id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20589v1 | Increasing The Performance of Cognitively Inspired Data-Efficient Language Models via Implicit Structure Building | 2023-10-31T16:26:36 | 2023-10-31T16:26:36 | Omar Momen, David Arps, Laura Kallmeyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we describe our submission to the BabyLM Challenge 2023 shared
task on data-efficient language model (LM) pretraining (Warstadt et al., 2023).
We train transformer-based masked language models that incorporate unsupervised
predictions about hierarchical sentence structure into the model architecture.
Concretely, we use the Structformer architecture (Shen et al., 2021) and
variants thereof. StructFormer models have been shown to perform well on
unsupervised syntactic induction based on limited pretraining data, and to
yield performance improvements over a vanilla transformer architecture (Shen et
al., 2021). Evaluation of our models on 39 tasks provided by the BabyLM
challenge shows promising improvements of models that integrate a hierarchical
bias into the architecture at some particular tasks, even though they fail to
consistently outperform the RoBERTa baseline model provided by the shared task
organizers on all tasks. | [
0.0076916479,
0.0842045993,
-0.0274719521,
0.0452128649,
-0.0363424979,
0.0137117598,
0.008585263,
-0.0351077542,
0.0120413592,
-0.066159457,
-0.0350300558,
-0.0558573045,
0.0066799573,
0.0229930039,
0.0455817804,
-0.0701512024,
0.0386242121,
-0.060499128,
0.006027061,
0.005658092,
-0.0283948109,
-0.0152986618,
0.0005440366,
0.0184196327,
-0.0068859425,
-0.0369723849,
-0.0207982231,
-0.0003050089,
-0.0324964821,
-0.0618329532,
0.0316822566,
0.0590155162,
0.010062078,
0.0534708165,
0.0000022077,
-0.0289116967,
0.0039212801,
-0.0026718732,
-0.0241102334,
-0.0125954151,
0.0446390249,
-0.0455722772,
-0.0117608998,
0.0244994294,
-0.0482590795,
-0.0465766862,
0.0127766952,
0.0616082139,
0.0276366584,
0.0748926327,
-0.0275349133,
-0.0374541767,
0.0524129905,
-0.0294308122,
-0.0193582959,
0.0282517169,
0.0275538974,
-0.0113116018,
-0.0613987036,
0.0212056655,
-0.0152671309,
0.0330871269,
0.0129284104,
-0.0027450693,
0.0193455555,
0.0306819379,
-0.0291645788,
-0.033414714,
-0.0306297876,
0.038417194,
-0.0280658584,
-0.0278591421,
0.0099401735,
-0.0145333838,
-0.003231239,
0.0057498715,
-0.0416015312,
0.0469528027,
0.0323716253,
0.0111539746,
0.047073368,
0.0084397281,
0.0317827165,
-0.0162872542,
-0.0019458723,
0.0818799883,
0.0155653451,
-0.0579995736,
0.0007106463,
0.0146584604,
-0.0161410831,
-0.0651400462,
-0.0248698387,
-0.0034539867,
0.0020327407,
0.0163645837,
-0.0661434308,
-0.0988693163,
-0.0207586568,
-0.0376842842,
0.0734333396,
0.0219140295,
0.0035381033,
0.026154967,
-0.0699078292,
0.0579863414,
-0.0217870399,
0.0122934263,
-0.0243019927,
0.0054297308,
-0.0038029235,
-0.013709289,
-0.065175578,
0.0450581051,
-0.0566144995,
-0.0455213115,
-0.0151038347,
0.0275639445,
-0.0071524461,
-0.0131129585,
0.006927378,
-0.0159428362,
-0.0378002115,
0.0016572368,
-0.0113933077,
-0.0353687257,
0.0168047342,
0.0186351929,
0.0159417056,
-0.0441975258,
-0.0188397765,
0.0545871779,
0.0130554968,
-0.0321367159,
-0.0055121379,
0.0502435304,
-0.0413557775,
-0.0283426829,
-0.0303488132,
-0.0188196767,
-0.0061820326,
-0.0315009132,
0.0525730215,
-0.0693006292,
0.0151130566,
-0.0168854073,
0.0161371585,
-0.0225852039,
0.0260510333,
0.030712422,
-0.033162605,
0.0534704328,
-0.015133976,
-0.0045421338,
-0.0163753517,
-0.0099985758,
-0.0098916627,
0.0437602326,
0.0483340062,
0.0152810263,
0.0173866041,
0.0011663991,
0.0058948207,
0.0457318872,
0.0186384209,
0.0056617125,
-0.0062717022,
0.0033712015,
-0.0176293962,
0.0059087989,
0.0319664925,
0.0598673187,
-0.0109510124,
0.0406164154,
0.0651484504,
0.0155361062,
0.0185270086,
0.0231028665,
0.0423353054,
0.0083244704,
0.0033609567,
-0.0027101415,
-0.0332384706,
0.0018120707,
-0.039301794,
0.0242830627,
-0.0372211635,
0.0237789378,
-0.023256585,
-0.0410881341,
-0.0148143051,
-0.0130716758,
0.0439817607,
-0.0020324436,
0.0257167779,
0.0766800269,
-0.0684139356,
0.0453347042,
-0.0065745148,
-0.0520770065,
-0.0411783867,
-0.0287119094,
-0.0074958554,
-0.0058633815,
0.0355883315,
-0.003837625,
-0.0147200422,
-0.0143635329,
0.0379618369,
0.0760252625,
0.0046041175,
0.0004362909,
0.015953334,
-0.0503032729,
-0.0154666118,
0.0030428334,
0.0166565217,
-0.0174184479,
0.0234221295,
-0.0350203253,
0.0123633919,
-0.0048628463,
-0.0244740918,
0.0683549792,
-0.0223633032,
-0.0238770936,
0.0045574009,
0.0105472915,
0.0331891924,
-0.0173689295,
-0.0015203151,
0.0264086612,
0.0334492289,
-0.0710731,
-0.0350565463,
0.0071925344,
-0.0971293077,
-0.061598286,
0.0139680989,
-0.0193728097,
-0.0040966435,
0.0717360005,
-0.0073450897,
-0.0405201539,
-0.0013861855,
-0.0393802151,
0.0517139807,
-0.0321739092,
0.0525955595,
0.0122585585,
0.0201983247,
-0.0159960557,
0.0686488524,
-0.0268620513,
-0.0004994668,
0.03313981,
-0.0128358509,
0.0122727007,
-0.0163013842,
-0.0232125316,
-0.0192777291,
-0.0159361307,
-0.0089542074,
0.0216655601,
0.0028303338,
-0.0211038105,
-0.0317779109,
-0.0598606803,
-0.0161687732,
-0.0280315597,
0.0002874968,
0.0173023157,
0.0165109485,
-0.0085855098,
-0.0135361319,
-0.0285563841,
-0.0075462069,
-0.0113838119,
-0.00447171,
0.0502610579,
-0.0291553531,
-0.0412199944,
-0.0358290598,
-0.02976734,
-0.0402428955,
0.0595255755,
-0.0202244967,
-0.0359756015,
-0.0307210758,
0.0275447927,
0.0195076242,
0.0335927419,
-0.023575481,
-0.04786212,
0.0072415681,
-0.0086442512,
0.0997516066,
0.0749154687,
0.015055581,
-0.0182192884,
0.0451473221,
0.0088855876,
-0.0142621603,
0.0261769686,
-0.0148664797,
0.0329477116,
-0.0298227873,
-0.0180822928,
0.0341034196,
0.1223655343,
0.0117602106,
-0.0082888892,
-0.046932254,
0.0036935857,
-0.0207099766,
-0.0338066369,
-0.0200347453,
-0.0323346518,
-0.02913009,
0.0119147059,
-0.0426958762,
-0.0564638935,
0.0389378481,
-0.0610726848,
-0.0378824249,
-0.0313537307,
-0.004560479,
-0.0279393233,
0.0593796857,
0.0707782879,
0.0119795017,
0.0399403945,
-0.0113803279,
-0.0753254518,
0.0391787477,
0.032435786,
-0.0009723125,
0.0295247529,
-0.0365337171,
-0.0094289668,
0.0027590087,
-0.0621023439,
-0.0546996556,
-0.0461602956,
-0.0122362673,
0.0237620585,
0.0511875115,
-0.0111974347,
-0.0346117467,
-0.0089324368,
0.0291209482,
0.0590995289,
0.0175974108,
-0.0270165931,
-0.0235350579,
0.031728413,
0.0608500056,
0.0227010101,
0.0195884332,
-0.0399722978,
0.0310988631,
0.0381730199,
0.0494723879,
0.0252692644,
-0.023792183,
0.0152062122,
0.0359921046,
-0.0173443537,
-0.0363850035,
0.0193542056,
0.0546772219,
-0.0440078527,
0.0007968583,
0.13839899,
0.0161328521,
-0.0052348431,
0.0208666064,
-0.0078141503,
0.0723093748,
0.0309809763,
0.0161122791,
-0.0961678624,
-0.0172945317,
0.0132179949,
-0.0069192434,
-0.0257658549,
-0.030131191,
0.0132129062,
-0.1011294052,
0.0278298501,
0.0051048873,
0.0011357891,
0.0133010354,
-0.0114243617,
-0.0384156592,
0.0055753971,
-0.0218403209,
-0.0035744351,
-0.0252516642,
-0.02346416,
0.0086669978,
-0.0915914401,
-0.0179242902,
0.0134085473,
-0.0312756822,
0.0196125228,
0.0456635952,
-0.0023905393,
-0.0191212054,
-0.0362699367,
0.0605166852,
-0.0087694433,
0.0024161006,
0.0084107639,
0.0244229063,
-0.0225664862,
-0.0043056007,
-0.031062426,
0.0544756651,
-0.04225244,
-0.0306680817,
-0.0156726763,
0.0758033991,
0.0109900404,
-0.0484823473,
-0.0020678684,
-0.0078207562,
-0.0015005944,
0.0886796787,
0.0282545146,
-0.0404628962,
-0.0217736773,
-0.0246519949,
0.0275012609,
-0.0078913774,
-0.0249390695,
0.053779494,
0.0158469565,
0.0012407149,
-0.0733960494,
-0.0358757116,
0.0273121763,
0.015919283,
-0.0016916152,
0.0013766836,
0.0116003538,
-0.0464061983,
-0.0532114655,
0.0190384332,
-0.0200219434,
0.0238622427,
-0.0780317709,
-0.0385959595,
-0.0006419721,
0.011449419,
-0.0258537643,
0.0230148062,
-0.0749670342,
-0.048437506,
0.0279132891,
0.0765519589,
0.008887792,
0.0475458317,
0.0018650697,
-0.0139422286,
0.0514175072,
0.0032563745,
-0.0491607338,
0.0370098762,
0.0580745786,
-0.0460699871,
0.0169818532,
0.0394196697,
-0.0276539661,
0.0323048159,
0.0235988181,
0.0621866584,
-0.00103146,
0.0410506763,
0.0406302884,
0.0198833365,
0.0733614713,
-0.0271382406,
0.0089819552,
-0.0326782912,
0.0294560324,
-0.0461091399,
-0.0385753326,
-0.0602184311,
-0.0007026428,
0.0034454034,
0.0480269305,
-0.0169545244,
0.0550242215,
-0.0197337307,
0.0283128582,
-0.0257453285,
0.0322942212,
0.0193763133,
0.0371636078,
0.0140973469,
0.0113151642,
-0.0104658585,
-0.0022531576,
-0.0095458953,
0.0206561666,
-0.0011908484,
0.0313276649,
0.0193538368,
-0.0023439573,
-0.0647105798,
0.0317816995,
-0.0532999747,
0.0190230887,
-0.0340828896,
-0.0398020558,
0.0483965538,
-0.0255184639,
0.0622893646,
-0.0546942726,
-0.0022438914,
0.0051729837,
0.0507564694,
0.0047421614,
-0.0498642586,
0.0436738953,
0.0161219593,
-0.0415751748,
-0.014246651,
0.0900792032,
0.0526045747,
0.020524228,
0.0316407643,
0.0159554332,
-0.052203577,
-0.0011350265,
0.0470463373,
0.0694268197,
-0.0156989805,
-0.0010776462,
-0.0357514285,
-0.0394148789,
0.0256296117,
0.0067302748,
0.0294307955,
-0.024918383,
0.0452998914,
0.0420210436,
-0.009826933,
-0.0788513869,
-0.0361261293,
-0.0231488533,
0.0390612334,
-0.0233073272,
-0.0293493364,
-6.637672767e-33,
-0.0203133635,
-0.0230820403,
0.0066336999,
0.0234652329,
-0.0102569098,
0.0305643994,
-0.0495036691,
0.0286389589,
-0.0099565564,
0.0324539058,
-0.0117825298,
0.0112175699,
0.0077909422,
0.0621483847,
0.0005889388,
0.0314717777,
0.059606608,
-0.027883539,
-0.0235719047,
-0.0238201804,
-0.03792613,
0.0257624499,
0.0365026817,
-0.0424034894,
-0.0107262945,
-0.0175716728,
-0.0043782103,
0.0002706696,
0.0276290793,
0.0618470833,
-0.0368783213,
0.0059547788,
0.0294967387,
-0.0134472093,
-0.0293499809,
0.0418356396,
-0.1050323099,
-0.0146963783,
0.0085139358,
0.0143630579,
-0.0673391074,
-0.0180785917,
0.0293243472,
-0.0085496763,
-0.0067315632,
-0.0209664721,
0.0267117172,
-0.0123835858,
-0.0230338778,
-0.0249009784,
-0.0849587619,
0.0207350291,
0.0185551848,
0.0049276436,
0.0220300499,
0.0313171297,
-0.0107888337,
0.0167760793,
-0.0779821277,
0.0122486716,
0.00297475,
0.0472913235,
0.0344884172,
0.038621556,
0.0242564585,
0.0649122968,
0.0421996787,
0.0216835588,
-0.0454366095,
0.0369870588,
0.053070195,
0.0431773402,
0.0380504578,
0.0058076908,
0.0366157778,
0.0233513433,
-0.0620390885,
0.0009172029,
0.0144777587,
0.0138739422,
0.0158148091,
0.0293311756,
-0.0358850509,
-0.0352845974,
-0.0484727807,
-0.0089063924,
-0.0177725554,
-0.0152143445,
0.0257303491,
0.0256930944,
-0.0004686958,
-0.0130943786,
0.0131511595,
-0.0311864074,
-0.0116133736,
-0.0332075842,
0.0057551847,
0.0428092778,
-0.0023695303,
0.0274013095,
-0.0669641495,
-0.0329778753,
0.0178082082,
0.0406737961,
0.034108784,
0.0361707024,
0.0514242463,
0.0535964072,
-0.0955639705,
-0.0173837002,
-0.0134562356,
-0.0059442581,
0.0008661693,
0.0050701234,
0.0265814438,
0.038504649,
-0.014794318,
0.0402522385,
-0.003201795,
-0.0259519182,
-0.0285085738,
0.0381968319,
0.0097519159,
0.0371125042,
0.0109392861,
-0.0244288519,
-0.0614904575,
-0.0220729448,
0.0712859109,
-0.070729427,
-0.018854985,
0.0087452186,
2.783e-7,
0.0311832167,
0.0517679527,
0.0218885876,
0.0365686044,
0.0208117533,
0.0159719046,
0.0091947624,
0.0136817619,
-0.0251055751,
0.0159256123,
-0.0103980256,
-0.0020727576,
0.0552128479,
-0.0025611413,
-0.1158922985,
-0.0287289917,
-0.0602228642,
-0.0141308252,
-0.045361802,
0.0020083913,
0.0209593438,
0.0968946218,
-0.0111154448,
0.0169913527,
-0.0201571304,
-0.023002997,
0.0643812045,
-0.0192253403,
-0.0006184233,
0.0173412059,
-0.0151103335,
0.036783807,
-0.0125833033,
0.0271781199,
-0.0352960564,
0.0259144157,
0.0171609335,
0.0533957742,
-0.0076263631,
0.0065042181,
0.0324832536,
0.0166099891,
-0.0401326902,
-0.0303791594,
0.0460604317,
-0.0758008957,
-0.0292776544,
0.0262309238,
-0.0453364588,
0.0317707509,
-0.0219784752,
-0.0055167298,
-0.0376520269,
0.0239622127,
0.0626325086,
-0.0134889372,
-0.0109314648,
-0.0497189686,
-0.0282895658,
-0.0008425767,
-0.0141527606,
-0.0416565165,
-0.0419477113,
-0.0228328854,
0.0147400796,
-0.0353322662,
-0.018488301,
3.19025172e-34,
0.0366904102,
-0.0066617071,
0.0072227363,
0.0285803657,
0.0434772894,
-0.048893299,
0.0350389555,
0.0172736533,
0.0162520185,
-0.1300184578,
-0.0101530254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20588v1 | Zero-Shot Medical Information Retrieval via Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-10-31T16:26:33 | 2023-10-31T16:26:33 | Yuqi Wang, Zeqiang Wang, Wei Wang, Qi Chen, Kaizhu Huang, Anh Nguyen, Suparna De | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | In the era of the Internet of Things (IoT), the retrieval of relevant medical
information has become essential for efficient clinical decision-making. This
paper introduces MedFusionRank, a novel approach to zero-shot medical
information retrieval (MIR) that combines the strengths of pre-trained language
models and statistical methods while addressing their limitations. The proposed
approach leverages a pre-trained BERT-style model to extract compact yet
informative keywords. These keywords are then enriched with domain knowledge by
linking them to conceptual entities within a medical knowledge graph.
Experimental evaluations on medical datasets demonstrate MedFusion Rank's
superior performance over existing methods, with promising results with a
variety of evaluation metrics. MedFusionRank demonstrates efficacy in
retrieving relevant information, even from short or single-term queries. | [
0.0159538984,
-0.0109252287,
0.0066318135,
-0.0347300693,
-0.0009601047,
0.0003702774,
-0.0366681814,
0.0618840717,
0.0451097153,
-0.0497179925,
-0.0078243958,
-0.0106573151,
-0.041328311,
0.0229495373,
0.0094644716,
0.0023738786,
0.0442173779,
0.0858280584,
0.0234910343,
0.0155632719,
-0.0123613579,
-0.0072579342,
-0.0032391057,
0.0357437283,
0.0305802487,
0.0383012816,
0.0081362966,
0.0085821655,
0.0265696701,
-0.0859944522,
-0.0090538254,
0.0145765617,
0.0125765763,
-0.004883558,
0.0000017011,
-0.055176273,
-0.0457056388,
0.0410739705,
-0.0465829633,
-0.0719341114,
-0.0142404987,
-0.035228122,
0.0533865802,
0.0172834601,
-0.0336757228,
-0.0372342095,
0.0268558692,
0.0465419404,
0.0085524293,
0.0673961863,
-0.0168960001,
0.0095318295,
0.0156518761,
-0.0243033301,
0.0223986395,
-0.0400510877,
0.0600640848,
-0.0342717171,
0.0538253374,
-0.0109400386,
-0.0095332712,
0.0163122285,
-0.0339366943,
0.0510089435,
0.0837597251,
0.0507359728,
-0.0772094801,
0.0147739518,
-0.0043282602,
0.0997702703,
-0.0593943521,
-0.0197343864,
0.0303082131,
0.0058790362,
-0.0372898988,
0.0157973077,
-0.0442744195,
-0.0523461141,
-0.0052855718,
0.0068454547,
-0.0337750614,
-0.0003708169,
0.0660823435,
-0.0024844981,
-0.0515224338,
0.0646488741,
0.0067753084,
-0.0453381613,
0.0225740559,
-0.0491703153,
-0.0238158219,
-0.016095696,
-0.0051094419,
0.0465601832,
0.0082654646,
0.0176380016,
-0.0008931816,
-0.0201815404,
0.0682654902,
-0.0574938208,
-0.0091224527,
-0.0129368119,
0.032114502,
0.0711224154,
-0.0219302904,
-0.0341954231,
0.0080017652,
0.0446132682,
-0.0316100083,
0.0003984924,
-0.0550224483,
-0.0133762648,
-0.0180737395,
0.0748876631,
0.0213498697,
-0.04294708,
-0.0503084436,
-0.0159746017,
-0.0024371615,
0.0159658939,
0.0020516443,
0.0502214506,
-0.000543942,
-0.0073874416,
0.0126186656,
0.0416030027,
-0.0002532977,
0.0128278639,
-0.0581205636,
-0.0088113714,
0.0128830448,
-0.009062618,
0.0425728261,
-0.0160715934,
0.0256708097,
0.0521328039,
0.0366615281,
-0.072595641,
0.0269721374,
-0.0495479107,
0.0020144768,
0.0162642375,
0.0272005219,
-0.0271057673,
0.0076490534,
0.013469019,
0.0009518446,
-0.0116961403,
0.0486707017,
0.0125760036,
-0.0806896091,
0.0652192682,
-0.0775040686,
-0.0081070103,
-0.0254682619,
0.0339754261,
0.0223733708,
0.0109189888,
0.0029922607,
-0.0081776306,
0.0275861565,
-0.017682964,
-0.007457633,
-0.0094694328,
0.0666013286,
-0.0388593599,
0.0063373665,
0.0266935453,
-0.0468975753,
0.0529161654,
-0.070624955,
0.0084568709,
0.0005425618,
0.0113531081,
0.0004991195,
0.0937291756,
0.0687728524,
-0.0143328197,
-0.0283142328,
0.0002624964,
-0.0251473207,
-0.0575003922,
-0.003045636,
-0.0222042315,
-0.0032781826,
0.0005715372,
0.0293041989,
-0.0247420277,
-0.0234232694,
0.007233541,
-0.0291079227,
-0.0115086604,
-0.0147935748,
-0.0137088066,
0.0641747937,
-0.0193546619,
-0.0280198585,
0.0572551601,
0.0389459245,
-0.0063855308,
-0.0205136463,
-0.0360235423,
-0.0463643074,
0.0789154693,
0.063411504,
-0.0842984393,
-0.0517689213,
-0.0042192484,
-0.0092914589,
-0.0268938411,
-0.0080996118,
-0.0018273636,
0.0180018563,
-0.0300639682,
-0.0228212904,
0.0419576466,
0.0390200131,
-0.0310108196,
-0.0082723377,
0.0433708876,
0.0060722008,
-0.0759759992,
0.0241469163,
0.0025560665,
-0.0010741133,
-0.0253832825,
0.0146410158,
-0.010956984,
0.0123137906,
0.0428842977,
-0.0304707401,
0.0483464673,
0.062750712,
-0.0297083147,
-0.061621353,
-0.0200455543,
0.003260693,
0.0054973993,
0.0184435211,
-0.0263306722,
0.0515384674,
-0.0332563147,
-0.0242234599,
-0.0344517231,
-0.0214597564,
-0.0050280271,
0.0986620337,
0.0170865655,
0.0010824396,
0.0172271747,
-0.0330587849,
-0.0440804176,
0.0196412299,
-0.0045961649,
0.0373761132,
-0.0120126745,
-0.0554929115,
0.0203780886,
-0.0046423133,
-0.0276438091,
0.0241919085,
0.0049215076,
0.0357670821,
0.016067937,
-0.0070513133,
-0.0313337781,
0.0250142347,
-0.1212811247,
0.0259949751,
0.0274170004,
0.0113245081,
-0.0045628836,
0.0476607606,
-0.0008374713,
-0.0263210982,
-0.0445747226,
-0.0236233398,
-0.0088121165,
-0.0140190404,
0.0407254733,
0.0555913709,
0.0280369651,
-0.0180141311,
-0.0335333869,
-0.0275982991,
0.0401862785,
-0.0054807439,
0.0041824202,
0.0816079825,
0.0143821938,
-0.0552935675,
0.0095978221,
-0.0197218992,
0.0002986873,
-0.0018284096,
-0.0315182023,
-0.0262863562,
0.0203942414,
-0.0075743585,
0.0153870806,
0.0074928831,
-0.0168460142,
-0.0340907685,
-0.0040163328,
-0.0596770719,
0.0203384701,
0.0290924832,
0.0065941629,
0.0074584549,
0.0008202516,
0.0209771898,
-0.0193686951,
-0.0472473018,
-0.0169486981,
0.0005521188,
0.0191903058,
-0.084566839,
0.0591641963,
-0.0069095492,
0.0264221802,
-0.0094225556,
-0.0434055254,
0.0627684817,
0.0112437494,
0.064237006,
-0.0265630856,
-0.0165446922,
-0.0260815378,
0.0076361084,
-0.0169399865,
0.0169680249,
-0.0185385458,
0.0061323582,
0.0222729389,
0.0002073245,
-0.012686518,
-0.0886506215,
0.0104431277,
0.035994146,
0.0294354279,
0.0208749995,
-0.0352404565,
-0.0122962585,
-0.0195650794,
-0.0057932334,
0.024678329,
0.0018462857,
0.0033306573,
-0.0427312627,
0.0382288247,
-0.0031841951,
0.0326626301,
0.0167347547,
-0.0072087473,
0.0162094068,
0.0342133008,
0.0339646302,
-0.0509329736,
-0.0095613943,
0.0500706844,
0.0156157771,
0.0455261357,
0.044985462,
-0.0086307516,
-0.0220614616,
-0.0120928278,
0.0010359929,
-0.0585361682,
-0.0163872801,
0.0025361814,
-0.0075680544,
0.0010298935,
0.0328640901,
0.0954339877,
0.0416014232,
-0.0331151038,
0.0173888933,
-0.0009396551,
-0.0330674388,
-0.0046840343,
0.0109646525,
-0.0825253949,
-0.0235616434,
-0.0063799052,
0.0277425647,
0.0030126348,
-0.0507680029,
0.0227032434,
-0.0529414676,
-0.0026884144,
-0.0054273079,
0.0294418614,
-0.0538110249,
-0.0863054618,
0.0170447342,
0.0103292102,
-0.065657042,
-0.0274063386,
-0.0402667522,
0.0023879413,
-0.0061159246,
-0.0356295332,
-0.0863784477,
0.0449755527,
-0.0289046727,
0.0273969844,
0.039898131,
0.0353885889,
-0.0300931614,
0.0026919995,
-0.0395251513,
0.0046182983,
-0.0346818231,
-0.0327281617,
0.0415321998,
-0.0467564426,
-0.0021535323,
-0.0327217579,
-0.0123082278,
-0.0180647131,
-0.0070745726,
-0.0262633562,
0.0538210273,
-0.0361592174,
-0.00124986,
-0.0607541166,
-0.0362567753,
-0.0114591969,
0.0321941786,
-0.0129447281,
0.0446466282,
-0.0037294843,
0.0231464319,
0.0652111396,
0.0227445345,
-0.0220066588,
0.0082094725,
-0.0596790649,
-0.0107199419,
-0.0357655138,
-0.0111392345,
0.0411745198,
0.0138504738,
0.0193798728,
0.0215828549,
0.0157945305,
-0.0094717024,
-0.0921521112,
0.0456076488,
0.0344481356,
0.0122882575,
-0.0245336909,
-0.0138793718,
0.0518722832,
-0.002279538,
-0.0364661142,
-0.021077022,
0.0277897343,
-0.0176422466,
-0.050288666,
0.0326103456,
0.0128479702,
-0.0079153385,
-0.0194700081,
-0.0087767057,
0.0737129748,
0.0768158063,
-0.0465753898,
-0.0505479053,
0.021335315,
-0.0425117128,
0.0017581027,
0.0288101137,
-0.0438253134,
0.040728271,
-0.0114495633,
0.0451260544,
-0.034350995,
-0.0301666316,
0.0169095509,
0.0429918244,
0.0845033675,
-0.023218425,
-0.0066153337,
-0.0334080644,
0.0259047709,
-0.0302239005,
0.0147543652,
-0.0358892195,
-0.0030967167,
0.0042502247,
-0.0154336309,
-0.0053037321,
0.0229040366,
-0.0344748013,
-0.0340685509,
-0.0434365682,
0.0214117486,
-0.0002804529,
-0.0260460414,
0.054268904,
-0.0218106341,
0.0037865755,
0.0204616636,
0.0099003343,
-0.005971876,
-0.0451799296,
-0.0010139215,
0.0046253419,
0.0184719358,
-0.0384173132,
0.0678541511,
-0.0381241143,
-0.0211264659,
-0.0034282212,
0.0166893341,
0.0785217211,
-0.007302281,
0.0104007972,
-0.0111199711,
-0.0127856452,
-0.0152977509,
0.0131385019,
-0.0354671068,
0.0262073707,
0.0257041343,
0.0516487323,
-0.0075916196,
0.0277711302,
0.0952471942,
0.0277500264,
0.0488967225,
-0.0025991879,
-0.0778746456,
-0.0283875186,
0.0235945601,
0.0917557478,
0.0942135677,
-0.0348820314,
0.0197878201,
-0.0650561228,
-0.0418578088,
0.0433815382,
-0.0289593413,
-0.0489462987,
-0.0049701664,
0.078707248,
0.0459729582,
0.0111347307,
-0.017785402,
-0.0231999997,
0.0270221066,
-0.0413033254,
-0.0158917904,
0.0428413153,
-6.0639463e-33,
0.0264757369,
-0.0362521298,
0.0095182722,
-0.016787203,
-0.0033492444,
0.0535461158,
-0.002295166,
-0.023619445,
-0.0226654615,
0.0279043447,
-0.0298481453,
-0.0103883697,
-0.0033703097,
0.012906896,
-0.0141304377,
-0.0379381292,
-0.0097887665,
0.0297591463,
-0.0044164658,
0.0045186905,
-0.0034245546,
0.0830763578,
0.0293195825,
-0.0265948642,
-0.0034044865,
-0.0042855171,
0.0474533364,
0.0149006387,
0.0271277279,
0.0411308259,
-0.0265136231,
0.0666920468,
0.0349695347,
-0.011813513,
0.0301878303,
-0.0096566658,
-0.0762410313,
-0.0377871878,
-0.004422666,
-0.0568512641,
-0.0272223782,
0.0032636905,
0.0509415418,
-0.0132181412,
-0.0029155307,
0.002813776,
0.0416658334,
0.0033885767,
-0.0724504963,
-0.0713042468,
-0.0039629177,
0.0634653941,
-0.0045835683,
-0.0216447674,
-0.006168691,
-0.0332520492,
-0.021266222,
0.0468142368,
-0.038843248,
0.0113968756,
0.0132764755,
0.0283860303,
-0.0197537374,
-0.0279029924,
-0.0036056924,
0.0596152432,
-0.0086448761,
-0.046180781,
-0.0269546788,
0.0214110613,
-0.0181132965,
0.0325504839,
0.0163882021,
-0.0048730234,
0.0373802073,
-0.0245211888,
-0.0959368944,
0.0192127097,
-0.0581777021,
0.0468515977,
-0.0143971117,
0.0002295843,
-0.0477802679,
0.0071611968,
0.0029271636,
-0.0194511693,
-0.0239434354,
-0.0343137756,
0.0127198584,
0.0167395398,
0.0170573648,
0.0542621724,
-0.006038357,
-0.0163004957,
0.0021989075,
0.0183031894,
0.0571098551,
-0.0122960201,
-0.0370338894,
0.0135204187,
-0.0474220514,
-0.0010549444,
0.032596074,
-0.0130698038,
0.0015861904,
0.0132102137,
0.0033714389,
-0.0206744839,
-0.0232604276,
-0.0332705304,
0.0290636532,
-0.0631624386,
-0.0346250348,
0.0151443221,
0.0252173096,
0.0673307031,
0.03503659,
0.0565126985,
0.0391421467,
0.0314041637,
-0.0125470432,
-0.0281172339,
0.0262390263,
-0.0243223216,
-0.0064777364,
0.0048836004,
-0.0539116226,
0.0796770528,
0.0134180048,
-0.0536050424,
-0.0179888327,
0.0032616432,
2.757e-7,
0.1098730266,
0.0549398474,
-0.026301764,
-0.0302854143,
0.0191404596,
-0.0042755855,
0.0066051679,
0.0296397209,
-0.0286167283,
0.0171373934,
0.0550065599,
-0.0007337009,
-0.0304559171,
0.0202568695,
-0.0734790117,
-0.0441958904,
-0.0794594362,
-0.0439869426,
-0.0186345056,
-0.0457308516,
0.0766023844,
0.065101102,
-0.0011919973,
0.0023263823,
0.0116968397,
-0.0354948901,
0.0253619123,
-0.0078853946,
0.0151008852,
-0.0081648491,
0.0363213494,
0.0506067015,
-0.0032698386,
0.0392255709,
-0.0191808064,
0.0071814032,
0.015265232,
0.0513729155,
-0.0790306479,
0.0066943155,
0.0069036242,
-0.0265050344,
0.0230765734,
-0.0313280001,
0.0959358662,
-0.0671853647,
-0.0481146686,
0.0276387315,
-0.0302974656,
-0.0013738862,
0.0531355888,
-0.0189008582,
-0.0527287722,
0.0084033012,
0.0247610733,
0.0280780233,
-0.0222046636,
-0.0801647082,
0.028127389,
0.0234607868,
-0.0130041009,
-0.0246052202,
0.0334457755,
-0.0544739887,
0.0015744964,
-0.0497177988,
0.0228989925,
2.434618007e-34,
0.0231012534,
0.0041437824,
0.0049457271,
0.0011492692,
0.0107788285,
-0.0318080001,
-0.0014035513,
-0.015438579,
0.0171103366,
-0.0802881718,
-0.0075317821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20558v1 | Breaking the Token Barrier: Chunking and Convolution for Efficient Long Text Classification with BERT | 2023-10-31T15:41:08 | 2023-10-31T15:41:08 | Aman Jaiswal, Evangelos Milios | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Transformer-based models, specifically BERT, have propelled research in
various NLP tasks. However, these models are limited to a maximum token limit
of 512 tokens. Consequently, this makes it non-trivial to apply it in a
practical setting with long input. Various complex methods have claimed to
overcome this limit, but recent research questions the efficacy of these models
across different classification tasks. These complex architectures evaluated on
carefully curated long datasets perform at par or worse than simple baselines.
In this work, we propose a relatively simple extension to vanilla BERT
architecture called ChunkBERT that allows finetuning of any pretrained models
to perform inference on arbitrarily long text. The proposed method is based on
chunking token representations and CNN layers, making it compatible with any
pre-trained BERT. We evaluate chunkBERT exclusively on a benchmark for
comparing long-text classification models across a variety of tasks (including
binary classification, multi-class classification, and multi-label
classification). A BERT model finetuned using the ChunkBERT method performs
consistently across long samples in the benchmark while utilizing only a
fraction (6.25\%) of the original memory footprint. These findings suggest that
efficient finetuning and inference can be achieved through simple modifications
to pre-trained BERT models. | [
0.0481470637,
0.046888303,
0.0024040765,
0.0301821064,
-0.0211876929,
-0.0035145646,
0.0346761718,
0.0093320273,
-0.0302359723,
-0.0840040073,
-0.005676663,
-0.0012616088,
-0.0309890024,
0.0118149798,
0.0263458937,
-0.057152953,
0.0194372218,
-0.0071358941,
0.0284160934,
0.0186562892,
0.0193919837,
-0.00019636,
0.0198367909,
0.0363498665,
-0.0294254906,
0.0062433952,
-0.0043848697,
0.0239645522,
0.0048630997,
-0.022120472,
0.0354291946,
0.0510469377,
0.0020030611,
0.0302723423,
0.0000017683,
-0.0344553292,
-0.0293265581,
0.0197947286,
-0.0045617726,
0.0334043726,
-0.0056484076,
0.0038537912,
0.0153164556,
0.0069827936,
0.0186097082,
-0.0112754088,
0.0236717798,
0.0998581648,
0.0352001674,
0.0778670385,
-0.0153185064,
-0.0369304456,
0.0406800285,
-0.0377750061,
-0.0187274888,
-0.0260784272,
0.0382570662,
-0.0917069912,
0.0103900246,
0.0126078418,
-0.0349454395,
0.0100375647,
0.0435445979,
0.0296971295,
0.0139227472,
0.0555685423,
-0.093298316,
-0.0225395635,
0.0056069512,
0.0647852197,
-0.0399288237,
-0.028198123,
0.0115267374,
0.0067565278,
0.0179513283,
-0.0263476074,
-0.009690728,
-0.0029450329,
0.0000684235,
0.0192233082,
-0.0217398219,
0.0010293169,
0.0155796055,
0.0352660492,
-0.077580139,
0.0029906146,
0.0120321475,
-0.0288580451,
-0.0071768397,
0.0026585641,
-0.0248294286,
-0.0634440109,
0.0110696824,
0.0101389876,
0.0029579527,
-0.0146024078,
-0.0552649684,
-0.036159087,
0.0307452269,
-0.0232319105,
-0.0344413631,
0.0334323868,
-0.0746283531,
0.0288338754,
-0.0691034123,
0.0210006274,
-0.0348389745,
0.0461432636,
-0.0282690413,
-0.023584947,
-0.0350049287,
-0.0147732524,
-0.0935775489,
0.0495012291,
-0.0149492463,
-0.036771562,
-0.0272994712,
-0.0026253618,
-0.0016146557,
-0.002643195,
-0.0017924816,
0.0178173501,
-0.0018240802,
-0.0023535888,
-0.0018391317,
0.0391778015,
-0.0815674812,
0.0104113482,
0.0074157901,
-0.0325639956,
-0.0114253042,
0.0151601024,
0.0118881967,
-0.0668031275,
0.0385614298,
0.0371203087,
0.0023215637,
-0.0773075521,
-0.0199652221,
0.007248228,
-0.0582535639,
-0.0499575734,
0.0053361738,
-0.0694823191,
0.0242251027,
0.0142410249,
0.0102243181,
0.0345648527,
-0.0006555338,
0.0135202799,
-0.040018484,
0.077479668,
-0.0000814727,
-0.0273070931,
0.0342420712,
0.0073979096,
0.0109634725,
0.0609065183,
0.0256664455,
0.0641287044,
0.048220668,
-0.0108814426,
0.008492263,
0.0365055539,
0.0363194905,
-0.0169284623,
-0.0245860964,
0.0154715395,
-0.0179465804,
0.0192392506,
-0.0080389846,
0.0807895809,
-0.0306028388,
-0.0251751617,
0.0241876524,
0.0527726598,
0.0044718701,
0.0368682258,
0.0216833819,
0.0125048896,
0.0080935648,
-0.0056114229,
-0.0468481109,
0.0077274796,
0.0288315602,
-0.0057394989,
0.0484078936,
0.0144773759,
-0.0315121785,
-0.0034918189,
-0.0183861107,
-0.0275058914,
-0.0028289757,
-0.0269557275,
0.0699902549,
0.0110611254,
-0.031378217,
0.0859258696,
0.0292043183,
-0.0283112694,
-0.0014836993,
-0.0616307482,
0.010089715,
0.0655657798,
0.0331955627,
-0.0504043847,
-0.0253171809,
-0.0139469979,
0.0260576326,
0.0140727833,
0.0373198055,
-0.0041070906,
0.0127068721,
-0.0369040743,
-0.0025457449,
-0.016669089,
0.0018395773,
-0.0162815712,
0.0452708118,
0.0477136672,
0.0172335375,
-0.0563553609,
0.0152488165,
0.047822386,
0.0234294143,
-0.0354668386,
0.0175941885,
0.0301748868,
0.0170109607,
-0.0059143892,
-0.0336703584,
0.0033181107,
0.0276774019,
-0.0367950089,
-0.0338897444,
-0.0291113947,
-0.0294887125,
-0.0568664148,
0.0148098217,
-0.0190836787,
0.0005353682,
0.0231773257,
-0.0481694974,
-0.0230384339,
-0.0212833174,
-0.049869664,
0.0720350891,
-0.0210045818,
0.0006516081,
-0.0052790693,
0.0109335547,
-0.0226402171,
0.0338494219,
0.0185869168,
0.0190959349,
-0.0169932004,
-0.0150193619,
0.0505496748,
-0.0202655811,
-0.061367441,
0.0168381818,
-0.0285024438,
-0.0238049943,
0.0300215855,
-0.0177901462,
-0.0270697698,
-0.0404641815,
-0.1274799556,
0.0043704449,
-0.01370834,
0.0240410995,
-0.0249707345,
-0.0045992215,
-0.0048386054,
-0.023164859,
-0.0216233153,
-0.0485816859,
-0.0513803624,
0.0186365768,
0.0398011096,
-0.0082489708,
-0.0270599201,
-0.0068046511,
-0.0326966755,
-0.0204175785,
0.0715047941,
-0.0278887004,
-0.0372582898,
-0.0204192232,
-0.084205687,
0.0010896961,
0.0253583603,
-0.0039303629,
-0.0687250793,
-0.0108787538,
-0.0252661873,
0.0792440251,
0.0546512417,
0.0688594058,
0.0545757525,
-0.0315626822,
0.0186366849,
-0.0150036151,
0.0335443951,
-0.0162226893,
0.0369474143,
-0.0230279081,
-0.0111743044,
0.0093686301,
0.0462438352,
-0.038313549,
0.0008011037,
-0.058459729,
-0.0147700002,
-0.0007546315,
0.0083397292,
0.0087181246,
0.0091721509,
-0.0284540933,
-0.0370027013,
-0.0152226025,
-0.0507211424,
0.0703328699,
-0.0410630368,
0.0067973188,
-0.0226810668,
0.0082824985,
-0.0376853459,
0.0888785496,
0.0305356327,
0.0038114605,
0.0119869914,
-0.0166221261,
-0.0079820091,
-0.0046582371,
-0.035899587,
-0.0199671518,
0.0321421437,
0.0036574225,
0.0194255207,
-0.0337994806,
-0.0486061014,
-0.0133244377,
-0.0600982569,
-0.0263462178,
0.0345242918,
0.0349849425,
-0.0295330621,
-0.056572713,
0.0174318217,
0.0114371134,
0.0533740781,
-0.0403838381,
0.0131582124,
-0.0016112428,
0.0639729351,
0.0263136495,
-0.0072773155,
0.0046385834,
-0.0346721187,
0.003722053,
0.0556651242,
0.0313730463,
0.0343729295,
-0.0375227071,
-0.0268716086,
0.0280904081,
-0.057660006,
-0.0093570305,
-0.0028470985,
0.0784686133,
-0.0630697981,
-0.0081105111,
0.114192307,
0.0297964066,
-0.0135737974,
0.0035054965,
0.0312788226,
0.0237706043,
-0.009085984,
0.0042545386,
-0.0615330711,
-0.0797804892,
0.0312205143,
0.0067831688,
-0.0001749407,
-0.0054748124,
0.0222341418,
-0.08312466,
0.012774419,
-0.039466247,
-0.0295882095,
0.0109891314,
-0.0397241712,
-0.0234945416,
0.0030444872,
-0.005261187,
-0.0205844101,
-0.0184996016,
-0.0110494262,
0.0292441789,
-0.0473921634,
-0.0072180033,
0.0342321098,
-0.055604212,
0.0273489878,
0.0268097986,
0.0397807695,
-0.0251433197,
-0.0300902296,
0.0514478609,
-0.034492135,
-0.008033732,
0.0034465487,
0.0892518833,
-0.0497747771,
-0.0207908694,
-0.0067278603,
0.0063149356,
0.0029242847,
-0.0357283838,
-0.0137790171,
0.0552972965,
0.022580605,
-0.0267312527,
-0.0420626886,
-0.0171775799,
-0.0365522988,
0.0877520889,
0.0193513166,
-0.0604031831,
-0.0648494139,
0.0107296277,
-0.0280377921,
-0.0641124249,
0.0438806787,
0.0114009501,
-0.0471039861,
-0.0387776904,
-0.0522568002,
-0.0299062207,
0.0543360598,
0.0465633087,
-0.014935323,
-0.029076755,
0.0031777606,
0.0182599258,
-0.0720405728,
0.0647156835,
0.0105764149,
0.0414521098,
-0.0958847031,
-0.0114206411,
0.0465221591,
-0.0147163859,
-0.0197026376,
0.0050551239,
-0.0797973275,
-0.0335651375,
0.0056317151,
0.0214665942,
0.0091390144,
0.0157287959,
-0.0149821527,
-0.043124795,
0.0577686988,
0.0840928704,
-0.0607319139,
-0.032584209,
0.0202406589,
0.0088867228,
0.0007751186,
0.0297008082,
-0.046957422,
0.0200298559,
0.0180947296,
0.0210616514,
-0.0012121332,
0.0185991898,
-0.0217888132,
0.0031396556,
0.0436592288,
-0.0267054588,
0.0001120986,
-0.0097070653,
0.0398791917,
0.0063301492,
-0.0006199579,
-0.0234702583,
-0.0001566033,
0.0277529377,
0.0029307674,
-0.0387365073,
0.0701165125,
0.0164523814,
0.0063583548,
-0.0202683769,
0.0276023634,
-0.0183400437,
0.0078711864,
0.0316639319,
-0.0205297824,
-0.0339261889,
-0.0553798936,
-0.0015499713,
0.0141156008,
-0.0541922413,
0.0312768519,
0.0555362925,
0.0062883305,
-0.0246284809,
0.0393182263,
-0.0476054549,
0.0003133928,
-0.0383754373,
0.0281801857,
-0.0011962224,
-0.0276806429,
-0.0137192979,
-0.0057953326,
-0.0290128775,
0.0006274984,
0.0049138148,
-0.0199393872,
-0.0096592139,
0.0040275007,
0.0207773969,
-0.0381113999,
-0.0280487295,
0.0437079296,
0.0273835268,
0.0166503172,
0.028810963,
-0.0246934053,
-0.0289992262,
-0.0041136122,
0.0309326146,
0.0129192853,
0.0083953086,
0.0035982351,
-0.0123380013,
-0.034039434,
0.0234039426,
-0.0363310166,
0.0117834881,
0.0010426502,
0.0327664502,
0.0683499724,
0.025663428,
-0.050974071,
-0.0087744845,
0.012165349,
0.0528054647,
0.0028080863,
0.0044607762,
-5.9933226e-33,
0.0129112769,
-0.0032106603,
-0.0016057729,
-0.0060510091,
-0.0485041551,
0.0248676296,
0.0062987767,
-0.0471324027,
0.0005246932,
0.031553179,
0.0030734334,
-0.0086673098,
0.0116707599,
0.0657295957,
-0.0044576274,
-0.0272736065,
0.06590195,
0.0132480487,
-0.0406505093,
0.0172010884,
0.0297845881,
0.0464424342,
0.042860724,
0.024964001,
-0.019827025,
0.0223090928,
0.0234546047,
0.0177482255,
0.0278860088,
0.0489607006,
-0.0041281651,
-0.005630943,
0.0479538366,
-0.0233624,
0.0212271288,
0.0655669421,
-0.1264373064,
-0.0016932682,
-0.0092371805,
0.0377982035,
-0.0120241987,
0.0006665121,
0.0612781867,
0.0064744158,
0.0230225101,
-0.0095805265,
0.0419081934,
-0.0032054104,
-0.0160355214,
-0.0648988411,
-0.0651556328,
0.0443607941,
0.0062097013,
-0.0449014753,
0.0188890044,
0.0182365216,
0.0218238644,
0.0376495272,
-0.0388289206,
-0.0493522957,
0.0021112182,
0.0370528027,
-0.0029542095,
0.0111867273,
-0.0135215502,
0.0579031855,
0.0296081547,
0.0015746093,
-0.0479347222,
-0.0067106942,
0.0408155993,
0.048073411,
0.0502763465,
-0.0140117519,
0.0763693675,
-0.0192121807,
-0.0586984754,
-0.0067212554,
0.0119610755,
0.0179450698,
0.0378951579,
0.0034952031,
-0.008084462,
-0.0060411873,
-0.0176383778,
0.008707555,
-0.0305588897,
0.0383060463,
0.0250156112,
0.0446647704,
0.0076620658,
0.0421391614,
0.0366253406,
-0.0260869619,
-0.0132041238,
-0.0066704871,
-0.0015061294,
0.016443355,
0.0011199713,
0.0110987788,
-0.0586698465,
-0.0385176837,
0.0452373289,
0.008512388,
-0.0104244817,
-0.0101515343,
0.0915399864,
0.0168084912,
-0.0901220441,
-0.0032760026,
-0.0297243595,
-0.0022112653,
-0.0160129499,
0.0474311747,
0.0318044089,
0.0510665588,
0.0012014292,
0.0312306713,
0.0117195742,
0.0191513058,
-0.0166276917,
0.0135338819,
0.0177974459,
0.0125870584,
-0.0028275836,
-0.0140364058,
-0.0317683257,
0.0332577378,
-0.0134016722,
-0.1037983149,
0.000278982,
0.0333343185,
2.54e-7,
0.0334594995,
0.0610985644,
0.066645816,
-0.0513018742,
0.0142797744,
0.0269008912,
0.019907048,
0.0597598739,
-0.0164481346,
0.0230911449,
-0.0103796599,
0.0104703745,
0.0327617712,
0.0186454523,
-0.0940403491,
0.0141227776,
-0.0822745636,
0.0047142017,
-0.0607719496,
0.0089346422,
0.0769601911,
0.0992313251,
0.0306724422,
-0.0027856252,
0.0400548987,
-0.0551054589,
0.0606733225,
-0.0210585613,
0.0281985905,
0.0345658064,
0.0123129813,
0.0193047244,
0.0138951959,
0.0103670442,
-0.0232435651,
0.0300208237,
0.0027445115,
0.0505906008,
-0.002858144,
-0.0269367155,
0.0059298528,
-0.0506632142,
-0.0096085072,
-0.0448673777,
0.079014428,
-0.0796094239,
-0.0033233999,
0.0109321671,
-0.0308117289,
0.0140575692,
0.0184085071,
-0.0041831345,
-0.005410532,
0.0599079803,
0.038854599,
-0.0162038654,
-0.0011874074,
-0.1403579861,
-0.0059160562,
-0.0077454196,
-0.0561429337,
-0.0079300515,
-0.0716048926,
-0.0475185849,
0.0258230753,
-0.096676603,
-0.0006364909,
2.178537711e-34,
0.0248533227,
-0.0214439258,
-0.0280888565,
0.0071738637,
0.0168140642,
-0.0154749826,
0.0281422716,
-0.0128812082,
-0.0059609702,
-0.0404958464,
-0.0182543714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20550v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20550v3 | CapsFusion: Rethinking Image-Text Data at Scale | 2023-10-31T15:31:39 | 2024-04-05T05:29:29 | Qiying Yu, Quan Sun, Xiaosong Zhang, Yufeng Cui, Fan Zhang, Yue Cao, Xinlong Wang, Jingjing Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large multimodal models demonstrate remarkable generalist ability to perform
diverse multimodal tasks in a zero-shot manner. Large-scale web-based
image-text pairs contribute fundamentally to this success, but suffer from
excessive noise. Recent studies use alternative captions synthesized by
captioning models and have achieved notable benchmark performance. However, our
experiments reveal significant Scalability Deficiency and World Knowledge Loss
issues in models trained with synthetic captions, which have been largely
obscured by their initial benchmark success. Upon closer examination, we
identify the root cause as the overly-simplified language structure and lack of
knowledge details in existing synthetic captions. To provide higher-quality and
more scalable multimodal pretraining data, we propose CapsFusion, an advanced
framework that leverages large language models to consolidate and refine
information from both web-based image-text pairs and synthetic captions.
Extensive experiments show that CapsFusion captions exhibit remarkable
all-round superiority over existing captions in terms of model performance
(e.g., 18.8 and 18.3 improvements in CIDEr score on COCO and NoCaps), sample
efficiency (requiring 11-16 times less computation than baselines), world
knowledge depth, and scalability. These effectiveness, efficiency and
scalability advantages position CapsFusion as a promising candidate for future
scaling of LMM training. | [
0.0308093354,
0.0790171772,
0.0007684332,
0.0531244501,
0.0152906105,
0.0097106379,
0.0163052455,
0.0094697662,
-0.0016338382,
-0.0874030367,
-0.0650427565,
-0.0312535055,
-0.0005116573,
0.0702581555,
0.0272780582,
-0.0737754777,
0.0058723576,
-0.0311125685,
-0.0481606424,
0.0014620706,
0.0345676802,
0.0052317516,
-0.0160350241,
0.0240309276,
-0.0356833674,
-0.0015569009,
-0.0181778558,
0.0328279138,
0.0103619415,
-0.0553482696,
0.0075968229,
0.0856252834,
0.0546129122,
0.0338755883,
0.0000019456,
-0.0234212913,
0.0305671934,
-0.0077073793,
0.0214533582,
0.0151978265,
0.0617769212,
-0.0255913362,
0.0107203079,
-0.0105561083,
-0.0059646107,
0.0032243591,
0.0651837736,
0.0483741239,
0.0578974672,
0.0477420613,
-0.0332453586,
-0.040859025,
-0.0147480071,
-0.0332999416,
0.0081226183,
-0.0360824615,
0.0068866801,
0.0463253595,
-0.0260078721,
-0.0029330861,
-0.0434821695,
0.0460933931,
-0.0023175217,
-0.0231897105,
0.0250137951,
0.0567956828,
-0.0331871323,
-0.0647260696,
-0.0288049951,
0.1175078154,
0.0150015159,
0.015472482,
-0.0304220449,
0.0046014907,
0.0048890398,
-0.008937655,
-0.0564305708,
0.0407357067,
0.0098352209,
0.0051230099,
-0.0848966092,
0.0097142616,
0.0178046916,
0.0007843819,
-0.0236755181,
-0.0541466847,
0.0107835261,
0.0351597816,
0.0013213764,
0.0027021079,
-0.0685457513,
-0.044117786,
0.028371688,
0.0128356135,
0.0063261082,
-0.004117283,
-0.058014825,
-0.0295435358,
0.0223372802,
-0.0582681373,
0.0270811208,
-0.0070660845,
-0.0637209415,
0.0857741833,
-0.0283597261,
0.0249489918,
-0.0123166777,
0.056841772,
-0.0326776318,
-0.007736085,
-0.0521905534,
-0.0174536388,
-0.0028248779,
0.0147983367,
-0.0607119054,
-0.0423258841,
-0.0321673229,
0.0045948797,
0.0093655949,
0.0200625043,
-0.0160238966,
0.0401990414,
-0.0340107828,
-0.0092252577,
-0.0400073826,
0.0558933951,
-0.0011049876,
0.0253870003,
-0.0179959442,
-0.0435296111,
-0.0028049913,
0.0465720072,
0.005494704,
-0.0099601103,
0.012085692,
0.0992815122,
-0.0555762798,
-0.0455624387,
-0.0027022529,
-0.0386559032,
-0.0574257299,
-0.032508295,
0.0337501504,
-0.0243621692,
0.048896689,
-0.0091043431,
0.0364965796,
-0.0295130573,
0.0036456543,
0.0053418353,
0.0030792512,
0.1040492132,
-0.0221080109,
-0.0127502661,
0.0339908116,
0.0102984672,
-0.030408062,
0.067093201,
0.0391381681,
0.0516677909,
0.0336229913,
-0.0158421937,
0.0305656306,
0.0310248118,
0.0182703342,
0.0271235965,
-0.0384074338,
0.0008904925,
0.0454754084,
0.0268451776,
0.0577325635,
0.032733243,
-0.0306683052,
0.0109374216,
0.1193837002,
0.0133535489,
-0.0126857366,
0.002736625,
0.0291174576,
-0.0070899399,
0.0113511812,
-0.0281648841,
-0.067323558,
0.0410255119,
-0.0153431026,
-0.009831138,
0.0325807445,
0.0406750515,
-0.0358234234,
-0.0339767411,
0.0030074599,
-0.0198177136,
-0.0166174844,
-0.0081613706,
0.0460383967,
0.0111996746,
-0.0531056486,
0.0508562811,
0.0107459286,
-0.0319073312,
0.006928945,
-0.0219392423,
-0.0311475936,
0.0427719019,
0.0282992739,
-0.0009370993,
-0.0217536353,
-0.0017305457,
0.0628289878,
0.0733614638,
0.0296743456,
0.0062041129,
0.0425008349,
-0.0429579057,
-0.0470701717,
-0.0219697692,
-0.0133679574,
0.0080689713,
0.0155467456,
0.0075257481,
0.0301351957,
-0.0361856967,
-0.0501624644,
0.046914231,
0.0520304814,
-0.0141647989,
-0.025463352,
-0.0088666324,
0.0054033371,
-0.00056798,
-0.0260547306,
-0.0105375331,
0.0119831283,
-0.0136432722,
-0.0416465215,
0.0322558507,
-0.0531860627,
-0.0628232285,
0.0333232209,
-0.0689129084,
-0.0056688269,
0.0043015415,
-0.0388403237,
-0.020128604,
-0.0093183406,
-0.0165158734,
0.0071466165,
-0.0475992858,
0.0080931252,
0.0153446905,
0.0165221784,
0.0024872427,
0.0485849418,
-0.016409466,
-0.0419810489,
0.0105692698,
-0.0103875604,
-0.0088929869,
-0.000037013,
-0.0479031801,
0.0023614522,
-0.0027498126,
0.0137816677,
-0.0053236806,
0.0350925177,
-0.0452506691,
-0.0005565707,
-0.0871129781,
-0.0286174268,
0.001767871,
-0.0369527377,
0.003315768,
-0.0063478854,
0.0075335694,
-0.0420353599,
-0.0083407685,
-0.0121426675,
-0.0028744531,
0.0145747038,
0.0420303345,
0.0260824133,
-0.0035755537,
-0.0198768955,
0.0091473926,
0.0308787692,
0.0794404745,
0.0031628844,
-0.0176689606,
-0.0206635967,
0.0006881066,
-0.0344920829,
0.0021664142,
-0.0393103287,
-0.0287582353,
0.021582175,
-0.0089111403,
0.00868758,
0.0180734657,
0.0193949286,
0.007199469,
0.0501283742,
0.0047055432,
-0.0220058709,
-0.0002020068,
0.006369303,
-0.0816916525,
-0.0183999483,
-0.0199925918,
0.006952852,
0.0560136586,
-0.0343201756,
0.0336250067,
-0.0557179861,
-0.0042125578,
-0.006558436,
-0.0763014853,
-0.0763127059,
0.0240765791,
-0.0104344692,
0.0005438704,
-0.0541362576,
-0.0578116588,
0.0171066951,
-0.0607002527,
-0.0396954119,
0.0093461312,
0.0096950494,
-0.0127967773,
0.074879989,
0.0229621362,
0.0391091071,
0.0101172477,
-0.0108837653,
-0.0158856325,
0.0063189426,
0.0237944108,
-0.0104360487,
0.018307006,
-0.0597257577,
0.0164090116,
-0.0263860449,
-0.0378005691,
-0.0199678764,
-0.0131946392,
-0.018726388,
-0.0400051773,
-0.0252479985,
-0.0129104732,
-0.0166042689,
0.0207979269,
0.0409272797,
0.0421514548,
0.0100132087,
-0.0108564449,
-0.0048752408,
0.0282020643,
0.0356815681,
0.0505276769,
-0.0356965549,
-0.0557932407,
0.0223177727,
0.046270892,
0.0064924038,
-0.0359118767,
-0.0316689387,
0.0224670898,
-0.0004447431,
0.0315951891,
-0.0022402257,
0.0345885083,
0.0735149905,
-0.0255710743,
0.018679874,
0.068994984,
0.0061406018,
-0.0578605905,
-0.0335821249,
0.0428700149,
0.0338917784,
0.0267230775,
-0.0325169265,
-0.0750880316,
-0.0772372186,
-0.0152119072,
-0.0037060729,
0.0378971733,
0.027615549,
-0.030652469,
-0.0684393868,
0.0234427992,
0.0218903013,
-0.0962299332,
-0.0365255959,
-0.0085654231,
-0.0189050715,
-0.0052219229,
-0.0093820319,
-0.0056196302,
-0.0029582381,
-0.0032640533,
0.0184038449,
0.00734118,
-0.0664637461,
-0.0167854037,
-0.0491573475,
0.0043364274,
0.0237100143,
0.0147846546,
-0.000158014,
-0.0096882209,
0.0175185241,
0.0103128124,
0.0132332556,
-0.0168112013,
0.1081955507,
-0.0303610414,
-0.0422989987,
0.0216422174,
0.0141565837,
-0.0258738268,
-0.016193537,
0.003277082,
0.0289082061,
0.0029022971,
-0.004805956,
-0.0477193296,
0.0163438097,
-0.0064274822,
0.0591451488,
0.0222023688,
-0.0221697856,
-0.0061259968,
-0.0037067102,
-0.0219397619,
-0.0763564631,
-0.0221845172,
0.0258679166,
-0.0134369172,
-0.0184135623,
-0.0625960156,
-0.0192846153,
0.0584360063,
0.0231171027,
0.0133086042,
-0.0123004261,
-0.0182178039,
0.0366765,
-0.067812264,
0.0767306983,
-0.0749136209,
-0.0088119144,
-0.0435846597,
-0.010018724,
0.0567828566,
-0.0306057539,
-0.0138443746,
0.0516696796,
-0.0716587678,
-0.0152886957,
-0.0341685638,
0.0723844022,
0.0132003846,
0.0244551282,
0.0326058343,
-0.0335212089,
0.0440672114,
0.0412948802,
0.0007123357,
0.024852043,
0.0346502066,
0.0046431185,
-0.0164496768,
0.0064460221,
-0.0403984264,
0.0221129749,
-0.0189545564,
0.0283450708,
-0.0002479637,
-0.0169473551,
0.0126342103,
0.0023113487,
0.0236325506,
-0.0613142624,
0.0121119795,
-0.021760663,
0.0201853607,
-0.0127937375,
-0.0254185814,
-0.0453656055,
0.0159048289,
0.0219125375,
0.0493764468,
0.0060649407,
0.0162307825,
0.0023169811,
0.0423957035,
-0.0023482048,
-0.014542033,
0.0304300468,
-0.0315243602,
0.0259320028,
0.0263952166,
0.0008361586,
0.0037745498,
-0.0039293389,
0.0127842939,
-0.0138962669,
0.0484684743,
0.0281442702,
-0.0238030702,
-0.0249522105,
0.0634444579,
-0.0035312916,
-0.0048386487,
-0.0668215305,
0.0627085194,
0.0590964146,
0.0208869092,
0.0489091203,
-0.0178569648,
-0.0160029046,
-0.0098239249,
0.0399691947,
0.0069764471,
-0.0185388997,
0.0654102266,
-0.0059694625,
0.009338744,
0.0109358151,
0.0774288476,
0.0096396329,
0.0558827408,
-0.0031977741,
-0.0160392262,
-0.0499496721,
-0.015263496,
0.0140396254,
0.0024764817,
-0.01317068,
0.0201986805,
-0.019889608,
-0.0433468521,
0.0104858596,
-0.0133407163,
-0.0115033491,
0.0249136481,
0.0501730666,
0.0216941088,
0.0123147406,
-0.0054621291,
-0.0149061978,
0.0120338714,
0.0199712366,
0.0299718492,
0.0300893337,
-6.065785582e-33,
-0.0330112278,
-0.0349997245,
0.0296720695,
-0.0385516509,
-0.0348961502,
0.0135495039,
-0.0364420637,
0.0335358009,
0.0082991738,
-0.0049708658,
0.0201606061,
-0.0160974804,
0.0195489414,
0.0516849831,
-0.0046665571,
-0.0005296916,
0.0530357733,
-0.0211661663,
-0.0044282512,
0.0156197352,
0.0055825231,
0.0295504835,
0.0525984354,
-0.0353631042,
0.0072199777,
0.0083269514,
-0.0514234155,
0.0046435697,
0.0414378718,
0.0431181118,
-0.0643835664,
0.0334563367,
0.0075769923,
-0.0179812871,
-0.028230289,
-0.0058710729,
-0.0753169134,
0.0068490896,
0.0060567707,
0.0282859839,
-0.0430730172,
0.0003366382,
0.0482633598,
-0.0186970606,
0.0237821471,
-0.0106743239,
0.0496439971,
-0.0157221258,
0.0023856442,
-0.0085721361,
-0.0488704778,
0.0191665161,
-0.0126900794,
-0.0208905116,
0.0165903307,
0.0461253896,
0.0289746523,
0.0438744538,
-0.0207031053,
0.0311454255,
0.0074694892,
0.0180895459,
0.0754479468,
0.0695209578,
-0.0052524814,
0.0868245959,
0.0052897246,
-0.0074151913,
-0.0315796398,
0.0333035849,
0.0438338481,
0.056112837,
0.0404669382,
0.1062709019,
0.0494786724,
0.0186951924,
-0.0286330711,
0.0417746641,
-0.0990870744,
0.0093897022,
0.0030878226,
0.0314407051,
0.0045267469,
0.0155698294,
-0.0436935946,
0.0065637771,
-0.0393617563,
-0.0025657902,
0.0411849841,
0.0376215205,
-0.042335473,
0.0110273743,
0.0565211996,
-0.0212184228,
-0.0217778031,
-0.0343946144,
-0.0130303716,
0.0621924065,
-0.0143307336,
-0.0341080278,
-0.0061812452,
-0.045225203,
0.0840087384,
0.0056446474,
0.0226900838,
-0.0000455377,
0.0451323912,
0.0253568664,
-0.0209345426,
-0.0027788554,
-0.031197546,
-0.0150111178,
-0.0111488383,
0.0045831599,
0.0209761243,
0.0190632287,
-0.0873738304,
0.0002821232,
-0.0103640649,
0.0128629357,
-0.0149569213,
-0.0694708526,
0.0256729014,
0.0449951254,
-0.0406634957,
0.0156796351,
-0.0501619689,
-0.0373270959,
0.0483942702,
-0.0965284482,
-0.0367720127,
0.0127910394,
2.518e-7,
0.0480605215,
0.0217679255,
0.0146519011,
-0.0170603096,
0.0201573949,
0.0551928952,
-0.0361991823,
0.024548769,
-0.0201604534,
-0.0588595606,
0.0348540209,
0.0603050254,
0.0396158136,
0.0083263172,
-0.0393134616,
-0.0455519408,
-0.0322306156,
-0.0217118878,
-0.0543054491,
-0.00598288,
0.037872009,
0.0733841807,
-0.0217941832,
-0.0416439287,
0.0367863029,
-0.0699298233,
0.0931129381,
-0.035431806,
-0.0058057178,
-0.0188908987,
0.0246461686,
0.0518846698,
-0.0506391674,
0.0278253891,
-0.0177326947,
-0.0460891761,
0.0653786361,
0.0360944532,
-0.0246867854,
-0.0243028887,
-0.0281444471,
0.0511740111,
-0.0153374011,
-0.0163799748,
0.077876173,
-0.0516577289,
-0.0090917274,
-0.0337827802,
-0.0323300473,
-0.0209855158,
0.0423762053,
-0.040840663,
-0.0526283197,
0.0300974362,
0.019222483,
0.0246348977,
-0.0532838479,
-0.0945347473,
-0.0387374945,
0.0046855086,
-0.046283409,
-0.0385654233,
-0.0741621554,
-0.0451506935,
0.0316500142,
-0.0339232571,
-0.02515186,
1.99185704e-34,
0.0231919568,
-0.0275417771,
0.0183326155,
-0.0072274986,
0.0251757558,
0.0094328839,
-0.0162128042,
-0.0269559007,
-0.0205295347,
-0.069474645,
0.0001970131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20501v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20501v2 | LLMs may Dominate Information Access: Neural Retrievers are Biased Towards LLM-Generated Texts | 2023-10-31T14:42:23 | 2024-01-14T14:41:06 | Sunhao Dai, Yuqi Zhou, Liang Pang, Weihao Liu, Xiaolin Hu, Yong Liu, Xiao Zhang, Gang Wang, Jun Xu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, the emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized
the paradigm of information retrieval (IR) applications, especially in web
search. With their remarkable capabilities in generating human-like texts, LLMs
have created enormous texts on the Internet. As a result, IR systems in the
LLMs era are facing a new challenge: the indexed documents now are not only
written by human beings but also automatically generated by the LLMs. How these
LLM-generated documents influence the IR systems is a pressing and still
unexplored question. In this work, we conduct a quantitative evaluation of
different IR models in scenarios where both human-written and LLM-generated
texts are involved. Surprisingly, our findings indicate that neural retrieval
models tend to rank LLM-generated documents higher. We refer to this category
of biases in neural retrieval models towards the LLM-generated text as the
\textbf{source bias}. Moreover, we discover that this bias is not confined to
the first-stage neural retrievers, but extends to the second-stage neural
re-rankers. Then, we provide an in-depth analysis from the perspective of text
compression and observe that neural models can better understand the semantic
information of LLM-generated text, which is further substantiated by our
theoretical analysis. To mitigate the source bias, we also propose a
plug-and-play debiased constraint for the optimization objective, and
experimental results show the effectiveness. Finally, we discuss the potential
severe concerns stemming from the observed source bias and hope our findings
can serve as a critical wake-up call to the IR community and beyond. To
facilitate future explorations of IR in the LLM era, the constructed two new
benchmarks and codes will later be available at
\url{https://github.com/KID-22/LLM4IR-Bias}. | [
0.0490929224,
0.051459197,
-0.0085203806,
0.0443358421,
-0.0299365073,
-0.0156217562,
-0.0136691472,
0.0482483767,
0.004344617,
-0.039769806,
-0.0266240239,
-0.0097667743,
-0.0117105972,
-0.0167264715,
0.0164230261,
0.0116612939,
0.014114853,
0.0140874544,
0.0084980009,
0.0064790407,
-0.0133468602,
-0.0092894062,
0.0706227496,
0.0165805146,
-0.0052260687,
0.0230017751,
0.0080657871,
0.055608768,
-0.0376194715,
-0.0045907255,
0.0051165912,
0.0352474526,
0.0244145412,
0.0292498004,
0.0000019959,
-0.0306872036,
-0.0273966398,
0.0179833956,
-0.0467452146,
0.0254339408,
0.0518400297,
-0.0045166812,
-0.0080103697,
0.0028345664,
-0.0303041749,
-0.0152230384,
0.0122836167,
0.0374259837,
0.0548159964,
0.0805160403,
-0.0063082632,
-0.0053126137,
0.0261554271,
-0.0387372002,
0.0457310751,
-0.0266894642,
0.0150515418,
-0.0241507702,
-0.0171129666,
0.0494399816,
0.0133082215,
0.0261959098,
0.010978614,
-0.0139223747,
0.0342944637,
0.0109467329,
-0.0612006634,
0.002844552,
0.0234045517,
0.0575035326,
-0.0057418621,
-0.0242064297,
0.0249734502,
0.0167328231,
0.0340746455,
0.0282915719,
-0.0654333308,
0.0593988448,
-0.0020837663,
0.0243866537,
-0.0180185866,
0.0167704504,
0.0375065655,
0.0432132334,
-0.0117947571,
0.0497261398,
0.0048654242,
-0.042989362,
-0.0043069283,
-0.0020289195,
0.0253670383,
-0.0189698488,
0.0364205167,
0.0234139338,
0.023121709,
0.0110322498,
-0.0346161015,
-0.0515764356,
0.0359864645,
-0.0634168759,
0.0251622796,
0.029773932,
-0.0057220012,
0.0472552627,
-0.0444069616,
0.0644763336,
-0.0251835957,
0.0027503136,
-0.0298928041,
-0.0107010417,
-0.0063950587,
-0.0275041796,
-0.0104232449,
0.0437530987,
-0.0135186026,
-0.009712222,
-0.0175239146,
0.0260307789,
0.0282974001,
-0.0087642223,
0.0171441678,
0.0181816649,
-0.0337573923,
-0.0138975447,
-0.0485950038,
-0.0081203906,
0.0040915743,
0.0042481967,
0.0101900008,
-0.0453269854,
0.004690337,
0.0322517827,
-0.0002650352,
-0.0224116258,
0.0158598945,
0.0580219068,
-0.0011212239,
-0.0213922337,
-0.0404221267,
-0.0574200414,
0.0221816301,
-0.0048847888,
0.0170246363,
-0.0492115989,
0.0285234898,
-0.0009057226,
-0.0272620227,
-0.0857626572,
-0.0056921616,
0.0443038531,
-0.0595893636,
0.0029847687,
0.0001742083,
0.0384099036,
0.0556521416,
0.0060818926,
0.0228495151,
0.0276825447,
0.0335925929,
0.0651599914,
0.0655066669,
0.0180597641,
0.0191067588,
0.0406988896,
0.0504032858,
-0.003061939,
-0.007826074,
-0.007925963,
-0.0170571767,
0.0340188071,
0.0724600032,
0.1036196053,
-0.0671855286,
-0.0498839281,
0.0788151696,
0.0691260993,
0.0408346206,
0.0342737995,
0.0126584703,
0.0236338619,
0.014553153,
0.0281926692,
-0.0410085469,
0.0237429217,
-0.0150275016,
0.0100627244,
0.085488528,
0.0027020783,
-0.0283546969,
-0.0353756323,
0.0005367388,
-0.0091126487,
-0.0058868406,
-0.0282465667,
0.0335658044,
-0.0045045707,
-0.0294094011,
0.048677057,
0.0099794418,
-0.0613521002,
0.0294558238,
-0.0529866666,
-0.009590989,
0.0584592596,
0.0810842067,
-0.0169277266,
0.0445654131,
0.0174909383,
-0.0477202423,
0.0521742553,
0.0196750164,
-0.0123040415,
-0.0272595752,
-0.0526683591,
-0.0474783927,
-0.0148235392,
-0.0033984301,
-0.0039759493,
0.030165989,
-0.0106904907,
0.0495985709,
-0.0450426601,
-0.0639422387,
0.035354279,
-0.0491068996,
-0.0238300115,
-0.0038072388,
-0.0108516989,
0.0009912091,
-0.0010709841,
-0.0478418097,
0.0286275111,
0.0449340791,
-0.028572863,
-0.0364839807,
-0.0524920337,
-0.0189331211,
-0.0057004131,
0.0326204039,
-0.0671817362,
0.027485121,
0.0453331172,
-0.0144803273,
-0.0036834462,
0.0113176871,
-0.0385134183,
0.0143735055,
-0.0491537079,
-0.0034470451,
0.0111358576,
0.0244855247,
-0.0712139532,
0.0681717172,
-0.0194285028,
0.028993573,
0.0336486958,
-0.0340189487,
0.0114626465,
-0.054732684,
-0.0008871508,
-0.0043017315,
-0.0247968212,
0.0341859981,
0.0497609675,
0.0049822284,
-0.0119771622,
-0.0336112641,
-0.0735173896,
-0.0021408419,
-0.0185872503,
-0.002808999,
0.02158002,
-0.0163469203,
-0.0078798048,
-0.0234265476,
-0.0629222319,
-0.0428301767,
0.0109260082,
0.0209251717,
0.0396614671,
-0.0048028561,
0.04955725,
-0.0508319773,
-0.0688449144,
0.0188223198,
0.0473946184,
0.0049121329,
-0.028266564,
-0.0418101549,
0.0547521822,
-0.0314622819,
-0.0118761379,
-0.0277903359,
-0.0111914258,
-0.019772131,
-0.0521834195,
0.0074265264,
0.0673097447,
0.0358782969,
-0.0031889852,
0.0521426126,
0.0305240266,
-0.0841242373,
-0.008797776,
-0.0307521112,
-0.0055793445,
-0.0043683904,
-0.0671667829,
0.0558988973,
0.0385569036,
-0.0002637277,
0.0073217214,
-0.0055351532,
0.0270235315,
-0.0143158212,
-0.0331661142,
-0.0625746325,
-0.0208197087,
-0.0053420505,
0.0759426057,
-0.0209649689,
-0.0768965185,
0.0340673178,
-0.029373074,
0.0385726281,
-0.0151441423,
0.0065580993,
-0.0607035905,
0.013380778,
-0.0029721169,
0.0354559496,
-0.0002845591,
0.0093807103,
-0.0620029531,
0.0480347835,
0.0425107554,
-0.0795632005,
0.0180396661,
0.0157124884,
0.0118775694,
-0.0362035967,
-0.0652185604,
-0.0287390463,
-0.0769445077,
0.046466697,
0.009841091,
0.0703408346,
-0.0188792385,
-0.0225878153,
-0.0119207157,
0.052634418,
0.0415332988,
-0.0295176413,
-0.0204228647,
0.000833687,
0.0465343297,
0.0386387371,
-0.0225882027,
0.0222627316,
-0.0052043661,
-0.0261933338,
0.0481268726,
0.0537669212,
-0.0055868514,
0.022019878,
-0.006808788,
0.0487902425,
-0.0183484908,
-0.0452838168,
0.0120441727,
-0.0218213461,
-0.0264182929,
-0.0052902736,
0.1015878618,
0.0268046129,
-0.0924626663,
-0.0174049437,
-0.0411015265,
0.0104084881,
0.0137772607,
0.0470552631,
-0.0448267311,
0.0197441317,
0.0339348651,
0.0325420946,
-0.0203028508,
-0.0203855392,
-0.0166046955,
-0.1285740435,
0.049721878,
0.0008974556,
0.0317349881,
-0.0012127861,
-0.0569449551,
-0.0080869058,
0.0086909235,
0.0054899827,
0.0501004234,
-0.0229401756,
-0.0034769136,
0.000222815,
0.0055328864,
-0.0314179994,
-0.0506013446,
-0.0412185825,
0.0139839528,
0.059513595,
0.012463931,
-0.0150620714,
-0.0241635945,
0.0230639428,
-0.0019946734,
0.0175580606,
-0.0199041571,
0.0784484074,
-0.0134515343,
0.0161443073,
-0.0402547158,
0.0055018119,
-0.0073433649,
0.0274412148,
-0.0246666316,
0.0323532186,
0.0118293371,
-0.0126677221,
-0.0606936142,
-0.0475432649,
-0.0236974861,
0.0856296644,
0.0309400503,
-0.0106140245,
-0.0358972847,
-0.0498495661,
0.0126932915,
-0.0091662081,
-0.0683156624,
0.0279432461,
-0.0070152697,
-0.0071649011,
-0.091502741,
-0.0276589505,
-0.0538802929,
-0.0038893791,
-0.0063274712,
0.0019509883,
0.0037904917,
-0.0505638942,
-0.0458872505,
0.0033372953,
-0.0241462123,
-0.0251032729,
-0.0624622703,
0.0240724776,
0.0315431915,
-0.0650313944,
-0.0119750844,
-0.0096488213,
-0.0274196379,
-0.050525289,
-0.0158551205,
0.0386896208,
0.0266538449,
0.0439136177,
-0.0066519752,
-0.1027971879,
0.057839036,
0.0541521758,
-0.0497177355,
0.0205093212,
-0.004800953,
-0.0066951183,
-0.0189972464,
0.0265005194,
-0.0875889584,
0.0294899736,
-0.0033512474,
0.0220239926,
0.0060154572,
-0.0494096316,
0.0449083336,
0.0467441417,
0.0399112627,
-0.0094215199,
0.024490336,
-0.0224023964,
-0.003043416,
-0.0433380008,
-0.0212673265,
-0.0214670431,
0.0057120891,
0.0437944084,
0.0235432051,
0.0049947095,
0.0597252436,
0.0303987153,
0.0260547418,
-0.0464483872,
-0.0419659652,
-0.0379741229,
0.0034238622,
-0.0059416397,
0.0107918559,
-0.0276066959,
0.0219847318,
-0.0109262178,
0.0467710644,
-0.0241508167,
0.0109240795,
0.0171342865,
0.0240806676,
-0.0184493344,
0.0270509999,
-0.0859709308,
-0.0408730656,
-0.0290667787,
-0.0294983163,
0.0397728495,
0.0047577512,
0.0440918766,
-0.0128896441,
-0.0097223353,
-0.0285546146,
-0.0414538644,
0.0411932059,
0.0099186888,
0.0014431532,
0.0096176211,
-0.0358862504,
0.0325604118,
0.1115482301,
0.0484628193,
0.0037453207,
-0.0585254282,
-0.027393721,
-0.009812694,
-0.0126729552,
0.004749293,
0.0097248843,
-0.0150507744,
-0.0470199436,
-0.0328189209,
-0.049245514,
0.0253810026,
0.0402290933,
0.0268201232,
-0.0408021808,
0.027735319,
0.0753140077,
-0.0041716644,
-0.000736015,
-0.0459969528,
-0.0027057151,
-0.0614029765,
-0.029864911,
-0.0149924345,
-6.593861358e-33,
-0.0003612245,
-0.0016181122,
0.0098165534,
0.0020976602,
-0.0138455536,
0.0237200484,
-0.0339017995,
-0.0333055742,
-0.0498147123,
-0.009863222,
-0.0574832968,
0.02062729,
0.0079675289,
0.0193509888,
-0.0064553446,
0.003995907,
0.0442282483,
-0.0342679657,
-0.0466699712,
0.0111826705,
0.031100139,
0.0157132074,
-0.0109377783,
-0.0611499436,
0.0083949389,
-0.0356359184,
0.0199921113,
0.0146308551,
0.0355231129,
0.0576737039,
-0.0334807411,
0.0320926048,
0.0436088108,
-0.0516772866,
-0.0129058911,
0.015050347,
-0.0515714027,
-0.016560616,
-0.0234635491,
-0.0344348215,
-0.0260477196,
-0.0455241576,
0.0890501738,
-0.0037202851,
-0.0432353914,
0.0091062644,
0.051825434,
0.0138232885,
-0.0638356432,
-0.0790146664,
-0.023175532,
0.0330085456,
0.0151410569,
0.0249650069,
0.0360412747,
0.0321896598,
-0.0185149685,
0.06795872,
-0.0537740178,
0.0334749781,
-0.0507838279,
0.0664971918,
0.0442872047,
-0.0032208657,
0.0134798614,
0.0695219859,
0.0375624076,
0.0291380212,
-0.0255089831,
-0.0529124886,
0.0219114292,
0.0195178315,
0.0364053175,
0.0835661516,
0.0292160027,
-0.0092626251,
-0.0661310032,
0.0606587902,
0.0232232418,
0.01831319,
0.0376897305,
0.0310564339,
-0.0422702357,
-0.0355386175,
-0.047680378,
-0.0264572818,
-0.0351189747,
-0.0215431973,
0.0122166816,
0.0376896635,
0.0021463616,
-0.0549337827,
0.0354865193,
-0.0458790362,
0.0128435232,
0.0654561892,
-0.0167192295,
0.0111057637,
0.01502157,
-0.008497742,
-0.0587093532,
0.0071244091,
-0.0042715818,
0.0151430806,
0.0033285422,
0.0240736734,
0.0187074635,
0.0108083878,
-0.0174160935,
-0.0040976689,
-0.0255125538,
-0.0099169267,
0.0301083829,
-0.0273055471,
0.0208920129,
-0.007689097,
-0.0013308423,
0.0158009566,
0.0499142408,
0.0505535565,
-0.0195415821,
-0.0385375433,
0.0384101942,
-0.0121207032,
-0.0053840103,
0.0205936022,
-0.0388913676,
0.0479480326,
0.0478564911,
-0.0558624975,
-0.0058817528,
0.0082469508,
2.768e-7,
0.0280528869,
0.0424298197,
0.0315217339,
0.010478179,
0.028985979,
0.0232757423,
0.002218446,
0.0248972848,
0.005654755,
-0.0159344617,
0.0092655458,
0.014734257,
0.0382726267,
0.0086070225,
-0.0754644871,
-0.0016856876,
-0.0748221949,
-0.0075681838,
-0.017002508,
-0.0284897815,
0.0218366534,
0.0765907913,
-0.0283304434,
-0.0178771522,
-0.0118135288,
-0.0727848411,
0.0587971322,
-0.0422421768,
-0.0064763627,
0.0130638508,
0.0608380698,
0.0216072928,
0.0005576101,
-0.0353282504,
-0.0233724695,
0.0177817773,
0.0262697786,
0.0549576916,
0.0093056085,
0.0017076622,
0.0209434126,
-0.0419645868,
-0.0083481241,
-0.057199236,
0.0649288744,
0.0078498432,
0.0038802114,
0.0110605704,
-0.0247036107,
-0.0195667259,
0.0112672495,
-0.0479658246,
-0.0040828465,
0.0172912627,
-0.0118170111,
0.0334703662,
-0.0070412192,
-0.0839828327,
-0.0310296305,
-0.0356735326,
-0.0296391845,
-0.0249338187,
-0.0548308119,
0.0265724249,
0.0334965289,
-0.0335182659,
0.0258759353,
2.519569515e-34,
0.0328832194,
-0.0001996052,
0.0069700223,
0.0142778261,
0.0138507001,
0.0037931635,
-0.0475200266,
0.0334630497,
-0.0165065397,
-0.1013380289,
-0.009708303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20499v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20499v2 | Leveraging Word Guessing Games to Assess the Intelligence of Large Language Models | 2023-10-31T14:37:42 | 2023-11-06T02:27:34 | Tian Liang, Zhiwei He, Jen-tse Huang, Wenxuan Wang, Wenxiang Jiao, Rui Wang, Yujiu Yang, Zhaopeng Tu, Shuming Shi, Xing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The automatic evaluation of LLM-based agent intelligence is critical in
developing advanced LLM-based agents. Although considerable effort has been
devoted to developing human-annotated evaluation datasets, such as AlpacaEval,
existing techniques are costly, time-consuming, and lack adaptability. In this
paper, inspired by the popular language game ``Who is Spy'', we propose to use
the word guessing game to assess the intelligence performance of LLMs. Given a
word, the LLM is asked to describe the word and determine its identity (spy or
not) based on its and other players' descriptions. Ideally, an advanced agent
should possess the ability to accurately describe a given word using an
aggressive description while concurrently maximizing confusion in the
conservative description, enhancing its participation in the game. To this end,
we first develop DEEP to evaluate LLMs' expression and disguising abilities.
DEEP requires LLM to describe a word in aggressive and conservative modes. We
then introduce SpyGame, an interactive multi-agent framework designed to assess
LLMs' intelligence through participation in a competitive language-based board
game. Incorporating multi-agent interaction, SpyGame requires the target LLM to
possess linguistic skills and strategic thinking, providing a more
comprehensive evaluation of LLMs' human-like cognitive abilities and
adaptability in complex communication situations. The proposed evaluation
framework is very easy to implement. We collected words from multiple sources,
domains, and languages and used the proposed evaluation framework to conduct
experiments. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the proposed DEEP and
SpyGame effectively evaluate the capabilities of various LLMs, capturing their
ability to adapt to novel situations and engage in strategic communication. | [
0.0633466393,
0.018914707,
-0.0482719094,
0.0738102347,
-0.0461322255,
-0.0061386046,
0.0281722546,
0.0178105049,
0.0212012641,
-0.034097895,
-0.0437162295,
-0.0499897152,
-0.0123773878,
0.0475686342,
0.046439223,
0.0267638694,
0.0435049795,
-0.0315459892,
0.0531459898,
-0.0131539609,
-0.0225768201,
-0.0065044756,
-0.0080381921,
0.0305680409,
-0.0054117679,
0.0023712087,
-0.0100470381,
-0.0198874697,
0.008673395,
-0.0090921354,
0.0016889507,
0.0222866163,
0.0251192357,
0.0493496768,
0.0000018538,
-0.0631692111,
-0.035492219,
-0.0408853926,
-0.02669896,
-0.0358541831,
0.0872655883,
0.0335899629,
-0.0067350231,
0.002635933,
-0.0884199217,
0.0292968377,
0.0281129926,
-0.0132015888,
0.0658039823,
0.0685123354,
0.0152223753,
-0.0116347671,
0.0052167317,
-0.0204675607,
0.0172423683,
-0.0948580652,
0.0114093162,
-0.0294961613,
-0.0160005949,
-0.0085959472,
0.0159964189,
0.0173613951,
-0.025283806,
-0.0065662502,
-0.0424843244,
0.0051921518,
0.0194911044,
0.0091890655,
-0.0082771135,
0.0650303513,
-0.0091398684,
0.0277991388,
-0.0076389806,
0.0155086666,
0.0318487622,
0.0351184756,
0.0005056379,
0.0187034812,
0.0318017229,
-0.0179273263,
0.0422656201,
0.0269235298,
0.026620036,
0.0283580683,
-0.0236039162,
0.0911313072,
-0.0299563594,
-0.0171698928,
-0.0040166606,
-0.0432021394,
-0.0122618498,
-0.0747359693,
-0.0108502945,
0.0466219336,
-0.0600154623,
0.050042171,
-0.0421256758,
-0.0203012526,
0.0166461319,
-0.0501712039,
0.0384265818,
-0.0012235679,
0.0341361538,
0.0734745488,
-0.007631721,
0.0656875148,
0.020776052,
0.0406198986,
-0.0266139153,
-0.0393664576,
-0.0287980214,
-0.043657288,
-0.0093940161,
0.0497711189,
0.0184420832,
-0.0302906185,
-0.0327518471,
0.029294258,
-0.0526345409,
0.0495472625,
-0.0220037866,
0.025353428,
-0.0094200745,
-0.0278436989,
-0.0969293341,
-0.0478093214,
-0.0369750001,
0.0250436794,
-0.0093033863,
-0.0648110062,
0.0043385229,
0.0095471526,
-0.0240716655,
-0.0297977403,
0.0399153791,
0.1096054018,
0.0012040201,
-0.0492612273,
-0.0207677763,
-0.0358786061,
0.0320491865,
-0.0674000233,
0.0157240741,
-0.055777546,
0.0291973744,
-0.0162250325,
-0.0130165536,
-0.0797714517,
0.0146255251,
0.0061251232,
-0.0109582469,
0.1030583084,
-0.0176227801,
0.0020269938,
0.0288759824,
0.0214630924,
-0.0346306302,
0.0758075118,
0.0432094745,
0.0405442454,
0.0506024994,
0.0100299511,
0.0538967662,
0.0567134619,
-0.0054838005,
0.0114001418,
0.0060957023,
-0.000125118,
-0.0248930231,
0.0284145605,
-0.013897717,
0.0311592966,
0.0084345713,
-0.048046086,
0.0663249269,
0.0770607591,
-0.0179571062,
0.0168053303,
0.0558208413,
0.0338976197,
-0.0146108679,
-0.0122402217,
-0.0228068661,
0.0476382039,
-0.0673409849,
-0.0229132753,
-0.0460168533,
0.0168008991,
-0.0095045902,
-0.0559226386,
-0.0120091112,
0.0034183608,
0.0679163486,
0.036994487,
0.0295930039,
-0.0199608132,
-0.0571329892,
0.0624733195,
0.0022457172,
-0.0160301086,
-0.0136556718,
-0.099803187,
0.0109388512,
0.0732171237,
0.0506971851,
-0.0341899842,
-0.0451714993,
-0.0116519257,
-0.0053993957,
0.0712282583,
0.0247283354,
-0.014742231,
-0.0014957326,
-0.0198862646,
-0.0191223063,
-0.0365781821,
0.0125208208,
0.0528407581,
-0.0000447922,
0.001552267,
0.009429574,
-0.0347957835,
0.0008061489,
0.0407397188,
-0.0186844468,
-0.0628136173,
-0.0247185715,
0.0187809318,
0.0610473193,
0.0077551631,
-0.0139156487,
0.0216764342,
0.0360017903,
-0.0171123687,
-0.0328248702,
-0.0185884405,
0.0250531342,
0.0227262173,
0.0363509953,
-0.0405090414,
0.0134816226,
0.0435488857,
-0.0113364225,
-0.0079606418,
0.0520368665,
-0.0576869436,
0.0273213238,
-0.0355399586,
0.0238434933,
-0.0477617197,
0.037854407,
-0.0228586774,
0.0753202587,
-0.0134639516,
-0.0003158274,
0.0238318201,
0.0062334365,
0.0128296297,
-0.0208379645,
-0.0104019763,
0.0095039103,
0.0014617352,
0.0004832411,
0.0249466412,
0.0126435189,
-0.0344026908,
-0.0662623048,
-0.0439520292,
0.0026142495,
0.0040166308,
0.0172484387,
0.0065702968,
-0.033804398,
-0.0073463395,
0.0264176577,
-0.0406642035,
0.0007892153,
0.0022243699,
0.0154482005,
0.0315589979,
0.0055852989,
-0.0526554063,
-0.0245987233,
0.0075287465,
-0.0161091909,
0.038001094,
0.0106361872,
-0.0103116808,
-0.0169669725,
0.0007232829,
-0.0635059252,
0.0315031148,
-0.04273054,
-0.0687334836,
0.0373614021,
-0.0108857844,
-0.0569675788,
0.0670716241,
0.034421891,
0.0433267578,
0.0458361693,
-0.0238389913,
-0.0474055633,
0.0319198556,
-0.002246083,
-0.0075480877,
-0.0720621869,
-0.0470444337,
-0.0005273931,
0.0649304762,
-0.0019514029,
0.0088391211,
-0.0200514141,
0.0679057091,
0.0224247444,
-0.051724039,
-0.025824938,
-0.0184385739,
-0.0105173504,
0.04569925,
-0.012811346,
-0.0092530763,
0.1039469317,
-0.0252621118,
-0.0037760972,
-0.0027421678,
-0.0247806814,
-0.0284847543,
0.0806408748,
-0.0229769815,
-0.0068156067,
-0.0427562371,
-0.013517593,
-0.0817383304,
-0.0439347625,
0.0413192958,
-0.0568147153,
0.0109653827,
-0.0541534014,
-0.0133017404,
0.026679974,
0.0028099907,
-0.0576161817,
-0.017544914,
-0.0639969707,
0.0242507327,
0.0657872707,
-0.0225829445,
-0.0824709535,
0.0052760281,
0.0311682895,
-0.0424394608,
0.0178166367,
-0.0089721959,
-0.0275365841,
-0.0286121238,
0.0559393317,
0.0426221602,
0.0305567998,
-0.0107977781,
0.0425666422,
0.0150121581,
-0.0491255708,
-0.0344718397,
-0.0004942519,
-0.0038368087,
0.0364696607,
-0.0293725971,
-0.0107342647,
0.0147542562,
0.0018549813,
-0.0426743142,
0.0250615012,
0.1119999662,
0.0408200733,
-0.0134121208,
0.01428161,
0.0013474628,
-0.0171931889,
0.0398098119,
0.0314886346,
-0.0645809397,
-0.0373883247,
-0.0111526409,
-0.0142707191,
-0.0373534597,
-0.0576394461,
-0.0349774323,
-0.1152529046,
0.000659407,
-0.0038205592,
-0.0192480329,
0.0081908051,
0.0011217563,
-0.0053216112,
-0.0126255369,
0.0129725151,
-0.0108881323,
0.0336862542,
-0.022243876,
-0.03217021,
-0.0501616597,
-0.0038021605,
0.0360867269,
-0.0292875189,
0.0449838117,
0.0658538863,
0.0287401527,
-0.0347795933,
-0.0679502711,
0.0281446092,
0.0121643841,
0.0158701167,
0.0001441926,
0.0526003242,
-0.0452117696,
0.0051619569,
0.0195407365,
-0.0148891611,
-0.0042340867,
0.0098420428,
0.0136609906,
0.0369881503,
-0.0156719442,
-0.0207307041,
0.0096834349,
0.0113419145,
0.0297014061,
0.0735683292,
-0.0086369039,
-0.035031952,
-0.0187806841,
-0.0315381512,
-0.0085661039,
-0.0417464487,
-0.0575298816,
0.0166929737,
0.0201625712,
-0.0115270186,
-0.0518167801,
-0.067795299,
0.0274068806,
-0.007341316,
0.0029254493,
0.0360418335,
-0.0360016525,
0.041812636,
-0.0372269526,
-0.0197237302,
0.0007128625,
0.0525528602,
0.0005291203,
-0.0444595926,
0.0127323475,
-0.0599109605,
-0.0109915417,
0.0493031703,
-0.0485034883,
-0.0335538164,
0.0056509273,
0.0454944111,
0.0234923419,
0.0093863364,
-0.0368421078,
-0.0591873527,
0.0606288835,
-0.0039364132,
-0.031647563,
0.0022625686,
0.0223125089,
0.0378634445,
0.0102176517,
0.0529633127,
-0.0666506737,
-0.0061309258,
0.0325438976,
0.0259650871,
-0.0662064552,
-0.0446035787,
0.0218102448,
0.0135253025,
0.004877869,
-0.0305171981,
-0.0051990855,
0.0100914333,
0.001972809,
-0.0108669568,
-0.0382200144,
-0.0128541915,
-0.0201102439,
-0.0031209604,
-0.0230630208,
0.0380279832,
0.0198557824,
-0.0388804898,
-0.0245197527,
0.0128697576,
0.0269649345,
0.0142917214,
0.0034448667,
-0.013739408,
0.0408558697,
0.0048328415,
0.0449777916,
-0.0152254775,
0.035401646,
0.0425092988,
0.0237706006,
0.0014309771,
-0.0181714036,
-0.0288694594,
0.036826238,
-0.0289790649,
-0.0396259837,
0.0316979662,
0.0839632377,
0.0637630001,
0.0390560776,
-0.0076990183,
-0.0373561569,
0.0249452796,
0.0171935372,
-0.0327708125,
-0.0018852182,
-0.0684036389,
0.0407660902,
0.0344450176,
-0.0159890354,
-0.0022495508,
0.0641158074,
0.006951652,
0.034421932,
-0.0248588193,
-0.0204617567,
-0.0454715528,
-0.0136176543,
0.0180325881,
0.0585744977,
-0.0176440887,
0.0320840515,
-0.0733515397,
-0.061361257,
0.0207031164,
0.0308372211,
0.0126440721,
-0.0049986281,
0.0232428182,
0.0735683665,
-0.0035449201,
-0.0156566706,
-0.0701805651,
0.0082041463,
-0.0367916785,
-0.0252615623,
0.0029706222,
-5.894986253e-33,
-0.0256805904,
-0.071311295,
0.051361084,
0.018623421,
0.0033713938,
-0.0017364344,
-0.0214832891,
0.0253541674,
-0.0481670052,
0.0044564577,
-0.016492432,
0.0101284645,
0.0086423391,
-0.0237538926,
-0.025800081,
-0.0285802707,
-0.0183471609,
0.0187179688,
-0.0197229497,
-0.0249138009,
0.0208276343,
0.0161212925,
0.0574982017,
-0.0626096651,
0.0466095544,
-0.0049968031,
-0.041912239,
0.0528650992,
-0.012010742,
0.0447272025,
-0.0160946641,
0.0210694559,
0.0135306884,
-0.023279056,
0.0077392673,
0.0019496329,
0.0233210009,
-0.0291466136,
0.0309824143,
-0.0006828016,
-0.0049507869,
-0.0627993718,
0.0117398053,
-0.0063880216,
-0.0429907069,
0.0154510178,
0.0486682318,
-0.030027261,
0.0217608046,
-0.0043274197,
-0.0401462987,
0.0159211755,
-0.0300637558,
-0.0138820112,
0.0015311504,
-0.0226356462,
0.0111671221,
-0.0115160979,
-0.0728468671,
0.0527428426,
0.0091712847,
0.0018265254,
0.082571499,
0.0502743311,
0.0131316138,
0.0722482353,
0.0293181166,
0.0422524102,
-0.0194299985,
-0.0269203819,
0.0381802917,
0.063876994,
0.063748613,
0.0599897131,
-0.0076542357,
-0.0280050263,
-0.0179590099,
0.0286223516,
0.0690038875,
0.0355498604,
0.0271978527,
-0.0076703914,
-0.0408266596,
0.0062410543,
-0.0338308439,
0.0342674814,
-0.0364804566,
-0.04872448,
0.0102855433,
-0.0067557162,
-0.0067997249,
-0.0242274273,
0.0260356963,
-0.0561348721,
0.0160635635,
-0.0125106638,
-0.000780869,
0.0199202765,
0.0194611475,
0.0159178115,
0.0056311502,
-0.0290182848,
-0.0023772381,
0.0105803367,
0.0368650742,
-0.0060959617,
-0.0074602528,
0.0216740835,
-0.0019741405,
-0.0111343535,
-0.0296279434,
0.0144266505,
0.0082950769,
-0.0524417125,
-0.0064672632,
-0.0196472201,
-0.03112779,
-0.047315307,
0.0050115264,
-0.0294480585,
0.0078551406,
0.0336621813,
-0.0366465114,
0.0164316949,
-0.06558007,
0.0017165988,
-0.0266067628,
0.0248279721,
-0.0068684821,
-0.0175056215,
-0.0057936618,
-0.0253621042,
2.679e-7,
0.0113128703,
0.0592877381,
-0.0431058854,
0.0533489101,
-0.0135695357,
0.0421160012,
-0.028348526,
0.0187051035,
-0.0189116765,
-0.0472642779,
0.0257723443,
0.0404387526,
0.060475111,
0.0275125951,
-0.0919904187,
-0.0130658625,
-0.0144197084,
0.0298332497,
-0.0383270979,
0.0050851828,
0.0392168015,
0.0815605447,
0.0305616092,
-0.0096591869,
-0.0463318564,
-0.105555132,
0.00773544,
-0.0519397631,
-0.0085215559,
0.0361452661,
0.0360220037,
0.0209231842,
-0.0131921554,
0.0386236757,
0.0011984841,
0.0365602486,
0.0007074586,
0.0230661668,
-0.0093472423,
-0.0385986082,
-0.0333313644,
-0.0456929393,
-0.0051337713,
-0.0324468389,
0.059187647,
-0.0063407407,
-0.0398228727,
-0.0064106025,
-0.0106386654,
-0.0119058872,
0.0057467949,
-0.0440092236,
-0.0285903253,
0.0079457639,
0.0053871139,
-0.0355106592,
0.0072364141,
-0.0519203842,
0.0113208285,
-0.0130723678,
-0.0392245874,
-0.0505318753,
-0.0106827589,
-0.0008202153,
0.0248625893,
-0.0052201166,
0.0407344401,
2.026858073e-34,
0.0239192639,
0.0059955125,
-0.0289766863,
0.0230902936,
0.0899577737,
0.0231961086,
-0.0173557252,
0.0255948063,
0.0343135819,
-0.0607828014,
-0.0031410477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20479v1 | Multi-User MultiWOZ: Task-Oriented Dialogues among Multiple Users | 2023-10-31T14:12:07 | 2023-10-31T14:12:07 | Yohan Jo, Xinyan Zhao, Arijit Biswas, Nikoletta Basiou, Vincent Auvray, Nikolaos Malandrakis, Angeliki Metallinou, Alexandros Potamianos | cs.CL | cs.CL | While most task-oriented dialogues assume conversations between the agent and
one user at a time, dialogue systems are increasingly expected to communicate
with multiple users simultaneously who make decisions collaboratively. To
facilitate development of such systems, we release the Multi-User MultiWOZ
dataset: task-oriented dialogues among two users and one agent. To collect this
dataset, each user utterance from MultiWOZ 2.2 was replaced with a small chat
between two users that is semantically and pragmatically consistent with the
original user utterance, thus resulting in the same dialogue state and system
response. These dialogues reflect interesting dynamics of collaborative
decision-making in task-oriented scenarios, e.g., social chatter and
deliberation. Supported by this data, we propose the novel task of multi-user
contextual query rewriting: to rewrite a task-oriented chat between two users
as a concise task-oriented query that retains only task-relevant information
and that is directly consumable by the dialogue system. We demonstrate that in
multi-user dialogues, using predicted rewrites substantially improves dialogue
state tracking without modifying existing dialogue systems that are trained for
single-user dialogues. Further, this method surpasses training a medium-sized
model directly on multi-user dialogues and generalizes to unseen domains. | [
0.0547342114,
0.0435781255,
-0.0133307511,
0.0277164411,
-0.0502491184,
-0.0020236135,
0.0020725296,
-0.0083596716,
-0.00971682,
-0.0418421067,
-0.0630448014,
-0.030464422,
-0.0196066089,
0.0351646543,
0.0131671401,
-0.0403587781,
0.0384725183,
0.021526657,
0.0367714986,
0.0153565975,
0.0547478907,
0.0112582305,
-0.0168240536,
0.0602960922,
-0.0187432971,
0.0004197475,
-0.0429765545,
0.0223027375,
0.0006684851,
0.0146310432,
0.0334117971,
0.0666372031,
0.0408384353,
0.0165534522,
0.000001814,
-0.0655683503,
-0.0450247787,
-0.0297545623,
-0.0292167291,
-0.0240451042,
0.0352084823,
0.0202339385,
-0.0087054241,
0.0141051076,
-0.062143039,
0.0419980995,
0.0094448859,
0.0772057101,
0.0677588582,
0.092622675,
-0.0299648233,
-0.0167507883,
-0.0209036693,
-0.0306937397,
-0.0083583435,
-0.0903107151,
0.0027995468,
0.011956336,
-0.0289134067,
0.0044637164,
0.0137991654,
-0.016873911,
-0.0033960678,
-0.0599364527,
-0.0260640085,
-0.01191922,
-0.0209769178,
-0.0320942663,
-0.0168046206,
0.1022330523,
0.0330065042,
0.0271950476,
0.0255560186,
0.0092960084,
-0.0057707038,
0.0027566419,
-0.0375047959,
-0.032916788,
-0.0184930731,
-0.006073337,
-0.0200612117,
0.0395853147,
-0.0076535456,
0.0037831909,
-0.0262563806,
0.0547835529,
-0.0193140358,
-0.0213583708,
-0.0235393643,
-0.0028486706,
0.0212595575,
-0.0599511452,
0.0102871461,
0.016386861,
-0.1061836854,
0.0175741594,
-0.0628985912,
-0.0075912424,
0.0035703864,
-0.0686173216,
0.0364843048,
0.0240136664,
0.0090964679,
0.0681349933,
0.0324084237,
0.0139200632,
0.0019693903,
0.0047443816,
-0.0129976049,
-0.0296383128,
-0.0543728694,
0.0136964992,
-0.0831500888,
0.0350029022,
-0.0707654878,
-0.0281748604,
-0.034245465,
0.0560723916,
-0.0183750242,
-0.0152231511,
0.0042447001,
0.0445564538,
-0.0411701873,
-0.0211387407,
-0.0217780843,
0.0479203314,
-0.015534983,
0.027100116,
0.022716945,
-0.043799255,
-0.0049893344,
0.0270556323,
0.0432490557,
-0.0261371583,
-0.0387686379,
0.052805122,
-0.042633459,
-0.0189792719,
0.0077332775,
-0.0504349098,
-0.0336651765,
-0.0349279307,
-0.0456308387,
-0.0014082408,
0.0800986066,
-0.0312997214,
-0.0203024577,
-0.0242716502,
0.0045338646,
0.0267046411,
0.0112669989,
0.0424240157,
0.0261209942,
-0.0083805621,
0.0186182931,
0.03253261,
-0.0310324896,
0.065158315,
0.0435700454,
0.0166280549,
0.0555541068,
0.0196815357,
0.0174273234,
-0.0161290802,
0.0170052238,
0.0096481079,
0.0319781639,
0.0657206625,
-0.0283057503,
0.0359774046,
0.0119350618,
0.0611823946,
-0.0647038221,
-0.0488143377,
0.0664887354,
0.0343195572,
0.0110030491,
-0.0019950827,
0.0245650355,
0.0383570082,
-0.0251600612,
0.0431589186,
-0.0050544119,
0.0390523076,
0.0129363863,
-0.0375894308,
0.0494764075,
-0.0054498785,
-0.0421383865,
-0.0513527803,
0.0611040555,
0.0076370477,
0.0290709659,
-0.0059038014,
0.0096859131,
0.0146123106,
-0.0796096325,
0.0266014673,
0.0027495616,
-0.059009105,
-0.0384850539,
-0.0513146035,
0.0116848787,
0.0794800967,
0.0406210236,
-0.0146123301,
-0.0632009208,
-0.0416474454,
0.0294947773,
-0.0132672302,
0.0699189007,
-0.0400498062,
0.0689832568,
-0.0174416415,
-0.0230263676,
0.0045797476,
-0.0085460832,
0.0222702734,
0.0340879783,
-0.0418246351,
0.0189725515,
0.039039623,
0.0156134441,
-0.0089513231,
0.0126881329,
0.017788671,
0.0178896189,
0.0209556408,
0.063156113,
0.0180420075,
0.0084518446,
-0.0085802134,
0.0221666452,
0.0056192107,
-0.0335332341,
0.0332385264,
-0.0642150789,
-0.0665856153,
0.0238977596,
0.0119220093,
-0.0092411051,
0.0267260876,
-0.0191221964,
-0.051462274,
0.0291609522,
-0.0168162379,
0.0121166576,
-0.0498372503,
-0.0095163984,
0.0375020094,
-0.0030892384,
-0.0333350077,
-0.0080061918,
0.0199654251,
-0.0332875811,
0.0148344729,
-0.0257469136,
0.0029183328,
-0.0466519855,
0.0149125205,
0.0075421501,
0.0051352838,
0.0083371857,
0.0141266612,
-0.0015501541,
-0.0529734679,
-0.022695655,
-0.1045149192,
-0.0178417135,
-0.0396904871,
-0.008872903,
0.0079732975,
0.0188509766,
0.0108504938,
-0.0195846781,
-0.045907937,
-0.0024325787,
0.0508714058,
0.0114131877,
0.0551232398,
0.0439751185,
-0.0217508115,
-0.0525477231,
0.0137756187,
-0.0045222421,
0.0196628198,
-0.0026413742,
-0.0424843617,
-0.0259217415,
0.003226625,
-0.043535471,
0.0355222747,
-0.0386176854,
0.0022504227,
0.0205437634,
-0.0057018427,
0.0552014858,
0.0408762693,
0.0245411359,
0.0800657943,
-0.0268862117,
-0.0454882979,
-0.0594229028,
0.0501964688,
-0.0393386967,
0.0052267006,
-0.0562361218,
-0.0079685207,
0.0517261103,
0.0208572354,
0.0093973409,
0.0087039052,
-0.0231802817,
-0.0035585053,
0.0108489851,
-0.0465038009,
-0.0018340955,
-0.0461651832,
-0.0143919028,
0.00465771,
-0.0144720972,
-0.0264332481,
0.0880962089,
0.0029219124,
-0.03557612,
-0.0466339216,
-0.0427215248,
-0.0458270386,
0.0656146333,
-0.0384404622,
0.0367480367,
0.0445273705,
-0.0309785493,
-0.0446803197,
-0.0404263437,
0.0362971164,
-0.0408563726,
0.0416137837,
-0.0547116883,
0.0372859724,
-0.0166259445,
-0.0581273846,
-0.0083385641,
-0.0574890971,
-0.0126035744,
-0.0121480152,
0.0294369888,
-0.036133159,
-0.0231537297,
0.0244600382,
0.0137820169,
0.0157893058,
0.0178322885,
-0.0159770772,
-0.0251663588,
0.0255817566,
0.0501618013,
0.0229016598,
-0.0466951877,
-0.0480638035,
0.0398394279,
0.0827070549,
0.0600422733,
-0.0622157939,
0.0121491533,
-0.059931457,
0.0125313085,
-0.0080982903,
-0.0134725394,
-0.0076999436,
0.0803989992,
-0.0326205008,
0.0338933282,
0.0933746994,
0.0332835056,
-0.0501900874,
-0.027495347,
-0.0240266714,
0.0171673726,
-0.0189537257,
0.0218722131,
-0.0828201473,
-0.0531727485,
-0.011658418,
-0.0279688928,
-0.0024479043,
-0.0510058179,
-0.013375015,
-0.042012997,
0.0176418982,
-0.0127572035,
-0.0022262726,
0.0024209947,
-0.00090585,
0.0225171093,
-0.0036788876,
0.0132570295,
0.0198195055,
0.0336860493,
-0.0339751951,
0.0151344314,
-0.0027457834,
0.0257786848,
0.0357072204,
-0.0147565641,
0.0602427982,
0.0347605571,
0.0875428692,
0.0595861152,
0.0204239208,
0.0070285643,
0.0152187562,
0.0133635541,
-0.0006665931,
0.037264131,
-0.0250159204,
0.0215452984,
-0.0236195121,
0.0114922682,
-0.0133645488,
0.0011573307,
0.0033481116,
-0.0055320347,
-0.066561684,
0.0221756659,
0.010507823,
0.0430662334,
0.0455135405,
0.0539912283,
0.0283272248,
-0.0257298294,
-0.0386448801,
-0.0097070476,
-0.0138130486,
-0.0640123934,
0.0101890797,
-0.0846780166,
-0.0122762918,
0.0213690568,
-0.0622383021,
-0.0568662696,
0.0370825119,
0.0526998416,
-0.0284312908,
0.0195473544,
0.0439386889,
0.008368725,
-0.0086878743,
-0.0199690387,
-0.0498696156,
0.0541993603,
-0.0294149593,
-0.0085397838,
0.0299557019,
0.0055086664,
-0.001913289,
0.0453915559,
-0.0641516149,
-0.063124463,
-0.0546512678,
0.06283319,
0.0247131474,
0.011063545,
-0.0034955957,
0.0029562097,
-0.0507430844,
-0.0046997583,
-0.0514198169,
0.0047048563,
0.0613417327,
0.0757711977,
-0.0116798319,
0.0630028471,
0.0099187344,
0.0082101282,
-0.0431017801,
0.0174241289,
-0.0802895799,
-0.1103814989,
-0.0089837806,
-0.0235528406,
0.0233523753,
0.0461393371,
-0.0148913534,
-0.0173612814,
0.0596182421,
-0.0344263539,
-0.012232746,
-0.0502247512,
0.0215328857,
-0.0305445716,
-0.027038388,
0.0304358583,
0.0093983822,
-0.0147660682,
0.0048832051,
-0.0240637548,
-0.0202590115,
0.0061310497,
-0.0410085246,
0.0427199267,
0.0133292982,
0.0022670871,
0.0274904445,
0.0519824736,
0.0267477948,
0.0123918233,
0.0424321108,
0.0196046531,
-0.0257542729,
-0.004022724,
0.040020857,
-0.0930932537,
-0.0277081858,
0.0096140588,
0.0281794537,
0.0035915528,
0.0539129041,
0.0623860247,
-0.0061786575,
0.0175244883,
-0.0196916666,
0.084077768,
-0.0052340478,
-0.0250140224,
-0.0002915674,
0.0185772311,
-0.0230213404,
0.0351058021,
0.120080471,
0.0054481281,
0.0141534964,
-0.007377937,
-0.0320978649,
-0.0591471456,
-0.0264640879,
0.0177519713,
0.0530897006,
-0.0054101618,
-0.0160218589,
-0.0391778909,
0.0048784213,
0.0247776508,
-0.0106358603,
-0.0041691442,
-0.0424983986,
0.0207916144,
0.0596937835,
0.0068077561,
-0.0047722314,
-0.0414843336,
-0.0099483309,
0.0000377094,
-0.011644572,
-0.0134812873,
-5.571954528e-33,
-0.0208920613,
-0.0327306092,
0.0526319332,
-0.012444417,
-0.0350893773,
-0.0151905483,
-0.0468513407,
-0.0032224224,
-0.033781521,
0.0053769685,
-0.0236703381,
0.0449864306,
0.0306186918,
0.0234857202,
-0.0201681461,
-0.0252496991,
0.050030522,
0.0004623633,
0.0099859536,
0.050037574,
0.0492540486,
0.0199808571,
0.0226876494,
-0.0569122583,
0.0230221096,
0.0214427337,
-0.0243487302,
0.0356108807,
0.0002642446,
0.0214596987,
0.0066966112,
0.0234255772,
0.0051577459,
-0.0241752788,
-0.0186047852,
0.0327013023,
-0.0284016095,
0.0055915494,
0.0138733154,
-0.0172869712,
-0.0428044051,
0.0044629253,
0.0087760882,
0.0128979767,
0.0289436355,
0.0188260656,
-0.004979149,
0.004606422,
-0.0252616312,
0.0022323981,
-0.0589725673,
0.0185543671,
-0.0321950838,
-0.0737970322,
-0.0241897758,
0.0653583035,
0.023798449,
-0.0360533707,
-0.0428875759,
0.0308106113,
-0.0623657629,
-0.0016136342,
-0.0242932122,
0.0168355256,
-0.0000398097,
0.0608379394,
0.0370664895,
0.0619123764,
-0.0224622544,
-0.0339846462,
-0.0613381378,
0.0770163983,
0.007145246,
0.0441441499,
-0.0445058309,
-0.013218292,
-0.0414904207,
0.0435454249,
0.0609746389,
0.0048549795,
0.0089732204,
0.050440155,
-0.0439625792,
-0.0192705095,
0.0258453004,
0.045389019,
-0.0112276589,
-0.0186667182,
0.0116777364,
0.0444027744,
0.0040056403,
0.0156042343,
0.0338802449,
-0.0377029367,
-0.0080828611,
0.0073565254,
-0.0272182338,
-0.0007721235,
-0.0095330104,
-0.0183147285,
-0.0287689026,
-0.0093516381,
0.0476447493,
0.0250254087,
-0.0056245369,
-0.0152848288,
0.0204766393,
0.0049866699,
-0.0242149178,
-0.024676498,
-0.0364831127,
0.0364217572,
-0.0421266332,
0.041670572,
0.0143519966,
0.014072556,
-0.0356502831,
0.0591223389,
-0.01427982,
-0.012680456,
-0.0388785899,
-0.0431683213,
0.0131656192,
0.011247186,
-0.0050201165,
-0.0150643876,
-0.0132746007,
-0.0037032138,
0.0213014968,
0.0005758677,
-0.0166385937,
-0.0308641661,
2.618e-7,
0.014047415,
0.0238836538,
0.0375512466,
0.0026784374,
0.0119987484,
0.0773645192,
0.0002907675,
0.0628736764,
0.0057984004,
-0.0142688369,
0.0500357337,
0.0193278231,
0.045737762,
0.0328831896,
-0.1100842059,
-0.0751023367,
-0.0381762981,
-0.0479920059,
-0.0365314409,
-0.0065769432,
0.0533136316,
0.0395579115,
0.0401506163,
-0.0056132129,
0.0056178411,
-0.0288993828,
0.0419895351,
-0.0395047069,
-0.040365614,
0.0140338978,
0.0326594524,
-0.0580216795,
0.0013812064,
-0.0032190729,
-0.0158525538,
0.0157161858,
0.0079189651,
0.082048744,
-0.0005453569,
-0.0455125943,
-0.0232426431,
0.0148779955,
-0.0138477515,
0.0034915868,
0.0337170325,
-0.0570132695,
-0.025221711,
0.0118160853,
0.0178834386,
-0.0207922924,
0.0194447264,
0.0047782403,
-0.016616093,
0.0083032269,
0.0089042392,
0.0116041433,
0.0132661117,
-0.092200458,
0.0127720926,
-0.0270987414,
-0.0556592532,
-0.0466341637,
-0.0329502858,
-0.022499932,
0.01829453,
-0.0111595029,
-0.0051976251,
1.978300514e-34,
0.050097771,
0.0177307427,
-0.012793486,
0.0362781063,
0.0499935448,
0.0003866201,
-0.0481376648,
-0.0365866311,
0.0428983346,
-0.0482899174,
-0.0218392015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20470v1 | Representativeness as a Forgotten Lesson for Multilingual and Code-switched Data Collection and Preparation | 2023-10-31T14:04:07 | 2023-10-31T14:04:07 | A. Seza Doğruöz, Sunayana Sitaram, Zheng-Xin Yong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingualism is widespread around the world and code-switching (CSW) is a
common practice among different language pairs/tuples across locations and
regions. However, there is still not much progress in building successful CSW
systems, despite the recent advances in Massive Multilingual Language Models
(MMLMs). We investigate the reasons behind this setback through a critical
study about the existing CSW data sets (68) across language pairs in terms of
the collection and preparation (e.g. transcription and annotation) stages. This
in-depth analysis reveals that \textbf{a)} most CSW data involves English
ignoring other language pairs/tuples \textbf{b)} there are flaws in terms of
representativeness in data collection and preparation stages due to ignoring
the location based, socio-demographic and register variation in CSW. In
addition, lack of clarity on the data selection and filtering stages shadow the
representativeness of CSW data sets. We conclude by providing a short
check-list to improve the representativeness for forthcoming studies involving
CSW data collection and preparation. | [
0.0160658304,
0.0561566129,
-0.0286100917,
-0.0004530332,
-0.0474651828,
0.0335183218,
0.0448420271,
-0.0294494145,
-0.0316270888,
-0.0202599112,
-0.0430936739,
-0.0443018861,
0.061635606,
-0.0256247669,
0.0548834875,
0.0201619789,
0.0267082173,
-0.033469405,
-0.040563561,
-0.0127209956,
0.0100748409,
0.0472742841,
0.0208513476,
0.0491691008,
-0.0296572577,
0.0032311345,
0.028281929,
0.0114420103,
0.0162072405,
-0.0227794107,
0.0006046862,
0.0418693684,
-0.006886695,
0.0787842125,
0.0000019906,
-0.0261804406,
-0.0290724635,
0.0190302934,
-0.0227388237,
0.0441994369,
0.0232921168,
-0.030486349,
-0.0125712212,
0.0195366219,
0.0033423838,
-0.0199740138,
0.0736488253,
-0.0759268254,
0.0134069128,
0.013582442,
-0.0113680186,
-0.0348059982,
-0.0090497006,
-0.0010484811,
-0.0260839481,
0.0020860338,
0.0313947201,
0.0215844475,
0.0293283928,
-0.0238027442,
-0.0221298244,
0.0758196339,
-0.0113753891,
-0.0355502516,
-0.0616669878,
0.0142254774,
-0.0649312735,
-0.0571458638,
0.0553187169,
0.0122412965,
-0.0054053273,
-0.0428109393,
0.0203607865,
-0.0134877115,
-0.0317332372,
-0.0367129929,
-0.0236143377,
0.0309568439,
-0.0239051711,
0.0264348853,
0.0376540646,
0.0204079803,
0.0266522467,
-0.0333862714,
-0.0603760071,
0.0108200423,
0.0210570209,
-0.0225563664,
0.011052913,
0.0354979485,
0.0347225405,
-0.016034469,
0.0090947533,
-0.0430191755,
-0.0348517001,
0.0276012942,
0.0272568576,
-0.0452991053,
0.0193433631,
-0.0268798098,
0.0416313745,
0.028817337,
-0.0411378779,
0.0136967059,
0.0297593344,
-0.0036560057,
0.0006206632,
-0.0014741581,
-0.0241471864,
-0.0359562039,
-0.0176931676,
0.0097741131,
-0.02146977,
-0.0421216637,
-0.0011347117,
0.044171147,
-0.0311616603,
0.0139524164,
0.0205956511,
-0.0083346386,
-0.0051874607,
-0.0834485069,
-0.0085130716,
0.0552652329,
0.0725341067,
0.0471958257,
0.007718388,
-0.009686077,
-0.0224629864,
-0.0815211087,
0.0646705329,
0.0242118165,
-0.0139121125,
-0.0255624671,
-0.0016907831,
-0.0045179049,
-0.0053340415,
0.0090343673,
-0.0244039893,
0.0343371779,
-0.037208423,
-0.0087314248,
0.005181429,
-0.0780213997,
0.0729942694,
0.0607918873,
0.0302138813,
-0.0586896092,
-0.026924083,
-0.0256159715,
-0.0267980676,
0.0010338553,
-0.0417991541,
0.036776077,
0.0321739316,
-0.0429778546,
0.0056152982,
0.0858953744,
0.0439213701,
-0.070544742,
0.0579086281,
-0.0728879049,
-0.0001329006,
0.0814244896,
0.0067360592,
0.0439809449,
-0.0140063567,
0.0021119532,
0.0324714147,
-0.0033397754,
0.0271954685,
0.0471548773,
-0.0268613417,
0.0035459134,
-0.0149439415,
0.0482159443,
0.0068761227,
0.0075701759,
0.0269456729,
0.0314459726,
-0.0120955044,
-0.0374176279,
0.0311958417,
-0.017517399,
0.0008455479,
-0.0129077686,
0.0140697015,
0.0463422649,
-0.0140909497,
0.0080606584,
-0.0189375188,
0.0101594757,
0.0480741188,
0.0112434253,
0.0439937897,
-0.0354525521,
0.0304479059,
0.0160313733,
0.0283918772,
-0.0684882626,
-0.0008623393,
-0.0314325206,
-0.022854764,
0.0321503244,
-0.0288485549,
0.0195747726,
0.007444622,
-0.0111723188,
0.0198570583,
0.0534009524,
0.0403665602,
-0.0237279907,
0.0364064053,
-0.0244191475,
0.0084365699,
0.0296479445,
-0.0354751796,
0.0390167609,
-0.0079658236,
0.0256061256,
-0.0113178566,
-0.0323553421,
-0.0630049109,
0.0126427226,
-0.0727210417,
0.0634808242,
-0.0118872179,
-0.0167473517,
0.0117881251,
0.0334064327,
-0.0480924845,
0.0246500485,
-0.0103349704,
-0.0029742236,
0.0693689734,
0.0325460061,
0.0159594845,
0.0006054008,
0.0246915724,
-0.0329501778,
-0.0121049499,
-0.0065671927,
0.0237349905,
-0.0329757668,
0.0068659089,
-0.0256324504,
0.0476952568,
0.0023963272,
0.0377391465,
-0.0378243625,
-0.0318234116,
-0.0007016119,
-0.0274789669,
-0.0188645329,
0.0312235374,
-0.0020375601,
-0.0330763683,
0.047418613,
-0.0334161483,
-0.0325116925,
0.0467963368,
0.0018140021,
0.0254284926,
0.0336628258,
0.0232571438,
-0.0141919591,
-0.0164169539,
-0.0750531182,
-0.0515694879,
-0.0300030857,
0.0261942837,
-0.002218863,
0.0122911213,
-0.0248619411,
0.0006274098,
-0.0115047889,
-0.0428335816,
-0.0086386334,
0.0433203578,
-0.0202237368,
-0.0531575307,
0.03263871,
-0.034487538,
-0.0125266071,
0.023410039,
0.0236254204,
-0.0208683945,
-0.0758522749,
-0.0465763547,
0.0115533154,
-0.0258587208,
-0.0243241843,
-0.0008515942,
-0.0115536246,
0.0536374934,
0.0019428018,
0.0364427678,
-0.0446114019,
-0.0593618155,
-0.0283442512,
0.0399397314,
-0.018024113,
-0.0711409971,
-0.0460003242,
0.0401961803,
-0.0088349208,
-0.0509273633,
-0.0899946392,
0.0271362513,
0.0563266352,
-0.0118327048,
-0.0315906815,
-0.0492098145,
-0.0500386432,
-0.0737339556,
-0.008868332,
-0.03795081,
0.0090455757,
-0.0225324202,
0.0714035407,
-0.024749469,
-0.0571299829,
-0.0194668863,
-0.0404572301,
-0.0020984723,
-0.0976361185,
-0.001912977,
-0.0052484307,
0.0012722056,
-0.0199602284,
0.0026093167,
0.0065934868,
-0.0263860226,
0.0031341887,
0.0140831135,
-0.0122956717,
-0.008219013,
0.0217826366,
-0.0468832292,
0.0468289964,
-0.0225810222,
-0.0482155792,
0.0112164235,
-0.0160578955,
-0.0125578586,
0.0009973118,
0.0797525644,
-0.01717408,
0.0273759943,
0.0398948789,
0.039484486,
0.0691745058,
0.0128211956,
0.025772687,
0.0127442554,
-0.0237389188,
0.0020819281,
0.0157716442,
0.0177815128,
-0.0140242195,
-0.0120263686,
-0.0051910169,
0.0092862742,
0.0307979248,
0.0411415547,
0.0049599549,
0.064337872,
0.0048858286,
-0.0778580606,
0.0024271018,
0.0498214439,
-0.0275770705,
-0.0104072224,
0.0604678132,
0.0366892219,
-0.0859535411,
0.0012212251,
-0.0512632243,
0.0200045258,
0.0201465804,
0.0172138382,
-0.077959463,
0.0489773713,
0.0080300774,
0.0291001927,
-0.0277380161,
0.0144942533,
-0.0220217649,
-0.0698147342,
0.023325948,
0.0237286352,
-0.0878520533,
0.0011776324,
0.0002421898,
-0.0262636691,
-0.0153168654,
-0.0013864095,
0.0197642576,
-0.0082129696,
-0.0170905404,
0.0667090714,
-0.0912003592,
-0.0408229902,
0.0117003741,
-0.019986419,
0.0454230644,
0.0345953107,
0.036614161,
-0.0571809113,
-0.0310484599,
0.0127355279,
-0.0101253605,
-0.048881758,
-0.0425606929,
-0.0135908388,
0.033543285,
-0.0165148824,
0.0062078489,
0.014677179,
-0.0290492643,
-0.0234643482,
0.0080168955,
0.0715642348,
-0.0143769765,
-0.0054473975,
0.0146257207,
0.0134338634,
0.0100085484,
0.0152337346,
0.0277575925,
-0.0890201554,
0.0337388478,
-0.0399903916,
-0.0019085547,
-0.035318803,
-0.0052933488,
0.0571375117,
-0.0340881459,
-0.0540709458,
-0.0098344609,
-0.0537261777,
0.0620870218,
0.0193111487,
0.0189060494,
0.027373936,
0.0353602469,
-0.041745089,
0.0000195129,
0.0036361748,
-0.0176595114,
0.0303702299,
-0.0589459985,
-0.036012359,
0.0172992088,
-0.008658668,
0.0122548966,
-0.0352560766,
-0.053535834,
-0.0549033396,
0.045901347,
-0.0054599741,
0.0121597024,
-0.0077506187,
0.0353177078,
-0.0431617573,
-0.0322148651,
-0.0296753533,
0.014147195,
0.0060538934,
0.0268351678,
0.01085814,
-0.0103225876,
0.015669411,
-0.0220170934,
-0.0045723179,
0.0076367995,
0.0177343078,
-0.0683789626,
0.0104213506,
-0.0293081179,
0.0155124906,
0.0085191317,
-0.0707189664,
-0.0342587046,
-0.0451039672,
-0.0279154964,
0.0101248408,
0.0045864685,
-0.0161999539,
-0.0356854647,
0.0307921935,
0.0064655291,
-0.0655366555,
0.0346814692,
-0.0417495854,
0.0056926608,
-0.0302188434,
0.101068832,
0.0465650484,
0.0696792081,
0.0342798047,
0.0119382367,
-0.0131275142,
0.042430833,
-0.0044893036,
0.0268875491,
-0.0075581814,
0.0116131799,
-0.0203257874,
-0.0121477218,
0.0125642633,
0.0314665139,
-0.0030792151,
-0.0120670032,
0.0216448568,
-0.0246261414,
0.0689750463,
0.0201656967,
0.1109135449,
0.0227709524,
-0.00117578,
-0.0191051681,
0.0270000882,
0.0087020695,
-0.0063650962,
0.0062625441,
-0.0317138247,
-0.067544654,
0.0020342825,
0.0514252111,
0.0237377062,
-0.0023428435,
-0.0055033751,
0.0056778053,
0.01685559,
-0.0036137833,
0.0373844132,
-0.009310659,
-0.0279953592,
-0.0570326,
-0.0674615428,
-0.0649413168,
0.0124155665,
0.0193204507,
-0.0055515645,
-0.0129251275,
-0.0314329416,
0.0473090485,
0.0089953374,
0.0087678172,
-0.0585953444,
-0.016577119,
0.029248815,
-0.046548292,
0.051399678,
-6.209257239e-33,
0.015925806,
0.0287357699,
0.0156460926,
-0.0054526473,
-0.000708291,
-0.0112410774,
-0.0068237144,
0.0156574398,
-0.0324494578,
-0.0090938956,
-0.0291750021,
-0.0077965683,
0.0226606969,
0.0010977114,
0.0888366774,
0.0498272628,
-0.0028312604,
0.0043676696,
0.0086629568,
-0.0019991978,
0.0448987074,
-0.0091710044,
0.1065414995,
-0.0605646633,
0.0792138427,
-0.0189247169,
0.0271866899,
-0.0256721824,
-0.0007365193,
0.0227599125,
0.0040888218,
0.0362695605,
0.0163829513,
-0.0114463512,
-0.0327082761,
-0.0160791557,
-0.0273540244,
-0.0063749608,
0.0359866992,
0.0425303951,
0.0468058847,
-0.0368002914,
0.0194215737,
-0.0121732224,
-0.0185501706,
0.0239152946,
-0.013387843,
-0.0018601205,
-0.0194909666,
-0.0150293577,
-0.0509949774,
0.0365717076,
-0.0027427266,
0.0425816029,
0.0357637778,
0.0744288117,
-0.0367229246,
-0.0070854505,
-0.1026705727,
0.0444057807,
0.0215651412,
0.0203949399,
0.0639635548,
0.0007479186,
0.0042737643,
-0.0095365364,
0.0434514657,
0.0043757088,
0.0740358829,
-0.006875494,
0.0723346919,
-0.0283951908,
-0.0057806754,
0.0523757264,
0.0267198477,
-0.068702817,
-0.0440816022,
-0.0128897224,
0.0100559695,
-0.0463595167,
0.0141554335,
-0.0001613897,
-0.0113907512,
-0.0825466588,
-0.0427789874,
-0.0475607775,
0.0074611879,
-0.0154069755,
0.0310644731,
-0.0672079474,
0.0021305564,
0.0305680204,
0.0893809944,
-0.0261672679,
-0.0723109394,
-0.018738918,
-0.0074206935,
0.0384599231,
-0.0091191856,
0.0875725374,
-0.0833185092,
-0.0084990561,
0.0146026099,
0.0184702054,
0.0191672835,
0.0390389636,
0.0476792119,
0.0226282887,
-0.0608262606,
-0.0002277379,
-0.0150710922,
0.0273280218,
-0.0233285949,
0.0200842638,
0.0157982986,
0.0044229105,
0.0445257537,
-0.0139865279,
0.0679672956,
-0.0025202462,
-0.0335480347,
-0.0323589332,
-0.0173637029,
0.0187319051,
-0.0056209625,
0.0136989225,
-0.0408115461,
0.0674852505,
0.064042896,
-0.0192958433,
-0.0041447789,
0.0307951216,
2.698e-7,
0.0785324574,
0.0430254154,
-0.0077809622,
-0.023265643,
0.0286841113,
-0.0438482091,
-0.0217681639,
-0.0107439542,
0.0364848264,
0.0640624836,
0.0003834074,
-0.0288751815,
0.091599606,
0.0884436592,
-0.0438376106,
-0.0310258865,
-0.0377288386,
0.0479608141,
-0.0421644486,
0.019309435,
-0.0341643356,
0.0782368481,
-0.0437638797,
-0.0124718081,
-0.0326024741,
0.043156065,
0.0181919634,
-0.072111845,
0.0072194771,
-0.0091305869,
-0.0209917165,
-0.0185597539,
0.0457333587,
-0.0088950712,
-0.0251932889,
0.0152355535,
0.0217009485,
0.0259676334,
-0.0206203442,
0.0086533586,
0.0401432849,
-0.027376974,
-0.0439248644,
-0.0733836517,
0.0409249775,
0.0212144833,
0.0089921597,
-0.0088307057,
0.0092302682,
0.0178101119,
0.0340398699,
-0.0605313107,
0.0026281453,
0.0368107073,
0.0578539036,
-0.0204007346,
-0.0332345963,
0.0078531578,
-0.0159847643,
0.0259615835,
0.0059081046,
-0.0729821399,
0.0327581279,
-0.0044400794,
-0.0265574902,
-0.0056558815,
0.051523786,
2.126089311e-34,
0.0408729464,
-0.0111533953,
0.0343206562,
-0.0116850911,
0.01251016,
-0.0153319333,
0.01006018,
0.0332461745,
-0.0404587127,
-0.0055931499,
-0.0268646423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20467v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20467v1 | ACL Anthology Helper: A Tool to Retrieve and Manage Literature from ACL Anthology | 2023-10-31T13:59:05 | 2023-10-31T13:59:05 | Chen Tang, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The ACL Anthology is an online repository that serves as a comprehensive
collection of publications in the field of natural language processing (NLP)
and computational linguistics (CL). This paper presents a tool called ``ACL
Anthology Helper''. It automates the process of parsing and downloading papers
along with their meta-information, which are then stored in a local MySQL
database. This allows for efficient management of the local papers using a wide
range of operations, including "where," "group," "order," and more. By
providing over 20 operations, this tool significantly enhances the retrieval of
literature based on specific conditions. Notably, this tool has been
successfully utilised in writing a survey paper (Tang et al.,2022a). By
introducing the ACL Anthology Helper, we aim to enhance researchers' ability to
effectively access and organise literature from the ACL Anthology. This tool
offers a convenient solution for researchers seeking to explore the ACL
Anthology's vast collection of publications while allowing for more targeted
and efficient literature retrieval. | [
0.0622041412,
0.0656355396,
-0.0357446596,
-0.0213744696,
-0.1059253588,
0.0374036767,
0.0483957753,
0.0055348254,
-0.0089161694,
-0.058387585,
0.0322877392,
0.0257979408,
-0.0084488895,
0.0038104986,
-0.0136428084,
-0.0221620742,
0.0571845695,
0.0187309925,
0.0302707683,
-0.0092149116,
0.0028243458,
0.0275870301,
-0.010544884,
0.0356468931,
0.0605268404,
-0.0199722424,
-0.0174901355,
-0.0417466462,
-0.0170792677,
-0.0138859805,
-0.0053154505,
0.0458441004,
-0.0137342066,
0.0233130306,
0.000002056,
-0.0770882294,
-0.0927032977,
0.0159126446,
0.0163197201,
-0.034222547,
0.0899330676,
-0.0055410541,
-0.02289805,
-0.0238324422,
-0.0250508282,
-0.0225940552,
0.0503745675,
0.0159266479,
0.0296121072,
0.0669980049,
-0.0053327559,
-0.0639454946,
-0.0131986225,
0.0288228504,
-0.0042151688,
0.0114738001,
0.0282646939,
-0.0326871611,
0.055317048,
-0.0104400674,
0.0130669978,
0.036701642,
-0.0245397724,
-0.0242348183,
0.0276695769,
-0.011377262,
-0.0762071982,
-0.0776136145,
0.0179650746,
-0.0280835945,
0.0481790826,
-0.0346571878,
0.0430256389,
0.0160031952,
-0.0161927324,
0.0618127547,
-0.0866464004,
0.0621388145,
-0.025347909,
-0.0203179028,
0.0331097096,
0.0187277868,
-0.0327307843,
0.0239145998,
-0.0053945994,
0.0655293614,
-0.0103241764,
-0.0328526758,
0.0373916067,
-0.0158035792,
-0.0068265214,
-0.0101224119,
0.056411989,
0.0293525737,
0.0267499257,
0.0092559708,
0.0330025181,
-0.074947387,
0.0880426839,
-0.0379657149,
0.0226953458,
-0.0173300412,
-0.0040027224,
0.0472479351,
0.062329974,
-0.0175933614,
0.0216831882,
-0.0065057399,
0.0033426841,
0.0120577775,
-0.0586964749,
-0.0273852292,
-0.0464729294,
0.0482898131,
-0.0448453315,
0.0055008195,
-0.0151278153,
-0.0180423446,
-0.0360567421,
-0.0098805865,
0.011875391,
0.0476102494,
-0.0231191125,
0.0139493514,
0.0118504167,
-0.0062736277,
-0.0478505865,
0.0068498962,
-0.0158333518,
-0.0357489772,
0.0299249999,
-0.0242642909,
0.0837335959,
-0.0335165523,
0.0055550556,
0.0086696073,
0.0349821448,
-0.0616694652,
-0.0060822265,
-0.0306014493,
0.0133245932,
-0.0215241499,
-0.0212808661,
-0.0648713186,
0.0794014335,
0.0091024153,
-0.0059893932,
-0.0102469912,
-0.0038174663,
0.0244520642,
-0.0296557173,
0.0167621151,
-0.0295053571,
-0.0127120484,
0.0365229659,
0.0057231844,
0.0603796281,
0.0133778537,
-0.0031958774,
0.0149056474,
0.0793644711,
-0.0186142158,
0.0022686373,
-0.0181392636,
-0.0009649131,
-0.0682732761,
-0.0080392361,
0.009105782,
-0.0746364892,
0.0020079776,
-0.0565892942,
0.0805268288,
-0.0241510179,
-0.015125107,
-0.0011384598,
0.0988474339,
0.0525537431,
0.0514862761,
-0.0177155305,
0.0413065739,
0.0342704952,
-0.0235232189,
-0.0123494249,
0.0082096681,
0.0284763966,
-0.0265122242,
-0.0194981992,
0.0499842353,
0.0547497012,
-0.0166172776,
-0.0118962163,
0.0176825579,
-0.0071389708,
-0.0358970501,
0.0253519565,
0.0055061704,
0.0352979228,
-0.0311297793,
0.0284008775,
-0.0266475007,
0.0078561287,
-0.0103034861,
0.0041876016,
0.0199280456,
0.0336971879,
-0.0401901156,
0.022841109,
-0.0283464584,
-0.0534248315,
0.0322549418,
-0.0254619904,
-0.0173099972,
-0.0032021271,
-0.0145009551,
0.0097104609,
0.0291332826,
0.0115940906,
-0.002628956,
-0.0008151663,
0.0478448644,
0.007784863,
0.0102641489,
-0.0366482921,
0.01889286,
0.0236461852,
-0.043601092,
0.0008345692,
-0.0083362842,
0.0594417043,
0.0321546569,
-0.0240237564,
0.0369814672,
0.0419720858,
-0.0051895515,
-0.0552156754,
0.0391533002,
0.0308825038,
-0.0058006379,
0.0278282296,
-0.0934285223,
0.0234432053,
-0.0331128724,
0.0064175217,
-0.0335613564,
0.0164783821,
-0.0212426372,
0.0627708137,
-0.0523092039,
0.0274093766,
-0.0083564809,
0.0043107104,
-0.0549170375,
0.0540441126,
0.0229402911,
0.0104505112,
-0.0081496369,
-0.1034087688,
-0.0018786561,
-0.0093697952,
0.0012442132,
0.0412767194,
-0.0044171182,
0.003937352,
0.0798237845,
0.0127599314,
-0.0543905348,
-0.0127683263,
-0.0996292755,
0.0070679653,
-0.0059056194,
0.0014923927,
-0.002172909,
0.0038104071,
-0.0316205025,
0.0167246442,
0.0312640518,
-0.0408627652,
0.0272897612,
0.0279733595,
0.0254066382,
0.0228394344,
0.0067418134,
-0.0361958221,
-0.0224002469,
-0.0164143499,
0.0342135765,
0.0235275086,
-0.0720456168,
-0.0056688669,
-0.0023427578,
-0.0067624175,
-0.0030301849,
0.016713649,
-0.0043203649,
-0.0345946923,
-0.0280360058,
-0.0384685732,
0.0691954195,
0.0197654348,
0.0597620457,
0.0647056177,
-0.0314542092,
-0.0538886711,
-0.0031979471,
-0.0171268396,
0.0287059136,
0.0269217603,
-0.0228555556,
0.1038410887,
-0.0102747902,
0.0240405351,
0.0013128519,
0.0109091429,
0.0095737306,
-0.0406781472,
-0.0181836132,
-0.0466970652,
-0.028689364,
-0.0316741988,
0.0491537564,
0.0147916041,
-0.0181402154,
0.0496301316,
0.0173801128,
-0.0108645856,
-0.1044367999,
-0.0400473513,
-0.0537158512,
0.0784483179,
0.0298447572,
0.0307542142,
0.0442880578,
-0.0500417836,
0.0175913423,
0.0045095361,
0.0259837732,
-0.0193352047,
-0.0145910848,
-0.0220265221,
0.0065068379,
-0.0047983523,
0.0019869099,
0.0091078915,
-0.0311767384,
-0.0025136475,
0.000476038,
0.0438861959,
0.0044600456,
-0.0552478433,
0.0099236546,
0.0527810939,
0.0232063122,
-0.0286577791,
-0.0021583547,
0.0146987811,
0.0204531811,
0.066720672,
-0.0206954516,
0.0051513831,
0.0417558812,
-0.0259464663,
0.0521397479,
0.0125067029,
0.0110221766,
0.0299163926,
0.0188261401,
0.0287256762,
-0.1141869724,
-0.0150633454,
-0.017244393,
-0.0499072559,
-0.0789713711,
0.0055253678,
0.0925829932,
0.0637247935,
-0.0875223577,
-0.0264663976,
-0.05128159,
-0.028970018,
-0.0197104476,
0.0254880898,
-0.0763470232,
0.0290131904,
-0.0053194617,
0.0092182001,
-0.0568927713,
-0.0239938796,
-0.0078666927,
-0.0723303631,
0.0316945165,
-0.0182545837,
-0.0280153342,
-0.0043592658,
-0.0717817321,
-0.005261553,
-0.0352525227,
-0.0496926755,
0.040784467,
-0.0703991354,
0.0215256866,
0.0241516251,
-0.0203064773,
-0.0270502083,
-0.0185138416,
-0.0158298407,
0.0228600353,
0.0181543287,
0.0665228665,
-0.036067564,
-0.0077230739,
-0.0119275479,
-0.0215033088,
-0.037064597,
-0.0575403832,
0.0121291121,
-0.0087919571,
0.0312883481,
-0.0272662714,
0.0024907403,
-0.0075379177,
-0.0257255938,
0.0434492938,
0.0675471202,
-0.0159232579,
-0.0101063233,
-0.0668538138,
0.0126772383,
-0.0045894943,
0.0354861319,
-0.0004835389,
0.0184760261,
-0.0207154993,
-0.0079865763,
-0.0024898376,
-0.0311163086,
-0.0501868613,
0.0116840899,
-0.0484541655,
-0.040760573,
-0.0543899201,
-0.0430099778,
0.0011140874,
0.0308055617,
0.0356679931,
-0.000306117,
0.0411740169,
0.0130630918,
-0.0739272982,
-0.0231319312,
0.0175196044,
-0.0257240217,
-0.0202374235,
-0.0124534443,
0.0699576959,
0.0455690399,
-0.0332713909,
0.0133840498,
-0.0067404485,
-0.0464575998,
0.0779871717,
0.0056787748,
0.0290555414,
-0.0146610821,
-0.0045106513,
-0.0500363484,
0.0057749241,
0.0696104914,
-0.0567185692,
-0.0279216766,
-0.0145228803,
-0.0142971184,
-0.0363279283,
0.0158094913,
-0.0166739933,
0.0204382967,
-0.0880509838,
0.0062787104,
-0.0366668776,
-0.0106027881,
0.0373148061,
0.0038816712,
0.0020019857,
-0.0299892556,
-0.0418181382,
-0.0199639443,
-0.0065331105,
0.0058659501,
-0.0424700566,
-0.0080231307,
0.0124111464,
-0.0102202334,
-0.0101939877,
-0.0321886763,
0.0641693622,
-0.0181160215,
0.0417832285,
0.0076375897,
0.0935715958,
0.0109566385,
0.0105175227,
-0.0209098738,
0.008035345,
-0.0331581756,
0.0126363067,
-0.0139167234,
0.0769428164,
-0.0290062614,
-0.0112638362,
0.0114804879,
-0.01962246,
-0.033886224,
0.0199379828,
-0.0736319125,
0.0198295917,
0.0287372358,
-0.0121395467,
0.0212240405,
-0.0646143854,
0.0729616657,
-0.037036363,
-0.024058776,
-0.0013024755,
0.0109935459,
0.0099496301,
-0.0057363492,
-0.0292724669,
0.0135207959,
-0.0296764914,
-0.0088978913,
0.0313546024,
-0.0206189267,
-0.0267041568,
0.0444631726,
-0.0305709429,
-0.0251593012,
-0.0252540763,
-0.0022866849,
0.0156546868,
0.0177992359,
-0.0315486006,
-0.0451094992,
0.0072564776,
0.0161804538,
-0.0048572007,
0.0100009805,
-0.0303727873,
0.0424891636,
0.075114809,
0.0438371338,
-0.0152715985,
-0.0583144762,
0.044201266,
-0.0504019484,
-0.0118588684,
0.0009997707,
-6.774049213e-33,
-0.0585864969,
-0.039575085,
-0.0122618861,
-0.0137666147,
0.0164270606,
-0.0231506694,
-0.0187372584,
-0.0251656007,
0.0080634104,
0.0052975523,
-0.0361145884,
0.0146973738,
0.0377997644,
-0.0210911892,
0.0604715943,
0.0594370887,
0.0018180067,
0.0172624774,
-0.0018274428,
-0.0061650914,
0.0678533167,
0.0364415348,
0.0559255145,
-0.0758349001,
0.0606176257,
0.0338132083,
0.0193904247,
0.0024191672,
0.025670087,
0.0396776795,
0.0075278925,
0.0167336687,
0.0197356269,
0.0010186725,
0.0132280421,
-0.0122554014,
-0.0796187446,
-0.0445490032,
0.02793644,
0.0046251565,
0.0433968604,
-0.022731917,
0.0514328405,
-0.007035464,
-0.0131817348,
0.0130248349,
0.0605388954,
-0.0144118285,
-0.0482337438,
-0.0519298762,
-0.054095719,
0.0172004048,
-0.0233983453,
0.0637886003,
0.0543164909,
0.0227224063,
0.0062427381,
-0.0068877521,
0.0043583307,
0.0133988261,
-0.0082833087,
0.0576944686,
-0.0054147053,
-0.0589844063,
0.0094222752,
0.0365260839,
-0.0218538269,
-0.0397099629,
0.0136161325,
0.0639894828,
0.0338021889,
0.0419751927,
-0.0298773143,
0.0641653538,
0.0783980414,
-0.007874134,
0.0089303199,
0.0360516831,
0.0603214204,
0.0577373654,
-0.0075377803,
0.0201352071,
-0.0125417495,
-0.0289840791,
0.0287735239,
-0.0355454162,
-0.0008980375,
-0.0343350694,
-0.0207911618,
-0.0035130132,
-0.0575685352,
0.0325130448,
-0.003664155,
0.0160837993,
-0.0682992786,
0.0293892622,
0.0289003998,
0.0253011771,
-0.0072848434,
0.02651079,
-0.0619459003,
0.0108081494,
-0.0196004305,
0.016324643,
0.01654201,
-0.0047207307,
0.032702174,
0.0130952653,
-0.066902563,
-0.0185370259,
0.0229374766,
0.0140570272,
-0.0332608446,
0.0033037257,
0.0028325296,
0.0535130948,
0.0177184585,
0.0065227337,
0.0500239842,
0.01635224,
-0.0519107394,
-0.0047011399,
-0.0150325727,
0.0101030376,
0.0084321694,
0.0075125741,
-0.0175588708,
0.0379737057,
0.0590739362,
-0.0195249412,
0.0140305655,
-0.0470291078,
2.968e-7,
0.0561138056,
0.061025776,
0.0466458239,
0.0064486121,
0.0165595133,
-0.0280399676,
-0.0038318394,
0.0107477,
0.0143565927,
0.0415746421,
0.0091443807,
0.0199940801,
0.009997529,
0.0917069465,
-0.0685743615,
0.0028782014,
-0.0611498766,
-0.0418356806,
-0.0728306621,
0.0311077032,
0.0100555941,
0.0366849154,
0.0109048737,
0.0125149228,
-0.0436622947,
-0.02663197,
0.006220595,
-0.0253071524,
0.0074814036,
0.0269802101,
0.0081906347,
0.0087595601,
0.0200401694,
-0.0440830253,
0.0018178968,
0.0296586007,
-0.0168972071,
0.0194444098,
-0.0082639763,
-0.0215063673,
0.0270585772,
-0.0410791449,
-0.0019129098,
-0.0175029058,
0.0516080372,
-0.0188703239,
-0.0054088542,
-0.0308975782,
-0.0272269007,
-0.0127789769,
0.0117993262,
-0.0207581557,
-0.0500274524,
0.0213223752,
0.0001577527,
-0.0317653678,
-0.0121110603,
-0.0852350667,
0.0065562734,
0.0198480785,
0.010848186,
-0.0042034974,
0.0074691656,
-0.0001579363,
-0.020270437,
-0.0557576157,
0.0042483914,
3.001375262e-34,
0.0323539153,
0.0370369889,
-0.0117728803,
0.057754565,
0.0290740263,
-0.0101168612,
-0.0255106036,
0.0546876118,
-0.011636924,
-0.0427461378,
-0.0258683171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20456v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20456v1 | Towards a Deep Understanding of Multilingual End-to-End Speech Translation | 2023-10-31T13:50:55 | 2023-10-31T13:50:55 | Haoran Sun, Xiaohu Zhao, Yikun Lei, Shaolin Zhu, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we employ Singular Value Canonical Correlation Analysis
(SVCCA) to analyze representations learnt in a multilingual end-to-end speech
translation model trained over 22 languages. SVCCA enables us to estimate
representational similarity across languages and layers, enhancing our
understanding of the functionality of multilingual speech translation and its
potential connection to multilingual neural machine translation. The
multilingual speech translation model is trained on the CoVoST 2 dataset in all
possible directions, and we utilize LASER to extract parallel bitext data for
SVCCA analysis. We derive three major findings from our analysis: (I)
Linguistic similarity loses its efficacy in multilingual speech translation
when the training data for a specific language is limited. (II) Enhanced
encoder representations and well-aligned audio-text data significantly improve
translation quality, surpassing the bilingual counterparts when the training
data is not compromised. (III) The encoder representations of multilingual
speech translation demonstrate superior performance in predicting phonetic
features in linguistic typology prediction. With these findings, we propose
that releasing the constraint of limited data for low-resource languages and
subsequently combining them with linguistically related high-resource languages
could offer a more effective approach for multilingual end-to-end speech
translation. | [
-0.0315769799,
0.0327724032,
-0.0192297436,
0.0413440652,
-0.0225970726,
-0.0020192438,
0.0361348726,
-0.0171630532,
-0.0495737232,
0.0254222229,
-0.0829716697,
-0.0317938961,
0.0620362274,
-0.048471462,
0.0415898785,
-0.0209078565,
0.0181364566,
-0.0005691711,
-0.0428838916,
-0.0367167816,
0.0039222608,
-0.0100137396,
0.0288292356,
0.0290923975,
-0.0284431744,
-0.004957492,
0.0105145061,
0.0375897922,
0.0377326533,
-0.0066820672,
-0.0334384777,
0.0231696274,
0.0533321351,
0.0747385398,
0.0000019777,
-0.0258673783,
0.0100863306,
-0.0000636182,
0.0126017919,
-0.0253110584,
0.0184926931,
-0.0595701411,
0.0112081869,
0.0196839087,
-0.0100896582,
0.0160342027,
0.0558373109,
0.0002234417,
0.0127635272,
0.0467954017,
-0.0152905406,
-0.0842335373,
-0.0325137712,
-0.0259749796,
-0.0242949482,
-0.0164608452,
-0.018621739,
-0.0180752147,
-0.0506041907,
-0.0194066204,
-0.0378005542,
0.0541042723,
-0.0034037705,
0.0337380432,
-0.045698449,
-0.0068184352,
-0.0381964669,
-0.0531595312,
0.0170853008,
0.094201915,
-0.0232887249,
-0.0473928601,
-0.0182155203,
0.0370698459,
-0.0191694573,
-0.0192374438,
-0.0502411835,
-0.0148894098,
0.0304816104,
0.0262018833,
0.0269267466,
0.0540388823,
0.0291759707,
-0.0580969229,
-0.0284930412,
-0.0046378453,
0.0401859023,
-0.0427629426,
0.0157572646,
-0.0100993877,
0.0421449281,
0.0144618051,
0.0345225669,
-0.0089826221,
-0.0347259641,
0.0103052491,
-0.0323486552,
-0.1093595251,
0.0228470061,
-0.082296215,
0.0194888357,
0.0811969116,
-0.0498672426,
0.0313365012,
-0.0394991301,
0.0829661041,
-0.048551023,
0.0375783257,
-0.0535017699,
-0.0469690003,
-0.0279346555,
0.0153966919,
-0.0037724939,
-0.028264612,
0.0033738161,
-0.0046118763,
-0.0197773762,
-0.0172018334,
0.0001534674,
0.0468106233,
0.0058646468,
0.0112132579,
-0.0632604286,
0.0043171467,
0.0092203878,
0.0930652395,
-0.030850824,
-0.0220803767,
-0.0404725187,
-0.0218876936,
-0.0310547408,
0.0531628095,
-0.0169156436,
-0.0235157814,
0.0259585455,
0.0836574733,
-0.0072584678,
0.0154383844,
0.0264713354,
-0.0150461355,
-0.0305270683,
-0.0624388941,
0.0035318928,
-0.0752302706,
0.1025244296,
0.032048177,
0.0102188541,
-0.0399552211,
-0.0111343805,
-0.0168730225,
-0.0195033457,
0.0266977381,
0.0255372114,
0.0105322478,
0.0399888083,
-0.0349904783,
0.0139409201,
0.0582542717,
0.0418531708,
0.0023997899,
0.0129904253,
-0.0389024131,
-0.0630287305,
0.069485791,
0.0006138458,
-0.002323295,
-0.0745879114,
-0.0109632239,
0.0682106391,
0.0410102382,
0.0420235842,
0.0402360484,
-0.0191928297,
-0.0677705631,
0.040825095,
0.0409286171,
0.0399113484,
0.0244381875,
0.0396286435,
-0.0062045404,
-0.0068407441,
0.0084348051,
0.0136832707,
0.037190266,
0.0036656512,
-0.0169405881,
0.0181780495,
0.0844925269,
-0.0296027102,
0.0181227773,
0.0163551457,
-0.0170288496,
-0.0076791034,
-0.0446005911,
0.0251464508,
-0.0312172677,
-0.03206167,
0.0653451681,
-0.0190052651,
-0.0359360985,
0.0331818871,
0.0217157826,
-0.0468064509,
0.0267132837,
0.019039778,
0.0288251992,
-0.0035716142,
-0.0357971415,
-0.0258948728,
0.0215389114,
0.0314231552,
0.0218358207,
0.0347172059,
-0.0541331023,
-0.015935028,
-0.0034522705,
-0.0020285775,
0.0755610466,
-0.0681233555,
0.0560984947,
0.0345924795,
-0.0186075419,
-0.0665780157,
-0.0018433098,
-0.0268280338,
0.0111603132,
0.0506437086,
0.0375230722,
0.0189250819,
0.0301484559,
-0.0175737832,
0.0075074453,
0.0153360469,
-0.0535961576,
0.0119643947,
0.0735732391,
-0.0556694195,
-0.0148622449,
0.0411487669,
-0.0782566592,
0.0398806185,
0.0308945887,
-0.0131013114,
-0.0754293278,
0.0451859385,
-0.0010594523,
0.003243787,
-0.0282231085,
0.0218262095,
-0.0138059733,
0.0602309629,
0.0223056022,
0.0225058086,
0.0353682674,
-0.0053064856,
0.022957461,
-0.0085204616,
0.0686934888,
-0.0405320972,
-0.0298793651,
0.0616395511,
0.0134435147,
0.0098927179,
0.0126984185,
-0.0077954619,
0.0110373916,
-0.0274821036,
-0.0886074156,
0.006381196,
-0.0236369632,
0.0201628879,
0.0240656715,
0.0198455844,
0.0343065858,
-0.021857569,
-0.0286384691,
-0.0039650723,
0.0132177314,
0.0050509549,
-0.0189573281,
0.0032794229,
-0.013736723,
-0.0192334838,
0.0034712816,
0.0159195513,
0.0577955134,
-0.0336132459,
-0.0539523624,
-0.0480277799,
0.03323761,
-0.0384763815,
-0.0059876405,
-0.0037071821,
-0.0365033075,
0.0000293389,
0.0166867487,
0.0630841628,
0.0133768115,
0.0043558967,
-0.0234718714,
0.0460113212,
-0.0085372375,
-0.0582538582,
0.0033789356,
-0.0183812454,
0.0209412221,
-0.0553753525,
0.0282685719,
-0.0289809313,
0.0447779521,
0.0259243026,
0.0031040413,
-0.0572858043,
-0.0618787073,
0.0081759458,
-0.0326915905,
-0.0448292606,
0.0056454297,
-0.0070532644,
0.0236211419,
-0.0102128042,
-0.0236378312,
0.0319637693,
-0.0710118935,
-0.0169602595,
-0.0192288943,
-0.0254047476,
-0.025057409,
0.011944755,
-0.014809343,
0.020315202,
-0.0538630262,
-0.0157236438,
-0.0452957489,
0.0332777835,
0.0106582344,
-0.0235320479,
0.0101769511,
-0.0377344266,
-0.0300315358,
-0.0148606654,
-0.0311027952,
-0.0265734289,
0.0194705091,
-0.0116061056,
-0.0029153323,
-0.0273517575,
-0.0067494391,
-0.033094015,
-0.0087607922,
0.0352946222,
0.0322846025,
-0.00746931,
0.0387169309,
-0.0042736554,
0.0226043407,
-0.001304011,
0.0154512078,
0.00306515,
-0.0590382852,
0.0211396571,
-0.0229461566,
-0.0003535615,
-0.0031767166,
-0.0505012348,
-0.0214722883,
0.0166963935,
0.0325254612,
-0.0648531765,
-0.0155923702,
0.029948961,
-0.0044284235,
0.0259297099,
0.0775966719,
-0.0115523851,
-0.0510768257,
0.0018831105,
-0.0298279859,
0.0336619988,
0.0384902284,
0.0147205386,
-0.0587097108,
-0.0325119458,
0.0001691735,
0.0075142384,
0.0520659909,
0.0226405617,
-0.020164961,
-0.0496422723,
-0.0157006215,
0.0273052733,
-0.0750879869,
-0.0416443273,
-0.0134666422,
-0.04745299,
-0.0273862854,
0.0627490208,
-0.0320751667,
0.0385154523,
-0.0259122401,
0.0257362518,
0.0098541034,
-0.028567804,
0.0096972752,
-0.0274656061,
0.0163411144,
0.046424605,
0.0572945215,
-0.0332790837,
-0.0216070917,
-0.0203324296,
-0.006780487,
0.0244785193,
-0.0012579203,
0.0168168675,
0.0204395335,
-0.0246108975,
0.0373727977,
0.0142932544,
-0.013976655,
0.0568193644,
0.0071405205,
0.0725085139,
-0.0233455338,
-0.0100207822,
0.0321671851,
-0.0001810347,
-0.0170341041,
0.0557930544,
0.0212722216,
-0.0338531807,
0.0127251195,
0.0030673265,
0.003412796,
-0.0356968939,
0.0057009188,
0.0034359714,
0.0018003117,
-0.0638183057,
-0.0448278002,
-0.0197309628,
-0.0066132867,
0.0110400449,
0.0372479483,
0.0043007252,
-0.0234277826,
-0.0193980765,
0.0111619215,
0.016187055,
-0.0197193231,
0.043327909,
-0.0441156067,
0.0400689989,
0.0251190159,
-0.0496184267,
0.0033506737,
-0.010581187,
-0.0932413712,
-0.0700613633,
-0.0409613997,
0.0334132724,
0.0119159603,
0.0419049896,
-0.0265271459,
-0.0195630509,
0.0239366628,
0.0251026507,
-0.0491107143,
-0.0067970417,
0.0351083241,
-0.0328298733,
0.0063044862,
0.035285566,
-0.0179914907,
-0.0106513863,
-0.0384973697,
0.0454177633,
0.0014950368,
-0.0941699594,
0.0133281695,
0.01845471,
0.0299864728,
-0.0239711832,
0.0055750604,
-0.0300465934,
0.0284487586,
-0.0182451252,
0.0193722993,
-0.0139235621,
-0.0120808445,
0.0451907888,
0.0328307599,
0.0170695242,
-0.0020385955,
0.0250721034,
-0.0392662324,
0.0194925237,
-0.0022081039,
-0.0254562311,
0.0318877548,
0.003022942,
0.0396284685,
0.0006558135,
0.0454648733,
0.0061473488,
0.0142714316,
-0.043568816,
0.0238072015,
-0.00977429,
0.0498409681,
0.0220171288,
0.0178169813,
-0.0106425127,
-0.0118678873,
0.0174573287,
-0.0270050485,
0.0692298636,
0.0019713156,
0.1114079729,
0.002130419,
0.0230890401,
-0.0143743269,
0.0530388653,
-0.0290801749,
-0.0168630406,
0.0206819456,
-0.0421245694,
-0.0010749029,
0.0189199261,
0.0705508515,
-0.0505462177,
0.0183561761,
-0.0571395308,
0.0032796848,
0.0140236262,
-0.0300006047,
0.009604536,
-0.0260596424,
-0.0349090435,
-0.0527732931,
-0.0312885419,
-0.0512294434,
0.0277892873,
0.0005786474,
-0.0025555373,
-0.0099220453,
0.0026628796,
0.059868589,
-0.0715631023,
0.0355743021,
0.0121209286,
-0.0423473753,
0.028449323,
-0.0314026438,
-0.0195786562,
-5.703247328e-33,
-0.0030498225,
0.0124777835,
0.0107557988,
0.0013477642,
-0.0228737257,
-0.0654722825,
-0.0159087218,
0.0004811501,
-0.0423865542,
0.0004524987,
0.0258379728,
-0.0029847077,
0.0100226616,
0.0050031962,
0.0332264453,
-0.0034070464,
0.048903238,
0.006060034,
0.0089441305,
0.0168254469,
0.0975691155,
0.0306732692,
0.1029699147,
-0.0686792657,
-0.0180843603,
-0.0104114078,
0.027666796,
0.0038865306,
0.0064771054,
0.0130224209,
-0.0050582876,
0.0297860596,
0.003501982,
-0.0273339972,
-0.0168669093,
-0.0282636434,
-0.0602671318,
-0.046504017,
0.0125471447,
0.0441786274,
-0.0071926257,
-0.0338478908,
0.0428690128,
-0.0301566422,
-0.0068480973,
0.0054973299,
0.0372514725,
-0.0216074288,
-0.0381007493,
-0.021640081,
-0.0600180775,
-0.0019236318,
-0.0320518836,
0.0345990248,
0.0671365336,
0.1188432574,
-0.0225717463,
0.0162258204,
-0.0775113925,
0.0221883096,
-0.070587799,
0.0235269517,
0.0833338574,
0.0023860869,
0.008177096,
0.0143363327,
0.034726087,
-0.0772172734,
0.0541655719,
0.0165623017,
0.0486592688,
-0.0044612135,
0.0225031711,
0.0857235938,
0.034735892,
-0.0245715231,
-0.0519110598,
0.0296010748,
-0.0032752806,
0.0192801096,
0.0200520866,
-0.0036011708,
0.0074238339,
0.0071953177,
-0.049409803,
-0.0254560187,
-0.0072002769,
-0.0607683547,
0.0052423649,
-0.0153232561,
0.0213536527,
-0.0093590841,
0.1002568454,
-0.0234037824,
0.0053331349,
0.0171130318,
-0.0380544439,
-0.0236744266,
0.0036818956,
0.0437430739,
-0.0173952263,
-0.0595288798,
0.0291812904,
0.0196778905,
0.046447929,
-0.0366523378,
0.0462696254,
0.0112053268,
-0.0109736482,
0.0155290877,
-0.0275039095,
-0.0556670353,
-0.0183238611,
0.0007201012,
0.0258258823,
0.0031908615,
-0.0117279496,
0.0420727134,
0.0162922069,
0.0202518106,
-0.0299409069,
-0.080240339,
0.0622067116,
0.0344152786,
-0.0545725264,
0.0082500149,
-0.0374134518,
-0.023405347,
0.0482810326,
-0.0260944348,
-0.0226566195,
0.0111098336,
2.81e-7,
0.0031833518,
0.0113981832,
0.0078849606,
0.0171937756,
0.029069569,
0.0252864156,
-0.0500951707,
0.038590353,
0.0019682262,
-0.0095324442,
0.018190911,
0.0092011364,
0.0890249535,
0.0499215797,
-0.0709868148,
-0.0586058423,
-0.0458657518,
0.0193429757,
-0.0547883958,
-0.0046100677,
0.042973049,
0.1002804413,
-0.0197132528,
-0.0119141145,
-0.0150282234,
0.0399996266,
0.0918725058,
-0.0116238026,
0.0118326852,
-0.0514015667,
-0.0006060599,
-0.0347474627,
-0.0474705249,
0.0045647682,
-0.0347280987,
0.0724556223,
0.0389379561,
0.0427274033,
-0.0118917339,
-0.0464475788,
0.0340140052,
0.0107287243,
-0.0568095334,
-0.0500595719,
0.0316660218,
0.0027023542,
-0.0166240521,
0.021013733,
-0.008929464,
0.0646499544,
0.0586988144,
-0.0226318706,
-0.0029001751,
-0.0024409182,
0.0397709757,
-0.0158822592,
-0.0177832432,
-0.0042974427,
-0.0163701512,
0.0003901463,
-0.0280136093,
-0.0017272811,
-0.0082375621,
-0.0352736376,
0.0386714526,
0.0125042126,
0.0133913178,
1.962138844e-34,
0.0213173255,
-0.0158282854,
0.0362561569,
-0.0515689552,
-0.0000830956,
-0.0673802122,
-0.0260488372,
0.0238454323,
-0.0015841118,
-0.0434413701,
-0.048524335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20440v1 | The SourceData-NLP dataset: integrating curation into scientific publishing for training large language models | 2023-10-31T13:22:38 | 2023-10-31T13:22:38 | Jorge Abreu-Vicente, Hannah Sonntag, Thomas Eidens, Thomas Lemberger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Introduction: The scientific publishing landscape is expanding rapidly,
creating challenges for researchers to stay up-to-date with the evolution of
the literature. Natural Language Processing (NLP) has emerged as a potent
approach to automating knowledge extraction from this vast amount of
publications and preprints. Tasks such as Named-Entity Recognition (NER) and
Named-Entity Linking (NEL), in conjunction with context-dependent semantic
interpretation, offer promising and complementary approaches to extracting
structured information and revealing key concepts.
Results: We present the SourceData-NLP dataset produced through the routine
curation of papers during the publication process. A unique feature of this
dataset is its emphasis on the annotation of bioentities in figure legends. We
annotate eight classes of biomedical entities (small molecules, gene products,
subcellular components, cell lines, cell types, tissues, organisms, and
diseases), their role in the experimental design, and the nature of the
experimental method as an additional class. SourceData-NLP contains more than
620,000 annotated biomedical entities, curated from 18,689 figures in 3,223
papers in molecular and cell biology. We illustrate the dataset's usefulness by
assessing BioLinkBERT and PubmedBERT, two transformers-based models, fine-tuned
on the SourceData-NLP dataset for NER. We also introduce a novel
context-dependent semantic task that infers whether an entity is the target of
a controlled intervention or the object of measurement.
