id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17953v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17953v3 | MADGF: Multi-Agent Data Generation Framework | 2023-10-27T08:01:55 | 2024-06-11T12:06:43 | Peng Xie, Kani Chen | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems predominantly cater to monolingual
inputs and struggle with the complexity introduced by mixed language audio. In
this paper, we present a novel Multi-Agent Data Generation Framework (MADGF) to
address this challenge. We finetune the open-source multilingual ASR model,
Whisper, utilizing our generated Mixed Cantonese and English (MCE) audio
dataset, Which achieved an impressive Mix Error Rate (MER) of 14.28%, 35.13%
lower than the original model. Meanwhile, single language recognition ability
is not affected, 12.6% Character Error Rate (CER) in Common voice zh-HK, 14.8%
Word Error Rate (WER) in Common voice en. However, these metrics do not
encompass all aspects critical to the ASR systems. Hence, we propose a novel
evaluation metric called Fidelity to the Original Audio, Accuracy, and Latency
(FAL). | [
-0.0334391445,
0.0250086561,
0.0028762885,
0.0216867924,
-0.0264810715,
-0.0183429755,
0.0789687708,
-0.0203822721,
-0.0018462867,
-0.0010687319,
-0.0686999038,
-0.0451617539,
0.0338517129,
0.0048034997,
0.0224093255,
-0.0453658141,
0.0079875765,
-0.0489225909,
0.0095618749,
-0.0392610095,
-0.012513292,
-0.0092384219,
-0.0089760432,
0.0702184513,
-0.020762803,
0.0142744454,
-0.0270302854,
0.0219209511,
0.0406873785,
0.008172025,
-0.0258631725,
0.0073982067,
-0.007864682,
0.0815204903,
0.000001833,
-0.0354084559,
-0.010515443,
0.0185012612,
-0.0381770544,
-0.0081151342,
0.0135795549,
0.0641906038,
-0.0470752344,
0.0452258773,
-0.0093003633,
-0.0381726883,
0.0524555817,
0.0114089269,
0.0324954242,
0.0826936662,
-0.0070332927,
-0.0323913135,
0.0031802843,
0.0068925186,
-0.0280742869,
-0.0583386049,
-0.0308996104,
0.0034653533,
0.0002502493,
-0.0492804497,
-0.0029317355,
0.0433215536,
0.0058367853,
0.016709825,
-0.0056914035,
-0.001391534,
-0.0393999591,
-0.0320481844,
-0.0326490253,
0.0661771968,
0.0083921887,
-0.0016640068,
0.0101843029,
-0.0038631104,
-0.0189499035,
-0.0308429208,
0.0103475191,
0.0048695351,
-0.0185343008,
0.0104398495,
-0.0178732984,
0.0153254066,
0.033438351,
-0.0224893,
-0.0279657505,
0.0036540462,
-0.002650392,
-0.02087106,
-0.0228169374,
-0.0543224439,
0.0182896685,
-0.0156365782,
0.0419708788,
0.0115169697,
-0.0619388334,
-0.0300886203,
-0.0239189658,
-0.0357879363,
-0.0233090073,
-0.0781381577,
0.0169647988,
0.0489255451,
-0.0442304052,
0.0177435204,
-0.0050044758,
0.0685023814,
0.0015755708,
0.013020861,
-0.0116920378,
-0.018316526,
-0.0175038334,
0.0041799536,
-0.0294080563,
0.0158719718,
-0.0158882607,
-0.0188657232,
-0.0219638553,
0.00940705,
-0.0532526523,
0.0471749417,
0.0285023917,
-0.0209665503,
-0.0551480874,
-0.0309866592,
0.0186000187,
0.0177728664,
-0.0103345364,
0.0643255264,
0.0152099123,
-0.0636367202,
0.0139484312,
0.0262965355,
0.0335091576,
0.0260641873,
-0.0009669383,
0.0883987695,
0.003884139,
-0.0223617516,
-0.0382645167,
0.0018072461,
0.0126046818,
-0.0695604533,
-0.0540985391,
-0.0702756867,
0.053265214,
-0.0321269929,
0.019893581,
-0.0373494476,
0.007843513,
-0.0393853374,
0.0309624858,
0.0619150139,
-0.0179461706,
0.0372601934,
0.0502163246,
0.0059396904,
-0.0291005056,
0.0718521401,
0.0972745642,
-0.0161472391,
0.0380712375,
-0.0332655348,
-0.0103247566,
0.0441825725,
-0.0039534932,
0.0228703134,
0.027291229,
-0.026896853,
-0.0264328755,
0.0260014217,
-0.0206920281,
0.0688834339,
-0.0343187638,
-0.0183885247,
0.0331313871,
0.0339607075,
0.032825347,
0.0037780677,
0.0582709089,
0.0194068626,
-0.0091588115,
0.0035430703,
0.0243547447,
0.0243836474,
0.00587996,
0.0315846764,
0.0645883754,
0.083768934,
-0.0660093054,
-0.0140321488,
-0.0110145668,
-0.0346892849,
0.0077594495,
0.0151498029,
0.0429927036,
-0.0109548941,
-0.0450864322,
0.0055500069,
0.0010931157,
-0.093641378,
0.0464466624,
-0.0431626886,
-0.0007544681,
0.0788364783,
0.0289658494,
-0.0074441666,
0.003347188,
-0.0125011103,
-0.0240607914,
0.0456609838,
0.0162893943,
-0.0229751896,
0.0600593388,
-0.0812147632,
-0.0276382212,
0.0674180239,
-0.0273099989,
0.0793752074,
-0.0278530866,
0.026056353,
0.032289464,
0.0097274845,
-0.0201919507,
-0.0379870385,
-0.0564126074,
-0.0046568918,
0.030685734,
0.0321795642,
0.1104644388,
0.06416329,
-0.0678758398,
0.0026441009,
0.0027038064,
-0.0069027171,
-0.0177643765,
0.0532703549,
-0.0036633802,
-0.0202421993,
0.0585562401,
0.0001867077,
0.0494741984,
0.0048584403,
0.000832943,
-0.0907364935,
0.0432228372,
-0.0013655461,
0.0397592001,
-0.0752234235,
0.0431246981,
0.0316815674,
0.0208891835,
0.043941658,
-0.0112440027,
0.0157734938,
-0.0054683657,
0.0319436453,
0.0571717694,
0.0055497708,
-0.064929001,
-0.0208101925,
0.061837025,
0.0086987894,
0.0653061047,
0.0073187924,
0.0181613006,
-0.0021489013,
-0.0168192666,
-0.0555922762,
-0.0111344224,
-0.0364051014,
-0.0015991894,
-0.0423487909,
0.0331516154,
-0.0029256437,
-0.0294902157,
-0.0457475595,
0.0301228538,
0.0068758889,
-0.0153847951,
-0.068537131,
-0.0030410541,
-0.0512001812,
-0.0028255254,
0.0095522813,
0.0262925215,
-0.0050562834,
-0.0285542905,
0.0016734644,
-0.0678829104,
0.0133822635,
-0.0218105391,
0.0306954253,
0.0041670473,
-0.039922867,
0.0120063527,
0.0070205815,
0.0235866793,
0.0203107037,
-0.0060058031,
-0.0099368151,
0.0036717374,
-0.0321547389,
-0.0447744131,
0.0321034193,
0.0124966735,
0.0386309139,
-0.0209192503,
0.0053957948,
-0.0166080594,
0.0097406078,
0.0282325111,
0.0025950263,
-0.0751896873,
-0.0390942357,
-0.0076942351,
-0.0508283339,
0.0247394256,
-0.0137429452,
-0.0462378003,
0.0190106966,
-0.0129632317,
-0.025278002,
0.0427880883,
-0.0887212381,
-0.0311932694,
-0.0269648507,
-0.025817316,
-0.0144292377,
0.0204378664,
-0.0365830474,
0.0217143483,
-0.0538540371,
-0.0487745069,
-0.0312062278,
-0.0049410318,
0.0390163809,
-0.0585239828,
0.0199569315,
-0.0132640433,
-0.0073833899,
-0.0214382038,
-0.0211297702,
-0.0039560106,
0.0279002842,
-0.0246950556,
0.0376821049,
0.0031384581,
-0.0505030826,
-0.0153422533,
0.067340605,
0.0234272052,
0.0300994087,
0.0054299361,
0.0314959176,
-0.0153987929,
0.0153750824,
-0.0254605412,
0.0537502132,
0.0159017574,
-0.0374874622,
0.0906319842,
-0.00834441,
0.0757849738,
-0.0118940696,
-0.0233605541,
-0.0311760176,
0.0421173461,
0.030825302,
0.0061618597,
0.0204493571,
0.0796063766,
-0.0221263189,
0.0400913022,
0.0817735046,
-0.0174955372,
-0.0278307777,
-0.0232146252,
0.002003429,
0.0408925042,
0.0051348615,
-0.0192921255,
-0.0481089167,
-0.0096692219,
0.063950628,
0.0564290844,
-0.005964478,
0.0251843799,
-0.0107634021,
-0.0680112243,
0.058189895,
0.0461914688,
-0.0583264045,
-0.0503854975,
-0.0435467884,
-0.047304865,
-0.0345340781,
0.0731126145,
0.0128181102,
0.0388857648,
-0.0473891236,
0.0350672752,
-0.039524287,
-0.0575625375,
0.0182810575,
-0.0530679524,
0.1372496337,
0.0609564781,
0.0331961811,
-0.0058367136,
-0.0371499732,
-0.0221092198,
0.029162595,
-0.0101009989,
0.0039853384,
0.0051739933,
0.0108356914,
-0.0159300622,
0.043768663,
0.0101360353,
0.0041297013,
0.020271875,
0.0419885702,
0.0197334643,
-0.0206122585,
0.0098655717,
0.0243227147,
0.0252935756,
0.0088227186,
0.0627590567,
0.0190257393,
-0.0229011457,
-0.0062273382,
0.0112368278,
0.0155970762,
-0.0667503327,
0.0147904176,
0.026051309,
-0.0576392673,
-0.0660786703,
-0.031750448,
-0.0370935984,
-0.0006725146,
0.0373041704,
0.0275343899,
-0.0018581208,
0.0145057663,
0.0433112383,
-0.0109060556,
-0.0590815209,
0.0125076948,
0.0449216627,
-0.0545975268,
-0.0426883064,
0.0003122785,
-0.0634990856,
0.0162686761,
0.0103804674,
-0.0842033774,
-0.0709916279,
0.0197876226,
0.0092747556,
0.0115627795,
0.0379277319,
-0.0233615153,
-0.0251672044,
0.0496838167,
-0.0009975741,
-0.0604972839,
0.0356817879,
0.0739833266,
-0.01289046,
-0.0324186273,
0.0286557358,
-0.0647537336,
0.0184521805,
-0.033916913,
0.039698001,
-0.0185233708,
-0.0377818793,
-0.0273221321,
0.0320880003,
-0.0143510131,
-0.051160939,
0.0138481027,
-0.0430191047,
0.0373122804,
-0.0220774729,
0.0162945334,
-0.0438897759,
-0.0181677565,
0.0079187062,
-0.0026947118,
0.0129919089,
0.0003602548,
-0.0128002465,
-0.0410717204,
0.0427664258,
0.0651719645,
0.0281427577,
0.0124594811,
0.0211052243,
0.0015812682,
-0.0132537549,
0.0308950506,
0.0174583234,
0.0000983754,
0.0296271667,
0.0173782259,
-0.0116551286,
0.0067546843,
0.0282956325,
0.0120081399,
-0.0680028498,
-0.0389617123,
-0.0008677712,
0.0334578529,
0.0434993505,
0.0455093533,
0.0645259544,
-0.0218389668,
0.0280482303,
-0.0617975704,
0.0167851485,
-0.0130069759,
-0.0103035541,
-0.0223854631,
-0.0104459049,
-0.0141296824,
0.0126050171,
0.0733991638,
-0.0018041237,
0.0230434816,
-0.0553669333,
0.0374071524,
-0.0267258827,
-0.0521393791,
-0.0182243623,
0.0162708107,
-0.0363317803,
-0.0153697813,
-0.0359581262,
-0.0548984073,
0.014680557,
0.0298801027,
0.035359893,
0.0136487745,
-0.0150806308,
0.0366833732,
-0.030628087,
0.0213707052,
-0.0452472866,
-0.0807987005,
0.0028687268,
0.0053653293,
0.066438593,
-5.609564102e-33,
-0.0469784662,
-0.0087366989,
0.0185525883,
0.0268351305,
-0.0197426025,
0.0059741396,
-0.0323173143,
-0.0092775691,
0.0064658024,
-0.0267689303,
-0.0078691002,
0.0079935333,
0.0287512187,
0.0059967004,
0.0004676929,
0.0086892284,
0.0761742964,
-0.0308628101,
0.0021965073,
0.0064821849,
0.0577034093,
0.0386602506,
-0.0063350154,
-0.0158701763,
-0.0078779059,
0.0053176521,
-0.0221093502,
-0.0340914465,
0.0007090179,
0.0457958989,
0.025498325,
0.0353207625,
-0.0334102325,
0.0006759151,
-0.0409821309,
-0.0407152176,
-0.0512652472,
-0.005751146,
-0.0321893431,
0.0720355064,
0.0055083851,
-0.005928128,
-0.0199574754,
-0.0025721316,
-0.0602146685,
-0.0125593999,
0.0052147224,
-0.0245559532,
-0.0311894342,
-0.0240296554,
0.0051849415,
0.0555374175,
-0.0202820841,
-0.0177080184,
0.0742711127,
0.0428849049,
-0.0357198119,
-0.0494865589,
-0.0848081559,
0.0538929217,
-0.0199732631,
0.0061616721,
0.0429291204,
0.0742234588,
0.0218299534,
0.0280796308,
0.1133077368,
-0.0448281839,
-0.0021143702,
-0.0214083325,
0.0257940143,
0.0340435691,
0.0029652042,
0.0715683401,
-0.0324201062,
-0.0540597476,
-0.0083346302,
0.0153758014,
0.0517474227,
-0.0293443333,
0.0195419602,
0.0314060971,
-0.057361342,
-0.0056059989,
-0.0404496789,
-0.0304531436,
-0.022164287,
-0.0412696488,
0.0436708853,
0.0125169335,
0.0089154234,
-0.0426900871,
0.084802635,
-0.0307572596,
0.0248143338,
-0.0256659444,
-0.0019656825,
-0.0128417835,
-0.0175680462,
0.0005126221,
-0.042117577,
-0.0343974419,
0.061940264,
0.0434420854,
-0.0079421047,
-0.0437691174,
0.0016690086,
0.0818881243,
-0.0459697805,
0.019253552,
0.0282754414,
0.0097082099,
0.0385721922,
-0.0065105138,
0.0098691555,
-0.0495960638,
-0.0047016232,
0.035634771,
-0.0032210485,
-0.0038438661,
-0.0060413722,
0.0015413092,
-0.0322384685,
-0.0005482077,
-0.0442940481,
0.0290090628,
-0.0244786665,
-0.0272425041,
0.0310946945,
-0.0078459801,
-0.0192256439,
-0.0033921562,
2.742e-7,
-0.0726452768,
-0.0395952389,
0.0517736562,
-0.0145345181,
0.00419479,
0.0319887325,
-0.05291605,
0.0017515143,
-0.0278314725,
0.0443038978,
0.0339256339,
0.0032113234,
0.0916258842,
0.0351269394,
-0.0715432763,
-0.0052111289,
-0.0471611135,
0.0171911661,
-0.0024794315,
-0.0119042844,
-0.0185752492,
0.0412587337,
0.0160788093,
-0.011927221,
0.026808599,
-0.0160344504,
0.0280235298,
-0.0038924266,
-0.0028673455,
0.0166105237,
0.0144713838,
-0.0207501873,
-0.0003098642,
0.0045200186,
-0.0375791825,
0.0255593508,
0.0205749832,
0.0324628204,
0.000077841,
-0.0876880959,
0.0032933571,
0.01726868,
-0.0244084876,
0.0037319819,
0.0159753114,
0.0671036988,
-0.0395735949,
-0.0045683593,
-0.0379413106,
0.0066116857,
0.0300268698,
-0.0238896962,
-0.0020894022,
0.0152062671,
0.0021340253,
-0.0107613876,
0.021638222,
-0.0305801053,
0.0191506129,
-0.0286864471,
-0.0494612753,
-0.0545938276,
0.0098795602,
-0.0014590535,
0.0151912179,
0.0019014766,
0.004017761,
1.605404663e-34,
0.0457230471,
-0.0228052493,
0.0060371598,
0.0298500191,
0.0110124396,
-0.0651283637,
-0.0149933975,
-0.0024651706,
0.0017668217,
-0.0037931483,
-0.0631179512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17940v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17940v4 | Unified Segment-to-Segment Framework for Simultaneous Sequence Generation | 2023-10-27T07:34:51 | 2023-11-30T08:26:16 | Shaolei Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Simultaneous sequence generation is a pivotal task for real-time scenarios,
such as streaming speech recognition, simultaneous machine translation and
simultaneous speech translation, where the target sequence is generated while
receiving the source sequence. The crux of achieving high-quality generation
with low latency lies in identifying the optimal moments for generating,
accomplished by learning a mapping between the source and target sequences.
However, existing methods often rely on task-specific heuristics for different
sequence types, limiting the model's capacity to adaptively learn the
source-target mapping and hindering the exploration of multi-task learning for
various simultaneous tasks. In this paper, we propose a unified
segment-to-segment framework (Seg2Seg) for simultaneous sequence generation,
which learns the mapping in an adaptive and unified manner. During the process
of simultaneous generation, the model alternates between waiting for a source
segment and generating a target segment, making the segment serve as the
natural bridge between the source and target. To accomplish this, Seg2Seg
introduces a latent segment as the pivot between source to target and explores
all potential source-target mappings via the proposed expectation training,
thereby learning the optimal moments for generating. Experiments on multiple
simultaneous generation tasks demonstrate that Seg2Seg achieves
state-of-the-art performance and exhibits better generality across various
tasks. | [
0.0142057138,
0.0420383923,
0.0192760415,
-0.0427705422,
-0.026831964,
0.0010417609,
0.0304562338,
-0.0375575572,
-0.0855919123,
-0.026827164,
-0.0220422838,
-0.0782042742,
0.0061146566,
0.0344447829,
0.030817505,
-0.0643562526,
0.0249774475,
0.0012132367,
0.0083585633,
0.0156525988,
-0.0024393736,
0.0125604002,
-0.0202001426,
0.0471753851,
-0.0524159446,
0.0330357552,
-0.0389018282,
0.0118376082,
0.0336462371,
-0.0562605262,
0.0084226886,
0.0389770679,
0.0070652007,
0.0364021882,
0.0000017733,
0.0013444602,
-0.0250341073,
-0.0223907642,
-0.0018569941,
-0.0154329585,
0.0193370059,
-0.011238141,
-0.0536398031,
0.040236447,
-0.0336805396,
-0.0015949188,
0.0492835715,
0.0311745405,
0.0286741462,
0.0687962547,
-0.024497889,
-0.0338435024,
-0.0023857672,
-0.0778123364,
0.0196985994,
-0.0011166638,
-0.0147591615,
-0.0125067914,
-0.0278633423,
-0.0169174466,
-0.0043825284,
0.0358272903,
0.0478153862,
-0.0228031576,
0.014614759,
0.0400189534,
-0.0176810063,
-0.0543085262,
-0.0334973149,
0.0515496321,
-0.0515046343,
0.0179314185,
0.0308830068,
-0.0137544265,
-0.0003768583,
-0.0458000302,
-0.0260175485,
0.0310797859,
-0.0118394056,
0.0243395306,
-0.0256392993,
-0.0054166326,
0.0237457901,
-0.0340218209,
-0.0137622133,
-0.0119219525,
0.0344672799,
0.0026407707,
-0.0333997831,
0.0110723143,
-0.0554373674,
-0.044486966,
0.0341879316,
0.0368213505,
-0.0456010327,
0.0323089845,
-0.0861530229,
-0.0688272491,
-0.0023719117,
0.0005482197,
0.0507965013,
0.0586663149,
0.0102201328,
-0.0088885454,
-0.064935036,
0.0279840212,
-0.0029307886,
-0.0132016316,
-0.0508963354,
0.0060851467,
-0.0335009396,
0.0228272695,
-0.0157513823,
0.0133183738,
-0.0599105917,
-0.0602857433,
-0.0681815669,
0.0321110263,
0.0002299976,
0.0010244529,
0.0282340441,
0.0169547722,
-0.0898271278,
-0.0062038582,
0.0330407582,
0.014493919,
-0.0008937095,
0.0397629514,
0.0552283153,
-0.0234893579,
-0.0262613539,
0.0279926546,
0.0115488777,
-0.0054442058,
-0.0054555079,
0.0360361598,
-0.0463902242,
-0.0187394861,
-0.0499305725,
-0.0353388973,
-0.0440223403,
-0.0247787479,
0.0499581285,
-0.0486373678,
0.0330522507,
-0.0190235991,
-0.045029331,
0.0270268172,
0.0266722664,
-0.0259941481,
0.0197486393,
0.0522015467,
0.0256518498,
-0.0090538915,
0.0546623357,
0.0362036601,
0.0297818519,
0.0694508106,
0.0586408228,
0.0285643414,
-0.0072554215,
0.0303177442,
-0.0291843005,
0.0613511167,
0.0449425243,
0.0076891654,
0.0081467498,
-0.0240976959,
0.024524698,
0.0466320477,
0.0615341403,
0.044223845,
-0.0368313827,
0.0015261882,
0.0486823283,
0.0242361613,
0.0156905688,
0.0445377268,
0.1064408869,
0.0025564148,
-0.0603928044,
0.0398380496,
0.0251964945,
0.060818471,
0.0654877052,
0.0410404764,
0.0647985935,
0.0273766406,
-0.0301574115,
-0.029677419,
0.0281580798,
-0.0350769013,
-0.0245129578,
-0.0259836689,
0.029617846,
0.0259165075,
-0.0964246467,
0.0593865961,
-0.016134942,
-0.0697167367,
0.0267795529,
-0.0157739427,
-0.0304885767,
0.0397765078,
0.0078051565,
0.0164752044,
-0.0788199827,
-0.0095235975,
-0.0023233185,
0.0474589951,
-0.0174839683,
-0.0185951665,
0.0515368767,
-0.0423294567,
-0.0324686281,
0.0193901565,
-0.0034464644,
0.0662522539,
0.0059373579,
0.0183938164,
0.0526000373,
0.0150385965,
0.0209375825,
0.0035544594,
-0.05015916,
-0.0056410334,
0.0388046689,
0.0072413106,
0.0279099979,
-0.0025895776,
-0.014409841,
0.0372188129,
0.0215698276,
-0.035549745,
-0.0086645298,
0.042228017,
-0.09275233,
-0.0319456048,
0.0326375067,
-0.0298555046,
0.0220839903,
0.0276597366,
-0.0023431215,
-0.0860237479,
0.0178429261,
0.0041552456,
0.0002904894,
-0.0345163234,
0.0171215981,
0.0744520426,
0.0098317107,
-0.0192321315,
-0.0133738471,
-0.0177287571,
-0.0019727156,
0.0322579816,
0.0151877962,
-0.0151964622,
-0.0638718829,
0.021487698,
0.0234579686,
-0.0072515216,
-0.0022236225,
-0.0059256027,
0.0186046548,
-0.0419146642,
-0.062662378,
-0.070554316,
0.0026332459,
-0.0081439801,
0.0582425706,
0.0303551797,
-0.006294095,
-0.0059098722,
-0.0023179145,
-0.0271693077,
-0.0053101005,
0.0285169091,
-0.0234901477,
-0.0109583391,
0.0316143371,
-0.0183946937,
-0.0116900718,
0.0079031177,
0.0126130152,
0.025354825,
-0.0211443882,
-0.009492062,
-0.029146092,
-0.0301423389,
0.0168586243,
0.026418779,
0.0058498695,
-0.0153694181,
0.0013856404,
0.0107822018,
0.0591832884,
0.0061588716,
0.0339761302,
-0.0023163436,
-0.0061753346,
-0.0617324561,
0.0122443195,
0.0128089236,
-0.0245583244,
0.0367656201,
-0.037936192,
-0.0112276571,
0.0244152173,
0.0472447351,
0.012085842,
-0.0016544305,
-0.0561176911,
-0.0317526273,
0.0321289189,
-0.0628017038,
0.0109456582,
-0.0492221043,
-0.0286942162,
-0.0193270296,
-0.0267386846,
-0.0344928354,
0.0152102523,
-0.0611873381,
-0.021403322,
-0.0484979674,
0.0087599205,
-0.0003288307,
0.0462579653,
-0.0113894008,
0.0118459314,
-0.0117832776,
-0.059044227,
-0.069378607,
0.064786315,
0.0127161359,
-0.02063209,
0.031365443,
-0.0436364077,
-0.0201744791,
-0.0479225144,
-0.0210975185,
-0.0347962715,
0.058186084,
0.0298976395,
0.0343502425,
0.0688838437,
-0.0348992161,
-0.0409774929,
0.003688216,
-0.0079523316,
0.0532579906,
-0.0188381877,
-0.0148755964,
0.0031198792,
0.0735205337,
0.0420408361,
0.0210349187,
-0.0186066441,
-0.0218891669,
-0.0003158191,
0.0350134782,
0.1026527658,
-0.0014537483,
-0.0255890843,
-0.0133263953,
0.0311527103,
-0.0187896341,
-0.0067815525,
0.0200018659,
0.0331464261,
-0.0272165723,
0.0091108456,
0.1052728519,
-0.0008314492,
-0.0172575824,
-0.0018190275,
0.0004454654,
0.0305823404,
0.0025798196,
0.0092114219,
-0.0696897209,
-0.0024682735,
0.0000012546,
0.0276447013,
0.0146100251,
0.0137725826,
-0.0411870778,
-0.0648376495,
0.0416241623,
0.0280222595,
-0.0608316734,
-0.0389121473,
0.0091344202,
-0.0276599098,
0.0016869463,
0.0330640823,
0.0070894361,
-0.002365323,
0.0284374245,
0.058062762,
-0.0121746212,
-0.0471713357,
-0.0183946956,
-0.0334064662,
0.0395891257,
0.0731162056,
0.0271514915,
0.0566023551,
-0.0094510559,
0.0318465419,
-0.04463939,
-0.0014995029,
0.009495928,
-0.0063404464,
-0.0148797138,
-0.005204936,
-0.0070087733,
0.0235129539,
0.0070679095,
0.0003679273,
0.0017363717,
0.0232500564,
-0.0112052262,
0.010291405,
-0.0203100126,
0.0096836071,
0.0529575348,
0.0334261991,
0.014805547,
-0.0404344574,
-0.0207496379,
-0.0040054014,
0.0186154433,
-0.104629308,
0.0130864652,
-0.0039539263,
0.015003412,
-0.0645074993,
-0.0872636884,
-0.0225038081,
-0.0013917645,
0.0968585014,
0.0058001494,
0.0122368177,
0.0022650321,
-0.0056209643,
-0.0418608934,
-0.0535674244,
0.0188289229,
-0.0069373958,
-0.0453584716,
-0.0123632802,
0.0120382309,
-0.0388671868,
-0.0001991621,
0.0249011163,
-0.1098336354,
-0.0681062266,
-0.0318042673,
0.0134268058,
0.0116910134,
0.0732154027,
-0.0069466056,
0.0208604299,
0.0460480601,
0.0435969718,
-0.0258382745,
0.0112230647,
0.0674121156,
0.0109558264,
-0.0352183133,
0.0100567359,
-0.0256822929,
0.0262202565,
-0.0053633284,
0.0602349415,
0.0044473866,
-0.0360321663,
-0.0055656685,
0.0072353715,
0.048431173,
-0.0540504567,
0.0550882258,
-0.0227576587,
0.033259742,
0.0169428606,
0.0506854095,
-0.0587848872,
0.0069024358,
0.0273313932,
0.0145599376,
0.0154756252,
0.0169253647,
0.0263230689,
-0.013154461,
-0.0370345339,
0.003134575,
-0.0138222165,
-0.009381067,
-0.001206274,
0.0057027135,
0.0073572923,
-0.0094030472,
0.0280800872,
0.0037785084,
-0.0494463257,
0.0456498489,
0.0309637301,
0.045221474,
0.0413136631,
0.0211729761,
-0.0213044193,
0.0202173144,
-0.0706764683,
-0.0159747209,
0.0856244117,
0.006057783,
0.065703176,
-0.0235987194,
0.0134054897,
-0.0353854038,
0.0692203045,
-0.0535032973,
-0.0373259336,
0.0052654771,
-0.0146413669,
-0.0053665373,
0.007170524,
0.0882318094,
-0.0311590396,
0.0538104549,
-0.0083299857,
0.0045146104,
-0.0428601056,
-0.0579331592,
-0.0026599998,
-0.0640580282,
-0.0339908004,
-0.0209208112,
0.0095442487,
-0.0361896008,
0.0246621426,
0.011214151,
0.0300911441,
0.0050527002,
0.0596790463,
0.059684176,
-0.0503927805,
0.027165072,
-0.0142779136,
-0.0482587256,
0.0001208821,
-0.0243919846,
0.0321658067,
-5.621492431e-33,
-0.036140155,
-0.012831971,
0.0333186798,
-0.0313553736,
-0.0514422059,
-0.0007335823,
-0.0278616901,
0.0167486724,
0.0245774277,
-0.0259604249,
-0.0056188302,
-0.0035978141,
0.037782155,
0.0196327027,
0.0147340912,
0.0153622394,
0.0901850984,
-0.0281197317,
-0.0239191577,
0.0262439623,
0.0327416398,
0.0309879277,
0.0419310667,
0.0038508154,
-0.0321242735,
0.0223402865,
-0.0128328009,
-0.0430428348,
0.0302180015,
0.033973787,
0.0284410007,
0.004152576,
-0.0127629824,
-0.0798143595,
-0.0460311957,
0.0261087492,
-0.0588818453,
0.0012279415,
-0.0258679278,
-0.0048487661,
-0.0697773546,
-0.0426183827,
0.0024843251,
-0.0014145648,
-0.0018523332,
-0.0136609403,
0.0114150336,
-0.0218085106,
-0.030277228,
-0.060766466,
-0.0293350387,
0.0045336951,
-0.0217381045,
-0.016297644,
0.036998421,
0.0607162379,
0.0057765548,
-0.0857949778,
-0.0372826271,
0.0535422042,
0.0119300811,
0.0701999068,
0.0547218099,
0.0106297079,
0.0010142244,
0.0340392143,
0.038644772,
-0.0497655123,
0.0090839295,
0.0272471886,
-0.0011723166,
0.0262423456,
0.0001512929,
-0.0122848377,
-0.0029623485,
-0.034642037,
-0.0657922924,
0.0375652425,
0.0174200814,
-0.0181141589,
0.0211677477,
0.0187357366,
0.021373285,
0.0150111858,
-0.03056949,
-0.0087146992,
0.013431889,
-0.0361256972,
0.0437795073,
0.0771260783,
0.0398654714,
0.0248280782,
0.0788505971,
0.0321958251,
0.0271705985,
-0.0030089943,
-0.0504850708,
-0.0056960797,
-0.0109054791,
-0.0064172652,
-0.0629491955,
-0.0199250728,
0.0875174254,
0.0169568341,
-0.0138528598,
-0.0203958154,
0.0035348351,
0.0438688323,
-0.0406495519,
0.0133277411,
-0.0388842374,
0.0898633078,
0.0196755938,
0.0094904331,
0.0536153466,
-0.0545299351,
-0.028628936,
0.0140687656,
-0.0372047648,
-0.0248950142,
-0.0107555455,
0.0169735067,
0.0060953978,
0.0326940827,
-0.0426431708,
0.0431905463,
-0.0220144745,
0.001575582,
0.0152644692,
-0.0334248766,
-0.0588246025,
0.0269458294,
2.585e-7,
0.006448627,
0.0012689709,
0.039815966,
0.0007185583,
0.0351406634,
0.0143034067,
-0.0339032114,
0.0470900163,
-0.0231382549,
0.0453400239,
0.0240481347,
-0.0424787179,
0.0483539663,
0.0090902047,
-0.0779922009,
-0.0323122628,
-0.0619262718,
0.0557361282,
-0.0198126379,
0.0093041277,
-0.0170217752,
0.0309626739,
-0.0521568283,
-0.0107157761,
0.0375890695,
-0.0073302351,
0.055290807,
0.0197639819,
0.0053398865,
-0.017992381,
0.0015322029,
-0.0170600899,
-0.0431176201,
0.0147620915,
-0.0553153902,
-0.0045512542,
0.042811811,
0.0518898666,
0.0349590108,
-0.0686833337,
0.0354398265,
0.0396880023,
-0.0004740025,
0.0084642656,
0.0373249985,
-0.0540629514,
-0.0375308208,
0.0127957677,
-0.0505282283,
0.0529007837,
-0.0302975718,
-0.0252216514,
0.0023821515,
0.0065642619,
0.0292086601,
0.0339867137,
0.012412766,
-0.0369177647,
0.0104120914,
0.0155537864,
-0.05022154,
-0.0324193649,
-0.0740424097,
0.0243323948,
0.0312084351,
-0.0122460295,
-0.0481094457,
2.197264346e-34,
-0.0077264612,
-0.0380614623,
-0.0089608962,
0.0037276433,
-0.0218666624,
-0.0260617491,
-0.0322957262,
0.0014852926,
-0.0076332828,
-0.0222001877,
-0.0905339047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17936v1 | Transformers as Graph-to-Graph Models | 2023-10-27T07:21:37 | 2023-10-27T07:21:37 | James Henderson, Alireza Mohammadshahi, Andrei C. Coman, Lesly Miculicich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We argue that Transformers are essentially graph-to-graph models, with
sequences just being a special case. Attention weights are functionally
equivalent to graph edges. Our Graph-to-Graph Transformer architecture makes
this ability explicit, by inputting graph edges into the attention weight
computations and predicting graph edges with attention-like functions, thereby
integrating explicit graphs into the latent graphs learned by pretrained
Transformers. Adding iterative graph refinement provides a joint embedding of
input, output, and latent graphs, allowing non-autoregressive graph prediction
to optimise the complete graph without any bespoke pipeline or decoding
strategy. Empirical results show that this architecture achieves
state-of-the-art accuracies for modelling a variety of linguistic structures,
integrating very effectively with the latent linguistic representations learned
by pretraining. | [
0.0347997434,
0.0609198585,
0.0011996205,
0.0239682868,
-0.020268105,
-0.0132312262,
-0.0159425214,
-0.0322614387,
0.0101482365,
-0.0193598662,
-0.0383067317,
-0.0078676799,
0.008601605,
0.0464918651,
0.0405253209,
-0.0455550514,
0.0312793814,
0.0068596159,
-0.0149091873,
0.0063591781,
-0.0164836142,
0.0037334119,
0.0317588113,
0.0474047959,
-0.0244836342,
-0.0174978916,
-0.0165915973,
0.0138365654,
-0.0166490711,
-0.030827431,
-0.0027565267,
0.024174124,
0.0314276107,
0.0165443886,
0.0000016438,
0.0345641635,
0.0066790837,
-0.0014319402,
-0.0292925444,
-0.0274910647,
0.0585617498,
-0.0462757461,
0.0165031534,
-0.0136753554,
-0.0366951823,
-0.0620464608,
0.0749319345,
0.0299665798,
0.0776277184,
0.0844514519,
-0.0315127671,
-0.0649149343,
0.0223704111,
-0.0440464057,
-0.0151831387,
-0.0268756561,
0.0007157266,
-0.0324054956,
-0.0164196976,
-0.0206434689,
-0.0727302358,
0.0248189084,
0.0214112066,
0.0023461666,
0.0546092689,
0.0101949014,
0.0019171003,
-0.0264716018,
-0.0201364234,
0.0993219167,
-0.0396378711,
-0.0376446247,
-0.0123777995,
-0.0025328654,
0.0021181917,
-0.015603072,
-0.0325418003,
-0.0099839792,
0.0267118495,
0.0177857317,
-0.0279694963,
-0.022071505,
0.042575743,
-0.0536310747,
-0.0284677204,
0.0453382619,
0.0171258133,
-0.0022416816,
0.0068744398,
0.0155168166,
-0.0134713706,
-0.0338823572,
0.0164353196,
0.0340779498,
-0.0190990772,
0.0054030372,
-0.0316706263,
-0.0358336121,
-0.0396642275,
0.0157484338,
0.0618790798,
0.0245759264,
-0.0032240667,
0.0059513748,
-0.0076066004,
0.0657031164,
-0.0658536032,
0.0796843395,
-0.0763426349,
0.0072370237,
-0.0133564835,
0.0101285111,
-0.0728289187,
0.0252828691,
0.0213288609,
-0.0736706257,
-0.0469157584,
0.0534772538,
-0.0066415211,
-0.0362431444,
0.0605107024,
0.0484832115,
-0.0311252847,
0.0048962887,
0.0214367621,
0.0807176232,
0.0330879726,
-0.0035545025,
0.0193856582,
-0.002080847,
-0.033538755,
0.0413765311,
0.0353334509,
-0.0289402083,
0.0003504181,
0.0941437632,
0.0054289582,
-0.0624635369,
-0.0004414332,
-0.0018455856,
-0.0292983707,
-0.0308461394,
0.0728876144,
-0.0222560521,
0.0464658923,
0.0183138624,
0.0053195097,
-0.0351732075,
0.0100953402,
0.0051449803,
-0.0316480994,
0.047306031,
0.0243084785,
-0.0036391045,
-0.030381145,
-0.0381972641,
-0.0111538181,
0.0175214596,
0.0332643203,
0.0248916931,
-0.0115776062,
-0.015649708,
-0.0263485517,
0.0325359963,
0.0554820411,
-0.0177624952,
0.0227414127,
-0.0315651558,
-0.0506966114,
-0.0099301627,
0.055525057,
0.0629770383,
-0.0423011482,
-0.0399821438,
0.0472851507,
0.0294331517,
0.0567420609,
0.0275805742,
0.0545971803,
0.0111063691,
-0.0265096053,
0.0362807326,
-0.0600526147,
0.0388395749,
0.0439613089,
0.014201534,
0.0033424241,
-0.0033002733,
-0.0349710397,
0.0117257545,
0.0280058645,
-0.0293738451,
0.0706682131,
-0.0355628543,
0.0270645302,
0.0684456378,
-0.0716101527,
0.0878969878,
0.0017893574,
-0.0160512701,
0.0038776572,
-0.0201397073,
-0.0326840021,
0.0218120944,
0.0112155201,
0.024925204,
-0.0103806835,
0.0027421594,
-0.019307645,
0.022348024,
0.0164904278,
0.0084528793,
-0.0120862955,
-0.0359945707,
-0.023646215,
-0.0255992748,
-0.0067980108,
0.020394614,
0.0024308742,
-0.0229648799,
0.0080021434,
-0.063515313,
-0.0065062772,
-0.0045458726,
0.045334138,
-0.0071911644,
-0.0171371512,
0.0114663262,
0.0247646254,
0.0074908347,
0.027098218,
0.0566611253,
0.0300756898,
-0.0187216382,
-0.0308582522,
0.0164876413,
-0.074872613,
-0.0416935347,
0.0269016698,
-0.0572104603,
-0.012782325,
0.0437288359,
-0.045957461,
-0.045381587,
0.070988588,
-0.121658273,
0.0615978763,
-0.0052548675,
-0.0043327953,
0.0321011059,
0.0432993211,
-0.0033709502,
0.0315470174,
-0.0103263156,
0.0031540683,
-0.0065579009,
0.0057260222,
-0.0174814537,
-0.0324853435,
-0.0030203185,
0.0067481892,
-0.005508658,
0.0078390567,
0.0118428105,
-0.017703522,
-0.0150818657,
-0.0188387297,
-0.0464599468,
-0.0174312275,
-0.0328336805,
0.0285151079,
0.0185404997,
0.0100737335,
0.0421417765,
-0.0259247422,
-0.0417844839,
0.0553198233,
0.0216568653,
0.0414134674,
0.019864602,
-0.0317664742,
-0.0004790665,
-0.0073685055,
-0.0701665282,
-0.0262984987,
0.1053253487,
-0.0048063509,
-0.0322880931,
-0.0276949555,
-0.0165722631,
-0.0199426655,
0.031628415,
-0.0051035853,
-0.0247933529,
0.0151214367,
-0.0047306255,
0.0677363127,
0.0410458371,
0.0031176368,
0.0320786275,
0.0186668448,
-0.019373754,
0.0069299559,
-0.0010167642,
-0.0788844004,
-0.0271878,
-0.0445850268,
-0.0000789803,
-0.0183755793,
0.0660580322,
-0.0075690662,
-0.0061355308,
-0.0805380419,
-0.0282091573,
0.012974144,
0.0210265201,
0.0338625833,
-0.0252500027,
-0.0230007898,
-0.0291700028,
-0.0494517609,
0.0035839763,
0.0749889091,
-0.0031659256,
-0.027484471,
0.0203770399,
0.0224538986,
-0.0338079855,
0.0464863777,
0.0854227915,
0.0146309296,
-0.0189204775,
-0.0359896086,
-0.0534778349,
0.0352193862,
0.0307197105,
-0.0341013558,
0.0433731042,
0.0323356874,
0.0173215177,
-0.0139333494,
-0.0082269544,
-0.0055723768,
0.0346905477,
-0.0178980939,
0.035398744,
0.0446153022,
-0.0394111276,
-0.0421565399,
0.0227985457,
-0.0196504071,
0.0226688515,
-0.0185836535,
0.0137317879,
-0.0308116749,
0.0493591242,
0.0288870018,
0.0219003111,
0.0124534201,
-0.0510854311,
-0.0190439373,
0.0482545979,
0.0125342347,
-0.0047937618,
-0.0657686815,
0.0315671563,
0.003082725,
0.0042740889,
-0.0097005405,
-0.0176310167,
0.0209925622,
-0.0322856084,
-0.0033295937,
0.0462527201,
-0.0203720517,
-0.0668309256,
0.0135053834,
0.0189282931,
0.0243758541,
0.0281713288,
0.0069168857,
-0.1043773443,
-0.0281496085,
-0.0266897678,
0.0217246916,
0.0442634895,
-0.031849809,
-0.0122964103,
-0.0607153475,
0.0194599293,
0.0331217684,
0.0027130865,
-0.0379269347,
-0.0291434098,
-0.0122144418,
-0.0023487329,
0.0006714486,
-0.008456165,
-0.0209337063,
0.0012274355,
0.0194287226,
-0.0231867023,
-0.0077106236,
0.0109445313,
0.0229019336,
-0.0240552556,
0.0079158545,
0.0187333692,
0.0438030735,
-0.0310547836,
0.0384516604,
-0.0095744571,
0.0030077312,
0.0119293509,
0.0582199953,
-0.0105450125,
-0.0211708751,
-0.0400495119,
-0.0096900519,
-0.0384123847,
0.0045098541,
-0.0802977383,
0.0828520879,
-0.0031384386,
-0.0546851456,
0.0020398232,
-0.0032471409,
-0.0156554636,
-0.0023600501,
0.0590975694,
-0.0171901844,
-0.0598986112,
-0.0149082085,
0.0454431437,
-0.0378963836,
-0.0705405399,
0.0230526663,
0.0084880125,
-0.0576265305,
-0.0487111621,
-0.0434939861,
-0.0139721716,
-0.0048204642,
0.0011784751,
-0.0797692239,
0.0831467733,
-0.0545974448,
-0.0789264515,
0.0154218981,
-0.0157985482,
0.0084740575,
-0.0542934015,
-0.0166484155,
0.0351345725,
0.021874221,
-0.0073597245,
0.025418913,
-0.1094274074,
-0.0629561543,
0.0094551388,
0.0535808951,
0.0069247792,
0.0452647544,
-0.0133740697,
0.0007850315,
0.0584170483,
0.0072715594,
-0.0407762788,
0.0080813942,
0.048494827,
-0.0285232365,
-0.0199448764,
0.0352707878,
-0.0230657421,
0.0431342237,
0.0209975559,
0.0509199724,
-0.0098272664,
-0.0662807897,
0.0335591398,
0.0166291799,
0.0565252528,
0.0517082736,
0.0508996919,
-0.0130752334,
0.0182539411,
0.0137970718,
0.0107613495,
-0.0635009184,
-0.0442597531,
0.0246471446,
-0.0032687313,
0.0002332116,
-0.0024914835,
0.0070107332,
0.0285120234,
-0.017291924,
0.0100163938,
-0.0272529572,
-0.0265599489,
0.0317525528,
0.0278933793,
-0.0122137899,
0.0097331358,
0.0163427629,
0.016027974,
-0.0048455908,
0.0115669742,
0.0258029941,
0.0278393514,
-0.0264218897,
0.0208625346,
-0.0640042573,
0.0015047914,
-0.0351323336,
-0.0476242341,
0.0412341394,
0.0137797967,
0.0617075972,
-0.0044511897,
-0.0089565767,
-0.0187198818,
0.0708026513,
-0.0372539945,
-0.0532454029,
0.0408549793,
0.0057939193,
0.0111548714,
0.0053336537,
0.036796581,
0.0173012912,
0.0122324945,
0.0052563054,
-0.0163575392,
-0.038929414,
-0.064421609,
-0.0428240895,
-0.0186180659,
-0.0034799075,
0.0166602582,
-0.0035805868,
-0.1032072753,
0.0358370692,
-0.0300492551,
0.0003034788,
-0.0123289386,
0.0417473465,
0.0083524324,
0.0134656746,
-0.0481038466,
-0.0072046355,
0.0439644307,
0.0053866091,
-0.0071348902,
-0.0206259303,
-5.75713603e-33,
-0.0250170454,
-0.0487696603,
0.0121208271,
0.0353108533,
-0.0538633652,
0.0110244714,
-0.0773060843,
0.0048808027,
-0.0318247937,
0.0173630156,
-0.0066697975,
0.0149939107,
-0.0023902964,
0.0492885225,
-0.0141568808,
-0.0238841753,
0.0787771568,
-0.0072732661,
-0.007695294,
0.0385186113,
0.0063038119,
0.025838498,
0.0669199526,
-0.0305312406,
-0.0314358659,
0.0096635083,
0.0088072922,
0.0019940098,
0.0123763457,
0.0409187041,
-0.0102185952,
0.063455537,
0.0259058923,
-0.011857803,
-0.0270980615,
0.0161366351,
-0.0972829759,
-0.0290550385,
-0.0185575467,
0.0296104383,
-0.0441669449,
-0.0276426692,
0.0547673553,
0.0086068148,
0.0223227926,
-0.0611086227,
0.0189836714,
0.0302730929,
-0.0259481035,
0.0076518301,
-0.0242780391,
0.0016005343,
0.001486537,
0.0014600143,
0.0249082167,
0.0624367669,
0.0014602297,
0.0000457172,
-0.0786109343,
0.0211595148,
-0.0547804683,
0.0369272828,
0.0078644706,
0.0262833238,
0.0076596113,
0.0101133678,
-0.0027220517,
-0.0328506902,
-0.0430820137,
-0.0006122348,
0.0260594133,
0.0433448441,
-0.0004657818,
-0.0548131131,
-0.0299748778,
-0.0047413977,
-0.0415830202,
-0.0475506485,
-0.0263202153,
0.0849085972,
0.0106329443,
0.0230384469,
0.0408481397,
-0.0296194181,
0.005015071,
-0.0139914574,
-0.0267565791,
-0.0275488589,
0.0050920807,
0.0146852694,
0.0026297008,
0.0439600609,
0.0145648494,
-0.0449469574,
0.0092512108,
0.0488080643,
-0.0009968727,
0.040344011,
-0.0227307826,
0.0529378913,
-0.0637425482,
-0.017642498,
0.0184148643,
-0.0014910927,
0.0022872323,
-0.0010263936,
0.0409998521,
0.0582380742,
-0.0408366658,
-0.0326344818,
-0.0447062403,
0.0035525928,
-0.0624165088,
0.0181207396,
0.0559278093,
0.0476803146,
-0.0368017517,
0.0462893695,
-0.0092111351,
0.0370040797,
-0.0273567978,
0.0455894843,
0.0504618622,
0.0627843365,
-0.054851491,
-0.0119762747,
-0.0391280055,
0.0602427945,
0.0263675433,
-0.0571464971,
-0.0358225964,
0.0294886921,
2.417e-7,
0.0910408422,
0.0173765253,
0.0658268407,
0.0504790209,
0.01675044,
-0.0032661895,
0.0078942059,
0.0511049107,
0.0219737031,
-0.0030069547,
0.0314989239,
0.0471619293,
-0.0071282443,
0.0080471411,
-0.0515179858,
0.036323294,
-0.085771963,
0.0069675846,
-0.0069256984,
-0.006825767,
0.0229740292,
0.0766180605,
0.0016943871,
-0.0036984086,
-0.017283773,
-0.0076350067,
0.0746514052,
0.048715394,
0.0154795172,
-0.0042447052,
-0.005906838,
-0.0193745699,
-0.0292939376,
0.0222752355,
-0.0191276409,
0.0089747747,
0.0157338511,
0.0152438497,
-0.0452199206,
-0.0644464791,
-0.0084078256,
-0.0051261326,
-0.0193405487,
0.015674144,
0.0249450132,
-0.1103106514,
-0.0532878898,
-0.0327532627,
-0.0589030087,
0.0126696341,
-0.0111256661,
0.0104500689,
-0.009031117,
0.0255557764,
0.058003217,
0.0070016729,
0.0194227677,
-0.0802980289,
-0.0094222929,
0.0153142521,
-0.0198079068,
-0.0237056892,
-0.0422633849,
-0.0081536667,
0.031687133,
0.017862564,
-0.0110834325,
1.914316198e-34,
0.0365468189,
0.0130796358,
0.0267446619,
-0.0086362427,
0.0134248883,
-0.0656892583,
0.0109227691,
0.0153897936,
0.0194026008,
-0.0874904767,
-0.0696447045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18385v1 | Matching of Descriptive Labels to Glossary Descriptions | 2023-10-27T07:09:04 | 2023-10-27T07:09:04 | Toshihiro Takahashi, Takaaki Tateishi, Michiaki Tatsubori | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Semantic text similarity plays an important role in software engineering
tasks in which engineers are requested to clarify the semantics of descriptive
labels (e.g., business terms, table column names) that are often consists of
too short or too generic words and appears in their IT systems. We formulate
this type of problem as a task of matching descriptive labels to glossary
descriptions. We then propose a framework to leverage an existing semantic text
similarity measurement (STS) and augment it using semantic label enrichment and
set-based collective contextualization where the former is a method to retrieve
sentences relevant to a given label and the latter is a method to compute
similarity between two contexts each of which is derived from a set of texts
(e.g., column names in the same table). We performed an experiment on two
datasets derived from publicly available data sources. The result indicated
that the proposed methods helped the underlying STS correctly match more
descriptive labels with the descriptions. | [
0.0288668685,
0.0229292568,
-0.0327469185,
0.0517939217,
-0.0405918919,
0.0526413843,
-0.0176395141,
0.0154026467,
-0.0114298565,
-0.0562601276,
0.0149256773,
-0.0101923142,
-0.0012851665,
0.0086019356,
0.0232536253,
-0.0139669254,
0.0334514342,
0.0795057192,
-0.0688228384,
0.0419361852,
0.0450431779,
0.0409170911,
-0.0309203286,
0.044205673,
0.0151043674,
-0.0144437673,
0.0313291401,
-0.0002365221,
-0.0007827117,
-0.0007631001,
-0.0012095313,
0.0196928345,
-0.0184312165,
-0.0198370665,
0.0000018602,
-0.0692335367,
-0.0518570989,
0.0036131374,
0.0357473865,
0.0191447381,
0.0816286951,
0.0079928795,
0.032174848,
-0.0088088429,
-0.0177064333,
-0.0102280397,
0.0218778327,
-0.0216016248,
-0.0166443288,
-0.0299677849,
-0.0293653626,
-0.0569013208,
-0.0513246953,
0.0429199226,
0.041092962,
-0.0710991398,
-0.010279825,
0.05180135,
0.0443643928,
0.0070804246,
0.0163108539,
0.0565568171,
-0.0248271096,
0.0361892581,
0.032139577,
0.0366844535,
-0.0261000544,
0.0237245895,
0.0173100177,
0.050735198,
0.0585799851,
-0.0416666865,
0.0135870688,
-0.0132946726,
-0.0127144139,
0.0231223572,
-0.0181697905,
0.0001098644,
-0.0258617084,
0.0022710881,
-0.0244111326,
0.021137828,
-0.0031220303,
-0.0346855186,
-0.0092675602,
0.0460634008,
0.0120112523,
0.0037712604,
-0.0181196257,
-0.0261860918,
-0.0249573924,
-0.0071847634,
-0.0369912051,
0.0113235172,
-0.0509449691,
0.0314565189,
-0.0315416567,
-0.0381324999,
0.0792179406,
-0.0183479469,
0.0042090174,
0.0085526286,
0.008608574,
0.0176368505,
-0.029685704,
0.0156474188,
0.0188827049,
0.0143532362,
-0.0872175023,
-0.0734855011,
-0.1091096699,
0.0117488448,
-0.0205669012,
0.0418697372,
0.0126725482,
-0.008607151,
-0.0261948239,
0.028176371,
-0.0386477858,
0.0613174848,
-0.0624797381,
-0.0040272963,
-0.0043077082,
-0.0027498445,
-0.0474290177,
-0.0690192953,
-0.0406700186,
0.0133176157,
-0.024963269,
-0.0302864481,
0.0004848214,
0.0065608281,
0.0293364543,
0.009153178,
-0.0141485445,
0.0518242866,
0.0102803893,
0.0184941683,
-0.066268079,
-0.0465755016,
0.0300490558,
0.0545128211,
-0.0840689614,
-0.0649847761,
0.0148970522,
0.0179401562,
-0.0095840171,
-0.0528769009,
-0.0143079441,
0.0354028568,
-0.0177197233,
0.1159271523,
-0.0628219023,
0.0221313536,
0.0449501164,
0.0029122785,
0.0178212244,
0.0086110169,
-0.0023218661,
-0.0067703812,
0.0562451631,
0.0182362553,
0.0125816651,
-0.011808007,
-0.0188577231,
-0.0084669832,
-0.0347479917,
0.0330612548,
0.0478178971,
0.0127666155,
-0.0269859936,
0.0279153027,
0.0002185575,
0.0106047895,
0.0164912585,
0.0838877931,
0.0207714569,
0.0402137451,
0.0394871794,
0.0522347279,
-0.0609308444,
0.0050745169,
0.0399328843,
-0.0080682198,
-0.031053599,
0.0515158214,
0.0158433653,
0.0090626907,
-0.0145400148,
-0.0498338677,
-0.025656689,
-0.0054081138,
0.0186020862,
-0.0182817727,
0.0246930551,
0.0344078876,
-0.005876164,
0.0193354208,
0.066153273,
-0.027186377,
-0.0336951204,
0.0038516226,
-0.0112091526,
0.0623927675,
0.0376901887,
-0.0723626837,
-0.057420183,
0.0079766726,
0.0170632508,
-0.0021650477,
0.0309747588,
-0.0576377809,
-0.0461771525,
-0.0254091267,
-0.0303580686,
0.0131432647,
-0.0123217599,
-0.0035993233,
0.028855009,
0.006030981,
0.0519441962,
-0.0735907033,
-0.0787705407,
0.0388453901,
0.0223526135,
-0.0047191218,
0.0092546875,
-0.0012424487,
0.0262171738,
0.0236671641,
-0.0086881956,
0.0143632106,
0.0285132844,
-0.0364612043,
-0.0472842418,
-0.0129969148,
-0.0031347419,
0.0163382478,
0.0305239148,
-0.0370382071,
0.0145301856,
-0.0105155781,
-0.0495631061,
-0.0147224208,
0.0245909598,
-0.040280547,
0.0073229554,
0.0000421308,
-0.0020343522,
-0.0457110442,
-0.0351746418,
-0.0593901239,
0.0587237515,
0.0474199876,
0.0280509945,
-0.0371625796,
0.0107588712,
0.0581733435,
-0.0040032929,
-0.0051935441,
-0.0112038255,
-0.0126260445,
0.0400445685,
0.0349232182,
0.00907561,
-0.0630456656,
0.0435994938,
-0.0671607405,
0.0296403412,
0.0370878428,
0.011393494,
0.0742282644,
0.0039962484,
0.0037902801,
0.003669431,
-0.0227158442,
0.0095002819,
-0.0344143994,
-0.0400337651,
0.0503225066,
0.0017208665,
-0.0531282686,
-0.0113480678,
0.0135959601,
-0.0452772453,
0.0541785061,
0.0283989664,
-0.0506474636,
-0.0365034714,
0.0271056723,
-0.0365301408,
-0.025291387,
0.0101436041,
0.0204650238,
-0.035771668,
0.0236450545,
-0.0079102358,
-0.0042530303,
0.0098221553,
-0.028602032,
0.023085149,
0.0247098394,
-0.0375022106,
-0.0254072752,
-0.0096177096,
-0.0282556098,
0.023633603,
-0.0584229566,
0.0652169213,
-0.0031052951,
0.0096059022,
-0.0046022166,
-0.0112840123,
-0.0323817357,
-0.0318832323,
0.0253757611,
-0.0975245088,
0.0089779152,
0.0238326676,
0.028542785,
0.0027788344,
-0.0104714734,
0.0656069666,
-0.0383261889,
0.0214757957,
-0.078877531,
-0.0283877533,
-0.0197218936,
0.0797153413,
-0.0574260801,
0.0526206344,
0.0393154919,
0.0102548683,
-0.0190278068,
0.0113192769,
0.0686968192,
-0.0004309363,
0.0500783883,
-0.0709798634,
0.0246429816,
0.019985253,
0.0293357316,
-0.0108413752,
-0.0042829057,
-0.0147629781,
0.0398079641,
0.0473495163,
0.0415577739,
-0.0074741603,
0.0348003432,
0.0013458838,
0.026171105,
0.05824228,
-0.0359536521,
-0.0323040374,
0.0047625774,
0.0254648272,
-0.0338197723,
-0.0326675512,
0.0328845717,
0.0036945543,
0.0248304941,
0.0210088845,
-0.0194412861,
-0.0292571038,
-0.0416643657,
-0.0231379159,
-0.0742425919,
0.0102628432,
0.025987247,
-0.0500627346,
0.0124729592,
-0.0073798317,
0.0727708414,
0.0653765351,
-0.0397482812,
-0.0061046444,
0.0465499908,
0.0254382417,
0.0694219992,
-0.0164671838,
-0.0750098154,
-0.009772866,
-0.0211555455,
0.0145462696,
0.0197072588,
0.0053812512,
-0.007697749,
-0.0739042088,
-0.0086947223,
-0.0355903283,
-0.0413003378,
-0.027795529,
-0.0443774685,
0.0139050465,
0.001467226,
-0.0273081865,
0.0056782491,
-0.0143982815,
0.0111394115,
0.0083803972,
-0.0300303269,
-0.0626202598,
0.0319439173,
-0.0349682085,
0.0296411812,
0.0493109487,
0.0343443528,
0.0005025291,
-0.0016960278,
0.0343322456,
-0.052195359,
-0.0132235726,
0.007121474,
0.0565984882,
-0.0212067459,
0.0174813997,
0.0396857634,
0.0183999445,
-0.0654186904,
0.0023248221,
0.0614334047,
0.0387188233,
0.0179171823,
0.0310526118,
-0.027386399,
-0.0082090702,
-0.0042468305,
0.0551906265,
0.0623103417,
0.0277574789,
0.0100661172,
0.0207955968,
-0.0236048531,
0.0140852658,
-0.0243318807,
0.0098180734,
-0.0450036526,
-0.0015886045,
-0.0577490292,
-0.0144014768,
0.0308711715,
-0.0035341587,
-0.0092656966,
0.0498833582,
-0.0006699517,
-0.0259409323,
-0.0922667161,
-0.0160224587,
-0.0338716693,
0.0382445678,
0.0078294836,
-0.0476256125,
0.0300545804,
-0.0033893876,
-0.0721515715,
0.0298694577,
-0.0152922869,
-0.007410645,
-0.0397583246,
-0.0468636639,
0.0039504496,
0.0077997865,
-0.0440906398,
-0.0133836074,
0.0147318691,
0.0254659206,
-0.0163748451,
-0.0114652207,
-0.0445091166,
0.0033571068,
0.0170520544,
0.0167640373,
-0.0295696482,
0.0457217209,
-0.0213522129,
0.0098317582,
-0.0058191684,
-0.0338324755,
0.0690530166,
0.0494463965,
-0.0196682289,
0.0105772419,
-0.0055172932,
-0.0173844472,
0.009951679,
0.0034584282,
-0.0632345229,
0.00764404,
0.0113766873,
-0.0040058861,
-0.0491318665,
0.0251216013,
0.0468261614,
-0.037913803,
0.043310672,
-0.0259685013,
-0.0043119271,
-0.0099699041,
0.0068957042,
-0.0262407772,
-0.0159962196,
-0.0040834746,
-0.0666652918,
-0.0111405216,
0.0122878654,
-0.0232594106,
-0.0089141084,
0.0529176891,
0.0045021353,
-0.0543033779,
0.04029762,
-0.0317398831,
-0.0435397625,
-0.0340175331,
-0.0306890644,
0.0072364518,
-0.0022488518,
0.0038292017,
-0.0024749339,
-0.0348125286,
0.0112665165,
0.0374317318,
0.0021441618,
0.0063096867,
-0.0114180036,
0.016938936,
-0.0226875488,
-0.0326581784,
0.0802860707,
-0.0029700426,
0.002327454,
-0.0446118414,
-0.0668729916,
-0.0536506549,
-0.0079510873,
0.009490435,
0.0390593894,
-0.0156584065,
-0.0365301743,
-0.0454938002,
-0.0386384875,
0.0448419191,
0.0059046489,
0.0065721786,
0.016890211,
0.0724625736,
0.0686417744,
0.0583175719,
0.0060402313,
0.0007383887,
-0.0412618071,
-0.0352894142,
-0.009105741,
-0.0702967942,
-5.38607581e-33,
-0.0384303033,
-0.0548653752,
0.0003244214,
0.0308019239,
0.0178634375,
0.0027838382,
-0.0018085655,
-0.0183167644,
0.0016274893,
0.0220219754,
0.0348813348,
0.0482013859,
0.0137539404,
-0.0135511057,
0.0230487175,
-0.0065493789,
-0.0051510613,
0.0188009366,
-0.0185008347,
0.0361259952,
0.0097128116,
0.0025214134,
0.0324608684,
-0.09581054,
0.0321263224,
-0.0328057595,
0.0152555043,
-0.041112449,
0.0558171049,
0.0452304408,
-0.0185665414,
0.078556031,
0.0331968404,
-0.017589828,
-0.0074050128,
-0.0126505792,
-0.0422639921,
-0.0358511582,
0.001940075,
-0.0727584511,
0.0350744165,
0.0100150909,
0.0161104333,
-0.0058806972,
-0.0334321856,
0.0208455902,
0.0960679725,
-0.020161029,
-0.0231326949,
-0.0529607423,
-0.0461868718,
0.0147208236,
-0.0206601974,
0.0469343439,
0.035166949,
0.003722559,
-0.0142966658,
0.0892921314,
0.0541720279,
0.0032168026,
-0.0010152203,
0.0214391556,
0.0608204566,
0.0272953529,
0.042720601,
0.0011191162,
-0.0205205437,
0.0003978782,
-0.0058856593,
-0.0239109173,
-0.0155474907,
0.0142254084,
-0.0040716473,
0.0740612745,
-0.0025330994,
-0.0176844075,
-0.0124821477,
0.0836839601,
-0.0690605491,
0.0003482644,
0.0037450923,
0.0131699909,
-0.0451768078,
-0.0245209951,
-0.0412923545,
0.052789215,
-0.0382839702,
-0.0004178752,
0.0373870656,
-0.039888829,
-0.0283646956,
0.051604405,
-0.0608860776,
-0.0292671919,
-0.0138190016,
-0.0478676558,
0.0085819941,
-0.0055892421,
-0.0171007179,
0.0016910295,
-0.0355853438,
-0.0685469061,
-0.0156830214,
0.0453065708,
0.0506352112,
-0.0179130416,
0.0453448743,
-0.0204989091,
-0.0361356549,
0.0453203097,
-0.0140769752,
-0.0768438429,
-0.0643486455,
-0.065546371,
-0.0030509594,
0.0254988652,
0.0157786608,
0.0210486073,
0.0562083088,
-0.0257387739,
-0.0061292686,
-0.037413571,
-0.0444850251,
0.002338856,
0.0058225929,
0.0209485553,
-0.0357251167,
-0.0192034449,
0.0639135763,
0.0408089645,
-0.0193259735,
-0.0093234461,
2.592e-7,
0.0666676238,
0.0163292568,
0.0106414109,
0.0263636056,
-0.0177796837,
0.0093790814,
0.0289871562,
0.0092712976,
-0.0369396657,
-0.0370196365,
0.0719452947,
-0.0173073635,
0.0194911156,
0.0457080081,
0.0039854776,
0.0289937351,
-0.0537710153,
-0.0082496572,
-0.061898414,
0.0228866041,
0.1122661084,
-0.0019694616,
0.0130865751,
0.0075435294,
-0.0187579468,
-0.0462815613,
-0.024966646,
-0.0791855305,
0.0466707759,
0.0721468478,
0.012796877,
0.0199593604,
0.0071635633,
0.0715460181,
-0.0026017758,
-0.0031015733,
0.0000778122,
-0.0391195901,
-0.0352297425,
0.0123353135,
-0.030226225,
-0.0774292946,
0.0333768316,
-0.0761478543,
0.0329357386,
-0.033087641,
0.0311974715,
0.0510808006,
-0.0335576721,
0.0536803044,
-0.0370971784,
0.0363606215,
-0.0365722552,
0.0008038062,
0.004376037,
0.0169316046,
-0.0366918519,
-0.0705703124,
0.0356130451,
0.0768428445,
-0.0185110997,
-0.0110665755,
0.0086471895,
0.0168867391,
0.0057948483,
-0.0296818409,
0.0244608019,
2.284395799e-34,
0.0223432016,
0.0489437059,
0.0029013096,
0.0281046703,
0.049613107,
-0.0136614088,
-0.0440938361,
0.0147057185,
-0.0174804442,
-0.0318001024,
0.0258855801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17924v1 | SOUL: Towards Sentiment and Opinion Understanding of Language | 2023-10-27T06:48:48 | 2023-10-27T06:48:48 | Yue Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Sinno Jialin Pan, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis is a well-established natural language processing task,
with sentiment polarity classification being one of its most popular and
representative tasks. However, despite the success of pre-trained language
models in this area, they often fall short of capturing the broader
complexities of sentiment analysis. To address this issue, we propose a new
task called Sentiment and Opinion Understanding of Language (SOUL). SOUL aims
to evaluate sentiment understanding through two subtasks: Review Comprehension
(RC) and Justification Generation (JG). RC seeks to validate statements that
focus on subjective information based on a review text, while JG requires
models to provide explanations for their sentiment predictions. To enable
comprehensive evaluation, we annotate a new dataset comprising 15,028
statements from 3,638 reviews. Experimental results indicate that SOUL is a
challenging task for both small and large language models, with a performance
gap of up to 27% when compared to human performance. Furthermore, evaluations
conducted with both human experts and GPT-4 highlight the limitations of the
small language model in generating reasoning-based justifications. These
findings underscore the challenging nature of the SOUL task for existing
models, emphasizing the need for further advancements in sentiment analysis to
address its complexities. The new dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/SOUL. | [
0.0417681374,
0.0808977708,
0.0200766176,
0.0471637435,
-0.0085159289,
0.0281171687,
-0.0013967435,
-0.0254881438,
-0.0203450043,
-0.0397647768,
-0.0598667413,
-0.0247356948,
-0.0155825866,
0.0260033216,
-0.0207472481,
-0.0283265226,
0.0230770987,
0.0465409048,
0.0465706438,
0.0077102557,
0.0311869849,
0.0350170247,
0.004674329,
0.0340140164,
0.0245682206,
-0.0228252448,
0.0045175808,
0.004319984,
-0.0030271159,
-0.0407073535,
0.0439681821,
0.0352921709,
0.0094599966,
0.0377491079,
0.0000017773,
-0.0006238333,
0.0113258557,
-0.0157184564,
0.0125023313,
0.0007964083,
0.0826185048,
-0.0378148258,
0.0239229389,
0.0051462548,
-0.0393998101,
-0.0304958429,
0.0282483175,
0.102609992,
0.0528674535,
0.0787130594,
-0.004182437,
-0.0420075171,
-0.0710153952,
-0.0144201722,
-0.0166223925,
0.002756275,
-0.030906463,
0.0005991385,
-0.0323234834,
0.0114114536,
0.0139483577,
-0.0046109827,
0.0029166599,
-0.0096272212,
0.0054599908,
0.0026113146,
-0.0297667496,
-0.0385845117,
-0.0050916183,
0.0713312626,
0.012846184,
-0.0805054531,
-0.0274842009,
0.0050637359,
-0.0314873196,
-0.0329392515,
-0.0129828593,
0.027994981,
0.0153938076,
0.0506836362,
0.0016456972,
0.0440546311,
0.058665745,
0.0523837581,
0.012191413,
0.0647445098,
-0.0252656173,
-0.0297619738,
0.0080236522,
0.0487659387,
-0.0153556233,
-0.0059572323,
-0.0243112333,
0.0266967062,
-0.0015856777,
0.0197944976,
0.0029822073,
0.0204609483,
0.0239642225,
-0.0518797673,
0.0150085343,
0.0006460208,
-0.0130896317,
0.050832022,
-0.0063367132,
-0.0040433449,
0.0032924714,
0.0262951907,
0.0010275923,
0.0071846638,
-0.0484463871,
0.0029091053,
0.0240030382,
0.0170118995,
-0.0434080251,
0.0072312802,
-0.0616590604,
-0.0230252557,
-0.027313875,
0.0017309489,
0.0345290899,
0.0204972252,
0.0130267562,
-0.028106723,
-0.0592905246,
0.0256416127,
-0.0207785666,
0.0452328809,
-0.0289235543,
0.0028254702,
-0.0148121314,
0.0408225171,
-0.017519407,
-0.0167821608,
0.028288085,
0.0336239673,
0.0578378402,
0.0005253776,
-0.0249769669,
-0.0187003128,
-0.0151528884,
-0.0883754939,
-0.023786366,
-0.0165153183,
0.006294122,
-0.0002447983,
-0.0281562414,
0.0020044295,
0.0195971951,
0.0229054987,
-0.0142298536,
0.0898548588,
-0.0540542938,
-0.0170859192,
-0.0325305723,
-0.0041381335,
0.0130343549,
0.0523546599,
-0.0182343796,
0.0230179857,
0.0240269117,
-0.0159261879,
0.0066243117,
-0.0437136218,
0.0174874533,
-0.0422310308,
-0.0150755076,
0.0133156264,
-0.0900788233,
0.001228394,
0.0146404812,
0.0142345168,
0.001980145,
-0.0282145012,
0.0394499525,
0.0053275158,
-0.0286966953,
0.0607030354,
0.0155836251,
0.0002579786,
-0.0007905285,
-0.0344073698,
-0.0654368997,
0.0393794514,
-0.02134398,
-0.006878329,
-0.0096395705,
-0.0012449698,
-0.0213693753,
-0.0591507778,
-0.0131495837,
-0.0342094973,
0.0238642823,
-0.000690386,
0.0683009923,
-0.0031596464,
-0.0698874295,
-0.0046251733,
0.0193116702,
-0.097292535,
-0.0145487674,
-0.0155306542,
0.06475427,
0.0808392912,
0.038750384,
-0.0163061358,
-0.0331248417,
-0.0152800111,
-0.0214018747,
0.0352091938,
0.0621502511,
0.0006171982,
0.0151661718,
-0.0408453383,
-0.016061468,
-0.0429949909,
0.0136854341,
0.0027742204,
0.0046448899,
-0.0017298377,
0.0315934494,
-0.0233495515,
-0.0470830165,
0.0206233021,
0.0436429456,
-0.0270271841,
0.0115843909,
0.0176396929,
0.0480683744,
0.0501032844,
-0.0083200522,
0.0181132108,
0.0192146339,
-0.0268926639,
-0.0512003675,
0.0432756543,
-0.0085361199,
-0.0394328274,
0.0264800861,
-0.0268941019,
-0.0396282114,
0.059157066,
-0.0553326719,
-0.028979389,
0.030860737,
0.0326437391,
0.0061794301,
-0.0479834937,
-0.037160296,
-0.017667314,
0.0091222748,
-0.0205122102,
0.0489171296,
0.0191806629,
0.0055385008,
-0.0461019427,
-0.0314335972,
0.0401513241,
0.0105387913,
-0.0565801486,
-0.0147308521,
0.0008925729,
0.000557981,
0.0456101075,
0.0276058018,
-0.0257355887,
-0.0017201534,
-0.1175607666,
0.0126705971,
-0.007157845,
0.0534058474,
0.0474929437,
-0.0390034504,
0.0172148924,
0.0227902457,
-0.0408895835,
0.0271319058,
0.010853068,
-0.0107983658,
0.0672323629,
-0.0132257501,
0.0073848865,
-0.0597395822,
-0.0028735811,
-0.0382255167,
0.0084688189,
0.0273900907,
0.012913676,
-0.0226522703,
0.0270867869,
-0.023928605,
-0.0076484545,
0.0141988266,
-0.0686547756,
0.0089843413,
-0.0063679395,
-0.0088380715,
0.0345224924,
-0.001382843,
0.0330520086,
0.0443605408,
0.0378511474,
-0.0166327879,
-0.0006646545,
-0.0553463884,
0.030359406,
-0.0266470034,
-0.0032146804,
-0.0090284012,
0.0907806456,
-0.0177199543,
-0.0213663634,
-0.0575958714,
0.002960152,
-0.0187046286,
0.0099024018,
-0.0087186955,
-0.0229440834,
0.0044730036,
0.0244189948,
-0.0379551575,
-0.0184769332,
0.0586843975,
-0.0092049977,
-0.0099501908,
-0.0640789196,
-0.008067132,
-0.0544805154,
0.0541860871,
-0.0302472357,
-0.0125870174,
-0.038121067,
0.0284286272,
0.0029565692,
-0.0494266897,
0.0076148449,
-0.0034000496,
0.0236151423,
-0.0253128614,
0.0022181806,
-0.0006036712,
-0.0261783786,
-0.0000665083,
-0.0470791906,
-0.077010341,
-0.0382953919,
0.0058478652,
-0.0166843925,
0.012855269,
-0.0050706416,
-0.0066387984,
0.0017057724,
-0.0215447228,
0.0083044991,
0.0050019124,
-0.0170486774,
0.012559751,
-0.0025064426,
0.0529504977,
0.0017603678,
0.034001112,
0.019880956,
-0.0103889741,
0.0175399315,
-0.069899343,
-0.0072695957,
-0.0110671064,
0.0004886689,
-0.0043898132,
-0.0473145582,
0.1037884206,
-0.0451224297,
-0.0008129345,
0.1345278919,
0.0264315493,
-0.0564246178,
-0.0130440732,
0.0068177199,
-0.0087064551,
0.050077986,
0.0035092484,
-0.0362735391,
-0.0382410996,
-0.0167692695,
0.0389296748,
0.0276217423,
0.0092934072,
-0.0236591063,
-0.100801006,
0.0204056408,
-0.0183128435,
-0.0064042755,
-0.0526184849,
-0.0247009676,
-0.0130921509,
-0.0318714753,
0.0154274302,
-0.0168223735,
0.0088016354,
0.0375452973,
0.0047729807,
-0.0409738608,
-0.0083552618,
0.0768348053,
-0.0069260155,
0.0454880632,
0.0213287678,
0.0794145763,
0.0062600975,
-0.0148130869,
0.0826717988,
-0.0324279331,
-0.0076043452,
-0.0320439637,
0.0758380815,
0.0148379058,
-0.0221543461,
-0.0191748645,
0.0183536224,
-0.1000808477,
-0.0082795434,
-0.0149736265,
0.0430122204,
-0.0213380437,
-0.0489349067,
-0.0236655064,
0.0649026036,
-0.0029864123,
0.0985802338,
0.034102533,
-0.0218510479,
-0.061928276,
0.0089456756,
-0.0262178127,
-0.089670442,
-0.0202781092,
0.003127686,
0.0422505029,
-0.0063109579,
-0.047068622,
-0.0703898519,
0.0272213444,
0.0075941123,
0.0006270523,
-0.0108431885,
-0.0009528297,
-0.0190014597,
-0.0429079607,
0.0567010678,
0.0075927521,
-0.005880977,
-0.0143161928,
-0.0253127143,
0.0190991368,
-0.0157644209,
-0.022701079,
-0.0149817541,
-0.0313279182,
-0.0205863174,
-0.0409334339,
0.0591308437,
0.0199457239,
0.0385117345,
-0.0092885168,
-0.0451684967,
-0.0206017438,
0.0356080905,
-0.0486601666,
-0.0487851053,
0.0616870113,
0.0664275512,
0.0480178446,
0.0388293639,
-0.0053287079,
0.0421649665,
0.0215852223,
-0.0067895795,
-0.0033562537,
0.0106463842,
0.0332405567,
-0.0004390842,
0.0606597289,
0.0137077859,
0.0424286015,
-0.0430528633,
-0.0128857186,
-0.0459624156,
-0.0135478349,
-0.0391990058,
-0.0064278347,
-0.0024837002,
-0.0210938081,
-0.0577547923,
-0.0316232406,
-0.0468181334,
0.0256889947,
-0.0017139965,
0.0546288043,
0.0339058451,
0.0194502678,
-0.025444949,
0.0237410981,
-0.038158752,
-0.0129786581,
-0.017867608,
-0.0041773687,
0.0251830015,
0.0565002002,
0.0326744355,
0.0182261821,
-0.0140758837,
-0.0035971587,
-0.0353564546,
0.0221327506,
0.0041303178,
-0.0011674435,
-0.0072483029,
-0.0408159718,
0.0513235107,
-0.024980139,
-0.0040067127,
-0.0106490925,
0.0721170902,
-0.0228622202,
0.0100965565,
0.0161931925,
0.0065420065,
-0.036580801,
-0.0416294895,
0.0558735169,
-0.0337475166,
-0.0006111356,
0.0493461341,
0.0010860276,
-0.0402608179,
-0.0110262856,
0.011524342,
0.0096169813,
0.0000198598,
0.0626818985,
-0.0465921946,
-0.0525901467,
0.0199418776,
-0.003086051,
0.0284738317,
0.0063534859,
-0.0052142418,
0.0759461373,
-0.0123162912,
0.0161733739,
-0.0467340127,
-0.0058052046,
-0.0154969357,
-0.0006530783,
-0.0313788392,
-6.291513191e-33,
0.0069245379,
-0.0283549801,
-0.0051826662,
0.0047508166,
0.0155542493,
0.0024983704,
-0.0724407136,
-0.0020050984,
-0.0101577649,
0.0708582476,
0.0100145331,
0.0393751897,
0.00014251,
0.0269374792,
0.0269009788,
-0.0043756305,
0.0469749235,
-0.0100534894,
0.0025304109,
0.0264573172,
0.0340072997,
0.0172930062,
0.0683160722,
-0.0986798778,
0.0638305619,
0.0212923959,
-0.0498223193,
0.0087693641,
-0.0000875752,
0.0354833417,
-0.0436435305,
0.0577319749,
0.0370654762,
-0.0033986098,
0.019154001,
0.0410319939,
-0.0507443361,
-0.0250858665,
0.0228591859,
0.0071357116,
-0.0397991277,
-0.0142567419,
0.0272466261,
0.0004185435,
-0.0303544849,
0.0161662344,
0.028271053,
-0.0246047918,
0.0349571817,
-0.0760642216,
-0.0500699244,
0.0208419822,
-0.0189123228,
-0.0133540239,
0.0354162939,
0.0134787876,
-0.0269708913,
0.055689808,
-0.0409208275,
-0.0022755258,
-0.0517269112,
0.0082515208,
0.0020688407,
-0.055039864,
-0.0167540945,
0.0919146538,
-0.0269261803,
0.0065000043,
-0.0670361966,
0.05198019,
-0.0048596901,
0.0042917719,
0.0560168996,
0.0463428348,
0.0225125477,
-0.0252909772,
-0.0621804111,
0.0074338838,
0.0239885245,
0.0044561559,
0.062113408,
-0.0262171403,
-0.0329386704,
0.0263333283,
-0.0046101823,
-0.068744503,
-0.0327820517,
-0.0054881698,
0.0150685022,
-0.0029774967,
-0.0279514529,
-0.0549177304,
-0.0102579538,
-0.0898223817,
0.0032364533,
0.0404291935,
-0.0347711518,
-0.0361074619,
0.028860474,
-0.011648776,
-0.0312540121,
-0.0139973424,
-0.0221553389,
0.0339550078,
0.0034620771,
0.0017203271,
0.1046135351,
0.0204070788,
-0.0709669143,
-0.001247172,
-0.0517797209,
0.0381887592,
-0.0155685386,
0.0623268932,
-0.0156264827,
0.0284376889,
-0.007444479,
0.0463909358,
0.0091670556,
0.0530727729,
0.0111199422,
0.0332011692,
0.0080798017,
0.0172442384,
-0.0129789831,
-0.0421318561,
0.0012482549,
-0.0494709462,
-0.0128452023,
-0.0602000393,
-0.000550085,
-0.0050859395,
2.428e-7,
0.06092057,
0.0710158125,
0.0194706023,
-0.0130540244,
0.00554477,
0.0378189012,
0.0034914752,
0.0059246668,
-0.0262716748,
-0.026116617,
0.0351945646,
0.0293439589,
0.0356472693,
0.0033073982,
-0.0686173141,
0.0286955852,
-0.0436597578,
-0.0172843896,
-0.0038577798,
0.0181034468,
0.1024065167,
0.1180595383,
0.0289643947,
-0.0205117743,
-0.0141917951,
-0.0112719312,
0.0436576605,
-0.0576076172,
-0.0032915811,
-0.0000313676,
0.0276543237,
0.0026303791,
-0.0007577572,
-0.0384340622,
-0.012049255,
0.0203109365,
-0.0221743081,
0.0674762502,
-0.0132042319,
-0.0580080934,
0.0145430714,
0.0135046653,
0.0190904681,
-0.0591113381,
0.055727385,
-0.0632340834,
-0.0430062152,
-0.1024754569,
-0.0115698399,
-0.0095508192,
0.0330444202,
0.0076180883,
0.0054997294,
0.0198479928,
-0.0258101635,
-0.0510259196,
-0.0281633846,
-0.0889246985,
-0.0371992253,
0.0364594199,
-0.0022346617,
0.0370455049,
0.011240202,
0.0135677848,
0.0456093326,
-0.0239420496,
0.0098276269,
2.044455591e-34,
0.0737634152,
-0.0372451618,
-0.004653743,
-0.0189613756,
0.0546202473,
0.0226103272,
-0.0663071871,
-0.0133944284,
0.0395993777,
0.0033824248,
0.0109289428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17918v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17918v2 | Knowing What LLMs DO NOT Know: A Simple Yet Effective Self-Detection Method | 2023-10-27T06:22:14 | 2024-03-21T10:57:23 | Yukun Zhao, Lingyong Yan, Weiwei Sun, Guoliang Xing, Chong Meng, Shuaiqiang Wang, Zhicong Cheng, Zhaochun Ren, Dawei Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great potential in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. However, recent literature reveals that LLMs generate
nonfactual responses intermittently, which impedes the LLMs' reliability for
further utilization. In this paper, we propose a novel self-detection method to
detect which questions that a LLM does not know that are prone to generate
nonfactual results. Specifically, we first diversify the textual expressions
for a given question and collect the corresponding answers. Then we examine the
divergencies between the generated answers to identify the questions that the
model may generate falsehoods. All of the above steps can be accomplished by
prompting the LLMs themselves without referring to any other external
resources. We conduct comprehensive experiments and demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method on recently released LLMs, e.g., Vicuna, ChatGPT,
and GPT-4. | [
0.0584636964,
0.0275684763,
-0.040738225,
0.070303306,
-0.0753327459,
0.011615715,
0.0026572503,
0.0134130958,
0.0703257993,
-0.0555813387,
0.0014556943,
-0.0218679775,
-0.0225206167,
0.0209592301,
0.0220717061,
0.0225651357,
0.0618169867,
-0.0345522389,
-0.0097041028,
-0.0218712445,
-0.0211924016,
0.0221294351,
-0.0030337619,
0.013569355,
0.0098035242,
-0.0425705984,
-0.0170530081,
-0.005729083,
-0.0226633996,
-0.0314500965,
0.0328377709,
0.0644387826,
-0.0123984069,
0.0634234995,
0.0000019753,
-0.0479638912,
-0.0444241725,
-0.0239450652,
-0.0526702218,
0.0061492044,
0.0411710292,
0.0333880447,
0.0223479439,
0.0365004018,
-0.05864048,
-0.0035319917,
0.0109414281,
0.0626322627,
0.0579872467,
0.0640061423,
0.0141934864,
0.0168626029,
0.0074018878,
0.0149939544,
0.0421421006,
-0.0355103724,
0.0339384228,
-0.0128598996,
-0.040635515,
0.0089361556,
-0.0000479498,
0.0363643281,
0.0064077098,
0.0194077529,
-0.0108341314,
0.0176030751,
-0.0519536734,
-0.0403266847,
-0.0177542921,
0.0492744967,
0.014382082,
-0.0408627316,
0.0149888275,
-0.0181229617,
0.0184345003,
0.0628687441,
-0.0227550752,
0.0174132697,
-0.0363232978,
-0.0068853809,
0.0194603335,
0.0159212966,
0.0275680143,
-0.0058185933,
-0.0127230017,
0.0872477442,
0.008388116,
-0.0473344177,
0.0012712914,
-0.000318682,
-0.0274350028,
-0.0727265626,
0.0068754689,
0.0372198895,
-0.0150169171,
0.0269858558,
-0.0165017992,
0.0006366175,
0.0711483806,
-0.0695279911,
0.0074633858,
0.0089434534,
-0.0378302746,
0.0515619926,
-0.0343963616,
0.0247367974,
-0.0413530171,
-0.0049790456,
-0.0379351825,
-0.0057091345,
-0.0144270696,
-0.0574562326,
0.0033924924,
0.0460274592,
-0.0326844268,
0.0015108807,
-0.0227804109,
0.0422464684,
-0.0029558716,
0.0120868571,
0.00237447,
0.0425684229,
-0.011140069,
-0.0197956357,
-0.0915824249,
0.0250983499,
0.0013788271,
0.0159740131,
-0.0293666422,
-0.0873049274,
-0.023684701,
0.0103689907,
0.0034132996,
-0.0189816058,
0.0203370359,
0.0688744783,
0.0205849186,
-0.0278499909,
-0.0762159303,
-0.044775065,
-0.0342995971,
-0.0818897709,
0.0135218184,
-0.0600691102,
0.0097561218,
0.0211029053,
-0.0044868421,
0.0042276471,
0.0262518339,
0.0388615392,
0.0005855871,
0.0847885013,
0.0225164127,
0.0336354859,
0.0549572557,
-0.0053351759,
0.0211213343,
0.09280999,
-0.0159197506,
0.0024777621,
0.0610735863,
0.0110552423,
0.0417916924,
0.0233185813,
0.0312220044,
0.0031184086,
0.0015463595,
0.028982807,
-0.0041067731,
-0.0107479626,
-0.0051194858,
0.056123808,
0.0171825401,
-0.0573355183,
0.0601366833,
0.0665160194,
-0.0237881504,
0.0227886457,
0.040986944,
-0.0054959725,
0.0098560834,
0.079729028,
-0.0431008674,
0.0070473496,
-0.0838791281,
-0.0106382081,
0.0256266892,
0.0237212535,
-0.0047985725,
-0.0612063408,
-0.0425408185,
-0.0002643346,
-0.0155406129,
0.0256692357,
0.037139874,
0.0050923917,
-0.0214141794,
0.022200115,
-0.0011746468,
-0.0295063369,
-0.0097169485,
-0.0672955737,
0.0519646965,
0.0384192541,
0.0610179268,
-0.0421905778,
-0.0243444089,
-0.0082712146,
-0.0399672724,
0.0357231312,
0.0619456656,
0.0056431489,
-0.0053962632,
-0.0083095366,
0.0025510925,
-0.0036026284,
0.0428921953,
-0.0112368315,
0.026833998,
-0.002700039,
0.0105539365,
-0.0701396093,
-0.0028636723,
0.0455850288,
-0.0716835484,
-0.0494594909,
0.0377783179,
-0.0083403103,
0.0435970761,
-0.0065789605,
0.0021308644,
0.0344375409,
0.0413910709,
-0.016053468,
-0.0660177842,
-0.019380305,
-0.0234161895,
-0.0530727506,
0.038813483,
-0.0062860521,
-0.035141699,
0.0449216031,
-0.0294962153,
-0.0252893455,
0.0086615747,
-0.0333544761,
0.0301570166,
-0.0609538183,
0.0195872914,
0.0326703899,
0.020625731,
-0.0301779062,
0.0865492672,
-0.0190883018,
0.0288715791,
-0.0208778586,
-0.0046900623,
0.0176001359,
-0.0382991172,
-0.0328498408,
-0.0088370051,
-0.0057620467,
-0.0031655068,
0.0151898116,
-0.0169668682,
-0.0611674637,
-0.0301791579,
-0.0846197233,
0.0080241943,
-0.0020752721,
0.0077008279,
0.0129194362,
-0.0187654961,
-0.0369187184,
-0.0178509466,
-0.0282797553,
-0.0210697204,
0.0556686297,
0.024046259,
0.0665602759,
-0.0183947049,
0.0456973165,
-0.0282374714,
-0.0031580806,
-0.0486143865,
0.0442534536,
0.0037390813,
-0.0009852264,
-0.0432270579,
0.0106983306,
-0.0353844874,
0.0421865582,
-0.0014367711,
-0.0082747489,
-0.0094928006,
-0.0182582233,
0.0154994037,
0.0707638711,
0.0332545824,
-0.0018566817,
0.0400559679,
-0.0059268302,
-0.046458222,
0.0181641709,
-0.0367350541,
-0.0251895618,
0.0044044033,
-0.0713746846,
0.0428150818,
0.0443925448,
0.0421513095,
-0.0226341058,
-0.0367166251,
0.0274974182,
-0.0260108262,
-0.0345251709,
0.0107785249,
-0.0037992948,
-0.0226831343,
0.0641428232,
0.0175522957,
-0.0498695262,
0.0654034093,
-0.0355376676,
0.0062757009,
-0.0611601584,
-0.0050698984,
-0.0442899168,
0.0603933632,
0.0114059811,
0.0088136299,
0.0722192451,
-0.0229569748,
-0.0311543532,
-0.0206074119,
0.0273480956,
-0.0488756821,
0.0567359477,
-0.040056482,
0.0122423796,
0.0019411859,
-0.0140533037,
-0.0790741369,
-0.0886082798,
-0.0077292775,
-0.0400681347,
-0.0131967794,
0.0048550479,
-0.0189101957,
-0.0032519547,
-0.0029588907,
0.026643483,
-0.0502209812,
-0.0126759773,
-0.0177908745,
0.0647490397,
0.0634784847,
0.0195803344,
0.0639693215,
-0.0253798924,
0.0285030454,
0.0594580434,
0.0072381319,
0.0003752093,
-0.0025488466,
-0.0139162121,
0.0076461188,
-0.0200121533,
0.0132511416,
0.0158207826,
0.0193600133,
-0.0615472235,
-0.0122815901,
0.1067781895,
0.0570920855,
-0.0186843518,
-0.0013164835,
-0.0462848879,
0.0023541055,
0.0377074704,
0.0101334341,
-0.0695329085,
-0.0185902454,
-0.015257447,
0.0074041244,
-0.0635298714,
-0.0406649895,
-0.0250852481,
-0.1324689984,
0.0419444218,
-0.0053513376,
0.0027428181,
0.0064646765,
-0.0258707963,
-0.0088000773,
-0.0057964609,
0.030042531,
-0.0092444206,
-0.0159487464,
-0.0017351586,
0.0203919336,
-0.0726106986,
-0.0352930874,
0.0209145155,
0.0119629866,
0.0687773079,
0.0546235181,
0.0141916797,
-0.0138458703,
-0.0027642795,
0.0445778333,
-0.0360966064,
0.0047151586,
-0.0357767157,
0.0507255346,
0.016795937,
0.0093667079,
-0.0128859757,
0.0070446529,
-0.0290225819,
0.0100682462,
0.0369644202,
0.0810139552,
-0.0331719294,
-0.0397025086,
-0.0324999914,
0.0173913427,
-0.0107480334,
0.0967195183,
0.0039947373,
-0.015718082,
-0.0419724993,
-0.0253341962,
0.0120527372,
0.004230157,
-0.0546961688,
0.0181382671,
0.0521248728,
-0.0048800237,
-0.0763524845,
-0.0187151954,
0.0225724224,
-0.0019386901,
-0.0131658427,
0.0260758214,
0.0191441476,
0.0250939168,
-0.0084618684,
-0.0032468471,
-0.0401729643,
-0.0083424626,
-0.0263353772,
0.0154154105,
0.0382537283,
-0.0227702335,
-0.0028866671,
0.0234843884,
-0.0987749472,
-0.076848425,
-0.0010235468,
0.0216967054,
0.0303128809,
0.0212481357,
-0.0225057919,
-0.0184180737,
0.0275407434,
0.0611956567,
-0.0639929101,
0.0247267913,
0.0056045097,
0.041867353,
-0.0078969505,
0.0396508053,
-0.0091748163,
0.0023857944,
-0.0040575648,
0.0302750356,
-0.0511684343,
-0.0512838513,
0.0550001636,
0.0322290957,
0.0498827659,
0.0194831919,
0.0307638086,
-0.0211929902,
0.0088877343,
0.0050661801,
-0.041221559,
-0.0219017863,
0.0342311859,
0.0126120187,
-0.0239819959,
-0.0061199842,
-0.0332049914,
-0.0727537349,
0.0522367954,
-0.0233226884,
-0.0256808735,
0.0467095301,
-0.0204574894,
-0.0063065668,
-0.0266514104,
-0.021906931,
0.0008666028,
0.0079754731,
0.041564282,
0.0272349194,
0.0597436167,
-0.0235273857,
-0.0054899477,
-0.0171235893,
-0.0126811387,
-0.0732421726,
-0.0296433754,
-0.0294963997,
0.0568672866,
0.0155324154,
-0.0102990847,
0.0124513209,
-0.0342924781,
-0.0075674327,
-0.0281328671,
-0.0194704421,
0.036024984,
0.0171595514,
0.052801419,
0.0172210541,
-0.0454486273,
-0.0237199161,
0.0697388947,
0.0193699226,
0.0479400866,
0.0262940619,
-0.030731352,
-0.0587004721,
-0.0575268045,
0.0103666848,
-0.0032913119,
-0.0175988674,
0.0335047208,
-0.0882162154,
-0.0762971044,
0.0118156038,
0.0213806778,
0.0060744132,
-0.0384457484,
-0.015097687,
0.0807957277,
0.0164485034,
-0.0092645362,
-0.05576564,
0.0549826324,
-0.0196922179,
0.0276789702,
-0.0092577571,
-6.986342759e-33,
-0.0341086052,
-0.085766241,
-0.0021194008,
-0.0184821412,
0.0307014287,
0.0059730508,
-0.0047805202,
0.011943114,
-0.0221808143,
-0.0225904956,
-0.0224034525,
0.0344737805,
0.0141087947,
-0.005991478,
0.0311920103,
-0.0376801752,
0.0382039063,
-0.0204361863,
-0.0354158841,
0.0021013941,
0.0284141582,
-0.0106910169,
0.0304326434,
-0.0694764927,
0.0323733352,
-0.0328991301,
-0.007469621,
0.0600762963,
-0.0662749112,
0.0578043908,
-0.0488199778,
0.051763393,
0.0250774398,
-0.0278077144,
0.0075410898,
-0.0030053065,
-0.0224254746,
-0.0480032489,
0.0414249487,
-0.0175809003,
-0.0225345828,
-0.0140162855,
0.0557154678,
-0.0079130521,
0.0051222024,
0.0086193494,
0.0337338783,
-0.0385651663,
0.0125171011,
0.0063527189,
-0.0207997952,
0.0291823,
0.0105404686,
-0.0000519396,
-0.0139245074,
0.0636465997,
0.0154839801,
0.008952193,
-0.0232234355,
0.0077378629,
0.0302798301,
0.0154546229,
0.0561824925,
-0.0126266964,
0.0057820966,
0.0446409322,
-0.0008940696,
0.0060350192,
-0.0295736603,
-0.049786061,
-0.019857537,
0.0249513909,
0.0399419591,
0.0684890971,
0.0185445827,
0.0107765198,
-0.0314548127,
0.0224957671,
0.0353897735,
0.0047039636,
0.0565201417,
-0.0392814279,
-0.0432600603,
-0.0242034197,
-0.0218822584,
0.003803906,
-0.040665593,
-0.0067167426,
0.0350383744,
0.0205194708,
-0.0176062416,
-0.006926673,
0.0102326721,
-0.0413987264,
-0.0117783099,
0.0018050134,
0.0063203503,
-0.0246458296,
0.0218995288,
0.0513189323,
-0.0343619585,
0.0312502868,
-0.0155786341,
-0.0079026213,
-0.0031267777,
0.0045736628,
-0.0156617314,
-0.0029747065,
-0.0929185748,
-0.0083059827,
-0.0266140103,
0.0467258841,
-0.022844106,
-0.0116490228,
0.035591837,
-0.0159645062,
-0.0238144826,
0.0361535959,
0.0081769554,
0.0021277091,
-0.0668603927,
0.0355802998,
-0.0149579328,
0.0315288492,
-0.0242906399,
-0.009205414,
-0.0034306285,
0.0405765437,
0.0165336169,
-0.0402600616,
0.0067929355,
0.0087583456,
2.737e-7,
0.038340997,
0.037119247,
-0.0000728255,
0.0100105889,
0.037044324,
0.0761054009,
-0.0423800386,
0.000186776,
0.0236602034,
-0.037306644,
-0.0066032531,
0.0225874167,
0.0373243131,
0.0725733116,
-0.0552200191,
0.0215482991,
-0.0455210805,
-0.0178794321,
-0.0536247939,
-0.0074883755,
0.0504208095,
0.0774486363,
0.0120891482,
-0.0147807393,
-0.0183387995,
-0.0506140962,
0.0499310419,
0.0014766562,
-0.0371815525,
0.0120225539,
0.0579577163,
0.0071274019,
0.0301948879,
0.0372721143,
-0.0042035221,
0.0028742428,
-0.0147845885,
0.0445685573,
0.0202775076,
-0.0573973209,
-0.0313604362,
-0.0191113986,
0.0105575053,
-0.0779269859,
0.098364234,
-0.0302150045,
-0.0180364586,
-0.0455534123,
0.0305410009,
-0.0318988338,
0.0376911312,
-0.0018206574,
-0.0284175035,
0.0292959549,
0.0005654493,
0.0049537509,
0.0028833756,
-0.0579126254,
-0.0188655388,
-0.0066947821,
-0.0681307912,
-0.0533928089,
-0.0135792168,
0.0387290604,
0.025057096,
-0.0646647438,
0.0368004218,
2.786211582e-34,
0.0303732287,
0.0382125489,
-0.0156751703,
0.0245570149,
0.0317643993,
0.0028661992,
-0.0164207239,
0.0147543233,
0.0043682647,
-0.0674978271,
-0.0167537984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17914v1 | 3D-Aware Visual Question Answering about Parts, Poses and Occlusions | 2023-10-27T06:15:30 | 2023-10-27T06:15:30 | Xingrui Wang, Wufei Ma, Zhuowan Li, Adam Kortylewski, Alan Yuille | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Despite rapid progress in Visual question answering (VQA), existing datasets
and models mainly focus on testing reasoning in 2D. However, it is important
that VQA models also understand the 3D structure of visual scenes, for example
to support tasks like navigation or manipulation. This includes an
understanding of the 3D object pose, their parts and occlusions. In this work,
we introduce the task of 3D-aware VQA, which focuses on challenging questions
that require a compositional reasoning over the 3D structure of visual scenes.
