0.022078773,
-0.0248564482,
0.01431573,
-0.0353231579,
0.0406408422,
0.0155127198,
-0.0262429751,
-0.0307314638,
0.0081516206,
-0.0894329622,
0.0060441261,
-0.0189873837,
0.0338854641,
0.0226089861,
0.0057385433,
-0.0048790351,
0.0312280376,
-0.0932869092,
-0.0654250458,
0.013576909,
0.0245345701,
0.0203607418,
0.0510943793,
-0.0319195949,
-0.0268107932,
0.0278374664,
0.0081494311,
0.0113883046,
0.0333734937,
0.0143886525,
-0.035161566,
0.0020214997,
0.0417101011,
-0.0292314403,
-0.004004173,
0.0112472381,
0.0408045948,
-0.0093625365,
-0.0137831615,
0.0419083983,
0.0115729105,
0.0190653633,
0.0142818224,
0.0496018343,
-0.0094371093,
0.0122701507,
-0.021004634,
-0.0265877843,
-0.0400290377,
0.0342989303,
0.0053273439,
-0.0557539724,
0.0157931857,
-0.0329566747,
-0.0601145886,
0.0352874026,
-0.0293426663,
-0.0556438603,
0.0001492205,
0.0234622099,
0.017570965,
-0.0426730923,
-0.0275710337,
0.0042868624,
-0.0004919372,
0.0567168593,
0.0127135776,
0.0538646132,
0.004374532,
-0.032220915,
-0.0114742285,
0.0179250091,
-0.0579957254,
-0.02568301,
-0.0331597887,
-0.001818509,
0.0149227986,
0.0121610109,
0.0633042008,
-0.0098013822,
-0.0032248849,
-0.0152464071,
0.0148592964,
0.0485640131,
-0.0471737608,
0.0142992381,
0.0304835346,
-0.0097980052,
0.025707176,
0.0454996191,
-0.0050973184,
0.0418498032,
-0.0005893984,
-0.0120956218,
-0.0287701804,
-0.0603087917,
-0.0605407208,
-0.012733276,
-0.0299157035,
-0.0206865985,
-0.0763844103,
-0.0768395662,
0.0083000241,
0.0415015258,
0.0122652985,
0.0138130467,
-0.0068712602,
0.0954954773,
-0.0022592188,
-0.0166319329,
-0.0267967824,
-0.0102613363,
0.0034262436,
-0.0032023673,
0.0045312964,
-6.777363373e-33,
-0.0111170728,
-0.062736176,
0.0059982692,
-0.077526629,
-0.0053601675,
0.0004678448,
-0.0321354568,
0.0150535675,
-0.0131072756,
0.0152068278,
0.0001887689,
0.0452647656,
0.0148674333,
0.0211219229,
-0.0188046973,
-0.0301819723,
0.055632513,
0.0035614518,
-0.0648576394,
0.0222993232,
0.0248342603,
-0.0118136378,
0.0453166403,
-0.0321454741,
0.0635822564,
-0.0386239141,
-0.0328228995,
0.0151144052,
-0.039295949,
0.0639042482,
-0.0132666603,
0.038391944,
0.0101596732,
-0.0519147441,
-0.0170094203,
-0.0077917287,
-0.032202892,
-0.019869674,
0.0097308569,
-0.0044789296,
-0.0717081428,
0.005393696,
0.0349446349,
-0.0201216824,
0.0118529005,
-0.0077469302,
-0.0086877458,
-0.0266811773,
-0.0059100688,
0.0275204927,
-0.0436268598,
0.0208528787,
0.0099297781,
-0.0100866612,
-0.0250138324,
0.0848530829,
0.0143320039,
-0.0220751539,
-0.0311455037,
0.0194638502,
0.0071337074,
-0.001303179,
0.0733760521,
-0.0035489341,
-0.0178794246,
0.0733750388,
0.0221520104,
-0.0033678471,
0.0061437264,
-0.0102945762,
0.0359069519,
0.0254023131,
0.0597983412,
0.0632979572,
0.0193341766,
0.0166863147,
-0.0331407599,
0.0086415838,
-0.0108886212,
0.0144000351,
0.0552503131,
-0.04297309,
-0.0676430017,
-0.0124381632,
-0.029029604,
-0.0137880314,
-0.0425376892,
-0.0216137376,
0.0415931679,
0.0222496707,
-0.0624772198,
-0.0153896781,
0.0437658876,
-0.0437926725,
0.003739865,
0.0341467559,
-0.0420060046,
-0.0187551659,
0.0023137578,
0.0530490912,
0.0243580863,
0.0250236895,
0.0066097137,
-0.0106830224,
0.0158885252,
0.0253538489,
0.0094578462,
-0.0109021515,
-0.0522671826,
0.0297122989,
-0.0336803049,
0.0375168622,
-0.022156598,
-0.02141493,
0.0495311618,
-0.029328594,
-0.031338878,
0.0219771471,
0.044771336,
-0.005125259,
-0.0417738296,
0.0582136661,
-0.0232498813,
0.0331639983,
-0.0363938957,
-0.0152126988,
-0.0267022233,
0.0005851801,
0.0381450802,
-0.062478181,
0.0033514886,
-0.0074908407,
2.733e-7,
-0.002491405,
0.0326460861,
0.025845971,
0.0196287744,
0.0243679136,
0.026818553,
0.0150263738,
0.0169413481,
0.0172002967,
-0.0365104303,
-0.0428426899,
0.0153297689,
0.0719046071,
0.0566695407,
-0.0646241382,
-0.0140630882,
-0.0831734538,
0.0216099676,
-0.0500809178,
-0.0412798375,
0.0244039744,
0.0729614943,
0.0158323646,
-0.0353243388,
-0.0045713047,
-0.0456750542,
0.050667841,
0.0273297615,
-0.0060679335,
0.0412667878,
0.0249895863,
0.0171107203,
0.0414318442,
0.0318409391,
0.0067506651,
-0.0034271143,
-0.0012502184,
0.0259038769,
0.0145308096,
-0.0599191301,
-0.0259897094,
-0.0010718849,
0.0247376226,
-0.0732619613,
0.0795112699,
-0.0043654162,
0.0064077177,
-0.0440838598,
-0.0082181087,
-0.0248922985,
0.0567019396,
-0.023013331,
-0.0416105911,
0.0313458517,
0.010201538,
0.0351398997,
0.0000767846,
-0.0268871803,
-0.0465072691,
-0.0360112637,
-0.0196518973,
-0.0559899695,
0.0039188196,
-0.01405444,
-0.0286014657,
-0.0916130394,
0.0278977212,
2.807620962e-34,
0.0247607436,
0.0017741827,
0.0426213779,
0.025056826,
0.0306299664,
0.0073046153,
0.0479463972,
-0.0062214476,
0.0009643957,
-0.0372991525,
-0.028489206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01732v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01732v2 | Proto-lm: A Prototypical Network-Based Framework for Built-in Interpretability in Large Language Models | 2023-11-03T05:55:32 | 2023-11-12T04:28:43 | Sean Xie, Soroush Vosoughi, Saeed Hassanpour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of Natural
Language Processing (NLP), but their lack of interpretability has been a major
concern. Current methods for interpreting LLMs are post hoc, applied after
inference time, and have limitations such as their focus on low-level features
and lack of explainability at higher level text units. In this work, we
introduce proto-lm, a prototypical network-based white-box framework that
allows LLMs to learn immediately interpretable embeddings during the
fine-tuning stage while maintaining competitive performance. Our method's
applicability and interpretability are demonstrated through experiments on a
wide range of NLP tasks, and our results indicate a new possibility of creating
interpretable models without sacrificing performance. This novel approach to
interpretability in LLMs can pave the way for more interpretable models without
the need to sacrifice performance. | [
0.0365546085,
0.0421514139,
-0.0252040233,
0.0766043067,
-0.002613226,
0.0044712839,
-0.0067270221,
-0.0040981662,
0.0319025479,
-0.0247694738,
-0.013288592,
0.0001497395,
-0.0227564294,
0.0846895501,
0.0326486938,
-0.0158584602,
0.0068900343,
-0.0043738913,
0.0022825189,
0.0259339083,
0.0033045772,
0.025022516,
0.0298817325,
0.0718952566,
0.0568866767,
-0.0104739796,
-0.0316381827,
0.0129966298,
-0.01509823,
-0.0025750168,
-0.0414523445,
0.0440622047,
0.0557455011,
0.0408324786,
0.0000017669,
-0.0306806024,
-0.0321543403,
0.0024438188,
-0.0974869132,
0.0238687824,
0.0194244348,
-0.0217775367,
0.0146259749,
0.0157579277,
-0.0079697771,
-0.0012492357,
0.0392410792,
0.0476042032,
0.0315987393,
0.0626099706,
0.0104793729,
-0.0290614497,
0.0072842049,
-0.0296996012,
-0.0167507995,
-0.0521778949,
-0.0073903571,
-0.0114954365,
-0.0265294276,
0.0182524789,
-0.061956089,
0.001588408,
0.0365684219,
-0.0228829291,
0.0405722372,
0.0006908848,
-0.0093458435,
-0.0434207879,
0.014660188,
0.1031898186,
-0.0421102345,
0.0025441356,
-0.0167960599,
-0.0203366727,
-0.0130448695,
-0.0196483843,
-0.0428504422,
-0.0261834133,
0.0230937321,
0.0437598303,
0.0135925673,
0.0040467856,
0.0901455283,
0.0247897506,
-0.0393840298,
0.0520400442,
-0.0270890873,
0.0255541857,
-0.0214975625,
0.0066577597,
-0.0269307867,
-0.0088358615,
0.0452654436,
0.0169797745,
-0.0236236509,
0.0510945581,
0.0021650326,
0.0230405275,
0.0145562133,
-0.0328232162,
0.0395219214,
-0.0210929792,
0.0009304847,
0.0765668973,
-0.017944809,
0.0210534539,
-0.0448299646,
-0.0057002134,
-0.0390656479,
-0.0199581292,
-0.0645506606,
-0.0365840681,
0.0156376995,
0.0210777055,
-0.0360705666,
-0.0470521748,
-0.0293446109,
0.0220987145,
-0.0254983827,
-0.012009114,
0.02131637,
0.0209684148,
-0.0108038941,
-0.0555565245,
0.0019741307,
0.0250213481,
-0.0157331843,
0.0208037831,
-0.0435261428,
-0.0297161862,
-0.020574823,
0.0071845483,
0.0103490427,
0.0019219383,
-0.0088871485,
0.0907930657,
0.0467053875,
-0.0474490039,
-0.0056532924,
-0.0396326147,
-0.013000261,
-0.0407053232,
-0.0032318274,
-0.0224152729,
0.0220980793,
0.0192171503,
0.0157158971,
-0.0431614891,
-0.002771667,
-0.0283807609,
-0.058645986,
0.0689606592,
0.0060903253,
-0.0013301945,
-0.0499438085,
0.0193141568,
0.0224388726,
0.0683983564,
0.0313870721,
0.0360955819,
0.0455564186,
-0.0218773484,
-0.0136146843,
0.0168525018,
0.0476721041,
-0.0059919683,
-0.0010398289,
-0.0043260143,
-0.027676275,
0.0186306778,
0.0152328359,
-0.0053681373,
-0.0232957546,
-0.0296926517,
0.0282338932,
0.0348462947,
0.0809646696,
0.0239891447,
0.0504832007,
0.0431432463,
-0.0317114778,
-0.0148975272,
-0.0652202293,
0.0095343543,
-0.0271988362,
-0.0236908421,
0.0068101981,
0.0135749131,
0.0117327096,
-0.0507909656,
-0.0010302212,
-0.006248767,
0.0230082106,
0.0186037254,
0.0704818666,
0.0141272023,
-0.017400302,
0.0306497123,
0.0214470271,
-0.0085834842,
0.0321115516,
-0.0527545996,
0.0254053026,
0.0982171893,
0.0552098677,
-0.0110286083,
0.0277597606,
-0.0088790208,
0.0118249459,
0.0166546218,
0.0191956814,
-0.0043271426,
0.0601660572,
-0.0586945787,
-0.0466163494,
-0.0092094718,
0.041126173,
0.0104512852,
-0.0289860591,
-0.052918531,
0.0147114769,
-0.0495406687,
-0.0331518427,
0.0098628392,
-0.0270621572,
-0.0139184603,
-0.0172509123,
-0.0066867,
0.0223379917,
0.0537767932,
0.0113740508,
0.0088485936,
0.0112439226,
-0.0242261048,
-0.0063864682,
0.0143910889,
-0.0336905122,
-0.0309260935,
-0.018240789,
-0.0240027402,
-0.0160382707,
0.0326706842,
-0.0734760687,
-0.0290774032,
0.0291052405,
-0.044584889,
0.0384290479,
-0.0202064998,
-0.0100365328,
-0.0309023596,
0.0272675212,
-0.0249935947,
0.0207369104,
-0.0236462634,
0.0058743213,
-0.0002196101,
0.0216053221,
-0.0053777564,
-0.0306087751,
-0.0303867441,
0.0309344735,
0.0242213625,
-0.0173206143,
-0.007667582,
-0.0161724705,
-0.0467258468,
0.002115164,
-0.0383036956,
0.0113615375,
-0.0196747836,
0.0063481913,
0.0395633243,
-0.0014069743,
0.0376882106,
-0.0171390884,
0.0081937332,
0.0353015736,
0.0050957887,
0.0026983172,
0.019179998,
-0.0311902892,
-0.0377060585,
-0.0248603243,
-0.0425660759,
-0.0185680091,
0.1162861139,
0.0083534522,
0.0039934521,
-0.0636110157,
0.0009743042,
0.0126484018,
-0.0043823929,
-0.029047735,
-0.0162594318,
-0.0244453643,
-0.0130077424,
-0.0463527888,
0.0431734361,
-0.0212830156,
0.100961253,
0.0169021562,
0.0123593444,
-0.0634873509,
-0.0360220782,
-0.0283307098,
0.0122704469,
-0.0735946298,
-0.0460759066,
0.0019073031,
0.0842336416,
-0.005564725,
-0.0166944098,
-0.0468380675,
0.0212566499,
-0.0111847604,
-0.0322449766,
-0.0271373075,
-0.0204886701,
0.0133587569,
0.0160371419,
-0.0320304856,
-0.0712686703,
0.0715120286,
-0.0212180074,
-0.0152236065,
-0.0078260647,
-0.0495239235,
-0.0614412799,
0.090492323,
0.0333512947,
-0.0043270607,
0.005546744,
-0.0570240691,
-0.0170449261,
0.0008736624,
0.0061167851,
-0.0432658382,
0.0517831668,
-0.012202885,
-0.021149965,
0.0154749593,
0.0085676834,
-0.0073456494,
-0.0175079927,
-0.0521452688,
0.0245790109,
0.0393858664,
-0.0088230977,
-0.0110388268,
-0.0006232663,
-0.021266669,
-0.0083116554,
-0.0196041856,
0.0146258008,
-0.0301082619,
0.015856538,
0.0317524001,
0.0285986122,
0.046398405,
-0.0144996485,
0.0410455316,
0.0532343164,
-0.0289641563,
-0.0454978868,
-0.0726450682,
0.0393628366,
-0.0132308472,
-0.0205899589,
-0.029559765,
-0.0224570651,
0.0598150976,
-0.1085296124,
0.0045902738,
0.0972915217,
0.0143710496,
-0.041671209,
0.0207158867,
-0.0025764075,
-0.0013796469,
0.0291774496,
0.0238367897,
-0.0295616388,
-0.0539556593,
0.0034583029,
0.0322766453,
0.0154965026,
-0.0383431129,
-0.0181271154,
-0.0708113387,
0.0279425681,
0.011963916,
-0.0207185522,
-0.0365282632,
-0.0622039922,
-0.034385372,
-0.0427985936,
0.017646987,
0.0146143893,
0.0158860665,
0.019538153,
0.0100438213,
-0.0369894765,
-0.0577559657,
0.0291563552,
-0.0197751373,
0.0744102374,
0.0074227159,
0.003340462,
-0.0104824547,
0.0122643085,
0.0180547629,
-0.00626683,
0.0074458686,
-0.0279887635,
0.0654801801,
0.0030921574,
-0.014344383,
-0.0553000942,
0.0193650983,
-0.0299142729,
-0.0368649028,
-0.0267629828,
0.1034949571,
-0.0094940886,
-0.0360150971,
-0.0141814472,
-0.0135010881,
0.0074264905,
0.0754866302,
0.0566931851,
-0.0197518058,
-0.0470618531,
-0.0330717713,
-0.0218487792,
-0.0403492227,
-0.0662426725,
-0.0131300511,
0.0086327428,
0.0117170699,
-0.0036479321,
-0.036343202,
0.0250701997,
0.0068946639,
-0.0009226556,
0.0413109027,
0.0112836184,
-0.0281628761,
-0.0391997881,
0.0579637848,
-0.0205575842,
0.0102389809,
0.0032422377,
-0.0051867566,
0.0582310073,
-0.0248764697,
-0.0364041515,
0.0070364717,
-0.032413777,
-0.0448493958,
-0.0000171845,
0.0130742649,
0.0306030642,
0.0579979867,
-0.0249621905,
-0.0770272017,
-0.0012143729,
-0.0096946144,
-0.0172740649,
-0.0113419713,
0.0516773649,
0.0009176793,
0.0014023064,
0.0714284778,
-0.0315242223,
0.0256637894,
-0.0063095554,
0.0337320268,
-0.0243368354,
-0.0118592232,
-0.0103589268,
-0.0080965273,
0.031869594,
0.0336353555,
-0.0244610291,
-0.0670626014,
0.0023725573,
-0.0063836272,
-0.0047819233,
-0.0657480657,
-0.0022472746,
0.0301674455,
-0.0302630085,
-0.0154135078,
-0.0667412654,
-0.0289089363,
0.0080735032,
-0.005515283,
0.0298794769,
0.0241869632,
-0.0300755166,
0.0180912837,
0.0129397782,
-0.0162219517,
0.0412979163,
-0.0284005683,
0.0316447727,
-0.002795201,
0.0216696877,
0.004914437,
-0.0357909687,
-0.0992162377,
0.035970591,
-0.0584740192,
-0.0547961295,
0.0255925599,
0.0477246605,
0.0400200188,
-0.0177173633,
0.0567586608,
0.0131030157,
-0.000818298,
-0.0028682132,
0.0669009462,
-0.0019116583,
-0.0335545354,
0.0635992512,
0.0233044643,
-0.0277518779,
0.0081420001,
0.0682768002,
0.0493688919,
0.0167195182,
-0.0222517475,
-0.0306085162,
-0.0353526175,
-0.0305958521,
0.011351848,
0.0467140302,
-0.0544420369,
0.0397096574,
-0.0414008275,
-0.082178317,
-0.0142049883,
-0.0078771068,
0.0017261468,
-0.0139717786,
-0.0200374145,
0.0617959313,
0.0178725254,
-0.0084856888,
-0.0537294708,
0.0319654979,
-0.0110520152,
0.005061897,
0.0432199091,
-6.048507652e-33,
0.0011835166,
-0.0536854081,
-0.0124561377,
-0.0045178616,
-0.0096679376,
0.024640644,
-0.0465890057,
-0.0094484929,
-0.0064638127,
0.0209885407,
0.0232756585,
0.0278290324,
0.0046268767,
0.0389659889,
-0.0116147408,
-0.0375972092,
0.064213492,
0.0376319252,
0.0305316765,
0.0191460103,
0.0505480208,
0.0629874691,
0.0406864882,
-0.0427992754,
0.0491919927,
-0.0146519141,
0.0241236072,
0.0388115197,
-0.0142505066,
0.0588819236,
-0.0103706764,
0.01563517,
0.05750148,
-0.0628092512,
-0.0307966527,
0.0164260119,
-0.059813872,
0.0085077314,
0.0341528505,
0.0147209046,
-0.0612152629,
-0.0204122104,
0.0660305545,
-0.0006433963,
0.0383119509,
-0.0390039496,
0.013798004,
-0.0292798523,
-0.0370507054,
0.0490165055,
-0.0371124223,
0.0411776006,
-0.0360711515,
0.003530072,
0.0364323854,
0.0091789877,
-0.0100137163,
0.0569583885,
-0.0519801974,
-0.0332238264,
-0.0095569408,
-0.0106469039,
0.062354546,
0.0290539097,
-0.0188051332,
0.0574387424,
0.0381752886,
-0.0191312693,
-0.0398879126,
-0.0088328607,
0.0071253912,
0.0599492081,
0.0590119399,
0.0276350658,
-0.0042970083,
0.0247331541,
-0.0811503381,
-0.0330623984,
-0.0183644537,
0.0242217313,
0.0469339862,
0.0478763618,
-0.0456473529,
-0.0173733607,
-0.0472928509,
-0.0632894486,
-0.0251555853,
-0.0195093025,
0.010444859,
0.0065825754,
-0.0665938258,
0.0136253173,
0.0341131277,
-0.0867693499,
0.0095203426,
0.0584820211,
0.0349074863,
-0.0061026565,
0.0216720663,
0.0276492909,
-0.0246420801,
-0.0303398315,
-0.0236441027,
-0.0185966808,
0.0355894081,
-0.0302121118,
0.0416773148,
-0.01347885,
-0.0006990082,
-0.010018318,
-0.0491876826,
-0.0469481274,
-0.0443075038,
0.0506803952,
0.0462638326,
0.0198151767,
-0.0417676829,
0.0503881052,
0.0414839536,
0.0334355384,
0.0126237106,
0.0129110906,
0.0054807612,
0.0191441868,
-0.0389351137,
-0.035841208,
-0.002941882,
0.0270055067,
0.0669162199,
-0.0599490851,
-0.0179191045,
-0.0102590267,
2.42e-7,
0.0755607486,
0.0477969907,
0.0005674887,
-0.0109493881,
0.0546327569,
0.0440220013,
-0.0153595405,
0.0145471385,
-0.0049615572,
0.0093683349,
0.0208004322,
0.0463757999,
0.0211154185,
-0.0165417679,
-0.0299618654,
0.0234862585,
-0.0466135293,
-0.0008000344,
-0.0456010252,
-0.0096314447,
0.0451783091,
0.0952624828,
0.0223949347,
0.0071739955,
0.0313417055,
-0.0272834562,
0.0332377926,
-0.0505349971,
0.013109345,
-0.0293495823,
0.0184960719,
0.0425349288,
0.0139898648,
-0.0116967876,
-0.0079800719,
0.0447939858,
-0.0059139361,
0.0930010751,
0.0067963484,
0.0152172362,
-0.0233787801,
-0.0611188747,
0.0216803756,
-0.0643842369,
0.0740546212,
-0.0585173368,
-0.0812626034,
-0.0412799008,
0.0162548348,
-0.0776668042,
0.0151207075,
-0.0151585238,
0.0372606479,
0.0002138222,
-0.0183810666,
-0.0549522005,
-0.0031396484,
-0.0878028795,
0.0007368387,
-0.0004041289,
-0.0556613468,
-0.0074707712,
-0.0482587293,
-0.0220757872,
0.0899644122,
-0.0177276172,
0.0049176896,
2.101127964e-34,
0.0276827589,
0.0020894881,
0.0369973294,
0.0265021082,
0.0349365994,
0.0089024231,
0.0042948471,
0.0042916904,
0.0346350037,
-0.10007108,
-0.0029225461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01713v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01713v1 | An Empirical Study of Benchmarking Chinese Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction | 2023-11-03T05:00:44 | 2023-11-03T05:00:44 | Junxian Zhou, Haiqin Yang, Ye Junpeng, Yuxuan He, Hao Mou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect sentiment quad prediction (ASQP) is a critical subtask of aspect-level
sentiment analysis. Current ASQP datasets are characterized by their small size
and low quadruple density, which hinders technical development. To expand
capacity, we construct two large Chinese ASQP datasets crawled from multiple
online platforms. The datasets hold several significant characteristics: larger
size (each with 10,000+ samples) and rich aspect categories, more words per
sentence, and higher density than existing ASQP datasets. Moreover, we are the
first to evaluate the performance of Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT)
series models on ASQP and exhibit potential issues. The experiments with
state-of-the-art ASQP baselines underscore the need to explore additional
techniques to address ASQP, as well as the importance of further investigation
into methods to improve the performance of GPTs. | [
0.0138025908,
0.0867445022,
0.0063597211,
0.0028229249,
0.0140923522,
-0.0058900765,
0.0203291103,
0.0157957058,
-0.0530424975,
-0.0131163718,
-0.0589380413,
-0.0426378697,
-0.0377697721,
0.0798065364,
-0.0457601398,
-0.0167460963,
0.0077453949,
0.0375787318,
-0.0138102686,
-0.0119161699,
0.0135513367,
0.0314340517,
0.041455254,
0.0086193876,
-0.0389197133,
-0.0108162472,
0.0161471851,
0.0079347007,
0.0182358809,
-0.0352696218,
0.0281587429,
0.0462107472,
-0.0042191166,
0.0027908878,
0.0000022679,
-0.005500996,
-0.0529061444,
-0.0224438626,
0.0454092175,
0.0274192095,
0.0481325835,
-0.0301430579,
0.0050761523,
0.0378219895,
-0.0804143548,
-0.0645572394,
0.0065057408,
0.1238975301,
0.036511723,
0.0676491037,
-0.0401000641,
-0.0319997407,
0.0211568251,
-0.0480847098,
-0.0344714634,
-0.0795410797,
-0.0141365333,
0.0032069625,
-0.0646129772,
0.070993796,
-0.0264127031,
-0.0038093461,
0.0402965844,
0.0286565162,
-0.01407173,
0.0279909838,
0.0250497106,
0.0254078452,
-0.0089490926,
0.0416272245,
0.003027264,
-0.0372667201,
-0.0300859101,
-0.0428754576,
-0.0142584387,
0.0274194758,
0.0134743806,
0.0045314017,
-0.0085990559,
0.0518634394,
0.0126973689,
0.0380028896,
-0.003585529,
-0.0117463022,
-0.0364648625,
0.0124016814,
-0.0102100633,
-0.0416208208,
-0.0000664825,
0.0537954904,
0.0058533084,
-0.0239579845,
0.0009294701,
-0.0276070684,
0.0097250519,
0.0025965157,
0.0103546483,
0.0199605525,
-0.0162437614,
-0.0439266935,
0.0255550724,
0.0096306968,
-0.0475121215,
0.010534714,
0.0078438846,
0.0134434029,
0.019628888,
-0.009347681,
-0.0456788205,
0.0237689987,
-0.0691227391,
-0.009487275,
-0.0383840054,
0.0344310664,
-0.0276882313,
0.0009336619,
-0.054034736,
-0.0014089938,
0.0210785698,
-0.0411462747,
0.0496857353,
0.0001672336,
-0.0034166928,
0.0039405916,
-0.0123887947,
0.0641932338,
-0.0407721549,
0.040081434,
-0.0448907949,
0.0036037653,
0.0034451359,
-0.0008535339,
0.0339203477,
-0.0185394734,
0.022520287,
-0.0051258681,
0.0183704216,
-0.0518624596,
-0.0012007648,
0.0005573467,
-0.0054056421,
-0.0284517333,
-0.0033959688,
-0.0369018577,
0.0049830261,
-0.0000778246,
-0.0032380868,
0.0128590185,
-0.0081110233,
0.0161760207,
-0.0019108064,
0.0402099751,
-0.0007268015,
-0.000603072,
-0.0620511398,
0.0142765185,
0.0626368225,
0.0245694574,
-0.0124489395,
0.0397548564,
0.0537831523,
-0.029557582,
0.0373146571,
0.001377968,
-0.0280011315,
-0.0014815887,
0.041269023,
-0.0265579131,
-0.0437256657,
-0.022191776,
0.01781624,
0.0150223505,
-0.0024418107,
-0.0254528597,
0.0343681388,
-0.0164590366,
0.0425990038,
0.1043322533,
0.0191248655,
0.0204457548,
-0.0312735587,
-0.0046751252,
-0.0095873838,
0.0375431329,
-0.022479929,
-0.0082324315,
0.0185685828,
0.0363196358,
-0.0582102947,
-0.0719951019,
-0.0048962538,
-0.0089523448,
0.0076823435,
-0.0235565286,
0.047837507,
0.0282804035,
-0.0570619665,
-0.016022414,
0.0352904536,
-0.0635863692,
-0.0448473208,
-0.0226929896,
0.0254071262,
0.0550031178,
0.0264975093,
0.013904551,
-0.0226676464,
-0.0057399282,
-0.0562339202,
0.0012931061,
0.0304455888,
-0.0039672819,
-0.024614349,
-0.0339892916,
-0.0205547269,
-0.0023861604,
0.0044076126,
-0.0135708479,
0.0102025401,
0.0659526587,
-0.0016163947,
-0.0254209433,
0.0091523109,
-0.0062417141,
-0.0363866016,
-0.0362429135,
0.0526957214,
0.0060620611,
-0.000662932,
0.0557713434,
-0.0267780162,
-0.0299760532,
0.0587458201,
-0.0325586647,
-0.0960217342,
0.0317593329,
-0.0700307116,
-0.0431523174,
-0.000498174,
-0.0123275667,
0.0415412821,
0.0268489253,
-0.0343512222,
-0.0217445605,
-0.0017289069,
0.0173687991,
0.0241142809,
-0.0427363776,
-0.0068254839,
0.0253349673,
0.0440317243,
0.0040227138,
0.0499841236,
-0.0168363098,
0.012283043,
-0.054156173,
0.0078851487,
0.0131837726,
0.0279062763,
-0.0134498561,
0.0044327411,
0.0153825274,
0.0259674303,
0.0443246365,
0.0193882231,
0.0252892617,
-0.017479904,
-0.1046487764,
0.0064565968,
-0.018678464,
0.0200814195,
0.0272414945,
0.0001085243,
0.0009572294,
0.0276918486,
-0.0610252656,
-0.0057244301,
-0.0127165429,
-0.0027930096,
0.004597255,
0.0041140742,
0.0582614206,
-0.0120198308,
-0.0207428727,
-0.0261120424,
0.0226996336,
0.0087939566,
0.000684246,
-0.0319032408,
0.0538792647,
0.0045927516,
-0.0026118343,
-0.0123556182,
-0.0355230682,
-0.0479432866,
-0.024615394,
0.0244253632,
-0.0112976069,
0.0348936766,
0.0228651967,
-0.0155486874,
0.0078948522,
-0.0081806509,
0.0257814992,
-0.0822774917,
-0.0283094384,
-0.0280686747,
-0.0283525456,
0.0033742043,
0.0813039243,
-0.0017204301,
-0.0079682907,
-0.056335941,
0.0159975421,
-0.0148456506,
0.0231762063,
0.0465138517,
0.0504511893,
0.00562901,
0.0280646589,
0.0261367913,
0.0098484671,
0.0349940583,
0.0269274972,
0.0179625005,
-0.0624218658,
-0.006189785,
-0.046083007,
0.0784365311,
-0.0180068146,
0.0070568137,
0.020123221,
0.0227017496,
-0.0204080362,
0.0281220824,
-0.0256710313,
-0.0226205103,
0.026119547,
0.045759391,
-0.0025149703,
-0.0167198703,
-0.0328267589,
0.0169199873,
-0.0432289839,
-0.0239475276,
0.0135602271,
0.0085738879,
-0.024933774,
0.0338688418,
0.0141593916,
-0.0499453545,
0.0136408703,
-0.0139388582,
-0.0441875868,
0.0274766143,
0.0564478822,
0.0395829901,
-0.0302915033,
0.0368673131,
-0.0386628397,
0.0236328393,
0.0550893694,
-0.0412649773,
0.017709462,
0.016591955,
-0.0283359438,
0.0461926237,
0.0072400323,
-0.0122263236,
-0.0235714465,
0.0628876463,
-0.0368967652,
-0.0280524623,
0.1061732098,
0.0283172447,
-0.0284156241,
0.0060821525,
0.0617787018,
-0.0376900584,
0.0131402081,
-0.0045589176,
-0.1100436375,
-0.019940028,
-0.0512738675,
0.007627741,
0.0245204009,
0.0093283793,
0.0108321002,
-0.1211795211,
0.0371191502,
-0.0318521485,
-0.0192630105,
-0.0627496019,
-0.0464930907,
0.005126413,
-0.0560591891,
0.0037447824,
-0.0260582175,
-0.0205032676,
0.016890686,
-0.0159598906,
-0.0270641353,
-0.0144075667,
0.0657502264,
0.009470663,
-0.0177125353,
0.0285958555,
0.0333516747,
-0.0287331305,
-0.0570806004,
-0.0127920238,
-0.0614252649,
-0.0062324852,
-0.0124188671,
0.0580253825,
-0.0284704845,
-0.0133739831,
0.0054404624,
0.0260286741,
-0.0629091337,
0.0117537864,
-0.0214128252,
0.0258344617,
-0.0056997491,
-0.0739428326,
-0.0097807907,
0.0276270527,
-0.0040761144,
0.0682658851,
-0.0242892653,
-0.0999355987,
-0.0059039369,
-0.0053769699,
0.0286341719,
-0.0713954717,
-0.0674332529,
-0.0046437159,
0.000426877,
-0.0419412032,
-0.0940460339,
-0.0391029529,
-0.0219245236,
0.0313107856,
-0.0327855945,
-0.0229072571,
0.0198955983,
0.0184336696,
-0.0370236561,
0.0026090615,
0.0093478989,
-0.0171529632,
-0.0311596598,
-0.0283394698,
0.0910647362,
-0.0540355295,
-0.015987156,
-0.0128725469,
-0.0680038333,
-0.0216004122,
-0.0021473907,
0.0138321882,
-0.0070394976,
-0.0022830607,
-0.0070302072,
0.048047591,
0.0454960689,
0.052016627,
-0.0081835268,
-0.0037579245,
0.0556485616,
0.0313701145,
0.0053875465,
0.0252807364,
-0.0020566129,
0.0684623793,
0.0109017109,
0.0122085148,
-0.0567522347,
-0.0725253746,
0.0066681402,
-0.0202618856,
0.0759912729,
0.0223924052,
0.0057280464,
-0.0213828217,
0.0089831408,
-0.0136282956,
0.0126353772,
-0.0613102242,
-0.0087170508,
0.0415245295,
0.0074277227,
-0.0769239888,
0.0697835758,
0.0038878389,
0.0353734829,
-0.0839425698,
0.0290085226,
-0.0368388966,
-0.0027805716,
-0.0324564353,
0.0250660926,
0.0170435384,
-0.0548718013,
0.0426061489,
0.0119169718,
0.0013536816,
0.07321845,
0.0084709916,
0.0585569516,
0.0103033558,
0.0236871447,
-0.0442017838,
0.000847475,
-0.0564224124,
-0.0477122962,
-0.003102704,
-0.0381472297,
0.0325743072,
-0.0439741649,
0.0029638768,
-0.0093094464,
0.0349179171,
-0.0156984758,
0.0005390963,
0.0165051688,
-0.0113442354,
-0.0335212611,
-0.0168797132,
0.0694134161,
-0.0886353254,
0.0317733176,
0.0533182323,
0.0121633522,
-0.0194391254,
0.0018425164,
0.0169833098,
-0.0199954715,
0.0122351097,
0.0212185867,
-0.0498677753,
-0.0270803757,
0.0231070723,
-0.0450535417,
0.0238347482,
-0.0094415518,
0.040514715,
0.0447245091,
0.0168753024,
0.0587738566,
-0.0468902737,
-0.0569243357,
-0.0083610723,
-0.0165207125,
0.0185525212,
-7.078192948e-33,
-0.0069913561,
0.01381246,
-0.0139993429,
0.0183181223,
-0.0123404618,
0.0140789161,
-0.0128741153,
0.0100599779,
-0.0064095198,
0.020520715,
-0.0053017228,
0.0181665532,
-0.0112136602,
0.0382655077,
0.0204255916,
0.009780365,
0.0766017511,
0.006125079,
0.0003915245,
0.0722433329,
0.044228103,
0.0393686295,
0.1071390361,
-0.0909459218,
-0.0506774187,
0.0038197774,
-0.0281959716,
-0.0096396487,
0.0267859232,
0.04363098,
0.0073590712,
0.0267624725,
0.0298654009,
-0.0846965164,
-0.0000573616,
-0.0324837975,
-0.0282680411,
-0.0100097302,
-0.0241328757,
0.0149005074,
0.0153369214,
-0.0089430008,
-0.0144741386,
-0.0122398417,
-0.0123179592,
-0.0444362611,
0.0163086113,
0.0125898328,
0.0227113254,
-0.1434730142,
-0.0193382129,
0.0212343317,
0.0024601074,
-0.016436385,
0.0123737315,
0.0381495617,
0.0137479221,
0.0347546451,
-0.0129334461,
0.0148024401,
0.0098810531,
0.0476609506,
-0.0103233317,
-0.0507713631,
0.0255442541,
0.0289632846,
-0.0097975126,
0.019762978,
-0.0357967988,
0.0298600104,
0.0303239562,
0.0353165567,
0.004511124,
0.0286255479,
0.0695823506,
-0.0491896048,
-0.0323480479,
0.0426668674,
-0.0137354266,
-0.022268204,
0.0579818487,
0.0122135999,
-0.0256481133,
0.001007734,
0.0378915519,
-0.0151840085,
-0.0173349697,
-0.0370212793,
-0.0073365709,
0.0560347922,
-0.0168267041,
0.0328342654,
0.0224188846,
-0.0851512179,
0.0082506258,
0.0205866341,
-0.0802376121,
0.0226217285,
-0.0254119132,
-0.0138005484,
-0.0608021542,
-0.0157329068,
0.0017210259,
0.0230183788,
-0.0044665975,
0.002744131,
0.0701546222,
0.0148735186,
-0.1101422086,
-0.014418127,
-0.0117284553,
0.0264402442,
0.0135440351,
0.0647130907,
0.0028322488,
0.0195027199,
-0.0327570103,
0.0668500215,
0.0103514353,
0.0671051666,
-0.0477001779,
0.0008340517,
0.0179364029,
0.0133173959,
0.0025528262,
-0.0150354514,
-0.0112309558,
-0.0036063725,
-0.0047717262,
-0.0592539236,
-0.0649674907,
0.0330639295,
2.916e-7,
0.0338962525,
0.0462032221,
-0.0102436524,
0.0382388644,
-0.0021295676,
0.0459754616,
0.0262531582,
0.0401484109,
-0.004413031,
0.0314140022,
0.0543239973,
0.028389927,
-0.0087555787,
0.0353739038,
-0.0589365251,
0.060516119,
-0.0244815517,
0.0128092002,
-0.0067477119,
-0.001127544,
0.063558355,
0.107365407,
-0.0115155382,
-0.0024712244,
0.0433167107,
0.0448565893,
0.0440869294,
0.0028406647,
-0.0147607056,
0.0578641221,
-0.0304652862,
0.0412461087,
-0.0148056448,
-0.0411151424,
-0.0288315527,
0.0271484908,
0.0111356052,
0.0442627408,
0.0352934338,
-0.0907557309,
0.0293052215,
0.0464046858,
0.0142074758,
-0.0162203852,
0.0546852052,
-0.0266601276,
-0.0298274308,
-0.0631648079,
-0.0570161305,
0.0303568915,
0.0079214247,
-0.0031388132,
0.0158758461,
0.0488313958,
-0.002561338,
-0.0101495367,
-0.0184043422,
-0.0418667346,
0.0026502206,
0.0550509766,
0.0074794735,
-0.0489151515,
0.0147218825,
-0.0211260002,
-0.0212170519,
-0.0127032306,
0.0036141921,
2.500895455e-34,
0.0564549603,
0.0199089907,
0.0038030786,
0.0165810194,
-0.011515419,
-0.0324552432,
-0.0064719957,
-0.0315769687,
0.0019516668,
-0.0385837257,
-0.0080695599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01712v1 | A New Korean Text Classification Benchmark for Recognizing the Political Intents in Online Newspapers | 2023-11-03T04:59:55 | 2023-11-03T04:59:55 | Beomjune Kim, Eunsun Lee, Dongbin Na | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many users reading online articles in various magazines may suffer
considerable difficulty in distinguishing the implicit intents in texts. In
this work, we focus on automatically recognizing the political intents of a
given online newspaper by understanding the context of the text. To solve this
task, we present a novel Korean text classification dataset that contains
various articles. We also provide deep-learning-based text classification
baseline models trained on the proposed dataset. Our dataset contains 12,000
news articles that may contain political intentions, from the politics section
of six of the most representative newspaper organizations in South Korea. All
the text samples are labeled simultaneously in two aspects (1) the level of
political orientation and (2) the level of pro-government. To the best of our
knowledge, our paper is the most large-scale Korean news dataset that contains
long text and addresses multi-task classification problems. We also train
recent state-of-the-art (SOTA) language models that are based on transformer
architectures and demonstrate that the trained models show decent text
classification performance. All the codes, datasets, and trained models are
available at https://github.com/Kdavid2355/KoPolitic-Benchmark-Dataset. | [
0.0565451868,
0.0720938742,
0.0095828343,
0.0116990507,
-0.0073622232,
0.0388301872,
0.0327372849,
0.0057829325,
0.0359629355,
-0.0449559093,
-0.0488596372,
-0.0417198353,
0.0017954701,
0.026196897,
-0.0499385111,
-0.0553905405,
0.0325423554,
0.0347500332,
0.0570357293,
-0.0096398434,
0.0074556111,
0.0382801108,
0.0144611262,
0.0226740688,
0.0042320164,
-0.0349588245,
-0.0295510925,
0.0195586737,
0.0351822115,
-0.0183103178,
0.0247494988,
0.0317957401,
0.003357755,
0.042283386,
0.0000018896,
-0.0055205687,
-0.0290125068,
-0.04733935,
-0.0032209209,
-0.02727063,
0.0985241085,
-0.0545813665,
-0.0201961007,
0.0226864032,
-0.0323220938,
-0.0255597383,
0.0545018017,
0.0862012431,
0.0585979447,
0.1100706458,
-0.0199529808,
-0.0191724058,
0.0050650137,
0.0031693906,
-0.0184404422,
-0.0531281866,
0.0576575883,
-0.0329012945,
-0.0825673416,
0.0124367299,
-0.0155534828,
-0.0138578853,
0.0324885063,
-0.0117961597,
-0.056915015,
-0.0169466659,
0.0006043345,
-0.0215639658,
0.0219980497,
0.0549416319,
-0.0214221273,
-0.0504112467,
0.0263492037,
-0.0148852039,
-0.0208653919,
0.0146497004,
0.0013615914,
0.0282105561,
-0.0187186897,
0.0388600342,
0.0416350625,
0.0047809277,
0.0298915971,
0.0594240576,
-0.0396012776,
0.0591670014,
-0.0132765733,
-0.0273563843,
0.0120184636,
0.0010929802,
0.0003846349,
-0.0471341126,
0.033844769,
-0.0145144397,
-0.0165456478,
0.019471962,
-0.036287576,
-0.0469176546,
0.0129611809,
-0.0665127411,
-0.0107288817,
0.0075255395,
-0.017036587,
0.0518720523,
0.0153837996,
-0.0016422897,
-0.0057252464,
0.044566974,
-0.0139010716,
0.0079162363,
-0.0148126399,
0.0050382521,
-0.0106172962,
0.0208266899,
-0.0176563039,
-0.0196334198,
-0.0538892895,
0.0236416459,
0.0056411866,
0.0104090795,
0.0225711055,
0.0179630648,
-0.0583830103,
-0.0207190197,
-0.0148520991,
0.0519197211,
-0.0159056596,
0.0521998741,
-0.0012465855,
0.0002833554,
0.0242022928,
0.0430320352,
0.0382266864,
-0.0140080564,
0.0101672374,
-0.0027635389,
-0.014227625,
-0.0326507166,
-0.0344702676,
-0.0022804162,
-0.0322798267,
-0.0467327423,
-0.0041896524,
-0.0400163978,
0.0053393552,
-0.0125757707,
0.0107052801,
-0.0243408568,
0.0110134725,
0.0475329943,
0.0164706931,
0.0715998635,
0.0456258059,
-0.0077603059,
0.0513193719,
0.0346342288,
0.031421572,
0.09814246,
0.0150648458,
0.0764125362,
0.0420092866,
-0.0138988439,
-0.0143268444,
0.0216855053,
-0.0235969909,
0.002704751,
0.0060672835,
0.0137015469,
-0.055859182,
0.0131990556,
-0.0067337034,
0.012399869,
0.0201301314,
0.0103778196,
0.0712810308,
0.0297622327,
-0.0043392587,
0.0501408391,
0.0069638328,
0.0521047078,
-0.0019151506,
-0.0083277021,
0.0055279909,
0.0060213022,
-0.0151471002,
-0.0285004992,
-0.0215076637,
0.0372926295,
-0.0453620106,
-0.029357167,
-0.0160456374,
-0.0180250406,
0.0415266231,
-0.0058368328,
0.0879207104,
0.0086456733,
-0.0564699098,
0.032077726,
0.0154564092,
-0.0265982933,
-0.003496208,
-0.034913592,
0.0210783444,
0.0146260271,
-0.0041795783,
-0.0348687954,
-0.0057976558,
-0.0653152689,
0.0478465855,
0.0347772688,
0.0651497915,
-0.0210036319,
-0.0178999081,
-0.03839086,
-0.0144615313,
0.0169409867,
0.0207957923,
0.0220643431,
0.0117627485,
0.044864554,
0.0243219137,
0.0146066118,
-0.0146029759,
0.0393738113,
-0.0200896375,
-0.0123329889,
0.0446483605,
0.0567858741,
0.0425283909,
0.0363991335,
0.0067291195,
-0.0544749349,
0.0414036512,
-0.0180173796,
-0.0580484942,
-0.0145398611,
-0.0242119208,
-0.0346016288,
-0.0215120371,
-0.0404705219,
0.0105888946,
0.0755027533,
-0.0324880518,
-0.0274783783,
0.0203218218,
0.0063798404,
0.0015660429,
-0.0457543209,
0.0024150978,
-0.0537821911,
0.0297852866,
-0.0133590214,
0.0764355287,
-0.0012256001,
-0.0018807544,
0.0257106032,
-0.0371490903,
0.0069006234,
0.0043889275,
-0.0474920161,
-0.0013008716,
-0.0269736107,
0.0215568449,
0.0364418738,
-0.0029346498,
-0.0282474793,
-0.0505389944,
-0.0789437741,
0.0246978756,
-0.0454879813,
0.0209487136,
0.0251253359,
0.0088735949,
0.0063806553,
0.0104571339,
-0.0239315052,
0.0114010312,
-0.019178357,
0.0048970445,
0.0211598445,
-0.0257141795,
0.0152190104,
0.0116006928,
-0.0093510142,
-0.0274122618,
0.0196962114,
0.0124739232,
-0.0142656453,
-0.031512022,
0.0438785926,
0.0152639206,
-0.0293234754,
-0.0250225458,
-0.0545849279,
-0.0073526641,
-0.0107214935,
-0.027151648,
0.1011076123,
0.0559467264,
0.0595555492,
0.0200796016,
0.0295001417,
-0.0293522421,
-0.006112074,
-0.0570579097,
0.0214385241,
-0.0492329188,
-0.0121788708,
0.0153151089,
0.0607724935,
0.0195960533,
0.0126933744,
-0.0206982344,
-0.0085677868,
-0.0232515335,
0.000507344,
-0.0039298898,
-0.0022367961,
-0.0003929979,
0.0104233585,
-0.0092341146,
0.00843425,
0.0597105846,
0.0154518569,
0.0270981155,
-0.0646818206,
-0.0182294827,
-0.0431269817,
0.061824847,
-0.0297902562,
0.032266181,
0.0012597219,
-0.0318284109,
-0.0142153688,
-0.0087088961,
-0.0014589992,
-0.0457643904,
0.0578088202,
0.0170908645,
0.0080671152,
-0.028931452,
-0.031871438,
-0.0460767895,
-0.0670307875,
-0.0076755164,
-0.0130159641,
0.010108145,
-0.019215541,
-0.0460717268,
0.0195790157,
-0.0078736981,
0.0115604233,
-0.0074784257,
-0.0036468143,
-0.0046152174,
0.0344428793,
0.0380275585,
-0.0302536339,
-0.0091421222,
0.0113025969,
0.0137166856,
0.0369268209,
-0.0239279717,
0.0402179547,
-0.0427345894,
-0.0363273807,
0.0547717623,
-0.041739054,
-0.0086706495,
-0.0362013541,
0.0382479466,
-0.0565757565,
0.0140694566,
0.1064243391,
0.0180431511,
-0.0821182132,
-0.0239113979,
0.0200843606,
-0.0364967883,
0.0148312291,
0.0097288461,
-0.0908305049,
-0.0168252084,
0.0325722396,
-0.0376951993,
-0.025952803,
-0.0036886847,
-0.0058899494,
-0.0730491132,
-0.0173986852,
-0.0344878361,
-0.0258475207,
-0.0208545923,
-0.0782408789,
-0.0006207033,
-0.0330781452,
-0.001859428,
-0.0369639322,
-0.0006176476,
-0.0353689827,
-0.0064542657,
-0.0716141015,
-0.0722802058,
0.0307599287,
0.0078221057,
0.0073870365,
0.0117893061,
0.0847659484,
-0.0264883395,
-0.0150612853,
0.0277667735,
-0.0279111192,
-0.0546128936,
-0.0043768953,
0.0601776317,
-0.0492567532,
-0.0034026993,
-0.0029503405,
0.0505029745,
-0.051849734,
0.0166513827,
-0.0233433098,
0.0251381211,
-0.0161668826,
-0.0407028832,
0.0236509293,
-0.0212197788,
0.051419016,
0.0531618893,
-0.0115081854,
-0.0764885545,
0.0058439998,
-0.0468543395,
0.0153946457,
-0.0566654131,
-0.0096552055,
0.0047841258,
-0.0406870022,
-0.0243391246,
-0.0275706667,
-0.0366820022,
-0.0078663891,
0.0180484895,
0.0145068755,
-0.0242456291,
0.0192658249,
-0.0016977191,
-0.0404080637,
0.0051946687,
-0.0124080451,
0.0187509209,
-0.0029846702,
-0.0232046545,
0.0085032089,
-0.0259242784,
-0.0184922107,
-0.0149186207,
-0.0952224135,
-0.0138914231,
0.0100286985,
-0.0316596255,
0.0108598713,
0.0142604802,
-0.0264477506,
-0.0007996773,
0.035068363,
0.0389488079,
-0.0337677859,
-0.0442593843,
0.0358215235,
0.006635305,
0.0041950028,
0.0447415449,
-0.0260760374,
0.0395165794,
0.0264765676,
-0.0591936037,
-0.0613837056,
-0.0174403321,
-0.0119716004,
-0.0139809903,
0.0433641486,
0.0222017188,
-0.0693462268,
-0.0701233819,
0.0111409565,
0.0063973241,
-0.0323707275,
0.0080014961,
-0.0187273212,
0.0763761103,
-0.0284378137,
-0.0436936095,
0.0793990642,
-0.004830387,
0.013602009,
-0.0263797846,
0.0527726524,
0.0173314456,
0.0790367275,
0.001263299,
0.0111698201,
-0.0531127453,
-0.0031172077,
0.0280200057,
0.0123274615,
-0.0202548802,
0.0190261435,
0.002882635,
0.0263704322,
0.0241080672,
-0.009634966,
-0.0366067886,
0.0083177928,
-0.0412871055,
-0.0097498354,
0.0426936857,
-0.0498272777,
0.0370039307,
-0.0334588028,
-0.0108319269,
-0.0098430607,
0.0388997085,
-0.0094386199,
-0.0661113411,
0.0013172947,
-0.0089421989,
-0.0255103912,
0.0246185195,
0.0318763144,
-0.0093736732,
0.0310501065,
0.079856582,
-0.0549207143,
-0.0520673841,
0.0188192427,
0.043330133,
0.0238052867,
-0.0156719517,
-0.0531872734,
0.0040030824,
-0.027929971,
0.0322451778,
-0.0350783765,
0.0173474178,
0.0120719802,
-0.0118625024,
0.0760959759,
0.0087122601,
0.0165148955,
-0.0693577379,
0.0223125517,
-0.0360858403,
0.0066402629,
-0.014496156,
-6.206759313e-33,
0.0131851137,
-0.0124259172,
-0.0121837845,
0.0068687042,
-0.0182646196,
0.0256971624,
-0.0436767265,
-0.0120636001,
-0.0294446349,
0.0069299606,
-0.0082415845,
0.0264048651,
0.0189019572,
0.0534996949,
-0.0249182507,
-0.03753867,
0.0486044697,
0.0009917167,
-0.0125360284,
0.0292421915,
0.0553610325,
0.0213912372,
0.0685489625,
-0.0552140921,
0.0169826783,
0.0124328751,
-0.0274409335,
-0.0464976989,
0.0383942313,
0.0623743944,
-0.0217768513,
0.0348389968,
0.0579679497,
-0.0496635623,
0.0128765041,
0.1056803614,
-0.0619185865,
-0.013301638,
-0.0360516496,
0.0708208904,
-0.0203846991,
-0.0106511228,
0.0259612165,
0.0066341553,
0.0041628322,
-0.0354595371,
0.0591756925,
-0.0202241465,
0.0082345027,
-0.0369864367,
-0.0491146855,
0.0229387097,
-0.0181971285,
0.0002827861,
0.0168207716,
0.0401301272,
0.0212467574,
0.036034286,
-0.0924252048,
0.0062753982,
-0.0461852439,
0.0410327725,
0.0215817671,
-0.0040962035,
-0.0149307111,
0.0642833188,
-0.0052531511,
0.0335861072,
-0.0533658862,
-0.0233435575,
0.0533381216,
0.022922188,
-0.0073314463,
0.054714676,
0.0755652115,
-0.0993116498,
-0.0919738114,
0.0296330899,
0.0688713342,
0.0142538603,
0.0709689334,
-0.0141826076,
-0.0157431643,
0.0079444358,
-0.029466074,
-0.0490173697,
-0.03601465,
-0.030645553,
-0.0048472635,
0.0382869877,
-0.0310329366,
0.0369965173,
0.0269648023,
-0.0786109865,
-0.0163125601,
0.0590467006,
-0.0186988842,
0.0182233136,
-0.0080079678,
0.013679306,
-0.0610354505,
-0.0471136272,
-0.0221207775,
0.0173680168,
0.0077199256,
-0.0111001302,
0.0617430657,
0.0288575925,
-0.0648559704,
-0.0073161121,
-0.0022712864,
-0.0206172783,
-0.0001837659,
0.0972578824,
0.021683082,
0.0194449481,
0.0067268554,
0.0602292307,
0.0178334005,
0.0265792422,
-0.0093426751,
-0.0192141812,
-0.0004620758,
0.0039447974,
-0.0215102378,
-0.0392690971,
-0.0308940876,
0.015458093,
0.002691264,
-0.0710461587,
0.0013407242,
-0.0114934947,
2.54e-7,
0.0375249982,
0.0432488807,
0.0216545351,
0.0169258285,
-0.0024268632,
0.0371315926,
0.0234252177,
0.0667721555,
-0.0377740711,
-0.0063699414,
0.0369884633,
-0.0007136146,
0.0392064638,
0.0264818277,
-0.1364964247,
0.0266518872,
-0.0519524477,
0.0398125872,
-0.0344318822,
0.0071142102,
0.0202233121,
0.0881291404,
0.0273141712,
-0.0302474853,
-0.0064751063,
0.0091906013,
0.0639527515,
-0.0126119507,
0.0004845615,
0.0493177399,
0.0450451858,
0.0048509161,
0.0032458068,
-0.0103834756,
-0.0302438885,
-0.0011328054,
-0.0006791678,
0.0837278068,
0.0044586495,
-0.0151051823,
0.0018214952,
-0.0062853754,
0.0041549541,
-0.0367875509,
0.1016607136,
-0.0687038004,
-0.0320781842,
-0.0566301383,
-0.0200154614,
-0.0071929884,
0.0416825712,
-0.0071939901,
0.0275183097,
0.0200320762,
0.0169257484,
-0.0054494031,
-0.0090001412,
-0.0706253201,
0.0097421408,
-0.0197859779,
-0.0373087823,
0.012262865,
-0.0063329213,
0.0006301531,
0.0434279665,
-0.0480684265,
0.0280976519,
2.383161201e-34,
0.0168953873,
0.0096992748,
-0.0576263629,
-0.0165830031,
-0.0008044355,
-0.0157752,
-0.0213444717,
-0.0101583824,
0.0040905359,
-0.0898726657,
0.0067050629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01689v1 | Data-Free Distillation of Language Model by Text-to-Text Transfer | 2023-11-03T03:31:47 | 2023-11-03T03:31:47 | Zheyuan Bai, Xinduo Liu, Hailin Hu, Tianyu Guo, Qinghua Zhang, Yunhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data-Free Knowledge Distillation (DFKD) plays a vital role in compressing the
model when original training data is unavailable. Previous works for DFKD in
NLP mainly focus on distilling encoder-only structures like BERT on
classification tasks, which overlook the notable progress of generative
language modeling. In this work, we propose a novel DFKD framework, namely
DFKD-T$^{3}$, where the pretrained generative language model can also serve as
a controllable data generator for model compression. This novel framework
DFKD-T$^{3}$ leads to an end-to-end learnable text-to-text framework to
transform the general domain corpus to compression-friendly task data,
targeting to improve both the \textit{specificity} and \textit{diversity}.
Extensive experiments show that our method can boost the distillation
performance in various downstream tasks such as sentiment analysis, linguistic
acceptability, and information extraction. Furthermore, we show that the
generated texts can be directly used for distilling other language models and
outperform the SOTA methods, making our method more appealing in a general DFKD
setting. Our code is available at
https://gitee.com/mindspore/models/tree/master/research/nlp/DFKD\_T3. | [
0.0103450743,
0.0946222171,
0.004263076,
0.0304723121,
-0.0214276146,
0.0205058195,
-0.0407504328,
0.0538213365,
-0.0398228541,
-0.0252791308,
0.0008789961,
-0.0056177364,
-0.0081612673,
0.0537816435,
0.023395678,
-0.0344360732,
0.0055459356,
-0.0054879766,
0.0215530507,
-0.0157255866,
0.0304233525,
0.008258326,
0.041877225,
0.0050749979,
-0.0173336342,
-0.0192777999,
-0.0233193748,
0.0098619377,
-0.0176717974,
0.0147343734,
0.0230649915,
0.0649745315,
0.0463398173,
-0.0217018463,
0.0000022958,
-0.0210404843,
-0.0280589256,
0.0075447839,
-0.0325160623,
-0.0024539367,
0.0681625158,
-0.0255209077,
0.0372720137,
0.0259750281,
-0.0370470844,
-0.0265961923,
0.0254043564,
0.0614709966,
0.0867827609,
0.0912559107,
-0.018858932,
-0.026617853,
0.0366609991,
-0.0577848591,
-0.0096571501,
0.0127919549,
-0.0013508485,
0.0041305791,
-0.0355754755,
0.0338454209,
-0.0513638519,
0.0210050959,
0.0044741691,
0.0073186653,
0.024323944,
-0.0002070331,
-0.0336232446,
-0.0474689938,
0.0070904116,
0.0980516896,
-0.0211667474,
-0.0428249724,
0.0168580785,
0.0147096319,
-0.0034804223,
0.0132981911,
-0.0368874893,
0.0035194864,
0.0381420031,
0.0472853705,
-0.0001398512,
0.0073828646,
0.0191525035,
-0.0548898242,
-0.0068349186,
0.018395368,
0.0184557401,
-0.0247744396,
-0.0005102134,
0.0134682981,
-0.0182009097,
-0.0605222993,
-0.0104860505,
0.0055655106,
0.0383327939,
-0.0087191779,
-0.0573794544,
-0.039407514,
-0.0039896541,
-0.0435863361,
0.0400412232,
0.0245552901,
0.0092631569,
-0.0060457336,
-0.0191754587,
0.0331236906,
0.010086989,
0.0125152133,
-0.0406571887,
-0.0323098004,
-0.0781499296,
0.0170701779,
-0.0385252051,
0.0531382672,
-0.0662666112,
-0.0225022677,
0.0070799976,
-0.0068141711,
-0.0200786553,
-0.0345671251,
0.0764570832,
0.0263711438,
-0.0209750384,
0.0066286251,
-0.0184145607,
0.0533193089,
-0.0504390672,
-0.0133901238,
0.0036012118,
-0.0291724466,
-0.0457594916,
0.0210141912,
0.0392087065,
-0.0105482079,
0.0213303808,
0.0015802348,
-0.011384991,
-0.0431791581,
-0.031850826,
0.0380384736,
-0.0167985149,
-0.0697896779,
0.0113212671,
-0.0705141425,
0.0729202479,
-0.011816035,
0.0068100742,
-0.0953717679,
-0.0004939246,
0.0005438138,
-0.0275087636,
0.0517320409,
-0.0189425778,
0.0115209557,
0.0005791007,
-0.0033430106,
0.004321645,
0.0792174339,
0.0310826339,
0.0262971334,
0.0060025854,
-0.0102144172,
0.0209524091,
0.0173928197,
0.0605343655,
0.0441564247,
-0.0327113122,
-0.0019595239,
-0.0366737843,
-0.0463375337,
0.0664140955,
0.0808809847,
-0.0382792056,
0.0236232877,
0.047136575,
0.0091914972,
0.0480218306,
0.0572279356,
0.0217026398,
0.0452585034,
-0.0218165945,
-0.0004436302,
-0.013748657,
0.0004986844,
0.0010373099,
0.0009577246,
0.0438336618,
0.0536213443,
-0.0419888608,
-0.0400481261,
-0.0010327125,
-0.0422062613,
0.0509753674,
0.000688159,
0.0252204463,
0.0470422357,
-0.0241474975,
0.0945311859,
0.0451314449,
-0.0966810137,
0.0016780575,
-0.0291402061,
-0.0014373907,
0.0239369534,
0.0237446651,
0.0081730792,
0.0039959927,
-0.0397949629,
0.0005502235,
0.0272500627,
0.013390881,
-0.007573619,
0.031403888,
-0.0556936786,
-0.043683812,
-0.0153903626,
0.0392654575,
-0.0031209418,
0.0331301168,
0.0207623616,
0.0281369239,
-0.0618701056,
-0.014482297,
0.0075468845,
-0.0381923765,
-0.0625615492,
-0.0102939261,
0.0038418097,
0.0297892727,
0.0142415939,
-0.0351011865,
-0.0200375821,
0.0244356003,
-0.0454799719,
-0.037371438,
-0.0130636208,
-0.0366764814,
-0.1015020311,
0.0121739898,
-0.0365692005,
0.0368766151,
0.0727603585,
-0.0578252599,
-0.0624026358,
-0.0077234781,
-0.0095541431,
0.0410080738,
-0.0412390679,
0.002924846,
0.004443781,
0.0288109314,
0.0055135982,
0.051918637,
-0.024478754,
-0.0238462724,
-0.0398839451,
-0.0006585395,
0.0157425329,
0.0174612198,
-0.0513864756,
0.0173634049,
-0.0237139314,
0.0409643576,
0.0490075946,
0.0173823088,
-0.0025868798,
-0.0311299544,
-0.0815795138,
0.008259071,
-0.0279373862,
0.0298941396,
0.0441444032,
0.0365880802,
0.0127358576,
0.0171342399,
-0.0739921629,
-0.0153986085,
0.0161470026,
-0.0128155332,
0.019634055,
-0.0181112345,
0.014952084,
-0.0203926731,
-0.0225610845,
0.0245132819,
0.0695309266,
-0.0739601403,
-0.0057443087,
-0.0036921285,
0.0476864018,
-0.0355543755,
0.0391733907,
0.0081925448,
-0.0471698642,
-0.0347954929,
-0.0308233406,
0.037038222,
0.0197385773,
0.0088110771,
0.029026594,
0.0151097504,
0.0092824986,
-0.0677428693,
0.0356540866,
-0.0595745444,
0.0292228609,
-0.0006055561,
-0.0535050929,
0.0137750283,
0.0864913464,
-0.0151448017,
-0.0352721401,
-0.0880520642,
-0.0383814164,
0.0015049255,
-0.0195502061,
-0.0114152292,
0.0181279965,
-0.0123616308,
0.0064399159,
-0.0290269516,
-0.0391565934,
0.0460092761,
-0.0443090312,
0.0016721442,
-0.0474934876,
-0.0132806832,
-0.0291742459,
0.0455504246,
0.0019238506,
0.0149452342,
0.0463712364,
0.031385541,
-0.0266406946,
0.007485948,
-0.0109155672,
-0.0301265344,
0.0362279266,
-0.0205343198,
0.0193908866,
-0.0037741114,
-0.036730729,
-0.0127985645,
-0.0266382284,
0.0173367485,
0.0329349451,
0.0600217544,
-0.0219987314,
-0.017946396,
-0.0228835735,
-0.0014994596,
0.0516660511,
-0.0041189506,
0.0071098474,
-0.0205797385,
0.0612709709,
0.0382010043,
0.0052641551,
-0.0016043275,
-0.0148373842,
-0.0105010988,
0.0583213866,
0.0058395974,
-0.0012855307,
-0.0125482203,
0.0104958424,
0.023776548,
0.0077534951,
-0.0195442345,
-0.0217880514,
0.0471521579,
-0.0048686606,
-0.0377857238,
0.1017756239,
0.0085578291,
-0.0327611044,
0.0015539533,
0.0349626318,
0.088482894,
0.0001992824,
0.0203213561,
-0.0580752939,
-0.0423257388,
0.0015838518,
0.0252561998,
0.0304327533,
-0.0187289286,
-0.0148343202,
-0.0981703177,
0.0030816381,
-0.009596929,
0.0127656562,
-0.0632892475,
-0.0182148498,
-0.0103128385,
-0.0207820367,
-0.0260469615,
-0.0117627131,
0.0094921002,
0.0452757366,
0.0108200954,
-0.0305585787,
-0.0578489415,
0.0106250541,
0.0168199427,
0.0497187451,
0.0677983686,
0.047916811,
0.0207662918,
-0.0135162631,
-0.0134925302,
-0.0123831639,
-0.0308605358,
-0.0134704923,
0.0879602805,
-0.0032826918,
0.0011504333,
0.0250634421,
0.0317506343,
-0.0698005334,
0.0058512865,
-0.0046294397,
0.0502317548,
0.0383997597,
-0.0621523485,
-0.010613854,
-0.0513741635,
0.0249525271,
0.1100128666,
0.05444213,
-0.0364831984,
-0.0414580591,
-0.024623001,
-0.0006937934,
-0.0471813008,
0.0000303784,
-0.0156580806,
0.0027380816,
-0.0186008681,
-0.0944236144,
-0.0300521739,
-0.0041466826,
0.0249228273,
-0.011570232,
-0.0147422869,
0.0009191624,
0.001379084,
-0.0440498665,
0.0097375391,
-0.0192179289,
-0.0410877652,
-0.0365740396,
-0.0348087102,
0.0073683048,
-0.0157900322,
-0.0247345697,
-0.0051899147,
-0.1015358865,
-0.038187027,
-0.0119537292,
0.0433483236,
0.0182721708,
0.0527567454,
-0.0075068972,
-0.0115226507,
0.0740841776,
0.0395962074,
-0.0567475706,
0.0276754741,
0.0470313802,
0.0097632241,
0.0372723974,
0.0529700331,
-0.0200433917,
0.0510668866,
0.0055384017,
0.0617508627,
-0.0069580344,
-0.0136218024,
0.001045707,
0.0456525199,
0.0344363973,
0.0194459874,
-0.0058470252,
-0.0293535963,
-0.0136921173,
-0.0067030913,
0.0020389424,
-0.1129313186,
0.0358147956,
0.0318964012,
0.0098566525,
-0.0037794008,
0.0439374335,
-0.0033597939,
0.0090348627,
-0.0411261916,
-0.0074913283,
0.0198000036,
-0.0134331724,
0.0436612107,
0.0063358257,
-0.0002486366,
-0.0208067801,
0.0015699794,
-0.0148178898,
-0.0484540947,
0.0196952764,
0.020862231,
0.0228778645,
0.0087363515,
0.0305438489,
-0.0357923284,
-0.0189597588,
-0.0549529679,
0.0312000848,
-0.00213542,
0.0165841989,
0.0826579854,
-0.0172684882,
-0.0111796251,
-0.0161431246,
0.0223877486,
0.0025575,
0.0170069207,
0.0122668277,
-0.0030585269,
-0.0291110445,
-0.0324479342,
0.1072055846,
0.0042282674,
0.0417032689,
-0.0173693299,
0.0387295187,
-0.0589219108,
-0.0278460439,
0.0038475806,
0.0034734297,
0.0258505996,
0.0165546201,
-0.0279122051,
-0.0823446512,
0.0070759016,
-0.0215853713,
0.0054532574,
-0.0071224682,
0.0525850393,
0.0330498628,
-0.0181306619,
-0.0145113422,
-0.0402171984,
-0.0072763362,
0.0294767097,
-0.0433373787,
0.0063256077,
-6.967229955e-33,
0.0208229292,
0.0384611934,
-0.0219292976,
-0.0450340807,
-0.0264530499,
-0.0054597133,
-0.028240798,
-0.0213044826,
-0.0289321616,
0.0313273072,
-0.0319909789,
0.0409820862,
-0.0059372392,
0.0817148611,
-0.0394074358,
0.002983917,
0.0721607208,
-0.0136837605,
-0.0405408554,
0.0734487027,
0.0539777428,
0.0474169962,
0.0394394584,
-0.0391579121,
0.0141916433,
-0.020816626,
-0.0124221481,
0.0104966573,
0.042872034,
0.0010063918,
-0.0200782605,
0.053100884,
0.0062089968,
-0.0555839948,
-0.0291969925,
0.0383876078,
-0.0842290372,
-0.0471893959,
0.0154423509,
-0.0705379471,
-0.0175269917,
-0.0197466966,
0.0476050451,
-0.0198389888,
0.0300479233,
-0.0240658168,
-0.0025207624,
-0.0075613656,
-0.0094234897,
-0.0637067258,
-0.0517487042,
-0.0003894182,
-0.0055113412,
-0.0591108836,
0.043425478,
0.0443522371,
-0.015386234,
0.038942676,
-0.0483440049,
-0.0002460731,
0.0219037905,
0.0499844253,
0.0327708609,
-0.0259178635,
0.002388305,
0.0394284762,
-0.0417962261,
-0.0066000628,
-0.0404940434,
0.0116227921,
0.0263837408,
0.0580206551,
-0.0040285168,
0.0541232936,
0.0420760587,
-0.0395472795,
-0.0430892631,
0.0323079228,
-0.0116158035,
0.0053888923,
-0.0013090599,
0.0004966682,
-0.029676199,
-0.0431091003,
-0.0485323444,
-0.0199083108,
-0.0007286278,
-0.0196500216,
0.0331115983,
0.0258526336,
-0.0485425554,
-0.0426979288,
0.0156797934,
-0.0625789091,
-0.0013198177,
0.0739407465,
-0.0484635495,
0.0081934426,
0.0323931873,
0.0025714198,
-0.0681356713,
-0.0030725866,
0.0164939184,
0.0263536852,
-0.0222789198,
0.0026261641,
0.0385298766,
0.045936022,
-0.0601867102,
0.0082463454,
-0.0425966755,
0.0390639603,
-0.0047952468,
0.0791861564,
0.0083237374,
0.0193831008,
-0.0046385503,
0.0018017214,
0.0304823332,
0.0120004434,
-0.0191337746,
0.0108942511,
0.0299196299,
0.0160239656,
-0.0147669604,
-0.0163525864,
-0.0367823951,
-0.0038490596,
0.0458305478,
-0.0439788848,
0.0071937121,
0.0118206823,
2.876e-7,
0.0356467329,
0.0372441635,
-0.0025674629,
-0.0239757169,
0.0135800596,
0.0456270613,
0.0273355469,
0.0458845235,
0.0089432895,
-0.0488087088,
-0.0163981803,
0.0440967418,
0.0460620485,
0.0100213764,
-0.0907254741,
0.0111744665,
-0.0230682585,
-0.0091199763,
0.0239969976,
-0.0154461376,
0.0501985066,
0.1098382697,
0.0238183979,
-0.0145182088,
-0.0043612663,
0.0285312794,
0.0574801266,
-0.0226983372,
0.0133264633,
0.0424598977,
0.0127114803,
-0.0305603836,
-0.0236552116,
-0.0052460097,
-0.0533418246,
0.0307166893,
-0.0189576186,
0.0933187455,
0.0245487038,
-0.0355946161,
0.0103304358,
-0.0213188045,
-0.0160096008,
-0.0555039123,
0.0857261792,
-0.0477208607,
-0.0180198699,
-0.02919228,
-0.0377548486,
0.0110360775,
0.0044749309,
-0.008448218,
0.0149506619,
0.0332435779,
0.011340322,
0.0020822356,
-0.0355414823,
-0.0717168152,
-0.0149365617,
-0.0243863296,
-0.0249860995,
-0.0455535538,
-0.0162446741,
-0.0203404389,
0.0166478101,
-0.030154556,
0.0271035228,
2.755437737e-34,
0.0316752754,
0.0040997886,
-0.0049911742,
-0.0146229519,
0.0000729647,
-0.035939876,
-0.0254440866,
-0.0238135885,
-0.0168068241,
-0.0751562342,
-0.0207586475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01684v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01684v1 | CASE: Commonsense-Augmented Score with an Expanded Answer Space | 2023-11-03T03:15:26 | 2023-11-03T03:15:26 | Wenkai Chen, Sahithya Ravi, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs have demonstrated impressive zero-shot performance on NLP tasks thanks
to the knowledge they acquired in their training. In multiple-choice QA tasks,
the LM probabilities are used as an imperfect measure of the plausibility of
each answer choice. One of the major limitations of the basic score is that it
treats all words as equally important. We propose CASE, a Commonsense-Augmented
Score with an Expanded Answer Space. CASE addresses this limitation by
assigning importance weights for individual words based on their semantic
relations to other words in the input. The dynamic weighting approach
outperforms basic LM scores, not only because it reduces noise from unimportant
words, but also because it informs the model of implicit commonsense knowledge
that may be useful for answering the question. We then also follow prior work
in expanding the answer space by generating lexically-divergent answers that
are conceptually-similar to the choices. When combined with answer space
expansion, our method outperforms strong baselines on 5 commonsense benchmarks.
We further show these two approaches are complementary and may be especially
beneficial when using smaller LMs. | [
0.0285525899,
0.0231870189,
-0.0048580286,
0.0002090457,
-0.0156246945,
-0.0016591558,
-0.0454073101,
0.0277767833,
0.0245604329,
-0.0720287785,
0.0140161477,
0.0133865727,
-0.0266359858,
-0.0061808676,
0.0314612687,
-0.0177769717,
0.0400823504,
0.0000479692,
-0.0137466211,
-0.0264615063,
-0.0075893342,
0.0018040453,
-0.0284292884,
0.0133533068,
0.0181718394,
-0.0273443609,
-0.0023129452,
-0.028932672,
0.0245422944,
-0.0145373866,
-0.0216470938,
0.0472908691,
-0.0036609902,
-0.0222677886,
0.0000018865,
-0.0595316403,
0.0319573097,
-0.021762928,
-0.0192900375,
-0.0181916412,
-0.0276646148,
0.0456333049,
0.0299237967,
0.0020894757,
-0.0575622581,
0.0223204698,
0.0282454249,
0.0152221527,
0.0502298214,
0.0328439362,
0.0131820897,
-0.0110157225,
0.0017153533,
-0.0043836939,
0.0900725946,
-0.0723763034,
0.0177750755,
0.0368093997,
-0.0052973996,
-0.0048476686,
-0.0117363511,
0.0258772224,
0.009462052,
-0.0332707874,
0.0329125784,
0.0313032977,
-0.0302134678,
0.0338715352,
-0.0155165261,
0.1116234437,
0.0048610764,
-0.0190004241,
-0.027134981,
-0.0265630651,
0.0340789817,
0.0399199761,
-0.0559008308,
0.0115980962,
0.0254341438,
0.0132849114,
0.0469644405,
0.0098737963,
0.0118145747,
0.0574711859,
0.0345693603,
0.0624579303,
0.0012014785,
-0.014048948,
0.020279957,
0.0225658435,
-0.0335542001,
-0.0600965992,
0.0058165095,
0.0801045746,
-0.0212724619,
0.0330639854,
-0.0057312534,
0.0046050511,
0.0539543703,
-0.0751171932,
0.0476917624,
0.0419210903,
0.0100222519,
0.0409981906,
-0.04077553,
0.0243384615,
0.0179055743,
-0.0095624719,
-0.0536293238,
-0.0011311352,
-0.0673327148,
-0.0287749581,
0.0241199061,
0.0926081017,
-0.0355786793,
-0.005163522,
-0.0301732589,
0.0184931066,
-0.0136542488,
-0.0125421518,
0.0332815424,
0.0594064444,
-0.0286679156,
0.0005952246,
-0.0731387734,
0.0540510081,
-0.0620152876,
0.0686660334,
0.0152196381,
-0.0154547328,
-0.0180662889,
0.0072292439,
0.0236073099,
-0.004226448,
0.0179412086,
0.0642255545,
-0.0402540639,
-0.0285756495,
-0.0036382459,
-0.0220811255,
0.0055430811,
-0.0185876191,
-0.0366398543,
-0.0632621124,
-0.0059628729,
0.0148250675,
-0.0071554054,
0.015841024,
0.0139278695,
0.0562373698,
-0.0190123897,
0.0845207199,
0.0205962341,
-0.0032126408,
0.0219615865,
0.0223116204,
0.0243342277,
0.0540998243,
-0.0048378692,
-0.0145493466,
0.0513138026,
-0.0039965236,
0.0258915089,
-0.0079093743,
0.0065451176,
0.0219636913,
-0.002302164,
0.0289230254,
-0.0333499499,
0.0346236788,
0.0331173688,
-0.0043864301,
-0.0128495479,
-0.0023454437,
0.0638684183,
0.0883391127,
0.0119740823,
0.0094556324,
0.0031858434,
-0.001664356,
0.0028119637,
0.0212696083,
-0.0261664037,
0.0408287197,
-0.0891349167,
0.0054900432,
0.0016801317,
-0.0143191544,
-0.0326411165,
-0.0208904892,
0.0002916561,
0.009235003,
0.0059238058,
0.0282407962,
0.0025885585,
0.0061703459,
-0.005603123,
0.1087331101,
0.0113883875,
-0.0526740924,
0.0258606337,
-0.025581453,
0.0316570327,
0.0273899361,
0.0367301106,
-0.0259570573,
-0.0577659719,
0.0086072041,
-0.0066215391,
0.0541998148,
0.0327930152,
-0.0406603292,
0.0161967967,
-0.035643477,
-0.0003699334,
0.0160436742,
-0.003197877,
-0.0115394518,
0.0132695064,
0.0209271144,
-0.0106210541,
-0.0698544532,
0.0048963176,
0.0228012335,
-0.0034014583,
-0.0614651963,
0.0401751101,
-0.0384682566,
0.0315581821,
0.0373044461,
0.0245927423,
0.022938136,
0.0202269051,
-0.0189461559,
-0.0460115783,
-0.008267262,
-0.0230393466,
-0.0503346361,
0.0562183596,
-0.0344320685,
-0.0360700674,
0.0170096178,
-0.0388561115,
-0.0431161411,
-0.003606153,
-0.0106982561,
0.000578207,
-0.067220673,
-0.0346562155,
-0.0043990975,
-0.0040633655,
-0.0617359281,
0.1056934521,
-0.0096938424,
0.0454218723,
-0.0189667549,
-0.0145785436,
0.0161489714,
-0.0383725539,
-0.0053245258,
-0.0379117131,
0.0107470555,
0.0103865275,
0.0041701607,
0.0334848277,
-0.0527719148,
-0.0071717231,
-0.0750129223,
0.0004909554,
-0.0009355719,
0.0143030416,
0.0037986124,
0.004945802,
0.0103266938,
-0.0126339709,
-0.0579309054,
0.0174521022,
0.0277654026,
0.0119688967,
0.0448423401,
0.0225023776,
0.0520538017,
-0.00987921,
-0.0020482617,
-0.0182628371,
0.0202877261,
0.012549853,
0.0772278905,
-0.0292730425,
0.0284466036,
-0.0617081001,
-0.0085683009,
0.0146295251,
-0.032926172,
0.0126008671,
-0.0038844673,
0.0006724186,
0.0381219387,
-0.0033743032,
-0.0120322295,
0.0580050908,
-0.0211511552,
-0.0558128506,
0.0080135306,
-0.0125221806,
-0.005250616,
-0.0124569051,
-0.0162075758,
-0.0114975395,
0.0499925017,
0.0076041771,
-0.0318526998,
-0.0502321534,
0.014591191,
0.0144257946,
-0.0322205722,
-0.0696827918,
0.0267798435,
-0.0392890722,
0.0441557504,
-0.0078075272,
-0.0344012082,
0.0964500979,
-0.0092956284,
0.0307138003,
-0.0536404215,
0.0045076604,
-0.051613979,
0.0336343795,
-0.0539409891,
-0.0291771162,
-0.0211703666,
-0.0186084472,
-0.0313310809,
-0.0459717922,
0.0038036332,
-0.064480491,
0.0781941488,
-0.058658611,
0.026270533,
-0.0080381818,
-0.0282496586,
-0.0243390147,
-0.0430786498,
-0.0146982986,
0.0106655825,
-0.0443789624,
0.0177057087,
-0.0252382252,
-0.0310184602,
0.0372967459,
-0.0195363872,
-0.0058950041,
-0.0159912016,
-0.0136143919,
0.0754553601,
0.0668119192,
0.0885690898,
0.0289051328,
0.0218384974,
0.0027654902,
0.0478281677,
0.0489791222,
-0.0154836299,
0.0362515114,
0.0335561298,
0.0313441232,
-0.058009699,
-0.0051259967,
0.0524443686,
0.0478516854,
-0.0168980639,
-0.014641216,
0.0846265256,
0.0517304838,
-0.0190459341,
0.0132073369,
-0.0414830707,
0.0123969046,
0.0359083153,
0.0466968678,
-0.0545793921,
-0.0615537092,
-0.0071608759,
0.0197769832,
-0.0437559113,
-0.0717078149,
0.0110849263,
-0.1191659272,
-0.0187592693,
-0.0240392834,
-0.0579366833,
-0.0059269718,
-0.0602907874,
0.0169412103,
-0.0016943881,
-0.0033713235,
0.0024088402,
-0.0053938683,
0.0147978831,
0.0059813797,
0.0006102844,
-0.0366189592,
0.0555932075,
-0.0203890521,
0.056419909,
0.050050877,
0.0281765759,
-0.032257881,
-0.0551249683,
-0.0146696009,
-0.0833863616,
0.0263171662,
-0.0438200273,
-0.0043587289,
-0.0057458845,
-0.0022971262,
-0.0357090682,
0.0418646112,
-0.0646075532,
-0.023084851,
0.0217033681,
0.0776166394,
-0.0271264743,
0.0059714555,
-0.0281496979,
-0.0023237485,
0.0163066629,
0.0876720026,
0.0335208215,
-0.0090400819,
-0.0158812124,
-0.0497559868,
-0.0268335845,
-0.0277317334,
-0.0495960377,
-0.0015311025,
0.0050350493,
0.0147347953,
-0.0657755956,
-0.042332571,
0.0388003103,
0.0224481728,
-0.021010343,
0.043711938,
-0.0237063766,
0.0079126777,
-0.0497987196,
0.0296733808,
-0.035161566,
-0.0115364585,
0.007871178,
0.0133149587,
0.0420059301,
-0.0076422673,
-0.0237488486,
0.016027309,
-0.0326169282,
-0.0430351309,
-0.0354144834,
0.0502810441,
0.0202533919,
-0.0265920926,
-0.0275452696,
-0.0644040182,
0.0825925767,
0.0292658843,
-0.02571119,
0.0332217962,
0.0044062757,
0.0113716414,
0.019274313,
0.0523888916,
-0.0458352119,
-0.0180477165,
0.0219779834,
0.1024472639,
-0.0505270623,
-0.0282761473,
-0.0091400901,
0.0151540292,
0.0038017773,
0.0167102218,
0.0193442386,
-0.0084839435,
0.0153778447,
-0.0187670048,
-0.0284451898,
-0.0005113637,
-0.0132387364,
0.0225470886,
-0.0380222797,
-0.03328152,
0.0374419242,
-0.0736766905,
0.0475265831,
-0.0124315415,
0.0223032478,
0.0679661855,
-0.0065024472,
-0.0145717934,
-0.0220299158,
-0.0233918522,
-0.0377233475,
-0.0020413871,
0.0351918563,
0.0260825884,
0.0362359509,
-0.0002058255,
0.0037975295,
-0.0103642093,
-0.0136861401,
-0.0727766082,
0.0155984713,
-0.0118355248,
0.0819557309,
0.0083017685,
-0.0018954935,
0.0189505443,
0.0080829728,
-0.0199157801,
-0.0001664874,
0.0032419865,
0.0014713358,
-0.0149359358,
0.0759010538,
0.0437981635,
-0.0002241321,
0.0305374991,
0.0809335187,
-0.0493827611,
0.019996373,
-0.0106716435,
-0.0088257091,
-0.0304250326,
-0.0102647757,
0.0181383714,
0.0850636214,
0.0263905544,
0.0468943529,
-0.0888289437,
-0.0477801859,
0.0385410115,
0.0216044113,
0.0100022275,
-0.0122395903,
0.0250861701,
0.0613048002,
0.0367980488,
-0.0498035736,
-0.0378345102,
0.0268051755,
-0.0998138562,
-0.0138963405,
-0.0212111287,
-6.513622113e-33,
-0.0353875943,
-0.0855861306,
0.0104299458,
0.0106303496,
-0.0047379751,
0.0283402205,
-0.023458872,
0.0066427095,
-0.0370375402,
0.0103635145,
-0.0308327712,
0.0326177031,
-0.0056614117,
0.0245330464,
0.0287486799,
-0.0415279344,
-0.0251533836,
0.0113736996,
-0.0220323,
-0.0053777569,
0.0198812466,
-0.0120122433,
0.0500515923,
0.0057353117,
0.045231279,
-0.0014999115,
0.0140766464,
0.0279022027,
-0.0338200741,
0.0477677509,
-0.036039684,
0.0971777737,
0.0463312753,
-0.0443455651,
0.0179705322,
0.0296473093,
-0.056132488,
-0.0839101747,
0.0395118855,
-0.0422011092,
-0.0111309942,
-0.0244492348,
0.0397676118,
0.0254643932,
-0.0264604036,
-0.0153461816,
0.0356354602,
-0.0511277094,
-0.0415606163,
-0.0357814431,
0.0013451226,
0.0060231942,
0.0029327353,
-0.005286043,
-0.0510965809,
-0.0084395027,
-0.0177995209,
0.0141010024,
-0.0436571799,
0.0075121191,
0.0312716961,
0.0263306964,
0.033414945,
-0.0169932321,
-0.0155943688,
0.046909485,
-0.0388182141,
-0.0516399369,
-0.0262320358,
0.0012125991,
-0.0164447073,
0.0054802503,
0.0615161173,
0.082701616,
0.0504990779,
0.0425815396,
-0.0661314204,
0.0770233199,
0.0356052928,
0.049973283,
0.0138347978,
0.0009684657,
-0.0263343249,
-0.0088499179,
-0.0725319609,
0.0053553847,
-0.0583241135,
-0.016571179,
0.0084619187,
-0.0187067986,
-0.0423862226,
0.0137658603,
0.0079383506,
-0.0227984283,
-0.0033713568,
0.0061512035,
0.0250987671,
0.0114580868,
0.0171521138,
-0.0036028821,
-0.0571369641,
0.0236036088,
0.0285396818,
0.0006176599,
-0.0023161448,
0.007743991,
-0.0126193855,
-0.0148705672,
-0.0368085094,
-0.0266279317,
0.0190720875,
-0.0227465462,
-0.012251257,
0.0187754743,
0.0202394109,
0.0083970148,
0.010260947,
0.026583733,
-0.0070793158,
-0.0240050107,
0.0245274361,
-0.0326157473,
0.0055491733,
0.0227562245,
-0.0406568609,
0.0301473849,
-0.0067925476,
-0.0116244284,
-0.0116887037,
-0.0320578739,
-0.0148511771,
0.0570480265,
2.59e-7,
0.044306688,
0.0324495956,
-0.0102863377,
0.0093698567,
-0.0015981524,
0.0428957194,
0.0016408446,
0.0416289382,
0.0414788425,
-0.0500741303,
-0.0101130353,
0.0416080095,
0.0228328258,
0.0328270346,
-0.0716269389,
-0.0063021788,
-0.0312767327,
-0.0070252572,
-0.0210609548,
-0.00471933,
0.0693353638,
0.065026857,
0.0177344717,
-0.0271024257,
-0.0030817306,
-0.0442121029,
0.0368403904,
-0.0019172322,
-0.0121220723,
-0.0142923119,
0.0435931496,
-0.0076065636,
0.0066483053,
0.0539642386,
-0.0179823358,
0.0000996863,
0.0116653945,
0.0313274525,
-0.0109315766,
-0.1026172042,
-0.0330340564,
-0.0557396077,
0.0415040739,
-0.0325653926,
0.0927015692,
-0.0604819171,
-0.0417231843,
-0.0246425383,
-0.038668938,
-0.015685644,
0.0162104964,
-0.0146675119,
-0.0295428503,
-0.0164393149,
0.0036293778,
0.0181133281,
-0.0370069295,
-0.0622636341,
-0.0309688281,
0.0043622535,
-0.0074399565,
-0.0362767018,
-0.0125747696,
-0.0669677779,
0.0103533128,
-0.0924154148,
-0.0088573787,
2.124622469e-34,
-0.0000670666,
0.0124102058,
0.0211943351,
0.0178518388,
0.0055765086,
0.0206173211,
-0.0189198218,
0.0081659174,
0.0487931781,
-0.0895658657,
0.0030608885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01677v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01677v2 | DialogBench: Evaluating LLMs as Human-like Dialogue Systems | 2023-11-03T02:59:56 | 2024-03-29T11:35:30 | Jiao Ou, Junda Lu, Che Liu, Yihong Tang, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable breakthroughs in new
dialogue capabilities by leveraging instruction tuning, which refreshes human
impressions of dialogue systems. The long-standing goal of dialogue systems is
to be human-like enough to establish long-term connections with users.