Conclusions: SourceData-NLP's scale highlights the value of integrating
curation into publishing. Models trained with SourceData-NLP will furthermore
enable the development of tools able to extract causal hypotheses from the
literature and assemble them into knowledge graphs. | [
0.0408482961,
0.0425175838,
0.0055979989,
-0.031364847,
0.0080413939,
0.0259768777,
0.0298766103,
0.0022302615,
0.0213435255,
-0.0485540964,
-0.0186642483,
0.0397241227,
-0.0039431844,
0.0521888994,
0.0415652841,
-0.0133328186,
0.0199770816,
0.0283285156,
0.0149487574,
0.0332796201,
-0.0130967349,
0.0214586928,
0.0255717523,
0.0316103324,
0.0107617397,
-0.0308091361,
0.0308114458,
-0.0098204082,
0.0478353612,
-0.0711692646,
-0.0194410868,
0.0422344469,
0.0183092263,
0.0303364545,
0.0000018204,
-0.0621006377,
-0.0456967466,
0.0358727686,
-0.03101293,
-0.0065792785,
0.0390130244,
-0.0770551562,
0.0036989378,
-0.035363771,
0.0120789958,
-0.0424137525,
0.0474900939,
0.0837614313,
0.0024038085,
0.0417920351,
-0.0021029129,
-0.0508922487,
0.0722268671,
-0.0145512922,
0.0258106347,
0.0172290746,
0.0625607371,
-0.004869014,
0.0237202607,
0.0254666246,
0.0205383282,
0.0580280945,
0.0057111671,
-0.0186027195,
0.0403371751,
0.0596071966,
-0.0407041237,
-0.020722989,
0.0120864175,
0.0942176878,
0.0196651667,
-0.0408316739,
0.0457193516,
-0.0212908033,
-0.0200483147,
0.0497031175,
-0.0438338704,
-0.021380933,
-0.0048255818,
-0.0174957309,
0.004780177,
-0.019294912,
0.0277284645,
-0.005544391,
0.0251922514,
0.0123630008,
-0.011410444,
-0.0234349202,
0.0050845598,
0.0078704329,
-0.0273339935,
-0.0336813815,
-0.0025750296,
0.0152118718,
0.030251598,
0.0372546092,
0.0072852396,
-0.028715577,
0.0660523772,
-0.0180066396,
-0.0345618501,
-0.0524890572,
-0.0243293773,
0.0419168025,
-0.0182475653,
-0.0134831816,
-0.0499756448,
0.0464668982,
0.0159057062,
0.0161976535,
-0.0459532142,
-0.0448072478,
0.0063174525,
0.0301570669,
-0.0026274249,
-0.0109920222,
-0.0671648532,
-0.0235479232,
-0.0110168057,
0.0295892134,
0.0382163711,
0.0061043175,
-0.048366949,
0.0237169545,
-0.021611413,
0.0575912036,
0.0201097969,
0.0037823322,
-0.0515838116,
-0.0310609341,
-0.0135908769,
-0.0135124782,
0.014227761,
-0.0340912715,
0.0123339044,
0.0952861086,
0.037384782,
-0.0699692518,
0.0219210535,
-0.056102559,
0.0076387459,
-0.0631303117,
0.0515723526,
-0.0446105078,
0.0333971754,
0.0094986968,
-0.0000201967,
-0.078640148,
0.009913696,
-0.0075312876,
-0.0551790446,
0.0604543686,
-0.0682122186,
-0.049683243,
0.0122956596,
-0.0008511908,
0.0121343816,
0.0250131227,
0.0361406058,
-0.0277025886,
0.0182646066,
0.0077467714,
-0.0029914244,
-0.0222182535,
0.0557503551,
-0.0315070339,
0.0236087218,
0.0043048859,
-0.0263062734,
0.0427361578,
-0.017629331,
-0.0131493546,
-0.0226206072,
-0.0324433334,
0.019751152,
0.0624775067,
0.0278597306,
-0.0044688638,
0.0134361647,
-0.017029427,
0.0284925345,
-0.0135906888,
-0.0440532453,
0.0374621339,
0.0046009384,
0.0250625517,
-0.0416662134,
0.0562917553,
0.0145827448,
-0.007749592,
-0.00954301,
0.0290359221,
-0.0422337577,
-0.0298885312,
0.0568199679,
-0.00000223,
-0.0209935158,
0.0674570575,
0.0417783558,
-0.0029144578,
0.0100581571,
-0.0016838524,
0.0204261672,
-0.0074682338,
0.0598179065,
-0.0880742446,
-0.0473782644,
-0.0405911952,
-0.0215973724,
0.0541580506,
-0.0445106141,
-0.035376329,
-0.0129311904,
0.0228366405,
0.004466428,
-0.0263583101,
0.0063202642,
0.0055168788,
0.0040483708,
-0.0012441679,
-0.023212282,
-0.0352827087,
-0.0177950375,
0.0489433892,
-0.0214391574,
-0.0330145359,
-0.0292647015,
-0.0120917745,
0.0352914035,
0.0191246513,
-0.0268454235,
0.0172988996,
0.0514445156,
-0.0353155062,
-0.0303527731,
0.0476200283,
0.0641177669,
-0.0367424116,
0.0257753916,
-0.0561181717,
-0.0416807942,
-0.0129229501,
-0.05412421,
-0.0239619967,
0.016101256,
0.0273661129,
-0.0186738838,
0.0232891794,
-0.0139562665,
0.0129060401,
-0.0063061039,
-0.0303762294,
0.051868327,
-0.0118706394,
0.0203331169,
0.0266417116,
-0.0610212423,
0.0342792869,
-0.0033721356,
-0.0222537406,
0.0179729946,
0.0299211666,
-0.0239968374,
0.0324453712,
-0.0063701686,
-0.0333035812,
0.0080000507,
-0.0011232349,
0.0137520898,
0.0273791514,
0.0140199969,
0.0049170582,
-0.022928644,
0.0014660263,
-0.0201972201,
0.0009254307,
-0.0207082443,
-0.0101193478,
0.0099698231,
0.0572305508,
0.0257431623,
-0.0217780583,
-0.0503872968,
-0.0206764881,
-0.0794770792,
0.0705297515,
0.0611703098,
-0.0171687081,
-0.0111792162,
0.0358937569,
-0.0250770077,
0.0082492195,
-0.0192952603,
0.0151017401,
0.0266126804,
0.02324773,
-0.02913744,
0.0862751901,
-0.043190524,
0.0511294715,
0.0439241864,
0.0210679211,
-0.0371858291,
-0.0018924767,
-0.0505617671,
0.0302339196,
0.017625846,
-0.0217280239,
0.0366343595,
0.0426567942,
-0.0231942181,
-0.0062624021,
-0.0317172632,
0.0370872617,
0.0010410453,
-0.040398322,
-0.0289324466,
0.0200277902,
0.0178076271,
0.027815314,
0.0144815119,
-0.0350492671,
0.0733092949,
-0.0100343823,
0.0155939553,
-0.0330417491,
0.0359651968,
-0.0269606933,
0.0079756752,
0.0619694628,
0.0005197263,
0.0476241373,
-0.0162171423,
0.0081420364,
0.0494860969,
0.0054297457,
-0.0059129577,
0.0023619786,
-0.0471226089,
0.0459964983,
0.001111017,
-0.0249066763,
-0.0075667752,
0.0214657318,
-0.0330270603,
0.019077396,
-0.0002909557,
-0.0466727614,
-0.0523161627,
0.0164255891,
0.0305602793,
0.0175345819,
-0.0126825022,
-0.0086619928,
-0.0390861742,
0.0223848335,
0.0768966004,
-0.0256233029,
0.0213445351,
0.0162323341,
0.0163335279,
0.0502975732,
-0.0321866982,
-0.0007401319,
-0.027763769,
0.0210579131,
-0.0245212168,
-0.0566870756,
0.0179071464,
-0.0132417642,
0.0333555266,
-0.0439127609,
-0.0092834467,
0.0662721023,
0.0304298811,
-0.0343298241,
-0.0205065217,
0.0252367631,
-0.0162997451,
-0.0035438717,
0.0357269421,
-0.1160388514,
-0.006493079,
-0.0434003174,
-0.0337255374,
-0.0178269316,
-0.07627628,
0.0089191785,
-0.0518025793,
0.0585918389,
-0.0242782161,
-0.0831447318,
-0.0208600629,
-0.1081413776,
0.0008332357,
-0.0535209626,
-0.0380380973,
-0.0246620849,
-0.0053242035,
0.0020807551,
0.0085628312,
-0.0181751885,
-0.0860960856,
0.010003523,
-0.0358301066,
0.0350545198,
0.0097866068,
0.0354695842,
0.0077100303,
0.0221904088,
-0.0082028015,
0.0072403993,
-0.0163146164,
-0.0216273647,
0.1088871062,
-0.0102244439,
-0.0051401155,
-0.0390562937,
0.0410344973,
-0.0404372476,
-0.0336674228,
-0.0204580128,
0.0843614414,
0.0215008445,
-0.009234597,
-0.0737027451,
-0.0120271323,
-0.0039778464,
0.0499706119,
0.0194256362,
0.0088290824,
-0.0541811511,
0.0011976267,
0.0301584527,
0.0065652942,
-0.045065105,
0.0143237021,
-0.0674286783,
-0.0215749238,
-0.0574118383,
-0.0222654212,
0.0415306315,
-0.0147843547,
0.033297088,
0.0115206065,
0.0539595783,
-0.0124387527,
-0.0515973158,
0.0595831461,
0.0178501457,
0.007362145,
-0.0103508383,
-0.0327896513,
0.0977904275,
0.0237553269,
-0.0393987186,
0.0365495235,
-0.0236242525,
-0.0519661717,
-0.0458351783,
0.0182643682,
0.0204768684,
0.009269136,
-0.0023365254,
-0.0489330851,
0.0353630036,
0.0761606246,
-0.0165095683,
-0.0349879302,
-0.0186753832,
0.0062030512,
-0.0215205364,
-0.0000329638,
-0.0352230445,
0.0422686636,
0.0013925137,
0.0076993704,
-0.0338753574,
-0.0248496514,
0.0284982547,
0.0288100932,
0.0567367934,
-0.0457802489,
-0.0110333012,
-0.0366310291,
0.0018771854,
-0.0198789965,
0.013596708,
-0.0099697374,
0.0053445781,
0.0077863405,
0.0126795266,
-0.0352738947,
0.030117441,
-0.0407479852,
0.0339317694,
-0.0689746514,
0.0263517797,
0.0662349686,
-0.0119831031,
0.0164284445,
-0.0146918474,
0.0167060476,
-0.032567326,
-0.0406791344,
0.044139076,
-0.0054774848,
-0.0055577387,
0.0297655687,
0.0253692009,
-0.0426297784,
0.0208384581,
-0.0778408349,
0.0395226218,
-0.0130202519,
0.0218316745,
0.0415082052,
-0.0028839328,
0.0639749318,
-0.0233093668,
-0.043499928,
0.013545963,
0.0451175198,
-0.0010584163,
0.0320582241,
0.076974161,
0.0184227172,
-0.0225676391,
-0.0471907929,
0.0549226813,
0.0625953749,
0.0664915517,
0.0034809229,
-0.0418561026,
-0.0250027012,
-0.0253248792,
-0.0308603216,
-0.0224973597,
-0.0044308896,
0.0093187662,
-0.0615833886,
-0.050770998,
0.0711991191,
0.0062460238,
-0.0266906824,
0.0184954237,
-0.0048107277,
0.0076191518,
0.0521780401,
-0.0679877698,
-0.0102640782,
0.0114867743,
-0.0142247872,
-0.0680284128,
-0.0154492175,
-5.767093202e-33,
-0.0147999004,
-0.0315901302,
0.0115908524,
0.0278169271,
0.0045836931,
0.0375682078,
-0.0621987619,
-0.0526450537,
0.0203935523,
0.0517427996,
-0.0198252629,
0.0028979124,
-0.017334044,
-0.0248210207,
-0.0001285966,
-0.0141815096,
0.0398359373,
-0.0221265312,
-0.0115198987,
0.0313070975,
0.0501496159,
0.0349889509,
0.052156955,
-0.1009377092,
0.0201542974,
0.062804088,
0.0349174924,
-0.0274839178,
0.0053086914,
0.0594909079,
-0.0398464017,
0.0198288541,
0.0092879105,
-0.0641688406,
0.0046908529,
0.0018411274,
-0.1071529835,
0.0056220484,
0.0357223079,
0.0161885936,
-0.0196249019,
-0.015910754,
0.0498169065,
0.0043883463,
0.0229163989,
-0.0262572691,
0.0774101838,
-0.0012321584,
-0.0377502069,
-0.0727604106,
-0.0674255416,
0.0190469958,
-0.0266739596,
0.0580055863,
0.0309616141,
-0.0160654429,
-0.0029092743,
0.0801167265,
-0.0387216844,
0.00040033,
0.0318678543,
-0.0106102172,
0.0299821291,
-0.0136421444,
0.0264377408,
0.050655812,
-0.0097578708,
-0.0319505744,
-0.016056845,
0.0122143859,
0.0158793945,
0.0368678048,
0.0203407556,
0.0350522809,
0.0314546898,
0.0262241829,
-0.1154970601,
0.0320823044,
-0.0284926854,
0.0375727862,
-0.0105243232,
0.0009390031,
0.0225949753,
0.0043504573,
-0.017166283,
-0.0183458924,
-0.0054373848,
-0.0212113876,
-0.0042018564,
-0.0395238884,
-0.0582152009,
0.0536446944,
0.0219201967,
-0.0404276513,
-0.0719081983,
0.0336071961,
0.0287164599,
0.0411603227,
-0.01175969,
-0.0171063542,
-0.0764948726,
-0.0166538898,
0.0605865754,
0.0076822238,
0.0536354445,
-0.0311865881,
0.0640691817,
-0.0126600675,
-0.0132003669,
0.0127748121,
-0.0182703622,
-0.0099856295,
0.0118519636,
0.0394208096,
0.0189318396,
0.0490579754,
0.0030613977,
-0.0057955775,
0.0405898429,
0.0000884141,
-0.0008898666,
0.0635482296,
0.0023227516,
0.0181013849,
-0.0432284661,
-0.0353912003,
-0.016089607,
0.0477754325,
0.0142312758,
-0.0897352323,
-0.0036317154,
-0.0059871743,
2.755e-7,
0.0785651579,
0.0270955861,
0.0185723193,
0.0069023459,
0.0369926989,
-0.0241645984,
-0.0005492675,
0.0172599573,
0.0098227225,
-0.0429591648,
0.020719165,
-0.0165017303,
-0.0049870703,
0.0142416321,
-0.0647141039,
-0.0433909819,
-0.0437603854,
-0.0291243084,
-0.0448566638,
0.0003822231,
0.0034603376,
0.0411909334,
-0.0329671092,
0.0040712352,
-0.017181335,
0.0132840928,
0.0280558616,
-0.038284,
0.0424329452,
0.0415708758,
-0.0036663653,
0.0433713682,
-0.0109773716,
0.0349737443,
-0.0254080761,
0.0144014535,
0.0067912051,
0.0310826562,
-0.0106124077,
0.0164103359,
0.0276180524,
-0.0118933069,
0.0442218706,
-0.0034576454,
0.0376779549,
-0.0848735496,
-0.0585842989,
0.0030737077,
-0.0071500693,
-0.0322982222,
0.027531296,
-0.0264672767,
-0.0011416337,
0.0472982712,
-0.0185165592,
-0.023921065,
-0.0004427569,
-0.0723737702,
-0.0143637611,
0.0461193211,
-0.016339479,
-0.016174376,
0.0026930457,
-0.0406433977,
-0.0077983891,
-0.0640540048,
-0.0161749776,
2.729704972e-34,
0.0412774906,
-0.0094647584,
-0.0136824986,
0.0524468981,
0.0422548465,
-0.0400005132,
-0.0154551687,
0.0027980716,
-0.0231604967,
-0.1056184098,
0.0198933203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20410v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20410v3 | FollowBench: A Multi-level Fine-grained Constraints Following Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2023-10-31T12:32:38 | 2024-06-05T15:39:26 | Yuxin Jiang, Yufei Wang, Xingshan Zeng, Wanjun Zhong, Liangyou Li, Fei Mi, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The ability to follow instructions is crucial for Large Language Models
(LLMs) to handle various real-world applications. Existing benchmarks primarily
focus on evaluating pure response quality, rather than assessing whether the
response follows constraints stated in the instruction. To fill this research
gap, in this paper, we propose FollowBench, a Multi-level Fine-grained
Constraints Following Benchmark for LLMs. FollowBench comprehensively includes
five different types (i.e., Content, Situation, Style, Format, and Example) of
fine-grained constraints. To enable a precise constraint following estimation
on diverse difficulties, we introduce a Multi-level mechanism that
incrementally adds a single constraint to the initial instruction at each
increased level. To assess whether LLMs' outputs have satisfied every
individual constraint, we propose to prompt strong LLMs with
constraint-evolution paths to handle challenging open-ended instructions. By
evaluating 13 closed-source and open-source popular LLMs on FollowBench, we
highlight the weaknesses of LLMs in instruction following and point towards
potential avenues for future work. The data and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/YJiangcm/FollowBench. | [
0.0536402985,
0.0922647119,
-0.0071723233,
0.0418790616,
-0.0311371125,
0.0021264651,
-0.0161017254,
0.0171841048,
-0.0180911869,
-0.0446203761,
0.0035849246,
-0.0113290409,
-0.0107000917,
0.0109473728,
0.0410043485,
-0.0644834489,
0.0465545133,
-0.0739704818,
-0.016732702,
-0.001253648,
0.0322798602,
0.0097653577,
-0.0147606377,
0.0472646281,
0.0049158484,
-0.0187703725,
-0.0026172532,
0.0221841279,
0.0072647501,
-0.0193307307,
0.0322313718,
0.063766323,
0.0080824113,
0.0410359949,
0.0000021154,
-0.0675866753,
-0.0269417409,
-0.0028253011,
-0.0059355567,
0.063448146,
0.0129868053,
-0.0395495072,
-0.0340471528,
0.0188877955,
-0.0170590039,
0.0253241826,
0.0337682031,
0.0116704172,
0.076587528,
0.0801411867,
-0.0035438139,
-0.0201574396,
0.0064673079,
-0.0226748809,
-0.0096316542,
-0.0496175289,
0.0160143524,
0.0098147457,
0.0524396449,
0.0390830785,
-0.019766368,
0.0173357166,
0.0233295765,
-0.0082143303,
-0.0508464985,
0.0004158811,
-0.0642662942,
-0.0243130941,
-0.0137753412,
0.0833711624,
0.0163306128,
-0.0171432123,
-0.0095733181,
-0.0394176021,
0.0015126263,
0.0124905519,
-0.0637393072,
0.0030125089,
0.0064631547,
0.0022513361,
-0.0005754693,
-0.0159635656,
0.0072268639,
-0.0095144678,
-0.0115537383,
0.0607882887,
0.0252820067,
-0.0471011475,
-0.0148549043,
-0.0081957309,
-0.0337708853,
-0.0515944995,
0.002077597,
0.0132864779,
-0.0553814396,
0.004443998,
-0.0574504323,
-0.0041623893,
0.0309341159,
-0.0083919559,
0.0612888746,
0.0407335721,
-0.0139860688,
0.0384503156,
-0.0052311756,
0.1102778241,
-0.0396132022,
-0.0027252927,
-0.0363858603,
0.0256894678,
-0.016672276,
0.0113463113,
-0.0316027366,
0.0019518513,
-0.0314577408,
-0.0227325559,
-0.018004654,
0.0337702669,
-0.0127667561,
0.0617778823,
-0.0100729698,
-0.0377202183,
-0.0185661614,
-0.0166924316,
0.0031846808,
0.0242563877,
-0.0555340536,
-0.0156746935,
0.0003644507,
-0.0160239264,
-0.0010696794,
0.0260650236,
-0.0085119037,
-0.0368447118,
0.0124446154,
0.0557789356,
0.0245028716,
-0.0106795076,
-0.0338166319,
-0.0181846637,
-0.009470921,
-0.0612236336,
-0.0123717077,
-0.0800897777,
-0.0088141002,
0.0143091381,
-0.0010441911,
-0.034109395,
0.0061367722,
-0.0041595856,
-0.0143058812,
0.0178992767,
0.0231457315,
0.0077854241,
-0.0400522798,
0.0314782336,
0.0321285687,
0.0781221539,
0.0313734822,
0.0309658647,
0.0517990962,
-0.0160417147,
-0.009208967,
0.0771781281,
0.0108655468,
0.0375215188,
-0.0162297953,
0.013607692,
0.0231972858,
0.0506532677,
0.0413509943,
0.0573572107,
-0.0090220943,
-0.0069145043,
0.0605050996,
0.0274236072,
0.0376021639,
0.0092877354,
0.0536233559,
0.0272042342,
-0.0082190866,
0.060157232,
-0.0624636672,
0.0058117537,
-0.0077663036,
0.0318950191,
0.0304661412,
0.0478811599,
-0.0200933497,
-0.0263209306,
0.0003820454,
0.0058069001,
-0.0245201215,
-0.0130370194,
0.0375489481,
0.0040973127,
-0.0536083989,
0.0469963513,
0.0411141403,
-0.0503556915,
-0.0120286671,
-0.0381837375,
0.021885464,
0.0572937131,
0.0698577836,
-0.0338709131,
-0.0415040702,
0.0278736353,
0.0444724299,
0.0614228472,
0.0629887208,
-0.009433399,
0.0347708054,
-0.0463185981,
-0.0231340304,
-0.0000011063,
0.0097907856,
0.0107464176,
0.0367557518,
-0.0261253081,
0.002183493,
0.0034721147,
-0.0268978253,
0.0330473892,
-0.0340502821,
-0.0354538076,
-0.0370718762,
-0.0082244622,
0.0140935257,
0.0308660083,
-0.0009754124,
0.0030011088,
0.0238718521,
-0.0347595513,
0.0398657173,
-0.0110773668,
-0.0498147346,
-0.0404703766,
0.0196620431,
-0.0271818433,
-0.016251564,
0.0401141383,
-0.0380310751,
-0.0447546281,
0.0388170145,
-0.0035980078,
0.0490723774,
0.0010738961,
0.0260862522,
-0.0271493252,
0.0019388404,
-0.03233831,
0.0282729995,
-0.0034298394,
0.0433229282,
0.0599674173,
-0.0071904999,
-0.0348162912,
-0.0142792407,
-0.0433642566,
-0.0103269629,
-0.0080354977,
0.0233241599,
0.0258481596,
0.0457811244,
-0.0404798761,
-0.0362735353,
-0.0518261045,
0.03801753,
-0.0265397262,
0.0493242256,
0.0139802657,
0.0266165007,
-0.0386330076,
0.0079941405,
-0.0178619418,
-0.0105818091,
-0.006650981,
0.0189348571,
-0.006571773,
0.0406055264,
-0.0431259908,
-0.0503934175,
-0.0163057428,
-0.01290516,
0.0172975902,
-0.009887971,
0.0165098198,
-0.0712319538,
0.0198892429,
-0.0297002066,
0.0451856367,
-0.0195207447,
-0.0295089651,
0.0263151228,
-0.0053173862,
0.0634346828,
0.0296827983,
-0.0185558945,
0.0095266076,
0.0370751284,
-0.0401649512,
-0.0804601982,
0.0220022146,
-0.0155277355,
-0.0354958773,
-0.0559965596,
-0.04386051,
0.0152771976,
0.0820828825,
-0.0097065773,
-0.0012138032,
-0.0560757294,
0.00727882,
-0.0200291649,
0.0018487447,
0.0174092073,
-0.0202206597,
-0.0439573973,
0.0286402535,
-0.0210920926,
-0.0493096299,
0.0621881895,
-0.0727039054,
-0.0228408165,
0.0120653994,
0.0180054475,
-0.0481103696,
0.070922941,
0.0384210572,
0.0236984175,
0.0297203958,
-0.0171949528,
-0.0433949456,
0.0349738188,
0.0369163714,
-0.0249211956,
0.0708640665,
-0.051799953,
-0.0093417028,
-0.0319511779,
-0.0258551668,
-0.0239040162,
-0.0440091453,
-0.0060758125,
0.0034090083,
0.0495353863,
-0.0462229699,
-0.0051421709,
0.0165726785,
0.0242362469,
0.0445016921,
-0.0275662839,
-0.0015465228,
-0.0555219986,
0.0064577279,
0.0692348257,
0.0292234495,
0.006573569,
-0.0510902368,
0.012236868,
0.0422189496,
0.0388382114,
0.0084791938,
-0.0287937019,
0.0168999843,
0.0508722141,
-0.0216728486,
-0.0195290893,
0.0305052698,
0.0827277601,
-0.0636692643,
-0.0278840531,
0.1135285944,
0.0350203887,
-0.046075888,
0.0170081351,
-0.035209693,
0.1072391197,
0.03510914,
0.0471531413,
-0.0865161791,
-0.0368920006,
0.0208495725,
0.0472605489,
-0.0021205682,
-0.0133768898,
-0.0131404167,
-0.1281239986,
0.0316560194,
0.0082391249,
-0.0403857864,
-0.0132614635,
-0.049952466,
0.0178784765,
0.0124889454,
0.0238655731,
0.0222542416,
-0.0262150653,
-0.0309681427,
0.0127679622,
-0.0411769412,
-0.0633153245,
0.0368639529,
-0.0636344925,
0.0814606994,
0.0541132763,
-0.0081727533,
-0.0010208121,
0.0127473827,
0.0685632229,
-0.0165300034,
-0.0093749436,
-0.0183271859,
-0.0032435011,
0.0094508547,
-0.005334985,
-0.0141144488,
0.0125389267,
-0.0268869735,
0.0072741774,
0.0271797907,
0.0710110739,
0.0011030388,
-0.0114936261,
-0.028976541,
-0.0041402509,
-0.0152826617,
0.0707067549,
0.0591478124,
-0.0710000843,
-0.0271055866,
-0.0565879978,
-0.0216306485,
-0.0642464459,
-0.0283532869,
0.0077265231,
-0.030675374,
0.0219087843,
-0.0660752729,
-0.0242830645,
0.0031772247,
0.0449909903,
0.0096201394,
-0.0020658111,
0.0330138467,
-0.0496450737,
0.0052345754,
0.0124070719,
-0.0249301512,
0.023312699,
-0.0872715786,
-0.0101961344,
-0.001363171,
0.002321986,
-0.0092911851,
0.0315698385,
-0.1007912904,
-0.0881319866,
-0.0201261938,
0.057512261,
0.0266820379,
0.0513005219,
-0.0062038591,
-0.0698492751,
-0.0501456968,
0.0108253993,
-0.0017663055,
0.0253016334,
0.025561804,
-0.0302623827,
-0.0117287617,
0.0358980894,
-0.0363163128,
0.0245215856,
-0.0186574087,
0.070748046,
-0.022278389,
-0.0667039081,
0.0245308746,
-0.0024307184,
-0.0028686768,
-0.0105316294,
-0.0495732278,
-0.0191067718,
0.026974652,
-0.0239201225,
-0.0212545954,
-0.043856442,
-0.0032049199,
0.0037371248,
-0.0219927318,
0.0124406861,
-0.0163329095,
-0.0110995742,
0.0362917706,
-0.097830601,
0.0463642552,
0.005676215,
0.0082113082,
0.0434287824,
-0.015722923,
0.0028404745,
0.0457521491,
-0.0200140979,
0.0417113863,
-0.0211280677,
0.0602891184,
0.0150868725,
0.000380914,
0.0005120821,
0.014100871,
-0.0415463373,
0.0085287187,
-0.0284675676,
-0.0054548145,
0.042932421,
-0.0067858174,
0.0778068751,
0.0060442579,
0.009738286,
-0.0234358888,
0.0433071107,
0.0015049411,
-0.0519743636,
0.019868128,
0.0623018332,
0.011833488,
0.0248460397,
0.0755722672,
0.0460891426,
0.0191859249,
0.0205129925,
0.0260154139,
-0.0272492748,
-0.0472826175,
0.0120549854,
0.0128321387,
-0.0350831151,
-0.0015279743,
-0.0571018793,
-0.0652437955,
-0.0235048868,
0.0275216289,
-0.0033612035,
-0.0294721965,
0.0084003117,
0.0310646743,
-0.0003500641,
-0.0070182765,
-0.0357793756,
-0.0302101336,
-0.0130898682,
-0.0262496546,
-0.000050976,
-6.965836994e-33,
-0.0406996123,
-0.0102970032,
0.0184094794,
-0.0128706498,
-0.0192167964,
0.0002064856,
-0.0618689023,
0.0035199011,
0.0113060065,
-0.0363387018,
-0.0030201816,
-0.0111291725,
-0.0055412129,
0.0082374811,
0.0010228547,
0.017089149,
0.0249477625,
0.0091719804,
-0.0487865657,
0.0216416735,
0.011158267,
-0.0094692716,
0.0227369424,
-0.0204886328,
0.0314041935,
-0.0412712209,
-0.0356149785,
0.0102413734,
-0.0126834968,
0.0986282974,
-0.0140290121,
0.0218606927,
0.0185907632,
-0.0337156579,
-0.0414617471,
0.0021219712,
-0.0563060418,
-0.0273677353,
0.0304104853,
-0.0035311303,
-0.0366806276,
-0.0162613355,
0.0386126973,
0.006093265,
-0.0223149713,
0.0138392327,
0.0111836465,
-0.0078310575,
-0.019536756,
-0.0095540993,
-0.0733905882,
0.0353300609,
-0.0185517017,
-0.0268580988,
0.0051475908,
0.0479008481,
0.0248792395,
0.0002463709,
0.0171083938,
0.0222888719,
0.0341355763,
0.0754556283,
0.0725110397,
-0.0052804258,
-0.0195916332,
0.0431986824,
-0.0487817749,
-0.0040600398,
-0.0053574136,
-0.0183363222,
0.0606223419,
0.0434291661,
0.0372253768,
0.0359768532,
0.0031366004,
0.0026200521,
-0.0376460217,
0.0297927,
0.0025129791,
0.0443535596,
0.0278789289,
0.0392216966,
-0.0573844016,
-0.0211144183,
-0.0314222574,
0.0194585603,
-0.0475265272,
0.0015106213,
0.0535394065,
0.0100451922,
-0.0452726446,
-0.0006789558,
0.0421998203,
-0.0250990149,
-0.0417799987,
0.011778784,
-0.0456985831,
0.0421204604,
-0.0226844251,
0.0657508522,
-0.0656193718,
-0.0557822995,
0.0330140069,
-0.0452748649,
0.0454013385,
0.0105836317,
0.0319018438,
0.0306726843,
-0.0750660673,
-0.004252159,
-0.0344663151,
0.0271087345,
-0.0226264689,
-0.0049325447,
0.0412255898,
-0.0275868513,
-0.0080576567,
0.0643095151,
0.0346386619,
-0.0285590887,
-0.044114396,
0.0147183137,
0.0002825401,
0.0142101636,
-0.0372748077,
-0.0112506188,
-0.0262431595,
0.0222426616,
0.0047641098,
-0.0434853509,
-0.0366408713,
0.0105495928,
2.784e-7,
0.0254145209,
0.0723163709,
0.0260155797,
0.0476819724,
0.0213243086,
0.0123891952,
-0.019159615,
0.0119969612,
-0.0007793515,
-0.0117142098,
0.0000550128,
0.018876845,
0.0497145616,
0.0296179391,
-0.0685487986,
0.0468834862,
-0.0559614301,
0.0174632166,
-0.0687744319,
0.003007533,
0.0548933744,
0.0804471895,
-0.0162568875,
0.0174309518,
-0.00307905,
-0.0438502878,
0.0395155586,
-0.0296707563,
-0.0022724755,
0.0361708142,
-0.0111764017,
0.0198514108,
-0.0170193762,
-0.0014401467,
-0.0122857084,
0.009775077,
-0.0007708198,
0.0893738493,
0.0268867705,
-0.0037123424,
0.0189557541,
-0.0034605728,
-0.0024393213,
-0.051803425,
0.0539811626,
0.0049161166,
-0.0096690329,
-0.0601936765,
0.0054035652,
-0.0469726175,
-0.040750023,
-0.0208382346,
-0.0143601708,
0.002431876,
0.0261929724,
-0.0345355421,
-0.0345552079,
-0.0770761296,
-0.0378368758,
0.006442681,
-0.0164930485,
-0.035164699,
-0.0582586974,
0.0005862036,
-0.0134880282,
-0.0700398386,
-0.0106699392,
3.20521838e-34,
0.0502334237,
-0.030756345,
0.0383339003,
0.0262502041,
0.033602383,
0.0016705182,
-0.0551359914,
0.0279552285,
0.024546992,
-0.0972875506,
-0.0418885052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20384v1 | Do large language models solve verbal analogies like children do? | 2023-10-31T11:49:11 | 2023-10-31T11:49:11 | Claire E. Stevenson, Mathilde ter Veen, Rochelle Choenni, Han L. J. van der Maas, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Analogy-making lies at the heart of human cognition. Adults solve analogies
such as \textit{Horse belongs to stable like chicken belongs to ...?} by
mapping relations (\textit{kept in}) and answering \textit{chicken coop}. In
contrast, children often use association, e.g., answering \textit{egg}. This
paper investigates whether large language models (LLMs) solve verbal analogies
in A:B::C:? form using associations, similar to what children do. We use verbal
analogies extracted from an online adaptive learning environment, where 14,002
7-12 year-olds from the Netherlands solved 622 analogies in Dutch. The six
tested Dutch monolingual and multilingual LLMs performed around the same level
as children, with MGPT performing worst, around the 7-year-old level, and XLM-V
and GPT-3 the best, slightly above the 11-year-old level. However, when we
control for associative processes this picture changes and each model's
performance level drops 1-2 years. Further experiments demonstrate that
associative processes often underlie correctly solved analogies. We conclude
that the LLMs we tested indeed tend to solve verbal analogies by association
with C like children do. | [
0.0255724434,
0.033972621,
-0.0421145819,
0.0407584831,
-0.033746209,
0.0249595139,
0.0234624594,
-0.0057229251,
0.0136711961,
-0.0527130365,
-0.0408098511,
-0.0353223644,
0.0042264475,
-0.050981842,
0.0112864282,
-0.0457545891,
0.0503791086,
-0.0176507719,
-0.0018639483,
-0.0141334701,
-0.0217711255,
0.0166886505,
-0.0517124645,
0.0284933969,
0.0160651896,
-0.0168822594,
0.0399442129,
-0.0477568097,
0.0336274691,
-0.0394064635,
-0.0108356187,
-0.0051531582,
0.0271774363,
0.0085939514,
0.0000020373,
-0.0936854333,
0.0457306691,
-0.0246454962,
-0.0046016066,
0.0581145212,
-0.000147283,
0.033179611,
-0.0142856371,
-0.0024292176,
-0.0150758149,
-0.0299731959,
0.0994716659,
-0.0065595829,
-0.0020792359,
0.0090261791,
-0.0055988538,
-0.0619466566,
0.0289793983,
0.0248555671,
0.0333833955,
-0.0106795831,
0.00046124,
0.0167276114,
0.0281332787,
-0.0499847084,
-0.0112243881,
-0.0038148647,
0.0171499215,
-0.0017989691,
-0.0000848534,
0.0238374677,
0.0145450672,
-0.0078072804,
0.0143852709,
0.0287757553,
-0.0063706613,
-0.032468766,
-0.0050972113,
0.0075150095,
0.0161863063,
0.0669587702,
-0.0886319056,
0.0441137962,
-0.0126388697,
0.0329691507,
0.0345775075,
-0.0258072577,
-0.004049988,
0.0431201123,
-0.0016427475,
0.060634274,
-0.0174389947,
-0.0124487868,
0.0228426531,
0.0388339944,
-0.0237387661,
-0.0421670191,
0.0113460748,
0.026950404,
0.000279285,
0.0181880314,
-0.0275900904,
-0.0107020289,
-0.0119709112,
-0.0927710608,
0.0603486598,
0.0487534627,
0.0056972285,
0.0412346795,
-0.1115735993,
0.0474168509,
-0.0237388685,
0.0544421822,
-0.0369430371,
0.0068565253,
-0.074038364,
-0.0238086339,
-0.0511435643,
0.0617897585,
0.059208557,
-0.0052747661,
-0.0392101221,
0.0158975963,
-0.020453006,
-0.0497384295,
-0.0573996939,
0.005771548,
0.0140927378,
-0.0383657254,
-0.0928808153,
0.0398025587,
-0.0552989841,
0.059422873,
-0.0297166705,
-0.0287520681,
0.0249724127,
-0.0273576826,
0.0263975766,
-0.0469661318,
0.0139062386,
0.0760764256,
-0.0669003054,
0.0237668753,
-0.0124348151,
0.0064383154,
0.0310714208,
-0.0509721264,
0.0397345684,
-0.0527198948,
0.0170567837,
0.0429093093,
0.0210935827,
-0.0628760308,
-0.0023092078,
0.0135780554,
-0.0849083886,
0.0510581248,
0.040657606,
0.0296074804,
-0.0210652743,
-0.0123197669,
0.0055570626,
0.0137917968,
0.0412287042,
-0.0510852076,
-0.0242123585,
-0.0397161953,
-0.0519947931,
0.0140728988,
-0.0135994097,
-0.0021151647,
-0.0433491915,
-0.0090016518,
0.0165269747,
0.059553083,
0.0421482399,
0.0625366867,
-0.004715567,
-0.0317399502,
0.0871789977,
0.0517563075,
-0.0001853446,
0.0508015379,
-0.0006967946,
-0.008875424,
0.0600925647,
0.0012655692,
-0.0375857204,
0.0520314388,
-0.0350330658,
-0.0028379911,
-0.0137219075,
0.0679952353,
-0.0307089221,
0.0002247053,
-0.0384069867,
0.0237818472,
0.0126957353,
-0.0205259584,
0.0172562636,
0.0231458545,
0.0001530325,
-0.0051295552,
0.0218071621,
-0.0197676402,
0.0214473251,
-0.0788167939,
0.0252688471,
0.0190234426,
0.0003232143,
0.0044817086,
-0.0106033189,
-0.0050954153,
-0.0031699645,
0.0335391089,
0.0438343845,
-0.0202743597,
-0.0364733189,
-0.0136840176,
0.0089434665,
0.0176838506,
-0.0122105395,
-0.0056737754,
-0.0359892547,
-0.0023573523,
-0.0320225358,
-0.0140851466,
0.0422361121,
0.0102214692,
-0.0396117494,
-0.0209533591,
-0.0129741784,
0.023862388,
0.0151808476,
-0.009836778,
0.0121986493,
0.0389695689,
0.0021706587,
-0.0490754396,
-0.0218254868,
0.0633183122,
-0.0449769832,
0.0088061607,
0.024901785,
-0.0204605646,
0.0087473309,
-0.0177239385,
0.0139666097,
-0.0034320971,
0.0663975254,
-0.0439171679,
0.1209020466,
0.0287870038,
0.0544294231,
-0.031548854,
-0.0230931602,
-0.0134848356,
0.0817535296,
0.0093294811,
-0.0012600176,
-0.0290698856,
0.0037207797,
-0.0128076067,
0.0254334398,
-0.0050747171,
0.0107447803,
-0.0143109057,
0.0068003442,
-0.0036495028,
-0.0172806252,
-0.0415588543,
0.0158267245,
-0.033433523,
0.0093441643,
0.0604555979,
0.024986146,
0.0310163535,
-0.0128306542,
-0.0012356107,
-0.0088427719,
0.0005533955,
0.0651282221,
-0.0236880574,
0.080597803,
0.0091282297,
-0.0252324566,
-0.0430785231,
-0.0119715491,
-0.0298851375,
-0.05069343,
0.0475590602,
0.0079987738,
-0.0229301918,
-0.0128761074,
0.0134287076,
-0.0505939573,
0.012452445,
-0.0004670137,
-0.0165507868,
0.0287236534,
0.0215740744,
0.0498620458,
0.083505705,
0.0041625998,
0.0074461875,
0.089472346,
-0.012469803,
-0.0632276833,
-0.0069215167,
0.0147871654,
-0.0433750115,
-0.0000065813,
-0.0433826372,
-0.0492762476,
0.1043095961,
0.03157207,
-0.0008755456,
-0.0272870716,
0.0587831512,
0.0105455955,
0.0251735356,
-0.0720570683,
-0.060869813,
-0.0185835715,
0.019931715,
-0.0217105094,
-0.0284371153,
0.0540679283,
0.0465177,
0.0060842852,
-0.0392867699,
0.0181647874,
0.0023348276,
0.0665336251,
0.0019454162,
0.0451139323,
0.0300724432,
-0.0062042153,
-0.0839594603,
-0.0472368933,
0.0129928989,
-0.0196914822,
0.1077466831,
-0.051375024,
0.0454924926,
-0.0028987327,
-0.0489213876,
-0.0219212491,
0.0018000287,
-0.0618901625,
-0.0004106415,
-0.0504629761,
-0.0171772707,
-0.0539463535,
-0.0002730966,
0.0460889824,
-0.0036983779,
-0.0285078436,
-0.0183925871,
0.0157814976,
0.0203852504,
0.028896248,
0.0051741446,
0.0021597745,
-0.0180958156,
0.0399405733,
0.0254786499,
0.0308744311,
-0.0021958952,
0.0033068897,
0.0119260158,
0.0109940954,
-0.0406483077,
-0.0134346904,
0.0270197168,
-0.0004885379,
-0.0536020249,
-0.0048878081,
0.0237231907,
0.0497503914,
-0.0036239435,
0.0325045474,
-0.025643168,
0.0392698906,
0.025281731,
0.0092088524,
-0.0350242406,
-0.0066401851,
0.0042474768,
-0.0646716133,
-0.0030087025,
-0.0404708758,
0.0115146441,
-0.1106695235,
-0.0098974174,
0.013412429,
-0.1003620476,
0.0008243098,
-0.009126992,
0.0473948605,
0.0263267942,
0.0066002673,
0.0259328447,
-0.0668478981,
-0.0121196052,
0.0311095286,
0.020818796,
0.0082165487,
0.002031737,
-0.0234745741,
0.0886046588,
0.0169221777,
0.0012841249,
-0.0183665305,
-0.034489356,
0.0406282768,
0.0072496091,
-0.0116666984,
-0.0163785908,
0.0116999503,
0.0449915975,
0.0106257768,
-0.0408661254,
0.0049679866,
0.0098601878,
-0.0416654386,
0.0206044801,
0.079867579,
-0.0094215488,
-0.0449882671,
-0.0179011375,
0.0073854104,
-0.0531419255,
0.0708147436,
0.0341476016,
-0.0475334935,
0.0075280289,
-0.0250630099,
-0.0420190915,
-0.0175449345,
-0.0575537235,
0.0212051552,
-0.0190479625,
0.0335688815,
-0.0626613051,
0.0114592807,
0.0363638662,
0.0034820999,
0.0183538105,
-0.0190823618,
0.0251231845,
-0.0294749923,
-0.0314665996,
0.0169014409,
-0.0240626223,
0.0063878112,
-0.0264120661,
-0.0216497742,
0.0549885072,
-0.0385639183,
-0.0220496878,
-0.0320310183,
-0.0443382747,
-0.0299700648,
0.0282888934,
-0.0029981101,
0.0298157502,
-0.0112895025,
0.0517240614,
-0.0625476912,
-0.0003870289,
-0.0023938119,
0.0431404822,
0.0176224392,
-0.0636457428,
0.026938118,
0.0116067771,
0.0102343289,
-0.022674514,
0.0239909459,
0.033530768,
0.0397566967,
-0.0177721698,
0.0057196831,
0.031012876,
-0.0032351646,
-0.0306719691,
0.0226012748,
-0.0388114527,
-0.0316684246,
0.0032443213,
0.0145660434,
0.0103225233,
0.0215269607,
-0.0520098396,
0.0285018273,
0.0410968438,
0.0073696887,
-0.0838372409,
-0.0068934876,
0.0370967798,
0.0367167555,
0.0312864445,
-0.0173262525,
0.0288738646,
0.0189996064,
0.0476671718,
-0.0018967057,
0.0192885865,
0.036010392,
0.0648936257,
-0.0368047543,
0.0337290093,
-0.0031435392,
-0.0199988987,
-0.020504022,
-0.0297477096,
-0.0120769683,
-0.0490258373,
-0.0208415985,
0.0391479023,
0.0179202203,
-0.048226729,
0.028113544,
-0.053095866,
0.0107629607,
-0.0202961992,
-0.0363609418,
-0.026657423,
-0.0301076658,
0.0645241365,
0.0136234313,
0.0278909709,
-0.0029359718,
0.0181852467,
-0.0422958173,
0.0587910637,
-0.016012989,
-0.006799845,
0.002330486,
-0.0056526698,
0.0205699597,
0.0072099227,
-0.0180817377,
0.0048100241,
-0.040485695,
-0.0584126003,
-0.0527224913,
0.0002828715,
-0.0108476942,
-0.049465064,
0.0186832286,
0.0070550023,
0.0019512658,
-0.0345033146,
0.0075797029,
0.0556837581,
-0.0687675551,
-0.0320233703,
-0.0447903164,
-6.547241987e-33,
-0.0423787273,
-0.0030824523,
0.0054387492,
-0.0469885059,
0.0162011813,
-0.0189535767,
-0.0328463353,
0.0267192796,
-0.063831754,
-0.0047848434,
-0.0021106834,
-0.0491048321,
0.0098999655,
-0.0109064793,
0.0400855206,
-0.021377787,
-0.0054771919,
-0.0192125607,
0.0128997723,
-0.0491592772,
0.0191014186,
-0.0519941747,
0.0606372394,
-0.0562064871,
-0.0166773051,
0.0014608037,
-0.010177589,
0.0099442415,
-0.0139630269,
0.0840559825,
-0.0006673597,
0.0490190983,
0.0522197038,
0.0509646311,
0.0058296463,
0.0325584337,
-0.0644649342,
-0.0467606746,
0.0650994331,
-0.010670987,
-0.007185658,
-0.0144618703,
0.0658427998,
0.0167483967,
-0.0374162644,
-0.0078284508,
0.0343673043,
-0.0284721944,
0.0038675298,
0.0398474745,
-0.097591579,
-0.0571167395,
0.0044310754,
-0.0188480765,
-0.0238220543,
0.0296785012,
-0.0244631823,
0.0116881449,
-0.0465243086,
0.0455195531,
0.015903214,
0.0204343665,
0.043074429,
0.0285308938,
0.0026795515,
0.0460307486,
0.0346865579,
0.0111865848,
-0.0048994296,
-0.0003007785,
0.0443041474,
0.0130603323,
0.0246279463,
0.0040433095,
0.0710552037,
0.0070858835,
-0.0144384839,
0.0018068718,
0.0829652995,
0.0365874879,
0.0297170039,
0.0417283997,
-0.0060742954,
-0.0078855976,
-0.0237700175,
0.0194648802,
-0.0527133159,
-0.0647576824,
0.0265610088,
-0.0607468896,
0.0182925109,
-0.0045710709,
0.028122697,
-0.0068330872,
-0.0585113131,
-0.0386936739,
0.015298578,
0.0622785315,
-0.0373038165,
0.0068451073,
-0.0663030222,
-0.0658001229,
-0.0300732497,
0.0157503132,
0.0382202677,
0.0593373328,
0.0018353622,
-0.019471189,
-0.0936416015,
0.0067480085,
-0.0381855853,
-0.0448705517,
0.0239985585,
-0.0657484978,
0.012733927,
0.0162497777,
0.0205394682,
0.036071416,
0.0215231404,
-0.0579701774,
-0.0514925085,
-0.0022910051,
-0.0758232474,
0.0125444615,
0.0186437741,
0.0380047038,
-0.0364018977,
0.010941078,
0.0321819112,
-0.0523927547,
-0.0091494098,
0.0202222709,
2.903e-7,
0.0200227089,
0.0533490777,
-0.0216369275,
-0.0171833653,
0.0131727541,
0.0213111117,
-0.0023271581,
-0.02832314,
0.0576097369,
0.0341181383,
-0.0107103037,
0.0212275628,
0.0335953534,
0.0449126549,
-0.0328128152,
0.0070408247,
-0.0861819237,
0.0374512896,
-0.0326348692,
0.0199364014,
0.0199706797,
0.0168819316,
0.0362528265,
-0.029807955,
-0.0740571022,
-0.0565164648,
0.0317051895,
-0.0285398383,
0.0158187579,
0.0067605893,
-0.0449044891,
-0.0052735112,
0.0135960393,
0.060134992,
0.0320830755,
0.0193690248,
0.0205860157,
-0.0123641929,
-0.0145459576,
0.0474351831,
-0.0102335531,
-0.0390859619,
0.0082386062,
-0.0721403807,
0.0424348935,
-0.0619864613,
0.001928414,
0.0184706245,
0.017663056,
0.0044071879,
-0.0065968116,
-0.025300527,
-0.0302028358,
0.0175519679,
0.0197437517,
0.0015055791,
-0.0050672456,
-0.0405661799,
-0.0155814793,
0.0422682688,
-0.0266866963,
-0.02461976,
-0.008410247,
0.0186250992,
0.0207056478,
0.0066421973,
-0.0167928729,
1.813347203e-34,
-0.0201142654,
0.0055175414,
0.0736501664,
0.0314559303,
0.0213111043,
0.006086221,
0.0261029936,
0.0487181395,
0.0302892141,
-0.0592687465,
-0.0080942353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20352v1 | AMERICANO: Argument Generation with Discourse-driven Decomposition and Agent Interaction | 2023-10-31T10:47:33 | 2023-10-31T10:47:33 | Zhe Hu, Hou Pong Chan, Yu Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Argument generation is a challenging task in natural language processing,
which requires rigorous reasoning and proper content organization. Inspired by
recent chain-of-thought prompting that breaks down a complex task into
intermediate steps, we propose Americano, a novel framework with agent
interaction for argument generation. Our approach decomposes the generation
process into sequential actions grounded on argumentation theory, which first
executes actions sequentially to generate argumentative discourse components,
and then produces a final argument conditioned on the components. To further
mimic the human writing process and improve the left-to-right generation
paradigm of current autoregressive language models, we introduce an argument
refinement module which automatically evaluates and refines argument drafts
based on feedback received. We evaluate our framework on the task of
counterargument generation using a subset of Reddit/CMV dataset. The results
show that our method outperforms both end-to-end and chain-of-thought prompting
methods and can generate more coherent and persuasive arguments with diverse
and rich contents. | [
0.0348060168,
0.0582136251,
0.0114218257,
-0.0045074252,
-0.0258647632,
0.0165132806,
0.011051883,
-0.0393673405,
0.020519482,
-0.0653807744,
0.0227333568,
-0.0288603511,
-0.0114096506,
0.0057052164,
-0.0069863293,
-0.0700299218,
0.0074740108,
-0.0060442043,
0.0759474188,
-0.025684759,
0.0295349285,
0.0012009767,
-0.0421998426,
0.0488501713,
-0.0215712357,
-0.0513986237,
-0.0223053787,
0.001370235,
0.039196942,
-0.0476235859,
0.0159828365,
0.065110594,
-0.0082727708,
0.0546484552,
0.0000019219,
-0.0268366542,
0.0052720252,
-0.0011526119,
-0.0173679311,
-0.006575475,
0.0724616423,
0.039111495,
-0.0126102157,
0.0356467031,
-0.0577603281,
-0.0044689397,
0.0344272591,
0.0969542414,
0.1010106057,
0.1147175655,
-0.0042843381,
-0.0236599855,
-0.000794356,
-0.0170144178,
-0.0530917384,
0.0290543325,
-0.0060437727,
0.0117339548,
0.0249619316,
0.0322027914,
0.0096711079,
0.0004279381,
0.043009501,
-0.0517924391,
-0.0144748585,
0.0206980892,
-0.0084465062,
-0.0289686099,
-0.0221882965,
0.0376052074,
0.0367644541,
-0.0372520201,
0.0309020262,
-0.0058383453,
0.0246004537,
-0.0199662372,
-0.0413314216,
0.0725150853,
-0.0203731097,
0.0328435525,
0.0660304651,
0.0296574589,
-0.0053590215,
0.0156005165,
0.033797659,
0.0108109713,
-0.0211633742,
-0.0282765832,
-0.0054144128,
-0.0055664196,
0.0044518481,
-0.0899458081,
0.000996546,
0.0242658965,
-0.0550889969,
0.009409464,
-0.0515738502,
-0.0227126423,
0.0420759916,
-0.0632936209,
0.0531362146,
0.0072149863,
0.0214117933,
0.0333572738,
-0.005786926,
0.0061950921,
-0.0334421657,
-0.0361904353,
0.0024012784,
0.0022064853,
-0.0551696643,
-0.0191029776,
-0.0318292342,
0.0309755839,
-0.0430806689,
-0.0032582139,
-0.011717259,
0.0205754191,
-0.0447332077,
-0.0013321456,
0.0221355446,
0.0313745439,
0.0026913187,
-0.0091623254,
-0.0395550393,
0.0147117255,
-0.0666321442,
0.0052792444,
0.0724407434,
-0.0051888763,
-0.0173514262,
0.0350897871,
-0.0010214918,
-0.0034910571,
-0.04338824,
0.0304318666,
-0.0340094678,
0.0491992943,
-0.0356980413,
-0.0720932558,
-0.0260799844,
-0.0477900095,
-0.0039918432,
-0.0835803747,
0.0179756619,
-0.0214799959,
-0.0347885378,
-0.02782741,
0.0226446148,
0.0419576131,
-0.0100832982,
0.0159501992,
-0.0138080772,
-0.0329091027,
0.04331173,
0.0052852011,
-0.0351284668,
0.039191179,
0.024488451,
0.0351530127,
0.0230022054,
0.0485330112,
0.0103879049,
-0.0229587443,
0.0125608053,
0.0005839776,
0.0685245022,
-0.0033581858,
-0.0782632679,
0.0300825946,
-0.0158390496,
0.0456378832,
-0.046055574,
-0.0331178494,
0.0355098434,
0.0160604585,
-0.0108354846,
0.0173515845,
0.0718433708,
0.0375991091,
-0.0029695644,
0.0153651545,
-0.0104347132,
0.0242124461,
-0.0045988602,
-0.0144812055,
0.0057258932,
0.014759195,
-0.0188903976,
-0.0679114237,
0.0125660347,
-0.0111496104,
0.0411941111,
-0.0350329168,
-0.0043272381,
0.0384609513,
-0.0197217781,
-0.0413504168,
-0.0036087658,
-0.0506566428,
-0.0315670818,
-0.024351947,
0.0423558056,
0.0172103755,
0.030989714,
-0.0077528968,
0.0028668467,
-0.0314130522,
0.1116302013,
0.0934583321,
0.0740355253,
-0.0186521653,
-0.0275420304,
-0.0254812073,
-0.0296959225,
-0.0299423188,
0.0277436655,
0.0186994467,
0.0110797184,
-0.0006948449,
0.0292585921,
0.055421371,
-0.0452386513,
0.0291007385,
0.0127853407,
-0.0018469582,
0.0301073287,
0.0138337938,
0.0102527654,
0.0447892994,
-0.0164462086,
0.0248527136,
0.0297886003,
-0.0181599725,
-0.0352236889,
0.0538396612,
-0.0206245054,
-0.0564508811,
0.0292602014,
-0.0413198657,
0.0034946636,
-0.0106775323,
-0.0181662962,
-0.0377074592,
0.0555081666,
-0.0269433297,
0.0218452327,
-0.0289511457,
-0.0041907602,
0.0345442407,
-0.0026723742,
-0.0114254821,
0.0579113364,
0.0240582936,
-0.0417379551,
0.0273410417,
0.0065663778,
0.0264475998,
-0.050827764,
0.0064557246,
-0.0043043918,
0.0085028885,
0.003958317,
0.0796161518,
0.0044460562,
-0.0424110405,
-0.0291643552,
-0.0953571051,
-0.0129868258,
-0.0339217111,
0.0174376164,
0.0386117771,
-0.0307028163,
0.0195102394,
-0.0003041911,
-0.0430992208,
-0.0191074908,
0.0255687367,
0.0179003365,
0.0607929565,
-0.0388857797,
0.0111622419,
-0.0180712324,
-0.003569467,
-0.0159915965,
0.0286537223,
0.0312254224,
0.0026898379,
-0.0377934091,
-0.0191632789,
-0.0374742597,
0.0099617243,
-0.0014150703,
-0.0460332446,
0.0637135655,
0.0336956568,
0.0651824549,
0.0613351278,
0.0546983369,
0.0504458994,
0.0091756005,
0.0120176552,
-0.0393116362,
0.008863043,
-0.0256498773,
0.07840956,
-0.0114149172,
-0.0124736493,
0.010377205,
0.0828637853,
-0.0075228489,
0.0286195371,
-0.0550222322,
0.074466683,
-0.0079563353,
-0.0265868269,
0.0307344627,
-0.0384009555,
-0.0115624694,
0.0561844856,
-0.0616998784,
-0.0106523922,
0.0700425878,
-0.0264073052,
0.0047913389,
-0.0200933665,
-0.008229143,
-0.0053646252,
0.0542395189,
0.0250561833,
0.0149220442,
0.0095511014,
0.0245632473,
-0.0146606769,
-0.0223966837,
0.0624102801,
-0.0252498705,
0.0072637643,
-0.0533247627,
0.0004490026,
0.0101746758,
-0.0443803184,
-0.0544015393,
-0.0392336361,
-0.0069038281,
0.0033590717,
-0.0114581743,
-0.0114048459,
-0.0146201486,
-0.0133155491,
0.0240756832,
0.0325123183,
-0.0225319639,
-0.0036709779,
-0.0045301123,
0.0386749394,
0.0230465513,
0.0020797143,
0.0478487611,
-0.0125698987,
0.0808182433,
0.0827615112,
0.0064036697,
-0.0304061528,
-0.0423293523,
-0.0323968939,
-0.0435337424,
-0.0366347171,
-0.0062500127,
-0.0259210225,
0.0550145134,
-0.0581468865,
0.0055706347,
0.0853352398,
0.0237316322,
-0.0005123058,
-0.0007520798,
-0.030232545,
0.0524190441,
0.0028045611,
0.0368402526,
-0.0781939402,
-0.0078052832,
-0.0165132005,
0.0118169216,
-0.039063178,
-0.0498205945,
-0.0085008852,
-0.0866148174,
0.0797350258,
0.0100166807,
0.0466744304,
0.0335668549,
-0.0345588326,
-0.0111294584,
0.0067435973,
-0.0490207039,
0.0293192063,
0.0062229214,
0.0098565826,
0.0134705501,
-0.0155803654,
0.0308596287,
-0.0265576877,
-0.0374079384,
0.0542721935,
0.01630155,
0.0627744719,
0.0524442829,
-0.0193555057,
0.0144469189,
-0.0077354917,
-0.0075373026,
-0.0245160051,
0.0039683543,
-0.001875482,
0.0101953512,
-0.0394218452,
0.0495193414,
-0.01954652,
-0.0597195402,
0.0264099706,
0.0610182583,
-0.0486467108,
-0.0425051674,
-0.0406200401,
0.0368273482,
0.0270614531,
0.0567263886,
0.0351596475,
-0.008865362,
-0.0809659064,
-0.0531604327,
-0.0093643721,
-0.0959380493,
0.0074029476,
-0.0456170179,
0.0159584079,
0.0171254929,
-0.1116973087,
-0.0777619258,
-0.0224054176,
0.0351609848,
-0.0315087289,
-0.0302606039,
0.0124302339,
-0.0358071774,
-0.0218668785,
-0.0302813239,
-0.0030471033,
0.0081757596,
0.0000630674,
-0.0266204346,
-0.0059376806,
-0.038147483,
-0.0337216333,
0.0133422501,
-0.0166934747,
-0.0761847869,
-0.0082224011,
0.0562418662,
0.0189885292,
0.0666147992,
-0.0079961075,
-0.0277035385,
0.027636515,
0.0020399671,
0.0100095598,
0.0038644604,
0.0354590118,
0.0102936476,
0.0139600877,
0.0260979217,
0.0012163628,
0.0541861802,
-0.020328911,
0.0623576455,
-0.0438992083,
0.0035878259,
0.0046222396,
0.0018840862,
0.006991914,
-0.0109646097,
-0.0105980765,
-0.0353702344,
-0.0134782046,
-0.0687132999,
-0.0269893743,
-0.0413287729,
0.0478267223,
-0.0315286182,
-0.0176091678,
0.0065503325,
0.0067722732,
-0.033671841,
0.0386132635,
0.0348989405,
0.0245476421,
0.0066748671,
0.0458942689,
-0.0040105591,
-0.0050534727,
-0.0267582946,
0.0495236777,
-0.0074562323,
0.0417589322,
-0.0286363158,
0.0832791626,
0.0262340959,
-0.0278214831,
0.0034530114,
0.0260423161,
-0.0845889971,
0.0003105703,
0.0023890743,
0.0002594783,
0.0123081123,
-0.0097527197,
0.0938869193,
-0.0463889949,
0.0006514311,
0.0116194524,
0.0538042262,
0.0178023539,
-0.0402829386,
-0.0027587102,
0.0188050848,
-0.0386473015,
-0.010292734,
0.0405161083,
-0.0590709075,
0.0001811909,
0.0307462625,
-0.0180832185,
-0.055151917,
-0.0722486749,
-0.0490945354,
0.0147854285,
0.0016043683,
-0.0207638722,
-0.0257786792,
-0.0013038008,
-0.0250763074,
0.0280119926,
0.0089862728,
0.0008737986,
0.0168459173,
0.0375888683,
-0.0158676524,
0.0026273625,
-0.0726508796,
0.0118854828,
-0.0290161874,
-0.0318949521,
-0.0250510219,
-6.065973294e-33,
-0.0114284456,
-0.047934331,
0.0353810191,
0.043143075,
-0.0140180178,
-0.0053829788,
-0.0499252081,
0.0197134148,
0.0252590422,
0.0831863359,
0.0036255603,
-0.0018303498,
0.0084519899,
0.0167866889,
-0.0078922939,
0.0163932312,
0.042133607,
-0.0237722658,
-0.0397193916,
0.0319675989,
0.0225850753,
-0.0133952312,
-0.0285375658,
-0.040569827,
0.0244027581,
-0.0131038036,
0.0006603964,
0.0191498958,
-0.0099198231,
0.0509208031,
-0.0031739718,
0.0459664427,
0.0411402807,
-0.0276676044,
0.0015036558,
0.0384838842,
-0.0609494038,
-0.0320045725,
0.0094469944,
-0.0617834516,
-0.0616775043,
-0.0234551467,
-0.003118179,
0.0072853225,
-0.0006168575,
0.0073431297,
0.0109853316,
-0.0030762593,
0.0279581826,
-0.0187999103,
-0.0775713399,
0.0321408883,
-0.0109320758,
-0.0427714773,
-0.0111853732,
0.0627171397,
0.0070622182,
0.007776225,
-0.064996846,
0.0364736654,
-0.019149458,
0.0089488756,
0.0272107273,
-0.0211393982,
-0.0059190309,
0.0667940974,
0.0063922252,
0.0392703079,
-0.0885753036,
0.0562837347,
-0.0425684266,
0.032622166,
0.0305833239,
0.0788937584,
-0.0075089168,
-0.0088457875,
-0.0572536923,
0.0009358912,
0.0614854358,
0.0226107277,
0.022070257,
-0.025756726,
0.0043932311,
-0.0037310615,
-0.0292616487,
-0.0773014873,
-0.002158006,
-0.0481215678,
-0.0149409762,
0.049339395,
-0.0435848683,
-0.0340973921,
0.0009906931,
-0.0148268286,
0.0005226281,
0.0191787444,
-0.0323929749,
-0.0112558175,
0.019376196,
0.0079134619,
-0.0244021937,
0.0241758171,
0.0350555778,
0.0280482844,
0.0075632958,
0.0055517652,
0.0253239851,
-0.0104095116,
-0.0462328009,
0.0182994846,
-0.0463785268,
0.0827657655,
-0.0321801156,
0.0117676007,
0.0037616952,
0.0296227857,
-0.004764101,
0.0591708459,
0.0070251543,
0.0034461587,
-0.0406205505,
-0.0008878245,
0.0116057973,
-0.0012459982,
-0.0268742498,
0.0220135301,
-0.0194911268,
0.0612606071,
0.0118447049,
-0.0677938536,
-0.0003724744,
0.0073903543,
2.484e-7,
0.0028939282,
0.0501708612,
0.0457762294,
-0.0030375649,
0.0372570455,
0.0315889381,
0.008556081,
0.0019961896,
-0.0038551628,
-0.0288648587,
-0.0182012971,
0.0381024331,
0.0517198928,
0.0341313109,
-0.0739277974,
-0.04370768,
-0.0997775868,
-0.0329958238,
-0.0529284216,
-0.0277385451,
0.0799735039,
0.0443015769,
0.0152598862,
0.0068284301,
-0.0189570654,
0.018724395,
0.0737832114,
0.0083744274,
-0.0014951742,
-0.0095471302,
0.0222174097,
-0.0753505453,
0.0052912552,
0.0058297128,
-0.0061710114,
-0.0008902073,
-0.0462241769,
0.0472526923,
0.0035822494,
-0.0370723009,
0.0273959991,
-0.0077091986,
0.014398762,
-0.0380719639,
0.0261249878,
-0.0695986897,
-0.0152859148,
-0.053711053,
-0.0572494455,
0.0110848853,
-0.0011120613,
-0.0310578365,
-0.0416215137,
-0.0019255425,
-0.0060760551,
0.0163513068,
0.0303458776,
-0.0615492389,
-0.03841535,
-0.0236631576,
-0.0358593054,
-0.0164232999,
-0.0222175885,
0.0020287521,
0.0183280502,
-0.0211510696,
-0.0133959567,
1.99975053e-34,
0.0396419242,
-0.024609806,
0.0065385974,
0.0044059707,
0.0385486893,
0.0175954439,
0.0153014055,
0.0069321273,
0.0445504449,
-0.0514947325,
-0.0375115871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20347v1 | Automatic Generators for a Family of Matrix Multiplication Routines with Apache TVM | 2023-10-31T10:36:26 | 2023-10-31T10:36:26 | Guillermo Alaejos, Adrián Castelló, Pedro Alonso-Jordá, Francisco D. Igual, Héctor Martínez, Enrique S. Quintana-Ortí | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the utilization of the Apache TVM open source framework to
automatically generate a family of algorithms that follow the approach taken by
popular linear algebra libraries, such as GotoBLAS2, BLIS and OpenBLAS, in
order to obtain high-performance blocked formulations of the general matrix
multiplication (GEMM). % In addition, we fully automatize the generation
process, by also leveraging the Apache TVM framework to derive a complete
variety of the processor-specific micro-kernels for GEMM. This is in contrast
with the convention in high performance libraries, which hand-encode a single
micro-kernel per architecture using Assembly code. % In global, the combination
of our TVM-generated blocked algorithms and micro-kernels for GEMM 1)~improves
portability, maintainability and, globally, streamlines the software life
cycle; 2)~provides high flexibility to easily tailor and optimize the solution
to different data types, processor architectures, and matrix operand shapes,
yielding performance on a par (or even superior for specific matrix shapes)
with that of hand-tuned libraries; and 3)~features a small memory footprint. | [
0.0373897552,
0.0010523635,
-0.0382330641,
0.053764075,
-0.0314353034,
0.0053650565,
0.0548096076,
-0.002144556,
-0.000539276,
-0.0296900366,
0.0131095396,
0.0223478545,
0.0059286598,
0.0202262923,
-0.0240745284,
-0.0110313818,
0.0169591885,
0.0235083476,
-0.086254172,
-0.0046212086,
0.0000577667,
0.034842208,
-0.0209033154,
-0.0460598618,
-0.0004503021,
-0.0472908951,
0.0150566651,
0.0172724165,
0.0297815744,
0.0706579313,
-0.0161968581,
-0.0270276982,
-0.0234761294,
0.0485272631,
0.0000021812,
0.0133393528,
0.0080283368,
0.06062603,
0.0517019741,
0.1220180392,
0.0717299134,
0.0241965912,
0.0194178354,
0.0214342382,
-0.0045899544,
-0.0178669225,
-0.0082222382,
-0.0196970347,
0.0085128583,
-0.0036570136,
0.0057327123,
-0.0070775389,
0.0040143291,
0.035665039,
0.004320235,
-0.0392129645,
0.0170132704,
0.0045614764,
0.021035485,
0.0175285041,
0.0107890423,
0.0180471223,
-0.0225932728,
0.0007131023,
0.0554808937,
0.02727901,
-0.0242688563,
0.0097840307,
-0.042964261,
0.0135805383,
-0.0160740875,
-0.0449138135,
0.0182036497,
0.0190408658,
-0.0168621521,
-0.0097166924,
-0.0079727648,
0.0322731584,
0.0070810029,
-0.0202137064,
-0.0402672961,
-0.0586927868,
0.0079198163,
-0.0200110823,
0.0315958224,
0.0857052505,
0.0740467906,
0.0187041275,
-0.068841666,
-0.0071704616,
0.0092147943,
0.0106861396,
0.0404718816,
-0.039552968,
0.0008813422,
0.0024406007,
-0.0711648539,
0.0136348698,
0.0189779419,
-0.0789985955,
0.0466004536,
0.0435371511,
0.0309134144,
-0.0051002665,
-0.0722619966,
-0.014476792,
-0.0916129127,
0.0009757204,
0.0106021892,
0.0432069525,
0.0244423468,
0.0367368981,
0.002791462,
-0.012615148,
-0.0419517085,
-0.0039599524,
-0.0708502233,
0.0515214764,
-0.0126856193,
0.0186365787,
-0.0758174583,
0.0112759722,
0.0589588992,
-0.0328060612,
-0.0131807756,
-0.0431491509,
0.0039573708,
0.0008049203,
-0.0451480635,
0.0076446547,
-0.0013350224,
0.0131631671,
-0.0236483216,
0.0033576435,
0.0255655143,
-0.0202679094,
0.0011570398,
-0.0409171507,
-0.0072935224,
0.0117555782,
-0.0228138845,
-0.0376630165,
0.0218842514,
0.007823322,
0.0356716514,
0.0134333,
0.0181249715,
0.0512190685,
0.0243052244,
0.0385661609,
-0.0191781521,
0.0391794667,
0.0218187291,
-0.0111372871,
-0.0074988422,
0.012742077,
0.0280596651,
-0.0007582597,
-0.0537322722,
0.0029445598,
-0.0041815364,
-0.0121188127,
-0.0070916698,
-0.0071326299,
0.0038728826,
-0.013701234,
-0.0249390397,
0.0193235669,
0.0449090749,
0.016886346,
-0.0045339195,
0.0500777587,
-0.015054971,
-0.0111569902,
-0.024670003,
0.0051666726,
-0.0354494452,
0.0847455338,
0.0760197565,
-0.0033317003,
0.0132970363,
-0.0175968353,
0.038219098,
0.0332478397,
-0.0219422206,
-0.0465968512,
0.0224193912,
0.0850143135,
0.0187230445,
0.0415465608,
0.023663057,
0.0166455749,
-0.0323675983,
0.0364311971,
0.0178512391,
-0.0498049483,
-0.0574773178,
0.0089541795,
0.0254096221,
-0.09210971,
-0.0721509084,
-0.0274244547,
0.0235091541,
-0.0199341439,
0.0594472215,
0.0133415172,
0.0283164214,
-0.0106087942,
-0.0107092923,
-0.0381749235,
-0.0030290016,
0.0303373113,
-0.02568122,
-0.0242425539,
0.0111224959,
-0.0030571599,
0.003119129,
0.0374152325,
0.0446850806,
-0.004091939,
0.0035450384,
-0.0135673517,
0.0055042473,
-0.0210548248,
0.0411961935,
-0.0096728541,
0.0962019861,
-0.0125984717,
-0.0114864791,
0.0592909865,
0.0193520635,
-0.0405430421,
0.0400263704,
-0.0107981311,
-0.0142640295,
-0.0959406197,
-0.0065709408,
0.0307138134,
0.0169886276,
-0.0028299699,
-0.0092516681,
0.0499427058,
0.0009069174,
-0.0148277506,
0.0643604398,
0.0402964428,
-0.0111395055,
-0.0481327176,
0.0043752836,
-0.0278041456,
0.0152618922,
0.0162604805,
0.0315049514,
-0.0181227084,
0.0272358283,
0.0727195665,
0.01465178,
-0.0060505369,
0.0763904974,
-0.0421132073,
-0.051733233,
-0.0187584534,
0.0297289081,
-0.0401842855,
-0.0170379523,
0.0421233363,
-0.0041784816,
-0.0095639797,
0.0449749716,
-0.0215256326,
-0.0264884643,
0.0310597643,
0.0409941114,
0.0374555774,
0.0014338355,
0.0134215588,
0.050933674,
-0.0451847874,
-0.0677970648,
-0.0637365282,
0.0059856274,
-0.0933504924,
0.0111409482,
-0.0346025266,
0.0047447011,
0.0219745804,
-0.0780400559,
0.0592079759,
-0.0465369187,
0.015835464,
0.0018456429,
0.0152443228,
-0.029855907,
-0.0022841312,
-0.0223566182,
-0.0310577583,
0.034650404,
0.0212815981,
-0.053254161,
0.0354546122,
0.0182994325,
0.0515751094,
-0.0003251391,
0.0407672375,
-0.0336101279,
-0.0048278426,
0.0578578338,
-0.0060171164,
-0.0054590567,
-0.0334682353,
0.0023740078,
-0.0447899401,
0.0279565193,
-0.0559588484,
0.0531504974,
0.0054585687,
-0.0255549625,
-0.0283965077,
-0.0415498056,
-0.014875209,
0.0222355705,
0.0039851489,
-0.0174727961,
-0.0255518984,
-0.0635398701,
-0.0463803299,
-0.0430980958,
-0.0201723184,
-0.0503396951,
-0.0044200392,
0.0093103508,
-0.0668995678,
0.0310147367,
0.0966192335,
0.0766124278,
0.0406985767,
-0.0302995984,
0.001387742,
0.062960647,
0.0060941693,
0.0103278682,
0.0142645938,
-0.0213296954,
0.0416661687,
0.0030032746,
-0.0180498231,
0.0550163127,
-0.0435394906,
0.0202165339,
0.0161571819,
0.0301721469,
-0.0179867595,
-0.0149384458,
-0.0350702927,
-0.0030868186,
-0.0265374761,
-0.0218430869,
-0.0518363006,
-0.0291427951,
0.0565753914,
0.0330801494,
0.0170665961,
0.087216571,
-0.0171185713,
-0.0457508862,
0.0085784113,
0.0647022128,
0.0465708412,
-0.0148446942,
0.0490257703,
-0.0238244459,
-0.0048121163,
-0.0255187675,
-0.0568847097,
0.0531254597,
-0.0252126846,
-0.0294749774,
-0.0118853645,
0.0504263602,
0.0689319894,
0.0441889465,
-0.0680213496,
0.0141670294,
0.0125647709,
0.0155172469,
0.0092545347,
0.0100896759,
-0.0000117933,
-0.0396250188,
0.0575822778,
0.0098403702,
-0.0133948857,
-0.0132629415,
-0.0503871739,
0.0058119595,
0.0402183123,
-0.028631499,
0.0296959169,
-0.0408183895,
0.0274308808,
-0.038032528,
-0.0380557477,
0.0213600826,
0.016979374,
0.0282279812,
-0.0251443535,
0.0007066849,
-0.0158957094,
-0.0031332569,
-0.1100962833,
0.0399920791,
-0.015880039,
-0.0441817939,
-0.0822792426,
-0.0378543958,
-0.0194036663,
-0.0457504168,
-0.0792473033,
0.0204040837,
0.0362778977,
0.0166715048,
-0.0454789326,
0.1014597639,
0.0003870217,
0.0047834497,
-0.0156370699,
0.0100700548,
0.0188095476,
0.0238463283,
-0.0306777973,
0.0104292985,
-0.0232830141,
-0.0250656512,
-0.0294573102,
-0.0433864146,
-0.0429043397,
-0.0304077901,
-0.0162126571,
0.0238043554,
0.0609029233,
0.0706155002,
0.0096860854,
0.0224643033,
0.0014764123,
-0.0520688631,
0.0040697842,
-0.053369917,
-0.0771709681,
-0.0682738274,
-0.0157239046,
0.0463650487,
0.0395611189,
-0.0025581617,
0.0070803198,
0.0393139981,
0.018834129,
0.0312936865,
-0.0364106558,
-0.0096237082,
-0.0117633482,
0.0890694261,
0.0072576664,
-0.0138956681,
0.0536476746,
0.0415527672,
0.0261068977,
-0.0153071415,
-0.0243687686,
0.0678763464,
-0.0161836408,
-0.0518441536,
-0.0036555966,
-0.0307914242,
0.0074702264,
-0.0489366539,
0.070647344,
0.003539098,
0.0121937441,
-0.0009643837,
-0.0515828803,
-0.043998532,
-0.0086550033,
0.0019113843,
-0.0014280486,
0.009169721,
-0.0028801276,
-0.0434494093,
0.0380490869,
-0.0478633717,
-0.0239457525,
-0.0158511549,
-0.0022303285,
-0.0192425624,
0.0530385599,
0.0169354659,
0.0465383306,
-0.002956531,
-0.0245022383,
-0.0410663337,
0.0123103298,
0.0225269143,
0.0134225292,
-0.0112405587,
-0.009628146,
0.0747072399,
0.0107504055,
-0.0333617553,
0.026884025,
-0.0249009989,
0.0295109861,
-0.0202347096,
-0.0382827595,
-0.023070462,
-0.0428151153,
-0.0202040561,
-0.0207782909,
0.037797004,
0.041343201,
0.0132202925,
-0.0398560502,
-0.0205912776,
-0.0570005178,
0.0305208713,
-0.064270474,
0.0097229537,
-0.0020609871,
-0.0011572852,
-0.0250802618,
-0.0017262441,
0.0102231055,
-0.0039104507,
0.0121243466,
-0.0141819986,
-0.0193009451,
-0.0291512739,
-0.0343925618,
0.0038614122,
0.0922878012,
0.0034413922,
-0.0345886312,
-0.0376012847,
-0.0046966262,
-0.0123995291,
-0.0300647691,
0.0169190783,
-0.0398183577,
0.0107159968,
0.0052256705,
0.0478579774,
-0.0023752868,
0.0084004281,
-0.0194766093,
0.0087917112,
-0.0223475173,
0.0357194096,
-5.184085105e-33,
-0.0180761572,
0.0071177869,
-0.0045773592,
0.0524305589,
-0.0144231264,
-0.006701564,
0.0279048402,
0.0225644801,
0.0190203115,
-0.0075753252,
0.0232354198,
-0.0056271823,
0.0056201974,
-0.0373385362,
-0.0101528866,
0.0414990857,
0.0210423861,
0.0004683678,
0.0195575543,
0.03374644,
-0.0216797832,
0.0545151457,
-0.0536922887,
-0.0286632758,
-0.0328261219,
-0.0131140621,
0.0045506009,
-0.0457103364,
-0.0556937791,
-0.0100057451,
-0.0729643703,
0.0183534399,
-0.0332186595,
0.0037922331,
0.0155200511,
0.0172062218,
-0.0785878226,
0.0609529689,
0.0647298768,
0.0228191521,
-0.0765038952,
-0.0015520414,
-0.0367896669,
0.0715580583,
-0.053149946,
0.001316354,
-0.0319437385,
0.0225572716,
-0.0200943928,
-0.021960469,
-0.0275417566,
0.0098309871,
0.0054263212,
0.0354763493,
0.0350764468,
-0.0807486624,
-0.0721971244,
-0.0370961726,
0.0020875353,
-0.0194687545,
-0.0078561818,
-0.0290602595,
0.0218096692,
0.0105071086,
-0.0416892208,
0.020269094,
0.1014941633,
-0.0050096377,
-0.0137957819,
-0.0263065677,
0.0495752878,
0.0349055417,
0.0001567552,
0.0336746685,
0.0300443526,
0.0101890871,
-0.0463302843,
0.034643285,
-0.0271734875,
0.0142592881,
0.0222357698,
-0.0361377932,
0.0168601479,
-0.0733691156,
0.047213532,
0.0657713637,
-0.0783852935,
0.0267627109,
0.0123721464,
0.0146046011,
-0.0249841753,
0.0547692589,
-0.0029968806,
0.0114674717,
0.0515530668,
0.0217006542,
0.0095087951,
0.0026438076,
0.0435020924,
-0.0201491043,
0.0278828852,
-0.0094772261,
-0.0379936546,
-0.076643452,
0.0173269287,
-0.0298103299,
0.0422601029,
0.0297170132,
-0.0440677702,
0.0061013554,
-0.0375923477,
-0.0073574898,
0.0014151987,
-0.0046722838,
-0.0464515761,
0.0065631396,
0.0210893601,
0.0207630284,
-0.0167475324,
0.0317918546,
-0.0276977811,
-0.0811211094,
0.0209302511,
0.0392721146,
-0.0445758998,
0.0059521315,
0.0148844533,
0.0095099192,
0.0356390551,
-0.0300349351,
-0.0497865006,
-0.0627602562,
2.822e-7,
-0.0066404152,
0.0475890338,
0.0042849267,
0.0275935736,
-0.0134391626,
0.0089884,
0.0312610641,
0.0436816514,
-0.003757556,
0.0213159956,
0.0005493109,
-0.019187063,
0.0295241959,
-0.077780813,
0.0449229591,
0.0446203426,
0.0251352601,
0.0342250653,
-0.0295383241,
-0.0186574087,
0.0219051261,
-0.0437155105,
0.0208423976,
-0.0242262334,
0.0140301669,
-0.031359911,
0.0627716854,
0.0021706813,
-0.003305553,
-0.0507588647,
-0.0109849377,
0.0354249328,
-0.0348100439,
-0.0235032905,
-0.0000590615,
-0.0083435578,
-0.0216890369,
0.0830885693,
0.0489344001,
0.0132586528,
0.0196758825,
-0.0219965558,
-0.0573598742,
0.0000829176,
0.0342283249,
0.1225007847,
0.0129785556,
-0.0493806824,
-0.0132342679,
-0.032924246,
-0.0089719677,
-0.015696872,
0.0608350635,
0.0147578204,
-0.0198482182,
-0.0068271263,
-0.0125931948,
-0.026879115,
-0.0064582778,
0.0377773605,
-0.0502946787,
-0.0400312766,
-0.0121316109,
0.0107930358,
0.0006943422,
0.0209380724,
0.0256859101,
3.187220689e-34,
0.0666317791,
-0.0050126459,
0.0154834352,
0.0886568353,
-0.0208948385,
-0.0286903325,
-0.0539111234,
-0.0500399806,
-0.0368351862,
-0.061777547,
-0.0286888108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20329v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20329v3 | InstructCoder: Instruction Tuning Large Language Models for Code Editing | 2023-10-31T10:15:35 | 2024-02-28T15:47:11 | Kaixin Li, Qisheng Hu, Xu Zhao, Hui Chen, Yuxi Xie, Tiedong Liu, Qizhe Xie, Junxian He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Code editing encompasses a variety of pragmatic tasks that developers deal
with daily. Despite its relevance and practical usefulness, automatic code
editing remains an underexplored area in the evolution of deep learning models,
partly due to data scarcity. In this work, we explore the use of Large Language
Models (LLMs) to edit code based on user instructions. Evaluated on a novel
human-written execution-based benchmark dubbed EditEval, we found current
models often struggle to fulfill the instructions. In light of this, we
contribute InstructCoder, the first instruction-tuning dataset designed to
adapt LLMs for general-purpose code editing, containing high-diversity
code-editing tasks such as comment insertion, code optimization, and code
refactoring. It consists of over 114,000 instruction-input-output triplets and
covers multiple distinct code editing scenarios. The collection process starts
with filtered commit data sourced from GitHub Python repositories as seeds.
Subsequently, the dataset is systematically expanded through an iterative
process, where both seed and generated tasks are used to prompt ChatGPT for
more data. Our findings reveal that open-source LLMs fine-tuned on
InstructCoder can significantly enhance the accuracy of code edits, exhibiting
superior code-editing performance matching advanced proprietary LLMs. The
datasets and the source code are publicly available at
https://github.com/qishenghu/CodeInstruct. | [
0.0255161561,
0.0704046041,
-0.0085049057,
0.0066671236,
-0.0050818813,
-0.0022798032,
-0.0218694098,
-0.0199631415,
-0.0292667355,
-0.0078679556,
-0.0390089862,
-0.0083266571,
0.0012136168,
0.0188189987,
0.0313934945,
-0.0128456522,
0.0469721667,
-0.0153277284,
-0.0329635814,
0.0460291952,
-0.0275562275,
0.0058512911,
-0.0019231993,
0.0617361292,
0.0298175737,
-0.0399436615,
-0.0140781058,
0.0621929243,
-0.0124327317,
0.0184732843,
0.032927189,
0.0608352311,
-0.0037527129,
0.0275069997,
0.0000021733,
-0.0165177193,
-0.0049043274,
-0.0109458761,
-0.004871333,
0.0569676496,
-0.0117944451,
-0.0273518469,
-0.0422437042,
0.0063975202,
-0.0350360349,
-0.0057365275,
0.0579017922,
-0.0398203507,
0.0976504833,
0.0762070194,
0.0143859098,
0.0170809496,
0.0021514907,
-0.0167889539,
0.0417678021,
-0.0038992697,
0.0055753374,
0.0087666921,
-0.0157046448,
0.0246975552,
-0.0012457911,
0.0177230928,
0.0444413945,
-0.0397668146,
0.0308178272,
0.0182540119,
-0.0351226218,
0.0013575756,
0.0038241502,
0.0421014093,
-0.0825091898,
-0.0069552977,
-0.0113417944,
-0.0252829082,
-0.0165713057,
-0.0561954714,
-0.0203373544,
0.001784804,
0.0156938136,
-0.0035119345,
-0.0221880302,
-0.0821096897,
0.0188877322,
0.0094432645,
0.0151037173,
0.0315214619,
0.0162508059,
0.0093185101,
-0.0372457691,
-0.0274731759,
0.0072343512,
-0.0672878549,
-0.0064968178,
0.0447663851,
-0.0441054441,
-0.0244938619,
-0.0781991109,
-0.0265581012,
0.0041881097,
-0.0203442071,
0.062241964,
0.0647068024,
-0.0360649079,
0.0325269252,
-0.0550245158,
0.0614042953,
-0.0289860219,
0.0121175041,
0.0035155518,
0.0113206748,
-0.0470202193,
0.0388075598,
-0.0274396669,
-0.0015917036,
-0.0393474139,
0.0510470569,
-0.0450708307,
0.0528890938,
0.0054408964,
0.0420506112,
0.0096774083,
0.0003638594,
-0.0325003639,
-0.0045315581,
0.0349894352,
-0.0252482779,
0.0050855521,
-0.0170083437,
0.0097011402,
-0.0609049238,
-0.0005138161,
0.0061774752,
-0.0170263965,
-0.0567517057,
0.0409234352,
0.0604756959,
-0.0069352076,
0.0306294896,
-0.0494146384,
-0.0278537869,
0.0317483097,
-0.0113498708,
-0.0433195345,
-0.085138239,
-0.0235726833,
-0.0084719444,
-0.0229334179,
-0.1295955479,
-0.0081568509,
0.0062010186,
0.0008833027,
0.0384279899,
-0.0704544485,
0.0215245634,
0.0527920984,
0.0187033359,
-0.0440448485,
0.0077275243,
0.0533880666,
0.0187832192,
0.0304146428,
-0.0496400669,
0.0425592214,
0.0427765511,
-0.022308683,
0.0280068479,
0.0135047566,
0.0152262598,
0.0191817228,
0.0024828706,
0.053815566,
0.0383694805,
-0.0132322591,
-0.0229910668,
0.0315677598,
0.011862658,
0.0085726855,
0.0498055033,
0.0513182506,
0.0291868038,
0.0114365797,
-0.0493616313,
-0.0369469076,
0.0718448386,
0.0243764743,
0.0011542151,
0.0191854425,
0.0178664904,
-0.0119825145,
-0.0413126387,
-0.0006038889,
0.0079588108,
-0.0201800168,
-0.0128664961,
0.0006534853,
-0.0424186774,
-0.0675577745,
0.0103816371,
0.0093677789,
-0.0571369007,
-0.0335956439,
-0.0432269089,
-0.0190209989,
0.0645223334,
0.051966574,
-0.0444134176,
-0.0686978102,
-0.043460086,
0.025039833,
-0.0251337923,
0.0355365686,
-0.0163596421,
0.0278570224,
-0.0486723222,
-0.0137025788,
-0.0744168907,
-0.0136702871,
0.0236623269,
0.0485828109,
-0.050367184,
0.0356942043,
0.0259673391,
-0.0750658661,
0.0347302258,
-0.0147633273,
-0.0314787552,
0.0383617021,
-0.0052501652,
0.0032380358,
-0.0382408015,
-0.0596132353,
-0.0198513642,
0.0132128987,
0.0063270135,
-0.0084277019,
-0.0296907946,
-0.0137746632,
-0.0182263814,
0.0389727242,
-0.0348441266,
-0.0599552058,
0.0102700861,
-0.0538190603,
-0.0083031766,
0.0219007768,
-0.0251932852,
0.0098987399,
0.0024730775,
0.0162525214,
-0.0264848787,
-0.016508026,
-0.0121239703,
-0.0057002106,
0.0035700826,
0.0026919602,
0.0295529515,
0.0796783641,
-0.0014547958,
-0.0138730248,
-0.0140616866,
-0.004759015,
-0.0195808522,
0.0188696012,
-0.0000218879,
0.0774305016,
-0.0179561563,
-0.0517514236,
-0.0844045207,
0.03086612,
-0.023753589,
0.0024615922,
0.0250236932,
0.025215162,
-0.0054928181,
-0.0122388005,
0.0011268177,
-0.0137890736,
-0.0483650342,
0.0245770961,
0.0363382399,
-0.0138691841,
-0.045033142,
-0.0772206411,
-0.0084959976,
-0.028715549,
0.0070598368,
-0.011479564,
-0.0148825152,
-0.0605981946,
0.050185658,
0.009042426,
0.0276757181,
0.0154481502,
-0.0613286719,
-0.0131600061,
-0.0122862328,
0.0985632017,
0.0968163833,
-0.0089413384,
-0.0016376266,
0.0606982782,
0.0047046752,
-0.0191550627,
0.0328637846,
0.0428299531,
-0.0466745459,
-0.0038032376,
-0.0254205409,
0.0247185901,
0.0775188431,
-0.0098722661,
-0.0247819554,
-0.0385823958,
0.017890377,
0.0108883884,
0.0197383501,
0.0189514272,
0.0025521133,
-0.0155701516,
0.042695336,
-0.0533559844,
-0.100333713,
0.0490235463,
-0.0183450188,
-0.0258704554,
-0.0139201414,
-0.034316767,
-0.0422536843,
0.0376259126,
0.0071411026,
0.0152004799,
-0.0494194217,
-0.0179073904,
-0.0484658889,
0.038972944,
-0.0126471333,
0.0003123897,
0.0633779168,
-0.0775813982,
0.0135468571,
-0.0337468386,
-0.0251346808,
-0.0230331644,
-0.0211309865,
-0.0166508947,
0.0127293542,
0.0672205463,
-0.046889469,
0.0166296177,
-0.0098904492,
0.007576996,
0.0963234678,
0.0225948431,
-0.0362553261,
-0.0169480871,
-0.067275621,
0.0014336965,
-0.0417870656,
-0.0382523276,
-0.0085499017,
-0.0058157868,
0.0305037051,
0.0497982688,
0.0057618893,
-0.0690402985,
0.0145467743,
0.0136104897,
-0.0449943021,
-0.0283272229,
0.0346846357,
0.081505008,
-0.0384815596,
-0.0208255984,
0.0985671356,
0.026297031,
-0.0632147267,
0.0110553326,
-0.0067017288,
0.0242138486,
0.0867655724,
0.0566558391,
-0.091824919,
-0.058364965,
0.0144188516,
0.0155249573,
0.0077139055,
-0.033239767,
-0.0187841803,
-0.059393011,
0.0139552457,
0.0005509204,
-0.0217764154,
-0.0355143473,
-0.0193834268,
0.0233261269,
-0.0219540074,
-0.0217159707,
0.0472369976,
0.0070083439,
0.0098866178,
-0.0149343088,
-0.0149602611,
0.0036872374,
0.0491614044,
-0.0452363715,
0.0258390997,
0.0836469755,
-0.0030942026,
0.0356824435,
0.0102587715,
0.0739348605,
0.0263370648,
0.0012236689,
-0.0182979461,
0.0305013172,
0.0033422101,
-0.0083286259,
0.0607451648,
0.0396245196,
-0.0621011518,
-0.0089130383,
0.0404306799,
0.0513079166,
-0.0223217122,
0.0156658944,
-0.0135359997,
-0.0485397503,
-0.0135080349,
0.0094007719,
0.064450644,
-0.0501525439,
-0.0204863138,
-0.0881173909,
-0.0092515666,
-0.0745784491,
-0.0105316881,
-0.0328590423,
-0.0137312226,
0.0162484273,
-0.0353778861,
-0.0269224644,
0.0307947341,
0.0045731291,
0.0616527274,
-0.0555061363,
0.0208979435,
0.0008548956,
-0.0541966222,
0.0068070223,
-0.0155562265,
0.0249261651,
-0.0818118379,
-0.0431321152,
0.0285743531,
-0.0048038866,
-0.0214775819,
-0.0022723952,
-0.0723692402,
-0.0464030802,
-0.0184119157,
0.0652702004,
0.006346921,
0.0344646797,
-0.0122542717,
-0.0827487484,
-0.0448693894,
-0.0123549961,
-0.0072759087,
0.0208611283,
0.0216731206,
0.0081092063,
-0.0029656605,
0.0144680757,
-0.0453548804,
-0.0013571189,
0.035908293,
-0.0163234975,
-0.0261612628,
-0.0502715856,
0.0194608849,
-0.0092528602,
0.0045732833,
0.051483389,
-0.0177748222,
-0.0295390878,
0.0268607438,
0.0314725526,
0.0045963689,
-0.0454216413,
0.0197434612,
0.0084269801,
-0.0356541984,
0.0097984057,
0.0499919616,
-0.0034604361,
0.0409760065,
-0.01557317,
0.063084051,
-0.0114883147,
0.0713958666,
0.0706357211,
0.0085227061,
-0.0178129394,
0.0491373204,
-0.0017054732,
0.0292920787,
-0.0007864982,
0.0293711331,
0.0038257039,
0.0322627462,
-0.0018579194,
0.0285024457,
-0.0449035875,
-0.0461724326,
-0.0191848315,
-0.0064803879,
0.0524491705,
0.031839475,
0.0165999271,
-0.0017365366,
-0.0114166746,
-0.031263195,
0.0622377656,
-0.0062440583,
-0.02472407,
-0.0107287606,
0.0063603725,
-0.008698036,
-0.0235648956,
0.0895199478,
-0.0076189456,
0.0662455559,
-0.0006195167,
-0.0043031238,
-0.0219065584,
0.0137166688,
0.0318569988,
-0.0232451726,
-0.0096219247,
-0.0340912081,
0.0400929153,
-0.0394559428,
-0.0048410106,
0.0386673026,
0.0180781074,
-0.0016734028,
0.0100532295,
0.0697990283,
-0.0366447568,
-0.013521947,
-0.0079937242,
0.0027561514,
0.0021968647,
-0.0533126108,
-0.0571514666,
-5.466731253e-33,
-0.003773629,
-0.0020118426,
0.0319222659,
0.0454055443,
0.0067313914,
0.0050760498,
-0.0554839745,
0.0034263134,
-0.0093888137,
-0.0337058753,
-0.0061123208,
0.0410148427,
-0.0161645617,
-0.014074496,
0.0712725222,
0.0380166844,
0.0866445303,
0.0325173475,
-0.0395662002,
0.0500338227,
-0.0514177047,
0.0331024267,
0.0390962698,
-0.0220961254,
-0.0297053307,
0.0282123964,
0.0375160351,
0.0222214442,
0.0046643182,
0.0262420978,
0.0198597424,
-0.0165267512,
-0.0203522108,
-0.0401963741,
-0.0329895392,
-0.0521744676,
0.0118721947,
-0.0151160853,
-0.0322047696,
0.019720193,
-0.0327083394,
-0.0866518989,
0.0777686313,
0.0107022254,
-0.0493163951,
-0.0329498015,
0.0147391316,
0.0018633459,
0.0318343975,
-0.0138189206,
-0.0512762032,
0.0511468314,
-0.0302091204,
-0.0379427187,
-0.0143924402,
-0.0131393615,
0.0098874606,
0.0117079401,
-0.0380552672,
-0.0235450286,
0.0151611716,
0.069979012,
0.0689714402,
0.0002775443,
-0.0048468024,
0.0136214802,
0.0562536754,
0.0424324833,
-0.0014390574,
0.0334940366,
0.0245839786,
0.0543366037,
0.0023092607,
0.0166307278,
0.0104956599,
-0.0021003408,
-0.0286808182,
0.018040657,
-0.0150230909,
0.0333517492,
-0.0085742027,
0.0794019848,
0.0142681217,
0.0060993517,
-0.0385252573,
0.0072050607,
-0.025928773,
-0.0212932657,
0.0241223443,
-0.0134775555,
-0.0080143437,
0.0141196055,
0.0351797193,
-0.0209983848,
0.0136716245,
0.0219346583,
-0.0640449449,
0.0469352193,
-0.0084077204,
-0.0095606837,
-0.0196675379,
-0.0006690706,
0.0113428691,
-0.0097961929,
0.0826221406,
0.0127202561,
0.0354296304,
0.0409784466,
-0.0716839656,
-0.0013460645,
-0.0536422059,
0.0037887818,
-0.0193222668,
0.0491735935,
-0.0347194932,
0.0031056835,
0.0144790439,
0.0452811383,
-0.0061200587,
-0.0215629246,
-0.0637814328,
-0.0146409096,
0.0253819376,
0.016378032,
-0.0314697474,
-0.0175593756,
-0.0443662293,
0.0093836933,
-0.0057903579,
-0.0381837226,
-0.0452573076,
0.0137397945,
2.73e-7,
0.0020117965,
0.0827845559,
0.0088570658,
0.0171345212,
0.0066498197,
0.0431641005,
-0.0263294503,
-0.0135568576,
0.0362700857,
0.0059376014,
-0.0011580037,
0.0308199227,
0.0350412801,
0.0313204229,
-0.0208392534,
0.0142218536,
-0.0308638085,
0.0518078245,
-0.0691817924,
-0.013625863,
-0.0084627345,
0.0532858148,
0.0164517667,
-0.0017108335,
0.0504687987,
-0.0054571126,
0.0111261662,
-0.0131299188,
0.0256202724,
0.065385744,
-0.0340398774,
0.0197733548,
-0.0160847288,
-0.0223836601,
-0.0181498658,
-0.0454762988,
-0.0102479048,
0.0871438608,
-0.0435925648,
0.0611414798,
0.0447676741,
0.0020912373,
-0.0225961786,
-0.0448759869,
0.0316923112,
-0.0175492968,
0.0253654607,
-0.0176081657,
0.0027399678,
0.0165079217,
0.0350903161,
-0.0231145136,
0.0460749194,
-0.0082775094,
0.0100241303,
-0.0112547288,
-0.0724079013,
-0.0104224319,
-0.0326888748,
0.010481311,
-0.0072352397,
-0.0265564322,
-0.0755494907,
0.0301173814,
0.0063761864,
-0.0126817459,
0.0177378282,
2.606487909e-34,
-0.0000225564,
-0.0098506548,
0.0509417318,
0.0262119304,
0.0631406978,
-0.0166923422,
-0.0145560643,
0.0030609884,
-0.0125494301,
-0.0319757387,
-0.0651113242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20328v1 | ChiSCor: A Corpus of Freely Told Fantasy Stories by Dutch Children for Computational Linguistics and Cognitive Science | 2023-10-31T10:15:20 | 2023-10-31T10:15:20 | Bram M. A. van Dijk, Max J. van Duijn, Suzan Verberne, Marco R. Spruit | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this resource paper we release ChiSCor, a new corpus containing 619
fantasy stories, told freely by 442 Dutch children aged 4-12. ChiSCor was
compiled for studying how children render character perspectives, and
unravelling language and cognition in development, with computational tools.
Unlike existing resources, ChiSCor's stories were produced in natural contexts,
in line with recent calls for more ecologically valid datasets. ChiSCor hosts
text, audio, and annotations for character complexity and linguistic
complexity. Additional metadata (e.g. education of caregivers) is available for
one third of the Dutch children. ChiSCor also includes a small set of 62
English stories. This paper details how ChiSCor was compiled and shows its
potential for future work with three brief case studies: i) we show that the
syntactic complexity of stories is strikingly stable across children's ages;
ii) we extend work on Zipfian distributions in free speech and show that
ChiSCor obeys Zipf's law closely, reflecting its social context; iii) we show
that even though ChiSCor is relatively small, the corpus is rich enough to
train informative lemma vectors that allow us to analyse children's language
use. We end with a reflection on the value of narrative datasets in
computational linguistics. | [
0.0157774556,
0.0555509962,
-0.0558628999,
0.0529021919,
-0.0485508256,
0.021833552,
-0.0207518358,
-0.0197937414,
-0.0247622244,
-0.035692662,
0.0410793051,
-0.007700921,
0.0780893564,
0.0182984341,
-0.0024764035,
-0.0764122084,
0.0308313649,
-0.0213941727,
0.0057497257,
0.0002346977,
-0.0027710046,
0.0378614292,
-0.0239402205,
0.0484031253,
-0.0198669583,
-0.0194151327,
-0.0199886449,
-0.0147652449,
0.0328450054,
-0.0219913293,
0.0038235113,
-0.0161497388,
0.0033817019,
0.0209152196,
0.0000018951,
-0.0398136452,
0.0384430327,
-0.0247392301,
0.0003263442,
0.0139450822,
0.0322488323,
0.0106272856,
0.0063114851,
-0.0037070131,
-0.0148484036,
-0.0037157743,
0.0727632344,
0.0103314612,
-0.0010966624,
0.0326247215,
-0.007246776,
-0.0513304695,
-0.0294795632,
-0.0018699724,
0.0582890585,
0.0386336669,
-0.0224482417,
0.0005436749,
0.0749796182,
-0.0543108433,
-0.0465073287,
0.0200135037,
0.016190378,
0.006143664,
-0.040697746,
0.0120344404,
-0.0213656705,
-0.0135633284,
0.0052117612,
0.042187959,
0.0496852696,
-0.036238905,
0.0203078911,
0.0005774864,
0.0032686528,
0.0387339555,
-0.0382115878,
0.0696193278,
-0.0146478135,
0.0130509967,
0.0462567396,
0.0264823604,
-0.0010422552,
0.0120107885,
0.016171651,
0.0450021215,
-0.0288521126,
0.0154449213,
-0.0168746617,
0.0116335573,
0.0042001684,
-0.0656055212,
-0.0349231437,
-0.0125962542,
0.0271497611,
0.0171155892,
-0.0475256182,
0.0243040323,
0.0054194918,
-0.0217573345,
0.00100065,
0.0015466688,
-0.0386165343,
0.0173598789,
0.0420114063,
-0.0122597944,
0.0330181718,
0.0031149704,
-0.0288557634,
0.0086126123,
-0.0427702703,
0.003670352,
-0.0383906327,
0.0173697118,
-0.0362754501,
0.0009519641,
-0.0084487312,
-0.0169581771,
0.0159923416,
-0.0178217925,
-0.0348020084,
0.0184661057,
-0.0008652533,
0.0349713899,
-0.0511299446,
0.0076046586,
-0.0821020454,
0.0308271423,
-0.0283166245,
-0.0440023132,
-0.009534358,
-0.001576675,
0.0651204512,
-0.0210795458,
0.0262444876,
0.022042986,
0.0261054859,
0.0041075088,
-0.0081223119,
-0.0511354506,
-0.0098610846,
-0.0725950748,
-0.0118471989,
-0.0702470988,
-0.002104409,
-0.0171027146,
0.0530553758,
-0.0512004495,
-0.0066589988,
0.0186819471,
-0.0228997413,
0.0212003812,
-0.0141795138,
-0.0165257677,
-0.0243550614,
-0.0151890609,
0.0407100841,
0.0226328913,
0.0955972522,
-0.0631152019,
0.0233942252,
-0.0156257059,
-0.0203476064,
-0.0083980169,
-0.0656691715,
-0.0428254418,
0.0120459106,
-0.0233146641,
0.0122724036,
0.0295169558,
-0.0049639475,
0.0661328211,
-0.0228835102,
-0.024269538,
0.0558202565,
0.1062072292,
0.0155203743,
0.0038513937,
0.0378803909,
0.0451789685,
0.0708235353,
0.0332797505,
-0.0038742274,
0.0071595777,
0.0360118411,
-0.0133928573,
-0.050004717,
0.0326335132,
0.0262899101,
-0.0210082475,
-0.024090508,
0.0144286035,
0.0256489404,
-0.0154200923,
-0.0117712719,
0.0083459318,
0.0254040007,
-0.0426139012,
0.0505583808,
-0.0752618685,
0.0265044328,
0.0125105837,
0.0436246544,
0.0422832891,
-0.0132574467,
-0.0466480292,
0.0131267449,
-0.0259176176,
0.0033470625,
0.012762255,
-0.0536433645,
-0.0126392124,
0.0553345308,
-0.0045140185,
0.0269399155,
-0.0316890031,
0.0250601899,
-0.0110249529,
-0.0394352563,
0.0014428905,
-0.0143433465,
-0.0228858571,
-0.0125375977,
0.0389908552,
-0.0779335946,
-0.0036127276,
-0.0347586125,
0.0132494541,
0.0107623972,
0.0193836708,
-0.0266563054,
-0.0162673965,
0.0254363194,
-0.0157004092,
0.0241727587,
0.0835638717,
-0.0606090724,
-0.0576770008,
0.0294025298,
-0.1175209507,
0.035587728,
-0.0178738181,
0.0300339554,
-0.0030137408,
0.0824710801,
-0.0855423957,
0.0608425215,
0.0157500338,
0.0137512535,
-0.042909462,
-0.0175660029,
-0.013303929,
0.0386289768,
0.0167168137,
0.0319237299,
-0.0488840155,
-0.0257735662,
0.0191290397,
-0.0054190662,
0.0250174776,
-0.0038281397,
0.0084705222,
0.0122512178,
0.0101423394,
-0.0327901728,
-0.0469468087,
-0.0239379536,
-0.0661347285,
-0.008101291,
0.0115851667,
0.0237685833,
-0.0006018284,
-0.0118499724,
-0.0146220364,
0.0300158095,
-0.0557203107,
0.0128535898,
-0.0057654367,
-0.0173495077,
0.0247296281,
0.0129343923,
-0.0280694924,
-0.0257918127,
0.0175963975,
-0.0065486329,
0.0866770521,
0.0270592682,
-0.0537984483,
0.0102139199,
-0.0385622121,
-0.0567424707,
0.0138828084,
-0.02840285,
0.0045265658,
0.0211058054,
-0.0015317647,
0.0376958661,
-0.0065636039,
-0.0195866469,
-0.0046268394,
0.0294628534,
-0.0704877973,
-0.0253394376,
-0.0093870666,
0.0226073824,
0.0113477996,
-0.0272236243,
-0.0320199504,
0.0327408798,
0.1035685465,
0.00191645,
-0.0041394755,
-0.0442142785,
0.0621900819,
0.0108082658,
-0.0014247485,
0.0142170647,
-0.0622696765,
-0.0090237884,
0.0616168231,
-0.0342274681,
-0.0261807162,
0.0546782762,
-0.0297569968,
-0.0107562989,
-0.0407095179,
-0.0160195101,
-0.0393044539,
0.1188610122,
0.0130224284,
0.0331934765,
0.0904741362,
-0.0163629204,
-0.0404252559,
0.0272624176,
0.0501861721,
-0.0257642474,
0.0389188342,
-0.0831973627,
0.0037627083,
0.0289877318,
-0.0359900482,
-0.006861046,
-0.0559804477,
-0.0325095095,
-0.0365096666,
0.0026050066,
-0.0770342872,
-0.0346487761,
-0.0339960754,
0.0090005705,
0.065133892,
0.0204589088,
-0.0250236616,
0.0066981977,
0.0037515853,
0.0065828552,
0.0042446558,
0.015706351,
-0.026511794,
0.0086585963,
0.0539362729,
-0.0648492873,
0.0217184667,
0.0524082892,
0.0585355461,
0.0118785212,
0.0033293974,
-0.0579281077,
-0.0017107213,
0.0280884299,
-0.063253887,
-0.0097883716,
0.018633876,
0.042110946,
0.0303244945,
0.0555753373,
-0.0103497775,
0.0285147,
0.0183259528,
-0.0166185778,
-0.0921139047,
0.0095830038,
0.0270947497,
0.0168312024,
-0.0289272983,
-0.0539401546,
-0.0314297974,
-0.0887773037,
0.0232352912,
0.0059243087,
-0.0431313626,
-0.0366749354,
-0.0020109743,
-0.0294309817,
0.0429104492,
-0.0267082155,
0.0087777767,
-0.0474968106,
0.0291068796,
-0.0117039653,
-0.0220355373,
-0.0169817228,
0.0040041963,
-0.0175758041,
0.0628382862,
-0.0094985124,
0.0344547071,
-0.0157665256,
0.0015692345,
-0.0670116618,
-0.0038159199,
-0.0415305495,
0.0080825984,
0.0335096791,
0.0130391484,
-0.0226245914,
-0.066205956,
0.0381220207,
0.0009735209,
-0.0378937423,
0.0376645327,
0.0464674085,
0.0085578822,
-0.0360376276,
0.0199702587,
0.0393470004,
-0.0065229503,
0.0558815151,
0.0188633129,
-0.0157333538,
0.0309149697,
-0.0607848503,
-0.0438160896,
-0.0089237336,
-0.0982587263,
0.0285574384,
0.0412025861,
0.0015006175,
-0.1033978462,
-0.0232011341,
0.0576254763,
0.0389118902,
0.0398207828,
-0.0366325006,
0.0006945269,
-0.0106473938,
-0.0854973793,
0.0432653986,
-0.0117932726,
-0.0068778922,
-0.0239147302,
-0.0247331988,
0.0143651627,
-0.0501503833,
-0.0061850161,
0.0247765202,
-0.1036832333,
-0.0408908948,
0.0233924352,
-0.0335592888,
0.0269125383,
0.0149331819,
0.0365317166,
-0.0581618622,
0.0017607454,
0.0239505917,
-0.0598905869,
0.0550940931,
-0.0256416257,
-0.0177017599,
0.0218583625,
0.0100376057,
0.0018845333,
0.0024396256,
-0.0211921073,
0.0252477713,
-0.0328981057,
-0.0338738486,
0.0172945037,
-0.0268368945,
-0.0088477163,
-0.026923256,
-0.0456044115,
-0.0710977018,
-0.0323002897,
-0.0352830924,
-0.0228530075,
-0.029573286,
0.0032096319,
0.0021862157,
0.0235161539,
-0.0123673566,
0.0177320857,
-0.027390819,
0.0001275608,
-0.0221407004,
0.0617812015,
0.0535052754,
-0.0084551796,
-0.006936131,
0.0457147993,
0.0025695174,
-0.0082999431,
-0.0565331466,
0.0792718381,
-0.0055703274,
-0.0412205644,
-0.0010951514,
-0.0085665397,
-0.0002055355,
-0.0407493934,
-0.0089014778,
0.0016998482,
0.0023305714,
-0.0131131597,
0.0284754541,
-0.0333673172,
0.0928513333,
-0.0381809771,
0.0250272602,
-0.0069280481,
-0.0105089303,
0.0388718545,
-0.0206537247,
-0.0256657656,
0.0162008051,
-0.0381781198,
0.0264489986,
0.0550491773,
-0.0178426262,
0.0549588613,
0.0226457603,
0.0086220894,
-0.0252924562,
-0.0271218438,
-0.0243245829,
0.0480342731,
0.0142144077,
0.0257632006,
-0.0725459754,
-0.0254796706,
-0.001899419,
-0.0056589134,
0.0199974384,
-0.0243745409,
0.0168254357,
0.0064674579,
0.0143234599,
-0.006386349,
-0.0367246009,
0.0118569192,
-0.0085669169,
-0.0166292861,
0.0089590773,
-5.79723251e-33,
-0.0177166015,
-0.0009633047,
-0.030262677,
0.0315426514,
-0.0018855497,
-0.0023000676,
-0.0188490432,
0.0490207635,
-0.0083543332,
0.0416525006,
0.0197237264,
-0.0192670804,
0.006762899,
-0.0067182262,
0.0034054385,
0.0150056975,
0.011214802,
0.009984402,
-0.0234064143,
-0.0460948832,
0.0403676257,
-0.0179453623,
0.0798321515,
-0.0635293797,
0.0323335044,
-0.0135010872,
-0.0234153252,
0.0147468392,
0.0328463987,
0.0335180946,
-0.0075170854,
0.0462508649,
0.0111193201,
0.0391933508,
-0.0220225248,
0.0222158302,
-0.0941921771,
-0.0406179391,
0.0527748913,
-0.0021558627,
-0.0159946047,
-0.0369034857,
0.0251467302,
0.0035686337,
0.0221347902,
-0.0287319422,
0.0484952293,
-0.0168556999,
0.045234289,
-0.0109584061,
-0.0683514923,
-0.0087195234,
-0.0514085926,
-0.0325701833,
0.0498561449,
0.0614147261,
0.0052731549,
-0.025801111,
-0.0224910025,
0.0645422563,
-0.0044828705,
0.0436745957,
-0.0215402804,
-0.0101233255,
-0.0022953502,
0.1052414775,
0.0581270605,
0.0326372311,
-0.0377603173,
0.1020146236,
0.0354123861,
0.0029708776,
0.0154027464,
0.0650663078,
0.0486354418,
0.0568276867,
-0.0656122416,
-0.0179273989,
0.0459207334,
0.0087865274,
-0.0067590219,
-0.0056288796,
-0.0312715061,
-0.042168539,
-0.0516607165,
0.0239946991,
0.027170578,
0.0268333945,
-0.0202537272,
-0.0254357327,
-0.0067009311,
0.0260255784,
-0.0214969087,
-0.006492618,
-0.0391989239,
-0.0124138035,
0.0053738779,
0.0394155644,
0.0057188566,
0.0294746757,
-0.004878134,
-0.0052594794,
0.0285669155,
0.042688746,
0.092923224,
0.0346408077,
0.0263617877,
0.0400726087,
-0.0780297443,
-0.0134023875,
-0.0027097189,
0.0393470563,
-0.0100822942,
0.0226211436,
0.0380242392,
-0.0151741561,
-0.0124949887,
-0.0166745763,
0.0002658124,
-0.0160900578,
-0.0341837332,
-0.0183580164,
-0.0572201796,
-0.0213596225,
-0.0213005189,
0.0002447453,
-0.0513965376,
0.0193699934,
0.0795322731,
-0.0081379218,
0.011487551,
-0.0383263789,
2.743e-7,
-0.0029261084,
0.0451172702,
0.0564139076,
0.0220269803,
0.0310315248,
-0.0013403321,
0.0077677532,
0.0003201117,
-0.0359029807,
-0.0304631479,
-0.0281909741,
-0.0020067622,
0.0719115585,
0.0558736883,
-0.1105808243,
0.0046014022,
-0.0373430252,
-0.0059993728,
-0.0376714021,
-0.0082491934,
0.0620448142,
0.0670408532,
0.0574128851,
-0.0297009777,
0.0198161695,
0.0090118311,
-0.0178653933,
-0.0411633141,
0.0275165979,
0.0051704873,
-0.0561975725,
0.0067891171,
0.0185996853,
-0.0093026785,
0.0135456491,
0.0340821743,
-0.0302562993,
0.0117627708,
0.0044903303,
0.0503707267,
0.0125332922,
-0.0349188335,
-0.0404287465,
-0.0117177442,
0.0551918782,
0.0168755855,
-0.0395547599,
0.048899699,
0.0225477181,
0.0047617885,
-0.0010787862,
0.002858978,
-0.0294247251,
0.0344404429,
0.0141912438,
-0.0478816852,
0.0299417023,
-0.0695842654,
-0.0287999641,
0.0142043764,
-0.0249891616,
-0.0477874726,
0.0328401662,
0.0071968697,
-0.0544796325,
-0.0071117533,
0.0428341404,
2.28827493e-34,
0.0028282318,
-0.0035695634,
0.0363702923,
-0.033863537,
0.0517963134,
-0.017736977,
0.0863755494,
0.0016903331,
0.0450077169,
-0.0022945767,
-0.0130589241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20326v1 | Erato: Automatizing Poetry Evaluation | 2023-10-31T10:06:37 | 2023-10-31T10:06:37 | Manex Agirrezabal, Hugo Gonçalo Oliveira, Aitor Ormazabal | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Erato, a framework designed to facilitate the automated evaluation
of poetry, including that generated by poetry generation systems. Our framework
employs a diverse set of features, and we offer a brief overview of Erato's
capabilities and its potential for expansion. Using Erato, we compare and
contrast human-authored poetry with automatically-generated poetry,
demonstrating its effectiveness in identifying key differences. Our
implementation code and software are freely available under the GNU GPLv3
license. | [
0.0312694572,
0.0620728247,
-0.0210271291,
0.0004797753,
-0.0407910198,
0.0106145861,
0.0140271997,
-0.0036834234,
-0.0048523177,
-0.0201126542,
-0.0343801714,
0.019995356,
0.0202086028,
0.0259706788,
-0.0028182985,
-0.0607633367,
-0.0319918767,
0.0053772232,
0.0428780206,
0.0265771691,
0.0298675131,
0.0091851307,
-0.0193348918,
0.0406026281,
0.0369994231,
-0.0153260734,
-0.0243285336,
0.0216152556,
0.0275657456,
-0.0511878543,
-0.0324223004,
0.0567836538,
-0.0654541105,
0.023416141,
0.000001634,
-0.0475715883,
-0.0098217828,
-0.0341257751,
0.054845266,
0.0388993919,
0.0218109563,
-0.0056752558,
-0.0133003956,
-0.019915102,
0.0112064565,
0.014080761,
0.0441682227,
-0.0391300172,
0.1007988974,
0.093570374,
0.0087449746,
0.0035192545,
0.0187874027,
-0.0261065718,
0.0136730513,
0.0275095701,
-0.0160488449,
-0.0051406417,
0.0134078246,
-0.01764654,
-0.0453904793,
0.0156657603,
0.0071964688,
-0.0113033541,
0.0541074388,
0.0195048656,
-0.017917864,
-0.0081073595,
-0.0079644341,
0.0269207675,
0.0469617359,
-0.0086007752,
0.0320981555,
0.0093242479,
-0.0202184077,
-0.026354311,
-0.0608473495,
0.0115319286,
0.0389869772,
-0.0029301543,
-0.0188442878,
0.0210624151,
-0.0231310409,
0.015878763,
0.0578814372,
-0.0224494133,
0.0317102261,
-0.0324056335,
-0.0000155807,
0.0215293244,
0.0229704697,
-0.0785860568,
0.0301535949,
0.0271725543,
-0.0037116746,
-0.0265994985,
-0.0073611145,
-0.0954016447,
0.0376616158,
0.0338676833,
0.1143699661,
0.042796839,
0.0265828781,
0.0165267047,
-0.0109196166,
0.025550656,
0.0404464379,
-0.0168038774,
-0.0580742173,
0.0513414033,
-0.0210246574,
0.0101379361,
-0.0551384389,
-0.0190748889,
0.0045955065,
-0.0266333185,
-0.058898069,
-0.0266576484,
-0.0173573494,
0.0058300192,
0.0190922469,
0.0369657502,
-0.0000664135,
0.0174126606,
0.0142821949,
0.0092121894,
-0.0399811715,
0.001500497,
-0.0088273864,
0.0135837449,
0.0062876022,
0.0249923598,
0.0375853665,
0.0083939005,
0.0213370193,
0.0335495621,
0.0518595278,
-0.0505749471,
0.0156926066,
-0.0338160992,
0.009105227,
-0.046587415,
-0.0149581693,
-0.0747221559,
0.0350550488,
-0.0070430445,
0.0198097043,
-0.0048330077,
0.0068493113,
0.0197610818,
-0.0043320628,
0.0008211901,
-0.0200013667,
0.0280222222,
-0.048788961,
-0.0070617776,
0.008911578,
0.008974717,
0.0733546689,
0.0457870737,
0.0025566688,
0.0073337504,
0.029816851,
-0.0044768276,
-0.0339744315,
-0.019911496,
0.0009036962,
-0.0132168792,
-0.0504760481,
0.0669965446,
0.0020036655,
0.0662903488,
0.0034716276,
0.0029599795,
0.050212089,
0.0319939889,
0.0283583459,
0.0471606888,
0.0857556388,
-0.0038798086,
0.0473871082,
0.0094081257,
-0.0086320741,
0.0318289362,
0.0540518612,
0.0261455961,
0.0621816255,
0.0357474238,
0.0270887651,
-0.0138441315,
-0.0368044823,
0.0169606507,
-0.0104607325,
-0.0204060171,
-0.0089952573,
0.0049265735,
-0.0066342819,
-0.0154564474,
-0.0006301449,
-0.0860709175,
0.0404787809,
-0.0222153999,
0.0408320241,
0.1104975268,
0.0578140542,
-0.0112040704,
0.0892300233,
-0.0044321162,
-0.0162506662,
0.0364918821,
-0.0312488694,
-0.0004758773,
-0.0071098222,
0.0281023029,
0.0255851615,
0.0020076158,
0.0177746322,
0.0029029029,
-0.0366633683,
0.0596139096,
0.0220671147,
-0.0178060718,
-0.0799560398,
0.0358851328,
0.0059713414,
-0.0656140521,
0.0058280351,
0.0150118107,
0.0103166196,
0.0347999521,
-0.0558347777,
0.0486593693,
0.0120545942,
0.0202422813,
-0.0116757452,
0.0600108467,
-0.0003393487,
-0.0259492975,
0.0357109271,
-0.0855907202,
0.0231116209,
0.0212659966,
0.0251056775,
-0.0357434638,
0.0552959889,
-0.0024872585,
0.0080471486,
-0.0236662608,
0.0278904494,
-0.0082549825,
-0.0162288863,
0.0039917352,
0.0033217815,
0.0084543182,
0.0552694425,
-0.0410157107,
-0.0064482163,
0.0237927195,
-0.0080191465,
-0.0260363724,
-0.0064952704,
0.0211336743,
0.0222246908,
-0.023991596,
0.0186774489,
-0.0630088747,
-0.0582019165,
-0.0939237103,
-0.0027690481,
-0.0032789656,
-0.0145169776,
0.0456137322,
-0.0298955832,
-0.0373100862,
0.0304345209,
-0.0025547941,
0.0249233134,
0.0339658558,
0.0202674214,
0.0122938082,
-0.0402730629,
-0.0180786941,
-0.0451776683,
-0.010404489,
-0.0329536088,
0.0280368272,
0.0422777645,
0.0445366837,
-0.0038165366,
-0.0099403784,
-0.0174110923,
-0.0670076758,
0.0519117713,
-0.043122638,
0.0047770203,
-0.0609290451,
-0.00183188,
0.0635373816,
-0.0082322694,
0.0169554874,
0.0725036934,
-0.0384981856,
0.0602393635,
-0.0303037558,
0.0311730187,
0.0449862182,
0.0291390307,
-0.0467567705,
-0.0019798719,
0.0206520353,
0.0453393981,
-0.0333719328,
0.0041886512,
0.0618012659,
-0.0256280769,
0.0234693494,
-0.0292763747,
0.0000585773,
-0.0099353567,
0.0208660271,
-0.0147931073,
-0.0224528648,
0.0587518476,
-0.0445380285,
-0.0091095781,
-0.0402424298,
0.0216051023,
-0.0534639768,
0.0775177628,
0.0022827277,
0.0413623936,
-0.0350918844,
-0.0147548197,
-0.0121711148,
0.0376058891,
0.0365330875,
-0.0338427387,
0.0191557147,
-0.018708501,
-0.0311616156,
0.009337537,
-0.0002937745,
0.0156619977,
0.0413551852,
-0.0193977747,
0.0047433726,
0.0326783434,
-0.0428544208,
0.0271940902,
-0.0199527759,
-0.0332763195,
0.0234324802,
-0.0317630544,
-0.0200939607,
-0.0145845329,
0.0431802832,
0.0038891535,
-0.0171463471,
-0.0106396778,
0.0167778954,
0.0128308628,
-0.0067877797,
-0.0010166073,
0.0200310014,
-0.0130786281,
0.0505480468,
-0.0032777654,
-0.031208422,
0.0719339326,
0.0083715227,
0.008126976,
-0.0596794486,
-0.013936094,
0.0834235772,
0.0414909273,
-0.030253021,
-0.0081399176,
-0.00316095,
-0.0023394995,
0.0158532895,
-0.0020356847,
-0.038903676,
-0.0094535882,
0.0146631189,
0.0794744864,
0.0160510037,
-0.027632745,
-0.0220764596,
-0.0377203003,
0.0217251237,
0.0217315275,
-0.0198970139,
0.0168322045,
0.0214673653,
-0.0172191858,
-0.0167963449,
-0.0646828711,
0.0181356166,
-0.0343371257,
0.0532670245,
-0.0471541025,
-0.006522649,
0.0149554461,
-0.0171669442,
-0.0748704374,
0.0495995395,
0.048616793,
0.0831803232,
0.0222617704,
-0.0211047437,
-0.0473039858,
-0.0393227004,
-0.0115832537,
0.0219389629,
0.0106071839,
0.0504925773,
-0.0089979032,
-0.0399225764,
0.016736526,
-0.0030631358,
-0.0161853395,
0.0567082763,
0.0113636488,
-0.021839425,
-0.0085608466,
-0.0446965992,
0.0516700596,
0.0074673817,
0.0470336378,
0.0464934371,
-0.0242324248,
-0.0606983937,
-0.0406695716,
-0.0343348309,
-0.1104842126,
-0.0446014553,
-0.0228294004,
-0.006973112,
-0.0527230091,
-0.1001875773,
-0.0477155559,
0.0039948635,
0.0142925605,
0.058425881,
-0.0396971442,
-0.0553004928,
-0.0138919475,
-0.0633370951,
0.0138809336,
0.0017448722,
0.0268480219,
-0.0226253588,
-0.0729950592,
-0.0197601393,
-0.0402835384,
-0.005111252,
0.0513296053,
-0.0795872658,
-0.0155315828,
0.0429036282,
0.0052262568,
0.0210446566,
-0.0448996164,
-0.0198199153,
-0.0018949168,
0.0114480965,
0.0323502123,
0.0264390092,
0.0515290238,
-0.0279965289,
0.0093896445,
-0.0020457737,
-0.0056101712,
-0.008942131,
-0.0046430132,
0.0188143011,
0.0192167461,
0.0734739006,
-0.0451194793,
0.0366820768,
0.0119297849,
0.014440746,
-0.0411759801,
-0.037112426,
0.0026466884,
-0.0909759775,
-0.0338524915,
-0.0194783453,
-0.014703433,
-0.0145017216,
0.0283450242,
0.0322450772,
-0.0286889523,
0.0341511481,
-0.0052719009,
-0.0476369932,
-0.0280997548,
0.0219093375,
0.0438839011,
-0.0252417121,
-0.0087335231,
-0.0158082787,
-0.0133119803,
-0.0199141782,
-0.0439766459,
0.0445746519,
-0.0030949875,
-0.0233670268,
0.0168096367,
-0.0254786313,
0.0042458102,
0.0413749516,
-0.0672180727,
0.0052895043,
-0.0603262298,
-0.0223712232,
0.070650436,
-0.0107640726,
0.0720941573,
-0.0466810353,
0.0092740385,
-0.0011086263,
0.0089580389,
-0.0064268052,
-0.027693117,
-0.0909487456,
0.0092378035,
0.0321111865,
-0.0334085971,
0.0484317951,
-0.0328793265,
-0.0145986229,
0.0388786905,
-0.0437660925,
-0.0116404779,
-0.009865338,
-0.0670649037,
-0.0270978268,
0.0166496467,
0.0006182174,
-0.0395835191,
-0.033268813,
0.0042206873,
0.0273563638,
0.0586479455,
0.0167436022,
0.0156850573,
0.0220126659,
-0.0262447335,
0.0261320788,
-0.0586086735,
-0.0036525202,
-0.0704010874,
-0.0219907276,
-0.0154268388,
-5.526553262e-33,
-0.0684179887,
-0.0343425013,
-0.0353556089,
-0.0048977309,
-0.0633032769,
-0.0163594726,
-0.0828043371,
0.0375709757,
0.0472452417,
0.0095698135,
-0.0012691024,
-0.0073968661,
-0.0082825841,
-0.0023149049,
0.0589514449,
0.0220056809,
0.0378880911,
-0.0265278444,
-0.0626949966,
0.0028798464,
0.0369275026,
0.0047941902,
-0.0177300088,
-0.0458262451,
0.063324526,
-0.0366025306,
-0.0283807255,
-0.0408074856,
0.0262958314,
0.0129559133,
-0.0126320068,
0.0300929472,
0.0336612575,
0.0335011967,
-0.0066866297,
-0.0019137404,
-0.033699438,
-0.0147283291,
-0.0152026704,
-0.0148981772,
0.0062803365,
-0.0608926117,
0.0482880808,
-0.0465831868,
-0.0394104719,
-0.0083280997,
0.0072369743,
-0.0290609766,
0.0433356725,
-0.0697671622,
-0.0598417372,
-0.0188557915,
-0.0496222898,
-0.0473083295,
-0.0067411209,
-0.0132187782,
0.0174608342,
0.0295281727,
-0.0359747335,
0.0422985889,
-0.0278451443,
0.0516384207,
0.0069077453,
-0.014226838,
-0.0039373026,
0.0643701255,
-0.0114643835,
-0.032979127,
0.0013215743,
0.0946065262,
0.0118536158,
-0.0106141623,
0.0943640172,
0.018959742,
0.0538356267,
-0.0042201057,
0.0237924419,
0.0535716303,
-0.0077681825,
-0.0131344795,
0.0115041714,
-0.018444648,
0.0050406251,
0.000640335,
0.0206658952,
-0.0748762041,
-0.0155055597,
-0.0194331966,
0.0366665833,
0.0045821872,
-0.0296103321,
-0.0279887207,
-0.0458879769,
-0.0434470661,
-0.0175278336,
0.0247193705,
-0.0551812686,
0.0692749247,
-0.013944664,
-0.0116168763,
0.0430766419,
0.0122174099,
0.0506825484,
0.038028501,
0.038921196,
-0.0139158554,
0.031548176,
0.0364776105,
-0.0615027845,
0.020964874,
-0.0263722837,
0.0128770964,
0.0025148431,
-0.0329814628,
-0.0154355131,
-0.0253220126,
0.0158418715,
0.0270085111,
0.026464371,
0.0450168662,
-0.0247159507,
-0.000360712,
-0.003290385,
0.0160471667,
0.0058778333,
0.0221462045,
-0.0371132307,
-0.031283211,
-0.00685817,
-0.0065133017,
-0.0117012868,
-0.0101794414,
2.458e-7,
0.0076894406,
0.0299661774,
0.0519534722,
0.010508867,
0.0303424448,
0.0047288006,
-0.0842753798,
0.026641747,
-0.0305825528,
0.0359505005,
0.04084621,
0.0026210605,
0.0642434135,
0.0200446397,
-0.1210594326,
0.0147450576,
-0.0543196388,
-0.0309768524,
-0.1032172814,
-0.0001386741,
0.0960393846,
-0.0218427125,
0.017586749,
0.0140299536,
0.0174086206,
-0.0293566119,
-0.0119445324,
0.0218606275,
0.0480066873,
-0.0172790978,
0.0014489874,
-0.0382988751,
-0.0087877149,
-0.0319048949,
-0.0305140894,
0.0125717875,
0.0484038405,
0.0333888493,
0.0109037077,
0.0188552793,
0.0495993234,
-0.0129038589,
0.0361686759,
-0.0178923588,
0.0392233506,
0.0693184957,
-0.0111505697,
0.0053389347,
-0.0089550549,
-0.0157004241,
0.0350641273,
-0.0372677557,
-0.0648065656,
-0.0079951994,
0.0050922516,
-0.018570466,
0.050013151,
-0.0232595,
-0.0282693431,
-0.0040427367,
-0.0283824541,
-0.0402554758,
-0.0150306262,
0.0092757847,
-0.0102999695,
-0.1214917675,
-0.0375586338,
1.982334388e-34,
0.0725241229,
-0.0359472856,
0.0117336819,
-0.0347163714,
0.0327379107,
0.0141411731,
-0.01128121,
-0.0136771528,
-0.0202804524,
-0.0286657158,
-0.0305251051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20322v1 | FA Team at the NTCIR-17 UFO Task | 2023-10-31T09:56:12 | 2023-10-31T09:56:12 | Yuki Okumura, Masato Fujitake | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The FA team participated in the Table Data Extraction (TDE) and Text-to-Table
Relationship Extraction (TTRE) tasks of the NTCIR-17 Understanding of
Non-Financial Objects in Financial Reports (UFO). This paper reports our
approach to solving the problems and discusses the official results. We
successfully utilized various enhancement techniques based on the ELECTRA
language model to extract valuable data from tables. Our efforts resulted in an
impressive TDE accuracy rate of 93.43 %, positioning us in second place on the
Leaderboard rankings. This outstanding achievement is a testament to our
proposed approach's effectiveness. In the TTRE task, we proposed the rule-based
method to extract meaningful relationships between the text and tables task and
confirmed the performance. | [
0.0400651507,
0.0822877213,
-0.0057859626,
0.0581880324,
-0.0312400982,
0.0414188243,
-0.0529165231,
0.0605545007,
-0.0341934785,
-0.0315485746,
-0.0445309766,
0.001894158,
0.0033793258,
0.0580221713,
0.0045118867,
0.0048921974,
0.0218555704,
0.011253614,
0.0109150698,
0.060998667,
0.018811319,
-0.0011843947,
0.0110732103,
-0.0152372392,
-0.0093876421,
0.0261421185,
0.0139165549,
-0.0373909585,
-0.0198304169,
0.0277434271,
-0.005254583,
0.0312973782,
-0.0029755696,
0.007933436,
0.0000021792,
-0.0438576788,
-0.1081140414,
0.0126661584,
-0.025796596,
-0.0205624457,
0.0553857647,
-0.0589322858,
0.0121673457,
-0.0003461141,
-0.0484425724,
0.0016330985,
0.003519393,
0.0761036277,
0.037258476,
0.049914401,
-0.0231142323,
-0.0174080543,
-0.0049613714,
-0.0136941178,
0.0409662947,
-0.0391652808,
-0.0134387091,
0.0358024389,
-0.0131268362,
-0.0330455564,
0.0110527584,
0.0374374948,
0.0322312228,
-0.0248506349,
0.0105735781,
0.0092401616,
-0.0595620833,
0.0085207941,
-0.0187797211,
0.0322770774,
0.0369950533,
0.0116394758,
0.04213278,
0.0109039759,
0.0153671457,
0.0189673007,
-0.0340578966,
0.0072876527,
-0.0313877314,
-0.0123705314,
0.0369217843,
0.0169343688,
-0.0267170258,
-0.003816341,
-0.0453289971,
0.0227040276,
-0.0317202583,
-0.0480400324,
0.0501935109,
0.0149807157,
0.0265930295,
-0.0237940252,
0.0444612466,
0.0248913877,
0.0505957454,
0.0225159936,
-0.001329239,
-0.0419176966,
0.0128579922,
-0.0780971646,
-0.0038988823,
0.0141593572,
-0.0307291169,
0.0365766324,
-0.0545840785,
0.0192559175,
0.0036535279,
-0.0371477306,
-0.0044439668,
0.0156798214,
-0.0401438624,
0.001204477,
-0.014055551,
0.0726904795,
-0.0967386439,
-0.009682985,
0.0201007668,
-0.0230946504,
-0.0247196127,
0.0762619302,
0.0314495154,
-0.0274419338,
0.0029080911,
-0.0132211028,
-0.0329424664,
-0.0480563119,
0.014670345,
-0.0224311426,
-0.0366304219,
-0.0629928857,
-0.0155391581,
-0.0011661234,
0.0402685478,
-0.0381227285,
0.0335320681,
0.0856581256,
-0.0228705946,
-0.0246014651,
-0.0313471928,
-0.0316729583,
0.0068861092,
-0.0441122018,
-0.01063726,
-0.0031443615,
0.0421047099,
0.003537884,
-0.0200593676,
-0.0372858085,
0.0117357895,
-0.0070708538,
-0.025730582,
0.0455731787,
-0.0249283873,
-0.02014184,
0.0082510319,
-0.0374432802,
-0.0003462476,
0.0432254374,
0.0064409422,
0.0025529421,
0.0074652964,
-0.0049550082,
-0.0127342958,
0.0449971743,
0.0030580587,
-0.0662949681,
-0.008776946,
0.0816069096,
-0.0025351453,
-0.0568993762,
0.0026749987,
-0.0063015409,
0.0056685256,
0.0342562571,
0.0243368428,
-0.0027385107,
0.0206485447,
0.082263045,
-0.0122171203,
0.0033057192,
0.0504735373,
0.0093923202,
-0.0030380981,
0.0165387969,
-0.0065124878,
0.041546315,
-0.0384233855,
0.0140002286,
0.0126726525,
-0.0611623377,
0.0078779524,
-0.000584204,
-0.0152040096,
0.0104613854,
0.0566720814,
0.0140849976,
-0.0593382642,
0.01815724,
0.022503648,
-0.0452062488,
-0.0049444688,
0.0010429714,
0.0511984788,
0.0542424507,
0.0402312502,
-0.0713765323,
-0.02278319,
-0.0260653589,
-0.0165182222,
0.0334695093,
0.0129016284,
-0.0304406192,
-0.0115354182,
-0.008814157,
-0.00902751,
0.0419850424,
0.0323354006,
-0.0371830314,
-0.016627783,
0.0239789411,
0.0249861311,
-0.0569893643,
-0.0415274687,
0.0307942443,
0.041652102,
0.0068212165,
-0.0002406382,
0.0200280119,
-0.0046416656,
0.0546837896,
-0.0185838845,
0.0233888291,
0.0013731821,
-0.0324139297,
0.0279804468,
0.0091577433,
-0.0046806242,
0.041902788,
-0.0113850599,
-0.0027616592,
-0.0596733056,
0.0192336254,
-0.0057310425,
0.0060275095,
-0.0019516968,
0.000506817,
0.0000021469,
-0.0459299348,
0.0326230526,
0.0230424982,
0.0206747614,
0.010966111,
0.0936744064,
0.0061533009,
0.0051575163,
-0.0217382088,
-0.0928065777,
0.0186984707,
-0.0196103249,
0.0811725631,
0.0211708173,
-0.0328783095,
0.0268883742,
0.0539487042,
0.0038294096,
-0.0519065037,
-0.0445538424,
-0.0164903235,
-0.0071450733,
-0.0066346782,
0.0549307987,
0.0178700686,
-0.0033290714,
-0.0282550808,
-0.0210302174,
-0.0259345211,
-0.0353663713,
-0.0299090892,
-0.0572928451,
0.084277153,
0.0069162548,
-0.0297906883,
-0.0503447503,
0.0084018493,
-0.0422725454,
0.0226022527,
0.0477043726,
-0.0833331794,
-0.019522436,
0.0335886776,
0.0216438845,
-0.0008254716,
0.0210548732,
0.0306610782,
-0.0246069301,
-0.0241843872,
0.0372681506,
0.0540381335,
-0.0112175308,
0.0735400617,
-0.0466320589,
-0.0419652723,
-0.024303589,
-0.0011079194,
-0.0053116884,
0.0725574866,
0.0436456464,
-0.0574464612,
0.0843706205,
0.0184982363,
-0.0386732258,
-0.0022739994,
-0.0446843952,
0.0118705155,
-0.0008563651,
0.0097859111,
-0.0490114875,
0.0462673493,
0.0188734364,
0.0168490577,
-0.0095078954,
0.0201989654,
-0.0054680067,
-0.0179974809,
0.0088158874,
-0.0580241717,
-0.0062325979,
-0.0639304295,
0.0647562072,
-0.0045828582,
0.0039713057,
-0.0091782752,
-0.0636021346,
0.0245490335,
-0.0167115778,
0.0351646431,
-0.0133153526,
0.0857320353,
-0.0337133631,
0.0227109678,
-0.0133120799,
0.0165583603,
-0.0115739657,
-0.0506824441,
0.0157856438,
0.0215243232,
0.0258220099,
0.0049540075,
-0.0721466392,
0.0207785908,
0.0185760707,
0.0265103523,
-0.0202739406,
-0.0340968743,
-0.011805539,
0.0548817627,
0.0919080377,
-0.055536367,
-0.0190938525,
-0.0410629027,
0.0263240132,
0.0328533612,
-0.0189157277,
-0.0011912161,
0.012518676,
0.0161607768,
-0.0427281931,
-0.038892407,
0.0239066929,
0.0167593732,
-0.0840370879,
-0.0547070056,
-0.0146473786,
0.0566059239,
0.0317344777,
0.0381092839,
-0.0292452797,
0.0056590312,
-0.0351342857,
-0.0196455717,
0.0569180511,
-0.055420801,
0.0159223061,
-0.0279421434,
-0.0205365829,
0.0129310833,
-0.0614840835,
-0.0422232598,
-0.0637291595,
0.0218347758,
-0.0246030744,
-0.0777672678,
-0.1039832383,
-0.0555783808,
-0.0037153414,
-0.0589204244,
0.0062386193,
0.0413776152,
0.0008157143,
0.0090754991,
0.0205993447,
-0.0857204199,
-0.0067010662,
-0.0203242004,
-0.025859803,
-0.0491711758,
0.0595463812,
0.0274278056,
-0.0615955666,
0.0370103791,
-0.0391845852,
-0.0099582272,
-0.0097457105,
-0.0301415958,
0.0849166065,
-0.0180796124,
-0.0317245126,
0.0024958823,
0.0071168831,
-0.0219605286,
0.0492202155,
0.0303479955,
0.0330234356,
-0.0094465669,
-0.0288439617,
0.0307812802,
-0.0073527726,
0.0048584184,
0.0544777922,
0.010222597,
-0.0017691741,
-0.0174884312,
-0.0183728598,
-0.0214063637,
-0.0433621295,
0.0595052913,
0.0251448359,
-0.0344425663,
-0.0512890108,
-0.0691937208,
-0.0611056797,
0.0474792831,
0.0462037735,
0.0157243367,
0.0357041657,
-0.0024285263,
-0.0096153887,
-0.0360223129,
-0.0043064267,
-0.0500500202,
-0.0039553395,
0.0021981006,
-0.0167515613,
-0.0137008401,
-0.0058161914,
-0.0464451201,
0.0156397671,
-0.0376091376,
0.0094603719,
-0.0052104602,
0.004759891,
0.0219237991,
-0.0257897954,
0.0118865427,
0.0470399521,
-0.0324455425,
0.0180379376,
-0.083454825,
-0.0613813512,
-0.0133387111,
-0.0345074534,
-0.0051693292,
0.0164072141,
-0.0269252509,
-0.0013969687,
0.0017618806,
0.0419270322,
-0.0131996591,
0.0309223756,
0.0528019145,
0.0330348313,
-0.0181870144,
0.0731060281,
-0.0619566478,
-0.0397514179,
0.0281668697,
-0.0554220937,
-0.015322865,
-0.0121715777,
0.0107817044,
0.0053975331,
0.045247782,
-0.0189773925,
0.0054663313,
-0.0271895789,
0.0072553055,
-0.0158484969,
0.0219663642,
0.031850677,
0.0210979097,
-0.005593461,
-0.053941559,
0.0033429156,
-0.0548386276,
0.03519357,
0.0144986706,
-0.014662249,
0.0189228561,
0.0221437793,
-0.0320224352,
-0.0192248933,
0.0281220041,
0.0107476888,
0.0519219339,
0.002415386,
0.0136338416,
-0.0103412494,
-0.0200612023,
0.0041788095,
-0.0450829118,
0.0089317057,
0.0585621893,
0.0311879087,
0.0576618202,
0.0255643707,
0.0268530212,
-0.0029646477,
-0.0222212821,
-0.0229828916,
0.0597316697,
0.0006815661,
-0.0096892435,
-0.0064939624,
-0.0134044942,
-0.0774480924,
0.0274796169,
0.0701421797,
-0.0765679628,
-0.0139124189,
-0.0116388546,
-0.0427834168,
-0.0211567394,
0.0364270546,
0.0260793529,
-0.0256606247,
0.0018633439,
0.0074616191,
0.084323138,
0.0482245758,
-0.0134548517,
-0.0177025013,
0.0370467342,
0.0084571941,
-0.0242232122,
-0.0169851556,
-6.53350707e-33,
-0.0393869244,
-0.0076113879,
0.0006716395,
0.0249065533,
0.0346105695,
0.012920605,
-0.0312320571,
-0.0447637178,
0.0131613156,
0.0165094323,
-0.013550221,
0.0413905531,
0.0379578918,
-0.0459417738,
0.0077340547,
-0.0401793048,
0.0166219715,
-0.0208767001,
-0.0035000206,
-0.0505958833,
-0.0030837993,
0.0628465861,
0.0510695502,
-0.076828666,
0.0763118118,
0.0143040894,
-0.0349541605,
-0.0030767412,
0.0897712111,
0.0092399903,
-0.0373653024,
-0.0101556042,
0.0118816914,
-0.097190626,
0.000712997,
-0.0104653584,
-0.1221662909,
-0.0527790636,
0.0110974805,
0.0188625082,
0.0268556606,
-0.013852044,
0.0348898321,
-0.0265647992,
-0.0015617809,
-0.0170332156,
0.0296534672,
-0.0019266234,
0.0056893611,
0.0044886614,
-0.0814462677,
0.0355240293,
0.0055916631,
0.0577564612,
0.1237028241,
0.0240537915,
-0.0160907526,
-0.0438952893,
0.0035060062,
-0.0247450005,
0.0174061768,
0.0208231248,
0.0328363329,
-0.0429570712,
0.0255956668,
0.0099840928,
0.0095376754,
0.0262703486,
-0.0096335961,
0.0164726228,
-0.0234402064,
0.0552681684,
-0.0001223657,
-0.0293980055,
0.0102367895,
-0.0040459447,
-0.0553716756,
0.0568121001,
0.0192214996,
0.0084316079,
-0.0197783131,
-0.0492620245,
-0.0644688904,
-0.0021101523,
0.0614110865,
0.0027925237,
-0.0197596494,
-0.0381037332,
0.0216769949,
-0.0070847487,
-0.0016332067,
0.0245456323,
-0.0212072134,
0.008998842,
-0.0328870676,
0.0072282273,
0.0099841785,
0.0009168974,
0.0035556864,
-0.0308235567,
-0.0172833223,
-0.0292744432,
-0.0078985458,
0.0153798927,
0.0378254242,
0.004898767,
0.0279520154,
0.0110607399,
-0.0498559214,
-0.0139465481,
-0.0100315074,
0.0262392387,
0.0207510646,
0.0188077465,
-0.0288763959,
0.034505073,
-0.0046741189,
-0.0091635417,
0.0530790314,
-0.0070230407,
0.0009967493,
0.0505119115,
-0.0131342774,
0.0320464857,
0.0280267149,
-0.0324489363,
0.0012682314,
0.0014270711,
0.0251749307,
0.0029590845,
0.0125933522,
0.0121199042,
2.787e-7,
0.0494642481,
0.0316337347,
0.0451599583,
0.0132941352,
-0.0168907456,
-0.0120020602,
-0.0232292358,
0.0158087946,
-0.0102759432,
0.0048902305,
0.0532318838,
-0.0465136394,
0.0660779849,
0.0432094187,
-0.0284248739,
-0.0819201171,
-0.0268633086,
-0.0818260461,
-0.0690097436,
0.0191589706,
0.0235699601,
0.0390921645,
-0.0349886082,
-0.0136806862,
-0.0521894693,
-0.027498126,
-0.004927096,
-0.0750369802,
-0.0097984895,
0.0234224778,
0.0471617468,
-0.0470592678,
-0.0350380726,
0.04858879,
-0.0212519076,
0.0572231337,
0.0496640019,
0.0436895117,
-0.0208878275,
0.0877894536,
0.0119178444,
-0.0502179787,
0.0251229461,
-0.0396160334,
0.0680412054,
-0.0185978767,
-0.0354630835,
0.0701802224,
-0.0338922888,
0.0439235829,
-0.0318935998,
0.0259807333,
-0.0113699064,
0.0382259227,
0.0258565415,
0.0149012413,
0.0226385966,
-0.0132307904,
0.0173930172,
0.0652154461,
0.0081576789,
0.0225143563,
0.0170787517,
0.015986966,
-0.0012990864,
-0.0079638259,
0.0000500648,
2.687422302e-34,
0.0259378143,
-0.0222257841,
-0.001152553,
0.0476880074,
0.092308946,
-0.035811957,
-0.0259900931,
0.0406258516,
-0.0225965623,
-0.0786936805,
0.0130992895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20320v1 | Theory of Mind in Large Language Models: Examining Performance of 11 State-of-the-Art models vs. Children Aged 7-10 on Advanced Tests | 2023-10-31T09:55:07 | 2023-10-31T09:55:07 | Max J. van Duijn, Bram M. A. van Dijk, Tom Kouwenhoven, Werner de Valk, Marco R. Spruit, Peter van der Putten | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To what degree should we ascribe cognitive capacities to Large Language
Models (LLMs), such as the ability to reason about intentions and beliefs known
as Theory of Mind (ToM)? Here we add to this emerging debate by (i) testing 11
base- and instruction-tuned LLMs on capabilities relevant to ToM beyond the
dominant false-belief paradigm, including non-literal language usage and
recursive intentionality; (ii) using newly rewritten versions of standardized
tests to gauge LLMs' robustness; (iii) prompting and scoring for open besides
closed questions; and (iv) benchmarking LLM performance against that of
children aged 7-10 on the same tasks. We find that instruction-tuned LLMs from
the GPT family outperform other models, and often also children. Base-LLMs are
mostly unable to solve ToM tasks, even with specialized prompting. We suggest
that the interlinked evolution and development of language and ToM may help
explain what instruction-tuning adds: rewarding cooperative communication that
takes into account interlocutor and context. We conclude by arguing for a
nuanced perspective on ToM in LLMs. | [
0.0457881615,
0.0338056199,
-0.0570731238,
0.0273930226,
-0.0455755964,
0.0236899368,
0.0242557395,
-0.0134872943,
0.0057867835,
-0.0107525205,
-0.0112298541,
-0.0340231322,
-0.0047669145,
0.0139453029,
0.0387261398,
-0.0458082408,
0.0408068709,
-0.0480065309,
0.0475651361,
-0.0105270613,
-0.0494006239,
0.0108969174,
-0.0142269647,
-0.0000592938,
0.0072402353,
-0.0052262801,
-0.0028724223,
-0.0429709367,
0.0020829707,
-0.0414347537,
-0.0357072912,
0.0044372804,
0.0356872156,
0.0645257905,
0.0000021756,
-0.0723903328,
0.0189440269,
-0.0329848751,
-0.0134696551,
0.0224914365,
0.0112077165,
0.0167417396,
0.0228583459,
0.0107605755,
-0.0211693011,
-0.0016783434,
0.0250607077,
0.0517718941,
-0.0158663951,
0.034404356,
0.012591091,
-0.0144964484,
0.0360756144,
-0.0160564743,
0.0950712264,
-0.0532822087,
0.018425826,
0.0172720402,
0.0219345801,
-0.0078636315,
-0.0202136785,
0.0026491124,
0.0208973754,
-0.0201064497,
-0.034019351,
-0.0168395266,
-0.0056619672,
-0.0250167176,
-0.0110352533,
0.0384581871,
0.122301273,
-0.0025193943,
-0.0140772462,
0.0189541671,
0.0223961268,
0.0543369502,
-0.0331853516,
0.0781572089,
0.0135979038,
0.0056096702,
0.0189774036,
-0.0164127108,
0.0070302603,
0.0258639921,
-0.0011766312,
0.0728593171,
-0.0396655165,
-0.015813075,
0.0090159494,
0.0203659516,
-0.0700884759,
-0.0620157234,
-0.0785105154,
0.0043408503,
-0.0218785871,
0.0149686197,
-0.0282739718,
0.0502476282,
-0.0063474225,
0.0263812952,
0.0634715781,
0.0426299199,
0.0076853684,
0.0354117788,
0.0006120621,
0.0510884002,
-0.0206505507,
0.0619958229,
-0.0049610208,
0.0249089859,
-0.0467088558,
-0.0237228833,
-0.0049102628,
0.0438103713,
0.0332250111,
-0.0056903604,
-0.0002660496,
0.0007377004,
-0.0053489031,
-0.0237235855,
-0.0408586636,
-0.039198257,
0.0180092193,
-0.0054500899,
-0.0709977448,
0.0389569029,
-0.0537914038,
0.0301644858,
0.0238011815,
-0.0589958727,
-0.0439523198,
-0.0125498679,
0.0032103702,
0.0218084119,
-0.0012767365,
0.0214955583,
0.0067557115,
-0.031353347,
0.0180625692,
-0.0205921922,
0.0127899526,
-0.0973239616,
0.0217187181,
-0.028726602,
-0.0272524301,
0.0272680391,
-0.0114465188,
-0.0087699136,
0.0270863809,
-0.0123636331,
-0.0405225791,
0.0032699306,
0.017758267,
0.0265015084,
-0.0139919035,
0.0107984664,
-0.0024379797,
0.0204823837,
0.0234333463,
-0.0443224311,
-0.0296750255,
0.0199059825,
-0.019796513,
-0.0119774761,
-0.0092288638,
-0.015245216,
-0.0094043203,
-0.0001650495,
0.039223168,
0.0532516539,
-0.0022831364,
0.0316244513,
-0.0104258703,
0.0300029758,
0.0668130293,
0.0380076393,
-0.0382916406,
-0.0128387306,
0.0382655226,
0.0265987851,
0.0513592735,
0.0102885142,
-0.0543152168,
0.0414073989,
-0.0469147041,
-0.0311936531,
0.0173803829,
0.0278697535,
-0.0310254302,
0.0149280792,
-0.0099317087,
0.0351621471,
0.0323143341,
0.0446265563,
0.0352325402,
-0.0265729148,
-0.0117055392,
-0.0051395507,
0.0238489024,
-0.0134734046,
-0.0235799197,
-0.081412226,
0.0244983006,
-0.0031829174,
0.0082016652,
-0.0067638382,
-0.0324153975,
-0.0289969686,
-0.0039263419,
0.0789644271,
0.0551554598,
0.0260061231,
-0.0438058004,
-0.0121769318,
-0.0078857718,
-0.0521017015,
0.0205179155,
0.0174049865,
-0.0556660146,
-0.0083634816,
-0.0140375439,
0.0080028949,
0.0338539779,
0.0016098374,
-0.0069720969,
-0.0191821866,
-0.0810560584,
0.0202238876,
0.0360254943,
0.0016089516,
-0.0022436478,
0.0011684727,
0.0058298912,
0.0149187194,
0.012022364,
0.0450099483,
-0.0612111241,
0.0219150875,
0.0171700865,
-0.0067856344,
-0.0312638953,
0.0314019583,
0.0182463713,
-0.0132712275,
0.0789079294,
-0.041041337,
0.0517000258,
0.0077543659,
0.043946635,
-0.0868182629,
-0.0373903513,
0.0061027119,
0.0727349892,
-0.0006446838,
0.0006955999,
0.0242023598,
-0.0724116564,
0.0180878565,
-0.0110782506,
-0.009428164,
0.0076049995,
0.003518464,
-0.0041613397,
0.0011107875,
0.0081759039,
-0.0409038775,
-0.0115807196,
-0.0584916621,
-0.0278655328,
0.0369038731,
-0.004179439,
0.0013113492,
-0.0404683314,
-0.018323632,
0.0547047146,
-0.0100589618,
0.0537386015,
0.03017563,
0.0158415847,
0.0079429084,
-0.0105092302,
-0.0569326654,
0.0084862765,
0.0290506165,
-0.0640894845,
0.0173363015,
0.0169008672,
-0.0295051374,
-0.0149252107,
0.0316481888,
-0.0788762271,
0.0244739018,
-0.0459116362,
-0.0092518535,
0.0514678806,
0.0085247671,
0.0004860196,
0.0956882685,
-0.0241697337,
0.0126377782,
0.0532734059,
-0.0132708382,
-0.048867777,
0.0299918912,
0.03662977,
-0.0435562097,
-0.0393484868,
-0.0502262376,
-0.0461699739,
0.0774340034,
0.0313360728,
0.0075525395,
-0.0491780899,
0.0706150085,
-0.0080457227,
-0.0246706866,
-0.0065790722,
-0.0506646298,
-0.0191017836,
0.056963902,
-0.0211602598,
-0.0478398539,
0.0650267303,
-0.0005987,
0.0016486711,
-0.0328031406,
0.0449661314,
0.0053566573,
0.0852809474,
0.019524144,
0.0218883175,
0.0629613847,
-0.0088760406,
-0.1000642851,
-0.0087475181,
0.0195417851,
0.0042166882,
0.013746351,
-0.0322670862,
-0.012159491,
0.0201193038,
0.0174628571,
-0.0232477672,
0.0180094261,
-0.049811013,
0.0078985253,
-0.0246143956,
-0.0218772776,
-0.061412625,
-0.044789169,
0.0856538713,
-0.0069539864,
-0.0232642367,
-0.0074564684,
-0.0043861326,
-0.070057191,
0.0257389806,
-0.0123585621,
0.0637477487,
-0.0555106625,
0.0496403091,
0.0245491713,
-0.0161050931,
0.036172621,
0.0481401607,
0.0226011146,
0.0193681661,
0.0722773299,
-0.0252852552,
0.0406745188,
0.1130869836,
-0.0314785987,
0.003823508,
0.0877687111,
0.0240263809,
-0.0106873596,
-0.0158356111,
-0.0156250242,
0.0070436089,
0.0355874449,
-0.0088941883,
-0.0688067153,
0.0079586003,
0.0107128778,
-0.0239401925,
-0.0547118746,
-0.0699755996,
-0.0111127635,
-0.0756811723,
-0.0091558984,
0.0098627657,
0.0089508211,
0.0145659093,
-0.0068796682,
0.0210722741,
0.0800324157,
-0.0091799563,
0.0257814154,
0.0123922341,
0.0035245565,
-0.0332521796,
0.0332233123,
-0.0291011203,
0.0738588646,
-0.0085061807,
0.0987908393,
0.0265065189,
0.0019593427,
-0.0228703879,
-0.0652168542,
0.0335931219,
0.0357017703,
-0.0199854355,
-0.0025351346,
-0.0450217314,
-0.004667623,
0.0258944239,
-0.0391247422,
0.0205440111,
-0.00657799,
0.0138619654,
0.0006891901,
0.0917977542,
-0.0014323439,
-0.0416571125,
0.0315532684,
0.0409015939,
-0.055960089,
0.0759396479,
0.0272283107,
-0.0331356451,
0.0544928722,
-0.0181170888,
-0.0602403469,
0.0438628793,
-0.052772183,
0.0171902645,
0.0464406274,
0.0029075656,
-0.0396322869,
-0.031252522,
0.0388212875,
-0.0224059727,
0.0275430549,
-0.0255712159,
-0.0064916816,
0.0002208417,
-0.0221987236,
0.0364794321,
-0.0146715688,
-0.0219951384,
-0.0476785116,
-0.0249429625,
-0.0402736291,
-0.0892617702,
-0.0046359398,
-0.0048107416,
-0.0055001173,
-0.0716915354,
0.0046526007,
0.0053304471,
0.0300230607,
-0.0176272914,
0.0373930186,
-0.0410529114,
-0.013697871,
-0.0754028112,
-0.0248595625,
0.0617849268,
-0.0288761985,
0.047458481,
0.0223301742,
0.0282223411,
-0.0182202533,
0.0155119747,
0.0120520871,
-0.0016952194,
0.0167558771,
-0.01170386,
0.032203801,
0.0249456707,
0.0212210435,
0.0326199494,
0.0086709717,
-0.0292588845,
-0.0268370286,
-0.0511159413,
-0.008529475,
-0.0236610919,
-0.0249979515,
0.0440723263,
0.0338240787,
0.0188461747,
-0.0892233774,
-0.0149868559,
0.0128549663,
0.0129357213,
0.036498528,
-0.0243602339,
0.0393637307,
-0.0103242118,
0.0430992693,
0.0012651625,
-0.0195615236,
-0.0511822738,
0.0247336142,
0.0228125621,
0.1204921752,
0.0178673528,
-0.0198960714,
-0.004167337,
-0.0256532542,
-0.0614359677,
-0.1000936031,
0.0535048135,
0.0039254902,
-0.0129890954,
-0.0026411251,
-0.0156658553,
-0.0745677203,
0.0208817888,
-0.0081864987,
-0.0007162679,
0.0217802469,
-0.0534118414,
0.0152422851,
-0.0005378713,
0.0093410686,
-0.0307882372,
-0.00369865,
-0.0282234289,
0.0490173548,
-0.0119275674,
0.0072318884,
-0.0189451762,
0.0464690179,
-0.0176590588,
0.063478373,
-0.0053171101,
0.0632051751,
-0.0808443204,
0.0001710137,
0.0013066931,
0.0058095753,
-0.009119546,
-0.0355991609,
0.0063708536,
0.0565266572,
-0.0148473745,
-0.0657546967,
0.0295585245,
0.0201036558,
-0.0127655538,
-0.0164784789,
-0.0274429526,
-6.375303897e-33,
-0.0344921164,
-0.008036837,
-0.0014100934,
-0.0035797509,
-0.0389984548,
-0.0251664743,
-0.0519649871,
0.0601648279,
-0.0426848829,
-0.0036132091,
0.0236469395,
-0.0078797191,
-0.0130448891,
-0.0059709228,
0.0123851066,
-0.01047685,
-0.0330043286,
-0.021800641,
-0.0404860415,
-0.0245036911,
0.0071041943,
-0.0355377458,
0.0706060007,
-0.0478000753,
0.0441891886,
0.0123958271,
0.0352800749,
0.0307401475,
-0.0608896911,
-0.0250363927,
-0.0075910119,
0.014845415,
0.0307202041,
-0.0138727222,
0.0023780181,
0.0124367904,
0.00298489,
-0.0304323938,
0.0912266523,
-0.0419506058,
-0.0199203454,
-0.0490287393,
-0.0027902373,
-0.010986208,
-0.0424244292,
-0.0165475756,
-0.0034191876,
0.0154555095,
0.0459387824,
0.074792102,
-0.0608745813,
-0.0549789667,
-0.0005265227,
-0.036871668,
0.0022766432,
0.0079108775,
-0.0066987709,
-0.0251399577,
-0.0353633091,
0.0379725359,
0.0427608341,
0.0014170023,
0.0521246791,
-0.0294949841,
0.0645506904,
0.0770252496,
0.0510941669,
0.0386302769,
-0.0246667434,
-0.0185374673,
0.033272095,
0.02823532,
0.0334800594,
0.0059552942,
-0.0278719235,
-0.0187339522,
-0.056803789,
-0.0393743329,
0.0400622301,
0.0467812158,
0.0413225368,
-0.0265871566,
-0.0170767289,
-0.0017278756,
-0.0461228937,
-0.0312882811,
-0.0335594527,
-0.0035260664,
0.0103791887,
-0.0117555028,
-0.0122516779,
-0.0596618652,
0.0168455243,
0.0004590176,
0.0137934592,
-0.0276485253,
-0.0116528524,
0.0341106057,
-0.0026083337,
0.0104651544,
-0.0605335012,
-0.0179688651,
-0.0130038941,
0.00178217,
0.0333542936,
0.0413598903,
-0.0120260045,
0.0004957304,
-0.012069528,
0.0012519181,
-0.0400510803,
0.0160720684,
-0.000512735,
-0.0534141436,
0.0251727998,
0.0260323118,
-0.016359508,
-0.0425361283,
0.0082740951,
-0.075720638,
-0.0757277682,
0.0242696125,
-0.0305162501,
-0.0205778647,
-0.020359192,
0.0038039025,
-0.0171357691,
0.0143361827,
0.0264541786,
-0.0180309415,
-0.0155493403,
-0.0290913619,
2.968e-7,
-0.0163637325,
0.0849503577,
-0.0293287784,
0.0100559965,
0.0255865436,
0.0368099622,
-0.0333869569,
-0.0110702235,
0.0756507069,
-0.0500078835,
-0.0551206246,
0.0182251427,
0.0343169644,
-0.0026738197,
-0.0313073099,
0.0319979638,
0.0371051058,
-0.0055563166,
-0.0193676557,
0.0291094668,
0.044727236,
0.019980615,
0.0323176757,
0.0033892333,
-0.0037220598,
0.0306376368,
0.0151375653,
-0.0412096493,
0.009299146,
-0.0306510925,
-0.0081155999,
-0.019156225,
0.0167000238,
0.0422912613,
0.0523475669,
0.0439770408,
-0.0565309599,
0.0084430417,
0.0039975699,
0.0082944948,
-0.0267410018,
0.0036959522,
-0.036992643,
-0.0741641521,
0.0384387523,
-0.0505299233,
-0.0415219404,
0.0761500373,
0.0260996055,
-0.0190753918,
0.0085281422,
0.0330401883,
-0.0012891042,
0.0132950349,
0.0057488745,
-0.0289435275,
0.0456554592,
-0.0359749459,
0.0048710154,
-0.019896606,
-0.0165267512,
-0.0678468049,
-0.0375173315,
-0.0197376627,
-0.0009500727,
-0.049842976,
0.0154580968,
2.410072675e-34,
0.0049337745,
-0.031667199,
0.0582927652,
-0.0569549054,
0.0583279543,
-0.0142219663,
-0.000156218,
0.017785795,
0.0412273034,
-0.07734593,
-0.0117133548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20274v1 | Extracting Entities of Interest from Comparative Product Reviews | 2023-10-31T08:43:11 | 2023-10-31T08:43:11 | Jatin Arora, Sumit Agrawal, Pawan Goyal, Sayan Pathak | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; H.3.3 | This paper presents a deep learning based approach to extract product
comparison information out of user reviews on various e-commerce websites. Any
comparative product review has three major entities of information: the names
of the products being compared, the user opinion (predicate) and the feature or
aspect under comparison. All these informing entities are dependent on each
other and bound by the rules of the language, in the review. We observe that
their inter-dependencies can be captured well using LSTMs. We evaluate our
system on existing manually labeled datasets and observe out-performance over
the existing Semantic Role Labeling (SRL) framework popular for this task. | [
0.0522876531,
0.0175866988,
0.0128407571,
0.0570686534,
-0.0262135658,
0.0132173458,
0.0017527281,
-0.0247440413,
-0.0392532386,
-0.0857868791,
-0.070305258,
-0.0503483862,
-0.0435933918,
0.0477522686,
-0.033736337,
-0.025207743,
0.0112073254,
0.0376205854,
0.0520630442,
0.0215737168,
0.0113336211,
0.0325934105,
-0.0007239198,
-0.0106864823,
0.0118756313,
0.0057624946,
0.0503794923,
-0.0170937832,
0.0416733585,
-0.0138514582,
0.0261862539,
0.0254262201,
0.0056164279,
0.0182503387,
0.000001829,
-0.0196068101,
0.0001271456,
-0.031679891,
0.0050408733,
-0.0061983215,
0.0614420399,
0.0008458281,
0.0251644999,
-0.0171851665,
-0.0585446097,
-0.068900995,
0.0120676225,
0.0850122795,
0.0096764537,
0.049423214,
-0.0306426827,
-0.0211231373,
-0.0295403339,
-0.0501678884,
-0.0100914473,
-0.0369794257,
0.009745338,
-0.0183050297,
-0.0084841978,
0.0340737477,
0.0332808048,
0.0067346543,
0.0362700745,
-0.0178363789,
-0.0094001796,
0.0106727136,
0.0512318574,
0.0616385005,
-0.013391139,
0.0932163149,
0.0183753427,
0.0203345232,
-0.0047004241,
-0.0139085418,
-0.0122788986,
-0.0090739978,
0.0115935076,
0.0076714125,
0.0367366932,
0.0356650725,
0.0011074407,
0.0551880226,
0.0270658992,
-0.0019952422,
-0.0188772436,
0.0485739484,
-0.0174355004,
-0.0433727913,
0.0330739431,
0.0543272793,
0.0283632185,
-0.0168129168,
0.0132620391,
-0.038629204,
0.003820637,
0.0116469506,
-0.0086667556,
0.0066671432,
-0.0255745724,
-0.0707102641,
0.0075741583,
-0.0681433678,
-0.0196975898,
0.0653166249,
-0.0283821467,
0.0118980333,
-0.0068597398,
0.0112891542,
-0.0426433831,
0.0236318409,
-0.0814470872,
-0.0240731519,
0.0353400707,
0.0638565123,
-0.005102077,
-0.0029530597,
-0.0556873158,
-0.0419236273,
-0.0766812488,
0.005552311,
0.0341502316,
0.0239996947,
0.012876167,
0.016911868,
-0.0565828234,
0.0208445583,
-0.0393841974,
0.0237487461,
-0.0460602529,
-0.0289841071,
0.0322126299,
0.021909574,
0.0524381511,
-0.0480576791,
-0.0055969385,
0.0482906215,
0.0470454544,
-0.0241786744,
-0.0174801443,
-0.0445125252,
0.0178832076,
-0.0189515278,
-0.0292881206,
-0.066667363,
0.0468768589,
-0.0351672992,
-0.0249395724,
-0.0088536972,
0.0079395836,
0.0075918734,
-0.0063488111,
0.0745188072,
-0.0478343964,
-0.0499363951,
-0.0201207176,
-0.0014357303,
0.038287919,
0.0176399779,
-0.0097841937,
0.0195838157,
0.0255028568,
-0.0014355747,
-0.0017714765,
-0.0069082053,
-0.0220630206,
-0.0396611877,
0.0006118587,
0.0151380105,
-0.0645901859,
-0.0115826204,
0.0434334837,
0.0247694906,
-0.0174108297,
-0.0158508532,
0.0476927683,
0.025082916,
-0.0217363201,
0.0371891633,
0.0230810959,
0.031894546,
-0.0191662535,
0.0139059573,
-0.0159542523,
0.0038921281,
0.0685881525,
-0.0248065908,
-0.0642148703,
-0.0354492962,
-0.0059470013,
-0.0285216309,
0.0276251584,
-0.0672798306,
0.0104105817,
-0.0106409453,
0.0515099876,
0.0387875177,
-0.0259835459,
0.0651289076,
0.0401031002,
-0.021575857,
0.0009577341,
-0.0422883295,
0.010239277,
0.0869893357,
-0.0231573936,
-0.0163147692,
-0.0331877284,
-0.0046481616,
-0.0476390943,
0.0243481379,
0.0712081939,
0.003772866,
-0.0059785717,
-0.0262907408,
-0.0305232946,
-0.0665764064,
-0.0138326278,
0.0251091104,
-0.0028246117,
0.0224810094,
0.0521925837,
0.0115898717,
-0.0279926695,
-0.0134292506,
0.0746105984,
-0.0145594478,
0.0390587747,
0.0280524511,
0.0272449888,
0.0538957603,
-0.0044632745,
0.0179973952,
0.0038987626,
-0.0505451672,
-0.0801585987,
0.0210879724,
-0.0314146727,
-0.0247559194,
-0.0076953978,
-0.0661428496,
-0.0272740815,
0.044530578,
-0.0533354804,
-0.0440216884,
0.0013014998,
0.0055832812,
0.0299129356,
0.0103134653,
-0.0379418992,
0.0531728864,
-0.0256280769,
-0.0291217268,
0.060672421,
0.013098483,
0.0085446211,
-0.0199280009,
-0.0360470675,
-0.0359601453,
0.0073731998,
-0.0339897051,
0.0159480702,
0.0173075981,
0.0002799607,
0.0263361037,
0.0330391265,
-0.0172884669,
0.0321138091,
-0.0494667143,
-0.0098529477,
0.0122502791,
0.0559141263,
0.0342763029,
-0.0202811547,
0.0206110198,
0.0115300231,
-0.0712924153,
-0.0142216971,
-0.0269082431,
-0.0011808642,
0.0653800368,
0.0502368696,
0.0216147304,
-0.0565140098,
-0.0314049534,
-0.0034568887,
0.0304474588,
0.0045135482,
-0.0046220887,
-0.0145310117,
0.0134352949,
-0.0462738723,
0.0134587148,
0.0114513719,
-0.0034877043,
-0.0367212445,
-0.0221094601,
-0.0269965529,
-0.0066487123,
-0.0113135679,
0.0341735929,
0.0450911149,
-0.0059921346,
-0.0408152305,
-0.0036476885,
-0.0355471857,
0.0464700721,
-0.018059751,
0.0086669577,
0.0478680208,
0.0544060133,
0.0032659622,
0.0083177201,
-0.0183730833,
-0.0118213696,
-0.0228216331,
-0.0177104417,
-0.0045481934,
-0.0045797345,
0.0093499608,
0.0053751026,
-0.0346791521,
0.011413699,
0.0803767368,
0.0354289263,
0.0296135582,
-0.0472774878,
0.0078559779,
-0.0735761598,
0.055559434,
0.0112432055,
0.0109509528,
-0.0562259704,
-0.0156425852,
0.0278885271,
0.0256145205,
0.0316890851,
-0.0007104861,
0.0186741371,
-0.0200712252,
0.0200077742,
-0.0385649428,
-0.0695681721,
0.0199579857,
-0.0036147353,
-0.0322992876,
-0.0447808541,
0.0291714855,
-0.0051308,
0.0070625907,
0.0331902355,
-0.0608432852,
0.0255881604,
0.0037119118,
0.0240395274,
0.0128365923,
0.0506865308,
0.0751987249,
-0.0161062665,
-0.0140045946,
-0.0012367407,
0.0231658742,
0.0548380762,
-0.0290775448,
-0.0035236357,
-0.0340800285,
-0.0341766402,
0.0071436046,
-0.0411295593,
0.0030540887,
-0.043609526,
-0.0039787618,
-0.0713671148,
0.0157936048,
0.1247806251,
0.0044580759,
-0.0596930534,
-0.0092073511,
0.04890012,
-0.0375546031,
-0.0007902212,
-0.0126699209,
-0.0931906849,
-0.0093328012,
-0.0407972224,
-0.013352531,
-0.0024513225,
-0.0124248229,
0.0122964624,
-0.1290120631,
-0.0163640101,
-0.0506337695,
-0.0254039411,
-0.0495555848,
0.0096109621,
0.0021953827,
-0.024236355,
0.0244263634,
-0.0176144876,
-0.0068348111,
0.0054949177,
0.0028481483,
-0.0399917625,
-0.043128442,
0.0699811876,
-0.0398725979,
0.0038694851,
0.0537483916,
0.0163513049,
-0.0120372539,
0.0201024935,
0.0228738654,
-0.0368044078,
-0.018329503,
0.0102423215,
0.0668123588,
-0.0264531597,
-0.0328263193,
-0.0148371719,
-0.0027944406,
-0.0506555736,
0.0481156446,
-0.0193903875,
-0.0436151773,
0.0137273036,
-0.0525949039,
-0.0041049849,
0.0035161972,
-0.0171178617,
0.0817415714,
0.0037678848,
-0.0640405715,
-0.0481891744,
0.0163717847,
-0.045640517,
-0.0630527064,
-0.0465579815,
-0.0073739244,
0.0079141948,
-0.0308138169,
-0.1031000167,
-0.0676780194,
0.0226307809,
-0.0179752484,
-0.0013380303,
-0.0282876492,
0.0330724642,
0.0046460582,
-0.0706950426,
0.0074386499,
-0.0121080186,
0.0090544885,
-0.0102254683,
0.0022424886,
0.1113903373,
0.0311085507,
-0.019803118,
-0.0196226891,
-0.0338660628,
0.0027013032,
-0.0165975932,
0.0488667376,
0.0063599269,
0.0309538841,
0.001497145,
-0.0295920726,
-0.0212983321,
0.0122044664,
-0.0168764032,
-0.0467335507,
0.0258321259,
0.0405772068,
0.0039356118,
0.032458283,
-0.0232947171,
0.0414781533,
0.0196306612,
-0.0145456381,
-0.0425060801,
-0.0410765074,
0.0196847785,
-0.0324901976,
0.066116631,
0.0554571375,
0.0384745598,
-0.0588409267,
0.0250581559,
-0.0288171861,
-0.0079678344,
-0.0512264818,
0.0083523663,
-0.0009787466,
0.0227857418,
-0.0398891829,
0.0449872054,
0.0839288756,
0.0197336543,
-0.0532717556,
0.0405702405,
0.0191869475,
0.0147575997,
-0.041005183,
-0.0059745805,
-0.0399640352,
0.0237447824,
0.052340053,
0.0019907465,
-0.0074847615,
-0.0086948788,
0.0347719342,
0.022840254,
0.0027787753,
0.0534712039,
-0.015114815,
0.0063101724,
-0.0485832207,
-0.0208908468,
0.0052522854,
-0.0479550362,
0.0524880067,
-0.014059959,
-0.0165752321,
0.0209392589,
0.0193144828,
-0.0307209231,
0.0319453515,
0.0567717291,
0.0123586338,
0.0014791639,
0.0112390425,
0.07497143,
0.0062707742,
0.0167598519,
0.0242870115,
-0.0360614471,
-0.0402400307,
-0.0035671808,
-0.0154767903,
0.0039790194,
0.0105332928,
0.0017203256,
-0.0184732135,
-0.0484716929,
-0.0082352841,
0.020484522,
0.0431961715,
0.0319625065,
0.0837879553,
0.0359399617,
0.0461928286,
0.0053803357,
-0.0108062942,
-0.0281304177,
0.0180766191,
-0.0350721292,
-0.0317426845,
-6.332059664e-33,
-0.0106767528,
-0.0363574848,
-0.0334392972,
0.0372654125,
-0.0143719176,
0.023628924,
-0.0090554683,
-0.0131221721,
0.003881874,
0.048025094,
0.0536242202,
0.0026527506,
0.016075246,
0.0336531773,
0.0205653328,
-0.0434988029,
0.0530697629,
0.0218955036,
0.0450612754,
0.0381543972,
0.024529824,
0.0457592383,
0.1017916277,
-0.0733333528,
0.0443029702,
-0.0050083697,
-0.0013968888,
-0.000163217,
0.0040988806,
0.0484291874,
0.0080641015,
0.0612023883,
0.0591824464,
-0.0436550751,
0.0261296201,
0.0227654018,
-0.0726684183,
-0.0142161772,
-0.0125431437,
-0.0188733581,
-0.0283861961,
0.0080987904,
0.0525876917,
0.0234294944,
0.0251499247,
0.0239974335,
0.0683829561,
-0.009589036,
0.027686568,
-0.0872226357,
-0.0600202978,
0.0295023099,
-0.0266157277,
0.0152124381,
0.0291992314,
0.0348488204,
-0.0066095293,
0.0065566669,
-0.0704470575,
0.0218492169,
-0.0307528414,
0.0571677424,
0.0051513454,
0.0035064556,
-0.0602846257,
0.0636126474,
-0.0216843355,
0.011708797,
-0.0068184994,
0.0265030414,
-0.0126238698,
0.0673376843,
0.0024429171,
0.0191057269,
0.0391601287,
-0.0100721242,
-0.0599502213,
0.0101563847,
0.0429858677,
0.0039568795,
0.0019791776,
-0.017383825,
-0.0296284109,
0.0046994053,
0.0265482962,
0.0189650524,
-0.046005547,
-0.0211632047,
0.0064742086,
-0.0002786567,
-0.0730359852,
0.0062825861,
-0.0367611572,
-0.0474800244,
-0.0322303548,
-0.0263235662,
-0.0112333046,
-0.0008186413,
-0.0082917903,
-0.0555609427,
-0.035830114,
-0.026770601,
-0.048039332,
-0.0065431977,
-0.0033788919,
-0.0046076397,
0.0537378825,
-0.0123877162,
-0.0560921319,
0.0016578633,
-0.0012405572,
-0.0098069478,
-0.0519428961,
0.0766671896,
0.0058861105,
0.0016383978,
-0.0278822035,
0.0785307512,
0.0199292321,
0.0148180705,
-0.0374801867,
0.0368827768,
0.0310648791,
-0.0019769946,
0.0165365059,
-0.0274095945,
-0.0262158234,
0.0040973322,
-0.0150466124,
-0.0491895266,
-0.0109983124,
0.0047838944,
2.598e-7,
0.0569163151,
0.0210680049,
0.030613929,
-0.0254940093,
0.0338010043,
0.0251294505,
0.053465426,
0.0573014356,
0.001354276,
0.0044276663,
0.056355264,
0.024439184,
0.0029009087,
0.0212526526,
-0.0935814232,
0.0239889044,
-0.0829098523,
-0.0676943287,
-0.0303842016,
-0.0218086727,
0.0873430669,
0.0543819256,
0.0179745872,
-0.0131601952,
-0.016248595,
-0.0206954163,
0.0469509251,
-0.0525632426,
0.0128328865,
0.0102771288,
0.0496197678,
0.0088658221,
-0.0429715589,
0.0024520671,
-0.0198273864,
0.0309251435,
0.0309195649,
0.0271209478,
0.0155956848,
-0.0614586286,
0.0069938311,
0.0008244127,
0.0151786041,
0.0145326518,
0.043402072,
-0.0602189936,
-0.0288797617,
-0.0616105236,
-0.0170978289,
-0.0023573742,
0.0185406804,
-0.0128178587,
-0.0240089782,
0.0428540148,
0.0004585253,
-0.0615156926,
-0.0665752515,
-0.0789899305,
0.022132704,
0.0288413148,
0.0004048944,
0.0112119252,
0.021788992,
-0.0107991882,
-0.0292244125,
0.0002136508,
0.0293237027,
1.892789843e-34,
0.046521835,
0.0292766094,
0.008419509,
0.0136136338,
0.0483746454,
0.0454756171,
-0.0963197872,
-0.0256566461,
-0.0131065231,
-0.0171662737,
0.0101615898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20260v1 | Learning to Play Chess from Textbooks (LEAP): a Corpus for Evaluating Chess Moves based on Sentiment Analysis | 2023-10-31T08:26:02 | 2023-10-31T08:26:02 | Haifa Alrdahi, Riza Batista-Navarro | cs.CL | cs.CL | Learning chess strategies has been investigated widely, with most studies
focussing on learning from previous games using search algorithms. Chess
textbooks encapsulate grandmaster knowledge, explain playing strategies and
require a smaller search space compared to traditional chess agents. This paper
examines chess textbooks as a new knowledge source for enabling machines to
learn how to play chess -- a resource that has not been explored previously. We
developed the LEAP corpus, a first and new heterogeneous dataset with
structured (chess move notations and board states) and unstructured data
(textual descriptions) collected from a chess textbook containing 1164
sentences discussing strategic moves from 91 games. We firstly labelled the
sentences based on their relevance, i.e., whether they are discussing a move.
Each relevant sentence was then labelled according to its sentiment towards the
described move. We performed empirical experiments that assess the performance
of various transformer-based baseline models for sentiment analysis. Our
results demonstrate the feasibility of employing transformer-based sentiment
analysis models for evaluating chess moves, with the best performing model
obtaining a weighted micro F_1 score of 68%. Finally, we synthesised the LEAP
corpus to create a larger dataset, which can be used as a solution to the
limited textual resource in the chess domain. | [
0.0446763933,
0.0125324419,
-0.035086032,
0.0692941472,
-0.0073917289,
0.0019606422,
-0.0567412935,
-0.0096200397,
-0.0025924982,
-0.0460095666,
-0.0406444594,
-0.0378434807,
-0.0033057763,
-0.0104404204,
0.0206680913,
-0.0379601307,
0.0053514624,
0.0088681849,
0.0075506605,
0.0113483286,
0.0186138302,
-0.0060979915,
-0.0159462355,
0.0469103046,
0.0080097532,
0.0264841802,
-0.0597220734,
0.0027981121,
-0.0137597686,
-0.0422898419,
-0.0279635452,
-0.0168879367,
-0.0152289215,
-0.0339346193,
0.0000018295,
-0.0037397214,
-0.0252033807,
-0.0678752661,
0.0661162212,
-0.0385438278,
0.0604586639,
-0.03175769,
0.0280507617,
-0.027711235,
-0.0616278499,
-0.0142491078,
0.0497915484,
0.0404848382,
0.0571880117,
0.0762555376,
-0.005048878,
-0.0497481786,
0.0251257606,
0.0455043837,
0.0054447106,
-0.0199519284,
0.0012706345,
0.0253846832,
-0.0281113107,
0.0414548144,
-0.0244801529,
-0.0048286193,
-0.0376131386,
0.0007476876,
-0.0104294056,
-0.0068180859,
0.0166073125,
0.0414290354,
0.0001739544,
0.0162149649,
-0.0417355932,
0.0074402406,
0.0362191573,
-0.0003542136,
0.0344076417,
0.0106347967,
-0.0121892663,
0.0298983343,
-0.016535243,
-0.001186664,
-0.0052499371,
0.0215578955,
0.0178654641,
-0.0079341289,
0.0080835186,
0.0255384352,
-0.0343412235,
-0.0432561189,
-0.003025179,
-0.0004256623,
-0.0151578644,
-0.0434713438,
-0.0100690518,
0.0098446589,
-0.0348203629,
0.0274783541,
0.0059158951,
-0.0002194516,
-0.0192304719,
-0.0523429774,
0.0528075136,
0.0275503267,
0.0500556603,
-0.003341903,
-0.0278099012,
0.0041913586,
-0.0049631614,
-0.0023599174,
-0.0749170259,
0.0042381147,
-0.086344026,
0.0019811885,
-0.0220504571,
0.0481033809,
-0.0427225009,
-0.0035306204,
-0.0508024655,
0.0027854526,
0.0139287636,
0.0401248112,
0.0186838843,
0.0279431026,
0.0488848984,
0.0140386093,
-0.0376318209,
0.0049435133,
-0.050841067,
0.0118017951,
-0.032857269,
-0.0236676801,
0.0115603628,
0.0157254767,
-0.017792562,
-0.0249493401,
0.037304014,
0.0524612926,
0.0178244375,
-0.0016215706,
0.0123652592,
0.0013401773,
-0.0140411137,
-0.051255472,
0.031429477,
-0.0602286123,
-0.0100479331,
-0.0237572342,
0.019366838,
0.0153242145,
-0.0048325201,
0.0377353393,
0.0059545231,
0.061830312,
0.0167276356,
0.0035824201,
-0.0007822537,
-0.0272958037,
-0.0252765305,
0.0541495718,
0.0232758094,
-0.0003816947,
0.0309993122,
0.0050878795,
0.0219858456,
0.0113465488,
-0.0217561908,
-0.0582985356,
-0.0086267488,
0.0181552731,
-0.0237880498,
0.0548668653,
-0.0509255081,
0.028142307,
0.0073636537,
-0.0546161495,
0.0279356316,
0.0389753506,
0.0364614017,
0.0639920607,
0.0246623121,
-0.0029984177,
0.0187658109,
-0.0264401119,
0.0181467012,
0.0220691804,
0.0327663794,
0.0079780845,
-0.0488064699,
0.0229592044,
0.007270264,
-0.0952792615,
0.0037816342,
-0.0259659104,
0.0099928975,
-0.0184170641,
0.0524981469,
-0.008669286,
-0.042337466,
0.046262078,
0.0052431077,
-0.0733402073,
-0.0057667191,
-0.0554338507,
-0.0058677592,
0.0650270507,
0.0158104934,
-0.0721730962,
-0.0148955751,
-0.0008021523,
-0.0163179561,
0.0242612809,
-0.0332120098,
-0.0175025463,
0.0079530496,
-0.0458039455,
-0.0089661898,
-0.015349282,
0.0225516316,
0.0085752383,
-0.0270108208,
0.0170527454,
-0.0041795666,
-0.0326232314,
-0.0504526347,
0.0328988545,
0.0348685309,
-0.05535274,
0.0169174243,
0.0084170317,
0.0118254004,
0.073735632,
-0.0070699309,
-0.0055743502,
0.0380440019,
0.0065584271,
-0.0524659678,
0.0128851412,
0.0175365936,
-0.0191364754,
0.007772747,
-0.0707188845,
0.0226144083,
0.0581078716,
-0.000878413,
-0.00996162,
-0.0063074585,
-0.0041057356,
0.0289332289,
0.0359189063,
0.0184694845,
-0.0316778682,
-0.0057486445,
0.0096136676,
0.0437671281,
0.0167975686,
0.0026806989,
-0.0265448075,
-0.0386441499,
0.0207337104,
-0.00370398,
-0.047944475,
0.0258784872,
0.0105768228,
0.0040887315,
0.051760599,
0.001472049,
-0.0456746444,
-0.0219021216,
-0.1043566242,
0.025180323,
0.0116200987,
0.0135311456,
0.0122557636,
-0.0293466542,
0.0024625338,
0.019346131,
-0.0351119041,
-0.0022718585,
-0.0074987262,
-0.0150405606,
0.0266565606,
0.0208736621,
0.0446834639,
-0.0486235358,
-0.0240386557,
-0.030157961,
0.026614435,
0.0289427824,
0.039848607,
-0.0385700092,
0.0586916879,
-0.027288802,
0.0119294543,
-0.0302786622,
-0.0535096861,
0.0283434801,
-0.0413937941,
-0.0517125204,
0.037776418,
0.0223845169,
0.0265302192,
0.0704346672,
-0.0546452738,
0.0045726821,
0.0066062524,
-0.0472967625,
-0.0386222899,
-0.0655105934,
-0.0065939738,
0.0484417006,
0.0476420186,
-0.0054568974,
-0.0126801329,
-0.0777062476,
-0.0339612477,
-0.0284440331,
0.0217418279,
-0.0398890898,
-0.0073659597,
0.0177369453,
-0.031189438,
0.010962653,
0.0587201007,
0.0575225279,
-0.0010936944,
0.0317072496,
-0.0662758052,
-0.0011083323,
-0.0221974738,
0.0474068262,
0.0031910627,
-0.0054106913,
-0.0160946473,
0.0291653294,
-0.0415604636,
-0.0367546156,
0.0581434555,
-0.0265145209,
0.0320648476,
0.0066295681,
-0.0212837718,
0.0459624454,
-0.0107163535,
0.0234614033,
-0.0232013278,
-0.0459377654,
-0.0319301412,
0.0705392361,
-0.0300931484,
-0.0795235261,
-0.0234370586,
0.0131386444,
-0.0415937491,
0.0031776181,
-0.0677329525,
0.0261725914,
0.0169364084,
0.0254777279,
0.0080418093,
0.0054825833,
-0.0376035795,
0.0435315371,
0.0706696287,
-0.0193620007,
-0.0464665145,
-0.0089065591,
-0.0502667502,
-0.0078136493,
-0.0301180463,
-0.0349783301,
-0.0106512299,
-0.0169231761,
-0.0704562366,
0.0228381399,
0.1009518057,
0.0467203632,
0.0114980061,
-0.0158150978,
0.0320966393,
-0.0382241346,
-0.0437646918,
-0.0090089897,
-0.086925447,
-0.007592387,
-0.0400117859,
0.0329147279,
-0.0234683454,
-0.0295960307,
0.0318476632,
-0.1107242927,
-0.0392803289,
0.0035739765,
-0.0130531443,
-0.0477270372,
0.0029842581,
-0.0152363228,
-0.0565104969,
-0.0392258726,
-0.0223011225,
-0.0082056122,
0.051360786,
0.0076802587,
-0.0248013586,
0.001819146,
-0.0081826337,
-0.0440065078,
0.0050649797,
0.0194416363,
0.0976703614,
-0.0366643481,
-0.0331384614,
-0.0287773069,
0.007318432,
0.0069690607,
-0.0047244276,
0.0880370289,
-0.0353667997,
-0.0055659339,
0.0021192257,
-0.0217391178,
-0.0120214066,
-0.018415207,
0.062699005,
0.0511580482,
0.0339103155,
-0.02123552,
0.0122856153,
0.0142437508,
0.0477066189,
0.0555726476,
-0.0398379117,
-0.0274066776,
0.0325462781,
0.0049172738,
0.0493869334,
-0.0415885933,
-0.0791006014,
-0.0129436143,
0.0313961953,
0.0025979467,
-0.1082933098,
-0.0554407537,
-0.0174407978,
0.0313609652,
-0.0032223635,
0.0540276691,
-0.0150249358,
0.0134860212,
-0.0568169616,
0.0034802824,
0.059516944,
-0.030090427,
-0.0353555419,
-0.060711287,
0.0877757594,
-0.0323449485,
-0.0281612165,
-0.0375306495,
0.0256026536,
0.0049360087,
0.0255939793,
0.087599501,
0.0126375733,
0.0060808663,
0.0644702017,
-0.0083247172,
0.0476660728,
0.0674849972,
-0.0213207565,
-0.006196796,
0.0483717285,
0.0206029322,
0.0034963498,
0.008658587,
-0.0041934769,
0.0014549653,
-0.0156941954,
0.0069689681,
-0.0351010561,
-0.0152038345,
0.009860483,
-0.0425589718,
0.1025366709,
0.0039297678,
-0.0171878189,
0.0183133837,
0.0012484514,
-0.0506219044,
0.0036987206,
-0.0150199225,
-0.0454063751,
0.0213285554,
0.0441886671,
-0.0406439491,
0.0420057885,
-0.0035371562,
-0.0363354348,
-0.0388239324,
0.0735902712,
0.0659512356,
0.0294508561,
-0.0095193116,
0.0149814337,
0.0253428854,
0.0095328055,
0.040771164,
0.0094140926,
0.0297873598,
-0.0076269214,
0.0654261336,
-0.0429859236,
0.0011546143,
0.0105037931,
-0.043135561,
0.0179069489,
0.0037853213,
-0.0655125752,
0.0268283989,
-0.0427244082,
0.0316840522,
-0.0185121,
0.0026460767,
0.0373393819,
0.0122653302,
-0.0182780605,
-0.0549265631,
0.0106586022,
0.0118541885,
-0.0004263369,
-0.0161538515,
0.0220226273,
-0.0407721773,
0.0663909838,
0.0005902838,
-0.063830331,
-0.0443872474,
-0.0099277673,
0.0075946697,
0.0047511384,
-0.0136697609,
0.0082098758,
-0.0637220219,
0.0048060031,
0.0729442835,
0.0377702117,
0.0102806725,
-0.022078421,
0.0402505845,
0.0216746926,
0.0351415165,
0.0335115306,
-0.0737175941,
0.0626224428,
-0.0360524543,
-0.0134184435,
-0.0402317569,
-5.59423235e-33,
-0.0102555593,
-0.0376036689,
0.0082227737,
0.0711671859,
-0.0105925845,
-0.0105225444,
-0.0203031935,
0.0148545019,
-0.0068428372,
0.0438142791,
-0.0076052248,
0.035126403,
-0.0134455767,
0.0194102302,
0.0639917925,
-0.0670750216,
0.0532678962,
-0.0266954061,
-0.0058595059,
0.0070835124,
0.0618620217,
0.0313793905,
0.0326500684,
-0.0781347975,
0.0269307215,
-0.0429975167,
-0.0528368056,
-0.0049722516,
0.0329478495,
0.0593763031,
0.0187970046,
0.0158138573,
0.0019530522,
-0.0133213094,
0.0450899936,
0.0147235412,
0.0073282421,
-0.0078792749,
-0.0394307002,
0.045094911,
0.0388324037,
0.0094118714,
0.033007279,
0.0211383719,
-0.037279468,
-0.0126741435,
0.06029962,
-0.0335463881,
0.0456139036,
-0.0909205973,
-0.0662657544,
0.0058569135,
-0.0131482789,
0.0028832299,
0.0654194728,
0.055988986,
0.0189459529,
-0.0182520263,
-0.0285155103,
0.0547882803,
0.0229739919,
0.0438374057,
-0.0147099132,
0.0223284997,
0.0196891539,
0.0295640137,
0.0511006489,
-0.0101363016,
-0.0184304956,
0.0475253612,
0.0434272774,
-0.0034687836,
0.045442529,
0.1025455147,
0.0239382461,
0.0132924961,
-0.0490049124,
0.034009546,
0.0504640415,
0.0497664325,
-0.0227091145,
0.0087710088,
-0.0253535081,
0.018916063,
0.0157698058,
-0.0045860265,
0.0113804974,
-0.0458016358,
-0.0281746611,
-0.0339506492,
0.0179255754,
-0.0298331231,
-0.0204622541,
-0.0142961228,
-0.0378359333,
0.0231951214,
-0.0406275429,
0.0894807875,
-0.0278106406,
-0.02749612,
-0.036529813,
-0.0391023234,
0.0159464683,
0.017226804,
0.0104038771,
0.0276058707,
0.0227230601,
0.0688914657,
-0.0469609536,
-0.0139672132,
0.0198612176,
-0.0168109573,
-0.0075810715,
0.0083042895,
-0.0168190226,
0.0125120841,
-0.0014357569,
0.0317043513,
-0.0467065275,
0.002614381,
-0.0117440959,
0.0264925882,
0.0264474917,
-0.0011270627,
-0.0043689152,
-0.0075206761,
-0.0169287287,
0.0403680727,
-0.0175145138,
-0.0447396897,
-0.010790132,
-0.0241184421,
2.776e-7,
0.0538578294,
0.0629120618,
-0.0647887141,
-0.0396848246,
-0.0565800294,
0.0629708096,
-0.0551677197,
-0.0170363523,
0.0169675238,
0.0214493144,
0.0923905745,
0.0135636721,
0.023995474,
0.0176018886,
-0.1228756458,
-0.0492692068,
-0.0170526654,
-0.0351832137,
0.0077004754,
0.0633746907,
0.0819351375,
0.0798513293,
0.0370292552,
0.0211465694,
-0.0417487063,
0.0028305301,
0.0434233584,
-0.0403574072,
0.0335109979,
-0.0051688137,
0.0069457414,
-0.0021779242,
-0.075530462,
-0.0292269904,
-0.0334941037,
0.0335847475,
0.0137930531,
-0.0035204969,
0.0129495654,
0.0236406829,
0.0115144216,
0.028498685,
-0.0246171914,
-0.0163204931,
0.0330964141,
-0.0847527906,
-0.0178623945,
-0.0392330028,
-0.0725868642,
0.0356337391,
0.0063047097,
-0.0219472293,
-0.0654070601,
0.0241362061,
-0.0274596158,
0.0005665126,
0.0261062309,
-0.045429945,
0.0043964325,
0.0161815379,
-0.0193676744,
0.0151609741,
0.0056105945,
-0.0028849375,
-0.0214259159,
-0.0191087984,
0.0347262025,
1.775434066e-34,
0.0030421696,
-0.0283947233,
-0.0395982973,
-0.0422048457,
-0.0090367598,
0.0006763895,
-0.0061705462,
0.029852422,
0.0460551605,
-0.0173438732,
-0.0013207853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20256v2 | PsyCoT: Psychological Questionnaire as Powerful Chain-of-Thought for Personality Detection | 2023-10-31T08:23:33 | 2023-11-05T03:19:18 | Tao Yang, Tianyuan Shi, Fanqi Wan, Xiaojun Quan, Qifan Wang, Bingzhe Wu, Jiaxiang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have
showcased remarkable zero-shot performance across various NLP tasks. However,
the potential of LLMs in personality detection, which involves identifying an
individual's personality from their written texts, remains largely unexplored.
Drawing inspiration from Psychological Questionnaires, which are carefully
designed by psychologists to evaluate individual personality traits through a
series of targeted items, we argue that these items can be regarded as a
collection of well-structured chain-of-thought (CoT) processes. By
incorporating these processes, LLMs can enhance their capabilities to make more
reasonable inferences on personality from textual input. In light of this, we
propose a novel personality detection method, called PsyCoT, which mimics the
way individuals complete psychological questionnaires in a multi-turn dialogue
manner. In particular, we employ a LLM as an AI assistant with a specialization
in text analysis. We prompt the assistant to rate individual items at each turn
and leverage the historical rating results to derive a conclusive personality
preference. Our experiments demonstrate that PsyCoT significantly improves the
performance and robustness of GPT-3.5 in personality detection, achieving an
average F1 score improvement of 4.23/10.63 points on two benchmark datasets
compared to the standard prompting method. Our code is available at
https://github.com/TaoYang225/PsyCoT. | [
0.0318413191,
0.053092353,
-0.0468456708,
0.0156183532,
-0.0605135225,
0.0222552512,
0.0281329043,
-0.0152613642,
0.0419850089,
-0.0139849493,
-0.0312943757,
-0.0107290242,
0.0102721592,
0.0096685169,
0.0028316486,
-0.032028567,
0.0452416576,
0.0015864844,
0.0351313353,
-0.007434702,
0.0087598469,
0.0494804978,
-0.0109979128,
0.0302840527,
0.0027382758,
-0.0529271401,
-0.0297704674,
-0.0189451072,
0.0522124842,
-0.0310996566,
0.0169123039,
0.0712266043,
-0.0315019339,
0.0270350054,
0.0000020928,
-0.0151381502,
-0.0191640053,
-0.013911847,
0.0241825711,
-0.0172897596,
0.0600896962,
0.0551855266,
0.0222754516,
0.0496224388,
-0.0527368486,
-0.0412181839,
0.0244726427,
0.0617569573,
0.0783259198,
0.0637743026,
-0.0116517739,
-0.0241041351,
0.0021688954,
-0.0118151251,
0.0331664085,
-0.033803802,
0.007043974,
-0.076285854,
-0.0024984987,
0.0356322229,
0.0133390846,
-0.0039198045,
-0.0082233176,
0.0049161939,
-0.0292456187,
-0.0138396723,
-0.045649305,
-0.0087830946,
0.008170248,
0.0734269619,
0.0188436303,
-0.0080704149,
-0.0213572681,
-0.0230259728,
0.0227948893,
-0.0070546167,
0.0179814678,
-0.0048998273,
-0.0380121991,
-0.0365674533,
0.0374887101,
0.0000505222,
-0.0169611741,
-0.004414211,
-0.0270112082,
0.0570299998,
-0.0158863887,
-0.0305795502,
0.024694534,
0.0121624423,
-0.0037021965,
-0.0703271478,
0.0221132189,
0.0032766054,
-0.0252185948,
0.005493409,
-0.0347838178,
0.0231904853,
0.0123350676,
-0.0121004963,
0.0061345077,
0.0258993879,
-0.0304363035,
-0.0056457082,
0.0609369352,
0.0425810106,
0.0295735188,
0.0218040645,
-0.033616256,
-0.0178671908,
-0.0815738887,
0.000373028,
0.0076981988,
0.0188282002,
0.0289450306,
0.0026451088,
-0.0647971034,
0.0167775694,
-0.0217090771,
0.005490771,
0.0181853212,
-0.0106107546,
0.0287987106,
0.0452015325,
-0.0594965369,
0.0382322967,
-0.0360378176,
-0.0136597669,
0.001812626,
0.0037366892,
0.0226166621,
0.0005959991,
0.031043116,
-0.0351756066,
0.0411088914,
0.0111027323,
0.0289907828,
-0.0647571981,
-0.0270781629,
-0.0406276174,
-0.0345884897,
-0.0834343061,
-0.0080969473,
-0.0272248704,
0.0568775982,
0.0126772542,
-0.0085545518,
-0.0159163661,
0.0201938953,
0.0747474805,
-0.0303984396,
0.066514194,
0.0120006632,
0.022390645,
-0.0251848903,
0.012608692,
-0.0186432321,
0.0128424121,
0.0038242915,
0.0134927835,
0.0336378552,
-0.0359061956,
0.0417087711,
0.0415424146,
-0.0262227282,
-0.0202746298,
0.0326207317,
0.0061287559,
-0.0047742748,
0.0093135247,
-0.0035383578,
0.0514408089,
-0.0073192986,
-0.012445041,
0.0807857066,
0.0727773309,
0.0038053198,
0.0423282199,
0.0359212495,
0.0594368801,
0.0365509354,
0.0164008215,
-0.0468158014,
0.0109302811,
-0.0480899401,
-0.0258173086,
-0.0161160808,
0.0281134099,
-0.0043483283,
-0.0462086909,
-0.0180043001,
0.0012838716,
0.0307678469,
0.0384580381,
-0.0373737291,
-0.0104165375,
0.0006792559,
-0.0485579371,
0.0609572865,
-0.038321007,
-0.0397805721,
-0.0630344748,
0.007342869,
0.1125472263,
0.0346396342,
-0.0137676876,
-0.0156625621,
-0.0236235373,
-0.0430122837,
0.0314397812,
0.0278291516,
-0.0202464685,
-0.0014516196,
-0.0245774612,
0.025263384,
0.0211725142,
-0.0098847849,
0.0227278322,
0.0046636811,
0.0184303503,
-0.0203512888,
0.0225018449,
0.0155285541,
0.0087876143,
-0.0452108495,
-0.0530734658,
0.0572892241,
0.0404818952,
0.0308100451,
0.0250465553,
-0.0011000136,
-0.0244513117,
-0.0056368317,
0.0132151917,
-0.038211789,
0.0139268162,
-0.0007593954,
-0.0583759919,
0.0109018739,
0.0213268343,
-0.0436969362,
0.0454376824,
-0.0054488853,
0.0067499285,
-0.0140207801,
-0.0473082624,
-0.0133804642,
-0.004775296,
0.0137157077,
-0.0183166992,
0.0593243837,
-0.0229763761,
0.0567447469,
-0.0012799867,
0.0169339031,
0.0141279772,
-0.0059078154,
-0.0210363027,
-0.0458251461,
-0.0471775755,
-0.0378734469,
0.0441855192,
0.0169878472,
0.0056479392,
0.0257908665,
-0.0223712213,
-0.0596519075,
-0.0993623883,
0.0221688636,
0.0179494359,
0.0098429555,
0.0121144801,
0.003010436,
-0.0350930281,
0.0230541918,
-0.0555724166,
0.0139220636,
0.0179845709,
0.0320908166,
0.044247359,
-0.0306457616,
0.0076010246,
-0.0426897295,
0.0179329216,
-0.0647161901,
0.0306447968,
-0.02628172,
0.0390325151,
-0.0105522191,
0.0014533483,
-0.0722261146,
0.0205567665,
0.0080777872,
-0.0377970524,
0.0257093906,
-0.0264304914,
0.037123166,
0.0598260909,
0.030919781,
0.0074987994,
0.0066379802,
-0.0043434482,
-0.007154122,
0.0107542053,
-0.0166283734,
0.0002011051,
-0.0205621589,
-0.0599860474,
-0.0183264446,
0.025362961,
0.0400847197,
-0.0018585054,
-0.0616824888,
0.0375531577,
0.0388001353,
-0.0169102494,
0.0506036468,
0.0473991372,
-0.0015145711,
0.0326373279,
0.0053479122,
0.006424001,
0.0896448493,
-0.0152397845,
0.0139367124,
-0.0570206381,
-0.0513407998,
-0.051360622,
0.088686049,
0.038924545,
-0.0017359476,
0.0588705987,
0.0262541268,
-0.0365779959,
-0.0360302292,
-0.0188466609,
-0.0285904258,
0.0187878776,
-0.0099559473,
-0.0333988219,
0.0462428406,
-0.0430072211,
-0.0368023813,
-0.0641203821,
-0.0337634087,
-0.0321780592,
0.0200163983,
-0.0278818831,
-0.0220697057,
-0.0437835716,
0.0325214565,
-0.0010938243,
-0.0407479741,
-0.0281900279,
-0.0010347853,
0.028736325,
0.0484468304,
-0.0275046714,
0.0321051218,
-0.023333136,
0.0159388762,
0.0377545953,
-0.0623977594,
0.0245704278,
0.0005792434,
-0.0050020721,
-0.0121678617,
-0.00922151,
-0.0242425576,
-0.002243587,
0.01870941,
-0.0143607426,
-0.0178180896,
0.1417973042,
0.0461865887,
-0.0382984616,
0.0124703785,
0.0369091555,
0.0191682037,
0.0268892515,
0.0517069958,
-0.0333701298,
-0.0190436952,
-0.0296374746,
0.0199036431,
-0.0489511229,
-0.0414763428,
-0.0357353278,
-0.0976642743,
0.0346875079,
-0.0325515233,
0.0052294242,
0.0138447536,
-0.0360515639,
0.0193166863,
-0.023144545,
-0.0147320218,
-0.0450668894,
0.0140887965,
0.0063063018,
-0.0457875319,
-0.0454901569,
0.0156012969,
0.0979845002,
-0.0356001481,
0.0258730296,
0.0173949096,
0.0732165352,
0.012924104,
-0.0484609418,
-0.062664032,
-0.0089324648,
-0.0075914073,
0.0140404887,
0.0825592503,
-0.0193901937,
0.0104580056,
-0.0861462504,
0.0190232173,
-0.0239820946,
0.0169281606,
0.0390890203,
0.0319500715,
-0.0164086986,
-0.0482041277,
-0.0150292544,
0.0446214229,
0.0194597654,
0.0544461161,
-0.0299870186,
-0.1100190729,
-0.0288680252,
-0.009962013,
-0.0174903441,
-0.0199854076,
-0.0962279364,
0.000217282,
0.0401090272,
0.0063648135,
-0.0504623391,
-0.0827379525,
0.0027010255,
0.0116914157,
-0.0282237027,
-0.0351792313,
0.0055713104,
0.0479808934,
-0.0255432986,
0.0008733721,
-0.0148623921,
0.0281010568,
-0.0126169752,
-0.0211382098,
0.0688776672,
-0.0242533628,
-0.0106484657,
0.0297852252,
-0.0908252597,
-0.0261846296,
0.0168515984,
0.0002182772,
0.0110911485,
0.026352901,
-0.0022405772,
-0.0310284086,
0.0164863858,
0.0099383816,
-0.0366992913,
0.0389684029,
-0.0207426045,
0.0773499012,
-0.0069686803,
0.0309883747,
0.0033530155,
0.0370081142,
0.0033154893,
-0.0394031107,
-0.0398024507,
-0.0897329599,
0.0081571918,
0.0233491678,
0.0058942037,
0.0156489331,
-0.0007141435,
-0.006791994,
-0.0310634747,
-0.0316038132,
-0.0398979597,
0.0021655643,
-0.0757427663,
0.0281304009,
-0.0090167504,
-0.0447698981,
-0.0423780493,
-0.016222164,
0.0399354286,
-0.0668918341,
-0.0119398693,
0.0195433777,
0.0257501565,
-0.0184289161,
-0.0228484608,
-0.0063440041,
-0.0197317246,
0.0097646005,
0.0543195345,
-0.0193673503,
0.0905149877,
-0.0288620312,
-0.0191800315,
-0.0076763225,
0.0553620048,
-0.0806824267,
-0.0111655202,
0.0063748476,
-0.0052904105,
-0.0236351546,
0.0231391899,
0.010663867,
-0.0127310455,
0.0029315925,
-0.0072862827,
0.0381412655,
0.0036397828,
-0.0237917509,
0.004713254,
0.0064268531,
-0.0137902256,
-0.0261693634,
0.0329591371,
0.01795757,
-0.0099716168,
0.0386142433,
-0.0576178506,
-0.0536004938,
-0.0028646286,
-0.0308304541,
0.0351614505,
-0.0108456453,
0.0226618275,
-0.0816336274,
-0.0728537813,
0.0714731142,
-0.0260560233,
0.035665296,
-0.0108925262,
0.014684896,
0.034216024,
-0.0114701279,
-0.0288037453,
-0.0628210753,
0.008917205,
-0.0258954857,
-0.0161670968,
-0.0257601235,
-6.103878946e-33,
-0.0246499088,
-0.026206268,
0.029490998,
0.059387736,
0.0022299213,
-0.0199837591,
0.00066408,
0.0453754291,
-0.0156148886,
0.0077732825,
-0.0374671072,
0.0200109612,
-0.0033420348,
0.0211404506,
-0.0090635074,
0.0067156656,
0.0224315077,
-0.0272598136,
-0.0032940928,
0.0270406157,
0.0229284763,
-0.0027631836,
0.0297946054,
-0.0873346254,
-0.0071039591,
-0.0254795663,
0.0017151691,
0.0119206626,
-0.0186231229,
0.053570725,
-0.0065479618,
0.0565546826,
0.0406584814,
0.010263701,
0.0205486901,
0.0558464453,
-0.0536250472,
-0.0518431887,
-0.0185895842,
0.012912224,
-0.0053807287,
-0.0350905731,
-0.0240489263,
-0.0227205232,
-0.0100843115,
-0.0531190969,
0.0570212826,
0.007139768,
0.0524344519,
0.0086344909,
-0.0288953781,
0.0092889173,
-0.0165099986,
-0.0298437849,
-0.028597666,
0.0356025472,
-0.0015708108,
-0.0023801809,
-0.0651814193,
0.0362253115,
-0.0457409397,
-0.0141159482,
-0.0284433365,
-0.0064357342,
-0.0250061341,
0.0414725058,
0.0689966753,
0.0428069346,
-0.0156935193,
0.0074230046,
0.0175074395,
0.0127481222,
0.0242645331,
0.0665007234,
-0.0220842529,
-0.0293903165,
-0.0301271919,
0.0056823627,
0.1172763929,
-0.0662984848,
0.0485681854,
-0.0246903989,
-0.0471429601,
-0.0287401453,
-0.0223647915,
-0.0317119136,
-0.0507270806,
-0.0184789877,
0.0176098067,
-0.0050317319,
-0.0091003291,
-0.0293394178,
0.012010566,
-0.0308009293,
0.0039570327,
0.0307011399,
-0.0821340233,
0.036898151,
-0.0046534068,
0.0072831442,
-0.0387750231,
0.0130180353,
0.0154308155,
0.0297525208,
0.0685709119,
0.0086983349,
0.0358775593,
0.0182182156,
-0.0843396261,
-0.027740214,
0.0051027932,
0.0536086969,
-0.0478652827,
0.0510250553,
-0.0024407576,
0.0183962211,
-0.0108476421,
0.0499959402,
0.0048663518,
0.0384119339,
-0.0599002428,
-0.0161897615,
0.0239210371,
-0.0276266653,
-0.0026440548,
-0.0027313347,
-0.0422149859,
-0.0368532278,
0.021784192,
-0.0577990077,
0.004441828,
0.020215163,
2.732e-7,
-0.0094477329,
0.0756075457,
-0.029481465,
0.0570361726,
0.0294886678,
0.0442938879,
0.0248404257,
0.0045180931,
0.0428350903,
-0.0248069502,
0.0026955889,
0.0440962985,
0.0353888795,
0.0679515228,
-0.0682949647,
0.0039497269,
0.024189014,
-0.0034251667,
-0.0468855873,
0.0099590896,
0.0845106095,
0.090686202,
0.0635225698,
-0.0160615016,
0.0071746721,
0.0208343118,
0.0356742777,
0.0468027331,
-0.0270139948,
0.0437089615,
-0.0283197332,
-0.0023043561,
0.0086318469,
0.05301762,
0.0071855732,
0.0152507611,
-0.0183058735,
0.0629867986,
-0.0172037818,
-0.031280417,
0.0012000594,
0.028358331,
-0.0071681519,
-0.0286345817,
0.0786526203,
-0.0093771806,
-0.0402800329,
-0.0483994968,
-0.0114993555,
-0.0302212518,
0.0259510428,
0.0154340193,
-0.0327056833,
0.041398745,
0.017906066,
-0.0233981814,
-0.0036883745,
-0.0800392851,
0.0191951301,
0.014559879,
-0.0296384804,
-0.0371129513,
0.0113745695,
-0.0026895986,
0.0272120181,
-0.0671613291,
0.0324204192,
2.546838458e-34,
-0.0101851868,
0.0222136844,
0.0031753781,
-0.0494542383,
0.072587736,
0.0298166629,
0.0209734961,
-0.0165354796,
0.0356901735,
-0.0803802386,
-0.0070507722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20246v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20246v4 | Breaking Language Barriers in Multilingual Mathematical Reasoning: Insights and Observations | 2023-10-31T08:09:20 | 2023-11-28T05:25:14 | Nuo Chen, Zinan Zheng, Ning Wu, Ming Gong, Yangqiu Song, Dongmei Zhang, Jia Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing research predominantly focuses on developing powerful language
learning models (LLMs) for mathematical reasoning within monolingual languages,
with few explorations in preserving efficacy in a multilingual context. To
bridge this gap, this paper pioneers exploring and training powerful
Multilingual Math Reasoning (xMR) LLMs. Firstly, by utilizing translation, we
construct the first multilingual math reasoning instruction dataset,
MGSM8KInstruct, encompassing ten distinct languages, thus addressing the issue
of training data scarcity in xMR tasks. Based on the collected dataset, we
propose different training strategies to build powerful xMR LLMs, named
MathOctopus, notably outperform conventional open-source LLMs and exhibit
superiority over ChatGPT in few-shot scenarios. Notably, MathOctopus-13B
reaches 47.6% accuracy which exceeds ChatGPT 46.3% on MGSM testset. Beyond
remarkable results, we unearth several pivotal observations and insights from
extensive experiments: (1) When extending the rejection sampling strategy to
the multilingual context, it proves effective for model performances, albeit
limited. (2) Employing parallel corpora for math Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT)
across multiple languages not only significantly enhances model performance
multilingually but also elevates their monolingual performance. This indicates
that crafting multilingual corpora can be regarded as a vital strategy for
enhancing model performance in a specific language, especially in mathematical
reasoning tasks. For instance, MathOctopus-7B improves its counterparts that
trained on English from 42.2% to 50.8% on GSM8K testset. | [
-0.0313632004,
0.0769618601,
-0.0307508316,
0.0626569539,
-0.0402001254,
0.0514938533,
0.0466201007,
-0.0197409578,
-0.0379071012,
-0.0161293168,
-0.0514098182,
-0.0259056222,
-0.0085501708,
-0.019540716,
0.0371427983,
-0.030547997,
0.0184295606,
-0.0585694537,
-0.0062792916,
-0.0487406068,
-0.0174278878,
0.0163513906,
-0.0291391928,
-0.0203908663,
0.0011140405,
-0.0580670573,
0.0473193862,
-0.033980608,
0.0043353522,
-0.0311701819,
0.0098345596,
0.0572796129,
0.0180752184,
0.0625603572,
0.0000024974,
-0.0724429116,
-0.0213564429,
-0.0144347316,
-0.0118948137,
-0.0336841345,
-0.0181019399,
-0.0575963333,
0.0172200836,
-0.0108055295,
-0.0662518367,
0.0238643698,
0.0194928423,
0.0015489246,
0.0329872705,
0.046722129,
-0.0084041813,
-0.0299550556,
0.0083637228,
-0.0403522588,
0.0236534085,
-0.0448870249,
-0.0143123278,
0.0524418503,
-0.0139592681,
0.0111236321,
-0.0372000076,
0.0495717265,
0.0587050468,
0.0193382669,
-0.0510345288,
-0.0049636806,
-0.0457599834,
-0.0032265256,
0.0046132971,
0.0526502915,
-0.0367071517,
-0.0129486509,
-0.0325292908,
-0.0021502057,
-0.0169540774,
-0.0139910076,
-0.0897266492,
0.0444330834,
-0.0161513221,
0.0131313512,
-0.0058023115,
-0.0241648275,
0.0208922364,
0.0196583327,
-0.0365136154,
0.0611002296,
0.0050987252,
-0.0142273828,
0.03812287,
-0.0101321796,
-0.0737979263,
-0.0126911458,
0.0157502685,
0.0255233757,
0.0022497883,
0.0101364739,
0.0037303311,
-0.0785219967,
0.0113535821,
-0.0376861803,
0.0344311818,
0.0785835311,
-0.0032550574,
0.0350190774,
-0.0426770896,
0.0500300117,
-0.0002565695,
0.0590358675,
-0.0209522247,
-0.0047348784,
-0.0299441405,
-0.0018696985,
-0.0101464652,
0.0276014525,
-0.0123401033,
0.0440403782,
-0.0385697484,
-0.0026903709,
-0.0366621502,
0.0296690352,
-0.0140549056,
-0.0625733361,
-0.0149228079,
-0.0535667539,
-0.0149797564,
0.032410901,
-0.0599678159,
0.0192465764,
-0.0370616578,
-0.0395745859,
-0.038452331,
0.0148271248,
-0.0500546992,
-0.0497415029,
0.0533747114,
0.0871970952,
-0.0079237763,
0.0000297065,
-0.0145251006,
-0.0045420243,
0.0498571321,
-0.1040762365,
0.0291684214,
-0.0914869457,
0.0539324731,
0.0366243646,
-0.0060074092,
-0.0305193327,
0.0017067085,
0.0084843235,
0.0158041809,
0.0660565197,
0.02357262,
-0.0290550627,
0.0198563822,
-0.0192402694,
-0.0576862767,
0.1093994677,
0.0271652546,
-0.051647339,
0.0394776873,
-0.0109224506,
-0.0123720551,
0.0455113761,
0.0206960328,
0.0192194525,
-0.0030794651,
0.0168984737,
0.0296001267,
0.0298035145,
-0.0089197876,
-0.0093255937,
-0.0337823071,
-0.0113624539,
0.0086094262,
0.0452390648,
-0.0231996942,
0.0162698384,
0.0032486855,
-0.0195734501,
0.0096763615,
-0.0100263618,
-0.0611781552,
0.0311694443,
0.0058392803,
-0.0040315744,
-0.0224113762,
0.0497143641,
-0.0277582649,
-0.0666088015,
-0.0063481098,
-0.0149137313,
-0.0052212439,
0.0162453,
0.0822392553,
0.0102060316,
0.0191541463,
0.0699122623,
0.0315573029,
-0.0357932448,
0.0069980291,
-0.0185410734,
0.0021245123,
-0.031381201,
0.0065672565,
-0.0459333584,
-0.0368214026,
-0.0330062695,
0.0382408686,
0.0377026498,
0.0379109122,
0.003740412,
0.0005151203,
-0.0674806908,
-0.0024054754,
-0.0223796442,
0.0049538915,
0.0245765038,
0.0004020955,
0.0524203591,
0.0146390377,
-0.0546820909,
0.0057511679,
0.011618563,
-0.0505645648,
-0.0380089656,
0.006772975,
0.0013542392,
-0.0230118204,
-0.0231510773,
0.0412297323,
-0.0025872153,
-0.0160480719,
-0.0438461043,
-0.0064882264,
0.0054705902,
-0.054603368,
-0.0547906049,
0.0606111065,
-0.0416619517,
-0.0351120196,
0.0067379214,
-0.065543443,
-0.0108494507,
0.0506432094,
0.0228439067,
-0.0111285811,
-0.0290087182,
-0.0114981867,
-0.0119705759,
0.0067679854,
-0.015789967,
0.0570212901,
0.0058222688,
0.0411552191,
0.0318236388,
0.0021659576,
0.0650973246,
0.0054409774,
0.0291816611,
0.0132818772,
-0.0246235076,
0.0341283195,
-0.0148310261,
0.0605271272,
-0.0190793872,
0.0033194693,
0.003875393,
0.030639546,
-0.0139259994,
0.0589619316,
0.0024079597,
-0.0250428841,
-0.0120577086,
-0.0276014209,
-0.0296022426,
-0.0085317167,
0.0032553007,
0.0086881369,
0.0163987949,
-0.0147931632,
0.0232233461,
-0.0038878936,
-0.0339769125,
-0.0198988263,
0.0432192869,
0.0065241144,
0.0485379919,
-0.0088066403,
0.0064472631,
-0.0627811253,
-0.012094711,
-0.0273358431,
-0.0002357181,
0.0096976496,
-0.005058893,
0.0135001913,
0.0730524063,
-0.042531319,
-0.0107272789,
0.0169981644,
-0.0044217408,
-0.0462804027,
0.0365692563,
-0.0228119157,
-0.010293914,
-0.0318684578,
0.0157033056,
-0.0179116502,
0.0511542298,
-0.044491265,
-0.0299632978,
-0.0387138464,
0.0299719814,
-0.021791121,
0.0134484842,
-0.0377291143,
0.0588795915,
-0.0021135418,
0.0495825447,
-0.0086642317,
-0.0188745018,
0.0540481918,
0.0056452169,
-0.0203320961,
-0.0957273468,
0.024532333,
-0.0595076233,
0.0128233386,
-0.0080358554,
-0.0014850129,
-0.0393249914,
0.0122365309,
-0.0643855408,
-0.0097363563,
0.0627183616,
-0.0116315279,
0.0411412977,
-0.010208372,
-0.0259047039,
-0.0456279851,
-0.0548767373,
-0.0066188322,
0.036122445,
-0.0138131138,
0.0321191438,
-0.0209533609,
-0.0202304404,
-0.0187867247,
-0.0196389351,
0.0310187191,
0.0230915584,
-0.0425602421,
-0.008944218,
-0.0092987996,
-0.0327163935,
0.0061301193,
0.0174165592,
0.0514464639,
-0.0761903599,
0.0129502201,
0.0162093472,
0.0376330279,
-0.0329653323,
0.0286803786,
0.0218595676,
0.0251036268,
0.0011704719,
-0.0217343047,
-0.0143428035,
0.0406281836,
-0.0715642124,
0.0095245019,
0.0907481238,
0.012686545,
-0.0030474309,
-0.013710442,
-0.1037626788,
0.0426312909,
0.0476475358,
0.0081918025,
-0.0963988081,
-0.0248021279,
0.0112298671,
-0.001091246,
0.0325402096,
-0.0232044198,
0.0032800909,
-0.1264074594,
0.003310367,
0.0241876692,
-0.0862164944,
-0.0130470339,
-0.0504764505,
-0.0016172444,
-0.0016797492,
0.0210460275,
-0.0062964964,
0.0033609257,
0.0197379347,
0.0181728378,
-0.0044107991,
-0.0400303453,
0.0337983258,
-0.0341594517,
-0.0509393848,
-0.0239419993,
0.0313315839,
-0.0260245036,
-0.07361909,
0.0313404612,
0.0217318069,
-0.045411557,
-0.0309894346,
0.0060709366,
0.0171443,
-0.0226811916,
0.0144602843,
0.0595849566,
-0.0422661714,
-0.0176803321,
0.0389737003,
0.1330791861,
-0.0023721962,
0.0080728056,
0.0169604719,
-0.0057790107,
-0.0337065086,
0.0399262197,
0.0235355664,
-0.0172785427,
-0.0267242398,
-0.0427211188,
-0.0350206979,
-0.0778291449,
0.0138561446,
0.045313403,
0.0288766176,
-0.0206131432,
-0.0007771394,
-0.0515575893,
0.0379332714,
0.0248950981,
0.0259005558,
-0.0015146572,
-0.0056389133,
-0.0091270218,
-0.0173500571,
0.0405475199,
-0.0367569141,
0.0227220524,
-0.0168085303,
0.0459383391,
0.0052383966,
-0.0189658236,
-0.0388593748,
0.01643808,
-0.09142223,
-0.069236517,
-0.04860783,
0.0725097209,
0.0109328441,
0.0357604399,
0.0133706033,
-0.0166290794,
-0.0076396191,
0.0203177575,
-0.0228058938,
0.0049418397,
0.0858522952,
-0.0104095312,
0.0098800613,
0.0459054336,
-0.0094639985,
0.0271877889,
0.0350717641,
0.0292385165,
-0.0121524259,
0.0166015811,
0.0090591107,
0.0201762877,
-0.0115267616,
0.0019927069,
0.0082265539,
-0.0237394478,
0.0570016503,
-0.0165296886,
-0.0027613603,
-0.0120955752,
-0.0050640502,
-0.0061321035,
-0.0486729965,
0.0161324963,
-0.0301460903,
0.0276503544,
0.0237573646,
0.0260195993,
0.0791493654,
0.0087623876,
0.0323957428,
0.0343830138,
0.0003146515,
0.0169034768,
0.0048597544,
0.0007203246,
0.053569518,
-0.0305650439,
0.0636375174,
0.020195676,
0.0145532396,
0.0051332205,
-0.0251754299,
0.0174886622,
-0.100179702,
0.0132403765,
-0.0235404056,
0.0623819381,
-0.0100869397,
0.0044228141,
-0.0295552332,
-0.0135307265,
0.0007023006,
0.0198771451,
0.0094688274,
-0.0104862778,
0.0388050564,
0.0178089608,
0.0121327462,
-0.0352529213,
0.0510227643,
-0.071043998,
0.0236946009,
0.0053980099,
0.0413371474,
-0.0195801575,
-0.0155999279,
0.0035843563,
-0.0174618885,
0.0105582466,
0.010605935,
-0.0558209233,
-0.0908315778,
0.0033563105,
0.0076201712,
-0.0237043984,
0.013071062,
0.0197726469,
0.097899735,
-0.0241232459,
0.0000332624,
0.0011715498,
0.0338088721,
0.0034716739,
-0.0105162365,
0.0016748258,
-6.150636437e-33,
0.0141874403,
0.000106536,
0.0279096626,
0.0229800586,
0.0456113592,
-0.060318552,
-0.0270520691,
-0.0043676724,
-0.0190397762,
0.0126812384,
0.0134987207,
-0.0044113649,
0.0022702808,
0.0339749977,
0.0127813071,
0.0128422016,
0.0104830265,
0.0022482646,
-0.0315005817,
-0.0015922469,
0.0351405106,
0.0220445078,
0.1250701249,
-0.0536718331,
-0.0029648275,
-0.0119321831,
0.0174453799,
0.0339760222,
-0.0448676161,
0.0654921532,
0.0151387891,
0.0499780178,
0.0187432282,
-0.0438818857,
-0.0272773206,
-0.0304348227,
-0.0622159317,
-0.0641706288,
0.0102858674,
0.0629480928,
-0.0340347439,
-0.043317996,
0.0095063299,
-0.0132970009,
-0.0283838697,
-0.0644740537,
0.0142804636,
-0.0368038714,
-0.005105047,
0.0238283388,
-0.0458062477,
0.0321220756,
-0.0242284928,
0.0002113541,
0.038559366,
0.0348757915,
-0.0160058681,
0.0044795624,
-0.0265487153,
0.0026693083,
0.0112137925,
0.0268659648,
0.0610572621,
-0.0111303646,
0.0143469116,
0.009596115,
-0.0014009587,
-0.0049965386,
0.0542961545,
0.008579839,
0.0816827193,
0.0416851006,
0.0806466118,
0.0543038733,
0.0572791174,
-0.0087630143,
-0.0863914862,
-0.0133973984,
-0.029399395,
0.0362974368,
0.0137279583,
-0.0135784959,
-0.0102076335,
-0.0147486115,
-0.0607856549,
-0.0162795875,
-0.0326748863,
-0.0286410693,
0.022767283,
-0.0242245644,
0.0055908165,
0.0243719928,
0.0540238023,
-0.0133554293,
-0.0554205365,
0.0215177573,
-0.0101375943,
0.0062696002,
0.0128921587,
0.0364933461,
-0.0438195318,
-0.0345374271,
-0.0428144559,
-0.0000795819,
0.044850003,
0.0127236256,
0.080648832,
0.0044202083,
-0.0380412824,
-0.0135549456,
-0.0363356024,
0.0133303981,
0.0565114357,
0.0743360296,
0.0103332372,
0.0394331403,
-0.0115792248,
0.0594157726,
0.0085987728,
-0.0588693395,
-0.0470603183,
0.0201841276,
-0.0398119949,
0.0441135243,
-0.0086459015,
-0.0241279323,
-0.0414280854,
-0.0080670454,
0.0413762145,
-0.0882359967,
-0.0032431895,
0.0102927303,
3.038e-7,
0.0538368858,
0.0402981378,
-0.0209237542,
0.0100384764,
0.0019044369,
0.0466340221,
-0.0549048893,
-0.0289075561,
0.0138321007,
-0.0047037448,
-0.0186898448,
0.0647456199,
0.0401389115,
0.0606540479,
-0.0593468249,
0.049350597,
-0.0288502257,
0.0065809176,
-0.0610592365,
0.0276751891,
0.0300124325,
0.0930868462,
0.0144731374,
-0.0086488016,
-0.0190759003,
-0.0474156514,
0.073323667,
-0.0123130642,
-0.0104485387,
0.0243334156,
-0.0295897331,
0.0059975609,
0.0135577163,
0.0208222289,
-0.0254269112,
0.0276344381,
-0.0019582869,
0.0519436859,
0.0064786416,
0.0264545679,
0.008887371,
-0.0218807273,
-0.0253408253,
-0.0525490753,
0.0620576665,
-0.0555640943,
-0.0147593431,
0.0014898037,
0.0160178356,
-0.0114275254,
0.0719379559,
-0.0327679925,
-0.0016192376,
0.0149286836,
0.0323924311,
-0.0238272063,
0.001822699,
-0.0339238644,
-0.0272245798,
0.0541046448,
-0.0127945393,
-0.0236399788,
-0.0371431224,
-0.0063635167,
0.0324716792,
-0.0087415287,
0.0024471169,
2.697179364e-34,
0.0358341374,
-0.0289266948,
0.028718546,
0.0367585495,
0.0243432373,
-0.0311138909,
-0.0336465575,
0.0150080584,
0.0249195155,
-0.0186779983,
0.0063055162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20236v1 | Dynamically Updating Event Representations for Temporal Relation Classification with Multi-category Learning | 2023-10-31T07:41:24 | 2023-10-31T07:41:24 | Fei Cheng, Masayuki Asahara, Ichiro Kobayashi, Sadao Kurohashi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal relation classification is a pair-wise task for identifying the
relation of a temporal link (TLINK) between two mentions, i.e. event, time, and
document creation time (DCT). It leads to two crucial limits: 1) Two TLINKs
involving a common mention do not share information. 2) Existing models with
independent classifiers for each TLINK category (E2E, E2T, and E2D) hinder from
using the whole data. This paper presents an event centric model that allows to
manage dynamic event representations across multiple TLINKs. Our model deals
with three TLINK categories with multi-task learning to leverage the full size
of data. The experimental results show that our proposal outperforms
state-of-the-art models and two transfer learning baselines on both the English
and Japanese data. | [
0.0193793867,
0.0191654842,
-0.0127055738,
0.0160208438,
-0.0328106247,
0.0209269058,
0.0022960592,
0.0004080616,
0.0097116511,
-0.0490448065,
-0.0163092278,
-0.0305994749,
-0.0352893695,
0.028097542,
-0.0197668467,
-0.0653787181,
0.0570223369,
0.0364916064,
0.009864876,
0.0352055468,
0.0009772244,
0.0365710407,
-0.025143465,
0.0063243601,
-0.0197812691,
-0.0218322109,
-0.0216128677,
-0.0313577168,
0.0409220047,
-0.0246034767,
0.0155776795,
0.0336461514,
0.0405555815,
-0.0050198687,
0.0000016698,
-0.052266892,
-0.0296118651,
-0.0377277546,
0.0038500899,
-0.0045778533,
0.0037734972,
-0.0227957647,
0.03765288,
-0.0327630937,
-0.0271880385,
-0.0550329462,
0.0113056125,
0.0656053275,
0.011097502,
0.0727959052,
-0.0468964688,
0.0028667685,
0.0491688326,
-0.0262890458,
0.0197346266,
-0.0537500754,
0.0269413311,
0.0043325759,
0.0058077355,
-0.0080695469,
0.0058256458,
-0.0019261646,
0.0033532798,
-0.0064466833,
0.0545128062,
0.0389930941,
-0.0355784148,
0.0290170759,
-0.0162177738,
0.0615297109,
0.0060430788,
-0.0149150733,
0.0314510353,
0.030034611,
-0.0004941812,
0.0209909789,
-0.0476747118,
-0.0540750138,
-0.0064822221,
0.0182433985,
0.0330464393,
0.0138578042,
0.0220071469,
0.0201257113,
0.0234398469,
0.0012395692,
-0.007655438,
-0.0044143023,
-0.02693858,
0.0178991575,
0.047331173,
-0.0409309454,
0.0312580913,
0.0472040288,
0.0114563582,
0.0131903645,
-0.0321404077,
0.013499747,
-0.0007110753,
-0.0979300663,
-0.0131831784,
-0.0156532302,
0.0110856714,
0.0584876128,
-0.0223578177,
0.0019675838,
-0.0191279333,
-0.0231842063,
-0.01929662,
-0.0281697232,
-0.0773717016,
0.0276776049,
-0.0142456666,
0.0610407256,
0.0062973485,
0.0053964569,
-0.0388453081,
0.0280500036,
-0.0144144231,
-0.0169703364,
-0.008054018,
-0.0331147574,
-0.0600159205,
0.0091787875,
-0.0170872454,
0.001491655,
-0.0004250844,
0.0397736393,
-0.0552722812,
0.0013020216,
0.0013663523,
0.0058287438,
0.0318135768,
-0.0532703176,
-0.0416159891,
0.0547699369,
-0.0523150191,
-0.0182975084,
-0.0590145215,
-0.0404993147,
-0.0115963137,
-0.0260319896,
-0.0142573556,
-0.0348954871,
0.0286886338,
-0.0160355158,
-0.003048701,
0.0004792228,
-0.0003787173,
-0.0352745391,
-0.0390463024,
0.0497769266,
0.0473523028,
0.0041376087,
0.0006309316,
0.0021920039,
0.0135242753,
0.0314895883,
0.0576900207,
-0.0009715492,
0.0312524922,
0.0477163158,
-0.0364464559,
0.007571144,
0.0247094128,
0.0060888235,
0.0090008732,
-0.0101815788,
0.0097714849,
0.0057440773,
0.0446705222,
-0.0273717679,
-0.0242498703,
0.0014090807,
0.0169007685,
-0.0127889104,
0.0000092603,
0.02774515,
0.0569913946,
-0.0114397667,
-0.0396545902,
0.0069777733,
0.006056881,
0.0306640416,
0.0087761637,
-0.0222820472,
-0.0379161946,
-0.0158047825,
-0.0427593999,
-0.0008141904,
0.035516113,
-0.0341890864,
0.0025464937,
-0.021057928,
0.0804476365,
-0.0172328204,
-0.0239359792,
0.0798260272,
0.0178597961,
0.0209135227,
0.0125681087,
-0.0073655937,
0.0046204808,
0.0401786007,
-0.0062359427,
-0.0266704801,
-0.058197625,
-0.036035981,
0.0517380722,
0.0168526955,
0.0551498681,
-0.0519032516,
0.0261945836,
0.0046556909,
-0.0334085636,
0.0115189906,
-0.0076843873,
0.0195650868,
0.0165151786,
0.0696884394,
0.0160937048,
0.0192026999,
0.0228157993,
-0.0017660094,
-0.0072264518,
-0.0079110088,
-0.0238516983,
0.0185460225,
0.0131163681,
-0.0119980983,
-0.0018066922,
-0.0280804727,
0.0523868352,
-0.0498534963,
-0.019215079,
0.0613741837,
-0.0266180579,
-0.0334396698,
0.0663452968,
0.0310066696,
-0.0228460394,
0.0112416614,
-0.0370991863,
-0.0322693326,
0.0500454083,
0.0250890832,
0.0210388042,
-0.0273144767,
0.0018704394,
0.0021426359,
0.0068770098,
-0.0267030448,
0.0444017462,
0.0055123325,
-0.0167395566,
-0.0198991112,
-0.052578669,
0.0140333399,
-0.0124015156,
-0.0082205096,
0.0163416564,
0.0047797109,
-0.0087019624,
0.0252748672,
-0.0095357504,
-0.041822806,
-0.0019226706,
-0.0664380938,
0.0073757959,
0.0003191672,
0.0463386476,
-0.0024624986,
-0.0213738233,
0.0057161804,
-0.0082988953,
-0.0346163325,
-0.0256242696,
-0.042726662,
-0.0008649426,
0.0580651462,
0.0374563485,
-0.0015392136,
-0.0191376489,
-0.0013349046,
-0.0537509769,
0.066618681,
0.0015988303,
-0.1066791341,
-0.005347624,
-0.0101822875,
-0.0009852399,
0.0073651783,
0.0052374564,
0.0454342067,
-0.0353265032,
-0.0191268027,
0.0415958725,
0.0011282964,
-0.0151793472,
0.0597412847,
0.0030820756,
-0.0533674061,
-0.0562415943,
0.046337314,
-0.0213403311,
0.0361869149,
-0.0445218533,
-0.0146374069,
-0.0257231779,
0.0398626216,
-0.0051579103,
0.0015736019,
-0.040201813,
-0.0336392745,
-0.003158022,
0.0093092946,
-0.0343055278,
-0.0126558552,
-0.0233756062,
-0.0141456714,
-0.0469443724,
-0.0133045577,
0.0346667729,
0.0362776555,
0.0097104395,
-0.0155010018,
-0.0160789248,
-0.0641173571,
0.1095167696,
-0.0340082534,
0.0109664369,
0.0237297434,
-0.0378961563,
-0.0474338047,
0.0138095403,
0.0251859035,
0.0028544338,
0.0327491835,
-0.0432381518,
0.0419255421,
-0.0180914532,
-0.0229060948,
-0.0143637126,
-0.059454795,
0.0077826576,
0.0067171892,
-0.090417318,
0.0177279618,
-0.0256687477,
0.0371377394,
-0.0455514118,
0.0291119032,
0.000536698,
-0.0397577211,
0.0203115847,
0.1207948849,
0.0669372901,
0.0077243764,
-0.0630915537,
-0.0096641732,
-0.0298285,
0.0239253044,
0.0582502075,
-0.0084778201,
-0.0262420736,
0.0220688898,
0.0065387152,
-0.0611549951,
-0.0159165189,
-0.0353031568,
0.0126051065,
-0.0503117703,
0.0095888497,
0.0929892883,
0.0315782912,
-0.0479312055,
-0.0058116163,
0.0295339953,
-0.0352376699,
0.0030417934,
0.0167450178,
-0.0552008487,
-0.0069937147,
-0.0366662107,
-0.0584105812,
0.0148008233,
-0.0386833698,
-0.0197326485,
-0.0512645058,
-0.0057138531,
0.014095583,
0.0039028767,
0.0148408459,
-0.0406316221,
0.026594514,
-0.0220644828,
-0.0431546494,
-0.0360963903,
0.0036651902,
-0.0128541822,
0.011303992,
-0.0225336552,
-0.0458313897,
0.0612579174,
-0.0046711289,
0.0492392443,
-0.0248311292,
0.0689565688,
-0.0195389763,
0.0136901895,
0.0507633463,
0.0002825769,
-0.0232767761,
-0.0133278649,
0.0252752975,
-0.0328980014,
0.0079572955,
-0.0036094673,
-0.0011797828,
-0.002941302,
-0.0197624508,
0.0031885377,
0.1262830049,
0.0035943789,
0.0074967882,
-0.0219800603,
-0.0355751812,
0.0213390794,
0.0348231047,
-0.0303384289,
-0.035455361,
-0.0044056321,
0.0400377549,
-0.0071225925,
-0.0340188928,
0.0327828638,
-0.031356886,
-0.0866555125,
-0.0139169069,
-0.0739284456,
-0.042485714,
-0.0036731372,
0.0077110305,
-0.020439826,
0.039763052,
0.0140409321,
-0.0145811895,
-0.0904588252,
0.0295815282,
-0.0091483621,
0.028702898,
0.0191135723,
-0.021119507,
0.0388846509,
0.0248185936,
-0.0123641398,
0.0047490387,
-0.0500106066,
-0.0301206857,
-0.0664798692,
-0.0271027945,
0.0088293273,
0.0716321543,
0.0028629329,
0.026822431,
-0.0028889028,
0.0263713039,
-0.0095231524,
0.0062764157,
0.0377444327,
0.0230750032,
-0.0247195829,
0.0610165671,
-0.0441931039,
0.0216203593,
-0.0132071292,
0.0131515944,
-0.0670610741,
-0.0111863464,
-0.0228830986,
-0.0183235612,
0.08122655,
0.0355911925,
-0.0020784445,
-0.0302828755,
0.007647065,
-0.0036816639,
0.0102056181,
-0.0312223621,
-0.0011216757,
0.0250787884,
0.0141964769,
-0.0599786155,
0.0096936608,
0.0130375465,
-0.0023377389,
-0.0621630028,
-0.0007742888,
0.0233083852,
0.0316909142,
-0.0245550517,
0.0302733574,
-0.0204099044,
-0.0222706255,
0.0453213081,
-0.018250091,
-0.0339562595,
-0.0126109207,
0.006902867,
0.0420442857,
-0.0139251314,
-0.0216526743,
-0.0524713174,
0.0708286092,
0.0004587217,
-0.03689114,
0.0769719481,
-0.0157347042,
0.0700602457,
0.0046168528,
-0.0185181312,
-0.0049069561,
0.066787906,
-0.0275637824,
0.0122514693,
0.0074081337,
-0.0041729813,
-0.0154869249,
0.0575986169,
0.0858098492,
0.0005062256,
0.052286502,
0.0221977681,
-0.0283449087,
-0.0391707718,
-0.0096233236,
0.0006786375,
-0.0034300704,
0.0116495844,
0.0188993402,
-0.049336832,
-0.0015731584,
0.0987078547,
-0.0726981387,
0.0058567906,
0.0047643115,
0.0138754556,
0.0168928318,
0.0348781161,
-0.0184542499,
-0.0188014302,
0.0014158386,
0.054589577,
-0.0227643587,
-0.0455030017,
-5.727249821e-33,
-0.0157576632,
0.001389194,
0.0144569427,
0.0398243181,
-0.046169702,
0.0722106993,
-0.0149823241,
-0.0512697436,
-0.0057859235,
-0.0048966683,
0.0095758373,
0.0258368235,
0.0231997129,
-0.0229135528,
0.0351850614,
-0.0170815028,
0.0437234491,
-0.0106254118,
0.0247774012,
0.0533549152,
0.0675585642,
0.0370369852,
0.0726837814,
-0.0941979215,
0.0310667194,
0.038908612,
-0.0187868234,
0.007160842,
0.0825566575,
0.0472698584,
-0.0022182357,
0.028361747,
0.0472620241,
-0.0360246897,
-0.0039040362,
0.0013575075,
-0.1591075957,
-0.042488046,
-0.0140391076,
-0.000178317,
0.0317737088,
-0.0457203276,
-0.0132340323,
0.0170571357,
0.0295222923,
-0.0482569896,
0.054578729,
-0.0176280867,
-0.059026707,
-0.1087813377,
-0.040191438,
0.0433001705,
-0.0068660281,
0.0150731336,
0.0273126289,
0.0092692226,
0.0329845995,
-0.0212711934,
-0.0413890444,
0.0120293237,
-0.0635775328,
-0.0215164144,
-0.0048703183,
-0.0371490456,
-0.0171664394,
0.0435790792,
-0.0200824309,
0.0157668162,
0.0019753117,
0.0419322476,
0.0010254564,
0.0199788827,
-0.0162114333,
0.0263168402,
0.0019516001,
-0.0188763496,
-0.103580147,
0.0355220251,
0.1076549366,
0.0091172559,
-0.0103625571,
0.0300749969,
-0.0294532422,
0.0023524109,
0.0035698037,
0.06983722,
-0.0063934349,
-0.0165825561,
0.0056672664,
0.0393861234,
0.0454942659,
0.0754924715,
0.0103258975,
-0.0345495343,
-0.0614136904,
0.0397655964,
-0.016590355,
0.027609352,
0.0241823662,
-0.0248489305,
-0.0573086329,
-0.0663558021,
-0.0098070912,
0.0013281227,
0.0270867255,
0.0086552538,
0.0658621565,
0.0286609419,
-0.0389862582,
-0.0223357771,
0.0094563356,
-0.0293918401,
0.0047808108,
0.0149986707,
-0.000514977,
0.0104868896,
0.0014333898,
0.0514870211,
0.0522240251,
0.0429990478,
0.0128543945,
0.0158515759,
-0.0001362619,
0.045768369,
0.0286607109,
-0.0270239934,
-0.0277342908,
0.0294983704,
0.0088929413,
-0.0505837053,
-0.0250358786,
-0.0010188306,
2.488e-7,
0.0375270732,
0.0210205372,
0.0138887716,
0.0350216292,
0.017630348,
-0.0159705058,
-0.0224848874,
0.0747015998,
-0.0235693902,
0.0726955757,
0.0127131678,
0.0106519088,
0.0259138234,
0.0491986498,
-0.0645577535,
-0.0775711685,
-0.0649240464,
-0.0165898595,
-0.0793335661,
-0.0020211202,
0.049472101,
0.0407789275,
0.067894727,
0.0138727743,
-0.0127287405,
-0.0714286119,
0.0907343104,
-0.0212115142,
-0.029945042,
0.0358817577,
-0.0166333336,
0.036850743,
-0.038986221,
0.0572560318,
-0.0475175232,
0.0345057026,
-0.0019014769,
0.0492362045,
-0.0404098071,
-0.0203985777,
0.0075052478,
-0.0338686369,
-0.0124755371,
0.0290059354,
0.0759091303,
-0.0793112814,
0.0121105444,
0.016722925,
0.0007087977,
0.0430811383,
0.0143297818,
0.0300701577,
-0.0330203585,
0.0427300185,
0.0246177744,
-0.0096195145,
-0.0385776572,
-0.0986425951,
0.0003088071,
0.0722747371,
0.0094814822,
-0.0091373846,
0.002468637,
-0.0550728329,
0.0165619422,
-0.0578143112,
0.0210827682,
1.871707398e-34,
0.0128974225,
0.0209044553,
-0.0383557193,
0.0362689644,
0.003253343,
-0.0474912897,
-0.0436607376,
-0.0056595653,
0.0442370437,
-0.0240619704,
0.0161487181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10746v1 | EIT: Earnest Insight Toolkit for Evaluating Students' Earnestness in Interactive Lecture Participation Exercises | 2023-10-31T07:05:00 | 2023-10-31T07:05:00 | Mihran Miroyan, Shiny Weng, Rahul Shah, Lisa Yan, Narges Norouzi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | In today's rapidly evolving educational landscape, traditional modes of
passive information delivery are giving way to transformative pedagogical
approaches that prioritize active student engagement. Within the context of
large-scale hybrid classrooms, the challenge lies in fostering meaningful and
active interaction between students and course content. This study delves into
the significance of measuring students' earnestness during interactive lecture
participation exercises. By analyzing students' responses to interactive
lecture poll questions, establishing a clear rubric for evaluating earnestness,
and conducting a comprehensive assessment, we introduce EIT (Earnest Insight
Toolkit), a tool designed to assess students' engagement within interactive
lecture participation exercises - particularly in the context of large-scale
hybrid classrooms. Through the utilization of EIT, our objective is to equip
educators with valuable means of identifying at-risk students for enhancing
intervention and support strategies, as well as measuring students' levels of
engagement with course content. | [
-0.0281202719,
-0.0574981943,
-0.0526677445,
-0.0131718935,
-0.0126749342,
0.030582048,
-0.0140506411,
-0.0279622637,
0.0177432764,
0.0022102213,
0.0137233436,
0.0283302125,
-0.0433427915,
0.0218146797,
-0.0040866421,
-0.0570310391,
-0.0004911615,
0.0162444785,
-0.0144635215,
0.06854368,
0.0178129561,
-0.0120871514,
-0.0729928687,
0.0053433753,
0.0090192184,
0.0014465447,
-0.0287288614,
0.0112430751,
0.0485130511,
-0.0232655872,
0.052748885,
0.0430237576,
0.0014257578,
0.0011497247,
0.0000023789,
-0.0346413217,
-0.0115312058,
-0.0216580313,
-0.0772835389,
0.0391713493,
0.0206872709,
0.1048259139,
0.023126889,
-0.0103790993,
-0.0393039212,
0.0256035812,
0.0322861038,
-0.0005656554,
0.0343333893,
-0.022845313,
0.0249152593,
0.0584108457,
0.0227380022,
0.0298644286,
0.0993880481,
0.0567553788,
0.0041497322,
0.0320879109,
0.0299938787,
-0.0097237071,
-0.0290950332,
0.0239941217,
-0.0061680544,
-0.0372422822,
0.0711743683,
-0.0015445737,
-0.0469062701,
-0.0119084828,
0.0182480477,
0.0160349384,
0.0712206364,
0.0483111665,
-0.0099648004,
-0.0144522302,
0.0603297129,
0.027952766,
-0.0734300241,
-0.0518549979,
0.0079115611,
-0.0085236654,
-0.0325233787,
0.0498399585,
-0.0247576069,
0.0283481348,
0.063086696,
-0.0419469438,
-0.007890163,
0.0004368207,
-0.0263569988,
0.032821089,
0.0199590474,
0.0142706474,
-0.0150482785,
0.0455935821,
-0.0149488635,
-0.0048375134,
-0.006654324,
-0.0313969888,
-0.0163892079,
0.028933851,
-0.029520005,
0.0721110925,
-0.0090447972,
0.0151562579,
0.0558705702,
0.032721743,
0.053919062,
-0.0396079756,
0.0132449213,
0.0706822574,
-0.0233189464,
0.0187296402,
-0.0035230983,
0.0226744544,
0.0437166095,
-0.0567673072,
-0.0083744982,
0.0029160501,
-0.0636661053,
0.0545888208,
-0.0718239248,
-0.0125635825,
-0.0000489294,
0.0308861956,
-0.0035070137,
0.0856719911,
-0.0014508036,
-0.0216801167,
0.001815435,
-0.0243348964,
0.0376499444,
0.020939745,
0.0020565705,
-0.0137248505,
0.0085339714,
-0.0416286848,
0.0120775858,
-0.0654841959,
-0.0198151302,
-0.0248021521,
0.0589755625,
0.023051694,
-0.0153478114,
-0.0122267427,
-0.0071951505,
-0.0034757196,
0.0033208774,
0.0152765056,
0.0241560563,
0.0013520721,
0.0696087927,
0.0253118388,
-0.0278674439,
-0.0406113304,
0.048639603,
0.0530710444,
-0.0035781811,
0.0213226471,
-0.0036507153,
-0.0028433399,
0.0443031266,
-0.0635443702,
0.0191791318,
-0.0104079964,
-0.00520653,
0.0055627702,
0.0946521237,
-0.0123440195,
0.0028755658,
-0.0073684682,
-0.1023661271,
-0.0325117968,
-0.0072361971,
0.1003019959,
0.0231412798,
0.0112536028,
-0.0402882174,
-0.0582989119,
-0.0538391136,
0.0164465494,
0.0411327928,
0.0191207491,
-0.0373976082,
0.0374749079,
0.0248244908,
-0.0032138133,
0.0433898382,
0.011934069,
-0.0018411299,
-0.090636231,
-0.0382065699,
0.0024866674,
-0.008304731,
0.0592722073,
-0.0083939284,
-0.0395870171,
-0.0118111186,
0.0235911701,
0.0075590657,
-0.0786319599,
0.0702997744,
-0.018355675,
0.0318984613,
0.0774404779,
0.0457472764,
-0.0615130849,
-0.0497747138,
-0.0366774388,
0.0481010526,
0.0215155408,
0.0049302308,
-0.0073899599,
-0.018262228,
-0.0357232541,
-0.0030255294,
-0.0220893268,
0.0199583154,
0.014553261,
-0.0170221757,
0.0108891325,
-0.0263311006,
-0.0176111627,
-0.0107596619,
0.0272536278,
-0.0535618365,
-0.0640827864,
-0.0417162441,
0.0332207158,
0.0287435856,
0.0488161705,
0.0034234463,
-0.0234322753,
-0.0025659958,
0.056757208,
0.018541513,
-0.0404921845,
0.0217617135,
0.0593534783,
0.0276322085,
-0.055722516,
-0.0191745851,
-0.0781425238,
0.0247939173,
0.0023440423,
0.01519721,
0.0115788728,
0.0205171816,
-0.0011694318,
0.012127053,
-0.0425763242,
0.0201861616,
-0.0354797468,
-0.047516536,
0.0056007877,
0.0429891385,
0.0486276038,
-0.0822852626,
-0.0078648943,
-0.0046124738,
-0.0364526622,
-0.0347112939,
-0.0667903945,
-0.0132969161,
-0.0429304913,
-0.0340439118,
-0.0781833604,
0.0047453595,
-0.0286450554,
-0.0329041854,
0.011560699,
0.0050997655,
0.0070715602,
0.0176623669,
-0.0259033758,
0.0400482491,
-0.0160836224,
-0.0346096195,
-0.0235341936,
-0.020247316,
-0.0362268277,
0.0107588759,
0.0445902497,
-0.0148692168,
0.0071930927,
-0.0232471321,
-0.0133501533,
0.0775666833,
-0.00601527,
0.0170066673,
-0.0438861474,
0.0051097577,
-0.0520520099,
-0.0075215367,
-0.0495189652,
0.0092696585,
-0.0096452534,
0.0235584993,
0.0336198919,
0.013385945,
0.0604268275,
-0.0022420171,
-0.0764920339,
-0.016226517,
0.0177541655,
-0.0237892028,
0.0415419377,
-0.0210848767,
-0.0740215331,
0.0046476386,
-0.0188929532,
0.020368509,
-0.003486654,
-0.0041433312,
-0.0272052512,
-0.0302376933,
0.0353921428,
-0.0316768587,
-0.0635037795,
-0.0273533892,
-0.0362698883,
0.0227844734,
0.0339024514,
0.0241106488,
-0.0029028533,
-0.0144550093,
-0.0026049817,
0.0341052674,
0.0077403542,
-0.0139143327,
-0.0302014351,
-0.0128737055,
-0.017823007,
-0.0005053206,
0.005026679,
-0.0167055111,
0.0298380591,
-0.064589113,
0.0243625324,
-0.0179575607,
-0.0743242428,
-0.0120653743,
0.0449447222,
-0.0263859853,
0.0426635519,
0.0145642273,
-0.0487053581,
0.000424008,
-0.0369625911,
-0.0080198077,
-0.0446543284,
0.0194802042,
-0.0354798436,
-0.0176599622,
-0.03222657,
0.0493030548,
-0.0051402808,
0.0013274276,
0.0417404547,
0.0466342382,
-0.0204365086,
0.0336031243,
0.0594739355,
0.0067600776,
-0.0252056718,
0.0525222532,
-0.0110865738,
0.0400891528,
-0.0225121938,
0.0097155822,
0.0232693292,
0.0247461777,
-0.0447554402,
0.0161908343,
0.0601647012,
-0.0038130796,
-0.0027315025,
-0.0164100118,
-0.0233441181,
0.0116665615,
-0.0085166162,
0.0040904256,
-0.0823241919,
0.0052274177,
-0.0315329917,
0.0562714972,
-0.0233921185,
-0.006153659,
0.011498116,
-0.0091096032,
0.0499477126,
0.0094335703,
0.0344771668,
0.0257586204,
0.0037851504,
0.0496423095,
0.0322121419,
-0.0059453282,
-0.0416646004,
0.0229461621,
0.0265524164,
0.0407846943,
-0.0177118983,
-0.0115702171,
-0.0141832931,
0.0483961254,
0.0080549531,
-0.0198220797,
0.0063284663,
-0.0311331078,
-0.0687554702,
0.0341072194,
-0.0334431753,
-0.047167331,
0.0173276328,
0.0593504459,
-0.044634454,
0.0418492965,
-0.0063985782,
0.0440042615,
0.0127764978,
-0.0174625609,
0.0247283839,
0.0928500816,
0.0052759023,
0.0248561408,
-0.0582546666,
0.0112688411,
0.039341934,
-0.0077792876,
0.0394549966,
-0.0337467231,
0.0635409728,
-0.0243631229,
0.0313627049,
0.0028465628,
-0.0172050912,
0.0057966388,
-0.0032082079,
0.0136267124,
0.040819779,
-0.0343734473,
0.082248956,
0.0384809263,
-0.0130525399,
0.042345617,
-0.0259123668,
0.0279479548,
-0.0322416089,
0.0242572855,
0.0518726148,
0.0281765331,
-0.03507277,
-0.0574766695,
-0.0805203915,
-0.070188269,
-0.0195085015,
-0.0543814339,
0.0065878415,
-0.0373961255,
0.0736238137,
0.0130552817,
0.0203190297,
-0.0581380017,
0.0247148648,
0.0314403288,
0.0002367227,
0.0039119045,
0.0347693264,
-0.0035607491,
0.0178136099,
0.0079586394,
0.0124101806,
-0.0270607397,
0.042218633,
-0.0527694672,
0.0221051555,
-0.0175253376,
-0.0126656303,
-0.0595062561,
-0.0338745341,
0.0406315774,
0.0579235256,
-0.0063088513,
-0.0352288447,
-0.000983372,
-0.0099554006,
0.0098009575,
-0.052496843,
0.0086855888,
-0.0533273593,
0.00814927,
0.0016694942,
-0.0233729668,
0.0440842696,
-0.0024616001,
-0.0038517548,
-0.0608746558,
0.0404238254,
0.0099102641,
-0.0330345146,
-0.009367357,
-0.0057940795,
-0.0103643434,
0.0074860528,
0.0328952409,
0.0367920212,
0.0290870983,
0.0892645046,
0.0140218502,
0.0086043738,
0.0238877181,
0.0092217652,
-0.0310618971,
0.0597640947,
-0.0146054728,
0.0683303848,
-0.0586497076,
0.0405777209,
-0.0028471537,
0.0146660246,
0.0066523296,
0.0119035244,
0.0268069152,
-0.0073334281,
-0.0793417469,
0.036085967,
0.022458842,
0.0264392998,
-0.006872118,
-0.0428198539,
-0.1174763888,
0.0069649662,
0.0055765701,
0.0295480546,
-0.0087632723,
0.0069976621,
0.055372797,
0.0570666976,
0.0243695173,
0.0454266183,
-0.0385149643,
-0.0236345436,
-0.0075794319,
0.0218327455,
-0.0043601641,
-0.0328073986,
0.0148031963,
-0.0277423132,
0.0088501507,
0.0015848385,
0.0051305494,
0.0079650022,
-0.073064141,
-0.0117092468,
0.0280401707,
-6.37893544e-33,
-0.0218801759,
-0.0544937514,
-0.0227851551,
0.0819221139,
-0.0465627983,
-0.0010766641,
-0.0249056742,
0.0726301745,
-0.0253668111,
-0.0175076593,
0.0244361106,
0.0087939883,
-0.0217925385,
0.0457279906,
-0.0116819646,
-0.0342628919,
-0.0089686587,
0.0438608378,
-0.0223284736,
0.0173749942,
-0.0098744743,
-0.0097303884,
0.0206616949,
-0.0463094376,
0.0665426552,
0.0001011269,
-0.0279412512,
-0.0490595847,
-0.0329578668,
-0.0002085987,
-0.0228647236,
0.0605999455,
-0.0089104148,
0.0189757776,
0.03040847,
0.0441060998,
-0.0130058192,
-0.0718441233,
-0.0162282865,
0.008050587,
-0.0373366624,
-0.0350068547,
-0.0230645537,
0.0007957417,
-0.043123696,
-0.0565626062,
0.0568847507,
0.0080438517,
0.0245124474,
-0.0098641226,
-0.0494646542,
-0.0098001147,
-0.0766676739,
-0.0128986221,
-0.0172995552,
0.0417992063,
0.0330107436,
-0.039615076,
-0.0286285039,
0.038345132,
0.0186148826,
0.0075458391,
0.0179863311,
-0.0029112028,
-0.002211595,
0.0281371269,
0.0069208369,
-0.0214066431,
0.0039024833,
0.0090856496,
0.0367013738,
-0.015569035,
0.0884820148,
0.0657776445,
-0.0346807614,
-0.0013325845,
0.0278509688,
0.0650659129,
0.08825434,
-0.0214428324,
-0.0110320896,
-0.0370427854,
-0.0951848105,
-0.0196836181,
-0.0204200726,
-0.011391147,
0.0298457481,
-0.0304794069,
0.0136010405,
-0.0652347058,
-0.0639444888,
-0.0166981071,
0.002713989,
0.0188786499,
-0.0232864767,
0.0048213,
0.0062917378,
0.0607637726,
-0.0026816514,
-0.0405845828,
0.007477853,
0.0194405466,
-0.0207824931,
-0.0053016827,
0.0191190653,
-0.0211098976,
-0.0210518297,
0.0268203039,
0.0250856318,
-0.0125610316,
-0.0006142718,
0.0087522585,
0.0406141169,
-0.0183502808,
-0.0038817681,
0.0139525412,
-0.0000603612,
0.056150429,
0.001694481,
-0.0137138655,
-0.0217887163,
-0.0226624757,
-0.0290559642,
-0.0350846387,
-0.0159369595,
0.0019282696,
-0.0248883907,
-0.031234853,
-0.0513438098,
-0.060800381,
0.0118787158,
-0.0266155917,
2.971e-7,
-0.0074983784,
0.0202515088,
-0.01465875,
-0.0350461006,
-0.0301999934,
0.0041092187,
-0.0172521044,
-0.0193312261,
0.1014798954,
0.0070648235,
0.0634655729,
-0.0075382316,
0.0340558887,
0.0348360762,
-0.0490881652,
-0.0936521143,
0.0328405537,
0.0095422054,
-0.0130116977,
0.0531204045,
0.0976611227,
-0.0235673822,
0.0106616598,
0.0299188308,
0.0325177163,
0.0201065913,
-0.0494922772,
-0.0038334299,
0.026590351,
0.0374071859,
-0.0593556948,
-0.0324738398,
0.0045424444,
0.0161870737,
-0.0281544011,
-0.0198921524,
-0.0007432476,
0.0236479547,
0.0344913602,
-0.0605434962,
-0.0095450934,
0.0388065428,
0.0332506113,
-0.0352072082,
0.0148028973,
-0.0224260259,
0.0165765639,
0.0511156395,
-0.0643091202,
-0.082796894,
0.0128180124,
0.0199933127,
-0.0340343453,
-0.0249420889,
0.0038800263,
-0.0162068494,
-0.017346194,
0.0101329703,
0.0164481141,
-0.0881523639,
-0.0492029376,
-0.0296454392,
0.0028461986,
-0.0067006522,
-0.0340790041,
0.0169359893,
-0.0555402264,
2.432336814e-34,
-0.0133616105,
-0.0252768118,
0.0858712718,
-0.0003487595,
0.0014077658,
0.0318918638,
0.0275455061,
0.0078036985,
0.0459815525,
-0.0203926433,
-0.0348279551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20216v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20216v2 | Does GPT-4 pass the Turing test? | 2023-10-31T06:27:52 | 2024-04-20T20:47:28 | Cameron R. Jones, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We evaluated GPT-4 in a public online Turing test. The best-performing GPT-4
prompt passed in 49.7% of games, outperforming ELIZA (22%) and GPT-3.5 (20%),
but falling short of the baseline set by human participants (66%).