We address 3D-aware VQA from both the dataset and the model perspective. First,
we introduce Super-CLEVR-3D, a compositional reasoning dataset that contains
questions about object parts, their 3D poses, and occlusions. Second, we
propose PO3D-VQA, a 3D-aware VQA model that marries two powerful ideas:
probabilistic neural symbolic program execution for reasoning and deep neural
networks with 3D generative representations of objects for robust visual
recognition. Our experimental results show our model PO3D-VQA outperforms
existing methods significantly, but we still observe a significant performance
gap compared to 2D VQA benchmarks, indicating that 3D-aware VQA remains an
important open research area. | [
0.023151448,
0.0679690093,
0.0129609387,
0.0634129792,
-0.0126776276,
0.036227569,
0.0131293442,
-0.0353377983,
-0.0159386732,
-0.0447254404,
0.0085027963,
-0.0215778369,
0.0018408651,
0.0702071264,
0.0262028649,
-0.0466770865,
0.0140644489,
-0.0325958841,
0.0014827142,
-0.0100722527,
-0.0042326334,
0.0436333716,
-0.0187093858,
0.0077886065,
-0.0203198176,
-0.0190061331,
-0.0340547115,
-0.002761059,
0.0158846267,
-0.0193790141,
0.0105771888,
0.012190409,
0.0731394291,
-0.0297568887,
0.0000018078,
0.0044641201,
0.0022533282,
-0.0035002155,
-0.0036837463,
-0.0251144636,
-0.0526551157,
-0.032415811,
0.0070623187,
-0.0024957636,
-0.0556661226,
0.0262860134,
0.0355813541,
0.0258831941,
0.0479750894,
0.0256661382,
-0.0097585805,
0.003022573,
0.0033800923,
0.0043297098,
0.070564881,
-0.0021053709,
-0.0173089802,
0.043334879,
0.0127621461,
-0.0039301962,
-0.0354491025,
0.010287731,
0.0703635514,
0.0236814022,
-0.0080327429,
0.0234453697,
-0.015878167,
-0.0059422664,
-0.0055873599,
0.102491796,
-0.0093413228,
0.0119565884,
-0.0038808356,
-0.0123573234,
0.0209503751,
-0.015497094,
-0.0385390669,
0.0422411822,
-0.0318187587,
-0.0318371989,
-0.0516600385,
0.02676378,
-0.0188968368,
-0.0197676085,
-0.0341987312,
0.0214320011,
0.0038427785,
0.0309030432,
-0.0304234624,
-0.0040689395,
-0.0202345513,
-0.0569690429,
-0.0362727493,
0.0427040234,
0.0036179323,
0.0145806381,
-0.020897584,
0.0270879846,
-0.0439929217,
-0.0233208649,
0.0402093045,
0.021136459,
-0.0164229311,
0.0768157542,
-0.0414914154,
0.0531289913,
-0.0459055565,
0.0457481965,
-0.0193658862,
-0.0084792078,
-0.0116460128,
-0.0180722941,
-0.0395072885,
0.0196505804,
-0.050240133,
-0.0497403815,
0.019847136,
0.0183456447,
-0.0325751193,
0.0041619884,
-0.009637746,
0.1046703607,
0.0094877649,
-0.0304621551,
-0.0285388939,
0.0303106252,
-0.040622402,
0.0083127692,
-0.0493381172,
-0.0171706602,
-0.0145892547,
0.0022704776,
0.0223704036,
-0.0263074432,
0.0119912177,
0.0680920184,
-0.0406029373,
-0.0246850643,
0.0360715091,
-0.0582452565,
0.0118945604,
-0.0376129113,
0.0613703541,
-0.0686900839,
0.0252115075,
-0.0243064817,
-0.0304867271,
-0.0487517826,
0.0135579845,
0.02548551,
0.0324019492,
0.0651776046,
0.0004023673,
-0.0361923948,
0.001853949,
0.0276373494,
0.0234656092,
0.0385044403,
0.0258679576,
0.0251148716,
-0.0062871524,
0.0334347226,
0.0257282294,
0.0382072479,
0.0076373694,
0.000754552,
-0.0441387631,
0.0172270909,
-0.0137689449,
0.048237063,
-0.0018284451,
0.0089998255,
-0.01791206,
-0.0692620426,
0.0146434577,
-0.0134955999,
-0.045993831,
-0.01227092,
0.0482676774,
-0.019138651,
0.0198865794,
-0.0109459423,
-0.048152674,
0.094315201,
0.0176396146,
-0.009318077,
-0.06886971,
0.0329335518,
-0.0448898524,
-0.0633569807,
-0.0038304869,
0.0308304857,
0.0193470344,
0.0174627397,
0.0476992242,
0.0130984401,
-0.0277020708,
0.027199585,
-0.0196721032,
-0.0158657879,
-0.0247771647,
0.0120900488,
0.0628179163,
0.0286832396,
0.0270626005,
-0.0070078704,
-0.0442231484,
0.0058743507,
0.0486360863,
-0.0005695331,
0.0011333037,
-0.0121094566,
0.0401027463,
-0.0210782997,
-0.042801775,
-0.0375278257,
-0.0048823482,
0.0537084341,
0.0837983713,
-0.0181877706,
0.0155278519,
-0.0570891649,
0.0878774747,
0.0164833106,
0.0061415993,
0.0084898742,
-0.0236747209,
0.0323751047,
-0.0040866164,
-0.0132957557,
0.0420418009,
-0.0324569941,
0.003713314,
-0.0331264585,
-0.021912897,
0.0182677377,
-0.0427092463,
-0.0448233262,
0.0201184414,
-0.0556954406,
-0.0426836163,
0.0348106697,
-0.0597583614,
0.0038782922,
0.04027614,
-0.0216899626,
-0.0284401756,
-0.0038348343,
-0.0787101164,
0.0661229119,
0.0358597822,
-0.0087502897,
0.0510610454,
-0.0611614995,
-0.0251117796,
0.0325308293,
0.0118281757,
0.0377847515,
0.0029830926,
0.0205284283,
-0.0139314914,
-0.0252484325,
0.0003498271,
-0.0108459471,
0.0101898201,
-0.0380907431,
0.0189800728,
-0.0090422984,
-0.0068557328,
-0.0077180634,
-0.0094970763,
0.0084706005,
-0.0093310224,
0.0067135631,
-0.0481643118,
-0.0540762879,
0.0203558896,
-0.0183221251,
-0.0063298191,
0.046303086,
-0.0002002478,
-0.0203155018,
0.0026715291,
0.0052943397,
-0.0155389914,
0.0871569887,
0.0502710231,
-0.0124806855,
0.0260722488,
-0.0550653823,
-0.0848192498,
0.063944079,
-0.0106727071,
0.0035045305,
0.0330236815,
-0.0536402464,
0.0122096855,
0.0826748312,
-0.0452326275,
0.0004980752,
-0.0026874295,
-0.0007995299,
-0.0396496058,
-0.0002565862,
0.0102008712,
-0.0114461612,
0.0001233391,
-0.0361831598,
-0.0303824972,
0.0138402833,
-0.016308181,
-0.0130370334,
-0.0435422622,
0.0421963483,
0.046399828,
-0.0441829264,
-0.0416618623,
0.0192367006,
0.0295961928,
0.0354042612,
-0.0425811708,
-0.0187211428,
0.047371693,
-0.0015330743,
-0.0007326555,
0.0264348798,
0.0330556482,
-0.035650894,
0.0967549905,
0.0269856732,
0.0056480528,
-0.0222774819,
-0.0210719425,
-0.0402992144,
0.0109727019,
0.0124774957,
0.0229151156,
-0.029054869,
-0.0875153542,
0.0315145291,
-0.0220269747,
-0.0373083092,
0.0114154834,
-0.0084511181,
-0.053234417,
0.0162486341,
-0.0748680606,
-0.0329909511,
-0.0026397435,
0.0109197656,
-0.020916434,
0.0304745566,
-0.0307483915,
-0.0031872934,
-0.0278014969,
0.0130947018,
0.0365887508,
0.0808745623,
-0.0184610654,
-0.0269260649,
-0.0124431737,
0.0767602473,
-0.0358571187,
-0.0036124208,
-0.0674139112,
0.0604638122,
0.0029072901,
0.0579228774,
0.0137855401,
0.0084737912,
0.0213406272,
-0.0764309093,
-0.0353786796,
0.01835417,
0.0337387808,
-0.0013372903,
-0.0251385104,
0.0031133927,
0.0099176336,
0.0455015749,
0.0121614188,
-0.1295391023,
-0.0627166554,
-0.0356511734,
-0.0384686999,
0.0386178792,
-0.0214223471,
-0.0103966063,
-0.0891270936,
0.0342662744,
-0.0360482037,
-0.0431548022,
-0.0832879543,
0.0424983799,
0.024677394,
-0.0189982448,
-0.0515941307,
-0.0360562876,
0.0000503548,
0.0102845971,
-0.0068625547,
0.0228186734,
-0.0075476961,
0.0308658928,
-0.0262366403,
-0.0373677909,
-0.0037865171,
-0.0155567471,
0.0066062231,
-0.0741322488,
0.0270543508,
0.0138796968,
0.000044971,
-0.000961817,
0.0166605245,
-0.0056432653,
-0.0424599536,
0.0217626244,
0.0483663641,
-0.04289997,
-0.0390901379,
-0.0390069894,
0.0549787991,
-0.0154336337,
0.0066189272,
-0.0542901084,
0.0335247181,
-0.0043992558,
0.033269126,
0.0273057874,
-0.000684165,
-0.0516756475,
-0.0342224725,
-0.0315617882,
-0.0183718391,
0.021617312,
-0.0108894855,
0.0580537058,
0.0044139265,
-0.0648118705,
0.01952447,
0.0922097415,
0.059387479,
-0.0336105376,
-0.0551627614,
-0.029353464,
0.0250744764,
-0.09040609,
0.0378893465,
-0.024421677,
0.0388191082,
0.0058779321,
0.0378174409,
0.0078944825,
-0.0693579987,
-0.0383814499,
-0.0397073627,
-0.0783942789,
0.0010713255,
-0.0279914159,
0.076118961,
0.0097881388,
0.0382627137,
-0.0027975021,
-0.0325189829,
-0.0051456988,
0.0460141599,
0.0284641106,
0.0152939958,
0.0223201532,
-0.0112827774,
-0.0012166207,
-0.0150507661,
-0.0065657971,
0.0062860153,
0.0018123849,
-0.0262603946,
-0.0080730356,
0.0054983231,
0.0041833199,
-0.0315080322,
0.0045891926,
0.0245952103,
0.0221464112,
-0.0357192159,
0.0392444171,
0.0216934122,
0.0109893959,
-0.0906442925,
0.0426972881,
0.0177900102,
0.0004165813,
-0.0106702214,
0.0180459265,
0.0259658042,
0.0382092185,
-0.0405886322,
-0.005332903,
0.0579316728,
-0.0449665934,
0.0080823172,
0.0026473971,
0.0015805633,
0.0572229028,
-0.0533759668,
0.05236651,
-0.0171384867,
0.032270316,
0.0411241949,
-0.0261326879,
-0.0564145111,
0.047487434,
-0.0466865487,
-0.0641569421,
-0.0120866485,
0.0338651352,
0.0266413167,
0.0368650481,
-0.0519823059,
-0.0010861779,
-0.0253621936,
0.0622979067,
0.0211922713,
0.0116762761,
-0.036452949,
0.0855367705,
0.0471414439,
0.018494254,
-0.0406119227,
0.0339695215,
0.0279180426,
0.0138668604,
0.0242236629,
0.007541894,
-0.009880892,
-0.0070638843,
0.0263500027,
0.0177032016,
0.0277015083,
0.0452075377,
0.0011776743,
-0.0506319739,
-0.0415448323,
0.0956782773,
-0.0287257154,
0.0322920419,
0.0530763716,
0.0488060415,
0.0340464339,
-0.0364068449,
0.025006732,
0.0004436399,
-0.0176022965,
-0.0199458245,
0.0133785969,
-5.45325421e-33,
-0.012161985,
-0.0372230373,
0.0288958196,
-0.028466383,
-0.0088646533,
0.0028263731,
-0.037629813,
-0.0086471569,
-0.0319507346,
0.0171030797,
0.0243679695,
0.0240346119,
-0.0068176189,
0.0289890021,
-0.0043866364,
-0.0490049496,
0.0003313431,
0.0167166237,
-0.0371483229,
0.0048893131,
0.0178209525,
0.0093762893,
0.0582844503,
-0.0063288971,
-0.0291583203,
0.0104754241,
-0.0265259929,
0.0422692224,
-0.0490663052,
0.055777207,
-0.018052727,
-0.0467619263,
0.0271816868,
-0.0133953709,
0.0063348324,
0.016482057,
-0.1027256772,
-0.0069264406,
-0.0059016873,
0.0083707375,
-0.0824241191,
0.0294175632,
0.0045329658,
0.0043441406,
0.0371200033,
-0.0670395643,
0.0322077461,
-0.0117645934,
0.008881974,
-0.0382071137,
-0.0020199111,
0.001478026,
-0.0504772849,
-0.0427575149,
0.0069634705,
0.0167145282,
0.0581257641,
0.022133749,
-0.0014997275,
-0.0151862772,
-0.0374639779,
0.0034249765,
0.0500034392,
0.0178604741,
-0.0034478314,
0.0517839566,
0.0245856605,
-0.0268108435,
-0.0646863282,
0.0228007268,
0.0148788169,
0.0736578107,
0.055517327,
0.0554815009,
0.0507853851,
0.0596165136,
-0.0537356101,
0.0269512814,
-0.1057766452,
0.0536043532,
-0.0233278628,
-0.0391377546,
-0.0021865608,
-0.0093972431,
-0.0322682038,
0.0019307054,
-0.0339459814,
0.0344962887,
0.0359921642,
0.0198426675,
-0.0276111979,
0.0178662352,
0.0342912488,
-0.0606167838,
0.0410878323,
0.0700034946,
-0.0135602234,
0.0396615937,
0.0153059866,
0.0358926915,
0.0005191664,
0.0360213593,
0.0116442582,
-0.0194685664,
-0.0023152335,
-0.0033160921,
0.0306002423,
0.0436218455,
-0.0210527238,
-0.0237079877,
-0.0639886558,
0.0398102403,
-0.0226970762,
0.0651169419,
0.0285233147,
0.0430218242,
-0.0447942354,
0.0154653108,
-0.0575875305,
0.0048237373,
-0.0299659818,
0.0213928409,
-0.0351603553,
0.0347241201,
-0.0349230692,
-0.0162810199,
-0.0634430945,
-0.0519900657,
0.0171536654,
-0.090131782,
-0.0026867352,
0.0866958052,
2.411e-7,
0.0116852969,
-0.0032186322,
0.0146548999,
0.041642759,
0.0051072622,
0.0291632991,
0.0175638907,
0.0401178263,
-0.0122621125,
-0.0427129939,
0.0061624129,
0.0841049105,
-0.0124993613,
0.0191120841,
-0.0643826127,
0.0626076385,
-0.0117212888,
-0.0214098599,
-0.0678706095,
0.0030065009,
0.0463583171,
0.0526269116,
-0.0257699732,
-0.0069105085,
0.0242969077,
-0.0123578534,
0.0265892111,
0.0055249068,
0.0358054005,
-0.0013419839,
0.0413575172,
0.0173725933,
0.0133849233,
0.019611381,
-0.0094563896,
-0.0050112265,
0.0345019624,
0.0219263509,
0.0128899105,
-0.0192548297,
-0.0212030225,
-0.0193030648,
0.0037867383,
-0.0173184145,
0.0954900682,
-0.0567513108,
0.0087488154,
-0.0243692566,
-0.0197329074,
-0.0145998048,
0.0323609151,
0.0079884352,
0.0170271397,
0.0122839855,
0.0283456277,
-0.0582806952,
0.0136394575,
-0.0651341602,
-0.0206170548,
-0.0413468927,
-0.0243558735,
0.0176133532,
0.0030883197,
-0.0426677279,
0.0148209538,
-0.0106534492,
-0.0844565183,
1.464472762e-34,
0.0268566851,
0.018109953,
0.0019587663,
0.007862133,
0.0323835239,
-0.0198440999,
0.0144562824,
-0.0164646991,
-0.0084738992,
-0.0464944355,
-0.0055860379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17894v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17894v3 | Natural Language Interfaces for Tabular Data Querying and Visualization: A Survey | 2023-10-27T05:01:20 | 2024-05-20T02:45:37 | Weixu Zhang, Yifei Wang, Yuanfeng Song, Victor Junqiu Wei, Yuxing Tian, Yiyan Qi, Jonathan H. Chan, Raymond Chi-Wing Wong, Haiqin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergence of natural language processing has revolutionized the way users
interact with tabular data, enabling a shift from traditional query languages
and manual plotting to more intuitive, language-based interfaces. The rise of
large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and its successors has further
advanced this field, opening new avenues for natural language processing
techniques. This survey presents a comprehensive overview of natural language
interfaces for tabular data querying and visualization, which allow users to
interact with data using natural language queries. We introduce the fundamental
concepts and techniques underlying these interfaces with a particular emphasis
on semantic parsing, the key technology facilitating the translation from
natural language to SQL queries or data visualization commands. We then delve
into the recent advancements in Text-to-SQL and Text-to-Vis problems from the
perspectives of datasets, methodologies, metrics, and system designs. This
includes a deep dive into the influence of LLMs, highlighting their strengths,
limitations, and potential for future improvements. Through this survey, we aim
to provide a roadmap for researchers and practitioners interested in developing
and applying natural language interfaces for data interaction in the era of
large language models. | [
0.0040468355,
0.0419381633,
-0.0266717579,
0.0230866857,
-0.0369565301,
-0.0005175181,
-0.0293553807,
0.0266318917,
0.0425844714,
-0.0119829439,
-0.0113569228,
0.0152397985,
-0.0190012064,
0.0368351005,
0.0237630736,
-0.0660485327,
0.0483857282,
0.0112930872,
-0.0076254425,
0.0728813335,
-0.0030771517,
0.0368004404,
-0.0074947085,
0.0183125772,
-0.0255007986,
-0.0242907908,
-0.0267093237,
-0.0094300127,
-0.0363449939,
-0.0471264347,
-0.0574171655,
0.0224650055,
0.030382948,
0.0050101811,
0.0000020347,
-0.0542570613,
-0.0564747341,
0.0106878439,
-0.013512698,
-0.0189598184,
0.0729838833,
-0.0334021747,
0.0124712074,
0.0071870941,
-0.0373041704,
-0.0206030589,
0.0310360622,
0.0264860075,
0.0859070271,
0.0013002455,
-0.0313019194,
-0.0327997804,
-0.0223541856,
0.0359551571,
0.0220319256,
0.0000063987,
-0.023743799,
0.0228950102,
0.0536328256,
0.0209296979,
0.0090420656,
0.0222383216,
-0.0171759091,
-0.0502612554,
0.0151191419,
0.0130678322,
-0.0370894261,
-0.0028446324,
-0.00906335,
0.0254954938,
0.016693024,
0.0042995391,
0.014261716,
0.0063405763,
0.0144129461,
0.0152534731,
-0.0612477958,
-0.0172770172,
-0.0137564642,
-0.0072223595,
0.0032553058,
0.0034808132,
-0.0043862741,
-0.008454877,
-0.0596918389,
0.0104451505,
-0.0105417594,
-0.0250481702,
0.0204245411,
-0.0442732982,
0.0030259066,
-0.0280843172,
0.0438473411,
0.0517702177,
-0.0708144233,
0.0414847173,
-0.0126444278,
-0.0416574776,
0.0297986493,
-0.0469394252,
0.0248159245,
0.034464974,
0.0064801089,
0.0375700146,
0.0230728108,
0.0406508371,
0.0308012608,
0.0078753242,
-0.009235343,
-0.0483699813,
-0.045892287,
-0.0257350225,
-0.0756630227,
-0.0029844448,
-0.077663824,
0.0092235655,
-0.0060808985,
0.014885433,
0.0098247342,
0.0289570484,
0.0238735806,
-0.0075815474,
-0.0137496088,
0.0183874704,
-0.0875435546,
0.0113766603,
-0.0093701119,
-0.0487298518,
-0.0239480454,
-0.0825156048,
0.0103364056,
0.0152250919,
0.0315426998,
-0.034632992,
-0.0200982261,
0.0813413635,
0.0097563397,
0.0367161781,
-0.0443066061,
-0.0347225629,
-0.039404314,
0.0128849177,
-0.0256834924,
-0.0470314771,
0.0532276481,
0.0162447821,
-0.0121016195,
-0.0455163307,
0.0016876599,
0.0649656653,
-0.0188707039,
0.0744087845,
-0.0654709712,
0.0088128494,
-0.0027790782,
-0.0440882444,
0.0101862913,
0.0487394743,
0.0344971083,
-0.016964959,
0.0120476913,
-0.0249685254,
-0.0149193369,
0.034552075,
-0.0046053459,
-0.0447454415,
-0.0722497329,
0.0357531644,
0.0005891907,
0.0327419788,
-0.0364843085,
0.049584765,
-0.0124636758,
-0.0043807328,
0.0210175142,
0.0922260359,
0.0362988859,
0.0487886779,
0.0050584041,
0.0751331374,
0.0143904379,
-0.0378301591,
-0.0013677425,
0.0232675411,
0.0453505367,
0.001803153,
0.0125911636,
0.0204758178,
0.0108621428,
-0.0892521665,
-0.0158395842,
0.025536688,
0.0255240686,
-0.0242282208,
0.0320208669,
-0.0012465072,
0.0085146492,
-0.0068709031,
0.0022695547,
-0.0432404093,
0.0010916814,
-0.000578081,
-0.0146099068,
0.0793524384,
0.0236030016,
-0.0553618781,
-0.0229055528,
-0.0003212521,
0.0017890523,
0.0461046919,
0.0380089283,
-0.0084576895,
-0.0309785306,
-0.0085470984,
-0.01580639,
0.0508768708,
-0.0064218659,
-0.0235292409,
-0.0119676357,
0.0060332608,
-0.0108541306,
-0.0255659409,
-0.0596072488,
0.0144376317,
0.0453427732,
0.0065603177,
-0.007751774,
0.015755631,
-0.0152318617,
0.0486218892,
0.0160061773,
0.0463474952,
0.0392776616,
-0.0086588627,
-0.0035704372,
0.0208971202,
0.0399174169,
-0.0215965398,
-0.0037214542,
-0.032748837,
-0.0357469693,
-0.062687546,
-0.030284496,
-0.0167247858,
-0.0143303135,
-0.0342152789,
-0.0037741743,
-0.0174120944,
-0.0167425964,
0.0019359343,
-0.0373926014,
-0.0484970249,
0.0632581711,
0.0205411837,
0.0168340914,
0.011985614,
-0.0549643934,
0.0417040065,
-0.0472263582,
0.0335364155,
0.021147633,
0.0069639701,
0.002941347,
0.0314585343,
0.0202586763,
-0.0431462787,
-0.0025376908,
-0.074002631,
0.0221146047,
-0.0052853962,
0.0444450714,
0.0012252114,
0.032731995,
-0.0338164642,
-0.0279173609,
-0.0621873029,
-0.0312097687,
0.0375303067,
-0.0165078957,
0.0799244046,
0.004919738,
0.0016585145,
-0.0242142975,
-0.0029267601,
-0.0626042932,
0.0047953366,
0.0308612101,
-0.0929109454,
-0.0085437028,
-0.0167737547,
-0.0198639836,
0.0127288103,
0.0216903277,
0.0320813321,
0.0320965089,
-0.0443116538,
0.0325018801,
0.0198211167,
-0.0212829001,
0.0452833883,
0.0058375299,
-0.0327257067,
-0.0460418947,
0.0372308008,
-0.0044588898,
0.0301659815,
-0.0075353635,
-0.0380359851,
0.0842259973,
0.0219683908,
0.0007895442,
0.0093130264,
-0.0114291655,
0.0304051414,
-0.0040468671,
0.050768055,
-0.0539617799,
0.0288799107,
0.0063295523,
0.037940897,
-0.0092702406,
-0.0001895988,
0.0393466018,
-0.0327137075,
-0.0035133078,
-0.0640281662,
-0.0216235109,
-0.0546477139,
0.0945012048,
0.0143821146,
0.0044898158,
-0.0032628193,
-0.0554870442,
-0.0059045302,
-0.015768623,
0.0012264543,
-0.01791838,
0.0635401979,
-0.0319938138,
0.0027988846,
-0.0200898517,
0.012236326,
-0.0102158347,
-0.007305346,
-0.0268467367,
0.0039449618,
0.0736248866,
-0.0161624998,
0.0002288818,
-0.0012860575,
0.0169505272,
0.0109678423,
0.0231244545,
-0.0505360737,
-0.0410992689,
-0.0114182206,
0.0116921784,
0.0173678361,
-0.027661711,
0.029649999,
0.0148618547,
0.0523377545,
-0.0237273797,
-0.0168241858,
-0.0298494231,
0.0160907246,
-0.001927813,
-0.0409004092,
-0.0172313359,
0.0336883925,
-0.0343335159,
-0.0623866357,
0.0446805097,
0.0934778303,
0.0476937555,
0.0102580395,
-0.0048176423,
-0.003999752,
0.0272629894,
0.027921414,
0.0565966703,
-0.0975386426,
-0.01509705,
-0.0303439647,
-0.0054469421,
0.0340053327,
-0.0615769029,
-0.0137315616,
-0.1048571095,
0.0599091202,
-0.0177072678,
-0.0302519817,
-0.0323937014,
-0.0493995845,
-0.0154832061,
-0.0337472633,
-0.0018813153,
0.022112783,
-0.0169191957,
-0.0038960841,
0.0026335013,
-0.0427859165,
-0.0120735159,
-0.0326424167,
-0.0596106164,
0.0071708336,
0.0167904999,
0.0861919448,
0.0089331567,
-0.0169955753,
-0.0069543337,
0.0678474456,
0.0162406061,
-0.0487183332,
0.0592937842,
0.0216111746,
-0.0101559767,
-0.0343369991,
-0.0450564213,
0.0063149491,
0.0182050858,
-0.0119029079,
0.097176753,
-0.0450764261,
0.0704419985,
-0.0189145505,
-0.0119700115,
0.0184051655,
0.0406948552,
0.0164534692,
-0.0012391424,
-0.0736187324,
-0.0601114891,
-0.0171637423,
-0.0312582366,
-0.0360828564,
0.0464644991,
-0.0375166535,
-0.0469664559,
-0.0370862707,
-0.0212515481,
0.0843575746,
0.0162794441,
0.0096603716,
0.0358042084,
0.0553884804,
-0.0205780473,
-0.0055983216,
-0.0098810168,
-0.0427140594,
0.012043138,
0.0125332205,
-0.0039636656,
0.0059976354,
-0.0070827114,
-0.0167666767,
-0.0037944948,
-0.0095483428,
-0.0199064594,
-0.0295899939,
-0.0139345843,
0.0177678559,
-0.0156986471,
0.0061126044,
-0.0289235767,
-0.0473138765,
0.0475743413,
-0.068959482,
-0.1047160476,
-0.0595026501,
0.0482497551,
0.0141305309,
0.0148284612,
-0.0095848935,
-0.0190804712,
-0.0889832303,
0.0364890024,
-0.0214240346,
0.0039296034,
0.0677086785,
0.0261126067,
0.0191758312,
0.0508631431,
-0.0133416727,
0.0072377198,
-0.0062017897,
-0.0901498422,
-0.0758552253,
-0.0153365666,
-0.0020249556,
-0.0297404509,
-0.0198882185,
0.0296973903,
-0.0076725003,
-0.0231014714,
0.0420933291,
-0.0390763581,
0.0389632694,
0.0198442414,
-0.0415919013,
0.0092701055,
0.0033908079,
0.0103683965,
0.0117706191,
-0.0048201028,
0.0451123565,
-0.0171583034,
0.0320862494,
0.025684068,
-0.0350397974,
-0.0214560293,
-0.0032064547,
-0.0261493679,
-0.0691065416,
0.0447332598,
0.0244535338,
-0.0038276727,
-0.0024956616,
0.0215366948,
-0.026594881,
-0.009663647,
0.0161979534,
0.017997453,
0.0714656711,
-0.0116997613,
0.0248703044,
-0.0104239378,
-0.0237671603,
-0.0936895609,
0.0430185758,
0.0211753193,
-0.0272520334,
-0.0056642452,
-0.0976268873,
-0.0208891612,
-0.0005313477,
0.024674328,
-0.0113804927,
-0.0219084583,
-0.0143649513,
-0.0534902923,
-0.0220276993,
0.0157072488,
0.0495040864,
-0.0377772041,
-0.0220631957,
0.0393472314,
0.04246163,
0.0640791059,
-0.0336644389,
-0.0089127515,
0.0443600416,
-0.0473083965,
-0.0559288114,
-0.0303535648,
-5.664876989e-33,
-0.0575873293,
-0.0509123057,
0.0452569872,
0.0129201291,
0.0104430094,
-0.0834120288,
-0.0194483306,
-0.0022166918,
-0.0061863745,
0.013049366,
-0.0237204898,
0.0145476442,
0.0237789266,
0.0155442785,
0.0131172854,
-0.0533653833,
0.0415246226,
0.019903155,
0.0199177563,
-0.0160835776,
0.0131279519,
0.0118691782,
0.0314282663,
-0.0619503371,
0.0661443397,
0.0327654593,
0.0373831242,
0.0285964888,
0.0265207756,
0.0156780984,
-0.0144578991,
0.0473896973,
0.0199621208,
-0.0151134273,
-0.0562678613,
0.029601343,
-0.0889559612,
-0.0562191606,
-0.0025759824,
0.0353019014,
-0.0189202838,
-0.0145626934,
0.0487783067,
-0.0161397476,
-0.0233640913,
0.0302596763,
0.0324642099,
-0.0294550918,
-0.0175903179,
0.0245058332,
-0.0191724263,
0.0396594144,
-0.013214591,
0.0281154234,
0.0439241789,
0.0201430172,
0.0138979256,
0.0088774748,
-0.0525534898,
0.0335917585,
0.0365402438,
0.0108332112,
0.0439344235,
0.005101053,
0.0424316637,
0.0135757253,
0.032649219,
-0.0058037844,
-0.0151594374,
0.0587742031,
-0.0185159631,
0.0665084794,
0.0247782748,
0.0068861777,
0.018204676,
0.0185889546,
-0.0700735077,
0.0477873497,
-0.0379255228,
0.0369636603,
-0.0279373918,
0.0280881077,
-0.0417939872,
-0.0396761931,
-0.0218667947,
0.0090515343,
-0.0168280546,
-0.0126250824,
0.0255889967,
-0.0445232093,
0.042155236,
0.0257179644,
0.0044794283,
0.0153987668,
-0.0634327307,
0.0040740483,
0.0034274198,
-0.0105968658,
-0.0118736168,
0.000827255,
-0.0120781828,
0.0088847037,
-0.0196702126,
-0.0025230553,
0.0219028648,
0.0309061632,
-0.0061558061,
0.008918466,
-0.0673135743,
0.0128036533,
0.0051429495,
-0.005218918,
-0.0148486048,
0.008882191,
0.0288313571,
-0.0122811729,
0.015088968,
0.0611294061,
0.0274196099,
-0.0164859369,
-0.010530143,
-0.0396893099,
-0.0217854232,
-0.0496393889,
0.0277192537,
0.0080451574,
-0.035659235,
-0.0074833361,
0.0521329902,
-0.0145161254,
0.0011350127,
0.0057785888,
2.528e-7,
0.0998091996,
0.0560579672,
0.0539829694,
0.0816831738,
0.0074129649,
-0.0038434414,
0.0173528381,
0.0067418604,
0.0028406528,
-0.0008648344,
-0.0002763539,
0.0029699481,
0.0357024707,
0.0706443191,
-0.060739886,
-0.0131069636,
-0.0157171208,
-0.0450349599,
-0.1148075461,
0.0477973074,
0.1473606229,
0.0490629263,
-0.0445451513,
0.020526085,
-0.0232617203,
-0.0560346581,
0.0080988472,
-0.0457495451,
0.0003216249,
0.0405703932,
0.0523273461,
0.00030026,
0.0057119834,
0.0296198521,
0.0028016979,
-0.00067266,
-0.0056612683,
0.0358305946,
-0.0057081305,
0.075793393,
0.0151513154,
-0.0650365651,
0.0026922741,
-0.0308156069,
0.0652364492,
-0.0572299175,
0.0078000086,
0.0627217218,
0.0301181488,
-0.0047582546,
0.0072314776,
-0.0144364238,
-0.0490718521,
-0.0027365661,
0.0330990329,
0.0049605821,
-0.0038943137,
-0.0098913396,
-0.0290916786,
0.0215576869,
0.0066747931,
0.0171788428,
-0.0500188209,
0.0207774751,
0.0078979451,
-0.0079431962,
-0.0021338749,
2.844978264e-34,
0.0367577113,
0.0247749165,
0.0379471816,
0.0154178571,
0.1041149199,
0.0012266396,
0.002897304,
0.0310553983,
0.0174614415,
-0.0879035965,
-0.0171519797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17884v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17884v2 | Can LLMs Keep a Secret? Testing Privacy Implications of Language Models via Contextual Integrity Theory | 2023-10-27T04:15:30 | 2024-06-28T23:27:10 | Niloofar Mireshghallah, Hyunwoo Kim, Xuhui Zhou, Yulia Tsvetkov, Maarten Sap, Reza Shokri, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | The interactive use of large language models (LLMs) in AI assistants (at
work, home, etc.) introduces a new set of inference-time privacy risks: LLMs
are fed different types of information from multiple sources in their inputs
and are expected to reason about what to share in their outputs, for what
purpose and with whom, within a given context. In this work, we draw attention
to the highly critical yet overlooked notion of contextual privacy by proposing
ConfAIde, a benchmark designed to identify critical weaknesses in the privacy
reasoning capabilities of instruction-tuned LLMs. Our experiments show that
even the most capable models such as GPT-4 and ChatGPT reveal private
information in contexts that humans would not, 39% and 57% of the time,
respectively. This leakage persists even when we employ privacy-inducing
prompts or chain-of-thought reasoning. Our work underscores the immediate need
to explore novel inference-time privacy-preserving approaches, based on
reasoning and theory of mind. | [
0.0168643147,
0.0864648372,
-0.0411791913,
0.0676944405,
-0.0943307579,
-0.026204912,
0.0725590512,
-0.0059057269,
0.0398560129,
-0.0179910064,
-0.041217234,
-0.0489372611,
0.0132382866,
-0.0055858344,
-0.0014131345,
0.015602096,
0.0336318873,
-0.0554997511,
0.0054881163,
-0.0279896129,
-0.0491310507,
0.0149853984,
0.005473976,
0.0394857153,
-0.0007192091,
-0.0344986916,
-0.0282706786,
-0.0183248725,
0.0149887204,
0.0077675888,
-0.0294351019,
0.0643422231,
0.0053512007,
0.0796469077,
0.0000020051,
-0.0648244768,
-0.0300387368,
0.0432391651,
-0.062876679,
0.0304377675,
-0.018937571,
0.0062643667,
0.0026243369,
0.0080751348,
-0.0458938181,
0.0541576967,
0.0202094093,
0.0299954638,
0.0234593898,
0.066258356,
-0.0052791834,
0.0019660469,
0.0414896533,
-0.0442048647,
0.0271738786,
-0.135874927,
0.0022922182,
-0.0561775602,
-0.0215144958,
0.0150574455,
0.0268773362,
0.0331316926,
0.0367009565,
0.0056595257,
-0.0497807786,
0.0313757844,
-0.0077906693,
-0.0234318972,
-0.0244849715,
0.0427087657,
0.0379615612,
0.0213471595,
-0.0001301063,
0.0205019042,
0.0322605409,
-0.0006552701,
0.0150361536,
0.0643061996,
-0.0630476028,
-0.0024685878,
0.0341242328,
0.0138704414,
0.0462778509,
0.0281748436,
0.0123639889,
0.066162765,
0.006378314,
-0.0008669457,
-0.0055732229,
-0.0340045542,
-0.0103497636,
-0.077124469,
0.0168083068,
0.0251203813,
-0.0042905975,
0.0154586723,
-0.0597763769,
0.0072588678,
0.022216998,
-0.0109300949,
0.0076203449,
0.0293210596,
0.0200002976,
0.0376607738,
0.0264416598,
0.0688071176,
-0.0200860519,
0.04014761,
0.0247034058,
-0.004334576,
-0.0209511034,
-0.0306519847,
-0.0042575309,
0.0545623899,
-0.048029732,
-0.0170288049,
-0.0101952869,
0.0336625464,
-0.0509189554,
0.0486096255,
-0.0229279473,
-0.0052232794,
-0.0252006091,
-0.031017622,
-0.0209222883,
-0.0592231043,
-0.0012993154,
0.0247722212,
0.0207595471,
-0.0726764649,
-0.0167572405,
-0.058365494,
-0.0373203121,
-0.007935266,
-0.028261967,
0.0888092369,
0.0095814904,
-0.0655857399,
0.0023765464,
-0.0729299113,
0.0057393326,
-0.0694768131,
-0.0037364163,
-0.0132472739,
0.0178826377,
-0.006089367,
-0.016387675,
-0.0602476709,
0.013326548,
0.0069236429,
-0.0336833857,
0.0878072381,
0.0351430513,
-0.0163988229,
-0.0268964898,
0.082212612,
-0.0377016217,
0.0158004537,
0.0306246374,
0.0260113757,
0.0455161072,
0.0103852954,
0.0420999639,
-0.0149688153,
0.023070978,
0.0140968291,
-0.0210710149,
0.0251103081,
0.0021533417,
-0.0297964811,
-0.0259839483,
0.0753589198,
0.0049349838,
-0.0358263254,
0.0824170783,
0.0747300684,
-0.020487817,
0.0137017062,
-0.0360023305,
0.0017261056,
-0.0089654392,
0.0072922106,
-0.0850951448,
0.0131774796,
-0.0735902339,
-0.0303474199,
-0.00562444,
0.016234532,
-0.0180243887,
-0.0039785798,
0.008326062,
-0.0485889129,
0.0377167612,
0.0048823319,
-0.0307622049,
-0.0047534807,
0.0032291587,
0.0111815054,
-0.0140158907,
-0.0479369946,
-0.037344832,
-0.0850891992,
0.0418052934,
0.0881371275,
0.0592872687,
0.0043805661,
0.0009525443,
-0.0319131985,
-0.0062505873,
0.0283641331,
0.0235620458,
0.0200868752,
0.069134675,
-0.0180039555,
-0.0206593666,
-0.0226743594,
0.0433558561,
0.0267637335,
-0.0172527712,
-0.0103991777,
0.0210724529,
-0.0233250372,
0.0277282018,
0.0010768394,
-0.0340056159,
-0.0165763646,
-0.0114572458,
0.0090778917,
0.0048054946,
0.0321928449,
-0.0086939791,
0.0150609007,
0.0185965709,
0.0255424958,
0.0039890991,
-0.0039688102,
-0.0558865815,
0.0148509191,
-0.0220108498,
-0.0126291597,
0.0163698476,
0.0041379146,
-0.0012188425,
-0.0087879021,
-0.0156654902,
-0.0164663885,
0.0550704449,
-0.0224288423,
0.0356832929,
-0.0136166569,
0.0082684169,
-0.0068932148,
0.0362870954,
-0.0600629337,
-0.0271845385,
-0.0038370413,
0.0237676892,
-0.0092762811,
-0.03098814,
0.0173034333,
0.0174248554,
0.00885153,
0.0239230115,
0.0021625236,
-0.0088121789,
-0.0076966183,
-0.0203535818,
-0.0638308451,
-0.0015213734,
-0.0050318115,
0.0196137987,
-0.0037223669,
0.010027403,
-0.0074761161,
-0.0041887779,
-0.0251599681,
-0.0169919059,
-0.0233407319,
0.0340420231,
0.0211110469,
0.0001302459,
-0.0373403654,
0.0083996411,
0.0255257208,
-0.0190762114,
0.0002647549,
-0.0400714725,
0.0009602649,
-0.0232129134,
0.0414500572,
-0.0093595814,
0.0332772397,
-0.0284149945,
-0.0092771864,
0.0188938119,
0.0118057188,
-0.0274772365,
0.0810857043,
0.0085180234,
0.0355292894,
0.0457797758,
0.0000649725,
-0.0297654755,
0.0056591202,
0.0168701541,
-0.0381503515,
-0.030387301,
-0.0184123982,
-0.0049899784,
0.0246201698,
0.0103935562,
-0.0201486293,
-0.042713467,
0.0556659736,
-0.0073851934,
-0.0434303209,
0.008743234,
-0.0489142649,
-0.0153994374,
0.0713963136,
-0.0151935937,
-0.0746355727,
0.0648426786,
-0.0397645272,
0.0426265858,
0.0016976547,
0.0020657661,
-0.0117162215,
0.09852276,
-0.0094971396,
0.0173200313,
0.0505444929,
-0.0407111757,
-0.0284403991,
0.0014323363,
0.0236712825,
-0.0459732413,
0.0157704074,
-0.0489743911,
-0.0447420329,
-0.0068332343,
-0.0590314046,
-0.0619007125,
-0.0300901216,
-0.0157527775,
0.0147363357,
-0.0082789566,
-0.0431816168,
0.0344520546,
-0.0360132232,
0.0277963988,
-0.0019145539,
-0.0176150315,
-0.0073905955,
-0.0440428257,
-0.0246150419,
0.0037395826,
-0.0106999893,
-0.005080746,
-0.0098972553,
0.0363557525,
0.0674345121,
0.0407202356,
0.0423951522,
0.0271877013,
-0.0252081454,
0.0008057065,
0.0258641131,
-0.049303595,
0.034363661,
0.0694039389,
-0.0468405001,
-0.0289734602,
0.1070870236,
0.0332747698,
-0.0525903739,
0.0007969064,
0.0015621819,
-0.0040379567,
-0.002515564,
-0.0117766224,
-0.1018807888,
-0.0112685245,
0.0533076189,
0.0210391674,
-0.0527178459,
-0.0523039177,
-0.0329573713,
-0.1039518192,
-0.0077149174,
-0.0043262471,
0.0000319628,
-0.0356711783,
-0.0360149629,
0.0109730875,
0.0099238064,
0.045899082,
-0.032143563,
0.0266583227,
-0.0300320238,
-0.0168242641,
0.0061623394,
-0.0265575089,
0.0443225428,
-0.0155998105,
0.0607915558,
0.0676452667,
0.0204925314,
-0.0042712279,
-0.0815650821,
0.0269054025,
0.0307196714,
-0.0022293101,
0.0158795863,
0.0271673556,
-0.0054492219,
0.0175062884,
0.016316345,
0.056078326,
0.0047211144,
-0.0004729882,
0.021471316,
0.0298436321,
-0.0467106327,
-0.0112092355,
0.0071172407,
-0.0289338995,
0.0311061312,
0.0781709701,
0.0006604483,
-0.0288237501,
-0.0025215836,
-0.0361814611,
0.0397144184,
0.0041933693,
0.0248659998,
0.0172173232,
0.0231356379,
-0.0489377752,
-0.0187457707,
-0.0121398009,
-0.0142468959,
0.0046413895,
0.0500641353,
-0.0098257298,
0.014414886,
0.0158982556,
-0.0035090132,
-0.015102475,
-0.0778624564,
0.0383002199,
-0.0222021248,
0.0300308615,
-0.0086487625,
-0.0101218186,
0.0084538115,
0.0326565839,
-0.0526347533,
-0.0457394868,
0.0214821827,
0.0370633081,
0.0321428739,
0.0445679985,
-0.0435124971,
-0.0270638131,
0.0213158764,
0.037791986,
-0.0571943633,
0.032825008,
0.0817862377,
0.0004960934,
0.0267219301,
0.0517272875,
-0.0280841868,
-0.0148456832,
0.0238121375,
-0.0085395398,
-0.0369168781,
-0.0675209314,
-0.0055921506,
0.0231188722,
-0.0014640009,
0.0333856344,
0.0598315448,
-0.020674102,
0.0341623425,
-0.034519624,
0.0090157213,
-0.0267168488,
-0.0074828663,
0.0500101522,
-0.0016890598,
0.0463011675,
-0.0587669127,
0.0281532332,
0.0067341719,
-0.0111221895,
-0.0043152976,
0.0184674505,
0.0493216515,
0.02498281,
0.0003754008,
-0.0290245134,
0.0623701103,
-0.014342512,
0.0492552929,
-0.0204827823,
0.0780734122,
0.0165766813,
-0.0205497742,
-0.0459579155,
0.0625970587,
-0.0728679746,
-0.0502214693,
0.0542699508,
0.0500365086,
0.0009247743,
0.0111966673,
-0.0138966786,
-0.0592219271,
0.0158593208,
-0.0046309861,
0.016006697,
0.0302769914,
-0.0456082001,
0.0102080191,
-0.0009897997,
-0.0173210241,
0.0487145782,
0.0645363852,
-0.0191440545,
0.0595075563,
-0.0247995313,
-0.016026549,
-0.0466245562,
-0.0182206556,
-0.0087237572,
0.0620762929,
-0.0033974764,
0.0014201157,
-0.0865036473,
-0.064003624,
0.001310245,
-0.0214168783,
0.0166052021,
-0.0306999777,
-0.0027304096,
0.0381983072,
0.0144302621,
-0.0710726753,
-0.0524703749,
-0.0335252248,
-0.0014863341,
0.0084941369,
-0.0236654021,
-5.647402898e-33,
-0.012983649,
-0.0340630896,
-0.0241207816,
0.0357878208,
0.0235494748,
0.0297458395,
-0.0261506215,
0.0090664551,
-0.0477973856,
-0.0332756415,
-0.0640018806,
0.0325459987,
0.0084276721,
0.01039638,
-0.0390232839,
-0.0109105613,
0.0146027394,
-0.0091602625,
-0.0097088628,
0.0314733945,
0.0462721288,
-0.0137331225,
0.0098914197,
-0.0757975653,
0.0670731887,
0.0134654595,
-0.0589234978,
0.0277078375,
-0.1016103998,
0.0418483838,
-0.0411198623,
-0.0088075567,
0.0005812185,
-0.0081208553,
0.0253574792,
0.0362492725,
-0.0174154285,
-0.0284489561,
0.0214132816,
-0.0431467667,
-0.0262567271,
-0.0920614675,
-0.0108445231,
-0.0147626139,
-0.0372092202,
0.0074994205,
-0.0270387474,
-0.0140142115,
-0.0074495464,
0.0035919959,
-0.0074175815,
-0.0199657176,
-0.0169273727,
-0.0296473484,
0.0462885946,
-0.0160228685,
0.0097703766,
-0.0471164808,
-0.0465181991,
0.0250588916,
0.0350558646,
-0.0242476985,
0.0684321001,
-0.0224110931,
0.012060157,
0.0480711646,
0.049150072,
0.0342694446,
-0.0264567304,
-0.0116543807,
-0.0144753587,
0.059043318,
0.0115568517,
0.0106640505,
-0.0224930085,
-0.0479570441,
-0.016636325,
-0.014530818,
0.0081259841,
0.00565443,
0.0767792612,
-0.0047875922,
-0.0983697176,
-0.0055959891,
-0.0568958297,
-0.025246812,
-0.0527723543,
0.0237490255,
0.0138965668,
0.0185583979,
-0.0223225709,
-0.0283830669,
0.0116650527,
-0.0488322973,
-0.0112341549,
0.0277106855,
0.0309166182,
-0.0248692837,
-0.0083699999,
0.0307135619,
-0.0391934365,
-0.0074299774,
0.0244096871,
0.0058730473,
0.0371073931,
0.0261475649,
0.0351087004,
0.0221820716,
-0.0430743061,
-0.0314289033,
-0.0478775762,
0.0481250435,
0.0273009166,
-0.0375927724,
0.0570639782,
-0.0148137566,
-0.0209142361,
0.0337952077,
0.0295508523,
0.0165002812,
-0.0617668293,
0.0474409088,
-0.0307059586,
-0.0102106631,
0.0171125233,
-0.0191930626,
0.0090889214,
0.0347080044,
0.0928371698,
-0.0030385747,
-0.0039676772,
-0.0306929369,
2.774e-7,
-0.0140329823,
-0.0117331529,
0.0037331192,
0.0385341756,
0.0259977225,
0.0704960302,
0.0065849507,
0.0516315475,
-0.0062997383,
0.0073887962,
-0.0210868828,
0.0092392704,
0.0647191703,
0.0338720568,
-0.0122244535,
0.0050962302,
-0.0002786573,
-0.0127563542,
-0.0428641774,
0.03524445,
0.0415741429,
0.0648654327,
0.0539750271,
-0.0264157224,
-0.0089074951,
-0.0485954136,
0.0308702309,
-0.0413485393,
0.0007297775,
-0.0314601958,
0.0488446653,
0.059684597,
0.0177488197,
0.036312785,
0.0173878483,
0.0219835863,
-0.0676623732,
0.0663128123,
-0.0012017057,
-0.0522978231,
-0.0174975879,
-0.0616660342,
-0.0037800502,
-0.037377093,
0.0742850006,
0.0079461383,
-0.0578536503,
0.0005996943,
0.0556415506,
-0.0489398018,
0.0188976824,
0.0024320271,
-0.0080149295,
-0.000472354,
-0.0367768295,
0.0076811914,
-0.0024382616,
-0.0643404499,
-0.0219156872,
-0.0514684357,
-0.0106099723,
-0.0512233786,
0.0056384653,
0.0101992451,
0.0019609602,
-0.0434630401,
0.0409757793,
2.567855471e-34,
-0.0144058857,
-0.0256568547,
0.0136374887,
0.0641843602,
0.0458614156,
0.0151844025,
0.0377559364,
0.0201789569,
0.0280069765,
-0.0505766869,
-0.0198295526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17877v1 | ASPIRO: Any-shot Structured Parsing-error-Induced ReprOmpting for Consistent Data-to-Text Generation | 2023-10-27T03:39:51 | 2023-10-27T03:39:51 | Martin Vejvar, Yasutaka Fujimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present ASPIRO, an approach for structured data verbalisation into short
template sentences in zero to few-shot settings. Unlike previous methods, our
approach prompts large language models (LLMs) to directly produce
entity-agnostic templates, rather than relying on LLMs to faithfully copy the
given example entities, or validating/crafting the templates manually. We
incorporate LLM re-prompting, triggered by algorithmic parsing checks, as well
as the PARENT metric induced consistency validation to identify and rectify
template generation problems in real-time. ASPIRO, compared to direct LLM
output, averages 66\% parsing error rate reduction in generated verbalisations
of RDF triples on the DART dataset. Our best 5-shot text-davinci-003 setup,
scoring BLEU of 50.62, METEOR of 45.16, BLEURT of 0.82, NUBIA of 0.87, and
PARENT of 0.8962 on the Rel2Text dataset, competes effectively with recent
fine-tuned pre-trained language models. | [
0.0143657951,
0.023457678,
0.0308322869,
0.0272730403,
0.0034325083,
0.0111649176,
-0.0394845679,
0.0088968081,
-0.0389498249,
-0.1006731465,
-0.0229058247,
-0.005322366,
-0.0005347313,
-0.0019605858,
0.0419121459,
-0.0555309914,
0.0334341824,
-0.0197866,
0.0009256987,
0.0130267283,
0.0170780234,
0.0439187735,
0.01655991,
0.0245947521,
-0.0166035257,
-0.0299610533,
-0.0198543929,
0.0398150533,
-0.0191865433,
-0.0739213824,
-0.0051193214,
0.0440357365,
0.0084855212,
0.0213135444,
0.0000021368,
-0.0402612984,
-0.0303248409,
0.0304084271,
-0.00921614,
-0.0182186905,
0.0180103816,
-0.0444754064,
0.0311626196,
0.0288353525,
-0.0323718078,
-0.075243786,
0.0030483643,
0.0369566455,
0.0682252869,
0.0745014027,
-0.0148171624,
-0.0442636907,
0.0318760611,
-0.0395458043,
0.0140812695,
0.0166397821,
-0.0156805534,
0.0115188537,
0.0064868676,
0.0447458215,
0.0108993184,
0.0132827237,
-0.0094843637,
-0.0041986327,
0.0186729617,
0.0006825789,
-0.0595081337,
-0.0323446207,
-0.0086371647,
0.0874665156,
0.009898182,
-0.0117904749,
0.0155232865,
-0.0180578213,
-0.0171147101,
-0.0323333479,
-0.0249437187,
0.0235186666,
-0.0239375886,
0.0231116377,
0.0056249462,
-0.0343562216,
0.0513213649,
-0.0123172449,
-0.0111790104,
0.0679883957,
0.0173504185,
-0.0260993019,
-0.0350653306,
0.0107274204,
0.0082630496,
-0.0927629024,
-0.0240899231,
0.0233063269,
-0.0739655942,
0.0147048067,
-0.0949326903,
-0.0401369259,
0.0379002243,
0.0293446053,
0.0361958556,
0.0428825766,
-0.0165398605,
0.018678274,
-0.0362637676,
0.040521495,
0.0003434058,
0.0090471758,
-0.0144208558,
0.0136852302,
-0.0613311082,
0.0055094892,
-0.0320407748,
0.050643228,
-0.0390867144,
-0.0348373801,
-0.0142294159,
0.0376033038,
0.0021862779,
0.0765335858,
0.0444160961,
-0.0093114786,
-0.0136217438,
0.0286196694,
-0.0125115141,
0.0135618756,
0.0036819456,
-0.0294855684,
0.0395008139,
-0.049847465,
0.0245338026,
0.0153964339,
0.0037244493,
-0.0168618262,
-0.0121846292,
0.0831534415,
-0.0019113575,
0.0004714809,
-0.0415549651,
-0.0748504996,
-0.0112281227,
-0.0475459918,
0.0159661788,
-0.0785067007,
0.0547492206,
0.0342576616,
-0.0008842653,
-0.0418291315,
0.0494947918,
0.0193907134,
-0.0495644361,
0.0698122233,
-0.084434092,
0.0173706431,
-0.0220832136,
-0.0035441087,
-0.0030593297,
0.0754954442,
0.0463797674,
-0.0111407815,
0.0299596563,
0.0256877858,
-0.0286735054,
0.0278645456,
0.0264576077,
0.0047398265,
-0.0480926186,
0.0341447778,
-0.0223917421,
0.070116438,
0.0590570047,
0.0791435614,
-0.0378889926,
0.0364356637,
0.013543522,
-0.0239758566,
0.0088188984,
0.0336667895,
0.1016092673,
-0.0027341896,
-0.0173500627,
0.0138262212,
-0.0617865697,
-0.0191281475,
0.0332224518,
0.0312585831,
0.0385838225,
0.0091865342,
-0.0245298054,
-0.0137410667,
-0.0337887518,
0.0066725397,
-0.0496405438,
-0.0525196604,
-0.0070516597,
0.0317247063,
-0.0605886057,
0.0696295351,
0.0086193215,
-0.0564671531,
0.0312733203,
0.0032844313,
0.0325223096,
0.0890462101,
0.0653447658,
-0.0111405272,
-0.0589949451,
-0.0220546462,
0.0207284093,
0.0545971207,
0.0209153388,
-0.0114729945,
0.0106756706,
-0.0356378667,
-0.0414757393,
-0.0201885272,
0.0026484285,
-0.0002626267,
0.0077816737,
-0.0063826172,
0.0316345207,
-0.0312856585,
-0.0166468676,
0.0516286902,
0.0125183826,
-0.0317630284,
0.0078438129,
-0.0073360894,
0.0082933651,
0.0193607938,
-0.0263832863,
0.0252751336,
0.0043501384,
-0.0102334162,
-0.0045654839,
0.0034054092,
-0.0334490687,
-0.0840433836,
0.0268801339,
-0.0050434861,
-0.014737051,
-0.0176103413,
-0.0624424331,
-0.045993004,
-0.0343440697,
-0.0041469354,
0.0342980921,
0.0109430933,
0.033886835,
0.0666523352,
-0.0030896673,
-0.0250796694,
0.0448688008,
-0.0128631415,
0.0271409545,
0.0197880249,
-0.0344237499,
0.0137184123,
-0.0564982556,
0.0280263219,
-0.0101561323,
-0.0064682956,
-0.0066208979,
0.0176168755,
0.0466560163,
-0.0448879004,
-0.0042165797,
-0.0439745449,
0.0004108633,
-0.0009136364,
0.0479422845,
0.0077616093,
0.0131052528,
0.0063214516,
-0.0102665639,
-0.0542696677,
-0.0085843224,
0.0239513777,
0.013380195,
0.0645645559,
-0.0060587386,
-0.0447393619,
-0.0179112609,
-0.0143457148,
-0.0388543345,
0.0457243249,
0.0159822442,
-0.0205814,
-0.0659598187,
0.073272258,
-0.0437074415,
0.0150676221,
0.0442476496,
0.0171289835,
0.0166316852,
-0.0179921295,
0.0531828552,
0.002296078,
-0.0345380828,
-0.0181661807,
0.0072220359,
-0.0049464698,
-0.0555967689,
-0.0017358139,
-0.0023024632,
0.0185415726,
0.002460904,
-0.0091106789,
0.0541290231,
0.0067168148,
0.004891654,
0.0073327795,
-0.0416805223,
-0.0011635551,
0.0214553252,
-0.0161965322,
-0.0137997884,
-0.016809931,
0.0248030573,
0.0216520578,
-0.0185524635,
-0.0058066091,
0.0479522794,
-0.0787274465,
0.0129322605,
0.0234830491,
0.0389076509,
-0.0511015914,
0.022217989,
0.0309279896,
0.0106816525,
-0.0348642021,
-0.0442613848,
-0.0381265953,
-0.048123274,
0.0220686533,
-0.0092835147,
0.0363307111,
-0.0402735509,
0.0124822827,
-0.0193272289,
-0.0368361995,
-0.0237074047,
0.0037232242,
-0.0176582299,
0.0382297859,
0.0088536916,
-0.0135505954,
0.0103895292,
-0.0237994324,
-0.0134593416,
0.0419609398,
-0.0233319029,
-0.056961108,
-0.0473563932,
0.0386341736,
0.0202436298,
-0.0323169604,
0.017471157,
-0.0432981029,
0.0235630497,
0.0431627445,
0.044229947,
0.0158160944,
-0.034458369,
0.0288779177,
0.0046127322,
-0.0264097583,
-0.0400179923,
-0.0067275027,
0.0265249163,
-0.0767770186,
-0.030421719,
0.1053424105,
0.0156974085,
-0.0108425207,
0.0181303453,
-0.007269301,
0.0534776859,
0.0216135532,
0.0362668857,
-0.132650122,
-0.0392835736,
0.017987458,
0.0610609241,
0.0281321164,
-0.0550741553,
-0.0064539486,
-0.1334657371,
0.0340289809,
0.0045106662,
-0.0299703125,
0.0197656378,
0.0078494856,
-0.0175792202,
0.0007737023,
0.0255790818,
0.0305467993,
-0.0429386906,
0.02208234,
0.009555907,
-0.0710359067,
-0.0381482728,
0.0058081257,
-0.0566401184,
0.0407616459,
0.0645341873,
0.0173794739,
0.0324386247,
-0.0240690242,
0.0074066967,
0.0344306454,
-0.0064161029,
-0.0330554657,
0.033860907,
-0.0328692608,
-0.0153061775,
0.0037444762,
0.0286760274,
-0.0545836017,
-0.019452082,
-0.0067508682,
0.0528245196,
-0.0123657761,
0.017383432,
0.0016014425,
-0.030734295,
0.0283168666,
0.0572260544,
0.0296426304,
0.0268647242,
-0.0630665123,
-0.0308722854,
-0.0038608958,
-0.0880051628,
0.006661199,
0.0398529023,
-0.0399807394,
-0.0218830574,
-0.0723851174,
-0.031132631,
0.0765030608,
0.0440123864,
-0.0062850537,
-0.0074108215,
-0.0260946192,
-0.0236861706,
-0.0396132208,
0.0022324033,
-0.0342446342,
-0.0044545494,
-0.072735481,
0.0022796863,
0.0051534288,
0.0016941478,
0.0010821897,
0.0123970807,
-0.0726224929,
-0.0342545882,
0.0176582206,
0.0841314346,
0.0166719798,
0.0378374457,
0.0119887898,
-0.0266113896,
0.0406925492,
0.0788199306,
-0.0529303625,
-0.0150094852,
0.0000256844,
0.0586828142,
-0.0022787175,
0.0422099084,
-0.0592793748,
-0.017764112,
-0.0047055031,
0.0695588365,
0.0248509366,
-0.0022443205,
0.0606809109,
0.0789717436,
-0.015382004,
-0.0349148735,
0.030159317,
0.0100762919,
0.0125359092,
-0.0508542247,
-0.0204816107,
-0.0632951632,
0.0486153364,
-0.0234518573,
-0.0182216167,
0.0192319155,
-0.0069711348,
-0.0261251442,
0.0569256917,
-0.044432845,
-0.0273448937,
-0.0194411892,
0.0045773918,
0.0451796614,
-0.0183492173,
-0.0324186571,
0.0410734825,
-0.0210878402,
0.0148213627,
-0.0499400795,
0.0116379065,
0.0444243252,
0.0268889684,
-0.0329392441,
0.0166139491,
-0.006637671,
-0.0272740852,
-0.0240077525,
-0.0120103257,
0.0496426336,
0.0417000577,
0.0963582844,
-0.0233231746,
-0.0109726842,
-0.0140703041,
0.063805759,
-0.0081597008,
-0.031236466,
0.0228914879,
0.0080684656,
-0.0409866124,
-0.0407086574,
0.0724900439,
0.0218945853,
0.0365253612,
0.0115568405,
-0.020703489,
-0.0548563525,
-0.0155695276,
0.0171590317,
-0.0155125149,
-0.0220591109,
-0.0394522361,
-0.0337460935,
-0.05438504,
0.0161564779,
0.0433838964,
-0.035760466,
0.0013035097,
0.0102831442,
0.0383434333,
0.0316996686,
-0.0374671705,
-0.0226055589,
-0.0014709736,
-0.0095314486,
-0.0460814312,
-0.0292900465,
-6.590250386e-33,
-0.0499556027,
-0.0200973023,
0.0412264317,
-0.0338553563,
-0.0489801913,
0.0000501799,
-0.0500097498,
-0.010711723,
0.0422334038,
0.0239708144,
-0.0099961748,
-0.0025385241,
0.0207393635,
0.043657247,
0.0261585359,
-0.0361898988,
0.056789279,
-0.0003936282,
-0.0281327087,
0.0137872808,
0.0579366349,
0.0252337754,
0.0104120048,
-0.0459753834,
0.007709288,
-0.0054442175,
-0.0364375226,
0.0425008126,
0.0251684096,
0.0368870422,
0.0062398571,
0.0122426981,
0.0145916184,
0.0101193916,
-0.0569508374,
-0.0390046686,
-0.125557065,
-0.0209648181,
0.0095768189,
0.0073276949,
-0.0889069214,
-0.0202853903,
0.0604105182,
-0.0247489642,
0.0169809535,
-0.0306580234,
-0.0088033797,
-0.0165293943,
-0.0168458968,
-0.0680880472,
-0.0561253838,
0.0298848189,
0.0226538628,
-0.0103500262,
0.0141832884,
0.0281406846,
0.0053198775,
0.0279034618,
-0.0882028118,
0.0042558946,
-0.0213172883,
0.0366842151,
0.0525287166,
0.0098211812,
0.005217148,
0.0589088537,
0.013994283,
-0.0031964283,
-0.0220407248,
0.0218232591,
-0.0106706079,
0.067819804,
-0.0186643805,
0.0638324693,
0.0038325104,
0.0222952738,
-0.0463518277,
0.0197209232,
-0.0278858766,
0.0381793901,
-0.0352620073,
0.0042842077,
-0.0099446895,
-0.0322807841,
-0.0193073638,
-0.0084197307,
-0.0314179063,
-0.0460187979,
0.0486343279,
0.0084152976,
-0.0130769685,
0.0185953844,
0.0279076118,
0.0030323621,
-0.0387206189,
0.0186186191,
-0.0314982757,
0.0096687749,
-0.0390622132,
0.0290872995,
-0.0261693373,
-0.0565495305,
0.0354287028,
-0.001106087,
0.0248990804,
0.0380511917,
0.0603610873,
0.0629901662,
-0.0923063904,
0.012667262,
-0.029949801,
0.0271541774,
-0.0300665405,
0.0195168499,
0.0461826511,
-0.0085899886,
-0.0028813838,
0.0325174481,
0.0156066697,
-0.037784826,
0.0008540029,
0.0267253984,
0.0277667902,
0.0639804453,
-0.0267600622,
-0.0113366321,
-0.0273432266,
-0.0496234335,
0.07670369,
-0.0292990766,
-0.0150734484,
-0.0133422837,
2.9e-7,
0.0409713015,
0.0550930724,
0.0486862659,
0.0443880595,
-0.0121025415,
0.0063249376,
0.0080645029,
0.0418430008,
-0.0219341256,
-0.0025623387,
0.0054761311,
-0.0159091391,
0.0399749428,
0.0525663607,
-0.060853865,
0.0134773403,
-0.0736048594,
-0.0029974908,
-0.0484282263,
-0.0247936919,
0.0502297096,
0.0553836934,
0.0144064873,
0.0020895819,
0.0052503669,
0.0015706733,
0.0306994841,
0.0244855229,
-0.0108357994,
0.0382384919,
-0.0051722284,
-0.0005761449,
-0.0098759662,
0.0059115742,
-0.0071820705,
-0.0257361457,
-0.001686306,
0.056234844,
-0.0015391062,
0.0407086276,
0.0128762908,
-0.0497957952,
0.0116504822,
-0.0148722026,
0.0333282985,
-0.0397672728,
0.00096945,
0.0256426185,
-0.0428453237,
0.0001621042,
-0.0158656538,
-0.0059091579,
-0.0124646751,
0.0279525965,
0.0303716976,
0.0349565893,
-0.0256782454,
-0.04533685,
-0.0291370861,
-0.0115239127,
-0.0232215989,
-0.0279195793,
-0.0167841073,
0.0067967982,
-0.0206042491,
-0.0827423185,
-0.0323551893,
3.246145328e-34,
0.0419629812,
0.0176520944,
-0.0034877323,
0.0160246324,
0.0464573316,
-0.0224430095,
0.0286153182,
0.0177745465,
0.0170069914,
-0.0474951006,
-0.0108779436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17876v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17876v2 | TarGEN: Targeted Data Generation with Large Language Models | 2023-10-27T03:32:17 | 2023-10-30T19:08:56 | Himanshu Gupta, Kevin Scaria, Ujjwala Anantheswaran, Shreyas Verma, Mihir Parmar, Saurabh Arjun Sawant, Chitta Baral, Swaroop Mishra | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has sparked interest in
data synthesis techniques, aiming to generate diverse and high-quality
synthetic datasets. However, these synthetic datasets often suffer from a lack
of diversity and added noise. In this paper, we present TarGEN, a multi-step
prompting strategy for generating high-quality synthetic datasets utilizing a
LLM. An advantage of TarGEN is its seedless nature; it does not require
specific task instances, broadening its applicability beyond task replication.
We augment TarGEN with a method known as self-correction empowering LLMs to
rectify inaccurately labeled instances during dataset creation, ensuring
reliable labels. To assess our technique's effectiveness, we emulate 8 tasks
from the SuperGLUE benchmark and finetune various language models, including
encoder-only, encoder-decoder, and decoder-only models on both synthetic and
original training sets. Evaluation on the original test set reveals that models
trained on datasets generated by TarGEN perform approximately 1-2% points
better than those trained on original datasets (82.84% via syn. vs. 81.12% on
og. using Flan-T5). When incorporating instruction tuning, the performance
increases to 84.54% on synthetic data vs. 81.49% on original data by Flan-T5. A
comprehensive analysis of the synthetic dataset compared to the original
dataset reveals that the synthetic dataset demonstrates similar or higher
levels of dataset complexity and diversity. Furthermore, the synthetic dataset
displays a bias level that aligns closely with the original dataset. Finally,
when pre-finetuned on our synthetic SuperGLUE dataset, T5-3B yields impressive
results on the OpenLLM leaderboard, surpassing the model trained on the
Self-Instruct dataset by 4.14% points. We hope that TarGEN can be helpful for
quality data generation and reducing the human efforts to create complex
benchmarks. | [
0.0244418643,
0.0581033751,
-0.0089781582,
0.047860764,
-0.004845737,
0.0205342248,
0.0174013954,
-0.023491567,
-0.0417575054,
-0.0242497064,
-0.0380792506,
-0.0372598059,
0.0054005105,
0.0359735005,
0.0368112437,
-0.0218288768,
0.0232391953,
-0.0406209752,
-0.0348291323,
-0.009917587,
-0.0406427905,
0.0379887633,
0.0098938122,
0.0445308276,
-0.0062678964,
-0.019678276,
-0.0142276753,
0.0429521985,
0.000796037,
-0.0085965209,
0.0148220481,
0.0741380304,
0.0305626821,
0.0450415872,
0.0000022334,
-0.0298327114,
0.0163612105,
-0.0248062462,
-0.0489177443,
0.0079879761,
0.0496940911,
-0.0225791,
-0.04800383,
0.0272103325,
-0.018695673,
-0.0456239395,
0.0601106398,
-0.0101719592,
0.0600811727,
0.0835193917,
-0.0120023508,
-0.0478331521,
-0.0012638776,
-0.0193285514,
0.0215361845,
0.0134339528,
0.0037005467,
0.02441095,
-0.0101247812,
-0.0049951519,
-0.011178365,
0.0233273804,
0.0371967815,
-0.004692391,
0.0104233809,
0.0320518166,
-0.0403215326,
-0.0479771607,
0.0012846382,
0.0743100867,
-0.055065807,
-0.0353754014,
-0.0251756161,
0.0027414565,
-0.0150429821,
-0.0391561612,
-0.0186345503,
0.0499607623,
-0.0082707629,
0.042013213,
0.0454345345,
-0.0054638432,
0.0229912605,
-0.0411095917,
-0.0264011603,
0.0013614991,
0.030939471,
-0.0165319275,
-0.0223745964,
0.0092760194,
-0.0065225717,
-0.0522673018,
-0.0235158298,
0.0046350197,
-0.0447661541,
0.0049304664,
-0.0835852847,
-0.0574790239,
0.0066086166,
-0.0230719112,
0.0836753622,
0.0457348898,
-0.0392040201,
-0.0129672717,
-0.0324857906,
0.0496708788,
-0.0026196523,
0.0350542329,
-0.0556004047,
-0.0263667889,
-0.0182833448,
0.0216746554,
-0.0254886895,
0.0019344729,
-0.0535917394,
0.0167311002,
-0.0254394207,
0.038415134,
0.0046082004,
0.0153139494,
0.0449807793,
-0.0074807848,
-0.0814609602,
0.0025436843,
0.0108398851,
-0.0112285363,
-0.0033695647,
0.0191725846,
0.0131573966,
-0.0968521237,
-0.0137002757,
0.0168746356,
-0.0022856134,
-0.0365617871,
0.0309618488,
0.0648240596,
-0.0230449159,
-0.01341628,
-0.0416678786,
-0.0025218001,
0.0194832049,
-0.0563566945,
0.0022929141,
-0.0719098672,
0.0337707102,
0.0025155656,
-0.0176268127,
-0.0337211825,
0.0057218489,
0.0045852428,
-0.004377007,
0.0471427143,
-0.0575572141,
0.0393127464,
-0.0002417748,
-0.016411975,
0.0031923593,
0.0782324821,
0.0405807532,
0.0418685004,
0.0247149114,
-0.0163439307,
0.0264128093,
0.0663327128,
0.0129865678,
0.011863742,
-0.0326429233,
-0.0134942885,
0.0249430221,
0.0315914638,
0.0683270022,
0.0305582024,
-0.0169734452,
0.0096459268,
0.0819697753,
0.0170255862,
0.0173977278,
0.0213604197,
0.0498307794,
0.0083061028,
0.0087142931,
-0.0053983266,
-0.0212651882,
0.0208093561,
-0.0006065755,
0.0157339815,
0.0033593348,
0.073771663,
-0.0599632561,
-0.0394106731,
-0.0161752626,
-0.0103919478,
-0.0176570639,
0.015743196,
0.0575364493,
0.0410796441,
-0.0694460273,
0.0385867767,
0.0262526982,
-0.0640615001,
-0.0049272091,
-0.0538205728,
0.0138663473,
0.0796480179,
0.0573378988,
0.0240014587,
-0.0421618149,
-0.0068981284,
0.0017544801,
0.0639542341,
0.0375444144,
-0.013784199,
0.0181837641,
-0.0783279687,
-0.0338055566,
-0.0045510409,
-0.0007951488,
0.0156291891,
0.0229308326,
-0.0146345431,
0.008124846,
-0.0400204584,
-0.0452443659,
0.0505103581,
-0.0431155115,
-0.0280411225,
0.0295212436,
-0.0263677966,
0.0350927487,
0.0185149629,
-0.0289443042,
-0.0080576846,
0.0563397296,
-0.0475015938,
0.0216047037,
-0.0121716969,
-0.0496237837,
-0.0641860738,
0.0145559656,
-0.0169434156,
-0.0281507112,
0.0459478199,
-0.0575650297,
-0.0489680953,
-0.0127195297,
-0.0138952704,
0.0092018563,
-0.0459387861,
0.0272505656,
-0.0056302035,
0.0286925454,
-0.017044954,
0.0472220741,
-0.0088076508,
-0.0019099965,
0.0303535797,
0.0434899218,
-0.0107832355,
-0.0459825993,
-0.0056470041,
0.0263514835,
-0.0080714226,
0.0205343645,
-0.016093662,
0.0497987345,
-0.0210270006,
-0.0281724203,
-0.052296441,
0.0107111698,
-0.0519630946,
0.0193834826,
0.0389991961,
0.0094848685,
-0.0203998256,
-0.0034884801,
-0.0316844136,
-0.0225468632,
0.0153675573,
-0.0076597477,
-0.013353779,
0.0002984894,
-0.04582287,
-0.0204024445,
-0.0220431499,
0.032222189,
0.0350174978,
-0.0138614718,
-0.0283184089,
-0.0725050792,
0.051665213,
0.0084776748,
0.0325263105,
-0.0049729287,
-0.050315246,
0.0204057731,
-0.0161673259,
0.0541704111,
0.0381711572,
-0.0048199184,
0.0107357595,
0.0555626824,
-0.0085311811,
-0.0417204164,
0.0012864126,
-0.019141864,
-0.055242721,
-0.0390518084,
-0.0601266064,
-0.011916534,
0.0611198246,
0.0063233743,
0.0104934769,
-0.0654901639,
-0.0095826425,
0.0168586969,
-0.052844964,
-0.0076659601,
-0.0086870873,
-0.0252589229,
0.0236110333,
-0.0486303084,
-0.0600607507,
0.0313616097,
-0.0365403555,
-0.0382925607,
-0.0328219272,
-0.0106473649,
0.0015340607,
0.0543411858,
0.0122440699,
0.0130458809,
0.0164625365,
-0.0163183268,
-0.0302750431,
0.0364334546,
0.0018580059,
-0.0458329357,
0.0255013146,
-0.0630054623,
0.0064448752,
-0.0200936664,
-0.022645507,
-0.0701707676,
0.0146704521,
0.018014662,
0.0008235634,
0.021405438,
-0.0227337051,
-0.0117220841,
0.0032916993,
-0.0069307284,
0.0805555955,
-0.0096474364,
0.0189905185,
-0.0199763626,
0.0053962511,
0.0272074491,
0.007838143,
-0.0135217188,
-0.0219058562,
0.0248224996,
0.0148392962,
0.0594333149,
0.0085736681,
-0.0369338468,
0.0300001651,
0.0557701178,
0.0359877981,
-0.0030730772,
0.0340546295,
0.045594953,
-0.0515075698,
-0.0344470702,
0.095504187,
0.0228545796,
-0.0412019193,
0.0040680184,
0.0040555187,
0.0501610227,
0.028249234,
0.0096989973,
-0.0858210474,
-0.0346089602,
0.0214441624,
0.0267336685,
-0.0066417605,
0.0119060427,
-0.0092792995,
-0.1432091445,
0.0750087872,
0.0239427369,
-0.0576908141,
-0.0498722047,
-0.0306515731,
-0.0295374729,
-0.0104748076,
0.0425019972,
0.0322184972,
0.000860679,
-0.0005114775,
0.0500101671,
-0.013858363,
-0.1276600957,
0.0293800496,
-0.0307225194,
0.091676645,
0.0826506093,
-0.0018305404,
0.0082684411,
-0.0155386468,
0.0259998813,
-0.0047821561,
-0.0018912127,
-0.0022503822,
0.0684193149,
0.0077871736,
-0.0205365047,
0.0198142473,
0.0270332806,
-0.0555059947,
0.0135615692,
-0.0197352171,
0.0678009987,
-0.0216863025,
0.0038336578,
0.0125169642,
-0.041177161,
0.0208234731,
0.0734120831,
0.039701011,
-0.0382236615,
-0.0095366156,
-0.0159641299,
-0.0084730322,
-0.1012381017,
-0.0236480292,
0.0701656789,
-0.0405418575,
-0.0614960492,
-0.0435770638,
-0.0390319638,
0.0577851683,
0.0417908467,
0.0149982059,
-0.0036434343,
-0.0195020735,
-0.0069111702,
-0.0759881586,
0.0314593464,
-0.0286481939,
0.0169999562,
-0.0679815859,
-0.0698416978,
0.0105729075,
-0.0164248962,
0.0072133648,
0.062208686,
-0.0740683526,
-0.0598557442,
0.0107906349,
0.0560482778,
0.0268237442,
0.0526221246,
-0.0000867598,
-0.0342477858,
0.0369597673,
0.0522198826,
-0.0404677913,
0.0173798781,
0.034842208,
-0.0762620047,
0.0010045138,
0.0253484212,
-0.0528870672,
0.0396454036,
0.0175652783,
0.0312991291,
0.0133199869,
-0.0258978475,
0.0408714749,
0.0145017374,
0.034984652,
-0.0443654768,
0.0064266971,
-0.0414409712,
0.0195488948,
-0.0263087619,
0.0067548975,
-0.0718169361,
0.0267733131,
0.0271226149,
-0.0020093301,
0.0155040426,
0.0290652048,
-0.0276811309,
0.0294043217,
-0.0465870164,
0.0054861265,
-0.034124393,
0.0554213189,
0.0545289777,
0.0143041378,
-0.0296381656,
0.0008476317,
0.013007991,
0.0148544423,
-0.0044565084,
0.0024201015,
0.0177494958,
0.0381403714,
-0.0302683078,
0.0428264141,
-0.0222172327,
-0.0503093861,
-0.0968475714,
-0.0217681918,
0.0765230879,
0.0124991583,
0.0615526475,
-0.0171591118,
-0.0011748936,
-0.0279944148,
0.0418739058,
-0.0039881193,
-0.0399354398,
0.0060912617,
-0.0094498834,
-0.0314064547,
-0.0487838537,
0.0865455344,
0.0240554474,
0.0593432821,
-0.0180617291,
0.0265567861,
-0.0335231461,
-0.0261719394,
0.0139764706,
-0.0390831642,
-0.0173618793,
-0.0342293791,
-0.0154847726,
-0.0813452676,
-0.0048846989,
0.0273622125,
0.0120430626,
0.012071901,
0.0495501384,
0.0354906544,
-0.0274293888,
-0.0026053174,
-0.0208970904,
-0.0044104583,
0.0125889303,
-0.0361490734,
-0.0105529306,
-6.51678052e-33,
-0.019503599,
0.0082771638,
0.0216394905,
-0.0286926068,
-0.0240728278,
-0.006740185,
-0.0514490753,
-0.0141147804,
0.0028109194,
-0.0048950356,
-0.0170326624,
-0.0055579273,
0.0306224227,
0.0342297778,
0.0165061895,
0.0119157499,
0.0906654447,
-0.036343094,
-0.0127407694,
0.0394079126,
0.0242069513,
0.0167886317,
0.0690139905,
-0.0368847139,
-0.0103380997,
-0.0137006147,
-0.0050920076,
0.0011044733,
0.0004773467,
0.057128489,
-0.0119110094,
0.0709589198,
0.0035337419,
-0.0566092618,
-0.0570489913,
-0.0066847727,
-0.0629644692,
-0.0136249,
-0.0027469783,
0.023527611,
-0.0324355811,
-0.0275704786,
0.0114584882,
0.0095263124,
-0.0502676778,
0.0127572017,
0.0255897231,
-0.0510198697,
-0.0181155931,
-0.0240150839,
-0.0439731292,
0.007400116,
0.0257864427,
-0.0319531411,
0.0348704755,
0.0480161496,
0.0008749409,
-0.0027071007,
-0.0529948808,
0.0289820526,
0.0254900232,
0.0428344123,
0.0879925117,
0.0558187328,
0.0345973298,
0.0485052541,
0.0345309451,
0.0150644956,
-0.0009716797,
0.0178225078,
0.0294745862,
0.0524491891,
0.0219825022,
0.0567287169,
0.0460621156,
-0.0203006975,
-0.0359745733,
0.044558648,
-0.0008731492,
-0.0288812257,
0.0394610986,
0.0151629103,
-0.0176736359,
-0.0196119733,
-0.03930071,
0.0119590051,
-0.0293024871,
-0.0104224496,
0.0483661518,
0.0210671555,
-0.0057954127,
-0.0096039567,
0.0557727404,
-0.0126029644,
0.0302125104,
0.0071172318,
-0.0447698869,
0.0185271222,
-0.0044128122,
0.0017031534,
-0.0185538586,
-0.0504538864,
0.0640735179,
0.0142253181,
0.0233127996,
0.0162169822,
0.0207630228,
0.0503286868,
-0.045296561,
0.0185604431,
-0.0604536012,
0.0462196469,
0.0208697226,
0.0147911273,
0.0183920469,
-0.0109576639,
-0.0140037611,
0.0426376574,
-0.0053409156,
-0.0045577064,
-0.0369442068,
-0.0174254458,
0.0127625428,
0.0274981223,
-0.0232044421,
0.0236430839,
-0.0743319467,
-0.0058917194,
0.0446354747,
-0.0429366305,
-0.0321678855,
0.0181368478,
2.828e-7,
0.0106426114,
0.029213462,
0.035262838,
0.0382046141,
0.010082338,
0.0266629402,
-0.020719327,
0.0209354218,
0.0131574776,
-0.0452861972,
0.0112709915,
0.0202372372,
0.0697046444,
0.0312049314,
-0.0647912472,
0.0145751499,
-0.0413492136,
0.0317793787,
-0.054489214,
-0.0041462262,
0.009775714,
0.1043962091,
-0.0005475671,
-0.0371272415,
0.0304307472,
0.016884651,
0.0248866454,
-0.0471949875,
-0.0230008364,
0.028292682,
0.0034706122,
0.0272539984,
-0.0170586649,
0.0299220495,
-0.0365512371,
-0.0314962119,
-0.0172026828,
0.0397206582,
-0.0241010841,
-0.0265518725,
0.0279321503,
-0.0082946261,
-0.02686847,
-0.0426273942,
0.0304213725,
-0.0312018823,
-0.011520627,
-0.0103279669,
-0.0145847257,
0.0268935263,
-0.0217558034,
-0.0625614151,
0.0032861358,
0.0312454794,
0.0512636751,
0.0082026627,
-0.0239253324,
-0.0566612445,
-0.0377821811,
0.0192038249,
-0.0539566204,
-0.0499800257,
-0.0325886384,
0.0110014798,
0.0302533023,
-0.0462485626,
0.017938802,
3.094157352e-34,
0.0173294879,
0.014919701,
0.0192466415,
0.0178165976,
0.0111682396,
-0.0300635081,
-0.0248487592,
0.0296850912,
-0.0381455198,
-0.0503377207,
-0.052637618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17857v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17857v1 | From Values to Opinions: Predicting Human Behaviors and Stances Using Value-Injected Large Language Models | 2023-10-27T02:18:10 | 2023-10-27T02:18:10 | Dongjun Kang, Joonsuk Park, Yohan Jo, JinYeong Bak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Being able to predict people's opinions on issues and behaviors in realistic
scenarios can be helpful in various domains, such as politics and marketing.
However, conducting large-scale surveys like the European Social Survey to
solicit people's opinions on individual issues can incur prohibitive costs.
Leveraging prior research showing influence of core human values on individual
decisions and actions, we propose to use value-injected large language models
(LLM) to predict opinions and behaviors. To this end, we present Value
Injection Method (VIM), a collection of two methods -- argument generation and
question answering -- designed to inject targeted value distributions into LLMs
via fine-tuning. We then conduct a series of experiments on four tasks to test
the effectiveness of VIM and the possibility of using value-injected LLMs to
predict opinions and behaviors of people. We find that LLMs value-injected with
variations of VIM substantially outperform the baselines. Also, the results
suggest that opinions and behaviors can be better predicted using
value-injected LLMs than the baseline approaches. | [
0.0554221906,
0.0869569406,
0.0077643315,
0.0085091209,
-0.0202043131,
-0.0125811473,
-0.0234010257,
-0.0306701213,
-0.0025976924,
-0.0320146009,
0.014319906,
-0.0178247746,
-0.0422807001,
0.0101460274,
0.0182200745,
-0.0490988456,
0.0443684161,
0.0155029502,
0.0573715344,
-0.0400978103,
0.0355665348,
0.0018624328,
0.027598083,
0.0266381409,
0.0002600363,
0.0205889568,
-0.0315524042,
-0.0111361509,
0.0901141763,
-0.013846443,
0.0217433777,
0.028730467,
0.0079053529,
-0.0241735801,
0.0000020126,
-0.0485729426,
-0.0049751792,
-0.0198295973,
0.0192825496,
0.0262329802,
0.0748197809,
0.0494789705,
0.0031106444,
0.0541659892,
-0.0504330918,
0.0195438471,
0.0305627808,
0.0418529026,
0.0898916945,
0.0575877614,
-0.0088954857,
-0.0323826745,
0.0146096321,
-0.0233523529,
0.0142863868,
0.0011569201,
0.036931362,
0.0288977269,
-0.0454689823,
0.0572886318,
0.0328234658,
-0.0032622346,
0.000878251,
0.0058974065,
0.0224459432,
0.0230851341,
-0.0284979232,
-0.0333233476,
-0.0240673982,
0.0503884479,
0.00266817,
-0.0261208639,
0.0183958616,
-0.0097349091,
0.012178394,
0.0208718348,
-0.035460338,
0.0405185446,
0.0139026577,
0.0259979274,
0.0672666281,
0.0467276946,
-0.003060065,
0.0449529886,
0.0001857254,
0.0368144289,
-0.0042697266,
-0.0236175023,
0.0104813399,
-0.0142542198,
-0.0598780997,
-0.0543888919,
-0.0110519603,
0.0183330029,
0.015236672,
0.0295861643,
-0.0084068254,
0.0210893694,
0.0525895394,
-0.1092197746,
0.0302532557,
0.0421664305,
0.0163162574,
0.0400629342,
-0.0062117265,
-0.000247367,
-0.003826021,
-0.0012508632,
-0.0329739228,
0.0027474791,
-0.046294421,
-0.0119925383,
-0.007676925,
0.0289805196,
-0.0251590628,
-0.0133952638,
-0.0361649469,
-0.0127751976,
-0.0220386684,
-0.0210440643,
-0.0282037221,
0.0325285159,
0.0140042705,
-0.0055701206,
-0.0876585245,
0.0490845926,
-0.05963061,
0.0208764747,
-0.0068640658,
-0.003921343,
0.0326676704,
0.0202360861,
0.0189547613,
-0.0023782023,
0.0514030531,
0.0337047353,
0.0044278875,
0.025583446,
-0.0190401785,
-0.0387701839,
-0.0159583241,
-0.0581276342,
0.0204946566,
-0.0817494243,
0.0097643295,
-0.0029247608,
-0.0058871098,
-0.0255737305,
0.0465506464,
0.0580218956,
-0.0343188532,
0.036944665,
0.0488971248,
-0.0064128051,
0.0217497814,
0.006813745,
0.0433183387,
0.0262381118,
0.0020853612,
0.0596676469,
0.0069515039,
-0.0144488951,
0.0085508609,
0.0121487472,
0.0137184672,
0.0085261222,
-0.0300933346,
0.0383130759,
-0.0203425754,
0.0041187187,
-0.0072751306,
0.0944572017,
-0.0174504183,
-0.0123583712,
0.0861710161,
0.0369069427,
-0.0527919233,
-0.0000840267,
0.0180825926,
0.0134931467,
0.0192801915,
-0.0672576949,
-0.0257764291,
0.0179957505,
-0.0009633931,
-0.0039680554,
0.0105450777,
0.028414553,
-0.020616455,
-0.0613431931,
-0.0181535147,
-0.0113428095,
0.0685105175,
0.0225941353,
-0.0075268522,
-0.0167471245,
-0.0387136042,
-0.0399425402,
0.0356838033,
-0.0425524041,
-0.0202995837,
-0.0316219665,
0.0639078543,
0.0523286201,
0.0130836936,
0.0261161495,
-0.0005478886,
-0.0395954959,
0.0347674489,
0.0263566971,
0.0899096802,
-0.0276817679,
-0.042041596,
-0.0222104415,
0.0006855379,
-0.003317147,
-0.0083075622,
0.0285502058,
0.0492129996,
0.0090228822,
0.0238112137,
-0.0175256897,
-0.0129499771,
-0.0005726845,
0.0162243545,
-0.0213673655,
0.0233586095,
0.0019207692,
0.0360654294,
0.0235567465,
0.0072983657,
0.0312674716,
0.0217099655,
-0.0293446649,
-0.068995446,
-0.0075299335,
-0.030318737,
0.0035373608,
0.0165123399,
-0.0371612757,
-0.0035143686,
0.0221519209,
-0.0196553376,
0.0256989095,
-0.0178464297,
-0.0267421585,
-0.0097098686,
-0.0431233197,
-0.0167920832,
-0.0258433186,
0.0082644755,
-0.0613440461,
0.0673420206,
0.0124650681,
-0.0280489326,
-0.0520552583,
0.0000895699,
0.0040365933,
-0.0276742578,
-0.0383534767,
-0.0253997538,
0.0220121965,
0.0572366305,
0.0584127642,
0.0041842121,
-0.0299071502,
-0.0280677304,
-0.1093475297,
0.0024642101,
0.0216533467,
0.031076692,
-0.0043948642,
-0.0175644774,
0.0194133818,
0.0264633689,
-0.0840527117,
-0.0075102742,
0.007614566,
0.0296593737,
0.0567533709,
0.0031328802,
0.000991703,
-0.0233660154,
0.007305454,
-0.0316203386,
0.0144679192,
0.0119585078,
0.0532578416,
-0.0131296758,
0.0020089711,
-0.0637386292,
-0.0005238761,
0.0099981315,
-0.0682301298,
-0.0092097456,
0.0042120935,
0.0621564761,
0.0743721947,
0.0635723397,
0.0171033647,
0.0170620251,
0.0559783503,
-0.0636831596,
-0.0313009843,
-0.0789797828,
0.020561818,
-0.0087681515,
-0.0044325502,
0.02358393,
0.0724915117,
0.010970843,
0.0243753511,
-0.0528660044,
0.1048411056,
-0.0093039684,
-0.019595962,
0.0098197702,
-0.001742386,
-0.0234925207,
0.0468167625,
0.0056718886,
-0.0333312973,
0.0600223988,
0.0081231613,
0.0264701173,
-0.0410140567,
-0.0205145311,
-0.0391670577,
-0.0093455687,
0.0022093123,
0.0197278336,
0.0032816611,
0.0378291532,
-0.0449788235,
-0.0449291095,
0.0162784159,
-0.0645626709,
0.0321529731,
-0.0096666059,
-0.0363871083,
0.0085155498,
-0.0470205918,
-0.0411771014,
-0.0767567083,
-0.0677607134,
-0.0044125989,
0.0539538041,
-0.0109845353,
0.0074632177,
-0.0214837063,
0.0254358146,
-0.0501493663,
-0.0333689228,
-0.0147328889,
0.0076760519,
0.0111755682,
0.0689062774,
-0.0011950521,
0.0310750231,
-0.0128247607,
0.0289814807,
0.0585517623,
-0.01250422,
0.0255593825,
-0.0535405949,
-0.020571921,
-0.0123320259,
0.0003928472,
-0.0079019144,
0.0154846208,
0.0309342574,
-0.0270664319,
0.0301757343,
0.108053863,
0.0374277718,
-0.0040050023,
-0.0075553223,
-0.0415913016,
0.0345216356,
0.0358468406,
0.0354732424,
-0.086713843,
-0.0333626419,
-0.0237021316,
0.0160710569,
-0.0581287183,
-0.0213109851,
0.0061820787,
-0.1362569183,
0.0277521573,
0.003924272,
0.053477481,
0.0159471314,
-0.0456425138,
0.0123911696,
-0.0255493633,
-0.0133091575,
-0.0116675915,
0.0167353265,
0.0005407894,
0.0126086902,
-0.0441386588,
-0.009207299,
0.0648477748,
-0.0231748167,
0.0423197486,
0.074075684,
0.067444019,
-0.0034443475,
-0.0400331505,
0.0226574633,
0.0063252454,
-0.0147346491,
0.0021844076,
0.0428323373,
-0.0314433761,
-0.0026283492,
-0.0554294549,
0.0582895763,
-0.0005070861,
-0.0279754307,
0.0159750395,
0.0540748425,
-0.0133485738,
-0.0490553007,
-0.023424983,
0.0307696052,
0.017815372,
0.0833465979,
0.0019141638,
-0.0821670592,
-0.0195521228,
-0.0283739269,
-0.0221732575,
-0.0438879691,
-0.0881396085,
-0.0256639309,
0.0068314811,
-0.0077447891,
-0.0601476841,
-0.0447018296,
0.0162029024,
0.0078957826,
-0.001323276,
-0.0373132825,
0.0333063453,
0.0192063935,
-0.0244375709,
0.0051656254,
-0.0259940941,
0.0308803059,
-0.0352459811,
0.006125059,
0.0306391735,
-0.026320966,
-0.0368669555,
-0.0193140097,
-0.0495237485,
-0.0626060143,
-0.0029710887,
0.0638723448,
0.0146066882,
0.0327354036,
0.022374643,
-0.0139686326,
0.0490460843,
0.039440874,
0.0112629393,
0.0084786722,
0.0265597254,
0.0649358928,
0.0244274624,
0.0006205836,
0.0159601364,
0.0428177081,
0.0239099283,
-0.0089133065,
-0.0635471344,
-0.0269990023,
0.0109204473,
0.017198056,
0.0312245972,
0.0115368972,
-0.0262565874,
0.0067506288,
-0.0284353774,
-0.0430312268,
-0.0544377044,
-0.0235352293,
-0.0133526959,
0.0143458927,
0.0114701483,
-0.0068392144,
-0.0208212528,
-0.0171231721,
0.0378624648,
0.0149221858,
0.0380136482,
0.0109219681,
0.0537730977,
0.0339208357,
-0.0029760022,
-0.0283049643,
0.0010110794,
-0.0138498629,
0.0490952097,
-0.0143624088,
0.029877536,
0.0126468288,
-0.0101270461,
0.0147205126,
-0.0073206378,
-0.051170852,
-0.0956982151,
-0.0177460145,
-0.0151011487,
-0.0526621081,
0.0063555175,
0.020042425,
-0.0328126214,
-0.0275442805,
-0.0074496469,
0.0260353535,
-0.0294269305,
-0.0280496646,
0.0574472882,
0.0125107886,
-0.0469783656,
-0.0451190695,
0.0200892352,
0.0101671098,
-0.0011460107,
0.0185739771,
-0.0426843911,
-0.0472216345,
0.0036991611,
0.0075172,
-0.011573893,
0.0023882496,
-0.003995066,
-0.0671610236,
-0.0341240838,
-0.005375138,
0.0261776466,
0.0056983843,
-0.020647604,
0.0148659078,
0.0382931493,
-0.0138493963,
0.0399026684,
-0.0656734928,
0.0246609934,
-0.0751799196,
-0.0106089534,
-0.0349414423,
-6.513183507e-33,
-0.0008186116,
-0.0165544599,
-0.0012390111,
0.0026650236,
0.0030649048,
-0.0076403548,
-0.0277797692,
0.0425337739,
-0.0084560271,
0.0561492071,
0.0167932697,
-0.031188596,
-0.0000603227,
0.0168387312,
0.0154111953,
-0.0286084656,
0.0349963084,
-0.0166865624,
-0.0327943824,
0.0082518151,
0.0113806324,
-0.0225459356,
-0.0012188371,
-0.058142744,
0.0012272847,
0.0266962908,
-0.0170448758,
0.0073119085,
0.0044898079,
0.0546547808,
0.0085063381,
0.0549815185,
0.0132509917,
-0.0650014058,
0.0064980653,
0.1103325039,
-0.0394426137,
-0.0230946559,
0.0084675308,
-0.0481924675,
-0.0218493175,
-0.0342051275,
-0.0048507946,
-0.0105132861,
-0.002570563,
-0.0132458694,
0.0359981321,
-0.0211116932,
0.0312439464,
-0.0582819134,
-0.0504238568,
0.0021111218,
-0.0283220224,
-0.0087385001,
-0.0414980724,
0.0377431139,
-0.0151421065,
0.0606795587,
-0.0338879153,
0.040647395,
-0.0336029492,
-0.0125853773,
0.005601774,
-0.001500068,
0.0027214363,
0.0753657147,
-0.0113448584,
0.0071841702,
-0.0620691068,
0.048747018,
-0.0008460813,
0.0257927757,
0.0413418673,
0.0731818229,
0.014139194,
-0.022884259,
-0.0268358532,
0.0073926039,
0.0501331575,
0.0045872438,
0.0383162089,
0.0042951126,
-0.0435208604,
-0.0258533396,
-0.0516937003,
-0.0354279876,
-0.0347585008,
-0.0345118046,
0.0017496841,
0.0041039842,
-0.0603586324,
0.0180897359,
0.0398416705,
-0.0337873027,
-0.0005695031,
0.0494158044,
-0.0630788505,
0.0160496403,
-0.0219151471,
0.0104965148,
-0.0787101537,
0.0257226471,
0.006918591,
-0.017961273,
0.0124506084,
0.0169932302,
0.0045081484,
-0.0140679628,
-0.075676769,
-0.0379938446,
-0.0099099521,
0.0225595981,
-0.0077146832,
0.0374330021,
0.0123725468,
0.0279798005,
0.0210098196,
0.0220217742,
-0.0089202551,
0.0168331452,
-0.0338093005,
-0.0480350368,
0.0148506342,
0.0276906006,
-0.0282965228,
0.0058494085,
-0.0444841757,
-0.0043639778,
-0.0093950527,
-0.0582609139,
-0.0060756034,
0.0146560222,
2.682e-7,
0.036446888,
0.0630858764,
-0.0271565299,
0.0309780464,
-0.0194413774,
0.0918326825,
0.0547784939,
0.0055142716,
0.0496047623,
-0.0573454387,
-0.0012282757,
0.0380467884,
0.0372451991,
0.0073942598,
-0.1041320935,
-0.0466535166,
-0.0380555019,
-0.0171550494,
-0.0369133241,
0.0111084897,
0.0653198883,
0.0748423561,
0.0517208613,
-0.0086542256,
-0.0100174667,
0.0475219712,
0.0685314685,
-0.0197524987,
-0.0543599278,
0.019451078,
-0.0365490727,
-0.0231763069,
-0.0007855106,
0.0185279138,
-0.0162255559,
-0.0090406956,
-0.017264219,
0.0769199356,
0.0110011371,
-0.0451443866,
-0.0062319636,
0.0006599826,
-0.0023843416,
-0.0561799444,
0.0795620158,
-0.1148812547,
-0.048686374,
-0.0690173581,
-0.0434392355,
0.0058122575,
0.0020120128,
-0.0163365211,
-0.0243181791,
-0.0267247297,
0.0078976089,
-0.0077355439,
0.0207987856,
-0.0275973901,
-0.0201095473,
-0.0008366833,
-0.0384481959,
-0.0897857472,
-0.0029638268,
0.0443882346,
-0.0082306899,
-0.0326881222,
-0.0024624947,
2.444363361e-34,
0.0467996411,
0.0018049688,
0.0155941797,
-0.0113191782,
0.0767026097,
0.044129245,
0.0049399575,
-0.0034042201,
0.0588779375,
-0.0534357689,
-0.0198919345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18376v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18376v4 | SQLformer: Deep Auto-Regressive Query Graph Generation for Text-to-SQL Translation | 2023-10-27T00:13:59 | 2024-05-27T17:55:18 | Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, the task of text-to-SQL translation, which converts natural
language questions into executable SQL queries, has gained significant
attention for its potential to democratize data access. Despite its promise,
challenges such as adapting to unseen databases and aligning natural language
with SQL syntax have hindered widespread adoption. To overcome these issues, we
introduce SQLformer, a novel Transformer architecture specifically crafted to
perform text-to-SQL translation tasks. Our model predicts SQL queries as
abstract syntax trees (ASTs) in an autoregressive way, incorporating structural
inductive bias in the encoder and decoder layers. This bias, guided by database
table and column selection, aids the decoder in generating SQL query ASTs
represented as graphs in a Breadth-First Search canonical order. Our
experiments demonstrate that SQLformer achieves state-of-the-art performance
across six prominent text-to-SQL benchmarks. | [
-0.0079283789,
0.0926093683,
-0.0049868198,
0.0157862585,
-0.001286966,
0.0170109216,
-0.0353716947,
0.0133691933,
0.0028322893,
-0.024456935,
0.0317729078,
-0.0037514274,
-0.0316155814,
0.0651227906,
0.0289114546,
-0.0241428353,
-0.0066088964,
0.0005932879,
-0.0245252866,
0.0204876401,
-0.0168066267,
0.0166919269,
0.0318823904,
-0.0117135923,
-0.0264313612,
0.009268499,
-0.0428346097,
0.0634033233,
-0.0578724891,
-0.0285732541,
-0.0134384353,
0.0199581925,
0.0179934017,
0.0125930579,
0.0000021258,
-0.0209637545,
-0.0666724369,
0.0070503936,
-0.0484557524,
-0.0039122151,
0.0214697216,
-0.0527457558,
0.0396496505,
0.0655226707,
-0.0572788678,
-0.0375191793,
0.0379145518,
-0.004695422,
0.0589066483,
0.0746066868,
-0.0213931855,
-0.0768963844,
0.008568895,
-0.0028772671,
0.0426298156,
-0.054581672,
-0.0398906842,
0.0136292875,
-0.0295733195,
-0.0063151098,
-0.0379760936,
0.0152932862,
0.0294711925,
-0.0451549068,
0.016703194,
-0.0324819311,
-0.0381982028,
-0.0117825279,
-0.0049251053,
0.0406062305,
-0.0074007548,
-0.0315916911,
-0.0101503199,
-0.0009538481,
0.0094456328,
-0.0092343288,
-0.010746113,
-0.0011153209,
0.0214441139,
0.01072009,
-0.008225115,
-0.0064140433,
0.0156718586,
-0.0497736856,
-0.0778219178,
0.0288899262,
-0.0000820257,
0.0005273718,
0.0440946184,
-0.0060282703,
0.037019778,
-0.0071585034,
0.0444353595,
0.0162192397,
-0.0668661818,
0.0129100243,
-0.033218313,
-0.0107054161,
-0.021866275,
-0.0397077687,
0.0212026611,
0.0493455827,
0.0266425051,
0.0132149244,
-0.0251950696,
0.0419324934,
-0.0105238706,
0.0362284966,
-0.0546613783,
-0.0358428694,
-0.0519793667,
0.016930325,
-0.0800151378,
0.0057425313,
-0.0933113545,
-0.0215892177,
0.0060566529,
0.030560229,
0.0294374637,
0.0113491854,
0.0336395539,
0.0578367412,
-0.0174483433,
-0.0213584527,
-0.0309248399,
0.0187442955,
0.0067700269,
-0.0176050216,
0.0091785407,
-0.0768117979,
-0.04167483,
0.0147947744,
0.0273217782,
-0.0238711536,
-0.0011172934,
0.0352038555,
-0.0327621847,
0.0119441366,
-0.0701372772,
-0.0486562215,
0.0347637162,
0.0411042459,
0.0287864599,
-0.0231050774,
0.0683262572,
-0.0034386343,
-0.000608691,
-0.0526486933,
-0.0101297004,
0.0040306533,
0.0193049628,
0.057703279,
-0.0137857432,
0.0003780677,
0.0174231268,
-0.0437993929,
0.0424123108,
0.0554511733,
0.0520762838,
0.0553672276,
0.0038333442,
-0.025922101,
-0.0036283317,
0.0308270119,
0.0253280122,
0.0148153957,
-0.0750409961,
0.0505413637,
-0.0258049536,
0.0407605506,
-0.0035905528,
0.0609076135,
0.0052617602,
-0.0294928197,
-0.0086576948,
-0.0056079919,
0.0363615751,
0.0494599454,
0.0338952318,
0.0333752073,
-0.0411975011,
-0.0400979668,
-0.0360435322,
0.0316816643,
0.0197574459,
-0.0008871809,
-0.0009405568,
0.0066588926,
-0.0301018711,
-0.0335350856,
0.0115330722,
-0.0116302138,
0.0303940829,
0.0055755731,
-0.0074338517,
0.0756749883,
-0.0640310422,
0.0612753853,
-0.0523002595,
-0.0364387296,
-0.0003054689,
-0.0121243158,
-0.0968913212,
0.054706566,
0.0175199583,
-0.0139712309,
0.0011473331,
-0.0193135794,
-0.004166618,
0.0074953549,
0.0269344524,
-0.0278546009,
0.0097712856,
-0.0326462612,
-0.0390608795,
0.0361584947,
0.0182338227,
0.0128337834,
-0.0031392556,
0.0067228917,
0.0458857343,
-0.0727898851,
-0.0563305616,
0.0216242373,
-0.0024560865,
-0.0440346897,
0.0667964816,
0.0069093527,
0.0035688609,
0.0423695408,
-0.0237756316,
0.0406665355,
0.0275367927,
0.0028486846,
-0.0668808073,
-0.0208788756,
-0.0217045434,
-0.0346478038,
-0.0175381359,
-0.0468147062,
-0.0017364142,
-0.0265540276,
-0.0733554214,
-0.0562513284,
0.0170066357,
-0.0648038089,
0.0336657353,
-0.0117236665,
0.0365629643,
-0.0006731789,
-0.0265076626,
-0.0179876946,
0.0261582322,
-0.0014412401,
-0.0330953151,
-0.0237482898,
-0.0542617925,
0.0390035696,
-0.0370517038,
0.0575352795,
-0.0132308519,
-0.0068124286,
0.0233592764,
0.0090123154,
0.0144887203,
-0.0436286367,
-0.0015858044,
-0.0398111455,
0.0140620843,
-0.023642011,
0.0279464349,
0.0395105146,
0.0787956864,
0.016018942,
-0.0214021951,
-0.0634874851,
-0.0035884092,
-0.0101238154,
0.0046610157,
0.0169181731,
-0.0288025364,
-0.0045247981,
-0.0236120652,
-0.0399086326,
-0.0492110625,
0.0423588753,
-0.0241039358,
-0.0477282852,
0.040801771,
0.0043970244,
0.0298741162,
0.0344454758,
0.0112121059,
-0.0077772019,
-0.009949482,
-0.0451647602,
-0.0335732475,
0.0598553531,
0.0089188255,
-0.0104901586,
-0.0199068859,
-0.000794579,
-0.0525301471,
0.0050330651,
-0.0278284475,
0.0160121378,
0.0005165972,
-0.0599512495,
0.0472007915,
0.0074177198,
0.0097558703,
0.0102848122,
-0.0471791551,
-0.0231839381,
0.0479974747,
0.0130496677,
-0.031257771,
0.0087215425,
0.0132196266,
0.0168735534,
-0.0046283165,
0.0007841712,
0.0521999188,
-0.019390326,
-0.0093296701,
-0.019247707,
0.01090643,
-0.0575424582,
0.0488041639,
0.0515804738,
0.0083974078,
-0.0139907496,
-0.083159402,
-0.0228205044,
0.0084754257,
0.0223106071,
-0.0433698818,
0.0565249361,
-0.0059811962,
-0.0077458178,
0.0036793675,
-0.0074827061,
-0.0154560823,
0.0074037607,
-0.016213106,
0.0192685127,
0.0761465356,
-0.0195724107,
0.0089687034,
-0.0120865898,
-0.022614399,
0.0444287211,
0.0046376972,
-0.0322652385,
-0.0011570001,
-0.026268797,
0.0294380747,
0.0248454902,
-0.000364134,
0.0091642439,
0.0281605683,
0.0358081758,
0.0156025821,
-0.0487927347,
-0.0263211392,
0.019535359,
-0.001398902,
0.0117761921,
-0.0040670317,
0.029317718,
-0.0303779151,
-0.0381640643,
-0.0095276283,
0.0645837784,
0.0179674234,
0.0034802645,
0.0025980354,
0.0156411827,
0.058591757,
0.0443871692,
0.0298022181,
-0.1634923667,
-0.0304597095,
-0.0306704137,
0.0500325412,
0.0680777952,
-0.0314532034,
-0.0026349216,
-0.1106718183,
0.0112664141,
-0.0080168564,
-0.0179443602,
0.0071194968,
-0.0291943848,
-0.0751445889,
-0.0439403951,
-0.0120327277,
0.0620991103,
-0.0103565855,
0.0049792212,
-0.0076142997,
-0.0291282311,
-0.015241446,
-0.0207744204,
-0.0314889587,
-0.0330503136,
0.0486480221,
0.0197989885,
0.0122647351,
-0.000591886,
0.0047288132,
-0.0084825875,
0.0052436511,
-0.0315023474,
0.0799558461,
0.0189136341,
0.0139546171,
0.0328720734,
0.0035268429,
-0.0786446109,
0.0657773763,
0.0123254387,
0.1083092242,
-0.0374903381,
-0.0057806666,
-0.0027502293,
-0.0673869103,
-0.0000577406,
0.0279741213,
0.0121401744,
0.03924549,
-0.0876743644,
-0.0437929332,
0.0239345189,
-0.094623886,
-0.031951528,
0.0590489432,
-0.0262896121,
-0.0479679704,
-0.0143534159,
-0.007857278,
0.030729901,
0.0310656168,
0.0023909004,
-0.0139516452,
0.0600675121,
-0.0493800566,
-0.0373550206,
-0.0269126594,
-0.018210208,
-0.0129749672,
-0.008586172,
-0.0114988703,
-0.0035484484,
-0.0069421409,
-0.0169511717,
-0.0286712274,
-0.0337750502,
-0.0369169973,
-0.008070359,
-0.0008122681,
0.0119627491,
0.0074254856,
0.0035558371,
-0.0271735117,
-0.0076595889,
0.0391542315,
-0.0534234755,
-0.079580009,
0.0191571675,
-0.0458659679,
-0.0029736052,
0.0347131118,
-0.0547208376,
-0.0129023278,
-0.0480239168,
-0.0077760909,
-0.0289489068,
-0.0067807171,
0.0769753605,
0.0599068888,
0.0251253806,
0.0545426346,
-0.0142040746,
0.0096985195,
0.05328089,
-0.0644097477,
-0.0240429696,
-0.0573055595,
0.0496168695,
0.056423638,
0.0202680863,
0.0427703746,
-0.0052402136,
0.0049963323,
0.0296899378,
-0.0198296607,
-0.0048669213,
0.0425811782,
-0.002043681,
0.0345657431,
-0.0173784029,
0.0016109392,
0.0330644771,
0.0676564127,
0.0733960196,
-0.016952917,
0.0096036317,
0.0266767088,
0.0473516211,
-0.0090216547,
-0.0099391248,
-0.0460786372,
-0.0508396514,
-0.0196210332,
-0.0591205806,
0.004957912,
0.0032946346,
0.0363691524,
0.0259310901,
0.0190297291,
0.0028059159,
0.0362961031,
0.0330935791,
-0.0209007431,
0.0258030239,
-0.0131275384,
-0.0210258793,
-0.0258864239,
0.0427545644,
0.0247192569,
0.0065428764,
-0.0029578828,
-0.0384644978,
-0.0350608192,
-0.0391927101,
0.0044873338,
-0.0419301912,
0.0022965977,
-0.0278956201,
0.0088227829,
-0.0104576228,
0.0123269502,
0.0128890928,
0.0080301836,
-0.0263681915,
0.0555810183,
0.0676513612,
0.0420984179,
-0.0551686473,
-0.0122328801,
0.0234563593,
-0.056234017,
-0.0493565835,
-0.0321746543,
-6.302703897e-33,
-0.0268621147,
-0.0250911377,
0.0308114961,
0.0046741278,
-0.0185105503,
-0.0203571618,
-0.0419988111,
0.0008692133,
-0.0451555476,
0.0174945612,
-0.0268286746,
0.0596175194,
0.0329276361,
0.0445571989,
0.0311573986,
-0.0254129395,
0.0453688763,
-0.0316952653,
0.0179597009,
0.0306028016,
0.0292430967,
0.0380240194,
0.017008163,
-0.0203436911,
-0.0143823195,
0.0241455417,
0.0126057426,
0.0234222654,
0.051025413,
0.0077287485,
0.0130986935,
0.0080453977,
0.0127313761,
-0.0157930087,
-0.0296016354,
-0.0330515094,
-0.0828254074,
-0.0378422849,
-0.0349973142,
0.0282501113,
-0.0067718551,
0.0010026455,
0.0755785778,
-0.0390095524,
-0.0246814005,
-0.0387416966,
-0.0007021424,
0.0093684969,
-0.0170198847,
-0.0839035362,
-0.0293232463,
0.0097079827,
0.0149981277,
0.0279641896,
0.0296613779,
0.0772441477,
0.0014191704,
-0.003327633,
-0.0474227257,
0.0315386429,
-0.002403928,
0.0483036041,
0.0152492728,
0.0335290059,
0.0146776922,
-0.0208485983,
0.0077275019,
-0.0036290132,
-0.0246167183,
0.098983191,
-0.0084008873,
0.0743597001,
0.0363677256,
0.0068705068,
0.0221760776,
-0.0362452976,
-0.0700838864,
0.0312597193,
-0.0461902022,
0.0181856174,
-0.0368748344,
0.048178941,
-0.0345611237,
-0.0617077053,
-0.0274921954,
0.0252587404,
-0.020552434,
0.0029041888,
0.0371129327,
0.0035780771,
0.0069134282,
-0.0189595874,
0.0283605196,
-0.0322661586,
-0.0215740819,
0.0606176257,
-0.0277108178,
-0.0293080192,
0.0014573325,
0.0606744178,
-0.0103886044,
-0.0335370488,
0.0119710723,
-0.0016403794,
0.0215802491,
0.0333798602,
0.0050800405,
0.0267645065,
-0.0654730052,
0.0010009962,
-0.0236995257,
0.0081263715,
-0.019037256,
0.0207678303,
0.0080215,
0.0222533979,
0.012674381,
0.0535594374,
-0.0001080533,
0.0138782989,
-0.0154024651,
0.0092469519,
0.0326484106,
0.044895824,
-0.0219558533,
0.0116228117,
-0.0235207453,
-0.0307584498,
0.0403599031,
-0.0546680279,
-0.0410024859,
0.0340130515,
2.819e-7,
0.0839152783,
0.0328845643,
0.0733818039,
0.0750313923,
-0.0028300816,
0.0304635447,
0.0436035246,
0.0378898568,
0.0199962258,
-0.0388962179,
0.0273515042,
-0.0202466287,
0.0364203267,
0.0497118346,
-0.0637340844,
0.0244237706,
-0.0414926335,
-0.0192025062,
-0.019097263,
0.0048854216,
0.0713101327,
0.0749715641,
-0.0625145733,
0.0302215256,
0.0128297126,
-0.053887859,
0.0055969162,
0.0151425861,
-0.0019581767,
0.0343215875,
0.003027393,
-0.0109860469,
-0.0309237074,
0.0211047549,
-0.0335063227,
0.0194604192,
-0.0206112508,
0.0424261205,
-0.0172973257,
-0.0110551221,
0.0285310335,
-0.0848294422,
0.0162077844,
-0.023693569,
0.0616456605,
-0.0463563018,
0.0138509991,
0.0694442764,
-0.0363905765,
0.0166784711,
0.0200735014,
0.0085072322,
0.0256517902,
-0.0359411091,
0.0808439627,
0.0196838062,
-0.0026335614,
-0.0189082287,
-0.0250977483,
0.0274202209,
-0.0210171919,
0.0317062102,
0.0091012232,
0.041237928,
-0.057656575,
0.067668587,
-0.0166970696,
2.873771906e-34,
0.051091373,
0.0212875213,
0.0490889885,
-0.0038271809,
0.0888234153,
-0.0268347599,
-0.0046166591,
0.018173188,
-0.005845258,
-0.0867499858,
-0.0539808087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17811v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17811v2 | Style-Aware Radiology Report Generation with RadGraph and Few-Shot Prompting | 2023-10-26T23:06:38 | 2023-10-31T17:07:17 | Benjamin Yan, Ruochen Liu, David E. Kuo, Subathra Adithan, Eduardo Pontes Reis, Stephen Kwak, Vasantha Kumar Venugopal, Chloe P. O'Connell, Agustina Saenz, Pranav Rajpurkar, Michael Moor | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Automatically generated reports from medical images promise to improve the
workflow of radiologists. Existing methods consider an image-to-report modeling
task by directly generating a fully-fledged report from an image. However, this
conflates the content of the report (e.g., findings and their attributes) with
its style (e.g., format and choice of words), which can lead to clinically
inaccurate reports. To address this, we propose a two-step approach for
radiology report generation. First, we extract the content from an image; then,
we verbalize the extracted content into a report that matches the style of a
specific radiologist. For this, we leverage RadGraph -- a graph representation
of reports -- together with large language models (LLMs). In our quantitative
evaluations, we find that our approach leads to beneficial performance. Our
human evaluation with clinical raters highlights that the AI-generated reports
are indistinguishably tailored to the style of individual radiologist despite
leveraging only a few examples as context. | [
0.0494786948,
0.0444144495,
0.0139262928,
-0.0154290721,
-0.0261959489,
0.0155454539,
-0.009132795,
0.0536913723,
0.0025987821,
-0.0109749231,
-0.0192159694,
-0.0305285025,
0.0124826925,
0.0519603677,
0.0113495737,
-0.0934545621,
-0.0129745416,
-0.0052319653,
0.0363989957,
0.0096666487,
0.0268132072,
0.0275272802,
-0.0017432917,
0.0402253941,
-0.0264313985,
-0.0172524657,
0.0183854997,
0.0447341055,
0.0140897697,
-0.0343765616,
-0.0490905233,
0.0506063551,
0.0050596562,
0.0084593985,
0.000001738,
0.0075505781,
0.004789236,
0.02229972,
0.0305394568,
-0.020555092,
0.1180446744,
-0.0725785047,
0.002734357,
-0.0205935687,
-0.0194651242,
-0.0666819662,
0.0536067113,
0.0393175371,
0.093397148,
0.0637407452,
-0.0345871709,
-0.0047791507,
-0.0405617505,
-0.0304279253,
0.0143812029,
-0.000472564,
-0.0028738733,
0.0408238024,
0.0332571603,
-0.0104801124,
-0.0323013477,
0.0329028592,
-0.0206846483,
-0.0421349853,
0.0127594024,
0.0574822165,
-0.0103159789,
-0.0059873085,
0.0086457469,
0.0881037414,
-0.003654958,
0.0081761843,
0.0211625583,
0.0005954489,
-0.0203942973,
0.0025462832,
-0.0702350289,
0.0109480498,
-0.021215735,
-0.0147319343,
-0.0482594334,
-0.0017409794,
0.0058704824,
0.0074972357,
0.0109637519,
-0.0170716532,
0.0133394999,
-0.0066002277,
-0.0073034917,
0.0281909816,
0.0032877806,
-0.0720249712,
0.0267086886,
0.045270633,
-0.0558911972,
0.0118697016,
-0.0457448475,
-0.0199667495,
0.0498273447,
0.0082955528,
0.0182961281,
-0.0211416669,
0.0046280753,
0.0607843287,
-0.0014801691,
0.0248706769,
-0.0085312873,
0.0174541418,
-0.0408640765,
0.0229393523,
-0.0393518656,
-0.0065799886,
-0.0230512768,
-0.0053888643,
0.0107611744,
-0.0525710583,
-0.0598031022,
-0.0083315447,
-0.0095501589,
0.0230350271,
0.0585913286,
0.0637768582,
-0.0773033649,
0.0198710281,
-0.007654713,
0.0481926277,
0.017913552,
-0.01446776,
0.0114454981,
0.0161869023,
0.0195920859,
0.044030115,
0.0177955739,
0.0289572217,
-0.0302712321,
0.0232922863,
-0.0133543126,
0.0126031265,
0.0397780649,
-0.0793507472,
-0.032654807,
-0.0267818905,
0.0334875584,
-0.0872679576,
0.025578538,
0.0064984411,
0.0224414449,
-0.0145392483,
0.0140812965,
0.014614528,
-0.0306704417,
0.0439224765,
-0.0237226412,
0.0370675065,
0.0306165703,
0.0154264104,
0.0268473309,
-0.0030616634,
0.0261370763,
0.0467122644,
-0.0019119752,
-0.0031288671,
0.0192559864,
0.0177538618,
-0.0025075066,
-0.0114840828,
-0.0252997912,
-0.0224338416,
-0.0151094394,
0.0683405474,
0.0373494066,
0.0762768537,
-0.0176837649,
0.0145418951,
0.04363418,
0.0443808734,
0.0482318327,
0.0088640787,
0.066509448,
-0.017333312,
-0.003458668,
0.0084481761,
-0.0118026491,
0.029806003,
0.0505846888,
0.029313758,
-0.0152750099,
-0.025561234,
-0.0320911892,
0.0075751217,
-0.0092776055,
0.0031503974,
0.000535631,
-0.0268430822,
0.0326469168,
0.0153325507,
-0.0541428961,
-0.0066660554,
0.0400119461,
-0.0405013748,
-0.0047553098,
-0.0436615497,
-0.0202070959,
0.1214594245,
0.0902246609,
-0.0029080936,
0.0039679427,
0.0019184438,
0.0481168367,
0.0465044118,
0.064588502,
-0.0062877703,
-0.0001569221,
-0.0549787991,
-0.0383601785,
0.001110241,
0.0046376046,
0.0087051596,
-0.0079079941,
0.020673655,
-0.0162890181,
-0.0324302576,
-0.0928161293,
0.0221792161,
-0.0461658128,
-0.0278137755,
0.011551396,
0.0058797626,
-0.0242847204,
0.0136959646,
-0.0485320874,
0.0536585078,
-0.0140753798,
0.0090993615,
-0.0003094098,
0.031085819,
-0.0497753844,
-0.0341498852,
-0.0079275072,
-0.0784304589,
-0.0081565576,
-0.0230999291,
-0.0202812869,
-0.0357175916,
-0.0324405432,
-0.0727374181,
0.023790339,
-0.0061143092,
0.0271738581,
0.0625193939,
-0.0164308865,
-0.0242844615,
0.0540898517,
0.0145129682,
0.0055686729,
0.0459771119,
-0.0078747422,
-0.013336557,
-0.0335089155,
-0.0165319107,
-0.0140361628,
0.0334359854,
0.0174012389,
0.0103176124,
0.0352204964,
-0.0312269088,
-0.0232891925,
-0.0923609287,
-0.0263260156,
0.0160027109,
-0.0415846854,
0.027623916,
0.0064837723,
-0.002216052,
-0.0224695634,
-0.0378508009,
-0.0155811002,
0.0560778342,
0.0130991144,
0.05898422,
0.0096719991,
0.0028747546,
-0.058392372,
-0.0430211723,
-0.0240096413,
0.0293334667,
0.0912923291,
0.0025778229,
-0.0199211035,
0.0631535724,
-0.0257477351,
-0.0093546035,
0.0221678019,
-0.050976228,
0.0356304608,
-0.0398335978,
0.0073192348,
0.0883517563,
-0.0000857242,
0.0339737907,
0.0471170768,
-0.0226296149,
-0.0107309697,
-0.0273723397,
-0.0388664827,
-0.0106398733,
0.0433828048,
-0.0930646211,
0.0061603566,
-0.00144565,
0.0384559035,
0.0488070399,
-0.0256289504,
-0.0210809205,
-0.0122187501,
-0.0065813116,
-0.0087917913,
-0.0049583414,
0.007211078,
0.0335338823,
-0.025747817,
-0.0321312882,
0.0878081992,
-0.0005726625,
0.0222476907,
-0.0195266753,
0.0016659077,
-0.0389731042,
0.0625877008,
0.0168835856,
0.0457367897,
0.0127650052,
-0.0260647554,
-0.0325746983,
-0.0049866312,
0.0638438836,
-0.054767631,
0.0223188475,
-0.0138017051,
-0.0046312721,
-0.0119331628,
-0.0328608677,
-0.0199373178,
-0.0245062932,
0.0202979762,
-0.0008930687,
0.0194111913,
-0.0551780276,
-0.0716535449,
0.0641853809,
0.0159890745,
0.0247291382,
-0.0301099326,
-0.0256395712,
0.0142204016,
0.0632966161,
0.0589763895,
-0.0219413023,
-0.048897218,
-0.0393195823,
0.0229927208,
0.0454760939,
-0.012973343,
0.0708194301,
-0.0376953892,
0.0001372232,
-0.0347715579,
0.0047989492,
-0.0025645685,
0.0002820045,
0.0472731814,
-0.0282588582,
-0.0287264604,
0.1060481369,
0.0338406824,
-0.072168529,
-0.0257378574,
0.0114591932,
0.0053384225,
0.0072526876,
0.0314291865,
-0.0418687165,
-0.0003865381,
-0.030362701,
0.0402917005,
-0.0140428888,
-0.0294507612,
-0.0044754799,
-0.066525355,
0.048088707,
0.0264873095,
-0.0352679268,
-0.0560866185,
-0.029221639,
-0.000766812,
0.0315279141,
-0.069374457,
-0.017066475,
-0.0360714048,
-0.0042175567,
0.0085487831,
-0.0527641848,
-0.0435371995,
0.0043712794,
-0.0529291257,
-0.0102999471,
0.0690371767,
0.0613520779,
-0.0025353879,
-0.0165074598,
-0.0586562455,
0.0616435595,
0.0256125126,
-0.0076811919,
0.0836638063,
0.0142328339,
-0.0347905383,
-0.0874594525,
0.0181770306,
0.0047474685,
0.0190947372,
-0.0029383395,
0.0282743759,
-0.0300755333,
-0.0311433524,
-0.069933109,
0.0576366372,
0.0487402976,
0.0228433292,
0.0248945914,
-0.0050364444,
-0.0649246573,
-0.0238079727,
0.098552756,
-0.0622569658,
-0.0594856739,
0.021495536,
-0.0721607655,
-0.053053055,
-0.0776394308,
-0.0112896254,
0.0296975076,
0.0384281725,
0.0037765238,
-0.0376507863,
-0.0171515513,
-0.0040201959,
-0.0733300596,
0.0172555204,
0.0220786314,
0.0165668391,
-0.0211028308,
-0.050183136,
0.0469505005,
0.0138913337,
0.0064796731,
0.0652561486,
-0.045048181,
0.0001615,
-0.0150299389,
0.04145227,
0.0221995898,
-0.0019587101,
0.0161523465,
-0.0227202438,
0.0605659224,
0.0751445591,
0.0093582589,
-0.01375164,
-0.019899942,
-0.0189813022,
-0.0330087543,
-0.0035982397,
-0.0503794365,
0.0125666987,
0.0098827314,
0.0318258554,
-0.0321950689,
-0.0469737165,
0.0105011947,
0.0385149382,
-0.0100876428,
-0.0479310304,
0.0022327383,
-0.0137592331,
-0.0507996567,
-0.0488383621,
-0.0208446886,
-0.0268086176,
0.0083872443,
0.0176063869,
0.0051860451,
-0.0137498211,
0.0203346983,
-0.0330678299,
0.0096226782,
-0.0685093328,
0.0061413846,
0.0430814512,
-0.0184471551,
0.0389234573,
-0.0104221907,
-0.0238216147,
-0.0116735324,
-0.0107045602,
0.0033476099,
0.0025285846,
0.0544200353,
0.0212474577,
0.0205917377,
-0.0281288307,
0.0391497687,
-0.0241682678,
-0.0336142033,
-0.0260089897,
0.013666668,
0.0333333537,
0.0104831122,
0.006171803,
-0.0546693876,
0.0096678296,
-0.0261772145,
0.0567329079,
0.0156226614,
0.0037894396,
0.0457051434,
0.0067445775,
0.0444455296,
-0.0205933321,
0.097074084,
0.012567427,
0.0047005555,
-0.0085433573,
-0.0989317447,
-0.0485853627,
-0.0193812847,
0.0261566378,
-0.0200315099,
-0.0056493771,
-0.0064539574,
-0.0571733676,
-0.0535718463,
0.0056886952,
0.0084289014,
-0.0145186465,
-0.0131507646,
0.0466494821,
0.0397616029,
0.010450501,
-0.0144523941,
-0.0341203175,
0.0696897581,
-0.0493765995,
-0.020753732,
-0.0011179798,
-5.159444172e-33,
-0.0103178099,
-0.0971516296,
0.0129529275,
-0.0035873761,
-0.0145148365,
0.031905856,
-0.0474196076,
-0.0023744656,
0.025515357,
0.0271037985,
-0.0206117593,
-0.0241240859,
0.0158145782,
0.0220377129,
-0.0004109963,
0.0333171263,
0.0459687226,
-0.0126390168,
-0.0505446978,
0.0457196832,
-0.0223960057,
0.0017657484,
0.0089528132,
-0.0826180503,
-0.0162146036,
-0.0153681012,
-0.017818233,
-0.0316909961,
0.0352155827,
0.0552598126,
-0.0223128647,
0.024608558,
0.0175983086,
-0.0144345546,
-0.0160290916,
0.057073433,
-0.072548531,
-0.0258145612,
0.0093456544,
-0.0163413305,
-0.0538720787,
-0.0082791531,
0.0446331091,
-0.0282824989,
0.0184028763,
-0.031259343,
0.0612368025,
0.0042764619,
-0.0183660258,
-0.027016988,
-0.0391037092,
0.0369223431,
-0.006580004,
-0.0497502759,
-0.0164412037,
-0.0025300893,
-0.0200785287,
0.0295708254,
-0.036547415,
0.0325813331,
0.0143103227,
0.0122546498,
0.0376094282,
0.0196962375,
-0.0033854381,
0.0476766042,
0.0318652801,
0.0186157208,
-0.0064186505,
0.019874502,
-0.0357304923,
0.0765971169,
0.0076645291,
0.0218789894,
0.0021920188,
-0.0303399712,
-0.0464458875,
0.0439918302,
-0.0193962585,
0.0577550679,
0.0164707545,
-0.0222697873,
-0.0476717576,
-0.0059695207,
0.0235156845,
-0.0344154276,
-0.0267864764,
-0.0381630287,
0.013618255,
0.0436514951,
-0.0190985873,
0.0421834551,
0.0203985758,
0.0102936272,
-0.0011376316,
-0.0096236216,
-0.0194134731,
0.0574775264,
-0.0625606254,
-0.0273319203,
-0.0181366745,
0.0011734476,
0.0526271425,
0.0407975577,
0.0317371972,
0.0345726758,
0.0276101604,
0.0251736008,
-0.0542420708,
-0.0048425235,
0.016144475,
-0.0184501484,
-0.0424545184,
0.0007135717,
0.0292073861,
0.0000198485,
-0.024862349,
0.0257995203,
-0.0275271293,
0.0094979461,
-0.0153435571,
-0.0719205365,
0.029125588,
-0.0075082746,
-0.0629821122,
-0.0206139702,
-0.0357528552,
-0.012416617,
0.0558322705,
-0.0110534215,
-0.0278866086,
-0.005764721,
2.405e-7,
0.0625265464,
0.0242994539,
0.0289567355,
0.0430163816,
0.0428410359,
-0.0018544935,
-0.0106464755,
0.0159733575,
-0.0038507094,
-0.0025994822,
0.0508575514,
0.001929134,
0.0195780098,
0.0374640524,
-0.0702707916,
-0.0045725368,
-0.0693380386,
-0.0150412219,
-0.0235932395,
-0.0403326638,
0.081517823,
0.0392469205,
-0.0435230099,
-0.0459431633,
0.003090709,
-0.0360760801,
0.0590029433,
-0.0058980947,
-0.0069446219,
-0.0049797576,
0.0270262901,
-0.0014568812,
-0.0156483985,
0.0360366143,
-0.0083562704,
-0.0584804267,
0.0459298044,
0.0797904357,
-0.0460773669,
0.0158772711,
0.0224911291,
0.006839572,
0.0165461674,
-0.0147120692,
0.0324430987,
-0.0209614653,
-0.0241090283,
-0.0444186032,
-0.0164293647,
-0.0088360962,
0.0536801778,
-0.0552868061,
-0.0514151677,
0.0548741855,
0.0231043734,
0.0078757899,
-0.0319161452,
-0.0577230416,
-0.0125458175,
-0.0105505055,
-0.0012665362,
-0.0348079875,
0.0184501968,
-0.0069571189,
-0.0229707062,
-0.0328516476,
0.0048808465,
2.196829276e-34,
0.038607154,
0.0274955407,
0.003318572,
-0.0239137467,
0.0397372879,
-0.0130092753,
-0.0117886672,
0.0375444256,
0.0417520516,
-0.07561405,
-0.0426541641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17802v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17802v1 | TIMELINE: Exhaustive Annotation of Temporal Relations Supporting the Automatic Ordering of Events in News Articles | 2023-10-26T22:23:38 | 2023-10-26T22:23:38 | Sarah Alsayyahi, Riza Batista-Navarro | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal relation extraction models have thus far been hindered by a number
of issues in existing temporal relation-annotated news datasets, including: (1)
low inter-annotator agreement due to the lack of specificity of their
annotation guidelines in terms of what counts as a temporal relation; (2) the
exclusion of long-distance relations within a given document (those spanning
across different paragraphs); and (3) the exclusion of events that are not
centred on verbs. This paper aims to alleviate these issues by presenting a new
annotation scheme that clearly defines the criteria based on which temporal
relations should be annotated. Additionally, the scheme includes events even if
they are not expressed as verbs (e.g., nominalised events). Furthermore, we
propose a method for annotating all temporal relations -- including
long-distance ones -- which automates the process, hence reducing time and
manual effort on the part of annotators. The result is a new dataset, the
TIMELINE corpus, in which improved inter-annotator agreement was obtained, in
comparison with previously reported temporal relation datasets. We report the
results of training and evaluating baseline temporal relation extraction models
on the new corpus, and compare them with results obtained on the widely used
MATRES corpus. | [
0.0331093036,
0.0101431897,
-0.0044315462,
0.0539259873,
-0.0491140187,
0.0251594726,
0.0034951353,
-0.0032603517,
0.0237172451,
-0.0410091504,
0.0401706472,
0.0072469302,
-0.0205118544,
-0.0025692983,
-0.0724105611,
-0.0921597034,
0.0331329219,
0.0256498605,
0.0387289561,
0.0623379909,
0.0180646852,
0.0339205973,
-0.0394453816,
0.013618377,
-0.0291557964,
-0.0226533487,
-0.0191013198,
-0.0363422632,
0.0666173175,
-0.0783779174,
-0.0253792498,
0.0330690406,
0.0305406377,
-0.0046509369,
0.0000015741,
-0.0263955127,
-0.0309999529,
-0.0073426967,
-0.0001748105,
0.0073528904,
-0.028211426,
-0.0384872481,
0.013982919,
-0.0237397347,
-0.0562608652,
-0.0350032002,
-0.0109712444,
0.0636423901,
0.0341410078,
0.0863886401,
-0.0459851511,
-0.0071887402,
0.0375565141,
0.0212068185,
-0.0267826635,
-0.0414156467,
-0.0114629157,
0.0169906821,
0.0219262745,
0.0081881555,
0.0452939458,
0.0103118224,
0.0112229008,
-0.0215222482,
-0.0135656539,
0.021188492,
-0.0679448321,
0.0013948306,
-0.019004764,
0.038125217,
0.0583506674,
-0.0153796664,
0.0274565816,
0.0055722529,
-0.0204870086,
0.0316456258,
-0.0357645825,
0.0063831448,
-0.0344402045,
0.0067683351,
0.0650134832,
0.0326720066,
-0.0227515977,
0.0237673167,
0.0304199159,
0.0657134354,
0.0082854237,
0.0020887379,
-0.0369753353,
0.0159424562,
0.0161913112,
-0.0437835678,
0.0420072041,
0.0318830796,
0.0455902852,
0.0091479514,
-0.0364909843,
0.0088278661,
-0.016469948,
-0.1101453528,
-0.0618089996,
0.0016479113,
0.0040913639,
0.0435216613,
0.0019385201,
0.0009019657,
-0.0086368257,
-0.0490962677,
0.0052893898,
0.0254914425,
-0.0327284336,
0.0336625651,
-0.0144939525,
0.0137564875,
-0.0546646565,
-0.0017936203,
-0.0253936946,
0.0386392027,
0.0237073153,
-0.0130967693,
-0.0030363759,
-0.0305361971,
-0.0280290712,
-0.0040562605,
-0.0301763788,
-0.0060867216,
-0.0375366434,
0.0126941195,
-0.0266564284,
-0.0386625044,
-0.0209758189,
0.0186480358,
0.0227690227,
-0.0289121252,
-0.0748324767,
0.02091619,
-0.0401757061,
-0.0178314038,
-0.0368541107,
-0.0398663357,
0.0004967366,
-0.0069947494,
-0.0168414786,
-0.0369570293,
0.0165254381,
0.0084556006,
-0.0226941444,
0.0111845424,
0.0282177068,
0.0052521555,
-0.0370268114,
0.0219467096,
0.0024368749,
0.0098865721,
0.0166605394,
0.0115135899,
0.0440352261,
0.0453795716,
0.0713726208,
-0.0024352684,
0.0406062566,
0.034963835,
-0.0271537732,
0.0152530819,
-0.0329740793,
-0.0115621472,
-0.0403865464,
-0.0066845734,
0.0018225953,
0.0123300236,
0.0155120939,
-0.0017818678,
-0.03115361,
-0.0151072424,
0.0234320201,
-0.0173599776,
-0.0263925921,
-0.0293304808,
0.0622601658,
-0.0262136851,
0.0487157404,
0.0392280035,
0.002492104,
0.0006261251,
0.0114811547,
0.0109650921,
-0.0873038769,
0.0023575111,
-0.0071941949,
-0.01539037,
-0.0113402726,
-0.0167748276,
-0.0087262448,
-0.0279357322,
0.0431687534,
-0.0053581679,
-0.0149200745,
0.0495813824,
0.0178591646,
-0.0053043403,
0.0078695687,
0.0421645753,
-0.0025518525,
0.0409773625,
0.0402084179,
-0.0434848964,
-0.0742059872,
0.0031267924,
0.0341170281,
0.0242854208,
0.0313147381,
-0.0555551574,
-0.0086554177,
-0.0181530789,
-0.0225199331,
0.0085579334,
0.0101220356,
-0.0298434757,
0.040775869,
0.0182400458,
0.0000619506,
0.0280838795,
0.0027728472,
0.0393813103,
-0.0322198234,
-0.024693979,
-0.0339378044,
0.0138746751,
0.0151895257,
0.0581598617,
0.0083661675,
-0.0161358397,
0.0583765283,
-0.0313247181,
0.0356859751,
0.067371808,
-0.0180820841,
-0.0472175889,
0.0058002453,
0.0141521413,
-0.0348901711,
0.0016453019,
-0.0222402979,
-0.0517201982,
-0.0047782646,
0.0528276078,
0.0492670573,
-0.0110982871,
0.0133697791,
0.0377767086,
-0.0124780918,
-0.0487909019,
0.0785865039,
0.0020261693,
-0.0083819292,
0.0150358984,
-0.0226174742,
-0.0128862942,
-0.0197507888,
-0.0120616443,
0.0445216,
0.0137571339,
-0.0643728077,
0.0382728204,
-0.0535551831,
-0.0581873395,
0.0087115113,
-0.0792983174,
0.0296132881,
-0.0216078181,
0.0493746363,
0.0394680649,
0.015486409,
-0.0183012839,
-0.0311946478,
0.0240983311,
0.0059881979,
-0.0210482553,
0.0141878827,
0.0491155796,
0.0559546426,
0.0022890493,
-0.0591279007,
0.0131271472,
-0.0680186078,
0.055588793,
0.0519355461,
-0.07381396,
0.0104752854,
0.0221532155,
0.0017205741,
0.0325745903,
-0.0130894119,
0.0071242484,
0.0188832898,
-0.0052830828,
0.01753534,
0.061182674,
0.043010626,
0.0825683773,
0.00959705,
-0.0322994255,
-0.0360064059,
0.0203963816,
-0.0400217511,
0.0444129184,
-0.0223859511,
-0.0035932912,
-0.0219771285,
0.0439686589,
0.0010576474,
0.0461219326,
-0.0026106338,
-0.0243684985,
-0.0398760289,
0.020407455,
0.0193961672,
-0.0323959552,
-0.0276462901,
0.0026730131,
-0.040423777,
0.0271696188,
0.0401501544,
0.0118173007,
0.0171712153,
-0.0145563092,
-0.0231693629,
-0.0555640049,
0.1073054522,
-0.0142683163,
0.0022739705,
-0.0063621537,
-0.0661972091,
-0.0288651306,
-0.0314718261,
0.0594999678,
0.0083830003,
0.0330086313,
-0.0597409084,
0.037000332,
-0.0156466849,
0.001379324,
-0.047248926,
-0.0835380554,
-0.0121513344,
-0.0130014019,
-0.0468790084,
0.0109047871,
-0.0100801587,
0.0407224782,
-0.0193687975,
0.0414675623,
-0.0417616814,
-0.0035218899,
0.0130359279,
0.1218132004,
0.0524738245,
-0.0217133611,
-0.0332495831,
0.0296741277,
0.0348691531,
0.0074242139,
0.0074299043,
0.0015454063,
-0.0341901146,
-0.0012422123,
-0.0173465721,
-0.0858616233,
-0.0235344283,
-0.0378511585,
0.0204522293,
-0.0729688182,
-0.007687082,
0.110279724,
0.0501347072,
-0.0086460104,
-0.01634432,
0.051046595,
-0.0015834866,
0.0177143291,
-0.0021845163,
-0.0673407614,
0.0263396073,
-0.0248074867,
-0.0406301692,
-0.0109715397,
-0.0400136374,
-0.0144803254,
-0.0392664038,
-0.027246166,
0.0001580307,
-0.0326572284,
0.0225215163,
-0.0514742807,
0.0013283395,
-0.0361040644,
-0.0262215193,
0.0086815413,
-0.0104705375,
0.016310161,
0.026139278,
-0.0542720817,
-0.0598693565,
0.0038554412,
0.0083592888,
0.0546412729,
-0.0082641141,
0.0406143367,
-0.0193951018,
0.0531942137,
0.0384537093,
0.0257111546,
-0.0129692117,
-0.0096008126,
0.0570364147,
-0.0254219137,
-0.0064637479,
-0.0401155762,
0.0087819854,
0.0315582491,
-0.0404681191,
0.0072860378,
0.0555994548,
-0.0227644816,
0.031261798,
-0.0047366982,
-0.0161173195,
0.0188399069,
0.0218177252,
-0.0081465682,
0.0246288516,
-0.0327488035,
0.0058049518,
0.0241341665,
-0.0699817091,
-0.0166568477,
-0.0210436303,
-0.0610854216,
-0.0459341109,
-0.07343404,
-0.0980704501,
-0.0103881732,
0.0312186144,
0.0074993926,
0.0063099405,
0.0384883732,
0.0207344797,
-0.0701500848,
0.0363905467,
0.0252865758,
-0.0363662317,
0.0114179188,
-0.0014178404,
0.0381873213,
0.0401126668,
-0.0034637665,
0.0445466936,
-0.0387790129,
-0.0208662078,
0.0184918381,
-0.0291319396,
0.0146505684,
0.0582964942,
-0.0143624358,
0.0250515118,
-0.0065999068,
0.015742382,
0.0151934028,
-0.035761673,
-0.0054325787,
-0.0003934607,
-0.0166532453,
-0.0059857192,
-0.0215051472,
0.0323671326,
-0.0684054568,
0.0535455495,
-0.0591477305,
-0.0123802694,
0.0174174644,
-0.0287134778,
0.0599383973,
-0.0009677265,
-0.0190916229,
-0.0377914868,
-0.0025918768,
-0.0777672306,
0.0125903282,
0.0009132769,
0.0406103581,
0.0048450674,
0.011860746,
-0.0554682426,
0.0132414168,
-0.0204661228,
0.029210614,
-0.0215063915,
0.0313461646,
0.0656627715,
0.0148246316,
-0.0525687784,
0.0136307646,
-0.0452563874,
0.0067023467,
0.006156187,
-0.0094048362,
-0.0256968513,
-0.0055934149,
-0.0134068225,
0.0118447635,
0.0200104285,
-0.0059638545,
-0.0736177042,
0.0804446265,
-0.0280768666,
0.0039674458,
0.0677970201,
-0.0748838261,
0.094624728,
0.0100948904,
-0.0214143135,
0.0261653978,
0.0235651508,
0.0264055729,
-0.0011817698,
-0.0157664642,
0.0072054085,
-0.0168904047,
0.0556478947,
0.0636532456,
-0.0355726928,
0.0492372885,
0.0659690723,
-0.0617536418,
-0.0105503323,
-0.032936424,
-0.0367316157,
-0.0236002486,
-0.0016767536,
-0.0297732875,
-0.058299534,
0.0088856462,
0.0357493162,
-0.0108464919,
-0.0045464481,
0.0057428447,
-0.008244873,
0.025258027,
0.0541240647,
-0.0289998949,
-0.0615347438,
0.0489922538,
-0.0111304643,
-0.0392834879,
-0.0630852953,
-5.349048473e-33,
-0.053511072,
-0.0194080118,
-0.0183677357,
0.0310896561,
-0.049963478,
0.0615647845,
-0.0393303968,
-0.0366471261,
0.0018216335,
0.018908795,
-0.0076210005,
0.0136517929,
0.0277166441,
-0.0472985618,
0.0460832641,
-0.0039285347,
0.0219447743,
-0.01910468,
-0.003048253,
0.0057192086,
0.0657690391,
0.0297621638,
0.0504622236,
-0.0551340878,
0.0440360792,
-0.0003507664,
0.0026395908,
0.0012042483,
0.0969880298,
0.0638568923,
0.0055719628,
-0.0432912931,
0.0506947786,
-0.0372833833,
-0.0014014741,
0.033255782,
-0.1120125651,
-0.0388462991,
0.0268536862,
0.011652654,
-0.001682659,
-0.0265138224,
-0.0124750063,
-0.0137742274,
0.0119972955,
0.0034472812,
0.0522845276,
-0.0382609777,
-0.0194087811,
-0.0756203905,
-0.0498531684,
0.0541351512,
-0.0144658508,
0.0058186045,
0.0433890149,
0.0250022002,
0.0509093292,
-0.0080842339,
-0.0356033966,
0.0080092493,
-0.0609611347,
0.0492221005,
0.0058656512,
-0.028663421,
-0.0391231962,
0.0368545167,
-0.0490335785,
0.0085707242,
0.009433642,
0.0714075789,
-0.0280841123,
0.0231438279,
-0.0187653638,
-0.0024937114,
-0.0014050053,
0.0027369566,
-0.072509408,
0.0452231877,
0.0932238474,
0.0074679027,
-0.0266831927,
0.0017933911,
-0.0278305318,
0.0398286432,
0.0336585604,
0.0123740826,
0.0105834771,
-0.0199323446,
0.0018792462,
-0.0076111276,
0.0247193836,
0.0590028353,
0.0190782025,
-0.0039695594,
-0.0262012146,
0.0264205802,
-0.033302214,
0.0505680926,
0.000840062,
0.0286219232,
-0.0397508331,
-0.0180535465,
0.0033102559,
0.0167879891,
0.0374149717,
-0.0319190212,
0.0374817736,
0.0042456863,
-0.0216183029,
-0.0366863608,
0.0018433373,
-0.020060854,
-0.0375539847,
-0.0068950714,
0.0074156546,
0.0191501491,
0.0137097202,
0.0430523492,
0.0204149354,
0.052808702,
0.0159460939,
-0.0269363578,
0.0066444306,
0.0127506116,
0.0307505876,
-0.0071761529,
0.0180811156,
0.0963255614,
-0.0269158445,
-0.0109394873,
0.0011834604,
-0.0004287944,
2.196e-7,
0.0356148481,
0.0401112437,
0.0689931437,
0.0371318124,
-0.0053906646,
-0.0468444563,
0.0084502641,
0.0408326015,
-0.0206666235,
0.0220257454,
0.0358137749,
-0.0121636912,
0.020626517,
0.043072179,
-0.0492657311,
-0.0674715564,
-0.0689104423,
-0.0573301092,
-0.0806314945,
-0.0221342165,
0.0943050981,
0.0203803312,
0.0327773951,
0.0524495095,
-0.0718350708,
-0.003311533,
0.0346841142,
0.0007216536,
-0.0901557803,
0.028952647,
0.0565682054,
-0.0063962289,
-0.0524398386,
0.0251558423,
-0.0391859971,
0.0237655062,
-0.0204944443,
0.0456901118,
-0.0199229289,
-0.0202556439,
-0.0015942812,
-0.0384360179,
0.0226249397,
0.0040897462,
0.0650067627,
-0.023019867,
-0.0046845302,
-0.0215886142,
-0.0500108786,
0.0405535996,
-0.0044494397,
0.0413164943,
-0.004026345,
0.0443302728,
-0.0068004127,
-0.0269858111,
-0.0193253532,
-0.0684619546,
-0.0232648887,
0.0853357688,
0.0115388269,
-0.0095885489,
0.0128505481,
-0.0255278386,
-0.0293716379,
-0.0022053996,
-0.0026001264,
1.621780653e-34,
-0.002100687,
0.047720775,
-0.0176791362,
0.0531403124,
0.0209889133,
-0.0144554535,
-0.0242887568,
0.0171906389,
-0.0014550802,
-0.0386549383,
0.0371408574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17793v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17793v2 | "You Are An Expert Linguistic Annotator": Limits of LLMs as Analyzers of Abstract Meaning Representation | 2023-10-26T21:47:59 | 2023-12-11T17:11:25 | Allyson Ettinger, Jena D. Hwang, Valentina Pyatkin, Chandra Bhagavatula, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) show amazing proficiency and fluency in the use
of language. Does this mean that they have also acquired insightful linguistic
knowledge about the language, to an extent that they can serve as an "expert
linguistic annotator"? In this paper, we examine the successes and limitations
of the GPT-3, ChatGPT, and GPT-4 models in analysis of sentence meaning
structure, focusing on the Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR; Banarescu et
al. 2013) parsing formalism, which provides rich graphical representations of
sentence meaning structure while abstracting away from surface forms. We
compare models' analysis of this semantic structure across two settings: 1)
direct production of AMR parses based on zero- and few-shot prompts, and 2)
indirect partial reconstruction of AMR via metalinguistic natural language
queries (e.g., "Identify the primary event of this sentence, and the predicate
corresponding to that event."). Across these settings, we find that models can
reliably reproduce the basic format of AMR, and can often capture core event,
argument, and modifier structure -- however, model outputs are prone to
frequent and major errors, and holistic analysis of parse acceptability shows
that even with few-shot demonstrations, models have virtually 0% success in
producing fully accurate parses. Eliciting natural language responses produces
similar patterns of errors. Overall, our findings indicate that these models
out-of-the-box can capture aspects of semantic structure, but there remain key
limitations in their ability to support fully accurate semantic analyses or
parses. | [
0.037255466,
0.0191928428,
-0.0494131185,
0.0652213916,
-0.0510471091,
0.0186001863,
-0.0478966795,
-0.0142017473,
0.0005386298,
-0.0647372678,
-0.0033625446,
0.00559898,
-0.0279372856,
0.0342051201,
-0.0016349261,
-0.0686949417,
0.0405344218,
0.0170712937,
0.0535235628,
0.0429949537,
0.0367535949,
0.0457186028,
0.0085753407,
0.0730054155,
-0.0593827181,
-0.0386529975,
-0.0395195223,
0.0014775575,
-0.0097735338,
-0.0492137782,
-0.0268456377,
-0.0054896404,
0.046266906,
0.0371403061,
0.0000020257,
-0.045283787,
-0.022725407,
0.0063186036,
-0.0250946209,
0.0007144827,
0.073683314,
-0.0448601581,
0.0058300812,
-0.0081286822,
-0.0555863194,
-0.0208646748,
0.0209184438,
0.0388727784,
0.0722378492,
0.0502944887,
-0.0258197021,
-0.0274139121,
0.0270654336,
0.0072084893,
-0.0336290598,
-0.0368278138,
-0.0147207864,
0.0555896312,
0.0071147205,
0.0100611802,
-0.022187382,
0.0289819818,
0.0205409117,
0.008828328,
-0.029124165,
0.0248801,
-0.0529398844,
-0.028903421,
0.0028178431,
0.0312984176,
-0.0026398038,
-0.0186511949,
0.0011161732,
-0.030226225,
0.0102211088,
0.0175796952,
-0.0468429215,
0.0614409335,
-0.0304213762,
0.0389479175,
0.0543944426,
-0.0068219607,
0.0073586232,
0.0171201359,
0.0003342284,
0.0689052343,
-0.0047913501,
-0.0245115086,
0.0087964097,
0.0296748914,
-0.0430354364,
-0.0480125621,
0.0126806572,
0.0200294331,
-0.0060280524,
0.0379184484,
-0.0375684798,
-0.0212594904,
0.0090723289,
-0.027708089,
0.04917714,
0.0619020239,
-0.0282640737,
0.0471186563,
0.0115929954,
0.0253481623,
-0.0035682484,
0.0292606447,
-0.0484328344,
-0.0166086275,
-0.0603329577,
-0.0308417715,
-0.0700233728,
0.0594052635,
-0.0633990318,
-0.0315613672,
-0.0070902058,
0.0436381325,
0.0215672441,
-0.0034861437,
0.0035844082,
-0.0002303306,
-0.0467638373,
0.0320201665,
-0.0506326482,
0.0145255253,
-0.0326445736,
0.0096630529,
-0.0187444147,
-0.0671329424,
-0.0012188111,
0.0290840901,
0.0322832353,
-0.0388335101,
-0.0180186555,
0.0639429688,
0.0182229634,
-0.0216579083,
-0.0028131136,
-0.0809419006,
-0.030549692,
-0.0164305456,
0.0145594031,
-0.0304900911,
0.0265496876,
0.0239153635,
0.0158262569,
-0.0330125913,
0.0134384613,
0.0051440196,
0.0014590339,
0.0315802507,
-0.0138003379,
-0.0075413249,
-0.0198246446,
-0.0081089651,
-0.0256185886,
0.0427740067,
0.0607945025,
0.0392190181,
0.0168874469,
0.0033430511,
-0.0179929174,
0.0334407985,
-0.0219890568,
-0.0205805637,
0.0049663717,
0.0036929413,
-0.0579446368,
0.0315159708,
0.018303195,
0.0532074943,
-0.0334589668,
-0.0018849078,
0.0253830887,
0.0673116595,
-0.000824502,
0.0375543609,
0.0875656754,
0.0242305361,
0.0112615479,
-0.0012523211,
-0.0474934615,
-0.0042808047,
-0.0176305324,
0.0155488458,
-0.0589545853,
-0.0269354135,
0.0194289628,
-0.0355852321,
-0.0243203752,
-0.0101110013,
-0.0039920202,
-0.0010912395,
0.021089796,
0.0142770875,
-0.0078559639,
0.0539665408,
-0.0056836475,
-0.0582172126,
-0.0026164702,
-0.0282720029,
0.0041200588,
0.0456157401,
0.0411885753,
-0.0379769504,
-0.0438774116,
-0.017214682,
0.0216475334,
0.0641440749,
0.0271192174,
-0.0097154211,
-0.008999018,
-0.0132511109,
-0.0110553512,
-0.0597007498,
0.029754445,
0.0118411472,
-0.0273122191,
-0.0168660618,
0.0024803078,
-0.0454547256,
-0.0177609418,
0.0255042724,
0.0076924623,
-0.0120977033,
-0.0476928204,
-0.0018113683,
0.0348793417,
0.0327781737,
0.0068621617,
0.0300782528,
0.0218006987,
-0.0395238139,
-0.0054549067,
0.0576802269,
-0.0385167487,
-0.0443683714,
0.0334141254,
-0.0248508044,
-0.0484858304,
0.0072251637,
-0.0489991531,
-0.0483023897,
0.0081441179,
-0.048784364,
0.0698021799,
-0.0375955664,
-0.0215027183,
0.0095469626,
-0.0316161178,
-0.0223999545,
0.0784069449,
0.0012745804,
-0.0240598433,
-0.0398725644,
0.0107881129,
0.0268988907,
-0.0343706235,
-0.0260444544,
-0.0228523687,
0.0202588197,
0.0023175813,
0.0155714415,
0.0024220832,
-0.0561923124,
-0.0084579,
-0.0871678293,
0.0261809025,
-0.0052149277,
0.0427979901,
0.0570097454,
-0.0084056696,
-0.0026817652,
0.0127663314,
-0.020123329,
-0.0250348616,
-0.0099843089,
0.0159871671,
0.054810904,
-0.0121628083,
-0.0080358554,
-0.0379735529,
0.0111901462,
-0.0881935135,
0.019535074,
0.019706944,
-0.0321879461,
-0.0070136623,
0.028377017,
-0.0268263146,
0.0038799748,
0.0058355993,
-0.0335949548,
0.0397868901,
-0.0240307692,
0.0093131354,
0.0521095395,
-0.0200991035,
0.0855915919,
0.0349198803,
-0.0425906666,
-0.0427532941,
0.0083874352,
-0.0036390759,
-0.0044484846,
-0.0288568512,
-0.045947101,
-0.0045058904,
0.0892500281,
0.0471736751,
0.0380860604,
-0.067781426,
0.0183171239,
-0.0620483235,
-0.0081008812,
-0.0057149231,
-0.0097014941,
-0.0236253217,
0.0350360088,
-0.013953045,
-0.0125502152,
0.0727353543,
-0.0031605591,
-0.0373571217,
-0.0192041285,
-0.0272727162,
-0.0637011454,
0.1034584269,
-0.0089510027,
0.0032930151,
0.0107776737,
-0.0420783162,
-0.0196035895,
-0.0237697773,
0.0477049202,
-0.0244588647,
0.0383081958,
-0.0512168705,
0.0011159948,
-0.0103025585,
-0.0124424361,
-0.0074998797,
-0.0558737442,
-0.0646938905,
0.0196829699,
-0.0349862128,
0.0412560552,
0.0158327036,
0.0194502082,
0.0183208436,
-0.0254544802,
-0.0069875056,
-0.0257969238,
-0.0523914024,
0.0288469233,
0.0383886434,
-0.0025666491,
-0.0211801026,
-0.0004701842,
0.0408002473,
0.0423812941,
-0.0362466425,
0.022827806,
-0.0807302967,
0.0234762486,
-0.0130446469,
-0.0204994176,
-0.0787296742,
0.0036091907,
0.0515230447,
-0.0706452653,
0.0068992237,
0.1173681766,
0.0447492748,
0.0030560179,
0.025382923,
-0.016982533,
0.0272830818,
0.0230409075,
0.010497164,
-0.1092969105,
-0.0298105553,
-0.0033098178,
-0.0238120779,
-0.0184807014,
-0.0401871167,
0.0037433647,
-0.1150270253,
0.0557596646,
-0.0025405998,
-0.0144592682,
0.0380052105,
-0.0002511516,
-0.0034539727,
-0.0246379096,
-0.0029583371,
-0.0184084885,
-0.0236516241,
0.0213393122,
0.0114342328,
-0.0523297414,
-0.0267531984,
0.0484598167,
-0.0149441836,
-0.0251095407,
0.0383212417,
0.0592226163,
-0.0219541062,
-0.0011449493,
0.0568712652,
0.007667338,
0.0445664264,
-0.0136812627,
0.0208395794,
-0.0108589726,
0.0037770185,
-0.0428810269,
0.0074561471,
-0.0111639639,
-0.0436138734,
-0.0226666313,
0.1085615307,
-0.0373258777,
0.0207233317,
-0.0258634221,
-0.003534622,
-0.0213792808,
0.0743192881,
0.0566202886,
0.0033833738,
-0.0646462366,
-0.042909205,
0.034071587,
-0.025504183,
-0.0427539609,
0.0367391184,
-0.0090509756,
0.0097964043,
-0.0438469499,
-0.0747043341,
0.0551978834,
-0.0094682835,
-0.0054709385,
0.0146473637,
0.0076250811,
-0.0213448945,
0.0071872282,
0.0599052384,
-0.0392340869,
0.012570899,
0.0097228736,
-0.0121336859,
0.0155513249,
0.0038674867,
-0.0326202735,
0.0079539996,
-0.0238083713,
-0.0378338732,
-0.0070223319,
0.0454741977,
0.0237242784,
0.0009448213,
-0.0002848789,
-0.0071645309,
-0.0250669904,
-0.0044473121,
-0.0181332398,
0.0029874635,
0.0386428796,
0.0642922446,
0.0011456081,
0.0175690278,
-0.0243584551,
0.0487592779,
-0.00884494,
0.0732445568,
-0.0357207619,
-0.0091388859,
0.0593623519,
0.0529707596,
0.043809671,
0.0082621351,
-0.0216902234,
-0.00230052,
-0.0327556394,
-0.0729299337,
-0.0396314971,
-0.0576967932,
-0.0053786277,
0.0245276988,
-0.0270054862,
-0.013366756,
-0.0189687703,
-0.0389285125,
0.0380020514,
-0.0376528166,
0.0145579092,
0.0378092863,
-0.0466503762,
-0.0220134798,
0.0102427062,
-0.040525265,
-0.0052638487,
-0.032148324,
0.0199767984,
-0.021604199,
0.0316683501,
0.0195435751,
0.002795147,
-0.0066847778,
0.0247722305,
-0.0330271348,
-0.0191384554,
0.0400313251,
0.0306591596,
0.095624961,
-0.0403336883,
0.0899702981,
-0.0338639282,
0.0022789577,
-0.0044845934,
0.0688111857,
0.0400788784,
-0.056867294,
0.0643356442,
0.0203935783,
-0.0334178172,
-0.0677040592,
0.0290278569,
-0.0291699041,
0.0507827513,
0.0278769955,
-0.0310408715,
-0.0469015241,
-0.0106989183,
0.0165836886,
-0.0010161063,
0.0042227348,
-0.0078222929,
-0.0995695591,
-0.0533832423,
0.0132399686,
0.0141305914,
0.0064778696,
-0.0564523749,
0.0220001303,
0.0277757905,
0.023140762,
-0.0611157641,
-0.034705326,
0.0156271625,
-0.0226503294,
0.015905261,
-0.0618215576,
-6.010701549e-33,
-0.0565983094,
-0.0132788345,
0.0223712306,
0.0257012788,
-0.0390372947,
0.0020598581,
-0.0514845699,
0.0001623905,
0.0000420447,
0.0215046424,
0.0086853551,
0.0065439926,
0.0093395216,
-0.0089954929,
0.0267530717,
-0.0290838238,
0.0335944705,
-0.0080611566,
-0.0097373324,
0.0090699457,
0.0356530659,
-0.0016028269,
0.0395121276,
-0.0423850529,
0.0084515186,
0.0182396322,
0.0019409297,
0.010380921,
-0.0131833488,
0.0638705269,
0.0003743217,
0.0345091261,
0.0512639843,
0.0229927599,
-0.0126004312,
-0.0010446332,
-0.0678104311,
-0.0449888296,
0.0594274327,
0.0099161509,
-0.0554532893,
-0.0457696691,
0.0279512703,
-0.0206137262,
-0.0037086289,
-0.0131306723,
0.0449945182,
-0.0018348632,
-0.0124897566,
-0.0170959588,
-0.0528789796,
0.0237163324,
-0.0180872604,
0.007011706,
0.0204968136,
0.0180272795,
0.0309789591,
0.0138270138,
-0.021143863,
-0.0138939237,
-0.0143318949,
-0.0014854663,
0.0158359502,
-0.0097704325,
0.0213665087,
0.0577482954,
0.0001850539,
-0.0032503007,
-0.0155312801,
0.0571791604,
0.0127017004,
0.0709962696,
0.0140023613,
0.0367617495,
0.0069343243,
0.0326417722,
-0.0411898978,
-0.0062798401,
0.0123657146,
0.0759283006,
0.0257253647,
0.0169440079,
-0.0310082845,
-0.0110228145,
-0.0465229675,
0.001619645,
-0.0119119715,
-0.0260488223,
0.0517585129,
-0.0414738841,
0.0206252374,
0.0241475478,
0.0196629781,
-0.0375080183,
0.0032928567,
-0.0277961921,
-0.0257195402,
0.0425846092,
-0.0108853746,
0.0599967875,
-0.0053927675,
-0.0534638166,
-0.0202945415,
-0.0269396212,
0.0544972792,
0.031483572,
0.0386308767,
0.0093979603,
-0.0072028842,
0.0109087303,
-0.039535705,
-0.0232417453,
-0.0530157462,
-0.0207305066,
0.0633495077,
0.030188553,
-0.0158205293,
0.0046544881,
0.0161136743,
0.0252408218,
-0.0248235911,
-0.0052026277,
-0.022274971,
0.0016562376,
-0.0298699886,
0.0061560306,
0.0000036553,
0.0078625744,
0.0642570853,
-0.0340002626,
-0.0281671677,
-0.0091123655,
2.791e-7,
0.0891530365,
0.0641905814,
0.0247673579,
0.0717799291,
0.0126142958,
0.0100383274,
-0.0416576415,
0.0380309857,
0.0276305228,
-0.0182051491,
-0.0028470319,
0.0163464006,
0.0197582394,
0.0507361926,
-0.0899840519,
0.0353921652,
-0.0525668673,
0.0065838424,
-0.0501423068,
0.0909878388,
0.1234480366,
0.0487815328,
0.0268380977,
0.0049598673,
-0.0409346744,
-0.0560885631,
0.0695888698,
-0.0274208561,
-0.0127473082,
-0.0009644638,
0.0007337661,
0.026837144,
0.0049965712,
0.0200217515,
0.0147692058,
0.0015724853,
0.0066346237,
0.0637229383,
-0.0338728987,
0.0181515925,
0.0007931823,
-0.0452663936,
0.012261942,
-0.0504725613,
0.0754007623,
-0.0676459968,
-0.0530869029,
-0.0313370302,
-0.0214447547,
-0.0090984097,
-0.0316175707,
0.0067098858,
-0.0264368728,
0.002457612,
0.0192514658,
-0.0204040874,
-0.0136060547,
-0.0235143658,
-0.029549351,
0.0383032784,
0.0044146255,
-0.0508815534,
-0.0352385715,
0.0221755672,
0.0209847875,
-0.0790410712,
-0.0352622643,
2.628864776e-34,
0.0297543425,
0.0048575345,
0.0582878105,
0.0412110947,
0.0673021078,
0.0210650992,
0.0237618722,
0.0350743607,
0.0326802284,
-0.0761809647,
-0.0174570028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17788v1 | Utilizing Language Models for Energy Load Forecasting | 2023-10-26T21:36:06 | 2023-10-26T21:36:06 | Hao Xue, Flora D. Salim | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Energy load forecasting plays a crucial role in optimizing resource
allocation and managing energy consumption in buildings and cities. In this
paper, we propose a novel approach that leverages language models for energy
load forecasting. We employ prompting techniques to convert energy consumption
data into descriptive sentences, enabling fine-tuning of language models. By
adopting an autoregressive generating approach, our proposed method enables
predictions of various horizons of future energy load consumption. Through
extensive experiments on real-world datasets, we demonstrate the effectiveness
and accuracy of our proposed method. Our results indicate that utilizing
language models for energy load forecasting holds promise for enhancing energy
efficiency and facilitating intelligent decision-making in energy systems. | [
-0.0042604185,
0.1183071733,
-0.007243081,
0.0211356487,
0.0098085459,
-0.0102382451,
0.0208952501,
0.0021566804,
0.0144654326,
-0.0316607989,
0.0392407477,
0.0017404363,
-0.0061356761,
0.0467767976,
0.0284858961,
-0.0457777455,
0.042764172,
-0.0216029808,
0.0294465795,
-0.001602885,
0.001696049,
-0.0128084198,
0.0492560677,
0.0459173284,
-0.0512054414,
-0.0145970723,
-0.0368860923,
-0.0006257954,
0.0000401,
0.0042513274,
0.0273010414,
0.0370978862,
0.0103028677,
0.0306834467,
0.0000017914,
-0.0256611463,
-0.0540498719,
-0.0169916898,
0.0352392383,
-0.0351732709,
0.0612141602,
-0.044943288,
0.0158287361,
0.0106673874,
-0.0599511787,
-0.0110190492,
0.0677715167,
0.0017814238,
0.0435539447,
0.0440628119,
-0.0238993019,
-0.0237787142,
-0.0209195521,
-0.023758186,
-0.006841457,
0.03751982,
0.0196678564,
-0.018194288,
-0.0200461596,
-0.0280623883,
-0.0137821371,
0.0226291064,
-0.0247590058,
-0.0017364139,
-0.0065189647,
0.0122692008,
-0.0155943688,
0.034619879,
-0.0380709954,
0.0091837989,
0.0229507051,
-0.0423445776,
0.0323176309,
-0.0096160127,
-0.0488272868,
0.0271964427,
-0.0423862673,
-0.0246018004,
0.0250942372,
0.01442507,
0.0062881885,
0.002007291,
0.0102108223,
0.0194800347,
-0.0094336877,
0.1432248205,
0.0031237153,
-0.0290636718,
-0.0154939322,
0.0412225313,
0.0322791226,
-0.0467654914,
-0.0063466411,
0.0012109148,
-0.0180622023,
0.0290797483,
-0.0051205363,
0.016478397,
0.0020624937,
-0.0318614841,
0.0443659201,
0.0205592364,
0.0479422249,
0.0108312946,
-0.0065549086,
0.0744068697,
0.0050818673,
-0.0755123794,
-0.0718196705,
-0.0027443648,
-0.0311120376,
-0.0080647776,
-0.060724467,
-0.0326563306,
-0.0375414416,
-0.0012009732,
-0.0234481115,
0.0007368233,
-0.034688428,
0.026591396,
0.016979726,
0.0050015398,
-0.0195885096,
-0.0248237159,
-0.0150928004,
-0.000809159,
-0.0324218124,
0.0191304311,
-0.0333127566,
-0.0591006614,
0.0079569444,
0.006248353,
-0.02121819,
0.0306927469,
-0.0399543568,
0.0367478766,
0.0532506667,
0.0460840166,
-0.0039532469,
-0.0772032663,
0.0346362852,
-0.0111500891,
-0.0059480174,
-0.049565345,
-0.0476821251,
-0.0041810903,
0.0294815544,
-0.0072710877,
-0.0044897827,
0.000413101,
-0.0048654405,
0.063833937,
-0.0970483124,
0.0129911061,
0.0111227771,
-0.0448073782,
0.0080916341,
0.0608206205,
0.0368377268,
0.0054676454,
0.0227894038,
-0.0112299128,
0.0368311554,
0.0169696193,
0.00957203,
0.0085912067,
-0.0519367456,
-0.0222237855,
-0.0146879563,
-0.0339075066,
-0.041126743,
0.0135589,
0.0662475675,
0.0049673496,
0.0349692404,
0.0218081549,
-0.0041675246,
0.036565803,
0.0317902677,
0.0361512043,
-0.0324241221,
-0.0365848318,
0.0089260023,
0.0189629979,
-0.0627700314,
0.023764506,
-0.003058627,
0.0255852789,
-0.0028465174,
-0.0602053739,
0.0014464369,
-0.0176015664,
0.0142015964,
0.0093598301,
0.0122934589,
0.0085176872,
-0.0334367864,
0.0472135246,
0.0474640317,
-0.0135152796,
-0.0054454659,
-0.042960532,
-0.0305205416,
0.0707558841,
0.0079552997,
0.0148679912,
0.0385098159,
-0.0202300679,
0.0442648269,
-0.0101707056,
0.0677799061,
0.0018833007,
-0.0081343148,
-0.040712703,
-0.0329628401,
0.0257801879,
0.0228686519,
-0.0193446968,
-0.0605691373,
0.0143027287,
0.0207285918,
-0.0088144233,
-0.0656978041,
0.0127272708,
-0.0152806127,
-0.0316426605,
0.0158765484,
0.0112270229,
-0.0208969284,
-0.0308480263,
-0.0133382808,
0.041213613,
0.0166271999,
-0.0460377708,
-0.063431628,
0.0556897223,
-0.0619343482,
-0.0034939533,
0.0054370537,
0.0166473649,
0.0597947501,
-0.0385197848,
-0.0209730528,
-0.0620749183,
0.0577040277,
-0.0634517223,
0.0621814057,
-0.03070838,
-0.0076824673,
-0.002676337,
0.0169696622,
-0.0032635282,
0.0652663857,
0.0291660875,
0.0375951976,
-0.0109576313,
0.0221037846,
-0.0325602591,
-0.0113261724,
-0.0134170875,
-0.0221011862,
-0.0205984432,
0.0219491255,
0.024265375,
0.0157806501,
0.010075178,
0.0639223084,
-0.084406279,
-0.0296852477,
-0.0124252401,
0.0332273655,
0.0057602902,
-0.019660648,
-0.0149062248,
-0.0144736236,
-0.0311930235,
0.0403329954,
-0.0458770506,
0.0000119528,
0.0000761991,
0.0049276068,
-0.0410563014,
-0.0339523479,
-0.01888071,
-0.0362777784,
0.0901372433,
0.0362223424,
-0.0144570358,
-0.0256099794,
0.0239930488,
0.0161938854,
-0.0055713854,
0.0030459426,
-0.0447875857,
-0.0523432158,
-0.0340580046,
0.103147693,
-0.0262960792,
0.0282865353,
-0.0186148118,
0.0070906281,
-0.065791361,
-0.0719632506,
0.0368890278,
-0.0198132787,
-0.0124015762,
0.0324948244,
-0.0673540458,
0.0496664308,
0.0726339072,
0.0190374497,
0.0071326178,
-0.0039524226,
0.0505119711,
-0.0248942804,
-0.0109478813,
-0.052955959,
0.0370106325,
0.0022136336,
0.0989143476,
0.0360006727,
-0.067284368,
0.077838406,
-0.0471605323,
-0.0007245849,
-0.0171089973,
-0.0449170657,
-0.0317582525,
-0.0035942157,
0.0082664341,
0.044592388,
0.0134886922,
0.0196316671,
-0.0203143787,
-0.0237765051,
-0.0134094628,
0.0090383338,
0.0458130725,
-0.0250894576,
-0.0148616228,
0.0288440268,
-0.0199303105,
-0.0183307379,
-0.0368340127,
-0.0500725508,
-0.0198609512,
-0.0022579411,
-0.0288636163,
-0.0349643789,
0.0379386321,
-0.0313901268,
0.0366950482,
-0.0189193971,
-0.0256168451,
0.0216923077,
-0.0027606562,
0.0542620495,
0.0009782831,
-0.0402134843,
-0.0014342861,
0.0627713129,
-0.0068467343,
-0.0018553174,
0.058523383,
-0.0537605248,
0.0604164712,
0.0334237851,
-0.0026727023,
-0.0297395047,
0.0358165801,
-0.0175515693,
-0.0382553861,
0.0250771139,
0.0791629404,
0.0086203571,
-0.0097630192,
0.0119888429,
-0.0526233576,
0.0521751344,
0.0159565397,
0.0360405333,
-0.0776905715,
-0.0195597354,
0.0472412854,
0.0532852337,
-0.0313298516,
-0.0368985869,
-0.0498587154,
-0.0535873771,
0.0179456975,
-0.0012844228,
0.0424856544,
0.007496946,
-0.0505275689,
0.0213565882,
-0.007834876,
-0.0699642226,
-0.036291007,
-0.0043920153,
-0.0098145781,
0.055233594,
-0.096051462,
-0.0343969055,
-0.0259396564,
-0.0074791019,
0.028619187,
0.0817587301,
0.033807829,
-0.0116999643,
-0.0149375871,
-0.0310883243,
-0.0033831981,
0.0066144178,
-0.0604519099,
-0.0358203165,
0.0652298704,
-0.0211805254,
0.0130866226,
0.0387349762,
-0.0213133972,
-0.001182074,
0.0524160042,
0.0872416869,
-0.0275580697,
-0.0435363352,
-0.0070255245,
0.0442572348,
0.0964469314,
0.0499178357,
0.0061479122,
-0.0112857874,
-0.0574412383,
-0.0691445544,
-0.000223743,
-0.0197942089,
-0.0200589299,
0.000015788,
-0.0187297706,
-0.0323001929,
-0.0369801559,
-0.0084823547,
0.0260327384,
0.0009909895,
0.0448441021,
-0.0120127425,
0.0339451768,
0.0134511637,
-0.0377513878,
-0.0048958408,
0.0059178909,
0.0394647978,
-0.0479829833,
-0.0600193366,
0.08094161,
0.0153246513,
-0.0002393482,
0.0047252667,
-0.08114779,
-0.0639923289,
0.0097317109,
0.0535258837,
0.0204879139,
0.006091089,
0.0330661312,
0.0284900293,
0.0022866074,
0.0577790439,
-0.0137689989,
-0.018983122,
0.0391237251,
0.0175556429,
0.0292567424,
0.0505887568,
-0.008344641,
0.0729768276,
-0.0544557348,
0.0443012416,
-0.089813672,
-0.0250113066,
0.0087600965,
0.0021426687,
0.0167062562,
-0.0071887579,
-0.0468088165,
0.0002404375,
-0.0407588594,
-0.0161631107,
-0.0268549286,
-0.0567749664,
0.0223166607,
0.0056099505,
0.0606852248,
0.0106763169,
0.0783886313,
0.0068790857,
-0.0485785045,
-0.0098799113,
0.0374766923,
0.0234122444,
0.0439759977,
0.0216642898,
0.0321311057,
0.0334401168,
-0.0326831192,
0.0287933778,
-0.0102890227,
-0.0006466287,
-0.0178362131,
0.0070822039,
0.0258069653,
-0.047862839,
-0.0119619621,
-0.0141528351,
-0.0676073506,
-0.0047650728,
-0.0003190937,
-0.0406099781,
0.0192218181,
-0.004549576,
-0.0480511747,
0.0248242263,
-0.0039767986,
0.0588565022,
-0.0003025209,
-0.014099976,
0.0501341112,
0.0068192389,
-0.0799543634,
-0.0108289076,
0.0705641806,
0.039009925,
0.0141436532,
0.0200659372,
-0.0366337635,
-0.0674640238,
0.0146491639,
0.0012365425,
-0.0594505742,
-0.0034565262,
-0.0143782785,
-0.0464598909,
-0.0212070439,
-0.0045429985,
-0.0145083135,
0.0241540167,
0.0030009274,
0.0676093474,
0.0385183059,
0.0001305604,
0.0081786076,
-0.0116927465,
0.0086084977,
-0.0427747257,
-0.0216261763,
-0.006391617,
-6.074469179e-33,
-0.0115267998,
-0.0535045825,
-0.0004791194,
0.0276809298,
0.0323931053,
0.0168831553,
-0.0254807658,
-0.0097432295,
0.0025603569,
0.0057010697,
-0.0264256708,
-0.0150561295,
0.0275964178,
-0.0174412001,
0.0623875745,
0.0179877859,
0.0649034083,
-0.0281316601,
-0.0134943174,
-0.0137145827,
0.0379837938,
0.0518115796,
0.043572586,
-0.0201888103,
0.0280379765,
-0.0026856326,
-0.0227339491,
-0.0079149073,
0.0412405506,
-0.0053696688,
-0.0187624115,
0.0706838518,
0.0138968155,
0.0011410958,
-0.0603655688,
0.0926389471,
-0.0273429323,
-0.0548063666,
0.0038663489,
0.0136855431,
-0.005389364,
-0.0121555356,
0.0081058685,
0.0042221295,
-0.0437426604,
0.0434044451,
0.0544930436,
-0.0385740623,
0.0048711654,
-0.0168749392,
-0.0088350568,
0.0025198464,
-0.0230825823,
0.0342999622,
0.0161819719,
0.0658788159,
0.0179940797,
0.0283740871,
-0.0331128053,
0.0461584367,
0.0775325671,
0.0668492094,
0.0558019094,
0.0081815291,
0.0032675811,
0.0437178761,
0.0005673054,
-0.0126162227,
-0.0255936719,
0.0246515609,
0.0546133965,
0.0333453193,
-0.0143177072,
0.0236881748,
0.0523700714,
-0.0433367603,
-0.0306730103,
0.0144559192,
0.0498117954,
0.0293572359,
0.0010352588,
-0.0356734842,
0.0114478627,
-0.0452795625,
-0.0051218276,
0.0166418534,
-0.0254341364,
-0.0381380878,
0.0002759703,
0.0035737178,
-0.0133653479,
-0.0017948754,
-0.0055983528,
-0.0283157881,
-0.0218386408,
0.067640245,
-0.0001482431,
-0.0508329235,
0.0036679565,
0.055192329,
-0.0418484211,
-0.0465413444,
-0.0216722451,
0.0457860604,
0.0079095745,
-0.0119846156,
-0.0068002366,
0.061196126,
-0.0486033075,
-0.0078692781,
-0.0185078606,
-0.01145449,
0.0083544534,
-0.0203342047,
0.0281112865,
-0.0233245846,
0.0090435799,
0.0296262968,
-0.034223102,
-0.0090721659,
-0.0029030221,
0.0041732327,
-0.0229271669,
0.0313406624,
-0.0257513504,
-0.0533246249,
-0.0665257573,
-0.0318746381,
0.0328812636,
-0.0109728137,
-0.0400848873,
0.0242845435,
2.558e-7,
-0.0168341231,
0.045256041,
-0.0254076552,
0.0537725575,
-0.0440656021,
0.0312130637,
-0.0235929657,
-0.0028126575,
-0.0028819062,
0.0238298737,
0.0041826135,
-0.0667840391,
0.0747646242,
0.035348095,
-0.094888024,
-0.0273897778,
-0.0907901973,
0.0288019571,
-0.058571022,
-0.0676951557,
0.0784676597,
0.0670192614,
0.040043354,
0.0112681407,
0.0234831888,
-0.0582529642,
0.0192251801,
-0.0709467828,
0.0007960016,
0.0392670408,
0.0262113139,
0.0346888937,
0.0241095554,
-0.0257533509,
-0.0336364545,
-0.002743653,
-0.0110680237,
-0.0023827825,
0.0528262965,
-0.0211245771,
0.0451072976,
-0.0204468369,
-0.0012362056,
-0.0182598848,
-0.0029412678,
-0.0231688116,
-0.0020846073,
0.0230417792,
-0.0126646683,
-0.003869859,
-0.0121583119,
-0.0434603505,
-0.0255221426,
-0.003288903,
0.0070554023,
-0.0288181938,
-0.0040043024,
0.0092366701,
-0.0033837622,
-0.007577695,
-0.0386909172,
-0.0037972073,
-0.0702489316,
0.0125009958,
-0.0023568522,
0.0248262119,
0.0496781021,
2.037378518e-34,
0.0054084198,
-0.0014695522,
-0.0370646119,
0.0487287603,
0.0024890406,
0.0133128865,
-0.0275579002,
0.0494172573,
0.0046174503,
-0.0854855552,
-0.057088241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17787v1 | Evaluation of large language models using an Indian language LGBTI+ lexicon | 2023-10-26T21:32:24 | 2023-10-26T21:32:24 | Aditya Joshi, Shruta Rawat, Alpana Dange | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are typically evaluated on the basis of
task-based benchmarks such as MMLU. Such benchmarks do not examine responsible
behaviour of LLMs in specific contexts. This is particularly true in the LGBTI+
context where social stereotypes may result in variation in LGBTI+ terminology.