Therefore, there has been an urgent need to evaluate LLMs as human-like
dialogue systems. In this paper, we propose DialogBench, a dialogue evaluation
benchmark that contains 12 dialogue tasks to probe the capabilities of LLMs as
human-like dialogue systems should have. Specifically, we prompt GPT-4 to
generate evaluation instances for each task. We first design the basic prompt
based on widely used design principles and further mitigate the existing biases
to generate higher-quality evaluation instances. Our extensive tests on English
and Chinese DialogBench of 26 LLMs show that instruction tuning improves the
human likeness of LLMs to a certain extent, but most LLMs still have much room
for improvement as human-like dialogue systems. Interestingly, results also
show that the positioning of assistant AI can make instruction tuning weaken
the human emotional perception of LLMs and their mastery of information about
human daily life. | [
0.0475318693,
0.0559293628,
-0.0252275895,
0.0418483578,
-0.0191278514,
0.0110816564,
0.0165942144,
-0.0095689828,
0.029958846,
-0.0121679436,
-0.0853481591,
-0.0501421727,
-0.0125970291,
0.0277152378,
0.0106148273,
-0.1022263244,
0.0383727103,
-0.0179149024,
0.0265707206,
-0.002295143,
0.0184485503,
0.0038808733,
-0.037179485,
0.0505222045,
-0.0049638706,
-0.0237615313,
-0.0446805097,
0.0119012529,
0.0289538968,
-0.0381428152,
0.0024241703,
0.0431746133,
-0.0029487959,
0.0140822856,
0.0000018688,
-0.0414751992,
0.0596470498,
-0.0329352058,
-0.0542628095,
0.0271242931,
0.0345965549,
0.0357067622,
-0.0078514842,
0.0126647772,
-0.0408926792,
-0.0146171497,
0.0230728406,
0.0499082692,
0.1037791818,
0.0840456933,
-0.0040021855,
0.0000866073,
-0.0125209168,
-0.0212156642,
-0.0119264163,
-0.0933866575,
-0.034777727,
0.005909123,
0.038068451,
-0.0104614794,
0.001372681,
0.0046167844,
0.0370549969,
-0.040557079,
-0.0080493428,
0.0179691389,
-0.0485473722,
-0.0102262776,
-0.0493776649,
0.0986478478,
0.0331886522,
0.0191491302,
-0.0295356084,
-0.007736159,
0.0262703933,
-0.0379858837,
-0.0441979356,
-0.0041555488,
-0.0011791399,
-0.0104534831,
-0.0232209247,
0.0219326355,
-0.0208694078,
0.0167807657,
0.0134813292,
0.0447181389,
-0.0027550049,
-0.0356352925,
0.013186004,
-0.0089998366,
-0.0094795916,
-0.0466886722,
0.0103706708,
0.0253114775,
-0.0799870417,
0.026982652,
-0.0389842615,
0.0453822166,
0.0154843023,
-0.0076459888,
0.0623059273,
0.0649514943,
-0.0200974327,
0.0420718305,
0.0355118699,
0.120183073,
0.0292693898,
-0.0015625153,
-0.0542905033,
0.0148278903,
-0.0495104231,
0.0006913648,
-0.0578057617,
0.0072337147,
-0.0482718311,
-0.0240606666,
-0.0219404008,
0.04751518,
-0.0101604369,
0.0184718892,
0.0036249205,
0.0199487396,
-0.0278426707,
-0.0183988437,
-0.0539057106,
0.007255638,
-0.0564310104,
0.0067953044,
0.0361843705,
-0.0818473399,
-0.0172047671,
0.0358523242,
-0.0138621097,
-0.0068089552,
-0.0186281297,
0.0588232875,
-0.0068780761,
-0.0134160072,
0.0033733458,
0.0086411601,
-0.0177872907,
-0.0690659508,
-0.0381626748,
0.0098542562,
0.0215227753,
-0.0210381299,
0.0049223402,
-0.0054621114,
0.013272794,
0.0184820946,
0.0196679737,
0.0560166016,
0.0238145329,
0.0296432748,
0.0320907868,
0.0241534337,
-0.0359438099,
0.0432456508,
0.0268792287,
0.0476636738,
0.0309789311,
-0.0154660819,
0.0414812006,
0.0341961347,
-0.0269918069,
0.00540249,
0.0212222058,
0.0357947014,
-0.0429482199,
0.0600139387,
0.0382768996,
0.0740084946,
-0.0337262116,
-0.0053934352,
0.0771917179,
0.0644328073,
-0.0296853315,
0.0171881672,
0.0398276523,
0.0412330665,
0.0428392477,
0.0346298926,
-0.069992736,
0.0186920669,
-0.0019926925,
-0.0037548337,
0.0126693696,
-0.0043687853,
-0.0291887093,
-0.0428450294,
0.0082405088,
0.0028514944,
-0.0009959375,
0.0023692816,
-0.0148933427,
-0.0017817741,
-0.0450803563,
0.0268102586,
-0.0091352873,
-0.0610709898,
-0.0243868548,
-0.0546075329,
0.0060193124,
0.0952193365,
0.0361716896,
-0.0068037235,
-0.0465006195,
0.0002478132,
0.0016765342,
0.0654191002,
0.0869236141,
-0.0243966933,
0.0260754805,
-0.0466762781,
0.012209015,
-0.0163568947,
0.0045363917,
0.0271982141,
-0.0025489407,
-0.0046862005,
0.0089879464,
-0.0099058906,
-0.0303087085,
-0.0019686711,
-0.0159620326,
-0.025374271,
0.0008112111,
0.0082507739,
0.0369613282,
0.0240850132,
-0.0169974566,
-0.0107985903,
0.0207991954,
-0.0034994655,
-0.0010647328,
0.0511324033,
-0.0890537947,
-0.0319055356,
0.0392442197,
-0.0102957338,
-0.0226948764,
0.0316210873,
-0.0312071294,
-0.0514244251,
0.0229665563,
-0.0647280663,
0.01748541,
-0.0466815792,
0.0451354943,
-0.0105740586,
0.0131243635,
-0.0175942425,
0.0260773525,
-0.0037990867,
-0.0090405084,
0.0370179676,
0.065502964,
0.0078142807,
-0.0829502121,
-0.0052484078,
0.0120881796,
0.0087504489,
0.0230984129,
0.0075634359,
0.0231636148,
-0.0765310153,
-0.0522556752,
-0.1376201957,
0.0067484002,
-0.0127656786,
0.0123534389,
0.0308459289,
-0.007590109,
-0.0411903895,
-0.030494282,
-0.0705895722,
-0.015723262,
0.0359585583,
0.0055189095,
0.0448138714,
-0.0048157978,
-0.0084009711,
-0.0513085909,
0.0417730473,
0.0080087539,
-0.0017511238,
-0.0060824831,
0.0320669748,
-0.0468471944,
0.0118072284,
-0.0255922191,
0.013935525,
-0.0161190685,
-0.0771698579,
0.0368939787,
0.036000438,
0.0537041128,
0.0813053176,
0.0310200881,
0.0454657786,
-0.0077097197,
-0.0038633451,
-0.0457908735,
0.0508657098,
0.0170033574,
-0.0118638538,
-0.0214824788,
-0.0254745465,
0.0109586213,
0.0135601144,
0.0235743728,
0.0539437942,
-0.0464086048,
0.061013557,
0.0075805741,
-0.0578023978,
-0.0099084377,
-0.0108450418,
-0.0617207736,
0.0334391929,
-0.0203853101,
-0.0573129989,
0.0847068205,
-0.0230377167,
-0.0340319946,
-0.0418400653,
-0.0132248858,
-0.0393703319,
0.0715753138,
-0.0238545537,
0.0129967453,
0.0031870625,
-0.0241399892,
-0.0371453501,
0.0029098578,
0.0048405505,
-0.0488320403,
0.0471573472,
-0.0513840616,
-0.0355427749,
0.0100684809,
-0.0613999404,
-0.0562976673,
-0.0053057796,
-0.0403990559,
0.010671705,
0.025959,
-0.0258459542,
0.0021778743,
0.0177663136,
0.0101421196,
0.0152276652,
-0.0249655787,
0.0104479417,
-0.0128591647,
0.0237311013,
0.0578208677,
0.0367728099,
-0.0101572275,
-0.010948291,
0.0938836858,
0.0163590219,
0.0441698171,
-0.0046742,
-0.0222633537,
0.008886504,
0.00908037,
-0.0050351615,
-0.0034082658,
-0.0036186564,
0.0829955116,
-0.0349485017,
-0.0077226087,
0.1434494257,
0.0113549335,
-0.0430947393,
0.0030390981,
-0.0230924077,
0.0146860676,
0.0139888804,
0.0281958729,
-0.0677804574,
-0.0366930403,
0.0124690058,
0.0342476107,
-0.0148453712,
-0.017913308,
-0.0048240237,
-0.1226915494,
0.0321799628,
-0.0162724555,
-0.0257191565,
-0.0193919986,
-0.0092567345,
0.0134028299,
-0.006905695,
0.0589653626,
0.0201608576,
0.0098985387,
-0.0122209331,
-0.0035522557,
-0.0100345323,
-0.0130072813,
0.0615907386,
-0.0256223809,
0.0863194019,
0.0588238277,
0.0622127689,
0.0276544765,
-0.0284774005,
0.0103717921,
0.0037972683,
0.015902875,
0.0202102102,
0.0398296155,
-0.0108904196,
-0.0193462782,
-0.0301080681,
0.0140467212,
-0.0078096385,
0.017738305,
0.0420557857,
0.0241877697,
-0.0434895195,
-0.010189998,
-0.0136937574,
0.0266824458,
0.0211780276,
0.0860969275,
0.0504256077,
-0.0590826161,
-0.0327053033,
-0.0376587175,
0.001048038,
-0.0456572473,
-0.0219527129,
0.0027002478,
-0.0076771649,
0.002632234,
-0.0717427805,
-0.0685508177,
-0.0023699692,
0.0251433421,
0.0036030794,
-0.0387262441,
-0.0132685984,
0.0280788522,
0.0296309758,
0.0191798545,
-0.0306049362,
0.0297322273,
-0.070103839,
-0.0238788947,
0.0612281077,
-0.0271031726,
0.0091552911,
0.0377379097,
-0.0365191214,
-0.0545958616,
-0.0231189504,
0.0491887145,
0.0239460841,
0.0434841663,
-0.0113145784,
-0.0247286167,
-0.0191741306,
-0.0085820872,
-0.0294715818,
0.0074058524,
0.0282614231,
0.0520408526,
-0.0211422294,
0.034557648,
-0.0154035939,
0.0333886817,
-0.0345390141,
0.0246529952,
-0.0280855093,
-0.1138326377,
0.015508797,
0.0535304211,
0.0098222652,
0.0049962178,
-0.0009631132,
-0.0080926381,
0.0253108442,
-0.0251058619,
-0.0233056191,
-0.0522052981,
-0.0180937517,
0.0169611331,
-0.0137791792,
0.0055375076,
-0.0344248936,
-0.0472726338,
0.037734922,
-0.0269180685,
0.0042822324,
0.0128979422,
0.0183723085,
-0.017749656,
-0.002492253,
-0.015315285,
0.0087550459,
-0.0042343959,
0.0453927107,
0.0222227816,
0.106742844,
0.0062944549,
-0.0476572625,
0.059956789,
0.0642830133,
-0.0558469594,
-0.0458548777,
-0.0075977095,
0.010086556,
0.0251385719,
0.0243564937,
0.0515272059,
-0.0276878048,
0.0279308483,
-0.0089612398,
0.012005995,
0.0230212137,
-0.0271013957,
0.0082794139,
0.0381442606,
-0.01511057,
0.012818886,
0.0371816531,
-0.0070391716,
0.0287352838,
0.0031284175,
0.0110420203,
-0.0608151406,
-0.0235839505,
0.0014475829,
-0.0016045908,
0.002804155,
0.0002822665,
-0.0606823415,
-0.0529206209,
-0.0024390679,
0.0309368186,
0.0164247099,
-0.0468778871,
0.0456294306,
0.028653644,
-0.0371791832,
-0.0002785808,
-0.0254994668,
0.0150284879,
-0.038539838,
0.0003886815,
-0.046902068,
-5.801613063e-33,
-0.036311686,
-0.0186268389,
0.0095285354,
-0.0000220071,
-0.0604768842,
-0.0258918144,
-0.0546137169,
0.0232300889,
-0.0253223293,
0.0138717778,
-0.0297853351,
0.0144832535,
0.0092170732,
0.0027410672,
-0.0145073673,
-0.0235780925,
0.0424918458,
-0.0124101313,
-0.0336098932,
0.0410823636,
0.0007527155,
-0.0095821954,
0.011142063,
-0.0544298217,
0.0154454038,
-0.0067762136,
-0.0406107865,
0.0342135988,
0.0032232727,
0.0569535866,
-0.0138306525,
0.0602666736,
0.0151876835,
-0.0215879846,
-0.0107456017,
0.0310956836,
-0.0202757455,
-0.0369254947,
0.0324496403,
-0.0064343056,
-0.0160435475,
-0.0287762955,
-0.0217740368,
-0.0230031367,
-0.0376222134,
0.0256031416,
-0.01113379,
-0.027165208,
0.015443868,
0.0171001181,
-0.0420359671,
0.0151046487,
-0.0301155131,
-0.0763158873,
-0.031877093,
0.0432128869,
-0.0046801763,
-0.0203758068,
-0.0156019516,
0.0157623477,
0.0162099563,
-0.005604404,
0.0434612297,
0.0070078755,
0.0019182089,
0.0449324958,
0.0449435413,
0.0317750536,
-0.0303247776,
-0.0228862688,
-0.0072452058,
0.030191822,
0.0404460095,
0.0544055402,
-0.0071677584,
-0.0170992948,
0.0166446436,
0.0337756015,
0.062334992,
0.0567649901,
0.002668215,
0.0334146842,
-0.0526036136,
0.0062152846,
-0.0357191749,
-0.0199351255,
-0.0431248844,
-0.0355148911,
0.0518069342,
0.0031704034,
-0.0080818068,
-0.0532968342,
0.0059948177,
-0.0180600993,
0.0382614098,
0.0034803192,
-0.0370244831,
0.0225162786,
-0.0116774226,
0.0052262172,
-0.0181255098,
-0.0176069289,
0.0403877012,
0.0613966733,
0.0345491804,
-0.0013500535,
-0.0024468286,
0.0115713002,
-0.0340727568,
0.0067229806,
-0.0434734896,
0.0491631106,
-0.0326638892,
-0.0035510149,
-0.0080246143,
-0.0185016263,
-0.0482354723,
0.0577669293,
-0.0139366686,
-0.0139120948,
-0.0621621087,
-0.0288359877,
0.0112689044,
-0.0023755259,
-0.0480411053,
0.0142695243,
-0.0094183404,
-0.011649671,
0.0012882382,
-0.0266883578,
-0.0097544249,
-0.0075619752,
2.598e-7,
-0.0396999568,
0.039720457,
0.0501134358,
0.0276503228,
0.0250975266,
0.0457702689,
-0.0164173096,
0.0301362127,
0.0333909355,
-0.0204173867,
0.0151790287,
0.0182311628,
0.0760470107,
0.0051710675,
-0.1238909662,
-0.0061574066,
-0.0713112503,
-0.0197495949,
-0.0366256572,
0.007293182,
0.0702112764,
0.0620041415,
-0.0080999676,
0.005445655,
-0.0040484248,
-0.036639113,
0.010678852,
-0.0330438428,
-0.0301547665,
0.0298183281,
0.0438144691,
0.0071612573,
-0.0077402471,
0.0035999415,
0.0057790657,
0.0166807994,
0.0214993134,
0.0943382829,
-0.0099497745,
-0.0712125972,
-0.0127907386,
0.0062429011,
0.0146733029,
-0.0454293378,
0.0428927578,
-0.0180683322,
-0.0080752941,
-0.0350664072,
-0.0175161269,
-0.0267405715,
0.0244538672,
-0.0397715196,
-0.0412342511,
0.0224350747,
-0.0007116331,
-0.0234951489,
0.0122249424,
-0.0531792417,
-0.0163890999,
-0.0163831152,
-0.0342211314,
-0.0581549443,
-0.0467346311,
-0.0108435582,
-0.0139994621,
-0.0381310806,
0.0011903041,
1.711565463e-34,
0.038577795,
-0.0110256989,
0.0495410562,
0.052929081,
0.0651833117,
0.0208894219,
-0.0058037555,
0.0021506327,
0.0540567264,
-0.0673381761,
-0.0076071331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01666v1 | Plot Retrieval as an Assessment of Abstract Semantic Association | 2023-11-03T02:02:43 | 2023-11-03T02:02:43 | Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Jiangnan Li, Mo Yu, Fandong Meng, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Jie Zhou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Retrieving relevant plots from the book for a query is a critical task, which
can improve the reading experience and efficiency of readers. Readers usually
only give an abstract and vague description as the query based on their own
understanding, summaries, or speculations of the plot, which requires the
retrieval model to have a strong ability to estimate the abstract semantic
associations between the query and candidate plots. However, existing
information retrieval (IR) datasets cannot reflect this ability well. In this
paper, we propose Plot Retrieval, a labeled dataset to train and evaluate the
performance of IR models on the novel task Plot Retrieval. Text pairs in Plot
Retrieval have less word overlap and more abstract semantic association, which
can reflect the ability of the IR models to estimate the abstract semantic
association, rather than just traditional lexical or semantic matching.
Extensive experiments across various lexical retrieval, sparse retrieval, dense
retrieval, and cross-encoder methods compared with human studies on Plot
Retrieval show current IR models still struggle in capturing abstract semantic
association between texts. Plot Retrieval can be the benchmark for further
research on the semantic association modeling ability of IR models. | [
-0.0193296708,
0.0066957949,
-0.0206000842,
0.0584599264,
-0.0291134603,
0.0290363152,
-0.054104656,
0.0431697369,
0.0047348975,
0.0169651359,
-0.0470879264,
0.0282916408,
0.0329688005,
0.0530560613,
-0.0158034768,
-0.0534196757,
0.0443067439,
0.046469681,
0.0079862969,
0.0594324134,
0.0053853975,
0.0196246635,
0.0057360115,
0.0135252075,
-0.0473634526,
0.0092301005,
0.0418819375,
0.0212058239,
0.0650432557,
-0.0567278676,
-0.0311970003,
-0.0395042449,
0.0610288195,
-0.0151681872,
0.0000017204,
-0.0289258361,
-0.0520522445,
0.0011538115,
0.0304322485,
0.010214515,
0.0312297028,
-0.0276150871,
0.0778306648,
-0.062151663,
-0.0025831112,
-0.0042439462,
0.0404343605,
0.0610724539,
0.008836953,
-0.0075285463,
-0.0245216861,
-0.0282767694,
-0.0042336732,
-0.0043384871,
0.0581582449,
-0.0495195426,
0.0027066541,
-0.0072984183,
0.0356345363,
0.0559109673,
-0.0586268567,
0.0600646585,
-0.0231899004,
0.0431123823,
0.0359845087,
0.0528202578,
-0.0240323544,
0.0196191426,
0.0365614407,
0.0574933104,
0.0123804361,
-0.0342601351,
-0.011890511,
-0.0009290779,
-0.0473427884,
0.1207460687,
-0.0746952817,
-0.0462026931,
-0.0334956273,
-0.0280061997,
-0.0208896957,
0.024643071,
0.031996455,
-0.0150469951,
-0.0339607224,
0.0181414559,
-0.0050299438,
-0.0276592765,
-0.0110858204,
-0.0051765791,
-0.0530732796,
0.024467621,
-0.002761374,
0.0049068583,
0.0552380793,
0.015303324,
-0.0079833865,
-0.0383825526,
0.0150659094,
-0.0146522671,
0.0174850598,
0.0149765871,
-0.0326102562,
0.064207375,
0.0029716925,
0.0241732169,
0.0031708118,
0.0051293378,
-0.0116730575,
0.014030138,
-0.0118311578,
0.002741606,
-0.0240651295,
0.0359045081,
-0.036475081,
-0.0502628945,
-0.0019429179,
-0.0135750696,
0.0239580628,
0.0092055164,
-0.0474116802,
0.0183565486,
-0.0675500482,
-0.0064028515,
-0.1031874865,
0.0329753198,
-0.0256961212,
0.0162927005,
-0.0282868613,
0.0291500837,
0.0111140385,
0.0133005157,
0.0488915667,
-0.0424708538,
-0.0148786819,
0.0291728098,
-0.0002108951,
-0.0294499286,
-0.0115083782,
-0.0895490423,
0.0310462099,
0.0103167202,
0.0078511396,
-0.0123684723,
0.039304778,
0.0160938706,
0.0089803757,
-0.0250996072,
-0.0018724991,
0.0346989334,
-0.0666471347,
0.0699161962,
0.0099347588,
-0.0051936279,
0.0651745498,
0.0290721208,
-0.0102440398,
0.010184031,
0.0122832675,
0.0267030615,
0.0358139277,
-0.017325243,
0.0032970805,
-0.0256081093,
0.016994657,
-0.0196618177,
-0.0020234287,
0.0365077183,
-0.0225196723,
0.0052126511,
-0.0068969983,
0.0654869303,
-0.0827705488,
-0.0520079806,
-0.0046722726,
0.1233725324,
0.023922801,
-0.0129858004,
0.0170488544,
0.0227962807,
-0.0178461652,
0.0033474402,
0.0128582846,
0.013808893,
0.0061103068,
0.0447081327,
0.0166650321,
-0.0564608686,
-0.0037333649,
-0.0471054725,
-0.0035847027,
0.0209955685,
0.0037717237,
-0.0117901815,
0.055996947,
0.0079018008,
-0.0408008397,
-0.031639751,
0.0163616724,
-0.0529711507,
0.0081345122,
0.0025520939,
0.0211813021,
0.037334647,
0.0657988563,
-0.0335505307,
0.0148641849,
0.0064405133,
-0.0141055128,
-0.0077592148,
0.0005683001,
-0.0297064595,
-0.0209070407,
-0.0651032105,
-0.0378690138,
-0.008792364,
-0.0235138889,
0.0402499884,
-0.0120783392,
0.020485295,
0.0032475819,
-0.0728089288,
-0.0355094634,
0.0210770238,
-0.0508301221,
-0.0304337218,
-0.0205807947,
0.0201267842,
0.0024034104,
0.0004858325,
-0.0176860634,
0.0311623812,
0.0407876335,
-0.0221036803,
0.0143357078,
0.0100292889,
0.0017591786,
-0.0093584675,
-0.0262152981,
-0.0681769326,
0.0093414458,
0.0149630168,
0.0202893652,
-0.025781408,
-0.0013016503,
-0.0471393391,
0.0323546082,
0.0107297003,
-0.0085495254,
-0.0049010203,
-0.0413856208,
-0.0474605523,
0.0538771078,
0.0104076015,
0.0606157258,
-0.0114596486,
0.0248818938,
0.0357621461,
-0.0373367295,
-0.0363076292,
-0.0129728047,
0.009784136,
-0.0123055363,
0.0218892768,
-0.028286621,
0.000026242,
0.0320219956,
-0.0509878099,
-0.0077789761,
0.0167290866,
-0.0383898392,
-0.0049379459,
-0.0025988137,
-0.0237114672,
-0.0306200348,
0.0187303256,
0.0325405374,
-0.0305510238,
-0.0016860989,
0.0332531855,
0.0249452107,
0.0181399472,
-0.0021564015,
-0.0068755019,
-0.0100118332,
0.0659320429,
0.0674338937,
-0.0218756609,
0.02327279,
0.0856733918,
-0.0243052635,
-0.0115564205,
-0.0494690835,
0.0312808119,
0.0364408083,
-0.0078860437,
-0.0463006608,
0.0147596765,
-0.0044653262,
-0.0031315284,
0.0140430462,
-0.0515194908,
-0.0765059963,
0.0313537978,
-0.041250363,
0.0156474505,
0.0550515279,
-0.0344074778,
0.0286491215,
0.0385735407,
0.0364937074,
0.0023551851,
-0.0181758497,
-0.0307893641,
0.0146315238,
0.0340148285,
-0.0901496708,
-0.0223788302,
0.0365965702,
0.0536463857,
-0.0355507731,
-0.0342853256,
0.0361426286,
-0.025019452,
0.0258507654,
-0.0750616789,
0.0326127,
-0.0389247984,
0.0625502989,
-0.013012019,
0.026457496,
-0.0184656903,
-0.0247002672,
-0.0154198082,
-0.0107470984,
0.0342849605,
-0.0451303497,
0.029959185,
0.0007743094,
0.0262821745,
0.0115980748,
-0.0270251669,
-0.0275374781,
-0.0189314447,
0.0010666617,
-0.0518826358,
0.0077908002,
-0.0033951662,
-0.0262055676,
0.0140861357,
0.0207543727,
-0.0300223082,
-0.01089093,
-0.0576430447,
0.0138048632,
0.0319763161,
0.0641639307,
-0.0084255598,
-0.0841378048,
-0.0373416133,
-0.0028044551,
0.0291775092,
-0.0502813533,
0.0064027254,
-0.0032182864,
0.0158370268,
-0.0280187577,
0.0149010289,
-0.0140208071,
-0.0157679897,
0.0087626297,
-0.0336460695,
-0.0168681666,
0.0377408825,
0.0336626507,
-0.0289427452,
-0.049945727,
-0.010152678,
0.0242940355,
0.0143465241,
-0.0039417702,
-0.0036667958,
0.0095152576,
-0.0179014727,
0.010185956,
0.0256169382,
0.0168194361,
0.0184115134,
-0.0779969618,
0.0394540057,
0.0206398442,
-0.0566192046,
-0.0235638618,
-0.0726812929,
0.0021310791,
0.0109552043,
-0.0408516787,
-0.0406916104,
-0.015531932,
-0.0187967531,
-0.0122517953,
0.0175512098,
0.014071662,
-0.0239292979,
-0.0110383546,
-0.0753656477,
0.0055155978,
0.062950477,
-0.0203988049,
-0.0220113471,
0.0223618653,
0.0265706237,
0.0293209441,
-0.0220068693,
0.1141374782,
-0.0231531039,
0.0028101902,
-0.0205061678,
-0.0066324398,
0.0142696565,
-0.0385547839,
-0.0200863853,
0.03091955,
-0.0060118102,
0.0108687272,
-0.091127418,
0.0235763434,
-0.0217626933,
0.0232085902,
0.0085664708,
0.0377761349,
-0.0260061137,
-0.0366874337,
0.0784040168,
-0.0344781876,
-0.0441581495,
-0.0001602521,
-0.0324415304,
0.0042671505,
-0.0605632029,
-0.0171179809,
0.0034004475,
0.0317880102,
0.0216622632,
0.0135280779,
0.0138038956,
-0.0374606363,
-0.0671981871,
0.0701239035,
-0.018458331,
-0.0128256306,
-0.0189827271,
-0.0173793044,
0.0529786646,
-0.0163959786,
-0.0405197218,
-0.0026117801,
-0.0213654879,
0.0169356316,
-0.0529705472,
-0.0184981357,
0.0132818911,
0.0518339165,
-0.0047553652,
-0.0146145383,
0.0941799507,
0.0313346572,
-0.0696590915,
-0.0316255018,
-0.0561738722,
0.0556127205,
-0.0496480092,
-0.0488520116,
-0.0458232723,
0.0455775857,
0.0140960654,
0.0128425295,
-0.0357892364,
-0.0145954201,
-0.0117649231,
0.0486131422,
0.0566071793,
0.0264056548,
-0.0425448343,
-0.0458589643,
-0.0516068153,
-0.0079234941,
-0.0205697622,
0.015424612,
-0.0156385172,
0.0580490828,
-0.0115048001,
-0.043824736,
-0.0320216753,
0.0245263968,
0.0329904668,
-0.0393495671,
-0.021578094,
0.034038581,
-0.0287234802,
-0.0022256263,
0.054457739,
-0.0249195546,
-0.032604862,
-0.0181812961,
0.0760702342,
0.0375286452,
0.0275813993,
0.0354407839,
0.0230725184,
-0.0145199141,
-0.003671763,
-0.0793499798,
0.0198904444,
0.0065484135,
-0.019257661,
0.0079852007,
-0.0645341575,
0.0016300754,
0.0024167562,
-0.0065843738,
-0.0186516922,
0.0035195001,
0.0185073633,
0.0232307035,
0.0583690368,
0.0344318449,
0.0157129988,
0.0036642679,
0.044258099,
-0.0019077079,
0.0127717331,
-0.0178686101,
-0.0683605224,
-0.0133624021,
0.0553739294,
0.0521847904,
0.0564448722,
0.0326291136,
-0.0102703348,
-0.0454030074,
-0.0494041964,
0.0854973048,
0.0056997561,
-0.0186609719,
0.0323699825,
0.0499429591,
0.0551245399,
0.025604995,
0.0102896718,
-0.0008378415,
0.0100555588,
-0.0371492691,
-0.0273313299,
-0.0498210713,
-5.084155963e-33,
-0.0232605487,
-0.0171717163,
0.0251686852,
0.0551593788,
-0.0166684594,
0.0235907268,
0.0084492667,
-0.0486210026,
-0.0182321612,
0.0222534165,
0.0190849341,
0.0057448619,
-0.0174679719,
-0.0008918727,
-0.0351622216,
-0.0034553716,
0.0272133946,
0.0179688241,
-0.0512456,
-0.0025291434,
0.0772070885,
0.0224488471,
-0.0185497887,
-0.0922741443,
-0.0531648733,
0.0039276946,
0.0542178191,
-0.0466353931,
0.0385954231,
0.0627643391,
-0.0380313136,
0.0423637256,
0.0304191653,
0.0366306305,
-0.0170670617,
0.059951704,
-0.0545227826,
-0.1022003442,
0.0044435174,
-0.0203982443,
-0.0063443454,
-0.0111059574,
0.0709698871,
-0.0121044079,
0.0026287315,
-0.0643022507,
0.0876307264,
0.0212186798,
-0.0431240462,
0.0102075329,
-0.0099553,
0.0230728202,
-0.017811466,
-0.002574502,
0.0713642985,
0.0150004812,
0.0255926959,
0.0420904607,
-0.0336913466,
0.0642257482,
-0.0371389352,
0.0041145538,
-0.0351611637,
0.0093678087,
-0.0004535329,
0.0862369314,
0.0014100571,
-0.0174085349,
0.0010417367,
0.0341084413,
0.0387558378,
0.0367186405,
-0.0040021292,
0.0549049862,
0.0412604176,
-0.0365474224,
-0.0116529753,
0.0875668898,
-0.0447913557,
0.0239131022,
0.0559789799,
0.0144642945,
-0.0820336044,
-0.0406986959,
-0.0192616712,
0.0258670207,
-0.0495715849,
0.0013528779,
0.030437002,
-0.0054118088,
0.0569991022,
0.0295149423,
0.0165397301,
-0.0185233392,
-0.0050059925,
-0.0054078307,
0.0103042694,
0.0541356057,
-0.0094275502,
-0.025279399,
-0.0069737309,
-0.0341116264,
-0.0041962713,
0.0137364585,
0.0180433989,
-0.0217898786,
0.0178447738,
-0.0154942414,
-0.0418703295,
-0.0445745662,
0.0122310035,
-0.1269259006,
-0.0242570303,
-0.0604835674,
0.0269734282,
0.0356153809,
0.0068544173,
0.0304472353,
-0.0445980504,
0.0061253291,
-0.0467387773,
-0.0802771598,
-0.0454163998,
-0.000463318,
0.0214657113,
0.0057105096,
0.0254102573,
-0.012793893,
0.0161323361,
-0.0644717216,
-0.0104502803,
0.0279979743,
2.573e-7,
0.0588008575,
0.0142878629,
0.0378521122,
0.0146662043,
-0.0236201081,
-0.0014092223,
-0.0131336842,
0.0115006724,
0.0349557362,
-0.0163922198,
0.0284018721,
0.0067664585,
-0.0023917858,
0.0449420623,
-0.0617460683,
-0.0210017264,
-0.0164607372,
-0.0346735679,
-0.0425829925,
0.0142804217,
0.0785020664,
0.0138953403,
0.0043277908,
0.0031941812,
-0.0048891208,
-0.0459387563,
0.0735190213,
-0.0646100566,
-0.0177596342,
0.0235517826,
-0.0466075875,
0.0531652272,
0.0207016319,
0.0353305489,
-0.0129457284,
0.0363021158,
0.098970592,
-0.0275925025,
-0.0336680524,
-0.0058516082,
0.0116207041,
0.0411014408,
-0.0092088915,
-0.0197475087,
0.0370958894,
-0.0075409324,
-0.0103900563,
0.0634254143,
-0.01851804,
0.0282501876,
0.0186570063,
0.0229698382,
-0.0510316342,
0.0080936318,
0.0343823694,
0.034614712,
0.0122218849,
-0.0489830598,
0.0350482874,
0.0530002229,
-0.0356228501,
0.0113947159,
-0.0167368222,
0.0206001252,
-0.0079156291,
-0.0116115296,
-0.0552486181,
2.033959023e-34,
-0.0059668827,
-0.0055641178,
-0.0136139421,
-0.0347122364,
0.0387227871,
-0.0486977622,
0.0066063832,
0.0193211567,
0.0091414005,
-0.0714602098,
0.0116886981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01650v1 | MARRS: Multimodal Reference Resolution System | 2023-11-03T00:48:42 | 2023-11-03T00:48:42 | Halim Cagri Ates, Shruti Bhargava, Site Li, Jiarui Lu, Siddhardha Maddula, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Anil Kumar Nalamalapu, Roman Hoang Nguyen, Melis Ozyildirim, Alkesh Patel, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Vincent Renkens, Ankit Samal, Thy Tran, Bo-Hsiang Tseng, Hong Yu, Yuan Zhang, Rong Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Successfully handling context is essential for any dialog understanding task.
This context maybe be conversational (relying on previous user queries or
system responses), visual (relying on what the user sees, for example, on their
screen), or background (based on signals such as a ringing alarm or playing
music). In this work, we present an overview of MARRS, or Multimodal Reference
Resolution System, an on-device framework within a Natural Language
Understanding system, responsible for handling conversational, visual and
background context. In particular, we present different machine learning models
to enable handing contextual queries; specifically, one to enable reference
resolution, and one to handle context via query rewriting. We also describe how
these models complement each other to form a unified, coherent, lightweight
system that can understand context while preserving user privacy. | [
0.0398719236,
-0.006598148,
-0.0062120855,
0.0241768975,
-0.0397314392,
-0.0086949803,
0.0476999618,
-0.0123788714,
-0.000002266,
-0.0809200704,
-0.0259578675,
0.0045482107,
0.0113834105,
0.0328141376,
-0.0126480479,
-0.0596930161,
0.0338378139,
-0.0323820338,
0.0052188132,
0.0315019861,
0.0148487501,
0.0370529331,
-0.0178828407,
0.0445690453,
-0.0479374044,
-0.0431624316,
-0.0296978597,
0.0380408913,
-0.0155865792,
-0.022348674,
-0.0056194337,
0.0396813862,
0.0336418636,
0.0144010605,
0.0000018511,
-0.0261667259,
-0.0108107803,
0.005614257,
-0.0162252579,
-0.0492934547,
0.0529391393,
0.0104303947,
0.0199117102,
0.0303180758,
-0.0621329583,
-0.0134105887,
0.0486911982,
0.0597974733,
0.0654240176,
0.0058112,
-0.0121206194,
-0.0310814753,
-0.0243011508,
0.0053453776,
0.0322012678,
-0.1072909236,
-0.0242861193,
0.0195178315,
0.0152908284,
-0.01817655,
-0.0021831114,
0.0256861318,
0.0088518299,
0.0221584383,
-0.018442234,
-0.00354896,
-0.025288526,
-0.0121661853,
-0.0018950355,
0.0909424275,
0.0012776898,
-0.0042265733,
0.0195730887,
0.0316337049,
0.0027428241,
-0.0096100885,
-0.0440333597,
-0.0235878173,
-0.0531358048,
-0.0100638084,
-0.0726214945,
0.0051292912,
0.0145669505,
0.0166911744,
-0.0195070989,
0.0241025127,
-0.0170162935,
0.0196590293,
-0.0041836901,
-0.0342493653,
0.0132114673,
-0.0640368685,
0.0450938269,
0.0436561778,
-0.073882103,
0.0378043689,
-0.0576711595,
-0.0119166812,
0.0113893924,
-0.0515778214,
-0.0398280695,
0.0013744704,
-0.0106488401,
0.0692755356,
0.0371305123,
0.0221549273,
0.0063845748,
-0.0050312113,
-0.0195953045,
-0.0409152322,
-0.0529330373,
0.0029946161,
-0.063564539,
0.0104294159,
-0.1239325777,
-0.0388043188,
-0.0335252658,
0.0532968789,
0.0103621902,
-0.0157333035,
-0.020484753,
0.0467564464,
-0.0279762074,
0.0197989196,
-0.0117894411,
0.0505474582,
-0.0292381402,
0.0274513122,
-0.0161248185,
-0.0899771824,
0.0130979419,
-0.0046440749,
0.0327811018,
-0.0053490996,
-0.0516656041,
0.0627053306,
-0.0159604754,
-0.0410063751,
-0.0336746946,
-0.0555014238,
-0.0245845597,
-0.0433473326,
-0.0366339609,
-0.0408754721,
0.0410114713,
-0.0115694338,
-0.0188658871,
-0.0262554064,
0.0132320076,
0.0783689171,
-0.0048006889,
0.0914589688,
0.0024488054,
0.0085582081,
0.0398296639,
0.0389327295,
-0.0029455631,
0.0630866513,
0.0293738618,
0.0044025597,
0.0482301898,
-0.0276367627,
0.0132290348,
-0.007416565,
-0.0068257903,
-0.064469181,
-0.012503691,
0.027727643,
-0.0209179595,
0.0025127244,
-0.0208555292,
0.0404604338,
-0.0134291155,
-0.0548755042,
0.0413947701,
0.0611089654,
-0.0036359022,
-0.0080375895,
-0.0154292565,
-0.0085738245,
-0.0349642374,
0.0254628286,
-0.0682254508,
0.0286142658,
-0.0339705199,
-0.0100534903,
0.0322122909,
-0.0058354195,
-0.0155096566,
-0.0468483195,
0.0185628701,
-0.0136206299,
-0.0079748584,
0.0388553999,
0.0229429491,
0.0032732992,
-0.0214426853,
0.0179978721,
-0.0181339607,
-0.0464764275,
-0.0131752444,
-0.0164600257,
0.0436704904,
0.0762270242,
0.0509624779,
-0.0142426202,
-0.0327795707,
-0.0275128223,
0.0269840453,
-0.0166681595,
0.0055179554,
-0.0054403525,
0.1045525819,
-0.0381654091,
-0.0587236509,
-0.0158867277,
-0.0078303618,
0.023550801,
-0.0219194833,
-0.0174979139,
0.0282685291,
-0.0388610214,
0.0416016169,
0.012280697,
0.0342534594,
-0.0338526778,
0.0101040266,
0.0298225526,
0.0245099459,
0.0392369293,
0.0111777829,
-0.0032608788,
0.0311914124,
-0.0035928448,
0.056208957,
0.0452415571,
-0.0622644797,
-0.0116146458,
0.0191086754,
-0.0579239093,
-0.0088407584,
-0.0153496452,
-0.036180865,
-0.03675019,
0.0314726681,
-0.0105087133,
0.0246231891,
-0.047953248,
-0.0124820732,
0.027308017,
0.0235619061,
-0.0152838575,
0.0521240868,
0.0058712484,
0.0006526035,
0.0341501236,
0.0016886882,
0.0239824411,
-0.0343285576,
0.0208176225,
-0.009922592,
-0.0076322309,
0.0378894061,
-0.0006602143,
-0.0082679996,
-0.0614740886,
0.0042977766,
-0.1041965187,
-0.0130520742,
-0.0254758317,
-0.0252892561,
0.0270799138,
0.0649688914,
0.0180780776,
-0.0851913691,
-0.0054033981,
-0.0139792366,
0.0101454239,
0.0327656306,
0.0037357006,
0.0464940183,
0.0119104777,
-0.0266524423,
0.0076521672,
0.0021096114,
0.0611250363,
0.0062643471,
-0.0073744431,
-0.0251701847,
-0.0261389688,
-0.0282128751,
0.0656095147,
-0.0038369009,
0.0188500583,
0.0373069495,
-0.0308915805,
0.0115547655,
0.0564933941,
0.0077288281,
0.048399318,
-0.0079632867,
-0.0507754758,
-0.0496177003,
0.0261321254,
0.0113843298,
-0.0324713327,
-0.0162400138,
-0.0176626295,
0.0089187939,
0.0391130596,
0.0146056302,
0.004188586,
-0.0221810583,
0.0329252109,
0.0231748391,
-0.0494414866,
-0.0798546374,
0.02607744,
0.0003369329,
0.0816854015,
-0.0283026882,
-0.0335458964,
0.069554463,
-0.0236524362,
-0.0241489951,
-0.0256733634,
-0.0293595567,
-0.0287486631,
0.0680674985,
-0.0151607925,
0.0110562043,
0.0393811874,
-0.0794313177,
-0.0151752196,
-0.0299898107,
0.0262728278,
-0.0490044802,
0.0359959491,
-0.0590107143,
-0.0080186492,
0.0078863278,
-0.0120704947,
-0.0389012694,
-0.0295105651,
-0.0286606867,
-0.02554355,
-0.0560188964,
0.0126221571,
-0.0560249723,
0.0520474091,
0.0049149012,
0.0293372516,
0.0230700113,
-0.0207249112,
-0.038892556,
0.0409900695,
0.0318968333,
0.0469779111,
-0.0431376435,
0.0109532112,
0.0111084655,
0.0512661636,
0.0505975261,
-0.029382091,
-0.0407337472,
0.0038563712,
0.0024815726,
0.0065834834,
-0.0114243533,
0.0547466837,
0.0292114746,
-0.0670067519,
0.0017726424,
0.1085869521,
0.0131317191,
-0.0369503163,
-0.0368720964,
-0.0207231045,
0.0036577273,
0.051773794,
0.0297694746,
-0.0809487253,
-0.0790238008,
0.0012301042,
0.0026669046,
0.0438041277,
-0.0245206207,
-0.0420420989,
-0.0719654709,
-0.0036352728,
-0.0082426332,
-0.0756682456,
-0.0342723951,
-0.0165474303,
0.0340353362,
-0.0034716716,
0.0249966271,
0.005348505,
-0.0325681753,
0.0006151915,
-0.0219388176,
0.0236461964,
0.0035231938,
0.0036661413,
-0.0570818484,
0.0064433115,
0.0426361188,
0.0485721342,
0.064934738,
-0.0230588801,
-0.0067028664,
-0.0442128778,
0.0493104085,
-0.039487727,
0.0279910751,
-0.0067862081,
0.0125366589,
-0.0134211034,
0.0296439826,
-0.01233235,
-0.0243901704,
0.0220987666,
0.0431795791,
-0.0157518461,
0.0293331612,
-0.0219854694,
0.0287269875,
0.0541177318,
0.0434268266,
0.027594192,
-0.005851767,
-0.0499427468,
-0.0190675706,
0.0308087505,
-0.0128015755,
0.0426729582,
0.0151179833,
-0.0184063166,
-0.0156506691,
-0.0473656952,
-0.0263363812,
0.0340664238,
0.0449401438,
0.0311157368,
0.0263569038,
0.0364502817,
0.0229929183,
-0.0564565696,
0.0148500735,
-0.0087720742,
0.028807804,
-0.0294937473,
0.0369611457,
0.0227339994,
-0.0312937945,
-0.0167444497,
0.0448604822,
-0.0027872236,
-0.0407568514,
-0.060128767,
0.0385273434,
0.0225856844,
0.0543409698,
-0.0449192151,
-0.0308208745,
-0.0514024533,
0.0323183313,
-0.0328501798,
-0.0039975811,
0.0087103918,
0.0233673509,
-0.0283602756,
0.0244369283,
-0.0533504337,
0.0006114297,
-0.051798854,
0.0023054683,
-0.0961156189,
-0.0804609507,
0.0117607834,
-0.0400295071,
0.0532748252,
0.0293971952,
0.0023419962,
-0.0053199911,
0.0491493121,
0.0082178907,
0.0048621348,
-0.0374766551,
0.0090856068,
-0.054895021,
-0.0143723655,
0.034674041,
-0.0077421777,
-0.0188669115,
0.0264329482,
-0.0116494363,
0.012104271,
0.0500912108,
0.0081560975,
-0.0113124019,
0.0003147005,
0.0002069361,
0.0392690338,
0.016625436,
0.0571065545,
-0.0178124402,
0.088912718,
-0.0021355494,
-0.0267373901,
-0.0180909596,
0.0291815493,
-0.0586723872,
0.0023589074,
0.020697182,
0.0473345593,
0.0312839411,
0.0067512365,
0.0137827704,
0.0377144404,
0.0182474907,
-0.0173735004,
0.0747676939,
0.0131691052,
-0.0429480374,
0.0221181568,
0.0220653918,
0.0127757732,
0.0199487358,
0.0494536012,
-0.0161510967,
0.0078822346,
0.0207373593,
-0.0491906442,
-0.058991041,
-0.0192202218,
-0.0159929432,
0.065584138,
-0.0067768344,
0.0442035832,
-0.0304982606,
-0.0380498022,
0.0297581106,
0.008236682,
0.0114313597,
0.0057936204,
0.0477413423,
0.0592529997,
0.0363268815,
-0.058813177,
-0.0189107284,
0.0224199686,
-0.0545123294,
-0.0097475899,
-0.0465461612,
-5.382889486e-33,
-0.0627257749,
-0.0555998199,
0.0306754503,
-0.0177372005,
0.0037065365,
-0.0018766725,
-0.0399291031,
-0.0113518387,
-0.010354911,
-0.0148860607,
-0.0255443417,
0.0051466753,
0.0199811123,
0.0314522311,
-0.0581223071,
-0.0461499132,
0.0452608876,
0.0049344436,
0.0029557412,
0.0162122473,
0.06562379,
0.0404117964,
0.040428929,
-0.1092924029,
-0.0366069712,
0.0331896283,
0.0075501953,
0.0285493694,
-0.0020126051,
0.0392810106,
0.0021796189,
0.0101757022,
0.0236242656,
0.0177558009,
-0.0152041307,
0.0936885327,
-0.1232117712,
-0.0169140324,
0.0539422706,
0.057046555,
-0.0425373912,
-0.0127477674,
0.0499815159,
-0.0285294075,
0.0450498275,
-0.0019480067,
0.047129795,
-0.0302882139,
-0.0568260737,
-0.0001590859,
-0.0138736833,
0.0062784133,
-0.0356419869,
-0.0375160314,
0.0091390694,
0.0820323229,
0.0006461556,
-0.0253903903,
-0.0466552861,
0.0194007978,
-0.0355391577,
-0.0149863129,
0.0478101037,
0.0275963303,
0.0084943762,
0.0434642099,
0.0350228734,
-0.0548755415,
-0.03102744,
-0.0463701375,
-0.0225966498,
0.1005757824,
-0.0002854793,
0.0567777865,
0.0073195649,
0.0103524076,
-0.0225364808,
0.0181271527,
-0.0029375553,
0.063459672,
0.02204399,
0.0259919669,
-0.0211082716,
0.0102846399,
-0.0533951409,
-0.0165931154,
-0.0595008843,
-0.0082112905,
0.0539689027,
0.0115437815,
-0.0113195032,
0.014465603,
0.0642414615,
-0.0336628854,
-0.0071625649,
0.034303695,
0.062464796,
-0.007045859,
-0.0012101518,
0.0099186515,
0.0239532627,
0.0247588623,
0.0459448323,
0.0012877824,
0.0385437459,
-0.0280597173,
-0.014027142,
-0.0141713638,
-0.0249759927,
-0.0219010711,
-0.0334400423,
0.0716844797,
-0.0347729065,
0.0212654099,
0.0557668768,
-0.0182760563,
-0.0517641157,
0.0477266274,
-0.0372600704,
-0.0228422657,
-0.0428296998,
-0.0590979531,
0.036065314,
0.0153198792,
-0.0451776534,
-0.0260670409,
-0.0047371546,
-0.0311779026,
0.0762991682,
-0.0155758746,
-0.0089515913,
0.0507691279,
2.529e-7,
-0.0123597393,
0.0016786031,
0.017255621,
0.0182615519,
0.024761077,
0.0632172003,
0.019377498,
0.0440070853,
0.0039821407,
-0.0166629571,
-0.0118858684,
0.0019480396,
0.0249956902,
0.0065180813,
-0.0488845147,
-0.0293163992,
0.0021898432,
0.0229455233,
-0.0159898065,
0.0272343401,
0.0376030207,
0.0635804981,
0.0035046451,
-0.0245856605,
0.0087815234,
-0.0548468083,
-0.0019586103,
-0.0332851894,
0.0375126675,
-0.032208316,
0.0241623949,
0.0090836231,
0.011667083,
0.0267420057,
-0.009498491,
-0.0175208896,
0.0166447479,
0.0651033074,
-0.0102963699,
-0.0492385551,
-0.0290573444,
0.0062609916,
-0.0131559977,
-0.0302753393,
0.0841041729,
-0.0024245877,
-0.0156658404,
-0.035086602,
-0.0172967743,
-0.0465631895,
-0.0252986792,
0.030770326,
-0.0132932169,
0.0180106126,
0.0087893158,
-0.0305783022,
-0.0026899583,
-0.0859898254,
-0.0252330415,
-0.0020052795,
-0.0047489321,
0.0150478696,
-0.0310375467,
-0.0352759212,
0.0477282405,
-0.036619857,
-0.0115210917,
1.716224048e-34,
0.0136959935,
-0.0078577092,
-0.0062391516,
0.057363756,
0.036585886,
-0.0013948891,
-0.0255482532,
0.0038039719,
0.0538372621,
-0.0374421217,
-0.0119262664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04921v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04921v1 | Successor Features for Efficient Multisubject Controlled Text Generation | 2023-11-03T00:17:08 | 2023-11-03T00:17:08 | Meng Cao, Mehdi Fatemi, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung, Samira Shabanian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in
generating fluent and realistic text, controlling the generated text so that it
exhibits properties such as safety, factuality, and non-toxicity remains
challenging. % such as DExperts, GeDi, and rectification Existing
decoding-based methods are static in terms of the dimension of control; if the
target subject is changed, they require new training. Moreover, it can quickly
become prohibitive to concurrently control multiple subjects. In this work, we
introduce SF-GEN, which is grounded in two primary concepts: successor features
(SFs) to decouple the LLM's dynamics from task-specific rewards, and language
model rectification to proportionally adjust the probability of selecting a
token based on the likelihood that the finished text becomes undesired. SF-GEN
seamlessly integrates the two to enable dynamic steering of text generation
with no need to alter the LLM's parameters. Thanks to the decoupling effect
induced by successor features, our method proves to be memory-wise and
computationally efficient for training as well as decoding, especially when
dealing with multiple target subjects. To the best of our knowledge, our
research represents the first application of successor features in text
generation. In addition to its computational efficiency, the resultant language
produced by our method is comparable to the SOTA (and outperforms baselines) in
both control measures as well as language quality, which we demonstrate through
a series of experiments in various controllable text generation tasks. | [
0.0251590088,
0.0487668067,
0.0269464795,
-0.0064400984,
-0.0125396485,
-0.0013980621,
0.0067538256,
0.004584895,
-0.0155251874,
-0.0270945709,
-0.0222218577,
-0.0516381115,
-0.0139921745,
0.0529078133,
0.0204180051,
-0.0567715131,
0.0248326361,
-0.0269402023,
0.0186387375,
0.0022203368,
-0.0053657647,
0.0161480159,
-0.012629604,
0.0583912097,
-0.0329059549,
-0.0013617071,
-0.0057809856,
0.0179700498,
-0.006156371,
-0.0498376824,
0.0455116108,
0.0475748703,
0.0333102755,
0.0294311363,
0.0000020227,
-0.0098348893,
-0.0193012543,
-0.0091041438,
0.0165978726,
-0.0284290817,
0.0676411688,
-0.0201909095,
-0.0249196365,
0.0315500721,
-0.041349005,
0.008803823,
0.0680086836,
0.0272986833,
0.0625069514,
0.05771593,
-0.008308759,
-0.021089647,
0.0000699246,
-0.0415876172,
0.0094797676,
-0.0046748109,
-0.0019625199,
-0.0184984934,
-0.00817052,
0.0139624057,
-0.0216447711,
0.027402591,
0.0494100899,
-0.0307474993,
0.0063228179,
0.0563784279,
0.0437607057,
-0.0270902123,
-0.0315752737,
0.0399507098,
-0.0523598194,
-0.0018949681,
0.0153279267,
0.0017594267,
-0.016774755,
-0.0325475372,
-0.0256104562,
0.0312947184,
-0.0158168245,
0.0447794534,
0.0186390076,
0.0318679512,
0.0111056827,
0.0125337858,
0.0023336275,
0.0126479641,
0.0340398587,
-0.0223302934,
0.001020574,
0.0309353638,
0.006130462,
-0.0670306832,
0.0339303166,
0.0445020832,
-0.0627040118,
0.0277447607,
-0.0902334452,
-0.0596118532,
0.013998935,
-0.0354578197,
0.0362215973,
0.0040897694,
-0.0151721714,
0.0036036882,
-0.0362455845,
0.0302826501,
-0.0202622432,
0.0228934977,
-0.0381598957,
0.0338130668,
-0.0107398937,
-0.0456399359,
-0.052041553,
0.0419520214,
-0.0405162387,
-0.0194314271,
-0.0681915805,
0.0086973626,
0.0038509811,
-0.0240571685,
0.0002368414,
0.0481211804,
-0.0765163749,
0.0050702714,
0.0061186296,
0.0141151017,
-0.0060378648,
-0.0160014592,
0.0376912132,
-0.0061846194,
-0.0279407073,
0.0212133937,
-0.0064955745,
-0.0204580836,
-0.0253982004,
0.0889684036,
-0.0756535381,
-0.0204322115,
-0.0311854631,
-0.0550587438,
-0.0227894299,
-0.0408305861,
0.0143225677,
-0.0439878181,
0.0069251475,
-0.0271194801,
-0.0225428641,
-0.0649619699,
0.0322469212,
0.00572062,
-0.0102826813,
0.0136396457,
-0.0242671277,
-0.0158445965,
0.0256801248,
0.0077974224,
0.0190330651,
0.0586847886,
0.0596661381,
0.0833342895,
-0.0159498733,
0.0326447636,
0.0184063222,
0.0169503577,
0.0355400294,
0.0257747117,
-0.0240110364,
-0.0623469576,
0.0173035655,
0.0599675849,
0.0638588369,
0.0511890687,
-0.0460670069,
0.0295756143,
0.0975547656,
0.0202548075,
0.0142598404,
0.0211300068,
0.0869703889,
-0.0066173566,
-0.0413115062,
0.054610271,
-0.0152020147,
0.0568861812,
0.0179731846,
0.0105036255,
0.0176533107,
0.0283829775,
-0.0136412345,
-0.0477283932,
0.0314011164,
-0.0274795387,
0.0180328134,
-0.0419257618,
0.0264349543,
0.0436273478,
-0.071680598,
0.0122718653,
0.0183052439,
-0.0810120702,
0.0306791309,
-0.0533971824,
0.0295758937,
0.0814559758,
0.0576751642,
0.0035127676,
-0.0338139758,
-0.0063306992,
0.0168745965,
0.093405202,
0.0177989509,
0.0033970461,
0.0306868423,
-0.0534122214,
-0.0175272319,
-0.0018956872,
-0.0014927873,
0.0342846662,
-0.0102376901,
0.0154781444,
0.0110912099,
0.0309042837,
-0.0387363918,
0.0590992384,
-0.0330181308,
-0.0138262277,
0.0248045512,
-0.0085722217,
0.012932119,
-0.0254704766,
-0.0264067892,
0.0167554095,
0.0014299726,
-0.0479588807,
-0.053074263,
0.0285767913,
-0.0627666712,
-0.043391563,
-0.0097837439,
-0.010561185,
0.0112415496,
-0.01191644,
-0.021269802,
-0.0404398888,
0.011359809,
-0.0731482431,
0.0145801064,
-0.0311209876,
0.0072531807,
0.041607108,
-0.0296110995,
-0.0360441506,
0.0705818161,
-0.0089460351,
-0.0274428502,
0.0129937371,
-0.0205986854,
-0.0064221914,
-0.0512205623,
0.002428805,
0.0175878331,
0.008313165,
0.0150369667,
0.0315122418,
0.052005019,
-0.0048711798,
-0.066253826,
-0.0289112516,
0.0145103633,
-0.0385953374,
0.0079854317,
0.0106538273,
-0.0201022867,
0.0042861993,
-0.0044859368,
-0.0832311586,
-0.0194652062,
0.0155486278,
-0.015346772,
0.0354503281,
-0.0144166546,
0.0327669419,
-0.0403849334,
-0.0036052165,
0.0108897947,
0.0253833979,
0.0232597906,
-0.0121910563,
-0.048301056,
0.0522257164,
-0.034115646,
0.0012872057,
0.018550301,
-0.0422053859,
0.0339277163,
0.0132658156,
0.0678173378,
0.0626176149,
0.0404725783,
0.0383297838,
0.0244315527,
0.0159490611,
-0.0262398515,
0.0156183802,
-0.0526197515,
-0.0267004538,
-0.0025250462,
-0.0193017051,
0.046742294,
0.0600804389,
0.0381596573,
-0.0007882627,
-0.0914584622,
0.016319409,
-0.025750773,
-0.0645631179,
-0.0281812996,
-0.0138477422,
-0.0300407074,
-0.016795475,
-0.0541238785,
-0.0754529163,
0.075738512,
-0.0109503521,
0.0067993319,
-0.0410894975,
0.024947634,
-0.0052272794,
0.0460161865,
0.0173717663,
0.0476059467,
0.028340809,
-0.0177248847,
-0.0326450914,
0.0443048067,
0.0009659614,
-0.0252028573,
0.0287600365,
-0.0643135458,
-0.0106362272,
-0.0093692467,
-0.0666522011,
-0.0382946171,
-0.0203031544,
0.037137337,
0.0098771853,
0.0089262426,
-0.0231777281,
-0.0104403486,
-0.0143257966,
0.0273602139,
0.0620437115,
-0.0326614939,
-0.0023442002,
-0.0306338593,
0.0129204514,
0.0692459866,
-0.0067291558,
0.0001478508,
-0.0679004118,
0.0042971722,
0.0682981461,
-0.0054036868,
0.0095695462,
-0.0123940334,
0.0171933714,
0.0109018181,
-0.0129198711,
-0.0202580299,
0.0212779511,
0.0630339682,
-0.0568175502,
-0.0184606463,
0.0824885815,
0.0134125901,
-0.0178790558,
0.0359378308,
0.0321745835,
0.0636184514,
-0.0038107387,
-0.0064485916,
-0.0700496361,
-0.0198032334,
-0.0144369081,
0.0464290529,
-0.0091474485,
-0.0114874663,
-0.0187960751,
-0.0625898317,
0.028811451,
0.030534571,
-0.063795194,
-0.0046376544,
0.0408729985,
-0.0312143862,
0.0147505244,
-0.0000413885,
0.0401366688,
0.002715061,
0.0121509321,
0.0284726899,
0.0106296167,
-0.0220878925,
-0.0518374257,
-0.0299331006,
0.0346055143,
0.0866979808,
0.0228409097,
0.0223469399,
-0.0083357142,
-0.030400401,
-0.0083684446,
0.0119831217,
-0.0143825645,
0.058398094,
-0.0121062985,
-0.0208346434,
-0.0302385855,
0.0540811867,
0.0084235836,
-0.0200795233,
-0.0085388999,
0.0216281191,
-0.0064549674,
-0.0519315191,
-0.0333414264,
0.0078887446,
0.0542372428,
0.0546861216,
0.0410143398,
-0.0683674291,
-0.0453200825,
-0.0533527322,
0.0054896367,
-0.1107377484,
-0.023385141,
-0.0215333495,
-0.0406048596,
-0.0376549698,
-0.1309567988,
-0.0055384184,
0.0205831062,
0.0436313823,
-0.0115474686,
-0.0123485336,
-0.0200572256,
-0.0463957079,
-0.0291380547,
-0.0170254577,
0.0000969107,
0.0015389336,
-0.0657306314,
-0.0330486186,
0.0133084515,
-0.0418126769,
0.0011155544,
0.0434902012,
-0.0501528718,
-0.0639367476,
0.0000564674,
0.0848541707,
0.0179428291,
-0.009142248,
-0.0011559584,
-0.0683029145,
0.0715179518,
0.0400498882,
0.001339928,
0.0330005214,
0.0132962093,
0.0223477613,
-0.0111601651,
0.0314194076,
-0.0218185335,
0.0232970864,
0.0242000353,
0.0603956394,
0.0229835734,
0.0029468415,
0.0262189247,
-0.0076419609,
0.0062604733,
-0.0681485534,
0.0529286787,
-0.0403843597,
-0.0039125485,
-0.0192045476,
-0.0055718105,
-0.0723581985,
0.0392596498,
0.0181631763,
-0.0023144761,
-0.01490793,
-0.0253818277,
0.0023017148,
0.0438562259,
-0.023622172,
-0.024998093,
-0.0483244583,
0.0325318053,
0.0442903936,
0.0235732496,
-0.0168218315,
0.0207411945,
-0.0343801938,
0.0025355292,
-0.0125677697,
0.0365529396,
0.0346565358,
0.0041662334,
-0.013908172,
0.0390828475,
-0.0235772412,
0.0048807631,
-0.0481037982,
0.0074650273,
0.0658330768,
0.0584455319,
0.0875176638,
-0.0513386466,
0.0046693599,
-0.004429956,
0.0437640548,
0.0058912034,
-0.0490507223,
-0.0032211707,
-0.0080896029,
-0.020989608,
-0.0635706261,
0.1094814166,
0.0181187708,
0.0128870485,
-0.0210330281,
0.0273976307,
-0.0205365587,
-0.045351766,
0.0280305929,
-0.0054069138,
-0.0036022523,
0.0069566211,
-0.0471724384,
-0.0299154334,
0.031148443,
0.0259297211,
0.0163312815,
-0.0226655696,
0.0599932112,
-0.0020019053,
-0.0373062864,
-0.0319130421,
-0.0327826776,
-0.0052587106,
0.0239081606,
-0.0227142144,
-0.0335003398,
-5.990993652e-33,
-0.049055703,
-0.0435294509,
0.0229834523,
0.012160168,
-0.0604739711,
-0.0042185904,
-0.044793956,
0.0231215991,
0.0556874909,
0.0094230101,
0.0134951202,
-0.0080186557,
0.0120751653,
0.0366835147,
0.0014731725,
-0.0127023831,
0.0652826428,
-0.0266875215,
-0.0521131158,
0.05394537,
0.0599450171,
0.0393243022,
0.0649110302,
-0.0419023857,
0.0067571877,
0.0286943484,
-0.0330816843,
0.0042760833,
-0.0169514567,
0.0229041949,
-0.0091219172,
0.027669942,
0.0150345033,
-0.0409095809,
-0.0527806766,
0.0265340898,
-0.010845514,
-0.0134231867,
-0.0164579656,
-0.044512596,
-0.0726327077,
-0.0675919652,
0.0465016514,
-0.0066116732,
-0.0196259897,
0.0067760223,
0.0123162381,
-0.0210834201,
-0.0394307487,
-0.0413266495,
-0.0872443244,
0.0065482003,
-0.0035352209,
-0.0307959076,
-0.0103801759,
0.0236111321,
-0.0255706999,
-0.0355035365,
-0.0150856646,
0.0317858011,
0.0130202817,
0.0462794937,
0.0096540563,
0.0279921554,
0.0102338241,
0.0554024316,
0.0123018669,
0.015902862,
-0.0583217144,
0.019181991,
0.0181843489,
0.035919413,
0.0641336069,
0.0289385635,
0.0159318503,
-0.0274520665,
-0.0563215837,
0.0278073139,
-0.0246975496,
0.0063659735,
0.0212756228,
0.0081914412,
0.0060829469,
-0.0242733937,
-0.0326446779,
0.0142599838,
0.0098289456,
-0.0518756136,
0.0384708382,
0.0466009416,
-0.0187384505,
-0.0557060875,
0.0073736599,
0.016946068,
0.0299874675,
0.0136640985,
-0.0258215517,
0.0251987334,
-0.0205968563,
-0.0008726841,
-0.0426466167,
-0.0276605748,
0.0374124721,
0.0169556178,
0.0014895959,
0.022783896,
0.0395253599,
0.0536532775,
-0.051349882,
0.0413465798,
-0.0312042087,
0.0420824923,
0.0336444266,
0.0090943221,
0.0244047511,
-0.0357165486,
-0.0092479186,
0.0081485547,
0.0121881459,
-0.0310409293,
-0.0515812747,
-0.0094415005,
0.0298271719,
0.0364302173,
-0.0257561374,
0.047106456,
-0.045630496,
0.0029683879,
0.0201973766,
-0.0738152042,
-0.0206402317,
0.0101363845,
2.694e-7,
0.0066317394,
0.0328697413,
0.0356155224,
0.0183474682,
0.0358086377,
0.0209608674,
0.0042230194,
0.0676705539,
-0.0043686246,
0.0182556473,
0.0015900218,
0.023012992,
0.0765556544,
0.0040051839,
-0.0777587369,
0.0246319119,
-0.0829357579,
0.0246782638,
-0.0438050404,
-0.0519853234,
0.0667190179,
0.0167538878,
-0.0154060088,
-0.0059432061,
0.0535477065,
0.0003135451,
0.0746061355,
0.014769949,
0.0032535053,
-0.0009923837,
0.0123268077,
0.0037124217,
-0.032037694,
-0.0399236903,
-0.0268868674,
-0.0326166376,
0.0188370105,
0.0799902827,
-0.0081205908,
-0.0366568863,
0.0377732031,
0.009118706,
0.012034582,
-0.0046002413,
0.0348275825,
-0.0528538898,
0.0056060581,
-0.0110023217,
0.0162078012,
0.0133451698,
0.0009295417,
-0.0737296045,
-0.0577721223,
0.0393528938,
0.0115592396,
0.0571104474,
0.0067164344,
-0.0529548228,
-0.048160892,
-0.0139278704,
-0.0423076302,
-0.0330293067,
-0.083215557,
0.0440329239,
-0.0154055357,
-0.0573306046,
-0.0183185209,
2.539019584e-34,
0.0219227206,
-0.0434820727,
0.0218872949,
-0.0047340295,
0.0157571118,
0.0210977737,
0.0097598247,
0.0152880857,
0.0246292502,
-0.0086776977,
-0.0349964052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01620v1 | ACQUIRED: A Dataset for Answering Counterfactual Questions In Real-Life Videos | 2023-11-02T22:17:03 | 2023-11-02T22:17:03 | Te-Lin Wu, Zi-Yi Dou, Qingyuan Hu, Yu Hou, Nischal Reddy Chandra, Marjorie Freedman, Ralph M. Weischedel, Nanyun Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal counterfactual reasoning is a vital yet challenging ability for AI
systems. It involves predicting the outcomes of hypothetical circumstances
based on vision and language inputs, which enables AI models to learn from
failures and explore hypothetical scenarios. Despite its importance, there are
only a few datasets targeting the counterfactual reasoning abilities of
multimodal models. Among them, they only cover reasoning over synthetic
environments or specific types of events (e.g. traffic collisions), making them
hard to reliably benchmark the model generalization ability in diverse
real-world scenarios and reasoning dimensions. To overcome these limitations,
we develop a video question answering dataset, ACQUIRED: it consists of 3.9K
annotated videos, encompassing a wide range of event types and incorporating
both first and third-person viewpoints, which ensures a focus on real-world
diversity. In addition, each video is annotated with questions that span three
distinct dimensions of reasoning, including physical, social, and temporal,
which can comprehensively evaluate the model counterfactual abilities along
multiple aspects. We benchmark our dataset against several state-of-the-art
language-only and multimodal models and experimental results demonstrate a
significant performance gap (>13%) between models and humans. The findings
suggest that multimodal counterfactual reasoning remains an open challenge and
ACQUIRED is a comprehensive and reliable benchmark for inspiring future
research in this direction. | [
0.0354148895,
0.0416455492,
-0.0030732695,
0.0491620563,
-0.0312281698,
0.0067028236,
0.0171478894,
-0.008800542,
0.000066267,
-0.0389923491,
0.0001150009,
-0.02673053,
-0.0390475206,
0.0656051934,
0.0421380922,
-0.0536200665,
0.0507879257,
-0.0289118327,
0.0112612685,
-0.0036258425,
0.0249704458,
-0.0012047037,
-0.0300093256,
0.0152612366,
-0.0485770255,
-0.0102579389,
-0.0195262432,
0.002227037,
0.0659954995,
-0.023796415,
0.0254423525,
0.0089805201,
0.0719393268,
-0.0126575325,
0.000001717,
-0.0359239317,
0.0342316851,
-0.0230122693,
-0.0224729665,
-0.0329914987,
-0.0565159358,
-0.0235417131,
0.0049569663,
0.030685151,
-0.0679191723,
0.036440555,
0.0248891059,
0.015853012,
0.0443831682,
0.0459860079,
-0.0121821947,
-0.0397741385,
0.0181462392,
0.0075536743,
0.0027601346,
-0.045757547,
-0.0196756478,
0.0460800678,
-0.0081014978,
-0.033106219,
-0.0424773619,
0.01846385,
0.0610353388,
0.0184626356,
-0.0125223948,
0.0353573784,
-0.0432806648,
-0.0269674156,
-0.0151451761,
0.1055701524,
0.0079353414,
-0.0203014594,
-0.0272441413,
-0.00730319,
0.0260215625,
0.000693699,
-0.057002563,
0.0196499787,
-0.0091902427,
0.0001814015,
-0.0566521697,
0.0364040546,
0.025044078,
-0.005486046,
0.0484062135,
0.0291587543,
0.0013901081,
0.0185873862,
-0.0052251248,
0.0014374622,
-0.0395688042,
-0.0361786783,
-0.0119978003,
0.0233303178,
-0.0341009982,
-0.0162572805,
-0.009893544,
0.0124976356,
-0.0007625276,
-0.0695194751,
0.0541704148,
0.016619008,
-0.0167363696,
0.0699364096,
-0.011663706,
0.011627635,
-0.0598471127,
0.0241078641,
-0.015855642,
-0.0295361914,
-0.0446131937,
-0.0065337489,
-0.014241158,
-0.0140186762,
-0.0448838621,
0.0117046628,
0.0310759693,
-0.0008246583,
-0.0637546107,
0.0089792367,
-0.0368471704,
0.0807988867,
0.0015098992,
-0.0492108911,
-0.0292671565,
0.0031194305,
-0.0826827958,
0.0569177084,
0.0059535592,
-0.08863049,
-0.0133664636,
-0.0079152491,
0.0024416342,
-0.0418914706,
0.0401854925,
0.0852386281,
-0.0286123399,
0.0095803533,
-0.0070898505,
-0.0189896785,
0.0252048541,
-0.0649759918,
0.0392448194,
-0.0576343127,
0.0462235399,
-0.004029179,
-0.0352366567,
-0.0205898024,
0.0109823514,
-0.011803939,
0.0034510223,
0.092798993,
0.0288136471,
0.001716443,
0.0488623567,
0.0097234091,
-0.0132393576,
0.0704407394,
0.0275023039,
0.0074003041,
0.0633616894,
0.0261849258,
0.0558793433,
0.023492353,
0.0217852388,
0.0310523883,
-0.0686458498,
0.0433416218,
-0.0078294948,
0.0346695408,
0.0200257953,
0.0013400569,
-0.0027921861,
-0.1132402048,
0.030832326,
-0.0009543565,
-0.0774919242,
-0.0295230988,
0.0205908846,
-0.0113656316,
0.0001659371,
0.0079054264,
-0.0275728405,
0.0873636305,
-0.043653924,
0.0053856252,
0.0091221668,
0.0176176671,
-0.0449317768,
-0.0233690757,
-0.0022750576,
0.0011820131,
0.0259734783,
0.0349426866,
0.0491514057,
0.0111485897,
-0.0340429321,
-0.0209843721,
-0.0129553741,
0.0011596319,
-0.0043957927,
-0.0256918222,
0.0003072308,
0.0289851911,
0.0327084772,
-0.0587612316,
-0.0622527041,
-0.0005301671,
0.0256070681,
-0.0152489813,
0.0511036403,
-0.0160046499,
0.0615820326,
-0.0200334489,
-0.0169764236,
-0.0296419431,
0.0140163824,
0.0230629425,
0.0290409178,
0.0097229583,
-0.0068620294,
0.0001552577,
0.0458742715,
0.0259599444,
-0.0142244687,
0.0123494444,
-0.0285814423,
-0.0024720244,
0.017714899,
-0.0059753498,
-0.0200859662,
-0.0260580499,
0.0293091498,
-0.0086920317,
-0.0237535015,
0.0335909277,
-0.0138245048,
-0.0450895838,
0.0326538198,
-0.0914725587,
-0.0556929074,
0.1035889313,
-0.052600041,
-0.0082945582,
0.0412341543,
0.003838198,
0.0132587785,
-0.04064757,
-0.0367843881,
0.0233942661,
0.0167397261,
0.0157769006,
0.0120707992,
-0.0336971767,
-0.0317777619,
-0.018542638,
0.0194918551,
0.0456543639,
-0.0385440663,
-0.0133046657,
-0.0124671469,
-0.012135867,
-0.0122905066,
0.0282957591,
-0.0341459997,
-0.0595414154,
0.0375726372,
-0.0705787987,
0.0132721635,
-0.0311397873,
-0.0244533084,
-0.0035223819,
-0.030323185,
0.0097392891,
-0.051248394,
0.0077790683,
0.0210467372,
0.0269674398,
0.0121207591,
0.0151870316,
0.0102347424,
0.0385071672,
-0.0446856506,
-0.0136289392,
-0.0249630641,
0.0553457104,
-0.0096005173,
0.0027744109,
0.0281074159,
-0.0478527211,
-0.0504389927,
0.0844801739,
-0.0429468416,
-0.0443983227,
0.0278734174,
-0.0176174268,
0.0063343467,
0.0638363361,
0.0119265839,
-0.013700542,
0.0351689197,
-0.0029061562,
-0.020238772,
0.0206576642,
0.0020567533,
-0.0202240441,
-0.0340835601,
-0.0478970781,
-0.0640303418,
0.0032457642,
0.0009267555,
-0.006533864,
-0.0617468171,
0.0190379284,
0.041700229,
-0.0559250489,
-0.0524964705,
0.0000110041,
-0.003711747,
0.0591149703,
-0.0312037524,
-0.0162224583,
0.0648090616,
0.0340949036,
-0.0033965134,
0.0236599445,
0.026273299,
0.0123100216,
0.0955283418,
0.0215396769,
-0.0071010692,
-0.0123518445,
0.040836785,
-0.0548773184,
-0.0218539871,
0.0271731261,
0.0101559712,
-0.0096646575,
-0.0854904503,
-0.0174450371,
0.0001752062,
-0.0320590548,
-0.0491048992,
-0.072707653,
-0.0243779793,
0.0018058923,
-0.0883427262,
0.0098575484,
-0.0315032527,
-0.0034700306,
0.0108337132,
0.0299787186,
0.0081271343,
0.004358531,
-0.0036720396,
0.0372758172,
0.0905314609,
0.0522563271,