Participants' decisions were based mainly on linguistic style (35%) and
socioemotional traits (27%), supporting the idea that intelligence, narrowly
conceived, is not sufficient to pass the Turing test. Participant knowledge
about LLMs and number of games played positively correlated with accuracy in
detecting AI, suggesting learning and practice as possible strategies to
mitigate deception. Despite known limitations as a test of intelligence, we
argue that the Turing test continues to be relevant as an assessment of
naturalistic communication and deception. AI models with the ability to
masquerade as humans could have widespread societal consequences, and we
analyse the effectiveness of different strategies and criteria for judging
humanlikeness. | [
0.0456027985,
0.0392935537,
-0.0679008216,
0.0262123961,
-0.051447358,
-0.0080010658,
0.0361090638,
0.0389474668,
0.0689360276,
0.0105192866,
-0.0500267819,
-0.0113862446,
0.031667009,
0.0205754191,
0.0594567992,
-0.009879481,
0.0175462905,
-0.0026425016,
0.0419485271,
-0.0037302903,
-0.0174993277,
0.0361550935,
0.0087408572,
0.0276203081,
0.007276535,
-0.0273636598,
0.0069324682,
-0.0177415926,
0.0321871042,
-0.0173831228,
-0.0021549,
0.0020034348,
0.0189832523,
0.0564350635,
0.0000019887,
-0.04670237,
0.0229890682,
-0.0165876113,
-0.0269736107,
0.0045898426,
0.0260355603,
0.0442229286,
0.0195488352,
0.027213566,
-0.0720054805,
0.0302864257,
0.0169968847,
0.0057145944,
0.0448258445,
0.0805705041,
-0.0122348266,
0.0259247404,
0.0454373471,
-0.0152010461,
0.0341865607,
-0.0323020555,
-0.0172498375,
-0.0427420624,
0.0222960096,
-0.015159186,
0.0360670425,
0.0013775768,
0.0138885612,
0.019585982,
-0.0716286004,
0.0419759005,
-0.0020378255,
-0.0116826082,
0.0083081257,
0.0318196155,
0.0318167955,
0.0123022776,
0.0092149042,
0.049332615,
0.0608058423,
0.0059547904,
0.0278887209,
0.0252638943,
-0.030614445,
-0.0373372026,
-0.0201668981,
-0.0079782214,
0.0241758227,
0.0192222986,
0.0303140692,
0.0386502221,
-0.0133457333,
-0.018499855,
-0.0029101167,
-0.0122362459,
0.0160571057,
-0.0325967483,
-0.0301959198,
0.0072663119,
-0.0344399251,
-0.0199676137,
-0.0389176011,
0.0454834662,
0.0293105636,
0.0175374094,
0.0233565792,
0.044007577,
0.0322607607,
0.0146039398,
0.0266675744,
0.0834092051,
0.0028983364,
0.0408546701,
-0.0208782032,
0.0095576514,
-0.017114006,
-0.0507799014,
0.0063715535,
0.0154102864,
0.049564641,
0.0175904781,
-0.0249935612,
0.0107110906,
-0.0747208446,
0.0210906304,
-0.0570915565,
-0.0459490903,
-0.0155385798,
-0.0211244468,
-0.037121933,
-0.0185708646,
-0.0376090407,
0.0120685436,
-0.0026467205,
-0.1019978821,
-0.0132163186,
-0.0207328741,
-0.003738113,
-0.0150008248,
0.0367343985,
0.0524686985,
0.0123581998,
-0.0543343388,
0.0257151444,
-0.0007640176,
0.0018517931,
-0.0710419789,
0.0265422426,
-0.0241431911,
-0.0308983251,
-0.0209839903,
0.0084036374,
-0.0144469598,
-0.0042087408,
0.0367611311,
-0.0106149772,
0.0495194271,
-0.008502393,
0.0264420677,
0.0272080023,
0.0330858789,
-0.031050913,
0.0153537355,
0.0254793223,
0.0434188582,
0.0132045252,
-0.0266205929,
0.0880816281,
0.04083566,
-0.0235628672,
0.0115838768,
0.0471071973,
-0.0078455163,
-0.0025306796,
0.0246604029,
0.0214608125,
0.0326616094,
-0.0148124825,
-0.0066686654,
0.099635914,
0.062981464,
-0.0174668524,
0.0225876831,
0.0313374698,
0.0430048406,
0.022776749,
0.0171936769,
-0.0284602344,
0.0078597311,
-0.0827678367,
-0.0113046514,
-0.0256513767,
0.0327693485,
-0.013729752,
-0.0004205994,
0.0146946739,
-0.0029127933,
0.0489456803,
0.0393547826,
-0.0235923305,
-0.0433455855,
-0.0443775021,
-0.0486304723,
-0.0199554898,
-0.0231414065,
-0.011478967,
-0.1264263242,
0.0234572645,
0.0616137683,
0.0004601485,
0.0068428526,
-0.0059371628,
-0.0243990868,
-0.0043929978,
0.0558941849,
0.0181260835,
0.0031289638,
-0.0003495673,
0.0164130647,
0.0235583112,
-0.0428824984,
-0.0075770547,
0.0448976271,
-0.0349541679,
0.0306266788,
0.0118822781,
-0.0240425803,
0.0472486466,
0.0067562191,
0.0026949677,
-0.0271764323,
-0.0457076244,
0.0082283793,
0.0634534732,
0.0182417203,
-0.0122120827,
-0.0026840316,
0.0194905438,
0.0127401697,
-0.0017268526,
-0.0231424887,
0.0009193688,
0.0571036786,
0.008659753,
-0.1004560739,
-0.0217531528,
0.1107304469,
0.0180096496,
0.0206770264,
0.0118329721,
-0.0700800195,
0.0341369472,
-0.0115178348,
0.0027326492,
-0.0595081523,
-0.0071118171,
0.0194122698,
0.0420944281,
-0.0018209296,
-0.0197404176,
-0.022020964,
-0.0596143603,
0.0065791858,
-0.0589034073,
0.0033099339,
0.005565634,
0.0035083198,
0.0129843336,
0.02170025,
0.0394241996,
-0.0727521777,
-0.0277267639,
-0.1402328461,
-0.0150909526,
0.0098690633,
0.0034843562,
0.0350457095,
-0.0281445514,
-0.0427202359,
0.0217880886,
-0.0382349007,
-0.0138738938,
0.0100002084,
0.0266849305,
0.0038329498,
-0.018615853,
-0.0237553157,
0.0323836133,
0.0256086979,
-0.0364818349,
-0.0130207939,
0.003408548,
-0.0072061401,
-0.0198760107,
-0.0121612409,
-0.0492673069,
-0.0071532289,
-0.0208984092,
-0.0582852997,
0.0376922339,
0.0028784645,
-0.0007831987,
0.0562403128,
0.0721930936,
0.0316593759,
0.0395521596,
0.0379272327,
-0.0103263911,
-0.0050591063,
0.0529961623,
-0.0129843969,
-0.0172213186,
-0.1050039455,
0.0221845638,
0.0144813303,
0.0104037011,
0.0245065726,
-0.0502827018,
0.0876858309,
-0.0107507259,
-0.0461556166,
0.00378604,
-0.0434006453,
-0.0266710594,
0.0050710165,
-0.0047971969,
-0.0593728982,
0.0610179193,
-0.0202377029,
0.0011500566,
0.0198040865,
0.0032298628,
0.0300107375,
0.0696086213,
0.0218477231,
-0.001734321,
0.0051746885,
-0.0455315635,
-0.0244799871,
-0.0269081388,
0.0114731435,
-0.0367789716,
0.0177932698,
-0.038308531,
-0.0080909636,
0.0281706974,
-0.0101417582,
-0.0303513613,
-0.0278273374,
-0.0346810482,
-0.0220640004,
-0.0011902617,
-0.0319059566,
-0.0302653704,
-0.0659060404,
0.0319614746,
0.0038234713,
0.0182707943,
-0.0194503795,
0.0086190589,
-0.0346654914,
0.0341830589,
0.0371675789,
0.0296923779,
-0.0327847041,
0.0234225355,
0.0224862769,
-0.0352677181,
-0.0123536615,
0.0163570046,
-0.01597373,
0.0176371317,
-0.0022335434,
-0.0039297938,
0.0605375469,
0.028681675,
-0.0110969022,
0.0144883692,
0.0979090184,
-0.0012961261,
-0.0093338853,
-0.0068906834,
0.0251086801,
-0.0215551741,
0.0130779427,
0.0030756074,
-0.074277319,
0.0016874175,
0.0212905388,
0.0218301434,
-0.0760770515,
-0.0201205667,
-0.0164376292,
-0.070597291,
0.0068689189,
0.0081933038,
-0.0597771145,
-0.0374414027,
-0.024453558,
-0.0168035496,
0.0066390825,
0.0532932058,
-0.0228686258,
0.0053484817,
-0.004935429,
-0.0705010593,
-0.070703499,
0.0224820077,
0.0752669573,
-0.010647703,
0.0748769566,
0.0424114726,
0.057780914,
-0.0585705042,
-0.0885963514,
0.0159668066,
0.0158085898,
-0.0050254371,
0.0201142635,
0.0713052973,
-0.0442807749,
0.0196566172,
-0.0466620326,
-0.0063199997,
0.0083019109,
0.0118445521,
0.0393210724,
0.0380686969,
-0.0145855453,
-0.1183135957,
0.0326224826,
-0.0296860468,
0.0228279401,
0.0444114842,
-0.0150580313,
-0.0111790793,
0.0057018301,
-0.0139660239,
0.0397170335,
0.0171615779,
-0.0903702006,
-0.0060105589,
0.0609958172,
-0.0148444073,
-0.0474722423,
-0.064529404,
-0.0095654214,
0.0024442743,
0.012507027,
-0.0296699256,
-0.003780813,
0.0613310561,
-0.0330604538,
0.013132615,
-0.0147267831,
0.0097741885,
-0.0479081236,
-0.0221139248,
-0.0164470598,
-0.0819618627,
0.0355545357,
0.0047640405,
0.0195099171,
0.0242389906,
0.0337748975,
0.0358594097,
0.0273275618,
-0.0050135627,
-0.0106489491,
0.0365369581,
0.0365168005,
-0.0229854789,
-0.0534684435,
0.0222276822,
0.0447654538,
0.0227366425,
-0.00097621,
0.0065071499,
-0.003816101,
0.0061786855,
-0.0029879462,
-0.0053660884,
-0.001107809,
-0.0106355147,
0.0473405942,
0.0526848324,
0.027606288,
-0.0173322968,
0.0630883649,
0.0162724499,
-0.0401833467,
-0.0260039344,
0.0036916006,
0.0049502291,
-0.075169377,
0.0173750259,
0.0180782191,
0.0092953239,
-0.0157740321,
-0.0739483684,
-0.0274986289,
-0.0399452373,
0.0055872635,
-0.0237515625,
0.0670100152,
-0.0247278269,
-0.0234965011,
-0.0085571241,
0.0563026667,
-0.036835473,
0.0577265918,
0.0420903414,
0.0551075824,
-0.0134915272,
-0.013487027,
0.0186421182,
0.0647709817,
-0.0533185042,
-0.0513663851,
0.0444582626,
0.0645911098,
0.0107910866,
0.0335030258,
-0.0037210216,
-0.0257546697,
0.0213725176,
-0.0125401514,
-0.0205547009,
0.0047800206,
-0.0499846525,
-0.0239508245,
0.0192081425,
-0.041950684,
-0.004895214,
0.0234018154,
-0.0403989218,
0.0435321964,
-0.0085812947,
-0.0202938784,
-0.0334145837,
-0.060436368,
0.0003048429,
0.0158202332,
-0.0041944231,
-0.0372878984,
-0.0503060147,
-0.0351269431,
-0.0133750523,
0.012354916,
0.011115632,
-0.0150865987,
-0.007701871,
0.0603174083,
-0.0273342561,
-0.0333564132,
-0.0267345291,
0.0115294289,
0.0075221094,
0.0093209492,
-0.0167371277,
-5.892460409e-33,
0.0055827103,
-0.0485406369,
0.0016423101,
0.0025530728,
-0.0184316002,
-0.00507859,
-0.0220920853,
0.0221117157,
-0.0564374849,
-0.0061712116,
-0.0113226073,
0.0149003686,
-0.0066042105,
-0.0354384184,
-0.0264898036,
-0.0241876692,
0.0079211602,
-0.0056300536,
-0.0400828905,
0.034369912,
-0.0250158254,
-0.0395228453,
0.048217684,
-0.0241580661,
0.0498830825,
-0.0088552553,
-0.0358460546,
-0.0285412967,
-0.0537442081,
-0.0331531838,
-0.0030266182,
0.028510347,
0.045274388,
0.0008956156,
0.0222882982,
0.0558449961,
0.0360410921,
-0.0199363716,
0.0189875923,
-0.0385449529,
-0.00393085,
-0.0882905945,
-0.0068738628,
-0.0474173836,
-0.0604175888,
-0.0118542658,
0.0340756923,
-0.0103042712,
0.0656945333,
-0.0082394974,
-0.0291579496,
-0.0288658962,
-0.0260427557,
0.0060563507,
-0.0615959167,
0.0517749265,
0.000679943,
-0.0199163221,
-0.0798076242,
0.0871762261,
-0.0048491121,
-0.0513393432,
0.043243058,
-0.0332079083,
0.0301582739,
0.057920035,
0.0425782874,
0.0349355489,
-0.0559521131,
-0.0228461809,
0.0328358486,
-0.006468561,
0.0716468915,
0.0250760745,
-0.0140957376,
-0.0611854158,
-0.0103845913,
0.0158900321,
0.0540954433,
-0.0000181943,
0.0288178474,
-0.021059176,
-0.0979212597,
0.0019206232,
0.024087213,
0.008442279,
-0.0299986154,
-0.0267124865,
0.0449828319,
-0.0275341049,
0.0022310428,
-0.0762738585,
0.0347306281,
-0.0323752426,
0.029176062,
-0.0465948284,
-0.0085786143,
0.004418836,
0.0002126767,
0.0125591811,
0.0301847029,
-0.0186097119,
0.0518524498,
0.0460175239,
0.0644796565,
-0.0124515817,
-0.0141513366,
0.031618759,
-0.0217263866,
-0.0173202232,
-0.0060252682,
0.0405753851,
0.0330742635,
-0.0559911057,
0.0372229889,
-0.0080659511,
0.0074480283,
-0.0527958982,
0.0047857282,
-0.0272255689,
-0.0763918608,
0.0647169501,
-0.0691739097,
-0.0101702698,
-0.0128633063,
-0.0179296006,
-0.0405033976,
0.0459569357,
-0.017607335,
-0.0101543963,
-0.0288053546,
-0.0391598828,
2.942e-7,
-0.0706848428,
0.0318704434,
-0.0272952579,
0.0194744933,
-0.0067983335,
0.0356014371,
-0.0063973148,
0.0568199903,
0.0546469837,
-0.0031410134,
0.0232452471,
0.0039841277,
0.0481734313,
0.0035319547,
-0.0672228262,
0.000504831,
0.0075373948,
-0.0175113399,
-0.0527964719,
0.0525661893,
0.0609989017,
0.0274965372,
0.0311549399,
-0.0281134527,
0.0237387437,
-0.0493088141,
-0.0301170833,
-0.0537474044,
0.018629659,
-0.0168298557,
0.0142085273,
0.0122303953,
-0.0089815119,
0.0651693642,
0.0017124919,
-0.0120521281,
-0.0236082803,
0.0397967175,
-0.0244486257,
0.0005166935,
-0.025917083,
-0.0103584696,
0.0298488401,
-0.0527424142,
0.0608644634,
0.0146091906,
-0.0421935618,
0.0201275628,
-0.0148489764,
-0.0559453405,
0.0146152163,
-0.0205806177,
-0.0562788658,
0.0276107844,
0.0249930918,
-0.0091928495,
0.0345355459,
-0.0149624972,
0.0322537832,
-0.0111498069,
-0.0230861213,
-0.0921074674,
-0.0254777167,
0.0415433645,
0.0225965548,
-0.0503820777,
0.0206588041,
2.130841339e-34,
-0.0288342051,
-0.0014917665,
0.0410504565,
-0.0258894991,
0.0745374784,
0.0628550351,
0.0429396853,
-0.0058503379,
0.0419862904,
-0.0355374627,
0.0175065435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20204v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20204v3 | General-Purpose Retrieval-Enhanced Medical Prediction Model Using Near-Infinite History | 2023-10-31T06:04:18 | 2024-03-20T10:52:03 | Junu Kim, Chaeeun Shim, Bosco Seong Kyu Yang, Chami Im, Sung Yoon Lim, Han-Gil Jeong, Edward Choi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Developing clinical prediction models (e.g., mortality prediction) based on
electronic health records (EHRs) typically relies on expert opinion for feature
selection and adjusting observation window size. This burdens experts and
creates a bottleneck in the development process. We propose Retrieval-Enhanced
Medical prediction model (REMed) to address such challenges. REMed can
essentially evaluate an unlimited number of clinical events, select the
relevant ones, and make predictions. This approach effectively eliminates the
need for manual feature selection and enables an unrestricted observation
window. We verified these properties through experiments on 27 clinical tasks
and two independent cohorts from publicly available EHR datasets, where REMed
outperformed other contemporary architectures that aim to handle as many events
as possible. Notably, we found that the preferences of REMed align closely with
those of medical experts. We expect our approach to significantly expedite the
development of EHR prediction models by minimizing clinicians' need for manual
involvement. | [
0.0339794941,
0.0866392106,
-0.0229193177,
-0.0713028163,
-0.0102315564,
0.0065259035,
0.0056059402,
0.0306263287,
0.0452717394,
0.0328076109,
0.0331466645,
-0.0479008593,
-0.0347635224,
0.0600394234,
-0.0461477526,
-0.0290293582,
0.0162273031,
0.0290792808,
0.0430657603,
0.010654076,
-0.0302891694,
-0.0356396511,
0.0079876613,
0.0572874509,
0.0134131508,
0.0352110937,
-0.0019263832,
-0.0152413324,
-0.0169495977,
-0.0805050135,
0.0245071575,
-0.0095355995,
0.0036699912,
-0.0412840769,
0.0000020769,
-0.0556206517,
-0.0394248329,
0.0147836953,
-0.0832472146,
-0.0730200261,
0.0035483376,
-0.0310664941,
0.0327121094,
-0.0154052153,
-0.0383195505,
-0.0548247024,
0.020189628,
0.0346365869,
0.0133070285,
0.0259549376,
-0.0112887211,
0.0354172476,
0.0387638956,
-0.0409978665,
0.047323402,
-0.0188117605,
0.0339116491,
-0.0546016544,
0.0311861876,
-0.0496348627,
0.020480752,
0.0495701581,
0.004797007,
0.0738939866,
0.0486886092,
0.0288465433,
0.00338588,
-0.0026596868,
-0.0353442356,
0.0049691997,
0.014557221,
-0.0156582706,
0.0417224504,
0.0143167255,
-0.0197003987,
0.0003144357,
-0.0419050679,
-0.0291176662,
-0.0268491879,
-0.0051159011,
-0.0201561283,
0.0290564261,
0.030874813,
0.0024218541,
-0.0056200945,
-0.0092791738,
-0.0007456518,
-0.0078031896,
-0.0024708041,
-0.0090322383,
0.0424186662,
0.0169021618,
0.0364088863,
0.0268464852,
-0.0581415966,
-0.0189589411,
0.0323880985,
0.0202527288,
0.0789890662,
0.0011193261,
0.0502532646,
0.0100439331,
0.0227796882,
0.0377732329,
0.0146568157,
-0.0235965829,
-0.0100076795,
-0.0374932587,
-0.014935323,
0.0192208998,
-0.0487477481,
0.0006684739,
0.018031843,
0.052470088,
0.0476825386,
0.0334972404,
-0.0693910047,
-0.0243210308,
-0.0149544002,
-0.0073578628,
0.0245472863,
0.0697088912,
-0.040504247,
0.0048694825,
-0.0591583475,
-0.0153396903,
0.0078932438,
0.0006110434,
-0.0020217334,
-0.0301124789,
0.0198100004,
-0.0239683799,
-0.0003295674,
-0.017082952,
0.0407596976,
0.0532214157,
0.0295719188,
-0.0213551037,
-0.0129525587,
-0.048893597,
-0.0066020573,
-0.000499715,
0.0002349204,
-0.0296444409,
0.0153466165,
0.0035161984,
-0.0286890939,
-0.042140495,
0.0059226202,
-0.013049094,
-0.039318461,
0.0102526955,
-0.0179841835,
0.0186202265,
0.0296127759,
-0.0086893598,
-0.021514805,
-0.0158986673,
-0.0014405247,
-0.0116001302,
0.0098683266,
0.0122564882,
0.0414153561,
-0.0154256783,
0.0323979594,
-0.0500336252,
-0.0053640469,
0.0327197611,
-0.0301706214,
0.0414038152,
-0.0639017448,
0.0206140559,
0.0181158576,
-0.0633531064,
0.0211280826,
0.0387738198,
0.0467890389,
0.0214426201,
-0.0112450104,
-0.0478041023,
-0.0238568112,
-0.057667844,
-0.0133300535,
0.0323214382,
-0.004724842,
-0.0047638654,
-0.0088579748,
-0.024727013,
-0.037237186,
-0.0346091352,
0.0018237762,
-0.0160075761,
-0.0222043376,
0.0064933007,
0.0503922664,
-0.0409905948,
-0.018089164,
0.0599407181,
0.0231945422,
-0.015143102,
-0.0470584594,
-0.0664948374,
-0.0193512514,
0.0634448603,
0.0523208752,
-0.0524264611,
-0.0355226025,
-0.0079582511,
0.0041031982,
-0.0921085924,
0.035435807,
0.0004053487,
0.0236570239,
-0.0090951985,
-0.019869376,
0.0741993189,
0.0226249006,
-0.0253150612,
0.0090119271,
0.0282427184,
-0.0060243146,
-0.038511049,
-0.0293511804,
0.0144205112,
-0.0680232048,
0.0000564577,
0.0300581791,
0.0101879574,
0.0455392003,
-0.0101093194,
-0.00847572,
0.0295176264,
0.0604182296,
-0.0594612211,
-0.0346361436,
-0.0080402512,
-0.0504738539,
0.0090464344,
-0.0253981631,
-0.0182299986,
0.0386313498,
-0.0276750773,
-0.014434821,
-0.0394377671,
-0.0245705843,
-0.039498385,
0.0289880261,
-0.029991053,
0.0085995216,
0.0109457886,
-0.0481441543,
-0.0305281468,
0.0201502647,
-0.0229975767,
-0.0280202851,
-0.0068531204,
-0.0807690173,
0.0251264367,
-0.0551471747,
-0.0237973686,
-0.0028898811,
-0.0276031569,
-0.0001347462,
0.0377568826,
-0.0411010683,
-0.0329819173,
-0.0153196603,
-0.1113553718,
0.035134688,
0.0059908712,
0.0097994916,
-0.0426120572,
0.0296949577,
-0.0153521085,
-0.041832041,
-0.0179829225,
-0.0250628013,
0.0132650966,
0.0405349359,
0.024388399,
0.0564782768,
0.0072897756,
-0.020153651,
-0.0216275603,
-0.0127410693,
0.0469450057,
0.0054284418,
-0.0290528461,
0.0430584848,
-0.0018928022,
-0.030143369,
-0.00040665,
-0.0279868301,
0.0207458641,
-0.0036084189,
-0.0660330504,
-0.0312884226,
0.0502874181,
-0.0048155892,
0.0123332106,
0.0194098484,
0.0019623251,
-0.0433028713,
0.026987223,
-0.0827300996,
-0.0293181054,
0.055923745,
-0.0003176685,
-0.027687652,
-0.0034309125,
0.0153374719,
0.0103208199,
-0.0266146865,
0.0136197293,
-0.0104614887,
0.0271311216,
-0.0696065351,
0.0380131826,
-0.030833168,
0.0229196046,
-0.0311800446,
-0.0733843595,
0.0702597275,
0.0697095022,
0.0564818047,
0.0102044912,
-0.0128116654,
-0.0524893813,
0.0313214846,
-0.0136848511,
-0.0004911915,
-0.0145104611,
0.0007541445,
-0.0063067232,
0.0286384355,
-0.0162957776,
-0.0797021762,
0.0415306352,
0.0044922424,
0.0342304334,
0.0362728126,
-0.0476161204,
-0.0414704345,
-0.0340326764,
0.0031915337,
0.002211395,
-0.0523148179,
0.059590023,
-0.0963201374,
0.0111747021,
-0.0123016229,
0.0593100302,
-0.0015190853,
-0.031837523,
0.0385161452,
-0.0051492858,
0.0095169479,
-0.0308181457,
-0.0271488801,
-0.0219763871,
0.045869153,
0.055739481,
0.0508658253,
0.0220400859,
-0.0104964096,
0.0298348255,
-0.0048136273,
-0.0326838009,
-0.0308479797,
0.0648981482,
-0.0123890452,
-0.0663933456,
0.0247899983,
0.0467353202,
0.0408914946,
-0.0744680092,
0.0001094488,
0.0049821478,
0.0026010119,
-0.002144811,
-0.0002196067,
-0.0125741558,
-0.0281939022,
0.0151018826,
0.0351402611,
-0.0261176769,
-0.0676055476,
0.0542660877,
-0.0180797912,
0.0455993004,
-0.0047394806,
0.0203185175,
-0.0130298808,
-0.0666150674,
0.0298433248,
-0.0347834192,
-0.068956092,
0.0116956923,
-0.0269304477,
-0.0204616021,
0.0083539374,
-0.0867368206,
-0.0393904559,
0.0658792853,
-0.006841104,
0.0034033032,
0.0615152381,
0.0198557433,
-0.002889693,
-0.0252279714,
-0.0398715362,
0.0277869515,
0.0566898286,
-0.0272081345,
0.1251645684,
0.0467780307,
0.0231887233,
-0.053371001,
0.0182307363,
-0.0022687982,
-0.0043775076,
0.0186989438,
0.1048190221,
-0.0695006028,
-0.0427155234,
-0.0598614216,
-0.0509843118,
0.028079858,
0.0275234394,
-0.0329405107,
-0.0222750176,
-0.070285432,
0.0451909192,
0.0500323996,
0.0170113519,
0.0002561218,
0.0244726706,
-0.005786832,
-0.0179317519,
-0.015054971,
-0.0257222895,
-0.0285271574,
0.0158952046,
0.0169426166,
0.0192892905,
0.0180045366,
0.0026994974,
-0.0851296261,
0.0435421057,
0.018864708,
0.0000868616,
-0.0310749207,
0.0123380898,
0.064504534,
0.0087154256,
-0.0100597199,
-0.0042242184,
0.0001275673,
0.0150066419,
0.0027302015,
0.0604817867,
0.0228160899,
0.0023871036,
0.0178824328,
-0.0003635947,
0.0997422859,
0.0372389257,
-0.0377814174,
-0.0306319054,
-0.0096003274,
-0.053336367,
-0.0304004215,
0.0152487382,
-0.0142106023,
0.0344733745,
-0.0222534463,
-0.0157172363,
-0.0178786833,
-0.0176649857,
-0.0073253233,
0.03450666,
0.0756257921,
0.0301700588,
-0.0268576648,
-0.0032337005,
0.0388807282,
0.0123312864,
0.0298868008,
-0.0211848859,
0.0329316668,
0.0031826668,
0.0190592036,
0.0003702266,
0.030478552,
0.0098641999,
-0.0636492446,
-0.0753104091,
0.0342095681,
-0.0060704937,
0.0174500234,
0.0490119755,
0.0257799048,
-0.0117042996,
0.0210797098,
0.0099099707,
0.045029968,
-0.0055137794,
0.0191747379,
-0.0217860043,
0.0532852039,
-0.0211067274,
-0.0032322877,
-0.0662352219,
-0.0343827158,
0.0064646886,
-0.0118292263,
0.0421585254,
-0.0064251311,
0.0141228009,
-0.0246072598,
0.0209944751,
-0.054569684,
0.0266571678,
0.0115914047,
0.0346888602,
-0.011787056,
0.0128228683,
-0.0375016704,
0.0056702858,
0.0719595999,
-0.0166080166,
0.0400648303,
-0.0294581708,
-0.0445904024,
-0.0238972474,
-0.0099618807,
0.0821908191,
-0.0116515998,
-0.0142006297,
-0.0537676215,
-0.0511118285,
0.0062182206,
0.1014583707,
-0.0134392781,
-0.0315142982,
-0.0357907861,
0.0405311957,
0.0475399643,
0.0031650548,
0.0090351515,
-0.0150984786,
0.0187735017,
-0.0622569844,
-0.0092883017,
-0.0316413715,
-5.766098807e-33,
0.0480727404,
0.0038061235,
0.0158734657,
-0.045960132,
0.0053421985,
0.0317520201,
-0.0483623147,
-0.0189955346,
0.0366815999,
-0.0211149082,
-0.0336456113,
-0.0126263201,
0.0004602014,
0.0222487058,
0.0543901213,
-0.0333555266,
0.0221743379,
0.0170328896,
0.0067141186,
0.0475876033,
0.0128874807,
0.0639079288,
-0.0227766354,
-0.0685201436,
-0.034036696,
0.0505471453,
0.045262441,
0.0165944658,
-0.0162671059,
0.0520378277,
-0.0086505655,
0.0332934521,
0.0332677811,
-0.0487236157,
-0.0042708563,
-0.0297489427,
-0.0469496623,
-0.0111161685,
-0.0467760786,
-0.0755421594,
0.0062457584,
-0.0157151725,
0.0442724824,
-0.0063481126,
-0.0455583036,
-0.0152280359,
0.0179572031,
-0.0262577962,
-0.0483455323,
-0.0775510073,
0.0770396814,
0.0555070564,
-0.01236137,
0.0141021172,
-0.0174206328,
0.0442317389,
-0.020623548,
0.0248137005,
-0.0514504686,
-0.00720829,
-0.0168849677,
0.0081523238,
-0.0424745381,
-0.0210336559,
-0.0083018942,
0.0958295539,
0.029004436,
-0.0031379752,
-0.0485015325,
-0.0074115475,
-0.0474913195,
0.0424088985,
0.0048031383,
0.0047567124,
0.0641932264,
-0.0611353777,
-0.0899111405,
0.0814825594,
-0.0321450196,
0.0372103527,
0.0510255955,
-0.0170793273,
-0.0679534301,
0.0146272564,
-0.0240546484,
0.0353642814,
-0.0182950255,
-0.0060542538,
0.0559188873,
0.0430980735,
0.0238652583,
0.0467797406,
0.0304953307,
0.0013754847,
0.0274882354,
0.0283421688,
0.0233683567,
-0.0139881838,
-0.0183700807,
0.0101168817,
-0.0071068336,
-0.0087444326,
0.0032374852,
-0.0297104996,
0.0144344755,
-0.0167134665,
0.0098388083,
-0.0114964321,
-0.0512504354,
-0.0321332887,
0.0411321595,
0.0007894498,
-0.0097338874,
-0.0465832986,
0.0484320149,
0.0400100164,
0.0214693155,
0.0706480518,
-0.0074114725,
0.0154730231,
-0.072281979,
-0.0317765735,
0.0269590858,
-0.0295497142,
0.0105169192,
0.0030429368,
-0.0550518371,
0.0351446159,
-0.0007257338,
-0.0213284008,
0.0054222434,
0.0370906033,
2.895e-7,
0.0468981192,
0.0263669789,
0.0013863142,
-0.0308321938,
0.0238697082,
0.0076290686,
-0.0012044816,
-0.0012296867,
0.0271429308,
0.0054373569,
0.0744781718,
0.025030002,
0.0637036711,
0.0407264605,
-0.0666450262,
-0.0416044332,
-0.0450019129,
0.0133761186,
-0.0420353077,
-0.0131506817,
0.0610484928,
0.0456360988,
-0.0205215234,
-0.0252013188,
0.0333201811,
0.0006138867,
0.035099972,
-0.0464638844,
0.0020080386,
-0.0048260838,
0.038888149,
0.0293272268,
-0.0133439796,
0.029578669,
-0.0181920864,
-0.0199256372,
-0.0306695625,
0.0818833932,
-0.0395647846,
-0.0243154131,
0.0437074117,
0.0368206203,
0.0169044677,
0.0330401734,
0.0903112516,
-0.0308435652,
-0.0127719622,
0.0049303668,
-0.0173511747,
0.0340884924,
0.0364713147,
0.0019629879,
-0.022740433,
0.0077456427,
0.0038419687,
0.026840901,
-0.0031052739,
-0.0415075682,
-0.0167415962,
0.0784388185,
-0.0325194672,
-0.0407211334,
0.0112716211,
0.0109486533,
-0.024651086,
-0.0621292405,
0.0314626917,
2.617149551e-34,
0.0277356431,
0.0286220256,
-0.005510313,
-0.0388441086,
0.0117678931,
-0.0187705103,
0.0375763252,
0.0020336113,
0.0191218276,
-0.0556635298,
-0.0318912156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20201v1 | Video-Helpful Multimodal Machine Translation | 2023-10-31T05:51:56 | 2023-10-31T05:51:56 | Yihang Li, Shuichiro Shimizu, Chenhui Chu, Sadao Kurohashi, Wei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing multimodal machine translation (MMT) datasets consist of images and
video captions or instructional video subtitles, which rarely contain
linguistic ambiguity, making visual information ineffective in generating
appropriate translations. Recent work has constructed an ambiguous subtitles
dataset to alleviate this problem but is still limited to the problem that
videos do not necessarily contribute to disambiguation. We introduce EVA
(Extensive training set and Video-helpful evaluation set for Ambiguous
subtitles translation), an MMT dataset containing 852k Japanese-English (Ja-En)
parallel subtitle pairs, 520k Chinese-English (Zh-En) parallel subtitle pairs,
and corresponding video clips collected from movies and TV episodes. In
addition to the extensive training set, EVA contains a video-helpful evaluation
set in which subtitles are ambiguous, and videos are guaranteed helpful for
disambiguation. Furthermore, we propose SAFA, an MMT model based on the
Selective Attention model with two novel methods: Frame attention loss and
Ambiguity augmentation, aiming to use videos in EVA for disambiguation fully.
Experiments on EVA show that visual information and the proposed methods can
boost translation performance, and our model performs significantly better than
existing MMT models. The EVA dataset and the SAFA model are available at:
https://github.com/ku-nlp/video-helpful-MMT.git. | [
0.0540262572,
0.0053798673,
-0.0163843222,
0.0549601801,
0.0116014592,
0.0113875121,
0.0075440849,
0.0244265981,
-0.0206714403,
-0.0553633869,
-0.0324858353,
-0.0125648864,
0.0073954691,
-0.0261259377,
0.0306947436,
-0.1249518618,
0.0527927801,
0.0021926309,
0.0112641593,
0.0258204825,
0.0335906669,
0.0005156168,
0.0126221394,
-0.0247708801,
-0.0606360734,
-0.017018402,
0.0153458593,
0.0495954975,
0.0785147473,
-0.0130370874,
-0.0177070629,
0.0147134122,
0.0458998308,
-0.0036677145,
0.0000020754,
-0.0103087397,
-0.0109142801,
-0.0174947158,
-0.0028832941,
0.0382506587,
0.0335816517,
-0.0425245948,
0.0303473547,
0.0125354519,
0.006743589,
-0.0130229965,
0.0646257177,
-0.0239775386,
0.0852384493,
0.0319474712,
-0.0407965407,
-0.0375867747,
-0.0535505973,
-0.0265320111,
0.0388613269,
-0.0584283695,
-0.0316328146,
0.0072636735,
-0.004921467,
0.0129551636,
-0.0708937123,
0.0720089898,
-0.0068322509,
0.0041059414,
-0.0044293343,
0.0123842135,
-0.0162238348,
-0.0375791192,
-0.005603977,
0.0944158137,
0.0065664747,
0.0291060917,
-0.0342366174,
-0.0186295044,
0.0100278258,
0.0325903371,
-0.0425392203,
0.0263578147,
-0.0013090386,
-0.0227746293,
-0.0088844709,
0.0577093251,
0.0170124397,
-0.0065952092,
0.0247455668,
-0.062708661,
0.0255230926,
-0.0060601197,
-0.041526746,
-0.0136303473,
-0.0650871545,
-0.0117927715,
0.0607127324,
-0.0176829826,
0.0220687985,
0.0342208333,
-0.057209868,
-0.0809357092,
-0.0196409654,
-0.0744021684,
0.0082716243,
0.0466911048,
-0.053179875,
0.0809122473,
-0.0065566762,
0.0471851826,
-0.0211239588,
0.0494958051,
-0.051732067,
-0.015493542,
-0.0523539521,
0.0450211465,
-0.05276867,
0.0007228242,
-0.0352059677,
0.003496909,
-0.0310574602,
-0.018478157,
-0.0390310697,
0.0240475796,
-0.0240547508,
-0.0215879194,
-0.0473644696,
-0.0199523177,
-0.0434033051,
0.0536794774,
-0.0422154889,
0.0138018196,
-0.0321320072,
-0.0464956053,
-0.0312126353,
0.0370103791,
-0.0014574004,
-0.0515502468,
0.0049562515,
0.0717698187,
-0.0423341617,
-0.0389348343,
-0.0107546728,
0.0080124987,
-0.0365376212,
-0.0172340423,
0.0061977911,
-0.0172489099,
0.0702811852,
0.0111106718,
0.0388960801,
-0.0290524233,
0.0118351355,
-0.0105085978,
-0.0152501408,
0.0819187015,
-0.0020194405,
-0.0007623948,
0.0210557822,
0.0205674097,
-0.0426237211,
0.0590953417,
0.0402494818,
0.0292382687,
0.0638864934,
0.0335660018,
0.0079347929,
0.0339914896,
-0.020637868,
0.0243152808,
-0.0049994523,
-0.0007830705,
-0.0180562884,
0.0246158279,
0.0239710603,
0.0389838628,
-0.0217855312,
-0.0101435473,
0.0506174527,
-0.0447155833,
-0.0486092418,
-0.0030922615,
0.0350868851,
0.0501044653,
0.0100795534,
0.0343426205,
-0.0076509211,
0.0701211616,
0.0433793776,
0.0250175633,
0.0265804641,
-0.0031227234,
-0.0482646897,
-0.0435578525,
-0.0308798607,
-0.0224146117,
0.0234510563,
0.0482936278,
0.0339777842,
0.0167871509,
-0.0647008345,
0.0782716721,
-0.0053511439,
-0.0269030724,
0.0549633764,
0.0123953074,
-0.0372646675,
0.1129021868,
0.0100280102,
-0.045090761,
-0.0335067138,
-0.0223986432,
0.0613627546,
0.0301732533,
0.0388027504,
-0.0106504448,
0.0337940007,
-0.0937771425,
-0.0258019753,
0.0183019675,
0.0016554297,
0.0145812109,
-0.0122911148,
0.0212765783,
0.0292628147,
-0.0280334614,
-0.03884257,
0.0299505666,
0.04129209,
0.0013204078,
-0.0440459587,
0.0205976088,
0.0292885583,
0.0276407041,
-0.030037025,
-0.0273002591,
-0.004246287,
-0.0188655034,
0.0145380618,
0.0340287834,
-0.0240302514,
-0.0573315024,
0.016741382,
-0.074391678,
-0.0375228077,
0.0386887603,
-0.0576559193,
-0.0386488326,
-0.0275510773,
-0.0472242869,
-0.0164241251,
-0.0253183115,
0.0292808358,
0.0256255157,
-0.000891901,
-0.0294935573,
0.0208996683,
-0.0117610376,
-0.0045414227,
0.0294813495,
-0.0030046094,
0.0322011635,
-0.0375934355,
-0.0322025977,
0.016009707,
-0.0115889711,
0.0007245262,
0.0238248557,
-0.0059746392,
-0.0685993284,
-0.0227511767,
-0.0352025293,
0.00740036,
-0.0258360039,
0.021137584,
-0.0053197383,
0.0174732711,
-0.0034655379,
-0.0260553062,
0.0464696512,
0.0030270892,
-0.0414274558,
-0.0014985692,
-0.0072547034,
0.020720249,
0.0605983324,
-0.0202571824,
-0.0149812652,
0.0275842194,
0.0248022266,
0.0092304228,
-0.0670168325,
-0.0231324118,
0.0143035678,
-0.0104411049,
-0.020109022,
-0.0125138061,
-0.0452914461,
-0.0135190561,
0.0123142768,
0.0079803336,
0.0276429392,
-0.0058853878,
-0.0064316387,
0.016429456,
-0.0255090408,
-0.005779318,
0.048682157,
0.0261851065,
-0.055332832,
-0.0062550618,
-0.0598115735,
-0.0440768078,
-0.0033554011,
0.0093004946,
0.0153567232,
-0.0556978136,
-0.021665113,
0.0012222863,
0.0017202006,
-0.0027282611,
0.0296572167,
0.0122690005,
0.0039802473,
-0.0437747128,
-0.0356612019,
0.0516497232,
-0.0021244525,
-0.0470736548,
-0.0657204688,
0.0593545772,
-0.0030554021,
0.0440392047,
-0.0235477667,
0.0229783058,
-0.0186782498,
-0.0363675579,
-0.0564834885,
-0.0135294953,
0.0434539728,
-0.0064494167,
0.0557355434,
-0.0389523096,
0.0013015626,
-0.0330430008,
0.0291027613,
-0.0282708034,
-0.0102939093,
-0.001465405,
-0.0221336614,
0.0051456532,
0.0221513677,
-0.0367970206,
0.0094518661,
0.0393376872,
0.0410926603,
0.0198193081,
0.0060054911,
-0.0061584371,
0.0307235271,
0.0162789412,
0.007875829,
-0.0410556309,
-0.0972491056,
0.0395541601,
0.010320195,
-0.0109266089,
-0.0582441352,
-0.002321546,
-0.0019916953,
0.0401658788,
-0.0130629316,
-0.0159778874,
-0.0044930819,
0.0624967404,
-0.0650289059,
0.0372073762,
0.0889509097,
0.0252196994,
-0.0445489548,
-0.0285017584,
0.0152226035,
-0.0280966721,
0.0260084234,
0.0120800231,
-0.0931216925,
-0.0686348826,
-0.0168654323,
0.0114692841,
0.0677392632,
0.0522280522,
-0.0316285715,
-0.0385290906,
0.0617985614,
0.0479636192,
-0.0296976063,
-0.0285574384,
0.0306004416,
-0.0030929667,
-0.0333373882,
0.0130419852,
-0.0271917842,
-0.0082165617,
-0.0016519234,
-0.0036541121,
0.0545296147,
-0.0895260274,
-0.0001206247,
-0.0464614779,
0.0105313864,
0.0109830247,
0.0295681376,
-0.0162293799,
-0.0069467733,
0.0038805315,
-0.0222214926,
0.0041299616,
-0.0388824008,
0.0791984648,
-0.0347897485,
-0.0471253432,
0.0269380398,
-0.0157394037,
0.0408306271,
-0.018339036,
0.0267853849,
0.0405593067,
0.000392518,
0.0092428774,
-0.0348568112,
-0.013989334,
-0.0037625453,
0.0572620519,
-0.0185376387,
-0.0249437578,
0.0220507607,
0.0152778989,
0.0067809597,
-0.0472648703,
0.0621562302,
-0.0163099729,
-0.0774743855,
-0.0150480447,
-0.0643199608,
-0.018421581,
0.0523242019,
0.0011845969,
0.0157960337,
0.0174564403,
0.0169998258,
0.0537356362,
-0.0481342413,
0.0642026141,
-0.0182349719,
0.0097000515,
-0.0299358517,
-0.0490193553,
0.0195664875,
-0.0407729708,
0.007736959,
0.0694532618,
-0.0525501147,
-0.0402609631,
-0.0161883514,
0.0600350238,
0.0129032834,
0.0749411359,
0.0029672554,
-0.0290771686,
-0.0230256934,
-0.0284046102,
0.0221886151,
0.0031698921,
0.0303729177,
-0.0275250375,
-0.0281443056,
0.0140140997,
-0.0374934599,
0.0002284769,
-0.0123689864,
0.0476913601,
-0.0286654197,
0.005214165,
-0.0199181754,
-0.0066110832,
0.01397778,
-0.0445203632,
-0.0018604186,
-0.0437621139,
0.0140499389,
0.0249633174,
0.0159577411,
-0.0599664822,
0.0071644066,
0.0363697633,
-0.0169085078,
-0.0026805934,
0.0489508584,
-0.0319874287,
-0.0568641573,
0.007408842,
0.0271935556,
-0.0322745182,
0.0015276753,
-0.0295435581,
0.0360990278,
0.0250752531,
0.017798556,
0.0065175258,
0.0008907825,
0.0113703646,
0.0766061991,
-0.0034879502,
0.0018557685,
0.006698133,
0.0381809734,
0.0403998792,
0.0168591216,
-0.023627758,
0.0483141169,
0.0651461333,
-0.0408753566,
0.0624209717,
0.0018025576,
-0.0187152326,
-0.0198486,
0.0607344173,
-0.0089932159,
-0.0508806743,
0.0215357393,
-0.0074990392,
0.0172575079,
0.0521353446,
0.0781054273,
0.013111935,
-0.0099353716,
-0.004011034,
-0.0311594792,
-0.036452163,
-0.0067201103,
-0.002146434,
0.0347274132,
-0.0273133218,
0.0241741817,
-0.0279444102,
-0.0583021827,
-0.0110827377,
-0.0436960757,
-0.0132375937,
0.017651042,
0.0497918427,
0.0150245493,
-0.0047625871,
-0.0238756016,
-0.0223048385,
-0.02468987,
-0.0028449099,
-0.0140267108,
-0.030295074,
-5.604376131e-33,
-0.0415985398,
-0.0185912382,
-0.0267849378,
-0.0126180369,
-0.051643841,
0.0233614985,
-0.0215172935,
0.0031067727,
-0.0468395427,
0.0226188116,
0.0494761989,
0.0203241985,
0.0242285822,
0.0321539976,
0.0018166279,
-0.0445652753,
0.0767366216,
0.0078997416,
-0.0141079072,
0.012896792,
0.023102982,
0.0250253472,
0.0778883398,
-0.0469781421,
0.0262652803,
-0.0295214839,
-0.0481024347,
-0.0021522834,
0.0077777505,
0.0639569163,
0.0230664928,
0.0271034651,
0.002883438,
-0.0168145597,
-0.0484069847,
-0.0358246304,
-0.0838271528,
0.0141484262,
0.0481317043,
0.0602380745,
-0.0418004543,
-0.0488318354,
0.0593449883,
-0.0301811714,
0.0208436847,
-0.0370689668,
0.0641324818,
-0.0541842319,
0.0007925512,
0.0046440228,
-0.0249095652,
-0.0020439085,
-0.0488743,
-0.0463776477,
0.0713538155,
0.0231680777,
0.0283812899,
0.0361872874,
-0.0657985583,
0.0168060958,
-0.0011741959,
0.0343844593,
0.085736312,
0.0085774064,
-0.0335119367,
-0.0191627312,
0.0017866998,
-0.046790041,
0.0388184078,
-0.0351279527,
-0.0032014137,
0.01847969,
0.0678543523,
0.0181236193,
0.0453461036,
-0.0118850004,
-0.0338474028,
0.0089133931,
-0.0706173033,
0.061134059,
0.0246010888,
0.0166693553,
-0.0207830947,
0.0156468991,
-0.0432136469,
-0.0149503909,
-0.0293368753,
-0.0344372094,
0.013465845,
0.0057982695,
0.0002194519,
0.0009175675,
0.0907994732,
-0.0070678061,
0.0329490192,
-0.0058557675,
-0.0054292041,
0.0635557473,
0.0015651938,
0.0140939597,
-0.008280267,
-0.0029927159,
0.0385646261,
0.0011205504,
-0.0011927047,
-0.0134112155,
0.0342700854,
0.0355067924,
-0.001237819,
0.0158680957,
-0.0023319165,
-0.0367449261,
-0.0414930545,
0.0143924206,
-0.004428959,
0.0378518254,
-0.0446626432,
0.0530467518,
0.0252843592,
0.0163985677,
-0.0125210322,
-0.0322395824,
-0.0169942547,
0.0292233042,
-0.0457382314,
0.0482959896,
-0.0207897611,
-0.0332435593,
-0.0088861808,
-0.0532510579,
-0.0371673033,
0.0313462764,
2.657e-7,
0.041913271,
0.0360901356,
-0.0052075693,
0.0244121961,
0.0083245039,
0.0257907342,
-0.0175926518,
0.0125054903,
0.024192106,
-0.0148353232,
0.0476135239,
0.0277908985,
0.0470160469,
-0.0308914464,
-0.054709807,
-0.0108215809,
0.0148441559,
0.0275764316,
-0.0201984886,
0.0273222551,
0.077123329,
0.1213728487,
0.0088014277,
0.0238584895,
-0.0186213031,
-0.0217524599,
0.0743120089,
0.0062027709,
-0.0412954278,
0.0189435277,
0.0454569794,
0.0281898044,
-0.0784095079,
0.0066518816,
-0.03526631,
-0.0419104882,
0.0923976824,
0.061075449,
-0.0226665046,
0.0014814228,
-0.0378397666,
0.0411481932,
-0.0207646657,
-0.0140418196,
0.0462655276,
-0.0396167375,
-0.0035784557,
0.046799317,
-0.0279133804,
0.0507615395,
0.0221531186,
-0.0288188756,
-0.0506300963,
0.0170870665,
0.0293817278,
0.0034445594,
-0.0783597678,
-0.0507955179,
-0.0205072146,
-0.0085868184,
-0.0184135828,
-0.010499021,
-0.0109463437,
-0.0115423854,
0.0173810571,
-0.0140123265,
-0.0422340743,
1.845056163e-34,
0.0567622036,
-0.0270200633,
-0.0098569421,
-0.0294530895,
0.0079706758,
-0.0313656218,
-0.0940414146,
0.0032907515,
-0.0122853136,
-0.0161018707,
-0.0181078948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20195v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20195v2 | Generating Continuations in Multilingual Idiomatic Contexts | 2023-10-31T05:40:33 | 2023-11-04T04:15:18 | Rhitabrat Pokharel, Ameeta Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The ability to process idiomatic or literal multiword expressions is a
crucial aspect of understanding and generating any language. The task of
generating contextually relevant continuations for narratives containing
idiomatic (or literal) expressions can allow us to test the ability of
generative language models (LMs) in understanding nuanced language containing
non-compositional figurative text. We conduct a series of experiments using
datasets in two distinct languages (English and Portuguese) under three
different training settings (zero-shot, few-shot, and fine-tuned). Our results
suggest that the models are only slightly better at generating continuations
for literal contexts than idiomatic contexts, with exceedingly small margins.
Furthermore, the models studied in this work perform equally well across both
languages, indicating the robustness of generative models in performing this
task. | [
0.0119557334,
0.0498791225,
-0.0287419539,
0.0435122922,
-0.0482196771,
-0.004018663,
0.0018335899,
-0.0147452448,
-0.0518482588,
-0.0182930734,
0.0018162826,
-0.0494002923,
0.0068558883,
0.0109196054,
0.0566002056,
-0.0434556641,
0.0183632039,
0.00053167,
-0.0148678469,
-0.0261895154,
-0.0173066854,
0.0313653052,
0.0104469173,
0.0499807037,
-0.0215916876,
-0.0092674484,
0.017113518,
0.0083214063,
0.035852775,
0.0009012894,
-0.0225011222,
-0.0076891915,
0.0163534973,
-0.0032336239,
0.0000018424,
-0.080073826,
0.000844442,
-0.0249622501,
0.0084081246,
-0.0137682259,
0.0637774989,
-0.0214851331,
0.0007435,
-0.0352607518,
-0.0331131108,
0.0348778255,
0.0287965238,
0.0235797837,
0.0037385076,
0.052322004,
-0.0044463989,
-0.0840085447,
-0.0049783308,
-0.0515546463,
0.0162363518,
-0.0288841315,
0.0171842761,
-0.0195354689,
-0.0293337759,
-0.0342594609,
-0.0736501515,
0.034592025,
0.0348769799,
0.0098134857,
-0.0693040341,
0.0605441406,
0.0033714462,
-0.0048155435,
0.0016560393,
0.0439037308,
0.0050304276,
-0.0307202637,
-0.0276125073,
-0.0290586818,
-0.0018088123,
-0.0325089507,
-0.0670487061,
0.0583825521,
-0.0017792857,
0.0375753529,
0.0746450573,
-0.0078810789,
0.0000039363,
0.0199734941,
-0.020462282,
-0.0166458171,
0.0435471795,
0.012617073,
-0.0210114326,
-0.0155698275,
-0.0423624888,
-0.0281413682,
-0.0168532934,
0.0035018343,
-0.00504384,
0.0502541736,
-0.0454523005,
0.0054067457,
0.0085456977,
-0.0608960763,
0.0167459808,
0.0370117165,
-0.0175176598,
0.0360616595,
-0.0307812113,
-0.0053608264,
-0.0011098878,
0.0380841643,
-0.0228587408,
-0.0186853856,
-0.0321030095,
-0.0027168293,
-0.0345244072,
0.0167667735,
-0.0355894268,
-0.012544903,
-0.0507143699,
0.0125197554,
0.0243715998,
-0.0318836868,
-0.0373952016,
0.0100986073,
-0.072173439,
-0.0153081976,
-0.0146864448,
0.001752584,
-0.0629367307,
0.0438709296,
0.0158368014,
-0.0561479516,
-0.0243714079,
0.0140628247,
0.0047241971,
-0.0349490382,
0.0006826026,
0.0302396454,
-0.005316902,
-0.0467628092,
-0.0521610752,
-0.054615166,
-0.038075339,
-0.0790330023,
-0.0218272321,
-0.0557092354,
0.0564889461,
-0.006030303,
0.008944164,
-0.1017538607,
0.0125878239,
0.0047200802,
-0.035256952,
0.0410701334,
0.0170829128,
0.0050083147,
-0.0312583186,
-0.0024475839,
-0.0133097516,
0.0766578466,
0.0547184683,
-0.0162596647,
0.0528761409,
0.0302435253,
-0.0334755182,
0.0132811842,
-0.0022179803,
0.0076768631,
-0.0605150014,
-0.0053419014,
-0.0055050654,
0.0445146374,
0.0459404513,
0.0585954264,
-0.035131678,
0.0081231585,
0.0256917942,
0.0189698171,
0.0259266589,
0.0070636775,
0.1584263295,
-0.0277005844,
-0.0148804393,
0.0701716915,
-0.0001649823,
-0.0409187824,
0.0031473916,
0.031084815,
-0.0105681457,
0.0400751159,
-0.0200371854,
-0.0340748616,
0.0160393156,
-0.0143942256,
-0.0070903408,
-0.0399139002,
0.0589771047,
0.0432099476,
-0.0399789102,
-0.0003714731,
0.0428676642,
-0.0696300045,
0.0204281136,
-0.0351801999,
0.0439335518,
0.0503875874,
0.0372082032,
0.0267806686,
-0.0334302001,
-0.0046775192,
0.0104616452,
0.0383327641,
0.0130794067,
-0.0039518103,
0.0699184239,
-0.0310999639,
0.0278538987,
-0.0321271084,
0.0237069596,
0.0244112145,
-0.0346222408,
0.0334430262,
0.0122899134,
-0.0459620915,
-0.0041320515,
0.0483043715,
-0.0754861608,
-0.0038608799,
0.0173098594,
0.0060784714,
0.0061086472,
0.0090486892,
-0.0105421944,
0.0014103553,
0.0266474485,
-0.0513607971,
-0.0264036618,
0.0929660946,
-0.0763671994,
-0.063963525,
0.0171909146,
-0.0705458447,
0.0013230473,
-0.0755005777,
-0.0005266063,
-0.0439687185,
0.027294917,
-0.0252793171,
0.0405689105,
-0.0522315241,
0.00957435,
0.0065613966,
0.0403880961,
-0.0058168708,
0.0809746981,
-0.0001418724,
0.0371163078,
-0.000154334,
0.004597431,
0.0104928659,
-0.0146642001,
0.0313913524,
0.0151381865,
-0.0052586626,
-0.024606118,
0.0121123409,
0.0139546264,
-0.0243746452,
-0.0183197688,
-0.0885103941,
0.0231718104,
-0.0118563911,
0.010427095,
0.0393087454,
0.0083818883,
-0.0282110143,
0.018785568,
0.0142209874,
-0.0395139121,
0.0167838447,
0.0116958627,
0.0134110246,
0.0275587253,
-0.0275236946,
-0.0296332464,
0.0253019612,
-0.0266282074,
0.0779094547,
0.0041910792,
0.0279502776,
-0.0140300663,
0.0022796562,
-0.0559859984,
-0.0156621747,
-0.0283784531,
-0.0374555923,
0.0334619209,
0.0294130761,
0.1134487987,
0.0512313731,
0.0178432614,
0.0288524497,
0.0292952098,
-0.0363012664,
-0.0207701866,
-0.0057397103,
-0.0196092185,
-0.022793008,
-0.0439290442,
-0.0349609107,
0.0005366326,
0.0699171871,
0.0630213171,
-0.0034903949,
-0.0466203168,
0.0333468504,
0.0121108815,
-0.0268205125,
0.0438509211,
0.0133863725,
-0.0324903131,
0.0502848439,
-0.0019317253,
-0.0028549735,
0.0605266839,
-0.0294383392,
-0.0187721066,
-0.0029560504,
-0.0028078798,
-0.0147638777,
0.0943330452,
-0.0185168348,
0.0266148038,
0.0266335886,
-0.0105035026,
-0.0433664732,
-0.0036479998,
0.0381571949,
0.0049357167,
0.0464392602,
-0.0498491675,
-0.0226963423,
0.0065861344,
0.0015828831,
-0.0372835547,
-0.0562004521,
-0.0112388805,
-0.0023490728,
0.0168330688,
0.0516732596,
0.010322433,
-0.0059133242,
0.0093456991,
0.0162193831,
-0.0224696174,
-0.018752763,
-0.0231171213,
0.0330555402,
0.0379181616,
-0.0079090726,
-0.0039410195,
-0.0419280827,
0.064120926,
-0.0060366257,
-0.0652454793,
0.0047379625,
0.005730798,
0.0064586904,
0.0020174417,
-0.0299421232,
-0.0628284216,
0.0130804237,
0.0498703085,
-0.0356193557,
-0.0412367508,
0.0661422685,
0.0254108664,
-0.0083870953,
0.0596994385,
-0.0210837368,
0.037693508,
0.0329143293,
-0.0144110201,
-0.088468276,
-0.0218946207,
0.0217748862,
-0.0361863598,
-0.0123412814,
-0.0345682614,
-0.0472657718,
-0.1249851733,
0.0474936515,
0.0047793123,
-0.0538005382,
-0.0012631477,
-0.0000864762,
-0.0024014239,
0.0216312688,
0.0103380838,
0.024429081,
-0.0270003546,
0.0085795904,
-0.0261751246,
0.0191843417,
-0.0648447201,
0.0012378533,
-0.0226322263,
-0.0131860022,
0.0380785353,
0.0428039692,
0.0168580078,
0.0091102272,
0.00623842,
-0.0273305625,
-0.0027237413,
-0.0076668807,
0.0041038818,
-0.0053478614,
0.008301056,
0.026696682,
0.0592584983,
0.0096886335,
-0.0375212021,
0.0305495244,
0.0343268402,
-0.0151080666,
-0.0553285368,
-0.0128232371,
0.0149084926,
-0.0226563159,
0.081509769,
0.0712227151,
-0.0567767583,
-0.0110666472,
-0.0126721896,
0.0063807266,
-0.0547330752,
-0.0015691032,
-0.0111012189,
-0.041043099,
-0.0046347221,
-0.0715209991,
-0.0638151392,
0.0182790644,
0.0408645123,
0.0022740585,
0.0016338014,
-0.0703564361,
-0.0209345091,
-0.0189046729,
-0.0142394258,
-0.0268334597,
0.0094387289,
-0.0290130842,
0.0182519332,
0.0395147316,
-0.0428879857,
-0.02198915,
0.0492176339,
-0.0542984493,
-0.0857206732,
-0.0252401493,
0.0387464426,
0.0184544828,
0.0351253226,
-0.0131928492,
-0.0170103144,
-0.020733932,
0.0477746166,
-0.007932514,
0.0427376553,
0.0172231086,
0.0487677567,
0.0285611842,
0.0652059466,
-0.0009902985,
0.043686334,
0.0103507265,
0.1008642539,
-0.0055479067,
-0.0043447097,
0.0278968923,
-0.0214517433,
0.0084284823,
-0.0891866684,
-0.0470496975,
-0.0335161611,
-0.0108943069,
-0.0721469671,
-0.0326956697,
-0.0230634604,
0.0357894078,
0.0348372944,
0.0044517512,
-0.0365351252,
-0.0513443686,
-0.0666185692,
0.0276799258,
-0.0221357625,
-0.0210614838,
0.068055898,
-0.0414209366,
-0.0132094994,
0.0332975164,
-0.0112977512,
-0.0090964492,
-0.0498932637,
0.0297497921,
-0.038065657,
0.0307950266,
0.0121675087,
0.0081073847,
0.0063143619,
-0.0169328824,
0.0174313225,
0.0381777398,
-0.0048920056,
0.0187332407,
0.075165309,
-0.0008582242,
0.0602466539,
-0.0175458305,
0.0222191755,
0.002480092,
0.0503696203,
-0.0025616821,
-0.0669713616,
0.0016150209,
0.0122090057,
-0.0295978542,
0.0062139146,
0.0677356198,
-0.0350898989,
0.044941213,
0.006647585,
0.0349779055,
-0.0330878347,
-0.0366834812,
0.01381269,
0.0181253664,
0.0226829723,
0.0115450714,
-0.0782939494,
-0.0569628067,
0.0469691381,
0.0131446607,
0.0175106768,
-0.0014884594,
0.0155058159,
0.0599958859,
-0.0117638297,
0.0317784213,
-0.0488921106,
0.0020897081,
-0.0021161737,
-0.0070752394,
-0.0525256544,
-5.726686318e-33,
-0.0602950826,
0.015018723,
0.0135118356,
-0.0187762417,
-0.0419369601,
-0.0089532519,
-0.0795930177,
0.0191907752,
0.0105555272,
0.0217346232,
-0.0043248688,
-0.0094210282,
0.0030089396,
0.032030914,
0.0243154783,
0.0311882123,
0.0189011097,
0.040138334,
-0.0358570553,
-0.0045133182,
0.0558706298,
0.0256140176,
0.0748936608,
-0.0079431618,
0.0330632627,
-0.0091415262,
-0.037424501,
0.017186489,
0.0157984011,
0.0557670034,
-0.0091670714,
0.0487113521,
0.0194246043,
0.0249711778,
-0.0194535889,
-0.0292054694,
-0.043667309,
-0.0359305479,
0.0888492614,
-0.0148708001,
-0.0152906626,
-0.0452237949,
0.0596919581,
-0.0237119067,
-0.0003693766,
0.0145408995,
0.030491095,
-0.0258839857,
-0.0006127434,
-0.0406564288,
-0.1132077426,
0.0114017902,
0.0033497694,
-0.0324183516,
-0.038554132,
0.0023685636,
0.0048169917,
0.011220797,
-0.0165520906,
0.0204478931,
-0.0347964577,
0.0118424213,
0.0105186673,
-0.0302997287,
0.0194855537,
0.047077857,
-0.0179660842,
-0.0284585096,
-0.0145188496,
0.0210074373,
0.0520302206,
0.0502068996,
-0.0080421148,
0.0752881914,
0.038434431,
-0.0147478227,
-0.0382661968,
-0.0199076645,
0.0248838626,
0.0211605635,
0.0157762952,
-0.0092387218,
-0.0046653054,
-0.001884582,
-0.054728549,
-0.0425928496,
0.0124935759,
-0.0396355987,
0.0193773527,
-0.0101854512,
-0.0041591441,
-0.0106557198,
0.0380221531,
-0.0319545381,
-0.0065666754,
0.0101507977,
-0.0762081593,
0.0253861155,
0.0154281426,
0.0382366218,
-0.0102181146,
-0.0176233202,
0.0031357636,
0.0353289694,
0.0155570442,
-0.0126565946,
0.0610800795,
0.0247456711,
-0.0295526255,
0.0052515808,
-0.0542959645,
0.0081550432,
-0.0652642921,
-0.0339032672,
0.0538854823,
0.0651446357,
-0.0365677811,
0.0077627306,
0.0225167125,
-0.0330940038,
-0.005374053,
-0.0193320252,
-0.0153985638,
0.0673994794,
-0.0534638613,
-0.0038272722,
0.0060218521,
-0.0305562112,
0.0585285947,
-0.0265186299,
-0.0146291349,
0.0291841868,
2.588e-7,
0.0290140193,
0.0209177062,
0.0248461552,
0.0432056673,
-0.0004138857,
-0.0138734467,
-0.0021084261,
-0.0067002368,
-0.0273087099,
-0.0060341666,
0.012950059,
0.028820673,
0.0237445068,
0.0229735803,
-0.0692862943,
0.069370538,
-0.035455469,
0.0410052165,
-0.0503939502,
-0.0161106884,
0.0618615411,
0.0867478177,
0.0104206959,
0.0083507048,
-0.0006406489,
-0.052111879,
0.0904196128,
-0.0166306663,
-0.0054027922,
0.0225528535,
-0.008893705,
0.0378939658,
0.02881529,
-0.0365800448,
0.0197237413,
0.0365106612,
-0.0046861689,
0.0555957146,
-0.0033600421,
0.0131808883,
0.0275629237,
-0.0574525669,
-0.026742667,
-0.0293997321,
0.0520583354,
-0.0508795939,
-0.0098423976,
-0.0179312155,
-0.0044357008,
0.0413424671,
0.0270706732,
-0.0471190624,
-0.0473980047,
0.045768775,
0.0523074307,
0.0020052672,
-0.0201912262,
-0.0455947109,
-0.0254813042,
0.037825305,
-0.0413255319,
0.0183536038,
0.0233936254,
0.0199576449,
-0.0129948314,
-0.0626016557,
-0.0263766628,
2.059787986e-34,
0.057639841,
0.0074543338,
0.0328279659,
0.0295184609,
0.0495296232,
0.001956407,
0.0232699551,
0.032952968,
0.0099665951,
-0.0082929591,
-0.0402581096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20170v1 | DIVKNOWQA: Assessing the Reasoning Ability of LLMs via Open-Domain Question Answering over Knowledge Base and Text | 2023-10-31T04:37:57 | 2023-10-31T04:37:57 | Wenting Zhao, Ye Liu, Tong Niu, Yao Wan, Philip S. Yu, Shafiq Joty, Yingbo Zhou, Semih Yavuz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive generation
capabilities, but they suffer from hallucinations when solely relying on their
internal knowledge, especially when answering questions that require less
commonly known information. Retrieval-augmented LLMs have emerged as a
potential solution to ground LLMs in external knowledge. Nonetheless, recent
approaches have primarily emphasized retrieval from unstructured text corpora,
owing to its seamless integration into prompts. When using structured data such
as knowledge graphs, most methods simplify it into natural text, neglecting the
underlying structures. Moreover, a significant gap in the current landscape is
the absence of a realistic benchmark for evaluating the effectiveness of
grounding LLMs on heterogeneous knowledge sources (e.g., knowledge base and
text). To fill this gap, we have curated a comprehensive dataset that poses two
unique challenges: (1) Two-hop multi-source questions that require retrieving
information from both open-domain structured and unstructured knowledge
sources; retrieving information from structured knowledge sources is a critical
component in correctly answering the questions. (2) The generation of symbolic
queries (e.g., SPARQL for Wikidata) is a key requirement, which adds another
layer of challenge. Our dataset is created using a combination of automatic
generation through predefined reasoning chains and human annotation. We also
introduce a novel approach that leverages multiple retrieval tools, including
text passage retrieval and symbolic language-assisted retrieval. Our model
outperforms previous approaches by a significant margin, demonstrating its
effectiveness in addressing the above-mentioned reasoning challenges. | [
0.0393173397,
0.0216265507,
-0.0029327353,
0.0618052073,
-0.0469990782,
0.0046343557,
-0.0295358449,
0.0111728394,
0.0563132539,
-0.066413641,
-0.0056556198,
0.0093970634,
-0.0589516871,
0.0061419494,
0.0275245644,
0.0130840484,
0.0185640752,
-0.0429735072,
0.0232652668,
-0.0063403728,
-0.0075530312,
0.0472857021,
-0.0152920093,
0.0015298609,
-0.0006831276,
-0.0235865638,
-0.0065305741,
0.015796151,
-0.0081821131,
-0.0187806543,
0.0139496829,
0.0429577902,
0.0427423157,
0.0030475585,
0.0000020962,
-0.0579527617,
-0.0112166218,
0.0055713085,
-0.0397569239,
-0.0305385925,
-0.017146254,
0.0326937474,
0.0493400171,
0.0166221224,
-0.0580711626,
0.0121433362,
-0.0190910548,
0.0330366194,
0.0641188622,
0.0550887026,
0.013979258,
-0.0263325479,
0.0088555515,
0.0157056991,
0.0405089073,
-0.0111237736,
0.01923736,
0.0374701619,
0.0150238285,
0.0060882024,
0.0136276614,
0.0254270229,
0.0122638289,
-0.0110340044,
0.0038924755,
-0.0033355711,
-0.0424781628,
0.0124257486,
0.0122073134,
0.1051447615,
0.0572852343,
-0.0211335272,
0.0173153449,
0.0175372306,
0.0064582326,
0.0451282635,
-0.0546193123,
0.0561124757,
-0.0472330526,
-0.0247726087,
-0.0256304666,
-0.0108974194,
0.0185404103,
0.0083578341,
-0.0299268551,
0.1264160126,
0.0205513686,
-0.0175719801,
0.0348383524,
-0.0163311977,
-0.025983654,
-0.0545144714,
-0.0156790148,
0.0755647644,
-0.0128218895,
0.0491765924,
-0.0086545032,
-0.0033117381,
0.046923358,
-0.0266850442,
0.0014680478,
0.0439120606,
-0.0089188628,
0.0484968983,
-0.0246934742,
0.0348869488,
-0.0200318471,
0.0462626219,
-0.042402368,
-0.0246898308,
-0.0611117519,
-0.0289814752,
-0.0294926446,
0.0437341221,
-0.0384554416,
0.0018460733,
0.0089014573,
0.0230723433,
0.0104271797,
0.0052891304,
0.0412112586,
0.0165840574,
0.0070111114,
-0.0060011712,
-0.0827283114,
0.0358106755,
-0.0290019978,
0.0141960429,
0.0196272321,
-0.0238708816,
-0.0040945183,
0.0161560457,
0.01250361,
-0.0227834713,
0.0215018652,
0.0609148107,
0.0222286507,
-0.0059319381,
-0.0611902811,
-0.0750879794,
0.0032545617,
-0.0435637645,
0.0228445344,
-0.0833906084,
0.0240566041,
0.0374204554,
-0.0474117696,
-0.0400739275,
0.0498007908,
0.072306931,
-0.0285928324,
0.0360458829,
-0.0394247137,
0.0007961543,
0.0404355489,
0.0117926216,
-0.0170997437,
0.0682255328,
0.0236058682,
0.00384484,
0.0645824894,
0.033876244,
-0.0340271033,
0.012550056,
0.0335774608,
0.0255080312,
-0.0110201975,
0.0812902749,
-0.0202514119,
0.0069821347,
0.0052227722,
0.036091689,
-0.0074997363,
-0.0207018461,
0.0191224422,
0.073806487,
0.0066011045,
-0.0386684835,
0.0442272685,
0.0277327765,
0.0289033838,
-0.0136798304,
-0.013031844,
0.0271512214,
-0.0371826999,
0.0177953001,
0.0086792521,
0.0338409021,
-0.0247968026,
-0.0411451869,
-0.0365178809,
0.0096214535,
0.0012503355,
0.0474024974,
0.0635373592,
0.0295752622,
-0.0333915614,
0.1061089188,
0.0357457586,
-0.0723306537,
0.0071599223,
-0.0169920232,
0.0543896593,
0.0454367958,
0.0550968796,
-0.0395627245,
-0.0441771969,
-0.0040518236,
0.025972629,
0.0316486023,
-0.0016653767,
-0.0192335714,
-0.0299626961,
-0.0435177758,
-0.0268662609,
-0.025361266,
-0.0017510926,
-0.0070460546,
0.0294042993,
0.0003924564,
0.034300819,
-0.1024302095,
0.0111113107,
0.0212233327,
-0.0557616577,
-0.0121613396,
-0.0303020068,
0.0012275497,
-0.0148992026,
0.0334654003,
0.0139095606,
0.0498526059,
0.0372639932,
-0.0276547372,
-0.06073175,
-0.012049214,
-0.009920272,
-0.0223412998,
0.0508224405,
-0.0191085935,
0.0011689716,
0.0014880941,
-0.0269778762,
-0.0462396666,
0.0069370968,
-0.0110274395,
0.0207773373,
-0.036782559,
-0.0429332927,
0.0477636866,
-0.0412422046,
-0.047731813,
0.0815953612,
0.0030479976,
0.031422127,
0.0387771651,
-0.0061461953,
0.0482229441,
-0.0281744376,
0.0039398386,
-0.0256463327,
-0.0097775618,
0.0150890853,
0.0222170278,
-0.006860469,
-0.0897892192,
0.0064763986,
-0.0699675009,
0.0334043913,
-0.0285246819,
0.0289151203,
0.021785643,
-0.0049332986,
0.0013183638,
-0.0016836735,
-0.057639692,
0.0320482217,
0.0295850653,
0.0140144769,
0.0270534456,
0.0253575873,
0.0114174895,
-0.014833618,
0.0020153695,
-0.0299418699,
0.0461738594,
0.0016105837,
0.0243305657,
-0.0270167645,
0.0455185138,
-0.078765735,
0.0096649444,
-0.011351929,
0.0072541917,
0.0077350121,
-0.0440137945,
0.0039158901,
0.0308682416,
-0.0062520001,
-0.0173701178,
0.0226280726,
-0.0302064046,
-0.0602647997,
0.0222645421,
0.0067133661,
-0.0014167448,
-0.0118295746,
-0.0250208899,
0.0101469075,
0.0233694222,
0.0150161134,
-0.0141355125,
-0.0445017181,
0.0227528084,
-0.0188141745,
0.0177331474,
-0.0825634226,
-0.0194515754,
0.0171733424,
0.0655951872,
-0.0131203728,
-0.0170222484,
0.0615866482,
-0.0152800344,
0.0204583146,
-0.0117364731,
0.0072634276,
-0.0712715238,
0.0907481313,
-0.0184843596,
0.0091760159,
-0.0145699857,
0.0030933549,
-0.0519241169,
-0.0105834026,
0.0145142637,
-0.0597767532,
0.0505647995,
-0.0511739664,
0.0305490065,
-0.005725313,
0.0002692169,
-0.0304411016,
-0.0000795655,
-0.0263754725,
0.0068121292,
-0.0153792044,
-0.0013186339,
0.0242869817,
-0.0203784686,
0.0327524431,
-0.0107091377,
-0.0066704098,
0.000162112,
-0.0093303733,
0.0514224358,
0.0715285912,
0.0043679532,
0.0042934245,
-0.0116383061,
0.0071508386,
0.0528815538,
0.0319570638,
-0.0268013012,
0.0241529718,
-0.0159524791,
0.0241107289,
-0.0518756211,
0.0051398329,
0.0094604054,
0.0326158591,
-0.0665392056,
-0.0305934921,
0.0998355821,
0.0490144752,
0.00390046,
-0.0172023159,
-0.0566074774,
0.0357895419,
0.0344378576,
0.0389826894,
-0.1176789179,
-0.0391894132,
-0.0128878672,
0.0290691089,
-0.0008663904,
-0.0564384647,
-0.0058673564,
-0.1267363727,
0.0090542529,
-0.0190662295,
-0.0223006532,
-0.0100081153,
-0.0438926816,
-0.0123723708,
0.0107640279,
-0.0325633846,
0.0529557094,
-0.0098487949,
0.0093925213,
0.0061561051,
-0.0027712209,
-0.0000264774,
0.0458194129,
-0.0149767343,
-0.0188363288,
0.0217635185,
0.0317532755,
0.0084464252,
-0.0701606795,
0.0127645209,
-0.0307519846,
0.0038669852,
-0.007290449,
0.0439570509,
0.0129972594,
0.0060458644,
-0.0513704382,
0.0287517998,
-0.0740640089,
-0.0141564012,
0.0250386875,
0.0890572295,
-0.0072949347,
0.01804493,
-0.0201330725,
-0.0000755037,
-0.0030674092,
0.0871268436,
0.0138794156,
0.0119718844,
-0.0248646103,
-0.0307277311,
-0.0075714341,
-0.0291743688,
-0.0579329878,
0.0373782963,
0.0187888388,
0.0430398732,
-0.0742601827,
-0.0417148247,
0.0511331744,
0.0264656637,
-0.0089825513,
0.034815982,
-0.0148419328,
0.0033408117,
-0.0551188327,
0.0464645363,
-0.0734008476,
0.0128373532,
-0.0182387736,
0.0016159734,
0.0101774978,
-0.0519173741,
-0.0365231261,
-0.0101867253,
-0.0532018431,
-0.0600831732,
-0.0561694913,
0.0356719568,
0.0226973314,
-0.0013334596,
-0.0109108714,
-0.012854021,
0.0517101586,
0.0251813773,
-0.0615905635,
-0.0254134666,
-0.0094007067,
0.0209743027,
-0.0028790457,
0.046517849,
-0.0993469059,
-0.0136849247,
-0.0283525474,
0.079276368,
-0.0005055984,
-0.0623738617,
0.0476185866,
0.0462314114,
-0.0195328444,
0.0383420885,
-0.0232789535,
-0.0301513616,
0.0224718563,
-0.0400963426,
-0.0468338579,
-0.0252354052,
0.0362863056,
-0.0169423968,
-0.0685120597,
0.0063045821,
-0.0217335559,
-0.018972287,
0.0608604848,
-0.0172390193,
-0.0099291168,
0.0473080687,
0.0165545102,
0.0178047679,
-0.0376063399,
-0.0238315165,
-0.0112808328,
-0.0292486995,
0.0477522761,
-0.010088997,
0.0626663268,
0.0089842398,
-0.0140207289,
-0.0126604605,
-0.0106417276,
-0.0620872825,
-0.0796149969,
0.0176360011,
-0.0040545678,
0.0366827324,
0.0043736193,
0.0417334065,
-0.0024566236,
-0.0289244801,
0.0035565386,
0.0010442192,
0.0219301488,
-0.0178931653,
0.0558914505,
0.0486252122,
-0.0171584133,
0.0093158353,
0.0672488287,
-0.0165490471,
0.0354592465,
0.0003477216,
-0.0289487131,
-0.0277915876,
-0.0391916558,
0.0186264068,
0.0139336372,
-0.0004369449,
-0.0092887282,
-0.0715161562,
-0.0832173973,
0.0167366769,
0.0233878475,
-0.0157749932,
0.0086706504,
0.0359761678,
0.0665229708,
0.0346895643,
-0.0480390191,
-0.0501329601,
0.0289151967,
-0.0549353324,
-0.0203829352,
-0.0109047731,
-6.359759454e-33,
-0.0335881449,
-0.0590358153,
0.0563065149,
-0.009282154,
-0.0097486991,
-0.0107062254,
-0.0282009821,
-0.0169648789,
-0.0299904272,
0.0100168074,
-0.012227308,
0.0037415412,
-0.0144448821,
0.0110901399,
-0.0122269709,
-0.0379160903,
-0.0318243168,
-0.0018668136,
-0.015025978,
0.0140655702,
0.09463083,
0.015662713,
0.0203230046,
-0.0166582055,
0.0508511439,
-0.032674253,
0.030914655,
0.0380253978,
-0.023773009,
0.0561856441,
0.0059401458,
0.0434788018,
0.0203982312,
-0.0085237166,
0.0189281404,
0.0130247148,
-0.0573998541,
-0.0239348523,
0.0190385282,
-0.0345848016,
-0.0484989174,
-0.0253252573,
0.0419770814,
-0.0127089964,
0.0389635973,
-0.0217818972,
0.0471701063,
-0.0030655214,
0.0065691229,
-0.0671039075,
-0.0232638549,
0.0325107239,
-0.0087253368,
-0.0173148457,
-0.0658953339,
0.0657348707,
0.0109612066,
0.0400253832,
-0.0545619242,
0.0150219686,
-0.0200744681,
0.0053502563,
0.0464612097,
-0.0303639434,
0.0051972177,
0.0274396613,
-0.0242632981,
-0.0084811207,
-0.0291355457,
-0.0172861982,
-0.0230617672,
0.0566539429,
0.0417086631,
0.0399178974,
0.0099158557,
0.0108101573,
-0.1058636531,
0.0341709405,
-0.0277628973,
0.0307399277,
-0.003903877,
-0.0092700515,
-0.0160392821,
-0.0153435227,
-0.0664022267,
0.0224446468,
-0.0354537852,
-0.0201504603,
0.0537945628,
-0.0384314172,
-0.0089087766,
-0.0575516783,
0.0080559431,
-0.0233706925,
0.0169253014,
0.0589048229,
0.0034696183,
0.0015690061,
-0.0223824028,
0.0487280712,
-0.0390552431,
0.0215338524,
0.0191648565,
-0.0363088027,
0.0025486695,
0.0369375274,
-0.0002229519,
-0.0082151983,
-0.0352877453,
-0.0157504175,
-0.0454035066,
0.0005273054,
-0.0209042635,
-0.0145398639,
0.0339360647,
0.0515695475,
0.0102922125,
0.0526686907,
0.0134218065,
-0.0180929247,
-0.0259116292,
-0.0100956541,
0.0120768119,
-0.0179510713,
0.0027252934,
0.028435532,
-0.0065061399,
0.0394515023,
-0.0103214774,
-0.0334056467,
0.0120097958,
0.035206113,
2.808e-7,
0.0535143912,
0.0102380551,
0.0112096509,
0.0751477554,
-0.0180925708,
0.0041996646,
-0.0012651165,
-0.0033102899,
0.0336305238,
-0.0803334936,
-0.0307417661,
0.0511257797,
0.0242785942,
0.0569480844,
-0.0909181759,
0.0047576176,
-0.0262249224,
-0.0631587505,
-0.0333236493,
-0.0182484929,
0.074993521,
0.0100472094,
-0.0120232366,
-0.0088300761,
-0.0370223187,
-0.0665009767,
0.0570728891,
-0.0117252767,
-0.0197589714,
0.0111620259,
0.0548243858,
-0.0240164269,
0.0145622687,
0.0389243364,
-0.0041515478,
0.0130717736,
0.0090596005,
0.0266389214,
0.0072583151,
-0.0452176109,
-0.0324461609,
-0.0600827485,
0.0298619438,
-0.0326882005,
0.0724617094,
-0.0355475545,
0.0004925707,
0.0263055395,
-0.0312139951,
-0.0230491217,
-0.0044964254,
-0.0150822848,
0.0041480456,
0.016605882,
0.0011020658,
-0.0018840068,
0.0338530652,
-0.0530318841,
-0.0056860745,
0.0071524861,
-0.0297381151,
-0.057098709,
-0.0173312649,
0.0049446155,
-0.0126536079,
-0.0487687327,
0.0100555727,
2.666360979e-34,
0.0221662447,
-0.0006927162,
0.0023584017,
0.0274254661,
0.0730833784,
-0.0230712704,
-0.0341015868,
-0.0146424472,
0.0252667367,
-0.1191147566,
-0.0017001065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20158v1 | GAR-meets-RAG Paradigm for Zero-Shot Information Retrieval | 2023-10-31T03:52:08 | 2023-10-31T03:52:08 | Daman Arora, Anush Kini, Sayak Ray Chowdhury, Nagarajan Natarajan, Gaurav Sinha, Amit Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given a query and a document corpus, the information retrieval (IR) task is
to output a ranked list of relevant documents. Combining large language models
(LLMs) with embedding-based retrieval models, recent work shows promising
results on the zero-shot retrieval problem, i.e., no access to labeled data
from the target domain. Two such popular paradigms are generation-augmented
retrieval or GAR (generate additional context for the query and then retrieve),
and retrieval-augmented generation or RAG (retrieve relevant documents as
context and then generate answers). The success of these paradigms hinges on
(i) high-recall retrieval models, which are difficult to obtain in the
zero-shot setting, and (ii) high-precision (re-)ranking models which typically
need a good initialization. In this work, we propose a novel GAR-meets-RAG
recurrence formulation that overcomes the challenges of existing paradigms. Our
method iteratively improves retrieval (via GAR) and rewrite (via RAG) stages in
the zero-shot setting. A key design principle is that the rewrite-retrieval
stages improve the recall of the system and a final re-ranking stage improves
the precision. We conduct extensive experiments on zero-shot passage retrieval
benchmarks, BEIR and TREC-DL. Our method establishes a new state-of-the-art in
the BEIR benchmark, outperforming previous best results in Recall@100 and
nDCG@10 metrics on 6 out of 8 datasets, with up to 17% relative gains over the
previous best. | [
0.037685737,
0.0093083736,
0.0175830647,
-0.0018324911,
-0.0224347543,
0.0120497895,
-0.0060507772,
0.011865777,
0.0090892185,
-0.0646814555,
0.0023281525,
-0.0506079607,
-0.03761556,
0.0052637816,
0.0048169545,
0.0074928571,
0.0285946857,
0.0033738152,
0.0164989494,
0.0084273238,
-0.0096939458,
0.0172070116,
0.0036128878,
-0.0020509134,
0.0287230872,
0.0302194469,
-0.0126351798,
0.0338503309,
0.0108277583,
-0.0524557382,
-0.0008345971,
0.0078121917,
0.058878988,
0.0633415282,
0.0000019354,
-0.0495042428,
-0.0484283864,
0.0242722705,
-0.0402467847,
-0.01183959,
0.067117393,
0.0079033645,
0.0372634567,
0.0257474892,
-0.0167524442,
-0.0420354232,
0.007384249,
0.0318094529,
0.0345110558,
0.0668234229,
-0.0049807057,
-0.0538263805,
0.0237420239,
-0.0327930152,
0.0691151768,
-0.0629030094,
0.0200129841,
0.0094646635,
0.0521177799,
0.0708532333,
0.0043061227,
0.0163083151,
-0.0067201974,
-0.0046266573,
0.0505617112,
0.0131378518,
-0.0888869464,
0.0434410572,
0.0182408597,
0.0512920246,
0.0076382225,
-0.0292944163,
0.0163691603,
0.031215325,
-0.0302857216,
0.0127538759,
-0.0703412145,
0.0014438652,
-0.0155422743,
0.0153761264,
-0.0191938337,
-0.0068371133,
0.0193478465,
0.0086738253,
-0.0264965687,
0.0398153216,
0.0216478538,
-0.0338782296,
-0.0375859626,
-0.0036980354,
-0.0115925074,
-0.0189421028,
-0.015014559,
0.03770338,
0.0049755047,
0.0159697887,
-0.0029350934,
-0.0240049008,
0.054759223,
0.0002326783,
0.0221224204,
0.0303308144,
0.0326923095,
0.0820500702,
-0.0557033643,
0.0521665476,
0.0172374956,
-0.0324165076,
-0.0609847046,
-0.0182154682,
-0.0524337031,
-0.0352393575,
-0.0317642726,
0.0782708302,
-0.00249385,
-0.0131604588,
-0.0208658203,
0.0257638656,
0.0330192745,
-0.0078007816,
-0.0272227284,
0.0133807939,
-0.0426783189,
-0.0115775615,
-0.0124236774,
0.0296228826,
-0.0091276197,
-0.0259201862,
-0.0051434059,
-0.0158783179,
-0.0213854779,
-0.0145070674,
0.0296528619,
-0.015450431,
-0.0156764016,
0.0057254527,
-0.013437435,
-0.0583673567,
-0.0177224074,
-0.0394374244,
0.0250312146,
-0.0452361479,
-0.0015323313,
-0.0537163466,
0.0214954969,
0.0203113127,
-0.0137298843,
0.0108755799,
0.0150661953,
0.0730494931,
-0.057609532,
0.0290257055,
0.0498110205,
-0.0118364487,
0.0196105503,
0.0236299504,
0.0602588244,
0.0516479276,
-0.0236348677,
0.0179377384,
0.0295816213,
0.0402700454,
0.0231603831,
-0.0288340021,
0.0130797876,
0.02320203,
-0.0279419664,
0.025273025,
0.0198314786,
0.0282165632,
0.002321803,
-0.0021861058,
-0.0626699179,
-0.0228172373,
0.0066128606,
0.0243434664,
0.0364989005,
-0.0284782313,
0.0107094226,
0.0074850628,
-0.0313858613,
-0.0023161394,
-0.0001970814,
0.0306267142,
-0.043433357,
0.0120136179,
0.066466026,
-0.0036301503,
-0.0452838466,
-0.0100977998,
-0.0230591465,
0.0272509791,
-0.036313381,
0.0168846101,
0.0423316471,
0.0113793742,
-0.0550680384,
0.0171272941,
-0.0093452148,
-0.0658602118,
0.0071988516,
-0.0220136903,
0.0081303092,
0.0668249801,
0.1143188402,
-0.0702789724,
-0.0321022943,
-0.0276022889,
0.0052099004,
0.009598664,
-0.0094313193,
-0.000442423,
-0.0254980307,
-0.0735187903,
-0.0329694711,
-0.0038983871,
-0.0013364743,
0.0269851275,
-0.0017835479,
0.0419478528,
0.0510568246,
-0.0504241101,
0.0063089551,
0.0171505604,
-0.0370364226,
-0.0634124875,
0.0442219712,
-0.0290192813,
-0.011638822,
0.0133009609,
-0.0043038223,
0.0249761324,
0.0537681282,
-0.0175914019,
-0.0334973149,
-0.0609466434,
-0.0226039682,
-0.0402971543,
0.0107379509,
-0.0104119554,
0.0408237316,
0.0143939294,
-0.0380683392,
-0.0422907621,
-0.0004304638,
0.0158494283,
0.0039687422,
-0.0562284328,
0.0148676997,
0.018647965,
-0.0044146292,
-0.0730947554,
0.0420551449,
0.0181002151,
0.0557791665,
0.0207223445,
0.0104599176,
0.0125598889,
-0.0735589266,
-0.0671956614,
0.0118306242,
0.0010967836,
0.0233123619,
0.0458780266,
-0.0005299847,
-0.0268639773,
-0.0069166836,
-0.109157145,
0.0210296847,
-0.0169452801,
-0.0233611912,
0.0001119927,
-0.0002040182,
0.0113569973,
-0.0172358342,
-0.039870061,
-0.0172095858,
0.0247700308,
0.0440024287,
0.0113225253,
-0.0025263657,
0.0077373534,
-0.0036333511,
-0.0288913529,
0.0018713173,
0.0549668558,
-0.0112815676,
0.0243689287,
-0.0354075246,
0.0384362713,
-0.0694372132,
0.0196667314,
-0.0160164237,
0.0193516854,
0.0045923493,
-0.0499966964,
0.0065648211,
0.0355561003,
0.0117533589,
-0.0066787344,
-0.0010142399,
-0.0100855157,
-0.0702664554,
0.0011264024,
-0.0549722202,
-0.0258187111,
0.0604419187,
-0.0113509428,
-0.0090799583,
0.0108145475,
0.0057839579,
-0.0073819873,
-0.0336680152,
0.022151852,
-0.0081920847,
0.0103230113,
-0.0829355642,
0.0256950259,
0.0258182008,
0.020291971,
-0.0248373821,
-0.0115435664,
0.0451356843,
-0.0040061618,
-0.0015212101,
-0.0271746404,
0.0290451068,
-0.0715443641,
0.0299146697,
0.0175767932,
0.0156298876,
-0.0173367765,
-0.0143312588,
0.0017758969,
0.011459155,
0.0424262695,
-0.0647459477,
0.0080333697,
-0.0078290617,
0.0486813635,
-0.0158492047,
-0.0394653976,
-0.0336121395,
-0.0477309376,
0.0325647369,
0.0101150675,
-0.0514606573,
0.0028330563,
-0.0564522147,
0.0418575816,
0.0509280525,
0.0362495184,
-0.0178928748,
-0.0159488358,
0.0084875114,
0.0646313429,
0.058316268,
-0.0572101064,
-0.014653841,
0.0443510637,
0.0191332996,
0.0687165111,
0.0656391606,
0.010819017,
0.023122998,
-0.0041856002,
0.0603380091,
-0.0201192107,
-0.026123032,
0.0037341567,
-0.0385605916,
-0.0301362425,
-0.0522062629,
0.074425593,
0.0592829585,
-0.0377459116,
-0.0521818995,
-0.0438946374,
0.0409336202,
0.0417410731,
0.0463796817,
-0.1008910835,
-0.0102186305,
0.0248485394,
0.0232003685,
-0.0142964795,
-0.0383879654,
-0.0031077769,
-0.1677222103,
0.0665978044,
0.0023330667,
-0.0169802997,
-0.0019255708,
-0.0775342062,
-0.0158747844,
0.0364244767,
-0.0362230018,
0.0787747279,
-0.023807304,
0.0030716073,
0.0040604519,
0.02752419,
-0.0438247658,
0.0082945554,
-0.0015552256,
0.0086300941,
0.0277500134,
0.01743095,
0.0151923411,
-0.0124813253,
0.0049337521,
-0.0478901602,
-0.0191844907,
-0.013576787,
0.0216346849,
-0.0430084988,
0.0284132473,
-0.0175429229,
0.0119789746,
-0.008383261,
0.0024848292,
-0.019751342,
0.0494922027,
-0.0134604005,
0.0336146802,
-0.0433132313,
-0.0340274051,
-0.0024385168,
0.081331715,
-0.0196872335,
0.0117468694,
-0.0345161185,
-0.0374275036,
0.0483078286,
-0.0111999726,
-0.0257113613,
0.0165561177,
-0.022471603,
-0.0138796624,
-0.0613114722,
-0.031218214,
0.0127655016,
0.0461627506,
-0.0070816251,
0.036605835,
-0.0488005877,
-0.0319645293,
-0.0329640098,
-0.020739818,
-0.0547181442,
-0.0006141993,
-0.0536913164,
0.0360345505,
0.0479331091,
-0.0492468588,
-0.0147174969,
-0.018653933,
-0.0151894884,
-0.0385028832,
-0.0044667437,
0.0388538539,
0.0145063605,
0.007183258,
-0.0006599153,
-0.0468886718,
0.0988950208,
0.038239941,
-0.0015319464,
0.0223058108,
-0.0116096884,
0.00769787,
-0.0230549239,
0.0174778663,
-0.0760038719,
0.0313496515,
-0.0159862172,
0.069797121,
-0.0248942673,
-0.0035728726,
0.0206317846,
0.0372265242,
0.0460068807,
0.0318538286,
0.0063240081,
-0.0112190079,
0.0468209647,
-0.0623908117,
-0.0280029662,
-0.0177953579,
0.0216212645,
0.0316516049,
-0.0312493294,
0.0077183084,
0.0038481383,
-0.0262661614,
0.0881508216,
-0.0409630314,
-0.0338439196,
0.0072854641,
-0.0024679743,
0.0114807449,
0.0127605824,
-0.0473932512,
0.007645451,
-0.0062825042,
0.0553319529,
-0.0342225842,
0.0473099463,
0.0133489501,
0.0000952096,
-0.0522065833,
0.0236991532,
-0.088324368,
-0.0002162718,
-0.0084242709,
0.0217269845,
0.0388025679,
0.0084811244,
0.0170825627,
0.0152847469,
-0.0300559457,
-0.037867751,
-0.0129265478,
0.0256257802,
-0.0224638991,
-0.0148074999,
0.0555661805,
-0.0084904227,
0.0784693733,
0.0967667475,
0.0187292788,
0.032646291,
-0.006297511,
-0.053821601,
-0.0086488007,
0.005723122,
0.0307439715,
0.0515975505,
0.0098582208,
-0.0204979368,
-0.0560170375,
-0.01740296,
0.0465216897,
-0.0216951128,
-0.0191066191,
-0.0208649002,
0.0492900424,
0.0606505796,
0.0018827202,
0.0080519877,
-0.0728625804,
0.016313104,
-0.0491777509,
-0.0350966714,
-0.022823507,
-6.343422286e-33,
0.0047759023,
-0.0102152638,
0.0245625824,
-0.0390883498,
-0.0194356255,
0.0119824102,
0.0049742567,
-0.017424196,
0.002561193,
-0.0142678022,
-0.0356744118,
-0.0099803843,
0.0011569884,
0.0269889254,
-0.0323698372,
-0.0165283866,
0.0298815295,
0.0063662855,
-0.0279313941,
0.0189578068,
0.0890584663,
0.062704742,
-0.010202447,
0.0012915665,
-0.0027820976,
-0.0479397886,
0.0273261331,
0.0039121904,
0.035954982,
0.0445060171,
-0.01980008,
0.0363486446,
0.0446185581,
-0.0639604554,
0.0176290534,
0.0152023789,
-0.0940897763,
-0.026033558,
-0.0229245909,
-0.0424957573,
-0.0012192903,
0.000434211,
-0.0019858293,
-0.0234916117,
-0.0007164134,
-0.0065479893,
0.0204198267,
-0.0049482724,
-0.0869191885,
-0.0436742716,
-0.0226945579,
0.0101533551,
0.0116145797,
-0.0166631397,
0.0298680384,
0.0681365579,
0.0169128049,
0.0879497007,
-0.0720630959,
0.0158542041,
-0.045908343,
0.0638393685,
0.001847828,
0.010790796,
0.0079678372,
0.0473874621,
-0.0055861915,
-0.0075288075,
-0.0258224253,
-0.0509042479,
-0.0078775175,
-0.0154479221,
-0.0015523044,
0.036988765,
0.0717434809,
0.0019233027,
-0.078238681,
0.0319979116,
-0.0098938877,
0.0636614412,
0.0515791476,
0.0371823348,
-0.0726946369,
-0.0427060537,
-0.0407055356,
0.0021320591,
-0.0790801644,
-0.014691608,
0.0556430183,
0.049002286,
-0.0325656794,
-0.0175613388,
0.0773824453,
0.0017983305,
-0.0237138253,
0.0452967957,
-0.0128258802,
0.0195006467,
-0.0292846989,
0.0299014337,
-0.0233589467,
0.0001418427,
0.040071182,
-0.015553073,
-0.0371348038,
-0.020208301,
0.0224039406,
0.0087668141,
-0.0628658235,
0.0005364039,
-0.0060515655,
-0.0003273543,
-0.0209174026,
0.0053637139,
-0.0080451341,
0.0359604098,
0.0353092253,
0.0832476318,
0.0289760195,
-0.0045564082,
0.0088738026,
-0.0240291785,
-0.0038783352,
-0.0201737639,
0.0022183589,
0.0480487868,
0.0201831125,
0.0672434345,
0.0178611893,
-0.0535859913,
0.0080054132,
0.0564712696,
2.789e-7,
0.0104479063,
0.0214956384,
0.0160965435,
-0.0036810287,
-0.0072840219,
0.0192015432,
0.0227322597,
0.0338495933,
0.0403674915,
0.0139811579,
-0.0097280871,
0.0116313845,
0.0118343746,
0.0038408011,
-0.1009075716,
0.0024074542,
-0.0474124178,
-0.0323383287,
-0.0153112924,
-0.0515192188,
0.045883581,
0.0690786764,
-0.0002070345,
0.0043873903,
-0.014330511,
-0.0649475306,
0.0674900189,
0.0280676149,
-0.0494404547,
-0.020004198,
0.0409655347,
0.0431797057,
-0.0048051188,
-0.0188266262,
0.0057788705,
0.0077401483,
0.0407953002,
0.0314337462,
-0.0135210352,
-0.0405081846,
0.0037520751,
-0.0020443858,
0.0016246451,
-0.0256188978,
0.0881634653,
-0.041908104,
-0.001853939,
0.0428587496,
-0.0668483451,
-0.0139057003,
0.030272916,
-0.0065730461,
-0.0500876494,
0.0288717691,
0.0152815944,
0.0318583176,
-0.0035217132,
-0.0836947933,
0.0254367702,
-0.0009369186,
-0.0335507877,
0.0100559331,
0.0095054312,
-0.0049946066,
-0.0210064761,
-0.0610560142,
-0.0002225363,
2.814099038e-34,
0.0509860478,
-0.0027773643,
-0.0072573121,
-0.0095838131,
0.0183973536,
-0.0065744021,
-0.0478318632,
0.0295931138,
0.0308916681,
-0.1090080515,
-0.0218102466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20153v1 | Interactive Multi-fidelity Learning for Cost-effective Adaptation of Language Model with Sparse Human Supervision | 2023-10-31T03:39:23 | 2023-10-31T03:39:23 | Jiaxin Zhang, Zhuohang Li, Kamalika Das, Sricharan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various tasks. However, their suitability for domain-specific tasks, is limited
due to their immense scale at deployment, susceptibility to misinformation, and
more importantly, high data annotation costs. We propose a novel Interactive
Multi-Fidelity Learning (IMFL) framework for the cost-effective development of
small domain-specific LMs under limited annotation budgets. Our approach
formulates the domain-specific fine-tuning process as a multi-fidelity learning
problem, focusing on identifying the optimal acquisition strategy that balances
between low-fidelity automatic LLM annotations and high-fidelity human
annotations to maximize model performance. We further propose an
exploration-exploitation query strategy that enhances annotation diversity and
informativeness, incorporating two innovative designs: 1) prompt retrieval that
selects in-context examples from human-annotated samples to improve LLM
annotation, and 2) variable batch size that controls the order for choosing
each fidelity to facilitate knowledge distillation, ultimately enhancing
annotation quality. Extensive experiments on financial and medical tasks
demonstrate that IMFL achieves superior performance compared with single
fidelity annotations. Given a limited budget of human annotation, IMFL
significantly outperforms the human annotation baselines in all four tasks and
achieves very close performance as human annotations on two of the tasks. These
promising results suggest that the high human annotation costs in
domain-specific tasks can be significantly reduced by employing IMFL, which
utilizes fewer human annotations, supplemented with cheaper and faster LLM
(e.g., GPT-3.5) annotations to achieve comparable performance. | [
0.0365074091,
0.0309249144,
-0.018703118,
0.0284157246,
-0.0053293533,
0.0156249898,
0.0145987663,
0.0015836705,
0.0029125793,
-0.0714772567,
-0.0678754672,
-0.0578107797,
-0.0184222274,
-0.0189888086,
0.0558295548,
-0.0789399445,
0.0489573441,
-0.0552331209,
0.0013565825,
0.0018125251,
-0.0108946897,
0.0043527596,
-0.0164566152,
0.0467953198,
-0.0155999521,
0.0130703151,
-0.0097168069,
-0.0000147673,
-0.01339781,
-0.042163074,
-0.0026438276,
0.0754428208,
0.0558448918,
0.0328973681,
0.0000023535,
-0.0478871465,
-0.038537316,
0.0320483968,
-0.0343672931,
0.0138732744,
0.080308564,
-0.006609092,
-0.0001147483,
0.0100925677,
-0.0326166488,
0.0003572277,
0.0684925616,
0.0078159068,
0.0552373752,
0.0408208929,
0.0067168269,
0.0050997315,
-0.0335905291,
-0.0290903132,
-0.0239068978,
-0.0737582669,
0.0155629637,
0.0082767541,
-0.0033742734,
0.0102458475,
-0.0072284988,
0.0356768779,
-0.017737193,
-0.0044140001,
-0.004014052,
0.0002315601,
-0.0399619415,
-0.0361302011,
-0.0065826909,
0.0672863796,
-0.0153143397,
0.0197488926,
0.0050462289,
-0.0185318198,
0.0150957741,
0.0392703377,
-0.0477524772,
0.0158656482,
0.0169639587,
0.0075001535,
-0.0313874818,
-0.0196125284,
0.0246220995,
0.0400559381,
-0.0238759387,
0.0134612955,
-0.0179041494,
-0.016704252,
0.0456177816,
0.0059659914,
-0.0890577212,
0.0060263439,
-0.0198809654,
0.0084716938,
-0.038875144,
0.0303119533,
-0.0525144041,
-0.0560103655,
0.023969112,
-0.0439984947,
0.0689427406,
0.030917773,
-0.0310381055,
0.0552792661,
0.0036815351,
0.0009515081,
-0.0061511323,
-0.0081937946,
-0.0311220735,
0.0046131909,
-0.0508541688,
0.0017296211,
-0.0561454482,
0.0427143052,
-0.0403726958,
0.0175501052,
-0.0404642411,
0.0261783022,
-0.013071618,
0.0037456362,
0.0035803756,
-0.0156688727,
-0.0513896719,
-0.0000874302,
-0.0319998302,
0.0206286591,
-0.0038928373,
0.0247851536,
0.0152613679,
-0.0645212084,
-0.002365242,
0.0319599845,
-0.0129623776,
-0.0507387519,
0.0031850059,
0.0690174326,
-0.009131901,
-0.0422013514,
-0.0657665506,
-0.0262220446,
-0.0054167048,
-0.0265123416,
-0.0078609027,
-0.0424803011,
0.0206374526,
-0.0029798613,
-0.0066462066,
-0.0574867427,
0.0036630151,
0.0149918227,
-0.0406958833,
0.0784061849,
-0.0211994406,
0.0054618181,
0.027596863,
-0.0227377508,
-0.0554872043,
0.122195743,
0.0198320206,
0.0065277265,
0.0226772912,
0.0054668016,
-0.0086948555,
0.0508500524,
0.0071242787,
0.0292951353,
-0.0119071919,
-0.0102740889,
0.0375448875,
0.0356028415,
0.0583577342,
0.0190146118,
-0.0291999299,
0.0119026238,
0.0392381884,
0.049902834,
0.0190493558,
-0.0267115086,
0.0635084361,
0.0524302572,
0.0078948196,
-0.0148752462,
-0.0479977354,
0.0209663976,
-0.031965144,
-0.0064324532,
0.0144088501,
-0.0050691678,
-0.0243642367,
-0.0325344391,
-0.0220958348,
-0.0139723159,
-0.0191815197,
0.0324780084,
0.0731813833,
-0.000974398,
-0.0165995657,
0.0570312142,
0.0677186549,
-0.0201458391,
-0.0171501376,
-0.0374273136,
0.003545213,
0.0731782094,
0.0206422806,
-0.0685663223,
-0.0108766463,
-0.0057281125,
0.0334051028,
0.044050388,
0.0787487179,
-0.0328304097,
-0.0003109045,
-0.0499499254,
-0.0443810932,
0.0094335023,
0.0192728005,
0.0315080062,
0.0273760632,
-0.0359165072,
0.0124652591,
-0.0427702963,
-0.0376514718,
0.0463340506,
-0.03209747,
-0.0160352141,
-0.016156327,
0.018992966,
0.0306583438,
0.0267606173,
-0.0028219465,
0.0095663648,
0.0144769158,
-0.0144172031,
0.0221546236,
-0.0386741273,
-0.0146521833,
0.0120681291,
0.0141448453,
0.0367973223,
-0.0140273049,
-0.02893118,
-0.051139012,
-0.0334023386,
-0.0248487871,
-0.0131996302,
0.0216216873,
-0.0521229245,
0.0048493259,
-0.012005833,
-0.0092272023,
-0.0712596998,
0.0433810577,
0.0043670642,
-0.0091694472,
0.0180133004,
0.0028040204,
-0.0051727369,
-0.0572915636,
-0.04371069,
-0.0042065843,
0.0069237323,
0.0376375169,
0.0090558957,
0.0241204146,
-0.0155874118,
-0.0028372104,
-0.0850487128,
-0.0105734179,
-0.0092213163,
0.008291522,
-0.0047788057,
0.0254846644,
-0.0048790425,
-0.0333067887,
0.0052915048,
0.0000725215,
-0.0312147588,
0.0536983982,
0.021010289,
0.0363350697,
-0.0072316951,
-0.056131918,
0.003837195,
-0.0086977296,
0.0169984214,
0.0095140487,
-0.0415174142,
-0.0603373311,
0.0049021379,
-0.0020247027,
0.0425169766,
-0.004962292,
-0.0037688317,
-0.0048360042,
-0.0321829952,
-0.0189040042,
0.0384390242,
-0.0161458757,
0.0606525689,
0.0694492906,
0.0374355763,
-0.0690563396,
0.028324414,
-0.0141356643,
-0.0387935974,
-0.0407201312,
0.0436390676,
0.0134602915,
0.0583908446,
-0.0231368802,
-0.0056992639,
-0.0668283477,
0.0190270264,
-0.0378809869,
-0.0372920819,
-0.0509944595,
0.0218815319,
-0.0317411982,
0.0532401353,
0.0002559498,
-0.0341896862,
0.0743210986,
-0.006300916,
0.0091285827,
-0.0237532426,
-0.0107880328,
-0.0210485887,
0.0400162712,
-0.0374823809,
0.005521914,
0.0336674526,
-0.0327310152,
-0.0882644802,
0.0341376998,
0.0684386715,
-0.0373523235,
0.0759861618,
-0.0899169818,
0.0422495641,
-0.0311618187,
-0.0466073193,
-0.0263557099,
-0.0488758273,
-0.0334432833,
0.0230045337,
0.014727613,
0.0023252924,
-0.039549645,
0.0208413284,
0.0236654226,
0.0575171448,
0.0081030969,
-0.0125185614,
-0.0047438825,
-0.0086269276,
0.0151389688,
0.0827863291,
-0.0352379084,
-0.0351016037,
0.0178367328,
0.0125329355,
-0.002959362,
-0.0332361497,
0.0107011367,
0.0165160932,
0.034881644,
-0.0447004996,
-0.036730729,
0.0370804071,
0.0367236808,
-0.0861262977,
-0.0066314377,
0.1088402122,
0.0213868469,
-0.0553093366,
0.006440334,
0.0070286598,
0.0462565124,
0.0288543161,
0.0522824004,
-0.1038877219,
-0.0352915637,
-0.0022612542,
0.0744312257,
0.0146548338,
-0.0319008566,
-0.0047527323,
-0.1475310773,
0.0441953763,
-0.0059237233,
-0.0605688021,
-0.0038597188,
-0.0751666874,
0.0215007998,
-0.040602494,
0.0211257227,
0.0099210488,
0.0098493136,
0.010944413,
0.037437845,
-0.0119874477,
-0.0896420255,
0.0148098143,
-0.0117529854,
0.0509807989,
0.0611219332,
0.0054670242,
0.0134030059,
-0.0225891359,
0.0305736754,
-0.0043661245,
0.0212376919,
-0.0302255973,
0.0928386971,
0.0014539354,
-0.0149613367,
0.0451329686,
0.0284818616,
0.0011506357,
-0.0067423703,
-0.0111802118,
0.080447264,
-0.0125396121,
0.0696255192,
0.0101026995,
-0.0381590612,
0.0274338499,
0.0656132102,
0.0161864012,
-0.070652537,
0.0100713698,
-0.0058540478,
-0.0241115261,
-0.0611934252,
-0.0318679325,
0.0245404784,
-0.0537005626,
-0.0199136324,
-0.0497810207,
-0.0216199327,
0.0680079535,
0.0605568998,
0.0218508486,
0.0200868864,
0.0279781129,
0.033156652,
-0.0260817148,
0.0448284522,
-0.0660252795,
0.0150650656,
-0.055827409,
-0.043852143,
0.0222655497,
-0.0393046252,
-0.0192914549,
0.0166444946,
-0.021914931,
-0.0545487963,
0.0040846206,
0.05198998,
0.0177536216,
0.066524677,
-0.0124528762,
-0.0598773323,
0.0161104165,
0.0410543755,
-0.0298529509,
-0.012045864,
0.0351135843,
0.0220632199,
-0.0429887027,
0.0395854004,
-0.0590391085,
0.0039981594,
0.0105656814,
0.0483630598,
0.0061054765,
-0.0561681427,
0.0230186991,
0.026434036,
0.0511399284,
-0.0462333038,
-0.0135504929,
-0.0247738324,
0.0015429917,
0.0152615681,
-0.0397358052,
-0.0644245148,
-0.0007947382,
-0.0043860306,
-0.0300793108,
0.0142006809,
-0.0184365958,
0.0213797297,
0.0383356959,
-0.0364851579,
0.0166782774,
0.0041871187,
0.004905263,
0.028139947,
0.0247897916,
0.0016844108,
0.0235015694,
-0.006599409,
0.0313524194,
-0.025080869,
0.0446009748,
0.010417765,
0.009468291,
-0.016196616,
0.0204742681,
-0.0082353102,
-0.0292492695,
-0.0588373989,
0.0371508412,
0.0605908111,
-0.0321893618,
0.0747273639,
-0.0158714466,
-0.0255136266,
-0.0101932911,
0.024644943,
0.0059678131,
0.0078382771,
0.0458115079,
0.0323481224,
-0.0232983399,
0.0198610239,
0.0974189565,
0.0095708929,
0.0421172716,
-0.0516310409,
-0.0138270929,
-0.0380962379,
-0.0102155125,
0.0261263307,
0.0239003878,
-0.0368613005,
0.0133582568,
-0.083919704,
-0.0387626253,
-0.0197086446,
-0.027925916,
-0.0573865585,
-0.0189478826,
0.0779814571,
0.0526986048,
-0.0126795508,
0.0065040435,
-0.0493814982,
-0.0315145552,
0.0239002593,
-0.0032981408,
-0.0011548636,
-6.655582893e-33,
-0.0609398708,
-0.0066630743,
0.0195218679,
0.0104671288,
-0.0169416275,
-0.0016351988,
-0.0128307147,
0.030751856,
-0.0338962413,
-0.0053586643,
0.0084746983,
-0.0266100112,
0.0193461999,
0.0071981787,
0.0395942703,
0.0137077058,
0.0425109714,
-0.0177198686,
-0.0165975112,
0.0053979768,
0.0373999402,
0.0283470135,
0.0509263873,
-0.0619183034,
0.0284016654,
0.0458076224,
-0.0026955425,
0.0295556094,
0.0426611081,
0.0594460331,
-0.0055484059,
0.0437677987,
-0.0042178445,
-0.06884446,
-0.0328783616,
-0.0316633396,
-0.0702778623,
-0.0122339195,
0.0249944311,
0.015586772,
0.0175078288,
-0.0246756878,
0.0342425033,
-0.0020445252,
0.0015218345,
0.005909082,
0.0385417864,
-0.0455048718,
-0.054344397,
-0.0191012975,
-0.0695820749,
0.0546215624,
0.0092268074,
-0.0124252625,
0.0639041215,
0.0501644015,
-0.0061116912,
0.0097387983,
-0.0467953756,
0.0123282103,
-0.0071932208,
0.040897958,
0.0599961095,
0.039688386,
-0.0096778693,
0.0257663969,
-0.0075950869,
0.026693441,
0.0118894493,
-0.02426452,
0.0323231667,
0.0555323996,
0.0079060113,
0.0644614249,
0.0067964871,
-0.0019333087,
-0.0295444317,
0.0139510464,
-0.0126369847,
0.0163867231,
0.0218009334,
0.0446375422,
-0.0320400372,
-0.0305034239,
-0.0558141507,
0.0090947794,
-0.0267620943,
-0.0243847724,
0.0332225896,
-0.0033159764,
-0.026532717,
-0.0105625261,
0.0372503921,
-0.0304269157,
-0.0311159678,
-0.0464444421,
-0.0227182601,
0.0442661531,
-0.0023675279,
-0.0001736654,
-0.0399403423,
-0.0523135252,
0.0119949561,
0.0012725578,
0.0278061628,
-0.0041149482,
0.0509716719,
0.0210874435,
-0.0487661995,
-0.0034104339,
-0.0227957405,
-0.0091238758,
-0.0092019569,
0.0146346856,
0.0351972952,
-0.0084702726,
-0.0110360952,
0.0472238325,
0.0148053151,
-0.0239357892,
-0.0132441549,
-0.0352862477,
-0.009102677,
-0.0146747865,
-0.0276428219,
0.0071510025,
-0.0077348133,
0.0041950666,
0.0284675378,
-0.0359378085,
-0.0275447648,
0.0165180918,
3.017e-7,
0.0694479793,
0.055514317,
-0.0159538854,
-0.0309930351,
-0.0114875967,
0.0341168195,
-0.0162156727,
-0.0210144427,
-0.0132480254,
-0.0191385541,
0.0316748545,
0.0145874331,
0.0711558163,
0.0248528998,
-0.0946747139,
-0.0316946507,
-0.0375047848,
0.0242348574,
-0.0414590836,
-0.0086209401,
0.0299484767,
0.089891769,
0.0146777425,
-0.0141481915,
-0.0023624618,
-0.0281413235,
0.055954244,
-0.0281522125,
-0.0190714765,
0.0123150218,
0.0243063252,
0.0647384152,
-0.0105391145,
0.0271863639,
-0.046887096,
0.0176713057,
0.0245838854,
0.078549616,
-0.0140609359,
0.0063799755,
0.0201285575,
0.0005386998,
0.0019626939,
-0.0347636044,
0.0488553755,
-0.0770738497,
-0.0350960046,
-0.0098528033,
0.0216486864,
-0.0196508616,
-0.0233142134,
-0.005854195,
0.0064084451,
0.0152894631,
0.0272791628,
0.0038206638,
-0.0535831153,
-0.0507757626,
-0.0159597117,
0.0563552789,
-0.0421457514,
-0.0481693372,
-0.0262457766,
-0.0317657292,
-0.0086813001,
-0.0451693721,
0.0261569582,
3.000663307e-34,
0.0472829156,
-0.0197923761,
0.0285609923,
0.0547409281,
0.0010567372,
0.0271062553,
0.0006714966,
0.0243471786,
0.0252011642,
-0.0806842074,
-0.0026968957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20151v1 | Multi-Agent Consensus Seeking via Large Language Models | 2023-10-31T03:37:11 | 2023-10-31T03:37:11 | Huaben Chen, Wenkang Ji, Lufeng Xu, Shiyu Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.RO, cs.SY, eess.SY | Multi-agent systems driven by large language models (LLMs) have shown
promising abilities for solving complex tasks in a collaborative manner. This
work considers a fundamental problem in multi-agent collaboration: consensus
seeking. When multiple agents work together, we are interested in how they can
reach a consensus through inter-agent negotiation. To that end, this work
studies a consensus-seeking task where the state of each agent is a numerical
value and they negotiate with each other to reach a consensus value. It is
revealed that when not explicitly directed on which strategy should be adopted,
the LLM-driven agents primarily use the average strategy for consensus seeking
although they may occasionally use some other strategies. Moreover, this work
analyzes the impact of the agent number, agent personality, and network
topology on the negotiation process. The findings reported in this work can
potentially lay the foundations for understanding the behaviors of LLM-driven
multi-agent systems for solving more complex tasks. Furthermore, LLM-driven
consensus seeking is applied to a multi-robot aggregation task. This
application demonstrates the potential of LLM-driven agents to achieve
zero-shot autonomous planning for multi-robot collaboration tasks. Project
website: westlakeintelligentrobotics.github.io/ConsensusLLM/. | [
0.0508461483,
0.0097081931,
-0.0132758273,
-0.0029279024,
-0.0651107877,
-0.0456963815,
0.0029028009,
-0.0500057936,
-0.0022181573,
0.0001673626,
-0.0358969606,
-0.0269207656,
-0.0177579448,
-0.0075213555,
-0.0249099638,
-0.0022962734,
0.0097816708,
-0.0429835506,
0.0044107228,
-0.0136698857,
0.0007609541,
-0.0225559138,
0.0110581694,
0.0396043807,
-0.0231433529,
0.0266689528,
-0.0419176184,
-0.0345414393,
0.0238318164,
-0.0052915532,
-0.0352130495,
-0.0028242168,
0.0431799181,
0.0230228007,
0.0000020728,
-0.0501804277,
-0.0637881234,
-0.0357769988,
0.0180289503,
-0.0502127856,
0.04567663,
-0.0200509764,
-0.0347871147,
0.0038192458,
-0.0615132526,
0.0082349665,
0.0214035977,
0.0217062887,
0.0503144041,
0.0546217039,
0.0250713322,
-0.0037594796,
-0.0282962713,
0.0050776778,
-0.0532771796,
-0.0813746378,
0.0472207069,
0.037430115,
0.0592041574,
0.016397588,
0.0202449076,
-0.0150875226,
0.0208319314,
-0.0443866439,
-0.0638107806,
0.0373692624,
-0.0185186658,
-0.0563229956,
0.0379593223,
0.0458626673,
0.0102715753,
-0.020799851,
0.0119169457,
0.0204053,
-0.012070803,
0.0511386655,
-0.0458421707,
0.0622819848,
0.0108369179,
0.0036107884,
-0.0308637246,
-0.011666798,
-0.0023352909,
0.0011660929,
-0.0515138134,
0.1103983447,
-0.0047443896,
-0.0008192155,
-0.0098057706,
-0.0375355631,
-0.0529491194,
-0.074038364,
0.026004795,
0.0838864222,
-0.0609720238,
0.0188746545,
0.0057292446,
0.0169375595,
-0.0103666792,
-0.0368415266,
0.0346044153,
0.0094240643,
0.0254818276,
0.0356555358,
0.0313294046,
0.019032713,
-0.0303773955,
-0.0133904442,
-0.0122433156,
-0.0257853903,
-0.0520791337,
0.0128232241,
-0.0373102017,
0.0440432541,
0.0039423341,
-0.0208597314,
0.0085673491,
0.067548804,
-0.0368877016,
0.025866909,
-0.0165048782,
-0.0037631167,
0.0388190262,
-0.0170267243,
-0.0127980346,
0.0075208978,
-0.0148792714,
0.0017169443,
0.0023342026,
0.0074042589,
0.0335660428,
0.0003426857,
0.0058610798,
-0.0215333328,
0.0013052168,
0.0611821227,
0.0154814105,
0.0310345273,
0.0350936465,
-0.0288504399,
0.0094434144,
-0.0544230416,
-0.0299311746,
-0.0540462211,
-0.0034240144,
-0.0157277435,
-0.0214106981,
-0.0328224227,
-0.0027637184,
-0.0239209235,
-0.0006117918,
0.0150651522,
-0.0000026396,
0.0875789449,
0.0325908847,
0.0192222986,
0.0024165811,
0.0532469302,
0.0246037897,
0.0587580092,
0.0357871763,
0.0409220494,
0.0359991826,
0.0705604404,
-0.0152625935,
0.0197249819,
0.0462905578,
-0.005150748,
0.0011845448,
0.0322893672,
-0.0556319281,
0.0470851213,
-0.0352859683,
-0.0436683297,
0.0728056878,
0.0579062924,
-0.0299950726,
-0.0232777409,
-0.0463665277,
0.0385359153,
-0.0154498043,
-0.0410510823,
-0.0006751964,
0.028426867,
-0.025373131,
-0.0044608908,
-0.0095510287,
0.047474876,
-0.0075968807,
-0.0111545762,
-0.0104363756,
0.008718201,
0.0233118832,
-0.0029623876,
0.0314315744,
-0.0324717797,
-0.0420426913,
-0.0472578816,
-0.0254719704,
-0.0170338824,
-0.0150184138,
-0.0449554846,
0.0390778817,
-0.0083185136,
0.062642917,
-0.0003807983,
-0.0810504258,
0.0093729747,
-0.0123752179,
0.0049293581,
-0.0113915019,
-0.020720752,
-0.0571944714,
-0.0353945158,
-0.0386018232,
0.0614057854,
-0.0458340347,
0.0240867585,
-0.0218136553,
0.0074992911,
-0.03486339,
0.0387723036,
-0.0216315165,
-0.004044313,
-0.008551199,
0.0499052256,
-0.0407019705,
0.0296432525,
0.0736564249,
0.0347719155,
-0.0376266427,
0.0089637889,
0.0504594296,
0.0010367268,
-0.0526705571,
0.0446103737,
0.0421209969,
0.033829134,
0.024237819,
-0.0014061987,
0.0165765695,
0.01279034,
0.0025843347,
-0.0296894535,
0.0516496338,
0.0121325227,
-0.0145985689,
0.0138890687,
0.0088208523,
-0.0260982625,
-0.0145388488,
-0.0323605537,
0.0133305099,
-0.0041623507,
-0.05717507,
0.0250516217,
0.0233422648,
0.016576698,
-0.0283797327,
0.0143884532,
0.1143238768,
0.0608208776,
0.0150658889,
0.073522158,
-0.0145031353,
0.0089241005,
-0.0717678145,
-0.0422012247,
-0.0082973512,
-0.0053091687,
0.0068392218,
0.0019932752,
-0.0424058661,
-0.0019112022,
0.0479348153,
0.0156700891,
0.084664315,
0.008661963,
0.0230642091,
-0.0017152029,
0.0488290302,
-0.0913292244,
-0.0402488932,
0.0198646095,
-0.0095545966,
-0.00760904,
0.0232027341,
-0.0209463853,
-0.0562225133,
0.0276206639,
-0.0869094208,
0.0285795964,
-0.0148197655,
-0.0635912046,
0.0653107315,
-0.0380851291,
-0.0199655648,
0.060018301,
-0.0072771013,
0.0465540737,
0.0555582419,
-0.0392255522,
-0.0560061559,
0.014441411,
-0.0579830743,
-0.0344313681,
-0.0606616847,
-0.005717936,
0.0175739471,
0.0540934913,
-0.0412975028,
-0.0221414566,
0.0155414222,
-0.0028114044,
0.0120049398,
-0.0324011892,
0.0209203493,
-0.0204317402,
-0.0005773641,
0.0733691081,
-0.0237016343,
-0.0109730605,
0.0783514529,
0.008531305,
-0.0166395232,
-0.0159615278,
-0.0375114679,
-0.0484399199,
0.0471265428,
0.0092854518,
0.0161717013,
0.0083557647,
0.0336140618,
-0.026976645,
-0.0204241816,
-0.010175013,
-0.0026545853,
0.0531801172,
-0.0178587642,
0.0166734401,
0.0061685108,
-0.0259853043,
0.0355973467,
0.0224241652,
-0.0280081425,
0.0533013269,
0.005680264,
-0.0519898906,
-0.0415002443,
0.0056016976,
0.065252319,
-0.0063703889,
0.0313304253,
-0.0065506627,
-0.0595830865,
-0.056772247,
0.0173764303,
0.0004183094,
0.0084990952,
-0.0432173796,
0.0064841756,
0.0522510968,
0.0493578911,
-0.0280606523,
-0.0197553169,
-0.0432457887,
0.0233680569,
0.0076528159,
0.0033301783,
-0.0044177677,
0.0191927347,
-0.0102306586,
0.0100021036,
0.0501411967,
0.019075444,
-0.0249698497,
0.0022032522,
-0.0536072962,
0.0250467658,
0.0076537561,
0.0127254408,
0.0095284786,
0.0307150669,
0.0113492263,
-0.0366621055,
-0.0281848684,
-0.0532386154,
-0.019460693,
-0.0816300064,
0.0130143631,
-0.0046094707,
-0.0598523468,
0.0260829255,
-0.0488792695,
0.0278165024,
-0.0292987544,
0.0113009522,
-0.0073548178,
0.0500704087,
-0.0180030968,
-0.0008819485,
-0.0004184599,
0.0135542499,
-0.0049318932,
-0.063598305,
0.0682893842,
0.0739882737,
0.05207761,
-0.0062098973,
0.0266229492,
0.0425442196,
0.0677616596,
0.0233022831,
-0.0192267187,
-0.0638182014,
-0.0204727426,
0.0279018525,
-0.0010882225,
-0.0184059609,
-0.0119444756,
-0.002864497,
0.0075030653,
0.0585202388,
-0.0120271696,
-0.0181430038,
-0.017227903,
0.0272682738,
0.0061987201,
0.041504398,
-0.0416040458,
-0.0322892293,
-0.0261155237,
-0.0208107345,
-0.0369518436,
0.0031040676,
-0.0647915825,
0.0027672511,
-0.0169800408,
-0.0097165005,
-0.0192319509,
-0.0791564807,
0.0413243771,
0.0307619926,
0.0072281077,
0.0053737438,
0.0924075991,
0.0094299437,
0.0347139575,
-0.0310738049,
0.0008718511,
0.0053886189,
-0.0424952358,
0.0168893877,
0.0532669425,
-0.0194081254,
-0.0115429601,
-0.0224443898,
0.0078759464,
-0.0782329217,
0.0087764505,
0.0262108482,
0.0202070922,
-0.025532553,
0.0233705528,
-0.0817111731,
0.0094010299,
-0.0098190084,
0.0627550781,
0.0336708203,
-0.035599228,
0.0384653918,
0.0203762781,
0.0643065199,
-0.0367639177,
0.0437047444,
0.0292170215,
-0.0013231426,
-0.0836768001,
-0.061924085,
0.0243571643,
0.0086299386,
-0.0781110823,
0.0355034955,
-0.0102908788,
0.0034091994,
-0.0109107522,
-0.0374785773,
-0.0332333446,
-0.0386342816,
-0.0071989931,
-0.0286545586,
-0.0209490154,
0.0627948567,
0.0725323111,
0.0525736548,
0.0438034758,
0.0511732996,
0.0137304878,
-0.0192916151,
-0.0029760844,
0.0360621735,
0.0236614197,
0.0381222889,
-0.0242681056,
-0.0245269034,
0.0506905019,
0.0429276079,
0.0431988053,
0.0408055037,
-0.0731859058,
-0.0120778112,
0.0235232916,
-0.0599381886,
-0.0921465605,
0.0688434616,
0.0430373624,
0.0894996077,
0.0459440686,
0.0308998302,
-0.0930736437,
0.0432470702,
-0.0379731618,
-0.0206092615,
-0.0065084225,
-0.0235546809,
0.0326281451,
0.0090147592,
-0.0041765128,
0.0161654949,
0.0276276898,
-0.0231630486,
0.0343471467,
0.0002726276,
-0.0157869309,
-0.0093775475,
0.0202470627,
-0.0246705953,
0.0035446405,
-0.0228881054,
0.0092047397,
-0.0352260359,
0.0039341613,
-0.0047241272,
0.0396218039,
-0.011934543,
-0.0287013855,
-0.0354588404,
0.0111948187,
-0.0147925224,
-0.0276009049,
-0.0321519934,
-0.0255297646,
-0.0271562096,
0.0172505733,
-0.0025453055,
-6.107043597e-33,
-0.0058480445,
-0.0885905027,
0.0704505295,
0.0028312944,
-0.0141843194,
-0.0655477345,
-0.0253519192,
0.0127925184,
-0.0346959569,
0.0235352628,
-0.0154369427,
-0.0092273243,
0.0384353958,
-0.0137993591,
0.0279650521,
0.035500899,
0.0075661172,
-0.0277714096,
-0.0180450752,
-0.0339281484,
0.0386906713,
-0.0164742842,
-0.0161327608,
-0.0251277164,
0.0021280474,
-0.0060922219,
-0.0087867836,
0.0541299842,
-0.0094739124,
0.0457254909,
0.0383222178,
-0.0225898251,
0.0044323406,
-0.0314876586,
-0.0630454272,
0.0094965296,
0.0619355738,
0.0024418179,
-0.0063544139,
0.0190020222,
-0.0010260516,
-0.0152603323,
-0.0155570451,
-0.0081387535,
-0.0485968068,
0.042729564,
-0.0088124936,
0.0013530608,
-0.0013567472,
0.0584651306,
0.0016739276,
0.0222152714,
0.0056580799,
-0.0357878581,
0.0487918109,
-0.0351696275,
-0.002310385,
-0.0026403395,
-0.038677983,
0.045818679,
-0.0689449161,
-0.0060101468,
0.0361877903,
0.010191204,
0.0323864333,
0.0518970564,
0.0577766113,
0.0561201349,
-0.0284998063,
-0.0662878305,
-0.0414695665,
0.0915162712,
0.0017004916,
0.0443650186,
-0.0714274421,
0.0524750054,
-0.0183051042,
-0.0167064779,
0.0164642744,
0.0464996323,
0.0632256493,
0.0392667502,
-0.0312781222,
-0.0167209264,
-0.0050651766,
0.0177464802,
-0.0166310668,
-0.0422525816,
-0.0066165761,
0.0338226035,
0.0395944491,
0.0171623081,
0.0411441401,
-0.0516149849,
-0.0457388386,
0.0510907397,
-0.0147491824,
0.0495343879,
-0.0210998878,
-0.023935521,
-0.0973534286,
-0.0050521572,
-0.0582936034,
-0.0337883867,
-0.0218435824,
0.0640943199,
-0.0719963834,
0.0253267474,
0.0152627043,
-0.0251228232,
-0.0074597625,
-0.0371989049,
0.0251136385,
-0.0509865284,
0.0734452456,
-0.0074203811,
0.0042820154,
0.0074742702,
0.018631313,
-0.0691081583,
0.0033228225,
0.060198728,
-0.0228811558,
-0.0153540643,
0.001813032,
-0.0104425075,
-0.0539979637,
0.0186923146,
0.0196468234,
0.0338286012,
-0.0286955107,
-0.0571754836,
2.898e-7,
-0.0380610041,
0.0531744994,
0.0128401807,
0.0384897254,
0.0118937232,
0.0649085194,
-0.0393240266,
0.010820643,
-0.0124123273,
-0.0231864452,
0.0189468879,
0.0574083552,
-0.0100238966,
0.0112801744,
-0.0170835741,
0.0007188765,
0.0035873312,
-0.0349027105,
-0.0299468543,
-0.0150650749,
-0.0083867069,
0.0250640195,
0.0135773104,
0.0128625957,
-0.0185071491,
-0.0495640412,
0.0267193262,
-0.0651928931,
-0.0249925852,
0.0554646179,
-0.0138795376,
-0.0536767282,
-0.0294558741,
-0.0040347814,
0.0668343157,
0.0206492748,
-0.0294648018,
0.0619308315,
-0.0181676988,
-0.0197870173,
-0.0052121896,
-0.0340760797,
-0.0444547795,
-0.0129362941,
0.0044043236,
-0.0511499457,
-0.021025423,
-0.0024904134,
0.0343944766,
-0.0379792675,
-0.0063611562,
-0.0156325754,
0.0201566946,
0.0135364039,
-0.0377752483,
0.0049374313,
0.0125339469,
-0.0039216639,
0.0353448056,
0.0118076624,
-0.0429063588,
-0.0478540212,
0.0158692636,
-0.0018846795,
-0.0069335001,
0.0213789511,
-0.0157741662,
2.054860782e-34,
0.0277986657,
-0.0087705282,
-0.0067163669,
0.0689524338,
0.0006794558,
-0.0074828607,
-0.0974074528,
0.0095732119,
0.0213812292,
-0.0344885252,
-0.0370823033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20150v1 | Unlearn What You Want to Forget: Efficient Unlearning for LLMs | 2023-10-31T03:35:59 | 2023-10-31T03:35:59 | Jiaao Chen, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant progress from
pre-training on and memorizing a wide range of textual data, however, this
process might suffer from privacy issues and violations of data protection
regulations. As a result, the ability to easily remove data related to
individual users from such models while not deteriorating their predictive
quality after the removal becomes increasingly important. To address these
issues, in this work, we propose an efficient unlearning framework that could
efficiently update LLMs without having to retrain the whole model after data
removals, by introducing lightweight unlearning layers learned with a selective
teacher-student objective into the transformers. In addition, we introduce a
fusion mechanism to effectively combine different unlearning layers that learns
to forget different sets of data to handle a sequence of forgetting operations.
Experiments on classification and generation tasks demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed methods compared to the state-of-the-art
baselines. | [
0.0066351383,
0.1092334092,
0.0071610869,
0.0369189754,
-0.0215299651,
0.0053896238,
0.042255234,
-0.0218283888,
0.0280829184,
-0.0390686542,
-0.0627855808,
-0.0313793831,
-0.016228836,
-0.0241266005,
-0.0103430441,
-0.0121431099,
0.0249990057,
-0.0083276657,
-0.0308609791,
-0.0186489709,
-0.0102060288,
0.0061674356,
0.0040873792,
-0.0047193738,
0.0146543765,
-0.0145511432,
-0.0075740116,
-0.0128048286,
0.0091280108,
0.000338988,
0.067505233,
0.0547685213,
0.0065145874,
0.0613218583,
0.0000020307,
-0.0377297886,
-0.057428211,
-0.0021968011,
-0.0338232704,
0.0395644829,
0.0252790041,
0.0302048959,
-0.0018704905,
0.0492935292,
-0.0454679914,
0.0084104333,
0.0339400023,
0.0444783233,
0.0683061033,
0.0976248384,
0.0002462777,
-0.0290964972,
-0.0183411911,
-0.0366699062,
0.0143229635,
-0.0176952742,
0.04247934,
-0.0776144639,
-0.0811193436,
-0.0374577828,
0.0137462635,
0.0457590297,
0.0216380768,
0.0183184221,
0.001986112,
0.0328850076,
-0.0267604683,
-0.01420708,
-0.0197390411,
0.0577684157,
-0.0069897231,
-0.0225259494,
0.036919646,
0.013771954,
-0.0076099653,
-0.0067023039,
-0.0310429372,
0.0196021926,
0.0003509662,
0.0443591475,
-0.0414678715,
-0.0399034061,
0.0625799596,
0.02358092,
-0.0221167821,
0.0228059385,
0.0246629212,
-0.0093263201,
0.0101519078,
0.0002668866,
0.0210051574,
-0.0346964039,
0.0432598926,
0.0411413088,
-0.0197743122,
0.0258687865,
-0.0325420015,
-0.0200548116,
0.0316184051,
-0.0454274938,
0.0415663868,
0.0167449843,
-0.0029685174,
0.0532387346,
-0.0254066847,
0.0025084738,
0.0242547859,
0.0440412201,
-0.0107183857,
0.0122653106,
-0.0255336612,
-0.0145492312,
0.0088257706,
0.0605353937,
0.0118032945,
0.0333889201,
-0.0319470279,
0.0217969958,
-0.0297702961,
0.0172878094,
0.0312200971,
0.0173956919,
-0.0408949777,
-0.0146494498,
-0.0277813058,
0.0319661126,
0.0184022021,
0.0133175347,
0.0148631101,
-0.0597073361,
-0.023297023,
-0.0048386706,
0.0140710054,
-0.0087137138,
0.0173940361,
0.054953441,
-0.0228574164,
-0.0486172363,
-0.0811537504,
-0.0280014426,
0.0256504174,
-0.0739261582,
0.0169437192,
-0.0483589843,
0.0381520428,
-0.0287964176,
-0.0122391945,
-0.0888537616,
0.0110780038,
0.0429987423,
-0.0364915319,
0.0495634228,
-0.0151423495,
-0.0161085371,
0.0212071668,
0.012232705,
0.0081804153,
0.0419585593,
-0.0294267386,
0.0269119106,
0.0166711714,
-0.006275869,
0.0486467965,
0.029935563,
0.0444060043,
0.0040808162,
-0.0169427339,
-0.0237839818,
0.0055512027,
-0.0247576311,
-0.0039627086,
0.063280277,
-0.0287761129,
-0.0168501958,
0.0497030281,
0.0185075495,
0.0125636915,
0.0557606965,
-0.0220987815,
0.0027078274,
0.0065046642,
0.0241214316,
-0.0637312904,
-0.0018888814,
-0.0367747992,
-0.0229900293,
-0.0232809465,
0.039009016,
-0.0611400679,
-0.0410491526,
0.015161871,
-0.0708296746,
0.027536517,
0.0491362251,
0.0414859764,
0.0424980894,
-0.0222677309,
0.1140806153,
0.0410180762,
-0.1143131405,
0.0403796621,
-0.0336711518,
-0.000005341,
0.0535644777,
0.0314247198,
-0.0371540263,
-0.0187517554,
-0.0059283054,
-0.0009221446,
-0.0218536947,
0.0135050844,
-0.0059596961,
0.0736213252,
-0.0890162736,
-0.0487086028,
0.0328123122,
0.0171043742,
0.0121508446,
0.044270359,
-0.0512683168,
0.0499900468,
-0.0212501287,
-0.0103623811,
0.0369391553,
-0.0827275813,
-0.0593365803,
0.0313810147,
0.0117780296,
0.0049694758,
0.0210161824,
0.0087990686,
-0.016558744,
0.0581425466,
-0.006139006,
-0.0252529662,
-0.025566088,
-0.0565909781,
-0.0130536808,
0.0387957096,
0.0001604291,
0.0214004908,
0.0750591606,
-0.0424073711,
-0.0365032032,
-0.0027911225,
0.0098591223,
0.0650302917,
-0.0539708138,
0.0365338288,
-0.006983473,
0.007359962,
-0.0141610857,
0.0490354151,
-0.0340796486,
-0.0050348239,
-0.0101854224,
-0.0309551116,
-0.0126751019,
-0.0370290689,
-0.0470337756,
-0.0094775436,
-0.0187934209,
0.0529948696,
0.0177287403,
-0.0112296697,
-0.0545688979,
-0.0353032686,
-0.0615973994,
0.0139064919,
-0.0367793813,
0.0197372157,
0.0033718464,
0.0228335671,
0.0013834749,
-0.0543646701,
-0.0453617275,
-0.026868118,
-0.0325668082,
0.0171049684,
-0.0020202282,
-0.0156017458,
-0.0152433086,
-0.0037633171,
-0.0167082045,
0.0233628154,
0.0218535103,
-0.0464312471,
-0.0153677063,
-0.0109953657,
0.0399479158,
-0.0482027568,
0.0480035357,
0.0118986461,
-0.0104519743,
-0.0380079374,
-0.005078441,
0.0120439511,
0.0201007444,
-0.0100899963,
0.0452102572,
0.0735430196,
-0.0062011769,
-0.0348562524,
0.0183451194,
-0.0605815984,
-0.0362320803,
-0.0196948852,
0.017161971,
0.0154334204,
0.0238126945,
-0.0010602259,
-0.012834263,
-0.0112996846,
-0.0135951741,
-0.0088360962,
-0.0281512477,
-0.0272529423,
0.0119927824,
-0.0323575214,
-0.006583218,
-0.0023944781,
-0.0382481217,
0.0331062339,
-0.0101011889,
0.0223280918,
-0.0238573011,
-0.0314357243,
-0.0312322695,
0.0157978628,
0.0080693346,
0.0358546153,
0.0133209871,
-0.0582158566,
-0.0332224965,
-0.0233827196,
0.0148099996,
-0.0663723722,
0.054443527,
-0.0275701731,
-0.0045091999,
-0.0013378088,
-0.0429997742,
-0.0612272955,
-0.0322490856,
-0.007063482,
-0.0100676753,
-0.0321889557,
-0.0276613832,
-0.0642782226,
-0.0844800845,
0.0343740769,
0.0291990433,
0.0098470161,
0.0148326689,
-0.0003910729,
0.0315795913,
0.0031932506,
0.0019991267,
-0.0250563901,
-0.0396069027,
0.0159582607,
0.1013991684,
0.0567423739,
-0.0098813716,
0.0142356725,
-0.0168317687,
0.038399443,
-0.0217440091,
0.0065732305,
0.0340698697,
0.0308690388,
-0.0443202592,
0.0055866218,
0.0879816413,
0.0108956797,
-0.0649927258,
-0.0385559388,
0.0455304906,
0.0436866134,
0.0187926106,
0.0166854337,
-0.0751608014,
-0.0211444497,
0.0269773826,
0.0497864373,
0.0148135424,
-0.0279133115,
-0.030130377,
-0.0859686732,
-0.0109563265,
0.0319313407,
-0.0033433642,
0.0133569753,
-0.0568543933,
-0.002745023,
-0.0238106605,
0.0496983565,
0.009499887,
-0.0091126207,
-0.014763522,
0.028834369,
-0.0435491167,
-0.0728110969,
-0.0165491346,
-0.0123452796,
0.0344964974,
0.0375220366,
0.0274499394,
-0.0053482139,
-0.0644595698,
0.0287285689,
0.0029932824,
-0.0096636685,
-0.0216974635,
0.0777092576,
0.0083213896,
-0.0008014816,
-0.0117558595,
0.0767477974,
-0.031209508,
-0.0343278535,
-0.0071675717,
0.042502813,
-0.0029426215,
-0.0150372423,
0.0351375714,
-0.034601476,
0.0015700541,
0.076385498,
0.0011993506,
-0.0431281067,
-0.0147245303,
-0.0170719996,
0.010420844,
-0.0158555582,
0.003842738,
0.035391476,
-0.0194075294,
-0.0443156771,
-0.0402723774,
-0.0142656313,
0.0248363707,
-0.0110699674,
0.0211682171,
0.0217682347,
0.0293898415,
-0.0097629586,
-0.0357501432,
0.0075789266,
-0.0763113871,
0.0060546417,
-0.0334661528,
0.0007692089,
-0.0020207344,
-0.0006252563,
0.0113221146,
0.0039155986,
-0.1023401842,
-0.1000101566,
0.0599124283,
0.0195122808,
0.0200997852,
0.0475794561,
0.0148896575,
-0.0616759807,
0.0923532546,
0.0848497376,
-0.0341701955,
0.0114938766,
0.0441517234,
-0.020571785,
-0.009182184,
0.0317742489,
-0.0451043025,
-0.0024344076,
0.0461279005,
0.0077101551,
-0.0348031595,
0.0119346799,
0.0190116316,
0.0148526262,
0.0621308349,
0.0072998521,
0.029571699,
-0.0221477486,
0.0310027786,
0.0052117165,
-0.0208064727,
-0.0121993786,
0.0034297293,
0.0362468176,
0.0090142023,
0.0109090395,
0.0137542104,
0.0197074637,
0.028105827,
-0.0132849924,
-0.0233247224,
0.0317616165,
-0.02240506,
0.038072329,
0.0165718291,
-0.0289629716,
0.0341291502,
0.0320227519,
0.0113194697,
-0.0087919626,
0.0242947303,
0.0070028203,
0.0292380508,
-0.0429039188,
-0.0022002726,
-0.0387643315,
-0.0454339162,
-0.054021243,
-0.004370328,
0.0212830435,
-0.0047660177,
-0.0005943396,
-0.0178108048,
-0.0067988816,
-0.0312466826,
0.0126531031,
-0.0193036888,
-0.0225142241,
-0.0150510622,
-0.009368577,
-0.0171485692,
0.0291191097,
0.0823540464,
-0.0224495474,
0.0417800769,
-0.0183849595,
0.0200156346,
-0.0582301095,
-0.0427505597,
0.0213324148,
0.0170443933,
-0.0187616926,
-0.0377879217,
-0.0029902442,
-0.061544437,
0.012610333,
-0.0182086825,
0.0068885419,
-0.0242925957,
0.0407005399,
0.026003601,
-0.0341832153,
0.0078034946,
-0.0570378974,
-0.0252475403,
0.0190057401,
-0.02942257,
0.0045108888,
-6.596089654e-33,
0.0203275196,
0.0016770351,
0.01574165,
0.0388337635,
-0.0054952856,
0.0051057469,
0.0005961322,
-0.0177638233,
-0.0043658875,
-0.027290415,
-0.0382980444,
0.0089634378,
0.0171141736,
0.0570395701,
-0.0281709787,
-0.0079353126,
0.1034169346,
-0.0191369466,
-0.0064688125,
0.0468383022,
0.0668184683,
0.0622149557,
0.0578313246,
-0.0650287643,
0.0072061541,
-0.0125946142,
-0.0541827381,
0.0499181971,
-0.0223392919,
0.0239427611,
-0.0370202959,
0.0506296679,
0.0070180651,
-0.0151773477,
-0.0285322573,
0.0369372703,
-0.0930179432,
-0.0070653851,
-0.0344822407,
0.0047483472,
-0.0034346455,
-0.0510694161,
0.0559363626,
-0.0262126494,
0.0044523757,
-0.0362805277,
0.013492832,
0.0228678863,
-0.0472473502,
-0.0198249016,
0.0081720799,
0.0113324402,
0.0077759563,
-0.029423181,
0.0203512479,
0.0106697381,
-0.0099811926,
-0.001220847,
-0.1101831496,
0.0036418082,
0.0333420262,
0.0300963633,
0.0469379611,
0.0432299897,
-0.0085647684,
0.089421764,
0.0409701131,
0.0153172892,
-0.0008871826,
-0.038382031,
0.0360482261,
0.0382967107,
0.0139857335,
0.0052057845,
0.0418396406,
-0.0643400773,
-0.0449781753,
0.0361795127,
-0.0126104699,
0.0309055001,
0.0141991172,
0.034266863,
0.0265898649,
-0.0299120601,
-0.0459411927,
0.012452106,
-0.045232892,
-0.0046286732,
0.0095676053,
0.0383231305,
-0.0356565267,
-0.006670204,
0.0168221369,
-0.0338603221,
-0.0359995924,
0.0430401117,
0.0373180769,
-0.0060766945,
-0.0132580036,
-0.0143056624,
-0.0567088574,
-0.0154611152,
-0.0087984027,
-0.0125370985,
-0.0047512664,
0.0041835792,
0.0846127421,
0.0682653859,
-0.076325193,
-0.0012394317,
-0.0364242755,
0.0420109481,
0.0458204374,
0.049396392,
0.0079422798,
0.0162080396,
-0.000928783,
0.0406824946,
0.0348872356,
0.0280728079,
-0.0623677485,
-0.0043518911,
0.0199376829,
-0.0066615911,
0.0047279503,
-0.0218763929,
-0.002124999,
0.0258673392,
0.0686299577,
-0.0372900739,
0.0264878385,
-0.004531513,
2.685e-7,
-0.0048351367,
-0.0110251121,
0.0055186888,
-0.035606198,
0.0044638664,
0.0419468097,
-0.0188040808,
0.0341753215,
0.0052965316,
0.0278518889,
0.0096925152,
0.0104062026,
0.0710391924,
0.0338979587,
-0.115252465,
0.0136135761,
-0.0706422329,
-0.0260181688,
-0.0346907973,
-0.0075500342,
0.0037654887,
0.0842168257,
0.0560976304,
-0.0507732444,
-0.0020428696,
-0.0210014656,
0.0792690143,
-0.0643195882,
-0.0181397572,
0.009241486,
0.0732533038,
0.0420099981,
0.0159540959,
-0.0337680094,
-0.0605119057,
0.0180441849,
-0.0285942797,
0.0777663663,
0.0268506892,
-0.0585036911,
0.0162480045,
0.0116579589,
-0.0105416002,
0.0182774272,
0.0513111986,
-0.0315108709,
-0.0084093781,
-0.0042337347,
-0.0059030228,
-0.0362005718,
0.0227851942,
0.0044332123,
-0.0065908451,
0.0367583446,
-0.0031020546,
0.0019805715,
-0.0303098764,
-0.0981481522,
-0.0311080869,
-0.0276908744,
-0.0588792413,
-0.0430206656,
-0.0000594386,
-0.0017620522,
-0.0192588046,
-0.07816571,
0.0694947392,
2.053559244e-34,
-0.0014986804,
-0.0186102334,
0.0086867511,
0.033126846,
0.0030103282,
-0.0132974209,
0.0377684906,
0.0265484564,
0.0092537655,
-0.0658708811,
-0.0043499786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20144v1 | EELBERT: Tiny Models through Dynamic Embeddings | 2023-10-31T03:28:08 | 2023-10-31T03:28:08 | Gabrielle Cohn, Rishika Agarwal, Deepanshu Gupta, Siddharth Patwardhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T07, I.2.7; I.2.6 | We introduce EELBERT, an approach for compression of transformer-based models
(e.g., BERT), with minimal impact on the accuracy of downstream tasks. This is
achieved by replacing the input embedding layer of the model with dynamic, i.e.
on-the-fly, embedding computations. Since the input embedding layer accounts
for a significant fraction of the model size, especially for the smaller BERT
variants, replacing this layer with an embedding computation function helps us
reduce the model size significantly. Empirical evaluation on the GLUE benchmark
shows that our BERT variants (EELBERT) suffer minimal regression compared to
the traditional BERT models. Through this approach, we are able to develop our
smallest model UNO-EELBERT, which achieves a GLUE score within 4% of fully
trained BERT-tiny, while being 15x smaller (1.2 MB) in size. | [
-0.0084540071,
0.0402516797,
-0.0029150075,
0.0153426621,
-0.0022699214,
-0.006513631,
0.022536166,
0.0011169775,
-0.0190353021,
0.0103099877,
-0.0089004692,
0.0083162999,
0.0022828674,
0.005273744,
0.0468913987,
-0.0697582215,
0.0195631273,
0.0141004017,
-0.0228189919,
-0.0137159005,
-0.0022878898,
-0.0165064745,
0.0217560101,
0.0791697279,
-0.0066096974,
0.0311388653,
-0.0677137598,
0.0409288593,
0.0076318006,
0.0394969247,
0.0102117686,
0.0550597869,
0.0494773872,
0.0560047254,
0.0000018151,
0.0132613406,
-0.0186216664,
0.0340076461,
-0.0239459779,
0.0028392216,
-0.025217535,
-0.0038166407,
-0.0224002209,
0.042350892,
0.0099156955,
-0.0417237021,
0.0657586679,
0.0532626994,
0.0667882487,
0.0564825833,
-0.0131032551,
-0.0181126986,
0.0176951494,
-0.0409489609,
-0.0012492557,
0.0222722758,
-0.0008488402,
-0.0420437939,
-0.0260473639,
-0.0125142382,
-0.0381558351,
0.0280250143,
0.0544850267,
0.0112238778,
0.0004501588,
0.0423788168,
-0.0579303652,
-0.0370525829,
0.0119178258,
0.0429654419,
-0.0673698336,
-0.0277928188,
-0.0189579763,
0.015141123,
0.0150673036,
-0.0083329184,
-0.0497080833,
0.0048919241,
0.0255572647,
0.0114330966,
-0.0507722311,
0.0025436874,
0.0225000661,
-0.0155412015,
-0.0551113486,
-0.015756594,
0.0257452559,
-0.0121842846,
-0.0525415838,
-0.0176109932,
-0.0293884836,
-0.0351126865,
0.0137048466,
0.0388246588,
0.0245673489,
-0.026499236,
-0.0658508837,
-0.0398681648,
0.000661745,
-0.0358041748,
0.0626400411,
0.0542694032,
0.0016850771,
0.0259577911,
-0.0709851235,
0.0746915713,
-0.0474501476,
0.0425919481,
-0.0134001132,
-0.0241519231,
-0.0306230169,
0.0012789288,
-0.0867565423,
0.0515671447,
-0.034944851,
-0.0332475491,
-0.0095801102,
0.0166666228,
0.0140663749,
0.0051771933,
0.0168223623,
0.0288115703,
-0.050582055,
0.006841315,
0.0432669595,
0.0474133566,
-0.0403130203,
0.002142373,
0.0134534789,
-0.0108842235,
-0.0291544292,
0.0104465289,
0.0157242808,
-0.0284189954,
0.0155110937,
0.0184345376,
0.008507235,
-0.0517113581,
-0.0143844858,
0.0156757478,
0.0132102603,
-0.0226176344,
0.0150662903,
-0.0493571572,
0.0267528649,
-0.031273976,
0.0038542694,
-0.0192846917,
0.0078903073,
0.0029978035,
-0.0289564393,
0.0414603129,
-0.0062732752,
-0.0111465873,
0.0058441274,
0.0092880605,
0.0080919992,
0.0339039229,
0.0509841517,
0.0388065353,
0.0032026544,
-0.0301383249,
-0.0379335582,
0.0343231782,
0.0562589169,
-0.0046101762,
-0.068070747,
-0.0216447599,
-0.0253979098,
0.0115581881,
0.0034906059,
0.0779883787,
-0.04347267,
-0.0531996563,
0.0687711462,
0.0512478799,
0.0465965159,
0.0701023042,
0.0233294461,
0.0156356767,
0.0269547217,
-0.0047348947,
-0.0394677967,
0.0415365621,
-0.0061141723,
0.0108214617,
0.0090045733,
0.0368291028,
-0.0608090423,
-0.0107748294,
-0.0114591541,
-0.0284501389,
-0.0083917975,
-0.0262968484,
0.0363480896,
0.0169832427,
-0.0471792072,
0.123381868,
-0.0201567858,
-0.0528480783,
-0.0460762717,
-0.0634413064,
-0.0211332198,
0.0315761156,
0.0499671586,
0.0182185322,
-0.0984833613,
-0.0069454289,
-0.0180178303,
0.0289994292,
0.0109630404,
-0.0057238336,
0.0247592535,
-0.0467801765,
-0.0302588642,
0.01654559,
-0.011529359,
-0.0117469197,
0.0570928156,
-0.0029917655,
0.0112314057,
-0.0488446727,
0.0370423198,
0.0304154977,
-0.026839029,
-0.0043774545,
0.0154484836,
0.0334366895,
0.0070973197,
-0.0160962883,
-0.0294911359,
-0.0091837468,
0.0669796541,
-0.0388719104,
-0.0294294618,
0.0015941601,
-0.0302471071,
-0.0295378026,
0.0246341228,
0.0029064254,
0.0331730656,
0.0628136918,
-0.0455846153,
-0.0303105079,
-0.0307787843,
-0.0718106404,
0.0768707618,
-0.0369026773,
-0.0033640722,
-0.0290596131,
-0.0104195466,
-0.0063863262,
0.0115631195,
-0.051343441,
0.0093365153,
0.0306479726,
0.0436646529,
0.0104103582,
-0.0171836969,
-0.0631173626,
-0.0081161112,
-0.0195412319,
0.0180808138,
0.0205623265,
-0.0213613547,
0.0226569343,
-0.0528801791,
-0.0711555853,
-0.0060818107,
-0.0019847355,
0.0137379095,
0.0072312653,
0.034274321,
0.0266102888,
-0.0079504633,
-0.0000063486,
-0.0155047709,
-0.0290773008,
0.0149685619,
-0.000621004,
0.0000853309,
-0.0310019236,
-0.0226623267,
-0.0415592641,
0.0059847878,
0.0544364937,
-0.0506529547,
-0.0328432061,
-0.0424959362,
-0.0283581205,
-0.0122239552,
0.0498734415,
0.0069822031,
-0.093616426,
-0.001704606,
-0.0206118822,
0.052649498,
0.0725664869,
0.0154563952,
0.0328378715,
0.0239364766,
0.0252552591,
-0.067115739,
0.0351780131,
-0.031411767,
0.018270744,
-0.0255111922,
-0.0179601703,
-0.0355035588,
0.076639086,
-0.0648029745,
0.007409221,
-0.100722231,
-0.0228474773,
0.0335582197,
-0.0120963585,
0.0036203836,
-0.0034332657,
-0.0206694417,
-0.0335579626,
-0.0259413999,
-0.0563544966,
0.0490279384,
-0.0344285965,
-0.0065665594,
0.0192378405,
-0.0008846411,
-0.013269187,
0.0433696248,
0.0112408241,
0.0403156653,
-0.0129767098,
-0.0130206896,
-0.0693189129,
0.0036790906,
-0.0204515196,
-0.0205088295,
0.0222443379,
0.0175379477,
-0.0170917846,
-0.0172213968,
-0.0501043797,
-0.033536803,
-0.033396136,
0.0029742741,
0.0482486933,
0.0055217105,
-0.0824605599,
-0.0886566788,
0.0183765218,
0.0202966407,
0.0669821352,
0.0044655432,
0.0097832028,
-0.0099281287,
0.044794593,
0.0130829616,
0.0484319888,
0.0458822325,
-0.0041374834,
0.0232314225,
0.0488938652,
0.0504395366,
0.0024349529,
-0.0903355703,
-0.011577053,
0.0217768438,
-0.003202399,
-0.0277988445,
0.0068604746,
0.0174045712,
-0.0651123524,
-0.0205188449,
0.1034860313,
0.0161728673,
0.0119267143,
0.0045522787,
-0.0074463123,
0.0937291309,
0.0044311495,
0.0313278548,
-0.0388561226,
-0.0240818691,
0.0403144509,
0.0258393753,
0.0398734659,
0.0056718965,
0.013419182,
-0.0921230018,
0.0271342937,
0.0125145698,
0.0563085973,
-0.0098449998,
-0.0386745594,
-0.0295562726,
0.0036199156,
-0.0272105522,
0.0085428087,
-0.0148541797,
-0.010191408,
0.0337549113,
-0.022255417,
-0.039383743,
0.0057138014,
-0.0326124653,
0.0287402514,
0.0321354307,
0.0072754938,
0.0113864169,
-0.0751523897,
0.0447955355,
0.0135105141,
-0.0214912295,
-0.0016576336,
0.0430527441,
-0.0093557853,
-0.0128609017,
-0.0024563284,
0.0135985129,
0.0081617422,
-0.0118390247,
-0.0711928904,
0.085281834,
0.011477489,
0.0252277479,
-0.0393097848,
-0.0466619432,
-0.0616553687,
0.0615384653,
0.0399703048,
-0.0171950329,
-0.0447206683,
0.0039060272,
-0.008554426,
-0.0134456567,
-0.0307447612,
0.0296652988,
-0.0110080028,
-0.0829022527,
-0.0441701449,
-0.0029837615,
0.0231814831,
0.0695196465,
-0.0110574597,
-0.0687600151,
0.0074392078,
0.0469535887,
-0.104759492,
0.0271433964,
0.0176790655,
0.0074420772,
-0.0742647499,
0.0106349308,
0.049363073,
0.0325491242,
-0.0206946321,
-0.0283735506,
-0.0667742565,
-0.0343088545,
0.0018962455,
0.0789504573,
0.0244043134,
0.0356182642,
-0.0163889173,
-0.0188039169,
0.0628511235,
0.0534223914,
-0.0152847562,
0.0060327617,
0.0688334778,
-0.0733374059,
0.0120560629,
0.0622382201,
-0.0606561787,
-0.0064934404,
-0.0318750739,
0.0281202048,
-0.0171358809,
-0.0068102917,
0.0109511977,
-0.015484497,
0.0274592713,
-0.0079470649,
0.0283378586,
0.0035401713,
0.0535649322,
0.0119067961,
0.0278154034,
-0.0686483458,
0.0201019645,
0.0067262221,
0.0062068691,
0.0269971248,
0.0279689543,
0.0314564072,
0.0125582358,
-0.0463032722,
0.0269801877,
-0.0320055708,
0.0026124234,
0.0425102636,
0.0165830273,
-0.0191127658,
-0.0190081708,
0.0069463393,
-0.0005725441,
-0.0552353226,
-0.017195968,
0.0379896387,
0.0341411643,
-0.0495332517,
0.0531291179,
-0.0354363434,
-0.0424038544,
-0.0666154251,
0.0277721547,
0.0012019062,
0.0207375903,
0.0235530064,
-0.0129437679,
-0.0203410946,
-0.0127594238,
0.0001401231,
0.0094360141,
-0.0382165387,
0.0406060033,
0.0171019528,
0.0115030752,
-0.0138404202,
0.0800603181,
0.0052200831,
0.0579071343,
-0.0197332222,
0.0001783025,
-0.0455804281,
-0.032966394,
0.0485339053,
-0.0096619707,
-0.012919412,
-0.0176652409,
-0.0308443457,
-0.0638710186,
-0.0029313473,
0.0132838646,
-0.0112754349,
-0.0136844739,
0.0358710922,
0.0102277696,
0.0342360102,
-0.031737823,
0.0278508533,
-0.0138179343,
-0.0049376865,
-0.026609024,
0.0389114544,
-5.752810211e-33,
-0.0234087016,
0.0242674239,
-0.0004819555,
-0.0312529802,
-0.0242842827,
0.0459704548,
-0.0313793123,
-0.0134815369,
-0.011638551,
-0.0001306061,
-0.0166150443,
0.0273099355,
0.0066239838,
0.0350531079,
0.0009300971,
0.0243652146,
0.0920618847,
-0.0132158073,
-0.0268527586,
0.0167276319,
0.016458692,
0.0297746658,
0.0125731844,
-0.0040037963,
-0.0651058331,
0.0161044076,
-0.0117103374,
0.0181283988,
0.0338556059,
0.0546526089,
-0.0119545888,
-0.0161302797,
-0.0258013234,
-0.0355639011,
-0.0245650187,
0.0304206535,
-0.1020190939,
-0.0106069148,
-0.0341589786,
0.0210102461,
-0.0455876142,
-0.0115270205,
0.0439816527,
-0.008386679,
0.0172881894,
-0.0381896496,
0.0000128457,
-0.0323468074,
-0.0333204567,
-0.0286701787,
-0.026242137,
0.0109619172,
0.0077123884,
-0.0506932847,
0.0597409457,
0.0625573173,
0.0126095107,
-0.0165660437,
-0.0432832986,
-0.0151367402,
0.0127387792,
0.0420302972,
0.0418237485,
-0.0063641854,
0.0043919147,
0.0411037691,
0.008903224,
-0.0146207819,
-0.0169232916,
0.0005795934,
0.0540604889,
0.0730381459,
0.0726631731,
-0.0120015461,
0.029935265,
0.0079826768,
-0.0524722412,
0.0401585512,
0.0394243337,
0.0533868596,
0.00570308,
0.0084369481,
-0.0024689762,
0.0204009805,
-0.0111086629,
-0.0113065951,
0.0024164561,
-0.0280868486,
0.0230272356,
0.0349790901,
-0.0351769365,
0.0018782105,
0.0636198893,
-0.0350780413,
0.0352650657,
0.0085277287,
-0.0036665136,
0.0356653258,
0.0125922067,
0.0483451635,
-0.0224499125,
-0.0494209044,
0.0399451815,
0.0133231925,
0.014443825,
0.0181507915,
0.0363955386,
0.0672992244,
-0.0789094865,
-0.0144289415,
-0.0361703075,
-0.0158969704,
-0.0053975987,
0.035417255,
0.0669734254,
-0.0038529269,
0.0109278616,
-0.0016098222,
-0.0301465075,
0.0232684352,
-0.005425802,
0.0453936607,
0.0376764685,
0.035335321,
0.0034305532,
-0.0238465853,
-0.0768546239,
0.0525087081,
-0.0100809829,
-0.0664738193,
-0.0257233866,
0.0186656285,
2.552e-7,
0.0090428432,
0.0264937244,
0.0421919748,
-0.0168305989,
0.0214403011,
0.0302173998,
-0.0134835346,
0.0326609425,
-0.0245850123,
0.0093434313,
0.0179911032,
0.0101813115,
0.0351181515,
0.00318195,
-0.0625578165,
-0.0189751778,
-0.0725045651,
0.0136842625,
-0.0238859188,
-0.0125004333,
0.012182558,
0.134309411,
0.0194188058,
-0.0153958555,
0.0168174189,
-0.0178608187,
0.0468889028,
-0.0012715554,
0.0331933461,
-0.0066249762,
0.001871114,
0.0585665219,
-0.0286561362,
-0.0278249104,
-0.0242741499,
0.0373737551,
-0.0115376348,
0.0627261475,
-0.0347006917,
-0.029761225,
0.0271700434,
-0.0386568904,
-0.037993107,
-0.063670814,
0.026347965,
-0.062790364,
-0.0092857676,
0.0172339063,
-0.0252538845,
0.0067918161,
0.0103786997,
-0.0237169489,
-0.016493395,
-0.001108743,
0.032672815,
-0.0548833311,
0.0180316344,
-0.0877873451,
-0.0046913889,
0.0000950719,
-0.0563881844,
-0.0120106246,
-0.0575541705,
-0.0235701595,
0.0604358129,
-0.0489856191,
-0.0215048678,
2.668409829e-34,
0.0143731888,
-0.0092281178,
0.0051854905,
0.0699668154,
-0.0081048636,
-0.0357028544,
0.0367151052,
-0.0202732962,
0.0087245898,
-0.0591571443,
-0.065632984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20138v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20138v2 | DEPN: Detecting and Editing Privacy Neurons in Pretrained Language Models | 2023-10-31T03:09:36 | 2023-12-05T16:14:24 | Xinwei Wu, Junzhuo Li, Minghui Xu, Weilong Dong, Shuangzhi Wu, Chao Bian, Deyi Xiong | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Large language models pretrained on a huge amount of data capture rich
knowledge and information in the training data. The ability of data
memorization and regurgitation in pretrained language models, revealed in
previous studies, brings the risk of data leakage. In order to effectively
reduce these risks, we propose a framework DEPN to Detect and Edit Privacy
Neurons in pretrained language models, partially inspired by knowledge neurons
and model editing. In DEPN, we introduce a novel method, termed as privacy
neuron detector, to locate neurons associated with private information, and
then edit these detected privacy neurons by setting their activations to zero.