Therefore, domain-specific lexicons or dictionaries may be useful as a
representative list of words against which the LLM's behaviour needs to be
evaluated. This paper presents a methodology for evaluation of LLMs using an
LGBTI+ lexicon in Indian languages. The methodology consists of four steps:
formulating NLP tasks relevant to the expected behaviour, creating prompts that
test LLMs, using the LLMs to obtain the output and, finally, manually
evaluating the results. Our qualitative analysis shows that the three LLMs we
experiment on are unable to detect underlying hateful content. Similarly, we
observe limitations in using machine translation as means to evaluate natural
language understanding in languages other than English. The methodology
presented in this paper can be useful for LGBTI+ lexicons in other languages as
well as other domain-specific lexicons. The work done in this paper opens
avenues for responsible behaviour of LLMs, as demonstrated in the context of
prevalent social perception of the LGBTI+ community. | [
0.0723736808,
0.0416656956,
-0.035797853,
0.052153904,
-0.0309251081,
0.0298001822,
0.009337184,
-0.0002646988,
0.0538516566,
-0.0589158945,
-0.0118490411,
-0.0563674942,
-0.0014003686,
0.0375727341,
-0.0060127527,
0.0079048248,
0.0246129073,
0.0480429679,
-0.0041493159,
-0.0073149689,
0.0366235971,
0.0465096943,
0.0195605829,
0.038032122,
0.0036647334,
-0.0038101762,
0.0500992984,
0.0186075177,
-0.0118883755,
-0.0104940906,
0.013742758,
0.0368205011,
-0.0155959148,
0.0286173932,
0.0000018737,
-0.0784443766,
0.0087558748,
0.0111598903,
0.0143383769,
-0.0071328655,
0.0613278598,
-0.02978939,
-0.005331167,
0.0266337581,
-0.0180130284,
0.009026709,
0.0658660382,
0.0081742676,
0.0620805658,
0.0512291715,
-0.0125463344,
-0.0396876298,
-0.0379498452,
0.0090913214,
-0.0165715702,
0.0063513792,
0.0587742478,
-0.0102930116,
-0.003472222,
-0.0305590313,
-0.0156989079,
0.0132569401,
0.0055982317,
0.0119221527,
0.0180104133,
-0.0604083277,
-0.0087554185,
-0.0667958632,
0.0185382236,
0.0297712442,
-0.007043954,
0.0068073766,
0.0406142883,
0.0078279739,
-0.0554151945,
0.0255733803,
-0.0108131915,
0.0389101245,
-0.029101247,
0.002882947,
0.0197742917,
-0.0292816125,
0.0486673713,
0.0760140717,
0.0304498896,
0.0507769026,
0.0224166159,
-0.0166009404,
0.0001024434,
-0.0420600437,
-0.019813532,
-0.0325152241,
0.0427845679,
0.0253171828,
-0.0058525931,
0.0845921934,
0.0031403599,
-0.0191170871,
0.0508920886,
-0.0854954645,
0.0530518331,
0.0750022903,
0.0010331233,
-0.0013512035,
0.0359364897,
0.066310145,
-0.0031660085,
-0.0000856459,
0.0300978646,
-0.0257370248,
-0.0006865851,
-0.0108586587,
0.0179914981,
-0.0168166403,
0.001074584,
0.0793661997,
-0.047978472,
0.0226176847,
-0.0521546677,
0.0070425365,
0.0171894692,
-0.0297702029,
-0.0165321808,
-0.0210530609,
-0.0312857553,
-0.0189674534,
-0.0524651073,
0.0193918757,
-0.0565809719,
-0.0745173022,
0.0486005619,
0.0088120308,
-0.0275792126,
-0.0432704985,
-0.001408881,
0.0373369828,
0.0313566402,
-0.0616009571,
-0.012459999,
0.0111377789,
-0.0709299892,
-0.0525415838,
-0.0390970632,
-0.0626063421,
0.0286100302,
0.0304073878,
-0.0054095634,
-0.0897744,
0.0005991309,
0.009417248,
-0.0482114851,
0.0925453901,
0.0232341718,
0.0004906639,
0.0765007064,
0.053846214,
-0.0071181101,
0.0711695328,
0.0064915265,
0.0074543469,
0.043714013,
0.0010799747,
-0.0009855407,
0.0434279777,
0.0097113047,
0.0243679062,
-0.0662404671,
0.0553166978,
-0.0164140966,
0.0132218385,
-0.027817443,
0.0857970715,
0.014302277,
0.0120367995,
0.0061997483,
0.0671431497,
-0.0019992236,
0.0342933275,
0.0360968634,
0.0367406383,
-0.0078745652,
-0.0002021188,
-0.0500817411,
-0.0283522177,
-0.0157942846,
-0.0449622832,
0.0374243706,
0.0308252927,
-0.000483501,
-0.036239028,
-0.0582210794,
-0.0003791535,
0.0576402582,
-0.034018524,
0.0330606177,
0.0122751519,
0.0050348681,
0.0152695291,
0.0627736896,
-0.0612827539,
0.055901356,
-0.0453532673,
0.0198367797,
0.0547697619,
0.0484200865,
-0.0295640528,
-0.0234472584,
-0.0259677283,
-0.0528301522,
0.0492426194,
0.031572096,
0.0001139149,
-0.0304914284,
-0.0284468159,
-0.0121108443,
0.0668488666,
-0.0128157921,
-0.0214818101,
0.0638735667,
0.0430531651,
0.0175686777,
0.0082902443,
-0.0510518029,
0.0360738635,
-0.0319253504,
-0.0206892453,
-0.0209514182,
-0.0119944382,
0.0742957965,
0.0147095332,
-0.0342078805,
-0.0550025105,
-0.0059700846,
0.0115091177,
-0.0479200669,
0.0144291483,
-0.0344741344,
0.0165643562,
0.0352894031,
-0.0730402395,
-0.0030269248,
0.0794551969,
-0.0048350859,
0.0080430964,
0.0484180003,
-0.0075663314,
0.0060803755,
-0.0486666411,
0.0127249938,
-0.0431794561,
-0.0098975552,
-0.0375803225,
0.04228881,
-0.0388840176,
0.0099390578,
-0.0104397284,
-0.0194120742,
0.0270101577,
0.0173696578,
-0.0700675249,
0.0146972509,
-0.0137105603,
0.0363866761,
0.0233928487,
0.0182203688,
-0.0082858959,
-0.055042576,
-0.0923861489,
-0.0094619952,
0.0092180641,
-0.0263092574,
-0.025306493,
0.023774216,
-0.0394335687,
0.0399065837,
0.0018068433,
-0.0479849651,
0.0717166886,
0.0262273513,
0.0140052903,
-0.0338336192,
-0.0100900587,
0.0002438168,
-0.0163261965,
-0.0271980539,
0.0397580527,
-0.0028673087,
-0.0190972481,
0.0295169316,
0.0030586137,
-0.0672950149,
-0.026320653,
0.0080795372,
-0.0607079603,
0.0249948055,
0.0330455042,
0.046758581,
-0.0026951155,
0.0555834845,
0.0287865438,
0.0267853085,
-0.007869347,
-0.0140950633,
-0.0206785407,
0.0264112931,
0.0090672532,
-0.0300389454,
-0.0724219531,
-0.00616054,
0.0335515365,
0.0332865305,
-0.0180695541,
-0.0669568554,
0.0594540052,
-0.1144290715,
-0.0495089106,
-0.011465013,
-0.0397117063,
-0.0355688371,
0.0376911238,
-0.0322504379,
-0.0435655266,
0.0535731278,
0.002324237,
-0.0068441853,
-0.0520996116,
0.0128722331,
-0.0277144369,
0.0512284935,
-0.0411784537,
0.0464499295,
-0.0457685813,
0.0002437998,
-0.0276192147,
-0.0468350947,
-0.01469291,
-0.0523000546,
0.0773518607,
-0.0574069917,
0.0326500535,
-0.0043854071,
-0.009707042,
-0.066766955,
-0.0288083535,
-0.0219375771,
-0.0288261287,
0.0150249675,
0.0075701838,
0.0606228411,
0.0508379489,
-0.0194968767,
-0.0308309607,
0.0012890004,
0.0021120978,
0.0311700609,
-0.041643694,
0.0039422917,
-0.03471018,
0.0320065655,
0.0368322693,
-0.0285092928,
-0.0065296912,
-0.0180093534,
0.008712491,
-0.0071260249,
0.0171522517,
0.0255662072,
-0.0209094808,
0.0065857982,
-0.0225205421,
0.0483626015,
0.0058093835,
-0.0166019946,
0.0842142329,
0.0509725884,
-0.0256852023,
0.0030756861,
-0.02624253,
-0.0222051013,
0.004030766,
0.0198630877,
-0.1044980735,
0.0242846869,
-0.0165733639,
0.0105422065,
-0.0295097716,
-0.0246774033,
-0.0098827425,
-0.0520759933,
-0.0143970232,
-0.0109124528,
0.0032912823,
-0.0510680228,
-0.0112320054,
0.0235689227,
-0.0096957488,
0.018772075,
0.0060210964,
-0.0121304244,
-0.0050252317,
0.015005393,
-0.0437456816,
-0.0221466254,
0.0305094142,
-0.0414687917,
0.0403918773,
0.0377266034,
0.0591036454,
-0.042570591,
0.0011902361,
0.0052997665,
-0.029752804,
-0.0374965519,
-0.0458314195,
-0.034492746,
0.0073070703,
-0.039881371,
-0.0043613557,
0.000395265,
-0.0171681773,
0.0121389963,
0.0096594691,
0.0227652453,
0.0097826971,
-0.0166561846,
-0.0317688659,
0.0102490261,
-0.0222543813,
0.1000914648,
0.0223184619,
-0.0439412296,
0.0380321033,
-0.075626798,
-0.0191097483,
0.0186404455,
-0.1095526367,
-0.006904237,
0.0187786687,
-0.032121703,
-0.0240177196,
-0.0763907358,
0.0247908253,
-0.0022278058,
0.0646302849,
-0.0220577177,
-0.0164990593,
0.0184024684,
-0.0580214895,
-0.000593729,
-0.0185400136,
0.0301325899,
-0.0181371681,
0.0050344374,
-0.0163369495,
-0.0123346224,
-0.0206673704,
0.0250219051,
-0.0062721674,
-0.0574094094,
0.0737291202,
0.0580518059,
0.0247863196,
-0.0136489933,
-0.0367210023,
-0.0901231691,
0.0200895648,
0.0164847784,
-0.0057870727,
0.0003631011,
0.0253724493,
0.0262976736,
-0.007958591,
0.0407846868,
-0.0196867064,
0.0380282961,
0.0072286301,
-0.0030114483,
-0.0406181626,
-0.0881955549,
-0.0017933859,
0.0109275328,
-0.0121344235,
-0.0657810718,
-0.0208936203,
-0.0249360837,
-0.0615282543,
0.0010449961,
-0.0371494554,
0.0051417723,
-0.0492144935,
0.0353281945,
0.0182421226,
-0.0509305298,
-0.0015424989,
-0.0537937619,
0.0105650621,
-0.0413745306,
0.050419841,
0.0307326615,
0.0435319841,
-0.0114303734,
0.0177665614,
-0.0203579143,
-0.0047118855,
-0.0464549325,
-0.0076525589,
-0.0024150263,
0.055296585,
0.0085791899,
0.0257278327,
0.0671102628,
0.0067315935,
0.0554556735,
-0.0252895188,
0.0099334205,
-0.0328606851,
0.0104161818,
0.0033777747,
0.0217481516,
-0.0051105064,
0.0023767035,
-0.0546381027,
-0.0017471279,
-0.0003911142,
-0.025332192,
0.0636381954,
0.0171737298,
-0.0078749601,
-0.0434257239,
-0.0010508298,
-0.0002103723,
-0.0043511358,
0.0530466549,
0.012930695,
-0.0294343345,
-0.0122086331,
-0.0012310557,
-0.0157055836,
0.0043805232,
0.015420639,
-0.1108084768,
-0.0534154028,
0.0253617894,
-0.0433273651,
0.0374321043,
-0.0504252054,
0.0257915519,
0.0852780789,
0.0135476468,
0.0053825509,
-0.0290716328,
-0.0143684689,
-0.0037308102,
-0.0241420884,
-0.0170690641,
-5.84539435e-33,
-0.0481879562,
-0.0520860776,
0.0047961688,
-0.0263062939,
-0.00562221,
-0.0184879471,
-0.0021583042,
-0.0221540276,
-0.001882189,
-0.0136617338,
-0.0113115581,
0.0485499166,
-0.0015249756,
-0.013240004,
0.0021435891,
-0.0129335411,
0.0429715328,
0.0297413655,
-0.0187747646,
-0.0272741877,
0.0250089951,
0.0004780289,
0.0382102989,
-0.0687501803,
0.08460401,
-0.0027145734,
-0.021316139,
-0.0063720988,
0.0045782323,
0.0272894129,
-0.0541172884,
0.0598753467,
0.0340399556,
0.0155022861,
0.0382495746,
0.0619437844,
-0.0386871323,
0.0044610905,
0.0528744981,
0.0265400466,
0.0431303009,
-0.0180840269,
0.0457281657,
-0.001736325,
-0.0677491501,
0.0235311929,
0.0347262546,
-0.0026031274,
-0.0067779054,
0.0049457913,
-0.0477512702,
0.0406865478,
-0.0026380143,
0.0018726172,
-0.0123351542,
0.0251817629,
0.0174063817,
0.001309408,
-0.0676013976,
-0.0121986689,
-0.0077520958,
-0.0078125261,
0.0434048809,
0.0098273419,
0.0229885802,
0.0422642417,
-0.0001553599,
0.0070401556,
-0.0141407698,
-0.0182932299,
0.0537695177,
-0.0139291417,
0.0004667293,
0.0288420338,
-0.0085830148,
-0.0619136058,
0.0193214603,
0.0085215494,
0.0484009497,
0.0230622645,
0.0216447879,
0.001955224,
-0.0597073771,
-0.0468314365,
-0.0185604077,
-0.0344605148,
-0.0063048056,
-0.0388125554,
0.0369682126,
-0.0558994263,
-0.0696562231,
0.035589084,
-0.0016363238,
-0.0142528825,
-0.0171429813,
0.008791822,
0.0119220121,
-0.0402603298,
0.0294932798,
0.0591791309,
-0.0471098796,
0.0130917504,
-0.0229041297,
0.018037891,
0.0334791392,
0.0000996167,
-0.040777985,
0.0271151587,
-0.0738177598,
0.0051617865,
-0.0038856494,
0.0359358005,
-0.02481056,
0.0617360137,
0.0176463444,
0.0490776226,
-0.0074271308,
0.0231513567,
0.0850325823,
-0.0122200819,
-0.0381349362,
-0.0045097559,
-0.0162013657,
0.0284723435,
-0.0380336717,
-0.0327867605,
-0.0315861441,
0.03931804,
0.0513027199,
-0.0482269861,
0.0172648579,
-0.02400833,
2.663e-7,
0.0219865739,
0.0537968837,
-0.0100927791,
0.0527547598,
-0.0158835892,
0.0058435341,
0.0045944513,
-0.0028857763,
0.0039533144,
0.0013028237,
-0.031511806,
0.0614592507,
0.0298879277,
0.0398178473,
-0.0120162312,
-0.0180216655,
-0.0559382401,
0.055533696,
-0.0491373539,
0.0326429605,
-0.037445765,
0.0873799771,
0.0853530541,
-0.0134086413,
-0.0546382256,
-0.0388586968,
0.0089087738,
-0.0206308067,
-0.0188177396,
0.0192614533,
0.0447575711,
0.02549202,
0.0350310728,
-0.0216969345,
0.0198980141,
0.0009240713,
0.0246783793,
0.0459136553,
-0.0103825741,
0.0507643223,
-0.0096075283,
-0.0401734039,
-0.0414425395,
-0.0614720508,
0.048851788,
0.0191062372,
0.0031170582,
-0.0418340378,
-0.0387036391,
-0.0174486265,
0.019473698,
-0.0297190603,
-0.0370407999,
0.0063823303,
0.0178628974,
-0.0458506346,
0.0120707657,
-0.0529026277,
0.0059278528,
-0.0334964432,
0.0270491783,
-0.0419712365,
-0.0146397222,
0.0172423255,
-0.0141284261,
0.0122487927,
0.0212564655,
2.041097626e-34,
0.0519548431,
0.0117874024,
-0.0064194663,
-0.0284838602,
0.0719128177,
0.019111257,
-0.0194067545,
0.0053335922,
0.0225322675,
-0.0046595535,
0.0194761716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17774v1 | Words, Subwords, and Morphemes: What Really Matters in the Surprisal-Reading Time Relationship? | 2023-10-26T20:55:29 | 2023-10-26T20:55:29 | Sathvik Nair, Philip Resnik | cs.CL | cs.CL | An important assumption that comes with using LLMs on psycholinguistic data
has gone unverified. LLM-based predictions are based on subword tokenization,
not decomposition of words into morphemes. Does that matter? We carefully test
this by comparing surprisal estimates using orthographic, morphological, and
BPE tokenization against reading time data. Our results replicate previous
findings and provide evidence that in the aggregate, predictions using BPE
tokenization do not suffer relative to morphological and orthographic
segmentation. However, a finer-grained analysis points to potential issues with
relying on BPE-based tokenization, as well as providing promising results
involving morphologically-aware surprisal estimates and suggesting a new method
for evaluating morphological prediction. | [
0.0011839854,
0.0556351021,
-0.018580813,
0.0459574945,
-0.0666010156,
0.0010071518,
0.0558738299,
0.0477361307,
-0.0484499373,
-0.0185316112,
-0.0199164189,
-0.1026530415,
0.0547600314,
-0.0172484666,
0.0489238352,
-0.0338931531,
0.0534644499,
-0.015920952,
-0.0030150961,
0.020537477,
0.008622068,
0.0206024144,
-0.0064641563,
0.0121045075,
-0.0102451639,
0.0095089376,
0.0138945058,
-0.0180373248,
-0.0101081282,
-0.0105449632,
-0.0442003421,
0.0104470877,
-0.0212990232,
0.0087222783,
0.000001437,
-0.0869653225,
-0.0022879199,
0.0084037678,
0.0001096293,
0.0132137267,
0.0761262327,
-0.036154516,
-0.0050711078,
-0.0025063988,
0.0058459044,
0.0207281243,
0.017142728,
-0.0040645655,
-0.0669481829,
-0.0018494647,
-0.0158570167,
-0.0318404473,
0.0583130941,
0.0069258981,
0.0045196144,
0.0380340144,
0.0168211497,
-0.0467986092,
-0.0197465122,
-0.0394541956,
-0.0492839627,
0.0303849,
-0.0280216075,
0.0672714785,
-0.0159917418,
0.0181704294,
0.0297728069,
-0.0293235593,
-0.0112427091,
0.0023247676,
-0.0122847715,
-0.00272555,
0.0101566324,
0.0011038037,
-0.0296806414,
0.012605398,
-0.0043554311,
0.027966002,
-0.0232703034,
0.0174304247,
0.0723668635,
0.0228738263,
0.0084527396,
-0.0210012663,
-0.027475521,
0.108465232,
0.0470220484,
-0.060698837,
0.0282555725,
-0.0157704465,
-0.0257917214,
0.0037808954,
0.0177756548,
-0.0251406245,
-0.0083511779,
0.0610322468,
0.0110613657,
-0.0127364723,
0.0203968752,
0.0129343299,
0.0368501358,
0.0101800291,
-0.0201224629,
-0.0169601943,
-0.0391308144,
0.0149673866,
0.0149054201,
0.0156866163,
-0.0669752434,
-0.0125487931,
0.0199205317,
-0.0051200357,
0.0139946863,
0.0027700088,
-0.0196464788,
0.0166829489,
-0.095081158,
0.0033120397,
0.0627233163,
-0.0487390496,
0.0297393966,
-0.0182252694,
-0.0485104434,
-0.0005000683,
-0.0421224944,
0.0142737813,
-0.018075088,
0.0094613638,
-0.0364056453,
-0.0397890545,
0.0238625258,
0.0268803313,
-0.0141164241,
-0.0151819102,
0.0080794394,
0.0891695619,
-0.0420981795,
-0.0792956576,
-0.0439399853,
-0.0535540432,
-0.0717165396,
-0.0210081581,
0.0021652286,
-0.0570178293,
-0.0047057918,
0.0142157059,
-0.0365888849,
-0.0005893047,
-0.0342289172,
-0.0064239712,
-0.0262909401,
0.0650543347,
-0.0149346655,
0.0223260187,
-0.0245875344,
0.0119512109,
0.017522065,
0.0307691731,
0.0422920436,
-0.0185626745,
0.0429471508,
-0.0203937665,
-0.0301318597,
0.0706996843,
-0.0152192088,
-0.0198048092,
-0.0424705781,
-0.0544872917,
-0.0037823368,
0.0137602612,
0.0607894473,
0.0409225561,
0.0127813267,
-0.038738016,
0.0026886119,
0.1482065171,
-0.0075200605,
0.0335115008,
0.0253495984,
0.0393868499,
0.0145027433,
0.0401701145,
0.0247057024,
-0.0338374861,
-0.0409240723,
0.045225393,
-0.0292410199,
0.0336670205,
0.0298019256,
-0.0158535894,
-0.04010465,
0.0000809168,
-0.0064053037,
-0.0093063144,
0.0259294305,
-0.0028031673,
-0.0576310977,
0.0423755124,
0.0447287746,
-0.0278630666,
0.0159562621,
-0.0128443148,
-0.0315942802,
0.0474471338,
0.026793303,
-0.0340215154,
-0.0076683499,
0.051855363,
-0.0124276197,
0.0496193916,
-0.0487441532,
-0.0014831251,
0.0246862397,
-0.0345963612,
0.0316866413,
0.0555097871,
-0.0017417149,
-0.0109781539,
-0.019080691,
0.025806861,
-0.0122349914,
-0.069695875,
0.0010743822,
0.0353281908,
-0.0842855498,
-0.0234156214,
-0.0344134308,
0.018042624,
0.0171735846,
0.000620252,
0.0048392895,
0.0340497643,
0.0050850874,
-0.012479634,
0.0583235249,
0.0437743366,
-0.0514013581,
-0.0225025434,
0.0412340164,
0.0253494661,
0.0201285761,
-0.0416912436,
0.0638933852,
-0.0214997567,
0.0110505298,
-0.0343815796,
0.0986926928,
-0.0278558135,
0.0703720152,
-0.0248979647,
0.0100903669,
-0.0562644973,
0.0056199832,
-0.0404591672,
0.0417898521,
0.0084477663,
-0.0295888465,
-0.0120060286,
-0.0057821292,
-0.0248224624,
0.0089231012,
0.0053778109,
-0.0494914502,
-0.0268928241,
-0.0351658352,
-0.0546470918,
-0.0359019898,
-0.0836137906,
-0.0251253061,
0.0000887706,
0.0579155982,
-0.0010274603,
-0.0076828501,
-0.0464336351,
0.0308177825,
0.001929039,
-0.0009749159,
0.0015731797,
0.0305885598,
0.0353260115,
-0.0178752784,
-0.0287608914,
-0.043112535,
-0.0369549096,
-0.0397348031,
0.0227019899,
-0.0248931609,
-0.0504102856,
-0.0226875842,
0.0416984633,
-0.0320839137,
-0.0083254324,
-0.0227371622,
-0.039195355,
0.0349375345,
-0.002255809,
0.1298696399,
-0.0060836747,
0.0019333343,
-0.0031427687,
0.0388474539,
-0.0738516152,
-0.0237479676,
-0.053567566,
-0.0150468722,
-0.0078177629,
-0.0483654812,
-0.0860445648,
0.0047720666,
0.094501026,
0.0242444631,
0.0009925397,
-0.0030769641,
-0.0015339399,
-0.0445777439,
-0.0543314181,
0.0214242842,
0.0154888025,
-0.0676845685,
0.0369710289,
-0.0166855752,
-0.045936659,
0.0603818893,
-0.0603486709,
-0.0050314278,
-0.0422611572,
-0.0185245369,
-0.0224737208,
0.0196554326,
-0.0075323228,
-0.0051977579,
-0.0020493213,
-0.0800849497,
-0.0542299226,
-0.0118406881,
-0.0185905918,
-0.0025037427,
0.0432932898,
-0.0481563359,
-0.0380952321,
0.0455632694,
0.0240128227,
-0.0049764635,
-0.0291084088,
-0.023132477,
0.02502211,
0.0273273531,
-0.0287776962,
0.002095924,
-0.0098648909,
-0.0120765558,
-0.0127843088,
-0.0166442972,
0.0040959707,
-0.0139052263,
0.0126236165,
0.0315288529,
-0.0092884153,
-0.0034551125,
-0.0302393399,
-0.0181300361,
-0.0041823671,
-0.0104839271,
-0.0084395325,
0.0223931335,
-0.0001713184,
0.0262751654,
-0.0500531085,
-0.0248844437,
0.0088845249,
0.0152865844,
-0.0133320019,
-0.0001929299,
0.0990903974,
0.0473482236,
-0.012032412,
0.0172862336,
-0.0259795059,
0.0350182205,
0.0139603103,
-0.0272214487,
0.0319274589,
0.0051225671,
0.0018212051,
0.0390414074,
-0.0118499156,
-0.0337397754,
-0.0222529322,
-0.0454192571,
0.0066309301,
0.004647979,
-0.0458997376,
0.0325441696,
0.0047789463,
0.0204360988,
0.0225962549,
0.0204681326,
0.0226053894,
-0.0612616464,
0.0172206108,
0.0455166511,
-0.0867969245,
0.0092104636,
-0.0033557913,
-0.0267079528,
-0.0136373406,
0.0031125713,
0.036794249,
-0.0513124205,
-0.0596897788,
0.0641240254,
-0.0062324596,
0.0222935807,
-0.021734532,
0.0265897065,
0.010598762,
0.0194315854,
-0.0530038625,
-0.0057038707,
0.0210089497,
-0.0132162599,
-0.0084632477,
0.0528615564,
0.0229539108,
-0.032294441,
-0.0125973476,
0.0367005058,
-0.0239184257,
0.0465508066,
0.0211958904,
-0.0220225751,
-0.0265645348,
0.0476804003,
0.0112563586,
0.0224179048,
-0.0459023081,
-0.0242751464,
-0.0321679972,
0.0138804615,
-0.0733841956,
-0.0417570695,
0.0210680924,
0.0542421117,
0.0147556225,
0.0252343304,
-0.0206919126,
-0.0251725987,
-0.0733129457,
-0.0051734452,
0.0351877809,
0.0013351752,
-0.1044048518,
0.0151654724,
0.0637914613,
-0.0134844994,
-0.0128734866,
-0.0326387696,
-0.0519125797,
-0.0472868644,
0.0419323295,
-0.0415518545,
0.0215815678,
-0.0100185117,
0.0294013824,
-0.0504049622,
0.1084119752,
0.0200803876,
0.0407289155,
0.0445283391,
-0.0060200309,
0.0605117455,
0.0138081927,
0.0117571866,
0.0335275866,
-0.0073733144,
0.0193806794,
0.001741124,
-0.0064376518,
-0.0033166155,
-0.0283869077,
0.0473190844,
0.0533830523,
-0.0487203524,
0.024094237,
-0.0375466757,
-0.0363130532,
-0.0049419771,
0.0578130111,
0.0141934343,
-0.0097445725,
0.032402128,
-0.0082742171,
-0.0699355006,
0.0146139078,
-0.072536312,
-0.0226624701,
-0.0001827532,
0.0306115616,
0.0067317821,
-0.0150307082,
-0.0004193482,
0.0400873125,
0.0191172622,
-0.0004940341,
-0.0621307641,
0.0346792005,
0.0061190072,
0.0243539084,
-0.0386169516,
0.0163808595,
-0.0519608743,
0.0261904672,
0.0091621289,
0.0063942848,
0.0062852376,
0.0421135128,
-0.0310774911,
-0.0301639587,
0.0475557335,
-0.0629521981,
0.0362190381,
-0.0216334108,
0.02689646,
-0.0432403609,
-0.003321182,
0.0414642096,
-0.0070270789,
-0.0390669741,
-0.0272421148,
0.063927792,
0.0508648567,
-0.0271400847,
0.0174756125,
-0.0505528152,
-0.0303983539,
-0.0329393297,
0.0010664687,
0.0310573541,
-0.0370016918,
-0.0212267656,
-0.0970250741,
-0.0501371659,
0.0506365933,
-0.0150632411,
0.0232125241,
0.0073371143,
-0.0116615174,
0.0417390987,
-0.0142340008,
-0.030502094,
-0.0049839602,
0.0241806563,
0.0288166665,
-0.0289549194,
0.0115181161,
-5.074605439e-33,
-0.0084121395,
-0.0384991206,
0.0034317172,
0.01699619,
-0.003831482,
0.0329141319,
0.0052008596,
0.0474797413,
0.038031105,
-0.0274515543,
-0.0148068834,
0.0057729436,
0.0276420079,
-0.016380202,
0.0303952731,
-0.0038905311,
-0.0033303425,
-0.0250878986,
0.0075536021,
-0.0644416735,
0.0292871203,
0.0439722426,
0.1214405298,
-0.0139131304,
0.0548249707,
0.0260446109,
0.0304883886,
-0.0114140082,
0.0089578498,
0.0198661983,
-0.0312392414,
0.0758202821,
0.0309057105,
0.0490710028,
-0.0259015281,
0.0042805057,
-0.0343947634,
0.0001555266,
0.098927483,
0.0210265052,
-0.0696829483,
0.0083151823,
0.0546746328,
-0.0225374028,
-0.0304719526,
0.0008143652,
0.0185255893,
-0.0241050739,
-0.0143454596,
0.0022448525,
-0.0723136067,
0.0029040948,
0.0338532999,
0.0484656431,
0.091232352,
-0.0178927202,
0.0307372492,
0.0017255348,
-0.0159847271,
-0.0007869064,
0.0249034017,
0.0580838807,
0.0448351726,
0.0260150097,
0.0018884793,
0.0397573449,
0.0887242481,
0.0058247978,
0.0771354288,
0.0164230131,
0.1112167686,
0.0107571715,
-0.0091443863,
0.0201231614,
0.0511650369,
-0.0152338194,
0.0238912143,
-0.0117720477,
0.073863782,
-0.0219132472,
0.01757426,
-0.0010379025,
-0.0408035889,
-0.0443043448,
-0.0008661113,
-0.0240576454,
-0.0057640723,
-0.0135268699,
0.0130454171,
-0.046993006,
0.0228369478,
0.0245657172,
0.0381917506,
0.018363053,
-0.0189561285,
-0.0421746969,
-0.0201358367,
0.046428673,
-0.0232809465,
0.0228181127,
-0.0542816408,
0.0019436958,
-0.0094297165,
0.0168465879,
0.007482029,
-0.0173868146,
-0.0390591808,
-0.0374409705,
-0.0642502233,
-0.0109831756,
-0.0114840185,
-0.0129493177,
0.0149641121,
-0.0043874737,
0.0566806085,
-0.0128924586,
0.0001417875,
0.0038612182,
0.0441034511,
-0.0115578035,
-0.0219659097,
0.0386079028,
-0.0351810455,
0.0267828256,
-0.0204786099,
0.0206393115,
0.0367433019,
0.0098802345,
0.0396861993,
0.0063217222,
0.0026795634,
0.018036535,
2.244e-7,
0.0420815684,
0.0817898884,
0.0260720998,
0.0123991147,
0.0104021877,
-0.0310382023,
0.0092710191,
0.016671272,
0.0156340431,
-0.0278504919,
0.018208649,
-0.0312701389,
0.0393776819,
0.0198218357,
-0.0631649718,
-0.0274091456,
-0.0247461684,
0.037724521,
-0.0881704241,
0.0325402059,
0.0238630902,
0.0276126508,
-0.0207628515,
-0.0379039198,
-0.0262555052,
0.0113480939,
0.0074768621,
-0.0533872657,
-0.0223079938,
0.0344395712,
0.0496620797,
0.0007032233,
0.0494650006,
0.0361590423,
0.0094336029,
0.0132908281,
0.0316588208,
-0.0238697305,
0.0038763182,
-0.0296336394,
0.0247529503,
-0.0050431592,
-0.0471084863,
-0.0163646601,
0.0308170803,
0.0247591324,
-0.0234251041,
0.0037423747,
-0.0240907595,
0.0436474346,
0.0033523885,
0.0072236946,
-0.0143369753,
0.0364719108,
0.0311435033,
-0.0496152639,
-0.0249210056,
-0.0226322059,
-0.0065945894,
0.0557418503,
-0.0303601827,
-0.0545233972,
-0.0111094266,
0.042520836,
0.0207994785,
-0.0972048417,
-0.0451836102,
2.168996692e-34,
0.0002359576,
0.0198960174,
0.0587226935,
0.0119330222,
-0.0057845144,
-0.0026303066,
0.0490586534,
0.0316417255,
-0.0164642185,
-0.0636245087,
-0.0189491771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17770v1 | GROOViST: A Metric for Grounding Objects in Visual Storytelling | 2023-10-26T20:27:16 | 2023-10-26T20:27:16 | Aditya K Surikuchi, Sandro Pezzelle, Raquel Fernández | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | A proper evaluation of stories generated for a sequence of images -- the task
commonly referred to as visual storytelling -- must consider multiple aspects,
such as coherence, grammatical correctness, and visual grounding. In this work,
we focus on evaluating the degree of grounding, that is, the extent to which a
story is about the entities shown in the images. We analyze current metrics,
both designed for this purpose and for general vision-text alignment. Given
their observed shortcomings, we propose a novel evaluation tool, GROOViST, that
accounts for cross-modal dependencies, temporal misalignments (the fact that
the order in which entities appear in the story and the image sequence may not
match), and human intuitions on visual grounding. An additional advantage of
GROOViST is its modular design, where the contribution of each component can be
assessed and interpreted individually. | [
0.0070849494,
0.0142139997,
-0.001002709,
0.0060743731,
-0.0206525419,
0.0104176458,
-0.0239237901,
0.0141166802,
0.0080469307,
-0.0360444784,
0.0116823167,
-0.0047517093,
0.0609766208,
0.0609820075,
-0.0018794733,
-0.0941924378,
-0.0160812717,
0.0282951891,
-0.0006734315,
0.0461517274,
0.0287990104,
0.0279189572,
-0.0221958291,
0.0415916257,
-0.0645940006,
-0.0340802558,
-0.0127752451,
0.0269498937,
0.0705310777,
-0.0489270277,
-0.0551421419,
0.0051890928,
0.0303790737,
-0.012414746,
0.0000020012,
-0.0255710557,
0.0068426761,
-0.009013352,
0.0534929894,
0.0012969431,
-0.0246141646,
-0.0231173951,
0.0014452232,
-0.0458947346,
-0.021747265,
0.0184036214,
0.0692287013,
0.0775988623,
0.0445266105,
0.0526250154,
-0.022254562,
-0.0246830918,
-0.0135241132,
0.0202640761,
0.0413399972,
0.0286186766,
-0.0415443331,
0.0649054497,
0.0125368508,
-0.0432373621,
-0.0586893521,
0.0301379804,
0.0117470939,
-0.0047945981,
-0.0047503593,
0.0608041957,
-0.0141855665,
-0.0081895627,
-0.0187788829,
0.0822118968,
0.0369651578,
-0.0066582025,
-0.0017513765,
-0.0262522828,
-0.0149413263,
0.0382185392,
-0.0476653129,
0.0218485706,
-0.0270334072,
0.0232474059,
-0.0454133525,
0.0378200077,
-0.0161382444,
-0.0250427611,
0.0494334735,
-0.0005672975,
0.0210427381,
0.0164621715,
-0.0326722711,
0.0354238227,
-0.023138253,
-0.0828253701,
0.0129447719,
0.0085318526,
0.0013685238,
0.0046851113,
-0.0349550098,
0.0206168629,
-0.0176834464,
-0.062248826,
0.0327679478,
0.018462766,
-0.0423373394,
0.0496796668,
0.0037981709,
0.1022255197,
-0.011552806,
-0.0154056018,
-0.0231931396,
0.0487858169,
-0.0434779413,
0.012036154,
-0.0068465117,
-0.0026831804,
-0.0495991185,
-0.0651146621,
-0.0148206977,
0.0165274609,
-0.0288574193,
0.0052732783,
-0.041396305,
0.0233093593,
-0.001467392,
0.0233487953,
-0.0446629599,
0.0449510925,
-0.0514035299,
0.0039524897,
-0.0265496392,
-0.0040782779,
-0.0100095635,
0.0100009516,
0.0138271591,
0.0018368699,
-0.0283371359,
0.0325547755,
-0.0162012707,
-0.0069921408,
-0.0512077808,
-0.0561625659,
-0.0196954571,
-0.0412724428,
-0.0207031071,
-0.0422428437,
0.0110770483,
-0.014362515,
0.041965887,
-0.0206355881,
0.0022274568,
0.0083834976,
-0.0006596732,
0.0287556481,
0.0169633236,
0.0088764578,
-0.0159608237,
0.0250302088,
0.0158957075,
0.0244862027,
0.0723071694,
0.0512710065,
0.0514829084,
0.005044634,
0.0109141953,
-0.0099758273,
-0.0375650823,
-0.0078964531,
-0.0231766086,
-0.0003993948,
-0.029865928,
0.0614441857,
-0.0077512972,
0.0198190715,
-0.0155840553,
0.0207264964,
0.1118999496,
0.0667016953,
0.0034770726,
-0.0229688976,
0.0605757572,
-0.0242596921,
-0.0223898292,
0.0991063938,
-0.00811077,
0.0562016815,
0.0227873772,
0.0324793197,
-0.0195408724,
0.0412207209,
-0.026121337,
-0.0203938074,
0.0110534457,
0.0274968389,
0.002612876,
-0.0374875553,
-0.0369439386,
0.0026960087,
-0.0736649409,
-0.0180142503,
-0.014831041,
-0.0949488133,
0.0322970301,
0.0670727342,
0.0514967963,
0.0537024476,
0.0501232035,
0.0314405635,
-0.0086269649,
-0.0122217564,
0.0483791567,
0.0385028869,
-0.0250226501,
0.0032859284,
0.0220494233,
-0.026979845,
-0.0146586606,
-0.0264310185,
-0.0119000636,
0.0016249142,
-0.0379412286,
0.0511847548,
0.0002788427,
-0.0394914635,
-0.0109726638,
0.048568055,
0.0191376861,
0.0468088873,
-0.0784009025,
0.051223442,
-0.0160664693,
0.0185823962,
-0.0393095575,
-0.0087782955,
0.0052285003,
0.0070253299,
0.004759707,
0.0809600055,
-0.0455787145,
-0.0113249794,
0.0067168381,
-0.146876201,
-0.0061708754,
-0.0220566653,
0.0196637604,
-0.0223328583,
0.0161700342,
-0.0640604794,
0.0095885685,
-0.0161508862,
0.0106969085,
-0.0140878838,
-0.0026472972,
-0.0170698371,
0.0698471516,
0.0087526198,
0.0230124798,
-0.0545993596,
-0.0156649314,
0.0200774446,
-0.029444145,
0.0236465149,
0.025088964,
0.0358432606,
-0.0084642079,
0.0380961224,
-0.0230874419,
-0.0679858178,
-0.02146779,
-0.1044116914,
-0.0083526066,
0.0073532211,
-0.0075915493,
0.0239614937,
-0.0203647241,
-0.0327511579,
-0.0156949535,
-0.0229181275,
0.0320055112,
-0.0204324536,
-0.0260037594,
0.0400929786,
0.0151631664,
-0.0192683004,
-0.0197465941,
0.0331767835,
-0.0101676108,
0.0732664317,
0.0823280662,
-0.0415331796,
-0.0720465109,
0.0247382969,
-0.033370588,
-0.0143928928,
0.020892702,
-0.0210733805,
0.0235271808,
0.0744413063,
0.0561567992,
0.0525394864,
0.0196475368,
0.0101204468,
0.02618788,
-0.0699620545,
-0.0068604313,
-0.0139743946,
0.0062179733,
0.0175875649,
0.0023343356,
-0.0611283854,
0.009668177,
0.0276782028,
0.0057740011,
0.0438241027,
-0.0659102201,
0.0066381348,
0.0166423097,
0.0013500408,
-0.0008602515,
-0.0294356626,
0.0063421624,
0.0519542396,
-0.0357347764,
-0.0449412353,
0.0673797578,
-0.0841787606,
-0.0040476043,
0.042307172,
0.0302667376,
-0.0550758466,
0.0801606029,
0.0113762962,
0.0390772074,
0.0329092555,
-0.0139135532,
-0.0620167442,
0.0007606861,
0.0483946018,
0.0144469431,
0.022897467,
-0.0382253937,
-0.0061383159,
0.0207662564,
-0.0113595352,
-0.0183844753,
0.0025041518,
0.0028487919,
-0.0370655283,
-0.0103541315,
-0.0204082504,
-0.0863387585,
0.0601278171,
0.0131606618,
-0.0147555722,
-0.0082293907,
-0.0144634563,
-0.0180904754,
0.0236544069,
0.0484952368,
0.0243279319,
-0.0085886242,
-0.0195870586,
0.0315798633,
0.0392296165,
-0.0151066668,
0.0082059707,
-0.0193260387,
0.0592702292,
-0.0112994239,
-0.0003262183,
-0.0241053607,
-0.0023327668,
0.0813742876,
-0.0455831178,
-0.01409961,
0.075178355,
0.0079288669,
-0.0085529853,
0.0084250718,
0.0211195517,
-0.008722988,
0.0275148153,
-0.0050630062,
-0.0357885063,
-0.0061254581,
0.0083174584,
-0.0177921243,
0.0309041496,
-0.0559058301,
-0.0197868608,
-0.0602176152,
0.0627099499,
0.0179883782,
-0.013938196,
-0.0668128431,
-0.0218620207,
0.0275330395,
0.0172302909,
-0.0314431004,
-0.0170736387,
-0.0205074288,
0.0069414582,
-0.016909603,
0.0109765055,
0.0196443312,
-0.0394349173,
-0.050686501,
-0.0191250984,
0.0388983488,
0.0433169194,
0.0280986,
-0.0759485215,
-0.0668430328,
0.0087934574,
0.0173018891,
0.016784275,
0.0447904654,
-0.0627407283,
-0.0369821005,
-0.0238094293,
0.0208426565,
0.0574539229,
-0.032610476,
-0.0032581026,
0.0309087541,
-0.0211863909,
-0.0013194802,
-0.0143258348,
0.044977501,
0.0061123697,
0.0337790512,
0.0826252475,
-0.0001501025,
-0.0152770067,
0.0100785615,
0.0688657463,
-0.0303789433,
-0.0323946178,
0.0087067448,
-0.0244904272,
0.0097125322,
-0.0974776,
-0.0349815339,
0.0102592865,
0.0622529425,
0.0373183787,
-0.018196756,
-0.0068345605,
-0.0106261028,
-0.0759726241,
0.0593608543,
0.0225701854,
0.0321546793,
-0.0413634405,
0.0427393429,
-0.0234321952,
-0.0100833261,
-0.0092886547,
0.0297479648,
-0.0341625363,
-0.0240632221,
-0.0376317352,
-0.0074042161,
0.0140663851,
-0.0042000143,
0.0515945889,
-0.0045220824,
-0.0012647373,
0.0048956666,
-0.0336167663,
0.0530929379,
-0.054559648,
-0.0265381634,
-0.0025867883,
-0.0063800304,
-0.0272980947,
-0.030379463,
-0.0188475251,
0.0567731187,
0.0000912035,
0.0078652566,
0.012805732,
-0.0126987323,
0.0239028074,
-0.0481564403,
0.0008959157,
-0.0415380895,
-0.0298181996,
-0.0160285123,
-0.0235575605,
-0.0564379171,
0.004317285,
0.0074733673,
0.028767623,
-0.0074540433,
0.0492499806,
-0.0639158413,
0.0072911307,
-0.0509015806,
-0.0355066992,
0.0246461667,
-0.0440902449,
-0.0432957783,
0.0166770052,
-0.0068985499,
-0.0210692324,
-0.0392409451,
0.054116752,
-0.0077894437,
0.0311533194,
0.0389781408,
0.0032142764,
-0.0192081369,
0.0420532115,
-0.0220224503,
0.0252130758,
-0.0196511243,
0.0431505069,
0.0568377115,
-0.0233817622,
0.0632151216,
0.0066747996,
0.0134279653,
0.0323148407,
0.0209707264,
0.0086040515,
-0.0153874215,
-0.031643346,
0.0285727549,
-0.0002345375,
0.0270125661,
0.045196183,
-0.0384931564,
0.0094133345,
-0.014184338,
-0.0474859439,
-0.0183952618,
-0.0084904134,
0.0149736712,
0.0058356081,
0.0233332943,
-0.0006232294,
-0.0858995169,
-0.0402600393,
0.0088932384,
0.0256374478,
0.0141281132,
0.028905917,
0.0509723462,
0.0131369093,
0.0082774553,
0.0226954259,
0.008092775,
-0.0346609019,
-0.0308032893,
0.0176266227,
-0.0265329983,
-5.993273743e-33,
-0.0764668807,
-0.0599249601,
0.0014718476,
0.0237520747,
-0.0834528506,
0.0461423509,
-0.0262138471,
0.0280806068,
0.0299273357,
0.0484326445,
0.0607272349,
-0.0223924853,
0.0053528748,
-0.0215769894,
-0.033855956,
0.022107726,
0.0291443281,
0.0210857242,
-0.0874019489,
-0.0223502014,
0.0446693711,
0.0170156844,
0.0418571793,
-0.0818521753,
0.0015362654,
-0.0081947157,
-0.0379524343,
-0.0260789115,
0.0771757886,
0.0355808586,
0.0130049791,
0.0012091529,
-0.0000558951,
0.0014148718,
-0.0062431288,
0.0488647185,
-0.026657192,
-0.04733086,
0.0572386719,
0.0295068566,
-0.0401338078,
0.0107359504,
0.0312298704,
-0.0212553106,
-0.0039307298,
-0.0336590745,
0.0729360208,
0.006698838,
0.0600485392,
0.0287629291,
-0.0511577427,
-0.0133993849,
-0.0681541488,
-0.0783890411,
0.0115783243,
0.0069771372,
0.0379661731,
0.0224958099,
-0.006830099,
0.0354539454,
-0.070176512,
0.0195632596,
0.0550135039,
0.0057445331,
-0.0148036294,
0.1214619875,
0.0117222127,
-0.0243473109,
-0.0730552599,
0.0254266113,
0.0056206365,
0.026761096,
0.0356347039,
0.0200704057,
-0.0018865392,
0.0401852429,
-0.0620161034,
0.0602122359,
-0.0543597341,
0.0654096529,
0.0032076715,
0.0156474877,
-0.0228095967,
0.0141810384,
-0.0150183141,
-0.0659973174,
-0.0193708502,
-0.0395451188,
0.0159354582,
-0.014407008,
-0.0007268402,
0.0292779487,
0.0107434485,
0.00544084,
0.0277196281,
0.0121103134,
-0.0346273854,
0.0550500527,
0.0068373908,
-0.0126154497,
0.0151592726,
-0.0133443838,
0.0628850982,
0.0540349111,
0.079586871,
-0.0486093387,
0.0151430173,
0.009334893,
-0.0268392134,
-0.0123855015,
-0.0131474333,
-0.0306706689,
-0.028740108,
-0.0442591757,
0.0274466779,
-0.0087391492,
-0.0573585853,
-0.0129619092,
0.0050669028,
-0.017678665,
-0.0060120448,
-0.0756039023,
-0.0515750535,
0.0197139252,
-0.0311460812,
0.0203702636,
-0.0020129709,
-0.0320233069,
0.0293503404,
-0.0421305485,
-0.0370530486,
0.0358742699,
2.712e-7,
0.0015074206,
0.0148149822,
0.054956276,
-0.0063694431,
-0.0080469623,
0.0307104345,
-0.0234821085,
0.012132531,
-0.0271234885,
-0.1033769995,
0.021378886,
0.0035128994,
0.0401360951,
-0.0042662569,
-0.0333921388,
0.0429716669,
-0.0470130295,
-0.02655112,
-0.0425684862,
-0.0016925873,
0.0530415401,
-0.0463291928,
0.0188158583,
0.0048449459,
0.0213111732,
-0.0549224243,
0.0383390076,
-0.0211838428,
-0.0337486528,
-0.0143515477,
-0.0365647599,
-0.0028928695,
-0.0326868221,
0.002134006,
0.0064467727,
0.0085383337,
0.0724546015,
-0.0123765431,
-0.048250854,
0.0241995603,
-0.0477607772,
0.0242478698,
-0.022662187,
-0.0257130172,
0.0360983014,
-0.0066577671,
-0.0322268605,
0.0084249433,
-0.0081410091,
-0.0002383648,
0.035621684,
-0.0038613887,
-0.0554840229,
0.0393794999,
0.0376308858,
0.0050308709,
-0.0355636626,
-0.0344419517,
-0.0193715561,
0.0144320047,
0.012029944,
-0.0162094049,
-0.0112184947,
-0.0235019494,
-0.0048912596,
-0.0291808899,
-0.0379447117,
2.296114467e-34,
-0.0064012911,
0.0165626127,
0.0031684767,
0.0036495004,
0.0486763045,
0.0028002125,
-0.036426276,
-0.0143642565,
-0.002025729,
-0.0158576015,
-0.0202689543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17769v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17769v2 | Social Contract AI: Aligning AI Assistants with Implicit Group Norms | 2023-10-26T20:27:03 | 2023-12-03T17:42:33 | Jan-Philipp Fränken, Sam Kwok, Peixuan Ye, Kanishk Gandhi, Dilip Arumugam, Jared Moore, Alex Tamkin, Tobias Gerstenberg, Noah D. Goodman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We explore the idea of aligning an AI assistant by inverting a model of
users' (unknown) preferences from observed interactions. To validate our
proposal, we run proof-of-concept simulations in the economic ultimatum game,
formalizing user preferences as policies that guide the actions of simulated
players. We find that the AI assistant accurately aligns its behavior to match
standard policies from the economic literature (e.g., selfish, altruistic).
However, the assistant's learned policies lack robustness and exhibit limited
generalization in an out-of-distribution setting when confronted with a
currency (e.g., grams of medicine) that was not included in the assistant's
training distribution. Additionally, we find that when there is inconsistency
in the relationship between language use and an unknown policy (e.g., an
altruistic policy combined with rude language), the assistant's learning of the
policy is slowed. Overall, our preliminary results suggest that developing
simulation frameworks in which AI assistants need to infer preferences from
diverse users can provide a valuable approach for studying practical alignment
questions. | [
0.0435058773,
0.0714550316,
-0.0284768101,
-0.0114820441,
-0.0385678634,
-0.0111575145,
0.0105620278,
-0.0091462415,
0.0614444166,
0.0330250598,
0.0122667113,
-0.0085290931,
-0.0195003673,
0.0137926852,
0.0152966399,
-0.0259147212,
0.0418616608,
0.0080439774,
0.0838942751,
-0.0512357652,
0.026446905,
-0.0131015796,
-0.0017056705,
0.0123468582,
-0.0387060083,
0.0034199813,
-0.0230801087,
-0.0389483869,
0.0420454703,
-0.002988887,
0.0234671645,
0.0216002204,
0.0197090879,
0.019301733,
0.0000022293,
-0.0932754949,
-0.0240801834,
-0.0152454423,
-0.0074668243,
-0.039590735,
0.03551073,
-0.0130381845,
0.0234337691,
-0.0030218347,
-0.1011288986,
0.0628631786,
0.0633066818,
0.0045897551,
0.023857465,
0.0246166736,
-0.0006406375,
0.0035142989,
-0.0184860155,
-0.0294811334,
-0.0242311638,
-0.0710900575,
0.0282880291,
-0.0435994267,
-0.0200938713,
-0.0452498049,
0.0015235438,
-0.0200067256,
-0.0055254507,
-0.0032526439,
0.0175737552,
0.0271105897,
-0.0313019417,
-0.0272345878,
-0.0571272559,
0.0547860786,
0.0327798873,
0.0172041133,
0.0376077481,
-0.0210743211,
0.0255716573,
0.0140780509,
0.015817713,
-0.0072379224,
-0.0087069422,
0.0203260835,
0.0370452255,
0.0320402421,
0.0210434459,
0.0220562629,
-0.0070732599,
0.0832188278,
-0.0259754341,
-0.0129670026,
-0.0034742279,
0.0102139171,
-0.057949435,
-0.0534309186,
-0.009950974,
0.0300698485,
-0.0895655155,
0.0098905563,
-0.0244898479,
0.0568091944,
0.0177691691,
-0.0201241039,
0.05411743,
0.0495908223,
0.0197984837,
0.0381060168,
0.0452267639,
0.0542803556,
-0.03373532,
0.015198594,
0.0018038852,
0.0290594194,
-0.0093060387,
-0.0139380218,
-0.0338260345,
0.0253241621,
0.010322989,
0.0093749976,
-0.0035216864,
0.0041468395,
-0.1060713008,
0.0669951662,
0.0217017774,
0.0475810766,
-0.0207119882,
-0.0166112613,
-0.0932461396,
-0.020855194,
-0.0810022205,
0.0175648965,
0.0194187872,
0.0278087836,
0.0029121973,
-0.0353996158,
-0.0195904784,
-0.0090502957,
0.0230624434,
0.1139852107,
0.0123597113,
0.0250731558,
0.0284244493,
-0.0215065796,
0.0140230469,
-0.0609928668,
-0.0048840242,
-0.0538173802,
0.0712000579,
-0.0071108527,
-0.0352828689,
-0.0815796703,
-0.009758926,
-0.0297954716,
-0.051190529,
0.0741211474,
0.0575163625,
0.0097985948,
0.0098605733,
-0.011047028,
-0.042438522,
0.0236547124,
0.011964622,
-0.0091216369,
0.0269523188,
-0.0104241911,
0.0198341701,
0.0395343117,
0.0099075828,
0.0079702362,
0.0039352668,
0.0115660708,
-0.0063436693,
0.0443359055,
0.0117473621,
0.0219784416,
-0.005089948,
-0.0718339235,
0.0505835116,
0.0772868469,
-0.0223106239,
0.0142542887,
-0.0083993543,
0.0210819952,
-0.0151368603,
0.0452921055,
-0.0500848517,
0.0332055651,
-0.0023646881,
-0.0070777498,
-0.0478678681,
0.0383545905,
-0.0318167843,
-0.0137323299,
0.0276463497,
-0.0316409655,
0.0614637919,
0.0209622812,
-0.0142803891,
-0.0141561739,
-0.0272572823,
-0.045945704,
0.0466827191,
-0.0194325987,
-0.034798231,
-0.045960255,
0.060942445,
0.0672181249,
0.0553672016,
-0.0301723275,
0.0196302533,
-0.0111222696,
-0.0364852287,
0.0684686154,
0.0701896921,
-0.0387136042,
-0.0353290215,
-0.0461160354,
-0.0298856888,
0.0404183343,
-0.0002656226,
0.0650081858,
0.0442927368,
-0.0146977929,
-0.0466305539,
0.0305886995,
0.007340197,
0.0289620459,
-0.0183891784,
-0.0402749144,
-0.0143210962,
0.0253787916,
0.043833036,
-0.003417728,
0.0191975366,
-0.0084069679,
-0.0089235706,
0.0161632877,
-0.0016305749,
0.0353333764,
-0.0469574258,
0.069988884,
0.0328381211,
-0.0239544101,
-0.0338908955,
0.0286599882,
-0.000176133,
0.0204079878,
0.0329534858,
0.01705979,
0.0233361144,
-0.0015918963,
-0.0009529111,
-0.0169221275,
-0.0024492529,
-0.0053187632,
0.0229224302,
0.0048935125,
-0.073687166,
-0.0193186104,
-0.0389924496,
0.0101344036,
-0.0515825786,
0.0263460837,
-0.0276984386,
0.0047675231,
0.0416135825,
0.0652956516,
0.0034957782,
0.0090382528,
-0.0038350699,
-0.0333896875,
-0.0116423666,
0.0156694222,
-0.0126931649,
-0.0079160854,
-0.006718257,
0.0052196104,
-0.0230237488,
-0.0556411371,
0.0525095053,
0.0190034844,
0.0191468205,
0.0610114783,
-0.0139520587,
-0.0257081557,
-0.0544038452,
0.0117873019,
-0.0546771772,
-0.0271674953,
0.0053229546,
0.0297075268,
-0.0151384948,
-0.0549724363,
-0.0629587919,
0.048605483,
-0.0224357899,
-0.0619591959,
0.0287360437,
0.0333749354,
0.0320198722,
0.0772197396,
0.0094472375,
0.0574826449,
0.0615710244,
0.039513655,
-0.0689560473,
0.0042358334,
-0.0455606095,
-0.0016460562,
-0.0411359146,
-0.0522034951,
-0.0397480838,
0.1139229164,
0.0003049635,
0.0133290794,
-0.0434622355,
0.0499290787,
0.0331756473,
-0.0502828546,
-0.0139603615,
-0.0168315787,
-0.0171666238,
0.0201566815,
-0.0225592609,
-0.0476256572,
0.1065102816,
0.0325376354,
0.0243643988,
0.0136456694,
-0.0229181033,
-0.0172632001,
0.0273214895,
0.0071497709,
0.0019629307,
-0.0220550839,
0.042431239,
-0.062207032,
-0.0445334278,
0.0534598678,
-0.0071887062,
0.0362481959,
-0.0446752161,
-0.000578315,
0.0130784949,
-0.0254233796,
-0.0188141391,
-0.0764995366,
-0.0058110575,
0.0284086093,
0.052614633,
-0.040001411,
0.0162319411,
-0.0165027827,
0.0178849809,
0.0126789296,
0.007558302,
-0.0019289532,
-0.0298264176,
-0.0534973629,
0.051944349,
0.0189191774,
-0.0212645233,
-0.006973071,
-0.0121980263,
-0.0068085911,
-0.0012303089,
-0.0497497767,
-0.0058251675,
0.0254886802,
-0.0068887132,
-0.0072455327,
0.0593666434,
0.0443585552,
-0.0173210111,
0.0126993405,
0.0132655473,
0.0459859818,
0.0281452741,
-0.0297335442,
0.0466481149,
-0.009225551,
0.0373857096,
0.011095712,
0.0394554324,
-0.0877874196,
0.0155580994,
-0.0224271305,
0.0399263799,
-0.0338259563,
-0.0716871768,
0.0025520925,
-0.0614380389,
-0.0135905761,
0.0028955725,
-0.0157063194,
0.0230503548,
-0.0111193415,
-0.0014641065,
-0.0669175312,
0.0149678867,
-0.0373197943,
0.051989127,
-0.0378050543,
-0.004803332,
0.0205617715,
0.0594610497,
0.0181268677,
-0.0671118647,
0.0705918372,
0.0660378709,
0.0576399639,
-0.0080456296,
-0.0320515595,
-0.0463710539,
0.0872379392,
-0.0140335038,
0.0435760133,
0.0147213629,
0.0008211882,
0.0038348862,
0.0045273905,
0.0273867678,
-0.0133776115,
-0.0173345823,
0.0345544219,
0.0268726237,
0.0030327486,
-0.0510041118,
0.005618785,
-0.02271365,
0.0467404723,
0.0605541542,
-0.0355532318,
-0.038334623,
-0.0268585347,
-0.0316265672,
-0.0376564898,
0.0059820479,
-0.0258928593,
-0.0230794232,
-0.0118586496,
-0.0437633581,
-0.0309451185,
-0.0736674592,
-0.0283552613,
0.0120703774,
0.0353642367,
-0.091361165,
0.0525229163,
-0.0127497176,
0.0234268419,
-0.0244790912,
-0.0121001694,
0.0041582785,
0.02106327,
-0.0236338526,
-0.0527155437,
-0.0424118601,
-0.0219250415,
-0.0146929594,
0.0301374681,
-0.0649438277,
0.0655428767,
0.0655015856,
0.0268711708,
0.0508525036,
-0.0139235165,
0.039437063,
-0.0031426142,
0.0482224263,
-0.0167829469,
0.0339176133,
0.0257090982,
-0.014078794,
0.0003245467,
0.0157263465,
-0.0310609341,
0.0316844769,
-0.0010321399,
0.0002214051,
-0.0963723287,
-0.0549168102,
0.0481657796,
-0.0093991533,
-0.0342338346,
-0.0151553201,
-0.0151035665,
0.0014200945,
-0.012532522,
0.0030945891,
-0.0247833617,
0.0210209247,
-0.1216668114,
0.0249739736,
-0.0076640057,
0.0260296408,
0.022316359,
-0.0170220211,
0.0063977498,
0.0162816979,
0.009927812,
0.0308364611,
0.0498826392,
0.0092780106,
-0.0058592143,
0.0134309959,
0.0235414114,
-0.0091441497,
0.0240599401,
0.0129569238,
0.0342403762,
0.0434313901,
-0.0056049307,
-0.0098803947,
0.0057641496,
-0.0151352389,
-0.0784921572,
0.0206007566,
-0.0061020134,
-0.0397791043,
-0.0781314448,
0.0117007988,
-0.052707538,
0.0089576691,
0.0135155171,
0.0142843602,
-0.024137482,
-0.0367049128,
0.0123007083,
0.0054795686,
-0.0267591961,
0.041515965,
0.0534355938,
-0.0363251753,
0.0373983346,
-0.0613671951,
0.0129567906,
-0.0240390617,
-0.0335450992,
0.0338122956,
-0.0303013045,
-0.0195671096,
-0.0283667892,
-0.0605418272,
-0.0189425126,
-0.0719136149,
0.0397170335,
-0.0387719795,
-0.0131669175,
0.0134918811,
0.0390396044,
-0.0398591198,
0.0120491264,
0.0067394939,
0.0195849985,
-0.0783785954,
-0.0157812163,
-0.0343026444,
-5.914583213e-33,
0.0021638605,
-0.0452811755,
0.0219509061,
-0.0023023661,
0.0261791926,
-0.0364774019,
-0.0262232926,
-0.0216318443,
-0.0296641439,
0.0106100896,
-0.0229375288,
-0.0045413012,
0.0128663145,
-0.0557488054,
0.0327030756,
-0.0101601174,
-0.0188379362,
-0.0369401462,
-0.0271210168,
-0.0349891745,
-0.0128706899,
-0.0089243911,
0.0147741837,
-0.0649759024,
0.0390402712,
0.0100242179,
-0.0354856066,
0.0009935374,
-0.0323497131,
0.0269281007,
0.0002974526,
-0.0134975296,
-0.0086341668,
0.0018434454,
0.0191154666,
0.0394978486,
-0.0321068354,
-0.0396599919,
0.0074878018,
-0.036480315,
-0.0319351219,
-0.0389106683,
-0.023797065,
0.0141896131,
-0.074872449,
0.018458195,
0.0384560339,
0.0077633145,
0.0294108056,
0.0670054406,
-0.0710111335,
-0.0172512401,
-0.0551158972,
-0.0268886127,
-0.000369963,
0.0195826441,
0.0011129066,
0.0209126323,
-0.0238737501,
0.0677764714,
-0.0402362049,
-0.0410149731,
0.0574486144,
-0.0286288969,
0.0347780138,
0.0309831537,
-0.0166253354,
0.019509986,
-0.0398827903,
-0.052031152,
-0.0051527056,
0.0312368907,
0.0172588732,
0.0605341196,
-0.0029953711,
-0.0376786105,
0.0191027448,
0.0405222885,
0.0780390948,
-0.0067121722,
-0.006890513,
0.0294459667,
-0.0703233033,
-0.0179025587,
-0.0096512949,
-0.0525236018,
-0.0132575771,
-0.063684769,
0.0074393526,
-0.0014276797,
0.012552619,
0.0085060829,
-0.0052568335,
-0.0418161303,
-0.0338651054,
-0.0033213599,
0.0233220402,
-0.0000332907,
0.0199691616,
-0.0267901756,
-0.1070113704,
-0.0318053439,
-0.0408997014,
0.0145392669,
0.0491411388,
0.0749640763,
0.0280228332,
0.0324482732,
-0.0001880961,
0.0180420037,
-0.0008020196,
0.0206172559,
0.0245555863,
-0.0537052266,
0.03206072,
0.0021422803,
-0.0006157883,
-0.0102507947,
0.0051000533,
-0.0244573243,
-0.0373319983,
0.012999055,
-0.0388323106,
0.0335517302,
0.0015483806,
0.0289975386,
-0.0346344374,
0.0547282882,
0.0073125637,
0.0019048436,
-0.0111815566,
-0.0410783812,
2.817e-7,
-0.026288392,
0.0405951031,
0.0539247245,
0.0207020827,
-0.0219921954,
0.0870558396,
-0.0327303857,
0.0637824535,
-0.0342664905,
-0.028504489,
0.0646630973,
0.0333109498,
0.0307122301,
0.0206540078,
-0.0248549078,
0.0316936262,
-0.0660888106,
-0.0236501396,
-0.0160115622,
-0.0014892595,
-0.0228254851,
0.0090728682,
0.0329845585,
0.0121208122,
-0.0093974192,
0.0108291581,
0.0056094988,
-0.0505946167,
-0.0106006125,
-0.013843067,
-0.0444679707,
-0.0577403083,
-0.0042222319,
0.0188188348,
0.0078014815,
0.0205006544,
-0.0342603251,
0.0505741574,
-0.0322772041,
-0.0159892142,
-0.0325331353,
-0.0238675475,
0.0176846571,
-0.0300048683,
0.0020339144,
-0.0191587079,
-0.0405913144,
-0.008940882,
0.013056457,
0.0205108263,
-0.0025123619,
0.0151473451,
0.0361722447,
-0.0204561148,
0.0148594566,
0.0424693078,
0.0302707125,
-0.0030661037,
-0.0193207618,
0.0284808669,
0.0038221995,
-0.024575796,
0.0165205207,
0.0824593753,
0.0078713484,
-0.0542096756,
0.02107458,
2.07752188e-34,
-0.031930998,
0.0272653438,
0.0255979281,
0.0172358323,
0.0379963741,
-0.0011918297,
0.0238676723,
0.0562081002,
0.0786212459,
0.0098608853,
-0.0055436837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17750v1 | A Framework for Automated Measurement of Responsible AI Harms in Generative AI Applications | 2023-10-26T19:45:06 | 2023-10-26T19:45:06 | Ahmed Magooda, Alec Helyar, Kyle Jackson, David Sullivan, Chad Atalla, Emily Sheng, Dan Vann, Richard Edgar, Hamid Palangi, Roman Lutz, Hongliang Kong, Vincent Yun, Eslam Kamal, Federico Zarfati, Hanna Wallach, Sarah Bird, Mei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a framework for the automated measurement of responsible AI (RAI)
metrics for large language models (LLMs) and associated products and services.
Our framework for automatically measuring harms from LLMs builds on existing
technical and sociotechnical expertise and leverages the capabilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs, such as GPT-4. We use this framework to run through
several case studies investigating how different LLMs may violate a range of
RAI-related principles. The framework may be employed alongside domain-specific
sociotechnical expertise to create measurements for new harm areas in the
future. By implementing this framework, we aim to enable more advanced harm
measurement efforts and further the responsible use of LLMs. | [
0.013484491,
0.0994794816,
-0.0522273816,
0.0318596959,
-0.03597546,
0.0114433076,
0.0293013025,
-0.0039953291,
0.0330687091,
-0.0164116006,
-0.0116680181,
-0.0141747613,
0.0228311308,
0.0355927087,
0.0226965174,
0.0053855381,
0.0336818881,
-0.0124119855,
0.0192256067,
0.0036500727,
0.0151839117,
0.0433749743,
0.0219584573,
0.0734184086,
-0.0466185063,
-0.0426987819,
0.037421383,
0.0085523762,
0.0441188887,
-0.0131093264,
-0.0082956254,
0.0192463323,
0.0028369694,
0.0813203976,
0.0000018138,
-0.0618473031,
-0.0043611666,
0.0429163277,
0.0153741557,
0.0028094486,
0.0470966808,
0.0191276632,
-0.0409472436,
0.0428282954,
-0.0148920985,
0.0403194465,
0.0573656149,
-0.0205055811,
0.0561789572,
0.0566145889,
-0.0305059496,
-0.0082978504,
0.068081677,
-0.0005955259,
0.0026050133,
-0.017186692,
0.0293947235,
0.0278470311,
-0.0154160121,
-0.0259316657,
0.0111692697,
0.0644169897,
0.0284737665,
-0.0298991334,
-0.0407946743,
-0.0255474374,
-0.0055091069,
-0.0346497372,
0.0330246836,
0.0482470989,
0.0280731451,
0.0072225453,
0.0100290421,
-0.0140737183,
0.0265021268,
-0.0164096802,
-0.0006574966,
0.0563476011,
0.0001084646,
0.0005180674,
0.0138973324,
0.0022217575,
0.0499964878,
0.012036535,
0.0365717374,
0.0485731401,
0.0228655618,
-0.013413108,
-0.0253256895,
-0.0085440725,
-0.0110411691,
-0.0279762298,
-0.0025358479,
0.0000947576,
-0.0493056849,
0.0459974073,
-0.0423749946,
-0.0371204279,
0.0405682139,
-0.0445420295,
0.0236563403,
0.0319096856,
-0.0088989092,
0.0139678316,
0.0251731295,
0.0565904751,
-0.0085671106,
0.0229102205,
-0.0107054096,
0.0262983311,
0.0158376116,
-0.0326344296,
-0.0187812969,
-0.0134884091,
-0.0025407132,
0.0212786049,
-0.0248605348,
0.0474474803,
-0.0982582122,
0.0288703907,
0.0024652302,
-0.0019497785,
-0.0225332305,
0.0015679484,
-0.0020663098,
-0.0278687812,
-0.0590229854,
0.0354819819,
0.0020647659,
-0.0813687742,
0.0195467416,
0.0002520666,
-0.0602712743,
-0.0044825906,
0.0031900487,
0.1154572293,
0.0577536449,
-0.0209025647,
-0.0492255762,
-0.0658280626,
-0.0274604801,
-0.0655984506,
-0.0286087152,
-0.0496300757,
-0.0203179978,
-0.02538638,
-0.0053555029,
-0.1095609367,
0.0029044864,
0.0002839449,
-0.0297113378,
0.0204019789,
-0.0304275155,
0.0299846679,
0.0201408956,
0.0468902029,
-0.0237413067,
0.0738998875,
0.0442595147,
0.0220577139,
0.0470159985,
-0.0043116086,
0.0311583616,
0.0421181992,
-0.0156390611,
0.0206023324,
-0.0403181091,
-0.0062069171,
-0.0534047,
0.0292471908,
-0.0019172396,
0.0846434161,
-0.0136513868,
0.0089570358,
0.0823775828,
0.0610967912,
-0.0460795201,
0.0370913334,
0.0385504812,
-0.0248968881,
-0.0080552008,
-0.0199044906,
-0.0391974859,
0.0003519661,
-0.042896755,
-0.0173269454,
-0.0152901085,
0.0523457862,
-0.015581009,
-0.048243694,
0.0077627352,
-0.0133340023,
0.0248449855,
0.0257079862,
0.0153111834,
0.0171836615,
-0.0040462413,
-0.0204230566,
-0.0141218826,
-0.077396594,
-0.0036128161,
-0.0628897324,
0.0261377655,
0.0788072497,
0.0810364112,
-0.0489078052,
-0.0142098814,
-0.0344500467,
-0.0545434617,
0.0149064632,
-0.0082245711,
-0.0316873752,
-0.0002480861,
0.0185148045,
-0.0075047761,
-0.0096774921,
0.0218465403,
0.0177504029,
0.0214099307,
0.011717598,
0.0093596689,
-0.042191308,
-0.0527962148,
0.0179607794,
-0.0214989353,
-0.0360172838,
-0.0450558513,
0.0198324863,
0.0295216925,
0.0320865028,
-0.0424093343,
-0.007912606,
0.0365711898,
0.0279336479,
-0.0162884817,
0.0274058133,
0.0178095251,
0.0655180886,
0.0479503684,
-0.0429870896,
-0.0179457702,
0.0542624928,
-0.0113906991,
0.0109775951,
0.0164384898,
-0.0453089066,
0.0038963836,
-0.0497816876,
0.0031895218,
-0.0582626797,
-0.0234921668,
-0.0236409158,
0.0299918,
-0.0124077564,
-0.010775229,
0.0221573953,
-0.0242697727,
0.021436872,
0.0047736643,
-0.0818664655,
0.0058801086,
-0.0403581373,
0.0464474745,
0.0505114794,
0.0029967732,
-0.0442432649,
-0.001022412,
-0.0353055559,
-0.0243920609,
-0.0120863654,
0.0214581713,
0.0037679262,
0.0101050772,
-0.0274941977,
0.0105429301,
-0.0196459666,
-0.0428394154,
0.0221821889,
0.0463970751,
0.0078116902,
-0.019934589,
-0.0453720689,
-0.0130144078,
0.0215438027,
-0.0185702015,
0.0144603793,
0.0260296091,
-0.0032091269,
-0.0676668361,
0.0323410109,
-0.0537097678,
-0.0037728606,
0.0083508501,
-0.062314976,
0.0404773243,
0.021195136,
0.0145148113,
0.05887587,
0.0055590291,
0.0640445128,
0.0497477837,
0.0034013838,
-0.0443873927,
-0.0265231226,
0.0360074677,
-0.0503256358,
0.0033351094,
-0.0625416785,
-0.0214911532,
0.0060596508,
-0.0138270603,
-0.0209632441,
-0.0357739143,
0.0417563543,
-0.0831272975,
-0.0780566931,
0.0265272614,
-0.065069221,
-0.0400882848,
0.0253135543,
0.0215964094,
-0.0840372443,
0.03101057,
-0.0264071301,
0.0220020842,
-0.001052988,
0.0055514718,
0.0056539266,
0.0717254356,
-0.0058492562,
0.0504016615,
0.0264463816,
-0.0271102283,
-0.033550851,
0.0432838462,
0.0585636981,
-0.0396252126,
0.0420117155,
-0.0553187169,
-0.0009022653,
0.0038564247,
-0.0197729953,
-0.0293147303,
0.0021283426,
0.0266979933,
0.0093754604,
0.0480432324,
-0.0238335077,
0.0319416076,
-0.0292728022,
0.0167930182,
-0.0168534499,
0.0225162208,
-0.0307307784,
-0.0025962244,
-0.0221821461,
0.0498794876,
-0.0306948293,
0.0375093222,
0.0201903097,
0.002244683,
0.0453665778,
0.0069442037,
-0.0099613946,
-0.0276075602,
-0.002044033,
0.0156861059,
-0.0016097524,
0.0417019688,
0.0519949123,
0.0438742861,
-0.0284231827,
-0.0148857171,
0.0616263673,
0.0072834999,
-0.0439728349,
0.0326231271,
-0.0000618612,
-0.0135199819,
0.0263511837,
0.0110438429,
-0.100302279,
0.0288677327,
0.0167268198,
0.039800521,
-0.0707481056,
-0.0423300304,
0.0158704966,
-0.1000547707,
0.0590979159,
0.0131893102,
-0.0303092375,
-0.0427261516,
-0.0030116183,
-0.0103615364,
-0.0224558543,
0.0443807282,
-0.0402468815,
0.0002832819,
-0.0502382517,
-0.0011438749,
-0.0377684608,
-0.0364902802,
0.0169855431,
-0.0388337895,
0.0831461027,
0.1039241031,
0.0108733494,
-0.0514030159,
-0.0117565542,
-0.0000816178,
0.0484371111,
-0.0198464207,
0.0230780058,
0.0229754932,
0.0262373742,
-0.024483433,
-0.0126336338,
0.0100200186,
-0.0271423981,
-0.0208196249,
-0.0262247641,
0.0662457347,
0.0105309309,
-0.0038228487,
-0.0217335429,
-0.0352712162,
0.0352042764,
0.0616446473,
0.0248013437,
-0.0111469049,
-0.0051939231,
-0.0526788868,
0.0188340228,
-0.0008240555,
-0.0365959667,
-0.0403417237,
0.0138908923,
-0.059151724,
-0.084807232,
-0.0421460606,
-0.021064017,
-0.0039804885,
0.0397997014,
-0.0356181301,
-0.0116827255,
0.0261094756,
-0.0018121942,
0.0057650874,
-0.010093933,
0.0550788492,
-0.0225207042,
0.0127519164,
-0.0320352651,
0.0209837426,
0.0111741163,
0.021782374,
-0.0474634133,
-0.0726486295,
0.056111183,
0.0825087503,
0.0279972311,
-0.0141280685,
-0.0316135138,
-0.0326542258,
0.0418397188,
0.0544363745,
-0.028788574,
0.0317149013,
0.0705604851,
-0.0329467058,
-0.0011967869,
0.0218787063,
-0.0439556614,
-0.0054115541,
0.0133324685,
0.0311799496,
-0.0355943181,
0.0068910993,
0.0159342643,
0.058925923,
-0.0058219237,
-0.0703594312,
0.0248012412,
-0.0258260407,
-0.0324082263,
-0.0398792811,
-0.0371309146,
-0.0348819718,
0.0256523937,
0.0299725942,
-0.0039147357,
-0.0161861274,
0.0188091248,
-0.0335621871,
0.0105644697,
-0.0214432366,
0.0285619292,
0.0092048673,
0.0609605536,
0.0097452141,
0.0105600962,
-0.0143718645,
0.0107951993,
-0.0477743447,
0.0512100682,
0.0094547831,
0.0360804349,
0.0076783495,
0.0414390899,
0.0394011661,
0.0632960871,
0.0018002467,
-0.0708799884,
-0.0183190573,
0.0493212454,
0.0242576227,
0.0266639311,
0.0562725216,
-0.0384437181,
-0.0004989399,
-0.0235331133,
-0.0113288919,
-0.0076986658,
-0.0705650151,
-0.0394118652,
0.012208147,
-0.0252496526,
-0.0264615845,
0.0654855222,
-0.0089062061,
0.0592368692,
-0.030267993,
-0.0226538796,
0.0197424106,
-0.0704824701,
0.0010516731,
-0.0312611759,
-0.0228766091,
-0.0569292456,
-0.0914349705,
-0.114621684,
-0.0668916032,
0.0263796691,
0.0162331406,
-0.0166555457,
-0.0167603698,
0.0595447384,
0.015162251,
0.0218349565,
-0.0387396626,
-0.0239328723,
-0.0662770718,
-0.0113345813,
-0.0156826116,
-5.622347603e-33,
-0.0024920464,
-0.0659427717,
-0.0072974619,
-0.0026943432,
-0.0313589163,
0.008235937,
-0.0349001698,
0.0131748142,
-0.0157665703,
0.0122838439,
-0.0050270674,
0.0080332235,
-0.0097901709,
-0.0305341575,
0.0308443233,
-0.0312504061,
0.0136465076,
0.0086005013,
-0.0476823151,
0.0466616936,
0.0213270411,
-0.0318639576,
0.0176081639,
-0.0803858414,
0.0636093467,
0.006129751,
-0.0463031679,
0.0112908063,
-0.0382493734,
0.045440238,
0.0159071255,
0.071013242,
0.0085520875,
-0.031536568,
0.0148729393,
0.0068755071,
-0.0056671975,
-0.010002845,
0.0087785823,
-0.0114674857,
-0.0197369941,
-0.045085758,
0.0216505378,
-0.0145547045,
-0.0136627024,
-0.0082875183,
0.0198841784,
-0.0348988809,
0.0026419125,
-0.0500219837,
-0.0842408016,
0.0032962658,
-0.0484641939,
0.0085150264,
0.0080404952,
0.0058795512,
0.035889335,
0.0250650905,
-0.0251976978,
-0.0179925859,
-0.0023755094,
-0.0413348228,
0.0839115307,
-0.0185232405,
0.021884013,
0.0634924844,
-0.0063539152,
0.0369936079,
-0.0073287352,
-0.0245480277,
0.009072734,
0.0405696332,
0.0358507894,
0.0537407324,
-0.0140038012,
-0.0342750922,
-0.0126037207,
0.0336684063,
0.0059130522,
0.0404575653,
-0.0000126546,
-0.0229529627,
-0.078641966,
-0.0118803205,
-0.000351439,
-0.036766652,
-0.0197770689,
-0.0332163945,
0.0348512344,
-0.0471553169,
-0.035366796,
-0.0130903954,
-0.0016023515,
-0.0659810007,
0.0367701873,
0.0244011879,
-0.00332902,
0.0016177369,
0.0017602757,
0.0500042215,
0.0008870378,
0.0119968103,
0.0106343785,
0.0064630127,
0.0715305954,
-0.0044305185,
0.0463346355,
0.0641545281,
-0.0179571286,
0.0232658722,
-0.0344637781,
0.0431834497,
0.0035485546,
0.00249107,
0.0147559065,
-0.0007860304,
0.0034452165,
-0.028056128,
0.0737786889,
0.0449592397,
-0.0604881309,
0.0326431952,
-0.0387210958,
-0.0332118273,
-0.0404974669,
-0.0267152432,
-0.0017471367,
0.039408844,
0.0711388588,
-0.0515003279,
-0.0326816104,
-0.0404539295,
2.649e-7,
0.0208287872,
0.0078214668,
0.0161193032,
0.0596129261,
-0.0004767463,
0.0398600101,
0.0239164513,
0.0533787198,
0.0288362671,
0.0214191321,
0.047414422,
-0.0250868276,
0.0557895675,
0.0619267151,
-0.0323512442,
0.0224902518,
-0.0605061129,
0.0144154523,
-0.0441257395,
0.0053569796,
0.0323697589,
0.0196402855,
0.0210378971,
-0.0467797704,
0.01114571,
-0.0310478918,
-0.0037121226,
-0.0392290093,
0.0408647396,
0.0009386843,
0.0244635288,
0.0406468399,
0.0255938545,
-0.0218019094,
-0.0074446183,
-0.0031710775,
-0.0124036139,
0.0297237933,
-0.0167781953,
-0.0093456442,
-0.0260820594,
-0.0598884895,
0.0361662619,
-0.0525850095,
0.0471879765,
0.0262572933,
0.0264251698,
-0.0382313617,
-0.009337482,
-0.0443262495,
0.0411740653,
-0.0444621928,
-0.0176752787,
0.0047973478,
0.0018028346,
-0.0184633769,
0.0266009066,
-0.0453882292,
0.0056809848,
-0.0180136878,
-0.0037973127,
-0.0686520562,
-0.0015508663,
0.0295476131,
-0.0365788676,
-0.0160045754,
0.0503338017,
2.244095628e-34,
-0.0011489649,
-0.050108701,
0.0275573786,
0.0157935582,
0.052753903,
0.0444597714,
-0.0383262187,
-0.0144373504,
-0.0268028043,
-0.0188818369,
-0.0189257059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17749v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17749v1 | Salespeople vs SalesBot: Exploring the Role of Educational Value in Conversational Recommender Systems | 2023-10-26T19:44:06 | 2023-10-26T19:44:06 | Lidiya Murakhovs'ka, Philippe Laban, Tian Xie, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Making big purchases requires consumers to research or consult a salesperson
to gain domain expertise. However, existing conversational recommender systems
(CRS) often overlook users' lack of background knowledge, focusing solely on
gathering preferences. In this work, we define a new problem space for
conversational agents that aim to provide both product recommendations and
educational value through mixed-type mixed-initiative dialog. We introduce
SalesOps, a framework that facilitates the simulation and evaluation of such
systems by leveraging recent advancements in large language models (LLMs). We
build SalesBot and ShopperBot, a pair of LLM-powered agents that can simulate
either side of the framework. A comprehensive human study compares SalesBot
against professional salespeople, revealing that although SalesBot approaches
professional performance in terms of fluency and informativeness, it lags
behind in recommendation quality. We emphasize the distinct limitations both
face in providing truthful information, highlighting the challenges of ensuring
faithfulness in the CRS context. We release our code and make all data
available. | [
0.0676347762,
0.0449592471,
-0.0207803231,
0.0391940325,
-0.0041861096,
-0.0283337049,
0.0409885608,
-0.0161027834,
0.055614382,
-0.0288248509,
-0.0589578524,
0.00207961,
-0.0287807193,
0.0416087322,
-0.0332559273,
-0.0367030948,
0.0017958306,
-0.0560418069,
0.0283365306,
-0.0370432064,
0.0280614439,
0.0235724207,
-0.021164827,
0.0598580167,
0.0192537811,
-0.0487303473,
-0.0201291516,
-0.0255244225,
0.0045033181,
0.0042177774,
0.0538247414,
0.0417573564,
0.0428829677,
0.0292132683,
0.0000021503,
-0.0392331965,
-0.0011868537,
-0.0344421156,
-0.0725961775,
-0.0061935955,
0.0663385987,
0.0685409084,
-0.0028072898,
0.0017770563,
-0.0566838793,
0.043676205,
0.0187815521,
0.0421836823,
0.0309653021,
0.0417641029,
-0.0010176299,
0.0057125846,
-0.0000129966,
-0.0070405933,
0.0318679698,
-0.042349007,
-0.0059207664,
0.0019198924,
0.0452909879,
0.0308582354,
0.0123760067,
-0.0053691482,
-0.001025344,
-0.055446215,
0.010356863,
0.0376663953,
-0.0343279094,
-0.0227794331,
-0.0134687712,
0.0820524693,
0.0180381853,
0.0073886113,
-0.0087384116,
0.0214474555,
0.0226753317,
0.0039354707,
-0.0323988348,
0.0208445434,
0.0135031966,
0.0144279953,
-0.0457444191,
0.0112609984,
0.0104700318,
0.0361194648,
0.0201357175,
0.0768829361,
-0.0113225309,
-0.0171662476,
0.0061171101,
-0.0036576686,
0.0429283865,
-0.056576658,
0.0096232109,
0.0210837927,
-0.1023128629,
0.0015529728,
0.0076858844,
0.0676683262,
-0.000191825,
-0.076193504,
-0.0062082927,
0.0116427355,
0.0072124093,
0.0644004568,
0.0217728298,
0.0345265791,
0.0321185179,
0.0241952222,
-0.0345987119,
0.0006170743,
-0.0223700572,
-0.0053761736,
-0.0263959784,
0.0335410386,
-0.0348208025,
-0.0540754497,
-0.0240915995,
0.0149325617,
-0.0255727414,
0.0204804596,
-0.0462523028,
0.049252063,
-0.0067257565,
-0.0182064064,
-0.0971615836,
0.015012945,
-0.0405371524,
0.0223243274,
0.0256679393,
-0.0155281918,
0.0381904319,
0.0338202156,
-0.0218572076,
-0.0068591037,
-0.001079431,
0.0301907472,
0.0030555537,
-0.0227889363,
-0.0301389657,
-0.0142892431,
0.0095288781,
-0.0771481618,
-0.0341033489,
-0.0674340725,
0.0423253179,
0.0237913951,
0.0027026329,
-0.037897978,
0.0288370755,
0.0135194864,
0.0022676156,
0.0699081942,
0.0038357109,
0.0008664042,
0.0205751788,
0.0173684917,
-0.0130853662,
0.0497388579,
0.0320255421,
0.0500326678,
0.0483084284,
0.007268345,
0.0371987894,
0.0339548476,
-0.0533342771,
0.0025035937,
-0.0074873194,
0.0038369226,
-0.0168827698,
0.031758707,
0.0113402065,
0.037622951,
-0.0610898696,
0.0229712892,
0.0844494179,
0.0239426158,
-0.0286378693,
0.0067736753,
0.0332120769,
0.0766989961,
0.020565616,
-0.0332820565,
-0.0165530816,
0.017610468,
-0.0193402432,
-0.0395672061,
0.0205237661,
-0.0152006466,
-0.0210221838,
-0.0335567743,
0.0600834116,
-0.0335404463,
0.0489292443,
0.0278727319,
0.0104766255,
-0.0275612567,
-0.0281919986,
0.0229859706,
0.0202807728,
-0.0362214893,
-0.0243497901,
-0.0212714132,
0.043379657,
0.148427546,
0.0606382079,
-0.0027717112,
-0.0195937548,
-0.0102867782,
-0.0313015021,
0.0611795895,
0.0464034714,
-0.0384757221,
0.0030216184,
-0.0529484376,
-0.0279386379,
-0.0051706159,
-0.0118087297,
0.0290008262,
-0.0034691209,
-0.001699373,
0.0067109019,
-0.0333323218,
-0.026474135,
-0.03621969,
-0.0293996967,
-0.0172020867,
-0.0101011563,
0.0131369093,
0.0021393001,
0.0049326583,
0.0246923007,
-0.0142042879,
0.0160805862,
-0.0094786482,
-0.0371955,
0.0062586758,
0.0101643102,
-0.0075057046,
0.0282143485,
-0.0158008989,
-0.0309444014,
0.0219715033,
0.0248358268,
-0.0148823103,
-0.0025458317,
-0.0031788656,
0.0511324741,
-0.0117586227,
0.0157678798,
-0.0276756771,
0.0048987116,
-0.0212778579,
0.0437776521,
0.0424116887,
-0.012035381,
0.0540237874,
-0.0240048729,
-0.0252880976,
-0.0459673963,
0.0095128752,
0.0257271584,
0.0223326534,
0.0356679298,
0.0364159383,
-0.0152143538,
-0.034646485,
-0.0203324705,
-0.0886083394,
-0.0119836628,
0.0233050846,
-0.0323083214,
-0.0355009474,
-0.0001101834,
0.0092352293,
-0.0179586243,
-0.0490948595,
0.0379553735,
-0.0004564179,
0.0096979663,
0.0144523503,
0.0198960695,
-0.0329664797,
-0.0429946817,
0.0345279388,
0.0074644899,
0.0173048489,
0.0435236357,
0.0317413211,
-0.0820839256,
-0.0069691045,
-0.0594782196,
0.0044974149,
-0.0205731019,
-0.0100059556,
0.0170435328,
-0.0154986307,
0.0461643338,
0.0226104613,
0.0241725631,
0.0286051724,
0.047446344,
-0.0306124948,
-0.1086574569,
0.0003670153,
-0.0119557958,
0.0147710033,
-0.080506973,
-0.0176084321,
-0.0033977791,
0.0274633281,
-0.0210800767,
0.0218544547,
-0.0268925838,
0.029950764,
0.0280759949,
-0.0286711901,
-0.0156832244,
0.0018641131,
-0.0359606594,
0.0691180974,
0.005664764,
-0.0311941858,
0.0739803836,
-0.0123490226,
-0.0048676063,
-0.035926424,
-0.042830158,
-0.0525116064,
-0.0122843748,
-0.0172773488,
0.0224242471,
-0.0362074301,
-0.0259493794,
-0.0095141847,
0.0367291495,
0.0344914496,
-0.0472693145,
0.0522529706,
-0.0446817949,
-0.0047703022,
0.0219646096,
-0.0442016944,
-0.0526713766,
-0.0522574,
-0.0384661146,
-0.0234966464,
0.0684744939,
-0.0113180038,
-0.0894569382,
-0.0264292248,
0.032169912,
0.0397270024,
-0.0023222335,
-0.0335712433,
0.0060660131,
-0.0442586765,
0.051109504,
0.0158375967,
0.0080449283,
-0.0333748125,
0.0900547579,
0.0309499241,
0.0199924596,
-0.038702894,
-0.0451135412,
-0.0428130738,
0.0433456823,
0.0173296984,
0.0035690507,
0.0355167091,
-0.0027781669,
-0.0238107275,
0.0029297946,
0.1214292198,
0.0130958911,
-0.0788068473,
0.0223777182,
-0.0477068499,
0.018375678,
0.0159476995,
0.0431650393,
-0.0641084984,
-0.0130164661,
-0.0064200731,
0.0448288731,
0.0093333162,
-0.0249131843,
-0.0053757676,
-0.1072126105,
0.0446291454,
0.0008431699,
0.0072891787,
0.0234323349,
-0.0206067134,
-0.0243858509,
0.012464324,
0.0563335456,
-0.0025364754,
-0.018468773,
-0.0036642954,
-0.000549487,
-0.0123744067,
-0.0096266251,
0.0594225787,
-0.0277828611,
0.0289733391,
0.0860536397,
0.0349922255,
0.0174781624,
-0.0071413522,
-0.0081499042,
0.0579916313,
-0.0283958819,
0.0274721459,
0.027042266,
-0.0239005443,
0.0022782625,
-0.0109964395,
0.0166844148,
-0.0091900863,
0.0027599758,
0.0370461568,
0.0317847989,
-0.014138313,
-0.0219622236,
-0.0055353148,
0.0321884789,
0.0172141716,
0.0669900626,
0.0089626927,
-0.0928478613,
-0.0055992529,
-0.0628214926,
-0.0114796441,
0.0154014928,
-0.0770581737,
0.0046096146,
0.0173405465,
0.0131544424,
-0.0437979437,
-0.0613315925,
0.039122466,
-0.0144951753,
0.0290158466,
-0.0035255039,
0.0087649943,
-0.0133351898,
0.0744465813,
0.0200061668,
-0.0553957559,
0.0449413285,
-0.1147863865,
0.0036824844,
0.0083666565,
-0.0859460384,
-0.0049284557,
-0.0301066935,
-0.0099191675,
-0.0532736741,
-0.0387816429,
0.0424312279,
0.0240894761,
0.0476069488,
-0.0271310825,
-0.0454859063,
-0.0137077067,
0.0622134954,
-0.0750477836,
-0.0282974634,
0.0333041921,
0.0578118823,
0.0020139301,
0.0416742936,
-0.065444231,
0.0092125535,
-0.0234396998,
0.0199742671,
-0.0151858581,
-0.0558161251,
0.0545778237,
0.0031879805,
0.0326833427,
0.0248189699,
0.0488040186,
-0.0189043786,
0.0416091718,
-0.0330080613,
-0.0399762429,
-0.0582782589,
-0.0164556354,
0.0202248022,
-0.0132969292,
0.0400221311,
0.0077316654,
-0.0252566617,
0.0290820338,
-0.0065731173,
0.0239770059,
0.0024456871,
-0.0209284984,
0.0526176468,
-0.0015869343,
-0.0065929359,
0.0279618781,
0.0323487557,
0.0590004697,
0.0198857244,
0.0886285752,
0.0115417754,
-0.0497292913,
0.0131553365,
0.0095786499,
-0.0175425056,
-0.1085384786,
0.0379543751,
0.0315929018,
-0.0258309487,
-0.0088307736,
0.026761055,
-0.051184725,
0.0259100534,
-0.0440026186,
-0.013845779,
-0.0028583971,
-0.0519587286,
0.0212207995,
0.0273180977,
-0.0093360227,
0.0445473716,
0.0812405124,
-0.0380876027,
0.0240289215,
-0.0351894237,
-0.0263791792,
-0.0462924354,
-0.040544305,
-0.0186661072,
0.045212619,
-0.0377823301,
-0.0034474486,
-0.0644526854,
-0.0178310797,
-0.0416785739,
-0.0060125459,
-0.0014586952,
-0.0553273,
0.0349635482,
0.0501039512,
-0.040488936,
0.0273266304,
-0.0642772317,
0.0217859559,
-0.0435552076,
0.0092693279,
-0.0447133929,
-5.928572698e-33,
0.0077150608,
-0.0435232297,
0.0446065068,
0.0134916427,
0.0204907078,
-0.031569574,
-0.0105546201,
0.0313693658,
0.0208223704,
0.0329642296,
-0.010408951,
-0.0098730372,
0.008352818,
0.0153880846,
0.0220246259,
-0.0289481226,
0.0625462905,
0.0285752118,
-0.0521612428,
0.0412809178,
0.0239772722,
0.0097156251,
0.002129429,
-0.0418843478,
0.0354828797,
-0.0330035426,
-0.0055287457,
0.0226549413,
0.0002716086,
0.0665979013,
-0.0064038383,
0.0664500892,
-0.0146569051,
-0.0430077016,
0.0058929031,
0.0137209846,
-0.027539799,
0.0165706594,
0.0379051454,
0.0072706835,
-0.0212118868,
-0.0229207594,
-0.0058946018,
-0.0314523801,
-0.0080702668,
0.044471249,
0.0276005138,
-0.043668095,
0.0079180785,
0.0391889885,
-0.0742104724,
-0.0060757548,
-0.0350346938,
-0.0474365018,
0.0268220771,
0.0902130976,
-0.022229882,
0.0169503503,
-0.0114121782,
0.074086532,
-0.0152889648,
-0.0150886923,
0.0291911233,
-0.0247571487,
-0.0402640849,
0.0783398151,
0.0260154791,
0.0064596105,
0.0002457859,
-0.0234096013,
-0.0129402326,
0.0794145316,
0.0119331656,
0.0472285673,
-0.0257197153,
0.0249213278,
0.0233870763,
0.0357663073,
0.0765440241,
-0.0169839542,
-0.0143112494,
0.0203722399,
-0.0436891392,
-0.029077746,
-0.0132015087,
0.0228714515,
-0.0444802195,
-0.0518988296,
0.0321735665,
0.0189395864,
-0.0116489651,
-0.0266925078,
0.0141896354,
-0.0445341617,
-0.0683839396,
0.0057532233,
-0.0136787323,
-0.01915038,
0.0033880032,
0.0028007466,
-0.0635284111,
-0.0184572395,
0.0215472281,
-0.0389106534,
-0.0117348433,
0.0460337736,
-0.0057868785,
0.004855101,
-0.0248418953,
0.0008037894,
-0.0162637308,
-0.007837208,
-0.0163000356,
-0.0096956408,
0.0233588256,
0.0000539002,
-0.0312693305,
0.0522914082,
-0.024740316,
-0.0119191529,
-0.0179348569,
-0.06786374,
-0.0112838736,
-0.009701577,
-0.0472909994,
-0.0107817054,
-0.0458209924,
-0.0164330341,
0.013256643,
-0.0566466115,
-0.0205409154,
-0.0371456333,
2.862e-7,
-0.0229943357,
0.0730734691,
-0.0462962687,
0.0153071098,
0.0059530232,
0.060040649,
0.0065308698,
0.0164449234,
0.0274550598,
-0.0166182201,
0.007124464,
0.0193626042,
0.0362818912,
0.0185914841,
-0.108080633,
-0.032192342,
-0.0127289584,
-0.0267021749,
-0.0701603964,
-0.0399710685,
0.0086730579,
0.0481366515,
0.0427353121,
-0.0037212232,
-0.0040342938,
-0.0110897776,
0.0453887545,
-0.0710103288,
-0.0158423614,
0.0210088342,
0.0051321452,
-0.0059779873,
0.0003473631,
0.0087313801,
-0.0065990472,
0.0235235654,
0.0244006962,
0.0572164319,
0.030776009,
-0.0089259008,
0.009333726,
-0.024686059,
-0.0162621345,
-0.0166305881,
0.0492364839,
-0.0272654872,
-0.0225747172,
-0.0252317395,
-0.0486093685,
-0.0337074362,
-0.0143190073,
-0.0467928909,
-0.0267492868,
-0.0066974261,
-0.0095080789,
-0.0241443273,
0.0080034751,
-0.0018409613,
0.0247567389,
-0.0320248716,
-0.0439585708,
-0.0666246787,
-0.0132894283,
0.0200313199,
-0.0121362461,
-0.0299683325,
0.0570381954,
2.165695206e-34,
0.0515695289,
0.0343929082,
-0.0011011332,
0.029168684,
0.0570730381,
0.0138333114,
-0.0002256238,
0.0043296567,
0.0372302309,
-0.0429450795,
-0.0074763768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17743v2 | StyleBART: Decorate Pretrained Model with Style Adapters for Unsupervised Stylistic Headline Generation | 2023-10-26T19:31:22 | 2023-11-13T06:38:53 | Hanqing Wang, Yajing Luo, Boya Xiong, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stylistic headline generation is the task to generate a headline that not
only summarizes the content of an article, but also reflects a desired style
that attracts users. As style-specific article-headline pairs are scarce,
previous researches focus on unsupervised approaches with a standard headline
generation dataset and mono-style corpora. In this work, we follow this line
and propose StyleBART, an unsupervised approach for stylistic headline
generation. Our method decorates the pretrained BART model with adapters that
are responsible for different styles and allows the generation of headlines
with diverse styles by simply switching the adapters. Different from previous
works, StyleBART separates the task of style learning and headline generation,
making it possible to freely combine the base model and the style adapters
during inference. We further propose an inverse paraphrasing task to enhance
the style adapters. Extensive automatic and human evaluations show that
StyleBART achieves new state-of-the-art performance in the unsupervised
stylistic headline generation task, producing high-quality headlines with the
desired style. | [
0.0511339195,
0.0535133034,
-0.0027674076,
0.0068061082,
-0.0243690293,
0.0028667676,
-0.0020410561,
0.0024353028,
0.00436243,
0.005344796,
-0.0309208594,
0.0066144611,
-0.0355270132,
0.0123586878,
0.0230842009,
-0.0793375373,
-0.0167244319,
-0.0146656223,
0.0106511526,
-0.0033446969,
0.0588679239,
0.04058256,
0.0195363127,
0.0158952679,
-0.0047944873,
-0.0266509224,
-0.0297128987,
0.0458719395,
-0.0135917719,
0.018138459,
0.0732788146,
0.0843199268,
0.000959866,
0.025753364,
0.0000015595,
0.0042101853,
0.0016095033,
-0.0343665071,
0.0733299032,
0.0109872324,
0.0557134114,
-0.0079338318,
0.005578876,
0.0047944975,
-0.0267857332,
-0.0081821335,
0.0296626575,
0.062760368,
0.0999093354,
0.0792670026,
-0.021020703,
-0.0959831327,
-0.010630561,
-0.0426680557,
-0.0026743929,
-0.0182064176,
-0.0138750644,
-0.0267245602,
-0.0377205834,
0.0324515551,
-0.007854824,
0.0181843154,
0.0132654179,
-0.0200604238,
0.0068320157,
-0.0074646468,
-0.0756253749,
0.005252786,
0.0021107162,
0.0790409893,
-0.0133501384,
-0.0705414861,
0.021695856,
-0.003295806,
0.0034737617,
0.012699631,
-0.0659506693,
0.0062012863,
-0.0030508561,
0.0055936929,
-0.0242940877,
0.0380596481,
-0.02539864,
0.0044106925,
-0.0097390767,
-0.0116825849,
0.027209267,
0.0108299907,
-0.0315684602,
0.0192550216,
-0.0073566018,
-0.0730940253,
0.0227133706,
0.0222283155,
-0.0274237934,
-0.0034693747,
-0.0780371651,
-0.0530986935,
-0.0120257456,
-0.0399284475,
0.0720364824,
-0.0114102429,
0.0221773218,
0.0166072678,
-0.0327896066,
-0.0219398402,
-0.0503024869,
-0.0045845443,
-0.0447235741,
0.0192291103,
-0.0441375412,
-0.0254893191,
-0.049027551,
-0.0076536215,
-0.0142929414,
-0.0405792594,
-0.0019547215,
0.008336667,
0.0347247384,
-0.0328472331,
0.0112334546,
0.0351774804,
-0.0598030649,
-0.0220790785,
0.0381248854,
0.0050122095,
-0.0230034627,
-0.021192167,
0.0311420653,
0.0305476319,
-0.0244627688,
0.037888445,
0.0183212534,
-0.0157038104,
0.0023357365,
0.0271137133,
-0.0670737624,
0.0029829803,
-0.0332413651,
-0.0277194995,
-0.0003553875,
-0.0335941352,
0.0166664422,
-0.0546022728,
0.0206063855,
-0.0074614184,
-0.0047177197,
-0.0320823267,
0.0023134989,
0.0255886074,
-0.0248110518,
0.0104624443,
0.0108060632,
-0.0036647893,
0.0060441047,
-0.0092276558,
0.0564597361,
0.0503240637,
0.0370687246,
0.1071633399,
0.0187243,
0.018923752,
0.0154379103,
0.0379285924,
0.0499282107,
-0.0054148552,
-0.0118738282,
-0.0425794534,
-0.0282874592,
0.0490271375,
0.0406915471,
0.0318983123,
-0.0082203373,
-0.0006164867,
0.084914878,
-0.0432207659,
0.0653203949,
0.0608120337,
0.0824969262,
0.0267800782,
0.0285654832,
0.038961079,
0.030089695,
0.0070667365,
-0.0374673232,
0.0644344166,
-0.0201063268,
0.0338123515,
-0.0458371751,
-0.0237281304,
0.0399606638,
0.0212954096,
-0.0407536998,
-0.0215375479,
0.0073401215,
0.0792774782,
-0.0537719615,
0.0054584048,
0.0049840277,
-0.0631881133,
-0.0049101277,
-0.013266244,
0.0191732775,
0.0767920166,
0.0467683375,
0.0205107238,
-0.016918676,
0.020302454,
0.0356660374,
0.0532574914,
0.0237333477,
-0.0231120642,
-0.0014808154,
-0.0421656817,
-0.0130970264,
-0.043354895,
0.0002299634,
0.0303808693,
0.0044252914,
-0.0028703734,
0.0261556711,
-0.0092364829,
-0.075230509,
0.0453142747,
-0.0184322167,
-0.0366340615,
0.026832968,
0.0008175729,
-0.0335312933,
0.0038685165,
-0.0260533858,
0.0062849689,
-0.0290565379,
-0.0543610528,
-0.0200848598,
0.0615958795,
-0.0385096036,
-0.0540484749,
-0.0290253945,
-0.0624075159,
-0.004136635,
0.0137127722,
-0.0356085934,
-0.0863907486,
-0.0009082769,
-0.0394105799,
0.0030832456,
-0.0401644111,
-0.0135986982,
-0.0037577196,
-0.0009560951,
-0.0320713073,
0.0485360026,
0.040159706,
-0.0364735462,
-0.0000170209,
0.0004527797,
-0.0019489847,
0.014872604,
-0.020006625,
-0.0417964347,
0.0341985375,
-0.0078862077,
0.0238033608,
0.0336337797,
-0.01165637,
-0.0340082794,
-0.0787959099,
-0.0007334956,
-0.0413522199,
0.0014723742,
0.0579595715,
0.02928905,
-0.0391544923,
-0.0372500829,
-0.0355880819,
-0.0147220576,
-0.0139407422,
0.0065147765,
0.0490197949,
0.0012408189,
0.0215088818,
-0.0366352834,
-0.0256966949,
0.002318677,
0.0434761569,
0.0401856415,
-0.0021048153,
-0.0340206176,
-0.00793292,
0.0036846283,
-0.033807721,
0.0145528857,
-0.0342906006,
0.0097352583,
-0.0420385152,
0.075892657,
0.0766486004,
0.0829102099,
0.0101448279,
0.0043970076,
0.013147884,
-0.0124576502,
-0.0021375527,
-0.0437802859,
-0.0054532797,
0.0164776612,
-0.041426748,
0.0739196017,
0.0405627899,
0.0146921901,
0.0095400279,
-0.0446679257,
0.0443702526,
0.045136936,
-0.0167021751,
0.0199290328,
0.0399976298,
-0.0074856188,
0.0499999039,
-0.0000306453,
-0.005273859,
0.0373963416,
-0.0225360151,
-0.0008013701,
-0.0000257631,
0.0106247514,
-0.0406880155,
0.0391048677,
0.0213003196,
0.0523658842,
0.003412209,
-0.0687572882,
-0.031409163,
0.0045666569,
0.0656320453,
0.0099734003,
0.0119491648,
-0.0235009044,
0.0078058364,
0.0096917069,
-0.0200678948,
-0.0309781581,
-0.0657250732,
0.0198364705,
-0.0155706983,
0.0319073759,
-0.0268345773,
-0.0198585205,
0.0223733149,
0.0027484759,
0.0673552677,
-0.0712677315,
-0.0150532657,
-0.0077273664,
0.0747056976,
0.0670150518,
-0.0057367673,
-0.0316030495,
-0.0318262912,
-0.0115514705,
0.0104381088,
-0.0147597957,
0.041809395,
-0.029884845,
0.0095294751,
0.0138935689,
-0.0621796884,
0.0011486273,
-0.0115001081,
0.0752129555,
-0.0330425128,
-0.0372350216,
0.1194928586,
0.0317806415,
-0.0129823275,
-0.0328121036,
0.0389307477,
0.0584104434,
0.0091874385,
0.0330252796,
-0.0335789509,
-0.0175746921,
-0.0178308431,
0.0230507571,
0.0375656597,
-0.009234109,
-0.0185972787,
-0.0153137343,
0.0038463175,
0.0233013891,
-0.0826771185,
0.0206555221,
0.0082199052,
-0.0100030228,
-0.0402702801,
-0.0215480123,
0.0032995802,
-0.029734768,
0.022207113,
0.0141584417,
-0.037124332,
-0.0456270985,
-0.0676942468,
-0.0285182558,
-0.0083275717,
0.0509611554,
0.0261344165,
-0.0099618891,
0.0348302983,
-0.0447945818,
-0.0349870846,
0.0107845981,
-0.0184603017,
0.0526429638,
-0.018763816,
-0.0256673452,
-0.0722443089,
0.0624142066,
0.0282379054,
0.0288687199,
0.0294917542,
-0.031710621,
-0.0038145669,
-0.032312341,
-0.02911341,
0.0339625552,
0.0280396957,
0.0444154963,
0.0594118498,
-0.0520728528,
-0.0489716716,
-0.0503678247,
-0.0098096607,
-0.1123276502,
-0.0629908293,
-0.0267772935,
-0.0348364301,
-0.0078566857,
-0.1013721451,
-0.0426183641,
-0.0050406475,
0.065789476,
0.0134472027,
-0.0350419804,
-0.0200594775,
-0.0231617745,
-0.0566542298,
-0.0269138552,
-0.0277565382,
-0.0125347944,
-0.0062025846,
-0.0415354967,
0.0579638034,
-0.0324172452,
-0.0187558029,
0.0513287149,
-0.0329507701,
-0.0350543186,
0.013873674,
0.0592671633,
0.0164873824,
0.0311865918,
-0.0246262923,
-0.0750882551,
0.070806317,
0.0596445538,
0.0608634092,
0.0041039586,
-0.0002989515,
-0.0101454845,
0.0068816124,
0.0328492559,
0.0012753458,
0.0653813034,
0.0129178679,
0.0580143072,
-0.0071230154,
0.0375135094,
0.041399546,
-0.0088043353,
-0.0340171866,
-0.0413569137,
0.0376281179,
-0.0229232758,
-0.0154410843,
-0.0147815319,
-0.0232793055,
-0.0490211733,
0.0155973313,
0.0246536806,
0.0113471225,
-0.0335164331,
0.041953478,
-0.0201622713,
0.0288282745,
-0.0771704018,
-0.0399321914,
0.0228650793,
0.0426620841,
-0.0381916538,
0.008911849,
-0.0054519684,
0.0196628422,
-0.0005302665,
0.0227098148,
0.0090765068,
0.0420797169,
0.0351626836,
-0.003314425,
-0.0592944548,
0.0551535338,
-0.0978148282,
0.0061544827,
-0.06183061,
0.0586437397,
0.023764994,
-0.0513067618,
0.0542137139,
-0.0100514144,
-0.0171138253,
0.0111341812,
0.0577549003,
-0.0000530033,
-0.0028841032,
-0.0339437202,
0.0067868656,
-0.0045256033,
-0.0315825194,
0.0700892061,
0.0285798125,
-0.0126499664,
0.0240654238,
-0.0152655775,
-0.0324260294,
-0.0284247678,
0.068267718,
0.0114780795,
0.037869446,
-0.0346593484,
-0.0059969975,
-0.0033570379,
0.0223226752,
0.0240049995,
0.0261702351,
0.0163896158,
0.0309007876,
0.0474191979,
-0.0054322602,
-0.0059622838,
-0.0434137844,
0.0455711558,
-0.0202845968,
-0.0277441945,
-0.0060682045,
-5.477913877e-33,
-0.064743042,
-0.0126565397,
-0.0391268991,
0.0254168604,
-0.0344716907,
-0.0347120427,
-0.0631263405,
-0.0052263038,
0.02223395,
0.0136095211,
-0.0224561207,
-0.0035401818,
0.0153683694,
0.0503526032,
0.0427208655,
0.0323690735,
0.075434044,
0.0128186485,
-0.0383825712,
0.0520529673,
0.017897198,
0.0316671543,
0.0468450971,
-0.0171906184,
-0.0235504843,
-0.0753457025,
-0.0334397927,
-0.0228590518,
0.0644942746,
0.0135043515,
0.0393906832,
-0.0046098973,
0.0196979102,
-0.0146776624,
-0.0398124009,
-0.0074310848,
-0.0575963147,
-0.0302203689,
0.0121962233,
0.0316170491,
-0.0298346337,
-0.0135718333,
0.0596125349,
-0.041789256,
0.0493497588,
-0.007614288,
0.0649484321,
-0.0068161325,
0.0042361864,
-0.0610746555,
-0.0534473136,
-0.0092549631,
-0.0095023997,
-0.0221824199,
0.0004755659,
-0.0109040933,
-0.0100846281,
0.0215185452,
0.0010721165,
0.013780647,
0.0014060432,
0.0193593036,
0.0326088183,
0.0337539017,
-0.0162897278,
0.0310490336,
-0.0233225226,
0.0289451871,
-0.0408996493,
0.0667388961,
0.0226493273,
0.0338911787,
0.0266617686,
0.059584789,
-0.002882736,
0.0288889054,
-0.0101711089,
0.0699730292,
0.0464781635,
-0.0321580358,
0.0020059787,
0.018091755,
0.0060234712,
0.006275624,
-0.0198848415,
-0.0706042498,
-0.0120441802,
-0.0362801887,
-0.0115966816,
0.0141562084,
-0.0828740895,
0.0130162165,
0.0065620723,
-0.0084312335,
0.010306349,
-0.0159754008,
-0.0518530533,
0.0394604057,
-0.0294012614,
0.0017594154,
-0.0123746432,
-0.0051471456,
0.0525510721,
0.0460352711,
-0.0242297091,
-0.0088369977,
0.0750854984,
0.0289144795,
-0.0652458966,
-0.0109404568,
0.0030877283,
0.0003783458,
-0.0311004985,
-0.029934248,
0.018031748,
-0.0052499636,
-0.0408918634,
0.0141730625,
0.0134523148,
0.00818602,
-0.0196141023,
-0.0286697224,
0.0275234319,
0.0412932374,
-0.023217082,
0.0004783572,
-0.049753055,
-0.0309319422,
-0.0224360414,
-0.0791080147,
-0.021150399,
-0.0066628149,
2.208e-7,
0.0177706666,
0.0090682162,
0.0340707153,
0.0425441116,
0.0153479408,
0.0044097477,
0.0228210483,
0.0559911244,
-0.0076328525,
-0.0055822222,
0.0319833755,
0.0191725418,
0.0294902194,
-0.0320367739,
-0.086092405,
-0.007355303,
-0.046008002,
0.0117680663,
-0.0597344674,
-0.0294656213,
0.0736348927,
0.032484144,
0.006461475,
-0.0174508616,
0.0477670208,
-0.0006474499,
0.0857704729,
0.0140447775,
-0.0349738188,
0.0296897199,
0.0468308814,
0.0114169419,
-0.0377946049,
-0.0199369229,
-0.0093163857,
-0.0152300196,
0.0465663597,
0.0455770008,
0.0283663403,
0.0229537282,
-0.0022924009,
0.0212945305,
0.0255788751,
-0.0440386832,
0.0548546128,
-0.0309423283,
-0.0102900919,
-0.0551100597,
-0.0491258129,
0.0033524784,
-0.0084573086,
-0.0409429707,
-0.0320183858,
0.0421719365,
0.0168891978,
0.0093246121,
0.0285403077,
-0.0547749959,
-0.0454117954,
0.003221808,
-0.0254579261,
0.0424082726,
-0.0271162204,
0.0043286709,
-0.0104574785,
-0.0600971729,
-0.0137547236,
1.920753063e-34,
0.0392188579,
0.0060414821,
0.0020207537,
-0.0103079947,
-0.0006943581,
0.0082188873,
0.0101945102,
0.0200461801,
0.0053622876,
-0.0616426468,
-0.0266048182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17737v1 | ArchBERT: Bi-Modal Understanding of Neural Architectures and Natural Languages | 2023-10-26T18:58:52 | 2023-10-26T18:58:52 | Mohammad Akbari, Saeed Ranjbar Alvar, Behnam Kamranian, Amin Banitalebi-Dehkordi, Yong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Building multi-modal language models has been a trend in the recent years,
where additional modalities such as image, video, speech, etc. are jointly
learned along with natural languages (i.e., textual information). Despite the
success of these multi-modal language models with different modalities, there
is no existing solution for neural network architectures and natural languages.