0.0132176727,
-0.0291608218,
0.0270391796,
0.0395071656,
0.0585662276,
-0.0290398672,
-0.0454398431,
0.0279170889,
-0.0228599235,
0.0484643802,
0.0055101705,
0.0335708,
0.0352769308,
-0.0302761663,
0.0137981176,
0.0549382269,
0.0238370486,
0.0082020918,
0.0264568534,
-0.014959868,
-0.0104065575,
0.0508374982,
-0.0209973212,
-0.0565627255,
-0.0476128347,
0.0020072577,
-0.0139082074,
-0.0112764006,
-0.0396514349,
-0.0071028825,
-0.0978905708,
0.0494492128,
-0.0231773537,
-0.0088505056,
-0.0543257967,
-0.0164818,
-0.0127370823,
-0.030729169,
-0.0464342572,
-0.0033323111,
0.033954341,
0.0115541387,
-0.0182961412,
-0.0029715954,
-0.0365885869,
0.0524300486,
-0.0249887388,
0.0446198881,
0.0369516425,
0.0107226893,
-0.0334818512,
-0.0191676989,
0.0184260234,
0.0018469837,
0.0067610727,
0.004545995,
0.0549419336,
-0.0244603995,
-0.0116727883,
0.0046457215,
0.0429194458,
0.0089801364,
-0.0490120612,
0.0272758752,
0.0807933062,
-0.0315762013,
-0.0068974369,
-0.0704018772,
0.0164477732,
0.0082062865,
0.0494951904,
0.0051727025,
-0.0155195855,
-0.0375223942,
0.0029533817,
-0.0428786613,
-0.0350537412,
0.0030751519,
-0.0264469963,
0.0781600848,
0.0017325412,
-0.0355637185,
-0.0548306666,
0.0087105511,
0.0391613171,
-0.0432471707,
-0.0485908724,
-0.0063652238,
0.0298103411,
-0.0669501349,
0.0502618961,
0.0058101891,
0.0314048082,
0.0238754097,
0.0239355229,
0.0151992775,
-0.045128312,
-0.0507346429,
0.0199209265,
-0.0632010847,
-0.0362749323,
-0.0009358253,
0.0953726172,
0.0202159584,
0.0567072071,
0.0014143884,
-0.0202247314,
-0.0192112718,
-0.0122680245,
-0.0004655437,
0.0181579255,
0.0509161018,
-0.0246729832,
0.0090699317,
0.0334115475,
-0.0186418425,
0.0061723455,
0.0093348287,
0.0050197789,
-0.0339224376,
0.0016698695,
-0.0078076189,
-0.0412036926,
0.0423171185,
-0.0066196914,
-0.0157840494,
-0.0261493903,
0.0148621434,
-0.0091722831,
0.0115450677,
-0.0314687788,
0.0255154986,
0.0265997723,
-0.0176793002,
-0.0275530722,
-0.0027928215,
-0.030189909,
-0.0063770078,
-0.0294679124,
-0.0057128067,
0.0787263885,
0.0061745113,
-0.0114884991,
-0.0069391592,
0.0029082976,
0.0090116253,
-0.0030274675,
0.0322226211,
0.0148587059,
0.0444681272,
0.0322533958,
-0.0191983413,
-0.0212636031,
0.0053645642,
-0.0841298252,
-0.0182796344,
-0.0366410054,
0.0633651838,
0.0443243384,
-0.0102251042,
-0.0216671173,
-0.023048427,
-0.010573416,
-0.0006646786,
0.0125384228,
0.0041817147,
-0.059700314,
0.0565228947,
0.0274579599,
-0.0063030841,
0.0451051481,
0.081709139,
-0.0046733534,
0.0570148304,
-0.0173203032,
0.0020454146,
-0.0124179861,
-0.0324751996,
0.0324357674,
0.0444483534,
0.0285385121,
0.0286778007,
-0.0557068735,
-0.0670181364,
-0.0200084504,
0.0486934334,
-0.014656228,
0.0095602497,
0.0125838676,
0.0240743179,
0.0327319913,
-0.0429405272,
0.0175877381,
0.0013550355,
-0.0282248296,
0.0099036144,
-0.0321379974,
-5.651716227e-33,
0.008769826,
-0.0177248884,
0.02142708,
-0.0596968345,
0.0093235327,
-0.0095309233,
-0.0271815825,
-0.0056299362,
-0.0653258711,
0.0287501663,
0.0097338343,
0.0454991199,
0.0062123952,
0.0262808427,
0.0268936343,
-0.0435841791,
0.0018311848,
-0.0197638683,
-0.0113574769,
0.0107727749,
0.0064325635,
-0.004340888,
0.051417429,
-0.0873483717,
0.0051866774,
-0.0272220727,
-0.0398364402,
0.0376924425,
-0.0507531464,
0.0341201201,
-0.0254606809,
0.0080135185,
0.0362903252,
-0.0335784517,
-0.0142385606,
-0.0089262435,
-0.023820661,
-0.0123010436,
0.0223243199,
0.0018954327,
-0.0688358247,
-0.0000752031,
0.0130513553,
0.0089680692,
-0.0208844654,
-0.0156052951,
0.030444948,
-0.0265023839,
0.070462063,
0.0162826609,
-0.0451825671,
0.0062799132,
-0.0527780652,
-0.0446535088,
-0.0165705215,
0.0802831575,
0.022336131,
-0.0055099437,
-0.0433770381,
-0.0058888467,
-0.0362059735,
-0.0552984253,
0.0830059871,
-0.0147738131,
0.0133465584,
0.0560625605,
0.0429329239,
-0.0090865754,
-0.0410374738,
-0.0502985418,
-0.0208506379,
0.0790106803,
0.0412172154,
0.1279567033,
0.0453248546,
-0.0095036617,
-0.066646345,
0.0258662887,
-0.0662707239,
0.0365632102,
0.0189078003,
0.0026311439,
0.0043447847,
0.0066637439,
-0.0396123677,
-0.0159602165,
-0.013673191,
0.011085771,
0.0299003087,
-0.0181742627,
0.0112689482,
0.0227005053,
0.0569006242,
-0.0566717573,
0.0431619547,
0.0685044751,
-0.0012709104,
0.0324332826,
0.0424730927,
0.0789568797,
-0.0405412018,
0.028464919,
0.073590219,
-0.0104584722,
0.0090211136,
-0.0037652277,
0.0169530287,
0.0478218384,
0.0032971133,
-0.0061805071,
-0.0201774035,
0.0189974457,
0.0113031222,
0.008546235,
0.0344900899,
0.0412493534,
-0.036854554,
-0.0124607794,
-0.0051781097,
0.0026721728,
-0.020245526,
-0.0170621779,
-0.0272715036,
0.0243240297,
-0.0204716027,
0.0151913501,
-0.0599170923,
-0.0614156052,
-0.0263379067,
-0.0401272774,
-0.0219843201,
0.0537647642,
2.309e-7,
0.0090444097,
0.0079121599,
0.0244479477,
0.0170993004,
0.0331627466,
0.0780705139,
-0.024585491,
0.0595725402,
0.0197735466,
-0.0146153737,
0.0123212375,
0.0756589547,
0.024707973,
0.0263094902,
0.030633498,
0.0274354033,
-0.0667973459,
-0.040303763,
-0.0391546637,
0.0041739251,
0.0515195392,
0.0869668201,
0.0269154944,
-0.0036149162,
0.0302758757,
-0.0049531022,
0.0366981775,
-0.0143603608,
-0.0026480826,
-0.0450664908,
0.005245042,
0.0084813144,
-0.0171181373,
0.0505365431,
-0.0159756504,
-0.045622278,
-0.0096786572,
0.0283864047,
-0.039218694,
-0.0974612609,
-0.0473602228,
-0.0021756729,
0.0016976579,
-0.0575820357,
0.1050984189,
0.009682321,
-0.032254681,
-0.0073414985,
-0.0245002285,
0.0298885722,
-0.0081553273,
0.0067190537,
-0.0244342908,
-0.0095390966,
0.025425598,
-0.0210334733,
-0.0210708492,
-0.0724026188,
-0.0204045139,
0.0371943712,
-0.0550442524,
-0.0068103126,
-0.0099976072,
-0.0087643666,
0.070889473,
-0.0144506404,
-0.0258291718,
1.280946755e-34,
0.0369227268,
0.0315594673,
-0.0141545441,
-0.0421936661,
0.024143137,
-0.0253914725,
-0.0448965244,
-0.0242819116,
0.036293257,
-0.009368455,
-0.0169331618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01615v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01615v1 | FLAP: Fast Language-Audio Pre-training | 2023-11-02T21:58:50 | 2023-11-02T21:58:50 | Ching-Feng Yeh, Po-Yao Huang, Vasu Sharma, Shang-Wen Li, Gargi Gosh | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | We propose Fast Language-Audio Pre-training (FLAP), a self-supervised
approach that efficiently and effectively learns aligned audio and language
representations through masking, contrastive learning and reconstruction. For
efficiency, FLAP randomly drops audio spectrogram tokens, focusing solely on
the remaining ones for self-supervision. Through inter-modal contrastive
learning, FLAP learns to align paired audio and text representations in a
shared latent space. Notably, FLAP leverages multiple augmented views via
masking for inter-modal contrast and learns to reconstruct the masked portion
of audio tokens. Moreover, FLAP leverages large language models (LLMs) to
augment the text inputs, contributing to improved performance. These approaches
lead to more robust and informative audio-text representations, enabling FLAP
to achieve state-of-the-art (SoTA) performance on audio-text retrieval tasks on
AudioCaps (achieving 53.0% R@1) and Clotho (achieving 25.5% R@1). | [
-0.0435429625,
0.0492635295,
0.0024085117,
0.0374101363,
-0.0066148466,
-0.0246575586,
0.0703390315,
-0.0271618515,
-0.0219834596,
-0.0294385012,
-0.1091620475,
-0.0237719808,
0.0009358941,
0.0650683418,
0.0151290223,
-0.0460564159,
0.0223052856,
-0.0495280586,
0.0108546028,
-0.0081339777,
0.0077412883,
0.0140465647,
-0.0429670475,
-0.001159307,
-0.0224818476,
-0.0152886137,
-0.0032753311,
0.0228996444,
0.0155981919,
-0.0346937366,
0.0102345357,
0.037112467,
0.0490936972,
0.0369757265,
0.000001732,
-0.0214578435,
-0.0188743155,
0.011932184,
0.0169658195,
0.0180054549,
0.0491279215,
0.0141258296,
-0.0259702131,
0.0422793441,
-0.011526526,
-0.0420572795,
0.0341913216,
0.0191529319,
0.0331460349,
0.0737547502,
-0.0386270806,
-0.0206050314,
-0.0166921578,
-0.0363730863,
0.004466068,
-0.0042016101,
-0.0106488876,
-0.039787747,
-0.0016966192,
0.0502211824,
0.0112602571,
0.0561930276,
-0.0120691424,
-0.0087484447,
0.0182327703,
0.0225206111,
-0.0951335952,
0.0013459972,
-0.0080690822,
0.0906907618,
0.012402813,
-0.0243929997,
-0.0261790566,
0.0187062137,
-0.0241320096,
-0.0237526894,
-0.0355458111,
-0.0003276356,
0.0264448561,
0.0351189896,
-0.0616448708,
0.0344923139,
0.0438734144,
-0.0023925842,
0.0098423464,
-0.0247757267,
0.0278558694,
-0.0143080875,
0.0198936984,
-0.0181489028,
-0.0062569445,
0.0076690405,
0.0395403951,
0.009591829,
-0.011564143,
-0.0200843196,
-0.0188550577,
-0.0486989282,
-0.0052654692,
-0.0222880803,
-0.0014570777,
0.028974317,
-0.1079202592,
0.1014840007,
-0.0476402268,
-0.0124999611,
-0.0089467643,
0.0146484589,
-0.0303330943,
-0.0360583924,
0.0065263049,
-0.021533642,
-0.0372955352,
0.0253157131,
-0.0513734482,
-0.0253401101,
-0.0034465138,
-0.0398704186,
-0.0389214866,
0.042137105,
-0.0188156627,
-0.0041213334,
-0.0310081411,
-0.0235996284,
0.0278894845,
0.0360859968,
0.0138243437,
0.0656937882,
-0.0394851677,
0.0030466476,
-0.0230711997,
0.0432379209,
0.0334991664,
-0.0070424033,
0.044066254,
0.0653447211,
-0.0188680105,
-0.0252862312,
-0.0077574519,
0.0079948278,
-0.0481464826,
-0.0299012922,
-0.0348562561,
-0.0747915134,
0.0447111502,
0.0046651014,
-0.0397593379,
-0.0141681395,
-0.0103221778,
0.0066821803,
0.0397221893,
0.096082665,
0.0076833339,
0.0010449199,
0.0258768257,
0.0243745614,
-0.0200093091,
0.0664924383,
0.0464355648,
0.0128260544,
0.0293701515,
-0.0266292691,
-0.0191556513,
0.0945979953,
0.0212455876,
0.003946248,
-0.047688596,
-0.0210250467,
0.035161607,
0.0244265795,
0.0684173256,
0.0479684062,
-0.0150532443,
-0.0659637749,
0.0216126777,
0.0497676395,
-0.0024092081,
0.0064157592,
0.0181703158,
0.0156255253,
0.0001515725,
-0.0189470295,
0.0160046257,
0.0321727321,
0.0032316162,
0.0017106273,
0.0562343039,
0.0251941439,
-0.0456566103,
0.0149948923,
0.0074890302,
-0.0144461906,
-0.0009846142,
0.0300408881,
0.038951382,
-0.010173914,
-0.0353344753,
0.0493213832,
0.0280898903,
-0.0410472639,
0.010818338,
-0.0204508081,
-0.0033164201,
0.0585332103,
0.0189398248,
-0.0903323218,
0.0316822343,
-0.0005639088,
-0.0029696552,
0.0521231703,
0.0199789647,
-0.0014319191,
0.0495043956,
-0.0424135663,
-0.0364951156,
-0.0211352874,
-0.0343072154,
0.0574508496,
-0.0133587718,
0.0663326755,
0.0243061148,
-0.0281460844,
0.0173077658,
-0.0030522337,
-0.0209124535,
-0.0659008548,
0.019017132,
0.017452037,
0.0211482923,
0.0277256146,
-0.0258622747,
0.0246924851,
0.0245061759,
-0.0346961133,
0.0420675389,
0.0067254947,
-0.0924696103,
-0.0560926199,
0.0541246347,
-0.0347281657,
0.0118398368,
0.0597451441,
-0.0054962323,
-0.0473031215,
0.0231950339,
0.0100368932,
0.0423533283,
-0.0295817368,
0.0143448859,
0.0076085911,
0.0286838263,
0.0038485597,
-0.0035533344,
0.0541130342,
-0.0003794819,
-0.0220869165,
0.0408780724,
0.055140961,
-0.0073021776,
-0.020026274,
0.0232306756,
0.0161953084,
0.0161593296,
0.0080022477,
-0.0289057996,
-0.0645925403,
0.0080532813,
-0.1022645608,
0.0146629391,
-0.0203531943,
-0.0163186286,
0.0078402292,
-0.0190365203,
0.0127156666,
-0.0536815412,
-0.0451001637,
-0.0352582261,
-0.0148644187,
0.0097127128,
-0.0550156832,
0.0034620918,
-0.016150536,
-0.0316322781,
-0.013917516,
0.0166536644,
0.0039023864,
-0.0310513955,
-0.0270280242,
-0.0077857594,
0.0105926478,
0.0142904036,
0.0439731814,
-0.0158178695,
-0.0077361702,
-0.0128140189,
-0.0287457258,
0.0377700776,
0.024165472,
0.0079111746,
-0.024735935,
0.0622343943,
0.009820723,
-0.0347893685,
0.0124079566,
0.0202772468,
0.0408133864,
-0.0388981923,
0.0264999457,
-0.0150523856,
0.0294007622,
0.0148060834,
0.0180593804,
-0.0184271578,
-0.0491685458,
0.0171896592,
-0.0329193994,
-0.0697858781,
-0.0424648561,
-0.0432158262,
0.0230757128,
-0.0279410519,
-0.0221406519,
0.0410744213,
-0.0694316104,
-0.0313539393,
-0.0698841363,
-0.0607271269,
-0.0312713161,
0.0630276054,
-0.0297551975,
0.025062928,
-0.0193983242,
-0.0606122874,
-0.0478571579,
0.0166629069,
0.0427679084,
-0.0694283247,
0.0015445808,
0.0218601488,
0.0222634114,
-0.0146610336,
-0.0697592869,
-0.0339169465,
-0.0767740831,
-0.0085738543,
0.002519029,
-0.0256183241,
-0.0244097076,
-0.0718140602,
0.0109610204,
0.0489560813,
0.0632409304,
0.0030298405,
0.0277937576,
-0.0225759503,
0.0497160964,
0.0212069172,
-0.0232022945,
-0.0253861062,
-0.0267061945,
0.0346328318,
0.0282347929,
0.0491947681,
-0.0139735537,
-0.0421826616,
0.0154774543,
0.0392631963,
0.0387366116,
-0.0331576541,
0.0054175253,
0.0288688447,
-0.0281553622,
-0.0000302682,
0.1109750494,
0.0088842101,
-0.0622946322,
-0.0503829084,
0.0079992199,
0.0108045498,
0.0178512689,
-0.000165539,
-0.0387494639,
-0.0229476895,
0.0198589079,
0.0358207673,
0.0792470723,
0.0501390509,
-0.0061865244,
-0.0701615512,
0.0158170816,
0.0518791266,
-0.0649586692,
-0.0321295559,
-0.03373776,
-0.0101648998,
-0.0045085363,
0.0566267483,
-0.0077107456,
-0.0289815795,
-0.0158167332,
0.0165394675,
0.002728319,
-0.0171582457,
0.0295544807,
-0.0437376574,
0.0183257908,
0.038100943,
0.0211310834,
-0.0334845148,
-0.0358451903,
0.015333062,
0.0101929642,
-0.0213361569,
0.021542361,
0.0741518214,
-0.0120602567,
-0.0176940728,
0.0335553586,
0.0290430468,
-0.0033902742,
-0.0227440838,
-0.0017589831,
0.0361004211,
0.0164857674,
0.0367937461,
-0.0209876802,
0.045642294,
0.0097285314,
0.0783109739,
-0.0066389907,
-0.0075501469,
0.0400207639,
0.0198501274,
0.0287176482,
-0.0693079829,
-0.0163576957,
0.0183565486,
-0.0025912777,
0.0206081457,
-0.0197297614,
-0.0085043004,
0.0105606755,
0.0213795211,
0.0056406921,
0.0352612659,
-0.0155721512,
-0.0239624046,
-0.0736168027,
0.0782156736,
-0.0230923537,
0.0299683381,
-0.0344573557,
-0.0536978245,
0.0377970301,
-0.0694624633,
-0.006336845,
0.0036932305,
-0.0390671156,
-0.0435776003,
0.0126158493,
-0.0132718077,
0.0098601673,
0.0649166107,
0.0031719427,
-0.027955262,
0.0451621786,
0.0222383365,
-0.0538648106,
0.0162393674,
0.0213756599,
-0.0149670858,
-0.0205966495,
0.004539826,
-0.0837496817,
0.0467371494,
0.0023503564,
0.0233519711,
0.0561279766,
-0.0305322651,
0.0089583714,
-0.0451967604,
0.0815546066,
-0.0232662,
0.0470847636,
-0.0437082686,
-0.0020068819,
-0.0218559243,
0.0057353866,
-0.0130797476,
0.0018933828,
0.0296109226,
-0.003657728,
-0.0365754776,
0.0488958582,
0.0001557229,
-0.0060965503,
-0.038434796,
0.0397773311,
0.0021841996,
-0.0559908338,
0.0446570255,
0.0038967438,
0.0087648239,
0.0204560775,
0.0315582864,
0.0248945858,
-0.0030258095,
0.0201693606,
0.0200545061,
0.0144203464,
-0.0398645774,
0.0224471837,
-0.0272320714,
-0.0035232713,
-0.011642551,
-0.0088257901,
0.0338301845,
-0.0648456812,
0.0011504109,
-0.015535973,
-0.0112789627,
-0.0372861959,
0.0172430556,
-0.0376649462,
0.006904494,
0.022829473,
0.0037101523,
-0.0050663538,
0.0522542447,
0.0732371882,
-0.0180572122,
0.0055513573,
-0.0062512401,
0.0068161464,
-0.0104471929,
-0.0017872355,
-0.0110514089,
0.0567623787,
-0.0357657447,
-0.0051960773,
0.0284933373,
-0.0890702158,
-0.0254839007,
-0.0466059111,
-0.0381079465,
0.0191495921,
0.029649334,
0.051265914,
0.0062751733,
0.0379736461,
0.051835563,
-0.0057917335,
0.0098375846,
-0.0371917523,
0.0079125408,
-5.731199849e-33,
-0.0073904102,
-0.0098775281,
0.0058747539,
0.0038794293,
-0.0003657579,
0.0165084805,
-0.0318555497,
0.015230136,
0.0010131054,
-0.0134619223,
0.0179428477,
0.0172838774,
0.0289115775,
0.0594261363,
-0.0056338604,
0.0275848024,
0.080237627,
-0.0330185704,
0.0023614618,
0.0062267766,
0.0432535447,
0.0522032566,
0.01346849,
-0.0973907039,
-0.0538737699,
0.0030679302,
0.0006946943,
-0.0216975734,
0.0401087999,
0.0521840528,
-0.0105542652,
0.0289927553,
-0.0266623553,
-0.0021406338,
-0.0067585576,
0.0588964783,
-0.1025739089,
0.0006373471,
-0.0213465542,
0.042164553,
-0.0213107951,
-0.0198072717,
0.0326055735,
-0.0299172141,
-0.0016267544,
-0.0112126544,
0.0349459723,
-0.0069042398,
0.0117295021,
-0.0187774356,
-0.0439451188,
0.0097557949,
-0.0113669187,
-0.0314547233,
0.0741663352,
0.0278064962,
0.032472942,
0.0266978331,
-0.0654988885,
0.0321781486,
-0.0234270822,
0.0359167904,
0.029406799,
0.0580826327,
-0.0195571352,
0.0844267532,
0.0610775314,
-0.0728519931,
0.025330035,
-0.0233732648,
0.0415035598,
0.0015442548,
0.0090618599,
0.0136077572,
0.0301836375,
-0.004078364,
-0.0682121366,
0.0147597007,
-0.0255002808,
-0.0307733454,
0.0274930075,
0.0605214983,
-0.0524842218,
0.0123755764,
-0.0457354933,
0.005051706,
-0.0516235828,
-0.0398389623,
0.0420173705,
0.0343291052,
0.0237064399,
-0.0004373273,
0.0523599312,
-0.0118288575,
-0.0157908928,
0.0057576383,
-0.0347357132,
-0.0226573888,
-0.0097377747,
0.0466638021,
-0.0519019961,
-0.0179757904,
0.0965574309,
-0.0074455626,
0.003320345,
-0.0163285546,
0.0354813486,
0.0453431644,
-0.0868646055,
0.006672116,
-0.0011147186,
-0.0252116248,
0.0236449242,
0.0249777175,
0.019021241,
0.0416727737,
-0.0337868817,
0.0567432493,
-0.0102691883,
0.019748304,
-0.0291193221,
-0.0705506951,
-0.0326900296,
0.0080859512,
-0.0085126972,
0.0351683348,
-0.016584212,
-0.0186348762,
0.0350747965,
-0.0406039096,
-0.01088956,
0.0134130158,
2.501e-7,
0.0226465259,
-0.0179074891,
0.0128738508,
-0.0169605091,
0.0294172335,
0.0222374592,
-0.0664641708,
0.0224434752,
-0.0001498914,
-0.0035495106,
0.0096464967,
0.0150043555,
0.0538127087,
0.038385652,
-0.07369221,
-0.0012374055,
-0.0456991792,
-0.0001978224,
-0.0494799502,
-0.0097293984,
0.0456122123,
0.1307077408,
-0.0034978951,
-0.0391041674,
0.0294899046,
-0.058602687,
0.0857009143,
-0.0154716158,
-0.007055372,
-0.062854901,
-0.0347098857,
0.0338504985,
-0.0411364622,
-0.0150043676,
-0.0456134267,
0.0512556992,
0.048996754,
0.0237869881,
0.0204628948,
-0.0763711482,
0.001308358,
0.0757603571,
-0.0126965232,
-0.0050919265,
0.0730138496,
0.0175090153,
-0.033573512,
-0.0220063329,
-0.0558655448,
-0.0086875828,
-0.0088402536,
-0.0219325963,
-0.0402153172,
-0.0054720966,
0.0239428878,
-0.0008718378,
-0.0514316931,
-0.0876522139,
-0.0226397328,
0.0245887656,
-0.0296203308,
-0.0022716508,
-0.034787029,
-0.0181879457,
0.0126518467,
-0.0445765927,
0.0288538039,
2.018003065e-34,
0.0248066261,
-0.0545752309,
0.0049407035,
-0.003745903,
-0.0272986665,
-0.0185949728,
-0.0171545148,
0.0137624107,
0.0131903179,
-0.0520499162,
-0.0247328244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01580v1 | MetaReVision: Meta-Learning with Retrieval for Visually Grounded Compositional Concept Acquisition | 2023-11-02T20:19:58 | 2023-11-02T20:19:58 | Guangyue Xu, Parisa Kordjamshidi, Joyce Chai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Humans have the ability to learn novel compositional concepts by recalling
and generalizing primitive concepts acquired from past experiences. Inspired by
this observation, in this paper, we propose MetaReVision, a retrieval-enhanced
meta-learning model to address the visually grounded compositional concept
learning problem. The proposed MetaReVision consists of a retrieval module and
a meta-learning module which are designed to incorporate retrieved primitive
concepts as a supporting set to meta-train vision-anguage models for grounded
compositional concept recognition. Through meta-learning from episodes
constructed by the retriever, MetaReVision learns a generic compositional
representation that can be fast updated to recognize novel compositional
concepts. We create CompCOCO and CompFlickr to benchmark the grounded
compositional concept learning. Our experimental results show that MetaReVision
outperforms other competitive baselines and the retrieval module plays an
important role in this compositional learning process. | [
0.0206535682,
-0.0126489028,
-0.024126716,
0.0028071599,
-0.0117117958,
0.0072222501,
-0.0393803492,
-0.0346851237,
-0.0966612697,
-0.0482234098,
-0.0411751531,
0.0043321606,
0.0355147943,
0.0447143763,
-0.0398810431,
-0.0605649985,
0.0073373681,
0.0203043502,
-0.0470927209,
0.0140744625,
-0.0081160571,
-0.0264101122,
-0.0153641766,
0.0137481652,
0.0043495777,
-0.0165434163,
-0.0290472731,
-0.0072599836,
0.0256242249,
-0.032304164,
0.0112764807,
0.0215784535,
0.049116157,
0.0290330499,
0.000002018,
-0.034923397,
0.0076331086,
-0.0339138955,
0.0218706205,
-0.0738987997,
0.028565269,
-0.0021643685,
-0.0034838032,
-0.0228070319,
-0.0312656537,
-0.0160814039,
0.0598235875,
0.0370981693,
0.0396561883,
0.0130515257,
-0.0248607956,
-0.0476795919,
-0.0006650359,
-0.002038538,
0.0476448946,
0.0418240838,
0.0009858205,
0.0453204662,
-0.039381329,
0.0003740429,
-0.0494087972,
0.0151554737,
0.0206006858,
0.0230274741,
0.0551573038,
0.0534890108,
-0.0305963475,
0.0179824103,
-0.0162512567,
0.0921069607,
-0.0116826138,
-0.0335359462,
-0.0294170883,
0.0023230417,
0.0125348261,
-0.0128709245,
-0.0647582635,
0.0173936263,
-0.0698603392,
0.0014202071,
-0.0836442858,
-0.0013786539,
-0.0094332956,
-0.0095474534,
-0.0161779243,
-0.0174010843,
0.0027907267,
-0.0025150622,
0.0377137214,
-0.0186392013,
0.0156145729,
0.012133413,
-0.003014467,
0.026951002,
0.0470389426,
-0.0045490833,
-0.0018497609,
-0.0094012953,
-0.0166910011,
-0.0389474966,
0.0916068628,
0.0199422985,
-0.0671123266,
0.0790512413,
-0.0682543144,
0.0289241988,
-0.0005792812,
0.0006056259,
-0.0355893932,
0.0017356684,
-0.0908944383,
-0.0238032993,
-0.0570763946,
0.0648971945,
-0.0062272954,
-0.0180949979,
-0.0164796747,
0.0180367231,
-0.0260780435,
0.0204560608,
-0.0135290241,
-0.0100430148,
-0.0365231894,
-0.0341026448,
-0.0031011638,
0.0241086632,
-0.0069407639,
0.0327746309,
-0.0092527494,
-0.0276178103,
0.0082400776,
-0.0189523846,
0.0225782506,
-0.0147072617,
0.0171900205,
-0.0125922887,
-0.0090130083,
-0.0770901069,
-0.0530146062,
-0.0204847194,
0.0008428757,
-0.0342978165,
0.0253072493,
-0.0402868204,
-0.0014152093,
-0.0331015699,
0.0011802339,
-0.0296404213,
0.0054634172,
0.0271869078,
0.0143884989,
0.0678999498,
-0.0002411587,
-0.0313723758,
-0.0141033102,
0.0149136893,
-0.0564872734,
0.0790551901,
0.0248824656,
0.0567755736,
-0.0177433491,
-0.0090850191,
0.0096020559,
-0.0722961351,
0.0273125954,
-0.006293939,
-0.0340905413,
-0.0287122,
0.0070319031,
0.0071379244,
0.0072380966,
0.0351058654,
-0.0334689431,
-0.0031423189,
0.065456681,
0.0315397084,
-0.0030416704,
0.0115263471,
0.0575931557,
-0.0386969037,
-0.0033835075,
0.0316993073,
-0.0226845238,
0.0999746621,
-0.0401195511,
0.0094756894,
-0.0750367418,
0.021494478,
-0.0555789508,
-0.0188889075,
0.0071962918,
-0.0147168869,
-0.016199654,
-0.0318808965,
0.0514703952,
0.0352081098,
-0.0189441685,
0.0011646081,
0.0161935296,
-0.0494218357,
0.0068697501,
-0.0135199325,
0.0121081453,
0.0402684733,
0.0153736183,
-0.0214010775,
-0.0067825341,
-0.0493526198,
0.0686603561,
0.0323875025,
-0.0119312089,
-0.0132282451,
0.0090509132,
-0.0443982668,
-0.0225449223,
-0.0272511654,
-0.009545546,
0.0331750885,
-0.0024426668,
0.0091635222,
0.0257075708,
-0.0664332435,
0.0250455718,
0.0356237032,
0.0200627875,
-0.016552221,
-0.0330001488,
0.0477938913,
-0.0198914018,
-0.0052395645,
0.0106719518,
0.0088817263,
0.031220546,
-0.0325495414,
-0.0218778364,
0.0855783671,
-0.0690759942,
-0.0189364552,
0.0312887095,
-0.0888493732,
0.0184170045,
-0.0281857569,
0.0072372053,
-0.0306084454,
0.0274958611,
0.0014170241,
0.0443549119,
-0.0496376976,
-0.0078944108,
-0.0019181262,
0.0000706219,
0.0096159652,
0.0441137329,
-0.0250271782,
0.0003293236,
0.0029735849,
-0.0562388711,
0.0338467993,
-0.0078609772,
-0.019105019,
0.0407280922,
-0.0114679793,
0.0144602032,
-0.0054677795,
-0.0230960492,
-0.0494127572,
-0.0186496377,
-0.0328409411,
-0.0430836231,
-0.0028275023,
-0.0491409339,
0.0139391469,
-0.010650822,
0.0249527711,
-0.0393798947,
0.0074989405,
0.0606118627,
-0.0355714485,
0.0496633239,
0.0003149883,
0.0246955566,
0.0058661448,
-0.0018474438,
0.0003098673,
0.0193216354,
0.0671817362,
0.0061672996,
0.0020906692,
-0.002551046,
-0.0327683985,
-0.0022027714,
-0.0019277504,
-0.0358898602,
-0.0146697843,
0.0013453828,
-0.0387518592,
0.0087372493,
0.0709426925,
0.0225816835,
0.0458461121,
0.0600650236,
0.0037297811,
-0.0416245237,
-0.0007144847,
-0.0234484673,
-0.0227710884,
0.0030435524,
0.0382219292,
-0.0118295196,
0.044896137,
-0.0256588981,
0.0176011696,
-0.0888061076,
0.0356800854,
0.0104200523,
-0.0359748006,
-0.0686408877,
0.0030213627,
-0.0214604028,
0.0032145421,
-0.056374643,
-0.0363733433,
0.0618840083,
0.0099088252,
-0.0115302447,
0.0151941422,
0.028335683,
-0.0116933556,
0.0693036094,
-0.034741614,
0.0375866406,
0.0199819729,
-0.038712278,
-0.0735398009,
-0.0273544192,
0.0750363991,
-0.0132532278,
0.0249342807,
-0.0268295314,
0.0267397165,
-0.0271803625,
-0.0272030998,
-0.0580181219,
0.0668014884,
-0.0177466813,
0.0090804985,
-0.059632618,
0.0431772061,
-0.0479684435,
0.01892744,
0.0138258208,
0.0097019086,
0.0368815809,
-0.0082789147,
0.016817214,
0.0101712877,
0.0442319326,
0.0135067767,
-0.0428449288,
-0.0157909598,
0.064489238,
0.0339540914,
0.0120837232,
-0.0238156822,
-0.0447962247,
0.0536817908,
0.000689936,
0.0056101601,
0.0160189345,
0.0157397427,
-0.0370448269,
-0.0432367101,
-0.0219663419,
0.0372081846,
0.0309291594,
-0.0611448698,
-0.0274978541,
-0.0102810226,
0.0135183623,
0.0591464378,
-0.0030487643,
-0.0308675431,
0.0032708598,
0.005151148,
-0.0164892878,
0.0438218154,
-0.0327979401,
-0.0296527762,
-0.0724643469,
-0.0021206862,
0.0335581638,
-0.0780273601,
-0.0752856135,
-0.0010083986,
-0.023278961,
0.0333201364,
-0.0485130176,
0.0245290976,
-0.0264503453,
-0.0164603218,
-0.0015154729,
0.0230887346,
-0.0222362783,
-0.0094432477,
-0.0129425172,
-0.0223258063,
0.0211313721,
0.0136376573,
-0.0039975694,
-0.0566762164,
0.0758710057,
-0.0473258011,
0.0128221195,
-0.0088715618,
0.0618685111,
-0.0485257693,
0.0065480047,
0.0277869664,
0.0201549083,
-0.0334687792,
-0.0591819137,
-0.0206285715,
0.0434999019,
-0.007376621,
0.0118439971,
-0.0250153858,
0.0060629579,
0.0106495228,
0.0219971631,
0.0561643727,
-0.0268995222,
0.0109460289,
0.0087402249,
0.0116037661,
-0.0562549755,
0.0223455075,
0.0511582121,
0.0546473339,
0.0609830059,
-0.0850544497,
0.0067851818,
0.0213299841,
0.0844241306,
0.0172290504,
0.0145608187,
-0.0260192882,
0.0069364477,
-0.1040249765,
0.028363334,
-0.0108028622,
-0.0031871155,
-0.066810146,
-0.0064294464,
0.0483747311,
-0.0821732208,
-0.015694879,
-0.074226059,
-0.0368188508,
-0.0281856488,
0.0082942722,
0.0750088468,
0.0165350139,
0.0242222026,
0.0398066677,
-0.0052316538,
0.048876103,
0.024677692,
0.0514530912,
0.0258000027,
0.0388433151,
-0.0073075914,
-0.0137507934,
-0.0001947845,
-0.0492324494,
0.015157993,
0.0521818213,
0.0300639141,
0.0732567832,
0.0387972705,
0.0841568559,
-0.0357288867,
0.0402196608,
-0.0095338672,
0.0371624343,
-0.0397988446,
0.0100639872,
0.0362341963,
-0.0061470391,
-0.0342490077,
0.0035073189,
0.0001858314,
0.0055630771,
0.0183580276,
-0.0188350026,
0.0044179154,
0.0704787299,
0.0268878415,
-0.0043050116,
0.0070807268,
-0.0214406457,
-0.0091180792,
0.04958703,
-0.026203407,
0.0285218693,
-0.0178677216,
0.0368653089,
-0.0006148954,
0.0549826883,
0.0214363337,
-0.0308012981,
-0.0785173699,
0.0350844488,
-0.0320828408,
0.0455797091,
-0.0309489034,
0.0113540115,
0.0694641173,
0.0217489563,
-0.0319913067,
0.0033137447,
-0.0085223122,
-0.0306572448,
0.0143278986,
-0.0202724412,
-0.0267694779,
0.02005223,
0.0383766368,
0.0234493446,
0.0019829581,
0.0532756709,
-0.068199791,
0.055361487,
-0.0262182914,
0.0324980281,
-0.0274351537,
0.0188514199,
-0.0088180518,
0.0356341042,
0.0009703995,
0.0340947732,
-0.0596310161,
-0.0300160367,
0.0551559739,
0.0062294458,
0.0289193746,
0.0286201723,
0.0790057108,
0.0424209796,
0.0185559802,
-0.0117925638,
0.0070704115,
0.0041967691,
0.0036867431,
0.0421002768,
0.0116769969,
-5.990978223e-33,
-0.0563212223,
-0.0033412499,
0.0343274958,
0.0444670282,
-0.0123595977,
-0.0074175815,
-0.0195605606,
0.0207841508,
-0.0061139883,
-0.0005577626,
0.0392141677,
-0.0032164124,
-0.0074405107,
0.0215262417,
-0.0040720589,
0.0213703364,
0.0405778475,
0.0187936425,
-0.013389972,
-0.0148966098,
0.0550281927,
0.0521837138,
0.020566931,
-0.0356250629,
-0.0777429417,
0.0664138198,
0.0010911025,
-0.0187601093,
0.0156423077,
0.0774187371,
0.0011486821,
0.0479164422,
0.0256054476,
0.0548832826,
-0.008454591,
0.0044759894,
-0.0825853944,
-0.0189272147,
-0.01069964,
0.0132932495,
-0.0192437861,
-0.0183921475,
0.0129916212,
-0.0495805778,
0.0116888341,
-0.0359517038,
0.0386762321,
-0.0414207652,
-0.0473805442,
-0.0073142583,
-0.0632662773,
-0.0160086658,
0.0257532801,
0.0029726701,
0.0313931629,
0.0088196555,
0.0177077744,
0.0217402801,
-0.0106644789,
0.0619065315,
-0.0697204396,
0.0175602008,
0.0021549661,
0.0632271394,
0.0406151451,
0.0865872577,
0.0419001095,
0.0090984879,
0.02405148,
0.008887711,
0.0371851139,
0.0302182529,
0.0068562725,
0.0918566361,
0.035116028,
-0.0053945105,
0.019744372,
-0.0029566404,
-0.0480364002,
0.1044436395,
0.0073743369,
0.0301895011,
-0.0162467696,
0.0070861666,
-0.0607431456,
-0.0268560816,
-0.0488721095,
-0.0365387686,
0.0602520257,
0.0563113205,
-0.0028189761,
-0.0289217476,
0.0509416759,
-0.0342336595,
0.0211616922,
0.0000877325,
-0.0325793289,
0.0398017243,
0.009289477,
-0.0070156888,
-0.0331518427,
-0.041456122,
0.0687860847,
0.0130358301,
-0.0005571026,
-0.0056419722,
0.0591220669,
0.0587782636,
-0.039726045,
-0.0045476831,
-0.0380149335,
-0.0428033173,
0.0312486757,
-0.0106380489,
-0.0000594463,
0.0352208428,
-0.0510505065,
0.0046794587,
-0.0152630685,
-0.0343136601,
-0.0257145837,
-0.0745559186,
-0.0156776477,
0.0694831014,
0.0010075126,
0.0153980115,
-0.0156777743,
-0.0150403343,
0.0791479498,
-0.0540663674,
-0.0043177633,
0.0152118811,
2.831e-7,
-0.0186985321,
0.0093239928,
0.0310211331,
-0.053635098,
0.0158205219,
-0.0140386885,
-0.0598779768,
-0.0066390135,
0.0051687346,
-0.0443592817,
0.0155722154,
0.0387389213,
0.0249852482,
-0.0089430222,
-0.048932232,
0.0633016005,
-0.031938646,
-0.0212391224,
-0.0240445919,
-0.0449453928,
0.049419567,
0.0050234511,
0.0009460596,
0.0069173849,
0.0207204893,
-0.0326722786,
0.1047678739,
-0.0102188811,
0.0487537682,
-0.0665930659,
-0.0288545638,
0.0401070938,
-0.0268230606,
-0.0045855059,
-0.0050650276,
-0.0035301833,
0.0506997406,
-0.0192122553,
-0.0357293561,
-0.0055117533,
-0.0046906355,
0.0485500917,
-0.0032885449,
-0.0156285316,
0.0409478061,
-0.0808433294,
0.0147926128,
-0.0507124774,
-0.0815904886,
-0.0018360275,
0.0091064461,
0.0058485372,
-0.0280264113,
-0.0285805408,
-0.0033680911,
0.0487903431,
-0.001155919,
-0.0944325775,
-0.0076287645,
0.0161901675,
0.0007192788,
-0.0128899654,
-0.0145981116,
-0.0404300764,
0.0042067524,
-0.0308296084,
-0.0474098809,
1.925026627e-34,
0.0173027888,
-0.0278160144,
0.0382793956,
0.0038283009,
-0.0287315585,
-0.0304742064,
-0.0482881293,
-0.0043675965,
0.0469537079,
-0.0189570598,
-0.0171304774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01571v1 | Preserving the knowledge of long clinical texts using aggregated ensembles of large language models | 2023-11-02T19:50:02 | 2023-11-02T19:50:02 | Mohammad Junayed Hasan, Suhra Noor, Mohammad Ashrafuzzaman Khan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Clinical texts, such as admission notes, discharge summaries, and progress
notes, contain rich and valuable information that can be used for various
clinical outcome prediction tasks. However, applying large language models,
such as BERT-based models, to clinical texts poses two major challenges: the
limitation of input length and the diversity of data sources. This paper
proposes a novel method to preserve the knowledge of long clinical texts using
aggregated ensembles of large language models. Unlike previous studies which
use model ensembling or text aggregation methods separately, we combine
ensemble learning with text aggregation and train multiple large language
models on two clinical outcome tasks: mortality prediction and length of stay
prediction. We show that our method can achieve better results than baselines,
ensembling, and aggregation individually, and can improve the performance of
large language models while handling long inputs and diverse datasets. We
conduct extensive experiments on the admission notes from the MIMIC-III
clinical database by combining multiple unstructured and high-dimensional
datasets, demonstrating our method's effectiveness and superiority over
existing approaches. We also provide a comprehensive analysis and discussion of
our results, highlighting our method's applications and limitations for future
research in the domain of clinical healthcare. The results and analysis of this
study is supportive of our method assisting in clinical healthcare systems by
enabling clinical decision-making with robust performance overcoming the
challenges of long text inputs and varied datasets. | [
0.0117904665,
0.0815761164,
0.0177181792,
-0.0396438651,
-0.0150471767,
0.0405742489,
0.0170795172,
0.0317746289,
-0.0053517632,
-0.0292609576,
0.0038879483,
-0.0984589681,
0.0440584458,
0.0032778212,
0.0083407499,
-0.0417380705,
0.0285294019,
-0.0019186373,
-0.0055440608,
-0.0036832986,
0.0015374809,
0.0213034041,
0.0232066009,
0.0533751175,
0.0260990597,
0.0192471854,
0.0015128651,
-0.0200438332,
0.0202691667,
-0.0508729704,
0.0051787207,
0.032948412,
0.0120861586,
0.0031939524,
0.0000017056,
-0.0538491011,
-0.0632349923,
0.0320302323,
-0.0497665368,
-0.0453933775,
0.0148927104,
-0.0519142784,
0.0108029507,
0.0315494239,
-0.0141036529,
-0.0421224311,
0.0090922369,
0.0414844714,
0.0358612947,
0.0502337702,
-0.0190934055,
-0.0132402182,
0.0374893919,
-0.0337942801,
-0.0110472748,
-0.0171747059,
0.0753789619,
-0.006501927,
0.0304333623,
-0.0524877198,
-0.0009892125,
0.033074148,
-0.0119874729,
0.0176191796,
0.0257386211,
0.0650691986,
-0.0381324887,
0.0102493335,
-0.0101571968,
0.0310262255,
-0.03366201,
-0.0034235339,
0.0336101875,
0.0051844697,
0.0070751519,
0.0017414474,
-0.0329981185,
-0.0096412227,
-0.0387143269,
0.0090664588,
-0.0363746472,
0.0044164844,
0.0214388929,
-0.0008906775,
-0.053710755,
-0.0104155559,
0.0134628108,
-0.0334608071,
0.0086038895,
0.0094141327,
-0.0378532372,
-0.0203740895,
0.0111354664,
0.0125548523,
-0.0293189008,
0.0375483707,
-0.0202370137,
-0.0545771495,
0.0555153862,
-0.0549540222,
0.026865514,
-0.0005716622,
0.0058917333,
0.055003453,
-0.0093373992,
-0.0177878346,
-0.005253803,
-0.0115468055,
-0.0524030477,
0.0053920466,
-0.0567666218,
0.0102436505,
-0.0032754175,
0.0392501727,
0.0113603873,
0.013601399,
-0.0574150607,
-0.0154272802,
0.0128526678,
0.0395808294,
0.051167272,
0.0295951962,
-0.0189627707,
-0.0211721454,
0.0034862258,
0.0125686591,
0.035012126,
0.0125361755,
-0.0156068169,
-0.0181733668,
0.025754299,
0.0121007776,
0.0134523595,
-0.0082554901,
0.0166237634,
0.0188069437,
0.0212172624,
-0.0171346106,
0.0163664874,
-0.0314717069,
-0.0636018738,
-0.018685868,
-0.0089692185,
-0.0600730851,
0.0598219857,
0.0133658852,
0.0045747901,
-0.0519926175,
0.0162111707,
0.0067078639,
-0.0311038028,
0.0494544543,
-0.0563928895,
-0.0006609036,
0.0277583078,
0.0050525484,
0.0118146064,
0.0394321941,
0.0209257435,
0.0035911554,
-0.0144021241,
-0.0099404063,
0.0225042272,
0.0414074138,
0.0205628555,
-0.0239610709,
-0.0422702655,
0.0211820547,
0.0405045748,
0.0166719444,
-0.0748060122,
0.0560706183,
0.0043654731,
-0.0207488034,
0.0349677317,
0.0279824659,
0.0155805405,
0.0210622419,
-0.015973866,
-0.0366872512,
0.0092663076,
-0.0198528394,
0.018865943,
-0.0139149576,
0.0116522973,
0.0202543121,
0.0475187786,
0.0271107666,
-0.0160381384,
-0.0577526093,
-0.0620574653,
-0.0231929086,
-0.0485417321,
0.0007606987,
0.0709305927,
-0.046538569,
-0.0387843847,
0.0445647836,
0.0553447381,
-0.0313367918,
-0.004580779,
-0.015362761,
-0.0352454372,
0.0834268183,
0.0475208536,
-0.0565081313,
-0.0291798748,
-0.0434176698,
0.0052157845,
-0.0288240127,
-0.0033786539,
-0.0123654967,
0.0398550332,
-0.0396172069,
-0.031882029,
0.0936496258,
0.016238397,
-0.0001508672,
-0.006862659,
-0.0061978363,
-0.0270662047,
-0.0132980747,
-0.0733786151,
0.0504721217,
-0.059138,
-0.0031620574,
0.009241323,
-0.0137969311,
0.0390401781,
-0.0182079803,
-0.0453370102,
0.0123118749,
0.0463971794,
-0.0422632322,
-0.0766114146,
0.0165902395,
-0.0553941876,
-0.0613647252,
0.020774154,
0.0099226683,
-0.007847379,
-0.0506209284,
-0.0223007239,
-0.0451754108,
-0.0541953221,
-0.0718487799,
0.0302092694,
0.003574918,
0.0371650085,
0.0149456207,
-0.0137235783,
-0.0503235683,
0.042661529,
-0.0519700274,
0.0246562958,
-0.0341258645,
-0.050327871,
0.0255285949,
0.001730061,
-0.0304647461,
0.0343856923,
0.0140803009,
0.0230133999,
0.0247836746,
-0.0662758201,
-0.0204466954,
-0.047949601,
-0.1545799822,
0.0153713673,
-0.0028436196,
-0.0011364776,
-0.0013039456,
0.0386090986,
-0.0108125396,
-0.0162810516,
-0.0359391682,
-0.0440488867,
0.0274693295,
0.0082441699,
0.0189723093,
0.0583658256,
-0.0112690721,
-0.0180372763,
-0.014474228,
-0.058380086,
0.0613337308,
-0.0221883729,
-0.0615429021,
-0.0159521233,
-0.0135425739,
-0.0402165614,
-0.0201346278,
-0.0162460431,
-0.0162325315,
-0.0135971745,
-0.039976012,
0.0382762328,
0.0322779715,
0.0275655054,
0.0082212733,
0.0463044643,
0.0189426374,
-0.018453449,
0.0073686289,
-0.0387744047,
-0.0137129417,
0.0060551027,
-0.0347871855,
-0.0266240556,
0.0378581844,
0.0291328616,
-0.013449261,
-0.0375230461,
-0.0257674102,
-0.0248920005,
0.0477144867,
-0.0454280972,
-0.010277153,
-0.0308496449,
0.0083600096,
0.0048505277,
-0.0580411255,
0.0871373042,
-0.0112299835,
0.027138399,
-0.0675249696,
-0.0226715636,
-0.0543545783,
0.0040524718,
0.0001347441,
0.0136020882,
0.0178305544,
0.0229824092,
0.0085111381,
-0.0014873827,
0.0046912213,
-0.0683960021,
0.0843782425,
0.0095924651,
0.0486285314,
0.0236325301,
-0.0409980193,
-0.0394183062,
-0.0449490659,
-0.0140156765,
0.0150538841,
-0.013777338,
-0.0062686144,
-0.1178473383,
0.007218319,
0.0033408701,
0.059301015,
0.005560148,
-0.0251057632,
0.0138706667,
0.008654614,
0.0023783017,
-0.0245663952,
-0.011885602,
-0.0925029069,
0.0719004348,
0.0460988693,
0.0190035906,
0.0432221927,
-0.0051067895,
-0.0165715702,
-0.0025752047,
-0.0320499279,
-0.0062838066,
0.0210279487,
-0.0033574824,
-0.0405983999,
0.0236706194,
0.1219364777,
0.0302740615,
-0.070546031,
-0.015073387,
0.002751752,
0.0302755684,
-0.0230409317,
-0.0116147771,
0.0026534651,
-0.0180582032,
-0.0021050596,
0.0225200206,
0.0238793995,
-0.0419088788,
0.0224698614,
-0.0431489162,
0.0026288375,
0.0282975007,
-0.0436717831,
0.0172437262,
-0.054361213,
0.01428637,
-0.0381776318,
-0.0227838177,
-0.0097345049,
-0.0210294593,
-0.0126095694,
0.0162557121,
-0.085613519,
-0.0649096742,
-0.0079264259,
-0.0344891697,
0.0379902273,
0.0662216619,
0.0280300863,
-0.0269490946,
0.0123715792,
0.0066431984,
-0.0094919438,
-0.021803027,
0.0125042107,
0.0974580795,
0.0372128896,
-0.0012322133,
-0.0221677385,
0.022276653,
-0.0137677249,
-0.0244456138,
-0.0215461869,
0.0612287335,
-0.0378203169,
-0.0466990992,
-0.0487464182,
-0.0095961271,
0.0153383985,
0.043845199,
-0.0360698029,
-0.0200981125,
0.0077201561,
0.0195374601,
0.0192963406,
0.0175146461,
0.0444741473,
0.0486497767,
-0.0508126579,
-0.0283273868,
-0.0702225193,
-0.0167668853,
0.0615833849,
0.0077799745,
0.0108177857,
0.075787507,
0.0282454379,
0.0212444756,
-0.0674044192,
0.0507584438,
0.0245121475,
0.0167742725,
-0.0369902737,
-0.0324283876,
0.054053355,
0.0222068503,
-0.0117782326,
-0.0375258699,
-0.0098174224,
-0.0296642557,
0.0137656983,
0.0321600437,
0.014690036,
0.0041717221,
0.0358883254,
0.0004549346,
0.0949141085,
0.0512317717,
0.0181793924,
-0.0431896001,
-0.0176512245,
-0.0211782977,
-0.011477598,
0.017204769,
-0.0022571487,
0.0348820128,
-0.0171768107,
-0.013790329,
-0.0306026861,
0.0024261007,
0.0013026749,
0.023365939,
0.0061521013,
-0.0335346423,
-0.0433368757,
-0.0085525075,
0.023715755,
0.0130166486,
0.0141493697,
-0.0171173848,
0.0177446865,
0.0483938307,
-0.0074891569,
0.0050465316,
0.0493494719,
-0.0042145848,
-0.0675673485,
-0.0509383194,
0.0429116637,
0.0062664337,
0.0012020114,
0.073347114,
-0.004271084,
-0.0006607341,
0.0060898503,
-0.0039029433,
0.0155469691,
0.0059008012,
0.0063049793,
0.0123957805,
0.0624255948,
-0.0005500877,
0.0470872037,
-0.0510934368,
-0.01928211,
-0.0586878397,
0.0180256702,
0.0455726795,
-0.0198555384,
0.0361170098,
-0.0152689395,
0.02495813,
-0.0579231791,
-0.0006360327,
-0.008974608,
0.0388739817,
0.0144464727,
0.0259217881,
-0.0314954557,
-0.0085535962,
0.097287342,
0.0169921592,
0.0523926876,
0.0154175647,
-0.0184714142,
-0.0475692824,
0.0054727858,
0.0423136465,
-0.0063551022,
-0.0565816201,
0.011266808,
-0.0293579325,
-0.0208638795,
0.079758808,
-0.012897525,
-0.0197420288,
0.0019591812,
0.0360243171,
0.0045098914,
-0.0170705449,
0.0354337208,
-0.0261740256,
0.0342736207,
-0.014347191,
-0.0115272366,
0.0181177035,
-4.796624902e-33,
0.010166849,
-0.0273807626,
-0.0016661606,
-0.0520160124,
0.0012939975,
0.0313446745,
-0.0106763709,
-0.0208012015,
0.0341376737,
0.0265583359,
-0.0318037644,
0.0051572439,
-0.0025684268,
0.0467572436,
0.0310808141,
-0.021139821,
0.0091769425,
0.0197202489,
-0.0298020877,
0.0188233014,
0.0185670983,
0.0612957031,
0.0372474603,
-0.0489759967,
0.010142711,
-0.0146229006,
0.0044236681,
-0.0056701214,
-0.004818839,
0.0555044375,
-0.0188249052,
0.021449035,
0.0336587615,
-0.0083355997,
-0.0404186286,
0.0121744741,
-0.0099686002,
0.0041283402,
0.0117564583,
-0.0296399351,
0.0124685746,
0.0022615041,
0.0352672935,
-0.0160374567,
-0.0035132561,
-0.0114187263,
0.0245282613,
-0.0668456405,
-0.0292179342,
-0.055719167,
0.0165506229,
0.0690651387,
0.0046025738,
-0.0152598703,
0.0040363986,
-0.0066318819,
-0.0017480797,
0.0564761758,
-0.0105932374,
-0.0251353942,
0.0088049276,
0.0593022294,
-0.0325088575,
-0.0187123362,
-0.0181634594,
0.0998783335,
-0.0067869532,
0.0096571734,
-0.0566111207,
-0.0298118163,
-0.0465603024,
0.0294318777,
0.0711542889,
0.0202843174,
0.0323058553,
-0.0272845104,
-0.0805516988,
0.0850941762,
-0.0447301008,
0.0054328148,
0.0327512771,
-0.0087389918,
-0.023636369,
-0.0027459348,
-0.0301242229,
0.0298251137,
0.0080764014,
0.0239359774,
0.0114859501,
0.0184390843,
0.0044090897,
0.0248978343,
0.0235386342,
-0.0201380923,
-0.0419322141,
0.0145952189,
0.0510132872,
0.0129448213,
-0.0201633386,
0.0180914123,
-0.0194506142,
-0.0212171935,
0.0179285668,
0.0068382081,
0.0164349917,
0.0067043398,
0.063090533,
-0.012659993,
-0.0518192761,
-0.012610239,
0.0344124325,
-0.0319446474,
-0.017558163,
0.0421919972,
0.055725649,
0.0471634939,
0.0319974013,
0.0384367183,
-0.0000624917,
-0.0087688426,
-0.0479514264,
-0.0231595598,
0.019470524,
-0.0172163174,
0.0037991742,
-0.0068472582,
-0.0425234921,
0.022037629,
0.0580220856,
-0.0081025884,
-0.00103219,
-0.0011326656,
2.383e-7,
0.0991680995,
0.058001712,
0.0114364792,
-0.0473896712,
0.0098713338,
0.0078021153,
-0.0410160907,
0.0242568776,
0.0031749515,
-0.0023625307,
0.0250710119,
-0.0017959843,
0.0758327916,
0.0480534509,
-0.0929988772,
-0.0369349159,
-0.1025076061,
-0.0173682924,
-0.054875344,
-0.0132531105,
0.0542158484,
0.1126927584,
-0.0393387005,
-0.0202109553,
0.0036429598,
-0.0137119954,
0.0450944975,
-0.0337167233,
-0.002904969,
0.0484372899,
0.0341009349,
0.0092484886,
-0.0069350414,
0.0452242605,
-0.0296106134,
0.0275922827,
-0.0021564732,
0.0773156211,
-0.041836869,
0.0469397008,
0.0208122171,
0.007971447,
0.0090819802,
-0.0259338059,
0.0483366475,
-0.02859574,
-0.0109899407,
-0.0218182262,
-0.0177586153,
-0.0030160279,
0.0908019096,
0.0295227617,
-0.0222902428,
0.0687630251,
-0.0039759679,
-0.0055056619,
-0.0170858279,
-0.095781751,
-0.0406350456,
0.0637373477,
-0.0428749993,
-0.0446841344,
0.0351808481,
-0.0130323032,
0.0033572172,
-0.1026318967,
0.0322919227,
2.15553269e-34,
0.0525785871,
-0.0132641504,
-0.0258057695,
0.0431550257,
0.0229931958,
-0.0736532658,
0.0263321754,
0.016805578,
-0.0158702005,
-0.0999974385,
0.0205583218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01555v1 | Instruction Distillation Makes Large Language Models Efficient Zero-shot Rankers | 2023-11-02T19:16:21 | 2023-11-02T19:16:21 | Weiwei Sun, Zheng Chen, Xinyu Ma, Lingyong Yan, Shuaiqiang Wang, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Dawei Yin, Zhaochun Ren | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recent studies have demonstrated the great potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) serving as zero-shot relevance rankers. The typical approach involves
making comparisons between pairs or lists of documents. Although effective,
these listwise and pairwise methods are not efficient and also heavily rely on
intricate prompt engineering. To tackle this problem, we introduce a novel
instruction distillation method. The key idea is to distill the pairwise
ranking ability of open-sourced LLMs to a simpler but more efficient pointwise
ranking. Specifically, given the same LLM, we first rank documents using the
effective pairwise approach with complex instructions, and then distill the
teacher predictions to the pointwise approach with simpler instructions.
Evaluation results on the BEIR, TREC, and ReDial datasets demonstrate that
instruction distillation can improve efficiency by 10 to 100x and also enhance
the ranking performance of LLMs. Furthermore, our approach surpasses the
performance of existing supervised methods like monoT5 and is on par with the
state-of-the-art zero-shot methods. The code to reproduce our results is
available at www.github.com/sunnweiwei/RankGPT. | [
0.0200172123,
0.0554623865,
0.0178234559,
0.0408614986,
0.0135618495,
0.008404254,
0.030850511,
-0.0008766229,
0.0250822119,
-0.0901731253,
-0.0668767169,
-0.0147919375,
-0.0137165394,
-0.0301114134,
-0.0022023399,
-0.0145459427,
0.0157267805,
-0.0395845659,
-0.0181279965,
-0.0130524207,
-0.0307655167,
0.028986251,
0.0313995481,
0.0183442757,
0.0958966613,
-0.0093619814,
-0.0150887575,
0.0319678187,
0.036169,
-0.0164954253,
0.0042412174,
0.0707325563,
0.0282782614,
0.0564011969,
0.0000020175,
-0.0235936139,
-0.0370425768,
0.0126176225,
-0.0126647484,
0.0588742234,
0.0110031655,
0.0173279736,
0.0108146919,
0.0172640271,
-0.0194894727,
0.0076630036,
0.0003225356,
-0.0116266273,
0.0621870682,
0.066076532,
0.0177217573,
-0.0113197668,
0.0407780446,
-0.0308105834,
0.048070062,
-0.0406329818,
0.0359876342,
-0.0307706948,
0.0325536914,
0.0863875672,
-0.0248729419,
0.0074896426,
-0.0157667268,
-0.039190501,
0.0186262261,
0.0325581394,
-0.0750489756,
0.0125624342,
0.0223899987,
0.0832491294,
-0.0400502682,
-0.0101216203,
0.0208215695,
0.0155172329,
-0.0000755606,
0.0158605222,
-0.0596977957,
0.0183891859,
-0.0076982379,
0.0035410777,
0.0215909835,
-0.0038404819,
0.0116016325,
0.0289943665,
-0.0209877864,
0.0553976074,
0.0334416069,
-0.0407568291,
0.0198654756,
-0.0076761045,
-0.0446946658,
-0.0227470864,
-0.0296774395,
0.0162333231,
-0.0184325706,
0.0098642604,
-0.0229034424,
0.0019197076,
0.0146891745,
-0.0621520542,
0.0479997508,
0.0478887334,
-0.000418643,
0.0618347079,
-0.04252306,
0.0732312575,
0.0152313691,
0.0190945156,
-0.0504440852,
0.0214485116,
-0.066284582,
0.0097659482,
-0.0143609131,
0.0419089384,
-0.024770597,
-0.0109734042,
-0.0475396216,
0.017101083,
-0.0243267976,
-0.0142961647,
0.0397205912,
-0.0202407204,
-0.0257648695,
0.0113192676,
-0.0011097592,
0.0335614793,
0.0083476575,
-0.0110086435,
-0.0522152968,
-0.0349939987,
-0.0093848128,
0.0199693833,
-0.0005769023,
-0.0147589715,
0.0210454371,
-0.0092137372,
-0.0049770307,
-0.0482734852,
-0.0021294614,
-0.0160393044,
0.0000447649,
-0.055611562,
-0.0158664249,
-0.0703400224,
0.0022283907,
0.0120356949,
0.037707366,
-0.0330624916,
0.0176114626,
0.0414608754,
-0.0394802131,
0.0502165854,
0.0406048,
0.0050842403,
0.0115489056,
0.0243557673,
-0.0114439391,
0.0416833758,
-0.0069505027,
0.0317277722,
0.0372138172,
-0.0142330416,
-0.0115329446,
0.0131712407,
0.0244538765,
0.0454907604,
-0.0025263645,
0.0262225028,
0.0126228537,
0.0006487063,
0.0362538509,
0.0195872225,
-0.0327430069,
0.0013911393,
0.0167158712,
0.0195460226,
0.0487193875,
-0.0379228108,
0.057898242,
0.0251943916,
-0.0302264355,
0.0272865985,
-0.0480073877,
0.0035175832,
-0.0279142335,
-0.0239800271,
0.0967983231,
0.011092931,
-0.0457868166,
-0.0181916635,
-0.0037865003,
0.0173597876,
-0.0395689867,
0.0109309573,
0.0413027033,
-0.0253289156,
-0.0292566661,
0.0417764746,
0.0441461504,
-0.0391088389,
0.0101777958,
-0.063165307,
-0.01044467,
0.0698487461,
0.0491681471,
-0.0582177639,
-0.0020943384,
0.0123834806,
0.0339450501,
-0.0193376634,
-0.0147235105,
-0.0169579703,
0.0206552465,
-0.0505852848,
-0.0578925349,
-0.0192877036,
0.0093903169,
0.0482406802,
0.009141814,
0.0311101656,
0.034788616,
-0.0495863333,
-0.0190536622,
0.0234980583,
-0.0396805815,
-0.0672969297,
0.0390925929,
-0.0239180885,
0.0009046897,
-0.0176382456,
-0.0035812976,
-0.0064943414,
0.0367403738,
-0.0005467868,
-0.0078378012,
-0.0887061507,
-0.0283675175,
-0.0633688271,
0.0310947113,
-0.0290677492,
0.031510666,
0.0325985923,
-0.0737903416,
-0.0346742049,
0.0029482895,
0.0100594331,
-0.0017107484,
0.0040361281,
0.0510465167,
0.0005356081,
0.0113735441,
-0.0432791188,
0.0614588857,
-0.0053727659,
0.0673202723,
0.062043082,
0.0011182565,
0.0017592964,
-0.0200866014,
-0.0450793393,
0.0206168685,
0.0029934593,
0.0122144027,
0.0210530963,
0.0498123616,
-0.0229227617,
-0.0463353023,
-0.1038361043,
0.0226662401,
-0.028245654,
0.022535624,
0.0158111192,
0.0039748689,
0.0205806755,
-0.0035093958,
-0.0071671903,
-0.0480029546,
-0.0294228978,
0.0193097778,
-0.0166627131,
0.0131237544,
-0.0166773871,
-0.0266823974,
-0.063480407,
0.0089670252,
0.0505829901,
-0.0237963069,
0.032681454,
-0.0503661819,
0.0622106753,
-0.0471861996,
0.0155827748,
-0.0106883785,
-0.0020584017,
0.0007015293,
-0.0506565459,
0.0066918507,
0.0514011681,
-0.0075424071,
0.0190069526,
0.086350739,
-0.0071329353,
-0.0961811692,
0.0072592045,
0.0004636836,
-0.0208606198,
-0.0157132149,
-0.0304074883,
-0.0102036605,
0.0311695728,
-0.0021084347,
-0.0359055139,
-0.0545062609,
-0.0024035424,
-0.0198537055,
-0.0008666467,
-0.0864295289,
0.0069342162,
0.0224656742,
0.0078630894,
0.007391097,
-0.048549071,
0.0538149774,
-0.0209141336,
0.0070370208,
-0.0383646265,
-0.0075378884,
-0.081709519,
-0.0025623811,
0.0172824282,
-0.0002284421,
-0.0508290827,
0.0109559838,
-0.0463867933,
0.0257268995,
0.0239596535,
-0.053231623,
0.0375957265,
-0.0362774171,
0.0301987845,
-0.0315374918,
-0.0348556265,
-0.0179167632,
-0.0668574944,
0.0421977192,
0.0309594423,
0.0106980531,
-0.0250112824,
-0.0392991528,
-0.0073406002,
0.0405609868,
0.0594373122,
-0.0375452377,
-0.0398714282,
-0.0087309303,
0.0431651473,
0.0438188203,
-0.0647559538,
-0.0396761484,
0.0024905987,
0.0514158867,
0.0401896536,
0.058346536,
0.0080047073,
-0.0020906043,
-0.0052624717,
0.0732534677,
-0.0299529247,
-0.0437557176,
0.0239154268,
-0.0015080883,
-0.017663341,
-0.0229938496,
0.1034901068,
0.0426049866,
-0.0471892767,
-0.0265293289,
-0.0179680865,
0.0416695401,
0.0237710122,
0.0431865007,
-0.084628962,
-0.0112831919,
-0.007339736,
0.04097436,
-0.0014639451,
-0.0166908205,
-0.0204346273,
-0.1427820921,
0.0527028553,
0.0117284171,
0.0002786356,
0.0063822013,
-0.0731951296,
-0.0020924944,
-0.0081819361,
-0.0154539244,
0.0284276307,
-0.04887826,
0.0159498435,
0.0097213956,
0.0073135467,
-0.0433456339,
0.0372310691,
0.0163398143,
0.0164157394,
0.0396267846,
0.0547640137,
-0.0004159534,
-0.0313400216,
-0.0054513691,
-0.0548645295,
-0.0188771859,
-0.0400474817,
0.037422739,
-0.0285231099,
0.0183762684,
0.0156329703,
0.0340229683,
-0.0162372906,
0.0324489884,
0.0176437832,
0.0658862442,
-0.0211816803,
0.0094778463,
-0.0370923914,
-0.0236489344,
0.00746996,
0.0741497427,
-0.0033061409,
-0.0349779837,
0.0187981892,
-0.0579713657,
0.0006865445,
-0.0200089533,
-0.0428189002,
0.0179825202,
-0.0571624748,
-0.0080367066,
-0.0363063551,
-0.0044305767,
0.0301961899,
-0.0079716826,
-0.0114320423,
0.0251813121,
-0.0539669394,
-0.0060421336,
-0.0159903485,
0.0056242421,
-0.0094725275,
0.0083134454,
-0.0879492015,
0.0032821675,
0.0502522066,
-0.0093126455,
-0.0392518118,
-0.035378892,
-0.0552101657,
-0.0483083464,
-0.029356733,
0.0459460989,
0.0104981856,
0.0069726864,
-0.0024804336,
-0.0566842742,
0.0795874968,
0.0628794804,
-0.0117655499,
0.0141981421,
0.0376839079,
-0.0084586386,
-0.0264413822,
0.0335626155,
-0.0731793493,
0.0473971292,
0.0174528081,
0.0197687931,
-0.0324828401,
-0.0285503455,
0.0103088776,
0.0402741544,
0.0701761097,
-0.0170156918,
0.0055347765,
-0.0183340963,
0.0500038192,
-0.0308833662,
-0.0163157713,
-0.0364731327,
0.0343742184,
0.0663061887,
-0.0323219858,
-0.034019459,
0.0368377529,
-0.0115511939,
0.0169194154,
-0.0698325932,
0.0168950167,
0.015188776,
-0.015428449,
0.0310063064,
-0.0000071693,
-0.0275475048,
0.0120224841,
0.0261298362,
0.0382295176,
-0.0399660505,
0.041495733,
0.0123146521,
0.0376897044,
0.0056580491,
0.0463425703,
-0.1015279964,
-0.0343036428,
-0.0421665236,
0.00887373,
0.0389910303,
0.0278797653,
0.0704079494,
0.0149313416,
-0.0140751703,
-0.0458537117,
-0.0254546478,
0.0360230766,
-0.0138313314,
0.0083389524,
0.0539542213,
0.0242803283,
0.0582090169,
0.0997790024,
0.0183994044,
0.0134937167,
0.0156461149,
-0.0309670176,
-0.0188182909,
-0.0157110598,
0.0133907283,
0.0433037691,
0.0051750899,
0.0152746746,
-0.0164968278,
-0.000765016,
-0.0036094037,
-0.0173256658,
-0.0179540385,
-0.0599941276,
0.0237692539,
0.0165169351,
-0.023665119,
0.0126416078,
-0.0793060139,
-0.0157798957,
-0.0078169787,
-0.0707551464,
-0.0339238569,
-6.20396531e-33,
-0.0266630743,
-0.0188531782,
-0.0044359053,
0.0017219057,
0.0302455779,
0.0245035607,
0.0174085144,
-0.0228672475,
-0.0199355707,
-0.0050393911,
-0.0202692747,
0.0294651389,
0.0119467657,
0.010981,
0.0200732611,
0.0157565549,
0.0511829332,
0.0162767675,
-0.030786423,
0.0412841737,
0.052299425,
0.0141745089,
0.0127436994,
-0.0382944122,
0.0171199348,
-0.0436216854,
-0.0007998132,
-0.0111001777,
-0.0168858897,
0.0772973672,
0.0118473982,
0.0546110272,
0.0242779013,
-0.0618560538,
0.0013499559,
-0.0146721238,
-0.0379624069,
-0.0399418138,
-0.0033036319,
-0.0563241988,
-0.0263670441,
-0.0176375844,
0.0246352013,
0.0210759509,
-0.0232969336,
-0.0629349127,
0.042274788,
0.0106153795,
-0.0381184965,
-0.0431781188,
-0.0364766046,
0.0238163508,
-0.0155569063,
-0.0293867365,
0.038226705,
0.0696703494,
0.0063852142,
0.0800508857,
-0.0560375154,
0.0334445201,
0.0067423866,
0.1072060019,
0.0446353815,
0.0009156765,
-0.03218152,
0.0211358964,
-0.008395277,
-0.0005818536,
0.0354953557,
-0.0743859261,
0.0138119683,
0.0384426862,
-0.0025052868,
0.0246750787,
0.068122074,
0.0518268161,
-0.0692213774,
0.0513161197,
-0.0007754439,
0.01239336,
0.016796343,
0.0086852871,
-0.0452868938,
-0.0411038212,
-0.0330869257,
0.0006089515,
-0.060345985,
-0.0164106693,
0.0301436428,
0.0141222961,
-0.0372403041,
-0.0171046183,
0.0590113886,
-0.0462574027,
-0.0410708785,
0.0648526549,
-0.0322127864,
0.0104636727,
0.0034546352,
0.0292596817,
-0.0326847658,
-0.0232052132,
0.0389406011,
-0.0222850535,
0.0009753294,
0.0024025396,
0.0373597071,
0.0185228083,
-0.0655615702,
-0.0198476668,
-0.0124106249,
-0.013791197,
-0.0385250598,
0.0400560908,
-0.0141296713,
0.0174742714,
0.01242931,
0.075629659,
0.0405082032,
0.0111478698,
-0.0124424081,
-0.0418942682,
0.0159260333,
-0.0072978558,
-0.0215571374,
0.0305857603,
-0.0085028755,
0.0395301506,
0.0206871014,
-0.0372327305,
-0.0326702483,
0.0081283515,
2.782e-7,
0.0283328258,
0.0335697308,
-0.0493665077,
0.0070627318,
0.0153070204,
0.0174726304,
-0.0195293538,
0.0435214713,
0.0501766317,
-0.0055503906,
0.0146763381,
0.004992424,
0.0309177861,
0.0117398519,
-0.0650147349,
-0.001695014,
-0.0673389658,
-0.0193021204,
-0.0577837825,
-0.0469091237,
0.0478875078,
0.0957773775,
0.0090597114,
0.008869281,
-0.0159593653,
-0.0113016712,
0.0495215133,
-0.0001384335,
-0.0149705894,
0.0170490723,
0.0511827134,
-0.0093948524,
-0.0176899377,
-0.0230538547,
-0.0274041761,
0.0240525138,
0.0130940964,
0.0763456747,
-0.0295699891,
0.0122043574,
0.01662286,
-0.0206203386,
-0.0092736082,
-0.0350674354,
0.0844323635,
-0.0186653305,
0.0069067553,
0.0111473575,
-0.0408292264,
-0.0187081695,
0.0408904143,
-0.0225821473,
0.0094237374,
0.0303289462,
-0.0020550787,
-0.0302999895,
-0.0185959693,
-0.0624078363,
-0.0080031026,
-0.015517923,
-0.0164812263,
-0.0574579537,
-0.0021923115,
0.0004734309,
-0.0213384479,
-0.0621969178,
0.0281050187,
2.544496883e-34,
0.0388965793,
0.000593062,
0.0138681512,
-0.0324823372,
0.0173310693,
0.0022914438,
-0.0609795824,
0.0202471372,
0.0199324023,
-0.1073710173,
-0.0302637406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01544v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01544v3 | Divergent Token Metrics: Measuring degradation to prune away LLM components -- and optimize quantization | 2023-11-02T18:55:53 | 2024-04-03T11:49:53 | Björn Deiseroth, Max Meuer, Nikolas Gritsch, Constantin Eichenberg, Patrick Schramowski, Matthias Aßenmacher, Kristian Kersting | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have reshaped natural language processing with
their impressive capabilities. However, their ever-increasing size has raised
concerns about their effective deployment and the need for LLM compression.
This study introduces the Divergent Token Metrics (DTMs), a novel approach to
assessing compressed LLMs, addressing the limitations of traditional perplexity
or accuracy measures that fail to accurately reflect text generation quality.