Furthermore, we propose a privacy neuron aggregator dememorize private
information in a batch processing manner. Experimental results show that our
method can significantly and efficiently reduce the exposure of private data
leakage without deteriorating the performance of the model. Additionally, we
empirically demonstrate the relationship between model memorization and privacy
neurons, from multiple perspectives, including model size, training time,
prompts, privacy neuron distribution, illustrating the robustness of our
approach. | [
0.0173796322,
0.1188383698,
-0.0262695327,
0.0619689934,
-0.0225400236,
-0.026618354,
0.0537021346,
-0.0251665674,
-0.0134948902,
-0.0107553769,
-0.0859722421,
-0.0097443108,
0.008097576,
0.0280905813,
0.019645771,
0.0103909206,
0.0793936774,
-0.0003085816,
0.0224686917,
-0.0177760217,
-0.0244900063,
-0.0025758054,
0.012596963,
-0.0104592433,
0.0153081883,
-0.0127237709,
-0.0351600423,
-0.0184704438,
0.0131090218,
-0.0167483333,
0.039870061,
0.0544139929,
0.0259896889,
0.0743061155,
0.0000020322,
-0.0219972897,
-0.0236277934,
0.0245688353,
-0.0616261959,
0.0683501363,
-0.0098230978,
0.0008411567,
0.0180310886,
-0.0192755107,
-0.0274922363,
-0.0109031992,
0.0387047604,
0.039010711,
0.0566165783,
0.0859680474,
0.0038784118,
-0.0043008747,
0.0219563004,
-0.0452068262,
0.0248142742,
-0.0632657111,
0.0203349274,
-0.0680395961,
-0.0732062235,
0.0056858691,
-0.0101909395,
0.0412355214,
0.0264327303,
0.0177483074,
0.010904355,
0.026877882,
0.033808846,
-0.0293999594,
-0.0306448117,
0.0393284857,
-0.001535245,
-0.0376972109,
0.0185429174,
0.0068203863,
0.0514451377,
-0.0200442355,
0.0140457926,
0.0109742461,
0.0024845477,
-0.006400187,
-0.0131234797,
-0.0260833278,
0.042454157,
0.0036539577,
0.0103376629,
0.0357059576,
0.0096162129,
-0.0072526485,
-0.0300989337,
-0.0345298275,
0.0273956228,
-0.0844095573,
0.087793678,
0.0189326964,
0.029366577,
0.0311461184,
-0.0827639624,
-0.0411602668,
0.0159229655,
-0.0225706957,
0.0363430716,
0.0122582084,
0.0345444269,
0.027793834,
-0.0107509252,
0.0101955272,
-0.0170316771,
0.061278563,
0.0258289222,
0.0329770893,
-0.0041126139,
-0.0162593629,
-0.0278991479,
0.0550257638,
-0.0433478877,
-0.0102245109,
-0.0056700874,
0.0131575149,
-0.0208197162,
0.0035812855,
-0.0378615893,
0.0065006106,
-0.0232103858,
-0.0079047186,
-0.0114458231,
-0.0556737967,
-0.0109895188,
0.0013624715,
0.0395858549,
-0.0429504067,
-0.031185247,
-0.0754774436,
0.0165389162,
-0.0286086276,
-0.0123001728,
0.0296300352,
0.0076265885,
-0.02568659,
-0.0301018935,
-0.0805612653,
0.0354668647,
-0.0252895802,
0.0025370934,
-0.0173419174,
0.0377293006,
-0.0707149953,
-0.0280022137,
-0.0599015392,
-0.0026955365,
0.032486394,
-0.0449693315,
0.0792128295,
-0.0290323533,
-0.0143788448,
0.0104520498,
0.0408496372,
0.0007116272,
-0.0227650478,
0.0266806595,
0.0371279754,
0.053058289,
-0.0083624758,
0.0458609313,
-0.0106254816,
0.0990962088,
-0.0086918473,
-0.0182974879,
-0.0068958323,
-0.0026848596,
-0.0408696234,
0.0175671875,
0.0362206623,
-0.0313890204,
-0.0499375835,
0.088918753,
0.0560474247,
0.0034543218,
0.031147005,
-0.0433202684,
0.0109933289,
0.000148335,
-0.0043281373,
-0.0852103606,
0.0146491472,
-0.0636806041,
-0.0146569731,
-0.0399851948,
0.0210176446,
-0.0035748382,
-0.0172255561,
0.0473809987,
-0.0319460966,
0.0423822813,
0.0354525521,
-0.0230669025,
0.0475480705,
0.0053912173,
0.0648126081,
0.0032104449,
-0.0535047092,
-0.0111104911,
-0.0637819022,
0.0184262805,
0.0703402907,
0.0219996907,
-0.0318870731,
-0.0233219247,
-0.0418000706,
-0.047773432,
-0.0147215966,
0.0321443975,
0.0041075749,
0.0913018733,
-0.0330803879,
-0.031173531,
-0.0166302584,
0.0392668843,
0.0326869003,
0.0193247348,
-0.0197178163,
0.0151269138,
0.0004989365,
-0.0194477793,
0.0418917798,
-0.0240519699,
-0.0405699275,
0.0356618278,
0.0141764442,
0.0118040694,
0.0188773442,
-0.0110161342,
0.0164501537,
0.0286865383,
0.036003612,
0.0296349935,
-0.0255530104,
-0.0747909024,
-0.0454648137,
0.0062324894,
0.0338367112,
0.0136486376,
0.0504787378,
-0.0228667725,
-0.0196876787,
-0.0017131455,
-0.0022393193,
0.0683110729,
-0.0359712951,
0.0085733095,
-0.0194843207,
0.0295302179,
0.0019573548,
0.014756971,
-0.0334451832,
-0.0425660349,
-0.0480871759,
0.0117407581,
-0.0049396623,
-0.0217246693,
-0.0288796816,
-0.0211111214,
-0.0116961123,
0.0213589873,
0.0060674013,
-0.0032605235,
0.0071381927,
-0.0002340227,
-0.0288688,
-0.0038730225,
0.0101439729,
0.0133652622,
0.0279492661,
-0.0032950526,
-0.0126734218,
-0.0310810525,
-0.0320108123,
0.0253959466,
-0.0469139852,
0.0253519453,
0.0117908772,
0.0283310823,
-0.0168441739,
-0.0118086925,
-0.0150004076,
-0.0053286091,
0.0293857846,
-0.0471702591,
-0.0358867608,
-0.00681266,
0.0433236733,
-0.0250036661,
0.0431769527,
-0.0118751591,
-0.033993993,
-0.0217600968,
0.0243735164,
-0.0612039678,
0.0798265263,
-0.0035440235,
0.0224544574,
0.0558675602,
-0.0024012963,
-0.0279627759,
0.0049417857,
-0.0156610273,
0.0021548888,
-0.0399079621,
0.026489377,
0.036500603,
0.0242207572,
0.0144785121,
-0.0537208579,
-0.0004851478,
0.0298904479,
-0.0121090915,
-0.0645508319,
-0.0228000265,
-0.0583368018,
-0.0291837864,
0.062636517,
-0.0393819883,
-0.0452827886,
0.0679034889,
-0.0024770598,
0.0083404165,
-0.0006023541,
-0.0184978768,
0.0179649759,
0.0561690927,
0.0276759882,
0.0517527089,
0.0518868491,
-0.0539825708,
-0.0318433754,
-0.0174234286,
0.0047985772,
-0.0266196821,
0.0353156514,
-0.0040209489,
-0.0440586507,
0.0263180025,
-0.0473658592,
-0.0492552631,
-0.0672313273,
0.0159873199,
-0.0051667304,
0.0049386886,
-0.0496839322,
0.0061193467,
-0.0595784858,
0.0122518269,
0.059960153,
-0.0120558329,
0.0204065982,
-0.0287140086,
0.0044390718,
-0.0120877977,
-0.0409738161,
0.0278567765,
-0.0262067318,
0.0004155364,
0.0784597397,
0.0366631076,
0.0180661567,
0.0139807984,
-0.0244641118,
-0.0063295723,
-0.0162097365,
0.0087100584,
0.0154032698,
0.0445049144,
-0.0727992356,
-0.0068383855,
0.0856210962,
0.0141990827,
-0.0603311621,
-0.0105868662,
0.0639153272,
0.0094947256,
0.0069447937,
0.0078255124,
-0.0895111337,
0.0155576393,
0.0347242579,
0.0145920049,
-0.0109327435,
-0.0337579548,
-0.0536339507,
-0.0854312852,
-0.0420306101,
0.0141032161,
-0.0165222045,
-0.00711824,
0.0017150316,
-0.0116851097,
0.00795695,
0.029405389,
-0.0028268746,
0.0234811492,
-0.0234142989,
-0.0350000411,
0.0245631244,
-0.0277677812,
0.0149322003,
-0.0434483998,
0.0737654716,
0.0631785318,
0.0225883555,
-0.0193950739,
-0.036976479,
0.0374847464,
0.0196006224,
-0.000435656,
0.0174639635,
0.0708856881,
-0.0160492565,
-0.0081054568,
0.0078589898,
0.0544602014,
0.0134798121,
-0.0255869403,
-0.0029901541,
-0.0007262257,
-0.0051228078,
-0.0264945365,
0.0311375707,
-0.0327659063,
0.0224025771,
0.0491104051,
0.0256250668,
-0.0248788968,
0.0243186057,
-0.0113484198,
0.0097190673,
-0.0372151062,
0.0489877649,
0.0130135473,
0.0203297194,
-0.074285917,
-0.0421166755,
-0.0058864541,
-0.0062287189,
-0.0036738745,
0.0600159466,
-0.0046819299,
0.0653504804,
-0.0191437416,
-0.0442624316,
0.0133700976,
-0.0460138358,
0.0054839049,
-0.0292468965,
-0.0217274074,
0.0148458919,
0.025122188,
-0.0208230447,
0.0079578124,
-0.0640590265,
-0.08244358,
0.0454826318,
0.0611980595,
0.0094046062,
0.0490518175,
-0.0350726135,
-0.0602760687,
0.0781174377,
0.0437277481,
-0.0810796097,
0.0195790157,
0.0491781086,
-0.0213536602,
0.0044563371,
0.0127960071,
-0.0049582287,
-0.0147054037,
0.0649786592,
-0.0514800698,
-0.0482580736,
-0.0359782875,
-0.0078562768,
0.0272330046,
0.0209994968,
0.0245142374,
0.0574623272,
-0.0716989413,
0.0248408597,
-0.0111384057,
0.0260299984,
-0.0307768267,
0.0023379992,
0.052673962,
-0.0149010504,
0.0184920765,
-0.0317138173,
0.0672289655,
0.0046682032,
-0.0383701213,
-0.0324761234,
0.0217562225,
0.0158110671,
0.0207338594,
0.0206830893,
-0.0275870711,
0.0905663595,
-0.0024705438,
0.0386993103,
-0.0307086967,
0.0277524386,
0.0105099771,
-0.0293927342,
-0.0554576479,
0.0481132008,
-0.0648859143,
-0.0264729969,
-0.0143526103,
0.0390952528,
-0.0126199797,
0.0374984108,
-0.0138571262,
-0.0272756033,
-0.0074756807,
-0.0069346251,
-0.0032836529,
-0.0139515894,
-0.0314642936,
0.0014226774,
-0.0083627524,
0.0070626214,
0.0196554307,
0.0596872009,
-0.0039918208,
0.0593168661,
-0.0053191506,
-0.0117141986,
-0.0397891924,
0.0049322117,
0.0140770311,
0.0369486175,
-0.0441303104,
-0.0086322529,
-0.0071068481,
-0.0852200687,
-0.0142788757,
0.0198758002,
0.0082322499,
-0.0021369548,
0.0030928138,
-0.0039859633,
0.0048196544,
-0.0289387181,
-0.0406149589,
-0.0092385467,
0.0295517687,
-0.008474011,
-0.0232319515,
-5.811504113e-33,
-0.0187483914,
-0.0154212825,
-0.0155810853,
0.0208126027,
-0.0000633806,
-0.0058606239,
-0.0219955463,
-0.0101200202,
-0.0118585881,
-0.0220137089,
-0.0615878999,
0.0407843553,
0.0061692665,
0.026875712,
-0.0377549306,
-0.0219966453,
0.0693517327,
-0.0354044214,
0.0038767175,
0.0449419282,
0.0293075796,
0.065767847,
0.0622303337,
-0.0529126488,
0.0316167884,
0.0170135014,
-0.0419525728,
0.0326836519,
-0.0825880691,
0.0261715464,
-0.0178809576,
-0.0439377241,
0.0005562017,
0.0063893879,
-0.0284962747,
0.0482587777,
-0.0550339743,
-0.018176686,
-0.018528074,
0.0160559211,
0.0122185871,
-0.0751591176,
0.0526528843,
-0.0579173081,
0.0229049623,
0.0141736623,
-0.0208133943,
0.000994641,
-0.0248777252,
-0.0275596157,
0.0024267996,
-0.0173356291,
0.0135346437,
-0.0341445804,
0.0538511127,
-0.0258175079,
-0.0191543307,
-0.0640543178,
-0.0846896544,
-0.0090963673,
0.0681326389,
0.003694087,
0.0127179334,
0.0299355686,
0.0449295565,
0.0433941782,
0.0709996223,
0.0255069342,
0.0034110167,
0.0257943328,
0.0252716616,
0.0147063229,
0.00250882,
0.0044228998,
0.0532042012,
-0.0548560433,
-0.0092085674,
-0.0307767279,
-0.0506776944,
-0.0058287256,
0.0372789167,
0.0053693275,
0.0068769925,
0.0008257265,
-0.0615776516,
-0.0201187711,
-0.042329438,
0.0247615278,
0.0012783787,
0.0160442367,
-0.0444468744,
-0.0047060996,
-0.0047327699,
-0.0572406277,
-0.0347283073,
0.0421629585,
0.065034911,
-0.0161418654,
-0.0042963899,
0.0085054887,
-0.0683641955,
0.0082067037,
0.0037388622,
0.0032073529,
0.0178526677,
0.0262213089,
0.0790053383,
0.0344483443,
-0.0526382811,
0.0040430324,
-0.045075804,
0.0390442275,
0.055083517,
0.0479997881,
0.0338002034,
-0.0101009328,
-0.0052550263,
0.0090522887,
0.0406812876,
0.0182565916,
-0.0591726787,
0.0662974566,
0.0090278881,
0.0290503949,
0.0160528775,
-0.0459939167,
0.0077575347,
0.0318902172,
0.1006056592,
-0.0182437487,
0.0292819031,
0.0036406585,
2.69e-7,
-0.0207201224,
-0.0176053662,
0.0075677726,
-0.0099605778,
0.0342852846,
0.0613429807,
0.0095069539,
0.0494290292,
-0.0111313779,
-0.0166394021,
0.0019929069,
0.0168023966,
0.0230818521,
0.0197828189,
-0.044620581,
-0.0311858803,
-0.0240099709,
0.0093630981,
-0.0483730622,
-0.0157379806,
-0.0251817778,
0.0849286392,
0.06318786,
-0.0286160354,
0.0387161635,
-0.0498924553,
0.0371544473,
-0.0319598727,
-0.0253308136,
-0.0040243166,
0.0399479382,
0.0752253756,
-0.0267450344,
0.0008995451,
-0.0239031538,
0.030202793,
-0.0948856845,
0.0724929422,
-0.0258172844,
-0.0304365493,
-0.0005800971,
-0.0397190414,
-0.0547171533,
-0.0248033181,
0.0236399081,
-0.0112987179,
-0.0200066473,
-0.0031605898,
0.0710380301,
-0.0448422283,
0.0273099877,
-0.0327033103,
0.0052346359,
0.0032080889,
-0.0116102956,
0.0153968111,
0.00858064,
-0.0872920007,
-0.0324706733,
-0.0499444269,
-0.0126026301,
-0.0336337872,
-0.0108970851,
-0.0280717295,
-0.0239726771,
-0.0482849516,
0.0449210033,
2.164683867e-34,
-0.0025245624,
-0.041230686,
-0.0117988568,
0.0324582234,
0.0419835001,
0.0089555793,
0.0670801252,
-0.0131715937,
-0.0014494398,
-0.0434608385,
-0.0414346643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20127v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20127v1 | Improving Prompt Tuning with Learned Prompting Layers | 2023-10-31T02:07:51 | 2023-10-31T02:07:51 | Wei Zhu, Ming Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt tuning prepends a soft prompt to the input embeddings or hidden states
and only optimizes the prompt to adapt pretrained models (PTMs) to downstream
tasks. The previous work manually selects prompt layers which are far from
optimal and failed to exploit the potential of prompt tuning. In this work, we
propose a novel framework, \underline{S}elective \underline{P}rompt
\underline{T}uning (SPT), that learns to select the proper prompt layers by
inserting a prompt controlled by a learnable probabilistic gate at each
intermediate layer. We further propose a novel bi-level optimization framework,
SPT-DARTS, that can better optimize the learnable gates and improve the final
prompt tuning performances of the learned prompt layer settings. We conduct
extensive experiments with ten benchmark datasets under the full-data and
few-shot scenarios. The results demonstrate that our SPT framework can perform
better than the previous state-of-the-art PETuning baselines with comparable or
fewer tunable parameters. | [
-0.0375478193,
0.0104739768,
0.0061553055,
0.0211553872,
-0.0036486723,
-0.0071013491,
0.0598500296,
-0.0213660393,
-0.0107818786,
0.0072899372,
-0.0440908559,
-0.0188195501,
-0.0038440374,
0.0660463795,
0.0094437161,
-0.0616203249,
0.0672572628,
-0.0353005826,
0.0082710972,
0.0006085447,
-0.0098345941,
-0.0397016518,
-0.0420978479,
0.0331718996,
-0.0362857655,
0.0010287333,
-0.0724830329,
0.0490671694,
0.0159979872,
-0.0195915867,
0.0090568159,
0.0470973998,
-0.0187526755,
0.0476877764,
0.0000023123,
-0.0234545134,
-0.0130549343,
-0.0163385961,
-0.0323589742,
0.0235440154,
-0.0105924876,
0.0266273823,
-0.0501617864,
0.0359688662,
-0.0019482173,
-0.0030436283,
0.0641771331,
0.0626276508,
0.0272442605,
0.0796533003,
0.0084525347,
0.0407381468,
0.0332459547,
-0.0594515055,
-0.0064924294,
-0.0403271355,
-0.0010241308,
-0.1136227921,
-0.0404224917,
0.0002751854,
-0.0336426049,
-0.010283309,
0.0411747433,
-0.0489647388,
-0.0204167422,
0.0237956587,
0.0184858181,
-0.0261466149,
-0.0470039397,
0.0573641621,
-0.0674516633,
0.0195366926,
0.0214141421,
-0.0518402308,
0.0134028429,
-0.025539875,
-0.000212116,
-0.0075167515,
-0.0231231004,
0.0102843894,
-0.08072263,
0.0129216146,
0.0153176449,
-0.0095890397,
0.0158620421,
0.0642761216,
0.0078073507,
-0.0081464108,
0.0060336585,
-0.0242504012,
0.0180089977,
-0.0699125081,
0.0550491028,
0.0235665403,
-0.0706691444,
-0.0016856283,
-0.0297220498,
0.0306456685,
-0.0312671699,
0.0573958196,
0.0624436066,
0.0610987134,
-0.034558285,
0.0323878638,
-0.0470886305,
0.0060796053,
-0.0272215959,
0.0343092345,
-0.0297526959,
0.0582872257,
-0.0188430101,
0.0046041845,
-0.0477494337,
-0.0118856393,
-0.0437163189,
-0.0427781306,
-0.0159696825,
0.0455202349,
-0.0076075629,
-0.0168033987,
0.0059449244,
0.0128198657,
-0.0522516742,
-0.0137036396,
-0.0100688748,
0.0446554162,
-0.0530298725,
0.011797417,
0.0303422455,
-0.0190884937,
-0.0488525033,
-0.0067161331,
0.0132919345,
0.0005820063,
-0.0005924693,
0.0152149871,
-0.03034137,
-0.0135014653,
-0.0029074221,
0.0049490868,
-0.0070078843,
0.0017655219,
0.0398104787,
0.0069158203,
0.0358997434,
-0.0576884113,
0.0109365061,
-0.0301877875,
0.0027867574,
0.0047408063,
0.0207649581,
0.0690110028,
0.0176705495,
-0.0157971028,
0.0180936623,
-0.0091070207,
-0.0539701879,
0.0374700278,
-0.0068474626,
0.0973174572,
0.0070024049,
-0.0055481354,
0.0098924246,
0.0371323451,
0.0538989455,
-0.0290778466,
0.0113656847,
-0.0416159853,
0.0648876503,
0.015422021,
0.0750897676,
-0.0009252369,
-0.0325646065,
0.0172856413,
0.0301971715,
-0.0068271779,
0.0179717317,
-0.0097223558,
0.039577499,
-0.0187255312,
-0.0261849258,
0.002480139,
-0.0476690605,
0.0467377529,
-0.0789790526,
0.0102281179,
-0.010241583,
-0.0030991314,
-0.0434409305,
-0.0525429659,
0.0395740867,
-0.0058576535,
-0.01183879,
0.0354908332,
0.0216869544,
0.0104608377,
-0.0842223316,
0.038406644,
-0.0143073304,
-0.0212838277,
-0.0236506108,
-0.0675295815,
0.0019243348,
0.0475818291,
-0.0066813473,
-0.0450697169,
-0.0168791395,
-0.0163867977,
0.0502060205,
0.0550508313,
0.0234919153,
-0.0338591449,
0.0524435043,
-0.0230319854,
-0.0577587597,
-0.0232835636,
0.0047939816,
0.0523029789,
-0.0160526447,
-0.0044061104,
0.0112448586,
0.0353095233,
0.0581542291,
0.0446324721,
-0.0277260896,
-0.0496060848,
0.0389595665,
0.0314418562,
0.0066576083,
0.0032904586,
-0.016724389,
0.0079409173,
0.022977097,
-0.019343609,
0.0264021512,
-0.0477803163,
-0.0646035299,
-0.0414131358,
0.0395264924,
0.0188025255,
-0.0169814397,
0.0103116669,
-0.0629420727,
-0.0418258309,
-0.008963027,
0.0078033861,
0.0000872076,
-0.050061509,
0.0365266353,
-0.0145575376,
-0.0378524624,
-0.0333873257,
0.0505652837,
0.0148648955,
0.0102267032,
0.0436792374,
0.0374438204,
0.0193644855,
-0.0938337445,
-0.0392032564,
0.0046191202,
-0.0261219852,
-0.0116742253,
0.0463185757,
0.0177633241,
-0.0237422828,
-0.0398433656,
-0.0719051585,
0.0284470599,
-0.0324385129,
-0.0073233861,
0.0015781762,
-0.0051343096,
-0.0310592894,
-0.0486446545,
-0.0121810185,
-0.000824435,
-0.0323444083,
0.0034639195,
0.0192707516,
0.0097099598,
-0.026836209,
-0.0404978991,
-0.0121155288,
-0.0076431008,
-0.0214181542,
-0.05667153,
-0.0343503244,
-0.0138952285,
0.0426755771,
0.0065097995,
0.0352402814,
0.0055770855,
0.003227914,
0.0188028645,
0.015431474,
0.0009340384,
0.098211512,
-0.0127255134,
0.0082785804,
0.0282468833,
0.0152887525,
-0.0360522494,
0.0503167436,
-0.051425647,
-0.003797082,
0.0313997418,
0.0553044081,
0.0454653054,
0.0445913784,
0.0067029819,
0.004921088,
-0.0625289753,
0.0333464332,
-0.0054810992,
0.0043910011,
-0.0591957644,
-0.0245952699,
-0.0251004212,
0.0314989053,
-0.0568159297,
-0.0533345006,
0.0469334982,
-0.0236235633,
-0.0111806169,
0.0084002158,
0.015170279,
0.0030782514,
0.0343968086,
0.0293605402,
0.0044349395,
-0.0171609521,
-0.0295873843,
-0.0579513907,
0.0076334244,
0.0009525592,
0.0024524038,
-0.0297970381,
0.0273246765,
-0.0081932191,
-0.0352057032,
-0.0866684914,
-0.0312349498,
-0.0080978395,
0.0054271882,
0.0255163107,
-0.0219151005,
-0.0172398947,
0.0441412441,
-0.0342470147,
-0.0004770058,
0.0905647725,
-0.046006795,
-0.0084977876,
-0.0489676856,
0.0231546443,
0.0254324172,
-0.0101038469,
0.0022480041,
-0.0037046499,
0.0510624237,
-0.0014152675,
0.0487044975,
-0.007334582,
-0.0401845351,
0.0147229107,
0.0070055556,
-0.0476880744,
-0.0013959793,
0.0315789916,
0.0338633843,
-0.0359624214,
0.0051000919,
0.0517818481,
0.0261799805,
-0.0223184917,
-0.0130590247,
0.0207429528,
0.0315483175,
0.0277257096,
0.0342180543,
-0.0164489374,
-0.0306147542,
0.0055239657,
0.0424221307,
0.0405540615,
0.0069271419,
0.0062570553,
-0.1067521945,
0.0376727208,
-0.008716546,
-0.0232996792,
-0.0230913833,
0.0116093997,
-0.0049791005,
0.0197244529,
0.0152841872,
0.0557569489,
0.000352736,
-0.0047732764,
0.0253497474,
0.0198338646,
-0.0661958158,
-0.0129124615,
-0.0348211043,
0.0085342042,
0.1055733413,
0.002609235,
0.0159126632,
-0.0471739247,
0.0885743201,
-0.0182508454,
0.020664582,
-0.0063814926,
-0.0119037945,
0.0196782891,
-0.0023953919,
-0.0090683326,
0.0371557623,
0.0060285926,
-0.0416363701,
-0.0301399659,
0.0444686934,
-0.0182952639,
0.0032633392,
-0.0057567395,
-0.0110985851,
0.0263723247,
0.0272264834,
0.0175696369,
-0.0323274657,
-0.0475133955,
-0.0328523554,
0.0213105753,
-0.0714754313,
0.0394727811,
-0.0128746396,
0.0048819799,
-0.0704654306,
-0.059805017,
0.0045138169,
0.0268523023,
0.0696047246,
-0.0190004352,
-0.0095499214,
-0.0274441764,
0.0486125723,
-0.0408395752,
0.0276232045,
0.0016937831,
0.0147314668,
-0.0462818034,
-0.0199474078,
0.0214847326,
-0.0389946811,
-0.009477349,
-0.0184765551,
-0.0302896332,
-0.0681440458,
0.0160245765,
0.0558690093,
0.0188338663,
0.0442343727,
-0.0378467441,
-0.0480316058,
0.0925524086,
0.0403890498,
0.0242835823,
-0.0036225196,
0.0562575087,
0.0283548702,
-0.0378156863,
0.0297833048,
-0.0563989505,
0.004789833,
0.0261266883,
0.0200750902,
0.0161746182,
-0.0719024613,
0.0164510179,
0.0077054617,
0.0969198868,
-0.0026725628,
0.0005183409,
-0.0627179891,
0.0283067226,
0.0178263634,
0.0274874493,
-0.0410544649,
0.0079396693,
0.0040453686,
-0.0424968787,
0.0287155733,
-0.0407192819,
0.0375491343,
0.0415584035,
-0.0216615889,
0.0141402753,
0.0458652228,
0.0390703827,
-0.0131311305,
-0.0007126702,
0.0048068068,
0.0773565248,
0.0032937385,
0.0295418054,
-0.0205535982,
0.0385156535,
0.0409531966,
0.023069907,
-0.0750439391,
0.0735835657,
-0.0486908033,
-0.0905398577,
-0.0453621447,
0.0438254923,
0.0425213426,
0.0125987325,
-0.0363790356,
-0.0049908683,
-0.035932973,
0.0104520945,
0.0123982439,
0.0593668707,
-0.0384342894,
0.0394571461,
0.0241354369,
0.0112526901,
-0.0189397596,
0.0327874236,
-0.0490674376,
0.0439867005,
0.0122650703,
0.0377050564,
-0.0298085902,
0.018984722,
0.0250702668,
0.051421538,
-0.0212394781,
-0.0036692319,
-0.0063928058,
0.0162113309,
-0.0364449918,
0.056433931,
-0.0066700326,
-0.0035385489,
0.06205092,
0.020259995,
-0.0068075382,
-0.0018571033,
-0.0044594794,
-0.0469254889,
0.0293593574,
0.0095618553,
-0.0138510428,
-6.490744055e-33,
-0.0598175377,
0.027994303,
0.0033787424,
0.0168469995,
-0.0548637547,
0.0235800575,
-0.0236367919,
0.0077276523,
-0.000723467,
-0.0073677218,
-0.0774094537,
-0.0089068543,
0.0301939677,
-0.0000816756,
-0.0051600807,
-0.0348152816,
0.0745054334,
-0.0264279582,
-0.0451561846,
0.0177340545,
0.0191613808,
0.0291958898,
0.0141928755,
0.0175797921,
-0.0162117723,
0.0561964884,
-0.0587092191,
0.0210729372,
-0.0006250722,
0.0044424445,
-0.0124607068,
-0.0282372385,
-0.0209394656,
-0.0246628486,
-0.0226566773,
0.0743996277,
-0.0584924631,
-0.0558632277,
-0.0456746407,
0.00404217,
-0.0621263012,
-0.0273551773,
0.010914024,
-0.0115846843,
-0.0346372016,
0.005087859,
-0.0138310436,
0.0088667879,
-0.0153276548,
-0.052043926,
-0.0308042616,
-0.0120076304,
0.0102530289,
-0.0740399361,
0.0039466457,
0.0296921358,
-0.0144368242,
-0.007619991,
-0.0928899795,
-0.0288854875,
0.0268331859,
0.039859876,
0.0343057923,
0.0471146777,
0.0079502342,
0.0294627212,
0.0663721636,
0.0194003172,
0.0230973139,
0.0021456429,
0.0141211022,
0.0261940006,
0.0695967898,
-0.0322308354,
0.0592287965,
-0.0431064591,
-0.0179001223,
0.054068543,
0.0918408483,
0.0040953653,
0.0000918376,
0.0224556047,
0.0100976322,
-0.0310052112,
-0.058273226,
-0.037805561,
0.0065640565,
-0.043477416,
0.0444144793,
0.0608186275,
-0.0202922244,
-0.0460575595,
0.0613397099,
0.0187125057,
0.0386107899,
-0.0208274573,
-0.003926944,
0.0367147066,
0.0201603398,
-0.0120311035,
-0.0431472436,
-0.0553628094,
0.0204658154,
-0.0104034357,
0.019140821,
0.019057326,
-0.0141655263,
0.0689529106,
-0.0578472875,
0.0217585713,
-0.0202284846,
0.0402701087,
0.0201030541,
0.0488618426,
0.0397589095,
-0.0176282302,
-0.0071336464,
0.0149046071,
-0.0141798565,
-0.0184511561,
-0.0113440519,
0.0497415066,
0.0027956925,
0.0497382693,
0.007572351,
-0.0189688597,
-0.0043134256,
0.0456965603,
-0.0195967741,
-0.0681092367,
-0.0238568801,
0.0395286493,
3.015e-7,
0.0026535343,
0.012152805,
0.0234598331,
0.0600737408,
0.0226823334,
0.0310214907,
-0.0372724831,
0.0183185823,
-0.0342471339,
-0.0312721729,
0.0176852588,
-0.0032697937,
0.0233968496,
-0.0046329647,
-0.1045788378,
-0.0450706407,
-0.0316166021,
0.0734394938,
-0.0377182998,
-0.0089904228,
0.0199713875,
0.0806865022,
-0.0009921837,
-0.009019779,
0.0739127025,
0.0071055042,
0.0222381745,
-0.0098253908,
0.0521910451,
0.0001997871,
0.0230475571,
-0.0656390041,
-0.0331561565,
0.0442508832,
-0.0222484842,
0.0516077951,
-0.0014881551,
0.0337876268,
-0.0132677611,
-0.0405109078,
0.0065963557,
0.022027852,
0.0185422078,
-0.0718480647,
0.0920590684,
-0.0199763495,
0.0137274219,
-0.0287702214,
0.0065070698,
-0.0321702845,
0.0595320612,
-0.0345223285,
-0.0240573604,
0.0129365511,
0.0007233931,
0.0169728901,
-0.0072337142,
-0.0385374464,
-0.0074082795,
-0.0271892697,
-0.0438924246,
-0.0473455675,
-0.052474618,
0.0223467965,
0.0101906005,
-0.0372042581,
-0.0633979738,
3.056961451e-34,
0.0214374121,
-0.0510836393,
0.0419125706,
0.0064335451,
0.0125196893,
0.0142183928,
0.0097408378,
-0.0024134119,
0.0407949165,
-0.0100593949,
-0.0446714796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20121v1 | Ling-CL: Understanding NLP Models through Linguistic Curricula | 2023-10-31T01:44:33 | 2023-10-31T01:44:33 | Mohamed Elgaar, Hadi Amiri | cs.CL | cs.CL | We employ a characterization of linguistic complexity from psycholinguistic
and language acquisition research to develop data-driven curricula to
understand the underlying linguistic knowledge that models learn to address NLP
tasks. The novelty of our approach is in the development of linguistic
curricula derived from data, existing knowledge about linguistic complexity,
and model behavior during training. By analyzing several benchmark NLP
datasets, our curriculum learning approaches identify sets of linguistic
metrics (indices) that inform the challenges and reasoning required to address
each task. Our work will inform future research in all NLP areas, allowing
linguistic complexity to be considered early in the research and development
process. In addition, our work prompts an examination of gold standards and
fair evaluation in NLP. | [
0.0441826321,
0.031196963,
-0.0562454201,
0.0356213488,
-0.0383088589,
0.0558542907,
-0.0365591049,
-0.0007957165,
0.0077302088,
-0.0499643944,
0.0273301471,
-0.0087607475,
0.0173945315,
-0.0153091382,
0.0377111398,
-0.0786997378,
0.0485104583,
-0.0084114289,
0.0165913049,
-0.0092044557,
0.0003860809,
-0.0070351125,
-0.0254642572,
0.0360796489,
-0.0217864271,
-0.0236535762,
-0.0003094066,
-0.0219641216,
-0.0547217131,
-0.0202610753,
0.0334897824,
0.0479810424,
-0.0111220116,
0.0418931581,
0.0000018737,
-0.0726523027,
-0.018766202,
-0.0053944439,
-0.0293236934,
-0.0107008237,
0.0708141476,
-0.0187318716,
-0.0057362872,
0.0135185868,
-0.0139360726,
0.0267038047,
0.0467569083,
0.0638648197,
0.0286558103,
0.0395457,
-0.0007171788,
-0.0421258062,
0.0227501504,
0.0125812767,
-0.0236229748,
-0.0252481233,
0.0138661861,
0.0401388854,
0.0085349735,
0.0139131658,
-0.0404536016,
0.007381516,
0.022340443,
0.0584109277,
-0.0010711378,
0.0106862206,
-0.0180043802,
-0.0567368455,
-0.0108259441,
0.0160892885,
-0.0401684567,
0.0002983341,
0.0083061913,
-0.0257989373,
0.0156847294,
-0.0121324053,
-0.0270793047,
0.0228748899,
-0.0052875392,
0.0039616101,
0.0360456966,
-0.0043223021,
0.0119169354,
0.0280199442,
0.0055347313,
0.0551294275,
-0.0165038053,
-0.0366102383,
0.0436594337,
0.0140422583,
-0.0098160747,
-0.0084990077,
-0.0220197663,
0.0136946058,
-0.0213384703,
0.0491017997,
0.0102488985,
-0.0167743992,
0.071900323,
-0.0499146171,
0.0478695892,
-0.0246358421,
-0.0288502648,
0.0147483889,
-0.0071469834,
0.0426835045,
0.0433965437,
0.017271582,
-0.0386620797,
-0.0001903031,
-0.0909932107,
-0.0307788793,
-0.0308750477,
0.0047719949,
0.0187541284,
-0.0104761207,
-0.0430040173,
-0.0363115929,
-0.0453408882,
-0.00176168,
-0.0021832481,
0.007650285,
-0.0388092995,
0.004480246,
-0.0638478026,
0.003208376,
-0.0497938283,
0.0396207534,
-0.0145225655,
-0.0272486676,
0.0278629605,
-0.0018869707,
-0.0108075961,
-0.0094395904,
-0.0033805189,
0.0437780507,
-0.0034262864,
-0.0423959643,
-0.0537709072,
-0.0232012328,
-0.0427734666,
-0.049489174,
0.0212154165,
-0.0873682648,
-0.0195382684,
0.021221105,
0.014738691,
-0.0499140434,
-0.0051237065,
-0.0014648073,
-0.0390500277,
0.0805886388,
-0.0252717156,
-0.0003907281,
0.005612602,
-0.0185169429,
0.0222910736,
0.1033578515,
0.0007480272,
-0.0262219664,
0.077646181,
-0.0349802226,
0.0127834473,
-0.0030781038,
-0.0029641762,
-0.0207272507,
-0.0073845815,
-0.003158388,
0.0079153329,
-0.0011133173,
-0.0346994698,
0.0477507897,
-0.0180885065,
-0.0164300334,
0.0171986893,
0.0518712141,
0.0388507955,
-0.0100076059,
0.0333643444,
0.0217716601,
0.0287259426,
0.0557029471,
-0.0023414507,
-0.0217054412,
-0.0497506745,
-0.0022030594,
-0.0253194887,
0.0133521669,
0.0108546782,
-0.0976431817,
-0.0439594574,
0.0090743247,
0.0364768915,
-0.0175415073,
0.0023394418,
0.0596414506,
0.0205811299,
0.0226436239,
0.0736285225,
-0.0296969879,
-0.0035308572,
-0.0027504647,
-0.0354869589,
0.0442137532,
0.0109357638,
-0.024214562,
-0.034521345,
-0.0047672861,
0.027520122,
0.0192544367,
0.0397362225,
-0.0320780277,
0.0203986019,
-0.0198800601,
-0.0054024914,
-0.0004138389,
0.0546152852,
-0.0331351534,
0.0394352786,
-0.0493599623,
-0.0337279513,
-0.0314740911,
-0.0943040401,
0.0573954694,
-0.0764672682,
-0.0496725775,
-0.0212450363,
0.0287016947,
0.0289802812,
0.0156435985,
0.0356089883,
0.0075094374,
0.0100269038,
-0.0037785205,
-0.0011638091,
0.0007489431,
-0.0048427582,
-0.0047758841,
0.0387358889,
-0.0215638559,
-0.0101496903,
0.0125123803,
-0.0056755058,
-0.0073987893,
0.0190456007,
-0.0583019257,
0.0477796346,
-0.0289391261,
0.0236142687,
-0.0339666158,
0.0227229707,
-0.0523213595,
0.0672699139,
-0.0099114357,
0.0657153577,
0.03020739,
-0.0156301539,
0.0235150978,
-0.0093787927,
-0.0253420305,
0.0113273216,
-0.0147760669,
0.0334510282,
0.0463879704,
0.0168313533,
-0.091076076,
-0.0503736399,
-0.0558867641,
-0.0175012387,
-0.0162976198,
-0.0121553978,
0.0186075848,
-0.0453409404,
-0.0047953888,
0.0032761649,
-0.0110650891,
-0.0072532916,
0.0033999374,
0.0341226049,
0.0620414615,
0.0045564892,
-0.0246552415,
-0.0322987735,
-0.0143284043,
-0.0311907809,
0.0526419356,
0.0044921571,
0.0371293426,
-0.012837288,
0.0096213911,
0.0218759421,
-0.0181724112,
0.0159963388,
-0.0206152741,
0.0290392451,
0.0257246271,
0.023174556,
0.0436030589,
-0.0001504414,
0.0915533006,
0.0144406082,
-0.0269437768,
-0.0404057391,
0.0094014574,
-0.0662055314,
-0.0460113287,
-0.0678519383,
-0.0270765182,
0.0180698317,
0.0840926468,
-0.0207813829,
-0.0306746289,
-0.0495509058,
0.0360231996,
-0.0835140496,
-0.0273991004,
-0.017642023,
0.0326961987,
-0.0335753039,
0.0407421738,
-0.0165164303,
-0.0315459371,
0.048123531,
-0.0003512322,
0.0141248666,
-0.1016561612,
-0.0099668028,
-0.0370367877,
0.0669918507,
0.0209433697,
0.010301928,
0.0877100229,
-0.0437530577,
-0.0512267649,
0.0016281536,
0.0333515741,
-0.0138209928,
0.0356626883,
-0.0367424078,
-0.0346818455,
0.0346287377,
-0.0116091445,
-0.0393277593,
0.0119667063,
-0.0026571467,
0.0286627598,
0.034284059,
-0.014749581,
-0.0164871402,
-0.0679989979,
0.0073205447,
0.0014508852,
0.0003915218,
-0.0464616567,
-0.0195469707,
-0.0061483551,
0.0255800989,
0.0234909337,
0.0535371713,
-0.0322302058,
0.0281062331,
0.0149286781,
0.0201780684,
0.0089856433,
-0.0227990672,
0.0549928695,
0.0305034723,
-0.0604172163,
-0.0200761277,
0.0518382154,
0.0096845077,
-0.0318058394,
-0.0130047854,
0.1000542417,
0.0465643518,
-0.016659677,
0.0537840351,
0.0194639899,
0.0527505055,
0.0565257333,
0.0117584243,
-0.0333065949,
-0.0117642973,
-0.0101488577,
0.0138610173,
-0.0436889678,
-0.03529853,
-0.0248479377,
-0.0724236742,
-0.0117789088,
-0.0241163969,
0.003627738,
0.0093728798,
-0.0639161021,
-0.0141197108,
-0.0174255073,
0.0509718768,
-0.0237883478,
-0.0688985959,
0.0135920858,
0.0458219126,
-0.0719520152,
-0.0859069154,
0.0244342946,
-0.0126386285,
0.0803322122,
0.0148424422,
0.0237184502,
-0.0573014244,
0.017195968,
0.0283933692,
-0.015968509,
-0.0229462907,
0.004116449,
0.0694708973,
0.0183725152,
-0.0186900422,
-0.0119176414,
0.0128307659,
-0.0204271637,
-0.0158230644,
-0.00572058,
0.0783566833,
0.0454951078,
-0.0287559088,
-0.0194132626,
-0.0100232037,
-0.0236706771,
0.0701716989,
0.0311723445,
-0.0452596508,
0.0032791246,
-0.0507295094,
0.0155228022,
-0.0040541454,
-0.0904531777,
0.0550088361,
-0.0015604242,
-0.0205437988,
-0.067921944,
-0.0893606767,
0.0511669889,
-0.0044379751,
0.0254627708,
0.0214742627,
0.0326341242,
-0.0205680486,
-0.0545075499,
0.040515352,
0.0042036669,
0.001147869,
-0.0711527243,
-0.0548739657,
0.0047272807,
0.0147587117,
-0.0325172357,
0.0045726849,
-0.0431323946,
-0.0490399152,
0.0337254591,
0.0242806599,
0.0220119543,
0.0146451741,
0.0094100768,
-0.0689783171,
-0.0133322701,
0.0165693667,
-0.0391920432,
-0.0152693894,
0.0613997504,
-0.0119367158,
0.0177012496,
0.0428360999,
-0.0151924947,
0.0149527891,
0.0055478062,
0.0547039211,
-0.0186697785,
-0.0077392226,
0.0702502802,
0.0218351837,
0.0286241025,
-0.023034649,
-0.0229551103,
-0.0441693775,
-0.0518765487,
-0.0011185008,
-0.0397417396,
-0.0288225096,
-0.0146399178,
0.0134903733,
0.0468171835,
-0.0365991108,
-0.0162604488,
0.0055910982,
0.0385569595,
-0.0080520278,
0.0310960319,
0.0215706713,
-0.0101116952,
-0.0003351191,
0.0038451429,
-0.0023422306,
0.0212576911,
-0.0408547632,
0.0261222403,
-0.0049752509,
0.0279614795,
0.0259012692,
0.019913882,
-0.009208926,
0.00887895,
-0.028387174,
-0.0162226893,
-0.005519832,
-0.008241225,
0.043356102,
-0.0812226683,
0.0425282829,
-0.056505803,
0.0079007912,
-0.0148045998,
-0.0089972811,
-0.0009570238,
-0.0474467501,
0.0201655459,
0.0490541793,
-0.0261025317,
-0.0179883707,
0.1011765674,
0.0324816257,
0.0180708822,
0.004782273,
0.0139793623,
-0.0312607624,
-0.0322361998,
0.0290566124,
0.0305713769,
-0.0286926851,
0.0725463107,
-0.0726116821,
-0.0830552652,
0.0154145518,
-0.0156072294,
0.0292967353,
-0.0147004146,
0.0264776982,
0.0880830139,
-0.0165033638,
-0.0286551043,
-0.053175725,
-0.0284407791,
0.0346720852,
0.0049612806,
0.0043727611,
-5.748649328e-33,
-0.0063096574,
-0.0480290577,
0.0175574087,
0.0094230557,
0.0519235693,
0.0184741654,
0.0143734245,
0.0504733808,
-0.0399812385,
0.049515076,
0.0072979406,
0.011947752,
-0.0036982053,
0.0264597964,
0.0485810451,
0.0152825238,
0.0243812017,
0.0028887179,
0.0050667273,
-0.0376116745,
0.0077583278,
0.0097214244,
0.0551966354,
-0.0648619086,
0.0555568971,
0.0536603928,
0.0120335389,
0.0083438018,
-0.0004283361,
0.0691780671,
-0.0240895711,
0.090171136,
0.03842365,
-0.0721951574,
-0.0110777356,
-0.034705542,
-0.0769984722,
-0.0639800504,
0.0234962702,
0.0404759087,
-0.02506705,
-0.0349146165,
0.0326853134,
-0.0369345993,
-0.0319840349,
-0.0336983502,
0.0430652983,
-0.0357225128,
0.0101851858,
0.0235617869,
-0.0911236033,
0.0264491718,
-0.0242974758,
-0.0000688306,
0.0585120581,
-0.0032452489,
-0.0050705089,
-0.0258537792,
-0.0260825213,
-0.0007634862,
0.0204853397,
0.0736865476,
0.0202786177,
0.0042464747,
-0.0109693948,
0.0661601126,
0.0184717011,
0.0459132902,
0.0017184316,
0.0341430269,
0.0757584125,
0.0780498758,
0.0315474533,
0.0298271663,
0.0100644734,
-0.0182466283,
-0.0142209418,
-0.0093756029,
0.0285586361,
0.045714736,
-0.0019445706,
-0.0246064644,
-0.0505787767,
-0.0565501638,
-0.0567091107,
0.0096023483,
-0.0077496311,
0.0012432818,
0.028761372,
0.0077113737,
-0.0099739237,
0.0070110955,
-0.0307658482,
-0.0559782237,
-0.0686075091,
0.007905364,
-0.0029423835,
0.0077680582,
0.0137102259,
0.0468054153,
-0.0727526695,
-0.0288521368,
-0.0246497896,
-0.0104501406,
0.0480846465,
0.0099988859,
0.0609574094,
0.0165067762,
-0.0437819958,
-0.0220384281,
-0.0221186075,
-0.0027752342,
0.0048236786,
0.0109930653,
0.0144602731,
0.0214547738,
-0.0284368023,
0.0006588858,
0.0389297344,
-0.0255393945,
-0.0496566445,
-0.0056168991,
-0.030504128,
0.0288881231,
-0.0294957962,
-0.0600148402,
-0.0356768705,
-0.0008987354,
0.0652384758,
-0.0256911255,
-0.0099778753,
-0.0178101175,
2.531e-7,
0.0399799347,
0.1107820049,
-0.0021024733,
0.0283312369,
0.0069112279,
0.0304873288,
-0.0404317155,
-0.0116789034,
-0.0086394418,
-0.0339323245,
-0.043224059,
0.0229953565,
0.0456932634,
0.0285137072,
-0.0781178102,
-0.0209381171,
-0.0103896577,
0.0228757802,
-0.0432993434,
0.0218165535,
0.0708225891,
0.056038145,
0.0132634956,
0.0110174185,
-0.047237549,
-0.0066745812,
0.0097833686,
-0.0368662067,
0.0395470634,
0.0345134027,
0.0505991429,
0.0330842882,
0.0659642816,
0.034599252,
-0.0114797177,
0.0248248596,
0.002785757,
0.0435182601,
0.0082993852,
-0.0227647666,
-0.0051267603,
-0.0485186055,
-0.0288075414,
-0.0582269691,
0.0447527729,
-0.0525476038,
-0.0458132625,
-0.0201170333,
-0.0279180724,
0.0235402081,
0.01814197,
0.0063812318,
-0.046923548,
0.0053567486,
0.0251155086,
-0.0179796424,
0.0286650192,
-0.0488708951,
-0.008486907,
0.0278937817,
0.022230193,
-0.0036612444,
0.0077335248,
0.0123202419,
0.0044124988,
-0.0437806658,
0.0191858616,
2.509732785e-34,
0.037818931,
-0.0046954136,
0.0603119172,
0.0064983158,
0.0364433825,
-0.0183927417,
0.0180307291,
0.0256543923,
0.0085187359,
-0.03832037,
0.0156360399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20111v1 | Making Large Language Models Better Data Creators | 2023-10-31T01:08:34 | 2023-10-31T01:08:34 | Dong-Ho Lee, Jay Pujara, Mohit Sewak, Ryen W. White, Sujay Kumar Jauhar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) have advanced the state-of-the-art in
NLP significantly, deploying them for downstream applications is still
challenging due to cost, responsiveness, control, or concerns around privacy
and security. As such, trainable models are still the preferred option in some
cases. However, these models still require human-labeled data for optimal
performance, which is expensive and time-consuming to obtain. In order to
address this issue, several techniques to reduce human effort involve labeling
or generating data using LLMs. Although these methods are effective for certain
applications, in practice they encounter difficulties in real-world scenarios.
Labeling data requires careful data selection, while generating data
necessitates task-specific prompt engineering. In this paper, we propose a
unified data creation pipeline that requires only a single formatting example,
and which is applicable to a broad range of tasks, including traditionally
problematic ones with semantically devoid label spaces. In our experiments we
demonstrate that instruction-following LLMs are highly cost-effective data
creators, and that models trained with these data exhibit performance better
than those trained with human-labeled data (by up to 17.5%) on
out-of-distribution evaluation, while maintaining comparable performance on
in-distribution tasks. These results have important implications for the
robustness of NLP systems deployed in the real-world. | [
0.0547040813,
0.0739344433,
-0.0030553902,
0.0245117713,
-0.0288140532,
0.0099791568,
0.0393792689,
-0.0165009759,
0.0145493457,
-0.0776490793,
-0.0355785452,
-0.0242858883,
-0.0371090248,
0.0288504586,
0.0435055643,
-0.048743058,
0.0225348976,
-0.0342206135,
0.0070872307,
0.0229146034,
0.006119492,
0.0082844449,
0.0154610658,
0.0351171419,
-0.0378937311,
-0.0093443608,
-0.0102631683,
0.0072984942,
-0.0300411917,
-0.0516628958,
0.0114966864,
0.0670176446,
-0.0014447167,
0.0299878363,
0.0000019053,
-0.0419830568,
-0.0198487919,
0.0099795097,
-0.0722066984,
0.0157335158,
0.0484586544,
-0.0308417734,
-0.0174150858,
0.0297985803,
-0.0410384722,
-0.0291028116,
0.0411411785,
0.0521766543,
0.0794978589,
0.0707804114,
-0.0125270644,
-0.0040455093,
0.000647157,
-0.0268224515,
0.0143068628,
-0.0523709618,
0.0230904091,
-0.0140354428,
0.0159251075,
0.056253504,
0.0274580792,
0.0324657373,
0.017286038,
-0.0195836723,
0.0039896322,
0.0344419889,
-0.0319682546,
-0.0330268107,
-0.0391819514,
0.0962889716,
-0.0141630163,
-0.0217883307,
0.0152413482,
-0.0065579764,
0.012032439,
-0.0094765155,
-0.0344522111,
0.0617631041,
-0.0066273427,
0.0164709594,
0.0158982538,
-0.0001693471,
0.0322534554,
0.0208415482,
-0.0004488604,
0.062853165,
0.0105694951,
-0.0288554169,
0.011278023,
-0.002579842,
-0.0411578678,
-0.0739805624,
0.0138289072,
0.0190298837,
-0.0485928804,
0.0352941826,
-0.0916505381,
-0.0478146374,
0.0152273551,
-0.0159687474,
0.0548909381,
0.0107596358,
-0.0022904791,
0.0555803701,
-0.0252887607,
0.0410602205,
0.0028986391,
0.0255269725,
-0.0211770162,
-0.0179531518,
-0.0515125841,
-0.0114805149,
-0.0620011762,
0.0379270054,
-0.0482577235,
-0.0172380749,
-0.0094750635,
0.0527029447,
-0.0210456569,
0.0376754701,
0.0356256813,
-0.0038386469,
-0.0274154339,
-0.0116323819,
-0.0203348678,
-0.0293557364,
-0.0184250306,
-0.0112235183,
0.0159374475,
-0.0698828548,
-0.0044433521,
0.0208607651,
-0.0114590861,
-0.0245479066,
-0.0056888876,
0.089922078,
0.0001164173,
-0.0233071074,
-0.0521436669,
-0.0405118018,
0.0063013937,
-0.0291676,
-0.0351412632,
-0.0643750429,
0.035653621,
0.0285912752,
-0.0101164058,
-0.0660760105,
0.0222624224,
0.0418560244,
-0.035947524,
0.1033494845,
-0.0544838011,
0.0284454934,
0.0209321454,
-0.0242155846,
0.0083059855,
0.0492656864,
0.0354140513,
0.0203423854,
0.0644784048,
0.0021036156,
0.0535997003,
0.0563067086,
0.0164703298,
0.0036526327,
-0.0281251781,
0.0039039857,
0.0424105264,
0.0256513525,
0.0162970424,
0.0755780563,
0.0016803999,
0.0128034512,
0.0695152059,
0.0235921908,
-0.0068968832,
-0.0168264918,
0.0443031639,
0.0412769951,
-0.0128830047,
-0.0458751991,
-0.0659776106,
0.0030856044,
-0.0212881677,
0.0000672541,
0.0106176594,
0.0022901881,
-0.033652287,
-0.0338621289,
-0.0503613316,
-0.0176350046,
0.0011269638,
0.0235471223,
0.0273036752,
0.0424115919,
-0.0278173909,
0.0709008723,
0.0345060639,
-0.0301630143,
0.009599884,
-0.0400904343,
0.0034283302,
0.0727154985,
0.0473157093,
-0.0232922826,
-0.0093901381,
-0.0151395593,
0.0497172512,
0.0357188024,
0.0556670763,
-0.0389441475,
-0.0128689073,
-0.0433071256,
-0.0303315558,
0.001272762,
0.0142403888,
-0.0044211997,
0.0647809356,
-0.0456031486,
0.0134676388,
-0.0514738336,
-0.064745903,
0.0641516075,
-0.0236620512,
-0.0719575137,
0.0329865627,
0.0040261578,
0.0062205521,
0.0224541258,
-0.0051875003,
0.0212041046,
0.0278231148,
-0.0149014024,
0.0038947272,
-0.0406590514,
-0.0277104937,
-0.0256780572,
0.0156517774,
0.0189827401,
-0.0194024183,
0.0069812993,
-0.0538163818,
-0.0417702645,
-0.0485967249,
-0.0377177931,
0.0073088096,
-0.0276741423,
0.0332678929,
0.0423980653,
-0.009600631,
-0.0794650838,
0.06407056,
0.0136272535,
0.00852942,
0.0207511988,
0.0434190221,
-0.0028385413,
-0.0292363949,
-0.0218209233,
0.0151104936,
-0.0155235091,
0.0014731804,
0.0126058878,
0.0283867382,
-0.0445008241,
-0.0233307853,
-0.0781900659,
0.030828381,
-0.0249941833,
0.0186793525,
0.0353405289,
0.0156223141,
-0.0192760974,
-0.0301799849,
-0.0513967946,
-0.0360643715,
0.0039203698,
0.0423146971,
0.0512717813,
0.0184472259,
-0.0164424479,
-0.0117283622,
-0.0166658312,
-0.0022872826,
0.0370334908,
-0.0020609736,
-0.0223726332,
-0.06610585,
0.0234520324,
0.0101280455,
0.0313888676,
0.0180028677,
-0.0030426846,
-0.0040252837,
-0.0144462259,
0.0591925308,
0.0416430198,
-0.0006695287,
0.0379733779,
0.0466849245,
0.0150302798,
-0.048090633,
-0.0023453669,
-0.0391428694,
-0.040267095,
-0.0074594845,
-0.0337675735,
0.0234869756,
0.0659181923,
-0.0071382704,
0.0024586555,
-0.0420794711,
0.0032297566,
-0.0300535206,
-0.0293801483,
-0.0613812879,
0.004185983,
-0.026858991,
0.0333877094,
-0.0339940414,
-0.0558922067,
0.0568997636,
-0.0266207922,
-0.005073688,
-0.0296138786,
-0.0252477117,
-0.0239014793,
0.0734649524,
0.0155255813,
0.0043761595,
0.0227466878,
-0.0475293696,
-0.021907676,
0.0084075294,
0.0180843882,
-0.0296839196,
0.0321697518,
-0.0812420249,
0.0129387761,
-0.0160951372,
-0.038143456,
-0.0721265152,
-0.0695549697,
-0.0119311269,
0.0233568847,
0.0073022973,
0.003096259,
-0.0041456185,
0.0029608917,
0.0424646847,
0.0619431287,
-0.0117972167,
-0.0093003297,
-0.0302626379,
0.0221372973,
0.0467921197,
-0.0144616263,
-0.0136791999,
-0.0283708088,
0.0247826148,
0.0449348539,
0.0647532195,
0.0120482985,
0.0007170864,
0.0083399555,
0.0301412251,
-0.0337569006,
-0.0264505893,
0.045753058,
0.0483615547,
-0.0505470484,
-0.0134573588,
0.1314318329,
0.0478321426,
-0.0371656232,
-0.0007474961,
0.0336282291,
0.0221279003,
0.039756529,
0.0282986034,
-0.0711027905,
-0.0392941795,
0.0340774506,
0.0451905243,
-0.0136703402,
-0.0419104062,
-0.0234447997,
-0.1367571652,
0.0275349766,
-0.0248121303,
-0.0201954674,
-0.0113925617,
-0.0710177422,
-0.0061503043,
-0.0100956075,
0.0285713039,
0.0023711182,
-0.0081234286,
0.0059708157,
0.0478735231,
-0.0192166995,
-0.0685870796,
0.0067744581,
-0.0473872349,
0.0787175447,
0.0545576476,
-0.0059572659,
0.002608828,
-0.0195561629,
0.0468521938,
0.014298154,
-0.0047953301,
-0.0272504836,
0.0646192431,
-0.0158215333,
-0.0219760314,
0.001285997,
0.0467746705,
-0.0520343333,
-0.0186174288,
0.0013384447,
0.0485683754,
-0.0142092137,
0.0380160771,
0.002341137,
-0.0448203087,
0.0373327024,
0.1103840023,
0.013980777,
-0.0638622716,
-0.0282709058,
-0.0325084217,
-0.014871778,
-0.0443113409,
-0.0287097842,
0.0332082734,
-0.0362997241,
-0.0413551703,
-0.0640148893,
-0.0477957763,
0.072386086,
0.0531169139,
0.0337560177,
-0.0127061075,
0.0140911005,
-0.0157132056,
-0.0467924215,
0.0203576796,
-0.0638478622,
0.0114258472,
-0.0929211825,
-0.0500003248,
0.0284631271,
-0.0133579625,
-0.0096388152,
0.0252110902,
-0.0507257096,
-0.0609257817,
0.022224959,
0.0391920209,
0.0239713714,
0.037757691,
-0.0102447961,
-0.0511584058,
0.0320298746,
0.0554744154,
-0.0413551629,
-0.0227952916,
0.0076690335,
0.0111429673,
0.0090371901,
0.0319342874,
-0.0548751503,
0.0285069495,
0.0364940725,
0.0457838848,
-0.0321843401,
-0.0256834067,
0.0449912474,
0.0413698703,
0.0471433923,
-0.0244444422,
-0.0060879458,
-0.0330295227,
-0.0085605402,
-0.0434328616,
-0.0567648001,
-0.0349331833,
0.0265686531,
0.014533421,
0.0118240304,
-0.0033075754,
0.0200140309,
0.0110578947,
0.0512627773,
-0.0427865647,
-0.0176407527,
-0.0146030039,
0.0109366504,
0.0294013247,
0.0066410415,
-0.0272928085,
0.0284020621,
0.0351002626,
0.0217300281,
-0.0189973414,
0.0368079841,
0.0288603511,
-0.0079996772,
-0.0256591011,
0.0279755518,
-0.0495253354,
-0.0279546753,
-0.0365671106,
0.0337521732,
0.027795868,
-0.0095535377,
0.0343444198,
-0.0507945009,
-0.0376476534,
-0.0214035939,
0.0237210654,
0.0440865979,
-0.0419138856,
0.0272702575,
0.0224983785,
-0.0450049601,
-0.0181834754,
0.0879818723,
0.0460414104,
0.0459093861,
-0.0194961131,
-0.0313833766,
-0.0619819164,
0.0082909232,
0.0102508683,
-0.0145523949,
-0.0261230189,
0.0241803229,
-0.0492935032,
-0.060783986,
-0.0129712326,
0.0162899569,
-0.0011589315,
-0.0069928095,
0.071985513,
0.0648666173,
0.0093345363,
-0.012347511,
-0.0661339611,
0.0013848154,
0.0307761487,
-0.0480079539,
-0.0273379534,
-5.959021307e-33,
-0.0176242664,
-0.0446413532,
0.0143255861,
-0.0096165389,
0.0176186189,
0.0194016099,
-0.0339098163,
0.011279922,
0.0093448274,
0.001583316,
-0.0306833796,
-0.007588617,
0.0245325211,
0.0526554286,
0.0031989776,
-0.019218307,
0.063129507,
-0.0245406646,
-0.0170986485,
0.0252793301,
0.0212163404,
0.0188645516,
0.0145017216,
-0.0713879988,
0.0449523143,
-0.0025021748,
-0.0083512263,
0.0257288981,
0.0236360412,
0.0584604703,
-0.0294205714,
0.044111222,
0.0222275387,
-0.0676488504,
-0.0230094083,
0.0332623012,
-0.086107567,
-0.007654422,
-0.0089772763,
0.008519737,
-0.0280862879,
-0.0272142421,
0.0298372339,
-0.031080123,
-0.0259114224,
0.0443415344,
0.0332058892,
-0.0159776248,
-0.021414632,
-0.0126429917,
-0.0547445007,
0.0198279675,
0.0307469722,
-0.029866403,
0.0510587841,
0.0067616152,
0.0035566653,
0.0087688146,
-0.0499655381,
0.0014770695,
0.0132745802,
0.0326708779,
0.0607097745,
0.0405173264,
0.0150133967,
0.0369230993,
0.0208446961,
0.0452512279,
-0.0014366206,
0.0000820411,
-0.0113999238,
0.0284954123,
0.018343579,
0.0429627076,
0.0120257698,
-0.007052572,
-0.0323448442,
0.0203178748,
-0.003458448,
-0.0274816956,
0.0155002382,
0.0087138265,
-0.0628836825,
-0.019291386,
-0.0447445586,
0.0167712234,
-0.0397422388,
0.011564143,
0.0467816666,
0.0213780515,
-0.0380153209,
0.0200849865,
0.0178554561,
-0.0180605892,
-0.0441726707,
0.0023300666,
0.018725954,
0.0069028661,
-0.0118297087,
-0.010399634,
-0.0505088903,
-0.03855538,
0.0074144742,
-0.0032496122,
0.0154801067,
0.0201435797,
0.0476299487,
0.0227416456,
-0.0957462639,
0.0230135974,
-0.0333231799,
0.059670046,
0.0049644108,
0.0201100446,
0.0382204875,
-0.0070086736,
-0.0086142188,
0.0499091297,
0.0338283777,
-0.0358740538,
-0.0234158561,
-0.0080303717,
-0.0073431404,
0.0031090085,
-0.0237040706,
0.0127288587,
-0.0364171304,
0.0041677179,
0.0313088372,
-0.0152511261,
-0.0007705959,
-0.009661654,
2.551e-7,
0.0233145785,
0.0543534346,
0.0252208319,
0.0396197699,
0.0141061144,
0.0442103036,
0.0063280538,
0.0168409664,
-0.0154617084,
-0.0398581848,
-0.0198820941,
0.001646271,
0.0615650415,
0.0190262701,
-0.094980754,
0.002659322,
-0.0220526475,
0.0185787585,
-0.0667428225,
0.0165182538,
0.0786782056,
0.1040600911,
0.0143846171,
-0.0025765628,
-0.0262579657,
-0.0366635583,
0.0223085992,
-0.0315490477,
-0.0036653045,
0.0298200343,
0.0365193337,
0.0456294492,
0.0021516506,
0.0247927904,
-0.0381553546,
-0.028658418,
0.0079194671,
0.091365248,
0.0157560539,
-0.0058291974,
-0.0135086561,
-0.0515250228,
0.0060161655,
-0.041469492,
0.0689673722,
-0.0412571579,
-0.0206759162,
-0.0017586711,
-0.0021031175,
-0.0198305566,
-0.0434568487,
-0.0313245803,
-0.0031541458,
0.0090678735,
0.0326553322,
-0.0033384855,
-0.0316697694,
-0.0885551572,
-0.03528139,
-0.0039202631,
-0.0235304423,
-0.0423111133,
-0.0253127534,
0.0095613105,
0.012263664,
-0.0515711382,
0.0050801821,
2.821753297e-34,
0.0030449617,
0.0015080182,
0.0161713865,
0.01788605,
0.0223801676,
0.0134433825,
0.0059922342,
0.0104832696,
0.0087978076,
-0.0752634555,
-0.0110845948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20105v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20105v1 | Efficient Classification of Student Help Requests in Programming Courses Using Large Language Models | 2023-10-31T00:56:33 | 2023-10-31T00:56:33 | Jaromir Savelka, Paul Denny, Mark Liffiton, Brad Sheese | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | The accurate classification of student help requests with respect to the type
of help being sought can enable the tailoring of effective responses.
Automatically classifying such requests is non-trivial, but large language
models (LLMs) appear to offer an accessible, cost-effective solution. This
study evaluates the performance of the GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models for classifying
help requests from students in an introductory programming class. In zero-shot
trials, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 exhibited comparable performance on most categories,
while GPT-4 outperformed GPT-3.5 in classifying sub-categories for requests
related to debugging. Fine-tuning the GPT-3.5 model improved its performance to
such an extent that it approximated the accuracy and consistency across
categories observed between two human raters. Overall, this study demonstrates
the feasibility of using LLMs to enhance educational systems through the
automated classification of student needs. | [
0.0717859343,
-0.0128790298,
-0.0399680883,
0.0490507036,
-0.0239538345,
0.0212125741,
0.0005630447,
0.0093291691,
0.0295760054,
-0.0977207795,
0.0318795666,
-0.0210077092,
-0.0246908516,
-0.0085548507,
0.0035497185,
-0.086431168,
0.0122346422,
-0.0214855243,
0.0143561838,
0.0423653349,
0.0157589335,
0.030306017,
-0.0428954177,
0.0773301721,
0.0297628175,
-0.0268894173,
-0.0010749263,
-0.0219372008,
-0.0193049274,
-0.0089640524,
0.0468470342,
0.0445229858,
0.0163542833,
0.0147106433,
0.0000022709,
-0.0595230684,
-0.000637254,
-0.0025800965,
-0.0284398198,
0.0410506316,
-0.0087294504,
0.0417351536,
0.0200357772,
0.0442942977,
-0.0128757916,
-0.0262184348,
0.0432485864,
0.0074615669,
0.0669142827,
0.0279875733,
0.0250490066,
-0.0099171968,
0.0018680405,
0.0268459655,
0.0627311617,
-0.0142894527,
0.0273357853,
0.0378116518,
0.0684447661,
0.025435565,
-0.0012089243,
0.0018857501,
-0.0105886785,
-0.0328059457,
0.0260281358,
0.0231874213,
-0.0579560213,
0.0000253297,
0.029164739,
0.0217990279,
-0.0333899781,
-0.0242402088,
0.0025687506,
-0.0195652507,
0.0248383936,
0.0563302487,
-0.0576746315,
0.0128039559,
-0.0292823296,
-0.037523821,
0.0231207032,
-0.0143258767,
-0.0128463013,
0.027959805,
0.0152257578,
0.0173157621,
-0.0186348855,
-0.0494768359,
-0.0180673897,
0.0342680551,
-0.0353454128,
-0.0219364911,
0.0289619584,
0.0532283187,
-0.0038198344,
0.0098472545,
0.0067332252,
0.0101948902,
0.0362703167,
-0.0372646004,
0.021926811,
0.0344007611,
0.001161217,
0.0215048958,
-0.0102136945,
0.0660177618,
0.0422357544,
-0.0485710874,
-0.0193520263,
0.0388157368,
-0.1088362858,
-0.0135653568,
-0.0508900583,
0.075679414,
0.0279013384,
0.0377758555,
-0.0507436842,
0.0559771769,
0.0022152164,
-0.0017147948,
-0.0072904848,
-0.0472746007,
0.0125525352,
0.0250741094,
-0.029250294,
0.0034810107,
-0.0200153701,
-0.0089563122,
-0.0369940996,
-0.0428409763,
0.0459043719,
0.008934522,
-0.0278430972,
-0.0101187089,
0.0063786646,
0.0311252028,
0.0059389421,
-0.0046085124,
-0.0521844588,
-0.0460322276,
0.0251087286,
0.0091489777,
-0.0402761698,
-0.0649655685,
-0.041420158,
0.0447631329,
0.016020216,
0.040750999,
0.0001835427,
0.0117710792,
-0.002286358,
0.0427295417,
-0.0179964062,
0.0309200361,
0.0852360949,
0.0144485002,
-0.000003843,
0.0142093394,
-0.0094465744,
0.0158073809,
0.0346049964,
-0.0816461444,
0.0793465525,
0.0114891296,
-0.0624262728,
-0.0103784911,
0.0234063379,
0.0049533532,
0.0061244126,
0.01142086,
-0.0246432591,
0.0132001322,
0.0065795192,
0.020365892,
0.0127012478,
0.0735729188,
0.0327762961,
0.0309481509,
0.029648019,
0.0684778094,
0.0173681788,
-0.0358474031,
-0.0230834689,
0.0263487697,
-0.0355623402,
-0.016348172,
0.02363999,
0.006647279,
-0.004927801,
-0.0665321946,
-0.0399312489,
-0.0103527876,
-0.0498847924,
0.0263015889,
0.0608496666,
-0.0419670157,
-0.0153763844,
0.0205621533,
0.0179275628,
-0.0343872532,
-0.0048298445,
-0.0930374786,
0.055889003,
0.0855871662,
0.0443531275,
-0.0699728206,
-0.013998569,
-0.0048440881,
-0.0115573239,
-0.0234024376,
0.0566092655,
-0.0139819542,
-0.0506981388,
-0.0395226739,
-0.022494521,
0.0353016183,
-0.0028365967,
0.0046488279,
0.0092744259,
-0.0253051054,
0.0128765497,
0.0025409204,
-0.0742351338,
0.0282626487,
0.0382938646,
-0.0414483063,
-0.0134862419,
0.0214824341,
0.0204359908,
0.0164629295,
0.0059323665,
0.004191143,
0.0155126881,
-0.001686784,
-0.0169899538,
-0.0665734485,
-0.0201292597,
-0.0106551768,
0.0492725074,
0.0237605497,
-0.012090263,
0.0171761792,
0.001822884,
-0.0050378432,
0.0553972572,
-0.0592942312,
0.0343142413,
-0.0023367703,
0.0243080109,
-0.0449369103,
-0.0512254834,
-0.0530040041,
0.0140473899,
0.0608936399,
0.0476300605,
-0.0355170742,
0.0024244206,
0.0128461588,
-0.0129037891,
-0.024540877,
0.0125124045,
-0.0332070738,
0.0496479087,
0.0265340041,
0.024307359,
-0.0264128204,
-0.0265285037,
-0.0615028106,
-0.0220675357,
0.0265429709,
0.0271734353,
0.0040590954,
-0.0312084407,
-0.0202253275,
0.0058426955,
-0.0355090164,
-0.0186306294,
-0.0244689733,
-0.017289944,
0.0009463123,
0.0096272528,
-0.0613870136,
-0.0232621245,
-0.0066387127,
-0.0443735234,
-0.0140139554,
0.0621745698,
-0.0619784556,
-0.0600946173,
0.0688193813,
0.0030554754,
-0.0139730023,
0.0132870572,
-0.0542960018,
-0.0122043472,
-0.0471620262,
0.0261248592,
0.0551884808,
-0.0007916404,
0.0125013022,
0.0438695475,
0.0063610254,
-0.0652932674,
0.005144415,
-0.0107957618,
-0.0573748425,
0.0316296555,
-0.0705173612,
0.0357129984,
0.0628292039,
0.0190951098,
-0.0343273319,
-0.035364341,
-0.0010353082,
-0.0403023846,
0.0702855587,
-0.0506666079,
-0.01569039,
0.0083010718,
0.0085549215,
0.0313057341,
-0.0617154688,
0.0739706382,
-0.0196744483,
-0.0099506546,
-0.0511580408,
-0.0530929081,
-0.0225093719,
0.0161475148,
-0.0023635903,
0.0188126899,
-0.0163999405,
-0.0260348786,
0.0229016729,
-0.0109090153,
0.0239594541,
-0.0338006355,
0.0393252447,
-0.0802806467,
-0.0035063238,
-0.0042807548,
0.0077651772,
-0.0228914805,
-0.0108165005,
0.0010089499,
-0.0124332188,
-0.0032447926,
-0.0132185686,
-0.0048067099,
0.0315693393,
0.0294410829,
0.0472469553,
-0.0343911089,
-0.0359113477,
0.0240322351,
-0.0077056759,
-0.0328205787,
-0.0258816052,
-0.042267181,
-0.0104933288,
0.0410833396,
0.0266949534,
0.0244711246,
0.0300160982,
0.0001173367,
-0.00456955,
0.0592002459,
-0.0494884811,
-0.0380549729,
0.0528021194,
-0.0144766318,
-0.0768571347,
-0.0037938824,
0.1058651805,
0.0569680706,
-0.0871136412,
-0.0370738022,
-0.0231923871,
-0.0225371569,
0.0482263602,
0.0424278714,
-0.0395719372,
-0.0285079479,
-0.0246222056,
0.0566586703,
-0.0397662632,
-0.0027882603,
0.005234086,
-0.0776480213,
0.0253778156,
0.0101873884,
-0.0271838643,
-0.0330201425,
-0.0491857976,
0.0107597094,
0.0121092126,
-0.018019719,
-0.0072897887,
-0.0083644716,
0.028630618,
0.0829555541,
-0.0841100365,
-0.0652230307,
0.0218785964,
0.0256382842,
0.0547707751,
0.0253634918,
-0.0172836818,
-0.0584915429,
-0.0087272245,
0.0618466027,
-0.0000915772,
-0.0236646645,
-0.0199023597,
0.0204684157,
-0.0122812651,
0.019554615,
0.0026414637,
-0.0122798998,
-0.0596365929,
0.0329802297,
0.0945756361,
0.0926596597,
-0.0144856963,
0.0031074884,
-0.0309012383,
-0.0040187147,
-0.0093308641,
0.0509397648,
0.0549307726,
-0.0504827797,
0.0293214712,
-0.0732916966,
-0.0503056422,
0.0140917506,
-0.0335205495,
-0.0015528166,
-0.0396745987,
-0.0071416162,
-0.0030011202,
-0.0124907177,
0.0787787586,
-0.0233233757,
0.0066091409,
0.0318237506,
0.0310978647,
0.0241229683,
-0.0362076834,
0.0295670312,
0.0095850686,
0.0028294902,
-0.1222439781,
-0.0503651649,
0.0284451246,
-0.0266965833,
-0.016357284,
-0.0127816722,
-0.0029169756,
-0.0493117906,
-0.0062965592,
0.036304988,
0.0223503988,
-0.0736311004,
0.0135596069,
-0.0644966364,
-0.0742056072,
0.0363414995,
0.0039692088,
-0.0170890689,
-0.0344108008,
0.0041232272,
-0.0039346302,
-0.0316497572,
-0.0243339222,
0.0278183166,
-0.0098060612,
-0.0295870528,
-0.0627806857,
-0.0137880845,
0.027561456,
0.081656456,
0.0190943759,
0.0109280143,
-0.04618131,
-0.0069211172,
-0.0055075553,
0.0002808744,
-0.0246578436,
-0.0203220155,
0.0084912954,
0.0479940362,
-0.008209453,
0.0164612364,
-0.0317286029,
-0.0553232804,
-0.0219202582,
-0.0156165296,
0.0587926097,
-0.0036727786,
0.0621186569,
0.0375344269,
-0.0089922613,
-0.0420066081,
-0.0557892956,
0.0393049791,
0.03320406,
-0.0075724907,
0.0698370486,
-0.0153732365,
0.0255158935,
0.0265191607,
0.026798863,
0.0208657272,
-0.0950727314,
0.0018702819,
0.0099439612,
-0.0068876464,
0.0300742183,
0.0024149837,
-0.0187154748,
0.0040872041,
-0.0238260236,
0.053046938,
0.0059004733,
-0.0134867094,
0.0230573583,
0.0311110076,
0.0014752119,
-0.0244310703,
0.0309932698,
0.001769157,
-0.0208532512,
0.0139643867,
-0.0623130985,
-0.0282619409,
0.0464596674,
0.0455922671,
0.0064633144,
-0.0078743752,
0.0209285077,
-0.0570623316,
-0.0448758192,
-0.0606701747,
0.0066160616,
0.0319737904,
-0.0078519406,
0.052928064,
0.0723602921,
-0.033584334,
-0.0165115334,
-0.043076314,
0.0065834126,
-0.0550274588,
-0.013067863,
-0.0058796322,
-5.956229876e-33,
-0.0298129246,
-0.0514069498,
-0.0016387559,
0.033706639,
0.0283903908,
0.0073497724,
0.0062667131,
0.0434760824,
-0.0042839404,
-0.0273775496,
0.0467200987,
0.0152384806,
-0.0091097448,
-0.0186376907,
0.0408257619,
0.020152986,
0.0086311409,
0.0110906456,
-0.022352621,
0.0514195487,
0.0134681808,
-0.0204959288,
0.0478571691,
-0.0744883567,
0.0294975769,
-0.0366302729,
0.0102063343,
0.0162629746,
0.0047589401,
0.0569269694,
-0.0134632699,
0.0760763735,
0.0347273573,
0.0026355919,
0.0257876758,
0.0296943393,
0.0106158732,
-0.0401119962,
0.0243770573,
-0.0156973097,
0.0472300649,
-0.0275636017,
0.0173888858,
0.0224865358,
-0.0415317006,
0.0037669577,
0.0717978999,
-0.002463985,
0.0190599989,
-0.0052900403,
-0.0433995873,
0.0107250707,
-0.0452681743,
-0.0227573868,
0.0160994902,
0.0312611125,
-0.0287976265,
0.0323204622,
0.0490661487,
0.0319661349,
0.0518368818,
0.053531982,
0.0220684223,
0.0055922447,
-0.054504972,
-0.0000737198,
-0.0048818598,
0.0076412898,
0.0045746989,
-0.0205556583,
0.0228057243,
-0.0283057243,
0.0706029534,
0.0310814809,
0.068668358,
0.0053960145,
-0.0464305729,
0.0441830344,
0.088670589,
-0.0257889964,
0.0043752133,
-0.0282915253,
-0.0702610314,
-0.0325444154,
-0.0080333995,
-0.0236407351,
-0.0367756709,
-0.0217913929,
0.0569742061,
-0.0470107011,
0.0005869897,
-0.0288958382,
-0.0066489112,
0.0025017723,
-0.0305752698,
-0.0220767204,
-0.0095958887,
0.0434267111,
-0.0285991877,
0.0079726893,
-0.0609097667,
-0.0207064245,
-0.0110414838,
-0.0457668491,
0.0379005931,
0.0011807148,
-0.0101347594,
0.0040686484,
-0.044307556,
0.0079055075,
-0.0254596956,
-0.0327412412,
0.002914197,
0.0403209254,
0.0046722479,
0.0006628714,
0.0192644503,
0.0538279861,
-0.0021530222,
-0.072646901,
-0.0586996675,
-0.0179117005,
-0.0325217471,
-0.0132440748,
-0.0182372704,
-0.0201510731,
-0.0292912368,
0.0188694764,
0.0295739714,
-0.0307152439,
-0.0161769725,
-0.0220986698,
2.907e-7,
0.0141141964,
0.0787246749,
-0.0387664624,
-0.0152939213,
-0.0406446643,
0.0236730091,
0.0069219572,
-0.0194264203,
0.0616921335,
0.0385120921,
-0.0022367379,
-0.0168986376,
0.0273513831,
0.0182479173,
-0.0645797402,
-0.0252891704,
0.0086139375,
0.0007003347,
-0.0585047491,
0.0373349525,
0.105360195,
0.0248776339,
0.0228938106,
0.0047233445,
-0.0339095592,
-0.0612881035,
-0.0176233836,
-0.040848095,
-0.0122638522,
0.0632652044,
0.0056446744,
0.0205541663,
0.0349407755,
0.0584245846,
0.0083017359,
-0.0357354879,
0.0016265106,
0.0294990838,
-0.0030643495,
0.0219156891,
0.0379861034,
0.0094980616,
0.0145968292,
-0.0704924241,
-0.0225763693,
-0.0104671773,
0.0312958136,
0.0689941123,
0.0000658602,
-0.0595556498,
-0.0162740368,
-0.03884653,
-0.0013249617,
0.0213495251,
0.003833537,
-0.0489411876,
0.001873698,
-0.0470473617,
-0.0019275248,
0.0105924997,
-0.0269033238,
-0.0444569662,
-0.0024990882,
-0.0161707047,
0.0253475923,
0.0114040636,
0.031428352,
2.766468328e-34,
0.0096265264,
0.0040310728,
0.0595072322,
0.0209672991,
0.0200544149,
0.0423637666,
-0.018425975,
0.0403064638,
0.0152790304,
-0.0207931828,
-0.0135954199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20093v1 | Evaluating Neural Language Models as Cognitive Models of Language Acquisition | 2023-10-31T00:16:17 | 2023-10-31T00:16:17 | Héctor Javier Vázquez Martínez, Annika Lea Heuser, Charles Yang, Jordan Kodner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The success of neural language models (LMs) on many technological tasks has
brought about their potential relevance as scientific theories of language
despite some clear differences between LM training and child language
acquisition. In this paper we argue that some of the most prominent benchmarks
for evaluating the syntactic capacities of LMs may not be sufficiently
rigorous. In particular, we show that the template-based benchmarks lack the
structural diversity commonly found in the theoretical and psychological
studies of language. When trained on small-scale data modeling child language
acquisition, the LMs can be readily matched by simple baseline models. We
advocate for the use of the readily available, carefully curated datasets that
have been evaluated for gradient acceptability by large pools of native
speakers and are designed to probe the structural basis of grammar
specifically. On one such dataset, the LI-Adger dataset, LMs evaluate sentences
in a way inconsistent with human language users. We conclude with suggestions
for better connecting LMs with the empirical study of child language
acquisition. | [
0.0151669821,
0.0800054967,
-0.0308891162,
0.0313074924,
-0.0400005057,
0.0220644251,
-0.0060444088,
-0.0287650675,
-0.0255091731,
-0.0324267522,
-0.0444641784,
-0.0761796907,
0.0254293289,
-0.0146006476,
0.0343251601,
-0.011010292,
0.0570511296,
-0.0425014123,
-0.0055935537,
0.0083289417,
-0.027714083,
-0.0183852762,
-0.0336119793,
0.047821492,
-0.0248321574,
-0.0195966549,
0.0053383219,
-0.0150178913,
-0.0723682791,
-0.0435160473,
0.0050711669,
0.0340325274,
0.0164617691,
0.048876334,
0.0000018937,
-0.043595925,
0.0571316779,
-0.0391809344,
-0.061939802,
0.0224441569,
0.0517144054,
-0.020278044,
-0.0242381487,
-0.0094205299,
-0.0425732993,
-0.0210481528,
0.0234844219,
-0.0054499535,
0.0012800551,
0.0469476432,
-0.0024630295,
-0.0182415005,
0.0477033257,
-0.0180294402,
-0.0204516649,
0.0195418634,
0.0273894444,
0.0070706392,
0.0064232694,
-0.0538643375,
-0.0285668783,
0.0083543677,
0.0263428725,
0.0270798188,
-0.0092275981,
0.0336927474,
0.0006045589,
-0.0462396368,
-0.0558550879,
0.0298231859,
-0.0103815775,
-0.0308797006,
0.0036237405,
0.0052887555,
0.000441021,
-0.0034483646,
-0.0437212624,
0.0597079284,
0.0066603851,
0.0560322367,
0.0447805487,
-0.0802349001,
0.0519974343,
0.0229212698,
0.019291183,
0.093355976,
0.0055550812,
-0.0560351945,
0.0129356515,
0.037524011,
-0.0066448343,
-0.0405064709,
-0.022133464,
0.004204799,
-0.0087982882,
0.0377218984,
-0.0380126759,
-0.0120609542,
0.0070602596,
-0.0503002889,
0.1013604552,
0.0092663867,
-0.0031237968,
0.027968945,
-0.0205080044,
0.0574157052,
0.0081252465,
0.0448834933,
-0.0427532233,
0.0320885181,
-0.01584314,
-0.0352478176,
-0.0154297575,
0.0227134358,
-0.0221687146,
-0.0031511574,
-0.0395223312,
-0.0161875822,
-0.0051970398,
-0.0423407443,
0.0164448619,
-0.0050829123,
-0.0310809016,
0.0317476392,
-0.0639717057,
-0.0152228558,
0.0101625053,
0.0802004933,
0.0311607607,
-0.0773073956,
-0.0094450321,
0.0103415931,
-0.0128390528,
0.0204692762,
0.018961275,
0.0375613645,
-0.0047232737,
-0.0497056693,
-0.0323960818,
0.0234510154,
-0.0362784192,
-0.0530905947,
0.0384599455,
-0.05201957,
-0.0019297197,
-0.0001923707,
-0.013552404,
-0.0821908861,
-0.0147753088,
0.0089730844,
-0.0229436997,
0.0212858059,
-0.0124006821,
0.0274477806,
-0.003647194,
-0.0048179301,
0.0283185318,
0.0499088243,
0.0582842901,
-0.0332063921,
-0.0001018354,
-0.024086386,
-0.0228094961,
0.0395505875,
0.0022957218,
-0.0028362572,
-0.0525023378,
-0.0355919637,
-0.0081435768,
0.0353028066,
0.0489670113,
0.0492667072,
-0.0243809577,
-0.0021203463,
0.0825329795,
0.0874467939,
-0.0104221515,
0.0002532241,
0.0714013427,
-0.0007750878,
0.0378042236,
0.0162690841,
-0.0315532722,
-0.0098281289,
-0.0287409294,
-0.0021261387,
-0.0281492509,
0.0391768627,
-0.0225801375,
-0.0335613377,
-0.0155703565,
-0.0187758673,
0.0331806913,
-0.0030293432,
0.0494830608,
0.0600729175,
-0.0334170535,
0.0365737937,
0.0656643808,
-0.0442631394,
0.0295685064,
-0.0318429545,
0.0323231034,
-0.0122370133,
-0.0058447835,
0.0222115275,
-0.0217038654,
0.0213969946,
-0.0218445007,
0.0616671294,
0.0262844823,
0.0228739679,
0.0341358818,
-0.0254032165,
0.0186783634,
-0.0019002409,
0.0501906089,
0.0070700953,
-0.0366314128,
-0.0308071505,
-0.0252843164,
-0.0286034327,
-0.0538720973,
0.0789620429,
-0.0583045557,
-0.0120941559,
-0.0076425443,
-0.004870289,
0.0478539653,
0.0012595386,
0.0108849993,
0.0223842878,
0.0525321327,
-0.0036042603,
0.0364778265,
0.0324121676,
-0.0949297994,
-0.0362185277,
0.0166324992,
0.0120860934,
-0.0084703332,
0.0445319973,
0.0121044209,
-0.0235007573,
0.0606802516,
-0.0453700125,
0.0384007022,
-0.0115984464,
0.062081486,
-0.0301372837,
0.0354141705,
0.0018047076,
0.0477065109,
-0.0166288707,
0.0206154808,
-0.0097387936,
0.0016100347,
0.0061705867,
-0.069497712,
-0.042639412,
-0.011690015,
-0.0385434516,
0.0260804631,
-0.0333810113,
0.0040752692,
-0.061074201,
0.0020254953,
-0.057344351,
-0.0000048494,
0.0053614038,
0.039417576,
0.006922727,
-0.0575913973,
-0.0013590029,
0.0129620004,
-0.0068217795,
0.0304549318,
0.0105759781,
0.0252050962,
0.0576249324,
-0.0128124338,
-0.0547609963,
-0.0535120927,
-0.0246375892,
-0.0448665097,
0.0473668799,
-0.0022862754,
0.0221635867,
-0.0119893467,
-0.0120440461,
-0.0200574622,
0.0188870504,
-0.0059226719,
-0.0447741933,
0.0553329065,
0.0079307286,
0.0342776626,
0.0751209408,
-0.0283337031,
0.0259641893,
0.0299346019,
-0.0040561962,
-0.0400772579,
-0.0093578668,
-0.0287772622,
0.0006684785,
-0.0256279595,
-0.0160769112,
0.0108055314,
0.1384004056,
0.0232910309,
-0.0148267811,
-0.0230455529,
0.0395525731,
-0.0364293344,
-0.0111650135,
-0.026029462,
-0.041113209,
-0.0644575655,
0.0461101905,
-0.0588027164,
-0.0739288554,
0.0096746143,
-0.0481306016,
-0.0191365518,
-0.0357625745,
-0.0212753117,
-0.0167849194,
0.033577662,
0.0546598397,
-0.0057372455,
0.0414274968,
-0.0047683031,
-0.060013175,
0.0195022319,
0.0227866862,
-0.0112875085,
0.0321451277,
-0.066308029,
-0.0062898211,
0.0347924717,
-0.0073069371,
-0.0360300355,
-0.0277383067,
-0.0226309113,
0.0325240567,
0.0070505636,
0.0137928482,
-0.002572896,
-0.0075309444,
0.0166408625,
0.0434235111,
0.0182116143,
0.0046875933,
-0.0285453908,
0.0050390917,
0.0178470146,
-0.0104100071,
0.0033061188,
-0.0245932378,
0.0161288343,
0.0287814066,
0.0225545261,
0.0663842037,
-0.0587403551,
0.0751732662,
0.0258246567,
0.0271190442,
-0.0141399214,
0.0414271541,
0.0318504721,
-0.0405736528,
-0.014219746,
0.061250031,
0.0394619703,
-0.0240820982,
0.0402908772,
0.0329127498,
0.01854234,
0.0260561239,
-0.038760297,
-0.0409180224,
-0.0009318633,
0.02577422,
-0.0015442761,
-0.0031548806,
-0.0218190458,
-0.0200872999,
-0.0979449749,
-0.019837182,
-0.0001410048,
-0.0527347811,
0.0170983002,
-0.0339989178,
-0.0158008914,
0.0292198341,
0.0664911196,
0.0538982302,
-0.0370290726,
0.0066006226,
0.0371508375,
-0.0394028351,
-0.0976154506,
0.0180723686,
-0.0659528077,
0.0726883039,
0.0473886654,
-0.0007408263,
-0.0510569438,
-0.0427570343,
0.0707671717,
-0.0049838107,
-0.0037626962,
-0.0015169206,
0.0022733398,
0.011007987,
-0.0214151498,
-0.0223779678,
0.0073341136,
-0.0449650139,
-0.0103616361,
-0.0183659792,
0.0943102166,
0.0339499898,
-0.0428178608,
0.0312922709,
0.0182651784,
-0.0136905434,
0.0730421245,
0.0655191988,
-0.0750144869,
0.0067537916,
-0.0174030177,
-0.0219622664,
-0.0130958008,
-0.0392129868,
0.0697773173,
0.0052103917,
0.0110148592,
-0.099694401,
-0.0385725461,
0.0049563972,
-0.003927114,
0.0328051299,
0.0161396749,
0.0260797814,
-0.0611476675,
-0.0034793925,
0.074996382,
0.0104612028,
-0.0221171137,
-0.0949073732,
-0.0238854997,
0.0200959854,
-0.0362010077,
-0.0268797223,
-0.0200984851,
-0.0617592633,
-0.0755103305,
0.0001403376,
0.034964297,
0.0267280973,
-0.0237682443,
0.0008190063,
-0.0507610515,
0.0198580734,
0.033995159,
-0.0070132362,
0.0103886249,
0.0077346764,
-0.0228663702,
0.0075365836,
0.0105377436,
-0.0068330062,
0.0292838663,
-0.0047600209,
0.0376483202,
0.0034789511,
0.0218073521,
0.0611728244,
0.0135317156,
0.0534073599,
-0.0127028208,
-0.0217730589,
-0.0556488484,
-0.0237904117,
-0.0050761802,
0.0299092028,
-0.0312166102,
-0.0435978919,
0.0248224549,
0.0480898321,
-0.0292670522,
-0.0358051881,
-0.0103667239,
0.0603803582,
-0.0155026307,
0.0145769985,
-0.0037629111,
0.0358910225,
0.0118565066,
0.0390290432,
0.0071257856,
-0.0033775393,
-0.0757483244,
0.0230309833,
-0.0006019707,
0.0167557914,
0.003924014,
0.0136363618,
-0.006000808,
-0.0095913801,
-0.0117605468,
-0.0217343755,
-0.0103626177,
-0.0246508066,
0.0766436532,
-0.0479800887,
0.0419783406,
-0.052631747,
0.0257009044,
-0.039141912,
0.0032118072,
-0.0083564492,
-0.0286772456,
0.0846703351,
-0.0003734308,
-0.0167915691,
-0.0005410581,
0.0523971468,
0.0251215827,
0.0356025696,
-0.0085380226,
0.0506008528,
-0.025944341,
-0.0027133618,
0.0188610069,
0.00250861,
-0.0530656762,
0.0044827457,
-0.0298777297,
-0.0719323307,
-0.0470145158,
0.0222767722,
0.035178937,
-0.0499212109,
0.013905663,
0.0431479029,
-0.0240110755,
0.0075872941,
-0.0123167401,
-0.0061506489,
-0.0318334475,
0.0080993995,
-0.0277393647,
-6.220635289e-33,
-0.0030385866,
-0.0107895173,
0.0187427681,
0.0114335055,
0.0166472774,
-0.0000014284,
-0.044273898,
0.0393589772,
-0.0466632508,
-0.0060286275,
-0.0055956426,
-0.0088558216,
0.0087321354,
0.0385636948,
0.0275405124,
0.0156900138,
0.004019584,
-0.0575467199,
0.0082752211,
-0.0394577719,
-0.0298388731,
-0.0051463661,
0.0624898747,
-0.0009879792,
0.0353144072,
-0.0149519797,
0.0233616587,
0.0050003049,
-0.0483255647,
0.0681385547,
-0.0202373601,
0.0262795594,
0.0425912701,
0.0088849105,
-0.0079811756,
-0.0126378667,
-0.0543508157,
0.001688876,
0.0610364489,
0.0210149158,
-0.0611654408,
-0.0055221878,
0.0695530325,
-0.0173423775,
-0.0460367948,
0.0376752205,
-0.0078642955,
-0.0162642375,
-0.0246908609,
0.0129959797,
-0.0560368933,
-0.0055703707,
0.0179241262,
-0.0078740101,
0.0323241055,
0.0492949747,
-0.0728970617,
-0.0141484924,
-0.05628464,
0.0087132556,
0.0263301954,
0.0578810312,
0.0752044469,
0.0045723524,
0.0322775915,
0.0513470434,
0.0720856264,
0.0208523925,
0.0013431805,
0.0064938595,
0.0942786932,
0.0198880918,
0.0355650969,
-0.0128602143,
0.0655277297,
-0.0083863251,
-0.0695509836,
-0.0333961695,
0.0714498013,
0.0372051969,
0.0243128557,
0.0161713343,
-0.0240162276,
-0.0269332044,
-0.0526882187,
-0.0709085688,
-0.0350127406,
-0.0243874583,
0.0293642953,
0.0034397615,
0.0235594194,
-0.0385349318,
-0.0127477776,
-0.0062131793,
0.0006745384,
-0.0183771849,
0.0139471246,
0.0143050384,
0.0168981273,
0.0256070532,
-0.0981868207,
-0.0449129492,
-0.012967024,
0.0254238602,
0.0375119075,
0.057932958,
0.0405834578,
-0.0131162135,
-0.0085022971,
-0.007417188,
-0.0354266651,
-0.0076563936,
0.0294710342,
0.0120308539,
0.0625528246,
0.0024448694,
-0.0412732288,
0.0086255046,
-0.0113494219,
-0.0151607944,
-0.037351381,
0.0068155006,
-0.0287927222,
0.057833042,
-0.0066771223,
-0.0119434316,
-0.0472605452,
0.0254278239,
0.0597832352,
-0.0233334154,
0.0007789783,
0.0155404173,
2.582e-7,
-0.0084175663,
0.0582358725,
0.0001580462,
0.0259093214,
0.0449495576,
-0.0051695956,
-0.0694236234,
-0.026346894,
0.0115357321,
-0.0081511652,
-0.0520835333,
0.0046140882,
0.0787677318,
-0.017946234,
-0.0652522743,
-0.0136302114,
-0.062812455,
0.0302495584,
-0.0360869989,
0.0102242101,
-0.0001025519,
0.0599151291,
-0.0215376448,
-0.0275526214,
-0.0123557504,
-0.0243711397,
0.0480116718,
-0.0554485805,
0.0162123535,
-0.0260883197,
0.0031388868,
0.0165048074,
-0.0108731268,
0.0391283818,
-0.0175132491,
0.0377630107,
-0.0265355911,
0.0214792341,
0.0113621941,
0.0096446071,
0.0159216169,
-0.0047712573,
-0.0483124405,
-0.0504406393,
0.0253499839,
-0.0720319301,
-0.0385946035,
0.0266508646,
-0.0316360146,
0.0242480338,
-0.0033186586,
-0.0094878823,
-0.0039059345,
-0.0063023446,
0.025317993,
-0.0246068574,
-0.0063891718,
-0.0001480669,
0.004296415,
0.0585070327,
-0.0171168838,
-0.0490862653,
-0.0345836356,
-0.0015888981,
0.0202832632,
-0.0170426089,
0.015250192,
1.9982605e-34,
-0.0006865831,
-0.0323636048,
0.085271135,
0.0050750966,
0.0334436968,
-0.0097101238,
0.0224008374,
0.0330532864,
0.0185134299,
-0.0901467279,
0.0126020359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20089v1 | Keyword-optimized Template Insertion for Clinical Information Extraction via Prompt-based Learning | 2023-10-31T00:07:11 | 2023-10-31T00:07:11 | Eugenia Alleva, Isotta Landi, Leslee J Shaw, Erwin Böttinger, Thomas J Fuchs, Ipek Ensari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Clinical note classification is a common clinical NLP task. However,
annotated data-sets are scarse. Prompt-based learning has recently emerged as
an effective method to adapt pre-trained models for text classification using
only few training examples. A critical component of prompt design is the
definition of the template (i.e. prompt text). The effect of template position,
however, has been insufficiently investigated. This seems particularly
important in the clinical setting, where task-relevant information is usually
sparse in clinical notes. In this study we develop a keyword-optimized template
insertion method (KOTI) and show how optimizing position can improve
performance on several clinical tasks in a zero-shot and few-shot training
setting. | [
0.0665875375,
-0.0423513129,
0.0465377346,
-0.0447920896,
-0.0157919247,
0.038691096,
0.012051207,
0.0416777655,
-0.015067447,
-0.0545959473,
-0.0228361916,
-0.0339535736,
-0.0059526968,
0.0115752136,
0.0080360686,
-0.050969772,
0.0602726825,
0.0370728336,
0.0532129966,
0.0469486527,
-0.0131964041,
-0.0141031062,
-0.0420339629,
0.015411919,
0.0072301459,
0.0120594455,
0.0074392576,
0.0112474328,
0.0181970745,
-0.0585627258,
-0.0038967603,
0.0335320532,
-0.037294358,
-0.017088607,
0.0000016355,
-0.0462361649,
-0.0243199598,
0.0438048504,
-0.0561842248,
-0.0221033897,
0.0382565632,
-0.0501838923,
0.0127992267,
0.0236130115,
-0.0146975797,
-0.0742938295,
0.0250482149,
0.0709237829,
0.0462417752,
0.1075033993,
-0.018444743,
0.0118437335,
-0.0052351989,
-0.0343916751,
0.0372156836,
-0.0251151305,
0.0355196372,
-0.0493504182,
0.0253387354,
0.016551381,
0.0251326729,
0.0370611548,
-0.0381790772,
0.0206216387,
0.0462885685,
0.0383403897,
-0.0319406278,
-0.0416552164,
-0.0237892494,
0.0362978056,
-0.038344048,
-0.0162232574,
0.0422899351,
-0.0588235781,
-0.0075961901,
0.0157120153,
-0.0054270015,
-0.0086804861,
-0.0460645556,
-0.0282885078,
0.0511915646,
0.0042276499,
0.0014870415,
-0.0074085342,
-0.0275801141,
-0.0353169963,
0.0171271674,
-0.0641068593,
0.0232560188,
-0.0065691243,
-0.0181484167,
-0.0488773547,
0.0082082171,
0.0219054613,
-0.0333625972,
0.0167920496,
-0.0076483265,
-0.0500261858,
0.0716189519,
-0.0423798822,
0.0668923631,
0.0108493399,
-0.022005463,
0.0480179973,
-0.0326792374,
-0.0084605338,
-0.0093411291,
0.0382840931,
-0.0312421396,
0.0731752068,
-0.0137182204,
-0.0286798645,
-0.0221243184,
0.0342405215,
-0.0006959593,
-0.0249499641,
-0.0248738434,
0.0342623927,
0.027462773,
0.0117970044,
0.0098102586,
0.0022293208,
-0.014807594,
0.0205067713,
0.0320362747,
-0.017536914,
-0.0216205642,
-0.0141200097,
-0.0272535868,
-0.0047946172,
0.0081088999,
0.011953393,
0.0552639849,
-0.0201754645,
0.0485514328,
-0.0034729016,
0.0135571631,
-0.0493588559,
0.0188324936,
-0.0283914823,
-0.0171309654,
0.0421228744,
-0.0007673177,
-0.0281273276,
0.008073031,
0.0173836146,
-0.0033402226,
-0.0028805556,
0.015588589,
0.0356012397,
-0.0756471604,
0.0630545989,
-0.0437515825,
-0.0170498397,
0.020384362,
0.0140092941,
0.0070390301,
0.0211533327,
-0.016319355,
-0.0016867885,
0.0194890779,
-0.0196452308,
0.0281682704,
-0.0044919793,
0.0150534017,
-0.0610279478,
-0.0033576346,
0.0259913895,
0.0750231296,
0.0741140172,
-0.0396379121,
0.0291266032,
-0.0091674849,
0.0334943086,
-0.0064407461,
0.0406441018,
0.0344626345,
-0.0244837347,
0.0408952571,
-0.0065538683,
-0.0089864656,
0.0035246278,
-0.0042826501,
-0.0609425083,
-0.0341873243,
0.0118700806,
-0.0058547738,
-0.0382502265,
-0.0192893166,
-0.0256527476,
-0.0255911052,
0.0053564208,
-0.0764315501,
-0.0183911696,
0.0310836099,
0.0195172392,
-0.0698069111,
0.0428868644,
0.0538881123,
-0.0151997544,
-0.0360052548,
-0.0237094015,
-0.0165405367,
0.0037203769,
0.0318760313,
-0.0773464292,
-0.071660161,
-0.0168734454,
0.009377595,
-0.0062606735,
0.029848706,
-0.0063220621,
0.0071186027,
-0.0280964579,
-0.0080952467,
0.0226867776,
0.0176191032,
-0.0099345902,
0.0020628402,
0.0092345355,
0.0017021883,
0.0289207473,
-0.0381403826,
0.0732894838,
-0.006618815,
-0.0881608948,
0.0222440567,
0.0178969204,
-0.0030057856,
0.0072781495,
-0.0278500561,
0.010331546,
0.0206691064,
-0.0249769762,
0.0070633367,
-0.0376109146,
-0.0651881397,
-0.0382279232,
0.0006086994,
0.0211561341,
0.0357742123,
-0.0547731929,
-0.0244251657,
-0.0145157985,
-0.0944477022,
0.0152455242,
0.0441855341,
0.0101370625,
0.0209767427,
0.042257525,
-0.0154829659,
-0.0629046038,
0.0426308922,
0.0251055658,
0.0506913252,
0.0280110314,
-0.0341883935,
0.0075058769,
-0.0086771008,
-0.0046766815,
0.0193579905,
-0.0348020531,
-0.0273540337,
0.0250716954,
0.0230051968,
-0.0178964753,
-0.0401635841,
-0.1268096268,
0.0144872637,
0.0140752951,
0.0244272631,
0.0303201638,
0.0336556956,
-0.038483154,
-0.0362884179,
-0.0433762558,
-0.0774145871,
-0.0030934429,
0.0264727175,
0.0422115549,
0.0793362334,
0.0124484496,
-0.0042606876,
0.001827365,
-0.0252191946,
0.0351472087,
0.0197233465,
-0.0894306377,
-0.0101306476,
0.0436931327,
0.0214246921,
-0.005701744,
0.033597216,
0.0068457881,
0.0110911792,
-0.0345759653,
0.0142878974,
0.0416051671,
0.0062878132,
0.0323242098,
0.0055221175,
0.0065926127,
-0.0178478155,
0.0106117139,
-0.0380687565,
-0.0174700767,
0.0390034281,
-0.0012666426,
0.0404100604,
0.0695300028,
0.0194560103,
-0.0158350952,
-0.0449867472,
-0.0338598229,
-0.0012592942,
0.0334673114,
-0.0818465576,
0.0168737005,
-0.0662753657,
0.0400157049,
0.0133836232,
-0.028996978,
0.0607804917,
-0.015697645,
0.0418380164,
-0.0592117868,
-0.0055645048,
-0.0481521226,
-0.0243030731,
0.0038974225,
-0.0034157247,
0.0282880906,
-0.0090503357,
-0.0093923593,
0.006624524,
0.0316842981,
-0.0419944562,
0.012958739,
0.0167654697,
-0.0136833265,
-0.0155665297,
-0.0332751386,
-0.0452006385,
-0.0846062899,
-0.0035048318,
-0.0034816656,
-0.0229823068,
0.0422776826,
-0.0114937089,
0.0358267166,
-0.0307646878,
0.1065361053,
0.0059311287,
0.0043439493,
-0.0215517338,
0.0421590768,
0.0107486024,
-0.0322775133,
-0.0193170328,
0.0048504476,
0.0276182238,
0.0502032824,
0.0371558107,
0.0492784083,
0.0259975679,
0.0001915724,
0.0059515415,
-0.1005260572,
-0.0435616113,
0.0452420525,
-0.0066216565,
-0.0603536963,
0.0059859953,
0.1006006971,
0.0611118674,
-0.0936436653,
-0.0095894095,
0.0253157038,
-0.0146206841,
0.0066192434,
0.0464630798,
-0.0316835903,
-0.0280724335,
0.0198931769,
0.046858374,
-0.0442046635,
-0.0193815492,
-0.0136606665,
-0.0273936167,
0.0037463889,
-0.014135709,
-0.0053467276,
-0.0023589309,
-0.0851726755,
-0.0052383207,
0.0019665267,
-0.0325424746,
-0.0032913305,
-0.057514701,
-0.0018039416,
0.0385453738,
-0.0780479461,
-0.0874867141,
-0.0262780078,
-0.016797984,
0.0189866424,
0.0475300029,
0.0034893861,
-0.038935408,
0.0030625332,
0.0338058285,
-0.0154828262,
-0.0059313388,
-0.0108191008,
0.0203149505,
-0.0199071448,
-0.0043353704,
0.0182910934,
-0.001337843,
-0.0413947292,
-0.012387298,
0.0066149263,
0.0710482672,
-0.0105474787,
0.0046551619,
-0.0247123372,
-0.0007110452,
0.0281815249,
0.0140277846,
0.0153614581,
-0.0040477552,
0.0100325784,
0.0434407555,
0.0285069346,
0.0280438941,
-0.0146002164,
-0.0013212832,
-0.0670917705,
-0.0212005749,
-0.0735689998,
-0.0249358676,
0.0338273086,
0.0689025223,
0.0197648667,
0.0312041473,
-0.0800201967,
-0.0032126505,
-0.0431529023,
0.0453346446,
0.0328328758,
-0.002732923,
-0.0972866863,
-0.0364616215,
0.0607965998,
-0.0252909381,
-0.0324879251,
-0.0380003378,
-0.0060190586,
0.0026669959,
0.031904649,
0.0460140482,
0.0057290699,
0.0196833387,
0.0048181247,
-0.0088230474,
0.0977689177,
0.0616464503,
-0.0333896317,
-0.0526351519,
0.0144944368,
-0.0421635136,
-0.0271588936,
-0.0207192432,
-0.0167475529,
0.0204014853,
0.0259744171,
-0.0043100351,
0.0210254695,
-0.0326496065,
0.014151453,
0.0569826141,
0.1097346023,
-0.0207955297,
-0.045696415,
-0.027352551,
0.0559892282,
0.0205497779,
0.0198184978,
-0.0017354223,
0.0230818447,
-0.0003063676,
-0.004144731,
-0.0433513075,
0.0341997556,
-0.0634227619,
-0.0047209742,
-0.0561435036,
0.0102387248,
0.0079654558,
-0.0018247215,
0.02827047,
0.0065094712,
-0.0282141119,
0.0532576554,
0.0132217752,
0.0172620397,
-0.0333993025,
0.0508338958,
0.0175996963,
0.0456750244,
-0.0001942705,
0.0899697915,
-0.0571717061,
0.0058550006,
-0.0490330458,
0.002788105,
0.0172599256,
-0.0510126539,
-0.0317038,
-0.0223923214,
-0.0070163202,
-0.0078706723,
0.0378446281,
0.0078959344,
0.002414508,
0.0329726823,
0.0254754201,
0.0103742303,
0.0068351706,
0.0638175607,
0.0030178248,
0.0262642838,
0.0383185223,
-0.0375412777,
-0.0350236446,
0.0436946228,
0.059167318,
0.0168324336,
-0.0410047881,
-0.0101023186,
-0.0500265956,
-0.011513154,
0.0526284911,
-0.0166626126,
-0.0312676281,
0.0025935138,
0.0446006358,
0.029306652,
0.015755251,
0.0167428888,
-0.0245810449,
0.020897489,
0.0074405144,
0.0075603211,
0.0704143345,
-5.531442951e-33,
-0.0033040463,
-0.0070116599,
-0.0109926658,
0.0170637202,
0.004574514,
0.0373291634,
0.018260451,
-0.0017001266,
0.018034542,
0.0061015347,
-0.0746183321,
-0.0328880884,
0.0350353494,
0.0167915132,
-0.0080627939,
-0.0207120683,
-0.002210723,
0.0296538826,
-0.0495966077,
0.012318234,
-0.0278206486,
0.0567988716,
0.0463496298,
-0.0179749373,
0.0244204924,
-0.0001543924,
0.0294355918,
-0.010611481,
0.0068379352,
0.0366026424,
-0.0416108407,
0.011102573,
0.0375436693,
-0.0366009846,
-0.0067302636,
0.0096387407,
-0.0657367259,
-0.0444567464,
0.0061847987,
0.0072886697,
-0.0281291064,
-0.0419049226,
-0.0003753585,
-0.0237957947,
0.0240190923,
0.0185815562,
0.0182919689,
-0.0052281371,
-0.0658538789,
-0.0550822504,
-0.0204077996,
0.0571267866,
0.0318367593,
-0.0288584922,
0.0221381839,
-0.0190067682,
-0.0218761377,
0.0062097153,
0.0078113605,
-0.0409901738,
0.0425076149,
0.059432257,
-0.055793941,
0.002498772,
-0.0413513817,
0.0220639128,
0.0189568624,
-0.011708336,
-0.0048002065,
-0.0006009667,
-0.0570466444,
-0.0065083522,
0.0275035594,
-0.0013666224,
0.0569837354,
-0.0059458008,
-0.0618747845,
0.0379000567,
-0.0238644071,
0.0147365518,
0.0194913503,
-0.0431621931,
-0.0380737036,
-0.022282159,
-0.0237990301,
-0.0382830948,
-0.0224522911,
-0.00034497,
0.0176727753,
0.0335268229,
-0.035951063,
0.0527676642,
0.0109559223,
0.0276214611,
0.0476888716,
-0.0176771246,
0.0434460156,
0.0292001963,
-0.0528225116,
-0.0228095353,
-0.0470768735,
-0.039455846,
0.0309331715,
-0.03147934,
0.04992304,
-0.0023839741,
0.0424211584,
-0.014497607,
-0.0817260668,
-0.0272119436,
0.049712237,
0.0043922025,
0.0135542313,
0.0424709842,
0.055606246,
0.0195716042,
0.0147219058,
0.0882871449,
0.0238953531,
-0.0141194994,
-0.0115973838,
-0.0044085975,
-0.0155362999,
0.0115997419,
-0.0224818829,
0.0055847801,
-0.0014646451,
0.0667384639,
0.0111851739,
-0.0137344962,
-0.0064202058,
-0.0022142257,
2.469e-7,
0.0878424272,
0.0534388162,
0.031620089,
-0.055618763,
0.0116511751,
0.0149186179,
0.0193978269,
0.0308153052,
-0.0122503117,
-0.0015216572,
0.0731234178,
-0.0264537875,
-0.0013482558,
-0.0040834625,
-0.101328589,
-0.0125482632,
-0.0909460634,
0.0445743427,
-0.0301737525,
-0.0343281478,
0.0683562979,
0.0524287894,
-0.055015929,
-0.0241596717,
-0.0153395059,
0.0054626162,
0.0250729434,
-0.0292806532,
0.0013619626,
0.0325615518,
0.0303137172,
-0.0110205067,
0.0057959487,
0.0427794643,
-0.0251463894,
0.0083718011,
0.0153887719,
0.0757696852,
-0.0352587216,
0.0168711226,
0.0182540584,
0.0238558371,
0.0202129595,
-0.0368541814,
0.0726546869,
-0.0709992424,
-0.0140409516,
-0.0593827702,
-0.0444830954,
-0.0203169603,
0.0449748337,
-0.0112331612,
-0.0134312101,
0.0558927879,
0.0169633906,
0.0097042099,
-0.0563479736,
-0.1046840847,
-0.0183502678,
0.0298782364,
0.0136688491,
0.016669929,
0.0315269046,
-0.0455492698,
0.0044630524,
-0.0637313724,
-0.0079441061,
2.347626834e-34,
0.0227572601,
-0.0072950125,
0.0202248078,
0.0288596489,
-0.0080079669,
-0.0277581178,
0.0164316539,
0.0101426812,
0.0316854306,
-0.0634280965,
-0.0016463794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20081v1 | Integrating Summarization and Retrieval for Enhanced Personalization via Large Language Models | 2023-10-30T23:40:41 | 2023-10-30T23:40:41 | Chris Richardson, Yao Zhang, Kellen Gillespie, Sudipta Kar, Arshdeep Singh, Zeynab Raeesy, Omar Zia Khan, Abhinav Sethy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, I.2.7; H.3.3 | Personalization, the ability to tailor a system to individual users, is an
essential factor in user experience with natural language processing (NLP)
systems. With the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs), a key question is
how to leverage these models to better personalize user experiences. To
personalize a language model's output, a straightforward approach is to
incorporate past user data into the language model prompt, but this approach
can result in lengthy inputs exceeding limitations on input length and
incurring latency and cost issues. Existing approaches tackle such challenges
by selectively extracting relevant user data (i.e. selective retrieval) to
construct a prompt for downstream tasks. However, retrieval-based methods are
limited by potential information loss, lack of more profound user
understanding, and cold-start challenges. To overcome these limitations, we
propose a novel summary-augmented approach by extending retrieval-augmented
personalization with task-aware user summaries generated by LLMs. The summaries
can be generated and stored offline, enabling real-world systems with runtime
constraints like voice assistants to leverage the power of LLMs. Experiments
show our method with 75% less of retrieved user data is on-par or outperforms
retrieval augmentation on most tasks in the LaMP personalization benchmark. We
demonstrate that offline summarization via LLMs and runtime retrieval enables
better performance for personalization on a range of tasks under practical
constraints. | [
0.0813372508,
0.0261541009,
-0.0162131675,
0.0253355261,
-0.0168932322,
-0.0130729098,
-0.0024926146,
-0.0159647092,
0.0192302074,
-0.0345859006,
-0.0135263037,
-0.0320549682,
-0.0101326667,
0.0160531588,
-0.0131995538,
-0.1047688648,
0.0292621888,
-0.0323509686,
0.0028618069,
-0.0098987082,
0.0259040017,
0.0245093144,
0.0230489857,
0.0610097647,
0.0151244905,
-0.0124880103,
0.0011681764,
0.0067422562,
-0.016986547,
-0.0084714619,
-0.0066181473,
0.0101765804,
0.0289440081,
-0.0095606027,
0.0000019133,
-0.0553334616,
-0.0251663104,
-0.0098513458,
-0.0422698446,
-0.0190128442,
0.0833893418,
0.0628120899,
0.0031615049,
0.0170362275,
-0.0016303483,
0.0195315052,
0.0221473891,
0.0181019213,
0.0578362867,
0.0493173599,
0.002787756,
-0.0006464928,
0.0098461239,
-0.0126067335,
0.0391259007,
-0.0368743017,
-0.019004615,
-0.0434251949,
0.028932292,
-0.0011197386,
0.0407593958,
0.051344797,
-0.0038690232,
0.0077056009,
0.0255533885,
0.0091841277,
-0.0249118563,
-0.0108798379,
-0.0174200982,
0.0542158745,
0.0109516457,
0.0136413444,
0.0134896776,
0.0030087272,
0.0269269403,
-0.0110278334,
-0.0600412674,
0.023161171,
-0.0277917702,
-0.0025308188,
-0.0331058949,
0.0436118543,
0.0083995983,
0.0269099399,
-0.0359984189,
0.0670408159,
0.0154437535,
-0.0265550092,
-0.0243711974,
-0.0090625565,
-0.0128043219,
-0.0426938906,
0.0192119516,
0.0447765291,
-0.0403279625,
0.0131462608,
-0.0236568935,
-0.0261393823,
0.0169169474,
-0.0070151119,
0.0684738234,
0.0334731862,
-0.0241303928,
0.0519878231,
0.0081247017,
0.0424218588,
0.0159979928,
-0.0363777317,
-0.0662745088,
-0.0553766452,
-0.0297839791,
-0.0178743564,
-0.0404833667,
0.05702696,
-0.0685501993,
-0.0003014795,
-0.0337933674,
0.0687632412,
0.0118086673,
0.015001568,
0.0079005016,
0.0316215307,
-0.0470788553,
-0.0012427202,
-0.0357814133,
0.0010026649,
-0.0409529246,
-0.0146723175,
0.0409262888,
-0.0619482212,
0.0163433217,
-0.0053962832,
0.0414034799,
-0.0062426575,
-0.0051017222,
0.0371926464,
-0.0089827199,
-0.0691634789,
-0.0266389959,
-0.0481582507,
-0.0087853894,
-0.0545268208,
-0.032066714,
-0.0608170219,
0.0347507335,
0.0020001698,
-0.0090356199,
-0.0146363312,
-0.000522648,
0.0421469212,
-0.0135782985,
0.0501366369,
-0.0123192854,
0.0170777384,
0.0464089476,
-0.010854125,
-0.0049485452,
0.0326591842,
0.0143705299,
0.0833434239,
0.0696159154,
0.0155831976,
-0.0026149603,
0.0292931851,
-0.0298620407,
0.0012788442,
-0.0202641953,
0.0038025829,
-0.0359588787,
-0.0180595797,
-0.0024016118,
0.0484868065,
-0.0154983653,
0.0516038164,
0.0693353638,
0.0931947678,
0.0193637628,
0.0244563092,
0.0310286507,
0.055966612,
0.0011783227,
-0.0165241528,
-0.032500118,
0.024528088,
-0.0578934215,
0.0362890176,
0.0708946586,
0.0373596139,
-0.0251667537,
-0.0381722301,
0.0141247474,
-0.027248187,
0.0327170268,
0.0551875122,
0.0266010761,
-0.0077559105,
-0.0089206677,
0.0491691232,
0.0200557318,
-0.0919225067,
0.0267080385,
-0.0391613767,
0.0177065264,
0.1318708956,
0.0339220092,
-0.0236250479,
0.0090248054,
0.0057663871,
-0.0238122568,
0.0280124862,
0.0293784644,
-0.0073424052,
-0.0003770852,
-0.0384010822,
-0.0368640423,
0.0280561913,
-0.0100700408,
0.0197780915,
0.0346883945,
-0.0129870428,
0.0528407693,
-0.0170541573,
-0.0236507822,
-0.0168660786,
-0.0269894097,
-0.0380124822,
0.021806471,
0.0093196519,
0.0170133058,
0.0475215688,
0.0237248316,
0.0027246443,
0.0337689333,
-0.0296023674,
-0.0078723095,
-0.00594158,
-0.0416049771,
0.0064191725,
0.0272099823,
0.0272095837,
0.0440424383,
0.0424646437,
0.0046204715,
-0.0586902015,
-0.001313061,
-0.0499838889,
0.0434233174,
-0.046497874,
0.0149407126,
0.0103580868,
0.0025601159,
-0.0428123288,
0.0508369394,
-0.0057196352,
-0.007438262,
0.0295343939,
-0.0072543388,
-0.0287284292,
-0.0610882416,
-0.051589746,
0.0082478672,
0.0255491883,
0.0319278017,
0.0716333166,
-0.0072714398,
-0.0437332578,
-0.0210134778,
-0.1351614147,
-0.0003521479,
-0.0110158036,
-0.0000608825,
0.009181723,
0.0746320784,
-0.0052430537,
-0.0371573493,
-0.0451385081,
-0.0208164062,
0.0294533167,
0.0420164615,
0.0183394738,
0.0357116424,
-0.0054957643,
-0.0557361767,
-0.0109266965,
0.019307157,
0.0075772833,
-0.0303123165,
-0.0278223641,
-0.0559065379,
-0.0287346803,
-0.0615663715,
0.0298920013,
0.0013879187,
0.0187933911,
0.0008824704,
-0.0527223498,
0.0710829943,
0.0384249166,
0.0334996954,
0.0169078019,
0.0429309458,
-0.0071825017,
-0.065522179,
0.0217019506,
-0.0392579623,
-0.017548494,
0.0203021523,
-0.0204634629,
0.0360310823,
0.0288605373,
-0.0014909026,
0.0157734919,
-0.039901901,
0.0043233284,
-0.0020294087,
0.0051624011,
-0.0535946824,
-0.0043738605,
-0.0629629865,
0.0406186618,
-0.0017270894,
-0.0493237488,
0.061190445,
-0.0295781512,
-0.0044796332,
-0.0517261103,
-0.0527292527,
-0.0258537754,
0.0860184431,
-0.013129455,
0.0428307094,
-0.0246554092,
-0.025584342,
-0.0237641856,
-0.0188988354,
0.0095979394,
-0.083335638,
0.049093876,
-0.0392318703,
-0.008600248,
0.0011088899,
-0.0415622965,
-0.0487558581,
-0.0571993738,
-0.0393806882,
-0.0146464566,
0.0254219137,
-0.0081435181,
-0.0463702045,
-0.0006750227,
0.0561882406,
0.0543171205,
-0.0254763104,
-0.0070595965,
-0.0184298921,
0.0002552857,
0.0574802719,
0.0267019346,
-0.0186806526,
-0.0029075544,
-0.0029948766,
0.0279282723,
0.0629444271,
-0.0525521003,
0.0279469974,
-0.0195436869,
0.0726875812,
-0.0490099564,
-0.0284069553,
0.0647258908,
0.0392439738,
-0.0486768149,
-0.0040918696,
0.0937021673,
0.0166557301,
-0.0736961812,
-0.0239304658,
0.0019034112,
0.003847403,
0.0336176194,
0.0559944697,
-0.0395486802,
-0.0363761857,
0.0295042805,
0.058289364,
-0.0005994955,
-0.0111940587,
-0.0532316007,
-0.1210114881,
-0.0023159366,
0.0003586207,
-0.031249322,
0.018706575,
-0.0197229143,
-0.0066648698,
0.0202484503,
0.0234503504,
0.0123355575,
-0.0294199437,
-0.0106169721,
0.0022516914,
-0.0305774938,
-0.0076812301,
-0.0046409816,
-0.0135381706,
0.0295688678,
0.0660996437,
0.03393884,
0.0289380383,
-0.0329214633,
0.0205871016,
0.0154956626,
0.0287546962,
-0.0036636658,
0.0484684817,
-0.0148734208,
0.0188447535,
-0.0330565684,
0.0071694222,
0.0081919869,
0.0039512818,
0.0140368706,
0.0277694333,
-0.0053616296,
0.0589575171,
-0.0326640345,
-0.003236162,
0.00378564,
0.0685792044,
0.0142428642,
-0.0755196065,
-0.0032933503,
-0.048486121,
-0.0233123507,
-0.019747328,
-0.0220598597,
-0.0125219366,
-0.0437073968,
0.0076635918,
-0.0665119737,
-0.0537021607,
-0.0053212917,
0.0043522762,
0.0093849087,
0.0277273431,
0.0053914338,
0.0220633168,
-0.0480259284,
0.0327992886,
-0.0634347424,
0.0117651131,
-0.0715764761,
-0.0116605991,
0.0478596948,
-0.0896203518,
0.0059885369,
0.0105610043,
-0.0559544563,
-0.0524058156,
0.0029401707,
0.0451592058,
0.0197138004,
0.0737632588,
-0.0078610219,
-0.0918540359,
0.0444708467,
0.020683514,
-0.0386435874,
-0.0009060394,
0.0004674104,
0.0632396564,
-0.0146237109,
0.030822726,
-0.1046541259,
0.0061100996,
-0.032697551,
0.0223600119,
-0.0054829619,
-0.0883740485,
0.00318913,
0.0639567077,
0.0441659801,
-0.0077659753,
-0.0035739539,
0.0033672075,
0.0171843003,
-0.0118757244,
-0.0429626405,
-0.0310841557,
-0.0039235284,
-0.0233160704,
-0.0071519036,
0.0183963049,
0.0152859837,
-0.0143911839,
0.0338293016,
-0.0567460358,
-0.0343048461,
-0.0478828587,
-0.0312207453,
0.0222508833,
0.0333896466,
-0.053923402,
0.0266619548,
0.0030041996,
0.0300340205,
-0.0280773416,
0.0197747461,
-0.0132278306,
-0.0171569809,
-0.0597791001,
0.066885896,
-0.0601688735,
-0.0446109138,
-0.0000057691,
0.0143377371,
0.0160416197,
-0.0185084417,
0.0466193669,
-0.0072640297,
0.0023219057,
-0.0551970936,
-0.0042201048,
0.0263265278,
-0.0355451256,
-0.0405749939,
0.0190741904,
-0.0203740075,
-0.0072552757,
0.0520112365,
-0.033974871,
-0.0042241467,
-0.019731326,
-0.0217249952,
-0.053678792,
-0.0076847756,
-0.0105330925,
0.061256662,
-0.0272495933,
-0.0535024814,
-0.0398888811,
-0.0316014476,
0.0568632297,
-0.0212375578,
-0.018581016,
-0.0333816595,
0.0708425194,
0.0421774127,
-0.0100308536,
-0.0224884246,
-0.050501246,
0.0049974131,
-0.0134890461,
0.0060784058,
0.014101401,
-6.029371338e-33,
-0.0291946642,
-0.0046301824,
0.0031316988,
0.0115966629,
-0.001923278,
0.0024571163,
-0.024784103,
0.0255116373,
0.0244565345,
-0.0482745245,
-0.0548750237,
-0.026600711,
0.0272689201,
0.0551858507,
-0.0114164334,
0.0211710278,
0.078653492,
0.0169781484,
-0.0268102232,
0.0460714214,
0.0839536116,
0.0411582552,
0.0173028763,
-0.060260348,
0.0409368016,
-0.0314039849,
0.0147941737,
0.0163271092,
0.0530380532,
0.047494188,
-0.0146142039,
0.0699154288,
-0.0046524075,
-0.0383615233,
-0.0303271767,
0.0322653949,
-0.0560889207,
-0.0198437627,
0.0457736403,
-0.0189312566,
-0.0201794859,
-0.0488003828,
0.0204941891,
-0.0163604934,
-0.0143813537,
0.0371557549,
0.041594591,
-0.032178618,
-0.0430774055,
-0.0386758,
-0.0111254388,
0.0018751508,
0.0210947506,
-0.0104883481,
0.0352185555,
0.025056392,
0.0141129475,
0.037827529,
-0.0315411538,
0.0510772765,
-0.0014939411,
0.0028060125,
0.0487269945,
0.0428289063,
-0.0009952043,
0.0532697327,
0.0198749006,
0.0087672062,
-0.0226057079,
-0.0034934699,
-0.0025427216,
0.0136257736,
0.0079943826,
0.0423322394,
0.0296921209,
0.0126597509,
0.0255516283,
0.05007964,
0.0249658078,
-0.0075687431,
0.0533311106,
0.022536194,
-0.0425968692,
-0.0043488652,
-0.025072705,
0.0138965333,
-0.0434268229,
-0.0325795747,
0.0341528021,
0.0439266562,
-0.0472308174,
-0.0462866202,
0.0219372232,
-0.008173855,
0.007508303,
-0.0008504594,
-0.0032778715,
-0.0052205808,
-0.0066732061,
-0.0152206458,
-0.0233252291,
0.017724216,
0.0123164384,
-0.0362623222,
-0.0353531353,
0.0328824297,
-0.0043580183,
0.0329273678,
-0.0474890582,
0.01911279,
-0.0049653957,
0.030172592,
-0.0225213692,
0.0338651314,
0.0674550831,
-0.0024388279,
-0.0408314727,
0.0834643096,
0.0094834631,
-0.0034166174,
-0.0254318025,
-0.0707545131,
0.022912249,
-0.0167574361,
-0.0229679476,
0.0184443649,
-0.0298575796,
0.0305378959,
0.0422827303,
-0.0050191679,
0.0032332509,
0.0024843989,
2.718e-7,
-0.0178362578,
0.0171066914,
0.0140153347,
0.000896024,
-0.014622693,
0.0259101894,
0.0316174999,
0.0243625306,
0.0290704612,
0.0166277774,
-0.012595553,
0.029206479,
0.0527475663,
0.021055663,
-0.1221954003,
-0.02004922,
-0.0487673096,
0.0290721953,
-0.0442903377,
0.0195268989,
0.037548285,
0.077426523,
0.0339286067,
-0.0031776852,
0.0054853256,
-0.0496108383,
0.0258702412,
-0.0535940789,
-0.0420003757,
-0.0160294045,
0.0675296485,
0.0393915921,
-0.0052526593,
-0.0320607834,
-0.0063052494,
0.0091590853,
0.027920654,
0.0478690602,
0.0050991662,
-0.0349968486,
-0.007180552,
0.0135437101,
0.0042635393,
0.0008375079,
0.0571833439,
-0.0043278616,
0.0189661738,
-0.0127316006,
-0.0054237815,
-0.0289667677,
-0.0247395206,
-0.0240281019,
-0.0243397299,
0.0117497481,
-0.0051820674,
-0.0071325921,
-0.0038404178,
-0.0959928185,
-0.0284797139,
0.0095021082,
-0.0262664314,
-0.0634105131,
-0.0766880065,
0.0044217217,
-0.0082237059,
-0.086659193,
0.0114299124,
2.417348342e-34,
0.0209113583,
0.0422842614,
0.0126402332,
0.0024732177,
0.024249468,
0.0082539897,
-0.0166797526,
0.0107681453,
0.0522698238,
-0.0922295451,
-0.0444353223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20077v1 | Partial Tensorized Transformers for Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-30T23:19:06 | 2023-10-30T23:19:06 | Subhadra Vadlamannati, Ryan Solgi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The transformer architecture has revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) and other machine-learning tasks, due to its unprecedented accuracy.
However, their extensive memory and parameter requirements often hinder their
practical applications. In this work, we study the effect of tensor-train
decomposition to improve the accuracy and compress transformer vision-language
neural networks, namely BERT and ViT. We focus both on embedding-layer
compression and partial tensorization of neural networks (PTNN) through an
algorithmic approach. Our novel PTNN approach significantly improves the
accuracy of existing models by up to 5%, all without the need for post-training
adjustments, breaking new ground in the field of tensor decomposition. | [
-0.0000299445,
0.056749586,
-0.0185763426,
0.0588260666,
-0.0031788743,
0.0163273681,
-0.0058241822,
0.042713955,
0.0072623393,
-0.00426132,
-0.0311562121,
-0.0242459849,
0.0017162089,
-0.0240755063,
0.0159778744,
-0.0466851145,
0.0021200443,
0.0134169897,
-0.008529908,
0.0090948995,
0.0024027287,
0.0073197023,
0.0101162484,
0.0257418118,
-0.0155077567,
0.0165100973,
-0.012237248,
-0.0072432104,
-0.0093170535,
0.0465508401,
-0.0136133367,
0.0052519711,
0.0371990539,
0.0363435373,
0.0000019419,
0.0482073724,
0.0110623091,
0.0201688018,
0.0031800985,
0.0350186191,
0.0164990518,
-0.0356791988,
0.0109389834,
0.0212290641,
-0.019377239,
-0.0641632229,
0.050784342,
0.0724556297,
0.0869265571,
0.0410373956,
-0.0115235867,
-0.0065066488,
0.0394658409,
0.0013821153,
-0.026163863,
-0.0094916979,
-0.0229204111,
-0.0479662232,
-0.0626328588,
-0.0273453929,
-0.0272811577,
0.0209834743,
0.0287637655,
0.0353147648,
-0.0066281455,
0.0401292257,
-0.0805368125,
-0.0413888022,
-0.0057348213,
0.0500237495,
-0.0291012879,
-0.018103607,
-0.0116772763,
0.0105723869,
-0.0136378994,
0.0077197398,
-0.0280117374,
0.0137291625,
0.039899487,
0.0258639045,
-0.0536691137,
-0.0149509506,
0.0172293875,
-0.0169841647,
-0.0281113032,
-0.033120431,
0.0486173779,
-0.0202592742,
-0.0401037186,
0.001959431,
-0.0291260649,
-0.000844422,
0.0101820603,
0.0076722759,
0.0081718694,
-0.0374224484,
-0.0577686951,
-0.104216218,
-0.0249214489,
-0.0696141496,
0.0593857467,
0.0515362918,
-0.0348844156,
0.0335611738,
-0.0623688772,
0.070331566,
-0.0375934094,
0.0041991607,
-0.036021214,
-0.0546383522,
-0.0177467521,
-0.012626553,
-0.0783600435,
0.0179863703,
-0.0238999072,
-0.0352045409,
-0.0524309203,
0.015551975,
-0.0191631876,
-0.017580729,
0.0457460843,
0.0545962304,
-0.00728558,
-0.0095881661,
0.0050359033,
0.0442172475,
0.0319294967,
-0.0090823071,
-0.0777372494,
-0.0011607334,
-0.0129854502,
0.028785944,
0.0266922731,
-0.0110612558,
0.0285673365,
0.0524030663,
-0.0221254844,
-0.0956146419,
0.0081783552,
0.0433842503,
0.0189846009,
-0.0368243791,
0.0462059863,
-0.0178713426,
0.0672664642,
-0.0321209468,
0.0039916625,
0.004110164,
-0.0019188508,
0.0228084456,
-0.0569758937,
0.0619570985,
0.0099095898,
-0.0115643675,
0.0162177123,
0.0131458417,
0.0443495549,
0.0251626484,
0.0532557331,
0.0142173311,
-0.0019565211,
-0.0521727912,
0.0002287305,
0.0313500836,
0.0319911167,
-0.0350748114,
-0.039840132,
-0.0467447564,
-0.0214048885,
0.0080614146,
0.0102638891,
0.0963226482,
-0.0726938173,
-0.0131281046,
0.0482858717,
0.04534759,
0.0236945245,
0.0711141378,
0.0307951029,
0.0095031206,
0.0122454856,
-0.0026066231,
-0.0468059778,
0.0227576587,
0.0014968488,
-0.0241918582,
-0.0119782249,
0.024239365,
-0.0496154241,
-0.0135684758,
0.0035233637,
-0.0373294801,
0.0579173155,
-0.0106125791,
0.051569812,
0.0111207943,
-0.043547973,
0.1315796375,
-0.0111577343,
-0.0640705749,
0.0068332106,
-0.0325511023,
-0.0387575738,
0.0011786089,
0.0492792316,
-0.0014305401,
0.0022166066,
0.0112457201,
-0.0184479989,
-0.0145239253,
0.0321696624,
0.0075774789,
0.0422865972,
-0.073482044,
-0.0080409246,
0.0073364731,
0.0114929779,
-0.0351861864,
-0.0104515459,
-0.0098814219,
0.0180845503,
-0.0382973589,
0.0295138266,
0.0378484651,
-0.0199591611,
-0.0357687548,
0.0397621915,
0.0304167755,
-0.0142957233,
-0.0026082089,
-0.0203182194,
-0.0134712029,
0.0520038605,
-0.076570034,
-0.0111153033,
0.0019396293,
-0.0156819317,
-0.0036937161,
0.0402913094,
-0.0491810478,
0.0099018617,
0.0718959346,
-0.047777731,
-0.034727551,
0.0544249378,
-0.0671650767,
0.0605929233,
-0.0421769768,
-0.0080388552,
-0.0124028632,
0.030164618,
0.0078516202,
0.0165075362,
-0.0484676249,
0.0133466423,
0.0290500205,
-0.0664996058,
0.0163458362,
-0.0005556199,
-0.0425351113,
0.0096645439,
0.0141526116,
0.0057803672,
0.0296199787,
-0.0039724689,
0.0371214673,
-0.0436384827,
-0.1449929476,
-0.0234695543,
-0.0234799646,
-0.0100758979,
0.0123458486,
0.0231434181,
0.0390107781,
-0.0079866992,
-0.0023779781,
0.0020416724,
0.0044189682,
-0.0167541206,
0.0310592763,
-0.0402722955,
-0.0164269749,
-0.0014067341,
-0.0677173585,
0.0136399316,
0.0751625448,
-0.0382172801,
0.0007424028,
-0.0332126133,
-0.0454162359,
-0.002691715,
0.0685253814,
-0.0034072152,
-0.0578555688,
-0.0055400007,
-0.005191803,
0.0398722254,
0.0317567177,
0.0303331073,
0.0404856168,
0.0557602644,
0.03316826,
-0.0183354542,
0.020752497,
-0.0385090522,
-0.0202303268,
-0.0100206109,
-0.0168574881,
-0.0431484655,
0.0598702691,
-0.0134594338,
0.0118505331,
-0.0763869137,
-0.0544471703,
-0.0052430602,
0.0119368769,
-0.0156164253,
-0.0366952792,
-0.0261315219,
0.0099028545,
0.0082003577,
-0.0240209829,
0.0525526032,
-0.0346636474,
-0.0091939596,
-0.012748328,
-0.0262557063,
-0.0325405262,
0.0226017665,
0.0534694865,
0.0416440777,
-0.0385778286,
0.0160440989,
-0.0621565804,
0.0055338503,
0.0144527014,
-0.0317796096,
0.0223467276,
0.0268845409,
-0.0151984645,
-0.0402313024,
-0.023676632,
-0.0273297783,
-0.0248585735,
0.0071694856,
0.0372554064,
-0.0010005762,
-0.0403947979,
-0.0149254566,
-0.0102978842,
0.0007862658,
0.0474975705,
0.0355077423,
-0.0002623665,
-0.0052791759,
0.0742494091,
0.0213808548,
0.0090623237,
0.044197958,
0.0006299067,
-0.0221858285,
0.0733792782,
0.0726688579,
0.0167787466,
-0.1015112102,
-0.0133598978,
0.0415384583,
-0.0171559229,
-0.0167627018,
-0.0134366509,
-0.0167849604,
-0.0415467918,
0.0116774021,
0.0715483502,
0.0173956715,
-0.0323299728,
0.0040286686,
0.0693019405,
-0.0208780076,
0.024495624,
0.0306358766,
-0.0560336486,
-0.0074473373,
-0.0026417384,
0.0101914844,
0.0301851202,
-0.018097572,
-0.0121769654,
-0.0522121452,
0.0442380086,
-0.0095384493,
0.0759784132,
-0.0421670228,
-0.0285861827,
-0.017996747,
-0.0129126972,
0.0288233142,
-0.0240456108,
-0.0018434008,
-0.033318907,
0.02121865,
0.0210153833,
-0.0201688726,
-0.0038904147,
-0.0191209204,
-0.0172686148,
-0.009624253,
0.0377707779,
-0.0407016873,
-0.0893749669,
0.0319589004,
0.0250828732,
-0.0073122154,
0.0449278727,
0.0434581712,
-0.0079314979,
-0.0410425477,
-0.0020787839,
0.0223227311,
-0.0257256422,
-0.0247150864,
-0.0755534321,
0.0878871903,
0.0100566009,
-0.0289247315,
-0.0314176865,
-0.0189575609,
-0.0610615239,
0.0442874581,
0.0322621875,
-0.0459131226,
-0.0172103345,
0.0633718446,
0.0373843387,
-0.0083331931,
-0.0333384126,
-0.0237024855,
0.028975971,
-0.0496258847,
-0.0439343713,
0.0333934203,
-0.0005806125,
0.0215944201,
-0.0263355467,
-0.0513721034,
0.035247501,
0.0041322508,
-0.0805931687,
0.0550846681,
0.0137559501,
-0.0096099898,
-0.0229874942,
0.019607218,
0.0201717522,
-0.0250232294,
-0.0199455097,
-0.0115780383,
-0.1043479964,
-0.0332172997,
0.0030523578,
0.0591291524,
0.0063979798,
-0.0014229079,
0.0207898282,
-0.0523958728,
0.066259414,
0.0524412766,
-0.0489057973,
0.0386878103,
0.0108256806,
-0.0745337829,
-0.0138142807,
0.0272178054,
-0.0174323432,
0.0009569498,
0.0005372243,
-0.0020620071,
-0.0022547392,
0.0153263155,
0.0230569001,
0.0102192657,
0.0759097785,
-0.0072004143,
0.0780944303,
-0.0321985446,
0.0263172258,
0.0189861599,
0.0186822787,
-0.0573923364,
0.0144530674,
0.0083803507,
0.0229271129,
-0.0232390426,
0.0105576394,
0.0387130603,
-0.0004736725,
0.0028016367,
0.0122858984,
0.0012717196,
-0.0249825697,
0.0242445413,
0.0217557158,
-0.0228531454,
-0.0110820206,
-0.0350739136,
-0.0006192531,
-0.0331825726,
0.0161536932,
0.0056151361,
0.0209163334,
-0.0652739629,
0.0628216267,
-0.0380765237,
-0.0911691859,
-0.0150530115,
0.0275935438,
0.0237145312,
-0.0025414422,
-0.0135352435,
-0.0431603231,
-0.0170530919,
0.0168032739,
0.0103330417,
0.0090280119,
0.002338337,
0.047648374,
-0.0029023844,
-0.0087611163,
0.0117414529,
0.067507863,
-0.0097241588,
0.0361898765,
-0.0255506225,
-0.0183635149,
-0.0381075591,
-0.0378273576,
0.0080578877,
0.058160644,
-0.0147179887,
0.0147526665,
-0.0205996446,
-0.0640395135,
-0.0222293474,
0.0008207064,
0.0109793749,
-0.0479405783,
0.0491247438,
0.0274634231,
0.0213066209,
0.0160682797,
0.0319839753,
-0.0097722365,
0.0193506218,
-0.0312466566,
-0.0175028965,
-5.777850812e-33,
-0.0000607888,
0.0344903842,
0.0138877872,
-0.0062070824,
-0.0184463058,
0.0509055518,
0.0011597017,
-0.0055514611,
-0.0141605297,
-0.0019705051,
-0.0293470994,
0.0173976123,
-0.0136305103,
0.0385513715,
-0.0075943866,
-0.0053074001,
0.0509091839,
-0.0394007489,
0.0053056558,
0.0274931751,
0.0222120546,
0.0212706216,
0.0754057691,
-0.0527040772,
-0.0545403734,
0.0219915789,
0.0085050222,
0.0089222798,
0.0441051535,
0.0505397096,
-0.0670551583,
0.0029444583,
0.0199947804,
-0.0207319893,
-0.005654152,
0.0133016463,
-0.0733889639,
-0.0021057215,
-0.0029035085,
0.0208176244,
-0.1031484902,
0.021763945,
0.059335541,
0.0061240573,
-0.0142094987,
-0.0234356448,
0.0082865972,
0.0173035413,
-0.0270418096,
-0.049078159,
-0.0129628219,
-0.0137991011,
-0.0232188348,
-0.0167839453,
0.0659794509,
0.0213207901,
-0.0194456317,
0.0380719602,
-0.0709678531,
-0.0335883275,
-0.0287262071,
0.0026462439,
0.0344489925,
-0.01192421,
0.0007813671,
0.0513029844,
0.044946745,
-0.0249702632,
-0.0331638157,
-0.0380249172,
0.0398795642,
0.0399385355,
0.0746269003,
0.0080005396,
0.0316311494,
-0.0356245562,
-0.0366983227,
-0.0324613564,
0.0167706646,
0.0474302359,
0.0300584789,
0.0085997721,
0.0138490237,
-0.0115304198,
-0.0275621209,
-0.0307425112,
-0.0296450127,
0.0099974554,
-0.0123691084,
0.0548144542,
-0.05287591,
-0.027483413,
0.0280590635,
-0.073578544,
0.0617565885,
0.0568059646,
-0.0129212709,
0.0403907262,
0.0352121182,
0.0068526966,
-0.0396027863,
-0.0213184133,
-0.0165707618,
-0.0190790817,
0.0040978109,
0.0078255525,
0.0316141993,
0.0568232872,
-0.0390430726,
0.0097421743,
-0.0276317354,
-0.0144431815,
0.0013614687,
0.0454483889,
0.0393395312,
0.0306166876,
-0.0190543327,
-0.008699649,
-0.0047159456,
0.0481012203,
0.0013502567,
0.0073488262,
0.063226454,
0.0304506831,
0.0156101789,
-0.0165875927,
-0.0330841802,
0.0311285239,
0.0749365836,
-0.0749880448,
-0.0183562748,
0.0204822347,
2.649e-7,
0.0319103375,
0.0402892716,
0.0088605219,
-0.0166995656,
0.0254439544,
0.0544792078,
0.0449442044,
0.0624082014,
0.0080315191,
0.032488618,
0.0370273665,
0.0205036551,
-0.0178729557,
-0.0192066152,
-0.0428937897,
-0.0424915403,
-0.0697596818,
-0.0065797176,
-0.0083414493,
-0.0103135416,
0.0228138752,
0.1153316423,
0.0268420074,
-0.0295842178,
0.0091708498,
-0.0101712625,
0.0674160495,
-0.0434455276,
0.015287159,
-0.015706135,
0.0311788693,
0.0360609218,
-0.0242460687,
-0.00704849,
-0.0291817039,
0.03960298,
0.0357317105,
0.0322253518,
-0.0034412968,
-0.001595795,
0.0122391451,
-0.0044264896,
-0.0519735143,
-0.0309112016,
0.056454245,
-0.04285831,
-0.0226372331,
-0.0571044311,
-0.0344900303,
0.0018397683,
0.0373558104,
-0.0121687995,
0.0173513796,
0.0542307459,
0.0279102568,
-0.0326043107,
-0.0118372487,
-0.0975900143,
0.018052876,
-0.0132209118,
-0.043723736,
-0.0045654937,
-0.0199956987,
-0.0489748605,
0.0916749388,
-0.0120430803,
-0.0462609045,
2.142288634e-34,
0.0259507969,
-0.0004428186,
0.023438504,
0.0220006388,
-0.0094105788,
-0.0518412478,
0.0250248276,
-0.0080515696,
-0.0106213251,
-0.0655852854,
-0.025563566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20072v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20072v1 | Automatic Evaluation of Generative Models with Instruction Tuning | 2023-10-30T23:00:52 | 2023-10-30T23:00:52 | Shuhaib Mehri, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Automatic evaluation of natural language generation has long been an elusive
goal in NLP.A recent paradigm fine-tunes pre-trained language models to emulate
human judgements for a particular task and evaluation criterion. Inspired by
the generalization ability of instruction-tuned models, we propose a learned
metric based on instruction tuning. To test our approach, we collected HEAP, a
dataset of human judgements across various NLG tasks and evaluation criteria.
Our findings demonstrate that instruction tuning language models on HEAP yields
good performance on many evaluation tasks, though some criteria are less
trivial to learn than others. Further, jointly training on multiple tasks can
yield additional performance improvements, which can be beneficial for future
tasks with little to no human annotated data. | [
0.04287678,
0.0912346542,
0.0109550003,
-0.000410021,
-0.0063227117,
0.022870224,
0.029642418,
-0.0156554859,
-0.0306632668,
-0.0476872213,
-0.0527065769,
-0.0336509421,
-0.0309426989,
0.0170030519,
0.0403338186,
-0.0548396222,
0.0090192277,
0.0089456439,
0.0237958673,
0.0258281566,
-0.0006085078,
0.0226793811,
-0.0097305188,
0.0590093099,
-0.0106582101,
-0.0067441165,
0.0126980674,
0.005914161,
0.0126113584,
-0.0134177404,
0.0211492404,
0.0868736356,
0.0004705343,
-0.0230796449,
0.0000018106,
-0.0378762297,
-0.0006965441,
-0.0206366237,
-0.0007492459,
0.0202430636,
0.0626511425,
0.0053196112,
-0.0006338226,
0.0160467401,
-0.0513962545,
-0.0238111857,
0.0348241404,
0.0198249742,
0.0761779547,
0.0631882623,
0.0023022115,
0.0039837658,
-0.0109862499,
-0.0393274613,
0.0111851487,
-0.0462979078,
-0.0095487451,
0.0417373627,
-0.0235320609,
0.0149534773,
0.0088826921,
-0.0073905955,
0.012426679,
-0.0069378321,
0.0393621959,
0.0335937329,
-0.0239723288,
-0.0203250926,
-0.0267840307,
0.0634842664,
-0.0297962315,
-0.0485046022,
0.0075285714,
-0.0296380352,
0.0093381116,
-0.0202727728,
0.0066256155,
0.0429269038,
0.0200263504,
0.0051689488,
0.0193576347,
0.0285925623,
0.0028253056,
0.0306432564,
0.0247425865,
0.0437978506,
0.0265610628,
-0.0136091355,
-0.0023451636,
0.0367139615,
-0.0526637435,
-0.0607368834,
-0.0048321211,
0.0144819543,
-0.0464686565,
0.001758486,
-0.0749840885,
-0.0049212975,
0.0239006151,
-0.0259262398,
0.0884246975,
0.0245897416,
-0.000425613,
0.019077437,
-0.0372489616,
0.0582073443,
0.0448400863,
0.0210840143,
-0.0486114211,
0.0405781232,
-0.0518126488,
0.011044004,
-0.0470753759,
0.0032860867,
-0.0262780208,
-0.024384575,
-0.0601498522,
-0.0007067553,
-0.0105709424,
-0.0263380129,
0.0336122252,
0.0495037436,
-0.0564211383,
-0.0203830674,
-0.0424389318,
-0.0221970752,
-0.0598606281,
0.0211800113,
0.043273937,
-0.0399416834,
-0.0119601898,
0.0337024368,
0.0180175602,
0.0027868652,
0.021543473,
0.0655222163,
-0.0217405055,
-0.0113083897,
-0.0340108834,
-0.04433861,
-0.0209428184,
-0.0657792762,
-0.0236135684,
-0.0587782413,
0.0144254453,
0.0016774497,
-0.0070484546,
-0.0358749591,
-0.0059600067,
0.0128703266,
0.0073109479,
0.0261243992,
0.0059027988,
-0.0088896407,
-0.0014355993,
0.0027601994,
0.0130692692,
0.0465776175,
0.0353305899,
0.0683840588,
0.0128639964,
0.0057097161,
0.030215513,
0.0035053161,
0.0074406681,
-0.0163488612,
0.0033689453,
-0.0138413087,
-0.0401862897,
0.0249873381,
0.0456359535,
0.0564735308,
-0.0173519496,
0.0179927126,
0.0264830831,
0.009792666,
0.044030834,
0.0375332609,
0.1192812994,
0.0312432926,
-0.0273252986,
0.0376069099,
-0.0242777839,
0.0300297495,
-0.0276154038,
0.0176303871,
0.0390813723,
0.0337297581,
-0.0204014368,
-0.0794470981,
0.0060480558,
0.0052248784,
0.0022467135,
-0.033329118,
0.0102818394,
0.057460513,
-0.0552277677,
0.0051508788,
0.0380613394,
-0.0833946392,
0.0348969884,
-0.0485153198,
0.0336007029,
0.0796145797,
0.059470389,
0.0291158967,
-0.0133220674,
0.0111016631,
-0.0287209079,
0.0354517885,
0.0377260037,
-0.0167531092,
-0.0067520547,
-0.0413780883,
-0.0149106635,
-0.0394147448,
0.0545381121,
0.0085683782,
0.0372941755,
-0.0278277323,
0.0575588346,
-0.0480073579,
-0.0779913962,
0.0484199263,
-0.0218486283,
-0.0384620503,
0.007384622,
0.0090860408,
0.0046790256,
-0.0171580687,
-0.0372209921,
0.0328135453,
0.0089196116,
-0.0129089588,
-0.01493687,
0.0136459749,
-0.0428976975,
-0.0357649624,
-0.0085272491,
-0.0648949742,
0.027317835,
-0.0190299805,
-0.0417077355,
-0.0380934887,
0.0227191225,
-0.0412510335,
0.0154817998,
-0.0586503595,
0.01745205,
0.0188994035,
-0.0223896652,
-0.0342298597,
0.063067019,
-0.0003523803,
0.0340996869,
0.0014097855,
0.0274709631,
0.0112460805,
-0.0368357524,
-0.0073967958,
-0.0309487712,
-0.0198984779,
0.0357540809,
0.0422556251,
0.073490642,
-0.0580257736,
-0.0301377662,
-0.1031672657,
0.0198690891,
-0.0353383087,
0.0182817597,
0.0622409657,
-0.0281824004,
-0.0045486223,
0.0127926609,
-0.05715679,
-0.0202146489,
0.0415596403,
-0.0187802855,
0.0480792485,
-0.0216374639,
0.0286258124,
-0.0555207804,
0.0047779363,
-0.0033615471,
0.028309457,
0.051631853,
0.0500104092,
-0.0391911864,
0.0692664161,
-0.0349766575,
-0.0091363322,
0.029674137,
-0.0681630149,
0.0088539748,
0.002214205,
0.0424862318,
0.0638057813,
0.0274277423,
0.042949032,
0.0286621638,
0.0274534728,
-0.0345551744,
-0.0036612714,
-0.0390565507,
-0.0008351943,
0.0214262269,
-0.0201022439,
0.0374460518,
0.0766868293,
0.0186868291,
-0.0086074639,
-0.0762787908,
0.0481896959,
-0.0401561595,
-0.0329026841,
-0.0166641064,
-0.0071984446,
0.0090978425,
0.0206053983,
-0.0419071428,
-0.0725722164,
0.0756006241,
-0.0323003754,
0.0021476063,
-0.0499676205,
0.0018251071,
-0.0215511918,
0.0365223996,
0.0124302562,
0.0404912941,
0.005533475,
-0.0046016267,
-0.0393839106,
0.0408789963,
0.0164194088,
-0.0275279153,
0.0155670149,
-0.0677416623,
-0.007961412,
0.0209593084,
-0.0361437351,
-0.0440696739,
-0.039881777,
0.0201680567,
0.0094815223,
0.0758956373,
-0.020336831,
-0.0138890184,
0.0055444716,
-0.008977741,
0.0133847985,
-0.0026984413,
-0.0237309113,
-0.0188862924,
0.0033398808,
0.0533265769,
-0.003663793,
-0.0159970801,
-0.035701286,
-0.0124940807,
0.0239043534,
0.0317591056,
0.0290497448,
-0.0307599008,
0.0321230777,
0.0103755007,
-0.0218418576,
0.0138568692,
0.0449393354,
0.0663655102,
-0.0276972204,
-0.0465620831,
0.1212050393,
0.0306584183,
-0.0222018845,
0.0082096104,
0.052058287,
0.0379201397,
0.0017356238,
0.0009038775,
-0.0634128451,
-0.0375723951,
-0.0163567793,
0.0319585353,
0.0008198468,
-0.0183805525,
-0.014090199,
-0.1289805472,
0.0306405146,
0.0169052426,
0.0095625827,
0.0055671977,
0.004163214,
-0.0227551293,
-0.0448624082,
-0.025793789,
0.0044420804,
-0.0230947956,
0.0587651879,
0.0445483439,
-0.0041873516,
-0.0778907314,
0.0307855085,
-0.02694414,
0.0420457348,
0.0731495172,
0.017649129,
0.029795466,
-0.0496254601,
-0.003319914,
-0.0174351446,
0.0119742416,
0.0053607291,
0.0413570479,
-0.0154734431,
-0.00821721,
-0.0137506425,
0.0375077911,
-0.0234119203,
0.0189198386,
-0.0121194534,
-0.0018104012,
-0.0002147496,
-0.0293116327,
0.003103626,
0.033865355,
0.0280756596,
0.0797358826,
0.0480391607,
-0.0557031371,
-0.0411188975,
-0.036268346,
0.030106185,
-0.1201402172,
-0.0441744924,
0.0095580248,
-0.0031498212,
-0.0193487145,
-0.107225582,
-0.0399704911,
0.0234729704,
0.0490671992,
0.0191376582,
-0.0593922138,
-0.0141897062,
-0.0065361229,
-0.0068076025,
0.0349386446,
-0.0125402343,
-0.0131867984,
-0.081382215,
-0.0657162741,
0.0326966904,
-0.0286446176,
-0.0394099057,
0.0458924957,
-0.0774563551,
-0.0490780696,
-0.0092659006,
0.0603518263,
0.0206365138,
0.0066837831,
-0.0340511538,
-0.0519427657,
0.0228799414,
0.0229040664,
-0.0543966331,
0.0073464056,
0.0151875066,
-0.0013733222,
-0.010632392,
0.0129406471,
-0.0131456768,
0.0848676637,
0.0204932503,
0.0576261021,
0.0075768484,
-0.0419389494,
0.0352030359,
0.0048322594,
0.0231477544,
-0.0692481548,
0.0030010678,
-0.0443063378,
-0.0408239998,
0.0072040251,
-0.025184771,
-0.0729065314,
0.0128211463,
0.029398419,
0.0160596725,
-0.02797121,
0.0092488928,
-0.0276769772,
0.0448015593,
-0.0492949001,
0.0032787414,
0.0270014163,
0.0033086762,
0.0000873282,
-0.0098021189,
-0.02548391,
0.0021371881,
-0.0318177715,
0.0289004166,
-0.0024432086,
0.0479690135,
0.0172804948,
0.0420831181,
0.0088276481,
0.0447406098,
-0.0282039363,
0.0013349659,
-0.0923347101,
0.0081085246,
0.0618396029,
-0.0177919175,
0.0595783144,
-0.0274416655,
0.0141287157,
-0.0210520886,
0.0679024979,
0.0138392104,
-0.0502506867,
-0.0119000282,
0.0065878439,
-0.0241008438,
-0.0519381277,
0.0828504786,
0.0118732098,
0.0310948379,
-0.019212842,
-0.0133724008,
-0.0478718728,
-0.0355263613,
-0.02962506,
-0.0140107675,
0.010559326,
0.0468416438,
-0.0290113222,
-0.0621584803,
-0.0601609759,
0.0662776679,
0.0620352589,
0.001864665,
0.0703122169,
0.0723212734,
-0.04640726,
0.0108756553,
-0.056683749,
-0.0322967358,
-0.0160469431,
0.0223656408,
-0.0721436366,
-6.226844104e-33,
-0.0419580676,
-0.0340943784,
0.0096040182,
-0.0204673186,
-0.0076495674,
-0.0219763089,
-0.0286241919,
0.0286517162,
0.0221453086,
0.0194818545,
0.0053012911,
-0.0192362983,
0.0042553055,
0.035064958,
0.013383843,
0.0014454067,
0.0544221215,
-0.0104503054,
-0.0733182132,
0.0478213504,
0.0169204455,
0.0036515724,
0.0174385104,
-0.0114193875,
0.0170834251,
0.0130944196,
-0.0483074039,
-0.0079394644,
0.0078354636,
0.0367749818,
-0.0138142435,
0.0108362213,
0.0269346498,
-0.0291501768,
-0.0222728029,
0.0021425993,
-0.0472956263,
-0.0114990287,
0.0222522002,
-0.0318950415,
-0.0486560725,
-0.0192067251,
0.0243213437,
-0.0244403463,
-0.0564636625,
0.0189362727,
0.0369569585,
-0.0177814104,
0.0067449077,
-0.0493756905,
-0.0616866834,
0.0141504565,
-0.0247872658,
-0.0518512838,
0.0016771563,
0.0264976565,
-0.0283120181,
-0.016081607,
-0.014376374,
0.036451295,
0.0258446112,
0.0569472089,
0.0474267937,
0.0118119679,
-0.0292987078,
0.0573168918,
-0.0257393196,
0.0079543199,
-0.0344069302,
0.0158096328,
0.0130808465,
0.0698749721,
0.0270140246,
0.0048199305,
0.0400068462,
-0.0106372759,
-0.036766123,
0.0660198405,
-0.0127308499,
0.0035705327,
0.0348828621,
-0.0205024593,
-0.0218119193,
-0.0080832355,
-0.0377063602,
-0.0261287633,
-0.0300699454,
-0.0365179516,
0.0428625345,
0.0362915993,
-0.0273784436,
-0.0402945839,
-0.0039412803,
-0.007951281,
0.0145458011,
0.0091573512,
-0.0432873182,
-0.01099208,
-0.0206213035,
-0.0020376488,
-0.0520734079,
-0.0242217463,
0.0435506701,
0.0555195659,
0.0074102404,
-0.0077254423,
0.0469293594,
0.0030313304,
-0.0530487783,
0.045375146,
-0.0577676818,
0.0412953086,
-0.0050491323,
-0.0032643513,
0.0149037037,
-0.0065581077,
-0.0465496182,
0.0022214889,
-0.0184931401,
0.0150941061,
-0.0279731676,
-0.0195085034,
0.005901461,
0.0372476466,
-0.0437771268,
0.0249396786,
-0.0152266547,
-0.0333475284,
0.0026894063,
-0.0112020494,
-0.0187633969,
0.0136367511,
2.409e-7,
0.0177657865,
0.0376070552,
0.0201009251,
0.034496408,
-0.0069439043,
0.0232902747,
-0.0114870127,
0.0270388424,
0.0216754153,
-0.0025025446,
0.0026377253,
0.021976389,
0.056491375,
-0.0125950798,
-0.0431234464,
0.0308950748,
-0.0659073368,
0.0340517722,
-0.025336666,
-0.0587112866,
0.0766324326,
0.0471829511,
-0.0083570397,
0.0100714006,
0.0202490408,
-0.0330037475,
0.0630731359,
-0.0115167676,
-0.025477441,
0.0483472608,
0.0871218592,
0.0395034403,
-0.020424746,
0.0090940641,
-0.0345598496,
-0.0073854211,
0.0190813281,
0.0643346235,
0.0348692499,
-0.0157371685,
0.0224864427,
-0.0031962742,
0.0274701156,
-0.0352304466,
0.0607713684,
-0.0513209477,
0.0038109045,
0.0103261136,
-0.0095463265,
0.023103375,
0.0070842393,
-0.0434083566,
-0.0353531204,
0.004331429,
0.0392042324,
0.0086459974,
-0.010004702,
-0.0471310727,
-0.0491246358,
0.0309593938,
-0.0316104069,
-0.0275174771,
-0.0272538532,
-0.0210637022,
-0.0079145171,
-0.0621547401,
-0.0052103288,
1.958584351e-34,
0.0548167713,
0.012055248,
0.0232636631,
-0.0345058516,
0.0698180124,
0.0183709189,
0.002873044,
-0.0187667739,
0.0088095637,
-0.0629136413,
-0.0134569947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09424v1 | Open Domain Knowledge Extraction for Knowledge Graphs | 2023-10-30T22:18:34 | 2023-10-30T22:18:34 | Kun Qian, Anton Belyi, Fei Wu, Samira Khorshidi, Azadeh Nikfarjam, Rahul Khot, Yisi Sang, Katherine Luna, Xianqi Chu, Eric Choi, Yash Govind, Chloe Seivwright, Yiwen Sun, Ahmed Fakhry, Theo Rekatsinas, Ihab Ilyas, Xiaoguang Qi, Yunyao Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T30 (primary), F.4.1; I.2.4 | The quality of a knowledge graph directly impacts the quality of downstream
applications (e.g. the number of answerable questions using the graph). One
ongoing challenge when building a knowledge graph is to ensure completeness and
freshness of the graph's entities and facts. In this paper, we introduce ODKE,
a scalable and extensible framework that sources high-quality entities and
facts from open web at scale. ODKE utilizes a wide range of extraction models
and supports both streaming and batch processing at different latency. We
reflect on the challenges and design decisions made and share lessons learned
when building and deploying ODKE to grow an industry-scale open domain
knowledge graph. | [
0.0265084486,
0.037885882,
-0.0040513016,
0.0648483634,
-0.0292102192,
0.0114425858,
-0.0536954142,
0.0303545073,
0.0975317284,
-0.0110873505,
0.0375914127,
0.0291801114,
-0.0320796221,
0.0750837177,
-0.0386792384,
-0.010885329,
-0.0016980431,
0.0060104784,
0.0302189253,
-0.0028155465,
-0.0089508528,
0.0185888931,
-0.0467440933,
-0.0423612036,
-0.0071049766,
-0.0437550433,
0.0197636653,
-0.0410090163,
0.0129547855,
-0.0216754079,
-0.0389926843,
-0.0046266755,
-0.0356131978,
0.0131845577,
0.0000019869,
-0.0459463894,
-0.0326805264,
0.0282818992,
-0.0805519894,
-0.0362115689,
-0.0096752141,
-0.0104319202,
0.0019442778,
0.0021770475,
-0.0690709949,
-0.0376905464,
0.0115109906,
0.0133236842,
0.0179330241,
0.0172465425,
-0.0161950961,
-0.0217563752,
0.0101990756,
0.0157519691,
-0.0302360784,
-0.0184907485,
0.0452195369,
0.0005589242,
0.0247869641,
-0.0106285615,
-0.0127785373,
0.0153480656,
-0.0169373211,
-0.0028103208,
0.041257102,
0.0365473442,
0.0067356895,
0.0074189929,
-0.0276152249,
0.1092317179,
0.0677823946,
0.0521703698,
0.0500478707,
-0.0033939385,
-0.0036100096,
0.0192812961,
-0.0397144333,
0.0095122512,
-0.0246800203,
-0.0025960763,
-0.0510730483,
-0.0282846056,
0.0015232783,
-0.0264030285,
-0.0114955576,
0.0620981194,
-0.0001055047,
0.0042874645,
0.0131476354,
0.0119189173,
0.0101095997,
-0.04329383,
-0.0115532167,
0.0262114033,
0.0157658067,
0.0327366143,
-0.0165947359,
0.0031026399,
-0.0050473297,
-0.0116356285,
-0.0093670655,
-0.0175345466,
-0.0206333268,
0.0755524933,
0.0300573818,
-0.0053647072,
0.0049367733,
-0.0044171498,
0.019466158,
-0.0245693102,
-0.058956787,
0.0324907377,
0.0332834348,
0.0619880147,
-0.0225958768,
-0.0078014317,
-0.0087212417,
0.01947538,
-0.0195122454,
0.0420675352,
0.0382680595,
0.0004840636,
0.0330674388,
0.0004099197,
-0.0654636919,
0.0682342127,
-0.0108122956,
0.0084156925,
-0.0017218213,
-0.0637092516,
-0.0115681989,
-0.0096534807,
0.0837782919,
0.0054097706,
0.0097030886,
0.0549094379,
0.0541322827,
0.0264376178,
-0.0420585647,
-0.0811204836,
0.020299498,
-0.0055887564,
-0.0107862288,
-0.052069705,
0.0414736308,
0.0307855569,
-0.0024266716,
-0.0515747815,
0.0061826971,
-0.0159125961,
-0.0867244974,
-0.0199686754,
-0.1064372733,
0.0081402911,
-0.0222521089,
-0.0203771088,
0.0001359609,
0.0375165157,
0.0156927258,
0.0015111904,
0.1015508249,
0.0100851161,
-0.0289511234,
0.029769348,
0.0400399379,
-0.0086338287,
0.089243412,
0.0544691496,
0.0286536403,
0.0139645496,
0.0114525678,
0.0021361138,
-0.0152375754,
-0.0188643374,
0.0426490195,
0.0111689884,
0.002935023,
-0.0143992407,
0.022173604,
0.0199838243,
0.0297307931,
-0.0087074134,
-0.0348981991,
0.0319891348,
0.0359705351,
0.0149872173,
-0.0197455548,
0.0441772752,
0.0357536636,
0.0071676681,
0.0154790962,
-0.0029935429,
-0.0216560662,
0.0205050725,
0.0685165599,
0.0295369495,
-0.0340730511,
0.0622806586,
0.0631425008,
-0.0188179892,
0.0005150309,
0.0237065777,
0.0078824162,
0.044260297,
0.0600780919,
-0.0215922948,
-0.0447805375,
-0.0000645686,
-0.0090284841,
-0.0059032333,
0.0580384247,
-0.0420315675,
0.0082742078,
-0.00037039,
-0.0580845624,
0.0275682248,
-0.0012947833,
-0.019719515,
0.0715646744,
0.0330616273,
-0.0205540601,
-0.069129616,
-0.0263954885,
0.016866697,
0.0051488369,
-0.0179510526,
-0.0275829248,
-0.0035062789,
-0.0034407869,
0.0532477722,
-0.0128690191,
0.002477898,
0.0315498561,
-0.0090135504,
-0.0293397624,
-0.0227735396,
0.0179718807,
0.0257591326,
0.0592570938,
-0.0161872264,
-0.0137515189,
-0.0064618504,
-0.0362928696,
-0.0040915515,
0.0009956637,
0.04368864,
0.0462359041,
0.0147019308,
-0.0235095993,
0.022783827,
-0.010627253,
0.0027257702,
0.0574822761,
0.0096629141,
-0.0295732841,
-0.0020780028,
-0.0587309115,
0.0138806719,
-0.0058332644,
0.0445055626,
0.0061735096,
-0.0286125708,
0.0239383541,
-0.0195576791,
-0.0294096973,
-0.1353274882,
0.0509171449,
-0.0700291693,
0.0563293248,
0.0285200328,
0.0513296537,
-0.0082896603,
0.0375405885,
0.0014920544,
-0.0064448407,
0.0051230649,
0.0497163646,
-0.0370348766,
-0.0131603088,
0.037880078,
0.0233907998,
0.0366400033,
0.0172277596,
-0.025088463,
-0.0149934618,
0.0326768048,
0.0200040098,
0.0242947936,
0.0032264909,
0.010087735,
-0.1073761955,
0.010426444,
0.0275483727,
0.0482057184,
-0.020625094,
-0.0336599164,
0.0115583716,
0.0202605128,
-0.0167427976,
0.0129498029,
-0.0252521858,
-0.0455083698,
-0.0039550886,
-0.0138111273,
-0.0566994026,
0.0282124784,
-0.0019437427,
0.0519989766,
0.0272127856,
-0.0526680499,
0.0222301129,
-0.0205082111,
0.0116531821,
0.0294544008,
-0.0310288016,
0.0473929793,
-0.048249606,
0.0353632644,
-0.0208403897,
0.0054455586,
-0.005220138,
0.0060469708,
0.0425129235,
0.0193211976,
0.0543094203,
0.0126164537,
-0.0018657218,
-0.0444969945,
0.0552707054,
-0.0185580011,
0.0096014412,
0.0160199385,
-0.0032619492,
-0.0040682903,
0.0339043252,
0.0510079488,
-0.0781379566,
-0.0135326069,
0.001189791,
-0.0161118396,
-0.0116682779,
-0.0228096712,
-0.0364068262,
-0.0100814281,
-0.0380061194,
0.0003033439,
0.0377025194,
-0.0199777652,
0.0132577959,
-0.0388282239,
0.0040572747,
-0.0132865552,
0.0010124116,
-0.0110963006,
0.0028319436,
0.0611060224,
0.0384605676,
0.0203109682,
0.0291378926,
0.0285336394,
0.0152647728,
0.0968813524,
0.0214258842,
-0.0962562487,
0.0195137542,
0.0005616863,
-0.0063412189,
-0.0565688424,
0.0183014292,
-0.0184522439,
0.0201129317,
-0.0583870001,
0.0047575268,
0.0678621009,
0.0101586506,
0.0176131632,
-0.0007214631,
0.0126358075,
-0.01562641,
0.0027458272,
0.0183852073,
-0.1367552727,
-0.0093899211,
-0.033797916,
0.0598328225,
0.0144933313,
-0.0829504579,
0.0075511383,
-0.1128395423,
0.0381197035,
-0.0169694796,
-0.0265860278,
-0.0133905541,
-0.0698986575,
0.0268767104,
-0.0114432368,
-0.0807427168,
0.0307405517,
-0.0183877945,
0.0073123821,
0.0198118184,
0.003830086,
-0.012774921,
0.0509229526,
-0.0582872778,
0.0213302746,
-0.0320219696,
0.044217553,
-0.0014477464,
-0.0268979445,
-0.0300869271,
-0.0319128893,
-0.049395185,
-0.0317413881,
0.0821525753,
-0.0001119388,
-0.0299857911,
-0.0755556375,
0.0279289559,
-0.0272410233,
0.0157836657,
0.0182866547,
0.1260441393,
0.0382464118,
-0.0259965565,
-0.0033638657,
-0.0456225723,
-0.0048259231,
0.0438848138,
0.0091292523,
-0.0130455457,
-0.0194126926,
-0.0016352317,
-0.0326759331,
-0.0352291614,
-0.0311255585,
0.0265311822,
-0.0745961964,
-0.0110533806,
-0.0750870109,
-0.0141923884,
0.0534879602,
0.0024144319,
-0.0033242048,
-0.0288997553,
0.0710963309,
0.0081535997,
-0.0792875886,
0.0012563013,
-0.0403084606,
-0.006938173,
-0.031489823,
-0.0111113908,
0.0380661413,
-0.0010364809,
-0.0418925732,
0.0311319176,
-0.0316597819,
-0.0471870676,
0.0331975855,
-0.0136866244,
0.0083411923,
0.0208372381,
0.0043525924,
0.0355590656,
0.0314062722,
0.0433333851,
-0.0690999776,
-0.0418478884,
-0.0026192113,
-0.0271485522,
0.0179071445,
0.0367672555,
-0.0445373133,
-0.0119458539,
-0.0161970053,
0.0022023607,
-0.0367598869,
-0.0402831323,
0.0099127227,
0.0657513887,
0.0038367028,
0.0611207411,
-0.0192742832,
-0.0657634512,
-0.0075661479,
0.0033951555,
-0.0209420659,
-0.0023870107,
0.0344067104,
-0.0365416892,
-0.0157973357,
0.00919165,
0.044544939,
0.047908593,
0.0038458325,
-0.0544910915,
-0.0623075441,
0.0159865171,
-0.0205254257,
0.0367389619,
-0.0523059107,
-0.007995788,
0.0219726879,
-0.0019796561,
0.0174747668,
-0.0203071479,
0.0117909443,
0.0058327164,
-0.0165244061,
0.0327521749,
-0.0199632309,
-0.0527139045,
-0.0186817907,
0.0011924474,
0.0194269195,
0.0213353783,
0.025795646,
0.0602968484,
-0.0171367824,
-0.0341761149,
0.0088767149,
0.0063224258,
-0.0224929079,
0.0237182118,
-0.0024420859,
0.0314317159,
-0.0214529596,
-0.0022338724,
0.0502724871,
-0.041956719,
0.0304579325,
0.0047212145,
-0.0202346351,
-0.0504516214,
-0.0166581031,
-0.013281987,
0.029864097,
0.0182945933,
-0.0153526077,
-0.031660296,
-0.0419618115,
0.0088200402,
0.0055535203,
-0.0154276742,
0.015216263,
0.0229165368,
0.0161949433,
0.059092842,
-0.0428833291,
-0.0482855365,
0.045089379,
-0.0546159036,
-0.0076978956,
0.0759609491,
-6.544306924e-33,
0.004196235,
-0.0316717587,
0.0084119895,
0.0414767191,
-0.0482605025,
0.008721604,
0.0001387332,
-0.0103443656,
-0.0527175553,
0.0292693488,
0.0189171061,
0.0446957238,
0.0128741357,
0.0142672062,
-0.003122706,
-0.0271074548,
0.0143818008,
-0.0257064551,
0.0198436826,
0.0293768942,
0.1056036577,
0.0388842933,
0.0281529799,
-0.0722752064,
0.0376927219,
-0.0343906283,
0.0288539287,
-0.0003190744,
0.0824636221,
0.0436716117,
-0.0095860185,
0.0618804954,
-0.0054183714,
-0.0491141602,
0.0110259829,
-0.0655664504,
-0.1163906753,
-0.0136909969,
-0.0183260143,
-0.0238664225,
-0.0372166075,
0.0207011476,
0.0206757206,
0.0181731712,
0.0521166883,
-0.0592740588,
0.0318074636,
-0.0231512152,
-0.0127368933,
-0.0312677994,
0.0036865843,
0.0281096008,
0.0200599078,
0.0289598238,
0.003187428,
-0.079140842,
0.0133662438,
-0.0178883206,
-0.0874964148,
0.0188101865,
-0.0180075765,
-0.0157262441,
0.0174381156,
-0.0289403014,
0.0101160537,
0.0237598699,
-0.0552097,
-0.0139054172,
0.0161470678,
0.0591089092,
-0.0416738056,
0.1113513708,
-0.001345392,
0.0158931334,
0.0036154417,
-0.0646772236,
-0.0800196975,
0.0017419856,
-0.0064663067,
-0.0184209999,
-0.0583289191,
-0.0304802414,
-0.0085291015,
0.0236742795,
0.0319961905,
0.0209511928,
-0.0211058613,
0.0028933776,
0.0083407713,
-0.0186741333,
-0.0380165279,
0.014088314,
-0.020158818,
-0.05099044,
0.0184334945,
0.0353595018,
-0.0085100671,
-0.0083242152,
-0.0094251381,
-0.0253820606,
-0.0747208148,
0.0028633557,
-0.030884508,
-0.0077045066,
-0.0076926015,
0.0390992016,
0.0164744779,
-0.0217367783,
-0.0365146361,
0.0018316633,
-0.0315491073,
0.042088192,
-0.0074145049,
-0.0102190105,
0.0329619162,
0.0408288836,
0.0085856598,
0.0255966969,
0.0866785198,
0.0487979539,
-0.0145276226,
0.0278062839,
0.0457892306,
-0.0286512766,
-0.0084587382,
-0.0113337534,
-0.013371516,
0.0079804985,
-0.0541164838,
-0.0613617189,
-0.0241837874,
-0.0074075363,
2.75e-7,
0.0248454884,
0.0152790919,
0.0117480867,
0.0554387383,
0.01271821,
0.0112040536,
0.0461534411,
0.0203481987,
-0.0144856088,
-0.0256357715,
-0.0280257948,
0.0237574,
-0.00407675,
0.0707180724,
-0.0635613129,
-0.0442153886,
-0.008794276,
-0.0710248798,
-0.0463650338,
-0.0230320524,
0.0531023778,
-0.0159064047,
0.047213845,
0.0046017175,
0.0049838298,
-0.0244780928,
0.0076846345,
0.0450717434,
0.0192275029,
0.0213473719,
0.0369763486,
0.01784149,
-0.0341210701,
0.0205947738,
-0.0232250448,
0.0016926163,
0.0147261797,
0.0046621687,
0.0163313784,
0.0002874612,
0.0031920846,
-0.0760417506,
0.0291418526,
-0.0248676389,
0.0862046406,
-0.0024761385,
-0.0286647268,
-0.0011727182,
-0.0543294214,
-0.0216962788,
-0.0512066968,
-0.0120953033,
0.0030692921,
0.0032735625,
-0.019644035,
-0.000225902,
-0.0272158924,
-0.01500447,
0.0196403209,
0.0023251274,
0.0230708756,
-0.0900645256,
0.0481534079,
-0.0351435319,
0.0100157941,
-0.0041428311,
0.0092155319,
2.13858376e-34,
-0.0138328094,
0.0451961569,
-0.0072305747,
-0.0074964049,
0.0262921173,
-0.0366209522,
-0.0256306473,
-0.0552453399,
-0.0079041235,
-0.0508404262,
0.0168007631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20046v1 | Which Examples to Annotate for In-Context Learning? Towards Effective and Efficient Selection | 2023-10-30T22:03:55 | 2023-10-30T22:03:55 | Costas Mavromatis, Balasubramaniam Srinivasan, Zhengyuan Shen, Jiani Zhang, Huzefa Rangwala, Christos Faloutsos, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can adapt to new tasks via in-context learning
(ICL). ICL is efficient as it does not require any parameter updates to the
trained LLM, but only few annotated examples as input for the LLM. In this
work, we investigate an active learning approach for ICL, where there is a
limited budget for annotating examples. We propose a model-adaptive
optimization-free algorithm, termed AdaICL, which identifies examples that the
model is uncertain about, and performs semantic diversity-based example
selection. Diversity-based sampling improves overall effectiveness, while
uncertainty sampling improves budget efficiency and helps the LLM learn new
information. Moreover, AdaICL poses its sampling strategy as a Maximum Coverage
problem, that dynamically adapts based on the model's feedback and can be
approximately solved via greedy algorithms. Extensive experiments on nine
datasets and seven LLMs show that AdaICL improves performance by 4.4% accuracy
points over SOTA (7.7% relative improvement), is up to 3x more budget-efficient
than performing annotations uniformly at random, while it outperforms SOTA with
2x fewer ICL examples. | [
0.024680011,
0.0209174175,
-0.0150398249,
0.0143695334,
-0.032934323,
0.0400682762,
-0.0085369674,
0.0095802993,
-0.0064936876,
-0.0996399224,
0.0081713861,
-0.0610150769,
-0.0277620163,
-0.0255587436,
0.0245379787,
-0.0327101909,
0.0381030589,
-0.0660429969,
0.0126589509,
0.0041018971,
-0.0278606452,
0.02935954,
0.0052861641,
0.031920027,
-0.0172909796,
0.0111272642,
-0.0205941629,
0.0052595795,
-0.0086450279,
-0.0365444422,
0.0188615806,
0.0479006432,
0.0349053703,
0.0068274029,
0.0000021189,
-0.0729630664,
-0.0498397164,
-0.0056860279,
-0.0465321653,
-0.0058857687,
0.0513626859,
0.0281753652,
0.0195832551,
0.0184096247,
-0.0345398448,
0.0003470694,
0.0575711839,
0.0156032229,
0.0202514119,
0.0725216344,
-0.0030798584,
0.0188294183,
-0.0274960697,
-0.0464904718,
0.021593269,
-0.0419624895,
0.0374463834,
0.0032259149,
0.0103294766,
0.0157904085,
-0.0087348083,
0.0136018721,
-0.0297517609,
-0.0155989816,
0.0105640348,
0.008198441,
-0.0529792421,
-0.0087149432,
0.0100316862,
0.077745527,
-0.0401264578,
-0.0169433225,
0.0114774713,
-0.0440459624,
0.0122964531,
0.0160791539,
-0.0415915176,
-0.0077253003,
-0.004567862,
0.0439510383,
0.0295270663,
-0.0037769105,
0.0505493693,
0.0275796801,
-0.0138286753,
0.0337031595,
-0.012594061,
-0.0226613656,
0.0348912179,
0.001195304,
-0.0705858991,
-0.0093533276,
-0.0108160535,
0.0152039686,
-0.0435801595,
0.0625346601,
-0.0531926677,
-0.0427104458,
0.0131530445,
-0.0386262201,
0.0460362993,
0.0230325479,
-0.0090385014,
0.0789033696,
0.027609013,
-0.0409287997,
0.0112575339,
-0.0042601926,
-0.0337628089,
-0.0105889896,
-0.0498169549,
0.0172726437,
-0.0779140815,
0.0397616662,
-0.0221162345,
-0.0122805675,
-0.0320763513,
0.0501400419,
-0.0291121677,
-0.0083982423,
0.0091671254,
-0.0303111877,
-0.0392131992,
0.0241886247,
0.0048259869,
-0.0261514038,
0.0013043286,
0.0099788271,
-0.0101850042,
-0.07610441,
0.0096938685,
0.0019118988,
0.0100871846,
-0.0442172326,
0.002294959,
0.0900402591,
0.0026089207,
-0.076716207,
-0.0421774164,
0.0207368396,
-0.0053926338,
-0.022273114,
-0.0270252358,
-0.0599006936,
-0.0062856488,
-0.0000374955,
0.0227360055,
-0.0403028503,
0.0120036621,
0.032310836,
-0.0381386541,
0.0562951639,
-0.0183394589,
0.0130118178,
0.0464297943,
-0.036623802,
-0.0072657652,
0.1281482875,
0.0233701747,
-0.0244103931,
0.0702846423,
0.0337470509,
0.0021990279,
0.0364845544,
0.0209434535,
0.0274244025,
-0.0086477185,
0.0050821011,
0.0141063947,
0.009402941,
-0.0178587455,
0.0146439252,
-0.025309192,
0.0085357474,
0.0443964154,
0.0035462799,
-0.0181967523,
-0.0170870423,
0.0147954663,
0.0200704951,
0.0155492704,
-0.0308526978,
-0.0335419066,
0.0185029674,
-0.0307171419,
-0.014094661,
-0.0062148403,
0.0053222449,
-0.0294546206,
-0.0451475047,
-0.0577818528,
-0.0236130003,
-0.0000768595,
0.053459201,
0.062054459,
0.0184523501,
-0.0390207134,
0.0717523694,
0.0497929081,
0.0130211683,
-0.0215332005,
-0.0253402852,
0.0312221423,
0.022958979,
0.0292581785,
-0.0868513063,
-0.0383749567,
-0.0439893454,
0.0247360002,
0.014793816,
0.0537108555,
-0.0358247012,
0.0264803413,
-0.077310577,
-0.0274329893,
0.0078228228,
0.0318364315,
0.0197186302,
0.0254222956,
0.0083254799,
-0.0158627033,
-0.0548957065,
-0.0496219508,
0.0534862876,
-0.0013558835,
-0.0234347582,
0.0317790955,
-0.0173357558,
0.0799856856,
-0.0147487158,
-0.0096063297,
-0.0132918339,
0.0014515268,
-0.0315662585,
-0.0174340215,
0.0041082161,
-0.0626940206,
-0.0539450198,
0.0177642945,
-0.0069800746,
-0.0269683078,
0.0053205248,
-0.0663857758,
-0.0236114543,
-0.0202366952,
-0.0484973788,
0.0243725013,
-0.0529896617,
0.0259381421,
-0.0316385292,
0.0289341006,
-0.0713483915,
0.0786775723,
-0.0008134563,
-0.0165141094,
0.0150531288,
0.0131235383,
-0.0006785812,
-0.0475617684,
-0.0622242726,
0.0068684937,
-0.0046938444,
-0.0005694308,
0.0144188069,
0.030515261,
-0.0215804111,
0.004801258,
-0.078714937,
-0.0173702314,
-0.0526883416,
-0.0146265412,
0.0028888213,
0.0332203247,
-0.0022214085,
-0.0221585743,
-0.0012047413,
0.001697775,
-0.0406409018,
0.0237332545,
0.0199902635,
0.0282434151,
0.0140025644,
-0.0399210602,
-0.0201888755,
0.0135634718,
0.0554328188,
-0.0069274558,
-0.0496139005,
-0.0618347041,
0.0202804562,
0.0091031427,
0.0200226028,
-0.0084255924,
0.0447979048,
-0.0387963802,
-0.0297124889,
-0.0280467793,
0.0245563947,
0.0258649103,
0.0666317418,
0.0421948209,
0.0203340072,
-0.0517080799,
0.0357993618,
-0.0173228402,
0.0328579247,
-0.0236678552,
-0.0017323043,
0.0400564373,
0.0320065171,
-0.014977647,
-0.0266635753,
-0.0266884528,
-0.0116889421,
-0.0358151197,
-0.0381611511,
-0.0610824302,
0.0146840345,
-0.0143130058,
0.0427100845,
0.0083256606,
-0.0347189829,
0.0540495776,
0.0253619235,
-0.0062919138,
-0.0683056489,
-0.0107486118,
-0.0370839536,
0.041066166,
0.0041984096,
-0.0072939177,
0.0071984567,
-0.0076317373,
-0.0347207598,
-0.0401564501,
0.0427863114,
-0.0166427363,
0.074709855,
-0.0693903193,
0.0389379114,
0.0130001083,
-0.0258592814,
-0.0485978872,
-0.0216879714,
-0.0188042056,
0.020385202,
-0.0011233755,
0.0433120653,
-0.0292399153,
0.0094632441,
-0.0244351644,
0.0853465497,
-0.0045796731,
-0.0072038728,
-0.0170339216,
0.0032940186,
0.0473674461,
0.0144415256,
0.0156266708,
-0.0249816794,
0.0032574304,
0.0006845854,
0.0235881861,
-0.0281892065,
-0.0210122392,
0.0353776179,
0.051986821,
-0.0615236051,
-0.0226180069,
0.0396438055,
0.0292477142,
-0.0431000181,
-0.0252278075,
0.1054536626,
0.0225209761,
-0.0655581057,
0.0185168516,
-0.0182437263,
-0.0024673028,
0.0332398899,
0.0457719713,
-0.0521702133,
-0.0457373634,
0.0045417305,
0.0357955545,
-0.0096002053,
-0.0346920937,
0.0022835238,
-0.1149057001,
0.0464178398,
-0.0049927859,
-0.0974285603,
0.023433581,
-0.0439353101,
0.045134522,
-0.0491653346,
0.0350671411,
-0.0164397657,
-0.0045568207,
-0.0084721847,
0.0440663211,
-0.0265905168,
-0.0924265906,
-0.0026446134,
0.0085674739,
0.0447492339,
0.0404383242,
0.014988183,
-0.0055606551,
0.0273139086,
0.0574951768,
-0.0349435061,
-0.0027954089,
-0.0475951955,
0.0593734495,
0.0299839806,
-0.005784465,
0.0698157027,
0.0296918508,
-0.0246910956,
-0.0155981984,
0.020916149,
0.0771268085,
-0.029024912,
0.0596771762,
0.0096886819,
-0.0564147569,
0.0678155273,
0.0661083534,
0.0219883397,
-0.0450034328,
-0.0083168531,
-0.0143850315,
-0.018687332,
-0.0551882572,
0.0481535234,
0.0301789101,
-0.0437166281,
-0.0242628269,
-0.0667639896,
0.011924468,
0.0573487394,
0.0755596682,
0.0154001946,
0.0556564406,
0.0312939398,
0.0328942351,
-0.0208487045,
-0.0049192309,
-0.0356986895,
0.008910818,
-0.0090092001,
-0.0404483862,
0.0182899442,
-0.047882244,
-0.013787901,
0.0464893766,
-0.0562536269,
-0.0682068095,
0.0438699871,
0.0205049105,
0.0229885615,
0.0725258887,
-0.0142543614,
-0.0464240946,
0.0493115745,
0.0400319658,
0.0308619887,
0.0059152497,
0.0386221223,
0.0109596821,
-0.0168749262,
0.0502289571,
-0.0851782411,
-0.0023624529,
0.0281270742,
0.0232044533,
-0.0453177132,
0.001395284,
0.0048829499,
0.0078538451,
0.0022730648,
-0.0453554541,
-0.0227315426,
-0.027081022,
0.0522780977,
0.0371235199,
-0.0222047027,
-0.0488413721,
0.0311767347,
-0.023594413,
-0.0350595824,
-0.0177675113,
0.0138330925,
0.0021137367,
0.0595697649,
-0.0131058851,
0.0048113214,
-0.0075349947,
0.0096418355,
0.0090822959,
0.0124785975,
-0.0062257093,
0.0261458084,
0.0204014219,
0.0208241437,
-0.0081675239,
0.0258816145,
0.0208957512,
0.0209153462,
-0.0217962563,
-0.0059689428,
-0.0408185609,
-0.0062774206,
-0.0449498817,
0.0711220205,
0.0688320026,
-0.0597708933,
0.0833138824,
-0.0372324139,
-0.0231658351,
-0.0298587922,
0.0166870672,
0.0212697554,
-0.0320919454,
0.0338003673,
0.0299001019,
-0.0128878895,
0.030599175,
0.0848675743,
-0.016507864,
0.0536813736,
0.0047683357,
-0.0002833468,
-0.0576263964,
0.0297760479,
0.0376879387,
0.0334334597,
0.0034206805,
0.0149646131,
-0.0291699339,
-0.0433089025,
0.022053251,
-0.0543556288,
-0.043636214,
-0.0153411934,
0.0731128156,
0.0632028952,
0.019417068,
0.0312481858,
-0.0577813499,
-0.0242114794,
-0.0040233773,
-0.0005040486,
-0.0146191353,
-6.403180746e-33,
-0.0200392324,
-0.0128691746,
-0.0273863841,
-0.0094538499,
0.0107649853,
0.0111482032,
-0.0099236565,
-0.0050998013,
-0.0038086651,
-0.0053359084,
-0.0080797672,
-0.0179205518,
0.0212559178,
0.0540338792,
0.0157542974,
-0.0330713764,
0.01954877,
0.0169059969,
-0.0235989578,
0.0180400722,
0.0426988788,
0.0174945388,
0.0468196496,
-0.0561486222,
0.0042269398,
0.0088638132,
-0.0036392137,
0.0228659436,
0.0069627981,
0.0632600039,
0.0211004093,
0.0492109843,
0.0198708978,
-0.0389226265,
-0.0325835012,
-0.0592100993,
-0.0632581413,
-0.0537654608,
0.0150241908,
0.0225358214,
-0.0212854166,
-0.0130898897,
0.0177589897,
-0.0053852219,
0.0159912147,
0.0117784971,
0.0390268639,
-0.0567481257,
-0.0646006912,
-0.034399014,
-0.0393254533,
0.0411954932,
-0.0182173494,
0.0087275729,
0.0042803967,
0.001032031,
-0.0098678553,
0.0302813426,
-0.0053358697,
-0.0024156317,
-0.0077081374,
0.0322118551,
0.0229508802,
0.017141033,
0.0108202714,
0.0513924286,
-0.0387274213,
-0.0025943615,
0.0610859878,
-0.0464239679,
0.0120191453,
0.0368594602,
-0.0042882091,
0.063077718,
0.027876446,
0.0306621231,
-0.0619275831,
-0.0022310098,
0.0794347227,
-0.0198745783,
0.0538895838,
0.0144299343,
-0.0514950268,
-0.0250717811,
-0.0431542359,
-0.0129639087,
-0.0169289578,
-0.0242170952,
0.0324516296,
0.0242974814,
-0.0456128158,
0.0539544486,
0.0362488739,
-0.0084038563,
-0.0460820496,
-0.0011292526,
-0.0281522479,
-0.0110000828,
0.0259100441,
0.0061450927,
-0.0217827391,
-0.0740567297,
-0.0076094978,
0.0041991351,
-0.0047167763,
-0.0213490129,
0.0515173748,
0.0562421195,
-0.0548836403,
0.0097469036,
-0.0090617388,
0.0368289761,
-0.0160332937,
0.0277597755,
0.0147559093,
-0.0044128778,
-0.0051765619,
0.0713322163,
0.0369652845,
-0.042862501,
-0.0155881261,
-0.0504347384,
-0.0512703508,
0.0092147132,
-0.0479600988,
-0.0202607792,
0.0158227794,
-0.0275216103,
0.0301980693,
-0.0518587567,
-0.00637169,
0.0248452295,
2.763e-7,
0.0602404065,
0.0616727211,
-0.0312547572,
-0.0098410193,
0.0472513959,
0.0198392812,
-0.0303043332,
0.0178737845,
-0.0073974864,
0.0236588474,
0.0027117969,
0.0005063431,
0.0523889177,
0.0365015082,
-0.0914884061,
0.0123825744,
-0.0393112414,
0.0300430004,
-0.0285799466,
-0.0040877941,
-0.0000343855,
0.1144371852,
0.0382820666,
-0.0233931076,
-0.0417657755,
-0.0564841218,
0.0399607718,
-0.0457123332,
-0.0063173641,
0.0356197804,
0.0077400184,
0.0485401154,
-0.0007660424,
0.0168070141,
-0.0373821445,
0.0195967667,
0.0099723125,
0.0490961149,
0.0109628504,
-0.0035724321,
0.0111131994,
0.0216441862,
0.0182059705,
-0.0398529693,
0.0667230189,
-0.0757258981,
-0.0349451452,
-0.0422465205,
0.032902278,
-0.0219233148,
0.0012139127,
0.0167669579,
0.0108125564,
0.0320124552,
0.0021303885,
-0.0046992511,
-0.0480067208,
-0.0532571562,
0.007532761,
-0.0157178082,
-0.0438653566,
-0.032624241,
-0.0329407044,
0.0329691507,
0.0361709334,
-0.0554697998,
0.0332075395,
2.689133886e-34,
0.061140649,
0.0069447034,
-0.0499625094,
0.0756838918,
-0.044985801,
-0.0032249095,
0.0077763959,
0.0295281131,
0.0002429512,
-0.0207739156,
0.0046216929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01469v1 | Leveraging Language Models to Detect Greenwashing | 2023-10-30T21:41:49 | 2023-10-30T21:41:49 | Avalon Vinella, Margaret Capetz, Rebecca Pattichis, Christina Chance, Reshmi Ghosh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, climate change repercussions have increasingly captured
public interest. Consequently, corporations are emphasizing their environmental
efforts in sustainability reports to bolster their public image. Yet, the
absence of stringent regulations in review of such reports allows potential
greenwashing. In this study, we introduce a novel methodology to train a
language model on generated labels for greenwashing risk. Our primary
contributions encompass: developing a mathematical formulation to quantify
greenwashing risk, a fine-tuned ClimateBERT model for this problem, and a
comparative analysis of results. On a test set comprising of sustainability
reports, our best model achieved an average accuracy score of 86.34% and F1
score of 0.67, demonstrating that our methods show a promising direction of
exploration for this task. | [
0.041957628,
0.0779182017,
0.0005382861,
0.0554367304,
-0.0215909295,
-0.0107374769,
-0.0192970112,
0.0216806848,
0.0150828892,
-0.0923150703,
0.0163039248,
0.0503728054,
-0.0188209116,
0.0609016716,
-0.0166753195,
-0.0384440273,
0.071516104,
0.0080551691,
0.0548578165,
-0.0172827635,
0.0297011677,
0.0002170865,
0.0491199791,
0.0192419384,
-0.0377918594,
-0.0428566411,
0.0454067029,
-0.0088240523,
0.0419472978,
-0.0146901552,
0.0227076355,
0.0420885719,
0.0140809929,
0.0615282878,
0.0000016594,
-0.0526398197,
-0.0388122872,
-0.0180116966,
0.0536855906,
0.0119781019,
0.0919600055,
-0.0483201593,
-0.0040111104,
0.0228499565,
-0.0290308818,
-0.0213730056,
0.0667621493,
0.0474474207,
0.0861686468,
0.015221511,
-0.0078623723,
-0.0042354446,
-0.0122985207,
0.0075049372,
-0.0093729915,
0.0320276767,
0.0837610215,
0.0019351779,
-0.0764141604,
0.0056846924,
-0.0171098653,
0.0727367699,
-0.0123438435,
-0.0041447324,
-0.0031035796,
-0.0094587151,
-0.0237152893,
0.0049960795,
-0.0319908522,
0.0484685712,
-0.0217876974,
-0.0081849704,
-0.0194994789,
-0.0279144794,
0.0209778454,
0.0016667378,
0.0002630827,
0.0268405918,
0.0088090999,
-0.0040751304,
-0.0005659863,
0.0176353659,
-0.010228659,
0.0738540068,
0.0237894449,
0.0703151524,
-0.0090811513,
-0.0532519147,
0.0179278329,
-0.0171730556,
0.0075423978,
-0.0299046058,
-0.0047921794,
-0.0040639206,
0.036511533,
0.0521551557,
-0.0241119992,
-0.0040718941,
0.0271474496,
-0.0757795647,
0.020293273,
-0.0226925109,
0.0158380233,
0.0303273369,
0.0134615162,
0.0390777439,
0.0234840419,
0.0173989758,
-0.0316101126,
0.0210713539,
-0.0200511273,
-0.0362678729,
-0.0245932825,
-0.0029697211,
-0.0026298077,
0.0127083268,
-0.0425996594,
-0.0163625311,
-0.0501337796,
0.0047464096,
0.0218129382,
0.0110458517,
0.006877569,
-0.0304616056,
0.0100447517,
0.0273380857,
-0.0164416265,
0.0386058129,
-0.0329507999,
0.0052903858,
0.0369174704,
0.0265392717,
0.0013661989,
0.0143984966,
-0.0272580981,
0.0775144026,
0.0423853733,
-0.006249473,
-0.012361466,
-0.0393919088,
-0.0290678162,
-0.0180948935,
-0.0315095037,
-0.0068657785,
-0.0276834834,
-0.0329533629,
0.0050743972,
-0.0744842961,
-0.0016450234,
-0.0244193804,
-0.0396286845,
0.0631871521,
-0.0478695258,
-0.02841511,
0.0377504677,
0.0150585379,
-0.0046368702,
0.0698318779,
0.0530569591,
0.0432068035,
0.0490070991,
-0.0168121513,
0.019857347,
0.0419203825,
-0.0063465326,
0.009485513,
-0.0028126503,
-0.0172873922,
0.0097003551,
0.0128596649,
-0.0097840345,
0.0184702296,
0.0130988993,
-0.0107503571,
0.0717472285,
0.015109282,
-0.0252047163,
-0.0232810806,
0.0004383136,
0.0271368939,
-0.0562047884,
-0.0037181573,
-0.0008325104,
-0.0273213778,
-0.040419817,
-0.009731519,
-0.0231438875,
0.0100339008,
0.0065539205,
-0.0546254739,
-0.0368251428,
0.0165975019,
0.0295141451,
-0.0434564129,
-0.0035211442,
0.0241422672,
-0.068517901,
0.0291232951,
0.0086362995,
-0.0472779423,
0.0182464626,
-0.020257581,
0.0406471528,
0.0546842888,
0.010434716,
0.0243377518,
0.0443237349,
-0.0798813924,
-0.0231903456,
-0.0047254735,
0.0227131229,
-0.0133717414,
-0.0523324311,
-0.0151259787,
-0.0452217311,
-0.0059682331,
0.024830386,
0.0264486186,
-0.0038146025,
0.0207494646,
0.0183975343,
-0.0323854014,
-0.0434292443,
0.0597538501,
0.0619018376,
-0.0465285741,
-0.0142231956,
0.0162571352,
0.0259135142,
0.0007521709,
0.0042031761,
0.0043724105,
0.0426560864,
-0.0165284798,
-0.0611900017,
0.0211485643,
0.0366580039,
0.0200271215,
0.0367220528,
-0.0503919162,
-0.0198476724,
0.0474783033,
-0.0390321314,
-0.002775785,
0.0084604258,
-0.0034619907,
-0.0064203776,
-0.0346364193,
-0.0323578455,
-0.029240042,
0.0069396808,
-0.0161543209,
0.0716882199,
-0.0002102936,
0.0344867148,
-0.0591175631,
-0.0246370044,
0.0089947991,
-0.0218040366,
0.0376305133,
-0.0354204178,
-0.0463653095,
0.0348251089,
0.0538473651,
-0.0068142065,
-0.030016467,
0.0000792585,
-0.0406043157,
-0.0256697256,
-0.0002715336,
0.015675433,
0.0002894418,
-0.044225622,
-0.0174074471,
0.0323718786,
-0.0182528421,
-0.0335477255,
-0.0102200126,
0.044687856,
0.0100368876,
-0.0019291438,
-0.0235681459,
-0.0119585264,
0.0060949917,
-0.0490719788,
0.0826850161,
0.0686233342,
-0.0817506462,
-0.0751471296,
0.0113055566,
-0.0213663131,
-0.0244751684,
0.0191830304,
-0.0244232472,
-0.0171796512,
0.0170016214,
-0.0230745226,
0.015524867,
0.074200958,
0.0271804947,
0.0011712505,
0.0104437042,
-0.0551718995,
-0.0227788575,
-0.0288620573,
-0.0182681531,
0.0402423255,
-0.0507141761,
0.056650389,
0.0546411984,
-0.0362468138,
-0.0155318864,
0.0047293045,
0.0861043558,
-0.0521847233,
-0.0448128544,
-0.0435966663,
-0.0604176186,
-0.007034943,
0.0492388345,
-0.0063437945,
-0.0923680887,
0.0437904224,
-0.0053311079,
0.0251515023,
-0.0469748788,
-0.0008007796,
0.0158225503,
0.0507295541,
-0.0234885719,
0.0413324423,
0.063750118,
-0.0069053858,
0.0063028224,
-0.0402686782,
0.0435035154,
-0.0037225182,
0.0165926274,
-0.0471751094,
0.0285319779,
0.0260146782,
-0.0222116355,
-0.0238844529,
-0.0795486718,
-0.0080650691,
0.0146291899,
0.0189957377,
0.0223110616,
-0.0724559501,
0.0538310558,
-0.0135354828,
-0.0220327433,
0.0025159705,
-0.0009668694,
0.0237971488,
0.0095023615,
0.0314155258,
-0.0486967526,
0.0250773691,
-0.0141026946,
-0.0070538097,
0.0002655828,
0.0132718747,
0.0186563022,
-0.0093254205,
0.005035819,
-0.0017394281,
-0.0111183068,
0.0387235731,
0.0066825729,
-0.0214933734,
-0.0553121231,
0.0260690153,
0.0589184538,
0.0136347394,
-0.0163308512,
0.0338436551,
0.018532902,
0.0041968012,
0.0102379676,
0.0061872215,
-0.0654562637,
-0.0219921768,
0.0038322899,
-0.005076536,
-0.0367482603,
-0.0364949368,
-0.0399861932,
-0.0528751127,
0.0439800881,
0.0272108614,
-0.055445753,
-0.0107705947,
-0.0492514111,
-0.0334002562,
-0.037091922,
-0.0265876614,
-0.0308631212,
-0.0171098784,
-0.0356008224,
0.0117392205,
-0.0592194237,
-0.0429578274,
-0.0031202952,
0.0156248985,
-0.0244490951,
0.114834033,
0.023460472,
-0.0308134295,
-0.0415448621,
0.0410032384,
-0.0101108868,
-0.0295022205,
-0.0252149869,
0.0162961576,
-0.0397883616,
-0.0093828943,
0.0380206108,
0.0333595462,
-0.0212410763,
0.0270020459,
0.0197276752,
0.0466357619,
0.0529220738,
-0.0560049415,
0.0215447005,
0.0288640987,
0.0595675781,
0.0553923249,
-0.0009940341,
-0.0010979699,
-0.0224386994,
-0.1113526523,
0.0133536067,
-0.014904513,
-0.0142392647,
-0.0264307205,
-0.0677811354,
-0.061061915,
-0.0472215004,
-0.050377816,
0.0373714305,
-0.0011233947,
0.0330674723,
0.013938061,
0.0395675376,
0.0160994641,
-0.0449668653,
0.0302938335,
-0.0318389535,
0.0698243454,
-0.0214174185,
-0.0064690569,
0.0512290485,
0.0814028978,
-0.0494026057,
0.0568578765,
-0.0346953571,
-0.0877578706,
0.0206585247,
0.0522809289,
0.0234666727,
-0.0056998665,
0.0145006459,
0.0010920501,
0.0090932194,
0.1056656316,
-0.024305163,
0.0141749037,
0.0290648956,
-0.0077068959,
0.0084474338,
0.0301035438,
-0.0190558508,
0.0307111684,
-0.0038729263,
0.0593838915,
-0.0972833857,
0.0227883924,
0.0310139079,
0.0017956585,
0.0439993851,
-0.009847654,
0.0018070944,
-0.047394041,
-0.0162200462,
-0.0088511873,
-0.0596886165,
-0.0472410172,
0.0244226158,
0.0169466622,
0.0240804665,
-0.0409454629,
0.0556939654,
-0.0969556347,
0.0137834204,
-0.0363258496,
0.0492711663,
0.0077173891,
0.04456928,
0.015717255,
-0.0323609337,
-0.0159987248,
-0.0267818607,
0.0360452607,
-0.0224955007,
0.0353921317,
-0.002050048,
0.0467079207,
0.0479649641,
-0.0321326777,
0.0149214305,
-0.0024743765,
-0.0050322376,
-0.0437441282,
0.0221835114,
-0.0175025538,
0.029694397,
-0.003555719,
-0.0115228351,
-0.0364098027,
-0.0023984825,
0.0348196104,
0.0120046185,
-0.0744762048,
0.0828657225,
0.0001300433,
-0.0588664524,
-0.0310692005,
0.0394894034,
0.020360956,
0.0268216785,
-0.0209679231,
-0.0430186205,
-0.0311425384,
-0.0206525587,
0.0230333097,
-0.0160498843,
0.0191966407,
0.0260479059,
-0.0939731896,
-0.0482960194,
0.045839496,
0.005631018,
0.0390192233,
0.0138787944,
-0.0144909406,
0.0621583089,
-0.0061754859,
-0.0283087306,
-0.0268513262,
-0.0214426275,
-0.0307701193,
-0.0292152036,
-0.0145756034,
-5.216232672e-33,
-0.0263149329,
-0.0697483495,
-0.0306906886,
-0.0003690691,
0.0165691823,
0.0457538515,
0.0220806431,
0.0093231043,
-0.0015567205,
0.0492124222,
0.0271047316,
-0.0073511717,
0.0172465667,
-0.0227698702,
0.0026081086,
0.0098157823,
0.0233976021,
-0.0093758618,
-0.0227021072,
-0.0320373029,
0.0290288106,
0.0387601107,
0.01298704,
-0.0908743516,
0.0507139079,
-0.0007718413,
-0.0826235339,
-0.0208575539,
-0.0024327142,
0.027241407,
0.0039179651,
0.0802623332,
0.0198306423,
-0.048158057,
-0.0175378621,
0.0915757418,
-0.0422287174,
-0.0193343125,
0.0364812203,
-0.0148432087,
-0.0237832125,
0.0105483793,
0.0155772902,
0.0003923091,
-0.034369953,
0.0325760879,
0.0637121052,
-0.0616764128,
-0.0461768731,
-0.0194467418,
-0.0539213941,
0.0027019107,
-0.0018584408,
0.0662437528,
-0.0101546375,
0.0426155701,
0.0039997632,
0.089076139,
-0.0518522188,
0.0167734511,
0.0394579172,
0.0102206059,
0.0475565419,
0.032393422,
0.007799889,
0.0484851673,
-0.0336758494,
0.0395482071,
-0.0143210441,
-0.0023592524,
0.0214024112,
-0.0350953713,
0.0432779901,
0.0654076114,
0.0332398377,
-0.0401121564,
-0.0487193018,
0.0199276786,
0.0278182775,
0.0004046868,
0.0022282216,
-0.0399094746,
0.0134772528,
-0.0263888035,
-0.062411271,
-0.0076284567,
-0.0385624841,
0.0186047405,
0.0468920432,
0.0255183317,
-0.0546448454,
0.0335603319,
-0.0013428505,
-0.0294623096,
-0.0452340171,
0.0269885659,
0.0010640037,
-0.0120641319,
0.0136832064,
0.0448115766,
-0.045703318,
-0.0117007745,
-0.0199224167,
0.0175369475,
0.0248656031,
-0.031058697,
0.0730145946,
-0.0218732543,
-0.0685003027,
0.0088946326,
0.0038598471,
0.0054214722,
0.0073891985,
-0.035294082,
-0.0153891193,
-0.0181745812,
0.0205016024,
-0.0046211323,
0.035508588,
-0.0010897793,
0.0354619212,
-0.0230148658,
-0.0455491431,
0.0540819578,
-0.0276577994,
-0.0233505424,
0.0042489981,
-0.0056041661,
0.0444062166,
-0.0415373221,
-0.0038525779,
0.0078585213,
2.276e-7,
0.0579235777,
0.0329694115,
-0.0257549528,
-0.0188933183,
-0.0109135788,
0.0544781387,
0.0117727416,
0.0339279473,
0.0030207147,
-0.0328132585,
-0.0414175279,
-0.0455269702,
0.001571252,
-0.0110068778,
-0.0700530559,
0.006231755,
-0.0496602617,
-0.0001097577,
-0.0858678594,
-0.0015876174,
0.0250813123,
0.0560927279,
0.0148910237,
0.0027409852,
-0.0190445799,
-0.029424632,
0.0878491327,
-0.0832958743,
-0.0007059082,
0.0193577632,
0.0086894967,
-0.0354538113,
-0.0135077145,
0.0211033784,
-0.0342043526,
-0.0205094777,
0.0256691966,
0.0353121907,
0.0271400455,
-0.001663432,
0.0100413077,
-0.0176922213,
-0.0190645326,
-0.0279633775,
0.0106180003,
-0.0224802736,
-0.0047873701,
-0.0383504815,
-0.0473292321,
0.0300235171,
0.004826,
-0.0653965622,
-0.0404265523,
0.0093012303,
-0.0025546665,
0.0151546812,
0.0171653517,
-0.021730043,
0.0274614785,
-0.0562396012,
0.0120069878,
-0.0193456616,
0.0055987667,
0.0280892756,
0.0384437218,
-0.0160786062,
0.029555833,
1.846030996e-34,
0.0577982739,
-0.0520351417,
-0.0291666146,
-0.0324303322,
0.067046538,
0.0333409347,
0.0110849906,
0.028970452,
-0.0222899206,
-0.0477167405,
0.0077109053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20033v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20033v2 | Synthetic Imitation Edit Feedback for Factual Alignment in Clinical Summarization | 2023-10-30T21:33:22 | 2023-11-03T13:49:16 | Prakamya Mishra, Zonghai Yao, Shuwei Chen, Beining Wang, Rohan Mittal, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) like the GPT and LLaMA families have
demonstrated exceptional capabilities in capturing and condensing critical
contextual information and achieving state-of-the-art performance in the
summarization task. However, community concerns about these models'
hallucination issues continue to rise. LLMs sometimes generate factually
hallucinated summaries, which can be extremely harmful in the clinical domain
NLP tasks (e.g., clinical note summarization), where factually incorrect
statements can lead to critically erroneous diagnoses. Fine-tuning LLMs using
human feedback has shown the promise of aligning LLMs to be factually
consistent during generation, but such training procedure requires high-quality
human-annotated data, which can be extremely expensive to get in the clinical
domain. In this work, we propose a new pipeline using ChatGPT instead of human
experts to generate high-quality feedback data for improving factual
consistency in the clinical note summarization task. We focus specifically on
edit feedback because recent work discusses the shortcomings of human alignment
via preference feedback in complex situations (such as clinical NLP tasks that
require extensive expert knowledge), as well as some advantages of collecting
edit feedback from domain experts. In addition, although GPT has reached the
expert level in many clinical NLP tasks (e.g., USMLE QA), there is not much
previous work discussing whether GPT can generate expert-level edit feedback
for LMs in the clinical note summarization task. We hope to fill this gap.