Providing neural architectural information as a new modality allows us to
provide fast architecture-2-text and text-2-architecture retrieval/generation
services on the cloud with a single inference. Such solution is valuable in
terms of helping beginner and intermediate ML users to come up with better
neural architectures or AutoML approaches with a simple text query. In this
paper, we propose ArchBERT, a bi-modal model for joint learning and
understanding of neural architectures and natural languages, which opens up new
avenues for research in this area. We also introduce a pre-training strategy
named Masked Architecture Modeling (MAM) for a more generalized joint learning.
Moreover, we introduce and publicly release two new bi-modal datasets for
training and validating our methods. The ArchBERT's performance is verified
through a set of numerical experiments on different downstream tasks such as
architecture-oriented reasoning, question answering, and captioning
(summarization). Datasets, codes, and demos are available supplementary
materials. | [
-0.0047845095,
0.1031204686,
-0.0288408771,
0.0666918382,
-0.0403792486,
0.0068394984,
0.0246398188,
-0.0425542034,
0.0054089152,
-0.0499837697,
-0.0524113551,
-0.0618327633,
-0.0134888412,
0.0677735284,
0.0452335328,
-0.0092031937,
0.0451718532,
-0.0218169726,
-0.0023188216,
-0.0229089763,
0.0093250927,
0.0363502838,
-0.0015453055,
0.0239766408,
0.0130136413,
-0.0207082145,
-0.0491358899,
0.0262871236,
-0.0245707259,
-0.0278514698,
0.0247591287,
-0.0022883017,
0.0400361679,
0.0719264597,
0.0000020619,
0.0055229939,
-0.0191602502,
0.0236614142,
-0.0282827802,
-0.0215703323,
0.0701876506,
0.0139728421,
0.0201169755,
-0.0068919151,
-0.0587983541,
-0.0709476545,
0.0470261872,
0.0617772229,
0.0875916183,
0.0784055665,
-0.0146205975,
-0.0798767209,
0.0145359356,
-0.0308243316,
-0.0479434095,
-0.0306047294,
-0.0029034449,
-0.0547225066,
-0.0118577089,
0.0573191643,
0.0097887879,
0.0533970334,
0.0395913161,
0.0497854762,
-0.0194494948,
0.0428729579,
-0.0263389573,
-0.0302642286,
-0.0101132663,
0.0833583251,
0.0309297387,
0.0082113612,
0.0267538913,
0.005358485,
-0.0016656287,
-0.0001748577,
-0.0344869383,
0.0344738699,
0.0282092933,
0.0116934367,
-0.0267671142,
-0.0255094506,
0.0262489542,
0.0023818847,
-0.0227264445,
0.0286602788,
0.0113801751,
0.0125145549,
-0.0366309658,
-0.0067121037,
0.0070290794,
-0.0618751757,
-0.0162831675,
0.0513115525,
0.0123947933,
0.0135312732,
-0.039580442,
-0.0465218462,
-0.000575346,
-0.0202988274,
0.0506600589,
-0.0063233101,
-0.0515630059,
0.0430572741,
-0.0602201447,
0.0159163401,
-0.0294231419,
0.0249158405,
-0.0257183649,
-0.0239764098,
-0.0563581958,
-0.041210793,
-0.0426839553,
0.0400700644,
-0.0758111626,
-0.0456370972,
-0.0268791709,
0.0175337642,
-0.0168800522,
0.0038637898,
-0.0037901327,
0.0460343845,
-0.0093040448,
-0.0172981247,
-0.0219096858,
-0.0076768571,
-0.0268761087,
0.0272458196,
0.0042625074,
-0.0659447983,
-0.0020242957,
0.0260731671,
-0.0118567459,
-0.0067711459,
0.0208712388,
0.1031408161,
-0.039228186,
-0.0136774983,
-0.023860056,
-0.0837467089,
-0.0014031517,
-0.0512665696,
0.0606688298,
-0.0625765249,
0.0532576032,
-0.0235822499,
-0.018933,
-0.0169222038,
0.0036039955,
0.0260109678,
-0.024144955,
0.0836443454,
-0.0202870723,
-0.0296705868,
0.0147138387,
0.0244058017,
-0.0201396886,
0.0821101144,
0.0320769809,
-0.000858077,
0.0396110453,
0.038927637,
-0.0242518373,
0.031404186,
0.0458003134,
-0.0158251598,
-0.0000744365,
-0.0025730038,
-0.0232962091,
0.0132253235,
0.0004450852,
0.0357231982,
-0.0335456803,
-0.032087855,
0.0523648113,
0.0059165214,
0.0476533659,
0.0550917201,
0.0200444832,
0.0167731866,
0.0030182563,
-0.0035406612,
-0.024947878,
0.0567678064,
-0.0295805149,
0.0128044458,
-0.0103606302,
0.0454037338,
-0.0428632013,
-0.0471471138,
0.0334771611,
-0.0098964982,
-0.0337245315,
0.0069823558,
0.0645251051,
0.0212590527,
-0.0303631295,
0.0356216505,
0.0063817766,
-0.0171264596,
0.0210235994,
-0.0456083007,
-0.0130202109,
-0.004415411,
0.0114544025,
-0.0377361886,
-0.0019406738,
0.0293967295,
-0.0135652116,
0.0332923308,
-0.010274874,
-0.012786339,
0.0452129133,
-0.0576965138,
-0.0055365977,
-0.0543113276,
0.0115280896,
-0.0135674113,
-0.0215681717,
-0.0086769611,
0.0276717152,
0.0063167694,
0.0064663528,
0.0445051417,
-0.0146343149,
0.0027149611,
0.0291146133,
0.0117702717,
0.0122965742,
0.0083152298,
-0.0326357931,
0.0248308349,
0.0322048329,
-0.0379376784,
-0.0363353416,
0.0123712486,
-0.0520298854,
-0.0432716943,
0.0288438722,
-0.0564758554,
0.0240978599,
0.0268826745,
-0.0413929224,
-0.0545914993,
0.0431142077,
-0.0505997986,
0.0246834345,
-0.0649292767,
-0.0136269722,
0.0279483348,
0.0137236463,
-0.0081681218,
0.0498367921,
-0.0037579741,
-0.0038189178,
0.0132001778,
-0.0235174205,
0.0193287544,
0.0055350433,
-0.0582495444,
-0.0070748935,
-0.01261687,
0.0105616795,
-0.0056222198,
-0.0163082629,
-0.0389646851,
-0.006711557,
-0.1202336401,
-0.0149377547,
-0.0181099027,
-0.006256002,
0.0239650346,
0.0190691017,
0.0161299389,
-0.0364290699,
-0.0544504523,
0.0333886929,
-0.0039276616,
0.0271812491,
0.0523190498,
0.008780865,
-0.0165927541,
-0.0055999863,
-0.0483268648,
-0.0157866888,
0.0625317916,
-0.0165935997,
-0.0042907898,
-0.0152040971,
-0.0334299095,
-0.0181073882,
0.0482280888,
-0.0303113069,
-0.0267631188,
0.0076831318,
-0.0418564118,
-0.0150688766,
0.0697676092,
0.0039867652,
-0.0045106481,
0.0356439985,
-0.0141380709,
-0.0285429098,
0.0299156643,
-0.0269565471,
0.0210807119,
-0.0070400019,
-0.0086837877,
-0.0037537091,
0.0440955795,
-0.0220440365,
-0.0184569396,
-0.0242981557,
0.0342174508,
0.0072442172,
-0.0077571063,
-0.0253413171,
0.0135463318,
0.0117729837,
0.0353929996,
-0.0168961473,
-0.0272772405,
0.0765943527,
-0.041699253,
-0.0189552661,
-0.0171339102,
0.0052015246,
-0.027753545,
0.075014092,
0.0353811309,
0.0554659925,
0.0315869413,
-0.0044615967,
-0.0559165813,
0.0138532678,
0.0181988087,
-0.0293964855,
0.0295524895,
-0.0302499402,
-0.0054028621,
-0.0037879113,
-0.0613572821,
-0.0091311838,
-0.0212840103,
-0.0412293933,
0.0306498297,
-0.0134494659,
-0.0246382654,
-0.049600523,
-0.0257399492,
0.0022236854,
0.0402843766,
-0.0292317308,
-0.0068547721,
-0.0476283357,
0.0527578257,
0.0497649722,
0.0447421744,
0.0141350972,
-0.0404226966,
-0.0079288566,
0.0503686033,
0.027768394,
0.0404043756,
-0.0639721304,
0.0221979897,
0.0481793955,
0.0061591566,
-0.0358374976,
0.0158821084,
0.0728694424,
-0.0497868545,
-0.0196746998,
0.0654631034,
-0.0164519735,
-0.0326808207,
-0.0186232775,
0.0322075784,
0.0224294923,
0.0253794082,
0.0398658216,
-0.0753186196,
-0.0568298548,
0.0053339167,
0.0248686261,
-0.0113896253,
-0.0012016391,
-0.0093281325,
-0.0922606587,
0.0156764369,
-0.0114063136,
-0.0312820338,
-0.0119944289,
-0.0065517323,
-0.0103343939,
-0.0068671457,
-0.0356316417,
0.0051437104,
0.0008206476,
-0.0118123516,
0.0015211151,
-0.0216529667,
-0.0302641355,
-0.0050976183,
-0.0532576814,
0.0414300896,
0.0449399054,
0.0046732845,
-0.0101109603,
-0.0444416851,
0.0293109268,
0.0206174906,
0.0280155689,
0.004404319,
0.0573379435,
-0.0083939992,
-0.0250975005,
-0.0308432803,
0.0412520245,
-0.0218235217,
0.0000830003,
-0.0102405306,
0.0640425533,
0.0162535179,
0.0329099298,
-0.0557412654,
0.0065332707,
-0.0087279174,
0.0421181284,
0.0116885286,
-0.0214760564,
-0.0436974056,
-0.0096426057,
0.0053975172,
-0.0771276578,
-0.0006696086,
0.0371704772,
-0.0172989909,
0.0211557839,
-0.0537339523,
-0.0103369001,
-0.0060342536,
0.0530826859,
-0.0004844146,
-0.0190054681,
0.0398127213,
-0.0053056874,
-0.0758513883,
0.0069847037,
-0.0271626264,
0.0279180557,
-0.0130456463,
-0.0212957691,
0.0582712106,
-0.0505607612,
-0.0454264358,
0.0183487386,
-0.0736913458,
-0.0665630102,
-0.0176194776,
0.0681788251,
0.013821478,
0.0485295616,
0.0061249174,
-0.0699356571,
0.0507903136,
0.0329720825,
-0.0530830324,
-0.0175835695,
0.0331253447,
-0.0400742702,
-0.0312232822,
0.0504839346,
-0.0423296951,
-0.0077394354,
0.0050417129,
0.0363009349,
-0.0045513688,
0.0383149721,
0.0121306675,
0.0160610862,
0.0213216767,
0.0059812707,
0.0006973583,
-0.0509487018,
0.0319577605,
0.0007038323,
-0.0225678142,
-0.0604255907,
0.01700514,
-0.0107255755,
-0.0189239681,
0.0121565992,
0.011854833,
0.045286648,
0.0266816672,
-0.0143446624,
0.0165779442,
0.0818605423,
0.0167578403,
-0.0178197939,
-0.0014680562,
-0.0104519399,
0.0255247131,
-0.0049041854,
0.041751679,
-0.0574494712,
0.0550684743,
0.0404784381,
0.0084978342,
-0.062654987,
0.0437472016,
-0.0454538688,
-0.0543495901,
-0.0250319745,
-0.0182218794,
0.0334067419,
-0.0091492981,
0.0275260285,
-0.0117781498,
-0.0200694855,
-0.0252280477,
0.048982475,
0.0007334377,
-0.025367463,
0.0443010591,
0.0272395089,
0.0041252673,
-0.0124516301,
0.0899110138,
-0.0015031892,
0.0218303651,
-0.0215511248,
-0.0002140494,
-0.0281716678,
-0.0120674465,
0.0545984991,
0.0651145875,
-0.0304160174,
-0.021825403,
-0.0281210411,
-0.0618299395,
-0.0037267196,
0.0232488438,
0.0175250266,
-0.004492552,
0.0508924797,
0.0905892104,
0.0835375562,
-0.0411697663,
-0.0519538447,
0.0018315957,
0.0045665577,
0.0109543186,
-0.0028072351,
-6.631806316e-33,
-0.0169380121,
-0.0053592483,
0.024353914,
-0.0532189086,
-0.0218702629,
0.0505390055,
-0.0196405537,
0.0076619103,
-0.0424757861,
-0.0086829448,
-0.0013097995,
0.0101415245,
0.002430591,
0.0716454983,
0.0012947583,
-0.006322898,
0.0223558396,
-0.0358125679,
-0.0169572849,
0.0342365503,
0.0324045457,
0.0292109288,
0.0185496602,
-0.0519928634,
0.0177475233,
0.0021571335,
0.0188794304,
0.0177550092,
-0.0165850185,
0.0660925135,
-0.0286042672,
0.0268344637,
0.0246013626,
-0.0089004291,
-0.0175634958,
0.0082706697,
-0.0897582993,
-0.0158458091,
0.0097581912,
0.0246725418,
-0.083384417,
-0.0011800886,
0.0699608102,
-0.0209534094,
0.0166192017,
-0.0380738787,
0.0466051027,
0.0151537526,
-0.0053187744,
-0.0335040949,
-0.0345769301,
0.0114651052,
0.0047258688,
-0.0229440797,
0.0554564595,
0.0304699671,
0.0301212482,
0.0238481518,
-0.0752062127,
0.0176162403,
-0.0397017188,
0.0382471867,
0.0437859446,
0.0510659032,
0.0071114232,
0.0583437532,
0.088972941,
-0.0343061164,
-0.0605667308,
0.0044910819,
0.0573632009,
0.0761925802,
0.0393776074,
0.0197425447,
0.038955912,
0.025804881,
-0.0678401887,
-0.0215363707,
0.021269707,
0.032826107,
0.027604185,
-0.0056891134,
0.0246477034,
0.0064848848,
-0.0730758607,
-0.0641266331,
-0.0529857278,
0.0190268271,
-0.0061002783,
0.0440735444,
-0.0040290458,
0.0112745576,
0.0380853675,
-0.0574205071,
-0.0018924375,
-0.0038573542,
-0.008184663,
0.0217325129,
0.0199961551,
0.0579188578,
-0.0111552384,
-0.0051470823,
-0.0022113984,
-0.0142933726,
0.0267520845,
0.0072995997,
0.0321637467,
0.0353338644,
-0.0389644243,
-0.0177272465,
-0.0450477451,
-0.0204047952,
0.0026222391,
0.0293613095,
0.0285895132,
0.0278553423,
-0.0269428045,
0.0323934481,
-0.015168868,
0.0460907593,
-0.0482212901,
-0.0117904544,
0.015238747,
0.0295372382,
-0.0175815411,
0.0001161065,
-0.0418474264,
-0.0374357551,
0.0275830626,
-0.0920080915,
-0.0261020437,
0.0681914613,
2.802e-7,
0.0339080282,
0.0121691339,
0.0272429995,
0.0342043638,
0.021770047,
0.0675903708,
-0.0177635923,
0.0272955634,
-0.0201608613,
-0.0199561585,
-0.0347766094,
0.0427151881,
0.0412179604,
0.0367626622,
-0.0423540659,
-0.0005387185,
-0.0460221581,
0.0199537314,
-0.0420052819,
-0.0122509636,
0.0700357556,
0.0869505405,
-0.0186849013,
-0.0151531436,
0.0070487647,
-0.0227501523,
0.071556665,
0.0163700283,
0.0163361002,
0.0087346723,
-0.0062468699,
0.0435029119,
-0.0324200429,
0.0005824632,
-0.0115894135,
0.0083725397,
0.0137688033,
0.0328966491,
0.0236170124,
-0.0436557867,
0.0266316738,
-0.0202805977,
-0.0263205823,
-0.031384863,
0.090738833,
-0.0708953291,
-0.0268191509,
-0.0469654649,
-0.0528826192,
0.0014584449,
0.0053395606,
-0.0000856087,
-0.0271058548,
0.0408559591,
0.0186545979,
-0.0448394865,
0.0163459703,
-0.1162105203,
0.0076289042,
-0.0036713013,
-0.0423946567,
0.0299503002,
-0.0584435053,
-0.0106674219,
0.0467918776,
-0.0609482303,
-0.0093331756,
2.603717462e-34,
0.0171339232,
-0.0423579849,
-0.0220357813,
0.053984765,
0.0116920611,
-0.0418582596,
-0.0199333653,
-0.0055041737,
-0.0146115152,
-0.0889505446,
-0.0457813665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17734v1 | Investigating Multilingual Coreference Resolution by Universal Annotations | 2023-10-26T18:50:04 | 2023-10-26T18:50:04 | Haixia Chai, Michael Strube | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual coreference resolution (MCR) has been a long-standing and
challenging task. With the newly proposed multilingual coreference dataset,
CorefUD (Nedoluzhko et al., 2022), we conduct an investigation into the task by
using its harmonized universal morphosyntactic and coreference annotations.
First, we study coreference by examining the ground truth data at different
linguistic levels, namely mention, entity and document levels, and across
different genres, to gain insights into the characteristics of coreference
across multiple languages. Second, we perform an error analysis of the most
challenging cases that the SotA system fails to resolve in the CRAC 2022 shared
task using the universal annotations. Last, based on this analysis, we extract
features from universal morphosyntactic annotations and integrate these
features into a baseline system to assess their potential benefits for the MCR
task. Our results show that our best configuration of features improves the
baseline by 0.9% F1 score. | [
0.0473691598,
-0.0030101289,
0.0159893781,
0.0208305474,
-0.0243556742,
0.0143889999,
-0.0104830107,
-0.0283729937,
0.0245040525,
-0.0300046019,
-0.0351045355,
0.0298838206,
-0.0148960799,
-0.035436362,
0.0077317492,
-0.0056994543,
0.0465959311,
-0.0189962573,
-0.0023631426,
-0.0125692403,
0.0102939364,
0.0293329377,
-0.002227165,
0.0214252733,
-0.0593812764,
-0.025909178,
0.0191946644,
-0.0059613842,
0.0489463806,
-0.0054296898,
0.0380332544,
0.0602732226,
-0.0267511383,
0.0590168834,
0.0000016961,
-0.061756894,
-0.0186812412,
0.0445285253,
-0.0057992609,
0.0038117312,
0.0058184559,
-0.0103323609,
0.0014473813,
-0.0203670766,
0.0048789415,
0.0035245179,
0.035540022,
0.0448631682,
0.0322681926,
0.0114536816,
-0.029051993,
-0.0186503716,
0.0133001795,
-0.0253451224,
-0.0923541114,
-0.0498511977,
0.0030580082,
0.0377128981,
-0.0152432257,
0.0035736237,
0.0164782908,
0.0497566126,
0.0024945268,
0.0066651534,
-0.0227813963,
0.0015630554,
-0.1061597764,
-0.0179135874,
0.0359720662,
0.054414995,
0.0324960239,
0.0252346341,
0.0209471602,
0.0228033289,
-0.039849516,
-0.0357220024,
-0.0305357799,
-0.0110086035,
-0.044516433,
0.0121923434,
0.0416753739,
0.0105908718,
-0.0293291435,
0.0098463027,
-0.000541438,
0.0887539759,
0.0133389905,
0.0009300701,
0.0800166801,
0.0303767882,
-0.0189435668,
-0.0505855381,
0.0726111382,
-0.0268644691,
-0.0411970094,
0.0102761872,
-0.0159700308,
0.0126424693,
0.0345020369,
-0.0850128606,
0.0068624518,
-0.0014335153,
-0.0582156442,
0.0499916822,
-0.0116978949,
0.0494637825,
-0.0114540802,
0.0202448592,
0.0042912667,
-0.0554655269,
-0.0406854264,
0.0430827737,
-0.0206779875,
0.0502411425,
-0.0383855253,
0.0026022557,
-0.0618429072,
-0.0234776009,
-0.0040753181,
0.0339089781,
0.0075200396,
-0.0356201045,
-0.0356900468,
0.0126645882,
-0.013708245,
0.0509388633,
-0.0350307003,
-0.01123772,
-0.0636259392,
-0.0569740683,
0.0102069303,
0.0181542002,
0.004638908,
-0.0366998166,
0.0129473871,
0.0397240743,
0.0059570577,
-0.0389322676,
0.006467036,
-0.0520142503,
-0.0491924621,
-0.0649671406,
-0.0173963048,
-0.0838639364,
0.0288824048,
0.0156608988,
0.0039750668,
-0.0474583954,
0.0278617777,
-0.0061749849,
-0.0519714616,
0.0422562212,
-0.0014957165,
-0.0043407804,
0.0171840023,
-0.0341423824,
0.0274749417,
0.0642597601,
0.0021429402,
-0.0006544067,
0.0616776831,
0.0499281809,
-0.0444621332,
0.0372634903,
0.0264107808,
0.0235603433,
0.0726977214,
-0.0128698163,
-0.0629699454,
-0.0122437403,
0.0376923159,
0.0315920487,
0.0058839233,
-0.0444978401,
0.0065872483,
0.0472523533,
-0.0320443176,
-0.0008495969,
-0.0313286446,
-0.0086496966,
0.0139850508,
0.0480531976,
-0.0272509735,
0.0242865123,
-0.0043788301,
-0.0059120278,
0.0681710616,
0.0236021318,
-0.0253766309,
-0.0190552454,
-0.0167596079,
0.0021814413,
-0.0405176803,
-0.0003876774,
0.0530781895,
0.0079393005,
-0.0059161256,
0.0567807406,
0.0205294471,
-0.0769252926,
-0.0192645751,
0.0253791064,
-0.0298504643,
-0.0119769517,
0.0319208987,
-0.0161810666,
-0.1007094011,
0.0091038235,
0.0337893255,
0.0552636646,
0.0264640655,
-0.0100501301,
0.0508719236,
-0.0118004167,
-0.0180776808,
0.0088288002,
0.0113298073,
0.0422752723,
0.0150531549,
-0.0052170036,
0.0119965747,
-0.0356275365,
-0.0443842635,
-0.0024360227,
-0.0348161496,
0.0437947996,
-0.0110350605,
0.0192554183,
0.0346166193,
0.0571417175,
-0.0128606819,
-0.0200238992,
0.0141729945,
-0.0341481902,
0.0075921859,
0.054025121,
-0.0138712535,
-0.0051716911,
0.0537048616,
-0.0828489438,
-0.027564602,
-0.0420148596,
-0.0063107,
-0.0475337282,
-0.0032029774,
-0.0127049144,
0.0146630518,
-0.0262666494,
0.0033038468,
0.0179913379,
0.0189261511,
-0.0165913273,
0.0385457836,
0.0125613259,
0.0279174354,
0.0363308825,
-0.0542248338,
0.0570825115,
-0.0283433907,
-0.0340792127,
0.0207586754,
-0.0115142642,
-0.0206581969,
0.050536707,
0.0114364671,
-0.0605289042,
-0.0034094858,
-0.1083995327,
0.0200667549,
-0.0338893868,
0.0400115699,
0.0197479222,
0.0208411291,
-0.0079904953,
-0.0178296063,
-0.0081704594,
-0.0027785276,
0.0312013701,
0.0273746923,
0.0203525051,
0.0201455355,
0.0010455339,
-0.051084172,
0.0050848578,
-0.0192988086,
0.0203617867,
0.0018658558,
-0.0631336048,
-0.0093747368,
0.0430057384,
-0.0449312441,
0.0320043005,
0.0123857558,
0.0023014362,
-0.0155254547,
0.0275827125,
0.0168916117,
0.0079929559,
-0.0472048745,
0.0134311067,
0.012852761,
-0.0801416561,
-0.0614661761,
0.0272727795,
0.0255679805,
-0.051642742,
-0.0046223667,
-0.0228321329,
0.029795127,
0.0546545163,
-0.0122843822,
-0.0214075614,
-0.0429736637,
-0.0232429877,
-0.0565613844,
-0.0117765106,
0.0305164065,
0.0016922161,
-0.0071709864,
0.0679052472,
-0.0314748734,
0.0215788279,
0.0522529632,
-0.0477208756,
-0.0186589882,
-0.0282713734,
0.0275718234,
-0.0562985055,
0.0463540629,
-0.0141388234,
-0.0027885395,
0.0654418692,
-0.0967940465,
-0.0056864331,
0.0154532976,
0.0350040905,
0.005658594,
0.0657253787,
-0.0469897129,
0.0415765829,
-0.0291142482,
-0.0009352103,
-0.0163231771,
0.0498335846,
-0.0435708612,
0.0072119362,
-0.0340435691,
0.0126108192,
0.0068078199,
0.0087808091,
0.020733187,
0.0326583572,
-0.0144091845,
0.0056915642,
-0.0269511137,
0.0309697222,
0.0184578132,
0.0223480687,
-0.020154357,
0.0097797858,
-0.0037463796,
0.0306152571,
-0.0088714184,
-0.0085218661,
0.0004543912,
-0.0204402097,
0.0256845802,
-0.0529786348,
-0.0701306462,
-0.0592116527,
0.0576571524,
-0.0254243631,
-0.0335043333,
0.095197022,
0.0485201851,
-0.0377454832,
-0.039585378,
-0.0245448928,
0.0011079885,
0.0416551195,
-0.0098203076,
-0.0505092666,
-0.0162676312,
-0.0171876587,
-0.0135119203,
0.0384439863,
-0.0524458028,
0.0085517615,
-0.0696547553,
0.0347549878,
-0.0137457941,
-0.0970961452,
-0.0391617455,
-0.0197642855,
0.0399894118,
-0.0402649678,
0.0112293391,
-0.0205192957,
0.0090798736,
0.021688804,
0.0008145507,
-0.0263936445,
0.0081665851,
0.03924907,
-0.073306784,
-0.012052143,
0.0556092821,
0.0657518879,
0.0278261527,
0.0209930688,
0.0063506593,
-0.0176515561,
-0.0331413001,
-0.0178870689,
0.0375257321,
0.0075781601,
-0.0127712926,
0.0058049574,
0.026076505,
0.0002815331,
0.0052810526,
0.0189000443,
0.0504320972,
0.0339141376,
0.0506953448,
-0.0047985925,
0.0302708894,
-0.0094443541,
0.0400880091,
0.0109887226,
0.011998619,
-0.018524766,
-0.0170916468,
0.0437392853,
-0.0620001704,
-0.0150006339,
0.0271644089,
-0.060348507,
-0.0221913047,
-0.0665411055,
-0.0808750391,
0.0436218865,
-0.0076007461,
0.0076406365,
-0.0159003083,
0.0257095974,
0.0111392299,
-0.0214373432,
-0.0016895009,
-0.0720142499,
0.0024203092,
-0.052146554,
0.0383579135,
0.0827065408,
0.0782613084,
-0.0096492488,
0.0814496279,
-0.0271833949,
-0.052260261,
-0.0131810419,
-0.0182668641,
0.0101466095,
0.0274046399,
-0.0390002988,
-0.0273076985,
-0.0279412884,
0.0271262079,
-0.0187110603,
0.0184652451,
0.047117386,
0.01143895,
-0.0120921256,
0.0729907751,
-0.0423981957,
0.0263778456,
-0.0344406664,
0.0708786175,
-0.0063364981,
-0.0825513378,
0.0300023183,
0.038956821,
0.0132720489,
-0.0090897456,
0.0094050812,
-0.035648562,
0.0314248465,
-0.0339213349,
-0.0186378546,
-0.0010066762,
0.0367272906,
-0.032056734,
-0.0095331632,
0.0219812468,
0.0451586209,
-0.0415152572,
0.0656364933,
0.0030009374,
-0.0066025681,
0.060892839,
0.0061719362,
-0.0555594154,
-0.008669382,
-0.0153273158,
0.0035724253,
0.038856376,
0.0501171909,
-0.0638663322,
0.0210546069,
-0.0270413253,
0.0005548384,
0.0098490473,
-0.0205415692,
-0.0100028468,
0.0257253721,
-0.0232186727,
0.0122953793,
0.1020331085,
-0.0093723461,
0.142578423,
-0.0237055793,
-0.0185804162,
0.004901717,
0.0156762227,
-0.0180046353,
-0.0035338963,
0.0001903615,
-0.003818952,
0.0121382624,
0.0264568347,
0.0731079951,
-0.0134563306,
0.005596343,
0.0217862092,
-0.0299266949,
-0.0315999389,
-0.0552131124,
-0.0284794513,
-0.0162158068,
0.000485707,
0.0048155244,
-0.0537864156,
-0.0357103571,
0.0916255713,
-0.0140538914,
-0.03763441,
0.0138239888,
-0.0007669794,
0.0349975564,
0.0346346833,
-0.0194847062,
-0.0402482636,
-0.0029252281,
0.006692573,
-0.0333383754,
-0.0140123535,
-5.538294614e-33,
-0.0773885846,
-0.025978012,
-0.0256465971,
0.0199320465,
0.0067757554,
0.0196399279,
-0.0351978764,
0.0178291574,
-0.0106356675,
0.0101324944,
-0.0284574367,
0.0004300907,
0.0338757671,
0.009994301,
0.0209243316,
-0.0237234402,
0.021138411,
0.0349607319,
-0.0194438696,
0.0217627678,
0.0555056259,
-0.0159706492,
0.130534187,
-0.1060564443,
0.0747737139,
0.0397561155,
-0.0143865366,
-0.0148084406,
0.0403775275,
0.0442123376,
-0.0133217275,
0.0351472385,
0.0056571383,
-0.0200591423,
-0.0080307722,
-0.0424508229,
-0.1105814427,
-0.0435821041,
0.0417481326,
0.052876398,
-0.0051168855,
-0.0307187289,
0.0047536404,
-0.0264339242,
0.0180170927,
-0.0099994047,
0.0405140929,
-0.0326320976,
-0.0075442232,
-0.0252579879,
-0.0869300291,
0.0417182297,
-0.0077911043,
0.0325704478,
0.0418978892,
0.07216236,
0.0070699197,
-0.0092890998,
-0.0420635305,
0.0406756587,
-0.0197308622,
0.0147097278,
0.036100816,
-0.0330153555,
-0.0227625724,
0.0156482849,
-0.0316767544,
-0.0167149808,
0.0106323604,
0.0200058725,
0.0194858182,
0.0195322558,
0.0070750709,
0.1428522915,
-0.031729687,
0.0380697064,
-0.0416479483,
0.0399386138,
0.0183074735,
0.0221742708,
-0.017169375,
-0.0005569055,
-0.0291529652,
-0.0248440318,
-0.0516389646,
-0.0348355025,
-0.0205272492,
-0.0510288216,
0.0107541159,
-0.0390878655,
-0.0219228044,
0.060212519,
0.0319306292,
-0.0316618718,
-0.0538182594,
0.029528128,
0.0255063605,
0.0423392504,
0.0198851563,
0.0445451476,
-0.0357850231,
0.0090359831,
-0.0080431774,
-0.011921064,
0.0337095633,
-0.0187954362,
0.0436912477,
-0.015975412,
-0.0497516245,
-0.0112119792,
-0.009654982,
0.0204470586,
-0.0785420015,
-0.0041959803,
0.0082408544,
-0.0097693475,
0.0081434529,
0.0254281051,
0.0661792308,
0.0184196942,
-0.06548623,
-0.0194560476,
0.0441474579,
0.0463859923,
0.0090142377,
0.0023033118,
-0.0045978837,
-0.0228090882,
-0.016583493,
-0.0084896497,
-0.0111558745,
-0.0087546734,
2.313e-7,
0.0235921536,
0.0288569704,
0.0547535755,
-0.0141210565,
-0.0191028342,
-0.0018464646,
-0.01362928,
0.0296224151,
0.0124482652,
-0.0294700507,
-0.0029508194,
-0.0188360643,
0.0212653074,
0.0774625689,
-0.085983336,
-0.0323631428,
-0.014792758,
-0.0339145586,
-0.0528636314,
-0.0102647068,
0.0038785883,
0.0480453931,
0.0111693116,
0.0046440968,
-0.0588691682,
-0.0006707999,
0.0325489864,
-0.0112353163,
-0.0346173383,
0.0216774046,
-0.0196343288,
0.0256626755,
0.0003738156,
0.033783976,
0.0059555764,
0.005183632,
0.0719539896,
0.0329921804,
0.0255592763,
-0.0471306145,
-0.0177415814,
-0.0199444871,
0.0159239303,
-0.0341203548,
0.0445932969,
-0.0011530768,
-0.0206658989,
-0.069000341,
-0.0244600438,
0.0395874828,
0.0056437561,
0.0014448565,
-0.0062882472,
0.0391621999,
-0.0001279476,
0.0180872921,
-0.029467212,
-0.0293683279,
-0.0111393994,
0.0491641387,
0.0284352843,
-0.0012351451,
0.013300187,
-0.0475053824,
-0.0549914464,
-0.0261590444,
0.0072366651,
1.914757008e-34,
0.0190991797,
0.0120515963,
0.0194653533,
0.0178948157,
-0.0002354295,
-0.0216805004,
-0.040165063,
0.0144695574,
-0.0249888822,
0.0336194411,
0.0045383144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17723v1 | ZeroQuant-HERO: Hardware-Enhanced Robust Optimized Post-Training Quantization Framework for W8A8 Transformers | 2023-10-26T18:34:41 | 2023-10-26T18:34:41 | Zhewei Yao, Reza Yazdani Aminabadi, Stephen Youn, Xiaoxia Wu, Elton Zheng, Yuxiong He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Quantization techniques are pivotal in reducing the memory and computational
demands of deep neural network inference. Existing solutions, such as
ZeroQuant, offer dynamic quantization for models like BERT and GPT but overlook
crucial memory-bounded operators and the complexities of per-token
quantization. Addressing these gaps, we present a novel, fully
hardware-enhanced robust optimized post-training W8A8 quantization framework,
ZeroQuant-HERO. This framework uniquely integrates both memory bandwidth and
compute-intensive operators, aiming for optimal hardware performance.
Additionally, it offers flexibility by allowing specific INT8 modules to switch
to FP16/BF16 mode, enhancing accuracy. | [
-0.0391692221,
0.0902004316,
0.0111355875,
0.0378938168,
-0.0044062031,
-0.010898279,
0.0638285577,
0.0041841413,
-0.0144661833,
-0.0121074449,
-0.0107623627,
-0.029628681,
-0.0377537757,
-0.0003497078,
0.0350218229,
-0.0235926583,
0.0436601564,
0.0391942449,
-0.0074010985,
-0.0164767113,
-0.0116103627,
-0.0244386028,
-0.0154314684,
0.0090371231,
-0.0438333936,
-0.0170274824,
-0.0125020482,
0.0212586317,
0.0059644794,
-0.0026726704,
0.0187175181,
0.0310366862,
0.0278799795,
0.023315426,
0.0000019166,
0.028292032,
-0.0018434044,
0.0060947896,
-0.0224382989,
0.0406092666,
-0.0272630975,
0.0208656956,
-0.0318242721,
0.0010022173,
0.0135272276,
-0.0341310501,
0.0612936504,
0.0389540456,
0.0653366148,
0.0104613099,
-0.0021101898,
0.0041182619,
0.0678089708,
-0.0227261391,
0.0005295433,
-0.0179756768,
0.0041236244,
-0.0521174073,
-0.0315531082,
-0.030844003,
-0.0177959166,
0.0138052981,
0.0501087494,
0.0185367279,
-0.0221674684,
0.0244182367,
-0.111114718,
-0.0082407929,
-0.0112757534,
0.0344725326,
-0.0794606656,
-0.0196307804,
-0.0109286038,
0.0181203801,
-0.0603060983,
-0.1048466638,
-0.0232591592,
0.0320862979,
0.0160340592,
0.004500547,
-0.0391655043,
0.0128434617,
0.0610007793,
0.012112774,
-0.0287692845,
0.0464469939,
0.0423966162,
0.0312652662,
-0.003539853,
0.0001173777,
-0.1344684064,
-0.0355224162,
0.0083105648,
0.030892171,
0.020426644,
-0.0103979167,
-0.0858739987,
-0.0088654952,
-0.0203618556,
-0.0361814834,
-0.0320111848,
0.0712929964,
-0.0354330353,
-0.0059247771,
-0.0305082593,
0.0245635696,
-0.0817875639,
0.0396534316,
-0.030500764,
0.0112742847,
0.0175782926,
-0.0192813389,
-0.0506991446,
0.041630283,
0.0147791747,
-0.0179542918,
-0.0448868796,
0.0007552904,
-0.0177421868,
-0.0425037146,
0.0264526866,
0.0427769795,
-0.0323603563,
0.0021650449,
0.0276103355,
0.0343816504,
-0.0250131097,
0.0039087697,
-0.0043671504,
-0.0510685071,
-0.0134108085,
0.027512148,
-0.0073342742,
-0.038178619,
0.0402080193,
0.0183326825,
0.0020011992,
-0.0728552416,
-0.0048812265,
0.0205799639,
0.0159606934,
-0.0383351296,
0.0260802787,
-0.011422758,
-0.0004501881,
-0.0060868622,
0.0005789973,
-0.0243134685,
0.0195027553,
0.0206990428,
0.0262789242,
0.0131869353,
-0.0466882139,
-0.0651874244,
0.0129580731,
0.0056332103,
0.0610521808,
0.0576848947,
0.0185357332,
0.0130649386,
0.0102402521,
0.0152684785,
-0.0095368922,
0.0282905847,
0.0469457768,
-0.0110320924,
-0.0303676464,
-0.0178006962,
-0.0185604785,
0.0161275119,
0.0570746139,
0.0678055882,
-0.0457215048,
-0.0774532109,
-0.0054003061,
0.0418474786,
0.0564182699,
0.0392966829,
-0.0035872301,
-0.0426814966,
0.0348753594,
-0.0372736156,
-0.0480406322,
0.0371287093,
0.0513819456,
-0.02596437,
0.0161266699,
0.0554897264,
-0.0418937244,
-0.0061626565,
-0.0014175298,
-0.0091428459,
-0.0105070239,
0.0250170585,
0.0179483462,
-0.0144163147,
-0.0106247803,
0.1552482843,
0.0045960392,
-0.0460116193,
-0.009461062,
-0.1141999811,
-0.0248007551,
0.0161362719,
0.0204332247,
-0.0251510739,
-0.0281684492,
0.0214748569,
0.0081163971,
-0.0189860668,
-0.0346904583,
0.0082406839,
0.0500831865,
-0.0305625517,
-0.021576453,
-0.02136641,
0.0050374968,
-0.0044903322,
0.052147232,
-0.0002460956,
-0.0209307969,
-0.0547887161,
0.0302471146,
0.0189806912,
0.0669978783,
-0.0576976612,
0.0508893616,
0.0188852027,
0.0012735787,
0.0280111711,
-0.0315328278,
-0.0124210306,
0.038027022,
-0.0408093296,
0.010148285,
-0.033629965,
-0.0366419293,
0.0212493669,
0.0558875576,
-0.0120462552,
0.0298816953,
0.0679035485,
-0.0282793101,
-0.0476580188,
0.0199557878,
-0.026596291,
0.0471426919,
-0.0248607285,
0.0045520323,
-0.0043557398,
0.0454693474,
0.0010903903,
0.0079248687,
-0.0244101863,
-0.0132135218,
0.0145862866,
0.0429254547,
-0.0038244659,
-0.0193455964,
-0.0648170486,
-0.0077207,
0.0104339272,
0.0454611033,
0.0056920927,
-0.0280215088,
0.0371436812,
-0.0046838848,
-0.101081185,
0.0178115126,
-0.0751472116,
0.0242903475,
0.0222037211,
0.0263108257,
0.0407431982,
0.0050988211,
-0.0126198465,
-0.0288106054,
-0.0437034518,
-0.0145403203,
-0.0258685295,
-0.0171396248,
0.0016566382,
0.0075688334,
-0.0841543674,
0.0155862877,
0.0325361416,
-0.0310217608,
-0.0225805696,
-0.0026114122,
-0.053434357,
-0.0096596684,
0.0784107894,
-0.0253884029,
-0.0279587619,
0.0176500063,
-0.0002975368,
-0.0192859769,
0.0573671125,
0.0077482127,
0.0374316648,
0.0038777366,
0.0524730757,
-0.0025968647,
0.0339912772,
-0.0015114887,
-0.0496190414,
0.0345465243,
0.0203531552,
-0.0455093123,
0.0670804083,
-0.0775704905,
-0.0160162579,
0.0013592097,
-0.0336117782,
0.0271071624,
-0.0205123723,
0.0017758927,
0.0095095206,
-0.0135124167,
0.0102582872,
0.0019983172,
-0.0295809172,
0.0231851842,
0.0057744547,
0.0033734371,
-0.0002571326,
0.0069561801,
-0.0097691277,
0.0133248949,
0.0208973829,
0.0324059278,
-0.025240289,
-0.0109944819,
-0.0143943997,
-0.004534591,
-0.0314587019,
-0.0190758221,
0.0348873697,
0.0274997391,
0.0280204955,
-0.039250128,
-0.0539662056,
-0.0063546812,
0.0401673876,
-0.0180293061,
0.0478000157,
0.0381056927,
-0.0542654209,
-0.0000452334,
0.0536605492,
0.0061371634,
0.057619337,
-0.0146665424,
-0.0029437311,
-0.0088417856,
0.0320238955,
-0.0005263623,
-0.0246440787,
0.0122780129,
-0.0042659226,
-0.0202470012,
0.0235932507,
0.0508635603,
0.0442381091,
-0.0800883025,
0.0202360749,
0.0312325489,
-0.0062149698,
-0.026439283,
0.00158395,
0.0261477139,
-0.0185131934,
0.0045487876,
0.0090252813,
0.0089360857,
-0.0494897403,
-0.00267651,
0.0401659682,
0.0409741625,
0.0255197268,
0.0424503498,
-0.0975622386,
-0.0300977305,
0.027011605,
0.0156587157,
0.0148842884,
-0.0263271481,
-0.0176769849,
-0.0115445787,
0.0051855398,
0.0028547228,
0.0183446556,
-0.0054006339,
-0.0033278035,
-0.0081020873,
-0.0426072218,
0.0495661683,
0.0100883842,
0.0058854218,
-0.0199779663,
0.0171508603,
0.0114577152,
0.011005884,
0.0230325144,
-0.0280799251,
-0.015330906,
0.0371755771,
-0.0349389724,
0.0014078212,
0.0080685643,
0.0070280894,
-0.0198693629,
-0.0199397728,
0.0066409591,
0.0372877233,
-0.0230378695,
-0.039340619,
-0.0337235481,
0.0064348332,
0.0324884355,
-0.0319181681,
-0.039021872,
0.053611178,
0.0096587352,
0.0058948128,
-0.0288672671,
-0.0478591695,
-0.0245097578,
0.0072683287,
-0.0086954953,
-0.0148638589,
-0.0558784753,
-0.0073087756,
0.0084740464,
-0.0493802875,
-0.0452244543,
-0.0451908298,
0.0104184328,
-0.101470761,
-0.0034641579,
0.0199702326,
-0.0038016415,
0.0349270776,
-0.0091928812,
-0.0777037218,
0.0428365096,
0.0160505846,
-0.1241606176,
0.0129769053,
0.0064470745,
0.0351453051,
-0.0472096354,
0.0094883274,
0.0465272553,
-0.009586866,
-0.0020463848,
0.0035261877,
-0.0948300958,
-0.0442486554,
0.0449643992,
0.0329762213,
0.0199923906,
0.0090290755,
0.0250029974,
-0.0311143287,
0.0347993262,
0.0865291506,
-0.0151520018,
0.0323717035,
0.0431531221,
-0.0165165178,
0.0001062655,
0.0237440057,
-0.0226532463,
0.063915126,
0.0059970543,
0.0310867708,
-0.0427609831,
0.0051160427,
-0.0108528659,
-0.0235410333,
0.0817242712,
0.0026417277,
0.0058582197,
0.0244274698,
0.0357813537,
-0.0012301707,
0.0221154504,
-0.0346420221,
0.0357361212,
0.0139752654,
-0.0081377653,
-0.0294301379,
0.0198267512,
0.0683794394,
-0.0168403294,
0.0375716425,
-0.0132659655,
-0.0746954232,
0.0164032057,
-0.0094805406,
0.0064172451,
-0.0312387347,
-0.0171180032,
0.0232398156,
0.0385629199,
-0.0316806026,
0.002512217,
-0.0036896039,
0.00823595,
-0.044009883,
0.0051238467,
-0.0229937918,
-0.0537419282,
-0.0682379156,
0.0209367946,
0.0235013384,
0.0525932573,
-0.0107712923,
-0.0198789071,
-0.0301070325,
0.0231565721,
-0.0200397745,
0.002229556,
0.005668927,
0.0373057388,
0.0281133633,
0.0137322145,
-0.0383100584,
0.010151376,
-0.0009237983,
0.0264728237,
-0.0113756405,
0.0236767363,
-0.009757895,
-0.0600825623,
-0.0181211028,
-0.0139062926,
0.0352263264,
-0.0327135026,
-0.000770586,
-0.0248283222,
0.0072351531,
-0.0169665813,
0.0161512643,
-0.0152307805,
0.0256182943,
0.0303909313,
-0.0192843303,
-0.097297363,
0.015960861,
-0.0179474503,
0.019122947,
0.0067537874,
0.0135604441,
-6.05599702e-33,
-0.0121606775,
0.0347106457,
0.0310441814,
-0.0320227444,
-0.0263504088,
0.0453688912,
0.0196866915,
-0.0202085227,
-0.0542841852,
-0.024544619,
-0.0252117068,
0.0337609015,
0.0273493249,
0.0279856157,
-0.0478589088,
-0.0165232699,
0.0977884233,
-0.0249256417,
-0.0006233939,
0.049696669,
-0.0015703691,
0.0229765251,
0.0410350151,
0.0202686395,
-0.0911958963,
0.0083091678,
0.0003352936,
-0.0034262626,
0.0281819459,
-0.0135813663,
-0.0448113121,
0.0260010194,
-0.0118015083,
0.0080453334,
0.015682295,
-0.0010823531,
-0.1078584567,
0.0138485506,
-0.0252405759,
0.0341326408,
-0.0051257615,
-0.0462757722,
0.0417158082,
0.0522302352,
-0.0305460803,
-0.0522649735,
-0.0403388776,
0.0518099032,
-0.0338939466,
-0.0901861489,
-0.006445799,
0.0342868045,
0.0214935765,
0.0264302436,
0.0453269333,
-0.0022908149,
-0.0379557535,
-0.0359469056,
-0.0752190799,
-0.0198328514,
0.0296333004,
0.0427886285,
0.0397919044,
0.0418421812,
0.0265683439,
0.0386926532,
0.0944327712,
-0.0413022935,
-0.0176248215,
0.0249663647,
0.0628073961,
0.03636536,
0.0313710384,
-0.0058157719,
0.1241557449,
-0.020659266,
-0.0601878054,
-0.0115550729,
-0.0028340169,
0.0311475489,
0.0270247925,
0.018543398,
-0.0062233694,
-0.0315067992,
0.015967913,
0.0027714383,
-0.0427739918,
-0.0254050344,
0.0006327402,
0.0227189213,
-0.0459597036,
0.0694213435,
0.0276726037,
-0.0284362175,
0.0471804626,
0.0205930863,
0.0329127721,
0.0634386241,
0.0026460278,
0.0221799966,
-0.0112688234,
-0.0313575231,
-0.0017704627,
0.0593818091,
0.0242952965,
-0.0073778182,
0.0270190984,
0.0736631006,
-0.0530930795,
-0.0378000513,
-0.0454089567,
0.0118692555,
0.0156984441,
0.0321629196,
0.0192856062,
0.0278166123,
0.0154761598,
-0.0125456145,
-0.0345693715,
0.0164399073,
-0.0167751033,
0.0098400693,
0.0494522974,
0.0584315434,
-0.0125273932,
0.0096029807,
-0.0438839123,
0.0514038503,
-0.0067080818,
-0.1248837933,
-0.0213733688,
0.0391747057,
2.766e-7,
0.0290111545,
0.0240241867,
0.0090602404,
-0.0351538137,
-0.003428729,
-0.0342491195,
0.0382259972,
0.0392702781,
0.0168715063,
0.0276655909,
0.0372644179,
0.0164727625,
-0.0108513432,
-0.0042081899,
-0.0092830183,
-0.0238809921,
-0.0265882574,
0.0147639187,
-0.0276597049,
-0.050774157,
0.0323860943,
0.1162791327,
-0.0141966511,
-0.0105328476,
0.0854664072,
-0.0009328414,
0.0267266128,
0.0224075243,
0.0836868808,
-0.0023617467,
0.0155849112,
0.0312947854,
0.0023816063,
-0.0245213117,
0.010802269,
-0.0048305779,
-0.0179447271,
0.0926195532,
-0.02664751,
-0.0682054237,
-0.0255735051,
0.0031324057,
-0.0065803514,
-0.018881496,
0.0571025684,
-0.0467547141,
-0.0338406637,
-0.0598644912,
-0.0303900111,
-0.0166879185,
0.0046024611,
-0.0102247205,
0.0309620295,
0.0410439372,
-0.0001413712,
-0.0222941153,
-0.0207364708,
-0.0889103934,
-0.0145396264,
0.0040109493,
-0.0476692393,
-0.0329116732,
-0.0444040708,
-0.0415883586,
0.0233291481,
-0.0260954946,
-0.0130586866,
2.457449689e-34,
0.0379028879,
-0.0175598059,
0.0293546133,
0.0303746052,
-0.0068741222,
-0.0328827649,
0.028510429,
-0.0236129742,
-0.0210346989,
-0.0200441461,
-0.0468714274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17722v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17722v2 | Large Language Models as Generalizable Policies for Embodied Tasks | 2023-10-26T18:32:05 | 2024-04-16T17:54:06 | Andrew Szot, Max Schwarzer, Harsh Agrawal, Bogdan Mazoure, Walter Talbott, Katherine Metcalf, Natalie Mackraz, Devon Hjelm, Alexander Toshev | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We show that large language models (LLMs) can be adapted to be generalizable
policies for embodied visual tasks. Our approach, called Large LAnguage model
Reinforcement Learning Policy (LLaRP), adapts a pre-trained frozen LLM to take
as input text instructions and visual egocentric observations and output
actions directly in the environment. Using reinforcement learning, we train
LLaRP to see and act solely through environmental interactions. We show that
LLaRP is robust to complex paraphrasings of task instructions and can
generalize to new tasks that require novel optimal behavior. In particular, on
1,000 unseen tasks it achieves 42% success rate, 1.7x the success rate of other
common learned baselines or zero-shot applications of LLMs. Finally, to aid the
community in studying language conditioned, massively multi-task, embodied AI
problems we release a novel benchmark, Language Rearrangement, consisting of
150,000 training and 1,000 testing tasks for language-conditioned
rearrangement. Video examples of LLaRP in unseen Language Rearrangement
instructions are at https://llm-rl.github.io. | [
0.0581140071,
0.0507149361,
-0.0008110524,
0.0351399444,
-0.0346969217,
0.0291117206,
-0.0053918418,
0.0237332899,
0.0047496734,
-0.0402632579,
-0.0350950696,
-0.033830449,
0.0042148447,
0.0163382292,
0.040061906,
-0.0868546814,
0.0177119188,
-0.0764806345,
0.0038401117,
0.0137963565,
0.0062700408,
-0.0032765327,
-0.0335179865,
0.0282661896,
-0.0204088651,
0.025631059,
-0.0244364031,
-0.0034056972,
0.0382619575,
-0.036913,
-0.042978961,
0.0058890237,
0.0626977533,
0.0433450527,
0.000002042,
-0.0327435955,
0.0173107591,
-0.0324826874,
0.0402349606,
-0.0189193599,
0.0368146189,
-0.0717712343,
-0.0136024728,
0.0120193157,
-0.0470703505,
-0.0263814349,
0.0709139034,
0.0452136695,
0.0629545897,
0.0878113359,
-0.0053913621,
-0.0048696082,
-0.014444923,
-0.0218956824,
0.0339561626,
0.0107929837,
0.0516990498,
-0.0056287902,
0.0184372216,
0.0212848615,
-0.059665937,
0.0166680366,
0.0370006263,
-0.0239698477,
-0.044404801,
0.0782996193,
-0.0203391481,
-0.0449049883,
-0.0204633027,
0.0907892063,
-0.0529435351,
-0.0044736038,
0.0288267434,
-0.0154691553,
0.010759565,
-0.0228586569,
-0.0344873667,
0.0600707531,
0.0374639854,
0.0308652669,
-0.0292822402,
-0.0097551299,
0.0150060719,
0.0183242299,
-0.0426135994,
0.0447616763,
-0.0082533322,
-0.0187432226,
0.0257435795,
0.0076341401,
-0.0048270631,
-0.0471827351,
-0.0047665075,
0.0444413312,
-0.0395432599,
0.0221106987,
-0.0725323632,
-0.0147847999,
-0.029980924,
-0.0188908931,
0.0874446258,
0.0396524146,
0.007392013,
0.0247539189,
-0.0410546288,
0.1039491147,
-0.0520418026,
0.0532968529,
-0.0375294723,
0.0200397968,
-0.0276001804,
0.0212100893,
-0.0111670746,
-0.0039762254,
-0.0652699545,
-0.0455481149,
-0.0077899382,
0.0174986925,
-0.0042293374,
0.0230274852,
0.002975964,
0.0064047128,
-0.003500317,
-0.0446245223,
-0.0317905694,
-0.0337144472,
0.0022352862,
0.0490713567,
-0.0108391223,
-0.002988368,
-0.0301526282,
0.0317272693,
0.0152117936,
-0.0174411796,
-0.0050696777,
0.1022936776,
-0.0189722646,
-0.0094550578,
0.0126290275,
0.0351499021,
-0.0125681227,
-0.03664729,
0.04466483,
-0.0631861165,
0.0133593446,
-0.0505794063,
0.0261143073,
-0.0589887202,
0.0338607654,
-0.0049686329,
-0.0288876053,
0.0608627982,
0.0545321293,
0.0246389247,
0.002393449,
-0.0090774866,
0.0139228785,
0.0434670597,
0.0676464438,
0.0158209708,
-0.0197500847,
0.004783255,
0.0379658155,
0.0581823215,
-0.0245390758,
0.0549264662,
-0.0305524245,
-0.0189077873,
0.001772945,
0.0677459985,
0.0439597629,
0.0435479023,
-0.0309339426,
-0.0089181941,
0.0678807199,
0.0646744743,
-0.0810102373,
-0.0451502539,
0.0510530993,
0.0160373393,
-0.0368759111,
-0.0299623813,
-0.0667094663,
0.0513135903,
0.0631427988,
-0.0199906658,
-0.0106002502,
0.0036936281,
-0.0293935183,
-0.0382296517,
0.0317920372,
-0.0140510863,
0.0088123176,
0.0012520356,
0.0172661021,
0.0562141389,
-0.0613749884,
-0.0245267693,
0.0063287579,
-0.0368121155,
-0.0188103877,
-0.0304135997,
0.0151537163,
0.0702925697,
-0.0210835971,
-0.0183733348,
-0.0315560773,
-0.0099339401,
0.0198391303,
0.080266133,
-0.00781452,
0.0181085747,
0.0248282216,
-0.0286904071,
-0.0085871574,
0.0032001084,
-0.0019131725,
0.0264122915,
0.0167034436,
0.0200103316,
-0.0181278083,
0.0410211235,
-0.0498840846,
0.0677470118,
-0.0396462902,
-0.0165307261,
0.0326316059,
-0.0068762144,
0.0018456595,
-0.0413106605,
-0.0441064164,
-0.0071454863,
0.0239244699,
-0.0588318296,
-0.0099323941,
0.017306475,
-0.0428165309,
-0.0440447256,
0.022081187,
-0.044620201,
-0.0010082141,
0.0145635419,
-0.0328456536,
-0.0473114289,
0.0237278305,
-0.0005147647,
0.0069251116,
0.0392732099,
0.0053939288,
0.0160219371,
-0.0328764096,
-0.0372805148,
-0.0065675084,
-0.0385020748,
0.0023777187,
0.0108252866,
-0.001278735,
-0.0343773849,
-0.0646822527,
-0.0001598368,
0.0167687908,
0.0339452587,
0.0119263586,
0.0130209159,
0.0551390722,
-0.0273606889,
-0.0476084054,
-0.0498385169,
-0.0257122554,
-0.0090871155,
-0.0148052759,
0.0173709542,
-0.0243448485,
-0.034160234,
-0.016389396,
-0.001690688,
0.0325375535,
0.0014582209,
-0.029747298,
0.0450271107,
0.0026508309,
-0.0174127258,
-0.0460809395,
0.0042662988,
0.0074620778,
0.0202332363,
-0.0002578115,
0.0036497395,
-0.0668167248,
0.0255996622,
-0.0053190012,
0.0527155027,
-0.0288792755,
-0.0387624279,
0.0145143522,
-0.0497109964,
0.0329183564,
0.1174463108,
-0.0256552342,
0.0195089895,
0.0475572012,
0.00511079,
-0.0559562854,
-0.005721454,
-0.0134964464,
-0.0062479777,
-0.0622538626,
-0.0150269065,
0.0048985449,
0.048177585,
-0.0146073755,
0.0216503479,
-0.0859767273,
0.0400813147,
-0.0529479794,
-0.0805013999,
-0.0384760834,
0.0139314039,
-0.0544525906,
0.0001336979,
-0.0780720264,
-0.0381274819,
0.0296545606,
-0.0126243755,
-0.0041474253,
0.011284749,
-0.0162525699,
-0.0172399133,
0.0978130475,
0.0537563749,
0.0359148607,
-0.0247910339,
0.0040233061,
-0.0645680502,
0.0089065097,
-0.0413082205,
0.0097898161,
0.0355401188,
-0.0729862228,
0.0032950835,
-0.0060251439,
-0.0404751785,
-0.0200707838,
-0.0177824646,
-0.023539139,
-0.0069471058,
-0.0401463024,
-0.0503393076,
-0.049866166,
-0.0045633256,
0.0651124939,
0.0474485867,
-0.008501932,
0.0039546541,
-0.0490938649,
-0.0336217284,
0.0545583367,
0.0474457927,
-0.0681952611,
-0.0432928577,
0.009400744,
0.0468778983,
0.053727854,
-0.0168187227,
-0.047979556,
0.0186989624,
0.0136871729,
0.0111559657,
0.0057839989,
0.0118111558,
0.0442687348,
-0.0398899652,
-0.0192147829,
0.0665595457,
0.014359626,
-0.0032660004,
0.0060206265,
0.0448750965,
0.0343112461,
0.0279195905,
0.0437069833,
-0.0432807282,
-0.014137351,
-0.004742906,
-0.0176750775,
0.0378226414,
-0.0357480124,
-0.0135837058,
-0.1223918349,
0.0305411108,
0.0295454487,
-0.0643132851,
-0.033494737,
0.0050534802,
0.0130421976,
-0.0149520822,
-0.0351731256,
0.0043473113,
-0.0011195823,
-0.0103334496,
0.0081946375,
0.0247680284,
-0.006584608,
-0.0277104191,
-0.0292678159,
0.0123954536,
0.0493035465,
0.0285076834,
-0.0517626405,
-0.0366589315,
0.0120248394,
0.0374216586,
-0.007878378,
0.0221593492,
0.0075488542,
-0.0000078779,
-0.023508992,
0.0125752576,
0.0559608378,
-0.0345930383,
-0.0312252585,
0.0189175326,
0.0539036319,
-0.0149644949,
-0.0281712133,
0.0001464309,
-0.0266011171,
0.0126079619,
0.0478720516,
0.0088481922,
-0.0608654469,
-0.0554293953,
-0.0354396664,
-0.0662141144,
-0.0457827039,
-0.0780094266,
-0.0105157699,
-0.041384615,
0.0077118468,
-0.0977866203,
0.0130805159,
0.0476988256,
0.0743649676,
0.0361651741,
-0.0358743966,
0.0448642671,
0.0015769678,
-0.0320439786,
0.0192848891,
-0.024573572,
0.0371582359,
-0.0444092564,
-0.0212757345,
0.0534518547,
0.0000948669,
0.000058841,
0.0059743742,
-0.0231393743,
-0.0640757382,
-0.0087918695,
0.0879416466,
0.013503206,
0.0621185564,
0.0040695891,
-0.0301429275,
0.061238315,
0.0088784546,
0.0031723299,
0.0610233471,
0.0083303815,
0.0135718416,
0.0112497751,
0.0305121392,
-0.0362317227,
0.0322492607,
0.0190711953,
-0.0023089617,
-0.027915515,
0.0055025667,
0.0135263326,
-0.0159592107,
0.0056530214,
-0.0275099501,
0.0173295345,
-0.0399749577,
0.0077642817,
0.0000934161,
-0.0168457553,
-0.0686980337,
0.0167304948,
0.0725820363,
0.0547966585,
0.0208748113,
0.0319760777,
0.018944703,
0.0108982306,
-0.0149801681,
-0.011553322,
0.0173088722,
0.0267303679,
0.0222165398,
0.0773663297,
0.0146086104,
0.0432614945,
-0.044755023,
0.037659537,
0.0199952275,
0.0316539444,
0.0399598666,
-0.0219919048,
-0.0542743541,
0.0321848318,
-0.0669047162,
-0.0520875193,
0.0334150381,
0.0466336347,
0.0547995754,
-0.0114501594,
0.0719887614,
-0.038575884,
-0.0000978701,
0.0201246124,
0.0404641144,
-0.003493805,
-0.0185088534,
0.0226420313,
0.029400507,
0.0091973161,
-0.0015068568,
0.068575114,
0.0242602956,
0.0543427579,
0.0108992392,
0.0329847001,
-0.0300895013,
-0.0062060845,
0.0117775919,
-0.0141056208,
0.0130437193,
0.0125430943,
0.0095907943,
-0.0514668636,
-0.047891397,
0.0535207838,
-0.0156061081,
-0.0336625502,
0.0461894311,
0.0022325905,
0.009744172,
0.007108795,
-0.0227765888,
-0.0433518402,
0.0198328886,
-0.0786205828,
-0.0261545461,
-5.844062001e-33,
-0.0316887945,
-0.0074769077,
0.0348642468,
0.0046749073,
-0.0373864472,
-0.0106106978,
-0.0199010391,
0.0188313276,
0.0247923471,
0.0232514273,
0.0198519342,
0.0027194542,
0.0067829257,
0.017961638,
0.0120975683,
0.0140857296,
0.0093145967,
-0.0437900163,
-0.0250874236,
-0.0024462454,
0.0298166573,
0.011692239,
0.0198060181,
-0.0376232602,
0.0109121287,
0.0152607542,
-0.0127135264,
0.0414380729,
-0.0109439138,
0.0421155468,
-0.0281473305,
-0.0365498997,
0.0087905778,
-0.0037776357,
-0.0395052731,
0.0668205246,
-0.0556040071,
-0.0279193763,
-0.0041194116,
0.0149128102,
-0.1182303652,
-0.0117417816,
0.0585624985,
0.0104017779,
-0.0392905921,
0.0383380242,
0.0023840154,
-0.0109067969,
-0.0008404552,
0.047545407,
-0.0211916938,
-0.0011160175,
-0.0182986483,
-0.0355713181,
0.0653925687,
-0.0033867278,
-0.0057758731,
-0.0045445338,
-0.0161568429,
0.0213248152,
-0.0187097155,
0.0028165225,
0.0257592276,
0.0542006232,
0.0307176728,
0.0662850365,
0.0010579163,
0.000803761,
-0.0212426893,
-0.0303137824,
0.0282747243,
0.0608791821,
-0.0094731785,
0.0303134192,
-0.0111594014,
0.0175873786,
-0.0452333242,
0.018509604,
-0.0199061017,
0.0387137942,
0.0216227416,
0.025712898,
-0.0277759507,
-0.0080319596,
-0.0405021831,
0.0198885575,
-0.0203231592,
0.0064783087,
0.0608104505,
0.0403760038,
-0.0006278093,
-0.0407784022,
0.0451321788,
-0.0253886916,
-0.0086382106,
-0.0121478755,
-0.0632407367,
0.0410667248,
-0.003609628,
-0.0151235182,
-0.0775762945,
-0.0457982793,
0.0339485779,
0.0020998258,
0.0036420021,
0.0021399688,
0.0360560678,
0.0364619978,
-0.0589715764,
-0.0033228646,
-0.0142281437,
-0.0045154146,
0.0386571549,
0.0134756984,
0.0262780599,
0.0033823929,
-0.0223253909,
0.0223157201,
0.0204328522,
-0.0572612286,
0.0106135812,
0.0171669703,
-0.043195948,
0.0280110203,
-0.0334517211,
-0.0142471194,
-0.040852502,
0.0089464234,
0.0231845882,
-0.0904596522,
-0.011110805,
0.004503848,
2.814e-7,
-0.0013902308,
0.0395400226,
-0.0023745303,
0.0081635294,
0.0525681004,
0.0311779696,
-0.0636579022,
0.0506920815,
-0.0493535735,
-0.0300290659,
0.0241499189,
0.0568469912,
0.0308972802,
-0.0433676131,
-0.0826069489,
0.0120303705,
-0.0317961462,
-0.0301756579,
-0.0704420805,
-0.0397787988,
0.0114403097,
0.0889126807,
0.0010374651,
0.0037797589,
0.0176322404,
-0.0330691375,
0.0585395321,
-0.0579092763,
0.024404414,
-0.0477268696,
-0.0190807022,
0.0169296935,
-0.0267044846,
-0.0158078298,
0.0142170237,
0.0005137356,
0.0251597296,
0.0757475123,
-0.0356394947,
0.0264330935,
-0.0017414667,
0.0370284729,
0.0034956918,
-0.0243787151,
0.0532241017,
-0.0737039074,
0.0051584197,
0.0014772973,
0.0066517941,
-0.0039154575,
0.0114764497,
-0.00592267,
-0.0022814532,
0.007391952,
0.033088427,
-0.0142253805,
-0.008302507,
-0.060848482,
-0.0447235666,
-0.0122795198,
-0.0198239051,
0.0126510551,
-0.0407043584,
0.0122040827,
-0.0286677089,
-0.0232037492,
-0.0345916413,
2.206670367e-34,
-0.0058363858,
0.0060928282,
-0.0058936523,
0.0131034888,
0.0158135556,
0.003633992,
-0.024386283,
0.0310534239,
0.0445656665,
-0.044997137,
-0.0347757414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17721v1 | From Transcripts to Insights: Uncovering Corporate Risks Using Generative AI | 2023-10-26T18:30:37 | 2023-10-26T18:30:37 | Alex Kim, Maximilian Muhn, Valeri Nikolaev | econ.GN | econ.GN, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.EC | We explore the value of generative AI tools, such as ChatGPT, in helping
investors uncover dimensions of corporate risk. We develop and validate
firm-level measures of risk exposure to political, climate, and AI-related
risks. Using the GPT 3.5 model to generate risk summaries and assessments from
the context provided by earnings call transcripts, we show that GPT-based
measures possess significant information content and outperform the existing
risk measures in predicting (abnormal) firm-level volatility and firms' choices
such as investment and innovation. Importantly, information in risk assessments
dominates that in risk summaries, establishing the value of general AI
knowledge. We also find that generative AI is effective at detecting emerging
risks, such as AI risk, which has soared in recent quarters. Our measures
perform well both within and outside the GPT's training window and are priced
in equity markets. Taken together, an AI-based approach to risk measurement
provides useful insights to users of corporate disclosures at a low cost. | [
-0.0276993383,
0.0364547595,
-0.0360157117,
-0.0469893329,
0.001552097,
-0.0114345597,
0.0119425915,
0.0064532151,
0.0282870643,
-0.0138338525,
0.0236097239,
-0.0003837451,
-0.0472487137,
0.0796376318,
0.0245802104,
-0.0378491655,
0.033997599,
-0.0159213729,
0.0744222328,
0.0015333357,
0.0157454032,
-0.0026721279,
0.0215399284,
0.0246596839,
-0.0457473956,
-0.0347552635,
-0.00563735,
0.0014350667,
0.0618283153,
-0.0168194771,
-0.0209984891,
-0.0245433822,
0.0149739236,
0.0301503353,
0.000001942,
-0.0504155345,
-0.0414800756,
-0.0118285175,
0.0185862891,
-0.0045801015,
0.0243065618,
0.0046793232,
0.0149031142,
0.0236408617,
-0.0933607221,
-0.006887184,
0.0549785569,
0.0400608294,
0.0296544656,
0.050966315,
-0.0155829648,
0.0091636926,
0.0548256561,
-0.0673125386,
0.019484885,
-0.0844465569,
0.0015599732,
-0.0092327232,
-0.0378132723,
-0.0182169899,
0.0120310271,
0.0653217286,
0.0285560656,
-0.0145611903,
0.0183872189,
0.0225709099,
0.0112030916,
0.0138009069,
-0.0423333682,
0.0160889719,
0.0415146314,
0.0501952916,
-0.0022648603,
-0.0276052337,
0.0776618198,
0.0119582703,
-0.0086959573,
0.0271350276,
-0.0368198007,
0.021380106,
0.0537798479,
0.0453587621,
0.000406785,
0.0070722131,
0.0136145251,
0.0193449706,
-0.021989461,
-0.0237758923,
0.0253459401,
0.0082910983,
0.0442403518,
-0.0379659645,
0.0041898466,
0.0090455292,
-0.0063289301,
0.0126601644,
-0.0215490758,
-0.0257915445,
-0.0245980304,
-0.077145651,
-0.0202406179,
0.0199575946,
0.002592982,
0.0415746011,
0.0118832365,
0.027042659,
0.0281096026,
-0.0190344714,
-0.0075456123,
0.0139227128,
-0.0252003465,
0.014735451,
-0.0220206175,
0.0735612735,
-0.0140978787,
-0.0175830834,
-0.0666175783,
0.0342378095,
-0.0638066456,
0.0231213905,
0.0013102848,
-0.0113510555,
-0.0076349289,
0.009677914,
-0.030147491,
-0.0727671683,
-0.0681708679,
0.0151778888,
-0.0001350763,
-0.0364285186,
0.0226782728,
0.0115243513,
0.003137399,
0.0058311881,
-0.0116793159,
0.0839434862,
0.033598721,
-0.0299913697,
-0.020714296,
-0.0554308556,
0.0119986832,
-0.0345979892,
-0.025752984,
0.0140653923,
0.0048987465,
-0.0421278961,
-0.025371233,
-0.0290594157,
0.0049277623,
-0.0271625742,
0.0219703522,
0.0513552353,
0.0235564727,
-0.0332932509,
0.0089336857,
-0.0072370945,
-0.0195142645,
0.0592024475,
0.0126045048,
0.0160224214,
0.0597145595,
-0.008789409,
0.0404034443,
0.0432117619,
0.0319088176,
0.0048585036,
0.0375382416,
0.0135311978,
-0.0208244156,
-0.0555557534,
0.0202623773,
0.0336781964,
0.0057529304,
-0.0096563855,
0.0753815696,
0.0242154729,
0.0038891484,
0.0723021924,
0.0023120586,
-0.006653598,
-0.0207628254,
-0.0038220377,
0.0116775669,
0.0209917035,
-0.0592796244,
0.0112840328,
0.0537354015,
0.0239841696,
-0.0401864052,
-0.0475596786,
0.0209754501,
0.017461922,
0.0022909322,
0.0111661162,
-0.0183233935,
-0.0477366336,
-0.0216343477,
0.0044057942,
0.0160591044,
-0.0480217524,
-0.0054720384,
-0.0653047264,
0.0247084666,
0.0732478425,
0.0122071831,
-0.0236078557,
0.0288411267,
-0.0289139636,
-0.0771581978,
0.0009844225,
0.0522882342,
0.0060081976,
-0.0484105274,
-0.0202251561,
-0.0221099593,
0.0378872529,
0.0409550108,
0.0477308631,
-0.0220937021,
0.0125911338,
-0.0091935443,
-0.0368986651,
-0.0157298744,
0.0194642395,
0.0029710138,
-0.052199956,
0.0286835209,
-0.0182214733,
0.0304961167,
0.0258629601,
0.0002697094,
0.0156901162,
0.0046422556,
-0.0036564316,
-0.0573411509,
0.0105322991,
-0.0267491974,
0.0424079038,
-0.0423358344,
-0.0337261409,
0.0283113029,
-0.024380289,
-0.0150213949,
-0.0051141977,
0.0330808237,
-0.0308391787,
-0.0044437232,
-0.0647148266,
-0.0794202834,
0.0211781878,
0.0395956971,
0.0217793137,
0.091910325,
-0.0284348987,
-0.0408326536,
-0.0413626246,
-0.027151024,
-0.0136162303,
-0.0631579384,
0.0397795103,
-0.0098262066,
-0.0376178846,
0.0693568662,
0.0524818674,
-0.0208032411,
0.0157974232,
-0.0358655341,
-0.0630487502,
-0.0382990576,
-0.0213723667,
0.0283801109,
0.0043534199,
0.0279957801,
-0.0487317517,
-0.0029421833,
-0.048867628,
-0.0490935966,
-0.0309460368,
0.023548197,
0.0043284036,
0.0286120865,
-0.0015201003,
-0.0319204181,
-0.0055368757,
-0.0246091485,
0.0379535221,
0.0828570873,
-0.0293450076,
-0.0059337253,
0.0009869057,
-0.0186122954,
0.0193161368,
-0.0016285507,
0.007304125,
-0.0075446665,
-0.0155503415,
0.0394643769,
0.0711301342,
0.0382005163,
0.081529133,
-0.0418115221,
0.0081425374,
-0.0261108726,
0.052991692,
-0.0323597826,
-0.0027058176,
0.0090222042,
-0.0361522287,
0.0234632976,
-0.0168532245,
0.0026706085,
-0.0262581147,
-0.0699055046,
0.0680568069,
-0.0163833722,
-0.0257019997,
-0.0039601787,
-0.0333316363,
-0.0038608143,
0.0927656591,
0.0211393628,
-0.0642454252,
0.0380218849,
0.0251193661,
0.0099494103,
-0.0165089965,
-0.0636005104,
-0.0345543362,
0.052859921,
-0.0245455168,
-0.0128206424,
-0.0001808625,
0.0082658669,
-0.0468465984,
-0.0346450433,
0.0474933162,
-0.0315063037,
-0.0001284717,
-0.0277617704,
0.0117816348,
0.0289580747,
-0.0203113444,
-0.0183042362,
-0.0338075124,
0.0125029078,
0.0684416369,
0.0826124325,
-0.027304979,
-0.0338443033,
0.0094303377,
0.0100332443,
0.010491279,
-0.0193143673,
-0.0370512381,
0.0318563469,
0.0082130656,
0.0475527346,
-0.0413766168,
0.0434018262,
-0.0208602026,
0.0512897931,
0.0233624708,
0.0493130945,
0.0103612039,
-0.0208118856,
0.0127869602,
-0.0589750335,
0.009045301,
0.038956143,
0.0240945462,
0.006230813,
-0.0201849863,
0.0185345337,
0.0417988412,
-0.0279037189,
0.0059387456,
0.0212477986,
0.0219116341,
0.0475311317,
-0.0376375802,
0.0397561602,
-0.0570582636,
0.0314938612,
-0.0290713068,
0.0205716807,
-0.0162302516,
-0.0806118473,
0.0036502976,
-0.0894344673,
0.0900523439,
-0.0125308689,
-0.0358976908,
-0.0346229747,
-0.037225049,
0.0112946182,
-0.0683180243,
-0.0281747635,
-0.0159062929,
-0.0049062739,
0.0168165807,
0.0100674648,
-0.1131514087,
0.0107656941,
0.0185224134,
0.0010979646,
-0.0587508753,
0.0953969285,
0.0110237477,
-0.0376946814,
0.0044861068,
-0.0436210595,
-0.0270831697,
0.0115619535,
0.0477784351,
0.1022918224,
-0.0173272341,
-0.013667129,
0.0060737045,
0.0646825284,
0.0266511403,
0.0480219871,
0.0238821469,
0.02370313,
-0.0400960445,
-0.0388520248,
0.0114444159,
0.0480774157,
0.0563690029,
0.0159127582,
0.0168659147,
-0.0228163172,
-0.0348558351,
-0.0752968341,
0.0697400421,
-0.0832810998,
0.0162803307,
-0.0007099143,
0.0026061006,
-0.0771619007,
-0.0693784654,
-0.0867249519,
-0.035114821,
0.0154449809,
0.0052759084,
-0.0346498527,
0.0188311506,
0.0344605558,
-0.0183973908,
-0.0236420073,
0.0179216899,
-0.0013183063,
0.0298353024,
0.0031176242,
-0.0179838128,
-0.0034055403,
-0.0459658466,
0.0771361366,
-0.0683624744,
-0.0490168817,
-0.005588606,
0.0503334403,
0.0329640321,
-0.0406021513,
-0.0481490977,
0.0470045209,
0.0853803083,
0.056153778,
-0.0560244732,
-0.0278625973,
0.0582497828,
0.0156530663,
-0.0242699534,
0.0216871388,
-0.0379389487,
0.0054681711,
-0.0417308733,
0.0038309104,
-0.0571736507,
-0.0436220318,
-0.0323149562,
-0.0156982038,
0.0154030053,
0.0012288537,
-0.0305838492,
-0.0350776687,
-0.0465611927,
0.0382690504,
0.0324029066,
-0.0087215109,
-0.0207213331,
0.0106209703,
-0.0110580754,
-0.0124217588,
0.0698506311,
-0.0287622008,
-0.0296802092,
-0.0670254603,
0.0302631985,
-0.0003581903,
0.0086456519,
-0.0143345706,
-0.0117570888,
-0.005176425,
-0.0201437771,
0.0248562321,
-0.0070697623,
0.0178518053,
-0.0141988434,
-0.005031209,
0.0340940021,
0.0498928353,
-0.0046390081,
-0.0872035548,
-0.0469867587,
-0.0028765528,
0.077922225,
-0.0178295337,
0.0289386213,
0.0015810796,
-0.052222617,
0.0201626103,
0.0172783509,
0.0427044183,
0.0287510492,
-0.0424471945,
0.017613735,
0.0018276456,
-0.0539154001,
-0.0351860113,
0.0659313649,
0.0104417428,
0.058542043,
-0.0485826917,
-0.0168090239,
-0.0409917273,
-0.0487132706,
0.0361740105,
0.0139538962,
0.0270367283,
0.0258672871,
-0.0956214145,
-0.0386427119,
0.0096627586,
0.0052027986,
0.0115739973,
0.0081662871,
-0.0050984379,
0.0406162925,
-0.0218189973,
0.0325539559,
-0.0086661074,
-0.010262399,
-0.0707120672,
-0.0039308378,
-0.0749835223,
-6.267387638e-33,
-0.0065200627,
-0.0406739078,
-0.0004385857,
0.0300185494,
0.0092446087,
0.0282238834,
-0.0023332913,
0.007599731,
-0.0156225087,
0.0254057292,
0.0157515872,
0.0348303691,
-0.0022176774,
-0.0021736093,
0.0062162387,
-0.0348644704,
-0.000208111,
-0.0442717932,
-0.0027962895,
0.0228227731,
-0.000630839,
0.019579323,
0.0256701596,
-0.0586213209,
0.0107638417,
-0.0014902805,
-0.0765936077,
-0.0684028864,
0.0312345736,
0.030482702,
0.0208251774,
0.0310799386,
0.0035541684,
-0.0913964733,
0.0146196457,
0.0178032611,
-0.0072656595,
-0.0629604086,
-0.0044158334,
-0.0241815001,
0.0081349872,
-0.0304390267,
-0.0105397003,
0.0111045241,
0.0068024825,
-0.0269576721,
0.0350067616,
0.0114024132,
-0.0122925118,
-0.1063519642,
-0.015993841,
0.0350981802,
-0.0324287005,
0.0264503248,
-0.0057482026,
0.0978007242,
0.0116249081,
-0.0074451081,
-0.0244553108,
0.0074562239,
0.0270532239,
-0.0133977495,
0.001416018,
0.0015413992,
0.0009293584,
0.0363126025,
0.0080213742,
0.0109084481,
-0.0520846285,
-0.0206184983,
-0.0067586768,
0.0467247143,
-0.0113574537,
0.0409757867,
0.0005731717,
-0.0055667507,
-0.0908154324,
0.0754094422,
-0.0170410555,
0.036642842,
0.0494616255,
-0.0146121886,
-0.0452930294,
-0.0332674086,
0.0075952029,
-0.0418109037,
-0.0106654856,
0.0225032642,
-0.0061911521,
0.0007408598,
-0.0019965398,
0.0276717525,
0.0249573942,
-0.017985886,
-0.0037939672,
0.0088558812,
0.007142697,
-0.0181646459,
0.0059590884,
-0.0034549353,
0.0100335125,
-0.0039803223,
0.0348267071,
0.0472535752,
0.0010244367,
-0.0212081596,
0.047047928,
0.0043707737,
-0.0194014087,
-0.0015874821,
0.0036986195,
0.0710956976,
0.0182050895,
-0.0194464661,
0.0091574192,
0.0016741023,
0.0053467052,
-0.019132819,
0.0160735324,
0.0804790482,
0.004634168,
-0.0091098361,
-0.0495358519,
0.0108111566,
-0.0040926561,
0.0332730338,
0.0213902853,
0.0257990286,
0.0405661836,
-0.0453083143,
-0.0167246554,
0.0288255736,
2.687e-7,
0.0431852303,
0.0276844259,
0.0099937776,
0.0315575749,
0.0345649198,
0.0719855502,
0.0456448831,
0.0333355032,
0.006666291,
-0.0056979256,
0.0649461299,
0.0205419548,
0.0336402804,
0.0513938963,
-0.0335811377,
-0.0804574862,
-0.0774298906,
0.0412982069,
-0.0634902716,
0.0329900458,
0.0570587926,
0.0368917957,
0.021653071,
-0.0116396239,
0.0247285143,
-0.0259312633,
0.0502895117,
-0.050489787,
-0.0176056866,
0.0033932289,
0.0367883779,
0.0394477919,
-0.0013906281,
0.0390257277,
-0.0431395844,
-0.0240067206,
0.0181605108,
-0.0118835242,
0.0309241004,
0.001833326,
0.0276922435,
0.0013670232,
0.0005744407,
-0.0370388366,
0.0305188503,
-0.0316679776,
-0.0095728673,
-0.0362293944,
-0.0313863233,
0.0623606071,
0.0038708099,
-0.0076371077,
-0.0123927733,
0.0201890282,
-0.017047327,
-0.0164037012,
0.0545563363,
-0.0168829653,
-0.0219708681,
0.011705948,
-0.0311699789,
-0.0129292374,
-0.0135301892,
0.0155452797,
0.0294678081,
-0.0134263514,
0.0477300994,
2.186112073e-34,
0.0652222633,
-0.018314885,
-0.0706948191,
-0.0118977241,
0.084446542,
0.0136277135,
-0.0131504713,
0.0140675548,
0.0103529617,
-0.0511523895,
-0.0462761596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17715v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17715v2 | Outlier Dimensions Encode Task-Specific Knowledge | 2023-10-26T18:22:13 | 2024-01-23T18:19:18 | William Rudman, Catherine Chen, Carsten Eickhoff | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representations from large language models (LLMs) are known to be dominated
by a small subset of dimensions with exceedingly high variance. Previous works
have argued that although ablating these outlier dimensions in LLM
representations hurts downstream performance, outlier dimensions are
detrimental to the representational quality of embeddings. In this study, we
investigate how fine-tuning impacts outlier dimensions and show that 1) outlier
dimensions that occur in pre-training persist in fine-tuned models and 2) a
single outlier dimension can complete downstream tasks with a minimal error
rate. Our results suggest that outlier dimensions can encode crucial
task-specific knowledge and that the value of a representation in a single
outlier dimension drives downstream model decisions. | [
-0.0169979427,
-0.0110464832,
-0.0227485187,
0.0257815104,
0.0009794952,
0.0412242375,
-0.0090821572,
-0.0129871275,
-0.0425521024,
-0.0245883893,
-0.03662863,
-0.024089545,
-0.0044597094,
0.0446814708,
0.0449897945,
-0.0030417619,
0.044764664,
-0.0486150905,
0.027377665,
-0.0180694629,
-0.0070303516,
-0.0058056545,
0.044471398,
0.0420312136,
0.0050931815,
-0.0251865815,
0.016795991,
-0.0142352339,
-0.0047320505,
0.005086273,
-0.0136165991,
0.0526743755,
0.0685570836,
0.0227880944,
0.0000016607,
-0.0283897277,
0.0397095904,
-0.0139046116,
-0.0506600179,
0.0549747646,
-0.0144925816,
-0.0271625463,
0.0104516521,
0.0010785908,
0.0109759392,
-0.0486170091,
0.0372110978,
0.0606653653,
0.0026479552,
0.0945594311,
-0.0001824072,
0.0085502919,
0.0157436933,
-0.0540581718,
0.011653957,
-0.0116812233,
-0.0014170196,
-0.0257381368,
-0.0363453664,
0.0334441438,
-0.0663505048,
-0.0158319902,
0.0088550104,
0.0414474979,
0.0188494287,
0.0343784913,
0.015912706,
-0.0089443652,
0.0285084471,
0.0588558502,
-0.0465071276,
0.0260370169,
-0.0394730382,
-0.0304004382,
0.0211300272,
0.0062613091,
-0.058147572,
0.0113768047,
0.030518068,
0.0406356864,
0.0158390123,
0.0093780207,
0.0602011345,
-0.0244328175,
-0.0105529837,
0.0283238962,
0.0102130091,
-0.0345629938,
-0.0063573522,
0.0072348365,
-0.0414503552,
-0.0024038649,
-0.0153303863,
-0.0179330856,
0.0097678639,
-0.0008140518,
-0.0073385397,
-0.0042429492,
0.0306833591,
-0.0393995084,
0.0842777118,
0.0491714031,
-0.0458172522,
0.0437522605,
-0.0234515537,
0.0664210841,
-0.0102218492,
0.0682262033,
-0.0193500333,
-0.0077512083,
-0.0043029315,
-0.0180862136,
-0.0027843642,
0.0037080105,
-0.0351826586,
-0.0149930203,
0.0018554897,
0.0549377054,
-0.0192576852,
0.008388971,
0.0017388442,
0.0094287451,
-0.0103673907,
-0.0142927431,
-0.0211968422,
0.0435159393,
-0.0688109845,
0.036936637,
0.0040533049,
-0.0311489832,
-0.0475094318,
0.0149900923,
0.0287304651,
-0.0427417383,
0.0136740701,
0.0415397882,
0.0109888911,
-0.0441409312,
0.0066620903,
0.002777705,
-0.024307929,
-0.0830074251,
0.0106891319,
-0.0418626741,
0.0206058566,
0.0196795259,
-0.0029292197,
-0.0559672415,
-0.0075746691,
0.0091881379,
-0.0511574969,
0.0449614637,
0.0300604049,
0.0237335227,
-0.0054434515,
0.0056309197,
-0.0238101296,
0.0608611777,
-0.0194175523,
-0.0037913048,
0.018650217,
-0.0420296453,
0.0167020969,
0.0162404403,
0.0080304397,
-0.003952744,
-0.0302935019,
0.0159185231,
0.0586164482,
0.0456922948,
0.0708621517,
-0.0090591302,
-0.0417191125,
-0.0140934289,
0.0826494694,
0.0551975258,
0.013748548,
-0.013579444,
-0.0008484455,
-0.0167637002,
-0.0167792886,
0.0219536722,
-0.0839308277,
0.05591245,
0.0275004953,
-0.0272138063,
0.0379114002,
0.0508059449,
-0.0633901581,
-0.0116122924,
-0.046413403,
-0.0207444075,
0.0048258039,
-0.0076833968,
0.048416473,
-0.017935412,
-0.0290434957,
0.0063797073,
0.0253572203,
-0.0099825738,
0.0105728069,
-0.000068951,
0.011848663,
0.0720034614,
0.0257278327,
0.0041541853,
-0.0032123637,
-0.0063636396,
0.0382755399,
0.0194178,
0.0556330346,
-0.0098172026,
0.0374884568,
-0.0563310944,
-0.0285177995,
-0.0460414216,
0.0429200828,
-0.0048969961,
-0.0235597659,
-0.0201072861,
0.0179512147,
-0.0967354774,
-0.0446597897,
0.0415457226,
-0.0356624462,
-0.0549406596,
-0.0231428146,
0.0145428842,
-0.0290911142,
-0.0143061392,
-0.0023228661,
0.0258082151,
0.0047100284,
-0.0482238866,
-0.0024610625,
-0.0080121942,
-0.0790633783,
-0.0154006705,
0.0310791824,
-0.0003182898,
-0.0100873392,
0.0264647286,
-0.0149892243,
-0.0265222918,
0.0284168068,
-0.0250816289,
0.0465820059,
-0.058146514,
-0.0055197687,
-0.0141491517,
0.0397352166,
-0.0104973018,
0.0529738106,
-0.0286024902,
0.0366773307,
-0.0121525358,
-0.0048525035,
0.0020717906,
0.0108895991,
-0.0212814286,
0.0103709903,
-0.0025923115,
0.0367269218,
-0.0048646107,
-0.0477422513,
-0.0256477185,
0.0075646755,
-0.0334058814,
-0.0028972083,
-0.0280740187,
0.0082318475,
0.0194130447,
-0.0104352366,
0.0020549672,
-0.003799672,
-0.0298241004,
-0.0280893259,
0.0083567565,
0.0538550764,
0.0186261367,
0.0035058861,
-0.0024657066,
-0.0104813073,
-0.0205242727,
0.0084957844,
0.0525138564,
-0.0569218285,
0.0342652388,
-0.0592138991,
0.0084157111,
-0.0235043745,
0.0062291124,
-0.0168287065,
-0.0473079085,
0.0119522531,
-0.0050310497,
0.0768706501,
0.0528738052,
-0.0271585155,
0.0408974402,
0.0825973153,
-0.0149440737,
-0.0375132971,
-0.0145875113,
-0.0329059176,
-0.0122383302,
-0.0548311099,
0.0270420704,
-0.0292816535,
0.0524228029,
-0.0025269592,
-0.0288235825,
-0.0582232811,
0.0460734963,
-0.0145924157,
-0.0062407688,
-0.0144449659,
0.0046647624,
-0.039106261,
0.0856170654,
-0.0498052798,
-0.0511123054,
0.0498084426,
-0.0007440744,
-0.0309847686,
-0.0060686558,
0.0154851573,
-0.0155837778,
0.0326347165,
0.0010150262,
0.0202857833,
-0.0417585745,
-0.0357326269,
-0.0739266053,
0.0284844972,
0.0321721472,
-0.0139002921,
0.044122979,
0.0023567162,
-0.048545748,
-0.011278755,
-0.0244952794,
-0.0212276503,
-0.0445279963,
0.0200080872,
0.0317860469,
-0.0077364333,
-0.008601022,
-0.0262683686,
-0.0260869954,
-0.0046558999,
0.0348725431,
-0.0328576341,
0.009542861,
-0.0144887166,
0.0088338042,
0.0243628807,
0.0273658428,
0.0451984555,
-0.0462821387,
0.01611582,
0.026179824,
-0.0146014653,
-0.0100989463,
0.0183932725,
0.0253288001,
0.0329806879,
-0.0019077396,
-0.0337800905,
0.0360768549,
0.0882106796,
-0.019660864,
-0.0419728085,
0.0981376991,
-0.0010905282,
-0.0178190954,
0.0435542464,
-0.0266973581,
0.0438337512,
0.0609686598,
-0.003382673,
-0.0313235484,
0.0144961262,
0.0153650027,
0.0247760378,
0.0296413954,
-0.0229530521,
0.00662649,
-0.1080043316,
0.0378799178,
0.0309669003,
-0.0105917575,
-0.0705201179,
-0.0462493151,
0.0051566837,
0.0061762459,
0.0772188455,
0.0206507742,
-0.0032822832,
-0.016089702,
0.0226706564,
0.0026366496,
-0.0806425586,
0.0713547245,
-0.0490539372,
0.0488132685,
0.0407657251,
-0.0007527578,
-0.0087066609,
-0.0120554622,
0.0234650746,
-0.0114714978,
0.019071579,
0.0082410872,
0.0556830429,
0.0270466581,
-0.0343322158,
-0.0156941339,
-0.0021227577,
-0.0353215002,
-0.0139575405,
-0.0517274067,
0.1145543829,
-0.0157123152,
-0.0275693033,
0.0156802777,
-0.0401815251,
-0.0135728829,
0.0767174512,
0.039909225,
-0.0388665572,
-0.0262931082,
-0.0238430277,
-0.0019850819,
0.0082610818,
0.0040708859,
0.0485248119,
0.0649273172,
-0.0412529074,
-0.0370318964,
-0.064193666,
0.0323102437,
0.0218613241,
0.0042749001,
0.0092199463,
-0.0599210635,
-0.0180914812,
-0.0471657738,
0.0517491959,
-0.0218703896,
-0.0164921451,
0.0074124695,
0.0114186695,
0.01234747,
0.0140614798,
-0.0159382559,
-0.0265373737,
-0.0593210608,
-0.0739911646,
0.0006725524,
0.013063618,
0.0199242085,
0.0398127809,
0.0000712285,
-0.0624252856,
0.0347322524,
-0.0194472764,
-0.0628067851,
0.0374650508,
0.0471438356,
-0.060571108,
0.0026444527,
0.0684400871,
-0.0199164506,
-0.0027994858,
0.0368002281,
0.0172142647,
0.0290520769,
-0.022716729,
0.0170692652,
-0.0278117433,
0.0866711512,
0.0012341969,
-0.0098141441,
-0.0646104589,
0.0011047847,
-0.0442199036,
0.0063982066,
-0.0131035279,
-0.0381105803,
0.0609352589,
0.0386827514,
-0.0132202217,
0.0548358262,
0.0245841686,
0.050266467,
-0.0516742803,
0.0075927926,
0.0001997571,
-0.0229348969,
0.0390061848,
0.0485822111,
-0.0315355733,
0.0160852391,
-0.0415889397,
0.0012306609,
-0.035367392,
-0.0031506275,
0.0082513466,
0.0480642803,
-0.0571641997,
0.0049725431,
-0.0477774851,
-0.0828194246,
-0.0119931018,
-0.0308450535,
0.0351711214,
-0.0500289984,
0.0332101136,
-0.0051214341,
-0.0157691445,
-0.0418023504,
0.0045102937,
-0.0418539569,
0.0005841795,
0.0316389874,
0.0305718482,
-0.0207575429,
-0.0267313123,
0.0863240808,
0.0010046025,
0.082182236,
-0.0331685878,
0.0141703729,
-0.0192496944,
-0.0072351182,
0.0237407703,
0.069638975,
-0.0122045409,
0.0153031955,
-0.0603638552,
-0.0744919404,
-0.0133919735,
-0.0174435899,
-0.0265034903,
0.0045475457,
0.0111049032,
0.0525403917,
-0.0236191582,
-0.0072401501,
-0.0041415645,
-0.0367612243,
-0.0026872109,
0.000143552,
0.0092990091,
-6.427716986e-33,
-0.0135666495,
-0.0023765324,
0.0008763038,
-0.0586460754,
0.0112250065,
-0.0202137176,
-0.0116855558,
0.0290011112,
-0.0460211858,
0.0190949179,
-0.0184775591,
0.0007399677,
-0.0022602363,
0.0224524569,
0.0456821844,
-0.0039184326,
0.0561750978,
-0.0155611355,
-0.0167490859,
0.0116469208,
0.0534836613,
0.0247357003,
0.1041087434,
-0.0289247762,
0.0196912251,
0.0092542628,
0.0000785698,
0.0271604732,
0.0085314196,
0.0479493737,
-0.0273368787,
0.0777854472,
0.0381162427,
-0.0533437692,
-0.0715506673,
-0.0171386786,
-0.0592605434,
-0.0553314164,
0.0352649502,
-0.0032014544,
0.0199629553,
-0.0492410138,
0.0421547554,
-0.0316606872,
-0.0060770954,
-0.0465577617,
0.0182795506,
-0.0207567159,
-0.0504741184,
0.053018745,
-0.0849010795,
0.0034708933,
-0.0088921199,
-0.0176088624,
0.031504415,
-0.0097060455,
0.0322205983,
-0.0090898164,
-0.0410983041,
0.0157132689,
-0.0393375941,
0.0359205119,
0.0213979855,
0.0352828354,
0.0016332024,
0.0805173069,
0.0423720926,
0.0226420537,
-0.0120701296,
-0.0083754668,
0.0722414851,
0.0534919351,
0.0174467377,
0.026431147,
0.0438849293,
-0.0186805762,
-0.0690036565,
-0.0296653006,
-0.0031848338,
-0.0078462185,
0.0217924546,
0.0063511725,
-0.0341170058,
-0.0703271329,
-0.0327737629,
-0.0239571631,
-0.0284718927,
-0.0236805715,
0.0292303916,
0.0153314425,
0.0363950357,
-0.0169746708,
0.0359155647,
-0.0314196236,
0.0070405216,
0.0262502413,
-0.0190876517,
-0.0054569654,
0.0233775731,
-0.0154350698,
-0.0475802347,
-0.0337757729,
0.0049456684,
-0.0237936024,
-0.0055164518,
0.009997529,
0.0820251703,
0.0205009542,
-0.0803620443,
-0.0084527386,
-0.0534284636,
0.0012597503,
0.0452669486,
0.067973569,
0.0521283671,
-0.025287563,
-0.0263736099,
0.0458628833,
0.0242237523,
0.0074426364,
-0.039918799,
0.0051794983,
0.0014559444,
-0.0081878426,
-0.0187663995,
-0.0279467031,
-0.0403099395,
-0.021276677,
0.0709111616,
-0.0076267258,
-0.0200264491,
-0.019975476,
2.332e-7,
0.0407521687,
0.0486371852,
0.0006763161,
0.0080302702,
0.0510309376,
0.0303757228,
-0.0235555209,
0.013346158,
-0.0190338101,
-0.030626053,
0.0169376042,
0.0358087346,
0.0362918228,
0.0166839492,
-0.0451868214,
0.0317027122,
-0.0375771672,
0.0444777273,
-0.0241211206,
-0.0099341599,
0.0183820892,
0.0955534652,
0.0108959712,
-0.0076160785,
0.0073112352,
-0.0473630913,
0.0935317352,
-0.0668423101,
0.0248785671,
0.0042620259,
-0.0153888986,
0.046097815,
0.0311677027,
0.0075899041,
0.0002521833,
0.0468300395,
-0.0094519388,
0.0762590691,
-0.0102579696,
-0.0498284325,
-0.0192160234,
0.0243397541,
-0.0262389276,
-0.0569981486,
0.0721672252,
-0.0539709888,
-0.069122076,
-0.0754465163,
-0.0023178773,
0.0004116295,
0.0444348119,
0.0106176529,
0.0017598323,
0.0159745179,
0.0275271367,
-0.016088089,
0.0061236215,
-0.091640912,
-0.0447307043,
0.0363208167,
-0.0785301849,
-0.0833765566,
-0.0309588555,
0.0201458149,
0.0850311518,
-0.0064885253,
0.0069488836,
2.337822476e-34,
0.0456067622,
-0.0013005326,
0.0443454199,
0.0142719438,
-0.0105581954,
-0.0453942344,
0.0157535058,
-0.006593137,
0.017520329,
-0.0687162727,
-0.0283280145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17714v1 | Nearest Neighbor Search over Vectorized Lexico-Syntactic Patterns for Relation Extraction from Financial Documents | 2023-10-26T18:19:56 | 2023-10-26T18:19:56 | Pawan Kumar Rajpoot, Ankur Parikh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | Relation extraction (RE) has achieved remarkable progress with the help of
pre-trained language models. However, existing RE models are usually incapable
of handling two situations: implicit expressions and long-tail relation
classes, caused by language complexity and data sparsity. Further, these
approaches and models are largely inaccessible to users who don't have direct
access to large language models (LLMs) and/or infrastructure for supervised
training or fine-tuning. Rule-based systems also struggle with implicit
expressions. Apart from this, Real world financial documents such as various
10-X reports (including 10-K, 10-Q, etc.) of publicly traded companies pose
another challenge to rule-based systems in terms of longer and complex
sentences. In this paper, we introduce a simple approach that consults training
relations at test time through a nearest-neighbor search over dense vectors of
lexico-syntactic patterns and provides a simple yet effective means to tackle
the above issues. We evaluate our approach on REFinD and show that our method
achieves state-of-the-art performance. We further show that it can provide a
good start for human in the loop setup when a small number of annotations are
available and it is also beneficial when domain experts can provide high
quality patterns. | [
0.0499044992,
0.0515525714,
0.0165589079,
0.0582472309,
-0.0090863826,
0.0045818556,
0.0114332484,
0.0716373399,
0.008752997,
-0.0533169582,
-0.0474597253,
0.0080535896,
-0.0454065353,
0.0146403266,
-0.0046730945,
-0.023191683,
0.0018464671,
-0.0040469561,
0.0602985285,
0.0353443995,
0.0368278697,
0.029552348,
0.0128853908,
-0.0143242814,
-0.0376383401,
-0.0096368194,
0.025224058,
-0.0209980216,
0.0121636549,
-0.0317751318,
0.0319251828,
0.0259808749,
0.0245998036,
0.0052344841,
0.0000017282,
-0.0639044419,
-0.0518848896,
0.0321563594,
-0.0105920956,
0.0072789406,
0.0023472335,
-0.0511432104,
0.0571012944,
0.0050336947,
-0.0794453472,
-0.0580418743,
0.0374947712,
0.0847193152,
0.048230052,
0.0601496063,
-0.0477259867,
-0.0579399504,
0.0101198992,
-0.0590998866,
0.0024523246,
-0.0896881446,
0.0472336002,
0.036019668,
-0.0059008161,
-0.0318377726,
0.0026593045,
0.019327499,
-0.0001211706,
-0.0409911908,
0.0372336954,
0.0107259462,
-0.0224944968,
0.0111642824,
-0.0581946746,
0.0654493421,
-0.0063096392,
0.0560575649,
0.0507315695,
-0.014158872,
-0.0104888026,
0.0513964407,
0.0136270048,
0.0266523771,
-0.0467631631,
-0.0248192921,
0.0214959793,
0.0159185231,
0.000658214,
0.0069724177,
-0.0160287339,
-0.0032948961,
-0.034402445,
-0.0629653037,
0.0792473108,
0.030111976,
-0.0212080255,
-0.0342730172,
0.0364139602,
0.0101312948,
0.0338766538,
0.0186736025,
-0.0204111077,
-0.0231709667,
-0.0240372252,
-0.0852674022,
0.017557567,
0.0033382,
-0.0165283941,
0.0623726845,
-0.0708914176,
-0.0004387438,
0.0123127755,
-0.04079891,
-0.0002677095,
0.0373100303,
-0.0357205234,
0.0122587848,
-0.0721298531,
0.1092135981,
-0.0751046017,
-0.0401569866,
-0.032373853,
0.0029312002,
-0.0034090504,
0.029289037,
-0.0043570665,
-0.0408705324,
0.0160582382,
-0.0165318958,
-0.03020899,
-0.0359521061,
-0.0326107815,
0.0079443092,
-0.030112749,
-0.0139424028,
0.0066455058,
0.0021603138,
0.0365615189,
-0.0474872552,
0.001769059,
0.0580155328,
0.0270750802,
-0.0661358386,
-0.0125711104,
-0.0579570383,
0.0173036885,
-0.0018374691,
-0.0084540173,
0.0086762002,
0.0330337882,
0.0062649581,
-0.0366501734,
-0.0199112277,
0.0253725406,
-0.0273311529,
-0.0460533202,
0.0531803407,
0.0097297933,
-0.0221749619,
-0.0216086656,
-0.0339976214,
0.0364983343,
0.0301616527,
-0.000157473,
0.0058935671,
0.0382176675,
0.0138561837,
0.0062915813,
0.0434394516,
0.0105758253,
-0.074515976,
-0.0190261938,
0.0820822939,
0.0139910458,
-0.0224642735,
0.0569070242,
0.0187028795,
-0.0258862115,
-0.0095299911,
0.0144055029,
0.0153191304,
0.0640689507,
0.0370268822,
0.0177322049,
0.0381190702,
0.0445740037,
-0.0184689965,
-0.0207291581,
-0.0108124148,
-0.0262101982,
0.044601243,
-0.0345573239,
0.0135785118,
0.0112511273,
-0.0253607146,
-0.0064599551,
0.0002280608,
-0.0610673651,
0.0102381548,
0.055059053,
0.0011072484,
-0.0365927108,
0.0738666132,
0.0353596658,
-0.0164506193,
-0.0254669525,
0.0230705161,
0.039037656,
0.0271950215,
0.0557208955,
-0.0675541759,
0.017982062,
-0.0166232567,
-0.0252075661,
0.0399979204,
0.0513250269,
-0.0113094635,
0.003977525,
-0.0337619595,
-0.0427857637,
0.0632034168,
0.0098676886,
-0.0199893527,
0.0303274021,
-0.0091243982,
0.0246551707,
-0.0103317359,
-0.0242972001,
0.0507913455,
-0.0036737418,
-0.0361239165,
0.0131316604,
0.0088221719,
-0.0066207694,
0.0424692035,
-0.0406126007,
-0.0026930633,
0.024149619,
-0.0331000499,
0.0036179852,
0.0007326155,
-0.0609920435,
-0.0242409278,
-0.0095974104,
0.0115231965,
-0.033389546,
-0.0450238958,
-0.0407532938,
0.0372555554,
-0.0643761009,
-0.0046750237,
0.0675375611,
-0.0395394303,
-0.004192194,
0.0306967944,
0.0201205909,
-0.0051169298,
0.0863885731,
0.0069105797,
0.0154592879,
-0.0275751036,
-0.0449491926,
-0.0059441812,
-0.0053770263,
0.0347813219,
-0.0166718643,
-0.0494863987,
-0.0052095442,
0.0327313058,
0.0196924265,
-0.0174717754,
-0.0209632721,
-0.0169875622,
-0.0139209833,
0.0192127917,
0.0458855927,
-0.0121709276,
0.0523430184,
-0.0205010958,
-0.0482230522,
-0.0078359097,
0.0036927876,
-0.030852383,
-0.0322125517,
0.0710119754,
0.0391007327,
-0.038010776,
-0.0545950346,
-0.0123350304,
-0.0091995345,
0.0391182862,
0.0471662357,
-0.0252953433,
-0.0124202995,
0.0533353314,
-0.0087613976,
0.0253633223,
0.0184058342,
0.0312337093,
-0.041002918,
-0.0182448253,
-0.0104547562,
0.0401022397,
0.016490059,
0.0763934702,
-0.0447074287,
-0.0105067706,
-0.0289856959,
0.027032923,
-0.0100941062,
0.0294839293,
-0.0046807257,
0.0203808397,
0.0128767192,
0.0291098244,
-0.0272132624,
0.0051009017,
-0.0393924192,
0.0253470223,
0.0252929833,
0.016687531,
-0.0219653491,
0.0202782154,
0.0218194798,
0.031037122,
-0.0235357843,
-0.0199892111,
0.0620261542,
0.0033528961,
-0.0224076193,
-0.0192006156,
-0.0077660028,
-0.065680407,
0.0559048317,
-0.0345501937,
0.0076316069,
0.0130559914,
-0.0466956906,
-0.0027091326,
-0.0551309586,
0.0617526658,
-0.0085859122,
0.0452329405,
-0.0314357243,
0.0610106252,
-0.0028019201,
-0.0277329311,
-0.0429639295,
-0.0649094656,
-0.0116663435,
-0.004145531,
0.0071332366,
-0.0045177471,
-0.0143164415,
0.0510911979,
-0.0185396746,
0.0084226718,
-0.0067501767,
-0.0370684937,
0.001014863,
0.0686416775,
0.0946870297,
-0.0237112399,
0.0126137538,
0.0024548753,
0.0550171174,
0.0071541527,
0.0087199928,
-0.0134302685,
-0.0012488622,
-0.0146166477,
-0.0460444316,
-0.0494442545,
0.015152663,
0.0012740497,
-0.0580978878,
-0.0621441342,
-0.005306554,
0.0854325369,
0.0043688691,
0.0053451611,
-0.0015754178,
0.0534501374,
-0.0170716159,
-0.0049743522,
0.0843877792,
-0.098041594,
-0.0062671388,
-0.038249258,
-0.009847207,
0.044539988,
-0.068946436,
-0.0014213575,
-0.1161545664,
0.0294934716,
-0.0190075226,
-0.0246887431,
-0.0251030307,
-0.0354020298,
-0.0330851823,
-0.0394063629,
-0.0293865576,
0.021673901,
-0.0642396733,
-0.0018982923,
-0.0225405674,
-0.0434844941,
-0.0018052632,
0.01262978,
-0.0323888175,
-0.0396100841,
0.027174674,
0.0056182821,
-0.0115186553,
0.0043082302,
-0.0309999976,
-0.0242376644,
-0.0172660947,
-0.0408575125,
0.0639273301,
-0.0221206006,
-0.0302790105,
0.002276096,
0.0040876474,
-0.0525731929,
0.0504683927,
0.0230535753,
0.0051759342,
0.0156411231,
-0.0249402188,
0.0007321693,
0.0036021327,
-0.015606204,
0.0528970733,
-0.0112028029,
-0.0028842178,
-0.0335988589,
-0.0084771262,
0.0192232728,
-0.028507635,
0.0090830298,
-0.0274100509,
-0.0564528145,
-0.0017119291,
-0.0784754753,
-0.0733202994,
0.0483979881,
0.0557884723,
-0.0047894912,
-0.0046252436,
0.0458843783,
0.0177029707,
-0.0563260354,
0.0090251071,
-0.0087300893,
0.0058213938,
-0.0087542525,
0.0416672938,
-0.002283291,
0.0016845771,
-0.0621120743,
-0.0100245299,
-0.0243119411,
-0.0085834125,
-0.0060503841,
0.0217328202,
0.0107454974,
0.0317469202,
-0.0230187979,
0.0323299393,
0.0373202525,
0.0794454962,
-0.1062996313,
-0.0362226516,
0.030140711,
-0.0271566287,
0.0150494231,
0.020838324,
-0.0646835193,
0.0327240191,
0.0022205799,
0.0427646153,
-0.0255241897,
-0.02336777,
0.0198516361,
0.0102354102,
0.0366269052,
0.0490240492,
-0.0409239829,
-0.036672283,
0.0000369032,
-0.0423542261,
-0.0000454406,
-0.0487133451,
0.0232137274,
-0.0024655364,
0.0263587981,
-0.0188262835,
0.0140261771,
-0.0228517428,
0.0312734842,
-0.0032008747,
0.0174088906,
0.0149790263,
0.0004382399,
0.0099979816,
-0.0512859747,
0.0203111805,
-0.0258720368,
0.0379050523,
0.0063697272,
-0.0271071699,
-0.0108126448,
0.0221732743,
0.001985539,
-0.0064065466,
-0.0249781348,
-0.01488523,
0.0239039827,
-0.0267602,
0.0123650422,
0.036592897,
-0.0618465394,
0.001704182,
-0.0475872308,
0.0336537734,
0.0290416144,
0.0362332873,
0.0160048343,
-0.0198502094,
0.031415984,
0.0195215028,
-0.0277447216,
0.0065369247,
0.0778494775,
0.0122004151,
0.043767076,
-0.0015529515,
-0.0400946066,
-0.0704246685,
-0.0273419078,
0.0405977406,
0.0233672466,
-0.0201170314,
0.0017477758,
-0.0589366406,
-0.040361423,
0.0266415942,
-0.0290147234,
-0.0565230511,
0.0075428174,
0.0291423369,
0.0512302928,
0.0444008857,
-0.0315847583,
-0.0252679586,
0.0365061983,
-0.047797028,
-0.0419758521,
-0.051637955,
-5.556634897e-33,
-0.0252784248,
-0.0348106064,
0.0236566365,
0.0156576056,
-0.0138207003,
0.0464578196,
-0.0150908371,
-0.0481374674,
0.010134656,
0.0350651853,
0.0018305954,
0.027532896,
0.0128991194,
-0.0094621675,
0.0014335033,
0.0139545761,
0.0227874909,
-0.0432236642,
0.024913393,
-0.025800908,
-0.0077985334,
0.0789584294,
0.0453700051,
-0.1088548601,
0.015050536,
0.0169591513,
-0.0184066426,
0.035187427,
0.0712857097,
0.0480209365,
-0.0115062287,
-0.0152421435,
-0.0019440786,
-0.0448284037,
0.018046027,
-0.022541998,
-0.0984405652,
-0.020460099,
-0.0136460848,
0.0026284428,
0.0111491559,
0.0333464071,
0.0474532954,
-0.0110323951,
0.0146432882,
-0.0083271572,
0.0162744895,
-0.0225891434,
-0.0141805522,
-0.0662036985,
-0.0769422352,
0.0476648025,
0.0334397443,
0.02679836,
0.0704136714,
0.0487999022,
0.0078526894,
-0.0217931699,
0.0099264607,
-0.0099960519,
-0.0186075941,
0.0292955209,
0.0095955469,
0.0079197874,
0.0158622619,
0.0159142781,
0.0086021209,
-0.0268391911,
0.0357554443,
0.0105627896,
-0.002257915,
0.063750729,
-0.0314918607,
0.0208627321,
0.0531010814,
0.0024144494,
-0.0572917983,
0.0092048803,
0.0453510359,
0.0294733234,
-0.0058907354,
-0.0106461253,
-0.05423126,
-0.0117647843,
0.0551118478,
0.0146812266,
-0.0178834237,
-0.0239730049,
0.0108195432,
0.0338788927,
0.0028910511,
0.0542920679,
-0.0054056388,
-0.0231468454,
-0.0790841281,
-0.0110457996,
0.0282722674,
-0.0043695504,
0.0149350883,
-0.0534971133,
-0.0372330882,
-0.0586435683,
-0.0276804287,
-0.0188811701,
0.0116165429,
-0.009368957,
0.0411618911,
-0.0247255247,
-0.0516235083,
-0.021085687,
0.0070699961,
0.0093170516,
0.004842157,
0.010331396,
-0.0124999788,
0.0703810677,
0.0017884963,
0.0318839699,
0.0365132764,
-0.0286976527,
-0.0151773477,
0.0052777836,
0.0287169106,
0.047317449,
0.0477741249,
-0.0318878479,
0.0131238932,
0.0488823615,
0.0277945939,
-0.0045771198,
-0.0128155975,
0.0347703621,
2.47e-7,
0.0326948129,
0.0465374403,
0.0522949211,
0.0175944995,
0.0040094219,
0.0130888168,
0.0389634147,
0.0196087733,
-0.0303260442,
0.0320643857,
0.0356400572,
-0.0168442987,
0.0446232595,
0.0188384987,
-0.0874675512,
-0.0641772002,
-0.0634195879,
-0.0622970983,
-0.0959500745,
0.0033338068,
0.0426586829,
0.0399405956,
0.01002941,
-0.0013436342,
-0.060327895,
-0.0967935696,
0.0352378152,
-0.0291603487,
-0.0056316894,
0.0076338141,
0.0374791175,
-0.0279444009,
-0.0362305678,
0.0340240002,
-0.0118193347,
0.0690848082,
0.0371947996,
0.0425967649,
0.0062701073,
0.0433666818,
0.0043473179,
-0.0006039605,
0.0148667693,
0.0004770558,
0.0272623561,
-0.0468917526,
0.0073400475,
-0.0091531239,
-0.0264463965,
-0.0180939529,
-0.0269887615,
0.0317444056,
0.0048842719,
0.0290660709,
0.0472397432,
-0.010066824,
-0.0081775943,
-0.0566143095,
0.0125753051,
0.0585494377,
0.0072003161,
0.0354409739,
-0.0388758816,
0.0144596789,
0.0233308095,
0.0141639439,
0.014566727,
2.197267101e-34,
0.029049458,
-0.0329507776,
-0.0284055676,
0.0762935877,
0.0915800631,
0.0027392071,
-0.0203451607,
0.0660850629,
-0.007269654,
-0.1039043516,
0.0304719824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17711v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17711v1 | Is Explanation the Cure? Misinformation Mitigation in the Short Term and Long Term | 2023-10-26T18:12:02 | 2023-10-26T18:12:02 | Yi-Li Hsu, Shih-Chieh Dai, Aiping Xiong, Lun-Wei Ku | cs.CL | cs.CL | With advancements in natural language processing (NLP) models, automatic
explanation generation has been proposed to mitigate misinformation on social
media platforms in addition to adding warning labels to identified fake news.