DTMs measure token divergences that allow deeper insights into the subtleties
of model compression, in particular, when evaluating components' impacts
individually. Utilizing the First Divergent Token Metric (FDTM) in model
sparsification reveals that 25% of all attention components can be pruned
beyond 90% on the Llama-2 model family, still keeping SOTA performance. For
quantization, FDTM suggests that more than 80% of parameters can be naively
transformed to int8 without special outlier management. These evaluations
indicate the necessity of choosing appropriate compressions for parameters
individually -- and that FDTM can identify those -- while standard metrics
result in deteriorated outcomes. | [
-0.0143991681,
0.056379769,
-0.018292198,
0.0187858529,
-0.0380643122,
-0.0025524993,
0.0051175472,
0.0327156223,
-0.0599355511,
-0.0281410608,
-0.0308760609,
-0.0401344337,
0.0131963659,
0.0289664865,
0.0398548916,
-0.0088822106,
0.0771761239,
-0.0211401619,
0.0175371617,
0.0207207277,
-0.0020416945,
-0.0232804492,
0.0483751334,
0.0525869429,
0.0005121318,
-0.0233128164,
0.0178676825,
0.0118596433,
-0.0118927835,
-0.0348006263,
-0.0169736501,
0.0633686259,
-0.0063724192,
0.0403811373,
0.0000019645,
-0.0603367724,
0.0079381317,
0.0191739593,
-0.0366381444,
0.0772223473,
0.0484108403,
0.0003653548,
-0.0052987649,
0.0318072699,
-0.0049813082,
-0.0067720269,
0.036325518,
0.0358241536,
0.0479450524,
0.0528488681,
0.0057625952,
0.0023597467,
0.0385785475,
-0.0351647362,
-0.0105185667,
0.0212812293,
0.0091176312,
-0.0145083973,
-0.025965564,
0.0071902662,
-0.0281703807,
0.0257639382,
0.0223247688,
-0.0012383935,
0.0249813329,
0.0275823269,
-0.0485027917,
-0.0330856778,
0.0102681676,
0.0338486582,
-0.049008619,
-0.029424062,
-0.0072776368,
-0.0062548839,
-0.0034602061,
-0.0702436641,
-0.0545346551,
0.0103382906,
0.0344545655,
0.0217198431,
0.0250436179,
-0.0104121203,
0.0429995544,
-0.0136261741,
-0.0420723036,
0.0431786515,
0.0192503333,
-0.0354586281,
-0.0295893159,
-0.0323848017,
-0.0687610656,
-0.0433168709,
0.0085209366,
-0.0169895086,
-0.0152650941,
-0.0025872986,
-0.0527072959,
-0.06976711,
0.046143394,
-0.0168241169,
0.0553189255,
0.042840682,
-0.0300962608,
-0.0089084459,
-0.0245895404,
0.099597849,
0.0139870169,
0.0179649778,
-0.0409336574,
0.0300135091,
0.0031257477,
-0.0344204344,
-0.0188943762,
0.0501664728,
-0.0351769663,
-0.0395519994,
-0.0250396989,
0.0057449029,
0.0089159226,
-0.0287228338,
0.0431570075,
0.0244670548,
-0.035442695,
0.0130482791,
-0.0034381354,
0.0283844899,
-0.0431611873,
0.0250582881,
0.0424896069,
-0.0541710593,
-0.0292998012,
0.0442497469,
-0.0034115484,
-0.0279581565,
0.0044615339,
0.047306668,
0.016641004,
-0.0305679031,
-0.0139384111,
-0.0283691976,
-0.025053665,
-0.0643361807,
-0.0048805298,
-0.066696614,
0.0035268185,
-0.007128743,
-0.0142796375,
-0.0421986654,
-0.0025046209,
0.003476562,
-0.0098042451,
0.0093975747,
-0.045858033,
0.0176462494,
-0.0034388532,
0.0051753041,
0.0407307968,
0.0832082629,
0.0331965424,
0.0270439815,
0.0392107181,
-0.0164895598,
-0.0173068047,
0.0222394876,
0.0377426632,
0.0202850103,
-0.0431943908,
-0.0256012026,
-0.0455676727,
0.0218458809,
0.0937926322,
0.0910890996,
-0.056618657,
-0.0260180589,
0.0682151914,
0.0718299076,
0.041928865,
0.0387520455,
0.0199795924,
0.0031685149,
0.0038647861,
0.0240451936,
-0.0332784131,
0.0261040572,
0.0191708226,
0.0122699551,
0.0892559215,
0.0284752622,
-0.0225169659,
-0.0708775818,
-0.0228138864,
0.0042875712,
-0.0215242244,
-0.0436785445,
-0.0031602213,
-0.0089692175,
-0.0355826393,
0.0879747942,
-0.0049855541,
-0.0644290149,
0.0001842275,
-0.0815117508,
-0.0006378549,
0.0405494273,
0.0452879258,
-0.0041703372,
-0.0157429967,
0.0159876961,
-0.0362451784,
0.0242766589,
-0.0001304381,
0.0274139717,
0.0297058187,
-0.0311636422,
0.0091540758,
-0.0365100205,
0.0485364385,
-0.0162868984,
-0.0039848941,
0.0004444149,
0.0319895074,
-0.0785665214,
-0.011072496,
0.0419117026,
-0.0022483882,
-0.0274167489,
0.028453283,
-0.0196393263,
0.0643163398,
0.012982849,
-0.0198416356,
0.0416605137,
0.0403715819,
-0.0541988835,
0.0115893325,
-0.0087755043,
-0.007903887,
-0.0148922428,
0.0463354923,
-0.0176214948,
0.0658399984,
0.0682203993,
-0.0140432054,
-0.0300130043,
0.0421523489,
-0.0706147626,
0.0333421193,
-0.0414083079,
0.0483789146,
-0.0127778444,
0.0625703782,
-0.024816107,
0.0386664718,
-0.0456258059,
0.0261372756,
0.0113780173,
-0.0094307987,
0.0208462067,
-0.018408902,
-0.0117939264,
-0.0243560933,
-0.0321527347,
-0.0062738708,
0.017386144,
-0.0042282105,
-0.0332112648,
-0.030006662,
-0.0526951961,
0.0115185687,
-0.0286318734,
0.0611205511,
0.0483385697,
0.0082639083,
-0.0102829318,
0.0492684133,
-0.0103816474,
-0.0356042907,
0.0351864882,
0.0285405498,
0.0424529053,
-0.0100862663,
-0.0224239696,
-0.0568253435,
-0.0302383322,
0.0131257977,
0.0530771278,
-0.0496976562,
-0.0216267537,
-0.0723092407,
0.0393068306,
-0.0438526459,
-0.0209521335,
0.0046798536,
-0.0680362955,
0.0162631962,
0.0337396599,
0.0513655283,
0.0495549925,
0.010478179,
0.0229027607,
0.0488634855,
0.0016573246,
-0.0302810539,
-0.0124618877,
-0.0053157248,
0.0095892353,
-0.0114097008,
-0.0617247187,
0.0459931232,
0.0539117828,
-0.0021369217,
-0.0202469267,
-0.0427421853,
0.0143832453,
-0.0351505652,
-0.0491998643,
0.0172589738,
-0.025160579,
-0.0362800993,
0.0704376176,
-0.0106494371,
-0.0710793436,
-0.0003677363,
-0.0541449599,
0.014377676,
-0.0125435051,
0.0086085433,
-0.0420130789,
0.0270039495,
0.0217061955,
0.0177355241,
0.0002673079,
-0.0368081555,
-0.0372524671,
0.0158454683,
-0.0271510594,
-0.0249191485,
0.0330730304,
-0.0154497931,
-0.0088479482,
-0.0054358039,
0.0053633088,
0.0171326231,
-0.0020005016,
0.0300750807,
0.0398776978,
0.0702463463,
-0.0171464607,
-0.0165166575,
0.0194813497,
-0.0148144765,
0.0223854333,
-0.019797897,
0.0007237897,
-0.0094987443,
0.0289957765,
0.0410512313,
0.0029182341,
0.0785631388,
-0.0243709162,
0.015453429,
0.0450271703,
-0.0060806223,
0.0293691363,
-0.0154365897,
-0.0022974473,
0.0161766186,
-0.0178501923,
-0.0478921644,
0.0341282301,
0.0877146348,
-0.047509905,
-0.034008909,
0.0909490064,
0.0307283215,
-0.0035363205,
0.0530396067,
-0.0356816724,
0.0846970752,
0.0229544323,
0.0025646894,
-0.0658599436,
-0.0026700455,
0.0252636131,
0.0395786949,
-0.0261075255,
-0.0017844167,
-0.0171714611,
-0.0647892579,
0.0400580838,
0.0137892403,
-0.0337930843,
-0.0055552744,
-0.0592316017,
-0.0133927651,
-0.0189490635,
0.0642298907,
0.0204615314,
0.0001879227,
-0.0023818838,
0.01666677,
-0.0653672144,
-0.0443251058,
-0.009258708,
-0.0010067821,
0.0569298342,
0.0300182514,
0.0207724664,
0.0091356961,
-0.0196421593,
0.0429990292,
0.0004882521,
0.0186723657,
-0.0314322822,
0.0306074694,
0.034291137,
0.0067965407,
-0.0191729777,
0.0099238949,
-0.0148151247,
-0.0072018164,
-0.0477010272,
0.0517193489,
-0.0085574389,
-0.0289527755,
-0.0386485271,
-0.015695164,
-0.0392970815,
0.077306129,
0.0700444207,
0.0025826439,
-0.065862447,
-0.0104400162,
0.0269605946,
-0.038125921,
-0.0100468723,
-0.0154286893,
-0.0137291467,
-0.07553339,
-0.0730635375,
-0.0084838159,
-0.0242139585,
0.0147744631,
-0.0241881013,
0.0189071111,
-0.0324120522,
-0.0087211626,
-0.0418818295,
0.036158666,
-0.0031099129,
-0.0089584207,
-0.0786527768,
0.0360553041,
-0.0185315292,
0.0092859007,
-0.0355517566,
-0.0220534597,
-0.1350126565,
-0.0642315671,
-0.0056526386,
0.0320264995,
0.0241011009,
0.0148459608,
0.0179060586,
-0.0673265532,
0.0341354348,
0.0687795579,
-0.0242269151,
0.0838123858,
0.0124634765,
-0.0481301881,
0.0055928524,
0.0456063002,
-0.0090151243,
0.0242404714,
-0.0122888023,
0.0514412895,
0.0053355563,
-0.0297309645,
-0.0045106597,
0.0534760803,
0.0497875549,
-0.01702228,
-0.0157095734,
0.0030275688,
0.0051349103,
-0.0446258932,
0.0100219883,
-0.0401693955,
-0.0210530888,
0.0143470522,
0.0205152333,
-0.024229737,
0.0340422839,
-0.0328272097,
0.0308632981,
-0.0053962683,
0.0191064999,
-0.0605023019,
0.0066072824,
-0.0041243718,
0.0025263417,
-0.0223458968,
-0.0593971498,
-0.0469096154,
0.0160261802,
-0.0270625334,
-0.0008511773,
-0.038257435,
0.0577429719,
-0.0172672458,
0.0654029697,
-0.0333003923,
-0.0222680531,
-0.0286842063,
0.0007041993,
0.0246592555,
0.0066020079,
0.0842962265,
-0.005806216,
0.0068384735,
-0.0342243202,
0.0112511916,
0.009754275,
0.0002097653,
0.0199879073,
0.0062172748,
-0.0250057485,
-0.0319051221,
0.0890410691,
0.009473999,
0.02490055,
-0.03307347,
0.0085658533,
-0.0103398599,
-0.0370518267,
-0.019732276,
0.0382061936,
-0.0069193533,
-0.0327505767,
-0.0398317166,
-0.0536165349,
0.0050541544,
0.0067577125,
-0.000555628,
-0.0187739953,
-0.0020683866,
0.0498991497,
-0.0057615521,
-0.0436855294,
-0.0096238777,
-0.0451749228,
-0.0026237513,
0.0000154959,
0.0122445086,
-6.612859551e-33,
-0.0273431428,
-0.025094606,
0.0084615983,
-0.0400560983,
-0.0829117149,
0.0299590696,
-0.0270422567,
0.0172163863,
-0.0070870877,
-0.0198310018,
-0.0120373694,
0.0194271579,
-0.0001557422,
0.0079061231,
-0.0145675959,
0.024613617,
0.0582346395,
-0.0085696522,
-0.0426866524,
0.0153757129,
0.017041916,
0.000586819,
0.0336246118,
-0.0079701263,
-0.0219521448,
0.0243431646,
-0.0038115412,
-0.0112723308,
0.0140101817,
0.0511265732,
-0.0262065511,
0.0451337993,
0.0273793191,
-0.0293622538,
-0.0278427135,
0.0016891608,
-0.0204409827,
-0.0503326058,
0.0548760146,
-0.0197874494,
0.0191400778,
-0.0866585448,
0.0666253492,
0.0293035973,
-0.0319827981,
-0.0241935346,
-0.0053438428,
-0.0262650251,
-0.0498864502,
-0.042607937,
-0.0550275259,
0.0316523053,
-0.0253750775,
0.028412085,
-0.0106225852,
0.0420270264,
-0.0339710191,
0.0455286875,
-0.0295244455,
0.011381547,
0.0256949998,
0.1011698693,
0.0678239465,
0.0117169609,
0.0177117661,
0.0485002771,
0.0269427933,
-0.0122505063,
-0.0172029901,
0.0136000104,
0.0656726584,
0.0391451642,
0.0636126548,
0.0236422662,
0.0758611038,
-0.0192974005,
-0.078212522,
0.0166264512,
-0.016816305,
0.057937026,
0.0361833014,
0.032251671,
-0.0167776477,
-0.0152534442,
-0.0251257233,
-0.0002074995,
-0.0281774271,
-0.0396635905,
0.0353252664,
-0.0030655684,
-0.0409060642,
-0.053287793,
0.0327082239,
-0.0244460143,
0.0187481921,
0.0023740374,
-0.0282978639,
0.0355898142,
-0.0004080719,
0.0214854553,
-0.0576502569,
-0.0160039272,
0.0378502496,
0.0275851116,
0.0410153866,
-0.0309805479,
0.0158271156,
0.0208384339,
-0.0746567473,
-0.0027347731,
-0.0064576566,
0.0003913625,
0.016023783,
0.0140364915,
0.0280558933,
-0.025322061,
-0.0035480857,
0.0157992262,
0.0146320928,
0.0087537449,
-0.0402171537,
0.0176636055,
0.0264941081,
0.0365110673,
-0.04478902,
-0.0053668013,
-0.0496385582,
0.0405000672,
0.0306342058,
-0.0629230738,
-0.0586729236,
0.0162194967,
2.702e-7,
0.0529397465,
0.0605235584,
0.0042015789,
0.0045109284,
0.0198137779,
-0.0089853806,
0.0056964494,
0.0001421143,
0.0027996344,
0.0255373865,
0.0171033219,
0.0006345946,
0.0203676485,
0.0325455442,
-0.037962772,
0.044264283,
-0.0933064744,
-0.0073248628,
-0.0636075363,
-0.0161536727,
0.0496944711,
0.11284291,
-0.0359831862,
-0.0169103425,
0.0110240821,
-0.0217112824,
0.0314475372,
-0.0129190665,
0.0095107239,
0.0170576405,
0.0470912978,
0.0088941781,
0.0201621037,
-0.0152488779,
-0.0159766488,
-0.0168803856,
-0.0213056821,
0.0607232824,
-0.0182531886,
-0.0647404492,
0.0217888709,
0.0042351461,
-0.0077171437,
-0.0807302147,
0.0876015723,
0.0074336943,
-0.03170681,
-0.0841613114,
-0.0440245122,
0.0200904757,
0.0340739451,
-0.039806217,
-0.005017186,
0.0315028206,
0.0129569396,
0.0006133839,
-0.021182403,
-0.0417407155,
-0.035977941,
-0.011261398,
-0.0445823818,
-0.0678897649,
-0.0752816945,
0.0333615877,
0.0233198609,
-0.0303091593,
-0.0018859977,
2.927259884e-34,
0.0337022208,
-0.0342432894,
0.0470107011,
0.0116411475,
-0.0020169131,
-0.021425359,
0.0103102624,
0.0192491859,
-0.0294303745,
-0.0861143619,
-0.0092829494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01460v1 | Implicit Chain of Thought Reasoning via Knowledge Distillation | 2023-11-02T17:59:49 | 2023-11-02T17:59:49 | Yuntian Deng, Kiran Prasad, Roland Fernandez, Paul Smolensky, Vishrav Chaudhary, Stuart Shieber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | To augment language models with the ability to reason, researchers usually
prompt or finetune them to produce chain of thought reasoning steps before
producing the final answer. However, although people use natural language to
reason effectively, it may be that LMs could reason more effectively with some
intermediate computation that is not in natural language. In this work, we
explore an alternative reasoning approach: instead of explicitly producing the
chain of thought reasoning steps, we use the language model's internal hidden
states to perform implicit reasoning. The implicit reasoning steps are
distilled from a teacher model trained on explicit chain-of-thought reasoning,
and instead of doing reasoning "horizontally" by producing intermediate words
one-by-one, we distill it such that the reasoning happens "vertically" among
the hidden states in different layers. We conduct experiments on a multi-digit
multiplication task and a grade school math problem dataset and find that this
approach enables solving tasks previously not solvable without explicit
chain-of-thought, at a speed comparable to no chain-of-thought. | [
0.0234954916,
0.0353848711,
-0.0163298044,
0.0317873284,
-0.0281850509,
0.0161840469,
0.0501514748,
-0.0020848503,
0.0002320838,
-0.0307524651,
0.0119512966,
0.0307230726,
0.0082980338,
0.0199027956,
0.0379427522,
-0.0653986931,
0.029206913,
-0.0618624128,
0.0148835806,
0.0063025565,
-0.0135459807,
0.003419044,
-0.0416232422,
0.0089018699,
0.0111159049,
-0.0446231291,
-0.0628419146,
-0.0191946533,
0.0322389565,
-0.0072468491,
-0.0275265966,
0.015206241,
0.0336973555,
0.0214386955,
0.0000022013,
-0.0371012129,
-0.0077010035,
-0.0029244025,
-0.05898441,
0.011157847,
-0.0821897537,
0.0252387524,
0.0217788685,
0.0344406553,
-0.0546291843,
0.044539921,
-0.0010994239,
0.0321242921,
0.0499500297,
0.0347478203,
0.001943211,
-0.0098248199,
-0.0126893446,
-0.0003678275,
0.0476125143,
-0.0377296545,
0.0141322017,
0.0079790466,
-0.0265634079,
0.0169224329,
-0.0246182214,
0.0269591361,
0.06218642,
-0.0460264273,
-0.0446093492,
0.0301150195,
0.0397651121,
-0.0255616773,
-0.0118740443,
0.0574594587,
-0.0006096895,
-0.0191584788,
0.0393630527,
-0.0168806538,
0.0022836844,
0.0195588581,
-0.0364666879,
0.0313710868,
-0.0110992184,
0.001644299,
-0.0016063288,
0.007581817,
0.0262721721,
0.0123089254,
-0.009731059,
0.0869878381,
-0.0329481773,
-0.0297518317,
0.0111987405,
-0.0004371111,
-0.0019161424,
-0.0842606127,
0.0257020686,
0.0795820281,
0.0109187318,
0.0266308933,
0.0057223844,
-0.0138775101,
-0.0214061402,
-0.0070283632,
0.0260846484,
0.0867898911,
0.0117106177,
0.022115251,
-0.044879403,
0.0351273566,
-0.0124334125,
0.0341774188,
-0.0020384982,
0.031523414,
-0.0436108224,
-0.0261850338,
-0.0142609635,
0.0585550964,
-0.0084168222,
-0.0076044383,
-0.014124779,
0.0073493156,
-0.0316954367,
-0.0038866561,
-0.0067841834,
0.0242429655,
0.0411720239,
-0.0271463841,
-0.0767823607,
0.0582536645,
-0.0367858298,
0.0386112258,
0.0519975722,
-0.0067177312,
-0.0143256718,
-0.0406154878,
0.0092904065,
0.008285054,
-0.0101066986,
0.0399543606,
-0.0342455991,
0.0111826947,
-0.0707596764,
-0.0666219741,
0.0040575541,
-0.0549729839,
0.0230963212,
-0.0714633763,
0.0115030063,
0.0039140051,
-0.0057275589,
-0.0197728686,
0.0293436646,
0.023090532,
-0.028990224,
0.0705713332,
0.0074650748,
0.0113481544,
0.0208663885,
0.0431883484,
-0.0239992142,
0.0332116298,
0.0359983183,
0.0270426888,
-0.0031982569,
0.0161235016,
0.0119535113,
-0.0018228238,
0.0447835401,
-0.0022684953,
-0.0572489314,
-0.0124033,
-0.074178122,
0.0195203088,
0.0135196047,
0.0468404219,
-0.0363281816,
0.0244973116,
0.0383942947,
0.0611552261,
0.0014354907,
0.0236425027,
0.0509198233,
-0.0068228911,
0.013495395,
0.0159218181,
-0.0487846509,
0.0673712343,
-0.0414797328,
-0.012485913,
0.0598289259,
-0.0026084462,
-0.0195690114,
-0.0881803408,
-0.0079784542,
0.0157451406,
0.0494449623,
0.0479660593,
0.0496646129,
0.0197373275,
-0.0074472749,
0.0593755506,
0.0166592244,
-0.0518007204,
-0.0202910714,
-0.1001864299,
0.0306825917,
0.0439221673,
0.042434603,
-0.0078411866,
0.0054960148,
-0.0069659348,
0.0194007717,
0.03356985,
0.0316564105,
-0.0096922647,
-0.0035292644,
-0.049919989,
-0.0327827595,
-0.010223723,
0.0084722983,
-0.0381515622,
0.0052909204,
0.0077496213,
0.0194888674,
-0.0308694113,
0.0217218101,
0.0227231719,
-0.0315577947,
-0.0134724351,
-0.0316545404,
0.0492798053,
-0.0232422724,
-0.0002211993,
0.0395731181,
0.0234426707,
0.0029957525,
-0.0102619976,
-0.0727766156,
-0.0339829549,
-0.0806919634,
-0.0592855737,
0.0293452479,
-0.0453437939,
-0.0018094865,
-0.0028199535,
-0.0474032648,
-0.051770594,
0.044823993,
-0.0146386037,
0.0282546617,
-0.0131784398,
0.017949177,
0.0233976021,
-0.0436851121,
-0.0000497356,
0.083545588,
-0.0251354389,
0.0089454567,
-0.0090285204,
-0.0083205272,
0.0135088405,
0.0170401316,
0.0310286283,
-0.0078498786,
-0.0206174664,
-0.0072042914,
-0.0290050711,
0.0002059842,
-0.0552714355,
-0.0198173523,
-0.0337728374,
-0.0157628469,
0.0065524597,
0.007847744,
0.0129415207,
0.015950609,
0.0408747084,
-0.0125824818,
-0.0269926488,
0.0371745788,
0.0055316193,
0.008069016,
0.0417203121,
-0.0009025012,
0.009005893,
-0.0183158647,
-0.0116636278,
-0.0653734729,
0.0569601282,
-0.0150692789,
0.0215316974,
-0.0197061691,
0.0279626362,
-0.0818743706,
0.0340618752,
-0.0115340659,
-0.0184581894,
0.0561882667,
-0.0251551699,
0.0173330847,
0.0735352412,
-0.0145162614,
0.0284788124,
0.0853917599,
-0.0298804939,
-0.0765504837,
0.0494413674,
-0.0010115426,
0.0098027447,
0.0153271779,
-0.004648237,
-0.0757185891,
0.0765165836,
0.0072311331,
-0.0210831445,
-0.0611162111,
0.0254960228,
0.0183255374,
-0.0012670546,
-0.0471158698,
-0.0619003735,
-0.0020890343,
0.0864430889,
-0.0232609436,
-0.0229740106,
0.0818908364,
-0.0087852785,
-0.0034897865,
-0.0227760058,
0.0219433513,
-0.0049899276,
0.0741202012,
-0.0309672169,
-0.0063709575,
-0.0170563813,
0.0136879664,
-0.0303081814,
0.0008969589,
0.0266312007,
-0.0401209146,
0.0593175702,
-0.0585823357,
-0.0048220363,
-0.0033949416,
-0.0406625383,
-0.0680554882,
0.016680304,
-0.0530412644,
0.0043541389,
-0.0349970646,
-0.0306256935,
-0.008356249,
-0.0265693907,
0.066841349,
0.0474159792,
-0.0197937805,
-0.0441931151,
-0.0173525326,
0.0093965419,
0.026195351,
-0.0027208917,
0.0312348828,
-0.0119818319,
0.075649336,
0.0455831438,
0.0808512196,
-0.0196780786,
-0.012434138,
0.0231531877,
0.0016106152,
0.0091473479,
-0.0289522931,
0.037280269,
0.0078585884,
-0.0901338309,
-0.0212539248,
0.1197926998,
0.0497054011,
-0.0623954199,
0.0062373825,
-0.0710340291,
0.0146167092,
0.0294191279,
0.016940454,
-0.0729339868,
-0.0499017313,
0.0463968962,
-0.0216161329,
-0.0107976831,
-0.0607379414,
-0.0160621498,
-0.0864914209,
-0.0140044494,
-0.0126636745,
0.0141754085,
-0.0129360314,
-0.0559891574,
-0.0126707619,
0.0825718269,
-0.0244475603,
0.023633346,
0.0132410079,
0.0089974971,
0.0133459242,
-0.0026321628,
0.0019405799,
0.0534949824,
0.0090789916,
0.0043309913,
0.0300066732,
0.032399565,
0.0251610689,
-0.0838079676,
0.0467091911,
0.0101233972,
-0.0016686628,
-0.0092099765,
0.0173336025,
0.0131340567,
0.0014888273,
-0.0308053717,
0.0508799404,
-0.0387956202,
-0.0112440353,
0.0112282904,
0.0994290113,
-0.0317951888,
-0.0423392467,
-0.0037834609,
0.016279256,
-0.0075439084,
0.0666920766,
0.0326904468,
-0.0118752727,
-0.0339795053,
-0.0550465398,
-0.0615720339,
0.0043884306,
-0.0603834167,
0.0139941098,
0.0682379827,
0.0249111336,
-0.0479165949,
-0.0347115584,
0.0345731638,
0.0563287102,
-0.0077144001,
-0.0069895135,
0.0537234657,
-0.0007595404,
-0.0276811533,
0.0031469923,
-0.0036040153,
0.0188440457,
0.0246293601,
0.0073167435,
-0.0349581726,
-0.022589026,
-0.0167861339,
0.0392947271,
-0.0745720565,
-0.0607174039,
-0.0194960684,
0.0375731476,
0.0307991598,
0.0261169504,
-0.0142925428,
-0.0420124382,
0.0636357963,
-0.0072215055,
-0.0370797217,
-0.0069255307,
0.0259734374,
0.0145148765,
0.0466975234,
0.0443962663,
-0.0309495162,
-0.0055925683,
0.0229373034,
0.0352929123,
-0.0435671546,
-0.0174495634,
0.0112174125,
0.0074065523,
0.0429206789,
0.0206064265,
0.008495843,
-0.0195575785,
0.0227807537,
-0.0315914564,
-0.0277289562,
-0.0475631393,
0.0378804915,
0.0080616763,
0.0147772748,
0.0004602866,
-0.0445281789,
0.0403944626,
-0.0015527721,
0.0485630706,
0.0185797662,
0.0338084735,
0.0433156826,
0.0342421159,
-0.0144540686,
0.0017706894,
0.0214514527,
0.0048247855,
0.0427273624,
-0.0170621686,
0.0975182354,
0.0472084731,
0.0219697002,
-0.0617395043,
-0.0237264633,
-0.0836473182,
-0.0813882351,
0.0320294388,
-0.0110141234,
0.0070775226,
0.0288938805,
0.0152112031,
-0.0415504649,
0.0103991367,
0.0382387601,
0.0474872403,
0.0037288794,
-0.0568156056,
0.0261408929,
0.0279716197,
0.0205229931,
-0.0004543251,
0.0473568551,
-0.0214689486,
0.0326768272,
0.0072658588,
0.008627139,
-0.0116701378,
-0.0210473724,
-0.0131491954,
0.0646143183,
0.0187278688,
0.0120175742,
-0.0382984728,
-0.0944834948,
-0.0544737764,
0.0050146966,
0.011504408,
-0.0279579349,
0.0245310478,
0.057436239,
0.0020240166,
-0.0387494154,
-0.0196549874,
0.010168748,
0.000116056,
-0.0423124023,
-0.0475861989,
-6.418790576e-33,
-0.0100282077,
-0.05174556,
0.0513204671,
0.0307603385,
-0.0174791031,
0.0167384036,
-0.0649609417,
0.0247434508,
-0.0189198945,
0.0489666052,
-0.0445279106,
0.0512354225,
0.0054154247,
0.0164673999,
0.0188738909,
0.0150997471,
0.0082972404,
-0.0308202077,
-0.0248093698,
0.0056202593,
0.0348044895,
-0.0014128038,
0.0329950973,
-0.0348914377,
0.025256943,
-0.0019772009,
0.0050007794,
0.0430885293,
-0.0734155029,
0.0207658652,
-0.0315973088,
0.0099775475,
0.0088224066,
-0.0288267955,
-0.0088197514,
0.0301123932,
-0.0837628692,
-0.0358410776,
0.0280066673,
-0.0252252389,
-0.0880969316,
-0.0183657911,
0.0316737369,
0.0283906125,
0.0140307508,
-0.0242044404,
0.0269395597,
0.0011090053,
0.0082888259,
-0.019847976,
-0.0171172209,
-0.0058789579,
-0.0428878181,
-0.0513417609,
0.0366086252,
0.0060488121,
-0.0455841273,
-0.0411773212,
-0.0822110549,
0.0219146926,
0.0228351653,
0.0033011937,
0.0580871999,
-0.0069746203,
-0.0227761064,
0.0364953801,
0.0208477937,
-0.0143722454,
-0.0882662684,
-0.0010132861,
0.0268716738,
0.0380969644,
0.0292611532,
-0.0423873775,
0.0595292263,
0.0222681575,
-0.0612363517,
-0.0116229393,
0.0194111262,
0.015090364,
0.0249817371,
-0.0042345333,
-0.0252063219,
-0.0267128609,
-0.0679204538,
-0.0027997002,
-0.0526079759,
-0.0151367225,
0.0160622336,
0.0024919643,
0.0066783219,
-0.0567471385,
0.0026251532,
-0.0167403724,
-0.0042064842,
0.0223733503,
0.0220945328,
0.004977372,
-0.0028645888,
0.0088127097,
-0.0477584787,
0.0187349282,
0.0058134384,
0.0398619957,
0.0183034707,
0.0352775194,
0.0240489077,
0.0105331615,
-0.0472903065,
-0.0226580817,
-0.0793937296,
-0.0077598682,
0.0024792345,
-0.0034332364,
0.0321207382,
0.0164301191,
-0.0331109837,
0.0137359453,
-0.0194413103,
-0.0414050445,
-0.007456054,
0.0468657911,
-0.0114785722,
0.0320675224,
-0.0293479301,
-0.0507167019,
-0.0589681529,
-0.0221772604,
0.0385650657,
-0.0516516455,
-0.0092782136,
0.0424014963,
2.921e-7,
-0.008709305,
0.0260686465,
-0.0051746545,
0.022108078,
0.0297306702,
0.0452136621,
0.0037143722,
-0.0452963822,
0.0273759011,
-0.0623070821,
-0.0190613829,
0.0641101897,
0.0466307253,
0.0354396813,
-0.0308325849,
-0.025829846,
-0.0261810645,
-0.0522527434,
-0.0068440204,
-0.017922299,
0.0213675797,
0.0167833678,
0.0623468719,
-0.0002502664,
0.0166090038,
-0.0142550543,
0.0188182555,
0.043835029,
0.057714764,
-0.0205541179,
0.02819895,
-0.0299924184,
0.0101350481,
0.0329257101,
0.0207692347,
-0.0014181881,
-0.0318647809,
0.0703399479,
-0.0091374665,
-0.0329510421,
-0.0475653,
-0.0184941478,
0.0029370964,
-0.0498987958,
0.0633784905,
-0.0282834098,
-0.0079150107,
0.0594495572,
0.0193793345,
-0.0358072519,
-0.0151307695,
0.0310033131,
0.0005344983,
0.0125361988,
-0.0146342851,
-0.0193537436,
0.0167541374,
-0.1054285467,
-0.0631292611,
-0.0102051133,
-0.040568307,
-0.0243513528,
-0.0387048945,
0.0097940871,
0.0299145672,
-0.0044394773,
-0.0189644601,
2.782103551e-34,
-0.0138229076,
-0.025805831,
0.0358882025,
0.0062383977,
0.0434245691,
-0.0134853031,
-0.025987966,
0.0019367774,
0.0678748116,
-0.0702165067,
-0.0393704921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01449v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01449v2 | TopicGPT: A Prompt-based Topic Modeling Framework | 2023-11-02T17:57:10 | 2024-04-01T18:02:57 | Chau Minh Pham, Alexander Hoyle, Simeng Sun, Philip Resnik, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topic modeling is a well-established technique for exploring text corpora.
Conventional topic models (e.g., LDA) represent topics as bags of words that
often require "reading the tea leaves" to interpret; additionally, they offer
users minimal control over the formatting and specificity of resulting topics.
To tackle these issues, we introduce TopicGPT, a prompt-based framework that
uses large language models (LLMs) to uncover latent topics in a text
collection. TopicGPT produces topics that align better with human
categorizations compared to competing methods: it achieves a harmonic mean
purity of 0.74 against human-annotated Wikipedia topics compared to 0.64 for
the strongest baseline. Its topics are also interpretable, dispensing with
ambiguous bags of words in favor of topics with natural language labels and
associated free-form descriptions. Moreover, the framework is highly adaptable,
allowing users to specify constraints and modify topics without the need for
model retraining. By streamlining access to high-quality and interpretable
topics, TopicGPT represents a compelling, human-centered approach to topic
modeling. | [
0.0602414422,
0.0281641781,
-0.0163689032,
0.0201385338,
-0.0242532715,
0.015200668,
0.0010026868,
-0.0050162869,
-0.0109889852,
-0.0223387107,
-0.0098299123,
-0.0065962183,
-0.0339743756,
0.0326085649,
-0.0163361188,
-0.0753682107,
0.0149312885,
-0.0187087003,
0.0293290969,
0.0287814662,
0.0169846155,
0.0140646882,
-0.0056324629,
0.0271294639,
0.0244582798,
-0.0373774767,
-0.030103758,
-0.0203194451,
-0.0126380911,
-0.0216078814,
0.0257053133,
0.0858595669,
0.0249758605,
0.0030598184,
0.0000021777,
-0.0142136896,
0.0094384514,
-0.0604941063,
0.0050633387,
0.0744986609,
0.0739664137,
0.0022578256,
0.0234101638,
0.0066765896,
-0.0110590272,
0.0033845978,
-0.0045360103,
0.0670761466,
0.0724431947,
0.0411879197,
-0.0138636297,
0.0095401173,
0.0097715193,
-0.0257973187,
0.0659446269,
-0.0223485287,
0.0192456935,
-0.0164885186,
0.0166653171,
0.0709299818,
0.0149606504,
0.012096419,
-0.0118113402,
-0.038445469,
0.0509733409,
0.0201150998,
0.0116678597,
-0.0579273179,
0.0036570758,
0.0453061499,
0.0222195759,
-0.0325681232,
0.0486972854,
-0.0102431392,
-0.0241479538,
0.0464703627,
-0.0557907932,
0.0562978722,
-0.0254741646,
0.0012329725,
0.0500584207,
-0.0102879005,
0.0301526729,
0.0302892514,
0.0161768403,
0.0465306751,
0.0391080789,
-0.0039994065,
-0.0095094694,
-0.0107511692,
-0.0240986943,
-0.0680806935,
0.0340826064,
0.0149071636,
-0.0297146607,
0.0100749824,
0.0079314765,
-0.0306177568,
0.0531462245,
-0.0134879714,
-0.0509192199,
-0.0166441165,
-0.0261197686,
0.0466605239,
0.0668191314,
-0.0129327076,
-0.0235900544,
-0.0589595921,
-0.0315033644,
0.0091833891,
-0.0109449122,
-0.0045268727,
-0.0260831788,
-0.0095829349,
-0.0240821633,
-0.0193188228,
0.0220549852,
0.0552551746,
0.0019897721,
-0.0022509713,
0.0031640488,
-0.0115396529,
-0.0309513323,
-0.0199166778,
-0.0397738107,
0.0194947757,
-0.0695049539,
0.0319940299,
-0.0155592971,
0.0317254476,
0.00618293,
0.0419925787,
0.0010847743,
-0.017645251,
-0.0097984262,
-0.0060474998,
-0.0144395046,
-0.0412135087,
-0.0571309514,
0.0082831616,
0.0056397659,
0.0142810149,
0.0139156254,
-0.0792904347,
0.0024063033,
0.013558994,
0.0028410419,
-0.0106302015,
0.0119485753,
0.0600025244,
-0.026256185,
0.0453749783,
-0.0622346252,
0.0179630201,
0.1084019765,
0.0270341188,
0.0114214439,
0.042448163,
-0.0117523642,
0.0704853684,
0.0678389445,
0.007461736,
0.0185164362,
0.0104019223,
-0.0092254989,
0.0294785798,
0.0333467014,
0.0092163319,
-0.0007830015,
0.0261892639,
0.0343556516,
0.0565869957,
-0.0015271473,
-0.0072621685,
0.030149227,
0.0820857063,
-0.0023792365,
0.0133052943,
0.0309448056,
0.0550963432,
0.0275122244,
-0.009522113,
0.008771969,
-0.0351278894,
-0.0142811527,
-0.0203633197,
0.0251313653,
0.0062843817,
-0.0148212379,
-0.0130834663,
-0.0294552241,
0.0004913398,
-0.005375986,
-0.0274091363,
0.066582419,
-0.0126170944,
0.025082048,
0.0476867743,
0.060339503,
-0.0183053799,
0.0198601782,
-0.0108888783,
0.0851183236,
0.0563604422,
0.033203803,
-0.0572981387,
0.0098829698,
-0.0326875597,
0.0760520995,
0.0251294188,
-0.0040160283,
-0.0418542773,
-0.0385543443,
-0.0282705314,
0.0098494859,
0.005434711,
0.0363656431,
0.0174874831,
-0.0157570355,
-0.0051780655,
0.0094655016,
-0.0576891154,
0.0160638783,
0.0646208972,
-0.0307780709,
-0.028043421,
0.023383623,
-0.0251829326,
0.0224525984,
0.0469538756,
0.0134498253,
0.0092864837,
0.0452099256,
-0.038956061,
-0.0223152637,
-0.0324788727,
-0.0023969118,
0.0180488043,
0.0089514535,
-0.0229921043,
0.0058451425,
-0.0074471235,
-0.0054962169,
-0.0264569819,
-0.0079833232,
-0.0358439647,
-0.0114174439,
-0.0432235524,
-0.0075523951,
-0.0195776615,
-0.0217883084,
-0.0497560613,
0.0804543644,
0.0108976634,
0.0318490751,
0.0379404388,
-0.0088762501,
0.0000688924,
-0.0388230793,
-0.0160700418,
0.0521954969,
0.0287331808,
0.0281833094,
0.0485171564,
0.0084778331,
-0.0211986285,
-0.0254769139,
-0.1048962325,
0.0288690459,
-0.0349659361,
0.0186249763,
0.0419831499,
-0.0048416136,
-0.0426675119,
0.0059734876,
0.0002134109,
-0.0148755396,
-0.0114387246,
0.0174286999,
0.0289398432,
-0.0026799105,
0.0373758525,
-0.0294271074,
-0.0091734203,
-0.0335008353,
0.0605281144,
0.0304523446,
-0.0253359992,
-0.0243487041,
0.0319977254,
0.0243833531,
-0.0420407131,
-0.0261950903,
0.028275948,
-0.0013489692,
-0.0526493154,
0.087358661,
-0.0017615112,
0.0429060906,
0.069103241,
0.0379782729,
-0.0174512304,
-0.0224755779,
-0.0190219674,
-0.0009444243,
0.0088768294,
0.0029605429,
-0.0508017205,
0.0564259812,
0.0768543482,
0.0011667983,
0.0222351067,
-0.0487501025,
0.010285167,
-0.0357627235,
0.0250344668,
-0.0985517502,
-0.0059499564,
-0.0127576888,
0.0328386351,
-0.0122519797,
-0.0350330956,
0.0450254828,
-0.0079355892,
0.0175168999,
-0.065930739,
-0.0402125567,
-0.0597100332,
0.0449863076,
-0.0087508215,
-0.0195859931,
0.0106225712,
-0.0249668155,
0.0099804588,
0.0470186509,
0.0316220596,
-0.0113896793,
0.054956831,
-0.0469584763,
-0.0012078811,
-0.0042935726,
-0.0053373831,
-0.0325648859,
-0.1005051881,
-0.0019738653,
-0.0108966399,
0.0245333891,
-0.0016447189,
-0.0227425415,
0.0083382074,
0.0305708908,
-0.0015902878,
-0.0129086981,
-0.013018189,
-0.0210345332,
0.0478696674,
0.057897307,
-0.0529427193,
-0.0348215848,
-0.0118353684,
0.0384000838,
0.003303769,
0.0202278923,
-0.0029844102,
-0.0291049667,
0.0226355251,
0.0101855164,
-0.0733325332,
-0.0298242308,
0.0117925992,
0.0245378725,
-0.0218073744,
0.0017198893,
0.1263940632,
0.0602982268,
-0.1004301533,
-0.0099648936,
-0.0265245624,
0.0108445715,
0.0086385366,
0.0341970585,
-0.0576953255,
-0.013350049,
0.0039951783,
0.0394860543,
0.0182640944,
-0.0366797037,
-0.0151492953,
-0.0260256547,
0.0247097164,
-0.0061088377,
-0.0191689376,
0.0066194669,
-0.1046764851,
0.003566894,
-0.0217083879,
-0.0293339044,
0.0135992952,
-0.0389963798,
0.0283356365,
0.0042134966,
-0.0278580263,
-0.0490657464,
0.0012802068,
-0.0341579653,
0.0341148116,
-0.0091262357,
0.0004823486,
-0.0089198379,
0.0037930415,
-0.0064461073,
-0.0525115654,
-0.0377138965,
-0.0060014073,
0.0299631413,
-0.0306530446,
0.014126204,
-0.0367379971,
0.0413312986,
-0.0359315611,
-0.0602314062,
0.0617652684,
0.0696781278,
-0.0269720089,
-0.0013491814,
-0.0254192203,
-0.0155794853,
0.0414072648,
0.0551678129,
0.0284500942,
-0.0610860251,
0.0381281041,
-0.0465488173,
0.0228881296,
0.0681600124,
-0.0383538418,
-0.0259041376,
-0.0130579816,
-0.0518916175,
-0.064937301,
-0.0408420451,
0.0209978446,
-0.0047334805,
0.0162424445,
0.0248120204,
-0.0145765003,
-0.0140905194,
-0.0440554954,
0.0794578791,
-0.0228565056,
-0.0076682181,
-0.0824045017,
-0.0461715944,
0.0441199839,
-0.0390239544,
-0.0226559658,
-0.0045256712,
-0.0777631253,
-0.0205383021,
0.0091315415,
-0.0458738916,
0.0151733374,
-0.0187051147,
-0.0432289243,
-0.0793274641,
0.0147421155,
0.0604951009,
-0.0849192515,
-0.0154468268,
-0.0431343429,
0.031810943,
-0.0072165653,
-0.0034589658,
-0.0634494573,
0.0504304729,
-0.0420957357,
0.0242540892,
-0.0504906736,
-0.0817264318,
0.0095017925,
0.0099791987,
0.0795797482,
0.0039513088,
-0.0230329558,
-0.0888141394,
-0.0634609312,
0.0057778661,
-0.0247769821,
0.0131440368,
0.0160374697,
0.0207472835,
-0.0416913182,
-0.0396613292,
0.0425790064,
-0.0265723895,
0.0418395735,
-0.0443754718,
0.0051686661,
-0.0001779576,
0.0332928933,
-0.0158562046,
0.006318761,
0.0100350138,
-0.0079152016,
-0.0448950157,
0.0167805795,
-0.0045192367,
0.0826039463,
0.0004347206,
-0.0421322137,
0.0066650487,
0.0320830457,
-0.0749009848,
-0.0356147625,
0.0026895145,
0.0553897619,
0.0512460731,
-0.0226698816,
0.0135103455,
-0.0482415371,
-0.016317863,
-0.0366550907,
0.025176473,
0.0273304339,
-0.005911787,
0.0272762589,
0.047962781,
-0.049564179,
0.0069608344,
0.05334609,
0.0126197245,
-0.0009480761,
0.0349616669,
-0.0379365608,
-0.0390642248,
0.0154021699,
0.0184347499,
0.0208514053,
-0.0401549339,
0.0024209798,
-0.049485635,
0.0186538491,
0.0306122676,
-0.0346578769,
-0.034550827,
0.019915767,
0.0406105854,
0.0992426053,
-0.0407008864,
0.0100471405,
-0.0699028671,
0.0382322595,
-0.0480868407,
-0.0390640646,
-0.0427915528,
-6.663153076e-33,
-0.0297466461,
-0.054260686,
0.008665612,
0.0231718533,
0.0249645729,
0.0014167487,
-0.031821914,
0.0192631278,
0.0273061972,
0.0253594313,
-0.0182493702,
0.0267514009,
0.0030635404,
-0.0075942944,
0.0116818966,
-0.0055149449,
0.0484614633,
0.0059773307,
-0.0393435024,
0.0534663126,
0.0244323555,
0.0248982403,
-0.0125686079,
-0.0682006702,
0.051402837,
-0.0269290153,
0.0019849339,
0.0162090417,
0.066727519,
0.0201288145,
-0.06115577,
0.0596920326,
0.039575547,
-0.0410094671,
0.0094725238,
0.0712471679,
-0.0417111665,
-0.0446118936,
-0.0057655768,
-0.042518232,
0.0163057204,
-0.0812198147,
-0.0113695795,
-0.0058067744,
0.0050003412,
0.0430597402,
0.0884318948,
0.00496139,
-0.0121144811,
-0.0325289927,
-0.0208475906,
0.0452377722,
-0.0194410812,
0.001893152,
-0.021586949,
0.0007131033,
0.011717895,
0.0602551103,
-0.0084169302,
0.0637115836,
0.0040417076,
0.0147198001,
0.0195760541,
-0.0178140495,
0.0045660906,
0.0509780198,
-0.0137773221,
0.0101082735,
-0.0252300389,
0.009668543,
0.009080071,
0.0108113363,
0.0190759655,
0.03725674,
-0.0078815352,
-0.0100051276,
-0.0171971433,
0.0709975585,
0.0142291244,
0.0152304545,
0.003329369,
0.0116486903,
-0.0261562932,
-0.0355510525,
-0.0309302416,
-0.0108976401,
-0.0237736274,
-0.0070679318,
0.014122799,
-0.0135260355,
-0.0489175618,
-0.0156086441,
0.0009336405,
0.0164118931,
0.0034353291,
0.0307959504,
-0.0138600217,
0.0257497653,
-0.0120174838,
0.0276288576,
-0.079644531,
-0.0259152818,
0.0309159756,
-0.0229911041,
0.017329976,
-0.0165100209,
-0.0436631553,
-0.0111308284,
-0.0532621145,
-0.0029777596,
0.0001896972,
-0.0101500219,
-0.0228909664,
0.0168066174,
0.0196365453,
-0.0034782481,
0.0045076986,
0.0727619976,
0.0505558215,
0.0012273865,
-0.011353571,
-0.0698170289,
-0.0388112925,
0.003835168,
-0.0002233485,
0.0230255909,
-0.0100895595,
0.0454281271,
0.0481458418,
-0.0414364785,
-0.0007735854,
-0.034644518,
2.782e-7,
0.0366511345,
0.0882575661,
-0.014614339,
-0.0111065023,
0.0184686426,
0.0250246879,
-0.0088512795,
0.022201445,
-0.0060793334,
-0.027363833,
0.0135241244,
0.0171898007,
0.0347509533,
0.0531051941,
-0.0979254469,
-0.0035380109,
-0.0636894777,
0.0005194776,
-0.0897168964,
0.0078291707,
0.0350062102,
0.059320882,
0.0259275939,
0.0209342651,
-0.0153708691,
-0.0543905273,
0.0487422198,
-0.0692155138,
-0.0485264808,
0.0331672616,
0.0854846686,
0.0038077596,
0.0026235359,
-0.0230681952,
-0.0221440066,
0.0051948251,
0.0280831065,
0.0702683926,
0.0215646494,
0.0100210356,
-0.0303736031,
-0.0375204794,
0.0068312702,
-0.0430106334,
0.0583033487,
0.0080526806,
-0.0213932768,
-0.0205547139,
-0.0064595165,
-0.0268256441,
0.0104091614,
-0.0460576005,
-0.0090461746,
0.0012005029,
-0.0238373689,
-0.0046699685,
-0.003630968,
-0.04466822,
-0.0011982196,
-0.005455798,
-0.0737312585,
-0.0244164318,
-0.046273645,
0.0120951701,
0.0063182064,
-0.060035605,
0.0527088158,
2.458400875e-34,
0.0288630296,
-0.0159723815,
-0.0546809845,
-0.0106421653,
0.0220913664,
0.0094808163,
-0.047828868,
0.0339126214,
0.0110439183,
-0.0674576014,
0.0236261021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01398v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01398v1 | Server-side Rescoring of Spoken Entity-centric Knowledge Queries for Virtual Assistants | 2023-11-02T17:07:23 | 2023-11-02T17:07:23 | Youyuan Zhang, Sashank Gondala, Thiago Fraga-Silva, Christophe Van Gysel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | On-device Virtual Assistants (VAs) powered by Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR) require effective knowledge integration for the challenging entity-rich
query recognition. In this paper, we conduct an empirical study of modeling
strategies for server-side rescoring of spoken information domain queries using
various categories of Language Models (LMs) (N-gram word LMs, sub-word neural
LMs). We investigate the combination of on-device and server-side signals, and
demonstrate significant WER improvements of 23%-35% on various entity-centric
query subpopulations by integrating various server-side LMs compared to
performing ASR on-device only. We also perform a comparison between LMs trained
on domain data and a GPT-3 variant offered by OpenAI as a baseline.
Furthermore, we also show that model fusion of multiple server-side LMs trained
from scratch most effectively combines complementary strengths of each model
and integrates knowledge learned from domain-specific data to a VA ASR system. | [
0.0145511404,
0.0249985717,
0.0060131913,
0.0301096961,
-0.0123105915,
0.0119019076,
-0.0081975777,
0.00521095,
0.0201576296,
-0.0678135455,
-0.0307280533,
-0.0528206863,
0.011157657,
-0.0106724547,
0.0323597938,
-0.0212114993,
0.0275451001,
-0.0256962162,
-0.021393327,
-0.0068747648,
-0.0264282301,
0.0309249312,
-0.0282809511,
0.0454351008,
0.0211539958,
0.0035337037,
-0.0114898486,
0.0480681583,
-0.0003885411,
-0.0115705468,
-0.0267621353,
-0.0183362756,
0.0212684274,
0.0337874219,
0.0000019425,
-0.020268267,
-0.0539606996,
0.0155976908,
-0.0921982229,
0.0084532592,
0.031855531,
0.0031553665,
0.0032320637,
0.0682268962,
-0.0305273086,
-0.0313850641,
0.0252705477,
0.0505233482,
0.0096963169,
0.0383360423,
-0.0184799246,
-0.0276455656,
0.0465323254,
-0.0012517691,
-0.0270544272,
-0.0676328391,
-0.0185118616,
-0.0606901869,
0.033424601,
0.0040304423,
0.0429984741,
0.0392645672,
0.001184862,
0.0372470878,
-0.0216559339,
0.0225690976,
-0.0263206083,
0.0377358012,
-0.0261029489,
0.0659013987,
0.0151349986,
0.021485487,
0.0273323357,
0.0114579881,
-0.0103801796,
0.0015188059,
-0.0094195139,
-0.022450868,
0.0009854297,
-0.0187862851,
-0.0061434307,
-0.0110592609,
0.0480230786,
0.0138460556,
-0.0232851021,
0.0122983502,
0.0486010611,
-0.0339327827,
-0.0112430779,
-0.0206176974,
-0.0201705992,
-0.0104719456,
0.0062668063,
0.0454344191,
-0.0374135002,
0.0441967659,
-0.0089488253,
-0.0377486385,
-0.0008482972,
-0.0006025099,
0.0315513015,
0.0358632542,
-0.0217669327,
0.0308287907,
-0.0070671933,
0.0589180924,
-0.012531464,
0.0267162807,
-0.0341022201,
-0.044016093,
-0.0362468362,
-0.0186133236,
-0.0101280101,
0.0528570637,
-0.0397642702,
-0.0370696187,
-0.0251818374,
0.0068243234,
0.0418922789,
0.0114379395,
0.0275000986,
0.0186637696,
-0.0151444022,
-0.0325994864,
-0.0035952725,
0.0570114404,
0.0068707727,
0.0560656823,
-0.003991494,
-0.1160990521,
0.0066816406,
-0.0381000936,
0.0051221387,
0.0088749034,
0.0038737061,
0.0483696386,
0.0044878824,
-0.056331221,
-0.0591614097,
-0.0208182838,
-0.0061797393,
-0.0208595004,
0.0026321795,
-0.0151109193,
0.0612925775,
-0.018054666,
0.0210657753,
-0.037080083,
0.023978591,
0.0222236793,
-0.0209022462,
0.0857506618,
-0.0208104365,
0.0220547151,
0.0530150607,
-0.0083984304,
0.0323541351,
0.0963505656,
0.0594437234,
-0.015243751,
0.0290777218,
0.0109613659,
0.0071835625,
0.0170537941,
0.0186252017,
-0.0225154199,
-0.0388567336,
0.0062169475,
-0.0021441404,
0.0330116861,
-0.0049415948,
0.0630554333,
-0.0173408762,
-0.0177849196,
0.0407289863,
0.0469692722,
0.0153527102,
-0.0174882915,
0.0087887086,
-0.0238738321,
-0.0069525316,
-0.0086794198,
-0.0423606522,
0.0090589458,
0.0216219556,
0.041593913,
0.034645915,
0.0300451238,
-0.0388664156,
-0.0385851972,
-0.0067149964,
-0.0474920869,
-0.064884074,
0.0578555129,
0.0405141972,
0.0142126251,
-0.0530503392,
0.0102669597,
0.0026820053,
-0.0531574227,
0.0274838544,
-0.0366468132,
0.0117001077,
0.0967800319,
0.0703087449,
-0.0213270299,
-0.0361406095,
-0.0101141622,
-0.0535292029,
0.0355148427,
0.0142680043,
-0.0105639733,
0.0397044457,
-0.0667593926,
-0.0083628856,
0.0332040563,
0.012157171,
0.0402774252,
-0.0279952586,
0.0177424885,
0.0431952961,
-0.0814580172,
0.0052240607,
0.0076655643,
-0.0284072384,
-0.0389190577,
0.0111746565,
0.0552391112,
0.0128609007,
0.0380093046,
-0.0230375174,
0.0076511763,
0.0344292112,
-0.0408844501,
-0.0133781554,
-0.0156643502,
0.0042531914,
-0.0261404589,
0.0212730374,
0.0181940496,
0.0493138023,
0.0225323942,
0.0039257724,
-0.0472381227,
-0.0090256901,
-0.0200213399,
0.069658868,
-0.047595121,
0.0200762264,
0.0455334336,
-0.0042007281,
-0.0054924358,
0.0232070312,
0.0031750666,
0.0089135412,
0.0486430526,
-0.0107919788,
-0.0147645008,
-0.0276002605,
0.0096889418,
0.0314449705,
-0.0113014346,
0.0050906707,
-0.0325893052,
-0.0430895314,
-0.0217036847,
-0.0055705258,
-0.1474433541,
-0.0192818046,
-0.038936168,
0.0210526194,
-0.000696708,
0.088435322,
-0.0088062258,
-0.0380842127,
-0.0180334151,
-0.0155888377,
-0.0114203021,
0.0343174376,
-0.0143378405,
-0.012345491,
-0.0056315553,
-0.0243118349,
0.0189843141,
-0.0228116643,
0.0197215844,
-0.0306361225,
0.0078134909,
-0.0337804593,
0.0168314837,
-0.0565384887,
0.0261415504,
-0.0073687574,
-0.0407378823,
0.0054860692,
-0.0266468171,
0.0328503549,
0.0601569973,
-0.0065961359,
-0.0416589901,
0.0223645736,
-0.0383556336,
-0.0673807561,
0.0298730843,
0.0070715146,
-0.0250695925,
0.0137291374,
0.026575936,
0.0284881312,
0.0590023026,
-0.0012841184,
0.0253978632,
-0.0313518457,
-0.0269237924,
-0.0231168605,
-0.0118770478,
-0.0179343931,
0.0304235276,
-0.0545112714,
0.042635303,
-0.0011259977,
-0.0219395682,
0.0497021936,
-0.0577758476,
-0.0083653964,
-0.0689158589,
-0.0023553621,
-0.0220579263,
0.0297483783,
-0.0325398333,
0.0120737329,
-0.0174396336,
-0.0674650222,
-0.0222147685,
0.0395404436,
-0.003648656,
-0.0731195062,
0.0333055407,
-0.0420109294,
0.0360694602,
-0.0105410023,
-0.0339093581,
-0.0233344492,
0.0155055793,
-0.0748283863,
0.0041298154,
0.0081338389,
-0.0189274382,
-0.0084450524,
0.0306452271,
0.0242275856,
0.0639324337,
-0.001757992,
-0.0254553109,
-0.0198391918,
0.0208899733,
0.0625243112,
0.0611415878,
-0.036622636,
0.0390751958,
0.061538592,
0.0209166668,
0.1044606268,
-0.0627569407,
0.004303412,
0.0050928011,
0.0645670593,
-0.0261139646,
-0.0172669087,
0.0694703311,
0.0150334639,
-0.0283300467,
0.0020265847,
0.1092062891,
-0.0097387824,
-0.0339046232,
-0.0330478773,
0.0175273027,
0.0022800586,
0.0135674085,
0.0346004106,
-0.0787315592,
-0.0488421954,
0.0340279639,
0.0631354377,
0.029420346,
0.0078080529,
-0.0169820823,
-0.1401847601,
0.0425535589,
-0.0015897453,
0.0017018882,
-0.0328815915,
-0.0184099264,
0.0376165099,
-0.0163885839,
0.0273088589,
-0.0106966235,
-0.0133659225,
-0.0323146433,
0.0083435802,
-0.0114203393,
-0.0482474416,
0.0155355558,
-0.0579055436,
0.0491426289,
0.1177188084,
0.0370371453,
0.0500365123,
-0.0491214655,
-0.0462532379,
-0.0445916951,
0.036936637,
-0.0005969654,
0.035056565,
-0.0362954959,
-0.0156729575,
0.0186469406,
0.0101319114,
-0.0455791317,
0.0044547478,
-0.0078685312,
0.0557543337,
-0.0330888703,
0.0440165624,
-0.0130330026,
-0.0150852147,
0.0051565804,
0.0514998399,
0.0093218237,
-0.0015792671,
-0.0106513482,
0.0183827411,
0.0348169953,
0.0017808758,
0.0073718922,
-0.0081221554,
-0.0107606901,
0.0022636191,
-0.0601363368,
-0.043275144,
0.0344297327,
0.0195873529,
0.0470426641,
0.038579423,
0.0445633382,
0.0329260267,
-0.015998235,
-0.0459078029,
-0.061403472,
0.0443670228,
-0.0716438219,
0.0070884572,
0.0709697157,
-0.0608761162,
-0.0140788574,
-0.0294032265,
-0.0267666336,
-0.0750435665,
0.0021307808,
-0.0025734461,
0.019603787,
0.0260691941,
-0.055798132,
-0.0481726974,
-0.0026035788,
0.0570235997,
-0.1210820675,
-0.0179813113,
0.0216587242,
0.0095745809,
-0.0282038581,
0.0354767181,
-0.0835242271,
0.0083026113,
-0.0207025912,
0.0441185236,
-0.0192098003,
-0.0891457647,
0.0152044352,
0.028265724,
0.0757765099,
0.000660044,
0.0122815026,
-0.038829647,
0.0523757264,
-0.000296873,
0.0433798917,
-0.0376160517,
-0.0348274708,
-0.0084045343,
0.0119812982,
-0.0120500522,
0.0330004469,
-0.0078463051,
-0.0267142951,
-0.029495975,
-0.0173464492,
-0.0222878996,
0.0061691995,
0.0058966544,
-0.0047187628,
0.0033990915,
0.052071251,
0.031594798,
0.0365541168,
-0.0489852354,
0.0264365152,
0.002959115,
-0.0107236952,
-0.0295820422,
0.0410739519,
-0.067177251,
-0.0498375334,
-0.0054545351,
0.0328946859,
0.0554805249,
-0.0192195792,
0.0408116356,
0.0174173489,
0.0285288133,
-0.0402214974,
0.0096400678,
-0.0090472689,
0.0275779925,
0.0451097041,
0.0364988521,
-0.018331252,
0.023456106,
0.0726344287,
-0.020202687,
0.075472489,
-0.0170209128,
0.0217981283,
-0.0548598692,
-0.0185935758,
0.0187550597,
0.0166744646,
-0.0630004257,
-0.0131203495,
-0.0374528691,
-0.0486554466,
0.0281915087,
-0.0441055782,
-0.0206843745,
-0.0345816165,
0.0147739211,
0.0596953332,
0.0120451022,
-0.0029637842,
-0.0166926775,
-0.0256149154,
-0.0603130013,
-0.017446978,
0.0155928833,
-6.491826979e-33,
-0.048367478,
0.0318069793,
-0.0007810823,
-0.0280243531,
-0.0254414268,
0.0219918825,
-0.0047427844,
-0.0155924065,
-0.0495221689,
-0.0627271459,
-0.0592561141,
0.0328487232,
0.0411282927,
0.0070766094,
-0.0103176199,
-0.0753308013,
0.066817835,
-0.0208427906,
0.0099449223,
0.0114604309,
0.010328602,
0.0626046062,
0.0346245505,
-0.0713014677,
-0.008796569,
-0.0169198085,
0.0281248987,
-0.000149893,
0.0057107434,
0.0504797995,
-0.0209923331,
0.0273586586,
0.019997308,
-0.0522039495,
0.0068005146,
-0.0037469584,
-0.0922803655,
-0.0123246619,
0.0039488631,
0.04119936,
-0.0315185711,
-0.0258098654,
0.033351317,
0.0065944283,
0.0022552423,
0.0054925699,
0.0175928883,
-0.0107807955,
-0.0644866601,
-0.0307362992,
-0.0178087577,
-0.0022164911,
0.0182353538,
-0.0450075604,
0.0577229075,
0.022042539,
0.01621232,
-0.0042812349,
-0.09554369,
0.0479794592,
-0.0109751252,
0.0146617237,
0.0437682606,
0.0129442336,
-0.0303522125,
0.0253469087,
0.0303264167,
-0.046814248,
-0.0485761277,
-0.0114428205,
0.0091739278,
0.0424519107,
0.0039944421,
0.0325784273,
0.03509764,
-0.0333282687,
0.0000471378,
0.0167552885,
0.0232663061,
0.0369535908,
-0.0142027801,
0.0205300525,
-0.0444517434,
-0.0107131377,
-0.0436336547,
-0.0066025341,
-0.0731232315,
-0.0259249248,
0.0814637765,
0.0265868641,
0.0017199607,
-0.0303772818,
0.0291247722,
-0.0207111388,
-0.0068409708,
0.0232456457,
0.0662629977,
-0.0130632669,
-0.0181561764,
-0.0124386763,
-0.0411508866,
0.0074879886,
0.025264902,
0.0194665603,
-0.0198441427,
-0.0105554797,
-0.040086247,
0.0398313478,
-0.0367476158,
-0.0121919122,
-0.0044505945,
-0.0053541292,
-0.0133893415,
0.0356527492,
0.0684246942,
-0.0378131084,
0.0097525334,
0.0385847203,
-0.012644711,
-0.0070768162,
-0.0285562743,
-0.0482463464,
0.0210882612,
0.0001245384,
-0.0431145169,
0.0070789224,
-0.0203526411,
-0.0120800426,
0.0029927355,
-0.0014181662,
-0.0250820443,
0.0048189331,
2.952e-7,
-0.0107406843,
0.0073750904,
0.0194694083,
0.0136003625,
-0.0278542545,
0.0236946251,
0.0290246867,
0.0095798569,
0.0202527028,
-0.0093228528,
0.0209253412,
-0.0153538892,
0.0981897637,
0.0076126335,
-0.1026483849,
-0.0216252301,
-0.0321043842,
0.037452016,
-0.0262018088,
-0.0042384951,
0.038911365,
0.09040723,
-0.0104999039,
-0.0215242505,
-0.0132363057,
-0.0090208864,
0.0181443524,
0.0065692645,
-0.004993564,
-0.0109610176,
0.050402116,
0.0828623623,
-0.0373382643,
0.0229141619,
-0.0247785039,
0.050067205,
0.0570113622,
0.0000786566,
-0.0086961007,
-0.0353671908,
-0.0064587123,
-0.0144325104,
0.0082123531,
-0.0172949135,
0.0929317102,
0.0034883323,
-0.0002774358,
0.0199384335,
-0.0059260153,
-0.0272048153,
0.0110476157,
-0.000505924,
-0.0105400793,
0.0081909141,
-0.0007558473,
-0.0106863678,
-0.042600397,
-0.0687995702,
0.0259084906,
-0.0011747895,
-0.0188396107,
0.0244335067,
-0.0519780666,
-0.018240137,
0.0150052477,
-0.0260708518,
-0.0070910067,
2.377863212e-34,
0.0097971056,
-0.0322915651,
-0.0013891093,
0.0886717439,
0.011038444,
-0.0094242953,
0.0430763364,
0.0262840334,
0.0059953691,
-0.087356545,
-0.0124102533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01386v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01386v2 | Can Language Models Be Tricked by Language Illusions? Easier with Syntax, Harder with Semantics | 2023-11-02T16:44:24 | 2024-02-04T15:00:11 | Yuhan Zhang, Edward Gibson, Forrest Davis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have been argued to overlap substantially with human
beings in grammaticality judgment tasks. But when humans systematically make
errors in language processing, should we expect LMs to behave like cognitive
models of language and mimic human behavior? We answer this question by
investigating LMs' more subtle judgments associated with "language illusions"
-- sentences that are vague in meaning, implausible, or ungrammatical but
receive unexpectedly high acceptability judgments by humans. We looked at three
illusions: the comparative illusion (e.g. "More people have been to Russia than
I have"), the depth-charge illusion (e.g. "No head injury is too trivial to be
ignored"), and the negative polarity item (NPI) illusion (e.g. "The hunter who
no villager believed to be trustworthy will ever shoot a bear"). We found that
probabilities represented by LMs were more likely to align with human judgments
of being "tricked" by the NPI illusion which examines a structural dependency,
compared to the comparative and the depth-charge illusions which require
sophisticated semantic understanding. No single LM or metric yielded results
that are entirely consistent with human behavior. Ultimately, we show that LMs
are limited both in their construal as cognitive models of human language
processing and in their capacity to recognize nuanced but critical information
in complicated language materials. | [
0.0674121603,
0.0327748358,
-0.0616188459,
0.0540556163,
-0.0358766504,
0.0305092335,
-0.0333686471,
-0.0155889876,
-0.0149075687,
-0.0660607815,
-0.0370038636,
-0.0288842358,
0.0423274487,
-0.0063763889,
0.0493357591,
-0.0441758074,
0.0459050611,
-0.0069955238,
0.0338471085,
-0.0164963193,
-0.0086755175,
-0.0014153571,
-0.007418334,
-0.0146449525,
0.0159122422,
0.0376666337,
0.0140427304,
-0.0162680279,
-0.0068566408,
-0.0472576767,
-0.0277494416,
0.0440858416,
0.0028492862,
0.0230760798,
0.0000020198,
-0.0390104614,
0.0700829774,
-0.0346122421,
-0.0148835061,
0.0491364375,
0.0723369941,
-0.0079483353,
0.0110236192,
-0.0216245223,
-0.0081236577,
0.0010666633,
0.0124504734,
0.068077594,
-0.017447779,
0.0405677781,
-0.0004133206,
0.0144897373,
0.0075706607,
-0.014688395,
0.019413067,
-0.0003072293,
0.0392650552,
-0.0121750087,
-0.0688500404,
-0.0096516823,
-0.022085242,
-0.0090255123,
0.0089300843,
0.0314334966,
-0.062766999,
0.0431332774,
-0.0259705633,
-0.0107478891,
0.0172161814,
0.0115888165,
0.0021196678,
-0.0557616614,
-0.0291324947,
-0.0153043363,
0.0175499041,
0.0624413714,
-0.0058411201,
0.0524586365,
0.0169911347,
0.0078388285,
0.0371431522,
0.0169855803,
-0.0047599711,
0.0175847411,
0.0031184491,
0.0890446305,
0.0016402479,
-0.0219743829,
-0.0116733853,
0.0063570724,
-0.0520421416,
-0.0687774643,
-0.0383118875,
-0.0017730555,
-0.0148690864,
0.0126027381,
-0.005438704,
0.0159200337,
0.0549490601,
-0.070181638,
0.0064865332,
-0.0051130899,
-0.0261326861,
0.0341632664,
-0.0094418647,
0.0478182063,
-0.022891961,
0.0333430693,
-0.0178592838,
0.0155889234,
0.0119624734,
-0.0317491554,
0.0141446842,
-0.0238690972,
0.0194123592,
0.0310286749,
-0.0530967675,
-0.0586501732,
-0.0613033399,
-0.0127611961,
-0.0604863949,
0.005142211,
-0.0263988152,
-0.0409572646,
-0.0638710558,
0.023619419,
-0.0083807223,
0.0716057122,
-0.0686956644,
-0.0668364987,
0.0190038402,
0.0098142466,
-0.0307136588,
0.0002189494,
-0.0179440323,
-0.0119403973,
0.0178598221,
-0.0216008052,
-0.0083227344,
0.0194431711,
-0.0190718677,
-0.0175641924,
0.0029795715,
-0.0396816023,
-0.0445291959,
0.0133253075,
-0.0012725932,
-0.0534703024,
0.005894003,
0.0131787276,
-0.0818262547,
0.0399596766,
0.0324775688,
0.0257119797,
-0.0032753828,
0.0168556459,
-0.0076074121,
0.0257965494,
0.0193625633,
0.0252206139,
0.0042478996,
0.0132964822,
0.048850175,
0.0009238147,
-0.008558874,
0.0468557626,
-0.0259121824,
-0.0017663783,
-0.0351624601,
-0.0233860053,
0.0468804799,
0.0422593504,
-0.0080386633,
-0.0274595842,
0.0817884803,
0.0158148948,
-0.0603290424,
-0.010440859,
0.0163392071,
0.0040932251,
-0.0085349306,
0.0683256462,
-0.0612553284,
0.0146237053,
-0.0123344921,
-0.019971041,
-0.0180444717,
0.0097752716,
0.0138160298,
-0.0062062778,
-0.0334683843,
-0.0053313528,
0.0794495419,
-0.0128760077,
0.0363423154,
-0.0071475506,
-0.040169742,
0.008674317,
0.0636599809,
-0.0321644768,
-0.0015728128,
-0.0337475538,
-0.0114087285,
-0.0123412078,
-0.0071751694,
0.032297451,
0.0378102995,
0.0075743599,
-0.0236590635,
0.0684217289,
0.0644562095,
0.0373693146,
-0.0279429015,
0.0273930896,
0.0262994636,
-0.0283803158,
0.0431393236,
0.0016904008,
-0.0259901304,
0.0200761892,
0.0221511032,
-0.0473439358,
0.0048773233,
0.0401267,
0.0116200959,
0.0166913923,
-0.071100235,
-0.0015111082,
0.0213642474,
-0.0193992592,
0.0081935655,
0.0295302775,
0.0197579172,
-0.0256187133,
-0.0335941128,
0.0276622791,
-0.0452150665,
0.0099776089,
-0.001809842,
-0.0590345338,
-0.0232404731,
0.0108436244,
0.0177666489,
0.0003182114,
0.024123244,
-0.0507552288,
0.0431653969,
0.0033533417,
0.0543715209,
-0.0261998456,
0.0144227045,
-0.0085301837,
0.0661487728,
-0.0386012569,
0.0767249241,
-0.0727144778,
-0.0161368996,
0.0259954222,
-0.0258469805,
-0.0040119784,
-0.0263181161,
0.0201808326,
-0.0425283238,
0.0045269406,
-0.0464406759,
-0.0439971499,
0.0064407638,
-0.0504879951,
-0.0366132334,
0.0174802504,
-0.0104036024,
0.0195054915,
-0.0541773736,
-0.0056283968,
0.0144276964,
0.0136354947,
0.0129288994,
0.0130018266,
0.0412103646,
0.0180944949,
-0.0151681276,
-0.0172245037,
0.0060929484,
0.015981853,
-0.0476218723,
0.0346551873,
-0.0103250323,
-0.0193735007,
-0.0426510759,
0.0261102915,
-0.0656968951,
0.0123038525,
-0.027252946,
-0.0684100688,
0.0124991117,
0.0512933806,
0.0171122141,
0.0276084691,
0.0264318138,
0.0448636338,
0.0790119916,
0.0025511375,
-0.0120437341,
-0.0498977117,
-0.0232602619,
0.0030164339,
0.011001355,
-0.0965821967,
-0.0042303754,
0.0845371187,
0.0434650742,
-0.0074024955,
-0.0307040438,
0.0655574724,
-0.0719044358,
-0.0435396396,
0.0433493778,
-0.0556366444,
-0.0314440057,
0.0616738535,
-0.0139201581,
-0.0214480739,
0.0763410032,
-0.0064053605,
0.009135942,
0.0079970816,
0.0319849029,
0.0103861289,
0.0405133851,
0.0727648214,
0.0112889213,
0.035610944,
0.0050217188,
-0.0617545806,
-0.0393026918,
0.0026969197,
-0.016197687,
0.011148341,
-0.0529508255,
-0.0308480188,
0.0047678156,
-0.0296685956,
-0.0253557283,
-0.0264091268,
-0.0354558565,
-0.0359189101,
-0.0217116978,
0.0103739994,
-0.0374676473,
-0.0271689128,
0.0213049203,
-0.0186060481,
0.0104997195,
0.0005006416,
-0.0154520897,
-0.0211443938,
0.0313120484,
-0.0189053528,
0.069903478,
-0.0201227702,
-0.0135084316,
0.0614744537,
-0.0429978818,
0.0468705446,
0.0233115889,
-0.0140464334,
0.0408932865,
0.0165784378,
-0.0408101231,
0.0515680835,
0.0084649296,
-0.0266321283,
0.003747311,
0.0758323222,
0.0568033643,
0.0015367197,
0.0473047569,
-0.023766391,
0.0113159353,
0.0308468677,
-0.0429540537,
-0.0630285293,
0.0196136683,
0.0269778632,
-0.0444878303,
-0.0883912295,
-0.0197831448,
-0.0184605066,
-0.0718082786,
0.0292092171,
0.005330144,
0.0185461678,
-0.0019937793,
-0.0415573046,
0.0171333533,
0.0395800285,
0.0306035765,
0.0366262458,
-0.0010749671,
0.0135876341,
-0.0315998495,
0.0108625609,
-0.0270682629,
-0.0155713111,
0.0156058352,
0.0546016656,
-0.0250389185,
0.0471831001,
-0.0394535847,
-0.0739471242,
0.0595225021,
0.0189996045,
-0.0150080808,
0.0101479841,
0.0241631158,
0.0266585201,
0.0005058254,
-0.0698926896,
-0.0067454237,
0.0261814725,
-0.0466064699,
-0.0175414197,
0.037693873,
-0.0159157049,
-0.0569943711,
0.0200180728,
-0.0152381659,
-0.0232910756,
0.0921749845,
0.0282944366,
0.0113103073,
0.0077698268,
-0.0171191748,
0.0081871739,
0.0736691058,
-0.0603519827,
0.0771656483,
0.0322265513,
-0.0286083203,
-0.0736593604,
-0.0632416457,
-0.0183097199,
-0.0442687832,
0.0125160553,
0.0099912025,
0.0444885977,
-0.0417145714,
-0.0238759331,
0.0364484079,
-0.0178837199,
0.0045412676,
-0.0242868587,
0.0365408622,
-0.0006417794,
-0.0400852002,
-0.0040601017,
-0.0242316704,
-0.0090849344,
-0.0287413206,
0.0646141768,
-0.0166633762,
0.0258054454,
0.0038350383,
0.0098086921,
-0.0397096239,
-0.0241337586,
0.0203371588,
-0.0329959355,
0.0637362748,
0.0027182077,
0.03407472,
0.045619756,
0.0378130898,
-0.0115827825,
0.0403877608,
0.044212088,
0.0052556456,
-0.0246590786,
-0.0208848715,
0.0648036227,
0.017599754,
0.0890778229,
0.0076069636,
0.0508678183,
-0.0223156344,
-0.0252806712,
-0.0415531918,
-0.0289050546,
0.018441923,
-0.0629788414,
0.0283801164,
0.057217937,
-0.0371888168,
-0.0390261151,
-0.0564617924,
0.0460872278,
-0.0205255076,
-0.0166017096,
0.0377145484,
0.0030015795,
0.0218163915,
-0.0131659769,
0.0001751448,
0.0218320731,
-0.0645604953,
0.0370081216,
0.0183573328,
0.0567175746,
0.0171630271,
-0.0334662758,
-0.0537486672,
-0.041036997,
-0.0250849687,
-0.003117552,
0.0222454406,
0.0313065685,
0.0044115866,
-0.049296733,
0.0463520102,
-0.0411125906,
0.0003464099,
0.0112947077,
-0.0091343885,
0.0043533295,
-0.0427656807,
0.0436161198,
0.0078807035,
-0.0118457684,
0.0402230658,
0.0535357036,
-0.0213107001,
0.0007904625,
-0.0014769167,
-0.0387960635,
-0.0079732966,
-0.0170004163,
-0.0040376321,
0.0228957776,
-0.0016619423,
0.0381464474,
-0.0978735909,
-0.0629467666,
-0.0503329523,
0.0115231546,
0.0391662531,
-0.0478462353,
-0.0296806004,
0.0613692328,
-0.0006478204,
-0.0270433966,
-0.0204272158,
0.0385132506,
-0.0016570952,
0.0391420089,
-0.0362272002,
-6.493062717e-33,
-0.0043534725,
-0.0356220864,
-0.0508421175,
0.0059725828,
-0.0029050517,
0.0064436994,
-0.0226801876,
0.0449065305,
-0.0131559912,
0.0713805035,
0.0055347257,
0.0013753435,
-0.0028022442,
-0.0247517414,
0.0043394072,
0.0459016636,
0.024768116,
0.011905157,
-0.0371271856,
-0.0702364817,
0.0374195427,
-0.0267352015,
0.0577964969,
-0.0598812327,
0.101616852,
-0.0080584604,
-0.0001879005,
0.0165035706,
-0.0259811133,
-0.0162732229,
-0.015314349,
0.026657844,
0.0443019047,
-0.028901564,
0.0133549906,
0.0277049225,
0.0196747854,
-0.0206443947,
0.0843751505,
0.0094349589,
0.0065779202,
0.012459348,
0.0288081411,
-0.0423491076,
-0.0453297161,
0.0563748665,
0.0253439527,
-0.0191869959,
0.0454246067,
0.0269651115,
-0.0553283803,
-0.0183336567,
0.0219969396,
0.0061556958,
-0.0187505018,
0.0117632709,
-0.0232409928,
0.0155988727,
-0.0852568075,
0.0321818404,
-0.0197892487,
0.017537849,
0.0154760312,
-0.0344609432,
-0.0010644292,
0.0640496239,
0.0515277013,
0.0579096489,
-0.0404873788,
0.0352604426,
0.0302961171,
-0.001821486,
0.0552029386,
0.0720257983,
0.0529280044,
-0.0399291813,
-0.0315723419,
-0.0317258351,
0.0022739528,
0.0309552923,
0.0419785976,
0.0160914045,
-0.0701482967,
-0.0427644849,
-0.0334251039,
-0.0337604545,
-0.0402850248,
-0.0049323933,
0.0151457479,
-0.0247429609,
-0.0038408341,
-0.0589631759,
0.0043395343,
-0.0084400382,
-0.0172407869,
-0.0515507683,
-0.0193994474,
-0.0064653498,
0.0184293427,
0.0101446519,
0.0018747248,
0.0003425888,
0.0115621556,
0.0220063347,
0.013079796,
0.0242887754,
0.0403503738,
-0.052735094,
-0.027172409,
-0.0074635944,
-0.0085599981,
-0.0431082174,
0.0082921283,
-0.0179897454,
0.0751006082,
0.014215705,
-0.0406530909,
-0.0443595685,
0.0533753932,
-0.0366422981,
-0.0430741571,
0.0351078473,
-0.0708714575,
0.021954868,
-0.0606832877,
-0.0455295108,
-0.0314728729,
-0.0031772507,
0.0512003265,
-0.039299041,
-0.0428252146,
-0.0085298689,
2.859e-7,
0.0092920698,
0.0898668692,
-0.0702762604,
0.0260067601,
0.0488177687,
0.0732027665,
-0.0183844455,
-0.0118653597,
0.068852134,
-0.035709843,
-0.0439559408,
-0.0080728997,
-0.0044679451,
0.0117435176,
-0.0082135135,
0.0314841121,
-0.0079809893,
-0.0087149218,
0.0002078213,
0.0373928398,
0.0531559028,
0.0069338838,
0.0457484126,
-0.0008847767,
-0.0352112874,
-0.0297063161,
0.0214216691,
-0.0283666346,
-0.0204843506,
-0.0063465745,
0.0184136964,
-0.0025750177,
0.0073940251,
0.0712003037,
0.0254099667,
-0.0047300966,
-0.0102272285,
0.0017452094,
-0.0264987759,
0.0176810138,
-0.0275781564,
-0.036642462,
-0.0154413311,
-0.118401289,
0.0336686,
-0.0958219171,
-0.0630736649,
0.007705559,
-0.0552068986,
0.0119805252,
0.02086436,
0.0484538376,
-0.0586000532,
-0.0009862236,
0.0265413038,
0.0181615762,
-0.004379225,
-0.0028724847,
-0.0560953543,
-0.0007816467,
-0.00124731,
-0.0443906933,
-0.0221036281,
0.0486799516,
0.0037520633,
-0.0506576002,
-0.0006997472,
2.620075889e-34,
0.0326195806,
0.0067512528,
0.0402245298,
-0.044573389,
0.0577335954,
0.01526454,
0.0244318247,
0.0447097607,
0.0467581488,
-0.0245514717,
0.016797049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04228v1 | Graph Neural Networks for Topological Feature Extraction in ECG Classification | 2023-11-02T16:14:34 | 2023-11-02T16:14:34 | Kamyar Zeinalipour, Marco Gori | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL, cs.LG | The electrocardiogram (ECG) is a dependable instrument for assessing the
function of the cardiovascular system. There has recently been much emphasis on
precisely classifying ECGs. While ECG situations have numerous similarities,
little attention has been paid to categorizing ECGs using graph neural
networks. In this study, we offer three distinct techniques for classifying
heartbeats using deep graph neural networks to classify the ECG signals
accurately. We suggest using different methods to extract topological features
from the ECG signal and then using a branch of the graph neural network named
graph isomorphism network for classifying the ECGs. On the PTB Diagnostics data
set, we tested the three proposed techniques. According to the findings, the
three proposed techniques are capable of making arrhythmia classification
predictions with the accuracy of 99.38, 98.76, and 91.93 percent, respectively. | [
-0.0453862473,
-0.0026616794,
-0.0033635842,
0.0106419008,
-0.010299949,
0.0066082063,
0.0280973352,
0.0139121143,
0.0573343635,
0.0624340549,
-0.0073257778,
-0.0299094059,
0.0085616326,
0.0790833011,
-0.0038557313,
-0.0377518721,
0.026573753,
0.0333769135,
-0.0067635765,
-0.0300583839,
0.0054224422,
-0.0007048291,
0.0227302164,
0.0549179129,
0.0114545189,
-0.0224461928,
-0.031570062,
-0.0117137171,
0.0025205729,
-0.0789010525,
-0.0061353939,
0.0008769538,
-0.0325822532,
0.0262591615,
0.0000016097,
0.0352130756,
0.0072552096,
0.0053021149,
-0.0139364703,
-0.0701409504,
-0.0270150118,
-0.0220007449,
0.0605730675,
-0.048308488,
-0.0345983244,
-0.0375103466,
0.0340289958,
0.0283176787,
0.0160638895,
0.036306493,
-0.025628943,
0.0138544459,
0.0340395756,
-0.0423780307,
0.0305920541,
-0.0293956865,
0.0303609483,
-0.0319826752,
0.0721155554,
-0.0287572984,
-0.0261907559,
0.0158341192,
0.0418046452,
0.0670078695,
0.1030312851,
0.0234762859,
0.0383658297,
-0.0069105411,
-0.0190281868,
0.0775166601,
-0.0503127612,
-0.0045045647,
0.0092697768,
0.0211524051,
0.0102978274,
-0.0184971355,
-0.0208425708,
-0.0432682261,
-0.0418424346,
0.0100532556,
-0.0160340481,
0.0120163569,
0.017600866,
-0.0499213822,
-0.0286212098,
0.0488435961,
-0.0103322463,
0.0313743241,
0.0305375271,
0.0034283199,
-0.0252583921,
-0.0032249712,
0.0217938609,
-0.036079824,
0.0052449801,
-0.0442196876,
0.0156560335,
0.0164450444,
-0.0355602615,
0.010944698,
0.0222442225,
-0.0265127216,
0.0064067566,
-0.0109712183,
-0.031180229,
-0.042900227,
-0.054377269,
0.0929441079,
-0.0196861271,
0.0438350625,
-0.0790563971,
0.026473375,
0.0107501158,
0.0627169982,
0.0808355361,
-0.0551556833,
-0.0658226684,
0.0172653757,
-0.056948211,
-0.0418671779,
0.0131977834,
0.0833243281,
0.0610324368,
0.0205661133,
0.0359056145,
-0.0148419952,
0.0226976909,
0.0334820077,
-0.0351317599,
0.006649388,
0.0309389196,
-0.0108884219,
0.038837146,
0.0263935365,
0.0292292982,
0.0289502032,
0.0323896967,
0.003498194,
-0.0189134646,
-0.0365715101,
-0.0156218596,
0.000734742,
0.0366216153,
-0.0371553563,
0.0186274163,
-0.0009680277,
-0.0178788714,
-0.0043955622,
0.0020004297,
-0.0344910584,
0.0078759417,
0.069504872,
-0.0253204424,
0.004609955,
-0.0003168394,
-0.0009391172,
0.0031215476,
-0.0249914695,
0.0251798425,
0.0182198957,
0.0000837906,
-0.012063494,
-0.0341634527,
-0.0185675379,
0.0103644477,
-0.0913518071,
0.0168280005,
-0.0289959963,
-0.0459954329,
0.029258348,
0.0345296711,
-0.0031989971,
0.0075883884,
-0.0825363696,
0.0022260596,
0.012615256,
0.0450953618,
0.0717725381,
0.0131776789,
-0.0239256341,
-0.0187314674,
-0.0029212995,
-0.026132727,
-0.005665415,
0.002841884,
-0.0013668437,
-0.0817842335,
-0.0733431205,
0.004843045,
-0.0271086097,
-0.0097044911,
-0.057594981,
0.0803107545,
-0.0297474954,
0.047471609,
-0.0185678527,
-0.0214579254,
0.0144427586,
-0.0124318618,
0.0567939393,
-0.070413895,
-0.0178257246,
0.0011122464,
-0.0070826611,
-0.0606067367,
-0.0128680216,
0.0000859644,
0.0082100937,
-0.0098134568,
-0.0803812966,
0.0333884843,
0.0135690002,
0.0033287457,
-0.037028037,
-0.0583569929,
0.0006438388,
-0.0085341549,
0.0537857376,
-0.0399672128,
0.0115540931,
-0.00714008,
-0.0387328342,
-0.0192975719,
-0.0132925836,
0.0329649746,
-0.0201675668,
0.0216149986,
0.0457771756,
0.0572625399,
0.0146566518,
0.02779603,
0.0127320122,
0.0008632098,
-0.0623482354,
-0.0249736998,
-0.004824141,
-0.0622734986,
-0.0009360031,
0.0256326105,
-0.0141726928,
-0.0160394982,
0.0178777985,
-0.0184499919,
-0.0171529111,
0.0233192109,
-0.0499692187,
-0.0226404723,
-0.0107208025,
-0.009827151,
-0.0019715019,
0.0074008331,
-0.0021155707,
-0.0380903259,
0.0674689934,
0.0338702872,
-0.026257975,
0.0028316355,
0.011695846,
-0.0225189459,
-0.0053738225,
0.0139613468,
-0.009860686,
-0.0566675514,
-0.0071556917,
0.0254974607,
0.0045091636,
0.0239244699,
-0.0669576004,
-0.0190542787,
0.0364628024,
0.0315727368,
-0.0491035432,
0.0002942533,
0.0009728597,
-0.0096909218,
-0.0524988957,
0.046859283,
0.0090573207,
-0.0002049129,
0.0254062694,
0.0036961939,
-0.0176496059,
0.0370162874,
-0.0333717093,
-0.0229584537,
0.0623134114,
0.0397950187,
-0.0090180337,
0.0295958333,
-0.0094730081,
0.0200181603,
-0.0062341066,
0.0301090367,
0.0062549398,
-0.03022849,
0.0002027086,
-0.0461420938,
0.052859012,
-0.0173248146,
0.0404453799,
-0.0148471333,
0.0422022603,
0.0457464978,
-0.0105777979,
-0.051639691,
0.0399155393,
0.0257981401,
-0.0212947242,
-0.035859637,
0.0320560336,
0.0513350703,
-0.0153441178,
0.0262202621,
-0.0374118462,
-0.007057569,
0.0077406811,
-0.0344684348,
-0.0359333865,
0.0173131265,
-0.035663791,
-0.0017927206,
-0.0210581645,
0.0348129161,
0.0371998027,
-0.0058989711,
0.0017959002,
-0.0634071454,
-0.0492998175,
0.0133574083,
0.0405248478,
0.0291534066,
-0.0162105523,
-0.0330424234,
0.0006963153,
-0.0138863502,
-0.0145642366,
-0.0546907708,
-0.0262241345,
0.0047601284,
0.0096982997,
0.0213273764,
-0.0206593089,
-0.0314852558,
0.0571863316,
0.0003263217,
0.0314189494,
-0.0440366194,
0.0184995923,
0.0756031126,
0.0743140802,
-0.0581134073,
-0.0097764181,
-0.0217317902,
-0.0027891975,
-0.0075665531,
0.104523465,
-0.0012207131,
-0.0010731624,
-0.0023132926,
-0.0314832553,
-0.025300147,
0.0092925923,
-0.0152945407,
0.0680672303,
-0.070751898,
-0.0031657922,
-0.0772136897,
-0.0238156207,
-0.0326881744,
-0.0301710218,
-0.0316272005,
-0.03250717,
0.0370779224,
0.0157545153,
0.0064126858,
-0.0673889816,
0.0008881115,
0.0241845511,
-0.0251155384,
-0.0205806363,
-0.0636318848,
-0.0163852982,
0.0002512568,
-0.0008995003,
0.0110218376,
0.0198814552,
0.0000545807,
0.0337364301,
0.0230424795,
0.0163235925,
0.0464476496,
-0.0359095372,
-0.0792526603,
-0.0534218028,
0.0301517155,
-0.0161764938,
-0.0114272609,
-0.0748218521,
-0.0313413069,
-0.0297145564,
0.051775381,
-0.0738970488,
0.0013305169,
0.031612996,
-0.0000573204,
-0.0213089418,
-0.0186191238,
-0.0247562919,
-0.0029226732,