Finally, our evaluations demonstrate the potential use of GPT edits in human
alignment, especially from a factuality perspective. | [
0.0935275331,
0.0198134929,
0.0267075133,
-0.0240855366,
-0.0231665354,
0.0104973968,
-0.0444599912,
-0.0133087737,
-0.025904214,
-0.0298974197,
-0.0318551846,
-0.0599901862,
0.0162509009,
-0.0022983323,
0.0415028408,
-0.0653467551,
0.0418566056,
0.0256056432,
0.0275320318,
0.0086276848,
0.0133643411,
0.0185952112,
-0.0272545423,
0.0440860912,
-0.0018631208,
-0.007569571,
0.0256285556,
-0.0078208558,
0.0475991592,
-0.0310374182,
-0.0115273856,
0.0526144691,
-0.0055833855,
0.0319555551,
0.0000018286,
-0.0444821902,
-0.0053785462,
0.0026258046,
-0.048228316,
0.0029070673,
0.0390598848,
-0.0420616977,
-0.0130622564,
0.0118173705,
-0.0307560563,
-0.0290778987,
0.0291159954,
0.0615792051,
0.0891423821,
0.1057548076,
-0.0052314196,
0.0172270145,
0.0244436972,
-0.0283882581,
0.0071449326,
-0.0027932203,
0.0333469994,
0.0349200368,
0.0189764854,
-0.0135689732,
0.0374523476,
0.0218421333,
-0.0086855805,
0.0003867847,
0.0284722745,
0.0481474027,
-0.0396965444,
-0.0078235799,
0.0260448121,
0.0542397313,
0.0178954192,
-0.0294487514,
0.0240475889,
0.0107554812,
0.0066749002,
-0.0065754093,
-0.0433928855,
0.0387983993,
-0.0459106527,
0.0182857476,
0.0262380037,
-0.0289994646,
0.0245931242,
0.0025304975,
0.002576072,
-0.0147914356,
0.0065614181,
-0.0364651084,
-0.0142919468,
0.0258560944,
-0.057684727,
-0.0656120479,
0.0204452332,
0.0124273747,
-0.0807567984,
-0.0079581849,
-0.0588001236,
-0.0155025348,
0.0609145761,
-0.0595322475,
0.0153570222,
0.0039554522,
-0.0104481205,
0.0192020852,
0.0034054623,
0.0283450782,
-0.0063541927,
0.0655667484,
-0.0568818562,
0.0171435978,
-0.0213607829,
-0.0175578929,
-0.0224772859,
0.0222794637,
-0.0167135168,
0.0176383983,
-0.0785469115,
-0.0057486733,
-0.0221988279,
0.0374095775,
0.0084283743,
0.0410268158,
-0.0477894247,
-0.0072137308,
-0.0234784223,
0.0044068168,
-0.0009716125,
-0.00475349,
0.0200031772,
-0.0333524235,
-0.0262738317,
0.0214305874,
-0.0093878033,
-0.0060132002,
0.0120950602,
0.0260850452,
-0.0209956542,
-0.0036502588,
0.003871449,
-0.0347258784,
-0.0188845769,
-0.0380209647,
-0.0061080805,
-0.0678223446,
0.0336526483,
-0.0194690824,
-0.0109735588,
-0.0414610729,
0.0069100522,
0.0167073943,
-0.0417960994,
0.0482526347,
-0.0628100634,
0.0050316518,
0.0259644743,
0.0079974597,
-0.0084059946,
0.0063379346,
0.0435262658,
-0.0176385026,
0.0042733899,
0.0300953276,
0.032306578,
0.0013510027,
0.0238903314,
-0.0337983668,
0.0221012291,
0.000728896,
-0.0073468778,
0.0979175195,
0.0378398895,
0.0883500278,
-0.0292330105,
-0.0128352111,
0.0627163649,
0.0211283118,
0.0082911467,
0.0200837795,
0.0410768092,
-0.0157722291,
0.0401490107,
0.0723010674,
-0.0377450138,
0.029753847,
0.0099898977,
0.0627077222,
0.0459813699,
-0.0021653592,
0.0037747398,
-0.0487506241,
-0.0317035951,
0.0257407315,
-0.0663198233,
-0.020397028,
-0.0086945146,
0.0061416086,
-0.0428118482,
0.037512891,
0.0395574644,
-0.0211324338,
-0.0137474742,
-0.059668079,
-0.0201291684,
0.0818851069,
0.0814015046,
-0.0421258397,
-0.0577668883,
-0.027030848,
-0.0192671716,
0.0454619117,
0.0619052202,
-0.0316643752,
-0.0269012675,
-0.0190687608,
0.0052391575,
0.0062659979,
0.0328114964,
-0.0229737777,
0.0075170468,
-0.038110245,
-0.0099209826,
-0.0067447159,
-0.0531986579,
0.0584207848,
-0.0410948023,
-0.0218910407,
-0.003201924,
-0.0123074995,
0.0154309869,
0.0173423346,
-0.0455961376,
0.0354518071,
0.0020077212,
-0.0155400103,
-0.0296163764,
0.01751405,
-0.0565819815,
-0.0659895167,
0.0390620716,
-0.0312158316,
-0.0295540094,
0.0016852499,
-0.0358243771,
-0.0366453268,
-0.0460990034,
-0.0651939362,
0.0166815836,
-0.0332290828,
0.02515845,
0.0674233213,
-0.021534238,
-0.0427251533,
0.0318895802,
-0.0242431965,
-0.0269216187,
0.0275387689,
-0.0101266475,
-0.0137740308,
-0.0368461274,
0.0034370266,
0.0104515627,
0.0382656083,
0.0066283639,
-0.010880745,
0.007617516,
-0.033144284,
-0.0466029905,
-0.1323518008,
0.0110176047,
-0.0242032781,
0.0088326344,
0.0771073848,
0.0249538571,
-0.0144879343,
0.0086831674,
-0.0449878387,
-0.0534669049,
0.0312459413,
0.0152521357,
0.0694088414,
0.0293292701,
0.0391200893,
-0.076805003,
0.0125672277,
-0.043728102,
0.0077227014,
0.0096896235,
-0.03291931,
-0.0382037051,
0.0148191536,
-0.0432804264,
-0.0094505716,
0.0145625984,
-0.007135266,
0.0116674621,
0.011397128,
0.0586003847,
0.0626581833,
0.0249449871,
0.0142410062,
0.0463657565,
0.0256391838,
-0.0072129797,
-0.0029069204,
-0.0224111062,
-0.0101785148,
0.0164576825,
-0.0250470601,
0.026487723,
0.0836297423,
0.0439463258,
-0.0016528787,
-0.0498118177,
-0.003518949,
-0.0132738557,
0.0150676314,
-0.0076330081,
-0.019214211,
-0.0558535121,
0.0178067107,
-0.0427331813,
-0.0142803127,
0.1369803846,
-0.0252097324,
0.0379803367,
-0.0711385608,
-0.0058529698,
-0.0460175015,
-0.022750048,
0.0152295511,
0.0236288924,
-0.0115114702,
0.0107515575,
-0.0304042846,
0.0090033449,
0.0436799042,
-0.0536741018,
0.0897510946,
-0.0548952892,
0.0206970833,
-0.0002226988,
-0.0391813926,
-0.0372747555,
-0.0249398146,
-0.0302067678,
0.0020864508,
-0.0005893534,
0.0007308417,
-0.0548460111,
-0.0114750061,
0.0182301421,
0.1125145182,
-0.0110443858,
-0.0233081989,
-0.0047832658,
0.0130614638,
0.05416134,
0.0228865184,
0.0133010289,
-0.0419857204,
0.0179339647,
0.0752257928,
0.0286667719,
0.0092403684,
0.0073991544,
-0.0181337148,
-0.0316955298,
-0.064134717,
0.0000804086,
0.0104536051,
0.0482321307,
-0.0421901271,
-0.0240267068,
0.1039532647,
0.0303246304,
-0.0426103324,
0.0119313439,
-0.0085771661,
0.0193433817,
-0.0075558391,
0.027703885,
-0.0689298511,
-0.0283158887,
-0.0101460507,
0.0413878299,
-0.0290911142,
-0.029919982,
0.0036774918,
-0.0686127469,
0.0258072987,
0.0196929984,
-0.0504767187,
-0.0320689119,
-0.0279684365,
0.0256770235,
-0.0355969146,
0.0239923038,
0.0241661351,
-0.0101369694,
0.0166593362,
0.0340490378,
-0.0665829629,
-0.0499865338,
-0.0018837875,
-0.0434179492,
0.0757956058,
0.0666615143,
0.0308434218,
0.0042288806,
0.0046701198,
0.0235255901,
0.0277417656,
0.0112276478,
0.0172047615,
0.081170544,
-0.0153919701,
0.0120125683,
-0.0351050012,
0.0406253934,
0.0203297269,
-0.02109088,
-0.0232152436,
0.0583559275,
-0.0372611731,
-0.0115883388,
-0.0333098918,
0.0563236885,
-0.0136846686,
0.0359097682,
0.0321238302,
0.0039656917,
-0.0027552363,
-0.0128528159,
0.0343470834,
-0.0369383842,
-0.0477150716,
0.0174090918,
-0.0216521453,
0.0071334569,
-0.1035426632,
-0.0481796898,
0.0367763564,
-0.023601817,
-0.0010846687,
-0.0013995853,
-0.0077787545,
-0.0223878901,
-0.0197920129,
0.0374309309,
0.0104161585,
-0.0130009986,
-0.0234784056,
-0.0420300029,
0.059576489,
-0.0362331271,
-0.0060589346,
-0.0056726206,
-0.0465263501,
-0.0182563923,
0.0075983228,
0.0787989646,
0.0209661089,
0.0589431524,
0.0248573981,
-0.0103871338,
0.03013389,
0.0400927328,
-0.0030457003,
0.012864097,
0.0070720236,
0.0092553385,
-0.0230525695,
0.016105419,
-0.0057881852,
0.0074716927,
-0.008005566,
0.0458467938,
0.0057833381,
-0.045488812,
0.0547377542,
0.0210301895,
0.0292673483,
-0.0197681393,
0.0094739459,
-0.0471877567,
0.0085290158,
-0.015715912,
0.0032403138,
-0.0148156593,
0.0152474521,
-0.0143065844,
0.0142301219,
-0.0318707712,
-0.0136091188,
-0.0835055038,
-0.0125768175,
-0.0417351425,
-0.0182376429,
-0.0155420527,
-0.0176931173,
-0.0010790779,
-0.0173159279,
-0.0403559543,
0.0036127332,
-0.0043042065,
0.0386229306,
-0.0063682874,
0.0524424724,
0.0201536547,
0.0091002416,
0.0080942502,
0.049958311,
-0.0737046227,
0.0128334332,
-0.0781528577,
0.0334010385,
0.0461198464,
-0.0135482093,
0.0485491306,
-0.0491590984,
0.0186659545,
-0.0110932849,
0.0385355838,
-0.0266912207,
0.0157678649,
-0.0123625938,
0.0163461659,
0.0325192437,
-0.0080822203,
0.0758517161,
-0.0123477094,
0.0662271157,
-0.0294942744,
-0.0211481266,
-0.0539091565,
-0.0585054643,
-0.0456367135,
-0.032413628,
-0.0472428873,
-0.0295715742,
-0.0782602057,
-0.0295659713,
0.0231035948,
0.0353583619,
-0.0136472862,
-0.0454940572,
0.032527063,
0.0251932144,
-0.0236702655,
-0.0207838453,
-0.0149454419,
0.0228119735,
0.0195368007,
0.018189121,
-0.0101065161,
-5.681532274e-33,
-0.0318530723,
-0.0304607078,
0.0322686397,
-0.0026126781,
-0.0548663251,
0.0001651821,
-0.0474971496,
0.0002409271,
0.0172620285,
0.039734643,
-0.0495546646,
0.0149272121,
0.0001731291,
0.021275619,
0.012944784,
-0.0080238432,
0.0430642776,
-0.0106185358,
-0.0556478202,
0.0296282787,
-0.0310112797,
0.0181978494,
0.0760762691,
-0.0642679855,
0.0513415821,
-0.0032226082,
-0.0086283144,
0.0181183126,
-0.052943822,
0.0536849536,
-0.0232686233,
0.0182949528,
0.044954434,
-0.0317924544,
-0.0267782696,
-0.0418722108,
-0.0280662961,
-0.0064361258,
0.0459129624,
-0.0342628248,
-0.0469937176,
-0.0328092687,
0.0465336666,
-0.0235712845,
-0.0189775247,
0.0002391113,
0.0199444778,
-0.0493164286,
0.0021251203,
-0.0133414259,
-0.043747887,
0.0366029479,
0.0126963146,
-0.0195255466,
-0.0204370879,
-0.0013592237,
-0.0237121172,
-0.0120556802,
-0.0305884071,
0.0091542443,
0.0256301221,
0.0344866067,
-0.0045423438,
-0.0222859439,
-0.0287554488,
0.076538749,
0.0033714534,
-0.0010714551,
-0.0541143976,
0.020840155,
-0.0613437742,
0.0105775623,
0.0513833202,
0.0695084482,
0.0206791013,
0.0244640969,
-0.0358842313,
0.0520911999,
-0.0830125585,
0.028771745,
0.0139303636,
-0.0371594504,
-0.0367663167,
-0.0000547965,
-0.0123049999,
0.0173624698,
-0.0010296344,
-0.008317546,
-0.0055503384,
0.0186513048,
-0.0105200587,
-0.0004379246,
-0.0335881896,
0.0183762573,
0.0426365212,
-0.0682966188,
-0.0097156214,
0.0179613661,
-0.0395764373,
-0.0380273163,
-0.0351765603,
0.014828397,
0.0317624435,
0.027404042,
0.0442970544,
0.017687479,
0.0480163731,
-0.0253126081,
-0.0401561707,
0.0259252284,
0.0116797509,
0.0365141332,
-0.0266939718,
-0.0036267755,
0.023059465,
0.0126114031,
-0.0031073666,
0.0453859642,
-0.012513225,
0.000120352,
-0.0504026897,
0.013209817,
0.0053521344,
0.0140462713,
-0.048995629,
0.03932954,
-0.0142200738,
0.0266503617,
0.0105788792,
-0.0588756874,
-0.0077825268,
-0.0122525049,
2.562e-7,
0.0747284666,
0.0565932728,
0.0697095767,
-0.0314742178,
0.0031047843,
0.0280111488,
-0.015575706,
0.0335265324,
0.0284377858,
-0.0411174484,
0.0585227124,
0.0374509245,
0.0464455932,
0.0343882442,
-0.0859564245,
-0.018229669,
-0.1024427488,
-0.0128141707,
-0.0186926741,
-0.0619849525,
0.0472729765,
0.06440714,
-0.0412717648,
-0.0345118493,
0.017014252,
-0.0124982279,
0.053193368,
0.0077237887,
-0.0475216173,
0.0558133237,
0.0659322515,
-0.0087744193,
0.016734302,
0.0210737791,
-0.0170339253,
-0.0340612605,
0.0261133946,
0.0851528719,
-0.0134557663,
-0.0053930068,
0.0072783213,
0.0159439873,
0.0452940986,
-0.0149146598,
0.0306926239,
-0.06710428,
-0.0092300568,
-0.0385890007,
-0.0156951193,
0.0067356657,
0.0346112885,
-0.0321473442,
-0.032450784,
0.0617650934,
0.0144150164,
0.0553412549,
-0.0362064168,
-0.0495069958,
-0.0632898435,
0.0239353497,
-0.0281246305,
-0.0156615041,
0.0325171761,
-0.0171333291,
-0.0122521333,
-0.073891148,
-0.0023168363,
2.462075902e-34,
0.0598041527,
0.0034072413,
0.0335298106,
0.0191197526,
0.0265482794,
-0.0108939707,
0.027957065,
0.0057352674,
0.0241615828,
-0.0342752971,
-0.0200426355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20003v1 | Early Detection of Depression and Eating Disorders in Spanish: UNSL at MentalRiskES 2023 | 2023-10-30T20:38:31 | 2023-10-30T20:38:31 | Horacio Thompson, Marcelo Errecalde | cs.CL | cs.CL | MentalRiskES is a novel challenge that proposes to solve problems related to
early risk detection for the Spanish language. The objective is to detect, as
soon as possible, Telegram users who show signs of mental disorders considering
different tasks. Task 1 involved the users' detection of eating disorders, Task
2 focused on depression detection, and Task 3 aimed at detecting an unknown
disorder. These tasks were divided into subtasks, each one defining a
resolution approach. Our research group participated in subtask A for Tasks 1
and 2: a binary classification problem that evaluated whether the users were
positive or negative. To solve these tasks, we proposed models based on
Transformers followed by a decision policy according to criteria defined by an
early detection framework. One of the models presented an extended vocabulary
with important words for each task to be solved. In addition, we applied a
decision policy based on the history of predictions that the model performs
during user evaluation. For Tasks 1 and 2, we obtained the second-best
performance according to rankings based on classification and latency,
demonstrating the effectiveness and consistency of our approaches for solving
early detection problems in the Spanish language. | [
0.042130921,
0.0117456941,
-0.0276016071,
-0.0499199256,
-0.0001424642,
0.0405312926,
-0.0023750546,
0.0414175093,
0.0617261156,
-0.0415457413,
0.0272308495,
-0.005948327,
-0.0523465835,
-0.0056712907,
-0.0580435544,
-0.0573708676,
0.0110308267,
0.0291148461,
0.0288648475,
-0.0055508516,
0.0161813553,
-0.0040310887,
-0.0044383919,
0.032395184,
-0.0108161215,
-0.0044169757,
0.0445875078,
-0.0373249985,
0.0324780457,
-0.0673970208,
0.0459416695,
0.0487909093,
-0.0427627042,
0.0208761655,
0.0000022038,
-0.0360449776,
-0.0443407595,
-0.0179276038,
0.0256701801,
-0.1161370054,
0.0483446382,
-0.0426196828,
0.014928096,
0.0278633498,
-0.0678318292,
-0.0215519518,
0.0562225878,
0.0719515979,
0.0751388893,
0.0335987806,
-0.0424381718,
-0.0161260795,
-0.0246203262,
0.003955733,
-0.0052073244,
-0.0099305548,
0.0485519506,
-0.0492591634,
0.0037613392,
-0.0419046767,
-0.0015161426,
0.0030094017,
-0.0214080811,
0.0460416004,
-0.0489352345,
-0.0088077672,
0.0180586427,
-0.0756169111,
-0.0069719027,
0.0179325379,
-0.0218309853,
0.0246063713,
0.0385297164,
-0.0211676452,
-0.0068009049,
0.0079874303,
0.0258151554,
-0.0409277901,
-0.0395642258,
0.0006066674,
0.0328537337,
0.0323108472,
0.0125945183,
0.0273194574,
-0.0151288435,
0.0767059848,
-0.0190559234,
-0.0344103649,
0.0251313653,
0.0209279582,
-0.0103927469,
-0.0457840338,
0.0655834228,
0.0374486148,
-0.0290518608,
-0.0126688536,
0.0024291864,
-0.0984074473,
0.0164731126,
-0.0722681955,
-0.0251429304,
0.0317113996,
-0.0468210019,
-0.0186194927,
0.0069985217,
0.0538903475,
0.0031555283,
0.0137121966,
-0.0353304483,
0.0221744701,
-0.0616420768,
0.0386120044,
-0.0464751795,
-0.0010451329,
0.0674879029,
0.0197437517,
-0.0894702598,
0.0101573355,
-0.0430946164,
-0.0652022213,
0.0254702326,
0.0043466878,
0.0040497254,
0.0428063199,
-0.0086107953,
0.037662778,
-0.0232126061,
-0.0126335835,
-0.0264405571,
0.0019380539,
0.0562966838,
-0.0069184322,
-0.0050778701,
-0.0507677607,
0.0508543067,
0.0448781885,
0.021242775,
-0.0543521233,
-0.026761286,
-0.0162328165,
-0.0255665109,
-0.0440619811,
-0.0112175466,
-0.032988634,
-0.0194424912,
0.0403194241,
0.016304465,
0.0155059136,
0.0195205901,
-0.0085490495,
-0.0117310574,
0.0636517778,
-0.0095157055,
0.012183072,
0.0184934232,
0.0164518524,
-0.0364016332,
0.0745509341,
-0.0161572266,
0.0523480177,
0.0180173274,
-0.0315286256,
0.0185785573,
0.0343074352,
-0.005447079,
-0.003981126,
0.0238439236,
-0.0334237963,
-0.0722231269,
0.0023704544,
-0.0108536053,
-0.0002718786,
-0.0017754826,
0.0618886426,
0.0399568565,
0.0687237233,
0.0354002304,
0.033206135,
-0.0009190956,
0.0236258302,
-0.0345510654,
-0.035859406,
-0.0250689555,
0.0065657841,
-0.0433467031,
-0.0430456735,
-0.04271942,
0.0324412882,
-0.0228590462,
-0.0395721979,
-0.0228535384,
-0.0192018393,
0.0297874417,
0.0128601501,
0.031482622,
0.0084171705,
-0.0099734729,
0.0473372266,
0.0053213574,
0.023875935,
-0.0479190238,
-0.0814584643,
0.016771175,
0.0641867965,
0.0121305576,
-0.0433992334,
-0.0052474351,
-0.0186868329,
0.0036796236,
-0.0289124046,
-0.010703112,
0.0263536647,
0.016194785,
0.0071616308,
-0.0205501951,
0.0985628515,
0.0153364334,
-0.0500728972,
0.0015231735,
0.0602746606,
-0.0346090458,
0.0336963795,
-0.0214595571,
0.0365449563,
0.0311421715,
-0.0031957645,
0.0370876268,
0.038934119,
0.0428600013,
0.0000165529,
0.0313925669,
-0.0234508105,
-0.0067079361,
-0.0129448855,
-0.0563881546,
0.0176805127,
0.0111800004,
-0.00954236,
0.0202599224,
-0.0293287579,
-0.0114492113,
0.0818756744,
-0.0133525636,
-0.0024046912,
0.0209193639,
-0.061386425,
0.0204624273,
-0.0157899298,
0.0062691481,
-0.0273787733,
0.0268620644,
-0.0091569088,
0.0416808873,
-0.0385489352,
0.0440556109,
-0.025696177,
-0.1078935713,
-0.0242524669,
-0.0198519453,
-0.0529044382,
-0.0058452873,
-0.01170965,
0.0199068245,
0.0247822236,
0.0567206331,
0.0099771982,
-0.0166643802,
-0.09405379,
-0.0027693606,
-0.0225260891,
-0.0004159941,
0.0076241316,
-0.0177095588,
-0.0204301924,
-0.0331581719,
-0.0015707242,
0.0464200564,
0.0555533804,
0.037530303,
0.0066736601,
0.0135388812,
-0.0158390496,
-0.0119833341,
-0.0026532935,
-0.0330793001,
0.0087129492,
0.0327002741,
-0.0857834965,
-0.0290828198,
-0.0166055746,
-0.030249292,
0.0012373466,
0.0259188898,
-0.0786867067,
-0.0212453809,
0.0033991442,
0.0398348235,
0.0304358955,
0.0313405357,
0.0931421444,
0.0317346193,
0.0395413674,
0.0163699687,
0.0007651984,
-0.0522267707,
-0.0135806501,
-0.0483525731,
-0.059186969,
0.0158642139,
0.0698811412,
0.0181482993,
-0.0171943698,
-0.0478401184,
-0.0045187213,
-0.0278740637,
0.0011854642,
-0.0062135132,
0.0231675655,
-0.0037001946,
0.0477673262,
0.0056112683,
-0.0384098403,
0.0612469278,
0.0541609116,
0.023969844,
-0.0516907424,
-0.0700808764,
-0.0012749395,
0.007108652,
0.0276986789,
0.0402732715,
0.013456461,
-0.0123968292,
0.0110533712,
-0.0420288034,
0.0214693304,
-0.0482507497,
0.0469410159,
-0.0184200555,
-0.0131712751,
0.0298753493,
-0.0478611775,
-0.0287090242,
-0.0642571226,
-0.0493578762,
-0.0408465564,
0.0137690678,
-0.0162237305,
-0.0878562257,
0.0223597791,
-0.0403284989,
0.0272549801,
-0.0121593978,
-0.0412080102,
0.0260297246,
-0.0230288152,
0.0201506317,
-0.0368329994,
0.0183501691,
-0.0609794855,
0.0344185717,
0.0434250385,
-0.0346327722,
0.0021599799,
-0.0263872091,
0.0353776738,
0.0289571006,
-0.0263210535,
-0.0214025006,
0.003055841,
-0.0169858392,
0.0044962484,
-0.0104519976,
0.0719311759,
0.0088769104,
-0.0438626371,
0.0058155917,
-0.0359155089,
-0.0328098498,
-0.0039355936,
0.016436426,
-0.0182771683,
-0.0083216857,
-0.0179745723,
0.0269548595,
-0.0567678176,
-0.0219277963,
0.0101333633,
-0.0075975866,
0.0233891141,
-0.011966249,
0.0081220856,
0.0155218774,
-0.0141924974,
0.0056593018,
-0.0598685034,
-0.0301965829,
-0.0584086664,
-0.0146496007,
-0.0233193394,
0.0124567272,
-0.0481153093,
-0.0310141146,
0.0564826168,
-0.0124750873,
-0.0010320222,
0.0177556537,
0.0643353686,
-0.0102778831,
-0.0310095493,
-0.0388763919,
0.0287817325,
0.0061450107,
-0.0189979449,
0.0600043237,
0.0200493988,
-0.0028675364,
-0.0751728117,
0.0102095054,
-0.0296104271,
-0.0019628266,
-0.0010511077,
0.1032823622,
-0.0543537885,
-0.0371785797,
-0.0248116795,
0.0127867768,
0.0540822521,
0.0387470461,
-0.012501752,
-0.092662625,
-0.022568116,
0.0364514478,
-0.0078785522,
0.0061631366,
-0.0577281862,
-0.002886266,
-0.0516072251,
-0.0994376838,
-0.0599336848,
-0.0055608884,
-0.0047606286,
0.0257487334,
0.0009261593,
-0.0355340615,
-0.0112567134,
0.0287837368,
-0.0448662415,
0.0446231067,
0.0722885579,
0.0424003266,
-0.0905450657,
0.0222864319,
0.0045960727,
-0.0001356429,
-0.0270326044,
0.0200558361,
-0.0972363502,
-0.0155828986,
0.0439853556,
0.0385736823,
0.0299981758,
-0.0374771059,
-0.0291097742,
-0.0610022172,
0.051664494,
0.0239236914,
0.0133811543,
-0.0201140624,
0.0398978628,
-0.0263597257,
-0.0181439724,
0.0417201705,
0.019130487,
0.0616699867,
-0.0048292475,
-0.0495341159,
-0.0632442385,
0.0019518905,
-0.0119573073,
0.0043098787,
0.0808784366,
-0.0417960659,
-0.0851496309,
-0.0109193008,
-0.0462183803,
0.044297304,
-0.0153762,
0.017113477,
-0.0255836137,
0.0201701913,
0.025538465,
-0.0226333272,
-0.0197559353,
-0.031863533,
-0.0593473278,
-0.0100434441,
0.0484383479,
0.0117455069,
0.0372667089,
0.0344271399,
0.0367328934,
0.0089106392,
0.0010933434,
0.0274206251,
-0.0011290433,
-0.0103649348,
0.0698348209,
-0.0052616722,
0.0350009315,
0.015546253,
0.0432124473,
-0.0027515541,
-0.0457302332,
-0.0341833383,
-0.0397846811,
0.0173871219,
-0.0027601395,
0.0567677803,
-0.0099978438,
-0.0069708717,
-0.0294275098,
0.0399322733,
-0.0562564954,
-0.0216416754,
0.0394775532,
-0.0203478914,
0.002745783,
-0.0275267884,
0.058599662,
-0.0520753935,
-0.0116386227,
0.0158002544,
-0.0581632704,
-0.0162377227,
0.0094755189,
0.0116013801,
-0.018571401,
-0.0330632068,
-0.0159855951,
-0.0489932895,
-0.0566657595,
0.0432092063,
-0.0664632767,
-0.0116058979,
-0.01038191,
0.0433025919,
0.0435369797,
0.0075974003,
-0.0065459628,
-0.0573081858,
-0.0127478074,
-0.0174462013,
0.0048134411,
-0.0558730774,
-6.028776612e-33,
0.0302596688,
-0.0458422899,
-0.0039834301,
-0.0044347756,
0.0092773056,
-0.0091240974,
0.0224391241,
0.0344486088,
0.0348576531,
0.0314164944,
0.0268473588,
0.0492705964,
0.0020182361,
-0.0082722632,
0.0064582848,
-0.0130824391,
0.0283549614,
-0.0016786483,
-0.0162357911,
-0.0063653858,
0.0187963694,
0.05910898,
0.0514529422,
-0.0641372725,
0.0038465234,
0.0542671904,
-0.0205996465,
0.0238568503,
0.0413781479,
0.0538234189,
-0.0046382728,
0.0781843215,
0.0487237573,
-0.0458711684,
0.0097220466,
0.0313536227,
-0.0307070203,
-0.0759155452,
-0.0024256089,
0.0344306007,
0.0035363017,
-0.0099004917,
0.0047691171,
-0.0168466866,
-0.0251971371,
-0.0076168068,
0.0588467605,
-0.0229503606,
0.0513376482,
-0.0083997501,
0.0044054817,
0.0082546258,
0.0071773371,
-0.0017282175,
0.0491331555,
0.0942424759,
-0.0330937207,
-0.0175686926,
-0.0464354046,
0.0295924861,
-0.0024249682,
-0.0398418568,
0.0191080589,
-0.0098239034,
-0.0210008975,
0.033717148,
0.0016848656,
-0.0317060463,
0.0160181057,
-0.0188549459,
-0.0088488758,
0.0635046363,
0.0379489958,
-0.0124351801,
0.0552821457,
-0.0491375066,
-0.0329694562,
0.0238681603,
0.0102558918,
0.0220869444,
0.024708841,
-0.0177274626,
-0.0334333442,
-0.0326783322,
0.0048328387,
0.0084731504,
-0.0190158579,
-0.0452539548,
-0.0005064795,
0.0038877507,
-0.0137888407,
-0.0077723875,
0.0021543051,
-0.0281573702,
0.0027164873,
-0.0113014095,
0.0014396602,
0.0239999238,
0.0201928746,
0.0275349449,
-0.0212633722,
-0.016590612,
0.0108753992,
0.0196319595,
0.0407743603,
-0.0034260738,
0.0306902621,
-0.0025844609,
-0.0355758741,
-0.0046930541,
0.0340289921,
0.051442001,
0.0106215216,
0.0879046619,
-0.0111524733,
0.0382554382,
-0.003357616,
0.0672328994,
0.0215035155,
0.0147276474,
-0.0583696403,
0.0200179629,
0.0018037917,
0.0075352392,
-0.0110332277,
-0.0248971507,
-0.0426057838,
0.0048998273,
0.0359883234,
-0.0620398596,
-0.0024739529,
-0.0267943703,
2.877e-7,
0.0454668179,
0.0438774526,
-0.026173126,
0.0231662262,
0.0124160126,
0.0189707074,
0.0129993223,
0.029392289,
0.0249292087,
0.0431857258,
0.0219483804,
-0.001741574,
0.0184631813,
0.0869410262,
-0.0205769464,
-0.0462817661,
-0.0266308822,
-0.0263302159,
-0.0422968566,
0.0273866765,
0.0738184825,
0.0617400594,
0.0214620195,
-0.0432285853,
0.0012258191,
-0.0156111838,
0.0387725383,
-0.0161840264,
0.040193487,
0.0009343086,
0.081930168,
0.0143631008,
0.0473804884,
0.0196232349,
-0.0087901838,
-0.0244128834,
-0.0196379106,
0.0060709827,
-0.0333148949,
0.0358994342,
0.0154730026,
0.0197509043,
0.0005433405,
-0.0018907356,
0.0370204933,
-0.1215086505,
-0.0352055468,
0.0006604624,
0.0021539747,
-0.0593869984,
0.0331651308,
-0.016938597,
-0.0184790902,
0.0797843859,
0.0392607115,
0.0083826194,
0.0251502153,
-0.0648528114,
0.0166157465,
0.0386986658,
-0.0220764503,
-0.0413984284,
-0.0146699287,
0.0285866559,
0.0266890414,
-0.0657270923,
0.0336860381,
2.347683542e-34,
0.0013452765,
0.0296886098,
-0.0152034378,
-0.0157022011,
0.0132908421,
0.0275070593,
0.0138264205,
0.0128482413,
0.0128534781,
-0.0412217043,
0.0096856421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19998v1 | Generative retrieval-augmented ontologic graph and multi-agent strategies for interpretive large language model-based materials design | 2023-10-30T20:31:50 | 2023-10-30T20:31:50 | Markus J. Buehler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cond-mat.dis-nn, cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, physics.app-ph | Transformer neural networks show promising capabilities, in particular for
uses in materials analysis, design and manufacturing, including their capacity
to work effectively with both human language, symbols, code, and numerical
data. Here we explore the use of large language models (LLMs) as a tool that
can support engineering analysis of materials, applied to retrieving key
information about subject areas, developing research hypotheses, discovery of
mechanistic relationships across disparate areas of knowledge, and writing and
executing simulation codes for active knowledge generation based on physical
ground truths. When used as sets of AI agents with specific features,
capabilities, and instructions, LLMs can provide powerful problem solution
strategies for applications in analysis and design problems. Our experiments
focus on using a fine-tuned model, MechGPT, developed based on training data in
the mechanics of materials domain. We first affirm how finetuning endows LLMs
with reasonable understanding of domain knowledge. However, when queried
outside the context of learned matter, LLMs can have difficulty to recall
correct information. We show how this can be addressed using
retrieval-augmented Ontological Knowledge Graph strategies that discern how the
model understands what concepts are important and how they are related.
Illustrated for a use case of relating distinct areas of knowledge - here,
music and proteins - such strategies can also provide an interpretable graph
structure with rich information at the node, edge and subgraph level. We
discuss nonlinear sampling strategies and agent-based modeling applied to
complex question answering, code generation and execution in the context of
automated force field development from actively learned Density Functional
Theory (DFT) modeling, and data analysis. | [
-0.0134389447,
0.0437772758,
-0.0534540266,
0.0541956946,
-0.0204800609,
-0.0413834378,
-0.0018286556,
0.0108621959,
0.0179106891,
0.032888595,
-0.0455322452,
-0.0098250452,
-0.0552064739,
0.0518378392,
-0.0108850123,
0.0183019657,
0.0052680145,
-0.0309912767,
0.0092179198,
-0.0336675048,
-0.0280997939,
-0.0212446973,
0.0048004789,
0.046386186,
-0.0170844402,
-0.0004217853,
-0.0339189172,
-0.0241557136,
-0.0045013879,
-0.0129323062,
-0.012797093,
0.0470608659,
0.0325846821,
0.021874832,
0.0000023647,
-0.0256100707,
-0.0135635063,
0.0521818548,
-0.009589972,
-0.0249015167,
0.0339162536,
-0.064208582,
-0.0078467568,
-0.0178344157,
-0.0364549905,
-0.0224597733,
0.0312163737,
0.0171058737,
0.0013815769,
-0.0105688311,
-0.0031901097,
-0.0299974661,
0.0713573918,
0.0061592986,
0.0402699001,
-0.0075410232,
0.0226419251,
0.0574893989,
0.0788133815,
0.0327227525,
-0.0176332425,
0.0545574278,
0.0388163403,
-0.0229636654,
0.0810517743,
0.0031010457,
-0.0190867186,
0.018786177,
0.0268655587,
0.0808649659,
0.0468427651,
-0.0286184773,
-0.0192497876,
-0.0318502448,
-0.0287746321,
0.0843206346,
-0.0603327043,
-0.0035274571,
0.0041195173,
-0.0107996473,
-0.0261902455,
-0.026260715,
0.0365182757,
0.0113887815,
-0.0357760526,
0.0597761199,
-0.0219195392,
-0.0106807295,
0.0088144336,
-0.0175532643,
-0.0079116235,
0.0193659887,
-0.0004512128,
0.0433939621,
-0.0045385994,
-0.0003240569,
0.0500114448,
-0.0328482687,
0.0083013773,
-0.0440022051,
0.015554212,
0.0177073516,
-0.0000047562,
0.0161827467,
-0.0478506014,
0.0377783515,
-0.0289196186,
0.0371627547,
-0.0685039908,
-0.0295690112,
-0.0937529653,
-0.0522369668,
-0.0404097177,
0.0513246879,
-0.0319073461,
-0.0429109894,
-0.0110125318,
0.0297786109,
-0.0291183721,
-0.0278415941,
-0.000512212,
0.0201532338,
0.0061433427,
-0.0172071643,
-0.0508361161,
0.0164260138,
0.015436532,
0.0318034887,
-0.0016847221,
-0.0146912849,
-0.0246927235,
-0.0097510498,
-0.0078585958,
0.0155865448,
0.0074888919,
0.1268002242,
-0.009016009,
0.0035543807,
-0.0124465274,
-0.0526846163,
0.0120945852,
-0.0244610868,
0.0542303212,
-0.027861312,
0.052594088,
0.023141589,
0.006017867,
-0.0890495107,
0.0062605198,
-0.0405445024,
-0.0264115743,
0.0899200439,
0.0384839922,
0.0004687561,
0.022792086,
-0.0086670583,
-0.0118563185,
0.0288823992,
0.0074717184,
0.0385413095,
-0.0147031629,
0.0057093212,
-0.0157732014,
0.0014995649,
0.0253164787,
-0.0399764925,
-0.0195137709,
-0.0267014336,
-0.025146028,
0.0484598726,
-0.0121704396,
0.0050586369,
-0.0148288039,
0.0257391389,
0.0344480947,
0.0377057269,
0.0296810977,
0.0554978438,
0.0119863842,
0.0523996055,
0.0131410388,
-0.036512401,
0.0176324565,
0.0460878313,
0.0082469732,
-0.0141865313,
0.0030132094,
-0.0064409957,
-0.0013133362,
-0.0525177382,
0.0042827339,
0.0000111555,
0.0327808559,
0.015072464,
0.0894345418,
0.0080021452,
-0.0225644857,
0.041971039,
0.0136126438,
-0.0190274157,
-0.0253310688,
-0.0202089716,
0.0095933853,
0.051687628,
0.0537785254,
-0.0720743835,
-0.0512994975,
0.0532862768,
-0.0453585833,
0.0050745443,
-0.0036413292,
-0.0195646323,
-0.0287084039,
-0.011225163,
-0.0095449379,
-0.0274916179,
0.0118890265,
0.0185974129,
-0.0429005064,
-0.0496602841,
-0.0065542487,
-0.0183363035,
-0.0498390719,
0.0030461759,
-0.029143706,
0.0157458577,
0.0483352505,
0.0090970965,
0.0497521609,
0.0362791531,
0.0153274722,
0.0183418989,
0.0765113458,
-0.0723835155,
-0.0384386778,
-0.0335952118,
0.0037139764,
0.0314034522,
0.0213924423,
-0.0447479784,
0.0487819016,
-0.0433505401,
0.0009636797,
-0.0559576564,
0.0617059208,
-0.0065775388,
0.0365532674,
-0.0162311848,
-0.0271768998,
-0.0228344183,
0.0127717033,
-0.0429756045,
0.0344096906,
0.0165825151,
-0.003530103,
0.005298961,
0.0128366612,
0.033423923,
-0.0157378502,
-0.0063422234,
0.0470049828,
0.0066453074,
0.0221145358,
0.0669618025,
-0.0288075916,
0.0224034525,
-0.0361799374,
0.0022286575,
0.002607821,
0.0231453199,
-0.0248746499,
0.0166785661,
-0.0192389712,
0.0008479781,
0.0147453174,
0.0211389363,
0.0532452278,
-0.0167444795,
-0.0617442615,
0.0399374813,
0.0251457859,
-0.0317444392,
0.0017332687,
-0.0271117929,
-0.0601439811,
0.053089723,
0.0403269827,
0.0251252055,
-0.0329622515,
0.0407957919,
-0.0105186049,
0.0183595661,
-0.0455549955,
-0.0491366349,
0.0366776325,
-0.0439341515,
0.0365966745,
0.0552126095,
-0.0479989722,
0.0793606788,
0.0519456454,
-0.0214967243,
-0.0405225307,
-0.003222035,
-0.0509790778,
0.0155857187,
-0.0104006324,
0.0006868488,
0.008837115,
0.0293822549,
0.019461615,
-0.0079644881,
-0.0326816477,
0.0425071456,
-0.0050709532,
-0.0269985553,
0.0000467264,
0.0007168608,
0.0450754166,
0.0258344095,
0.0149225118,
0.024942195,
0.0884833559,
0.0078363568,
0.0201588105,
-0.0022227329,
-0.0085698897,
-0.0282900799,
0.0993292928,
0.024577558,
0.0111283083,
0.0510411598,
0.0281129405,
-0.0362578221,
0.0032654949,
0.0370627046,
-0.0292693786,
-0.0135091245,
-0.0462963022,
0.0182613395,
0.0311281793,
-0.0314665735,
-0.0183331016,
0.0618931614,
-0.0016731179,
0.0772475228,
-0.0079541076,
-0.0239095334,
-0.0157782752,
0.0321628675,
0.0538128801,
-0.0267612915,
-0.0076405397,
-0.0087654311,
-0.0554033667,
0.0668163598,
0.0262001399,
-0.0116629424,
0.01806546,
-0.0106882602,
0.0041173911,
0.0056268121,
-0.0137254987,
-0.0203634575,
-0.0795694292,
-0.0074934349,
0.0347722247,
0.0096238879,
0.0254882667,
-0.0027797136,
-0.0208656825,
-0.0661500767,
-0.006067771,
0.0255184695,
0.0313070007,
-0.0399385057,
0.0096339639,
0.0412157811,
0.0107987504,
-0.0095975799,
0.0371626988,
-0.0530834496,
0.0090000592,
-0.033850424,
0.0340726525,
-0.0178797338,
-0.0352799892,
0.0165955573,
-0.0826092362,
0.0699833781,
-0.0153459106,
-0.0362703018,
-0.0613733307,
-0.0287157074,
-0.0183105525,
-0.0248692818,
-0.0175146293,
0.034161333,
0.001826977,
-0.0220835041,
0.0348981917,
0.0155843776,
-0.0483963862,
0.0272308961,
0.0086286217,
0.0058515742,
0.0247129556,
0.0231419504,
-0.0541576371,
-0.0395022146,
0.0229781996,
0.0272842627,
0.0354261361,
-0.0401973091,
-0.0188058186,
0.0648652762,
-0.0062427837,
-0.0335264951,
0.0422583148,
-0.0350176618,
-0.0542309061,
-0.0317856558,
0.0944324583,
-0.0430161916,
0.0174809564,
-0.0361004993,
-0.0472255088,
0.0024247454,
0.036390055,
-0.0184673462,
-0.0264404584,
-0.0458148904,
-0.0245530307,
0.0282459185,
-0.0258885454,
-0.0438640118,
0.0120903635,
-0.0063142669,
0.0178772043,
-0.0103298789,
0.0323125236,
0.0000704097,
0.0108635221,
-0.0088682836,
-0.0234945659,
0.0665035397,
-0.0108369123,
-0.0813188702,
0.0188191161,
-0.0218203738,
0.0060196123,
0.0074660727,
-0.0503017455,
0.0674941838,
-0.1150775477,
-0.0371571779,
0.0244697593,
-0.0045451419,
-0.0485874861,
0.0017365115,
0.0460349172,
0.0221960284,
0.0409382284,
-0.0220298227,
-0.0478695258,
0.0578006357,
0.0402030423,
-0.0890035629,
-0.02684463,
-0.0218758155,
-0.0070700776,
-0.0123141911,
-0.0106552169,
-0.0399952233,
0.0525580905,
0.0216875803,
0.0217410028,
-0.0139281629,
-0.0800318196,
0.0584145039,
0.0380131304,
0.0005059998,
0.0268829502,
0.0107752122,
-0.0483619459,
0.0173595659,
0.0375968143,
0.0131186927,
-0.039202746,
-0.0198333729,
0.0229914673,
-0.0436828658,
-0.0157853011,
-0.0603447743,
0.0410495549,
0.0513032563,
0.0103388848,
0.0557393655,
-0.0036084664,
0.0158525705,
0.043129012,
0.0040554679,
0.0178698283,
0.0228516422,
-0.0388109535,
0.0793650374,
-0.010493625,
0.0553314313,
0.0330588669,
0.0185849052,
-0.062047489,
0.0165626332,
-0.0544846356,
-0.1091985554,
-0.0282980502,
-0.0156867914,
0.0457115099,
0.0369634852,
-0.0014553536,
-0.0671659485,
-0.0009155234,
0.0041004978,
0.0443084128,
0.0006095618,
-0.0190251004,
0.0327051729,
0.0298659168,
0.0224571843,
-0.0597921498,
0.0455370285,
0.0170287918,
-0.0225113258,
-0.0390103608,
-0.0420758575,
-0.0163455904,
-0.0032348884,
0.0265000649,
-0.0151938377,
-0.0348922461,
-0.0050446959,
-0.0656128675,
-0.0295635872,
0.0308557302,
0.069945842,
-0.0210218914,
-0.0383091196,
0.0368750989,
0.0864731148,
-0.0009706322,
-0.0357742049,
-0.0172517393,
0.0031694113,
-0.0430958569,
-0.0198037382,
0.0001557416,
-6.314887896e-33,
-0.0327741243,
-0.0165790338,
0.0099490918,
0.0429059975,
-0.0417667553,
-0.0149092339,
-0.0576982051,
-0.0508969426,
-0.0196620096,
0.0322286338,
-0.0126730846,
-0.0031483416,
-0.0137371235,
-0.0102840364,
0.0397812612,
-0.0186625626,
0.0049591018,
0.0196049809,
0.0274961833,
0.0372417122,
0.032477174,
0.0196877364,
0.0037345055,
-0.0597939715,
0.0190082528,
0.0012019918,
0.0402249172,
-0.0069050919,
-0.0290427022,
0.0613930151,
-0.0465548672,
0.0524991043,
-0.0258043427,
-0.0546737313,
0.0031182528,
-0.0365573056,
-0.0847383589,
-0.0358331427,
-0.0190289654,
0.0099875238,
0.0254808236,
-0.0270691365,
0.0457296409,
0.0113224844,
-0.0486227237,
-0.0037475883,
0.0560148992,
-0.0382870883,
-0.0072816857,
-0.0558633357,
-0.0839662179,
-0.0210233871,
-0.0054513863,
-0.0011084811,
0.0183741227,
-0.0318412855,
-0.0233228374,
0.0318417512,
-0.0490093045,
0.0459924899,
0.0156859569,
-0.0135454908,
0.0153420968,
0.0412735902,
0.0628401041,
0.0085865539,
0.0189324711,
0.0091353217,
-0.0013653518,
-0.0342390761,
0.0086076297,
0.0731759593,
0.021252634,
0.0209656283,
0.0102878883,
-0.0134101966,
-0.1076116413,
-0.0231460873,
-0.0006496672,
0.0439755321,
0.0517978035,
0.0458366461,
0.0484851971,
-0.0316106901,
-0.0157877896,
0.0330690816,
0.0018113618,
-0.035326086,
-0.0353798531,
-0.0254039448,
-0.0413963646,
-0.0394404866,
0.0161003154,
-0.0969545022,
0.0332133211,
0.0130167026,
-0.0044548917,
0.0225716177,
-0.0188759193,
0.0206914991,
-0.0600653924,
-0.0202824455,
-0.0259922072,
-0.0180779248,
0.0145829078,
0.0276621711,
-0.0392243788,
0.0365808755,
0.0159556326,
-0.0049667596,
-0.0562584065,
-0.0372024924,
0.0115582906,
-0.0272433478,
0.0271405522,
0.0354702249,
-0.0093070325,
-0.0144504653,
0.0044893189,
0.0300750379,
0.0080351131,
0.0720195472,
-0.013443958,
0.0069712307,
-0.0333988853,
-0.0199104343,
-0.0448824242,
0.0243474115,
0.0276733004,
-0.0710957944,
-0.0084815258,
0.0373794101,
3.315e-7,
0.064843595,
0.0341785699,
0.0166479722,
0.0595697612,
-0.0115667377,
0.003783789,
-0.0228500348,
-0.0203249156,
0.0113115748,
-0.0144203473,
0.0676510707,
0.0595890023,
0.0057627209,
0.0039947969,
-0.1060352772,
-0.0122538749,
0.0233790688,
-0.0375594236,
-0.0496223196,
0.0196501072,
0.014710892,
0.0497597195,
-0.008589847,
-0.0139084086,
-0.0009741606,
-0.0417968482,
0.0436485037,
-0.0016519345,
0.06065448,
0.0395671166,
-0.0237871986,
-0.0606552102,
-0.0411293022,
0.0602381192,
0.0157566573,
0.0081938412,
0.0035171374,
-0.004809285,
0.0227167718,
-0.0014426558,
0.0101502519,
-0.0330959223,
0.0216944739,
-0.029990213,
0.0078192968,
-0.0976961181,
-0.0372324325,
0.0358143337,
-0.0165759567,
-0.0188633557,
-0.0309074,
-0.0206552017,
0.0379817151,
-0.0121571906,
-0.0148658026,
0.0140060168,
0.0423992909,
-0.0176823046,
0.0207781065,
0.035881348,
-0.0503893048,
-0.034019772,
-0.0111798169,
-0.0473179221,
0.0447834209,
-0.0009691679,
0.0103186993,
2.993895949e-34,
0.0448650755,
0.0147765279,
-0.0134878634,
0.0326874442,
0.0314343423,
0.0036443244,
-0.004913202,
0.039023865,
0.0044770367,
-0.1018662751,
-0.0178663135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01605v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01605v3 | Faithful and Robust Local Interpretability for Textual Predictions | 2023-10-30T20:27:36 | 2024-04-09T10:52:13 | Gianluigi Lopardo, Frederic Precioso, Damien Garreau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Interpretability is essential for machine learning models to be trusted and
deployed in critical domains. However, existing methods for interpreting text
models are often complex, lack mathematical foundations, and their performance
is not guaranteed. In this paper, we propose FRED (Faithful and Robust
Explainer for textual Documents), a novel method for interpreting predictions
over text. FRED offers three key insights to explain a model prediction: (1) it
identifies the minimal set of words in a document whose removal has the
strongest influence on the prediction, (2) it assigns an importance score to
each token, reflecting its influence on the model's output, and (3) it provides
counterfactual explanations by generating examples similar to the original
document, but leading to a different prediction. We establish the reliability
of FRED through formal definitions and theoretical analyses on interpretable
classifiers. Additionally, our empirical evaluation against state-of-the-art
methods demonstrates the effectiveness of FRED in providing insights into text
models. | [
0.0619222522,
0.043854218,
-0.0178550221,
0.0305689611,
-0.0257871356,
0.0222360548,
0.0033429067,
0.025391357,
0.0006823177,
-0.0147922868,
0.0253930558,
0.0331305303,
-0.0121678254,
0.066535525,
-0.0255116262,
-0.0738020092,
0.0125213098,
-0.0084501263,
0.034241695,
0.010150509,
0.0207899138,
0.0118733924,
0.0379518867,
0.0632282346,
0.0236854888,
-0.0151183512,
-0.0168893132,
-0.001281847,
-0.0153368423,
0.024927292,
-0.004590272,
0.0202867072,
0.0005029738,
0.0464465953,
0.0000020853,
-0.0148619544,
-0.0492680594,
0.0197075289,
-0.0415085219,
0.0040679961,
0.0283639766,
-0.0435242876,
0.0229581539,
-0.0281255413,
-0.0108667929,
0.04428,
0.028131146,
0.0750217214,
0.0404466614,
0.0578736141,
-0.0128097162,
-0.0119108278,
0.0066204299,
0.0161750838,
0.0273683667,
-0.0394983664,
0.0029092352,
0.0208952203,
-0.0552602448,
0.0223667827,
-0.0090409024,
0.020713741,
0.0243127402,
-0.0223153532,
0.03135252,
-0.0006185141,
-0.014645881,
-0.0343501829,
0.0195370596,
0.0240776855,
0.0213590991,
-0.0558441393,
0.0143194292,
-0.0399024487,
0.0063536237,
0.0694153085,
-0.0390314534,
-0.0350741893,
-0.006243295,
0.0250659715,
0.006905138,
0.0325165018,
0.0567633025,
0.0239350758,
-0.0043241386,
0.0657566786,
-0.034335684,
-0.0008661514,
-0.0465898365,
-0.0088479966,
-0.0565586127,
-0.0170975979,
0.0416191258,
0.0399966389,
0.0030938431,
0.0349413082,
-0.0151631525,
-0.0236725435,
0.0340812765,
-0.0762121752,
0.0230822172,
-0.0173994452,
-0.0074187452,
0.0605025552,
-0.0109078027,
0.0491209477,
0.0168765355,
0.0068702134,
-0.0098181358,
-0.022838641,
-0.0813047141,
-0.0388653167,
0.0105550839,
0.0200714115,
-0.0375823639,
-0.0154072726,
-0.010816697,
0.0012875269,
-0.0237282142,
0.0318494365,
0.0109304935,
0.0250046663,
-0.0449950024,
-0.035674084,
-0.0175808202,
-0.022408003,
-0.0167023651,
0.0171553381,
-0.0415208973,
-0.0372741371,
-0.0019761431,
0.0263052341,
0.0049139042,
0.0003723418,
-0.0326220393,
0.0626272485,
0.0336288102,
-0.0156460274,
-0.0178312864,
-0.0637793913,
-0.022608202,
-0.0274820477,
-0.0337205306,
-0.0006561381,
-0.0343875252,
0.0056812009,
-0.0040337089,
-0.0531040654,
-0.023439832,
0.0000925192,
-0.0296614058,
0.0478902198,
-0.0167278294,
-0.0133617986,
0.0144256782,
0.0164032876,
-0.0371529199,
0.0171380863,
0.0147535475,
0.0593558922,
0.0809589177,
-0.0335491151,
0.0360241123,
0.0060933819,
0.0287738219,
-0.0265141409,
-0.0343207158,
0.0026490567,
-0.0449151471,
-0.0495318882,
-0.0012024684,
-0.0025565112,
-0.0113029117,
-0.0329505429,
0.0553233922,
0.0104045952,
0.0143554341,
0.0321000107,
0.0464934856,
0.0471460856,
-0.0122005465,
0.0302146003,
-0.0490314476,
-0.0042043463,
-0.0418351591,
-0.0218300838,
-0.0445145331,
-0.0349190347,
-0.0093599493,
-0.0856415182,
-0.0193048585,
-0.0193222295,
-0.0144516975,
-0.0131298825,
0.0892580301,
0.0047695371,
-0.0374416634,
0.0154568767,
0.0092255967,
-0.0253128055,
0.0023388648,
-0.0440807641,
0.0448924117,
0.0618864,
0.0439569652,
-0.0718269497,
0.0439640172,
0.0001608199,
0.0199338477,
-0.0189344417,
0.0164027251,
-0.0037899048,
0.0460890345,
-0.0322823934,
-0.0392436609,
0.0042064996,
0.0644587576,
-0.0003574502,
-0.0010674793,
-0.0460818075,
0.015706744,
-0.0623623803,
-0.0611182228,
0.0439620204,
-0.0077752508,
-0.0222326349,
0.01295189,
-0.0156699494,
0.0093287677,
0.0233773347,
0.0108944131,
-0.000915064,
0.0301810186,
-0.0012594056,
-0.0303444266,
0.0192635916,
-0.0182299856,
0.0008223415,
-0.0277139079,
-0.0173801687,
-0.0151977027,
0.0329233557,
-0.0417586528,
-0.0116215665,
0.0163688287,
-0.0495114103,
0.012303791,
-0.0272898693,
-0.0126265092,
-0.0212805495,
0.0075408174,
-0.0248508994,
0.069585003,
-0.0184668917,
0.0026407051,
-0.0172029939,
-0.0206407178,
0.0110258376,
-0.0167976692,
-0.0090515865,
-0.0105199357,
-0.0243492965,
-0.0150703462,
0.0255617499,
-0.0272142645,
-0.0089241518,
-0.0102165472,
-0.0311203562,
-0.0217354596,
-0.0205262862,
0.00531844,
0.0344468579,
-0.0135983136,
0.0156843364,
-0.0356561057,
0.0168062672,
-0.0192019958,
0.0147641571,
-0.007901269,
0.0459264033,
-0.0228433106,
-0.0089692567,
-0.0156514328,
-0.0266732518,
-0.0077523189,
0.1044344753,
0.0293170493,
-0.0395365171,
-0.0409231298,
-0.0043945829,
0.0007570009,
-0.0226538889,
-0.0324159451,
-0.0102420747,
-0.0367003381,
0.0024143893,
-0.0602406226,
0.0373322442,
0.0076996572,
0.0939641893,
0.0145735592,
0.0408785231,
-0.0652250871,
-0.0366576239,
-0.0276101548,
0.0558277406,
-0.0274217948,
-0.0748417452,
0.0154168522,
0.0590268038,
0.0274768807,
0.0010599041,
-0.0628539473,
0.0602159128,
-0.0200719628,
-0.0316881798,
-0.0273477994,
-0.0593030639,
0.0060868151,
0.0473535769,
-0.0211558808,
-0.1048984379,
0.0572896004,
-0.020960521,
0.0146536417,
-0.0129817976,
-0.0315232463,
-0.036071714,
0.0610121898,
0.0132662551,
-0.0052035069,
0.0193189047,
-0.0122459158,
0.0145758698,
-0.0243289638,
0.041705098,
-0.0076602171,
0.0293331482,
-0.040191628,
-0.0138632944,
0.0370567553,
0.0007727512,
-0.0168164,
-0.0497633815,
-0.0101424335,
0.0103325611,
0.0087920725,
-0.0101508629,
-0.0545409843,
-0.0119223092,
0.0149949361,
0.0271611642,
-0.03663221,
-0.0096155815,
-0.0031402337,
0.0196824502,
0.0209162626,
-0.0165596008,
0.0139600961,
-0.0366434753,
0.0322500989,
0.0594789386,
-0.0373774357,
-0.021555189,
-0.0509378091,
0.009216872,
-0.0393196382,
-0.0408955365,
-0.0460541993,
-0.0232788697,
0.0552688017,
-0.0909452885,
-0.0132749528,
0.0886162445,
0.0337609909,
-0.005209554,
0.0230338741,
-0.0255052075,
0.0268269796,
-0.0155794751,
-0.0003671043,
-0.0175614636,
-0.0325091742,
0.0108449841,
0.0534193888,
-0.0024122067,
-0.0347574279,
0.0105469925,
-0.0107548051,
0.0435676165,
-0.0203625504,
-0.0386032797,
-0.0232314542,
-0.0723719969,
-0.041748289,
-0.0624155961,
-0.046116028,
0.0010842967,
0.0302766841,
0.0466196574,
0.0216023419,
-0.0676639304,
-0.0202353746,
0.0039261193,
0.0185230263,
0.0116801839,
0.0763416886,
0.0361946933,
0.0043300013,
0.0044909758,
0.008188406,
-0.0062390584,
0.0376757719,
-0.0128820017,
0.1181382611,
0.023208214,
0.0092171095,
-0.0404477045,
0.0505989604,
-0.0089461366,
-0.0362192169,
0.0017258968,
0.0682061166,
-0.0187413134,
-0.0493451804,
-0.0293991063,
0.0031332907,
0.0051483945,
0.1048422828,
0.0288801324,
-0.0048224595,
-0.0712423101,
-0.0504189432,
0.0216688775,
-0.0409401618,
-0.0141673675,
-0.0064029894,
0.0163351092,
-0.0239965394,
-0.0204123594,
-0.049238544,
-0.0341097936,
-0.0003119398,
-0.0166648477,
0.0126281707,
-0.049945008,
-0.0153417038,
-0.0284854993,
0.0227520764,
0.007024481,
-0.0230022743,
0.0244135298,
-0.0190924574,
0.0242246669,
-0.0438127331,
-0.0428614058,
-0.0002494715,
-0.0303726178,
-0.0018441729,
0.022904126,
0.0303780381,
0.0354919136,
0.0530419163,
-0.0056780865,
-0.0742463768,
0.0311625693,
0.0298244599,
-0.0288107898,
0.0080956593,
0.0781494081,
-0.0147302998,
0.0134415543,
0.0536650755,
-0.0293104369,
0.036232762,
0.0040304153,
-0.0406251699,
-0.0259087682,
0.0192017611,
-0.0098183686,
0.0087068118,
0.0269576255,
0.0275148973,
-0.0493260249,
-0.0076682386,
0.0068692728,
-0.0067484458,
-0.0208038613,
-0.0458136275,
0.0702229887,
0.0090790698,
0.0018244343,
-0.0301154945,
0.0012574052,
-0.026374694,
0.010407472,
-0.0503978431,
0.0432639606,
0.0583437905,
0.0377666205,
-0.0124012418,
0.0011992414,
-0.0239744205,
0.0164408535,
-0.016171813,
0.0211494043,
0.0025632156,
0.0243758522,
0.020396715,
0.0297898073,
-0.0268559363,
-0.0210912023,
-0.1087492704,
-0.0176626183,
-0.0142028602,
0.0307354145,
-0.0238627195,
-0.02815862,
0.0235671494,
-0.0175517183,
-0.0185021665,
-0.0105363317,
0.057101842,
0.0807819888,
-0.0319162719,
-0.0190765169,
0.0101279067,
-0.0405455492,
0.0342303924,
0.0789601728,
0.0204439647,
0.0265355371,
-0.0047900109,
-0.0483320653,
-0.0549792536,
-0.0246132817,
0.0375009142,
0.055738952,
-0.0162586402,
-0.0107140178,
-0.0592150614,
-0.0387298875,
0.0581169762,
-0.0161482189,
0.0210022032,
-0.0229930039,
-0.0249364097,
0.0763696134,
0.0056975042,
-0.0025125802,
-0.0601042435,
0.0114995651,
-0.0046149697,
0.0192845929,
-0.0033777652,
-5.694317245e-33,
0.0039331657,
-0.0748591125,
-0.0295932461,
0.0065091974,
0.0425865836,
0.0256765652,
-0.0576244369,
-0.0588807873,
0.0130305812,
0.0551448166,
0.0161484648,
0.0537313335,
0.0080485297,
0.0109574925,
-0.0098230708,
-0.0261385199,
0.0539322607,
0.0248656273,
-0.0126665644,
0.0293937158,
0.0788269863,
0.0571973175,
0.0590595193,
-0.0934991241,
0.0947049409,
0.0048826439,
-0.0302146804,
-0.0128805107,
-0.0199943706,
0.0721096992,
-0.0115967859,
0.0099432264,
0.0355512686,
-0.0378081128,
-0.0388146676,
-0.0024389164,
-0.0358008072,
-0.0251526181,
0.0108976308,
0.0058292365,
-0.0160215143,
-0.0046376213,
0.0648350567,
-0.0174614452,
-0.0048250738,
-0.0266206786,
0.0810722411,
-0.0365570672,
-0.039527148,
-0.0047947578,
-0.0396606848,
0.0749795064,
-0.0440688059,
0.0169782396,
0.0405883119,
0.0480750054,
0.0228036456,
0.0737275705,
-0.020067405,
-0.006602502,
0.0310678128,
0.0144807808,
0.051258482,
-0.0362166427,
-0.0220013242,
0.0861204863,
0.0363098085,
-0.0199530683,
-0.0439243242,
-0.0196134746,
0.0167330876,
0.0428033583,
0.0800392553,
0.0679081306,
0.0419726744,
0.0113434093,
-0.0707731396,
0.0485414639,
-0.0214927141,
0.0118719619,
0.044828672,
0.0065483772,
-0.0700491667,
-0.0045760502,
-0.0179251637,
-0.0668866187,
-0.0068646055,
-0.0114906179,
0.0107582146,
-0.0391034037,
-0.0873165652,
0.0363793895,
0.0018477241,
-0.067858927,
-0.0055057309,
0.0648049191,
-0.0160979107,
-0.0145874694,
0.0167453773,
-0.0258001015,
0.0098476307,
-0.0194347147,
-0.0059752008,
0.001460889,
0.0505726449,
0.0050244126,
0.0551649891,
0.0023123706,
-0.0276995748,
-0.0055232081,
-0.0169629194,
-0.0343176983,
-0.0161351934,
0.0434252508,
0.0308196787,
0.0023034997,
-0.033100754,
0.0559861548,
0.0124118244,
0.0516256504,
-0.0140094003,
0.0071031349,
-0.0139731532,
-0.010315029,
-0.0219239481,
-0.0660903975,
0.0099829976,
-0.0042210282,
0.0304335039,
-0.0503999367,
0.0008500335,
0.0051844134,
2.567e-7,
0.0773630887,
0.0405251458,
0.0308470912,
-0.0402213559,
0.0460872464,
0.0608135276,
-0.0067567076,
0.0034659717,
-0.0297873933,
-0.0033359528,
0.0540489443,
-0.0050573442,
0.0390274934,
0.0183078572,
-0.0378557146,
-0.0075518191,
-0.0852910727,
-0.0405113809,
-0.0242415126,
0.0365649611,
0.0444084182,
0.0794208348,
0.0302262362,
-0.020904474,
0.0128650218,
-0.0116956774,
0.0155227398,
-0.0504936725,
0.0182120595,
-0.0002031307,
0.0606543832,
-0.0471927784,
0.0217201766,
0.0064518582,
-0.0460175909,
0.0120219374,
0.015858585,
0.1087991074,
-0.0190056786,
0.0231347159,
-0.0308612958,
-0.028826328,
0.0353407711,
-0.0768725052,
0.0763656273,
-0.0165919289,
-0.0465406515,
-0.0140509717,
-0.0421287268,
-0.0293392707,
0.0097395657,
0.0291033052,
0.0034325884,
0.0374353044,
-0.0378752165,
-0.0101953307,
-0.0187978987,
-0.0536280274,
-0.0414212942,
-0.0607982613,
-0.0454191007,
0.002473504,
-0.035665337,
0.0273075588,
0.0448205024,
-0.0610226467,
0.0030211238,
2.588130223e-34,
0.0409714989,
0.0256337821,
-0.0141331982,
0.0305835269,
0.0400329344,
0.0115498286,
0.0395266488,
0.0384471491,
0.0403397754,
-0.0450178497,
0.0023846985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19975v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19975v3 | BioInstruct: Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models for Biomedical Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-30T19:38:50 | 2024-06-06T21:16:12 | Hieu Tran, Zhichao Yang, Zonghai Yao, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To enhance the performance of large language models (LLMs) in biomedical
natural language processing (BioNLP) by introducing a domain-specific
instruction dataset and examining its impact when combined with multi-task
learning principles. We created the BioInstruct, comprising 25,005 instructions
to instruction-tune LLMs(LLaMA 1 & 2, 7B & 13B version). The instructions were
created by prompting the GPT-4 language model with three-seed samples randomly
drawn from an 80 human curated instructions. We employed Low-Rank
Adaptation(LoRA) for parameter-efficient fine-tuning. We then evaluated these
instruction-tuned LLMs on several BioNLP tasks, which can be grouped into three
major categories: question answering(QA), information extraction(IE), and text
generation(GEN). We also examined whether categories(e.g., QA, IE, and
generation) of instructions impact model performance. Comparing with LLMs
without instruction-tuned, our instruction-tuned LLMs demonstrated marked
performance gains: 17.3% in QA, 5.7% in IE, and 96% in Generation tasks. Our
7B-parameter instruction-tuned LLaMA 1 model was competitive or even surpassed
other LLMs in the biomedical domain that were also fine-tuned from LLaMA 1 with
vast domain-specific data or a variety of tasks. Our results also show that the
performance gain is significantly higher when instruction fine-tuning is
conducted with closely related tasks. Our findings align with the observations
of multi-task learning, suggesting the synergies between two tasks. The
BioInstruct dataset serves as a valuable resource and instruction tuned LLMs
lead to the best performing BioNLP applications. | [
0.0664498135,
0.036595542,
0.0021621049,
0.0021892015,
-0.0116023542,
0.0440438129,
0.0107532423,
0.0057852399,
-0.0022400923,
-0.0303342026,
-0.07852415,
-0.0468770936,
-0.0015528073,
-0.0013582883,
0.036827378,
0.0048727146,
0.0651775077,
-0.0215404537,
0.019926589,
-0.0064694597,
-0.0174584482,
0.0131565826,
-0.0222743265,
0.0255185775,
0.081683822,
-0.0023331887,
0.0241630562,
0.0050291959,
0.0148349963,
-0.0256178752,
0.023243526,
0.0409069397,
0.0281107258,
-0.0052664983,
0.0000019304,
-0.0470007174,
-0.0084254062,
0.0164574422,
-0.0303665847,
0.0266190898,
0.0326263271,
0.0093316743,
-0.0003618061,
0.0301267747,
-0.0232894067,
-0.0109849125,
0.0496050268,
0.0300207306,
0.0440441482,
0.0817714185,
0.006597504,
-0.0222294852,
0.0475039184,
-0.0237561148,
0.0097407885,
-0.0284716915,
0.0416212492,
-0.0115929767,
0.0315241776,
0.031746015,
0.0026670431,
0.0361207798,
-0.0165801048,
0.0448251106,
0.0209926069,
0.0537291318,
-0.0024881251,
-0.0241609924,
-0.0104024569,
0.0738148242,
-0.0358635597,
0.0064825546,
0.0107101174,
0.0180325992,
-0.0135970544,
-0.0069961259,
-0.0560513362,
0.0266097169,
-0.0167046636,
0.0214444697,
0.0323588029,
-0.0586873665,
0.0215962585,
0.0154815949,
0.0012899555,
0.0457719937,
0.0307583362,
-0.0228053611,
0.0084372899,
-0.0071730944,
-0.0574513823,
-0.0001208805,
0.0385171287,
0.0466989242,
-0.0522851311,
0.0174965952,
-0.0431551598,
-0.0214981306,
0.0549062453,
-0.0353097469,
0.0802272707,
0.0346950367,
-0.0135712912,
0.0104136206,
-0.0682701841,
0.0367190689,
-0.0351089984,
0.0438795537,
-0.0397646315,
0.0027441354,
-0.070808053,
0.0057779765,
0.0072943922,
0.0438569039,
-0.0722850338,
0.0120943319,
-0.0543923192,
0.0244704448,
0.0343567654,
-0.0491088852,
0.0364217162,
0.020831598,
-0.0550867915,
0.0048735184,
-0.0437817909,
0.0146506066,
-0.0002855279,
0.0336889066,
-0.0087018181,
-0.074564904,
-0.0402304232,
-0.0209126752,
0.0239303708,
-0.0511596762,
0.0589180104,
0.0788948908,
-0.0265944488,
-0.0488738269,
-0.0338623337,
0.0012290906,
-0.0048635988,
-0.0735852048,
0.0175855421,
-0.0507280342,
0.047958333,
0.0056795999,
0.0017251071,
-0.0316697806,
0.0223914329,
0.0179113448,
-0.0488666594,
0.0668684542,
-0.0114802895,
0.006182421,
0.0496737994,
0.0047345534,
0.0126658017,
0.0378898196,
0.0368014313,
-0.0396443196,
-0.0099560041,
-0.0134430071,
-0.0461986288,
-0.0015185442,
0.0015546512,
-0.0302556157,
0.0127197914,
0.0289163236,
0.0000613817,
0.0648016185,
0.045700144,
0.0443002619,
0.0078390241,
-0.0157545041,
0.031985756,
0.0708155036,
0.0320462137,
0.019135341,
0.0355650187,
0.0086970162,
-0.0041877707,
-0.0254643001,
-0.0270451531,
0.0284768175,
-0.0178751554,
0.0264696013,
0.0224453583,
0.0298393257,
-0.0376083143,
-0.0386995971,
-0.0124736466,
0.0172395967,
-0.0134014366,
0.0212851968,
0.022645507,
-0.0182821508,
-0.0706816092,
0.0120917242,
0.0688511878,
-0.012846645,
0.0028315545,
-0.0861193687,
0.0205379669,
0.067366153,
0.0153195728,
-0.0392386131,
-0.0568739325,
-0.0203025229,
0.0093977507,
0.0420710444,
0.0037950494,
-0.0081416173,
0.0334687904,
-0.0576167367,
-0.0003292618,
-0.003376584,
-0.0028964358,
0.0047843414,
0.0117443688,
0.003816138,
0.00295408,
-0.0086401058,
-0.0436167195,
0.0597060509,
-0.0626946837,
-0.0593409799,
0.010098788,
-0.0373473577,
0.0430898741,
-0.0068709375,
-0.0242165904,
0.0164749473,
0.0232092682,
-0.0530199818,
0.0070219142,
-0.0455061086,
-0.0250634681,
-0.0422627889,
0.0246945471,
0.0010335157,
0.0070152478,
0.024906313,
-0.0188748203,
-0.0537136942,
-0.0124347452,
-0.0668464378,
0.0126370499,
-0.0204656627,
0.0109009361,
0.0065414486,
0.028936049,
-0.0713483989,
0.0320544392,
0.0065329866,
0.0010370754,
0.0463216528,
-0.0201656446,
-0.0000799324,
-0.0407033078,
0.0074051707,
0.0035739583,
0.0090937205,
0.0040139314,
-0.0138726858,
0.0453317612,
-0.051886443,
-0.0187666342,
-0.0936856791,
0.0560411438,
0.0080309361,
0.0490627773,
0.0293497499,
0.0163091086,
-0.0114461854,
0.0005029093,
-0.0453397818,
-0.0047677793,
0.0053328527,
0.0332358815,
0.0318767875,
0.0218688641,
-0.0011447722,
-0.0588587709,
-0.0011516532,
-0.029983338,
0.0061425082,
-0.0104123522,
-0.0137797995,
-0.0623225756,
0.0323658623,
-0.0135003617,
0.0071932534,
0.0165775008,
-0.0362858586,
-0.0078059379,
0.0251667555,
0.0630796626,
0.0801537111,
-0.0117148068,
0.0091550592,
0.0573587343,
0.0315969549,
-0.0267526638,
0.0331465229,
-0.0333442688,
-0.0206635501,
-0.0169710796,
-0.0218938831,
0.0067611285,
0.0695761144,
0.0127179855,
-0.0203082561,
-0.0529828705,
0.0188714396,
-0.0093695819,
0.0019909979,
-0.0190387815,
0.0409760475,
-0.0432304218,
0.0071926326,
-0.0253713857,
-0.0360461995,
0.0780929849,
0.0184116624,
0.0090598529,
-0.1002911776,
-0.0153647931,
-0.0401681885,
-0.0070813806,
-0.0003536112,
0.0291340761,
0.0114485277,
-0.0125252577,
-0.0280380901,
0.0476000533,
-0.0188747291,
-0.0435949266,
0.0386275351,
-0.0610662475,
0.0159133989,
-0.008282668,
-0.0458299071,
-0.0265981518,
-0.0077062575,
-0.0083444398,
0.0250611454,
0.0491006337,
-0.0084836204,
-0.0301128719,
-0.0006882541,
0.0337502137,
0.0570674725,
-0.0252795536,
-0.0197654553,
-0.0399052128,
0.0081637502,
0.0582423583,
0.0492554605,
0.0205714572,
-0.0253236126,
0.0176481195,
0.0228372458,
0.0242953636,
-0.0067613847,
0.0137543734,
0.0329925455,
0.0256867558,
-0.04285172,
0.0068953033,
0.0332417153,
0.0760202259,
-0.0598480813,
-0.0254266374,
0.1033435836,
0.018242605,
-0.0413716361,
0.008497077,
0.000535385,
0.0148900701,
0.0170269143,
0.049420353,
-0.0447115898,
-0.0507821105,
-0.0260406081,
0.0391615927,
-0.0213559754,
-0.0202233978,
-0.0092900572,
-0.0775329843,
0.0245182067,
0.0124799618,
-0.0395457223,
-0.0311453212,
-0.0745915771,
0.0023569451,
-0.0111173233,
0.0282395594,
0.0091449944,
-0.0444940478,
0.0038072257,
0.058573205,
-0.0132252732,
-0.1230563298,
0.0273762178,
-0.008577154,
0.0715995505,
0.0557582378,
0.0044689872,
0.0033249657,
-0.0222604983,
0.032784801,
-0.036892321,
0.0177547857,
-0.026758058,
0.0391904339,
0.0201807804,
-0.0079890741,
-0.0503399782,
0.0456662364,
-0.0386836194,
0.0024584958,
-0.0065017254,
0.081510663,
-0.0092724655,
-0.0016055538,
-0.0245415121,
-0.0238553733,
-0.0223933961,
0.0610105954,
0.022500366,
-0.0535552986,
-0.0397339575,
0.0005562744,
-0.007177521,
-0.088375628,
-0.0294166356,
0.021193197,
-0.0616481304,
0.0254297107,
-0.0529709198,
0.0068298364,
0.0541540235,
0.0056283227,
0.0196342375,
0.0305753835,
0.0285548232,
0.0016943242,
-0.0463763773,
0.047069639,
-0.0013271151,
-0.0116051743,
-0.0785620064,
-0.0784647837,
0.0567137599,
-0.0149173783,
-0.02339633,
0.0246123113,
-0.0481129251,
-0.0702353492,
-0.0272773989,
0.060977608,
0.0136104226,
0.0140523622,
0.0255275276,
-0.056849584,
0.0283261705,
0.0183586571,
-0.0433100685,
0.0136060808,
-0.0096469354,
0.0017748153,
-0.0225481279,
0.0184404459,
-0.02132627,
0.0292121656,
0.0270453971,
0.0532127395,
0.0077685304,
-0.0126252202,
0.0192249045,
0.0492269881,
0.0365270376,
-0.0179672837,
-0.019712016,
-0.0438835472,
0.0197272357,
-0.0004104279,
0.0390335582,
-0.0187260415,
-0.0162058547,
0.0393325984,
-0.0355988853,
-0.0216715094,
0.0033757933,
-0.0330880359,
-0.0100614503,
-0.0610682629,
0.0396038629,
-0.0111485552,
0.0012062715,
0.0244810581,
0.0030806363,
-0.0360782929,
0.011121002,
0.0115737226,
0.0327551775,
-0.0158814155,
0.0233808402,
-0.0082348296,
0.0139642004,
-0.0304188449,
0.0503631681,
-0.0529162288,
-0.0238571409,
-0.0208250973,
-0.0003487336,
0.0489752591,
0.0035524261,
0.0438622795,
0.0204534214,
-0.0135099785,
-0.0334729776,
0.0017858628,
-0.0343648307,
0.0504445769,
0.054214865,
0.0291845091,
-0.0181615669,
-0.0258935932,
0.1005044058,
0.0788917094,
0.0697318241,
-0.0000257236,
-0.0075476584,
-0.0373224169,
-0.026595002,
-0.0147878006,
0.01582787,
-0.0480541997,
0.010792667,
-0.0045155496,
-0.0333658122,
0.0029263066,
-0.0144665157,
0.0042030481,
-0.0367778353,
0.048317425,
0.0052906638,
-0.0028381988,
-0.0698717907,
-0.0200189129,
0.0066402652,
-0.0067529827,
-0.0333198383,
0.0055148453,
-6.605091737e-33,
-0.0309447665,
-0.0034029854,
0.0414019078,
0.0049258913,
-0.0045224344,
0.0061847419,
-0.0368685909,
0.0078084976,
-0.0265565366,
0.0016189191,
-0.0255678203,
-0.0068737906,
0.0183141157,
0.0156200239,
0.0153630022,
-0.0244852062,
0.0405109748,
-0.0246332176,
-0.0052642617,
0.028008882,
0.0090580955,
0.069418788,
0.0520042442,
-0.02373611,
-0.0231308825,
0.0196482465,
0.0342714675,
-0.0168877915,
-0.0219897982,
0.049469091,
-0.0594055988,
0.0696736574,
0.029652169,
-0.0419610068,
-0.022058459,
0.0179413017,
-0.0834722593,
-0.0120535623,
0.0588928387,
-0.0413742997,
-0.0413167439,
-0.0769086778,
0.0546803139,
0.0150798289,
-0.0429675505,
-0.0144034876,
0.0154275484,
-0.0502144769,
-0.0305659864,
-0.0212896932,
-0.0895355716,
0.0161575228,
0.0104411328,
-0.0336508043,
0.0100953337,
0.0114510916,
-0.0453980155,
0.0323829539,
-0.0152457012,
-0.0139528522,
0.0305837654,
0.0652631521,
0.0170920826,
0.0287949685,
0.0111534111,
0.022655189,
-0.0123450719,
-0.0034403626,
0.0189472623,
-0.0096441824,
-0.006017203,
0.0442894325,
0.0265907813,
-0.006533124,
0.0138453105,
-0.0028452191,
-0.1270302385,
0.0072359936,
-0.0061558979,
0.0196565371,
0.0353672691,
-0.009711178,
0.0011909755,
-0.0032832772,
-0.0106250336,
0.0562543981,
-0.0333210379,
-0.002598318,
0.042836383,
-0.0136253554,
0.0038293139,
0.0096049476,
0.0210436657,
-0.0350619145,
0.0163697507,
-0.0254959092,
0.0077997437,
-0.0105011854,
0.0085446807,
0.0177641474,
-0.0845289081,
-0.0503496267,
0.0372097008,
-0.0086857136,
0.0395779759,
-0.0137080438,
0.0062118601,
0.0012016692,
-0.0574681349,
-0.0152680008,
-0.0309891272,
0.0210014023,
0.012098101,
0.0718609765,
-0.0062972754,
0.020719124,
0.011645468,
0.0589823984,
0.0020944553,
-0.0162743963,
-0.0252427943,
-0.0160291288,
0.0064728879,
0.0347999334,
-0.03158281,
0.0289138909,
-0.0166623909,
0.0556569062,
-0.0505038984,
-0.0591287985,
-0.0328149199,
0.0307946894,
2.793e-7,
0.0651573986,
0.0928112641,
-0.0094933109,
-0.0123951929,
0.0138703808,
-0.0043376288,
-0.0173480194,
0.0335668176,
0.0087221507,
-0.0248642862,
-0.0033626056,
0.0308503434,
0.0302574225,
-0.0151248593,
-0.0512417741,
-0.0296738073,
-0.0502425767,
0.0135879256,
-0.0638310537,
-0.0325215235,
0.0293997396,
0.0784689486,
-0.054267481,
-0.0311049465,
0.0189720001,
0.020738814,
0.0536337867,
-0.0190412719,
-0.0346059166,
0.0456306078,
-0.0047297911,
0.018608721,
-0.0043359753,
0.0413586572,
-0.0205709152,
0.0150848264,
-0.016649982,
0.1051858664,
-0.0533103421,
-0.0276484657,
0.0642802343,
0.0224403143,
0.0141101042,
-0.0406292528,
0.063358739,
-0.05783353,
-0.0426818356,
-0.011509954,
0.014403807,
0.0096119838,
0.0129201571,
-0.0657808259,
-0.0014305561,
0.0137871932,
0.0172674712,
-0.0201684907,
-0.0363891162,
-0.074591659,
0.015101891,
0.050692562,
-0.0578834973,
-0.0441679358,
-0.0477796085,
-0.0097883157,
0.0415177792,
-0.0859192312,
0.0086795799,
2.537964853e-34,
0.0079087168,
-0.0221456625,
0.0400744453,
0.0567045137,
0.0205581505,
-0.003834699,
-0.0518750288,
0.013891398,
-0.0004008333,
-0.1071468741,
-0.0184838772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19970v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19970v1 | Strategies to Harness the Transformers' Potential: UNSL at eRisk 2023 | 2023-10-30T19:34:33 | 2023-10-30T19:34:33 | Horacio Thompson, Leticia Cagnina, Marcelo Errecalde | cs.CL | cs.CL | The CLEF eRisk Laboratory explores solutions to different tasks related to
risk detection on the Internet. In the 2023 edition, Task 1 consisted of
searching for symptoms of depression, the objective of which was to extract
user writings according to their relevance to the BDI Questionnaire symptoms.
Task 2 was related to the problem of early detection of pathological gambling
risks, where the participants had to detect users at risk as quickly as
possible. Finally, Task 3 consisted of estimating the severity levels of signs
of eating disorders. Our research group participated in the first two tasks,
proposing solutions based on Transformers. For Task 1, we applied different
approaches that can be interesting in information retrieval tasks. Two
proposals were based on the similarity of contextualized embedding vectors, and
the other one was based on prompting, an attractive current technique of
machine learning. For Task 2, we proposed three fine-tuned models followed by
decision policy according to criteria defined by an early detection framework.
One model presented extended vocabulary with important words to the addressed
domain. In the last task, we obtained good performances considering the
decision-based metrics, ranking-based metrics, and runtime. In this work, we
explore different ways to deploy the predictive potential of Transformers in
eRisk tasks. | [
0.0569763519,
0.0114579424,
-0.0180738177,
-0.0053046755,
0.0036938237,
0.0271370485,
-0.0351923704,
0.02637095,
0.0294538159,
-0.0496761017,
0.0122581553,
0.0139431395,
-0.073039256,
0.0220696889,
-0.0234781951,
-0.0451694354,
0.0277829636,
0.0327196233,
-0.0143564325,
0.0267112646,
0.0209507514,
-0.0182698891,
-0.0014512087,
0.047923401,
0.0167144965,
0.0224660821,
0.0178871322,
0.0097935526,
0.0471290015,
-0.0496163778,
0.0409443304,
0.0179280192,
0.0178741105,
0.0154531151,
0.0000022393,
-0.048679065,
-0.055947192,
-0.0105092507,
-0.0133397421,
-0.0800289214,
0.0431998447,
-0.0330437198,
0.035761822,
0.0285232514,
-0.0543696098,
-0.0153811155,
0.0740689561,
0.0971795768,
0.0487842336,
0.0670882016,
-0.0331974104,
-0.0233808085,
0.0063108234,
-0.0138503034,
0.0168659426,
0.0026363421,
0.0425934233,
-0.0457922965,
-0.0073611718,
0.001032441,
-0.0213075504,
0.0002627902,
-0.0268146098,
0.0219656657,
0.0240378734,
0.0324142575,
-0.0111449817,
-0.0358464941,
-0.0081316028,
0.0504773632,
-0.0122506358,
0.0183681604,
0.0323732905,
0.0072344467,
-0.0125456639,
0.0540187135,
-0.0031053366,
-0.0238599367,
-0.0250298213,
0.0097656986,
0.0188812912,
0.0537085459,
0.0091289245,
0.0065596248,
-0.0048346804,
0.0804938301,
-0.0029524427,
-0.0382464491,
0.0166530926,
0.0020212457,
0.0068031484,
-0.0304605905,
0.0336965024,
0.0103878872,
-0.0593697764,
0.0013200182,
0.0083047375,
-0.0696555376,
0.0384714864,
-0.0193007868,
0.0095432214,
0.0201530736,
-0.0068115131,
0.0146021442,
0.0057468885,
0.023141304,
-0.0313019939,
0.032348495,
-0.035446126,
0.033588998,
-0.0368499495,
0.0031328332,
-0.0290166382,
0.0208102595,
0.0282725003,
-0.0099432562,
-0.0859493241,
0.0550807677,
-0.0105234189,
-0.0173499323,
0.0201773718,
0.0149886087,
-0.0195010621,
0.0700044185,
-0.0264553372,
0.0139073879,
-0.0262753982,
-0.0072777495,
0.0009223633,
0.0012195064,
0.0232777465,
-0.0020006364,
0.0179818831,
-0.0625231713,
0.0286587626,
0.0709832162,
0.0403310023,
-0.0645454749,
-0.0049810749,
-0.0324321166,
-0.0114286216,
-0.010970464,
-0.0091252662,
-0.0400455222,
-0.0206095334,
0.0131719764,
0.0091066388,
0.012174367,
0.010395213,
0.018855352,
-0.0121254725,
0.0937216133,
0.0111878589,
0.0136763044,
0.0033731498,
0.0294747371,
-0.0309144482,
0.0507442355,
-0.0351120755,
0.0395942181,
0.0553738885,
-0.0250322614,
0.0176197626,
0.0068551637,
0.0041656853,
-0.0082716597,
0.0569354035,
-0.0084834294,
-0.0266049821,
0.0105027985,
-0.0103329485,
0.0294742994,
-0.0228496827,
0.0060253097,
0.0404921845,
0.0564968735,
0.0493671261,
0.0159615055,
0.0089136334,
0.0082738493,
-0.0474476926,
0.007038584,
-0.0163508989,
0.0144496625,
-0.0201974865,
-0.0275626164,
-0.0087344991,
0.0435759313,
-0.0101484153,
-0.0313353688,
-0.0259067453,
0.0068988046,
0.0116631547,
0.0088019026,
0.0367670245,
-0.0011232804,
-0.0162346102,
0.037162859,
0.0248208214,
-0.0259858742,
-0.0237523299,
-0.0735317394,
0.00347467,
0.053054899,
0.0521002524,
-0.0705633089,
-0.0197850317,
-0.0308654737,
-0.0071985889,
-0.0357394069,
0.0136590665,
-0.0003881415,
0.0005243635,
0.0022021376,
-0.0407664217,
0.05115005,
0.002050078,
-0.0367076099,
0.0039455304,
0.0314025097,
-0.0106088715,
-0.0365096666,
0.0118151261,
0.0487487763,
-0.0076715997,
-0.0087273382,
-0.0011531434,
0.0354511626,
0.0413732119,
-0.0056369668,
0.0050374372,
0.0077932025,
0.0522868708,
-0.0329946093,
-0.071571596,
-0.0131234201,
0.0130558955,
0.0236757696,
0.020751169,
-0.0804428756,
0.0382032469,
0.0685146302,
-0.0236830525,
0.0041450355,
-0.0094224932,
-0.053777203,
0.0265769828,
-0.0294484235,
-0.0093649952,
-0.0007795906,
0.029144153,
-0.0598787442,
0.0786937475,
-0.0036695832,
0.0336935669,
0.0052453927,
-0.0891929939,
-0.0184490513,
-0.0216662064,
-0.0650073886,
-0.0387732163,
-0.0191081427,
0.0209107585,
0.0459427051,
-0.0171332303,
-0.0224909429,
-0.0117958831,
-0.0856504291,
-0.0139971953,
-0.0191637836,
0.0053752149,
-0.0113320146,
0.0022214067,
-0.0153832873,
-0.0174243562,
-0.0177588966,
-0.0190906432,
0.012610401,
0.0450304672,
0.028272545,
0.019644225,
-0.0134110143,
-0.0106145153,
-0.0220301729,
-0.022813946,
0.0430297293,
0.0421208106,
-0.0352441519,
-0.0515344292,
0.0252986271,
-0.0397207551,
-0.0108575858,
-0.0038611183,
-0.0112306252,
-0.0433660373,
0.0007815671,
0.0272861291,
0.0350107625,
0.0354873203,
0.0926533192,
0.0164677016,
0.0254146531,
-0.0208317116,
0.0098665999,
-0.1007454693,
-0.0168908387,
-0.0468489267,
-0.0140456101,
0.0487116687,
0.0008655731,
-0.0051664161,
-0.0240075458,
-0.0533576421,
0.0130321253,
-0.0096890973,
-0.0227271747,
-0.0394389331,
-0.0092818402,
-0.0032166461,
0.0476896912,
0.0023782421,
-0.0307879075,
0.087274082,
0.0495810919,
0.0259405281,
-0.0474121906,
-0.0530153885,
-0.0252274256,
0.0231694262,
0.0004845068,
0.0306338556,
-0.0081696324,
0.0017463508,
-0.0217789281,
0.0018240213,
0.048387371,
-0.0486139804,
0.0529481992,
0.0349020362,
0.0022581576,
-0.0008292329,
-0.0784162208,
-0.0636063963,
-0.0713876933,
-0.0077352333,
-0.0110338246,
0.0265966021,
-0.0170931686,
-0.1070650071,
0.0265687685,
-0.030531995,
0.0082833776,
-0.0036767726,
-0.0630838126,
0.0270651244,
0.0429719388,
0.0570320599,
-0.0244401377,
0.0507459641,
-0.0070968363,
0.0446635447,
0.0765531212,
0.0017235755,
-0.039713636,
-0.0312633924,
0.0328021571,
0.0260213763,
-0.0677960292,
-0.0102426633,
0.0002090595,
-0.0309945028,
-0.0155768674,
-0.0226413999,
0.0727440119,
0.0102831125,
-0.0489981696,
0.015527688,
-0.0436606295,
0.0188460145,
0.0184577648,
0.0326317586,
-0.0493793003,
-0.0090999529,
-0.0096209599,
0.0327242389,
-0.0387930162,
-0.0516557768,
0.0439292043,
-0.0488071553,
0.0811573043,
-0.0349866413,
0.0257376786,
-0.0226424709,
-0.0642836615,
0.0183889996,
-0.0413397923,
-0.0301321261,
-0.0208930597,
-0.0460785441,
-0.0180730354,
0.0330788009,
-0.0126231918,
-0.05582745,
0.0093811546,
-0.0395555086,
-0.0228297468,
0.0415793508,
0.0407364592,
-0.0125810932,
-0.0499072336,
-0.0570466444,
-0.0222504456,
-0.0008540688,
-0.0068534892,
0.1020144895,
-0.0311498977,
-0.0134147489,
-0.0602181107,
0.0198361054,
-0.0136917811,
-0.026780786,
-0.0251186863,
0.0978735462,
-0.066398263,
-0.0131045114,
-0.0571790524,
-0.0193278585,
0.0458691381,
0.0461620092,
-0.0037520092,
-0.0408351347,
-0.0123274857,
0.0187084284,
0.0377771892,
0.0309976358,
-0.0568766296,
-0.0082458453,
0.0075241607,
-0.0616548061,
-0.0764491409,
-0.001555716,
-0.0214885008,
0.0150307054,
0.0178432912,
-0.0260182694,
-0.0235252064,
0.0252796616,
-0.1080685705,
0.0072353873,
0.026979601,
0.0244071372,
-0.0455512851,
0.0304554068,
0.0511143208,
-0.0034324983,
-0.0480812714,
-0.0109089613,
-0.0848741159,
-0.0343584418,
0.0235211998,
0.0377287194,
0.0306344368,
-0.0168748237,
-0.0089586247,
-0.0429534167,
0.0713657662,
0.0558438152,
-0.0107323164,
-0.0216321833,
0.0358345993,
-0.0483530462,
-0.0180592164,
0.0217149295,
-0.0302022211,
0.045616813,
-0.0152390385,
-0.0048929602,
-0.0321886726,
-0.0282105841,
0.0152360862,
0.0237567071,
0.0849680454,
-0.022104742,
-0.0109197171,
-0.0386220627,
-0.0074157161,
0.0402059853,
-0.0110689159,
-0.001201302,
-0.0061011445,
0.0225493591,
0.0153853856,
-0.0116692092,
0.0602007583,
-0.0153540308,
-0.0203659832,
-0.0658936054,
0.0466681942,
0.0157836284,
0.0051020985,
0.0350223929,
0.0201945379,
0.0188860316,
-0.0102051673,
0.0383881889,
0.0219635535,
-0.0211881492,
0.0242040381,
0.0219918136,
0.0127051696,
-0.0029030456,
0.0452366881,
-0.0683548152,
-0.0112273889,
-0.0277231745,
-0.0255310554,
0.024845127,
-0.016229989,
0.0185912531,
-0.0332732946,
-0.0138124377,
-0.0066687791,
0.0051196939,
-0.0265890043,
-0.0197358374,
0.0613601245,
0.0091838669,
-0.0092659108,
-0.0026929821,
0.060041938,
-0.0518659949,
0.0069002593,
0.007474741,
-0.0786558315,
-0.0189032424,
-0.0274463929,
0.0472593233,
0.0007313601,
-0.0314581282,
-0.0298562571,
-0.0625189245,
-0.0395309702,
0.0568078533,
-0.0410434268,
-0.0243314281,
-0.020294264,
0.045687478,
0.0407101959,
0.0411923714,
0.0147533258,
-0.0514900312,
-0.0199131146,
-0.0695377663,
-0.0039223968,
-0.0311580952,
-6.69165808e-33,
0.0288838409,
-0.0454328246,
-0.0080298781,
0.0045296587,
-0.0095161526,
0.0237124022,
0.0363489538,
-0.0069693732,
0.0138749275,
0.0111007737,
0.0065231002,
0.0059595383,
0.0013207037,
0.0046530557,
-0.0003681305,
-0.0583536103,
0.0127388919,
0.0163181871,
-0.0338239521,
0.0128233973,
0.0344591737,
0.0510670617,
0.0308476351,
-0.1034667194,
-0.0077469884,
0.0407222733,
-0.0079944562,
0.0233794097,
0.0096068317,
0.0948677436,
-0.0061198934,
0.073944442,
0.0355227217,
-0.0762661248,
0.0329235457,
0.036003232,
-0.0819602907,
-0.0219262373,
-0.0177440252,
-0.0162914153,
-0.0270797517,
-0.0006884624,
0.0290877093,
-0.015617175,
-0.0021286923,
-0.0200012438,
0.0695227906,
-0.0026134434,
-0.0100695994,
-0.0602137223,
-0.0045310776,
0.007602449,
-0.0026541508,
0.0111708809,
0.0309011601,
0.108046934,
0.0280438047,
0.0435308889,
-0.0544017516,
0.0451938882,
-0.0343536809,
-0.0146535244,
0.0331819132,
-0.0035809046,
-0.0313350707,
0.0754234195,
-0.0194114912,
-0.0462768823,
-0.0001994928,
-0.0534059778,
-0.0023924466,
0.0570247844,
0.0174361933,
0.0139630279,
0.02320089,
-0.0282356031,
-0.0621319413,
0.0602580123,
-0.00721086,
0.029536223,
0.063860409,
-0.0167346913,
-0.0696450621,
-0.0213861763,
-0.0010684133,
0.0123377563,
-0.0255018715,
-0.0330521055,
0.0343896337,
0.02232619,
-0.023144966,
0.0269743484,
-0.0048482814,
-0.0384302996,
0.0090509858,
0.0258682128,
0.0247675255,
0.0000760037,
-0.0132176122,
-0.024180891,
0.0013288625,
-0.007483568,
0.02921075,
-0.0121208383,
0.0245551653,
-0.0366784669,
0.0373757221,
0.0033616456,
-0.0522360951,
-0.0095670726,
0.0111601995,
0.0332628191,
-0.0265236665,
0.0804087892,
0.0058860211,
0.0310639236,
-0.0103037935,
0.0188224185,
0.0564161502,
0.0331972055,
-0.0353089161,
0.0063821445,
0.0242655911,
-0.0037661237,
0.0117186541,
0.0001723549,
-0.0276344623,
0.0431668125,
0.0267238282,
-0.0775570273,
-0.0016691091,
-0.0087002963,
3.04e-7,
0.0664391965,
0.0490742698,
-0.0017522383,
-0.0082978075,
0.0079254685,
0.0184026696,
0.0330259204,
0.0436843112,
0.0298903044,
0.0270780381,
0.0619356707,
0.0111870477,
0.0159036834,
0.0560548082,
-0.0637949854,
-0.0730237439,
-0.072697252,
-0.0119604105,
-0.0378171429,
0.0090009784,
0.0978075191,
0.0906537846,
0.0087122647,
-0.0349222906,
-0.0085006757,
-0.0211995784,
0.028656505,
-0.0459103435,
0.044723358,
-0.013644415,
0.0368457362,
0.0469603091,
0.0350899026,
0.0341038182,
-0.023948675,
0.0025612344,
0.0204094518,
0.0003488938,
-0.0072713802,
-0.011041184,
-0.0079481816,
0.02705428,
0.0183236767,
-0.0164551847,
0.0549123138,
-0.0839960575,
-0.0308109187,
0.0049990625,
-0.0344664045,
-0.0106708147,
0.0269576572,
-0.0310785137,
-0.0458328053,
0.0411224999,
0.0122622773,
0.0296449959,
0.0121723702,
-0.0879662558,
0.0116229365,
0.0095460229,
-0.0236733835,
-0.058456175,
-0.0223596431,
-0.0061125723,
0.0132927131,
-0.0511871874,
0.0005912084,
3.192546e-34,
0.005950388,
0.0410589352,
-0.0151107963,
0.0044655656,
-0.0059264121,
0.0002596088,
0.0164291598,
-0.0176381059,
0.0075096986,
-0.0786509812,
-0.0056806272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01468v1 | Remember what you did so you know what to do next | 2023-10-30T19:29:00 | 2023-10-30T19:29:00 | Manuel R. Ciosici, Alex Hedges, Yash Kankanampati, Justin Martin, Marjorie Freedman, Ralph Weischedel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We explore using a moderately sized large language model (GPT-J 6B
parameters) to create a plan for a simulated robot to achieve 30 classes of
goals in ScienceWorld, a text game simulator for elementary science
experiments. Previously published empirical work claimed that large language
models (LLMs) are a poor fit (Wang et al., 2022) compared to reinforcement
learning. Using the Markov assumption (a single previous step), the LLM
outperforms the reinforcement learning-based approach by a factor of 1.4. When
we fill the LLM's input buffer with as many prior steps as possible,
improvement rises to 3.5x. Even when training on only 6.5% of the training
data, we observe a 2.2x improvement over the reinforcement-learning-based
approach. Our experiments show that performance varies widely across the 30
classes of actions, indicating that averaging over tasks can hide significant
performance issues. In work contemporaneous with ours, Lin et al. (2023)
demonstrated a two-part approach (SwiftSage) that uses a small LLM (T5-large)
complemented by OpenAI's massive LLMs to achieve outstanding results in
ScienceWorld. Our 6-B parameter, single-stage GPT-J matches the performance of
SwiftSage's two-stage architecture when it incorporates GPT-3.5 turbo which has
29-times more parameters than GPT-J. | [
0.0378493629,
0.0208903998,
-0.0084844818,
0.0193516556,
-0.0193515345,
-0.0016122102,
-0.0001597572,
0.0060181022,
0.0056794723,
-0.0236095134,
-0.0424324907,
-0.0141137205,
-0.0137080625,
0.0381660648,
-0.0054446352,
-0.0533007756,
0.0605946183,
-0.0728926063,
0.0072562341,
-0.0117002903,
-0.0427764654,
-0.0327655077,
-0.0332125016,
0.0716980919,
0.0286464021,
0.00370652,
-0.0416868292,
-0.0228989627,
0.0130537655,
-0.0741605088,
-0.012781065,
0.0220057089,
0.0692302436,
0.0654135719,
0.0000023621,
-0.029979622,
0.029761821,
0.0017025005,
0.0094121341,
0.0299165808,
0.0619548112,
0.0166170988,
-0.033939708,
0.0211854521,
-0.0039126687,
-0.0247637946,
0.056443885,
0.0246440731,
0.0336051509,
0.0655593872,
0.0135266501,
-0.0368986242,
0.0248746723,
-0.0006312879,
0.0044677537,
-0.0425048023,
0.0259506479,
0.0200830065,
0.0818992108,
0.0051608193,
-0.0130840223,
0.0110672098,
0.0365309641,
-0.0053661065,
-0.0446215384,
0.1046762317,
-0.0078989882,
0.0070985965,
0.0045583514,
0.0104723191,
-0.0470774658,
-0.0186425094,
0.0046406877,
-0.0104715265,
-0.0207289197,
-0.0039439192,
-0.0401072279,
0.0599235259,
-0.0135718882,
0.008623437,
-0.0063317497,
-0.0215077028,
0.0287593734,
0.021845011,
-0.0322039649,
0.065685086,
0.0108118625,
-0.0328078158,
0.0008663996,
0.0119231697,
0.0066986172,
-0.0458547138,
-0.0101819029,
0.0516239256,
-0.0499049984,
0.028631296,
-0.0426883511,
0.0023062737,
0.0160802808,
-0.0469505563,
0.0488468781,
0.0330877081,
0.0352374241,
0.0295127183,
-0.0443849303,
0.0469013415,
-0.0308161285,
0.0430502109,
-0.0360480845,
0.0100797834,
-0.0742190257,
0.0007429543,
-0.0371139385,
0.0530043244,
-0.0138993161,
-0.0590345077,
-0.0347342305,
-0.0002417133,
0.0232481975,
0.0041094883,
0.0039483043,
-0.0228893682,
-0.0183282103,
0.0067630326,
-0.0527137034,
0.0003637121,
-0.0352880284,
0.0246872958,
0.0204725284,
-0.035961546,
-0.0252754949,
-0.0084781209,
-0.0341314562,
0.0032748161,
0.0164988618,
0.077536881,
0.0021438929,
-0.0420122743,
-0.0208766032,
0.0147010367,
-0.0026748579,
-0.0827986747,
0.0222121868,
-0.0396040231,
0.0017901863,
-0.0070150956,
0.0014209892,
0.0138103077,
0.026488414,
0.0236965567,
-0.0285405759,
0.0450686105,
0.0274288915,
0.010808087,
0.0303438492,
0.0095935399,
-0.0198852103,
0.0820964947,
0.0714166909,
0.0305392146,
-0.040589191,
0.0136355795,
0.0294001643,
0.0495049916,
-0.0192682613,
0.0093331868,
0.0059107053,
-0.0417162217,
0.0113428328,
0.0790770277,
0.0162881017,
0.0180375017,
-0.0411220863,
0.0476307198,
0.0612848848,
0.0569959171,
0.0023463098,
0.006340554,
0.0237855799,
0.0037810409,
0.028134929,
-0.0534063689,
-0.0315708257,
0.0439126119,
-0.0282962453,
0.0166244246,
-0.0222370382,
0.0319376811,
-0.0197228845,
-0.0120284576,
-0.0198990051,
-0.0010551139,
-0.0017269554,
0.0059670899,
0.0714639574,
-0.0322743654,
-0.0698360354,
-0.0246169567,
0.020496374,
-0.0256395862,
-0.0103823487,
-0.048736833,
0.0512283221,
0.0469833761,
0.0343035609,
-0.0811294913,
-0.0367981046,
0.0021631357,
-0.0124850525,
0.0873027369,
0.0581143163,
0.0197864566,
-0.0089634275,
-0.0450225584,
-0.0253456198,
-0.0474000797,
0.0017544441,
0.0532009602,
0.0440179631,
0.0333378315,
-0.022818638,
0.0238029696,
-0.0088722231,
0.0579791069,
-0.0383525193,
-0.034997426,
-0.0177844446,
-0.0462679453,
0.0654133707,
-0.034175124,
-0.0239992756,
-0.0000202437,
0.0234531183,
-0.0164221916,
-0.0099181607,
-0.0230956953,
-0.0431465507,
-0.0272479374,
0.0378455445,
0.0139601687,
0.0080222916,
0.0389592126,
-0.0085322466,
-0.0419086739,
-0.0077023185,
-0.0262044128,
0.0358214378,
0.0063029919,
0.0255678594,
-0.0271033403,
-0.0180849377,
-0.028481612,
0.0275613964,
0.0052912226,
0.0165039804,
0.0028481139,
0.0131930457,
0.0191870071,
-0.0425339527,
-0.0125768771,
0.0458252877,
0.0146951927,
-0.0071534705,
0.0280576497,
-0.0029437733,
-0.0528285429,
-0.0430680849,
-0.0622361749,
-0.0109078158,
0.0102904327,
-0.0037599895,
-0.0056131561,
-0.0262523033,
-0.0208450574,
0.0389165804,
0.0216611531,
0.0430770405,
-0.007808391,
-0.0181055441,
0.0208766516,
0.0215872806,
-0.0388928913,
-0.0455134027,
0.0084983865,
-0.0361166,
0.0231579319,
0.0115187205,
0.003054844,
-0.0743401796,
0.0540017411,
-0.0041646417,
0.0409926511,
-0.02047012,
-0.0654134974,
0.0718351826,
-0.0657727122,
0.0514925495,
0.0671800822,
-0.0023935807,
0.0047302279,
0.1016078293,
-0.0083868066,
-0.0579901785,
0.0486075245,
-0.0197913423,
-0.0318586268,
-0.0327982046,
-0.0047708955,
0.0289814919,
0.0664139017,
-0.0264564585,
0.0056957658,
-0.0606470332,
0.002367964,
-0.0213571601,
-0.0343709961,
0.0046805982,
-0.0026713298,
-0.0442560017,
-0.0396012403,
-0.0173424724,
-0.0117881466,
0.0543679632,
-0.0242177676,
0.0032649138,
-0.0401985534,
-0.0059178285,
-0.0084207579,
0.0632715896,
0.0235855933,
0.0059502348,
-0.0272901226,
-0.0040218332,
-0.0002572497,
0.019115787,
-0.0171969067,
0.0050007333,
0.0198394582,
-0.0765357614,
0.0264215264,
-0.0064543351,
-0.0466497764,
-0.0350047909,
0.0061737844,
-0.0593057796,
0.0254682638,
-0.0106514832,
-0.0672474653,
-0.0716167688,
-0.0024727404,
0.0830176622,
0.0785570145,
-0.0307218861,
-0.0183334667,
-0.0341479294,
-0.0089400196,
0.0381522886,
0.0099046268,
0.0293482784,
-0.0651701614,
0.075309284,
0.0175511036,
0.0628943816,
-0.0008775778,
-0.0581240356,
-0.0262394045,
0.0183770116,
-0.0315711051,
-0.0017503127,
0.0680452809,
0.0381710902,
-0.0833028853,
-0.0603387728,
0.0899858624,
0.0034246063,
-0.0094025116,
-0.0097582554,
0.0042383643,
0.0385706834,
0.0010411458,
0.0471086688,
-0.0222261455,
-0.0223854259,
0.0112093361,
0.0030978704,
-0.0041236659,
-0.0232565273,
-0.0080502592,
-0.135305658,
0.0275955852,
0.0221748427,
-0.1004832238,
-0.0282558203,
-0.0547633581,
-0.0334304273,
-0.0137717603,
-0.0130783292,
0.0320208631,
0.0174484011,
-0.0078341644,
0.005984955,
0.004675488,
-0.0484248027,
0.0163856111,
-0.0307788029,
0.0444614887,
0.0473567955,
0.0096614566,
-0.0384827033,
0.020336844,
0.0450542197,
0.0082502346,
0.0257387552,
0.0058910181,
0.0126912221,
0.0102352034,
0.0030049505,
-0.0053893849,
0.0075809625,
-0.0213545132,
-0.0399771668,
0.0009430266,
0.096444793,
-0.0212499984,
-0.0596351177,
-0.0193050522,
-0.0296004023,
-0.0168262143,
0.0807645768,
-0.0115797315,
-0.0401956066,
-0.0615762025,
-0.0220472012,
-0.0504883677,
-0.0511360504,
-0.0194104314,
-0.0054471185,
-0.0032807472,
0.0138522089,
-0.0386750996,
-0.0316997804,
0.0198648125,
0.0305135045,
0.0036225123,
0.0273513403,
0.0219156593,
0.0344680436,
-0.0024614616,
0.0059563951,
-0.0416899137,
0.004930845,
-0.0685037822,
-0.00784826,
0.0657928139,
-0.0253309365,
0.0048787403,
0.0090631573,
-0.0537581481,
-0.0424820371,
-0.0019808998,
0.080844678,
0.0163548477,
-0.0096580312,
0.0283956658,
-0.0280429889,
0.0400415175,
0.0044655511,
0.0056999149,
0.0295352731,
-0.0156281795,
0.0250378773,
0.0351305194,
-0.0095307278,
-0.0406165682,
0.0118026556,
-0.0100535192,
0.0452518277,
-0.0190822557,
0.0047380771,
-0.0029072675,
0.0081707733,
0.0555436723,
-0.0179594308,
-0.0282803215,
-0.0280489307,
-0.0029666943,
-0.031965144,
0.0225754976,
-0.0446964428,
0.0054777935,
0.0276960507,
-0.000924821,
0.014891712,
-0.0056297746,
0.0050917128,
0.0149284434,
-0.0056747813,
0.0167425834,
0.0374867544,
0.0481308438,
0.0439551547,
-0.0046864017,
-0.0204544943,
-0.0258453619,
-0.0159139298,
0.0296972264,
0.0063613565,
0.0581518561,
0.0284504406,
-0.0177011583,
-0.0128052989,
-0.0015268154,
-0.0680605844,
-0.0684808418,
-0.0188268907,
0.0595873557,
0.0502891988,
0.0180830602,
0.0066909534,
-0.0937745944,
-0.0023157597,
-0.0215869788,
-0.0123949759,
0.0046424228,
-0.0188348293,
0.0539025478,
0.0416410975,
-0.0027075347,
-0.0166437309,
0.0648558065,
0.0122262528,
0.0797535852,
0.0194665249,
0.0082017882,
-0.030195199,
-0.0187918227,
-0.0087815626,
0.0534649007,
-0.0065103858,
-0.0301104225,
-0.0302799102,
0.0095932866,
-0.0406734198,
0.0239455029,
0.0119216852,
-0.0446864255,
0.0563031696,
0.0040228437,
-0.023949651,
-0.0366549157,
-0.0008590768,
-0.0071530808,
-0.00595782,
-0.0266880691,
0.0072598932,
-6.190484594e-33,
-0.0137164285,
-0.0081189768,
0.0739246979,
-0.0150074307,
-0.0359562933,
0.0071601998,
-0.0524258204,
-0.011575575,
-0.0261964239,
0.0072834068,
-0.0168173797,
-0.0001093534,
0.0062370342,
0.0151126618,
0.0411945023,
0.0185945388,
0.0294403285,
-0.0169033594,
-0.0436101556,
-0.0043596113,
0.0232026018,
0.0002898242,
0.0202355292,
-0.0398718901,
-0.0484353155,
0.0182722732,
-0.0292582624,
-0.0132824192,
-0.0490014851,
0.0221658926,
-0.0291872658,
0.0178100318,
-0.0105983028,
-0.0649338141,
-0.0237879716,
0.0180435553,
-0.0171413943,
-0.0384437442,
-0.0257631894,
-0.0039839926,
0.0016023866,
-0.0379616097,
0.0347187966,
0.0175801329,
-0.0633333772,
0.003290761,
0.0088390056,
-0.0291529763,
-0.030897053,
-0.0045338161,
-0.0564539693,
0.0116043612,
0.0422029942,
-0.0242561903,
0.0446199998,
0.0154939201,
-0.0227761697,
0.0451377332,
0.0136996536,
0.0353775136,
0.0310711246,
0.0156546235,
0.0454866812,
0.0561971739,
0.0557624102,
0.0642363876,
0.063725926,
0.0145435408,
-0.0361483842,
-0.0489479303,
0.042039521,
0.0045338678,
0.0626543015,
0.0164481569,
0.0326628126,
0.0255030338,
-0.0678785741,
0.0288175698,
0.0444614366,
0.0432838239,
0.0417962819,
0.0158987902,
-0.028826531,
-0.0118478555,
-0.0269439891,
0.0236017946,
-0.0016509636,
-0.0160524752,
0.0511820689,
0.0036899941,
0.0301688351,
-0.0573844761,
0.0435313918,
-0.0187128,
-0.0071174204,
0.0411626436,
-0.0295642931,
0.0585709475,
-0.0180969909,
0.0003040475,
-0.0813765675,
-0.0902335644,
0.0131200841,
-0.0093492242,
0.0030340033,
0.0439412519,
-0.0478138439,
0.0510949455,
-0.0398745388,
-0.0061301016,
-0.0128648952,
-0.0343762822,
0.0673846453,
0.0039023887,
0.0501121357,
-0.0507499054,
0.018439129,
0.0513358526,
-0.0019076645,
-0.0516420677,
0.0038490854,
-0.0043483768,
-0.0381437317,
0.0043484075,
0.0077158068,
0.0075556426,
-0.068891421,
0.0186975747,
-0.0213730074,
-0.0607133321,
-0.0282326695,
0.0316310748,
3.003e-7,
-0.0154607687,
0.0809124783,
-0.018918002,
0.0199329052,
-0.0097528677,
0.0312497802,
-0.0266762562,
-0.0038621221,
-0.001603847,
0.0366718285,
0.0144352624,
0.0281552635,
0.0249125678,
0.0063359239,
-0.0912329108,
-0.0328857265,
-0.0237136688,
-0.0034829914,
-0.0619110391,
-0.0111535303,
0.0006902707,
0.0845049843,
0.0310518108,
-0.0001858311,
0.0354510546,
-0.0378938019,
0.0503137596,
-0.0477316268,
0.0264223274,
0.0206950083,
-0.0293865204,
0.0116315437,
-0.0332224146,
0.0092493305,
-0.0029826458,
0.0112476982,
-0.0207379647,
0.0688497201,
-0.0092146164,
0.0016792698,
0.061374709,
0.0202740934,
0.0096740974,
-0.0684944168,
0.0250295531,
-0.0666435584,
0.0204614419,
0.0121242264,
0.0208088681,
-0.0508671068,
-0.0083693713,
-0.0413040295,
0.0097698895,
0.0025305592,
-0.0489077494,
-0.0022918873,
-0.0008241234,
-0.0627864078,
-0.010150684,
0.0430621654,
-0.0697504282,
-0.035006091,
-0.0790258422,
0.0010451137,
0.0327037871,
-0.0709040761,
-0.0149054574,
2.821516591e-34,
0.0145472968,
-0.0707167089,
0.0164336301,
0.026578458,
-0.00360225,
0.0420584865,
0.0385934226,
0.0407774113,
0.0538091026,
-0.0664804727,
-0.0404904261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19956v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19956v2 | The Impact of Depth on Compositional Generalization in Transformer Language Models | 2023-10-30T19:10:06 | 2024-04-10T18:06:14 | Jackson Petty, Sjoerd van Steenkiste, Ishita Dasgupta, Fei Sha, Dan Garrette, Tal Linzen | cs.CL | cs.CL | To process novel sentences, language models (LMs) must generalize
compositionally -- combine familiar elements in new ways. What aspects of a
model's structure promote compositional generalization? Focusing on
transformers, we test the hypothesis, motivated by theoretical and empirical
work, that deeper transformers generalize more compositionally. Simply adding
layers increases the total number of parameters; to address this confound
between depth and size, we construct three classes of models which trade off
depth for width such that the total number of parameters is kept constant (41M,
134M and 374M parameters). We pretrain all models as LMs and fine-tune them on
tasks that test for compositional generalization. We report three main
conclusions: (1) after fine-tuning, deeper models generalize more
compositionally than shallower models do, but the benefit of additional layers
diminishes rapidly; (2) within each family, deeper models show better language
modeling performance, but returns are similarly diminishing; (3) the benefits
of depth for compositional generalization cannot be attributed solely to better
performance on language modeling. Because model latency is approximately linear
in the number of layers, these results lead us to the recommendation that, with
a given total parameter budget, transformers can be made shallower than is
typical without sacrificing performance. | [
0.055752147,
0.0397106409,
-0.0257413983,
0.0076133911,
-0.015656881,
0.0214778148,
0.0106425704,
-0.0305709075,
-0.0736410171,
-0.024819538,
-0.0290449187,
-0.0687905625,
0.0268047582,
0.0307666101,
0.0417381488,
-0.0949753448,
0.0319629014,
-0.0428556316,
-0.0359614342,
-0.015643999,
-0.0308114067,
-0.0103074871,
0.0198166911,
0.0540250875,
0.0147028742,
0.0284597501,
-0.045553036,
-0.0104749342,
-0.0050910362,
0.0117328186,
0.0098012118,
0.0488025211,
0.027153803,
0.0552519262,
0.0000019347,
-0.0356307738,
0.0143490657,
-0.0105081024,
0.0087233987,
0.0039315028,
0.016961541,
-0.0343813039,
0.0193198137,
0.016045101,
-0.0140298596,
-0.055322852,
0.0606716387,
0.0737613067,
0.0181081742,
0.0581723042,
-0.0159090925,
-0.0678670853,
0.0222585555,
-0.0424632281,
-0.0124568865,
-0.0044768122,
0.0164463315,
-0.0247313473,
-0.0115798349,
0.0010463313,
-0.0559109151,
0.0092469621,
0.0354340598,
0.0253043473,
0.0106891813,
0.0604935624,
-0.0067923171,
-0.0282514002,
0.0070046587,
0.026547689,
-0.0496664979,
-0.009782088,
-0.0166969765,
-0.0066126604,
-0.0040699062,
-0.0197487269,
-0.0383074954,
0.0318419859,
-0.0109451124,
-0.0068743005,
-0.0166046117,
-0.0090769362,
0.0346933939,
-0.0197818577,
-0.0422794446,
0.0432835706,
0.0287757199,
-0.0527931787,
0.0022978317,
0.0096393246,
0.0279388987,
-0.0648126006,
-0.0011604086,
0.0306785535,
0.0003377876,
0.0117960637,
-0.0128580714,
-0.0226437468,
0.0073656561,
-0.0404987596,
0.0717559606,
0.044742994,
-0.0179880466,
0.0074080899,
-0.0444016904,
0.0593675002,
-0.0337289013,
0.0450278223,
-0.0589564815,
-0.002184028,
-0.0275593176,
-0.0551484749,
-0.0712005496,
0.0339501128,
0.0046510603,
-0.0232677646,
-0.0598399714,
0.0250868611,
0.0228091311,
-0.0345427878,
0.0295106135,
0.0018164756,
-0.055994451,
-0.0213044453,
-0.0023193518,
0.0356912352,
-0.0108936084,
0.0404053703,
0.0210668761,
-0.0337714925,
-0.0042675301,
-0.02760287,
0.0183966458,
-0.0236600246,
0.0065809088,
0.0510218255,
-0.0129622733,
-0.0540398993,
-0.0006294565,
0.0209490545,
-0.0218600985,
-0.071252279,
0.0269535966,
-0.0570818037,
0.0326835997,
0.0089688934,
0.0136441691,
-0.0046872436,
-0.0086489925,
0.018683156,
-0.0181991793,
0.0354862288,
0.0404329486,
0.0260878894,
0.0192712992,
0.0043203407,
-0.0034762372,
0.0653818622,
0.034099903,
0.0246959664,
-0.01545229,
-0.0463124514,
0.008509431,
0.0117632141,
-0.0263735,
-0.0132722072,
-0.0026393875,
-0.0340011418,
-0.0394872725,
0.0225089081,
0.0177814346,
0.0633274317,
-0.0422637276,
-0.0069476222,
0.067676954,
0.0427896567,
0.0737809837,
0.0528324693,
0.0867541358,
-0.02509184,
0.0017812349,
0.04859633,
-0.0449513756,
0.0236235969,
0.0030804919,
0.0344713442,
-0.0285747256,
0.035022039,
-0.0434542,
-0.035897173,
-0.0392527096,
-0.0185469333,
0.0432853922,
-0.0292262677,
0.0453733876,
0.0419378914,
-0.0466350131,
0.0763751715,
0.0239100438,
-0.0651784465,
-0.0018606039,
-0.0265415255,
0.00534902,
0.0319388881,
-0.0106170047,
-0.0007677787,
-0.0090314988,
0.0208170488,
0.0107384538,
0.0584182702,
0.0758729801,
0.0080282073,
0.0415019356,
-0.0438401476,
-0.017106289,
-0.0354287252,
0.0283629708,
0.0304344613,
0.0271644592,
-0.028358575,
0.0193567742,
-0.0251072366,
-0.0009994656,
0.0365347601,
-0.0290441196,
0.00142899,
-0.026832724,
0.0156952664,
0.0049890629,
-0.0295548253,
0.0240733381,
0.022936983,
-0.0050580809,
-0.0389764644,
-0.0642401874,
0.0258890428,
-0.0779529735,
0.0098019335,
-0.0095528476,
-0.0327809192,
0.0324192457,
0.0404257216,
-0.0116106197,
-0.0349856913,
0.0353752449,
-0.0640336573,
0.0613798946,
-0.024082398,
0.0259047132,
-0.034731131,
0.0110387551,
-0.0260788593,
0.0414583124,
-0.0024206142,
0.0028705611,
-0.0124015855,
-0.0337569304,
-0.0050024735,
-0.0198640451,
-0.052467864,
0.0042249514,
-0.0243095048,
0.0020990735,
0.0050477749,
-0.0319649838,
-0.0142388726,
-0.0550523698,
-0.0574521311,
-0.0220470447,
-0.0164708979,
-0.0069248565,
0.0010588893,
0.0391619354,
0.008944734,
0.0082962587,
-0.0214877781,
0.0133689949,
0.0082944306,
0.0498307273,
0.019013714,
0.019901149,
-0.0402600169,
-0.0337395482,
-0.0449919812,
-0.0042533888,
0.0742814541,
-0.0305658355,
-0.0034199993,
-0.0601266399,
0.0071974336,
-0.0260223392,
0.0264350697,
-0.023192605,
-0.077295579,
-0.0016895195,
-0.0110478681,
0.0660629943,
0.0593405478,
0.0203833412,
0.0205043778,
0.0692250431,
0.0044418601,
-0.007374391,
0.0335223675,
-0.0532792173,
-0.0146163013,
-0.0665240809,
-0.0037180171,
-0.0076223593,
0.1363581866,
-0.0156530347,
-0.012322207,
-0.0715548024,
-0.0081475051,
-0.0336795636,
-0.0077056731,
0.0214951355,
-0.0531156212,
-0.0321919695,
0.0390755571,
-0.0279294103,
-0.0498468131,
0.0564694405,
-0.0261034165,
-0.0180124715,
-0.0074093794,
-0.0013933473,
-0.0582812354,
0.0694531053,
0.026114149,
0.0158867333,
-0.0017367534,
-0.0490507297,
-0.0800963193,
0.0401486456,
0.0350837,
0.004570791,
0.0691051856,
0.0060089603,
-0.0239332803,
-0.029172631,
-0.0499668345,
-0.0365851112,
0.0202120375,
-0.0406284221,
0.0251528844,
0.0561255626,
-0.0103164902,
-0.0540460795,
0.0250132103,
0.0122004058,
0.0532755293,
0.0036905317,
-0.0119697405,
-0.0069323187,
-0.0115597276,
0.004274894,
0.0373701416,
0.0335555896,
-0.051178962,
0.0438532643,
0.0073484299,
-0.0224362593,
0.008286518,
-0.0450384319,
0.00275476,
0.0265273694,
-0.0202028509,
-0.0373567119,
0.0094924262,
0.0369921103,
-0.063921541,
-0.0248506051,
0.0728757456,
-0.0058249324,
-0.0250328071,
0.019670032,
-0.006048644,
0.0361493118,
0.0345191546,
0.0294032078,
-0.0444924571,
0.0179853477,
0.0247015767,
-0.0360440984,
-0.0026229001,
0.0088396166,
-0.0133946799,
-0.1010353193,
-0.0028241051,
-0.0051215678,
-0.047999572,
-0.0109218499,
-0.0357657373,
-0.0130675118,
0.0112988446,
0.0060123,
0.0317980722,
-0.0367278792,
-0.050224226,
0.0253963508,
-0.0489767939,
-0.0502383821,
0.0094992695,
-0.0219145436,
-0.0272466112,
0.0196064077,
-0.007896943,
-0.0172488093,
-0.031736169,
0.0621376224,
0.0055189407,
0.0323705189,
0.0320158228,
0.0428941101,
0.0094773946,
-0.0068134945,
0.0076092188,
-0.008775454,
0.0006834211,
-0.0075934543,
-0.060130626,
0.0357332677,
0.0047652377,
-0.0686187446,
-0.0118577015,
0.0202208981,
-0.0435100459,
0.0565806217,
0.0538161434,
-0.0414395481,
-0.0252573192,
-0.0147397919,
-0.0127496924,
-0.057504449,
-0.0221104361,
0.046231281,
0.0316867121,
-0.0098532075,
-0.0392408296,
-0.010471669,
-0.0069813896,
0.025819499,
0.0128198992,
-0.0170099474,
0.0104602072,
0.005264556,
-0.0195034724,
0.0151730534,
0.0070456602,
0.0182807893,
-0.038191203,
-0.0066184257,
0.0124271205,
-0.0378322303,
-0.0354428366,
-0.0484434515,
-0.1360853016,
-0.0656158552,
0.0436468646,
0.0430180244,
0.0234733969,
0.0241608135,
0.0122420089,
-0.0686493963,
0.0457030125,
-0.0143790189,
0.0001009952,
0.0535835735,
0.0580305345,
-0.0438283496,
0.0071436106,
0.0238516033,
-0.0485365242,
0.035014011,
0.0376064703,
0.0147546567,
0.0281715561,
-0.0061669876,
0.0130046578,
-0.0350107141,
0.033588171,
0.0042767688,
0.042431172,
-0.0384479351,
0.0471495315,
-0.0426986292,
0.0054746312,
-0.0424615517,
-0.0316909067,
0.0317479819,
0.0408104174,
0.0072333314,
0.0028409185,
0.0063982368,
0.0473255999,
-0.021669928,
0.0178546607,
0.0380560495,
-0.0390172638,
0.0530113764,
0.0467035361,
-0.0385450199,
0.0149023114,
-0.0258807689,
-0.017491268,
0.0026615208,
0.0056400183,
0.0060361833,
0.0147976903,
-0.0770585462,
0.0075087147,
-0.0926067457,
-0.0352010466,
-0.0121417372,
-0.015666537,
0.0330473036,
-0.0294311959,
0.0179584846,
-0.0243202355,
-0.0041226693,
-0.004236429,
0.01517238,
-0.0024966933,
-0.046555113,
0.0485256761,
0.0291196126,
-0.0043439073,
-0.0234570801,
0.0837199166,
0.0311996676,
0.0531670637,
-0.0171706863,
0.0437121503,
-0.0081504434,
-0.0070901462,
0.0156147433,
0.0468524732,
-0.0185771249,
-0.017225951,
-0.0493143238,
-0.0399598777,
0.0192935374,
-0.0241466444,
0.0458335616,
-0.0212373342,
0.0419033244,
0.0720782131,
0.0110303387,
-0.0246543363,
0.0125434725,
-0.0561394058,
0.0151199857,
0.0308913346,
-0.0158233922,
-6.111768349e-33,
-0.0103563713,
0.0238629673,
0.0171717349,
-0.0030011244,
-0.0513163581,
0.0308003742,
-0.0184294656,
0.0294188391,
-0.0152470674,
0.0151672522,
-0.0052713691,
0.015175214,
0.0080568669,
0.0236642491,
0.0238360856,
0.0053380975,
0.0785381272,
0.0170766003,
-0.0130864521,
-0.0059678969,
0.0047347271,
0.0322344378,
0.0706852749,
0.0156098008,
-0.033049874,
0.0096360371,
-0.0138551481,
0.007328188,
-0.0161441788,
0.0838635042,
-0.0168622639,
0.0349907838,
0.039767392,
-0.0358123258,
-0.0443101078,
0.0374423265,
-0.046380043,
-0.0092852814,
0.0169908535,
0.0096924286,
-0.0417878106,
-0.0169911832,
0.0503047742,
-0.0154984649,
0.0120779518,
-0.0849549323,
0.0282460712,
-0.0191348121,
-0.0427493528,
-0.0560495555,
-0.078032583,
-0.0036813195,
0.0153630702,
-0.0109547507,
0.0027988853,
0.0475449599,
-0.0088830106,
0.0334248915,
-0.0179755557,
0.024966618,
0.0228731185,
0.0454398096,
0.0154725537,
0.0412929766,
-0.0098824492,
0.0288121346,
0.0090218419,
0.0402327105,
-0.0469997637,
-0.0092666335,
0.0528841428,
0.0532694273,
0.0431819074,
0.0140766157,
0.0512613989,
-0.0157062188,
-0.0283232108,
-0.0343737453,
-0.0432507955,
0.0640659928,
0.0379254892,
0.0269219149,
-0.0024653375,
-0.0268532075,
-0.0577787757,
-0.0066397097,
-0.0242544375,
-0.0276413523,
0.0268401075,
0.0618499555,
0.0031389659,
-0.0453620106,
0.0382922217,
-0.0261094756,
0.014679742,
0.0102785053,
-0.0353806876,
0.0377583988,
-0.0138309682,
0.0014891503,
-0.0265543908,
-0.0406394005,
0.0224504154,
0.0465448201,
-0.0011924265,
0.008840166,
0.0522997901,
0.0542124435,
-0.064735122,
-0.0172649994,
-0.0413347073,
0.0005400652,
0.0153873768,
0.0762462392,
0.0518056341,
0.0238292255,
-0.0294957664,
0.0388440862,
-0.0245719925,
-0.0004915537,
-0.0465227515,
0.0142865591,
0.01256142,
0.058887694,
-0.0042498847,
-0.0136728054,
-0.0483158454,
-0.0230618622,
0.0806141272,
-0.0462349951,
-0.0386773907,
0.0385194905,
2.6e-7,
0.0268713422,
0.0295375995,
0.0308628418,
0.0138562089,
0.029242482,
-0.0178994872,
0.0070294063,
0.0204190351,
0.0019521562,
0.0245655496,
-0.0043023271,
0.0201558918,
0.047173284,
0.0223914906,
-0.0880452096,
-0.0184572358,
-0.1152036339,
0.0175632294,
-0.0432286374,
-0.0077920333,
0.0183932539,
0.1021733209,
0.0054062246,
-0.0102226185,
-0.0177610125,
-0.0186419021,
0.0755444691,
-0.0129387351,
0.0347277187,
0.0313042514,
0.0365767702,
0.0481022336,
0.0327623561,
0.0094079943,
-0.0156808905,
0.0319870412,
0.0099586323,
0.0369352773,
0.0058948733,
-0.001383602,
0.0466883332,
0.0161348563,
-0.034846466,
-0.0857578889,
0.0293742176,
-0.1193051115,
-0.0115148565,
-0.0250242874,
0.0062193717,
0.0073455665,
0.0174123067,
-0.018002525,
0.0117703062,
0.0233089253,
0.0193756148,
-0.0082742581,
0.0058152257,
-0.0951742753,
-0.0430784188,
0.026966339,
-0.0455481336,
-0.0148083111,
-0.0500656739,
-0.0568158291,
0.0637298003,
-0.0122957621,
-0.0286109503,
2.453718184e-34,
0.0413586423,
-0.0235312991,
0.0269589759,
0.016971359,
0.0092191026,
-0.0369740985,
0.0202379934,
0.0181216747,
-0.0008352103,
-0.0843257084,
-0.0279947799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19942v1 | Split-NER: Named Entity Recognition via Two Question-Answering-based Classifications | 2023-10-30T18:57:28 | 2023-10-30T18:57:28 | Jatin Arora, Youngja Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.2.7; H.3.3 | In this work, we address the NER problem by splitting it into two logical
sub-tasks: (1) Span Detection which simply extracts entity mention spans
irrespective of entity type; (2) Span Classification which classifies the spans
into their entity types. Further, we formulate both sub-tasks as
question-answering (QA) problems and produce two leaner models which can be
optimized separately for each sub-task. Experiments with four cross-domain
datasets demonstrate that this two-step approach is both effective and time
efficient. Our system, SplitNER outperforms baselines on OntoNotes5.0, WNUT17
and a cybersecurity dataset and gives on-par performance on BioNLP13CG. In all
cases, it achieves a significant reduction in training time compared to its QA
baseline counterpart. The effectiveness of our system stems from fine-tuning
the BERT model twice, separately for span detection and classification. The
source code can be found at https://github.com/c3sr/split-ner. | [
0.0584403686,
0.0126039926,
0.0278086178,
0.0572811477,
0.0192854609,
0.0302680451,
0.0161051061,
0.0101196133,
0.0310572628,
-0.053930562,
0.0026799086,
-0.0077988752,
-0.0248847231,
0.0227715205,
0.0357854031,
-0.0266576037,
0.038091898,
-0.0077506397,
0.0330313593,
0.0160172563,
0.019029906,
0.0149939246,
-0.0511197858,
0.0123379603,
0.0208242703,
0.0207457598,
-0.0303547475,
0.0046702577,
0.0420369692,
-0.0315981545,
0.0533278137,
0.0367394984,
-0.0005744217,
0.0303417817,
0.0000017712,
-0.0661867931,
-0.0507126227,
0.0256067291,
-0.0107497973,
-0.0080378465,
-0.0237035919,
-0.0071544829,
0.0292396173,
0.0321602114,
0.0073326575,
-0.023541268,
-0.0197995417,
0.0895299092,
0.0603482351,
0.080616951,
0.0008555383,
-0.0103770616,
0.0592532568,
0.0052234745,
0.0127492733,
-0.0416414291,
0.0375005342,
-0.0430333018,
-0.0011314178,
0.0084294146,
0.0107471393,
0.0112556405,
-0.0163400229,
0.020828126,
0.0298905447,
0.0318773352,
-0.0740843862,
0.0133551257,
-0.0219540112,
0.074487187,
0.0126314471,
0.0466406196,
0.0784590244,
0.002522144,
0.0023965188,
-0.0147260576,
0.0106331725,
-0.0164942127,
-0.0607751161,
-0.0113550313,
-0.0064031011,
-0.0231608748,
-0.0076521374,
0.004534835,
-0.0371632241,
0.0266713034,
0.0169958882,
-0.0446748063,
0.0135862846,
0.0190815125,
-0.0091110589,
-0.0574894473,
0.0579837561,
0.0628336966,
0.0037053814,
0.0265558008,
-0.0127700996,
-0.0254141111,
0.0114632966,
-0.0167279188,
-0.0387614965,
-0.0122751836,
-0.0180193298,
0.0168188382,
-0.0587128401,
0.0176824499,
-0.0207200591,
-0.0157663226,
0.0062779216,
-0.0319897756,
-0.0479770117,
-0.0246206056,
-0.047918994,
0.0556376763,
-0.056194853,
-0.004452419,
-0.0087536657,
-0.0077416115,
0.0154893715,
0.0213085916,
0.0150301149,
0.0037758234,
0.0233766343,
0.0420234762,
-0.0085748285,
0.0376015119,
-0.0483865365,
0.0006898962,
-0.0215049442,
-0.0280148014,
-0.0069698719,
-0.0221277848,
0.0273408033,
-0.033139579,
0.041352734,
0.057196416,
0.0252860207,
-0.0884454399,
-0.0417678766,
-0.0113394419,
-0.0405560099,
-0.0457608812,
-0.0037021763,
-0.0254085101,
0.0316647775,
0.0204051379,
-0.008202252,
0.0112970332,
0.0236229375,
-0.0053066607,
-0.054991167,
0.0711350888,
-0.0341090485,
-0.0226091426,
0.0489279218,
0.004862986,
0.0657265633,
0.0514567122,
0.0620482378,
-0.0172587,
0.0459857509,
0.025791768,
-0.0204216,
0.0328833051,
0.0427230895,
0.0084689595,
0.0569675304,
0.0421118215,
-0.0271664169,
-0.0154190836,
0.0036203242,
0.0298509803,
0.0123599702,
-0.012972137,
-0.0083518233,
0.036591392,
-0.0075351,
0.0194947533,
0.0171134714,
0.0219247397,
0.0127543379,
0.0016683802,
-0.0093116919,
0.0019862307,
-0.0267584119,
0.0157906413,
0.039930094,
0.0249456037,
-0.0476029031,
0.0115981493,
-0.0114374356,
-0.0084678587,
-0.0266268123,
0.0193206053,
0.0476005301,
0.0131494515,
-0.0756825581,
0.1242610738,
0.0280691404,
-0.0491719991,
0.0168952476,
-0.029481465,
0.0396137834,
0.0312687233,
0.0001767401,
-0.0382995084,
-0.0711282119,
-0.0424083509,
-0.0239964891,
0.0685452819,
-0.0146605996,
-0.0219750479,
0.0400274619,
-0.0184938889,
-0.0075115985,
-0.028592227,
0.0042684791,
0.0195319522,
0.0304081123,
0.0392333008,
0.0096408539,
-0.0476547144,
-0.018053364,
0.0340048559,
-0.0254952703,
0.0018405543,
0.0092037665,
0.0384447016,
0.0114812143,
0.0557149351,
0.0059024678,
-0.0017537707,
0.013093329,
-0.0373362303,
-0.0325456411,
-0.026799567,
0.0186528731,
-0.0926131085,
0.003700715,
-0.0413974151,
-0.0092963846,
0.0122995554,
-0.0253391992,
-0.0606903546,
-0.0510887578,
-0.0221476015,
0.0024769122,
-0.012054936,
0.0012944107,
0.0144043267,
-0.0252311267,
-0.0322524607,
0.0478752702,
-0.0080507426,
0.0474811383,
0.0013007316,
-0.0034324185,
0.0287796389,
-0.0205702111,
-0.0554824285,
-0.0075992015,
-0.0081882244,
-0.0295453146,
0.0360873342,
0.0117104826,
-0.0794341192,
-0.0424826331,
-0.0828238875,
0.0176660288,
-0.0144778211,
0.0608663633,
0.0287528224,
0.0256372727,
-0.0166749414,
-0.0301703624,
-0.0303440243,
-0.0184284411,
-0.0097982502,
0.0012345368,
0.0460429639,
0.0128339445,
-0.0062935683,
-0.0114070419,
0.0195382573,
-0.0457565822,
0.0046290071,
0.0152183222,
-0.0439132527,
-0.066222325,
0.009833348,
-0.0411072262,
0.0013431982,
0.0163227804,
0.0179813337,
0.0009181779,
0.0195643343,
0.0225673951,
0.0127376532,
0.0234668329,
0.0386810191,
-0.0300789196,
0.0220921841,
-0.0436801873,
0.0548511818,
0.0001252266,
0.0350233354,
-0.0175353549,
-0.0488303602,
0.0409252755,
0.0894141421,
-0.0121148461,
0.0076511372,
-0.0584432818,
-0.0328274891,
-0.008831881,
-0.0325245485,
-0.0061044428,
0.0096086115,
-0.0189474747,
0.0040749605,
-0.012612029,
0.0087574041,
0.0715530738,
-0.0441063009,
-0.0356368236,
-0.0387362465,
-0.0014927909,
-0.0866718367,
0.0326740257,
-0.0128831211,
0.0059264051,
0.0446287543,
-0.0867407098,
0.0033329483,
0.0142892832,
-0.0135944095,
-0.0216003135,
0.0372158177,
0.0251941625,
0.0259595569,
-0.0225668307,
-0.0377434939,
-0.0553475544,
-0.0214720443,
-0.0475941412,
0.0126352897,
-0.0350502096,
-0.0234811939,
-0.0066882223,
0.0536734983,
0.0047686743,
0.0289796982,
-0.0269058403,
0.0028864839,
-0.0240619611,
0.1056189612,
0.0578766763,
0.0095751006,
0.0106802806,
-0.0034283767,
0.0040267245,
0.0374200493,
0.0018894114,
0.0405527055,
0.0093680285,
-0.0158871599,
0.0188183095,
-0.0913280323,
0.009479071,
-0.0248126704,
0.0618484877,
-0.0120491851,
-0.0277991928,
0.1272141337,
0.0409280248,
-0.0022020424,
-0.031374339,
0.0103241233,
0.0080047362,
0.0152532104,
0.0088350791,
-0.0812947303,
-0.051708445,
-0.0221097227,
0.0329531617,
0.0211094245,
-0.079957366,
-0.0033323397,
-0.0864069611,
-0.0344162062,
-0.0520665683,
-0.0606841408,
0.0255200081,
-0.0678100064,
0.0106239775,
-0.0222796593,
-0.0099999914,
-0.0248738807,
-0.0270146504,
0.0225377567,
0.0223860443,
-0.0016402239,
0.0130426865,
0.0134984199,
-0.0413036495,
0.0155302444,
0.0502002165,
0.0490920059,
-0.0294229239,
-0.0000163837,
-0.0020236732,
-0.0641462207,
-0.028283678,
-0.0055227769,
0.0997970328,
-0.0386128128,
-0.0042599398,
-0.0352574512,
0.0030869376,
-0.0123517048,
0.0067065288,
0.0616405196,
0.0311743505,
0.0105278669,
-0.0002159238,
-0.0237163026,
-0.0034071044,
0.0182652771,
0.1052608788,
0.0314146206,
-0.0286585186,
-0.0365198441,
0.015214677,
-0.0133001618,
-0.0732551143,
-0.0068555311,
-0.0065271673,
-0.0469819792,
0.0087871561,
-0.0433699638,
-0.0619781427,
0.0500471853,
0.0159178302,
-0.0095280381,
0.0036459034,
0.0393013693,
0.0431495421,
-0.0683239549,
0.017164588,
-0.0005494607,
0.0153745087,
-0.0348601826,
-0.0411724411,
0.04352355,
0.0194715317,
-0.0391642265,
-0.0108202798,
-0.0488405079,
-0.0434988998,
-0.0339982025,
-0.0036749358,
0.0108786644,
0.0289751925,
-0.0176242813,
0.0038409601,
0.0535227135,
0.0295659211,
-0.046520371,
-0.0228159111,
0.0263450667,
0.0495552309,
-0.0269442014,
0.0405475944,
-0.0521774888,
-0.0213156343,
0.0136738345,
0.0577984974,
-0.0325255543,
-0.0393625908,
-0.0295267496,
0.023570301,
0.0418794602,
-0.0061860578,
-0.023601193,
-0.0282215625,
0.0346669555,
0.0290916134,
0.0146976365,
-0.0211802367,
0.0119694611,
-0.0215985253,
-0.0476083644,
-0.006781226,
0.0906501561,
-0.0183668565,
0.0251922589,
-0.0705581456,
0.0294894688,
0.023396723,
0.0479665473,
0.0036125309,
-0.0426279008,
-0.0087833758,
0.0317725465,
0.0740093291,
0.0269335937,
-0.0185931139,
0.0323721319,
0.0108854212,
-0.0126235709,
0.0047643813,
0.0162167698,
-0.0585858859,
0.0235385466,
-0.0189053398,
0.0647750348,
0.0180171188,
0.0253415741,
0.0721070766,
0.0334664062,
-0.0138034187,
0.0146126971,
0.0022400664,
-0.0236936212,
0.0036502245,
0.0462019444,
0.0303518437,
-0.0175740533,
-0.0169490781,
0.0606578737,
0.032248877,
0.039188765,
0.0434162356,
-0.0127503658,
-0.0590425357,
-0.0208988246,
-0.0055777403,
-0.0135558955,
-0.0119130686,
0.0273679104,
-0.0225076843,
-0.0253145173,
0.029555779,
-0.0518288538,
-0.0131133962,
0.0143990619,
0.0330305174,
-0.0062558865,
0.0293246023,
-0.0412422232,
-0.0516726412,
0.0333129168,
-0.001422678,
-0.0439734571,
0.0098159118,
-5.818010474e-33,
-0.0164908972,
-0.0334064364,
0.0262971576,
0.0022469172,
-0.0191618856,
0.0344828218,
-0.0236784797,
-0.0185898691,
-0.0220022723,
-0.0307055246,
0.0006739857,
0.0091928756,
0.0122925388,
0.0400173962,
-0.0228256527,
-0.0642855689,
0.0347759686,
0.0317058749,
-0.0354608074,
0.0323451795,
0.0494427606,
0.0799138397,
0.0560994819,
-0.0330063887,
0.0506267995,
-0.0392505117,
-0.0010443418,
0.0056995777,
0.0577926897,
0.0594468564,
-0.034791816,
0.0099217305,
0.0364096388,
-0.0477146469,
0.0295257773,
0.0407993197,
-0.1742802411,
-0.0131651601,
-0.0176240113,
0.0057964791,
-0.0353162959,
-0.0159983598,
-0.0017621513,
0.0091823321,
0.0412207805,
-0.0117150638,
0.0575186275,
-0.0026947877,
0.0447047986,
-0.043029137,
-0.0501848534,
0.0212651193,
-0.0185689926,
0.0120783458,
0.0124665871,
0.0369910784,
0.0271629933,
0.0132497884,
-0.0485301763,
0.0004824263,
0.0475616604,
-0.0226124115,
-0.003749215,
0.0231531747,
-0.0647317469,
0.0146941599,
0.0142084565,
-0.0389375426,
-0.0058371793,
-0.0292279106,
-0.0138371643,
0.0228158571,
0.026818024,
0.0224468559,
0.0136626652,
-0.0083501954,
-0.0976430774,
0.0538155399,
0.0372493602,
0.0184043478,
-0.0143510913,
-0.0548836179,
-0.0371433049,
0.0051635527,
0.0040805829,
-0.0078341793,
-0.0499415398,
0.0012378679,
0.0223148484,
0.0252778865,
-0.0476085246,
0.0557254814,
0.0118944198,
-0.008430467,
-0.0348541178,
0.0466569401,
0.0264505576,
-0.0032622488,
0.0081879748,
0.0435893275,
-0.0472108535,
-0.0119596682,
0.0224977899,
0.0021895294,
-0.0090383301,
-0.0092858076,
0.0436014794,
-0.0415951163,
-0.0644506067,
0.0013445633,
0.0025911378,
0.0270953309,
-0.0749423951,
0.0676226243,
-0.0152977835,
0.0013959974,
-0.0011537119,
0.0264229197,
0.0225105826,
0.0042533102,
-0.0350568891,
0.0201868434,
0.0229916349,
0.054031048,
-0.008197004,
-0.0066860057,
-0.0028948467,
0.0295771677,
-0.030911576,
-0.084192127,
0.0115039861,
-0.0129642151,
2.441e-7,
0.0270427614,
-0.0056277486,
0.0360584296,
-0.0333640575,
-0.0024622141,
0.0109783001,
0.0149898883,
0.059312813,
-0.0180655606,
0.0039793001,
-0.0296294093,
-0.0201450922,
0.0013102578,
0.0236616265,
-0.1057573184,
-0.0494748764,
-0.0311282892,
-0.0119299479,
-0.0691334531,
0.0504077896,
0.0416107476,
0.0265775025,
-0.0158152562,
-0.0078153079,
-0.0319500715,
-0.0166311283,
0.0282668751,
0.0368179716,
0.0128231784,
0.0417577624,
0.0067369556,
0.0389411338,
-0.0102924695,
0.0148442462,
-0.0173092503,
0.0439713039,
0.010724091,
0.065582715,
0.0244604237,
-0.0479645915,
-0.0016874734,
-0.0348057821,
0.0216275696,
-0.0198141281,
0.0851712525,
-0.0347940288,
-0.0250387285,
0.019307388,
-0.0327263065,
-0.0117355483,
-0.0085561099,
-0.0095439442,
-0.0142952744,
0.0225782264,
0.0031362206,
-0.055782415,
0.0165474862,
-0.0776431262,
0.0329390801,
0.0452126935,
-0.0180085525,
-0.0283755381,
-0.010963588,
-0.0175770745,
0.0085167699,
-0.1083255708,
-0.005906485,
2.313031484e-34,
-0.0173074566,
0.0153529923,
-0.047672905,
0.0502423346,
-0.0031772514,
-0.0249982774,
-0.0706818625,
-0.0375298858,
0.0108362148,
-0.0728002489,
-0.0106096361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19923v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19923v4 | Jina Embeddings 2: 8192-Token General-Purpose Text Embeddings for Long Documents | 2023-10-30T18:35:30 | 2024-02-04T11:11:53 | Michael Günther, Jackmin Ong, Isabelle Mohr, Alaeddine Abdessalem, Tanguy Abel, Mohammad Kalim Akram, Susana Guzman, Georgios Mastrapas, Saba Sturua, Bo Wang, Maximilian Werk, Nan Wang, Han Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | Text embedding models have emerged as powerful tools for transforming
sentences into fixed-sized feature vectors that encapsulate semantic
information. While these models are essential for tasks like information
retrieval, semantic clustering, and text re-ranking, most existing open-source
models, especially those built on architectures like BERT, struggle to
represent lengthy documents and often resort to truncation. One common approach
to mitigate this challenge involves splitting documents into smaller paragraphs
for embedding. However, this strategy results in a much larger set of vectors,
consequently leading to increased memory consumption and computationally
intensive vector searches with elevated latency.
To address these challenges, we introduce Jina Embeddings 2, an open-source
text embedding model capable of accommodating up to 8192 tokens. This model is
designed to transcend the conventional 512-token limit and adeptly process long
documents. Jina Embeddings 2 not only achieves state-of-the-art performance on
a range of embedding-related tasks in the MTEB benchmark but also matches the
performance of OpenAI's proprietary ada-002 model. Additionally, our
experiments indicate that an extended context can enhance performance in tasks
such as NarrativeQA. | [
0.0014295059,
0.0345421173,
0.0091921398,
0.0320407413,
-0.0131972786,
-0.0094604772,
0.0035341035,
-0.0041454122,
0.0064726113,
-0.040477369,
0.0137350233,
-0.0267683584,
-0.0060303435,
0.0435759425,
0.0255636759,
-0.0560070761,
0.0320143923,
-0.0002296661,
0.0520711653,
0.012765348,
0.0024857293,
0.0023017058,
0.0373689607,
0.0467312485,
-0.0280494504,
-0.0233983025,
-0.0163876358,
-0.0087149693,
0.0304446332,
-0.0153989783,
-0.0153184375,
-0.0135753378,
0.0635801479,
0.0124234036,
0.0000017735,
-0.0049052741,
-0.0006997135,
0.011274239,
0.0039731627,
0.0666402504,
0.0300013758,
-0.0270070061,
0.0245064553,
0.0227153618,
0.0075710244,
-0.0406457186,
0.0040995046,
0.0825681612,
0.0395891964,
0.0833959877,
-0.0149389738,
-0.0570177846,
0.0540589094,
-0.0560310632,
-0.0020725164,
-0.0320589691,
0.0114711691,
-0.0401411727,
0.021153478,
0.0247312598,
-0.0342597254,
0.0095714042,
0.0386842862,
-0.0160644427,
0.0282537043,
0.0495416075,
-0.0571655259,
0.0262987688,
0.0265883952,
0.0906283855,
-0.0017470644,
-0.013453424,
0.0036435509,
0.0242323838,
-0.0042747362,
-0.0272213966,
-0.0355313644,
0.0075536217,
0.006124896,
0.0244921166,
0.008771969,
0.0256045926,
0.0463980325,
-0.0115408683,
-0.0503812879,
0.0056974529,
0.016715318,
-0.0326045565,
-0.0411451869,
-0.0295066889,
-0.0499239191,
-0.0077882139,
0.0390730835,
0.0106423572,
0.0037637341,
-0.0022632247,
-0.0508029126,
-0.0598850176,
0.0290311631,
-0.0524649173,
0.0004154819,
0.0546933301,
-0.0158335771,
0.0676162243,
-0.0649728104,
0.0432567187,
-0.0397119485,
0.0213988647,
-0.041915942,
-0.0329867229,
-0.0157649778,
-0.0243075266,
-0.0582229234,
0.0246770643,
-0.0502525792,
-0.0778256729,
0.0072540855,
0.0336629413,
0.0097645158,
0.0307395197,
-0.006851465,
0.0089055216,
-0.0000673956,
0.0067554913,
0.0130946506,
0.0068146014,
-0.0756971166,
-0.0170092806,
-0.0109482016,
0.0217600409,
-0.0327367373,
0.021608049,
0.0151821142,
-0.0331291631,
-0.0054857172,
0.0417082533,
0.0010554822,
-0.0665279403,
0.0141832931,
0.0072650104,
-0.0120381638,
-0.054559242,
-0.0080897892,
-0.0355436578,
0.0396819413,
-0.0054081422,
-0.0053815469,
-0.0069810161,
0.001075308,
0.0480560996,
-0.0452553667,
0.0594921634,
0.0500752367,
-0.0263878442,
0.0376753472,
0.0420978554,
0.0407954343,
0.0508977175,
0.040849492,
0.039563518,
0.0527516417,
0.0239620432,
-0.0083043166,
0.0046958779,
0.0264403634,
-0.0041764239,
-0.0111281667,
0.0415214635,
0.0142914606,
0.0884404629,
0.0337160006,
0.0578099973,
-0.0498918258,
-0.0397326797,
0.0194794964,
0.064386934,
0.0276890248,
-0.0064908662,
0.0455825292,
0.0058531398,
-0.005250657,
-0.0281706285,
-0.017454328,
0.0232507642,
0.0441272371,
0.0079036187,
0.071417518,
0.0386710949,
-0.0409019887,
-0.0026451054,
-0.0157337729,
-0.032716915,
-0.0039579123,
-0.032730855,
0.0087022567,
-0.0202832725,
-0.0360306241,
0.0460898504,
0.0060614678,
-0.0601818934,
0.0001134693,
-0.0053301933,
0.0417755097,
0.0777736083,
0.0677555129,
-0.0508245714,
-0.0139624067,
-0.016269384,
0.0188267361,
0.0298591424,
0.0339904279,
-0.0241855923,
0.0174509641,
-0.0740319639,
0.0002775511,
-0.0556274131,
0.0136769079,
0.0160200056,
0.0274034515,
0.0517267175,
0.0320502333,
-0.0688018426,
0.0322856754,
0.0423172824,
-0.0471016169,
-0.023789024,
-0.0092096664,
0.0157563835,
-0.0021925538,
0.0155870346,
-0.0019709023,
0.0247348789,
0.0519736856,
-0.0546910502,
-0.0332096107,
-0.015588901,
-0.0466084294,
-0.0503261201,
0.0260688309,
-0.0360620357,
0.0290423743,
0.0323482491,
-0.0301923025,
-0.0335826762,
0.0140037537,
-0.0256156642,
0.0421014652,
-0.0170405526,
-0.0152534517,
0.0032074999,
0.0163497515,
-0.0053886622,
0.0504106693,
-0.0247427318,
0.0044172807,
0.0151662817,
-0.0185073726,
0.0212556142,
-0.0403798893,
-0.0616767928,
0.0181295592,
0.0575954802,
0.0047359532,
-0.0018420346,
-0.0397348329,
0.003304814,
-0.0292562041,
-0.1396769583,
0.0226701144,
-0.0193713326,
-0.0007560785,
-0.0106608011,
0.0021467919,
-0.0126555208,
-0.0079595447,
-0.0545313135,
-0.0632196516,
-0.0536892563,
0.0371453017,
0.0273292419,
0.0001512334,
-0.0073915557,
-0.0370880403,
-0.0147361513,
-0.0186038893,
0.0927291065,
-0.0360881202,
-0.0124570178,
-0.0287059508,
-0.0364662297,
-0.0041142614,
-0.0005587973,
-0.0257972516,
0.0012275977,
-0.017507188,
-0.0178772453,
0.0841334984,
0.0847380012,
0.006837145,
0.0601346642,
0.0307118855,
0.0223511625,
-0.0339723267,
0.0252849571,
-0.0009066255,
0.0771208927,
-0.0013637457,
-0.0082273129,
0.0035520843,
0.0136996424,
-0.0162351429,
0.0014828838,
-0.0637899339,
-0.0086510954,
-0.011130101,
0.0039327019,
-0.0127326846,
-0.0210177246,
-0.013853305,
-0.0186653417,
-0.0267875977,
-0.0015855615,
0.0539763011,
-0.0298134573,
0.0049040047,
-0.0271322392,
0.0105623174,
-0.0683791339,
0.0525462776,
0.0168689638,
0.0096216025,
-0.0404233336,
0.0020383277,
0.0083338479,
0.0212504137,
-0.0286886618,
-0.0245449468,
0.0166498981,
0.021972632,
-0.0082173562,
-0.0268894508,
-0.0503265671,
0.0042796852,
-0.0585074015,
0.0049156579,
0.0325157195,
0.0104508409,
-0.0398077592,
-0.0415963009,
-0.0047127185,
0.0083241919,
0.0595239922,
-0.0244653039,
0.0068241772,
-0.0184341744,
0.0861712247,
0.0472731628,
-0.0053128069,
-0.0004391502,
-0.0211186446,
0.0337037221,
0.0479715243,
0.0401722975,
-0.0087026795,
-0.020073941,
-0.0398780704,
-0.0057229581,
-0.0442139767,
-0.0343900584,
-0.0263444148,
0.0423715897,
-0.0327829979,
-0.019607801,
0.0962085873,
0.0470507182,
-0.028156938,
-0.0085249003,
-0.0187820327,
0.0517421067,
-0.0109875249,
0.0149625298,
-0.0879679769,
-0.0246539861,
0.0176399499,
0.0079912292,
0.0463201366,
-0.0146567663,
0.0065321494,
-0.0749311969,
0.0291390922,
-0.0069535323,
0.0104805967,
-0.0341289043,
-0.0551686771,
-0.0155398697,
-0.00550257,
0.0357572064,
-0.0018840077,
-0.0102864495,
-0.0147142662,
-0.0095036644,
0.0032736452,
-0.0158889089,
0.020780379,
-0.043353159,
0.0418607481,
0.0030641714,
0.0512191579,
0.0127628269,
-0.0085766958,
-0.0225788783,
-0.0234112646,
-0.0328486972,
0.0180912036,
0.0692300126,
-0.0545469075,
0.0096823517,
-0.0099016633,
0.0215553865,
-0.0045229406,
-0.0316289514,
0.0038583756,
0.0796163231,
0.0091624176,
-0.0052191806,
-0.0663222894,
-0.0293482374,
-0.0295891538,
0.0775599182,
0.0394643024,
-0.0369107686,
-0.0609117784,
-0.0061824056,
-0.0150918337,
-0.049139861,
-0.0018195974,
-0.0266733374,
-0.0032324339,
-0.0011550174,
-0.0820301622,
-0.0617754981,
0.0210061278,
0.0298729856,
-0.0066688098,
0.0022270721,
-0.0328386538,
-0.0254606921,
-0.0744783282,
0.0193357859,
-0.0198501479,
0.0313263163,
-0.0373106673,
0.0493086837,
0.0308462847,
-0.0012426296,
-0.0155235752,
-0.0258891508,
-0.0486901179,
-0.044236742,
-0.0288778692,
-0.0058058253,
0.0041390024,
0.0328693241,
-0.0298232809,
-0.033662539,
0.0814155266,
0.0168495513,
-0.0714329705,
0.0167607777,
0.0239432119,
0.0250172503,
-0.0018473431,
0.0449282043,
-0.0260730702,
-0.0131983934,
-0.0400162973,
0.0267049428,
0.0044584572,
0.0003324872,
-0.0276719462,
-0.0200128481,
0.0247864202,
0.0068907589,
0.0177169908,
-0.0351675712,
0.0285214577,
-0.066436246,
-0.0030932773,
-0.0199390966,
0.0418521389,
0.0484895408,
0.0044253017,
-0.0288052745,
0.0460019894,
0.0123104388,
0.0208141003,
-0.0575966388,
0.0335220471,
0.0006153401,
0.0085702948,
-0.0040738313,
0.0082176747,
-0.0293516573,
-0.0488178544,
-0.0588645823,
0.0199520662,
-0.0573162548,
-0.003968609,
0.0253344402,
-0.0090021808,
-0.0185935553,
0.0645754114,
-0.0572660901,
-0.0026894419,
-0.0126998778,
0.0458353348,
0.0224738698,
-0.0333282091,
0.0216334686,
-0.0123321274,
-0.0240835771,
0.00340096,
-0.0030468532,
0.0129178055,
-0.0303279292,
0.003729145,
0.0393810458,
-0.024422165,
-0.0027440798,
0.0747087374,
0.0401462726,
0.0424542874,
0.0099043483,
-0.0092263073,
-0.0262426157,
-0.0245001968,
0.0652787015,
0.0611535273,
-0.0123292785,
-0.0182131063,
-0.0305638984,
-0.0095751779,
0.044503361,
-0.0182316862,
-0.0566762574,
0.0102102412,
0.0093565183,
0.0360099822,
0.024268724,
-0.0244903322,
-0.0354698747,
0.0084704626,
-0.0067244302,
-0.0536184087,
0.0383714139,
-5.505788155e-33,
0.0001207464,
0.0138753839,
0.0081580402,
-0.027091641,
-0.0514268056,
0.0384514667,
-0.0139105646,
-0.0404916666,
-0.0090721678,
0.0257580355,
-0.0220691413,
0.0230210628,
-0.0044610999,
0.0386730172,
-0.0288954284,
-0.0007352227,
0.0344800279,
-0.0035255502,
-0.0278003328,
0.0409746654,
0.0543254279,
0.0239439644,
-0.007113813,
-0.0008510151,
-0.0006869962,
-0.0081082955,
0.0091765616,
0.0019660888,
0.0271775145,
0.0731349885,
-0.0483216979,
0.0060016601,
0.0293403752,
-0.0128752934,
0.0029318957,
0.0672440231,
-0.086386323,
-0.0074585238,
-0.0118684815,
-0.0063005104,
-0.0402606614,
-0.0494852588,
0.0190522205,
-0.0031157446,
0.0346831456,
-0.0121806562,
0.0365001447,
-0.005777258,
-0.0571348034,
-0.0131112244,
-0.0630160496,
0.0296982471,
0.0037470676,
0.0014737664,
0.0282491073,
0.0063538915,
0.045406688,
0.0357263684,
-0.0633433089,
-0.0389540605,
-0.0577361397,
0.0325718224,
-0.013278191,
-0.018794015,
-0.0139074903,
0.0626828596,
0.0037695863,
-0.0373955555,
-0.0643009394,
0.0095099788,
0.0006203242,
0.0159691572,
0.0477795899,
0.0213431194,
0.0186278634,
-0.022911245,
-0.072258994,
0.0196222719,
0.0191131346,
0.0254313648,
0.0469264649,
0.0419241898,
-0.0671325922,
0.0006008085,
-0.0166377369,
0.004215824,
-0.0309008248,
-0.0002774773,
0.0522528216,
0.0423162356,
-0.0085547855,
-0.0170731749,
0.0184639134,
-0.0196709204,
0.0158026032,
0.0614426024,
-0.0163564775,
0.0294188038,
0.0042054043,
0.0308920164,
-0.0438468158,
-0.001504958,
0.0450933538,
0.0082215583,
-0.0085454807,
-0.0239337496,
0.0628637448,
0.0136713935,
-0.0821022168,
-0.0009965623,
-0.0060781557,
-0.0284736603,
-0.0064992625,
0.0292718038,
0.0153682595,
0.0082972292,
0.0115953488,
0.0398603678,
0.0278591365,
0.0287405271,
-0.0219124742,
-0.0436083972,
0.0225935951,
0.0021130086,
0.0062656128,
0.0170554295,
-0.0368043631,
0.0455142967,
-0.0047434252,
-0.0949328467,
0.0031395729,
0.0146545088,
2.333e-7,
0.0213143751,
0.0459047779,
0.067798987,
-0.0250350889,
0.0222562924,
0.0173309799,
0.0143451151,
0.0720680282,
-0.0466782264,
0.0162756741,
0.0006420906,
0.0281152353,
0.0154600842,
0.0095172534,
-0.1116608381,
0.0559881851,
-0.0786582008,
-0.0267330911,
-0.0683108345,
-0.0543422103,
0.0529388711,
0.1180629432,
0.0082437601,
0.0316750929,
-0.0022408164,
-0.070479244,
0.0889966637,
-0.0021360186,
-0.0182517264,
0.0009927729,
0.0108748367,
0.0272885598,
-0.0001049127,
-0.0618848614,
-0.0052211406,
0.0589855723,
0.0374600068,
0.08939787,
0.0053482237,
-0.0316144265,
0.0034604769,
-0.030942997,
-0.0281909946,
-0.0308964066,
0.0832549259,
-0.0082678283,
-0.0249129403,
-0.0122020328,
-0.0149906054,
0.0183218811,
0.0537944771,
0.0135663459,
-0.0121911764,
0.0367940404,
0.0305704139,
-0.0343648866,
0.0129893161,
-0.1339650452,
-0.0173515864,
-0.0152487624,
-0.0706320778,
0.0225009676,
-0.0681643859,
0.0088692671,
0.0549721718,
-0.0713996664,
0.0065828697,
2.608519999e-34,
0.0446248837,
-0.0195180662,
-0.0165929701,
0.0130295418,
0.0338993035,
-0.030221343,
0.0102610784,
-0.0153585318,
0.0319397114,
-0.0928437114,
-0.0240223445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19792v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19792v1 | The Eval4NLP 2023 Shared Task on Prompting Large Language Models as Explainable Metrics | 2023-10-30T17:55:08 | 2023-10-30T17:55:08 | Christoph Leiter, Juri Opitz, Daniel Deutsch, Yang Gao, Rotem Dror, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | With an increasing number of parameters and pre-training data, generative
large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities to solve tasks
with minimal or no task-related examples. Notably, LLMs have been successfully
employed as evaluation metrics in text generation tasks. Within this context,
we introduce the Eval4NLP 2023 shared task that asks participants to explore
prompting and score extraction for machine translation (MT) and summarization
evaluation. Specifically, we propose a novel competition setting in which we
select a list of allowed LLMs and disallow fine-tuning to ensure a focus on
prompting. We present an overview of participants' approaches and evaluate them
on a new reference-free test set spanning three language pairs for MT and a
summarization dataset. Notably, despite the task's restrictions, the
best-performing systems achieve results on par with or even surpassing recent
reference-free metrics developed using larger models, including GEMBA and
Comet-Kiwi-XXL. Finally, as a separate track, we perform a small-scale human
evaluation of the plausibility of explanations given by the LLMs. | [
0.0303743538,
0.0500982292,
0.0254503954,
0.0232117567,
-0.0226415694,
0.0294032749,
0.0200518817,
-0.0178468451,
-0.0161455739,
-0.0041438644,
0.0082272822,
-0.0486588664,
0.0069664926,
0.044920627,
0.0499621779,
-0.0652187169,
-0.0150057543,
-0.0606315732,
-0.0005038092,
0.005686163,
-0.003513918,
0.0053007076,
0.0092239203,
0.0522461608,
0.0198454261,
-0.0231389832,
-0.0054864222,
-0.0017247689,
0.0282983333,
-0.0015814557,
-0.0233551078,
0.0377804749,
0.0225257874,
0.010313686,
0.000002277,
-0.0515666381,
-0.0233565494,
-0.0016443996,
-0.0303110145,
0.0133477785,
0.0296360813,
0.0011321714,
0.0161107145,
0.0300220121,
-0.0263770353,
-0.0069860695,
0.0285216905,
0.0263774395,
0.0740204677,
0.0801051781,
0.0101676024,
-0.0112820482,
-0.0213644058,
-0.0632437989,
0.0142290322,
-0.0138448477,
-0.0085382331,
0.0288995691,
0.0091216555,
0.0047897426,
0.0159702934,
0.0138723096,
0.0404123291,
-0.0469540432,
0.0083610052,
0.0436322242,
-0.0156327356,
-0.0460309274,
0.0029821524,
0.0714620724,
0.0261878353,
-0.0135841751,
0.0273606945,
0.0112962266,
-0.0114545934,
-0.0124753369,
-0.0683781877,
0.0724742636,
0.0144554405,
0.0183535721,
0.0126743168,
0.0547229648,
0.0275299754,
0.0182525869,
-0.0330431536,
0.0028087678,
0.0316817872,
-0.0088614225,
-0.0349095948,
0.0250358488,
-0.0476417355,
-0.0858015716,
-0.0116659049,
0.0238083173,
-0.0389725678,
0.0025849005,
-0.0254506674,
-0.0180958975,
0.0100879567,
0.0067876438,
0.0483701155,
0.0205045994,
-0.0035560457,
0.0415930115,
-0.0360646546,
0.0922370702,
0.0227643624,
-0.0230319183,
-0.0799095482,
0.0075644339,
-0.0246687066,
0.007062492,
-0.0014049805,
0.0006675558,
-0.0642070696,
-0.0168468729,
-0.026565453,
0.0080687348,
-0.0024486484,
0.0020281828,
0.0380221382,
0.0085242018,
-0.0296744853,
-0.0094240708,
-0.0016776639,
0.0084878486,
-0.0431414619,
-0.0360477306,
0.0566956922,
-0.0598465279,
-0.0365081728,
0.0482953526,
0.0048087551,
-0.0127808228,
0.0066278074,
0.052318044,
-0.0170053151,
-0.0326092318,
0.0186341088,
-0.0244496521,
-0.0329966098,
-0.0792740658,
-0.01962642,
-0.0616101138,
0.0280029867,
-0.0026830428,
-0.0183581281,
-0.0021874225,
0.0212429073,
0.0134926029,
-0.0036900984,
0.0173803903,
0.0167807247,
0.029590657,
0.0178433545,
-0.0009310025,
0.0054639541,
0.0398830473,
0.040244706,
0.0633390546,
0.0216075759,
0.0021676533,
0.0112618711,
0.0240784492,
0.0253694989,
0.0239773504,
0.0070162397,
0.0022474704,
0.0113409292,
0.0372012891,
0.0358251855,
0.0522028804,
-0.0077558691,
0.0544418469,
0.0824204609,
0.0377484635,
-0.004490939,
-0.0005741072,
0.0686964393,
-0.0041500838,
-0.0163508076,
0.0288473833,
-0.0284230206,
0.0266421773,
-0.0337372459,
0.0372932702,
0.0816870183,
0.0501409583,
-0.0220317412,
-0.0770791173,
-0.0014960013,
0.0052479631,
-0.0240665749,
0.034094274,
0.0473037921,
0.0164327864,
-0.0536909923,
0.0022622682,
0.0004752524,
-0.0885097533,
0.0329994038,
-0.0601869784,
0.0653305426,
0.0577745251,
0.0557539985,
0.020337265,
-0.0065931827,
-0.0204938278,
0.0296545085,
0.0557074808,
0.039340049,
-0.0064972024,
0.0113628935,
-0.036593169,
-0.0119414385,
-0.0349331647,
0.0168480612,
0.0025452219,
-0.0056950077,
-0.0298336037,
0.0523524955,
-0.0439226106,
-0.0876065269,
0.0405662023,
-0.0208576173,
-0.044142019,
0.0237251874,
-0.0008629275,
0.0036572409,
0.0495530367,
-0.0205511171,
0.0293494966,
0.0219960883,
-0.0714114308,
0.0007640156,
0.0321715735,
-0.0425120667,
-0.0397028141,
0.0141792065,
-0.0243276265,
0.0027679489,
0.0084916689,
-0.0184401534,
-0.0705888942,
0.0078094751,
-0.0257538892,
-0.0140501857,
-0.0323520564,
0.0169086419,
0.0261586476,
0.0000511281,
-0.0514608063,
0.0717368051,
0.0153631503,
0.0233743284,
0.0263336133,
-0.0144637087,
-0.0059511326,
-0.028634591,
-0.037681777,
0.0175718516,
-0.0050465115,
0.0048112781,
0.0521385074,
0.0458138511,
-0.0242960937,
-0.0289000981,
-0.0886053294,
0.0307384431,
-0.03940906,
0.0191713087,
0.0473269485,
0.0239555314,
-0.02234805,
0.0142180165,
-0.064435482,
-0.0407085642,
0.0610226057,
-0.0110844886,
0.0307644047,
-0.0035418158,
0.0183256846,
-0.0379661024,
0.0015487495,
0.0115445051,
0.084526591,
0.0394928232,
0.0160675161,
-0.056956023,
0.0602169335,
-0.0255008209,
-0.0460645445,
0.0072818073,
-0.0258560516,
0.0139131993,
-0.0355333984,
0.0849292651,
0.0556654632,
0.0119586475,
0.0314440504,
0.0285090487,
-0.0016603353,
-0.0452788845,
-0.0149403354,
-0.0426524095,
-0.0347370617,
0.0278313905,
-0.0548803546,
0.0366432071,
0.0658729598,
0.0084809773,
-0.0152755016,
-0.0640175939,
0.0587465875,
-0.0188678559,
-0.0297489073,
-0.0551462173,
-0.0052637402,
0.0080564236,
0.0567127913,
-0.0379458964,
-0.0735621154,
0.0664276257,
-0.0660133436,
-0.0150540015,
-0.033868432,
-0.0083984099,
-0.0393299796,
0.0766263679,
0.0107210083,
0.0277527627,
0.013576895,
0.0099358931,
-0.0247041248,
0.014762599,
0.0093098152,
-0.0368984714,
0.0462380163,
-0.0675154105,
-0.0118485531,
-0.0113849156,
-0.0133668836,
-0.0366888829,
-0.0338210873,
-0.0020804962,
0.0124695441,
0.0191389266,
-0.0119121978,
0.0009688063,
0.0267693307,
0.0423484258,
0.0185907893,
-0.0472709611,
0.0010399705,
-0.0154989846,
0.0475323349,
0.062672548,
0.022997655,
0.0308728497,
-0.0757936314,
0.052442234,
0.0194178149,
0.0477896146,
0.0261022616,
-0.0222761109,
0.0055575981,
0.0092381258,
-0.0222554486,
0.0059682494,
0.0113694351,
0.0932017565,
-0.0588923544,
-0.01124031,
0.1203862578,
0.0178981703,
-0.0244872011,
0.0083579263,
0.0037480947,
0.0551038794,
-0.002044227,
0.0234651491,
-0.0425416976,
-0.0170487631,
0.014597781,
0.0525738858,
-0.0088637369,
-0.0137457894,
-0.0273573361,
-0.125884071,
0.0504697822,
0.0167922024,
-0.0313088559,
-0.035698954,
-0.0329710282,
-0.0167143345,
-0.018615758,
0.0030232791,
0.0100363167,
0.0150931729,
0.047811985,
0.03584392,
0.0001828084,
-0.0617172718,
0.0008807403,
-0.0486333519,
0.0361773372,
0.0852252766,
0.0187243652,
0.0196113884,
-0.0024077694,
0.0038396982,
-0.0507595204,
-0.0043760836,
0.0068638646,
0.0269250236,
0.0193755459,
-0.0270322934,
-0.0368835703,
0.0609799884,
-0.0254984442,
0.0074204854,
0.0191456173,
0.0419068635,
0.0129754134,
-0.0174045321,
0.0157768615,
0.0096790623,
-0.0041686241,
0.1019862294,
0.0767914131,
-0.0392093174,
-0.0305904336,
-0.0374228694,
0.0055692256,
-0.0913720056,
-0.0249706972,
-0.0042692563,
0.011087087,
-0.0302447155,
-0.098471269,
-0.0493732058,
0.0405083708,
0.0180275571,
0.0080455113,
-0.01961275,
-0.0564035513,
-0.0013790877,
-0.0186666083,
0.0640020296,
-0.0139119523,
-0.0037427587,
-0.0620445758,
-0.0082056234,
0.0227269251,
-0.041423101,
-0.0226869285,
0.059615396,
-0.0781468078,
-0.0522456542,
-0.0430552848,
0.0674159229,
0.0241653807,
0.0328451581,
-0.0033764073,
-0.0389303081,
0.0234107617,
-0.0018605359,
-0.0111927213,
0.0120374765,
-0.0020515425,
0.0220516082,
-0.0089019695,
0.0334859677,
-0.0216543488,
0.0192465521,
0.0030124164,
0.064000614,
0.0115761627,
-0.0390444882,
0.030976912,
0.0396605693,
0.0039162943,
-0.043664638,
-0.0346570797,
-0.0474647135,
-0.0288858749,
-0.0191056747,
-0.0317193866,
-0.064725928,
0.0156079456,
0.0029847012,
0.0326535814,
0.0170326959,
0.0150404852,
-0.0083385529,
0.0187095162,
-0.0533696711,
0.0159299802,
-0.0378568619,
0.0077301105,
-0.0036666696,
-0.0003778279,
-0.0248950124,
-0.0024256674,
-0.0417337529,
0.0075649042,
-0.0042341244,
0.0471204594,
0.0114456536,
0.0061888131,
0.0357868448,
0.0434044786,
-0.0526674055,
-0.0350378565,
-0.0209829882,
0.0243551638,
0.0674990565,
0.0010458799,
0.0923093185,
0.0116411755,
0.0130687943,
-0.0169020686,
0.0523007028,
0.0367271677,
-0.0387590863,
-0.0079356022,
0.0116001116,
-0.0142454226,
-0.0160765518,
0.0950565934,
-0.0151739782,
-0.0013677576,
0.0124807553,
0.0219673011,
-0.0348446257,
-0.0413831286,
-0.0160244554,
-0.0279231146,
-0.0003999033,
0.0027988746,
-0.0305132288,
-0.0396042727,
-0.0227298234,
0.0254550558,
-0.0049047582,
-0.0143149327,
0.0317744277,
0.0569237657,
-0.0508142151,
0.0007036912,
-0.0710526556,
-0.0040412084,
-0.0303421933,
0.0002179263,
-0.0214633364,
-6.961062283e-33,
-0.0326725729,
-0.0283154659,
0.015243887,
-0.0295841414,
-0.0466017537,
0.0143430671,
-0.0759274364,
-0.011710207,
0.013397309,
0.0001202316,
0.0008201966,
-0.018937543,
0.000964366,
0.0377609432,
0.0086290231,
-0.0190454125,
0.0537818931,
0.0053781006,
-0.0574899912,
0.0509766601,
0.0174889062,
0.0002014479,
0.0058258558,
-0.0262707379,
0.056170024,
-0.0340001509,
-0.0503826141,
0.0231457129,
0.0086789513,
0.0272301603,
-0.0457740724,
-0.0034303949,
0.0182531606,
-0.0561940484,
-0.0430621132,
0.03135157,
-0.0430970341,
0.0116085904,
0.038859345,
-0.0394425094,
-0.0451344214,
-0.0690570623,
0.0239522234,
-0.0221629832,
-0.0043548676,
-0.0092633869,
0.0168466344,
-0.0317494795,
-0.0151794646,
-0.0337398723,
-0.0264046006,
0.0219384637,
-0.0328409784,
-0.0523347333,
0.0028773737,
0.0814738497,
-0.0303171445,
0.0223849062,
-0.0019737522,
0.0472133793,
0.0415502526,
0.0568770431,
0.0991855115,
0.0224141125,
-0.0019183967,
0.0561622865,
-0.004516568,
-0.0144974887,
-0.0482350066,
-0.0185823459,
-0.0243227873,
0.0289659016,
0.0624166168,
0.0261973143,
0.0019485172,
0.0327040553,
-0.0524711274,
0.0649351031,
0.0019495714,
-0.0208105203,
0.0311367866,
-0.0366093889,
-0.032655146,
-0.0177027825,
-0.0611506589,
-0.0235197246,
-0.0470697954,
-0.0210244283,
0.0333357714,
0.0124700535,
-0.0418076217,
-0.0530828908,
0.0295718964,
-0.0227046553,
0.0484083556,
0.0140028549,
-0.0186264943,
0.0166059975,
-0.0111905746,
-0.0050084554,
-0.0344804376,
0.000105442,
0.0211629141,
0.017944118,
0.0079703387,
0.0096538719,
-0.0010219002,
0.0019346506,
-0.0269619767,
0.0176672004,
-0.0633752346,
0.0314832665,
-0.0287559722,
0.0226771906,
0.0114222551,
-0.0014392233,
-0.0228851512,
0.0438658074,
-0.0013742703,
0.0088027827,
-0.0006014445,
0.0058257002,
0.0015780048,
0.0296950974,
-0.035465911,
0.0169475991,
-0.0124085564,
0.0272023343,
0.040573176,
-0.0154592777,
-0.0254183691,
-0.0000559007,
2.833e-7,
0.0235804133,
0.0440548249,
0.0316317752,
0.008664906,
-0.0303317122,
0.0197167546,
-0.0154467821,
-0.007962252,
0.0178539082,
0.0308465194,
0.0165457185,
0.0179740582,
0.0880500972,
0.0015618047,
-0.0906989798,
-0.0185000878,
-0.0719734207,
-0.024285052,
-0.0575733222,
-0.0312806107,
0.0744707882,
0.0560124926,
-0.0279029403,
0.0166219529,
0.0089073209,
-0.0420519412,
0.0460410081,
-0.0540028512,
-0.0596277975,
0.0121742887,
0.0438120365,
-0.0068065454,
-0.024493577,
-0.0202623978,
-0.0090516759,
0.0017804261,
0.0347469524,
0.0704015642,
0.0599652864,
-0.0115020396,
-0.0000769423,
0.0084122801,
0.0188481007,
-0.0606444292,
0.0643060058,
-0.0496202037,
-0.024309678,
0.0009795505,
-0.021484118,
-0.0198042803,
-0.0166055206,
-0.0404792763,
-0.0231457632,
0.043361146,
0.0014493992,
-0.0245388132,
0.005965244,
-0.0228931811,
-0.060950458,
-0.0084701413,
-0.020199215,
-0.0426083803,
-0.0508903526,
0.0086058751,
-0.0142504573,
-0.041434437,
-0.0300081279,
2.917840087e-34,
0.0525387228,
-0.0114829307,
-0.0175235942,
-0.020010151,
0.0380267762,
-0.0253809597,
-0.0372173823,
-0.0232103877,
0.0074498625,
-0.0921159908,
-0.0190619342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19791v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19791v4 | LILO: Learning Interpretable Libraries by Compressing and Documenting Code | 2023-10-30T17:55:02 | 2024-03-15T16:55:47 | Gabriel Grand, Lionel Wong, Maddy Bowers, Theo X. Olausson, Muxin Liu, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL | While large language models (LLMs) now excel at code generation, a key aspect
of software development is the art of refactoring: consolidating code into
libraries of reusable and readable programs. In this paper, we introduce LILO,
a neurosymbolic framework that iteratively synthesizes, compresses, and
documents code to build libraries tailored to particular problem domains. LILO
combines LLM-guided program synthesis with recent algorithmic advances in
automated refactoring from Stitch: a symbolic compression system that
efficiently identifies optimal lambda abstractions across large code corpora.
To make these abstractions interpretable, we introduce an auto-documentation
(AutoDoc) procedure that infers natural language names and docstrings based on
contextual examples of usage. In addition to improving human readability, we
find that AutoDoc boosts performance by helping LILO's synthesizer to interpret
and deploy learned abstractions. We evaluate LILO on three inductive program
synthesis benchmarks for string editing, scene reasoning, and graphics
composition. Compared to existing neural and symbolic methods - including the
state-of-the-art library learning algorithm DreamCoder - LILO solves more
complex tasks and learns richer libraries that are grounded in linguistic
knowledge. | [
0.0028878448,
0.0674940422,
-0.0386336073,
0.0445475504,
0.0041536866,
0.0124156782,
-0.038334094,
0.009818051,
-0.0231598578,
-0.0040885508,
-0.0223867074,
0.0661893785,
0.0180680417,
0.0440124311,
0.0392420478,
-0.0326853171,
0.0254838746,
-0.0131992139,
-0.0035324602,
0.0153672723,
-0.0111001488,
0.0264049321,
0.0167672802,
0.0691592768,
0.0212148353,
-0.030398244,
-0.0251967888,
0.0210570768,
-0.0365047157,
0.0020711434,
-0.0218027346,
0.0288236775,
0.029894352,
0.022397371,
0.0000021462,
-0.0229435321,
0.0136835882,
-0.0119682401,
0.0090699494,
0.0018579371,
0.0312391669,
-0.0407598503,
0.0065108002,
-0.0138904592,
-0.0194445774,
-0.013151627,
0.0537718348,
-0.0190899447,
0.0952054337,
0.043146871,
0.0154469581,
-0.0283134542,
-0.007977427,
0.0076537854,
0.0645217672,
0.0326530449,
-0.0427436084,
0.0323782638,
0.0043433802,
-0.0262853839,
-0.029786,
0.0439398661,
0.0440705791,
-0.0197132081,
0.0232948605,
0.0218281783,
-0.0398450345,
-0.022768002,
0.0147623038,
0.0589411631,
-0.0654115751,
-0.0496725366,
-0.0033575096,
0.009342419,
0.0032072635,
-0.0354955718,
-0.0506276488,
0.0193472859,
0.0119113475,
0.0016782938,
0.0037509508,
-0.0288107172,
0.043001093,
-0.0016555169,
-0.0129230814,
0.0123186922,
0.0059683225,
0.0362810381,
-0.0267929584,
-0.0342288055,
0.0035226275,
-0.0478367321,
0.0179291777,
0.0458422936,
0.0042780745,
0.0029261743,
-0.0387260839,
-0.0361762196,
0.0025723926,
-0.0140599329,
0.0090374462,
0.0399204642,
0.0161387026,
-0.0011094838,
-0.0665574074,
0.07343629,
-0.0217837729,
-0.0039477507,
-0.0328990221,
-0.0018209711,
-0.0623724312,
-0.0248691589,
-0.049856212,
0.0566479973,
-0.0177302733,
0.0268025342,
-0.0235458631,
0.0476301946,
0.0001606726,
0.0302473269,
-0.0179987848,
-0.0057506249,
-0.0483240336,
-0.0269817952,
0.0009728015,
-0.0139593771,
-0.0170459803,
-0.0357611552,
-0.0069123846,
-0.0033785757,
-0.0191159304,
0.0350761339,
-0.0535465889,
0.0064711748,
0.0329485536,
0.0747503191,
0.0159657318,
0.0365962982,
-0.0487509444,
-0.0468933657,
0.0394693874,
-0.0114126028,
0.0030569443,
-0.1067100465,
-0.0019372059,
-0.0107046766,
-0.0059097195,
-0.1036260948,
0.0055360179,
-0.0219720565,
0.0116845174,
0.0643605217,
-0.059200801,
-0.0097872159,
0.0495707355,
0.0208627526,
-0.0077560716,
0.0427216738,
0.0810897499,
0.0323337838,
-0.0112465275,
-0.0402095653,
0.0657317936,
0.0210652631,
-0.0041016918,
-0.0208031088,
-0.0152880885,
-0.0128924465,
-0.0265445318,
0.0318225361,
0.0563693382,
0.0278019793,
-0.0322590061,
-0.0404862203,
-0.0039589102,
0.0486072004,
0.0377167985,
0.0631055906,
0.0965995789,
0.021489922,
-0.0012503456,
-0.0372464471,
-0.0562854894,
0.0892281234,
-0.0038311214,
0.0350486189,
-0.0305587724,
0.0129476255,
-0.0142886918,
-0.0775657818,
0.0171496514,
-0.0374325663,
-0.00326944,
-0.0183039922,
0.0001518163,
0.0296589509,
-0.0525383092,
0.060761489,
0.0039653657,
-0.0599753894,
-0.0092348689,
-0.0499434173,
0.0293931328,
0.0683903173,
0.0530801862,
-0.0511490032,
-0.0241604168,
-0.0278196502,
-0.0315952897,
0.0213341136,
-0.0179595854,
-0.0288905241,
0.0473456122,
-0.0558758974,
0.0223216768,
-0.0631158501,
-0.0039674914,
0.0640794858,
-0.012597898,
-0.0189217757,
0.0192916486,
-0.0420849919,
-0.0623213798,
0.0624758191,
-0.0190453418,
-0.0427994505,
0.0357082076,
-0.0150063075,
0.0164181236,
-0.04604223,
-0.028595442,
0.0169554744,
0.0340858065,
-0.0531182066,
-0.0137355635,
-0.0094794687,
-0.0309837945,
-0.0601707511,
0.035033334,
-0.0565860942,
-0.0181515142,
0.045078963,
-0.0742889643,
-0.0054353713,
0.0867905691,
-0.0309307184,
0.0118350461,
-0.0075387466,
-0.0166593716,
-0.0064327847,
-0.0291269179,
-0.0059251445,
0.0267888382,
-0.005774905,
-0.0138986204,
0.0101703368,
0.0426687077,
0.0384630263,
0.0078798309,
-0.0036033231,
0.003060801,
-0.0311501399,
0.013156021,
-0.0055821524,
0.0494223423,
-0.0081931632,
-0.0332221948,
-0.0742356181,
0.0150775071,
-0.0097813876,
-0.0301578399,
0.0038128616,
-0.0021538013,
0.0172660816,
-0.0269654617,
-0.003096713,
0.015497148,
-0.0464857481,
-0.0016056718,
0.0512271523,
-0.0095840367,
-0.0744584724,
-0.030786505,
-0.0397406407,
-0.0372234024,
0.0682931989,
-0.00289466,
-0.0305339899,
-0.06622269,
0.0207597818,
-0.01890916,
0.0213680919,
-0.0068957228,
-0.0333790481,
0.0101845767,
-0.0272194538,
0.0294690356,
0.0945887938,
-0.015691366,
0.013804378,
0.0726962313,
0.0346776284,
-0.0473737642,
0.037957117,
0.0203140751,
-0.0007019078,
-0.0008900965,
-0.0430412963,
0.0415710397,
0.0641957521,
-0.0107176583,
-0.0146545358,
-0.0498971753,
0.0217165891,
0.0210285373,
-0.0170539077,
-0.0084060449,
-0.0501362532,
0.0102652414,
0.0305299908,
-0.0107289776,
-0.0911016539,
0.0616140664,
-0.0261412729,
-0.0223531555,
-0.0301057957,
-0.0255250148,
-0.064235419,
0.0998342186,
0.0039218478,
0.0246648435,
-0.0021236951,
-0.0376666039,
-0.0229263268,
0.0142694535,
-0.0095682163,
0.0015870489,
0.0282501299,
-0.0647938699,
0.0104470383,
0.0164683778,
-0.0281154849,
-0.019712422,
0.0197893698,
-0.0271656401,
-0.0013075715,
0.0419694446,
-0.0098791439,
0.0026166819,
-0.0027545122,
0.0108221127,
0.0529872999,
0.0279167369,
-0.0398439467,
-0.0101300124,
-0.0478818603,
-0.0191572886,
-0.0323791616,
0.0208142493,
-0.0095204879,
-0.0151619082,
0.0110671585,
0.000713346,
0.0176857393,
-0.0784925967,
0.0251466893,
0.0001699893,
-0.0276424233,
-0.0289751887,
0.0500737056,
0.0352236331,
-0.0607797541,
-0.0117691522,
0.0901421532,
0.0211122669,
-0.0537840538,
0.0260523763,
-0.0305721518,
0.0396585912,
0.0715712607,
0.0684180409,
-0.059276171,
-0.052475743,
-0.0051521738,
0.0274927597,
0.0301409382,
-0.018351147,
-0.032578785,
-0.0477280505,
0.0285381377,
0.0192323383,
-0.0202746969,
-0.0097689917,
-0.0355689526,
-0.0511677936,
0.0003826568,
-0.0691311359,
0.0378519371,
-0.0042415722,
0.0288999751,
-0.041283913,
-0.0626583025,
0.0422083996,
0.0208889525,
-0.0156253669,
0.0300547853,
0.0474327914,
0.0381462909,
0.0157791469,
-0.0115856286,
0.0489928946,
0.0366152264,
0.0156781804,
-0.0463452488,
0.0367462188,
0.0337204002,
-0.0077860244,
0.0298320726,
0.0360610746,
-0.067399092,
-0.041947037,
0.0135454172,
0.0489096604,
-0.0006956414,
-0.0266137049,
-0.0346922129,
0.0077129779,
-0.0153188258,
0.0359779969,
0.0677778721,
0.00163077,
-0.03223297,
-0.064993754,
-0.0187704749,
-0.0502940826,
-0.0269752741,
-0.0279838853,
0.0164385494,
-0.0093589472,
-0.0605971441,
0.0168923773,
0.035270866,
0.0352547988,
0.0328096077,
-0.0338032693,
0.0206356905,
-0.0249403808,
-0.0844775662,
0.0289417859,
-0.00489971,
-0.016157642,
-0.0368557572,
-0.0205577333,
0.003190072,
-0.0156979971,
-0.0135194473,
0.0626975074,
-0.044503089,
-0.0307774246,
-0.038951844,
0.1072409227,
0.0256028529,
0.0261050556,
-0.0007563485,
-0.0382823944,
-0.0151175205,
0.0783054978,
-0.0081696874,
0.0132183395,
0.0312541276,
0.0081068017,
0.0395361222,
0.0206095688,
-0.0411033519,
-0.001395909,
0.007973711,
-0.020059688,
0.0191567428,
0.0380075686,
0.0416896902,
0.0373656899,
-0.0242578965,
-0.0197534412,
0.0077404235,
-0.0149322338,
-0.0149724251,
0.0073799444,
-0.0094468845,
-0.0620158799,
0.0475101508,
0.0244935844,
-0.009286291,
0.0470905267,
0.0222842582,
0.0166006535,
0.0148588484,
0.0314198993,
0.0092137912,
-0.0014048214,
0.0298463423,
0.0568364933,
0.0032055976,
-0.0162205845,
0.017158363,
-0.0185087267,
0.0556211509,
-0.0225665774,
0.0401237719,
0.0252259523,
0.0543457158,
-0.0665912256,
0.0257549156,
-0.0214772858,
-0.0951827466,
-0.0191378985,
0.0075765173,
0.0178651009,
0.0355619863,
0.0077887131,
-0.0463208146,
0.0168973524,
-0.0078072459,
0.0626997501,
-0.0059031313,
-0.0251858626,
0.0008398467,
0.0266790353,
-0.0192243438,
-0.0508639924,
0.0957644954,
-0.0256871749,
0.0255719591,
0.0032243121,
0.0168865975,
-0.0340049714,
-0.0048407195,
0.0036109125,
-0.0172042679,
-0.0272323564,
-0.0291896891,
-0.0315018594,
-0.0415011682,
0.0300113745,
0.0379676782,
0.0001660373,
0.010981841,
0.0472448096,
0.0596604645,
0.0214261152,
-0.0312771685,
0.0186696798,
0.0165485423,
-0.0212576874,
-0.0617712028,
-0.0441909768,
-5.372055468e-33,
-0.0336842164,
-0.0055681337,
0.0295990612,
0.0475591198,
0.007004173,
-0.0079677468,
-0.0819586292,
-0.0073764422,
0.0329059772,
-0.0010835972,
0.0289336555,
0.0090210587,
-0.0289858785,
-0.0229090117,
0.0388830192,
0.0256629158,
0.0216804445,
0.0242374167,
-0.0642307326,
0.0233720075,
-0.0233007371,
0.0311303884,
0.0243247468,
-0.0686906055,
-0.0504937246,
0.0360697396,
0.0407056063,
0.0213187952,
0.0135241253,
0.0114958482,
-0.0081771258,
-0.0170024969,
-0.0158388168,
-0.018504858,
-0.0292025786,
-0.0203322694,
-0.0407004394,
-0.0610896535,
0.0399027802,
0.0008913162,
-0.0442814007,
-0.0789898187,
0.0989892259,
0.0065271431,
-0.0199890658,
-0.0222627763,
0.0246159658,
-0.0111874519,
-0.0027939847,
-0.0617573969,
-0.0760272965,
-0.0113681899,
-0.051234141,
-0.0297386628,
0.0062990594,
-0.0006887076,
-0.0201698691,
0.0536259338,
-0.0024078635,
-0.0137048988,
-0.0118169989,
0.0517140441,
0.0786691979,
-0.0258030612,
0.04668428,
0.0415206403,
0.0422718748,
0.009612822,
-0.0433207266,
0.0358317457,
0.0556936972,
0.0474076718,
0.0547402166,
0.0068165883,
0.0285270549,
0.0152406637,
-0.0287246313,
0.0159193408,
-0.0208203197,
0.0626313016,
-0.010803354,
0.0613011792,
0.0054079639,
-0.0129915755,
-0.0465143435,
-0.0028746591,
-0.0159918237,
-0.0246837717,
0.0069684554,
-0.0247262027,
-0.0234849937,
-0.0339157656,
0.0066833314,
-0.0418621637,
-0.0032492364,
0.0254113767,
-0.0383464918,
0.0255538356,
0.0204140302,
0.0105789648,
0.0211593304,
-0.0006690281,
0.0131460326,
-0.0245029405,
0.0905318409,
-0.0003128974,
0.0586027615,
0.0602425076,
-0.0240269918,
0.0040137595,
-0.0527788028,
-0.0229586717,
0.0175507683,
0.0273936465,
-0.0264058113,
0.0212425105,
-0.0219848659,
0.0012974322,
-0.015501434,
-0.0242394228,
-0.0163829997,
0.0363418534,
0.021898333,
0.0364033543,
-0.0663671941,
-0.0578559972,
-0.0653616711,
0.0344376452,
0.0463217795,
-0.0552633479,
-0.0565379597,
0.0428770334,
2.821e-7,
0.0193215571,
0.0297948178,
0.0187492725,
0.0378048643,
0.0189815033,
0.0405929536,
-0.0213246103,
-0.0079506794,
0.0179267824,
-0.0200550016,
-0.0189208966,
0.0403193235,
0.0268141944,
0.0032743814,
-0.0872768387,
0.0396952778,
0.0335137919,
-0.0106706163,
-0.0633384958,
-0.0214830525,
-0.0011245948,
0.0625039488,
0.0362335816,
-0.0102931503,
0.0538099818,
-0.0433138348,
0.0118514281,
-0.0464173518,
0.0554599725,
0.0326835252,
-0.0146108381,
0.0213666316,
-0.0077957958,
-0.0368712991,
-0.0080069583,
-0.0251861587,
-0.0055979267,
0.0522694699,
-0.0228343476,
0.0370063782,
0.0349120125,
-0.028490454,
-0.0154781872,
-0.0450360402,
0.0183775816,
-0.0351140089,
-0.0173888318,
0.0045408984,
-0.01223737,
0.0045150481,
0.0142542487,
-0.0374201536,
0.0283671096,
0.0115043325,
-0.0072001154,
-0.0163655728,
-0.0143241808,
-0.0378756672,
-0.0319889635,
-0.0042944085,
-0.0134742381,
0.0318611749,
-0.0661382824,
0.0340621062,
0.0386407562,
-0.0388772152,
-0.0038010606,
2.637958097e-34,
0.0147783402,
-0.0274995491,
0.0146173118,
0.0483986475,
0.0702346116,
-0.0232226253,
-0.0356090888,
0.0236090384,
-0.0043209004,
-0.0091988575,
-0.0440502428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19785v1 | What's "up" with vision-language models? Investigating their struggle with spatial reasoning | 2023-10-30T17:50:15 | 2023-10-30T17:50:15 | Amita Kamath, Jack Hessel, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Recent vision-language (VL) models are powerful, but can they reliably
distinguish "right" from "left"? We curate three new corpora to quantify model
comprehension of such basic spatial relations. These tests isolate spatial
reasoning more precisely than existing datasets like VQAv2, e.g., our What'sUp
benchmark contains sets of photographs varying only the spatial relations of
objects, keeping their identity fixed (see Figure 1: models must comprehend not
only the usual case of a dog under a table, but also, the same dog on top of
the same table). We evaluate 18 VL models, finding that all perform poorly,
e.g., BLIP finetuned on VQAv2, which nears human parity on VQAv2, achieves 56%
accuracy on our benchmarks vs. humans at 99%. We conclude by studying causes of
this surprising behavior, finding: 1) that popular vision-language pretraining
corpora like LAION-2B contain little reliable data for learning spatial
relationships; and 2) that basic modeling interventions like up-weighting
preposition-containing instances or fine-tuning on our corpora are not
sufficient to address the challenges our benchmarks pose. We are hopeful that
these corpora will facilitate further research, and we release our data and
code at https://github.com/amitakamath/whatsup_vlms. | [
0.0414281934,
0.0570059977,
-0.0198416784,
0.064923808,
-0.0519804992,
0.0421512425,
0.0262323972,
-0.0280052759,
-0.0196555238,
-0.0835316107,
-0.0329458453,
-0.0140393274,
0.049846068,
0.0144236302,
0.015907947,
-0.1047366112,
0.0429258086,
-0.0245265868,
-0.0405852906,
-0.0022047244,
-0.0311443396,
-0.0158875864,
-0.0365334526,
0.0374405868,
-0.0093087032,
-0.0259900913,
0.0067892158,
0.0135782557,
0.0090522319,
-0.0124619277,
-0.0036786257,
0.0308755022,
0.0252159685,
0.0096470984,
0.0000020779,
-0.015824426,
0.0260672774,
0.0138839278,
0.0295132361,
-0.000378772,
-0.0000163099,
-0.0781119093,
0.0004458985,
-0.0180570409,
-0.0320520513,
-0.038411621,
0.0652354285,
0.0148595925,
0.0052645858,
0.036883153,
-0.0057014572,
-0.0630871728,
0.0054940982,
-0.029072471,
0.035107661,
-0.0202817917,
0.0111804847,
-0.0105072306,
-0.0097833769,
0.006010497,
-0.0628683344,
0.0154601624,
0.0486116558,
0.0451429002,
-0.0016851814,
0.0557769984,
-0.042610012,
-0.0438745841,
-0.0299046375,
0.0532597937,
-0.0314385146,
-0.0324532427,
0.0004569649,
0.0103030168,
0.002465891,
-0.0054608295,
-0.0483831204,
0.06668327,
0.006028424,
0.020488536,
-0.0449354053,
-0.01680848,
0.0055504413,
-0.0014802075,
-0.0247663017,
0.0492926016,
0.0164861102,
0.0244281273,
-0.0044613131,
0.0318538584,
-0.0150885638,
-0.0499283858,
-0.0159311891,
0.0031951864,
-0.0095820101,
-0.0026832635,
-0.0148012545,
0.0361680016,
-0.0064893332,
-0.0378376879,
0.0808929875,
0.0331285708,
-0.0428213999,
0.0581677109,
-0.0362771228,
0.0872695073,
-0.0220881868,
0.0859088525,
-0.019983029,
-0.0073862108,
0.0081620514,
0.0094679939,
-0.0232745875,
-0.0182563718,
-0.046989765,
-0.0465564393,
-0.0172279328,
0.0010532632,
-0.0331038088,
0.0183291938,
-0.0197891612,
0.0191359129,
-0.0173219591,
-0.0133523764,
-0.0069364677,
0.0119971875,
-0.0044181794,
0.0311971679,
-0.049290292,
-0.0600145236,
-0.0124969827,
0.0424385034,
-0.0328940488,
-0.0252148733,
-0.0183888301,
0.0546266399,
0.0056839394,
-0.0466207452,
0.0086134812,
0.0171506535,
-0.0216483735,
-0.0540715642,
0.0555073842,
-0.0679946989,
-0.0281445216,
0.0162126049,
-0.0054925703,
-0.0486140698,
-0.0094698118,
0.0157015473,
-0.0637556016,
0.0938291624,
-0.0092549063,
0.0188365299,
-0.0139838001,
-0.0131381266,
0.032973092,
0.0661404133,
0.0379816368,
0.0153710116,
-0.0017076152,
0.0121371299,
-0.0126951775,
0.0217131302,
0.0045624403,
-0.0099922568,
-0.0770204142,
0.0002249832,
0.016389396,
0.0265177302,
0.0234753024,
0.0521620288,
0.0098786028,
-0.0434851944,
0.0498997159,
0.0391965732,
-0.0324787796,
-0.0195497777,
0.0535659641,
-0.0263501853,
-0.0189423505,
0.0062290137,
-0.0854433179,
0.0374199413,
-0.0215429198,
-0.0093648154,
-0.0324127153,
0.0219070129,
-0.036801815,
-0.0533062592,
-0.0501208305,
-0.0138430288,
0.0209589973,
0.0107733449,
0.0564496368,
0.0348519459,
-0.0009727261,
0.0149913589,
0.0168781485,
-0.0280945897,
-0.0255351048,
-0.0109574394,
0.0150134172,
0.0040711458,
0.0076477248,
0.0134859271,
-0.0268334076,
0.0118843811,
0.0607042648,
0.0573177636,
0.0582736097,
0.0212605204,
0.0288702417,
-0.0073408415,
-0.053185109,
-0.0079158675,
0.0108995568,
0.0059935623,
0.0306152124,
-0.0202984214,
0.0080239885,
-0.0761142224,
0.0155514907,
0.0629481673,
0.0185240302,
0.0316860676,
-0.0532576293,
0.0312652811,
-0.0106202224,
-0.0276658386,
-0.0125209419,
0.0029808048,
0.0447378308,
-0.030864086,
0.0376304016,
0.0506512038,
-0.0516839288,
-0.0460662097,
0.0430854969,
-0.049907513,
-0.0211148188,
0.0226680133,
-0.0248639714,
0.0052209166,
0.0147057287,
0.0004489755,
0.0029829219,
-0.0267752539,
0.0052277702,
0.0251699686,
-0.0002337972,
-0.0344688408,
0.0617298633,
-0.0266175717,
0.0321965814,
-0.0361832641,
-0.011537903,
0.0308961738,
-0.0207966808,
0.0258105937,
0.0028763723,
-0.0072088758,
-0.0005505495,
-0.0083825681,
0.0401232876,
-0.0262405481,
0.0123426309,
-0.0489581749,
-0.0030019393,
-0.0247561112,
-0.0234834626,
-0.0071913698,
-0.0419882759,
-0.0183313359,
-0.0632695928,
-0.0065215691,
0.0168768205,
-0.027755456,
0.0366146788,
0.045006372,
-0.0319018736,
-0.0061938744,
-0.0039590816,
-0.022989789,
-0.0121949958,
0.0388677418,
0.0241924562,
-0.0063138339,
-0.0156003833,
0.0206232667,
-0.0114743495,
0.0195463579,
-0.0087189972,
-0.013310845,
0.0487381183,
-0.0229285825,
-0.005681437,
0.1042690203,
-0.0112544792,
0.0207458828,
0.0114982286,
0.0111344391,
-0.0328053944,
-0.0209564157,
-0.0072323997,
-0.0461258814,
-0.0277702771,
-0.0102191502,
-0.0580660477,
0.0432893746,
-0.0322687849,
-0.002911997,
-0.0810861588,
0.0399314351,
-0.0214632452,
-0.0319597013,
-0.039505396,
0.0300198216,
0.0207083803,
0.0507037081,
-0.0584417731,
-0.0416908748,
0.0168576855,
-0.0329045281,
-0.0184855144,
-0.0086160656,
0.0384344347,
-0.0172700733,
0.087165162,
0.074941203,
0.0229381826,
-0.0225861948,
0.0013131903,
-0.0670916438,
-0.0267930534,
-0.0092504891,
0.0310973302,
0.0199093688,
-0.0744740143,
0.0354054905,
-0.0408265404,
-0.0655287728,
-0.0339080356,
0.0042988486,
-0.0408402123,
0.0133435726,
-0.0758736655,
-0.0102200173,
0.0061238357,
0.0426996648,
0.015653329,
0.0188311078,
-0.0251900908,
-0.0061104982,
-0.0316829234,
-0.0163035858,
0.045290675,
0.0351712517,
0.0099499868,
-0.0404148698,
-0.0568554588,
0.0704735741,
-0.000745257,
0.0261538699,
-0.0621269532,
0.0797253326,
0.0238588564,
0.0191921964,
-0.0351767465,
0.0325670913,
0.0778266788,
-0.0438186899,
-0.0517039932,
0.0646553785,
0.0630042404,
0.009274045,
0.0081188567,
0.0126630766,
0.0182970092,
0.0505592562,
-0.0150259165,
-0.0616923794,
-0.0408188514,
0.0366337262,
-0.016777195,
0.0543490164,
-0.0175622273,
0.0076841018,
-0.118209295,
0.0589145832,
0.0019945391,
-0.0645502061,
-0.0427333862,
0.0163440518,
-0.004338278,
-0.0235260148,
-0.0053067384,
-0.0192014258,
-0.0263627432,
0.0449421853,
0.020891957,
-0.0115402453,
-0.0132214157,
0.017213339,
-0.0642802864,
-0.0022997051,
0.0407734439,
0.0050958213,
0.0153352702,
-0.0849140957,
0.0206881277,
0.0067925937,
0.0279502068,
-0.009264471,
0.0626535267,
-0.0253814477,
-0.0409551598,
0.0322924852,
0.0331467427,
-0.0524624512,
-0.0399717204,
-0.0537811816,
-0.0021781405,
-0.0154588055,
0.0156946089,
-0.0408123955,
0.0407382064,
-0.0241425186,
0.0722203553,
0.0426301025,
0.0055390382,
-0.0793880001,
-0.0196982492,
0.0051167659,
-0.0218815487,
-0.0053666104,
0.0376398601,
0.0206151288,
-0.0263603684,
-0.0590240546,
-0.045511499,
0.0331797451,
0.0563358665,
-0.0031695967,
-0.044614356,
0.0002709768,
0.003453122,
-0.0747136399,
0.0686506703,
-0.0084370999,
0.0366455987,
-0.0347243957,
-0.0183354057,
0.0048764264,
-0.0216340777,
-0.0241741166,
-0.0200586002,
-0.0645922348,
-0.038854789,
0.0013882051,
0.0957321748,
0.0257928055,
0.0335902125,
-0.0055291639,
0.0012718186,
-0.0005556489,
0.053480342,
0.0197394136,
0.070583798,
0.016838612,
-0.0391882956,
0.0088128326,
0.0239652172,
-0.0042816699,
0.0172169879,
0.0440518372,
0.0085731102,
-0.0274405964,
0.008008997,
0.0153351966,
-0.0174502954,
0.0946130455,
-0.0159442239,
0.0032889154,
0.0065083415,
0.0081911413,
-0.0282534212,
0.0171057899,
-0.0551658198,
-0.0137406336,
0.0214583185,
0.0611071549,
-0.0067921933,
0.0080797011,
0.0067761862,
0.0253035892,
-0.0196157303,
-0.0231533162,
0.0172039531,
-0.0109398523,
-0.0098139131,
0.0348982215,
-0.0063337511,
0.0262799747,
-0.0325622819,
0.0664750189,
0.0116069699,
-0.0014905666,
0.0520126671,
0.0162707176,
-0.0375424139,
0.0349081866,
-0.0598603711,
-0.0838197172,
0.0005509238,
0.0441934019,
0.0757773072,
-0.0433391519,
0.0119341612,
-0.0093321428,
-0.0049840775,
-0.0065008602,
0.0253378768,
0.0242842361,
-0.0315430015,
0.0425476693,
0.0084949881,
-0.0104056923,
-0.0342518464,
0.0608132407,
0.0178944804,
0.0285934024,
0.01424844,
0.012951416,
-0.0314622633,
-0.0262603816,
0.0389228873,
-0.0051112678,
-0.0059119761,
0.0312546119,
-0.0575169772,
-0.0661433265,
-0.0165444203,
0.0451312363,
0.015034806,
0.0229414739,
0.0453206636,
0.0405136757,
0.0141028697,
-0.0507019348,
-0.0252037756,
-0.0266547892,
0.0102918558,
-0.0101769408,
0.0317522958,
-6.371936841e-33,
-0.0523623079,
0.0052474784,
0.0376994871,
-0.0110224662,
0.0322804414,
-0.0112656346,
-0.0294806492,
0.007490193,
-0.0497679859,
0.0209902171,
0.0151820602,
0.0096252291,
0.0098434342,
0.0219780281,
0.0234370343,
-0.0008201954,
0.0071040224,
-0.0155554637,
-0.0121361194,
-0.0509236418,
0.0386527814,
0.0147266937,
0.0480300151,
-0.0319230855,
-0.0432142653,
0.0380022675,
-0.0127452742,
0.0145561481,
-0.0389331803,
0.0356580727,
-0.0114626279,
-0.0212796163,
0.0258314349,
0.0315722078,
-0.0485053733,
-0.0102163311,
-0.0851616114,
-0.0243795253,
0.0132742831,
0.0778714195,
-0.0714449286,
0.0175389536,
0.0722898394,
-0.0135164298,
-0.0272325035,
-0.0288173947,
0.0311464947,
-0.0427205674,
-0.0290831737,
0.0644210428,
-0.0337726772,
-0.0145101119,
0.000092532,
-0.0556937195,
0.040816471,
-0.0196599513,
-0.0080210762,
0.042304147,
-0.0520536453,
-0.0015137721,
0.0095483437,
0.0350807123,
0.071282655,
0.0272576343,
0.0312374234,
0.0649047419,
0.059239991,
-0.0445154645,
-0.0071726213,
-0.0089213829,
0.0635511428,
0.0606366508,
0.042578768,
0.0414715037,
0.0382740572,
0.0166133866,
-0.068554163,
0.0073852721,
-0.055296395,
0.0502084643,
-0.0156162018,
0.009373636,
-0.0345380418,
-0.010747564,
-0.0097278645,
-0.0632580891,
-0.0236093104,
0.004022236,
0.0441963039,
-0.0046877456,
0.0322571062,
0.0370293371,
0.0360973924,
-0.0332032815,
-0.0284447894,
-0.0054393224,
-0.0346972346,
0.0213989783,
0.0102493139,
0.0443140157,
-0.0616089627,
-0.0166763645,
0.0205819421,
0.0425103903,
0.0049322741,
0.0378694683,
0.0825593024,
0.0008809569,
-0.0452984273,
-0.024263788,
-0.0396581478,
-0.0173445437,
0.0006489175,
0.0326121561,
0.0563786179,
0.0217151958,
-0.0214093085,
0.057028044,
-0.0206647776,
-0.0279376227,
-0.0356019773,
0.0028152911,
-0.0295220185,
0.0534720533,
0.0107047595,
-0.0304480586,
-0.0451890938,
0.0050786594,
0.0523657016,
-0.0485410877,
-0.0206186529,
0.0195649508,
2.78e-7,
0.054332111,
0.0368656926,
0.0302723851,
-0.0076493579,
0.0200184248,
0.0479316674,
-0.0382257588,
0.0243761521,
-0.024589356,
-0.0079725655,
-0.0090538478,
0.0718998164,
0.0465692021,
-0.0234314501,
-0.0026137021,
0.0848241001,
-0.0311962757,
0.0050537842,
-0.0620995685,
0.0146991378,
0.0220524836,
0.0263651405,
-0.0120889619,
0.0022861122,
0.0379256494,
-0.0377951339,
0.0492923558,
-0.0603160597,
0.0200397111,
-0.024109859,
0.0056071868,
0.003946736,
-0.006606264,
0.0222007204,
0.004387124,
-0.0136973765,
0.0231833532,
0.0066282544,
-0.0487828217,
0.0007039784,
-0.0318517126,
-0.0126948012,
-0.0226611644,
-0.0984629467,
0.0952418968,
-0.0587258153,
-0.0184909739,
0.0159061477,
-0.0317970812,
0.0426849201,
0.0341895707,
0.0068079126,
-0.0147906253,
-0.023035625,
0.04430262,
-0.0140750054,
-0.0378994942,
-0.0648442954,
-0.0253733881,
-0.0043066153,
-0.0143930595,
0.0011966791,
-0.0402070247,
-0.0082011446,
0.0303406231,
0.0103263939,
-0.1008799672,
2.243601783e-34,
-0.001520791,
0.0162562542,
0.0196076669,
-0.0319261402,
-0.0087959692,
-0.0360611975,
-0.0244428776,
0.0121384393,
-0.0382107124,
-0.0093519818,
0.0207462162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19750v1 | Chain-of-Thought Embeddings for Stance Detection on Social Media | 2023-10-30T17:18:10 | 2023-10-30T17:18:10 | Joseph Gatto, Omar Sharif, Sarah Masud Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stance detection on social media is challenging for Large Language Models
(LLMs), as emerging slang and colloquial language in online conversations often
contain deeply implicit stance labels. Chain-of-Thought (COT) prompting has
recently been shown to improve performance on stance detection tasks --
alleviating some of these issues. However, COT prompting still struggles with
implicit stance identification. This challenge arises because many samples are
initially challenging to comprehend before a model becomes familiar with the
slang and evolving knowledge related to different topics, all of which need to
be acquired through the training data. In this study, we address this problem
by introducing COT Embeddings which improve COT performance on stance detection
tasks by embedding COT reasonings and integrating them into a traditional
RoBERTa-based stance detection pipeline. Our analysis demonstrates that 1) text
encoders can leverage COT reasonings with minor errors or hallucinations that
would otherwise distort the COT output label. 2) Text encoders can overlook
misleading COT reasoning when a sample's prediction heavily depends on
domain-specific patterns. Our model achieves SOTA performance on multiple
stance detection datasets collected from social media. | [
0.0249084421,
0.0604047179,
0.0212678332,
0.0649643019,
-0.0058465898,
0.0440109894,
-0.0217225738,
-0.0080400845,
-0.0014265726,
-0.0477416553,
-0.0189469382,
-0.0385168865,
-0.004337145,
0.0061275782,
0.0312707201,
0.0019440874,
0.0369270928,
0.0223477278,
0.0243855175,
-0.0193891525,
0.0710178837,
0.0578601062,
-0.0430325791,
0.0366352759,
-0.0544893332,
-0.0536952429,
-0.0206149854,
0.0109493956,
0.0381319113,
-0.0244710352,
0.0334181488,
0.0557375997,
0.0635360777,
0.0500190519,
0.0000017628,
-0.0178093445,
-0.0183628071,
-0.0314954259,
-0.0198508203,
-0.0088942107,
-0.0309516806,
-0.0448885262,
0.0154867982,
0.0148441577,
-0.0351104774,
0.0180459712,
0.0332495533,
0.0342009813,
0.0680692196,
0.059855286,
-0.0078337025,
-0.0119682513,
-0.0003692338,
-0.0403377116,
-0.036714334,
-0.0524475835,
0.0258553568,
-0.0183000378,
-0.056514591,
0.0811635181,
-0.051113788,
0.0100990934,
0.0402820669,
-0.0390058309,
-0.034178298,
0.0025461586,
0.0210560784,
-0.0229598358,
0.0003496629,
0.0690474138,
-0.0068343533,
-0.0225708839,
-0.0103858076,
-0.0044223634,
0.0275427438,
-0.0206283368,
-0.0217872411,
0.0149467289,
-0.0105049862,
0.0442562215,
0.0035083983,
0.003845165,
-0.0050449711,
0.0453378148,
-0.0179983061,
0.0567691587,
-0.0379266217,
-0.0378878005,
0.0305084735,
0.0581936687,
-0.0053729084,
-0.0434516929,
0.0468991064,
0.0169945508,
-0.0538133942,
0.039370589,
-0.0165908113,
0.0239965543,
0.014320327,
-0.0573638305,
-0.0098141786,
0.0166488457,
-0.0150550976,
0.0664727315,
-0.0510509312,
0.0251083001,
-0.0406211056,
0.0180442352,
0.0027202391,
-0.0082173739,
-0.0610336177,
-0.0318514407,
-0.0279283337,
0.0321843289,
-0.043484848,
-0.0253302809,
-0.012944405,
0.0031182393,
-0.0224636737,
0.0066899662,
0.0110161174,
0.0120509863,
0.0071821855,
0.0075896359,
-0.0038241944,
0.0728856102,
-0.0156542454,
0.0236938689,
0.0217794403,
-0.0241909418,
-0.0324459523,
0.0039805896,
0.003360366,
-0.0069623739,
0.0042387815,
-0.0280801058,
-0.0000103266,
0.0004970367,
0.0075925831,
-0.015083883,
-0.0539068542,
-0.0826459229,
-0.0081944959,
-0.0685609058,
0.0548066758,
0.0042068358,
0.000399978,
-0.0415866412,
0.0191492736,
0.0448255055,
-0.0071724067,
0.0740257949,
0.0207016524,
-0.0281204544,
-0.0030392199,
0.0336964503,
0.0201731659,
0.1128973663,
0.0010552043,
0.0332552344,
-0.0009235954,
0.0187355634,
-0.0397322327,
0.0107458122,
0.0317288116,
0.0044848961,
0.003505196,
0.0414939299,
-0.0612369552,
0.020186102,
0.0207915269,
0.0534566194,
0.0020306783,
-0.014033935,
0.0659098253,
0.0235574543,
-0.0018742646,
0.0057340129,
0.0644155443,
0.0317172445,
0.0008872143,
-0.0215765312,
-0.0123061622,
0.0454153568,
0.0151811549,
-0.0317825377,
-0.0045480886,
0.0278597567,
-0.0344288684,
-0.0503924899,
0.004271281,
0.0164574552,
0.0021907929,
-0.0038064218,
-0.0020519316,
0.0223708674,
-0.0653202012,
0.0524957031,
0.014657761,
-0.0457505621,
-0.0251218192,
-0.0209104195,
0.0096812584,
0.0045402288,
0.0077994522,
0.0000310191,
-0.0475321002,
-0.0475450084,
0.0333193727,
0.1064852998,
0.0165872164,
-0.0332671404,
0.0114586605,
-0.0407899022,
-0.0166630801,
0.0032588958,
0.0090378709,
0.0283804983,
0.0080094161,
0.0322207585,
0.0049122637,
0.0209374521,
0.0442658402,
0.0087134317,
0.0404013023,
0.0108170137,
0.0081206011,
0.0385100134,
0.010014086,
0.041765783,
0.0192000642,
-0.03582884,
-0.0038471378,
-0.0324901119,
-0.0573678724,
-0.0120694181,
-0.0578753427,
-0.1085340381,
0.0353581049,
0.0081966138,
-0.083263956,
0.0160639547,
-0.0591445416,
-0.0073574218,
0.0063770739,
-0.0422770008,
-0.0078680245,
-0.0657033846,
-0.0393706188,
-0.0165988244,
0.0409391411,
0.0047857929,
0.0624536574,
-0.0394562893,
-0.0167770088,
0.0307090599,
-0.0111347288,
0.0312327258,
0.0073658642,
-0.0204009991,
0.0033363486,
0.0084543377,
0.0029076077,
0.0203543548,
0.017833529,
-0.0299975816,
-0.0106823947,
-0.1028169394,
-0.0199452955,
-0.0460073538,
0.0138429385,
0.0287761595,
-0.0151326628,
0.0111586759,
-0.0230492838,
-0.0431432575,
-0.0207341053,
-0.0193382185,
0.0329997689,
0.0319373421,
-0.024799563,
-0.0038607181,
-0.0219755378,
0.0081637371,
-0.0122042848,
0.0349094085,
-0.0256440677,
-0.0648955181,
-0.0255999248,
0.0011295679,
-0.0308244955,
-0.024871856,
0.0070636435,
-0.0503405966,
0.0334455669,
0.015284338,
0.0402402319,
0.0613710098,
0.0346166715,
0.075078316,
-0.0084546963,
0.0158881247,
-0.0386016183,
0.0158699248,
-0.0130204866,
0.0179506224,
-0.0240875594,
0.0095133297,
-0.0043253107,
0.0698306486,
-0.013029946,
-0.0069364775,
-0.0616086088,
-0.0069602197,
-0.0378984883,
-0.030289704,
-0.0082371002,
-0.0391260274,
-0.0243027322,
-0.0068451688,
-0.0388081893,
-0.0058782529,
0.0946981609,
-0.0174148884,
-0.0243664272,
-0.0282455124,
-0.0164347552,
-0.0371757783,
0.0325990804,
0.0314649008,
0.0079911882,
0.0005430988,
-0.0190713536,
-0.0100412332,
-0.0400332026,
-0.0001464028,
-0.0306922905,
0.0303750113,
0.014004699,
0.0261784457,
0.0128834425,
-0.0543794967,
-0.040359363,
-0.0595605783,
-0.0476277433,
-0.0157959163,
-0.0276420116,
-0.0190576576,
0.0815973505,
-0.0009884944,
0.0039475798,
0.0035232401,
-0.0265913494,
-0.0010877576,
-0.0136977965,
0.0158010442,
0.0489815995,
-0.0108792568,
0.0140413139,
-0.0144516509,
0.0403780304,
0.0841357633,
-0.0282796342,
0.0153256813,
-0.0244867858,
-0.0171063375,
0.0087264525,
0.006616001,
0.0093069151,
-0.0278137866,
0.0754735768,
-0.0247758012,
-0.0224132836,
0.1070303842,
0.0402987301,
-0.044527363,
0.0092484374,
0.0601760559,
0.0173686706,
0.0125425011,
-0.0145515297,
-0.058917135,
-0.0430143811,
0.0031888841,
-0.0140907252,
-0.00905436,
-0.0162944775,
-0.0150056211,
-0.0909011066,
-0.0115427813,
-0.0303381607,
-0.0296710338,
-0.0255386457,
-0.0176748149,
0.0333020426,
-0.0036244898,
0.0454852954,
-0.0089687137,
0.0200276468,
-0.0097999964,
0.0404237323,
-0.0358980559,
-0.0104844384,
0.0020698211,
-0.0188443493,
0.0245318506,
0.0034421408,
0.044996161,
0.0284834243,
-0.0288128182,
0.04988686,
-0.0324647687,
0.0028606402,
-0.0278323852,
0.0329695717,
-0.0377966128,
-0.0102653317,
-0.0345875658,
0.0331050679,
-0.0561549701,
0.0081709391,
-0.0434104539,
0.0569768883,
0.0002030791,
-0.0091544697,
-0.0162527487,
0.039304968,
0.0365595929,
0.0515250079,
0.068472147,
-0.0474361107,
-0.0299988892,
-0.0566431582,
-0.0344504341,
-0.0713936016,
-0.0434899814,
-0.0393538177,
0.0298164897,
0.0323061235,
-0.0475188121,
-0.0406078994,
-0.0036427504,
0.0458169989,
-0.0334130153,
-0.0104332771,
0.0136997821,
-0.0000854964,
-0.0335313566,
0.0158965606,
-0.0166706443,
0.0380640551,
-0.0070794509,
0.0044552106,
0.047397431,
0.0291555505,
-0.0305440016,
-0.0057382002,
-0.094449535,
-0.0448505729,
-0.0414834991,
0.0250942167,
0.0127942907,
0.0464247279,
-0.0328473486,
-0.018630255,
0.0574468262,
0.0593047217,
-0.0083339205,
0.0192913432,
0.0447431728,
0.0346315391,
0.0023659617,
0.0663461685,
-0.0059474269,
-0.0074419277,
0.0112713771,
0.0266040713,
-0.024456596,
-0.0034958879,
0.0193451755,
-0.0288390033,
0.0276145842,
0.0065093613,
-0.0563534983,
-0.0238066427,
0.0025767754,
-0.0231575109,
-0.0489784703,
-0.0356380753,
0.013973183,
0.0253472775,
-0.0352500975,
-0.0467157364,
0.0079718288,
-0.0108873975,
0.0841882825,
-0.0116382483,
0.0215930287,
0.0380965322,
0.0238694344,
0.0005877832,
0.0010607138,
-0.050702177,
-0.030111013,
0.0327288248,
-0.0039206562,
0.004873402,
0.0739001259,
0.0295612682,
-0.0281515662,
0.0225606691,
0.034147948,
-0.018801298,
0.000165709,
-0.0235066749,
0.0117657464,
0.0290095359,
-0.0315290354,
0.0361634083,
-0.0111331102,
-0.0272317808,
0.0139483893,
0.0349684954,
-0.0406817868,
-0.060766533,
0.0408578031,
0.0173792839,
-0.0212114472,
0.0043169977,
0.0323808677,
-0.0324746743,
0.0031940143,
0.0455498658,
-0.0215664469,
-0.0270149298,
-0.015548747,
-0.0393691696,
0.015795555,
0.0143215777,
0.0592744648,
-0.0518469959,
-0.0892536864,
-0.0242332909,
-0.0082098767,
-0.0034742896,
0.062633723,
0.0030367514,
0.0522902831,
0.0159664005,
0.0263571236,
-0.0476074181,
0.0315481164,
0.0099570276,
-0.0531654097,
-0.0186203457,
-6.271300565e-33,
0.0008882498,
-0.0426197946,
-0.0259589795,
0.0083800089,
-0.0304660611,
0.0251074489,
-0.0320293233,
-0.000246863,
-0.0116513688,
0.0779163614,
-0.0029735072,
0.0389553085,
-0.0063631274,
0.0511379391,
-0.0035758333,
-0.0205030441,
0.0215244312,
-0.0041603469,
-0.039383661,
0.0012785101,
0.0549733154,
0.005793042,
0.0539888479,
-0.0579754077,
0.0428261124,
0.0048353998,
-0.0337788314,
0.0419859588,
-0.0031845279,
0.0716691166,
-0.0184394009,
0.036696244,
0.0435275398,
-0.0512695834,
-0.0008109226,
0.0821528137,
-0.0721831992,
-0.0053393985,
0.0047879554,
0.0445992574,
-0.0181399044,
0.0098154824,
-0.0079033924,
-0.0140849128,
0.021526346,
-0.016198799,
0.0004979462,
-0.0046259086,
0.0400453359,
-0.0238351077,
-0.0382197388,
0.0142186321,
-0.0222191624,
-0.0575014874,
0.0132458173,
0.0328278877,
0.0245201234,
0.0055279932,
-0.04909252,
-0.0057027945,
-0.1234090477,
0.007540999,
0.0230630096,
-0.0197733659,
-0.0240563806,
0.0621356443,
-0.0284730196,
-0.0075893565,
-0.0527544469,
0.0023919144,
-0.007030047,
-0.0059649176,
0.0667135268,
0.0412666239,
0.04390423,
0.0229611024,
-0.0766628087,
-0.0228980221,
0.055953946,
0.0201578159,
0.0167873856,
0.0182169713,
-0.0420705862,
-0.0240222532,
-0.0028847116,
-0.0427311473,
-0.0276726577,
-0.0245410539,
-0.011124637,
0.0111810844,
-0.0340599753,
0.041348096,
0.0461874045,
-0.052139055,
-0.0513836592,
0.0683252886,
-0.0128535377,
0.0106933909,
0.0379555114,
0.0541872047,
-0.0240616743,
0.0318925604,
0.0179327615,
0.0175038185,
0.010837174,
-0.0003657645,
0.1225924939,
-0.0017584421,
-0.0813129395,
-0.0171053335,
-0.0506940782,
0.0253809579,
-0.0671994165,
0.0676930845,
0.0243028719,
0.0156782642,
-0.0366595089,
0.0868385956,
-0.0127708707,
0.0072679403,
-0.0204846784,
0.0314069241,
-0.0290300585,
0.0233294759,
-0.029035965,
-0.0334079936,
0.0005600938,
0.0134500228,
-0.0206959844,
-0.1031180695,
0.0046706912,
0.0406176522,
2.532e-7,
0.0285872165,
0.0497405156,
0.0391569361,
-0.0216491222,
0.0610938631,
0.0496372245,
0.0163741652,
0.0183589198,
0.0009150555,
-0.0703250542,
-0.0295323152,
0.0798927322,
0.0566083789,
0.0226367246,
-0.0897737741,
-0.0161285177,
-0.0427981392,
-0.0107223801,
-0.0407260992,
-0.0175866056,
0.0106001217,
0.079001002,
0.0313754678,
-0.0172639452,
0.0152635658,
0.0081896046,
0.039563939,
0.0304048583,
0.0214053225,
-0.0015066932,
0.0190861449,
-0.0640621856,
0.0217209999,
0.0246666353,
-0.0102652879,
0.0101839071,
0.0206066649,
0.052582901,
0.030258555,
-0.0516197197,
-0.0342246108,
0.0018520253,
0.0219137352,
-0.0376344696,
0.0788256675,
-0.0469585471,
-0.0246494804,
-0.0414520949,
-0.0260187089,
0.0148179447,
0.050487861,
0.0111310687,
-0.0276089329,
0.0252992883,
0.0325247422,
-0.0110016037,
0.0069766315,
-0.105896607,
-0.0110029681,
-0.0155952713,
-0.0543477461,
-0.0046683797,
0.0167862438,
-0.0258125532,
0.0319044515,
-0.059864942,
-0.0130893784,
2.228731779e-34,
0.0047734589,
-0.0266413298,
0.0591971837,
0.0122656766,
0.0212335344,
0.0271180607,
-0.0031669808,
-0.0152183715,
0.0417931341,
-0.0449264832,
-0.0038474242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19740v1 | Collaborative Evaluation: Exploring the Synergy of Large Language Models and Humans for Open-ended Generation Evaluation | 2023-10-30T17:04:35 | 2023-10-30T17:04:35 | Qintong Li, Leyang Cui, Lingpeng Kong, Wei Bi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans are widely involved in the evaluation of open-ended natural language
generation tasks (NLG) that demand creativity, as automatic metrics often
exhibit weak correlations with human judgments. Large language models (LLMs)
recently have emerged as a scalable and cost-effective alternative to human
evaluations. However, both humans and LLMs have limitations, i.e., inherent
subjectivity and unreliable judgments, particularly for open-ended tasks that
require adaptable metrics tailored to diverse task requirements. To explore the
synergy between humans and LLM-based evaluators and address the challenges of
existing inconsistent evaluation criteria in open-ended NLG tasks, we propose a
Collaborative Evaluation pipeline CoEval, involving the design of a checklist
of task-specific criteria and the detailed evaluation of texts, in which LLM
generates initial ideation, and then humans engage in scrutiny. We conducted a
series of experiments to investigate the mutual effects between LLMs and humans
in CoEval. Results show that, by utilizing LLMs, CoEval effectively evaluates
lengthy texts, saving significant time and reducing human evaluation outliers.