While many researchers have focused on generating good explanations, how these
explanations can really help humans combat fake news is under-explored. In this
study, we compare the effectiveness of a warning label and the state-of-the-art
counterfactual explanations generated by GPT-4 in debunking misinformation. In
a two-wave, online human-subject study, participants (N = 215) were randomly
assigned to a control group in which false contents are shown without any
intervention, a warning tag group in which the false claims were labeled, or an
explanation group in which the false contents were accompanied by GPT-4
generated explanations. Our results show that both interventions significantly
decrease participants' self-reported belief in fake claims in an equivalent
manner for the short-term and long-term. We discuss the implications of our
findings and directions for future NLP-based misinformation debunking
strategies. | [
0.0541698225,
0.0024140622,
-0.0131860329,
-0.0105631305,
-0.0055938009,
0.0207334217,
0.0421500467,
0.0060691233,
0.0076867673,
-0.0194887482,
0.0558642708,
-0.012976733,
0.0121641485,
0.0348770283,
0.0382915102,
-0.061616078,
0.0454300828,
0.0193101894,
0.0953350142,
-0.0062538437,
0.0252720378,
0.0541341677,
-0.0155506348,
0.0353964679,
-0.0140577126,
-0.0271969289,
0.0285992268,
-0.0111740017,
0.0260247719,
-0.0528735816,
-0.0038195585,
0.0340071023,
0.0552514829,
0.0581719093,
0.0000019249,
-0.0146686407,
0.0016239488,
0.0125078894,
-0.0732845813,
0.042156633,
-0.0001642084,
-0.0590441078,
0.0083423909,
0.0460876785,
0.0080290725,
-0.000628897,
0.0474017188,
0.1059648842,
0.1008650959,
0.0752757862,
-0.0173191,
-0.0564278364,
0.0027922553,
0.0093419598,
0.016770456,
-0.0288517457,
0.0205200873,
0.00520337,
-0.043933522,
0.0485029556,
0.0295287948,
-0.0050973231,
0.0184314046,
-0.0161610637,
-0.0324177817,
0.0347373672,
-0.0225060917,
-0.0578282215,
0.0028615508,
0.0136279976,
0.0152701419,
-0.0787947029,
0.0206610989,
-0.0213090628,
0.0108887693,
0.0700613558,
-0.0343598798,
0.0252546985,
-0.0410409793,
-0.0004221975,
0.019446902,
-0.0199284144,
0.0506854914,
0.0618736856,
0.0641466081,
0.0702994615,
-0.0161528531,
-0.0067436933,
-0.0067217792,
-0.0302628949,
-0.0198167413,
-0.0320587978,
-0.0073747034,
0.0059866882,
0.0084813507,
0.0150225516,
-0.0157422759,
0.0012772086,
0.0511115454,
-0.0694825128,
-0.0424843319,
0.0206545312,
0.0127191367,
0.0331932753,
-0.0166546218,
0.0276117921,
-0.0342382565,
0.0097367847,
0.0285178572,
-0.0172435138,
-0.0400647596,
-0.0184978768,
-0.0154844802,
-0.0208633468,
-0.019773392,
0.0339259915,
-0.0182441883,
-0.0346778929,
-0.0281007029,
-0.0091297897,
-0.0226960275,
0.0164276864,
-0.022732297,
-0.0348805524,
-0.0490664616,
0.0688502118,
-0.043868091,
0.0114627164,
0.0131001547,
-0.0666094124,
-0.0170026477,
0.0171440151,
0.0004438737,
0.0137323635,
-0.007966157,
-0.005789299,
0.0318120606,
0.0340992734,
-0.0415561758,
-0.0267476197,
-0.0223865658,
-0.0588932894,
0.0171408914,
-0.0260420218,
-0.0112968385,
-0.0085368287,
-0.0071036038,
-0.0076894946,
-0.0027639808,
0.0342527479,
-0.0730315894,
0.0618712343,
-0.0586104318,
0.0194579978,
0.0770804361,
0.0318207704,
-0.0116891544,
0.0530699715,
0.0024066628,
0.0382277705,
0.0353891961,
-0.02830543,
0.0383593068,
-0.0606313795,
0.0618532151,
-0.0181321613,
0.0473264866,
-0.0177040342,
-0.053018,
-0.0103689218,
-0.0205946118,
0.0106036272,
-0.0269731805,
0.0023836941,
0.0696605816,
-0.0184931364,
-0.0317731872,
0.0223330203,
0.0272158477,
0.0093852691,
-0.0042725983,
-0.0003421392,
-0.0578311644,
0.039161887,
-0.0715979934,
-0.0027032911,
0.0026598687,
0.0244154148,
-0.0243442748,
-0.0155287674,
-0.0363889933,
0.0217945315,
0.0511356406,
-0.0059191021,
-0.0289178472,
-0.0041527492,
-0.0554460771,
0.0109195355,
0.0338188,
-0.0021744692,
-0.0071108676,
-0.0619619079,
0.0268170908,
0.0444030948,
0.013408999,
0.0352514796,
0.0092852749,
-0.0539405942,
0.038246084,
0.0400970317,
0.0665148795,
0.0061729602,
-0.0279423818,
0.0031824715,
-0.0180469118,
-0.0658823326,
0.0218652543,
0.0059902733,
0.0689956173,
0.0008567688,
0.018663289,
-0.0190298874,
-0.054076232,
0.0293818563,
0.03028116,
-0.02148862,
-0.0369220413,
0.0148830581,
0.0023453054,
0.0391758308,
0.0346154012,
-0.0028264741,
0.0402784273,
0.0368596949,
-0.0343263894,
-0.013248831,
-0.0098290574,
0.0015851235,
-0.0167111885,
-0.0484008305,
-0.0371305048,
0.0247407239,
-0.0475759469,
0.0054694,
0.032265231,
-0.0487429686,
0.0210993625,
-0.0395062752,
-0.0385641456,
-0.0260464307,
-0.0100281481,
0.0289310664,
0.0830683038,
0.0085389474,
-0.0109184673,
-0.0219485573,
-0.0163136832,
-0.0006078815,
-0.010260622,
0.0426229946,
-0.0018028317,
-0.0049975915,
-0.0237093586,
0.0352165028,
-0.0202862527,
-0.0125066265,
0.0506356843,
-0.05423785,
-0.0100484863,
-0.0279964004,
-0.0062279315,
0.0569705702,
-0.0247079469,
-0.0061997608,
0.0147081502,
-0.0065016607,
-0.0120220296,
0.0164146181,
0.0358226337,
0.0057590841,
-0.013262935,
-0.0192391835,
-0.0002569116,
0.0169960987,
-0.0275407098,
0.007629449,
0.0709096864,
-0.0799712688,
-0.0537840873,
-0.0262227114,
-0.0631155148,
-0.0125844134,
-0.0155800069,
-0.0266041588,
0.010541101,
0.058084134,
-0.0230351333,
0.0009639945,
0.0570494942,
0.0752138719,
0.0190984011,
0.0892003551,
-0.0142148007,
-0.0275801793,
-0.0724022016,
-0.0257475339,
-0.0028580101,
-0.0739866719,
0.0030739629,
0.046006456,
0.0430486873,
0.0210913289,
-0.0657121316,
0.0404019542,
-0.0175328143,
-0.0292357393,
0.0058787847,
-0.0928508863,
-0.0204477906,
0.0452841818,
-0.0361578055,
-0.0561928526,
0.101937212,
0.0135279,
0.0359005854,
-0.0384768061,
-0.0311952196,
0.0277319718,
0.0069988593,
-0.0302361157,
0.0089679789,
0.0861005932,
0.0117093306,
0.0461717099,
-0.0477300733,
0.0737881139,
0.0137102725,
-0.016457919,
-0.0529385433,
0.0068993699,
0.0423755981,
-0.000805918,
-0.0406430587,
-0.0959148109,
-0.0239086822,
-0.0294254664,
-0.0178078301,
-0.0134577313,
-0.0515816137,
-0.0072154496,
0.0793328583,
0.0093177538,
0.0102472221,
0.008455703,
0.031525027,
-0.0254236981,
0.0124297282,
0.0149005083,
0.0924650878,
-0.0280073266,
-0.0034361251,
0.0244675763,
-0.0031552559,
-0.0031880175,
-0.0132932337,
-0.0382012278,
-0.0592651963,
-0.0119295884,
-0.0203223862,
0.0129201887,
0.0351540186,
-0.0482964553,
0.0345645584,
0.08081837,
0.0138552384,
0.0258245301,
0.0013183038,
0.039154321,
-0.0114403358,
0.0113440389,
-0.031061627,
-0.0288119595,
-0.0122591956,
-0.0054510748,
0.0120952856,
-0.0275911223,
0.0194978528,
-0.0256703645,
-0.0588744357,
0.0281209983,
-0.0054148375,
0.0037292817,
-0.0219469201,
-0.1062715277,
-0.0255763307,
0.0118388711,
0.0024336744,
0.0028126745,
0.03805108,
0.0022259934,
0.0136524765,
-0.0332970731,
-0.0398799106,
0.0069049071,
-0.0137506975,
0.049395971,
0.0394879282,
0.0607789047,
-0.0057558869,
-0.0586751401,
0.0314133801,
-0.0099520441,
-0.0104630003,
-0.0240297057,
0.1090097502,
-0.0138955833,
0.0154233128,
-0.0672981739,
0.0486903489,
-0.0085182469,
-0.0496343747,
-0.0238739327,
0.0544795766,
0.020247519,
-0.0719414353,
-0.0076114833,
0.0258082822,
0.0012526308,
0.0844413117,
0.0231845547,
0.0491322279,
-0.0161597989,
-0.0431646109,
0.030883301,
-0.0141929034,
-0.0379287042,
0.0168552548,
0.015614762,
-0.0412721075,
-0.018906638,
-0.028580647,
0.0030070429,
-0.016343886,
-0.0108735692,
-0.0171596799,
0.01198701,
0.0157915056,
-0.0266659521,
0.0289444905,
0.0033477091,
0.0336254761,
0.0131963538,
-0.0442741886,
-0.0280233957,
-0.0218046084,
0.0174195152,
0.0468656272,
-0.0088375062,
-0.0375017561,
0.0014695607,
-0.0033146187,
0.0277112182,
0.0480737984,
0.0130750528,
-0.0443540029,
0.0030363526,
0.0003713927,
-0.0425241366,
-0.0039458214,
0.0216024816,
0.0097576361,
0.0570514686,
0.0051059565,
0.0237006787,
0.0119342739,
0.0003145097,
-0.010670742,
-0.0323327519,
0.024153972,
0.0480250232,
0.0313525833,
0.0531636737,
-0.0421980768,
0.0114894193,
-0.0147166224,
-0.0460579656,
-0.0217931308,
-0.014399319,
0.0418791585,
0.0406878889,
0.0072300131,
-0.0490414165,
-0.0180708412,
-0.0060094483,
-0.0654541403,
-0.0063119023,
-0.0261282213,
-0.0109586818,
-0.0159061421,
0.0324412398,
-0.025037488,
0.0162799582,
-0.0054148985,
0.0102372374,
-0.0007394995,
0.0292462967,
0.0042668805,
0.040405564,
0.0182079747,
-0.0119127613,
0.0413476564,
-0.0560051724,
-0.0493980013,
-0.0351246335,
-0.0107380468,
-0.0046695345,
-0.0144190025,
0.0046670241,
0.0652654022,
0.0010308921,
-0.0329583474,
0.0241545402,
0.0121529335,
0.0195313971,
-0.0399318412,
0.0026835664,
0.0118437512,
-0.0644060448,
0.0030560712,
0.0526439287,
-0.0013255335,
0.0294731613,
0.0186549742,
-0.0535339601,
0.001331238,
-0.012386892,
-0.0609254465,
0.0562968701,
0.0109289577,
0.0074364264,
-0.0874118581,
-0.0478830561,
-0.0182655938,
-0.0016209544,
0.0343773402,
0.0112779643,
-0.0266161803,
0.0547551364,
-0.0023846568,
-0.057653062,
-0.0283461884,
0.0342787243,
0.0007780016,
0.0042325351,
-0.0356922336,
-6.591843181e-33,
0.0041590743,
-0.0929234996,
-0.022618195,
-0.0102083981,
0.0154221896,
0.0235799477,
-0.0278431028,
-0.0216537043,
-0.0189582948,
0.0692185462,
0.03632126,
0.0373585448,
0.0099591091,
-0.0340567604,
-0.0415951535,
-0.0253688004,
0.0260544866,
0.0012909244,
-0.0395900644,
0.0411780104,
0.0237443466,
-0.0177208576,
0.0627935976,
-0.0846230164,
0.0851869434,
-0.008326658,
-0.0255415104,
-0.0047707539,
-0.0173945446,
0.0322365761,
-0.0084196376,
0.0318578035,
0.059538804,
-0.0461018719,
0.0145604545,
0.0320976153,
-0.0498302095,
-0.0262818728,
0.0937565118,
-0.0371038429,
-0.0347214863,
0.0092997663,
-0.0094620017,
-0.0154851275,
-0.0387786999,
0.0286567993,
0.018952867,
-0.0005156872,
0.0218770467,
0.0096581588,
-0.0488671921,
-0.0156195741,
0.0061800922,
0.0090317763,
-0.0219270959,
0.0558313392,
-0.0059337709,
0.0139267538,
-0.073975794,
0.0351019092,
0.0135945482,
-0.0338496007,
0.0368225724,
-0.0520400666,
-0.0334222503,
0.0450528115,
0.025582619,
0.0462792292,
-0.0835584998,
-0.0014373965,
-0.0318769105,
-0.0072845309,
0.0925031602,
0.0861514434,
0.0460290723,
-0.0779492483,
-0.0626803264,
0.0082437703,
-0.0258200858,
-0.0072245444,
0.016782457,
-0.0122179687,
-0.0440299883,
-0.0199237615,
-0.0463972092,
-0.0072536822,
-0.043689318,
-0.008945642,
0.0021113569,
0.0377780721,
-0.0564748161,
0.0322117098,
-0.0278798733,
-0.0304828919,
0.0398149379,
0.0132502727,
0.0040142499,
-0.0443134718,
0.0105847474,
-0.0030032978,
-0.0483031832,
0.0317684039,
0.0188802686,
0.0501096733,
0.0212790184,
-0.0303723384,
0.0361645371,
-0.0015449658,
-0.0158809256,
0.0261578187,
-0.0541225262,
0.03735983,
-0.010978573,
-0.0760785714,
0.0266205259,
0.0472334474,
-0.0255118106,
-0.0261919033,
0.0358572192,
-0.0088452781,
-0.0126887597,
0.0326636583,
-0.0432180725,
0.022818625,
-0.0196805485,
0.0002689893,
0.0049091005,
-0.0070426124,
0.0210402552,
-0.0952619463,
-0.0124965189,
-0.0096765524,
2.777e-7,
0.0096547799,
0.0650433376,
0.0283468869,
-0.0004003919,
0.0499756485,
0.0478288941,
0.0592723973,
-0.0209231693,
-0.006581937,
-0.0730846599,
-0.0413124636,
0.0322209783,
0.0060310387,
0.0236142222,
0.0265452601,
0.0098601617,
-0.0376305468,
-0.0457997695,
-0.0555035807,
0.0166075267,
0.0303081684,
0.014150071,
0.0447334647,
-0.0137421926,
-0.0199783649,
0.0192002114,
0.043807894,
-0.0001496841,
-0.0112090893,
-0.0135317342,
0.0355110802,
-0.0107353916,
0.022301428,
0.0164674856,
-0.025384685,
-0.0488729663,
-0.0227025002,
0.0209227633,
-0.0171594732,
-0.0213314891,
-0.0432255976,
-0.0257291626,
0.0297116842,
-0.0866691843,
0.0387795381,
-0.0353816785,
-0.0530899316,
0.0059133163,
-0.054119762,
0.0000721741,
-0.0115368254,
-0.0020796331,
-0.0375097729,
0.0246487577,
-0.0365968235,
0.0159765445,
0.0155516481,
-0.0348206758,
0.0003823031,
0.0074185124,
-0.0485538207,
0.0137674008,
0.0025386866,
-0.0283573512,
0.058905337,
-0.0298297908,
0.0085168295,
2.156517855e-34,
0.0175664891,
-0.0011752646,
0.0081095044,
-0.0363398604,
0.0574641079,
0.0651612431,
-0.0301016979,
-0.0286806487,
0.0413362831,
0.0093428334,
-0.0207884721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17703v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17703v2 | The impact of responding to patient messages with large language model assistance | 2023-10-26T18:03:46 | 2023-11-29T19:10:58 | Shan Chen, Marco Guevara, Shalini Moningi, Frank Hoebers, Hesham Elhalawani, Benjamin H. Kann, Fallon E. Chipidza, Jonathan Leeman, Hugo J. W. L. Aerts, Timothy Miller, Guergana K. Savova, Raymond H. Mak, Maryam Lustberg, Majid Afshar, Danielle S. Bitterman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Documentation burden is a major contributor to clinician burnout, which is
rising nationally and is an urgent threat to our ability to care for patients.
Artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots, such as ChatGPT, could reduce clinician
burden by assisting with documentation. Although many hospitals are actively
integrating such systems into electronic medical record systems, AI chatbots
utility and impact on clinical decision-making have not been studied for this
intended use. We are the first to examine the utility of large language models
in assisting clinicians draft responses to patient questions. In our two-stage
cross-sectional study, 6 oncologists responded to 100 realistic synthetic
cancer patient scenarios and portal messages developed to reflect common
medical situations, first manually, then with AI assistance.
We find AI-assisted responses were longer, less readable, but provided
acceptable drafts without edits 58% of time. AI assistance improved efficiency
77% of time, with low harm risk (82% safe). However, 7.7% unedited AI responses
could severely harm. In 31% cases, physicians thought AI drafts were
human-written. AI assistance led to more patient education recommendations,
fewer clinical actions than manual responses. Results show promise for AI to
improve clinician efficiency and patient care through assisting documentation,
if used judiciously. Monitoring model outputs and human-AI interaction remains
crucial for safe implementation. | [
0.0914821476,
0.0315954275,
-0.0304838438,
-0.058640074,
-0.0315975919,
0.024498919,
0.0178009924,
0.0226360373,
0.0320879743,
-0.0320389979,
0.0303396042,
-0.036311537,
-0.0100518502,
0.0388472825,
0.00301788,
-0.0607398413,
-0.0008540665,
0.0070512979,
0.0555916987,
0.0294863414,
0.0121968435,
0.0289255902,
-0.0264303628,
0.0893968567,
-0.0271248594,
-0.0067140404,
0.0057193702,
0.009584452,
-0.020075595,
-0.0341554172,
-0.0079676462,
0.0238752849,
-0.0233679786,
0.0022616042,
0.0000019277,
-0.0547103696,
0.0042043305,
0.0418803357,
-0.0841851979,
-0.0372413993,
0.0770721361,
-0.0498444848,
-0.0146681396,
0.0383216478,
-0.027461933,
-0.0168602634,
0.0428424664,
0.0303208232,
0.0219086297,
0.0730411932,
-0.0401216857,
0.0513681993,
0.0329375714,
0.0156497303,
0.011114941,
-0.0385638028,
0.0080958307,
0.022299001,
0.0473518744,
-0.0316834636,
0.0448314361,
0.0602336861,
-0.0097175818,
-0.0414032191,
-0.0240000151,
0.0612914898,
-0.0019357855,
-0.0270780623,
0.0000348616,
0.0283438712,
0.0392901301,
-0.0018541606,
0.0084180618,
-0.0108575989,
0.0329706743,
0.0218352657,
-0.0342203118,
-0.0036200376,
-0.0279517397,
-0.0380070694,
-0.0061121657,
-0.0311729256,
0.0065526813,
-0.0041349316,
0.0159765948,
-0.0317257717,
-0.0011409146,
-0.0341659039,
-0.0025692829,
-0.0031479192,
0.0272534452,
-0.0572389737,
0.0315495767,
0.0558523126,
-0.0618516281,
0.0118853515,
-0.0083539682,
-0.0336761512,
0.0658258423,
-0.0750772879,
0.0081191733,
0.0187060572,
0.0145135354,
0.0106700072,
0.0267533436,
-0.0117814504,
-0.0107688252,
0.047233168,
-0.0351612866,
0.0278876703,
-0.0353941396,
-0.0346709192,
-0.038812574,
0.0121551808,
0.031973362,
0.0018544438,
-0.0559729673,
0.0117838811,
-0.0096608754,
0.0378698297,
0.0370602235,
0.0309864748,
-0.0419834666,
0.013580773,
-0.0158258267,
-0.0084160157,
-0.0193874147,
0.0111813536,
-0.0017912064,
-0.0746799856,
0.0446115471,
0.0312966332,
0.0098339813,
0.0008862808,
-0.0100781778,
0.085081771,
-0.009567719,
-0.0160337016,
0.0220180154,
-0.0475638844,
-0.0292456299,
-0.0353000201,
0.0253104232,
-0.0440408438,
0.0285988394,
0.0186320134,
-0.0215311144,
-0.0536970198,
0.0077248169,
0.0093705403,
-0.0416472293,
0.0205408987,
-0.0467898548,
0.0470084623,
0.0615897588,
0.0288419798,
-0.0405665152,
-0.0271309111,
0.0205223337,
-0.0190051496,
0.0064189737,
-0.0403191783,
0.0498766601,
0.0177100841,
-0.0097891744,
-0.0195558928,
0.0321831517,
0.0241533108,
-0.0088536916,
0.0671766549,
-0.0343529284,
0.0758141503,
-0.0188111365,
0.0287831407,
0.0452320501,
0.0650831833,
0.0241824128,
0.0514034964,
0.0170104075,
-0.0066642053,
0.0226314738,
-0.0047567827,
-0.0299527068,
0.0173894968,
0.0018361452,
-0.0135222571,
-0.0141706597,
-0.0388642289,
-0.0479711518,
-0.0506482683,
-0.0335270576,
-0.029664075,
0.004214651,
-0.0054789288,
0.0342101976,
-0.0323324762,
-0.0120782303,
-0.0309324283,
0.021113487,
-0.02543322,
-0.0550245121,
-0.0790012255,
-0.0299844351,
0.1385055035,
0.0664150193,
-0.0488463789,
-0.0337783024,
-0.0552780889,
0.0156727694,
0.0178949442,
0.0655467436,
-0.007364783,
-0.0291559808,
0.0002023366,
0.0047363206,
0.0382617973,
0.0028303212,
-0.0249228347,
0.0048854663,
0.035749197,
-0.0309948251,
0.0077447891,
-0.0625674203,
0.0485852398,
-0.0649778396,
-0.0412168317,
-0.024509456,
0.0051294351,
0.031572096,
0.031648431,
-0.0193798468,
0.0387292579,
0.0183394589,
-0.0000411288,
-0.0303857792,
0.0463936925,
-0.0137228668,
0.0264787767,
0.0045091729,
-0.0049484209,
-0.0209176838,
-0.0257946905,
0.0096709812,
0.0108456556,
-0.0413741544,
-0.068591468,
0.0390668437,
0.0074153109,
0.0353868976,
0.0402639918,
-0.0133959483,
-0.008061056,
-0.0250799917,
-0.0224265847,
-0.0211841632,
-0.009421777,
-0.0257445145,
-0.0086585172,
-0.0205155108,
0.0036621522,
0.0401291065,
0.0066225594,
0.0014902285,
0.0089759985,
0.0249149315,
-0.017087914,
-0.0246275328,
-0.1526392996,
-0.0574600771,
0.0051703979,
-0.0266153142,
0.0245586708,
0.006423363,
-0.0100856107,
-0.0160381906,
-0.0467797555,
-0.0056114411,
0.0317299478,
0.0278116073,
0.0313204266,
0.0335322432,
-0.0191154256,
-0.0453366525,
-0.0210398342,
-0.0457498468,
0.0058845151,
0.071679987,
-0.0406593345,
-0.0214999467,
0.0092848297,
-0.0216256138,
-0.0086595649,
-0.0029133982,
-0.0497950092,
0.0391767323,
-0.0375919864,
-0.0003350779,
0.0579155907,
0.0228435267,
0.0403135791,
0.0558325686,
0.0198456161,
-0.0240171328,
-0.0045652492,
-0.0004142229,
-0.0429714285,
0.0243490078,
-0.0763208121,
0.0006401687,
0.0210155789,
0.0037582663,
0.0300960187,
-0.0306834243,
0.0105330655,
-0.0265727155,
-0.011566584,
-0.0190015174,
-0.0081348289,
-0.0383975469,
0.0195833165,
0.0097686239,
-0.0322278179,
0.0822358206,
0.0139866956,
0.0304581728,
-0.0535399094,
-0.0240574256,
-0.0058719972,
0.0357792452,
-0.0320228562,
0.0269637182,
0.0255860668,
-0.0004751148,
-0.0041779387,
-0.0239754021,
-0.0204818603,
-0.0363423005,
0.0225139465,
-0.0384984724,
0.022846071,
0.0024881936,
-0.018063277,
-0.0408244096,
-0.0317719281,
-0.0313232876,
-0.0093322499,
0.0319874473,
-0.0155013585,
-0.0700688586,
-0.015599302,
0.0355658047,
0.0871905908,
0.0393921435,
-0.0300194882,
0.022830829,
-0.0455871187,
0.0312929638,
0.0030159091,
-0.000666057,
-0.0136524485,
0.0787400752,
0.048840832,
0.0179827791,
0.0099937711,
0.0120521933,
-0.0608315691,
-0.0168358106,
-0.0080033364,
-0.0131420037,
0.0292727873,
0.0124914441,
-0.035499908,
-0.0093540372,
0.0916115865,
0.0279826615,
-0.0650267601,
0.0315365791,
-0.0538538806,
-0.0379691161,
-0.0347622409,
0.0334534198,
-0.0387360416,
-0.0019793345,
-0.0002193036,
0.0242683589,
-0.0461979322,
-0.0181377418,
0.0229151901,
-0.0170113109,
0.0332878493,
-0.0047186064,
-0.0177564304,
-0.0103601934,
0.0002479677,
-0.0002469517,
0.0131842177,
-0.0156585872,
-0.0156866331,
0.0063286005,
-0.0359169357,
-0.0081662117,
-0.0807790607,
-0.048454877,
0.0240114518,
-0.0167113226,
0.0456308238,
0.0636659861,
0.0563353375,
-0.0288929455,
0.007646224,
0.0095904507,
0.0799149126,
0.0319307633,
0.0279948954,
0.087190941,
0.0077394489,
0.0466150455,
-0.0416686535,
0.015024987,
-0.0213989038,
0.0080179079,
0.0362736061,
0.0568666086,
-0.0632425472,
-0.0296579301,
-0.0439353101,
0.0259800274,
0.0384864435,
0.0286830403,
-0.0028680239,
-0.036784187,
-0.0368674807,
-0.0043974239,
0.0488802232,
0.0469740517,
-0.0026715698,
-0.00335787,
-0.0218879953,
-0.0207615141,
-0.0822880045,
-0.072814934,
0.0293630473,
-0.0162565783,
0.0238058995,
0.003078972,
0.0118667446,
0.0194097739,
-0.0073627336,
0.0076962407,
0.0238570701,
0.0177953895,
-0.0521871112,
-0.0560947619,
0.0058255647,
-0.0115438858,
0.0395157672,
0.0119095212,
0.0300936569,
-0.0013081811,
0.0159244202,
0.0756092593,
0.0265307445,
-0.0176981296,
0.0035233833,
-0.0388740525,
-0.001899621,
0.0199627038,
-0.0488996431,
-0.0187587943,
-0.0097944969,
0.0317363851,
-0.0083887074,
-0.0129662929,
-0.0278342888,
-0.0095117567,
-0.0090005891,
0.0122169685,
-0.0134526752,
-0.041012831,
0.0340170301,
0.0522566065,
-0.0358476676,
0.0081772972,
-0.0085923364,
-0.0013932673,
0.012229709,
-0.0621599331,
0.0196498279,
-0.0106728347,
-0.0319767594,
-0.0134814391,
0.004799406,
0.0193981305,
0.0093570175,
-0.0784849524,
-0.0451683737,
-0.0134936115,
0.0194481555,
0.0181669481,
0.0358361378,
0.0281418245,
-0.021994099,
-0.014292039,
0.0246691536,
-0.0148260808,
0.0047230949,
0.0114402166,
0.044676356,
-0.0233470351,
0.009846299,
0.0075155729,
0.053014826,
-0.0514771901,
-0.1178537086,
-0.0181424078,
0.054160364,
0.0337707065,
0.0067715882,
0.0254175682,
-0.0750579387,
0.0148386899,
-0.0524935275,
0.0116337789,
0.0086781727,
0.0218395907,
0.0000100463,
0.0088520674,
-0.0009857204,
-0.0327460729,
0.0658170879,
-0.0168808568,
0.0618451945,
-0.0364704616,
-0.0516257584,
-0.0505920127,
-0.0166355614,
0.0333971567,
0.0033446453,
-0.0433318354,
-0.0074455771,
-0.0554986186,
-0.017069567,
-0.0026089493,
-0.0217115767,
-0.0274851061,
-0.0585071668,
0.0510606654,
0.0375411771,
0.0125299022,
-0.0319015644,
-0.0503157303,
0.0670051426,
-0.0421179794,
0.000305783,
-0.0171629991,
-5.045409465e-33,
0.0316846445,
-0.0529742427,
0.0191907417,
0.0161548387,
0.0101858275,
0.0084991874,
-0.0432728492,
0.016571153,
-0.0039175414,
0.0358220525,
-0.0427858271,
0.0167942829,
-0.0112424782,
-0.0136630302,
0.0136300744,
-0.0247341022,
0.0376951285,
-0.032319773,
-0.0095793838,
0.0298905149,
-0.0267976355,
0.0321457833,
-0.0186972246,
-0.1135362834,
0.0375922136,
-0.0180356968,
0.0116681941,
-0.0278221536,
-0.0302729718,
0.0434518009,
-0.0194843356,
0.0260679182,
0.0490732528,
0.0398573913,
-0.012154256,
0.05678818,
-0.0140721267,
0.000068249,
-0.0162061099,
0.0044434289,
-0.0272928067,
-0.0317137428,
0.030911753,
-0.0310549177,
-0.0399788693,
0.0018179432,
0.0277055074,
-0.0128821582,
-0.0195804704,
-0.0096168108,
-0.0439889543,
0.0248107985,
-0.0158988554,
-0.02814194,
-0.0296478178,
0.0706134811,
-0.0441708304,
-0.0111514525,
-0.0225425754,
0.0004859771,
0.0163000841,
-0.014848656,
0.0083614076,
-0.0606901459,
0.008290329,
0.0301859714,
0.0309947003,
0.0317559689,
-0.0641524494,
-0.0151785584,
-0.0362269655,
0.0179147832,
0.0447616279,
0.0340159088,
-0.0263252612,
-0.0463575013,
-0.0524068139,
0.0520637892,
-0.0599106066,
0.0427812226,
0.0573023446,
0.0061957608,
-0.0935448855,
-0.0046902373,
0.015017475,
0.0161280334,
-0.0015603695,
-0.0590757281,
0.0181669686,
-0.0075211325,
0.0216377582,
-0.0614726357,
-0.013860587,
-0.0073222006,
0.0473509841,
-0.0155383032,
0.0340207443,
0.0178865455,
-0.0316288806,
-0.0274709724,
-0.0379444845,
0.0056467927,
0.0142786605,
0.0166263375,
0.0613852739,
0.0416667573,
0.0296351723,
-0.0282200798,
-0.0269428734,
-0.0117919603,
0.0251770373,
0.0362659171,
0.0241763741,
-0.018109696,
0.0449041314,
0.0148505168,
0.008435145,
0.0566471294,
0.0048246873,
-0.0046533165,
-0.0614399314,
-0.0464076214,
-0.0140695255,
-0.0247588828,
-0.0669725537,
0.0207089931,
-0.0549507961,
0.0504423343,
0.0534467921,
-0.0343646929,
-0.0000065894,
-0.033236634,
2.642e-7,
0.0755388886,
0.0639244691,
0.0323487855,
-0.0195808876,
0.0509612411,
0.024509782,
0.0084831379,
-0.0036194841,
0.0138599742,
0.0142853996,
0.0720977038,
0.0012198305,
0.0465976559,
0.033503294,
-0.0243601296,
-0.0505078696,
-0.0757088959,
-0.0216906164,
-0.0211335048,
-0.0032046274,
0.0922224447,
0.012360096,
-0.0397109464,
-0.0331937745,
-0.0110981138,
0.0071054823,
0.0197279323,
-0.0572421364,
0.0229839236,
0.0111672916,
0.0316036791,
-0.0064898147,
0.0279407948,
0.0806892514,
-0.0051307254,
-0.0504890531,
0.0081745973,
0.1035571024,
-0.0573806465,
0.0465500131,
0.0676137954,
-0.0137657421,
0.0413344987,
-0.057627067,
0.0261342525,
-0.0545062572,
-0.0544457808,
0.0014152646,
-0.0047132457,
-0.0273404066,
0.0879286751,
-0.0414872281,
-0.0427435897,
0.0406127907,
0.0119997561,
0.0267993249,
0.0098007238,
-0.0274081305,
0.0099496907,
0.0345533676,
-0.0360658839,
-0.0427085496,
0.0323145017,
-0.0178796779,
-0.005690793,
-0.0605114661,
0.0367977098,
1.984527649e-34,
0.0190453026,
0.0396046452,
0.0027422095,
0.0443415456,
0.0469811298,
0.0190488063,
0.0616267622,
0.027982546,
0.0371796899,
-0.041363135,
-0.0259489585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17690v1 | Non-contrastive sentence representations via self-supervision | 2023-10-26T18:00:00 | 2023-10-26T18:00:00 | Marco Farina, Duccio Pappadopulo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sample contrastive methods, typically referred to simply as contrastive are
the foundation of most unsupervised methods to learn text and sentence
embeddings. On the other hand, a different class of self-supervised loss
functions and methods have been considered in the computer vision community and
referred to as dimension contrastive. In this paper, we thoroughly compare this
class of methods with the standard baseline for contrastive sentence
embeddings, SimCSE. We find that self-supervised embeddings trained using
dimension contrastive objectives can outperform SimCSE on downstream tasks
without needing auxiliary loss functions. | [
0.0035447895,
0.0338464566,
0.0113392584,
0.0605197847,
-0.0438772924,
0.0047519822,
0.0445228666,
-0.0224719737,
0.0438739099,
-0.043730095,
-0.0291885845,
-0.0165531635,
-0.0193808321,
0.0177847892,
0.0150539959,
-0.0744544119,
0.0040079611,
0.0095684016,
-0.0005635924,
0.0068774172,
0.0227256157,
-0.0065831123,
-0.011500339,
-0.0083935922,
-0.0381908119,
-0.0560322329,
0.0159478895,
0.0025739826,
0.0234080553,
-0.0319086574,
0.065767251,
0.0508965813,
0.0458861813,
-0.0229684766,
0.0000017319,
-0.010404787,
0.0142680993,
-0.0267925393,
0.0057505593,
0.0260146931,
0.063585721,
-0.079322353,
0.0179695059,
-0.0044338387,
-0.0289810747,
-0.0221965164,
0.0303341616,
0.0848449171,
0.0596611388,
0.0714496672,
-0.0170882661,
-0.066224575,
-0.0008638078,
-0.026688328,
-0.0249050371,
0.0376913324,
0.0046373275,
0.0035612327,
-0.0557220913,
0.0616546981,
-0.0416828282,
0.0282836147,
0.0391896591,
-0.0028795141,
0.0377541855,
0.025912663,
0.0000305329,
0.0475155562,
-0.0152186127,
0.0495447926,
0.0056681102,
0.026914075,
-0.0204312075,
-0.0284703933,
-0.0197630189,
-0.0309853163,
-0.0141798202,
0.016552167,
0.0494837239,
0.0496120192,
0.0205266289,
0.0933892354,
-0.0237609744,
0.0009842828,
0.0161571745,
-0.0243719015,
-0.002060212,
-0.0175544806,
-0.0102135036,
0.0246873405,
0.0025623594,
0.0335315913,
-0.0019124796,
-0.008649339,
0.0458865128,
-0.0274415743,
-0.0171008445,
-0.0550658032,
0.0127279395,
-0.0614854321,
0.0692539886,
0.007456881,
-0.0469112732,
0.0458836854,
-0.0114151947,
0.049508065,
-0.0175172985,
0.0249810815,
-0.0343425795,
0.0222472455,
-0.0203185398,
-0.0099003529,
-0.0442724489,
0.0497051179,
-0.0532233752,
-0.0329540707,
-0.0443131998,
0.0218321793,
0.0000852499,
-0.0012641945,
0.025228275,
0.042012278,
-0.0432436354,
-0.0285947155,
-0.0119028883,
0.0264410991,
-0.02765687,
-0.0003954848,
-0.0150510008,
-0.0192619264,
-0.0389217213,
0.0421414636,
0.024540836,
-0.0227999613,
0.0031447955,
0.0743044242,
-0.016599752,
-0.0761384889,
-0.0452171788,
0.0038823707,
-0.0777418837,
-0.0468284562,
-0.0085535422,
-0.0640411004,
-0.0020128591,
-0.0186129864,
0.0072373017,
-0.0290339552,
-0.0020440095,
-0.0121143153,
0.0074705239,
0.0684035048,
0.0248958096,
-0.0585718155,
-0.0213683546,
0.0172305312,
0.0362293534,
0.068984732,
-0.0085842749,
0.005728825,
0.008318333,
0.0175796486,
0.0272349026,
-0.0282190703,
-0.0193564873,
0.0112534584,
-0.0615510158,
0.0294724051,
0.0128507856,
0.0396255143,
0.0645211488,
0.042660851,
-0.0175170228,
-0.0586564578,
0.066758275,
0.0424590968,
0.055162359,
0.0162886586,
0.0552240424,
0.0358076058,
-0.0185978226,
0.0583004206,
-0.0138473669,
0.0369239561,
0.0563844666,
0.0009533328,
0.0307998732,
0.0013438314,
-0.0685364008,
-0.0464802571,
0.0172354765,
-0.0468935631,
-0.0031765541,
-0.0382732078,
0.0578779504,
0.0472919978,
-0.011291883,
-0.0337301716,
0.0166010596,
-0.043392688,
-0.0384754576,
0.0356132239,
-0.0048018517,
0.0799021423,
0.0066986526,
-0.0486394912,
0.017030837,
0.0002009102,
0.0165276732,
0.0549266487,
0.0287069865,
0.0151068307,
0.068748787,
-0.0495301448,
-0.0299165566,
-0.0941962898,
0.0335327238,
-0.0093132928,
-0.0296300128,
0.0019570023,
0.0258793868,
-0.0347154364,
-0.0240798127,
0.0326850116,
0.0173440594,
-0.0704479069,
0.0393757112,
0.0346826613,
-0.0353598632,
0.0183383003,
-0.0097032674,
0.0108065289,
0.0021196771,
-0.0552528054,
-0.0288767703,
-0.0194178615,
-0.0979219452,
-0.1456978321,
-0.0061963829,
-0.0825741962,
-0.0206999555,
0.0849131569,
-0.0405318923,
-0.0207756497,
0.0378435925,
-0.0437154733,
-0.0146755045,
-0.051113341,
-0.0388502032,
0.0422891714,
0.0406928398,
0.0102637876,
0.0640692785,
-0.014821386,
0.0033265189,
-0.0390819423,
0.0265431404,
0.0306279566,
-0.0430717245,
-0.0145008378,
-0.0490576215,
0.0287594814,
0.0377646461,
0.0127046807,
0.0009306581,
-0.0366000384,
0.0117896711,
-0.0402300172,
-0.0118377786,
-0.0382284224,
0.0097912373,
0.0308295861,
0.0108904876,
0.008374054,
-0.0570912287,
-0.0221915171,
-0.0353054218,
-0.040872775,
0.0249332767,
0.0833754614,
-0.0028848047,
0.0399343371,
-0.0100553185,
-0.027028108,
-0.0162101388,
0.0691801831,
-0.0476942025,
-0.004026907,
-0.0191821735,
0.0458237566,
0.0051151826,
0.0164547022,
0.0054422389,
-0.046423845,
0.0021374035,
-0.0173287001,
0.0675982758,
0.074548535,
0.0277588107,
0.048604615,
0.0252427068,
0.0068527958,
-0.014260334,
-0.008011342,
-0.0329372063,
0.0584412366,
0.0066654831,
-0.0003229367,
-0.0133910365,
0.081004329,
0.0165069941,
0.0014994354,
-0.0483987294,
0.005995234,
0.0205512699,
-0.0027152477,
-0.0070628589,
0.0344312266,
-0.0018815283,
-0.0077313115,
0.0047695502,
-0.0332365967,
0.0539112203,
-0.0094032092,
-0.0152711691,
-0.0348404534,
-0.0422230363,
-0.0198074616,
0.0577974692,
0.0213537756,
0.0193062164,
0.0134051489,
-0.0105959261,
-0.0194485113,
-0.0184319373,
0.0473898984,
0.0353189446,
0.0018717749,
0.0057030437,
-0.0103616584,
-0.0035463604,
-0.0437872671,
-0.0136371125,
-0.0786927715,
-0.0081010014,
0.0136055388,
-0.0025005292,
0.0093488637,
-0.0010507423,
0.001947796,
0.0068461616,
0.0531077944,
-0.0240162425,
-0.006756403,
-0.0225297268,
0.0768771768,
0.0401159935,
0.0059575089,
0.0013481588,
-0.009605688,
0.0680931732,
0.0413803793,
0.0246710386,
-0.0144680738,
-0.0635503456,
0.0204253141,
-0.0265461467,
-0.0173384286,
-0.0042159441,
0.0215486027,
0.0218846928,
-0.0534798726,
-0.0280834064,
0.0768879801,
0.0009469606,
-0.0182456207,
-0.0126416329,
0.0143691069,
-0.022183774,
0.0277752578,
-0.0213691648,
-0.0449697115,
-0.0289256908,
-0.0668813139,
-0.004533133,
0.0234440062,
-0.0014183741,
-0.0120952474,
-0.0660252199,
0.0458165891,
0.0189941712,
-0.0140815238,
-0.0261657145,
-0.0145162772,
-0.0111432411,
-0.0313833654,
-0.0225671511,
-0.0231668018,
-0.0229095593,
-0.0255215522,
0.0015302177,
-0.0477406569,
-0.0228067189,
-0.0248993449,
-0.0440574028,
0.0168427005,
0.0079258196,
0.0079088286,
-0.0056945309,
-0.023803791,
0.0265656486,
-0.094503969,
0.0028744172,
0.0025212441,
0.0938942507,
-0.0619567893,
-0.0216496382,
-0.0164504163,
0.0191276018,
-0.0174700078,
-0.0179936271,
-0.0323693156,
0.0489266776,
-0.0142662581,
-0.016066609,
-0.034963917,
0.024139557,
0.0071008028,
0.066792652,
0.0254706666,
-0.0403035022,
-0.0554892831,
-0.0010702519,
0.023955673,
-0.0497314595,
-0.0407316498,
-0.0085953269,
0.049619168,
0.0269247126,
-0.0491701886,
-0.0945483223,
-0.0121722845,
0.0256746039,
-0.0616382845,
0.0037069211,
-0.0595015772,
-0.0169314966,
-0.0394929014,
0.0196285825,
-0.0379091576,
-0.0311308745,
0.0118204691,
-0.0020988062,
0.0248370133,
-0.0151860937,
-0.0159721654,
-0.0429082252,
-0.044280149,
-0.0402142555,
-0.0195860676,
0.0615153834,
-0.0098162526,
0.036065504,
0.0143014453,
0.0010023394,
0.0787244141,
0.0545749515,
-0.0398138352,
0.009126462,
0.0553493798,
0.0056397715,
0.0068934215,
0.051998537,
0.0045782938,
0.0377230383,
0.0120839281,
0.0291330107,
0.0006003557,
-0.0265246853,
0.0227479599,
-0.0496541932,
0.0799282417,
-0.003411429,
0.0345309116,
-0.0203785636,
0.0038828321,
-0.0558694303,
-0.0222001225,
-0.0488660783,
0.0415970795,
0.0129045965,
0.0586067028,
-0.0199616421,
0.0232480336,
-0.0456965081,
-0.0215836186,
-0.0230791811,
0.0092298584,
0.0353869908,
-0.0134498524,
-0.0450057834,
0.0292792749,
-0.0203962494,
0.0031640651,
-0.0086074267,
0.0003385642,
0.0145158228,
0.0150511386,
0.0274788458,
-0.002969051,
-0.044119738,
0.0350967236,
-0.0604847856,
0.05730436,
-0.0386270545,
-0.0062319729,
0.0331326053,
-0.0641870871,
-0.0178665426,
-0.037945956,
-0.0157836564,
-0.0092338314,
0.0432390384,
0.0042008255,
0.023703374,
-0.0035966968,
0.0199517682,
-0.0389400199,
0.0001981152,
0.0516395681,
0.0148578975,
0.0183521602,
0.0552048087,
0.0026266242,
-0.0517076962,
-0.0110956421,
0.0163456574,
0.0264553931,
0.0108817266,
0.0076490338,
-0.0099875825,
-0.0490393937,
0.0421698987,
0.0146855637,
-0.0197199322,
0.0018545374,
0.0646329746,
-0.0199561939,
0.017538406,
0.0139997331,
-0.014797952,
0.0151025103,
0.0000844751,
-0.0190822221,
-0.0048508057,
-6.128833221e-33,
0.0150259882,
-0.0143615222,
-0.0195320025,
-0.0151323033,
0.0122170029,
0.0474802367,
-0.0243120454,
0.0078322114,
0.0242075045,
0.0501572862,
0.0378283001,
0.0214113053,
0.0019894578,
0.0585473441,
0.0110655809,
-0.0129561108,
0.0352530219,
-0.0389033593,
-0.0167694744,
-0.0101494147,
0.0026706778,
0.0328727663,
0.0602555722,
-0.0764460266,
0.0077928379,
-0.0137687316,
0.0000796492,
0.0284650065,
0.073935844,
0.0637343526,
-0.0317474902,
0.0464365259,
0.034025263,
-0.0384448171,
-0.0314216688,
0.0286524147,
-0.0693778098,
-0.037340112,
-0.0311679505,
-0.0176110864,
-0.1080830991,
-0.0166408736,
0.0196053609,
-0.0163250435,
0.0121999644,
-0.0370066091,
0.0459183119,
-0.009260932,
0.0187950954,
0.0335365757,
-0.0577539355,
0.0122439638,
-0.0088448916,
-0.0182196032,
0.0618239678,
0.017400261,
0.0376102403,
0.0264146738,
-0.0034468432,
-0.000249405,
-0.0250391383,
0.0294798668,
-0.0075152074,
0.0011898902,
-0.0180816017,
0.0432999507,
0.0386883058,
-0.0210253187,
-0.0139351413,
-0.0558689833,
-0.0082021663,
0.0268241223,
0.0679163039,
0.0642810389,
0.0105099166,
0.0207429882,
-0.0750007853,
0.0190079324,
-0.0362636335,
-0.0136757474,
0.0177129041,
0.0134609044,
-0.0498510115,
-0.0013900325,
0.0250408016,
-0.0557739884,
-0.0147807617,
-0.023624273,
0.0334497355,
0.011490114,
-0.0014229655,
0.0358362123,
0.0107756723,
-0.0381903127,
-0.0045947055,
-0.0058842595,
-0.0279893745,
0.0045493646,
0.0429200046,
0.0059993947,
-0.0437934734,
0.006412385,
0.0146276336,
0.0511039272,
-0.0134846447,
-0.0278370846,
0.0641188025,
-0.0052754637,
-0.0660841689,
-0.0242417715,
-0.0125427712,
-0.0352441631,
-0.032189358,
0.0115087079,
0.0109605798,
-0.0163428579,
-0.0389144532,
0.0712440163,
0.0086751506,
-0.0287216958,
-0.0224970393,
-0.0079647265,
0.0025139709,
0.038635809,
0.018705599,
-0.0037515545,
-0.0372870043,
0.0299301092,
0.0203882903,
-0.03906608,
-0.0032986787,
0.0205355361,
2.279e-7,
0.0212896802,
-0.0051957387,
0.0434105806,
-0.0249531567,
0.0203765053,
0.0736114234,
-0.0056209364,
0.0497501977,
-0.0720290095,
0.019602349,
0.0298914686,
0.060101293,
0.0300750174,
-0.0269482043,
-0.0463139489,
0.077094391,
-0.0503173582,
-0.0071900091,
-0.0198117364,
-0.0091262553,
0.0661433116,
0.0547892489,
0.0143545978,
0.0177640673,
0.0004411916,
-0.0235782582,
0.0781836957,
0.0124364002,
0.0114494087,
-0.0502136648,
-0.0438120887,
0.0424265191,
-0.0371411964,
-0.0129011245,
0.0073167584,
0.0226320084,
0.0317374282,
0.0496702939,
0.0264207106,
-0.0393467434,
0.0155305862,
0.0481760241,
-0.0046752975,
0.0152359782,
0.0515555479,
-0.0762030408,
-0.022312073,
-0.0141637335,
-0.0285532624,
0.0076742964,
0.0687128082,
0.015850015,
-0.0569947101,
-0.0069650025,
0.0315873697,
-0.0163495615,
-0.0272963066,
-0.0745248124,
-0.021432016,
0.0379834138,
-0.0222945251,
0.0113084652,
-0.0503935814,
0.0693879426,
0.0607139245,
-0.0313063487,
-0.0191956926,
1.524762191e-34,
0.0128940158,
-0.0024933228,
-0.008630082,
-0.0180400349,
-0.0383680128,
-0.0170524288,
-0.0373043716,
-0.0569793358,
0.0625043288,
-0.0372238718,
-0.0091052465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17688v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17688v3 | Managing extreme AI risks amid rapid progress | 2023-10-26T17:59:06 | 2024-05-22T16:19:38 | Yoshua Bengio, Geoffrey Hinton, Andrew Yao, Dawn Song, Pieter Abbeel, Trevor Darrell, Yuval Noah Harari, Ya-Qin Zhang, Lan Xue, Shai Shalev-Shwartz, Gillian Hadfield, Jeff Clune, Tegan Maharaj, Frank Hutter, Atılım Güneş Baydin, Sheila McIlraith, Qiqi Gao, Ashwin Acharya, David Krueger, Anca Dragan, Philip Torr, Stuart Russell, Daniel Kahneman, Jan Brauner, Sören Mindermann | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Artificial Intelligence (AI) is progressing rapidly, and companies are
shifting their focus to developing generalist AI systems that can autonomously
act and pursue goals. Increases in capabilities and autonomy may soon massively
amplify AI's impact, with risks that include large-scale social harms,
malicious uses, and an irreversible loss of human control over autonomous AI
systems. Although researchers have warned of extreme risks from AI, there is a
lack of consensus about how exactly such risks arise, and how to manage them.
Society's response, despite promising first steps, is incommensurate with the
possibility of rapid, transformative progress that is expected by many experts.
AI safety research is lagging. Present governance initiatives lack the
mechanisms and institutions to prevent misuse and recklessness, and barely
address autonomous systems. In this short consensus paper, we describe extreme
risks from upcoming, advanced AI systems. Drawing on lessons learned from other
safety-critical technologies, we then outline a comprehensive plan combining
technical research and development with proactive, adaptive governance
mechanisms for a more commensurate preparation. | [
0.0321744047,
0.0688835829,
-0.0158402659,
-0.0463013276,
-0.0287048109,
-0.0061169402,
0.0051874178,
-0.0097216135,
0.0635467395,
-0.0112412944,
0.0369409621,
0.0529858731,
-0.0391044393,
0.0738028288,
0.0248698648,
-0.0095445691,
0.0501793772,
-0.0577217899,
0.0262554772,
0.0178633407,
-0.0071306792,
-0.0039308988,
0.0150389122,
0.0369922556,
-0.0639308691,
-0.0332281329,
0.0250131246,
0.0047990405,
0.0444261134,
-0.0424115956,
0.0206446964,
-0.0326423049,
0.0247065164,
0.0403818339,
0.0000021668,
-0.0330416225,
0.0130431885,
0.0307908691,
-0.0197781678,
-0.0514578335,
0.0230925158,
0.0156792328,
-0.0015259025,
0.0440106615,
-0.0410648286,
0.0506471172,
0.026880553,
0.0185307804,
-0.0096255345,
0.0303732138,
-0.0230415463,
0.0237868708,
0.0526451766,
0.0362035632,
-0.0350771211,
-0.0535794273,
0.0095931198,
-0.0117032165,
0.0176263861,
-0.0259148683,
0.0150409052,
0.0432535671,
0.0142516606,
-0.0006441128,
-0.0024289868,
0.044794336,
0.0193805322,
-0.0617263913,
-0.0337769613,
0.016186811,
-0.0036466219,
-0.009141691,
0.0263244398,
0.0092395209,
0.0238122083,
-0.0437827818,
-0.0005402179,
0.038796518,
-0.0204682332,
-0.0248785429,
0.0105521511,
0.0309552606,
0.0310815275,
0.0507771261,
0.0135666709,
0.0402531624,
-0.008306725,
-0.0136199081,
0.0387929901,
0.0065878271,
0.061685238,
-0.0059320717,
0.0007314809,
0.0058484394,
-0.0513097718,
-0.0240377132,
-0.0441895761,
-0.0191203542,
0.0163257681,
-0.047857672,
0.0126141571,
-0.0218173247,
0.0042771301,
0.0108379731,
0.0592554286,
0.0025361674,
-0.0600189157,
0.0473294705,
-0.0241995864,
0.0314465389,
0.0052651642,
0.0269702505,
-0.0098100509,
0.0078772986,
0.0054045422,
0.018289471,
0.0383761115,
0.0523926467,
-0.0688094348,
0.0162908267,
-0.0398709364,
0.0534038395,
0.0131126782,
-0.0160493907,
0.0099486001,
-0.0666635633,
-0.0387125313,
0.0251227207,
0.0106629198,
-0.0263634864,
0.0040382482,
0.0045445752,
-0.0169157702,
-0.0272358898,
-0.0017289608,
0.1102904081,
0.0255646519,
-0.0293201525,
-0.0550186262,
-0.0360957012,
-0.0170248244,
-0.022125259,
0.0172599629,
-0.0030901376,
-0.0079076607,
-0.0184000302,
-0.027666349,
-0.0362733416,
-0.0101557281,
-0.0187881347,
-0.0504987203,
0.0150467232,
-0.0494380631,
0.0050656269,
0.0212190207,
0.0386657156,
-0.0487962775,
-0.0067433566,
0.035462711,
0.038191244,
0.0395666808,
0.0269399714,
0.0748519823,
0.0149147548,
-0.030633809,
0.021078404,
0.0255136155,
0.0184912421,
-0.0190075058,
0.0051524192,
-0.0046434198,
0.0472176746,
-0.0001114097,
0.0194888264,
0.0676096007,
0.0353200473,
-0.0828212872,
0.023847634,
0.0103378762,
-0.0128706517,
-0.0223539416,
-0.0769759566,
-0.0297356807,
-0.0040788539,
-0.0550874472,
-0.0408459231,
-0.0455329679,
0.060610313,
-0.0439256355,
-0.0295771044,
0.0054372759,
-0.0580460839,
0.0478919856,
0.0489969067,
0.006517523,
-0.0199586451,
0.0178763345,
-0.0943689346,
-0.025815405,
-0.0110253077,
-0.0146522466,
-0.0889791548,
-0.0091119511,
0.0895022005,
0.0283314474,
-0.051612515,
-0.0526701622,
-0.0392009653,
-0.0203879327,
-0.0330564156,
-0.0338076726,
0.0089516379,
0.0240568928,
0.0290065221,
-0.016431069,
0.0483858958,
0.0148194702,
0.0019970904,
-0.014022842,
0.0409606509,
-0.0442766063,
0.0244993586,
-0.0691417307,
0.010980173,
-0.0393211693,
-0.0323251598,
-0.0264615491,
0.0148987975,
0.0074077076,
0.0211613476,
-0.0322172567,
0.0243926477,
0.0764948949,
0.0042716959,
-0.0446476042,
0.0027644206,
0.0330979005,
0.1334654838,
-0.0040092939,
-0.0697000921,
-0.0429664776,
0.0593640134,
-0.0150287813,
0.0013534605,
0.017460376,
-0.0174442437,
-0.0652802587,
0.0321887061,
-0.0088532036,
0.0018063049,
-0.0024676821,
0.0037839839,
0.0222454667,
-0.001644115,
-0.1085106879,
-0.0061276676,
-0.0304072704,
0.0212268904,
-0.0043557431,
-0.037466377,
-0.0011866958,
-0.0239237621,
0.0293367915,
0.0509033091,
-0.0124582089,
-0.0113155507,
0.0408829749,
-0.009645218,
-0.0312208962,
-0.0054963529,
-0.0062723043,
-0.0312967822,
-0.0064253858,
-0.0145779718,
-0.0284013171,
0.0336653627,
0.01858937,
-0.0032441937,
0.0114533771,
0.0052750553,
0.031952627,
-0.0285687912,
-0.0025651678,
0.0191624202,
-0.0149828717,
-0.0019101948,
0.063633576,
-0.029130457,
-0.0550708696,
0.0200185589,
-0.0321980342,
0.0329098739,
-0.0056183897,
-0.0073958193,
0.0183850992,
-0.0128018595,
-0.0357548036,
0.0669832379,
0.0086888699,
0.0696005598,
0.0733767673,
0.0389200114,
0.0077973693,
0.0006037558,
0.0368041284,
-0.0202904418,
-0.0064168684,
0.0294793025,
0.0006426609,
-0.0331015252,
-0.0150221698,
0.0040034396,
0.0023898501,
0.0398179851,
-0.0554619096,
-0.0933547616,
0.0233711377,
-0.0766375661,
-0.0481775962,
0.0438220911,
-0.0182770826,
-0.0457869284,
0.0244870204,
0.0317368135,
0.0338601097,
0.0188940614,
-0.0533130132,
0.0203133617,
0.0590533651,
-0.0007329536,
0.0192205794,
0.0192436315,
-0.0048951586,
-0.0194549318,
-0.0086306082,
-0.0268592946,
-0.0297821816,
-0.0091213044,
-0.0336880758,
0.0116229299,
0.0035000949,
-0.0699193478,
-0.0271103792,
-0.0342603214,
-0.0190914162,
0.0228250381,
-0.0224053767,
-0.0294103511,
-0.0002462662,
-0.059751112,
0.0716139078,
0.0066460357,
0.0187754445,
-0.0271455217,
-0.00578995,
-0.0583744198,
0.0490938686,
-0.033987727,
0.0582538284,
0.0364549123,
0.0235319789,
0.0465200618,
0.0635454208,
-0.0167862289,
-0.0510795973,
-0.0109916693,
-0.0015214831,
0.0058251121,
0.0350770466,
0.0368707627,
0.0164873004,
0.0127223739,
-0.0158326216,
-0.0032563284,
-0.0145123396,
-0.0125455139,
0.0487607606,
-0.0009835559,
-0.0213025715,
-0.0045218533,
0.0252359193,
-0.0603434071,
0.0366239473,
0.0159869865,
0.0221967492,
-0.0713588893,
-0.0615662709,
0.0636008605,
-0.0134174889,
0.0652621239,
-0.0053712218,
-0.0048286826,
-0.0603508539,
0.0010464147,
-0.0192149933,
-0.0410775766,
0.0528401807,
-0.0224506389,
0.0023621761,
-0.0225604307,
0.0234054215,
-0.0344898477,
0.0236939341,
0.015291498,
-0.066039741,
0.0343600772,
0.0846757367,
0.0012814603,
-0.0666248798,
0.036428459,
-0.0281984489,
0.0222462527,
0.0338477865,
0.025911998,
0.0369130969,
-0.0149476137,
-0.0002049744,
-0.0350045301,
0.0156011293,
-0.0051154061,
-0.0200559087,
0.0481806546,
0.0640344992,
-0.0677312091,
-0.0303652864,
-0.0587779507,
-0.023445759,
0.0320058055,
0.0340903811,
-0.041043058,
-0.0377963148,
-0.0278936662,
0.0056768288,
0.0370247923,
-0.034412872,
-0.0080027794,
-0.0047839643,
0.0049170838,
-0.0572479293,
-0.0501791798,
-0.0479408838,
-0.0217924509,
-0.0153936287,
0.0284575224,
-0.0837339908,
0.0037202986,
0.05022154,
-0.0239015408,
-0.0019291543,
0.0161401127,
0.0053038825,
0.0170713868,
0.0566343516,
-0.0306500122,
0.0220222436,
0.0037678932,
0.058426097,
0.0302914269,
-0.0359695815,
0.0725634992,
0.1031771526,
0.0204587802,
-0.0200042333,
-0.0376295336,
-0.0231527556,
0.0856981799,
0.0275404286,
-0.0231284071,
0.0009120301,
0.0457800217,
0.0021256541,
-0.014691337,
-0.0042181597,
-0.0428518206,
-0.0159798078,
0.0237327721,
-0.0329769701,
-0.0573071875,
-0.0144604901,
0.00645601,
0.0431955792,
-0.0067539853,
-0.0561903678,
0.0624905378,
0.03042138,
-0.0297562405,
0.018972164,
0.0124528129,
-0.0203397498,
0.0158122201,
-0.0078398064,
0.0021264905,
0.0044506178,
0.0502922423,
0.0276858788,
-0.0273572057,
-0.0454958044,
0.0358299538,
0.0030647649,
0.0865154415,
0.0000659055,
0.0187614318,
0.0038537355,
0.0492297634,
-0.0276013073,
0.0207036939,
-0.0012720703,
0.0225663297,
-0.0266334284,
0.0049767876,
-0.0165114123,
0.0844235644,
-0.0503614955,
-0.1102391928,
0.0157674216,
0.066073209,
0.0028114035,
0.0682397559,
-0.026236821,
-0.0363566019,
0.0080729639,
-0.0284945723,
-0.0147430226,
-0.0135955354,
-0.0007039147,
-0.0615815073,
0.0134620499,
-0.0283489358,
0.0052857837,
0.0538771823,
-0.0097415363,
0.0754690245,
-0.0156740546,
-0.0020488035,
0.0117633902,
-0.0439723991,
0.0340391807,
-0.0196754988,
0.0046430705,
-0.0534497313,
-0.0512094684,
-0.0440847427,
0.0002856824,
0.011588674,
-0.0208988655,
-0.0198729951,
0.0013692091,
-0.0263670366,
0.0173621215,
-0.0602535494,
0.0109313261,
-0.0386527553,
-0.0419943109,
-0.0155973136,
-0.0166369267,
-6.025445187e-33,
0.0557442568,
-0.0157643072,
-0.0203975961,
0.0146844918,
-0.0437197126,
-0.0078193797,
0.0151617145,
0.0280248523,
-0.0291163512,
0.0257483404,
-0.0250570644,
0.0240228977,
-0.0061024209,
-0.0242540371,
0.0532809086,
-0.0622370653,
-0.0063863164,
-0.0195751656,
0.0231920537,
0.0474986173,
0.0164900497,
0.0185738299,
-0.0036229675,
-0.0962561369,
0.0331413709,
0.0148207704,
-0.0449846163,
-0.0040142816,
-0.0310561173,
-0.0028126899,
0.0342064388,
0.0319169126,
0.0216888525,
-0.0264271013,
-0.0060663526,
0.0673386902,
-0.0154100014,
-0.002973171,
-0.0644627437,
-0.0264346693,
-0.0327030234,
-0.0855908841,
0.0329802223,
-0.0263093244,
-0.0292911418,
-0.0023246082,
0.0102331731,
-0.0147542041,
0.002520171,
-0.014447799,
-0.029268207,
-0.0197322089,
-0.0344506539,
0.0224872753,
0.0184778143,
0.0512751378,
-0.0048401905,
-0.0320808031,
-0.0405012704,
0.0061553954,
-0.0408052765,
-0.0702578872,
-0.0018512409,
-0.0226663314,
0.0006720048,
0.0289664641,
0.0130911712,
-0.0109019792,
-0.0437247604,
-0.0418388695,
-0.0252425838,
0.096887365,
0.0046451013,
0.0249724109,
-0.0469279662,
-0.0372788906,
-0.0560052991,
0.0444963612,
0.0027483643,
0.0479178056,
0.006474528,
-0.0239311159,
-0.0948648974,
-0.0035574576,
0.0445856787,
-0.0305137187,
-0.0203026123,
0.0214443523,
0.0133465184,
-0.0076449299,
-0.049983386,
0.0267806239,
-0.0108525585,
-0.0627487227,
0.0816955566,
-0.0146712279,
0.0577441454,
0.000906109,
-0.0010478825,
0.0161533747,
-0.0076337731,
-0.0240170937,
-0.0183255076,
0.0153669529,
0.0481239446,
0.0063387747,
0.017653523,
0.0550756641,
0.0236405879,
-0.000278167,
-0.0069739013,
0.0458151884,
0.0548313931,
-0.0223781038,
0.0096805692,
0.0213457197,
0.0400668792,
-0.0179823302,
0.0543745197,
0.0444399416,
-0.0040679108,
0.0210062768,
-0.0401635543,
-0.0183879174,
-0.0108275479,
0.0121764485,
-0.0581891797,
0.0152525138,
0.0238426756,
-0.0719029382,
-0.0143096112,
-0.009466581,
2.89e-7,
-0.0213063266,
0.0142854946,
0.017501412,
-0.023904318,
0.0239386503,
0.066245243,
0.0423792042,
0.0795581266,
-0.0261810441,
0.0228573941,
0.0682103112,
0.0147900907,
-0.0071971607,
0.0012137574,
0.0027913942,
-0.0597242899,
-0.0223243181,
0.0075560957,
-0.0548586026,
0.0149144344,
0.0521768481,
0.0173899475,
0.0135788945,
-0.0447822846,
0.0301851742,
-0.0466971286,
-0.0298670568,
-0.0102330036,
0.0506335497,
-0.0532418303,
-0.0049254545,
0.1049042046,
-0.0058257566,
0.0250679608,
-0.0124646369,
-0.0253492929,
-0.0402697399,
0.0597303212,
-0.032706935,
-0.0055461712,
0.004920173,
-0.0355888456,
0.0289872624,
-0.0041521424,
0.0561714061,
-0.0113428216,
-0.0307151992,
0.0056301448,
-0.0014962951,
-0.0045479825,
0.0062657851,
-0.0024711222,
0.0224652737,
-0.0025343024,
0.0059005106,
0.0095033729,
0.01395554,
-0.0310822111,
0.064706549,
0.0029098103,
0.0119314874,
-0.0669507086,
0.017629195,
0.0633532777,
-0.0173188262,
-0.0359054208,
0.0206766501,
2.18720239e-34,
-0.0472781509,
-0.046392981,
-0.0280103739,
-0.0202196874,
0.0435784347,
0.0388100035,
-0.0530505143,
-0.0196796432,
0.0169411302,
0.008267439,
-0.0299251508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17644v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17644v1 | torchdistill Meets Hugging Face Libraries for Reproducible, Coding-Free Deep Learning Studies: A Case Study on NLP | 2023-10-26T17:57:15 | 2023-10-26T17:57:15 | Yoshitomo Matsubara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Reproducibility in scientific work has been becoming increasingly important
in research communities such as machine learning, natural language processing,
and computer vision communities due to the rapid development of the research
domains supported by recent advances in deep learning. In this work, we present
a significantly upgraded version of torchdistill, a modular-driven coding-free
deep learning framework significantly upgraded from the initial release, which
supports only image classification and object detection tasks for reproducible
knowledge distillation experiments. To demonstrate that the upgraded framework
can support more tasks with third-party libraries, we reproduce the GLUE
benchmark results of BERT models using a script based on the upgraded
torchdistill, harmonizing with various Hugging Face libraries. All the 27
fine-tuned BERT models and configurations to reproduce the results are
published at Hugging Face, and the model weights have already been widely used
in research communities. We also reimplement popular small-sized models and new
knowledge distillation methods and perform additional experiments for computer
vision tasks. | [
-0.0004503817,
0.046594128,
0.0069097597,
0.0436108187,
-0.0324376486,
0.024649648,
0.0147085646,
0.0131324083,
-0.0013161437,
0.0042841276,
0.0066812565,
0.0232103635,
0.00885107,
0.0479955636,
0.0160773825,
-0.0407408737,
0.0148181049,
0.0066648889,
-0.0037354862,
-0.0012690717,
0.0171068441,
0.0172081254,
0.0026257837,
0.0037082483,
-0.0435559265,
-0.0320854224,
-0.0339353234,
0.0122184958,
0.0396040417,
0.0146090947,
0.0384866707,
0.0605287515,
0.0290528815,
0.0445558503,
0.0000023271,
-0.0230513159,
-0.0142936967,
0.0111868707,
-0.0402591564,
0.0323398821,
0.0118561191,
-0.0246320497,
0.0176039468,
-0.0040622372,
-0.0193690602,
-0.0206909124,
0.06883616,
0.0391685367,
0.0790363029,
0.0266344957,
0.0044242856,
-0.0181445424,
0.0319643505,
-0.0217780229,
0.038444642,
-0.0161387566,
0.0233286731,
-0.0039043657,
-0.0423118621,
-0.037740238,
-0.0073898346,
0.0329261236,
0.0603902042,
-0.0009377035,
0.0242151152,
0.0541602038,
-0.1373945028,
-0.0498837382,
0.0041738129,
0.0830709338,
-0.0563950576,
-0.0282241106,
-0.0037795827,
-0.0097464267,
-0.0218493734,
-0.0133546265,
-0.0213083606,
0.0018781145,
0.0208666772,
0.027877856,
-0.0639937967,
-0.0274786372,
0.0441109128,
-0.0247868821,
-0.033362411,
-0.0080144936,
0.0181988869,
-0.0071215937,
0.0274706874,
0.0211705863,
-0.0235012695,
-0.0619932972,
0.0085866628,
-0.0050612483,
0.0670637041,
-0.0154464524,
-0.0419043191,
-0.0028271473,
0.0189180635,
-0.0213292837,
-0.0037980089,
0.0025807405,
-0.0360629149,
0.054595191,
-0.0630585477,
0.0576052405,
-0.0035092151,
0.054726053,
-0.0068751308,
-0.0027215288,
-0.0511279032,
-0.0097150346,
0.0025551957,
0.0398549959,
-0.0189703647,
-0.0342863984,
-0.0148727903,
-0.014430522,
-0.0305138584,
0.0156235499,
0.0089767314,
0.0536820143,
-0.0177308097,
0.0271859914,
0.0004613554,
0.0601204187,
-0.0117052021,
-0.0185974091,
0.0064403447,
-0.0681754276,
-0.0422803722,
0.0111323074,
0.0031021377,
-0.0150664672,
0.0542566106,
-0.0032617871,
-0.0117440373,
-0.06644921,
-0.0025649103,
0.0281849448,
-0.0477268957,
-0.0544746853,
0.0641154721,
-0.092402339,
0.0675221533,
-0.0242499523,
-0.0014866655,
-0.0291486867,
-0.0060846158,
-0.0252597909,
-0.0008694425,
0.0738311112,
-0.0374731608,
-0.037137907,
-0.0080925748,
0.0422498398,
0.024096664,
0.0433174074,
-0.0095134564,
0.0467690043,
0.0091046663,
-0.0185301229,
0.0078110551,
0.0276653189,
0.0420620553,
0.019051116,
-0.0246788058,
-0.0039160601,
-0.0080126543,
-0.0218316447,
0.0126624024,
0.0415851735,
-0.0557764024,
-0.0493989252,
0.0285380855,
0.0130721051,
-0.013878108,
0.013490675,
-0.0178653654,
0.0012747879,
0.0442343876,
0.0134437112,
-0.0596047603,
0.0455442369,
0.002650985,
-0.0088637853,
-0.0026682531,
0.0517767295,
-0.0696584582,
-0.0155605264,
0.0088873114,
-0.0388999283,
0.0313898697,
0.0037717742,
0.0274704136,
0.0128530245,
-0.0060806447,
0.0617886037,
0.0168918278,
-0.0353969373,
-0.0048006489,
-0.0516955405,
0.0039173369,
0.0540322475,
0.0439832024,
-0.0411911495,
-0.0527498573,
0.0105843768,
0.0362104177,
0.026758207,
0.0034375472,
-0.012261075,
0.0785191208,
-0.0545995086,
-0.036450427,
-0.0539548509,
0.0011481248,
0.0220646728,
0.0350319855,
-0.0099888574,
0.0057946653,
-0.0372606404,
0.041932255,
0.0461192876,
-0.0369700193,
-0.0365632437,
-0.0264315773,
0.0106135607,
0.0309983529,
0.0016177857,
-0.0480925776,
-0.0298885815,
0.0559582151,
-0.0243277494,
-0.0168604087,
-0.0104896724,
-0.0004095857,
-0.0670784116,
0.0444249697,
-0.0623841919,
-0.0248970911,
0.0719367191,
-0.0634770691,
-0.0132061895,
0.0215600822,
-0.0038745853,
0.0404290408,
-0.0326170623,
0.0151238712,
-0.0194020327,
0.0281546842,
0.0049414835,
0.0432829522,
-0.0417677574,
-0.0147318542,
-0.0040461523,
-0.0062211216,
0.0077995104,
-0.0014078183,
-0.0587861724,
0.0098292809,
-0.0235933308,
0.0202343687,
0.0052954154,
0.0379234776,
-0.0170049742,
-0.0254987963,
-0.0840878934,
0.0213199649,
-0.0275094621,
-0.0152097251,
0.0108991154,
0.0211714488,
0.0196782313,
-0.0045129484,
-0.0088033052,
-0.0199210029,
-0.0225537233,
0.0093090506,
0.0310843587,
-0.0228368603,
-0.0104749966,
-0.0346292332,
-0.0581307523,
-0.0030668646,
0.0571241528,
-0.0417731516,
-0.0150045976,
0.0046507902,
-0.0149433315,
-0.0495138429,
0.0629470199,
-0.006157123,
-0.0255170185,
0.0363525152,
-0.0391682498,
0.0339317396,
0.0875766426,
-0.0054438291,
0.0081616733,
0.00159885,
0.0253997631,
-0.0714883879,
0.0291084982,
-0.0247670673,
0.0159460846,
0.0103651863,
-0.0303916205,
-0.00574183,
0.0176489241,
-0.0282703023,
-0.0030438923,
-0.080213435,
-0.0039245258,
0.0644889027,
-0.0579406284,
-0.0065896274,
0.0131269488,
-0.0110847028,
-0.0318567567,
-0.0571766123,
-0.0634324402,
0.0653930828,
-0.0217826162,
-0.0252662133,
-0.0069880611,
0.013081356,
-0.0137658697,
0.0721308365,
0.0169988107,
0.002210405,
-0.0199386384,
-0.0072640134,
-0.0139955711,
-0.0129394736,
-0.0248911772,
-0.0170896426,
0.0273205452,
-0.0299337991,
0.0010201769,
-0.0333266146,
-0.0415537246,
-0.0216844752,
-0.0017553294,
0.0086506354,
0.0279023349,
0.0112623209,
-0.0335360877,
-0.0327158123,
-0.0319608636,
0.0429380238,
0.0529747084,
0.0048006298,
0.0055154217,
-0.0404500663,
0.025126338,
0.0272308644,
-0.0204700436,
0.0287555475,
-0.0325535238,
0.0019035713,
0.0808242783,
0.0428832136,
0.0247043241,
-0.0980775207,
0.026336845,
0.0014945319,
0.0184747819,
-0.0262622517,
-0.013265417,
0.0342710055,
-0.0451699905,
0.0219869707,
0.0772735924,
0.0047810557,
-0.0084712608,
-0.0312291589,
0.015356998,
0.0557978526,
0.0327809788,
-0.0103432527,
-0.0816205293,
-0.0419344008,
-0.0078690778,
0.0178971216,
0.0747926384,
-0.034516003,
0.0283545461,
-0.0678806603,
0.0431984812,
-0.0113094384,
-0.0043038442,
-0.0488186218,
-0.0662450939,
-0.0041578887,
-0.0190764479,
-0.0191216934,
-0.0014348351,
0.0035671215,
-0.0020238147,
0.0210226029,
0.0145925572,
-0.023170406,
0.0555823073,
-0.0792839378,
0.0147548784,
0.0511955284,
0.0341791436,
0.0087227784,
-0.0643741116,
-0.0051697805,
-0.0213953238,
-0.0155877667,
-0.0090412851,
0.0742918402,
0.0135467555,
-0.0302717015,
0.0208263211,
0.0212014709,
-0.0651459992,
0.0023374094,
-0.0365158543,
0.0397887193,
0.0190355908,
-0.0676797181,
-0.0491817705,
-0.017971009,
-0.0319181308,
0.0803740397,
0.0377113558,
-0.0087003671,
-0.0785351694,
0.0075757913,
0.0101314429,
-0.0384351686,
-0.0017481209,
0.0186090488,
-0.0253878608,
-0.024783032,
-0.0232783295,
-0.0051177982,
0.0574730188,
0.0333717652,
-0.0146944206,
-0.0591776073,
-0.015494626,
-0.0026452753,
-0.0723147988,
0.0423719585,
0.0092935385,
0.0249523092,
-0.0179543607,
-0.0038562168,
0.0096238339,
-0.0059695458,
-0.0066801216,
0.0401825979,
-0.0724925324,
-0.0699392259,
-0.0044505508,
0.064777717,
0.0332067311,
0.0565497987,
-0.0088031637,
-0.0415533334,
0.0132704508,
0.0652969107,
0.0178604834,
0.022588918,
0.0186955277,
-0.0464770943,
-0.0032690216,
0.0140027804,
-0.0203736853,
0.0004406197,
0.0170653593,
0.0064881104,
-0.0302255172,
-0.0065825148,
-0.0060731415,
0.027719697,
0.0178053007,
0.0227763262,
0.0067299651,
-0.014788596,
0.0002774275,
0.0493058115,
0.0044299569,
-0.0674482584,
0.0187131204,
0.0115473736,
0.0147848511,
0.0186264105,
0.063335225,
0.037450444,
0.0466409624,
-0.0598311946,
-0.0019426591,
0.0338860676,
0.0312946066,
0.0426133052,
0.0003798129,
-0.015672436,
0.0325021632,
-0.0212571658,
0.0143618295,
-0.0377101377,
0.0040747784,
0.0390599966,
0.0206823647,
-0.0121736005,
0.0218306649,
-0.0508372337,
-0.0543494262,
-0.0639214814,
0.0336256474,
0.0098272329,
0.0190871283,
0.0522263162,
-0.0193437207,
-0.0286965501,
-0.0335431434,
-0.0062078587,
0.0043119635,
0.0040020235,
0.0160430018,
0.0417716131,
0.0000713225,
-0.0082095321,
0.0590998046,
0.0070869597,
0.0515249558,
0.009313548,
0.0059834514,
-0.0609318316,
-0.063229084,
0.0705077127,
-0.0068188468,
-0.0032435334,
-0.0322281346,
-0.0066317734,
-0.0719442517,
0.0218667537,
0.0074648256,
0.0211930126,
0.0370693356,
0.060756512,
0.0564671643,
0.0046548313,
-0.0548134409,
0.0312012136,
0.0304357242,
0.0059550013,
-0.0288884193,
0.0308253467,
-6.981914084e-33,
0.0287553705,
0.0618848838,
-0.011549768,
-0.0111635532,
-0.013438791,
0.0484456383,
-0.0224399865,
-0.0081442008,
-0.0246302355,
0.0307878144,
-0.0042974055,
0.0466405377,
0.0133490311,
-0.0019515267,
-0.0218294021,
-0.0301226676,
0.069407694,
-0.016177794,
-0.0153636746,
0.0564068258,
-0.0005528146,
0.0285334103,
0.0423432589,
-0.0469999462,
-0.0372462906,
0.043800626,
-0.0107367709,
0.008291821,
-0.0088080456,
0.0310351308,
-0.0388878994,
-0.0004258416,
-0.0018351312,
-0.0070289662,
-0.0227409024,
-0.004482782,
-0.110502325,
-0.0159282722,
-0.0079304511,
-0.0028653559,
-0.0800724328,
0.0195304081,
0.0785908997,
0.0046714037,
0.0200177059,
-0.0174104087,
0.0236084517,
-0.0134538347,
-0.0218250565,
-0.0328233317,
-0.0345127769,
0.0109009454,
-0.0293256957,
-0.0372076929,
0.051660873,
-0.0083022295,
-0.0018616981,
0.0445144549,
-0.0881192163,
-0.0163287558,
0.027011564,
0.0254840273,
0.0454090275,
0.029992098,
0.008448584,
0.0908882469,
0.0365519896,
-0.0043014144,
-0.0098838918,
-0.0073133451,
0.069429107,
0.1277021617,
0.0501545593,
0.0284607615,
0.0356579348,
-0.0007631244,
-0.0580591969,
0.0115434742,
0.0248469114,
0.0243168883,
0.0070585134,
0.0154571235,
0.0010406359,
-0.0046193171,
-0.0220706053,
0.0058379699,
-0.0365712978,
0.0032460736,
0.0128690647,
0.0430281311,
-0.0853823945,
0.0336947478,
0.0242612977,
-0.0339202397,
0.0274313409,
0.0413005911,
-0.0170157775,
0.0440548547,
0.0471043065,
0.000671993,
-0.0659426525,
-0.0163575597,
0.0284627844,
0.0204576757,
0.0332068615,
-0.00387901,
0.049961783,
0.0428327844,
-0.029736802,
-0.0115995333,
-0.054592222,
0.0350420326,
0.0269228071,
0.069406487,
-0.0000624978,
-0.0040206262,
0.0007953888,
-0.0251527801,
0.0215177648,
0.0241284389,
-0.0287475828,
0.0386332646,
0.0513452068,
0.0130360238,
-0.004625503,
-0.0297202747,
-0.0678633079,
-0.010425332,
0.0390825234,
-0.0826215446,
-0.0258838218,
0.0088407779,
2.929e-7,
0.0157816671,
0.0268073324,
0.0697794855,
-0.0155311758,
0.0476141647,
0.027200086,
-0.0181055851,
0.0383733734,
-0.0005725268,
-0.0510726906,
-0.0396141447,
0.0615476705,
0.0400568284,
0.0059516635,
-0.062915802,
-0.0031392085,
-0.036448285,
-0.0433395393,
-0.0202683005,
-0.047655683,
-0.0321374089,
0.074866198,
0.034111362,
-0.0358089618,
0.0485753752,
-0.0007152261,
0.0276986398,
-0.0079553425,
0.0550128445,
0.026954446,
0.0011724867,
0.0101009263,
-0.0245281849,
0.0247037057,
-0.0071514845,
-0.0188361388,
0.0332961641,
0.0694657639,
-0.0143958488,
-0.046053309,
-0.0023352597,
-0.014606636,
-0.0021210283,
-0.0752771869,
0.0853758231,
-0.0129768262,
-0.0063738045,
-0.0218045078,
-0.0818855092,
-0.018432159,
0.0510978773,
-0.0045666979,
0.0124452868,
0.043419458,
-0.0107925031,
-0.0348564349,
-0.0540400632,
-0.0857763439,
-0.0396313183,
-0.0328644514,
-0.0680589676,
-0.0281258486,
-0.0400448367,
-0.0159571581,
0.0085416306,
-0.0630987138,
-0.007081124,
3.078118742e-34,
0.0232931487,
-0.0000931866,
0.0157868415,
-0.0125918956,
-0.0014518942,
-0.0370245613,
-0.0607215501,
-0.0238872226,
-0.0337973908,
-0.0406254493,
-0.0334175304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17639v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17639v3 | In-Context Learning Dynamics with Random Binary Sequences | 2023-10-26T17:54:52 | 2024-04-16T01:35:03 | Eric J. Bigelow, Ekdeep Singh Lubana, Robert P. Dick, Hidenori Tanaka, Tomer D. Ullman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) trained on huge corpora of text datasets
demonstrate intriguing capabilities, achieving state-of-the-art performance on
tasks they were not explicitly trained for. The precise nature of LLM
capabilities is often mysterious, and different prompts can elicit different
capabilities through in-context learning. We propose a framework that enables
us to analyze in-context learning dynamics to understand latent concepts
underlying LLMs' behavioral patterns. This provides a more nuanced
understanding than success-or-failure evaluation benchmarks, but does not
require observing internal activations as a mechanistic interpretation of
circuits would. Inspired by the cognitive science of human randomness
perception, we use random binary sequences as context and study dynamics of
in-context learning by manipulating properties of context data, such as
sequence length. In the latest GPT-3.5+ models, we find emergent abilities to
generate seemingly random numbers and learn basic formal languages, with
striking in-context learning dynamics where model outputs transition sharply
from seemingly random behaviors to deterministic repetition. | [
-0.0180244949,
0.0574022904,
-0.0289862994,
0.0317621753,
-0.0410556495,
0.0241464805,
-0.0248213876,
-0.0340551846,
-0.0118849939,
-0.0308351293,
0.0076644365,
-0.0617265664,
0.0186637007,
0.0506534688,
0.0298204254,
-0.0180824809,
0.0474591181,
-0.0563142858,
-0.0002317562,
-0.0164517965,
-0.0143021187,
-0.040620774,
0.0164993573,
0.0270380042,
0.0238851942,
0.0053821364,
-0.0439932048,
-0.0257511344,
-0.0302015822,
-0.04268701,
-0.0130283544,
0.0560339577,
0.020709848,
0.0962835699,
0.0000016822,
-0.0520149656,
-0.0138352793,
-0.0070018182,
-0.0318286233,
-0.0006873712,
-0.0016303556,
0.0187776759,
-0.0349920914,
0.0120417792,
-0.0504377522,
-0.0131104812,
0.0723553449,
0.0043709828,
-0.0146728931,
0.052167207,
0.0011894942,
-0.0131902322,
0.0463847667,
-0.0500077419,
0.048710715,
-0.0074611451,
0.0051008011,
-0.0372602046,
0.0048672287,
0.0096831983,
-0.0323838703,
-0.0430938341,
0.0485875458,
0.060602352,
-0.0165857226,
0.0631004348,
-0.0241824202,
-0.0289472081,
-0.0275790114,
0.0443766862,
-0.0534720756,
-0.0478675365,
0.00297558,
0.0045257467,
0.0095883152,
-0.0160620809,
-0.0508894771,
0.0546178222,
0.0087504629,
0.0430483073,
0.0118540665,
-0.0044918461,
0.0567135736,
-0.0277378447,
-0.0239304006,
0.0493329167,
0.007268589,
-0.0240107141,
-0.0140797235,
0.0197774582,
-0.0204896647,
-0.0700601563,
-0.0503532179,
0.0276083015,
0.0001094504,
0.0347227193,
-0.0337749049,
0.0166571923,
0.0349020548,
-0.0380189493,
0.0410788134,
0.048346065,
-0.0217539184,
0.0216150433,
-0.0423365086,
0.0320665799,
0.0037462863,
0.0152968848,
0.0012827606,
0.0406233482,
-0.0448919609,
-0.0044406378,
-0.0054176492,
0.0310778618,
-0.0101917339,
-0.0384311974,
-0.0301539265,
0.0482523665,
0.0036872043,
0.0351948626,
-0.0328670293,
-0.0158485565,
-0.0330108777,
0.012063588,
-0.0343588404,
-0.0247942694,
0.0057503986,
-0.0037085526,
0.0238380637,
-0.0209142286,
-0.0384138562,
-0.0218070447,
0.0030624191,
-0.025033772,
0.0006633943,
0.0802585557,
-0.0239972193,
-0.0627701283,
-0.0765417218,
-0.029494863,
0.0055505889,
-0.0619790331,
0.0207420029,
-0.0592711419,
-0.0385468788,
0.0590565726,
0.0036931026,
-0.0010329189,
0.0412406586,
0.0239790194,
0.0052219373,
0.0863668993,
0.026364319,
-0.0248239134,
-0.0208720919,
0.0134205567,
0.0575875044,
0.0829160661,
0.0213317648,
0.0225008763,
0.0181654599,
-0.0061662691,
0.0025047604,
0.0454114191,
0.0218250249,
-0.0032721527,
-0.0197933447,
-0.0058747404,
0.0616017506,
0.0211490784,
0.0498244129,
0.0317628682,
-0.0289316997,
-0.0007906015,
0.0812116638,
0.0530444793,
-0.0152283944,
0.0269391518,
0.0367413871,
-0.0232765768,
-0.0118155396,
0.0605410859,
-0.0789877251,
0.0290014744,
-0.0121726356,
0.049191352,
0.0309588201,
0.0120794643,
-0.007456067,
-0.0135549409,
-0.0299888384,
-0.0158724096,
0.0260248836,
-0.0152950371,
0.0340281837,
0.0227856226,
-0.068740584,
0.01929616,
0.0088101216,
-0.016918486,
-0.0274802744,
-0.0476852432,
0.025770383,
0.0676777214,
0.0389874168,
-0.0137689821,
0.0232027862,
-0.0315764099,
-0.0176134482,
0.040135961,
-0.0065021771,
-0.0089858519,
0.013469548,
-0.0088082906,
-0.0291224606,
-0.0205448549,
0.0244650431,
0.0361902043,
0.0076178829,
0.0101822596,
0.004431454,
-0.0410361774,
-0.0029586875,
0.0236266218,
-0.0695023313,
-0.0587544069,
-0.0097865574,
-0.0039080377,
0.0411775894,
-0.0462756939,
-0.0160788167,
0.0287831668,
0.044688344,
-0.0289143194,
0.0198885389,
0.0203048736,
-0.0811287239,
-0.0198062509,
0.0575074628,
0.0114676869,
0.0001824585,
0.0094273882,
-0.0167145543,
-0.0491004251,
0.0445608571,
-0.0495911054,
0.084795326,
-0.0524980053,
0.0077212476,
0.0194967967,
0.041316133,
-0.0120507935,
0.083069779,
-0.0270346832,
0.017355755,
0.0032674866,
0.019452855,
0.0332956314,
-0.0354639105,
0.0160530042,
-0.006754837,
0.0096205473,
-0.0015147616,
0.0049516428,
-0.005058228,
-0.0178473312,
0.001944368,
-0.0654337928,
-0.0186733529,
-0.0246632528,
0.0164537057,
0.0015911988,
-0.0350087956,
0.0103394547,
0.0015634358,
-0.0215546284,
0.0042899377,
0.0217006169,
0.0372799262,
0.0618104041,
0.0098511679,
-0.0535222813,
-0.049860809,
-0.01251572,
-0.0157927647,
0.0590368919,
-0.0018723964,
0.0419905372,
-0.0592181347,
0.0101881567,
0.0309245382,
0.0452389941,
-0.0391090028,
-0.0078869434,
0.0560265072,
-0.0234574322,
0.0736773536,
0.0539695658,
-0.0034863097,
0.0514627062,
0.0589194261,
-0.0130442586,
-0.0127427401,
-0.0138905831,
-0.0370231383,
-0.0016443257,
-0.0475527234,
-0.0212255232,
-0.0502806753,
0.0738396049,
-0.0032681548,
-0.0018520649,
-0.04919146,
0.0141387545,
0.0073599103,
-0.026868457,
-0.0570959747,
-0.0095888684,
-0.056291759,
0.0846225321,
-0.0175153334,
-0.068275705,
0.0498138182,
-0.0127975997,
-0.0024713373,
-0.0257389285,
0.0035411441,
-0.0200571828,
0.1021263748,
0.0681510195,
-0.0051571345,
0.0315247998,
-0.009480455,
-0.0818910375,
0.0059081074,
0.017203154,
-0.0125229452,
0.0462444946,
-0.0444678664,
0.000935412,
-0.0060507376,
-0.0358519144,
-0.0493291356,
-0.0044505382,
-0.0051161498,
0.0277445167,
0.0121717686,
-0.0346974023,
0.0006807147,
0.0080564208,
0.0350309499,
0.0668298304,
0.0026887744,
-0.0249817893,
-0.0271975752,
0.0384775512,
0.0534049571,
-0.0178248677,
0.0438174233,
-0.0499525778,
-0.0014979439,
0.0287083015,
0.0399286337,
0.0241398904,
-0.0566866659,
0.0335319713,
0.0060519623,
-0.0281452816,
-0.0022840009,
0.0654231384,
0.0200617071,
-0.0383544937,
-0.0658995435,
0.090983212,
0.0102662994,
-0.0246058386,
0.0382152312,
-0.0096054459,
0.0486248545,
0.0446672961,
0.0127062742,
-0.0909294412,
-0.0145251714,
0.005087073,
0.0036031983,
-0.023804687,
-0.0165558774,
0.0059770388,
-0.1176053733,
-0.0017549454,
0.003655622,
-0.0606378801,
-0.0378132835,
-0.0432503745,
-0.0238407645,
0.0033374343,
0.0402067602,
0.0164606161,
-0.0298276693,
0.0290202107,
0.010453552,
0.0141200954,
-0.0683930591,
0.0503746308,
0.0199822746,
0.043629013,
0.0887068436,
-0.028248908,
-0.0406564176,
-0.0192841031,
0.0147276232,
-0.0159064978,
0.01210545,
0.0290584695,
0.0126246251,
0.032829199,
-0.008679864,
-0.021907419,
0.0329276398,
-0.0357284248,
-0.0429194123,
-0.0198505167,
0.0864353403,
-0.0123353545,
-0.0519319475,
-0.0052110995,
-0.0327894576,
0.0358916074,
0.0633253232,
0.0419955589,
-0.0350482538,
-0.057436686,
-0.0585281067,
0.0440852381,
-0.038900353,
-0.0237685908,
-0.0116430046,
0.0478656217,
-0.0354809612,
-0.0554138646,
-0.0287938286,
-0.0028416563,
0.021014953,
0.0159797035,
0.0173969716,
-0.0027441883,
-0.0054906327,
-0.0340997688,
0.0065632053,
0.0093516242,
0.0091515593,
-0.0777059421,
-0.0445556492,
-0.0043830732,
-0.0551343299,
-0.0417271405,
0.0445197225,
-0.1170362756,
-0.081097804,
0.026813101,
0.0465974919,
0.0280523356,
0.0349351913,
0.0474343486,
-0.0137506248,
0.0467577837,
0.0256209597,
-0.0025281906,
0.013786125,
0.0245266147,
0.0220849719,
-0.0108973281,
0.0229645986,
0.0152633805,
-0.0006692843,
0.0274624825,
0.0214437321,
-0.0441948511,
-0.0093057333,
0.0354909673,
-0.0380095132,
0.0464392975,
-0.0125206532,
0.0130165638,
-0.0145488223,
0.0183067285,
0.0276166871,
0.0212184452,
-0.0157909468,
-0.0396563709,
0.0488144457,
0.0065059997,
-0.0180037227,
-0.017669769,
0.0281208269,
0.0421759523,
-0.0080288192,
-0.0115753962,
0.0203060769,
0.0398977324,
0.0487827919,
-0.0171259139,
0.0138227334,
0.0484456196,
-0.0455265567,
0.0464247726,
-0.0061798329,
0.0305952765,
0.0162259005,
0.0211210847,
0.0190220121,
-0.0090024993,
-0.0735750124,
-0.0241583996,
-0.0254554339,
0.0137112327,
0.0684588104,
-0.0136043169,
0.0139406547,
-0.0931054801,
0.0162217543,
-0.0228415206,
-0.0014011441,
-0.0192196853,
-0.0188261308,
-0.0023033984,
0.0344601572,
-0.0310239214,
0.0074935812,
0.1068994477,
0.050195992,
0.0561694019,
0.0078296792,
0.0120422412,
-0.0249538962,
-0.016543936,
0.0334546119,
0.0503106602,
-0.0196746346,
0.0059874668,
-0.0307278205,
-0.0617010295,
-0.0017557117,
0.026234908,
0.0355363414,
-0.0380517468,
0.03660772,
0.0715826228,
-0.0253521893,
0.0162204616,
0.0100141792,
0.0244358499,
0.0514963381,
-0.0124925803,
-0.0568978153,
-6.246294862e-33,
-0.0044840788,
-0.041725181,
0.0202836581,
0.0110325636,
0.0200278163,
-0.0409316123,
-0.0711640641,
0.0469085015,
0.0080819018,
-0.0110792583,
-0.0202569049,
0.0015183119,
0.0062400135,
0.0393797606,
0.0464534573,
-0.0184077732,
0.0258560311,
-0.0222720075,
0.0077964417,
0.0276398417,
0.0412715562,
0.0113858311,
0.0438305624,
-0.0437337682,
0.0157270655,
-0.0067255544,
0.0003209642,
-0.0260035247,
-0.0475161262,
0.0437420346,
-0.0370311402,
0.0295419488,
0.0225020871,
-0.0533380359,
-0.03941416,
-0.0243315045,
-0.0304225571,
-0.0252095945,
-0.0053898534,
0.0205021147,
-0.0147117907,
-0.0317111202,
0.0343676917,
-0.0519670509,
-0.0582778789,
0.006094031,
0.0271971021,
-0.0168099664,
-0.0378532931,
-0.0264340881,
-0.0676278099,
0.0024094654,
0.0193365254,
0.0065016518,
-0.0111568552,
-0.0548115075,
-0.0146517195,
0.0041714176,
-0.0458889753,
0.0313439369,
0.0346950032,
0.0569830127,
0.0296823774,
0.025874678,
0.0502492338,
0.0412695818,
0.0236126389,
0.004773485,
0.0062395362,
0.0010734189,
0.0380125269,
0.020886125,
0.0175905246,
0.0334877372,
0.0726746842,
0.0108804964,
-0.0720417798,
0.002814058,
0.0409503803,
0.0005838532,
0.0424998887,
0.0093082162,
-0.0047564921,
-0.0206922553,
-0.0252954923,
-0.005457432,
-0.0085113663,
-0.0222383868,
0.0215285998,
0.0165745299,
0.0487627052,
-0.0356374867,
0.0215314664,
-0.0258402657,
-0.049342379,
0.020588167,
-0.0148444846,
-0.0036587731,
0.0180433467,
0.0081024086,
-0.0807617381,
-0.0406811126,
-0.0203776639,
0.0106115164,
-0.0040975334,
0.0015762812,
0.0213696063,
0.0405488499,
-0.0723926798,
0.0123210466,
-0.0504155308,
0.044105567,
0.0196925532,
0.0336722024,
0.0566322058,
-0.0360214338,
-0.0073034419,
0.0000815109,
-0.0269141477,
-0.0020420495,
-0.0317005217,
0.0305596739,
-0.0499511324,
0.0215581656,
-0.0095439795,
-0.0293615554,
-0.0687002465,
0.0094667049,
0.0290336628,
-0.0282992981,
0.0038801136,
0.0419246145,
2.493e-7,
0.007144528,
0.0180181433,
0.0003590792,
0.0366370194,
0.0702694356,
0.0249516591,
-0.056088008,
0.0165558606,
0.0045424583,
-0.0488625728,
-0.0078632236,
0.0042548077,
0.0298123229,
0.0077058398,
-0.0614921711,
-0.021241108,
-0.0431759544,
0.0556891412,
-0.0302794054,
-0.003392136,
-0.023848867,
0.1047325209,
-0.0006965029,
-0.0134936683,
0.0444913395,
-0.0632930622,
0.0671293065,
-0.0155875953,
0.0392445251,
-0.0265773367,
-0.0721346065,
0.0231459774,
-0.0175361093,
-0.0049315519,
-0.0128792003,
0.0084242588,
-0.0500133522,
0.0398156904,
0.00659031,
-0.0404695086,
0.0111194504,
-0.0022080457,
-0.0157586653,
-0.0591353215,
0.0683199838,
-0.0607278422,
-0.0248767957,
-0.0097070588,
0.0170448832,
-0.0319569893,
0.0078054657,
0.0207173284,
-0.0252859332,
-0.0090592001,
-0.0061526331,
-0.0033202013,
0.009100304,
-0.0496576652,
-0.0048433719,
0.002315637,
-0.0517732389,
-0.0567518249,
-0.0859525204,
0.00710236,
0.0234470014,
-0.0089105843,
-0.0269164983,
2.697498034e-34,
0.0339329503,
-0.0319197923,
0.0340517089,
0.0011862846,
0.0063648433,
-0.0202366076,
-0.0195866432,
0.0211546831,
0.0459449105,
-0.041194573,
-0.0427712798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17631v1 | JudgeLM: Fine-tuned Large Language Models are Scalable Judges | 2023-10-26T17:48:58 | 2023-10-26T17:48:58 | Lianghui Zhu, Xinggang Wang, Xinlong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) in open-ended scenarios is
challenging because existing benchmarks and metrics can not measure them
comprehensively. To address this problem, we propose to fine-tune LLMs as
scalable judges (JudgeLM) to evaluate LLMs efficiently and effectively in
open-ended benchmarks. We first propose a comprehensive, large-scale,
high-quality dataset containing task seeds, LLMs-generated answers, and
GPT-4-generated judgments for fine-tuning high-performance judges, as well as a
new benchmark for evaluating the judges. We train JudgeLM at different scales
from 7B, 13B, to 33B parameters, and conduct a systematic analysis of its
capabilities and behaviors. We then analyze the key biases in fine-tuning LLM
as a judge and consider them as position bias, knowledge bias, and format bias.