0.0133645646,
0.003187133,
0.0433843844,
-0.0263387226,
0.0029878977,
0.0145831052,
0.0791907012,
0.0223584026,
0.0175024886,
0.0554390103,
-0.0383750871,
0.0220743474,
-0.0350102969,
0.0587757379,
-0.0198372342,
-0.0930260271,
-0.0195460357,
0.0107360482,
0.03961071,
-0.0061808024,
0.022185253,
-0.0036376924,
-0.0434973277,
0.0243325476,
0.05626183,
-0.0631664172,
-0.0647016689,
0.0250732824,
-0.0502041765,
-0.0489973687,
-0.007531825,
-0.0098171309,
-0.0492966957,
0.029806314,
0.0032440759,
-0.0338795967,
0.1314286739,
-0.0411126539,
-0.0714994743,
0.0575838611,
0.02355689,
0.0597297959,
0.0159859248,
0.0001403118,
0.0008165312,
-0.0021481533,
-0.0529437512,
0.0032691611,
-0.0486822501,
-0.0109844115,
0.0066577368,
-0.0383342169,
0.0038446616,
0.0300116912,
-0.0644942001,
0.0157119986,
0.0223952588,
0.0182157047,
0.027342122,
-0.0141655905,
0.0747219026,
-0.0400906354,
-0.0705470517,
0.0250967667,
-0.0164030977,
0.042858772,
0.0168032032,
-0.0178446509,
-0.0131688025,
-0.0129985875,
-0.02989644,
0.0547236949,
0.0515749641,
0.0320335329,
-0.0098958099,
-0.021793507,
0.0205095112,
0.0451534539,
0.0593211018,
0.0076758536,
-0.0468997285,
-0.0085195992,
0.0440089889,
-0.0153146666,
-0.0471051484,
0.0538704321,
-0.0778839514,
-0.0267484207,
0.0639216378,
-0.017322937,
0.0040544071,
0.0246090926,
0.0198826734,
-0.0126316007,
0.0221323539,
0.0391426086,
-0.0238102581,
-0.0157341342,
-0.0024616891,
0.0168941263,
0.0094641829,
-0.0481974632,
0.0296856761,
-0.0063527594,
0.048350893,
-0.0349175818,
-0.0220723134,
0.0367385149,
0.0081561953,
0.0080705872,
0.0066948589,
-0.0256381892,
-0.0219670571,
0.0508419685,
-0.063057743,
0.0393511765,
0.0469689369,
-0.0064062453,
0.0037675041,
0.0159640387,
0.0109854247,
0.0402829237,
0.0176861938,
0.0221200287,
-0.0430630818,
-0.0288253948,
0.0410287865,
0.0151784718,
-0.0035380742,
-0.0036856669,
0.0137680313,
0.0063959537,
-0.0505860075,
0.1139702275,
-0.006732502,
0.0192122571,
0.0201504678,
0.0579609349,
-0.0044419905,
-0.0417302884,
0.0370864607,
0.0194009766,
0.0066439621,
-0.0090932772,
-0.0286173765,
-0.0281153806,
-4.860607795e-33,
0.0277534071,
-0.0233348347,
-0.0240800772,
0.0320224427,
-0.0622365884,
0.0269515477,
-0.0131843612,
-0.0070352503,
0.018056985,
0.0235522203,
-0.0152103351,
-0.0171848498,
0.0111488597,
0.0288577359,
0.0072848666,
-0.0557512902,
0.02523968,
0.030979123,
0.0322950669,
0.0513649955,
-0.0087991804,
0.0448178127,
-0.0069952407,
-0.0961541906,
-0.0467912965,
0.0354356542,
0.0096134664,
-0.0165622998,
0.0301476531,
0.0084659448,
-0.0491565727,
0.0725784451,
0.0082095498,
0.0308435056,
0.0174041614,
-0.0017332492,
-0.0692299083,
-0.0082206009,
-0.0413069949,
0.0036524262,
0.0200348403,
-0.0401497819,
0.0356533378,
0.0123160277,
0.0102526983,
-0.0438323133,
0.0520139709,
-0.0206364654,
-0.0033902428,
-0.0303057171,
0.0394293182,
0.0420244299,
-0.0063637751,
-0.0087651759,
0.0391620845,
-0.0302885789,
-0.0443201251,
-0.004105974,
-0.0779050961,
0.0025106096,
-0.0230500791,
-0.0388105847,
-0.0431749001,
0.0232210103,
0.0065045399,
-0.0043975078,
0.0407790169,
-0.0297221486,
-0.016809117,
0.0843937695,
-0.0278385505,
0.1029927731,
0.0371962674,
-0.0528023057,
-0.0090033514,
-0.0537249036,
-0.0893645659,
0.014762003,
-0.003468605,
-0.0359785333,
-0.0403581671,
0.0257249437,
-0.0286932644,
-0.0059509431,
0.053816475,
-0.0607392527,
-0.0337348804,
-0.0121854739,
-0.0117484462,
-0.0275647212,
0.024383001,
0.0822288692,
-0.0438151732,
-0.074356623,
0.0212633535,
0.0084312493,
0.0293367617,
0.0186007656,
0.058618173,
-0.0075475881,
0.0423665382,
-0.0188249834,
-0.0050631762,
0.0241331719,
0.0563784838,
-0.012337151,
-0.0083580269,
0.0183374789,
0.0067660324,
-0.0327939875,
0.0265998151,
-0.0488042906,
-0.0128613953,
-0.0299454425,
0.039250277,
-0.0220474042,
0.0012347819,
0.0954742059,
-0.0182533134,
0.1062261313,
-0.0195027441,
0.0111634945,
0.0092515461,
0.0726439729,
-0.0145515446,
-0.0402391814,
-0.0078482591,
0.02164088,
-0.0227695704,
-0.0179434363,
-0.0402531736,
-0.0323535688,
2.673e-7,
-0.0071501937,
-0.0055422862,
0.0314063989,
-0.0326439962,
-0.0239129923,
0.0184264369,
-0.0215435345,
0.0281254463,
-0.0126582943,
0.0043914951,
0.0497319102,
0.0149018234,
0.0233111773,
0.0412317552,
-0.0514087602,
0.0000969733,
-0.0557222813,
0.0633870959,
0.0062024384,
0.022619348,
0.0033104855,
0.0387520753,
-0.018125603,
-0.0014384413,
0.0520275496,
-0.0072143408,
0.000477937,
0.0193730593,
-0.0065507647,
-0.0069287079,
-0.0025564791,
-0.0444283932,
0.0164676569,
-0.0263336375,
0.0111204255,
0.0397858992,
0.0711057484,
-0.0138607891,
-0.0269410629,
0.0038467906,
0.0013305392,
0.0289951228,
0.0520437546,
0.0060162009,
0.0802525878,
-0.0819986984,
-0.0586420745,
-0.0183723886,
-0.0111837955,
-0.0223202445,
0.0478913933,
-0.0162099451,
-0.0069289054,
0.0336217284,
0.0337809362,
-0.0567503199,
0.0344333574,
-0.0248249732,
0.0245296564,
0.0883894712,
-0.0103840427,
-0.0097105773,
-0.0006327261,
0.0499725975,
0.0754731223,
0.0159743391,
-0.0176498611,
1.776659381e-34,
-0.0224082731,
0.0280837249,
-0.0050667091,
-0.023626456,
-0.0106974291,
-0.0296175089,
0.0309479255,
-0.0238486566,
-0.0330943726,
-0.0467986614,
-0.0271739382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01361v1 | GPT-4V(ision) as a Generalist Evaluator for Vision-Language Tasks | 2023-11-02T16:11:09 | 2023-11-02T16:11:09 | Xinlu Zhang, Yujie Lu, Weizhi Wang, An Yan, Jun Yan, Lianke Qin, Heng Wang, Xifeng Yan, William Yang Wang, Linda Ruth Petzold | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Automatically evaluating vision-language tasks is challenging, especially
when it comes to reflecting human judgments due to limitations in accounting
for fine-grained details. Although GPT-4V has shown promising results in
various multi-modal tasks, leveraging GPT-4V as a generalist evaluator for
these tasks has not yet been systematically explored. We comprehensively
validate GPT-4V's capabilities for evaluation purposes, addressing tasks
ranging from foundational image-to-text and text-to-image synthesis to
high-level image-to-image translations and multi-images to text alignment. We
employ two evaluation methods, single-answer grading and pairwise comparison,
using GPT-4V. Notably, GPT-4V shows promising agreement with humans across
various tasks and evaluation methods, demonstrating immense potential for
multi-modal LLMs as evaluators. Despite limitations like restricted visual
clarity grading and real-world complex reasoning, its ability to provide
human-aligned scores enriched with detailed explanations is promising for
universal automatic evaluator. | [
-0.0040779058,
0.0676602498,
0.01881871,
0.0375678837,
-0.0325364433,
0.0112244068,
0.002285253,
0.0110231694,
-0.0169179495,
-0.0405564979,
-0.0433002412,
-0.0438654795,
0.0288357399,
0.0096695665,
0.0378839746,
-0.070163101,
0.0149437804,
-0.0106726345,
0.0039818552,
-0.0026277828,
0.0344530791,
0.0018879713,
-0.0049759857,
0.0302161053,
-0.0265918206,
-0.014626245,
-0.0155034866,
0.031695772,
0.071296744,
0.000335514,
-0.0375619046,
0.0422898494,
0.0200246833,
-0.0034011253,
0.0000018109,
-0.0127195539,
0.0088509638,
0.0274385698,
0.0422179475,
0.0045275227,
0.0255589355,
-0.0260914769,
-0.0137426686,
-0.0198533591,
-0.0457127169,
-0.0089235445,
0.0704656243,
0.0378521644,
0.0879862979,
0.0634303913,
-0.0241337735,
-0.0347851962,
0.0278207343,
-0.008410451,
0.0383243933,
-0.0427938029,
-0.0146095026,
0.0254705418,
-0.0107373279,
0.0041972916,
-0.0113757942,
0.041095838,
0.0433591194,
-0.0366629511,
-0.0068201129,
0.0179642756,
-0.0143201156,
-0.0304072723,
-0.0255928859,
0.0672206581,
0.0012113072,
-0.0020917205,
-0.0456402935,
-0.0193174034,
-0.0110633355,
0.0129967909,
-0.0397563353,
0.0216206964,
0.0040729996,
0.0333021246,
-0.054757975,
0.0115474965,
0.0100625623,
-0.0010445754,
0.0062919524,
0.034425918,
0.0409220457,
0.0115105109,
0.0084130345,
0.0452073999,
-0.0509881116,
-0.054466553,
0.0059228726,
0.0293042809,
-0.0147358682,
-0.0158762168,
-0.0405405536,
-0.0130689302,
-0.0076652947,
-0.009924612,
0.0522045419,
0.0573384054,
-0.0506793968,
0.0397267379,
-0.0464648493,
0.1092846021,
-0.009299499,
0.0636174902,
-0.0284162015,
-0.0301082078,
-0.0442651175,
0.0148410639,
0.0017607134,
-0.0095045054,
-0.0358906165,
-0.0066684899,
-0.0389585905,
0.0010712737,
-0.0212014858,
0.0301324055,
0.0280976482,
0.0230927598,
-0.0398494899,
-0.0288832895,
-0.0554436408,
0.023703156,
-0.0223367102,
0.0195652656,
-0.0010285979,
-0.029851811,
0.000736143,
0.0526607782,
0.0148827368,
-0.0243000891,
-0.016102843,
0.0750976652,
-0.0574249327,
-0.0049843532,
0.0020760056,
0.0006605992,
-0.0244983044,
-0.1096225232,
0.0269300137,
-0.0482045598,
0.0076499241,
-0.0005150936,
-0.0107385693,
-0.0273227785,
-0.0043879091,
0.0002204141,
0.0257626791,
0.0964018852,
0.0163731873,
-0.0134525113,
-0.0120550822,
0.0155041507,
-0.0138313426,
0.0395383798,
0.0400196724,
0.0536856465,
-0.0004018708,
0.0131316269,
0.049963966,
0.0516658463,
-0.0236048494,
-0.0024058674,
-0.025688244,
0.0038594997,
-0.020065276,
0.0263397917,
0.0427156053,
0.0731690452,
-0.0096538011,
0.0146681517,
0.0867204294,
0.0176526383,
0.0386158787,
0.0016825185,
0.0622719601,
-0.0028730209,
0.0062573701,
0.0399506427,
-0.0807630345,
0.082512714,
-0.0265800599,
0.0202238765,
0.005769474,
0.0320672132,
-0.0019577711,
-0.0599799864,
-0.0052271942,
0.0243419316,
0.0194751471,
-0.0033368294,
0.0331821442,
-0.0248286407,
-0.0452395007,
-0.0002218316,
-0.0241372939,
-0.0734568015,
0.0113615282,
-0.0530368425,
0.0159928408,
0.068149291,
0.0212565884,
0.0090559358,
-0.0075811357,
0.022230126,
-0.0062225973,
0.0643974394,
0.0113419928,
0.0200455282,
0.0205981676,
-0.0659473091,
-0.0369693115,
-0.004123495,
0.0005694535,
0.0104340268,
0.0202309974,
0.0014775876,
0.0221234467,
-0.0638761595,
-0.0244935118,
0.0363538228,
0.0734173656,
-0.0144349132,
-0.0329472683,
0.03752736,
0.0031334774,
0.0103331581,
-0.0058349269,
0.0065087555,
-0.0031215749,
-0.0121195735,
-0.0013880167,
-0.0009520735,
-0.0190710071,
-0.0375045612,
0.0428173989,
-0.0888673514,
-0.0437898822,
0.0334252566,
-0.047296878,
-0.0530251712,
-0.0099089593,
-0.0235439576,
-0.0278629437,
-0.0726787075,
-0.0103580747,
0.0296813697,
-0.0007726317,
-0.0353065208,
0.0666515157,
0.009023278,
0.0008857533,
0.0059977351,
0.0001820087,
-0.0008843536,
-0.0263586268,
-0.0326989032,
-0.0103319492,
0.0258583147,
0.0343292542,
0.0075992183,
0.0525879748,
-0.0405381024,
-0.0200282186,
-0.0894270539,
0.0123030413,
-0.0278531481,
0.0129893161,
0.0287835412,
-0.0271373764,
0.031029962,
0.0101501308,
-0.0809081942,
0.0324763246,
0.0173478313,
-0.0114579666,
0.0612761639,
-0.0098404894,
-0.0012451287,
-0.0398095511,
0.0096490355,
-0.0049305703,
0.026180746,
0.059140753,
-0.0062096892,
-0.0438235961,
0.0083048521,
-0.0406357497,
0.0146370074,
0.0004162959,
-0.0552238151,
0.0293241069,
-0.0058135847,
0.0260729976,
0.0572612211,
-0.0029599881,
-0.0224579331,
0.0084300376,
-0.0015539587,
-0.0463453569,
-0.0035251228,
0.0162619762,
-0.0538417548,
0.0083064185,
-0.0336467922,
-0.0594175793,
0.0320019014,
-0.0001465405,
0.0139961233,
-0.094746165,
0.0154181337,
-0.009499291,
-0.0267454721,
-0.0327183343,
0.0298282653,
-0.0196768437,
0.0507180318,
-0.0526553579,
-0.0799429268,
0.0775322616,
-0.0567791983,
-0.0405559801,
0.0307784695,
0.0261886623,
-0.0181487594,
0.0633954331,
0.000743002,
0.0072259433,
-0.0113393916,
0.0022827722,
-0.1018368453,
-0.022542553,
0.0188530572,
-0.027641682,
0.1078277305,
-0.0952560306,
0.0305802245,
-0.0455665663,
-0.0208563339,
-0.0027899225,
0.0304970983,
-0.0033256062,
0.011593679,
-0.0251538288,
-0.0284318589,
-0.0101656672,
0.0200230535,
0.0296176113,
0.0030742385,
-0.0274346787,
-0.0064068576,
-0.0226513296,
0.039027635,
0.0267875679,
0.0452011973,
-0.0066615166,
-0.0259773601,
-0.0312414467,
0.0388461202,
0.0063607204,
0.0036961036,
-0.0596874282,
0.0270663556,
0.023245031,
0.0428493023,
0.003351978,
0.0142352106,
0.0905562043,
-0.0658197924,
0.0067643914,
0.0575495213,
-0.009425628,
-0.0401056185,
-0.0416439995,
0.0259600151,
0.0075083934,
0.0143658835,
0.0095239636,
-0.0867296383,
-0.053114783,
-0.0192837603,
-0.0087853512,
0.0288296007,
-0.0003696691,
-0.0179878697,
-0.0478235669,
0.0731374398,
0.0447952263,
-0.0281709097,
-0.0485403873,
0.0408781916,
0.0243067238,
-0.0307365265,
0.0035800736,
0.0019944573,
0.0230187755,
0.0177607294,
-0.0061249286,
0.0403207392,
-0.0139034949,
0.0327348709,
-0.0479683913,
-0.013780497,
0.0739286989,
0.0196184833,
-0.0013485483,
-0.1038811207,
0.0366876237,
-0.0021944172,
0.0097888503,
0.0119165517,
0.0153090497,
0.0099514825,
-0.029422693,
-0.0127400588,
0.0304296706,
-0.0072644292,
-0.0147251347,
-0.0397726707,
0.0443873368,
-0.0212338883,
-0.001779244,
-0.0008777445,
0.0106616346,
-0.0028049082,
0.0375992469,
0.0358868502,
-0.0201960672,
-0.0606809556,
-0.0292448606,
0.0114219422,
-0.082150206,
-0.0470325388,
0.0064217029,
0.0122428183,
-0.026081657,
-0.0777873322,
-0.0201071277,
0.0363194123,
0.0443601161,
-0.0283177383,
-0.0642836988,
-0.0316839442,
0.0177379437,
-0.0237863753,
0.0768825039,
-0.0208846387,
0.0470532663,
-0.0423264913,
0.0064847041,
0.0112641677,
-0.0371134058,
-0.0046417098,
0.0644918308,
-0.0621685982,
-0.0410982519,
-0.0410358869,
0.0681525841,
0.0208703373,
0.0303136855,
-0.0025987024,
-0.0185339097,
0.0145761073,
0.0034789492,
0.0107337749,
0.0419680066,
0.0200626105,
0.0019644804,
-0.0099082533,
0.0259324778,
-0.0207916629,
0.0154101364,
0.0225940812,
0.0238103773,
0.0198843461,
-0.0498533025,
0.0294957291,
0.0380015671,
0.0603411496,
-0.0382031053,
0.0120133888,
-0.0246604234,
-0.0069483994,
-0.0087533602,
-0.0079433322,
-0.0874488652,
-0.0120962923,
0.0274447203,
0.0020709524,
-0.0084870197,
0.0095282337,
-0.0083392281,
0.0184349194,
-0.0163158346,
0.0080829309,
0.0100907879,
-0.0265537892,
0.0064952951,
0.0172701683,
-0.0161129739,
0.0074476153,
-0.0274750665,
0.0385737829,
-0.0013767733,
0.0594705828,
0.0290286317,
0.0162568931,
0.0161931608,
0.0563784465,
-0.0304545201,
-0.0337487832,
-0.0620705821,
0.0251078028,
0.0437386073,
0.0484327674,
0.0601377375,
-0.0079834629,
-0.0066492241,
-0.0106642749,
0.0482684411,
0.0106392261,
-0.0042656278,
0.0608620532,
0.0067335507,
0.0126662133,
-0.0337829441,
0.0520089567,
-0.0418451875,
0.009321223,
-0.042858161,
0.0042637927,
-0.0330765508,
-0.0515675582,
-0.013810561,
-0.0445087142,
0.0040335534,
-0.0176732298,
-0.0435888916,
-0.048601836,
-0.0175917335,
0.0887360275,
-0.0156805664,
0.0074448669,
0.0257144719,
0.0441222303,
-0.033072345,
-0.0316304862,
-0.0075648711,
-0.0652094781,
0.0207645688,
0.0090895295,
-0.0197836477,
-6.115735275e-33,
-0.069144249,
-0.0467030369,
0.0377177186,
-0.0203545131,
-0.0385099687,
-0.000513825,
-0.031994652,
0.0121086705,
-0.0119574424,
0.0419933386,
0.0149710681,
-0.01960936,
0.0248469822,
0.0198000278,
0.0188366473,
-0.0158800725,
0.0239275508,
0.0041765915,
-0.0401783548,
-0.0003639484,
-0.0076533365,
-0.0427140892,
0.0857946649,
-0.0485297814,
0.0360331163,
0.0490280651,
-0.0734982342,
0.0033652212,
-0.0438323058,
0.0278734975,
-0.0033785466,
-0.0041753901,
0.0141561702,
-0.0134937605,
-0.0176259149,
0.0167747121,
-0.0341023803,
-0.017644899,
0.0414296314,
0.0244378019,
-0.1146564856,
-0.0110953031,
0.0573322177,
-0.0565882809,
-0.0203365088,
-0.0455756746,
0.0419788361,
-0.0308456738,
0.0395268686,
-0.0016379496,
-0.0314516462,
0.0078852139,
-0.0039719553,
-0.0263056196,
0.0085576605,
0.032577306,
0.0094088512,
0.0389696397,
-0.0456698313,
0.0111612789,
0.0001352132,
0.0151898516,
0.0955410004,
0.021270059,
-0.0223346762,
0.0282686092,
0.0142125906,
-0.0706334263,
-0.017043801,
-0.0428584032,
0.0073874546,
0.0457020886,
0.089997381,
0.0792719498,
0.0009381824,
0.0462560542,
-0.0243117083,
0.052464433,
-0.0512839854,
0.0494585894,
-0.0365487672,
0.026189182,
0.0085676406,
0.0210333485,
-0.0237866826,
-0.0211777538,
-0.051434014,
-0.0301676169,
0.0218836907,
0.0061404365,
-0.0189831443,
0.0325291716,
0.0614136457,
-0.0163023621,
0.0257457849,
-0.0385776199,
-0.0308732558,
0.0529112145,
-0.0000745739,
-0.0021182487,
-0.0169542227,
0.0119260717,
0.0550882965,
0.0431631841,
0.0266523864,
-0.0072222603,
0.0192127191,
0.0359697491,
-0.039590016,
0.0119934939,
-0.0691828653,
0.0003972331,
-0.0108274957,
0.0023680453,
0.0096356273,
-0.0159123931,
-0.0492995754,
0.0149936797,
-0.0387276821,
-0.0014011218,
-0.0123853507,
-0.0307067987,
0.0209293645,
0.0252861399,
-0.0401954576,
0.0327504352,
-0.0004863584,
-0.0585973524,
0.0262860339,
-0.005965488,
-0.0065399301,
0.060165897,
2.564e-7,
0.0537845716,
0.0167103745,
0.0203929823,
0.0134049011,
0.0022638685,
0.0461894572,
-0.036049813,
-0.00835077,
-0.0155814467,
-0.0448785052,
0.036254935,
0.0403044112,
0.0602964349,
0.0180363264,
-0.0024821474,
0.0252226777,
-0.0122488989,
-0.0291206483,
-0.0081628421,
0.0026280053,
0.1124820188,
0.0406332761,
-0.0186691191,
-0.010470394,
0.0329299234,
-0.041830603,
0.0793193281,
-0.0255943779,
-0.000482948,
-0.0062768697,
0.0285610668,
-0.0131266918,
-0.0108938087,
0.0506067686,
0.0034737196,
-0.0412823036,
0.063623175,
0.0605614521,
-0.0391010307,
-0.0277700499,
-0.0386142023,
-0.0100074979,
0.004674193,
-0.0727816075,
0.0789209306,
-0.0376821719,
-0.0047365618,
-0.0198575836,
-0.0449281856,
-0.0049803224,
0.0185932759,
-0.0147962719,
-0.024241833,
0.0475103781,
0.0345077664,
0.0004378481,
-0.0522420779,
-0.0564262681,
-0.0340602063,
-0.0076469015,
-0.0224543773,
-0.0213227775,
-0.0470153317,
-0.0147949308,
0.0146508683,
-0.053667821,
-0.0664380193,
1.890599451e-34,
0.0250928588,
-0.0118706189,
0.023108419,
-0.0135756163,
0.0312460568,
0.0310426764,
-0.0595280491,
-0.0060276142,
-0.0219136309,
-0.0241406597,
-0.0225692596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01326v1 | Better Together: Enhancing Generative Knowledge Graph Completion with Language Models and Neighborhood Information | 2023-11-02T15:38:39 | 2023-11-02T15:38:39 | Alla Chepurova, Aydar Bulatov, Yuri Kuratov, Mikhail Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Real-world Knowledge Graphs (KGs) often suffer from incompleteness, which
limits their potential performance. Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) techniques
aim to address this issue. However, traditional KGC methods are computationally
intensive and impractical for large-scale KGs, necessitating the learning of
dense node embeddings and computing pairwise distances. Generative
transformer-based language models (e.g., T5 and recent KGT5) offer a promising
solution as they can predict the tail nodes directly. In this study, we propose
to include node neighborhoods as additional information to improve KGC methods
based on language models. We examine the effects of this imputation and show
that, on both inductive and transductive Wikidata subsets, our method
outperforms KGT5 and conventional KGC approaches. We also provide an extensive
analysis of the impact of neighborhood on model prediction and show its
importance. Furthermore, we point the way to significantly improve KGC through
more effective neighborhood selection. | [
0.040958561,
0.0681376085,
-0.009535959,
0.0384051092,
-0.0117313657,
-0.0199875291,
-0.0390248597,
0.0112747261,
0.0836559162,
0.0087024029,
0.0343402028,
0.0201684032,
0.0325480476,
-0.0002984412,
0.0366776139,
-0.0265681986,
0.005689966,
0.0042251037,
-0.0332982503,
-0.0572624765,
-0.0430774763,
0.0369872116,
0.0173039678,
0.0207260121,
0.0097210873,
-0.0110093607,
0.030275289,
-0.0077446112,
0.0125529058,
0.0378011204,
0.0138998469,
0.021070173,
-0.0089304931,
-0.0285149943,
0.0000020437,
-0.0040550525,
0.0038424898,
0.0014412749,
-0.008150504,
-0.0215164125,
0.0096170539,
-0.0373221338,
0.0303757191,
0.0038700702,
-0.029343944,
-0.0447215736,
0.0272050705,
0.042772688,
-0.0294291805,
0.0314974487,
-0.0045485748,
-0.0251017362,
0.0465611853,
-0.021891363,
0.0297553092,
-0.0268948767,
0.0498748422,
0.0392500758,
-0.0063378401,
-0.0271656271,
-0.0379169732,
0.0418746322,
0.0028495644,
-0.0141501362,
0.0452095345,
0.0436268412,
0.0032350735,
0.004499855,
0.0575015619,
0.0696709231,
-0.0117387474,
-0.0041440772,
0.0197426453,
0.0146632483,
0.0034260945,
0.0827051327,
-0.0380877592,
-0.0201351866,
-0.010845826,
0.0144297611,
-0.0325436853,
-0.0248438455,
0.059593793,
-0.0298968181,
-0.0296561345,
0.1052459031,
0.0227086172,
0.0020712139,
-0.0343026295,
0.0271918755,
-0.0350893922,
-0.0407356955,
-0.0096440138,
-0.017676428,
0.0102914851,
0.0208336562,
0.000307409,
0.0458046533,
-0.0131153055,
-0.0032283072,
-0.0274707898,
0.0136765055,
0.0103700142,
0.0283976551,
-0.0359140858,
-0.007353323,
-0.0068322737,
-0.0200778134,
-0.0683231428,
-0.0445394777,
-0.0626672432,
-0.0116778249,
-0.0050600665,
0.0256519374,
-0.0243563391,
-0.0226376634,
-0.0335569866,
0.0382677056,
-0.0245059375,
0.0356449597,
0.0559760816,
0.0263182521,
-0.0193853956,
-0.0357996263,
-0.0020347212,
0.036924921,
-0.0176847503,
0.0395814888,
-0.0580015518,
0.048335094,
-0.0091278264,
-0.0098765343,
0.0370925553,
-0.0298333466,
-0.0091018481,
0.0188431535,
0.0419269875,
-0.0048006638,
-0.0438120104,
-0.0118528362,
-0.0233004857,
-0.0336525254,
0.0086285044,
-0.0565923415,
0.0563348942,
0.0510126613,
-0.0016731056,
-0.0496017262,
-0.002934397,
-0.0033743731,
-0.0717187747,
0.0512524173,
-0.0564069413,
0.023087915,
0.0191799533,
-0.0181143451,
-0.0126818195,
0.0248070788,
0.0077914656,
0.0216529705,
0.0334547944,
-0.0038530841,
-0.0374539755,
0.0279165469,
0.0542332418,
0.0192879513,
0.0002507418,
0.0044193962,
0.0105611105,
-0.015710324,
0.0246707108,
0.0011617444,
-0.0357606746,
0.0136674624,
0.0430991612,
0.0145908268,
0.0247608926,
0.0167993251,
0.0372521877,
0.0067937057,
-0.0438841544,
0.0183703378,
-0.0262647513,
-0.0149951475,
-0.0705633163,
0.0400680713,
0.0193463713,
0.0171200745,
-0.0109858252,
-0.0150126116,
0.0245042946,
-0.030125564,
0.0278724972,
0.0283990316,
0.0851851553,
0.0385800228,
-0.0138578862,
0.0572117157,
0.0671555623,
-0.0345864631,
0.0452650525,
0.0265076682,
0.005223216,
0.0687055811,
0.0550115183,
-0.0198974796,
-0.0133937495,
0.0211308897,
-0.0190086961,
-0.0026551802,
-0.0261188429,
-0.0574927479,
-0.0131090153,
-0.0328471437,
-0.0695701316,
0.0272427518,
0.0042007309,
-0.0176051259,
0.0334627628,
0.0275678728,
0.0419257395,
-0.139590323,
-0.0164391976,
0.0041974275,
-0.0683342144,
0.0276667569,
0.0106108095,
0.007461335,
-0.0076477895,
0.0251882859,
0.0065849302,
-0.0161195938,
0.0301676784,
-0.0251129437,
-0.0535204895,
-0.00560953,
-0.0019263723,
-0.0635005608,
0.0477005392,
-0.0446391217,
0.0292410068,
-0.0062375176,
-0.0296100434,
-0.0344677828,
0.0235670879,
-0.0131148333,
0.0776490346,
-0.0110134603,
0.0098350393,
0.0075999484,
-0.021107832,
0.0095289284,
0.0925990865,
-0.0245551821,
0.0253215786,
0.000293205,
-0.0362776443,
-0.0029147137,
0.0334261581,
-0.0358846523,
-0.0139867468,
-0.0090321572,
-0.0022045923,
0.0528883375,
-0.0536250174,
-0.0455064587,
-0.0294030048,
-0.1235223413,
0.0001462965,
0.0295603145,
-0.0122288391,
-0.0229792539,
0.0332124382,
0.0310700852,
0.0021982759,
-0.0033985286,
0.0161534138,
-0.0276067574,
-0.0016743394,
-0.0082341442,
-0.0035539861,
-0.0100245951,
-0.0041430923,
-0.0486627147,
-0.0116759045,
0.086907424,
-0.0190934781,
0.0094346991,
-0.0270141177,
0.0443915762,
-0.0449802913,
0.0213298853,
-0.0502555333,
0.0042603835,
-0.023410311,
-0.0057045165,
0.0428414457,
-0.0128422612,
-0.0142081622,
-0.0168440249,
0.0279682465,
-0.0118803736,
-0.0490401424,
-0.0161828063,
-0.0626533404,
0.0034330371,
-0.0463952832,
-0.0248766746,
-0.0627972856,
0.0131109599,
0.0269686934,
-0.0569184162,
-0.0859227851,
0.0176013485,
-0.0079855882,
0.0251206663,
-0.0222200882,
0.0208292697,
0.0323386416,
0.0046192533,
-0.0213026404,
-0.0199165177,
0.0561607406,
-0.0136213275,
0.0247210842,
0.022412017,
0.0266511161,
-0.0072652786,
0.0390519239,
0.0326393768,
0.0044858633,
0.0272736736,
-0.0047111772,
-0.0387374088,
0.0344169661,
0.0317242518,
-0.0034716856,
0.0204118099,
0.0230582971,
0.0338100865,
0.0428059474,
0.0046320134,
-0.030646218,
0.0119699556,
0.0163351521,
0.0147341685,
0.0676743016,
-0.0329993404,
0.0268359147,
-0.0126726469,
0.009582187,
0.0234064367,
0.0261834413,
-0.021012973,
-0.0298664942,
0.0372062214,
0.0630031452,
-0.0576184206,
-0.0172813497,
0.0033856158,
-0.0218021572,
0.0202232953,
0.0389060527,
-0.0213982649,
-0.0086929975,
-0.0186434574,
0.0272760224,
-0.0377647243,
-0.0448725969,
-0.003961232,
0.0057119154,
-0.0005360389,
0.034234982,
0.108318992,
0.0133468937,
-0.0420781188,
0.0060400749,
-0.0120000448,
0.0197405778,
0.0347863473,
0.004122708,
-0.0854330212,
0.0157333855,
-0.0005807412,
0.0392907299,
0.0576335005,
-0.0597142056,
0.0327062048,
-0.1019077897,
0.0157251451,
0.0342631452,
0.0020312292,
-0.0403565466,
-0.0490512885,
0.0013282499,
-0.0129769994,
-0.0382080078,
-0.0130499732,
0.0089076674,
-0.0033535722,
-0.0163718536,
-0.0447833091,
-0.0708004534,
0.0415000841,
-0.0232309271,
0.0500786081,
-0.0047701364,
0.0381804258,
-0.0027043712,
-0.0148812048,
-0.0376779027,
0.0069574853,
-0.0196383167,
0.0080251675,
0.052313216,
-0.0002134176,
0.0019735936,
0.0029224823,
0.0203444026,
-0.0514459498,
-0.0208623596,
-0.0051496308,
0.1179552153,
0.0335932374,
-0.0604008883,
-0.0031145958,
-0.0343332849,
0.0110114319,
0.0668292418,
-0.0114653874,
-0.0141154956,
0.0242910255,
-0.0157741178,
0.0372568816,
0.0222697631,
-0.0129544036,
0.0050359154,
0.0016787768,
0.001042172,
-0.0642063916,
-0.0376457982,
0.060597349,
-0.0095297294,
0.0022046252,
0.0505937375,
0.0215849746,
-0.0473853648,
-0.066966787,
0.0149673652,
-0.0496915206,
-0.0292827934,
0.0093440525,
-0.002349114,
0.0309577323,
-0.0440627038,
-0.0351969749,
0.0000346934,
-0.0418427959,
-0.0626303926,
-0.0564590655,
0.0472669415,
0.00341583,
0.0909238383,
-0.0516254008,
-0.0207692888,
0.0504894182,
0.0590011254,
-0.0434762537,
-0.0032990193,
0.0140080508,
-0.0552548058,
0.0168598909,
0.0639126226,
-0.0733798072,
0.0082490267,
0.005423977,
0.0580146462,
-0.0371030942,
-0.0440784618,
0.0104393996,
0.025414018,
0.0362960845,
-0.0131739005,
0.0175516382,
-0.0677407086,
0.0137941604,
-0.0206943378,
-0.0316140652,
-0.0438157357,
-0.0083679678,
0.0535186566,
0.010878427,
0.0187116042,
-0.0151993902,
-0.0272784624,
0.0447858647,
-0.0565462187,
-0.0456839837,
0.0361553654,
-0.0181493517,
0.0775689334,
-0.0065555479,
-0.0130903022,
-0.0229870882,
0.0164194629,
0.0044593038,
-0.0410409048,
-0.0044185901,
0.0008870258,
-0.0204152092,
-0.043444816,
-0.0156159941,
-0.0079321368,
-0.0179113559,
-0.0601850748,
0.0509502292,
0.0528473221,
-0.0058572665,
0.0509286821,
-0.0192232002,
-0.0283416472,
-0.0272408091,
0.0326458514,
0.021113351,
-0.0409967527,
-0.0053575309,
0.0156930462,
-0.0375964679,
0.0495683923,
0.0911048353,
0.0218888205,
0.0780362636,
-0.0309965592,
-0.0554029085,
-0.0340385474,
-0.0529393367,
0.0060675163,
0.0201396476,
-0.0231736153,
0.0446340777,
-0.0354890339,
-0.1101821736,
0.0228971485,
-0.0496046916,
-0.0620432757,
0.0132858288,
0.0034953279,
0.0377994739,
0.0097684162,
-0.0340889208,
-0.0434026122,
-0.0009241515,
0.0076442356,
-0.0102098286,
0.0083031086,
-6.259127587e-33,
-0.0178677458,
-0.0449493043,
0.0106626581,
0.0159715265,
-0.0078795645,
-0.0187692847,
-0.0084845982,
-0.0224475153,
-0.0120504899,
0.04282647,
-0.0164642446,
0.0179712549,
-0.0100391265,
0.0221174769,
0.0029675327,
0.0394550078,
0.0365541875,
0.0398266204,
0.0138097219,
0.0331350453,
0.0393884927,
0.0244596303,
0.078780733,
-0.0840872899,
0.059509363,
-0.0413071662,
0.0127872499,
-0.0124510992,
0.0433662497,
0.0283820815,
-0.0235600471,
0.0713218451,
0.019709833,
-0.0187560376,
-0.0011245888,
-0.0625774935,
-0.0857664719,
-0.0189809632,
0.0206032805,
-0.0152966911,
-0.0206928793,
-0.0246638656,
0.0432556756,
-0.0006651865,
0.0551731996,
-0.0748528242,
0.053271208,
-0.0253237188,
-0.081473425,
-0.0295451116,
-0.0464421734,
0.0261514839,
0.0040193954,
0.0077166753,
-0.0209348034,
0.014154329,
0.0371947847,
-0.0238456037,
-0.0830428526,
0.0011083425,
0.0230446011,
0.0401088074,
0.0324330665,
-0.0388247706,
0.0324411541,
0.009761015,
-0.0160116982,
0.0019103814,
-0.0195741728,
-0.0163055044,
-0.0051987227,
0.0388218574,
-0.0135661662,
0.0142345196,
-0.0226807036,
-0.0532075055,
-0.0630539283,
0.0077179954,
-0.0525692105,
0.035697829,
0.0116025982,
0.0055243536,
-0.0346555002,
-0.0472783074,
-0.0449151583,
-0.0588644706,
-0.0141095733,
-0.0385810658,
-0.0086255549,
0.0039530839,
-0.0357698761,
-0.0115392664,
-0.0098941289,
-0.0866956934,
-0.0072439746,
0.0839066729,
-0.0238658674,
0.0102557633,
0.0046703885,
0.0313105658,
-0.0044048121,
-0.0397806317,
-0.0013185628,
-0.0217020363,
-0.0057167714,
0.0339435302,
0.0187762436,
0.0448854007,
-0.0067776493,
-0.0172183309,
-0.0164340269,
-0.0343248732,
-0.0291529316,
-0.0135485167,
0.0642084926,
0.0359810852,
0.0152852982,
0.0160423052,
0.0715836734,
0.0552410632,
0.0183059778,
0.0147825731,
0.0370087288,
-0.017504489,
0.0053219409,
-0.0173266027,
-0.0160131585,
0.0229001399,
0.0296465307,
0.0104123959,
-0.0234418642,
-0.0102899112,
2.796e-7,
0.0385099202,
0.0187779944,
0.0170580987,
0.0527646914,
-0.019416498,
-0.0019761457,
0.04099489,
0.0156107228,
0.0239083692,
-0.0236838423,
0.0401231796,
-0.0277830139,
0.0061922935,
0.024143843,
-0.1041756049,
-0.000249123,
-0.0357672311,
-0.0137963938,
-0.0163782891,
-0.0287781563,
0.0011225698,
0.0531426631,
0.0511296466,
0.0164688621,
0.0036856011,
-0.0506959483,
0.0764037818,
-0.0205434896,
-0.0165784545,
0.03959959,
0.0360240899,
0.0033933076,
0.0036850164,
0.0372624509,
-0.0253946073,
0.0475281887,
0.0463256948,
0.0483202301,
-0.001414877,
0.0078200269,
-0.0045383386,
-0.0531930365,
0.0326157212,
-0.0627323613,
0.0922133848,
-0.0604709312,
0.0251913462,
0.068468444,
-0.0697688013,
-0.0236178096,
-0.0101891384,
-0.0289711002,
0.0257599968,
0.0022633614,
0.0099175582,
0.0125253545,
-0.0074841566,
-0.0498489775,
0.0002044492,
0.0208185259,
-0.036718484,
-0.0478576869,
0.0277245604,
-0.0551296957,
0.0137423258,
-0.0214740057,
0.055333931,
2.447198552e-34,
0.0202618539,
0.0209870413,
-0.0088387914,
-0.0114000486,
0.0288416911,
-0.0587878488,
-0.0095331408,
0.0203376431,
0.0210208986,
-0.097292982,
-0.0251681749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01487v1 | What Makes for Good Visual Instructions? Synthesizing Complex Visual Reasoning Instructions for Visual Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-02T15:36:12 | 2023-11-02T15:36:12 | Yifan Du, Hangyu Guo, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jinpeng Wang, Chuyuan Wang, Mingchen Cai, Ruihua Song, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual instruction tuning is an essential approach to improving the zero-shot
generalization capability of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs). A surge
of visual instruction datasets with various focuses and characteristics have
been proposed recently, enabling MLLMs to achieve surprising results on
evaluation benchmarks. To develop more capable MLLMs, in this paper, we aim to
investigate a more fundamental question: ``what makes for good visual
instructions?''. By conducting a comprehensive empirical study, we find that
instructions focused on complex visual reasoning tasks are particularly
effective in improving the performance of MLLMs on evaluation benchmarks.
Building upon this finding, we design a systematic approach to automatically
creating high-quality complex visual reasoning instructions. Our approach
employs a synthesis-complication-reformulation paradigm, leveraging multiple
stages to gradually increase the complexity of the instructions while
guaranteeing quality. Based on this approach, we create the synthetic visual
reasoning instruction dataset consisting of 32K examples, namely ComVint, and
fine-tune four MLLMs on it. Experimental results demonstrate that our dataset
consistently enhances the performance of all the compared MLLMs, e.g.,
improving the performance of MiniGPT-4 and BLIP-2 on MME-Cognition by 32.6% and
28.8%, respectively. Our code and data are publicly available at the link:
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/ComVint. | [
0.0059166257,
0.0421897918,
-0.0208054427,
0.035939794,
-0.049346894,
0.0390127823,
0.0363615938,
-0.0002918179,
-0.0115277022,
-0.062855497,
-0.0232761875,
-0.008257472,
0.0117582846,
0.0017019574,
0.0501166135,
-0.0694878548,
0.0278118514,
-0.0704764649,
-0.0152424695,
-0.0074097747,
0.0002554696,
-0.0055330405,
-0.0113811912,
0.0353671163,
-0.0087905359,
-0.0415682644,
-0.0182722826,
0.0161903612,
0.0223510582,
-0.0065888567,
-0.0560744219,
0.047721155,
0.0604884103,
-0.0119721452,
0.0000020416,
-0.0272329301,
0.0138833066,
-0.0085851811,
0.0107542593,
0.0269219838,
0.0004986121,
-0.0467066281,
0.0041211271,
0.0122825205,
-0.0068376097,
-0.038506791,
0.0567226596,
0.025478866,
0.0712189972,
0.0731380656,
-0.0119541651,
-0.0324885659,
0.0069280821,
0.0008011419,
0.0509539321,
-0.0248980727,
0.0211066082,
0.0681836307,
0.0145617444,
-0.0096906209,
-0.0391502306,
0.0403165929,
0.0547500513,
-0.0052520535,
-0.0340494178,
0.0332919843,
-0.0070130937,
-0.0467478931,
-0.023728963,
0.0785248578,
-0.0315587558,
0.0018332358,
-0.0253915265,
-0.000437442,
0.0090828519,
0.0058788885,
-0.064091742,
0.0581210665,
-0.0072646099,
0.0069414382,
-0.0158010069,
-0.0405039787,
0.0056610969,
-0.0194281489,
-0.0196199659,
-0.0023293514,
0.0244831089,
-0.0021486606,
-0.0210305974,
-0.0174964201,
-0.073113814,
-0.0559985638,
-0.0515572689,
0.0526036546,
-0.0291442722,
0.0048418972,
-0.0265161768,
-0.001200019,
-0.0173394177,
0.002229658,
0.0962940827,
0.034257926,
-0.0223464128,
0.0623985678,
-0.0490566865,
0.0968606099,
-0.0114486804,
0.0543531403,
-0.0243865661,
-0.0148823848,
-0.048627425,
0.0165584683,
-0.0388012677,
0.0065214853,
-0.0443200655,
-0.0280725155,
-0.022990251,
0.0099859796,
-0.0290539917,
0.043179132,
-0.0000161933,
-0.0198423471,
-0.0043065404,
-0.0240196064,
-0.028970411,
0.0236389171,
-0.0546258017,
-0.0000851366,
-0.0188006312,
-0.0405713879,
-0.0028053198,
0.0489198081,
0.0075132591,
-0.0160673764,
0.0183603596,
0.0628845245,
-0.0351298675,
-0.0205173157,
-0.0554574355,
-0.0220391471,
0.0063929283,
-0.0840665698,
0.0633451417,
-0.0629079416,
0.0060175299,
-0.0025070028,
-0.0064206268,
-0.0022785531,
-0.0152386073,
0.0199180078,
-0.0026065975,
0.0711680651,
0.0155054824,
0.0105070639,
-0.0246986877,
0.0170183536,
0.0052762432,
0.0940834954,
0.024903832,
0.0204578675,
0.0176810864,
-0.0475113355,
0.0404676087,
0.0431647412,
0.0009110061,
-0.0091979681,
-0.0574521981,
0.020375466,
-0.0031753103,
0.014159915,
0.0105919829,
0.0439955518,
-0.0518040508,
-0.0166298449,
0.037243776,
0.0060805851,
0.0399527662,
-0.0271631628,
0.0873870775,
-0.0059612435,
0.0041746125,
0.0121817365,
-0.0743901879,
0.0625342503,
-0.0325848982,
0.0323865749,
-0.0346441232,
0.0324238762,
-0.0406633466,
-0.0414395332,
-0.0073284735,
0.0048071244,
0.0054419502,
0.0327452198,
0.0413912311,
0.0098810801,
-0.0505843014,
-0.0085671488,
0.0199382529,
-0.0246573593,
-0.0395565554,
-0.0492076688,
0.0411457233,
0.0574580207,
0.0267207082,
0.021016242,
-0.015512987,
0.0125629408,
0.0261674412,
0.0092669753,
0.0179208741,
-0.0128450878,
0.0206194874,
-0.0764912367,
-0.0281150863,
-0.045064453,
0.0100990944,
0.0152173918,
0.0386186875,
-0.0347309262,
-0.0053513912,
-0.035199739,
0.0315700807,
0.0194239188,
0.0356565677,
-0.0049577132,
-0.0376303345,
0.0216163415,
0.0070289066,
-0.01543839,
-0.0031213218,
-0.0016874686,
0.0207232349,
-0.0260823164,
0.0246035289,
-0.008880361,
-0.0374486335,
-0.0673745871,
0.0059205568,
-0.0570488498,
-0.0365794078,
0.0169330109,
-0.0546434522,
-0.0249990914,
0.0305741634,
-0.0115406569,
-0.0011706994,
-0.0182335004,
0.0153197153,
0.0027789571,
-0.0041982485,
-0.0189774521,
0.0615155213,
-0.0232734773,
0.0013705227,
0.0469048843,
0.0310641602,
0.009534114,
-0.0280287117,
-0.0023793266,
0.0113900481,
0.0024689671,
0.016505355,
-0.0259719081,
0.0376117937,
-0.0568211861,
-0.0132208979,
-0.1075425148,
0.0017705065,
-0.0364470258,
-0.022242602,
0.027633626,
-0.0030734993,
0.0035707839,
-0.0018894271,
0.0027981985,
0.0408340991,
-0.0173607562,
0.0243605878,
0.008116792,
-0.0031905044,
-0.037213318,
0.0089474414,
-0.0338188559,
-0.0059638089,
0.0526483692,
0.0017468171,
0.0445772968,
-0.0401339456,
0.0093125217,
-0.0177225582,
0.0310991555,
-0.0315075554,
-0.0265185479,
0.0358299688,
-0.0374627225,
0.0410551652,
0.1126499474,
-0.0159123037,
0.0248690583,
0.0236988701,
-0.0082642585,
-0.0326204412,
0.0320304185,
0.0095003583,
-0.0376157127,
-0.0271519572,
-0.038483493,
-0.0518943369,
0.05116418,
-0.0354746245,
0.0196690951,
-0.0871224105,
0.0328597575,
0.0170175806,
-0.048578091,
-0.0407228768,
0.0272900164,
0.0231124051,
0.0300430786,
-0.0472074002,
-0.0829859897,
0.0486588776,
-0.0328902677,
-0.0179754905,
0.0028940665,
0.0243779849,
-0.0286153909,
0.0789859146,
0.0268663596,
0.0139821004,
-0.0112230936,
-0.0063272682,
-0.0732890069,
-0.0155211445,
0.0372344442,
0.0046947398,
0.0622744635,
-0.0877990574,
-0.0208985545,
-0.0371931531,
-0.0146905612,
-0.0222633164,
0.0190931614,
-0.0185633171,
0.0143687613,
0.0068002013,
-0.0220069624,
-0.0329584926,
0.0235172305,
0.0288363378,
-0.0075782365,
-0.0147661306,
0.0048193461,
-0.0266328491,
-0.004662225,
0.0484215617,
0.0342297927,
-0.0206262805,
-0.0549988598,
0.0260336511,
0.0479614809,
0.0304831918,
0.0037131158,
-0.0395401381,
0.0591120273,
0.0145450504,
0.0469748192,
-0.0096242549,
0.0496013798,
0.0873045027,
-0.0654499084,
0.010122247,
0.0909835175,
0.0101159085,
-0.0183816031,
-0.017647557,
0.0217143092,
0.0605510175,
0.0392690115,
0.0191210918,
-0.0759841204,
-0.0552257821,
-0.0053816438,
-0.0110717313,
0.0059115309,
-0.005720038,
-0.0205302034,
-0.0998116881,
0.075583905,
0.0026387651,
-0.0271581709,
-0.0555752181,
-0.0144059202,
-0.017978048,
0.0039444617,
0.0084786369,
0.0166135542,
-0.0155587494,
0.0035838459,
0.0001398231,
-0.0010723032,
-0.064293243,
0.0487554558,
-0.0133884642,
0.022110831,
0.0285568833,
-0.0162075274,
0.013404103,
-0.0515915304,
0.0308245253,
0.0113383485,
0.0149913095,
-0.0311593749,
0.0563366897,
0.0063410425,
-0.0377154984,
0.0083549591,
0.0335189104,
0.0099861659,
-0.0320004448,
0.0015607155,
0.0594525076,
0.0018628552,
-0.0350058787,
-0.0138395252,
-0.0006137187,
-0.0405043028,
0.044931218,
0.0489218906,
-0.0266091377,
-0.0373432823,
-0.0298344027,
-0.0238888916,
-0.0716367885,
-0.0309495311,
0.0159652103,
-0.0001264243,
-0.0015388789,
-0.0389760695,
-0.023687413,
0.0897350311,
0.0886393264,
-0.0227325205,
-0.056768842,
-0.0044712578,
0.0084551256,
-0.0533808023,
0.0558974147,
-0.0305209048,
0.0262938906,
-0.0511894152,
-0.0225052666,
-0.0012392872,
-0.0170460306,
-0.0070403307,
0.0061980956,
-0.0759860873,
-0.0393710509,
-0.0399882346,
0.0587840341,
0.0192087069,
0.0690211579,
0.0196854901,
-0.0641680062,
0.0131968139,
0.0051647169,
0.0451019742,
0.0149915973,
0.0253651366,
-0.0344600081,
0.0147130219,
0.0193916708,
-0.0147258528,
0.0378362834,
0.0330513678,
0.0375590771,
-0.0068561914,
0.0714107305,
0.0307593178,
0.0267608408,
0.0186811741,
-0.01779861,
0.0225832835,
-0.0115206037,
0.0206840336,
-0.0309126843,
-0.017259635,
-0.0728475749,
0.0137823075,
0.0167709272,
0.0026711691,
0.026353104,
-0.005163813,
-0.003236901,
-0.0052661188,
-0.0391282588,
0.0260863584,
0.0053735976,
0.0034355575,
0.0286557414,
0.0095220516,
-0.0059754099,
0.0170662384,
-0.0248396881,
0.030886814,
0.0074225967,
0.0942050442,
0.0194259938,
0.0020410756,
-0.0509771183,
0.0120402751,
-0.0155642573,
-0.0709123537,
0.0054035829,
0.0565169603,
0.0892485902,
0.0069707106,
0.0276915058,
-0.0179282911,
-0.0186462421,
-0.0059579439,
0.0357419774,
0.0248682406,
-0.0526124537,
0.0499320216,
0.0637095496,
0.0194733199,
-0.0442411266,
0.063799873,
-0.0054148668,
0.0300681237,
-0.0300621856,
0.018234605,
-0.0499897264,
-0.0380674414,
0.0191893522,
0.0014289402,
0.0160012208,
0.0205285568,
-0.0480827764,
-0.0878868699,
-0.032878384,
0.0411109179,
-0.0013549316,
0.0254608784,
0.042750936,
0.0389565863,
0.0010437655,
-0.038590882,
-0.0092880651,
-0.0182245541,
0.0149586359,
-0.0036724918,
-0.0029478732,
-6.225875055e-33,
-0.0188287757,
-0.0108391736,
0.0769986883,
-0.0464478023,
0.0260716695,
0.0044668973,
-0.0182634201,
0.0048829662,
-0.0178959481,
0.0179609228,
0.0295076873,
-0.0099007003,
-0.0029078834,
0.0340601392,
-0.0170920417,
-0.0206558425,
0.0081767477,
0.0030582917,
-0.0584718436,
0.0121787069,
-0.0057017133,
-0.0364781097,
0.0227896478,
-0.0296744052,
-0.0363457203,
0.0414068364,
-0.0243095439,
0.0307411626,
-0.0409715921,
0.0891797617,
0.0167619307,
0.0178709142,
0.0213826764,
0.0081760176,
-0.0306022801,
0.0114321224,
-0.0381070971,
-0.027034048,
0.0414939784,
0.0198507607,
-0.1008640528,
-0.0167871639,
0.0395825431,
-0.0187383592,
-0.0020253791,
-0.0579094924,
0.0236257445,
-0.0101681175,
-0.0082271174,
0.0266186204,
-0.041602768,
-0.0003264366,
-0.031417124,
-0.0303831268,
0.014858366,
0.0411963053,
0.0138259772,
0.0455031134,
-0.0119440388,
0.0467987284,
0.0292112119,
0.0113344854,
0.0905894041,
0.0514479242,
0.0442074612,
0.0234863125,
0.0499212742,
-0.0169378724,
-0.0367110632,
0.0110529307,
0.0289025884,
0.0834596008,
0.0545116253,
0.0291763376,
0.0173332915,
0.0355466716,
-0.0550133921,
-0.0242353864,
-0.0461368002,
0.066171661,
0.0130618084,
0.0113395266,
-0.0241980553,
-0.020035537,
-0.0508531183,
0.022108322,
-0.0480437428,
0.0041173021,
0.0526005104,
0.0237865224,
-0.0307941157,
-0.014344085,
0.0498374701,
-0.0292274375,
-0.0101851262,
-0.0064662625,
-0.0474481992,
0.0673787966,
0.0056631104,
0.0267331805,
-0.0356449336,
-0.0265189633,
0.058357738,
-0.0262621958,
0.0160537418,
0.0168258157,
0.0396515168,
0.027385721,
-0.0405890681,
-0.0227189139,
-0.0606258437,
0.0063731563,
-0.0063109105,
-0.0323434956,
0.0219944827,
0.0031066318,
-0.0337256417,
0.0239087977,
0.0065783528,
-0.0317642614,
-0.0170580111,
-0.0258588195,
-0.0151487868,
0.0338506922,
-0.0113738626,
-0.0009508253,
-0.0481327474,
-0.039628163,
0.0279471874,
-0.0489605144,
-0.0192039721,
0.04544916,
2.664e-7,
0.0224201586,
0.0257736612,
-0.0062479875,
0.0654606819,
0.0237418469,
0.0430104323,
-0.0333326645,
-0.0329277366,
0.0171563271,
-0.0342920832,
-0.0136354687,
0.0733851269,
0.0123954751,
-0.0067683337,
-0.0100750271,
0.0444595218,
0.0146451509,
-0.0266762264,
-0.0533486493,
0.032823924,
0.0749268532,
0.0570008419,
-0.0207991768,
-0.0098857451,
0.0581574924,
-0.0322979614,
0.0523432344,
-0.0415090621,
-0.0119735431,
-0.0025435726,
-0.0043156035,
0.0438651033,
0.0065640961,
0.0455992073,
0.0191213097,
-0.0415531881,
-0.0181652289,
0.0660834759,
-0.0032246434,
-0.0198738091,
-0.0182921868,
-0.0217094757,
-0.042896755,
-0.0348671004,
0.1010516584,
-0.0671966448,
-0.0308463201,
0.0018835489,
-0.0275471564,
0.005439112,
0.013757199,
-0.0082691144,
-0.0335039981,
0.0137141421,
0.0244516302,
-0.0233846605,
0.0000733885,
-0.0651493594,
-0.0006405544,
0.0104181962,
-0.0301054679,
-0.0515727289,
-0.0557787605,
-0.0162908398,
0.0273643229,
-0.0210967045,
-0.0663327202,
2.623384492e-34,
0.0353916064,
-0.0305966958,
0.03968779,
0.0029310635,
0.0387048796,
-0.0441509038,
-0.0718422681,
-0.0073781637,
0.005827128,
-0.0787099898,
-0.0210106019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01307v1 | The Effect of Scaling, Retrieval Augmentation and Form on the Factual Consistency of Language Models | 2023-11-02T15:20:11 | 2023-11-02T15:20:11 | Lovisa Hagström, Denitsa Saynova, Tobias Norlund, Moa Johansson, Richard Johansson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) make natural interfaces to factual knowledge,
but their usefulness is limited by their tendency to deliver inconsistent
answers to semantically equivalent questions. For example, a model might
predict both "Anne Redpath passed away in Edinburgh." and "Anne Redpath's life
ended in London." In this work, we identify potential causes of inconsistency
and evaluate the effectiveness of two mitigation strategies: up-scaling and
augmenting the LM with a retrieval corpus. Our results on the LLaMA and Atlas
models show that both strategies reduce inconsistency while retrieval
augmentation is considerably more efficient. We further consider and
disentangle the consistency contributions of different components of Atlas. For
all LMs evaluated we find that syntactical form and other evaluation task
artifacts impact consistency. Taken together, our results provide a better
understanding of the factors affecting the factual consistency of language
models. | [
0.0743188858,
0.0609560199,
-0.040553797,
0.0577573776,
-0.0253724623,
-0.0055619436,
-0.0022795731,
0.0069841216,
0.0030032883,
-0.0327163637,
-0.0228244364,
-0.0706615448,
0.0153652923,
-0.0058540571,
-0.0061732875,
-0.0449817143,
0.0490539446,
-0.0092709763,
-0.0060867937,
-0.0241311826,
0.0178444609,
0.0014817852,
0.0346966572,
0.0290892255,
0.0108340979,
0.0177131649,
0.0165182035,
0.0035443681,
-0.0095225545,
-0.0066612996,
-0.0172204431,
0.0138080679,
0.0152967768,
0.067473419,
0.0000019015,
-0.0585187599,
0.008848398,
-0.009746152,
-0.0576717705,
0.036737062,
0.0318038277,
-0.0025327373,
0.008973741,
-0.0002153203,
0.0041494789,
-0.0486802272,
0.0221902169,
0.0267676897,
0.0205952805,
0.0446700603,
0.0103701157,
-0.0356751345,
0.0508363321,
-0.0459976122,
0.0004882808,
-0.0253481101,
0.0398669615,
0.069146432,
-0.0165482946,
0.0638467446,
-0.024262974,
0.0559472665,
-0.0001563648,
0.0096340347,
0.0107764918,
0.0379745401,
-0.023378253,
-0.0202966779,
0.0388827026,
0.0263820272,
0.0496817045,
-0.0491578877,
-0.0006839286,
0.0127796885,
-0.0076609743,
0.058643274,
-0.0542384945,
0.0347892232,
-0.0080209468,
0.007537338,
0.0272268616,
-0.0195300933,
0.043709822,
0.0304692481,
-0.0439203866,
0.0649132133,
0.0278614834,
-0.0572021157,
-0.0398283601,
0.0124968672,
-0.035802234,
-0.0518397093,
0.0064775459,
-0.0009727683,
-0.0221893918,
0.0259031411,
-0.0017030641,
-0.0092124026,
0.0439058132,
-0.0846236423,
0.0224996693,
0.0124119231,
-0.0499635674,
0.0493578129,
0.0019985777,
0.073463656,
-0.0071831467,
0.0012400878,
-0.0533968844,
-0.0015184556,
-0.0106723672,
-0.0168426726,
-0.0187062137,
0.028750604,
-0.0207939819,
0.0038377298,
-0.0303047206,
-0.0029287287,
-0.0079065375,
0.0063099833,
0.0078925947,
0.0016267486,
-0.0395011939,
0.0005898476,
-0.0881713703,
0.0512559675,
-0.0269174036,
0.0398052819,
-0.022243578,
-0.0503787808,
0.0037833741,
-0.0058555552,
-0.0277064666,
-0.0288705882,
0.0041059684,
-0.0016247687,
0.0257427245,
-0.0065287147,
-0.0034364988,
-0.0163583569,
-0.0348887108,
-0.0870671198,
-0.0303002317,
-0.0503363796,
0.0271679088,
0.0071102837,
-0.0185797438,
-0.0747413337,
0.0116193835,
0.0151948612,
-0.0517695099,
0.0635415316,
0.0132603338,
0.0177784469,
0.0575033985,
0.0101339594,
0.0265192166,
0.0221271571,
0.0229298491,
0.0043811342,
0.067747727,
0.0308340136,
-0.0040802378,
0.0085744988,
0.0206715558,
0.0014942094,
-0.0176980309,
0.0398296379,
0.0081273513,
0.0735324472,
0.0246728268,
0.0795149803,
-0.0274737366,
-0.0367671251,
0.0506024212,
0.0044220509,
0.0368518308,
-0.0211770777,
0.0401107073,
-0.0052686231,
0.0245717838,
0.0407316238,
-0.0731808171,
-0.0336206891,
-0.0052965819,
0.0244885068,
0.0219486989,
0.0417625383,
-0.0198422298,
-0.0445608236,
-0.0577203259,
0.0303631127,
-0.0053040814,
-0.0001849409,
0.0322449245,
-0.0110066608,
0.0292658638,
0.0965608358,
0.0308557265,
-0.0479903258,
0.0068983291,
-0.0477947183,
0.0228984226,
0.0231307503,
0.0750135332,
-0.0113864262,
-0.0480822027,
0.0396554656,
-0.0209927466,
0.0330991633,
0.0474231169,
0.0055629313,
-0.029668428,
-0.0391271599,
0.0093825422,
0.0320448615,
0.0376079381,
-0.0317916647,
0.0167661775,
0.0064991396,
0.0249106716,
-0.0742847621,
-0.01268062,
0.035014797,
-0.0665601268,
-0.048022639,
-0.0479062758,
-0.0068521765,
0.0151759638,
0.0021562839,
-0.0236842334,
0.0244126953,
0.039474681,
0.0004542293,
-0.0022047309,
-0.006458512,
-0.0353891477,
-0.0265308451,
0.0515245609,
0.0352009237,
0.0118289692,
0.0282610301,
-0.0110310232,
-0.0237982795,
0.0143239945,
-0.0374739394,
0.0285592079,
-0.0605804361,
0.040412385,
-0.0122573087,
0.0081561543,
-0.0615039431,
0.0842566416,
-0.0210085791,
0.0227116551,
-0.0098957866,
0.0174386296,
0.0032212764,
-0.0593954735,
-0.03396523,
0.0303059332,
0.0252304673,
0.0188886207,
0.0357734822,
-0.0505396128,
-0.0180909,
-0.0351147763,
-0.0643857196,
0.0169928297,
-0.022428453,
0.0048111039,
-0.0009064191,
0.0153296981,
-0.0102323936,
-0.0011401387,
-0.0116115725,
-0.0162773505,
0.021840306,
0.0474158153,
0.0390464514,
0.012277171,
-0.0068643494,
-0.0447394289,
-0.0332787372,
-0.0122496709,
0.0292807072,
-0.0067781885,
0.0005349024,
-0.0464659557,
0.0227433164,
-0.0938130692,
0.0238866005,
-0.0203796681,
0.0100997714,
0.0075918972,
-0.0141975703,
0.025548121,
0.018547859,
-0.0006560251,
0.0368998423,
0.0535986163,
-0.0126795089,
-0.0625268295,
0.004121677,
-0.0422638692,
-0.0220597573,
-0.0029926517,
-0.0530162305,
-0.0191079844,
0.0302195419,
0.0086168144,
-0.0264302138,
-0.0173782185,
0.0153938187,
-0.0380992852,
-0.0033057604,
-0.0259747002,
-0.0192818474,
-0.0080214376,
0.0445657372,
-0.0172098372,
-0.0278901123,
0.046521809,
-0.0593348853,
0.0224927068,
-0.0354097672,
-0.0033803037,
-0.0440025926,
0.0741661564,
-0.0026799561,
0.0120591074,
0.0076855589,
-0.0149093485,
-0.0531823523,
-0.0303970538,
0.0348332003,
-0.0675117671,
0.0547887608,
-0.0268109553,
0.0250404719,
0.0197391026,
-0.0410726555,
-0.0385628454,
-0.043451611,
-0.02110219,
0.009459395,
-0.010552465,
0.0037437358,
-0.031147493,
0.0041570766,
0.0246146228,
0.0141161149,
-0.0239965077,
-0.00570864,
-0.0222882833,
0.036449533,
0.0458365157,
0.0541550703,
0.0480367877,
-0.0100287627,
-0.0014500393,
0.0320870616,
-0.0158452783,
0.0042031356,
0.0121173477,
-0.0200914294,
0.0398143791,
-0.0366513394,
-0.0458422862,
0.0096139386,
0.0266769379,
-0.0673271343,
-0.055997055,
0.0896235406,
0.0422832593,
-0.0158568323,
-0.0239414293,
-0.0381391011,
0.0151960049,
0.0297695231,
0.0324552581,
-0.0612471215,
-0.0129418466,
0.0235553067,
0.012301011,
0.0027052648,
-0.0132433316,
0.0104431026,
-0.1162857115,
0.0460352264,
0.003187953,
0.0024432139,
0.000678303,
-0.0429312587,
0.0120720342,
-0.014578986,
0.0397647955,
0.0616151132,
-0.0291675031,
0.0106712962,
0.0029169444,
-0.0100222584,
-0.0416783653,
0.0241367519,
-0.057297051,
0.0638417378,
0.0435588509,
0.0440670028,
-0.0138063645,
-0.0598929152,
0.0231848583,
0.0125439046,
-0.0170349609,
-0.0089859338,
0.0323428512,
0.0078869853,
0.0133005902,
-0.0642474443,
-0.0242227484,
0.0514741018,
-0.0134667056,
-0.0288863312,
0.0533175766,
-0.0293834135,
-0.0174788423,
-0.0330357701,
0.0083283223,
-0.0235750955,
0.1006017849,
0.0162790809,
0.0256207716,
-0.0355187654,
-0.0037395158,
0.0246779211,
0.0232571661,
-0.0362197943,
0.0238576327,
-0.0155107407,
-0.00231366,
-0.0615596734,
-0.048799105,
-0.0185458064,
0.0026820556,
0.000632492,
-0.0037448548,
0.0332605541,
-0.0198562462,
-0.0087730065,
0.0280069709,
-0.0625864193,
0.0048766946,
-0.0023854813,
0.05662781,
0.0404612496,
-0.0327194408,
-0.0106390612,
-0.0122632133,
-0.0789715052,
-0.0371606946,
0.0422037356,
0.001244203,
0.0321498178,
0.0486941673,
-0.033247415,
-0.0544907674,
0.0081560817,
0.0204469971,
-0.0228092074,
0.0596437082,
-0.0045064222,
-0.0154370805,
-0.0067635016,
0.0395496637,
-0.0513486862,
0.0192041267,
-0.0072160731,
0.0629981905,
-0.0217042398,
-0.0444531664,
0.017175274,
0.0642905533,
0.0608573332,
-0.0022722003,
0.0034219685,
-0.0268587172,
0.0118873632,
-0.0399693586,
-0.0281115063,
-0.0042206114,
0.0033284209,
0.0209375527,
0.0324613005,
-0.0145299593,
0.0015392745,
-0.0319297276,
0.0627169013,
-0.0443130583,
-0.0641853586,
0.0030399626,
-0.0126969488,
0.0071512172,
0.0047578295,
-0.0255177822,
0.021432057,
-0.0241961293,
0.0740654022,
-0.0204188433,
0.0128971487,
0.0170367658,
-0.0118898628,
-0.056192264,
-0.0083015347,
-0.0870361999,
-0.0276887473,
-0.0269490331,
0.0022698143,
0.0435604788,
-0.0106136501,
0.0295193512,
-0.0239537265,
-0.0157237723,
-0.028961109,
-0.0229933839,
0.0628773645,
-0.0078227147,
0.037714202,
0.011868774,
-0.0184762422,
0.0126010161,
0.0346482024,
0.0147570791,
0.0299965832,
-0.0174595043,
-0.0413757041,
0.0073985732,
-0.0497309119,
-0.0284295175,
-0.0010474419,
-0.0454944856,
-0.0352935866,
-0.0960450172,
-0.0549072325,
0.044063393,
0.0280645918,
-0.0193318706,
-0.0459892079,
-0.0144561958,
0.0804099143,
0.0516154915,
-0.0169823505,
-0.0402640402,
0.0234729536,
-0.025077654,
0.00877285,
-0.0087742256,
-6.551242341e-33,
-0.0536884181,
0.0133090541,
0.0282859895,
-0.0725984126,
-0.0529172085,
0.0311264303,
-0.0188390147,
0.0102647273,
-0.048563119,
0.0248842034,
-0.0153001072,
0.0328086615,
0.0162848625,
-0.0013874182,
0.0199098382,
-0.0235742219,
0.0377871171,
0.0294748899,
-0.0215251427,
-0.0153962374,
0.0693612918,
-0.0044399318,
0.0180668626,
-0.0654246286,
0.0694385394,
-0.01285592,
-0.0030230109,
0.0521630272,
-0.0217189193,
0.0645719022,
-0.020770723,
0.0683491305,
0.0279501397,
-0.0399376154,
-0.0163665991,
-0.0232529324,
-0.0797227249,
-0.0518641472,
0.0849415138,
-0.0094976332,
-0.0143786902,
-0.0130362883,
0.0645249113,
0.0065851379,
-0.0582554564,
-0.0040211226,
0.0348660424,
-0.0194148254,
-0.0369073637,
0.0304278731,
-0.0381655879,
0.0072316164,
0.052532021,
0.0164786801,
-0.0184477866,
-0.0132929757,
0.0062010745,
0.050459303,
-0.0798995271,
-0.0201118216,
0.0113013759,
0.0531530976,
0.0267669987,
0.039739579,
-0.0091044866,
0.0523717105,
-0.0140496818,
0.0095304549,
-0.1040022746,
-0.0073327716,
0.0464617983,
0.0400000662,
0.0451517664,
0.0611965954,
-0.0076365508,
-0.002500986,
-0.0580438338,
0.0237541888,
0.0180492979,
0.0663957447,
0.0158649664,
0.0124793621,
-0.0651461631,
-0.0305219423,
-0.0579473004,
-0.0062357811,
-0.0439664051,
-0.0057127289,
0.0286715776,
0.015345335,
0.0046998565,
0.0479695424,
0.0108155496,
-0.0504303202,
-0.0610960871,
-0.0127688264,
-0.0362166427,
-0.0072065536,
-0.006126985,
0.0493915789,
-0.0116222082,
-0.0163327996,
-0.00957896,
0.0298814587,
-0.0295107104,
0.0300478637,
0.0201618541,
0.0080777667,
-0.0447881818,
-0.0082571609,
-0.0319694504,
-0.0278824959,
-0.0282567721,
-0.0288388953,
0.0310460404,
0.0311630554,
-0.0063620009,
0.0392589048,
0.0403344072,
0.0349523425,
-0.0488936715,
-0.0322328657,
0.0221743118,
0.0237684436,
-0.0310902111,
0.0260832459,
-0.0500966348,
0.0393365547,
0.0378103964,
-0.0427306406,
-0.0090393294,
0.0171628539,
2.674e-7,
0.0606624857,
0.0377860814,
0.0313706808,
0.0204183105,
-0.0172874779,
0.0237468816,
-0.01409462,
0.0289170872,
0.0103600807,
-0.0050340132,
-0.0154489651,
0.0493312441,
0.0454735309,
0.0342321023,
-0.0367042385,
0.0096684434,
-0.1058080345,
-0.0088326298,
-0.0589004569,
0.009125947,
0.0419046283,
0.1042482033,
0.0500702113,
-0.0144402338,
-0.0104669956,
-0.0429690965,
0.0599823743,
-0.0194343571,
-0.0325087383,
0.028662499,
0.0506131276,
0.0472176969,
0.0378118753,
-0.0285606068,
0.0039733876,
0.0120195914,
0.0093623195,
0.0537012517,
-0.0033451268,
0.0382039398,
-0.0253400002,
-0.0435909852,
0.0016025855,
-0.0666482672,
0.078188397,
0.0032977341,
-0.0050552813,
-0.0190652069,
-0.0231726971,
0.0281552337,
0.0443360358,
0.008173096,
-0.0349412784,
0.0128615703,
0.0211549029,
0.03201323,
-0.0187288038,
-0.0749695301,
-0.0641745925,
0.0130628115,
-0.0376560315,
-0.0620061085,
-0.017097326,
-0.0229722131,
0.0107360333,
-0.0945269391,
0.0077542202,
2.553901985e-34,
0.0369031355,
0.0445020311,
0.0129865268,
0.006617811,
0.0260688178,
-0.022160368,
0.0178673454,
0.0274709277,
-0.0100964839,
-0.10494937,
0.0092144292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01305v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01305v3 | AWEQ: Post-Training Quantization with Activation-Weight Equalization for Large Language Models | 2023-11-02T15:18:22 | 2023-11-12T07:54:09 | Baisong Li, Xingwang Wang, Haixiao Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models(LLMs) exhibit excellent performance across a variety of
tasks, but they come with significant computational and storage costs.
Quantizing these models is an effective way to alleviate this issue. However,
existing methods struggle to strike a balance between model accuracy and
hardware efficiency. This is where we introduce AWEQ, a post-training method
that requires no additional training overhead. AWEQ excels in both
ultra-low-bit quantization and 8-bit weight and activation (W8A8) quantization.
There is an observation that weight quantization is less challenging than
activation quantization. AWEQ transfers the difficulty of activation
quantization to weights using channel equalization, achieving a balance between
the quantization difficulties of both, and thereby maximizing performance. We
have further refined the equalization method to mitigate quantization bias
error, ensuring the robustness of the model. Extensive experiments on popular
models such as LLaMA and OPT demonstrate that AWEQ outperforms all existing
post-training quantization methods for large models. | [
-0.034715604,
0.0845924467,
0.0173246227,
0.0362817161,
0.0248649791,
0.0041924822,
0.0377121158,
0.0004972872,
-0.029633021,
-0.0376549587,
-0.0210789014,
-0.0432974584,
-0.0236137751,
0.0196495224,
0.0254054088,
-0.0066096098,
0.035126891,
-0.0311383866,
0.0128083127,
-0.0322841443,
0.0078160064,
0.0078535024,
0.0079733189,
0.0310789309,
0.0152862594,
0.0087964321,
-0.0284662545,
0.0287986435,
-0.0285556186,
-0.0321403965,
0.0105535965,
0.0616780408,
0.0329760648,
0.0285278857,
0.000002117,
-0.0145714851,
-0.0211806651,
-0.0172089916,
-0.0320289023,
0.0639155507,
0.0040331031,
0.0005526534,
-0.0545757562,
0.0171127394,
0.0195893515,
-0.0101742009,
0.0825971365,
0.0010931795,
0.0505268015,
0.0419347845,
-0.0080468636,
-0.0531569421,
0.0153915258,
-0.0076504573,
-0.0104244649,
-0.0313367322,
0.0268377773,
0.0444509909,
-0.0329596028,
-0.0189969372,
-0.0291461591,
0.0401264504,
0.0223179217,
-0.0054023126,
-0.0133826826,
0.0004110463,
-0.042554643,
0.0109851398,
-0.0310259406,
0.0452542379,
-0.0660916716,
-0.062279053,
-0.005750577,
0.0229892228,
-0.0574608408,
-0.1273194999,
-0.0233495999,
0.0110280858,
0.0320993699,
0.0564261638,
-0.019826429,
-0.0158322193,
0.0559820496,
0.0175565854,
-0.0392215215,
0.0527591035,
0.0379206091,
-0.0293141846,
0.0141534926,
0.0050853333,
-0.0674912632,
-0.0652039051,
0.0245845616,
-0.0001864718,
-0.0038206144,
-0.0092017837,
-0.0638991371,
-0.0347669125,
-0.0410836115,
-0.0348546244,
-0.0196577758,
0.0752995759,
0.003048091,
0.0206113532,
-0.0175187904,
0.0494009815,
-0.0019529514,
0.0238853227,
-0.0487016514,
0.0182768907,
0.0013513047,
-0.003904039,
-0.0730323568,
0.0489697941,
-0.0196984299,
-0.0378819555,
-0.0534493029,
-0.0383681953,
-0.0095599517,
-0.0449861139,
0.0205007214,
0.0179131031,
-0.0523705035,
-0.0271349102,
0.0389223211,
0.0340219401,
0.0187880825,
0.0145185636,
0.003113284,
-0.0411224663,
0.020275645,
0.0048791561,
-0.0053016385,
-0.0253225323,
0.0229067113,
-0.0126856063,
-0.0002522297,
-0.0184128098,
-0.0207121037,
0.0135953631,
-0.0039450102,
-0.0227560457,
-0.0380410813,
-0.0678466782,
-0.018364802,
-0.0110760406,
0.0113742594,
-0.0289568994,
0.020315012,
-0.0130183287,
0.0073067844,
0.0575336628,
-0.0411730185,
-0.0084401593,
0.0281924717,
0.009680937,
0.0540245213,
0.0958883762,
0.0444118418,
0.0290268306,
0.0012801598,
0.009451665,
-0.0299670622,
0.0608325489,
0.0394612178,
0.0026963099,
-0.068119064,
-0.0632240921,
-0.0546800494,
0.0382649638,
0.1052875072,
0.0970239118,
-0.0536398031,
-0.0137347057,
0.0427785181,
0.0323127173,
0.0361015759,
-0.0030012778,
-0.0082043847,
0.0156364199,
0.0040234858,
-0.0192105826,
-0.025914561,
-0.0015911508,
0.0347543582,
0.0088046873,
0.0716438368,
0.0424540266,
-0.0261171982,
-0.0187006257,
-0.01635365,
-0.0141919442,
0.0196914617,
0.0114495652,
0.0199961402,
0.0069301296,
-0.0037826151,
0.1168018058,
0.0342691913,
-0.0635373741,
0.0145788928,
-0.0776525214,
-0.0218239985,
0.0445504263,
0.0236746334,
0.0227968823,
0.0413732678,
0.0106115593,
0.0329182334,
0.0355485491,
-0.0060796202,
0.0074956291,
0.0201283861,
-0.0661248043,
-0.041249834,
0.0111547178,
0.0012104592,
-0.0025563072,
0.0111200269,
0.0118992785,
-0.0234103967,
-0.0203012805,
-0.0324802846,
0.0119560873,
0.0355760828,
-0.0659578964,
0.0271534752,
-0.0094309421,
0.0024760978,
0.0215966459,
-0.0281621423,
0.0109771108,
0.0158178639,
-0.0386740975,
0.0136169614,
-0.0188526288,
-0.012023082,
0.0095514171,
0.0759779513,
0.0163518563,
0.0462279879,
0.0410348251,
-0.0151008517,
-0.0433993563,
0.0297190063,
-0.0062679523,
0.0508791655,
-0.0302992444,
0.0460789613,
-0.0085860193,
0.0220940262,
-0.030707866,
0.005296119,
-0.0149361473,
0.0029296528,
0.0149455145,
0.0226995498,
-0.0072678155,
-0.0392586552,
-0.0538999513,
0.0156775955,
0.016612947,
0.0438930951,
-0.020610068,
0.0051521799,
0.0007098669,
0.0162171926,
-0.1068118885,
0.0100909891,
-0.0538159981,
0.0235624295,
0.0294905808,
0.0385380238,
0.0189979915,
-0.0148687838,
-0.0371332727,
-0.0367612876,
-0.0277993195,
-0.011689554,
-0.0379344299,
-0.021231629,
-0.0171507206,
-0.0332011059,
-0.0463486575,
0.0185949877,
0.0257223789,
-0.0452625379,
-0.0409033149,
-0.0635584891,
-0.0084844334,
-0.0061507602,
0.0710015744,
0.0215648897,
-0.0473616496,
0.0026027034,
0.0048025451,
-0.021593336,
0.0311129522,
-0.000812683,
0.0054273172,
0.0868751332,
0.0070349462,
-0.0330936462,
0.0226130541,
0.0249437094,
-0.0388990417,
-0.0218885671,
-0.0180685371,
-0.0187345054,
0.0848532692,
-0.0247331634,
0.0097450921,
-0.0195747446,
-0.0056411275,
-0.0343044475,
-0.032370951,
-0.0629977882,
-0.0244249552,
-0.0419146828,
0.0517508648,
-0.0262055229,
-0.0400843695,
0.0115990769,
-0.0282839257,
0.0027576033,
-0.0479032993,
0.0041814912,
0.0030606338,
0.0260015521,
-0.0043344549,
0.0654757246,
-0.0177121405,
-0.0232405644,
-0.0225294195,
-0.0239273068,
-0.0328429565,
-0.0430089645,
0.0097973226,
-0.0242435616,
0.0525640957,
-0.0393198654,
-0.0307863429,
0.0201511215,
0.052879788,
-0.0398827679,
0.0306943636,
0.046109356,
-0.031260401,
0.0466216393,
0.0880962387,
-0.0120643163,
0.0370728225,
-0.0129627753,
-0.0047977949,
-0.0305267721,
0.0354858786,
0.0408814251,
0.0089030508,
0.0187456105,
-0.0130449142,
-0.0086790724,
0.0051594335,
0.0351279043,
0.0604032278,
-0.0610249974,
0.0079935873,
0.0527147502,
0.0042758719,
-0.0010376712,
0.0076379906,
0.0521147475,
-0.0255762432,
0.0152482865,
0.0796575844,
0.023398485,
-0.0672288761,
0.0140536018,
0.0140813068,
0.016854357,
-0.0065645641,
-0.0077362745,
-0.1354961842,
-0.0303402524,
0.0298525766,
0.0014876708,
0.0272953026,
0.0375770144,
-0.01624237,
-0.0397873558,
-0.0098793479,
0.0490942448,
-0.0002908292,
-0.0335261002,
0.0190388206,
-0.0348847136,
-0.0371769816,
0.0916753784,
0.0450150594,
0.0095039709,
-0.0041387449,
0.0387290753,
0.0156252291,
-0.0472392291,
0.0231515206,
-0.0342838056,
0.0729084089,
0.0613388307,
0.012483336,
-0.0060585001,
0.0098813493,
0.0180636384,
0.0173743069,
-0.0230625309,
0.0160787534,
-0.0114655131,
0.0241422541,
-0.0234693345,
0.0133953113,
-0.005195193,
0.0212780554,
-0.008891671,
-0.0098195765,
0.0003809471,
-0.0063663605,
-0.016234614,
0.0301450696,
-0.0391882807,
-0.0222539268,
0.0406118222,
0.0211932473,
-0.0127839735,
-0.0682719722,
-0.0420473814,
0.0164247807,
-0.0640556067,
-0.0589133129,
-0.0122079346,
-0.0132645741,
-0.0694860965,
-0.0335490145,
0.0139602944,
-0.0023515527,
0.0183289293,
-0.0023469934,
0.004702948,
0.0329610519,
-0.0089122495,
-0.0629523247,
-0.0070361686,
-0.0496015809,
0.0452248305,
-0.0439426601,
0.0069769346,
-0.0203244295,
-0.0149143292,
-0.0130036278,
0.0077868453,
-0.096338056,
-0.0650829971,
0.0230339356,
-0.0148421181,
0.019386977,
0.0218184367,
-0.0108810309,
-0.1086489111,
0.0429232679,
0.0274739973,
-0.0147640212,
0.0552883781,
0.0324432328,
-0.0009736196,
0.0050701136,
0.0447415113,
-0.0384219922,
0.054434523,
-0.0090381093,
0.0521630123,
-0.0409076512,
-0.0338291191,
-0.0056593372,
-0.0003107267,
0.0386618525,
-0.0068026814,
-0.012491459,
0.0041778819,
0.0382306091,
-0.0106807584,
0.0239286236,
-0.0323264487,
0.0237565674,
0.0177359655,
0.0178759713,
-0.0063543227,
-0.0250444598,
0.0395927131,
-0.0551365465,
0.0411515124,
0.003135548,
-0.0718947351,
0.028378142,
0.0665755346,
-0.0165672675,
-0.021254316,
0.0240282752,
0.0214581396,
0.0298230965,
-0.0293512046,
-0.0050392263,
-0.0112466235,
-0.0048202863,
-0.0388538688,
0.0415100716,
0.0008236233,
-0.0135166366,
-0.0520420261,
-0.0061015622,
0.0900315866,
0.0396513715,
0.0789826661,
0.0112391245,
-0.0253510363,
-0.0149376411,
0.0189512558,
0.0184459817,
0.0074937255,
0.0471183024,
0.0117296278,
-0.0277351048,
0.0129231047,
0.0152195124,
0.0177035611,
0.0254275482,
-0.0037762525,
0.0092016347,
0.019179292,
-0.0162275787,
-0.0705870911,
0.0285230372,
-0.0334261656,
-0.0305709653,
0.0111269029,
-0.0427283086,
-0.0208628047,
0.0099363709,
0.0029799002,
-0.0449673943,
0.0282217246,
0.0133220125,
0.0002222052,
-0.0311802421,
-0.0133680822,
-0.0628979579,
-0.0001565308,
-0.0092832251,
-0.0077725444,
-6.473931547e-33,
-0.0071391836,
0.0440334044,
0.0203482956,
-0.0164836738,
-0.0174868256,
0.036769703,
-0.0229812507,
-0.001619351,
-0.0212609973,
-0.0317256898,
-0.0002959004,
0.0237902906,
0.0396400392,
0.0001359528,
-0.0333436541,
0.0418638662,
0.1016060784,
-0.0274380054,
-0.0139053613,
0.0216956902,
-0.015911663,
0.0127600385,
0.0365800038,
0.0124276271,
-0.0358500965,
0.0230367277,
-0.0226695016,
-0.0194022022,
0.0259787943,
0.0287304875,
-0.0432462357,
0.0376182571,
-0.018370688,
0.0048811892,
-0.0228583571,
-0.0378904939,
-0.0442100689,
0.0280885715,
0.0023476931,
0.0396604985,
0.0005315195,
-0.0268034376,
0.0594986752,
0.0436806045,
-0.0683914125,
-0.0075853183,
-0.0272736568,
-0.0027653994,
-0.0221567992,
-0.0699445605,
-0.0181716345,
0.0297786854,
0.023493981,
0.0240966119,
0.0872925594,
-0.0478516556,
-0.0544979386,
-0.0335072018,
-0.0754617155,
-0.008030816,
0.0518979803,
0.0878896415,
0.0491055474,
0.0438683443,
0.018397294,
0.032604292,
0.0525288023,
-0.064518027,
0.0060942913,
0.0685007349,
0.0540717058,
0.0081267208,
0.0311526395,
-0.0043584807,
0.1282662451,
-0.0210789405,
-0.0468747243,
-0.0203475785,
-0.005420424,
0.0233698767,
0.0291953813,
0.0806080997,
-0.0160618797,
-0.0330677964,
-0.0431061946,
-0.0118277231,
-0.0450265408,
-0.0698661581,
0.0163030792,
0.0094861994,
-0.0306330435,
0.0125891715,
0.0237315334,
-0.0293286834,
-0.0336750224,
-0.0044889683,
-0.0032412643,
0.0212304816,
-0.011494373,
0.0323472768,
-0.0344030298,
-0.0078304717,
0.0256911684,
0.0186148025,
0.0048325793,
-0.018204093,
-0.0076987306,
0.0654366612,
-0.0669911578,
-0.0169380251,
-0.022468349,
-0.0138670495,
0.0230922848,
0.0442607589,
0.0204482116,
-0.0031267928,
0.0170006417,
0.026640784,
-0.0389636196,
-0.0164102372,
-0.008173001,
0.0006834644,
0.0375603065,
0.0620805696,
-0.0650100112,
0.0240366329,
-0.0461135246,
0.034337081,
0.0475658067,
-0.0581088401,
-0.0647249818,
0.0167755056,
2.768e-7,
0.035710033,
0.0059553222,
0.0351055451,
0.0061551509,
-0.0059080175,
-0.0240531415,
0.0047025811,
0.0112130009,
0.0106944526,
-0.0082447873,
-0.0311461501,
0.0431371629,
0.029701747,
0.0045569367,
-0.0583827794,
0.0197370593,
-0.0602324009,
0.0097607179,
-0.0317640789,
-0.0471652411,
0.0084788529,
0.1171081811,
-0.0190514289,
-0.0157517567,
0.0590321831,
-0.0125014735,
0.0080277584,
0.0337659419,
0.0470267795,
0.0369066261,
0.0278994124,
0.0184300281,
-0.0206277762,
-0.0250437818,
0.0095645441,
-0.0088138068,
-0.0209585708,
0.0849889815,
-0.0467188433,
-0.012099579,
-0.0005665201,
0.0067104534,
-0.0227843504,
-0.0130917374,
0.0510165282,
-0.02141908,
0.0003303361,
-0.0998067409,
-0.0050154137,
-0.0204237662,
-0.0160034169,
-0.0218329728,
0.0098334188,
0.0054386826,
0.015539024,
-0.002180388,
-0.0083693508,
-0.0619261377,
-0.0427063778,
0.0241136849,
0.003076598,
-0.0392272286,
-0.0326744355,
0.0057865703,
-0.0270333253,
-0.0437126309,
0.0386396535,
2.455597597e-34,
0.0263036806,
-0.0190604739,
0.0404432863,
0.0447603092,
-0.0100547159,
-0.0322757065,
-0.01809581,
-0.0032129895,
-0.0422158539,
-0.043314483,
-0.0284546372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01282v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01282v4 | FlashDecoding++: Faster Large Language Model Inference on GPUs | 2023-11-02T14:57:03 | 2024-01-05T12:41:13 | Ke Hong, Guohao Dai, Jiaming Xu, Qiuli Mao, Xiuhong Li, Jun Liu, Kangdi Chen, Yuhan Dong, Yu Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | As the Large Language Model (LLM) becomes increasingly important in various
domains. However, the following challenges still remain unsolved in
accelerating LLM inference: (1) Synchronized partial softmax update. The
softmax operation requires a synchronized update operation among each partial
softmax result, leading to ~20% overheads for the attention computation in
LLMs. (2) Under-utilized computation of flat GEMM. The shape of matrices
performing GEMM in LLM inference is flat, leading to under-utilized computation
and >50% performance loss after padding zeros in previous designs. (3)
Performance loss due to static dataflow. Kernel performance in LLM depends on
varied input data features, hardware configurations, etc. A single and static
dataflow may lead to a 50.25% performance loss for GEMMs of different shapes in
LLM inference.