Human scrutiny still plays a role, revising around 20% of LLM evaluation scores
for ultimate reliability. | [
0.0652227849,
0.0343193747,
-0.0027824983,
-0.0000802565,
-0.0490192659,
0.0039893105,
0.0165643338,
-0.0318540931,
-0.0172641594,
-0.0475136153,
-0.0304411538,
-0.0612416826,
0.0252303444,
0.0441261306,
0.0292381123,
-0.0450401865,
-0.0307446625,
-0.0195146799,
0.0311506558,
0.0201254915,
-0.0081947865,
0.0283506941,
-0.0154120559,
0.0585844107,
0.0212678593,
-0.0012225893,
-0.0098265717,
0.0011268161,
0.040771082,
-0.0442056991,
-0.0230842028,
0.0684816763,
-0.0230785552,
0.0189092308,
0.0000018683,
-0.0767748579,
0.0151828015,
-0.0106874323,
0.0228515174,
0.0227599423,
0.0694833621,
0.0311118253,
-0.0034418534,
0.000619374,
-0.0260183532,
0.0076553598,
0.0124699548,
0.0228748303,
0.0689233243,
0.0341449939,
0.0060510826,
0.0126280766,
-0.0350264609,
-0.0217600428,
-0.005937885,
-0.0062253908,
-0.0118769407,
-0.0045953323,
0.0326325819,
-0.0150021091,
0.0189455412,
-0.0026715065,
0.0338923968,
-0.039287895,
0.0490895733,
0.0309133418,
-0.0493281409,
-0.0526425168,
0.0029563112,
0.0757362023,
0.028036125,
-0.0014281947,
-0.0149290273,
-0.0204929952,
0.0068432954,
0.0050414857,
-0.0246862192,
0.0497497953,
-0.0112947328,
0.0100584375,
-0.0190392751,
0.0256433375,
-0.0025357937,
0.032559786,
0.0257615708,
0.0560368821,
0.017770052,
-0.0127856554,
0.0118741207,
0.0448704176,
-0.0317720659,
-0.0724522546,
0.0199585482,
0.0082971454,
-0.0464342833,
-0.0024118565,
-0.0280562751,
-0.0232148282,
0.0302902218,
-0.0409727544,
0.0823042393,
-0.0061878562,
0.0002621166,
0.0155379381,
-0.0120938551,
0.0545435883,
0.0106752878,
-0.0117778992,
-0.0644831583,
0.020612115,
-0.0520896316,
-0.0009774246,
-0.0304323733,
-0.0009532319,
-0.0139639881,
-0.023685962,
-0.0647424757,
0.0057152091,
-0.0046213064,
-0.0127097201,
0.0142797763,
0.0667118803,
-0.0078806905,
-0.0073243957,
-0.052774556,
0.0068256953,
-0.0316240564,
0.0099407248,
0.0405729152,
0.0004284574,
0.0160734262,
0.0499076508,
0.0086713536,
-0.0269908253,
0.0037148637,
0.0444819555,
-0.0122894514,
-0.0156004634,
-0.0155992396,
-0.055539839,
-0.017499458,
-0.0648710206,
-0.0084892772,
-0.0475938842,
-0.0056938878,
0.0172202531,
-0.0111916065,
-0.0113543421,
0.0149826221,
0.0341032594,
0.0002995178,
0.0152539453,
-0.0113686128,
0.0173369665,
-0.0038702099,
0.0071161431,
-0.0085969623,
0.0417992808,
0.0730347037,
0.0685132444,
0.018676728,
0.0093618548,
0.0297571011,
0.005492934,
-0.0196184833,
-0.0212239921,
-0.0098410593,
0.0045111137,
-0.0258634146,
0.0724148452,
0.0231943838,
0.0946278796,
-0.0126996739,
0.0368716717,
0.0953205004,
0.0187377296,
0.0225578602,
0.0264527705,
0.099141039,
0.0395387001,
-0.0068314732,
0.026939949,
0.0030390748,
0.0377471559,
-0.0061873607,
0.0169572458,
0.0336188488,
0.0521241911,
-0.0007427727,
-0.0406607687,
-0.0315038934,
0.0165674426,
0.0268898234,
-0.0432676002,
0.018341383,
0.0333648361,
-0.0536832139,
0.0145971552,
-0.0198956709,
-0.0849490538,
0.0487102084,
-0.0201529749,
0.0623615943,
0.1051378921,
0.0824886933,
0.051179938,
0.0126007684,
-0.0092589473,
-0.0047755023,
0.055064857,
0.0497850999,
-0.0123173529,
-0.0319287106,
-0.0362336263,
-0.0163074303,
-0.0142796403,
0.0012530581,
-0.006996775,
0.0056999419,
-0.0114065865,
0.0346571393,
-0.0191425122,
-0.0877332091,
0.0410684943,
-0.012863053,
-0.0044348235,
-0.000273248,
0.0095420089,
0.0039878786,
0.0353672504,
-0.0324117765,
0.0486173779,
0.0089067519,
-0.0401866995,
-0.053403724,
0.0540318415,
-0.0233310387,
0.0067293379,
-0.0068737613,
-0.0651061311,
0.0075284094,
-0.0032333746,
0.0099195121,
-0.0251526963,
0.0248295199,
-0.0569472164,
-0.0138479574,
-0.0383006781,
0.0109641245,
0.0059467875,
0.0014557655,
-0.0263204556,
0.0368404761,
0.00700502,
0.0161046535,
0.0210793689,
-0.0124228671,
0.0033506625,
-0.0242262222,
-0.0315937661,
0.0067916838,
0.0105937487,
0.0178089775,
0.0325733088,
0.0325862914,
-0.0725764558,
-0.0613910519,
-0.0973804221,
-0.0060549835,
-0.0152727105,
0.0286956113,
0.0368822329,
-0.0424643643,
-0.010933836,
0.0563336685,
-0.0402477011,
-0.0205108728,
0.0361596867,
0.0099185426,
0.0377270989,
0.0056527038,
-0.0083262911,
-0.0122563038,
0.022220144,
0.0091574937,
0.0655003786,
0.0947643742,
0.0488673225,
-0.0379063822,
0.0534566194,
-0.0481447428,
-0.0497610606,
0.0366967358,
-0.0443684086,
0.0388329476,
0.0245295167,
0.0459430628,
0.0278620161,
0.0419549122,
-0.0002712444,
0.0544621833,
-0.036381606,
-0.003309909,
-0.0260027964,
-0.013904647,
-0.0061564664,
0.0088080605,
-0.013228056,
0.0160474107,
0.0346206613,
0.0155059136,
0.0009429375,
-0.0566407107,
0.0710162371,
-0.0552918948,
-0.0584628917,
-0.0182441641,
-0.0573279075,
-0.0347615704,
0.046643164,
-0.0177224148,
-0.0506887808,
0.0749038532,
-0.0383203663,
-0.0118926559,
-0.0356146879,
0.0266587604,
-0.0483625717,
0.0683018938,
-0.0156216873,
0.0202374216,
0.0017093475,
0.031368345,
-0.0409443788,
0.0305507071,
0.0202330891,
-0.0426482409,
-0.0077571482,
-0.0565489717,
-0.0342744067,
-0.0097599821,
-0.013197165,
-0.0401562154,
-0.0197911933,
-0.0036401011,
0.0144389886,
0.0696958601,
0.0013806811,
-0.0026498924,
0.0167546254,
0.014630801,
-0.0163993575,
-0.0197255947,
-0.0061476519,
-0.0017666152,
0.039629668,
0.0340632498,
0.0177577063,
0.0200131815,
-0.0415483452,
0.0131661352,
0.0230262205,
-0.0058623431,
0.0209785551,
-0.0153157674,
0.0112402579,
0.0039964607,
0.0003650081,
-0.0078222239,
0.0347884744,
0.061891593,
-0.043883495,
-0.0282867588,
0.0876221061,
0.0278646052,
-0.0331822969,
0.0047795083,
-0.0024030171,
0.021925563,
0.0012595176,
0.0145022031,
-0.0409836322,
0.0069446382,
0.006099741,
0.0419777185,
-0.0369533934,
-0.0377850719,
-0.0496168248,
-0.1122484207,
0.0590833127,
0.0194440354,
-0.0067850342,
0.0228864662,
-0.0112355985,
-0.0278281607,
-0.0164515264,
-0.0259167757,
0.0323750339,
-0.0087118838,
0.0458833203,
0.0189853311,
-0.0215571783,
-0.0503897779,
0.0303143747,
-0.0568658449,
0.0488617495,
0.0678956285,
0.0398033112,
0.0246549752,
-0.067378521,
-0.0002016746,
-0.018118035,
0.0344497822,
0.016554635,
0.0315252841,
0.0227640029,
0.0173616242,
-0.0626927614,
0.0163431559,
-0.0391160548,
-0.0212639663,
-0.0029428741,
0.0472342856,
-0.0228902716,
-0.0164698604,
-0.0141206952,
0.0595350564,
0.0050805183,
0.0838417038,
0.050360743,
-0.0899535716,
-0.0321028531,
0.0165838841,
-0.0137869334,
-0.1272921562,
-0.0402065143,
0.0092376191,
0.0160720609,
-0.0026597464,
-0.1250084341,
-0.0533782877,
0.0087918192,
0.0401667245,
0.0065699089,
-0.014190332,
-0.0280026197,
-0.0037234917,
-0.0108089354,
0.0474432632,
0.019065246,
0.020906752,
-0.0436579473,
-0.007344991,
-0.0242923163,
-0.0521772429,
-0.0092531722,
0.0745743737,
-0.0862360746,
-0.0555883981,
0.0015655002,
0.0207212232,
0.0259145927,
-0.01482003,
0.009328723,
-0.0621372685,
0.01000176,
0.0366485715,
-0.0422129445,
0.036382921,
-0.0273036435,
0.0397237502,
-0.0086836452,
0.0021598455,
-0.0057208701,
0.0038294417,
0.0224368609,
0.0614397749,
0.0644714162,
-0.0666321218,
0.0192037448,
0.036359217,
0.0041223741,
-0.081943512,
0.0020393333,
-0.0436176471,
-0.0455240496,
-0.0067358636,
-0.0426598303,
-0.0525609888,
-0.001371696,
-0.0040853536,
-0.0091375345,
-0.0084472653,
0.0150535041,
-0.0422075763,
0.0442764945,
-0.0408170149,
0.0235030577,
0.0168004632,
0.0015426767,
0.0250473544,
-0.0079614772,
-0.0151382154,
0.0001698419,
-0.0779440552,
0.0254304241,
0.0107520875,
0.0605110489,
-0.0055586467,
0.0027167213,
0.0152268503,
0.0543271601,
-0.0272898115,
-0.0097079352,
-0.0470497608,
0.0041034948,
0.0382954329,
0.0292160176,
0.0769483596,
-0.0324252024,
0.0192793608,
-0.0131727923,
0.0444730222,
-0.0268547144,
-0.0392304175,
-0.015704684,
0.0102755371,
-0.0152921779,
-0.0365640894,
0.0491610393,
-0.0187040996,
0.0025855952,
-0.0270074569,
-0.0230631139,
-0.0366286375,
-0.0344889686,
-0.0233461671,
-0.0138001675,
-0.0031785402,
0.0198664609,
-0.0930171162,
-0.034911193,
0.0156047968,
0.052249562,
0.046481993,
-0.0038798626,
0.053349223,
0.0422591642,
-0.0452259518,
0.0059024026,
-0.0508706421,
-0.022053998,
-0.0209797863,
0.0146420775,
-0.0553550459,
-6.095956114e-33,
-0.0263780728,
-0.0624472052,
0.031619221,
-0.0377343334,
-0.050467886,
-0.0088209175,
-0.0432824753,
0.045133546,
0.077286683,
0.018284779,
0.0213840473,
-0.0514466316,
-0.002766564,
-0.0063615949,
0.028577771,
0.0072630527,
0.0425411165,
-0.0293835178,
-0.0716563538,
0.0140488325,
0.0304576531,
0.0035539889,
-0.0096265851,
-0.051297687,
0.0479544774,
-0.0059424858,
-0.0408994853,
-0.0137233464,
0.0214846954,
0.0542796962,
-0.0152991163,
0.0275667198,
0.0419501625,
-0.0269955061,
-0.0195170194,
0.0086730206,
-0.0080411565,
0.0152747231,
0.013631722,
-0.0361388773,
-0.0424525477,
-0.0205422249,
0.0432929099,
-0.0028273971,
-0.043303892,
0.0206422918,
0.0275169555,
-0.0312779397,
0.0260237902,
-0.0458646715,
-0.0437044017,
0.0198647752,
-0.0105680646,
-0.0431190319,
-0.0282913689,
0.0610697195,
-0.0381109156,
-0.0057460745,
-0.0397967845,
0.0491190515,
0.0003415858,
0.0019763773,
0.0682938099,
-0.009841538,
-0.0214972198,
0.0662042573,
0.0054863906,
0.0389929935,
-0.0638946071,
-0.014545857,
0.0045824032,
0.0460451841,
0.0661554337,
0.0765351206,
-0.0059119854,
0.0029879822,
-0.0092136683,
0.0598680489,
-0.035661947,
0.0065967357,
0.0381162688,
-0.0125820013,
-0.0183024872,
-0.0209217295,
-0.0386714712,
-0.0430856459,
-0.0427623019,
-0.0290545933,
0.0429251343,
0.0174047053,
-0.0374744236,
-0.0584323108,
0.022454964,
0.0049037072,
0.0321992338,
-0.0084617473,
-0.0662413538,
0.0300189108,
-0.0124976756,
-0.0331780687,
-0.0461599417,
0.0109823802,
0.0488215648,
0.0518650264,
0.0264850501,
-0.0085695442,
0.0030285825,
0.0168021955,
-0.0379876979,
0.0267636944,
-0.047072947,
0.0440511182,
0.0246709622,
-0.016029384,
0.011909551,
-0.029648887,
-0.0508603416,
0.019286016,
0.0037351523,
0.0070058089,
-0.0245135911,
-0.0096170129,
0.022192562,
-0.006534047,
-0.0362379067,
0.0215219297,
0.0208399035,
-0.0193903111,
0.0374851897,
-0.0059163771,
-0.0159068741,
-0.0004310159,
2.631e-7,
0.0161296744,
0.0438001789,
0.0107723987,
-0.0093771238,
0.0223521087,
0.0193483979,
-0.0159678739,
0.0108466186,
-0.0188365486,
-0.0063628196,
0.008604411,
0.0073220399,
0.0612424538,
0.0442212746,
-0.0631827042,
0.0079612155,
-0.0820220485,
0.0115755908,
-0.0325637683,
-0.0401435643,
0.0918171406,
-0.021356374,
0.0057369266,
-0.0184712075,
-0.0131627629,
-0.0593738928,
0.0651415661,
-0.0222579353,
-0.024048578,
0.0054356409,
0.0641288236,
-0.0159093346,
-0.0043683168,
0.0265028141,
-0.0005140323,
-0.0294059385,
0.0343956426,
0.027464442,
0.0365855657,
-0.0083340816,
0.0225586481,
-0.002672615,
0.004611772,
-0.0706588253,
0.03525104,
-0.0601238571,
-0.0408298485,
-0.0285145696,
0.0095178355,
-0.0268247109,
0.0349086523,
-0.0409382731,
0.0093364343,
0.0234973114,
0.0087218815,
0.0087424191,
0.0020425811,
-0.0274289045,
-0.0532496311,
-0.008350349,
-0.0571487918,
-0.0447236672,
-0.0537881851,
0.0199617259,
-0.0290994067,
-0.0628940091,
0.0115779461,
2.187664782e-34,
0.0444589928,
-0.0124427956,
-0.0076344805,
-0.0253178272,
0.0706234798,
0.0205198713,
-0.0313448682,
-0.0130614778,
0.0038047961,
-0.0687056407,
-0.0178924892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19736v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19736v3 | Evaluating Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey | 2023-10-30T17:00:52 | 2023-11-25T17:35:12 | Zishan Guo, Renren Jin, Chuang Liu, Yufei Huang, Dan Shi, Supryadi, Linhao Yu, Yan Liu, Jiaxuan Li, Bojian Xiong, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
a broad spectrum of tasks. They have attracted significant attention and been
deployed in numerous downstream applications. Nevertheless, akin to a
double-edged sword, LLMs also present potential risks. They could suffer from
private data leaks or yield inappropriate, harmful, or misleading content.
Additionally, the rapid progress of LLMs raises concerns about the potential
emergence of superintelligent systems without adequate safeguards. To
effectively capitalize on LLM capacities as well as ensure their safe and
beneficial development, it is critical to conduct a rigorous and comprehensive
evaluation of LLMs.
This survey endeavors to offer a panoramic perspective on the evaluation of
LLMs. We categorize the evaluation of LLMs into three major groups: knowledge
and capability evaluation, alignment evaluation and safety evaluation. In
addition to the comprehensive review on the evaluation methodologies and
benchmarks on these three aspects, we collate a compendium of evaluations
pertaining to LLMs' performance in specialized domains, and discuss the
construction of comprehensive evaluation platforms that cover LLM evaluations
on capabilities, alignment, safety, and applicability.
We hope that this comprehensive overview will stimulate further research
interests in the evaluation of LLMs, with the ultimate goal of making
evaluation serve as a cornerstone in guiding the responsible development of
LLMs. We envision that this will channel their evolution into a direction that
maximizes societal benefit while minimizing potential risks. A curated list of
related papers has been publicly available at
https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/Awesome-LLMs-Evaluation-Papers. | [
0.0330377594,
0.0973290056,
-0.0223812275,
0.046397958,
-0.0757780373,
0.0074055167,
0.0323898308,
-0.0235757548,
0.0243314561,
-0.0302420594,
-0.0513434075,
-0.0543328524,
-0.000187235,
0.0417751893,
0.0288738441,
0.0174926035,
0.0438727736,
-0.0606866442,
-0.0065681697,
0.0092025707,
0.0035675433,
0.0063622561,
0.0384329893,
0.0492460653,
0.0039134119,
-0.0070167989,
-0.0050440817,
-0.0067334212,
0.011994794,
-0.0303495433,
-0.0265311543,
0.0380534232,
-0.0015853187,
0.1244732141,
0.0000022202,
-0.0637854263,
-0.0349373706,
0.0507654957,
-0.0303250682,
0.0588046759,
0.0557433814,
-0.0203049369,
-0.0370080583,
0.0035627652,
-0.0346147344,
0.0017716473,
0.0719757229,
-0.0270715971,
0.0536370464,
0.0596007407,
-0.0015729595,
-0.0312861241,
0.0258320589,
-0.0214078631,
-0.0507228747,
-0.043890167,
0.0498887338,
0.0156459436,
0.0230404828,
0.0159637239,
0.0180220958,
0.0392195508,
-0.0005909855,
-0.0358603597,
-0.0214449074,
0.0041991971,
-0.0214245226,
-0.0290725604,
-0.0081825014,
0.023307221,
0.0193630159,
-0.0141149927,
0.0170778334,
0.007877063,
-0.0231698379,
0.0067016291,
-0.0209041946,
0.0383008495,
0.0264421608,
0.0271676183,
0.0232331846,
-0.0074377223,
0.0587510131,
0.0276768915,
-0.0072693778,
0.0832515806,
0.0289089959,
-0.0331484415,
-0.029077705,
-0.018918328,
0.0107710967,
-0.0855207294,
-0.0051608565,
0.0227810796,
-0.0206509866,
0.0398310237,
-0.0380392708,
-0.0372868925,
0.0549722575,
-0.0821518227,
0.0426343977,
0.0122696189,
0.0295648705,
0.0583127402,
0.0096582072,
0.075466916,
-0.041498851,
0.0176516846,
-0.0199939273,
-0.0113337478,
-0.0235863496,
-0.0016349867,
0.0074391407,
0.0360486843,
-0.0109882569,
-0.012357234,
-0.0278809331,
0.0610520318,
0.0036922703,
0.056513302,
-0.0124806054,
-0.0449222997,
0.0229789652,
-0.0322517268,
-0.0156694427,
-0.0040065064,
0.0167553611,
0.0005379966,
-0.0147032207,
-0.0479185954,
0.0388533995,
0.0236872714,
-0.0591608696,
-0.0355242081,
-0.0064959028,
0.1136438176,
0.0249849688,
-0.0102677112,
-0.0288996305,
-0.0265524983,
-0.0284684375,
-0.0736859143,
-0.0378363132,
-0.0855563506,
0.002099701,
0.0175654329,
-0.0146525409,
-0.046701733,
0.000493674,
-0.0211093836,
-0.0359039493,
0.0273822844,
-0.0461200438,
0.0436395891,
0.0167946406,
0.0223720502,
0.0184788089,
0.1013570949,
0.038445197,
0.020030709,
0.0524172448,
-0.0108848372,
-0.0071880664,
0.064020969,
-0.02726846,
0.0367714614,
-0.0439511724,
0.0441686958,
0.0338977091,
0.0116100553,
-0.0220890772,
0.0816923752,
0.0183648653,
-0.0132654849,
0.0905851945,
0.0377895907,
-0.0117831174,
0.0259729084,
0.0338320285,
0.0069833933,
0.0226520542,
-0.0332384557,
-0.0427798964,
-0.0271828584,
-0.0594746433,
-0.007639396,
0.0030517108,
0.0618001819,
-0.0106974421,
-0.0161803588,
-0.0363558903,
-0.0304047707,
0.0234699883,
0.0281574074,
0.0569685809,
-0.0505704321,
-0.0002411988,
0.0226071533,
0.0091748415,
-0.0472381338,
0.0161502063,
-0.0593393818,
0.0014624442,
0.0846940205,
0.0730975717,
-0.0098537197,
-0.0251004007,
0.0141503671,
-0.0190897584,
0.033571329,
0.0343379192,
-0.0120890914,
-0.0005247491,
-0.0293839145,
-0.0283786003,
0.0122668231,
0.015097389,
0.0115308836,
0.0042458717,
0.022426391,
0.0013156767,
-0.0374811143,
-0.0569802187,
0.0305330716,
-0.0469505973,
0.0051317159,
-0.0412981547,
0.0134104993,
0.040301986,
0.030762393,
-0.0357873291,
0.0222084187,
0.0337541699,
0.0000258892,
0.0057771117,
-0.0152379703,
0.0131820561,
0.06640625,
0.0547093041,
-0.0172016434,
0.0046009207,
0.0366067365,
-0.0050483546,
-0.0331465229,
0.0217396058,
-0.0435436033,
0.0315070823,
-0.0185840167,
0.0543618277,
-0.0692253262,
-0.004412049,
-0.051561892,
0.0235223975,
-0.0007810413,
0.0205115117,
0.0046372153,
-0.0197840054,
0.0395637825,
-0.0063959379,
-0.086306259,
0.018884955,
-0.0068348236,
0.0296362098,
0.0255483445,
0.0080738561,
-0.0231684465,
-0.0470044427,
-0.0855337605,
0.0233067088,
-0.0053985296,
0.0733385012,
0.0292065535,
-0.0024707231,
-0.0220784359,
0.0236615483,
-0.0226784404,
-0.0094337165,
-8.67e-7,
0.0210670587,
0.0143165793,
0.0034577947,
-0.0650708452,
-0.0232188478,
-0.0229706354,
-0.0093744295,
0.0662198886,
0.0099945655,
-0.0072783856,
-0.0566451848,
0.0265565868,
-0.050293833,
0.028930245,
0.0019274069,
-0.0618321598,
0.0105045056,
0.0005807334,
0.0053958455,
0.022723943,
0.0005695655,
-0.0136605389,
0.0501184911,
-0.0074767177,
-0.02494164,
-0.0372375026,
-0.0077235936,
-0.0427399762,
-0.0694214106,
-0.0349318013,
-0.0124261165,
0.0496414937,
-0.0162309464,
-0.0189984869,
-0.0241457038,
-0.0033976843,
-0.0644982979,
-0.0324734338,
-0.008943907,
-0.0432594083,
-0.0071563148,
0.0625054538,
-0.0147022251,
-0.0854711309,
0.0661555603,
-0.0592707433,
0.0166482106,
-0.0268451981,
-0.0522269681,
-0.0549679212,
0.0643801689,
-0.0159233324,
0.0370349959,
0.0000747254,
-0.0231010541,
-0.0410550088,
-0.0013451542,
-0.0004691124,
-0.0467965975,
0.062515229,
-0.0420252196,
0.0260510724,
-0.0044377148,
-0.0131384144,
-0.0396836549,
-0.0422469154,
-0.0350312144,
0.021440912,
0.0377131365,
-0.0161456447,
-0.0285981745,
0.0431446433,
0.0457719117,
-0.0036806234,
0.0092557445,
0.0143907238,
-0.0175607298,
-0.0178548172,
0.0179202408,
-0.0224288795,
0.0424010083,
-0.0074526658,
0.0185197983,
0.0350570157,
0.0292788818,
0.0274219643,
-0.0289034043,
-0.0302598048,
0.044893343,
-0.0358448774,
-0.0178001933,
0.0098789101,
0.0434576161,
-0.0514975674,
0.0028006264,
0.1144905761,
0.0351415649,
-0.0256578121,
0.0140185552,
0.0074651688,
-0.008695228,
0.00862798,
0.0152334683,
-0.0718521401,
0.0137033546,
0.0085843243,
0.0048384462,
-0.0182904676,
-0.0333965197,
0.0075119101,
-0.1156289876,
0.0135643082,
0.0169481896,
-0.0404858962,
-0.040346805,
-0.0390035734,
0.0140400194,
-0.012812702,
0.029531071,
0.0050423304,
0.0061169346,
-0.0460583456,
0.0151249496,
-0.0562315695,
-0.068940632,
0.0235536769,
-0.0597063303,
0.0741503984,
0.0907086879,
0.0039675096,
-0.0224742759,
-0.012000707,
0.0032126859,
-0.0033088138,
-0.0194942318,
0.0288884193,
0.0039087599,
0.0108963251,
-0.0212471634,
-0.0292000361,
-0.0225271303,
-0.0164085999,
0.0032806736,
0.0181905851,
0.0938245729,
-0.027362885,
0.000907506,
-0.0236367173,
-0.020464994,
0.0105754146,
0.0722550154,
0.0006868098,
-0.05046973,
-0.0154054333,
-0.0015928036,
-0.021601392,
-0.018564282,
-0.0202067681,
0.0463791452,
0.0113800699,
-0.0373592079,
-0.0274792295,
-0.0063739708,
-0.022800805,
-0.0159751698,
0.0435777791,
0.0156455636,
0.0175014306,
-0.0296425186,
-0.0291354489,
-0.0100991847,
-0.0379665978,
0.0526552573,
-0.0804049298,
0.0057644234,
0.0102784708,
0.0022089826,
-0.0104663922,
0.0260283444,
-0.0918791518,
-0.1020641178,
0.0148759224,
0.0352809094,
0.0257449001,
-0.003112817,
-0.0484265983,
-0.0635937005,
0.0667649731,
0.0300290119,
-0.0486543402,
-0.0012063564,
0.0122181,
-0.0103742732,
0.0132192578,
0.0344250984,
-0.0570119284,
-0.0094133783,
0.0190595072,
-0.0092934174,
-0.0310549252,
-0.0369909406,
-0.0096094543,
0.0500058606,
0.0212025251,
-0.0519727394,
0.0032248499,
-0.0006607687,
-0.0078131566,
-0.0767802671,
-0.0230106395,
-0.0187153295,
-0.0208499562,
0.056176167,
0.0240862984,
0.0216165297,
0.0200566854,
-0.002497179,
0.0130977109,
-0.0190317184,
0.071088925,
-0.0221523158,
0.0228246637,
0.051171761,
0.0195500981,
-0.0202227235,
0.0237901863,
-0.0310687274,
0.0034021519,
-0.006932376,
0.0390105695,
-0.0015329981,
-0.0058679674,
0.0210313126,
0.0658102706,
-0.0386155769,
-0.0525931753,
-0.0076817642,
0.0483879521,
0.0605732314,
0.0406305902,
0.064264901,
-0.0445504338,
0.0084990421,
-0.0476011895,
0.0134619391,
-0.0055742064,
-0.0515027195,
0.010225229,
0.0307513233,
-0.0501986481,
0.0212200563,
0.0619869605,
0.0215616636,
0.0132469311,
-0.0010650626,
-0.0250770692,
-0.0094908299,
-0.0200061798,
0.0028175665,
-0.0140489303,
-0.0872318521,
-0.0260233358,
-0.0893189311,
-0.0684187189,
-0.0180665664,
0.0414507017,
-0.0025643164,
-0.0070549101,
0.0163549297,
0.0531307161,
0.0106522655,
0.0129654426,
-0.0673162639,
-0.0224813465,
-0.0180155709,
-0.0152514381,
0.0020082358,
-6.61483732e-33,
0.0101372236,
-0.0127568273,
0.0144603886,
-0.0245219693,
-0.036780227,
0.0140255801,
-0.026338527,
0.0165189616,
-0.0308289081,
-0.0236925874,
0.0134364329,
-0.018060375,
0.0096171489,
0.014124712,
0.0090103559,
0.0022866253,
0.0112280678,
0.0014897472,
-0.0080930414,
0.0189239159,
0.0309109613,
-0.0243035853,
0.0607704856,
-0.0823486745,
0.0371070243,
-0.0239405483,
-0.0302582122,
0.021917332,
-0.0032377979,
0.0889143571,
-0.0193109196,
0.0204107128,
0.0108614098,
-0.0344470218,
-0.0076818904,
-0.0074587497,
0.0053355005,
0.012107389,
0.0252595581,
0.0228101239,
0.0125437034,
-0.0398718268,
0.0431935638,
-0.0209263042,
-0.0345309377,
0.0145369656,
0.0147272125,
-0.0233754758,
-0.0276026353,
0.0110020367,
-0.0508567058,
0.0279166643,
-0.0213252939,
0.0156786144,
0.0398766957,
-0.0129851894,
0.0110183107,
0.0068531632,
-0.0420205817,
0.0354379602,
0.0214044452,
0.0123131275,
0.1184802577,
0.0265907962,
0.0301906932,
0.0500058383,
0.0036277452,
0.0047956039,
-0.0096242847,
-0.0122226318,
0.0281945746,
0.0313480943,
0.0390902646,
0.0371134952,
-0.0356880613,
-0.025043115,
-0.0706277043,
0.010108104,
0.0206194706,
0.0157949291,
0.0407696366,
0.0119197369,
-0.062481001,
-0.0114273671,
-0.0307074729,
-0.0053225965,
-0.0355733261,
-0.0286682323,
0.0249621272,
-0.0278622154,
-0.0107297702,
0.0282220095,
0.0430838615,
-0.0714619756,
-0.0352354944,
0.0245424733,
-0.0008084128,
0.0237575192,
0.0008773104,
0.0547474846,
-0.0681469962,
-0.0364874974,
-0.0099024633,
0.0049021603,
0.0099125626,
-0.006928911,
-0.0103389686,
0.0342442282,
-0.0534953438,
0.0264316779,
-0.0249345452,
0.0131668011,
0.0269325711,
-0.0043644002,
0.035974741,
-0.0374952927,
0.0198627301,
0.0138016241,
0.0462429263,
0.009539729,
-0.0045799287,
0.019518625,
-0.0025666361,
-0.0095759537,
-0.0003715279,
0.0167343114,
-0.0396536067,
0.0202054437,
0.0480786897,
-0.0002897737,
-0.0009667132,
0.0107541904,
2.972e-7,
0.0548971146,
0.0409602486,
0.0153555777,
0.0232856572,
0.0185678937,
0.0367092267,
-0.0453705862,
0.0235767551,
-0.0158284772,
0.005581372,
0.0083226757,
0.006201718,
0.0695147067,
0.0457076132,
-0.0626994297,
0.0047565755,
-0.0571523681,
-0.0059360312,
-0.0774569511,
0.011141235,
0.0373778455,
0.0996866003,
0.0189875886,
0.0021085751,
-0.0344054811,
-0.0694353729,
0.0187256057,
-0.0304742921,
-0.0213210471,
0.046466846,
0.0079873884,
0.0515066311,
0.0008408609,
0.0095566753,
0.0035941338,
0.0188946966,
-0.0082264515,
0.0608572289,
-0.0046064821,
0.0013506864,
0.003572237,
-0.076300092,
-0.0146006877,
-0.0828925669,
0.0570699312,
-0.0147857945,
-0.0604059808,
-0.0215979125,
-0.0101153273,
-0.0204888452,
0.0186857767,
-0.0098156016,
-0.0231249854,
0.034672603,
0.0184004996,
-0.0208573192,
0.0010362453,
-0.0499928221,
-0.0124021014,
-0.0070274686,
-0.0352649763,
-0.0727274045,
-0.0123183625,
0.0143732177,
0.0051673977,
-0.0437043905,
0.0381548665,
2.870416467e-34,
0.0007120863,
-0.0303089973,
-0.0050563784,
-0.008688923,
0.0164484996,
0.0136207165,
-0.0421747304,
0.0166506413,
-0.0183307938,
-0.0721595511,
0.0105679259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19727v2 | Generating Medical Prescriptions with Conditional Transformer | 2023-10-30T16:53:11 | 2023-11-18T17:10:29 | Samuel Belkadi, Nicolo Micheletti, Lifeng Han, Warren Del-Pinto, Goran Nenadic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Access to real-world medication prescriptions is essential for medical
research and healthcare quality improvement. However, access to real medication
prescriptions is often limited due to the sensitive nature of the information
expressed. Additionally, manually labelling these instructions for training and
fine-tuning Natural Language Processing (NLP) models can be tedious and
expensive. We introduce a novel task-specific model architecture,
Label-To-Text-Transformer (\textbf{LT3}), tailored to generate synthetic
medication prescriptions based on provided labels, such as a vocabulary list of
medications and their attributes. LT3 is trained on a set of around 2K lines of
medication prescriptions extracted from the MIMIC-III database, allowing the
model to produce valuable synthetic medication prescriptions. We evaluate LT3's
performance by contrasting it with a state-of-the-art Pre-trained Language
Model (PLM), T5, analysing the quality and diversity of generated texts. We
deploy the generated synthetic data to train the SpacyNER model for the Named
Entity Recognition (NER) task over the n2c2-2018 dataset. The experiments show
that the model trained on synthetic data can achieve a 96-98\% F1 score at
Label Recognition on Drug, Frequency, Route, Strength, and Form. LT3 codes and
data will be shared at
\url{https://github.com/HECTA-UoM/Label-To-Text-Transformer} | [
0.0734246448,
0.0402682349,
0.0246630777,
-0.0054484452,
-0.0012004704,
0.0142729785,
0.0086049335,
0.0024288942,
0.0472818762,
-0.0519176796,
-0.0161849856,
-0.0313765705,
-0.0228978228,
0.0607288741,
0.0377453007,
-0.021067597,
0.0081996145,
0.0269609932,
0.0105003566,
0.0389175341,
-0.0112096081,
0.02503209,
-0.0198787097,
0.0351658277,
-0.0049481862,
0.0204988159,
0.0332036354,
0.0093746949,
0.0343452469,
-0.0709774196,
0.025910398,
0.0575399436,
-0.033170931,
-0.0034007111,
0.0000018809,
-0.0299988482,
-0.0289055426,
0.0383609831,
-0.0572542734,
-0.067942284,
0.0783948377,
-0.0614615977,
-0.0077353567,
0.0197936762,
-0.0216460861,
-0.0470449589,
0.0183241256,
0.1040727347,
0.0286193211,
0.0933414772,
-0.0327859707,
-0.0177996252,
0.0507388823,
-0.0155953206,
0.0389212817,
-0.0235234592,
0.0324583203,
-0.0024925258,
0.0155353686,
0.0341481864,
0.0258139558,
0.0121506313,
-0.0086441105,
0.0127814077,
0.0661802441,
0.0505174994,
-0.0364845954,
-0.0237750672,
-0.0125055062,
0.0767831802,
-0.0395131558,
-0.0075395829,
0.038228929,
-0.0080790715,
-0.0044917753,
-0.0237423293,
-0.0008156515,
-0.0104111768,
-0.0277887136,
0.026536461,
0.016588008,
0.0014172032,
0.0116490461,
-0.0103180418,
-0.0034378781,
-0.0128857661,
0.0165424179,
-0.0149085354,
0.0186491869,
-0.0064040008,
-0.0179047137,
-0.0466854759,
0.052558627,
0.0266990531,
-0.0118532432,
0.0162789412,
-0.076124087,
-0.047559265,
0.0503493957,
-0.0571186133,
0.0434034355,
-0.0116725871,
0.0073423441,
0.0218883213,
-0.0592539832,
0.0155202299,
-0.0089406464,
0.0688358396,
-0.0422331356,
0.0030133605,
-0.0519558415,
-0.0034396201,
-0.0431105569,
0.0204314571,
-0.0343487412,
-0.0341156013,
-0.0472584814,
-0.0196755193,
0.0036217803,
0.0132275969,
0.050940644,
0.0331841446,
-0.0212645642,
-0.016812142,
-0.0131224962,
0.0074284733,
0.0329238288,
0.0185377207,
-0.0149526084,
-0.0592461228,
0.0309830941,
-0.0080419704,
0.0210086163,
-0.0384814776,
0.0433775596,
0.0632002428,
-0.0077252411,
-0.0736338422,
-0.080978103,
-0.0347931869,
0.007746947,
-0.0326612107,
0.0133521855,
-0.05178269,
0.0484684147,
-0.0205240529,
0.0039502745,
-0.0509101599,
0.031664487,
0.0076006255,
-0.0751678199,
0.092822507,
-0.0301870611,
-0.0329218581,
0.0282417666,
0.0028355918,
0.0519926809,
-0.0078181522,
0.0482221209,
-0.0015855061,
0.0126040662,
-0.0155128483,
0.0317742601,
0.0077394685,
0.0113946348,
-0.0533224009,
0.0155631434,
0.0079576224,
0.0091662416,
0.0249109082,
-0.0190884024,
0.0666221976,
0.0094145034,
0.0033580796,
0.0441910662,
0.0053212494,
0.0495178252,
0.0004907767,
0.0346838944,
-0.0071647256,
-0.0239714496,
-0.0371742509,
-0.0513418801,
0.0027533516,
0.0053239781,
0.0211683828,
-0.0328961425,
-0.0034850822,
-0.0161413699,
-0.0110955443,
0.0038314902,
-0.0373051129,
-0.0202483479,
-0.0283960607,
0.0376345515,
0.0488356091,
-0.1022915468,
0.0985921398,
0.025436094,
-0.011945961,
0.0082672946,
-0.0195731707,
-0.0279145259,
0.0852987915,
0.0399995372,
-0.0273831971,
-0.0223959144,
-0.0338892937,
-0.0574181713,
0.0266224239,
0.0065892474,
-0.0290604178,
0.0203083232,
-0.0442239679,
-0.0081529496,
0.0113872671,
0.0121740252,
-0.0152791413,
0.007408401,
0.0465368032,
0.0192404762,
-0.0373280905,
-0.0107012773,
0.0592540763,
-0.0517657585,
-0.0712946802,
0.0372148119,
0.0033291681,
-0.0072510964,
0.0362580009,
-0.0042565223,
0.0339733623,
0.0452076234,
-0.0577087887,
-0.0071863299,
-0.0384802073,
0.0251897518,
-0.0335801169,
-0.0038856724,
-0.0488051251,
0.0158894714,
0.0028666016,
-0.0615528375,
-0.0360906199,
-0.0451373421,
-0.0155217936,
-0.0009486633,
0.0041853962,
0.0257579722,
0.0481380299,
0.0298302211,
-0.0187930893,
0.0022277108,
-0.0071856072,
0.0094482834,
0.0036973588,
0.0124613103,
-0.023157103,
0.0072109853,
0.027316954,
-0.0039707799,
-0.0189485233,
-0.0029156657,
-0.0207260661,
0.0197912734,
-0.0105482303,
-0.0485758409,
-0.0462980047,
0.006453671,
0.0080706412,
0.0239843,
0.0410515629,
0.0258418359,
-0.0021517237,
-0.0282803345,
-0.0130953481,
-0.0384586491,
-0.0144156311,
-0.0251603965,
0.021556193,
0.0163538009,
-0.0235125534,
-0.0149188871,
-0.001591068,
-0.0244822167,
0.023654798,
-0.0056807748,
-0.0050015501,
-0.061296992,
0.0040997867,
0.0085949535,
0.0229472294,
0.0106244991,
0.0175757278,
-0.0142775476,
0.0267240051,
0.0330655612,
0.0299972668,
0.0022675022,
-0.0093039079,
0.0143395467,
0.0119002648,
0.0005379423,
0.0025673178,
-0.0460527278,
0.0047567496,
-0.0152818449,
-0.0978407338,
0.0215679184,
0.1023706049,
0.0159573499,
0.0269233603,
-0.0298439711,
-0.0239299461,
0.0012028335,
-0.0029686063,
-0.0129818339,
0.027065102,
-0.0329524577,
-0.000453314,
-0.0061048898,
-0.0362055153,
0.0557589456,
-0.0431648642,
0.0108780824,
-0.0759806186,
-0.0087080523,
-0.0226788539,
-0.0190580506,
0.0555669665,
0.0008582284,
0.0536700152,
-0.021172164,
0.013073748,
0.0251236167,
-0.002233794,
-0.0368580557,
0.0444379449,
-0.0084789367,
0.0369413123,
-0.0167415384,
-0.0219983477,
-0.0513384417,
-0.0188615154,
-0.005740176,
0.0067533888,
0.0246998966,
0.0137607064,
-0.0364571884,
0.035702236,
-0.042484194,
0.1040287167,
0.0395302139,
-0.0283481572,
-0.0190780647,
0.0482540242,
0.0767335296,
-0.0617184043,
0.0131893298,
-0.000959724,
-0.0017325758,
0.0476604365,
0.0132026253,
0.0199991614,
0.0009839005,
0.0171063337,
-0.0045999121,
-0.0382555015,
0.0159344375,
0.0296648275,
0.0061827735,
-0.0252754949,
-0.0056486363,
0.0984924808,
0.0266712904,
0.0016273053,
0.0235368945,
0.0352060907,
-0.0308035146,
-0.0050700074,
0.0184403397,
-0.0713847727,
-0.0199969225,
0.0005321231,
0.0322006717,
-0.038567055,
-0.05251313,
-0.0229633152,
-0.0815216228,
0.0239591282,
-0.011299991,
-0.0454765111,
-0.0094063655,
-0.0563482977,
-0.0428352505,
-0.0340587981,
-0.015303053,
-0.0236476623,
-0.0210045334,
-0.0251089185,
0.0048021511,
-0.0187260266,
-0.0566781722,
-0.005186283,
-0.0143366922,
0.0525961816,
0.0241522603,
-0.0049846205,
-0.0069472832,
-0.0248611346,
0.0074883075,
-0.0170169547,
-0.015100535,
0.0053495979,
0.0983676761,
-0.0087384935,
-0.004550518,
-0.043113932,
0.0502569191,
-0.0831455663,
-0.0533278361,
-0.0413041711,
0.0511230938,
-0.0067768288,
-0.0268193875,
-0.0441411361,
0.0117800031,
0.0439756215,
0.0519915223,
-0.0065135211,
0.0096080052,
-0.0291065443,
0.0176716056,
0.0174310096,
-0.0755052641,
-0.0412356704,
0.0589981228,
-0.049795825,
-0.0395793356,
-0.0674473569,
-0.0239761826,
0.0429670103,
0.0072575314,
-0.0070102308,
-0.0228243861,
0.0255474113,
-0.0386361033,
-0.0371304303,
0.0483193994,
0.007848287,
0.0194829982,
-0.0804140717,
-0.0537556373,
0.0253692605,
0.0168920904,
-0.0260005351,
0.0202922486,
-0.0588524044,
-0.0419626683,
0.0178163722,
0.0585583113,
0.0150851235,
0.0091001522,
-0.0054353713,
0.027805442,
0.0575087033,
0.0658802688,
-0.0275834296,
-0.0626087412,
-0.0111807128,
-0.0289319865,
-0.0131425997,
0.0178736597,
-0.0046451124,
0.0545047075,
0.0426224358,
0.0424328744,
0.0106457453,
-0.0353360139,
0.0338766053,
0.0031571237,
0.0416899137,
-0.0285415053,
0.0264004897,
-0.0550402217,
0.0325167179,
0.0032719984,
0.0260194167,
-0.0390365534,
-0.0151493615,
0.0512995757,
0.0069388309,
-0.0129485764,
0.0377628058,
-0.0554054976,
0.0087329699,
-0.0236719213,
0.0004193348,
-0.0156466179,
0.0185204819,
0.0695253983,
-0.0495312102,
0.0135131469,
0.0328770988,
0.0112423729,
0.0692847371,
-0.0278157368,
0.0637519658,
-0.0047411318,
0.0240359101,
-0.0482283607,
0.0593600683,
-0.0205472223,
-0.0261322949,
-0.0715177432,
0.0427363962,
0.0188279897,
-0.046746511,
0.0458234511,
-0.0506618656,
-0.0108630545,
-0.0248539522,
0.0385289714,
-0.0067445599,
0.0081615727,
0.0350134857,
0.0036429493,
-0.0169777349,
-0.0366844237,
0.0835449323,
0.0234556198,
0.0381556824,
0.0127035873,
-0.0225314572,
-0.0551227406,
-0.0149330739,
-0.0093134791,
-0.0382955112,
-0.0591786914,
0.0039554439,
-0.0311427098,
-0.0552553311,
0.0343860686,
-0.0289874692,
-0.004092583,
0.0193420649,
0.0284464937,
0.0093910191,
0.0096029285,
-0.0352019519,
-0.0331612565,
0.0309455991,
0.0479543358,
-0.043746978,
-0.0118413419,
-6.033172226e-33,
0.0044312552,
-0.0248458255,
0.0019764872,
-0.0139277941,
0.0248566289,
0.0343624055,
-0.0363632105,
-0.0186331496,
0.0168663915,
0.0217925813,
-0.0080077471,
-0.0264596734,
0.0316442065,
0.0522900857,
-0.0050739395,
-0.0212582853,
0.0400103703,
0.0129306437,
-0.0343959033,
0.029952066,
0.0160840973,
0.0823871344,
0.0805208012,
-0.0828629807,
0.0304193962,
-0.0110676996,
0.0342027657,
-0.010596999,
0.0350066982,
0.0653281584,
-0.0468363576,
0.0223363098,
0.0383114889,
-0.0952204764,
-0.0013954836,
0.0307319779,
-0.116468817,
0.021033654,
-0.0432927944,
0.0165567733,
-0.0379761569,
-0.0310469884,
0.0293641165,
-0.0179578587,
-0.0218566116,
0.0058174543,
0.0452134088,
-0.0273920447,
-0.0020830948,
-0.0491812229,
-0.0778140426,
0.0401733629,
0.0115804188,
-0.0047558052,
-0.0019943835,
0.0187318064,
-0.0024163036,
0.031991113,
-0.0658362359,
-0.0084090428,
0.0041917572,
0.0136892954,
0.0191017948,
-0.0028931841,
-0.0271931309,
0.0183324926,
0.0164334103,
0.0002531845,
-0.0206356235,
0.0117642572,
-0.0442795157,
0.0586229488,
0.0281154606,
0.0102930693,
0.0654896647,
-0.0156752542,
-0.0341890976,
0.0415831096,
-0.0949904248,
0.017248543,
0.0042196917,
-0.0159964077,
-0.0273452904,
-0.0052298615,
0.0016797819,
0.0036699167,
-0.037326958,
0.0098907258,
0.0208235942,
0.0344633162,
-0.0409068428,
0.0218856577,
0.0068170158,
-0.03960336,
-0.0443365648,
-0.0302632507,
0.0452890061,
0.0326567627,
-0.0388623513,
-0.015951125,
-0.0591323003,
-0.0319799371,
0.0648872852,
-0.0236604642,
0.0261885636,
0.0158365443,
0.0492122769,
-0.0224971995,
-0.065636605,
0.0106811756,
0.0082719028,
0.0337057896,
0.0385846719,
0.0772064403,
0.0069443365,
0.017714994,
-0.007855989,
0.0597099997,
0.0109257288,
-0.0288531333,
-0.0146625256,
0.0035101301,
0.047398515,
0.0277857054,
-0.0480263494,
0.0186326839,
-0.0688036606,
0.0259299185,
0.0496115796,
-0.0549557284,
0.0013403753,
-0.0228354745,
2.755e-7,
0.0849693343,
0.0165007412,
0.0201596878,
-0.0272091851,
-0.0076318784,
0.0370367803,
0.0081812255,
0.0471468531,
-0.0375675485,
-0.0322388336,
0.0300543699,
-0.0257679187,
0.0298549831,
0.0302377138,
-0.0503431,
-0.0102288639,
-0.0491673984,
-0.0441179648,
-0.0440438986,
0.0035640185,
0.029815957,
0.0897649899,
-0.0152830658,
-0.0428128317,
0.0028294956,
-0.0263387617,
0.014168662,
-0.0234630406,
0.0279512852,
0.0657979697,
0.0422383174,
0.0100500109,
-0.0252412464,
0.0481330194,
-0.0532810465,
-0.0117432401,
-0.0356890298,
0.0961656198,
-0.0370128229,
0.0040889722,
0.0109564597,
-0.0516529754,
0.002660956,
-0.0337705798,
0.0534278713,
-0.0444971919,
-0.0275585093,
0.0020141425,
-0.037814647,
0.0220162775,
0.036883302,
-0.0230385512,
-0.0214998703,
0.049814228,
0.0475779697,
0.0212945361,
-0.0181463361,
-0.0646743849,
-0.0002198247,
0.0364656784,
-0.020248834,
0.0276540704,
0.0182271283,
-0.0287835523,
0.0106293177,
-0.0463166498,
0.0155752338,
2.618028876e-34,
0.0024701713,
0.019298587,
0.0160291474,
0.0192975532,
0.0268707164,
-0.0153916487,
0.0169164725,
0.0126462225,
-0.0282606632,
-0.0773742869,
-0.0211947933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19708v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19708v3 | Combining Language Models For Specialized Domains: A Colorful Approach | 2023-10-30T16:35:55 | 2023-11-01T07:55:28 | Daniel Eitan, Menachem Pirchi, Neta Glazer, Shai Meital, Gil Ayach, Gidon Krendel, Aviv Shamsian, Aviv Navon, Gil Hetz, Joseph Keshet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | General purpose language models (LMs) encounter difficulties when processing
domain-specific jargon and terminology, which are frequently utilized in
specialized fields such as medicine or industrial settings. Moreover, they
often find it challenging to interpret mixed speech that blends general
language with specialized jargon. This poses a challenge for automatic speech
recognition systems operating within these specific domains. In this work, we
introduce a novel approach that integrates domain-specific or secondary LM into
general-purpose LM. This strategy involves labeling, or "coloring", each word
to indicate its association with either the general or the domain-specific LM.
We develop an optimized algorithm that enhances the beam search algorithm to
effectively handle inferences involving colored words. Our evaluations indicate
that this approach is highly effective in integrating jargon into language
tasks. Notably, our method substantially lowers the error rate for
domain-specific words without compromising performance in the general domain. | [
0.0458951257,
0.025989756,
0.0131835612,
0.0037266645,
-0.0374710336,
-0.0096907904,
-0.0007956318,
0.0177190006,
-0.0090612192,
-0.068984367,
-0.0589991026,
-0.0469079241,
0.0460279509,
0.0480523221,
0.0007022931,
-0.0807460621,
0.0365007669,
-0.0329488367,
0.0371856242,
-0.0116100665,
-0.0076834639,
0.0160129834,
-0.0246181916,
0.0438128747,
-0.0005218006,
0.0449003018,
0.039539665,
0.0184166897,
0.0220247936,
0.006526764,
0.009429316,
0.023793418,
-0.0107121263,
0.0100910598,
0.0000020866,
-0.0470553674,
-0.0280379802,
0.0061003729,
-0.0118275359,
-0.0173611809,
0.084685035,
0.0018160667,
-0.0084934859,
0.0383632928,
-0.0129887685,
-0.0500705466,
0.0801823959,
0.0272867754,
0.0140167652,
0.0353650525,
-0.0006136134,
-0.0324708596,
0.0033727281,
0.0058682174,
-0.0085851792,
-0.0872309804,
0.0428359471,
0.0210588407,
0.075507082,
-0.0317581557,
-0.0112380758,
0.0698853806,
-0.0487527549,
0.0291333757,
0.015399944,
0.0076270229,
-0.024470523,
0.0145720318,
-0.0224355776,
0.0382604487,
-0.0248675384,
-0.0053970637,
0.029887557,
0.0045598443,
-0.0364477225,
0.0291481446,
-0.0324893221,
0.0015622133,
-0.0222200621,
-0.0098295212,
0.0415923819,
0.0263481196,
0.0210849121,
0.0149344997,
-0.0600062124,
0.0750551149,
0.0409778282,
-0.0186703149,
-0.0086860331,
-0.0397325046,
-0.032293506,
-0.0260275677,
0.048368834,
0.0059620538,
0.0021910931,
0.0559744127,
-0.0476853773,
-0.0207597185,
0.026962284,
-0.0381319672,
-0.0155142089,
0.0321356766,
-0.0308944341,
0.0520861335,
0.0044612642,
0.0051762857,
-0.0093583455,
-0.016884258,
-0.0792231858,
-0.0373803414,
-0.0331816152,
-0.0237907544,
-0.0306634847,
-0.0151668675,
-0.0119644925,
-0.0313738622,
-0.0533690713,
-0.0075104339,
-0.007317306,
-0.039114885,
0.0277378056,
-0.0087092565,
-0.0250648223,
-0.0198014975,
0.0139797227,
-0.0178548973,
0.0037652305,
0.0312319957,
-0.0274872407,
-0.0810990259,
0.0075911684,
0.0421396196,
-0.0113122026,
-0.0158410762,
-0.0166315567,
0.1490297914,
0.0344844423,
-0.0509989858,
-0.0293057319,
-0.0065780799,
-0.0269349031,
-0.005201383,
0.0391343161,
-0.0606587678,
0.0128981508,
0.0180732831,
-0.0031574101,
-0.0449788682,
0.0198627394,
-0.0108392825,
-0.0559170917,
0.0786297992,
-0.0534944125,
0.005609063,
0.0640131012,
0.0168230552,
0.0257216301,
0.0550533794,
-0.0092872595,
-0.0421403833,
0.014453304,
-0.0401291661,
0.0182378702,
0.0767078921,
-0.0278537292,
-0.0469579473,
-0.0257838573,
-0.0468797684,
0.013225792,
0.0044738105,
0.0310552064,
0.0401743054,
0.0004610503,
-0.0017881633,
-0.0233055726,
0.070051305,
0.0532503985,
-0.0800977498,
0.0286788084,
0.0229995102,
0.019971434,
0.0255575292,
0.007741244,
-0.0545810498,
-0.0847053677,
0.0065259524,
0.0015205382,
0.034733478,
-0.0210988838,
0.0060429643,
-0.0536990799,
-0.0206192937,
0.0359195955,
0.0150644705,
0.0739170089,
0.0043636416,
-0.0468067452,
0.0819285661,
0.0574088283,
-0.0096634766,
-0.0099342056,
-0.0579042807,
-0.0579421408,
0.0614281408,
0.0592334494,
-0.0409657322,
-0.0447551049,
0.0157520548,
-0.0321454071,
0.0597706549,
0.0063458215,
0.0142692048,
0.0033956401,
-0.0960523486,
-0.0154536292,
0.0533807278,
0.0126465848,
0.047608275,
0.0006778526,
-0.0154118128,
0.0359789021,
-0.0233905148,
-0.0369350538,
0.0257123001,
-0.0496507697,
-0.0400977507,
0.0124000935,
-0.0217743739,
0.0412851162,
0.0332780741,
-0.0260208994,
0.0219376273,
0.003338943,
-0.0186151117,
-0.0032165367,
0.0333792008,
-0.0284880735,
0.0009855325,
0.0108891977,
-0.0110414485,
-0.0024599219,
-0.0462783314,
0.0043331562,
-0.0455500148,
0.0206487495,
-0.0290132985,
0.0358327888,
-0.0210547484,
0.0454984978,
0.0192879122,
0.0251337253,
-0.0596929565,
0.0282978602,
-0.0055196192,
-0.0081916936,
-0.0123832412,
-0.0603179634,
-0.0209777839,
-0.0461611338,
-0.0051969555,
0.0254783724,
-0.0088354954,
0.0162930898,
-0.0367972478,
-0.0144803431,
-0.0093862098,
0.0299285967,
-0.0494820848,
-0.0092152338,
-0.000196576,
-0.0060253749,
0.0129537517,
0.0283513125,
-0.0296312831,
-0.0067816805,
0.0166151207,
-0.0253029056,
0.0208926722,
0.0159664582,
-0.0411897562,
0.0272173993,
-0.0515079722,
-0.0429660529,
-0.0053716414,
-0.025835285,
0.0314431041,
-0.0100089898,
-0.0629998744,
-0.0401218086,
0.0757422745,
-0.0081106005,
0.0170845445,
0.0011402108,
-0.0145087754,
-0.0265076179,
-0.0337004624,
0.0239571575,
0.0208505485,
0.0211014785,
-0.0230293199,
0.0395622514,
-0.0724478588,
-0.0378562212,
-0.0132097276,
-0.0109948358,
0.0341641009,
0.0411410704,
-0.0350388065,
0.035981562,
0.0861723498,
0.033303,
0.0297045019,
-0.0165988952,
-0.0231617764,
-0.0216226503,
-0.0399982594,
-0.0233496055,
-0.0174030531,
-0.027196642,
0.0390780643,
0.0081185158,
-0.0315512642,
0.0561456867,
-0.0603641719,
0.014975193,
-0.0457469933,
-0.0411931537,
-0.035249956,
-0.0340729542,
-0.0252182353,
0.0048838696,
0.0130535746,
-0.0611094087,
0.0264605954,
0.0035033769,
-0.0158833694,
-0.0526195392,
0.0900769383,
-0.0522245839,
0.0006927067,
0.0064646592,
0.0290071927,
-0.0490293577,
0.0247449856,
-0.0517867021,
0.0089845415,
0.002379688,
0.0038661628,
-0.0428368598,
0.0724456534,
-0.0262165852,
0.02378604,
-0.0025423006,
0.0279855877,
-0.0109591112,
0.042881716,
0.0014170927,
-0.0101493439,
-0.0209983736,
-0.0102805002,
-0.0268054176,
-0.0269089807,
0.0104686264,
0.0035912707,
-0.0109573714,
-0.0441431254,
0.0771033913,
-0.0260822121,
-0.0513341576,
-0.0096395742,
0.0099649774,
-0.0571411327,
0.0502301529,
0.1122763976,
0.0308049694,
-0.0158219542,
-0.0165793877,
-0.0295521766,
-0.0103465263,
-0.0132269897,
0.0314239673,
-0.064168334,
-0.0537930354,
0.0268366747,
0.008511561,
-0.0002697033,
0.0235399455,
-0.0143252257,
-0.0861000568,
0.0087071769,
0.033383552,
-0.0089703929,
-0.039906159,
0.0135369133,
0.0088489167,
0.0114676803,
0.0001819045,
-0.0145808561,
-0.0090118386,
-0.0349284783,
0.0257640388,
-0.059015166,
-0.1412174106,
0.0181165859,
-0.0185964424,
0.0642933995,
0.0895294026,
-0.0076094801,
-0.0451111533,
-0.0217994507,
0.0393976569,
0.0128737669,
0.0204292685,
-0.0368606895,
0.0045162807,
-0.0236815084,
-0.0010928537,
0.0228147265,
0.0131177939,
-0.0163646545,
-0.0255409107,
0.0157840177,
0.0381238125,
-0.0080019822,
0.010201266,
-0.0338565521,
0.0410022214,
0.0256887805,
0.0717334971,
0.0116260415,
-0.0334908403,
0.0251261145,
-0.0558972284,
0.022932766,
0.0165048707,
-0.0798584968,
-0.0182978939,
-0.04179262,
-0.0198505558,
-0.0188663416,
0.0143466014,
0.0488217585,
0.0119879404,
0.0210599508,
0.0197164044,
-0.0504281595,
0.0144812446,
-0.028101895,
0.0480728708,
-0.0110726934,
0.0232217722,
-0.0757529587,
-0.0314505287,
0.010428695,
-0.0454210117,
-0.0480297282,
0.0643207803,
-0.0028943638,
-0.0412572026,
0.0564622581,
0.0103822118,
0.0253242757,
0.0063588545,
-0.0521823391,
-0.02849737,
-0.011787774,
0.0469865575,
-0.0227634776,
0.0144643961,
0.0381861664,
-0.0191093665,
-0.019402612,
-0.0131973792,
-0.0386381522,
0.0632747486,
-0.0127785895,
0.0353145152,
-0.0157785863,
-0.0406790338,
-0.0001697214,
0.002542079,
0.0847798139,
-0.0346462205,
-0.0198701508,
-0.0214050841,
0.0103593618,
0.0151919033,
0.0013540668,
-0.021526875,
-0.0208976902,
-0.0026935549,
0.0042714812,
-0.0117061352,
0.0161615275,
-0.0440636426,
-0.023900399,
0.0140354857,
0.0421407111,
0.0224423427,
0.0350394137,
0.0178309809,
-0.0306699704,
0.0130181285,
0.0476722233,
-0.003420152,
0.0133040622,
-0.0067898007,
0.0392963365,
-0.0171273779,
0.0070539578,
0.0025513649,
0.0367776155,
-0.0318112187,
-0.0467789993,
-0.0028070034,
0.0610993542,
0.0583635829,
-0.0259100404,
0.0240975935,
-0.0132992137,
0.0067893197,
-0.0451717265,
-0.0087104682,
0.0238737762,
0.0153152831,
0.0372939855,
0.0407824963,
-0.0117587848,
-0.0199022219,
0.0739732012,
0.0416554958,
0.0493295155,
-0.0528319776,
-0.0086995019,
-0.0033578763,
-0.005127003,
0.0461572334,
0.0055984948,
-0.0477822684,
0.0178128276,
-0.1021923721,
-0.0545261726,
0.0330315419,
0.0014582359,
0.0121253077,
0.0075912504,
0.0563209839,
0.0524131209,
-0.0089585334,
0.0082942052,
-0.0067256237,
-0.016599603,
-0.0121711325,
-0.000360622,
0.0331468508,
-6.678988455e-33,
-0.0764695033,
-0.0616786815,
-0.0057640574,
0.0266805328,
0.0254208986,
0.029154608,
-0.0029819626,
-0.0147037022,
0.0023882606,
-0.0354682282,
0.0052538677,
-0.0029085642,
0.0429857932,
-0.0152386883,
-0.0194185823,
0.0247556977,
0.0216904916,
0.0563053228,
0.0258883554,
-0.0467513688,
-0.0019099165,
0.0673617646,
0.0661640167,
-0.1014281735,
-0.0012288262,
0.0229258183,
0.0032478508,
-0.0247613266,
0.0134957535,
0.0669284388,
-0.0496397577,
0.056296505,
-0.0011874411,
-0.0185369737,
-0.035433948,
0.0320323519,
-0.0486711934,
0.0104717975,
0.0714480728,
0.0077156099,
-0.0397926457,
-0.038536761,
0.0129817249,
-0.003138345,
-0.0503541082,
0.021506818,
0.0336395502,
-0.0597050451,
-0.013929748,
0.0181302615,
-0.0698580369,
0.0751028135,
0.0441046804,
0.0020311016,
0.0215246677,
0.0109570781,
-0.012695062,
0.036153499,
-0.0093496293,
0.0523005351,
0.0439696908,
0.0578727312,
0.0482932515,
0.0623930842,
-0.0191367101,
0.0382114835,
0.0042511132,
-0.055543486,
0.0223938003,
-0.0461828411,
0.0233292989,
0.0171980914,
0.0087396419,
0.0090704495,
0.0472383574,
-0.023134673,
0.0127069876,
0.0019513268,
-0.0241035502,
0.0390232131,
0.0054966328,
0.0087726153,
-0.0395509414,
0.0025000062,
-0.0204233415,
0.019099839,
-0.0278396532,
-0.0264774058,
0.048706688,
-0.0073244995,
-0.029745847,
0.0110362414,
0.0273150075,
-0.0045128893,
0.0389463305,
0.0222602952,
0.0212700814,
-0.0139323361,
-0.0482751206,
0.0517303869,
-0.0496903323,
-0.0151726352,
0.0305349175,
-0.0167220403,
0.0186572187,
-0.0115730437,
-0.0406451449,
0.0144760879,
-0.0428678393,
0.0194239989,
0.0052121705,
-0.02864369,
-0.0359888449,
0.0030401032,
0.0870802477,
0.0138745587,
0.0130389072,
0.0674427226,
0.022349989,
-0.0238863826,
-0.0350607447,
-0.0283914246,
-0.0095459875,
0.0398056693,
-0.0353596136,
0.0275868438,
0.0093136011,
-0.0675120503,
-0.0155377714,
0.0002891767,
0.0022904358,
-0.000138826,
2.947e-7,
0.0540868342,
0.050563395,
0.0086902548,
0.0438193716,
-0.0097335484,
0.0048679477,
-0.0048466786,
0.0091971094,
0.0057888869,
0.0156265497,
-0.0123972287,
0.0111052571,
0.0280914642,
0.0085044224,
-0.0895470604,
-0.030787522,
-0.000827673,
0.0044970033,
-0.0186554585,
-0.019606851,
0.0494400375,
0.0925564095,
-0.0351005569,
-0.0214667507,
-0.0113517186,
-0.0402979776,
0.0425628163,
-0.0247566532,
-0.0266276933,
0.0448640063,
-0.0097145578,
0.0456954762,
-0.0283270776,
0.062176846,
-0.0098490166,
0.0184703525,
0.0511690229,
0.0663941503,
-0.0196920056,
-0.0242346842,
-0.0026749929,
0.0116892587,
-0.0261776056,
0.0289236885,
0.047870703,
0.0183110591,
-0.010296612,
-0.0617501661,
-0.0095729837,
0.0091565736,
-0.0069072773,
-0.0245179981,
-0.0328547731,
0.0075241537,
0.003042303,
-0.0213448256,
-0.0509691425,
-0.0743493512,
0.0017541846,
0.0127257667,
-0.0282925926,
0.0166423135,
0.0166616105,
-0.0071318923,
0.0426209979,
-0.0509370714,
-0.0147763984,
2.995128841e-34,
0.0364543684,
-0.0037087314,
-0.0159607548,
0.0738852173,
-0.0023272862,
-0.0072436454,
-0.080074504,
0.0500755981,
0.0147283552,
-0.0634512156,
-0.0094224783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19698v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19698v2 | When Do Prompting and Prefix-Tuning Work? A Theory of Capabilities and Limitations | 2023-10-30T16:19:34 | 2024-04-09T10:30:14 | Aleksandar Petrov, Philip H. S. Torr, Adel Bibi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Context-based fine-tuning methods, including prompting, in-context learning,
soft prompting (also known as prompt tuning), and prefix-tuning, have gained
popularity due to their ability to often match the performance of full
fine-tuning with a fraction of the parameters. Despite their empirical
successes, there is little theoretical understanding of how these techniques
influence the internal computation of the model and their expressiveness
limitations. We show that despite the continuous embedding space being more
expressive than the discrete token space, soft-prompting and prefix-tuning are
potentially less expressive than full fine-tuning, even with the same number of
learnable parameters. Concretely, context-based fine-tuning cannot change the
relative attention pattern over the content and can only bias the outputs of an
attention layer in a fixed direction. This suggests that while techniques like
prompting, in-context learning, soft prompting, and prefix-tuning can
effectively elicit skills present in the pretrained model, they may not be able
to learn novel tasks that require new attention patterns. | [
0.0491754301,
-0.0155243268,
-0.0335304327,
0.0063621979,
-0.0017307716,
0.0176220108,
0.0015565184,
-0.0280258022,
-0.0390957817,
-0.0363134332,
-0.0566078387,
-0.0041053272,
0.0194610711,
0.0388673618,
0.0530277081,
-0.0581291169,
0.072868526,
0.0033175531,
0.0227447189,
0.039082747,
-0.0264460109,
-0.0405613482,
0.0223994907,
0.0366626233,
-0.0057543642,
0.0021323862,
-0.0043615364,
0.0106346263,
0.0047612223,
0.0092706,
0.0204583816,
0.0718002096,
0.0086806649,
-0.0100019714,
0.0000020858,
-0.0399756618,
0.0165734217,
-0.0324771143,
-0.0261954851,
-0.0035768086,
0.0204717722,
-0.0149823269,
0.0035031131,
-0.0032337536,
-0.0300270151,
0.0102266567,
0.0462780222,
0.0589722544,
0.0179932509,
0.0759567693,
-0.0138421711,
0.0101567619,
-0.014818212,
-0.0549035259,
0.0139338858,
-0.0125678144,
0.0135956127,
-0.0783494264,
-0.0014725403,
0.0531927533,
-0.0559571907,
0.0072428053,
0.0409414805,
0.0359830409,
0.0693518445,
0.0469779372,
-0.0147269508,
-0.0258115884,
-0.0406610519,
0.0426568799,
-0.0432534143,
0.0003977635,
-0.0197197851,
-0.0206956211,
0.0444766469,
-0.0136199929,
-0.0336306244,
-0.0086799338,
0.0116192615,
-0.0006297857,
0.0058627194,
0.0003767489,
0.0193518773,
-0.0255180616,
-0.0175720286,
0.0284698363,
-0.0299917683,
-0.0646188334,
-0.018431589,
0.0033967819,
-0.0038073487,
-0.0619432926,
-0.0033850553,
0.0046481923,
-0.0289947428,
-0.0054606884,
-0.0806994215,
0.0071730888,
0.0161840394,
0.0475160442,
0.0566626154,
0.0400912575,
-0.0478497706,
0.0528859943,
-0.0395077541,
0.0391662158,
-0.0100618927,
0.0651712641,
-0.0373109691,
0.0615734719,
-0.0281052068,
-0.0053333133,
-0.0603821576,
-0.0122222127,
-0.0471873283,
-0.0561253317,
-0.0241857637,
0.0799418762,
-0.0054952232,
-0.0019888533,
-0.0403429754,
-0.0138308629,
-0.0676592588,
0.0307806376,
-0.007087484,
-0.0122020673,
-0.0427612998,
0.0554934517,
0.0682123974,
-0.0135523872,
-0.0300529096,
-0.0118706599,
0.0076635964,
-0.0342156142,
-0.0014554535,
0.038258668,
-0.002045806,
-0.0342797376,
-0.0049284482,
-0.0231815185,
-0.0144210653,
-0.022004921,
0.0359254703,
-0.0121030696,
0.0079764677,
-0.0133252386,
-0.0065416261,
0.0119912066,
-0.0129032964,
-0.0120128607,
-0.0600887164,
0.0593938231,
0.0165601932,
-0.0027840454,
-0.0053284615,
0.0082018515,
-0.0313573144,
0.0497919582,
-0.027370302,
0.0170999039,
0.01948357,
-0.0008134278,
0.0052074669,
-0.0113903843,
0.0443743877,
0.0134454668,
-0.0091754198,
0.0067197867,
0.0515941605,
0.0354494266,
0.03622628,
-0.0051605506,
-0.0483382232,
0.0005774601,
0.0512101613,
0.0450191163,
0.0472900234,
-0.0114943869,
0.0481561795,
-0.0211288314,
-0.0098354546,
0.0590259247,
-0.1193706021,
0.0391877964,
-0.0130124446,
0.005225895,
0.0180438664,
0.0079378514,
-0.0350086614,
-0.0470074378,
0.02437534,
-0.0040772934,
0.022629736,
-0.0015156942,
0.0341247581,
0.0208370704,
-0.0259441175,
-0.0294494461,
0.0127365543,
-0.0044094967,
-0.0080494629,
-0.074684903,
0.0334767923,
0.046089597,
-0.0084080258,
-0.0565294214,
-0.0423616692,
-0.0213634018,
0.0561774448,
-0.0282586552,
0.050669603,
0.0115471184,
0.0205145311,
-0.0092646899,
-0.0442504473,
-0.0753502026,
0.0155288363,
-0.0113131851,
-0.0176990032,
0.0011947065,
-0.0026452118,
0.0216078069,
-0.0071335663,
0.038801454,
0.0208102576,
-0.0337657966,
-0.0312329493,
0.0612885393,
0.0142123457,
0.0045779622,
0.0175649226,
0.0215121917,
0.0189759322,
-0.0101368548,
0.036646653,
-0.011034172,
-0.0777926967,
-0.0063320748,
-0.0077270428,
-0.001531521,
-0.0218552537,
-0.010982017,
-0.0201376509,
-0.0099443682,
0.0056020916,
-0.0048287692,
0.0453505218,
-0.0145113608,
0.0094267745,
-0.019449709,
0.0059506325,
-0.0465118028,
0.0364325494,
0.0044933832,
0.0306013543,
0.0408812203,
0.0504194498,
-0.0236283224,
-0.038784638,
-0.0153332027,
-0.0370565951,
-0.0218445864,
0.0037209583,
-0.0003016237,
0.007605236,
-0.0843346342,
-0.0313009061,
-0.0730652362,
-0.0028142156,
-0.0392642803,
-0.0233918987,
0.0061210115,
0.014336139,
-0.0260485914,
-0.0119632026,
-0.0064855455,
-0.009246733,
-0.0311767273,
0.0679537654,
0.0166150928,
0.0096247606,
0.0014558672,
-0.0092455801,
-0.0083237709,
0.0145520838,
0.0337284543,
0.0177412238,
-0.0048121195,
-0.0454653352,
0.0078468546,
0.0190636069,
0.0014221747,
-0.0263638888,
-0.0357392505,
0.0293785799,
-0.0057211239,
0.058391545,
0.1451397687,
-0.0009808453,
0.0311132036,
0.0172915813,
0.023730116,
-0.018087782,
0.0195233524,
-0.0339074023,
-0.0227538664,
-0.0131105119,
0.0357198492,
0.053479366,
0.0484625138,
-0.017376313,
-0.0063580042,
-0.0780097991,
0.0472442694,
0.0104461545,
-0.0187687762,
-0.0287326835,
-0.000160486,
-0.0283507556,
0.0668908283,
-0.060175851,
-0.0632786155,
0.0709122345,
0.0189754963,
-0.0216953512,
-0.0110589471,
-0.0126658222,
0.0014920833,
-0.008687011,
-0.0100175664,
0.0323661976,
0.0390074886,
-0.0477509759,
-0.0771353543,
0.0077618719,
0.0063863201,
0.002742273,
0.0279397015,
0.0526363626,
-0.052463863,
0.0021968163,
-0.0367251858,
-0.0192116033,
-0.03944223,
0.032289248,
0.0362026393,
0.0292580314,
0.0060724886,
-0.0013404291,
-0.0134543264,
0.022977069,
0.0543228164,
-0.0527270474,
-0.0250008274,
-0.0295199268,
0.0093230559,
0.0036118513,
0.0650392845,
-0.0245614219,
-0.0311835967,
-0.0047145379,
0.0160336699,
0.0177453868,
-0.0133449743,
-0.0120291803,
0.0550566055,
0.0141011635,
-0.0179383848,
-0.0191297568,
0.0422198959,
0.0808216482,
-0.0579426028,
-0.0340378396,
0.0685453638,
0.0108947195,
-0.045138672,
0.0098223044,
-0.0084200827,
-0.0354271121,
0.0677332208,
0.0219217632,
-0.0606501177,
-0.0202357192,
0.0239416081,
0.0505328663,
-0.0082246447,
0.0270445943,
0.0149616236,
-0.0780429617,
0.0726225302,
0.02299737,
-0.0512789339,
-0.0478231125,
-0.0273008123,
0.0309573766,
0.0373301655,
-0.002015376,
0.0263489746,
-0.0083546285,
-0.0002257341,
0.0271260459,
0.0553300567,
-0.1160320938,
-0.0031293363,
-0.0486494489,
0.0165338106,
0.0563774668,
-0.0235585384,
0.0292772017,
-0.0446225777,
0.0603576899,
-0.0144924307,
0.0387517698,
-0.0275715422,
0.0345534161,
-0.0316751935,
0.0107371667,
-0.0077821282,
0.066087991,
0.0178400744,
-0.0486325696,
-0.0299221203,
0.086958915,
0.0003078701,
0.0000632443,
-0.0363470428,
-0.0175820217,
0.0352674201,
0.0427088477,
0.0857278407,
-0.0516476519,
-0.0143550467,
-0.0207424238,
0.0062119146,
0.0099456171,
-0.0142570771,
0.0072829085,
-0.0145801539,
-0.0344940349,
-0.0399801768,
-0.0435443632,
0.0329089798,
0.0382845886,
0.0207047537,
-0.027725013,
-0.0275584515,
-0.0213463884,
-0.0335717238,
0.0733622313,
0.0215190388,
0.004644657,
-0.0832396448,
-0.0357573144,
0.0238281153,
-0.0582437553,
-0.0069354507,
-0.0397828594,
-0.0358067378,
-0.0605261959,
0.0046634083,
0.0435496718,
0.0115385894,
0.0767873377,
-0.0266320594,
-0.0262328126,
0.0602936968,
0.0208437331,
-0.0539203212,
0.0533899926,
0.055231221,
-0.0085914712,
0.0000791332,
0.0303821024,
-0.0544233434,
0.0125205815,
0.0652432442,
-0.0105302827,
-0.0131399874,
0.0131362453,
0.0161427893,
-0.0316346548,
0.1052419916,
0.0255107265,
-0.0024589908,
-0.0519542582,
0.0136359464,
0.0504529662,
-0.0314109772,
-0.0223271921,
-0.0454836003,
-0.0015415993,
0.0282730442,
0.0020302932,
-0.0144907925,
-0.0004086754,
0.0207840372,
-0.0890797228,
0.0353704691,
0.0073533407,
0.0111455284,
0.0212587006,
0.0462351032,
-0.0321839154,
0.0128303859,
-0.0236442126,
0.0234615877,
-0.0039701276,
0.0337050371,
0.0575544648,
0.0278687719,
-0.0740449578,
0.0705514178,
-0.0944171697,
-0.0377249308,
-0.0029723351,
0.0267019682,
0.0159482285,
-0.0665216222,
-0.0555810556,
0.0207329374,
-0.0298252236,
0.0021597922,
0.0137263294,
0.0068689208,
-0.0217501596,
0.011038404,
0.013328868,
0.0030596799,
-0.0052053141,
0.0370776467,
-0.0626515597,
0.0285141226,
-0.0135968924,
-0.0006753667,
-0.0318067521,
0.0157041959,
0.0604571961,
0.0435065962,
-0.0101664495,
0.0579797402,
-0.0289776307,
-0.0383620858,
-0.0121683571,
-0.0063706669,
-0.0083017331,
-0.0175322592,
0.0091518313,
0.0591722243,
0.0039739874,
-0.0131250983,
-0.0183056183,
-0.0295931865,
0.0221121293,
-0.0219613835,
0.0028286788,
-6.803011925e-33,
-0.0177949052,
0.0040517864,
0.002506118,
-0.0033765596,
-0.0260559767,
0.0233168416,
-0.0217971448,
-0.0084879799,
0.0002057284,
-0.0102017503,
-0.0389094353,
-0.0234198514,
-0.0032103488,
-0.0164104104,
0.0175670628,
-0.0201473366,
0.0354180485,
-0.0110728526,
-0.0717822537,
-0.0076355636,
0.0315733962,
0.0077410629,
0.0472346283,
-0.0095796902,
0.009302997,
0.0363733135,
-0.0101436237,
0.0019684979,
-0.0232504401,
0.054987587,
0.0285990164,
-0.008021581,
0.0194923431,
-0.0334818698,
-0.0322426781,
0.0815537572,
-0.094021976,
-0.0797360316,
0.0055083181,
-0.0081310943,
-0.0510415398,
-0.0580074973,
0.0826339573,
0.0015611083,
-0.0058973385,
-0.0315316282,
0.0193238184,
-0.0235178806,
-0.0459937602,
-0.0301941503,
-0.0755274668,
-0.0153512256,
-0.0015669467,
-0.0449151583,
-0.0079623368,
0.051331643,
-0.0082305772,
0.0429869145,
-0.0508422963,
0.0100908382,
0.0433547795,
0.05467996,
0.0158186015,
0.0371629298,
-0.0070955087,
0.0174739379,
0.0133881764,
0.0552620217,
0.0230325144,
-0.0326761529,
0.046018485,
0.0311026834,
-0.0088673625,
-0.0327416509,
0.0464359261,
-0.0141025204,
-0.0245291255,
-0.0148566058,
0.0049229297,
0.0126665672,
0.0552192256,
0.0074049709,
0.0010260353,
-0.0297700725,
-0.0421864502,
-0.0239583906,
-0.0541766696,
0.0152461277,
0.0551137142,
0.0450942628,
0.0013029688,
0.0237649847,
0.0391845778,
-0.0016665296,
0.044231087,
-0.0074599851,
0.0019590915,
0.0286850091,
0.0031686628,
-0.0301614795,
-0.0763024539,
-0.0570040531,
0.0512421653,
0.0025811326,
0.0183048043,
0.0172714796,
0.0751539543,
0.0174130425,
-0.0428722352,
-0.0238735843,
-0.0129128136,
0.0505406596,
0.0312443301,
0.0173973367,
0.0484345928,
0.0028518667,
-0.0246302225,
0.042435348,
0.0070450134,
-0.0392734371,
-0.0468924791,
0.0184171423,
-0.0025016335,
0.0289709195,
-0.0365874879,
-0.0119528472,
-0.0331777073,
0.0219316743,
0.0153814638,
-0.0482345484,
-0.0386187658,
0.0301129948,
2.968e-7,
-0.0162567347,
0.0306772292,
-0.0079655061,
-0.0142709436,
0.0411878601,
0.0306364652,
-0.0330675915,
0.0311698709,
0.0443222485,
0.0136784948,
0.0298688579,
0.0372522138,
0.0032664551,
-0.0473107435,
-0.0598905534,
0.0029832222,
-0.0459766388,
0.0705179349,
-0.0315081924,
0.0011344756,
0.0191859435,
0.0945410132,
0.0103308419,
0.0103910491,
0.030943349,
-0.0338858478,
0.0348085277,
-0.0487035699,
0.05901362,
-0.003535395,
-0.0311654359,
0.0315816179,
-0.0119080143,
0.0197892785,
-0.0276422817,
0.0407191366,
-0.0194206461,
0.0628605038,
-0.0279520787,
-0.0095043303,
0.0061150617,
0.0243292917,
-0.0014874903,
-0.0670976117,
0.0527965426,
-0.124310039,
-0.0170136951,
-0.0418658555,
-0.003519451,
-0.008282668,
0.0091616828,
-0.0075855511,
-0.0009178082,
-0.0120678712,
-0.0066636153,
0.025536282,
-0.0028837018,
-0.1007607058,
-0.004112957,
0.0273011755,
-0.032184463,
-0.046324607,
-0.0462221391,
0.0061184429,
0.0562783703,
-0.0082363347,
-0.0284454748,
2.677841105e-34,
0.0134639069,
-0.0178136379,
0.0717507675,
0.0118925143,
-0.0116372332,
-0.0232779384,
-0.0029496651,
0.0132823447,
0.0646116883,
-0.0383366719,
-0.0253382046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19687v1 | Sentiment Analysis in Digital Spaces: An Overview of Reviews | 2023-10-30T16:04:35 | 2023-10-30T16:04:35 | Laura E. M. Ayravainen, Joanne Hinds, Brittany I. Davidson | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Sentiment analysis (SA) is commonly applied to digital textual data,
revealing insight into opinions and feelings. Many systematic reviews have
summarized existing work, but often overlook discussions of validity and
scientific practices. Here, we present an overview of reviews, synthesizing 38
systematic reviews, containing 2,275 primary studies. We devise a bespoke
quality assessment framework designed to assess the rigor and quality of
systematic review methodologies and reporting standards. Our findings show
diverse applications and methods, limited reporting rigor, and challenges over
time. We discuss how future research and practitioners can address these issues
and highlight their importance across numerous applications. | [
0.0679799914,
0.0776707083,
-0.0075777951,
-0.0319572948,
-0.0085551115,
0.0211141072,
0.0044112182,
-0.0080847628,
-0.0056091547,
-0.0381672233,
-0.0252358541,
-0.0339024514,
0.0275333934,
0.0395769663,
-0.0092606321,
-0.0181511119,
-0.0150004085,
0.084781155,
0.0342083871,
0.0329605155,
0.0301103536,
0.0295134597,
0.0137563422,
0.0305375755,
-0.013330834,
-0.0262593795,
0.0513508618,
0.0192281324,
0.0157423653,
-0.0661233366,
0.0174378175,
-0.012127148,
-0.0342115238,
0.0529719815,
0.0000023979,
0.0030439056,
-0.0174252857,
0.0426813886,
0.066311866,
-0.0086919544,
0.0828299299,
-0.0360533372,
0.0213288888,
0.0288507696,
-0.0383325815,
-0.0293113645,
0.0648281723,
0.0425848663,
0.0182663929,
0.0302555077,
-0.0453847311,
-0.0292232037,
-0.0109632723,
0.031807512,
-0.0238006897,
0.060422115,
-0.029293932,
0.0180123765,
-0.0036098508,
-0.0261515696,
0.0261400715,
0.0168331582,
0.002334093,
0.0192307942,
-0.0110008186,
-0.020323433,
-0.0209716596,
-0.0713682473,
0.0315424129,
0.03637233,
0.0456629917,
0.0115693985,
-0.008839556,
-0.0373047367,
-0.0144421291,
-0.0005917905,
-0.0244508404,
0.0401378423,
-0.0065580956,
0.0287026577,
-0.0590471067,
0.0586243831,
0.0377450399,
0.0137006501,
0.0402496159,
0.0195202697,
-0.028450394,
-0.0412456207,
0.0172874816,
0.0398813896,
0.0304391235,
0.0409211256,
0.008295319,
-0.0420737118,
0.0057293004,
0.0135229109,
0.0098389881,
-0.0230099652,
0.0310948752,
-0.0523988791,
0.0453279279,
0.0244194102,
0.0126540996,
-0.0289529972,
0.0209127367,
-0.0564012676,
0.0240335334,
0.0061845104,
0.0021227163,
0.0431480035,
-0.0251101255,
0.0328400768,
0.0749191418,
-0.0261463448,
0.0000928078,
-0.0410394222,
-0.0275141411,
-0.0196579248,
-0.0153849553,
0.0110887159,
0.0031245404,
0.0242642518,
0.0176756643,
0.0298555959,
-0.0237335023,
0.0319767743,
-0.0119030392,
0.0522148982,
-0.0670279637,
-0.0286009125,
0.0576478578,
0.0066013625,
0.0036732741,
0.0434233509,
-0.007981522,
0.0223026592,
0.0487082452,
-0.0467308499,
0.0081601962,
-0.029536061,
-0.0130949859,
-0.0141553059,
0.0000556071,
-0.0373873338,
-0.0001804076,
0.0043999823,
0.0259199198,
0.0421494246,
-0.0049462942,
0.0219039135,
-0.0324172229,
0.0208662525,
-0.1151857302,
0.0032141313,
-0.016288301,
0.0364403091,
0.0340665877,
0.0542756841,
0.0057590855,
0.0790993273,
0.0228191018,
0.034018755,
-0.0134590687,
-0.042617891,
-0.0038187399,
-0.0879867151,
-0.002517299,
0.0022490362,
-0.0632798001,
-0.0290058702,
-0.0336472541,
0.0625310168,
-0.0116154812,
0.0380712338,
0.0279776733,
0.0179412253,
-0.009706093,
0.0487933941,
-0.0528542884,
0.0181077104,
0.0286052804,
-0.0514038689,
-0.0122099221,
0.014512267,
0.0536056347,
-0.0117480783,
0.0351843052,
0.0229287073,
0.0266274307,
-0.0554054007,
-0.0294989739,
-0.0394655615,
0.0389864706,
0.0037020983,
0.0046844245,
-0.0121081909,
0.0168410502,
-0.0442551263,
0.0506046936,
-0.063419044,
-0.0280780438,
0.0057243658,
0.0485602133,
0.0961458161,
-0.0122978734,
-0.0132914195,
0.0105505986,
-0.0259300135,
-0.0159713328,
0.0298954789,
-0.0193479322,
0.0116729047,
0.0336840674,
-0.0216371622,
-0.0332927704,
-0.0226563308,
0.0133556919,
-0.0101090316,
-0.011251607,
0.0465100892,
-0.0143768983,
-0.016967766,
-0.0614459366,
-0.0109484615,
0.0565883592,
0.0141177,
0.0171529558,
0.0197900757,
0.0169746373,
0.0549441278,
-0.0363195576,
0.010798675,
0.0155250663,
0.044865977,
-0.0528685786,
0.0434085131,
0.0184513107,
0.0133554926,
0.0224336069,
-0.0729013979,
-0.0425464846,
0.0315839089,
-0.0246795043,
0.0153447585,
0.0215263162,
-0.0129143121,
0.0346954167,
0.0169848297,
-0.0556244962,
-0.0576313362,
0.0118390964,
0.0260655582,
-0.004435637,
-0.0037830689,
-0.0133427856,
-0.0321811438,
-0.0599872768,
0.0231090579,
0.0774610564,
-0.0919163898,
0.015865406,
0.0061897417,
0.0480423756,
0.0160631798,
0.0119332038,
-0.0755443797,
-0.0183039792,
-0.1085155383,
-0.0252027381,
-0.0079523697,
0.0365754962,
0.004691761,
-0.0040448233,
0.0022282461,
-0.0145878503,
-0.0271824449,
-0.015706297,
-0.0190692134,
0.0318137705,
0.0251894183,
0.0133519955,
0.0700057372,
-0.0567102879,
-0.0227153208,
0.0024679168,
0.0050933827,
0.0626039281,
-0.0000053766,
0.0119323544,
0.0011677868,
-0.0642981231,
-0.0243597012,
-0.01464938,
0.0006505105,
0.0453534685,
-0.0090668006,
-0.0158718564,
-0.005852988,
-0.0144813322,
0.0354408659,
0.0405658968,
0.0203983188,
-0.0092815747,
-0.0102822129,
-0.0413616262,
0.0219871793,
0.0028507509,
-0.0476975255,
0.0021083124,
-0.0180016328,
-0.0033424795,
0.0143872602,
-0.0613330528,
-0.0194955245,
-0.0335786492,
-0.0141847152,
-0.0263975728,
0.0067856228,
-0.0018410002,
0.0302839316,
0.0219776053,
-0.0179559756,
0.0221427213,
-0.0006717894,
0.0258768369,
-0.0659134835,
0.0011633221,
-0.0314101316,
0.0037041667,
-0.0261528306,
-0.0066056997,
0.0107266596,
0.0287654605,
0.0622558743,
-0.0476887375,
-0.0031486952,
-0.0053243078,
0.0045137275,
0.0091568017,
0.0006406165,
0.0255329479,
-0.0137710888,
0.0400684699,
-0.0328751989,
-0.0670211613,
-0.0262085218,
-0.0043091988,
-0.0376857184,
-0.0223756861,
0.0080938051,
0.0113900909,
-0.0509742834,
-0.0061089261,
-0.0560127683,
0.0348202549,
-0.031981539,
0.0389800742,
-0.0505633764,
0.0776949748,
0.0354954377,
-0.0372010283,
0.0744003728,
-0.0269766338,
-0.0060515767,
-0.0434887111,
-0.0373022258,
-0.0224016625,
0.0038409629,
0.0009945633,
-0.0488054119,
0.0447562076,
-0.0254141577,
0.0457994118,
0.0851255581,
0.0219491497,
-0.0697317719,
-0.0210502855,
-0.0153174214,
-0.0518483892,
-0.0210077893,
-0.0696657225,
-0.0348653644,
-0.0370594077,
-0.0549617372,
0.0680656955,
-0.0282356404,
0.0007793966,
0.0163890086,
-0.053096734,
0.0065981434,
-0.0172751099,
0.020593008,
-0.0147433234,
-0.0468320362,
0.0227945987,
-0.0235892683,
0.0155824311,
-0.0865465477,
-0.0216326937,
0.0433610231,
-0.0203905124,
-0.0801888555,
-0.0242901072,
0.0020378034,
-0.0282653626,
0.0309370831,
0.0428390242,
0.0638061464,
-0.0228772052,
-0.0219655782,
-0.001726954,
-0.0140709123,
-0.0083000194,
-0.0046735853,
0.0765859485,
-0.0228279121,
0.0076163909,
-0.0418637134,
-0.0264447946,
-0.0568850972,
-0.0210350864,
0.0087156668,
0.0129059665,
-0.0019778467,
-0.0271042641,
-0.0587186404,
0.0636154115,
-0.0024486936,
0.0122322403,
0.0232055299,
-0.0271596145,
0.0008547712,
-0.0036384822,
0.014820992,
0.0055502537,
-0.0159326028,
-0.003279268,
0.0367390737,
-0.0430201143,
-0.0403457284,
-0.0725943446,
-0.0068187923,
-0.0170021132,
-0.027819138,
0.0056328881,
0.0272356775,
-0.0217256602,
-0.0195699688,
0.0674754158,
0.0378314778,
0.0214544721,
0.0225989744,
0.0110844038,
0.0080923177,
0.002234153,
0.0312191769,
-0.0410226062,
-0.0418189913,
0.013294532,
-0.0079241712,
0.065925613,
-0.0049764807,
-0.0118870297,
-0.0120868776,
-0.0230509825,
0.0358624496,
0.0573527254,
-0.0162563957,
-0.0511995144,
0.0304823108,
0.0707697496,
0.0287052859,
-0.0379376933,
-0.0075569148,
0.0017180511,
0.0068273954,
-0.0499887876,
0.0246468931,
0.0204404835,
0.0104241353,
-0.0035604287,
0.0250811335,
-0.037657056,
-0.0155124953,
0.0107830195,
-0.0380842425,
-0.0220079031,
-0.0118521759,
-0.0392318666,
-0.0042925496,
-0.0173011627,
0.0591636747,
-0.0782628432,
0.015814174,
-0.0456694998,
0.0136511466,
-0.0457886197,
0.1136884168,
0.034055274,
0.0399612188,
0.0199583396,
-0.0121535687,
-0.0171415806,
0.0125148632,
-0.0066233799,
-0.0199100487,
-0.0126328738,
0.0062341378,
0.0076855039,
-0.0098887431,
0.0065836762,
0.0701965839,
-0.0225081816,
-0.018044373,
0.0059899832,
-0.0218648296,
-0.0271325465,
-0.0044406308,
0.0910739675,
-0.0245403592,
-0.0007419512,
0.0382242985,
-0.0002774121,
-0.07127662,
0.0063786414,
-0.0424073003,
-0.014778723,
-0.0350337066,
-0.0106197735,
0.0138902729,
-0.1048533842,
0.0111617539,
0.0202034339,
-0.0278020501,
-0.0202792864,
0.0010877801,
-0.0083349636,
0.0261099674,
-0.0009551454,
-0.0256769713,
-0.0348298214,
-0.0502405055,
0.0409878567,
-0.0543389469,
0.0280073471,
-0.0049693435,
0.0005451091,
0.0198039338,
0.0413747691,
0.0526447892,
-0.0367724858,
-0.0271098949,
-0.0183658134,
-0.0404923707,
-0.0241298638,
-6.900356081e-33,
0.0480021834,
-0.0411997847,
-0.067210108,
0.017676888,
0.0017071139,
0.0093361661,
-0.014986028,
0.020431364,
0.0486054048,
0.046294868,
-0.0228185765,
0.0515204631,
-0.0042646471,
0.0548020415,
0.0352865681,
-0.0119098267,
0.0089483634,
-0.0297936425,
0.0019308341,
0.0303888526,
-0.0107067274,
-0.0260636937,
0.0220733788,
-0.1085092798,
0.0720972866,
0.0224731397,
-0.0815943107,
-0.0302587505,
0.0190206338,
0.0316190049,
-0.0205367319,
0.0598747097,
0.0518313609,
0.0453971662,
-0.0129687674,
0.0506281219,
-0.0556519218,
0.0032461255,
-0.0158157181,
0.020309303,
-0.0132579664,
0.0451747552,
0.0253744386,
0.0106278528,
-0.037626639,
0.0062523461,
0.0201940164,
-0.0254481267,
0.0152272591,
-0.0805077478,
-0.0167497806,
0.0245222859,
-0.0025415695,
0.0444457568,
0.0418975875,
0.0811249092,
0.0028244667,
0.036372155,
-0.0839918032,
0.020000251,
-0.0458761714,
-0.0606785528,
-0.028594505,
-0.0857214555,
-0.0018315357,
0.0626029894,
-0.0039728489,
0.0112801613,
-0.0253703911,
0.0480343886,
0.0278572235,
-0.0089130672,
0.0179860052,
0.0644102395,
0.0415017679,
-0.0820135921,
-0.0068532182,
0.0198842715,
-0.0181943569,
0.0036823002,
0.0731987432,
-0.0107015083,
-0.0282846149,
-0.016462557,
0.0074623781,
-0.0577947199,
-0.0252044462,
-0.0257121567,
0.0043690158,
-0.0499979705,
-0.0097214412,
-0.0253038872,
-0.0304749273,
-0.0499950275,
-0.0399942547,
0.0294454917,
-0.041781947,
0.0452580936,
0.0216022879,
0.0011097775,
-0.0400343351,
0.0334985144,
-0.0111391516,
0.0601694249,
0.012482455,
-0.0290771313,
0.0624324977,
0.0311597809,
-0.0746467039,
-0.0079579763,
0.0217818469,
0.0275248941,
0.019560881,
-0.0084560812,
-0.0171641577,
0.0211997107,
-0.0126762828,
0.0327230282,
0.0190231986,
0.0973580405,
0.0006147003,
-0.031385269,
-0.0069388896,
-0.0104158511,
-0.0291533917,
-0.048831258,
-0.0288324244,
-0.0241072755,
0.0335901119,
-0.0384661779,
-0.0116478065,
-0.0135910539,
3.088e-7,
0.0753250569,
0.0701638535,
-0.0509505905,
-0.0242703576,
0.021917887,
0.0493025742,
0.0511828624,
0.0029937942,
0.0251133703,
0.0351569578,
0.0328107513,
0.0129907439,
0.0032905003,
0.0585849136,
-0.030088596,
-0.0261636786,
-0.0237157308,
-0.0315612145,
0.0120498436,
0.0755689666,
0.0317522325,
0.0476099178,
0.0188133866,
-0.0103181563,
-0.0542158075,
0.0132983867,
-0.0061178971,
-0.038365908,
0.0199303217,
-0.0154352775,
-0.004063569,
-0.039726682,
-0.0008160123,
-0.0606218204,
0.0227393024,
-0.0027365265,
0.0288867932,
-0.0192194209,
0.0359999351,
-0.0258373898,
0.0244252365,
0.0166666303,
0.0466502197,
-0.0046410644,
0.0396564119,
-0.0578060225,
-0.0871924087,
-0.0582499802,
-0.0299403463,
0.0140417637,
0.1089369729,
0.0198130496,
-0.0420769192,
0.0348225757,
-0.0125502469,
-0.012952555,
-0.0473060831,
-0.0522326306,
0.0251403712,
-0.0152692832,
0.0131223807,
-0.0302798729,
0.0284564253,
-0.0206754059,
0.0232409909,
0.0056962874,
0.0388914682,
2.384013205e-34,
0.0164459813,
-0.0488659628,
0.0074070538,
-0.0385975093,
0.010200873,
0.0388759412,
-0.0177962389,
-0.031244358,
0.0300065633,
-0.0334112346,
0.0230479725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19680v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19680v4 | Integrating Pre-trained Language Model into Neural Machine Translation | 2023-10-30T16:00:13 | 2024-01-13T15:39:10 | Soon-Jae Hwang, Chang-Sung Jeong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Neural Machine Translation (NMT) has become a significant technology in
natural language processing through extensive research and development.
However, the deficiency of high-quality bilingual language pair data still
poses a major challenge to improving NMT performance. Recent studies have been
exploring the use of contextual information from pre-trained language model
(PLM) to address this problem. Yet, the issue of incompatibility between PLM
and NMT model remains unresolved. This study proposes PLM-integrated NMT
(PiNMT) model to overcome the identified problems. PiNMT model consists of
three critical components, PLM Multi Layer Converter, Embedding Fusion, and
Cosine Alignment, each playing a vital role in providing effective PLM
information to NMT. Furthermore, two training strategies, Separate Learning
Rates and Dual Step Training, are also introduced in this paper. By
implementing the proposed PiNMT model and training strategy, we achieve
state-of-the-art performance on the IWSLT'14 En$\leftrightarrow$De dataset.
This study's outcomes are noteworthy as they demonstrate a novel approach for
efficiently integrating PLM with NMT to overcome incompatibility and enhance
performance. | [
-0.0056069922,
0.0015767221,
0.0043781511,
0.0806602612,
-0.0257248562,
0.0087346034,
-0.0017110234,
-0.0350811593,
-0.0390659682,
-0.016472429,
-0.0651086941,
-0.0294987708,
0.0344605297,
0.0019653023,
0.0305764861,
-0.0115857944,
0.0332499743,
0.0111794025,
-0.0678415522,
0.0004750958,
-0.0046499721,
0.0070908396,
0.0392169729,
0.0150458422,
0.0065666842,
0.0003243418,
-0.0044726511,
0.0549754314,
0.0370122865,
-0.0142557397,
-0.0091629475,
0.0359838717,
0.0517024249,
0.0669861436,
0.0000021905,
-0.0218692832,
-0.0452687368,
0.0024757171,
0.0242416561,
0.0058719651,
0.0216968022,
-0.0440863892,
-0.0104227485,
0.0360986106,
-0.024887275,
-0.0002403243,
0.0496603698,
0.0439215489,
0.0730791017,
0.0901759192,
-0.0035518031,
-0.0279453658,
0.0282442123,
-0.0611410961,
-0.0528389588,
-0.0144773796,
-0.0049470346,
0.0026560999,
-0.0516690575,
0.0192706995,
-0.0031333873,
0.0634199306,
0.0180074386,
0.0262155067,
-0.0395877883,
0.0157497227,
-0.0093147941,
-0.0335795023,
-0.0231023785,
0.0673879683,
-0.0876998529,
0.001906595,
-0.0139083182,
-0.0077172136,
-0.0453294739,
-0.0421010926,
-0.0217168368,
-0.0065763406,
0.0219422411,
0.060641285,
0.032170888,
0.0403593481,
0.0651930049,
-0.0088845454,
-0.0439515039,
0.0252570193,
0.0394727774,
-0.0334204584,
-0.0054653408,
0.0078686941,
0.0404546484,
0.0108191781,
0.0438495688,
-0.0057567987,
0.0224273968,
0.0342878625,
-0.0414432511,
-0.0287947375,
-0.0101040807,
-0.0817945153,
0.0242552496,
0.0765257478,
-0.0194018465,
0.0432138368,
-0.0202059243,
0.0320615433,
-0.0286921076,
0.0107641937,
-0.0698851049,
-0.0225467961,
-0.0070434571,
0.0132330908,
-0.0479979292,
0.0079121403,
-0.032562919,
-0.0186834615,
-0.0250517912,
0.0093357572,
0.0086059859,
-0.0285028443,
0.0322334133,
-0.0418614186,
-0.0575544536,
-0.0084668724,
-0.0105652222,
0.0667186454,
0.0430708677,
-0.0244278125,
-0.0341674648,
-0.0505730137,
-0.0319006704,
0.0146301398,
-0.0260317717,
-0.0353336334,
0.0086417999,
0.0562868118,
-0.0278043468,
-0.070444487,
-0.0459315404,
-0.0034406434,
-0.0017746158,
-0.0492138602,
-0.0175123028,
-0.0710077509,
0.1170526445,
-0.0214746501,
0.00282375,
-0.0297248606,
-0.0042830338,
0.0126318187,
-0.018649783,
0.0867014825,
-0.0208516028,
-0.006392784,
0.0306348857,
0.0079117743,
0.0173673574,
0.0662203506,
0.0453284681,
-0.0066083423,
0.0000618823,
-0.0212481525,
-0.0501762666,
0.0786652118,
0.0354226194,
0.019919375,
-0.0450421199,
-0.0068659368,
0.0166261885,
-0.0035744524,
0.0456060469,
0.0498835146,
-0.0245391037,
0.0218251031,
0.0554265119,
0.025026124,
0.0468828268,
0.0477777347,
0.0419278592,
0.0084603373,
0.0018923893,
-0.0245129541,
-0.0216608997,
0.0025604554,
-0.0432295613,
-0.0067621334,
0.0555421859,
0.0753745735,
-0.0205327403,
-0.0202319082,
0.0234500896,
-0.0409047976,
0.0268014912,
-0.0205519255,
0.0166552495,
-0.0279167257,
-0.0602261908,
0.0726910457,
0.0091278125,
-0.0292177591,
0.05095575,
-0.0091432426,
-0.0461399183,
0.0429185554,
0.0197512414,
0.0088873776,
-0.0445627496,
-0.012360747,
-0.0183541961,
0.0556486398,
0.0567066669,
0.043855343,
0.0345619172,
-0.0579633638,
-0.0400007777,
-0.0035883507,
-0.0227142759,
0.0422548391,
0.0108808773,
0.042862352,
0.0700514913,
0.0012338334,
-0.0430899002,
0.0159152709,
-0.0442033596,
-0.0071567157,
-0.0022386704,
0.0057979594,
0.0196586717,
0.0468180627,
0.0063210516,
0.004708244,
0.0216237884,
-0.0132903811,
-0.0282787513,
0.0335243121,
-0.092114903,
-0.0671551824,
0.0438694283,
-0.023940647,
0.0243226606,
-0.0329762287,
-0.0483694337,
-0.0850025788,
-0.0268961228,
0.0018738819,
0.0241610892,
-0.0536062047,
0.0339343287,
0.022300005,
0.0104120281,
-0.0385054015,
0.0639503151,
-0.0153952036,
-0.0043876381,
0.0141423596,
0.0105207721,
0.0358308479,
-0.0261868741,
-0.0374739468,
0.0305017494,
0.0297611188,
0.0563808903,
0.0184629802,
0.0385032706,
-0.0244436227,
-0.0329126976,
-0.0590677224,
0.0367870666,
-0.0179677326,
0.0241052229,
0.0370980985,
0.0350872763,
-0.0084213708,
-0.0086569143,
-0.0471577123,
0.0210748222,
0.0131306052,
0.0011904903,
0.0021760319,
0.0111619988,
0.0216307398,
-0.0521907397,
-0.0113120936,
-0.0037778902,
0.0057976507,
-0.0157381203,
-0.0505371392,
-0.0670458823,
0.03634708,
-0.0248194952,
0.0391324051,
-0.0155214621,
-0.0437081382,
-0.0030066173,
-0.0423439927,
0.0363809429,
-0.0090912664,
-0.0079007661,
-0.0159580391,
0.0235055629,
-0.0279036798,
-0.0608689114,
0.0183888916,
-0.03179444,
0.0243900195,
-0.0232240651,
0.005266007,
0.010096522,
0.0453169905,
-0.0006923603,
0.0056279697,
-0.053966064,
-0.0241359193,
0.008820571,
0.0021717316,
-0.0057376442,
0.0053573386,
-0.0020296508,
-0.0136092063,
-0.0314715952,
-0.0576698296,
0.0423236601,
-0.086352326,
0.0101587242,
-0.0853869319,
-0.0322932899,
-0.0320926458,
0.0063738464,
0.0133831101,
0.0252217371,
-0.0616602674,
-0.0112071177,
-0.0291535426,
0.026625894,
-0.04669936,
-0.0318947136,
0.065471977,
-0.022561267,
-0.000603423,
-0.0337226056,
0.0053491821,
-0.0365063287,
-0.0121537317,
-0.0209230836,
0.0103550293,
-0.0010529254,
-0.009042535,
0.0040388592,
0.0299137495,
0.0048605949,
0.0747641921,
0.0044985027,
0.0266565606,
-0.0331756957,
0.0103210034,
-0.0072223139,
0.0012920942,
0.0010581687,
-0.0081256926,
0.0124495896,
-0.0117907636,
-0.0144164925,
-0.0227386151,
-0.0646415949,
-0.022800399,
0.0371716842,
-0.0060218391,
-0.0443889499,
-0.0189599767,
0.0087523907,
-0.0609894171,
0.0113169905,
0.1092742532,
0.0215262044,
-0.0748824477,
-0.0312082097,
0.0164343957,
-0.001999821,
0.0105428696,
0.0444451645,
-0.0382408239,
-0.0216471739,
-0.0274484102,
0.0103891175,
0.0406304523,
0.0284786001,
-0.0597067028,
-0.0831568092,
-0.0279920176,
0.0685189739,
-0.0552068502,
-0.0501580574,
-0.007434811,
-0.0399697423,
-0.0187323336,
0.0516818985,
-0.0115388585,
0.0234511979,
-0.00240563,
0.0113604851,
0.038531296,
-0.0851305351,
-0.0080985287,
-0.0641835406,
0.0278137382,
0.0888597742,
0.0120667135,
-0.0321411341,
-0.0264411215,
0.0637623072,
-0.0336086228,
0.0039951308,
-0.0149614029,
-0.0186029021,
-0.0262292717,
-0.0059877117,
0.0279896595,
-0.0058825021,
-0.0491925776,
0.0344560519,
0.0066356738,
0.0666591972,
-0.031650532,
0.0391588882,
0.0071600564,
-0.0169126559,
-0.0124534117,
0.056200169,
0.0151172392,
-0.0283548236,
0.0246668756,
-0.0031199499,
-0.0078437403,
-0.0195777137,
0.0099314665,
0.0214388482,
-0.0113964314,
-0.0012578974,
-0.0606593713,
-0.068563126,
-0.0128548788,
0.0369760692,
0.0265292469,
0.0261347666,
0.0205119792,
-0.0206669066,
-0.0190275013,
0.0701777488,
-0.0198099315,
-0.0088052964,
-0.0664510578,
0.0306492485,
0.0224744584,
-0.0496513247,
0.0215540566,
0.0263137147,
-0.0821479484,
-0.0675601885,
-0.0277845804,
0.0584757961,
0.0182806905,
0.0624140762,
-0.0376235284,
-0.0227400865,
0.0420974828,
0.0469395183,
0.009160229,
-0.0317712091,
0.0035561493,
-0.000067345,
-0.0135186799,
0.001406882,
0.0105788345,
-0.0053186202,
-0.0003553955,
0.0517044961,
0.002751247,
-0.0509743579,
0.0338653512,
-0.0140398089,
0.0894573554,
-0.0331798345,
0.0149836941,
-0.0446984395,
0.0138536375,
-0.0378035419,
0.000810769,
-0.0625481308,
-0.04525695,
0.0371998809,
0.0141059989,
-0.0085799079,
-0.0285934675,
0.0117865345,
-0.0064938017,
-0.0013326422,
-0.0196090434,
-0.0196284559,
-0.0023367025,
-0.0009148555,
0.0167762637,
-0.0034264664,
0.0415104218,
-0.0111675588,
-0.0084007131,
-0.0740732104,
0.0704381987,
-0.0064613125,
0.0047038351,
-0.0032323704,
0.0783539638,
-0.000450395,
-0.0234534349,
-0.0259937402,
0.0000886787,
0.0831781402,
-0.0248064324,
0.1136177257,
-0.0034685484,
-0.0111462111,
-0.0012065266,
0.038153436,
0.0335031934,
0.0019395263,
0.0548510663,
-0.007676586,
-0.0061453884,
0.0019529408,
0.0391652957,
-0.0257522278,
-0.0259401985,
-0.0077514909,
-0.0077630533,
0.0219886843,
0.0178401992,
0.0072327801,
-0.0072250334,
-0.0623439923,
-0.00939677,
-0.0138959028,
-0.0512336269,
-0.0118954703,
0.0141582824,
-0.0117873205,
0.0034256075,
0.0316875987,
0.0845221803,
-0.0437662676,
-0.0048839482,
-0.0083247619,
0.0004591683,
0.0392808467,
-0.0334630795,
-0.008704545,
-6.75709932e-33,
-0.0521870926,
0.0175871272,
0.0356668867,
-0.0057573123,
-0.0431112312,
0.014837631,
-0.0177562479,
-0.0233819019,
-0.003543938,
-0.0324274562,
0.0139954919,
0.0104278205,
0.0211276878,
0.0175255258,
-0.0305983964,
0.0137839662,
0.058238972,
0.0094165709,
0.0026108075,
0.0018322819,
0.0244339369,
0.0320217907,
0.0964397416,
-0.062498223,
-0.00164015,
-0.003928374,
0.0165427756,
0.0347186811,
-0.0064387624,
0.0075591751,
-0.0134302741,
0.0184359252,
0.0273906514,
-0.0250838604,
-0.0156262331,
0.0067594438,
-0.0639925897,
-0.0299573112,
0.0213787127,
0.0374403708,
-0.0209203307,
-0.0201981403,
0.0905827954,
-0.0377980433,
-0.0042591426,
-0.009528148,
-0.0032225004,
-0.018160319,
-0.016616255,
0.0040026167,
-0.0459556468,
0.0295657609,
0.0407494344,
0.0188613515,
0.0557953976,
0.0324908569,
-0.016868433,
0.0320659094,
-0.1512899995,
-0.0240630284,
0.0032551996,
0.0431535244,
0.0835315809,
0.0393995568,
-0.0068572182,
-0.0049181716,
0.0403079875,
0.0024724205,
0.0260511264,
0.013148061,
0.0594905205,
-0.0076249759,
0.064314954,
-0.008138068,
0.0158884712,
0.0171185937,
-0.0497371294,
0.0445688739,
-0.0064491946,
-0.0263133831,
0.0240231659,
0.0022311183,
-0.0124749439,
-0.0102054756,
-0.0434210375,
-0.0435190201,
-0.0195008349,
-0.0623987466,
-0.0006905098,
0.0190222263,
-0.0134348059,
-0.0074374788,
0.0593576394,
-0.0155017059,
0.0248869229,
-0.0072827763,
-0.033209119,
-0.0342178717,
-0.0257777441,
0.069108665,
-0.0276893545,
-0.0638116971,
-0.0200280249,
0.0142932795,
-0.0092957746,
-0.0177533496,
0.0280602556,
0.042645961,
-0.0230917167,
0.0045234002,
-0.0387928523,
-0.0281235389,
-0.0021319001,
0.0323795825,
0.0305159651,
0.0028890865,
-0.000718209,
0.0272711739,
0.0558585525,
-0.0208456106,
-0.0108566536,
-0.0220793355,
0.0370803587,
0.0582880676,
-0.0052923821,
0.0374977179,
-0.0209709983,
-0.0027291426,
0.0332444198,
-0.0452788025,
-0.0149750821,
0.0011790515,
2.926e-7,
0.0627238378,
0.0165954717,
-0.0030264698,
-0.0060571199,
0.0035186703,
0.0091251051,
-0.0356912725,
0.0440327786,
0.0128612416,
0.0367954187,
0.0341459997,
0.0085717728,
0.0488765351,
0.0242595095,
-0.0460193418,
-0.0478970967,
-0.0202229079,
0.036883492,
-0.0600159131,
0.0009809108,
0.0502884351,
0.1050627828,
0.0125077413,
-0.0148210879,
-0.0164459664,
-0.0345704146,
0.0724329054,
-0.016174091,
-0.0239527617,
-0.0044733188,
0.0253332593,
0.0457816869,
-0.0340088345,
0.0097091962,
-0.0501755625,
0.0504959486,
0.0391686782,
0.0820744187,
0.0015140213,
0.0082895774,
0.045518592,
-0.0124028139,
-0.0177168604,
-0.0694693699,
0.0569495447,
-0.0648777708,
-0.0127726421,
0.0119432909,
-0.0270078368,
0.0008090229,
0.0329105854,
-0.0143316016,
-0.0406289175,
0.0119350525,
0.0463513136,
-0.0175313111,
-0.022355495,
-0.0519003235,
-0.0523012839,
-0.0011801396,
-0.0152673982,
-0.0097261043,
-0.0239706226,
-0.019083621,
0.0195315424,
0.018118374,
0.0163637325,
3.015793435e-34,
0.0129257552,
-0.0372148491,
0.0380022936,
-0.0312087554,
0.0177385062,
-0.0025213475,
-0.0431894101,
-0.0022780381,
-0.0365913212,
-0.0515350699,
-0.0331031382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19677v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19677v2 | MoCa: Measuring Human-Language Model Alignment on Causal and Moral Judgment Tasks | 2023-10-30T15:57:32 | 2023-10-31T06:36:13 | Allen Nie, Yuhui Zhang, Atharva Amdekar, Chris Piech, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Tobias Gerstenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human commonsense understanding of the physical and social world is organized
around intuitive theories. These theories support making causal and moral
judgments. When something bad happens, we naturally ask: who did what, and why?
A rich literature in cognitive science has studied people's causal and moral
intuitions. This work has revealed a number of factors that systematically
influence people's judgments, such as the violation of norms and whether the
harm is avoidable or inevitable. We collected a dataset of stories from 24
cognitive science papers and developed a system to annotate each story with the
factors they investigated. Using this dataset, we test whether large language
models (LLMs) make causal and moral judgments about text-based scenarios that
align with those of human participants. On the aggregate level, alignment has
improved with more recent LLMs. However, using statistical analyses, we find
that LLMs weigh the different factors quite differently from human
participants. These results show how curated, challenge datasets combined with
insights from cognitive science can help us go beyond comparisons based merely
on aggregate metrics: we uncover LLMs implicit tendencies and show to what
extent these align with human intuitions. | [
0.0365810841,
0.0857032016,
-0.0187590457,
-0.000386004,
-0.0724791437,
0.0215627849,
0.0108583551,
-0.0053336164,
0.0432813242,
-0.0571401492,
0.0065976102,
-0.0059102974,
0.0074903248,
0.0018903814,
0.0193765108,
0.0033547918,
0.0041756663,
0.0018204845,
0.0780169889,
0.0068022665,
-0.0012835006,
0.0417171866,
0.014477971,
0.0150532061,
0.0307897273,
-0.0064677806,
0.0244257525,
-0.0121732773,
0.0379169919,
-0.0284945518,
-0.0166945197,
0.0573691241,
0.0403722078,
0.0440329388,
0.0000019424,
-0.0650420338,
0.0324838236,
0.0073152687,
0.0384545065,
0.042145662,
0.0342347808,
-0.0147475284,
0.0030645763,
-0.0244458281,
-0.0153280478,
0.0434998721,
0.0182372686,
0.0545161963,
-0.0272413604,
0.049236767,
-0.0085073756,
-0.0309916325,
0.0127152,
0.0217245016,
0.0070161535,
0.0105261439,
0.0474466644,
0.0563648902,
-0.0242493171,
-0.0161524545,
0.0116906604,
-0.0064149043,
-0.0013301268,
-0.0168044977,
-0.0318935104,
0.0013669041,
-0.001525316,
-0.0185661688,
0.0052923537,
0.0764771402,
0.0555544719,
-0.0520504527,
0.0276764389,
-0.0236741472,
0.0118890349,
0.0535681769,
-0.0169791728,
0.0369614102,
-0.0077851601,
0.0007545449,
0.0301501527,
0.0356444381,
0.0140342405,
0.0671954453,
0.0565206632,
0.0616067685,
-0.0030026156,
-0.0128619596,
-0.0286875498,
0.0018514189,
-0.043040432,
-0.035613846,
-0.050766781,
-0.009323244,
-0.0223579053,
0.0229957737,
0.0106236637,
0.0439774655,
0.0534387492,
-0.075229913,
0.0391892418,
0.0547091365,
0.028300928,
0.0331852362,
0.0254484732,
0.036827378,
-0.0377956256,
0.0427414887,
-0.0097082267,
0.0591061637,
-0.0081415148,
0.0078787021,
0.0602928773,
-0.0222756863,
0.0223222096,
0.0419555083,
-0.0321427584,
-0.0259156097,
-0.051271975,
-0.0083862385,
-0.0273767896,
-0.0143062612,
-0.0025676198,
-0.0119189927,
-0.0455026962,
-0.0199568328,
-0.05213416,
0.062476214,
-0.0456282869,
0.0006152447,
-0.0093173319,
-0.0264309961,
-0.0135608986,
-0.0104222614,
-0.0050326199,
0.1041478142,
0.010827058,
0.0088658966,
-0.0271739531,
-0.0412199683,
-0.0086044176,
-0.0239098985,
-0.0604819544,
-0.0354306325,
-0.0032378884,
0.0317953266,
-0.0283680055,
-0.064864032,
0.0123900827,
0.0151847024,
-0.0742360801,
0.0172924437,
0.0158204902,
0.0158284772,
0.0123067452,
0.0173743032,
-0.0152100604,
0.0408246033,
0.0300567895,
0.0084411725,
0.015028324,
0.017917715,
-0.003707696,
-0.0052490188,
0.0090250447,
0.0347369947,
-0.0372019708,
0.0092919823,
-0.000925621,
0.0282235835,
0.0228723567,
0.0218418073,
-0.0072661424,
0.0135224788,
0.0452566259,
0.0980285481,
-0.0505560562,
0.0138951885,
0.0165490564,
-0.0300382357,
0.003721708,
0.0079767145,
-0.0402692296,
0.0094940681,
-0.0129403714,
-0.0342936367,
-0.0034193846,
0.029610984,
-0.0096059358,
0.0185410995,
-0.0398672298,
0.0162426606,
0.0404989086,
-0.021671962,
0.0020603647,
-0.0257378202,
-0.0012280111,
-0.0349293649,
0.0450641476,
-0.0570047162,
-0.0064175348,
0.0100055197,
0.0623687096,
0.0465826318,
0.0437453389,
0.0092478059,
0.0166028775,
-0.0198847838,
-0.0033192758,
-0.0003991207,
0.0136858104,
-0.0067936634,
-0.0257044118,
-0.0155674415,
-0.0241428819,
-0.009130246,
-0.0023011949,
-0.0018394741,
-0.0159413293,
-0.0233702827,
-0.0133594312,
-0.0063904426,
-0.0468687266,
0.0623596683,
-0.0243357625,
0.025762856,
-0.0959466025,
0.0048697768,
0.0455731004,
-0.0175554138,
-0.0075986465,
-0.0100157596,
0.0128879827,
0.0088126613,
-0.0321227945,
0.0796865672,
-0.0179464128,
0.0278865341,
0.023068551,
-0.0872377157,
-0.0286983382,
0.0010047007,
-0.0135978665,
0.0196316279,
0.0079531297,
-0.0112645021,
-0.0041301986,
-0.01787626,
-0.0128742065,
-0.0757151097,
-0.0442510396,
-0.0093234414,
0.0862199515,
-0.0080063306,
0.055681739,
-0.0186541565,
-0.0401838645,
0.0535485484,
0.0262568742,
-0.01493329,
-0.0224989653,
-0.005673503,
-0.0141733009,
0.0466959514,
-0.0053184275,
-0.0479943566,
0.0022213282,
-0.0367251523,
-0.0074312896,
0.0237145741,
-0.0117398677,
0.014286926,
-0.0231982451,
-0.0143266255,
0.0212465581,
0.0014045284,
-0.0093140397,
0.0041104592,
0.0392197296,
0.0217402428,
-0.0357528925,
-0.0032948148,
-0.0574273318,
0.0151464688,
-0.0797500461,
0.0468047559,
0.0669216886,
0.0083712181,
-0.0381757878,
0.0424267612,
-0.0574182048,
-0.0003171349,
-0.0022061113,
-0.0758495256,
-0.0018566804,
0.044608146,
0.0057607987,
0.0596509725,
0.0379829183,
0.0181389824,
0.0379410572,
0.0100407014,
-0.0781359226,
-0.0444074906,
-0.0207613092,
0.0063928165,
-0.0168831795,
-0.0786619261,
-0.033684779,
0.0902620181,
0.0105054239,
-0.0082678217,
-0.0361171551,
0.0256160796,
-0.0605282746,
-0.0447651222,
-0.0162617341,
-0.1011120901,
0.0021375201,
0.0621997081,
-0.0190121848,
-0.0610987991,
0.0731258541,
0.0156416204,
0.0532964803,
0.0153143583,
0.0263421759,
-0.0274047609,
0.0411302298,
0.0242734365,
0.0222882498,
0.0147350188,
-0.0013379441,
-0.0416080952,
-0.0258755013,
0.0659371689,
0.0090654092,
0.0163382664,
-0.0685490146,
0.0413788483,
0.0108187925,
-0.0531471856,
-0.0093763648,
-0.0909314677,
-0.0152133824,
-0.0357738808,
0.0223449301,
-0.0207372028,
-0.0293999333,
-0.0048113517,
0.0449495539,
-0.0279422365,
0.004587804,
0.0058312081,
-0.0035740663,
-0.0415390842,
0.0296902154,
-0.0372712798,
0.0456580073,
0.0007247075,
0.0184197258,
0.0453444943,
-0.0101909833,
0.0108009512,
0.0108237509,
0.0412899479,
0.0276431683,
0.0093477489,
0.0286356676,
0.0256232563,
0.0793610364,
0.0091032526,
0.0090186205,
0.0757380426,
0.0356974714,
-0.0447048806,
0.012518133,
-0.0116754174,
-0.0399137586,
0.0299499147,
-0.0315028131,
-0.0775143206,
-0.0103384797,
-0.0077355807,
-0.026113715,
-0.0770104006,
-0.082768932,
0.029455753,
-0.0551548488,
0.0065293401,
0.0276979934,
0.011270836,
0.0020061217,
-0.062429212,
0.0167039428,
-0.0317156948,
-0.0104215937,
0.0123483976,
0.0266398266,
-0.0142973904,
-0.0144988047,
0.0100862244,
-0.0028199828,
0.0552559495,
-0.0261569135,
0.0497828238,
0.0277381521,
0.0580411293,
-0.0272143614,
-0.0427264534,
0.0005540625,
0.0369214751,
-0.0126250731,
0.026732374,
-0.0050755385,
-0.0083831986,
0.0203577373,
-0.0644796565,
0.078119196,
0.002142862,
-0.0697661489,
-0.015694337,
0.0779681578,
0.0190816168,
-0.020373011,
-0.0168769937,
0.0016779773,
-0.0139753716,
0.0770689547,
-0.0259696674,
-0.0089417826,
0.0042426195,
-0.0269546974,
-0.0514073782,
0.0120055499,
-0.0722193941,
-0.016041588,
0.0237755813,
-0.0347941592,
-0.034242101,
-0.0306447577,
-0.0286005493,
-0.0451728627,
0.0694322288,
-0.0370254107,
0.0398276709,
-0.0097272051,
-0.0514773987,
0.0397958085,
-0.0143062519,
0.0020935675,
0.0355811827,
0.0603874177,
-0.0111383209,
-0.0073756161,
-0.017487213,
0.006548964,
-0.0262715742,
-0.070244737,
0.0093002478,
-0.0068083792,
0.0141820358,
0.0258656628,
-0.017537592,
-0.0125618065,
-0.0120394919,
0.0158956479,
-0.0794748515,
0.0325571522,
-0.016487876,
0.0023997673,
0.0272285473,
0.0082934499,
-0.0200136397,
-0.0006924739,
0.0171890147,
0.0244338717,
-0.0478521362,
-0.0181972366,
0.0577943996,
-0.0040363586,
0.0360492729,
-0.051323019,
-0.012566532,
-0.0360547863,
-0.0478903651,
-0.0160237625,
-0.0499789007,
-0.0031905952,
0.0114687392,
0.0618231632,
-0.0186240058,
-0.0515338667,
0.0031053131,
-0.0711907819,
0.0258649811,
-0.0148744816,
0.0129016172,
0.0263811667,
0.0483893342,
0.015400866,
-0.0229985118,
-0.0192470979,
-0.0034562426,
-0.0640679225,
0.0278954711,
-0.0103837596,
0.0664499626,
0.0416282117,
0.037924163,
0.00266138,
-0.0343181714,
-0.0884205028,
-0.0139286239,
-0.0139014591,
-0.0312730297,
0.0075533339,
-0.0054550874,
0.0361369699,
-0.0090992656,
0.0083371755,
0.0052906969,
0.0461001955,
-0.0222654566,
-0.0063917381,
0.0254512914,
0.0023103592,
-0.0442837998,
0.0285570361,
0.0562067181,
-0.0508565009,
0.0147193838,
-0.0005887651,
-0.0453471616,
0.0291908588,
-0.0355189107,
0.0489956699,
0.0041959197,
-0.0075423624,
-0.0234818701,
-0.0983014107,
-0.012924334,
-0.035830494,
0.0161861163,
-0.0024966584,
-0.0212521665,
-0.0499775447,
0.0631935224,
-0.013456705,
0.0164962765,
-0.0089946035,
0.0473960415,
-0.0656517968,
-0.0011388136,
-0.0836053118,
-5.712434551e-33,
-0.019257687,
-0.0421120375,
-0.0405418351,
0.0094720777,
-0.0055284244,
-0.0201271251,
-0.0316840671,
0.0210183337,
-0.0389478169,
0.06672737,
0.0217997022,
0.0293083768,
-0.0020538087,
-0.031255208,
0.0425536297,
-0.0354044177,
-0.0329377912,
0.0129604246,
-0.0458933376,
-0.0120873917,
0.0151964445,
-0.0318372101,
0.0173718128,
-0.0786700547,
0.0879462138,
0.0130286943,
0.0021691201,
-0.0243334901,
-0.0286543015,
0.0024972176,
-0.0124033727,
0.0458192937,
0.0257874373,
-0.0100147687,
0.0286854077,
0.0621446967,
0.0300939698,
-0.0045962925,
0.1143730283,
-0.0199922547,
-0.0320684537,
-0.0428461954,
-0.0129688242,
0.0073232567,
-0.0603803694,
0.0139426421,
0.0715069398,
-0.01178932,
0.0218353011,
-0.0274157412,
-0.0632001087,
-0.0082101468,
-0.0504136235,
0.0101928879,
-0.077562727,
0.0332935266,
0.0040367302,
0.076613009,
-0.0400700569,
0.0472939722,
-0.0306409094,
-0.0261969827,
0.0090504903,
-0.046562653,
0.0329795405,
0.1008069441,
-0.0421364941,
0.0152422795,
-0.0665798411,
0.0078288401,
0.0089195911,
0.0115982769,
0.0233568903,
0.1019255444,
0.0166080408,
-0.0283196364,
-0.0581122227,
-0.0077621532,
0.0270580519,
0.0092350803,
0.0489401072,
0.0040307962,
-0.038733758,
-0.0151513778,
-0.0420278646,
-0.0501555763,
-0.0299980249,
-0.0008118703,
0.00175776,
-0.0450692326,
-0.0021108659,
-0.0388749428,
-0.014204232,
-0.0198633354,
0.0040030619,
0.0338743441,
-0.0261432268,
-0.0138968257,
-0.0105666909,
0.0398726277,
-0.0754002407,
-0.0077448431,
-0.0120115932,
0.0391299501,
0.0704552308,
0.0115915118,
0.0595408902,
-0.0238383319,
0.0188710093,
-0.0224938579,
-0.0430417843,
-0.0488734692,
0.0021654491,
-0.0557956696,
0.0350717343,
0.0498044826,
0.010151593,
-0.0506298281,
0.0303763021,
-0.0056818272,
-0.0033770662,
-0.0327378623,
-0.0239396971,
0.0215862021,
-0.0080713322,
-0.0102387946,
-0.0264224261,
0.0125274276,
0.0197011027,
-0.0389802605,
-0.0157657769,
0.0500671156,
2.605e-7,
0.0338613614,
0.0319996849,
-0.0092487223,
0.0205626152,
-0.0102066481,
0.0639681518,
0.0248852987,
0.0330596827,
0.0751297027,
-0.0236574523,
0.0063375109,
-0.0056927013,
0.0451953411,
0.0020358071,
0.0065645175,
0.0115803191,
-0.056735307,
-0.0403927527,
-0.0248072594,
0.027371455,
0.0770893618,
0.0005583402,
0.0442229807,
0.0173378885,
-0.0197387636,
-0.0139939347,
0.0521175861,
-0.0793127939,
0.0052709589,
-0.0005900596,
-0.0448282398,
-0.0143201761,
-0.0113640605,
0.032745298,
0.0187076647,
-0.0165487956,
-0.0037366673,
0.0186834168,
-0.0113774696,
-0.0021994987,
-0.0442402288,
-0.0505494401,
0.0017289204,
-0.0617355332,
0.0648917258,
-0.0358153768,
-0.0420333035,
0.0247221347,
0.0198839195,
-0.007127902,
0.0134567767,
0.0244676042,
-0.0073761418,
0.0143450415,
0.0220799409,
0.0218199007,
0.0110168234,
-0.0376121476,
-0.0583475046,
0.0289056171,
0.0211147256,
-0.0789499804,
-0.0039800261,
0.0196602661,
0.0332236588,
-0.070142962,
0.0168285128,
2.237882497e-34,
0.0049792794,
-0.0121992035,
0.0081863068,
-0.0090462053,
0.0413004756,
0.0203965623,
-0.0111093912,
0.0122920666,
0.0405756198,
-0.0463509597,
0.0063425102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19671v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19671v2 | Large Language Models: The Need for Nuance in Current Debates and a Pragmatic Perspective on Understanding | 2023-10-30T15:51:04 | 2023-10-31T08:17:29 | Bram M. A. van Dijk, Tom Kouwenhoven, Marco R. Spruit, Max J. van Duijn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current Large Language Models (LLMs) are unparalleled in their ability to
generate grammatically correct, fluent text. LLMs are appearing rapidly, and
debates on LLM capacities have taken off, but reflection is lagging behind.
Thus, in this position paper, we first zoom in on the debate and critically
assess three points recurring in critiques of LLM capacities: i) that LLMs only
parrot statistical patterns in the training data; ii) that LLMs master formal
but not functional language competence; and iii) that language learning in LLMs
cannot inform human language learning. Drawing on empirical and theoretical
arguments, we show that these points need more nuance. Second, we outline a
pragmatic perspective on the issue of `real' understanding and intentionality
in LLMs. Understanding and intentionality pertain to unobservable mental states
we attribute to other humans because they have pragmatic value: they allow us
to abstract away from complex underlying mechanics and predict behaviour
effectively. We reflect on the circumstances under which it would make sense
for humans to similarly attribute mental states to LLMs, thereby outlining a
pragmatic philosophical context for LLMs as an increasingly prominent
technology in society. | [
0.0369619802,
0.0381625779,
-0.0533260182,
0.0122633586,
-0.0374064855,
0.0319100581,
-0.0239500236,
0.0102384677,
-0.0168215595,
-0.0425128303,
-0.0316335484,
-0.0372196957,
-0.0034461501,
-0.0057807341,
0.068942219,
-0.0599642619,
0.0057433425,
-0.05341639,
0.0023598161,
-0.0082842354,
0.0080743982,
-0.0092061525,
0.01107434,
0.0451365337,
-0.007906503,
-0.0121081751,
-0.0281365179,
-0.0198904127,
-0.0368194506,
0.0079967082,
-0.0325464383,
0.0149270706,
0.043551337,
0.0232197475,
0.0000019406,
-0.042865254,
0.0534433611,
-0.0425111577,
-0.0249093249,
0.0334463418,
0.0311940331,
0.0106544448,
-0.0098370491,
-0.0048560603,
-0.052664239,
0.0063510374,
0.008028469,
0.0056072972,
-0.0157464035,
0.0416852944,
0.01238144,
-0.0218872018,
0.0400317796,
-0.0086870771,
-0.0038851157,
-0.0075531849,
0.0351435728,
0.0349699967,
0.0246205702,
0.0069358749,
-0.0603809357,
0.046085149,
0.0275110696,
-0.0053789043,
-0.0328542627,
0.0146917207,
0.0263936464,
-0.0680729523,
-0.0026455517,
0.0237377118,
0.0443022512,
-0.0311845876,
0.0087845605,
0.0003200059,
0.0083828568,
0.0262763351,
-0.0462343991,
0.0663951859,
0.000661884,
0.0513107106,
0.0433821082,
-0.0607235134,
0.028206706,
0.0293418635,
-0.0069825682,
0.0652026087,
-0.0307041556,
-0.0202355217,
0.0013040365,
0.0436272994,
-0.0034190421,
-0.0369627737,
-0.0326683186,
0.0354497917,
-0.0066674063,
0.0458315611,
-0.0249195732,
0.0187178757,
0.0196859371,
-0.0318492018,
0.0443319418,
0.0103963893,
-0.0163763501,
-0.0052891597,
0.0116383964,
0.0374770425,
-0.0157800745,
0.0457932837,
-0.0384583399,
0.0268628094,
-0.0467571169,
-0.0463660546,
-0.0200443901,
0.0022353204,
-0.0058673737,
0.0207616743,
-0.0131551381,
0.0091990018,
-0.0221023988,
0.0053786691,
-0.0418300964,
-0.01346415,
-0.0137442742,
-0.0130409067,
-0.0297243241,
0.0175421815,
-0.0172249079,
0.0519841835,
-0.0115229273,
-0.0829321593,
0.0246241409,
0.0235832371,
-0.0171314888,
0.0032034887,
-0.0134421345,
0.0422083251,
0.0048179971,
-0.0452973247,
-0.0215005241,
-0.0362172835,
-0.0187989473,
-0.0738512725,
0.026672069,
-0.0329819322,
-0.0326797068,
0.0424194261,
-0.0027238124,
-0.0971283242,
0.0018653423,
-0.0077797421,
-0.0235051792,
0.0214754567,
-0.0189745184,
0.0528992377,
0.0179737005,
-0.001234146,
0.0082387961,
0.0597037598,
0.0324554108,
-0.044598259,
-0.0178114735,
-0.0146821793,
0.0072462573,
0.0341631584,
-0.0074717603,
-0.0191796944,
-0.0626351908,
-0.012175505,
-0.018463403,
0.0250876807,
0.0669752434,
0.0441931039,
-0.0054130293,
0.0360266641,
0.0660655573,
0.0495397374,
-0.0010589957,
0.0360775962,
0.0614410713,
0.0222713184,
0.0397258513,
0.0493928753,
-0.012155233,
0.0018748875,
-0.0179446749,
-0.0127344066,
-0.0113556422,
-0.0014226973,
-0.0283403546,
-0.0325271674,
-0.0152709056,
-0.0139560131,
0.01748823,
0.0322555676,
0.0462005995,
-0.0046179984,
0.0100997994,
0.022893995,
0.0511547551,
-0.0131549099,
0.02587221,
-0.0650317892,
0.0448451228,
0.0430133604,
0.013282151,
0.0134903854,
0.0075013842,
0.0026097361,
0.0259199794,
0.0678792745,
0.0283915177,
-0.0112853944,
-0.0246301405,
-0.0137516158,
0.0147854313,
-0.01132596,
0.0091705341,
-0.0222786162,
-0.0379793718,
-0.0126997083,
-0.0160911717,
0.0073903147,
-0.0585497208,
0.0433275849,
-0.0719989836,
-0.0059211957,
-0.069404982,
0.0041915481,
0.0210402738,
-0.0073015015,
-0.0254312959,
0.0207193736,
0.0199878048,
-0.028859552,
0.023743473,
0.0447694659,
-0.0366677009,
0.0244368035,
0.0326535031,
-0.0196778681,
0.0043853284,
0.0022213482,
0.0177197177,
-0.0244178548,
0.0255622584,
-0.0583432876,
0.0484515876,
-0.0299602561,
0.0183098447,
-0.0335852839,
-0.0004198144,
-0.032078594,
0.0557998605,
0.0011995964,
0.0136840641,
0.0068551446,
-0.0131007191,
-0.0109195774,
-0.0354794711,
-0.0317120105,
0.0395707451,
0.0221991278,
0.0211175028,
-0.0137979938,
0.0078238975,
-0.0672773868,
-0.0204927493,
-0.0693337619,
-0.0496692173,
0.0043699061,
0.0032494001,
0.0404403247,
-0.0456686728,
-0.0205483865,
0.0213287473,
-0.0158522595,
0.0032673441,
0.0241619721,
0.0170197841,
0.0229811352,
0.0105893854,
-0.0400038324,
-0.0044722003,
0.0226496756,
-0.0196535233,
0.0084757181,
0.0183439646,
0.0174577422,
-0.0811371505,
0.0516198762,
-0.0217706114,
-0.0178791489,
-0.0125899194,
-0.0347368009,
0.0348999612,
0.0335591547,
0.0195628423,
0.0491631329,
-0.0032116438,
0.0456026532,
0.0312279388,
-0.0056835981,
-0.0336337239,
-0.0124850245,
-0.0083962865,
-0.0219638627,
-0.0651397556,
-0.0627521798,
-0.0604386777,
0.0735420212,
0.0307699498,
0.0278537348,
-0.039801918,
0.0605255216,
-0.0554556549,
-0.0508331284,
-0.0305569135,
-0.0262498036,
-0.0539088994,
0.037341021,
-0.0256675612,
-0.0625702143,
0.0569413789,
0.0118902475,
-0.018504668,
0.0008149879,
-0.0104693733,
0.0033151738,
0.0573655739,
0.0149486586,
0.0264459047,
0.0039291447,
-0.0125120739,
-0.068978183,
-0.0184551831,
-0.0171452165,
-0.0332019068,
0.0546463095,
-0.0693465993,
0.0084659113,
0.0264046472,
-0.0228236374,
-0.020617472,
-0.0381435566,
-0.0854044035,
0.0119492896,
0.0004920827,
-0.0093602659,
0.003479115,
-0.0144224428,
0.0657974035,
-0.0137455082,
0.0043194327,
-0.0082510356,
-0.0119146984,
-0.0347824469,
0.0357483365,
0.0190932434,
0.0473096073,
-0.0535522848,
0.0259190984,
0.0632483587,
0.0075615318,
0.0452460311,
-0.005469433,
0.0223802328,
0.0362221561,
0.0010309526,
-0.0590749457,
0.0471257456,
0.0999142155,
-0.0481984392,
-0.038092725,
0.0990032032,
-0.0040753125,
-0.0087909382,
0.037616156,
-0.0283289533,
0.0164460577,
0.0068322299,
0.0159545094,
-0.0331731997,
0.0010848634,
-0.0012556138,
0.0236456897,
-0.0728174895,
-0.0340430178,
-0.0015068311,
-0.0663826466,
0.0262814891,
0.0161081664,
-0.0268290918,
0.0326468162,
-0.0215996634,
-0.0004547738,
0.0567279235,
0.0353268236,
0.0303958021,
-0.0433629937,
0.0092538819,
0.0575711243,
-0.0421705879,
-0.0558505282,
0.0170580465,
-0.0220829342,
0.0818356201,
0.0372339711,
0.0325873569,
-0.0309173819,
-0.0605075173,
0.035295438,
0.0144358454,
0.0329244398,
0.0074502104,
-0.0105267344,
0.0297854133,
-0.01096744,
-0.0779269189,
0.0480668098,
-0.0437317714,
-0.0210103728,
0.009916652,
0.1065163463,
-0.0296099149,
-0.0294151232,
0.010201185,
0.0116994167,
-0.0256479811,
0.061347954,
0.0595103763,
-0.0818720236,
-0.0063290587,
-0.0401371419,
-0.005203648,
0.0409695581,
-0.0825421661,
0.0414083004,
0.0289040413,
-0.0028637869,
-0.0361309201,
-0.0631277636,
0.0361757204,
0.0264531542,
0.0382516012,
0.0139515288,
0.0162121858,
-0.0210913364,
0.0026567944,
0.02057424,
-0.0285888519,
-0.0099753672,
-0.0795377716,
-0.0288997665,
0.0173852798,
-0.0612326898,
0.0065729576,
-0.0521060042,
-0.0495301895,
-0.0819160044,
0.0356549509,
0.0297437962,
0.0341781154,
-0.00028886,
0.0446297191,
-0.1064786017,
0.0161949117,
0.008470498,
-0.0331003442,
0.0799931809,
-0.0100292806,
-0.0051567615,
0.0211079456,
0.0563208908,
0.0131314378,
-0.0072679813,
0.002484685,
0.0121481512,
-0.0229095407,
-0.0032878311,
0.0507562384,
0.0222370438,
0.040726997,
-0.0466764048,
-0.0319111682,
-0.0323633999,
-0.0433040559,
-0.0133900288,
-0.0009322555,
-0.0392522477,
-0.0198042635,
0.0290358569,
0.0498682782,
-0.0152559746,
-0.0463835858,
-0.033892639,
0.0535730347,
0.007483033,
0.043421939,
-0.011363171,
0.0178889725,
0.0131807942,
0.0132938372,
0.0119254272,
0.0415829495,
-0.0495412908,
0.0385091268,
0.0520916916,
0.0719748586,
0.0198450703,
0.0026322703,
0.0167362355,
-0.0243086461,
-0.0303046536,
-0.1143565327,
0.0419608913,
0.0248251446,
0.0683748871,
-0.0346516483,
0.0623279214,
-0.0607596673,
0.033427339,
-0.0143625848,
0.0144160697,
-0.0213304348,
-0.0687373206,
0.0309185516,
0.002698868,
-0.0362212323,
-0.0202692635,
0.0728241354,
-0.0017298154,
0.0631338581,
-0.0066525224,
0.0095455945,
-0.0057799583,
-0.0419949926,
0.0004370512,
-0.0117619913,
-0.0235832669,
0.0361616462,
-0.0848438591,
-0.0564009324,
-0.0292460788,
0.016903827,
-0.0135697378,
-0.1112797931,
0.0213125441,
0.0301744845,
-0.0268128924,
-0.0012232778,
-0.0634184703,
0.0363928042,
0.0286398213,
0.0189217255,
-0.0339159667,
-6.226540679e-33,
-0.0216608196,
-0.0512379631,
0.027952455,
-0.0194652136,
-0.0257288013,
-0.0195132773,
-0.0296648685,
0.0654408261,
-0.0299270656,
0.0416732021,
-0.0127447918,
-0.0172613412,
0.0020657498,
0.0216637161,
0.0475158356,
-0.0085568745,
0.0032307003,
-0.0133160055,
0.0280403849,
-0.0179123264,
0.0231523681,
0.0111300461,
0.0653648674,
-0.0428395793,
0.0545059405,
-0.0176213756,
0.0195170585,
0.0185889751,
-0.0114914756,
0.0100255497,
-0.0109801069,
0.0588718541,
0.0432559326,
0.0051776306,
-0.0221684705,
0.0097390478,
0.0156188244,
-0.0319996551,
0.0753633305,
0.0410593301,
-0.0045408835,
-0.0251182914,
0.0614090748,
-0.0239961706,
-0.0719668791,
0.0463442355,
0.0164704546,
-0.0256072208,
-0.0052980059,
0.0015916621,
-0.0542838983,
0.0024937137,
0.0065507265,
-0.0045591923,
0.0178157594,
-0.0015954776,
-0.0447118841,
-0.0321837217,
-0.0683496818,
0.0169204343,
-0.0172454137,
0.0153734991,
0.0744467825,
0.0195990466,
0.0542684682,
0.072142154,
0.0605712645,
0.0210609734,
-0.025052106,
0.0008146143,
0.0657019243,
0.0357258469,
-0.0212935749,
0.0155027062,
-0.0151089989,
-0.0255135708,
-0.0422605313,
-0.053022597,
0.01643252,
0.0323604904,
0.0211062208,
-0.0080675846,
-0.0418728963,
-0.0552103333,
-0.0287246536,
0.0068972055,
0.0094716772,
-0.0336310863,
0.0067158327,
-0.0519615337,
0.0182798635,
-0.0480464883,
0.007942996,
-0.0385164134,
-0.0363664739,
-0.0247753933,
-0.0434766822,
0.0443716012,
0.0091519868,
0.0344917998,
-0.0693728924,
-0.0556669272,
-0.0523353629,
-0.0023012098,
0.0122615267,
0.0467940196,
-0.0002729946,
0.0314157866,
-0.0071079005,
-0.0054736687,
-0.0553806834,
-0.0007288382,
0.0336230062,
-0.0305956956,
0.0971185267,
0.0100306254,
-0.0187068637,
-0.0042345333,
0.0056104022,
-0.0337877981,
-0.0164603516,
0.020815663,
-0.0323009193,
0.0231583621,
-0.045330368,
-0.033856418,
-0.0613513254,
0.0290310737,
0.0827509314,
-0.0452972725,
-0.0001884393,
0.0089590624,
2.76e-7,
0.0194217786,
0.0458654016,
-0.0268712472,
-0.0095665902,
0.0376147889,
0.0373504423,
-0.0430320315,
0.0000287343,
0.0221661199,
-0.0122554237,
-0.0082587935,
0.0326171741,
0.0547917485,
0.0133147091,
-0.0529418811,
-0.0183983948,
-0.0320645161,
0.048454538,
-0.0415634513,
0.0331530236,
0.0213227924,
0.0396346822,
0.0203365795,
-0.0190757643,
-0.0292817559,
-0.0299841799,
0.0696298331,
-0.0539397374,
0.0285560153,
0.0105049415,
0.0397480913,
0.0241444018,
0.0201729778,
0.0282389633,
0.0381093062,
0.0078949397,
-0.0399151184,
0.0881207213,
0.0275329612,
0.0185444467,
0.0107451137,
-0.0113729378,
-0.0283234082,
-0.0631635785,
0.0510476641,
-0.0662076548,
-0.0523381196,
0.0116795758,
0.0022487852,
-0.0227189977,
-0.0245832335,
0.0001446448,
0.0047429041,
0.0363146253,
0.0212688334,
-0.0707817301,
0.0177026335,
-0.0106104352,
-0.0260344185,
0.0004102424,
-0.0432469174,
-0.0433419943,
-0.0418518931,
0.040077135,
0.0125852367,
-0.0484406278,
0.0062685264,
2.230664227e-34,
-0.0021089832,
0.0048341202,
0.0465371646,
0.0137012424,
0.0065656402,
0.0171933342,
0.0093394388,
0.0556661896,
0.0230878182,
-0.0530757271,
-0.0034025393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19660v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19660v2 | Interpretable-by-Design Text Understanding with Iteratively Generated Concept Bottleneck | 2023-10-30T15:41:32 | 2024-04-03T14:29:03 | Josh Magnus Ludan, Qing Lyu, Yue Yang, Liam Dugan, Mark Yatskar, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Black-box deep neural networks excel in text classification, yet their
application in high-stakes domains is hindered by their lack of
interpretability. To address this, we propose Text Bottleneck Models (TBM), an
intrinsically interpretable text classification framework that offers both
global and local explanations. Rather than directly predicting the output
label, TBM predicts categorical values for a sparse set of salient concepts and
uses a linear layer over those concept values to produce the final prediction.
These concepts can be automatically discovered and measured by a Large Language
Model (LLM) without the need for human curation. Experiments on 12 diverse text
understanding datasets demonstrate that TBM can rival the performance of
black-box baselines such as few-shot GPT-4 and finetuned DeBERTa while falling
short against finetuned GPT-3.5. Comprehensive human evaluation validates that
TBM can generate high-quality concepts relevant to the task, and the concept
measurement aligns well with human judgments, suggesting that the predictions
made by TBMs are interpretable. Overall, our findings suggest that TBM is a
promising new framework that enhances interpretability with minimal performance
tradeoffs. | [
0.0369861349,
0.0432234593,
0.0048650424,
0.0370163396,
0.0038330816,
0.0192162376,
0.0286465921,
-0.0105262697,
-0.0170204137,
0.0136215957,
-0.0095116934,
-0.0164672676,
-0.0155835589,
0.0769656748,
-0.019543115,
-0.049917236,
-0.0124319624,
-0.0093030166,
0.0107186036,
0.0172536839,
0.0199266765,
0.0274891872,
0.0024852566,
0.031592235,
0.0294135287,
-0.0376024805,
-0.0166929122,
0.0109631494,
0.021074174,
-0.0285495725,
-0.0011012781,
0.0535872765,
0.0492789969,
0.0790142044,
0.0000023504,
-0.0007578367,
-0.0463190489,
-0.0164352488,
-0.1053984836,
0.0373742208,
0.0166192856,
-0.0643014982,
0.0390475988,
-0.0431215949,
0.0008210457,
-0.0127212759,
0.034529645,
0.0799751058,
0.0328130424,
0.044874765,
-0.0184186585,
-0.0279781278,
-0.0062849242,
-0.0415163301,
0.0188192651,
-0.0856224895,
-0.0074328859,
0.013875802,
-0.0245419759,
0.0375029184,
-0.0279804301,
0.0197757464,
0.0689148605,
-0.0095004011,
0.0583397225,
0.0197429042,
-0.0003155828,
-0.0340582468,
0.0005790687,
0.1085997149,
-0.0086126681,
-0.0099014016,
-0.0136048757,
-0.0314570665,
0.0021086163,
-0.0255377349,
-0.0275749713,
-0.0286842249,
0.0005088726,
0.0097786067,
-0.0072821737,
0.0432389304,
0.0676269382,
0.0310531761,
-0.0268538967,
0.0380705521,
-0.0359117389,
-0.0056434157,
-0.0174172875,
0.0135040255,
-0.043414712,
-0.0041369903,
0.0448604785,
0.0196183361,
-0.0045039011,
0.0355020612,
-0.0120848892,
-0.0054847514,
-0.0021954151,
-0.0492634028,
0.0434856266,
0.0236193333,
-0.0204868317,
0.0908222944,
-0.014991411,
0.0453404076,
-0.0296123829,
0.0026501571,
-0.0225197747,
-0.0070903096,
-0.0599963032,
-0.0226073004,
-0.0010678519,
0.0237678476,
-0.0205140542,
-0.0243803803,
-0.022287026,
-0.0065474948,
-0.0166031439,
-0.0151266148,
-0.0191905312,
0.0195835624,
-0.0268863328,
-0.0554958656,
-0.0080785565,
0.0173880048,
-0.0538230464,
0.0103672892,
-0.0180662312,
-0.0410772152,
-0.0196247175,
0.0115636326,
-0.0017593928,
-0.0151301669,
0.0126463436,
0.0421427749,
-0.0105435317,
-0.0452598967,
-0.040072687,
-0.0416374095,
-0.0116432607,
-0.0377804898,
-0.0078460518,
-0.0174799357,
-0.0088999839,
0.0021393895,
0.004273606,
-0.0767089576,
-0.0161619373,
-0.018025605,
-0.0130610764,
0.063906379,
0.0017023332,
-0.0224193484,
0.0306998082,
0.0438091271,
-0.003058732,
0.0730025321,
0.0119712809,
0.0879806653,
0.0140682952,
-0.0236944519,
0.0007884962,
0.0212716274,
0.0511119291,
0.0083347335,
-0.0491519012,
0.0018772122,
-0.020287713,
0.0243181176,
0.0587928183,
-0.0213122535,
-0.0187748279,
0.0027854668,
0.052168522,
0.031535849,
0.0222699586,
0.0472265892,
0.0126797957,
0.0505206175,
-0.0184046477,
-0.0149711827,
-0.007505232,
0.0456591547,
0.0002091315,
-0.0496032499,
0.0322034322,
-0.0068666739,
-0.0159357246,
-0.0609041899,
0.018726686,
0.0256173685,
-0.0055573191,
0.0106744999,
0.0800401419,
-0.0143901194,
-0.0401252396,
0.0213159043,
-0.007836448,
-0.0018091865,
0.0091716107,
-0.0375080854,
0.0437458903,
0.0865500197,
0.0402501002,
-0.0279113967,
0.0163681675,
-0.0031286574,
0.0257604979,
0.0648615286,
0.0111956829,
0.0158505198,
0.0455722511,
-0.0465414785,
-0.0518710651,
0.0010844882,
0.0304359179,
0.0507380515,
-0.0097369505,
-0.0032670945,
0.0327181816,
-0.0399566479,
-0.0409539938,
0.0285597574,
0.0089982683,
-0.0590039007,
0.0267621875,
-0.0044968463,
0.0322969146,
0.0206582677,
0.0015073571,
-0.0401297323,
0.007249942,
-0.0551350191,
-0.0252983347,
-0.0315501802,
-0.0569484495,
-0.0052426453,
-0.0378465764,
-0.0319354609,
-0.0219203029,
0.0316090658,
-0.0512704179,
-0.049579937,
0.0295368657,
-0.0315034017,
-0.022994807,
-0.0394592062,
-0.0477398001,
-0.0273808334,
0.0426647887,
-0.0244662743,
0.0420790873,
0.0078587923,
-0.0125050554,
-0.0168148018,
-0.0102556394,
0.0338612907,
0.0067771962,
-0.0260011312,
-0.0131137716,
-0.0085326992,
0.0096759778,
0.0055665621,
0.0147072505,
-0.0347195342,
0.0026143782,
-0.0452043451,
0.004299751,
-0.0256814267,
-0.0083179167,
0.0041026375,
-0.0026848924,
0.0072039273,
-0.0297420602,
-0.0278821886,
-0.0273727197,
-0.0245293733,
-0.0185216349,
0.010677183,
0.0248628911,
-0.0102367178,
-0.0172984228,
-0.0155085856,
0.0142531283,
0.0686824992,
0.0420753881,
0.0056586647,
-0.0326131694,
0.026511088,
0.0318352766,
-0.0039785691,
-0.0335788652,
-0.0249480661,
-0.0053905658,
-0.0271892212,
-0.0418471806,
0.0740318671,
-0.0015166355,
0.0496964045,
-0.0054450454,
0.0358804017,
-0.0658414811,
0.0018761056,
0.0037085039,
0.0220478941,
-0.0136630302,
-0.0524265654,
0.013494865,
0.0976522937,
-0.010554946,
-0.0074393069,
-0.0880520046,
0.0294482447,
-0.010714761,
-0.0229155067,
-0.1048917994,
-0.0036587629,
0.0242613126,
0.0552079156,
-0.02490413,
-0.0517743379,
0.0658636317,
-0.0138169518,
-0.006580784,
-0.008762802,
-0.0329378098,
-0.0605526902,
0.0682485402,
0.0080504455,
-0.0109477295,
0.015998451,
-0.015393476,
-0.0212839041,
0.0139423115,
-0.0212166458,
-0.0052660019,
0.0561507419,
-0.0461284369,
0.0064479746,
-0.0123647945,
-0.0257283002,
-0.0302042998,
-0.0411068723,
-0.0297337398,
-0.0077005904,
0.0494034179,
-0.0184399448,
-0.0454926081,
-0.0116098747,
0.0113718323,
0.0415243208,
-0.0360216275,
-0.0212820433,
-0.0084399004,
0.0108091617,
0.0451580249,
0.0079817241,
0.0052158455,
-0.0228976458,
0.0150616495,
0.0433154181,
-0.0083643189,
0.0029223068,
-0.0451123044,
0.0128423031,
0.0049205846,
-0.0118187591,
-0.0184216872,
-0.0295057185,
0.0269687418,
-0.111995168,
-0.0225663558,
0.1105941683,
0.0095986696,
-0.0635439605,
-0.0056589409,
-0.0275928602,
0.0388323702,
-0.0199149773,
0.0153643256,
-0.0523115508,
-0.0750675201,
-0.0067295167,
0.0325546898,
0.0015260078,
-0.0127188331,
-0.0259078387,
-0.0436411723,
0.0084269661,
-0.0208532158,
-0.0458131954,
-0.012050312,
-0.0288883056,
-0.045733925,
-0.0320305526,
-0.008625309,
0.0141926585,
0.0461850613,
0.0159571171,
0.0208996199,
-0.038734924,
-0.0199836344,
0.0504259951,
0.0195534565,
0.00806084,
0.0407832228,
0.016113745,
-0.0242437739,
0.0084142564,
0.0082466062,
-0.0567044616,
0.0151692415,
0.0083523393,
0.072622329,
0.0062661166,
-0.0246514175,
-0.0072146566,
0.0311412252,
-0.0633005798,
-0.0007418734,
0.0186641198,
0.0503964685,
-0.0017869005,
-0.0127100265,
-0.0253822673,
-0.0323644429,
-0.0216374174,
0.1025910452,
0.0348610505,
-0.0646646023,
-0.0520054214,
-0.0441410057,
0.0222355071,
-0.1027515009,
-0.0130009241,
0.0133786099,
0.0186336115,
-0.0234950203,
0.0188490916,
-0.0516865477,
-0.0183759406,
0.0128772901,
0.0102796685,
0.0188422017,
-0.0472855195,
-0.012113695,
-0.0489861853,
0.0623993576,
0.0062888898,
-0.0331817865,
-0.0547237918,
-0.0173176583,
0.0113163525,
-0.0626599491,
-0.0401774272,
0.0483632386,
-0.0595772825,
0.0165604986,
0.0102765169,
-0.0109486766,
0.0237381458,
0.0488024913,
0.0130806742,
-0.101448141,
0.0513420403,
0.0345582925,
-0.0369524956,
-0.0226286259,
0.0300384462,
-0.0073892581,
-0.0057938914,
0.0387093388,
-0.0236993302,
0.0791319385,
0.013950509,
-0.0366602838,
-0.047434222,
0.0124966912,
-0.0138460677,
-0.0312245116,
0.0287867729,
-0.0066659995,
-0.0442196913,
-0.0263891965,
0.0108375326,
0.0287165735,
0.0225218125,
-0.0524775051,
-0.015463233,
0.0543162003,
-0.0542677976,
-0.0312224589,
-0.0142993275,
0.0106615108,
-0.0051400443,
-0.0213680118,
0.0199974813,
0.0192212854,
0.0191529319,
0.0170420446,
-0.0037122879,
-0.0101461848,
0.029314056,
-0.0280606188,
0.0466375984,
0.0007371201,
0.0490234755,
0.0420727618,
0.0017933315,
-0.0186649486,
0.0224150103,
-0.0592296198,
-0.02705249,
-0.0042304969,
0.002057761,
0.0171507616,
0.0130190281,
0.0014992862,
-0.0053422735,
0.0047052209,
-0.0077103623,
0.0328555554,
0.0051664119,
-0.0208751541,
-0.0186640788,
0.0173581913,
-0.0102094682,
0.0056135063,
0.0795527175,
0.0569916144,
-0.006520676,
0.0252365991,
0.0041708844,
-0.0554732047,
0.0252668597,
0.0186951682,
0.0324099474,
0.0129871946,
0.0201733895,
-0.0343117341,
-0.0383513831,
0.0540797263,
-0.0278088208,
0.0102556227,
-0.015975114,
-0.0000929911,
0.0628773496,
-0.045002237,
-0.034459617,
-0.0330188833,
0.0260116104,
-0.0328211971,
0.0027898436,
-0.0083681634,
-7.111357317e-33,
-0.0211681686,
-0.0563616008,
-0.0194658041,
-0.0044588358,
0.0079844687,
0.0522997677,
-0.0439887233,
-0.029545011,
0.0158697646,
0.0467231423,
-0.0011919384,
0.055442892,
0.0034914683,
0.0591964461,
-0.0094251363,
-0.0246770084,
0.0569590069,
0.0258905906,
-0.0179817472,
0.0545436591,
0.0594333187,
0.0691918358,
0.0410585031,
-0.0554994307,
0.0617452785,
0.0109692151,
-0.0004091982,
0.0049824221,
0.0250077154,
0.0383825265,
-0.039946571,
0.0346994847,
0.061442934,
-0.0873171911,
-0.0121933641,
0.0352939926,
-0.0693955123,
-0.0206534863,
-0.0089712031,
0.0374884047,
-0.0218102802,
-0.040605817,
0.0597784631,
0.0026964566,
0.0238657817,
-0.0449476801,
0.0454691648,
-0.0294053666,
-0.0229285732,
-0.0121799652,
-0.0097191921,
0.0598978549,
-0.0364864729,
0.001975293,
0.0531787425,
0.0352163836,
-0.0155807529,
0.058513388,
-0.0812646374,
-0.0333619528,
0.018557962,
0.020178657,
0.0562056191,
0.0298669357,
-0.004888908,
0.065896973,
0.0323002934,
-0.0000718326,
-0.0701235011,
-0.0336333327,
0.030835975,
0.0117934113,
0.069144696,
0.0531554073,
0.0939376205,
0.0151401423,
-0.0863786116,
0.0433573797,
-0.047783412,
-0.0029606293,
0.0670998022,
0.0266001634,
-0.0669033378,
-0.0172273293,
-0.0431696028,
-0.0187694747,
-0.0445260853,
0.0004666359,
0.0251972377,
0.0004996475,
-0.0365506411,
-0.005809403,
0.040388763,
-0.0531123169,
0.023207454,
0.0311804786,
-0.0041041272,
0.0226853173,
0.0413977355,
0.0116819572,
-0.0419983454,
-0.0089456867,
0.0064983461,
0.0305658113,
0.0372056291,
-0.0027738297,
0.0422027633,
-0.0292840861,
-0.0120049147,
-0.0274720434,
-0.0279104747,
-0.0037744988,
-0.0408516265,
0.0424092002,
0.0294872783,
0.0013604937,
-0.0378562436,
0.047134079,
0.0285007861,
0.0202452429,
0.0140861543,
0.0162178017,
-0.009591247,
0.0243063048,
-0.0398941785,
-0.0533333272,
0.0264035128,
-0.0389267057,
0.0502356552,
-0.0771471262,
0.0040411316,
0.0198451336,
2.845e-7,
0.0363514759,
0.0379800908,
-0.0086480295,
-0.0193948746,
0.0583143421,
0.0771643072,
0.0326213948,
0.0032473698,
-0.0524489433,
-0.0444339588,
0.0455692895,
0.0546488166,
0.0579589158,
-0.0096583497,
-0.060998857,
-0.0149630029,
-0.0201227348,
0.0328700915,
-0.038670361,
0.0092248479,
0.0599154271,
0.0918795243,
0.0012011337,
-0.0385616422,
0.0564377643,
-0.0288107004,
0.0468251891,
-0.0439005978,
0.0487932377,
0.0180910677,
0.0278208759,
0.0247753132,
-0.0139561724,
0.0250019263,
0.0029115081,
0.0065899142,
0.0055500618,
0.0699623078,
-0.0078996951,
0.0020127576,
-0.0202924609,
-0.0065835477,
0.0091917189,
-0.0629575551,
0.0687999502,
-0.0470785126,
-0.0573376939,
0.0156120155,
-0.0077519771,
-0.0436848029,
0.0203958768,
0.0194132458,
0.0292923525,
0.0224128012,
-0.0284961332,
-0.0471559204,
-0.0067326589,
-0.0855068341,
-0.0085681239,
-0.0282689054,
-0.0465491973,
0.0392798856,
-0.0962419659,
-0.0085111726,
0.0341620855,
-0.0310012195,
0.0012804908,
2.505706258e-34,
0.0260668229,
-0.0203784928,
-0.0059563559,
0.0292576496,
0.0156505685,
0.0129117668,
-0.0324973986,
-0.006202782,
0.0434261858,
-0.06852483,
0.0304518696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19658v1 | Explaining Tree Model Decisions in Natural Language for Network Intrusion Detection | 2023-10-30T15:40:34 | 2023-10-30T15:40:34 | Noah Ziems, Gang Liu, John Flanagan, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Network intrusion detection (NID) systems which leverage machine learning
have been shown to have strong performance in practice when used to detect
malicious network traffic. Decision trees in particular offer a strong balance
between performance and simplicity, but require users of NID systems to have
background knowledge in machine learning to interpret. In addition, they are
unable to provide additional outside information as to why certain features may
be important for classification.
In this work, we explore the use of large language models (LLMs) to provide
explanations and additional background knowledge for decision tree NID systems.
Further, we introduce a new human evaluation framework for decision tree
explanations, which leverages automatically generated quiz questions that
measure human evaluators' understanding of decision tree inference. Finally, we
show LLM generated decision tree explanations correlate highly with human
ratings of readability, quality, and use of background knowledge while
simultaneously providing better understanding of decision boundaries. | [
0.0272953454,
0.0119218659,
-0.0140248388,
0.0355372243,
-0.0515694208,
-0.0158859156,
0.0143829519,
-0.0197945721,
-0.0037771876,
-0.0515888892,
0.0350658,
-0.0113568008,
0.0042585623,
0.0222943313,
0.0191066246,
-0.0556798019,
0.0060719117,
-0.0671969354,
0.0536004901,
0.0119349444,
0.0251294132,
0.0034500048,
0.0100632804,
0.0440181345,
0.0111328969,
-0.0392093174,
-0.0491808392,
-0.0180544369,
0.0102756685,
-0.0472479947,
-0.0253897477,
0.0141669866,
0.0174988173,
-0.0141780153,
0.0000021071,
-0.0496017598,
-0.0025146075,
0.010763295,
-0.0888818949,
0.0550896861,
0.0088413805,
0.056921795,
0.0178808626,
-0.0001404872,
0.0029586863,
0.0203768294,
0.0461759344,
0.0598822497,
0.0806296021,
0.0547690913,
0.0088751558,
-0.0429712832,
-0.0280655567,
0.0210650731,
0.0367954187,
-0.0191790368,
0.0127011482,
0.0243041031,
0.0161650125,
0.0123886541,
0.0076564974,
-0.0675015002,
0.0331952982,
-0.0560173467,
0.0138822859,
0.0535181165,
-0.0082568573,
0.0149051696,
0.0032294127,
0.038650725,
-0.0028365843,
-0.0063435086,
-0.0203780383,
-0.0198512152,
0.0128109977,
0.0168899391,
-0.0224327371,
0.0135916779,
-0.0260312427,
-0.0280009918,
0.0091171674,
0.033752773,
0.0322214551,
0.0367510542,
-0.0253062528,
0.0775531158,
-0.027642183,
-0.0115864715,
0.009975967,
-0.0226032156,
0.0252602007,
-0.0632698834,
-0.0027275903,
0.0251345616,
-0.0525016002,
0.008281027,
-0.003550458,
0.0433962792,
0.0187063031,
-0.0411763117,
-0.0174482912,
0.0063436865,
0.0040837512,
0.025588911,
-0.0032524115,
0.0790834874,
0.0320182331,
-0.0009351261,
-0.0277704578,
-0.0053403489,
-0.0785370469,
-0.0466034226,
-0.0125391996,
0.0199994668,
0.0024749413,
0.0102583617,
-0.0448200814,
0.0193794351,
-0.0293820482,
0.0064567453,
0.0141713992,
0.0016472955,
0.0107754227,
-0.0011928544,
-0.0422876105,
-0.0028622309,
-0.0551190898,
0.0066528711,
0.0244321879,
-0.0138943084,
-0.0144706378,
0.0439004153,
-0.0034836365,
-0.0120183732,
-0.0100414976,
0.0564071797,
0.0346516557,
0.0105251772,
-0.0144676138,
-0.0459717065,
-0.013033268,
0.0000863339,
-0.0397993401,
-0.0401175991,
-0.0528425984,
0.01809006,
0.0324958079,
-0.0095248139,
-0.0112874443,
0.0095705213,
-0.0075999708,
0.0812001526,
-0.0422786586,
0.026553655,
0.0022039085,
0.0007599578,
0.0019522756,
-0.0062128957,
0.0188167021,
0.0632594898,
0.018354103,
-0.0626872331,
0.0509807952,
-0.0164671391,
-0.0416842364,
-0.0530475639,
-0.0005843796,
0.0546604693,
-0.0692377687,
0.0203991663,
-0.0080225328,
0.005871281,
0.0076254699,
0.0113811456,
0.0669959337,
0.0619301312,
0.0110152438,
-0.0002745436,
0.0393076614,
0.039084617,
-0.0136117674,
0.0037365828,
-0.0124512278,
0.0298676789,
-0.0617000535,
-0.0011944338,
-0.0368281975,
0.014581929,
-0.0031944984,
-0.0478785299,
-0.0245291442,
0.0238817763,
0.0267715603,
0.0280112326,
0.0352610126,
0.0105387,
0.0055250991,
-0.0043343049,
0.0112727387,
-0.0112413662,
0.0032007494,
-0.0704504475,
0.0289932489,
0.117506586,
0.0115208309,
0.0015420361,
0.0059683095,
-0.0052643078,
0.0195964631,
-0.0014477265,
0.0257031024,
-0.0091148922,
-0.0302551761,
-0.0150627568,
-0.0191036817,
0.008802061,
0.0264188424,
0.0134500246,
-0.0232086573,
-0.0535736158,
0.0339092016,
-0.0418029912,
-0.1033252627,
0.0175974369,
0.0205960833,
-0.0315712765,
0.017432522,
0.0240484849,
0.03978616,
0.0249807779,
-0.002268096,
0.0497533008,
0.0274127033,
0.0188131016,
-0.0460680276,
-0.0029819643,
-0.0003858621,
0.0115279146,
0.0104694376,
-0.0406829417,
-0.0112245586,
0.0129375458,
-0.040197771,
-0.023238495,
0.0144674191,
-0.1057051346,
-0.0208015554,
-0.0252101012,
-0.0146519514,
-0.0102809006,
-0.0427773893,
-0.0407971106,
0.074949719,
0.0539878495,
0.0047390941,
-0.0010957043,
-0.0268654656,
0.0236911103,
-0.0420951173,
0.0345803946,
-0.0055522188,
-0.0269644596,
0.0294429231,
0.0259106532,
0.0233825333,
-0.0169408079,
0.0571396612,
-0.0664560273,
-0.0140181398,
-0.033806622,
0.0376944244,
0.0244270526,
-0.0148135955,
-0.0334927812,
-0.0219652858,
-0.0410889536,
-0.0045696753,
-0.0141527923,
0.0212484393,
0.0450735837,
-0.0016257318,
-0.0454513244,
-0.0112855723,
-0.0087028649,
-0.0394143946,
0.0803227127,
0.0753447562,
-0.0180967879,
-0.025059225,
-0.0232951343,
-0.0142388819,
-0.0740917623,
-0.0061175637,
-0.0102741607,
0.0301826019,
-0.0015787391,
-0.0322238579,
0.013570779,
0.0074237832,
0.0377586223,
0.0584587678,
-0.0002214045,
-0.0438094735,
-0.0089212945,
0.0169476736,
-0.0110453917,
-0.0223035719,
-0.0412779525,
0.032985881,
0.0707433969,
0.0175184999,
-0.001591282,
-0.005807702,
0.0390457585,
0.0018225082,
-0.0014841536,
-0.1062718034,
-0.1011903509,
-0.0053913519,
0.0569831394,
0.0082340194,
-0.0817859471,
0.1230026111,
-0.0419730209,
0.0048758518,
-0.0685456991,
-0.0565366223,
-0.043179404,
0.0657196641,
-0.0155390166,
0.0304334648,
0.0482612923,
-0.038651187,
-0.012940404,
-0.0161255077,
0.0524185114,
-0.0072954721,
-0.0064183986,
-0.0541087426,
-0.0153870173,
0.0274460558,
0.0077211647,
-0.0397234336,
-0.0625095963,
-0.0576565489,
-0.023129601,
0.0163707323,
-0.0319938064,
0.0097138677,
0.0260767564,
0.0500640236,
-0.015777003,
0.0037151135,
-0.0245523788,
0.0129486127,
0.0295808949,
0.0104554864,
0.0153188752,
0.0150453551,
-0.017205311,
0.0673626885,
0.0287157018,
0.0486906879,
0.0251661912,
-0.0388803929,
0.0157589931,
-0.0106015522,
-0.0530593246,
0.0140831023,
0.0478492491,
0.0346654616,
-0.039731577,
0.0158256181,
0.0962205827,
0.034185268,
-0.0091875279,
0.0096026184,
-0.0456017628,
0.0102198562,
0.0189015642,
0.0216696002,
-0.0399667919,
-0.0459447466,
0.0076651932,
0.0309692752,
-0.0262325201,
-0.009006856,
0.0087433662,
-0.0968002975,
0.0168681797,
0.0097986702,
-0.0350684598,
-0.0277203526,
-0.0832805112,
-0.0509467945,
-0.0093148472,
0.0136586111,
-0.0112545602,
0.0150072947,
0.0249807071,
0.0094764214,
-0.0739006549,
-0.0496899821,
0.0637555644,
-0.0131022716,
0.0190719515,
0.0555154495,
0.0112955263,
-0.0174449179,
-0.0066008517,
0.0419973321,
-0.0418908708,
0.0455021486,
0.0241618808,
0.0442060493,
0.0162176192,
0.0006464919,
-0.0560344122,
0.0171562042,
-0.005867241,
-0.0146758221,
0.0474172011,
0.0754299611,
-0.0498667136,
-0.0242449827,
-0.0016900366,
-0.0009610154,
0.0149217434,
0.0846273378,
0.0405594371,
-0.0448816232,
0.0107134255,
-0.0537090376,
-0.005424195,
0.0310564339,
-0.0680093244,
0.0380234644,
-0.007087457,
-0.0396060161,
-0.0219927263,
-0.0396380499,
0.0542418212,
-0.009612754,
0.0231448375,
-0.0255681444,
-0.0207125023,
0.0486438125,
-0.0107572842,
0.04550042,
0.0139936768,
0.0450706705,
0.0064176344,
0.0318016931,
0.0283783395,
-0.0018416684,
-0.0346979499,
0.0280487388,
0.0494974628,
-0.0162984654,
-0.0511754043,
0.0280177034,
0.0308535304,
0.004599167,
-0.0358212963,
-0.0588216633,
0.0007046561,
0.0089996485,
-0.0137950908,
-0.0555278659,
-0.0006593863,
-0.0361800753,
0.0207975246,
-0.0017350337,
-0.0335068107,
0.0010041394,
-0.0203995109,
-0.001537535,
-0.08160083,
-0.0448836945,
0.0790833905,
0.0580061972,
0.0407986678,
0.0032403243,
-0.0085496362,
0.0320689194,
0.0248306096,
-0.0319773108,
-0.0427873805,
0.023429852,
-0.0196638238,
0.0360388607,
-0.0251682065,
0.0428656451,
-0.0013629716,
-0.0303830467,
-0.0352655724,
-0.0352483168,
0.0155678457,
0.0821341127,
0.0455976203,
0.0037232717,
-0.0200537257,
-0.0222435221,
-0.0404247195,
0.0059991442,
0.0338061266,
0.0282910336,
0.0593420938,
-0.0173163805,
-0.0063816421,
-0.0080024833,
-0.0142319482,
-0.0628946349,
-0.0677961111,
0.0410401784,
0.004623347,
0.010304302,
0.0190039724,
-0.0150620611,
-0.0250167605,
0.0267437957,
-0.0094517693,
0.0367142521,
0.0228608325,
-0.0448115282,
0.033355888,
0.0395244099,
-0.0412643626,
-0.0323085301,
0.0676435158,
0.026401015,
-0.0000960195,
-0.0298258867,
-0.0725172758,
-0.0125349518,
-0.0142377494,
-0.0156108541,
0.065327093,
-0.0219099373,
-0.0208627358,
-0.1030078232,
-0.0333440751,
-0.0667640865,
0.0144567266,
0.0644147843,
-0.0069026388,
0.0315281749,
0.0780946314,
-0.0336894356,
-0.0214534234,
-0.0400950648,
0.0126064494,
-0.0857120529,
0.0274482481,
-0.0429562032,
-5.619808903e-33,
-0.0034130523,
-0.0612875931,
-0.0014790125,
-0.003717076,
0.0321708247,
-0.0035540191,
-0.0359363593,
0.0172762256,
-0.0029299273,
0.0307730064,
0.023213679,
-0.0071815858,
0.0022438292,
0.0010985035,
0.0023174416,
-0.0226709526,
0.0244536996,
0.0238411929,
-0.0318692848,
0.0396469384,
0.0371335372,
-0.0124033801,
0.002883062,
-0.0879404247,
0.0736181885,
0.016317891,
-0.0097922552,
0.0085379649,
-0.0354623422,
0.0203098506,
0.0024710495,
0.0434496328,
0.0173572656,
-0.0619901493,
-0.0084867617,
0.0515729561,
-0.0020340909,
-0.0219427925,
0.0381842554,
-0.0249263216,
0.006984564,
-0.0507037155,
0.0497729369,
0.0022019444,
0.0167852137,
-0.0014675853,
0.0405223705,
-0.0154112745,
-0.006088078,
-0.0196353272,
0.0022969954,
0.0217474792,
-0.0661889687,
0.0130799348,
-0.0276371706,
0.048397094,
-0.0028699876,
0.0030015553,
-0.0114608426,
0.0688899606,
0.0550612248,
-0.0236309506,
0.0550576746,
-0.0011351907,
-0.0312015656,
0.0509671234,
0.0123513686,
-0.0306750946,
-0.0151298381,
0.0243609119,
-0.0408648588,
0.0462629497,
0.1105517596,
0.0399620198,
0.0300924052,
0.0186734535,
-0.0707483068,
0.0563230142,
0.0102654314,
0.0415109731,
0.004434647,
-0.0161959436,
-0.0916236863,
-0.0246665291,
-0.0196164735,
-0.0207986012,
-0.0292721521,
-0.0395043902,
0.0151773784,
-0.056757763,
-0.0524554849,
-0.0081686573,
-0.0333811976,
-0.032507658,
-0.0007746716,
0.028445011,
0.0096902382,
0.0009438887,
-0.0000053887,
-0.0171672832,
0.0105150715,
0.0422079712,
-0.0051794196,
-0.0070424881,
0.0477341823,
-0.0099891573,
0.0129248491,
0.0241792258,
-0.0341023654,
-0.0205353387,
-0.029198518,
-0.0186906494,
-0.0450531468,
0.035363704,
0.0391675644,
0.0369429588,
-0.0106484089,
-0.02217797,
-0.0120822834,
-0.0143205971,
-0.0112303589,
-0.0223005395,
-0.0509581603,
-0.004154338,
0.005628739,
-0.020199487,
-0.008914927,
-0.0037878433,
0.0308959056,
-0.0243786331,
-0.0027631472,
-0.0005787381,
2.762e-7,
0.0133701386,
0.0352283381,
-0.0001670243,
0.0030138078,
0.0146316588,
0.0528660081,
-0.0241278801,
0.0067383866,
0.0218167994,
-0.0615004897,
0.0292667095,
-0.0239251945,
0.0528622232,
0.0246382542,
-0.0576106943,
-0.0382505991,
-0.035486538,
-0.020735532,
-0.0650753304,
0.0275018476,
0.1227937266,
0.0552850328,
-0.0030797182,
-0.0135163264,
0.0051101171,
-0.0763132796,
-0.0128131798,
-0.045344539,
0.0048511433,
-0.0176278818,
0.0900863931,
-0.0015947652,
0.0333523713,
0.0800240785,
-0.0190800149,
-0.0259848144,
-0.0282777473,
0.0436515287,
0.0121931322,
0.0268739592,
-0.0606483035,
-0.0429873168,
0.0282401443,
-0.0594254471,
0.0595534444,
-0.0448000841,
-0.0224987417,
0.0300473068,
-0.0137718003,
-0.0581573024,
-0.0198882055,
-0.0075220345,
-0.0029496597,
0.0045302263,
-0.0257387888,
-0.0400426537,
0.0309092049,
-0.0262790807,
-0.0226906054,
0.0166276526,
-0.0269365944,
-0.0146019347,
-0.0345403217,
0.007639355,
0.0693890676,
-0.0115218181,
-0.005528871,
2.19159029e-34,
0.0163204242,
0.0146402959,
-0.0020162726,
0.0039907102,
0.0430509001,
0.0503280498,
0.0036463332,
-0.012793093,
0.0422868989,
-0.0257839616,
0.0080850255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19651v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19651v2 | Dynamics of Instruction Tuning: Each Ability of Large Language Models Has Its Own Growth Pace | 2023-10-30T15:37:10 | 2024-02-22T13:21:27 | Chiyu Song, Zhanchao Zhou, Jianhao Yan, Yuejiao Fei, Zhenzhong Lan, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is a burgeoning method to elicit the general intelligence
of Large Language Models (LLMs). However, the creation of instruction data is
still largely heuristic, leading to significant variation in quantity and
quality across existing datasets. While some research advocates for expanding
the number of instructions, others suggest that a small set of well-chosen
examples is adequate. To better understand data construction guidelines, our
research provides a granular analysis of how data volume, parameter size, and
data construction methods influence the development of each underlying ability
of LLM, such as creative writing, code generation, and logical reasoning. We
present a meticulously curated dataset with over 40k instances across ten
abilities and examine instruction-tuned models with 7b to 33b parameters. Our
study reveals three primary findings: (i) Despite the models' overall
performance being tied to data and parameter scale, individual abilities have
different sensitivities to these factors. (ii) Human-curated data strongly
outperforms synthetic data from GPT-4 in efficiency and can constantly enhance
model performance with volume increases, but is unachievable with synthetic
data. (iii) Instruction data brings powerful cross-ability generalization, as
evidenced by out-of-domain evaluations. Furthermore, we demonstrate how these
findings can guide more efficient data constructions, leading to practical
performance improvements on two public benchmarks. | [
0.0257731751,
0.0713129863,
-0.0381660908,
0.0182170551,
-0.0243069828,
0.0131222866,
0.0237979535,
-0.0204397943,
-0.0098019978,
-0.0206723344,
-0.0324706286,
-0.0369618982,
0.0054110973,
0.0226652753,
0.0313340202,
-0.0321629047,
0.0384252258,
-0.0689432174,
0.0075925961,
-0.0024780496,
-0.0322070904,
0.0353905,
-0.0119985882,
0.0526090115,
0.0179969221,
-0.0301513299,
-0.0015422156,
0.0005610964,
-0.0194590073,
-0.0149572538,
0.0031488091,
0.071170941,
0.0233963672,
0.0196884107,
0.0000021256,
-0.0524722338,
0.0280809142,
-0.0253719352,
-0.0027342439,
0.0348004438,
0.0245776139,
-0.0005306824,
-0.0130749661,
0.0323820598,
-0.0215756074,
-0.0155606326,
0.0210191458,
-0.0190965477,
0.0371783562,
0.0722961575,
0.0133308908,
-0.0134618618,
0.0400685593,
-0.0168823879,
0.0355790965,
-0.0112833958,
0.0017275295,
0.0240706019,
0.035776604,
0.0129803307,
-0.0273620076,
0.0145210074,
0.0559875742,
-0.014677546,
-0.0252492521,
0.0469726101,
-0.0221402813,
0.0051681641,
-0.0027747781,
0.0321551636,
0.0056237495,
-0.0088777216,
-0.0241970588,
0.0033836979,
0.0195722263,
-0.0060270112,
-0.0294065066,
0.0606241599,
-0.003125625,
-0.0088864462,
0.0458762087,
-0.043227274,
0.0262466781,
0.0018171138,
0.001865892,
0.0529092886,
0.021155281,
-0.0287651978,
-0.0222336333,
0.000072808,
-0.0411168821,
-0.0540331006,
-0.0174746793,
0.021590963,
-0.0307498779,
0.0155751733,
-0.0815462843,
-0.0027285493,
-0.0088853985,
0.0061921296,
0.1047860384,
0.0604495816,
0.0306555871,
0.0148444306,
-0.0107958186,
0.0676384345,
-0.0018693118,
0.0584216267,
-0.0213278122,
0.0156693254,
-0.0798646212,
-0.0270696841,
-0.0334875956,
0.0213242956,
-0.0204363596,
0.0000756453,
-0.0314106792,
0.0406547077,
0.0068766875,
-0.0185714122,
0.0118982755,
-0.0077326344,
-0.026920503,
-0.0032152694,
-0.0345035978,
-0.016001828,
-0.0420075543,
0.0193457995,
0.0233120397,
-0.034193892,
-0.0069905841,
0.009181791,
-0.0114123626,
-0.0349623859,
0.0395663753,
0.0575342141,
-0.0155374808,
-0.0042884662,
-0.0570265241,
-0.036441192,
0.024296714,
-0.0863021165,
0.0275243465,
-0.0886601135,
0.0221565217,
0.0367934629,
-0.029067779,
-0.0716765597,
-0.0142229516,
0.0329087675,
-0.022034917,
0.0100424811,
-0.0097119873,
0.0388316475,
0.0151826991,
-0.0031057904,
0.0055656973,
0.0628076941,
0.0717600212,
-0.0010253775,
-0.0055603296,
-0.0186360572,
0.012347688,
0.0209725015,
0.0013764924,
0.0121228779,
-0.0078654271,
0.0146256443,
0.0023256959,
0.0399813727,
0.0303289834,
0.0374774151,
-0.0115132835,
0.0306850821,
0.061784666,
0.0355064906,
0.0228991229,
0.0419115424,
0.081775181,
0.0256700963,
0.0282378756,
-0.0229438134,
-0.0708088949,
0.0561058,
0.0011946716,
0.0243124831,
0.0031973661,
0.0513587482,
-0.0197104588,
-0.0600794926,
0.0039763446,
0.0334542356,
-0.0061683701,
0.0119864177,
0.0101131443,
-0.0083381003,
-0.0378060974,
0.0173666924,
0.0133570023,
-0.0596269146,
-0.0165888853,
-0.047224924,
0.0315800644,
0.0827031061,
0.0412080586,
0.011506008,
-0.0494008139,
0.0058938465,
0.0474039912,
0.0210702419,
0.0399924703,
-0.004786185,
0.0151367662,
-0.029748952,
-0.0197580233,
-0.0642524213,
0.0074883457,
0.0077506821,
0.0369115919,
-0.0193709992,
0.0159891453,
-0.0354016609,
-0.0708425045,
0.0328953117,
-0.0751198828,
-0.0341183245,
-0.0323833935,
-0.0078680832,
0.0101983082,
-0.0000049138,
-0.0268674139,
0.0171576664,
-0.0001740985,
-0.0302510932,
0.0063717333,
0.0080055315,
-0.0524248928,
-0.0006555158,
0.0313471071,
-0.0382367484,
-0.0097329253,
0.016044192,
0.0075832917,
-0.0242413748,
0.0604557656,
-0.0524654165,
0.0323841758,
-0.0088220062,
0.0390101895,
-0.049299296,
-0.030240206,
0.0022643756,
0.0562144779,
-0.0079519097,
-0.0008346445,
0.0396430977,
0.054196842,
0.0026073565,
-0.020790698,
0.0191484783,
-0.0006919436,
0.008883018,
0.0323945023,
0.0044325544,
0.0564569719,
-0.0390212163,
-0.0455145128,
-0.0737741739,
0.0349424034,
-0.0255197752,
0.0191488396,
0.0306409188,
-0.0247081108,
-0.0300158821,
0.0365209579,
-0.0365961529,
-0.0377173796,
-0.0107797971,
0.0128194913,
0.0052708299,
0.0021022882,
-0.0471679159,
-0.0131642912,
-0.0130680259,
-0.0442573503,
0.0124841556,
0.0231801365,
0.0492342152,
-0.0544547439,
0.0655637234,
-0.0155903874,
0.0088210935,
-0.009233918,
-0.0515412427,
0.0342125408,
-0.0177025478,
0.0594129153,
0.0796864107,
-0.019076854,
0.0022104091,
0.062732175,
-0.0100951623,
-0.0406554341,
0.0358785763,
0.0153523711,
0.0002725944,
-0.0377131738,
-0.0473097041,
-0.0024442172,
0.08873301,
-0.0032556008,
0.0047361529,
-0.0634560436,
0.0638246685,
-0.0138333067,
-0.0301751159,
0.0010642725,
0.0047819824,
-0.0043460736,
0.0361472741,
-0.0482901409,
-0.0835821182,
0.061802607,
-0.0164785143,
-0.0059802243,
-0.0496914536,
0.0029248544,
-0.0363782346,
0.0689057037,
-0.010052138,
0.0152127044,
-0.0334195904,
0.0016885068,
-0.0847939923,
0.0328752324,
0.0157537814,
-0.014567662,
0.0493987314,
-0.0812928155,
-0.0246805586,
-0.0001926628,
-0.0425380245,
-0.0350361541,
0.0196543187,
-0.0053429538,
0.0243220273,
0.0802990347,
-0.0452400669,
-0.0266981162,
-0.0324016511,
0.0414223559,
0.0299911313,
-0.024007326,
-0.0234265178,
-0.0183199272,
-0.0582252108,
0.0452680923,
-0.0230403189,
-0.0116793569,
-0.066789113,
0.0163675323,
0.0058809076,
0.0142775346,
0.0034245322,
-0.0109041622,
0.0387969427,
0.0235080533,
-0.0092293555,
-0.01576069,
0.064115651,
0.1033112109,
-0.0706174225,
-0.0277157184,
0.1092422307,
0.0298333205,
-0.0206646211,
0.0082324091,
0.0053032697,
0.0257537346,
0.0433845371,
0.0528778434,
-0.039788045,
-0.0243554432,
-0.0016207552,
0.0340351164,
-0.0192786101,
-0.0372916311,
-0.0220432859,
-0.1291836649,
0.0309389811,
0.0249147676,
-0.0334054343,
-0.0444065034,
-0.0300048757,
-0.0219924692,
0.0165068898,
0.0114359539,
0.0230357572,
-0.0320480391,
0.0143632693,
0.0201406162,
-0.0210886337,
-0.0689262077,
0.0554110967,
-0.025682399,
0.0547353402,
0.0335715301,
0.0107703339,
0.0021891298,
-0.0257782135,
0.0161031336,
0.0071852999,
0.0268275291,
0.0031256971,
0.0547094345,
-0.0003533216,
-0.0022707121,
-0.034404587,
0.0516961403,
-0.0420971401,
0.0037767119,
0.0324035287,
0.0748063326,
-0.0085543748,
-0.034330368,
-0.024428919,
-0.0180485472,
-0.0257552899,
0.0562210232,
0.0377652906,
-0.0704304203,
-0.0405316614,
-0.0543671958,
-0.0505411774,
-0.1210483909,
-0.0317608267,
0.0396729633,
0.0021878027,
0.0085393405,
-0.0239496287,
-0.0505581945,
0.060039036,
0.0252005719,
0.0327540226,
-0.0066968622,
-0.0007709599,
-0.0051458129,
-0.0521407388,
0.0384463184,
-0.0275265891,
0.017430963,
-0.0843806863,
-0.0787969008,
-0.0349588543,
-0.0478657,
-0.0052409265,
0.0298965815,
-0.0804700851,
-0.0624797978,
0.0040449281,
0.0500472449,
0.0198939964,
0.0282089449,
0.0059883678,
-0.0670922175,
0.013053718,
-0.0051611862,
-0.0349615775,
0.0129536092,
0.0065576751,
-0.0200305562,
0.0260445718,
0.0214449596,
-0.0278874617,
0.0488342531,
0.0576578788,
0.0393167734,
0.0010024149,
0.0244040731,
0.026737636,
0.0305653047,
-0.0255863406,
-0.0134053826,
-0.0025729956,
-0.0523422882,
-0.008809357,
-0.0320454203,
-0.0149656907,
-0.0455580056,
-0.0147140427,
0.0215007104,
-0.0125822816,
0.0054262429,
-0.011734955,
0.004948447,
0.0098314686,
-0.0467362329,
0.0421999581,
-0.0179566815,
0.0522013716,
0.0556881316,
0.0026017346,
-0.025621878,
0.021076899,
-0.0384447835,
0.0440758727,
0.0241208915,
0.0608839467,
-0.0103136636,
0.0186078735,
-0.0108125526,
0.0253055897,
-0.0696356744,
-0.0564604215,
-0.0012311001,
0.0085140755,
0.0523904189,
-0.0024175919,
0.0210906025,
-0.0317428596,
0.0148259141,
-0.0270952787,
0.0368437804,
0.0149301309,
-0.0341800489,
-0.0097478479,
0.0381513387,
-0.0114562223,
-0.062306121,
0.0841298252,
0.006644988,
0.048540853,
-0.0150846643,
0.0016457032,
-0.0232662223,
-0.0166280661,
0.0056724166,
0.0071297726,
-0.0073557734,
0.0182802863,
-0.0454223938,
-0.0692941621,
-0.025148103,
0.0219145138,
0.0224109199,
-0.0296940748,
0.019954225,
0.0701214299,
-0.0488513485,
-0.035861779,
-0.0099513652,
-0.0203916617,
-0.0623205081,
-0.0262503717,
-0.0326743051,
-6.089602934e-33,
-0.0275050569,
-0.0033212607,
0.0601997562,
-0.0001268351,
0.0148416869,
-0.0085867159,
-0.0567764565,
0.0263377633,
-0.0250204597,
-0.0012927988,
-0.0121705029,
0.0152840298,
-0.0107217431,
0.0119089577,
0.04678398,
0.0145028653,
0.0323140174,
-0.0038050856,
-0.0628816932,
0.0490654111,
0.0224347152,
-0.0186777208,
0.052300103,
-0.0465652309,
-0.0148873115,
-0.0117083546,
0.026149923,
0.0072662705,
-0.0179999042,
0.0610767677,
0.0070626196,
0.0494820923,
0.0246639103,
-0.038542334,
-0.0337893739,
-0.0265199468,
0.0020480203,
-0.0353055447,
0.0194309689,
-0.0151898628,
-0.0221444126,
-0.0999051332,
0.0222625341,
0.0115825022,
-0.0618974939,
-0.05094935,
0.034639217,
-0.0080644498,
0.0185860898,
-0.0085761407,
-0.0852112994,
0.0173092317,
-0.0216707382,
-0.0321300514,
-0.0249501579,
0.017524248,
-0.0095650032,
-0.0144795338,
-0.0210726429,
0.031879317,
0.0273631215,
0.0600339025,
0.0746159703,
0.0091068847,
0.0195631851,
0.048666399,
0.0323963016,
0.0574997589,
-0.0122593911,
0.0265569985,
0.0481311642,
0.0713822097,
0.0319268741,
0.0125682792,
0.0300084185,
-0.0138769699,
-0.0428634621,
-0.0047940789,
0.0185497962,
0.0056264945,
0.0445092171,
-0.0136206299,
-0.0526118539,
-0.0284827482,
-0.0316613093,
0.0107965609,
-0.0126186954,
-0.020387128,
0.0690708831,
-0.0021369003,
-0.005564109,
-0.03602653,
0.0261514187,
-0.0250789467,
0.007761721,
0.0077357423,
-0.0569559112,
0.0401525795,
-0.0033218241,
0.0247989148,
-0.0590243265,
-0.0526361465,
0.0353248268,
0.0227873847,
0.0502840951,
0.033469148,
0.0211511087,
0.0402455442,
-0.0593971014,
-0.0125467908,
-0.0713580027,
0.0387763642,
0.0223915894,
-0.0114687188,
0.0197869837,
0.0079463497,
0.002182825,
-0.0162818134,
-0.0011868052,
-0.0301045738,
-0.0531366579,
-0.0217691399,
-0.0155632896,
0.0126485834,
-0.0080510071,
-0.0086306529,
-0.0550736226,
-0.0385079943,
0.0057270839,
-0.0542234629,
-0.0327275582,
0.0306634288,
2.758e-7,
0.0056084599,
0.0518220663,
-0.0017432424,
0.0739698783,
0.0080898488,
0.0019508392,
-0.0314657949,
-0.0181016102,
0.0454388596,
0.0219902191,
-0.023238264,
0.0646091327,
0.0494311303,
0.0263624117,
-0.0588870533,
0.0139994118,
-0.0216477271,
0.0391664878,
-0.0869164765,
-0.0060396059,
0.0280446708,
0.0448166654,
-0.0080612777,
-0.0114384349,
0.0200566165,
-0.0557819717,
0.0260156747,
-0.0243128836,
0.0113458578,
0.0311546754,
-0.0187237691,
0.0353130065,
0.0044690492,
0.0358361825,
-0.0144200521,
0.0104127554,
-0.0331067517,
0.0753844008,
-0.0067641013,
0.0236147735,
0.0265689455,
-0.0163213182,
-0.0212250035,
-0.0531693734,
0.060021352,
-0.0390404128,
-0.0175903756,
0.0187531654,
0.0255855024,
-0.0012427354,
-0.0176484585,
-0.0186850689,
0.0287522282,
0.0037847366,
0.0192287657,
-0.0463370346,
0.024148548,
-0.0173240006,
-0.0172284544,
0.0410246514,
-0.0167713352,
-0.0759797916,
-0.0751493499,
-0.0030113857,
0.0304989759,
-0.0425823294,
0.0238249861,
2.782402246e-34,
0.0199118685,
-0.0173577722,
0.0650616288,
-0.0104689356,
0.0546264313,
0.0019277985,
0.0067156609,
-0.0023365756,
0.0146789718,
-0.0646420345,
-0.0354980081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19650v1 | KeyGen2Vec: Learning Document Embedding via Multi-label Keyword Generation in Question-Answering | 2023-10-30T15:35:45 | 2023-10-30T15:35:45 | Iftitahu Ni'mah, Samaneh Khoshrou, Vlado Menkovski, Mykola Pechenizkiy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Representing documents into high dimensional embedding space while preserving
the structural similarity between document sources has been an ultimate goal
for many works on text representation learning. Current embedding models,
however, mainly rely on the availability of label supervision to increase the
expressiveness of the resulting embeddings. In contrast, unsupervised
embeddings are cheap, but they often cannot capture implicit structure in
target corpus, particularly for samples that come from different distribution
with the pretraining source.