To address these issues, JudgeLM introduces a bag of techniques including swap
augmentation, reference support, and reference drop, which clearly enhance the
judge's performance. JudgeLM obtains the state-of-the-art judge performance on
both the existing PandaLM benchmark and our proposed new benchmark. Our JudgeLM
is efficient and the JudgeLM-7B only needs 3 minutes to judge 5K samples with 8
A100 GPUs. JudgeLM obtains high agreement with the teacher judge, achieving an
agreement exceeding 90% that even surpasses human-to-human agreement. JudgeLM
also demonstrates extended capabilities in being judges of the single answer,
multimodal models, multiple answers, and multi-turn chat. | [
0.0496226139,
0.0698839873,
0.0089311199,
0.0586849153,
-0.0332095437,
0.0160771124,
0.0124185337,
-0.0177696962,
-0.0207039677,
-0.0695538297,
-0.0614147708,
-0.0242633577,
-0.0142710283,
0.023897456,
0.0244962107,
-0.0671481118,
0.0521888584,
-0.0366367698,
0.0428131782,
0.0094006499,
0.0231270827,
0.0079404311,
-0.0004659397,
0.0423664749,
-0.0142446579,
-0.0522183254,
0.0206337199,
0.0035971117,
-0.0022488432,
0.0068914071,
0.0291663036,
0.0928810462,
0.0136393514,
0.0556726865,
0.0000020771,
-0.0212416705,
0.0240842514,
-0.0143115483,
-0.0093231788,
0.0467356555,
0.0062523922,
0.0143684931,
-0.0051712063,
0.0287207607,
-0.058595214,
-0.0522792116,
0.0325560123,
0.0518117808,
0.0930429474,
0.0941016749,
0.0117735956,
-0.0247358028,
0.0446515568,
-0.0335312597,
0.0094865691,
-0.0464934669,
0.0276534893,
0.0556020401,
0.0053722756,
0.0007556,
-0.0262855086,
0.0340597779,
0.0462609604,
-0.0312757902,
-0.0068689538,
0.01195601,
-0.0476510599,
0.0098935897,
0.0018316731,
0.0788852051,
-0.0159779917,
-0.0245384071,
-0.0283340365,
-0.0144642293,
0.0203368496,
-0.0332995392,
-0.0542810969,
0.0377368294,
0.0118963802,
0.0112387538,
-0.0015643974,
0.0138692055,
0.0265365411,
0.0176247973,
-0.0148247844,
0.0442798324,
0.0288127363,
-0.0288795028,
-0.0117655648,
0.0242266562,
-0.016402863,
-0.0602459051,
-0.0169870853,
0.0013537912,
-0.0656486526,
0.0192908701,
-0.0667898208,
-0.0126712453,
0.031071784,
-0.0090269316,
0.0335704386,
0.0080521703,
-0.0079081245,
0.0612973943,
-0.0091171507,
0.0629510507,
-0.0029394447,
0.0219045151,
-0.0428878404,
-0.0210896544,
-0.0237803869,
0.012238781,
-0.0141875111,
-0.0089822253,
-0.069700323,
-0.017606372,
-0.0457729176,
0.0241910461,
-0.027712144,
0.0118259843,
0.0458157174,
0.0196004286,
0.0004742104,
0.0089753736,
-0.0265381113,
0.0644232929,
-0.0437711999,
0.0131970253,
0.0310512632,
-0.0916949585,
-0.011700795,
0.0231201146,
0.0048812605,
-0.0487778559,
0.0065989164,
0.088644594,
-0.0071251253,
-0.0060263369,
-0.0076482357,
-0.0241116211,
-0.0401266553,
-0.0921706557,
-0.0217957012,
-0.0805639923,
0.0305844732,
0.0166097339,
-0.0069782836,
-0.0334682353,
0.0145197976,
0.0450860858,
-0.0117171267,
0.0492617637,
0.0148078967,
0.0046154303,
0.0040793656,
0.0138236983,
-0.0216927044,
0.0694597214,
0.0231938604,
0.0242187586,
0.0354872718,
-0.0347161628,
0.0187742691,
0.0403237231,
0.0290518329,
0.0174419358,
0.0073223519,
0.0459835529,
0.0291712638,
0.0578408539,
0.0272707827,
0.0862345025,
-0.0433097146,
-0.0492964424,
0.0856445357,
0.0124908648,
0.0034176616,
0.0252665803,
0.0216509104,
0.0019402103,
0.0349255577,
-0.0068143965,
-0.0780608356,
0.0412522666,
-0.0189650524,
0.0090787383,
0.0527844243,
0.0383334383,
-0.0160240158,
-0.0416275449,
-0.012991854,
0.0256539825,
-0.0224109683,
0.0135727543,
0.0311075859,
0.0096867392,
-0.0434864499,
0.0412628725,
0.0399416983,
-0.0338540338,
-0.0223592818,
-0.052081205,
0.0149752758,
0.0307698529,
0.0592410006,
0.0046338155,
-0.0583213642,
-0.0260003265,
0.0122659532,
0.05067458,
0.0712617636,
-0.0028246185,
-0.0156630538,
-0.0461056046,
-0.0259711724,
-0.0307010096,
0.0040880069,
0.0131661585,
0.0578102544,
0.0121283168,
-0.004396935,
-0.0551815033,
-0.0315145105,
0.0253501832,
-0.0071883094,
-0.0418216474,
-0.0121302679,
-0.021312451,
0.0284768697,
-0.0044937315,
-0.0277369041,
0.0311340373,
0.0181462765,
-0.0081761954,
0.0057728551,
-0.033192154,
-0.0694498196,
-0.0307516493,
0.0563198961,
-0.0464492813,
-0.0382171199,
0.0464023463,
-0.0535559952,
-0.0409427658,
0.0287784263,
-0.0140794842,
0.005412471,
-0.0540409759,
-0.0009055528,
0.0138556389,
0.0123596899,
-0.0632107109,
0.0386760756,
0.005566855,
-0.00165372,
0.0057070297,
0.0102016376,
0.0171347447,
-0.0341023393,
-0.0543725193,
-0.0156951565,
-0.0126060406,
0.044202935,
0.0109757967,
0.0164839774,
-0.0583769418,
-0.0431212336,
-0.0862685591,
0.0233888552,
-0.0303561985,
0.0050675659,
0.014892973,
-0.0131013477,
0.0031649196,
-0.0103821158,
-0.0591607317,
-0.0063411761,
0.0324579738,
0.0294024404,
-0.0014719018,
0.0089458544,
-0.0017475503,
-0.0409077555,
-0.0225411728,
0.0034013696,
0.0499569364,
0.0032064447,
0.0181844234,
-0.0121019268,
0.0147967674,
-0.0379052721,
0.0306477137,
-0.0057269614,
-0.0208894834,
0.0244470425,
-0.0264046025,
0.0155130774,
0.0525342748,
0.0140112406,
-0.0088930884,
0.0396720432,
-0.0226151608,
-0.0696464032,
0.0271998066,
0.0134786721,
-0.0368700735,
-0.0342461765,
0.0005296646,
-0.0122887054,
0.0724788755,
0.0043070801,
-0.0186487436,
-0.0556221455,
0.0409057215,
-0.0063931192,
-0.0408910364,
-0.0466143675,
0.0055534188,
-0.0084673492,
-0.0031656129,
-0.0496081635,
-0.0722111315,
0.0633011088,
-0.0375748351,
-0.0063652694,
-0.0384823494,
-0.0011754339,
-0.0431080982,
0.0574291274,
0.0048693544,
0.0047691828,
-0.0250036214,
0.0048182504,
-0.0470480546,
0.0025117991,
0.0044435454,
-0.0406090282,
0.0657426417,
-0.0480763353,
0.0130224051,
-0.0482840315,
-0.0518584512,
-0.0455706529,
-0.0324872658,
-0.0475680195,
0.0156805199,
0.0255523957,
-0.0280637071,
-0.0391505882,
-0.000829985,
0.0032280015,
0.0254457053,
-0.0375756621,
0.0098281289,
-0.0184339918,
0.0202175211,
0.0800270736,
0.0229070764,
0.0201432873,
-0.035256952,
-0.0064443946,
0.0701929778,
0.0245400351,
-0.0062835854,
-0.0354688503,
-0.0196235776,
0.0181703418,
-0.0186303947,
-0.0023831422,
0.011146768,
0.0455039442,
-0.0620225668,
-0.0025672454,
0.1190286279,
0.0046656956,
-0.053721942,
-0.0144878924,
0.0073476769,
0.0572863705,
0.0223292299,
0.033936426,
-0.1223995686,
-0.0472178236,
-0.0117991325,
-0.0116587821,
0.0263333097,
-0.0245814603,
-0.0038377224,
-0.1265337169,
0.0357000679,
0.0021330367,
-0.0422987677,
-0.0299958941,
-0.0116475048,
0.0051423828,
-0.0124275843,
0.0398267359,
0.0160921887,
0.0069428934,
0.0233360678,
0.0227907691,
0.0254351497,
-0.0090481713,
0.0634241551,
-0.0566681437,
0.0761367232,
0.0328905992,
0.017267663,
0.009662847,
-0.0488247052,
0.0208192784,
-0.010159607,
-0.0130187618,
0.000095738,
0.0484874174,
-0.0302936453,
-0.0141589167,
-0.022927545,
0.0185717698,
-0.0297780596,
-0.0016046226,
0.0455539413,
0.1003799364,
-0.0094824247,
-0.0291396193,
-0.0278480463,
-0.0021043678,
0.0072873137,
0.090512149,
0.047239244,
-0.0314227045,
-0.0603913069,
-0.0242760703,
-0.0265234802,
-0.049962502,
-0.0431807116,
-0.0068596923,
0.0370340049,
0.036839027,
-0.0627177805,
-0.0187047552,
0.0307562668,
0.0168834236,
-0.0190115236,
-0.013383925,
-0.0207829308,
-0.0007699054,
-0.03155737,
0.0616702624,
-0.0502104908,
0.0383878089,
-0.0868501142,
-0.0075277947,
0.0019840489,
-0.0122905159,
-0.0144926915,
0.0325281546,
-0.0841206908,
-0.0512747429,
0.0009763233,
0.0437653922,
0.0193269942,
0.0160561986,
-0.0173562728,
-0.0486598387,
0.0204705745,
-0.0076115793,
-0.0245994255,
0.0352657735,
0.0203833356,
-0.0319068395,
-0.0026081665,
0.0392859392,
-0.0230216626,
0.0160891954,
0.0322618261,
0.043888595,
0.0196546763,
-0.0613691695,
0.0017533751,
0.012225939,
0.0358407013,
0.0252027083,
-0.0112213092,
-0.0137226749,
0.0293052886,
-0.0325564779,
-0.0252162032,
-0.0556238368,
-0.0201583318,
0.0233134534,
-0.0076636658,
-0.009193182,
0.0105857542,
0.0199090652,
0.0171892364,
-0.0476264991,
0.0009983772,
0.0548142791,
-0.0542985462,
0.0146536874,
-0.0029760611,
-0.0202331878,
-0.0065617561,
0.0014578018,
0.0401666127,
-0.0002047027,
0.0572269335,
0.0228539407,
-0.0197931975,
0.003761871,
0.0267606191,
-0.0612247847,
-0.0419803821,
-0.0176972542,
0.0304220431,
0.0625431165,
0.0137928855,
0.0549663305,
0.0034538943,
-0.0212636106,
-0.030899778,
0.0113863098,
0.0069646155,
-0.006180021,
0.0472882241,
0.0356589891,
-0.0127402982,
0.0118940054,
0.060362909,
0.0047346931,
0.0519471988,
0.0175196137,
-0.0067600338,
-0.0257281382,
-0.0491928533,
-0.0261758249,
-0.0036116224,
0.0010420891,
-0.0029790031,
-0.045289889,
-0.0656464323,
-0.034191329,
0.0633960217,
-0.0223196726,
-0.0075850165,
0.0216800161,
0.0531575754,
0.0092163077,
-0.022151988,
-0.0282944571,
0.0103590377,
-0.0069026412,
-0.0198293161,
-0.0309621505,
-6.455753996e-33,
-0.0185097326,
-0.0062917639,
0.0498449467,
-0.0216318127,
-0.0205515102,
-0.0037589443,
-0.0186351091,
0.0145532126,
-0.0417185128,
0.0240553953,
-0.0169386584,
0.0058384379,
0.0051357681,
0.0436221138,
0.0153192077,
-0.0273061581,
0.0282898583,
-0.0044856863,
-0.0159678739,
0.0332254954,
-0.0102593079,
-0.0027696069,
0.0542872399,
-0.0417262092,
0.0102271354,
0.0166862588,
-0.0038332231,
0.0187835637,
-0.0756112263,
0.0690066069,
-0.0276342984,
0.0494497009,
0.0146084614,
-0.0377535336,
-0.0397591256,
0.0023150577,
-0.0668712109,
-0.0138347391,
0.048709631,
0.0035356453,
-0.0485707559,
-0.0137776034,
0.0315950923,
0.0126158018,
-0.0198434424,
-0.0396292619,
0.0081779715,
-0.0109486459,
-0.0142700952,
-0.0016833993,
-0.0403975248,
0.0343944281,
0.0045595663,
-0.0160620268,
-0.0165303759,
0.0255567469,
-0.0081859566,
0.0094246306,
-0.0325409546,
0.0142753776,
0.0405818447,
0.0397112183,
0.0618701987,
0.0176943019,
-0.0081039323,
0.072223559,
0.0272799078,
0.0107586104,
-0.004484016,
-0.0381716155,
0.0207427107,
0.077364631,
0.0662259385,
0.0738954172,
0.010686839,
0.0342159495,
-0.0651621148,
0.0140422871,
0.0253892802,
0.0492391475,
0.0360712968,
0.0095138401,
-0.025962662,
-0.0185908116,
-0.0491516292,
0.0130870072,
-0.0532719977,
-0.0126426034,
0.052574072,
0.0015255699,
0.0133594656,
-0.0063140378,
0.0487358384,
-0.0606366321,
0.0117561836,
0.0335031003,
0.0020217928,
0.0131433383,
0.0024407352,
0.0301870536,
-0.0543481335,
0.0081853569,
0.0434543379,
-0.0102414945,
-0.0033317902,
0.0080805207,
0.0311878826,
0.0017633528,
-0.063307941,
0.006701062,
-0.0434187092,
0.0194103252,
-0.0162368715,
0.031814117,
0.0247583911,
-0.0012272306,
-0.0202982388,
0.0331620984,
-0.0035901139,
0.014211772,
-0.0274355263,
-0.0289650299,
0.0202324744,
-0.014442198,
-0.023923656,
0.0061052162,
-0.0457660258,
-0.023751758,
-0.0029756799,
-0.0414047912,
0.0077027152,
0.020965388,
2.654e-7,
0.0525226034,
0.0470884554,
0.0168610793,
0.0153158326,
0.0303394422,
0.027026074,
-0.0133197634,
0.0228768829,
0.0543080121,
0.0041097682,
-0.010247835,
0.0310319439,
0.0533769168,
0.030679211,
-0.0712088048,
-0.0045269686,
-0.0949301049,
0.0038395938,
-0.0392644852,
-0.0226467028,
0.0409497097,
0.1217918396,
0.0001505138,
-0.0106613711,
0.0219510943,
-0.0145020215,
0.0464952067,
-0.0332392789,
-0.0288647637,
0.0055437759,
0.0469779819,
-0.0302368309,
0.0316470303,
0.0295350198,
0.0138760479,
0.0173940808,
-0.0026333446,
0.1018548906,
0.0095925117,
-0.0204417836,
-0.0107598798,
-0.0164549723,
-0.0115179764,
-0.0768342987,
0.0827544332,
-0.0256055556,
-0.0296413489,
-0.0548963547,
-0.0363874622,
-0.03357118,
0.0212384034,
-0.0163898878,
-0.0202330016,
0.0166240223,
0.0178402215,
-0.0076573421,
-0.0261460766,
-0.0689789653,
-0.0564556606,
-0.0026174141,
-0.0413684472,
-0.0531724766,
-0.0473246239,
-0.0355681032,
0.0200453531,
-0.0458386242,
0.0006164641,
2.725957165e-34,
0.0471898653,
-0.0051708375,
0.040334437,
-0.0183225702,
0.0330537446,
0.0100467689,
-0.0289076883,
-0.0004335643,
0.0115182083,
-0.1158007607,
-0.0252266396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17630v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17630v1 | InstOptima: Evolutionary Multi-objective Instruction Optimization via Large Language Model-based Instruction Operators | 2023-10-26T17:48:45 | 2023-10-26T17:48:45 | Heng Yang, Ke Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-based language modeling has received significant attention in
pretrained language models. However, the efficiency of instruction engineering
remains low and hinders the development of instruction studies. Recent studies
have focused on automating instruction generation, but they primarily aim to
improve performance without considering other crucial objectives that impact
instruction quality, such as instruction length and perplexity. Therefore, we
propose a novel approach (i.e., InstOptima) that treats instruction generation
as an evolutionary multi-objective optimization problem. In contrast to text
edition-based methods, our approach utilizes a large language model (LLM) to
simulate instruction operators, including mutation and crossover. Furthermore,
we introduce an objective-guided mechanism for these operators, allowing the
LLM to comprehend the objectives and enhance the quality of the generated
instructions. Experimental results demonstrate improved fine-tuning performance
and the generation of a diverse set of high-quality instructions. | [
0.0122185536,
0.052812662,
-0.0265861265,
0.0051740948,
-0.0152277341,
0.0123839304,
-0.0090716779,
-0.0019604282,
-0.0060622157,
-0.0342709385,
-0.0565928295,
0.0061340434,
-0.0263869911,
-0.0148799289,
0.015251779,
-0.0318689905,
0.0618784763,
-0.06459371,
-0.0621170066,
-0.0131865041,
-0.0098338677,
-0.0089490591,
0.0307912622,
0.0204939377,
0.044598829,
0.0151206898,
-0.0307196099,
0.0114449048,
-0.0218934882,
0.0008500901,
0.0202506185,
0.0526099429,
0.0168676991,
0.0075839534,
0.0000020501,
-0.0356793366,
-0.0081965746,
-0.0064176475,
0.0087882206,
0.0543652475,
0.0851626843,
0.0318004191,
-0.0383568294,
-0.0036768599,
0.0079853665,
0.0196837354,
0.015670646,
-0.0320281535,
0.1008888111,
0.0709904581,
0.0189900137,
-0.0275239032,
-0.0070394855,
-0.0015882506,
0.0425053872,
-0.0271518417,
-0.0011521518,
0.0266415309,
0.0333345234,
0.0467008948,
-0.0195043031,
0.0162600651,
0.0193003304,
-0.0096523641,
-0.0505400933,
-0.002003436,
0.0084848497,
-0.0041715018,
-0.0462289304,
0.0540929139,
-0.0595502369,
-0.0034095156,
0.0004425493,
0.0099521847,
0.0212070774,
-0.0295040701,
-0.0164348502,
0.0310933478,
-0.0036353215,
0.006030967,
0.0265334062,
-0.0286377594,
-0.0241804197,
0.0041489317,
-0.0163782388,
0.0488895662,
0.0495703481,
-0.0296041612,
-0.0182466358,
-0.0168039147,
-0.0327632613,
-0.0375496186,
0.0065947482,
0.0707070902,
-0.0368530899,
0.0192257855,
-0.085708715,
-0.0108328536,
0.0200417172,
-0.0311837438,
0.1104459092,
0.0515734181,
0.0091923028,
0.0107694846,
-0.0345668904,
0.0257410128,
-0.0145570459,
-0.0125202592,
-0.059489198,
0.0490184091,
-0.0522069149,
0.0194645543,
-0.042420011,
0.0382902622,
-0.033775717,
0.0117528243,
-0.0494225323,
0.047777269,
0.0384937488,
-0.0150098773,
0.0118196458,
-0.0315670632,
-0.0232618321,
-0.0036302067,
-0.0202065185,
-0.0088625485,
-0.0234558154,
-0.0165108256,
-0.0337719023,
-0.0164054055,
0.0049457038,
0.0395171046,
-0.0243914463,
0.0019672439,
0.0405661426,
0.065738067,
-0.0490130596,
-0.0169029776,
-0.0422459692,
-0.0224843379,
0.003496649,
-0.0298835132,
-0.0018985611,
-0.0462568179,
0.0233136211,
-0.0396368094,
-0.0279090125,
-0.0176797267,
0.0290660281,
-0.004550728,
-0.0062365206,
-0.0186247658,
-0.0076457476,
0.0488953926,
0.0513420776,
0.0088719567,
0.0436549522,
0.0655152649,
0.0224836823,
-0.0047372538,
-0.0140584903,
-0.0179647803,
-0.0034513497,
0.0612760633,
0.0121530946,
0.0257282592,
0.0393800214,
-0.0158648212,
0.0166754629,
0.0134807872,
0.0263275206,
0.0339581147,
-0.0357920118,
0.0198487043,
0.0146061126,
-0.0074341507,
0.0441225097,
0.0578480847,
0.0954084769,
0.0190964025,
-0.0270841178,
0.0191177335,
-0.0053362437,
0.0203407221,
-0.0144105423,
0.005495993,
0.0282748714,
0.0309213847,
-0.0196176749,
-0.0496091396,
0.0399186984,
-0.0121651758,
-0.0144903343,
-0.00726014,
0.0293922406,
-0.0088287694,
-0.0948748738,
0.0054169819,
0.0552017093,
-0.0247214548,
0.0057027293,
-0.0845992118,
-0.0016955327,
0.0917037278,
0.0530491397,
0.0038209572,
-0.0387605987,
0.0351979323,
0.0401810333,
0.0438513719,
0.0530215465,
-0.0124319857,
-0.015125067,
-0.068035461,
-0.0260225255,
-0.0217433143,
0.0209491383,
0.0711095855,
0.0297415331,
-0.0049308678,
0.0423404165,
0.0108845169,
-0.0732839108,
0.0422508903,
-0.0463801995,
-0.0285898149,
-0.0328346305,
-0.0198518857,
0.015582351,
-0.0139196292,
-0.0322046392,
0.0124136265,
-0.0006103381,
0.0011719825,
0.0006871001,
-0.046911858,
-0.0446355902,
-0.006659979,
0.0373958834,
-0.0310163088,
-0.0149668716,
-0.0445587374,
0.0044653709,
-0.027161967,
0.0335699208,
-0.0447435975,
0.0607415438,
-0.0084570954,
0.0552400686,
-0.0342973769,
-0.0169360265,
-0.0459998772,
0.0429286361,
0.0057254196,
-0.0229662973,
0.0364932865,
0.0155550437,
0.0368751436,
-0.0146418018,
0.0031727725,
-0.0303037744,
0.0045808586,
0.0146887787,
0.0132710086,
0.0869649276,
-0.028485246,
-0.0917307734,
-0.0677542612,
0.0431855284,
-0.0125671923,
0.0347097069,
0.0402007401,
-0.0027383796,
-0.0120054483,
0.0332758985,
-0.0025172797,
0.0210533142,
-0.0222798605,
-0.0191920474,
0.0035364977,
-0.0090691159,
-0.0556876212,
-0.0332863778,
-0.0294543654,
-0.0240646172,
-0.0047617094,
0.0187052786,
0.0748994648,
-0.1065502167,
0.0719314143,
-0.0259295627,
0.0379772969,
0.0088743726,
-0.0454854593,
0.0084427586,
-0.0096724331,
0.0863636062,
0.0798562542,
0.0100701442,
0.0087076966,
0.0464867279,
-0.0215765052,
-0.0418573208,
0.0211882852,
-0.0415156484,
-0.0716825351,
-0.0197374728,
-0.0624582767,
0.0043411092,
0.0617788918,
-0.019918751,
-0.0207479894,
-0.0688592792,
-0.0226986408,
-0.0082099969,
-0.0281632673,
-0.0003847418,
-0.021880487,
-0.0028209256,
-0.0075257891,
-0.0251727067,
-0.0173014887,
0.0899466872,
-0.0082830675,
-0.0001210169,
-0.0774677619,
0.0341648944,
-0.0212530755,
0.0098169642,
-0.0141583802,
0.0262619294,
-0.0114420801,
0.0154652931,
-0.0491100512,
0.0536070243,
0.0043442915,
-0.0120907621,
0.0023537211,
-0.0598540492,
-0.0265257731,
0.0250403434,
-0.0016477351,
-0.0118813198,
0.0062552718,
0.0547343418,
-0.0141810076,
0.0535764843,
-0.0121111311,
-0.0522589684,
0.0187906232,
0.0106514981,
0.0241871327,
-0.0311851557,
-0.0054098242,
-0.0330153368,
-0.0384756699,
0.0578068569,
-0.0305607542,
-0.0128591219,
-0.0587610938,
0.0213892329,
-0.0125225922,
0.0182396434,
-0.0257499255,
0.0214749221,
0.0478611067,
0.0341481715,
-0.0279931929,
-0.0278024152,
0.0517923757,
0.0468533337,
-0.0512085892,
-0.013258867,
0.0697223693,
0.0467642322,
0.0085529312,
0.0121876029,
-0.0127029829,
0.027330976,
-0.0004299115,
0.0783624947,
-0.0303370915,
-0.0138208643,
-0.0329637192,
0.0239649937,
-0.0028080209,
-0.0015459044,
-0.0146379303,
-0.0825451761,
0.0179047305,
0.0215495043,
-0.0383056253,
0.0096322596,
-0.0099578714,
-0.0219954737,
0.033838965,
0.0036435486,
0.0470752604,
-0.003659748,
0.0056743999,
0.0212004241,
0.0405966938,
-0.0362169705,
0.0292983893,
0.0020331026,
0.016539637,
0.0925364718,
-0.0085136704,
0.0213062279,
-0.0381474905,
0.0819509104,
-0.0115958648,
0.0215695687,
-0.0262604561,
0.007611128,
-0.0163339674,
-0.0124408277,
-0.0252711624,
0.0427396633,
-0.0120962914,
0.025568977,
0.0238034073,
0.0386893004,
-0.0007418839,
-0.0399675556,
-0.0106354076,
-0.0308489222,
0.0268491302,
0.0145561928,
0.0068309209,
-0.09550336,
-0.013836558,
-0.0548791885,
-0.0345782489,
-0.103667587,
-0.0367455669,
0.0296755116,
-0.041944135,
-0.0593059026,
-0.0389372669,
-0.0211318247,
0.0083477749,
0.0318601131,
0.0396955609,
-0.0533952378,
0.0361049213,
-0.026977364,
-0.0176240522,
-0.0128712384,
-0.0312275589,
-0.0318398066,
-0.0914538279,
-0.0671013892,
0.0476393513,
-0.0263301469,
0.0065134563,
0.0197536256,
-0.0378201008,
-0.0558271147,
0.0176527146,
0.1009943113,
0.0086790118,
0.0200983752,
-0.01057027,
-0.0284646302,
0.0414778814,
0.0065140054,
0.0189218037,
0.0243595559,
-0.0014338427,
-0.0191720054,
0.0079512233,
-0.0176193565,
-0.0232926477,
0.0618330836,
0.0395250618,
0.0242738165,
-0.0138437888,
-0.0073480103,
0.018820582,
0.031156145,
-0.0284368545,
-0.0565391332,
-0.0146017605,
-0.0151093164,
0.0086991498,
-0.0243702717,
0.0028963122,
-0.0390283614,
0.0010929883,
0.0119747948,
-0.0207481831,
0.0461158194,
-0.0267884079,
-0.0112486919,
0.0248695593,
-0.0067878854,
0.0604132488,
-0.0477473028,
0.0416666269,
0.0415518247,
-0.0010229665,
0.0170792397,
0.0492612757,
-0.0032827239,
0.036588598,
-0.013503368,
0.0533681996,
0.0058200122,
0.0173875168,
-0.0215975381,
0.0425073951,
0.0135168405,
0.0115563385,
-0.0681649745,
0.0171792693,
0.0507436432,
0.0293844659,
0.0332859717,
-0.0348017924,
-0.0007481993,
-0.0055315369,
0.0143188732,
-0.0203166865,
-0.0553482361,
-0.0062076831,
0.0275382623,
0.0192773584,
-0.052865535,
0.0504809022,
-0.0027378828,
0.0514589511,
-0.0057935673,
0.0356485881,
-0.0526469871,
-0.0227183625,
0.0090897372,
-0.0085231699,
-0.0128777279,
0.0257876776,
-0.0134443622,
-0.0114887077,
-0.0590457767,
0.0678149834,
0.0208346881,
0.0267686024,
0.0607456677,
0.0492478311,
-0.0622992925,
-0.006811365,
-0.0222472809,
-0.0173073187,
-0.0173149295,
-0.0455315262,
0.0046223043,
-5.932907333e-33,
-0.0497939773,
-0.0050132521,
0.0436049029,
0.0040069316,
-0.0142419646,
-0.0266687311,
-0.0431086309,
0.0308990572,
-0.0052013579,
-0.0454680473,
0.0209718794,
-0.0248412322,
-0.0152265318,
-0.0153346453,
0.017764695,
0.0273582246,
-0.0000483506,
-0.0213202164,
-0.0562381074,
0.0202629212,
-0.0280405805,
-0.0129903574,
0.0021235556,
-0.012515652,
-0.0315423943,
0.0002643023,
-0.0006972844,
-0.0063602431,
-0.0079460731,
0.0602951385,
-0.0021680505,
0.0215111617,
-0.0210008789,
-0.0384312235,
-0.0310719479,
-0.0221407712,
0.0126811313,
-0.0665273443,
0.0092759393,
-0.0047344798,
0.0006387013,
-0.0824837238,
0.0236070808,
0.0160434935,
-0.0670179203,
0.0155451996,
0.0247918982,
0.0183284562,
0.0188693926,
0.0249186009,
-0.0852318928,
0.0055220039,
-0.0110522928,
-0.0577581935,
-0.0001850165,
-0.0290947296,
0.006041314,
-0.0399510972,
0.0584973246,
0.0786052123,
0.051799234,
0.0553443097,
0.0734094232,
0.0119174682,
0.027927218,
-0.0220096614,
0.0143939462,
0.0499616899,
0.010314187,
-0.012084187,
0.0792860761,
0.0039905608,
0.0035188731,
-0.0154337995,
-0.0269072354,
-0.0120817944,
-0.0425334945,
0.0223463271,
-0.0017091149,
-0.0132311955,
0.0307335407,
0.0099577317,
-0.0006120258,
-0.0091472166,
-0.0355813764,
0.0207607988,
-0.0286306646,
-0.0442315936,
0.0318560116,
-0.0057611344,
-0.03834337,
-0.0233616624,
0.0377724431,
0.0043424792,
-0.0132316947,
-0.0368120559,
-0.064190492,
0.0276951026,
-0.0303803496,
0.0434838869,
-0.0107648578,
-0.1079187915,
0.0418325588,
-0.0319501683,
0.0213869754,
0.0125222038,
-0.0173741896,
0.0131786587,
-0.0517979488,
0.0180739965,
-0.0298633017,
-0.000699684,
0.0354754329,
-0.0295414422,
-0.0091812639,
0.0087477732,
0.0066254842,
0.0332024619,
0.0503054857,
-0.049987819,
-0.0609593801,
-0.0119026182,
0.036231745,
0.0475649349,
-0.0409043394,
0.0383079201,
-0.032858178,
-0.0087624751,
-0.0546699911,
-0.0293421708,
-0.0599085167,
0.0290875323,
2.741e-7,
0.0443357378,
0.0792632103,
0.004222631,
0.0493193865,
0.0131560275,
0.0000605723,
0.0106344512,
-0.0236397758,
0.0208916292,
0.000359388,
0.0277545452,
0.0534668453,
-0.0024209032,
-0.0082881693,
-0.0182964634,
0.0194388144,
0.0268269777,
0.0445166752,
-0.0759271532,
0.021927597,
0.0528316982,
0.0395961292,
-0.0220394284,
0.0240485501,
-0.0074636186,
0.0071759019,
0.0230908357,
0.010326812,
0.0120901177,
0.0862407684,
-0.0866674632,
-0.0018907801,
-0.0526419654,
-0.0008256909,
-0.0154933725,
-0.002532942,
-0.0140438424,
0.0939432234,
-0.0259028338,
0.0019660247,
0.0987026542,
0.0300438106,
-0.0233711321,
-0.0388824604,
0.0382253081,
-0.0200001821,
0.0081964713,
-0.0150373653,
-0.0088067874,
-0.0051204842,
-0.0501722321,
-0.0818326324,
-0.0000153425,
0.0355823748,
0.0064950744,
0.0106295692,
0.0185186695,
-0.0119015398,
0.0087814583,
0.0214707069,
-0.0279549044,
-0.0928061232,
-0.072107479,
0.0405989662,
0.0157614369,
-0.0215624515,
0.0001997447,
2.529044183e-34,
0.0186832268,
-0.0291730668,
0.0573381595,
0.016298214,
0.0254839677,
0.0147525147,
-0.0407798141,
0.0248621255,
0.0490531214,
-0.0480055399,
-0.0523728952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17623v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17623v2 | Proving Test Set Contamination in Black Box Language Models | 2023-10-26T17:43:13 | 2023-11-24T01:45:16 | Yonatan Oren, Nicole Meister, Niladri Chatterji, Faisal Ladhak, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models are trained on vast amounts of internet data, prompting
concerns and speculation that they have memorized public benchmarks. Going from
speculation to proof of contamination is challenging, as the pretraining data
used by proprietary models are often not publicly accessible. We show that it
is possible to provide provable guarantees of test set contamination in
language models without access to pretraining data or model weights. Our
approach leverages the fact that when there is no data contamination, all
orderings of an exchangeable benchmark should be equally likely. In contrast,
the tendency for language models to memorize example order means that a
contaminated language model will find certain canonical orderings to be much
more likely than others. Our test flags potential contamination whenever the
likelihood of a canonically ordered benchmark dataset is significantly higher
than the likelihood after shuffling the examples. We demonstrate that our
procedure is sensitive enough to reliably prove test set contamination in
challenging situations, including models as small as 1.4 billion parameters, on
small test sets of only 1000 examples, and datasets that appear only a few
times in the pretraining corpus. Using our test, we audit five popular publicly
accessible language models for test set contamination and find little evidence
for pervasive contamination. | [
0.0127020851,
0.1254893988,
-0.0342370458,
0.0392164215,
-0.0191617291,
0.0260135103,
0.0071309623,
0.0287591647,
-0.0072390093,
-0.0431990027,
-0.0000556737,
-0.0351738594,
0.0247649103,
0.0248949174,
0.0423622988,
0.0119706094,
0.0455597229,
-0.0014557386,
-0.0506746694,
-0.02820733,
-0.016356362,
-0.0194390044,
0.0224419199,
0.0042884182,
0.0047889953,
-0.0220420845,
-0.0065706777,
-0.00611242,
0.0076574408,
-0.0251399074,
0.0071643176,
0.088425234,
-0.0136265019,
0.0689544976,
0.0000018193,
-0.0246781223,
-0.0438783877,
0.0131252035,
-0.0371897817,
0.0427495539,
-0.008037338,
0.0232095756,
-0.0208208356,
0.0391678549,
-0.0163181089,
-0.0063695726,
0.0397208259,
0.011328646,
0.0475183614,
0.0704216957,
0.0068602669,
0.041236572,
0.0154101932,
-0.0328083411,
0.0050976039,
0.0204670019,
0.0385422781,
-0.0119595909,
-0.0114998575,
0.0025391174,
-0.0158147085,
0.0224279668,
0.0257404614,
0.0466062129,
-0.0577435568,
0.0379190221,
-0.0600848347,
-0.0186933652,
0.0225418452,
0.0710478798,
-0.0005684427,
-0.0400785469,
0.0086982865,
-0.0070188534,
0.0123937801,
0.0335324965,
0.0042455751,
0.0431955457,
0.0122298561,
0.0191468559,
-0.0045863921,
-0.0314738415,
0.0534016304,
-0.008569872,
-0.0375174694,
0.0988969132,
0.0318210274,
-0.0422179289,
-0.0076399045,
0.015771145,
-0.00806979,
-0.0444549434,
-0.0265080612,
-0.0560359359,
0.0164931603,
0.0426811315,
-0.0186990108,
-0.0387319028,
0.0363975801,
-0.021549996,
0.0566360876,
-0.0050644232,
-0.0436984785,
-0.0060789678,
-0.0107362969,
0.0219573956,
-0.0117658051,
0.0487512797,
-0.0248351935,
0.0478841774,
0.0152985491,
-0.0091002183,
0.0044796686,
-0.0010620451,
0.008458524,
0.0215627886,
-0.030000994,
0.0127479564,
-0.0457213074,
0.0043908758,
-0.0220128987,
0.0005411545,
-0.0145588303,
-0.001632021,
0.0032008693,
-0.0452410243,
-0.0092395358,
0.0327066854,
-0.0028702079,
-0.0843238831,
-0.0263495427,
-0.009337428,
-0.0069095469,
-0.0210828446,
0.0020116565,
0.0459594801,
0.045956187,
-0.0283231996,
0.0088526281,
-0.0272359811,
-0.0283767544,
-0.007484016,
0.0035526908,
-0.034186352,
-0.0012263,
0.0229798984,
0.0128765889,
-0.038680397,
-0.020933466,
0.0082981996,
-0.0450032242,
0.0358130783,
0.0123739736,
0.0023761126,
-0.03123766,
-0.000753001,
-0.0115960436,
0.0579540431,
0.0145520717,
0.0053390656,
0.0473114662,
-0.0251592416,
0.0109077953,
0.0552754551,
0.039689865,
0.0551414303,
-0.0477168821,
0.0019700353,
0.0283349641,
0.0061811777,
-0.0016096933,
0.0311273076,
-0.0341092348,
-0.0574244708,
0.0444206931,
0.0008648545,
-0.0289415643,
-0.045527298,
-0.0089453142,
-0.0319876783,
0.0096824151,
0.049745243,
-0.0543816611,
-0.0656179413,
-0.0187713839,
-0.0170200653,
0.0198456068,
0.0289801899,
-0.0104483776,
-0.0265678447,
-0.0302596502,
-0.0338901877,
0.0104126874,
0.0039960621,
0.0509392209,
0.0145901022,
-0.0202651396,
0.0802194774,
0.0339657478,
-0.0583196916,
-0.0143609531,
-0.0404046476,
0.0315317623,
0.0340228975,
0.0240309853,
-0.0250039492,
0.0076060737,
0.0015616675,
0.039386455,
0.0007236488,
0.0135532683,
-0.0233797282,
0.0242247637,
-0.007883478,
-0.0273274016,
0.016853245,
0.0441281125,
0.0504349768,
0.0206513163,
-0.0004232539,
0.0215564016,
-0.033531256,
-0.0853540897,
0.0352162383,
-0.0371045619,
-0.015809061,
0.0066518839,
0.0034205338,
0.0395191908,
-0.0142828571,
-0.0540188365,
0.0093251094,
0.0502324216,
0.0101428283,
0.008990488,
-0.0023366252,
-0.004055074,
0.016068399,
0.0271657221,
-0.0259367451,
-0.0154628055,
0.0985176563,
-0.0385539792,
-0.0322742946,
-0.0065559871,
0.0408806056,
0.0527163595,
-0.0033866703,
0.0337634645,
-0.018334806,
0.0297000092,
-0.0068965536,
0.0368724689,
-0.0130093899,
0.0525936149,
-0.0161083825,
0.0140885422,
0.0175033957,
-0.0294048488,
-0.0481033288,
0.0408745892,
-0.0407861918,
0.0305443183,
0.0165246855,
-0.0020338914,
-0.036584124,
0.0018332521,
-0.0520767532,
-0.0233012103,
-0.0103165908,
0.0285180621,
0.0174426585,
-0.02133606,
-0.0161135178,
-0.0268364605,
-0.0064034318,
-0.0235500727,
0.0163424313,
0.0595702678,
0.0066195615,
-0.0169773493,
0.0032689481,
-0.0145709962,
-0.0305260811,
-0.0272539556,
0.088337414,
-0.0466749817,
0.0524966344,
-0.0632029176,
0.0553637072,
-0.0356222354,
0.0140758455,
-0.0007571174,
-0.0462334193,
0.0464438684,
-0.0041935579,
-0.0611914247,
0.082720682,
0.0233829822,
0.0072159986,
0.067526713,
0.0235099345,
-0.0625031888,
-0.0468363985,
0.0168007631,
-0.0263372306,
0.0014904633,
-0.0557473041,
-0.0429392494,
0.0560141392,
-0.0105719892,
-0.0375168137,
-0.0248672906,
0.0506182089,
-0.0572855026,
-0.0006647934,
-0.0197806004,
-0.0247992929,
-0.0575036667,
0.0480011813,
-0.0193245709,
-0.051264517,
0.0150654074,
-0.0422097705,
0.0286229979,
-0.0215408877,
0.0176526625,
-0.0005496835,
0.0228671655,
0.0244357772,
0.0129484236,
0.0200319029,
-0.0151526937,
-0.0634244829,
0.0128494361,
0.0557620525,
-0.0410817489,
0.0083198473,
-0.0259302892,
0.0166717116,
-0.0014234097,
-0.0664415061,
-0.0537291989,
-0.0457360186,
0.0082204398,
-0.0255841203,
0.0027265679,
-0.0134821041,
0.0124460962,
-0.0033865122,
-0.0118795754,
0.0458293185,
-0.0097311493,
0.0177217722,
-0.0047503132,
0.0342799313,
0.0294628572,
-0.0401502773,
0.0520326532,
-0.02989069,
-0.0335336998,
0.0364488997,
0.0825652406,
0.0429356918,
-0.0312770568,
-0.0212399196,
0.0095723905,
-0.0150487022,
-0.0053576641,
0.0203135703,
-0.0130285081,
-0.0266863741,
0.0021741348,
0.0904614851,
0.0255909916,
0.0029842905,
0.0304056443,
0.0430026054,
0.0384994671,
0.0228582527,
-0.0079870969,
-0.1237442568,
0.0254193861,
0.0207108967,
0.0055339988,
-0.0237956326,
-0.042952545,
-0.0098412344,
-0.1382216811,
-0.0102709224,
0.026496347,
-0.0532902516,
0.0380778722,
-0.0380778909,
-0.0104846731,
-0.0411417969,
0.0684660822,
0.0047493549,
0.0008022326,
0.0264837667,
0.017759677,
0.0171623938,
-0.0877811238,
0.0391523466,
-0.0257057808,
0.0387422666,
0.012541825,
-0.004698101,
-0.0718294233,
0.0194433928,
0.0338728987,
-0.0123908985,
-0.0276483726,
0.0215054099,
0.0632870868,
0.0105900597,
-0.0327598304,
0.0422429778,
-0.0027851907,
-0.0502172112,
0.016225988,
-0.0167857669,
0.0077049891,
-0.0037055961,
-0.0654676259,
0.0196322519,
-0.0507424287,
0.0057054223,
0.0648773238,
-0.004869502,
-0.0199373085,
0.0214670412,
-0.0255161971,
0.0478413515,
0.0149369137,
0.0007052197,
0.0387081355,
0.0104160123,
-0.0440937057,
-0.0887753293,
-0.0427943431,
-0.0149739869,
0.0711534917,
0.0281259771,
0.000827633,
-0.0081188353,
-0.0285051428,
-0.0164525267,
0.0757145286,
-0.0107176937,
-0.0041300897,
-0.073273547,
-0.0054624188,
0.0180053189,
0.0315174125,
-0.046416264,
0.0106891431,
-0.0596122891,
-0.1039833501,
0.0464431606,
0.0515872501,
0.0252879877,
0.0288489144,
-0.0053118728,
-0.0526138693,
0.0225591287,
0.0147490213,
-0.0333148651,
0.0066531505,
0.056051217,
-0.101827234,
-0.0039693671,
0.0233824402,
-0.0665227994,
0.0233761333,
0.0068186694,
-0.0184302684,
-0.0273332745,
0.0018611148,
0.0239914414,
0.0377104878,
0.0610544682,
-0.0282764938,
-0.0271355137,
-0.0382374637,
0.0421762429,
-0.0379389562,
-0.0243231431,
-0.0073444438,
0.0370670781,
0.0311813802,
0.0279664882,
-0.0310351215,
-0.0187011939,
-0.0079850517,
0.0569300875,
-0.0240992475,
-0.0165549871,
0.0294506978,
0.0197224822,
0.0759632662,
0.0096349679,
0.0133290477,
0.0443082899,
-0.0070320088,
0.0652896389,
-0.0138771553,
0.0072715944,
0.014772119,
0.0122074243,
0.0009853627,
0.0505546443,
-0.0664016083,
-0.0386736467,
-0.0341134183,
-0.017446693,
0.0185631402,
-0.0419430956,
0.0494868793,
-0.0175720602,
0.0032465626,
-0.024634853,
-0.0325239636,
-0.0105828699,
-0.0149235781,
-0.0093177948,
0.0120140929,
-0.0358730257,
0.077364862,
0.0708793178,
0.0462819859,
0.0513571128,
-0.0297389757,
0.0046835635,
-0.0061808294,
0.0134156961,
0.0197523944,
0.0029648265,
-0.023813922,
-0.0474475622,
-0.0417658575,
-0.1112003028,
0.0078784944,
0.0082336254,
-0.0059769,
0.0111002261,
-0.0303918924,
0.0837187245,
-0.0138694271,
0.0466264151,
-0.0401313119,
-0.041590102,
0.0074638054,
-0.0312430505,
-0.010386155,
-6.352716039e-33,
0.0257356912,
-0.0150853703,
-0.0448475741,
-0.0366147272,
0.0663173869,
0.0384391733,
0.0150562515,
0.0001403766,
-0.035369534,
-0.0030149422,
-0.0389321335,
0.027589798,
0.0158926342,
-0.0051893131,
0.0134571483,
0.0010732862,
0.0219779462,
-0.018350793,
-0.0597606562,
-0.0000521688,
0.0367110111,
0.021323951,
0.0737844482,
-0.0467764959,
0.023829855,
-0.0286519378,
-0.0124867177,
0.0094699757,
-0.0715527609,
0.0618530065,
0.0210761055,
0.0358601883,
0.0203363802,
-0.0186806917,
-0.002655352,
-0.0330899321,
-0.0314210728,
-0.020781314,
0.002050708,
-0.0039257179,
-0.0068451995,
-0.0077036885,
0.0724865273,
-0.02552725,
-0.0209784023,
0.0246157814,
0.0069710743,
-0.0019893416,
-0.0411696285,
0.0149594704,
0.0123696579,
0.0240664482,
-0.006918157,
0.0238291919,
0.02874141,
0.0433274359,
0.0186065454,
-0.0139872823,
-0.0164530277,
0.0331375226,
0.0440436229,
0.0151451919,
0.0519680791,
0.0132193137,
-0.0052973023,
0.093086116,
0.0323317237,
0.0349628739,
0.105042547,
-0.0247326586,
0.0538492203,
0.0251486972,
-0.0017217749,
0.04938538,
0.0366539247,
-0.0164904911,
-0.0374113061,
0.0184554234,
0.012255867,
-0.0299632978,
0.0242225621,
-0.0218971819,
-0.0689704865,
-0.0310506988,
-0.0612523369,
-0.053265132,
-0.0375136212,
-0.0165260416,
0.0435176976,
0.0110781603,
-0.0424418822,
-0.023575915,
0.0109484224,
-0.0427974202,
-0.0792603046,
0.0333758332,
-0.0336863101,
-0.0014211457,
-0.0073814569,
0.0649008974,
-0.0354403853,
-0.0261590462,
0.010488919,
0.0013559753,
0.029852191,
0.0172796082,
0.0444913954,
0.0023413694,
-0.0560270585,
0.0148211336,
-0.0256192703,
0.0035418512,
0.0115063451,
-0.0064595346,
0.0487636589,
0.0140779214,
0.0249859933,
0.0122184539,
0.0701594204,
-0.0013442774,
-0.0540688224,
0.0100514609,
-0.0103221638,
-0.0082858689,
0.0141211869,
-0.0520529374,
0.0066756532,
0.0692299381,
0.1084311679,
-0.0361395366,
0.0013870083,
-0.0093558831,
2.57e-7,
0.0428776406,
0.0440938175,
-0.0151061481,
0.0024508345,
0.0243164245,
0.0188857447,
-0.0609742142,
0.0327509083,
-0.007398278,
-0.0321166143,
0.0033865918,
-0.0302430131,
0.0424254127,
0.0149056269,
-0.0674254149,
-0.024047697,
-0.0784217864,
-0.0009074715,
-0.0635950938,
-0.0279807802,
-0.0158688445,
0.0908766463,
-0.0027246913,
-0.0069747907,
-0.0225568898,
-0.052837044,
0.0234416425,
-0.0483245924,
-0.010151499,
0.0008530307,
0.0176381245,
0.0135343596,
0.0249270555,
0.0151322205,
-0.0283222403,
0.0059530851,
-0.0098422496,
0.0209956393,
-0.024294503,
-0.0126330899,
-0.0352208093,
-0.0431920253,
-0.0276123006,
-0.0428204425,
0.0729106367,
-0.0015602739,
-0.0107140988,
-0.0726589635,
-0.0278222896,
-0.0603533052,
0.0533406846,
-0.0019865558,
0.0094356192,
0.0335931592,
-0.0299925301,
-0.0080348393,
-0.0087211924,
-0.0460935496,
-0.0151995113,
0.0155083556,
-0.0210718066,
-0.0795542374,
-0.0010427637,
-0.0276572108,
-0.0010453286,
-0.0525625013,
0.0262409635,
2.693080517e-34,
0.0450560451,
-0.0314813629,
0.0220900364,
0.0094407192,
0.0638171583,
-0.047059387,
0.0112302992,
0.0112156384,
-0.0251223072,
-0.0582158454,
0.0031465832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17611v1 | Uncovering Meanings of Embeddings via Partial Orthogonality | 2023-10-26T17:34:32 | 2023-10-26T17:34:32 | Yibo Jiang, Bryon Aragam, Victor Veitch | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Machine learning tools often rely on embedding text as vectors of real
numbers. In this paper, we study how the semantic structure of language is
encoded in the algebraic structure of such embeddings. Specifically, we look at
a notion of ``semantic independence'' capturing the idea that, e.g.,
``eggplant'' and ``tomato'' are independent given ``vegetable''. Although such
examples are intuitive, it is difficult to formalize such a notion of semantic
independence. The key observation here is that any sensible formalization
should obey a set of so-called independence axioms, and thus any algebraic
encoding of this structure should also obey these axioms. This leads us
naturally to use partial orthogonality as the relevant algebraic structure. We
develop theory and methods that allow us to demonstrate that partial
orthogonality does indeed capture semantic independence. Complementary to this,
we also introduce the concept of independence preserving embeddings where
embeddings preserve the conditional independence structures of a distribution,
and we prove the existence of such embeddings and approximations to them. | [
-0.0190368872,
0.1019690558,
0.0064444719,
0.0670939088,
-0.0309253298,
0.0256431121,
-0.0359787643,
0.0205708537,
-0.0129863843,
-0.0474466123,
0.025947256,
-0.0047610723,
-0.021235561,
-0.0443850681,
-0.0074295835,
-0.0481270254,
0.0125288768,
0.0217898656,
-0.0026699938,
-0.0208394397,
-0.0153162461,
-0.0649680197,
-0.0321294814,
-0.0043265778,
-0.0525269769,
-0.0117752366,
0.0271583591,
-0.0781469494,
-0.0306314938,
0.0117875226,
-0.0706629828,
0.0018697969,
-0.0047971141,
0.0332295746,
0.0000016526,
-0.0010160464,
-0.0413330942,
0.0057439902,
0.0067441901,
-0.0119107217,
-0.0298163574,
-0.0393284,
-0.00413134,
-0.0497750454,
-0.0443594269,
-0.0599893369,
0.0712151304,
0.0375581346,
-0.0252044182,
0.0325599499,
-0.0338176414,
-0.0875585303,
0.0213679839,
0.0013441474,
0.0644426495,
-0.0041892934,
0.0118837878,
-0.0058835037,
-0.0387233794,
0.0310295075,
-0.0475263074,
0.0228040628,
0.0503737964,
0.0432271808,
0.0032668775,
0.0603799596,
-0.0051094419,
-0.0080489051,
0.0217268877,
0.0641360581,
-0.0177658703,
-0.0119694863,
-0.0184192508,
0.0075431978,
-0.008148673,
0.0342155024,
-0.0426912904,
0.0423766151,
0.0233389959,
0.0624098852,
0.0139067955,
0.0419089347,
0.0152838752,
-0.0053122556,
-0.0716824383,
0.0977960378,
0.029567346,
-0.0380282775,
-0.0154159758,
0.0109961536,
-0.0134612564,
0.043780569,
-0.021434458,
-0.0151994182,
0.0503635742,
0.0197563749,
0.0096571576,
-0.0128964093,
-0.0151653681,
-0.0817731842,
0.0475818291,
0.0088858064,
-0.0025978433,
0.0229052659,
-0.0186794158,
0.0311233606,
-0.0351225734,
0.0585431121,
-0.0177928824,
0.0741844252,
-0.0321878344,
-0.0149168829,
-0.0140298009,
0.070553042,
-0.0282178223,
-0.0076623098,
-0.0087149609,
0.0438345969,
-0.0448592119,
0.0409907773,
-0.0654888973,
-0.0179258417,
-0.0028673648,
0.0351122953,
0.000022376,
-0.0236098189,
-0.0137916123,
0.0191856865,
-0.0550183207,
-0.0423623025,
-0.0114698578,
0.0340827964,
0.0223405305,
0.0019918499,
-0.0432804748,
0.0552113168,
0.0328488015,
-0.0069430475,
0.0435241573,
-0.0210538991,
0.0070808032,
-0.0303941276,
0.0056518824,
-0.0427569114,
-0.0062764017,
0.011425877,
0.0118409758,
-0.1088904217,
0.0053674891,
-0.0211105943,
-0.0327067748,
0.0832692906,
0.0369074456,
-0.0142172696,
-0.0066646459,
0.0128832245,
0.0404828973,
0.0459636226,
0.0098480899,
-0.01093012,
0.0465609469,
-0.0201065131,
0.0147100259,
-0.0035439353,
-0.0051263142,
-0.0552236103,
-0.0675363019,
-0.0481538139,
0.0788779184,
0.0142027056,
-0.0437796786,
0.06673792,
-0.0196768902,
-0.0438612588,
0.0254656058,
0.0510177575,
-0.0096605355,
0.0394983292,
0.0695082694,
0.0040523838,
0.0237979665,
0.1038926318,
-0.027401749,
-0.0097977892,
-0.0216953382,
0.0160211828,
-0.0219917484,
-0.0204843301,
-0.0063353186,
-0.0691060647,
-0.0234229192,
-0.0416865759,
-0.003202385,
-0.0528289862,
0.0813600197,
-0.0280276425,
0.0105040465,
-0.0029564875,
0.0159424692,
-0.063387163,
0.0162034631,
0.0322145335,
0.0504903831,
-0.0020387252,
-0.0146074537,
-0.0773149133,
0.0548780225,
0.0351616181,
-0.0154991336,
0.0270642024,
-0.0019901677,
-0.0441827551,
0.0228069481,
-0.0129877543,
-0.0018719824,
0.0194629412,
0.0510364473,
0.014388117,
-0.0328121521,
-0.0156823061,
-0.0045229099,
-0.0152206523,
-0.0085811783,
0.0369038358,
0.0066894707,
-0.0431345887,
0.0372110717,
0.0307867974,
0.0196248833,
0.0342945717,
-0.0547025092,
0.0556516163,
0.0657185987,
-0.048369389,
-0.0512424409,
0.0101481033,
0.0076895389,
-0.0197558757,
0.0161213726,
-0.0509814285,
0.045586478,
-0.0055618854,
-0.0165268164,
-0.0103240116,
0.0915272161,
-0.016202474,
0.0175470784,
-0.0210960004,
0.0027851325,
-0.0002902267,
0.0278683547,
-0.0237690955,
0.0547286831,
-0.0047446252,
0.0659937412,
-0.0079409787,
-0.0150376121,
0.0310967769,
-0.0033846714,
0.0223910809,
0.0360906087,
0.0106489845,
0.069554545,
0.0004904211,
0.0170698799,
0.016005395,
-0.0617311373,
-0.0138185667,
-0.0471038111,
-0.0190947391,
0.0256681144,
0.0218385607,
-0.0084900139,
0.0556937642,
-0.0071945754,
-0.0121781034,
0.0044965143,
-0.0370905921,
-0.0115652606,
-0.0002802224,
-0.0235829726,
-0.0213088151,
0.0502045602,
-0.0300550051,
-0.0046927109,
0.067466341,
-0.0296388026,
0.0222710446,
0.0091960626,
-0.0389570594,
-0.0500743948,
0.0446717404,
-0.0401736982,
0.020441927,
-0.0297367536,
-0.0232680663,
-0.0097376946,
0.0281299669,
-0.0409303568,
0.0437611304,
0.0609972067,
0.0109856613,
0.0041305176,
-0.0346846133,
-0.0577802695,
0.0379830189,
-0.0047666947,
0.0058413162,
-0.0352579765,
0.0495897904,
0.0078027658,
-0.0387990177,
-0.0414431766,
0.0370902084,
-0.055537492,
-0.0229741503,
-0.0391763933,
0.0087561058,
-0.024862146,
0.0374581404,
-0.0232638046,
-0.0363028497,
0.0438920595,
-0.0027072928,
0.0169744696,
-0.0525538363,
-0.0368436351,
-0.0646214634,
0.0568065532,
-0.0050003319,
0.0049056355,
0.0041741738,
0.0192513727,
-0.0183805525,
-0.0005027744,
0.0034977125,
-0.0340945907,
0.0504303612,
-0.0232654307,
0.0242989343,
0.0166711565,
-0.0244840123,
-0.0413653031,
-0.0830934048,
0.028884707,
0.0181934386,
-0.0150575805,
-0.0179792419,
0.0072205071,
0.0368757397,
-0.0075406777,
0.0093357442,
0.0123253539,
0.0146049215,
-0.0309319608,
0.0727015585,
-0.0142221767,
-0.0242221914,
-0.0263499562,
0.0376472771,
0.017915979,
0.0178049058,
0.0093538119,
0.0313225351,
0.0129733467,
0.0464238822,
-0.0041373242,
0.0079756109,
-0.0545335263,
-0.0217068549,
-0.062391188,
0.0337665379,
-0.0308347344,
0.052515503,
0.0296423137,
-0.0166818071,
0.0593133569,
0.004373394,
0.0012914625,
0.0301617924,
0.004568228,
-0.0590528138,
0.0205557756,
-0.050008744,
-0.0490472354,
-0.0063061137,
-0.0348782763,
0.0054952009,
-0.0655363947,
-0.021719465,
0.0107201757,
-0.0828464627,
-0.0727077052,
0.009460398,
0.0097402316,
0.0009605354,
-0.0150505528,
-0.0271397214,
-0.0215674099,
0.0052472865,
0.0436218679,
-0.0214542467,
-0.0568644702,
-0.0644025803,
-0.0331545211,
-0.0315376259,
0.0170506649,
0.0377632268,
-0.0562751777,
-0.0589396693,
-0.0678416789,
-0.0342052691,
-0.0334384814,
-0.0095151514,
0.0326747112,
0.0239522234,
-0.0204789042,
0.0063960389,
-0.024756765,
0.0075046434,
-0.0256798025,
0.0198974907,
0.1137618944,
-0.0376460887,
-0.0336187631,
0.0108311847,
-0.028838668,
0.0119430171,
0.02718761,
0.013903033,
-0.0149509795,
-0.0144562516,
-0.0276487768,
0.0012340448,
0.041848857,
-0.0184886716,
-0.0115418006,
-0.016258236,
-0.0731766,
-0.0874922425,
0.0386391878,
0.0111883236,
0.0296206586,
0.0214263946,
0.0317019299,
-0.0078927521,
-0.0427357629,
-0.0633260459,
-0.0196199641,
0.0148740094,
0.0093760649,
0.0637977347,
0.0051728385,
0.0603103042,
-0.0136709167,
-0.0252131447,
-0.0119615942,
0.0507317111,
-0.0581561886,
0.0376209132,
0.0170300268,
0.0215947758,
-0.0116175348,
-0.0151123367,
-0.0533455424,
0.0320435725,
0.0365647525,
-0.001801722,
0.0534492359,
0.0603971332,
-0.0314764977,
0.0053947121,
0.0652272701,
-0.0187843032,
0.0341326743,
-0.0007867975,
0.0218203906,
-0.0585887283,
0.0199415721,
0.0398044959,
-0.0086159501,
-0.0000385826,
0.0484053828,
-0.0044345991,
-0.017839957,
0.0081999563,
-0.0454767421,
-0.0427538827,
-0.0401471965,
0.0125149051,
0.0289383903,
0.0380759761,
-0.0207094084,
0.0020466037,
0.0305376481,
0.0252442844,
0.0142126074,
0.0002156847,
-0.0018769865,
-0.009570498,
-0.0077495496,
0.0418737046,
0.027640922,
0.0261122547,
-0.0262698308,
-0.0061783204,
-0.0193861816,
-0.0150442449,
0.0304431785,
0.0050460538,
-0.0691330582,
-0.0491739884,
-0.0518120378,
0.0030499047,
0.026886981,
0.0457727052,
0.0203201864,
-0.019262366,
0.0261220038,
-0.0436084718,
-0.0130773019,
-0.0053608748,
0.0098833283,
0.0385722965,
0.0131678553,
0.047947295,
0.013000221,
0.0019023446,
0.0082263844,
0.0534820557,
-0.010214461,
0.0077048577,
-0.043191608,
-0.0066941506,
-0.0589480661,
0.0251993593,
0.0532585233,
0.0575059019,
-0.0224154554,
0.0493944176,
-0.0981707126,
-0.0450008027,
0.0013042676,
0.0156574156,
0.0496083125,
-0.0198050495,
-0.0016578157,
0.0515108407,
0.0412156433,
0.0277649555,
-0.0353147164,
0.0152925001,
-0.0639062226,
-0.0638964176,
0.0026491592,
-5.495634822e-33,
-0.0151360119,
-0.026920313,
-0.0292025059,
0.0315796994,
0.0012502688,
0.0531315245,
0.0262483153,
0.0234134346,
0.0139431925,
0.0230694655,
-0.0062654233,
0.0224068332,
0.0041401768,
0.0142119201,
0.0099293748,
-0.0261500664,
-0.0325002335,
-0.0287387837,
-0.0153920362,
-0.0297589097,
0.0461899601,
0.0002760714,
0.0454425961,
-0.073019743,
0.0457540378,
0.0061990093,
0.0274323411,
0.0053387587,
-0.0220482219,
0.0480262563,
-0.0397943407,
0.0393920653,
0.022633316,
-0.0202645808,
-0.0103959776,
0.031295158,
-0.0270283855,
-0.0841886029,
0.0228099637,
-0.0061395732,
-0.0705730543,
-0.0230049044,
0.0590931401,
-0.0428857841,
-0.0273963343,
0.0008748153,
0.0265903119,
-0.0203051604,
-0.0017287157,
0.0407691114,
-0.0306262001,
0.0261131711,
-0.0071424684,
0.0291499309,
0.1163416356,
-0.0494965091,
0.0065201176,
-0.0217797365,
0.0258643366,
0.027829336,
-0.0574426539,
0.0249108132,
0.0008358446,
-0.0091781188,
0.0091184909,
0.0578500219,
0.0642177314,
-0.0548945591,
-0.0065798187,
-0.0591087043,
0.0068716044,
0.0135765197,
0.041152209,
0.0174091086,
0.0536973961,
0.0353946239,
-0.0743499324,
0.0203770064,
0.0172674488,
-0.031469807,
0.0234412663,
-0.0042902967,
-0.057546854,
-0.0292078648,
-0.0133996587,
-0.0650902465,
-0.0138629247,
-0.0391384475,
-0.0181317348,
-0.0004627886,
-0.0227193553,
0.0342844166,
0.0085949991,
-0.0743307173,
-0.0269721933,
0.0312607959,
-0.0200437978,
0.0427928194,
-0.0191046465,
-0.0472025685,
0.0250118747,
-0.0247993991,
-0.0028392507,
0.0073513379,
0.0358687341,
0.0084325382,
0.0431174263,
0.0300793089,
-0.0169763081,
-0.0567200631,
-0.0155351674,
-0.0748617426,
-0.0005757803,
0.0395464897,
0.024415357,
0.0380833484,
0.0016153359,
0.0068571889,
0.0446605124,
0.0385415256,
0.0084241368,
-0.0164872501,
-0.0177401472,
0.0347779058,
-0.0275244154,
-0.0125936363,
-0.0046351179,
0.0169547163,
0.0452540293,
-0.0339748599,
-0.0100366417,
-0.0071867132,
2.514e-7,
0.0441165715,
0.0193848982,
0.0209610164,
0.0016210264,
0.017284967,
-0.003968305,
-0.0278542805,
0.0228895191,
-0.069985874,
-0.029192213,
0.0265042707,
0.0256029367,
-0.0030002326,
0.0066439598,
-0.0508121774,
0.0305455234,
-0.005704694,
0.0014863074,
0.0058094882,
0.0079449899,
0.0834561437,
0.0811279416,
0.0485834107,
-0.0073059197,
-0.0380279273,
0.0424217507,
0.0098250518,
-0.0143533442,
0.0386252552,
-0.0433684848,
-0.0304355118,
-0.0249956623,
0.053011138,
0.0481468923,
0.0235315878,
0.0364011265,
0.0680982992,
0.0425240397,
-0.0276020505,
0.0775369629,
-0.0111288624,
-0.0320746154,
0.0019113534,
-0.017840039,
0.0504349843,
-0.0087616472,
-0.084383063,
0.0212289244,
0.0076155039,
0.071266219,
0.0217548218,
0.047253225,
-0.0273079779,
-0.0180628821,
-0.013188879,
0.0147596765,
0.0105153089,
-0.0445467122,
-0.0031911554,
-0.00231145,
-0.0130199753,
-0.0598279014,
0.0218449514,
0.0318229645,
0.0094227996,
-0.012807861,
-0.0474714451,
2.566344318e-34,
0.0055579795,
0.0531712435,
0.0043793581,
0.0337849334,
-0.0139376754,
-0.0484092869,
0.0167375617,
0.0210756082,
0.0327265933,
-0.0659593269,
0.0068630874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17609v1 | LeCaRDv2: A Large-Scale Chinese Legal Case Retrieval Dataset | 2023-10-26T17:32:55 | 2023-10-26T17:32:55 | Haitao Li, Yunqiu Shao, Yueyue Wu, Qingyao Ai, Yixiao Ma, Yiqun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | As an important component of intelligent legal systems, legal case retrieval
plays a critical role in ensuring judicial justice and fairness. However, the
development of legal case retrieval technologies in the Chinese legal system is
restricted by three problems in existing datasets: limited data size, narrow
definitions of legal relevance, and naive candidate pooling strategies used in
data sampling. To alleviate these issues, we introduce LeCaRDv2, a large-scale
Legal Case Retrieval Dataset (version 2). It consists of 800 queries and 55,192
candidates extracted from 4.3 million criminal case documents. To the best of
our knowledge, LeCaRDv2 is one of the largest Chinese legal case retrieval
datasets, providing extensive coverage of criminal charges. Additionally, we
enrich the existing relevance criteria by considering three key aspects:
characterization, penalty, procedure. This comprehensive criteria enriches the
dataset and may provides a more holistic perspective. Furthermore, we propose a
two-level candidate set pooling strategy that effectively identify potential
candidates for each query case. It's important to note that all cases in the
dataset have been annotated by multiple legal experts specializing in criminal
law. Their expertise ensures the accuracy and reliability of the annotations.
We evaluate several state-of-the-art retrieval models at LeCaRDv2,
demonstrating that there is still significant room for improvement in legal
case retrieval. The details of LeCaRDv2 can be found at the anonymous website
https://github.com/anonymous1113243/LeCaRDv2. | [
0.0591499284,
0.0295140408,
-0.0169495251,
-0.0238695145,
-0.0531729609,
0.0112561658,
0.0222458001,
0.0473341346,
0.0051001175,
-0.0359217525,
-0.026828181,
-0.0117651178,
-0.0256686434,
-0.0226492956,
-0.0409793444,
-0.0297177006,
0.0400237441,
0.0649169534,
0.0632996932,
0.0211206265,
0.041612763,
0.000194591,
0.0257527195,
0.030979421,
-0.0074154409,
0.0046643862,
-0.0168044288,
0.0216548368,
0.0035489209,
-0.0363606066,
-0.0099792918,
0.0595149845,
0.0292418525,
0.0168504678,
0.0000016819,
-0.0644931942,
-0.0430649407,
-0.0398815386,
-0.0182727538,
0.0216984171,
0.0399766453,
-0.0045298804,
0.0032104102,
0.0129326861,
-0.0491803139,
-0.0121778296,
-0.0022296135,
0.0248783939,
0.0320156664,
0.0635486245,
0.0110719148,
-0.036795292,
-0.0067260084,
-0.0508633927,
0.0050818291,
-0.0480752476,
0.0316538885,
-0.0004793197,
0.0318976827,
-0.0095524164,
0.0290333312,
-0.0150913969,
-0.0009121671,
-0.0418687537,
-0.0125055397,
-0.0167716555,
-0.0782200769,
0.0201503821,
0.0387210362,
0.0553802177,
0.0602101013,
-0.0500424244,
-0.0030542966,
0.007755822,
0.0372062922,
0.0326407589,
-0.0460585281,
0.0890631005,
-0.0603241846,
0.0302658323,
0.0162801519,
0.0336826034,
-0.0143799596,
0.0339121222,
-0.020756796,
0.034368515,
-0.0125470581,
-0.0369690098,
-0.0090133278,
-0.0253900625,
0.0286741946,
-0.0108301705,
0.0405793898,
0.003185303,
-0.0338418484,
-0.000770273,
0.0344083309,
-0.0367910713,
0.0799367353,
-0.0595606714,
-0.003147078,
-0.0059633157,
-0.0157623906,
0.078373909,
0.0038000026,
-0.0160025246,
0.0142468875,
-0.0052118478,
-0.0317200869,
-0.0566706434,
-0.0238297693,
-0.0072602141,
-0.0363276415,
0.0565782599,
-0.0534403585,
0.0298191495,
-0.0259677283,
0.0192880128,
-0.0415431559,
-0.0160504561,
0.0049957917,
0.0032304551,
-0.0173360873,
-0.0013777586,
-0.0806477815,
-0.0436782055,
-0.0502275079,
0.0526902489,
-0.0125643089,
0.0198669247,
-0.0170464665,
-0.0009880984,
0.0349674486,
-0.0228528753,
0.0154190371,
0.0647945628,
0.0037584396,
-0.0187413488,
-0.049604062,
-0.0409588516,
0.0233884305,
-0.0215545036,
-0.0458292402,
-0.03714028,
-0.0147819771,
-0.0343101323,
-0.0368916988,
-0.0334102102,
0.01328672,
0.0724300519,
-0.0053728549,
0.0394545123,
0.0008453861,
-0.0101875197,
-0.0160421506,
0.039936468,
0.007829506,
-0.0063288314,
-0.0262410045,
0.0498433933,
0.0581703,
0.0010001274,
0.0380261205,
-0.0109660998,
0.0241930746,
0.0066368845,
0.0018783718,
0.0576740392,
-0.0217592195,
0.001988725,
0.0001148992,
-0.006723268,
-0.0184735935,
-0.0237058774,
-0.0088363979,
0.0468963422,
0.0213215705,
0.015721472,
-0.0359822661,
-0.0041308394,
-0.0050813328,
-0.0315664411,
-0.0369615406,
0.0227506589,
-0.0437134691,
-0.005422066,
-0.0300746914,
-0.0390420519,
-0.0496028028,
-0.056512028,
-0.0071669845,
0.030760536,
0.0268956721,
0.0035038048,
0.0178214479,
-0.0045053866,
0.017870253,
0.0320817344,
0.0216951724,
-0.0410817005,
-0.0511796661,
-0.0437816456,
0.0194445588,
0.0428498127,
0.0342087783,
-0.0777096078,
0.0029732257,
0.0233116094,
-0.03076455,
-0.0100765275,
0.0264612176,
-0.0255444348,
-0.0244260579,
-0.04377966,
-0.0536755882,
0.0634924248,
0.0161815714,
0.0121412808,
0.0108346585,
0.0260203928,
0.0277063884,
-0.0563659035,
0.0248259436,
0.0176430009,
0.0185605809,
-0.0123035507,
0.0324628092,
0.0093960566,
0.0366982035,
0.0253327414,
-0.0060583702,
-0.013969901,
0.043014612,
0.0403647125,
-0.0255315285,
-0.019290721,
0.0348820575,
0.0035319768,
0.0334989801,
-0.0355856456,
0.0338284448,
-0.0021296153,
-0.0480302088,
-0.0358641557,
-0.0184112843,
0.0340172239,
-0.0255310517,
-0.0878788158,
0.0117505863,
-0.0406729057,
0.0050999187,
-0.0291724652,
0.0749424994,
0.0262673032,
-0.0357648917,
-0.0020563866,
0.0088463025,
0.0536610037,
-0.0565494709,
-0.0206321478,
-0.0562135801,
-0.0335942321,
0.0348216929,
0.0530215912,
-0.0031970053,
-0.039926514,
-0.0095225405,
-0.0764795095,
0.056018427,
-0.0364545844,
-0.0322244838,
-0.0236086436,
0.0246283766,
-0.0086752577,
-0.0274123643,
-0.0367638133,
-0.0354631171,
0.0026827105,
0.001290486,
0.0073131989,
-0.0056018536,
0.0212054327,
-0.016074555,
-0.0343151987,
-0.0024932965,
0.012287722,
-0.0183727313,
-0.0110634668,
0.0182680562,
0.0707211494,
-0.0270184334,
-0.0259937309,
-0.0566452891,
0.0175011493,
-0.0045837318,
-0.0216115396,
-0.0795226246,
0.0289336033,
0.0544219427,
0.0187250283,
0.0222615004,
0.0143604921,
-0.0663824901,
0.0111331567,
0.0209122542,
0.0256775506,
0.0280216839,
0.0049265334,
0.0026036063,
-0.0218580235,
0.0203776527,
0.0002841104,
-0.0091592381,
-0.01148808,
0.0532569177,
-0.0077530784,
-0.0560298115,
-0.0109472191,
0.0112854196,
0.0245892443,
-0.013423821,
-0.0624024048,
0.047896117,
0.0411514826,
0.0821231306,
-0.0272026788,
-0.0115285553,
-0.0563960932,
0.1023498774,
-0.0046543181,
-0.0147441616,
-0.025896294,
-0.032035403,
0.0473106876,
0.0067821085,
0.0617134348,
-0.0636977777,
0.0672006309,
0.0249213632,
0.0396310166,
-0.052992478,
-0.0599451736,
-0.0257610157,
-0.0608884767,
0.0131949037,
0.0422358289,
-0.0064554238,
0.0203493554,
-0.0206410699,
0.0347562209,
-0.0096233133,
0.0130309369,
-0.0050486024,
-0.0048329853,
-0.0182675663,
-0.0180332568,
-0.0130123161,
-0.0316240825,
0.0095284777,
0.0439387001,
0.008578117,
0.0329809636,
0.0129003553,
0.0043319399,
0.0618586913,
0.0334518366,
0.0190212075,
-0.0734962896,
-0.0342033952,
0.0052855387,
-0.0180729628,
-0.0597805306,
0.03090542,
0.0634389967,
0.0378329642,
-0.0508960187,
-0.029284412,
0.0128140179,
-0.0229518805,
0.0409799665,
-0.0007233951,
-0.0922718942,
0.0113167576,
0.0160609242,
0.0105065713,
-0.0521540679,
-0.0480348617,
0.0148037486,
-0.0818421394,
0.1209648848,
0.0225530136,
-0.0078935614,
-0.0356154591,
-0.0580139458,
0.0178168863,
-0.0156026157,
-0.0026751228,
0.0191270057,
-0.0165551566,
-0.0307049807,
-0.0060886894,
-0.0203439742,
0.0168833975,
0.0367441513,
-0.0572395176,
0.0150088398,
0.0158977974,
0.0479034856,
-0.0083419364,
0.0067963121,
-0.0137462197,
-0.0256269537,
-0.0154383359,
-0.0088023786,
0.0504761599,
0.0273222551,
0.0302215815,
-0.0558371171,
0.0475118533,
0.0054968111,
-0.0251613501,
0.051372923,
0.0230382383,
-0.0666233078,
0.0356666595,
-0.0298908427,
-0.0550103374,
-0.016205851,
0.0659464449,
-0.008686862,
0.0324027762,
0.0009811019,
-0.0142148864,
-0.029902909,
-0.0227231532,
0.0051436601,
0.0199648216,
-0.027103547,
0.0421712063,
-0.0265283063,
-0.0317171328,
-0.0108818887,
0.0391737409,
-0.0122864274,
0.0507022105,
-0.0085715661,
-0.0048543583,
-0.0766688362,
0.018219484,
-0.0314846933,
0.0034200624,
0.0173550602,
0.0230230596,
-0.0082117794,
-0.036697641,
-0.0111250822,
-0.0100073228,
0.0348685868,
0.0256989747,
-0.0245403703,
-0.0524443947,
0.0098618139,
0.0057374067,
-0.072611481,
-0.0446018428,
0.062593013,
0.0385812074,
0.0007498974,
-0.0515191592,
0.0454687141,
-0.0444134437,
-0.0429850295,
-0.0030100539,
-0.0370782092,
0.0367417708,
0.0330618098,
0.0089325532,
-0.0411421023,
0.01266238,
0.0423828289,
0.0663055107,
0.0683591291,
0.0369461961,
-0.0205550063,
-0.0540384129,
0.0165832005,
-0.0397302918,
-0.0423030108,
0.0012860441,
0.0095251156,
0.0237363428,
-0.0010960276,
-0.0312753133,
0.0377938449,
-0.0126571096,
-0.0029102908,
-0.0807898119,
0.0237961039,
0.0201860275,
0.0306442641,
-0.0378662534,
-0.0306552742,
-0.0059130397,
0.0027487832,
-0.0046197432,
0.0707814395,
-0.0317491256,
0.0425575413,
0.0029358941,
0.0228379034,
0.0048873345,
-0.0121691367,
-0.0729270428,
-0.0032360542,
0.0064329985,
0.0377401151,
0.0723272562,
-0.0184879657,
-0.0261147842,
-0.0156569108,
0.004400563,
-0.0158165768,
0.0100953989,
0.0127078332,
-0.0281131919,
0.0049302997,
0.0339065157,
-0.0127813788,
0.0410127565,
0.0254587717,
-0.013759234,
0.0156334564,
-0.0279008262,
-0.0508203804,
0.008299971,
-0.010544559,
0.0597037114,
0.0488821119,
-0.0291693211,
-0.0919333622,
-0.0679176152,
0.0193464514,
-0.0058411807,
0.0130835986,
-0.0162408575,
0.0404943675,
-0.0075528347,
0.0567673557,
0.0045608343,
-0.008508089,
-0.0527772494,
0.0042871148,
-0.0416523516,
-0.0090327337,
-0.0043530972,
-5.265520783e-33,
-0.0083391424,
-0.0023471247,
0.0075557646,
0.0148245227,
0.0007701008,
-0.0159475468,
0.0215675402,
-0.0330420546,
-0.0598141477,
-0.0029925648,
-0.039879255,
0.0328547992,
0.0131309954,
-0.0168502852,
0.0284228195,
-0.0199604314,
-0.0009611231,
0.0252388231,
-0.004857461,
0.0175433345,
0.0370610431,
0.0273942202,
0.0101435771,
-0.0949638113,
0.018684227,
0.0282141883,
0.0022486171,
0.0110096009,
-0.0469221435,
0.0928937197,
0.0368122682,
0.0547922403,
0.0402429663,
-0.0544051453,
0.0175249856,
-0.0044680196,
-0.1005465835,
0.0064796731,
-0.0256089456,
-0.012507135,
0.057826452,
-0.0098352814,
0.002036138,
-0.0108494693,
0.0012600919,
0.0007367866,
0.04860048,
-0.0491922162,
-0.0699575171,
-0.0734820217,
0.0131977051,
0.0575037263,
0.0035670239,
0.0543845072,
-0.0299190637,
-0.0170895159,
0.0131927915,
0.0790892839,
-0.0906820595,
0.0031878899,
-0.0348686315,
0.0071210731,
-0.0229060333,
-0.0453023724,
0.0143838609,
0.0468637496,
0.0135060456,
-0.0149837257,
-0.0106855724,
-0.0328671709,
0.0127542615,
0.0992718637,
0.0118298717,
0.0622294806,
0.0434389897,
-0.0600130521,
-0.0955720469,
0.0036600383,
0.0414860658,
0.0393052846,
0.0310060866,
0.009028146,
-0.0837413892,
-0.0103754848,
-0.0242507011,
-0.0357908756,
-0.015466339,
0.0125428699,
0.0234225001,
0.0422164835,
0.027027458,
-0.0174068958,
0.0091636088,
-0.0203046426,
0.0242651831,
0.0638475716,
0.0011463182,
-0.0002601359,
-0.0174499582,
0.0275124442,
-0.0303911231,
-0.057061594,
0.0300704483,
-0.0275848415,
-0.0461232997,
-0.0147282286,
0.041527383,
-0.0296643991,
-0.0323835425,
0.0000377352,
0.0345502682,
-0.0022004393,
-0.0115642063,
-0.0045622382,
-0.0150319189,
0.0302852038,
0.0546269417,
0.0006331774,
0.0420155525,
0.0108674085,
-0.0644616932,
-0.072536774,
-0.0102462508,
-0.0528806858,
0.0490250923,
0.0504905172,
0.0111907264,
0.0310972854,
0.031544622,
-0.0055069919,
0.022594627,
0.083631523,
2.455e-7,
0.0473410375,
-0.0035287228,
-0.0346320607,
0.0423794389,
-0.0297887437,
0.0393856093,
0.0167520046,
0.0440820791,
0.0277323872,
0.0001463472,
0.0391446352,
0.0232608169,
0.0513682924,
0.0508405715,
-0.0455712117,
-0.0294839349,
-0.0207901094,
-0.0683746636,
-0.046577245,
0.0319123156,
0.0174628906,
0.0973575041,
0.0072047319,
-0.0081364652,
0.0276160669,
-0.0642450973,
0.0225522704,
-0.0147012873,
-0.0254725255,
0.0165743679,
0.0784450024,
0.0086672017,
-0.0066998983,
0.0191135239,
0.0091456203,
0.0797179267,
-0.0026456497,
0.0342825167,
0.0058445195,
0.00649552,
-0.0266086366,
-0.0604074746,
0.0322663896,
-0.0163399633,
0.0637709424,
0.0532662794,
0.0234314259,
0.0014902342,
-0.0050620195,
-0.0193386413,
0.0197808538,
0.041042719,
-0.0199481286,
-0.0088374624,
0.0255068447,
0.0159927625,
0.0274783615,
-0.1041658074,
-0.0000408364,
0.0009033227,
-0.0245721657,
-0.0118743265,
0.0331516005,
-0.0001722875,
0.0283228103,
-0.057255663,
0.0262867939,
1.958908301e-34,
0.0266317502,
-0.0189761799,
-0.0219459198,
-0.0095144808,
0.0419388525,
0.0228276011,
-0.0398098379,
-0.0065941205,
-0.0176784992,
-0.0660017729,
0.016005246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17606v1 | Using State-of-the-Art Speech Models to Evaluate Oral Reading Fluency in Ghana | 2023-10-26T17:30:13 | 2023-10-26T17:30:13 | Owen Henkel, Hannah Horne-Robinson, Libby Hills, Bill Roberts, Joshua McGrane | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper reports on a set of three recent experiments utilizing large-scale
speech models to evaluate the oral reading fluency (ORF) of students in Ghana.
While ORF is a well-established measure of foundational literacy, assessing it
typically requires one-on-one sessions between a student and a trained
evaluator, a process that is time-consuming and costly. Automating the
evaluation of ORF could support better literacy instruction, particularly in
education contexts where formative assessment is uncommon due to large class
sizes and limited resources. To our knowledge, this research is among the first
to examine the use of the most recent versions of large-scale speech models
(Whisper V2 wav2vec2.0) for ORF assessment in the Global South.
We find that Whisper V2 produces transcriptions of Ghanaian students reading
aloud with a Word Error Rate of 13.5. This is close to the model's average WER
on adult speech (12.8) and would have been considered state-of-the-art for
children's speech transcription only a few years ago. We also find that when
these transcriptions are used to produce fully automated ORF scores, they
closely align with scores generated by expert human graders, with a correlation
coefficient of 0.96. Importantly, these results were achieved on a
representative dataset (i.e., students with regional accents, recordings taken
in actual classrooms), using a free and publicly available speech model out of
the box (i.e., no fine-tuning). This suggests that using large-scale speech
models to assess ORF may be feasible to implement and scale in lower-resource,
linguistically diverse educational contexts. | [
0.0025779239,
0.0537171364,
-0.0138003156,
-0.008977239,
-0.0122796753,
0.0220350679,
0.0612982176,
-0.0053943475,
-0.0097428467,
-0.0162269305,
-0.0238496345,
-0.0456897691,
0.1238896027,
0.0056502153,
-0.0016015333,
-0.0477370247,
-0.0250210315,
-0.0710266903,
-0.0017357757,
0.0056451708,
0.0061735273,
0.032843098,
-0.0836775675,
0.047985509,
0.0088159237,
-0.0210903659,
-0.0008293185,
-0.0187279433,
-0.0165746305,
0.0163563583,
-0.0065015573,
0.055953972,
-0.0667905435,
0.022941526,
0.0000019427,
-0.0260091964,
-0.0048052287,
0.0023140884,
-0.025411088,
0.0797912329,
0.0679094642,
0.0533054546,
-0.0639043748,
0.0482733771,
-0.0091267768,
-0.0175769534,
0.0244101007,
-0.0595375486,
-0.0007923079,
0.0187031459,
0.0035172726,
-0.0085016862,
0.0721250474,
0.0055066654,
-0.0441585369,
-0.03083908,
0.0045865718,
0.0291200168,
-0.0259679779,
-0.0128360875,
-0.028639771,
0.0523560382,
-0.0490191057,
-0.0523180775,
-0.0086903144,
-0.0275742766,
-0.0208312385,
-0.0600872114,
-0.0278042816,
0.0252956077,
0.0129164336,
-0.0098254988,
0.0102110356,
0.0154361818,
-0.0246197414,
0.028301578,
-0.0514450781,
0.0115014222,
0.0023424774,
-0.0146538336,
0.0218614154,
0.0157630891,
-0.0018721127,
-0.0204948727,
0.0151802059,
-0.0144436369,
0.0271410905,
-0.0188258793,
0.0046668639,
0.0308277737,
-0.0037216912,
0.0330174826,
-0.0028065143,
-0.0089470521,
-0.0036043248,
-0.0008501997,
0.003492811,
-0.0710151419,
0.0222229213,
-0.0040056603,
0.0657648221,
0.0451681912,
-0.0487802178,
-0.0093667265,
0.0114744864,
0.0662211105,
0.0072296667,
0.0157314278,
-0.0268736836,
0.0274435896,
0.0093863234,
-0.0247516315,
0.0064209867,
-0.0211846046,
-0.0434801951,
0.0053756274,
-0.0859249756,
-0.0176884029,
-0.006224554,
-0.0063894326,
0.0184304435,
-0.0226945374,
0.0053874184,
-0.0062299687,
0.0278641135,
0.0503596254,
0.008126568,
0.0539186485,
-0.0306263771,
-0.0723509416,
0.0706672296,
-0.0040751919,
0.0161330439,
0.0627231151,
0.0050377399,
0.0223863088,
-0.0148979872,
-0.0147921015,
-0.0294197444,
-0.0091129243,
-0.0439814217,
-0.0178402513,
-0.0785538778,
-0.0355270542,
-0.0262647886,
0.0484411009,
0.0557593554,
-0.0065012579,
-0.0283809509,
-0.0214902684,
0.0584111512,
0.0076135448,
0.0169214904,
0.0404679216,
0.0874736831,
0.0200570151,
0.0400090851,
0.0299101155,
0.0518741198,
-0.057969071,
-0.0182496272,
-0.0407486707,
-0.0455357395,
0.0727074593,
-0.0026495617,
0.0306862034,
0.0290048495,
-0.0575649142,
-0.0119851902,
0.0037157608,
0.0147637948,
0.0441504829,
0.0100119747,
0.0145177217,
0.0547835007,
0.0778907463,
0.0530520082,
-0.0012513991,
0.0033090645,
0.0110057546,
0.0369067304,
0.0128224948,
0.0421976037,
-0.0500770248,
-0.0331725031,
-0.0123492628,
0.0716823488,
0.0574562885,
0.0048939441,
-0.0468637981,
0.0094167134,
0.0173776299,
-0.0282774642,
0.011426976,
0.0495470613,
-0.0276915282,
-0.0301264524,
-0.0349445231,
0.0337720327,
-0.0574403405,
0.0291489493,
-0.0465024337,
0.0441483185,
0.0285656806,
0.0322579257,
0.0190655738,
0.0626440495,
0.0044527538,
-0.019901637,
0.0367980115,
0.0044041229,
-0.0044439784,
0.0085461205,
-0.0357538909,
0.0061577191,
0.0736448765,
0.018720746,
0.0073688086,
0.0059469356,
0.0745068491,
0.0068890057,
-0.0204930045,
-0.055929862,
0.0050216196,
-0.0492989868,
-0.0036047653,
-0.0450337715,
0.0028097073,
0.0624662936,
0.0559908785,
0.0026252896,
0.0081036119,
-0.0202505421,
0.02545809,
0.0559498109,
-0.0046952656,
-0.0505316183,
0.0054151379,
0.0250469539,
-0.0252338611,
0.0410429798,
0.0253069047,
0.0583014451,
-0.0486083813,
0.0278351232,
-0.0280209575,
0.0397947542,
-0.0338823535,
0.0691593513,
-0.0475771017,
-0.0331893377,
-0.0077417898,
-0.0447597839,
0.0049209134,
0.0048086243,
-0.0283732656,
0.0254115723,
0.0241693724,
-0.0263288617,
-0.0411534123,
-0.0098318374,
-0.0314241908,
0.0428288393,
-0.038436152,
-0.0185817555,
-0.0341718048,
-0.0502408147,
-0.103099227,
-0.0092065232,
0.0188725665,
-0.0137967831,
-0.0000109258,
0.0126330368,
0.0060854498,
0.036210496,
-0.0119019002,
-0.0099422168,
0.0255899653,
-0.0307528414,
-0.0633940399,
-0.052102901,
-0.0369451642,
-0.0366208963,
-0.0171798002,
-0.0218450017,
0.024262704,
0.0698445216,
-0.0002160226,
-0.0556494184,
0.0155453924,
0.0419313684,
-0.0160918348,
0.0229863003,
-0.0258907713,
0.0175831579,
-0.0179563276,
0.0306974445,
0.0621526316,
-0.0072686607,
-0.0092440769,
0.0046704551,
-0.0246137511,
-0.0412501097,
-0.0481305905,
0.0149415564,
0.0219000578,
-0.0151908388,
-0.0088066747,
-0.0525382385,
0.0440696515,
0.0679927468,
0.0368967205,
-0.0230121072,
0.0306044985,
-0.0505141243,
-0.0431791805,
-0.01368153,
-0.0512945168,
-0.0254488587,
-0.0006746542,
-0.0163307358,
-0.0192116071,
0.0237672646,
-0.0742118955,
-0.0114029683,
-0.0243266411,
0.0348746479,
-0.0083079608,
-0.0130065186,
-0.0251559559,
-0.0275740549,
-0.0032792583,
-0.0190286003,
0.0000166829,
0.0151040498,
0.0523401126,
-0.0574883893,
0.0030366099,
-0.0407575816,
-0.0032018286,
0.0088393539,
-0.0114796124,
0.0085753733,
-0.0033346482,
-0.0141230877,
-0.0058604768,
0.0290151145,
-0.0265726168,
-0.038121935,
0.0666490346,
0.0254285205,
0.0566253848,
-0.0128882341,
0.0255408511,
-0.0033022838,
0.0455502197,
-0.0082112802,
-0.0162400808,
-0.0177858267,
-0.0755918622,
0.0495118462,
-0.0051027448,
-0.005740908,
0.0447815284,
0.0071915793,
0.0031551423,
0.0312055424,
0.0314082205,
0.0061571458,
0.0178665966,
0.0433299579,
-0.021860091,
0.0255090725,
0.0776552483,
0.0098091336,
0.0082215127,
-0.0389099307,
-0.0250757709,
0.0369386375,
-0.0503027514,
-0.0091189239,
-0.0144499335,
0.0036890437,
0.0391069166,
0.0761669651,
-0.0065724989,
0.0122846533,
0.0255353469,
-0.0647875294,
0.0195241235,
0.0385111906,
-0.0102876713,
0.0092609199,
0.0119171515,
-0.0195909273,
-0.0040990291,
0.0133007467,
0.0452104434,
-0.00635899,
-0.0238024034,
0.0667900294,
-0.062418893,
-0.0360364914,
0.045035176,
-0.0104819471,
0.0710539967,
0.0278275907,
-0.0339697152,
0.0083590867,
-0.042394951,
-0.0318846442,
-0.0051794946,
-0.0231679659,
-0.0234323479,
0.0195424799,
0.0347630456,
-0.0098117646,
-0.0593905449,
0.0334642082,
0.006693257,
0.0499392487,
-0.0238789599,
0.00719332,
0.0107276877,
0.0132142492,
-0.0170186646,
0.0339692123,
-0.0050826939,
0.0199098624,
0.0330830701,
-0.0869129598,
0.0042730756,
-0.0045007183,
0.0303674266,
-0.0566227473,
-0.0406806692,
0.0604886487,
0.045286119,
-0.0447317883,
-0.0172944013,
-0.0246362519,
0.0418286324,
-0.0153359808,
0.0469420031,
0.01987819,
0.0372270681,
-0.0018373526,
0.0070885634,
-0.0118487459,
-0.028132556,
0.0259252228,
-0.1216932908,
-0.0196638033,
0.0387922116,
-0.0153879384,
-0.0367366113,
-0.0052647577,
-0.0852749124,
-0.0457934961,
0.0597739555,
0.0185167156,
0.0235488508,
-0.0335368142,
0.0042001908,
-0.0472817495,
0.0545036383,
-0.045885805,
-0.0597800873,
0.0402225032,
-0.0120936884,
-0.0220597442,
0.0054105981,
-0.0240692254,
0.0377040505,
-0.0156192845,
-0.0254542604,
0.0143692717,
-0.0423687659,
-0.0492855087,
-0.0491979867,
-0.0070847762,
0.0317084603,
-0.0105719753,
-0.0177356154,
-0.079774864,
0.0081633702,
0.0398065597,
0.0572764277,
-0.0070387563,
-0.0449644104,
0.0386073999,
0.0052841357,
-0.0556060821,
-0.034996327,
-0.0633863807,
-0.0059366222,
0.0096485959,
0.0911860913,
0.001001899,
0.0210593678,
0.0053319251,
0.0040633199,
-0.0206758473,
0.056465216,
-0.028388951,
0.0575744323,
0.0400762185,
0.0039467621,
-0.0440639295,
0.0144194374,
0.0455741212,
-0.0030322112,
0.013063998,
0.0144098122,
-0.0589728542,
0.0136119612,
0.0118234605,
0.0213300046,
0.0576293543,
0.0124719255,
0.0282679144,
-0.052670449,
-0.0286012944,
-0.0520232841,
0.0117919305,
0.0190449338,
-0.0180891566,
0.0158145782,
0.030926872,
0.014182766,
0.0473148338,
-0.0179703739,
-0.017674014,
0.0109542264,
-0.0246853661,
-0.0428376347,
0.0150642898,
0.0171379969,
-0.0555942953,
0.0234146845,
-0.0597938858,
-0.0439675786,
0.0165411253,
0.0505244397,
0.0195428934,
-0.006873867,
-0.0314694308,
-0.01553364,
-0.060070049,
0.0122862561,
-0.0335922539,
-0.0502270795,
-0.0169686079,
-0.0636281967,
0.0594453216,
-5.758061365e-33,
-0.0239035133,
-0.0336293951,
0.0285874661,
0.0074352575,
-0.0090494063,
0.0213621594,
-0.0240201056,
0.0576995574,
-0.025214823,
-0.0119790705,
-0.0147049688,
-0.0249534864,
0.026323298,
0.0309954844,
0.0113732498,
0.0505285487,
0.0181591399,
-0.0040231273,
0.0004396852,
-0.0216453448,
0.0357150026,
0.0150057236,
0.0274365097,
-0.012523978,
0.0569902398,
-0.0271115135,
-0.0243896041,
-0.0645297691,
0.006202688,
0.0520440191,
-0.0049467636,
0.033694312,
-0.0043833898,
0.0222107545,
0.0415354967,
0.0419839881,
-0.0735576078,
0.0290617943,
0.0369543955,
0.0558414236,
0.0075045642,
0.002068768,
0.0455972366,
0.0164607614,
-0.0645639971,
-0.0225923676,
0.0115246698,
-0.0439217836,
0.0026994608,
0.0040600556,
-0.0203897059,
0.0366599038,
-0.0135652563,
-0.0249640197,
0.0229328014,
0.0383345559,
-0.0345702507,
-0.0411696099,
-0.032559976,
0.0300318245,
0.0963643491,
0.0806778967,
0.03012776,
0.0311020017,
-0.0529799648,
0.0118143149,
0.0125832418,
-0.0771236345,
0.0149921142,
-0.05103679,
0.0957044363,
-0.0335805379,
0.0314922631,
0.0333752297,
0.0162390713,
-0.0480097979,
-0.0613054782,
0.036169108,
0.0153341722,
0.004463932,
0.0184377618,
-0.0323043279,
-0.0590868331,
-0.0303486977,
-0.0521929115,
-0.0263059922,
-0.0421711206,
0.0055155489,
0.0851716101,
-0.0671726763,
-0.0072940816,
-0.011372556,
0.0459625311,
-0.0080494303,
0.0047156974,
-0.0261333399,
-0.0058206678,
0.045344878,
-0.0569162853,
0.0080568073,
-0.0347046852,
-0.0192219447,
0.007405201,
0.0354685001,
-0.0092017194,
-0.0157958772,
-0.0457633398,
-0.0327788666,
-0.0479596928,
0.0239830166,
0.0210658908,
0.0217564348,
0.0035259579,
0.0163842831,
0.0281961244,
-0.0187370311,
0.0080275424,
0.0178570095,
-0.0061254534,
-0.0060611647,
-0.0152750211,
-0.0366385207,
-0.0316970609,
0.0183088165,
-0.0600401536,
0.0061240019,
0.0048726625,
-0.002528996,
0.0000821658,
-0.0022856549,
0.0335079283,
0.0316279046,
2.527e-7,
-0.0182835199,
0.0565055981,
0.035721615,
-0.0301331487,
0.0062826965,
0.0002088508,
-0.0028269491,
-0.0324477367,
0.0441418141,
0.0493165143,
0.0208734889,
-0.0274755917,
0.1136498302,
-0.0035744703,
-0.0717465132,
-0.0222221892,
-0.045350533,
0.0558957011,
-0.0350282714,
-0.0041643134,
-0.0264290292,
0.0273464862,
-0.0420897156,
-0.0658664629,
-0.0431100391,
-0.0047591226,
0.0182509087,
0.0116852866,
-0.0114216404,
-0.0098615168,
0.0491955914,
-0.0081239631,
0.0251893178,
0.0520799607,
-0.0219902117,
0.0160215311,
0.0176872127,
0.0622091889,
-0.0219892915,
0.0255370755,
0.0146019449,
-0.0015826919,
-0.0569709875,
-0.0491777062,
0.0252059251,
0.0699076727,
0.0184746124,
0.0508253388,
-0.051982142,
-0.0166433919,
0.0067329453,
-0.0529069006,
-0.008059863,
0.007408333,
0.016472334,
-0.0602543019,
0.0057797558,
0.0604297519,
0.0177925639,
-0.0142417522,
-0.0080255,
-0.0653860718,
-0.0265477542,
-0.003542033,
-0.0335176475,
-0.0387592763,
0.0165712424,
1.752675393e-34,
0.0321793817,
-0.0226514954,
0.0576651208,
-0.0207006373,
-0.0152580095,
0.0198599733,
0.0835664123,
0.0039241146,
0.0335618481,
-0.0586080477,
-0.0305921212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17591v1 | Lil-Bevo: Explorations of Strategies for Training Language Models in More Humanlike Ways | 2023-10-26T17:13:07 | 2023-10-26T17:13:07 | Venkata S Govindarajan, Juan Diego Rodriguez, Kaj Bostrom, Kyle Mahowald | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Lil-Bevo, our submission to the BabyLM Challenge. We pretrained
our masked language models with three ingredients: an initial pretraining with
music data, training on shorter sequences before training on longer ones, and
masking specific tokens to target some of the BLiMP subtasks. Overall, our
baseline models performed above chance, but far below the performance levels of
larger LLMs trained on more data. We found that training on short sequences
performed better than training on longer sequences.Pretraining on music may
help performance marginally, but, if so, the effect seems small. Our targeted
Masked Language Modeling augmentation did not seem to improve model performance
in general, but did seem to help on some of the specific BLiMP tasks that we
were targeting (e.g., Negative Polarity Items). Training performant LLMs on
small amounts of data is a difficult but potentially informative task. While
some of our techniques showed some promise, more work is needed to explore
whether they can improve performance more than the modest gains here. Our code
is available at https://github.com/venkatasg/Lil-Bevo and out models at
https://huggingface.co/collections/venkatasg/babylm-653591cdb66f4bf68922873a | [
0.0100403549,
0.0596232899,
-0.0254541673,
0.0467372276,
-0.0193668511,
0.0110601531,
0.0136539498,
0.0135861216,
-0.0488213897,
-0.0460346974,
-0.0538899973,
-0.0089043966,
-0.0237364396,
0.0407316349,
0.0402448811,
-0.0791710243,
0.0392158106,
-0.0442855358,
0.0215249266,
-0.0118010724,
-0.0239678882,
0.0085315863,
-0.0468499176,
0.0648221746,
0.011207087,
0.0153593253,
-0.0063756569,
0.0094293961,
0.0158778336,
-0.0294133462,
-0.0026036184,
0.0731982067,
0.0098483227,
0.0260881539,
0.000001926,
-0.032284297,
0.0136136208,
-0.0349283069,
-0.0212068781,
-0.019910261,
0.0655689463,
0.0093188593,
-0.0204562787,
0.0387419909,
-0.0435643643,
-0.0210772753,
0.0416469462,
0.037626259,
0.0310563035,
0.0917254165,
0.0141119221,
-0.0027266752,
0.0080299769,
-0.0268836059,
0.0434795767,
-0.0025420699,
0.0189260747,
-0.0422832333,
0.0193419047,
-0.0085359979,
-0.040920116,
0.0287943762,
0.0211792532,
0.0481342822,
0.0365360901,
0.0484378673,
-0.0434035473,
-0.0382668748,
-0.0165605955,
0.0455629826,
-0.0385651439,
-0.037084911,
-0.000169907,
-0.0023367112,
-0.0116250943,
-0.0318316519,
-0.0458527505,
0.0101373326,
0.038274318,
0.0173090287,
-0.0203639418,
-0.0065674689,
0.0641958117,
0.013764645,
0.0199805666,
0.055775892,
0.0190086123,
-0.0544493794,
0.0169417448,
-0.0145218186,
-0.0030576536,
-0.0768267512,
0.000204457,
0.0068694288,
0.0172444116,
0.0179941077,
-0.0433307178,
-0.023376124,
0.0135120219,
-0.0151294982,
0.0554252155,
0.0328263417,
-0.0456358045,
0.0262629688,
-0.0284203161,
0.0332908519,
0.0156195853,
0.0505273007,
-0.0165280271,
-0.0044351546,
-0.0120262038,
-0.0279244017,
-0.0225345474,
-0.0020486133,
-0.0228742938,
-0.0049008327,
-0.0484027825,
-0.0356048718,
-0.0379284471,
-0.0040092696,
0.0038211476,
-0.0160418618,
-0.0367365666,
-0.0018508356,
0.0120007535,
-0.0193476155,
0.0040226066,
0.06148424,
0.0105281398,
-0.0371441059,
0.0042036893,
0.0126953237,
0.0036569857,
-0.0365803912,
0.0452350229,
0.0495020933,
0.0279876012,
-0.0501275435,
-0.0526025519,
0.017497303,
-0.0291807819,
-0.0609191619,
0.0218902808,
-0.0752540603,
-0.0001102255,
-0.0257503148,
-0.0097286422,
-0.0352694392,
0.0049222414,
0.0037827229,
-0.0068039391,
0.0958401635,
0.0084336847,
0.0070500765,
-0.0105807753,
0.0308119003,
-0.0257177092,
0.0941138044,
0.0482872799,
-0.0059594922,
0.0476962328,
-0.0526322834,
0.0326014422,
0.0695572868,
0.023813244,
-0.0042652963,
-0.0306436382,
-0.0380378515,
0.0086922571,
0.0056936322,
0.0739388093,
0.0382713936,
-0.0174017027,
-0.0498104505,
0.0556528904,
0.0564003997,
-0.0057492936,
0.0027196112,
0.0329793915,
0.0002439253,
0.0041390178,
0.0076601561,
-0.0505336374,
0.0162370224,
-0.019606879,
0.0084187156,
0.0293870512,
0.0318698995,
-0.012340338,
-0.0090395762,
-0.04257771,
-0.0253799837,
0.0633195192,
0.0202498864,
0.032993976,
0.0170773175,
-0.044678241,
0.0379880741,
0.0379837193,
-0.0472340696,
0.0035542441,
-0.0511861593,
0.0013888415,
0.0267693605,
0.0013738589,
-0.0308646411,
0.0113363881,
-0.013835852,
-0.016824767,
0.0903821364,
-0.0025632633,
0.0000983054,
0.0275604688,
-0.0292566754,
-0.0091731511,
-0.0011063112,
0.0203343332,
0.016186934,
0.016260406,
-0.0233581122,
0.0129618915,
-0.0158520229,
0.0116740018,
0.0462377742,
-0.0413155109,
-0.0362222679,
0.0113139208,
0.0074542053,
0.0651539117,
0.0219994094,
-0.0100750588,
0.0234682076,
0.047300905,
-0.0430585779,
-0.0009108636,
-7.683e-7,
-0.030100124,
-0.0391419679,
0.0719071552,
-0.0237657782,
0.0001708728,
0.1017406806,
-0.0064743697,
-0.0462772548,
0.0381465144,
-0.0283192638,
0.0407816023,
-0.0251716916,
0.0176474862,
-0.0121076992,
0.014789761,
-0.0193037242,
0.0138209509,
0.002992471,
0.0448525213,
-0.0257975012,
-0.0446925797,
0.0001093892,
-0.0470125973,
-0.0099209454,
0.0452229232,
0.0055723852,
-0.00003615,
-0.0060120155,
-0.0010971738,
-0.041513741,
-0.0156837441,
-0.1100057214,
-0.0060703228,
-0.032539133,
-0.0086672725,
0.0086693838,
-0.0176309068,
-0.045700606,
-0.0177541729,
-0.0364868864,
-0.0413872972,
0.0016974931,
0.0290319249,
-0.0266767759,
-0.0048040147,
-0.0681975111,
-0.0141174076,
-0.0261560827,
-0.0193669181,
-0.00389056,
-0.0392883644,
-0.0251354724,
-0.0067427452,
-0.0103086755,
-0.0429053009,
0.0247460436,
-0.0183026474,
-0.0314361006,
0.0058906814,
0.002607591,
0.0715208203,
0.0441552997,
0.0229910389,
-0.0040504257,
0.0851692185,
0.0096622026,
-0.0297975782,
0.0036492355,
-0.0249367785,
0.027569579,
-0.0576884411,
-0.0446724258,
-0.012084363,
0.0815172344,
0.0098355887,
0.0055817049,
-0.0521099754,
0.0086069368,
-0.028827861,
-0.0531213693,
-0.0131628923,
-0.0294274073,
-0.0668524131,
0.0351253711,
-0.0243127774,
-0.0379532687,
0.0630048513,
-0.0445660874,
-0.0476207659,
-0.0425683893,
-0.0358576216,
-0.0220385455,
0.0695161223,
0.0073542185,
-0.0003123255,
-0.0129068401,
-0.0167852677,
-0.0592315346,
-0.0011080028,
-0.0133123957,
-0.053287942,
0.0260266066,
-0.0243336465,
-0.0091475463,
-0.0076676607,
-0.0581142716,
-0.0479290523,
-0.0335459858,
-0.0167492442,
0.0111396704,
-0.0095221,
-0.0274847988,
-0.0313662775,
-0.0073269154,
0.0130366255,
0.0180546846,
-0.0184241869,
0.0321044065,
-0.0171927214,
-0.0015651969,
0.0579329655,
0.0010951116,
0.0501750037,
-0.0416955054,
-0.0197523199,
0.0077554076,
0.0473571829,
0.0037039979,
-0.0120732123,
0.0344045982,
0.0428890921,
-0.0123352502,
-0.0174802523,
0.043636851,
0.0592520386,
-0.034346249,
-0.0034259434,
0.1159373522,
0.015649952,
-0.0166650116,
0.0187247358,
0.0227420945,
0.0565226153,
0.0271570552,
0.0143137267,
-0.0490918346,
-0.0204252191,
0.0366789252,
0.0635154322,
-0.0226330161,
-0.0023400458,
-0.0128618069,
-0.1220389977,
0.0288432166,
0.0270631667,
-0.0235886313,
-0.0111785084,
-0.0498414859,
0.0007399655,
-0.0211618785,
0.0467341132,
0.006109322,
-0.0162891243,
0.0136970002,
0.0362442397,
-0.0406001657,
-0.0506623201,
0.019192392,
-0.0305038281,
0.0690008923,
0.0463640615,
-0.0094355885,
-0.0412055291,
-0.0608568527,
0.0439566337,
0.0182354823,
-0.0235364512,
0.0032852921,
0.0500136316,
-0.0114740115,
-0.0115155634,
0.0181748923,
0.0675358623,
-0.032726828,
-0.028997492,
-0.0093458658,
0.044899717,
0.0037929977,
-0.0266199168,
-0.0101092663,
0.0335670523,
0.0065735416,
0.1103582755,
0.0509056449,
-0.0473846942,
0.0269081835,
-0.0297766365,
0.0067906445,
-0.0588346012,
-0.0361992531,
0.0042908974,
-0.0040874579,
-0.0275261998,
-0.0573473945,
-0.0287782494,
0.0313705355,
0.0483420976,
0.0019923621,
0.0174275916,
-0.0318310596,
-0.0211207587,
-0.0677593425,
0.061987482,
-0.0103349611,
0.0545985475,
-0.0749658048,
-0.078994222,
-0.0063266451,
-0.0282591265,
-0.032120198,
0.0059041902,
-0.1165789664,
-0.0717568845,
0.0501015335,
0.0536909811,
0.0340695344,
0.0624773614,
0.0108215306,
-0.0593583696,
0.0171549581,
0.0443666242,
-0.0409974717,
0.0580360368,
0.0591995902,
-0.0251113139,
0.0135776214,
0.0245239437,
-0.0367663018,
0.0335302427,
0.059969265,
0.0406589918,
-0.0009633028,
0.0161633808,
0.0203830507,
0.0061488631,
0.0851131305,
-0.0407501906,
-0.0096627986,
-0.0267603528,
0.0036231983,
-0.0167050753,
-0.0015069917,
-0.0333248861,
-0.0276039001,
0.0267316978,
0.0210942626,
-0.0212148726,
-0.0027645372,
-0.037781816,
-0.00275101,
-0.036135871,
0.0587335601,
-0.0080156466,
-0.0051021124,
0.0146251768,
0.0245000757,
0.0012498756,
0.029321555,
0.0024833374,
0.0117706191,
0.0224282797,
-0.0047246767,
0.0047497419,
0.0054707564,
-0.0490365177,
0.0141249336,
-0.0595413819,
0.0194125883,
0.0037956126,
0.0145828193,
0.0532635041,
-0.0062231342,
0.0212200508,
-0.0212022886,
-0.0221750643,
-0.0238059964,
0.0156698897,
-0.0245561954,
-0.0254792925,
0.0601104759,
0.0252093542,
-0.0217746869,
-0.0015624738,
0.0750190169,
0.0167282522,
0.0425654911,
0.0144836269,
0.0182397254,
-0.0353309363,
-0.0041617616,
0.0255715605,
0.0450083055,
-0.0208485108,
0.0269346125,
-0.0552261807,
-0.0846657678,
0.0300918017,
0.0051528546,
0.0237288307,
-0.0172611494,
0.0349542685,
0.0199562721,
-0.032811787,
0.0070166066,
-0.0172808599,
-0.0240213983,
0.0184465386,
-0.0381896831,
-0.0081454571,
-6.365434888e-33,
-0.0498266853,
0.0026122821,
0.0134703908,
0.0140278321,
-0.0247209705,
0.0041334671,
-0.0236579254,
0.0406274572,
0.0089989575,
-0.0061294031,
0.001776492,
-0.0086660096,
0.0289833453,
0.0121662952,
-0.0041602347,
-0.0065136473,
0.0595005713,
-0.0131074917,
-0.0268307347,
-0.0235187802,
0.0147691807,
0.0471571498,
0.0298308097,
-0.0717982873,
-0.01472406,
0.0169288348,
-0.0224531759,
0.003872222,
-0.0012136921,
0.0827260241,
-0.0431406274,
0.0236523114,
0.0052337642,
-0.0151464045,
-0.0478125103,
0.0175407678,
-0.0513572134,
-0.0025599569,
0.0144686755,
0.0382376313,
-0.0243039336,
-0.0419988707,
0.0663306862,
-0.0077429572,
-0.050560046,
0.0147043122,
0.0325428098,
-0.0631386116,
-0.0241357964,
-0.0162313245,
-0.0321790799,
0.0042494303,
0.0020988712,
-0.0276043471,
0.0508856475,
0.0194328427,
-0.0282888897,
0.0290507786,
-0.0280228015,
0.0266764108,
0.0457189828,
0.0615610667,
0.0687431246,
0.0579445176,
0.0328804776,
0.0693068653,
0.0595453233,
-0.0290545188,
0.0037358727,
0.0024958169,
0.0772713199,
0.0295130946,
0.0612087436,
0.0020579572,
0.0502756275,
-0.0172758065,
-0.0293260422,
0.0085472148,
0.0191581547,
-0.0250371806,
0.0054502124,
0.0455272831,
-0.0257546827,
-0.0020717741,
-0.0425083451,
-0.0171619765,
-0.0169397686,
-0.0257730577,
0.0381230637,
0.0176562071,
-0.0221053679,
-0.000428796,
0.027892461,
-0.0312263053,
-0.0221284572,
-0.0300567783,
-0.0105755692,
0.001416459,
0.0156262834,
0.001679218,
-0.0613014959,
-0.0051469496,
0.067139484,
0.0059988415,
0.0368036218,
-0.0289650969,
0.0613864996,
0.0411918312,
-0.0945742801,
0.0046616653,
-0.0282574948,
0.018447496,
0.0556386039,
0.044568982,
0.0470587537,
0.0148975095,
-0.0183344092,
0.0322841443,
0.012226481,
-0.0376764536,
-0.0324241631,
0.0097533138,
-0.0283061676,
0.0458422415,
-0.0259315874,
-0.0234618988,
-0.0053239102,
0.0030079486,
0.0481313616,
-0.02565361,
-0.0237262268,
0.006237431,
2.655e-7,
0.0145497853,
0.0240938067,
0.0176659785,
0.0268560238,
0.0156710781,
0.0129817752,
-0.0855874047,
0.0166062452,
0.0004499585,
-0.005856832,
-0.0098032178,
0.0162854102,
0.0902309567,
0.0168259535,
-0.0873160288,
-0.0126752444,
-0.0658448488,
0.0253098682,
-0.0685229152,
0.0091438582,
0.0174253248,
0.1216844469,
0.0466981158,
-0.0154449176,
0.0017189548,
-0.0160826724,
0.0415851884,
-0.048041638,
0.006896324,
-0.0640132651,
-0.008697642,
0.0214199349,
0.017510809,
0.0108708544,
-0.035067182,
0.0396214165,
0.0017827689,
0.0577769578,
0.0130851716,
-0.0447357371,
-0.0135785863,
0.0619372614,
-0.0394695848,
-0.034385927,
0.0631743446,
-0.010817606,
-0.047467608,
-0.0437246896,
-0.0713849142,
0.0042401943,
0.006200443,
-0.035037525,
-0.0458968505,
0.0060940199,
0.0287589934,
-0.0186296832,
-0.0050356505,
-0.0721257627,
-0.0224146415,
-0.0060141385,
-0.060057126,
-0.04424043,
-0.0436127298,
0.0358128771,
-0.0148694953,
-0.0709137022,
-0.0284033027,
2.806706051e-34,
0.0349897183,
-0.0301835183,
-0.0113588125,
0.0198363941,
0.0182511304,
-0.0270825122,
-0.013040185,
0.0126403142,
-0.0045982813,
-0.064622812,
-0.0178622548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17589v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17589v3 | An Open Source Data Contamination Report for Large Language Models | 2023-10-26T17:11:42 | 2024-01-29T02:11:01 | Yucheng Li, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data contamination in model evaluation has become increasingly prevalent with
the growing popularity of large language models. It allows models to "cheat"
via memorisation instead of displaying true capabilities. Therefore,
contamination analysis has become an crucial part of reliable model evaluation
to validate results. However, existing contamination analysis is usually
conducted internally by large language model developers and often lacks
transparency and completeness. This paper presents an extensive data
contamination report for over 15 popular large language models across six
popular multiple-choice QA benchmarks. We also introduce an open-source
pipeline that enables the community to perform contamination analysis on
customised data and models. Our experiments reveal varying contamination levels
ranging from 1\% to 45\% across benchmarks, with the contamination degree
increasing rapidly over time. Performance analysis of large language models
indicates that data contamination does not necessarily lead to increased model
metrics: while significant accuracy boosts of up to 14\% and 7\% are observed
on contaminated C-Eval and Hellaswag benchmarks, only a minimal increase is
noted on contaminated MMLU. We also find larger models seem able to gain more
advantages than smaller models on contaminated test sets. | [
0.0042673703,
0.0976595208,
-0.0281309076,
0.0410106443,
-0.0270094164,
-0.0023662855,
-0.0007166355,
-0.0242528487,
0.0025962563,
-0.0590299182,
-0.0111534344,
-0.0310769994,
0.0110272337,
0.0302642025,
0.0319138877,
0.0033984217,
0.0754300654,
-0.0411846749,
-0.0514703616,
-0.0040498124,
-0.0267879646,
-0.0073684379,
0.0180676915,
0.0384727456,
0.0194524694,
-0.0412802771,
-0.0090605663,
-0.033728987,
-0.0058113593,
-0.0269093886,
-0.0083795972,
0.0699389502,
-0.0356419235,
0.0487537868,
0.0000020573,
-0.0558842868,
-0.0087046679,
0.0172848701,
-0.0493751988,
0.0783219039,
0.0274127536,
0.0371769182,
-0.0180685017,
0.0457468331,
-0.0077628968,
-0.0041144257,
0.0470316112,
-0.0077871224,
0.0568524152,
0.0332448892,
0.0069549014,
0.044388786,
0.0279306881,
-0.0100351367,
-0.003278885,
-0.022141302,
0.0403969064,
0.0154696573,
0.0340785906,
0.0061273202,
-0.0308236945,
0.0448372364,
0.019248236,
-0.0040759509,
-0.041653011,
-0.0003536174,
-0.034554366,
-0.0320965126,
0.0332081206,
0.0536098331,
-0.0123759666,
-0.0067562857,
-0.0323134325,
-0.0178238414,
-0.005875608,
0.0171090774,
-0.0282937661,
0.0269316081,
0.0170234293,
-0.0188747346,
0.007297874,
-0.0515596159,
0.0397339724,
-0.0154109811,
-0.0171091892,
0.0805880055,
0.0511676334,
-0.0290441737,
-0.0012869057,
0.0000834825,
-0.017626496,
-0.0525598973,
-0.0259140432,
-0.0091578346,
-0.0365606025,
0.0476808548,
-0.0333396383,
-0.0473283194,
0.0536142886,
-0.0323171504,
0.0255764816,
0.0315754302,
-0.0224331226,
0.0139978714,
0.0229762848,
0.0595261343,
0.0056786882,
0.009643266,
-0.0343614817,
-0.0025529505,
0.0330551043,
-0.016170837,
0.0034898845,
0.0206264686,
-0.0123273619,
0.0173065756,
-0.0594161563,
0.0197066832,
-0.0440499336,
0.0133351814,
-0.0023297612,
0.0113927582,
-0.0217828676,
0.013058845,
-0.0109623112,
0.034450043,
-0.0280375071,
0.0168203507,
0.0285007507,
-0.0851523578,
-0.0066058682,
-0.0103592882,
-0.0138222463,
-0.0446404368,
0.0102144238,
0.0617634505,
0.0368848816,
-0.0237565171,
0.0171637442,
-0.008851476,
-0.0496082343,
-0.0535240211,
-0.021341946,
-0.0487042367,
0.0005866057,
0.0258092452,
0.0062882751,
-0.0367479846,
-0.0116100172,
0.0526717566,
-0.0329513289,
0.0327100046,
-0.0330927633,
-0.0002660794,
-0.0142917559,
0.0100537473,
0.0141288256,
0.0755329654,
0.0218374915,
0.0066633858,
0.0394976549,
-0.0622840635,
0.0253171772,
0.060062319,
0.0082421564,
0.0245995894,
-0.0252550114,
0.0111254957,
0.0321382396,
0.0057610441,
-0.0117538217,
0.0725106373,
-0.0039301538,
-0.0157351159,
0.0419253409,
0.0374059044,
0.0094543761,
-0.0079378979,
-0.0062741642,
0.0100388825,
0.0443817675,
-0.020335611,
-0.0611704215,
-0.0311094411,
-0.0262546539,
0.0107701179,
0.0032574201,
0.0545862578,
0.0012932484,
-0.0688215345,
-0.0490439311,
0.0045445049,
-0.0047538024,
0.0353077166,
0.0448753126,
-0.0136661744,
-0.0267014932,
0.0376305915,
0.018452961,
-0.0676615089,
0.0116470093,
-0.0383806191,
0.0577224828,
0.0470781662,
0.0570462719,
-0.0264262259,
-0.0538515523,
-0.0160603914,
-0.0177809726,
-0.0030298869,
0.0438479446,
-0.0251987427,
0.0090578971,
-0.0304372646,
-0.0400292724,
-0.0081300521,
0.0346480086,
0.0154443653,
0.0052011535,
0.0114573259,
0.004187135,
-0.0297328252,
-0.0539214313,
0.0279868748,
-0.0309860259,
-0.0180080272,
0.0026737659,
-0.0071972343,
0.0157586746,
0.0141841164,
-0.017142335,
0.0249673799,
0.028210083,
0.02392653,
0.0032716242,
-0.0193074103,
-0.028279148,
0.023942953,
0.0591897704,
0.0161772966,
-0.0199954808,
0.0710611418,
-0.0126743298,
-0.0365029909,
0.0088774692,
-0.0139176995,
0.0064460719,
-0.0069283941,
0.0606660023,
-0.033528816,
0.0236457102,
-0.0376073867,
0.0485836379,
0.0012860501,
0.0459254831,
0.0179282222,
0.0141606824,
0.0367375948,
-0.0165083446,
-0.0682261065,
0.0223375168,
-0.0312179103,
0.0323881209,
0.0195903629,
-0.0070264293,
-0.0667570159,
-0.0059583546,
-0.0758733004,
0.0073318905,
0.0000300748,
0.0246068854,
0.0148248505,
0.0157007314,
-0.013151031,
0.0219182465,
-0.0250136629,
-0.0566888005,
0.0338339694,
0.0561014302,
-0.010728552,
-0.0048622466,
-0.0084081339,
-0.0506884567,
-0.0316187441,
-0.0394399911,
0.0671805069,
-0.0145624271,
0.0095054721,
-0.043492116,
0.0672092363,
-0.0359853096,
0.0047510588,
0.0053182375,
-0.0353594571,
0.0138299381,
-0.0122989528,
0.0147043206,
0.046213232,
-0.014202036,
0.0128417034,
0.0685808882,
-0.0222181566,
-0.0495200381,
0.0035177788,
0.0360470377,
-0.0239708722,
-0.0088563822,
-0.0485970639,
-0.0023585183,
0.0568921231,
-0.0135175744,
-0.0444861762,
-0.0049645375,
0.037755955,
-0.0787352696,
-0.0269651953,
-0.0162523817,
-0.00684545,
-0.0416683555,
0.0392034538,
-0.0178353805,
-0.0330715179,
0.0325254649,
-0.0238845292,
0.0144291315,
-0.051706627,
0.0139622595,
-0.0090657752,
0.0214188546,
-0.0111388443,
0.0068236054,
-0.0120222019,
-0.0380935073,
-0.0549152605,
-0.0155871715,
0.0088357879,
-0.0656516477,
0.0576218106,
-0.0445576757,
-0.0015189867,
0.0103274146,
-0.0340204611,
-0.040566273,
-0.0294383317,
0.0097136348,
0.0068720924,
0.0243739355,
-0.0040707076,
0.0011787476,
-0.0206266455,
0.0008159229,
0.0021036686,
-0.0196675994,
0.010274509,
-0.0013284249,
0.0288540423,
0.068104662,
-0.0146929985,
0.0455590896,
-0.0350010544,
0.0235589724,
0.0545998141,
0.0667498112,
0.0297166854,
-0.002759346,
-0.0044514718,
0.0432864539,
-0.0155433863,
-0.0322534628,
0.0430467092,
0.050286267,
-0.0865498111,
-0.0104134204,
0.0799703896,
0.0323178135,
0.018863542,
0.0078755794,
-0.0213343538,
0.0316732973,
0.0309434813,
0.0319780335,
-0.100286074,
0.0123805702,
0.025875235,
0.0126869306,
0.0008009948,
-0.0345943421,
0.0075415219,
-0.1386889219,
0.0379608646,
-0.0014534558,
-0.0616352558,
-0.0168173742,
-0.0405743457,
0.0015156702,
-0.0320214555,
0.0847124979,
0.0244979709,
-0.013514936,
0.0097236242,
0.0152533166,
-0.0417847112,
-0.0759764984,
0.060568653,
-0.0173941609,
0.0506430045,
0.0452847667,
0.0055408515,
-0.0548657961,
-0.0180774201,
0.0564128719,
-0.0366995297,
-0.0175411925,
0.0039465735,
0.0366518311,
0.025046492,
-0.0352748185,
0.0002321868,
-0.0010521808,
-0.0117736906,
-0.000243466,
0.009056231,
0.0816751346,
0.004449476,
-0.0218556523,
-0.0076220459,
-0.0476223864,
-0.0177129097,
0.0733049214,
0.0269482527,
-0.067606926,
-0.0206394382,
-0.0468790755,
-0.0122295562,
-0.0274405908,
0.0058646677,
0.0503423996,
-0.0152530735,
-0.0520271026,
-0.0362542681,
-0.0934994742,
0.0595200136,
0.019023018,
0.019185042,
0.0453431606,
-0.0295440815,
-0.011187817,
-0.0091130259,
0.06114503,
-0.0320453234,
0.0422278941,
-0.0507970303,
0.0453704335,
-0.0278005935,
0.0413475409,
-0.0329775549,
0.0258064158,
-0.1230252758,
-0.0776338354,
0.0463724732,
0.0685492083,
0.0239383616,
0.008243165,
-0.0095883831,
-0.0619603433,
0.0027983114,
-0.0158578455,
-0.051924672,
0.0179485679,
0.0187129173,
-0.0607257597,
-0.0032233912,
0.0118519366,
-0.0370785482,
-0.0134231066,
0.0182870235,
0.0407086425,
-0.0252037067,
0.0024657459,
0.0284601115,
0.0403642952,
0.0310298279,
0.0062050838,
-0.0168079212,
-0.0384491943,
0.0166893788,
-0.0646127611,
-0.0302871056,
-0.0251012389,
0.0153037328,
0.0352193899,
-0.0181332529,
-0.011805838,
-0.0221206322,
-0.0381609537,
0.052711308,
-0.035936866,
0.0451563969,
0.0274868384,
0.0246509667,
0.072904475,
0.0083365142,
-0.01120276,
0.0024406037,
-0.0000445603,
0.0575795211,
0.0056602592,
0.0288287699,
-0.016315477,
0.0159773733,
0.0335870273,
0.0209417213,
-0.0379287824,
-0.0468067154,
-0.0170420948,
0.01814932,
0.009983357,
0.0009032951,
0.0469349027,
0.0011301248,
-0.0064225751,
-0.0313201211,
-0.0125729684,
-0.0001536871,
-0.0288605969,
0.0471755676,
0.0150809651,
-0.0222578682,
0.0076665566,
0.0738363415,
0.011796033,
0.050027892,
-0.0377739184,
0.0058156676,
-0.0208321474,
-0.0013296442,
0.0270082559,
0.0222107712,
-0.0347869545,
-0.0315351263,
-0.078988567,
-0.1248922572,
0.0015209985,
0.0231067128,
-0.0073137521,
-0.0030001907,
-0.0112706171,
0.0740578473,
-0.0035127753,
0.0046654665,
-0.0460219942,
-0.0079250829,
-0.004242633,
-0.0331047662,
0.018960882,
-6.114912429e-33,
0.0115472255,
-0.0231528152,
0.0141198058,
-0.0560205206,
0.009150181,
0.0218188167,
-0.013288632,
0.0136321615,
-0.0479967073,
0.0060392655,
-0.0362813659,
0.0279257894,
0.0060966462,
0.0213850718,
0.0248481911,
0.0026585872,
0.0277144387,
0.0152989589,
-0.0345906317,
0.0052878987,
0.0173196588,
0.0043543829,
0.0573828146,
-0.0404236764,
0.0518367067,
-0.0166260824,
-0.0119843315,
-0.0094174696,
-0.0540829822,
0.077393122,
0.0041395933,
0.0458085053,
0.0123279886,
-0.0477516279,
-0.0154932104,
-0.0100187184,
-0.0339921415,
-0.0457840264,
0.0201958679,
0.0159836467,
-0.0127584441,
-0.0412576459,
0.064032346,
-0.0078972559,
-0.0286880061,
0.0010262837,
0.0120819975,
-0.0310545918,
-0.0469032861,
0.0059676305,
-0.0278964266,
0.0124075981,
-0.0129108177,
0.0348761752,
-0.0092305578,
0.0804006681,
0.0141164577,
0.0129962787,
-0.0062858206,
-0.0004087399,
0.0567590706,
0.0432043001,
0.0919036716,
0.022234397,
0.0043969266,
0.0567725822,
0.0195394978,
0.0209926888,
0.0519716404,
-0.0182737038,
0.043432638,
0.0288342573,
0.0526141301,
0.0530363694,
0.0255739503,
-0.0153753366,
-0.0475789197,
0.0313573703,
-0.0115843555,
0.048282776,
-0.010158103,
-0.0297269356,
-0.0609798692,
-0.0346121751,
-0.0774419531,
0.0238433313,
-0.05287439,
-0.0255803075,
0.082874544,
-0.0481708683,
-0.0365137048,
0.0186485015,
0.0182478633,
-0.036512699,
-0.0610406809,
0.0230677705,
-0.0235192943,
0.0240698997,
-0.0322518609,
0.0648915097,
-0.041564703,
0.0123014096,
-0.0116876848,
-0.0204528235,
0.0222592521,
0.0116913011,
0.0006264395,
0.0127633996,
-0.0949207246,
0.0046319384,
-0.016181428,
0.0209594425,
0.03404833,
0.0239162073,
0.0470157564,
-0.0011320097,
0.0225854088,
0.0244755782,
0.047824081,
0.022938,
-0.0353807285,
-0.0187267791,
0.0029510311,
-0.0176444389,
0.0074156863,
-0.0476626605,
-0.0307288133,
0.0494864471,
0.0457686484,
-0.0516399033,
-0.0034106688,
-0.000564072,
2.653e-7,
0.0707271397,
0.0539333858,
-0.0055294898,
0.025492996,
-0.0018644503,
0.0156541634,
-0.0387950204,
-0.013991545,
0.0456150398,
0.0445327424,
-0.0209911913,
-0.0356073454,
0.0359871723,
0.046623148,
-0.0737092569,
0.0073138746,
-0.0296099242,
-0.0049466779,
-0.0840756968,
0.0089003155,
0.0081840605,
0.120422639,
0.0066989451,
-0.0327195637,
-0.0380954258,
-0.0478082336,
0.0184304602,
-0.0313291959,
-0.0476793125,
0.0571833067,
0.0508858375,
0.0006291489,
0.0470665209,
0.0090044737,
-0.0203376822,
0.0007578752,
0.0214610677,
0.0154149411,
-0.0188488327,
-0.0122867972,
0.0000536225,
-0.0670049265,
-0.01795182,
-0.0727748275,
0.0808166638,
0.0006210254,
-0.0102734314,
-0.0502140373,
-0.0542411394,
-0.0488896444,
0.0525521524,
-0.0330894738,
0.0104080644,
0.0012380718,
-0.0071736746,
-0.020486692,
-0.0124210278,
-0.0186419729,
-0.0163193084,
-0.013886502,
-0.0073788711,
-0.075842306,
-0.0115206875,
-0.0397088267,
-0.0018289472,
-0.0672314465,
0.0213887729,
2.778034549e-34,
0.0517765917,
-0.0317865536,
0.0431173518,
0.0031690081,
0.0343932919,
-0.0143432254,
0.026766438,
0.0274869669,
-0.0164013132,
-0.0793024898,
-0.0274694245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17588v1 | PAC-tuning:Fine-tuning Pretrained Language Models with PAC-driven Perturbed Gradient Descent | 2023-10-26T17:09:13 | 2023-10-26T17:09:13 | Guangliang Liu, Zhiyu Xue, Xitong Zhang, Kristen Marie Johnson, Rongrong Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Fine-tuning pretrained language models (PLMs) for downstream tasks is a
large-scale optimization problem, in which the choice of the training algorithm
critically determines how well the trained model can generalize to unseen test
data, especially in the context of few-shot learning. To achieve good
generalization performance and avoid overfitting, techniques such as data
augmentation and pruning are often applied. However, adding these
regularizations necessitates heavy tuning of the hyperparameters of
optimization algorithms, such as the popular Adam optimizer. In this paper, we
propose a two-stage fine-tuning method, PAC-tuning, to address this
optimization challenge. First, based on PAC-Bayes training, PAC-tuning directly
minimizes the PAC-Bayes generalization bound to learn proper parameter
distribution. Second, PAC-tuning modifies the gradient by injecting noise with
the variance learned in the first stage into the model parameters during
training, resulting in a variant of perturbed gradient descent (PGD). In the
past, the few-shot scenario posed difficulties for PAC-Bayes training because
the PAC-Bayes bound, when applied to large models with limited training data,
might not be stringent. Our experimental results across 5 GLUE benchmark tasks
demonstrate that PAC-tuning successfully handles the challenges of fine-tuning
tasks and outperforms strong baseline methods by a visible margin, further
confirming the potential to apply PAC training for any other settings where the
Adam optimizer is currently used for training. | [
0.0049232678,
0.0834953636,
0.0026071758,
0.0272684768,
0.0209582895,
0.0186173096,
0.0158613343,
-0.0035270171,
-0.0635525659,
-0.0333618484,
-0.055182375,
-0.0252161045,
-0.0049973847,
-0.0172715057,
0.0548485294,
-0.0393595323,
0.0487575792,
0.0078513706,
0.0282329153,
-0.0030025896,
0.0082248803,
0.0103986328,
-0.0120113194,
0.0547317751,
-0.01356705,
0.0238949675,
0.0067949463,
0.0223341007,
0.003310832,
-0.0038041144,
0.0281690825,
0.0707816705,
0.0210743938,
0.0201561134,
0.0000021439,
-0.0512196682,
-0.0020267791,
0.0105092572,
-0.0271456335,
0.0361607485,
0.0039452063,
-0.0079939403,
-0.0011448503,
0.0151919536,
-0.0237445831,
-0.0922149271,
0.0437826104,
-0.0027321316,
0.0619949736,
0.1150048152,
-0.0044506374,
-0.0462400131,
0.0069516823,
-0.058036115,
-0.0093477936,
-0.0954816118,
0.0221085083,
-0.0420879796,
0.0026670506,
-0.025429653,
-0.0249522552,
-0.0055322242,
-0.0025584556,
0.0335694328,
0.0119233886,
0.0273731947,
-0.0633974597,
-0.0137040755,
0.0053348788,
0.0535933562,
-0.0605216697,
-0.0510099828,
-0.0133268954,
-0.0367462002,
-0.0216953401,
-0.0108265281,
-0.0330293588,
-0.0204146095,
0.0396435708,
0.0330693237,
-0.0090528009,
-0.0300244447,
0.046315033,
0.0161300711,
-0.0375487097,
0.024449002,
0.0141646964,
-0.000106375,
0.0011937895,
0.005260135,
-0.0217984468,
-0.0212023295,
-0.0025113963,
0.0174166691,
-0.0304612722,
0.006227022,
-0.0749951228,
-0.0660770908,
-0.0074615474,
-0.0254574735,
0.0892582238,
0.0475776568,
-0.0101826228,
0.0621659681,
-0.0186051745,
0.0338108353,
0.0142785106,
0.0254961234,
-0.0361387208,
0.0093893511,
-0.0192368291,
0.0147984773,
-0.0719166622,
0.015363697,
-0.0035351734,
-0.0144715821,
-0.033865016,
-0.0178462137,
0.0487358533,
-0.0139757628,
0.0332187451,
-0.0112689212,
-0.0464804545,
-0.0391881727,
0.0260298457,
0.0587655567,
-0.0781195089,
0.033556886,
0.0110992463,
-0.0305490028,
-0.0265231691,
-0.0056208353,
0.0338155366,
-0.0259206388,
0.0269330572,
0.054852467,
-0.0125578046,
-0.0511288419,
-0.0741495416,
0.0131204454,
-0.0012872253,
-0.0568060726,
0.0002019595,
-0.0406622514,
0.0452826172,
-0.0258595832,
0.0035518066,
-0.0503337942,
0.0013660841,
-0.0268456116,
-0.0278042555,
0.0588422567,
-0.0082454709,
-0.002854523,
-0.0100321909,
-0.0028351748,
0.0106540015,
0.1038286835,
0.0329569653,
0.0327071473,
0.0339921974,
-0.0062036845,
-0.0115056578,
0.0511966497,
0.0415088832,
-0.0030295986,
-0.0362139121,
-0.0201636013,
0.0057428996,
0.0077884877,
0.021984702,
0.0067576938,
-0.0690073371,
-0.015276067,
0.0502263606,
0.0341148116,
0.0403992161,
0.0230965856,
0.009907132,
-0.0239212308,
0.0319567584,
-0.0255890451,
-0.0524877384,
-0.0079560904,
-0.0189990476,
0.0034693084,
-0.001956956,
0.0386915207,
-0.0413212441,
-0.0298221726,
0.0186545737,
-0.0289238486,
-0.0373356231,
0.0210206937,
0.0651046261,
0.011438611,
-0.0452485047,
0.0484464429,
0.0420466661,
-0.0169852246,
0.0290488526,
-0.0412788056,
-0.0203681104,
0.0450121462,
0.0324241817,
-0.0412885621,
-0.0643841401,
-0.000173246,
0.0439244136,
0.0170949083,
0.0162439607,
0.004794992,
0.0612895079,
-0.058064349,
-0.0353606194,
-0.0105555337,
0.0335881747,
0.0217132363,
0.0258239284,
0.0109097809,
0.0148252388,
-0.0035350199,
-0.0153056188,
0.0516431369,
-0.0380448475,
-0.0467683263,
0.0307121053,
0.0153327389,
0.0138949146,
0.0211071949,
-0.034386307,
-0.0104496125,
0.0233823955,
-0.0199383348,
0.0175346173,
-0.0129669188,
-0.0212264396,
-0.0341066979,
0.04545708,
-0.0113948872,
0.0292026065,
0.0060048592,
-0.0538398325,
-0.0481083915,
0.0226836707,
-0.0137371197,
0.0705894157,
-0.0220521819,
0.0474467427,
-0.0429189466,
0.0124002481,
-0.0308449194,
-0.0084630251,
0.0020834238,
-0.0131535623,
-0.053524904,
0.0259682965,
0.0313323811,
0.004147667,
-0.0375950858,
-0.0177963153,
-0.0125241941,
0.0203393735,
0.017965233,
0.0290197004,
-0.0090069128,
-0.0068800696,
-0.0386085995,
0.0247638468,
-0.0382527411,
0.0131674539,
0.0193212647,
0.0055686119,
-0.0244671945,
-0.0242147129,
0.0159063973,
0.008646071,
-0.0266636927,
-0.0050414084,
0.0220852103,
0.0075875008,
0.0105783073,
-0.0580346771,
-0.0289093833,
0.0082668466,
0.0344774537,
-0.0217658114,
-0.033274807,
-0.025744576,
0.0266213808,
-0.0280024894,
0.0344080217,
-0.0116833244,
-0.0714059621,
-0.0001255732,
-0.0301445927,
-0.0205855388,
0.1061821878,
-0.0212914124,
-0.0092532681,
0.013596002,
0.0041498272,
-0.043294806,
0.0195562802,
-0.0332837813,
-0.0081424974,
-0.0524256639,
0.0229938067,
0.0111104418,
0.081314832,
-0.0556029789,
0.0066225091,
-0.0585024767,
0.0323926918,
-0.0202789959,
-0.022705242,
0.0027325877,
0.009197955,
-0.0135781048,
0.0252891276,
-0.0149606885,
-0.0315724462,
0.0537621006,
-0.0360414311,
-0.0044540237,
-0.0389689393,
-0.0067857052,
-0.0330142193,
0.0314672738,
0.0291657727,
0.0240295399,
-0.0211120136,
-0.0149599258,
-0.0562180355,
-0.0077038528,
0.0202715471,
-0.0106109967,
0.0221326556,
-0.0022017921,
0.0112872515,
-0.0088720387,
-0.0465325974,
-0.0128198778,
-0.0121335303,
-0.039208848,
0.0176879559,
0.0066489032,
-0.0532447174,
-0.0339900553,
0.008008372,
-0.0302408487,
0.0718077719,
-0.0038641151,
0.0135622602,
-0.0431994237,
0.0178427212,
0.0617215149,
-0.0325514488,
0.0070312647,
-0.00771413,
-0.0252893511,
0.0157675836,
0.0244673155,
-0.0130804628,
-0.041222699,
0.0041855942,
0.016025966,
-0.0263247527,
-0.0183730405,
0.0061325999,
0.0402210616,
-0.0686939806,
-0.0027220554,
0.0943305418,
0.0313740596,
-0.0575756878,
0.0026983868,
0.0466099195,
0.0336716622,
0.0235812534,
0.0367495716,
-0.0722608566,
-0.0534537733,
0.0068400879,
0.0363073125,
0.0180676132,
-0.0024344353,
-0.0122964485,
-0.1264812499,
-0.0200262032,
0.0262696911,
-0.0668601766,
0.0172347687,
-0.0396631211,
0.0030956895,
-0.0586778261,
0.0611051209,
0.0062409677,
0.0107355975,
-0.004982247,
0.0199283306,
0.0275817811,
-0.1048937067,
-0.0193743203,
-0.0656168461,
0.0623789877,
0.0483035073,
-0.0144713372,
-0.0067890985,
0.0123924203,
0.0857840329,
0.0364631414,
0.0039391499,
-0.0104751056,
0.0290332232,
-0.0279674437,
-0.0129326703,
0.032784719,
0.0217879117,
-0.0139378514,
0.0078950189,
0.0037641507,
0.0531694256,
0.0272055343,
-0.0100510912,
0.0102626048,
-0.0240536444,
-0.0293761604,
0.0400760621,
0.0453837365,
-0.0393999107,
-0.0523227006,
-0.0148022156,
0.0004969529,
-0.0573270097,
0.0139422929,
-0.0104202703,
-0.0233100764,
-0.0405328013,
-0.0527961068,
-0.0188998692,
0.0507860146,
0.0497787669,
-0.0228158385,
-0.0116282357,
0.0231254566,
0.0161760189,
-0.0440521799,
0.0306007508,
-0.0191914029,
0.0084707802,
-0.0479820929,
-0.0164959226,
0.0507305041,
0.0100548957,
-0.0178322233,
0.0007605309,
-0.0845475644,
-0.0891770944,
0.004998323,
0.0719230548,
0.0124456007,
0.0591337718,
-0.0461805314,
-0.1137383953,
0.0316061564,
0.0724815428,
-0.0096664913,
0.000525934,
0.0491867363,
-0.0472306274,
-0.0025671157,
0.0296135657,
-0.0435276441,
0.0402812548,
0.0367387645,
0.0393771678,
-0.0145217311,
-0.0014682662,
-0.0041510905,
0.0000829278,
0.0378152803,
-0.0270032734,
-0.0024498561,
-0.0308823977,
0.0446792319,
-0.0076297419,
0.0167504828,
-0.0324530602,
-0.0177595168,
0.0219231676,
-0.0019787138,
-0.010008499,
-0.0123170288,
-0.0123853143,
0.0394463167,
-0.0390928388,
0.0208334085,
0.0124809751,
0.0107080769,
0.0376095399,
-0.0019558161,
0.0080416566,
0.0709505156,
0.0184123144,
0.0288980287,
-0.0632879585,
0.0073746126,
0.012281552,
0.0097954348,
-0.0673654005,
0.020644052,
-0.046843797,
-0.0234092064,
-0.0710824952,
0.0696539506,
0.0634278804,
-0.0109124333,
0.0349262916,
0.0002609883,
-0.0362824053,
0.0126854666,
0.0039765239,
-0.0062438431,
-0.0012813931,
0.0006193012,
0.0223309956,
0.0018501045,
0.0349749513,
0.0954945534,
0.0119218668,
0.0512789562,
-0.0202211048,
0.0241012406,
-0.0282431748,
-0.0254061129,
0.0179846603,
0.0618852116,
-0.031175172,
0.0028789504,
0.0007883862,
-0.0680204481,
-0.0466272719,
-0.0035443995,
0.0088029159,
-0.0000624193,
0.0411876366,
0.030119827,
-0.0162805784,
0.0049316981,
-0.0028266467,
-0.0442249179,
0.0027680802,
-0.0032851372,
0.0156921819,
-6.691398736e-33,
-0.0281380266,
0.0340402685,
-0.0012210055,
0.0138534382,
-0.0412702821,
-0.0140615636,
-0.0182024334,
0.0020446084,
-0.0277279355,
-0.0044126031,
-0.03016272,
0.0085491762,
0.0181780159,
0.0434556864,
-0.0228269957,
0.0046755322,
0.0610298626,
-0.0258639436,
-0.0205554366,
0.0189008545,
-0.0293654818,
0.0465273894,
0.0547091216,
0.0377806202,
-0.0663882568,
0.0055232681,
-0.0278723799,
0.0436311141,
0.0383712538,
0.0465732664,
0.0087228203,
-0.0033617218,
0.0023385431,
0.0078527546,
-0.0140177822,
-0.0044765347,
-0.0687268823,
-0.0263300352,
0.009819217,
0.0348668136,
-0.0006097218,
0.0152801136,
0.0339088291,
-0.0332076587,
-0.0128953513,
0.0017820207,
0.0063978289,
-0.0268680025,
-0.0460886657,
-0.0514630973,
-0.0398930795,
0.0247749183,
-0.0058726701,
0.014212545,
0.036278028,
0.0165514164,
-0.0226680413,
0.042408172,
-0.0295280069,
0.0039576548,
0.0553909279,
0.0471000969,
0.0379635617,
0.0764107406,
0.0018662743,
0.0188387297,
0.0540537313,
0.0204208344,
0.0012941036,
0.0200965535,
0.0966414213,
0.0142267728,
0.0377099924,
0.0357169807,
0.0487754829,
0.0000328801,
-0.087937057,
-0.0108394418,
0.0600520521,
0.0267643351,
0.0112888385,
0.039338775,
-0.0197041668,
-0.0192418173,
-0.0742468908,
-0.0604326874,
-0.0268219877,
-0.0208285879,
0.0075001228,
0.045681674,
-0.0722352713,
0.0192953311,
0.0274903048,
-0.0486039035,
0.0251417514,
0.0038479571,
-0.0168376435,
0.0060475715,
-0.0004138251,
0.0380453803,
-0.0768881217,
-0.0512649566,
0.0236658454,
-0.0009554705,
0.02197304,
-0.0278672315,
0.0579641201,
0.0223066043,
-0.0550021119,
-0.0027361463,
-0.0173585564,
0.014460911,
0.0504893959,
0.0516540706,
0.0439297222,
0.0094203902,
0.0077796248,
0.0369357616,
0.047413867,
0.0104325349,
0.0108062839,
0.0322818495,
0.0283671767,
0.0079592634,
-0.0131768305,
0.008363355,
-0.0151038505,
-0.0075983726,
0.0252522528,
-0.0963109881,
-0.0272928942,
-0.0010928297,
2.768e-7,
0.0370359048,
0.0507261492,
-0.0144794434,
-0.0041344506,
0.0203242525,
-0.0081506614,
-0.016636461,
-0.0023106239,
-0.0076460242,
0.0171012226,
0.0352481045,
0.0230850037,
0.0440767072,
0.0236958321,
-0.0788530931,
0.018964598,
-0.0514512472,
0.0234494209,
-0.0550453886,
-0.0415636264,
-0.0012512648,
0.123740308,
0.0203265678,
-0.0287536364,
0.0262947436,
-0.0649726987,
0.0544454902,
-0.0068764272,
-0.003535195,
0.0528945588,
-0.0404814631,
0.065548487,
-0.0131953843,
-0.0074584894,
-0.0410052985,
0.0567641146,
-0.0381499939,
0.0680554286,
-0.0325958021,
-0.0243461523,
0.0271056294,
0.0020240797,
-0.0080601927,
-0.0470983125,
0.0824901238,
-0.0874258429,
-0.0011221054,
-0.0462321453,
-0.0048862663,
-0.0212415829,
0.039684888,
-0.0629771352,
-0.0165761299,
0.0187811628,
0.0517554283,
-0.0105773574,
-0.0479655489,
-0.0919594541,
-0.0134885004,
0.0498648211,
0.0059158122,
-0.0039551714,
-0.0318214409,
-0.0337041654,
0.0135504752,
-0.0239595715,
0.0135863135,
2.598050982e-34,
0.0588568337,
-0.0413271822,
0.0244363695,
0.0074688843,
0.0233131275,
-0.0000736959,
-0.0300270487,
0.0201674495,
0.0196319222,
-0.0705509335,
-0.0025445884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17586v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17586v1 | Global Voices, Local Biases: Socio-Cultural Prejudices across Languages | 2023-10-26T17:07:50 | 2023-10-26T17:07:50 | Anjishnu Mukherjee, Chahat Raj, Ziwei Zhu, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human biases are ubiquitous but not uniform: disparities exist across
linguistic, cultural, and societal borders. As large amounts of recent
literature suggest, language models (LMs) trained on human data can reflect and
often amplify the effects of these social biases. However, the vast majority of
existing studies on bias are heavily skewed towards Western and European
languages. In this work, we scale the Word Embedding Association Test (WEAT) to
24 languages, enabling broader studies and yielding interesting findings about
LM bias. We additionally enhance this data with culturally relevant information
for each language, capturing local contexts on a global scale. Further, to
encompass more widely prevalent societal biases, we examine new bias dimensions
across toxicity, ableism, and more. Moreover, we delve deeper into the Indian
linguistic landscape, conducting a comprehensive regional bias analysis across
six prevalent Indian languages. Finally, we highlight the significance of these
social biases and the new dimensions through an extensive comparison of
embedding methods, reinforcing the need to address them in pursuit of more
equitable language models. All code, data and results are available here:
https://github.com/iamshnoo/weathub. | [
0.0097088236,
0.0672764406,
-0.0411467217,
0.0416838937,
-0.0047597676,
0.0391111337,
0.0413122475,
-0.0301335342,
0.0607188344,
0.0012313012,
-0.0220588222,
-0.0278688539,
0.0289705191,
-0.0036060561,
0.0470195264,
-0.043016687,
0.0466440395,
0.0622349717,
0.0273607746,
-0.0343332775,
0.0240316167,
0.0322607532,
0.0062975995,
0.0681493804,
-0.021611359,
0.008826009,
0.066956833,
-0.0426062047,
0.0194511879,
-0.0343538485,
0.0093106804,
0.0662550777,
-0.0014400441,
0.0366893634,
0.0000018879,
-0.0410592817,
0.0247122627,
-0.0085748816,
0.0373728573,
0.01123848,
0.0611129887,
-0.0263208747,
0.0038698888,
0.0367972106,
-0.0321623422,
-0.0285048299,
0.0649565831,
-0.0245925765,
-0.0048697139,
0.0363083556,
-0.0230055023,
-0.0141313514,
-0.024133632,
-0.0200973507,
-0.023075467,
0.0104092089,
0.060984578,
-0.0263086352,
-0.0423917174,
-0.0196975786,
-0.0707189366,
-0.0000596014,
0.012622362,
0.0204583127,
0.0107523315,
-0.0111641539,
-0.0257563386,
-0.0694850758,
0.0649331957,
0.0516889356,
-0.0005224795,
-0.0218877904,
-0.0028402403,
0.0195936598,
-0.0532526001,
0.0185396113,
-0.0121514844,
0.0320329443,
0.0180118382,
0.0326591283,
0.0352670103,
0.0384476781,
-0.0040943138,
0.0463953428,
0.0503339954,
0.0420270935,
0.033606302,
-0.0188366454,
-0.019852845,
0.0070704711,
-0.0247833133,
-0.0095673576,
0.0051327394,
-0.0237686671,
-0.0101743769,
0.0257525407,
-0.0151011487,
-0.0245280191,
0.0472295731,
-0.0462871976,
-0.0142048392,
0.0414183363,
-0.0397743322,
-0.0062155221,
0.009373297,
0.0200618505,
0.0067407931,
0.0341143161,
0.0124208014,
-0.0001387771,
0.0311405603,
-0.0272289347,
0.0669448376,
-0.0685155615,
-0.0033200879,
0.050832212,
-0.0730789751,
0.0060917432,
-0.0642688721,
-0.0188254137,
-0.0068007289,
-0.0094899256,
0.0124011971,
-0.0099067315,
-0.0064068669,
0.0045455857,
-0.0758014992,
0.0140206637,
-0.0669019744,
-0.0691153333,
0.0187746007,
0.0106697511,
-0.0479520261,
-0.0331913382,
-0.0195669569,
0.0323856287,
0.0148076881,
-0.0189647842,
-0.010441822,
0.0271719024,
-0.0334635936,
-0.0292230994,
-0.0224479698,
-0.0422093831,
0.0523108989,
0.0122590819,
0.0022735836,
-0.0801009908,
-0.0173287652,
0.0278971996,
-0.0703403577,
0.0411349609,
0.0206000004,
0.022496758,
0.0771013051,
0.0557594821,
0.003157994,
0.0455971807,
0.0082984008,
-0.0298066717,
0.0590637848,
-0.0232030544,
-0.0025141977,
0.0338911004,
0.0203461032,
-0.0000684655,
-0.0582943484,
0.02983105,
0.0082394136,
-0.030434534,
0.0546768419,
0.0260535143,
-0.0018381007,
-0.0215475578,
0.020434957,
0.0871580616,
-0.0183969252,
0.0290191527,
-0.0268433187,
0.043487139,
-0.0316035599,
-0.0365371965,
-0.0674068779,
-0.0291987788,
-0.0002303315,
-0.0428254902,
0.0512814932,
0.0527642332,
-0.0073421015,
0.0272810031,
-0.0355325863,
0.0104286708,
0.0679642335,
-0.0267847832,
0.0064468398,
-0.0133194616,
0.0120552341,
-0.0358302183,
0.1017717198,
-0.065021351,
0.0194930397,
-0.0268203877,
0.042062629,
-0.0077165877,
0.0008986431,
-0.0031368586,
0.0561670139,
0.0058122901,
-0.0163436756,
0.0531888939,
0.0069691273,
-0.007051799,
0.001097555,
-0.0294775441,
-0.0019435727,
0.0604082681,
0.0102462145,
0.0082109394,
0.0227490254,
0.0426224135,
-0.000478015,
-0.0364478342,
-0.0227147825,
0.0285137352,
-0.0285362191,
-0.0161023438,
-0.0307446364,
0.0140115414,
0.0198620874,
-0.0032400424,
-0.0500472523,
-0.0330947675,
-0.0211589672,
-0.0006599202,
-0.0092334971,
0.0471080504,
-0.0611996613,
-0.0069447025,
-0.0092754252,
-0.0804860741,
0.0060513811,
0.0374312326,
-0.0016834129,
0.0016010563,
0.0659842342,
0.0131366551,
0.0232469365,
-0.0165767968,
-0.0015868833,
-0.0710474104,
0.0292921364,
-0.0307026245,
0.0388242044,
-0.0238631368,
0.009907648,
-0.0196684916,
-0.0183540862,
0.0639397129,
-0.0010929102,
-0.0548770204,
0.0091188625,
0.0070525035,
-0.0061082751,
0.011168641,
-0.002356559,
-0.0138151795,
0.0007590575,
-0.1268061996,
-0.0313074999,
0.0081933327,
-0.0166132655,
-0.0263778716,
0.0167582147,
-0.0403300524,
-0.0037931385,
-0.0166219808,
-0.0289701317,
0.0374875218,
0.0647691563,
-0.0007251385,
-0.0794489905,
-0.0001410595,
-0.0309890341,
-0.039721787,
-0.0409023762,
0.0622005351,
-0.0229664687,
-0.0302665699,
0.0098183583,
-0.0119521115,
-0.0634352714,
-0.0110663185,
-0.0254176762,
-0.04982467,
-0.0011741439,
0.0689793527,
0.0432318933,
0.0405588448,
0.0166565739,
-0.00147763,
0.0612005405,
0.0102256285,
-0.0352934003,
-0.0466454811,
0.0215493422,
0.0384564064,
0.0101011144,
-0.0915587097,
-0.0450215638,
0.0929240286,
0.0284378752,
-0.0265954416,
-0.0566037521,
0.0251393355,
-0.0828441978,
-0.017521169,
-0.017099075,
-0.0292829014,
-0.0250658114,
0.0337160155,
-0.0510263667,
-0.082760334,
0.0370007753,
0.020275984,
0.0188953821,
-0.008538059,
-0.0036504231,
-0.0147354463,
0.0213152878,
0.0148044331,
0.0263030697,
-0.0153577011,
-0.0174866151,
-0.0527408458,
-0.0349297337,
0.0067058653,
-0.0281336103,
0.0125700915,
-0.0315972157,
-0.0075550587,
-0.0278313067,
-0.0409874097,
-0.0301371329,
-0.0492172316,
-0.0138293067,
-0.0135749122,
0.0219520405,
-0.0149643216,
0.0296920277,
0.0350385793,
-0.0027087065,
-0.0239329673,
-0.0051129647,
0.029313663,
0.025012251,
-0.0389181226,
0.0551769659,
-0.0118566528,
0.0656381547,
0.0277654361,
0.0189012531,
-0.0055731842,
0.0240332317,
0.0188479051,
0.0260193106,
0.0195052996,
0.0178231094,
0.0029433179,
-0.0039001487,
-0.0015332017,
0.0569400527,
0.0346129462,
0.0241795871,
0.0529407673,
0.0272990745,
-0.0368254595,
0.0351475291,
-0.0468053818,
0.0213716272,
0.036946848,
0.0122477142,
-0.1149280295,
0.0155577241,
0.0135930758,
-0.0051171002,
-0.0525205433,
-0.0393791907,
-0.0108229723,
-0.0662064478,
-0.0119071808,
0.0039155697,
0.0141256209,
-0.013976763,
-0.0370480902,
0.0029215012,
-0.0137766069,
0.0519836545,
0.0103791943,
0.0023642539,
-0.0072987503,
0.0060120765,