We present FlashDecoding++, a fast LLM inference engine supporting mainstream
LLMs and hardware back-ends. To tackle the above challenges, FlashDecoding++
creatively proposes: (1) Asynchronized softmax with unified max value.
FlashDecoding++ introduces a unified max value technique for different partial
softmax computations to avoid synchronization. (2) Flat GEMM optimization with
double buffering. FlashDecoding++ points out that flat GEMMs with different
shapes face varied bottlenecks. Then, techniques like double buffering are
introduced. (3) Heuristic dataflow with hardware resource adaptation.
FlashDecoding++ heuristically optimizes dataflow using different hardware
resource considering input dynamics. Due to the versatility of optimizations in
FlashDecoding++, FlashDecoding++ can achieve up to 4.86x and 2.18x speedup on
both NVIDIA and AMD GPUs compared to Hugging Face implementations.
FlashDecoding++ also achieves an average speedup of 1.37x compared to
state-of-the-art LLM inference engines on mainstream LLMs. | [
0.0195646584,
-0.0030892135,
-0.0097174505,
0.0715793073,
0.0057938136,
0.0282343272,
0.0194631703,
-0.0113030281,
-0.0299422462,
-0.0250302311,
-0.0107760392,
-0.0519452058,
0.0182995833,
0.0316743925,
0.0162565242,
0.0027081908,
0.0451979749,
-0.0616036057,
0.0124243088,
-0.0111494996,
0.0348221287,
0.0346504077,
0.0318896286,
0.0084713316,
-0.0000937573,
-0.0075692516,
-0.004740573,
0.022506034,
0.0227821227,
0.0247462224,
0.0083417045,
0.0358173177,
0.0388982482,
0.0280926339,
0.0000024484,
-0.0021810862,
0.0054540122,
-0.0176369157,
0.0175499618,
0.0543360226,
0.0321468674,
-0.0310144946,
-0.0370046198,
-0.0273088161,
0.01394777,
-0.0198973566,
0.070190765,
-0.0241020843,
-0.0027331419,
0.0245567746,
-0.0073179062,
-0.0359905288,
0.0218117684,
-0.030866446,
-0.0373002589,
-0.0699416175,
0.0366877392,
-0.0149760619,
-0.0350301489,
-0.0268535838,
-0.0197693314,
0.038344793,
0.0066828583,
-0.0111883814,
-0.0134004643,
0.0314114466,
-0.0145998169,
-0.0101916417,
0.0137106031,
0.0435385294,
-0.042785719,
-0.0192166977,
0.0203496255,
-0.011016069,
-0.0309810583,
-0.0236962307,
-0.005100952,
0.0351687483,
-0.0146399122,
-0.0039853929,
0.0560715012,
-0.0054680184,
0.0273232628,
0.0028348779,
-0.0312515609,
0.0529609583,
0.042363286,
0.0309442934,
-0.0267573595,
-0.0001131791,
-0.0118416622,
-0.0428594463,
0.0491067767,
0.0243978351,
-0.0306089297,
0.0175747965,
-0.0801958367,
-0.0516212918,
0.0098184859,
-0.0808410719,
0.0808630884,
0.0723449364,
0.0036732315,
0.0426178686,
-0.0616589747,
0.0410083458,
-0.0391898379,
-0.0325487778,
-0.053045366,
-0.0077957967,
0.0683542639,
0.006159083,
-0.0076625245,
0.0103478907,
-0.0294561032,
-0.0320641547,
-0.0449295193,
0.0154688107,
-0.0178953689,
-0.0290040057,
-0.0129226409,
-0.0215453245,
-0.066151388,
0.0070049572,
-0.0240397677,
0.0492611416,
-0.0620418862,
0.0023936993,
-0.0366722122,
-0.056084875,
0.0137817822,
-0.019429408,
0.0344146006,
-0.0294049401,
0.0058774143,
0.021125637,
-0.0192978624,
-0.0440126173,
-0.062906161,
-0.0020386055,
0.0092025464,
-0.0662546381,
0.0259222724,
-0.0828490108,
0.0552839302,
0.0429098569,
0.0012727833,
0.0211856831,
0.016624799,
0.0165112671,
0.0076467805,
0.0053669885,
-0.0352207124,
-0.0051132799,
0.0127615053,
-0.0156727545,
0.0444913544,
0.1230854616,
-0.0153748058,
0.0315155052,
0.0015014043,
-0.0026597395,
0.0109228371,
0.0669243932,
0.0001921402,
0.0290072709,
-0.0544934124,
0.0226975661,
0.0510507002,
0.0205411538,
0.0520387292,
0.0417181067,
-0.0411919095,
-0.0408994108,
0.0293335319,
0.0616760254,
-0.0476407818,
0.0484004244,
0.0190691762,
-0.0353110917,
0.0024411285,
-0.000056672,
-0.0034296361,
0.0338734873,
0.0233243983,
0.0266446937,
0.0708704218,
0.0942146853,
-0.0131115159,
0.0160508044,
-0.005914079,
-0.0015199189,
0.0102721378,
0.0208591651,
0.0419897288,
-0.0307988469,
-0.0296570491,
0.0639379174,
0.0701083988,
-0.0395962633,
-0.0557152405,
-0.0261924453,
0.015892474,
0.0286910795,
0.0141261723,
0.0046745436,
-0.0621031895,
0.0202678498,
-0.0121391593,
0.0176925827,
0.0240038894,
0.0241699331,
0.0007875022,
-0.0750861168,
0.0221301876,
0.0052256128,
0.0090012308,
0.0628156364,
0.0431746207,
0.0183521453,
0.022457879,
-0.0084472969,
-0.0525364429,
0.0047189463,
0.0010012727,
0.0028729946,
-0.0068337293,
-0.0137023684,
0.0116422093,
-0.0187248792,
-0.0014900551,
-0.0203959551,
0.0286044758,
-0.029518839,
0.0248981137,
-0.0513200238,
-0.0848821625,
-0.0048744199,
0.0459251888,
0.0043188357,
-0.0249321405,
0.0245561171,
-0.0469973385,
-0.0303180609,
0.0593198687,
-0.0203966759,
0.0000033783,
-0.0441514701,
0.0375495218,
0.000112593,
0.0521750748,
0.0032776899,
0.0451766774,
-0.0103530437,
0.0172890518,
0.0088060061,
0.0130165769,
0.0052333265,
-0.0338947996,
-0.0172890872,
-0.0111488402,
-0.0177707355,
-0.0069928761,
-0.0412790366,
-0.0487662293,
-0.0082989885,
0.031014448,
-0.0587884411,
0.0054581924,
-0.0229490772,
0.033298105,
0.0334479734,
0.0250928495,
0.0141972778,
-0.0139698172,
0.0145794256,
0.0477830134,
-0.0333519205,
0.0238538086,
-0.041884426,
-0.0049629775,
-0.0068797441,
-0.001246668,
-0.0517822132,
0.0020601654,
0.0759027004,
-0.0127510577,
-0.0815957263,
-0.0174604617,
-0.013464273,
-0.0403256752,
0.0603994466,
-0.0242251363,
-0.0148730585,
-0.004493556,
-0.0303250551,
0.07955046,
0.0729909092,
0.035051737,
-0.033269614,
0.024222387,
-0.014609376,
-0.0158795957,
0.0361174196,
-0.0148024084,
-0.0288786218,
-0.0276771616,
-0.0085258558,
-0.0344377235,
0.0810108632,
-0.0365024656,
-0.0216033738,
-0.0153883938,
-0.0639763549,
0.0115508307,
0.0117409192,
-0.0251199845,
-0.0100208949,
-0.0269584041,
0.0054043857,
-0.0267056655,
-0.0594264083,
0.0523697399,
-0.0683579519,
-0.0097751264,
-0.0010942082,
-0.0189789962,
-0.0346339941,
0.0250080545,
0.0036671096,
0.0326693654,
-0.052691184,
0.0056098979,
0.0416709371,
0.0125485873,
-0.003738797,
-0.0254337452,
0.0647230968,
-0.0023451599,
0.052547697,
-0.0692533702,
-0.0042558042,
0.0222041029,
0.0232622102,
-0.055416435,
0.0087543083,
0.0536143407,
-0.0481618829,
0.0082911011,
0.0570096113,
-0.0082984855,
0.0796511173,
-0.0357476808,
0.0191989299,
-0.0280209575,
-0.0074807559,
0.059365429,
-0.0095601333,
-0.0356074013,
-0.0386616327,
-0.0523212776,
0.0522082634,
0.0244057998,
-0.0153923072,
-0.0781442225,
-0.0165878031,
0.0658672005,
0.0128709143,
-0.0087903393,
0.0246781725,
-0.0035347776,
-0.1157370508,
0.0216647852,
0.0631761253,
-0.0088753169,
-0.082907863,
-0.0102253966,
0.0335986018,
0.0181877874,
0.0221235082,
0.0358919092,
-0.0655395612,
-0.0508989505,
0.0243150312,
-0.0250695311,
0.0093802381,
0.0109811462,
-0.0120540205,
-0.0841317624,
0.0272099692,
0.0098938094,
-0.0352034159,
-0.0414600596,
-0.0221455824,
0.0247012656,
0.0660320148,
-0.0221403483,
0.0219823774,
0.0051534604,
-0.0026000815,
-0.0125228437,
0.0175643023,
0.0134654576,
-0.0012484627,
-0.0388721898,
0.0183215626,
0.0403093584,
0.0238264427,
0.0026076729,
-0.0285698511,
0.0664803609,
-0.0111731132,
-0.0206370801,
-0.0264960863,
-0.0142476019,
-0.0294244867,
-0.0101036588,
-0.0321839824,
0.0058679781,
0.0026478793,
0.0118141845,
-0.023751948,
0.087120451,
0.0254058708,
-0.0456364639,
-0.0026329134,
-0.013551645,
-0.0312764645,
0.0187001415,
0.016971577,
0.0017618558,
-0.0308679268,
-0.0650484189,
-0.0624552928,
-0.0175840184,
-0.0515143834,
-0.0390096456,
0.021510547,
-0.0091998428,
0.0425646342,
0.031740889,
0.0073503242,
0.0231139846,
-0.0013820766,
0.0255849715,
0.0106432587,
-0.0329483859,
-0.0752297863,
0.0275121033,
-0.0432696305,
0.0398912542,
-0.0427190363,
-0.0038168025,
0.0092593962,
-0.001267353,
0.0122591592,
0.0857867822,
-0.0770924687,
-0.0525983237,
-0.0067390902,
-0.0131534394,
0.0086597912,
0.0312254578,
-0.0086845197,
-0.059241347,
0.0339660048,
0.0414823033,
-0.0364382416,
0.0536698028,
-0.0240759663,
-0.0536810681,
0.0016123272,
0.0222072508,
-0.0145175857,
-0.0198875368,
0.0246246774,
0.0208695214,
0.0093505355,
-0.0406257436,
-0.041267883,
0.002775952,
0.0056499057,
0.00816496,
-0.0064849784,
-0.0282595977,
0.0328230038,
0.0301698633,
-0.015714163,
-0.0328428894,
-0.0080921613,
0.0164933149,
-0.0010488451,
0.0080306325,
-0.0076720365,
0.0735459924,
-0.044160936,
-0.0384156033,
-0.048659239,
0.0140106315,
-0.0175202601,
0.025357008,
-0.0358202681,
-0.0178668145,
-0.0022780295,
0.0133788213,
0.0446985513,
-0.0570820831,
0.0369256362,
0.0224074498,
-0.0246681627,
-0.0115751289,
0.0107293241,
-0.0205027051,
-0.0356561579,
-0.0733987987,
0.0023463818,
0.0614306703,
0.0009200905,
0.0285330694,
-0.0156718139,
-0.0180263054,
-0.0455332361,
0.0267457422,
-0.0334934555,
-0.0459851511,
0.0558649711,
0.025509771,
-0.0200247467,
0.0342954621,
0.0207884926,
0.0071304385,
-0.0018040214,
0.0132406289,
-0.0361259468,
0.0164136644,
-0.0511301905,
-0.0415685773,
-0.0149446921,
-0.0417335778,
-0.0198516194,
-0.0136008216,
-0.0743791759,
-0.0268090889,
-0.0010070791,
-0.0204292852,
-0.0207952727,
0.014006543,
0.0442569479,
0.0043988577,
-0.035101857,
-0.0336135924,
0.0450491533,
-0.0060974029,
0.0142509071,
-0.0000815199,
-6.942102294e-33,
-0.0172972791,
-0.0072763828,
0.0219285134,
-0.0538032502,
-0.022857422,
0.0377985463,
-0.017582478,
-0.0245113149,
0.0066808225,
-0.0051560556,
-0.0101596117,
0.0214803275,
0.0242369827,
-0.0069724182,
-0.0472793654,
-0.0034411133,
0.0229360722,
0.0214238819,
-0.0066902805,
0.0361462422,
0.0059794146,
0.0473175235,
0.0533766672,
-0.0246668644,
-0.0400392897,
-0.0332379714,
0.0350424349,
-0.0073244683,
-0.021532882,
0.0136214513,
-0.0452070385,
0.021665778,
0.0064684604,
-0.0598155782,
-0.0079495329,
-0.0118641471,
-0.0811680481,
0.012834454,
0.0446655452,
0.0435150452,
-0.0244595818,
-0.0157124437,
-0.0012557231,
0.0744680166,
0.0275721531,
-0.0412888937,
-0.012733194,
0.0100972224,
-0.0395128429,
-0.0462228879,
-0.0462905653,
0.0433826558,
0.0295491479,
0.0581448674,
0.0630736873,
-0.0227191299,
-0.0179557316,
0.0096374014,
-0.0419399999,
0.0072953496,
0.0535734519,
0.0896062255,
0.0817226544,
0.0544941686,
0.0017240192,
0.03059466,
0.0392304026,
0.0016255263,
-0.0145696634,
0.0107872942,
0.0481436215,
0.0152281439,
-0.015870044,
0.0406752601,
0.0749035254,
0.0261352994,
-0.0375764929,
-0.0102771204,
0.0296625867,
0.0085871285,
0.0808751062,
0.0209476314,
0.0176904388,
-0.0482127629,
-0.0260603931,
0.050056152,
-0.04624933,
0.0199381094,
0.0220853183,
0.0275968909,
-0.0314481668,
0.0186733566,
0.0322518423,
-0.0208446216,
0.0161068179,
-0.0038577605,
0.007072316,
0.0120632909,
0.0183696896,
0.024554925,
-0.0163069777,
-0.0490201749,
-0.0060782228,
-0.0311963279,
0.0294506848,
0.0076058479,
0.006786413,
0.0392705537,
-0.038423337,
-0.0159495249,
-0.0394023359,
-0.0185034759,
0.0219544508,
0.0455859303,
0.0464891307,
-0.0063842502,
0.0095478483,
0.0649262816,
0.0104696974,
0.0419245102,
0.0090428162,
-0.033973828,
-0.0004959552,
0.0487214811,
-0.0356489569,
0.0157552827,
-0.0710763335,
0.0241404548,
0.0189701617,
-0.0638895109,
-0.0387825966,
0.051912386,
3.172e-7,
0.0195484776,
0.0114329178,
0.0051683816,
0.0127935754,
-0.0021317259,
0.0308612399,
0.040931765,
0.0135450205,
0.0891961679,
0.0350791812,
0.009173871,
0.0449065603,
0.0220226645,
0.0125343855,
-0.0674511567,
-0.0036560234,
-0.0350371189,
0.032618247,
-0.0550531559,
-0.0353522152,
-0.0510851853,
0.1086925641,
-0.021206595,
-0.018699728,
0.0781435892,
-0.0300722532,
0.0161636546,
0.0041789417,
0.0052085896,
0.0242312495,
-0.0036423772,
-0.008105455,
-0.0640821382,
0.0173702575,
0.0207658149,
0.0106003592,
-0.0306581892,
0.0689338371,
-0.008689872,
0.0042343633,
0.0569606982,
-0.021692872,
-0.0234100204,
-0.0706443861,
0.0661655515,
0.0337790325,
-0.0022287315,
-0.0397338755,
0.0065000872,
-0.015565089,
-0.0417597182,
-0.0033473165,
0.0534602702,
0.0498277247,
0.0247702636,
-0.0393238887,
-0.066720672,
-0.0701472908,
-0.0359732807,
-0.0129061677,
-0.0626894087,
-0.0522022694,
-0.1081487536,
0.0268810261,
0.0270081908,
-0.0481520891,
0.0008775575,
3.322460166e-34,
0.0203584861,
0.0209427048,
-0.0020206815,
0.0448924303,
0.0347407088,
-0.0439737774,
-0.0141626364,
0.0440735146,
-0.027693646,
-0.0796997398,
-0.0614140816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01273v1 | Finding Common Ground: Annotating and Predicting Common Ground in Spoken Conversations | 2023-11-02T14:37:28 | 2023-11-02T14:37:28 | Magdalena Markowska, Mohammad Taghizadeh, Adil Soubki, Seyed Abolghasem Mirroshandel, Owen Rambow | cs.CL | cs.CL | When we communicate with other humans, we do not simply generate a sequence
of words. Rather, we use our cognitive state (beliefs, desires, intentions) and
our model of the audience's cognitive state to create utterances that affect
the audience's cognitive state in the intended manner. An important part of
cognitive state is the common ground, which is the content the speaker
believes, and the speaker believes the audience believes, and so on. While much
attention has been paid to common ground in cognitive science, there has not
been much work in natural language processing. In this paper, we introduce a
new annotation and corpus to capture common ground. We then describe some
initial experiments extracting propositions from dialog and tracking their
status in the common ground from the perspective of each speaker. | [
0.0425089002,
0.0311906859,
0.0041130306,
0.0024150563,
-0.0681927726,
-0.0119941365,
-0.0459411032,
-0.0451012589,
0.0265915934,
-0.074240692,
-0.0104572186,
0.0126938196,
0.0264455322,
0.0037510747,
-0.0049430598,
-0.0476868339,
0.03664352,
0.0570211112,
0.0423574448,
0.0011337691,
0.0578986518,
0.0330201201,
-0.0316083506,
0.0374144651,
-0.0458726175,
-0.0156261846,
-0.0143701294,
-0.0211007334,
0.0426670983,
-0.0154088438,
-0.0310609695,
0.0259561334,
0.0197684206,
0.0181228854,
0.0000018439,
-0.0543181337,
-0.0109172612,
-0.0357004181,
0.0051577897,
-0.0312842354,
-0.0260598678,
0.0544811971,
-0.0151335746,
0.0235165972,
-0.0531087071,
0.0553090125,
0.0424921811,
0.0949032456,
0.0871824995,
0.0385621302,
-0.0193375275,
-0.0227619726,
-0.0346877538,
0.0142556736,
-0.0131390048,
-0.0375943147,
0.0327279642,
0.0476646945,
-0.0245043747,
-0.0183733571,
0.0192445312,
-0.0105930204,
-0.0349750109,
-0.0480992459,
-0.0383550525,
0.0243615974,
-0.043306727,
-0.0465271957,
0.0024765516,
0.0548526496,
0.0606534928,
-0.0559502989,
0.0331063792,
0.0114314184,
-0.0073475162,
-0.0048168139,
-0.0136498641,
0.0456186719,
-0.0609319843,
0.0532834493,
0.0332931913,
0.0255902931,
-0.0092273233,
0.0037784751,
-0.0227776263,
0.1084232703,
-0.0198060069,
-0.0284922086,
0.0303684082,
0.0224913042,
-0.0688091069,
-0.0965078101,
0.0500145964,
0.0062174695,
0.0007763687,
0.0178962089,
-0.0305481516,
-0.0101944935,
0.038647525,
-0.1044955179,
0.0090967165,
0.0224652849,
-0.0281864516,
0.0628080666,
0.0311411582,
-0.0129843988,
-0.0056816027,
-0.0389980339,
0.0194206666,
-0.0182793476,
-0.0368874483,
0.0263262969,
-0.0254126228,
0.0444043614,
-0.005016427,
-0.0238443967,
-0.0362021476,
-0.0136677492,
-0.035992682,
0.0391630977,
-0.0031741026,
-0.0028330702,
0.0034255192,
0.0139908809,
-0.006536386,
0.0578849241,
-0.0700140446,
0.0408717506,
-0.0076212273,
-0.0634284541,
0.0239188969,
0.0373139828,
0.0328119174,
0.026842704,
-0.0108760493,
-0.0388605259,
0.0130075552,
0.0356037319,
-0.0552491248,
-0.0722765476,
-0.0493993126,
-0.0475175083,
-0.0447067358,
-0.0333917849,
0.0185353439,
0.0065418612,
0.0126265567,
-0.0253981836,
0.0276931152,
0.029368341,
0.0064625149,
0.0675172359,
-0.0114440182,
-0.0219639931,
0.0785736069,
0.0442318358,
-0.0034729098,
0.0108119017,
0.0197189562,
0.0345931686,
0.0520231947,
0.0241935514,
0.0038117394,
-0.0113573205,
0.0221591145,
-0.0516285002,
0.0478398949,
0.001339958,
-0.0255996101,
-0.0085559404,
-0.0446868539,
0.027976349,
-0.0120947044,
-0.0315917693,
0.0405313373,
0.0996037051,
-0.0360735133,
-0.0175682548,
-0.0189362653,
0.0533969142,
0.015069061,
0.0366540253,
-0.0089007234,
0.0143995797,
-0.042703975,
-0.0239014737,
0.0512465797,
-0.0008873923,
-0.0069798725,
-0.0306088924,
-0.0379151069,
-0.0221260749,
0.029862782,
-0.0180772003,
-0.0239233002,
-0.0082245795,
-0.0079676444,
0.0247832555,
0.0356896631,
-0.0725815818,
-0.0203827526,
0.0146826133,
0.0180343203,
-0.0226428211,
-0.0222770348,
0.0111077754,
-0.0276672393,
-0.0366884433,
0.0420258902,
0.062622048,
0.051694043,
-0.0316796191,
-0.022262672,
-0.0293499641,
-0.005273289,
0.0243326724,
0.0141773392,
0.0509637408,
-0.0178575031,
-0.0154925073,
-0.0049488982,
0.009178306,
0.0371346958,
0.0247764811,
0.0556372255,
0.0555642508,
-0.0350544155,
0.0077782208,
0.0777337998,
0.0695033371,
-0.0153862173,
0.010817118,
0.0498126447,
0.0086447736,
-0.0491403975,
0.1090218276,
-0.0453255847,
0.0134436591,
0.0342939645,
-0.0868203267,
-0.0229493529,
-0.0268630385,
0.0052927351,
-0.0766848847,
0.0245322958,
-0.0373801291,
0.0449063107,
-0.0427671261,
-0.0086767832,
0.0118673202,
-0.0153315719,
-0.0077166581,
0.0491274223,
0.0288349297,
-0.0152490037,
-0.032002233,
-0.0458920561,
0.055895377,
-0.0435307957,
-0.0012888724,
-0.0101172747,
0.0120750554,
-0.0149353333,
0.0714536011,
-0.0513182469,
-0.0464931615,
0.016375877,
-0.1332475543,
-0.0289937332,
-0.0343605988,
0.0066865319,
0.0137485806,
-0.0206011236,
0.0116763292,
-0.0061540827,
-0.036060188,
0.0192439891,
0.0143797407,
-0.0027921153,
0.0254202075,
-0.0009386119,
-0.0041209054,
-0.0436469205,
0.0554126203,
-0.0386675224,
0.0011721095,
0.0593531206,
-0.0724373162,
-0.0521660075,
-0.0100960266,
-0.0517166518,
0.0446271449,
-0.0067623379,
-0.0217215344,
0.0335630029,
0.0378469303,
-0.0116159292,
0.0561638027,
0.0415037498,
0.0020527819,
0.0244577117,
-0.0045516347,
-0.0598986596,
-0.0078326808,
-0.0221938845,
0.0293792058,
-0.0064151851,
-0.0281819552,
0.0408168174,
0.0664845631,
0.0398105979,
0.0100682182,
-0.0479059331,
-0.0027611621,
-0.017161211,
-0.0073853214,
-0.0224603675,
-0.0579920225,
-0.0200575069,
0.059505403,
-0.0026805296,
0.0047673816,
0.0576114208,
-0.03833149,
0.0140211098,
-0.0548329391,
-0.0062899957,
-0.0309183225,
0.0173317883,
-0.032096073,
-0.0016842331,
0.0214132741,
-0.0377627164,
0.0237653162,
-0.0257309452,
0.0472385883,
-0.0114895497,
0.0198813807,
-0.0402409285,
0.0206925999,
0.0110979211,
-0.0235324111,
-0.0368219167,
0.0079347659,
-0.0506010912,
0.001650405,
0.0227695163,
0.0057395152,
-0.0053455746,
0.0101794042,
-0.002822855,
-0.000277607,
0.0476752445,
0.004574155,
-0.0053714537,
-0.0136686787,
0.0080475491,
0.0384342037,
-0.0046244352,
0.0187356044,
-0.0016641503,
0.0831720233,
0.0093535427,
0.0162649676,
-0.0172020998,
-0.0298132077,
0.0086598061,
-0.0257275533,
-0.0295526516,
-0.0129000694,
0.0443322696,
-0.0001784492,
0.0223225318,
0.1266856641,
0.0573723949,
-0.0147943702,
-0.0111010019,
-0.0395205058,
-0.0214394815,
0.0286525488,
-0.0180896632,
-0.0925775692,
-0.0119896466,
-0.0196782481,
-0.0130210854,
-0.000880439,
-0.0525088757,
-0.0186832231,
-0.0601301827,
0.0141571406,
-0.0082308613,
0.0013084601,
-0.0222915057,
-0.0668780208,
0.0231897514,
-0.0047375704,
-0.0098867705,
-0.0143539896,
0.0561043136,
-0.0032623946,
0.0371600948,
-0.037103001,
-0.0089111496,
0.0239707232,
-0.031685546,
0.0446221195,
0.0219941661,
0.0808468238,
0.0200543106,
-0.0330232196,
0.0113724321,
-0.00728497,
-0.0161444545,
-0.0147070419,
-0.0241630562,
-0.0312257018,
0.0035836222,
-0.0124442633,
0.0441493914,
-0.0058118571,
-0.0328681283,
0.0236759651,
0.0379051827,
-0.0577280931,
0.0071835769,
0.0203956589,
0.0925365239,
0.0402087308,
0.081085138,
0.0363286659,
0.0145889781,
0.0159774031,
-0.0237779096,
0.0532292016,
-0.0246482193,
-0.0337474048,
-0.0272723995,
0.0260789953,
0.0221205801,
-0.101981245,
-0.0296095479,
0.00356393,
0.0147524057,
0.0185775347,
0.0011564043,
0.0634412616,
0.0167282075,
-0.0336728953,
0.0046620127,
-0.0003032282,
-0.0106194513,
-0.0176731888,
-0.0284711607,
0.0269330665,
0.0052620461,
-0.0502392799,
0.0162197147,
-0.001776276,
-0.0731848031,
0.0113513395,
-0.0144575154,
0.0251176562,
0.0053057121,
0.0120101599,
0.0091831926,
-0.0424934365,
-0.0247223862,
-0.0132893706,
0.0117478352,
0.0322223976,
0.0548058227,
-0.0016619719,
0.0127493599,
0.0221079737,
0.0403616279,
-0.016973801,
0.0215350147,
-0.0825887322,
-0.0890513435,
0.0284305625,
-0.0125858365,
0.0391207188,
0.0212378986,
0.0128393937,
-0.038860213,
0.005669632,
-0.0125232693,
-0.0167026967,
-0.0074024634,
0.0096226307,
-0.0150053902,
-0.0287830234,
-0.0075885025,
0.0114498753,
-0.0551072136,
0.0574091598,
0.0118903564,
-0.0091933068,
0.023713477,
-0.0029934272,
-0.0388649553,
-0.0259885937,
-0.0132528571,
0.026901748,
0.0099255601,
0.036317911,
0.0151841845,
0.0704025254,
0.0159135684,
-0.0461569279,
0.0410592891,
0.0033613702,
-0.0034514593,
-0.0224733911,
-0.0090055484,
0.0703521222,
0.0496390201,
-0.008363408,
0.0753152594,
-0.0336439535,
0.0161736403,
0.0076789553,
0.0574240535,
-0.0043902006,
-0.072960861,
0.0317535661,
-0.015755225,
-0.0394984633,
-0.0004624368,
0.0240381937,
-0.0758501515,
0.0164430141,
0.00333085,
-0.0224281549,
-0.0626834407,
-0.0230720732,
-0.0031317358,
0.0507065207,
-0.0115686962,
0.0297224168,
-0.0605301932,
-0.0081869867,
0.0353477933,
0.023602467,
0.0230909977,
0.0405589938,
0.0354274288,
0.0494044684,
0.0017383005,
-0.0032372139,
-0.0102014644,
0.0009243895,
-0.0349362083,
0.0087616276,
-0.047089044,
-6.016128292e-33,
-0.0438760482,
-0.0281660091,
-0.0219755229,
0.0737332776,
-0.0039343555,
-0.0187708046,
-0.0251045395,
0.02771689,
-0.0132366093,
0.0436432324,
0.0041627507,
0.0408440232,
0.0252930969,
-0.0007000325,
0.0021467535,
-0.0208617337,
0.03661054,
0.0101703741,
-0.0532104075,
-0.0127908774,
0.0791547224,
-0.0248671919,
0.060611587,
-0.1032389551,
0.0382106006,
0.0286445748,
-0.0240937937,
0.0026170877,
-0.0211979058,
0.01322689,
-0.0021075145,
0.0121259447,
0.0027788992,
-0.0308605563,
0.0049754726,
0.0990459025,
-0.0190226864,
-0.0388892293,
0.0578169227,
-0.0082929581,
-0.0276484434,
0.0249140784,
-0.0123836296,
-0.0263632946,
-0.0076252217,
0.0416718498,
0.0375742912,
0.0042562056,
0.0382048935,
0.0145200593,
-0.0578303374,
0.0303854961,
-0.0275232513,
-0.0230635013,
-0.004718144,
-0.0059657795,
0.02503464,
-0.0375214964,
-0.0717742369,
0.0541636758,
-0.0757559538,
0.0090678288,
0.0209310353,
-0.0583555661,
0.0193455629,
0.0990236253,
-0.0134677812,
0.0080840532,
-0.0463057496,
-0.0146520557,
-0.0265142135,
0.0195448212,
0.0386252776,
0.0445900783,
-0.0176501255,
0.0027708514,
-0.0598918311,
0.0190879442,
0.0629145429,
0.0326421782,
-0.0009435306,
0.0153031452,
-0.0299229249,
-0.0134610562,
-0.034508083,
-0.0161404107,
-0.0035311438,
0.0075707482,
-0.0145026566,
0.0041971989,
-0.0604483895,
0.0417242125,
0.0183318108,
-0.0113583347,
-0.0163200907,
0.0188251827,
0.0264440794,
-0.0023177778,
-0.0007275043,
-0.0129845683,
-0.0693777651,
0.0080211991,
0.0032895354,
-0.0119777555,
0.0293392818,
-0.0104437731,
-0.0121021494,
-0.0471824594,
-0.026347382,
-0.0192078482,
-0.0022059751,
0.0114819445,
-0.0671509355,
-0.0219288077,
0.0609415807,
0.0535279959,
-0.0102077443,
0.002601895,
0.0146214468,
0.0315652303,
-0.0358922854,
-0.0197468624,
-0.0191109944,
0.0147571433,
-0.0264237244,
-0.0176629275,
0.0175678059,
-0.0007218397,
-0.0071061454,
0.0031530231,
-0.0110280523,
-0.0503753945,
2.599e-7,
0.027392827,
0.0473939702,
0.0415498614,
-0.0054377629,
0.0280307177,
0.036953941,
0.0109077273,
0.0099827582,
0.0361824743,
-0.0999385491,
-0.0363682471,
-0.0256461557,
0.0387000702,
0.035865888,
-0.0862936527,
-0.0221239161,
-0.042584803,
-0.0706586465,
-0.0211807452,
-0.0195398629,
0.0704524368,
0.0307313763,
0.0407863781,
0.0154126128,
-0.032524962,
0.0258126091,
0.0218192916,
-0.0321725644,
-0.0028660346,
0.0275270399,
0.0258989409,
-0.0570401624,
-0.0261506904,
0.0680653006,
0.0009735962,
0.0174454637,
0.0037250631,
0.0222662482,
-0.0129236123,
-0.0445829369,
-0.0703028664,
0.0180047806,
-0.0063798241,
-0.015419486,
-0.0026439684,
-0.0672012419,
-0.0384914093,
-0.0632651299,
-0.0181804691,
-0.0100219697,
0.0249291733,
0.041679129,
-0.008926698,
-0.0167419855,
-0.0053843646,
0.0129892891,
-0.0081988536,
-0.0672497675,
-0.0094738854,
0.0026699689,
-0.0400643609,
-0.0403773226,
0.0069810837,
-0.0216517299,
0.0065601701,
-0.0288633946,
-0.0237375628,
1.798819631e-34,
0.0003672827,
-0.0007652522,
0.0010294388,
0.0113145588,
0.0502895601,
-0.0025617743,
-0.001813322,
0.0150687806,
0.0365862139,
0.0035808091,
-0.012244503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10751v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10751v2 | ProAgent: From Robotic Process Automation to Agentic Process Automation | 2023-11-02T14:32:16 | 2023-11-23T12:14:08 | Yining Ye, Xin Cong, Shizuo Tian, Jiannan Cao, Hao Wang, Yujia Qin, Yaxi Lu, Heyang Yu, Huadong Wang, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | From ancient water wheels to robotic process automation (RPA), automation
technology has evolved throughout history to liberate human beings from arduous
tasks. Yet, RPA struggles with tasks needing human-like intelligence,
especially in elaborate design of workflow construction and dynamic
decision-making in workflow execution. As Large Language Models (LLMs) have
emerged human-like intelligence, this paper introduces Agentic Process
Automation (APA), a groundbreaking automation paradigm using LLM-based agents
for advanced automation by offloading the human labor to agents associated with
construction and execution. We then instantiate ProAgent, an LLM-based agent
designed to craft workflows from human instructions and make intricate
decisions by coordinating specialized agents. Empirical experiments are
conducted to detail its construction and execution procedure of workflow,
showcasing the feasibility of APA, unveiling the possibility of a new paradigm
of automation driven by agents. Our code is public at
https://github.com/OpenBMB/ProAgent. | [
0.0203286055,
0.0264130216,
-0.0494216159,
-0.0062826937,
-0.0603430644,
-0.0168119445,
0.022465419,
0.0182790626,
0.0043563196,
-0.0254233088,
-0.0119187171,
0.0637827367,
-0.0368007682,
0.0583299585,
-0.0088890921,
-0.0416136496,
0.0007546879,
-0.0453946479,
0.0304209925,
0.0102689601,
-0.035377264,
-0.0100342389,
-0.0134203527,
0.0386139825,
0.0045980448,
0.0115178544,
-0.033298362,
0.0046085324,
0.0078146253,
0.0070890761,
-0.0147616686,
0.0479259714,
0.0314672329,
0.0594233014,
0.0000020693,
-0.0814511329,
0.0470224507,
0.0278488752,
-0.0399555042,
-0.0401658341,
0.0233347267,
0.020046439,
-0.0312685519,
0.0227102265,
-0.0172487572,
0.0050135707,
0.0401262566,
0.0512444079,
0.047795631,
0.0394386612,
-0.0104400935,
0.0044841142,
0.0112205353,
0.0285997968,
-0.0313075073,
-0.0466326773,
0.0111497706,
-0.0290175974,
0.0665297657,
0.0108943693,
0.0263685379,
-0.0203394555,
0.0284691732,
-0.0379503518,
-0.0398870111,
0.0203005988,
0.0061049373,
-0.0819705278,
-0.0202547107,
0.0512582511,
0.00000904,
-0.0073792129,
0.0206104983,
0.0114289699,
-0.0060084839,
-0.0107814008,
-0.0162689239,
0.0620842017,
0.0125898449,
-0.0325686894,
-0.0253434144,
-0.0206212364,
-0.032607615,
-0.0162027683,
-0.0062179212,
0.0913342535,
0.0004099691,
0.0223724991,
-0.0402138196,
-0.0213871691,
0.0532838106,
-0.0588156134,
0.0293875393,
0.0756830424,
-0.0482337326,
-0.002882299,
-0.0205676723,
0.0000942332,
0.0129414229,
-0.0299249869,
-0.0104950508,
0.0285031144,
0.0316618606,
0.0220769141,
-0.0271540098,
0.0497162901,
-0.0106938705,
0.0328365415,
-0.0474923253,
-0.006332424,
-0.0616905652,
0.0073383991,
-0.0633577257,
-0.0022654913,
-0.0249654148,
-0.0128728356,
0.0128476536,
0.0901080593,
-0.050582625,
0.0656206459,
-0.0221023876,
-0.0048233941,
-0.0032479053,
-0.0387530737,
-0.0478755124,
0.0030851434,
-0.037431471,
0.0337640643,
-0.0077119595,
0.0118589532,
0.023848176,
0.0352391712,
0.0073197335,
0.0116887791,
0.0039255498,
0.1172664613,
0.0120245926,
0.0160960853,
-0.0271358658,
-0.0668872297,
0.090273723,
-0.0554689579,
-0.0254339091,
-0.0433030352,
0.0467072353,
0.0164052267,
-0.0396795087,
-0.025015939,
-0.0017399398,
0.0056998064,
-0.005082184,
0.0406580232,
-0.0007667177,
0.05675615,
0.0018119073,
-0.0032353459,
-0.0177128389,
0.0209279153,
0.0426637791,
0.050819695,
0.0233480632,
0.0033185082,
0.0608487055,
0.0388021171,
-0.0780836865,
-0.0028134827,
0.0336647779,
0.0080401609,
0.0142130898,
0.0124408063,
0.0217782985,
-0.0046403878,
0.0116132302,
0.0415113606,
0.0601873249,
0.0498815551,
-0.05829769,
0.0125654414,
0.0460454412,
0.0722277537,
-0.0029744173,
-0.0268118046,
-0.0242779646,
0.0433304347,
-0.0223284215,
-0.017071072,
-0.0619947761,
0.0149408737,
-0.0342372283,
-0.0338918902,
0.0310923997,
-0.0419120267,
0.0422951318,
-0.0251651946,
0.051333636,
0.0092821065,
-0.0542965904,
0.009962826,
-0.0312380381,
-0.0297452789,
-0.0728979185,
-0.0763974935,
0.0244390089,
0.0656779334,
0.0554699525,
-0.0347215086,
-0.0057071685,
0.0088574206,
0.0034365526,
0.0346679688,
-0.005223895,
-0.0154857254,
-0.0626589581,
-0.0110707218,
-0.0378881469,
0.0341362469,
0.0158102661,
0.0203008261,
-0.0015050813,
-0.0175096355,
-0.0133185284,
0.017662568,
-0.0559759401,
0.0272049829,
-0.0126540074,
-0.0367289558,
-0.0151248435,
0.0148147373,
0.0373670869,
-0.0044906558,
-0.0200421885,
0.0186262093,
0.069318153,
-0.008163753,
-0.0547304004,
0.0337435678,
0.037021637,
0.0628738925,
-0.0071012084,
-0.0038436074,
0.015685305,
0.0004323389,
-0.0250730347,
-0.0423825197,
0.0262211375,
-0.017520085,
0.014712316,
0.036158368,
0.0513983779,
-0.0268793926,
-0.0139875934,
-0.024917854,
0.0282408521,
0.0286226962,
-0.036014054,
-0.0019194678,
0.0430935584,
0.0111239515,
0.0203489382,
0.0220971089,
0.0553818718,
0.0167189334,
0.0320070833,
0.0502209924,
0.0204179566,
0.003616408,
-0.0329890586,
-0.0470337979,
-0.0197496116,
0.0091172168,
-0.0151385544,
-0.0022299185,
-0.013377198,
-0.0035064949,
-0.0092764255,
0.0191603098,
0.0970067084,
0.0081704753,
0.0150016639,
0.0333387069,
-0.0124570904,
-0.0722844824,
-0.0059031998,
0.0084681287,
0.0010985367,
-0.0011790863,
0.0446427837,
0.0270562284,
-0.1016239747,
0.0366347097,
0.009431174,
-0.0009411937,
0.0100976424,
-0.0449725389,
0.0158152431,
-0.0116383415,
-0.0243057217,
0.0666127577,
-0.0570827127,
0.0142589761,
0.0758659169,
0.0016570669,
-0.0225112662,
-0.0006196175,
-0.0189075433,
-0.0108461455,
-0.0085212095,
-0.0028613226,
0.0027037377,
0.0399598852,
-0.02073,
0.0023918585,
0.0003315735,
0.0062602432,
0.0251898319,
-0.0316770673,
0.0456245355,
-0.0557320267,
-0.0348895751,
0.0532868132,
-0.0383219533,
-0.0473544784,
0.0550568514,
-0.0014234731,
-0.011483971,
-0.0070839287,
-0.0384072438,
-0.0378955193,
0.0824006945,
0.0414933376,
0.0008785297,
-0.0561236553,
-0.0051328875,
-0.046256464,
0.0319691189,
0.0076036407,
-0.0012383995,
0.0169164985,
-0.0776809752,
0.0263025276,
-0.0153232152,
-0.031171849,
-0.0336367004,
0.0516819879,
-0.0440730527,
0.0432400182,
-0.0355798192,
-0.0567760877,
-0.0334316865,
-0.0030744595,
0.0601307862,
0.0650597289,
0.03537108,
-0.0133040762,
-0.0727838576,
-0.0307289176,
-0.0133146849,
0.0101426281,
-0.0262753721,
0.046012532,
0.0477108695,
0.0398282036,
0.0383786522,
-0.0253882911,
-0.0285034589,
-0.0283165071,
0.0124247838,
-0.0174747258,
0.036140196,
0.0046426971,
0.01633274,
-0.0464546904,
0.0004636345,
0.0530507006,
0.0278630909,
-0.0446061417,
0.0328148045,
0.0006795056,
-0.0213750564,
0.0233115666,
0.0485691316,
-0.0311366059,
-0.0139243603,
0.0077687218,
-0.0305771697,
-0.0329159424,
-0.0090420377,
0.0075906254,
-0.0585402884,
0.0661589727,
-0.0311365258,
0.0069782916,
-0.0355115458,
-0.0693969727,
0.0282593183,
0.0070325094,
-0.0168107469,
0.0275107641,
0.0191862136,
-0.0386325456,
-0.0136497673,
-0.0248821173,
-0.0323369913,
0.0368390158,
-0.0164123531,
-0.0099241538,
0.083843559,
0.0138584692,
-0.0274583735,
-0.0218627788,
0.0313511267,
0.0318694115,
0.0154937636,
-0.0069601354,
-0.0023709442,
0.0517896153,
-0.0138909901,
-0.0266044922,
0.0105919596,
-0.0894934162,
-0.0303373858,
0.0242639966,
0.0953347832,
-0.0237171613,
-0.0540552251,
-0.0361700766,
-0.0454399325,
0.0201656353,
0.0257588327,
-0.0464816615,
-0.0512168854,
-0.0667675957,
-0.0324364044,
-0.0395914279,
0.0317413509,
-0.0440086983,
-0.0161408912,
-0.0174753089,
-0.0653083771,
-0.0521285161,
-0.0568665788,
0.0509882197,
0.0236025043,
0.0379413702,
-0.04468235,
0.0622068346,
0.0247486625,
-0.0374917798,
-0.0536059588,
-0.0241452903,
0.0386971682,
-0.0102774445,
-0.033543095,
0.002568271,
-0.0130688865,
-0.0118803876,
0.0070584049,
-0.0350337811,
-0.023706153,
0.0319830887,
0.0451008938,
0.0327597149,
-0.0177355781,
-0.0262786709,
-0.011686421,
0.0368759334,
-0.0242161583,
-0.0302292779,
0.0210182108,
-0.0204778071,
0.0159998909,
0.0050712312,
0.0050592399,
-0.0608957857,
0.0318212584,
-0.006368726,
0.0017416446,
-0.0568074249,
-0.052108217,
0.0213224124,
0.041978579,
-0.0642850548,
0.0290618837,
0.0084502371,
-0.020666616,
0.0289584473,
-0.0055744611,
-0.0175766163,
-0.0547476597,
0.0192568135,
-0.0640262216,
-0.0243947115,
0.0815148726,
-0.0101580499,
-0.0112143895,
0.002585924,
0.0444418378,
0.0322022773,
-0.0122950748,
0.0507676192,
0.0245977566,
0.0182477701,
0.0015919837,
0.0425713696,
-0.0048202137,
0.0614774488,
0.0094620539,
0.0518490113,
0.0014670192,
0.0035596711,
-0.0675400272,
0.015315773,
-0.0641844198,
-0.0632880926,
0.0353753977,
0.0540427603,
0.0496927537,
-0.0003347054,
0.0219622627,
-0.0855019838,
0.0235325638,
-0.0217860881,
0.0059186881,
0.0043587717,
-0.0000050646,
-0.035863664,
0.0303767342,
0.0098743308,
-0.0303113237,
0.0335426256,
-0.0328226723,
0.0582618341,
-0.0487515032,
-0.0644587129,
-0.0579816513,
-0.0662814528,
0.0087366691,
-0.0301055592,
-0.0169884879,
-0.0123155266,
-0.0499134026,
-0.010250886,
-0.0547976941,
0.023171274,
0.013374907,
-0.0498940833,
0.0219479445,
0.0622634627,
0.0087449346,
-0.0294239111,
-0.0234643314,
-0.0449607931,
0.0047534215,
0.0017673052,
-0.0443132557,
-5.529778158e-33,
0.0130962236,
-0.0688854754,
0.0613583475,
0.0432679504,
0.0123307602,
-0.0574451387,
-0.03922287,
0.01419638,
0.0212483294,
0.0466910675,
-0.0061534131,
-0.011796766,
0.020831665,
-0.0303910673,
0.0650759637,
0.0410046764,
0.0494453274,
-0.0279229861,
-0.0142242815,
0.0138749117,
0.0296280794,
-0.0253796019,
-0.0197454672,
-0.0215652939,
0.0175209492,
-0.005559301,
-0.0112374304,
0.0398637541,
-0.0055246321,
0.0149281071,
-0.0118036382,
0.0284290109,
0.0298977476,
0.0347635373,
-0.0176073126,
0.0220708363,
0.0064859795,
-0.0364435837,
-0.0403708071,
0.027126018,
-0.0454528742,
-0.028783096,
0.0400809124,
-0.0254446175,
-0.0482898504,
0.0582761653,
0.0242571831,
-0.0118860099,
0.0227792282,
0.0276449248,
-0.1114178151,
0.0000668118,
0.0290548299,
-0.0215286557,
0.0208195373,
-0.0050470694,
-0.0078898035,
-0.0647294521,
-0.0748498812,
0.0377088189,
-0.0398980454,
-0.0340623781,
0.0336449593,
-0.0061104009,
0.0045637651,
-0.0220846739,
0.0226619747,
0.0498820767,
-0.00292326,
0.0465563834,
-0.0253548119,
0.0961860567,
0.0182754472,
-0.0238834582,
-0.0603263415,
-0.0203379169,
0.0021649303,
0.0476145446,
0.022875607,
0.0733075961,
0.0539809503,
-0.0001826509,
-0.0381244794,
-0.0014797171,
-0.0056599192,
-0.0068706307,
-0.002308591,
0.0064569307,
-0.0097110542,
0.045295231,
0.0342651643,
-0.0672152862,
0.021207815,
-0.0167562254,
-0.019649446,
-0.018742552,
-0.033554282,
0.0310612731,
-0.0060139783,
-0.0079157334,
0.0060927742,
-0.0441816151,
-0.0322468281,
0.0025182727,
0.0403959528,
0.0267385803,
-0.050193537,
0.0387395844,
-0.0219250098,
0.0284894593,
-0.0782430619,
0.0027407736,
0.0349556319,
-0.0145710316,
-0.0164019652,
0.0093167434,
0.0134141268,
0.0107364058,
-0.0174827836,
-0.0537249409,
0.0146761741,
0.0789834633,
-0.0200328846,
0.004720672,
-0.0530382842,
-0.0147364242,
-0.0742866918,
0.0610232539,
0.0486936457,
-0.0084016137,
-0.0033154653,
0.0037566666,
2.86e-7,
-0.0396646783,
0.0176219624,
0.0021452748,
0.0742367804,
0.0677003339,
0.0751939043,
-0.0284201894,
0.0118670883,
-0.0368040055,
0.0043215537,
0.0394979417,
0.0066583329,
0.0144629255,
0.0059069884,
-0.0756965131,
-0.0415471941,
0.02701075,
-0.0004825042,
-0.0454689972,
-0.0139428778,
0.0668167025,
0.0339859389,
0.0239828192,
-0.0240639467,
-0.0222019292,
-0.0332502872,
-0.0283837412,
-0.0097587658,
0.0529422574,
0.0283463392,
-0.0266809817,
-0.005370575,
0.0070765517,
0.0229229517,
0.0028746584,
-0.0134949032,
-0.0284399576,
0.0839152485,
-0.0253755841,
0.009860307,
0.0074398229,
-0.0441692732,
0.0188516025,
0.0039803749,
0.009182048,
-0.0377623737,
-0.0338821262,
-0.0016676015,
-0.010002058,
0.0015496775,
-0.0438430198,
0.0041250726,
0.0137950722,
0.0190207716,
-0.022030266,
-0.0271070786,
0.0047499714,
-0.0370399803,
0.0288780667,
-0.02858725,
-0.0728186965,
-0.0475903042,
-0.0211507715,
-0.0052261078,
0.0257219709,
0.0329049453,
0.0146038365,
2.634775538e-34,
0.0004711527,
0.0072282213,
0.006761984,
0.0641285405,
0.0075389543,
0.0413558371,
-0.0226561073,
0.0382016152,
0.0435300209,
-0.0625590011,
-0.0226918627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01270v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01270v3 | People Make Better Edits: Measuring the Efficacy of LLM-Generated Counterfactually Augmented Data for Harmful Language Detection | 2023-11-02T14:31:25 | 2024-02-25T11:17:42 | Indira Sen, Dennis Assenmacher, Mattia Samory, Isabelle Augenstein, Wil van der Aalst, Claudia Wagner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | NLP models are used in a variety of critical social computing tasks, such as
detecting sexist, racist, or otherwise hateful content. Therefore, it is
imperative that these models are robust to spurious features. Past work has
attempted to tackle such spurious features using training data augmentation,
including Counterfactually Augmented Data (CADs). CADs introduce minimal
changes to existing training data points and flip their labels; training on
them may reduce model dependency on spurious features. However, manually
generating CADs can be time-consuming and expensive. Hence in this work, we
assess if this task can be automated using generative NLP models. We
automatically generate CADs using Polyjuice, ChatGPT, and Flan-T5, and evaluate
their usefulness in improving model robustness compared to manually-generated
CADs. By testing both model performance on multiple out-of-domain test sets and
individual data point efficacy, our results show that while manual CADs are
still the most effective, CADs generated by ChatGPT come a close second. One
key reason for the lower performance of automated methods is that the changes
they introduce are often insufficient to flip the original label. | [
0.0766840056,
0.0338453427,
-0.0280918833,
0.0255912915,
-0.0293928422,
0.0342482291,
-0.0022475158,
0.0079843178,
0.0347647816,
-0.0782335699,
-0.0153254261,
-0.0086677717,
-0.0166237596,
0.0584978871,
0.0227758754,
-0.0009965308,
0.0470280312,
0.0490629897,
0.0278081428,
-0.010879986,
0.0269036535,
0.0185895972,
0.0069044637,
0.0230025146,
-0.0523918271,
-0.00250166,
0.0333740674,
0.0119331116,
0.0456282645,
-0.0105046127,
0.0362651832,
0.0504933819,
-0.0165605247,
0.0326503515,
0.0000020011,
-0.0431499109,
-0.010927733,
0.0119777005,
-0.021665737,
-0.0278629549,
0.0778549016,
-0.0486102551,
-0.048280485,
0.0392382555,
-0.0444420427,
0.041060742,
0.0565348528,
0.0473955832,
0.0745439976,
0.0805284604,
-0.0159002915,
-0.0089341383,
0.0223821979,
0.0192780551,
0.0091218771,
0.0165068731,
0.0486517884,
-0.0341570675,
-0.0399076566,
0.0210730005,
-0.0114430329,
0.020578891,
0.0086934725,
0.003603457,
0.0319781415,
-0.0118099162,
-0.0352957472,
-0.0312652625,
0.0016524886,
0.0480730534,
-0.02071926,
-0.0398810841,
0.0021075879,
-0.040788237,
0.0088490713,
0.0136904093,
-0.0030038296,
-0.0029858977,
-0.0083369873,
0.0196665321,
0.0150554646,
-0.025392279,
0.0551193766,
0.0522175767,
0.0539536215,
0.054972183,
0.0184153002,
-0.0544137992,
-0.0032111374,
-0.0066410173,
-0.0063234158,
-0.0165209733,
0.0232745744,
-0.0200671311,
0.0285834689,
0.013701654,
-0.0347716287,
-0.0579709895,
0.0470161587,
-0.0903025791,
0.0089812819,
0.0395397544,
-0.0494784638,
0.0003843902,
-0.0399307385,
0.0154335508,
0.0040532411,
0.03065883,
-0.0105821416,
-0.0169463437,
-0.0019933982,
-0.014929709,
0.0039284234,
-0.000973115,
-0.0194259267,
0.0657321289,
-0.0662275702,
0.0114086913,
-0.0785359889,
-0.0140010668,
0.0093182717,
0.022609327,
-0.008508997,
0.0088919401,
-0.0035155884,
-0.0146496492,
-0.0163517091,
0.016803544,
-0.0521713048,
-0.0717891231,
0.0118803475,
0.0113990586,
-0.0220539365,
-0.0373771116,
0.0303284805,
0.0834206417,
0.0337508097,
-0.0409395322,
-0.0498052798,
-0.0231826622,
-0.0520177893,
-0.0375680402,
0.0160555039,
-0.0734099969,
-0.0022808812,
-0.0003899246,
-0.0233477354,
-0.0611349382,
0.0180030372,
0.0324287154,
-0.0498935804,
0.0910099596,
-0.0248414855,
-0.0046120016,
0.0402539559,
0.0073521989,
-0.0319742672,
0.0818722323,
0.02902673,
0.0026821608,
0.0611578152,
-0.0091145216,
0.0216643605,
0.0692763403,
0.0549473651,
0.0262608994,
-0.0371272191,
-0.0009002976,
-0.0189364664,
-0.0414899141,
-0.0052230139,
0.0212010834,
0.0136803994,
-0.0560407043,
0.0560965985,
0.0194889493,
-0.0248463843,
0.0122528039,
0.0436179042,
0.0056994096,
-0.0506317392,
-0.009026519,
-0.0760099068,
0.0024896776,
-0.0926221386,
-0.0224067699,
-0.0038034122,
0.0393304564,
0.0037323458,
-0.0343105309,
-0.0539968759,
0.0089086471,
0.0840696096,
-0.0301022436,
0.0126361232,
0.0465434454,
-0.0131779145,
-0.0186567344,
0.0444954559,
-0.0385775492,
0.0036675637,
-0.055491697,
-0.011039013,
0.0727954656,
0.0307981856,
-0.0173083209,
-0.0249713305,
-0.0538857058,
-0.0159283429,
0.03795176,
0.0268891007,
0.0026044515,
-0.0162150562,
-0.0130204624,
-0.0162960794,
0.0114514511,
0.0316816792,
0.0069716531,
0.0838427469,
-0.002371388,
0.0333145484,
0.0098339235,
-0.0538981222,
0.0361818373,
-0.0198942032,
-0.0192613043,
0.0319140069,
0.0269169658,
0.0316845663,
0.0362661593,
-0.0098576024,
-0.0251992401,
0.0093627442,
-0.0003972602,
-0.0470892973,
0.0197000857,
-0.0013724206,
-0.039087072,
0.0295919329,
-0.0412466638,
-0.0528071709,
0.0572475716,
-0.0231087264,
0.0082248505,
0.028131038,
-0.0417875126,
0.0231925212,
-0.0526960716,
-0.0124611463,
0.0181721728,
0.0208705626,
-0.0146938125,
0.056500189,
-0.0371479765,
-0.008863654,
-0.0050679855,
-0.0082890941,
0.0111535462,
-0.0019333907,
-0.0287116989,
-0.0225729942,
-0.0068163699,
-0.0220987648,
-0.0009615447,
0.0154360272,
-0.0457425714,
0.002017386,
-0.074887149,
-0.0147120152,
-0.020459367,
-0.0309626125,
0.0162260439,
-0.0099662691,
-0.0189796928,
-0.0020593139,
-0.0202949103,
-0.0320034362,
0.0447976515,
0.0540013984,
-0.0039552734,
-0.0410256833,
-0.0223439317,
-0.0345478468,
0.0031782561,
-0.0409166962,
0.0115500223,
0.0092742853,
-0.0697699264,
0.0189223159,
-0.0187049657,
-0.0288176257,
0.0080032842,
-0.0099817803,
-0.056988094,
0.0084477691,
0.0490342192,
0.0233726706,
0.0142283132,
0.0554054938,
0.0321937576,
0.0183157194,
0.0066915858,
-0.0291470047,
0.0066496017,
-0.0283628646,
0.0082764775,
0.0267033353,
-0.08548031,
-0.0273216572,
0.0487416275,
0.0301466733,
-0.0313060917,
-0.0777115524,
0.027919976,
-0.0257604439,
-0.0672037601,
-0.0142793218,
-0.0771055818,
-0.0400828831,
-0.0028912204,
-0.0385399722,
-0.0685896277,
0.076203987,
0.0016704826,
0.0149044339,
-0.01160134,
-0.0389906913,
0.0069185356,
0.0539372191,
0.033802323,
0.0368654951,
-0.011310257,
0.0110466592,
0.0178311206,
0.004322994,
0.0328476876,
-0.0287911631,
0.0054080347,
-0.0426790826,
0.0066170809,
0.0188956,
-0.0425640084,
-0.086201027,
-0.0743644387,
-0.0055923653,
-0.0376448594,
-0.0177261494,
-0.0072436328,
0.0135656213,
0.0115659824,
-0.0076530175,
0.0076460103,
-0.0139508294,
0.0075100749,
0.018349044,
-0.0384292118,
0.02606952,
-0.0109105241,
0.0130676655,
0.0045972271,
-0.0204438698,
0.0445933267,
-0.0362215079,
-0.0259171966,
0.0196717475,
0.0163596161,
0.0028182163,
0.0098621836,
-0.0072724666,
-0.0147363013,
0.0261401162,
0.001396183,
-0.0105409184,
0.0656623393,
0.0451178551,
0.0000994082,
0.0123700872,
0.0049135406,
-0.0000518912,
0.0386738256,
-0.0347187072,
-0.0749440566,
-0.0139708659,
-0.0048073991,
0.0243242718,
-0.1033441648,
-0.0389126502,
-0.0237713195,
-0.1290070415,
0.0293829087,
-0.0000187205,
-0.0131605603,
-0.0317226574,
-0.0250350367,
0.0106064007,
-0.0289097186,
0.0098144747,
-0.0208765399,
0.0086661289,
0.0036497624,
-0.0139731597,
-0.0454676077,
-0.0218507778,
-0.0048511126,
-0.0246389657,
0.0719501898,
0.0594094917,
0.026064191,
-0.0331715718,
-0.0255525224,
0.0744118914,
0.023351226,
0.0124656241,
-0.0380791984,
0.0666891783,
-0.0247137379,
-0.0170374829,
-0.0099974982,
0.0512286574,
0.0150570078,
-0.0367040448,
0.0045982189,
0.0498606861,
0.0148855764,
0.0195652246,
-0.0591672398,
0.0343832448,
0.0056663072,
0.1177884564,
0.0236112364,
-0.0615795888,
0.0478583723,
-0.0589326695,
-0.0012227121,
-0.008886979,
-0.064302519,
-0.0265938565,
-0.0215565804,
-0.0293682739,
-0.0687025711,
-0.0502371527,
0.0235203095,
-0.0187324416,
0.0353094339,
-0.0272509456,
-0.0371540859,
-0.0132827684,
-0.0648936555,
0.0124713331,
0.0084641473,
0.041721873,
-0.0028536238,
-0.034618549,
0.0189416967,
-0.0405953228,
-0.0310443472,
0.0286121871,
-0.0663667843,
-0.0675187036,
0.0811188668,
0.0523318984,
0.0175408479,
0.0316919573,
-0.0269269384,
-0.0318568684,
0.0053025968,
0.1101645157,
-0.0450666249,
0.0144476453,
0.0397546291,
0.0059115901,
0.0177599024,
0.0057155816,
-0.0216879118,
0.0262515601,
0.0503033809,
-0.001640809,
-0.03939436,
-0.01524447,
0.0205714647,
0.0209629461,
0.0757416487,
-0.0560824536,
-0.0302888397,
-0.0223793127,
-0.0166665558,
-0.0238573626,
-0.0455602556,
-0.0054146978,
0.0094003053,
-0.0081041679,
0.0001199416,
-0.0493289419,
0.0130830165,
-0.0827725604,
0.0505791642,
-0.0475468338,
-0.0126184924,
0.0126777356,
0.0387253165,
0.0086422125,
0.0161830951,
-0.0128377732,
0.0520603433,
0.0263230037,
-0.0059357597,
0.0080667445,
0.0245409757,
-0.0037383141,
0.0075269556,
-0.0095550045,
0.0053237877,
-0.0278522316,
0.0340539441,
-0.0764213428,
0.0318946391,
0.0008730298,
-0.0324602574,
0.0422097258,
-0.0310134217,
-0.0387716219,
-0.0022405556,
-0.0020251535,
-0.0075226594,
-0.0530891418,
0.0146745062,
0.005150103,
-0.0332325995,
0.009471382,
0.0282204822,
-0.0086424248,
0.0727339685,
-0.0049958634,
-0.0225597415,
-0.0151161365,
-0.0186471008,
0.0216724854,
0.0204401389,
-0.0014826559,
0.035935428,
-0.0857465491,
-0.0676106736,
-0.0029751596,
-0.0070634689,
0.0381258726,
0.0216731504,
0.0172025394,
0.0430827625,
-0.0179905407,
-0.0042415452,
-0.0141644171,
0.0312495232,
0.0525121614,
-0.0311730374,
-0.009048719,
-6.038101955e-33,
-0.0226572603,
-0.0619190447,
-0.0122954845,
0.0001838611,
0.0153779285,
-0.0463163108,
0.0339705497,
0.0239627045,
0.0089587541,
0.0143717555,
0.0100645786,
0.0336995535,
0.0088353232,
0.0140633769,
-0.0142683713,
-0.011701175,
0.0505915172,
0.0017361338,
-0.0032233405,
-0.0137059465,
0.0179308169,
0.0105394423,
0.0667629242,
-0.1114303991,
0.0681337565,
-0.0126522658,
-0.0328718461,
0.001578736,
-0.05465414,
0.0518627688,
-0.0005308889,
0.069918938,
0.039822489,
-0.0020974847,
0.0156449825,
0.0022742499,
-0.0256116278,
-0.0050878148,
0.0411851667,
0.0142612178,
0.0090632131,
-0.0128200362,
0.0445823222,
-0.0027703107,
-0.0611489639,
0.0269445218,
0.0320229605,
-0.0502355732,
0.05012016,
0.0085463412,
-0.0653857887,
0.0362728164,
-0.0104553681,
0.0138332648,
-0.02109324,
0.0394808501,
0.0266363472,
0.0139135756,
-0.0830826834,
0.023105694,
0.0408468246,
-0.0337097608,
0.0334812626,
0.0051713637,
0.0083013289,
0.0601643696,
0.0231952742,
0.031013824,
-0.0161390398,
-0.0001518569,
0.0183813609,
0.0140711898,
0.0554091558,
0.1221389472,
0.0552767105,
-0.0635075644,
-0.0377605595,
0.0237823352,
-0.012807129,
-0.0353002921,
-0.0064951903,
-0.0326170996,
-0.0515020415,
-0.0159468874,
-0.0219555479,
-0.0421271995,
-0.025880944,
-0.0303818174,
0.0172063857,
0.0026302114,
-0.0423021093,
-0.0166609474,
-0.0195085779,
-0.0286923535,
0.0177863594,
0.0291837193,
-0.0400354713,
-0.0283400808,
0.0264007039,
0.0241547432,
-0.0318214111,
0.0209107865,
0.0211920366,
0.0036207242,
0.0267325658,
-0.0291561913,
0.0856116787,
0.0171197914,
-0.0863100067,
0.0225186422,
-0.0130189909,
0.0783649012,
-0.0138749089,
0.0113807674,
0.0257364884,
0.0403743684,
-0.0154546155,
0.0077712629,
0.0682557151,
0.0119461054,
-0.065153785,
0.0021901545,
-0.016115807,
0.0043353415,
-0.0058727106,
0.0050966642,
0.0362437293,
0.0035752489,
0.0295463838,
-0.0792727619,
0.0140616978,
-0.0203120261,
2.688e-7,
0.0270691402,
0.030201165,
0.0132087395,
0.0086554373,
0.0276042372,
0.0499432795,
-0.0071472297,
0.0167126786,
0.0458149426,
-0.0230524521,
-0.021150142,
0.0290800221,
0.006322559,
0.0499035716,
0.0013270744,
0.0261045508,
-0.0657713488,
0.0056874645,
-0.0258103386,
0.0209832322,
0.0350026377,
0.0908521563,
0.0708211288,
-0.026826689,
-0.0111619262,
0.0136778168,
0.038073685,
-0.0435090102,
-0.0110507216,
-0.0361840911,
0.0315253027,
0.0201683752,
0.0284219589,
0.0261796992,
-0.040518079,
0.0189550389,
-0.0150145683,
0.0264137816,
-0.0009181985,
-0.0181974079,
-0.0258445386,
-0.028848581,
-0.0045385356,
-0.0223518107,
0.0719228461,
0.0043616272,
0.0024741578,
-0.0404558443,
-0.0501166694,
0.0182239357,
0.033309605,
-0.057901375,
-0.0356709063,
0.0140726008,
0.0422408655,
0.0056870389,
-0.0279476736,
-0.070538424,
-0.0323847681,
-0.0076228064,
-0.0198636428,
-0.0456370711,
-0.020301953,
0.0408084467,
0.0366184004,
-0.0231031775,
0.0242129061,
2.384062337e-34,
0.035393931,
0.0043558921,
0.0000476638,
-0.035373766,
0.0235175509,
0.0376576707,
-0.000054426,
0.0037225669,
0.0148118297,
-0.0139407488,
-0.0004798488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12866v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12866v1 | Modular Blended Attention Network for Video Question Answering | 2023-11-02T14:22:17 | 2023-11-02T14:22:17 | Mingjie Zhou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In multimodal machine learning tasks, it is due to the complexity of the
assignments that the network structure, in most cases, is assembled in a
sophisticated way. The holistic architecture can be separated into several
logical parts according to the respective ends that the modules are devised to
achieve. As the number of modalities of information representation increases,
constructing ad hoc subnetworks for processing the data from divergent
modalities while mediating the fusion of different information types has become
a cumbersome and expensive problem. In this paper, we present an approach to
facilitate the question with a reusable and composable neural unit; by
connecting the units in series or parallel, the arduous network constructing of
multimodal machine learning tasks will be accomplished in a much
straightforward way. Additionally, through parameter sharing (weights
replication) among the units, the space complexity will be significantly
reduced. We have conducted experiments on three commonly used datasets; our
method achieves impressive performance compared to several video QA baselines. | [
0.0267569069,
0.0196031071,
-0.0131432228,
0.0368023701,
0.0028055748,
-0.0168080162,
0.0541934781,
-0.045896899,
-0.0228698906,
-0.0590425357,
-0.0236697458,
-0.0469862632,
-0.0167180803,
0.0421174355,
0.0660820603,
-0.0674990043,
0.055575408,
0.0174106713,
-0.0334173627,
-0.0013907007,
0.0504899919,
0.0047777854,
-0.0132153733,
0.0419826768,
-0.0730222538,
-0.0270423032,
-0.0432032198,
-0.0091572246,
0.0531889498,
-0.0150466291,
0.0018114228,
0.0106320325,
0.0534493662,
0.0170176663,
0.0000021297,
0.0075215446,
0.0020831916,
-0.0108710164,
0.0019378668,
0.0097235125,
-0.0103790211,
0.0161548574,
0.0375537798,
0.0339546502,
-0.0672424734,
0.0066524544,
0.0676136464,
-0.0253665335,
0.0573963076,
0.0208155625,
-0.0279665552,
-0.0545318201,
0.0162526667,
-0.0087762661,
0.0172205549,
-0.0450231917,
-0.0126625858,
0.039485354,
0.0565984882,
-0.0145433554,
-0.0687704459,
0.0589224435,
0.0554935522,
-0.0017300566,
0.0409861468,
0.0281831697,
-0.0205613282,
-0.0030153645,
-0.0260740966,
0.0982201919,
-0.0083706379,
0.0470278747,
-0.0219183415,
-0.0049859011,
0.0460618883,
0.0104302606,
-0.0460297242,
0.0167455319,
-0.0146936104,
-0.0196716301,
-0.0218199063,
0.0171020832,
0.0132584963,
-0.0221392643,
-0.0138570135,
-0.0098679634,
0.0071554272,
0.0263384823,
-0.0380561016,
-0.0080693429,
-0.0478318967,
-0.0535659492,
-0.0165243708,
0.0460719801,
-0.0000959724,
0.0052211192,
-0.0313784182,
-0.0536722057,
-0.0238262713,
-0.0486354083,
0.0603749566,
0.0352250226,
-0.0325737484,
0.0345534123,
-0.0131031675,
0.0303484499,
-0.0789561123,
-0.0013514755,
-0.041985523,
-0.0269046165,
-0.0720567703,
-0.0065298504,
-0.0580587536,
0.0548585281,
-0.0227625277,
-0.0416955836,
-0.0033105044,
0.0579038262,
-0.0350394323,
-0.0231634621,
-0.015448737,
0.0591616631,
0.0455422774,
-0.0110557433,
-0.0512017384,
0.0645345896,
-0.1144270152,
0.0574008562,
0.0163098723,
-0.0464289822,
-0.0083281659,
0.0194855519,
-0.0050698677,
-0.0156768374,
0.0169575848,
0.047363326,
-0.0480175801,
-0.0306049492,
-0.0205774698,
-0.025980385,
-0.038456291,
-0.0132469265,
0.0538474545,
-0.0434420295,
0.094914332,
-0.015877841,
-0.042923186,
0.0240320005,
-0.0083330963,
0.0223130602,
-0.0257039163,
0.0690784827,
-0.0099415658,
-0.0090170568,
0.0191193018,
0.0052334312,
-0.0196148995,
0.057759881,
0.0210875813,
0.0132637005,
0.0223620273,
0.0213254467,
0.0245949887,
0.0034178698,
-0.0049908385,
-0.0059451405,
-0.0339971334,
0.0142123206,
-0.0140426839,
0.0262521505,
0.0210410729,
0.0106440298,
-0.019273676,
-0.0617698245,
0.027872989,
-0.0050442326,
-0.0151464827,
0.0010228347,
0.0401368514,
-0.0004267771,
0.0195849333,
0.0205043647,
-0.0114347478,
0.117640838,
-0.0113357203,
-0.0280657262,
0.0204246603,
0.05037928,
-0.0968191475,
-0.0423200391,
-0.0106528457,
-0.0089537809,
0.0301750209,
0.0391165949,
0.0241220053,
-0.001275246,
-0.0448910184,
0.0201805737,
-0.0061391881,
0.0005737519,
0.0237250477,
-0.0120812599,
0.0349852145,
0.0404708125,
0.0208960809,
-0.0407711565,
-0.0445531495,
0.0092137558,
0.037317317,
-0.0263214298,
-0.0084950393,
-0.0337050371,
0.0199116133,
-0.0644451156,
-0.043362163,
-0.0299213901,
0.0046425313,
0.0580866262,
-0.0149377249,
-0.0071685165,
-0.0118688187,
0.0095078871,
0.0479783751,
0.0233898796,
0.0532319099,
0.0064818566,
-0.0071568857,
0.0179480091,
0.0498535782,
0.0112510044,
-0.0042224978,
-0.0067468253,
0.0155486036,
-0.0314315297,
-0.0015437016,
0.0028383806,
-0.0449027978,
-0.0256369319,
0.0077385982,
-0.0902354121,
0.0091424882,
0.0492943004,
-0.0269188005,
-0.0418636948,
0.0360368602,
-0.0228871386,
-0.0237948131,
-0.058219377,
-0.0182199888,
0.0811630636,
0.0407824144,
-0.0319548622,
0.0351705812,
-0.0306761749,
-0.022140868,
0.0018398747,
0.0112350024,
0.0262034852,
-0.0088586742,
-0.0140377646,
-0.0263099968,
-0.0190754924,
0.00522367,
-0.0287036654,
-0.0316829607,
-0.0266134925,
-0.0397238806,
-0.073862724,
-0.003440633,
-0.0226550736,
0.0031618876,
-0.0002533302,
0.0203076359,
0.0187754352,
-0.0308169387,
-0.0247944742,
0.0630237833,
0.0071309768,
0.0269461144,
0.0124778301,
0.0435948744,
0.0196606014,
-0.0018851289,
-0.0501686148,
-0.0035248136,
0.0670841336,
-0.0105849495,
-0.0097765857,
0.0015596775,
-0.0822208002,
-0.0618588105,
0.0584824346,
-0.0179335289,
-0.0462504849,
0.0070283255,
-0.0182166062,
0.0310584623,
0.070184119,
0.0030379074,
0.0058502918,
0.0339443982,
-0.0185293742,
-0.0005736688,
0.0631867498,
0.0047548315,
0.0093232477,
0.0235436149,
0.0069584697,
0.0176994372,
-0.0267944764,
-0.0164917279,
-0.0123667205,
-0.041475974,
0.0295475721,
0.0644956976,
-0.0293386001,
-0.0176645666,
-0.0137069114,
0.0075743739,
-0.0136080291,
-0.0351132154,
-0.0199740697,
0.0293147955,
0.0116033675,
-0.0328255668,
-0.0111688916,
-0.0095833195,
-0.029795872,
0.057076551,
0.0159624591,
0.0140259145,
-0.0315801241,
-0.0300253052,
-0.0849205628,
0.0070593832,
-0.0020102286,
0.0316017941,
0.044636745,
-0.0280456971,
0.0275547989,
-0.0229810979,
-0.0148511734,
-0.0590844825,
-0.0086464547,
-0.0259039607,
0.0146433245,
-0.0294221006,
0.0034620974,
-0.0256505497,
0.0057740137,
0.0620079674,
0.0107187899,
-0.0086953621,
0.0304099806,
-0.0127131166,
0.0659016296,
0.0222811345,
0.0843348876,
-0.0148292091,
-0.0266847722,
0.0446377806,
0.0464962572,
0.0502993055,
-0.0289841145,
-0.0252718776,
0.006531911,
0.0164468568,
0.0152143985,
-0.0122897457,
0.0206398014,
0.0449883752,
-0.0748155043,
0.0302651711,
0.0543636382,
0.0215865001,
-0.0420818403,
-0.0114803528,
0.0095440624,
-0.0067831492,
0.0530637354,
0.0532170162,
-0.0994395763,
-0.0385557488,
-0.0303187389,
-0.0235157032,
0.0234559737,
0.0065987245,
-0.0222910605,
-0.0740113035,
0.0493399538,
0.0006124744,
-0.0459554531,
-0.0425499566,
0.0330477729,
-0.0023241965,
0.0408406556,
-0.0135127511,
0.003133154,
0.0097511206,
-0.0023004026,
0.0130290333,
-0.0014945782,
-0.0029216681,
0.0159420185,
-0.0430710837,
0.0059476267,
0.0113712149,
-0.0211435352,
-0.030695308,
-0.0757497624,
0.0109421853,
-0.0427762829,
0.0049947705,
0.0217160825,
0.0442084149,
-0.0296224076,
-0.0530859977,
0.0093390616,
0.0198566355,
0.0162563585,
-0.0180192254,
-0.009902278,
0.0938083231,
-0.0292498544,
0.0280403644,
-0.0618263371,
0.0245715529,
0.0021828918,
0.038856741,
0.0100607863,
-0.048704233,
0.0129954461,
0.0565652214,
-0.0739042014,
-0.0469409116,
0.0094462754,
0.0469848104,
0.0066628396,
0.0316449739,
-0.0399700925,
-0.0167767499,
0.0761704221,
0.0644300058,
-0.030216733,
-0.015366924,
0.0166500304,
0.0511334799,
-0.0684687719,
0.06353762,
0.0091789505,
-0.0050957911,
-0.0521943755,
0.0035501088,
0.0311430339,
-0.0571421273,
-0.0159262866,
0.0132636735,
-0.019244764,
-0.0142929042,
-0.0223280918,
0.0579497777,
0.0022163887,
0.0227225237,
0.0108967209,
-0.0269915685,
-0.0124651361,
-0.0207735077,
-0.0007094123,
0.0184623506,
-0.0160648804,
-0.043594759,
-0.0041910312,
0.0211805888,
-0.0453965627,
0.0111913364,
-0.0159631744,
0.0134916333,
-0.0577672683,
0.008157189,
0.0024024968,
-0.0355922095,
-0.0096933674,
0.0165962614,
0.0170467719,
-0.0324919447,
0.0250513703,
0.0257591847,
0.0209371168,
-0.0912811607,
0.0298043247,
0.0008599448,
-0.0254532527,
0.0058927233,
-0.0045916787,
0.0300647113,
-0.0283448733,
0.0103866188,
0.0000503942,
-0.0177220013,
-0.0064354558,
-0.02828761,
0.0347245559,
0.0123381857,
0.0085269241,
-0.008295049,
0.0247121621,
0.0150143951,
0.0736991614,
0.0197511744,
-0.0411875583,
-0.0650149882,
0.0565102026,
-0.045125775,
-0.0162427891,
-0.0124477092,
0.0557037219,
0.0129596675,
-0.0010731235,
-0.056349121,
0.0338461176,
-0.0285369754,
-0.0154994624,
0.0408124775,
-0.0081362035,
-0.0465015545,
0.0682026818,
0.0184574872,
-0.0064839758,
-0.0324516185,
0.0574827455,
-0.0381191224,
0.0169527233,
-0.0140293222,
0.0221223254,
-0.0208822694,
-0.0255863648,
0.0349692255,
0.0679216161,
-0.0328799896,
0.0214952771,
-0.0450370722,
-0.059103895,
-0.0252286419,
0.0163662247,
-0.0001172087,
0.0239697564,
0.0647036284,
0.0065819691,
0.0404395014,
-0.0266433861,
0.0146236634,
-0.0045007481,
-0.0310539417,
-0.022798812,
0.0616890639,
-6.358440696e-33,
-0.0236734878,
-0.0137284538,
0.0208008252,
-0.0310468972,
-0.0357157737,
0.0278393496,
0.0195592288,
0.0315561406,
-0.046250917,
-0.0223691557,
-0.0005879392,
0.0153261079,
-0.0039415085,
0.0260268897,
0.0305177756,
-0.0501542203,
0.0015305105,
-0.0183166843,
0.0134032797,
0.0129449917,
0.0222029947,
0.0156379957,
0.044901941,
-0.0416626446,
-0.0435653105,
0.0207413435,
-0.0191506073,
0.0318388157,
-0.0429335795,
0.068456158,
-0.0140706152,
-0.0040857955,
0.0424739681,
-0.0211128164,
-0.0182271488,
0.031832777,
-0.0680264235,
-0.0215691943,
0.0208253507,
0.0175879933,
-0.1193340346,
-0.0227314532,
0.0535360426,
-0.0085542528,
0.0558187775,
-0.0419040918,
0.0133925583,
0.0019704716,
0.0164782815,
0.0338417776,
-0.0079594413,
-0.0022756315,
-0.0091065047,
-0.0424777977,
-0.012710941,
0.0519959815,
0.0339835547,
-0.0119082257,
-0.0484368652,
-0.0390032381,
-0.029415261,
0.0285095926,
0.0435304157,
0.0349063985,
-0.0125067225,
0.0422991887,
0.057456933,
-0.0671985,
-0.0696085319,
-0.0255308729,
-0.0184041876,
0.0559129342,
0.0705149397,
0.0286007952,
0.0424078926,
-0.0079306988,
-0.0555348471,
0.010298511,
-0.0098944977,
0.0504621267,
-0.0297684595,
0.011277792,
0.0371500887,
0.0152592333,
-0.003886634,
0.0235220212,
-0.033859361,
-0.0204960536,
0.0206505451,
-0.0061463229,
0.0190399494,
0.0126028284,
0.0783703029,
-0.041450236,
0.0628597066,
-0.0016535098,
0.0245017689,
0.0780168474,
0.0519578122,
0.0295199621,
-0.0312126856,
0.0454123206,
0.0320978798,
-0.0123832449,
-0.0486403368,
0.0370646939,
-0.0002475282,
0.05897047,
-0.0148238251,
-0.0273593143,
0.0065278294,
-0.003215061,
-0.0195752103,
0.0586627983,
0.035421785,
0.0378163233,
-0.0396618694,
-0.0091652209,
-0.0268113371,
-0.011757154,
-0.0137184551,
-0.0333055705,
-0.0107053919,
0.0374096297,
-0.0181252882,
0.0229008552,
-0.0793942958,
-0.0383614376,
0.0002463665,
-0.0708306059,
-0.005337358,
0.0616067648,
2.902e-7,
0.0151790297,
-0.0427185446,
0.0010118181,
-0.0107425982,
0.0282755978,
0.0240324587,
0.0071108048,
0.065503709,
0.0159822442,
-0.0470411628,
0.0160565469,
0.0579467155,
-0.0026767279,
0.0040334682,
-0.0576305762,
-0.0283284355,
-0.0180339124,
-0.0212155022,
-0.0342175439,
-0.0026331076,
0.0465933681,
0.1199172586,
0.0236588717,
0.0107142134,
0.0164013524,
-0.015286156,
0.0365272239,
0.0694671199,
-0.0286439713,
-0.0327054784,
0.0379802138,
0.0017176974,
-0.0274005216,
0.0266167261,
0.011863376,
-0.004992418,
0.0380306393,
0.0099005364,
-0.0179658514,
-0.0816230699,
-0.0286835711,
0.016704984,
-0.0054032048,
-0.002722695,
0.0725532398,
-0.01982297,
-0.0337658785,
-0.0087949624,
0.0003537352,
0.0307753887,
0.0033200395,
0.0224712417,
-0.0107419258,
0.015457009,
0.0085721547,
-0.0357696116,
-0.0135318814,
-0.1066363454,
0.0408952124,
-0.0089970604,
-0.0573908202,
0.007386981,
-0.0182952397,
-0.0437800549,
0.0686696842,
-0.0256669018,
-0.0844551176,
1.947392129e-34,
0.0116512794,
-0.0128573412,
0.0339550339,
-0.0005164472,
-0.0218216367,
-0.0200436749,
-0.0756858066,
-0.0217660926,
0.0304707419,
-0.0581554845,
-0.0446238779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01256v2 | An energy-based comparative analysis of common approaches to text classification in the Legal domain | 2023-11-02T14:16:48 | 2024-02-05T11:13:59 | Sinan Gultekin, Achille Globo, Andrea Zugarini, Marco Ernandes, Leonardo Rigutini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF | Most Machine Learning research evaluates the best solutions in terms of
performance. However, in the race for the best performing model, many important
aspects are often overlooked when, on the contrary, they should be carefully
considered. In fact, sometimes the gaps in performance between different
approaches are neglectable, whereas factors such as production costs, energy
consumption, and carbon footprint must take into consideration. Large Language
Models (LLMs) are extensively adopted to address NLP problems in academia and
industry. In this work, we present a detailed quantitative comparison of LLM
and traditional approaches (e.g. SVM) on the LexGLUE benchmark, which takes