Our study aims to loosen up the dependency on label supervision by learning
document embeddings via Sequence-to-Sequence (Seq2Seq) text generator.
Specifically, we reformulate keyphrase generation task into multi-label keyword
generation in community-based Question Answering (cQA). Our empirical results
show that KeyGen2Vec in general is superior than multi-label keyword classifier
by up to 14.7% based on Purity, Normalized Mutual Information (NMI), and
F1-Score metrics. Interestingly, although in general the absolute advantage of
learning embeddings through label supervision is highly positive across
evaluation datasets, KeyGen2Vec is shown to be competitive with classifier that
exploits topic label supervision in Yahoo! cQA with larger number of latent
topic labels. | [
0.047572393,
0.0124443294,
0.0283289626,
0.0148934089,
0.0120200757,
0.0083522163,
0.0139834564,
0.0032606721,
0.0285908096,
-0.063880004,
-0.043178767,
-0.0174892433,
-0.0550590903,
0.0044290652,
0.0421174765,
0.0100722583,
0.0433729813,
0.0166133512,
-0.0126790917,
-0.0157529246,
0.023065472,
0.0326682888,
0.0424399637,
0.0475747846,
-0.0245293435,
-0.0031963715,
-0.0067340769,
-0.0130569851,
0.0134204831,
0.0153815066,
0.058267381,
0.0684963465,
0.0461246334,
0.0079654381,
0.0000014517,
-0.0183784962,
0.0108748749,
-0.0099391788,
0.0268522892,
0.0540694259,
0.0268647186,
-0.0059182909,
0.0713323578,
0.0244721062,
-0.033022061,
-0.0091557344,
0.0225958712,
0.0575257279,
0.0839297101,
0.023560768,
-0.0100592515,
-0.0570160784,
0.0080325203,
-0.0265229233,
0.0179982148,
-0.0581715889,
0.0162285734,
-0.0002735399,
0.0012919094,
0.0701903701,
-0.0080088796,
0.0228361972,
0.025799755,
-0.0509112924,
0.0897745192,
0.0424604826,
-0.0247505456,
-0.022755025,
0.0260571223,
0.1143702939,
0.0138094695,
-0.0105835469,
0.0407509841,
0.0080079501,
0.0086223008,
0.0458214208,
-0.0375012159,
-0.0277776495,
0.0097064199,
-0.0079705296,
0.0177510809,
-0.0062917355,
0.0191642046,
-0.0127059277,
0.0077825282,
0.013433476,
0.0423450395,
-0.0220454466,
-0.0155896908,
0.0068575083,
-0.0849338695,
-0.0150249563,
0.0166903045,
0.0226077307,
-0.0425559543,
0.0063222498,
-0.036802277,
-0.0552553199,
0.0618831813,
-0.0833502933,
-0.0091410084,
-0.0058447928,
-0.0016402254,
0.0496452413,
-0.0536390282,
0.025837766,
-0.0343670696,
0.0546561629,
-0.0545526892,
-0.0319247693,
-0.0431540683,
-0.0554027334,
-0.0433276519,
0.0456266217,
0.0310869906,
-0.0271682143,
-0.0130060138,
0.0335011296,
0.0149835711,
-0.0047195856,
-0.0000265986,
0.0650730506,
-0.0064542796,
0.0158325657,
0.0357544497,
0.0062847724,
-0.0998700783,
0.0363465473,
0.0182842501,
0.0313971825,
-0.0168393627,
0.0194270592,
0.031777963,
-0.0175633524,
0.0090977205,
0.0009958043,
-0.0351294614,
-0.0256270207,
0.010149166,
-0.0479373783,
-0.0389948897,
-0.022062825,
0.0165732689,
-0.0655412301,
0.0708500221,
0.0092433086,
-0.0381306931,
-0.0116408207,
0.0098471399,
0.046036955,
-0.0354487561,
0.048125729,
0.017454477,
-0.0341318585,
0.0769104585,
0.061153926,
0.0277703777,
0.0508348197,
-0.0014236722,
-0.0315562785,
0.0324357376,
-0.0083868746,
-0.002836901,
-0.0175768938,
0.0433588885,
0.0127439173,
0.0506105796,
0.0222638492,
0.0515677966,
0.0449207537,
0.024369223,
0.039620243,
-0.0471356772,
-0.0483770147,
0.0003376144,
0.0389650799,
0.0048827506,
-0.0044554733,
0.0280629322,
0.0484288596,
-0.0266597662,
-0.0114318207,
0.0111749042,
0.0296594631,
-0.0113325836,
-0.0107504949,
0.0901945755,
-0.0173998643,
-0.0559869595,
-0.0045987722,
0.0004282126,
-0.0112428656,
-0.0172626078,
-0.0388641618,
0.02110333,
0.0306830481,
-0.0272293426,
0.062698938,
0.0069390754,
-0.0217638556,
0.0058604642,
-0.0075585363,
0.0313165262,
-0.0244036168,
0.0174384639,
-0.0110233976,
0.0068718153,
-0.0227294918,
0.0510683134,
0.0212834347,
0.0333125666,
-0.0464905724,
0.0111175897,
-0.0473025925,
-0.0218535513,
-0.0603319369,
0.0027722369,
0.0010316096,
0.0102214087,
0.0113319308,
0.0516501181,
-0.0472954586,
0.0188745372,
0.0218446869,
-0.0135166934,
-0.0227069017,
0.023860557,
-0.0135406852,
-0.0052408804,
0.0173726603,
0.0073827771,
0.0237174742,
0.0509591848,
-0.0418587029,
-0.0706338361,
-0.03651613,
-0.0856661052,
-0.0733341724,
0.0272567794,
-0.0461801104,
0.0286257938,
0.0136577217,
-0.0309753753,
-0.0520266853,
-0.000563033,
-0.0361775644,
0.0006887873,
-0.0390886702,
-0.0504561514,
0.014149718,
0.0069047171,
-0.0461465903,
0.0485342778,
-0.0201203004,
0.0509042405,
-0.0127352895,
0.0150315585,
0.0152215138,
0.0136377625,
-0.0095320381,
0.0070452774,
0.0133365765,
-0.0185626782,
0.0379940867,
0.0308877416,
-0.049815692,
-0.0348361917,
-0.0771554112,
-0.0128089599,
-0.0257802084,
0.0072949887,
0.0356071256,
-0.0016241093,
0.0462434143,
-0.0109231276,
-0.090391092,
-0.0295704231,
0.0021547256,
0.0394430086,
0.0669017211,
0.0165928286,
-0.0275774859,
-0.0191424713,
-0.0167480819,
-0.0157826468,
0.074713394,
0.0077995867,
-0.01539768,
-0.0146133052,
0.0046444028,
-0.015506533,
-0.0374914631,
-0.0131762102,
-0.001855601,
0.0115691181,
-0.0248601865,
0.0619437285,
0.0061585754,
0.0178227611,
-0.0090380954,
0.0386592261,
0.0315930769,
-0.0481021143,
-0.0229434092,
-0.0342283733,
-0.0191364326,
-0.0127277523,
-0.0134302881,
0.0162582435,
0.0636575073,
-0.0023445671,
-0.0177281313,
-0.0545725487,
-0.001136535,
-0.0001721754,
0.0010732515,
-0.0744895339,
-0.0149235576,
0.0144353416,
-0.0125936856,
-0.0230016317,
-0.0175411142,
0.071021542,
-0.0033304163,
-0.0267247539,
-0.0339894593,
-0.0069007529,
-0.0432070307,
0.0402465127,
-0.0161479488,
0.029822113,
0.0123960404,
-0.0211916864,
-0.0325619578,
0.022509383,
0.017786542,
-0.0347023346,
-0.0171901602,
0.0261833146,
0.017755894,
-0.0038261537,
-0.0262593646,
-0.020110717,
-0.0428383499,
0.0163650885,
0.0297218952,
0.0346164517,
-0.0027402472,
0.0231900569,
-0.0143126892,
0.00882845,
0.0088241193,
0.0071419626,
-0.0166568216,
0.0091592139,
0.1154878959,
0.0672310889,
0.0155647453,
-0.0197427999,
-0.0218507126,
0.0280298591,
0.0642428473,
0.0651827455,
0.0038420425,
0.0195461977,
0.0002011133,
-0.0037835268,
-0.024945071,
-0.0342276841,
-0.0175665915,
0.0315894,
0.0093205599,
-0.0276893061,
0.0949453861,
0.0475852489,
-0.0352406688,
0.0041145422,
-0.0213297345,
0.039619714,
0.0431816764,
0.0059329229,
-0.0833948925,
-0.0163879227,
-0.0355235822,
0.0298249982,
0.0319180861,
-0.0355345011,
0.0107488278,
-0.069800362,
0.0009509987,
-0.0100844866,
-0.0532026179,
-0.0386989266,
-0.0777733177,
-0.0304291099,
0.0162361152,
-0.0379351787,
-0.0089540975,
0.0074235885,
0.0093515702,
0.0223591328,
-0.0215064511,
-0.0163537078,
0.0209002793,
-0.0444201753,
0.0504998975,
0.0209014285,
0.0292632505,
0.0127292294,
-0.0196817257,
0.0100701023,
-0.0165050961,
-0.0505102798,
-0.0005513073,
0.0061454363,
-0.0302127488,
0.0005370723,
-0.0075477134,
0.0596730076,
-0.0708082467,
0.0022231869,
0.0119069833,
0.068467319,
-0.0030059861,
-0.0519197807,
-0.018268317,
0.0075165411,
-0.0033602046,
0.0799564347,
0.0347960442,
-0.0244308617,
-0.0216986928,
0.0186375361,
0.0091229882,
-0.0249785893,
-0.0417625345,
0.0151684126,
0.0382480808,
0.0213525984,
-0.0779525042,
-0.0676553473,
0.0292253289,
0.0122222491,
-0.0547981896,
0.0027806233,
-0.052805312,
-0.0349697396,
-0.0309010223,
-0.006836012,
-0.0264886897,
-0.0181361008,
-0.0201860964,
-0.0130207231,
0.040796373,
0.0044513037,
-0.0551784188,
-0.0081750415,
-0.0715917274,
-0.0503428504,
-0.0272341687,
0.0209090095,
-0.0023157008,
0.013636847,
-0.0312697403,
-0.0311715547,
0.0637341589,
0.0422126204,
-0.0739437491,
0.011424914,
0.0179100242,
-0.0193982758,
0.004745503,
0.0579941347,
-0.0743475035,
0.0009795305,
-0.0097047696,
0.0719015598,
-0.0275425464,
-0.0533022992,
-0.001474243,
0.0026866498,
0.0041201799,
-0.0064486014,
0.0531985499,
-0.0510344207,
-0.0007284841,
-0.0089725954,
-0.0167127755,
-0.0382329188,
0.0181753412,
0.0229531843,
-0.054255791,
-0.011199777,
0.034882281,
-0.0142346062,
0.0832171962,
-0.0053980541,
-0.0058190445,
0.0549655035,
0.009361377,
0.003086094,
-0.0037759212,
-0.036468666,
-0.001511095,
0.0076767104,
0.022439843,
-0.0309159365,
0.0267812647,
0.0322444849,
-0.025548948,
-0.0019468337,
-0.0011704183,
-0.0946687609,
-0.0050094519,
-0.0351357162,
0.0298812278,
0.0258964561,
0.0107305069,
0.0286568739,
-0.0173550211,
-0.0329237394,
-0.0302014165,
0.0415606759,
0.0186291784,
-0.0444390438,
0.0584608391,
0.0205550808,
-0.0348003469,
0.0303491466,
0.0973369107,
0.062755473,
0.0392045975,
-0.0350096822,
-0.0185876917,
-0.034215983,
0.0058699972,
0.0527968593,
0.0419716053,
-0.0339736789,
0.0246170145,
-0.0000543099,
-0.021007115,
0.0398915485,
-0.0266169384,
-0.0383808017,
0.0442154035,
0.0483942702,
0.0649171025,
0.0061878571,
-0.0166698135,
-0.0473032743,
0.0126738409,
-0.0061482023,
-0.0542065203,
-0.0070817717,
-6.27185819e-33,
-0.0171834044,
-0.0350248106,
-0.018736681,
0.001106246,
0.0214786623,
0.0050374391,
-0.0344140418,
0.0066969171,
-0.0094777253,
0.033402767,
0.0023323738,
0.0179231744,
-0.0218384396,
0.035911452,
0.0156978555,
-0.0503825024,
0.0229900982,
-0.0107802702,
-0.0043523237,
0.0569656081,
0.0224650651,
0.0239075646,
0.0524828136,
-0.0347221382,
0.0553806461,
-0.06390322,
0.0281176027,
-0.0118720988,
0.0257571451,
0.0579089075,
-0.0206628945,
0.0654309392,
0.0377003364,
-0.0345080569,
0.0131181553,
0.0559019148,
-0.1086228415,
-0.0252976082,
-0.0551329553,
-0.0430941544,
-0.0746916756,
-0.0335712768,
0.0232388265,
-0.0073900283,
0.0587860718,
-0.0040312889,
0.0606399067,
0.0206977203,
-0.0394477434,
-0.0955068991,
-0.0289247669,
0.0050878148,
-0.0296637937,
0.0077146254,
-0.067691341,
0.0687347054,
0.0190422274,
0.0442641899,
-0.0332380347,
-0.0239744131,
-0.0230814051,
0.0209949836,
-0.0039890166,
0.0292602014,
-0.0087854574,
0.0228763819,
-0.0027528056,
-0.0137749985,
-0.0253917724,
0.0044756648,
0.0122430483,
-0.0102463169,
0.039736554,
0.048075892,
0.0006993291,
0.001263004,
-0.0892888904,
0.0379431061,
0.0047966791,
-0.0135699715,
0.0115128839,
-0.0018688564,
-0.0051386561,
-0.0344498344,
-0.0667142197,
0.0144165959,
-0.0293044541,
-0.0174816046,
0.0303865094,
0.043835666,
-0.0387882218,
0.0129164038,
0.0052612312,
-0.0193474926,
-0.0142308716,
0.0654972717,
-0.0105329771,
-0.0052724103,
0.0056370096,
0.0341005959,
-0.0444945134,
0.0043559521,
0.0553367399,
-0.0155345844,
-0.0118486099,
-0.0156808347,
0.040355213,
-0.0222968068,
-0.0661852509,
-0.0293659605,
-0.0226800498,
-0.0321806557,
-0.0282286461,
-0.0143524045,
0.0190025829,
0.0187222101,
-0.012696567,
0.0554322265,
0.0087980339,
0.0567196608,
0.008993038,
-0.0318854973,
0.0157149564,
0.0188844223,
-0.0039497083,
0.0208565518,
-0.0472841039,
0.0267590713,
0.0161356367,
-0.0470045581,
-0.0003207476,
-0.0059400015,
2.309e-7,
0.0558569022,
0.0182954744,
0.0015390959,
-0.0348256156,
-0.0105095226,
0.0422340222,
0.0356309637,
0.0744430423,
-0.033915367,
-0.0588930734,
0.0215329621,
0.0508656725,
0.0001334366,
0.031196842,
-0.0853647068,
-0.0182995759,
-0.1057027057,
0.0150272809,
-0.033023335,
-0.0138961961,
0.061422728,
0.0673863888,
0.0017878215,
-0.0128128249,
-0.0264529064,
-0.0499400608,
0.0832536072,
0.0125046596,
-0.0171654858,
0.0199982561,
0.0199396927,
0.0119814957,
0.041622445,
-0.0080458997,
-0.0384967402,
0.011924332,
0.0604901426,
0.0597074702,
0.0208691917,
-0.0400904901,
0.000963758,
-0.0337109715,
0.0063568372,
-0.0173504669,
0.0926458463,
-0.0652918741,
-0.0069507468,
-0.0382261202,
-0.0350342244,
-0.0184497964,
0.0511580929,
-0.0337322354,
-0.0243929699,
0.0143666603,
0.0113076512,
-0.0145557346,
0.0381747745,
-0.0849250332,
0.0212231148,
0.02081112,
-0.0417903401,
0.0057810787,
-0.0411150716,
0.022593135,
0.0354461372,
0.0094803367,
0.0177391525,
1.956203516e-34,
0.0142406272,
-0.0102380244,
0.0204148609,
0.018040387,
0.0137010543,
-0.0337171108,
-0.0374320708,
-0.0258338265,
0.0502247252,
-0.0684991255,
0.0078306319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19619v1 | Towards A Holistic Landscape of Situated Theory of Mind in Large Language Models | 2023-10-30T15:12:09 | 2023-10-30T15:12:09 | Ziqiao Ma, Jacob Sansom, Run Peng, Joyce Chai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have generated considerable interest and debate
regarding their potential emergence of Theory of Mind (ToM). Several recent
inquiries reveal a lack of robust ToM in these models and pose a pressing
demand to develop new benchmarks, as current ones primarily focus on different
aspects of ToM and are prone to shortcuts and data leakage. In this position
paper, we seek to answer two road-blocking questions: (1) How can we taxonomize
a holistic landscape of machine ToM? (2) What is a more effective evaluation
protocol for machine ToM? Following psychological studies, we taxonomize
machine ToM into 7 mental state categories and delineate existing benchmarks to
identify under-explored aspects of ToM. We argue for a holistic and situated
evaluation of ToM to break ToM into individual components and treat LLMs as an
agent who is physically situated in environments and socially situated in
interactions with humans. Such situated evaluation provides a more
comprehensive assessment of mental states and potentially mitigates the risk of
shortcuts and data leakage. We further present a pilot study in a grid world
setup as a proof of concept. We hope this position paper can facilitate future
research to integrate ToM with LLMs and offer an intuitive means for
researchers to better position their work in the landscape of ToM. Project
page: https://github.com/Mars-tin/awesome-theory-of-mind | [
0.0423463099,
0.0241434015,
-0.0624033585,
0.0369584486,
-0.0340052843,
0.0161807667,
0.0015800312,
-0.0058460222,
0.0312045515,
-0.0432244353,
-0.081788063,
-0.0249708388,
0.0279846452,
0.0091608707,
0.0703022629,
-0.061825268,
0.0291714091,
-0.0186079238,
-0.0143353604,
0.0013951381,
-0.0334674455,
-0.0014008845,
-0.0029773174,
0.0268000141,
0.017742658,
0.0022128313,
-0.0269494075,
-0.0199854728,
0.0463619903,
-0.0334253237,
-0.0448393263,
0.0091166561,
0.0220754314,
0.0514322259,
0.0000021624,
-0.0601548217,
0.0243098997,
-0.0129374592,
0.0446396358,
0.0011788697,
-0.0087598711,
0.0293939859,
0.0234062579,
-0.0034019463,
-0.036665298,
-0.0203357805,
0.0273452681,
0.0297956243,
0.0141405519,
0.0381116606,
-0.0111188199,
0.0019789501,
0.0093447054,
-0.0053757601,
0.0411102325,
-0.0368879661,
0.0373565592,
-0.0048116525,
0.0445006788,
-0.0059432816,
-0.0179272164,
0.0185946673,
0.0035062151,
0.013301353,
0.0213343371,
0.0262201093,
0.0025694196,
-0.022724146,
0.0092410035,
0.073130697,
0.0889114365,
0.0093575334,
0.0068607111,
0.0074466532,
0.0218394939,
0.0198698584,
-0.0274895206,
0.0431414731,
0.0104289828,
0.0036595203,
0.0009129398,
0.0237303935,
0.0051647644,
0.0310809128,
-0.0264959112,
0.1015064567,
-0.0382624604,
-0.0224388242,
-0.008379071,
0.0000268998,
-0.0370546766,
-0.067771174,
-0.0306531042,
0.0423808396,
-0.0157375466,
-0.0055814171,
-0.0190184712,
0.0436680056,
-0.0021591501,
-0.0254431814,
0.0954782963,
0.0385897234,
-0.0066854437,
0.0264163371,
0.0423049964,
0.0739827156,
-0.0353433117,
-0.0047588507,
-0.0114388261,
0.0233573522,
-0.0589681827,
-0.0005671468,
-0.0013114259,
0.0298283435,
0.0173258949,
-0.0336852372,
0.0098939994,
0.0405092016,
-0.0329511426,
-0.0128980065,
-0.0452439599,
0.000142987,
0.0336015522,
-0.0012572206,
-0.0159449112,
0.0204694234,
-0.071034424,
0.0299372338,
0.0046133809,
-0.0874611065,
0.01164719,
-0.0022579532,
-0.0079161068,
-0.010394848,
-0.0182577595,
0.0424716622,
0.0524011813,
-0.0388142876,
-0.0062325164,
-0.043029651,
-0.002119319,
-0.0805378482,
0.0132078435,
-0.0408448949,
-0.0193181112,
0.0223771799,
-0.0000663048,
-0.0290435608,
0.0060184812,
-0.0190690905,
-0.0437973887,
0.0394410044,
-0.0056222249,
0.0180256721,
0.0019775569,
0.0224278141,
-0.0028147046,
0.0098552499,
0.0186218806,
0.0052673123,
0.010384107,
0.0231082272,
0.0292148907,
0.0164740048,
-0.0154397925,
-0.0302039385,
-0.0038247355,
0.0121108769,
-0.0193779096,
0.0591435395,
0.0045070839,
0.0629076287,
-0.012371704,
0.0411984362,
0.077677764,
0.0808756873,
-0.0436844192,
0.0016836398,
0.0360254645,
0.0487911813,
0.0261726771,
0.0126130776,
-0.0590997711,
0.0363806747,
-0.0200645775,
-0.0246356744,
0.028306162,
0.0323863067,
-0.0370279551,
0.0033856716,
-0.0386636108,
0.0229050573,
0.0178946629,
0.0004885132,
0.0025583485,
-0.0422132835,
0.0187776517,
0.0088226479,
0.0167220104,
-0.0270320158,
-0.0311887059,
-0.0790207759,
0.0064136544,
0.0154021252,
0.0142261758,
-0.0054905182,
-0.0118713668,
-0.0181556251,
-0.0192825645,
0.0335764997,
0.0545277186,
-0.0043517938,
-0.0605518967,
0.0002601906,
0.0236480962,
-0.0454420298,
0.0309400093,
0.0073639047,
-0.0321249738,
0.0203007553,
-0.0195148513,
-0.0196379721,
0.0250468533,
-0.0014871384,
0.0066794148,
-0.0156665463,
-0.0820561647,
0.0295888167,
0.0488211475,
0.0187759213,
-0.0278337486,
0.0104120141,
0.0192603953,
0.0152214384,
0.0323982015,
0.0718620121,
-0.0105258981,
0.0537727326,
0.0326596946,
-0.0142164892,
-0.0171567705,
0.0471636057,
0.0465231985,
-0.0098293377,
0.0124558536,
-0.0517796092,
0.0186109878,
-0.0029108957,
0.0377632491,
-0.0763213634,
0.0136327455,
0.0021857675,
0.0683807582,
-0.0276562702,
0.013628195,
0.0376005881,
-0.0645108745,
0.0412979648,
0.0056000212,
-0.009967613,
-0.0079983538,
0.0041649649,
0.01492918,
-0.0034623756,
-0.0168204233,
-0.0543906875,
-0.0330968425,
-0.1299334317,
-0.0452608578,
0.012873685,
-0.0204470456,
0.0286871288,
-0.0235462245,
-0.0354814678,
0.0427761413,
-0.0220472328,
0.0531111471,
0.0351249315,
0.0439634882,
0.0103086596,
-0.018436553,
-0.0404044576,
0.0002527153,
0.040083468,
-0.0390873812,
0.0252058376,
-0.0135998465,
-0.043378558,
-0.031080097,
0.0832273886,
-0.0606043302,
-0.0045966688,
-0.0283337701,
-0.0372200832,
0.0464857221,
0.0063157519,
0.0042113261,
0.0658997372,
-0.02874065,
0.0459993593,
0.0662418902,
-0.0346882716,
-0.0337535404,
-0.0081041222,
0.0374090262,
0.009231871,
-0.035454236,
-0.0628052577,
-0.0129882591,
0.05596219,
0.0164877716,
0.0152892256,
-0.0422556922,
0.0788535476,
-0.040160995,
-0.0637839139,
-0.0162784513,
0.0085312808,
-0.0220897719,
0.0596531592,
-0.0082582524,
-0.0496352538,
0.0853410736,
-0.02142868,
0.0022320852,
-0.0019229404,
0.0161364544,
-0.0155052543,
0.0781398341,
0.0036611711,
0.0247637536,
0.0395615213,
-0.0041149114,
-0.0738607123,
-0.0454909913,
-0.0376848318,
-0.0056157066,
-0.0207802318,
-0.0429462679,
-0.0275537036,
0.0048295138,
-0.0193775501,
-0.0232714098,
0.0125010032,
-0.0719859451,
0.0179016627,
0.0102251023,
-0.0368922837,
-0.0062137274,
-0.0000739024,
0.0738027543,
-0.0036877817,
-0.0127774328,
-0.0127963275,
-0.0202585924,
0.0030687125,
0.0392540693,
0.0074959248,
0.0634433106,
0.005047461,
0.0051066489,
0.039675951,
0.0305381529,
0.0482613333,
0.0367336422,
-0.0028893049,
0.0357964486,
0.0460717455,
-0.0417091511,
0.0370911844,
0.0991680548,
-0.014781463,
-0.0317872539,
0.0975921303,
0.0172145572,
-0.0208265092,
0.0236944649,
-0.0259899423,
-0.0083387485,
0.020789085,
0.0136814909,
-0.021040231,
0.0244139414,
0.0232060887,
-0.0240055528,
-0.0513678603,
-0.0622815639,
-0.0069801491,
-0.0816181973,
0.0038944804,
-0.0011644437,
-0.0103607364,
-0.0425275303,
0.0144039178,
0.0367824696,
0.051478304,
-0.0036004507,
0.0004308979,
0.0019304333,
0.0125710173,
-0.015646765,
-0.0040867901,
-0.0552530549,
0.049077075,
-0.0348065943,
0.1004743576,
0.0164673068,
0.0587038957,
-0.0082057342,
-0.093921423,
0.0076172724,
0.0327221416,
0.0294151586,
-0.0071081743,
-0.0285694823,
-0.0188982543,
0.0130174458,
-0.0245809015,
0.0203641318,
-0.0402157009,
-0.0002743599,
-0.0083005,
0.0909479111,
-0.0345519893,
-0.0149836745,
0.0078692604,
0.0083582178,
-0.0042515877,
0.0512681343,
0.0445592105,
-0.0725663677,
0.0167656187,
0.0055238777,
-0.0193340499,
0.0601929799,
-0.0802611262,
-0.0085428962,
0.0272972248,
-0.0116296532,
-0.0367425568,
-0.0770392269,
0.0099555906,
0.0315635093,
0.0315331481,
-0.0267117042,
0.0168853328,
0.0095035434,
-0.019114133,
0.0233113486,
-0.0208788496,
0.0404670201,
-0.0041757934,
-0.001720509,
0.0363855809,
-0.0508978143,
0.0056646103,
-0.0216325577,
-0.0044333367,
-0.0714348331,
0.0459839664,
0.0119046196,
0.0356593654,
0.0065995594,
0.01317243,
-0.0496086963,
0.02342893,
-0.0427372493,
-0.0637518093,
0.1023288071,
0.0049874401,
0.0462456681,
0.0205148794,
0.0508777723,
0.0022457668,
-0.0160988066,
0.0088507496,
-0.0066326279,
-0.024602253,
-0.0193388369,
0.0129578952,
-0.0081443395,
0.0357592031,
-0.0053638048,
0.005941588,
-0.0260854028,
-0.0502384976,
-0.0227526147,
-0.0258883815,
-0.0635161996,
-0.03688078,
0.0409096554,
0.0764814317,
-0.013687633,
-0.045341365,
0.0001815951,
0.0156866089,
0.0239183605,
-0.0141347311,
-0.0123981684,
0.0206788238,
-0.0037000303,
0.0230964869,
-0.0190682746,
0.007840177,
-0.0710481331,
0.0180108175,
0.0118919443,
0.104125008,
0.0267760027,
-0.0668993667,
-0.0245677307,
0.0418440662,
-0.0576979965,
-0.0751417875,
0.0424119979,
0.0371696129,
0.0212273542,
0.0201510228,
0.0203468632,
-0.055699084,
0.0059869108,
0.0067556994,
0.0104367221,
-0.0022418899,
-0.0574866198,
-0.0266121104,
0.0182785112,
-0.024713926,
0.0086898999,
0.004406156,
-0.02192498,
0.0279640183,
-0.0038644837,
-0.0219612643,
-0.0216465294,
0.0563303232,
-0.0064976388,
0.0411896557,
-0.0068309908,
0.0378971659,
-0.1085235924,
-0.0523855686,
0.0291784424,
0.0180857554,
-0.0229217429,
-0.0391820595,
0.0228260756,
0.0612133369,
0.0134946313,
-0.0345488377,
-0.0269152615,
-0.007448683,
-0.0360629484,
-0.0089278398,
-0.0230239853,
-6.542551029e-33,
-0.0229041371,
-0.0326554626,
0.0085173231,
-0.006811446,
-0.0664202943,
-0.0231689271,
-0.0348533578,
0.0437012985,
-0.0310301594,
0.0012973056,
-0.0171451643,
0.0017102462,
-0.0012705921,
-0.0051363739,
0.0095310323,
0.0209386367,
0.0028986328,
-0.0333385579,
-0.0280185435,
-0.0102193067,
0.0105517693,
-0.0206074659,
0.0163726136,
-0.0929830596,
0.0562259816,
-0.0095684202,
-0.006519272,
0.0259826537,
-0.0225118846,
-0.0151067674,
-0.0407874472,
0.0364282727,
0.0406659916,
0.0170305837,
-0.0023881991,
0.0363255404,
0.0010425146,
-0.040763177,
0.0427431501,
0.0174066424,
0.0125924135,
-0.0595565364,
-0.016535107,
-0.0330715552,
-0.0577193908,
0.0197968706,
0.0178895239,
0.0004432786,
0.0234110802,
0.0442733727,
-0.0496068224,
-0.036613334,
-0.0031049319,
-0.0131899472,
-0.0018403905,
-0.0071631861,
-0.0058597024,
-0.0227536596,
-0.087100178,
0.037197195,
0.0132291205,
-0.0133495359,
0.0512489527,
-0.0038348169,
0.056017071,
0.0841035247,
0.0991084799,
0.0251860954,
-0.0450233333,
-0.0189905874,
0.0412528552,
0.0445606075,
0.0229667239,
0.0101296678,
-0.0492604934,
-0.0142042534,
-0.0112285195,
-0.0259753931,
0.0219151955,
0.0388897881,
0.0531819388,
-0.0096234409,
-0.046408955,
-0.0186218284,
-0.0233352799,
-0.0823785141,
-0.025544567,
0.0130631803,
0.0121443607,
-0.019007517,
0.0025989851,
-0.032153409,
0.0435523875,
-0.0619159266,
-0.0310773887,
0.0036540038,
-0.0223800708,
0.0583693609,
0.0145773301,
0.0084347064,
-0.036526069,
-0.0299748387,
-0.0445224196,
0.0390887931,
0.0387150869,
0.0140848486,
-0.0258677527,
0.0265155211,
-0.0171421599,
-0.0094158743,
-0.0300777704,
-0.0103221396,
0.0049343682,
-0.0414804518,
0.0332769789,
-0.0023536282,
-0.0155988615,
-0.0203002673,
0.0294084456,
-0.0231680311,
-0.0406868532,
0.0522666723,
-0.0596802607,
-0.0018914838,
-0.0042101215,
-0.0096451826,
-0.044343546,
0.0521709509,
0.0869458541,
-0.0131288003,
-0.0028616046,
-0.0377378948,
3.051e-7,
-0.0316422209,
0.0553684793,
-0.044050429,
-0.0425096639,
0.0271562282,
0.075377591,
-0.0297823567,
0.0237037577,
0.0301186554,
-0.0471874066,
-0.0265301839,
0.0205043443,
0.0318295956,
0.0319744535,
-0.0454982407,
-0.0036290572,
0.0039913231,
-0.0081291739,
-0.0245147347,
0.0218775645,
0.0151805375,
0.0124008683,
0.0425032713,
0.0007209636,
-0.0191743802,
-0.0237266403,
0.0222996715,
-0.0494713038,
0.0319883861,
0.0125955446,
0.0040484713,
-0.020825047,
0.0156772807,
-0.0093212798,
0.0748139471,
0.0494563915,
-0.0353614315,
0.0225691125,
0.0057907151,
-0.0103017921,
-0.0065320092,
-0.0293501318,
-0.0383050516,
-0.07796143,
0.0364786237,
-0.0816887245,
-0.0642836094,
0.0175217334,
0.0304453373,
-0.0086429082,
0.0336407349,
0.0281944051,
-0.0140291611,
-0.0036384768,
-0.0006352043,
-0.0257966425,
0.0027423652,
-0.0682839602,
0.0037908093,
-0.0606970675,
-0.0268360693,
-0.0747713074,
-0.0327165127,
-0.0218561348,
0.0113902343,
-0.0858183876,
0.0023471892,
2.676501684e-34,
-0.0157355312,
-0.0111346757,
0.0386708602,
-0.0049771047,
0.0310306232,
-0.0102785844,
-0.0098896651,
0.0224570762,
0.0334421918,
-0.0921687186,
-0.013009103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19596v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19596v2 | LLMaAA: Making Large Language Models as Active Annotators | 2023-10-30T14:54:15 | 2023-10-31T08:19:52 | Ruoyu Zhang, Yanzeng Li, Yongliang Ma, Ming Zhou, Lei Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prevalent supervised learning methods in natural language processing (NLP)
are notoriously data-hungry, which demand large amounts of high-quality
annotated data. In practice, acquiring such data is a costly endeavor.
Recently, the superior few-shot performance of large language models (LLMs) has
propelled the development of dataset generation, where the training data are
solely synthesized from LLMs. However, such an approach usually suffers from
low-quality issues, and requires orders of magnitude more labeled data to
achieve satisfactory performance. To fully exploit the potential of LLMs and
make use of massive unlabeled data, we propose LLMaAA, which takes LLMs as
annotators and puts them into an active learning loop to determine what to
annotate efficiently. To learn robustly with pseudo labels, we optimize both
the annotation and training processes: (1) we draw k-NN examples from a small
demonstration pool as in-context examples, and (2) we adopt the example
reweighting technique to assign training samples with learnable weights.
Compared with previous approaches, LLMaAA features both efficiency and
reliability. We conduct experiments and analysis on two classic NLP tasks,
named entity recognition and relation extraction. With LLMaAA, task-specific
models trained from LLM-generated labels can outperform the teacher within only
hundreds of annotated examples, which is much more cost-effective than other
baselines. | [
0.0555328764,
0.023625154,
0.0266382601,
0.0580385253,
0.0124642318,
0.0650544539,
-0.0075589777,
0.0063466351,
0.0441524684,
-0.0937886164,
-0.0479050241,
-0.0231474899,
-0.0556755848,
-0.0329099931,
0.0287920311,
-0.0106303077,
-0.0054543572,
-0.0144664291,
0.0334108621,
0.0274197217,
0.0020362604,
0.0128149195,
-0.0285256337,
0.0135051273,
-0.0259292573,
0.0099359872,
0.0253511705,
0.0070877755,
0.0122486409,
-0.0626578107,
0.0360466652,
0.0353421606,
-0.0149393314,
0.0223230086,
0.0000018108,
-0.0416127481,
-0.0046884706,
0.0147342719,
-0.0629755333,
0.03691094,
0.0180717446,
-0.0121468157,
0.0142651582,
-0.004296544,
-0.0331909955,
-0.0822917521,
0.0406637676,
0.0592189953,
0.0456446074,
0.0765945613,
-0.0075953901,
-0.0233316217,
0.0296450406,
-0.0585554838,
0.0051693823,
-0.0717366785,
0.051064238,
0.018467946,
-0.0142007666,
0.0201090015,
0.0339952782,
0.024438886,
-0.0108686024,
-0.028875608,
0.0313552059,
0.0392179601,
-0.0515536405,
-0.0263759028,
0.0057745851,
0.1258083731,
0.0052291611,
-0.0024267025,
0.0293361787,
-0.0404135026,
-0.0225332156,
0.0007768258,
-0.0275812838,
0.0083361883,
-0.0179230757,
0.0570938289,
0.0362958126,
-0.0078535331,
0.0524254367,
0.0085422238,
0.0324974433,
0.0183140468,
-0.0088489288,
-0.0313615352,
0.0662132204,
0.0683757737,
-0.0441934653,
-0.0473842174,
-0.0054217749,
0.02699087,
-0.0192033052,
0.0465275384,
-0.0112355994,
-0.0294945072,
0.0214803983,
-0.0757946447,
0.0291903298,
-0.0000015103,
-0.0224123783,
0.0738355964,
-0.036711596,
-0.0081026154,
-0.0082977694,
0.0349301845,
-0.0351544209,
-0.0141591933,
-0.0647937059,
0.0095032891,
-0.0214753598,
0.0664242953,
-0.0032086601,
0.0088679148,
-0.0484120622,
0.0117248073,
-0.0128478054,
0.0318591185,
0.0350017436,
-0.0101510556,
-0.0162412673,
0.0113111194,
-0.009429385,
0.0004328655,
0.003871266,
0.030738404,
-0.0202421229,
-0.0379851609,
-0.0163641777,
-0.0062820632,
0.0255242903,
-0.0464248247,
0.0321538672,
0.0929344073,
0.0010606227,
-0.0903115869,
-0.0460085385,
0.0089639165,
0.0195451789,
-0.0453921147,
0.0019804183,
-0.030664688,
0.0413415246,
0.0111475866,
0.0183215626,
-0.0338944271,
0.0668693259,
0.0132683758,
-0.0615953095,
0.0751340687,
-0.0201638807,
-0.0039092717,
-0.0068667582,
-0.0068080174,
0.0058157863,
0.0881970972,
0.0311709642,
0.0074604754,
0.0547941774,
0.0206018407,
-0.0010970457,
0.0432011336,
0.0257444754,
0.0091591096,
0.0053061252,
0.012693895,
0.0084116468,
-0.0023562319,
0.0005359048,
0.0337437913,
-0.0074687311,
0.0305144861,
0.0339720361,
-0.0028059056,
-0.0342574306,
-0.0132828625,
0.0496503115,
0.0047614551,
0.0359399505,
-0.0363739096,
-0.0384021252,
0.0019851881,
-0.0130097233,
0.0025671616,
0.0084690526,
-0.0151491631,
-0.021245515,
-0.0228059795,
-0.036268007,
-0.0047367811,
-0.0269170813,
0.0393449664,
0.056306202,
0.0505347438,
-0.0359508321,
0.06374266,
0.0689025819,
-0.0137992166,
-0.0140320063,
-0.0092030484,
0.0054932362,
0.0326725952,
0.0305144526,
-0.058525458,
-0.0545096025,
-0.0290655009,
0.0518529415,
0.0279176682,
0.0371056534,
-0.0523328558,
0.0419464745,
-0.0438587107,
-0.0228843223,
0.0208969992,
0.0378467813,
0.0023707626,
0.0486332625,
-0.0085926643,
0.0193887595,
-0.0571829751,
-0.0423751548,
0.0600362495,
-0.0425384827,
-0.0741628408,
0.0403164998,
-0.0005055818,
0.0355163515,
0.0133973928,
-0.0162267685,
-0.0071871206,
0.0471344851,
-0.0470392033,
0.0119603137,
-0.0205847118,
0.0097055137,
-0.0460206047,
0.0310370699,
0.0124239028,
-0.0422661602,
-0.005766728,
-0.0646841899,
-0.0126073444,
-0.076251924,
-0.0054041878,
0.0409701355,
-0.0260845795,
-0.0002948251,
0.0106549757,
0.0256499127,
-0.045930177,
0.0669845045,
0.0073750746,
0.0322287083,
0.0215747245,
-0.0412068628,
-0.0245641116,
-0.0160172936,
-0.0399480015,
-0.0079417471,
0.0083780279,
-0.0222738944,
-0.0185810365,
0.0264463499,
-0.0526229069,
-0.0182398241,
-0.0815191641,
0.0205456428,
-0.0067938198,
0.0292632151,
0.0198965035,
-0.0027300096,
-0.0134749785,
-0.0246342327,
-0.0036901738,
-0.0100726653,
-0.0322047099,
0.0102430899,
0.0285034236,
0.0323708877,
0.00540719,
-0.0671166852,
-0.0022239781,
-0.0170154199,
0.0521424301,
0.0029066298,
-0.0293430202,
-0.0284126643,
0.0577653237,
0.0144480644,
0.0178940352,
0.0156061398,
0.0124074165,
-0.0286646839,
-0.0088497661,
-0.0297124311,
0.038530875,
-0.0162455533,
0.0699789375,
0.0181258563,
-0.0097220019,
-0.0506634898,
0.0284070969,
-0.0297333803,
-0.0056451717,
-0.0309514627,
-0.0409724489,
0.0008567251,
0.0856501684,
-0.0404299572,
-0.0046551926,
-0.0271721892,
-0.0130574824,
-0.01817655,
0.0024536646,
-0.0418814123,
0.0405983664,
-0.0105726877,
0.00083039,
-0.0318568908,
-0.0092368713,
0.0374755301,
-0.0315706879,
-0.0126023348,
-0.0066102329,
-0.0126779294,
-0.0393650644,
0.0419094227,
0.0139806354,
-0.004009597,
0.0287427623,
-0.0032321394,
0.0015852207,
0.0078943754,
0.0218658093,
-0.0309750196,
0.0164618343,
-0.0381884724,
0.047184635,
-0.0157399159,
-0.0147193559,
-0.0704032481,
-0.0400791317,
-0.0507411063,
-0.0063505108,
-0.0512808003,
0.021532299,
0.0030562025,
0.0002333861,
-0.0180031583,
0.0374867879,
0.0097992914,
-0.0101477746,
-0.0370236449,
0.0502273217,
0.04705026,
-0.0239893086,
-0.0014206881,
-0.0169867426,
0.0133086508,
0.0400664024,
0.0068282839,
0.0232955348,
0.0072601219,
0.0064657838,
0.0333073922,
-0.0382268094,
-0.0057775765,
-0.0049143508,
0.031475395,
-0.0318494737,
-0.0336062536,
0.0991892219,
0.0326915234,
-0.040077351,
-0.0082229171,
0.0428622477,
0.0000176149,
0.0438467897,
0.0428252108,
-0.0496437028,
-0.0530264452,
0.0035610406,
0.0216895472,
-0.0131991636,
-0.0590480231,
0.0047103912,
-0.1351890266,
-0.0011364594,
-0.0231514685,
-0.0435854569,
0.0328643285,
-0.0610443577,
0.0103364931,
-0.0522371866,
-0.0061762691,
-0.02868836,
-0.0068409406,
0.016709527,
0.0516679734,
0.0196759365,
-0.0805489868,
0.0277778991,
-0.0213709492,
0.0755608827,
0.0311440434,
0.0365137532,
-0.0057577919,
0.0029807296,
0.0511897653,
-0.0216000639,
-0.0406608768,
-0.0161925722,
0.0642971992,
-0.0259732865,
-0.0462561697,
0.0083787534,
0.0177965704,
-0.0597585291,
-0.0165214408,
0.0237079617,
0.0674531087,
0.0207536891,
0.0305741634,
0.0058681685,
-0.051344499,
0.025618894,
0.063248314,
0.0208075438,
-0.0387138277,
0.0066395784,
0.0067713559,
0.0034944525,
-0.0464084782,
-0.033046525,
0.0149376243,
-0.05858602,
-0.0099890856,
-0.0680781826,
-0.0431560986,
0.0764993653,
0.0438017137,
0.0268453751,
0.0171305668,
0.0220916606,
-0.0044583934,
-0.0640647784,
0.0277207363,
-0.0501073152,
0.0036910707,
-0.0209765099,
-0.0565826148,
0.0374842249,
0.0059520695,
-0.0406135805,
0.0059704245,
-0.0954406708,
-0.0594812557,
-0.0130412895,
0.0445271432,
0.0131106088,
0.0159344003,
-0.0043016677,
-0.0342832692,
-0.0074415118,
0.0698224157,
-0.0315355398,
-0.0253573656,
0.0187630989,
-0.017748408,
0.0178858712,
0.0436884612,
-0.0680444911,
0.0240225792,
0.0750933588,
0.0613642298,
-0.0374697708,
-0.0059280503,
0.0156427622,
0.0168408062,
0.0740118176,
-0.0095041981,
-0.0160949938,
-0.042852141,
0.0273669083,
-0.0066937502,
-0.0202555675,
-0.0476035438,
0.0361318327,
0.0102070896,
0.0065800538,
-0.0472289398,
0.0215347819,
-0.007362755,
0.0835852623,
-0.01228429,
0.0008656404,
-0.0031774794,
-0.0249056183,
0.0159679223,
-0.0145976664,
0.0022087875,
0.0249851588,
0.0555102155,
0.0354737677,
-0.0091992803,
0.0041890079,
0.0085998774,
0.0076432088,
-0.0329813771,
-0.0010170167,
-0.0353530757,
0.0201468766,
-0.05605321,
0.0905655548,
0.0765576288,
-0.0601048358,
0.0371108018,
-0.0175162237,
-0.0287015233,
0.0151151437,
0.0136709427,
-0.012148642,
-0.0166905727,
0.0412896872,
0.0302444417,
-0.0138978064,
0.0216613654,
0.0780470818,
0.0176696479,
0.0574606545,
0.0198003892,
0.001499207,
-0.0571646206,
-0.0050399248,
0.0130671877,
0.010352998,
-0.0038487499,
0.017964771,
-0.020281218,
-0.0725851581,
0.0022700378,
-0.0606829524,
-0.0467237495,
-0.0058060223,
0.0222144295,
0.0100844773,
0.0234403443,
0.0030048124,
-0.0535250455,
-0.0197809264,
0.0068179891,
-0.019219609,
0.000529576,
-6.150435134e-33,
-0.0319220275,
-0.0200923327,
0.0031558801,
0.0086274706,
-0.0027448402,
0.0358070247,
-0.0341323018,
-0.0058929152,
-0.0012737875,
0.0052109677,
-0.0173833445,
-0.0033371833,
0.0261577982,
0.0344711542,
-0.0087046092,
-0.0447006486,
0.0229355767,
0.0140242167,
-0.0044344212,
0.0099545745,
0.0104308743,
0.0327385403,
0.0578993559,
-0.1080637574,
0.0462788828,
0.001192715,
-0.0075657386,
0.0338317156,
0.0345831513,
0.0340141803,
-0.0446992144,
0.0384425372,
0.0093687447,
-0.0685412958,
0.0330258273,
-0.015435894,
-0.111543484,
0.0028802112,
-0.0122191506,
0.0216958895,
-0.01061102,
-0.0267654732,
0.0234060511,
0.0090325931,
0.0240724944,
0.0206596162,
0.0335642248,
-0.0547030941,
-0.0316014439,
-0.0510156639,
-0.0570443459,
0.0170924366,
0.0061210068,
0.0138235139,
0.0371759273,
-0.0133979861,
0.009068625,
0.0317843035,
-0.0545480773,
-0.039275948,
0.002751014,
0.0145092253,
0.006731452,
0.0290195085,
0.0114992447,
0.0528460741,
0.0271435287,
-0.0014084121,
-0.0293068048,
0.0135144852,
-0.0183235928,
0.0275789071,
-0.0117754741,
0.0442316644,
0.0369294323,
-0.0158217475,
-0.0798881054,
0.0131947137,
0.0363308229,
-0.0156848487,
0.0211821571,
0.0027962918,
-0.0347497016,
-0.0073055653,
-0.0357416682,
-0.0149553875,
-0.0243302714,
-0.0089670168,
0.0287512355,
0.0344013125,
-0.0534178428,
0.038770467,
-0.0159709491,
-0.051713746,
-0.0603470132,
-0.0096929306,
0.0189880915,
0.0044923266,
-0.0185599271,
-0.0292622149,
-0.0708516389,
-0.0624679886,
0.0107006151,
-0.0193326604,
0.0375882424,
-0.003198154,
0.0779283792,
-0.0046592942,
-0.0758986175,
-0.0078189066,
-0.0305525307,
0.0316600949,
-0.008837671,
0.0633756518,
0.0074422839,
0.0015813877,
-0.0135550946,
0.0655608177,
0.0546514802,
-0.0088814665,
-0.0119637335,
0.0164554697,
-0.004364247,
0.0146442624,
-0.0079087131,
-0.0090542939,
0.0098268129,
0.0072906255,
0.0073578167,
-0.0754885003,
0.0082984809,
-0.015857866,
2.451e-7,
0.0423786156,
0.0511126444,
-0.0175102483,
-0.0056085479,
0.0135735469,
0.0505681932,
0.0006982609,
0.0075672367,
0.0134078944,
-0.0427254736,
-0.0076123876,
0.0026701803,
0.0344036669,
0.0411633626,
-0.117030032,
-0.0383647457,
-0.0420162529,
-0.0106366435,
-0.0327574834,
-0.0058157407,
0.0318224058,
0.1145075187,
0.0404762812,
-0.0278815161,
-0.0229022074,
-0.0540447831,
0.0681215674,
-0.0244729389,
0.0126174418,
0.0334996097,
0.0152650466,
0.0511017777,
-0.0074731428,
0.0291143879,
-0.0230248384,
0.0181578845,
0.0255577266,
0.0807072967,
0.0064110444,
-0.0068420204,
-0.018156264,
-0.0066881427,
0.038961634,
0.0106073106,
0.0893735439,
-0.0762825012,
-0.0287264921,
-0.0146120097,
0.0073930575,
-0.020239519,
-0.0245942697,
0.0035499898,
0.0231696665,
0.0254716109,
0.0097699901,
-0.0289945938,
-0.0548417531,
-0.0825105309,
-0.0166779216,
-0.0048196614,
0.0000047853,
-0.0182977375,
-0.0171357412,
0.0073457579,
-0.0141344247,
-0.0534563661,
0.0195125658,
2.126389613e-34,
0.0075993161,
0.0003348491,
0.0052926023,
0.0699274242,
-0.0143513996,
0.000265801,
-0.0296186972,
-0.0011896589,
-0.030027898,
-0.0536199249,
0.0389005691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19588v1 | DPATD: Dual-Phase Audio Transformer for Denoising | 2023-10-30T14:44:59 | 2023-10-30T14:44:59 | Junhui Li, Pu Wang, Jialu Li, Xinzhe Wang, Youshan Zhang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Recent high-performance transformer-based speech enhancement models
demonstrate that time domain methods could achieve similar performance as
time-frequency domain methods. However, time-domain speech enhancement systems
typically receive input audio sequences consisting of a large number of time
steps, making it challenging to model extremely long sequences and train models
to perform adequately. In this paper, we utilize smaller audio chunks as input
to achieve efficient utilization of audio information to address the above
challenges. We propose a dual-phase audio transformer for denoising (DPATD), a
novel model to organize transformer layers in a deep structure to learn clean
audio sequences for denoising. DPATD splits the audio input into smaller
chunks, where the input length can be proportional to the square root of the
original sequence length. Our memory-compressed explainable attention is
efficient and converges faster compared to the frequently used self-attention
module. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms
state-of-the-art methods. | [
-0.0324200131,
0.0553181134,
0.0267207939,
0.018666802,
0.0392431207,
-0.0192695297,
0.0608672015,
-0.0083840173,
-0.0492615774,
0.0321149454,
-0.0417706855,
-0.0621084608,
-0.0115064047,
0.0230574626,
-0.0019343322,
-0.0822809413,
0.0088979108,
-0.0303218402,
0.0452401191,
-0.013712286,
-0.0252356902,
-0.0047639222,
-0.0226577185,
0.0309373718,
0.0071835853,
0.006961185,
-0.0231711008,
0.0124759581,
0.0219336972,
0.0064629568,
-0.0059922687,
0.0156987235,
0.0160011165,
0.0285671297,
0.0000021691,
0.0121060545,
-0.03815303,
0.0237507392,
-0.0306748748,
0.0264441129,
-0.024094265,
0.0342028812,
-0.0274925753,
0.0054516834,
0.0136950864,
-0.0209116936,
0.0397293121,
0.0587751828,
0.0701472834,
0.052747868,
-0.0069126566,
-0.038657926,
-0.0068352302,
-0.0430435948,
-0.0255031772,
-0.0081975022,
-0.0040347083,
-0.0383586884,
-0.0081285518,
-0.0090357419,
0.0204796921,
0.051920034,
0.0244618468,
-0.0309180524,
0.062571913,
-0.000449161,
-0.0052993456,
-0.0468453653,
0.024570249,
0.0529386438,
-0.0266095549,
0.0077634309,
-0.0008794504,
0.001976874,
0.0005873584,
-0.0357202739,
-0.0492684916,
0.0011428201,
0.0553971268,
0.0264777727,
-0.0617361888,
0.0358818248,
0.052165553,
-0.0120427161,
-0.0251205489,
0.0052380427,
-0.0099324007,
-0.0197067484,
0.0010128227,
-0.0115172565,
-0.0494677648,
0.0015983689,
0.0549684055,
0.0520015247,
-0.0028876576,
-0.0392979831,
-0.0043165786,
-0.0603870042,
-0.0565127134,
0.0278595202,
-0.0095898155,
0.026243262,
-0.0299944896,
0.012627705,
0.0012495954,
0.0164759848,
-0.003207183,
-0.0293610618,
-0.0211757794,
-0.0263456777,
0.0288307555,
0.0455181487,
-0.0243279506,
0.065785028,
-0.0566847213,
0.0207587183,
-0.0543496236,
-0.0434396416,
-0.0629963651,
-0.0012555923,
0.0691291466,
0.027586,
-0.0688437745,
-0.0332916938,
0.0484701842,
0.0594403595,
0.0062328121,
0.0278908964,
-0.0013477394,
-0.0010484073,
-0.0506749228,
0.0192382149,
0.0507237054,
0.0181010887,
0.006488781,
0.0291257016,
-0.0034752707,
-0.0427657478,
-0.0285622291,
-0.0121345138,
0.0029721197,
-0.0149708893,
0.0083230305,
-0.0388299562,
-0.0119607197,
-0.0435253978,
0.0074270801,
-0.052515205,
-0.0034858386,
0.0012338108,
0.0081170732,
0.0456608757,
-0.016572699,
-0.0089263692,
0.0418117084,
0.0302806124,
0.0026994562,
0.0059160804,
0.081979908,
-0.0240969695,
-0.0205185786,
-0.0513220727,
0.0129016889,
0.0298241843,
0.0388978273,
-0.0062194313,
-0.0292153768,
-0.0360739864,
-0.075069502,
0.0055263992,
0.0529385917,
0.0412064269,
-0.0015002887,
-0.0383273587,
0.0578184128,
-0.010398577,
0.0796263665,
0.0395811349,
0.0432522856,
0.0381507874,
-0.0476951934,
-0.0001344517,
-0.0400459804,
0.0637323558,
0.0136388354,
0.0139141036,
0.0210130028,
0.0172743853,
-0.0370478742,
-0.0558860227,
0.0395788848,
-0.0177708771,
0.0219747499,
0.0302866641,
0.0198076703,
0.041226957,
-0.0720482618,
0.0930691883,
0.0057969708,
-0.0476336591,
-0.0196765829,
-0.0276885107,
-0.0035315291,
0.0207269844,
-0.0149755292,
-0.0731862485,
-0.0315777138,
-0.0762885958,
-0.0266970973,
0.0568661392,
-0.0489701219,
0.0174817592,
0.0607631318,
-0.0559942462,
-0.0445934869,
-0.0205138195,
-0.0170729905,
0.0067702676,
-0.0091664437,
-0.0310398638,
0.0102509288,
-0.0055158702,
0.0412690975,
-0.0146351736,
-0.0301466007,
-0.0238771234,
0.0233503412,
0.0154905245,
0.0380414128,
0.0447851233,
-0.020053044,
-0.0081601311,
0.0321417004,
-0.0452498868,
-0.0050008819,
-0.0126484744,
-0.0931674093,
0.016557809,
0.0488242581,
-0.0165567957,
-0.0075475718,
0.0980754122,
0.026324451,
-0.050194744,
0.0496493876,
-0.0447778814,
0.0428357832,
-0.0306341834,
0.0192381628,
0.035894338,
0.0340917893,
0.0190413743,
0.0003003052,
-0.0121247936,
-0.0413006507,
0.0461874865,
0.0112696439,
-0.0322780572,
0.0013350153,
-0.0258119162,
0.0009301565,
-0.0244700946,
-0.0236196052,
0.008310535,
-0.0373667963,
-0.0247371644,
0.0110378303,
-0.0034269488,
0.0020726884,
-0.0351297148,
-0.0104146982,
-0.0384115316,
0.0182867758,
0.0388376862,
-0.0189523026,
0.0058931117,
-0.0253063701,
-0.002017248,
-0.0243575368,
-0.0185676757,
-0.0094798505,
-0.0257516373,
-0.0136146322,
0.0078017758,
0.0479093678,
-0.0091052977,
-0.035891626,
-0.0438337624,
0.0195102729,
0.0221706368,
0.0364961401,
0.0389484204,
0.0038440153,
-0.059045963,
-0.0353876576,
0.0206315853,
0.0384421088,
0.0322711281,
0.0023254324,
0.006804721,
0.0396585315,
-0.0188761428,
0.0165041983,
0.0361715704,
-0.0154261375,
0.0746552572,
-0.0181845538,
0.0119819222,
-0.030417027,
0.0666118041,
0.0102368351,
0.0187103804,
-0.0478230491,
-0.025584165,
-0.0180640984,
-0.0225922167,
0.0689298213,
-0.0491375625,
-0.0323159173,
-0.0044391109,
-0.0207935888,
-0.015832739,
0.0499129444,
-0.0145519385,
-0.0498565957,
-0.0113924621,
-0.0522795431,
0.0098927654,
-0.0034258156,
-0.0100983279,
0.0092987772,
0.0212141648,
-0.0431247838,
-0.0468939915,
-0.0150847286,
0.0261634607,
-0.0594003238,
0.0713710561,
-0.0402663127,
-0.0278693587,
-0.0049509453,
-0.0219904967,
-0.0510773621,
0.0135287894,
-0.0025006391,
0.0349547453,
-0.0039299694,
-0.0387151912,
-0.0719257295,
0.032519836,
0.0434194654,
0.0631365106,
0.0335897096,
0.0211316571,
0.0001341573,
0.0785218552,
0.0253160372,
0.0633073896,
0.0331542753,
0.0128210485,
0.060211394,
-0.0006922149,
0.0307334922,
-0.0364848077,
-0.0712174103,
-0.0213202033,
0.0022160814,
-0.0333027467,
-0.0241806433,
0.0138047719,
0.0623518564,
-0.0606070049,
0.0044858246,
0.0976887271,
0.0045676515,
-0.0301751439,
0.0181401931,
0.0594007075,
-0.0089040874,
0.0246975794,
-0.061266508,
-0.0175427347,
-0.025238933,
0.041180972,
0.0266051162,
0.0090040062,
0.03014284,
-0.0170638505,
-0.0582643934,
0.032023225,
0.0297659542,
0.0172282383,
-0.0230314452,
-0.0363540724,
0.0057900501,
-0.0501624048,
0.051572144,
-0.0207456928,
0.0003393483,
-0.0341135412,
0.0462831929,
-0.0219213702,
-0.0143140508,
-0.053495612,
-0.0380356684,
0.0673883781,
0.0173081905,
0.0111474656,
-0.0058533978,
-0.0554400682,
-0.0244789291,
0.0362435617,
-0.0167414472,
-0.0042900429,
0.0230730139,
0.0290529728,
-0.0002191132,
0.0379888378,
0.0572741032,
-0.0419518277,
0.0067059044,
-0.0077819098,
0.0627311319,
0.0026598673,
0.0216826107,
-0.0232490692,
0.0728708208,
-0.02999104,
0.0428831391,
0.0195229091,
-0.0039170776,
0.0233167186,
-0.0013832853,
0.0136172464,
-0.0629036725,
-0.0568671003,
0.0130885625,
0.023275299,
-0.0649981275,
-0.0019392044,
-0.0386197753,
-0.0333162248,
-0.015383617,
-0.0045306967,
-0.0116961598,
0.0093992325,
0.0258511994,
-0.0428974777,
0.0283436626,
-0.0057012746,
0.0020477823,
-0.0320826583,
-0.0013506018,
-0.0155322729,
-0.0218975153,
-0.0104384003,
0.0512813255,
-0.082307525,
-0.0214383099,
0.0406394005,
0.0073546926,
0.0110166511,
0.0588840283,
0.0182251707,
-0.0192194656,
0.0192862693,
-0.007510297,
-0.0778027996,
-0.0024148764,
0.1104598194,
-0.0319510028,
0.0059385244,
0.0490793064,
-0.0532071665,
0.0891674161,
0.0001525411,
-0.0146697238,
-0.0430084914,
-0.0194592364,
0.0183554161,
-0.0246908292,
0.0610192865,
0.0347187556,
0.0442422926,
-0.0037346608,
0.0531879142,
-0.0188126788,
0.0089978334,
-0.0409776866,
-0.0023479401,
0.0164493099,
-0.0127267148,
-0.0221764557,
0.0332033001,
-0.0022888593,
-0.0382082909,
-0.0456826352,
0.0633460283,
-0.0137108499,
-0.0651578158,
-0.0399840623,
0.0140793091,
0.0474843085,
0.0110776983,
0.0860591754,
0.0169604551,
0.0340124778,
0.0343506671,
-0.0248826891,
0.0159869697,
-0.0220516138,
-0.0021811805,
-0.0337232053,
0.0045083249,
0.0033577229,
-0.0384216532,
0.025195498,
-0.0648696348,
0.050111521,
0.0262925234,
0.0040707653,
0.0089679314,
0.0238723792,
0.014753852,
0.037389446,
0.0065649212,
-0.0163061563,
0.0181153007,
0.012114048,
0.0568397902,
-0.0305003095,
0.0144756585,
-0.0036536681,
0.0237403121,
-0.0370865278,
-0.0545727275,
-0.0447170027,
0.0312051289,
-0.0227921419,
-0.0040108459,
0.0127464635,
-0.0538896509,
-0.0258159656,
-0.0821004063,
0.022804087,
-0.0695353001,
0.0501906909,
-0.0161624085,
-0.006023325,
-0.0224817879,
0.0456734411,
-0.0551107936,
0.0345437787,
-0.0349599384,
-0.0018025074,
-6.318678865e-33,
-0.0136107551,
0.0223614797,
-0.0075608953,
-0.0024982684,
0.0010248512,
0.0109925671,
-0.0278034825,
0.0201223418,
-0.0255437773,
0.0330226272,
-0.0100675337,
0.0655017272,
0.0189504307,
0.0436904132,
-0.0184002742,
-0.0004934479,
0.1315084994,
-0.0220406018,
0.004249386,
0.0573421419,
-0.0003975873,
0.039931763,
0.0371260308,
-0.0227553546,
-0.0412869938,
0.0082691656,
-0.0182069652,
-0.0293524936,
0.0449272804,
0.0255416911,
-0.0011479947,
0.0275559667,
-0.0177602656,
-0.1076929271,
-0.0127823036,
0.0081075449,
-0.0540990047,
0.0150498161,
-0.0260282252,
-0.0129418978,
-0.0321851932,
-0.0548129641,
0.0928128585,
0.0432018973,
-0.01456773,
-0.0501429401,
0.0272361487,
-0.0274464432,
-0.0249030981,
-0.0658769906,
-0.0054703881,
0.0434556156,
-0.058284048,
-0.0814338028,
0.086345762,
0.0270166826,
-0.028833285,
0.0380479693,
-0.0720553324,
-0.0021601627,
0.0300310869,
0.0320719816,
0.0292283967,
-0.0114245536,
-0.0614680313,
-0.009372307,
0.003088668,
-0.0369320661,
0.0021156177,
-0.0180403534,
-0.0034659985,
0.0526093021,
0.0842969716,
-0.0454663634,
0.0312017575,
-0.014370461,
-0.0532903709,
0.0348801315,
-0.029497087,
0.0558662042,
0.0124038626,
0.0454309285,
0.0243000872,
0.0247099474,
-0.0294853095,
0.014543782,
-0.0256496724,
0.0015959522,
-0.0206151363,
0.0102772703,
-0.0035038264,
-0.024121156,
0.035717044,
-0.0095079243,
0.069202058,
0.0137698501,
-0.0054968535,
-0.0175891034,
0.0040937201,
-0.017601002,
-0.0439085737,
0.0182327963,
0.0791990235,
0.0332917236,
-0.0289414544,
-0.0530240051,
-0.0141722923,
0.0618273839,
-0.0585818663,
-0.0128292898,
-0.0428764448,
0.051227957,
0.0075758132,
0.0611746982,
0.0355162546,
0.002667971,
0.0087392256,
0.0331368931,
-0.0264679641,
0.0226793792,
0.0056335414,
0.031920936,
-0.0006613913,
0.0039771274,
-0.0195036419,
0.0126151722,
-0.0135106714,
-0.0420814753,
0.0300203059,
-0.0646093413,
-0.0296900291,
-0.0137220379,
2.878e-7,
-0.0322691798,
0.0206926819,
0.0093670804,
-0.0184788797,
0.0200120229,
0.0200824626,
0.0077973325,
-0.0209531859,
-0.0332741439,
-0.031516552,
0.0401883796,
0.016704049,
0.0416797437,
0.0244303085,
-0.0637212545,
-0.0668959245,
-0.05813656,
-0.0069854409,
0.0281620715,
-0.0080634709,
-0.037634369,
0.1022375822,
-0.0117707318,
-0.0309967045,
0.0122379689,
0.0309497099,
0.0181910731,
0.0115378583,
0.004759823,
-0.0221271832,
0.0536130145,
0.0052685235,
-0.0157787986,
-0.0215196591,
-0.0509130992,
0.0264446363,
0.003142508,
0.0540569499,
0.0063494761,
-0.0653149858,
0.0004097671,
0.0540118814,
0.0051864916,
0.001724829,
0.034845151,
-0.0081578726,
-0.0251469091,
-0.0071244985,
-0.0890619606,
0.0180841405,
-0.0231023133,
0.0086848652,
0.0020353443,
-0.038555894,
-0.0094731841,
0.0188801028,
-0.0175067447,
-0.0371636227,
0.0014567273,
0.0265737083,
-0.0348925218,
0.0343648866,
-0.0391004942,
-0.0974419191,
0.0002688307,
0.0299678296,
-0.0179998204,
2.093915204e-34,
0.0354088768,
-0.0502829291,
-0.0251789521,
-0.0059402892,
-0.0219564438,
-0.0165927075,
-0.0352735296,
-0.0082720043,
0.0134915905,
-0.0320766717,
-0.0312541872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19572v1 | Improving Input-label Mapping with Demonstration Replay for In-context Learning | 2023-10-30T14:29:41 | 2023-10-30T14:29:41 | Zhuocheng Gong, Jiahao Liu, Qifan Wang, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai, Dongyan Zhao, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) is an emerging capability of large autoregressive
language models where a few input-label demonstrations are appended to the
input to enhance the model's understanding of downstream NLP tasks, without
directly adjusting the model parameters. The effectiveness of ICL can be
attributed to the strong language modeling capabilities of large language
models (LLMs), which enable them to learn the mapping between input and labels
based on in-context demonstrations. Despite achieving promising results, the
causal nature of language modeling in ICL restricts the attention to be
backward only, i.e., a token only attends to its previous tokens, failing to
capture the full input-label information and limiting the model's performance.
In this paper, we propose a novel ICL method called Repeated Demonstration with
Sliding Causal Attention, (RdSca). Specifically, we duplicate later
demonstrations and concatenate them to the front, allowing the model to
`observe' the later information even under the causal restriction. Besides, we
introduce sliding causal attention, which customizes causal attention to avoid
information leakage. Experimental results show that our method significantly
improves the input-label mapping in ICL demonstrations. We also conduct an
in-depth analysis of how to customize the causal attention without training,
which has been an unexplored area in previous research. | [
-0.0033905623,
0.0454826541,
-0.0099489754,
0.0289610922,
-0.031848684,
0.0149931731,
0.0075842883,
-0.0244777035,
0.0040745288,
-0.0488308482,
-0.0263852105,
-0.0160574522,
0.0032557009,
0.0347565599,
0.05029843,
-0.0346057266,
0.0580150485,
-0.0214515887,
-0.0279628672,
0.0124210017,
-0.0130938692,
-0.0239592828,
-0.016563829,
0.030431699,
-0.0764805898,
-0.0285626668,
-0.0321536921,
-0.0083814319,
-0.0012113216,
-0.0530055054,
-0.0144616542,
0.0272636581,
0.0257575717,
0.0312518328,
0.0000020973,
-0.03212744,
0.0087179039,
-0.001339009,
-0.0159653369,
0.003216048,
0.0144627681,
0.0258013941,
-0.0097853085,
0.0367766581,
-0.0424439386,
-0.0458147265,
0.0371129103,
0.0688138679,
0.0563611314,
0.0755440071,
0.000208532,
-0.024129631,
0.0184908509,
-0.0498553254,
0.0196214542,
-0.0404910743,
0.024226062,
-0.0289359521,
0.03368764,
0.0273935925,
-0.0457122624,
0.0792582184,
0.0791711733,
-0.0186256114,
0.0141528286,
0.0616163984,
0.0171972141,
-0.0105491737,
-0.0351875909,
0.0571613833,
-0.0299300645,
-0.038931869,
-0.0166602209,
-0.0071442807,
0.0116893714,
-0.0345170461,
-0.0461858511,
-0.0124503821,
0.0466927551,
0.0118675986,
0.0321811028,
0.0082221515,
0.037913844,
0.0035758347,
-0.0236411914,
0.068285659,
0.0010127646,
-0.0503830537,
-0.0082993926,
-0.0199428517,
0.0155582251,
-0.0506272167,
-0.0214647632,
0.0491427667,
-0.0631492138,
0.049929712,
-0.0317841582,
-0.0386361666,
0.0049725557,
-0.0260868333,
0.0406835191,
0.0269420557,
-0.0030910948,
0.0561173409,
-0.0384077989,
0.0738517195,
-0.0211328883,
0.0717896149,
-0.0330557264,
-0.0044726562,
-0.0361071378,
-0.0268930327,
-0.0616533794,
0.0114748878,
0.0049841115,
-0.0411235578,
0.0083142202,
0.0574339032,
-0.0291174762,
0.0042491932,
-0.0104577942,
-0.0198302288,
-0.0438406281,
-0.0060445084,
0.0080193151,
0.0316046253,
-0.0569462888,
0.0205524974,
0.0202229079,
-0.0387832522,
-0.057556197,
0.0166301113,
-0.0086821793,
-0.0107788108,
-0.0255288761,
0.0740831122,
-0.0142111853,
-0.0408107452,
-0.0250083767,
-0.0010888885,
-0.0002792844,
-0.0309002269,
0.0117331119,
-0.0415915325,
0.025024876,
-0.0004837422,
0.0100483932,
-0.0589259751,
0.0167401414,
0.0294303447,
-0.0277223978,
0.0859236717,
0.0406831168,
0.013116139,
0.0093154674,
-0.0083139548,
-0.0076174685,
0.0649328455,
0.0305418074,
0.0059020775,
-0.0195074901,
0.0106820241,
0.022294892,
0.0431661159,
0.0634007156,
0.0329516158,
-0.0748746023,
-0.0076638549,
0.0606188737,
0.0662549883,
0.0396209732,
0.0178440437,
-0.0050159092,
0.0351796113,
0.0457654893,
0.0075812028,
-0.0106464652,
-0.0320572034,
0.0264578369,
-0.0088606505,
-0.0148836784,
-0.0131567847,
-0.0863823891,
0.037330877,
0.0415373221,
0.0193846766,
0.0405938439,
-0.0296188612,
-0.0290194936,
-0.0353006162,
0.0007974603,
0.0246016122,
0.0130686741,
0.0165673103,
0.0197144132,
0.0772642195,
-0.0443313271,
0.0436227433,
0.0265511535,
0.0123144537,
0.0283990409,
-0.0506285392,
-0.0149280746,
0.0259239823,
0.0251321476,
-0.0486566052,
0.0079411361,
-0.0419925191,
0.0721674934,
0.0554809049,
0.0211158376,
-0.0037377966,
-0.0216580275,
0.0019429756,
-0.0273414757,
-0.0177531894,
0.0322118141,
0.0207813885,
0.018292414,
0.0202026721,
-0.0073434706,
-0.0468697324,
-0.006675235,
0.0483246557,
-0.0481006876,
-0.0714187026,
0.0170950908,
0.0235936977,
0.0237309337,
-0.0064661312,
0.0153587228,
0.0390081182,
0.0408208221,
-0.0325350091,
0.0167542845,
-0.0089091947,
-0.0719129667,
-0.0875795707,
0.0282012727,
-0.0068236403,
-0.0465411879,
0.0263039432,
-0.042087432,
-0.0532046854,
-0.0086109266,
-0.025112154,
0.0777678862,
-0.0057712481,
0.0159391556,
0.0335585028,
-0.0034553383,
-0.0445285663,
0.0448101424,
-0.032783065,
0.0168765858,
0.0035139362,
0.0515621342,
-0.0381099619,
-0.0191750135,
-0.0052309772,
0.0034048685,
-0.0211715586,
-0.0016948316,
-0.0153268147,
0.0167741347,
-0.0459951796,
-0.037185926,
-0.026951218,
0.0075156987,
-0.0497386307,
0.0033081111,
0.0149256475,
0.0207752138,
0.0023830768,
-0.0524384975,
-0.0249578692,
-0.0455326065,
-0.0421294868,
0.0268713944,
0.0331973396,
0.037217129,
0.0080413399,
-0.0007466767,
0.0093492698,
-0.0149542373,
0.047218699,
-0.021887945,
-0.0099409679,
-0.0426398776,
-0.028383879,
0.0557134785,
0.0048102043,
-0.0227635913,
0.0015540872,
0.0173056908,
0.0053963484,
0.0321006291,
0.0705017298,
0.0105767157,
0.0335385241,
-0.003462034,
0.0019308282,
-0.0706338882,
0.0395614766,
-0.0196195673,
-0.0118066045,
-0.0323543362,
0.0151244644,
0.0165211521,
0.0732871294,
-0.0270751622,
0.0109357778,
-0.0381332487,
-0.0079416698,
-0.0129424213,
-0.0523515604,
-0.0448722057,
-0.0115200719,
-0.0836950988,
-0.028259689,
-0.0352465324,
-0.0397282466,
0.0521357097,
-0.0265083257,
-0.0147442222,
-0.0343848243,
0.0312801898,
-0.0035483197,
0.0569068082,
0.0268141665,
0.0007950079,
-0.013259165,
-0.0588100478,
-0.0257657915,
0.0208296198,
-0.0111667402,
-0.0063638575,
0.0287347622,
-0.018319333,
0.0133696413,
0.0245094895,
-0.0271820221,
-0.0715960339,
-0.0453332886,
0.0208735596,
0.0230465624,
-0.047030028,
0.0169649813,
-0.0498738326,
0.0052979924,
0.052519314,
0.0489327088,
-0.0094321566,
0.0030771014,
-0.0247945376,
-0.0083791902,
0.0432431586,
0.0009610837,
-0.0128433723,
-0.0291545726,
-0.008212192,
0.0069520953,
0.0972319692,
0.006230738,
-0.0030493597,
0.0008845457,
0.0021575799,
-0.02555703,
0.0073323632,
0.0354170501,
0.006587103,
-0.0831752345,
-0.0179572869,
0.0823191851,
0.011753493,
-0.0749903992,
0.0263746474,
0.029856788,
0.0258109029,
0.0410530977,
0.0242748726,
-0.0336682312,
-0.0269088484,
0.0367817469,
-0.009473986,
0.0220123027,
0.0010342554,
-0.0420208164,
-0.1251398921,
0.0063390443,
0.013989226,
-0.082077302,
-0.018467119,
-0.0345460027,
0.0273429751,
0.0285077095,
0.0337496065,
0.0074150725,
-0.0197438169,
-0.0114678666,
0.0315280333,
0.026588114,
-0.0811551437,
-0.0025343979,
-0.0131369578,
0.0525745787,
0.0497931279,
0.0193215124,
-0.001000908,
-0.0050243987,
0.0804999471,
0.011945704,
0.0113622742,
-0.0132391909,
0.0164970513,
-0.041117277,
-0.0118691344,
0.0216398984,
0.0433858968,
-0.020888675,
-0.0317874961,
-0.0081612831,
0.0867168456,
0.001917021,
0.024361806,
-0.009500159,
-0.0685161278,
0.0561333224,
0.0671724454,
0.0544063672,
-0.0533123724,
-0.0291726515,
-0.0233790744,
-0.007838632,
-0.011114385,
-0.0201137587,
-0.001274859,
0.0101086888,
-0.0259417556,
-0.0427656882,
-0.0686327517,
0.025412634,
0.0513441637,
0.0053067966,
0.0276668482,
-0.0127677387,
-0.0464537628,
-0.0270652827,
0.0335872956,
-0.044300124,
0.0543700084,
-0.0680380166,
-0.0039221314,
0.0108609917,
-0.0189174712,
-0.0295103043,
0.0168808736,
-0.0715329275,
-0.0483086742,
0.0171977896,
0.0357361957,
0.0068398989,
0.0944574401,
-0.0408962779,
-0.045788426,
0.0648000762,
0.0309418403,
-0.0113101881,
0.0055006105,
0.0116814431,
0.0013375572,
0.0013243192,
0.0482410081,
-0.0484223217,
-0.0075776242,
0.027552478,
0.073635146,
-0.0176099911,
0.0006517302,
0.02660303,
-0.035250023,
0.0743051469,
-0.0153651685,
0.0120401466,
-0.0330869891,
0.0333259441,
0.0007901565,
-0.0339716226,
-0.0222338736,
0.0115687689,
0.0008699158,
0.00292231,
-0.0054939119,
-0.0228792727,
0.0157378633,
0.016065564,
-0.005975524,
0.0107933562,
0.0137723358,
-0.0034455424,
0.0123659205,
0.0425247848,
-0.0195717607,
-0.0187275615,
0.0173030626,
0.0243988987,
-0.0295392945,
0.0411051996,
0.0714090094,
-0.0075025526,
-0.0251652487,
-0.0023601626,
-0.0663052201,
-0.0018350747,
-0.0403702669,
0.0174781289,
0.0419984236,
-0.0069119548,
0.0402638987,
-0.0300048832,
-0.001033893,
-0.0071265553,
0.0087325089,
-0.0118539492,
-0.0610655732,
0.0158054698,
0.0210122019,
0.0047072908,
0.0104480684,
0.0567853115,
0.0286381878,
0.0173168182,
-0.005350552,
0.054847531,
-0.0207641199,
-0.0163407195,
0.0352719799,
0.0125380894,
-0.0076311775,
0.0326554477,
-0.0344698243,
-0.0667197853,
-0.029588908,
-0.0128940353,
-0.056197267,
-0.0192780439,
0.0423985086,
0.0176352635,
-0.0043103546,
-0.024828719,
-0.0279567707,
0.0026731514,
0.0580651909,
-0.0713386685,
-0.0096953269,
-6.55238404e-33,
-0.0315300189,
-0.0280712452,
0.0067787077,
-0.0293563642,
-0.0308724213,
0.0014876089,
-0.0561481416,
-0.0108780367,
-0.0192044396,
0.0327117816,
-0.0476896428,
0.0044929795,
0.0177857988,
0.031117402,
0.0187124014,
-0.0162394959,
0.0494683087,
0.0037903367,
-0.0213649906,
0.0347218178,
-0.0240711961,
0.0499900244,
0.0659664497,
-0.050305631,
0.023516247,
-0.0023473701,
-0.0288162455,
0.0400193147,
-0.0102980193,
0.0443022773,
-0.0044465112,
0.0288483351,
0.0187810753,
-0.0886379406,
-0.0405664183,
0.0482434966,
-0.1040074453,
-0.0429185368,
-0.0034804016,
0.0302321315,
-0.0535562225,
0.0092674969,
0.0520582423,
-0.0170467552,
0.0247354992,
-0.0123545695,
0.0269912574,
0.0085781896,
-0.0663425326,
-0.0013876565,
-0.0390089974,
0.0076911068,
0.0265611447,
-0.0297373328,
0.0038857511,
0.0164718367,
-0.0130907167,
-0.0201857947,
-0.0539644994,
-0.0081459172,
0.0075919065,
0.0462517105,
0.0457275733,
0.057716962,
0.0311422404,
0.0379811674,
-0.0339489393,
0.0172981899,
0.0146839097,
-0.0550613254,
0.0471685603,
-0.0000060718,
-0.0020797472,
0.0160869826,
0.0538200065,
0.0071865544,
0.0019785659,
-0.0406856611,
0.0107101044,
0.0550332442,
0.0215582605,
0.0023092588,
-0.0425174721,
-0.0196157917,
-0.0706876293,
0.0309936628,
-0.0331910364,
-0.0225995462,
0.0748772994,
0.0407269076,
-0.0057800501,
-0.0020265286,
0.0329517685,
-0.0343094096,
-0.0635886863,
0.0348615982,
0.0197915435,
0.0316234045,
-0.0176201742,
0.0200340655,
-0.0645252988,
-0.0285952445,
-0.0075856028,
0.0042028311,
0.0176669583,
-0.0024686628,
0.0585604198,
0.0379034169,
-0.0808743834,
-0.0060129398,
-0.0452964418,
0.0144635681,
0.0071494784,
-0.0289031509,
0.0768619552,
0.0010679016,
-0.0169748776,
0.0662842095,
0.0171152279,
-0.0213535521,
0.0066137933,
-0.0168961901,
-0.0308005102,
0.0149729773,
-0.0544494241,
0.006975899,
-0.0322029516,
0.0547475219,
0.0323226042,
-0.0558338203,
-0.0059073358,
0.0394823849,
2.823e-7,
0.0199591536,
0.0390353985,
0.0168711599,
0.0288028531,
0.0317417718,
0.0235669538,
-0.0333770439,
0.0612750649,
0.0051493328,
0.0064007393,
-0.0007253434,
-0.0011905549,
0.0597892888,
-0.0090240855,
-0.1049645618,
-0.0279973112,
-0.0732256472,
0.0362733901,
-0.0315870643,
-0.006182929,
0.0095273927,
0.1204806864,
0.043342527,
0.027161438,
-0.0054051816,
-0.0485624,
0.0448449031,
0.0042096064,
0.0231345929,
-0.0085430704,
-0.0457779914,
0.0274117477,
0.0143115958,
0.0097264573,
-0.0311605223,
0.018131515,
-0.0096997693,
0.022892911,
-0.0268060956,
-0.0634293631,
-0.0071392432,
-0.0006144194,
-0.002524975,
-0.0621847436,
0.0504365191,
-0.0855067521,
0.0076138126,
0.0095434422,
0.0059689633,
-0.0029510413,
0.0113886409,
0.0049295793,
-0.0269019995,
0.0202471223,
0.0326104313,
0.0258113649,
-0.0223504081,
-0.097331889,
-0.0642344579,
-0.0202408452,
-0.0526430942,
0.0129931094,
-0.0622328483,
0.0342377163,
0.024540117,
-0.0502963699,
-0.0201874431,
2.515071871e-34,
0.0209330153,
-0.034229707,
0.0108056879,
0.0347342454,
-0.0098773558,
-0.0037369865,
-0.0055024745,
0.0386343189,
0.0490784571,
-0.0618526116,
-0.0252041612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19567v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19567v3 | CreoleVal: Multilingual Multitask Benchmarks for Creoles | 2023-10-30T14:24:20 | 2024-05-06T15:30:09 | Heather Lent, Kushal Tatariya, Raj Dabre, Yiyi Chen, Marcell Fekete, Esther Ploeger, Li Zhou, Ruth-Ann Armstrong, Abee Eijansantos, Catriona Malau, Hans Erik Heje, Ernests Lavrinovics, Diptesh Kanojia, Paul Belony, Marcel Bollmann, Loïc Grobol, Miryam de Lhoneux, Daniel Hershcovich, Michel DeGraff, Anders Søgaard, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Creoles represent an under-explored and marginalized group of languages, with
few available resources for NLP research.While the genealogical ties between
Creoles and a number of highly-resourced languages imply a significant
potential for transfer learning, this potential is hampered due to this lack of
annotated data. In this work we present CreoleVal, a collection of benchmark
datasets spanning 8 different NLP tasks, covering up to 28 Creole languages; it
is an aggregate of novel development datasets for reading comprehension,
relation classification, and machine translation for Creoles, in addition to a
practical gateway to a handful of preexisting benchmarks. For each benchmark,
we conduct baseline experiments in a zero-shot setting in order to further
ascertain the capabilities and limitations of transfer learning for Creoles.
Ultimately, we see CreoleVal as an opportunity to empower research on Creoles
in NLP and computational linguistics, and in general, a step towards more
equitable language technology around the globe. | [
0.0143717127,
0.0956344679,
-0.0397218727,
0.0684304386,
-0.0114606647,
0.0694104806,
0.0233129449,
-0.0311224069,
-0.0097317761,
-0.0179285407,
-0.0321761519,
-0.1017360166,
0.0156528652,
-0.0202009622,
0.0271205027,
-0.0394080952,
0.0296088681,
0.0312198699,
0.0223696716,
0.0052995966,
-0.0268770214,
0.0295737572,
-0.0066389339,
0.0215872861,
0.0052966969,
-0.0082430504,
0.0157443825,
0.0210074149,
0.0050395699,
-0.0300634485,
0.0064912629,
0.0583467931,
-0.010024054,
0.0446853638,
0.0000019457,
-0.0491507463,
-0.0026434648,
-0.0212209225,
-0.0112718632,
-0.0077865603,
0.0434072874,
-0.059427619,
0.025008833,
0.0266316421,
-0.0603333227,
-0.0548408702,
0.0787973925,
-0.0525180399,
0.002865664,
0.037132442,
-0.0169953331,
-0.0078034559,
-0.008985443,
-0.0212491732,
0.0506062061,
-0.0545752384,
0.0225699563,
-0.0070089605,
0.0043772468,
-0.058452405,
-0.03464422,
0.0588035583,
0.0078507839,
-0.0136250509,
0.0270906109,
-0.0005046441,
-0.0021590057,
-0.035310261,
0.0000121567,
0.0808866248,
-0.0124792987,
-0.0279467236,
-0.0176003352,
0.0434923507,
-0.0352578834,
-0.0209028665,
-0.0394109003,
-0.0134260282,
0.0116885984,
0.0222612619,
0.0546427146,
-0.0093593504,
0.0668677911,
-0.0150649743,
-0.04284117,
0.0270665567,
0.0269971527,
0.0068795835,
0.031702254,
0.073449716,
0.0249575302,
-0.0009946309,
0.0098595554,
-0.0071872142,
-0.0229066294,
0.0319504961,
0.0434321426,
-0.0070235697,
0.0145038208,
-0.0303752534,
0.0170032792,
0.046373643,
-0.0165022742,
0.068731159,
-0.0365599729,
-0.0031039733,
-0.0218235105,
0.0389194116,
-0.0449403189,
-0.06735266,
-0.0655771419,
-0.0244354233,
0.0096329143,
0.010374032,
-0.0550996736,
0.0322647505,
-0.0106041254,
-0.0127395131,
-0.0064282147,
-0.0065792431,
-0.0007006224,
0.0052569453,
-0.0423166603,
0.0033604284,
0.0089676706,
0.043248754,
-0.0388606079,
0.0418130346,
-0.0296541601,
-0.1097873077,
-0.0134323528,
-0.0290208478,
-0.0522952266,
-0.0745862499,
-0.011457812,
0.0542245023,
-0.0554137751,
-0.0199090503,
-0.014246068,
0.0037199592,
-0.0190251078,
-0.0538147353,
0.0233935285,
-0.0790752396,
0.0613399632,
0.0268015973,
0.0788030773,
-0.0518029481,
-0.0031256287,
-0.0172145553,
-0.0379278399,
0.0697494,
0.0211724676,
0.0084675206,
0.0312795825,
0.0133685172,
0.0110476892,
0.0911914855,
0.0124154957,
-0.0778049752,
0.0539237224,
-0.0313215517,
-0.0830852836,
0.0120107932,
0.0086968755,
0.0266605895,
0.0088206204,
0.0311562642,
0.0350771584,
0.0337428711,
0.0148468558,
0.037001729,
-0.0067537255,
-0.0402313359,
0.0165421274,
0.0482232273,
-0.0100766392,
0.0524994433,
0.0715729073,
0.0314377025,
-0.0041598175,
0.007001271,
-0.0146414712,
0.0155343907,
-0.0148297772,
-0.0474036001,
-0.0351250693,
0.0365315191,
-0.0426573046,
-0.0136171123,
0.0250405185,
0.0251803771,
0.0081354082,
0.0042650877,
0.0271220058,
0.0319052711,
-0.0017197054,
0.000615608,
0.0825194791,
-0.0221393462,
0.0129602812,
-0.0335110649,
-0.0048603686,
0.0468853936,
0.0089335395,
-0.0041150749,
-0.0000952814,
0.0090461578,
0.0058551612,
0.007715256,
0.0174418204,
-0.0384537093,
0.082813181,
-0.0229013655,
0.0213768464,
0.0191775467,
0.0364191048,
0.0408250652,
0.0093922894,
0.058285702,
-0.001865854,
-0.020643305,
-0.0154837212,
0.0386045314,
-0.0527167507,
-0.0310196597,
0.0633708835,
0.0016413585,
0.016969353,
0.0211161133,
0.0318957567,
-0.0516026206,
0.0024712633,
-0.0418355726,
0.0465363301,
0.0602895282,
-0.0675138757,
-0.052358944,
0.0000613185,
-0.0526928417,
-0.0234501716,
0.0356521122,
-0.0011133294,
-0.0306417756,
0.0363654569,
0.0067388122,
0.0196483638,
-0.0516925976,
0.0179659165,
-0.0180592947,
0.0242532976,
-0.0231526997,
0.025282098,
0.0439824648,
-0.002273204,
0.0104456237,
-0.0308465753,
0.006054882,
-0.0055482653,
0.0015152764,
0.0356216691,
-0.0221103374,
-0.0214005373,
-0.0324915387,
0.0602674112,
-0.0460027605,
-0.0097240005,
-0.0630343184,
0.01607286,
-0.0194908231,
0.0261273477,
-0.0023999803,
0.0477741063,
-0.0042156694,
-0.0146110747,
-0.0108667528,
-0.0022039451,
-0.0051217098,
0.0010359694,
0.0264687184,
0.0024699839,
0.0149137257,
-0.0301562957,
-0.042261675,
0.0486303717,
0.070530273,
-0.0286036339,
-0.0055394513,
0.0062346514,
-0.0503685921,
-0.023498727,
-0.0536453165,
0.0235139187,
-0.0254624356,
-0.0266273748,
-0.0270765349,
-0.0152095659,
0.0160199758,
-0.012438111,
0.0258565564,
0.0023786125,
-0.0346818455,
-0.0607413985,
0.0305561107,
-0.0203564744,
0.0112732099,
-0.0462917089,
-0.0202794783,
-0.0174542535,
0.0879857615,
-0.000719229,
-0.0229859594,
-0.0219906326,
-0.0170652308,
-0.003154994,
-0.0517640971,
-0.0373138189,
0.0972832143,
-0.0197879728,
0.0053258929,
-0.052992329,
0.0018014309,
0.0746690705,
0.0161437374,
-0.0273004863,
-0.0435186028,
-0.0091711953,
-0.0424308069,
0.0440296493,
-0.0261112992,
-0.0092875725,
-0.0356457196,
-0.0357684791,
-0.0248465333,
0.0282375272,
0.0550970212,
0.0143795041,
0.050365489,
-0.0797077417,
-0.0082901344,
-0.0299788024,
-0.0532713458,
-0.0391804464,
0.0132081481,
-0.0212137103,
-0.0231496189,
0.045288641,
0.0155438222,
-0.0241608527,
-0.0479885973,
0.0171606429,
-0.0012217433,
0.0241282135,
-0.0048994888,
0.0169963464,
0.0632980242,
-0.0332827605,
0.0169203654,
0.0093938988,
-0.0218988974,
0.0238914695,
0.0034003346,
0.0114344079,
-0.0084526734,
0.0466775931,
0.0220244583,
0.0704990253,
-0.0164934192,
-0.0447670482,
-0.0280716959,
0.0516802631,
-0.0176184624,
-0.0348216966,
0.0456395522,
0.0314333886,
-0.0174472183,
0.0179587472,
-0.0158880204,
0.0430475175,
0.0097897789,
0.0154881105,
-0.0828504786,
-0.0113333734,
0.0041646976,
-0.0120121427,
0.033459913,
-0.0239134897,
-0.0318345241,
-0.0755786598,
-0.0015857852,
-0.0086827166,
-0.0462764949,
0.0044516311,
-0.0160000529,
0.0075600636,
-0.059385743,
0.0354928114,
-0.0058703148,
0.0169865936,
-0.0062113525,
0.0368299372,
0.0030598082,
-0.1040345505,
0.0210300069,
0.0010249389,
0.0039584544,
-0.0234075617,
0.0388876498,
-0.022630211,
0.000873227,
0.0126814395,
-0.0713185817,
-0.0400590263,
-0.0162859987,
0.0380283073,
0.0543273874,
-0.029099144,
-0.0078590252,
0.0108022075,
-0.0311637707,
0.0491536409,
0.0533422343,
0.0653459951,
0.0253960434,
-0.0335283093,
0.0143069793,
-0.067894429,
0.0203869864,
0.0385038704,
0.0354812145,
-0.0387802944,
-0.0525611229,
-0.0160417929,
-0.0329729915,
-0.0716537982,
-0.0424158946,
0.0184072033,
-0.0109202228,
-0.0330658741,
-0.0643619671,
-0.0753880143,
0.0447847582,
0.023831157,
0.0192598943,
0.0346552655,
0.0071435873,
-0.0217250995,
-0.0430619344,
-0.0032452275,
-0.0257155485,
0.0268006027,
0.0017656706,
-0.0403256565,
-0.0160915274,
-0.0570852272,
-0.0068035107,
-0.0452438407,
-0.1129496247,
-0.0460523143,
0.0059241503,
0.0086735245,
0.0218243487,
0.0301559214,
-0.0216652509,
-0.0321398973,
-0.049376253,
0.01485522,
-0.0652470961,
-0.0391999073,
0.0180846695,
-0.0459031016,
0.0092744762,
0.0643629208,
0.0178364851,
0.0331656449,
0.0174503773,
0.0402786806,
-0.0464709066,
-0.0345798656,
-0.0285074096,
-0.014235612,
0.0282680932,
-0.0260292292,
-0.0748169422,
-0.0323093981,
-0.0024151066,
-0.0212798454,
0.0196286552,
0.0095869796,
-0.0127703371,
0.0331685133,
-0.0027576021,
-0.0658087879,
0.0043008085,
0.0286428649,
0.0308899228,
-0.0250589624,
0.0293168295,
0.0232152231,
0.0044233832,
-0.0055243964,
0.0407406352,
-0.0088831568,
0.0275933761,
0.0040044659,
0.0760196149,
-0.0077170781,
-0.0152075104,
0.0203536768,
0.0076083192,
0.0334306434,
-0.0246269293,
0.0119072199,
0.0231308434,
-0.0068979897,
0.0381912924,
0.0753586963,
-0.0361005478,
0.0588017069,
0.0252522137,
-0.0256161522,
-0.0340173915,
0.0537640043,
-0.0223850757,
-0.0354394428,
-0.0099525675,
0.0050706239,
-0.0089143747,
0.0154955219,
0.0609185435,
-0.0101281283,
-0.0135273617,
0.0542330705,
0.0050722104,
-0.0246370379,
-0.0210982449,
0.0027015507,
0.00949967,
0.0075762118,
0.0331243835,
-0.0715449899,
-0.0651365072,
0.0054746158,
-0.0638174713,
0.0238246918,
0.0071999193,
-0.0280041322,
0.0443576872,
0.0073190387,
0.0012135806,
-0.0490211211,
-0.0132952556,
-0.0565476865,
0.0298917592,
0.020109117,
-6.120126482e-33,
-0.00111975,
-0.007176436,
-0.0057589281,
0.0005418952,
0.01196077,
-0.022451479,
-0.032161884,
-0.0066783791,
-0.0589870475,
0.0123347463,
-0.0186382197,
0.0162428524,
0.0219811592,
0.0495355725,
0.0568809025,
0.0277618542,
0.0047861086,
0.0287028681,
-0.0053822254,
0.0233431868,
0.0161371306,
0.0638757646,
0.0752618387,
-0.0606516749,
-0.0058570146,
-0.0004278607,
0.0137677016,
0.0215647481,
-0.0089715039,
0.0284253862,
-0.0563094318,
0.0598755181,
0.0393914133,
0.0140270591,
0.0003766866,
-0.046953328,
-0.1222800612,
-0.0454328358,
0.0215907283,
0.0362257138,
-0.0302746128,
-0.0344455615,
0.0055397875,
0.0274060462,
0.0231449995,
-0.0477553196,
0.0277631376,
-0.0533956811,
0.0030457438,
-0.0032919275,
-0.075835444,
0.0333368666,
0.0096097691,
0.0047389851,
0.041529052,
0.0776621923,
-0.0505601764,
-0.0518703647,
-0.0489138365,
-0.0440653749,
-0.0419373438,
0.0196112394,
0.0657993108,
0.0222886708,
-0.0307370052,
-0.0026432544,
0.0316519439,
-0.0287622511,
0.0127623668,
0.0437104255,
0.0458051153,
0.0222213306,
-0.0121798618,
0.100316979,
0.0619399175,
-0.0090284506,
-0.0317876786,
0.0213447493,
0.0042157862,
-0.0166875161,
0.0076761697,
-0.0278335232,
-0.0219487194,
-0.008288228,
-0.0330305472,
0.036209777,
-0.0088643609,
-0.0177537408,
0.0119955838,
-0.03029163,
-0.0057266629,
0.0478019863,
0.040772099,
0.0005928397,
-0.0457812399,
0.0060246084,
-0.0303801149,
-0.0237619281,
0.026578756,
0.0357853733,
-0.0770681873,
-0.0040806322,
-0.0217873268,
0.0423908383,
0.0150663257,
-0.014510355,
0.0583865643,
-0.013276956,
-0.0481076501,
0.003247004,
-0.0493962616,
0.0562877283,
-0.0312080756,
0.0838952512,
0.02739181,
-0.0037976471,
-0.0096040238,
0.0164078381,
0.030163791,
-0.0065111094,
-0.0355410427,
0.0303331371,
0.0030844007,
0.004615908,
-0.0337237716,
0.0086447308,
-0.0296677742,
-0.0003673646,
-0.0061980546,
-0.0212169401,
-0.005508393,
0.0040293206,
2.552e-7,
0.042210307,
0.0225248318,
0.0394980498,
-0.0020441215,
0.0031738633,
0.0043037897,
-0.0383955427,
0.0195758305,
-0.0075772442,
-0.0072210315,
0.0047969217,
0.0637437552,
0.1079650372,
0.059063293,
-0.0613229983,
0.0097961258,
-0.0224469695,
0.034614902,
-0.0214077868,
-0.0568624884,
0.0307320189,
0.0748317316,
0.0159440618,
-0.0380200483,
-0.0080562439,
0.0101334564,
0.0791247264,
-0.0316038206,
0.0152425608,
0.0114760827,
0.0104987985,
0.0464799069,
0.0031778251,
0.0287742112,
-0.0355130509,
-0.0183871035,
-0.0026834747,
0.0366533138,
-0.0145151448,
0.0104067838,
0.0019342387,
-0.0318565629,
-0.0200859271,
-0.0699652657,
0.0392964557,
0.0046044597,
-0.0197964944,
0.0581510291,
-0.0089288726,
0.0130284782,
0.0459565334,
0.0008435511,
-0.0146737983,
0.0225518644,
0.0212582257,
-0.0691746324,
-0.0288740937,
-0.0449846722,
-0.0179705229,
0.0570593067,
0.0005267964,
0.0140332021,
0.0392405875,
0.0166433621,
-0.0044529769,
-0.02018537,
0.052297093,
1.824057402e-34,
-0.0353492089,
0.0081360349,
0.034466695,
0.0210537408,
0.0064040823,
-0.0400975421,
-0.0498486347,
-0.0114207175,
0.0231717806,
-0.021654103,
0.0382029004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19539v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19539v1 | A Novel Representation to Improve Team Problem Solving in Real-Time | 2023-10-30T13:46:24 | 2023-10-30T13:46:24 | Alex Doboli | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes a novel representation to support computing metrics that
help understanding and improving in real-time a team's behavior during problem
solving in real-life. Even though teams are important in modern activities,
there is little computing aid to improve their activity. The representation
captures the different mental images developed, enhanced, and utilized during
solving. A case study illustrates the representation. | [
-0.0054024141,
-0.0317456461,
-0.0522030517,
-0.0055374564,
-0.0319157764,
0.019497335,
0.0141989235,
0.0187515784,
-0.0284781773,
0.0037251152,
0.0485007428,
-0.0028942812,
-0.021988865,
0.0533418208,
0.0131166624,
-0.1296657473,
-0.0055500874,
0.0009200702,
0.0277358685,
0.0121014304,
0.0182277728,
-0.0148194376,
-0.075143002,
0.0640751123,
-0.0499813519,
-0.0372432917,
-0.0414434224,
-0.0282871686,
0.048777502,
-0.0449660718,
-0.0544821955,
0.0054173763,
0.0237019621,
-0.0589923449,
0.0000019295,
-0.0000939748,
0.0012092926,
-0.0613483787,
-0.0028133711,
-0.0075939894,
0.0050727366,
0.004762941,
0.0163284875,
0.0168986823,
-0.0590564162,
0.0559488833,
0.0285008326,
0.0058821905,
0.0605305992,
-0.0177280456,
0.0039835046,
0.0533643626,
-0.0534268729,
0.0288169514,
-0.0030212805,
-0.0186488479,
-0.0277421903,
0.065355666,
0.0756181851,
-0.0363574699,
-0.0069410554,
-0.0341456048,
-0.0105688348,
-0.0101512764,
0.0235983916,
0.0087653799,
-0.0202044863,
-0.0104254456,
0.0065722256,
0.0022516402,
-0.0290055517,
0.0446412563,
0.0036533128,
-0.0121223656,
0.0431315154,
0.0339703895,
-0.0089009162,
-0.0107449805,
-0.0256222002,
-0.0279519707,
-0.0711620748,
0.0371351577,
-0.0257069841,
-0.0262701809,
0.0225932971,
0.0124440463,
-0.0114783607,
0.0047162645,
-0.0216697343,
0.0070335269,
-0.0413957499,
-0.0178347621,
0.0366643406,
0.0071215751,
-0.0664996058,
-0.0017777121,
0.0243861694,
-0.0468926206,
-0.0471548438,
-0.0283008926,
0.08335343,
0.0437724516,
0.0669340044,
0.0135999145,
0.0258643813,
0.0550298914,
0.0173554383,
-0.044623971,
-0.0415576324,
0.0052398816,
-0.115772292,
-0.017015025,
-0.0665586442,
0.0417280756,
0.0009977297,
-0.0459963419,
-0.0395656042,
0.0653720573,
-0.0474419445,
-0.0044642091,
-0.0014477142,
0.0520348586,
0.0386912636,
0.0327440649,
-0.0405724198,
-0.0161185469,
-0.0618483312,
-0.0148101132,
-0.0229121447,
-0.0122850845,
0.0312029235,
-0.0418483242,
-0.0212477781,
0.0198092218,
-0.0082763899,
-0.0012277196,
-0.0044264151,
0.0053602848,
0.0402701944,
-0.0146650784,
0.0278413463,
-0.0113240881,
-0.0069821398,
-0.0227015018,
0.0091092139,
-0.0284218863,
-0.0180955343,
-0.0095868949,
0.0164640788,
0.007420395,
0.0023437995,
0.0552962534,
-0.0343742594,
0.0428535789,
0.0111791929,
0.0210001934,
-0.0377027653,
0.0281267855,
0.0475941002,
-0.0063685239,
0.0032480559,
-0.0205247067,
0.0272872839,
0.00771371,
-0.0186489876,
-0.0433580242,
0.0146398796,
-0.0106635503,
-0.0297196433,
0.0372254401,
-0.0645778775,
-0.00686586,
-0.0249842629,
0.0535193942,
0.0470377319,
0.0218287483,
0.0724736601,
0.0019706851,
-0.028820172,
0.0088276165,
0.0050903424,
-0.0316542014,
0.017122576,
0.1270584911,
0.0244449545,
-0.0060358541,
-0.0455014668,
0.0366822705,
-0.0346231274,
-0.0194192827,
-0.0072847162,
0.0217646416,
-0.0327126049,
0.0084153609,
0.0084973508,
-0.0318803787,
0.0142076639,
0.027734749,
-0.0137068462,
-0.0207276326,
-0.0130957318,
-0.0288578942,
0.0169893317,
0.0642424151,
0.0366648659,
-0.0572080575,
-0.0704683885,
-0.0154458266,
-0.0285946615,
-0.0500256531,
0.0147014018,
-0.0001609834,
-0.0218773726,
0.0088502737,
-0.0322553366,
0.0215340406,
-0.008604208,
0.0350652039,
-0.0198338702,
-0.0168120209,
-0.0077688694,
0.0632672682,
-0.0015612447,
0.0264754537,
0.0215937085,
0.0576989539,
-0.0105388639,
0.0087396633,
0.0212664884,
0.0774901062,
-0.0103074955,
-0.013291562,
0.0428442582,
-0.0179727953,
0.0008669592,
0.0644030869,
0.0096973507,
0.0438692905,
0.0379155912,
-0.0619512312,
-0.0115069142,
0.0307720825,
-0.0051020053,
-0.0052287173,
0.043587938,
-0.0329903029,
-0.0249719787,
0.0017481953,
0.0028804853,
-0.0251462124,
-0.0043054111,
0.0230821632,
0.0260907467,
0.0088707553,
-0.0247248858,
0.021683393,
0.0035994265,
0.0093138153,
-0.0537567548,
0.0668386221,
0.0390375257,
0.0147704687,
0.0189746004,
-0.0005538776,
0.0053360863,
-0.0337780602,
0.0258775856,
-0.0398677215,
-0.0216514859,
0.0286634918,
-0.007089484,
0.0163865313,
-0.0438713916,
-0.0266316123,
-0.0261737984,
-0.0357953422,
0.0379341729,
0.0488863252,
-0.0362228788,
0.0098820077,
0.0264744218,
-0.0041713235,
-0.0074920952,
0.0332609899,
-0.0300221257,
0.0070984978,
0.0138737559,
-0.0394786596,
-0.0796967372,
0.0583837777,
-0.0012298796,
0.025423158,
0.038303677,
-0.0183990654,
0.0687150434,
-0.0073366147,
0.0496963002,
0.0532328673,
0.02720071,
0.0299002342,
0.0597246103,
-0.0444537513,
-0.0286310036,
0.0237669088,
0.0163049251,
0.0305130742,
0.0215200856,
-0.0734285563,
0.0131102055,
-0.0156487338,
-0.0176825728,
0.0164152402,
-0.0181722064,
0.0648543611,
-0.0034411766,
-0.0022958876,
-0.0584484674,
-0.0538828745,
-0.0342213102,
-0.0130625572,
-0.0277917534,
0.0151993055,
0.0169230178,
0.0290901922,
0.0049203639,
0.0057521327,
-0.0162982345,
0.0018198946,
0.0639157668,
-0.0276458263,
-0.0036646745,
-0.0441617407,
-0.01355033,
-0.0199178047,
-0.0071026878,
0.0216860399,
-0.0318826586,
-0.0263887066,
-0.0648522303,
-0.0465828367,
0.0023648769,
0.0392627344,
-0.0264948253,
0.0505026877,
-0.003724311,
0.0338503346,
0.0469912142,
0.0172533821,
-0.0519186147,
0.0157935899,
0.052617427,
-0.0369902477,
0.0134506561,
-0.0292873699,
0.0194223318,
-0.0416640528,
-0.0121264746,
0.0219845232,
0.0017895482,
-0.0634830222,
0.0177890286,
0.0796072185,
0.0833235011,
-0.0417997912,
-0.0758032873,
-0.0154210078,
-0.03069943,
0.0197222121,
0.0015897283,
0.0025137647,
0.020560598,
0.0300981961,
0.0121742478,
0.0499517024,
0.0212906022,
-0.0566087179,
0.0252003185,
-0.0120964516,
-0.03075164,
0.0240094084,
0.0208544489,
0.0084120426,
0.0114171728,
0.0001017479,
0.0231042281,
-0.0163600165,
-0.056674134,
0.0090417322,
-0.0288891289,
0.0006181864,
0.0135906357,
0.0122966534,
-0.0600292906,
0.0218531098,
0.036431253,
0.0104479967,
-0.0112675177,
-0.0224945918,
0.0394334085,
0.0290827174,
0.0414847173,
-0.0590782389,
0.0056299274,
0.0019159203,
-0.0428433456,
0.0279349443,
0.0217267014,
0.041385483,
0.029758092,
-0.040910732,
-0.0540937968,
0.0710864738,
0.0639767051,
-0.0479225963,
0.0420735106,
-0.0248662587,
-0.0033005048,
-0.0124811837,
-0.0329404585,
-0.0138174677,
0.0106733376,
0.0779130906,
0.0459810607,
-0.0421663076,
0.0727859512,
-0.0527678691,
-0.004217546,
0.0291906223,
-0.0102923512,
-0.0065464494,
-0.0255076718,
0.0271505434,
-0.0149336588,
0.0392243862,
-0.0283675697,
-0.0730257779,
-0.0258292183,
0.0102888588,
0.0493171848,
-0.0164593309,
-0.0438786037,
0.0652074069,
0.0532291196,
-0.0316484421,
-0.0429436527,
-0.0520537943,
0.0382754393,
-0.0201993436,
-0.0067110555,
0.0405505076,
0.0417076237,
0.016017545,
-0.0285552423,
-0.0401145481,
0.0246449932,
0.0360934138,
0.0469333269,
-0.021666592,
0.017227944,
0.006171322,
0.0541046187,
0.0184174031,
-0.1078966931,
0.0458471552,
-0.0333124176,
-0.0453745797,
-0.017283136,
-0.0135244643,
0.0065479903,
-0.0541796349,
0.0239977427,
0.0012774407,
-0.0107496241,
0.0210121479,
0.023516763,
-0.0467518084,
0.0156002948,
-0.0778369904,
-0.0096511636,
-0.0043143816,
0.0022779375,
0.0288103092,
0.0226688553,
-0.0548739769,
-0.0023701289,
-0.0047769551,
-0.0798786432,
-0.0096021276,
-0.0387526304,
-0.0273344163,
-0.0203014631,
-0.0370538384,
0.0409613401,
0.0483666398,
0.0021121567,
-0.0429105312,
-0.0028101928,
0.036397744,
0.0328538977,
0.0126403933,
-0.0294713899,
0.054693304,
0.0176050849,
-0.0474212319,
0.006928022,
0.0143511249,
0.0497006588,
0.0392028317,
-0.0119342655,
-0.030801056,
0.0137540018,
0.0365814939,
-0.0233303998,
-0.0555169322,
0.0768999085,
0.0170238465,
0.0439148322,
0.0358288474,
-0.0362124071,
-0.0181087777,
0.0184589885,
-0.0116848983,
-0.0014227452,
-0.048830118,
0.0171497092,
-0.0132034812,
0.0180959068,
0.0194122642,
-0.03948351,
0.0040258458,
-0.0755729377,
-0.0232691523,
-0.054497499,
-0.0470154062,
-0.0251945071,
0.0568039194,
0.0062497342,
0.0537174121,
-0.0224767718,
-0.0004779306,
-0.0963222533,
0.0089137368,
-0.0019698024,
0.0187359918,
0.0356503241,
-0.018687902,
0.0486694574,
0.0098449877,
-0.0141404849,
-0.0487789251,
-0.0000466806,
0.0387553647,
-0.0557798818,
0.0315012001,
-0.028826179,
-5.008297639e-33,
-0.0423482098,
-0.097108528,
0.0303311683,
-0.0116946241,
-0.0297654718,
0.0141656632,
0.0098138992,
0.034887556,
-0.0084975529,
-0.0115526821,
-0.0027345405,
0.0211691353,
-0.0181842893,
-0.065502882,
0.0333211087,
0.0302820168,
0.0336452648,
-0.0376011692,
-0.0071287304,
0.0006938004,
0.0357250981,
0.0030383519,
0.0219782945,
-0.1088369787,
-0.043256171,
0.0030810637,
-0.0298810154,
0.025512673,
0.0464017652,
-0.0261607189,
0.0161777753,
-0.038987156,
-0.0027245595,
-0.013016101,
-0.0120475749,
0.0365786925,
0.0196350887,
-0.0394647904,
-0.0149047505,
-0.0029049488,
-0.0305230282,
-0.0069598462,
-0.0208006874,
0.0387545526,
-0.0329844654,
-0.0542290919,
0.0388070084,
-0.0284085069,
-0.0098860255,
0.0468552373,
0.0034141573,
0.017322965,
-0.0190726817,
-0.0167150889,
0.0528212003,
0.0519179814,
-0.0328546092,
-0.0744056106,
-0.0512024499,
0.0519142784,
-0.0192771628,
-0.0438951701,
0.0504288711,
0.0047393302,
0.0340377726,
0.0159805249,
0.0301919747,
0.0336369313,
-0.0489076599,
-0.0517107807,
-0.0215739477,
0.095880717,
0.0951907784,
0.0004956411,
-0.0054940516,
0.0176941324,
-0.0089511434,
0.0239970908,
0.0239998791,
0.0426975191,
-0.0058873431,
0.0721419156,
-0.0411619693,
0.0376921035,
0.0353076458,
0.0104737608,
-0.0006134908,
-0.068415992,
0.0091536539,
-0.0171079375,
-0.0301386341,
0.0227767155,
-0.0003681312,
0.0342868194,
0.0877675787,
-0.019407155,
0.0383290984,
0.0319257453,
-0.0054180068,
-0.0623425953,
-0.0688948706,
-0.0274840817,
-0.0185157023,
0.0480072908,
0.0641197562,
-0.0140420171,
-0.0143657234,
-0.0035168475,
0.0182324033,
-0.0163981244,
0.0159592982,
0.0137035232,
0.0107690413,
-0.100318782,
0.0026379242,
-0.0256829821,
-0.0083624199,
-0.0352476873,
0.0135734091,
-0.1201308817,
-0.0225275047,
0.0247036107,
-0.0348367505,
-0.008586497,
-0.00488545,
-0.0231320448,
-0.0338881388,
-0.0031516582,
0.0404091701,
0.0039779674,
-0.0309002027,
-0.0740393177,
2.518e-7,
-0.0081301518,
0.0662419498,
0.0371484384,
0.0306021757,
0.0137783969,
0.0323256142,
0.0141990706,
0.0431395508,
0.0672478899,
-0.0145459175,
0.0556451976,
0.0594565943,
-0.0041352953,
0.0547916628,
0.0364621505,
-0.0554226935,
0.0330271125,
-0.0248269271,
-0.0016516856,
0.0453134142,
0.0700044557,
-0.0530608594,
0.079872407,
0.0309393201,
0.0035816806,
-0.0368355252,
0.0025071811,
-0.0211852733,
-0.008829752,
-0.0390300713,
-0.0024711434,
-0.0027426826,
-0.057947576,
0.0525060147,
0.0039146165,
-0.0204648599,
0.0017138735,
-0.0518689081,
-0.0539348498,
0.0181638617,
-0.0024539016,
-0.0112067526,
-0.0210227631,
0.0291320104,
-0.0096518518,
-0.0566530637,
-0.009633692,
0.0128814485,
-0.0169694982,
-0.0129859708,
0.0049999431,
0.0322091132,
0.0164992362,
0.0097123813,
-0.0424288511,
0.0064782002,
-0.010564127,
-0.0041364511,
0.00350391,
-0.013922628,
-0.0233408231,
-0.0130204288,
0.0113849472,
0.009994939,
-0.033804439,
0.0240144879,
-0.0265614111,
1.392449167e-34,
-0.0432111435,
0.0658334345,
0.0049061785,
0.0143998628,
0.0225723498,
-0.0231819712,
-0.0117384782,
0.0213983357,
0.053248357,
0.0319934748,
-0.0359928645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19531v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19531v7 | MiLe Loss: a New Loss for Mitigating the Bias of Learning Difficulties in Generative Language Models | 2023-10-30T13:33:21 | 2024-03-28T05:28:13 | Zhenpeng Su, Xing Wu, Xue Bai, Zijia Lin, Hui Chen, Guiguang Ding, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative language models are usually pretrained on large text corpus via
predicting the next token (i.e., sub-word/word/phrase) given the previous ones.
Recent works have demonstrated the impressive performance of large generative
language models on downstream tasks. However, existing generative language
models generally neglect an inherent challenge in text corpus during training,
i.e., the imbalance between frequent tokens and infrequent ones. It can lead a
language model to be dominated by common and easy-to-learn tokens, thereby
overlooking the infrequent and difficult-to-learn ones. To alleviate that, we
propose a MiLe Loss function for mitigating the bias of learning difficulties
with tokens. During training, it can dynamically assess the learning difficulty
of a to-be-learned token, according to the information entropy of the
corresponding predicted probability distribution over the vocabulary. Then it
scales the training loss adaptively, trying to lead the model to focus more on
the difficult-to-learn tokens. On the Pile dataset, we train generative
language models at different scales of 468M, 1.2B, and 6.7B parameters.
Experiments reveal that models incorporating the proposed MiLe Loss can gain
consistent performance improvement on downstream benchmarks. | [
0.0340218432,
0.0722628906,
0.0028928404,
0.0074743996,
-0.0261498112,
0.0213459507,
-0.0035819332,
0.0204981733,
-0.0306544881,
-0.0337042399,
0.0108796218,
-0.0547850169,
-0.0164877512,
0.018213775,
0.0501361787,
-0.0830600187,
0.0168507397,
-0.019791685,
0.036199376,
-0.0143068423,
0.0035554236,
0.0175382998,
-0.0117718987,
0.032548584,
-0.0670148209,
-0.0077399788,
0.0191616602,
0.0305311214,
0.0109649273,
-0.0340770409,
0.0330477692,
0.0471720248,
0.0074537969,
0.0396936499,
0.0000019754,
-0.0345733725,
-0.0083243428,
-0.0096070329,
-0.0202291645,
0.0024254888,
0.0649192035,
0.0003230657,
-0.0410291478,
0.0581779145,
-0.0040885606,
-0.060538169,
0.0633848533,
0.0525868423,
0.0045759222,
0.0758779198,
-0.001477147,
-0.0155622056,
0.0313175172,
-0.0584092848,
0.0170006678,
-0.0366190858,
0.0250152666,
-0.0075267819,
-0.0614561252,
-0.0212489311,
-0.0548729859,
0.0150490338,
0.0227658581,
0.0163772795,
0.0246483833,
0.0709384233,
0.0195257254,
-0.0076021394,
-0.0071574957,
0.0310064759,
-0.0744712055,
-0.0366609171,
-0.000478248,
-0.0356440395,
0.0049305991,
-0.0070098666,
-0.0351497643,
0.0168746058,
0.0186797511,
0.0397959575,
-0.0040753679,
0.0120218117,
0.0302022714,
0.0111668855,
-0.0329696648,
-0.0210729595,
0.0368873961,
-0.0237256829,
-0.0073635541,
-0.0010568838,
-0.0374023989,
-0.0344037153,
-0.0066292202,
-0.006319942,
-0.008767792,
0.039762523,
-0.023666909,
-0.0352015607,
0.0457886122,
-0.0551088154,
0.0150409788,
0.0113338623,
-0.0057568513,
0.0353589319,
-0.0190343,
0.0109286439,
0.0453385785,
0.025388686,
-0.0286168493,
-0.0115144737,
-0.0057647689,
-0.0108998232,
-0.0712703094,
0.0018952425,
-0.0075479466,
-0.026711192,
-0.0418020301,
-0.0183871966,
0.0021831475,
-0.0144518083,
0.0241441261,
0.0188744068,
-0.0435825214,
-0.0340864994,
-0.00528182,
0.0116564725,
-0.0508678891,
0.0459217317,
0.0478317626,
-0.0452476963,
-0.0337898135,
0.0125301452,
0.009624402,
-0.0057681389,
0.0214708243,
0.0611086152,
-0.0126866205,
-0.0548231602,
-0.0618875958,
0.0181146823,
-0.0357467234,
-0.0543525629,
-0.0269893855,
-0.0544349141,
0.0202688333,
0.0011160376,
0.0148444939,
-0.0556437299,
-0.0005018755,
0.003096926,
-0.0109032551,
0.0623263121,
0.017076863,
-0.0147948815,
0.0666202977,
0.0210985001,
0.0105320923,
0.0763399005,
0.0296091754,
0.0366406031,
0.0317630507,
-0.007320968,
0.004613854,
0.020619465,
0.0362297781,
-0.0069622966,
-0.0111094974,
-0.0307966359,
0.0058171647,
0.0485867858,
0.0829268023,
0.0827722549,
-0.0472935252,
0.0040475149,
0.0555172414,
0.0465683229,
0.0325799882,
0.0280497074,
0.0359106027,
0.0064466335,
-0.0143038156,
0.0054743881,
-0.0325194113,
-0.0137545625,
0.0066457829,
0.0109087899,
0.0743225664,
0.0306994487,
-0.0383742489,
-0.0639679804,
-0.0139558278,
-0.0095921932,
0.0052519818,
-0.0356551781,
0.060338188,
0.0353745595,
-0.040899545,
0.0479102358,
0.0369416885,
-0.0659228489,
0.0324122012,
-0.0318888389,
0.0250601955,
0.0508269556,
0.0455224328,
0.0035042902,
0.0035561684,
0.0193674732,
-0.0104808602,
0.0283916835,
-0.0002050077,
-0.0141626308,
0.0320134573,
-0.0565756112,
-0.0066703577,
0.0396131016,
0.0285626967,
0.0033539808,
-0.0034434928,
0.0088802576,
0.0251319557,
-0.0566500649,
-0.0190273933,
0.0488525927,
-0.0179444421,
-0.0527285561,
0.0093652382,
0.0016886485,
0.0328078903,
-0.0202003326,
-0.0183504857,
0.0263970718,
0.0426447056,
-0.0425544158,
-0.0285386294,
-0.0137198446,
-0.0742931366,
-0.026449943,
0.027493855,
-0.0331622325,
0.0356915146,
-0.0076917391,
-0.0636601597,
-0.0478641391,
0.0274255369,
-0.0515099317,
0.0892730281,
-0.0468798727,
0.0286252499,
0.0347278565,
0.0172448475,
-0.054507453,
0.0588383339,
-0.0297824983,
0.0648129508,
-0.064893268,
0.0053861332,
0.0003377883,
-0.0338369757,
0.0148350485,
-0.0077000083,
-0.0256665181,
0.0244875271,
0.0316801742,
-0.0242597498,
-0.0498564467,
-0.0418769717,
-0.0771349072,
-0.0169688817,
-0.0270934906,
0.0281934179,
-0.0072307549,
0.009270505,
-0.0412763692,
-0.0275357421,
-0.036027059,
-0.0008234202,
-0.0134392958,
-0.0081743747,
0.0299766231,
0.0136066088,
-0.0078255441,
-0.0436339639,
-0.0169039872,
0.0029990533,
0.0449561141,
-0.0091731036,
0.0315400325,
-0.0540358238,
0.0500018895,
0.0056808935,
0.0142416023,
0.0122641232,
-0.053532131,
-0.0190792736,
-0.009130721,
0.1138278916,
0.0452426486,
0.0586316586,
0.0296816975,
0.0202022195,
-0.0099488562,
-0.0508951135,
-0.0118758008,
-0.0498339459,
-0.0050103092,
-0.0254648793,
-0.0360746048,
-0.0058456697,
0.0766884387,
0.0240540709,
-0.0179151427,
-0.0565899424,
0.0253080092,
-0.0139004216,
0.0042537162,
0.0103338379,
0.0118200881,
-0.0293633454,
-0.0171868522,
-0.0272598974,
-0.0462602228,
0.0302781779,
-0.0425601155,
0.0094408942,
-0.0517940372,
0.0248474702,
-0.0117262416,
0.0462948792,
0.0473043956,
0.0241904985,
0.0369827598,
-0.0342893414,
-0.0432615913,
0.0245299358,
0.032285206,
-0.0040239436,
0.0147122052,
-0.0207072571,
0.0112820081,
-0.0279097073,
-0.0377147868,
-0.0171036664,
-0.0210926179,
0.0451790877,
0.0066662249,
0.0673524439,
-0.0149155166,
-0.0055078333,
-0.0415040404,
-0.0083651524,
0.0549217239,
0.0131841637,
-0.0302609466,
0.0023795976,
0.0334260687,
0.0534098633,
-0.0033736797,
0.0320961513,
-0.0304541271,
0.0012386437,
0.0571716577,
0.0724941418,
-0.0170115586,
-0.0245506521,
-0.0158758294,
0.0370009355,
-0.0397204459,
0.0140039641,
0.0389875993,
0.0362572223,
-0.0379625261,
-0.0283628143,
0.1000081748,
0.0152529497,
-0.0455532521,
0.0328120515,
0.0226768311,
0.0760116428,
0.0000360085,
0.001231009,
-0.0661623552,
-0.0133024389,
0.0225402042,
0.0359896459,
-0.0068111597,
-0.0093740877,
0.0132821258,
-0.1059137434,
0.0210290905,
0.0125931706,
-0.017106507,
-0.0059500956,
-0.0306761861,
-0.0363105051,
-0.0449545048,
0.0168277137,
-0.0059815012,
-0.0343486927,
0.0143711204,
0.0670113489,
-0.0162122622,
-0.0687118247,
0.0054068193,
-0.0637813807,
0.0697773322,
0.041914098,
0.0199088827,
0.0237204283,
-0.0128720831,
0.0458949804,
-0.0066323355,
-0.0345924608,
-0.0045317733,
0.0565176606,
0.0057596192,
0.0130075412,
0.008416485,
0.0345981456,
-0.0238566808,
-0.0022389826,
-0.0147485947,
0.0458588675,
0.0271547753,
-0.010079884,
-0.0231996421,
-0.0158962216,
0.0254747104,
0.088219136,
0.032390926,
-0.0324205384,
-0.0639102086,
-0.0515870675,
0.0594745949,
-0.0558967888,
0.0029991241,
-0.0119373146,
0.0024123008,
-0.0481132232,
-0.0832050815,
-0.0211520623,
0.0074988259,
0.0677521303,
-0.0135333426,
0.0078667179,
-0.0512377247,
-0.0046052849,
-0.0312840678,
0.0065048225,
-0.0108815506,
-0.0159902778,
-0.1172306389,
-0.0236537065,
0.0260922369,
-0.0175882298,
-0.038807638,
0.0155288242,
-0.0963205397,
-0.0599337481,
0.0062417602,
0.0359187424,
0.0201431569,
0.0367857032,
-0.0040868581,
-0.0775063485,
0.0738842562,
0.0522883274,
-0.0671571642,
-0.0037953523,
0.0284770299,
0.0143660773,
-0.0099587198,
0.0304410476,
-0.0236516781,
0.0300711691,
0.0261119343,
0.0737124085,
-0.007854715,
-0.0096794125,
0.0059850644,
-0.0198288448,
0.0624403954,
-0.0608824641,
-0.0124821672,
-0.057167165,
0.0301116724,
0.0127393492,
0.0099460613,
-0.0387414992,
0.0184886679,
0.0606052876,
-0.0106018092,
-0.0406757295,
0.0181442127,
0.0149662821,
0.0458600596,
-0.0246413387,
-0.0098344171,
0.0000961737,
0.0276815519,
0.0207564607,
-0.0037770451,
-0.0090431031,
-0.0413366035,
-0.0051712696,
0.011696239,
-0.0164570808,
0.0197604597,
0.0130624361,
0.0241990406,
-0.0147976829,
0.0043492666,
-0.0244858414,
0.0005367162,
-0.085826911,
0.023692444,
0.0455437042,
-0.0191886909,
0.0349675044,
-0.0351832733,
0.0002138564,
-0.0257445462,
0.0061049452,
-0.0105476705,
-0.0537429042,
0.0339429714,
0.0036773628,
-0.0328356624,
-0.0326784924,
0.1044643819,
0.0497401208,
0.0595501512,
-0.0016909367,
-0.0036663257,
-0.0279868562,
-0.0317610838,
0.0224046558,
0.0007937306,
-0.0109547284,
0.0401942097,
-0.0409157053,
-0.073600769,
-0.0316104293,
0.010489909,
0.0394627973,
-0.008036077,
0.0618897192,
0.0450547561,
-0.0456681959,
-0.0181229766,
-0.039054621,
0.0128763849,
0.0241126809,
-0.0131981876,
-0.0211168397,
-6.542005894e-33,
-0.0201337114,
0.0145125641,
0.0064200829,
-0.01785421,
-0.0087638721,
-0.0038837008,
-0.0328323245,
0.0109644346,
-0.0116966497,
0.040828567,
-0.0047203265,
-0.0127594126,
0.0138300667,
0.0670564994,
0.0170176383,
0.0415810496,
0.0724114999,
-0.0241759196,
-0.0302880704,
0.0430698693,
0.0492103957,
0.0286033507,
0.0265200399,
-0.0028125015,
-0.0087633356,
-0.0046672593,
-0.0496388227,
0.0197724402,
0.026894426,
0.0335206576,
-0.0430055596,
0.0274390317,
-0.0001286357,
-0.0377053693,
-0.0498384349,
-0.0037735775,
-0.1068648994,
-0.0228735264,
-0.0036703199,
0.0188153815,
-0.0076991091,
-0.0357762091,
0.0329820774,
-0.0143577615,
-0.0304314867,
-0.015629068,
0.0340789743,
-0.0236496944,
-0.0585179403,
-0.0606253631,
-0.0621997602,
0.0423262455,
-0.0009819698,
-0.031853959,
-0.0125030736,
-0.0014797752,
0.0146736233,
-0.0223597586,
-0.0363633931,
0.0098562138,
0.0116974991,
0.0807478204,
0.0195375942,
0.0267165303,
-0.0089211762,
0.0453825034,
0.0122318212,
-0.0432490967,
-0.0180330947,
-0.0043102619,
0.0416196212,
0.0067118392,
0.0266850404,
0.0102408882,
0.0930162668,
-0.0319444053,
-0.0662306175,
0.0351895206,
-0.0261565596,
0.0414620787,
0.0241180696,
0.0503049232,
-0.0388057195,
-0.0331687666,
-0.0296986513,
-0.0081512481,
0.0022268731,
-0.0317025706,
0.0188195575,
0.0648707598,
0.0040268051,
-0.059718959,
0.0042316047,
-0.0162026081,
-0.0502090454,
0.0171046853,
0.0032640419,
-0.0071517439,
-0.0152955474,
0.0185703412,
-0.0811496228,
-0.0284204688,
0.0264195614,
0.0121972766,
-0.0160555318,
0.0003736262,
0.0690341219,
0.0313424543,
-0.0972415134,
0.0120562315,
-0.0379642248,
0.0145336892,
0.0022405689,
0.0311796572,
0.0358245969,
-0.0083955601,
-0.0050247866,
0.007783215,
0.0219951924,
-0.0140712187,
-0.0048641646,
0.0401650146,
-0.0153500149,
0.0300446749,
-0.0503428839,
-0.0060092118,
-0.0297261402,
-0.016676655,
0.0508126281,
-0.0388354994,
-0.0166805442,
0.0044909697,
2.611e-7,
0.0411832556,
0.0365559533,
0.0403129831,
-0.0177792106,
-0.0014319618,
0.0235892367,
-0.0118439132,
0.0370005034,
-0.0243504532,
0.0601477362,
0.0076940623,
-0.0032354433,
0.038913317,
-0.0006647028,
-0.1019981429,
0.0415118672,
-0.0606157035,
0.038884934,
-0.010561944,
-0.0095441351,
0.0253038816,
0.1075115204,
-0.002969329,
-0.006354047,
0.0291730054,
-0.0525628291,
0.0742319301,
-0.0249272268,
0.0325690322,
0.0407929197,
0.0292554721,
0.0344042405,
0.0022795016,
-0.0092762355,
-0.0553378649,
0.0054948777,
0.0057801749,
0.0316594616,
-0.0013793437,
-0.0453427844,
0.0254096519,
0.0080089951,
0.0177196916,
-0.0350111276,
0.0208628103,
-0.0226015933,
-0.0210644547,
-0.0138143729,
-0.0070277732,
0.0215052702,
0.0416357331,
-0.0258332025,
-0.0488527305,
0.0090134311,
0.0311869849,
0.0078042746,
-0.0034337882,
-0.1058504358,
-0.0240584202,
0.0097484812,
-0.0446315259,
-0.0239782538,
-0.0548162423,
0.0292147342,
0.0127301002,
-0.0484395437,
-0.0237113647,
2.355558666e-34,
0.0542507507,
-0.0271284766,
-0.0252432935,
0.0082361382,
0.0287101697,
-0.0044860863,
0.0173296817,
0.0386907123,
-0.001682439,
-0.0494093671,
-0.0076645561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19462v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19462v2 | Constituency Parsing using LLMs | 2023-10-30T11:39:11 | 2023-10-31T07:19:51 | Xuefeng Bai, Jialong Wu, Yulong Chen, Zhongqing Wang, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Constituency parsing is a fundamental yet unsolved natural language
processing task. In this paper, we explore the potential of recent large
language models (LLMs) that have exhibited remarkable performance across
various domains and tasks to tackle this task. We employ three linearization
strategies to transform output trees into symbol sequences, such that LLMs can
solve constituency parsing by generating linearized trees. We conduct
experiments using a diverse range of LLMs, including ChatGPT, GPT-4, OPT,
LLaMA, and Alpaca, comparing their performance against the state-of-the-art
constituency parsers. Our experiments encompass zero-shot, few-shot, and
full-training learning settings, and we evaluate the models on one in-domain
and five out-of-domain test datasets. Our findings reveal insights into LLMs'
performance, generalization abilities, and challenges in constituency parsing. | [
0.0207586195,
0.0793738365,
0.0081239184,
0.0369260721,
-0.0284628775,
0.0357667096,
-0.0105987769,
0.0021898644,
-0.0333780795,
-0.0546383522,
0.0008995937,
-0.0446862765,
-0.0166530292,
-0.0053062099,
0.0220673196,
-0.0493799895,
0.0574491955,
-0.0196210593,
0.0090008788,
0.0246583931,
0.009079054,
0.0346000232,
0.0307773333,
0.0537767932,
-0.0500631146,
-0.048302386,
0.0009990291,
0.0099599445,
-0.0004005769,
-0.0465366617,
-0.0165386703,
-0.0210982282,
0.030602688,
0.0371958315,
0.0000019445,
-0.0136845717,
-0.0479660854,
0.0003179372,
-0.0366703793,
0.0105346376,
0.07977961,
-0.0495507643,
-0.0334734097,
0.0157049373,
-0.0340683758,
-0.0219828337,
0.0248172358,
-0.0061507383,
0.0721309409,
0.0822125226,
-0.0171671957,
-0.0687684566,
0.0266050417,
-0.0133419912,
-0.0131164482,
-0.0249185637,
0.0241860654,
-0.0267864857,
-0.0034388334,
0.0054982728,
-0.0008134438,
-0.0091622956,
0.0178900119,
0.0102280509,
-0.0249611139,
0.050684005,
-0.0261969566,
-0.0106934607,
-0.0044629457,
0.0670887381,
-0.0544465631,
-0.0197883192,
0.011977748,
-0.0122492975,
-0.0146238226,
-0.0551982149,
-0.0526531972,
0.0634598508,
-0.0106959082,
0.0501708761,
0.0543027706,
-0.0375720151,
0.02279176,
0.0119668264,
-0.0317595601,
0.0836400539,
0.0088633932,
-0.0431590453,
0.000832342,
0.0197448898,
-0.0435171649,
-0.0194489937,
0.0210852008,
0.0177808627,
0.0047307932,
0.0392229818,
-0.0133039225,
-0.0178248677,
0.0101169627,
-0.031183565,
0.0021640654,
0.0332867764,
-0.0145733627,
0.0476675779,
-0.0089612501,
0.053015992,
-0.031262517,
0.0462541282,
-0.0424625352,
-0.0113236476,
-0.0764794946,
-0.0184605867,
-0.0610836186,
0.0546987467,
-0.0338983685,
-0.0307779517,
-0.002355519,
-0.0048264889,
0.0163467024,
0.014720791,
0.0349583924,
-0.0141654536,
-0.030545488,
-0.0028462424,
0.0120311258,
0.0800873339,
-0.0089038489,
-0.0058356598,
-0.0175375026,
-0.0233680401,
-0.0183955524,
0.0428391509,
-0.0236589219,
-0.0299226921,
0.0091020949,
0.0381089374,
-0.0031926611,
-0.0371675752,
-0.0204565506,
0.0039987396,
-0.0251031499,
-0.0479611903,
-0.0009692968,
-0.0609345809,
0.0259634834,
-0.0039815544,
0.0326743014,
-0.0229600631,
0.0073361737,
0.0185808986,
0.0060097938,
0.0732830167,
-0.0041315281,
-0.0120745329,
0.0043071159,
-0.000664853,
0.004703233,
0.0688338056,
0.0482903458,
0.037187513,
0.0025253796,
0.0111944322,
-0.0113028437,
0.0689087063,
-0.0426306911,
-0.0200869851,
-0.0584839135,
0.003022434,
-0.0075441361,
0.0110757379,
0.0347117558,
0.0601287968,
-0.0250696763,
-0.0007724351,
0.0204254761,
0.0605319925,
0.0124576632,
0.0074428455,
0.0444321036,
-0.0044951946,
-0.0048662126,
-0.0209838282,
-0.0678916276,
-0.0453994535,
-0.0080227936,
0.0073032412,
-0.0676821396,
0.0346575566,
-0.0047863498,
0.0113772964,
-0.0383435786,
-0.0366136581,
0.0004944382,
-0.0201813728,
0.0575994961,
0.0002657704,
-0.0296852551,
0.0679391697,
-0.0000942373,
-0.0423460826,
-0.0063990089,
-0.0415087417,
0.0080166096,
0.0392572321,
0.051173158,
-0.0269575361,
-0.0321371853,
-0.0251499861,
0.0040746592,
0.0691758394,
-0.0076289698,
-0.0255794469,
0.0155209005,
-0.0456111133,
0.0078421449,
0.032872159,
0.0258504748,
0.0318614431,
-0.0098595051,
-0.0130482865,
0.0079262024,
-0.0496591926,
0.0297057629,
0.0517681949,
-0.0076676575,
-0.0047113234,
0.0245895796,
-0.018977901,
0.0316305123,
0.0255516954,
-0.0142958658,
0.0001634015,
0.0235227365,
-0.0649289787,
0.0081005283,
0.01576389,
-0.0655651391,
-0.0534586124,
0.0581738167,
0.0036727497,
-0.0287764501,
0.0452692695,
-0.0646795481,
-0.0265465546,
-0.0052442146,
-0.0243940335,
0.0155168045,
-0.0287436303,
0.0319016054,
0.0318708755,
-0.0099827358,
-0.048029013,
0.0979589149,
-0.0303204544,
-0.030056579,
-0.0166809782,
0.0324853174,
-0.0032622817,
-0.0251341574,
-0.0265274979,
0.0463261157,
0.0061091105,
-0.0340676494,
-0.0450883508,
-0.0133030759,
-0.0311201736,
-0.0410825722,
-0.0623043031,
0.0111172367,
-0.027643634,
0.066051513,
0.0223584156,
-0.0146318888,
0.0086810216,
0.0071306219,
-0.0153665561,
0.0318140015,
0.0088286605,
0.0141227441,
0.0578296073,
0.0141309444,
-0.0499063767,
-0.0421956889,
-0.0240597874,
-0.0506890416,
0.0132554937,
-0.0148292044,
-0.0402355827,
-0.0299006291,
0.0080765774,
0.0057541118,
0.033305224,
-0.0098322714,
-0.0115995938,
0.014421016,
-0.0634816065,
0.0233726818,
0.0543963872,
-0.0060969992,
0.0042137234,
0.0149227446,
-0.0034203262,
-0.0494132414,
0.0098909931,
0.0186441466,
0.0136488387,
-0.0447353907,
-0.0011808081,
0.0227189846,
0.1010612547,
-0.0230100192,
0.0277027749,
-0.0146070188,
-0.0060738842,
-0.0154827749,
0.0032199938,
-0.0166534893,
-0.0277757049,
-0.0277188513,
-0.0135648362,
-0.0349670015,
-0.0269222092,
0.0408810414,
-0.048999019,
-0.0490205511,
-0.033934325,
-0.0073479139,
-0.0716927424,
0.0718895122,
0.046781119,
-0.0286524855,
0.0056408062,
-0.076277554,
0.0033326382,
0.0050901831,
-0.0216197334,
-0.0190817025,
0.0694090649,
-0.0544547886,
0.0450652726,
-0.0355367325,
-0.0215341393,
-0.0168360583,
-0.0456243642,
-0.0302361473,
0.0401595645,
-0.0138367396,
0.0120259002,
-0.0051782471,
0.0275906175,
-0.0372244827,
0.0367805921,
0.0165153798,
0.0169205759,
-0.0353290103,
0.0170534644,
0.0397507213,
-0.0017640465,
0.0034656124,
-0.0245220568,
0.0538252443,
0.0622340776,
0.0619742349,
0.0165001415,
-0.0699932203,
0.0096028922,
-0.0111536793,
-0.047076419,
-0.0262455177,
-0.0089861769,
0.0108814677,
-0.0754299164,
-0.0026412937,
0.1101838946,
0.0415468886,
-0.0537614711,
0.0043002213,
0.0045995605,
0.0171959456,
0.0194012169,
0.0022622249,
-0.1255824566,
-0.0430443622,
0.0255319998,
-0.0124738365,
0.0226655733,
-0.050727535,
0.0021503798,
-0.1454913765,
0.0110877277,
0.0212361217,
-0.0113503542,
0.0124667697,
0.0001687961,
-0.0272415709,
-0.044767607,
0.0085878847,
0.0497569256,
-0.0324783549,
0.0061673769,
0.0155131128,
-0.0622609295,
-0.0185601451,
0.0071635386,
-0.0330645144,
0.0216116793,
0.0785452127,
0.0243587922,
0.0122121293,
0.021882927,
0.084779717,
-0.0314737074,
0.0080021508,
-0.0239837281,
-0.0405816101,
-0.0370692573,
-0.0083690938,
0.0153875379,
0.0084884288,
-0.0261049476,
0.0033538174,
0.0182511825,
0.0709169209,
-0.0225939751,
0.013735122,
0.0110933455,
-0.0134405168,
0.0037563054,
0.058991801,
0.0171581749,
-0.0038731552,
-0.0715605989,
-0.0571529977,
-0.0254156031,
-0.0060127391,
-0.0183558278,
0.0158909932,
0.0015481239,
0.0022125421,
-0.0718050376,
-0.0244257487,
0.0727625862,
0.0179889482,
-0.0311116949,
-0.0085218884,
-0.0102117062,
-0.0066230134,
0.0237363391,
0.0249023736,
-0.0310604498,
0.003929893,
-0.0435481444,
0.011470533,
0.0242193863,
0.0220501311,
-0.0336245112,
0.0018983264,
-0.0892029256,
-0.0461922288,
0.0124544706,
0.0364296511,
0.0221437085,
-0.0019428056,
-0.0253765676,
-0.0011999952,
-0.0356921665,
0.0798642784,
-0.0124093052,
0.0036604616,
-0.0030849422,
0.0467560254,
0.0235884134,
0.0354858562,
0.0100456104,
0.0468228906,
-0.0254893675,
0.0447516516,
-0.06096109,
0.0172043703,
0.0465046018,
0.0318092033,
0.0448792465,
0.007780741,
-0.0396459438,
0.0122401696,
0.0289479457,
-0.0620649494,
-0.0104082003,
-0.0360370725,
-0.0096451305,
0.0299194809,
-0.0264692511,
-0.0065686926,
-0.0195911918,
-0.0021572821,
0.0842616707,
-0.037784975,
0.0389843732,
0.0078423666,
0.0023936189,
0.0080132792,
-0.0017674871,
-0.0051749214,
0.0121515887,
0.003135076,
0.0093954885,
-0.0272642728,
0.0210846197,
-0.0154279405,
0.0142513253,
-0.0252104644,
-0.0086313244,
-0.0258388426,
-0.0171281639,
-0.0180237517,
0.0382903889,
0.0719608739,
0.0098216822,
0.0703684166,
-0.0143691255,
0.0047682445,
-0.0120142233,
-0.01013475,
0.0164819844,
-0.0257474557,
0.052035436,
0.0137189627,
-0.037414927,
-0.0370888188,
0.0671573877,
0.037656121,
0.0648475587,
0.0326855257,
0.0467123538,
-0.0473049171,
-0.0308543406,
-0.0339482911,
-0.0217371508,
-0.0239467639,
0.013437463,
-0.0361564755,
-0.0238497201,
-0.0001045156,
-0.0001715852,
0.0077308859,
-0.0156523343,
0.0310437568,
0.0314811878,
-0.0056570885,
-0.021130465,
0.005903577,
-0.0098328544,
0.0037462618,
-0.0331479497,
-0.0310728904,
-5.917736476e-33,
-0.0590785779,
0.0177211147,
0.0451549031,
-0.0143024568,
-0.0468529314,
-0.008690658,
-0.0254538562,
0.0030893337,
0.0209970418,
-0.0249355249,
-0.0184005909,
0.0049457909,
0.0222553723,
0.0343736224,
0.0392910242,
-0.016232539,
0.0580389239,
-0.0288534611,
0.0015834005,
-0.0175996106,
0.0301386714,
0.0576768033,
0.0534047745,
-0.0212805755,
-0.0429089628,
0.0201881789,
-0.0405747332,
0.0113059189,
-0.019430887,
0.0417143852,
0.0075175473,
-0.0165747013,
0.0295468569,
-0.0252179485,
-0.0386785567,
0.0248698816,
-0.0747021511,
0.0419446193,
0.0119338455,
0.0015539902,
-0.0025478685,
-0.0397951528,
0.0549395978,
-0.0131986849,
0.01458403,
-0.0035112244,
0.0038488761,
-0.0458133854,
0.0048983432,
0.0095360773,
-0.0406646095,
0.0356984735,
0.0137043046,
0.033964932,
0.0574455634,
0.0296531096,
0.0065059089,
0.0604862794,
-0.0343630314,
-0.0046729492,
-0.0146873379,
0.0697298869,
0.0286377817,
-0.0337151997,
0.0156564862,
0.043304123,
0.0260498803,
-0.051750809,
-0.0613797158,
-0.0287700091,
-0.0127214761,
0.0624917038,
0.0309988093,
0.0040594009,
0.0518956594,
0.0055187428,
-0.0592215098,
-0.0083151944,
0.0804125145,
0.083504349,
-0.0237899441,
0.0410326086,
-0.0250148512,
0.0126836468,
0.015953375,
-0.0184684973,
-0.0233932454,
-0.0290236417,
0.0325407758,
0.0220722966,
0.0061492529,
0.042800419,
0.0649554431,
-0.0361036807,
-0.0036202429,
0.0319514163,
0.0147139886,
0.0388665274,
-0.0170005392,
0.0071765482,
-0.067865029,
-0.0821609348,
-0.0077892011,
0.0031546124,
0.0108671132,
-0.0154590346,
0.0111099277,
0.0056164684,
-0.0811947137,
0.0130351838,
-0.0390333049,
0.0102649461,
-0.0253152326,
0.101689294,
0.0666081384,
-0.0135530708,
0.0188798085,
0.0544768721,
-0.026759658,
-0.0178051591,
-0.0030310918,
0.0028580616,
-0.0214751549,
0.022820767,
-0.0275866035,
0.0046351887,
0.0117412843,
-0.0325011127,
0.0308436006,
-0.0349770002,
-0.0014956041,
0.0024354139,
2.568e-7,
0.050689429,
0.0554862991,
0.0430135205,
0.0124286627,
0.050616391,
0.0043000705,
-0.0143857347,
0.0222536307,
-0.0349788219,
-0.022482207,
-0.0189493354,
-0.0154321827,
0.0525386669,
0.0313831866,
-0.1321870238,
0.0434304588,
-0.0653455704,
0.0002592885,
-0.0668050721,
-0.0276485309,
0.0234566685,
0.1128133237,
-0.0241033975,
-0.0209915098,
-0.0229990277,
-0.0352898501,
0.0375851728,
-0.0039471779,
-0.0214256942,
0.0030122877,
0.0006233033,
0.0031663072,
-0.0092094596,
0.0112683652,
0.0202467125,
0.0328756757,
-0.0045588282,
0.1111197099,
-0.0015971804,
0.0051071998,
0.0259784199,
-0.0079163965,
-0.0059319395,
-0.0189986359,
0.0822096094,
-0.0370143652,
0.0121816937,
-0.0410024747,
-0.0396029986,
-0.0055488474,
-0.023852719,
0.0044590537,
0.0150452508,
0.0330911539,
0.0344261937,
-0.0480395705,
-0.0237409454,
-0.0703916326,
-0.0383238345,
0.0015526641,
-0.0528518222,
0.0084205708,
-0.018822711,
0.0494263656,
0.0046280478,
-0.0526721478,
-0.064769417,
2.579176262e-34,
0.0273940936,
-0.0225888193,
0.033037357,
0.0903030783,
0.0154927541,
0.0216943659,
-0.0305600204,
0.0336039141,
-0.0271235462,
-0.0921693742,
0.0136427451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01606v1 | KG-FRUS: a Novel Graph-based Dataset of 127 Years of US Diplomatic Relations | 2023-10-30T10:53:02 | 2023-10-30T10:53:02 | Gökberk Özsoy, Luis Salamanca, Matthew Connelly, Raymond Hicks, Fernando Pérez-Cruz | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the current paper, we present the KG-FRUS dataset, comprised of more than
300,000 US government diplomatic documents encoded in a Knowledge Graph (KG).
We leverage the data of the Foreign Relations of the United States (FRUS)
(available as XML files) to extract information about the documents and the
individuals and countries mentioned within them. We use the extracted entities,
and associated metadata, to create a graph-based dataset. Further, we
supplement the created KG with additional entities and relations from Wikidata.
The relations in the KG capture the synergies and dynamics required to study
and understand the complex fields of diplomacy, foreign relations, and
politics. This goes well beyond a simple collection of documents which neglects
the relations between entities in the text. We showcase a range of
possibilities of the current dataset by illustrating different approaches to
probe the KG. In the paper, we exemplify how to use a query language to answer
simple research questions and how to use graph algorithms such as Node2Vec and
PageRank, that benefit from the complete graph structure. More importantly, the
chosen structure provides total flexibility for continuously expanding and
enriching the graph. Our solution is general, so the proposed pipeline for
building the KG can encode other original corpora of time-dependent and complex
phenomena. Overall, we present a mechanism to create KG databases providing a
more versatile representation of time-dependent related text data and a
particular application to the all-important FRUS database. | [
0.0697554573,
0.0647900999,
-0.0090482756,
0.0082118316,
-0.0207739417,
0.0040538553,
-0.024685774,
0.0420282483,
0.0825098455,
-0.0208571721,
0.0487802736,
0.0003364868,
0.0173204709,
0.0557873249,
-0.0115316613,
-0.0622334816,
0.0246823598,
0.0095067518,
0.0599165484,
-0.0172013082,
-0.0119973952,
0.025462551,
-0.0300283749,
-0.0103449309,
-0.0107968925,
-0.0049789986,
-0.0507288501,
0.0083795572,
0.0077038161,
-0.009791431,
-0.0401795767,
0.0131654004,
0.0157846231,
-0.0139668826,
0.0000020972,
-0.0067776032,
-0.0152337532,
0.0046262606,
0.0153916162,
-0.0136995958,
0.0461722277,
-0.0371376015,
-0.0117951045,
-0.0105631119,
-0.0629776865,
-0.0391279496,
-0.0008220069,
-0.012980151,
0.0463551506,
0.0731627196,
-0.0213606171,
0.0079994611,
-0.0034302208,
-0.010721866,
-0.0058475854,
-0.0440823957,
0.0365435518,
0.0111098532,
0.0115131401,
0.0248367246,
0.0293122046,
-0.0018289228,
-0.0445022658,
-0.0369052887,
0.0261817891,
0.0297326706,
0.0127117643,
0.017656697,
0.0169922486,
0.0336350501,
0.1086510941,
0.0015650395,
0.0624281466,
0.035041336,
-0.0017608339,
0.0712712407,
-0.0294581726,
-0.0007579878,
-0.0295609217,
0.0024817586,
0.0380571447,
-0.035282623,
0.0217820648,
0.002563748,
-0.0417556874,
0.0846102312,
-0.0142964637,
-0.0241825208,
0.0006035159,
-0.0225025732,
0.0490994826,
-0.0710209087,
0.0239806902,
0.0226182882,
-0.0085467258,
0.0184198748,
-0.0045816223,
0.0251712389,
0.0086400406,
-0.0661469847,
-0.0466658585,
-0.0240527093,
0.0527988635,
0.0780164674,
0.0612598099,
-0.0188615005,
0.0041881958,
-0.0083307084,
-0.0228525866,
-0.0445849746,
-0.0967778489,
0.0108078402,
-0.0175618958,
0.022279989,
-0.0309224483,
-0.000515059,
0.0115828728,
0.0234251618,
-0.0106746498,
0.0856299549,
0.0132191079,
-0.0032124121,
0.0010393754,
-0.0179335717,
-0.0788324103,
0.022371348,
-0.0376341194,
0.0039985352,
-0.0426329784,
0.0380396098,
0.0100542251,
-0.0186984334,
0.0491382778,
-0.0002817041,
-0.0121191256,
0.0559850931,
0.026831001,
0.0135018239,
-0.008512957,
-0.0384118371,
0.0473281741,
-0.006188578,
0.0233450998,
-0.0491508357,
0.0792070478,
0.0162929613,
-0.0091980053,
-0.0225453209,
0.0044039343,
-0.0230987724,
-0.0731549039,
0.0496569909,
-0.0211288426,
0.0289341435,
0.0325505994,
0.0047450759,
0.020961633,
0.0167164691,
0.0182945691,
0.0326508209,
0.0768659562,
0.0050887847,
-0.033020068,
-0.0029499389,
0.0194647368,
0.0685866624,
0.0214967467,
0.047113467,
-0.020027183,
-0.0038533795,
-0.014289611,
-0.0077558253,
-0.0107401591,
-0.0345536172,
0.0371629037,
0.0369788222,
-0.0524171367,
0.008444177,
-0.0099139502,
0.0280999783,
0.0121040894,
-0.004639585,
-0.0175316855,
0.0031538981,
-0.0110275568,
-0.0282112677,
-0.0045778295,
-0.0002619072,
-0.0164158158,
-0.0122302137,
0.0041575381,
0.0008472863,
0.0574446917,
-0.020203311,
0.0615753867,
-0.006482631,
-0.0326003172,
0.056886889,
0.0268065371,
-0.034718141,
0.0034878738,
0.0320451669,
-0.031377878,
0.0801959261,
0.0670069531,
-0.0376081318,
-0.0279228669,
-0.0014734895,
0.0270991679,
-0.0097572953,
0.034738712,
-0.0353479311,
0.0026933979,
0.0100897811,
-0.0435920469,
0.0353789628,
-0.0013849677,
0.0289631169,
0.0132464385,
0.0553418919,
-0.0227750931,
-0.074373953,
-0.0093766069,
0.0191355757,
0.0009550106,
0.0349353664,
-0.0109011093,
0.0138637042,
0.0195864178,
0.0638945177,
0.0157894008,
-0.0043494175,
0.0466630124,
-0.0198968574,
-0.0017393513,
-0.0434969552,
0.0276166424,
0.0502309725,
0.0207550973,
-0.0547264628,
-0.0256120916,
-0.0077936952,
-0.0085906982,
-0.0816921517,
0.0496273935,
0.0016329073,
0.05288231,
0.0261166971,
-0.0059699309,
-0.0186540093,
-0.0338535085,
-0.012395828,
0.0476581194,
0.0005372989,
-0.008147289,
0.0230949912,
-0.0489339605,
0.0227224045,
0.0328790024,
0.0003975687,
0.0422866009,
-0.0003133295,
-0.0137527948,
0.0452553891,
-0.0465714075,
-0.0418082811,
-0.0183246117,
-0.067871429,
0.0084036402,
-0.0179290604,
0.0195124038,
0.0395625196,
-0.0059278859,
0.0079261148,
0.0391283035,
-0.0315877572,
0.0206133351,
-0.0413762107,
-0.0401923209,
0.0166535061,
0.0239502154,
0.0115826037,
-0.0206690729,
-0.0374120772,
-0.0310615785,
0.0343146846,
-0.0048512202,
-0.0430581123,
0.0213821959,
0.0493480377,
-0.0687908456,
0.0164693203,
-0.0445500053,
-0.0347633809,
0.010394345,
-0.03882486,
0.0037945611,
0.004129665,
0.0239341427,
0.0695874169,
0.0442769304,
-0.0644273162,
-0.0195014887,
0.0019909509,
-0.0636145473,
0.0653778017,
-0.0527288243,
-0.0152150607,
-0.0037151217,
-0.0766804293,
0.0254278779,
0.0234371871,
-0.0243413132,
0.0076466417,
-0.013120262,
0.0292089023,
-0.0041380916,
-0.025312474,
0.0482851565,
0.0351567417,
0.0113594402,
0.0018269497,
0.0207025912,
-0.0018301491,
0.0682417825,
0.0145840263,
-0.007853182,
-0.0356330164,
0.1301444173,
0.0170328822,
-0.0202995464,
-0.030497361,
-0.012021563,
-0.0122887762,
-0.0295090992,
0.041950427,
-0.0451541767,
-0.0332757868,
-0.0170313008,
0.0165326688,
-0.0100292759,
0.0077222306,
-0.0088415844,
0.0238492507,
-0.0113534434,
-0.0004839837,
0.0363695361,
-0.0573961958,
-0.0147939762,
0.0397827886,
0.0310142692,
0.0173824653,
0.0033602838,
-0.0092979455,
-0.0123167858,
0.0254769847,
-0.0023622117,
-0.0451149456,
-0.0032342004,
0.0214190632,
-0.0330280848,
0.024332447,
-0.0237395205,
-0.0300882626,
0.0073449165,
-0.0421910472,
0.0058840932,
-0.0377048962,
-0.0138762975,
-0.0486444347,
-0.0384453647,
-0.0737027973,
0.0068311202,
0.0693086162,
0.0649121106,
-0.060779728,
-0.0004358316,
-0.001609199,
-0.0386123098,
0.0080730263,
0.0271102078,
-0.0998194069,
0.0608075894,
-0.0009357934,
-0.0013067431,
-0.0320258662,
-0.0798683837,
-0.0221179202,
-0.0811186656,
-0.0026900042,
0.009960467,
0.0006432135,
-0.00756789,
-0.0714931861,
-0.0194306374,
0.0081924163,
-0.0886434987,
0.0047831931,
0.010071476,
-0.0061979843,
-0.0183674023,
-0.0303311162,
-0.0492016338,
0.0189813022,
-0.0242254902,
0.018061066,
-0.0258296952,
0.1191724464,
0.0196267255,
-0.0086595509,
-0.0240310468,
0.0302216448,
-0.0380597562,
-0.0312721021,
0.0532772802,
0.0236920062,
-0.0043029026,
-0.0220190082,
-0.006894873,
-0.0141119864,
0.0089934617,
0.0255524497,
0.0573714711,
-0.0669143274,
0.019028753,
0.0037980536,
-0.0314210877,
0.0322387069,
0.0226627067,
-0.0328530483,
0.023471633,
-0.0313231535,
0.0056036822,
0.0789469481,
-0.0628285855,
-0.0145140206,
0.0226782225,
-0.0321701542,
-0.0145428507,
-0.0560341962,
-0.0611892417,
-0.0063342024,
0.034324009,
-0.007443584,
0.0347017162,
0.0692946911,
-0.0268913861,
-0.0391461886,
-0.0353695638,
-0.0111745056,
0.0066018957,
0.0235918704,
-0.0851965472,
-0.0279375669,
0.0391854011,
-0.0108721992,
0.0208902787,
-0.0127298348,
-0.0221385173,
-0.0022057015,
-0.0433902405,
0.0220734309,
0.0294837523,
-0.0153491301,
0.000138437,
0.0238255057,
0.0407928675,
-0.0628936514,
-0.0574315079,
0.0123868706,
-0.0222613309,
0.0030129529,
0.0456653871,
-0.0385063514,
-0.0184623655,
-0.02698173,
-0.0220950488,
-0.0543384664,
-0.0258359183,
-0.0049500195,
0.0006222686,
0.0196113884,
0.0273107756,
-0.0098290052,
-0.042052038,
0.0142397927,
-0.0783146545,
-0.0021547212,
0.013948475,
0.0123144863,
-0.0295175333,
-0.0465639122,
-0.0085100513,
0.0094920201,
-0.0106120519,
0.0209339689,
-0.0225210674,
0.0343683362,
0.0109777628,
0.0265251491,
0.0239030067,
-0.0202748794,
0.0042097503,
0.0085792355,
0.0094851824,
0.0234770533,
-0.0501615144,
-0.0364830457,
0.034088809,
-0.0146476589,
0.0106169181,
0.0095755691,
-0.0847828984,
-0.0496171601,
0.0240174085,
-0.0178141128,
0.0705287829,
0.0295399353,
0.0473846719,
-0.0345254131,
-0.0008072938,
0.0018846272,
-0.0049801753,
0.0127850669,
-0.0252706576,
0.0075950199,
0.0221824907,
-0.0197491832,
0.0949731991,
0.0370148644,
-0.0223581642,
0.0114895813,
0.0493717566,
-0.0624867454,
-0.0000159177,
-0.0379823223,
0.0149665652,
0.0621560253,
-0.0191205237,
-0.0420097969,
-0.0537047163,
-0.0281605478,
0.0367288031,
0.012221952,
-0.031545803,
0.0271034837,
0.0020616655,
0.0118352557,
0.0543816686,
0.027065061,
-0.0849554017,
0.0437257737,
-0.0743450299,
-0.0498148166,
0.0480625369,
-6.357606095e-33,
-0.0138850147,
-0.0402872488,
0.0152468421,
0.0334655978,
-0.0553099252,
0.0067524016,
-0.0480754822,
-0.0327632204,
-0.0274996813,
0.0052640396,
-0.0425232835,
0.0297965519,
0.0308202095,
-0.0166822709,
0.0008021091,
0.029211605,
-0.0110824108,
0.0222741012,
0.0064047072,
0.0477638803,
0.1057457179,
-0.0019020715,
0.0356188267,
-0.0959288403,
0.0551502928,
-0.0071082748,
0.0061197053,
-0.003278852,
0.0769311786,
0.0168689173,
-0.02068137,
0.0274171941,
0.0036624297,
-0.0329479873,
0.0083682109,
-0.006768126,
-0.0907722041,
-0.0112020858,
-0.0067200488,
-0.0154299466,
0.0268872418,
0.0098204901,
-0.0079134163,
0.0407907367,
0.0488069654,
-0.016875241,
0.0480671674,
-0.0144432373,
-0.0396513157,
-0.0132446438,
-0.0057864902,
0.0501360036,
-0.0254439358,
0.0650134534,
-0.0102620963,
-0.0155754909,
0.0218775496,
0.0120584657,
-0.0783715621,
0.0448859408,
-0.025551226,
0.0326914079,
0.01615474,
-0.048922237,
0.0272222236,
0.0288423039,
-0.0052150767,
0.0301950704,
0.012974361,
0.0306436494,
0.0008748235,
0.0400634035,
-0.0167869534,
0.0563501604,
-0.0293333214,
-0.0903966352,
-0.1175541207,
0.0288116615,
0.0116899693,
0.03556275,
-0.0127052106,
-0.0087279864,
0.0089614568,
-0.0287954789,
0.0032401124,
-0.0405576415,
-0.0149373468,
-0.0107908174,
-0.0231131725,
-0.0285702255,
-0.0084201507,
0.0176065005,
0.0150096202,
-0.024311427,
-0.0263930894,
0.0796092153,
-0.0273960736,
0.0249543618,
-0.0086105466,
-0.0162286945,
-0.0589662939,
-0.0228473134,
0.0034794891,
-0.0300930236,
0.0166383367,
0.0191284977,
-0.0406391025,
-0.0000147482,
-0.0066040154,
-0.0231435504,
-0.010038916,
-0.0050444687,
-0.0548356101,
-0.0274074581,
0.003803265,
0.0341703035,
0.0283778347,
0.013222605,
0.0384046361,
0.0226816069,
0.0157015678,
-0.0022385642,
-0.0035349447,
-0.0122267436,
0.0159100518,
-0.025752509,
-0.0140202399,
0.0311183501,
0.0365364142,
0.0041766488,
-0.0138948392,
-0.0111951698,
2.896e-7,
0.0381588116,
0.0489081368,
0.0364944488,
0.0685252771,
-0.0051355087,
0.0070188199,
-0.0075743701,
0.0718250722,
-0.0745679587,
-0.0486463755,
0.0577333719,
-0.0027638352,
0.0282178242,
0.1070061848,
-0.0728091374,
0.0008863779,
-0.0354517289,
-0.0760766715,
-0.0824565068,
-0.0026057686,
0.0359349325,
-0.0048653376,
0.0623653941,
0.0064062946,
-0.0394859649,
0.0024256886,
0.0160932429,
-0.0327978469,
-0.0449462645,
0.0037264777,
0.0389434695,
-0.036431551,
-0.034663368,
0.0646928251,
-0.0353534743,
0.0167367961,
-0.0343012027,
0.029174896,
0.0087311259,
0.0059703258,
-0.0111712981,
-0.0887286663,
0.0147194415,
-0.0234966576,
0.0587842688,
0.0021580309,
-0.0274217464,
0.0438874848,
-0.0169344805,
0.0212627612,
0.000141094,
0.0414073691,
0.0031583016,
0.0342669338,
-0.0329791233,
-0.0077634901,
0.0386256464,
-0.0302317217,
0.0246452969,
0.0005071005,
0.007529533,
-0.0145196291,
0.0005212856,
0.025834756,
0.0030889807,
0.0716397688,
0.0285990294,
2.482393817e-34,
-0.0015779899,
-0.0123560624,
-0.0502918176,
-0.0162207857,
0.0483293533,
-0.0335367471,
-0.0329050533,
-0.0197667256,
0.0091741243,
-0.0856150389,
-0.011594017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19420v1 | Mean BERTs make erratic language teachers: the effectiveness of latent bootstrapping in low-resource settings | 2023-10-30T10:31:32 | 2023-10-30T10:31:32 | David Samuel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper explores the use of latent bootstrapping, an alternative
self-supervision technique, for pretraining language models. Unlike the typical
practice of using self-supervision on discrete subwords, latent bootstrapping
leverages contextualized embeddings for a richer supervision signal. We conduct
experiments to assess how effective this approach is for acquiring linguistic
knowledge from limited resources. Specifically, our experiments are based on
the BabyLM shared task, which includes pretraining on two small curated corpora
and an evaluation on four linguistic benchmarks. | [
0.0105072679,
0.0554409176,
-0.0080796024,
0.0287695806,
-0.0198932998,
0.0105485674,
0.0329174027,
-0.0259786472,
-0.0409408249,
-0.0476384312,
-0.0326027423,
-0.0190799702,
-0.027482789,
-0.0353162698,
0.0690146163,
-0.062129315,
0.0243923962,
0.0130196717,
0.0038859569,
-0.0283371191,
0.0204679891,
-0.0124534462,
-0.0443776585,
0.0455940403,
-0.0624653362,
-0.014284078,
0.0042169765,
-0.0094914418,
0.0183660276,
-0.0015605768,
0.0327150635,
0.0877096131,
0.0513162725,
0.0299414285,
0.0000017544,
-0.0437747762,
-0.0014799797,
-0.0429242179,
-0.0094475094,
0.027284205,
0.0352863856,
-0.003772448,
-0.0216087457,
0.0227066949,
-0.0545690097,
-0.0180428419,
0.015843384,
0.0327923596,
0.0394889712,
0.0214511715,
0.0036792019,
-0.0076574972,
0.0018173695,
-0.016343819,
0.0381916352,
-0.009305655,
0.0002292155,
0.0110081173,
0.0067531937,
-0.0145202884,
-0.0574979484,
0.0234528948,
0.0144602051,
-0.024536442,
-0.0088893613,
0.0505610257,
-0.0270183943,
-0.0412831008,
-0.0162244551,
0.0533068031,
0.0221942011,
-0.0131310057,
-0.0068668579,
0.0014778123,
-0.0104328599,
0.0530852415,
-0.030282801,
0.0263419747,
0.0234420244,
0.0431378223,
0.0170328896,
0.0156264007,
0.0140191009,
-0.0094318977,
-0.0153243216,
0.031136658,
0.0239293464,
-0.0723919049,
0.0066978643,
0.0567031056,
-0.0399171971,
-0.0330329388,
-0.0051087979,
0.0050327373,
0.0255259909,
0.0494089201,
-0.058734484,
-0.0517242514,
0.0108683575,
0.0111319283,
0.0020573193,
0.0304165557,
-0.0584795512,
0.0326948166,
-0.0084059509,
0.0093039647,
0.0118643306,
0.0291864835,
-0.0286160596,
0.0186852124,
-0.0417731106,
0.0067949332,
-0.0528283492,
0.0025391725,
0.0085689807,
-0.0067631775,
-0.038721174,
0.0092979679,
0.0025915082,
-0.0095312353,
-0.0112923598,
-0.0073417849,
-0.0423136614,
0.0124836331,
0.0136189479,
-0.0052375249,
-0.0298463441,
0.004969188,
-0.0228680409,
-0.0477307625,
-0.0163070578,
-0.00156618,
0.0032451714,
-0.018737115,
0.0039297752,
0.0045045805,
0.0078665828,
-0.0847004056,
-0.063892737,
0.0264246147,
-0.0599848293,
-0.0497001,
-0.0126664918,
-0.0783736631,
-0.0088050654,
0.0044104946,
0.0339028202,
0.0027981808,
-0.0023968609,
-0.0091812769,
-0.006519184,
0.068072252,
-0.0380008258,
-0.0039433083,
-0.0016721301,
0.0081950538,
0.0417334586,
0.0966168568,
0.0407661088,
-0.0376790985,
0.0421119072,
-0.0114646954,
-0.0137776611,
0.0322816335,
0.0498587415,
0.0268839039,
-0.0298323166,
-0.020875806,
-0.0109553449,
0.0200029928,
0.0323359519,
0.0272632688,
-0.0435129106,
0.027495373,
0.051396396,
0.1134471893,
0.0400415771,
0.0127149038,
0.101055339,
-0.010388026,
0.001169985,
0.0354241692,
-0.0298333149,
-0.0389630571,
-0.0003314815,
-0.0133551266,
0.0242492817,
0.0189001169,
-0.0324006043,
-0.018687278,
-0.020785138,
-0.0276285186,
-0.0375544466,
-0.0136017483,
0.0556028709,
0.0460154824,
0.0090095894,
0.0034268408,
0.0665938258,
-0.0478151329,
0.0270032808,
-0.0138815679,
0.0099767698,
0.0529518612,
0.024205314,
-0.0449448451,
-0.0616407841,
-0.0057233647,
0.0577506311,
0.0542331934,
0.0263994522,
-0.0248397887,
0.008657801,
-0.0514133833,
-0.0158456974,
-0.00370952,
0.0636465549,
-0.0100309914,
0.001526639,
0.0170666147,
-0.0193571709,
-0.0973752439,
0.028918907,
0.0498382896,
-0.0515997633,
-0.0582519472,
-0.0251737852,
0.0354512483,
0.0027775068,
0.0307851881,
-0.030618893,
0.0038833802,
0.0346179307,
-0.0282967538,
-0.0011493929,
0.003318073,
-0.083463937,
-0.0871630386,
0.004453538,
-0.031779252,
-0.0462549776,
0.0191152319,
-0.0038235025,
-0.0428612381,
0.0177713148,
-0.0351222418,
0.0896368623,
-0.0598438978,
-0.0050786017,
-0.0235078875,
-0.0109391566,
-0.0268556736,
0.0541718155,
-0.0115799159,
0.038246382,
-0.005218578,
0.0369161516,
0.0299628656,
-0.0346798114,
-0.0438039415,
-0.0436809547,
0.0099731945,
0.0329880118,
0.0299788881,
0.0366849788,
-0.0669156089,
-0.0171123743,
-0.0891573206,
-0.0229948144,
-0.0367190652,
0.0304183997,
0.0286277756,
-0.0080223763,
-0.0177286528,
-0.0266411975,
0.0106126387,
-0.013761986,
-0.0338137858,
0.0298157744,
0.0430060215,
-0.0018927802,
-0.0130957719,
-0.0522313602,
-0.0151685085,
-0.0343590192,
0.0396037772,
0.0257884581,
0.0259505156,
-0.0290624984,
-0.0214072149,
-0.0275045522,
0.0183935873,
0.0224909522,
-0.0301685669,
0.0452199541,
-0.0293425154,
0.0986332223,
0.0399063639,
-0.0000186256,
0.097588785,
0.0267776288,
-0.0270554926,
-0.0767249689,
0.0071040676,
-0.0261043087,
-0.0235748887,
-0.0330051407,
-0.0045744912,
-0.0395349003,
0.0862225071,
0.0142137567,
-0.0197819136,
-0.095225215,
0.0015234201,
-0.036624182,
-0.0214462262,
-0.033644747,
0.0307757333,
-0.017590249,
0.0279222857,
-0.0016494232,
-0.0682774484,
0.0677127689,
-0.0259230342,
-0.025113415,
-0.0375347696,
-0.0066257846,
-0.0001677304,
0.0216617808,
-0.000049382,
0.0000581061,
-0.0116328346,
-0.0222244132,
-0.042258095,
0.0248677023,
0.0475345924,
-0.0146793649,
-0.0060785194,
-0.0378055871,
0.0142517881,
0.0350961275,
-0.0066286754,
-0.0512788557,
-0.0695630908,
-0.0098439949,
0.0091774045,
0.0222077705,
-0.0116716819,
-0.0182387568,
-0.0169273484,
0.0316875391,
0.0157992113,
0.0264015496,
-0.0226875488,
-0.0102532227,
0.019508943,
0.0029555832,
-0.0297742859,
0.0157650579,
-0.0612633638,
0.0283317026,
0.0229348391,
0.100897409,
-0.0072566168,
-0.0693143532,
0.0288041346,
0.0183293913,
0.0021771987,
-0.0135299368,
0.0170468669,
0.0471460484,
-0.0283360034,
-0.027719155,
0.1224869043,
0.0359454751,
-0.0091429316,
0.0089516602,
-0.0089569213,
0.0419018306,
0.0170793217,
-0.0033449708,
-0.0595788173,
-0.0173134599,
-0.0157723092,
0.0292378124,
0.0432710685,
-0.0570706762,
-0.0042913607,
-0.0966813862,
0.0018009297,
0.0020656784,
-0.0377008282,
0.0238686148,
-0.0425712056,
0.015669873,
0.0053462582,
0.0397344381,
-0.0346889272,
-0.0372621566,
0.0224649981,
0.0464886427,
0.0050470755,
-0.0684281737,
0.0317058191,
-0.0582706556,
0.0629994124,
0.031145459,
0.0215335637,
-0.0210938621,
-0.016769493,
0.0201166235,
-0.0658788458,
-0.0441735014,
-0.0076979822,
0.0346639715,
-0.0442995019,
-0.0304848608,
0.0055402038,
0.0305331871,
-0.0164148994,
0.0088563673,
-0.021357825,
0.0914673433,
0.001306801,
-0.0290225223,
0.0077275308,
0.0363467447,
0.0531097762,
0.0703670532,
0.0634901151,
-0.0792974308,
0.0139038274,
0.0335178003,
0.0336051062,
0.0015333678,
-0.0189488363,
0.0296435133,
-0.0346577466,
0.0071630734,
-0.0734685585,
-0.0821331367,
0.0739294067,
0.0656040385,
0.026214622,
-0.0043010092,
0.0035684381,
-0.0221924894,
-0.0052022091,
0.0533647798,
-0.005171211,
-0.0185934193,
-0.0772861317,
-0.0558212698,
0.0206330717,
0.0139334463,
-0.0101552121,
-0.0636862144,
-0.0387050547,
-0.0701282844,
0.021771349,
0.0491202883,
0.0203533955,
0.0344823636,
-0.0138203492,
-0.032739941,
0.0606443547,
0.0345624276,
-0.0419421531,
0.0222212486,
0.0643820986,
0.0097874394,
0.0254718438,
0.0494079255,
-0.0347585827,
0.0536279194,
0.0230796728,
0.057301335,
-0.0294866469,
-0.0108425999,
0.0141036715,
-0.0419421308,
0.0861294866,
-0.0533180609,
0.0196142606,
-0.0845921412,
-0.0101574557,
-0.007476232,
0.0167084001,
-0.0444436744,
0.017636558,
0.0245834403,
0.0099725192,
-0.0106129814,
0.031057924,
-0.0411639996,
0.0439404882,
-0.0431235582,
0.0255207382,
-0.0023024837,
0.0059007118,
0.0117940353,
0.0336078592,
0.0059155663,
0.001056937,
-0.0121594248,
0.0059757186,
-0.0128895519,
0.0337821096,
0.0382684506,
0.020751033,
0.0147345411,
0.0166033041,
-0.0315861814,
-0.0029104648,
-0.0133221215,
0.0307368282,
0.0535523146,
-0.0540405214,
0.0430284403,
-0.0311547052,
0.0133114746,
-0.0167633556,
0.0185510572,
-0.0283624232,
-0.0045988844,
0.050973393,
0.0132679343,
-0.0118740937,
0.0394964963,
0.0596014895,
0.0105689587,
0.0489649437,
0.0227262527,
0.0369028673,
-0.0270549431,
0.0053856228,
0.0483673029,
0.0105261663,
-0.0318742022,
0.0547684431,
-0.0531798638,
-0.0552584976,
-0.0263286829,
0.0369516276,
-0.0535615422,
0.035007365,
0.032910876,
0.0553646609,
-0.0401684716,
0.0387846716,
-0.0051861475,
0.0094287219,
0.0291066971,
-0.0444530211,
-0.0012879758,
-6.467979137e-33,
-0.0403127782,
-0.0366046168,
0.0372828022,
0.0257498603,
0.0357107036,
0.0246348474,
-0.0223395135,
0.0174961444,
-0.0121321231,
0.060872063,
-0.0040687378,
-0.0031942036,
0.0106015168,
0.0468803421,
0.0223278645,
0.0178266093,
0.0311762001,
0.002312636,
-0.0091201914,
-0.0008892011,
0.0072594732,
0.0679648072,
0.074387297,
-0.0426944718,
0.0304932464,
-0.0263374615,
0.0245198756,
0.0218570977,
0.0192309823,
0.0533738583,
-0.02735072,
0.0291541182,
0.0025378065,
-0.0007158032,
-0.0357579365,
0.0447958447,
-0.1015273035,
-0.0893205181,
0.0091867615,
-0.0065195067,
-0.0845441669,
0.0366948172,
-0.0153730009,
-0.0317804664,
0.0060275923,
0.0433127135,
0.0460012779,
0.0185471699,
-0.020979818,
-0.0078209788,
-0.0665251166,
0.017455386,
0.0030657549,
-0.0438534766,
0.0249892287,
-0.0100720692,
-0.0063969982,
-0.0384791866,
5.613e-7,
0.0255314931,
0.0019729768,
0.0090637142,
0.0214825757,
-0.0168399606,
0.0083951857,
0.0631883442,
0.000535656,
-0.0191313475,
0.0263988823,
-0.0262841918,
0.0746667683,
0.0118132932,
0.012200173,
0.0223267544,
0.0184065979,
0.0251276474,
-0.0353021175,
0.0020494824,
0.0429113545,
-0.0108563881,
-0.0108579574,
-0.0083293049,
-0.0350270309,
-0.0187871121,
-0.030107107,
-0.0255055502,
-0.0081449524,
-0.0317338407,
0.0308960434,
0.0294477139,
-0.0517898202,
0.015614518,
0.0126131941,
-0.02205888,
-0.0334214978,
-0.024238484,
0.0125615001,
-0.0325444862,
-0.0152672986,
0.0308049507,
-0.0803119242,
-0.0336460583,
0.0258943327,
0.009485364,
0.0097085256,
0.0066795195,
0.0628582537,
0.0252098758,
-0.0509962477,
-0.0241213683,
-0.0303335544,
-0.0095374007,
-0.0167272631,
-0.0311687551,
0.0545690954,
0.0135111725,
-0.0118127251,
0.0388978273,
0.0542376675,
-0.0210406519,
-0.0233204886,
0.0085150665,
-0.0209871698,
0.0097220512,
-0.0123870214,
-0.0297280103,
-0.0305294301,
0.0557557829,
0.0575632714,
-0.0486306585,
0.0100827236,
-0.0112471906,
2.524e-7,
0.062113408,
0.0526663363,
0.0209422149,
-0.0847789049,
0.0196366888,
0.0162035506,
-0.0486720614,
0.0152413202,
-0.0275174975,
-0.0321087688,
-0.0027667098,
0.0106590362,
0.026531117,
0.0348996893,
-0.0496195741,
-0.002964081,
-0.0661826879,
0.0372621752,
-0.0357197933,
-0.0127216959,
0.0220535547,
0.0506399274,
0.0401966684,
-0.0250405502,
-0.015827924,
-0.0635206178,
0.0553401932,
-0.0216905065,
-0.0138593465,
-0.0055395323,
0.0309606269,
0.0480298772,
0.0082551977,
0.0143787619,
-0.0225675888,
0.0416216552,
-0.0174438227,
0.0199079309,
0.0047757868,
0.0015346796,
-0.0009467105,
-0.0089319898,
-0.0408673398,
-0.0012859252,
0.0326393917,
-0.081177935,
-0.0087852981,
0.0370143279,
-0.0027129746,
-0.0046137315,
0.0462111123,
-0.0289309155,
-0.0412618257,
0.0220113359,
0.0206392705,
-0.0018732516,
-0.0218423456,
-0.0730558932,
0.0272656623,
0.0532125607,
-0.0511574075,
-0.0634149238,
-0.0095202569,
-0.0139685683,
0.0097086597,
-0.0410582721,
0.0135412784,
1.980665048e-34,
0.0171933193,
0.0031875125,
0.0318533666,
-0.006711104,
0.0008119597,
-0.0376489125,
0.0034065607,
-0.0009902448,
0.0210667104,
-0.0367363542,
-0.0103105875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19403v1 | A Lightweight Method to Generate Unanswerable Questions in English | 2023-10-30T10:14:52 | 2023-10-30T10:14:52 | Vagrant Gautam, Miaoran Zhang, Dietrich Klakow | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | If a question cannot be answered with the available information, robust
systems for question answering (QA) should know _not_ to answer. One way to
build QA models that do this is with additional training data comprised of
unanswerable questions, created either by employing annotators or through
automated methods for unanswerable question generation. To show that the model
complexity of existing automated approaches is not justified, we examine a
simpler data augmentation method for unanswerable question generation in
English: performing antonym and entity swaps on answerable questions. Compared
to the prior state-of-the-art, data generated with our training-free and
lightweight strategy results in better models (+1.6 F1 points on SQuAD 2.0 data
with BERT-large), and has higher human-judged relatedness and readability. We
quantify the raw benefits of our approach compared to no augmentation across
multiple encoder models, using different amounts of generated data, and also on
TydiQA-MinSpan data (+9.3 F1 points with BERT-large). Our results establish
swaps as a simple but strong baseline for future work. | [
0.0769339204,
0.0313026123,
-0.0129479682,
0.03095139,
-0.0251080375,
0.0381636843,
-0.0059598056,
-0.0053093918,
-0.0142615205,
-0.0223785974,
-0.0086861141,
-0.0099356975,
-0.0486252084,
0.0075689848,
0.0585770048,
-0.0302326791,
0.0390402749,
0.0061094272,
-0.0323039666,
-0.0432937592,
0.0080748405,
-0.0116857113,
-0.00939894,
0.0070999893,
-0.0001981245,
0.0043400438,
-0.0368487537,
0.0242796298,
0.0191446859,
0.0009639892,
0.0199283026,
0.0419008471,
-0.0030844572,
0.034397725,
0.0000019333,
-0.0437238142,
-0.0263314247,
0.0048539662,
-0.0519619882,
-0.0037671796,
0.0063919593,
-0.0043457388,
0.025113022,
0.0362134017,
-0.0387310199,
0.0123480344,
0.0766713619,
0.0034477641,
0.0959574357,
0.084001936,
0.0064545553,
-0.0072044739,
0.0318570584,
-0.01352295,
0.0537259616,
-0.0449459739,
0.0022337965,
-0.0269046612,
0.0071220677,
0.027955126,
-0.0358236507,
0.0454402938,
0.0513354875,
0.0284799207,
0.0335084796,
0.0200879332,
-0.0248262156,
-0.0207681358,
-0.0043491987,
0.0783336014,
0.0164394844,
-0.0279860888,
-0.0098988321,
0.0007624893,
0.0276228786,
0.0594814494,
-0.012707239,
0.0117015336,
0.0223141536,
-0.0000370639,
0.0200149883,
-0.0103702666,
-0.0018065521,
0.0203884635,
-0.0251324717,
0.0602982529,
0.0504430868,
-0.0617614239,
0.0070306133,
0.022014197,
-0.0577168912,
-0.0536153056,
0.0257419962,
0.0420478955,
-0.0271086637,
0.0387669168,
-0.0621987171,
-0.0570839159,
0.0240666177,
-0.0581528842,
-0.0150075601,
0.0392263979,
-0.0034283972,
0.0294622164,
-0.0271304268,
0.0211475138,
-0.0160010569,
0.0370322652,
-0.0579365976,
-0.02582822,
-0.0101058045,
-0.0445766151,
-0.0701627955,
0.0469668992,
-0.0515479334,
0.0155178597,
-0.0105006155,
0.0152646312,
-0.0017365784,
-0.0157085508,
0.0177237969,
0.0468628518,
-0.0372636504,
-0.0080377283,
-0.0363704152,
0.0151044074,
-0.1025952399,
0.0180308186,
0.0103896838,
-0.0480892882,
0.0029763111,
0.0098779537,
0.0183440279,
-0.0385520421,
0.0388433188,
0.0440095551,
-0.0387997068,
-0.0173988454,
-0.0125499777,
0.0023883239,
-0.0041827373,
-0.059213195,
-0.0123809818,
-0.0494322479,
0.0225892756,
0.0286234729,
-0.0126000699,
-0.0373718999,
0.0362722725,
0.0377527028,
-0.0264971852,
0.0864144042,
-0.0512429774,
0.0248281211,
0.0380417965,
-0.0116756577,
-0.0070881923,
0.0374624506,
0.0437145531,
-0.0323227458,
0.0538504943,
-0.0056668264,
0.0063800006,
0.0064965151,
0.0371649563,
-0.0079988921,
-0.009685752,
0.0285413489,
-0.036608696,
0.0181483645,
-0.0065569831,
0.0553852879,
-0.0109124947,
-0.0505290031,
0.0094322795,
-0.0207706783,
-0.0757457688,
0.0197430812,
0.0040651956,
0.0181046892,
0.0084411241,
0.0264381692,
-0.0296480674,
0.0616908446,
-0.0457003452,
-0.0073840409,
0.0381882228,
-0.0304547474,
-0.0462870412,
-0.0372365415,
0.0236140378,
0.0129023409,
0.0304194503,
0.0096912775,
0.0183691755,
0.0370500386,
-0.0326779485,
0.0442570783,
-0.0072829747,
-0.0845428929,
0.0308564045,
-0.0121676838,
0.0257871579,
0.0420165472,
0.0381134599,
-0.0155243156,
-0.1033680588,
0.0101993317,
-0.0331454203,
0.0585555732,
0.0129705863,
-0.0121875154,
0.0151538858,
-0.0619178563,
-0.000746344,
-0.0300507508,
-0.0085769091,
-0.0187545493,
0.0212298427,
0.0222206768,
0.0257089026,
-0.1105085537,
-0.0221832059,
0.0396793187,
-0.0489032455,
-0.0306002237,
0.0342097878,
0.0334343202,
0.022182202,
0.0246400274,
0.0013273648,
0.0216050688,
0.0513894521,
-0.0461425856,
-0.0350016318,
0.0210587289,
0.0074150614,
-0.0870098174,
0.0150434701,
-0.061533317,
-0.0415879227,
0.0869076476,
-0.0343177952,
-0.0758137405,
0.0026331702,
-0.0867721289,
0.0405556858,
-0.0639344379,
0.0229742955,
0.0259025712,
-0.0072237924,
-0.0196845978,
0.0546842068,
-0.0140626356,
0.040394783,
-0.0060412763,
0.0357734039,
0.0323919617,
-0.0295525379,
-0.0487122536,
-0.0300466567,
-0.0119583448,
-0.0252973828,
0.043517191,
0.0224148259,
-0.0560153574,
-0.0137110231,
-0.0885251388,
0.0188285429,
-0.0250686686,
0.0265033729,
0.051318869,
0.0216102432,
0.0011021753,
-0.0411863364,
-0.0771449283,
0.0331205651,
0.0192762725,
0.0398886576,
0.0432983674,
0.0193519183,
-0.0008480568,
-0.0173702873,
-0.0007115809,
0.0242013335,
0.0038075326,
0.0010525414,
0.0232975874,
-0.0174449552,
0.0376173742,
-0.0350473709,
0.010387186,
0.031519834,
-0.0614035092,
0.0089181708,
0.0098826643,
0.0309493169,
-0.0136930458,
0.0347077735,
0.0093365191,
0.0138075678,
0.0205046292,
-0.035972096,
0.0276431274,
-0.0318802036,
-0.0308370963,
0.0065138871,
-0.0724704564,
-0.0068275966,
0.0323045962,
-0.0103757782,
-0.0261765439,
-0.0708561316,
0.0379085317,
-0.0028465611,
-0.0422332436,
-0.0482342467,
0.0033008207,
-0.0254524034,
0.0513510965,
-0.0355278589,
-0.0053622476,
0.0788687095,
0.009350949,
-0.0413134098,
-0.0630371943,
0.0332699083,
-0.0043372321,
0.0531309992,
0.0073691844,
0.0401032418,
-0.003692454,
-0.0270822253,
-0.0469719097,
0.0176078044,
-0.0041677766,
-0.0173080303,
-0.007706258,
-0.0387200788,
0.003205156,
0.0234841909,
-0.0363029689,
-0.076638341,
-0.0457234159,
0.016132012,
-0.0165121723,
0.009448112,
-0.004420124,
-0.0226661861,
0.0005452087,
-0.007243955,
0.0082815439,
-0.0376266763,
-0.009806456,
-0.0137082841,
0.0610435307,
0.0760753378,
0.0476001054,
0.0073586646,
-0.0258576404,
0.0033713982,
0.0388698541,
0.0088058515,
-0.0165037867,
0.0404114462,
0.0285801403,
0.016402157,
-0.026277069,
-0.0114688771,
-0.0034970113,
0.0426190048,
-0.0175344255,
-0.075478971,
0.1157582328,
0.0747589618,
0.0117130233,
0.0193231367,
-0.010416491,
0.029122645,
0.036848709,
0.0301670693,
-0.0554545112,
-0.0151162418,
0.0044204122,
0.069460921,
-0.0217359476,
-0.0440071784,
-0.0115927747,
-0.1344245225,
0.019986026,
-0.0236414205,
-0.060405843,
-0.0431042612,
-0.0242401157,
-0.0002436933,
-0.0081059523,
-0.0051177768,
0.0176494103,
0.0285416711,
0.0267800987,
0.0197361838,
-0.0084801,
-0.0120053124,
-0.0311724339,
-0.0297283474,
0.0623783097,
0.0486551039,
0.0251404643,
-0.0116969515,
-0.0367397927,
0.0080031594,
-0.0399167724,
-0.0253700055,
-0.0051785223,
0.1024337336,
-0.0002532548,
-0.035654489,
-0.0421366096,
0.0489992388,
-0.0290198848,
0.0113868117,
0.0223711561,
0.0592647642,
-0.0173391607,
0.0194928683,
-0.0020998714,
0.0185461026,
0.0170526374,
0.101409696,
0.0210194644,
-0.048918929,
0.0031627915,
-0.0026579893,
0.0449118577,
-0.0899863243,
0.0244458411,
-0.0084216418,
0.0018002874,
-0.0151825938,
-0.0996977985,
-0.0850609094,
0.0492648184,
0.0427036583,
0.0029794145,
0.008525054,
0.006753725,
0.0086130118,
-0.049774453,
-0.0295318011,
-0.009853485,
-0.0064823241,
-0.0373289771,
-0.0693915859,
-0.0017356544,
-0.0197038967,
-0.0292671733,
-0.0197211821,
-0.0243966617,
-0.0357682146,
0.0140944617,
0.0609057769,
0.0249937642,
0.0024754202,
-0.019691797,
-0.035617467,
-0.0066096378,
0.0246281046,
-0.0382812396,
0.0020031703,
0.0142884431,
-0.0007970211,
-0.0182469059,
0.0538678095,
-0.0323468223,
-0.008980562,
0.008018163,
0.0827512592,
-0.0316335075,
-0.0374540165,
0.050235454,
0.0410825014,
-0.0043909736,
-0.0241382997,
-0.0177664459,
-0.0255093444,
0.0332926698,
-0.0304786675,
-0.0156767499,
-0.0465762578,
-0.0079230824,
0.0386432707,
-0.0103468504,
-0.0247759875,
0.0254366715,
-0.0251326356,
0.0374039374,
0.00381608,
0.000802384,
0.0251866132,
0.0324772447,
-0.0204090271,
0.0113053145,
-0.0063096113,
-0.0210114829,
0.036062099,
0.0465230159,
-0.0046783793,
0.0466311723,
0.0174563341,
0.0035115324,
0.0049597505,
0.0145678986,
-0.050379362,
-0.0134982914,
-0.0217215307,
0.066448614,
-0.0086583653,
-0.0019831443,
0.0498310216,
-0.0187314767,
-0.0202934016,
0.0087958993,
-0.0261606723,
0.0141475061,
-0.0195797049,
0.0419852883,
-0.0003952404,
0.0084360028,
0.006140314,
0.0577491894,
0.0000670302,
0.0585040785,
-0.0029674943,
-0.0015116204,
-0.0464532822,
-0.0061242096,
0.0029985153,
0.0048594163,
-0.0084844762,
0.0572942197,
-0.0403450504,
-0.0697222725,
-0.0276162289,
0.0024404621,
-0.0001183352,
0.0111080604,
0.044741936,
0.0486997217,
-0.0094410339,
-0.0208837315,
-0.0341253579,
0.0885885283,
-0.0366966873,
-0.0295294933,
-0.0319228657,
-6.614027698e-33,
-0.0336077288,
-0.0194591843,
0.0068059345,
-0.0823373944,
-0.0236149002,
-0.026127778,
-0.050600525,
0.0009655661,
-0.0214973912,
0.0192204583,
-0.0094449399,
-0.0132225817,
-0.0033766811,
0.0568537861,
-0.0043513472,
-0.0491463803,
0.0509334691,
-0.0049493867,
-0.0212122556,
0.0045087864,
0.0475844033,
0.0321216099,
0.0227619149,
-0.0143220592,
0.0166932456,
-0.0473970324,
-0.0150957387,
0.0547351316,
-0.0000991634,
0.0148395104,
-0.0095895799,
0.0357997939,
0.0185020193,
-0.0109218424,
0.0078450134,
0.0020991531,
-0.0788791403,
-0.0544885583,
0.0347393304,
0.0198118854,
-0.0306363832,
-0.0562784858,
0.0413998142,
-0.0260137524,
0.0030286973,
0.0468556993,
0.0005424931,
-0.0223394688,
0.0435331166,
-0.0098387571,
-0.0524833687,
-0.008841332,
-0.0116848303,
-0.0626794472,
-0.0226237252,
0.089586556,
-0.0012098009,
-0.0443723612,
-0.0283254385,
-0.0043874262,
0.0317876935,
-0.0048483661,
0.0466535948,
0.0037532211,
-0.018802451,
0.021591166,
0.0179265663,
-0.0051425719,
0.01074134,
0.0177765302,
-0.0033034615,
0.0435684882,
0.0728958771,
0.0606559776,
0.056019742,
0.0051995278,
-0.0336720832,
0.0719277561,
-0.0088865962,
0.0161542054,
0.0149561372,
-0.0270689297,
-0.0521085076,
-0.0304230992,
-0.0265206862,
0.0107991351,
-0.0492015705,
-0.0307262708,
0.0584422462,
-0.0110752331,
-0.0787501559,
0.0049118297,
0.0119519727,
-0.0247566756,
0.0280333105,
0.0361215733,
0.0201526601,
0.0197802018,
0.0163567252,
0.0355834775,
-0.0271542352,
0.0239044502,
0.0571136214,
-0.0039218604,
-0.0286977384,
0.0270709507,
0.0329775885,
0.0169739909,
-0.0662131608,
0.0067901881,
-0.0287877098,
0.0466717817,
-0.0564278066,
-0.0105741918,
0.0053277742,
0.0327675752,
-0.0183239523,
-0.0052600759,
0.0093262866,
0.0107290773,
-0.0637672469,
-0.0222121831,
0.0067174649,
0.0232496504,
-0.0168920141,
0.0263289772,
-0.0083284592,
0.0111795198,
-0.040715754,
-0.0730471835,
-0.001677373,
-0.0016097924,
2.707e-7,
0.0560604259,
0.033509016,
0.0644190907,
-0.0021925126,
-0.002332218,
0.0215231869,
-0.0087569393,
-0.0000858329,
0.0356332473,
0.0047256034,
0.0336033963,
0.0105060805,
0.023172453,
0.0095843887,
-0.0382622145,
0.0027195872,
-0.0535403863,
-0.0149774021,
-0.016134046,
0.0096867383,
0.1078594849,
0.0745237246,
0.023121763,
-0.022212768,
-0.0028604621,
-0.0007805016,
0.0298270993,
-0.0157202911,
-0.003831248,
-0.0151074054,
-0.0013397181,
0.029422693,
0.0206588674,
0.0442077108,
-0.0273889601,
0.0024386686,
0.0244665258,
0.011510455,
-0.0052146013,
-0.0808849335,
-0.0357105173,
-0.0201196838,
0.029366767,
-0.0750457048,
0.0908175632,
-0.0228052195,
-0.016441498,
0.056331072,
-0.0711220652,
0.0516053885,
-0.021109337,
-0.0265521146,
-0.0552391633,
-0.0199726075,
0.0438892655,
-0.0005156223,
0.0204354133,
-0.0317357443,
-0.0127640245,
0.0125110336,
-0.0177985243,
-0.0485581718,
-0.0461076722,
0.0342997834,
-0.024539195,
-0.0568099655,
-0.0237138178,
2.032562664e-34,
0.0243308581,
0.0305573419,
0.0105952108,
0.0204826482,
-0.0063448357,
-0.0112336082,
0.0183319915,
-0.0160334334,
0.0264005978,
-0.0557809025,
-0.0149186365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19349v1 | Japanese SimCSE Technical Report | 2023-10-30T08:43:26 | 2023-10-30T08:43:26 | Hayato Tsukagoshi, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL | We report the development of Japanese SimCSE, Japanese sentence embedding
models fine-tuned with SimCSE. Since there is a lack of sentence embedding
models for Japanese that can be used as a baseline in sentence embedding
research, we conducted extensive experiments on Japanese sentence embeddings
involving 24 pre-trained Japanese or multilingual language models, five
supervised datasets, and four unsupervised datasets. In this report, we provide
the detailed training setup for Japanese SimCSE and their evaluation results. | [
0.0236324929,
0.0213455316,
0.0139730973,
0.0556505322,
-0.0002345592,
0.0384632796,
-0.0074007851,
-0.0200348683,
0.0076871333,
0.0079986723,
-0.0363852642,
-0.0093871672,
-0.0014016151,
-0.0046906462,
0.0217040163,
-0.0632406697,
0.0440308787,
0.0412264578,
-0.0003917291,
0.0275073983,
0.0673151389,
-0.0012206573,
0.0478404202,
0.050234478,
-0.0468742326,
-0.037517596,
0.0179255251,
0.0170101319,
0.0313456133,
-0.0368536934,
0.057294935,
0.0103548821,
0.0399921797,
-0.0137877287,
0.0000016381,
0.0260895155,
0.0215042327,
-0.0462986268,
0.0113823228,
0.0545080788,
0.0144773433,
-0.0755024329,
0.0087503651,
0.0399605632,
-0.0210964046,
-0.0365834907,
0.045887541,
0.0405954123,
0.0770850629,
0.0737358928,
-0.0390527546,
-0.0739310384,
0.00241819,
-0.053497456,
-0.076703243,
0.0336740017,
-0.0002161842,
-0.0158829167,
-0.062525183,
0.0035154214,
-0.0047262236,
0.0161247514,
0.0360387489,
0.0103340102,
-0.0147111891,
-0.0008332802,
0.0185631812,
0.0112932585,
-0.0068938821,
0.0675574988,
-0.0396144763,
-0.0063697957,
-0.0311572496,
-0.0058932374,
-0.0292827412,
-0.0089093195,
-0.0448211469,
0.0086340681,
0.0692210495,
0.0423226543,
0.0550361238,
0.0601657704,
0.0432938039,
-0.0030908268,
0.0024336881,
0.02849227,
0.0364237949,
-0.0746690929,
-0.0450221151,
-0.0051571871,
-0.003445877,
0.0066421097,
0.0049489802,
-0.0053026713,
-0.006315616,
0.0253831241,
-0.0331895128,
-0.0437172465,
0.016703194,
-0.0420381874,
0.0351262093,
0.0428870618,
-0.0072838403,
0.009299458,
-0.0198928751,
0.0101390937,
-0.0105446223,
0.0428945161,
-0.0515015721,
-0.0147599922,
-0.0108765215,
-0.0199099965,
-0.0753290579,
-0.0070501156,
-0.0246078502,
-0.0667057559,
-0.0297519341,
0.0187289771,
-0.0195900798,
0.0072861314,
0.0295143872,
-0.0459043533,
-0.0355337411,
0.0126037179,
0.0235683713,
0.0120813837,
-0.0606581606,
-0.0099952742,
0.0198799856,
0.003524919,
-0.0298081897,
0.0206216611,
0.0538726225,
-0.010602206,
0.0059038294,
-0.0114886295,
0.0058404859,
-0.0692404956,
-0.0175079517,
0.0045946776,
-0.0216345862,
-0.0274700373,
0.0167100299,
-0.0176965427,
0.0598432086,
-0.0206539556,
0.0498992875,
-0.0320812091,
0.0143593475,
0.0139919696,
0.0145830316,
0.0438813195,
0.0244977511,
-0.0137035558,
-0.0766758546,
0.0089260992,
0.0561786592,
0.0829135478,
0.000638729,
-0.0114615597,
0.0608272143,
0.0251302551,
0.0080055865,
0.056041643,
-0.0264808163,
0.012151544,
0.0094070174,
0.0372463427,
0.0043588174,
0.067200534,
0.0148305949,
0.0007841477,
-0.0112893684,
0.0112826033,
0.0189542938,
0.0403897278,
-0.0012044375,
0.0228463579,
0.0796277598,
-0.0036174583,
-0.0210508648,
0.0287522692,
-0.0176913552,
0.0141144767,
0.0016373579,
0.0535950549,
0.0053779781,
0.0131056001,
-0.0291628093,
-0.0530870408,
-0.037522316,
-0.0526611172,
-0.0336224921,
-0.008183741,
0.0104372455,
0.0174670294,
-0.0538891442,
0.0457171462,
0.01281475,
-0.0732727274,
-0.0523074381,
0.0481473096,
-0.0075746509,
0.0727948323,
0.0345055424,
0.003726396,
-0.0067616268,
0.0036056873,
0.0477232076,
0.0466310196,
0.0602228455,
-0.0186785311,
0.0356068239,
-0.0556100234,
-0.0063337847,
-0.0084898742,
0.0278567523,
-0.0132681141,
0.0133396657,
0.0352969319,
0.0409471728,
-0.0266670398,
0.0076082796,
0.0361215957,
-0.0183379296,
0.022143282,
-0.0308950543,
0.0454199091,
0.0214934889,
-0.006431411,
-0.0166750457,
0.0164491069,
0.0415854938,
-0.0601630434,
0.0032886923,
0.0381098203,
-0.0784244686,
-0.1156459004,
0.0324665308,
-0.0397806168,
-0.0299214963,
0.0941047445,
-0.0433536842,
0.0077703423,
-0.0241184346,
-0.0077054491,
-0.0176124293,
-0.1027872637,
0.0129528157,
-0.0031300294,
0.0706966743,
0.0133565282,
0.0353679322,
-0.0165947955,
0.0091565102,
0.0367034599,
-0.0210853871,
0.05010489,
-0.0490172133,
-0.0490600318,
-0.0060159657,
0.0158169139,
-0.0090421345,
-0.0191772245,
-0.0080717914,
0.0162005201,
0.0092885625,
-0.0951206908,
0.0302898195,
-0.0404921956,
-0.0203489289,
-0.0046393308,
0.0266773812,
-0.0278203487,
-0.0033985183,
-0.0290503819,
0.0063642492,
0.0034796067,
0.0158317946,
0.0264202803,
-0.0436841995,
0.010494072,
-0.0609456077,
-0.0100311777,
0.0045105023,
0.0519999079,
-0.0560341664,
-0.0238901321,
-0.0207959171,
0.0268974658,
-0.0046501835,
-0.0230394527,
0.0113084801,
-0.0758538321,
-0.0275678188,
-0.0206902027,
0.068372719,
0.0345097072,
-0.0181648806,
0.0409072228,
0.0320458189,
0.0061651729,
0.0076864944,
-0.000422031,
-0.0213422142,
0.0452140868,
-0.0229363404,
-0.016671773,
0.0220230818,
0.0974958986,
-0.0002965067,
-0.0091894092,
-0.0344870612,
-0.0121356808,
-0.0364404954,
0.0202201344,
-0.0100596696,
0.0035798165,
-0.0421162695,
-0.0145582901,
-0.0105362879,
-0.0062813475,
0.0388288349,
-0.0232803021,
-0.0332785137,
-0.0784530267,
-0.0112853535,
-0.0280525088,
0.0212406404,
-0.0162108094,
0.0356945321,
0.0141540943,
0.0203272291,
-0.0329952501,
0.0052917614,
0.0181498919,
-0.0127155473,
-0.0413794443,
0.0197313223,
-0.0262576398,
-0.0156422369,
-0.0197680667,
0.0000639844,
-0.1117398962,
-0.0432279482,
-0.0002195446,
0.0390154235,
0.0262496416,
0.0151413856,
0.0091409711,
-0.0305636954,
0.0083364053,
-0.005167393,
0.0057009235,
-0.0317090303,
0.0520361774,
0.0821965039,
0.0109597063,
-0.0158015694,
-0.0267291665,
0.0300324447,
0.0032254553,
-0.000346415,
0.014353008,
-0.0450782515,
0.0065155104,
0.0361690931,
-0.0321410112,
0.025075173,
0.0097025093,
0.0622713827,
-0.0191231519,
-0.0056339055,
0.1216410398,
0.0500144921,
0.0039817435,
0.0060101841,
0.0115031032,
0.0175807141,
0.004287038,
-0.0023275591,
-0.066110447,
-0.0479806289,
0.0272804257,
-0.0458214656,
0.0090131322,
0.0214850157,
0.0086338585,
-0.112752445,
0.0200687833,
0.0162790529,
0.003118905,
-0.0596826673,
0.011267704,
-0.0230719615,
0.0074683931,
0.0345292389,
-0.0504235141,
-0.0129411845,
-0.0162301902,
-0.0022710527,
-0.0708080456,
-0.0730928034,
-0.0143023394,
-0.0584283471,
0.0301310606,
0.0085169896,
0.0464503877,
0.0066348528,
-0.0046479199,
0.0370743722,
-0.0148033593,
-0.016543135,
-0.0030761808,
0.0227974392,
-0.0179676451,
-0.0381891653,
-0.0216069147,
-0.0165102724,
-0.0121560823,
-0.0037709614,
0.0392141454,
0.0913911387,
0.0656471178,
-0.0018872452,
-0.0507146604,
0.0060106297,
0.0038640534,
0.0667317733,
0.0668554604,
-0.036971435,
-0.0029884533,
-0.0285482705,
0.0336283334,
-0.0385980271,
0.0058628009,
0.0251433458,
0.0124960579,
0.0327841975,
-0.0759292543,
-0.0928711966,
-0.0088487444,
-0.0052702911,
0.0297844931,
-0.0194867942,
-0.0666966513,
-0.0327811614,
-0.0281562898,
0.0136227896,
-0.0219112281,
0.0515774749,
-0.0187924914,
0.0248325579,
-0.0049815062,
0.0346101858,
0.0049874778,
-0.0333924256,
-0.0489475764,
-0.0414661616,
-0.0665791929,
0.0611397475,
-0.0077909827,
-0.0043109595,
-0.020700898,
-0.0113089615,
0.0385473147,
-0.0081691258,
-0.0514912046,
0.0009000734,
0.0876157507,
-0.0466552377,
0.0286261179,
0.0356057771,
-0.0022916375,
-0.0114021329,
-0.0029492301,
0.0631172359,
-0.00042595,
-0.0129863527,
0.0096140951,
-0.048324734,
0.0303812418,
-0.0213711616,
0.0000170229,
-0.0536428057,
0.021659255,
-0.049024947,
-0.0348147117,
-0.044245977,
0.0074355337,
0.047468815,
0.0405410714,
-0.0509403944,
0.0088541908,
-0.029571753,
0.0168979261,
-0.0045654736,
0.020679703,
0.0546476543,
-0.0146380002,
-0.013827607,
0.0216587782,
-0.0363659412,
-0.0307294112,
-0.0359769017,
-0.0414731093,
0.0075557446,
0.0357904769,
-0.0274672341,
-0.0249106027,
-0.0027628217,
0.0507022999,
-0.011011322,
0.0471681021,
-0.0009398656,
-0.0118608288,
0.0649409294,
-0.0417133272,
0.0409741364,
-0.0268948209,
-0.0309961829,
0.0089465901,
0.0485707372,
-0.027216278,
-0.0315432586,
0.0087088505,
-0.0006457318,
-0.0501417555,
-0.0281751379,
0.0847428367,
0.0213527288,
0.0182025339,
0.0073170052,
0.0123495571,
-0.0452160686,
0.03135591,
0.0412251353,
0.0525398925,
-0.0038696756,
-0.0332275033,
-0.0229524989,
-0.0608494207,
-0.0008140301,
0.014836139,
-0.0313035212,
0.0530384965,
-0.0184509177,
0.0082450984,
-0.0006959716,
0.00005463,
-0.013925517,
-0.0051292493,
0.003322917,
-0.0066925809,
-0.0280137192,
-5.39736276e-33,
-0.0196050722,
0.0405073687,
-0.0355109014,
-0.0199177694,
-0.0303225219,
-0.0013288842,
-0.0665934235,
0.0070294365,
-0.0160688516,
0.0336020067,
-0.0244185701,
0.0063329143,
0.013869442,
0.0342402719,
-0.0009030472,
-0.0086541353,
0.0345239192,
0.0203987844,
-0.005358228,
-0.0300612282,
-0.0237596016,
0.027709147,
0.0505157746,
-0.0164623559,
-0.0007514908,
-0.0097694118,
-0.0035139902,
0.0204821639,
0.0220595319,
0.08275529,
-0.0431377739,
0.0791118369,
-0.0121903708,
-0.0192223862,
-0.0529045425,
0.0326487049,
-0.0772693753,
-0.0245930832,
-0.0078376131,
0.0381446742,
-0.0231915396,
-0.0399620011,
-0.0359061733,
-0.0312175974,
0.0360321477,
-0.0269377679,
0.0366221778,
-0.027484512,
-0.0170036964,
-0.0243094079,
-0.0654387698,
-0.0033744411,
-0.0137940431,
0.0051763053,
0.0442344397,
0.0176870245,
0.0207859818,
-0.0024230909,
0.0132943997,
0.016078053,
-0.0117690172,
0.0136696966,
0.0034980716,
-0.0202864185,
-0.0042177606,
0.0195982251,
0.0083285235,
-0.0559379607,
0.026174495,
0.0062512723,
0.0405229293,
0.0101699317,
0.0634386986,
0.0912701413,
0.0142120635,
-0.0059160925,
-0.0575248972,
0.0175514929,
0.0089192195,
-0.0240621679,
0.0451390296,
-0.0003668619,
-0.0345887579,
-0.0484415591,
0.0174036082,
-0.0074760518,
0.0098280683,
-0.0489100218,
0.0603908375,
0.0178145319,
-0.0186372194,
0.0528443158,
0.0423909388,
-0.0805644691,
-0.0271290224,
0.0638612583,
0.0245280638,
-0.0032935725,
0.0105110053,
0.0198551137,
-0.0475644432,
-0.0215624589,
-0.0198174324,
-0.0056914198,
-0.0147576928,
-0.0359037966,
0.0683017001,
0.0112494361,
-0.0574521869,
0.0141380774,
-0.0069677737,
-0.0573938973,
0.0104716653,
0.0206368901,
0.0148427896,
0.0250875503,
-0.0173682719,
0.0291139428,
0.0337865911,
0.0006319184,
-0.0470651798,
-0.0213176869,
-0.0081142597,
0.0414637327,
0.0100149866,
0.0156895425,
-0.0278657582,
0.0203755125,
0.0400311314,
-0.052297432,
-0.0119520454,
-0.0263938289,
2.154e-7,
0.0296401829,
0.0011306802,
0.0168274976,
0.0010140589,
0.0028078826,
0.0228092726,
0.0061581805,
0.0262246896,
-0.0074702734,
0.0437507853,
0.0697176158,
0.0229390077,
0.083858408,
-0.0465145484,
-0.1342677474,
0.019723665,
-0.0472975075,
-0.015537139,
-0.0604772605,
-0.0162089318,
0.0425193906,
0.1101680472,
0.0077807121,
0.0296117701,
-0.0140942698,
-0.0250859093,
0.0523249619,
-0.0289500654,
-0.0331464708,
0.010539542,
-0.0148271872,
0.0380722545,
0.0129442578,
-0.0557793602,
-0.0269521214,
0.0608728901,
0.0586698316,
0.0304976385,
0.0182275288,
-0.0024015757,
0.0035713632,
0.0318977758,
-0.0399112478,
-0.0378195532,
0.0799973011,
-0.0804502442,
0.0047740601,
0.0113141676,
-0.028723998,
0.0007387057,
0.0317448042,
0.0101398574,
-0.0383343101,
0.0396385938,
0.0621243976,
-0.0370872989,
-0.0162496418,
-0.0311290286,
-0.04751027,
0.002590233,
-0.0001726901,
-0.0083579849,
-0.0605448298,
0.0063863532,
0.0367195196,
-0.0438963436,
-0.0064381473,
2.025150622e-34,
0.0196345579,
-0.0037224928,
0.0409558229,
0.0253181178,
0.0040899287,
-0.065111883,
0.0219452735,
-0.0108159166,
0.0264442265,
-0.0190443769,
-0.0059493659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19347v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19347v3 | Improving Factual Consistency of Text Summarization by Adversarially Decoupling Comprehension and Embellishment Abilities of LLMs | 2023-10-30T08:40:16 | 2023-11-14T06:55:56 | Huawen Feng, Yan Fan, Xiong Liu, Ting-En Lin, Zekun Yao, Yuchuan Wu, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li, Qianli Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the recent progress in text summarization made by large language
models (LLMs), they often generate summaries that are factually inconsistent
with original articles, known as "hallucinations" in text generation. Unlike
previous small models (e.g., BART, T5), current LLMs make fewer silly mistakes
but more sophisticated ones, such as imposing cause and effect, adding false
details, overgeneralizing, etc. These hallucinations are challenging to detect
through traditional methods, which poses great challenges for improving the
factual consistency of text summarization. In this paper, we propose an
adversarially DEcoupling method to disentangle the Comprehension and
EmbellishmeNT abilities of LLMs (DECENT). Furthermore, we adopt a probing-based
efficient training to cover the shortage of sensitivity for true and false in
the training process of LLMs. In this way, LLMs are less confused about
embellishing and understanding; thus, they can execute the instructions more
accurately and have enhanced abilities to distinguish hallucinations.