-0.0868381783,
-0.0279122647,
0.0272707883,
-0.034237925,
0.0540842153,
-0.0138420546,
0.0237902291,
-0.0275545456,
-0.0152343931,
0.0206609853,
-0.0211357977,
-0.0705168173,
-0.0164700877,
0.0265013464,
-0.0078740688,
-0.0350955054,
-0.0321131796,
0.0254650842,
0.0170261879,
0.0037399225,
0.0158726722,
0.0637978017,
0.0462518968,
-0.0300634373,
-0.0443578884,
0.0036073318,
-0.0092299944,
0.0664828718,
0.0215288401,
-0.0447822809,
0.0198024902,
-0.0282947198,
-0.0137102837,
0.0529543683,
-0.0970889106,
0.0091450056,
-0.0192072541,
-0.0353012718,
-0.0054722121,
-0.063617222,
0.0254762806,
-0.0188232251,
0.0516754575,
-0.0372312032,
0.0015218247,
-0.0287718568,
-0.0389757156,
0.0404250585,
-0.0212122276,
0.0152466502,
0.0001057752,
0.0195487365,
0.0047404412,
-0.0018803222,
-0.0286403839,
-0.0109299291,
-0.0354991928,
-0.0519854389,
0.0707990006,
0.0218044966,
0.008665829,
-0.0175800957,
0.0071562561,
-0.0868691355,
0.0696434826,
-0.0127469739,
-0.0128349299,
0.03016348,
0.0076462822,
-0.0123405503,
0.0133338617,
0.0426300503,
-0.0265408158,
0.061309617,
0.0225419216,
-0.0014599268,
-0.0245493259,
0.018261632,
0.0004813069,
-0.0175759774,
0.0356272534,
-0.0570247844,
-0.0171700157,
-0.0814828053,
-0.0448741503,
-0.014359721,
-0.0281278323,
0.0024658062,
-0.0450667329,
0.0606020167,
0.0297594424,
-0.0436203368,
-0.0543617941,
-0.0432603806,
0.0198523514,
-0.0362560712,
0.0701095089,
0.0113267647,
0.0558399111,
0.0107282652,
0.0311566852,
0.0140138548,
0.0120428437,
-0.0746607482,
0.0240847003,
-0.0194280408,
0.0470748506,
-0.006187256,
0.021503415,
0.0170394778,
0.0043164473,
0.0357238948,
-0.0095214872,
0.0270074941,
-0.0047202362,
0.034405943,
-0.0542337745,
0.0510872528,
0.0168351773,
0.0094964653,
-0.0360038877,
0.0021920672,
-0.0424536243,
-0.048351977,
0.0432577059,
-0.0041236267,
-0.0456291139,
0.040703427,
0.0538699478,
0.0077592228,
0.0033505384,
0.0103601078,
-0.0382712558,
-0.0003136196,
-0.0235305075,
0.0661737621,
-0.0057020355,
-0.0327007845,
-0.0128146131,
-0.0892686695,
-0.0700255483,
-0.0275291409,
-0.0391352214,
0.0055272542,
-0.0093267756,
-0.0251210909,
0.0495766513,
-0.0132003371,
-0.0082131587,
-0.0069474257,
-0.0017707796,
-0.0417438112,
-0.0567538999,
0.0106452713,
-5.652802825e-33,
-0.0067510307,
-0.0101603167,
-0.0222972035,
-0.0595922098,
-0.0043213167,
0.0005482686,
-0.0071503441,
0.0357687958,
-0.0518565141,
0.0433654338,
-0.0154408244,
0.0090057906,
0.0124312155,
-0.0006906677,
0.0306132045,
-0.0082861064,
-0.0165611953,
0.0470239148,
-0.0045188149,
-0.0146491919,
0.0200284179,
-0.0136459833,
0.0464157499,
-0.0428095907,
0.0752826333,
-0.0178020932,
-0.0053794794,
0.0193306822,
0.0163263921,
0.0177114308,
-0.0609519593,
0.0760313645,
0.0414355993,
0.0259028506,
0.0070225345,
0.0598528609,
-0.0456351824,
-0.0211128071,
0.023040086,
0.0192885902,
0.0109723294,
-0.0091929669,
0.01469611,
-0.0127854357,
-0.0719503611,
0.0310700014,
0.0297380593,
0.0363452248,
0.0098520163,
0.0394443348,
-0.0524350256,
0.0255241338,
-0.0320942812,
0.0339936502,
-0.0057710251,
0.0160868149,
0.0466250181,
0.0106133716,
-0.0475847535,
0.0037493275,
-0.0364744775,
0.0161614809,
0.0318112299,
0.0003622112,
0.0096481508,
0.0906869024,
0.0371064804,
-0.0010790033,
0.014061763,
-0.0313151143,
0.0579714961,
-0.0431851745,
-0.0182194319,
0.0449144021,
0.0235276893,
-0.0817884579,
-0.0052234083,
-0.0301395878,
0.0659555569,
0.0229355004,
0.0088198595,
-0.0021566784,
-0.0737008825,
-0.0566656739,
0.0053056604,
-0.0639403164,
-0.0151575655,
-0.0294898264,
0.0617454946,
-0.0240478665,
0.0150529025,
-0.0139650321,
0.0417658128,
-0.0316299461,
0.0066727572,
0.0222676378,
-0.0167396069,
-0.0362557061,
0.027837079,
0.0459417067,
-0.036312189,
-0.0044523738,
-0.0321573615,
0.0234517734,
0.0371392965,
-0.0069395769,
0.0140770823,
-0.0199885108,
-0.0898804441,
0.0142368106,
0.0121638021,
-0.0163211636,
0.0016923253,
0.039862942,
0.04891726,
0.0332114249,
-0.006608835,
-0.0488288999,
0.07705421,
0.0159919355,
-0.0140656121,
-0.0064733438,
-0.0406346731,
0.0296004955,
0.0026703787,
-0.0003118195,
-0.0230579432,
0.0156838372,
0.0442667082,
-0.0607039854,
-0.0018047232,
-0.0353174135,
2.46e-7,
-0.0029825831,
0.085608758,
-0.0205909163,
0.0104227895,
-0.0091477828,
0.008927932,
0.0123320324,
0.0190286096,
0.0097801303,
0.0333258659,
-0.0317792073,
0.019652281,
0.047838375,
0.0428698361,
-0.0312141087,
0.0393252559,
-0.1062536314,
0.0261972621,
-0.0281039476,
-0.0203043707,
-0.0621791929,
0.0671029538,
0.0403894857,
-0.0174154062,
-0.0677614957,
-0.0365814343,
0.0154638607,
-0.0333973393,
0.0031790768,
0.013725874,
-0.0026581148,
-0.0026785675,
0.0432641655,
-0.0020222412,
0.013420023,
0.0563622005,
0.0223474838,
0.0244958997,
-0.0157232564,
0.032940086,
-0.001257817,
-0.0077952743,
-0.010213811,
-0.0800903365,
0.0406641737,
0.0467188917,
-0.0442337953,
-0.0334836952,
0.0099340137,
-0.0046838312,
0.0914132372,
-0.0115250014,
-0.0096432399,
-0.024702901,
0.0512689315,
-0.0354577936,
0.0240680594,
-0.0475037768,
-0.0439106189,
-0.0192142483,
0.0001204238,
-0.035569381,
0.0237011462,
0.0364466384,
0.0187819898,
-0.0053426861,
0.0203959215,
1.956544225e-34,
0.0353422612,
0.0120105194,
0.0415559374,
-0.0299167149,
0.0697025582,
0.0090618078,
0.0290225204,
-0.0023199618,
0.0456110574,
-0.0438542441,
-0.0000130122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18373v2 | Can LLMs Grade Short-Answer Reading Comprehension Questions : An Empirical Study with a Novel Dataset | 2023-10-26T17:05:40 | 2024-05-05T16:01:40 | Owen Henkel, Libby Hills, Bill Roberts, Joshua McGrane | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open-ended questions, which require students to produce multi-word,
nontrivial responses, are a popular tool for formative assessment as they
provide more specific insights into what students do and don't know. However,
grading open-ended questions can be time-consuming leading teachers to resort
to simpler question formats or conduct fewer formative assessments. While there
has been a longstanding interest in automating of short-answer grading (ASAG),
but previous approaches have been technically complex, limiting their use in
formative assessment contexts. The newest generation of Large Language Models
(LLMs) potentially makes grading short answer questions more feasible. This
paper investigates the potential for the newest version of LLMs to be used in
ASAG, specifically in the grading of short answer questions for formative
assessments, in two ways. First, it introduces a novel dataset of short answer
reading comprehension questions, drawn from a set of reading assessments
conducted with over 150 students in Ghana. This dataset allows for the
evaluation of LLMs in a new context, as they are predominantly designed and
trained on data from high-income North American countries. Second, the paper
empirically evaluates how well various configurations of generative LLMs grade
student short answer responses compared to expert human raters. The findings
show that GPT-4, with minimal prompt engineering, performed extremely well on
grading the novel dataset (QWK 0.92, F1 0.89), reaching near parity with expert
human raters. To our knowledge this work is the first to empirically evaluate
the performance of generative LLMs on short answer reading comprehension
questions using real student data, with low technical hurdles to attaining this
performance. These findings suggest that generative LLMs could be used to grade
formative literacy assessment tasks. | [
0.0285408106,
-0.0210716184,
-0.0276941694,
-0.0154645946,
-0.0426165089,
0.0213211868,
0.0447832271,
-0.0239963923,
-0.0014967056,
-0.0530090332,
-0.0012226079,
-0.0217620749,
0.0031266441,
0.0238128342,
0.028834004,
-0.03567506,
-0.0021015068,
-0.0275093447,
0.011337826,
-0.0077315611,
-0.019554995,
0.0149280727,
-0.0039866567,
0.0067160926,
0.0267749242,
-0.0293865521,
-0.0228882171,
-0.0463547632,
0.0039146557,
-0.015738491,
0.0238432419,
0.0817406699,
-0.0423812196,
0.0131675676,
0.000002048,
-0.0500123203,
-0.0045860996,
0.0015731758,
-0.0082988236,
0.0419291817,
0.0429660007,
0.0378592424,
0.0148279145,
0.0257590506,
-0.0536249988,
-0.0321190506,
-0.0075978492,
-0.0193047021,
0.0628312901,
0.0303104389,
0.0279520135,
-0.0124352034,
0.0651130751,
0.0017931688,
0.0401187167,
-0.0090506496,
0.0196713675,
0.0597803257,
0.0256965738,
0.04350603,
-0.0674112886,
0.0321032703,
0.0234044753,
-0.0189305488,
-0.0040699621,
0.0038428735,
0.0029461666,
0.0163006373,
0.0086977016,
0.0612484626,
0.0274104252,
-0.0236570183,
-0.040342588,
-0.0195836741,
0.0154448738,
0.0690134838,
-0.0740985498,
0.0435109809,
-0.0258434508,
-0.0022141382,
0.0161546506,
-0.0219065994,
-0.0036545598,
-0.0017198927,
-0.0102418233,
0.0462184735,
0.0325919576,
-0.0384093486,
-0.0082971761,
0.0246495698,
-0.0180123467,
-0.018888535,
-0.0144080054,
0.050038524,
0.0224875715,
0.0000764521,
-0.0166018959,
-0.0299488045,
0.0313377455,
-0.0158548895,
0.0378732011,
0.0293335821,
-0.024957424,
0.0304707773,
-0.0364073701,
0.0664171875,
0.0545043275,
0.0315724909,
-0.0699889138,
0.02578732,
-0.0114619248,
-0.0315664969,
0.012805894,
0.0225273706,
-0.0464920104,
0.0048427852,
-0.0600072704,
-0.0041452469,
-0.0021983292,
-0.0014751633,
0.0057105748,
-0.0168905091,
0.0072798906,
0.0251944754,
-0.0307624396,
0.0359313637,
-0.0364801027,
0.0177689027,
-0.0028265822,
-0.0116324313,
0.0325185098,
-0.0001253749,
0.0055801263,
-0.0009018641,
0.025336273,
-0.0010588013,
-0.0061120759,
-0.018262336,
-0.0266746171,
-0.0086164353,
-0.0137707395,
-0.0445432737,
-0.0111839715,
-0.0707606971,
0.0006168939,
0.0567641072,
0.0106611755,
0.0098097753,
0.0046088034,
0.0276742503,
0.0314185172,
0.0440173224,
0.0190213863,
0.0074952287,
0.0256253853,
0.0153281875,
0.057818722,
0.0225806516,
0.052317109,
-0.0175296497,
0.0367138982,
-0.0464250483,
0.0205337871,
0.0352064744,
-0.0192833003,
0.0190078691,
0.0154651664,
0.0049929237,
0.0243484136,
0.000145118,
-0.0083633,
0.0487865508,
0.028344376,
0.0041704769,
0.052686993,
0.0440549888,
0.0207034629,
0.0300708879,
0.067658715,
0.016704455,
0.0438014045,
0.0543693118,
-0.0246521831,
-0.0193802267,
-0.0719217956,
0.0204939675,
0.0385672487,
0.0341971852,
0.0021830813,
-0.0628089607,
0.0015144033,
0.0284223128,
0.0061060693,
0.0480510406,
0.0727861971,
-0.0167271551,
-0.0413872041,
-0.0294618178,
-0.0015721282,
-0.0559105016,
0.045327466,
-0.061635498,
0.0926013887,
0.0525861718,
0.0753730983,
0.0089693516,
-0.0249815509,
-0.0044977455,
-0.0059994599,
0.0183265284,
0.0149033442,
-0.0230155252,
-0.0400966294,
-0.0467052311,
-0.0088984407,
0.004555658,
-0.0140270023,
0.0002985454,
-0.0171702579,
0.0291533433,
0.0203680675,
-0.0560423993,
-0.0514307581,
0.029013548,
-0.0398016199,
-0.0710583478,
-0.0295274612,
-0.0066561149,
0.0173567645,
0.0509492457,
0.0213299673,
0.0081479168,
0.0067906301,
-0.0052509056,
0.0011977328,
-0.0659441426,
-0.0579720363,
-0.0311532952,
0.0319343396,
-0.0272658989,
0.0338644423,
0.0291698128,
0.0074728867,
-0.0560843088,
-0.0150490757,
-0.0099363886,
-0.0008997963,
-0.0461607315,
0.03259556,
0.0029707281,
-0.0304486826,
-0.0714042932,
0.0291999523,
0.0175097361,
0.0787486061,
-0.050538037,
0.0354176499,
0.0408111252,
0.007487169,
-0.0535994768,
0.0150015876,
0.0052095586,
0.0144924521,
-0.0018635944,
0.0409236401,
-0.0514457151,
-0.0419286415,
-0.0931533501,
0.0076374002,
0.0125936503,
0.0156622361,
0.0207476951,
-0.0061522881,
-0.0153112039,
0.0479068644,
-0.0553344712,
-0.0088779572,
0.0394808725,
-0.0074633909,
-0.0156452619,
0.0049377261,
-0.0061383597,
-0.0237185601,
-0.0382482857,
-0.0348216146,
0.0204741638,
0.0658709928,
0.0434889644,
-0.0145521425,
0.0065990845,
0.0023901931,
-0.0238570254,
0.0180882905,
-0.0310880821,
0.0170777794,
-0.0365191549,
0.049506247,
0.0333897397,
0.0008654987,
-0.0122095533,
0.0300527401,
-0.0381147414,
-0.0538556986,
0.020513285,
-0.0193361714,
-0.017558381,
-0.0080205938,
-0.0560963526,
-0.0198501386,
0.057407219,
0.0460908376,
-0.0532360598,
-0.0271341372,
0.0418687761,
-0.0545775965,
-0.0202069134,
-0.0777053684,
-0.0068958667,
-0.021068044,
0.0382595547,
-0.0007294861,
-0.0395276323,
0.0561411977,
-0.0438447967,
-0.0123586096,
-0.052382037,
0.0530405156,
-0.0459531508,
0.0371138416,
0.0237077735,
-0.024482986,
-0.0497821383,
0.0108318729,
-0.041050449,
0.00614795,
0.0234274492,
-0.0520060845,
0.0585571714,
-0.0671053827,
-0.0189960338,
-0.0127490479,
0.0004795053,
-0.0226383191,
0.0070633707,
0.0279059783,
0.0016639502,
-0.002541936,
-0.0059860758,
-0.0217820518,
0.0350617804,
0.0186778866,
0.0109401541,
-0.0739791021,
-0.0034356501,
0.0066432017,
0.068220064,
0.0475927219,
-0.0437492467,
0.0008224117,
-0.0508436747,
0.0354137756,
0.0295100398,
-0.022475116,
0.0153226051,
0.041631896,
0.0202134624,
0.0464976989,
-0.0360204726,
-0.0085036894,
0.0321794711,
0.0343914181,
-0.0694476813,
-0.01611734,
0.1009599864,
0.0405081175,
-0.0070916698,
-0.0266682617,
-0.0496200845,
-0.0070776679,
-0.0029455395,
0.0350231677,
-0.0454099663,
0.0027728828,
-0.0070720767,
0.0722329393,
-0.0338346288,
-0.0200485867,
0.0097393747,
-0.1122849286,
0.0259913038,
0.0197450593,
-0.0657584667,
0.0065708519,
-0.0135722402,
-0.023466697,
0.0345703103,
0.006030234,
0.037629284,
0.0094228387,
0.0433891043,
0.019415196,
-0.0238239989,
-0.0027747697,
0.0231333319,
0.0217552651,
0.0369343907,
0.0331677869,
-0.0075485306,
-0.0360340327,
-0.0333795957,
0.0263766591,
-0.0553736538,
-0.046707876,
-0.0282459911,
-0.0027677892,
0.0070322761,
0.0193163455,
-0.0573357716,
0.0559729822,
-0.029287396,
0.0241460521,
0.0614451841,
0.0623956881,
-0.0022195319,
-0.0273059346,
-0.0421560667,
0.0119166262,
0.0009472068,
0.0787120759,
0.050137341,
-0.0730919316,
-0.0129388943,
-0.0582620241,
-0.0144270733,
-0.0793824047,
-0.0656248778,
0.0384918302,
-0.0051929695,
0.0109053859,
-0.0302010216,
-0.0860618725,
0.0870443583,
-0.0258862972,
0.0286641866,
0.028784994,
-0.0042114891,
-0.0217971765,
-0.0143895475,
0.0031813444,
-0.023697529,
0.0061844834,
-0.0813236833,
-0.032377813,
0.0207323171,
-0.0318620875,
-0.0278700627,
0.0214637704,
-0.0761048719,
-0.0203615893,
0.0166667458,
0.0379244126,
0.0153861027,
-0.0421614274,
0.0147862416,
-0.018965669,
0.0487371385,
-0.0379742086,
-0.0213647597,
0.0134539614,
-0.0516423695,
0.0353952795,
4.297e-7,
-0.024279058,
0.0035829863,
0.0215217583,
0.0269954167,
0.0526740812,
-0.0049542985,
-0.0535767525,
0.0067003327,
0.0451926067,
0.0096883802,
-0.0137436921,
-0.029512804,
-0.0424870439,
-0.0078990096,
-0.0228687916,
-0.0019485131,
-0.0214429367,
-0.00790211,
0.0398220047,
-0.0243143458,
-0.0461725444,
-0.001700756,
-0.0471238941,
0.0652237982,
-0.0488382019,
0.0836775973,
0.0298996121,
-0.000981215,
-0.0002161004,
-0.0274557825,
-0.0272491314,
-0.0382650457,
-0.0069600623,
0.0622565374,
0.039857287,
0.0889227316,
-0.0219088923,
0.0145232398,
0.0181769803,
0.0055595352,
-0.0179154538,
0.0236778203,
-0.0512866899,
0.0549416617,
-0.0310189091,
0.0257182643,
0.0003215936,
0.0120883929,
0.0020773432,
-0.0544383377,
0.003566111,
0.0256570037,
0.008136454,
0.0519350581,
0.016003171,
0.0300436877,
-0.0010924316,
0.053034462,
0.0137651907,
-0.0004068984,
0.00773542,
-0.0259260628,
-0.0430173241,
-0.0399253741,
-0.0099742217,
0.0265736114,
0.0068122488,
0.0070140827,
-0.0864568725,
-0.0467418917,
-0.0202932507,
0.0624842905,
0.024667684,
-0.0241006184,
-0.0090379911,
0.0549158379,
-0.0450439304,
-0.0216091815,
-0.0568143688,
0.0449010283,
-0.0338403955,
-0.0517851859,
-6.999e-7,
-5.934503801e-33,
-0.0231112875,
-0.0504959933,
0.0459266454,
0.0031704123,
-0.0110108256,
-0.0058117742,
-0.0107299201,
0.0226082541,
0.0001770963,
-0.0125102187,
-0.0237725377,
-0.0195592586,
-0.0081491275,
0.0703179166,
0.0149792479,
0.0235336833,
0.0086129429,
-0.017820891,
-0.0224547815,
0.025499057,
0.0110118631,
-0.0090967389,
0.0257417932,
-0.0054513365,
0.0869247541,
-0.0623441525,
-0.0063622678,
-0.0212265253,
-0.0354773998,
0.0620126501,
-0.0331424139,
0.0593111329,
0.0422202013,
-0.0205456875,
0.0276528578,
0.0543028675,
-0.0750785321,
-0.0344153717,
0.0497009903,
-0.0194962211,
-0.0384539925,
-0.0459672697,
0.0354212895,
0.014876754,
-0.0310932007,
-0.012846279,
0.0539309718,
-0.0417982563,
-0.008589766,
-0.0269880351,
-0.0415484644,
0.0163201746,
-0.0298557933,
-0.0102158152,
-0.0361320712,
0.0733966753,
-0.0210774988,
0.0103696771,
-0.0170584824,
0.0180211477,
0.1031815559,
0.0481681861,
0.0399246477,
0.0387265384,
-0.0166228451,
0.0178138036,
-0.0095566865,
-0.0355657972,
-0.0028701979,
-0.0043788813,
0.0551839247,
-0.0391539745,
0.0786107928,
0.0588183515,
0.0220860038,
0.0028446841,
-0.0582856238,
0.0774563402,
0.007883139,
0.0017386981,
0.0184582081,
-0.0813802928,
-0.0599615835,
-0.0382153243,
-0.0748823211,
-0.0169522911,
-0.0330037326,
-0.010282536,
0.0752065852,
-0.0672460869,
-0.0190030597,
-0.0297287907,
0.0424123816,
-0.0190053564,
-0.0049465871,
-0.0147836208,
-0.0082506659,
0.0665381998,
-0.012803196,
0.0364531651,
-0.0209270008,
0.0293978788,
-0.0050690905,
-0.0037234873,
-0.016692007,
-0.0090672364,
-0.0064893952,
-0.0154862385,
-0.0489760451,
-0.011049184,
-0.0128591135,
0.0190381333,
0.0042958944,
0.0112100309,
0.0281521808,
0.0154461507,
0.0142425802,
0.0392059162,
-0.0077745323,
-0.0230672881,
-0.0013198904,
-0.0496313348,
-0.0125254979,
-0.0109673403,
-0.053132806,
0.0027683126,
0.0012584729,
0.0166675635,
-0.0063171983,
-0.0172171202,
0.0330967717,
0.0569537766,
2.564e-7,
0.0541819744,
0.0333221108,
0.0019015383,
-0.0074747386,
-0.0077293948,
-0.0021171211,
0.0260809939,
-0.0184306633,
0.0697742403,
0.035043925,
0.0237681568,
0.0022084191,
0.0393253118,
0.0198517274,
-0.0794965625,
0.0143086324,
0.021018263,
0.0208342317,
-0.0442074388,
0.0153512768,
0.0899207145,
0.0156979822,
-0.0086125983,
-0.0317461528,
-0.0426432118,
-0.0484421179,
0.0228617601,
-0.0355711319,
-0.050110247,
0.0330530629,
0.0454451032,
0.0057920432,
0.046345491,
0.0415223353,
-0.0071473229,
-0.0087688956,
0.0322033912,
0.0552197509,
0.0397408903,
-0.0211196318,
0.0198183805,
-0.0164320376,
0.0077149929,
-0.077276893,
0.092279233,
0.0080226017,
-0.0005201872,
0.0438179187,
-0.0435506776,
-0.0442617722,
-0.0188235566,
-0.0344636664,
-0.0152194891,
0.0289312154,
0.018119432,
-0.0426149182,
0.0341304876,
0.0056278296,
0.0177064855,
-0.0028030057,
-0.0220517665,
-0.0681888983,
-0.0534564741,
-0.0029299287,
-0.0337225758,
-0.0578783751,
0.0052090501,
2.346252056e-34,
0.0411556736,
-0.0337440744,
0.0331824198,
-0.0396107845,
-0.0059667057,
0.0096257934,
0.0158049595,
0.0192078855,
0.0249507036,
-0.1202740744,
-0.0441075191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17576v1 | 1D-Touch: NLP-Assisted Coarse Text Selection via a Semi-Direct Gesture | 2023-10-26T17:01:22 | 2023-10-26T17:01:22 | Peiling Jiang, Li Feng, Fuling Sun, Parakrant Sarkar, Haijun Xia, Can Liu | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Existing text selection techniques on touchscreen focus on improving the
control for moving the carets. Coarse-grained text selection on word and phrase
levels has not received much support beyond word-snapping and entity
recognition. We introduce 1D-Touch, a novel text selection method that
complements the carets-based sub-word selection by facilitating the selection
of semantic units of words and above. This method employs a simple vertical
slide gesture to expand and contract a selection area from a word. The
expansion can be by words or by semantic chunks ranging from sub-phrases to
sentences. This technique shifts the concept of text selection, from defining a
range by locating the first and last words, towards a dynamic process of
expanding and contracting a textual semantic entity. To understand the effects
of our approach, we prototyped and tested two variants: WordTouch, which offers
a straightforward word-by-word expansion, and ChunkTouch, which leverages NLP
to chunk text into syntactic units, allowing the selection to grow by
semantically meaningful units in response to the sliding gesture. Our
evaluation, focused on the coarse-grained selection tasks handled by 1D-Touch,
shows a 20% improvement over the default word-snapping selection method on
Android. | [
0.0033215461,
0.0163691845,
-0.0069048866,
0.006380022,
-0.0464389957,
-0.006012456,
0.0313674696,
0.0782242641,
0.0341073908,
-0.0369665585,
0.0047509926,
-0.0158733875,
0.0329848789,
-0.0246528722,
-0.0193679258,
-0.0851398706,
0.0121729663,
-0.0358253457,
-0.0368564725,
0.0235515554,
0.0683547109,
0.0005500577,
-0.0105313817,
-0.0031626369,
-0.046955511,
-0.0014681376,
-0.0179918837,
-0.016046565,
0.015156839,
-0.0526513085,
-0.0113392575,
0.0321361013,
-0.0138530377,
-0.0132493852,
0.0000021174,
0.0120888576,
-0.0052357768,
-0.025411509,
0.0167653225,
-0.0354060382,
0.073786743,
-0.0397145636,
0.007173805,
-0.016103588,
-0.0017412333,
0.032378953,
0.0355902538,
0.0740672573,
-0.0216153692,
-0.0340187065,
-0.0180932768,
-0.0000727718,
-0.0279871728,
-0.0138246873,
0.0194922574,
0.0142413517,
-0.0074788397,
-0.0149938688,
0.0634982437,
0.0411871895,
0.0210835822,
0.0358817205,
-0.0210601278,
-0.0342132077,
0.0278124232,
0.0737385973,
-0.0150110452,
-0.0391900353,
0.0036413334,
0.0365836807,
0.0140178502,
0.0023068096,
0.0335319377,
-0.0584413111,
0.0021926886,
0.0358213112,
-0.0185544472,
-0.0113416854,
-0.0289283916,
-0.0027946606,
-0.0594047941,
0.0041634641,
0.00802984,
0.009801358,
0.0147574889,
0.0289439596,
0.0388393402,
-0.0314130262,
0.0209398586,
0.0033069316,
0.0341915786,
-0.0335278288,
0.0900148675,
0.0011930959,
-0.0009850204,
-0.0148073146,
-0.0826011971,
-0.0519074164,
0.0117918896,
-0.0070248018,
0.0177770574,
0.0263921153,
-0.0072571957,
0.0119308075,
0.0402879789,
-0.0292075425,
0.0361665338,
-0.0037742227,
-0.0607715435,
0.0295236483,
0.0318841673,
-0.0084052151,
-0.0093926145,
0.0356290974,
-0.0710892826,
-0.0420376547,
-0.010056234,
-0.0439696126,
0.0582759194,
-0.0507285073,
-0.0051800902,
0.0158354323,
-0.0039170766,
-0.0221376885,
0.0155965099,
-0.0167005602,
-0.0733866021,
0.0171115715,
0.0154479966,
-0.0133068943,
-0.0214550365,
-0.0120680341,
0.051003322,
-0.0331074819,
0.0096168462,
0.0511726066,
-0.0529557094,
-0.0397395082,
-0.0046315733,
0.0190420281,
-0.0817335621,
0.0260871071,
-0.0512246042,
-0.0266684778,
0.0138433529,
0.0178606398,
-0.0203162879,
-0.0235527996,
0.0370543152,
0.0825653523,
-0.0333546549,
0.0320331454,
-0.0813843533,
0.0119861942,
0.0191264134,
0.0082378481,
0.0017175452,
0.0095325997,
0.0479233563,
0.0524629317,
0.0655417517,
0.0324734151,
0.0092939818,
0.0530974455,
-0.024765458,
-0.0536285937,
-0.0061955019,
-0.0672203079,
0.0038034408,
0.0268657114,
-0.0106618879,
0.0497944094,
-0.0596201457,
-0.0029749037,
0.0970327258,
0.1215095297,
0.005142305,
0.0365452915,
-0.054063797,
0.0314028002,
-0.007466807,
-0.0358752459,
-0.0223482549,
0.006866015,
0.004220461,
0.0183112528,
0.0492944792,
0.007892102,
0.0250672363,
-0.0325260051,
-0.0455856994,
0.0187305603,
0.0428450592,
-0.0089316461,
0.0129697341,
0.036625132,
0.0062649315,
0.0161725581,
0.0524974726,
-0.0279291626,
-0.0101419613,
0.0266782213,
-0.0071575488,
0.0628438666,
0.043100439,
-0.0535526313,
0.0046262895,
-0.0229754206,
0.0169540662,
0.0402029157,
-0.0016298367,
-0.0071650315,
0.0041224337,
-0.058921136,
0.0011102195,
0.0269876942,
-0.0245711654,
-0.0404064916,
0.0111255767,
0.0672536716,
-0.0059068999,
-0.0196134374,
-0.0120724039,
0.0491845831,
0.0438897461,
-0.0488964282,
0.0303461719,
0.0067468123,
-0.065877445,
0.0014345155,
-0.0238355119,
-0.0279697664,
0.0020915244,
-0.0167447589,
0.0079485998,
-0.008266109,
-0.001549206,
0.01084584,
-0.0263623204,
0.0143801849,
-0.023939902,
-0.0445840433,
0.0523598827,
-0.0081734015,
-0.0473291427,
0.0535076037,
-0.022659732,
-0.0151594458,
0.0108410586,
0.0046028243,
-0.0134094227,
-0.0392943509,
0.0529828705,
0.0196137577,
0.033362668,
0.0002135076,
-0.0105545036,
0.0033427202,
-0.0151703209,
0.000913667,
0.0370499305,
-0.0253588259,
-0.0036650037,
0.0568880662,
0.0447360687,
-0.0480207391,
-0.0180801693,
-0.0331578441,
0.003372387,
-0.0113399988,
0.0366812982,
0.0002778391,
0.046897918,
-0.0506517254,
-0.0173998624,
0.0267866831,
-0.0073084175,
-0.0360584147,
-0.0078209257,
0.035105098,
-0.0517910384,
0.0962789878,
-0.048911009,
0.0234343316,
-0.0073288064,
0.004417873,
0.0708056614,
-0.0283243693,
-0.0194206107,
-0.0233947895,
0.0363471434,
-0.028143147,
0.0262474474,
0.0158128869,
0.0273209196,
-0.001332343,
-0.0258448701,
0.0786982924,
-0.0100682732,
0.0578503981,
-0.0016569002,
-0.027726667,
0.0264776275,
0.011132014,
-0.0038127957,
0.1062882543,
-0.0042847195,
0.0482947342,
0.036583405,
0.0685300305,
0.0180280171,
0.0383758061,
-0.0096492125,
-0.0356058627,
-0.0552339032,
0.0040316209,
0.0004314024,
0.0203189347,
-0.0720664784,
-0.0113457367,
-0.0322179608,
-0.0542602427,
0.0054747975,
-0.0114329057,
-0.0120827956,
-0.0230616909,
-0.0008237304,
0.0240467526,
0.09019164,
-0.0259919055,
-0.0059051234,
0.0124080312,
-0.0577020757,
0.0368862972,
0.0208216645,
0.020869704,
-0.0016579996,
0.0305182189,
-0.0621737055,
0.0217961669,
-0.0301100388,
-0.0651173592,
0.0062769926,
-0.0072696349,
-0.0263925809,
-0.0235883091,
0.0496036075,
-0.0334662944,
-0.012075346,
-0.0143934907,
0.059428405,
0.0685229003,
-0.0060986243,
-0.0096510146,
-0.0181511007,
0.0113347555,
0.0050274534,
0.0056262412,
-0.0703693703,
-0.0097078644,
-0.0004756248,
0.0499401726,
0.0427724496,
-0.0382696204,
0.0479225144,
0.0124069955,
0.0243655033,
-0.0544972941,
-0.0317994058,
0.0310990438,
0.0910552293,
-0.0054335147,
0.0235134773,
0.0731627122,
0.0316956677,
-0.0123912832,
0.0052426727,
0.0062485803,
0.0402801782,
-0.0118905688,
-0.0168405771,
-0.0473453999,
-0.0743145347,
0.0272939503,
-0.0100599583,
0.0463426225,
-0.058001332,
0.0050616753,
-0.0256165806,
-0.0122967428,
-0.0276849829,
-0.011350817,
0.0144629227,
0.0080256201,
0.0777477846,
0.0403337777,
-0.0168425571,
-0.016233433,
-0.039777562,
-0.0068413061,
-0.0409953333,
-0.0343857966,
0.066832684,
0.0012082083,
0.0161788072,
-0.064066641,
0.0520249568,
0.0693926886,
0.0378901996,
0.0379666872,
0.0249249674,
-0.0341430902,
0.022235807,
-0.0366317071,
0.0459190048,
-0.0031773308,
0.0257690791,
-0.034473829,
0.0613249205,
-0.0177034922,
-0.0247242339,
0.0326536559,
0.0257924795,
0.0351514481,
-0.0161803775,
0.0151728196,
-0.0696853101,
0.0129854642,
-0.019186629,
-0.0178556815,
-0.0743079558,
-0.0907094553,
-0.0347288698,
-0.0208645072,
-0.0059924917,
-0.0482581705,
0.0154727856,
0.0078621972,
-0.0495144315,
-0.0583175831,
-0.0474675186,
0.0872097984,
0.0490024574,
0.0530222692,
0.0359300897,
0.0499641746,
0.0109386342,
-0.0074300827,
-0.0378322266,
-0.0102800988,
0.028443411,
0.0143000502,
0.0001095983,
0.0191982705,
-0.0293722749,
0.0237889774,
-0.0056749689,
-0.0458489098,
-0.0630587861,
-0.0258484501,
-0.0226955768,
0.0107190516,
0.0262587462,
-0.0668143481,
-0.0810778588,
0.0409129374,
0.03599656,
-0.040930286,
-0.020074198,
-0.0191829577,
0.0053915349,
0.0050552916,
0.0354212821,
-0.0062283985,
-0.0277369004,
0.0059299134,
0.0163286775,
-0.051059559,
-0.0778486878,
0.008632211,
-0.0178878158,
0.0141960857,
0.0160035994,
0.0534388199,
-0.0670777559,
-0.0213736985,
-0.0033000477,
0.0073845261,
-0.0265791453,
0.0352805331,
-0.0462230742,
-0.0110440999,
-0.0191092901,
-0.0063533974,
-0.0064886268,
-0.034361355,
-0.0498509072,
0.0507619344,
-0.0217905287,
0.0288423263,
0.0195293482,
-0.0252190512,
0.0169769395,
0.0166217256,
-0.0610978417,
0.057443656,
-0.0076201758,
0.0624640472,
0.0308922864,
-0.0655400306,
-0.0146764638,
-0.0110214427,
-0.0263324939,
-0.0048738238,
-0.0316935033,
0.0054572737,
0.0010780377,
-0.0696132556,
0.0564996116,
-0.0203461312,
-0.0064469185,
0.0006741706,
0.0365568362,
0.0215978865,
-0.0431526378,
-0.0389482267,
-0.0083136382,
-0.0307675824,
-0.0045197825,
0.031649366,
-0.0843388215,
-0.0289354417,
0.0735194758,
-0.0290711857,
-0.044863034,
-0.0317537375,
0.0316992924,
0.0307864826,
-0.0077499356,
0.0118141752,
-0.0425125696,
0.0209523216,
0.0222480316,
0.0102674719,
-0.0051974747,
-0.0355029739,
0.0274227262,
0.0507829748,
-0.0166257992,
-0.0124904523,
-0.0402243622,
-0.0102469968,
-0.02173662,
0.0146946376,
-0.0365432054,
-5.508056859e-33,
0.0167244803,
-0.0308045615,
-0.0216559134,
0.0294179674,
-0.0459359474,
-0.0563507713,
-0.0332768857,
0.0395466648,
0.0347341783,
0.0147518702,
-0.0524905287,
-0.026792815,
0.018962808,
0.023952065,
0.0274982098,
-0.0147710377,
0.0319147259,
-0.0136047658,
-0.035894461,
0.0075556086,
0.0043650661,
0.0348746851,
0.0291348789,
-0.019704707,
0.0321803503,
0.0042195581,
0.0317716189,
-0.0614795499,
0.0509041734,
-0.0177565794,
-0.0442162566,
0.002018359,
0.0216247272,
-0.0128145637,
-0.0017424284,
0.0429274701,
-0.0584929883,
-0.0668033659,
-0.0464831926,
0.0345943905,
-0.0250152815,
-0.0006080788,
0.017851593,
0.0027091352,
-0.0162460972,
0.0057348707,
0.0295609646,
-0.0138833979,
-0.043595627,
-0.0645197928,
-0.0209614411,
0.047193259,
0.0275000036,
-0.0587940738,
0.012295248,
-0.0421368778,
0.0166510418,
-0.0090706572,
-0.058837112,
0.0098991832,
0.0287788212,
0.0319270901,
0.0113228606,
0.0159843378,
0.0184276812,
0.0816059411,
-0.0126097817,
-0.0389815532,
0.0275945775,
0.0380873345,
0.000611998,
0.0343043916,
-0.0402886905,
0.0441960841,
0.1128159985,
-0.0529936329,
-0.0000100493,
0.0059711891,
0.016288653,
0.0033203894,
0.0139186364,
0.0594929382,
-0.0220501721,
0.0032457775,
-0.0189719554,
0.0019325475,
0.0141280973,
-0.0276699942,
0.0112102143,
0.0108167343,
0.0136555843,
0.0198545735,
0.0015208849,
0.0260421429,
-0.0552959554,
-0.0667286366,
-0.0425850265,
0.0314613581,
-0.0112987198,
-0.0553611033,
-0.0412116759,
-0.0331579298,
-0.0199854784,
0.0166387707,
0.025999641,
-0.0036160038,
-0.04856693,
-0.0080184005,
-0.071081154,
-0.0009333316,
0.0356005765,
-0.0121530602,
0.0088117691,
0.0123019125,
0.0679626092,
-0.029229898,
-0.0354603082,
0.0481326841,
-0.0037592631,
-0.0418705307,
-0.0677270442,
0.0108312145,
0.0302597769,
-0.0355638675,
-0.0111944098,
-0.0077541121,
-0.0187776964,
0.0012708787,
-0.0046919952,
-0.0527109839,
0.002824357,
0.0253399648,
2.62e-7,
0.0214821864,
0.0322411321,
0.0008516746,
-0.0203256868,
-0.0163609255,
0.0441337675,
0.0464310423,
0.0471727066,
-0.0504101776,
-0.0433629826,
-0.0076790191,
-0.0025074522,
0.0565428883,
-0.007611251,
-0.0993149132,
0.0495215058,
0.0557870008,
-0.0094537698,
-0.0452734604,
0.0038216154,
0.0654194653,
0.0216395203,
0.0043011801,
0.0289702471,
0.0332448073,
-0.0296136755,
0.0266865976,
-0.0112516265,
0.080229871,
-0.0021995297,
0.0341696069,
-0.0419392549,
-0.0554104485,
0.0005651269,
-0.0257448144,
-0.0282230917,
0.0610009469,
0.0205913074,
-0.0511226393,
0.0402922817,
-0.0018689276,
-0.0382940024,
0.0256474596,
-0.0245445874,
0.0802083313,
-0.005398192,
0.0040155244,
0.0303404089,
0.0399721935,
0.0127711436,
-0.0145506673,
0.0110038184,
-0.0213851742,
0.0115964906,
0.0211689621,
0.0196750425,
-0.0276285633,
-0.0739030316,
-0.0260754116,
0.0096316654,
-0.0031256827,
-0.0132479584,
-0.0947381184,
-0.0103956992,
-0.0251524113,
-0.0429960862,
-0.0341879912,
1.93269271e-34,
-0.0042992756,
-0.0008691907,
-0.015513516,
0.056749355,
0.0504388213,
0.0154438335,
0.0918705463,
0.0097356942,
0.0262337588,
-0.0061584823,
-0.0117787654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17570v1 | DiffS2UT: A Semantic Preserving Diffusion Model for Textless Direct Speech-to-Speech Translation | 2023-10-26T16:58:14 | 2023-10-26T16:58:14 | Yongxin Zhu, Zhujin Gao, Xinyuan Zhou, Zhongyi Ye, Linli Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | While Diffusion Generative Models have achieved great success on image
generation tasks, how to efficiently and effectively incorporate them into
speech generation especially translation tasks remains a non-trivial problem.
Specifically, due to the low information density of speech data, the
transformed discrete speech unit sequence is much longer than the corresponding
text transcription, posing significant challenges to existing auto-regressive
models. Furthermore, it is not optimal to brutally apply discrete diffusion on
the speech unit sequence while disregarding the continuous space structure,
which will degrade the generation performance significantly. In this paper, we
propose a novel diffusion model by applying the diffusion forward process in
the \textit{continuous} speech representation space, while employing the
diffusion backward process in the \textit{discrete} speech unit space. In this
way, we preserve the semantic structure of the continuous speech representation
space in the diffusion process and integrate the continuous and discrete
diffusion models. We conduct extensive experiments on the textless direct
speech-to-speech translation task, where the proposed method achieves
comparable results to the computationally intensive auto-regressive baselines
(500 steps on average) with significantly fewer decoding steps (50 steps). | [
-0.0175016895,
0.0409127995,
0.0016851299,
-0.0191706549,
-0.0306958314,
-0.0056294678,
0.0475887172,
0.0090376483,
-0.067778416,
-0.0123997713,
0.0001646396,
-0.0577974729,
0.0578148328,
-0.0084880386,
0.0311985239,
-0.0509585105,
-0.0032479051,
-0.0464400426,
-0.0352916345,
-0.0174969099,
-0.0072780247,
-0.0065953205,
-0.0427456424,
-0.0125110028,
-0.0364908092,
-0.0180820245,
-0.0120133162,
0.0298714321,
0.0154135022,
-0.0293694977,
-0.0446818694,
0.0066670538,
0.0766808167,
0.031758517,
0.0000021145,
-0.0265951157,
-0.0059265825,
0.0308486857,
-0.0132513437,
-0.0233844817,
0.0558702648,
-0.0246639103,
-0.0469320342,
0.0177775063,
0.0141455624,
0.0027306934,
0.0605066791,
0.0227648467,
0.0420204327,
0.0567376316,
-0.0300924722,
-0.0979101956,
0.0319201499,
-0.0530329421,
0.0411250778,
0.0190944113,
-0.0149736665,
0.0317140594,
-0.0335853919,
-0.0285917837,
-0.0445455052,
0.0632319376,
-0.0097269267,
-0.0135397017,
0.0241469368,
0.0565743856,
0.0245688781,
-0.0691675544,
-0.0123872152,
0.0933219343,
-0.0120000634,
0.0089471266,
0.0319773927,
0.0065925415,
-0.0380554534,
-0.0138004133,
-0.0356106833,
0.0263404865,
0.0354474373,
-0.0006043272,
-0.018663723,
0.0121607734,
0.0238081012,
-0.0490081199,
-0.0627013445,
0.0000235641,
0.0321789347,
-0.0074375025,
-0.0226345528,
-0.0153611088,
-0.0208576936,
-0.0246970467,
0.0485965461,
0.0159256328,
0.0410850048,
-0.0065098312,
-0.0319460444,
-0.0584413223,
-0.0249360893,
-0.0220409669,
0.0272909272,
0.0526683666,
0.0114625208,
-0.015363547,
-0.0512405671,
0.0268256329,
-0.0033501082,
-0.0299452767,
-0.0343223326,
0.013637064,
-0.0132064335,
0.0352619216,
-0.0689017698,
0.0307029057,
-0.0618103147,
-0.025691621,
-0.0252817068,
0.0033647201,
-0.0040957481,
-0.026132565,
0.0559540614,
0.0090988772,
-0.0950397924,
0.0011274061,
0.0102890581,
0.0482190438,
0.0214625001,
-0.0069583454,
0.0240361113,
-0.0185200348,
-0.0406236239,
0.0213277526,
0.0551596805,
-0.0070103244,
-0.0370702073,
0.0671264604,
-0.0248970799,
0.0185719654,
-0.0051063341,
-0.0096813906,
0.0007330444,
-0.0593249276,
0.0086612049,
-0.0807329342,
0.014394762,
-0.0052940128,
0.007254432,
-0.0302964244,
0.0183894187,
-0.0143413376,
0.004072831,
0.0463172495,
0.0000053408,
0.0241253711,
0.0823744237,
-0.0054145614,
-0.003343062,
0.0164012425,
0.0598116256,
-0.0331737548,
-0.0204583239,
0.0072916267,
-0.0378109477,
0.0488071814,
0.0525711216,
0.0578040071,
-0.0519942157,
-0.0257161707,
0.0022230726,
0.0508268476,
0.063008748,
0.0496279635,
-0.0425398052,
0.0134043451,
0.0516442023,
0.0502911322,
0.0389084183,
0.0117135653,
0.0762582645,
0.0345845781,
-0.0666588545,
0.0111973463,
0.059983775,
0.0086217104,
0.0528203696,
0.0151002062,
0.0559392571,
0.0109841665,
-0.0547970124,
-0.0004355256,
0.0491319299,
-0.0227560587,
0.0485262722,
-0.0527102277,
0.0285404362,
0.0315732583,
-0.0742269531,
0.0646500215,
-0.0061162882,
-0.0953745693,
0.0062299417,
-0.0146491611,
0.0008198632,
0.0130385058,
0.0379056372,
0.0385635495,
0.0053436374,
-0.032293044,
0.0033108101,
0.030752819,
0.0028478072,
0.022498155,
0.0165279172,
-0.0574069582,
-0.0143942265,
0.061171975,
-0.000761003,
0.0079183904,
-0.0499602221,
0.0612873137,
0.0468180478,
0.0049369317,
-0.0196713097,
-0.0011617183,
-0.0487760305,
-0.009086811,
0.0299553182,
0.0108598005,
0.0225649644,
0.0107281506,
-0.0307552181,
0.0177645925,
-0.004343953,
-0.0353389382,
-0.0059222928,
0.0184608772,
-0.0478041992,
-0.0607285127,
0.0430848449,
-0.029310463,
0.0241078418,
0.0213524457,
0.0232679639,
-0.0668239072,
0.040985249,
-0.0183160789,
0.0225691441,
-0.0280121621,
0.0309695806,
0.0592339188,
0.0307776239,
0.0133713428,
0.0052184239,
0.0038762619,
-0.0169843156,
0.0275370404,
0.0531443246,
-0.0022490248,
-0.0505296253,
0.0184956454,
-0.0004886282,
-0.0065838415,
0.0267642941,
-0.0030429917,
-0.0076449416,
-0.0199156962,
0.0044406732,
-0.064745374,
0.0200974885,
-0.0186637975,
-0.0133941937,
0.0307544563,
0.0466544703,
0.0294683408,
0.0178011935,
-0.0437698029,
0.0075650779,
0.0229143836,
-0.0249574445,
-0.0187136699,
-0.0228372887,
-0.0293227118,
-0.0203350186,
-0.0069253817,
0.0297004338,
-0.0046859393,
-0.0283936765,
-0.040037699,
-0.0029827999,
0.0755440369,
-0.0104524512,
0.0237337947,
-0.0176618844,
-0.0284997579,
0.019324718,
0.0016435261,
0.0957110599,
-0.0083543137,
0.0375979468,
-0.0043034074,
-0.0297045056,
-0.0680533051,
-0.0296461973,
0.0017766281,
-0.0209696852,
0.0389223956,
0.0054634917,
-0.0305771232,
-0.0299828462,
0.0253018737,
0.0501408949,
-0.0107966205,
-0.0646454021,
-0.0621242449,
-0.021431407,
-0.0232503321,
-0.0213660188,
0.0151648764,
-0.021929644,
-0.0113794859,
-0.0302447248,
-0.0547897965,
0.0124149602,
-0.0949180424,
-0.0132250655,
-0.0435969085,
-0.0174999777,
0.0081360629,
-0.0138368364,
-0.0287385508,
0.0265571717,
-0.0392261334,
0.0025875999,
-0.0354831666,
0.0220975168,
0.0023889339,
-0.0456291921,
0.0234622434,
-0.0171232857,
0.0177745428,
-0.0308384299,
0.029445583,
-0.0238476302,
-0.0548817888,
0.0406215414,
0.0085096778,
-0.0418454818,
-0.0305842292,
-0.0282978714,
0.0424184613,
0.0278735217,
0.0360191204,
0.0088098012,
0.0023444281,
-0.0324433669,
0.0572400279,
0.0384771824,
0.0172797106,
-0.0291325469,
-0.0421493985,
0.0250950903,
-0.0129363751,
0.036741171,
0.0191580579,
-0.0296360645,
-0.0158315394,
-0.0078236032,
0.0377822742,
-0.0217216853,
0.0164394863,
0.0666155443,
0.0007148946,
0.0012579627,
0.080087781,
-0.0104037216,
-0.0067765997,
0.0085086972,
0.0174152907,
0.0817976817,
-0.0120009845,
-0.0305681285,
-0.0592509247,
-0.0221143626,
0.0142321354,
0.0203663204,
0.0096120667,
0.0071812333,
-0.0319403857,
-0.0677864105,
0.053407494,
0.0727372095,
0.0223286189,
-0.0136416377,
-0.0095803961,
-0.0363234319,
0.0336368755,
-0.0082011279,
0.0125349425,
0.0043379758,
0.0135689983,
0.033182662,
0.0053740521,
-0.0132147949,
-0.0272368602,
-0.0216527097,
0.0298207607,
0.0783094317,
0.0227403883,
0.0205890238,
-0.0481215417,
0.0698464289,
-0.0120131653,
0.0103581231,
0.008497525,
0.0077486229,
0.0324629694,
-0.0046646297,
0.0151981311,
0.0340497233,
-0.0189315658,
0.0360304825,
-0.0268175453,
0.0520854108,
-0.0116162924,
-0.0091143623,
-0.0061634071,
0.02961752,
0.0398974791,
0.0335762165,
0.0047368635,
-0.0265753493,
-0.0485988706,
-0.0043804646,
0.0449757241,
0.0158711225,
-0.0568199828,
-0.0253906604,
-0.0007750543,
-0.0920560136,
-0.085808292,
0.0049756453,
-0.0301081985,
0.0778069571,
0.004668694,
0.0345597044,
0.0028650591,
-0.0095877778,
-0.0440044366,
-0.0050708712,
-0.021140188,
0.0397227444,
-0.0417745076,
-0.0234224163,
0.0157315284,
-0.0144767063,
0.0048065558,
0.025257552,
-0.1149730682,
-0.0566538349,
-0.0217878222,
-0.0384952836,
0.0158108156,
0.0405014791,
-0.0269503742,
0.0153445136,
0.1246095598,
-0.0273179822,
-0.0010438112,
0.0443840511,
0.0360142663,
-0.0094312774,
0.0043411357,
0.0164731983,
0.0039519742,
0.020349836,
-0.0469110906,
0.0617705025,
-0.0012875507,
-0.0051441626,
-0.0049616629,
-0.0079716956,
0.0201573763,
0.0159208812,
0.0763344765,
-0.0141121205,
0.0096385833,
-0.0098057166,
0.0200705584,
-0.0568544045,
0.0028469097,
0.0610013828,
-0.0010942461,
-0.002413291,
-0.0192386173,
-0.0218213461,
-0.0164868832,
0.0142927421,
0.0166469906,
0.0374718942,
0.0342130028,
0.0167427249,
-0.0006758121,
0.0103608249,
-0.0110664442,
-0.0103386519,
0.0119273923,
-0.0145934084,
0.0388803296,
-0.0033050792,
0.0371381752,
0.0187649187,
-0.0112540293,
0.0233702604,
-0.007396894,
-0.008728846,
-0.0094805919,
0.0345541425,
0.0381551199,
0.0892206281,
-0.0039568502,
0.0358611606,
-0.039300032,
0.0287011079,
-0.0396864153,
0.0206743423,
0.0129052335,
-0.0171966571,
0.0190958921,
0.0524076372,
0.0359979793,
-0.014806075,
0.0037251369,
-0.0637139529,
0.0293434579,
-0.0028626476,
-0.0363789052,
-0.0521834604,
-0.0337624364,
0.0318833925,
0.0191882011,
-0.0087940982,
-0.0762095675,
-0.0035485614,
-0.0173401684,
0.0061627803,
-0.0425484926,
0.0544039421,
-0.0132233975,
-0.0220087152,
0.0485160053,
-0.0313044637,
-0.0027209506,
-0.0166494865,
-0.0211970601,
-0.0406192094,
-6.287382797e-33,
-0.0356105603,
-0.0154135181,
0.0339020975,
-0.0463513285,
-0.0934863985,
-0.0550101548,
-0.0686002895,
0.0102273487,
0.0159802623,
0.0076872292,
-0.0031399177,
0.0266853552,
0.0181510635,
0.0228104535,
-0.0364016257,
0.0423504487,
0.0830473006,
-0.0538873486,
-0.0399543047,
0.0515208393,
0.0534330755,
0.0320034921,
-0.0375998132,
-0.0483595468,
-0.0052850959,
-0.0236283448,
0.0015362395,
-0.0290771034,
0.0755994692,
-0.0278656688,
-0.008873634,
-0.0096773319,
-0.0183432288,
-0.028973043,
-0.0420389213,
0.020264389,
-0.0770319775,
0.0042880247,
-0.0097175427,
-0.0064567002,
-0.0254306067,
-0.0246926509,
0.0292584654,
-0.0027065931,
-0.0030437065,
-0.0008042066,
0.00317802,
-0.0241185948,
0.0001385305,
-0.0122561026,
-0.0490819775,
0.0481773764,
-0.0317397267,
-0.0176585801,
0.0432240814,
0.019264631,
-0.0102198524,
-0.0303126462,
-0.0850186124,
0.0392662063,
0.0086655905,
0.074597992,
0.0479992405,
-0.014719977,
0.0469022803,
-0.0119358283,
0.043681521,
-0.0334229022,
0.0353739224,
0.0140906116,
0.0082483608,
0.0308743436,
-0.0107447179,
-0.0136320759,
0.0478552431,
-0.0536776781,
-0.0659300536,
0.0139565198,
-0.0457715914,
-0.0229497887,
0.0487947725,
0.0154830776,
0.0025968377,
0.0054117208,
-0.0463330522,
-0.041087877,
0.0090925442,
-0.0266345963,
0.0309744384,
0.0267383885,
0.0288741793,
-0.0551028624,
0.0924888477,
-0.0010310214,
-0.0090703089,
-0.0400977321,
-0.0413438976,
0.0224094037,
0.00155024,
-0.0083192782,
-0.0272630658,
-0.0397203341,
0.048573073,
0.0895844549,
0.0045699775,
0.0083452091,
-0.0518803596,
0.0325881653,
-0.0214866828,
-0.0155313546,
-0.0213875268,
0.0297834855,
-0.0373562984,
0.0394186638,
-0.0023771692,
-0.0237607975,
-0.008915483,
0.0374663584,
-0.0392036811,
-0.0166473165,
0.0306752585,
0.0695565641,
0.0070856847,
0.0321577154,
-0.0776682347,
0.0202181004,
-0.0063778246,
0.059973333,
0.0951394439,
-0.0311298873,
-0.0389498882,
0.0321564004,
2.882e-7,
-0.0490986705,
-0.0178009011,
0.0143291848,
-0.0097107282,
0.0406883582,
0.0236822832,
-0.0394578166,
-0.0079694903,
-0.0009271973,
-0.0266982205,
0.0057902508,
0.0228912793,
0.0749722421,
-0.0282618757,
-0.0474293046,
-0.0628844351,
-0.0243682917,
0.0255148169,
0.000561768,
-0.0033287148,
0.0031588604,
0.0468996614,
-0.053031262,
-0.0242699049,
0.0476279147,
0.0343161933,
0.0777821243,
0.0390208773,
0.0410035029,
-0.0315323547,
-0.0105711324,
-0.0490880236,
-0.0521285906,
-0.0499992855,
-0.0313770287,
0.0252942517,
0.0402670577,
0.0536453277,
-0.0270574987,
-0.0837771893,
0.0395380668,
0.0201191697,
-0.0473929271,
0.0346405171,
0.0269432869,
-0.0088811321,
0.0062258537,
0.0444085933,
-0.0394127592,
0.0566395931,
-0.0070403283,
0.0006649607,
-0.04153293,
-0.0096242502,
0.0517887436,
0.0171095319,
-0.0045588426,
-0.015721716,
-0.0089586014,
-0.0316956975,
-0.0592782311,
-0.071027346,
-0.0294180252,
0.0213923901,
0.0109868376,
0.0404840484,
-0.0195312109,
2.20318544e-34,
0.0322432891,
-0.0245703366,
0.0131445471,
-0.0509564243,
0.0137802055,
-0.0267645009,
0.0060106362,
-0.0042436332,
0.0058404687,
-0.0489447042,
-0.0751018822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17568v1 | Navigating to Success in Multi-Modal Human-Robot Collaboration: Analysis and Corpus Release | 2023-10-26T16:56:01 | 2023-10-26T16:56:01 | Stephanie M. Lukin, Kimberly A. Pollard, Claire Bonial, Taylor Hudson, Ron Arstein, Clare Voss, David Traum | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.RO | Human-guided robotic exploration is a useful approach to gathering
information at remote locations, especially those that might be too risky,
inhospitable, or inaccessible for humans. Maintaining common ground between the
remotely-located partners is a challenge, one that can be facilitated by
multi-modal communication. In this paper, we explore how participants utilized
multiple modalities to investigate a remote location with the help of a robotic
partner. Participants issued spoken natural language instructions and received
from the robot: text-based feedback, continuous 2D LIDAR mapping, and
upon-request static photographs. We noticed that different strategies were
adopted in terms of use of the modalities, and hypothesize that these
differences may be correlated with success at several exploration sub-tasks. We
found that requesting photos may have improved the identification and counting
of some key entities (doorways in particular) and that this strategy did not
hinder the amount of overall area exploration. Future work with larger samples
may reveal the effects of more nuanced photo and dialogue strategies, which can
inform the training of robotic agents. Additionally, we announce the release of
our unique multi-modal corpus of human-robot communication in an exploration
context: SCOUT, the Situated Corpus on Understanding Transactions. | [
0.0333570428,
0.0085519524,
0.0002733831,
-0.0280561708,
-0.0243984908,
0.0038215786,
-0.0014640914,
-0.0359279029,
-0.0144031961,
-0.0566531941,
-0.0711340457,
-0.002300679,
0.0383568481,
0.0054486273,
0.0004831296,
-0.0736149848,
0.0195984226,
-0.0736085176,
-0.0209221356,
0.0290613677,
-0.0253650136,
-0.0046957643,
-0.0655898899,
0.0373892747,
-0.0133320512,
0.0265315678,
-0.0814271867,
0.0113594467,
0.0325138122,
-0.0875274315,
-0.0484250784,
0.0259174891,
0.1021541208,
-0.0195389856,
0.0000018521,
-0.0457902998,
0.0007918857,
0.0010529829,
0.030183468,
-0.0941102579,
0.0356873795,
0.002396605,
0.0508214273,
-0.0168700535,
-0.0201554485,
-0.0431000553,
0.0660971627,
0.0327533595,
-0.0020324183,
0.023014145,
0.0012315823,
-0.0190054104,
-0.0506496541,
0.023761088,
0.0198273901,
-0.0197586231,
0.0104359202,
0.0350473821,
0.0944674462,
0.0083945394,
0.004378817,
-0.0243137758,
0.0104075419,
-0.0094467569,
0.0146395629,
0.0910104364,
-0.0007092333,
-0.0904037878,
-0.016333472,
0.033400137,
0.0488916822,
0.0166456457,
0.0033951486,
0.0233325046,
-0.001503945,
0.0660780594,
-0.0208167899,
0.0571581833,
-0.0376993231,
-0.0158017632,
-0.0750407875,
-0.016035106,
-0.0037141729,
0.0315997861,
0.0256017186,
0.0624928102,
-0.0067893304,
0.0119403861,
0.0058567775,
0.0386668518,
0.0147926072,
-0.0567146093,
0.0011429898,
0.0366255529,
-0.0635230243,
0.0242143478,
-0.0284879953,
0.0510644801,
0.02213105,
0.0534470417,
-0.0133923003,
0.0134112108,
-0.0501904711,
0.019876102,
0.0254082512,
0.0006295043,
0.0288143437,
0.0379105248,
0.0000293922,
-0.0125562893,
-0.0651587248,
0.0200959407,
-0.0455161668,
0.0078942459,
0.0058796629,
-0.0124562606,
0.0390756205,
0.0515575446,
0.0328141265,
-0.0218016896,
-0.0623850599,
-0.0003875448,
-0.0483759083,
0.0158842336,
-0.0076341266,
-0.035089545,
-0.0340118632,
0.0667690188,
0.0105121024,
-0.016344972,
-0.002916262,
0.0406922102,
-0.0022106175,
-0.0048674513,
-0.0646552444,
0.0470897183,
0.0005399683,
-0.0791958421,
0.0094690276,
-0.0137126045,
0.0151248137,
-0.0201887693,
0.037743438,
-0.0333701372,
-0.0011147343,
0.0076294183,
-0.0166221801,
0.0313269347,
0.0116204247,
0.0069479067,
0.0055985367,
0.0906617567,
0.0120588867,
0.0057817749,
0.0232809018,
0.040840365,
0.0029476914,
0.0364679359,
0.0152863059,
0.0744372979,
0.0106327543,
0.0205030516,
0.0122188181,
-0.0074239159,
-0.0638403594,
0.000405945,
0.0463074595,
-0.0191879906,
0.0022636338,
0.0425405987,
-0.030715216,
0.0201859158,
-0.0145044755,
0.0576623008,
0.0163726229,
0.0817072392,
-0.0045005674,
-0.0694601089,
0.0010342944,
0.0179632828,
-0.0196657572,
-0.0356928892,
0.0072997739,
-0.0006879654,
0.0033742324,
-0.0078459634,
0.0143662607,
0.0131459422,
-0.0260455329,
-0.0039942237,
-0.0511921532,
0.0219926201,
0.0977986678,
-0.011817785,
0.0382812135,
-0.0196295828,
0.0092818281,
0.0021377169,
-0.0152894072,
-0.0226619951,
-0.0207831915,
-0.0062689278,
0.0249507781,
0.0173179843,
-0.0026433321,
0.0097465562,
0.0004576419,
0.0276826452,
0.0125585888,
-0.001751447,
0.0164761525,
0.0022617923,
0.0364040956,
-0.0153149869,
-0.0607266687,
0.0033241117,
0.0029984724,
0.0366415344,
-0.0159194916,
0.0381644778,
-0.0006002492,
-0.0025714166,
0.0166384093,
0.027271729,
0.048182223,
0.0245835502,
-0.0177260488,
0.0259559937,
-0.0060639824,
0.0458912179,
-0.0118821459,
0.0130382013,
0.0458413884,
0.0427864939,
-0.0183320679,
0.1043488756,
0.0029668042,
0.0171223953,
0.0006367294,
-0.0829196945,
-0.0208267216,
0.0025283955,
0.0135280499,
-0.0318127647,
0.0060187494,
-0.0627578869,
0.0099400282,
0.0077910945,
0.0012267939,
0.0470678695,
-0.0058325781,
-0.0513751358,
-0.0033853303,
-0.0188959856,
-0.0284872316,
-0.0014633895,
0.0092289224,
0.0190358106,
-0.0149467122,
0.0154346293,
0.0328194723,
0.0146657377,
-0.021712197,
0.0213070121,
0.034025535,
-0.0484137163,
0.0105979638,
-0.1130944937,
-0.0494812094,
-0.0185785592,
-0.0065244683,
0.0298674889,
-0.0443908013,
0.0023121228,
-0.0088954009,
0.0221740119,
0.0161939114,
-0.0132292146,
0.0089979572,
0.0257688146,
0.0343209282,
-0.0077191354,
-0.0023511085,
0.0045681624,
0.0029089213,
0.0002479621,
0.0797612295,
-0.0741937011,
-0.0794453919,
0.0351045765,
-0.0183953531,
-0.033653602,
-0.0348851867,
-0.035427127,
0.0850908235,
-0.0298246183,
0.0011170151,
0.0006886602,
0.0151995644,
0.0454286337,
0.0993651301,
0.0007525652,
-0.0062910109,
-0.0267083179,
0.0088110361,
-0.0086201401,
0.0013301334,
-0.0215746779,
0.0215090457,
-0.0342372581,
-0.0324514285,
0.0349795558,
0.0128091378,
-0.0405616127,
-0.0337531976,
-0.1034744903,
-0.0146721881,
-0.0197916739,
-0.0394657999,
0.018696826,
-0.013126567,
-0.0207387377,
0.017850969,
0.0065548085,
-0.0215081647,
-0.0313348435,
-0.0011750851,
0.0077902209,
0.0639329925,
-0.0078334128,
0.0099361725,
0.0611895658,
-0.040650297,
0.0138290096,
-0.0394285657,
-0.0038721219,
0.0292238761,
-0.0191484895,
-0.1074400395,
0.0149784982,
0.052225437,
-0.0469616391,
-0.0087163299,
0.0145678176,
-0.0182508174,
0.0126286605,
-0.0383321941,
-0.0508222878,
-0.0003608743,
-0.0155022712,
0.0698272809,
0.0012077671,
0.0340538882,
-0.0209931973,
-0.014435838,
-0.0006786685,
0.0175449587,
0.1024349257,
0.0140860165,
-0.0039449176,
-0.032553643,
0.0451612286,
0.0034064138,
-0.0200481787,
-0.0120270019,
0.0077085737,
0.0149889635,
0.051639013,
-0.0340529494,
0.0323159844,
0.1101510897,
-0.004028026,
-0.0214116778,
0.0220529009,
0.0295108184,
-0.0471145995,
0.0050891573,
-0.042174805,
-0.0171980858,
0.0031929412,
-0.0334343202,
-0.0421652533,
-0.0016358746,
0.0319494046,
0.0264494643,
-0.0269241463,
-0.0193340611,
0.011532506,
-0.1142261922,
0.0292850137,
-0.0154988021,
-0.0484267585,
-0.038699422,
-0.084302783,
0.0245134663,
0.0019012584,
-0.0588994101,
-0.0145396478,
-0.0240367353,
-0.0024502205,
0.0314987861,
0.028018659,
-0.0125644989,
0.0030017006,
-0.0599921755,
0.0258445926,
0.0328573249,
0.029476637,
-0.0112792188,
-0.0062142247,
-0.0090619894,
0.0600530989,
0.0672222748,
-0.0206170529,
-0.0275686029,
-0.0232973378,
0.0222218391,
0.0109537877,
0.0376859158,
-0.015472847,
-0.0533316992,
-0.0233910345,
0.0105986195,
-0.0537570231,
0.0323065072,
-0.0213111099,
0.0452573858,
0.0583463833,
0.0357276388,
-0.0397726595,
0.0175613575,
0.0097471243,
0.0018224047,
0.0066937869,
0.0226192474,
-0.0331715457,
0.0256518647,
-0.0416598059,
-0.0353189446,
-0.0577378981,
-0.0945570543,
0.0391292199,
0.0217579287,
-0.0086854976,
-0.0207007416,
-0.0088383807,
0.0513654687,
-0.0338134468,
0.080676727,
0.0272932816,
-0.0100681242,
-0.0125636142,
0.0044861655,
-0.0282444879,
-0.0548818409,
0.0101220831,
-0.0121554062,
-0.0635022372,
-0.0586597249,
0.0274684243,
0.0238393396,
0.0166879166,
-0.0149108497,
0.0046565239,
-0.0469825938,
-0.0180197097,
0.0085444935,
-0.0060898,
0.0075087287,
-0.0160354339,
0.0407224111,
0.0213076528,
-0.0191910788,
-0.0201971773,
-0.0360868089,
-0.0391512662,
-0.0064043067,
-0.0739612654,
-0.0574418046,
-0.0007381812,
-0.0047337604,
0.096039556,
-0.0092148697,
0.0261379667,
-0.0214153547,
-0.0265620165,
-0.016707873,
0.018185053,
-0.0359678715,
0.0474007651,
-0.0232085884,
-0.000416156,
0.0459599048,
0.0471778549,
-0.0245527476,
0.037838757,
-0.0067316759,
0.0123557709,
0.0629920736,
0.0002381176,
-0.0429032259,
0.0254314747,
-0.0152773373,
0.0278478824,
-0.0086684376,
0.0402201191,
0.03502509,
0.0717537701,
0.0289767478,
-0.03856894,
0.003824264,
0.0399020426,
-0.0199285299,
-0.0896834433,
0.0145092504,
0.0196663626,
0.0470407084,
0.0485008284,
-0.0053664884,
-0.0776840001,
0.0255623888,
-0.0091391951,
0.0161168408,
0.0067830151,
-0.0083190398,
0.0519410186,
0.0173748527,
-0.018035464,
0.0209946539,
0.0259562135,
-0.043341808,
0.0422901399,
-0.0287598185,
0.00262643,
-0.0404422283,
0.0219726767,
0.0161977913,
0.0294960011,
-0.0164708048,
0.0148043185,
0.0060688509,
0.0007743942,
-0.0165223554,
0.0238156542,
0.0103748767,
-0.0059571587,
0.0712543875,
-0.0084147071,
-0.0276619513,
-0.0556285903,
-0.0466593951,
-0.0273758601,
0.017139202,
0.0090006776,
-0.0459307842,
-5.61360817e-33,
-0.0053601568,
-0.1092350855,
0.0539657623,
-0.0346036367,
0.0043143011,
-0.036033608,
-0.0084580202,
0.0531368591,
0.0043421974,
0.0145017477,
0.0193968024,
-0.0255113114,
0.0100231562,
-0.0027231718,
0.0369706601,
0.0367578007,
0.0296795517,
0.0275628176,
-0.0253948886,
-0.0470140949,
0.0664140284,
0.0095737288,
0.0134496391,
-0.1099239886,
0.0304747708,
0.0327360407,
-0.0508055426,
0.0225804951,
0.0075262138,
-0.002422275,
-0.0209031515,
-0.032461334,
0.010685361,
0.0064953482,
-0.0396988243,
0.0424240492,
-0.0131264795,
-0.0206691567,
0.0012128032,
0.0618002824,
-0.0347017199,
-0.0212899167,
-0.0183238592,
-0.0295023825,
0.0187829826,
0.0203705225,
-0.0015012696,
0.0304925125,
-0.0073533496,
0.0422522351,
0.0005566372,
0.0302289594,
-0.0007253836,
-0.0682479367,
0.0477352813,
0.0868800879,
-0.0074778888,
-0.0024608125,
-0.010820495,
0.060429588,
-0.0355700627,
0.0033089221,
0.0387704447,
0.0000314306,
0.0199456941,
0.0556663089,
0.0031828117,
-0.0217946954,
-0.0204432532,
-0.0650005117,
-0.0219419412,
0.0860491022,
-0.0415010974,
0.0610638894,
-0.0214732271,
0.0418482795,
0.0176112782,
-0.000076901,
-0.0490045175,
0.0537739769,
-0.0265819356,
0.0654239804,
-0.0111959083,
0.0412184559,
0.0024776356,
0.002050967,
0.0117264045,
-0.0397582129,
0.006749636,
0.0279626623,
-0.0376483239,
0.0012049843,
0.0108558591,
-0.0087752165,
0.0015797826,
-0.0102907773,
-0.0310856458,
0.0368768089,
-0.0088340528,
-0.021421507,
-0.0799561515,
-0.0290514845,
0.0640090704,
0.0176498145,
0.0200788472,
0.0398417413,
-0.0678766221,
0.0546121746,
0.0265801065,
-0.0217136182,
0.0029714208,
-0.0328744538,
0.0353965946,
-0.0137927262,
0.0857456177,
-0.0152299264,
-0.046728503,
0.0603835881,
-0.0061913654,
-0.0206383653,
-0.02750054,
-0.0404028222,
-0.0460179336,
-0.0226009041,
0.0054995869,
0.001811494,
-0.0226148441,
-0.0588427745,
0.0367430411,
0.0056399852,
-0.0164003987,
0.0173514206,
2.86e-7,
-0.0161342286,
0.0540156513,
0.027705824,
0.0122676929,
-0.0113526825,
0.0254402589,
0.020160418,
0.0800627694,
-0.023909552,
-0.0299755149,
0.0013013065,
-0.0066071204,
-0.0067529427,
0.0060149217,
-0.035883043,
-0.0452113785,
0.0311899818,
-0.0433574505,
-0.0375883169,
0.0047257016,
0.0676635355,
0.0192240346,
-0.0455476493,
0.0105221728,
0.0125080021,
-0.0569225773,
0.0066699642,
-0.0603029691,
-0.0279958807,
-0.0448150039,
0.046531599,
0.0138344467,
-0.0181486178,
-0.0029668987,
-0.0071004955,
-0.0405634008,
-0.0075516361,
0.0176055711,
-0.0178170186,
-0.0904302672,
0.0001015883,
0.0265480708,
-0.0201189667,
-0.0198779367,
0.0202786736,
-0.0441434868,
0.0102045434,
0.0329645462,
0.0237333756,
-0.0152076716,
0.0187981557,
-0.0064030443,
0.011888342,
-0.0046366774,
-0.0251446832,
0.0099402349,
-0.0306765474,
-0.0409711935,
-0.005051882,
-0.0047589038,
-0.0711717606,
-0.029149171,
0.0086975815,
-0.0792165622,
-0.0363623649,
-0.0347994156,
-0.0655830875,
1.242324534e-34,
-0.0110761905,
-0.0079641836,
-0.0379644223,
0.0186937489,
0.0251879413,
0.031504754,
-0.0378008373,
0.0088761579,
0.0333466791,
-0.0214663912,
-0.002682718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17567v1 | Skill-Mix: a Flexible and Expandable Family of Evaluations for AI models | 2023-10-26T16:55:05 | 2023-10-26T16:55:05 | Dingli Yu, Simran Kaur, Arushi Gupta, Jonah Brown-Cohen, Anirudh Goyal, Sanjeev Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | With LLMs shifting their role from statistical modeling of language to
serving as general-purpose AI agents, how should LLM evaluations change?
Arguably, a key ability of an AI agent is to flexibly combine, as needed, the
basic skills it has learned. The capability to combine skills plays an
important role in (human) pedagogy and also in a paper on emergence phenomena
(Arora & Goyal, 2023).
This work introduces Skill-Mix, a new evaluation to measure ability to
combine skills. Using a list of $N$ skills the evaluator repeatedly picks
random subsets of $k$ skills and asks the LLM to produce text combining that
subset of skills. Since the number of subsets grows like $N^k$, for even modest
$k$ this evaluation will, with high probability, require the LLM to produce
text significantly different from any text in the training set. The paper
develops a methodology for (a) designing and administering such an evaluation,
and (b) automatic grading (plus spot-checking by humans) of the results using
GPT-4 as well as the open LLaMA-2 70B model.
Administering a version of to popular chatbots gave results that, while
generally in line with prior expectations, contained surprises. Sizeable
differences exist among model capabilities that are not captured by their
ranking on popular LLM leaderboards ("cramming for the leaderboard").
Furthermore, simple probability calculations indicate that GPT-4's reasonable
performance on $k=5$ is suggestive of going beyond "stochastic parrot" behavior
(Bender et al., 2021), i.e., it combines skills in ways that it had not seen
during training.
We sketch how the methodology can lead to a Skill-Mix based eco-system of
open evaluations for AI capabilities of future models. | [
0.0331031717,
0.015606056,
-0.0337733775,
-0.0080311289,
-0.0230538305,
0.0237576067,
-0.007652937,
0.0019362724,
0.0502884835,
-0.0313906446,
-0.0338312462,
-0.0104642762,
0.0153733548,
0.0342412405,
0.0329665057,
-0.0600977018,
0.0126618529,
-0.0253525134,
0.00026772,
-0.0095530702,
-0.0143703939,
-0.0060996204,
-0.0362384692,
0.0646838099,
0.0127830524,
-0.0045057223,
-0.0224010814,
-0.0413274728,
0.0134760626,
-0.0056670057,
-0.0209046919,
0.0139748082,
-0.0077665229,
0.0151238656,
0.0000020374,
-0.058397565,
0.0135434596,
-0.0006744096,
-0.0303538721,
-0.0217662472,
0.0544340946,
0.0605256036,
-0.0157754011,
0.0287138429,
-0.075723961,
-0.001283443,
0.0282211769,
-0.0247964226,
0.0399379134,
0.0705346391,
0.0324586183,
0.0193752032,
0.0689260513,
0.0087291403,
0.0446621925,
-0.061211139,
0.012298421,
0.0038616739,
0.0537432656,
0.0009571266,
-0.0017070239,
0.0037516481,
0.0503889024,
-0.0157167763,
0.0348465107,
0.0479775928,
-0.0114166699,
-0.0351159498,
-0.0259277709,
0.0202981941,
-0.0089684771,
-0.0055951858,
0.0047612977,
-0.0031593365,
0.0569942556,
0.0310921259,
-0.0580649227,
0.0312730633,
-0.002285562,
0.0000990259,
0.0237520337,
-0.0133981295,
0.0220967904,
0.0241484344,
0.0119488863,
0.0511835515,
0.0025158611,
-0.046644289,
0.0180260669,
0.0313183405,
0.0382987969,
-0.0814824477,
-0.029115947,
0.0695561022,
-0.0324860662,
0.0091419006,
-0.0369101502,
0.0204812344,
0.0028361359,
-0.0199060496,
0.0240813289,
0.021853799,
-0.0004217137,
0.0423914604,
-0.0202074386,
0.0593361929,
0.0393231176,
0.0463155285,
-0.0356849618,
-0.0002435227,
-0.1150194779,
-0.0095021175,
0.0153007032,
0.0545747913,
0.0277122352,
-0.003803924,
-0.0520002693,
0.0302069318,
-0.0579159595,
0.0150895901,
0.0056043225,
-0.0056143836,
-0.0108564375,
0.0163058732,
-0.0555564575,
-0.0307430048,
-0.013868467,
0.0311867315,
0.0509550162,
-0.0582081005,
-0.005562576,
0.0097469259,
-0.0030731948,
0.01607644,
0.0271367095,
0.0871174634,
-0.017727077,
-0.0117600271,
0.0060764109,
-0.0391220413,
0.0034853448,
-0.0671945587,
0.0306656845,
-0.0749855042,
0.0282334872,
-0.0411957391,
0.0045040348,
-0.0179651398,
-0.0092827249,
-0.0008359856,
-0.0139963906,
0.0367097408,
-0.0103119127,
0.0211043712,
0.0375056937,
0.0205783267,
-0.0452560857,
0.0549988113,
0.0512689613,
0.020895103,
0.0096480986,
0.0019789394,
0.0493232012,
0.0259148311,
-0.0275882427,
-0.0106481016,
0.0150550148,
-0.0099790497,
-0.0145409787,
0.0093454681,
0.0010053709,
0.0221000016,
-0.0433361568,
0.0264261849,
0.0496117733,
0.0749347806,
0.0036268458,
0.0180478506,
0.0819458142,
0.0225053355,
0.0677139536,
0.0307346005,
-0.048556067,
0.0227683354,
-0.0490896739,
0.0025369748,
0.0096860556,
0.0332510769,
-0.0320535861,
-0.0925181434,
0.0073560877,
-0.0287846364,
0.0185020994,
0.0323110409,
0.0203689355,
0.0045874473,
-0.0299628396,
-0.0259103719,
0.0130380681,
-0.0761216655,
0.0065429839,
-0.1039452255,
0.0172067005,
0.0900253803,
0.0423759669,
-0.0329662971,
-0.023187913,
0.0220257007,
-0.0397794768,
0.0314169712,
0.0337358043,
-0.0285901111,
-0.0107308095,
-0.0334388502,
-0.0452371649,
-0.0193796623,
0.0301022716,
0.0363694392,
0.0023451427,
0.0018437052,
-0.0101035126,
-0.0060250615,
-0.0572486892,
0.0278860945,
-0.0184264854,
-0.0158517044,
-0.0193547625,
-0.0103008784,
0.0570003875,
0.0198527873,
-0.006988538,
0.0283182561,
0.0202306435,
0.0098088123,
-0.0607730262,
0.0172809195,
0.0009610009,
0.0137483096,
0.0414585248,
-0.0359623805,
-0.0298560429,
0.04451878,
-0.0131802168,
-0.0282522421,
0.0176096056,
-0.0344528742,
0.0422956571,
-0.0053420728,
0.0394799076,
-0.0403230786,
-0.0146247018,
0.0032603238,
0.0874377266,
0.0186455995,
-0.0118085863,
-0.0351220034,
0.0360740609,
0.003564948,
-0.0640984997,
-0.0084886793,
-0.0012495328,
-0.000199566,
0.0661917925,
0.0179089494,
0.0350583792,
-0.0704768077,
-0.0788480937,
-0.0998426229,
0.0104529671,
0.0096375355,
0.0067769075,
0.011032111,
-0.047330521,
-0.0063916617,
0.0245971698,
-0.0500713699,
-0.0118512344,
0.0345425047,
0.0192577485,
0.0146968411,
0.0003816924,
-0.0519679561,
-0.0292851608,
0.0119039202,
-0.0316099897,
0.0110209715,
0.0506491475,
0.0538603701,
-0.0239762887,
0.0648448169,
-0.0405545831,
-0.0099992156,
-0.0145118022,
-0.0618566684,
0.0496109053,
-0.0167750437,
-0.0210218802,
0.083811,
0.0099789845,
0.0067535411,
0.0599797778,
0.0000859596,
-0.0219347104,
0.0149586583,
0.0068828794,
-0.0350048058,
-0.041991055,
-0.0384362563,
-0.0244463235,
0.0192874279,
0.0166240875,
0.0069733495,
-0.0529864915,
0.0454047099,
-0.017658608,
-0.0578071102,
0.0106020123,
-0.0282297172,
-0.018084798,
0.0389762446,
-0.0316623934,
-0.0522925705,
0.0639591441,
-0.0218401421,
0.0056080716,
-0.032054238,
-0.0583128147,
-0.0396418162,
0.0419446118,
-0.0192660242,
-0.0093359174,
-0.0376883149,
-0.0043637524,
-0.0735041499,
-0.0045048501,
0.0240598992,
-0.058474727,
0.0244455636,
-0.0502988398,
-0.0163489636,
0.0393928289,
-0.0251241419,
-0.050466761,
0.0036177032,
-0.0324326493,
0.0313318819,
0.0150285847,
-0.0407671258,
-0.0287000705,
-0.053117577,
0.031144673,
-0.0185516383,
-0.0158137046,
-0.0218694583,
-0.0033162194,
-0.0161165968,
0.026270723,
0.040852122,
-0.000015179,
-0.0511020645,
0.0183545388,
0.0128063429,
0.0585587658,
0.0127534065,
-0.0225562062,
0.0136486003,
0.0046354416,
-0.0294714589,
-0.0206581801,
0.0612009764,
0.0392411761,
-0.0417849533,
0.0010292176,
0.1065416262,
0.0064265165,
-0.0188564956,
0.0053809248,
0.0159059092,
-0.0121191805,
0.0182675086,
0.057890892,
-0.0583597012,
0.015869597,
-0.0054798638,
0.0449811332,
-0.0415177308,
-0.0347740203,
0.0074748518,
-0.119091168,
0.0527891368,
0.016657535,
-0.0509617217,
-0.0209913086,
-0.0148021728,
-0.0220543928,
-0.0310885496,
-0.0091606192,
-0.0142473429,
-0.0086553888,
0.0036392582,
0.0320906416,
-0.0428653769,
-0.0589761958,
0.0569639951,
-0.0227435138,
0.0904901996,
0.0563580729,
0.0323585533,
-0.0248908773,
-0.0523196943,
0.0069801561,
0.0135549866,
0.012448905,
0.0355473533,
0.0512920357,
-0.0173855033,
0.0079129068,
-0.0305916518,
0.0079495059,
0.0105181551,
0.0042024553,
0.0293150451,
0.0693008453,
-0.0153815523,
-0.0302628744,
-0.0094626034,
0.0082267411,
0.006571163,
0.0621113926,
0.0186486598,
-0.0271639805,
-0.0169861149,
-0.0420678891,
-0.0189219415,
-0.0109507926,
-0.0637209713,
0.029720014,
0.0008075915,
-0.0390452333,
-0.0761577263,
-0.0667569339,
0.0131427487,
0.0271865781,
0.0014643501,
0.0056487885,
-0.0027993345,
0.023061499,
0.0094596567,
-0.0053671245,
-0.0086161243,
-0.000521769,
-0.0689940304,
-0.041195672,
0.0031814254,
-0.0715866238,
-0.0192129947,
-0.0212744325,
-0.0863927081,
-0.0638736933,
0.0136212558,
0.0746709853,
0.0359944925,
0.0158283524,
-0.015245283,
-0.0366574675,
0.0673885122,
0.035906706,
-0.0307815913,
0.059813384,
0.0306812469,
0.010174714,
0.011531177,
0.0037825915,
-0.0728619024,
0.0158791821,
0.0007545521,
-0.0196567457,
-0.0356337503,
-0.0144085893,
0.0087985303,
0.0187282078,
-0.0151291406,
-0.0016385084,
-0.0197281633,
-0.0263791922,
0.0006686188,
0.0052326256,
-0.0191576406,
-0.0359066911,
-0.0295173358,
0.0328290835,
0.0139431134,
0.051526852,
-0.001249549,
-0.0175271928,
0.0241246764,
-0.027661277,
0.0185446441,
0.0098311761,
0.0214791689,
-0.0192903504,
0.0087244706,
-0.0219132584,
-0.0078598531,
-0.0327596553,
0.0369771421,
0.0393396877,
0.013207796,
-0.0157068595,
-0.0053678909,
0.0269395858,
0.0330171473,
-0.1123117134,
-0.1100380644,
0.0178663824,
0.0689374804,
0.060484983,
0.0006287578,
0.0282677636,
-0.0375550687,
0.0247400906,
-0.0126181506,
-0.0066173761,
-0.007267694,
-0.0221219808,
-0.0048570279,
0.0433034115,
0.0112546692,
-0.0435396321,
0.0572928563,
-0.0144887744,
0.0782092214,
-0.0476458035,
-0.003325833,
-0.0271015447,
-0.0408962481,
0.0309060868,
0.0335613489,
0.0023849558,
-0.0161788762,
-0.0735428408,
-0.0610973425,
-0.0048641269,
0.0689670965,
0.0064432849,
-0.0258457735,
0.0276023056,
0.0584555566,
-0.0525900237,
0.0339296721,
-0.0307579916,
-0.0588384271,
0.018398067,
0.0020623545,
-0.0041409703,
-6.201911868e-33,
-0.0375425145,
-0.0483672544,
0.0532033704,
0.0367515385,
0.0032791644,
0.0249584056,
-0.0002867914,
0.023213584,
-0.0350986086,
0.0024069704,
-0.0139867216,
0.0042820242,
-0.002291183,
-0.0249481462,
0.0473915525,
-0.0032052933,
0.0168060288,
-0.0212526098,
-0.0136294262,
-0.0015390902,
-0.0099939136,
-0.026107125,
0.054809086,
-0.0757357553,
0.0472358838,
0.0008371763,
-0.0278259404,
-0.0171075929,
-0.0377583802,
0.0750729218,
0.0243238062,
0.0258030668,
0.0286501385,
-0.0226693638,
-0.0084302416,
-0.0280659888,
0.0177297108,
-0.062092185,
0.0181849264,
-0.0138134081,
-0.022973638,
-0.0530011766,
0.0483733416,
0.001065013,
-0.0700060055,
-0.0234113596,
0.0582545102,
-0.0189320147,
0.0293594152,
0.0164819397,
-0.0366840027,
0.0182971936,
-0.025953941,
-0.0486351028,
-0.0310127642,
-0.0073918053,
-0.0026834309,
-0.0306967739,
-0.0547007583,
0.0559720509,
0.0230608154,
0.0100402227,
0.0859178305,
-0.0077505107,
0.0104842559,
0.0627075508,
0.0540929995,
0.0400286578,
-0.0016262799,
-0.0547828078,
0.024674207,
0.071253866,
0.039192576,
0.0440970659,
0.0197094921,
0.0033665171,
-0.0445563793,
0.0733481124,
0.0809644833,
0.0142568741,
-0.0209674295,
0.0141797569,
-0.0853731707,
-0.0048767845,
-0.0242495965,
-0.0057135881,
-0.0042581786,
-0.0358724631,
0.0321356319,
0.0133769233,
0.0123451892,
-0.0483273342,
-0.002235441,
-0.0449941158,
0.0090112165,
0.0058549219,
-0.0357217342,
0.0401346907,
-0.0033132983,
-0.0124074351,
-0.0265459158,
-0.047287114,
0.0357247293,
0.0210939031,
0.0422367491,
0.0277697481,
0.0096350964,
0.0644497648,
-0.0497041643,
-0.0030008657,
-0.0235941969,
0.005110078,
0.0597549155,
-0.0329760164,
0.0511781424,
-0.0080813468,
-0.0098942136,
0.0152275329,
-0.0383035541,
-0.0143996133,
-0.0394943543,
0.0357240215,
-0.025307484,
-0.0300955959,
-0.024173677,
0.0078152195,
-0.0220357738,
-0.0123874163,
0.0048227697,
-0.0130679719,
-0.016194215,
0.0096604144,
2.864e-7,
-0.0033359416,
0.0158962812,
-0.0131036341,
0.0455497801,
0.0109595153,
0.0415526442,
-0.0532827303,
0.0133665539,
0.0131376451,
-0.0017844813,
0.0106563037,
0.0585240424,
0.0565329343,
0.0147932284,
-0.0604221113,
-0.0566873103,
-0.0337386206,
-0.0039794468,
-0.0428396761,
-0.0153253665,
0.0583232827,
0.053839352,
0.0451758839,
-0.0184125006,
-0.0156151354,
-0.0539236218,
0.0435815789,
-0.0068082931,
-0.0117601482,
0.0164723359,
-0.0044553564,
0.0466402173,
-0.0041173287,
0.0553320833,
-0.0051264456,
0.0076624588,
0.0352322944,
0.0706530809,
-0.0279002544,
0.0034071524,
0.0315324701,
-0.001482266,
-0.0133813852,
-0.0429397859,
0.0654292107,
-0.0030379512,
-0.0410087705,
-0.0382899977,
-0.0285793152,
-0.018592922,
0.0209834222,
0.0016220968,
-0.0081102839,
0.0183278136,
-0.0251111705,
-0.0276359301,
0.017116785,
-0.029587267,
-0.0049796966,
-0.0048213052,
-0.0466622636,
-0.1096896157,
-0.0228751488,
-0.0095536327,
0.0202918258,
-0.0551906638,
0.00253601,
2.502533342e-34,
0.0058432589,
0.0195087846,
0.0539157279,
0.0237205457,
0.0419237018,
0.0311677083,
0.0161558073,
0.0182093475,
0.0313673057,
-0.0313472822,
-0.0185229741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17558v1 | Towards Matching Phones and Speech Representations | 2023-10-26T16:47:52 | 2023-10-26T16:47:52 | Gene-Ping Yang, Hao Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Learning phone types from phone instances has been a long-standing problem,
while still being open. In this work, we revisit this problem in the context of
self-supervised learning, and pose it as the problem of matching cluster
centroids to phone embeddings. We study two key properties that enable
matching, namely, whether cluster centroids of self-supervised representations
reduce the variability of phone instances and respect the relationship among
phones. We then use the matching result to produce pseudo-labels and introduce
a new loss function for improving self-supervised representations. Our
experiments show that the matching result captures the relationship among
phones. Training the new loss function jointly with the regular self-supervised
losses, such as APC and CPC, significantly improves the downstream phone
classification. | [
-0.044618126,
0.0103788199,
-0.0156055931,
0.0404464118,
0.0247764196,
-0.0313212015,
0.0542666577,
-0.0100364666,
0.0190662444,
0.021222597,
-0.0566197671,
0.0022933425,
-0.0155879455,
-0.0430252589,
0.0207004938,
-0.0278185923,
0.0228086878,
0.0289654452,
-0.0195030216,
-0.0171222519,
0.0281004384,
0.0309460405,
-0.0242889225,
0.020930374,
-0.0850202739,
-0.0306385253,
0.0123722702,
0.0112121496,
0.0078153536,
-0.0218361076,
0.0179643109,
0.0062862881,
0.0079436461,
0.0372097492,
0.0000015894,
-0.0447777472,
-0.0196851995,
-0.0147744128,
-0.0454337411,
0.0319667086,
0.0220906138,
0.0353139974,
-0.035221301,
-0.0109581994,
0.002612036,
-0.0540011041,
0.0496014953,
0.0344037786,
0.0391166434,
0.0325467214,
-0.0193164274,
-0.0110682501,
0.0175839681,
-0.0159087088,
0.0093777906,
0.0017810171,
-0.0188296549,
0.0123420106,
-0.019934196,
-0.0585429668,
0.0596046746,
0.0353338793,
0.0049231867,
0.0109140798,
0.0426872522,
0.0609940812,
-0.0480491929,
0.012635164,
0.0092254635,
0.0564168058,
-0.0269631427,
-0.0648364723,
0.0109730903,
0.0195050463,
-0.0041692182,
-0.0484607928,
-0.0009655561,
-0.0342005566,
0.0093495026,
0.0026828204,
-0.0512477458,
0.0727275982,
0.0473468229,
-0.0355199836,
-0.0392977148,
-0.0028802855,
0.0000179143,
-0.0536363274,
-0.0174537059,
0.0004589357,
-0.017326897,
0.0225814525,
0.0842105597,
-0.0110200504,
0.0598970018,
-0.0405091047,
0.0020849314,
-0.0101509131,
-0.0130060716,
-0.0390570424,
0.0071059042,
0.0411340147,
-0.0562217087,
-0.008090158,
-0.0348033197,
-0.0027735697,
-0.0023358592,
0.0266137756,
-0.0355704948,
0.0034272163,
-0.0511202961,
0.0047005294,
-0.0843841359,
0.0556536205,
0.03990959,
0.0066679865,
-0.0366460048,
0.034737505,
-0.0413509943,
0.0231213588,
-0.0211559925,
0.0143530453,
-0.0175712146,
0.0012783806,
0.0276135914,
0.0301972646,
-0.0404483825,
0.0313000828,
-0.0117331007,
-0.0056626974,
0.0008849138,
0.0239012185,
0.0479591079,
0.0008446503,
-0.0151529191,
0.0299974941,
-0.0164218992,
0.0168003011,
-0.0527866632,
-0.0050693615,
-0.0178831592,
-0.0178120825,
-0.0870192274,
-0.0118755428,
0.0295460913,
-0.000729119,
0.0031201455,
-0.0083715878,
-0.0201951172,
-0.0326529555,
0.0406882502,
0.0769514069,
0.0235027689,
0.0041409214,
0.1045693383,
-0.00474458,
-0.0124354875,
0.0296268612,
0.0111184409,
-0.0193370897,
0.0168115161,
-0.0699213296,
-0.0031074553,
0.0271158498,
0.0508426391,
-0.0299139954,
-0.0107913101,
0.0086188549,
0.0483404137,
0.0524866395,
0.0424585417,
0.0050078975,
-0.0505563542,
-0.0562622994,
0.0045161867,
0.107747227,
0.019574089,
0.0633778796,
-0.0256399009,
-0.0141109424,
-0.0023347351,
0.0178335849,
-0.003812636,
-0.0329186358,
-0.027689198,
-0.0237482078,
0.0376510732,
-0.0110398838,
-0.0914653838,
-0.0244999155,
0.0432791188,
-0.0375867449,
-0.009145556,
-0.0331314243,
0.0061676349,
0.0182584617,
0.0634458289,
0.0504223965,
-0.0373356417,
-0.0354216732,
0.0197130609,
-0.0253386032,
0.0206024721,
0.0131152142,
-0.0400823243,
-0.047853142,
0.0113825751,
-0.0043516895,
-0.0200576782,
0.0107447114,
0.0092203747,
-0.0461075939,
0.0314818434,
-0.047590021,
0.0043825214,
0.0260150302,
0.0029988391,
-0.0131614748,
-0.0267729778,
0.0068363408,
0.0311185177,
-0.0677808449,
0.020538874,
-0.0209870581,
0.0376743451,
-0.0245055277,
0.0280901734,
0.0615506433,
-0.0072859507,
0.0179212987,
0.0272690281,
0.0054220771,
0.0254233405,
0.0008165982,
0.0106379092,
-0.0170294624,
-0.0845312178,
-0.0217204019,
0.0100797461,
-0.0155221373,
0.0019187762,
0.0013951345,
0.0061069862,
-0.0506428033,
0.0744492486,
-0.0193934999,
0.1050093174,
-0.0173863899,
0.0440830737,
0.0265320353,
0.0205089767,
0.0006048598,
0.0265913196,
0.0239721853,
-0.0062760841,
-0.0128321266,
0.037774656,
0.0038369261,
-0.0504986942,
0.0033725125,
-0.0120910825,
-0.0436678119,
0.0654413253,
0.0019928152,
-0.0670531094,
-0.0133588715,
0.0103863375,
-0.0687915012,
-0.0077631208,
-0.0025773831,
-0.0031453762,
0.0252124202,
0.0361014493,
0.0314984955,
-0.0546960048,
-0.0325503275,
-0.032171987,
-0.0056526782,
-0.0056442749,
-0.0166336074,
0.001293771,
-0.0152214812,
-0.0209289566,
-0.0315625966,
-0.0131864082,
0.0385630652,
-0.0351639837,
-0.005335669,
-0.0314254239,
-0.0423766337,
0.0038517758,
0.0101617333,
0.012220894,
0.0093845213,
0.0047541424,
0.0236262456,
0.0123906322,
0.0630704165,
0.0114018219,
-0.0139460005,
-0.0170713961,
0.0292414315,
-0.0722223446,
-0.0177111421,
-0.0236995425,
-0.0003702001,
-0.0347849652,
0.002442634,
-0.0161550622,
0.0439028814,
0.0155461738,
0.0408973284,
-0.0239149425,
-0.0714193583,
0.0342442691,
-0.0426856428,
-0.0113223102,
-0.0024806953,
0.0239377245,
0.0028272627,
-0.0113310125,
-0.02144753,
0.0438625365,
-0.0143500473,
-0.0064964499,
-0.0160347838,
-0.0879193991,
0.0084840469,
-0.0063445293,
-0.0047521861,
0.0328641869,
0.0138998358,
-0.0194979161,
-0.0382886715,
-0.006539918,
0.0038715077,
-0.0163072012,
0.0438383669,
0.0293884166,
0.0062975097,
0.0091311149,
-0.1072465926,
-0.0352479517,
0.0149914697,
0.0124362335,
0.0083062593,
-0.0183981284,
-0.0189371258,
-0.0275150165,
0.0407200679,
-0.0085289991,
0.0335535631,
0.0310896095,
0.0045371489,
-0.0153316585,
0.0888396725,
-0.0240639653,
0.0253922306,
-0.0490354002,
0.0418732017,
0.015718678,
0.0230087936,
0.0517970808,
0.0115947146,
-0.0469569191,
0.0282540228,
0.00095265,
-0.0297619477,
-0.0144938016,
0.0006119424,
0.0082285814,
-0.0139771085,
0.0121206362,
0.075400129,
0.0157169942,
-0.038743332,
-0.0164026935,
-0.0449652858,
0.0055433828,
0.0098457737,
-0.0029003255,
0.0344786867,
-0.0026589525,
-0.0081541212,
0.0061860341,
0.0397556759,
0.0467294678,
0.0222753566,
-0.1088010743,
-0.0230549183,
0.0470949598,
-0.0654228851,
-0.0517142192,
-0.0456054993,
-0.0170573443,
-0.0489523895,
0.0308617596,
-0.025053909,
0.0069691879,
-0.0525212251,
0.0620265789,
-0.0814760774,
-0.0073174443,
0.0164222103,
-0.0600297302,
0.0392484553,
0.0388324484,
0.0037907027,
0.0236551557,
-0.0142626651,
-0.0052137855,
-0.0115395645,
-0.040473327,
-0.0063317451,
0.0364662819,
-0.0122904796,
0.023132924,
0.0346628465,
0.0476976894,
0.0153340781,
-0.0057775485,
0.0221174341,
0.0953574032,
0.0008514007,
-0.0030910557,
-0.0024828447,
0.0081853932,
-0.0194552206,
0.0478614382,
0.0251985174,
0.0000918389,
0.0035650234,
-0.0062712273,
0.065254122,
0.0063622463,
0.0119230496,
0.0447798744,
0.0111647118,
-0.0617592856,
-0.0009443816,
-0.0005391233,
0.0067757969,
0.0502401814,
0.0108817695,
-0.0268666036,
0.0017224581,
-0.0252489243,
-0.0603466891,
0.0080050994,
-0.0361307263,
0.0036594509,
-0.0392993167,
-0.0022016398,
0.0627661198,
-0.0142663447,
0.0228236523,
-0.039964702,
-0.0289900526,
-0.0648951232,
-0.0091652479,
-0.019588545,
0.0129302507,
0.1253544986,
-0.0580141954,
-0.0583905093,
0.0506139323,
0.0648404136,
-0.0795621052,
-0.0249155983,
0.0298490562,
-0.0310398899,
-0.0111945644,
0.0371373631,
-0.0221766047,
0.0560838319,
-0.017419396,
-0.0105247553,
-0.1159840375,
-0.0316873007,
0.0143482806,
-0.0187923983,
0.0890139937,
0.0177909769,
0.070465982,
-0.0423383042,
0.0151167661,
0.0436205529,
0.0286208317,
0.0365177095,
-0.0328957029,
0.0284627862,
0.0338073261,
0.0235123653,
0.0127523961,
0.0082456199,
-0.0115412232,
0.0197036024,
0.0001635014,
-0.0021896567,
0.0548042059,
-0.0200623609,
0.0095350724,
-0.0138348285,
0.0577885509,
0.0327956453,
0.0193721019,
-0.0228215754,
-0.0507262908,
0.0086371312,
0.0367175229,
-0.0073251235,
0.0258506835,
-0.016475942,
-0.0157027617,
-0.0992236137,
-0.0325564295,
-0.0047280788,
-0.0572285056,
-0.04703518,
-0.0046068747,
-0.0202894341,
-0.0259896871,
-0.003271746,
-0.0352672152,
0.0045510442,
0.0306699872,
0.0108424611,
-0.0219614357,
-0.0021636328,
0.0041609686,
-0.0099538965,
0.0146262404,
-0.0319063738,
-0.0225196648,
-0.0514731407,
-0.0246442072,
0.0265463237,
0.0303875636,
-0.0156357549,
-0.0064966669,
-0.0072469474,
-0.0959262252,
0.0293503515,
-0.0203542691,
0.0257740282,
0.0272438377,
0.0334077664,
-0.0184920039,
-0.0058047222,
0.0544946902,
0.0495487228,
-0.0268990006,
0.0339808427,
-0.0302493069,
0.0071140141,
-5.659772404e-33,
0.003914332,
0.0307942983,
-0.0042182221,
-0.0589962825,
-0.0065576723,
-0.0099599259,
0.0272582117,
0.0391294286,
0.0073030754,
-0.0332353264,
-0.0150786787,
0.0036786741,
0.0218352377,
0.0356546156,
-0.0290924273,
0.0035245379,
0.0927974284,
-0.0207983684,
0.0021707965,
0.0222711153,
0.0360846035,
0.0122588007,
0.0505120642,
-0.0347319022,
-0.0779137462,
0.0066791591,
-0.0197320376,
-0.0064514526,
0.0510889255,
0.0636926517,
-0.030307848,
0.0494629294,
0.009216506,
0.0040832409,
0.0139227509,
0.0724919215,
-0.1126950458,
-0.0394617543,
-0.0526441559,
0.0229984391,
0.0149273956,
-0.0203607716,
0.046879936,
-0.015780732,
-0.0221746564,
0.0151799079,
0.0556861721,
-0.0076056081,
-0.0613322966,
0.0655368641,
0.0143040838,
0.0253053531,
-0.055800505,
0.0037096627,
0.0787402987,
-0.0311640855,
-0.0033839282,
0.0263963267,
-0.097398065,
0.0135721806,
-0.0683224872,
0.0194275323,
0.0489082485,
0.0740916058,
0.0143611776,
0.0191284586,
0.0703544095,
-0.0392428562,
-0.0276466161,
-0.0509987809,
0.0293594431,
0.0511484966,
-0.0102684172,
-0.0019014651,
0.0291035697,
-0.0526463874,
-0.0469501726,
0.0224068742,
0.0007991481,
-0.0582631566,
-0.0084158303,
0.0400152318,
-0.0707344413,
0.0089244982,
-0.0335858278,
-0.0847856253,
-0.0387270674,
-0.0249082297,
0.0059393728,
-0.0053995969,
-0.0227545891,
0.0614733882,
-0.0005563812,
-0.0274030101,
-0.0133522945,
-0.0663982555,
-0.0036995995,
0.0031908054,
0.0229230281,
0.024297379,
-0.0343805142,
-0.0387564078,
0.0203650389,
0.03490033,
0.0117238527,
0.0282654352,
0.0679136887,
-0.0355190635,
-0.02904048,
-0.0318693854,
-0.0020630739,
-0.0539955162,
-0.0068945405,
-0.0311985034,
0.0153422495,
0.0197599195,
0.0025967918,
0.0402958579,
0.0123949815,
0.0189708751,
0.0217913985,
0.0138070472,
-0.0202755481,
0.0320596546,
0.0076764557,
-0.0055924552,
-0.0281979088,
0.0224277247,
0.0432866178,
-0.0398290232,
-0.0174342114,
0.0042214827,
2.309e-7,
-0.0217405222,
-0.0498696938,
0.0368802547,
-0.0235017203,
0.0247283764,
0.0434948839,
-0.0280267578,
0.0415312983,
-0.011643135,
-0.0445062891,
0.0313700736,
0.0239968728,
0.0439889096,
0.0369477272,
-0.0489052571,
0.0505758151,
-0.074377358,
0.0603180602,
-0.052566424,
0.0069875536,
-0.0376052745,
0.1094844639,
0.0513768829,
-0.0395005196,
0.0060867681,
0.0215590745,
0.0393108577,
-0.0300768092,
0.0573636107,
0.020964358,
-0.0118168602,
0.0356206521,
-0.0144107267,
0.0624615699,
-0.023785308,
0.0197590981,
0.0559533536,
-0.0189584568,
-0.0139331669,
-0.0402568132,
-0.0314558446,
0.0075459578,
-0.0028605487,
0.0075157057,
0.0221523233,
-0.0351947844,
-0.0189390965,
0.0052777333,
-0.0337697715,
0.0119751599,
0.0125510804,
-0.002475983,
-0.0397287905,
0.0238322392,
0.0004426972,
0.0021508883,
-0.0199570302,
-0.0713733882,
0.0245174319,
0.0677300245,
-0.0162000638,
-0.0434365869,
-0.0288986694,
0.017609572,
0.0733114108,
0.0713475347,
0.0542878322,
1.047700207e-34,
-0.0124782398,
0.0039514848,
0.0049924105,
-0.0298206583,
-0.0011417225,
-0.0629819334,
-0.0019584547,
-0.0052676755,
0.0546657033,
-0.0034090725,
0.0057233986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17551v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17551v1 | Unpacking the Ethical Value Alignment in Big Models | 2023-10-26T16:45:40 | 2023-10-26T16:45:40 | Xiaoyuan Yi, Jing Yao, Xiting Wang, Xing Xie | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Big models have greatly advanced AI's ability to understand, generate, and
manipulate information and content, enabling numerous applications. However, as
these models become increasingly integrated into everyday life, their inherent
ethical values and potential biases pose unforeseen risks to society. This
paper provides an overview of the risks and challenges associated with big
models, surveys existing AI ethics guidelines, and examines the ethical
implications arising from the limitations of these models. Taking a normative
ethics perspective, we propose a reassessment of recent normative guidelines,
highlighting the importance of collaborative efforts in academia to establish a
unified and universal AI ethics framework. Furthermore, we investigate the
moral inclinations of current mainstream LLMs using the Moral Foundation
theory, analyze existing alignment algorithms, and outline the unique
challenges encountered in aligning ethical values within them. To address these
challenges, we introduce a novel conceptual paradigm for aligning the ethical
values of big models and discuss promising research directions for alignment
criteria, evaluation, and method, representing an initial step towards the
interdisciplinary construction of the ethically aligned AI
This paper is a modified English version of our Chinese paper
https://crad.ict.ac.cn/cn/article/doi/10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330553, intended
to help non-Chinese native speakers better understand our work. | [
0.0248193052,
0.119335942,
-0.0198901892,
0.0291750375,
-0.0919955522,
0.0023871867,
0.04790508,
-0.0167325959,
0.0137906242,
-0.0106249386,
-0.0124252923,
-0.0266182665,
0.0128761567,
0.0242461227,
-0.0174764935,
0.0031056798,
0.0280899163,
0.0296662301,
0.031175714,
-0.0053864401,
-0.0202720556,
0.0047183274,
0.0381740704,
0.0022856868,
0.0079523074,
-0.0087421946,
0.0028873084,
0.0043185004,
0.0587753654,
0.0045666569,
-0.0135325165,
-0.0181386769,
0.0277270488,
0.0579549707,
0.0000018871,
-0.0733136386,
-0.0499412417,
0.0488094166,
0.0127187837,
0.017716663,
0.0625753403,
-0.001103029,
-0.0137204574,
-0.0128668165,
-0.0369594656,
0.0520104803,
0.07474114,
0.0606442653,
-0.0099854888,
0.0615883805,
-0.0116313202,
-0.011843442,
0.0763881877,
0.0264604129,
-0.0503587574,
-0.0200843979,
0.0478805527,
0.062816456,
-0.0240075253,
0.013124004,
0.0200516097,
0.0321023688,
-0.0022821955,
0.0177612808,
0.0157147609,
-0.0206931736,
0.0342481658,
-0.0606295876,
-0.0027071384,
0.0425320379,
0.0439212471,
0.0102680838,
0.051237002,
0.0121425474,
0.0287790094,
-0.0258076359,
-0.0017872119,
0.0442877337,
-0.0080900509,
0.0263131354,
0.0743626282,
-0.0083654476,
0.0497959219,
0.0866475105,
0.0042005354,
-0.0122902542,
-0.0163372438,
-0.0246288031,
-0.0429394878,
-0.0009875942,
0.0118900519,
-0.0202954561,
-0.0045017158,
0.0381578431,
-0.0126517899,
0.0066783722,
-0.0104448209,
0.0460714884,
0.0364732184,
-0.0256506298,
0.0333228558,
0.0282188468,
0.0678091422,
0.0205757674,
0.0483793542,
0.0186586734,
-0.0994428024,
0.0594855808,
-0.0376375057,
0.0225881208,
0.0143481093,
0.0136079555,
0.0505323708,
0.0299073663,
-0.0132941455,
0.0187663361,
0.0001273082,
0.0119547471,
-0.0639039055,
0.0616635419,
-0.0462397598,
0.0327060856,
0.0226037502,
-0.0130853113,
-0.0185118597,
0.0156477205,
-0.0266691037,
0.0442971736,
-0.0239824094,
-0.0233766995,
0.006285849,
-0.0183652081,
-0.0192790665,
-0.0122777764,
0.0223893002,
0.1020755619,
0.0343772471,
0.0229418855,
-0.0296175443,
-0.0595649071,
0.0259098653,
-0.0604601689,
0.0269003045,
-0.00846803,
0.0039148075,
-0.039846085,
-0.0143947769,
-0.0573111586,
-0.0152308019,
-0.0054840427,
-0.0119871991,
0.0327935889,
-0.0354995243,
0.0177818052,
0.0272636451,
0.0406313613,
-0.01883341,
0.017829746,
0.0345219374,
0.0242461711,
0.04851266,
-0.0262400322,
-0.0000926943,
-0.0084382948,
-0.0104304096,
0.0009936581,
-0.038513694,
0.0298567023,
-0.0000948823,
0.0465519652,
-0.0142314648,
0.0299293492,
-0.0131665338,
0.0181126315,
0.040796537,
0.0629952922,
-0.0287773684,
0.0254578646,
-0.0398655459,
-0.0385605395,
-0.0084450878,
0.0029232102,
-0.0641963333,
0.0227939393,
-0.0454459526,
-0.0041199829,
-0.0900225192,
0.071299538,
-0.0192525387,
-0.0424875803,
0.0140888887,
-0.0470401272,
0.0114205759,
0.0372856446,
-0.0070931776,
-0.0394195206,
0.0162557214,
-0.0763110369,
0.0061906609,
-0.0480525903,
-0.0111474702,
-0.0543613769,
0.05566632,
0.0632402971,
0.0389946029,
-0.0244097766,
-0.0333782732,
-0.0285833795,
-0.0489778556,
-0.0307210498,
0.0178298019,
-0.0198016334,
-0.0217271037,
-0.0432844684,
-0.0577035584,
-0.032432247,
-0.0124680027,
-0.0278860983,
-0.0066112136,
-0.0110909529,
-0.0195078608,
-0.0058941515,
-0.0614510402,
0.0125788189,
-0.0356787518,
0.0036655837,
-0.0551696382,
0.0202009436,
0.0598036461,
0.0351525322,
-0.0112248808,
0.007354694,
0.025777258,
0.037908908,
0.0045870696,
-0.0357319079,
-0.0049920795,
0.1012090221,
0.0184932314,
-0.0799044892,
-0.0175071359,
0.0362213366,
-0.021603493,
0.0476218611,
-0.0499179363,
0.027995998,
-0.0054077567,
-0.0195566881,
0.0156850871,
-0.0989665687,
0.011897509,
-0.0477913469,
0.0352454856,
-0.0292123295,
-0.0175539032,
0.0168097578,
-0.0286229439,
0.0263438337,
0.0075165201,
-0.0220265873,
0.022792913,
-0.0054614674,
0.0503670201,
0.0417954177,
0.0059481496,
-0.0286861658,
-0.0193961114,
-0.063944608,
0.0237672962,
0.0250785723,
0.0043989979,
-0.0241449792,
-0.0053895391,
-0.0143705849,
0.0181469005,
-0.0157123599,
-0.0198116936,
-0.019592965,
0.0151881315,
0.0262521878,
-0.0261814296,
-0.0242611896,
-0.0011210253,
0.0128801931,
-0.028595563,
-0.017879311,
0.045612108,
0.0083672097,
-0.0313344412,
0.0151344761,
-0.0589278862,
-0.0065720729,
0.0278641433,
-0.011927668,
-0.0302920528,
0.0408123434,
-0.0466049947,
0.0621067621,
0.0290861782,
0.0527150929,
0.0465993769,
0.0477630496,
-0.0207745433,
-0.0334006883,
0.012625535,
-0.0084825847,
-0.0020548236,
-0.0168323405,
-0.0262004696,
-0.0057530319,
-0.0333352126,
0.0088619264,
0.001063385,
0.0641885921,
-0.0433818847,
-0.0555204786,
0.0504433699,
-0.0639688596,
-0.0137258442,
0.0343136415,
-0.0300767273,
-0.0608611852,
0.0478030965,
0.0266798884,
0.0692004561,
0.0007646453,
-0.0255993009,
-0.0229443554,
0.0139430203,
-0.0176000576,
0.0667286143,
0.0246260185,
-0.014802834,
-0.0555397458,
0.0264349133,
0.0425173976,
-0.0724972188,
0.0356415622,
0.0011343701,
-0.0022991367,
-0.0248893015,
-0.047167521,
-0.042522274,
-0.0248410702,
-0.0181704164,
-0.0043632686,
-0.0095937131,
-0.0011273042,
-0.024325531,
-0.0465446115,
0.0616989955,
-0.0572332032,
-0.0086187795,
0.0059797037,
0.0009200195,
-0.03741166,
0.0320200659,
-0.017873615,
0.050778687,
0.0364549607,
0.0382442996,
0.0352179371,
-0.0174210239,
0.0172377992,
-0.0089794556,
0.0068269824,
0.0468589962,
0.0255848076,
0.0041188928,
0.0116419522,
0.0366503745,
0.0051171631,
0.0378871597,
0.058753442,
-0.0146351019,
-0.0431621969,
0.0164575763,
-0.0242158026,
-0.0727303922,
-0.0051901918,
-0.0260383654,
-0.0603635572,
0.0193371549,
-0.0133591807,
0.0020471795,
-0.0981941521,
-0.0555356629,
0.0251016729,
-0.0450158305,
0.0264922176,
0.0490984768,
0.009157937,
-0.0567931309,
-0.0066844756,
0.0104310149,
-0.0358031653,
0.0618660338,
-0.0314749144,
0.0140021136,
-0.0607113652,
0.0216962229,
0.0313067436,
-0.00825419,
-0.0118399477,
-0.0591251515,
0.0734581128,
0.0860407874,
0.0303820837,
-0.0371151716,
-0.0377026424,
-0.0394219272,
0.0457484797,
0.0017997753,
0.0418936163,
-0.0162151642,
-0.0274310932,
-0.0100179771,
-0.0817108825,
0.0294637978,
0.0147717884,
-0.0229971278,
0.0219012164,
0.0797888339,
-0.0263553411,
-0.0287036374,
-0.0432342552,
-0.0637840852,
0.0052838498,
0.0500850044,
-0.0454036407,
-0.0244513266,
0.0230936799,
0.0289815012,
-0.0513161719,
0.0462204628,
-0.0052274568,
0.0018305813,
-0.0080226017,
0.0201416705,
-0.0354318283,
-0.0487726368,
-0.0654594526,
-0.0082839066,
0.0523060858,
-0.0623112433,
0.0507572517,
-0.00269082,
-0.0419600606,
0.0071663712,
-0.0019958222,
0.0062515484,
0.0077548134,
0.0361104682,
0.0175001752,
-0.0409709327,
0.0281475056,
-0.0098999152,
0.0163621698,
-0.0274442062,
0.0284363031,
0.0250609946,
0.0148128727,
0.030565558,
0.0122962538,
0.0231009722,
0.0343515575,
0.0489020534,
-0.0526290648,
0.027138859,
0.0237356983,
-0.0288383104,
-0.0292878002,
-0.0209406111,
-0.0298298486,
-0.0078935921,
0.0362363756,
-0.0300819036,
-0.0683617815,
0.0022303874,
0.0356664918,
0.0535595454,
-0.0128454212,
-0.0379551202,
-0.0008844241,
-0.0095922751,
-0.0353891961,
0.0001585619,
-0.0368521512,
-0.0025689171,
-0.0300970189,
0.0659064576,
0.0060538701,
0.0046564429,
0.0387844779,
0.0188814308,
-0.0437389985,
-0.0296019763,
0.0007037909,
-0.049415499,
0.0666026399,
-0.0137895225,
0.0168661326,
-0.051008217,
0.0424556732,
-0.037277706,
0.0291096531,
0.0159855839,
0.0598281212,
0.0306620691,
0.0420295149,
0.0006180765,
0.0466951467,
-0.0659970939,
-0.0796831176,
-0.0237907972,
0.0058854781,
-0.0088469284,
0.0282480177,
-0.0072680386,
0.0006316454,
0.0078983717,
-0.0217834674,
0.0167291574,
-0.0066402862,
-0.0361869037,
-0.018527912,
0.0259931069,
-0.0316229947,
-0.0122135729,
0.013611502,
-0.02922423,
0.0458592623,
-0.0320457555,
0.0011998676,
0.0291060358,
-0.0581327155,
0.0439248048,
-0.0385525338,
0.0079273265,
-0.0348997153,
-0.0587538071,
-0.0464198627,
-0.0133479433,
0.0063002468,
-0.0384151489,
-0.0347094089,
-0.0176193528,
0.006806606,
-0.0189763177,
-0.0044787005,
-0.0143374978,
-0.0328172632,
-0.0656428635,
0.0043860991,
-0.0047702324,
-5.486847634e-33,
0.023678869,
-0.0436487421,
0.0117019266,
-0.0135492701,
-0.0704021752,
-0.0102613037,
0.0333797298,
-0.0244197864,
-0.0844458267,
0.0076014437,
-0.0049154675,
0.0033332261,
-0.0226317495,
-0.0191227011,
0.0133735798,
-0.0662203804,
-0.0134133399,
0.0044202046,
-0.0040309066,
0.0215222817,
-0.0373429917,
-0.0368675254,
0.0186933782,
-0.0738288388,
0.0590230636,
0.0212792605,
-0.0304056089,
0.0235508978,
-0.0386545025,
0.0520226993,
0.0117144762,
0.0501316674,
0.0173411388,
0.0089877388,
0.0282881428,
0.0442531742,
0.0065709995,
0.0250416752,
0.0102486657,
-0.0058356789,
-0.0086562242,
-0.071154274,
0.0188089982,
-0.007455274,
-0.0274790544,
-0.0074098809,
0.0405928344,
-0.0501516983,
0.0011333214,
-0.0008430825,
-0.0506554656,
-0.0170910005,
-0.0633062124,
0.0203542914,
-0.0069296882,
0.0191996805,
0.0255753323,
0.027547108,
-0.0169177465,
0.0022835236,
-0.0042221621,
-0.079234764,
0.0650121197,
0.0041844198,
0.0640852526,
0.0636915863,
0.0021709872,
0.012327983,
-0.0383859798,
-0.0466614589,
-0.0466222167,
0.0616513379,
0.0238133818,
0.0464744605,
-0.0576466359,
-0.0239264406,
-0.0463702939,
0.0081946719,
0.0064550592,
0.0375260711,
0.0110197011,
-0.0113641573,
-0.0609805025,
0.0034965945,
0.0062698023,
-0.070789203,
-0.0302456152,
0.0153278699,
0.0019991295,
-0.0350071751,
-0.0287717246,
0.0395186208,
0.0192896407,
-0.0884779766,
0.042730689,
0.0451159403,
0.0417787097,
-0.0048652967,
0.0052574603,
0.0132453833,
-0.0518053435,
-0.0476275682,
-0.0111576868,
0.0105479918,
0.0589843132,
0.0356105752,
0.0190632995,
0.0065722023,
0.0337843485,
-0.0001906154,
-0.0151329646,
0.006922706,
0.0373724476,
-0.0557880662,
0.0359873623,
0.0184504855,
0.0165476017,
0.0052488069,
0.0394906774,
0.0684149414,
-0.0429838151,
-0.0152305141,
-0.0330010094,
0.0019459531,
0.0100896182,
0.0066448706,
-0.0204252452,
0.0393513963,
0.0350227356,
-0.047766529,
-0.0404632799,
0.0175051726,
2.705e-7,
-0.0346901901,
-0.0224668197,
0.0141413556,
-0.0005768424,
-0.0469700098,
0.0820463151,
0.0116842547,
0.0647179857,
-0.0123097114,
-0.036604844,
0.086105749,
0.0038030099,
0.033170253,
-0.0231940392,
0.0080208927,
-0.0190920532,
-0.043452248,
-0.021762969,
-0.0363212004,
0.0709821805,
0.0177790392,
0.0055605564,
0.0161672384,
-0.0133908419,
0.0263150223,
0.0197100341,
0.0170252044,
-0.0599674173,
0.0170819219,
0.0284961518,
-0.030683402,
0.0207151491,
-0.0032464401,
-0.0211870838,
0.0498492047,
0.007473384,
0.0346363261,
0.072417289,
-0.0327683464,
-0.0176226627,
-0.0562542155,
-0.0616535023,
0.0221096706,
-0.0311751906,
0.0543915816,
0.0326820612,
-0.0481122583,
-0.0476266928,
0.0040242234,
-0.0328554437,
0.0351008326,
0.0177901629,
0.0218858197,
0.0106954286,
-0.0205680337,
0.0232923236,
0.0073305797,
-0.0169457868,
0.0163385104,
-0.0296787601,
0.0118071586,
-0.0695202723,
0.0448382795,
0.0263769943,
0.0361128375,
-0.0532292053,
0.0226478446,
2.182947192e-34,
-0.0303411726,
-0.0845719352,
0.0329721682,
0.0332847945,
0.0161629114,
0.0603980459,
-0.0334240682,
-0.0143289287,
0.0046945894,
-0.0312732086,
0.001543285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17530v1 | Evaluating Bias and Fairness in Gender-Neutral Pretrained Vision-and-Language Models | 2023-10-26T16:19:19 | 2023-10-26T16:19:19 | Laura Cabello, Emanuele Bugliarello, Stephanie Brandl, Desmond Elliott | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Pretrained machine learning models are known to perpetuate and even amplify
existing biases in data, which can result in unfair outcomes that ultimately
impact user experience. Therefore, it is crucial to understand the mechanisms
behind those prejudicial biases to ensure that model performance does not
result in discriminatory behaviour toward certain groups or populations. In
this work, we define gender bias as our case study. We quantify bias
amplification in pretraining and after fine-tuning on three families of
vision-and-language models. We investigate the connection, if any, between the
two learning stages, and evaluate how bias amplification reflects on model
performance. Overall, we find that bias amplification in pretraining and after
fine-tuning are independent. We then examine the effect of continued
pretraining on gender-neutral data, finding that this reduces group
disparities, i.e., promotes fairness, on VQAv2 and retrieval tasks without
significantly compromising task performance. | [
0.0178434253,
0.0722579584,
-0.0432874002,
0.0264112316,
0.0243743006,
0.0337800607,
0.0518957637,
-0.0050716549,
-0.0006765131,
-0.089981392,
-0.0488876216,
-0.0212148279,
0.0301419981,
0.0176090486,
0.0089506619,
-0.0728414655,
0.0515794829,
0.0258173682,
0.0175063834,
-0.0420494527,
-0.0001870492,
-0.0072563593,
0.0219521075,
0.062424127,
-0.0021348584,
-0.0126451561,
0.0503543541,
0.0220468137,
-0.031842269,
0.0198348463,
0.0527243912,
0.0620474443,
-0.0022134038,
0.0061897556,
0.0000020131,
-0.070564203,
0.027515946,
0.0230781157,
-0.0047832942,
0.0143781668,
0.02091543,
0.0096106231,
0.0056609702,
0.0303428322,
-0.024523804,
-0.0175108518,
0.0352382399,
0.0155836474,
0.0259482041,
-0.0121374251,
-0.0261923894,
0.0297467336,
-0.0627380237,
-0.0187798943,
0.0237585697,
-0.0300794747,
0.0172174666,
-0.0280203093,
-0.0663387775,
-0.0341833644,
-0.0224332344,
0.0024388058,
0.0128231253,
0.0488885604,
0.0257961974,
0.0413048901,
-0.044094909,
-0.0594458878,
-0.0173138026,
0.0467657931,
-0.0124789262,
0.0141023779,
-0.0134135727,
-0.0085316403,
0.0461964309,
-0.0019083639,
-0.0387006402,
0.0105770668,
-0.0045102336,
-0.0123061026,
-0.0544307679,
-0.0105728433,
0.0391002484,
0.0298361685,
-0.0226012655,
0.0541089252,
0.0040563638,
-0.0281031206,
0.0303519852,
0.0381703116,
0.0134557141,
-0.0155278984,
0.0069680484,
-0.0175677668,
0.0128107797,
-0.025343677,
-0.0461472161,
-0.015728578,
0.0152495699,
-0.0397977866,
0.0567094386,
0.0676462874,
-0.0458441488,
0.0135099636,
-0.0403239578,
0.0528698191,
0.0086014774,
0.0497368202,
-0.015071868,
-0.014936748,
-0.0001693376,
-0.0187418591,
-0.0052130898,
-0.0300937649,
-0.0568723828,
0.0292736273,
-0.0282666627,
0.006037348,
-0.0266032387,
-0.0394000448,
0.01425632,
0.031211691,
-0.0368562937,
0.0312158577,
-0.0440822318,
-0.0316286124,
-0.0450930484,
0.0264445525,
-0.0302046053,
-0.1111856923,
0.0020465308,
-0.0092133032,
-0.0124859419,
-0.0241228957,
0.0062207226,
0.0421001576,
-0.005839345,
-0.0293707754,
-0.0250721034,
-0.004876791,
0.0199280698,
-0.041885484,
0.0246990789,
-0.0065994156,
0.006380314,
0.0634867474,
0.0042720945,
-0.0195740722,
-0.0287346113,
0.0249475744,
-0.0585433729,
0.0688850805,
0.0398705229,
0.0128067173,
0.0536888987,
0.0193765927,
-0.0253149513,
0.0935247764,
0.034461055,
0.002189683,
0.0239818487,
-0.0163992736,
-0.0040258453,
0.0216215309,
0.0414483361,
0.0113163255,
-0.0331248082,
0.011755418,
-0.0095331213,
-0.0002388887,
0.057052739,
0.0114434371,
-0.0002520705,
-0.0228263475,
0.0596214533,
0.0873820558,
0.045784872,
0.0314056352,
-0.0006471882,
-0.0578258485,
-0.0213204715,
0.0039922893,
-0.0968145207,
-0.0036372729,
-0.018445516,
-0.027847806,
-0.0282020271,
0.0428738929,
-0.038803,
-0.0569230579,
-0.0066784713,
0.0104124872,
0.0425676666,
0.0276033264,
0.0379719697,
0.0060530463,
-0.0075556259,
0.0088943243,
0.0380943604,
-0.0638352036,
0.0032770613,
-0.0944786593,
0.0017022479,
0.0445967615,
-0.0093803182,
-0.0200472213,
0.0295964889,
0.005829195,
-0.0349373631,
-0.01289145,
0.0805269331,
0.0312849246,
0.0143897329,
-0.0501388423,
-0.0804583505,
0.003316741,
0.0303190388,
0.0090697082,
0.0327291228,
0.0435178094,
0.0318994708,
-0.0305321831,
-0.0518543087,
0.0468893051,
-0.0020946108,
0.00354638,
0.0035886895,
0.0043265121,
-0.0115561774,
-0.0038214666,
-0.0258663818,
0.0137380641,
-0.0119963204,
0.0021195901,
0.0344884954,
0.0280882325,
-0.0561865121,
0.0490207151,
-0.0048136129,
-0.0381019376,
-0.0169836245,
0.0549406894,
0.0161377545,
0.0378274769,
0.0355649032,
0.0277446397,
-0.0125290733,
-0.0138754975,
0.0047236402,
-0.0220141895,
0.0115408953,
-0.0415945947,
0.0183938816,
-0.0340187438,
-0.0305141341,
-0.0108488724,
-0.0523008481,
0.011830329,
-0.0447518751,
-0.0277831145,
0.0247877818,
-0.0024528843,
0.0169042759,
0.0161854327,
-0.0490318611,
-0.0233750679,
0.0249179602,
-0.0908534303,
-0.0131309601,
-0.033263579,
-0.0206763502,
-0.0226199366,
0.008322129,
-0.0400513634,
-0.0600315891,
0.0067761731,
-0.008910832,
0.0189341903,
0.0514951497,
-0.0058010109,
-0.0182541925,
0.0368972346,
-0.0233256519,
-0.0707935318,
-0.0184936784,
0.0652235895,
0.0634807125,
-0.003378253,
-0.0455652587,
0.0076110745,
-0.0029275098,
0.0348413177,
-0.0234514866,
-0.0048047411,
0.0373332538,
0.024563808,
0.0314949453,
0.1322829425,
0.0256524533,
0.0502679534,
0.0708729774,
0.0324715786,
-0.0451870337,
0.0010100834,
0.024565246,
-0.0163660534,
0.008734826,
-0.0474554822,
0.0021600011,
0.0383338928,
-0.0039060528,
-0.0182561371,
-0.0711085498,
0.0810480639,
-0.0615047961,
-0.0683248043,
-0.0534978956,
-0.0174555071,
0.0097238887,
0.0469527729,
-0.0463258959,
-0.0973870531,
0.0213910304,
0.0110972011,
-0.0049540596,
-0.0072666518,
0.0127960145,
-0.0228415206,
0.0426626801,
-0.0235648863,
0.0247251038,
0.0043165036,
-0.0008765027,
-0.0938353911,
-0.0341670103,
0.0359135345,
-0.0486784726,
0.0356668457,
-0.002464958,
0.0052646529,
-0.0480684377,
-0.0597218238,
-0.0539920107,
-0.0262493547,
-0.0025939683,
0.006143223,
0.0130993742,
0.0059942394,
-0.0227264352,
0.0187741239,
-0.0079801679,
0.0260868501,
-0.019145932,
-0.0148514388,
0.0105981929,
-0.0469363667,
0.0153025547,
0.0215395037,
0.0196675565,
-0.0814359263,
-0.0328132175,
0.0152532365,
0.032729812,
-0.0002865321,
0.0052926643,
0.0378236398,
0.0477503575,
-0.023073798,
-0.0286564734,
0.0060430565,
0.030289229,
-0.0522793531,
0.0263773985,
0.072165966,
0.0007047912,
-0.086369805,
-0.0050511351,
-0.0086241122,
0.0066354601,
0.0412972495,
-0.002921337,
-0.0813479573,
0.0007315123,
0.0452452488,
0.0556693412,
-0.0187921189,
-0.0277059432,
0.0100213792,
-0.1054955497,
0.0214680023,
0.0046322239,
-0.0248557311,
-0.03828061,
0.0099353977,
-0.0053808996,
-0.0490463041,
0.0448833555,
-0.0076555125,
-0.0169013608,
0.0359646827,
0.0115916068,
0.0031836191,
-0.0292841438,
0.0259568673,
-0.0681318566,
-0.0019157975,
0.0864414349,
0.0045979926,
-0.0036887478,
-0.0236269832,
0.0368132927,
-0.0428450182,
0.0316411145,
-0.0191741381,
0.0452575423,
-0.0455448814,
-0.0300227851,
-0.0428893641,
0.0248551629,
0.0540555418,
0.001532745,
-0.0138673605,
-0.0489024259,
0.0175486524,
-0.0320608541,
-0.0648027286,
-0.0425976962,
-0.0162859783,
0.0643425137,
-0.0002153907,
-0.0386958942,
-0.0434097499,
-0.0541974865,
0.0289368089,
0.006674272,
-0.0849963874,
0.0308763999,
0.0183417071,
-0.0075712684,
-0.0146194706,
-0.0465934314,
-0.0029628656,
0.0070548109,
-0.015527538,
-0.0702878162,
-0.0077014039,
0.0198431909,
-0.0801993236,
0.0918699726,
0.018950155,
0.0300600044,
-0.044608824,
-0.032397382,
-0.030293135,
-0.0392633118,
-0.0321278051,
-0.0293993242,
-0.0000836373,
-0.0273593664,
0.0468398444,
0.0778963864,
0.0239645001,
0.0512815304,
0.0245983005,
-0.0639672205,
0.0423893221,
0.0500935204,
-0.0101697277,
0.0382528901,
0.035080567,
-0.0132013168,
0.0002807906,
0.005143384,
-0.0314020663,
0.009462771,
0.0152663682,
-0.0075402115,
0.0087355962,
-0.0130447913,
-0.0117065711,
-0.0083826128,
0.0910581201,
-0.0115728313,
0.013600125,
-0.022603903,
0.0011585085,
0.0283033177,
-0.0179149788,
-0.0279379096,
-0.0456988849,
0.0280897673,
0.0272742156,
-0.0127081564,
-0.0002820841,
-0.0089148423,
-0.0164046884,
-0.0654297695,
0.0184022095,
0.0084947804,
0.0305036958,
0.0088283205,
0.0254354049,
-0.0017997803,
0.0374722779,
-0.0286153797,
0.0355774201,
0.0173739605,
0.0243498776,
0.0226577912,
0.0472900867,
-0.0392632447,
0.0263120569,
-0.0351968929,
-0.0381759889,
0.0042905528,
0.0045162137,
0.0156741142,
-0.0451443344,
0.0045357565,
0.0249287561,
-0.0030245676,
-0.0239630863,
-0.0378791019,
0.0221772492,
0.0583109818,
0.0158984195,
-0.0011958199,
0.0024077336,
-0.0397438742,
0.0530013293,
0.0548172183,
0.0782970265,
-0.071374841,
-0.0435890667,
0.0039778841,
-0.037622761,
0.0670067072,
-0.025603462,
-0.0319431983,
-0.0106543275,
-0.0674486756,
-0.0336796418,
-0.0352554619,
0.0040529785,
0.0538730659,
-0.0021971629,
0.0114566544,
0.0615538284,
-0.0423782989,
-0.0725204051,
-0.0143283419,
-0.0274153017,
-0.011864542,
-0.0083589284,
0.0111675411,
-6.128883914e-33,
-0.0236724019,
-0.0041475534,
-0.0074179531,
-0.0104990834,
0.0053733652,
0.0100743389,
0.0276295748,
0.0050393012,
-0.0271357615,
-0.0114290798,
0.0058672559,
0.025835583,
0.0186638609,
-0.0156291425,
0.0005236534,
-0.0222392883,
0.0671725795,
0.0196591206,
-0.0361254923,
-0.0379064418,
-0.032490924,
0.0392137878,
0.0132862292,
-0.054751046,
0.0514661074,
-0.0059521552,
0.0292116739,
-0.0216747615,
-0.0277722459,
0.0481345505,
-0.0031131289,
0.0553195141,
0.029150283,
0.0124757597,
-0.0120085478,
0.0483227149,
-0.0643870011,
-0.0001557917,
-0.0122570554,
0.0477642268,
-0.0173881892,
0.0062933671,
0.0590029992,
0.035756886,
-0.0907581374,
-0.0369084813,
0.059994068,
0.0062376857,
0.017474588,
0.016955046,
-0.0223576948,
0.0083208922,
-0.025487721,
-0.0177796464,
0.0463793427,
0.0139197139,
0.0249210764,
0.0215596296,
-0.0416039899,
0.0331753269,
-0.0072445655,
-0.0291613247,
0.0545612499,
0.059748657,
0.0345256589,
0.0176875237,
0.089476414,
0.0384223722,
-0.0452951975,
-0.0821415856,
0.0715256929,
-0.0143995723,
0.0160986781,
0.0271719825,
0.0588786937,
-0.0273457859,
-0.051346045,
-0.0000875458,
-0.0314900577,
0.0426562428,
0.0085178511,
0.0154022891,
-0.0626630783,
-0.0384471826,
-0.0473889709,
-0.0581530519,
-0.0359936766,
0.0035634807,
0.058566805,
0.0206033885,
-0.0267148055,
0.0263793617,
0.0206042789,
-0.0540248118,
-0.0239915643,
0.0023994758,
-0.0056571523,
-0.0259693656,
0.0094638774,
-0.0078365458,
-0.0653309226,
0.0080649676,
0.0192304365,
0.034476772,
0.0148155186,
0.023653755,
-0.040664956,
-0.0076753427,
-0.0503251627,
-0.000932914,
-0.0047276039,
0.0098169995,
0.0396303311,
0.0196342468,
0.0512329079,
0.0223349147,
-0.0010231176,
0.0341137461,
0.0256099477,
-0.0006610727,
-0.0674679801,
-0.0338044278,
0.0272332691,
0.0377758443,
0.0097394502,
-0.0256653558,
-0.0111479349,
0.016546566,
0.0368507318,
-0.0409611687,
-0.0248892456,
-0.0265911743,
2.514e-7,
0.017149739,
0.0543843061,
0.0000946463,
0.0001633368,
-0.0115078567,
0.0522421785,
0.012287708,
0.0376506038,
0.0685460642,
0.0201489143,
-0.0453484543,
0.0707851127,
-0.0101690358,
-0.0059134485,
0.0027022117,
0.0077444664,
-0.0471231975,
0.050599128,
-0.0209208969,
0.034702111,
-0.0091442131,
0.0015409378,
-0.0025499905,
0.0073255361,
0.0217938703,
-0.0376455262,
0.0429110192,
-0.0391739681,
0.0344115496,
-0.0078891506,
0.0335402936,
0.0505475551,
0.0280631185,
0.0415962078,
0.0092070727,
0.0244790781,
0.0193024054,
-0.0071561942,
-0.049651932,
0.0258578304,
-0.0234805122,
0.0257813837,
-0.0141252577,
-0.0683203414,
0.0796512738,
0.0009628415,
-0.0218975786,
-0.0444824435,
-0.0195696987,
0.0007620886,
0.0942875743,
-0.000592514,
-0.0050012665,
-0.0028157474,
0.0241277665,
0.0112306261,
-0.0191033855,
-0.0736330077,
-0.0179657005,
-0.0253667738,
-0.003288744,
-0.0648259744,
-0.0420226902,
0.0388109647,
0.0186120514,
-0.0046884832,
0.0073469686,
2.002662864e-34,
-0.0092788786,
0.0264563896,
0.0523410738,
-0.0062801954,
-0.0170562062,
-0.0109387236,
0.0146673322,
-0.0175044723,
0.0307448003,
0.018219566,
0.011966248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17526v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17526v2 | Can large language models replace humans in the systematic review process? Evaluating GPT-4's efficacy in screening and extracting data from peer-reviewed and grey literature in multiple languages | 2023-10-26T16:18:30 | 2023-10-27T12:14:27 | Qusai Khraisha, Sophie Put, Johanna Kappenberg, Azza Warraitch, Kristin Hadfield | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Systematic reviews are vital for guiding practice, research, and policy, yet
they are often slow and labour-intensive. Large language models (LLMs) could
offer a way to speed up and automate systematic reviews, but their performance
in such tasks has not been comprehensively evaluated against humans, and no
study has tested GPT-4, the biggest LLM so far. This pre-registered study
evaluates GPT-4's capability in title/abstract screening, full-text review, and
data extraction across various literature types and languages using a
'human-out-of-the-loop' approach. Although GPT-4 had accuracy on par with human
performance in most tasks, results were skewed by chance agreement and dataset
imbalance. After adjusting for these, there was a moderate level of performance
for data extraction, and - barring studies that used highly reliable prompts -
screening performance levelled at none to moderate for different stages and
languages. When screening full-text literature using highly reliable prompts,
GPT-4's performance was 'almost perfect.' Penalising GPT-4 for missing key
studies using highly reliable prompts improved its performance even more. Our
findings indicate that, currently, substantial caution should be used if LLMs
are being used to conduct systematic reviews, but suggest that, for certain
systematic review tasks delivered under reliable prompts, LLMs can rival human
performance. | [
0.0613331869,
0.0425207987,
-0.0120819025,
-0.017560361,
-0.0180583708,
0.0264117233,
0.0446474515,
0.0209860168,
-0.035118781,
-0.0237915199,
-0.0253634471,
-0.034013804,
0.0219559148,
0.0423465148,
0.0222737845,
-0.0241187885,
0.0162767451,
-0.0038062723,
0.0593117699,
-0.0038275919,
-0.0407820567,
-0.0005439748,
0.0118864179,
0.0415066853,
0.0901871473,
-0.0003196489,
0.0206601247,
-0.0179750863,
0.0172499865,
-0.0688766688,
0.0033931341,
0.0588382632,
-0.0124589829,
0.0807908475,
0.0000021512,
-0.0374013744,
0.0028283854,
0.0661189333,
0.0267075319,
0.0189116467,
0.0633859783,
-0.0341429189,
-0.0086236689,
0.0086005405,
0.0041803294,
-0.044216685,
0.0445152223,
0.0112953074,
-0.0349924862,
0.0105464999,
-0.0174914096,
0.0158147458,
0.0378634147,
-0.0332575552,
-0.0034496491,
-0.0082032559,
0.0408023782,
0.0002988756,
0.0598401316,
0.0303301215,
0.0359369181,
0.031382259,
-0.0078479266,
-0.0154267941,
-0.0323350281,
0.0468830429,
-0.0637797266,
-0.0627878979,
0.0196121484,
0.0212773029,
0.0276493635,
-0.0074604065,
0.0111897653,
-0.0365847535,
-0.0008722695,
0.0457272939,
-0.0362655558,
0.0302871335,
-0.0257921349,
-0.0230860561,
0.0204586387,
0.0021739283,
0.0254055001,
0.0208945293,
0.0070827533,
0.0197081957,
0.0174962822,
-0.0451369807,
0.0891269371,
0.0472952835,
0.0383497328,
-0.0385394357,
-0.014162044,
-0.0223236121,
-0.0251147971,
-0.0210593175,
0.0572740696,
0.0161145721,
0.1117735803,
-0.0261264648,
0.0233891495,
-0.0095830308,
-0.0133912116,
0.0217115134,
0.0187523421,
-0.0289381091,
-0.0091328574,
0.0259619653,
-0.0166410469,
0.0342732891,
-0.0278500337,
-0.0054288483,
0.0089460202,
-0.0312973484,
-0.0262051634,
0.0203109719,
-0.0767020583,
-0.0260378923,
0.0040502246,
-0.0192980058,
0.0023653272,
-0.007445226,
-0.0528647602,
0.0064515239,
0.0034976027,
0.0377282649,
0.0225518029,
0.0421989374,
-0.0378946252,
-0.0345717743,
0.0214267205,
0.0129396105,
0.0076811118,
-0.018223105,
0.0391900428,
0.0079588536,
-0.0014887017,
-0.0364061296,
0.0293611344,
0.0104021179,
-0.0343371406,
-0.0688051879,
-0.0091114538,
-0.079313226,
0.0252760965,
0.0029324843,
0.0168815888,
0.0016399452,
-0.0120157162,
0.0046572369,
-0.0343383104,
0.0202931296,
-0.0908707306,
0.0041832686,
-0.0023193771,
0.0063275849,
-0.0232862737,
0.0262290295,
-0.0144294109,
0.0048573404,
-0.0095190052,
-0.0159479193,
0.0159011483,
0.015582392,
-0.0352527387,
0.0395375937,
0.0516522154,
0.0167488847,
0.0123330355,
0.0298353489,
0.0133258952,
0.0527266338,
-0.0448393784,
0.0356836841,
0.0575151928,
0.0663212761,
-0.0144200437,
0.0356063955,
0.0165424496,
-0.0121836662,
0.0442097075,
-0.0228833407,
-0.026176447,
-0.0175706856,
0.0004947619,
-0.0011151483,
0.0131440917,
0.0192898251,
0.0019705759,
-0.0176559482,
-0.0079295542,
0.0240130518,
-0.0285926722,
-0.0004708192,
0.0444351323,
-0.041017171,
0.0066016861,
-0.0225293431,
0.0274848919,
0.0176977627,
-0.0105675133,
-0.0077479747,
-0.0168439355,
0.0119291171,
0.0518287681,
-0.0302760191,
0.0065155313,
-0.0412833132,
-0.0158005822,
0.041092433,
0.0110238669,
0.000758915,
-0.0039751646,
-0.0109057659,
-0.0444672629,
0.0125157665,
-0.0017877526,
0.0201719273,
0.0021275459,
0.0527064279,
-0.02981323,
-0.0299329013,
-0.0976153091,
0.0189789794,
-0.0626111478,
-0.0156210549,
-0.0060292971,
-0.0588533767,
0.0516223386,
0.0139425211,
-0.0377684198,
0.0225785784,
0.0070051826,
-0.0010411436,
-0.0290355124,
0.0061520073,
0.0186715201,
0.0414857492,
0.0148582757,
-0.0560776591,
-0.019701479,
0.0229158774,
-0.0355841629,
-0.0017157302,
-0.0199330579,
0.0114385234,
0.0118518732,
0.0043225363,
0.0032885226,
-0.0159658808,
-0.0281066895,
-0.0178028457,
0.0101960963,
0.0197708402,
0.0126538835,
0.0121099642,
-0.0918447748,
0.0198625159,
-0.0324277356,
-0.0516004451,
0.0766593441,
-0.000084181,
0.0008393338,
0.0336227342,
0.0400795117,
-0.0297353007,
-0.0303497817,
-0.1142989397,
0.0094984304,
0.0243948866,
0.0184878018,
0.0103960223,
-0.0365654081,
-0.0073175635,
0.0140781906,
-0.0226774532,
-0.0446962342,
0.0093613956,
0.0416458361,
0.0256011188,
0.0294327121,
0.0172935389,
-0.0873019546,
-0.0395062305,
-0.0121396575,
0.0367502943,
0.0671112761,
-0.0022924284,
-0.0047862493,
0.0241456907,
-0.0072212275,
-0.0176210832,
0.0074296612,
-0.0043861726,
0.0207429565,
0.0079755485,
-0.022546256,
0.0047732373,
-0.0104746725,
-0.0486474223,
0.0857077315,
0.0026899939,
-0.022442352,
-0.0138870729,
0.0008574891,
-0.0334783718,
0.0026321106,
-0.0666174218,
0.05329182,
0.0022936242,
-0.0049608732,
0.0206907131,
-0.0124270124,
-0.0216585267,
-0.0339192525,
-0.0162897278,
-0.0615848303,
-0.0275435634,
-0.0353768282,
0.0601359904,
-0.0180513896,
-0.0466034189,
0.0510687083,
-0.0109631084,
0.0070054801,
-0.0959240049,
0.0253924597,
-0.0285771675,
-0.0032296369,
-0.005578191,
-0.0061489679,
-0.0027966551,
0.0022434168,
-0.0089479284,
-0.0319424942,
0.0348645076,
0.0004464469,
0.0402419232,
-0.0557932258,
0.0604893826,
-0.0268332008,
-0.0329614803,
0.0016098793,
-0.0285330266,
-0.0335588604,
0.0180731937,
0.045618061,
-0.0016718748,
-0.0585578606,
0.0220809728,
0.0635407194,
0.0870001838,
-0.0186083391,
-0.0138943652,
0.0060409876,
-0.0426062122,
0.0359502435,
-0.0705862194,
0.0431637689,
-0.0203844607,
0.0311868135,
0.0615519993,
-0.0085994508,
0.003202433,
-0.0293703191,
-0.0165634137,
-0.0006868239,
-0.0575465485,
-0.0435500033,
0.0115896733,
0.0013934521,
-0.0359643996,
0.0241222791,
0.0911881775,
-0.0032143393,
-0.1412195414,
-0.0382671691,
-0.0573339649,
-0.0430929437,
-0.0211265069,
-0.0140515631,
-0.0554269627,
-0.0011546349,
0.0150828073,
0.058623828,
-0.0165841449,
-0.0255481694,
0.0183922537,
-0.0286377501,
0.0646206513,
0.0060868338,
-0.0420386679,
-0.0020821858,
-0.0259876642,
0.0280585103,
-0.0376595855,
-0.0048391814,
0.0153308017,
-0.0395004041,
0.0172876138,
-0.0152667183,
-0.0712155327,
-0.0706255436,
0.0557735153,
-0.0355132781,
0.0552977212,
0.0336103775,
0.0019382843,
-0.0373204872,
0.0209072158,
0.0680937916,
-0.0521177612,
-0.0325613432,
-0.0158778578,
0.0661908835,
0.0414581001,
0.0468403436,
-0.038464129,
0.0181308016,
-0.0409323238,
-0.0146766733,
0.0404071994,
0.0991294235,
-0.0171031859,
-0.0415934697,
-0.0241473485,
0.0268374607,
-0.0129532488,
0.033840932,
0.0161431357,
0.0006089483,
-0.0146997767,
0.0184373781,
-0.0130007574,
0.0252562966,
-0.045720838,
0.033357542,
-0.0336474217,
-0.0486126281,
-0.0159817711,
-0.0713213235,
0.0578862615,
-0.0031148219,
0.0244840868,
0.0681221709,
0.0565971956,
-0.0230481923,
0.010602152,
0.0763005242,
0.0215837955,
0.0066631492,
-0.058454141,
-0.0086549195,
0.064120166,
0.0139333783,
0.0149783241,
0.0182008743,
0.0309546608,
-0.020284012,
-0.0100553595,
0.0373561867,
0.0267421082,
-0.0131130544,
0.0193224698,
-0.0241946969,
0.0333539546,
-0.0265733134,
0.0153413387,
-0.037924055,
-0.0209406801,
0.0076362197,
-0.0005066809,
-0.0371815227,
-0.0439776741,
0.0241614301,
0.0006234373,
-0.0170270149,
-0.000494571,
0.0060971919,
0.0496393666,
0.0605032034,
0.0417856164,
-0.071204558,
0.0147912242,
-0.0255798493,
-0.0295827091,
-0.0202177353,
0.016039351,
-0.0381526016,
0.0219900757,
0.0294096582,
0.0198989082,
-0.0356617123,
0.0113505144,
-0.0842356756,
-0.0047709728,
-0.0728636757,
0.0962406322,
-0.0080333948,
0.0476199053,
0.0570171848,
-0.0216790512,
-0.0171393584,
-0.023185119,
-0.0377369262,
0.022051204,
0.0016933413,
0.0126821501,
-0.0048543806,
-0.0127575025,
0.0020289011,
0.0421498753,
-0.067113176,
-0.0454802401,
-0.0070908125,
-0.0437376313,
0.0294885151,
0.009922252,
0.0563983321,
-0.0377878323,
0.0010475378,
-0.0611142889,
-0.0032570276,
-0.0012566572,
0.0475366749,
0.0185786337,
0.0053372141,
-0.038000226,
-0.0613476112,
0.0601191521,
0.0157720968,
-0.0018145095,
-0.0083643924,
-0.0684589073,
-0.0015864073,
-0.0641738921,
-0.0277169049,
-0.0017672597,
-0.0527350679,
-0.0329586416,
-0.067855373,
-0.0189130474,
-0.0592132099,
-0.0044059278,
-0.005901875,
-0.0363734737,
-0.0483293049,
0.0427075736,
0.0236134473,
-0.0266754311,
-0.0492046811,
0.0242137238,
-0.0028919035,
-0.0380285494,
-0.0098559279,
-6.039005984e-33,
0.0397610664,
0.005618134,
0.0089799725,
-0.0107147694,
-0.0086035067,
0.0265116263,
-0.0357797183,
0.0097775552,
0.042534858,
0.0727014318,
-0.0360940173,
-0.0002112789,
0.0046213949,
-0.0154817821,
0.0949663669,
0.033647351,
0.0305558778,
-0.0022502749,
-0.0048744823,
0.0124885626,
-0.0600867085,
-0.0273384117,
0.0335358717,
-0.0270835552,
0.0653522834,
0.0453700535,
0.0133266188,
-0.0351284035,
-0.0059299204,
0.036799062,
0.0045239502,
0.0328453965,
0.0365441516,
-0.0260926373,
-0.0159977209,
-0.0251470972,
-0.0599292479,
0.0108359773,
0.0348745808,
-0.0290725678,
-0.0043666563,
0.0125569124,
0.0652302727,
-0.0015184652,
-0.0646499693,
-0.0025757777,
0.0166706108,
-0.0553151146,
-0.0332856514,
-0.0637063384,
-0.0485448502,
0.0515189804,
0.0084536038,
0.0566321574,
0.0107863881,
0.0894660205,
-0.0326002799,
0.0364561044,
-0.0151868751,
0.0154915424,
0.0456852615,
-0.0090506971,
0.003327813,
-0.0284990333,
-0.0293130856,
0.0525778979,
-0.0244361293,
0.0083331689,
0.01041154,
-0.0088487118,
-0.0026131307,
-0.0037602377,
0.0372063927,
0.0447050333,
0.0329708606,
0.0101524536,
-0.0687476397,
0.0726945251,
-0.0532923304,
0.031604439,
0.0728363693,
-0.0244930126,
-0.0110466015,
-0.0338033698,
-0.012348664,
-0.0278509818,
-0.0036923448,
-0.0071251858,
0.0314688161,
-0.0114284204,
-0.0046822899,
-0.0188269522,
0.0500103049,
-0.004660802,
0.0173723847,
0.0091592297,
-0.0281811971,
0.0331560485,
0.0087495781,
0.0112462901,
-0.0749071836,
0.0140230311,
-0.0051658689,
0.0545857176,
0.0490976647,
-0.0106537249,
0.007177629,
-0.0165248569,
-0.0720299631,
0.0072503025,
-0.0136120319,
0.0486346744,
0.013603067,
0.0109173404,
-0.0005159277,
-0.0055854982,
0.0366028398,
0.0134305414,
0.0272565801,
-0.0191184562,
-0.0378040373,
0.0268338099,
-0.024268033,
-0.011686272,
-0.002741965,
0.0145395733,
-0.0070485864,
0.025774328,
0.0674784407,
-0.0084395744,
0.0101044504,
-0.0164038483,
2.843e-7,
0.0776083246,
0.0529365353,
-0.0342381857,
-0.0262440126,
0.051267311,
0.0162321143,
-0.0093817199,
-0.0081780981,
0.0300713666,
0.0396675617,
0.071452409,
-0.0034398315,
0.0141943553,
0.0383281521,
-0.0435499325,
-0.0320351906,
-0.0685849637,
-0.0318038277,
-0.073523134,
-0.03934839,
-0.0183309466,
0.0370720811,
-0.0460505225,
-0.0050349561,
-0.0228459034,
-0.0268044341,
0.0097767944,
-0.0481329896,
-0.0089793215,
0.0286487844,
0.0498822592,
-0.0057443301,
0.022766497,
0.0342321619,
-0.0134125734,
-0.0096158497,
-0.0253355354,
0.0353991017,
-0.0260252859,
0.0635400936,
0.0435552709,
-0.0185442213,
0.0485110842,
-0.0769578665,
0.0268386174,
-0.0385858156,
-0.0431954786,
-0.017301783,
-0.0409805626,
-0.0280445646,
0.0958895013,
-0.0171589013,
-0.0218630731,
0.0509706251,
-0.0154920546,
0.0092604989,
-0.0250365641,
-0.0079784198,
0.0395956226,
0.0512536168,
-0.0365089886,
-0.0631470904,
-0.0022296447,
-0.0555255264,
-0.0461634584,
-0.071097672,
0.0520871691,
2.643346544e-34,
0.0815712214,
-0.0090485169,
0.0059399758,
-0.0311771352,
0.0264525991,
0.0329168141,
-0.0115751959,
0.0254356116,
-0.0011460595,
-0.0557209551,
-0.0020692358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17514v1 | The Validity of Evaluation Results: Assessing Concurrence Across Compositionality Benchmarks | 2023-10-26T16:11:04 | 2023-10-26T16:11:04 | Kaiser Sun, Adina Williams, Dieuwke Hupkes | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP models have progressed drastically in recent years, according to numerous
datasets proposed to evaluate performance. Questions remain, however, about how
particular dataset design choices may impact the conclusions we draw about
model capabilities. In this work, we investigate this question in the domain of
compositional generalization. We examine the performance of six modeling
approaches across 4 datasets, split according to 8 compositional splitting
strategies, ranking models by 18 compositional generalization splits in total.