into account both performance (standard indices) and alternative metrics such
as timing, power consumption and cost, in a word: the carbon-footprint. In our
analysis, we considered the prototyping phase (model selection by
training-validation-test iterations) and in-production phases separately, since
they follow different implementation procedures and also require different
resources. The results indicate that very often, the simplest algorithms
achieve performance very close to that of large LLMs but with very low power
consumption and lower resource demands. The results obtained could suggest
companies to include additional evaluations in the choice of Machine Learning
(ML) solutions. | [
0.0780239329,
0.0299934037,
0.0007683695,
0.019985849,
-0.0861718655,
0.0070548989,
0.0317718461,
0.0386642702,
-0.0034495112,
-0.1331716329,
0.0356229357,
0.0081571462,
-0.002371972,
0.0045963689,
-0.0076223095,
0.020614326,
0.0727694929,
-0.0060786274,
0.010133652,
-0.0023664336,
-0.0023685705,
0.0024289016,
0.0433653034,
0.0176627599,
-0.0213180743,
0.0384440459,
0.0150492024,
-0.0069377432,
-0.0227082428,
0.0015672761,
-0.0085499315,
0.056834735,
-0.0007433848,
0.0899905339,
0.0000018092,
-0.0674562678,
-0.0277996883,
0.0271726307,
0.0129051572,
0.0576829873,
0.0809937045,
-0.0111298375,
-0.0206804927,
0.0369018354,
0.0015187616,
0.0152862659,
0.05754802,
-0.0005070707,
0.021457307,
0.0595852882,
-0.028950749,
-0.05225363,
0.0433528423,
-0.0328016393,
-0.0296583492,
0.0052336738,
0.0496685542,
-0.0103229666,
-0.027997043,
-0.0292742085,
0.0022105733,
0.046007134,
-0.0048451293,
-0.0183273125,
0.0153196594,
0.0068714544,
-0.0549208336,
0.0070603578,
-0.0148301898,
0.0096398704,
0.0040749153,
-0.0199650228,
0.0075527113,
-0.0196430422,
-0.0266432967,
-0.0202213973,
0.0149575314,
0.0382241309,
0.0137928138,
0.0389148779,
0.0100822374,
0.0245168228,
0.0218078867,
0.0455057397,
-0.0181283206,
0.0356600285,
-0.0259190071,
-0.0337646045,
0.0681607798,
0.0360499695,
-0.0170430783,
-0.0260454081,
0.0180183947,
0.0000077716,
0.0376489051,
0.0366711281,
-0.0403156057,
-0.0302693807,
0.0380564742,
-0.1028687283,
0.0192763899,
-0.0247092769,
0.0533730462,
0.0520394892,
-0.0592460334,
0.0297904294,
-0.0055602882,
-0.0264959335,
-0.0118042044,
0.0082495827,
-0.0404551663,
0.0020905859,
-0.0467420965,
0.026681751,
-0.0332763456,
-0.0413494408,
-0.0450350717,
0.022000974,
-0.0034127787,
0.0503848642,
-0.0032929943,
-0.010063136,
0.0400023386,
0.024571795,
-0.0247915518,
-0.0072380095,
0.0138493935,
-0.0047661625,
-0.0438933969,
-0.0396449305,
0.0589241609,
0.042339772,
-0.0175445322,
0.0146716917,
0.0443710461,
0.0693179965,
0.0017306468,
-0.0501566045,
-0.0249945223,
-0.0435367078,
-0.0001633633,
-0.0449024029,
-0.0350751877,
-0.0752684027,
-0.0234497711,
0.0076400884,
-0.0015192082,
-0.0334925465,
0.035470441,
0.0268769618,
-0.0449198931,
0.0329373404,
-0.0327812284,
0.0043796781,
0.0269399062,
-0.0184561778,
-0.0109008653,
0.0777599737,
0.0586037003,
0.0080035515,
0.0378099233,
-0.0211314801,
-0.0271178801,
0.0513971411,
0.0032404249,
-0.0291895662,
-0.0473482758,
-0.0118537834,
-0.0046305461,
0.0141169894,
0.0057479134,
0.0598500259,
0.0090680905,
-0.000089751,
0.0407638215,
0.0640374571,
0.0019766761,
-0.0053556473,
-0.0268176496,
0.0312693492,
0.0128140692,
-0.0517109558,
-0.0007861914,
-0.0442845225,
-0.0472965464,
-0.0301389415,
-0.0069604176,
-0.0029546262,
-0.0070085926,
-0.0589633733,
-0.0406088717,
-0.0421527214,
0.035009142,
-0.0082595125,
0.0723014176,
-0.0489729047,
-0.0546434931,
0.0661618933,
0.0258577503,
-0.0206961595,
-0.0736991465,
-0.0408027433,
-0.0092989635,
0.0192450453,
0.0355760008,
-0.0152088646,
0.0454683788,
-0.0345012136,
-0.0283451248,
0.0157706365,
0.0541728847,
0.0110411653,
-0.0350331925,
-0.0355506614,
-0.006362184,
-0.0059713707,
-0.0094045894,
-0.0192614738,
0.0266658049,
0.0072603235,
0.0165359359,
-0.0265072193,
-0.0599312037,
0.0596491955,
0.0154232662,
-0.0318970606,
0.0209363941,
-0.0062037259,
0.0531286225,
0.0010188513,
-0.021814933,
-0.0019972734,
0.037238881,
-0.0456986204,
-0.0443235449,
-0.0233486835,
0.0237113852,
0.0349339508,
0.0124920681,
0.0243739672,
0.0180827528,
0.0385936014,
-0.0151996482,
-0.0121187288,
-0.0635397211,
-0.0564569794,
0.0635859519,
-0.0391586758,
0.0318497419,
-0.0517255627,
-0.0036209952,
-0.0615068264,
0.0468710139,
0.0037722664,
0.047566507,
-0.0197868403,
0.0009506237,
0.0567327477,
-0.0039785518,
-0.0393675193,
0.0240009651,
-0.0313278921,
0.0233717188,
0.026578648,
-0.0104652196,
0.0153419841,
-0.007231005,
-0.0670246929,
-0.0009535745,
-0.0172590036,
0.0180273596,
-0.0363367908,
-0.0536021665,
0.0019468301,
0.0074322997,
-0.0084914789,
0.0048318258,
-0.0167735033,
0.0058636358,
-0.0024875631,
-0.0236009173,
-0.0212229453,
0.0108171394,
-0.0271993391,
0.0028139038,
0.0853191763,
0.0286304019,
-0.0418672934,
-0.0371937603,
0.0852870792,
0.0127081238,
-0.0036484296,
-0.0122858314,
0.0075946972,
-0.0513615273,
0.0167209879,
-0.0220365655,
0.0392548107,
0.0320642777,
0.0062971259,
0.0526112095,
0.0350445472,
-0.062040627,
0.0065573775,
0.0136349751,
0.027996026,
-0.0454371721,
-0.0047870195,
0.0450688265,
0.0301411878,
-0.0468368307,
0.0034606401,
0.0210377872,
0.0037185538,
-0.0262041036,
-0.0227321777,
-0.0347765051,
0.011852731,
0.0040561734,
0.0212980341,
0.0293498375,
-0.0977986306,
0.0208667908,
-0.0562233105,
0.0302209985,
-0.0859016776,
-0.0437045135,
-0.0149795655,
0.0617516078,
0.0242230576,
0.0485115796,
-0.0434107929,
-0.0037929534,
0.0172788389,
-0.0073990165,
0.0370146781,
-0.019451689,
0.0376280248,
-0.0253270529,
0.061007183,
-0.0436993428,
-0.0165208559,
-0.0231225006,
-0.0489566326,
-0.0581101887,
0.0122628622,
0.0294659678,
-0.0209185574,
-0.0409357324,
0.0933671966,
0.0002793129,
0.03422793,
0.0184625238,
-0.0092884181,
0.0015464443,
0.0248771273,
0.0032609438,
-0.0313073955,
0.0044488488,
0.0175803062,
0.0091425655,
0.0474252179,
-0.006545872,
0.0261608232,
-0.0248385184,
-0.0185217075,
0.0410245247,
-0.0545901582,
-0.0383531973,
0.0123705966,
-0.0064388956,
-0.042015966,
0.02608441,
0.085610263,
0.0279219504,
-0.0432929844,
0.0098988004,
0.0597286038,
0.0037672976,
0.0082363486,
0.0343697183,
-0.0650154054,
-0.004583546,
0.0400219746,
0.0380436629,
-0.038147606,
0.010308261,
-0.0203138217,
-0.089040041,
0.0495501123,
-0.0078949817,
-0.0277000498,
0.0136899967,
-0.0768911615,
-0.0356701985,
-0.0398751833,
-0.013763194,
-0.0495629944,
-0.0157558974,
-0.0472586751,
0.0407413468,
-0.0916979387,
-0.0238609165,
-0.0013017212,
0.0019606492,
0.0177397374,
0.0498034842,
0.0133202393,
-0.0392142609,
-0.0214050319,
0.0447398759,
-0.0159025863,
0.0075621568,
-0.0553538203,
0.0035103618,
0.0301525649,
0.0136595629,
0.0202457383,
-0.0196415987,
-0.0076762135,
0.0031988209,
0.0163059719,
0.0692494512,
-0.0165786017,
-0.0290957764,
-0.0079321172,
-0.0299530141,
-0.0283516664,
0.0819196254,
-0.0161713399,
-0.0610413626,
-0.0988339186,
-0.0215427969,
-0.0225985236,
-0.0171552803,
-0.0047386959,
-0.008024863,
-0.048075296,
-0.0648871288,
0.0026942967,
0.0055373716,
-0.0148404259,
0.0568088368,
-0.0159492977,
0.0370338894,
0.0348596461,
0.0341613702,
-0.0667807534,
0.0138419988,
0.0041014408,
0.0635409802,
-0.0838439837,
-0.0172740035,
0.0535487421,
0.0317897536,
-0.0441080779,
-0.0367602855,
-0.0569907017,
-0.0616197959,
-0.0155888461,
0.0121025629,
0.0277563874,
-0.0126684317,
0.0156513192,
-0.0514115952,
0.0625852495,
0.0702043474,
-0.0105923498,
0.0096065421,
0.0177036412,
-0.0130469492,
-0.0301053952,
-0.0055194781,
-0.0262345057,
0.032081347,
0.0024159614,
0.0212096386,
-0.0262502003,
-0.0281030238,
-0.0166544523,
0.0591087863,
0.0235773455,
-0.0307755489,
-0.0298215412,
0.0118363854,
-0.0020233211,
0.0300307106,
0.0052111926,
-0.0401228406,
-0.0425689183,
0.014973483,
0.0094229672,
-0.0319072604,
0.0656620935,
0.0134786228,
-0.0331484191,
-0.0257738065,
0.0191783775,
0.0188873392,
0.0404389948,
0.0281178076,
0.0126840984,
-0.0394516438,
-0.0407460891,
0.0291620195,
-0.0096791638,
-0.0241198447,
0.0270566568,
0.0330020189,
0.036578916,
-0.0379339978,
0.0445225537,
-0.0070556975,
-0.0068753245,
-0.0095554693,
-0.0016323947,
0.0338011235,
0.0112228142,
0.0055465885,
-0.0695210993,
-0.0399543718,
-0.0185871981,
0.0250068009,
-0.0014130645,
-0.0059478721,
0.027130343,
0.013216313,
-0.0556328259,
0.0541487485,
0.0586846359,
0.0520448796,
0.0132665476,
-0.0030245853,
-0.0337729566,
-0.0385147259,
-0.0077142259,
-0.00063725,
-0.0071719391,
-0.0139561407,
-0.0191252008,
-0.0658820421,
-0.0241664294,
0.0323598124,
-0.042379085,
0.0431751311,
-0.0253624618,
0.0245554037,
0.083319135,
0.0439320952,
-0.0159510709,
-0.0189330429,
-0.0121357497,
-0.0283268783,
-0.0078091403,
-0.0043458752,
-5.502940519e-33,
0.0269017462,
-0.04947621,
0.0018887246,
0.0446464419,
-0.0168486666,
0.0594508387,
0.0193110332,
-0.0303199943,
-0.015711654,
-0.0238087326,
0.0007895503,
-0.0268247649,
0.0119378231,
0.0142037757,
0.0196008552,
0.0258299075,
0.0234451815,
-0.0140313199,
-0.0276748184,
-0.0074141272,
0.013711703,
0.0241229478,
-0.0074860048,
-0.0634384602,
-0.0092956377,
0.0268464945,
-0.0010061942,
-0.0089877527,
-0.0180831142,
0.032053791,
-0.0247582942,
0.0818061829,
0.0265152901,
-0.0283854567,
0.019682359,
0.0470526218,
-0.02787726,
0.0099753281,
-0.0369197167,
0.018624112,
0.0391739942,
-0.0063029737,
0.0415779315,
0.0296861697,
-0.0792026296,
0.0336526819,
0.0398420691,
-0.0315383114,
-0.087119177,
-0.0560979284,
-0.0398563221,
0.0228334405,
0.0120907733,
0.0371414423,
0.0276610311,
0.0152791189,
-0.0175353885,
0.0574601218,
-0.0711705089,
-0.0006114195,
0.0126076862,
0.0079344753,
0.042742528,
-0.0006759949,
0.0048725605,
0.0457243882,
0.0166119952,
0.0059097372,
-0.0298292264,
0.0152862538,
0.0601432025,
0.0429113954,
0.0447574407,
0.0158519894,
0.0674888417,
-0.0257670637,
-0.0833839849,
-0.0021346703,
0.0859246403,
0.0002787873,
0.0249341242,
-0.003025997,
-0.0050930097,
-0.0585657656,
-0.0409576595,
0.0044315308,
0.0175751317,
-0.0031299444,
0.0244676769,
0.0031513323,
-0.0138879074,
-0.0174966063,
0.0102294246,
-0.0591685735,
-0.0315381959,
0.0369636156,
0.0225131586,
0.0493404046,
0.0031937859,
0.042269852,
-0.0809940174,
-0.0643034577,
-0.0347453319,
-0.0102768503,
0.0193272475,
-0.0451953933,
0.022402294,
0.0138861034,
-0.047710143,
0.0114547834,
-0.0010738608,
-0.0074029071,
0.0380629189,
0.02554374,
-0.0102890851,
-0.0038879407,
0.0620206334,
0.0350592099,
-0.0053699506,
0.0050631631,
-0.006573169,
-0.0264614336,
-0.008701208,
-0.0132384887,
0.0047262306,
0.0094735771,
-0.0162582267,
0.0634062365,
0.0171469115,
-0.0308422931,
-0.0105223525,
0.011310433,
2.552e-7,
0.0596753694,
0.0606606007,
-0.0526545346,
-0.0259797368,
-0.0006899792,
0.0401786752,
0.0176857375,
0.0002318355,
-0.0316262506,
0.027329186,
-0.0201097243,
-0.0325720012,
0.0873075202,
0.0082495473,
-0.0437686704,
-0.0116840592,
-0.0813569725,
0.0268816445,
-0.0657830611,
0.0335968584,
0.0253112912,
0.0598045141,
0.0247390401,
-0.0374282151,
-0.0190463569,
-0.0518096015,
0.0404013954,
-0.0718977302,
0.0307567399,
0.0016733581,
0.0703139827,
-0.0043874243,
0.0122644994,
0.0161208753,
-0.0081372419,
0.0303747691,
-0.0208282974,
0.0458100624,
-0.0244624577,
0.0223597605,
0.0396135412,
-0.0400445014,
-0.0059581385,
-0.0190940797,
0.0685126483,
0.0141206309,
-0.0369871184,
-0.0299863145,
0.0020393955,
-0.0547734797,
0.0246736649,
0.0063808793,
0.0030339104,
0.0009529761,
0.0061225533,
-0.064122431,
-0.0101410691,
-0.0561629273,
0.0309540275,
-0.0092549343,
-0.018556701,
-0.0145257525,
-0.0278416052,
0.0609567724,
0.0667834505,
-0.0029467978,
0.0374803618,
2.490680823e-34,
0.0172458235,
-0.0338892192,
-0.0013534167,
0.0399565697,
-0.0155893546,
0.0544774979,
0.0109831179,
0.0012704254,
-0.0638433844,
-0.0982853994,
0.0367745683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04919v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04919v1 | The Impact of Preference Agreement in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback: A Case Study in Summarization | 2023-11-02T13:21:23 | 2023-11-02T13:21:23 | Sian Gooding, Hassan Mansoor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) can be used to capture
complex and nuanced properties of text generation quality. As a result, the
task of text summarization has been identified as a good candidate for this
process. In this paper, we explore how preference agreement impacts the
efficacy of RLHF for summarization. We show that sampling human preferences to
include a range of annotator agreement results in (1) higher accuracy reward
models and (2) alters the characteristics of quality captured. We additionally
show improvements in downstream generation when using a reward model trained
with a range of preference agreements. Our contributions have implications for
the design of synthetic datasets as well as the importance of considering
quality differentials in comparison-based data. | [
0.0485291593,
0.0353858136,
0.0164485611,
-0.0379692838,
-0.005662642,
0.0045624669,
-0.0147109833,
-0.0230260417,
-0.0410122722,
-0.0332659259,
-0.0099168038,
-0.0369560681,
0.0263813622,
-0.0043875575,
0.0196971297,
-0.1063991785,
0.0184382703,
-0.0106458366,
0.008488222,
-0.002968702,
0.0388019457,
0.0008588519,
0.0245947521,
0.0418964326,
0.0012875111,
0.0308044292,
-0.0024260851,
-0.006025387,
0.0623449795,
-0.0087200357,
-0.0091988351,
0.0567829758,
0.0040630773,
0.0139150033,
0.0000017678,
-0.015908286,
-0.0208113994,
-0.0107489005,
0.0202959683,
0.0021411865,
0.0386079215,
0.0065921554,
-0.0048704972,
0.019051861,
-0.006707001,
0.0195572134,
0.0302437916,
0.0421333723,
0.0782348365,
0.059369497,
0.0134185571,
0.0061225132,
-0.0032774808,
-0.0556947067,
0.001856099,
0.0379550494,
-0.0166262537,
-0.0162172131,
0.0296786856,
-0.0117935957,
0.0067942343,
-0.0092324549,
0.0272013396,
-0.0141602829,
0.0231086928,
0.0602707006,
0.0051363702,
0.0049095084,
0.0055722273,
0.0590541326,
0.0034646061,
0.0082746642,
0.0209034011,
-0.0244192667,
0.0064979838,
0.013947512,
-0.0228109192,
0.0787229314,
-0.0350670479,
0.0401450917,
0.0062154308,
0.0371828042,
-0.0215842575,
0.0084968256,
-0.0064402507,
0.0168277025,
-0.0199871436,
-0.0400866605,
-0.0048570624,
0.051491186,
-0.0515887439,
-0.0728370398,
0.0173564013,
-0.0163816568,
-0.0487181395,
-0.0081031956,
-0.0666060224,
-0.0248812959,
0.0221989248,
-0.0347785503,
0.0367853865,
-0.0017928076,
0.0181005802,
-0.001821085,
0.0111638634,
0.0306237843,
0.0218669977,
0.0468456037,
-0.0471121892,
0.0502181761,
-0.0161449965,
0.0012402015,
0.0098653063,
0.061902795,
-0.0354646146,
-0.0172922015,
-0.0792312399,
0.0022561476,
-0.0230885651,
0.0310769752,
-0.0006150131,
0.0410666727,
-0.0534866154,
0.0279718749,
-0.0544939451,
0.0250730813,
-0.0521989055,
0.0058292695,
0.0731928647,
0.0200839639,
0.0161839258,
0.0178982895,
0.0057799155,
-0.005984317,
-0.0028485637,
0.0527132377,
-0.0324722007,
-0.0117241843,
0.0109376907,
-0.0397172756,
-0.0363787711,
-0.0380131602,
-0.0064342837,
-0.0774519369,
0.0111987824,
-0.0288295001,
-0.0320098996,
-0.0063741924,
0.0005430398,
0.0358241834,
-0.0151886465,
0.0342026725,
-0.0157770719,
-0.0157660134,
0.0160362516,
-0.0270628463,
-0.0016210155,
0.0283239875,
0.0735604838,
0.0938529372,
0.0117029492,
0.0233433452,
0.0058532995,
-0.0075142346,
0.0136476895,
0.0001801374,
0.0006882541,
-0.0191624425,
-0.0357321128,
0.0270797722,
0.0652313009,
0.0877940208,
-0.0456211679,
0.0106078861,
0.0817711726,
0.0536657348,
0.0013993069,
-0.0424868353,
0.0288709663,
0.0532812141,
-0.0089960955,
0.0852831006,
-0.0050212187,
0.0528157353,
0.0041187648,
0.052874513,
0.0889696553,
0.0185463298,
0.0075474964,
-0.0816680789,
0.0095640924,
-0.0066871941,
0.01563536,
0.0004702617,
0.020613784,
0.0162170846,
-0.0356797799,
-0.0412745699,
0.0319081508,
-0.0756890401,
0.0456352159,
-0.0211157259,
0.0726288259,
0.0878112242,
0.037595056,
0.0024106123,
0.035077557,
-0.039839156,
-0.0672587156,
0.046713993,
0.054012876,
-0.0345952511,
-0.0442029275,
-0.0412026942,
-0.0297905896,
-0.0099853547,
-0.0011735533,
0.0439415164,
-0.0225362852,
-0.0322127678,
-0.0031040772,
0.0462115146,
-0.0816920325,
0.0303558018,
0.0320596322,
-0.0025421763,
0.0277218465,
0.0048609609,
0.0316624157,
0.0158571769,
-0.0339480527,
0.0239899177,
0.0040895669,
-0.0123174014,
-0.0383799896,
0.0187280346,
-0.0397917628,
-0.0387954563,
-0.0207262877,
-0.0653284863,
0.005987403,
0.0155106317,
-0.0162046682,
-0.0420526452,
-0.0104054222,
-0.0676814169,
-0.012716203,
-0.0396397859,
0.0006789608,
0.0371382162,
-0.0203860346,
-0.0652568862,
0.0490831509,
-0.0203898028,
-0.0033435449,
0.0033686678,
-0.0354803242,
-0.0182447191,
-0.0605102703,
0.0065928814,
0.01672782,
0.0206213072,
0.0368037187,
0.0839872286,
0.0356451795,
-0.0324385762,
-0.0334716737,
-0.0587497577,
0.003866113,
-0.0215637553,
-0.002581086,
0.0232430957,
-0.0131257325,
0.0048469156,
0.0011292404,
-0.0571555346,
-0.0603246316,
0.0280591566,
0.0249920972,
0.0477388874,
0.0222674347,
0.0616858192,
-0.0740854144,
-0.0262497216,
0.0204558671,
0.0319270305,
0.037021324,
0.0073851044,
-0.0420481116,
0.0194351431,
-0.0287967864,
-0.02483036,
0.0221110359,
-0.0074490658,
0.0261444189,
0.0100897187,
0.0388703905,
0.0735807717,
0.0523481444,
0.0562498681,
0.0575158,
0.033067815,
-0.0606515706,
-0.0061403518,
-0.0623713695,
0.0267702322,
0.0097383317,
-0.0397328176,
0.0531648025,
0.0533401407,
0.0262006205,
0.0223500673,
-0.0669524521,
0.0390025787,
-0.0177435838,
-0.0357140377,
-0.0194562152,
-0.0066641415,
-0.0296893492,
0.0549227744,
-0.0312713012,
-0.0405118167,
0.0929487795,
0.0025688112,
0.0459629297,
-0.0592587665,
0.0109703457,
-0.0166265406,
-0.0222864877,
0.0291915629,
0.0267977882,
-0.0019096335,
0.0160657242,
-0.0716047063,
-0.0271885265,
0.0640515238,
-0.015732646,
0.0473432168,
-0.051382225,
-0.0125088003,
-0.0275167059,
-0.0467867069,
-0.0283372588,
-0.0320619456,
0.0038490379,
0.0058206483,
0.0680397227,
-0.023379568,
0.020403998,
0.0013990474,
0.0411648043,
0.0363850817,
-0.0229161959,
-0.0210617986,
-0.0104888277,
0.0534389727,
0.0602912195,
0.0096353767,
0.0158698205,
-0.0658920407,
-0.0367228203,
0.0333417468,
0.0115580596,
0.025198549,
0.0045168633,
-0.0071234014,
-0.0033923502,
-0.0534368381,
-0.0008535641,
0.0065922346,
0.039052438,
-0.0349023938,
0.0097334599,
0.0624178872,
0.0321262181,
-0.0270177275,
-0.0040644775,
0.0326476246,
0.0709714964,
-0.0284327678,
0.0315474197,
-0.0606625862,
-0.000499372,
-0.0178382359,
0.0623734668,
-0.0253837295,
-0.009551405,
-0.0181212425,
-0.1076795533,
0.0212633442,
-0.0009721944,
-0.0865430236,
0.0065753199,
-0.0216569379,
-0.0120068686,
-0.0329548605,
0.0009387629,
0.0186444055,
-0.0020376013,
0.0324693471,
0.0494781137,
-0.0178624038,
-0.0118955597,
-0.0517866239,
-0.0399018228,
0.0351364389,
0.1211937964,
0.0270389449,
-0.0002901106,
0.0069773234,
-0.0292727686,
0.0113609191,
-0.0118498923,
0.0031927549,
0.0684413016,
-0.011662106,
0.0143698975,
-0.0379432254,
0.0434048362,
0.0493536256,
0.0026829047,
-0.002861321,
-0.0084011313,
0.0079185702,
-0.0211532842,
-0.0332364254,
0.0495436713,
-0.0008938615,
0.0439698733,
0.0446332283,
-0.0846889764,
-0.0429536179,
-0.0497158878,
-0.0373928919,
-0.1146211103,
-0.0252800472,
-0.0150602059,
-0.028604608,
-0.0157559551,
-0.124743633,
-0.0581691861,
-0.0048476085,
0.0062081404,
-0.0063898019,
-0.0288590584,
0.0141866142,
0.0015698326,
-0.0082779005,
0.0082626371,
0.0056290417,
0.0000740261,
-0.0601141267,
-0.0436975248,
0.0060652741,
-0.0524808131,
-0.0214789864,
-0.0027265146,
-0.0271814186,
-0.0555238463,
-0.0147272842,
0.0738602504,
0.019310832,
0.0691837966,
0.0522267222,
-0.0393082649,
0.040480569,
0.0497956797,
-0.0044099311,
0.0285707768,
0.0132845221,
0.077964291,
-0.0212279707,
0.0007517094,
-0.0398622565,
0.0143406326,
-0.0131146116,
0.0185030475,
-0.0193390176,
-0.0137891043,
0.0287926085,
0.0012815634,
-0.0157504007,
-0.0542004928,
0.0024894606,
-0.0497514084,
-0.0300046261,
-0.0362650119,
-0.0217043869,
-0.0511169061,
-0.0231848191,
-0.0222425666,
-0.0049883458,
-0.0011147388,
0.0126402443,
-0.0109310392,
0.055239547,
-0.0209465828,
-0.0183690228,
0.0009626274,
0.0218750332,
-0.006085868,
0.024585627,
-0.0272044837,
-0.0181436446,
-0.0220709685,
0.0509908944,
0.0174921732,
0.0123801939,
0.0417965949,
-0.0155123351,
0.0420960672,
0.0366727561,
-0.064208284,
-0.0103732534,
-0.0500878058,
-0.0151583636,
0.0121759744,
-0.0123811448,
0.0586301163,
-0.0176877156,
0.0060530612,
-0.0196882319,
0.0293816738,
-0.0076155793,
-0.0037045768,
-0.0193865206,
0.0190907754,
-0.0053333514,
-0.0287847277,
0.0697504282,
-0.0328806154,
-0.0227259472,
-0.0407886319,
0.0001824697,
-0.0514868498,
-0.0084915226,
-0.0250670463,
0.0259939041,
0.0022809878,
-0.0330171585,
-0.0704544485,
-0.004448886,
0.0026101212,
0.0587581806,
0.0427331328,
0.0034107,
0.0510098264,
0.0000433876,
-0.0327718407,
0.0289862622,
-0.05572984,
-0.0237356834,
-0.03615072,
-0.0063647446,
-0.0328779891,
-5.608501014e-33,
-0.0574218631,
-0.0374152511,
-0.0083600013,
-0.0147850281,
-0.030280469,
-0.0139158815,
-0.0283223372,
-0.0084777893,
0.0598554686,
-0.0078495182,
-0.0106677199,
-0.0419448912,
0.0100857448,
0.0379640311,
0.0240499135,
0.0095344707,
0.0665588751,
-0.0137161659,
-0.0771575868,
0.0309951026,
0.0624843799,
-0.0264222585,
0.0191384424,
-0.037322063,
0.0358201563,
0.0101404637,
-0.0456805378,
-0.0209721476,
-0.0240233783,
0.0445877053,
-0.0017982582,
0.0157247018,
0.003286934,
-0.0375711247,
-0.0436187685,
0.0318577103,
-0.0363089181,
-0.0241214819,
0.0061329422,
-0.0292509962,
-0.0557994135,
-0.037974745,
0.0391634479,
-0.0101828901,
0.0003216207,
-0.0114888158,
0.0527129099,
-0.0378520787,
-0.0251279455,
-0.0407616533,
-0.0302711446,
0.0148301143,
-0.016611848,
-0.019656783,
0.0054020868,
0.0695318207,
-0.0092806276,
0.0159276687,
-0.0196328778,
0.0877074748,
0.0609152913,
0.0233663172,
0.0388057046,
0.0182802975,
0.0129736932,
0.070057787,
0.0186272077,
0.0033725528,
-0.0081719095,
-0.0038069196,
-0.0090462491,
0.0205410253,
0.0337182879,
0.0567860976,
0.0324423872,
0.0250970889,
-0.0014362427,
0.0909975767,
-0.0049454309,
-0.0238392688,
0.0151744578,
-0.0079380637,
-0.0259289462,
-0.0237241574,
-0.0395341329,
-0.0359235108,
-0.0002503552,
-0.0346269868,
-0.0013430273,
0.0393865742,
-0.0443832651,
-0.0281099118,
0.0077228667,
-0.0069754813,
-0.0105007514,
-0.0174967162,
-0.0591495372,
0.0388205163,
-0.0035173136,
-0.0738042966,
-0.0633147955,
0.0343017466,
0.015874818,
-0.0062891324,
-0.0165648945,
0.0308210179,
0.0562938675,
0.0140016936,
-0.032699246,
0.0346793756,
0.0057836846,
0.0433418639,
-0.0074401186,
-0.0310319476,
0.0193976425,
-0.0172664206,
-0.0144309932,
0.0466980375,
-0.0332591608,
-0.0145179965,
-0.0343274027,
0.0005607298,
-0.0084193023,
0.0214793347,
-0.0197771471,
0.0302615017,
-0.0007026689,
0.0229747221,
0.0183631126,
-0.0200425442,
-0.0242956895,
-0.0184824057,
2.405e-7,
-0.0003643218,
0.0396106876,
0.0638644099,
-0.0078469981,
-0.0352422148,
0.0548246838,
0.0262496658,
0.0280724727,
0.0064394986,
0.0374788642,
0.0323442072,
0.0048488113,
0.0305779707,
0.0314036682,
-0.0566854477,
-0.0084421225,
-0.0808877423,
-0.003120112,
-0.0181819815,
-0.0548706092,
0.0582917705,
0.0264728237,
0.0099463789,
-0.0075964495,
0.0216686614,
0.0637646168,
0.0518845618,
-0.0360059142,
-0.0267081894,
0.0000849549,
0.037339922,
-0.0538554303,
-0.0287591517,
-0.0123514785,
-0.0039160331,
-0.039342504,
0.0253743269,
0.0190867744,
0.0446118712,
-0.0470718108,
0.0282802321,
0.0103858598,
0.0386988148,
-0.0170057062,
0.0125862658,
-0.0733830184,
-0.0138445841,
-0.0329333805,
-0.0202110242,
-0.023252571,
0.0049959566,
-0.0243485607,
-0.0258436725,
0.0205350257,
-0.0160386749,
0.0451617129,
0.0161527358,
-0.0383262038,
-0.045511961,
0.024994297,
-0.0144956084,
-0.0357208923,
-0.0306185912,
0.0525347926,
-0.027600443,
-0.0806683898,
-0.0340551548,
2.030188717e-34,
0.0619456954,
-0.0126340212,
-0.0140564358,
-0.0249527935,
0.0044796946,
0.0094827684,
-0.004194004,
-0.0120090004,
0.0654752105,
-0.0265433714,
-0.0376741104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01200v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01200v4 | Continual Learning Under Language Shift | 2023-11-02T12:54:50 | 2024-06-27T08:35:53 | Evangelia Gogoulou, Timothée Lesort, Magnus Boman, Joakim Nivre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The recent increase in data and model scale for language model pre-training
has led to huge training costs. In scenarios where new data become available
over time, updating a model instead of fully retraining it would therefore
provide significant gains. We study the pros and cons of updating a language
model when new data comes from new languages -- the case of continual learning
under language shift. Starting from a monolingual English language model, we
incrementally add data from Danish, Icelandic, and Norwegian to investigate how
forward and backward transfer effects depend on pre-training order and
characteristics of languages, for three different model sizes. Our results show
that, while forward transfer is largely positive and independent of language
order, backward transfer can be positive or negative depending on the order and
characteristics of new languages. We explore a number of potentially
explanatory factors and find that a combination of language contamination and
syntactic similarity best fits our results. | [
0.0040985551,
0.0760013387,
-0.0387363955,
0.0016154409,
-0.0285727475,
0.0337534323,
0.0100128883,
-0.0155552411,
-0.0494176894,
-0.0274279397,
-0.002844305,
-0.052867461,
-0.0098816371,
0.0108641768,
0.0308483653,
-0.0449979343,
0.0793954208,
-0.0563553944,
-0.0486311391,
-0.0368267372,
-0.0236091726,
-0.0460406281,
-0.0126892719,
-0.0102930069,
-0.0058633098,
0.028693486,
-0.0170845371,
-0.0539118797,
0.0268357787,
-0.0159019884,
-0.02628907,
0.0462539382,
0.0145838438,
0.0078200195,
0.0000017027,
-0.0806706101,
-0.0100871865,
-0.0235738028,
-0.0442999192,
0.0246022176,
0.0354595892,
-0.0036069348,
-0.0062382971,
-0.0000831717,
-0.015288569,
-0.0354522392,
0.0550637059,
-0.0018330833,
0.0484227203,
0.052090738,
-0.0093007823,
-0.0087877456,
0.032398507,
-0.038548898,
-0.0306394659,
-0.0205593668,
0.0424616635,
0.0248030256,
-0.0503746867,
0.0041433163,
-0.0465159491,
0.0554872118,
0.0183890555,
0.0231116433,
0.0021055378,
0.0603100397,
-0.0048350887,
-0.0074614584,
-0.0048981509,
0.0248333868,
-0.037061777,
-0.0476882234,
-0.0330144763,
-0.0057061636,
0.0066247545,
0.0167085025,
-0.0571528412,
0.0177243408,
0.0446710773,
0.0313708857,
0.0734874457,
-0.052564133,
0.0325434841,
-0.0070164027,
-0.0571716689,
0.0460984744,
0.0258469488,
-0.0541738458,
0.053624142,
0.028898295,
0.0011159353,
-0.036802955,
-0.0219124164,
0.0013062928,
0.0393529832,
0.0204571653,
-0.0225566179,
-0.0399283133,
0.0015261247,
-0.0285386126,
0.0413853228,
0.0200716686,
-0.0575845614,
0.030290639,
-0.0207868945,
0.0193233564,
0.0097852824,
0.0045099566,
-0.0541664474,
-0.0041614654,
-0.0458795503,
-0.0269030537,
-0.0327939205,
0.0185925122,
0.0242092889,
0.0068372996,
-0.036535386,
0.0030166169,
0.0214499906,
-0.0490876846,
-0.0252289195,
-0.0584583431,
-0.0754334107,
0.0231354106,
-0.011524261,
0.0667066053,
0.0031559921,
0.0479415655,
-0.0286930129,
-0.0170318726,
-0.0029231913,
0.0122019826,
-0.0119481804,
-0.0285724215,
0.0274157841,
0.0135971978,
-0.0284078345,
-0.0192658529,
-0.0500174426,
0.0450244918,
0.0029685486,
-0.0493587442,
0.0462815426,
-0.0425991453,
0.0079574715,
0.029545879,
0.0142496349,
-0.0425476618,
-0.0349583291,
-0.0297889356,
-0.0508381128,
0.0303621087,
0.0024992279,
0.050021179,
-0.0036209757,
-0.0419909619,
-0.0002111127,
0.0591245964,
-0.0160318632,
-0.0589232855,
0.025359923,
-0.0588175319,
-0.0327201113,
0.0576948076,
0.0180468485,
0.0533354282,
-0.0590018295,
-0.0008372732,
0.0328935385,
0.0017519421,
0.0379074961,
-0.031611599,
-0.0068775243,
0.0179735888,
0.0465538576,
0.0561352335,
0.034038011,
0.0245148782,
0.0182683114,
-0.0297014415,
-0.0230030399,
0.0129358759,
-0.0330921486,
-0.0184668303,
-0.0136117321,
-0.0028021117,
-0.0380267203,
0.0267530121,
-0.0127103291,
0.0035402526,
0.0199791957,
-0.0150806103,
0.0224396735,
0.001326388,
0.0618759207,
0.005471847,
0.0199036207,
0.0952074528,
0.0760661736,
-0.0649058446,
0.0093285814,
-0.0066380142,
0.0097369393,
0.0119193466,
-0.0420117378,
-0.001015843,
-0.0499829166,
-0.0126948617,
0.0410660654,
-0.0115312478,
0.0896560252,
0.0175534077,
0.0545617491,
-0.0285372734,
0.0032421399,
0.0300285593,
0.0025866041,
0.0576851442,
-0.0243510343,
0.0627267063,
-0.0194442905,
-0.0057214899,
-0.0540828668,
0.0334176533,
-0.0976208895,
0.0163084343,
-0.0043896311,
0.0107898349,
0.0198893324,
-0.0091265757,
-0.0168308411,
-0.0051230555,
0.0180670246,
-0.0496327132,
0.0025103586,
0.0700894818,
-0.0448759161,
-0.0114783989,
0.0410020277,
0.0511804149,
0.0151301492,
-0.0016322165,
-0.0203514937,
-0.0356423482,
0.0615308993,
0.0207072683,
0.0576347262,
0.0069473479,
0.0492292866,
-0.034524221,
0.0306252558,
-0.0283316448,
0.0247282684,
0.0060973344,
0.0255762432,
-0.0145824412,
-0.0347590558,
0.0141904717,
-0.0358153358,
-0.0125303278,
0.0399034992,
-0.0245546047,
-0.013093479,
0.0157505274,
-0.0088951886,
-0.0262043625,
0.0328916162,
-0.0437737852,
-0.0063551827,
-0.0142503958,
0.0309958253,
0.0303270053,
0.0067900349,
-0.0205432717,
-0.0239117499,
-0.0429696999,
0.0277856179,
0.0134078413,
0.0442345478,
0.0088057546,
0.0099746129,
-0.0135001652,
-0.051342912,
-0.0433699228,
0.0149706202,
0.0633861497,
-0.0320679508,
-0.0392304547,
-0.0813652724,
0.0425542034,
-0.0419938155,
0.0137866689,
-0.0009942711,
-0.0320693441,
-0.0187306106,
0.0036092645,
0.0416059867,
0.0293006711,
-0.0186380148,
0.0096991174,
0.0581836104,
-0.0268818345,
-0.0411134958,
-0.0170066897,
-0.0314600691,
-0.0269239787,
-0.0657724366,
-0.021156732,
0.014390396,
0.0655001327,
-0.0111653227,
-0.0463415124,
-0.0439219736,
-0.0190539639,
-0.0646777153,
0.0158050861,
-0.0389042571,
-0.0039028605,
-0.0172846392,
0.0698903352,
-0.0189896002,
-0.0367719047,
0.0105103971,
0.0017696208,
0.0213481374,
-0.0543413796,
-0.0282572042,
0.0116066011,
0.0362963676,
0.021546809,
0.0152031593,
0.0072059762,
-0.0150102749,
-0.0617408827,
-0.0115367025,
0.0567644015,
0.0154402191,
0.05784069,
-0.0389573164,
-0.0000299557,
0.011963129,
-0.0300270766,
-0.0256471857,
-0.0649774298,
0.0251096766,
0.0088190101,
-0.0270489156,
0.0219515711,
-0.0241471436,
-0.0263811033,
0.00632405,
0.0391428359,
0.0056150109,
0.0154386973,
0.0043186489,
-0.0035216943,
0.004061792,
0.0328187607,
0.0094336513,
-0.042441383,
0.0085544288,
-0.0307903066,
0.0457133017,
0.0020122516,
-0.0152092408,
0.0249785297,
0.0385780409,
-0.0507441498,
-0.0612270534,
-0.0054043699,
0.0282931589,
-0.010949092,
-0.0191584434,
0.0443134978,
-0.0089004217,
0.0108911972,
0.0377728455,
-0.0286140218,
0.0408440568,
0.0421289951,
0.0190049317,
-0.0428711511,
0.0106499773,
0.0149497101,
-0.0053720973,
0.0176296961,
-0.0305639058,
-0.0256788991,
-0.0995775759,
-0.0102715027,
0.0259611607,
-0.0940861851,
0.0297812708,
-0.0348138139,
-0.0136593627,
-0.0264425334,
-0.0020208729,
0.0149024222,
-0.03821145,
0.0199841708,
0.0459751822,
-0.030733183,
-0.0535635985,
-0.0015520223,
-0.0261364877,
0.0455038957,
0.0336526521,
0.004514772,
-0.0532559715,
-0.030461099,
0.0939599052,
-0.0257652868,
0.0000980008,
0.0012043973,
0.0674696565,
0.0559837967,
-0.0051564323,
0.0318346284,
-0.0117741432,
0.0088744694,
-0.029255433,
0.0161065944,
0.0579567514,
0.0395823047,
-0.0434769243,
0.0562142991,
-0.0183885004,
0.0037929094,
0.04037017,
0.0109412801,
-0.035059087,
-0.0053559714,
-0.0055582779,
-0.0012200007,
0.0189888682,
0.0199230574,
0.0395695493,
-0.0637990609,
-0.0343309417,
-0.050712619,
-0.0357120447,
-0.0101215411,
0.0276697371,
0.0582144782,
0.0358749852,
-0.0052546947,
-0.0278121773,
-0.0150145981,
0.0459447838,
0.004709573,
-0.0113325128,
-0.0383064337,
-0.0223544799,
0.0342484564,
-0.0067824437,
-0.0126621742,
-0.0728297457,
-0.0764513388,
-0.0735042542,
0.0618501566,
0.0447037295,
0.0228854921,
0.0656670332,
0.0363323018,
-0.0511732958,
0.0087707322,
-0.0061925999,
-0.025896905,
0.0268337596,
0.0519540459,
-0.0366120152,
0.0131618697,
0.0256340578,
-0.0152225094,
0.0221998822,
0.0421595611,
0.0024618448,
-0.0009170661,
-0.0014627827,
-0.0049987691,
0.0430061519,
0.0562650077,
-0.0314108953,
-0.03156716,
-0.0669144392,
0.0308231842,
0.0098466622,
0.0103367483,
0.0119453212,
-0.0370342396,
0.047933504,
0.0464821942,
-0.0124098267,
0.0260369554,
-0.0053156689,
0.016597677,
-0.0414461307,
0.011047991,
0.023926165,
0.0533672199,
0.0705442876,
0.0515680239,
-0.0045625991,
0.0114805521,
-0.0046504615,
0.0349270217,
-0.0394345596,
0.0286371838,
0.0056624701,
0.0125228995,
0.0022617078,
-0.0019048424,
-0.0671914145,
-0.0779711381,
0.0124819046,
-0.0355885588,
0.0592662133,
-0.0426759869,
0.1044396833,
-0.0234836712,
0.0222331919,
-0.0277685933,
0.0190232377,
-0.0393082798,
-0.0381129012,
0.0163597688,
-0.0181764271,
-0.0170456935,
0.0578964427,
0.04417843,
0.0022758315,
0.0563475601,
-0.0180388503,
0.0266021062,
-0.0151917906,
0.0118579604,
0.0444658324,
-0.0135368491,
-0.0168682169,
0.0465115868,
-0.0117117949,
-0.0718915015,
-0.0301671904,
-0.0406492613,
0.0029728203,
0.0101632299,
0.0074657993,
0.0525975488,
-0.0282331537,
-0.0135745453,
-0.0405855775,
0.0433950834,
0.0319373496,
-0.0005825472,
-0.0028228643,
-5.844840398e-33,
0.0038786312,
0.0724912807,
0.0171415079,
-0.0069163381,
-0.0258504618,
-0.0353540331,
-0.0069533451,
0.0399487875,
-0.0190421194,
0.010139755,
-0.0034459622,
-0.0026848414,
0.0178462788,
0.0346252136,
0.0382337756,
-0.0062396866,
0.0428415015,
-0.0032284935,
-0.0046664597,
-0.0063294582,
0.0333004966,
0.0470471308,
0.1258835346,
-0.0369552076,
-0.0024937605,
0.0275958125,
0.0421320312,
0.0138265397,
0.0069474005,
0.0231007002,
-0.0041296398,
0.0469591171,
0.0339659192,
-0.0606218167,
-0.0271747708,
-0.0511223041,
-0.0548093617,
-0.06174016,
0.0095827272,
0.0454115272,
0.0149040865,
-0.0123834303,
0.0064696358,
-0.0281436946,
-0.0342001393,
0.0034876838,
0.0047600335,
-0.0320083015,
-0.0329011604,
0.0295473486,
-0.0732580945,
0.0125039769,
-0.0053071901,
0.0249627661,
0.0153111015,
0.0613991097,
-0.0094515774,
-0.0622121431,
-0.0580037795,
0.0342665426,
0.0433729589,
0.0426550806,
0.0499413833,
0.0099220444,
0.0130308755,
0.0184286442,
0.0273649823,
0.0004807792,
0.055003386,
0.0018962469,
0.0861542746,
-0.0044234917,
0.0128569389,
-0.0088681085,
0.0763244852,
-0.0475618765,
-0.0626651645,
-0.031304419,
0.0229638368,
0.0258103572,
-0.0131891081,
0.0065762382,
-0.004341071,
-0.0706764683,
-0.0573290847,
-0.0380822122,
0.0046678451,
-0.0284425318,
0.0709822923,
-0.016330855,
0.0238221679,
-0.0241455846,
0.0558315143,
-0.0414962694,
-0.0927778035,
-0.0115033435,
-0.0366302952,
0.0119630126,
-0.0125156641,
0.0385467671,
-0.082024321,
-0.038331382,
-0.0218985341,
-0.0011445573,
0.0086647365,
0.000648584,
0.0770551413,
0.0282677412,
-0.0598108657,
-0.0084729316,
-0.0097710369,
0.0144430576,
0.0624821484,
0.028344091,
0.040891882,
0.0054726726,
0.0090336017,
0.0448390841,
0.0700134113,
-0.0584947988,
-0.0621984974,
-0.0160988383,
0.0257890746,
0.0302155204,
-0.0210634358,
-0.0270831976,
-0.0201760046,
0.0353852622,
0.0546674468,
-0.052308552,
-0.0305506028,
0.0018978572,
2.406e-7,
0.0339193381,
0.0305417962,
-0.0166834909,
-0.0380871817,
0.0046075811,
0.0006705863,
-0.0777084827,
0.0150178531,
0.0346750729,
0.0890330002,
-0.0213284604,
0.0109048821,
0.0301466305,
0.0183334611,
-0.0224694349,
-0.0642382354,
-0.0471222065,
0.027117338,
-0.0681974068,
0.0000193855,
0.0112426979,
0.0730840787,
0.0016786704,
-0.0172424428,
-0.0180542264,
-0.0384755693,
0.0588488281,
-0.0606701784,
0.0307213906,
0.0020135178,
0.0114118708,
0.0188141651,
0.0135803325,
0.0244344324,
-0.0288336761,
0.0383943431,
-0.0195975434,
-0.0050966362,
-0.0244403053,
-0.0037245636,
0.0251664799,
0.0212939866,
-0.0295544714,
-0.0677387342,
0.0485848524,
-0.0743298903,
-0.0423074216,
-0.0329672396,
-0.0321248919,
0.0406010039,
0.0412613489,
-0.0073515023,
-0.0070565878,
0.011916995,
0.0585387945,
0.029238034,
-0.0607782267,
-0.0289685111,
-0.0393936783,
0.0609921329,
-0.0107423691,
-0.0331249163,
-0.0178879797,
-0.0051639318,
-0.0016353814,
-0.0239410251,
0.0342823341,
1.812324844e-34,
0.0132107446,
0.0053984951,
0.0329242945,
0.0065329489,
-0.0083778026,
-0.0495144613,
0.0406212658,
0.042165827,
-0.0192716401,
-0.0385434963,
-0.0056210542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01173v1 | CRUSH4SQL: Collective Retrieval Using Schema Hallucination For Text2SQL | 2023-11-02T12:13:52 | 2023-11-02T12:13:52 | Mayank Kothyari, Dhruva Dhingra, Sunita Sarawagi, Soumen Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing Text-to-SQL generators require the entire schema to be encoded with
the user text. This is expensive or impractical for large databases with tens
of thousands of columns. Standard dense retrieval techniques are inadequate for
schema subsetting of a large structured database, where the correct semantics
of retrieval demands that we rank sets of schema elements rather than
individual elements. In response, we propose a two-stage process for effective
coverage during retrieval. First, we instruct an LLM to hallucinate a minimal
DB schema deemed adequate to answer the query. We use the hallucinated schema
to retrieve a subset of the actual schema, by composing the results from
multiple dense retrievals. Remarkably, hallucination $\unicode{x2013}$
generally considered a nuisance $\unicode{x2013}$ turns out to be actually
useful as a bridging mechanism. Since no existing benchmarks exist for schema
subsetting on large databases, we introduce three benchmarks. Two
semi-synthetic datasets are derived from the union of schemas in two well-known
datasets, SPIDER and BIRD, resulting in 4502 and 798 schema elements
respectively. A real-life benchmark called SocialDB is sourced from an actual
large data warehouse comprising 17844 schema elements. We show that our method1
leads to significantly higher recall than SOTA retrieval-based augmentation
methods. | [
0.0157994684,
0.0473427735,
-0.0224164166,
0.0125191044,
-0.0038935565,
0.0055956678,
-0.0414722487,
0.035785675,
0.0541170016,
-0.0185812637,
0.0187884495,
-0.033616066,
-0.0463903323,
0.0218605977,
0.0127509488,
-0.005951724,
0.0517686345,
0.0221149288,
-0.0821646973,
-0.0014653909,
-0.0408433117,
0.0145675289,
0.0490580387,
-0.035092894,
-0.0245450363,
0.0548807308,
-0.0257020127,
0.0497948676,
-0.0284246318,
0.0038771098,
0.0127777439,
0.0519073345,
-0.0042863442,
0.0387895294,
0.0000021077,
-0.0543059893,
-0.0693149492,
-0.0005168183,
-0.013658409,
-0.0017639133,
0.0226406083,
-0.0215890426,
0.0289570242,
0.0194101073,
-0.0426183492,
0.0193916,
0.0360340029,
0.0271908212,
0.0240747929,
0.0516808853,
-0.0272891968,
-0.0806214288,
0.0048511457,
0.001513448,
0.0794215426,
-0.0334585682,
-0.0022822628,
0.0294816699,
0.044282075,
0.024229059,
0.0248795338,
0.0391614921,
-0.0363040417,
0.0181740057,
0.069864355,
-0.0042858673,
-0.1052272618,
0.0125780776,
0.0084006125,
0.029488232,
0.0304024592,
-0.0189815648,
0.0240101647,
0.0497982018,
-0.0223407149,
0.0002684731,
0.0106302146,
-0.0001618052,
-0.0152030149,
0.0193601977,
-0.0629342571,
0.0081820423,
0.0208302289,
-0.0437805951,
-0.0752893537,
0.0304246489,
0.0035695801,
-0.0185485911,
0.0175974425,
-0.0198138617,
0.0252468195,
0.0186525211,
0.0185901932,
0.006479138,
-0.077346094,
0.0165762529,
-0.002936241,
0.0065336013,
0.0505343415,
-0.0585489385,
0.0268516876,
0.0320489258,
-0.0181517899,
0.052839689,
-0.0062563466,
-0.0261585582,
-0.0015645119,
0.0043404619,
-0.0235619247,
-0.03958074,
-0.0859845653,
0.027034454,
-0.0342965014,
0.0761171952,
-0.0691280365,
0.0031791627,
-0.0574911535,
0.0244621336,
-0.0030684208,
0.0296197254,
-0.0396905951,
0.0323873907,
-0.0222634654,
0.0074845511,
-0.03817055,
-0.0325350091,
0.0090585034,
-0.0314468592,
-0.0043840702,
-0.0807713419,
-0.0118864803,
-0.014607409,
0.0434028171,
-0.0207176469,
0.0385358818,
-0.0035156186,
0.001223776,
-0.0431208313,
-0.0594551712,
-0.0733035132,
0.0106990412,
-0.0109707452,
-0.0392533801,
-0.0276081897,
0.0659324601,
0.0065255729,
-0.0333925858,
-0.0276338346,
-0.0194693543,
0.0217365902,
-0.0083331987,
0.0626376197,
-0.0375993922,
0.0331137441,
0.0202582236,
0.0060488237,
-0.0209929924,
0.0608560108,
-0.0402183868,
0.0957956016,
0.0118169719,
-0.0093706725,
0.0086879972,
-0.0069681373,
0.0572969392,
0.0137170246,
-0.0258819126,
0.0321759321,
0.0394658223,
0.0075375186,
-0.0233055037,
0.0714896619,
-0.0255104471,
-0.0103490353,
0.0291931778,
0.0266028196,
0.029556375,
0.0142456451,
-0.0138048921,
0.014924719,
0.002501939,
-0.0201119427,
-0.0199435353,
0.0036042114,
-0.0774503425,
-0.0041623195,
0.0474055409,
-0.0081314621,
-0.0120348064,
-0.0382773802,
-0.0080619678,
0.0011635855,
-0.0142009491,
0.0072222394,
0.0342484824,
0.0148888351,
-0.0014136384,
0.0768608898,
0.0365106761,
-0.0640034154,
-0.0237455685,
0.0069393762,
-0.0148979649,
0.084030509,
0.0371652991,
-0.094656378,
0.0342237577,
0.0289785024,
0.0325259082,
0.0127884252,
0.0126812756,
-0.0251168888,
-0.0065429499,
-0.0254410282,
-0.0272679441,
0.042962227,
0.0372490697,
0.014896675,
0.0449179038,
0.00526695,
0.0183150172,
-0.0345380604,
-0.0510648638,
0.0022605362,
-0.0161246713,
-0.0045138001,
0.0210694298,
-0.000001455,
0.0310252048,
0.0312517472,
-0.0342014469,
0.004316478,
0.0626591295,
-0.0101423431,
-0.0828983486,
-0.029226277,
0.0274462961,
0.0163448974,
0.0088635795,
0.0016444708,
0.0126372352,
-0.0276694708,
-0.0294215474,
-0.0444719344,
-0.0008740512,
-0.052578181,
0.0196003504,
-0.0498511158,
0.0061279098,
-0.0293802451,
0.0012800397,
-0.071183525,
0.0815518647,
-0.0037870705,
-0.0086206999,
-0.0313281044,
-0.0818293393,
0.0445739143,
-0.0422443971,
-0.0154907666,
0.0017637754,
0.0014740282,
0.0540390089,
0.0027463252,
-0.0486818701,
-0.0916480422,
-0.0096780006,
-0.0593971461,
0.0311086066,
-0.0078713,
0.0236457661,
-0.0145461662,
0.0316200815,
0.0168421138,
-0.0233932082,
-0.0336227342,
-0.0110999327,
-0.0202031545,
0.0117016258,
0.005871457,
0.0132420668,
-0.0122322878,
0.0001379004,
-0.0154064763,
-0.008624359,
0.0161018129,
-0.0198483765,
-0.0464729629,
0.0095436182,
0.0331761874,
-0.0437333919,
-0.0081074927,
-0.0053587994,
0.0539789014,
0.0083562527,
-0.0454400629,
-0.0170674361,
0.031392552,
0.0118092727,
-0.0238536783,
0.0073244725,
0.0123823648,
-0.0432455987,
-0.0098568192,
-0.0118648829,
-0.0024870955,
-0.0037986243,
-0.0750857368,
0.0224067289,
-0.053841684,
-0.0131901428,
-0.0060531427,
-0.0495064445,
-0.0223976634,
0.0402563401,
-0.0034363149,
-0.0714991838,
-0.007127699,
0.0177894849,
0.0508630462,
-0.0218364261,
-0.0331340246,
0.0083366521,
-0.0048345681,
0.0207999144,
-0.0048574419,
0.0015651984,
-0.0395470001,
0.1003107652,
0.0044829757,
0.0213746298,
-0.0426132716,
-0.062643677,
0.0096491165,
-0.0061632711,
-0.0022045563,
-0.0758562163,
0.0373633616,
0.0122114299,
0.0305712912,
-0.0021943294,
-0.0126443701,
-0.0436569974,
0.0137564987,
-0.0032706084,
0.0030442195,
0.0383198112,
-0.0228552707,
-0.0277411081,
-0.0080840187,
-0.0122257732,
0.0067184051,
0.0247669555,
-0.0079845497,
0.0093145045,
-0.0406444483,
-0.0281185322,
0.0283268411,
-0.0126929525,
0.0124971718,
0.0032892472,
0.0676182434,
0.0489024743,
-0.0761124566,
-0.0092929183,
0.0093104644,
0.0094179334,
-0.026922632,
-0.0199785568,
-0.0185549594,
-0.0176778752,
-0.0048074932,
-0.0115589434,
0.0373177826,
0.0292241797,
-0.0076940237,
-0.0118296612,
0.015833687,
0.0209253523,
0.0411832146,
0.0244995523,
-0.1261410564,
-0.0048669796,
0.0024471525,
0.0290235393,
0.0348920934,
-0.0740946382,
0.0047186646,
-0.1253169179,
0.0573100559,
0.0057611545,
-0.0332599506,
-0.0004748974,
-0.0269238353,
-0.0134027628,
-0.0226789284,
-0.0326604918,
0.0447697751,
-0.0171941016,
-0.0212112498,
0.0106657501,
0.0457101278,
-0.0229317844,
0.0112259211,
-0.035299141,
0.0096650003,
0.0023971766,
0.0281402525,
0.0390156768,
-0.0323829986,
-0.0048537557,
0.0021032293,
0.0299487673,
-0.0259450637,
0.1357753426,
0.0174252167,
0.0147897443,
0.038265191,
0.0041056103,
-0.0065870527,
0.0262022782,
-0.0082667256,
0.0794550031,
-0.0305100065,
0.0065801851,
-0.0140770506,
-0.0414706022,
0.0135492058,
0.0561386123,
0.0084593138,
0.0362349413,
-0.0317016579,
0.0181480478,
0.0058326907,
-0.0312587768,
-0.0202011559,
0.0466128066,
-0.0162783582,
-0.0319588073,
-0.0381230973,
-0.0184188355,
0.0281022545,
0.0648304075,
-0.0120311752,
0.0579223745,
-0.0385989659,
-0.0111522507,
-0.0784700364,
0.0035524324,
-0.0643782616,
-0.0026430842,
0.0017247727,
-0.046629034,
0.0063965535,
-0.0171450749,
-0.0152955558,
-0.0592777245,
-0.0146124689,
-0.0425957851,
0.0441295765,
-0.0012684677,
0.0307480991,
0.036986202,
0.0144230435,
-0.0722581595,
0.0900755525,
0.1178938895,
-0.0533452295,
-0.0110060265,
-0.0057796673,
-0.0291370582,
-0.0147690531,
0.0351725966,
-0.0126225585,
0.0447447412,
-0.0243586078,
0.0018636008,
-0.0020842336,
0.0316964611,
0.0333442464,
0.0791654959,
-0.0320141427,
0.0360486433,
-0.0050690663,
0.0061362847,
0.0555503517,
-0.0544786565,
-0.0189302806,
-0.0098242322,
0.0025145542,
0.0088806506,
-0.0471253395,
0.0247510709,
-0.0269225929,
-0.0085547436,
0.0451826565,
-0.0248759389,
-0.0298917871,
0.0239658393,
-0.0145500703,
0.0534126125,
-0.0004746301,
0.001407194,
0.0230957493,
0.0467930511,
0.0963501707,
-0.0165383425,
-0.0594039895,
0.0210991185,
0.0240399502,
-0.0478867702,
0.0196474753,
-0.0469766967,
-0.0485198088,
0.0241761599,
0.0001381536,
0.0185751617,
-0.0110469302,
0.0512539223,
0.0055718897,
-0.0244041421,
-0.0096124467,
-0.0456683859,
0.0109986663,
-0.0282182954,
-0.0353825912,
-0.0003865578,
-0.0309832525,
0.0402737446,
0.0516469255,
-0.0410685502,
0.0186145082,
-0.0184067078,
-0.0440020375,
-0.0497824438,
-0.0330339484,
0.0267192293,
0.016937146,
-0.016434012,
-0.0544267818,
-0.0522273704,
-0.0147726433,
0.0955027714,
-0.0107747344,
-0.0272905882,
-0.0177328438,
0.0345792286,
0.0677829459,
0.0804255679,
0.0171647985,
-0.0131406253,
-0.0290605016,
-0.02847475,
-0.0307756849,
0.0259702094,
-6.521943879e-33,
-0.0116840182,
-0.0468734242,
0.0206681602,
-0.0243242253,
0.0010814345,
-0.0037237108,
-0.0397590548,
0.0086566675,
0.0241849367,
-0.0303229671,
-0.0631822795,
0.0341713242,
0.0335090794,
0.0119353617,
0.0281679984,
-0.0370392427,
0.0138524473,
0.0017764913,
-0.0020053913,
0.0360589288,
0.0765982568,
0.0515001602,
-0.0201158933,
-0.0463070273,
0.001379301,
0.0022214828,
-0.0157301798,
-0.0040172907,
0.0138894664,
0.014848019,
-0.0037096615,
0.0538106263,
0.0207929909,
0.011404573,
-0.0131964786,
-0.0421803035,
-0.0369827449,
-0.025764849,
-0.0111652864,
-0.0267611854,
0.0057517374,
0.029075725,
0.0545420684,
-0.0426905155,
-0.0276899338,
-0.0000976408,
0.0050344709,
-0.0420991927,
-0.0559275262,
-0.0700340644,
-0.0174458567,
0.02281777,
0.055388201,
0.0584877767,
0.0321103148,
0.0209531207,
-0.0043630712,
0.0654047057,
-0.0605918318,
0.0545928888,
-0.0474168584,
0.0069862055,
-0.038976647,
0.0129235694,
0.0115052406,
0.0390696153,
0.0563200749,
0.0538677387,
-0.0081248181,
0.0204032771,
-0.0005028665,
0.0741507411,
0.011754645,
0.0448636189,
0.0231162403,
-0.0412395746,
-0.0605082624,
0.0604330748,
-0.0097466251,
-0.0538568497,
0.0054351324,
0.0274771247,
-0.0696920604,
-0.0419219136,
-0.0266904328,
0.0632373989,
-0.0404343829,
-0.018508058,
0.0088385856,
0.0141458111,
-0.0522437356,
0.0138776684,
0.0020830415,
-0.0307129007,
-0.0339221358,
0.0348358713,
-0.0174904037,
-0.0246805158,
-0.0106457612,
-0.0040540127,
-0.0177227277,
-0.0533984229,
0.023730563,
0.0269980077,
0.0043216548,
0.0079793883,
0.0394298509,
0.0118360892,
-0.0522794835,
0.0155863529,
-0.0184509307,
0.0032248832,
-0.04516837,
-0.0374954306,
0.0349028818,
0.0286923368,
0.0381246656,
-0.0120013617,
0.0536879674,
0.0558174141,
-0.0170622487,
0.0081033902,
-0.006571338,
0.006920422,
0.055015035,
0.0679239109,
-0.0152004007,
-0.0594805814,
0.036861673,
-0.0176809132,
-0.013590551,
0.0105571495,
3.032e-7,
0.0441648923,
0.0149214696,
0.0163745806,
0.0220171139,
-0.006776344,
0.0113738906,
0.0193680022,
0.0189425666,
0.0253482759,
-0.0557152331,
0.0384628512,
0.0208644271,
0.0521608293,
0.0403095372,
-0.0963547826,
-0.0029033315,
0.0032131106,
-0.0328493454,
-0.0601491556,
0.0001441506,
0.0198183507,
0.0535669141,
-0.0051101609,
-0.0266177244,
0.0383476876,
-0.0178210363,
0.0182137284,
-0.0197393037,
-0.006348148,
0.0347180031,
0.0335595757,
0.0311606061,
-0.0233865101,
0.0397208892,
-0.0227016751,
0.0015875188,
-0.0277875848,
-0.0159470234,
-0.0190887805,
0.0133173373,
-0.0088360133,
-0.0744023845,
-0.0067377379,
0.0005749674,
0.0724548921,
0.0195812639,
-0.0069124126,
0.0852181464,
-0.0257180594,
-0.0098422132,
-0.0059841168,
0.0400897302,
-0.0040644053,
0.0021742599,
-0.0095023448,
0.0289564375,
-0.0011468732,
-0.0632864311,
0.0264178831,
0.0463240854,
-0.0135230739,
-0.0136189172,
0.0006310015,
0.0617930852,
-0.0574461259,
-0.0430964977,
-0.0034043165,
2.906339528e-34,
0.0543153584,
0.0449716263,
0.0517745428,
-0.0173813403,
0.0304608401,
-0.022380745,
0.0023023575,
0.0078367023,
-0.0078064809,
-0.058715377,
-0.0034720465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01166v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01166v1 | Generative Input: Towards Next-Generation Input Methods Paradigm | 2023-11-02T12:01:29 | 2023-11-02T12:01:29 | Keyu Ding, Yongcan Wang, Zihang Xu, Zhenzhen Jia, Shijin Wang, Cong Liu, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Since the release of ChatGPT, generative models have achieved tremendous
success and become the de facto approach for various NLP tasks. However, its
application in the field of input methods remains under-explored. Many neural
network approaches have been applied to the construction of Chinese input
method engines(IMEs).Previous research often assumed that the input pinyin was
correct and focused on Pinyin-to-character(P2C) task, which significantly falls
short of meeting users' demands. Moreover, previous research could not leverage
user feedback to optimize the model and provide personalized results. In this
study, we propose a novel Generative Input paradigm named GeneInput. It uses
prompts to handle all input scenarios and other intelligent auxiliary input
functions, optimizing the model with user feedback to deliver personalized
results. The results demonstrate that we have achieved state-of-the-art
performance for the first time in the Full-mode Key-sequence to
Characters(FK2C) task. We propose a novel reward model training method that
eliminates the need for additional manual annotations and the performance
surpasses GPT-4 in tasks involving intelligent association and conversational
assistance. Compared to traditional paradigms, GeneInput not only demonstrates
superior performance but also exhibits enhanced robustness, scalability, and
online learning capabilities. | [
0.0458719768,
0.0328923054,
0.0066396692,
0.0057059503,
-0.0124486499,
-0.0065847025,
0.0265579633,
0.0282998718,
0.0190375894,
0.0167789888,
-0.0619740374,
-0.0419310518,
0.0140745379,
0.0335575417,
0.0378543586,
-0.0478774682,
0.0430439189,
0.0079261027,
-0.0123106642,
0.0028251286,
0.0189575702,
-0.007105683,
-0.0114545617,
0.0798327327,
-0.0460292026,
-0.0412469693,
-0.0124229565,
-0.0029858004,
0.0002599678,
-0.0173104685,
-0.0072599896,
0.0602368563,
-0.0213464946,
0.0675290599,
0.0000018741,
-0.0329879783,
-0.0023479287,
-0.0235220455,
-0.0282677431,
0.0096934214,
0.0148668056,
0.0642203316,
-0.0568556376,
0.0381847173,
-0.02896888,
-0.0308128912,
0.0820151716,
0.0804076567,
0.0549881496,
0.0773505047,
-0.0121809896,
-0.0186889023,
0.0495555401,
-0.0451965556,
0.0260535181,
0.0085309763,
-0.002363526,
-0.0263977963,
0.0359833986,
-0.0192336906,
-0.015472535,
0.0528267696,
0.0336746797,
-0.0502519868,
0.0492323413,
0.0581363812,
0.0079478677,
-0.035321936,
-0.0176171809,
0.0614055768,
-0.0469103716,
0.0014163074,
-0.0192620438,
-0.0091432901,
0.0151112219,
-0.012303683,
-0.028558189,
-0.0343686715,
-0.0381667912,
0.0083872201,
0.0102173351,
-0.0222816952,
0.0166137666,
-0.0184197556,
0.0150879743,
-0.00394715,
0.0297148675,
-0.0297724344,
-0.0251510739,
-0.0094454428,
-0.0240320005,
-0.0532224737,
0.0235553868,
0.0421097018,
-0.0642888248,
0.0167494733,
0.0115423789,
0.0024606343,
0.0009484896,
-0.0564607196,
0.0273873154,
0.0533901192,
0.0167252664,
0.0013576001,
-0.0220488515,
0.0323183015,
-0.0056618261,
-0.0064208265,
-0.0024010886,
0.004514168,
-0.0867064148,
-0.0440166704,
-0.0355619714,
0.0213098768,
0.0229675677,
-0.0500930101,
-0.0499332175,
0.0391801521,
-0.0151635725,
0.0252647586,
0.0551398024,
0.0255880188,
-0.0475037843,
0.035353642,
-0.0263253003,
0.0222206376,
-0.0512395054,
0.0032441099,
0.022350762,
-0.0301801078,
0.0091865472,
-0.0049994555,
0.0167337097,
-0.0076787989,
-0.0131818308,
0.0608165078,
-0.031103421,
0.0029476904,
-0.0103438105,
-0.0009626697,
-0.0158265121,
-0.0063604787,
0.0014400705,
-0.0388047919,
0.0092247818,
-0.0190698095,
0.0003464647,
-0.0497037023,
0.0141462004,
0.0128703117,
0.0132584395,
0.0402070805,
0.0369911902,
-0.008121646,
0.0553917326,
-0.0052742586,
-0.0156409312,
0.0283385962,
0.0417861976,
0.0312645584,
0.0165653806,
-0.0185444262,
0.0603098758,
0.069909215,
-0.0173499621,
-0.0390572771,
0.0020970546,
-0.0223873854,
0.009347219,
0.0556159988,
0.0236345492,
0.0548200198,
-0.035046678,
0.036162179,
0.0766588151,
0.0714812353,
0.070545882,
0.0458798148,
0.029083157,
-0.0051908186,
0.0109974295,
-0.0243962891,
-0.0512307547,
0.0214717276,
-0.0138467764,
0.0536123179,
0.0265538804,
0.0022649874,
-0.0315346792,
-0.0785986781,
-0.0155316647,
0.0023072811,
0.0045472919,
-0.0194407403,
0.0342658237,
0.0052686771,
-0.0282636955,
-0.0537062623,
-0.00247918,
-0.0566954054,
0.025386015,
-0.0395910293,
0.0309763532,
0.1120564491,
0.0780562162,
0.0090845209,
0.0020373592,
-0.0202953648,
-0.0728328079,
0.0613324828,
0.0082795713,
-0.0616430938,
-0.0492652804,
-0.0401920602,
-0.0254372451,
0.0705704018,
-0.00421046,
0.0401671641,
0.018638432,
-0.010462801,
-0.0066301869,
0.0276129209,
-0.0098952139,
0.0338440239,
-0.0540261157,
-0.055556491,
0.0152119566,
0.019202657,
-0.0043648891,
0.0339619033,
-0.0253407508,
0.0302790366,
-0.0059202178,
-0.0097369449,
-0.0436065979,
0.0120065967,
-0.0595879406,
-0.034383826,
0.0466598049,
0.0093951477,
-0.0153635917,
0.0100347586,
-0.0116594695,
-0.0696640536,
-0.0103022819,
-0.0302460529,
0.0583328605,
-0.0931588858,
0.0095022032,
0.0227639694,
0.0032803733,
-0.0296559073,
0.0439342409,
-0.00441512,
0.0062515787,
-0.0007574876,
0.0331415981,
0.0221567154,
-0.0555488914,
-0.026791472,
0.0318518877,
0.0158389844,
0.0206863079,
0.0307614878,
0.0318928398,
-0.0171855763,
-0.0178311616,
-0.0874582306,
0.0251646377,
-0.0100764269,
0.0126410518,
0.0126149571,
0.0250635277,
-0.0135365222,
-0.0387477912,
-0.0784485787,
0.0018199545,
-0.0100844922,
-0.0197427329,
0.0420170799,
0.000303346,
0.0147643015,
-0.0280360729,
-0.0056509771,
-0.0278112888,
-0.0026618661,
-0.0071288194,
-0.033247944,
-0.0235723816,
0.004696154,
-0.0029129034,
0.0492660068,
-0.0037731335,
-0.0421887562,
0.027339058,
-0.0186536703,
0.0583104715,
0.0240752213,
0.0270288493,
-0.0080726044,
-0.0005325471,
0.0221406501,
-0.0449213609,
0.031190211,
-0.0123752411,
-0.022614412,
0.0219314881,
0.0354544073,
-0.0143311536,
0.0671399832,
0.0192260537,
0.0056562526,
-0.0800075382,
-0.0114457663,
0.0240925532,
-0.0141949477,
-0.0441522934,
-0.0026357081,
-0.0709157437,
-0.0389379002,
-0.0311034359,
-0.0188300405,
0.0887169316,
-0.0360948145,
-0.0432203263,
-0.0399154462,
0.0034011321,
0.0279364344,
0.0330648236,
-0.0038604033,
-0.0000506768,
0.0428338498,
-0.0531157926,
-0.0373151489,
0.0745817348,
0.0006673229,
-0.0420332476,
0.0371358879,
-0.007251888,
0.0008778526,
-0.014922318,
-0.0277576912,
-0.0518983901,
0.0194549002,
0.0194533672,
0.0364153981,
0.0410124175,
-0.0605182163,
0.0855604112,
0.0371391252,
0.0008763547,
0.086461328,
-0.0298922732,
-0.0136901885,
-0.0096527506,
0.0250399914,
0.0232380051,
0.0167878848,
-0.0318502635,
0.0265467223,
0.0600001886,
0.0104517657,
0.0218126271,
-0.0260389261,
0.0355558582,
-0.0116279516,
0.0068042218,
-0.0631834492,
-0.0064378316,
0.0296962671,
0.0380396843,
-0.0746595562,
-0.0148266749,
0.1111627892,
0.025739206,
-0.0634727702,
0.008027317,
0.0297892876,
0.0384213701,
0.0104953395,
0.0410684273,
-0.0916092545,
-0.0159702152,
0.0151250577,
0.0349536166,
0.0011530371,
-0.0058137164,
0.0259327963,
-0.1451536715,
0.0204643793,
-0.0138088921,
-0.0153389554,
-0.0074999332,
-0.0200031567,
-0.0053477744,
-0.0063666543,
0.0050823102,
0.012266228,
0.0053161378,
-0.0026994597,
0.0202302914,
-0.018039545,
-0.0522609279,
0.0022274824,
-0.008694442,
0.0552848838,
0.1139091775,
0.0266610589,
0.0247082207,
-0.0016513094,
0.0249229502,
0.0115309516,
0.0283239614,
-0.0257140696,
0.0418576375,
0.0036642321,
-0.0113121066,
-0.0248431731,
0.030529432,
0.0023054287,
0.014757202,
0.0249725878,
0.0535016507,
-0.0094992705,
0.015991345,
-0.0101694074,
-0.0283552296,
0.025328394,
0.0615140423,
0.0391715281,
-0.0603275709,
-0.051622171,
-0.071710445,
0.0011322494,
-0.0816294998,
-0.0454598218,
0.0095435744,
-0.0032478655,
-0.0534425564,
-0.119390808,
-0.0878206342,
0.0099170534,
0.018471254,
-0.0062532746,
0.0017217738,
-0.0116314525,
0.0157259181,
-0.0322267227,
-0.0319963768,
0.0419581532,
-0.0004760172,
-0.0629569888,
-0.0162534602,
0.0027089519,
-0.0573116168,
0.0053693503,
0.0136907455,
-0.0213335063,
-0.055959262,
-0.0228515659,
0.0446646102,
0.0148139978,
0.0434691161,
-0.0582635365,
-0.0245717,
0.0361299515,
-0.0012791107,
-0.0079992572,
-0.0629425198,
0.0253323,
0.021530766,
-0.0170189552,
0.0010239294,
-0.0039356342,
0.0114747714,
-0.004108286,
0.0638648495,
-0.0303457882,
0.0066439523,
0.0440765209,
-0.0115834139,
0.030383816,
-0.0463906303,
0.0010393026,
-0.0540644564,
0.0261824969,
-0.032038413,
-0.0102170389,
-0.0249976926,
-0.0140276123,
0.0091396403,
0.0018931117,
-0.0071322718,
-0.0238769352,
-0.0103084538,
0.0081614228,
-0.0447779968,
-0.0056210826,
0.0350024886,
0.0176836997,
-0.0191379953,
0.0086935312,
-0.0060237283,
0.027917197,
0.0298263766,
0.0105955033,
-0.0370780043,
0.0827040151,
0.0109908655,
-0.0000567242,
0.0236046463,
0.0279983021,
-0.0576115735,
0.0010152941,
-0.053350836,
0.0584499948,
0.0670263544,
0.0158073585,
0.0111821881,
-0.0507929996,
0.0067473706,
-0.03301185,
0.0072809029,
-0.0182088334,
-0.0287991222,
-0.0229700487,
0.0100061372,
-0.01848788,
-0.0945813283,
0.0635951757,
-0.0403598137,
0.0445676558,
-0.0293563548,
0.0081292503,
-0.0488724113,
-0.0034680364,
0.0470768921,
-0.0077058864,
-0.0363360308,
-0.0119439149,
-0.0315154493,
-0.0491963811,
-0.0442050807,
0.053263016,
-0.0135845672,
0.0132140527,
0.0388663784,
0.0067106858,
-0.0309078284,
-0.0170094166,
-0.0441335365,
-0.0088314544,
-0.0301446766,
-0.0287682991,
-0.0365072042,
-5.960608959e-33,
-0.0304410923,
-0.0021913755,
0.015190837,
0.0279768053,
-0.0288679972,
-0.0363682881,
-0.0469001867,
0.0044849371,
-0.0201158226,
-0.0325899087,
-0.085625492,
-0.0081692813,
0.0070279301,
0.0150492787,
0.0422632247,
0.0025962386,
0.0709011853,
-0.0178164952,
-0.0096751591,
0.0304944087,
0.0698004067,
0.0458431877,
0.0475745723,
-0.0214296915,
0.0346574634,
-0.01078487,
-0.0113335801,
0.0190027393,
0.0040675062,
0.0700468794,
-0.0206317939,
0.0437255949,
0.0191398133,
-0.061521709,
-0.0174933542,
0.0188974235,
-0.1093188822,
-0.0423193984,
-0.0361736454,
0.0214683376,
-0.0100699533,
-0.0308262296,
0.0355716459,
-0.0487434603,
0.0038455832,
0.0166174751,
0.0336473174,
-0.0055292798,
-0.0123408688,
-0.0492885858,
-0.0562419519,
0.0104759121,
0.0219161585,
-0.00908422,
0.0021221584,
0.042116262,
-0.0214615259,
-0.0593993291,
-0.0339361764,
0.0065127518,
0.0464349352,
0.0772995055,
0.0478793494,
0.0424015112,
0.0457586534,
-0.0075387098,
-0.000223869,
-0.0441291742,
-0.021620281,
0.0100730872,
0.0362565592,
-0.0144118983,
0.044109799,
0.047349073,
0.026688464,
-0.0282735359,
-0.0052536707,
0.0448596627,
0.075064078,
0.0120879896,
-0.0349819027,
0.0175145864,
-0.0277324542,
0.0002811535,
-0.0041257176,
-0.0179015081,
-0.0249846168,
-0.1016002223,
0.0323880501,
0.011117449,
0.0058397017,
-0.0114504825,
0.0346276015,
0.0035059964,
-0.0275982302,
0.0275513735,
0.0138647966,
0.0392534994,
0.0019716043,
-0.0133338682,
-0.0475375429,
-0.0332653113,
0.0268930793,
0.0098946849,
-0.0032040835,
0.0133759575,
0.0142938299,
0.0247809608,
-0.046267774,
0.0116916047,
-0.0132169789,
0.0121388156,
0.0062184394,
0.0380854607,
0.0301243048,
-0.0252733901,
-0.0147902276,
-0.0083748559,
-0.0046570511,
0.0253415313,
-0.0528659895,
-0.0354390815,
-0.0015916019,
-0.0022045001,
-0.0252229497,
0.037585441,
-0.0324478187,
0.0596899502,
0.0237751771,
-0.0313341208,
-0.0159407184,
0.0260797851,
2.55e-7,
0.0384076945,
0.0260267165,
0.0540925413,
0.0241259206,
0.0098557025,
0.0169494245,
-0.0168745518,
0.0340589918,
0.0004181691,
0.0372318365,
0.0397862345,
0.0019012243,
0.0482299812,
-0.0072347834,
-0.0838950276,
-0.0765664726,
-0.0373093337,
0.0516601279,
-0.0255382787,
0.0341893882,
0.0546115488,
0.0883674845,
-0.0157654118,
0.0297314972,
0.0327743068,
-0.0057978281,
0.0278152432,
0.0085501466,
-0.0055050161,
0.0038897241,
0.0476572476,
-0.0159228481,
-0.0125748329,
-0.0078504169,
-0.0238588583,
0.0290531069,
0.0250890441,
0.0500470735,
-0.0341196656,
-0.0516088679,
0.0016686404,
0.0072153872,
0.020504158,
-0.0583393276,
0.0216855798,
0.0024467218,
0.026379019,
-0.0034947766,
0.0118014421,
0.001525323,
0.0169490166,
-0.0588050224,
-0.027864309,
0.0350922756,
0.0102528054,
0.0178902782,
0.0158308856,
-0.0550964773,
-0.038730409,
-0.0037518372,
-0.0262622368,
-0.0240971539,
-0.0533526763,
0.0012210238,
-0.0083161751,
-0.0180352274,
-0.0274400786,
1.919185775e-34,
-0.0177367721,
-0.0176076628,
0.0312768631,
0.0393618755,
-0.0048779096,
0.0148447463,
0.0052715316,
0.0316375978,
0.0483823642,
-0.0519175716,
-0.0882885903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01161v1 | Weakly Supervised Semantic Parsing with Execution-based Spurious Program Filtering | 2023-11-02T11:45:40 | 2023-11-02T11:45:40 | Kang-il Lee, Segwang Kim, Kyomin Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The problem of spurious programs is a longstanding challenge when training a
semantic parser from weak supervision. To eliminate such programs that have
wrong semantics but correct denotation, existing methods focus on exploiting
similarities between examples based on domain-specific knowledge. In this
paper, we propose a domain-agnostic filtering mechanism based on program
execution results. Specifically, for each program obtained through the search
process, we first construct a representation that captures the program's
semantics as execution results under various inputs. Then, we run a majority
vote on these representations to identify and filter out programs with
significantly different semantics from the other programs. In particular, our
method is orthogonal to the program search process so that it can easily
augment any of the existing weakly supervised semantic parsing frameworks.