Experimental results show that DECENT significantly improves the reliability of
text summarization based on LLMs. | [
0.0491864942,
0.0398709774,
0.0013947855,
0.0213452503,
-0.0272567589,
0.016560914,
-0.0245295651,
-0.0276164431,
-0.0016415314,
-0.0398853272,
0.0103463,
-0.0450800285,
0.0447168127,
-0.0175719261,
0.0399455577,
-0.0371229649,
0.0592973307,
-0.0040408676,
-0.0344306454,
-0.0068084402,
0.0232339092,
0.0293079354,
0.0166757982,
0.015566634,
0.028734982,
-0.004092956,
-0.0156368557,
0.0067412294,
0.0350422598,
0.0147011979,
-0.0054960912,
0.0225265678,
0.0016662747,
0.0820050761,
0.0000020592,
-0.0260859467,
-0.0393179506,
-0.0062854146,
0.0132830311,
0.0494046137,
0.0382054746,
-0.0554070547,
0.0113345599,
0.0231413376,
-0.016746996,
0.0207996089,
0.005938876,
0.0895373672,
0.087647751,
0.0823334157,
0.0116277365,
-0.0553713366,
0.0375074893,
-0.0256438386,
0.0019884685,
-0.0023744144,
0.017945379,
0.0258989725,
-0.0108239399,
-0.0040174848,
0.0007270568,
0.0211897157,
0.0171259176,
0.0044111125,
-0.0181901958,
0.039564956,
-0.0196347442,
-0.0116959522,
0.0197155885,
0.0647119135,
-0.0231647063,
-0.0430370606,
0.0365957543,
0.0051382245,
-0.0066100927,
0.0296965726,
-0.0544580892,
0.0429762341,
-0.0305056386,
0.0456354022,
0.0142363589,
-0.0042613409,
0.0223022196,
0.0543592609,
-0.0304030105,
0.0363355316,
0.0101928934,
-0.0193572417,
-0.0423940793,
0.0082194842,
-0.0181894861,
-0.0595367588,
0.0339899398,
0.0337598063,
-0.0385710113,
-0.0138223162,
-0.0871695057,
-0.0402324609,
0.0268968586,
-0.0492188483,
-0.0131364064,
0.0103996042,
-0.0221558958,
0.0263931267,
-0.0507155098,
0.0288946293,
-0.0014785012,
0.0544250682,
-0.0348212197,
0.0041948557,
-0.007933924,
-0.0201468095,
-0.0234086011,
0.039645534,
-0.0404254384,
-0.0134675708,
-0.0448658988,
-0.0086557297,
0.0090390202,
0.0293796882,
-0.0487815961,
0.0236752164,
-0.0095982356,
-0.0247877575,
-0.0200231317,
-0.0052310117,
-0.0277610887,
-0.0022177675,
0.0332453512,
-0.0149973081,
-0.0415271744,
0.0363395102,
-0.0165664759,
0.0101856897,
-0.0029833482,
0.0163463987,
-0.0471587926,
0.0175745357,
-0.0521646515,
-0.051295463,
-0.0116457837,
-0.0689898282,
0.0113923512,
-0.058820568,
-0.0129879825,
-0.0210455991,
-0.0287086163,
-0.0349474661,
0.0208284538,
0.0335735604,
-0.0576131754,
0.048372332,
-0.0455112644,
-0.0233119018,
0.0475275964,
0.0296954364,
0.0102008637,
0.0522942506,
0.0358166285,
0.074799791,
0.0241575539,
0.0368580073,
0.0068655456,
-0.0127444137,
0.0375377648,
0.0036919585,
-0.0234786849,
-0.0349805541,
-0.038452886,
0.0003021934,
0.0455363877,
0.0792101771,
-0.0290441625,
0.0092385057,
0.0893262997,
-0.0296145473,
-0.0107842376,
0.0272462331,
0.0393252261,
0.0278211683,
0.0264686849,
0.1197411418,
-0.0356242359,
0.0348125286,
-0.0727861673,
0.0556420237,
0.1004211158,
0.034577176,
-0.0143981418,
-0.0537557639,
0.0090034129,
-0.0109006325,
0.0201219656,
-0.0410715081,
0.0037013423,
0.0243068486,
-0.0593845993,
0.0257265028,
-0.002204916,
-0.0288023166,
0.0266751722,
-0.0439981632,
0.0135273682,
0.0458785072,
0.0736119002,
-0.0205464102,
0.0034221355,
-0.015807569,
-0.0078721642,
0.0693127885,
0.0279343966,
0.0050388952,
-0.0226126406,
-0.0481743626,
0.0074306913,
-0.0436072424,
0.0382689312,
-0.0089908317,
-0.0363169685,
-0.0183401741,
0.0488240905,
-0.0273702499,
-0.0357337892,
0.0576784573,
-0.0148757882,
-0.023580255,
-0.0095400447,
-0.0178733729,
-0.0069439048,
0.0052677221,
-0.0076876571,
0.0440647937,
-0.0000205319,
-0.0352320187,
-0.0474568419,
-0.0022740141,
-0.0433204025,
-0.0662992597,
0.032296557,
-0.0310463849,
-0.0116016585,
0.0136327576,
-0.0384062082,
-0.0551922396,
0.022318013,
-0.0448509715,
-0.0028803179,
-0.0648393631,
0.036817912,
0.0230748635,
0.0318745188,
-0.0224874821,
0.0977658331,
-0.0254565664,
0.0025474087,
0.0641032681,
-0.0016694979,
-0.0082351454,
0.0054226597,
0.001266994,
0.002649466,
0.0177004002,
0.0251998343,
0.0335358344,
-0.0164335296,
-0.0200515855,
-0.0564584583,
-0.0497340448,
0.0264682863,
-0.0451394916,
0.0030462921,
0.0664080679,
-0.0245434307,
0.0095975678,
-0.00213463,
-0.0231819842,
-0.0222707167,
0.0208194256,
-0.0050108591,
0.047436364,
0.0027347608,
0.0264685042,
-0.0380192399,
0.0181822758,
0.0032748468,
0.0384550616,
-0.0039125201,
-0.0428778082,
-0.0821687654,
0.0339745358,
-0.0406632498,
-0.026001852,
-0.0079691848,
-0.0360831209,
0.0003960629,
0.0139477206,
0.0382135361,
0.0673859417,
0.0543406866,
0.0262142066,
0.064821206,
0.0152637325,
-0.0016915099,
-0.016525615,
-0.0146510117,
0.0423993282,
0.0101001691,
-0.0565702766,
0.023048006,
0.0402069278,
0.0530986264,
0.0151607804,
-0.01707533,
0.0355482362,
-0.0061165304,
-0.0504054539,
-0.0025477109,
-0.0079254638,
-0.0190304667,
0.0118074175,
-0.0479202494,
-0.0200311039,
0.0641169772,
-0.0557449013,
0.0268338192,
-0.0440811813,
-0.0116790039,
-0.022692753,
-0.0041184621,
0.0212252121,
0.0358829424,
-0.0038015512,
0.0032136948,
-0.0670203641,
-0.0247974396,
0.0250563826,
-0.0296934657,
0.0502130948,
-0.0379329063,
0.0039586523,
-0.0138562843,
0.013554303,
-0.0509412065,
-0.0646791384,
0.0178785026,
0.0268138852,
-0.0014360936,
0.0025823913,
-0.0546851717,
-0.0059440387,
0.0442136005,
0.0513545126,
-0.0513170771,
-0.014415808,
-0.0242892336,
0.0584832914,
0.0860423371,
0.0112377629,
0.0511404015,
-0.0695466623,
0.0315461084,
0.0648909286,
-0.0327975079,
0.0193948317,
0.0171259101,
-0.03556934,
-0.0181056838,
-0.0499139875,
-0.0136969341,
0.0036159002,
0.0489747822,
-0.0398645326,
-0.0127752209,
0.1066104248,
0.0225854497,
0.0159073733,
0.0154750776,
0.0330432393,
0.0400881656,
-0.0193774663,
-0.0159747116,
-0.0555077009,
-0.0177334007,
-0.0038437187,
0.0307246298,
0.0030359242,
-0.0098512825,
-0.0398880653,
-0.0882573351,
-0.001228987,
0.048023358,
-0.049550008,
-0.0514925532,
0.0073717553,
0.0042517297,
0.0260264073,
0.0658397526,
0.0210331976,
-0.0002959549,
0.0108763818,
0.0130452579,
-0.041000288,
-0.0322171152,
-0.0665831938,
-0.027142413,
0.019088706,
0.0666075796,
0.0513502546,
-0.0136072254,
0.0163568854,
0.0095807463,
-0.010214109,
0.0029913194,
-0.0115693416,
0.0820055455,
-0.0017917725,
0.0166322552,
-0.0126188844,
0.0460575633,
0.0276351999,
-0.0312185902,
-0.0045296466,
0.0070928736,
-0.0119338408,
-0.0558741093,
-0.0328082778,
0.0674322844,
-0.0161535926,
0.080105111,
0.0386731699,
0.0004637557,
-0.0447736979,
-0.037386585,
0.0119978487,
-0.0723708048,
-0.0104896566,
0.0492419414,
0.0079599703,
-0.0043011135,
-0.1028903201,
-0.0584630668,
-0.0095020812,
-0.0059430609,
-0.0198774021,
0.0529385321,
-0.0043943776,
-0.0479470789,
-0.0016087171,
-0.044937294,
-0.0131247481,
0.0004921186,
-0.0017228618,
-0.0146595808,
0.0340260863,
-0.0416591391,
0.0088944687,
0.0106076151,
-0.0831995159,
-0.0841826424,
-0.0085118562,
0.0254129153,
0.0217478424,
0.0734559074,
0.0035026099,
-0.034384314,
0.0653603971,
0.0740610063,
-0.0023438975,
0.0673988685,
0.0265527535,
0.0152441943,
-0.0076955436,
0.0174814779,
-0.0262971818,
0.0154608376,
-0.0000453311,
0.0287875813,
-0.0428215601,
-0.0055878474,
0.0396962985,
0.041726727,
-0.0139671024,
-0.0474062487,
0.0516811535,
-0.0278823264,
-0.0004836937,
-0.0308063012,
-0.0162904188,
-0.0308870301,
0.0318908393,
-0.0009635406,
0.0002099397,
0.000752628,
0.0123097757,
-0.0100197904,
0.0156783834,
-0.0382516049,
-0.0379108414,
-0.066997312,
0.0133681698,
-0.0214473736,
-0.0126061495,
-0.0478522703,
-0.0053101373,
-0.0264895801,
0.0201464295,
-0.0014598914,
0.0300629698,
0.0391918123,
0.0031146905,
-0.0222834535,
0.0283711888,
-0.0834310874,
0.0115546025,
-0.0686111525,
0.0561996028,
0.0507322662,
0.0083178002,
0.0791589022,
-0.0159913264,
0.0074994983,
-0.0208034813,
0.0395418629,
0.0533907749,
-0.002948307,
-0.0313749649,
-0.0093424832,
-0.0178246964,
0.0033836227,
0.071867086,
-0.0280952044,
0.0219528526,
0.0152088664,
-0.0184330959,
-0.047531724,
-0.0583853424,
-0.0119178751,
-0.0045678974,
-0.0153591437,
-0.0115395933,
-0.0510833338,
-0.0315509513,
0.0164087024,
0.0246664435,
0.0212898031,
-0.0460245162,
0.0149314115,
0.0244896375,
-0.0057787281,
0.0156257171,
-0.048879195,
0.0165934283,
0.026566308,
0.005984812,
-0.0003383868,
-6.327389278e-33,
-0.0546210371,
-0.0451334119,
-0.011342491,
-0.0591286309,
-0.0226685256,
-0.0073254616,
-0.0565433912,
-0.0267913342,
0.0152166076,
0.0129290475,
0.0066303872,
0.0197494067,
0.0012119265,
0.0290502235,
-0.0300754737,
0.0009878302,
0.0962022841,
0.0127370171,
-0.0543036908,
0.0270512067,
0.0488401875,
0.018650068,
0.0312198382,
-0.0407651663,
0.0437609218,
-0.0364450589,
-0.0718949363,
-0.0065995036,
-0.024955729,
-0.00065003,
-0.0121793589,
0.0144874891,
0.0094418135,
0.0034516077,
-0.0649556294,
-0.0148358699,
-0.0487169102,
-0.0386784263,
0.0484576039,
-0.0247072391,
-0.0608093329,
-0.0348008387,
0.0630920082,
-0.0347644761,
0.0322523266,
-0.014616739,
0.0284660272,
-0.0488909744,
-0.0507554002,
-0.0200035926,
-0.0481841341,
0.0196557753,
0.0067514647,
-0.0113846436,
-0.0211505573,
0.0120435329,
-0.0064729177,
0.000135626,
-0.0691308901,
0.0025048757,
0.0498688668,
0.0335054696,
0.0367725529,
0.0117556211,
-0.0086702975,
0.0864916146,
-0.0121125346,
0.0024807327,
-0.062805742,
0.0115069989,
0.0022870975,
0.0285091251,
0.0471077487,
0.0483744889,
0.0633910671,
0.0015498517,
-0.071973078,
0.0682523921,
-0.0012663404,
-0.0044748187,
0.0410202593,
-0.0141213788,
-0.0048270933,
-0.0169407278,
-0.0288732387,
0.0080803288,
0.0014362335,
-0.0217899047,
-0.0044993353,
0.0307001211,
-0.0610492267,
-0.0599388517,
-0.0090217972,
-0.048023846,
0.0383236594,
0.016941458,
-0.0639400259,
-0.0254862178,
0.0127870822,
-0.0003616262,
-0.0356469117,
0.005455438,
0.027049182,
0.0080393916,
0.0048127975,
0.0184246711,
0.0552735515,
-0.0210687593,
-0.0336557217,
0.0410610326,
-0.0051731416,
0.0342016667,
-0.0166297536,
-0.0226379074,
0.015906414,
-0.0182519816,
-0.0221282113,
-0.00887179,
-0.0093112681,
0.0127199991,
-0.0153335659,
0.0260807816,
0.0024904546,
0.0439371839,
-0.0374477915,
0.0222392213,
-0.0150419138,
-0.0127769886,
0.0473564267,
-0.0748032555,
-0.0119997011,
0.0052017681,
2.728e-7,
0.0119071482,
0.0484265126,
0.0516336374,
0.0237110928,
-0.0041895206,
0.0383167751,
-0.0176855121,
0.0323761925,
0.0031134435,
-0.0347362198,
0.0226142351,
0.0283633582,
0.0729012266,
0.0454458259,
-0.0686348304,
0.0144269802,
-0.0944058225,
-0.0128965424,
-0.0224500801,
-0.0380726606,
0.0584723204,
0.0492359214,
-0.0152520314,
-0.0076685045,
0.0053637773,
-0.0511622466,
0.0712436512,
0.0380733199,
-0.0405499823,
0.026499847,
0.065135397,
0.0104410416,
-0.007152583,
-0.0185894556,
-0.0269108079,
-0.0224608984,
0.0283891577,
0.0230330508,
0.024577653,
-0.0201476719,
-0.019650748,
-0.0322201736,
0.0373891741,
-0.0128392791,
0.0693663731,
-0.0399053283,
-0.0108295083,
-0.0237661246,
-0.0307429973,
0.0100513855,
0.0127091678,
-0.0111570833,
-0.0468999669,
0.0460400693,
-0.006544197,
0.0289332736,
0.0012550376,
-0.0519647598,
-0.0434935428,
0.0029810292,
-0.0201145727,
-0.0379824117,
-0.00738193,
0.0231679957,
0.0093272738,
-0.077624172,
-0.0059836344,
2.673129714e-34,
0.0767716244,
-0.0247840341,
-0.0085352417,
-0.0210940838,
0.0133158984,
-0.0109240739,
0.0005579202,
0.0077682212,
0.0129820295,
-0.0485127494,
-0.0255531706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19345v1 | Test Suites Task: Evaluation of Gender Fairness in MT with MuST-SHE and INES | 2023-10-30T08:36:30 | 2023-10-30T08:36:30 | Beatrice Savoldi, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | As part of the WMT-2023 "Test suites" shared task, in this paper we summarize
the results of two test suites evaluations: MuST-SHE-WMT23 and INES. By
focusing on the en-de and de-en language pairs, we rely on these newly created
test suites to investigate systems' ability to translate feminine and masculine
gender and produce gender-inclusive translations. Furthermore we discuss
metrics associated with our test suites and validate them by means of human
evaluations. Our results indicate that systems achieve reasonable and
comparable performance in correctly translating both feminine and masculine
gender forms for naturalistic gender phenomena. Instead, the generation of
inclusive language forms in translation emerges as a challenging task for all
the evaluated MT models, indicating room for future improvements and research
on the topic. | [
0.0318444185,
0.0509678014,
-0.0379373282,
0.0200293101,
-0.0100599723,
0.0001480531,
0.0439169221,
-0.0043786615,
-0.0538003743,
-0.034372136,
-0.0140639944,
-0.0973110646,
0.0384237356,
0.0122974301,
0.0469057336,
-0.0482313484,
0.0233724043,
0.0136077739,
-0.0630015358,
-0.0173260104,
0.0166107193,
0.0377628654,
0.0182758309,
0.0568807088,
0.0291671213,
-0.010057874,
0.0012652125,
0.0436966494,
0.0136317695,
0.0229669269,
0.0238659997,
0.0541873202,
-0.0093216263,
0.0412280113,
0.0000018928,
-0.0850735754,
-0.0098057007,
0.0095234159,
0.0124961175,
-0.0259851813,
0.0114332745,
-0.0393257365,
-0.0288660936,
0.0207128599,
-0.0097552799,
0.000440561,
0.0560470521,
0.0046587335,
0.0535302684,
0.0188187808,
-0.0080869719,
0.0519479923,
-0.0628673509,
-0.0436757319,
0.0093230112,
0.0032533484,
-0.0026461682,
-0.0506046042,
-0.0061011398,
-0.0160250273,
-0.0041216523,
0.0171905942,
0.0076098982,
-0.0137793515,
-0.0180456601,
0.0035033901,
-0.0101923477,
-0.0641624853,
-0.0211128332,
0.0442947745,
0.0489149168,
0.0023636804,
0.0039416733,
0.0306411795,
-0.0131370332,
-0.0141526945,
-0.0280201621,
0.0186394267,
0.0153130619,
-0.03526178,
-0.0209424831,
0.004678037,
0.0111800525,
0.0369330868,
-0.0460767932,
0.0940196291,
0.035680823,
-0.067238465,
-0.0010313347,
0.0137774581,
-0.0021019364,
-0.0447512083,
0.0419396199,
-0.0110866083,
-0.0120004527,
-0.0099845743,
-0.0194475856,
-0.0680962354,
0.0274288747,
-0.052833233,
0.0158999078,
0.0802287012,
0.0176482666,
-0.0100136306,
-0.0083339186,
0.0696912482,
0.0111573767,
-0.0202028826,
-0.0599854626,
-0.0420513712,
-0.0210437793,
0.001532466,
-0.0194449406,
-0.0266366042,
-0.077335149,
0.0400345698,
-0.0249227826,
0.0154919093,
-0.0174645148,
-0.0127183218,
0.038198147,
-0.0001541311,
-0.0478819534,
0.0094578508,
0.0085829943,
0.0137085896,
-0.0547011346,
0.0051637632,
-0.0045090839,
-0.0617349073,
-0.0084185936,
-0.0011666118,
-0.0160075538,
-0.0326574892,
-0.0216429401,
0.0261280853,
-0.0004511925,
-0.0373212546,
0.0403657742,
-0.006105436,
-0.0508930013,
-0.063931115,
0.0122679183,
-0.0566600561,
0.0193573106,
0.0395049527,
0.0291758291,
-0.013413392,
0.0094226692,
0.0004678219,
0.0232374575,
0.0336605087,
0.0815249756,
0.0251707118,
0.0454616025,
0.0117414538,
-0.0151388757,
0.0940025076,
0.0507112406,
0.006606705,
0.0346666314,
0.0153854694,
-0.0089002503,
0.0747266859,
0.0275705177,
0.0471127965,
-0.0460586436,
0.0209744349,
0.0089706657,
0.0931127369,
0.0606006198,
0.034088362,
0.0239285789,
0.0013274811,
0.0477671586,
0.045857925,
0.0533006415,
0.0280257631,
0.0742934942,
-0.0106320595,
-0.0152557483,
0.000279034,
-0.0498813055,
-0.005987457,
-0.0286783241,
-0.0232487656,
-0.0213674065,
0.0357519761,
-0.0059859729,
-0.0379824415,
-0.0121767884,
0.0064438954,
0.0382984094,
-0.0093753058,
0.0358844176,
0.0282282606,
-0.0090475352,
0.066509448,
0.0073269657,
-0.0750512481,
0.0071987007,
-0.0534889586,
-0.0184247456,
0.0635218546,
0.0151355667,
-0.0128579214,
-0.0165178627,
-0.0216348749,
-0.0323260166,
0.0616258532,
0.0732368156,
0.03637252,
0.0207390953,
-0.0600763708,
-0.0023578273,
0.0522603057,
0.0388759375,
0.0286583994,
-0.0028403429,
0.0748884976,
0.0264555383,
-0.0498325564,
-0.0446443595,
0.0249738861,
-0.0110015711,
-0.0045865923,
0.0352291837,
0.0099679688,
-0.0018437136,
0.0250179525,
-0.034977898,
0.0095843365,
-0.0028522396,
-0.0332548581,
-0.0407954752,
0.0896596089,
-0.0429049581,
-0.0145034101,
0.0272051543,
-0.0660193339,
-0.0675187036,
0.0647678226,
0.0109754,
-0.0359752811,
0.0316845961,
-0.0467432998,
-0.0510450117,
-0.047661908,
0.028478682,
0.0062566106,
0.0105767092,
-0.0207048468,
-0.0208032615,
-0.0409507379,
-0.01163089,
-0.0034579597,
-0.0574371293,
-0.0086594885,
-0.0645816624,
-0.0617879368,
0.0677072704,
-0.000408263,
0.027780598,
0.0276613683,
0.0353622325,
-0.014723896,
-0.05028034,
-0.0773031041,
0.0144755468,
-0.0246018637,
0.0342043564,
0.005667387,
0.0660710931,
-0.0350575,
0.0163493566,
0.0011947597,
-0.028619457,
0.0391373076,
0.0061602625,
0.0438051485,
-0.0062159696,
0.0038989985,
-0.0210213549,
-0.0226719789,
-0.0488949306,
0.0292681716,
-0.0065199616,
0.0038801683,
-0.0376249254,
-0.009144716,
-0.016023295,
-0.0364279859,
0.0142124929,
-0.0567781851,
0.0115467915,
0.0225765929,
0.0680179298,
0.058376845,
0.0205744542,
0.0163551942,
0.0261301249,
0.014237158,
-0.0560894571,
0.0022928778,
0.052325543,
0.0157477669,
0.0208111219,
-0.0866567269,
0.0090111122,
0.030836517,
-0.0070380531,
-0.0273872241,
-0.0626427978,
0.0363766067,
-0.0578251667,
-0.0716330558,
-0.010199585,
0.0117271943,
-0.0081055593,
0.0348639786,
-0.0360131115,
-0.0160375871,
0.0532537699,
-0.0364992805,
-0.0550119989,
-0.05686206,
0.0098889414,
-0.0528365523,
0.0367882289,
-0.0615144558,
0.0154512888,
0.0148091475,
-0.0323685408,
-0.0555823818,
-0.0174722206,
0.0166379511,
-0.0319132619,
0.0605881661,
-0.0491168797,
-0.0003364537,
-0.0241896249,
-0.0163494945,
-0.0320679806,
0.0108441347,
0.0032047573,
0.0297842044,
-0.0155710075,
-0.0202405993,
-0.0137407342,
0.0499024577,
-0.0170169007,
0.0399056748,
-0.0440143533,
-0.0022411959,
-0.0245778542,
-0.0258526001,
0.0083320551,
0.0320524797,
0.0083755236,
-0.0261824336,
-0.0064456989,
0.0180385355,
0.0037420085,
0.023918869,
0.0103515554,
0.0090208445,
0.0481396951,
-0.0352582596,
0.0061018202,
-0.0390122198,
0.0484530814,
-0.0643710643,
0.0109261218,
0.1009632796,
0.0269359313,
-0.0213757623,
0.0173590351,
-0.0182432719,
0.0389125533,
0.0277216192,
0.0263168402,
-0.0898259729,
0.0213274714,
0.0523332097,
0.0145700388,
-0.0113515398,
-0.0435512513,
-0.0119200908,
-0.100733079,
-0.0042231791,
0.0448925309,
-0.0388761535,
-0.0413969159,
0.0177659038,
-0.0104340827,
-0.0115429685,
0.0581739768,
0.0022978149,
0.009003954,
0.000615496,
-0.0104689617,
0.017428115,
-0.0517452918,
0.0348921753,
-0.1046389714,
0.0358352959,
0.0428203456,
0.0641245842,
-0.0295216702,
-0.038671501,
0.0151950419,
-0.006099469,
0.0098690698,
-0.0198945776,
-0.0504653864,
-0.0002115472,
-0.0262765083,
-0.0470342599,
0.016822122,
0.03384763,
0.0272034649,
0.0197625626,
0.027800519,
-0.0148922894,
-0.0220764764,
-0.0424540006,
-0.0089175226,
0.0188829713,
0.0732120275,
0.0298076086,
-0.0568513535,
-0.0397695489,
-0.0395566262,
-0.0042646029,
-0.0337072201,
-0.0605719015,
-0.022557918,
0.0344501063,
-0.0433477014,
-0.098450467,
-0.0716262981,
0.0186742526,
0.0377635658,
-0.0091035012,
-0.0916685238,
-0.0246100836,
0.0313045122,
-0.04325388,
0.0403701104,
-0.0000295889,
0.0462690219,
-0.0125717241,
-0.0055849915,
-0.0343485065,
-0.0352651551,
-0.0014912514,
0.0405535176,
0.000153397,
-0.0612453632,
-0.0100807827,
0.05708858,
0.0360773653,
0.0340747982,
-0.0303264186,
-0.0210956335,
-0.0017859958,
0.0228072312,
0.0001354178,
0.0267689191,
0.0715728104,
0.0050753886,
-0.0051867077,
0.052660577,
-0.0086161261,
0.0015388927,
-0.0583136827,
0.051839374,
0.0736510828,
-0.0598130226,
0.0338371471,
0.0140654277,
-0.0309582576,
-0.0774957091,
-0.0086228708,
-0.0340577476,
-0.0038370311,
-0.0359718315,
-0.0321275555,
-0.0255505256,
-0.0017907233,
0.0267482083,
0.0475437604,
-0.0048238891,
-0.022525778,
-0.0382549688,
-0.0109446002,
-0.0146429539,
0.0169458315,
-0.0044356408,
0.0497447588,
-0.0060563697,
0.0334431753,
0.0041636606,
-0.0399995074,
-0.0401492007,
0.0171527788,
-0.0060517136,
0.0045675333,
-0.0089401761,
0.0166007653,
-0.0330866277,
0.0341777094,
0.0061085187,
0.018756466,
-0.0193737447,
0.0013691173,
0.0559710562,
-0.0053888625,
0.0734942928,
-0.0207082722,
-0.0060776477,
-0.0042829113,
-0.0045153634,
0.0035675829,
0.0419879183,
-0.0114248917,
0.0048210267,
0.0272350665,
-0.0409886278,
0.0121765165,
0.0096387165,
0.0495715402,
-0.0037290442,
-0.0164618213,
-0.0244692788,
-0.0074362876,
-0.0250186231,
-0.0714107156,
-0.0329225995,
-0.0327180736,
-0.0752324164,
-0.0496160351,
0.0342591591,
0.0158931371,
0.0156776682,
0.0100639286,
-0.0036663113,
0.0769938156,
-0.02473321,
-0.0380404331,
-0.029731879,
-0.0189944133,
0.0180811901,
-0.0085492227,
-0.0263708644,
-6.234382696e-33,
-0.0353728533,
0.0136634484,
-0.0155077567,
-0.020459909,
-0.0483568124,
-0.0377533287,
-0.0288051907,
-0.0136222076,
0.0371428207,
0.0205682516,
-0.0043931673,
0.0208341889,
0.0271152314,
-0.022982765,
0.0251557194,
0.0361408442,
0.0756221861,
0.0137677435,
-0.0527468175,
-0.0299756229,
-0.0063028098,
0.0232127476,
0.075286366,
-0.0366832688,
0.0924329087,
-0.0241751429,
-0.0284884293,
0.0265666507,
-0.032288637,
0.0076159057,
0.0197813399,
0.0541986562,
0.0224675648,
-0.0161214527,
-0.0024568287,
0.0497924425,
-0.0600009896,
-0.0214783736,
0.015799867,
0.0262853205,
0.0199703332,
-0.035577029,
0.0481789596,
-0.0105477395,
-0.0439337082,
-0.0051212688,
0.0057451306,
-0.0037581318,
0.0699390173,
0.0239569675,
-0.0638876185,
0.0043166173,
-0.0309526529,
-0.0251897275,
-0.0047078421,
0.0431177132,
-0.0144486288,
-0.052119486,
-0.0600323901,
0.0304477196,
-0.0405610055,
-0.0132674845,
0.0557673201,
-0.0244840272,
0.0120448889,
-0.0216020495,
0.0599117056,
0.0308556799,
-0.0072389334,
-0.0358465612,
0.088143453,
-0.0187601298,
0.0633182824,
0.0521010645,
0.0153340707,
0.0116823707,
-0.0193396099,
0.0064257332,
0.0195944328,
0.0229600761,
-0.0066069444,
0.0006478198,
-0.0979530886,
-0.0186868962,
-0.0443431586,
-0.0438274518,
-0.0084135374,
-0.0265710093,
0.024726823,
0.0139718745,
-0.0562000982,
0.0205811709,
0.0431835502,
-0.0580184497,
-0.0288098305,
-0.025750801,
-0.0092330258,
-0.0269308612,
0.032564383,
0.0376369506,
-0.0149784805,
-0.007725508,
0.0208054632,
0.0568779372,
0.016036056,
-0.0040253061,
-0.0224148054,
0.0159981269,
-0.0695695728,
-0.0058933562,
-0.0422133617,
0.0340351872,
-0.0202569943,
0.0194274876,
0.0239462946,
0.0197095945,
-0.0046160039,
0.0047869496,
0.0475344658,
0.0140066082,
-0.0852349401,
0.0373528861,
0.0080876378,
0.0475751646,
-0.008262964,
0.0122907842,
-0.0160145629,
0.0215405338,
0.0783588886,
-0.0309705846,
-0.0069567421,
-0.0492254794,
2.713e-7,
0.0119505432,
0.0420574546,
0.0306498241,
0.0167039409,
0.0274048988,
0.0154127423,
-0.0441827327,
0.0527507253,
0.0518307127,
0.0329356864,
-0.0145552289,
0.0262131952,
0.0395481177,
0.0412047356,
-0.0502912551,
0.0026943467,
-0.0349399447,
0.0102982512,
-0.018254539,
0.0189080946,
0.0013548307,
0.0534534864,
0.029583076,
0.0233281497,
-0.0146163125,
-0.0432117879,
0.0438080616,
-0.0068969848,
0.0196398497,
0.0248983707,
0.0239141621,
-0.0118251089,
0.0297182128,
-0.0060104262,
0.0251880325,
0.0123318089,
0.0451713391,
0.0216585454,
-0.0104205841,
0.0409444533,
-0.0013166626,
-0.0215037782,
-0.0307873655,
-0.056488961,
0.0424229316,
-0.0050619789,
-0.0031097771,
-0.0117152873,
0.007478625,
0.0110935206,
0.0771011114,
-0.0303065088,
-0.0152870296,
0.0635966957,
0.0377987102,
0.0174024068,
0.0084384652,
-0.0385842323,
-0.0512022041,
-0.0252687857,
-0.0360937044,
-0.0557578467,
-0.0230122469,
0.0230108313,
0.0000568442,
-0.0473109111,
-0.0094852606,
2.303126337e-34,
0.0065005478,
0.0288689062,
0.0140409106,
0.0062647504,
0.0153512843,
-0.0247461498,
0.0139538944,
0.0014798823,
0.0224538278,
0.0245072674,
-0.0376577191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19341v1 | Skywork: A More Open Bilingual Foundation Model | 2023-10-30T08:31:47 | 2023-10-30T08:31:47 | Tianwen Wei, Liang Zhao, Lichang Zhang, Bo Zhu, Lijie Wang, Haihua Yang, Biye Li, Cheng Cheng, Weiwei Lü, Rui Hu, Chenxia Li, Liu Yang, Xilin Luo, Xuejie Wu, Lunan Liu, Wenjun Cheng, Peng Cheng, Jianhao Zhang, Xiaoyu Zhang, Lei Lin, Xiaokun Wang, Yutuan Ma, Chuanhai Dong, Yanqi Sun, Yifu Chen, Yongyi Peng, Xiaojuan Liang, Shuicheng Yan, Han Fang, Yahui Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this technical report, we present Skywork-13B, a family of large language
models (LLMs) trained on a corpus of over 3.2 trillion tokens drawn from both
English and Chinese texts. This bilingual foundation model is the most
extensively trained and openly published LLMs of comparable size to date. We
introduce a two-stage training methodology using a segmented corpus, targeting
general purpose training and then domain-specific enhancement training,
respectively. We show that our model not only excels on popular benchmarks, but
also achieves \emph{state of the art} performance in Chinese language modeling
on diverse domains. Furthermore, we propose a novel leakage detection method,
demonstrating that test data contamination is a pressing issue warranting
further investigation by the LLM community. To spur future research, we release
Skywork-13B along with checkpoints obtained during intermediate stages of the
training process. We are also releasing part of our SkyPile corpus, a
collection of over 150 billion tokens of web text, which is the largest high
quality open Chinese pre-training corpus to date. We hope Skywork-13B and our
open corpus will serve as a valuable open-source resource to democratize access
to high-quality LLMs. | [
0.0222239047,
0.097677432,
-0.0100921271,
0.0482434332,
-0.0143611468,
-0.0006617138,
0.0153173236,
0.0093139466,
0.0071029118,
-0.0184558909,
-0.0701784417,
-0.0498561338,
-0.0017085788,
0.0164761823,
0.0229266584,
-0.0287103374,
0.0477959812,
-0.0191350859,
-0.0355858095,
-0.0099549787,
0.0252258927,
0.00886478,
0.0530924201,
0.0339747369,
0.0054516406,
-0.0381178446,
0.0007005616,
0.0010007373,
0.0141267758,
-0.006396418,
0.0401844233,
0.0778509378,
0.0111799967,
0.0675096288,
0.0000023361,
-0.0369877927,
-0.0438706018,
0.018487148,
-0.0189079233,
0.0712433234,
0.0152668944,
-0.0286235046,
-0.0393301062,
0.0413554236,
-0.0300751347,
-0.0271167308,
0.0234517474,
0.0744606033,
0.0655081645,
0.0643889457,
0.0021896993,
0.0068821991,
0.0336106271,
-0.0435192063,
-0.0182580873,
-0.0255315788,
0.0312678181,
0.0052108606,
-0.0297320187,
0.0145976767,
-0.0170829389,
0.0110692466,
0.0309041943,
0.0013550569,
-0.0543882549,
0.0309367981,
-0.0697631165,
-0.017929934,
0.0072984332,
0.0645224974,
-0.0296278503,
-0.0487790257,
0.0081087658,
0.0204578973,
-0.0271502137,
0.0026667267,
-0.0200864971,
0.0337598585,
0.0053483765,
0.017596202,
0.0398765244,
-0.0556897148,
0.0540579222,
0.0386078432,
-0.0306933317,
0.0413687602,
0.0197862554,
-0.0317238867,
0.0057997773,
0.0174688939,
0.0119550461,
-0.056010209,
0.0210597645,
-0.0401094295,
0.0037800709,
0.0174456555,
-0.0580345728,
-0.036594294,
0.0304799266,
-0.0577487685,
-0.0058612069,
0.0041223541,
-0.0655503869,
0.0396205895,
-0.0293425024,
0.0108536407,
-0.0224939808,
0.0245583951,
-0.0443096794,
-0.01920381,
-0.0058488641,
0.0065725436,
-0.0307060573,
0.0339133479,
-0.0267598089,
-0.0129146976,
-0.0169857685,
0.0172036681,
-0.0117001114,
0.0031847989,
0.0257761348,
-0.0202187132,
-0.0258221906,
-0.0091128657,
0.0133597637,
0.0016374919,
-0.0104233576,
0.0205890723,
-0.0130095612,
-0.0808802843,
-0.0189545285,
0.0358412117,
-0.0256410278,
-0.0269007497,
0.0073309205,
0.0550715588,
0.0044133244,
-0.0333112702,
-0.0530085638,
-0.0297373645,
-0.0153969219,
-0.0477519967,
-0.0140423393,
-0.0723224729,
-0.0017508084,
-0.0093011316,
0.0276041385,
-0.0200867094,
0.0263255648,
0.022407772,
-0.0168349184,
0.0349133722,
-0.0289633851,
-0.0172538962,
-0.0096898265,
-0.0010032505,
0.0127027519,
0.0847828612,
0.0224752799,
0.0201304778,
0.0750262588,
0.0005367141,
-0.0070816204,
0.0665652156,
0.011890606,
0.0502729826,
-0.0100110713,
0.0160787962,
0.0334903114,
-0.0023227993,
0.0325348452,
0.0521987006,
-0.0260287393,
-0.012650446,
0.0661984012,
0.016850898,
-0.0028625373,
0.03371571,
0.0180868637,
0.0216295272,
0.021695992,
-0.0092366049,
-0.0630832538,
-0.0359867252,
-0.0290455315,
0.0050699697,
-0.0062851575,
0.0256589297,
-0.0401491225,
-0.0423011556,
-0.0232198592,
-0.0217299517,
0.0160632059,
0.0100775408,
0.0503157042,
-0.0053247539,
-0.0081891399,
0.0895445496,
0.0253688861,
-0.0567981265,
0.0438324288,
-0.0182994977,
0.0195875168,
0.0692847967,
0.0408623591,
-0.0247327182,
-0.0184982866,
-0.0305040535,
0.0159790497,
0.0411888808,
0.0492183194,
-0.0031004692,
0.0180831011,
-0.0621126071,
-0.0166723356,
0.0145406919,
0.0272749811,
0.0202586446,
0.0192302763,
0.0164436046,
0.0187247619,
-0.055950202,
-0.0699538141,
0.0540087037,
-0.0655969158,
0.007498363,
0.015413803,
0.0111715039,
0.0197420903,
0.0404440649,
-0.0562380441,
-0.0155729931,
0.0280611683,
-0.0059688645,
-0.0190837141,
0.0133887287,
-0.031409014,
-0.0271922443,
0.0463975556,
-0.0211874507,
0.0041510761,
0.047373917,
-0.0754927918,
-0.0352678075,
0.009383712,
0.0185254849,
0.031392511,
-0.0850195065,
0.0528608747,
-0.0222196709,
0.0366266482,
-0.006630105,
0.0441569127,
-0.0281768814,
0.0041563744,
-0.0097752083,
0.0206383243,
0.0412833765,
-0.0389537476,
-0.0720125586,
0.0083988234,
-0.0079983613,
0.0517564304,
0.020290751,
0.0347431824,
-0.032007426,
-0.0110081248,
-0.0839586556,
0.0219114367,
-0.0508477166,
0.0309662018,
0.0225283951,
-0.0007198342,
-0.0281934291,
0.0079698497,
-0.0128403502,
-0.0301891584,
-0.0285531953,
-0.0051900055,
-0.0075978371,
-0.025327852,
0.0050996286,
-0.019132508,
-0.0118281553,
-0.0030685933,
0.0295119453,
-0.0297091939,
-0.0476257056,
-0.0409327485,
0.0346120074,
0.000893461,
0.0359766372,
0.0009018764,
-0.0538040474,
-0.024370499,
-0.0123999193,
-0.0005629162,
0.0495301113,
0.0052154758,
-0.0084554525,
0.0362533517,
0.0084405225,
-0.0496302918,
0.0015186833,
0.0152512779,
-0.0189116336,
-0.028846547,
-0.0288248844,
0.0016382704,
0.0642304868,
0.0021901892,
-0.038954068,
-0.046412643,
-0.025416974,
-0.037038397,
-0.0100888293,
0.0033006154,
0.0151019786,
-0.0413028561,
-0.004393762,
-0.0375445075,
-0.0257265791,
0.0558381937,
-0.0575267784,
0.0201417822,
-0.0555943213,
0.0005470765,
-0.0492207371,
0.0120347226,
-0.0212424584,
0.0120007433,
0.0506770052,
-0.0305442419,
-0.0435007215,
0.0446832441,
0.0015504103,
-0.0338427313,
0.0621993691,
-0.0200588331,
0.0136039881,
-0.0110398745,
-0.0514294356,
-0.0463866852,
-0.0312307272,
-0.0132899154,
0.025745973,
0.0032246774,
0.0007169051,
-0.0068988949,
-0.0036309189,
0.0056405133,
0.0600237548,
-0.0168393608,
0.035367284,
-0.0168421902,
0.0155444033,
0.0297062472,
-0.0125780264,
0.0333607942,
-0.0587008111,
0.0122605488,
0.0581831783,
0.0438260622,
0.0302509647,
0.0024389625,
-0.0249237306,
0.0230354164,
-0.0061500734,
-0.0402417257,
-0.013065299,
0.0354356989,
-0.0730102882,
-0.0124775311,
0.1048994809,
0.0083055841,
-0.0240641274,
-0.0067956988,
-0.0027673843,
0.0242499989,
0.0306394491,
-0.0123409051,
-0.1166585237,
-0.024653906,
0.0327798389,
0.0032668661,
0.0329442546,
-0.0108317994,
0.0131728668,
-0.1392153651,
0.0120876739,
0.0275938995,
-0.036940597,
0.0258602723,
-0.0487656333,
-0.0010835006,
-0.0366800129,
0.0408621393,
-0.0187756345,
0.0212258976,
-0.0122006098,
0.0214662105,
0.0029875934,
-0.0920379087,
0.0176289063,
-0.0614960566,
0.0228831507,
0.0482580923,
0.0154419551,
-0.0416383892,
-0.0190307833,
0.0565324016,
-0.029214954,
-0.0209058784,
-0.0158924218,
0.046998404,
-0.0011611838,
-0.0163997486,
0.0132186385,
0.0444670506,
-0.034828674,
0.0171468705,
0.0302093197,
0.0590453967,
-0.0003096864,
-0.0121917455,
-0.010746507,
-0.0248258486,
-0.0123015456,
0.089180924,
-0.005656586,
-0.0721347257,
-0.0052283355,
-0.0225629173,
-0.0219752807,
-0.0499235876,
-0.0163565855,
0.0450080447,
-0.0136198625,
-0.0205815509,
-0.0971181095,
-0.0388887748,
-0.015370205,
0.0102604209,
0.0141558815,
0.0195022915,
-0.0362590402,
-0.0187672172,
-0.0280035827,
0.0596973225,
-0.0321976207,
0.0311030168,
-0.0975076556,
0.0132327089,
0.005010711,
-0.024226021,
-0.0096058352,
0.0219549481,
-0.0989493579,
-0.0685270429,
0.006282988,
0.0469147228,
0.0074024703,
0.0377587676,
-0.0437358059,
-0.0386656597,
0.0375302583,
0.0293439068,
-0.043774236,
0.008000426,
0.0466680117,
-0.049290657,
-0.0007985739,
0.0346083604,
-0.045298323,
-0.0059551559,
0.0324135534,
0.0264385436,
0.0016243804,
0.0137179559,
0.0168911628,
0.01554472,
0.0476749465,
-0.0211532731,
0.0141422348,
-0.0709177703,
0.0558269583,
-0.0297203343,
-0.0441954695,
-0.0162360426,
0.0211961623,
0.0488794744,
-0.003670387,
-0.0063962922,
0.0571221076,
0.0153086605,
0.0386941507,
-0.0021041068,
-0.0006606891,
0.0071471729,
0.045225367,
0.031819433,
0.0107707512,
-0.0157630909,
-0.0010719013,
0.0081721656,
0.03544854,
-0.032634303,
0.0494053513,
-0.0072775036,
0.0186065249,
0.0125381416,
0.0274486523,
-0.0404543579,
-0.0398562886,
-0.0271013081,
0.0222430974,
0.0624552593,
-0.014187213,
0.0632136539,
-0.032424774,
-0.0190764144,
-0.0543074347,
0.0011290436,
0.0036557666,
-0.033270821,
0.0194570124,
-0.007412483,
-0.0370213091,
0.0082519231,
0.0763343722,
0.0135258408,
0.0409186035,
-0.008208856,
0.015518656,
-0.0191880725,
0.0062856064,
0.0178714748,
0.0071517378,
-0.0565628894,
-0.013614893,
-0.0471273921,
-0.085273385,
0.0002045838,
0.0040267706,
0.0025763081,
0.0136133153,
-0.001490073,
0.0759197921,
-0.0103026405,
0.0010352079,
-0.0561805218,
-0.014808693,
0.0286826938,
-0.0139458366,
-0.0061418628,
-6.754744657e-33,
0.0215898324,
0.0255753696,
-0.0104702646,
-0.0232524499,
-0.0148388734,
0.0233517233,
-0.008009349,
-0.0162015799,
-0.0561897419,
-0.0188767556,
-0.0227613728,
0.0284444299,
0.0256755147,
0.0346379392,
-0.0234757271,
0.018285159,
0.0706386343,
0.0012378258,
0.0008109382,
0.0058093551,
0.0624992475,
0.0365758575,
0.0760515556,
-0.0733089596,
0.0075748148,
-0.0156739838,
-0.0163725857,
0.023096839,
0.000173729,
0.0774837211,
-0.0037831499,
0.0402499661,
0.0267672576,
-0.0164691638,
-0.0240614302,
-0.0117470445,
-0.1024882421,
-0.009747888,
0.0172484703,
0.0469857343,
-0.0060337642,
-0.026070172,
0.0409901962,
-0.0249666721,
0.0207896549,
-0.0116676893,
0.0265135746,
-0.0340506844,
-0.0106281294,
-0.0097500766,
-0.0280179754,
0.0371747203,
0.0290844999,
0.0265209731,
0.0222120006,
0.0381908044,
-0.024337817,
-0.0000807229,
-0.0590045229,
-0.0045456272,
0.0227280539,
0.0572862737,
0.0586989187,
0.0247590933,
0.0338002816,
0.0516604707,
0.0340327509,
0.0138772773,
0.0335117169,
-0.0232575554,
0.0637027398,
0.0211762879,
0.0264428295,
0.0688201934,
0.0024328621,
-0.0347717963,
-0.0882051885,
0.0172256157,
0.0210072733,
0.0311544668,
0.0150998384,
0.0085736923,
-0.0175236892,
-0.0115424227,
-0.0501577407,
-0.0341679752,
-0.0311462302,
-0.0303845964,
0.0323951431,
0.0321784168,
-0.0427643918,
-0.030623069,
0.0270087831,
-0.0600665621,
-0.0449159518,
0.0592633635,
-0.0106815277,
-0.0184574034,
-0.0169514399,
0.0587605797,
-0.0813142285,
-0.0563283227,
-0.0164747536,
-0.0446099527,
-0.000302747,
0.0009773541,
0.0650023818,
0.0112971961,
-0.065872848,
0.0127676064,
-0.0166220479,
0.0042019011,
0.0484470427,
0.0579999462,
0.0499078594,
0.004383266,
0.0182891432,
0.05557945,
0.071296975,
0.0195720159,
-0.0528661609,
-0.0174326599,
-0.0192026757,
0.0304420702,
-0.0170877483,
0.0012547858,
-0.0175155308,
0.0040282933,
0.0623076968,
-0.0780387521,
-0.0204769783,
0.0022313574,
2.891e-7,
0.0243331417,
0.0220015608,
0.0019171678,
0.0153446859,
0.00203069,
0.0283262189,
-0.0466576815,
0.0503087677,
-0.0010757319,
0.0197472554,
-0.0077495794,
-0.0092188045,
0.0859099925,
0.0192999188,
-0.1117617786,
0.0181620289,
-0.0186043028,
-0.007720937,
-0.0426415056,
-0.0016236955,
-0.0189806428,
0.1421495676,
0.0049639307,
0.004154013,
0.006427255,
-0.0405414328,
0.0520885959,
-0.0024563987,
-0.0340399295,
0.0582402982,
-0.003295342,
0.0560908467,
-0.0243771039,
-0.0025689763,
-0.0411359929,
0.0458920151,
0.0092592435,
0.0660165846,
0.0118988417,
0.002510272,
0.0039941738,
-0.0597783737,
-0.0084519004,
-0.0497867987,
0.0756005943,
0.0187375527,
-0.0066904728,
-0.0136060389,
-0.0148563208,
-0.0360544473,
0.0178464875,
-0.0424239114,
-0.0260808486,
0.052864261,
0.0136614935,
0.0033725037,
-0.0278137214,
-0.0600444973,
-0.0556526668,
-0.005252074,
-0.0524791107,
-0.0462606512,
0.0103705237,
-0.0052827569,
-0.0194307696,
-0.0399856344,
0.027030874,
2.915225072e-34,
0.0248445477,
-0.0287140422,
-0.0076775295,
0.0226872321,
0.0292579904,
-0.0305674933,
0.0078758914,
-0.0039797761,
-0.0271317977,
-0.0497880504,
-0.0161357019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19301v1 | ROME: Evaluating Pre-trained Vision-Language Models on Reasoning beyond Visual Common Sense | 2023-10-30T06:35:37 | 2023-10-30T06:35:37 | Kankan Zhou, Eason Lai, Wei Bin Au Yeong, Kyriakos Mouratidis, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Humans possess a strong capability for reasoning beyond common sense. For
example, given an unconventional image of a goldfish laying on the table next
to an empty fishbowl, a human would effortlessly determine that the fish is not
inside the fishbowl. The case, however, may be different for a vision-language
model, whose reasoning could gravitate towards the common scenario that the
fish is inside the bowl, despite the visual input. In this paper, we introduce
a novel probing dataset named ROME (reasoning beyond commonsense knowledge) to
evaluate whether the state-of-the-art pre-trained vision-language models have
the reasoning capability to correctly interpret counter-intuitive content. ROME
contains images that defy commonsense knowledge with regards to color, shape,
material, size and positional relation. Experiments on the state-of-the-art
pre-trained vision-language models reveal that most of these models are still
largely incapable of interpreting counter-intuitive scenarios. We hope that
ROME will spur further investigations on reasoning beyond commonsense knowledge
in vision-language research. | [
0.0376834944,
0.0719678625,
-0.02532815,
0.0704641342,
-0.0353824012,
0.0499620363,
0.0056659007,
0.0258708168,
0.0105136037,
-0.0626763478,
-0.0217072144,
0.0047394261,
0.042593129,
0.0617357716,
0.0023740444,
-0.0693694428,
0.007780889,
-0.0096620787,
0.0001698228,
0.0155895278,
-0.0185006075,
-0.0158802215,
0.0132915247,
0.0080691529,
0.0065175896,
-0.0261873677,
-0.0101190936,
0.0153186284,
0.0071435398,
0.0011233045,
-0.0035688961,
0.0256901328,
0.0404651649,
0.032509096,
0.0000017574,
-0.0130239362,
0.0589535832,
-0.0031792829,
0.0165847708,
0.0086361868,
-0.022442976,
-0.0647058636,
-0.0156644043,
-0.0352855399,
-0.0528217219,
0.0056552663,
0.059914995,
0.0423861556,
0.0263676178,
0.0280672442,
-0.010430973,
-0.0437096357,
-0.0039011126,
-0.0163658001,
0.0500306226,
-0.04761241,
0.0120359398,
0.0411685109,
-0.0268169083,
-0.007438302,
-0.0505479202,
0.0080124764,
0.0620678551,
0.0120089445,
-0.0796117261,
0.0504160337,
-0.0445718057,
-0.0325385071,
-0.0160058048,
0.0994636416,
-0.0537014492,
-0.0434517264,
-0.0219132695,
-0.0208462756,
-0.007879192,
0.0134307779,
-0.0124596022,
0.0389089137,
0.0091909477,
0.0267563779,
-0.0343003497,
0.0185197331,
0.0008225851,
0.0239710175,
-0.0302584022,
0.0395328254,
-0.0153574562,
0.0440849662,
0.0152880168,
0.0223272145,
-0.0513176955,
-0.0154342968,
-0.0090104053,
0.014033623,
0.0340826549,
0.0057832892,
-0.0144667691,
-0.0002274725,
-0.0068263412,
-0.0502832122,
0.0766965449,
0.018509727,
-0.0865729004,
0.1038024202,
-0.040292047,
0.039806556,
-0.0540858619,
0.0729834661,
-0.0042503993,
0.0051483246,
-0.0187162552,
0.0068228845,
-0.0140122613,
-0.0339484699,
-0.0679892451,
-0.0595165454,
0.0152125675,
-0.0300503615,
-0.028539801,
0.0068623517,
0.003997915,
0.0642002895,
-0.0240666196,
-0.0645299256,
-0.039980609,
0.0196373239,
0.0060156072,
0.0474581085,
-0.0405952409,
-0.0455622934,
-0.0102532906,
0.0184369311,
-0.0059690028,
-0.0212833937,
0.0105164433,
0.038752351,
-0.0250725206,
-0.0059808092,
-0.0346738137,
-0.0021661723,
0.0070525189,
-0.0422666222,
0.032307148,
-0.0417527445,
-0.0001674803,
-0.0244388804,
0.0080663739,
-0.0352519378,
-0.0043176156,
0.0064714612,
-0.0515018851,
0.1269030571,
-0.0530895144,
-0.0140149044,
-0.0018280045,
0.0310986843,
0.0223424193,
0.0811165497,
-0.0025970326,
0.0165401623,
0.0090509932,
0.0017790508,
0.0216683168,
-0.0042268438,
0.0205222052,
-0.0085750418,
-0.0881686658,
0.013935945,
-0.0307659823,
0.0071448986,
0.0115007097,
0.0145488158,
0.004562478,
-0.0631738901,
0.0548712723,
0.048625093,
-0.0360913165,
-0.012740572,
0.059175618,
-0.0200888123,
0.0073791086,
0.0204138663,
-0.0711745024,
0.0408535041,
-0.0417601913,
-0.021513598,
-0.0670686215,
0.0109611256,
-0.0469261184,
-0.0275672562,
-0.0013090492,
-0.0404394604,
0.0318647958,
-0.0000926329,
0.0693085119,
0.0364662372,
-0.0140520949,
-0.0264423769,
0.0242973994,
-0.0302247796,
-0.0219449103,
-0.034572497,
0.0283532273,
0.0201419611,
0.0234580636,
-0.0238549337,
0.0135879628,
0.0384376012,
0.0685784891,
0.0285814758,
0.0401291139,
0.0245294347,
0.0370683894,
-0.02200111,
-0.0435261354,
-0.0113703795,
0.0176963266,
0.0027605901,
-0.0023663521,
-0.0007278245,
0.0281554312,
-0.062644057,
0.0092007946,
0.042758245,
0.034634009,
0.011943507,
-0.0416928232,
0.0089591779,
-0.0170272719,
-0.0407703444,
-0.0084797302,
-0.0049162386,
0.034813188,
-0.0202928279,
0.0160051864,
0.0291644651,
-0.0274469163,
-0.0513973869,
0.0265010521,
-0.0999532789,
-0.0418959707,
0.0432159156,
-0.0550094023,
-0.0013065408,
0.0502440669,
0.0123279504,
0.0308911279,
-0.033159174,
-0.0318701155,
-0.0067358958,
0.0243616719,
0.0290046502,
0.0613526031,
-0.0339478776,
-0.0064309081,
-0.0380526707,
-0.0014669256,
0.0245379154,
-0.0256802738,
0.0056226389,
-0.0065589519,
-0.0074790553,
0.0146504603,
-0.024338657,
0.0185678583,
-0.0171236526,
0.0485069007,
-0.0413021855,
-0.0507928319,
-0.0328202918,
-0.0360003635,
-0.0049461024,
-0.0459548645,
0.0081750425,
-0.0557602085,
-0.0161806941,
0.039778024,
-0.0241192859,
0.0300856885,
0.0390225463,
-0.0208020769,
0.0245627929,
-0.0126153165,
-0.0090160845,
0.0241422281,
0.0889314562,
0.0445436202,
0.0184673239,
-0.0010774898,
0.0201613978,
-0.0484992042,
0.0513837114,
-0.027687896,
-0.0385927297,
0.0122074578,
-0.0234584305,
-0.0372560807,
0.0946868062,
-0.0122926868,
0.0163640343,
0.0236668028,
0.0094154421,
-0.0131806508,
-0.0517397672,
-0.0048009036,
-0.0230713878,
-0.0258470066,
0.0035141835,
-0.0179382674,
0.0382298343,
-0.0198196154,
-0.0108658476,
-0.0791167244,
0.0810332671,
0.0052757952,
-0.0533458292,
-0.0729038641,
-0.0028076626,
0.0289389733,
0.096630469,
-0.041901093,
-0.0448091589,
0.0504050814,
-0.005349054,
0.0023422746,
0.0243410803,
0.0235561244,
-0.0021567577,
0.0996557474,
0.0415636078,
0.0174658019,
0.0029842881,
0.003514922,
-0.0502064787,
-0.0175927579,
0.0019298728,
-0.0057361866,
0.0367838442,
-0.0756412223,
0.013597114,
-0.0128375171,
-0.0146279875,
-0.0249649826,
-0.0185470078,
-0.0353434496,
-0.0038481967,
-0.050088238,
-0.0073681916,
-0.0464268476,
0.045490995,
-0.0109719224,
0.0464175567,
0.0332999639,
-0.0088334233,
-0.0017619744,
0.0444527827,
0.033680357,
0.0103384349,
0.0167257078,
-0.0096018109,
-0.0111607919,
0.0774449259,
0.0060084211,
-0.0294458531,
-0.0611971058,
0.0673853606,
0.0006186421,
0.0764058605,
0.0059868335,
0.0191359539,
0.0082441,
-0.0471813604,
-0.0152855078,
0.0423528329,
0.0519862734,
-0.023768723,
0.0025982773,
0.0132390028,
-0.0172912125,
0.0366212539,
-0.0089558261,
-0.0719018728,
-0.0518480726,
-0.0012289266,
-0.0577642657,
0.0074958364,
-0.0491134226,
-0.047212299,
-0.0862379,
0.0366597772,
0.0005936468,
-0.0120835453,
-0.066729635,
0.0230887104,
0.0030472232,
-0.0276625827,
-0.0203204378,
-0.0161301475,
0.0184272975,
0.0168874152,
-0.0086537134,
0.0239129812,
-0.0475635268,
0.0379027575,
-0.0172604024,
-0.0130142551,
0.0376964174,
0.0199433528,
-0.0009909275,
-0.0783595517,
0.0063041691,
-0.0293208081,
0.0316062272,
0.0066660475,
0.0269448161,
0.0010184607,
-0.038416829,
0.0088507226,
0.0348123349,
-0.0651851296,
-0.0596810095,
-0.0159746204,
0.0389585644,
-0.0079032974,
-0.044094041,
-0.0297499616,
-0.0053949342,
-0.0060469653,
0.060126815,
0.0432338007,
-0.0119620198,
-0.0331886522,
-0.0236914959,
-0.0197244678,
-0.0127785737,
-0.0429853052,
0.0081113726,
0.0684474111,
-0.0212193858,
-0.0595050342,
-0.0009312375,
0.0170314666,
0.0673799664,
-0.009596616,
-0.0578694046,
-0.0085983071,
0.0017220357,
-0.0666972175,
0.085613668,
-0.0244968645,
0.0094702737,
-0.0112599907,
0.0050085806,
0.0025128499,
-0.0452835783,
-0.0466697328,
0.0378529802,
-0.0383110531,
-0.0494421236,
-0.0232571978,
0.0610795617,
0.0309009291,
0.0120981876,
-0.0010718965,
-0.0393668562,
0.045044139,
0.0378899723,
0.0246923286,
0.0272366945,
0.0287900809,
-0.0411054119,
0.0269560628,
0.0430638902,
0.0348213613,
0.0338607691,
0.0683045909,
0.0006977462,
-0.0615263134,
0.000988818,
0.0091196895,
-0.0349246189,
0.0777311698,
0.0021201079,
0.0221131016,
-0.0173061304,
0.0208521858,
0.0014927568,
0.0129688615,
-0.063031517,
-0.0111221904,
0.029895978,
-0.0000265403,
-0.0299213603,
-0.0035541775,
-0.0149294306,
0.0246339981,
-0.0199804194,
-0.021446418,
0.0823741481,
0.005852086,
0.0084343003,
-0.0027019021,
0.0165092554,
0.0255347714,
-0.0647681803,
0.0584750473,
0.0106047709,
0.0670024604,
0.05637132,
-0.0161789712,
-0.009902169,
0.0170272775,
-0.0411299653,
-0.0528940186,
-0.0042622774,
0.0758253634,
0.0338194594,
-0.0452486202,
-0.012044535,
-0.0325375423,
0.0008757074,
-0.0089398203,
0.0408905819,
0.0266381688,
-0.0382148027,
0.0698395297,
0.022502793,
-0.0019387429,
0.0012018968,
0.0591005459,
-0.01210027,
0.0163931362,
0.0024772927,
-0.0058361595,
-0.0074292962,
-0.003931602,
0.0328740329,
0.0228430722,
0.0046635363,
0.064749077,
-0.0544652604,
-0.0832995921,
-0.0320333391,
0.0763054863,
0.01383352,
0.0496529937,
0.0016320533,
0.0666456372,
0.0172189511,
0.0006469685,
0.0142616536,
-0.0295386761,
-0.0528228618,
0.025130976,
-0.0235694665,
-5.705607868e-33,
-0.0099020023,
-0.0276704859,
0.0114217773,
-0.0276876651,
0.0501066409,
0.0184897855,
-0.0295208395,
-0.0130775301,
-0.0352679119,
0.0424715467,
0.0118222553,
0.0357586816,
-0.0018685946,
0.0103990911,
-0.0078326585,
0.0047741001,
-0.0048254989,
0.0087002078,
-0.0063046571,
-0.040827062,
0.0157731101,
-0.0181714278,
0.0392085798,
-0.0294229314,
-0.0105527174,
0.0382637233,
-0.0237923451,
0.0284269638,
-0.0116170924,
0.0371769443,
-0.0255333856,
0.0065277284,
0.019224396,
0.0438102335,
-0.0372332148,
0.0206840001,
-0.0442834087,
-0.0391838253,
0.0226355884,
0.0425713584,
-0.0465747975,
0.0678890273,
0.0191507675,
-0.0216360018,
0.0046459623,
-0.0147953443,
0.0486829802,
-0.0511992611,
0.022881588,
0.0341215134,
-0.0192518923,
0.0126157012,
-0.0044220719,
-0.036633499,
0.0306153297,
-0.0131328339,
-0.0139623526,
0.0117088752,
-0.0501701124,
0.0408115946,
0.0194348004,
-0.0318582803,
0.0605059527,
0.0079257181,
0.0167748854,
0.0647684112,
0.0423958674,
-0.0151199428,
-0.0355930775,
-0.0164940991,
0.0320882723,
0.0587304421,
0.0480096713,
0.0546349846,
0.0544119664,
-0.0017066654,
-0.0451952219,
-0.0053589856,
-0.0611872375,
0.0285959728,
0.0077077034,
0.002359207,
0.0023289151,
-0.0012160965,
-0.0333302468,
-0.0303438082,
-0.0391586199,
0.0134372078,
0.0258183945,
0.0016955648,
-0.0151601713,
0.0483511873,
0.0198063888,
-0.0416124985,
0.0017922693,
0.0180703029,
-0.0018496043,
0.0117579699,
0.0218108203,
0.0335152298,
-0.0493360348,
-0.0327530056,
0.0689106062,
0.0046758242,
-0.0012983326,
-0.0163191259,
0.0560822338,
0.0070518865,
-0.021335518,
-0.0168365501,
-0.0394549929,
-0.0108770123,
0.039369531,
0.015856741,
0.059134949,
0.0205393601,
-0.0465371273,
-0.0079836799,
-0.0131443283,
-0.0568989031,
-0.0244996957,
0.0166632105,
-0.0342590734,
0.0550814904,
-0.0384465232,
-0.0490819179,
-0.0311208591,
-0.0669589713,
0.0448961891,
-0.0214249399,
-0.0058333841,
0.0640353784,
2.431e-7,
0.0211925562,
0.0030761757,
-0.0021303208,
-0.0308940727,
0.0368020944,
0.0571539626,
-0.0445221774,
0.017206423,
-0.0163841043,
-0.0459595956,
0.0113701532,
0.0679954365,
0.0088311313,
-0.0217333175,
0.0188239794,
0.0628310516,
-0.020904135,
-0.023619473,
-0.0436429903,
-0.0215004329,
0.0185292661,
0.0525367074,
0.01402291,
-0.0317022577,
0.051743418,
-0.0751686245,
0.064287968,
-0.0475305691,
0.0436582975,
-0.0405791327,
-0.004824731,
0.0163996369,
-0.0241580363,
0.0564733967,
0.0188008454,
-0.0303333029,
0.015649084,
0.0022557462,
-0.0474801175,
0.0060920967,
-0.0531006418,
-0.0046895822,
-0.0284570362,
-0.0710663199,
0.092848599,
-0.0735828355,
-0.0214317366,
-0.0249361154,
-0.0263180137,
-0.0062796371,
0.0229180958,
0.008317763,
-0.0118631246,
-0.0027412272,
0.0223301034,
-0.0296297222,
-0.0181286857,
-0.0719554573,
-0.0145993447,
0.0045793406,
-0.0250810459,
-0.0068848426,
-0.0446049906,
-0.0087437546,
0.0674850419,
-0.0165788382,
-0.053508807,
1.539864194e-34,
0.0181168318,
0.0019470395,
-0.0092268893,
-0.0598938577,
0.015790239,
-0.014489173,
0.0026384888,
-0.0038350602,
0.0103334775,
-0.0193838831,
0.0105580445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19292v1 | Fusing Temporal Graphs into Transformers for Time-Sensitive Question Answering | 2023-10-30T06:12:50 | 2023-10-30T06:12:50 | Xin Su, Phillip Howard, Nagib Hakim, Steven Bethard | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering time-sensitive questions from long documents requires temporal
reasoning over the times in questions and documents. An important open question
is whether large language models can perform such reasoning solely using a
provided text document, or whether they can benefit from additional temporal
information extracted using other systems. We address this research question by
applying existing temporal information extraction systems to construct temporal
graphs of events, times, and temporal relations in questions and documents. We
then investigate different approaches for fusing these graphs into Transformer
models. Experimental results show that our proposed approach for fusing
temporal graphs into input text substantially enhances the temporal reasoning
capabilities of Transformer models with or without fine-tuning. Additionally,
our proposed method outperforms various graph convolution-based approaches and
establishes a new state-of-the-art performance on SituatedQA and three splits
of TimeQA. | [
0.0336576588,
0.058787737,
-0.0024424859,
0.0288844686,
-0.0617462881,
-0.0081260381,
0.0208141897,
-0.0023746951,
0.0209057834,
-0.0285878759,
0.0311459247,
-0.0291298758,
-0.0130509194,
0.0277440548,
-0.0313504711,
-0.0492965691,
0.0486346222,
0.0074174684,
-0.0076173502,
0.0279414952,
-0.0104590748,
0.0188294519,
-0.0073624137,
0.0182160884,
-0.0123453029,
-0.0480737053,
-0.0327355824,
-0.0094638104,
0.055644799,
-0.0269674696,
-0.0182021987,
0.0070253694,
0.0064724502,
0.028266279,
0.0000015623,
0.0115909697,
-0.0367765799,
0.0038619395,
-0.03958055,
-0.0096019851,
-0.0147653483,
-0.0177985597,
0.0277522523,
0.0038906909,
-0.0826470628,
-0.0256102327,
0.0087461527,
0.0409735814,
0.0531046391,
0.0926612392,
-0.0226328988,
0.0041359416,
0.0310426708,
0.0041922899,
0.0139660314,
-0.0700954795,
0.0074604629,
0.020540351,
0.0703000128,
-0.0158830583,
-0.0143619785,
0.0288512968,
0.039809078,
-0.0137413219,
0.0281369686,
0.0406106785,
-0.0473728962,
0.0481093712,
-0.0309258681,
0.0790468827,
0.0139745716,
-0.0235703532,
-0.0087925261,
0.0049569695,
-0.020204382,
0.0135857193,
-0.0616018735,
-0.0260175969,
-0.007618208,
0.0045194789,
-0.0044748583,
0.024352951,
0.0228230655,
0.0144703714,
-0.0102185057,
0.1008185595,
0.0026089319,
-0.0050215223,
-0.0377660096,
0.0092413453,
0.016877871,
-0.0353719667,
0.0200468581,
0.0842430145,
0.007456169,
0.006548773,
-0.0142942267,
0.0094536869,
-0.0270728767,
-0.001959394,
-0.0226647295,
0.023981506,
0.0122783864,
0.0693101361,
0.0149713745,
0.0682617649,
-0.0589253902,
0.0152939344,
-0.0498676524,
-0.0365797617,
-0.0451043658,
-0.009953537,
-0.0363699459,
0.0125576854,
-0.0465321615,
-0.0236723386,
-0.0175708998,
0.0669806004,
0.0253969673,
-0.0259485617,
0.0244322289,
0.0440866202,
-0.0214736983,
-0.0305273514,
-0.0113105793,
0.0467295572,
-0.0227407161,
0.0031227267,
-0.0251559205,
-0.0476992764,
-0.0130018042,
-0.0008014192,
0.0646951199,
-0.0494599342,
-0.033885818,
0.0497617014,
-0.0393514,
-0.0168822818,
-0.0347854644,
-0.0278608091,
-0.0246727094,
-0.0094460789,
0.0248793606,
-0.0404683091,
0.0432565846,
0.000849293,
-0.0303483848,
0.0057435976,
0.0210301951,
0.0042425883,
-0.0213714931,
0.0672715679,
0.05257456,
0.02255149,
0.0237273257,
-0.0115654701,
0.0242046174,
0.0160071049,
0.0369289592,
-0.0033339621,
0.0230842456,
0.0126060788,
-0.0184366107,
0.0323871225,
0.018108815,
-0.0236233287,
-0.0203255862,
0.0209377389,
-0.0490535125,
-0.0088202609,
-0.012112054,
0.0586431101,
-0.0322277993,
-0.0484963506,
0.0407435857,
0.0142917335,
0.0099876067,
-0.0176645145,
0.0515102372,
-0.0019441704,
0.0139094992,
0.0018672366,
-0.0222061444,
0.0305594131,
0.0054159244,
0.0407599322,
-0.0608931333,
0.0003151936,
-0.0144758355,
-0.0109019298,
-0.021743305,
0.0008603928,
0.0564852133,
-0.0042482959,
0.0372074693,
0.0242314059,
-0.0506247468,
0.0549950264,
-0.0013296864,
0.0124944327,
-0.0082417857,
0.0012159952,
-0.0060103317,
0.0684033409,
0.052551847,
-0.0123021891,
-0.0430402271,
-0.0195505563,
0.018262051,
0.0136395311,
0.0517496467,
-0.0277866051,
-0.0238800365,
-0.0238902234,
-0.0325878747,
-0.0188664831,
-0.0176131502,
0.0016678103,
0.0702648759,
0.026597457,
0.0012678889,
-0.0610574298,
0.0328879468,
-0.0007892327,
-0.0037370734,
-0.0377565064,
-0.0170435719,
0.0176927336,
0.0022884281,
0.0284419525,
-0.0004583563,
0.044233501,
0.0361693427,
-0.0327338725,
-0.034868177,
0.0421654284,
-0.0715278238,
-0.0695649162,
0.0455357097,
-0.0079571968,
-0.0454349779,
0.0251339301,
-0.044213865,
-0.0284912493,
0.0181325842,
-0.0302728359,
0.0496981293,
-0.0185189936,
-0.0111063868,
0.0343680754,
-0.0013785115,
-0.0519240014,
0.0784312263,
-0.0212883204,
-0.0003856748,
-0.009128321,
0.0050447932,
-0.0132497111,
-0.0424755998,
0.0137772365,
0.019591473,
0.0113902716,
-0.013492153,
0.0042394674,
-0.0229896586,
-0.0652427822,
-0.0130643696,
-0.0901557282,
-0.0008076144,
-0.0152442427,
0.0288353246,
0.0040124883,
0.0137529559,
0.017041292,
-0.0308825597,
-0.0448095798,
-0.0075541469,
-0.0237802677,
0.0254396629,
0.043438971,
0.0137184961,
0.0066969842,
-0.016746683,
-0.0485881381,
-0.0590165779,
0.0928966925,
0.0113929436,
-0.0530861281,
0.0178098977,
-0.0275318287,
-0.0303757899,
0.0275203995,
-0.0061520017,
0.0114621837,
0.024237683,
-0.0284579657,
0.0661229715,
0.0460924208,
0.0140971737,
0.024599757,
0.003884255,
-0.0362346917,
-0.0178095046,
0.0523221083,
-0.0620825775,
0.0095974039,
-0.0161956139,
-0.0116166249,
-0.0393371396,
0.0346369967,
-0.0052236989,
0.0126658492,
-0.0341838002,
0.0134904506,
-0.0254064985,
0.0328643396,
0.0046853554,
-0.006464188,
-0.0422174931,
-0.0125793414,
-0.0556781404,
0.0034130728,
0.0691777319,
0.0299933571,
-0.0200188346,
0.0122879921,
-0.0246779732,
-0.0730443001,
0.108484365,
0.0010305012,
-0.0026433291,
0.0046372814,
-0.0514431857,
-0.0640627965,
-0.0222658962,
0.0378954224,
-0.055749625,
0.0235300642,
-0.0132914502,
0.038414333,
-0.0022991002,
-0.020702282,
-0.0464445017,
-0.0672173798,
-0.0322737284,
0.0100992229,
-0.0596173145,
-0.0118207168,
-0.0334565379,
0.0324766971,
-0.0554801524,
0.0011063011,
-0.0410498977,
-0.0011242533,
-0.0124286534,
0.1135257855,
0.0842030421,
0.0237313602,
-0.0118910046,
0.0002328804,
0.0168321487,
0.0368220359,
0.0704660043,
-0.0304608475,
-0.046171546,
0.0167413186,
-0.0343376473,
-0.0229053013,
0.0155796083,
-0.0283559896,
0.0285804104,
-0.0683963448,
-0.006926755,
0.0778959244,
0.0513401814,
-0.0014327335,
-0.0076914686,
0.0025113272,
-0.0138961365,
0.001782814,
0.0122094154,
-0.0886031389,
-0.013311591,
-0.0138886338,
-0.0201633442,
0.0104247984,
-0.043489892,
-0.0073631164,
-0.0824632049,
0.0028066519,
0.0214995332,
0.0114334207,
0.0099974675,
-0.0113689909,
-0.012450234,
-0.0010960069,
0.0104844254,
-0.0055247094,
-0.010147687,
0.0035012218,
0.0206530169,
-0.0146089476,
-0.0069096973,
0.0466410257,
0.0457231328,
0.010577892,
-0.0098906569,
0.0539954714,
0.0122569716,
-0.0420607179,
0.0361114889,
-0.0042355093,
-0.0094624069,
-0.0106927287,
0.0214958154,
-0.0046398388,
-0.0174594764,
-0.0192777906,
0.0279362984,
0.0043716398,
-0.0457303599,
-0.0409021303,
0.1126223952,
-0.0090176715,
-0.0117497137,
-0.0195396692,
-0.0213298053,
0.0058825021,
0.0220343973,
0.0056049377,
0.0139044598,
-0.0824782401,
0.0235716384,
-0.0106180739,
-0.0582143851,
-0.0508847497,
0.010561293,
0.0132384375,
-0.0033679693,
-0.0709491968,
-0.0505437255,
-0.0105568273,
0.0117159421,
-0.0455740802,
-0.0328030102,
0.0443457365,
0.0131319482,
-0.0964516103,
0.0449263006,
-0.0257817749,
0.0336823687,
-0.0128639741,
0.0119251609,
0.0048358589,
0.0167984832,
-0.0118417908,
0.0238070134,
-0.0893706158,
-0.0485387929,
0.0080533456,
-0.0382884257,
0.0147385383,
0.0571542121,
-0.0323279947,
0.0471446589,
0.0361874774,
0.021824671,
-0.0245074145,
-0.0234552734,
0.0142755127,
-0.0086526405,
-0.0081798295,
0.0231235586,
-0.072784178,
-0.0017680735,
-0.0177245922,
0.0676454604,
-0.0767899826,
-0.0232965332,
0.0136314724,
-0.0092442716,
0.0264460016,
0.068542093,
0.0098882243,
-0.0127828615,
-0.0092850495,
-0.0379786342,
-0.0041553932,
-0.0100691728,
-0.0128314998,
0.0298537239,
-0.0140399188,
-0.0270703826,
-0.0076095168,
0.0060037896,
0.0101914378,
-0.0156508815,
-0.0143846851,
0.0310644303,
-0.0216310937,
0.0178738404,
-0.0025547445,
-0.023838073,
0.0148324557,
0.0044603064,
0.0136103006,
0.0125508383,
0.0242325906,
0.0051942468,
-0.000131339,
-0.0738009959,
-0.0275133979,
-0.1294535398,
0.0034694457,
0.017151488,
-0.0199052002,
0.0352845117,
-0.0129968505,
0.0434568822,
0.0173021182,
-0.0239439048,
0.0081108836,
0.0221154969,
0.0480066016,
-0.0053775148,
0.0503037535,
0.0256714039,
0.0016570551,
0.0396839119,
0.0406828038,
-0.002225525,
0.0376186073,
0.0342765301,
-0.0464322604,
-0.0217988938,
-0.0371320434,
-0.079482764,
-0.0286829155,
-0.0012765367,
0.013172471,
-0.0740755275,
-0.0477067456,
0.0555559658,
0.0035884667,
-0.0277545694,
0.000970647,
0.0113108503,
0.0220729113,
0.0627867654,
-0.0536723286,
-0.03800698,
0.0830610245,
0.0170420855,
-0.0229403302,
-0.0535989814,
-5.879518951e-33,
-0.0168968383,
-0.0668694377,
0.0273137838,
0.0337633006,
-0.0645705909,
0.0655609742,
-0.0347062014,
-0.0122962417,
-0.0452339426,
0.0032841393,
-0.0238942485,
0.0531010553,
0.0223883651,
-0.0080376873,
-0.0251144785,
-0.0472818092,
0.0273010116,
-0.0074847704,
0.0148261189,
0.0204655379,
0.0504578352,
0.0429645181,
0.0280296579,
-0.0348669551,
0.0106386794,
-0.0123618394,
0.0318120345,
0.0333958976,
0.0357496962,
0.0839965791,
0.0056027998,
0.0150101846,
0.0343239941,
-0.0170254186,
-0.0032363392,
0.0547160991,
-0.1446522325,
-0.0566039123,
-0.0059299134,
0.0241433717,
-0.0368065573,
-0.0368156619,
0.0059415465,
-0.0085545983,
0.0566708148,
-0.081472747,
0.0258803088,
-0.00368151,
-0.0315164253,
-0.0656618848,
-0.0246587116,
0.0661298782,
-0.0146344732,
-0.0005363722,
0.0186797734,
0.039348051,
0.0410715677,
-0.0087090936,
-0.0321236514,
0.003879457,
-0.0257126745,
-0.0194139108,
0.0132877287,
0.0087253349,
-0.0228543282,
0.0200289227,
-0.0425994694,
-0.003088509,
-0.026423825,
0.0505411327,
-0.0110716997,
0.0320838988,
0.0163037386,
-0.0062316852,
-0.0140587306,
0.004643403,
-0.0587594658,
0.0059700902,
0.0342445709,
0.0505683683,
0.0019394994,
0.016810583,
-0.0038084723,
0.0160108749,
0.0177607052,
0.0643409565,
-0.0308346208,
0.0101531753,
0.0175594371,
0.0172496997,
0.0016327923,
0.0510461777,
0.0235517621,
-0.055720225,
0.0194281638,
0.0918735266,
-0.01213245,
0.0258561783,
-0.016065307,
0.0486673638,
-0.0331164561,
0.0120185427,
0.0353996344,
-0.0097924126,
-0.0051925546,
0.0014173451,
0.0090899225,
0.0515033975,
-0.0403000787,
-0.0374351256,
-0.032157857,
0.0108719608,
-0.0350199975,
-0.0239518583,
0.0571986884,
0.0320782959,
-0.0220319591,
0.0330100134,
0.0128535125,
0.0608490705,
0.0041935635,
0.0325000584,
0.0267291274,
0.0359068066,
-0.0189714283,
-0.0000542283,
-0.004050504,
0.0777982473,
0.0077426569,
-0.0203561317,
-0.0183537025,
0.0227462482,
2.265e-7,
0.0804252401,
0.0062524313,
0.0666842163,
0.0661545396,
-0.0009465842,
-0.0187173709,
0.0126850465,
-0.0059390166,
-0.0118907932,
0.0309939813,
0.0475790016,
0.0357338674,
0.0314754918,
0.0598793067,
-0.0255476572,
-0.0339615308,
-0.0582891665,
-0.0438596942,
-0.0543730408,
-0.0154433856,
0.075580366,
0.0583671555,
0.0525864549,
0.003683029,
-0.0552942306,
-0.0853878036,
0.0729355365,
0.0319455005,
-0.0393731333,
0.0156136742,
0.0272775963,
-0.0149087403,
0.0096124196,
-0.0009966134,
-0.011475279,
0.0245400351,
0.0020659519,
0.0279792715,
-0.0432618931,
-0.060500782,
-0.029708568,
-0.0693368763,
-0.0032624751,
-0.0072560101,
0.1024503633,
-0.0547176898,
-0.0201881323,
-0.0054462571,
-0.0479873903,
0.0420840271,
0.0052788053,
0.0250261072,
-0.0144024817,
0.0211320389,
0.0369603932,
-0.0075650732,
0.0027097422,
-0.0921620876,
-0.0281969868,
0.0449067354,
-0.01144417,
-0.0225279145,
0.0061283577,
-0.0042554913,
-0.0079439264,
0.0006815369,
-0.014784052,
1.749387912e-34,
0.0282367989,
0.0420683064,
-0.0239155404,
0.0389762409,
0.0313780867,
-0.025839854,
0.0102637894,
-0.0110784601,
0.0236188248,
-0.0843583941,
-0.0183386505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19271v1 | Learning to love diligent trolls: Accounting for rater effects in the dialogue safety task | 2023-10-30T05:08:23 | 2023-10-30T05:08:23 | Michael John Ilagan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chatbots have the risk of generating offensive utterances, which must be
avoided. Post-deployment, one way for a chatbot to continuously improve is to
source utterance/label pairs from feedback by live users. However, among users
are trolls, who provide training examples with incorrect labels. To de-troll
training data, previous work removed training examples that have high
user-aggregated cross-validation (CV) error. However, CV is expensive; and in a
coordinated attack, CV may be overwhelmed by trolls in number and in
consistency among themselves. In the present work, I address both limitations
by proposing a solution inspired by methodology in automated essay scoring
(AES): have multiple users rate each utterance, then perform latent class
analysis (LCA) to infer correct labels. As it does not require GPU
computations, LCA is inexpensive. In experiments, I found that the AES-like
solution can infer training labels with high accuracy when trolls are
consistent, even when trolls are the majority. | [
0.0796768069,
0.0285579916,
-0.0153194843,
0.0173258409,
0.0014777402,
0.0147459116,
0.0233591571,
-0.014067851,
-0.0078077503,
-0.0589109845,
-0.0143701928,
-0.0167683586,
-0.0204057358,
-0.0035626737,
0.0052562002,
-0.0625504181,
0.0353437103,
-0.0241472814,
0.0104987221,
-0.0139789078,
0.0766182318,
-0.0135355676,
-0.0504153073,
0.071202755,
-0.0699347854,
-0.0278557464,
-0.0381083712,
-0.0238686278,
0.0364970006,
-0.0088136001,
0.042397175,
0.0582111552,
0.0014264275,
0.0466465689,
0.0000019025,
-0.0138231581,
-0.0371071734,
-0.0098786354,
-0.0291528739,
-0.0142164286,
0.0626355931,
0.0523410589,
-0.0165266637,
0.0650612712,
-0.0552559346,
-0.0098174168,
0.0422478989,
0.0561237969,
0.090916492,
0.072204344,
0.0156729147,
0.0006102517,
-0.0022900468,
0.0212817267,
0.0076794811,
-0.0753015503,
0.0126172137,
0.0407957882,
-0.0214639958,
0.0211753268,
-0.0074470094,
0.0066184024,
0.0063251113,
-0.0462801978,
-0.0025710927,
-0.0018713847,
-0.0401800796,
-0.0252050124,
-0.0072378726,
0.0594124608,
-0.0055787754,
0.0105668698,
-0.0063002571,
-0.004544259,
0.018791711,
-0.0293686949,
-0.0204239972,
-0.0068041594,
-0.0194574036,
-0.0191250779,
-0.0011007506,
0.0048546214,
0.0129045583,
0.0205894466,
0.0496223308,
-0.0130447121,
-0.0120935095,
-0.0393305831,
0.0000509456,
0.0047066207,
-0.0094366437,
-0.0324594751,
0.0201672893,
0.0296425559,
-0.0617168508,
0.0119098779,
-0.0472332388,
-0.0498426035,
0.0178283099,
-0.0336150229,
0.0000709932,
0.0175967384,
-0.0172012839,
0.0193949863,
-0.0028056393,
0.0616148897,
0.0417990349,
0.0472283289,
0.0047124741,
0.004226156,
-0.05839343,
0.0248008575,
-0.0315722153,
0.0460829623,
0.0461266302,
0.0318976678,
-0.086601004,
0.0253265966,
-0.0770492479,
0.019656606,
-0.0154024307,
0.0412972085,
-0.02059507,
0.0525551885,
-0.0292446185,
0.0019300252,
-0.0176807586,
0.0130847637,
-0.0223973244,
-0.1039232686,
-0.0177657772,
0.0441089086,
-0.0063980101,
0.0062142923,
0.0223855488,
0.0307893027,
0.006309262,
-0.0349407531,
0.0088639976,
-0.0493043661,
-0.0119048674,
-0.0335943215,
-0.0020225018,
-0.0496643558,
0.0358765274,
-0.0280193482,
-0.0112654101,
-0.0128120678,
0.0079519125,
0.0347903371,
-0.0104538556,
0.0993965119,
-0.0003422338,
-0.0018190844,
0.0038405347,
0.0421606489,
-0.0226343051,
0.0300927535,
0.0282070395,
0.0177605338,
0.0363299027,
-0.0309478845,
0.0766046718,
0.0254192352,
0.0038511257,
-0.0133996336,
0.0406549647,
-0.0024044849,
-0.0029751151,
-0.0172941219,
-0.0039390251,
0.0408471227,
-0.0255294926,
-0.0522447787,
0.0691329837,
0.0287856013,
-0.0643749312,
0.020813752,
0.036049746,
-0.0152421398,
0.0186042991,
0.011616963,
-0.0364447162,
0.0051936815,
-0.0328684747,
-0.0502416603,
0.0771110952,
-0.0259474646,
-0.0254272297,
-0.049225267,
-0.0039305971,
-0.0296393372,
0.0177063905,
-0.0063749095,
0.0295844711,
0.0130157135,
-0.0354236886,
-0.0083616665,
0.0543038547,
-0.0375090763,
-0.0191470925,
-0.0532833375,
-0.0160257462,
0.0354033448,
0.0488638803,
-0.045185335,
-0.0374944136,
-0.045372244,
-0.0382499993,
0.0607569851,
0.0315882713,
-0.0565543771,
0.000676813,
-0.0435434394,
-0.0220579002,
0.0215073936,
-0.0246802997,
0.0208597612,
0.0510564558,
-0.004316071,
-0.0232394971,
0.027952211,
-0.0591709353,
0.0423307493,
0.0305346027,
-0.0267603062,
0.0075680213,
0.0242513884,
0.0951964334,
0.0242651142,
-0.0074108941,
-0.0253060684,
0.0175137725,
0.0021942912,
-0.036331106,
-0.0073023099,
-0.0110235196,
-0.0048473701,
0.0521514975,
-0.0119667863,
-0.0293772556,
0.0602836125,
-0.026871331,
0.0143603133,
0.0370121449,
-0.0482926816,
-0.0182491038,
-0.0368539542,
-0.0085296091,
-0.0197877493,
0.0154313128,
-0.0207809694,
0.0372459479,
-0.001136814,
0.028106045,
-0.0320748426,
-0.0106460229,
0.0070749163,
-0.0160697587,
-0.0794585124,
-0.0367932506,
-0.0197418965,
0.0613445826,
0.0406284593,
-0.0057364525,
-0.0258940998,
0.0009511394,
-0.0681280866,
-0.0243075397,
-0.0152893001,
0.0081315367,
0.0058432808,
-0.024263164,
0.0153486105,
-0.0296841059,
-0.0285184998,
-0.0053311498,
0.0209471229,
0.0322222821,
0.0381337143,
-0.0093599865,
-0.0510033965,
-0.0509199835,
0.0324840732,
-0.0109145893,
-0.0125259282,
0.0366280079,
-0.0265153646,
-0.0015831919,
0.0470247865,
-0.0420416296,
0.0341049619,
-0.0272075105,
-0.0685877651,
0.0575570539,
0.0212229956,
-0.007894027,
0.0742373988,
0.0721351877,
0.0769245625,
0.0506916121,
0.0438604914,
-0.0485681966,
0.0063177254,
-0.0331432857,
-0.034923438,
-0.011401074,
-0.0202605929,
0.0024488671,
0.0426486358,
0.0356616117,
0.0123334285,
-0.0565498695,
0.0017412718,
-0.0277719665,
-0.0501574278,
-0.0096078608,
-0.0048793834,
-0.0212712493,
-0.0368689857,
0.0144851226,
-0.0559579395,
0.1025740281,
-0.0186904594,
0.0035608055,
-0.0430151597,
-0.0367573611,
0.0323813036,
0.0195615944,
0.0026659537,
0.0048764064,
-0.0173969939,
-0.0089041544,
0.0050554117,
-0.0108179171,
0.0636767745,
-0.0522512086,
-0.0291110519,
0.0040796185,
0.003317453,
0.0196523406,
-0.0669655651,
-0.1005709171,
-0.0325160548,
-0.0415813029,
-0.020106554,
-0.0032735602,
-0.0336753838,
-0.035337802,
-0.0050170757,
0.035041105,
-0.0204458069,
-0.0152045768,
-0.0091528529,
0.001158052,
0.0053689233,
0.0458790362,
0.0210773796,
0.0004955496,
-0.036962878,
0.0116012339,
0.1082775667,
0.0325043276,
0.0007791802,
-0.0320932306,
-0.0634230301,
0.021535797,
0.0133323334,
0.0124122649,
0.0049220845,
0.0212097447,
-0.0162489135,
-0.0056676059,
0.0691412836,
0.0349588357,
-0.0041667749,
0.010803394,
0.016364878,
0.0310337003,
0.0023174363,
0.0175938662,
-0.0691112727,
-0.0127543109,
-0.0106428601,
0.0846311525,
-0.0758557692,
-0.0357520469,
0.0045506745,
-0.1003464237,
0.01737139,
-0.0425653942,
-0.0482675135,
-0.0325493664,
-0.0500940196,
0.0156376101,
-0.0006336253,
0.0492957793,
-0.0182754155,
0.0425408818,
0.0145504475,
0.049986586,
-0.0580266491,
0.0031142829,
0.0346305072,
-0.0511885993,
0.1036793366,
0.0584847853,
0.0328700207,
-0.0106443316,
-0.0354502201,
0.0293490123,
-0.0009671727,
-0.0003663005,
-0.0097686192,
0.1150602028,
-0.0128965918,
-0.02304863,
-0.032265123,
0.0035962334,
0.0108791152,
-0.0158108491,
0.0307179894,
0.0190590136,
-0.0274315923,
-0.0155212106,
-0.002551239,
0.0709393919,
0.0312186275,
0.0583289862,
0.0159720592,
-0.0687282383,
-0.0335001424,
-0.0563295893,
-0.0175834559,
-0.0471294485,
-0.0570193119,
0.0408500172,
-0.0307366438,
-0.0511582904,
-0.0741572231,
-0.0651010051,
0.0196627565,
0.0266040154,
-0.0139297117,
-0.0055851806,
-0.013426709,
0.0656752437,
-0.007990499,
-0.0016447132,
-0.0173793174,
0.0037274901,
-0.0313805453,
-0.0041371593,
0.0208623856,
-0.0487806126,
-0.0203970503,
-0.007523715,
-0.0336558111,
-0.0521544516,
0.0463986956,
0.076335147,
0.0085436096,
0.0239746552,
-0.0239201337,
-0.0552965887,
0.0769302696,
0.0757941455,
-0.0099196713,
-0.009221239,
0.049444098,
0.0159208365,
-0.0013008437,
0.0101770936,
-0.0237099063,
0.0156983119,
0.0594066791,
-0.0089224298,
-0.054266952,
-0.0428851061,
0.0110727828,
0.0429972596,
0.0113579566,
0.0125297317,
-0.0050345147,
-0.0003879852,
0.005675721,
-0.006441209,
-0.0425555483,
0.0180056877,
0.0193020049,
-0.0466121063,
-0.0101713128,
-0.0087747984,
0.0064070267,
-0.03920855,
0.0439714566,
-0.0077904928,
0.013895914,
0.049714718,
0.0404947884,
0.0016683993,
0.0065564136,
-0.0105041033,
0.0024461003,
0.0370949209,
0.0228925943,
0.0351835601,
0.0371088758,
0.0298379436,
0.0124786515,
0.0170639399,
0.0243062768,
-0.0405451283,
0.0001961608,
-0.0215989407,
0.0281415563,
-0.0153749594,
0.0447617657,
0.0356990211,
-0.0137937358,
0.0183321312,
-0.0168961287,
0.0147760855,
-0.0164961554,
-0.045151908,
0.0208179671,
0.0292637553,
-0.0080102123,
-0.0030055954,
0.0489161201,
-0.0295116343,
0.0410315171,
-0.0061632684,
-0.0584884658,
-0.0315213576,
0.0085470481,
0.0036389912,
0.010658077,
-0.0094792387,
-0.0003593219,
-0.032802403,
-0.0387205184,
-0.0279979147,
0.0405813493,
0.0277830716,
0.0168572553,
0.0043512573,
0.0386379845,
-0.0124239838,
0.0127437692,
-0.0516509935,
0.0113561219,
-0.0165198296,
-0.0250005648,
0.0330425203,
-5.779405403e-33,
-0.0175242033,
-0.0807183981,
0.0026001637,
0.0611965433,
-0.0001431772,
0.0004574819,
0.0113987848,
0.0204395596,
-0.0147178629,
0.0276590269,
0.0055945734,
0.0089405468,
-0.0001340743,
-0.011898594,
0.0094477208,
-0.0524153262,
0.0185210388,
-0.0374021903,
-0.0185317509,
0.052816648,
0.058333151,
-0.0167614743,
0.0203372389,
-0.118651785,
0.0572154745,
0.009576912,
-0.0162437521,
0.0144227426,
-0.0337363631,
0.0571529232,
-0.0003931818,
0.066603601,
0.02305777,
-0.0228028689,
0.0265344903,
0.0156661924,
-0.0221926421,
-0.0174217708,
-0.024749646,
0.0360939503,
-0.0205758717,
-0.0130271809,
0.0134079708,
-0.0197218563,
-0.01743179,
-0.0017972575,
0.0222501867,
0.0129025262,
0.0452387892,
-0.0649063513,
-0.0318069085,
-0.0045493385,
-0.0376093909,
-0.0591187514,
-0.0083272047,
0.0185395107,
0.0155630242,
0.008974757,
-0.0896578282,
0.0545749068,
-0.0750591084,
0.0039982824,
0.0084294602,
0.0175938588,
-0.0168525279,
0.0755413324,
0.01574759,
0.01471157,
-0.0155336102,
-0.0152600827,
0.0030214251,
0.0232667178,
0.0572822355,
0.0550042838,
0.0298198052,
-0.0621597432,
-0.0737789571,
0.032930214,
0.0687392429,
-0.013301936,
0.0109425699,
-0.027173616,
-0.0721051171,
0.0077952002,
0.0029632766,
-0.0183517467,
-0.022054771,
-0.0404574201,
0.0127696879,
0.0201031584,
-0.0242357384,
-0.0684052631,
0.009919066,
-0.041824393,
0.0048633548,
-0.050947886,
-0.0357867219,
-0.0089122374,
-0.0109885521,
-0.0272804145,
0.0135518434,
-0.0188166592,
0.0335003026,
-0.0765276104,
0.0483058691,
-0.0306469649,
0.0606134646,
0.0383505151,
-0.0588208772,
-0.0081402529,
-0.0092827948,
0.0607555881,
-0.0152792893,
0.0382695794,
0.0223994981,
0.0264084619,
-0.025101535,
0.0030749617,
0.0246970411,
0.0169446208,
-0.049041573,
0.0302523039,
-0.0211575124,
-0.033599034,
-0.0332432836,
-0.0033199105,
-0.0065159625,
-0.0078535201,
-0.0113406098,
-0.0695979372,
0.0012567829,
-0.0510412976,
2.647e-7,
-0.0172835477,
0.0547084659,
0.0193698853,
-0.0102639124,
0.0278523024,
0.0976015851,
0.0221600309,
0.039427083,
0.0264391918,
-0.0473867841,
0.0019991882,
0.0047083818,
0.0454801619,
0.061138723,
-0.0585325137,
-0.0574905202,
-0.023293715,
-0.0501345173,
-0.0098935198,
-0.0014032599,
0.0451878943,
0.0511659458,
0.0508489683,
-0.0381958336,
-0.0106386552,
-0.046855621,
0.0018571392,
0.0546047352,
-0.0400746576,
0.0130201112,
0.0733290315,
-0.0465174057,
0.0188541487,
0.0685055405,
0.0057886806,
-0.0084745204,
0.0125747966,
0.0424537845,
-0.0169776157,
-0.0388994701,
-0.0067031803,
0.0332874097,
0.0012288672,
-0.0144234877,
0.0458854921,
-0.0032180769,
-0.0206245985,
-0.029194722,
-0.0192557573,
0.0014445999,
0.0339497365,
-0.0020745927,
-0.0039694267,
0.0159931127,
0.0112155732,
0.0082942843,
0.0129878707,
-0.0454567894,
0.0305121597,
-0.0549679361,
-0.0428539105,
-0.0779486075,
0.0314118005,
-0.0056771417,
0.0224606879,
0.0127430903,
0.0149607752,
2.064678685e-34,
-0.0019914864,
-0.0155834435,
0.0194973946,
-0.0117807258,
0.0339266062,
0.046766229,
0.0419060178,
-0.0035268555,
0.0417577289,
-0.0071342471,
-0.0350606106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19268v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19268v3 | Moral Sparks in Social Media Narratives | 2023-10-30T05:03:26 | 2024-04-22T01:23:59 | Ruijie Xi, Munindar P. Singh | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY | There is increasing interest in building computational models of moral
reasoning by people to enable effective interaction by Artificial Intelligence
(AI) agents. We examine interactions on social media to understand human moral
judgments in real-life ethical scenarios. Specifically, we examine posts from a
popular Reddit subreddit (i.e., a subcommunity) called r/AmITheAsshole, where
authors and commenters share their moral judgments on who (i.e., which
participant of the described scenario) is blameworthy. To investigate the
underlying reasoning influencing moral judgments, we focus on excerpts-which we
term moral sparks-from original posts that some commenters include to indicate
what motivates their judgments. To this end, we examine how (1) events
activating social commonsense and (2) linguistic signals affect the identified
moral sparks and their subsequent judgments. By examining over 24672 posts and
175988 comments, we find that event-related negative character traits (e.g.,
immature and rude) attract attention and stimulate blame, implying a dependent
relationship between character traits and moral values. Specifically, we focus
on causal graphs involving events (c-events) that activate social commonsense.
We observe that c-events are perceived with varying levels of informativeness,
influencing moral spark and judgment assignment in distinct ways. This
observation is reinforced by examining linguistic features describing
semantically similar c-events. Moreover, language influencing commenters'
cognitive processes enhances the probability of an excerpt becoming a moral
spark, while factual and concrete descriptions tend to inhibit this effect. | [
0.0775028393,
0.0590966344,
-0.0137487333,
0.0033633865,
-0.0666591898,
0.0045955507,
0.0034192964,
0.0001967639,
0.0214705728,
-0.0541341715,
0.0120378248,
0.0165874772,
0.0077930298,
0.0018774266,
0.0115623903,
-0.0089315027,
-0.0058706789,
0.0407697782,
0.0819366127,
0.0016079369,
0.0476537272,
0.053082861,
0.0157187469,
0.0229612198,
-0.0372154787,
0.0061512981,
0.0377912745,
0.014640918,
0.0381127223,
-0.0401611552,
0.0211858395,
0.0646495223,
0.0084438268,
-0.0005053077,
0.0000017494,
-0.0388090126,
0.0438573621,
-0.0159813743,
0.0241998173,
0.0003383817,
0.0681613758,
-0.0111217573,
0.0329947062,
0.0019966715,
-0.0343603343,
0.0207308792,
0.0308874864,
0.0824969932,
0.0013747043,
0.0309145804,
-0.0190369263,
-0.0501164906,
-0.0274376813,
0.0255060587,
0.0196818952,
-0.0061559081,
0.0203615073,
0.0089918394,
-0.0201311484,
-0.0195332654,
0.0070557883,
-0.018092826,
-0.0238325037,
-0.0194236394,
0.0137590813,
0.0087569375,
0.0011114262,
-0.0106444303,
0.0055377902,
0.0387666784,
0.0640978813,
-0.0465547256,
0.0235805605,
0.0143717602,
0.0242492985,
0.0499703288,
-0.0320806354,
0.0435567647,
-0.039619498,
0.0078301411,
0.0370308049,
0.0091449022,
0.0168396626,
0.0783030838,
0.0861711577,
0.0016898818,
-0.0309822224,
-0.0067502107,
-0.0187468305,
-0.0002255518,
-0.0373444632,
-0.028491687,
0.0089890305,
0.02154967,
0.011720011,
0.0178523827,
-0.0049503557,
0.0341703147,
0.0346208513,
-0.0757285282,
-0.0074355095,
0.0104963789,
0.0196534581,
0.0404907614,
0.0257282946,
-0.0141562149,
0.0061140982,
0.0203940161,
-0.0021424086,
0.0229325462,
-0.0181388538,
0.0327138491,
0.010435774,
0.0084718969,
0.0276228357,
0.0375870466,
-0.0003245024,
-0.0238078032,
-0.0515458435,
-0.0366977789,
-0.035207063,
0.0213058945,
-0.0018926531,
-0.0055444902,
-0.0402991287,
-0.0084342891,
-0.0743495822,
0.0245031267,
-0.0245925821,
0.0074855662,
0.0156478081,
-0.0293674916,
0.05855285,
0.0190224443,
0.0070115691,
0.074458763,
0.0298224185,
-0.0142642483,
-0.060045965,
-0.0310518369,
0.0124397874,
0.0073379003,
-0.0388309695,
-0.0288796853,
0.0176217724,
0.0363941453,
-0.0274786893,
-0.0103656659,
0.0380242243,
0.0448326692,
-0.0697016492,
0.0423298627,
-0.0210946482,
0.0120721441,
0.0031571928,
0.0275321733,
-0.0123221138,
0.0314411558,
0.0088930391,
0.0255895536,
0.0480082482,
0.0255510267,
0.0132450592,
-0.0367782488,
0.0089405039,
-0.0021879417,
0.0036184764,
-0.0065992097,
-0.0373776257,
-0.0156596564,
0.0142896352,
0.0170710199,
-0.0260552522,
0.0092132613,
0.0518395342,
0.1386454552,
-0.0627231747,
0.0618598238,
0.0220210776,
0.0094588641,
-0.0019855886,
-0.0025685192,
-0.031954132,
0.0113811037,
0.0101895556,
-0.0628579482,
-0.036864195,
0.0239967816,
-0.0164338369,
-0.0000326403,
-0.0207387265,
-0.011297009,
0.0546324886,
-0.0306859668,
-0.0240577254,
0.0155698815,
-0.0122636706,
-0.0354684889,
0.084331274,
-0.0417919904,
-0.002561145,
-0.0298413523,
0.0406521112,
0.0798492655,
0.043476183,
0.0259805806,
-0.0134843737,
-0.0285040382,
0.0265269745,
0.0373075791,
0.0144433249,
-0.0138951037,
-0.0607645139,
-0.0313568562,
-0.0157919452,
0.0022870707,
0.0053495835,
0.0162521861,
-0.0065608397,
-0.0246216357,
-0.0161855947,
0.0375703126,
-0.027789548,
0.0197367333,
0.0273967851,
0.0384540744,
-0.082943283,
0.0217287801,
0.0309463311,
-0.0122554684,
0.0169361699,
-0.027739767,
-0.0048267301,
0.0195060782,
-0.0432284251,
0.0479982905,
-0.0041092685,
0.0303174164,
0.0088192932,
-0.0992805064,
-0.0418472923,
-0.0156390313,
0.0324091539,
0.0380038507,
0.0251147989,
-0.0405267663,
0.0120339496,
-0.0023543653,
-0.0512085631,
-0.0764288008,
-0.0277881064,
0.0113818934,
0.1069833487,
-0.0199734941,
0.0271382481,
-0.0273832753,
-0.0457170233,
0.0060181296,
0.0373687595,
0.0145890974,
-0.0603038482,
-0.0030652473,
0.0115464982,
0.0326653421,
-0.0133598642,
-0.0305627827,
-0.0034306806,
-0.0847389773,
-0.0343542881,
0.0002226103,
-0.0157619715,
0.0120391268,
-0.0362553038,
0.0075644376,
0.0407932289,
-0.0205152482,
-0.010364119,
-0.0172810592,
-0.0000247029,
0.0179022625,
-0.0213546809,
-0.0048539401,
-0.0295939855,
0.0250712521,
-0.0536570065,
0.0229652412,
0.0858004615,
-0.0236000884,
-0.0087951077,
0.0453300588,
-0.0937804282,
0.0086248731,
-0.0182861369,
-0.0540952273,
-0.0042827632,
0.0263520926,
0.0005829744,
0.036505837,
0.0748893619,
0.050745137,
-0.0206527095,
0.0480298959,
-0.0307746604,
-0.032071095,
-0.0374867246,
0.0467083119,
-0.0413183942,
-0.0709267855,
-0.0246413574,
0.0428976901,
0.0193444956,
0.0210603289,
-0.0602718852,
0.032804057,
-0.0533250384,
-0.0389064513,
0.0227325503,
-0.0844960213,
0.0244297199,
0.0380253531,
-0.0468101613,
-0.0567503273,
0.0598287471,
0.0352542996,
0.0474976338,
0.027468428,
-0.0167299937,
-0.0052089607,
0.0419269539,
0.0289600771,
0.026316952,
-0.0206235964,
-0.0170301348,
0.005659427,
-0.0331566185,
0.0611746125,
-0.0213341527,
0.0307949297,
-0.0065986146,
0.025080204,
0.032724116,
-0.0563425049,
-0.0157005284,
-0.1176602244,
-0.0389643572,
-0.0705851316,
0.0145436805,
-0.0173903722,
0.0508908294,
0.0090720402,
0.0252563562,
-0.0353848562,
-0.0263661854,
-0.0172955208,
0.0217466522,
-0.0470164753,
0.0166188367,
-0.0180357769,
0.0572973415,
-0.0076436349,
-0.0076341247,
0.0373112746,
0.0110229086,
-0.0297520757,
0.0099972803,
-0.0005800255,
-0.0121395187,
0.0140797384,
0.0213012248,
-0.0134725943,
0.0566439182,
-0.0067874459,
0.0038125808,
0.0568438284,
0.0178948622,
-0.032341525,
0.0126446867,
-0.0103824344,
-0.0383006744,
0.0305525996,
-0.0144141149,
-0.0661058128,
-0.0052476358,
-0.0492530689,
-0.0177039988,
-0.0783073604,
-0.0739618093,
0.0033649104,
-0.0636655837,
0.0235121809,
-0.0097367037,
0.0071613537,
-0.0428126752,
-0.0217239931,
0.0105245337,
0.001347642,
-0.0113158952,
-0.0070264102,
0.0134367133,
0.0029871562,
-0.0081409803,
0.0172100291,
0.0395591334,
0.0342083424,
-0.0456777923,
0.0543838255,
0.0168360285,
0.0877009109,
-0.0206104293,
-0.0200786162,
-0.0008837598,
0.0247064419,
0.0080078561,
-0.009075406,
0.0383956805,
-0.0281840675,
0.0003253316,
-0.0813942254,
0.0502985753,
0.0073677185,
-0.0596295856,
-0.0246775653,
0.0675869137,
0.0080272919,
-0.060477078,
-0.0011137194,
0.0227507763,
0.0084112333,
0.0429403894,
0.0173967443,
-0.0110943345,
0.0054073716,
-0.0247236975,
-0.0022702848,
-0.0554310158,
-0.0694326386,
-0.0348220356,
0.0268660281,
-0.0410729051,
-0.0411832891,
-0.0440199338,
-0.047508385,
-0.0303583797,
0.0448238291,
-0.048476398,
0.0329079404,
-0.000037948,
-0.0329808071,
0.0321002789,
-0.0339692309,
-0.0305378921,
0.0536256172,
0.0210395195,
0.0120525705,
-0.0298953652,
-0.0038863383,
0.0017866938,
0.0016846114,
-0.0116675347,
0.0275373682,
-0.0031155406,
0.0087906318,
0.0368378013,
-0.0241640825,
-0.009547336,
-0.0029661665,
0.0353985988,
-0.0641421378,
0.040018592,
0.0032495984,
0.037359044,
0.0107020484,
0.0157921631,
0.0022096878,
0.0281634014,
0.0217057541,
-0.0315616019,
-0.0604230277,
-0.0123047503,
0.0003441327,
-0.0190755296,
0.0123615554,
0.0167173352,
-0.0072185053,
-0.0476678945,
-0.0718472674,
-0.0050876415,
-0.0238818247,
-0.0039016884,
-0.0071709561,
0.0034130106,
0.0038321773,
-0.0531797297,
-0.0167284533,
-0.0830705166,
0.0435912386,
-0.0430350006,
-0.0103801424,
0.0256927405,
0.0287807379,
-0.0316380188,
-0.0261751916,
-0.0174293425,
0.0164537169,
0.0091735004,
0.002720267,
-0.0193841886,
0.0711232722,
0.030214427,
-0.0193371084,
0.0198149551,
-0.0232569836,
-0.0791684836,
0.0111478986,
0.0232430585,
0.0041769529,
0.0115247834,
0.0101524079,
0.0108908191,
0.0010180797,
-0.0064427587,
0.0306516606,
0.0541088954,
-0.015582935,
-0.0435034707,
0.0093747387,
0.0298798103,
-0.0271168761,
0.0435849056,
0.0107561583,
-0.0872364491,
0.0302166957,
0.0268691629,
-0.0777221695,
0.0284593236,
-0.0379098877,
0.0339237675,
-0.008078469,
0.0201921239,
0.0149899591,
-0.0891818702,
-0.0090116384,
0.0017157021,
-0.002958521,
0.0343848132,
-0.0476964898,
-0.0278308447,
0.0552384518,
-0.0044423919,
0.0096055074,
-0.0087273708,
0.0451556817,
-0.0525274128,
0.0114942575,
-0.0524482727,
-5.664170957e-33,
0.0068041594,
-0.0742461234,
-0.039299991,
0.0654067844,
-0.016565524,
-0.0071137627,
-0.0105732931,
0.0026300743,
-0.0176928081,
0.0734417439,
-0.0048783836,
0.0537567474,
0.0004091478,
-0.0455412231,
0.0048802057,
-0.0648867339,
-0.013036401,
0.0007782581,
-0.0017457218,
0.0297684912,
0.0010705538,
-0.0061061401,
0.0178563893,
-0.0821336359,
0.0461261682,
-0.0180215985,
-0.010509301,
0.0023345512,
0.0304050837,
-0.0013513942,
0.0151782287,
0.0579843074,
0.0499682985,
0.0070917336,
0.0224194862,
0.0775520355,
-0.0334779695,
-0.018329842,
0.0710662007,
-0.0303164981,
-0.0428799391,
-0.03379336,
0.0189294647,
-0.0072867894,
-0.0532920733,
-0.0041874414,
0.0886232108,
0.017611919,
0.0534591526,
-0.0389234796,
-0.0508226715,
-0.0111614848,
-0.0290235355,
-0.0104836086,
-0.0783779398,
0.0224162955,
-0.0007483584,
0.0389488041,
-0.0050260262,
0.039521277,
-0.0678116828,
-0.020259589,
-0.0333928391,
-0.0279472992,
0.0300988685,
0.0936385319,
0.009357309,
0.0793997794,
-0.0625743493,
0.0361764021,
-0.0122524919,
0.0335137397,
0.0664405674,
0.0885188058,
-0.008234214,
-0.0959086791,
-0.0902990401,
-0.0312888809,
0.0458840616,
-0.0150489472,
0.0339925252,
-0.0232391339,
-0.0445926934,
-0.0183253903,
-0.0233146194,
-0.0655490309,
-0.0355869085,
-0.0049178833,
-0.0405737385,
-0.0395498276,
-0.0288306661,
0.0176241007,
-0.0163135957,
-0.0370125137,
0.0074546048,
0.0461076014,
0.0046485653,
0.0051669893,
0.0022998042,
0.0272979327,
-0.0150094107,
-0.0055773007,
-0.0085971057,
0.0012930695,
0.0622808523,
0.0037059635,
0.0495922789,
0.0047355755,
0.0173533615,
-0.0236788355,
-0.036477834,
0.0048138471,
-0.0316114537,
-0.0454884022,
0.0257990342,
0.0796102434,
0.0147751411,
-0.0351360962,
0.0734484792,
0.0538757294,
-0.0143074812,
-0.0325994454,
-0.0542449802,
0.0117891757,
-0.0352500603,
0.0106683131,
-0.0356514752,
0.0161474217,
-0.0001994832,
-0.0583087802,
-0.0216213092,
0.0216745455,
2.518e-7,
0.02164701,
0.0407467075,
0.0161107834,
0.012909824,
0.0055719996,
0.0644152611,
0.0639875382,
0.0360574238,
0.0688297004,
-0.0675875768,
-0.0095837396,
0.0409127213,
0.0216167718,
0.0248783212,
-0.0344456658,
-0.0175906867,
-0.0223426912,
-0.0387994163,
-0.0186807346,
0.014994232,
0.038900055,
0.0090208743,
0.0408451147,
-0.0213400219,
-0.0244728122,
-0.0272972006,
0.0317477137,
-0.0496582985,
-0.0599842854,
0.0007257219,
-0.0602093898,
-0.0254257489,
-0.0242835023,
0.0579371192,
0.0044294996,
-0.0147014624,
0.023354793,
0.0086696083,
0.0018756279,
-0.0229349565,
0.007512663,
-0.0426330827,
0.0055076987,
0.0096267881,
0.0494404659,
-0.0254537947,
-0.028930176,
-0.0333728455,
0.0219857376,
-0.022287149,
-0.0122403111,
0.0073271012,
-0.0310381595,
-0.003778267,
0.009628539,
0.0211643018,
0.0033520355,
-0.044975765,
-0.0036773244,
-0.001494056,
-0.0002644609,
-0.079208076,
0.0280775186,
0.0263271276,
0.0494506732,
-0.0127305575,
0.0445980802,
1.939283973e-34,
-0.0047847,
-0.0289712623,
0.006420793,
-0.0242527481,
0.0553869046,
0.0451030843,
-0.02732048,
-0.0105484156,
0.0457284823,
-0.0030133422,
-0.0097842552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19267v1 | Overview of the CLAIMSCAN-2023: Uncovering Truth in Social Media through Claim Detection and Identification of Claim Spans | 2023-10-30T04:57:41 | 2023-10-30T04:57:41 | Megha Sundriyal, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | A significant increase in content creation and information exchange has been
made possible by the quick development of online social media platforms, which
has been very advantageous. However, these platforms have also become a haven
for those who disseminate false information, propaganda, and fake news. Claims
are essential in forming our perceptions of the world, but sadly, they are
frequently used to trick people by those who spread false information. To
address this problem, social media giants employ content moderators to filter
out fake news from the actual world. However, the sheer volume of information
makes it difficult to identify fake news effectively. Therefore, it has become
crucial to automatically identify social media posts that make such claims,
check their veracity, and differentiate between credible and false claims. In
response, we presented CLAIMSCAN in the 2023 Forum for Information Retrieval
Evaluation (FIRE'2023). The primary objectives centered on two crucial tasks:
Task A, determining whether a social media post constitutes a claim, and Task
B, precisely identifying the words or phrases within the post that form the
claim. Task A received 40 registrations, demonstrating a strong interest and
engagement in this timely challenge. Meanwhile, Task B attracted participation
from 28 teams, highlighting its significance in the digital era of
misinformation. | [
0.0884118751,
0.0560545698,
-0.0060053491,
0.0123836705,
-0.0494711138,
-0.0000738256,
-0.0172812939,
0.0041771103,
0.0272818282,
-0.0255197026,
0.035712298,
-0.0046195993,
0.0212294664,
0.0196128022,
0.0041762143,
-0.0229101498,
0.0391976535,
0.0625371784,
0.0636081472,
-0.0032966235,
0.0132650482,
0.0469892919,
-0.0474595465,
0.0248090941,
-0.082612589,
-0.0123194084,
0.0748272091,
-0.0003789399,
0.0246363226,
-0.0564428084,
0.0331991576,
0.0585949346,
-0.0149701666,
0.0982228369,
0.0000018519,
-0.0485004373,
-0.0109220715,
0.0144448802,
-0.0335440636,
0.0051687383,
0.0615768358,
0.0086378353,
0.0044541629,
0.0292210169,
-0.0078616925,
-0.0029853801,
0.044894781,
0.0526437238,
0.0442891233,
0.0908030048,
-0.0229103975,
-0.0115900226,
0.002333899,
0.0060263807,
-0.0113458121,
-0.0270559527,
0.0175288226,
-0.0103649097,
-0.0052588638,
-0.0153527549,
0.0407423116,
0.0346825682,
-0.0055064759,
-0.0267315581,
-0.0362626277,
0.0230963882,
-0.0572929271,
-0.0423657298,
0.0181323923,
-0.0070131575,
0.0219397712,
-0.0682075471,
0.0328082703,
0.0011536879,
0.0101659968,
0.0546372123,
0.0025392724,
0.0689696521,
-0.0269889217,
0.0122092851,
0.0008117295,
0.0579782538,
0.0163931288,
0.0574364848,
0.0198059846,
0.0331114046,
-0.0125602121,
-0.0506734885,
0.0174601525,
0.0009560579,
0.0528014563,
-0.044471696,
0.031834852,
-0.0078012431,
-0.0047126343,
-0.0015708406,
-0.0156394094,
-0.065713726,
0.0726672933,
-0.1154884323,
-0.0173391849,
-0.0049247355,
-0.0468173884,
0.0564084426,
-0.0358994827,
0.0101752207,
0.0050649084,
-0.0209269803,
0.0147318039,
-0.0138981035,
-0.0200668871,
-0.0136006894,
-0.0072638332,
0.0122147342,
-0.0241876878,
0.0014460447,
-0.0384779498,
-0.0373781659,
-0.0144279925,
0.0080265943,
0.0075690472,
0.0311256908,
-0.0076222224,
-0.0162176862,
-0.0236399863,
0.0396102518,
0.0052280524,
0.0029253054,
-0.0259715617,
-0.0431925207,
-0.0097764349,
0.0603741296,
0.0345875025,
-0.0203756467,
-0.0018042313,
-0.0430526957,
-0.0205455348,
-0.0435362235,
-0.026173804,
-0.0403160118,
-0.0260117929,
-0.0457377806,
0.0022148925,
-0.0358438194,
0.0117733125,
-0.0267138928,
0.0008493681,
0.0197283886,
0.0108828414,
0.059917897,
-0.0316677727,
-0.00201148,
-0.0047241752,
-0.0052244891,
0.068264842,
0.0333552286,
0.0263629593,
0.0363178812,
-0.0018074845,
0.1145682856,
0.078154996,
0.0453798622,
0.0147459591,
0.0067844917,
0.0432048328,
-0.0147232953,
0.072537519,
-0.0046404959,
-0.0145503143,
-0.0195262507,
-0.0307828356,
0.018968666,
0.0078179007,
-0.0122269392,
0.0659746677,
0.0411743484,
-0.0155944927,
-0.0321251377,
0.0163758174,
0.0078588612,
0.0518098697,
-0.0401759446,
-0.0266584475,
-0.0226892103,
-0.0686976016,
-0.0615012348,
0.0708572045,
0.0478335284,
0.0349383205,
-0.0452409387,
-0.0093499981,
0.0276403241,
0.0079057943,
-0.0299224667,
-0.00928286,
0.0159954634,
-0.031756036,
-0.0001627449,
0.0135774799,
-0.0203775391,
-0.0139557756,
-0.0408805646,
0.0277762357,
-0.0390839763,
0.0175870527,
-0.0008533751,
0.0264175069,
0.0074771242,
0.0550819486,
0.078794606,
0.0635729879,
0.0071252934,
-0.0260736942,
0.0297629461,
-0.0221865661,
-0.0081112236,
0.0201882049,
-0.0497028232,
0.0624045469,
0.0338850245,
0.0335728638,
-0.0218309443,
-0.0694186687,
0.0206099655,
0.0376562886,
0.007696616,
-0.0144016854,
0.0172465872,
0.0156596284,
0.0283309929,
0.0070181647,
-0.0249092299,
0.0243348088,
-0.0033222055,
-0.0591795705,
0.0062045874,
0.0430189297,
0.0114812497,
0.0086861337,
-0.0742827281,
-0.0369500332,
0.0476873182,
-0.0171286557,
-0.0020313547,
0.0401632152,
-0.0349562541,
-0.0349377431,
-0.030964531,
-0.0416435823,
-0.0320544653,
0.0315638818,
0.010466828,
0.1102667972,
-0.0102306046,
0.0019664865,
-0.0158983916,
-0.0527005717,
0.0051670587,
0.0158680435,
0.0105200177,
-0.0061157909,
-0.0238159951,
-0.0042924243,
0.040952418,
-0.0446625426,
-0.0288146008,
0.0309834685,
-0.0740930289,
-0.0039132484,
-0.0411827676,
0.0079448204,
0.0033906824,
-0.0154502895,
-0.0105257276,
0.0286427476,
-0.015353322,
-0.0473785065,
0.0343355462,
0.0087849395,
0.0189762078,
-0.0346080698,
0.0124215735,
-0.0045891125,
0.0317109525,
-0.0112591935,
0.0185840745,
0.0490709133,
-0.0871422887,
0.0028194033,
-0.0093307225,
-0.045744177,
-0.0172427427,
-0.0335152745,
0.0201488975,
-0.0075760689,
0.0153040523,
-0.0407439917,
-0.012899546,
0.0673464239,
0.0549631007,
-0.0114416452,
0.0733218193,
0.0026388092,
-0.0187618155,
-0.0250443965,
0.0241634436,
0.0119390972,
-0.0548643991,
0.0696413964,
0.0179996267,
0.039668899,
0.0188023709,
-0.034016341,
-0.0257344358,
-0.0429982655,
-0.045036491,
0.0563220717,
-0.0054771113,
-0.0020452661,
0.0316017382,
-0.0272792876,
-0.034949284,
0.0525842644,
-0.0197999794,
0.0489970893,
-0.0251211971,
-0.0490136556,
0.0043197344,
0.0125311958,
0.0146061797,
0.0239095762,
0.0215265155,
0.0030585786,
0.0685738698,
-0.0339199528,
0.0603501201,
-0.0334380902,
-0.0405956395,
0.0030989987,
0.0459565148,
0.0087587163,
-0.0104961293,
-0.0264380798,
-0.1021692008,
0.0145299099,
-0.0259999782,
-0.0609892234,
-0.0156388711,
-0.0992758572,
-0.0361372419,
0.0161909182,
0.0365571082,
-0.0067921188,
-0.0120353485,
0.026773788,
0.0355540775,
-0.0046601552,
0.0048338417,
0.0296490137,
-0.0184363201,
-0.0785051361,
0.0800555348,
-0.0547793806,
0.0443199798,
0.0158555619,
-0.0625647008,
-0.0067225057,
-0.0304764938,
0.0064107538,
-0.0342807993,
0.0446675532,
-0.0239017978,
0.0206054766,
0.043853227,
0.0249883793,
0.0461624414,
0.0240273476,
0.0235424563,
-0.0316560231,
0.0149036655,
-0.0081269806,
-0.1109136119,
0.0280569028,
-0.0220030751,
-0.0150286183,
-0.0649103522,
-0.008178561,
-0.0165021289,
-0.0635051504,
0.0533163734,
-0.0212442409,
0.0341971442,
-0.0408275016,
-0.0449953638,
0.0034903912,
-0.0062611224,
-0.0171752106,
-0.025808271,
0.0285909735,
-0.013129049,
0.0098940497,
-0.0304425247,
-0.0133655146,
-0.0057751131,
-0.0018149654,
0.0057104877,
0.0049312087,
0.0375976749,
-0.0114363171,
-0.0613287166,
-0.0185954347,
-0.0067490726,
-0.0444612093,
-0.0190697853,
0.0728559867,
-0.0036425949,
0.0103628458,
-0.0017945905,
0.0123588117,
-0.0025768762,
-0.0388114043,
-0.000879154,
0.0618589558,
-0.0070021544,
-0.0685901418,
-0.0208451375,
0.0308387633,
0.0332086831,
0.0445902646,
-0.0065039066,
0.0627915114,
-0.024825478,
-0.0251457207,
0.0117051424,
-0.0616724677,
-0.0455593765,
0.0394341983,
0.0392630473,
-0.0262774862,
-0.0629387721,
0.0111897523,
-0.0133856544,
0.0092445286,
-0.0439135842,
-0.026726963,
-0.006519712,
0.0167217832,
-0.0688626319,
0.0293796845,
-0.0370037034,
0.0464240946,
-0.0184099488,
0.0090228356,
0.0046257325,
0.0124444505,
-0.014134082,
0.0358738229,
-0.0527131222,
-0.0350933783,
-0.0226566456,
-0.0340334177,
0.0098088523,
0.0147372,
-0.0362151824,
-0.0341976024,
0.0717277378,
0.0540601835,
-0.0123314979,
-0.001821361,
0.0211288575,
-0.0252364688,
-0.0144670671,
0.0006265648,
0.0200001318,
0.0420075282,
-0.0028868644,
-0.0019825536,
-0.000715093,
-0.0098026954,
0.042368032,
0.0411911346,
0.0362446904,
-0.0161369499,
-0.0361572318,
-0.0421265662,
-0.046357315,
-0.0110864816,
-0.0525134131,
-0.0027152214,
0.0295435824,
0.0130970906,
0.0184877291,
-0.0000477532,
0.0060611065,
-0.0303711053,
0.011366765,
-0.0782471597,
-0.0195665602,
-0.0241838843,
0.053867992,
-0.0183641948,
-0.0225056186,
-0.0177207254,
0.01342614,
0.01541573,
0.0676187873,
-0.0214934312,
-0.0128152147,
0.0223508347,
0.0043460145,
0.013709412,
-0.0247564018,
-0.0338738374,
-0.0053891819,
-0.0369433016,
0.0268753842,
0.0212106835,
-0.0112383896,
0.0128144799,
-0.0093646673,
-0.0100465538,
0.0263546053,
-0.0358041711,
-0.0206309222,
-0.0454802588,
-0.0222635306,
0.0090656839,
-0.0319379345,
0.0445843972,
0.035602279,
-0.0032122962,
0.0370302275,
0.0156825688,
-0.0642812923,
-0.0142517071,
-0.0778218433,
-0.0326478668,
0.0482291244,
-0.0006068093,
-0.0016078664,
-0.0497421771,
-0.0127709731,
0.0376425348,
0.0113347871,
0.0468576699,
0.0513049848,
-0.0152259665,
0.0804718062,
0.0302784853,
-0.0284515452,
-0.0454735979,
0.0004747103,
0.0248159934,
-0.0027065717,
0.0108607905,
-6.644445084e-33,
0.0288490336,
-0.0721242055,
-0.014050656,
0.0142792938,
-0.0221149232,
0.0269413013,
-0.018885415,
-0.0518153831,
-0.0169454794,
0.0524055809,
0.0157431457,
0.0486116894,
0.0126979714,
0.0194809139,
-0.0292498078,
0.0104316445,
0.0364017077,
0.0241450593,
-0.0633189902,
0.0152696911,
0.0569854304,
-0.0133802211,
0.0199530851,
-0.0846961215,
0.0581475459,
0.0322113559,
-0.0280137789,
0.004418835,
-0.011752015,
0.0392907634,
-0.0148836663,
0.0361801125,
0.0393939093,
-0.0109020416,
0.0429992564,
0.0165997893,
-0.0722206756,
-0.0175290778,
0.0410104468,
-0.022404287,
-0.0404079109,
0.0156033002,
0.0125097362,
-0.0101546701,
-0.0377996564,
0.0046417145,
0.0419583917,
-0.0091529116,
0.0139100971,
-0.0499709807,
-0.0805054754,
0.0439979546,
-0.0018600766,
0.0295059104,
-0.0072958935,
0.0636248812,
0.0222930238,
0.0601482801,
-0.0903268307,
0.0366180092,
-0.1151832268,
0.0049514007,
0.0045421692,
-0.0467588976,
-0.0416681468,
0.0363296978,
-0.0286193918,
0.0219651964,
-0.0142843248,
0.0318891704,
-0.0405456051,
0.0159462988,
0.068501763,
0.073498413,
0.0159158465,
-0.0526195429,
-0.0698486269,
0.0058383145,
0.0467992909,
-0.0184412487,
-0.0143530462,
-0.0588243753,
-0.0360863991,
-0.0025763081,
-0.0020379429,
-0.0198853146,
-0.0299894214,
0.0511647016,
-0.0201470945,
0.0620442964,
-0.0432968102,
0.0734807104,
-0.0171102993,
-0.0382146835,
0.0410850421,
0.006879759,
0.0261310507,
0.0016505088,
0.0120556485,
0.0430193394,
-0.0273008943,
0.0199954156,
0.0076172422,
0.0264499262,
0.0308899283,
-0.045427449,
0.045008406,
-0.0148078334,
-0.0364772044,
0.0118589532,
-0.0117317429,
0.0441237576,
-0.0348000638,
-0.0175634921,
0.0192195382,
0.0226679016,
-0.0014409686,
-0.0256491806,
0.005450252,
0.0210467614,
-0.0256657228,
-0.0304298401,
-0.0256495699,
-0.0187126771,
-0.0271928534,
-0.0200858545,
-0.028699521,
0.0063096406,
0.0179232173,
-0.1014407575,
0.0285027474,
-0.0119631486,
2.768e-7,
0.0108403247,
0.0536480695,
-0.0075814356,
-0.0133542325,
0.0062027536,
0.0082672518,
0.0433318131,
0.0076213917,
-0.0107782856,
-0.075358063,
-0.0237894692,
0.0167942904,
0.0527153946,
0.0170228742,
-0.0499120206,
-0.0177747663,
-0.0303629339,
-0.0480724983,
-0.0605136789,
0.0140431598,
0.0216008872,
0.0094632776,
0.016568942,
-0.0275976956,
-0.0359261781,
-0.0268888194,
0.0119810784,
0.0533537306,
-0.0359914899,
0.010259795,
0.0742184743,
-0.0353232697,
0.0206127893,
-0.0032953271,
-0.0574573129,
0.0391253829,
-0.0025056812,
0.041894991,
0.0482659787,
0.01459831,
-0.0414797738,
-0.0309368595,
0.0286171865,
-0.0418543331,
0.0387242101,
-0.0083194813,
-0.0368333831,
-0.0614760257,
-0.0363252424,
0.0469469056,
0.0449943841,
0.0114238532,
-0.0394710861,
0.0383446626,
0.002696424,
0.0308878664,
-0.0106536783,
-0.0631133094,
0.0317218266,
-0.0017088983,
-0.0560452752,
0.0104632461,
0.0245806687,
-0.0103556179,
0.0335285589,
-0.0221228674,
0.0311012752,
2.236057037e-34,
0.0004080787,
-0.0102777909,
0.0134727489,
-0.0831391215,
0.0299300384,
0.0389257297,
-0.0310618412,
-0.0128002949,
0.000316896,
-0.030810982,
0.0300479624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19240v1 | M4LE: A Multi-Ability Multi-Range Multi-Task Multi-Domain Long-Context Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2023-10-30T03:11:30 | 2023-10-30T03:11:30 | Wai-Chung Kwan, Xingshan Zeng, Yufei Wang, Yusen Sun, Liangyou Li, Lifeng Shang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Managing long sequences has become an important and necessary feature for
large language models (LLMs). However, it is still an open question of how to
comprehensively and systematically evaluate the long-sequence capability of
LLMs. One of the reasons is that conventional and widely-used benchmarks mainly
consist of short sequences. In this paper, we propose M4LE, a Multi-ability,
Multi-range, Multi-task, Multi-domain benchmark for Long-context Evaluation.
M4LE is based on a diverse NLP task pool comprising 36 NLP datasets, 11 task
types and 12 domains. To alleviate the scarcity of tasks with naturally long
sequences and incorporate multiple-ability assessment, we propose an automatic
approach (but with negligible human annotations) to convert short-sequence
tasks into a unified long-sequence scenario where LLMs have to identify single
or multiple relevant spans in long contexts based on explicit or semantic
hints. Specifically, the scenario includes five different types of abilities:
(1) explicit single-span; (2) semantic single-span; (3) explicit multiple-span;
(4) semantic multiple-span; and (5) global context understanding. The resulting
samples in M4LE are evenly distributed from 1k to 8k input length. We conducted
a systematic evaluation on 11 well-established LLMs, especially those optimized
for long-sequence inputs. Our results reveal that: 1) Current LLMs struggle to
understand long context, particularly when tasks require multiple-span
attention. 2) Semantic retrieval task is more difficult for competent LLMs. 3)
Models fine-tuned on longer text with position interpolation have comparable
performance to those using Neural Tangent Kernel (NTK) aware scaling methods
without fine-tuning. We make our benchmark publicly available to encourage
future research in this challenging area. | [
-0.0064184675,
0.0205302332,
-0.0020725718,
0.0629170164,
-0.0464791581,
-0.0110323308,
0.0378599912,
-0.0315072797,
-0.0223996341,
-0.0578151979,
-0.0399256162,
-0.0844832212,
0.0235973224,
-0.0052839918,
0.0408694781,
-0.0466752686,
0.0081034275,
-0.0297301132,
0.0030846589,
0.0306749512,
-0.0090902708,
0.001293493,
0.0077663809,
0.071419023,
0.0029672068,
-0.0371159874,
0.0019030569,
-0.0140016973,
0.0097396933,
-0.0536477901,
0.0290875789,
0.0699562579,
0.0237985328,
0.0127704516,
0.0000019406,
-0.0417377912,
-0.0106122661,
-0.0131648947,
-0.0166868865,
0.0253729057,
0.022009775,
-0.0009582363,
0.0363613479,
0.0001980781,
-0.0424613692,
0.0014072063,
-0.0065050614,
0.0461417213,
0.0321481973,
0.0752849281,
0.0027260426,
-0.0491572507,
0.0211401973,
-0.0725496411,
0.0014276475,
-0.0991812944,
0.0498438887,
-0.010928059,
0.0397520661,
0.0458338484,
-0.0238558222,
0.0360250659,
0.0306609925,
0.0067672073,
-0.0110467859,
0.025610283,
-0.015104467,
-0.0145942913,
0.0102661662,
0.0878310204,
-0.0409291871,
-0.003627982,
0.0092066163,
0.0159782078,
0.0258621331,
-0.0391329937,
-0.0390869044,
0.019045068,
0.0090776179,
0.0084260795,
0.0093411366,
0.0214541554,
0.0389117263,
0.0267647598,
-0.0441270322,
0.0395450257,
0.0058949785,
-0.0285746027,
-0.0093084192,
0.0005947762,
-0.0615887716,
-0.050740242,
0.0226009022,
0.0274031889,
-0.0483788252,
0.018187644,
-0.0438894443,
-0.0460761674,
0.0199914332,
-0.0301851667,
0.0143160792,
0.0345554128,
-0.0409613661,
0.0539156608,
-0.0397557914,
0.0573072396,
-0.020169789,
0.0055140778,
-0.0355353542,
-0.010754874,
-0.0430545546,
0.0195047967,
-0.003765794,
-0.0007669942,
-0.057344567,
-0.0293736439,
-0.0305533893,
0.0049126185,
-0.0116870496,
-0.0062177842,
0.0252984371,
0.0093956385,
-0.0131012714,
0.0141393272,
0.0004625045,
0.0401108898,
-0.0383711569,
0.0199866537,
0.0302487742,
-0.0212179609,
-0.0247676875,
0.0308951065,
0.0104584815,
-0.0485768616,
0.0103672408,
0.0722135901,
0.0083786026,
-0.0678696558,
-0.0366471633,
-0.0281089842,
-0.0635023564,
-0.0780640319,
-0.0019908436,
-0.0728267729,
0.020485552,
-0.0024108051,
-0.0012901736,
-0.0323810168,
0.0061020972,
0.0235319603,
-0.0015034026,
0.062189132,
0.0562950149,
0.0047770236,
-0.0017776281,
0.0328850523,
0.0226598606,
0.0806189254,
0.0093758525,
0.0018440051,
0.035420794,
0.0033435419,
-0.0219674334,
0.0234607663,
0.023621656,
-0.0012100716,
-0.0017672342,
0.0094471695,
0.0182106532,
0.0515951514,
0.0373321772,
0.0396867022,
-0.0123749264,
-0.0544628613,
0.0376637839,
0.0387948826,
0.031314306,
-0.0192226116,
0.0688904449,
0.0031387124,
-0.0232113115,
0.0167139396,
-0.0437798128,
0.0173347313,
0.0164182186,
0.0321475528,
0.0697595477,
0.0337785892,
-0.0296638794,
-0.0131622059,
-0.0397705697,
-0.0002870986,
0.0113775115,
0.0234079752,
0.0396636948,
0.0043572588,
-0.0499225333,
0.0570189059,
0.00549025,
-0.0349811241,
0.0014882032,
-0.0164378826,
0.0031124265,
0.0508451797,
0.0041314573,
-0.0268491767,
-0.0443185866,
-0.0243517347,
0.0485242493,
0.037556842,
-0.0028755069,
-0.0044162846,
0.0215054452,
-0.0487051196,
-0.0255807992,
0.0006697869,
0.0262298007,
0.0192589816,
0.0161087532,
0.0082625262,
0.0460077636,
-0.0517293625,
0.0012637551,
0.0364597067,
-0.0577129088,
-0.0207454655,
-0.0170005206,
0.01686606,
0.0186928827,
0.0295012351,
0.0043197041,
0.0184832308,
0.0286249425,
-0.0611046515,
-0.0107654594,
-0.0324767232,
-0.1095634103,
-0.0585746765,
0.0598270185,
-0.0220494345,
-0.0275671035,
0.026671147,
-0.0442428403,
-0.0403560214,
0.012119093,
-0.0109484429,
-0.0160201564,
-0.0077517838,
0.0314957052,
0.01425929,
0.0637977049,
-0.0526590981,
0.0444001891,
-0.0217828322,
0.0419524685,
0.0319211036,
0.0515357181,
-0.0048595071,
-0.0441156551,
-0.0386783481,
0.0215729401,
-0.0051977132,
-0.0052021039,
0.0018267692,
0.0155425649,
-0.0412799604,
-0.0171755087,
-0.0966615751,
0.01835474,
-0.0476342738,
0.0321805365,
0.0023962355,
0.001748296,
0.0091055324,
-0.0029603129,
-0.0308683086,
-0.0143650211,
-0.0027063831,
0.0199414752,
0.0228704605,
0.0243612844,
-0.0046887528,
-0.0387402661,
-0.0183900893,
-0.0059950184,
0.0749129578,
-0.0218029674,
-0.0082537588,
-0.0367031619,
0.0340750515,
-0.0014260658,
0.0012244588,
-0.0255733877,
-0.0185413081,
-0.024470428,
-0.0268633496,
0.0666106567,
0.0525124036,
0.0197236985,
0.0051692612,
0.0252780207,
-0.0141391605,
-0.0195998047,
0.0233621746,
-0.0104810577,
0.0146293221,
-0.0508724861,
0.0238956846,
-0.0166856311,
0.0866715461,
-0.0244052876,
-0.0064505758,
-0.0477572829,
-0.0302132964,
-0.0198049508,
-0.0071300957,
-0.0182636287,
0.0130128413,
-0.0394096822,
0.0153386788,
-0.0483822748,
-0.0025780103,
0.0623043403,
-0.0610719398,
-0.0297165178,
-0.0334960669,
-0.0104307542,
-0.0634610951,
0.0939784124,
-0.0029007809,
-0.0091633601,
-0.0042138952,
-0.0219866298,
-0.0382251702,
0.0088159433,
-0.032589294,
-0.0286612287,
0.1051531062,
-0.046837233,
0.0150567908,
-0.0230258703,
-0.0219045952,
-0.029548591,
-0.0189173371,
-0.0121172154,
0.0168438777,
0.0165373459,
-0.0070839711,
-0.0425193682,
0.0200395845,
0.0235610716,
0.0719795004,
-0.0122118136,
0.0287339315,
-0.0079877255,
0.0497041605,
0.0498767644,
0.0360847227,
-0.0037171284,
-0.0322922878,
0.0101593481,
0.0328108184,
0.0179662034,
0.0191098694,
-0.0332928561,
-0.0118768699,
0.0163503848,
-0.028103482,
-0.0205812845,
0.0179514196,
0.0482152179,
-0.0909186453,
-0.0136047546,
0.1148975492,
-0.0091384826,
-0.0561660491,
0.020297952,
0.0312887467,
0.0136475153,
0.0295542311,
-0.0169294514,
-0.0733427182,
-0.0549548231,
0.0055831284,
-0.0191340465,
0.0276436005,
-0.0479168706,
-0.0056145694,
-0.1138969585,
-0.0206458103,
-0.0048132981,
-0.0618861057,
-0.0123113263,
-0.0432747677,
0.0200279672,
0.0137687651,
0.0404216126,
-0.0058334991,
-0.0055410867,
-0.0121713988,
0.0261629131,
0.0026649607,
-0.0881292522,
0.0740353763,
-0.0420549475,
0.0519017391,
0.0434731916,
0.0328371041,
0.0030270414,
-0.0345395654,
0.052556362,
-0.034819603,
0.0117993588,
0.014022178,
0.0391978584,
-0.0335538536,
-0.020891143,
0.0064545004,
0.0148525946,
-0.0595915206,
0.0062416736,
0.01426508,
0.0753694847,
0.0032792781,
-0.0126720648,
-0.014264347,
-0.0112429727,
0.0160532035,
0.087044321,
0.0519804209,
-0.0369524658,
-0.0276494063,
0.0060187965,
-0.0276251007,
-0.0774315372,
-0.0308892503,
0.0280234274,
0.0086846408,
0.0003446188,
-0.065332219,
-0.048834715,
0.0287256967,
0.0336273015,
-0.004149925,
0.0217528325,
-0.0047758748,
-0.004613094,
-0.0536024384,
0.0362202264,
-0.0133891199,
0.0442083254,
-0.0618441366,
0.03434496,
0.038612891,
-0.0141708544,
-0.0174500663,
0.0365360342,
-0.1171856597,
-0.0466466285,
-0.025683932,
0.0130774025,
0.0089505892,
0.0321087204,
-0.0042024986,
-0.0317642093,
0.0352879688,
0.0091499379,
-0.0385423191,
0.0313139595,
0.0113291442,
0.0056850407,
-0.0145850955,
0.0546998307,
-0.0461548157,
0.0312694609,
0.0150682107,
0.0675791726,
0.0260289554,
-0.0402394235,
-0.0283074379,
-0.0150519237,
0.0413616858,
-0.000576088,
-0.0128504764,
0.0099148611,
0.0007978639,
-0.0095168417,
-0.0108612096,
-0.0102015492,
0.015200696,
0.029667316,
-0.0143869733,
0.0133374538,
0.0108656399,
0.0319144391,
0.0024882257,
-0.0466857888,
0.056400124,
-0.0278201867,
-0.0204781853,
0.0106284041,
0.025501607,
-0.0252034981,
-0.0356208757,
-0.0090030227,
0.0340461917,
-0.0208978355,
0.0372340828,
0.0173098184,
0.0169815291,
-0.0057661231,
0.0374368466,
-0.0709785968,
0.0405565761,
-0.0079912571,
0.0093642669,
0.0899137184,
-0.028405074,
0.0668003336,
0.0138371857,
-0.0003214736,
-0.0592667684,
0.0336556286,
-0.0187892672,
-0.018726714,
0.0148246037,
0.0285383482,
-0.0220791809,
0.0068961126,
0.0964883789,
0.0090786666,
0.0266288258,
0.0458577797,
0.0047927285,
-0.0414802097,
-0.0538815781,
-0.0308954306,
0.0315876454,
-0.0305947307,
0.0133382631,
-0.0308783855,
-0.0645384192,
0.022427788,
-0.0197227336,
-0.011701108,
0.0074351099,
0.0313559845,
0.0715453029,
-0.0140525382,
0.0109604541,
-0.0248214845,
-0.0089087272,
0.0075376071,
-0.0370474495,
-0.0289808586,
-6.114497333e-33,
-0.012429907,
-0.031761732,
0.0262433495,
-0.0270953588,
-0.0541913919,
0.0296138097,
-0.0551948808,
0.0056647323,
-0.0106835542,
0.0018102759,
-0.001507801,
-0.0172665343,
-0.0001444095,
0.0555414632,
0.0160459168,
-0.0415506139,
0.0533505864,
0.0183861665,
0.0075626178,
0.0129893115,
0.0332834721,
0.0454569757,
0.0590188578,
-0.033333879,
0.0250528231,
0.0063019395,
0.0273671001,
-0.0126009947,
0.0098050293,
0.0716783777,
-0.011288912,
0.0357908271,
0.056953039,
-0.085581623,
-0.0419097729,
0.0064126207,
-0.0832408369,
0.000327404,
0.0002616838,
-0.0054259291,
-0.050048884,
-0.0461028107,
0.0541827492,
0.0098871561,
0.0049925349,
-0.0238900557,
0.0418412946,
-0.029869929,
-0.0150848534,
-0.0208433717,
-0.0407306962,
0.0364640765,
-0.0077465214,
-0.0331016816,
0.035417553,
0.0297463387,
-0.0094777402,
0.0337134339,
-0.0498204641,
-0.0253578741,
-0.0366342217,
0.0702052563,
0.0597534627,
0.0365185849,
0.006123112,
0.0405902341,
-0.0173842125,
0.0072836559,
-0.0017549724,
-0.052416604,
0.0287483688,
0.0447859429,
0.0272944197,
0.042524673,
0.0118141016,
-0.0010988682,
-0.049620796,
0.0074063796,
0.0101147322,
0.0192842782,
0.0439560115,
0.0151978908,
-0.006375663,
-0.0063297767,
-0.0341973826,
0.0115747917,
-0.0313527025,
-0.0044796416,
0.0606786162,
0.0129109686,
0.0316802375,
0.0331003927,
0.0575549155,
-0.0360573642,
-0.0215883348,
0.03876945,
0.0112020932,
-0.0048693456,
0.0145548051,
0.0263411794,
-0.0318762772,
-0.0176927485,
0.020048989,
0.019583419,
0.0052615558,
-0.0342213884,
0.0348856747,
-0.0220784117,
-0.048228126,
-0.0182369146,
-0.0438003913,
-0.0071923505,
-0.023578424,
0.082703121,
0.0628767461,
-0.0033320095,
-0.0210511908,
0.1040424332,
-0.002447091,
-0.0231282655,
-0.0061892923,
-0.0247847065,
0.0107655087,
0.0184581149,
-0.0313848369,
0.0021141251,
-0.0210810825,
0.005842444,
0.0227399319,
-0.0293970108,
0.000799144,
0.0234417003,
2.599e-7,
0.0307829119,
0.0260456353,
0.0354219154,
-0.0014743536,
0.0108194957,
0.0262236279,
-0.0184651129,
0.0399984866,
-0.0446481928,
-0.0149365896,
-0.0315351263,
0.0102935592,
0.0773362741,
-0.0083835768,
-0.0951575339,
-0.0190523751,
-0.0437402055,
0.0180726293,
-0.056936495,
-0.0165848434,
0.046222914,
0.1109851673,
0.000253111,
0.011368881,
0.0212930478,
-0.0548311472,
0.0434273221,
-0.0369332135,
0.0053139664,
0.0022117242,
-0.0202897824,
0.0142250387,
0.0171569306,
0.0152865816,
-0.0021846208,
0.0359659865,
0.0335094929,
0.0993349627,
0.027685428,
-0.0363810621,
-0.0008353274,
-0.0031436083,
-0.0099657178,
-0.0486720726,
0.0596870296,
-0.064106226,
-0.0251380634,
-0.0109371226,
-0.0177743658,
-0.007488417,
0.0206800345,
0.0291569065,
0.0115762213,
0.0226669982,
0.0135044921,
-0.0335374586,
-0.0136480657,
-0.1248199791,
-0.0273701418,
0.0233339015,
-0.0741031766,
0.0032877359,
-0.0532771386,
-0.0253980607,
0.0500397086,
-0.0758119076,
-0.017688971,
2.532942141e-34,
0.0157660879,
-0.0191722922,
0.0011947671,
0.0004566413,
0.0052674841,
-0.0220648758,
-0.0690976158,
-0.0136445854,
0.0054577333,
-0.0886522159,
-0.0089188535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19233v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19233v3 | Building Real-World Meeting Summarization Systems using Large Language Models: A Practical Perspective | 2023-10-30T02:25:21 | 2023-11-08T02:23:28 | Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Xue-Yong Fu, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper studies how to effectively build meeting summarization systems for
real-world usage using large language models (LLMs). For this purpose, we
conduct an extensive evaluation and comparison of various closed-source and
open-source LLMs, namely, GPT-4, GPT- 3.5, PaLM-2, and LLaMA-2. Our findings
reveal that most closed-source LLMs are generally better in terms of
performance. However, much smaller open-source models like LLaMA- 2 (7B and
13B) could still achieve performance comparable to the large closed-source
models even in zero-shot scenarios. Considering the privacy concerns of
closed-source models for only being accessible via API, alongside the high cost
associated with using fine-tuned versions of the closed-source models, the
opensource models that can achieve competitive performance are more
advantageous for industrial use. Balancing performance with associated costs
and privacy concerns, the LLaMA-2-7B model looks more promising for industrial
usage. In sum, this paper offers practical insights on using LLMs for
real-world business meeting summarization, shedding light on the trade-offs
between performance and cost. | [
0.0430726483,
-0.0001807021,
0.0158825628,
0.0676085576,
-0.0417500585,
-0.0321061611,
0.0195472687,
0.0044099446,
0.0345580727,
-0.0441123322,
-0.0663242117,
-0.0397435203,
0.0178470537,
0.0483767167,
-0.0129352324,
-0.0991380289,
0.0091953436,
-0.0291749295,
-0.0242208876,
-0.0025304214,
0.0385523103,
0.0116843442,
0.0033264617,
0.0500154682,
-0.0003376043,
-0.0154399453,
0.0098601626,
-0.0228682216,
-0.0010727883,
0.0066553811,
-0.0333147608,
0.0260729082,
0.0351553448,
0.0289953835,
0.0000020969,
-0.0400134362,
-0.0241888352,
-0.0043741222,
-0.0118564107,
0.0367567167,
0.0562988743,
-0.0153234545,
0.011302812,
0.029382715,
-0.0292729903,
0.0190684069,
0.0206027254,
0.049093347,
0.0447566658,
0.0299524944,
-0.0144495042,
-0.0406742841,
-0.0086198971,
-0.026717715,
-0.0426785983,
-0.0644191578,
-0.0044264435,
0.0146322781,
0.0198381245,
-0.0229905024,
0.0516551919,
0.0423738919,
-0.0297728237,
-0.0212287903,
-0.0185659658,
0.0423626676,
-0.0754731968,
-0.0166926943,
-0.0190654788,
0.0640722141,
0.0595641807,
0.0332554579,
0.0304031391,
0.0107031679,
0.0220859591,
-0.0203920547,
-0.1047040001,
0.0389808267,
-0.0108552231,
0.0238056704,
-0.0201102383,
0.0606513955,
-0.0265747383,
0.0106993178,
0.0230430886,
0.0359854437,
0.0004711758,
-0.0033093279,
-0.06587933,
-0.0114331236,
0.0070700007,
-0.061116796,
0.0544020645,
0.0225143377,
0.0424274802,
0.0353762545,
-0.032439325,
-0.0105405133,
0.0212153289,
-0.0583645068,
0.0132670589,
0.0133619476,
0.0623475946,
0.0424992144,
-0.0048008291,
0.035863407,
0.0005454166,
0.0115586212,
-0.0334539637,
-0.0256688874,
0.0023402655,
-0.0076483032,
-0.0189421009,
0.0657496154,
-0.0988886505,
-0.0711086616,
-0.043329291,
0.053809572,
0.0299989246,
0.0364334472,
0.0163977575,
-0.0155512374,
0.0131011074,
-0.0163878202,
0.0109063899,
-0.0043334858,
0.0046552601,
-0.0455527678,
0.006427187,
-0.0716453642,
0.0314824805,
0.0096831191,
0.0194101166,
0.0416670218,
-0.0539429262,
0.0742639899,
-0.0120429872,
-0.034952227,
-0.0119323758,
-0.0587007888,
-0.0210067611,
-0.0344866402,
-0.0455485024,
-0.0475338511,
0.0265408587,
0.0367946476,
-0.0148107,
-0.0129238619,
0.0158280637,
0.0173148271,
-0.0403881148,
0.0101783322,
-0.0403649509,
0.0329672396,
0.0582247712,
0.0158925969,
0.0050921473,
0.0629319996,
0.0350889079,
0.0553071201,
0.0707754716,
0.0103180548,
0.0231738798,
0.0625721589,
-0.043478556,
0.0014992733,
0.0191333517,
0.0090057561,
-0.0239966717,
-0.0406647958,
-0.0469987392,
0.0690661147,
-0.0270926598,
0.0280100834,
0.089563638,
0.0784972683,
-0.0055928878,
0.0105442908,
-0.0428300425,
0.0464125611,
0.0247884318,
0.0003377094,
0.0164430737,
0.0311546978,
-0.0408221558,
0.0238889027,
0.1006044745,
-0.0096642571,
-0.0218614601,
-0.032881882,
-0.0270854924,
-0.0291863699,
-0.0340260342,
-0.0130601404,
0.0225230791,
-0.0513129905,
-0.0630513206,
0.0818927065,
-0.0061436729,
-0.0694040731,
-0.0142263751,
-0.0325072706,
0.0124689164,
0.1083546206,
0.0512221381,
-0.0284602642,
-0.0051196525,
-0.0173474234,
-0.0318325721,
0.0555668958,
0.0502526574,
-0.0091300225,
-0.0046253153,
-0.0563299768,
-0.016471006,
0.0300859921,
-0.0056446819,
-0.0001206601,
-0.000389006,
0.0113626849,
0.0484766886,
0.0055447472,
-0.0334354192,
-0.0062479461,
0.0262584686,
-0.0028446042,
-0.0520796813,
-0.0062671024,
0.0367037542,
0.0592983924,
0.003824923,
0.0083905626,
0.0188793559,
-0.0110493032,
0.0235301014,
0.0081557054,
-0.0641955212,
0.0124461213,
0.0364730656,
-0.0039139125,
0.0445145853,
0.0277050734,
-0.0241533406,
-0.0766554847,
0.0027956201,
-0.0178185087,
0.0496828742,
-0.022891989,
0.0279742964,
-0.0056376401,
-0.000215668,
0.0014346566,
0.0057001519,
0.0044368687,
-0.0261172205,
0.0341333486,
-0.0340122059,
0.0164659154,
-0.0445257574,
-0.0037064676,
0.0576456785,
0.0051136487,
0.0207120758,
0.0243784972,
-0.0008024328,
-0.0315212943,
-0.0253008008,
-0.1208678484,
-0.0074202949,
-0.0079107992,
0.0165561996,
0.0322681181,
0.0329937264,
-0.0187357385,
-0.0101793064,
-0.0498785488,
-0.0292995665,
0.0260581747,
0.0206560474,
0.0089219855,
0.0264620632,
-0.0009929377,
-0.0710710287,
-0.014970893,
0.0366045572,
0.0401762202,
-0.007606606,
-0.0714518502,
-0.0588747337,
0.008806793,
-0.030761769,
0.0006671392,
0.0122843906,
-0.0012053702,
-0.0088321175,
-0.0046428521,
0.0382717215,
0.0112200798,
0.0173597541,
0.0100300089,
0.0123245567,
0.0008696883,
-0.0492705479,
-0.0268895142,
-0.025160294,
0.0102143353,
-0.007388792,
-0.032188829,
0.0474093407,
0.0014328962,
0.0237392988,
0.030201545,
-0.0446165502,
0.0224340614,
-0.0178336371,
0.0077733644,
-0.0228641871,
-0.0411887728,
-0.0445231125,
0.0469670407,
0.0128823863,
-0.0175875816,
-0.0117597505,
-0.0671562627,
0.0087503111,
-0.0035216564,
-0.018627936,
-0.0595718846,
0.0311901346,
-0.0389199108,
0.0405281447,
-0.0460230708,
-0.0422386117,
-0.0090308748,
-0.0167255271,
0.0151954442,
-0.0738610253,
0.0515944958,
-0.0552236475,
0.0123934364,
-0.0385570787,
-0.0173716173,
-0.0156652071,
-0.0206569918,
-0.0698383898,
0.0254578311,
0.0183546804,
0.019042192,
-0.0496505313,
0.0837874115,
0.0202454887,
0.0609375313,
0.0018001902,
0.007238369,
-0.0075733601,
0.0417660214,
0.0313535295,
-0.0254775751,
0.0280597191,
-0.040617533,
-0.0003578037,
0.0432775579,
0.0635457188,
-0.01761554,
0.0245348141,
-0.0687771365,
0.0321276821,
-0.039536573,
-0.0241305921,
-0.0106972707,
0.0306303129,
-0.0144980419,
0.0743969604,
0.1105273739,
-0.0010972713,
-0.0670085922,
-0.0414323024,
-0.0211885478,
0.0130656622,
-0.012889158,
0.0139323277,
-0.0594383851,
-0.0227393992,
0.0161303263,
0.056687139,
0.021592427,
-0.0112666627,
-0.0293010343,
-0.1058404073,
0.0317635313,
0.0099833049,
-0.0140328985,
-0.0218194034,
0.0041594352,
0.0288850814,
-0.017166052,
0.003524391,
0.0109621584,
-0.0271776877,
-0.0165041815,
0.0078174192,
-0.1110758632,
-0.0191395208,
-0.0345565155,
0.0030610887,
0.0055840951,
0.0451232567,
0.0405647531,
0.018745333,
0.0043828497,
0.0133897318,
-0.0116003612,
0.0065392028,
-0.02479784,
0.0470884405,
-0.0117398528,
0.0047284351,
-0.0165605359,
0.0182760134,
0.0075532347,
0.0090028085,
0.0162287019,
-0.0018100791,
0.0104165114,
0.0038306077,
-0.0207675546,
0.0319154896,
-0.0204764567,
0.0630332008,
-0.0091741439,
-0.0079807891,
-0.0286615249,
-0.0153971212,
0.0171498433,
0.0068539316,
0.0138359889,
-0.0172018521,
-0.0217221547,
-0.0179764926,
-0.0673543513,
-0.0155491894,
0.022841718,
-0.0214574113,
0.0123292096,
0.0223402064,
0.0155107221,
0.0263276175,
-0.0146237081,
-0.0411462039,
-0.0767136812,
-0.0010369082,
-0.068857789,
0.0055768769,
0.0712518767,
0.0055568861,
0.0022951984,
0.0294807069,
-0.0472479798,
-0.0513204969,
-0.0227222387,
0.0407024249,
0.0263969041,
0.0305177998,
0.0190617796,
-0.0083395988,
0.033175502,
-0.011553444,
0.0169213004,
0.0251655541,
0.0002828295,
0.038818799,
-0.0297129806,
0.0131529393,
-0.0572318286,
0.0044752588,
-0.0283032004,
0.0133133633,
-0.0404258892,
-0.1074977219,
-0.0328115895,
0.064393796,
-0.0334464535,
-0.0023538999,
-0.001496397,
-0.0277489498,
0.023507284,
-0.03355629,
0.0040035718,
-0.0275195595,
0.002337791,
-0.0356989205,
-0.027073713,
0.0277463757,
0.0471462794,
-0.0245154388,
0.0044676992,
-0.0517741404,
0.0226405039,
-0.0314119123,
-0.074078992,
0.0047794967,
-0.0091959257,
-0.0717826858,
-0.0006826257,
-0.0252129901,
0.0041157231,
-0.0325355381,
0.0409020409,
-0.0094070286,
-0.059746284,
0.0359859988,
0.0924415961,
-0.0390864611,
-0.0277867857,
-0.0429787189,
0.074964352,
0.0293300562,
-0.0047590006,
0.0814679563,
-0.0552346148,
0.0450778119,
-0.0427324809,
0.0441806354,
0.0261921939,
-0.0184430759,
-0.0326126963,
0.0017561278,
0.0046340395,
0.0219559073,
0.0902850777,
-0.0260729492,
-0.0334358253,
-0.0001135983,
-0.0378336012,
-0.0682248771,
-0.0284402054,
0.0124919172,
0.0360271037,
-0.0013917307,
-0.0519250855,
-0.0795630962,
0.0014141649,
0.0485619828,
-0.0292512625,
-0.0134273795,
-0.0443315729,
0.0427348912,
0.0299025364,
0.0376309566,
0.0070518344,
-0.0556653291,
-0.025558915,
-0.0261343531,
0.0340257436,
0.0067843436,
-6.30353262e-33,
-0.0447298139,
-0.0318464749,
-0.0210202597,
0.0361119621,
-0.0375924781,
0.0006070524,
-0.0108813504,
-0.0073787998,
0.0081914123,
-0.0557421632,
-0.0228374377,
0.0048114657,
0.0393362865,
0.0264600012,
-0.0259090718,
0.0198170934,
0.0458171256,
-0.0211755298,
-0.016775161,
0.0529116429,
0.0640057996,
0.0144284405,
0.0241372548,
-0.073122181,
0.0058076479,
-0.0419505537,
-0.0202190541,
-0.0363854691,
0.0600644462,
0.0141103277,
-0.0282887407,
0.0240542162,
0.0221686326,
-0.0184855815,
-0.0227537677,
0.038430091,
-0.0222248863,
0.0132094873,
0.042220626,
0.0160183925,
0.0202350318,
-0.02172691,
0.003731291,
-0.0060128411,
-0.0174702145,
0.0018409143,
0.0136425048,
-0.0464103147,
-0.0483755171,
-0.0158576015,
-0.0156190749,
0.0409734957,
0.0078214016,
-0.0061549428,
0.0625929758,
0.0274797007,
0.0248087384,
-0.0277951416,
-0.0524325781,
0.0631552339,
0.060917858,
-0.0260552913,
0.0861128345,
0.0319018625,
0.0255875234,
0.0554134585,
0.0059767044,
0.0104160719,
0.0045408513,
-0.0247842092,
-0.0359896645,
0.0397425368,
0.0241020247,
0.0202045217,
-0.0100910943,
0.0116401957,
-0.0043739188,
0.0316290595,
-0.0464227833,
-0.0233911444,
0.0910948664,
0.0116088586,
-0.0167418122,
0.0074270805,
-0.0106919063,
0.0579975992,
-0.0123966122,
-0.0104248468,
-0.0010928418,
0.0163948108,
-0.0426000357,
0.0005466007,
0.0314054266,
-0.0162004959,
-0.0226879138,
0.024794763,
0.0241193213,
0.0220822915,
-0.028409129,
-0.0259308591,
-0.0533960238,
-0.0070542623,
0.0018468029,
0.0029946882,
-0.0240320098,
0.0189797748,
-0.0153877819,
0.0002479183,
-0.0360374674,
0.0287033077,
0.0056895176,
0.0450055674,
-0.028396707,
-0.0245520603,
0.0211211164,
-0.0407521836,
-0.011580172,
0.0502657779,
0.0043076226,
0.0010908432,
0.0119259274,
-0.0338524804,
0.0035586827,
0.0076804697,
-0.0456768796,
0.026000319,
0.000456045,
0.0275770128,
0.0794454068,
0.0478141159,
-0.0054986654,
-0.0326140821,
2.735e-7,
0.0228391737,
0.0303821918,
0.0306495894,
0.0024687867,
0.0088804709,
0.0311882291,
0.0263319872,
0.0455462597,
-0.0033005057,
0.030423427,
0.019710863,
0.0047132326,
0.0830024928,
0.0392321609,
-0.0899154544,
-0.0095834509,
-0.0712090135,
-0.0299424399,
-0.0601707771,
0.0264703166,
0.0521285981,
0.0571453758,
-0.0219769645,
-0.0097654527,
-0.0453925207,
-0.0465139151,
0.053957954,
-0.062018618,
-0.026611194,
0.0189107172,
0.0360203758,
0.0408097133,
-0.0136277573,
-0.0146691706,
0.0090372451,
-0.014765203,
0.0342482328,
0.0680860728,
0.0011952737,
0.0016132067,
0.054137554,
-0.0479695462,
-0.0081570791,
0.0042531267,
0.0404707789,
-0.0269355457,
-0.004122179,
0.0097014969,
-0.0091575384,
-0.0475278683,
-0.0273891557,
0.006371011,
-0.0114714298,
0.0464452654,
-0.0288160294,
-0.032720495,
-0.0027462845,
-0.0415186659,
-0.0081159752,
-0.0281802863,
-0.0030597348,
-0.0602760799,
-0.0407818705,
-0.0500244424,
-0.0389363393,
0.0086037973,
0.0164293982,
2.184289368e-34,
0.0289444122,
0.0076513807,
-0.027330542,
0.0612031966,
0.0294529237,
-0.0110359844,
0.0371352918,
-0.0053412751,
0.011504096,
-0.0784703046,
0.0073711607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19232v1 | Adapter Pruning using Tropical Characterization | 2023-10-30T02:20:44 | 2023-10-30T02:20:44 | Rishabh Bhardwaj, Tushar Vaidya, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adapters are widely popular parameter-efficient transfer learning approaches
in natural language processing that insert trainable modules in between layers
of a pre-trained language model. Apart from several heuristics, however, there
has been a lack of studies analyzing the optimal number of adapter parameters
needed for downstream applications. In this paper, we propose an adapter
pruning approach by studying the tropical characteristics of trainable modules.
We cast it as an optimization problem that aims to prune parameters from the
adapter layers without changing the orientation of underlying tropical
hypersurfaces. Our experiments on five NLP datasets show that tropical geometry
tends to identify more relevant parameters to prune when compared with the
magnitude-based baseline, while a combined approach works best across the
tasks. | [
0.0115724141,
0.0200059749,
-0.0157036968,
0.0518495925,
-0.0269320253,
0.010163567,
-0.009136457,
0.0078594862,
-0.0120000951,
-0.0085735368,
-0.0080897976,
-0.030317964,
0.0286968872,
0.0044390834,
-0.0262215324,
-0.0993424207,
0.034426637,
-0.0161457602,
-0.0546836592,
0.0333988294,
-0.0190274045,
-0.002742812,
0.0343232453,
0.0218434278,
0.0219407938,
0.0235563926,
-0.0133314878,
-0.0127884764,
0.0077538774,
-0.0234037936,
-0.022264095,
0.0428653248,
-0.0185572449,
-0.0220966954,
0.0000021224,
0.0078182258,
-0.0695133954,
-0.0063086874,
-0.0030195254,
0.0222996622,
0.1031675339,
-0.0397018716,
0.0003761464,
-0.0057620709,
-0.0450547561,
-0.0125271697,
0.038238965,
0.0442957915,
0.0488775484,
0.0823303312,
-0.0158437118,
-0.0060935491,
0.0029309958,
0.0373902768,
-0.0207475629,
-0.0265197698,
0.0347687751,
-0.0412305668,
-0.0344587378,
0.0007032317,
-0.0138798198,
0.0183314122,
-0.0224730372,
0.0448688976,
0.0338806324,
0.0008990444,
-0.0089298468,
0.0202548224,
-0.0050751939,
0.0813197494,
-0.0584066883,
-0.0250576995,
-0.0072826846,
-0.0251209904,
-0.0302561633,
0.0369852968,
-0.010948767,
-0.0094150826,
0.0326231197,
0.0508456975,
0.0261682887,
-0.0213024709,
0.0034521974,
-0.0229487214,
-0.0632848889,
0.0522932373,
0.0243606605,
-0.0119619323,
0.0062266528,
0.0056389389,
0.0514944792,
-0.0287418235,
0.0236959904,
0.0224346593,
0.0276309438,
0.0056637023,
-0.0070255767,
-0.0320203826,
-0.0307789817,
-0.0334108993,
0.1107075363,
0.01973553,
0.0123633938,
0.0286620725,
-0.0614978671,
0.0129043311,
0.0275974609,
0.0444735177,
-0.0343758464,
-0.0407890826,
-0.0249501951,
-0.0030506544,
-0.0399610139,
0.049547974,
-0.050427936,
0.0002531518,
0.006738483,
-0.0081282593,
-0.0089997519,
-0.0769159719,
0.0147137111,
0.018174747,
-0.0264931712,
-0.0317898244,
-0.0141432565,
0.0621259473,
0.0065878374,
0.0287748463,
-0.0292419717,
-0.0216874238,
-0.0045173396,
0.0273495056,
0.0693782419,
-0.0347615592,
0.0135332514,
0.0483430885,
0.0028153511,
-0.0419963002,
-0.0383538343,
0.012616666,
-0.0222463086,
-0.0305483118,
0.0385983251,
-0.0266057178,
0.0063576666,
-0.0398911126,
-0.0013054643,
-0.0407410227,
-0.0216848254,
0.006724759,
-0.0495850518,
0.0774909705,
0.0082365647,
0.0174966659,
0.0032961802,
-0.011764206,
0.0046563214,
0.0841864347,
0.0447764732,
0.0600667447,
0.0069387672,
-0.0440005697,
-0.0035045415,
0.0196588114,
0.0194947105,
0.030859001,
-0.0764371157,
-0.0341634043,
0.0257878136,
-0.0307359081,
0.0107082138,
0.0131695531,
-0.0308872145,
-0.0297018792,
0.0293122195,
0.0315845571,
-0.004771519,
0.0365840942,
0.0554260202,
-0.0112746861,
-0.0117444489,
0.0174873974,
-0.0239916332,
-0.0154438559,
-0.0954907909,
-0.0235108323,
-0.0270442702,
0.0567389652,
-0.0120127136,
-0.010755064,
-0.0136905564,
-0.0325411335,
0.0255061723,
-0.0366343893,
0.0335046835,
0.0351023376,
-0.0204034392,
0.0409898683,
0.0205963887,
-0.0511042848,
-0.009232942,
-0.004845452,
-0.0108704846,
0.0032094063,
-0.0490714572,
-0.0218239017,
-0.0188867394,
0.0555538125,
0.0265711434,
0.0238249805,
0.0316581875,
0.0058799456,
0.0555565841,
-0.0179207195,
-0.01642536,
0.0523971952,
0.0461403914,
0.0157586746,
0.0019702122,
0.0194961894,
0.0120518031,
-0.0495637096,
-0.0681848228,
0.0394747108,
-0.0320461951,
-0.022440277,
0.044674404,
0.0204026103,
0.0258284677,
-0.0274613425,
0.0225587692,
-0.0360061228,
0.0454844981,
-0.0616287105,
-0.0078388471,
0.0463614985,
-0.0401984528,
-0.0187787134,
0.0171715822,
-0.0508642085,
0.0531351157,
0.0396683365,
0.0044780653,
-0.0276552979,
0.0360070392,
0.0104979528,
0.0673551559,
-0.0037684238,
0.0554048344,
-0.0503067113,
0.0397925861,
-0.0061646593,
0.0142640444,
0.0246198457,
0.0197295193,
0.0223814417,
-0.0996128395,
0.012097544,
0.0020889002,
-0.0053295488,
-0.0040042377,
-0.029350644,
-0.0114478245,
-0.0098403301,
0.0242304001,
-0.017847022,
-0.0300894696,
-0.0503769331,
-0.0041075614,
-0.0092830015,
0.034841679,
0.047927469,
0.0082647093,
0.000884374,
0.0141503001,
0.0206624642,
0.0289394055,
-0.0003166465,
0.0090202997,
0.0536489785,
-0.030701939,
0.0254256856,
-0.0117195323,
0.0024262059,
0.0047847484,
0.1038266346,
-0.0070884679,
-0.0172524266,
-0.0416973084,
0.0117583452,
0.0019196733,
0.0008735852,
0.0279985238,
-0.0312637277,
-0.0481295399,
-0.0279316083,
-0.0144995078,
0.0661642849,
-0.0065513398,
-0.0038997445,
0.0438088402,
0.0009430602,
-0.0505631454,
-0.0207211487,
-0.0542908013,
0.0603072904,
-0.0298279095,
-0.0577197038,
0.036608614,
0.0662879199,
-0.0262260437,
-0.0085643176,
0.002163721,
0.0308728442,
-0.0240064785,
0.016200006,
0.0346383974,
0.0422588997,
-0.0224223323,
0.0185808055,
-0.000513775,
-0.0646989867,
0.039068535,
-0.0313147306,
0.010178417,
-0.1020992398,
-0.0181262512,
-0.0478606336,
0.0130235525,
0.0246387739,
0.0216336865,
-0.0073211007,
-0.0008236661,
0.0146777239,
0.007505123,
-0.0001961844,
0.0093503566,
0.0053962651,
-0.0574977286,
0.0093158623,
-0.0269482154,
-0.0269920193,
0.008223379,
-0.0180329699,
0.0034125114,
0.0197450947,
0.0347682722,
-0.0327342004,
-0.0231634378,
0.0203401335,
0.001930779,
0.0330435038,
-0.0128793838,
-0.0020615968,
0.0023219553,
0.0257217977,
0.0138687231,
0.0832219124,
0.0315214656,
0.0171668418,
0.0023182773,
-0.0080234399,
0.0259689633,
-0.0036198599,
-0.0178145226,
0.0285816099,
0.0431318171,
-0.0223446134,
-0.0260475986,
-0.0090490868,
0.0652801171,
-0.0499565713,
-0.008342348,
0.0684019327,
0.0208323244,
-0.023107795,
0.0070664152,
0.010650075,
0.0242981985,
-0.0113308402,
0.0382842906,
-0.0101381307,
-0.0056948303,
-0.0164808687,
-0.0148218181,
0.0096369628,
-0.0475820079,
-0.0288181249,
-0.1230712309,
-0.0018176246,
0.0026770262,
-0.084875986,
-0.016602857,
-0.04390084,
-0.0143877966,
-0.0510158315,
-0.0090653598,
-0.0446882546,
-0.0448820926,
-0.0106462762,
0.0216910746,
-0.0640695468,
-0.0257636607,
-0.0047493577,
-0.0274478197,
0.0083445311,
-0.0117245838,
0.0356479809,
-0.0110296337,
-0.0230828393,
-0.0036159551,
-0.0066500278,
0.0098152524,
-0.0381015018,
0.0267428905,
0.0733277276,
0.0087671923,
0.0344013274,
-0.0222876146,
-0.0300208665,
0.0028528415,
0.0099497838,
0.132702902,
0.0126399891,
-0.0423374213,
-0.0065300101,
-0.0010331896,
0.0134001151,
0.0739898011,
0.0300095752,
-0.045084957,
-0.0376348384,
-0.0166388638,
-0.0276606306,
-0.065239124,
-0.0551518537,
0.0128364451,
-0.0451367646,
-0.0151790669,
-0.0975543931,
0.0184551999,
0.0494170599,
0.0858042538,
0.0239882227,
0.0251531713,
0.0153703252,
-0.0375438109,
0.0088312961,
0.0061497046,
-0.0455301404,
0.00503624,
-0.0063525159,
-0.0056913947,
0.0331944339,
-0.0384204164,
-0.038988024,
-0.0739308149,
-0.01774293,
-0.0552374423,
-0.004086961,
0.0141641563,
0.0225220062,
0.0642480627,
-0.0146172168,
-0.0342345536,
-0.0023522358,
0.0556710362,
-0.0134589961,
-0.0083233165,
0.0544029772,
-0.0139555847,
-0.0028632262,
0.056250792,
0.027222231,
-0.001524774,
0.0763983205,
-0.0009609767,
-0.0125988787,
-0.0395554379,
0.0036029294,
0.0146274306,
0.0729901195,
0.0286371671,
-0.0961832106,
-0.0158451311,
0.0216284133,
-0.008246881,
0.0081989644,
-0.0308973454,
0.0294252578,
-0.0025324551,
0.0752941966,
-0.0620250888,
0.0129275648,
0.0039895633,
0.0278409179,
-0.0012554079,
0.0363654867,
0.0493876003,
-0.015705511,
-0.0135391215,
0.0556270406,
0.0006028944,
-0.0168718174,
0.0049577025,
0.0100137684,
-0.0405068807,
-0.0484824628,
0.0034860475,
0.0300319903,
-0.0722399577,
0.0179022197,
-0.0574550442,
-0.0351795331,
-0.0441312827,
0.0174051393,
0.0062598321,
-0.0598673113,
0.034198314,
0.0133175617,
-0.0260661487,
-0.0173377376,
0.0098872501,
0.015937252,
0.0025506099,
0.0309077315,
-0.0089826286,
-0.040078029,
0.017459657,
0.0457060374,
-0.0062526618,
0.0424751304,
0.0251875091,
0.0000408171,
-0.0207827967,
0.03578116,
-0.0086807525,
0.0162005182,
-0.0217533633,
0.0343134701,
-0.0541769676,
-0.0639885813,
0.0346382968,
-0.0740896761,
0.0152757103,
0.0208263919,
0.0106829964,
0.0307351109,
-0.0347682871,
0.0227940157,
-0.0182942413,
-0.026086485,
-0.034985248,
-0.006774032,
0.0086661726,
-6.600685103e-33,
-0.0047824127,
0.0103840809,
-0.0019122268,
-0.0007269242,
0.0012585551,
0.0090719471,
-0.0031904804,
0.0044990759,
-0.0335650593,
-0.0036969359,
-0.0202218648,
-0.0395540223,
0.0292183384,
0.0172739588,
-0.0111927567,
0.049572017,
0.0328200534,
0.0328953639,
-0.0385854393,
0.031667795,
0.0180739183,
0.0479689576,
0.0950941518,
-0.0640506446,
-0.0611341186,
0.0789594874,
0.0169394799,
0.0217450242,
-0.0049949726,
0.0427761823,
-0.0250108186,
0.0276449174,
0.0147857433,
-0.0225881785,
-0.039905224,
-0.0078883898,
-0.0634093583,
-0.0668344498,
0.0054390691,
0.0224762894,
-0.0075457552,
-0.0536705144,
0.0416182242,
-0.0219055153,
-0.0120577635,
-0.0411407426,
0.0467997938,
-0.042791348,
-0.0609909929,
0.0023904759,
-0.1014796644,
0.050939016,
0.0137608191,
0.0204643961,
0.0367710851,
0.0227535386,
-0.0307500903,
0.0200069547,
-0.0438628644,
-0.002234912,
0.0467245989,
0.0271568205,
0.0195547547,
0.0131127695,
-0.020940274,
0.0477737673,
0.0689208359,
-0.0395030975,
0.0076645943,
-0.0161732826,
0.0695470423,
0.0501811467,
0.049870912,
0.0310203843,
0.0647923574,
-0.0618600883,
-0.0107675493,
0.0372389741,
-0.0379580781,
-0.0162645224,
-0.0163313318,
0.0045768069,
0.0134313963,
-0.0127138589,
-0.0320680402,
-0.0164343305,
-0.0175756998,
-0.021844212,
0.0106353583,
0.0208675228,
-0.0634631813,
0.0767409876,
0.0198526699,
-0.0565545447,
-0.0212871134,
0.0321201235,
-0.0302739721,
-0.0036442743,
0.0270601921,
-0.0094366837,
-0.0465291142,
-0.044765424,
-0.0241270401,
-0.0126993442,
0.014093169,
-0.0161259342,
0.0425020531,
0.0402148999,
-0.0695783123,
-0.018425053,
-0.0110292044,
-0.0295725539,
0.0219140183,
0.137930572,
0.0317532122,
0.0019444835,
-0.0030968362,
0.0414992198,
-0.0005101952,
0.0092126112,
-0.0224931724,
0.0030049493,
0.0086563593,
0.0163575448,
-0.0324582681,
-0.0035983678,
-0.0068807672,
-0.0222753156,
0.0117794927,
-0.0409596227,
-0.01650922,
0.0370716564,
2.913e-7,
0.0432631336,
0.0651903674,
-0.0338732004,
-0.0739069954,
-0.0116365161,
0.0122091109,
-0.0151691483,
-0.0245819036,
-0.0138427615,
0.0518896356,
-0.0078350324,
-0.0057753413,
0.0620270558,
0.0460403301,
-0.1112290397,
0.0203147382,
-0.0183241218,
-0.055956468,
-0.0349880569,
-0.0247125085,
0.0066195978,
0.0703706443,
-0.0026210486,
-0.0165886171,
-0.0203495603,
-0.0348935798,
0.0194235127,
-0.083203949,
0.0454864651,
0.0192652158,
0.0399618484,
-0.0332800187,
0.0032292842,
0.0313324258,
-0.0154907024,
0.0556493849,
0.0017605564,
0.0678447932,
-0.0061670239,
-0.0004168554,
0.0145928459,
-0.0249987803,
-0.0110191088,
-0.0693928227,
0.0730279386,
-0.0527960397,
-0.0072342018,
-0.0527819134,
0.0064690211,
0.0291006062,
0.0136913434,
0.0009448735,
0.0039082407,
0.0051276269,
0.0225223396,
-0.038253542,
-0.0345308408,
-0.0345961675,
0.0296181086,
0.04179487,
-0.0078031626,
-0.016359834,
-0.0295503512,
0.0066192537,
0.0705051497,
-0.0865506753,
0.0194855873,
3.099223917e-34,
-0.0352286026,
-0.014148063,
0.0174208824,
0.0150491325,
0.0091785807,
-0.0004331698,
0.0633722618,
-0.0077269641,
-0.0348709337,
-0.0817052647,
0.0176364165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.19212v1 | EHRTutor: Enhancing Patient Understanding of Discharge Instructions | 2023-10-30T00:46:03 | 2023-10-30T00:46:03 | Zihao Zhang, Zonghai Yao, Huixue Zhou, Feiyun ouyang, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have shown success as a tutor in education in various
fields. Educating patients about their clinical visits plays a pivotal role in
patients' adherence to their treatment plans post-discharge. This paper
presents EHRTutor, an innovative multi-component framework leveraging the Large
Language Model (LLM) for patient education through conversational
question-answering. EHRTutor first formulates questions pertaining to the
electronic health record discharge instructions. It then educates the patient
through conversation by administering each question as a test. Finally, it
generates a summary at the end of the conversation. Evaluation results using
LLMs and domain experts have shown a clear preference for EHRTutor over the
baseline. Moreover, EHRTutor also offers a framework for generating synthetic
patient education dialogues that can be used for future in-house system
training. | [
0.0836736858,
0.0369140506,
-0.0254823864,
-0.0280174762,
-0.0205813646,
0.0373048522,
0.0223319512,
-0.0224225968,
0.0404082909,
-0.0172471479,
0.0181686599,
-0.0434673354,
-0.0154885547,
0.0330380276,
0.0251141749,
-0.0607717521,
0.0126516279,
0.0049046348,
0.0222703721,
-0.0099714566,
0.02860526,
0.0066122692,
-0.0501384325,
0.0420303792,
0.0433665514,
-0.0276823137,
-0.0332938135,
0.0024971256,
0.0137180453,
-0.0894542262,
0.0151315033,
0.0232036076,
0.0215629917,
-0.0202022623,
0.0000021327,
-0.0650373846,
-0.0005829349,
0.0309512876,
-0.1054777801,
-0.030418206,
0.0029245876,
-0.0288687907,
0.0072157439,
0.0147120049,
-0.0169371758,
-0.0305469055,
0.0373151563,
0.0891679227,
0.0868218094,
0.0723845661,
-0.0182591528,
-0.0105293347,
-0.0220022425,
-0.004061162,
0.005953013,
-0.0396470688,
0.0060405242,
0.0639342591,
0.0579525866,
-0.0250221379,
0.0052167038,
0.023352541,
0.0098266713,
-0.0036888742,
0.0088773128,
0.0268470403,
0.0016430944,
0.0245900005,
-0.0181546062,
0.0513231941,
0.0533213094,
0.0307249259,
0.0228268541,
0.0168665536,
0.0307782404,
0.0099652214,
-0.0845802799,
-0.0062278928,
-0.0129225142,
-0.014843462,
-0.0191132948,
-0.0164146703,
-0.0026918247,
-0.0102724899,
-0.0121504972,
-0.0150207803,
0.0210222453,
-0.0223222319,
-0.0022215082,
0.0001823722,
0.0355973393,
-0.0589311272,
0.0349562392,
0.077419132,
-0.0558409989,
0.0244113207,
0.0115909921,
-0.0129002705,
0.0713500828,
-0.0610373355,
0.0156878643,
0.0156772956,
0.0376118794,
0.0361404493,
0.0240531992,
0.0357511006,
0.0053425631,
-0.0298455134,
-0.0310098156,
-0.0028452089,
-0.0693786144,
-0.0448699035,
-0.0568913035,
0.0486800335,
-0.000122488,
-0.0113668041,
-0.0725455061,
0.0224261284,
0.0136370771,
0.0471323319,
0.0189674813,
0.0066998214,
-0.0217406433,
-0.0153337438,
-0.0383688174,
0.0312677957,
-0.0346111655,
0.0056670033,
0.0011674272,
-0.0576995611,
0.0215204507,
0.0051489659,
-0.0057336809,
0.0098238122,
-0.0032385644,
0.0799451917,
-0.0243590344,
-0.0052638901,
-0.0143149318,
-0.0503679775,
-0.0115250479,
-0.0277564432,
0.0034940725,
-0.0760538578,
0.0160862524,
0.0163168218,
-0.006181892,
-0.0443117768,
0.0432353392,
0.0294164401,
-0.010295881,
0.0515198894,
-0.0338019952,
0.0358378179,
0.0413201377,
0.0325869508,
0.0278576892,
0.0267834347,
0.0078141922,
-0.0210432094,
-0.0146838306,
-0.0477115475,
0.0332696028,
0.0212933831,
0.0029494385,
-0.0580317378,
0.0342145823,
0.0447859541,
0.0021782492,
0.0536126979,
-0.0474077128,
0.0858926997,
-0.0086303838,
0.0499009006,
0.0204640236,
0.0331701487,
0.0108644422,
-0.0019951237,
0.0255216807,
0.0109702377,
-0.0040182569,
0.0085579809,
-0.0077813645,
0.0135815982,
0.0418835282,
0.009734218,
0.0091026584,
0.000548736,
-0.0551794581,
-0.0399036445,
-0.0135720233,
-0.0205678456,
0.008550276,
0.0147660198,
0.0338679999,
0.0002304489,
-0.0430365503,
0.0975727513,
0.0616574995,
-0.0291667376,
-0.0073394119,
-0.0576310344,
0.0081114303,
0.1325987875,
0.0448055789,
-0.013265267,
-0.056985382,
-0.0528767966,
0.0183513239,
0.034985356,
0.0350832008,
-0.0318046771,
-0.0236670915,
-0.0624618866,
-0.0210708939,
0.0041385801,
-0.0120116808,
0.0079187956,
-0.0222066753,
0.0228914432,
-0.0075214002,
-0.0273696929,
-0.0497452058,
0.025133701,
-0.0618592054,
-0.0244411901,
-0.0200633071,
0.00916724,
0.0098883454,
0.0459058285,
0.0112490384,
0.0208195318,
0.0323641673,
-0.0221730769,
0.0107071735,
0.0144903529,
-0.039280124,
-0.0312530324,
0.0230608638,
-0.0275850855,
-0.0128583713,
-0.028794013,
-0.0125442557,
-0.0253062937,
-0.0353417918,
-0.075682871,
0.041583363,
-0.0232684985,
0.0101317512,
0.064771086,
-0.0280037094,
-0.0327792987,
0.004715119,
0.0133013697,
0.0081766443,
0.0142871132,
-0.0092235627,
0.0038582773,
-0.0464083552,
0.0014681136,
0.0304375198,
-0.0202692356,
0.0021709895,
0.0153647298,
0.0206050109,
-0.0441472866,
-0.016433524,
-0.1471428126,
-0.0196962785,
-0.0094727995,
0.0167491641,
0.0262009334,
0.0407576375,
-0.0081137922,
-0.0365321673,
-0.069699958,
-0.0179156475,
0.0412805825,
0.0071582473,
0.009331611,
0.056572251,
-0.0210193153,
0.0098691285,
-0.0002219821,
-0.0259303246,
0.0158618167,
0.0195934158,
-0.0088663725,
-0.0559395775,
-0.0089094583,
-0.0150170522,
-0.0376297273,
0.0011503367,
-0.0454056673,
0.0123394001,
0.0015811102,
0.0765748993,
-0.0051352554,
0.0271776821,
0.0254009049,
0.0134361032,
-0.0317379013,
-0.0603991374,
0.0078978771,
-0.0254571736,
-0.0344882756,
-0.0220519677,
-0.0603111535,
0.0080212355,
0.0430894606,
0.0260312762,
0.0230241045,
-0.0109208673,
-0.0137439193,
-0.0109834038,
0.0310432483,
-0.055552423,
0.0124391112,
-0.038763389,
-0.0024170724,
0.0299459696,
-0.0010098083,
0.0833539888,
0.0046265479,
0.0042605032,
-0.0886604488,
-0.0487871133,
-0.0576014109,
-0.0019829478,
-0.0429173224,
0.0178320911,
0.0491159894,
-0.0620197654,
0.0210369416,
-0.012261508,
-0.0300296508,
-0.0391524173,
0.0637711734,
-0.0577120222,
0.0079152444,
0.0283089206,
-0.0175414868,
-0.0645009652,
-0.0096302554,
-0.0320424624,
0.0042001158,
-0.0264044926,
0.0228782985,
-0.0652575418,
-0.0141165182,
0.0395272188,
0.0349385589,
0.0223925207,
-0.0183131695,
0.0081406096,
0.0235680006,
0.0531079024,
0.0145736402,
-0.0149271032,
-0.0529152378,
0.0795400888,
0.0702173635,
0.0004926342,
0.0020939638,
0.0217147861,
-0.0239258315,
0.0171864703,
-0.0246676244,
0.0096344939,
0.0368045531,
0.0499776937,
-0.0450579673,
-0.0268267076,
0.1234517768,
0.0270666685,
-0.0250850897,
0.0265167803,
-0.0456198417,
-0.0096256239,
-0.0053796335,
0.0328618884,
-0.0741776749,
-0.0127875451,
-0.0172772985,
0.0339749567,
-0.0098640192,
0.0156433526,
-0.0099333199,
-0.0489351228,
0.0324547291,
0.0020352234,
-0.0274983943,
-0.0325001553,
0.0013910892,
0.0015131487,
0.0235622674,
-0.0052049607,
0.0083685024,
-0.0217194036,
-0.0185938217,
0.0142315561,
-0.062478669,
-0.0575178042,
0.0465814769,
-0.0019318761,
0.0602787361,
0.0740149096,
0.0181868356,
-0.0214368105,
-0.0114057818,
-0.0042750067,
-0.0263214447,
0.005160003,
0.0119120078,
0.0578366481,
0.0286210738,
0.0000079219,
-0.0482383631,
0.0500811338,
0.0042531844,
-0.042796813,
0.0399599299,
0.0577787235,
-0.0627014711,
-0.018674057,
-0.018790273,
0.0512667075,
0.0428347327,
0.0483156927,
0.0094424346,
-0.0297039412,
0.0006514989,
-0.0117739988,
0.0136364773,
0.0233647134,
-0.0021284835,
-0.0140086683,
-0.0150970574,
0.032941252,
-0.0558822528,
-0.0622962676,
0.0773908272,
0.0039852289,
0.0094208941,
-0.0030216402,
0.0262671653,
0.0387186743,
-0.0191822667,
0.0182054266,
-0.0114719914,
0.0136834951,
-0.0907609314,
-0.0770726353,
0.0194429439,
-0.0147266714,
-0.017726738,
-0.0080114529,
0.0195621736,
-0.0152469203,
0.0233944338,
0.0287872553,
0.0207240991,
-0.0230823308,
0.0412526429,
-0.0205057766,
-0.0096905483,
0.0332052298,
-0.0346191041,
-0.0242738612,
-0.0188008901,
0.0571110435,
0.002628213,
0.0066039544,
-0.0230516549,
0.0237483121,
-0.0074441121,
0.0493433923,
-0.036227107,
-0.046437975,
0.0265765283,
0.0409359597,
-0.0190492515,
0.0186411683,
-0.0051461584,
-0.0380378179,
0.0318297707,
-0.031456925,
-0.0153565202,
-0.0242693312,
-0.0091857826,
-0.0142637631,
-0.0241167489,
0.0321600102,
0.0149298832,
-0.052385103,
-0.0380153582,
-0.0354825556,
0.025125714,
0.0113723129,
-0.0246297549,
0.024585234,
-0.0214428175,
-0.0034285511,
0.0005234299,
0.0234960299,
0.0347551145,
0.0088022631,
0.1245510653,
-0.0094319964,
-0.0028875782,
0.0073370412,
0.0299554709,
-0.0203636996,
-0.066913411,
-0.0059647644,
0.0459752157,
0.0191147327,
0.0322519392,
-0.0179102477,
-0.0387058146,
0.0067233741,
-0.0228138659,
0.0213331506,
-0.0168665256,
-0.0004897425,
0.0650682002,
0.0336825661,
0.0019353823,
-0.0425510556,
0.0447530709,
-0.0125665134,
0.0523093864,
-0.0168521106,
-0.0123036308,
-0.0703726858,
-0.0138029614,
0.0453766882,
-0.0076771886,
-0.0393009819,
0.0006910244,
-0.0578940511,
-0.0247242488,
0.0156310424,
0.0041207229,
-0.0386953801,
-0.0240669101,
0.0967322886,
0.0200381745,
0.003071401,
-0.0172133744,
-0.0518390052,
0.067586422,
-0.0084602507,
0.0074049477,
-0.0246666763,
-5.653040863e-33,
-0.0154021122,
-0.0312191062,
0.0480486937,
0.0020534871,
-0.004414889,
-0.0262357984,
-0.0450519212,
0.0120527195,
-0.0166564249,
0.0302956346,
0.0215624031,
-0.0059171156,
0.0006056781,
0.0397739485,
0.0010187848,
-0.0478447899,
0.0484120399,
0.015743535,
-0.0254448745,
0.0571496971,
-0.0159027856,
0.0500538386,
0.0369647294,
-0.0537593924,
0.0294073746,
-0.0140764741,
0.0162163451,
0.0156292729,
-0.0088322833,
0.0490623601,
-0.0152664036,
0.0458458364,
0.0379854962,
-0.0350636616,
-0.0061709452,
0.0510990433,
-0.0730662048,
-0.0399691649,
0.0350005217,
-0.0295383576,
-0.0399202146,
-0.0585948788,
0.0263061728,
-0.040031068,
-0.0207226593,
-0.0034605735,
0.0188198145,
-0.0143619403,
0.0203129537,
-0.0116145294,
-0.0276963897,
0.0091928896,
-0.0373269543,
-0.020667078,
-0.0349502712,
0.015220711,
-0.0388696156,
-0.0159999765,
-0.0195913278,
0.0386611074,
0.0473661534,
0.0074241203,
0.0096061705,
-0.046760872,
-0.0175596494,
0.0323539674,
0.0110606579,
-0.0031574341,
-0.0372819826,
0.0355393328,
-0.0540252998,
0.0067237807,
0.0414876118,
0.0008508717,
-0.0310025569,
0.014002746,
-0.0691155717,
0.041486714,
-0.0394243635,
0.0632143095,
0.0276699793,
-0.009189399,
-0.0499220304,
-0.0201209281,
-0.0337141678,
0.070721209,
-0.0148600526,
-0.0606274568,
0.0342419185,
-0.0121277105,
-0.0072833453,
-0.0257319212,
-0.0118768886,
-0.0053594992,
0.0135722328,
0.02414486,
0.0486475304,
0.0018722572,
-0.0216835421,
-0.0274648648,
-0.0623067617,
0.0280755553,
0.0235155206,
-0.0065989802,
0.0254377481,
0.0309864506,
-0.0100952219,
-0.0270210467,
-0.0495549813,
0.0114113195,
0.021690635,
0.0420122594,
-0.0253051165,
0.0024001489,
-0.0010577226,
0.0307608265,
-0.0196287576,
0.0868928134,
-0.0143628465,
-0.0788616985,
-0.075164333,
-0.0254744254,
0.0248125605,
0.0106458031,
-0.072325781,
0.0332277566,
-0.0723954439,
0.0640322864,
0.0188707914,
-0.0086797532,
0.0331260338,
0.0141805233,
2.803e-7,
0.0436171181,
0.0455057248,
0.0173737742,
0.0188947525,
0.0184623543,
-0.007528313,
-0.013282286,
-0.0133057274,
0.025298439,
-0.0235652365,
0.0250060484,
0.0090239141,
0.0264480431,
0.0300786644,
-0.0762437284,
-0.0131109916,
-0.0435327478,
-0.0523767099,
-0.0438939855,
0.0162364859,
0.106436871,
0.0357059799,
-0.0568575673,
-0.0086079743,
-0.0289420113,
0.0208621379,
0.0291810948,
-0.0156375598,
-0.0376881622,
0.0376664139,
0.0032458,
-0.0197321381,
0.0140418429,
0.0411921628,
-0.0022770127,
-0.0198503826,
-0.0120696779,
0.0968620479,
-0.0336264893,
-0.0040080338,
-0.0025471263,
-0.0178096481,
0.0049720057,
-0.0162116867,
0.0441638455,
-0.0733670071,
-0.0588543117,
0.0187212881,
-0.0382039882,
-0.0415698774,
0.028472662,
-0.0157140791,
-0.0536556244,
0.0197301377,
0.0001570614,
0.0078311972,
0.0189134926,
-0.0230028369,
0.0175168775,
0.0177256819,
-0.0457599275,
-0.0403786562,
0.0259656422,
-0.0507697873,
-0.0477596,
-0.0513960347,
0.0184147824,
2.070344017e-34,
0.0293271225,
0.0233352408,
0.0084803067,
0.0558179095,
0.0284215491,
0.0123610655,
0.0407007635,
0.0492106006,
0.0475776121,
-0.0985576734,
-0.0222279839
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.