Empirical evaluations on the Natural Language Visual Reasoning and
WikiTableQuestions demonstrate that applying our method to the existing
semantic parsers induces significantly improved performances. | [
0.0505150184,
0.0022872889,
-0.0193576235,
0.0427862331,
-0.0255194176,
0.0480669662,
-0.0419451296,
-0.0045138304,
0.0239258371,
-0.0549314991,
-0.0195297487,
0.0608868375,
-0.0293465704,
0.0262503475,
0.0202122219,
-0.0203994587,
0.0509131365,
-0.0234476347,
0.0073018451,
0.0406578481,
-0.0033495135,
0.02977621,
0.0115948152,
0.0756156594,
-0.0628569126,
-0.0412503034,
0.0038241961,
0.0223856121,
-0.0288489945,
-0.047148902,
0.008156471,
-0.032289885,
0.0261358693,
0.024746554,
0.0000020125,
-0.0169368051,
-0.0232801046,
0.0061234478,
0.0140423914,
-0.0258233435,
0.0199927539,
-0.0511271544,
0.0157126468,
-0.0387570299,
-0.0295533072,
-0.0444528125,
0.0300583132,
0.0089323036,
0.0956732333,
0.0617010519,
-0.0163038764,
0.0006563706,
-0.0329067335,
0.0100020077,
0.0161807798,
-0.0501429625,
-0.0178598445,
0.0144155826,
-0.0162052773,
-0.0410715342,
-0.0135827307,
0.0267293379,
-0.0088627487,
-0.0235966779,
0.0038795245,
0.0038812235,
-0.0560158901,
-0.0571971498,
-0.0170886554,
0.0400504693,
-0.0110928211,
-0.0246426836,
0.0237069298,
-0.0117707821,
0.0129413623,
0.0094434023,
-0.0169790257,
0.0544179492,
-0.0028413441,
0.0137917437,
0.0220827237,
0.0331316404,
0.0072449241,
-0.0260689482,
0.017164208,
0.0812749937,
-0.0019877707,
-0.0222033188,
0.0090441117,
0.0012967546,
-0.0652707145,
-0.0254580993,
0.0065519591,
0.0147621557,
-0.0378219858,
-0.0053204298,
-0.0566707104,
-0.0015448371,
-0.0088135451,
0.0004409972,
0.0019896461,
0.044531282,
-0.0206039343,
0.0447895676,
-0.0344529338,
0.0144701498,
0.0063631651,
0.0552768819,
-0.0374456756,
-0.0220947862,
-0.0675936565,
-0.0373208895,
-0.0452135839,
0.0722830594,
-0.0434357375,
-0.0077981069,
-0.0225352757,
0.04475284,
-0.038169343,
0.0290037375,
0.0058309902,
0.0327639058,
-0.0543264002,
0.0691170916,
-0.0259986687,
0.0022154078,
-0.0290334281,
-0.008738366,
-0.0077687167,
-0.0022813007,
-0.0276236739,
0.0460505038,
-0.0291299149,
-0.0587670393,
-0.0192424525,
0.0748737156,
0.0347774737,
0.0401263349,
-0.0490145087,
-0.0840996429,
0.008305396,
0.0120711653,
0.0080392361,
-0.0669643059,
-0.0314696878,
-0.0187038779,
0.0423838086,
-0.0503989756,
-0.0231490359,
0.0069712931,
-0.0112999659,
0.0583075769,
-0.0547017343,
-0.023483986,
-0.0117683597,
0.0083532175,
-0.0333260857,
0.0440696776,
-0.0300016627,
0.0099715656,
0.0174696762,
0.016109651,
-0.0356167406,
-0.0112796519,
0.0023589132,
-0.055292394,
-0.0504561812,
0.0074148532,
0.0217836723,
-0.0023765818,
0.0034971223,
-0.0041463575,
-0.0290458184,
-0.003161981,
-0.0381901711,
0.0421769544,
-0.0338505879,
-0.0189394746,
0.1206113249,
0.005167814,
-0.0386542454,
0.0182149224,
-0.1248733401,
-0.0031952625,
-0.0029200553,
-0.0119117852,
-0.0863801166,
-0.0045891218,
-0.0088313119,
-0.0292332824,
0.0209590383,
-0.029423207,
-0.010918634,
-0.0440541282,
0.0208879169,
0.0523891598,
0.00147248,
0.0524566136,
0.0109277451,
0.009221687,
-0.0238586739,
-0.0360733308,
0.0283680316,
0.0653082728,
0.0341352299,
-0.0628821924,
0.0081912056,
0.0180479735,
0.0353587121,
-0.0036440962,
0.0156747289,
-0.0562473871,
0.0168255661,
-0.0067784195,
-0.032143876,
-0.0613568611,
0.0181083418,
-0.0224803984,
-0.0294656474,
-0.0113724666,
0.038817551,
-0.04106934,
0.0208976064,
0.0642405301,
0.0749035999,
-0.0035926267,
-0.0201241933,
0.0329074152,
0.0206514578,
0.0014466657,
0.0148580605,
0.0186217818,
0.0185038205,
-0.0250252206,
-0.0247690566,
-0.016299488,
-0.0311452691,
-0.0841688141,
0.0074506546,
-0.0371063165,
-0.0501571,
0.0168315358,
-0.0453359634,
-0.0119795017,
0.0353117175,
-0.024838075,
0.0230969619,
0.0084210513,
-0.0149545744,
0.0358823761,
-0.040350087,
-0.0619992875,
0.0885375664,
0.0330126062,
-0.030011991,
0.0007968671,
0.0064041228,
0.0212981831,
0.023859337,
-0.0204426572,
0.0066981232,
-0.0332528763,
-0.0200175419,
0.0085443798,
0.0282168295,
-0.0246356446,
0.0028165015,
-0.0564104617,
0.0247483514,
-0.0144651132,
-0.0294148345,
0.0239646398,
0.0315256603,
0.0489683971,
-0.0529093109,
0.0176155027,
0.0017385528,
0.0136527345,
0.0034085985,
0.0337552652,
0.0333309323,
-0.007871503,
-0.006518133,
-0.0166902859,
-0.0355882943,
0.0483430102,
-0.0120091457,
-0.022162348,
-0.0386745334,
0.0574618466,
-0.0209156591,
0.0333375297,
0.0187997948,
0.0250903685,
0.0402726084,
-0.0341021307,
-0.0703679919,
0.068978563,
-0.0434188321,
0.0332259238,
0.021068139,
-0.0217161048,
-0.0756321773,
0.0241911374,
0.0265299436,
-0.0049787615,
-0.0148256253,
0.0118890386,
0.0105901975,
0.0208072774,
0.0284684654,
0.0271829031,
-0.0455075391,
0.0508234873,
-0.0077662887,
-0.0487266295,
-0.027530903,
-0.037989676,
0.0223397221,
-0.0170401148,
-0.0082508922,
-0.0433009714,
0.1144560948,
0.0152286701,
0.0114171887,
-0.0271292441,
-0.0055279555,
-6.89e-7,
0.0544113219,
-0.0117708733,
-0.0089828921,
-0.0168819372,
-0.0392834917,
-0.0244452991,
-0.0345075391,
0.0332617722,
0.0343983434,
0.0915049613,
-0.0659387931,
0.0188759621,
0.0101178465,
-0.0099418322,
-0.0574882403,
-0.0753263459,
-0.0041633653,
-0.017363064,
-0.0259812661,
0.0359847508,
0.0252790619,
-0.0044278065,
-0.0510200933,
0.0206653308,
0.0293362532,
-0.04668165,
-0.0452091284,
-0.0430088937,
0.0258094314,
-0.0293642469,
-0.0491174497,
0.0461651199,
0.050585404,
0.0378911421,
0.0431685746,
-0.0549760573,
-0.0334528983,
0.049878303,
-0.0293849912,
-0.0071490631,
-0.040802747,
0.0298247579,
0.0560464635,
-0.0793556944,
-0.0196472965,
0.0758001581,
0.0572741702,
0.0185168274,
0.0404063389,
0.0031627414,
0.0271482673,
0.0903284922,
0.0117414789,
-0.0259118713,
-0.0813700259,
-0.0262514148,
0.0506794825,
0.0037023074,
-0.0197627489,
0.0320768952,
-0.1085144579,
-0.0046811295,
0.0171850156,
0.0046575218,
0.0033731475,
0.0023161788,
-0.0381723158,
-0.0350028276,
-0.0256916285,
-0.0380305201,
0.0080401991,
0.0217509475,
0.0036105739,
0.0425436869,
-0.006033042,
0.0476839729,
-0.0166512448,
0.0066976063,
0.0846441537,
-0.0087819006,
0.0060770861,
0.0139877796,
0.0577596016,
-0.0403697938,
0.0268997755,
-0.0341084525,
0.0327882618,
0.0001198477,
-0.0379468761,
0.0074307001,
0.0054969895,
-0.0336697139,
-0.0532918535,
0.0224190932,
0.0774243623,
-0.0661677048,
0.0026696087,
-0.0109670376,
-0.0340322293,
0.0173279475,
0.0514916666,
0.0181735028,
0.0234649051,
-0.0352568179,
-0.0346173719,
-0.0137491152,
-0.033765696,
-0.015609432,
0.006695956,
0.0275123566,
-0.0269536581,
-0.0520241149,
-0.0322001055,
0.0448936187,
0.036148563,
-0.0171492659,
0.0004703868,
0.0327368565,
-0.0124417916,
-0.0134566631,
0.0664069206,
-0.0132513577,
0.0309875589,
0.0125744855,
0.0047345129,
-0.0029956095,
0.0317717269,
-0.041481588,
0.029449787,
-0.0503615253,
-0.010342489,
-0.0206865203,
0.0852383375,
0.0102487616,
0.0692211315,
-0.052791018,
0.0131967952,
-0.032269042,
0.0688987821,
-0.0347885229,
-0.0243945438,
0.0187367275,
-0.0413591154,
0.0069681858,
0.020713903,
-0.0580928624,
0.0029451114,
0.0324216783,
0.0301307347,
0.014643006,
0.0285204668,
0.0863744766,
0.0386849642,
0.0533072501,
0.0113082901,
0.0226213392,
0.0338710733,
-0.0072387601,
-0.0067404523,
-0.0755261555,
-0.0359227583,
0.0375490859,
0.0168633517,
-0.000583998,
0.0242853966,
-0.0168580133,
-0.0412069932,
0.0527213924,
-0.0422392115,
0.0081418734,
0.0449218042,
0.0309780855,
-0.012156548,
0.0137101561,
-0.0040747095,
0.0211960021,
0.0139676454,
0.0499208681,
-0.044181969,
0.0413954854,
0.0410376526,
0.0383122489,
-0.0186494514,
0.0188070703,
-0.0407236032,
0.00498241,
0.0122169545,
0.0083358716,
0.0018945952,
-0.0352156274,
0.0076703839,
0.0229744297,
0.0008782657,
0.0160689838,
-0.0018758129,
0.0570591204,
-0.0458550602,
0.0403086655,
0.0189021826,
-0.0194305666,
-0.0574136376,
0.0369492732,
-0.0486232452,
0.0722006783,
-0.0129968021,
-0.0391388535,
-0.06192974,
-0.0547876991,
0.0320887864,
0.0098318271,
-0.0289188884,
-0.0051429765,
-0.0232446846,
-0.0622098371,
-0.0167928599,
0.0059630722,
-0.0061798375,
0.0270388965,
0.0325930752,
0.06069462,
0.0339874849,
-0.0356533006,
0.0007436774,
-0.0158808008,
0.0218656566,
-0.0231832378,
-0.0614754595,
-5.5190492e-33,
-0.0516684018,
0.0028803062,
0.002933729,
-0.0239264555,
0.0143698631,
-0.0336424001,
-0.0334644355,
-0.0468287505,
-0.0014904285,
0.0022030934,
0.0321046859,
0.0307905953,
0.0182542223,
-0.0170568861,
0.0197434146,
-0.0247381367,
0.0263463594,
0.0077001769,
-0.0422904678,
0.0250583794,
0.0336590596,
-0.0101108318,
0.0101470118,
-0.093607001,
0.0120530203,
0.0388866998,
-0.0142780934,
0.0384254046,
-0.0060377009,
0.0629377589,
0.0124543477,
0.0011854995,
-0.0021417772,
-0.0091677047,
-0.0340169296,
-0.050922364,
-0.0558159016,
-0.0311790071,
0.0416054875,
0.0027639174,
-0.0132257994,
-0.0184429307,
0.0363206081,
-0.0014512036,
0.0147522883,
0.0241477024,
0.0472771339,
-0.007751259,
0.0243870392,
0.0247440357,
-0.0627857968,
-0.0093909772,
-0.0451495051,
0.0026492355,
-0.0028953489,
-0.0017145721,
0.037615113,
0.0431592949,
-0.0204800218,
-0.0059329662,
-0.0701602325,
0.0403116643,
0.0531280525,
0.0040858095,
0.003038222,
0.0355984345,
-0.0289424639,
-0.0219245721,
0.0140098846,
0.0210902002,
-0.0232331585,
0.0680367649,
0.024160672,
0.0129843121,
0.0267787483,
0.0085959788,
-0.0424924828,
-0.0025684843,
-0.0572335944,
0.0620266199,
-0.0382383727,
0.0036377225,
-0.0395117216,
0.0188555066,
-0.0134976851,
0.0229323916,
-0.0407547243,
-0.0006424624,
0.0701095462,
-0.0146121988,
-0.0125333127,
0.0532772131,
-0.0071874647,
-0.0653564408,
0.0099710189,
-0.0121548073,
-0.0203093253,
-0.0181124099,
-0.011986169,
0.0131425317,
0.0506728962,
-0.063773267,
0.0698517039,
-0.0017250211,
0.0895256549,
0.0100425957,
0.056517832,
0.025867546,
-0.0118073858,
0.009565684,
-0.0448839441,
0.0098133981,
-0.0584462844,
0.0162475128,
0.0173808448,
-0.0022800809,
-0.0350749977,
-0.0027274671,
-0.008087243,
-0.0533757992,
-0.0208007414,
-0.0385557488,
0.0133310892,
-0.0030791627,
-0.0378374271,
-0.0312309153,
0.0090036169,
-0.0176310614,
-0.0005981781,
-0.0361877941,
-0.0115941064,
0.017553119,
2.697e-7,
0.0312821679,
-0.0225065723,
0.0093672257,
0.021916572,
0.0001718449,
0.0682833418,
-0.023142755,
0.0368566476,
-0.0096360827,
-0.0756380409,
-0.0250042975,
-0.0202614479,
-0.0041307197,
0.0141486395,
-0.0441186987,
0.0447629653,
0.013567457,
-0.0383209959,
-0.0499561913,
0.0180692822,
0.0992164314,
0.114012517,
0.0223069321,
-0.025319552,
0.015246246,
-0.0721686706,
-0.0150727546,
0.0374045037,
-0.0048602712,
0.0131013291,
-0.0316553637,
0.0061959508,
0.0368856192,
0.0409963578,
-0.0373997986,
0.0167889837,
0.039690055,
0.0442297868,
-0.0453096703,
0.0367654972,
-0.0419131704,
-0.0278840326,
0.0581898466,
0.0243510604,
0.0691371486,
-0.0549935699,
0.0095921634,
0.0437509008,
-0.0127286566,
0.0046849549,
-0.0459660962,
-0.0212774388,
0.0128186541,
0.0276414957,
0.0350423381,
0.0222862307,
-0.0131612429,
-0.04540544,
-0.0296334308,
-0.0130378231,
-0.0221456364,
-0.0078193089,
-0.0191196781,
0.082160145,
0.0610550046,
-0.0163906664,
-0.0140674114,
2.545382866e-34,
0.0318393484,
0.0219555963,
0.0328659937,
-0.0296634044,
0.0495043471,
0.0225295424,
-0.0405860804,
0.0166559275,
-0.0067758616,
-0.0184368752,
-0.0052578729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01153v1 | ACES: Translation Accuracy Challenge Sets at WMT 2023 | 2023-11-02T11:29:09 | 2023-11-02T11:29:09 | Chantal Amrhein, Nikita Moghe, Liane Guillou | cs.CL | cs.CL | We benchmark the performance of segmentlevel metrics submitted to WMT 2023
using the ACES Challenge Set (Amrhein et al., 2022). The challenge set consists
of 36K examples representing challenges from 68 phenomena and covering 146
language pairs. The phenomena range from simple perturbations at the
word/character level to more complex errors based on discourse and real-world
knowledge. For each metric, we provide a detailed profile of performance over a
range of error categories as well as an overall ACES-Score for quick
comparison. We also measure the incremental performance of the metrics
submitted to both WMT 2023 and 2022. We find that 1) there is no clear winner
among the metrics submitted to WMT 2023, and 2) performance change between the
2023 and 2022 versions of the metrics is highly variable. Our recommendations
are similar to those from WMT 2022. Metric developers should focus on: building
ensembles of metrics from different design families, developing metrics that
pay more attention to the source and rely less on surface-level overlap, and
carefully determining the influence of multilingual embeddings on MT
evaluation. | [
0.0053099738,
0.0588491671,
-0.0008669766,
0.0260982923,
-0.0397791676,
-0.0123498039,
0.0136654424,
0.0225333516,
-0.0453749634,
0.0019758733,
-0.0374991,
-0.0715427026,
0.0765305012,
0.013555971,
0.062795572,
-0.0606779307,
0.036020346,
-0.016890917,
-0.0381137691,
0.0152989672,
-0.0052631036,
-0.0013919027,
-0.0331077129,
0.0487354062,
0.0006324849,
-0.0211479347,
0.0162137449,
0.0371290855,
0.0567146316,
-0.0303385593,
0.0118967639,
0.0383357517,
-0.0101383431,
0.1168784052,
0.0000021443,
-0.0432332307,
-0.0248880163,
0.0192858428,
0.0016672049,
0.0241570324,
0.0169159267,
-0.063387081,
-0.0231129769,
0.025757907,
-0.0070462716,
-0.0300161168,
0.0494588763,
-0.0056264838,
0.0356829837,
0.0768618211,
-0.0102567626,
0.0178233068,
0.0183323827,
-0.0299201906,
-0.0123416008,
-0.0361980759,
-0.0424182601,
0.0104519455,
-0.0385897122,
0.0048892903,
-0.0229935758,
0.0223074518,
0.0032260311,
-0.0069550984,
0.0067076357,
-0.0040036198,
-0.0453445949,
-0.0130988583,
0.0062624905,
0.0618487,
0.0186354276,
0.0054424754,
-0.0352750719,
0.004946264,
-0.0488921553,
-0.062899895,
-0.0243115202,
-0.0193861369,
0.0043222862,
-0.017843904,
-0.0250050388,
0.05225683,
0.0352645405,
-0.0121566281,
-0.0185540784,
0.0089408951,
0.0389609709,
-0.0462505594,
-0.0203954093,
0.0248001572,
-0.0038479054,
-0.0314217806,
0.0388807021,
-0.0330131724,
-0.0471215174,
0.0000885777,
-0.0325555466,
-0.0478435867,
0.0199698824,
-0.0592289865,
0.0675962046,
0.0718299448,
-0.0118315229,
0.0469527468,
0.000856843,
0.1106917188,
-0.0062475288,
-0.015415349,
-0.0553686097,
-0.0293088611,
-0.0076676407,
0.0457454585,
-0.002143797,
-0.0326592475,
-0.0348680131,
0.0006012525,
-0.0403034985,
-0.0056612082,
-0.009446973,
0.0271685272,
0.0236390363,
-0.0295451991,
-0.0642047971,
-0.039863389,
0.0027223774,
0.0620378926,
-0.041800566,
-0.0225458778,
-0.0023095761,
-0.0258823298,
-0.015788909,
0.0250712465,
-0.0232833307,
-0.024119528,
0.0118296007,
0.078927584,
-0.026438104,
-0.0321440399,
0.011739647,
-0.0139807221,
-0.0361339338,
-0.075827755,
-0.0103657488,
-0.0558255762,
0.056530904,
-0.0012652465,
0.0084377592,
-0.0068710977,
0.0072032823,
-0.0166142415,
0.0213540159,
0.0461453237,
0.0143160708,
0.0091017857,
0.0205864273,
0.0128074279,
-0.0077080438,
0.067642279,
0.0560979918,
0.0131550375,
0.0624700971,
0.0087217242,
-0.0581710227,
0.0427430682,
0.0132803116,
0.0418736786,
-0.0313975997,
-0.0102883382,
-0.0077365004,
0.053463947,
0.014710539,
0.0718255341,
-0.0090678371,
0.0180878285,
0.0701125562,
0.0157386288,
0.0151234921,
0.0379701033,
0.0300298929,
-0.0005918954,
-0.0033876393,
-0.0139510836,
-0.0004720405,
0.0145698944,
-0.0225651637,
-0.0041599069,
0.0703263953,
0.036363069,
0.0012590321,
-0.0556196682,
-0.0216328464,
-0.0058460687,
-0.008414045,
-0.0396761112,
0.0243542753,
-0.0088622971,
-0.031756267,
0.0210143626,
-0.0219246168,
-0.0692180246,
0.0044094925,
0.0097049344,
-0.0228097029,
0.0452297665,
0.0682618544,
-0.0026445673,
-0.0527444743,
0.0150919165,
0.0169461463,
0.0684811547,
0.0780843869,
0.0128507921,
0.05932023,
-0.041011788,
-0.0201748963,
0.0337660462,
0.0163726378,
0.0240364783,
0.0156714264,
0.0596150681,
0.0211557355,
-0.1033221185,
-0.0306518245,
0.0274171513,
0.0055475258,
0.0108717587,
0.007400238,
0.0107477838,
0.0321621075,
0.0470444895,
-0.0284216423,
0.0020757951,
-0.0063202274,
-0.0540111996,
-0.0140890786,
0.0419185385,
-0.0390745252,
-0.0133270482,
0.0537755899,
-0.0704926476,
-0.0076034926,
0.014764972,
-0.0286579151,
-0.0425255373,
0.0024827113,
-0.0409969725,
-0.0011338575,
-0.0293309074,
0.0314644687,
-0.0143038211,
0.0081020417,
-0.01401053,
0.0187718254,
-0.0179868396,
0.052359093,
-0.0010238014,
-0.052101329,
0.0252488516,
0.0234091599,
-0.0238813106,
0.0236582905,
0.0090701999,
0.0421308614,
0.0455819741,
0.0309779998,
-0.0526754893,
-0.0345353223,
-0.0725545883,
0.0328501277,
-0.0302113928,
0.0514503717,
0.0198670905,
0.02942059,
-0.0113228811,
0.0167740975,
-0.0151459426,
-0.0419894755,
-0.0085672988,
-0.0135669876,
0.0234443545,
-0.0146692647,
0.0289240126,
-0.0547519587,
0.0018764855,
0.0012840616,
0.0348534994,
-0.0073162932,
0.0007182592,
-0.0552639551,
0.0209575668,
-0.0426696762,
-0.0149495015,
0.0031638555,
-0.0663440078,
0.009175946,
0.0182470493,
0.0520663373,
0.0339711718,
-0.0017405271,
0.0055782711,
-0.0076508671,
-0.0160027482,
-0.0489791781,
0.0052146618,
0.0210656747,
-0.015456521,
-0.0027749133,
-0.0403373651,
0.0224260315,
0.0547393635,
-0.0019335578,
-0.0008996385,
-0.0721417144,
-0.0109587768,
-0.0494146906,
-0.0253014471,
0.017175125,
0.0173484366,
0.0030236994,
0.0372147001,
-0.043825604,
-0.0459455661,
0.0679853559,
-0.0811455473,
-0.0261602085,
-0.0532254763,
0.0159067158,
-0.0164785106,
0.0580094457,
-0.0065133907,
0.0133322291,
-0.0262874942,
-0.0188394021,
-0.0382404849,
0.0182628129,
0.0104341805,
-0.0390121751,
0.0384496562,
-0.0620315522,
-0.0278592519,
-0.0419952571,
-0.0139797563,
-0.0048679756,
0.0172797795,
0.0137208346,
-0.0159561783,
0.0221686438,
-0.0571907535,
-0.0548072942,
0.014989621,
0.0237630103,
0.0501062982,
-0.011692429,
-0.0162282772,
-0.005868997,
0.0059942086,
0.0007321645,
0.0264977925,
0.0159616806,
-0.0565956831,
0.0227068625,
0.0473976284,
0.0312378686,
-0.0330028683,
-0.0244748704,
-0.0217223968,
0.0414007679,
-0.0160972811,
-0.0307106487,
-0.0174120404,
0.1187420487,
-0.0501115285,
0.0009130564,
0.1136865839,
0.0404748656,
-0.0308923647,
0.0043883384,
-0.0158991553,
0.0663958192,
0.0188121907,
-0.0037409926,
-0.0678257272,
-0.010749937,
0.0312291477,
0.0598229878,
0.0113348244,
-0.0155057302,
-0.0052540679,
-0.0783542842,
0.0177561399,
0.0557990633,
-0.053701777,
-0.0432452708,
-0.0064410251,
-0.0027761683,
-0.002085824,
0.056141004,
-0.0142660215,
0.0250036269,
-0.0028631047,
0.0385906883,
-0.0642568022,
-0.0658665746,
0.0310391597,
-0.0446304269,
0.0297817718,
0.037948031,
0.0439301357,
-0.0118586617,
-0.0489958301,
-0.00021895,
-0.0106605543,
-0.0211534575,
-0.0062255035,
0.0155382305,
-0.0017748753,
-0.0206874795,
-0.0017657119,
0.0047983769,
-0.0157236587,
0.0124404738,
0.0104908543,
0.0795471221,
-0.018265577,
0.0417989567,
-0.0033248984,
-0.0107924929,
-0.0172632206,
0.0436495878,
0.0273958109,
-0.0502492338,
-0.0009566614,
-0.0346329845,
0.0478563569,
-0.0909481198,
0.0083663538,
-0.0199452098,
-0.0246932525,
-0.0243083853,
-0.0848061368,
-0.0611889698,
0.0009981194,
0.0388213098,
-0.0118881362,
-0.0169586595,
-0.048417531,
-0.0054952451,
-0.0343411118,
0.0141575607,
-0.0232996643,
0.0528997183,
-0.0540695749,
0.03759294,
-0.0224456824,
0.0103360871,
-0.0029387423,
0.0408755206,
-0.06402082,
-0.0642243102,
-0.0279780161,
0.0445593223,
0.0191522669,
0.0078054424,
-0.0246669464,
-0.0186447911,
0.0118521918,
-0.0071837418,
0.0040372219,
0.0190147962,
0.0548061691,
-0.0373913124,
-0.017786596,
0.0437140204,
-0.0102627845,
-0.0394636281,
-0.0204243418,
0.0750168264,
0.0464515723,
-0.0366940983,
0.0159548707,
0.0146917189,
0.0452024639,
-0.0414036289,
-0.0316300429,
-0.0171414018,
0.0221923869,
-0.0071009216,
-0.0285332911,
-0.0430162139,
-0.0273883045,
0.0507944822,
0.0032517889,
-0.0163501333,
0.0293039493,
-0.028248243,
0.003893516,
-0.0087405704,
0.0401321277,
-0.0069315308,
0.0541707873,
-0.0090567842,
0.0192432087,
-0.026869392,
-0.0393036678,
-0.0070009683,
0.0253918972,
-0.034409456,
0.0289707072,
0.0015141254,
0.0306022298,
0.01109144,
0.0489964485,
-0.0031548217,
0.0297942031,
-0.0186563712,
0.0159917623,
0.0945661217,
0.0186139308,
0.115529485,
-0.0028878802,
0.004079524,
-0.0252542198,
0.0505924448,
-0.020156052,
-0.0128918383,
-0.0192331653,
0.003256012,
0.0061059818,
0.0379229374,
0.0584267229,
-0.045038756,
-0.0024259421,
0.0162188224,
-0.0060310932,
-0.0060126199,
-0.0178177841,
-0.0134998346,
-0.0162580404,
-0.0261263568,
-0.0386291072,
-0.0592502244,
-0.065361917,
0.0549291186,
0.0503452495,
-0.0192098189,
0.010327518,
-0.0111239832,
0.0833913609,
-0.0381385311,
0.0113832559,
-0.0298483465,
-0.0342416056,
-0.004069489,
0.0118515734,
-0.0051882365,
-6.380183668e-33,
-0.0392998308,
0.0119741028,
-0.0142695904,
-0.0573519059,
-0.0712694898,
0.0165127013,
-0.0259423926,
0.0105896173,
0.0093656098,
0.0331595652,
-0.0075917537,
0.0005207489,
0.0201609805,
-0.0094577875,
-0.0062884567,
0.0027748891,
0.0421781018,
0.0032490741,
-0.0654347613,
0.007860559,
0.011178555,
-0.0051045292,
0.103109926,
-0.0598939694,
0.0731718987,
-0.0007664041,
-0.0069601289,
0.0075038346,
0.0271593388,
0.0434938259,
0.013008425,
0.0504983477,
0.0028742943,
-0.0041982578,
-0.0248567965,
-0.0582218543,
-0.0693049505,
-0.0359788947,
0.0249824841,
0.0522055253,
-0.0299476627,
-0.0202694386,
0.0268965401,
-0.0120367063,
-0.0344774723,
-0.0475588888,
-0.0036783603,
-0.0584560893,
-0.0319499783,
-0.0065827579,
-0.0472220853,
0.0243342388,
-0.0402912684,
-0.0074596931,
-0.0019330349,
0.0420411825,
0.0207265634,
-0.0202923696,
-0.0900356174,
0.0097800223,
-0.0444608629,
0.0417121574,
0.0862048715,
-0.0387852266,
-0.0340257883,
0.0335381441,
0.0339929573,
-0.0112514999,
0.0436889566,
-0.013335648,
0.0501261689,
-0.0086675258,
0.0847355723,
0.050972987,
0.0089102089,
-0.0099270791,
-0.0477275141,
0.0672467053,
-0.0089213448,
0.0281712338,
-0.0140295355,
0.00703617,
-0.059232302,
0.0194845162,
-0.0376116037,
-0.0163086522,
-0.0273418482,
-0.0333769433,
-0.0027114097,
-0.0032637541,
-0.0059596444,
-0.0111521706,
0.0612678006,
-0.0133832758,
0.0148148779,
-0.0412832946,
-0.0043735262,
0.0270405021,
-0.0206373576,
0.0688933358,
-0.0213489346,
-0.0281484313,
0.0062194895,
0.0468271486,
0.020427363,
-0.0509810373,
0.0261589251,
0.0536764003,
-0.0720794499,
0.0166591834,
-0.0267883595,
-0.0015630166,
-0.0400936902,
0.0211259164,
0.0201245695,
-0.019141715,
-0.0141554093,
0.0334319137,
0.0213667471,
0.0092983097,
-0.0240725391,
0.0147707565,
-0.0074707409,
0.0255942717,
-0.0458234437,
0.0078439955,
-0.0191162173,
-0.0157516785,
0.0309381895,
-0.0320544243,
-0.0304277595,
-0.0052786008,
2.776e-7,
0.0642648786,
0.0739373267,
0.0249023288,
0.0140460972,
-0.0064119683,
0.0055952924,
-0.0627768636,
0.0222652815,
-0.0287752226,
0.0621300153,
0.0338648744,
-0.0131123615,
0.0998343006,
0.056672845,
-0.0394691005,
0.015170305,
-0.0614319481,
0.0069520841,
-0.0504043773,
0.0049378001,
0.0427883267,
0.0646074414,
-0.0059304112,
0.0237079225,
-0.0008249309,
-0.0451072603,
0.0669933856,
-0.0244143158,
-0.0297287777,
0.0216037165,
0.0464737825,
0.0106141856,
-0.0110619077,
-0.016945608,
-0.0334644727,
0.0104613313,
0.0643599108,
0.0329900682,
0.022741437,
-0.030214902,
-0.0003267345,
0.003523868,
-0.0066647269,
-0.0527851172,
0.0405440181,
0.0257625207,
-0.0296053272,
0.0103546241,
-0.0257481374,
0.0305353981,
0.0740999877,
-0.0230462495,
-0.0533903725,
0.0220641363,
0.0670563579,
0.0202314574,
-0.0260247942,
-0.0227334257,
-0.0382580049,
-0.0286596976,
0.0141801098,
-0.0621959753,
-0.0153676243,
0.0004411715,
-0.0116264485,
-0.0279211309,
-0.0208171401,
2.835438622e-34,
0.0660831705,
-0.0295279641,
0.0215320569,
-0.0268439297,
0.0362282507,
-0.0354519673,
0.0110375211,
-0.023712106,
-0.0202955417,
-0.0244667679,
-0.0026209375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01152v1 | Predicting Question-Answering Performance of Large Language Models through Semantic Consistency | 2023-11-02T11:27:21 | 2023-11-02T11:27:21 | Ella Rabinovich, Samuel Ackerman, Orna Raz, Eitan Farchi, Ateret Anaby-Tavor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic consistency of a language model is broadly defined as the model's
ability to produce semantically-equivalent outputs, given
semantically-equivalent inputs. We address the task of assessing
question-answering (QA) semantic consistency of contemporary large language
models (LLMs) by manually creating a benchmark dataset with high-quality
paraphrases for factual questions, and release the dataset to the community.
We further combine the semantic consistency metric with additional
measurements suggested in prior work as correlating with LLM QA accuracy, for
building and evaluating a framework for factual QA reference-less performance
prediction -- predicting the likelihood of a language model to accurately
answer a question. Evaluating the framework on five contemporary LLMs, we
demonstrate encouraging, significantly outperforming baselines, results. | [
0.0665601119,
0.0509415232,
0.0038186775,
0.0574065559,
-0.0340884067,
-0.0088830786,
-0.0227527414,
0.0083651142,
-0.0365398303,
-0.0658805668,
0.0003083815,
-0.0005354021,
-0.0243636016,
-0.0330308415,
0.0108207837,
-0.0068702828,
0.0411589891,
-0.0231508128,
-0.0219986681,
-0.0210083853,
0.0296691172,
0.0272731576,
0.0133857829,
0.0293427296,
0.0048507187,
-0.0276972335,
0.0254890937,
0.0053041251,
-0.0141496193,
0.005198373,
0.0194493327,
0.0120676039,
-0.0031058488,
0.0518826544,
0.0000015593,
-0.0791932195,
0.0022848973,
0.0038487324,
-0.0490794256,
0.03869728,
0.0143702803,
-0.0053843958,
0.0396083295,
0.0227963421,
-0.0274519138,
0.0059327567,
0.0122132059,
-0.0003368061,
0.0998637378,
0.0101545835,
0.0259822365,
-0.0207621306,
0.025121456,
0.0079311552,
0.017104106,
-0.0461730137,
0.0254814606,
0.0852151513,
-0.0209198743,
0.0112272287,
-0.0148331719,
0.0505206175,
0.0220202487,
0.025076136,
-0.0131090125,
0.0065643224,
-0.065555349,
-0.0071207643,
0.0216527507,
0.072676383,
0.0216727871,
-0.0478451289,
-0.0260108318,
0.0030161918,
-0.0090044308,
0.0486675762,
-0.0638849437,
0.0171677135,
0.0058653085,
0.0110147838,
0.0176201072,
-0.0068328381,
0.0155849904,
0.0401485227,
0.001515342,
0.0972821638,
0.0276436042,
-0.0297640953,
-0.0289761145,
0.0084925871,
-0.0373543911,
-0.0472176261,
-0.0198805239,
0.0374234132,
-0.0439422131,
0.0492053479,
-0.0436790064,
0.010844036,
0.0602486134,
-0.0466000587,
0.0199527442,
0.0373422876,
0.0178515781,
0.0593830235,
-0.03097222,
0.088085942,
-0.025667524,
0.041184172,
-0.0717718676,
-0.071957022,
-0.0312274415,
-0.0186731648,
-0.0212174971,
0.0460234098,
0.0204088781,
-0.0107777258,
-0.0295301452,
0.0278689805,
-0.0029288037,
0.0189476404,
0.0031237865,
0.0241757371,
-0.0269351117,
0.0008827539,
-0.0742278844,
0.032674633,
-0.0490507819,
0.0246301088,
-0.0169240627,
-0.0900880545,
-0.0072204862,
0.006018572,
0.0014364938,
-0.0355594419,
0.0128710046,
0.041211769,
0.0129047725,
0.010160855,
-0.011936049,
-0.0343214124,
-0.0025698,
-0.0694151893,
-0.0226795487,
-0.093309015,
0.0338006616,
0.0307784304,
-0.0004885645,
-0.0432134755,
0.0092081008,
0.0313399285,
-0.0047499556,
0.0620918386,
0.00781787,
0.0065116487,
0.0259809699,
0.0081596691,
0.0043275873,
0.046407029,
0.0123159289,
-0.0262698308,
0.087795414,
0.0074840672,
-0.0196605362,
0.0308341868,
0.04024354,
0.0224399231,
-0.0246032905,
0.0889405459,
0.0472799912,
0.0230232738,
0.0166897979,
0.0613887087,
-0.010055122,
-0.0747211277,
0.0390150622,
0.0331126451,
-0.0086535336,
0.0020041594,
0.0465290137,
0.0155708473,
0.0356171355,
0.0066455789,
-0.0406334288,
0.0042874566,
0.0005777533,
0.0332631953,
0.0301768854,
0.0027813115,
-0.0232428201,
-0.0303923134,
-0.0367135331,
-0.0006598409,
-0.0456518456,
0.0349008329,
-0.0101519777,
0.0026134027,
-0.0127970017,
0.1090121344,
0.0098524755,
-0.0292033125,
0.0104040653,
-0.0455552749,
0.0563846752,
0.0157152154,
0.0448378026,
-0.0134084346,
-0.0610215738,
0.005442108,
0.0254529957,
0.0340603851,
0.0437727571,
-0.0143662598,
0.0320719741,
-0.0042123208,
0.007505869,
-0.0131860096,
0.0136891818,
-0.0341884568,
0.0518344194,
0.0073603685,
0.031749174,
-0.0761089772,
-0.019058248,
0.0286469255,
-0.0225207917,
-0.012462155,
-0.0172232985,
-0.0276482385,
0.0238540974,
-0.0047069383,
-0.0196344424,
0.0303984862,
0.0263720192,
-0.0119893504,
-0.0032567338,
-0.0136045171,
-0.0364160575,
-0.0171546955,
0.0691360161,
0.0104304235,
-0.0240086503,
0.0654167607,
-0.0401272252,
-0.0260335617,
-0.0057821306,
-0.0470063277,
0.0187077206,
-0.0589136109,
-0.0071204775,
-0.0200536139,
0.0086784512,
-0.0336684473,
0.0272370037,
0.0141217131,
0.0682393163,
0.0141449608,
0.02231103,
0.0303694867,
-0.0234637428,
-0.0198010448,
-0.0004980643,
-0.0048510884,
0.0199504439,
0.0389255732,
-0.0049832007,
-0.0723316595,
-0.0101387482,
-0.0622900501,
0.0135511812,
-0.0206670575,
0.02034471,
0.0471651815,
0.0027714027,
0.0039519174,
-0.0271604173,
-0.0470368527,
-0.0219590515,
0.035182327,
0.0101490393,
0.0477681719,
0.0149679575,
-0.0161656402,
-0.0642327592,
-0.0181001388,
-0.0096955849,
0.0362205692,
0.0025354901,
0.0289132446,
-0.0463936329,
-0.0010318111,
-0.0878615007,
0.0129589224,
0.007493448,
-0.0188069064,
-0.0016112815,
0.0150154894,
-0.0122478437,
0.0466662236,
0.0097083161,
-0.0434163436,
0.0454655662,
0.0157450549,
-0.0877995491,
-0.0109961918,
-0.0041013896,
-0.0562949553,
-0.0304329768,
-0.0502514318,
0.0049561099,
0.0377222076,
0.0254920945,
-0.0092747211,
-0.0243947767,
0.0373807177,
-0.0301431809,
0.0006626326,
-0.0502379909,
0.0103852926,
-0.0218393598,
0.0433158129,
-0.0317875668,
-0.0268720724,
0.0761858374,
-0.0630044416,
-0.0024412805,
-0.0299021062,
-0.0112925973,
-0.0559478365,
0.0313343704,
0.0003274854,
0.0135040358,
-0.0248317085,
0.0152049819,
-0.0492610745,
-0.0276202373,
0.0381392017,
-0.0457775965,
0.0496407188,
-0.0406592563,
0.0326333977,
0.0005266952,
-0.0196406431,
-0.0507289544,
-0.0641881153,
-0.0484446771,
0.0234910324,
-0.0490943156,
0.0021949168,
-0.0122181764,
-0.006188178,
0.0057141916,
-0.0079120034,
-0.0152685037,
-0.0184257124,
-0.0271659344,
0.0498077422,
0.0912547335,
0.0660836399,
0.0299427155,
-0.0037915113,
0.0226414576,
0.0494794995,
0.0303635802,
0.0340690389,
-0.0263922568,
-0.0320019983,
0.006658155,
-0.0225605052,
-0.014872307,
0.0082942611,
0.0318216234,
-0.0340179801,
-0.0214810204,
0.1237511784,
0.0420891643,
0.0325367227,
-0.0138274897,
-0.0409244895,
0.040963944,
0.0329451002,
0.0316963941,
-0.0747922733,
-0.052110035,
-0.0323367864,
0.0397477448,
0.0078060417,
-0.0142715406,
-0.0166139733,
-0.0987515226,
-0.0009962971,
-0.027621543,
-0.0430215187,
-0.0109239072,
-0.0475966707,
0.0300164726,
-0.0178371836,
0.0332665071,
0.0125216758,
-0.020519793,
0.0179733634,
-0.0005897051,
-0.0175575018,
0.0008315215,
0.0662615597,
-0.0656516626,
0.0429279767,
0.0614460707,
0.0263045412,
-0.0050506941,
-0.0082532112,
0.0278355554,
-0.0662085116,
-0.0323644951,
0.0081460392,
0.0401766561,
-0.032030955,
0.0028094132,
-0.0179543048,
-0.0114439493,
-0.016018277,
0.0066954363,
0.0303284191,
0.0557217486,
0.0110272141,
-0.0196640324,
-0.025782777,
0.0254880413,
-0.0517943352,
0.121718362,
0.0351987332,
0.0041006394,
-0.0382462181,
-0.0134516219,
-0.0001738548,
-0.0162257329,
-0.0369102731,
0.0145200845,
0.0053720041,
0.0486240648,
-0.0649153218,
-0.0359261334,
-0.0027991687,
-0.0382767133,
-0.0275655929,
0.045658391,
0.0099968249,
-0.0004975402,
-0.0220478289,
0.0156984758,
-0.0754382238,
0.0322612673,
-0.0294536538,
0.0341902897,
0.0546620898,
0.0091007035,
-0.0308166444,
0.0075796512,
-0.100171864,
-0.0227717813,
-0.0078943204,
0.0302716363,
0.0226589758,
0.0255910251,
-0.0143670999,
-0.0220789611,
0.0035863621,
-0.0036103621,
-0.0440704562,
0.0411276817,
0.0088903671,
0.0030362345,
-0.0077341581,
0.0512322821,
-0.0720137805,
-0.0218770374,
0.0049284105,
0.0535049327,
-0.0157880429,
-0.0692571402,
0.0462835431,
0.045250576,
-0.0110506071,
0.0408853628,
0.0304027349,
0.0324238129,
0.0217500646,
-0.0009291935,
-0.0255478006,
-0.0179677345,
0.0248816554,
0.0116565851,
-0.0290874187,
-0.0028007708,
0.0004679522,
-0.047546301,
0.055863481,
-0.0381134301,
-0.0328452438,
0.0084407376,
-0.0193665605,
-0.0027440852,
-0.0266652666,
-0.0462227464,
-0.0288922321,
-0.015915541,
0.042463053,
-0.0005740655,
0.0341475904,
0.0130658038,
-0.0151411258,
-0.0248205457,
-0.0096359784,
-0.0826599076,
-0.0689326152,
-0.0045445659,
0.0361086391,
0.0154790515,
-0.0065582707,
0.0465216525,
-0.0157445204,
-0.0183263347,
-0.0220742431,
-0.0081975246,
0.0224900637,
0.0097491797,
0.092990227,
0.0289506018,
-0.0072265724,
0.0291609131,
0.0564937405,
0.0247796234,
0.0470391922,
-0.0083155753,
-0.0141591178,
-0.0176861417,
-0.0420799367,
-0.0329154991,
0.0008684666,
-0.0079212561,
0.0114700356,
-0.0629373193,
-0.0702524185,
0.0100239487,
0.0216936208,
-0.0171528254,
-0.0291853789,
0.0259858351,
0.0739082322,
0.0249654315,
-0.0266480967,
-0.0377471782,
0.0169810131,
-0.0316791646,
0.0019074158,
-0.0506522879,
-5.62261062e-33,
-0.0212248806,
-0.0020098803,
0.0043298602,
-0.0380934551,
-0.0130770747,
0.0046302914,
-0.0216621365,
-0.0262481011,
-0.0638933033,
-0.0109005552,
-0.0272058565,
0.0402981453,
0.0046951403,
0.0218184963,
-0.004265137,
-0.0598501451,
0.0098196641,
0.000712248,
-0.0373051763,
-0.0087769767,
0.0159796458,
-0.0286224708,
0.0206728969,
-0.0172305107,
0.0287676062,
-0.0399216153,
-0.0013819167,
0.0322972275,
-0.0148610566,
0.0926123112,
-0.0119499341,
0.0666334778,
0.0320849083,
-0.0522127561,
-0.0046255519,
-0.0033985074,
-0.071447514,
-0.0422089137,
0.0652850494,
-0.0116432626,
-0.0773210153,
-0.0040710466,
0.028230682,
-0.0102195628,
-0.0075141136,
-0.0196567066,
0.0259419996,
-0.0097727934,
-0.0075279404,
0.0079544149,
-0.0222556964,
0.0164404735,
-0.002277144,
-0.0013248782,
-0.0284095351,
0.0506969541,
0.0025754098,
0.0474002883,
-0.0223591961,
-0.0140526192,
-0.0117802583,
0.0487343781,
0.0567599945,
0.0104983523,
0.00412049,
0.0413884446,
-0.0085934792,
-0.0222112704,
-0.001604575,
-0.0294583887,
-0.0177244898,
0.0127581339,
0.0631294549,
0.0769452006,
0.0190961435,
0.0404236987,
-0.0634941608,
0.0378622822,
0.00675201,
0.0659175739,
0.0180860311,
-0.0113436542,
-0.01662343,
-0.0001279553,
-0.0916526839,
0.0512437448,
-0.0409009717,
-0.0095701097,
0.0473499224,
-0.0261390787,
-0.0335794352,
-0.0088482825,
0.0380526111,
-0.0670391321,
-0.0235882998,
0.0416546352,
-0.0446242951,
-0.0043725311,
0.0135061089,
0.0727419406,
-0.0281398501,
0.0336388573,
-0.0048936782,
-0.0212945733,
0.0091935899,
0.0045477743,
0.0014504377,
-0.0163086187,
-0.0410747491,
0.0167490747,
-0.0363933407,
-0.0246087536,
-0.0607999563,
-0.0448490418,
0.0184830148,
0.0454587303,
-0.0033462928,
0.0338458084,
0.0100711677,
-0.0181340035,
-0.0165655967,
-0.0045291092,
0.020000739,
0.0198075585,
-0.0428187773,
0.0042008483,
-0.050341811,
0.050387878,
-0.0206858385,
-0.0254650135,
0.0009805515,
0.023564348,
2.126e-7,
0.0727816671,
0.0139452172,
0.0157737434,
0.0538325347,
0.0006151104,
0.0217001662,
0.0029822695,
0.0088318484,
0.0377081297,
-0.0284095556,
-0.0188672915,
0.0363230482,
0.0319666006,
0.025611259,
-0.0700519755,
-0.0031553027,
-0.1145156249,
0.0021681103,
-0.0350983329,
-0.002943635,
0.0464251153,
0.1139629185,
0.0036145418,
-0.0132006286,
-0.0415518209,
-0.0449159853,
0.0509886704,
-0.0357287712,
-0.0080056479,
0.0276465882,
0.011252109,
0.0105636884,
0.0551785231,
0.0233044624,
0.0223718211,
-0.0049508815,
0.0306968894,
0.0509158671,
0.0209580045,
-0.0157833863,
-0.0581688285,
-0.0477410294,
0.0299974289,
-0.0960992351,
0.0907830447,
-0.027255591,
-0.0034813588,
-0.0100704562,
-0.0280710291,
0.0062700808,
0.0345106274,
-0.0148624964,
-0.0294891484,
0.0191132538,
0.0169682167,
0.0001577956,
-0.0133657269,
-0.0215672329,
-0.0477626882,
-0.0115095126,
-0.0276937392,
-0.0556915551,
-0.0141040012,
-0.0186349042,
0.0153186079,
-0.0780300796,
0.0057367594,
1.749907127e-34,
0.020459516,
0.0138898091,
0.0480821319,
0.0164278857,
0.0356833376,
-0.0098343659,
-0.0032290707,
0.0068795937,
0.0083390465,
-0.0707719773,
-0.000846114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01150v1 | Revisiting the Knowledge Injection Frameworks | 2023-11-02T11:18:16 | 2023-11-02T11:18:16 | Peng Fu, Yiming Zhang, Haobo Wang, Weikang Qiu, Junbo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs), such as GPTs, have attained
great impact worldwide. However, how to adapt these LLMs to better suit the
vertical domain-specific tasks by utilizing external knowledge remains not
completely solved. Indeed, there have emerged a few works on this line where
most of them rely on an alignment heuristic that is built to inject the
corresponding knowledge tuple into the associated text sample.
However, despite the promise, we identify a pivotal problem in this work
ubiquitously. Simply put, we find that injecting unaligned (i.e., random)
knowledge tuple into the LLMs achieves comparable (and sometimes better)
results than the aligned knowledge being injected. We therefore take a thorough
investigation of this frustrating finding on a variety of related prior work
and further provide a chain of potential interpretations for the phenomenon.
Based on all that, we offer a simple remediated technique. Briefly, the core of
this technique is rooted in an ideological emphasis on the pruning and
purification of the external knowledge base to be injected into LLMs. At last,
we show that by integrating this technique into most (if not all) knowledge
injection frameworks and recent LLMs, it manages to overcome the aforementioned
sanity problem and further pushes the boundary of the performance of the
domain-adaptive LLMs. | [
0.040042121,
0.0480309688,
-0.0199578851,
0.0598440468,
-0.0507377014,
-0.0053302436,
-0.0340156145,
-0.0196329094,
0.0311375204,
-0.0714215934,
-0.0263786241,
-0.0041146432,
0.0079000574,
0.020947136,
0.0427043922,
-0.0136933969,
0.0390158184,
-0.0412235372,
-0.029105423,
-0.0062659108,
0.0009448067,
-0.0133032249,
0.0254737958,
-0.0058228699,
0.0237920005,
0.009336561,
-0.0379486568,
0.0217581782,
0.0089350408,
0.0443663485,
-0.0153705152,
-0.0077143102,
0.0049662045,
0.0620286688,
0.0000022133,
-0.0422577336,
-0.0511570126,
0.0248190984,
-0.0111976741,
0.0288839098,
-0.0028332351,
-0.0141702816,
-0.0314456187,
0.0144077651,
-0.0564852729,
-0.0164053161,
0.0428159237,
0.0092013292,
0.0627012104,
0.090981245,
-0.0152755361,
0.0108335465,
0.0306298584,
-0.0061120023,
0.0049054138,
-0.0377427489,
0.0274313726,
-0.0124918027,
0.0035649664,
0.0352036431,
-0.0093855606,
0.0307897087,
-0.0035820401,
0.0061857416,
0.0266823452,
0.0332933888,
-0.0403497741,
0.0139460564,
-0.0438391641,
0.0222612228,
0.0104980376,
-0.007260127,
0.0237496831,
-0.0093210516,
-0.0021726338,
0.0458043963,
-0.0200241245,
0.015742261,
0.0026253518,
0.0339576378,
0.0388878435,
-0.0034132299,
0.0493044518,
-0.0185698438,
-0.0285150614,
0.0993607864,
0.0343188569,
-0.0532827675,
-0.0165593885,
0.001116415,
-0.03009215,
-0.0687340498,
-0.0627463311,
0.0490460917,
0.0296608396,
0.0459354557,
-0.0343310535,
0.0025628179,
-0.0036418212,
-0.0284825061,
0.051656235,
0.0534811318,
0.0254480187,
0.0441389605,
-0.0020401198,
0.0765750259,
-0.0365684107,
0.0118619232,
-0.0450646766,
-0.0106738452,
-0.0471328199,
-0.0284860265,
-0.0042216163,
0.0493435077,
-0.0189902745,
-0.0163610652,
-0.0079418607,
0.0911820903,
0.0012942101,
0.0303910766,
-0.0144599685,
-0.0391405225,
-0.0182551481,
-0.0195994545,
-0.0407511853,
0.0214096773,
0.0154099157,
-0.0154007468,
-0.0170773622,
-0.0426700525,
-0.0101151541,
0.019813206,
-0.0460108146,
-0.023762811,
-0.0206687059,
0.1211768463,
0.015171363,
-0.0274778921,
-0.0406268612,
-0.0328279622,
-0.0291166119,
-0.046948798,
0.0167546626,
-0.0667278245,
0.0101863835,
0.0222365502,
-0.0219322871,
-0.091016911,
-0.0024634006,
-0.0100416457,
-0.0734569728,
0.0586156175,
-0.0341437198,
0.0355401561,
0.0075315852,
-0.0013407107,
-0.011929879,
0.1036398187,
0.0215680823,
-0.021792002,
0.0262191352,
-0.0083013205,
-0.0092195747,
0.049529098,
0.0171012487,
0.0442554504,
-0.0380673967,
0.0252955202,
0.0486413538,
0.0111498963,
0.0206008274,
0.0443735421,
0.0154961683,
0.0294237547,
0.0566683076,
0.0051995763,
-0.016264664,
0.0142838927,
0.0403492935,
-0.0043509123,
-0.0256647188,
0.0501991734,
-0.0571768396,
-0.0125677157,
-0.0326117426,
0.0349225588,
0.0389484353,
0.0598905422,
-0.0220939536,
-0.0493143685,
-0.036323946,
-0.0063598631,
-0.0025337713,
0.0017292042,
0.0510611199,
0.0084806299,
-0.0296138152,
0.0336597748,
0.0231912676,
-0.0325134695,
-0.0047182101,
-0.0172298905,
-0.0052721966,
0.0331150405,
0.0658189282,
-0.0366093032,
-0.0616835207,
0.0317152143,
-0.0142431231,
0.0538852476,
0.0433122888,
-0.001958353,
-0.0248506814,
-0.047089383,
-0.056401711,
-0.028183328,
-0.000271364,
0.0418677256,
0.0407547951,
-0.0077302284,
0.0121832471,
-0.0590461381,
0.0029018542,
0.0263957232,
-0.0743360221,
-0.0323178135,
-0.0306580048,
0.0125493882,
0.0195110627,
0.0011260667,
-0.0095165325,
0.0015544762,
0.0378848948,
-0.0212277528,
-0.0443377793,
-0.0084657427,
-0.0076670153,
-0.0049603931,
0.0707955882,
-0.0147173163,
0.0084053632,
-0.0113648642,
-0.0378311761,
-0.0461701564,
0.0308885407,
0.011538933,
0.0721480399,
-0.0191633161,
0.0319649838,
-0.0015592903,
-0.0225389935,
-0.0487923212,
0.0588836819,
0.0244388096,
0.0192260351,
-0.0167362727,
-0.0232089646,
0.0141891055,
0.0153610976,
-0.0376255624,
-0.012205069,
0.0242247004,
0.0484079272,
0.0323122926,
0.0008434139,
-0.0039992505,
-0.0505236797,
-0.0758147612,
0.0561792552,
0.0125548737,
0.0287248082,
0.0279756263,
0.0507425517,
-0.0209817253,
0.0007067508,
-0.0474921316,
-0.0193741005,
-0.0072247861,
0.0286048204,
0.0606746525,
0.0111081824,
0.0082002264,
0.0157375298,
0.0233417843,
-0.0310252309,
0.0462615304,
-0.0139960004,
0.0184232704,
-0.0785992816,
0.0634288266,
-0.0589982942,
0.0498411059,
-0.0287864432,
-0.0216064993,
-0.0317043513,
0.0039622127,
0.0613526329,
0.028937621,
-0.0311665423,
-0.0049407887,
0.0227110516,
-0.0098613054,
-0.0275260042,
0.0124758082,
-0.0307550728,
-0.0461908169,
-0.0433708057,
0.0019528163,
0.0247233659,
0.0806455612,
0.0064975452,
-0.0382901803,
-0.0668448284,
0.0273289364,
-0.026099233,
0.0044867154,
-0.0102277985,
-0.0215702653,
-0.0330727361,
0.0203952212,
-0.0044292682,
-0.0641794801,
0.066119343,
-0.0772562325,
0.0048497501,
-0.0341070965,
-0.0170660913,
-0.0792582557,
0.0076806354,
0.0023767352,
0.0135540534,
0.0242388397,
0.0184347611,
-0.0829532519,
0.0184687637,
0.0103798565,
-0.0249149483,
0.108237043,
-0.044662524,
0.0156572498,
-0.013991002,
-0.0579551384,
-0.0524796993,
-0.0206752736,
-0.0019444907,
-0.006824492,
0.0359739698,
-0.0119334022,
-0.0122028477,
0.0313414484,
0.0267983582,
0.0411571376,
-0.0095748054,
-0.015040949,
-0.0418765806,
0.0201532878,
0.0350758582,
-0.0107838362,
-0.0033746297,
0.0115952268,
-0.0002298458,
0.0327054001,
0.0477023013,
-0.025243124,
-0.007859013,
-0.0164025538,
0.0161184333,
-0.046581585,
-0.0546050481,
0.0015673031,
0.0196395591,
-0.0145065635,
-0.0093202684,
0.1174371094,
0.0187056195,
-0.0233042054,
-0.0070159752,
-0.0059105721,
0.0445075147,
0.0504860505,
0.0523163378,
-0.0781549215,
-0.0111827403,
0.0079424009,
0.0277244132,
0.0049876566,
-0.0267415047,
-0.0390576236,
-0.1608204544,
0.0003625599,
0.0309818648,
-0.0184970461,
-0.0154926991,
-0.0085301232,
0.0272964593,
0.0120486142,
-0.0004370565,
0.0029962764,
-0.0145736709,
0.0054426207,
0.0150239915,
-0.0104457382,
-0.0593582205,
-0.0357999168,
-0.0254777707,
0.0705976635,
0.0572933033,
0.0044263005,
0.0062238476,
-0.0074564898,
-0.0050586327,
-0.0107149752,
-0.0056634555,
0.0087844245,
0.0198319014,
-0.0070647052,
-0.0135181313,
0.0232065562,
0.0001202709,
-0.0809836909,
0.0170321465,
0.0414795168,
0.1293431818,
-0.0012347852,
0.0106734093,
-0.0293378513,
-0.0383975878,
0.0051470678,
0.0981820002,
-0.0142888632,
-0.0327095017,
0.0121676289,
-0.0514067672,
-0.0241967905,
0.0338312611,
-0.0478949584,
0.0427538045,
-0.0165015776,
-0.0273262747,
-0.0657389611,
-0.0349397361,
0.0115650147,
0.0450006239,
0.0572606511,
0.0457769521,
-0.0054502622,
-0.0339645371,
-0.0387573652,
-0.0193206575,
-0.0637157336,
-0.0064855739,
-0.0247435831,
0.0044830092,
0.0028859945,
-0.0472287871,
-0.005252046,
0.0111901192,
-0.0595299229,
-0.1150154099,
-0.0233968757,
0.0354056656,
0.032641124,
0.0700326934,
-0.0213337652,
0.0208617132,
0.0622620657,
0.0392843783,
-0.0358925946,
0.0279717352,
0.0130006224,
-0.0304362662,
0.0313544944,
0.0350294337,
-0.0613857359,
-0.0235992316,
0.0151280537,
0.0081730764,
-0.0258363299,
-0.0348626338,
0.0210886002,
0.0163510982,
0.0486121923,
-0.0173130259,
-0.0070626545,
-0.0010126276,
0.0311419386,
-0.02402924,
-0.0630401373,
-0.0516670384,
-0.0103991935,
-0.0048075588,
0.0274138041,
0.0084903128,
0.0258138683,
0.0168109387,
0.0789381489,
0.0078409463,
-0.0354978926,
0.0217297729,
0.0147345848,
0.0553174242,
0.0214332491,
0.030396793,
0.0384461246,
-0.0028702007,
0.0278457962,
-0.0419706441,
0.0368936844,
0.0505427457,
0.003272637,
0.01255411,
-0.0034700148,
-0.0642869323,
-0.0677821264,
0.0001130104,
0.0175539814,
0.0313898772,
-0.0214779023,
0.0598330349,
-0.0276839957,
0.0047951066,
-0.0102359429,
-0.0006828613,
0.0157888811,
-0.0012749982,
0.0271622632,
0.0303459056,
-0.0385468528,
0.0043995786,
0.0867569968,
0.0151396571,
0.0359579511,
-0.0070627541,
-0.0197744891,
-0.0462806597,
-0.022444509,
0.0565154143,
-0.0061846171,
-0.0071564452,
-0.013828611,
-0.1013726816,
-0.074590154,
0.0124744708,
-0.0027070844,
-0.0112734521,
-0.0259248111,
0.013946739,
0.0786952153,
0.0130024338,
0.0164804198,
-0.0527991839,
0.0243301373,
-0.0663676783,
-0.0165455956,
0.0314543508,
-6.329284028e-33,
-0.0475662053,
-0.0041676327,
0.0234527402,
0.0117322132,
-0.0099043576,
0.0058191717,
-0.0032935308,
-0.0245101657,
0.0018848324,
-0.0189191476,
-0.0112184957,
-0.0118943863,
0.0053058104,
-0.0006427222,
0.0089148153,
0.0135473758,
0.0005247234,
-0.0159026552,
-0.032585144,
-0.000025945,
0.0354370214,
0.0063864323,
0.0539479256,
-0.019807132,
0.0248543825,
-0.0213099308,
0.0255776532,
0.0242593978,
0.0348258801,
0.0497214273,
-0.0184918903,
0.0458859019,
0.0056431112,
-0.0543332286,
-0.0142465727,
-0.0040482357,
-0.03238599,
-0.0410852917,
0.0491025671,
0.0142212957,
0.0018101924,
-0.0522954464,
0.0441306829,
-0.017246224,
-0.003303777,
-0.0105656739,
0.0278806463,
-0.0356435589,
-0.0101760579,
-0.0207997654,
-0.0543633886,
0.0169957671,
0.0125174625,
-0.0063643712,
0.0083517442,
-0.0491281189,
0.0508406982,
0.0147328097,
-0.0425368994,
0.0312846974,
0.0178930666,
0.0667766854,
0.0775430873,
0.0080656009,
0.003012001,
0.0317217745,
-0.0440740697,
-0.0008634829,
0.004006153,
-0.0120981988,
0.0101510286,
0.0023018841,
-0.0069264751,
0.0414218567,
0.0087987231,
0.0145394728,
-0.0417938195,
0.0465549231,
-0.0117060766,
-0.0181445368,
0.0110715339,
0.0254995134,
-0.0916754678,
-0.0355158113,
-0.015083883,
0.0167681333,
-0.0139607796,
-0.0477747247,
0.0227719434,
-0.0115027782,
-0.0068484508,
0.0037155747,
0.0043974887,
-0.0677717924,
-0.0080243228,
0.0285001714,
-0.0321561769,
-0.0107777491,
-0.0064970818,
0.042808041,
-0.0479801372,
-0.0301423799,
-0.0049334504,
0.0178848375,
-0.0031292129,
0.0331529714,
0.0128228683,
0.0575584881,
-0.0924759284,
-0.0066636913,
-0.067601651,
0.0364097059,
-0.0065418105,
0.0115088131,
0.0285921413,
-0.0002478361,
0.0143730966,
0.0143170226,
0.0615134314,
-0.0183899067,
-0.0127386581,
0.0349025466,
-0.0055414499,
-0.0058057224,
-0.0201533157,
0.0094647901,
0.0024417448,
0.0090464521,
0.0113260122,
-0.0395697989,
-0.0201112926,
0.0182713289,
3.069e-7,
0.0413072705,
0.0150827663,
0.0345873162,
0.0322228409,
0.0200858936,
0.0485476293,
-0.050170105,
0.0212717708,
-0.0023068336,
-0.020738354,
-0.0084877349,
0.033669807,
0.0239653736,
0.0158310737,
-0.1230153218,
0.017675912,
0.0150916977,
-0.0191271752,
-0.0527417436,
0.0027121354,
0.0041708532,
0.074696295,
0.0435950793,
-0.012424754,
-0.05019366,
-0.0747413114,
0.0520344898,
-0.0068137245,
-0.0343564562,
0.0324786901,
0.0325006545,
0.0219019428,
-0.0469919816,
0.0224892125,
0.0005414035,
0.051269915,
-0.0104619339,
0.0440787636,
0.0140201319,
0.0022995342,
-0.0123985456,
-0.0455296561,
-0.0141550787,
-0.0556959882,
0.0603608526,
-0.0317168832,
-0.0421082489,
-0.0195417237,
-0.0420636609,
-0.0318085663,
-0.0343452767,
0.0219209045,
-0.0085923225,
0.0143107651,
0.0060229236,
-0.0050630732,
-0.0058120228,
-0.0618834049,
-0.0361121781,
0.0155295543,
-0.0362795219,
-0.0804157108,
-0.0077543762,
-0.0038117943,
0.0210961774,
-0.0836596414,
0.0052617909,
3.4351088e-34,
-0.0028517998,
0.0002735345,
0.0141890235,
0.0246469621,
0.0168372449,
-0.0233651996,
-0.0209355112,
0.0088529969,
0.0409867093,
-0.0565474816,
-0.0122782644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01149v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01149v2 | ChineseWebText: Large-scale High-quality Chinese Web Text Extracted with Effective Evaluation Model | 2023-11-02T11:13:51 | 2023-11-10T06:28:48 | Jianghao Chen, Pu Jian, Tengxiao Xi, Dongyi Yi, Qianlong Du, Chenglin Ding, Guibo Zhu, Chengqing Zong, Jinqiao Wang, Jiajun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | During the development of large language models (LLMs), the scale and quality
of the pre-training data play a crucial role in shaping LLMs' capabilities. To
accelerate the research of LLMs, several large-scale datasets, such as C4 [1],
Pile [2], RefinedWeb [3] and WanJuan [4], have been released to the public.
However, most of the released corpus focus mainly on English, and there is
still lack of complete tool-chain for extracting clean texts from web data.
Furthermore, fine-grained information of the corpus, e.g. the quality of each
text, is missing. To address these challenges, we propose in this paper a new
complete tool-chain EvalWeb to extract Chinese clean texts from noisy web data.
First, similar to previous work, manually crafted rules are employed to discard
explicit noisy texts from the raw crawled web contents. Second, a well-designed
evaluation model is leveraged to assess the remaining relatively clean data,
and each text is assigned a specific quality score. Finally, we can easily
utilize an appropriate threshold to select the high-quality pre-training data
for Chinese. Using our proposed approach, we release the largest and latest
large-scale high-quality Chinese web text ChineseWebText, which consists of
1.42 TB and each text is associated with a quality score, facilitating the LLM
researchers to choose the data according to the desired quality thresholds. We
also release a much cleaner subset of 600 GB Chinese data with the quality
exceeding 90%. | [
0.0521473326,
0.062957719,
0.0116468016,
0.0173383486,
-0.0210329629,
0.011011282,
0.0015347267,
0.0564677194,
0.0356795937,
-0.0400878936,
-0.0617615916,
-0.0658535883,
-0.0134295132,
0.0168442726,
-0.0107146604,
-0.0098317778,
0.0000304271,
0.0138985114,
0.0190933682,
0.001955641,
0.0292619858,
-0.0213225838,
0.0668580309,
0.0109139588,
0.0169280265,
-0.0300083701,
0.029749006,
0.0158466119,
0.002430165,
-0.0170415975,
0.0636933073,
0.0253110752,
-0.0309058465,
0.0168777071,
0.0000021778,
-0.0367410257,
-0.051213339,
-0.003203619,
0.0098360684,
0.0556635149,
0.0405487567,
0.0026725708,
-0.0584695376,
0.0630177036,
-0.0125616053,
-0.0269828755,
0.0303783696,
0.0516747721,
0.0791179165,
0.0779275447,
-0.0105889272,
0.0197939761,
0.0145409731,
-0.0009826869,
-0.0391309261,
-0.0233232826,
0.048655346,
0.0194534175,
-0.0227457341,
0.009917981,
-0.0053436034,
0.0091908416,
-0.0028803041,
-0.0419019833,
0.0025776166,
0.0085529825,
-0.0381407924,
-0.0171239953,
0.0238054544,
0.0632733256,
-0.0281319059,
-0.0301113334,
0.0359081179,
0.002161005,
-0.0204652157,
-0.0083614467,
-0.039627336,
0.0725551322,
0.0003341915,
0.0487809181,
-0.0236217398,
-0.0180540904,
0.0340043604,
0.0655012876,
-0.0320040137,
0.0045579211,
0.001006784,
-0.0546558648,
0.0099547459,
0.0075382092,
0.0017052469,
-0.0213935506,
0.0276818145,
-0.0124342237,
0.0011174456,
0.0065137106,
-0.0204633046,
-0.0164084136,
0.0108437119,
-0.0440216698,
0.0072850194,
-0.0135826245,
-0.0196474474,
0.0480437577,
-0.0148719177,
0.0015086245,
0.0199591257,
-0.0168188363,
-0.0327676535,
-0.0270180013,
-0.0071805106,
0.0117117241,
-0.0201609619,
0.0486719161,
-0.0091939429,
-0.0028046435,
-0.027952686,
-0.0032849722,
-0.0196714904,
-0.0133340247,
0.0364448316,
-0.0265412219,
-0.0112350425,
-0.0132815968,
-0.0075367629,
0.0007099719,
0.0137387244,
0.0148658399,
-0.0079652574,
-0.0319914632,
-0.0094197672,
0.0325601362,
0.0745087564,
-0.0244567916,
0.0238298476,
0.0423951969,
0.0110702263,
-0.0218668692,
-0.049574621,
0.0000106342,
-0.0292713959,
0.0027764805,
-0.019072894,
-0.0468541719,
-0.0273169521,
-0.0245825481,
0.0371165574,
-0.0133245615,
-0.0024671734,
0.0173502862,
-0.0261626486,
-0.0037598347,
-0.0535414778,
0.0064065657,
-0.0388503224,
-0.0245163292,
-0.0027599079,
0.0203589462,
0.0240946915,
0.0752527043,
0.0655766129,
-0.0043339203,
0.0048783221,
0.0630246252,
-0.0034562596,
0.012496111,
-0.0036328696,
-0.0241549611,
0.0221726596,
-0.0377876312,
0.0104238885,
0.0607993081,
-0.0256357715,
0.0304738693,
0.0840448663,
-0.0099048289,
0.0411094166,
0.0375416391,
-0.0233398341,
0.0451581627,
0.0153907742,
-0.0146085545,
-0.0472405814,
-0.0317201205,
-0.0458969884,
-0.0059290021,
0.0494321361,
0.042351298,
-0.0028354411,
-0.0555348769,
-0.0198245924,
-0.0275101382,
0.0333320498,
-0.0084444592,
0.0537354909,
-0.0077264551,
-0.0281602014,
-0.0062009539,
0.0502444804,
-0.0469426587,
0.039523676,
-0.0357356109,
0.0178570878,
0.0666156784,
0.0444925427,
-0.0092436597,
0.0198154785,
-0.0064620203,
0.0070705866,
0.0393380448,
0.0136471195,
-0.015912503,
-0.0219545644,
-0.064619571,
-0.0839742944,
0.0552318618,
-0.0076065371,
-0.0376903936,
0.0201109461,
0.0076349368,
0.0324661545,
-0.0550280176,
-0.0843105391,
0.0281904284,
0.0030569606,
0.0089748818,
0.0118830092,
-0.0016652133,
0.0405214652,
0.0044655409,
-0.073087424,
-0.0072542508,
0.0198712647,
-0.0074459258,
-0.053936474,
-0.0308295749,
-0.0076090349,
-0.0083814003,
0.0578283258,
-0.0502635203,
0.0400147736,
0.0670193359,
-0.0297725052,
-0.0331131108,
-0.0504670255,
-0.0205988232,
0.0195029639,
-0.0633828044,
0.0315873697,
-0.0199342873,
0.0139302267,
-0.0296375733,
0.0460319929,
0.0232215058,
0.0079504196,
-0.0072964607,
-0.0280375164,
0.0096310321,
0.0193522759,
-0.0504197665,
0.0197989289,
-0.0238218885,
0.0736301541,
0.0868935883,
0.0708952099,
-0.0558769815,
-0.0237312764,
-0.088672094,
0.0189521555,
-0.0189290643,
0.0252094194,
0.0255065579,
-0.0080580954,
0.0043715448,
0.0289566852,
-0.0494621992,
-0.0242097415,
-0.0201099366,
-0.0071546156,
0.0216677915,
-0.0459074453,
0.0205943789,
-0.00887914,
-0.0195754766,
0.0281815473,
0.0127094965,
0.0080366423,
-0.043566145,
-0.0114407735,
0.066030696,
0.0083843628,
-0.020794224,
0.0060940385,
-0.096142441,
-0.0577286892,
-0.0411060788,
-0.0265919343,
-0.0013238357,
0.0292186365,
-0.0259089954,
0.0260627344,
0.0002425786,
-0.056194175,
-0.0364358276,
0.0040874691,
0.0059807915,
-0.0161801483,
-0.0310250074,
0.0473856032,
0.0314940922,
0.0072590737,
-0.0062344437,
-0.0282596201,
-0.0161460768,
-0.0301862042,
0.0291736163,
-0.0085313078,
0.0340103321,
-0.0529726781,
0.0065859933,
-0.0347669311,
-0.0392127112,
0.029764235,
-0.0042759227,
0.0289180931,
-0.0579355098,
0.0056651845,
-0.0065353983,
0.0114886491,
-0.0122941937,
0.0382288247,
0.0245926622,
-0.0214267578,
-0.0273755565,
0.0483738147,
0.0336597301,
-0.0609813556,
0.0011641672,
-0.0086866366,
0.0371654592,
-0.0401459038,
-0.0194502175,
-0.0213668365,
-0.045721285,
0.0291485228,
0.0070180199,
0.0463528968,
-0.0106180878,
0.0072230971,
0.0428479724,
0.0115517722,
0.0338866599,
-0.0140910475,
0.0163289383,
0.0161500964,
0.0430082642,
0.0390057117,
0.0104105333,
0.0218653604,
-0.0008169623,
0.0442370437,
0.0942836553,
0.0418060049,
-0.0010960205,
0.0331720784,
-0.0132961301,
0.0535905696,
-0.0092822406,
-0.0239687394,
0.000344896,
0.0234894715,
-0.0492828228,
0.0143932551,
0.1094847098,
0.024919644,
-0.0288862567,
-0.0129306242,
0.0255391467,
-0.0037569641,
-0.0028299079,
-0.036963243,
-0.0877103359,
-0.0166936237,
0.0351410508,
0.0225094184,
0.0021044994,
-0.0264983252,
0.0375219472,
-0.1322629154,
0.0465524495,
0.031972304,
0.0086599067,
-0.0036573906,
-0.0425684303,
0.0140898218,
-0.0270038713,
0.0127577968,
0.0254406985,
-0.0112497788,
0.0016624259,
0.022086177,
-0.0141033493,
-0.0855282992,
0.022799518,
-0.0531596802,
0.0405687504,
0.0251779575,
0.0452829041,
-0.0288578365,
-0.0118344324,
0.059002243,
-0.0614801832,
-0.0587017089,
-0.0208592415,
0.0669825375,
0.0068319119,
-0.0239998996,
0.0013914494,
0.0189005174,
-0.0240090005,
0.0256712213,
0.0252198055,
0.0497678854,
0.0004234948,
-0.0157491509,
0.012622444,
-0.04149561,
-0.0495372377,
0.0889122114,
0.0090661356,
-0.0824358165,
-0.0221943483,
-0.0239943992,
-0.0226533636,
-0.0274195131,
-0.025381865,
0.0670279562,
-0.0895930529,
-0.0217352919,
-0.1214647889,
-0.0596627407,
0.0062801586,
0.0058830143,
0.0101046171,
-0.0112453206,
0.009921914,
0.0088592404,
-0.0384534039,
0.0129212113,
-0.0536814816,
0.0029702918,
-0.0774100423,
-0.003805428,
0.0543079115,
-0.0513185598,
-0.0065591335,
0.0130374338,
-0.020089712,
-0.0273900591,
0.0081906198,
-0.0118933339,
0.0057343505,
0.0169874281,
-0.028497193,
-0.0306372177,
0.0453946367,
0.001142442,
-0.0611366704,
-0.0354743302,
0.0505010001,
-0.0240663849,
-0.0143849021,
0.0157611743,
-0.0698676556,
0.0416397862,
0.0213862266,
0.0396181792,
-0.0010793566,
-0.0045884,
0.0542048402,
0.0835878924,
0.0193653312,
-0.0004524776,
-0.022051366,
-0.0561116003,
0.0190421343,
0.000653841,
-0.0481636897,
-0.0519060902,
0.0459890254,
0.0503725298,
0.0237869229,
-0.0348253809,
0.1013268083,
0.0169363134,
0.0011077177,
-0.0264239516,
-0.0103514614,
-0.0316657275,
0.0210865717,
0.0030726721,
-0.0118186083,
0.0020687848,
-0.0291572418,
0.0434393771,
-0.006234305,
-0.0251092017,
0.0033013171,
0.0382332951,
0.0053692842,
0.0146320127,
0.0628546029,
-0.0319571346,
-0.0044614188,
-0.0652664751,
-0.0187226031,
0.071429424,
-0.011151623,
0.0875771344,
-0.0222789366,
-0.0084179202,
-0.0481557883,
0.0072550131,
0.0473405644,
0.0050868681,
-0.0156639367,
0.0019045172,
-0.0667969063,
-0.0140634123,
0.0676632971,
-0.0069534956,
0.0161172934,
0.0063727917,
-0.0148671968,
-0.0398104489,
-0.0079269055,
0.0267496519,
-0.0020575952,
-0.0205069613,
-0.0427982435,
-0.0080613177,
-0.0541250519,
-0.0259549133,
0.0043709525,
0.0075447117,
-0.0208425224,
0.0135643659,
0.0653251261,
0.0071925507,
0.0432152934,
-0.0460058711,
-0.0476499014,
0.0404701047,
-0.0048868074,
0.0177375991,
-6.781997025e-33,
0.0403932296,
-0.0071112891,
-0.0299608707,
-0.0139613999,
-0.0192219466,
0.0080933217,
-0.0156720802,
-0.0512615554,
-0.0357937776,
-0.0052002189,
-0.0128194522,
-0.00168524,
0.0226115044,
0.0488565862,
-0.0045390963,
0.0316927172,
0.0638116747,
-0.0145764621,
-0.0245923605,
0.0225661471,
0.0282490384,
0.0377570838,
0.0459344424,
-0.020375764,
-0.0001232965,
0.0021527198,
-0.0491845421,
-0.0188574046,
0.0535508469,
0.0425054543,
-0.0134442747,
0.0450216606,
0.0449709296,
-0.0180357676,
-0.0129294954,
-0.0215427093,
-0.0925260335,
0.0122658294,
-0.0212073904,
0.0067591728,
0.0087505579,
-0.0160745364,
0.053018678,
-0.0272753425,
0.0085642925,
0.0123931598,
0.0522084758,
-0.0742275119,
-0.0256989989,
-0.0649357513,
-0.0010497777,
0.048301205,
-0.003203108,
-0.0048612691,
0.032063473,
0.0094886832,
-0.0176948309,
0.0707426742,
-0.0447192676,
0.0237811394,
0.0420921557,
0.0578697734,
0.0203081109,
0.0030218947,
0.0184063632,
0.0564858541,
-0.019054113,
-0.0021501011,
0.0468107648,
-0.0254182331,
0.049356956,
0.0157276224,
-0.0057139043,
0.0634151101,
0.0346807241,
-0.0408580936,
-0.0677597225,
0.0523916483,
0.0184005927,
0.0321772434,
-0.0111435587,
-0.0006741646,
-0.0193641502,
-0.016277587,
-0.0158259645,
-0.0003637603,
-0.0274782982,
-0.0111755738,
0.0272629131,
0.0197159294,
-0.0862874538,
-0.0411809944,
0.0135802301,
-0.0619378425,
-0.0301302113,
0.0495008267,
-0.0314206295,
0.0016839074,
-0.0117722098,
-0.0130044147,
-0.0504507795,
-0.045545917,
-0.012758296,
-0.0056008268,
-0.032041546,
-0.0057996591,
0.0196916144,
0.029094724,
-0.0691927671,
0.0297176279,
-0.0503548048,
-0.0014263652,
0.0246087797,
0.0313121788,
0.0063956534,
-0.0179797038,
0.0017956179,
0.0306891967,
0.0724378675,
0.0511833318,
-0.0339858606,
-0.0181233846,
0.0003450681,
-0.005046797,
0.0007295277,
0.0079319887,
-0.0115292408,
0.022160532,
0.0400711596,
-0.0486195162,
-0.0073445751,
-0.0167341586,
2.863e-7,
0.0102422051,
0.041464597,
0.0151724583,
0.0146686286,
-0.0115933046,
0.035376627,
-0.0323693603,
0.0202908833,
-0.0340241604,
0.036832381,
0.0184044894,
-0.0251922123,
0.0808605328,
0.0083541134,
-0.0691651553,
0.0316204876,
-0.0632982776,
-0.0619850941,
0.0025198036,
0.0021177481,
0.042627085,
0.1250429153,
-0.0076351175,
-0.0163632892,
-0.0048395619,
-0.0478782654,
0.0332406983,
-0.0354346447,
-0.0410343744,
0.0589246266,
0.0451371893,
-0.0044691539,
-0.0228923243,
-0.0419524089,
-0.0296739731,
0.0191924889,
0.0339076072,
0.0823298246,
0.0139527321,
0.0401117317,
0.0006215581,
-0.0449302271,
0.0243503563,
-0.0303977858,
0.0911832154,
0.0385070704,
-0.008551985,
0.0053864438,
-0.047171291,
-0.0603351183,
-0.0040837652,
-0.0605841279,
-0.0112988679,
0.0397998132,
-0.0078451,
0.0165064484,
-0.0178713631,
-0.0406140536,
-0.0356566571,
-0.0198256038,
-0.0200183466,
-0.0725042522,
0.0187838804,
-0.0208251458,
0.0058914381,
-0.0634689257,
0.0421574526,
2.614600886e-34,
0.0466525629,
-0.0648597851,
-0.0061157211,
0.0177402142,
0.015144974,
0.005713929,
-0.0001863066,
-0.0095834229,
-0.0495517924,
-0.0609116592,
-0.0034183296
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.