Our results show that: i) the datasets, although all designed to evaluate
compositional generalization, rank modeling approaches differently; ii)
datasets generated by humans align better with each other than they with
synthetic datasets, or than synthetic datasets among themselves; iii)
generally, whether datasets are sampled from the same source is more predictive
of the resulting model ranking than whether they maintain the same
interpretation of compositionality; and iv) which lexical items are used in the
data can strongly impact conclusions. Overall, our results demonstrate that
much work remains to be done when it comes to assessing whether popular
evaluation datasets measure what they intend to measure, and suggest that
elucidating more rigorous standards for establishing the validity of evaluation
sets could benefit the field. | [
0.0592492782,
0.0887919143,
-0.0077961278,
-0.0180803053,
-0.0256234687,
0.0344266184,
0.0150861004,
-0.0126289288,
-0.0702684969,
-0.0619044378,
-0.0088827396,
-0.0674864203,
0.0215766001,
-0.0172896795,
0.0342324972,
-0.0435569137,
0.0273725316,
0.023127567,
-0.018820677,
0.0280367248,
0.0042141513,
0.007939511,
0.0111501412,
0.0534289591,
-0.0039157704,
0.0200241581,
0.0098963734,
-0.0273973811,
-0.0024233819,
-0.0109269582,
-0.0048428592,
0.0675321072,
0.0112114241,
0.0088839289,
0.0000018563,
-0.0654121339,
0.0215531606,
0.0040911017,
0.0141167017,
-0.0092149638,
0.0520526394,
-0.0263139978,
0.0276107155,
-0.0190434121,
-0.0202498939,
-0.0077732028,
0.0416528843,
0.0379145257,
0.0255756062,
0.0592616163,
-0.0083765415,
-0.0604479201,
0.0189037155,
0.0054912842,
0.0061735935,
0.0071943076,
0.0201098379,
0.0295054112,
-0.0149802389,
-0.0214192532,
-0.0210125446,
0.0122816823,
0.0153117459,
0.0475065894,
0.035290163,
0.0180652495,
-0.0894851238,
-0.060754925,
0.0138525749,
0.0576005094,
0.0308905356,
-0.0186442975,
0.0102723595,
-0.011113097,
-0.0201641768,
0.0245970488,
-0.0298387967,
0.0466571152,
-0.0240813084,
0.0100436667,
0.0179258715,
-0.0012840645,
0.0279817674,
0.0173933525,
-0.0064434535,
0.0726269558,
0.0256627668,
-0.0563881584,
0.0423899777,
0.0165232979,
-0.0001143845,
-0.0237781778,
-0.0224662647,
-0.0249448922,
-0.0053249639,
0.0157666262,
-0.0075327675,
-0.0174660981,
0.0164643321,
-0.0551329143,
0.0888776407,
0.0281061959,
0.0279700421,
0.0193149913,
0.0100296903,
0.040746022,
0.0025674242,
0.0151085043,
-0.0578649044,
0.0024559973,
-0.1002917737,
-0.0383738466,
0.0068371156,
0.0475006849,
0.0050388896,
-0.0360713154,
-0.0696589798,
-0.0178738702,
-0.0516147986,
-0.0280051231,
0.0324508734,
0.0370536558,
-0.0315747671,
0.0196948163,
-0.0261564739,
-0.0057916516,
-0.0461669825,
0.0390177518,
0.0085902959,
-0.0334106237,
0.0364231616,
-0.0123676378,
-0.0006596897,
0.0020995936,
-0.0065694028,
0.0331957713,
0.0257909577,
-0.061674837,
0.0136181265,
-0.0239818096,
-0.0408757851,
-0.0697953701,
0.0351073518,
-0.0727109537,
0.0643776208,
0.0101362923,
0.0179848578,
-0.0436713807,
-0.0130774928,
0.0097518973,
-0.02802746,
0.0524405725,
0.0190267581,
0.0285737794,
-0.0258885417,
-0.0129292645,
-0.017195655,
0.0909429193,
0.0061251493,
-0.0342215896,
0.0282692295,
-0.0088644447,
-0.0061777765,
-0.0313176736,
-0.0203224719,
-0.0333958939,
0.0250377692,
0.0014046755,
-0.024424402,
0.0356235392,
0.0003935215,
0.0643557012,
-0.0377951823,
-0.0236003753,
0.0423378795,
0.0369653739,
0.0518763959,
0.0240448024,
0.0675539598,
-0.0075232629,
0.0290635284,
0.0547322072,
-0.0236414317,
-0.0235360246,
-0.0389311388,
0.0247299057,
0.0122395307,
0.0196938384,
-0.0239814799,
-0.0360509679,
-0.0583395623,
0.0121844551,
0.0415221006,
-0.0428783335,
0.0333113894,
0.0359900706,
0.0068209311,
0.0399364978,
0.0607752986,
-0.0810579732,
-0.0015225882,
0.0175765064,
0.0253850333,
0.0364213251,
0.0079421047,
0.0023534843,
-0.0073929718,
0.0040584411,
0.0175844394,
0.0251422413,
0.0220929943,
-0.0097389622,
0.0523493774,
-0.0129877403,
0.0183545612,
-0.0679745227,
0.0374783278,
0.0000016313,
0.0440846495,
-0.0591636226,
-0.0012500163,
-0.0602649339,
-0.0157580525,
0.0562145822,
-0.0247095451,
0.0070041348,
-0.0104131717,
0.0151982773,
0.0332147367,
0.0297035966,
-0.0053550848,
0.0361452103,
-0.004208344,
-0.0119268596,
-0.0431414619,
0.0349782705,
-0.0495668128,
-0.0219629854,
0.0059737433,
-0.0800215974,
-0.0281968061,
-0.0083792703,
-0.0149862003,
-0.0131852981,
0.0404604226,
-0.0254044812,
0.0196938571,
-0.0387757421,
0.0172954109,
-0.017337013,
-0.0225657132,
0.0032405208,
0.0533011034,
0.0055673243,
0.0658128187,
0.0150782159,
-0.0285863746,
0.0130006932,
-0.0204445273,
-0.0605307594,
0.0305717885,
-0.0250103623,
-0.0073993509,
0.0110116331,
-0.0150193861,
-0.0742329136,
-0.0108176144,
-0.0917908773,
0.0010943363,
-0.0167393554,
-0.0009593889,
0.0628356859,
-0.0080212504,
0.0175358541,
0.0814776197,
-0.0048693088,
-0.045416031,
-0.0157308951,
0.0426567383,
0.023083549,
-0.0104508577,
0.0324041285,
-0.0282017123,
-0.0265978109,
-0.0241873264,
0.0727864131,
-0.0209807586,
0.0321653746,
-0.0107710585,
0.0246210024,
-0.0479518771,
-0.0184229333,
-0.002542332,
-0.0361997671,
0.0303417332,
0.0246046502,
0.0215051938,
0.0308085158,
-0.0089093251,
0.0098241717,
0.0432778038,
-0.0044173426,
-0.0250133984,
-0.0201311186,
-0.0384753421,
0.0133844223,
-0.0138634276,
-0.0450893454,
0.0137397172,
0.0753756911,
0.0180639457,
0.0076053087,
-0.0657745674,
0.0267798901,
-0.0860668197,
-0.0428628474,
-0.0427121334,
-0.040534731,
-0.0397801846,
0.0378311723,
-0.0299740843,
-0.0157174189,
0.0722939968,
-0.0027190195,
0.0110387439,
-0.0270930529,
0.0025048358,
-0.0438601635,
0.047558628,
-0.0238094144,
-0.0066865678,
0.0049492773,
-0.0034135592,
-0.0550184734,
0.0059841629,
0.0346854441,
0.0051239058,
0.0381851569,
-0.0216298699,
-0.0020105699,
0.0275001824,
-0.028945066,
0.0085004829,
0.0170879513,
0.00098443,
0.0403200164,
0.0769010037,
0.0225315038,
-0.0089396294,
0.014497607,
-0.0193157885,
-0.0304067675,
-0.0112136835,
-0.0191272106,
0.0180259664,
0.0265224986,
0.0000050456,
0.0084380507,
0.0214356929,
-0.0223148614,
0.00671412,
0.0135905556,
0.0083974982,
0.0459274054,
-0.0454038829,
0.0270975586,
0.006186726,
-0.0447477065,
-0.050358966,
0.0004409648,
0.0491582006,
-0.0349842384,
-0.0089359051,
0.0901144519,
0.0405541509,
-0.0087947967,
0.0068150652,
0.0322942436,
-0.0214161389,
0.027239494,
-0.0158989914,
-0.0502074957,
0.0060422057,
0.0306374449,
-0.0336998776,
-0.0416709147,
-0.0265723355,
-0.019902708,
-0.1187612414,
-0.0042505302,
0.002097172,
-0.0545713827,
-0.0033681511,
-0.0529826581,
0.0120207043,
-0.0304998215,
-0.0044688615,
0.006269556,
-0.043976739,
0.0226441193,
0.0185300186,
-0.0927556232,
-0.0684513077,
-0.0047071101,
-0.0433976613,
0.0100446166,
0.0298542455,
0.0477904715,
-0.0196024105,
-0.0180568732,
0.0432054885,
-0.0272324551,
0.0002342516,
0.0159204043,
0.0496023744,
-0.0226306375,
0.0147047648,
-0.0179354995,
0.0150941927,
-0.0243365094,
-0.0104638757,
-0.0444160514,
0.038262669,
0.0255341828,
-0.0430104062,
-0.0450982675,
0.0525116846,
-0.021293316,
0.090529494,
0.0570917651,
-0.0327873379,
0.0053839763,
-0.0233137533,
0.0102517437,
-0.058008492,
0.000656275,
0.0493640527,
0.0423714146,
0.0139213447,
-0.0759039894,
-0.0947084054,
0.0204947069,
0.0086419247,
0.0105303554,
0.0117805749,
-0.0007374675,
-0.0389314815,
-0.0045885448,
0.0119737294,
0.0345337652,
-0.0046639838,
-0.0144058224,
-0.0230405089,
-0.0121340761,
-0.0012564315,
-0.0381517299,
-0.030053189,
-0.0861265436,
-0.0733832121,
0.0142855002,
0.0244122799,
0.0197013803,
-0.0201026462,
0.0079900185,
-0.0787402838,
0.0085104955,
0.0217459705,
0.006990389,
0.0156290121,
0.0267324671,
0.008719692,
0.0407576263,
0.0161209479,
-0.0413064361,
0.0151662985,
0.0273812581,
0.0543688312,
0.0674858242,
0.0230372567,
0.038445387,
-0.0124367066,
0.0030675097,
-0.0309672337,
0.0117876092,
-0.0402114131,
-0.0327019654,
-0.0426514931,
-0.0289562475,
-0.049143862,
-0.0048920931,
0.0504611619,
0.048048038,
-0.0401518792,
0.0152324419,
-0.0371554531,
0.0783561692,
-0.0654764399,
0.0261710975,
0.0686761364,
-0.0589867011,
-0.0212431792,
0.026822852,
-0.0162989385,
0.0311272349,
-0.0568695888,
-0.014025378,
-0.0257899705,
0.022791611,
0.0117937298,
0.0206140447,
-0.0306365918,
0.010674241,
-0.0732165277,
0.0109536322,
-0.0310398936,
0.008779116,
0.0403340571,
-0.0523356572,
0.0434617214,
0.0016782661,
-0.0125451321,
-0.0131333219,
0.0328179933,
-0.0027029177,
-0.0314835198,
0.0349186324,
0.0357046165,
-0.0134397941,
-0.0174345896,
0.0862811953,
0.0003145991,
0.0167196654,
-0.0035421918,
0.0035685056,
-0.0121159367,
-0.0031930949,
0.0049881446,
0.0514082387,
-0.0067672143,
-0.021005448,
-0.0745971203,
-0.0229965951,
0.0036632132,
-0.0191618819,
0.0346175544,
-0.0015343442,
0.0369531736,
0.0840291679,
-0.0019147841,
-0.0020924169,
-0.0085954107,
-0.0758660138,
-0.003543006,
0.0219459198,
-0.0492928848,
-6.182677842e-33,
-0.0015126294,
-0.006958487,
-0.0252117775,
-0.0272344872,
-0.0047396529,
0.0222159214,
0.0062801805,
0.0249538366,
-0.0192821883,
0.0246112365,
-0.0123373643,
-0.0059371986,
0.0093504088,
0.0043330244,
0.0242912564,
0.0057579055,
0.0095896823,
0.0014152239,
-0.0461888798,
-0.0434299074,
0.0226164274,
0.0378032438,
0.0738277733,
-0.0151307983,
0.0507217534,
0.0412577689,
0.0057929615,
-0.0527757034,
0.0099574318,
0.0655838773,
-0.0157129504,
0.0808981732,
0.0754671693,
-0.0278304201,
-0.0005736775,
-0.0029718825,
-0.0390530229,
-0.0343928598,
0.084416084,
-0.0357823446,
-0.0385007188,
-0.0035592872,
0.0484487899,
0.0075169327,
-0.0401577801,
-0.069768548,
0.0488142669,
-0.0057336567,
-0.0181609057,
-0.0866341516,
-0.1026907936,
0.0122278752,
0.0022852567,
0.0148150511,
-0.0060364432,
0.0404303782,
-0.0480256863,
0.0295795128,
-0.0547642261,
0.023067398,
-0.0064253816,
0.024757782,
0.0235233214,
-0.0101252701,
0.0259829499,
0.0699954256,
0.0042933277,
0.032509096,
-0.0316301472,
0.0049518668,
0.0299591683,
0.0590142421,
0.0311929211,
0.0437465869,
0.0303252582,
-0.0189115405,
0.0007881419,
-0.0092809033,
-0.0281850528,
0.0113359177,
0.0566245131,
0.003634627,
-0.0330607407,
-0.0326598026,
-0.0730481744,
-0.0497644171,
-0.0248739552,
-0.0412351228,
0.0587854981,
0.0078620827,
-0.0165906139,
-0.0065667229,
0.0043038018,
-0.0655558482,
-0.0049836682,
0.0282349233,
-0.0397729948,
0.0304885749,
0.017412914,
0.0051557799,
-0.0742306933,
-0.0085970173,
0.0245997384,
0.0614679269,
0.03931069,
-0.0369997881,
0.0365211181,
-0.0012045285,
-0.0209397096,
-0.0232400186,
-0.0517458357,
-0.0329747312,
-0.0047003124,
0.0062155202,
0.0585889779,
0.055619061,
-0.0330295712,
0.0487303659,
0.008372372,
0.0351038203,
-0.0480556376,
-0.0045614098,
0.0061942041,
0.0264522694,
0.0023221083,
0.0054733502,
-0.0043872781,
-0.0216982495,
0.079978466,
0.0071610967,
-0.0368122607,
0.0193956811,
2.588e-7,
0.0801790506,
0.047599528,
0.0009944006,
0.0000769798,
-0.0052325348,
-0.0153871095,
-0.0343451761,
-0.0078209555,
0.0032238259,
-0.0151831824,
0.0027655566,
-0.001986349,
0.0461782254,
0.0157969855,
-0.0625923499,
0.0117087811,
-0.1020750627,
-0.0053359135,
-0.0518654212,
-0.0030251194,
0.0531580821,
0.0784481764,
0.0170710459,
0.0123962658,
-0.0304675102,
-0.0170018002,
0.0657319278,
-0.0449307486,
-0.0272708796,
0.0036548648,
0.0219559912,
0.0232449397,
0.0373389684,
-0.0029696187,
-0.0094465725,
0.0166749824,
0.0472283065,
0.0111232661,
0.0261767376,
-0.0084354999,
0.0072876518,
0.000014851,
-0.0293918047,
-0.0913672745,
0.0729336441,
-0.0786282867,
-0.0543621182,
-0.0494502783,
-0.0502912104,
0.0541133508,
0.0360814184,
-0.0117147584,
0.0242234208,
0.0287714452,
0.0086842477,
-0.0026679824,
-0.0182157848,
-0.0481958203,
-0.0272133816,
0.0149035342,
-0.0184644386,
-0.0292436741,
0.003672532,
-0.0183699634,
0.0191872008,
-0.0504941754,
-0.0325497985,
2.222918363e-34,
0.0357687213,
0.0126818055,
0.0726973116,
-0.0108587686,
0.0517869554,
-0.0244820155,
-0.0024589403,
-0.009146153,
-0.0431429632,
-0.0589148998,
0.007508724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17513v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17513v3 | The Expressive Power of Low-Rank Adaptation | 2023-10-26T16:08:33 | 2024-03-18T02:13:24 | Yuchen Zeng, Kangwook Lee | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA), a parameter-efficient fine-tuning method that
leverages low-rank adaptation of weight matrices, has emerged as a prevalent
technique for fine-tuning pre-trained models such as large language models and
diffusion models. Despite its huge success in practice, the theoretical
underpinnings of LoRA have largely remained unexplored. This paper takes the
first step to bridge this gap by theoretically analyzing the expressive power
of LoRA. We prove that, for fully connected neural networks, LoRA can adapt any
model $f$ to accurately represent any smaller target model $\overline{f}$ if
LoRA-rank $\geq(\text{width of }f) \times \frac{\text{depth of
}\overline{f}}{\text{depth of }f}$. We also quantify the approximation error
when LoRA-rank is lower than the threshold. For Transformer networks, we show
any model can be adapted to a target model of the same size with
rank-$(\frac{\text{embedding size}}{2})$ LoRA adapters. | [
0.0021584628,
0.0607310236,
-0.0213042311,
0.056744352,
0.0465760827,
0.0299235079,
0.003239041,
0.0103736557,
-0.020426156,
-0.0008698342,
-0.08737313,
-0.0116753699,
0.0218743086,
-0.0013615068,
0.0421457961,
-0.0328458026,
0.0123805506,
-0.0209446792,
-0.0671644658,
-0.0368244871,
-0.0331168249,
-0.0041188532,
0.0239686836,
0.0127597107,
0.0901731327,
0.0259366501,
-0.0258791745,
0.0081044016,
0.032107085,
0.0262000617,
-0.0040514916,
0.0320362933,
0.0286456104,
0.0331446268,
0.0000020947,
0.0056980546,
-0.0183529947,
-0.0057349778,
-0.0211485401,
0.0158583727,
-0.0045714038,
-0.0307200421,
-0.0256073866,
-0.0173430145,
-0.0111831222,
-0.0223551039,
0.0625253618,
0.046025347,
0.022990793,
0.0848516822,
-0.0261658952,
-0.0470688045,
0.0492091738,
-0.0528932922,
-0.033286918,
-0.0495475009,
0.0126736164,
-0.0033846579,
-0.0670755804,
-0.0129735908,
-0.0671604201,
-0.0001150804,
-0.0023127217,
0.032506898,
0.0093704285,
0.0220704116,
-0.0316601545,
0.0069936877,
0.0016834815,
0.0893609896,
-0.0796449259,
-0.0082779694,
-0.0091056777,
-0.0437052734,
0.0074815024,
-0.0197238978,
-0.0289714374,
-0.0317914262,
0.0573039092,
0.0310418308,
-0.0349164791,
0.0088155176,
0.0486699454,
-0.0120318197,
-0.087329492,
0.0195799228,
0.0274740607,
-0.0081587248,
-0.007732329,
-0.0333874375,
-0.0229575299,
0.0077247494,
-0.0040749288,
0.0066400818,
0.0038120158,
-0.0314522684,
-0.0515232794,
-0.0486613661,
-0.0172853079,
-0.0145463347,
0.1246035844,
0.0290257894,
0.0091390116,
0.0414960496,
-0.0868212879,
0.0547503792,
-0.090642795,
0.0263479892,
-0.0409740843,
0.0277618654,
-0.006845939,
0.0225478336,
-0.0288800746,
0.0037971919,
-0.061978925,
-0.0135939457,
-0.0340308584,
0.040674936,
-0.0136036742,
-0.0136080356,
-0.0442194566,
0.0071472884,
-0.0345287994,
-0.041039858,
0.008747437,
0.080232434,
0.0270159151,
0.0539732799,
-0.005021187,
-0.0212178305,
-0.0210891366,
0.0050204424,
0.0568111129,
-0.0320269614,
0.0555176027,
0.0752224773,
-0.0175061729,
-0.0305062626,
0.0055747386,
0.0433474928,
-0.0166024547,
-0.0398547687,
0.0422798283,
-0.0302048009,
0.0309817884,
-0.0129997851,
0.0568135045,
-0.0313086882,
-0.0317759141,
-0.0144197363,
-0.0682657957,
0.0536965095,
0.0103016701,
-0.0186503828,
0.0098496098,
-0.0190419387,
0.00807105,
0.0304788295,
0.0346451104,
0.0286348257,
-0.0059556901,
-0.0356277041,
-0.0569249056,
0.0311001111,
0.0079985671,
0.0256109219,
0.0048244996,
-0.011424398,
0.0058529098,
0.0019353345,
0.029567698,
0.0119510517,
-0.0246236566,
-0.0192602277,
0.0599354133,
0.0284452848,
0.0740028024,
0.0748520419,
0.0184499156,
-0.0331533439,
-0.0130114323,
0.0167686436,
-0.0324810296,
0.0377417989,
-0.0291506872,
-0.0162699018,
0.0069951923,
0.073591657,
-0.0511576831,
-0.0443097912,
0.0106446082,
0.0033804674,
0.0077020172,
-0.0356698148,
0.0462257005,
0.0208695866,
-0.0426463559,
0.0431250781,
0.0277451891,
-0.0384841003,
-0.0048401286,
-0.0781341046,
0.003537836,
-0.0063737622,
0.0096905436,
-0.0426718853,
0.0119265337,
0.0105655324,
0.0317439474,
-0.0064576082,
0.0366974287,
0.0342251919,
0.0191405285,
-0.0465918556,
0.0093112644,
0.0168418754,
0.0220973082,
0.0211045966,
-0.0315675028,
0.0036084112,
0.0159668345,
-0.0257525351,
-0.0318026692,
0.011323669,
-0.0201848876,
-0.012562965,
0.033596579,
0.0134966401,
0.023983987,
-0.0013068058,
-0.022840973,
-0.0250297431,
0.0144273872,
-0.0123516358,
-0.0173601545,
-0.0228132959,
-0.0175236538,
0.0382698737,
-0.0206586327,
-0.0302480552,
0.04398413,
0.0889788494,
-0.0397380404,
-0.0190405548,
0.0395734906,
0.0006800973,
0.0138982013,
-0.0110917939,
0.0209969673,
-0.0228891168,
0.0823275745,
-0.0093977554,
0.0097307498,
0.0122362003,
0.0235986114,
0.044066269,
0.0016038206,
-0.0036548611,
-0.0177138895,
-0.0846625045,
0.0148149468,
-0.0102511505,
0.0573179573,
0.0143720005,
0.0057023489,
0.0047414233,
-0.0418746546,
-0.05598142,
0.0231222622,
-0.02709141,
0.0193665065,
0.0253324974,
0.0233133696,
0.0211571511,
0.0004773726,
-0.0130149312,
0.0591811314,
-0.0456047803,
0.0087427134,
0.0301649515,
0.0109321661,
-0.0149603914,
-0.0618597977,
-0.0291309152,
0.0172298122,
0.0816835761,
-0.0264316071,
-0.0083409762,
-0.0509695634,
0.011537021,
-0.0016782705,
0.0389759354,
-0.0373161212,
-0.0670929626,
-0.030723216,
-0.013574902,
0.0340592749,
0.086114645,
0.0200932547,
0.0152634736,
0.0533805266,
0.0605123863,
-0.0095096873,
0.0007222302,
-0.0298075955,
-0.0440271683,
-0.066481173,
-0.0061040968,
0.0046937857,
0.0352770016,
-0.0318149216,
-0.02235502,
-0.0616684742,
0.0114648035,
0.0076054409,
0.0146200871,
-0.0157552604,
0.0342948548,
-0.0061630146,
-0.0273890253,
-0.0126787182,
0.0032703765,
0.0174164828,
-0.0217189472,
0.0061026015,
-0.0045057875,
-0.0721978173,
-0.0365464725,
-0.0036261498,
0.0334468409,
0.042696692,
-0.0321095772,
0.0255101509,
-0.0653771684,
-0.003683296,
0.0225901157,
0.0002152818,
0.043836493,
-0.0131851556,
-0.0053930292,
-0.0519251637,
-0.035184633,
0.0260450263,
-0.0580689013,
0.0054344051,
0.02892958,
0.0192984734,
-0.029166406,
-0.0316427015,
-0.0046233162,
0.0236207284,
0.0765871778,
-0.0265540518,
-0.0055749887,
-0.0460628308,
0.0523038544,
0.0285084173,
0.0745033845,
0.0505815968,
-0.0101837236,
0.0689849034,
-0.003737686,
0.0005416882,
0.0165618118,
-0.0666877925,
0.0405893624,
0.0209308546,
0.0395712629,
-0.0255294982,
0.0164435543,
0.0643971711,
0.0081707863,
0.0018508063,
0.0319918655,
-0.0242829714,
-0.0565101877,
0.0086495969,
-0.0203119982,
0.0654910207,
0.0251636002,
0.0353356488,
-0.0334778652,
-0.0052953619,
-0.0128749106,
0.0121943075,
-0.0014857862,
-0.0182948895,
0.0204357952,
-0.0763697028,
0.0243543535,
0.0316428654,
-0.0049165995,
-0.0409970134,
0.0067263888,
0.0205691122,
-0.0040148897,
0.0415387675,
-0.0133808665,
-0.0366351679,
-0.0639575571,
0.0266994946,
-0.0049765343,
-0.0415775627,
-0.0101880133,
-0.0129285809,
0.0390430354,
0.0125269862,
0.0046806131,
-0.0331590995,
-0.0469615795,
0.0282204188,
-0.0507455766,
0.002214672,
0.0250049327,
0.035330724,
0.0443052463,
-0.052946724,
0.0314546451,
0.0288419705,
0.0088461386,
-0.0017419346,
-0.0347792208,
0.0461419709,
0.0110179195,
-0.0308679119,
0.0112689575,
-0.0317705013,
-0.0304700136,
0.0145760896,
0.0439521074,
-0.0503649041,
0.0090360232,
0.0105488263,
0.0143248076,
0.0157503784,
-0.0572462939,
0.0272460356,
-0.0367033184,
-0.0170154497,
-0.0215028673,
0.0513234474,
-0.0061029047,
0.0446914174,
-0.0084066167,
-0.056877166,
0.0052660154,
0.0028809914,
0.0020932474,
0.0278600473,
-0.032854367,
-0.0122075947,
-0.0218941886,
0.0154078221,
0.0754885897,
-0.0284633338,
-0.0314097814,
-0.0457657166,
-0.0628610328,
-0.0480793603,
0.0029102184,
0.031832274,
0.0166569278,
0.0132657913,
0.005170288,
-0.0824145079,
0.0733793676,
0.0378542319,
0.0207128916,
0.0844192803,
0.0609205998,
-0.067677252,
-0.0466201268,
0.0472731404,
-0.0730117336,
0.0377915874,
0.0552007183,
0.0012438407,
-0.0072082109,
-0.0058988552,
-0.0132004265,
0.0010968334,
0.0293498971,
0.0520508029,
-0.0320812389,
-0.0125576984,
0.0503693186,
-0.0029308775,
0.0127745429,
-0.0216381773,
-0.0839940608,
0.0205815155,
0.0376058258,
-0.0218566693,
-0.0197510403,
0.0496020317,
0.0329848602,
-0.0760237426,
-0.0065219742,
0.0183279011,
0.0102307452,
0.0443241,
0.0366880633,
-0.0429459177,
-0.0002376946,
0.0312408544,
0.0209020637,
-0.0203137547,
-0.0179700591,
0.0105246939,
-0.012372083,
-0.1020789742,
0.0618676208,
-0.0721527711,
-0.0941578448,
-0.0347300209,
0.0273954794,
0.0475805961,
0.0137948198,
0.0267382991,
0.0376502797,
-0.0290195737,
-0.0028526473,
-0.0176544823,
0.0044023171,
-0.003847305,
0.0417190902,
0.0119159305,
0.0270498302,
0.0221048743,
0.0181577858,
0.02416672,
0.0475450195,
-0.0214535538,
0.0144859608,
-0.0150147881,
-0.0161556248,
-0.0125459656,
0.0312191881,
0.0150003526,
-0.0193520933,
-0.0074698948,
-0.0797211826,
0.0052239392,
-0.0067741182,
0.045252692,
-0.0355610996,
-0.0178696699,
0.0224134289,
0.0178471915,
0.0153795369,
0.0321016982,
-0.0399822928,
0.0204035044,
0.0256155096,
0.0171214826,
-6.559617738e-33,
-0.0302546658,
0.0269573368,
-0.0100647854,
0.005830748,
-0.0025437113,
0.0014145459,
-0.0149928862,
-0.0116801821,
-0.0419051126,
0.00597886,
-0.033969,
-0.0059603788,
-0.0004530282,
0.0179200377,
-0.0226317775,
0.0020399955,
0.0530043393,
0.0034995116,
-0.0193179511,
-0.0025600803,
-0.0094620697,
-0.0036217826,
0.0111635281,
0.0029052047,
-0.0465507023,
0.0191135686,
-0.0486667566,
0.0019191263,
-0.0199490301,
0.0464263037,
-0.0303889606,
0.059102837,
0.0144884102,
-0.0082960995,
-0.0109556979,
0.0248404611,
-0.0834259167,
-0.0032085881,
0.0000054478,
-0.0172251854,
0.0023769659,
-0.009917927,
0.0873397663,
0.0135244634,
-0.0242569484,
-0.0391424559,
0.037519522,
-0.022842966,
0.0068665803,
0.0049665798,
-0.0560262948,
0.0003800353,
-0.009158955,
-0.003126316,
-0.0011983637,
0.0287363324,
0.004024466,
0.0369037017,
-0.0822434798,
-0.0191026162,
0.0111711938,
0.0557679124,
0.0040482674,
0.014612386,
-0.0415140763,
0.040061675,
0.0176216643,
0.004217186,
0.0243038591,
-0.0594033636,
0.0397488177,
0.0212386195,
0.0629784837,
0.0087603629,
0.0065492578,
-0.0214162767,
-0.093608588,
-0.0336587653,
-0.0522799715,
0.0073587364,
0.0305004027,
0.0235712305,
-0.0096173836,
-0.012381183,
-0.0382493623,
-0.045973178,
-0.0514924042,
-0.002051854,
-0.0055871103,
0.0101027554,
-0.0184090845,
-0.0001306416,
0.0038520747,
-0.0517833978,
0.0315933824,
-0.009774426,
-0.0133418832,
0.0276542269,
0.0068768011,
0.0230119228,
-0.0055082296,
-0.0666237921,
0.0174636133,
0.0063421419,
0.0266651548,
-0.0105826603,
0.0387056917,
0.0530762151,
-0.0761274323,
-0.0560331792,
-0.0101499697,
-0.0092845857,
0.0045108525,
0.0685102567,
-0.0016714875,
-0.0014468423,
-0.0141740711,
0.0491904356,
0.008588451,
0.0215496179,
-0.0005523647,
0.0049498444,
0.0317536071,
0.0361219123,
-0.0493150949,
-0.0137779536,
-0.0144711118,
0.0586795099,
0.0355174653,
-0.065039739,
-0.0360948928,
0.0203854498,
2.977e-7,
-0.0101046627,
-0.0071015037,
-0.0253727511,
-0.0554984957,
0.0334357508,
0.0284832716,
0.001391875,
0.0606825948,
0.0062238392,
0.0133218877,
0.0071147364,
0.0006581041,
-0.0030061882,
-0.0446198359,
-0.0370660163,
-0.0073092775,
-0.077820994,
0.024403289,
-0.0241794214,
-0.0420045853,
-0.0092086159,
0.0996591896,
0.0014599788,
-0.0032257026,
-0.0126475533,
-0.0087660067,
0.0401381738,
-0.0376442745,
0.0162123665,
0.0058597713,
0.0369952768,
0.0071278019,
-0.0443614796,
0.0039061846,
0.0212668963,
0.1061380431,
-0.0160607509,
0.0243852884,
-0.0206197668,
0.0286169164,
0.0242947191,
0.0251863524,
-0.0011772391,
-0.0506076552,
0.0719527081,
-0.1081561297,
-0.0305975266,
-0.0240987763,
-0.0309378784,
-0.0174732562,
0.0182669573,
-0.0282126684,
-0.0010856661,
0.0081262551,
0.0097763147,
-0.0116588706,
0.0005646713,
-0.0919311717,
0.0565296486,
0.0264984146,
-0.052402854,
-0.0668786392,
-0.0363369808,
-0.0719553977,
0.092587471,
-0.0235654768,
0.037386477,
2.407383732e-34,
0.0263560116,
0.0141787594,
0.0395554826,
0.0002679694,
0.0360701978,
-0.0036945143,
0.0034120861,
-0.0120167565,
0.0479392745,
-0.1284869909,
-0.0187549964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17512v2 | CompeteAI: Understanding the Competition Dynamics in Large Language Model-based Agents | 2023-10-26T16:06:20 | 2024-06-07T09:13:27 | Qinlin Zhao, Jindong Wang, Yixuan Zhang, Yiqiao Jin, Kaijie Zhu, Hao Chen, Xing Xie | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MA | Large language models (LLMs) have been widely used as agents to complete
different tasks, such as personal assistance or event planning. While most of
the work has focused on cooperation and collaboration between agents, little
work explores competition, another important mechanism that promotes the
development of society and economy. In this paper, we seek to examine the
competition dynamics in LLM-based agents. We first propose a general framework
for studying the competition between agents. Then, we implement a practical
competitive environment using GPT-4 to simulate a virtual town with two types
of agents, restaurant agents and customer agents. Specifically, the restaurant
agents compete with each other to attract more customers, where competition
encourages them to transform, such as cultivating new operating strategies.
Simulation experiments reveal several interesting findings at the micro and
macro levels, which align well with existing market and sociological theories.
We hope that the framework and environment can be a promising testbed to study
competition that fosters understanding of society. Code is available at:
https://github.com/microsoft/competeai. | [
0.0216585398,
0.0294548236,
-0.0687143728,
0.0345871001,
-0.0447753742,
-0.0377967618,
0.0075810915,
0.0095111933,
0.0434653237,
-0.0024402246,
-0.0139707215,
-0.0333320983,
0.0099771982,
0.0343231969,
-0.005990441,
-0.019355854,
0.0157299284,
-0.0341806971,
0.0059136734,
-0.0336572304,
0.0002507834,
-0.0129811307,
0.03230929,
0.0511797555,
0.0250934977,
0.0133161284,
-0.0133978548,
-0.0159807559,
0.0209737085,
-0.0326344408,
0.0103288917,
0.0017075854,
0.0487346351,
0.0500934795,
0.0000020267,
-0.068571195,
-0.041726511,
0.0080997953,
-0.0387447476,
0.0362890847,
0.0714289472,
0.027770618,
-0.0189457759,
0.0103999376,
-0.0447852947,
-0.0084678559,
0.0386294462,
-0.000556145,
0.0386967286,
0.0332266949,
0.0000588168,
-0.0474709533,
-0.0269198027,
-0.0151903825,
-0.0948831886,
-0.0493227765,
0.043689508,
-0.0113380915,
0.0509250984,
-0.0123550519,
-0.0044299057,
0.00417929,
0.0124001708,
0.0106512858,
-0.0298512131,
0.073497206,
-0.0213166084,
-0.0219608378,
-0.0131639848,
0.0431833677,
0.0350634158,
-0.0158683732,
0.0477396771,
0.0019720257,
0.0013744853,
-0.0003409673,
-0.0147364819,
0.045183368,
0.0330431052,
0.0414407291,
0.0284377132,
0.0270071924,
0.0236838441,
0.0167090259,
-0.016631905,
0.09095186,
-0.0037309614,
-0.0135877663,
-0.050693132,
-0.0332288593,
0.0324083343,
-0.0244111214,
0.013934629,
0.0458795056,
-0.066383183,
-0.0007722027,
0.0088011511,
0.0511023104,
0.0140531855,
-0.0856726468,
-0.0077381744,
-0.0065158275,
0.0267801099,
0.0419220589,
0.0378979072,
0.0370312035,
-0.0108388988,
0.0017375431,
-0.0223850776,
-0.0219895579,
-0.0429244004,
0.0031559989,
-0.0496214032,
0.023978522,
-0.0218327828,
-0.0154686999,
0.0143002346,
0.0505568013,
-0.0332348384,
0.0581894517,
-0.0391723104,
-0.0005005792,
0.0205546953,
-0.0104366355,
-0.0741318315,
-0.0091219144,
-0.055520799,
-0.0063310345,
-0.01933592,
-0.042967841,
0.0376586132,
-0.0048743309,
-0.0048817224,
-0.0370239168,
-0.003924747,
0.0663482323,
0.0288274661,
-0.0036383017,
-0.0086654788,
-0.0084537864,
0.0464588776,
-0.0799247101,
-0.0448969826,
-0.066247724,
0.0073999269,
-0.014277217,
-0.0071394444,
-0.0034855357,
-0.0222861599,
-0.0200004578,
-0.0459593125,
0.0401464179,
-0.0331342742,
0.0469125696,
0.0648976639,
-0.0104951672,
0.0170980841,
0.0713869184,
0.0269569289,
-0.0039276816,
0.0470877886,
0.0069193528,
0.0678457096,
0.0496865064,
-0.0214770082,
0.0613647513,
0.0262731537,
0.0248455405,
-0.0038730255,
0.0207629502,
-0.0255790967,
0.0147173051,
-0.0408600233,
0.0097717764,
0.092045486,
0.0481593013,
0.0184139498,
0.0026498933,
0.0056149033,
0.0573252738,
-0.0371868834,
-0.0145409079,
0.0078617139,
-0.0013843395,
-0.0143556884,
0.0126765277,
-0.0510363542,
0.0314292386,
-0.0379925407,
0.006591815,
0.0363133885,
-0.0054373275,
0.0678045973,
0.0027355077,
0.0507916175,
-0.0480398871,
-0.0360447317,
0.0018866268,
-0.0063587008,
-0.0094759148,
-0.0109351585,
-0.0872354582,
0.0215812624,
0.0776429325,
0.0535738841,
-0.0080987336,
0.016201321,
0.0184828267,
-0.0577042513,
0.0854058936,
0.0785709247,
0.003409303,
-0.0467036627,
-0.0390141532,
0.0063278619,
0.0226941872,
0.0175461117,
0.0359251052,
-0.0082718274,
0.0066956542,
-0.0216900315,
0.0488541499,
-0.0003945632,
-0.0360282548,
-0.0048162905,
-0.0012461212,
-0.0852980465,
0.0151502704,
0.0118876547,
0.0063999454,
-0.031555295,
-0.015895674,
0.0127851488,
0.0115991123,
-0.0082848063,
0.043178916,
0.0644154325,
0.0450581983,
0.0178894028,
0.0114355665,
0.0074090082,
0.0304091237,
0.014357591,
0.0042788489,
0.0400942564,
0.0009221723,
0.1034076586,
0.00278937,
0.0159306023,
-0.0376910716,
0.0095396582,
-0.0118191307,
0.0468092412,
0.041805245,
-0.0288664401,
0.0211941935,
0.0274096821,
-0.0093069552,
-0.0205369312,
0.0196221974,
0.0228846688,
0.0250311587,
0.0431272052,
0.0477718376,
-0.0032729413,
0.0215790346,
-0.0211993996,
-0.0842049643,
0.0014937703,
0.0006902746,
-0.017446572,
0.040304631,
-0.0074716229,
-0.0152347842,
0.0649801046,
-0.0211565178,
0.0751697421,
0.0147763295,
0.0221588779,
0.020814117,
-0.0278607532,
-0.098569721,
-0.0364055112,
0.0289600231,
-0.015771782,
0.0183043461,
0.0089387409,
-0.0048727049,
-0.0509978421,
0.0139800189,
-0.0398539864,
0.0253233109,
-0.002381667,
-0.0631172881,
0.0332640931,
0.0001316751,
0.0193132646,
-0.0139740873,
-0.0450315401,
0.0601140112,
0.0528442748,
-0.0562515259,
-0.0630557761,
0.0026836221,
-0.0472396538,
0.0369032994,
-0.0879676864,
-0.0669191256,
-0.0040884702,
0.0908345953,
0.0022158406,
0.0015474054,
-0.0397902951,
0.0274634585,
-0.0364552028,
-0.0158364717,
-0.0192978494,
0.0307297036,
-0.0386305749,
0.0617331676,
-0.0215175468,
-0.0132357469,
0.0239482746,
-0.0111581683,
0.0125064291,
-0.0070977123,
-0.0162723605,
-0.0460224338,
0.0684687048,
0.0017894296,
0.0093838619,
-0.0255180988,
-0.0187353659,
-0.0273358133,
-0.0209302288,
0.0367397964,
-0.0140057486,
0.057498049,
-0.0716122612,
0.0004371555,
-0.0023438381,
-0.0106248176,
0.0063951714,
-0.0076704076,
-0.0417463146,
0.0414135046,
0.071782954,
-0.0007095891,
-0.0276370868,
0.0185231641,
-0.001020925,
0.0500813499,
-0.0065879188,
0.0043744952,
-0.039689593,
0.0139693134,
0.0285436306,
0.0758421719,
0.0088475272,
-0.0432565808,
0.0122986957,
-0.0104887458,
-0.01434997,
-0.0641538799,
-0.0127350166,
-0.0170038175,
0.0176103134,
-0.026284365,
0.0272342842,
0.0244511962,
-0.0197465383,
-0.0237780884,
-0.0074958806,
0.0635208637,
0.0092100976,
0.0050866976,
0.0237889327,
-0.0504053757,
0.0178305283,
0.0428539217,
0.0409332849,
-0.0529595762,
0.0418920442,
-0.0138226217,
-0.0265278965,
-0.0230448097,
-0.0061792117,
-0.0140966401,
-0.1040421128,
0.0638487935,
-0.0142952194,
-0.0522870794,
0.0007015674,
-0.008448882,
-0.0057940795,
-0.0226429235,
-0.0032017145,
-0.0178611744,
0.0315888599,
-0.0340173282,
-0.0181812067,
-0.0140006766,
0.0056397943,
0.0019356085,
-0.077104263,
0.1015110388,
0.0569238886,
0.04914077,
-0.0235635936,
-0.0095428694,
-0.0486248359,
0.0281558745,
0.0163746011,
0.0106111877,
0.0029088552,
0.016643621,
-0.0034569495,
0.0092269555,
-0.060018044,
-0.0321594998,
-0.0010179987,
0.0728215724,
0.0348828137,
0.0117885852,
-0.071301721,
-0.0014818498,
-0.0102268951,
-0.0109532187,
0.0487905331,
-0.0111674601,
-0.0267680828,
-0.0360674597,
-0.0407129712,
-0.0664112195,
0.0247081239,
-0.0569901392,
-0.0088693006,
0.0131903412,
-0.0378163233,
-0.0172401089,
-0.0597628653,
0.0232046787,
-0.0136645548,
0.0338413231,
-0.0005526533,
0.0380018353,
-0.007554085,
0.0401150212,
-0.0493037552,
-0.0593234263,
0.009979384,
-0.0031444102,
-0.0089705382,
0.0392514355,
-0.0482026041,
0.0009029946,
-0.0568529852,
-0.0620496981,
-0.0590834394,
0.0279068686,
0.0369946957,
0.0370469019,
0.0455770157,
-0.004191725,
-0.0041586142,
0.0017033344,
-0.0392996967,
-0.0417293906,
0.0324386917,
0.0097545274,
-0.0322095379,
0.0112316022,
0.005151114,
-0.0237555373,
0.0202546101,
-0.0109376945,
0.0252979305,
-0.0762247965,
-0.0199825298,
0.0185871962,
0.0105176605,
-0.0031343312,
-0.0008692357,
-0.0176525004,
-0.0285964105,
-0.0002011727,
-0.0484494083,
0.0029960559,
-0.0123061109,
-0.0595826767,
0.018829396,
0.0395413637,
0.0313841067,
-0.0101622054,
-0.0061098803,
-0.0129118264,
0.0208721366,
0.0046666223,
0.0246974174,
0.0063269986,
0.0360720269,
0.0149461366,
0.0029742273,
0.0503117554,
-0.0297584403,
0.0498863757,
0.0185494125,
0.0326054245,
-0.0085339397,
-0.0616373867,
0.0221880376,
0.0289875176,
-0.0096518872,
-0.0783765763,
0.0381694846,
0.0558033288,
0.0520406291,
-0.0179411303,
0.0691535324,
-0.0700731799,
0.0326297097,
-0.0164519046,
-0.0268396083,
-0.019168267,
-0.0511679538,
-0.0244292598,
0.0096228998,
-0.0206114221,
0.0137201641,
0.092790857,
0.0205449387,
0.0455026291,
-0.027188139,
0.0120581808,
-0.0331097506,
-0.0197191425,
0.0386370122,
0.0128666805,
-0.034763556,
-0.0236688666,
-0.074143596,
0.000946043,
-0.0260226354,
0.0438361801,
-0.0059483261,
-0.0428865515,
0.0216328241,
0.0062784189,
-0.0287716258,
-0.0193562359,
-0.0705769211,
0.0141725764,
-0.0329701826,
0.0110417316,
0.0027039787,
-6.310587056e-33,
0.0050301938,
-0.0515955165,
0.091413565,
-0.0213836394,
-0.0246512666,
-0.0512599237,
-0.0328931212,
-0.0097404504,
-0.0200583022,
-0.0363487117,
0.0066510686,
0.0022924722,
0.0288627911,
-0.03851844,
0.0260128025,
-0.0359160155,
0.0082502067,
-0.0121806674,
-0.0003851135,
-0.0114841824,
-0.0745538473,
-0.0260813255,
0.0142725715,
-0.0031964546,
0.0032684281,
-0.0362204239,
-0.0353518017,
0.0123116067,
-0.0353497639,
0.0229887534,
-0.0220945682,
0.0316720307,
0.0245673172,
-0.0601263344,
0.0169377625,
-0.0268327259,
0.0124654649,
0.0020019112,
0.0085212654,
-0.0063151382,
-0.0103611229,
-0.0386250876,
-0.0109693017,
0.0103817247,
-0.0316262096,
0.0518667325,
0.0452201068,
-0.0357595794,
0.0065280907,
0.0623756014,
-0.0936764926,
0.0075295842,
-0.0102778655,
0.0383464359,
0.0313340276,
-0.0330874026,
0.0149398306,
-0.00730045,
-0.0654718056,
0.0480182022,
0.0351778418,
-0.0352317244,
0.0359585546,
0.028087005,
0.0268755555,
0.0339750312,
0.0063602827,
0.0497092195,
0.0056108977,
-0.0272917822,
0.0220106989,
0.076394245,
0.0091427518,
0.0423997827,
-0.0718876049,
-0.0194099005,
0.0174326319,
0.0077189952,
0.0627435222,
-0.0504800007,
0.0107504092,
0.0011628409,
-0.0259618238,
-0.0096638659,
0.008374434,
-0.0123262778,
-0.0257133394,
-0.0296088662,
0.02665524,
-0.0165117346,
-0.0049251677,
-0.0066903103,
0.0212888587,
-0.0635136142,
-0.0754415914,
-0.0519687943,
-0.0023054383,
0.0035000201,
-0.0042360355,
-0.000009502,
-0.0730993301,
-0.0607679263,
-0.0873573795,
0.0437657721,
0.0076169628,
0.0586512126,
-0.0917182565,
0.0289004743,
-0.0107641499,
0.0183354635,
0.0096507454,
-0.0164024066,
0.0556224249,
-0.0241028052,
0.0128554115,
-0.0397556871,
0.0287560951,
-0.0068719331,
0.0308722481,
-0.0353656225,
0.0011315224,
0.0314695686,
-0.0022395467,
-0.0081298733,
-0.0106145982,
0.0283481125,
-0.0680118352,
0.0664473698,
0.0382599123,
-0.0344914719,
-0.0315355919,
-0.0681384653,
2.788e-7,
-0.0221832208,
0.0974178091,
-0.012970156,
0.0275678914,
0.0113750417,
0.0644855574,
-0.0031522196,
0.0332448184,
-0.0077180909,
-0.0333304144,
0.0466837436,
0.0248805862,
-0.0081646116,
0.0559049621,
-0.0721039101,
0.0190987345,
-0.0623632744,
-0.0032705439,
-0.0511689074,
-0.0409879051,
0.0377787724,
0.0319398567,
0.0581228212,
0.0212941412,
-0.0022258204,
-0.0116738006,
0.0110921282,
-0.0564069748,
-0.0041595581,
0.0482256636,
-0.0628635809,
-0.0057081128,
-0.0281625167,
-0.0200941451,
0.014035278,
0.0339688249,
-0.014130339,
0.0412821434,
0.0066253329,
0.0188370589,
0.0396651179,
-0.0874812007,
-0.017040303,
-0.0617980585,
0.0474360697,
-0.0312516131,
0.0121681029,
-0.0211996697,
0.0168702211,
-0.0192605872,
-0.0222369153,
-0.0464528948,
-0.0102322334,
-0.0020041883,
-0.0152305197,
-0.0183572676,
0.0196109693,
-0.0328565463,
0.0096694278,
-0.0094259866,
-0.0387856252,
-0.0603608899,
-0.0155462744,
0.0374448262,
0.0053565418,
0.0136681506,
0.0305815823,
2.292418548e-34,
0.0291018318,
0.0134824682,
0.0175329186,
0.0211304706,
0.0410266295,
0.0271076579,
-0.0380848758,
0.0025549654,
0.0054851999,
-0.0297425836,
-0.026968753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17499v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17499v1 | The IMS Toucan System for the Blizzard Challenge 2023 | 2023-10-26T15:53:29 | 2023-10-26T15:53:29 | Florian Lux, Julia Koch, Sarina Meyer, Thomas Bott, Nadja Schauffler, Pavel Denisov, Antje Schweitzer, Ngoc Thang Vu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | For our contribution to the Blizzard Challenge 2023, we improved on the
system we submitted to the Blizzard Challenge 2021. Our approach entails a
rule-based text-to-phoneme processing system that includes rule-based
disambiguation of homographs in the French language. It then transforms the
phonemes to spectrograms as intermediate representations using a fast and
efficient non-autoregressive synthesis architecture based on Conformer and
Glow. A GAN based neural vocoder that combines recent state-of-the-art
approaches converts the spectrogram to the final wave. We carefully designed
the data processing, training, and inference procedures for the challenge data.
Our system identifier is G. Open source code and demo are available. | [
-0.0256252233,
0.0950393826,
-0.014176609,
0.0356321298,
-0.0101720765,
-0.0266725626,
0.0084223198,
0.020993188,
-0.0610600933,
-0.0027498764,
-0.0447278358,
-0.0396275185,
0.0288328733,
0.0412697047,
0.0383069739,
-0.0729294792,
0.0247344933,
-0.0535406172,
-0.0415340848,
-0.0252739303,
0.0117574884,
0.0413305834,
-0.0415502302,
0.0533201732,
-0.0616713949,
-0.015106855,
-0.0092374673,
-0.0083636018,
0.0278526675,
-0.0145823257,
-0.0468815751,
-0.0043046842,
-0.000162789,
0.089104645,
0.0000019028,
-0.0527548157,
-0.0324377343,
0.0171723478,
0.0009599878,
0.0084203007,
-0.0051487875,
-0.0073168385,
-0.0613688603,
0.024086317,
-0.0013038728,
-0.0375702046,
0.0811460838,
-0.0629401505,
0.0367253758,
0.0494053848,
-0.0150153898,
-0.0598242208,
-0.0034980886,
-0.0140028922,
0.0047616875,
0.008865552,
-0.0105204117,
-0.0028507209,
0.0014344912,
-0.0153329801,
-0.0249795616,
0.0717920959,
-0.0025082058,
-0.0001753462,
0.037089821,
0.0153444549,
-0.01319867,
-0.0216927473,
-0.0008698172,
0.0493253842,
-0.026361797,
-0.0259842426,
-0.0035870024,
0.0311891306,
-0.0347252674,
-0.0183424111,
-0.01816638,
-0.0104265725,
0.0055937474,
0.0099848872,
-0.0365173034,
-0.0070476397,
0.014018802,
-0.0576523319,
0.00339,
-0.0155705884,
0.0204438455,
-0.0009848371,
-0.002818292,
-0.0110823968,
0.0044553448,
0.0037339302,
0.0166844856,
0.0210032277,
-0.0296607893,
-0.0093710637,
0.0013082508,
-0.0164221022,
0.0045654662,
-0.013754447,
0.0428835601,
0.0019887486,
-0.0310428403,
0.0356537774,
-0.0249962341,
-0.01998966,
0.0250521954,
-0.0539009944,
-0.0448557287,
-0.0578116253,
-0.0566085018,
-0.0116302529,
-0.0620048679,
-0.03336256,
0.0028136307,
0.0024360947,
-0.0424656607,
-0.0671903566,
0.0135639403,
0.0408201069,
0.0259716175,
0.0186949372,
-0.0301171932,
0.0311230272,
0.0120501705,
0.0202624742,
-0.0101382509,
0.0219731014,
-0.0040540933,
-0.0437666401,
-0.0096792961,
0.0176133551,
-0.008693452,
0.0444918089,
0.0454462916,
0.083272852,
-0.0300994273,
0.0095412806,
0.0237835031,
-0.0334677324,
-0.0342200659,
-0.0488129891,
0.0187042989,
-0.0929764882,
0.0438853055,
-0.0001081326,
-0.0300475955,
-0.0287569277,
0.0118679348,
-0.0127982022,
0.0401357859,
0.0857810378,
-0.046164915,
-0.0163222831,
0.0122355241,
0.0036266469,
-0.0190068167,
0.017545497,
0.0532286949,
-0.0262550414,
-0.0062572318,
-0.0460207574,
-0.000523822,
0.0512864254,
-0.0147388363,
-0.0170074254,
-0.0533238687,
-0.0692142248,
-0.0144029763,
0.0309063122,
0.0467534475,
0.0762874484,
-0.0052533848,
-0.0376798883,
0.0247691218,
0.0715504363,
0.0807122141,
0.0329458602,
0.0040778951,
0.0163509995,
0.0419758447,
-0.0727614015,
0.0437627248,
0.0063152709,
-0.0256555192,
0.0110733192,
-0.0185457841,
0.0514318943,
-0.0055163503,
-0.0328720845,
0.0064963941,
0.0129246507,
-0.0243073478,
0.0034587607,
0.0728678554,
0.0023895649,
-0.0334702581,
0.0122177796,
0.0130909784,
-0.0337282009,
0.0389872007,
0.0057809558,
0.041729752,
0.0539195463,
0.0143022873,
-0.0462817997,
0.0500037745,
-0.0205332283,
-0.0583698265,
0.0642102882,
-0.0182847567,
-0.0091382265,
0.0522401221,
-0.0828036591,
-0.0471276082,
0.0362415016,
-0.001839139,
0.0362915881,
-0.0058411928,
0.0120021068,
0.0115841869,
-0.0103168655,
0.0068231793,
-0.0002667339,
0.0015686809,
-0.0330125317,
-0.0238944665,
-0.0029277205,
0.0466447398,
0.0206578989,
-0.0301479399,
0.026816275,
0.0160869062,
-0.0477865674,
0.0144943511,
-0.0107881278,
-0.0215590131,
-0.0357274264,
0.0362351499,
-0.0950949714,
0.0158865154,
-0.0025843107,
-0.007993306,
-0.0364228152,
0.0662916228,
-0.0549453236,
0.0094198762,
0.00574996,
0.0018705429,
0.0278685652,
0.0366062038,
0.0271803103,
0.0033227422,
0.0322103463,
-0.0075338683,
-0.0208563805,
-0.0080066677,
-0.0041702664,
-0.0460263565,
0.0011682829,
0.0575238578,
0.0139663462,
-0.0032627485,
-0.0263704434,
-0.0266507268,
0.0040074596,
0.0040592258,
-0.0390742682,
-0.0193394069,
0.0010528829,
0.0022522225,
0.0027102095,
-0.0055814739,
-0.0005603899,
-0.0219962168,
-0.0342315398,
0.0465779267,
0.0190590415,
-0.0673782602,
0.0037800372,
-0.0257516652,
-0.0834979489,
-0.0269410387,
-0.0321250893,
0.0055634305,
0.0676228255,
-0.0252485555,
-0.061254546,
-0.0535604507,
-0.0171871372,
-0.0431474783,
0.0373580344,
0.0107042892,
-0.0709018856,
0.0318706445,
0.0065908139,
0.0470076986,
0.003698292,
-0.0030765082,
-0.0308259185,
0.0088075679,
-0.0231385138,
-0.0401017182,
-0.018720286,
0.0084225899,
0.047776185,
-0.0216489956,
-0.0079602627,
0.0118715074,
0.0370175131,
0.0571032241,
0.0201357529,
0.0049550566,
0.018803861,
-0.0088356938,
-0.0557333641,
-0.0152664073,
-0.0305480585,
-0.0068489527,
-0.0330410413,
-0.0102590648,
-0.0035275661,
0.0323508345,
-0.0514039248,
-0.0221758801,
-0.0587160476,
-0.0415321589,
-0.0241858605,
0.0686834231,
-0.0148662543,
0.0383513123,
0.077583164,
-0.026327936,
-0.0186475459,
-0.0335709602,
0.0347891115,
-0.0556754544,
0.0357675441,
-0.0215238761,
0.0007334308,
-0.0115048932,
-0.0030974019,
-0.0195000563,
0.0655498058,
-0.0018251279,
0.0369435772,
0.0689113662,
-0.0485205017,
-0.0293106884,
0.0470741279,
0.0102906106,
0.0195429642,
0.0296133049,
0.0063745836,
-0.009908082,
0.072010085,
0.0089633269,
-0.0255063567,
0.0241950843,
-0.0274914168,
0.0480758399,
0.04369656,
0.0286336485,
0.0119966045,
-0.0393360294,
0.0115065863,
0.0368933901,
0.0159306899,
-0.0448101386,
-0.0037683363,
0.0436489359,
-0.0537355468,
0.0338548981,
0.0348682292,
0.0012629392,
0.0027823218,
0.0317381099,
0.0888439715,
0.0272500552,
-0.0201359242,
0.0115181589,
-0.070637092,
-0.0017984475,
0.0299455486,
0.0356576703,
0.0476036519,
0.0386772752,
0.0049558203,
-0.0450042449,
0.0621477067,
0.0763342753,
-0.0045978711,
-0.0230869614,
0.0089534288,
-0.0260961819,
-0.0187501982,
0.0055414536,
0.0047086361,
0.0043455055,
-0.0272073466,
0.0539438054,
-0.0285766535,
-0.0242330879,
-0.0198112037,
-0.044518169,
0.0882963613,
0.0522273071,
0.0169591717,
-0.0105860075,
-0.0359765776,
0.032449048,
0.0289349463,
0.0282892752,
0.0025871173,
0.0421943963,
0.0769785419,
-0.013115406,
0.0268914308,
0.0178798959,
-0.0025548756,
-0.0020589312,
0.0263921693,
0.0445733592,
-0.0241399053,
-0.0205130074,
-0.0103024626,
0.0476961173,
0.0058245407,
0.0689872131,
0.0130910324,
0.0004252485,
-0.046361357,
-0.058979407,
0.029715104,
-0.0963079557,
-0.0776657239,
-0.0099120475,
0.0535666607,
-0.0790055618,
-0.0495832376,
0.02078682,
0.0354014263,
0.0426145792,
0.0160253495,
-0.0084182778,
-0.0071151573,
0.0053884215,
-0.0308282282,
0.0410465151,
-0.0177137032,
0.0299504511,
-0.0544221401,
-0.0607633106,
0.0174053963,
-0.0348744318,
-0.0167673379,
0.0682106316,
-0.0356090143,
-0.0245937146,
0.0276747048,
-0.0107870437,
0.0272697676,
0.0345088579,
-0.0219241753,
-0.0135081476,
0.0593326651,
0.0056730965,
-0.0277271494,
0.0222409684,
0.0089261709,
-0.0109059252,
0.0052885511,
-0.0104426164,
-0.0424653143,
0.0745252594,
0.0057183765,
0.0444850624,
0.0167226475,
-0.0341426432,
0.0349833332,
-0.0395304374,
0.0312066767,
-0.0296036825,
-0.0140403444,
-0.0218144618,
-0.0056047295,
0.0118737379,
0.0431435816,
-0.0405312851,
0.0123159792,
0.0359643921,
0.0462075211,
-0.011079222,
0.0435219556,
0.0504052825,
-0.0156103801,
-0.0105341496,
0.0574737415,
0.0404112749,
-0.0061173262,
0.0124265496,
-0.0074727139,
0.0126439622,
0.0412298292,
-0.0240536034,
0.0065772072,
-0.0175755788,
-0.0206351392,
0.0378096141,
0.0080296155,
-0.0472366996,
0.0255915578,
-0.0463841669,
0.0310243461,
-0.0198839027,
-0.0153963231,
0.1118064821,
0.0372199565,
0.0300851017,
-0.0297699627,
0.0134042837,
0.0118018128,
0.0231540352,
-0.051250957,
0.0115287071,
-0.0056869276,
0.0035704507,
-0.012397089,
-0.04060537,
0.0464177579,
0.0447594561,
0.0246963277,
-0.0148870656,
0.0063790418,
-0.0463245437,
-0.0284008477,
-0.0424801894,
-0.0024226615,
-0.0539550819,
-0.0236917119,
-0.0114793526,
-0.0422610492,
-0.0302916411,
-0.0032343639,
0.0125696864,
0.0101915542,
0.0666583851,
-0.0119569702,
0.0162010174,
-0.0265234504,
0.0586984307,
0.0002050868,
0.0068723923,
-0.040829014,
0.0116563328,
-5.942171698e-33,
-0.0190377086,
0.0215197168,
-0.0285698604,
0.0083142156,
-0.0527863503,
-0.0217753686,
-0.0241422206,
-0.0464493148,
0.0022547629,
-0.0220141429,
0.0020476712,
0.0331671946,
0.0217798706,
0.0172285587,
0.0196356587,
0.0149993859,
0.1070754826,
-0.0187828522,
0.0162721984,
-0.000684108,
0.0541105047,
0.0679950342,
0.0620025806,
-0.0612355471,
-0.0448958129,
0.0729834363,
0.0052776579,
-0.0350299403,
-0.0222265534,
0.0589817725,
-0.0275074523,
0.0597129948,
-0.0358943678,
-0.001444306,
-0.0181835014,
-0.0137448478,
-0.1168385595,
-0.0165265836,
-0.0145574436,
0.0462816581,
0.0004310322,
-0.0366359167,
0.0567795672,
-0.0108733578,
-0.0590165071,
-0.0307113212,
0.0475388654,
-0.0405558944,
0.0036116955,
-0.0947681442,
-0.0474855378,
0.0124816382,
-0.002302669,
-0.01094505,
0.0318873487,
0.0571101755,
-0.0197670329,
-0.0480942912,
-0.1127640605,
0.0677903891,
-0.0177945923,
0.0850932449,
0.023066815,
0.0807668939,
0.0008061375,
0.0435317419,
0.0819792673,
-0.1191591471,
-0.0404142216,
-0.0149611533,
0.0302097872,
0.0070613804,
0.0799708962,
-0.045150619,
0.0582072027,
-0.045434013,
-0.0582273267,
-0.0062393355,
0.0417812131,
0.0030509606,
-0.0263761617,
0.0430009291,
-0.0363630652,
-0.0203429423,
-0.0209513139,
0.0021905261,
-0.012403544,
-0.0441990606,
0.0296877082,
-0.0164689906,
0.0011108026,
-0.0349936448,
0.0282568876,
-0.0088730538,
0.0120497877,
-0.0112230489,
0.0308516789,
0.0120588457,
-0.0030503301,
-0.0056426181,
-0.0229836125,
-0.002042003,
0.0746535435,
0.0378545038,
0.045388408,
-0.0184950158,
0.0030706229,
0.079442963,
-0.0499703251,
-0.0064317137,
-0.0070902705,
0.015596116,
0.0337639004,
0.0087938551,
0.031506896,
-0.0155595606,
0.0088685155,
-0.0359497517,
-0.0067291041,
0.0255055241,
0.0193093885,
-0.0016460362,
-0.0181056745,
0.0261062086,
-0.0422315933,
0.0221736412,
-0.0710407421,
-0.0171604715,
0.0457064435,
-0.024249889,
-0.0359844975,
0.018811956,
2.879e-7,
0.0279044062,
0.0054690228,
0.031566266,
0.0271443669,
0.009828493,
-0.0312645175,
-0.041747082,
-0.0172776338,
-0.0110165877,
0.0255162381,
-0.0163048748,
0.0113054886,
0.0778150856,
0.0681434795,
-0.0722368807,
-0.0304885563,
0.0040800385,
-0.0011133044,
-0.0580440946,
0.0436113141,
0.0393048935,
0.100591071,
-0.003976597,
-0.0355674438,
0.0079763802,
0.0083456431,
0.017302474,
-0.0107769836,
0.0193210971,
-0.0244654436,
0.0360380262,
-0.0301082544,
-0.0135685578,
0.0239659585,
-0.0222691093,
0.0036877978,
0.0174562149,
-0.03081825,
0.006181208,
-0.0260493476,
-0.0246341527,
0.0230335314,
-0.0005913189,
-0.0151989916,
0.0144631108,
0.0281394403,
-0.0219650101,
-0.0014040465,
-0.0412733667,
0.005080644,
-0.0264690015,
-0.00571506,
-0.0351162553,
-0.0228073373,
0.0178521276,
0.0006406272,
-0.0114183826,
-0.0233510509,
-0.0230692308,
0.0125149172,
-0.0289608762,
-0.0311660208,
0.0161549579,
0.0264284499,
-0.0036852832,
-0.0042224843,
-0.0477498546,
2.808103098e-34,
0.0051577599,
-0.0261423178,
0.0010570668,
-0.0309253819,
-0.0098285787,
-0.040601816,
0.0388277099,
0.0316846929,
-0.0007668933,
-0.0541534573,
-0.0473549478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17490v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17490v3 | Improving Zero-shot Reader by Reducing Distractions from Irrelevant Documents in Open-Domain Question Answering | 2023-10-26T15:45:12 | 2023-11-14T06:49:33 | Sukmin Cho, Jeongyeon Seo, Soyeong Jeong, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) enable zero-shot approaches in open-domain
question answering (ODQA), yet with limited advancements as the reader is
compared to the retriever. This study aims at the feasibility of a zero-shot
reader that addresses the challenges of computational cost and the need for
labeled data. We find that LLMs are distracted due to irrelevant documents in
the retrieved set and the overconfidence of the generated answers when they are
exploited as zero-shot readers. To tackle these problems, we mitigate the
impact of such documents via Distraction-aware Answer Selection (DAS) with a
negation-based instruction and score adjustment for proper answer selection.
Experimental results show that our approach successfully handles distraction
across diverse scenarios, enhancing the performance of zero-shot readers.
Furthermore, unlike supervised readers struggling with unseen data, zero-shot
readers demonstrate outstanding transferability without any training. | [
0.011598492,
0.0143779786,
0.0010565794,
0.0418429151,
-0.0272679012,
0.0132333897,
0.0302483346,
0.0109678889,
0.002081783,
-0.0719706789,
-0.0519877337,
-0.019510461,
-0.0615300871,
-0.0374120437,
-0.0106842825,
0.0018448519,
0.0630812049,
-0.0403519422,
0.0289094783,
-0.0010567695,
-0.0152010499,
0.001952951,
-0.0102501595,
-0.0133013679,
0.0354400203,
-0.0524252169,
0.0144073069,
0.0017211973,
-0.0202285666,
-0.0371552855,
0.0131103955,
0.060448382,
-0.0219432302,
0.037696477,
0.0000018987,
-0.0450656936,
-0.0074600354,
-0.0168482848,
-0.0591231808,
-0.0282795615,
0.0323194265,
-0.0047111423,
0.0154729458,
0.0024412109,
-0.0222489294,
-0.0277158115,
0.0277382545,
0.0825070813,
0.0496340767,
0.0639562458,
0.0170886647,
0.0144607387,
0.0065414994,
-0.0004715954,
0.082005389,
-0.0701964572,
0.0445945896,
0.0097977696,
0.0380794033,
0.0542244092,
-0.0386322252,
0.0272572152,
-0.0077517405,
0.0030617621,
0.0368483216,
0.0579357818,
-0.0357607901,
0.0115188109,
0.0183808748,
0.123762697,
0.0021060486,
-0.0072420291,
0.0027900506,
-0.0155129079,
0.0009326254,
0.0085900286,
-0.0899926275,
0.0242403001,
0.0115704136,
0.0100296224,
0.0110257808,
0.0157244951,
0.0127740866,
0.0402767099,
-0.0101655936,
0.0502851754,
0.0011000161,
-0.0648230836,
0.0266158469,
0.0170754902,
-0.007643932,
-0.0726644173,
-0.0170039237,
0.0597415715,
-0.0074233469,
0.031960573,
-0.0402888767,
-0.0646944493,
0.01489243,
-0.0273697414,
0.0158011671,
0.039047692,
0.0000756842,
0.0770266578,
-0.0324285813,
0.0098127024,
-0.0038881092,
0.0146826776,
-0.0568913482,
-0.0257527437,
-0.0219994653,
-0.0028793821,
-0.0202739127,
0.0721132755,
-0.0525663272,
-0.0404693708,
0.0290894639,
0.019059835,
0.0161706321,
-0.0302848108,
-0.0169439781,
0.021527838,
-0.0338857062,
-0.0168214161,
-0.0220248457,
0.0920785069,
-0.0250526015,
0.017772628,
-0.0443924032,
-0.0653949976,
-0.0350248925,
0.0177563969,
0.0009660433,
-0.0478364527,
-0.0142139224,
0.0834745839,
-0.0181685667,
-0.0486440845,
-0.0390401147,
0.0019911474,
0.0020777965,
-0.0634338111,
0.0090132952,
-0.0473813042,
-0.0109133096,
0.0390164889,
-0.0040502022,
-0.0366942324,
0.0253517181,
0.0679440275,
-0.0205292888,
0.0284234937,
-0.025050465,
-0.0143848304,
0.0292381942,
0.0265902113,
0.0051569901,
0.0854676515,
0.001279484,
-0.0266372357,
0.0517823249,
0.0050386353,
0.0277110394,
-0.0156519897,
0.0210713763,
0.0250672698,
0.0327345841,
0.0277891979,
0.0454452373,
-0.0061562038,
0.02448049,
0.023531232,
-0.0387555286,
-0.0517777316,
0.0628615394,
0.040599063,
-0.0096514421,
-0.0080572311,
-0.0236499049,
0.0277080089,
0.0079691438,
0.0213943981,
-0.0331727043,
0.0545187481,
-0.0590465851,
0.0105429785,
0.0157279484,
-0.0420816801,
-0.0449691415,
-0.0055713509,
0.0058256821,
-0.0067611029,
-0.0155884577,
0.0242327694,
0.0663384423,
-0.0120104533,
-0.0627562851,
0.042935513,
0.0175636187,
-0.0367459692,
0.015881354,
-0.0016603785,
0.0992414802,
0.0039389264,
0.0574569032,
-0.0471452624,
-0.0484235883,
-0.035049729,
0.0453878157,
0.0371957347,
0.0265045632,
-0.0153985666,
0.0047128592,
-0.0733393356,
-0.0297655538,
-0.0128222685,
-0.0018124715,
-0.0364007652,
0.0161831044,
0.0453395322,
0.0215732269,
-0.0223223642,
-0.0195802767,
0.0229916908,
-0.0325029381,
-0.0948934481,
0.0188508816,
-0.0225615818,
0.0187578704,
0.015014098,
-0.0150321275,
0.0160928778,
0.0492923297,
-0.0087103657,
-0.0125941448,
-0.0460203961,
-0.0454923883,
-0.0065740948,
0.0094316956,
-0.0259939488,
-0.0192317385,
0.0190400928,
-0.0313108228,
-0.0220384989,
-0.0036913706,
-0.0202714037,
-0.0118332114,
-0.0081760399,
-0.0140357241,
0.0202955958,
0.0002363585,
-0.0632096976,
0.0528314859,
0.0243334118,
0.0351910815,
0.0352973379,
0.0010867444,
0.0165200606,
-0.0526218712,
0.0012519922,
0.0018071936,
-0.0029931238,
0.0077713933,
0.017776452,
-0.0102633415,
-0.0690788254,
-0.0026678792,
-0.0639375299,
0.0201110933,
-0.0075523378,
0.0463500768,
0.0209220406,
0.0035388279,
-0.0082658576,
-0.0322199762,
-0.0182490088,
0.0252476223,
0.0189877264,
0.0209969822,
0.0182385221,
0.002903206,
0.0498540886,
-0.0186602417,
-0.0199328829,
-0.0011261654,
0.0348023288,
0.0002921898,
0.0067582321,
-0.0164275467,
0.022283569,
-0.0393608734,
0.026687203,
0.0193916559,
0.036156211,
0.0015545979,
-0.0302215498,
-0.0224895701,
0.081305474,
-0.0213669073,
-0.0275345892,
0.031708207,
-0.0014007284,
-0.070504494,
0.0098993713,
0.0006569661,
-0.0362670422,
0.0110463928,
-0.0170094054,
0.0092098452,
0.0492302068,
-0.0102543542,
-0.0296032298,
-0.0282443371,
0.0278180186,
-0.0370966047,
-0.0247242525,
-0.0640141368,
0.0282968376,
-0.0011066926,
0.0239922982,
-0.0255519487,
-0.0111505874,
0.0548815094,
0.0203000009,
-0.0063517955,
-0.078865923,
0.0458761305,
-0.0451772176,
0.0205827076,
-0.0285899453,
-0.0023403822,
0.0343310423,
-0.0162390582,
-0.0212409589,
-0.0435866341,
-0.0253778808,
-0.0248927046,
0.0340276323,
-0.0375246368,
0.0136215985,
-0.0199175552,
-0.0049948976,
-0.0557207838,
-0.0581617728,
-0.0213724803,
0.0258240998,
-0.0554579161,
0.0395368598,
-0.0792227834,
-0.0323240384,
0.0514600985,
0.0231532454,
-0.0387742594,
-0.0015900063,
-0.0249265805,
0.0835579485,
0.067531392,
0.0022991688,
0.023829421,
-0.0315772444,
0.0062252218,
0.081238009,
0.0167467203,
0.0120532811,
0.0542272255,
-0.015372877,
0.0420434624,
-0.0486260094,
-0.012819903,
0.0221800171,
0.037267413,
-0.0381342471,
-0.0141994702,
0.118090041,
0.0574252792,
-0.020093862,
-0.0114622759,
-0.0615531355,
-0.0071174046,
0.0090622613,
0.0249120593,
-0.0975280553,
-0.062863335,
-0.0157104172,
0.0430429876,
-0.0138856806,
-0.0378434956,
-0.001179368,
-0.1461995989,
0.0138379959,
0.0110089723,
-0.0333371535,
0.0132851098,
-0.0663140938,
0.0316996425,
-0.0221000481,
-0.0109296031,
0.0318012759,
-0.0174431931,
-0.0034751329,
0.0128594274,
0.0718075782,
-0.0077216332,
0.0198480412,
-0.000349523,
0.0207024813,
0.0200786218,
0.0110501498,
0.0046483134,
-0.0308494307,
0.0158502031,
-0.0722756013,
-0.0078772632,
-0.0285625793,
0.0571991019,
-0.0384800881,
0.0097171841,
-0.0359716825,
0.0378187522,
-0.0212689564,
-0.0064175283,
0.0212569889,
0.0832639635,
0.0204188321,
-0.0302442946,
-0.0355297476,
-0.0066714264,
0.0387179069,
0.08859054,
-0.0042602825,
-0.027449524,
-0.043456126,
-0.0093844505,
-0.0219121147,
-0.0203331131,
-0.0109763974,
0.0194596872,
-0.0094738444,
-0.0467208624,
-0.0557829328,
-0.0687836483,
0.0526775345,
0.0010771813,
0.0029725139,
0.0211574249,
-0.0023527695,
0.018789066,
-0.0004648905,
0.0385757275,
-0.0517514758,
0.0162092019,
-0.0566067249,
0.0190992039,
0.0227952227,
-0.0220320411,
-0.0078101088,
-0.0086492356,
-0.0499812104,
-0.0291468054,
-0.0070761079,
0.0423658974,
0.0201070216,
-0.0426737554,
-0.0104929786,
-0.0653349385,
0.0150009077,
0.0429987125,
-0.0589286014,
0.0192634072,
0.0245569516,
-0.0326549187,
0.0115999812,
0.0344058648,
-0.0378035195,
0.0371320806,
0.0488406792,
0.0420539826,
-0.0412416086,
-0.0074044792,
-0.0013787034,
-0.0048077907,
0.001511484,
0.0516063794,
0.0232339464,
-0.017450016,
0.0282625388,
-0.0175470728,
-0.0130982921,
-0.0011475404,
-0.0189513508,
0.0231457036,
-0.0422082096,
-0.0017892619,
0.0026723552,
-0.0668605939,
0.0281989202,
-0.0412838832,
0.0107990587,
0.0701020956,
-0.0028187255,
0.0026278072,
-0.028528044,
-0.0585261285,
-0.0031962395,
0.0248451512,
0.0391990356,
0.0126570761,
0.0580826402,
0.0123609249,
0.0032155011,
-0.016632108,
-0.0189966355,
-0.0658237785,
0.0082111619,
0.0201982297,
0.052847866,
0.033350803,
-0.0283324607,
0.0304381754,
0.0081692738,
-0.0146959033,
-0.0501129851,
-0.01004171,
0.0095429383,
0.0040649092,
0.0258397646,
0.0414851792,
0.0364592932,
0.0288549531,
0.1004093513,
0.0122676147,
0.0250094999,
0.0070808977,
0.0182925537,
-0.0228408538,
0.0145426001,
0.0161907524,
0.0522410721,
-0.0017712185,
0.0687021464,
-0.0626108572,
-0.0452910922,
0.008680406,
-0.0110825719,
-0.0137339961,
-0.0468499027,
0.0296789631,
0.0103840195,
-0.0033767221,
-0.065562889,
-0.0469517149,
0.0703282803,
-0.0525936484,
-0.0238561761,
-0.0568162501,
-6.336809396e-33,
-0.0220839474,
-0.0540928952,
0.0113784643,
-0.0055927318,
-0.0122596081,
0.0061712353,
-0.0358477309,
0.012615487,
-0.0254864842,
-0.0250458904,
-0.0245460086,
0.0018202038,
-0.0011336702,
0.0347460434,
-0.0298426747,
-0.042276524,
0.0225266349,
-0.0141060287,
-0.0203114133,
0.0127449846,
0.0526179075,
0.0206389911,
0.014497811,
-0.0633202568,
0.0456161946,
-0.0534171127,
0.0388802551,
-0.0030878542,
0.0213825554,
0.0514849052,
-0.0017680747,
0.0593720451,
0.0442431234,
-0.0444545634,
0.0051786196,
0.0571546555,
-0.0811231881,
-0.0532414578,
0.015386574,
-0.0027721312,
-0.0168465897,
-0.0560162961,
0.0146758528,
0.0163935814,
0.0168304332,
-0.030618662,
0.0183266457,
-0.0139756445,
-0.0639211461,
0.0306904614,
-0.074453637,
0.0191654712,
-0.005958647,
-0.0240744296,
0.0180508178,
0.0709304735,
-0.0173011515,
0.0247052126,
-0.0334069841,
0.0106587727,
0.0376615785,
0.0291475076,
0.0401772596,
0.0110439789,
-0.0054378333,
0.0333437175,
0.0127482377,
-0.005891135,
-0.0150769828,
-0.0556117371,
-0.0098824836,
0.0066481959,
0.0356564261,
0.0181905963,
0.0573745519,
0.0223818962,
-0.1065885872,
0.0120510748,
-0.0324683525,
0.049163375,
0.0357851684,
-0.0075482195,
-0.0184766315,
-0.0017871968,
-0.0232601371,
-0.0005163776,
-0.05716867,
-0.0077426243,
0.0477420688,
0.0014620365,
-0.0479646884,
-0.003534168,
0.0553208739,
-0.0330682918,
0.001306459,
0.0692595914,
0.0068147178,
0.0233415738,
0.0000469546,
0.0004860125,
-0.0826674998,
0.0059889983,
0.0361977667,
-0.0119293695,
-0.0148754911,
0.0317506716,
0.0169937629,
-0.0273475312,
-0.0362533443,
-0.0362894274,
-0.0282492153,
0.018392574,
0.0179500431,
0.056958098,
0.0334063619,
0.030468272,
0.0036885319,
0.059806373,
0.0020740866,
-0.0160144027,
-0.0125909513,
-0.0112464447,
-0.0049650231,
-0.020104846,
-0.0321576521,
0.0168135576,
-0.0056585856,
0.0522815138,
-0.0198713038,
-0.0663115755,
-0.0114935488,
0.040253371,
2.565e-7,
0.0197264664,
0.0305695534,
-0.0133961299,
0.0282661989,
0.027161587,
0.0554911606,
-0.0006923045,
0.041172374,
0.0649234578,
0.0195236225,
-0.0162029788,
0.0363470167,
0.0223017279,
0.0130915968,
-0.0918137282,
-0.0170273799,
-0.0014901607,
0.0224278532,
-0.045578666,
-0.0005577581,
0.0720013827,
0.063446708,
-0.0191763584,
0.0055305571,
0.0041155568,
-0.0327283964,
0.0598845109,
0.0155280503,
0.0126379933,
-0.0066506551,
0.0492259562,
-0.0083989948,
-0.0015210795,
0.034091346,
-0.0021928675,
-0.00571462,
0.0297665969,
0.0702016056,
-0.0150577836,
-0.0566014983,
-0.0123666488,
-0.0249767751,
0.0006237468,
-0.0189479794,
0.1103962958,
-0.0613399521,
-0.0365104489,
0.0247983113,
-0.0561777763,
0.00911316,
0.0116746789,
-0.002058455,
-0.041444283,
-0.0230394825,
0.0300985929,
-0.0008777126,
-0.0068523521,
-0.0147356717,
0.0010085711,
0.0008005137,
-0.0082361642,
-0.0486434624,
-0.0205161981,
-0.0014015852,
0.0055660554,
-0.0546820424,
0.0054313508,
1.825856001e-34,
-0.0104964031,
-0.0045646941,
0.0190242846,
0.0243180078,
-0.0195644423,
-0.0036160722,
-0.0218360387,
-0.0266536046,
0.0534509979,
-0.1020217761,
-0.0108587528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17488v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17488v2 | LightLM: A Lightweight Deep and Narrow Language Model for Generative Recommendation | 2023-10-26T15:44:57 | 2023-10-30T02:50:17 | Kai Mei, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | This paper presents LightLM, a lightweight Transformer-based language model
for generative recommendation. While Transformer-based generative modeling has
gained importance in various AI sub-fields such as NLP and vision, generative
recommendation is still in its infancy due to its unique demand on personalized
generative modeling. Existing works on generative recommendation often use
NLP-oriented Transformer architectures such as T5, GPT, LLaMA and M6, which are
heavy-weight and are not specifically designed for recommendation tasks.
LightLM tackles the issue by introducing a light-weight deep and narrow
Transformer architecture, which is specifically tailored for direct generation
of recommendation items. This structure is especially apt for straightforward
generative recommendation and stems from the observation that language model
does not have to be too wide for this task, as the input predominantly consists
of short tokens that are well-suited for the model's capacity. We also show
that our devised user and item ID indexing methods, i.e., Spectral
Collaborative Indexing (SCI) and Graph Collaborative Indexing (GCI), enables
the deep and narrow Transformer architecture to outperform large-scale language
models for recommendation. Besides, to address the hallucination problem of
generating items as output, we propose the constrained generation process for
generative recommenders. Experiments on real-world datasets show that LightLM
outperforms various competitive baselines in terms of both recommendation
accuracy and efficiency. The code can be found at
https://github.com/dongyuanjushi/LightLM. | [
0.0494278632,
0.0374400727,
-0.0019493448,
0.0150930109,
-0.0205347072,
-0.0191492587,
0.0256732237,
-0.0022540251,
0.0408490561,
-0.0011323207,
-0.0422465727,
-0.0097330734,
-0.0328369178,
0.071890302,
0.0038539781,
-0.0288471822,
0.0086887022,
-0.0155040687,
-0.0151660135,
-0.0238941777,
-0.0190895274,
0.0268385783,
0.050813552,
0.0404000022,
-0.010779948,
0.0064558699,
-0.0198908746,
0.0078378413,
-0.0243037436,
-0.0096794665,
0.0040813186,
0.0351214372,
0.0032964721,
0.0149116507,
0.0000018572,
-0.0030694166,
-0.0131052341,
-0.032334473,
0.0462801568,
-0.0487803183,
0.0534408502,
0.0507297143,
0.0013468975,
0.0094160046,
-0.0308326464,
-0.0395663194,
0.054787267,
0.0808250308,
0.0180077609,
0.0569179766,
-0.0304064676,
-0.0237025544,
0.0599312074,
-0.0302957483,
0.0688488856,
0.0202104803,
0.0052089468,
-0.0286209323,
0.0135237342,
0.0416230448,
-0.0109151201,
-0.0038226466,
0.0408593714,
-0.0311910361,
0.0852763504,
0.030805828,
-0.0411217026,
-0.0504025482,
0.0125620924,
0.1078536436,
-0.0377147608,
-0.0361943915,
0.0149883097,
0.019387411,
0.0175529364,
-0.0073721856,
-0.0310398433,
0.0001813566,
0.0166836623,
0.0201121029,
0.0216388553,
0.0105335759,
0.056824334,
-0.0199612435,
0.0451611206,
0.0467304587,
0.0494161099,
-0.003073174,
-0.0274342746,
0.0003300685,
0.0179242399,
-0.0594341308,
0.0227624532,
0.0109027494,
-0.0496334806,
-0.0246244054,
-0.034559302,
0.0100532994,
0.0035596816,
-0.0104125477,
0.0297657829,
0.0140523547,
-0.0277539007,
0.0264343042,
-0.0438331589,
0.0114518935,
-0.0099361893,
-0.0006099179,
-0.0584760047,
-0.0476482771,
-0.0121226162,
-0.0184050854,
-0.0470675267,
0.03591571,
-0.0359204113,
-0.0705809444,
-0.0433277711,
0.0499895252,
-0.010667868,
0.0159196164,
0.0207100958,
0.0894909278,
-0.0154909147,
0.0060030073,
-0.0388808437,
-0.0066663432,
-0.0376094282,
-0.0175334569,
0.0319980904,
-0.018040821,
0.0253075864,
0.0462428518,
0.0202957746,
-0.0526278615,
0.0143875536,
0.0292017292,
0.0002824037,
-0.0544352755,
0.002604235,
-0.030989239,
0.0061633461,
-0.0650635734,
0.0277949143,
-0.1002187803,
0.0436284952,
0.0129217887,
0.0160396677,
-0.0631374791,
0.0168091245,
-0.0012642866,
0.0191526823,
0.0334697701,
0.0051301615,
-0.0198098216,
0.0191387944,
0.00139469,
0.0062070955,
-0.0103453239,
0.0101534324,
0.1126970649,
0.0246771853,
0.0141934725,
0.0386647955,
0.0081867082,
-0.0135125443,
-0.0038008059,
-0.0082741072,
-0.0106313331,
-0.0519502684,
0.04265875,
0.0267699957,
0.1060144454,
-0.05157049,
-0.0370530374,
0.0547164679,
0.0215207785,
0.062675871,
0.1006921455,
0.0755868405,
0.0099724168,
-0.0625700057,
-0.0289714467,
-0.011302677,
0.1079641953,
0.0173947848,
-0.0399808921,
0.0472308658,
0.0478173122,
-0.0617188178,
-0.0127588157,
0.0405783542,
-0.064056322,
0.0437839739,
-0.0077665355,
-0.0029856518,
0.0025810585,
-0.0448061563,
0.0446090885,
0.0301591754,
-0.0383801907,
0.0147152729,
-0.0317875929,
0.0504020229,
0.1166297793,
0.0382435583,
0.0483484343,
0.0114322398,
0.0002777185,
-0.0282620862,
-0.0044646021,
0.0457582846,
-0.0326147936,
-0.0074916501,
-0.0368853174,
-0.0267710928,
-0.0003116883,
-0.0190659631,
0.0494699888,
0.0072657056,
0.0013942574,
0.0235880967,
-0.0172522478,
-0.0096008824,
-0.0132699935,
-0.0288041588,
-0.0320075303,
0.0650848374,
-0.0065560504,
0.0003211955,
-0.0124817593,
0.0445418209,
-0.0088136327,
0.0332169123,
-0.0406400114,
-0.0649581179,
-0.0042385547,
-0.0280120187,
-0.0021397497,
0.0297954716,
-0.0551630147,
0.0405900106,
0.0582482442,
0.0057895742,
-0.0498075895,
0.0377361737,
-0.0293026399,
0.0250907019,
-0.0423994474,
-0.0172876716,
0.0266004335,
0.0372430608,
-0.0254228339,
0.06923078,
0.0085145719,
0.0053220536,
-0.0121864844,
0.0282217823,
0.0070450632,
-0.0552882664,
-0.0530093946,
0.0145980231,
0.0006923428,
-0.0008354039,
0.0382529013,
-0.0136464071,
-0.0278440081,
-0.0443640873,
-0.0801264718,
-0.0089201313,
0.010759362,
-0.0533993244,
-0.0250097495,
0.0555741116,
0.0332540981,
-0.0059623052,
-0.0772797167,
0.0317633599,
0.0025443775,
-0.0028343291,
0.0002026818,
-0.0055476706,
-0.0231076144,
-0.0172590949,
-0.0165089518,
0.0054702805,
0.0369705297,
-0.0109037152,
0.0351792946,
-0.0167740844,
-0.0206266511,
-0.0371180996,
0.0097479252,
0.0037207436,
0.0255231448,
-0.016808223,
-0.0288205873,
0.0858746022,
0.008955284,
0.010504921,
0.0240941513,
0.0411772206,
-0.0056501213,
-0.0598487146,
0.0034455294,
-0.0537266284,
0.0307895485,
-0.011736623,
-0.0115833562,
-0.0169608928,
0.0157305915,
-0.0313829407,
-0.006821834,
-0.0721676573,
0.0147021776,
0.0237251595,
-0.0105239032,
0.0124923848,
-0.0035783506,
-0.0140504707,
0.0294702984,
-0.0021368337,
-0.0361405276,
0.0720308125,
-0.0182910524,
-0.0068704812,
-0.0029082124,
-0.0247117039,
-0.0531203076,
0.0112756658,
0.0395722352,
0.0290698335,
-0.0471720248,
0.0011498911,
-0.0198320691,
0.0624377206,
-0.0097645586,
-0.0283943191,
0.0306592882,
0.029550517,
0.0033158204,
0.0083637265,
-0.0400346518,
-0.0483053252,
-0.0253246743,
0.0216065422,
0.0177954603,
0.0481436886,
-0.0351559632,
-0.0372071862,
-0.016393885,
-0.0361851119,
0.0495259203,
-0.0125880362,
-0.0198442135,
-0.0021289831,
0.0104710516,
0.0710855797,
-0.073580429,
-0.0048035011,
0.0077411612,
-0.0094965091,
0.0301826503,
0.0139445644,
0.002645385,
-0.0437462404,
0.0091518704,
0.0568827949,
0.0051643034,
-0.034713313,
0.0391807742,
0.0186077282,
0.0381404683,
-0.0266701207,
0.0888491049,
0.0326689631,
-0.1047629938,
0.0194141455,
0.0025375609,
0.0418827645,
0.021090243,
0.0441831276,
-0.0815825686,
-0.0067380574,
0.0002745422,
0.0111014927,
0.017206775,
-0.0272113681,
-0.0152482176,
-0.0610112473,
0.0470629223,
0.0045137028,
0.0347059146,
-0.0165854394,
-0.0391911902,
-0.0266304445,
0.0039781881,
-0.0078485506,
-0.0187140163,
-0.0031092262,
-0.0042036287,
0.0052581741,
-0.0068582869,
-0.0192960966,
0.0347241871,
-0.0336589031,
0.0325681232,
0.0338402465,
0.027912192,
0.027999226,
-0.0414548069,
-0.0169628412,
0.0252796635,
-0.0350113474,
-0.01730402,
0.0145694353,
-0.0231579058,
0.0119793406,
-0.0198062286,
0.0181962159,
-0.0608353913,
-0.0267942343,
-0.057072673,
0.07271301,
-0.0282000247,
-0.0340237245,
-0.0422154814,
-0.0001473238,
0.0109419813,
0.0606631711,
0.0040217279,
-0.0415688716,
-0.014826565,
-0.0646121502,
0.0093531255,
-0.0415098369,
-0.046556253,
-0.0317166261,
0.0423701294,
-0.0082621267,
-0.0688608587,
-0.0360002965,
0.0031101878,
0.0057252748,
-0.015658142,
0.0129905911,
-0.0304650571,
-0.0518770516,
-0.0192474108,
0.0060038436,
-0.0047608609,
0.0008124463,
-0.0608408414,
-0.0334333964,
0.0286381301,
-0.0760901645,
0.0050051222,
0.0242678598,
-0.0721044689,
-0.021965364,
-0.0147872614,
0.0740100518,
0.0214090236,
0.0095767658,
-0.0333281942,
-0.0744906589,
0.0128131937,
0.0688302889,
-0.027699599,
-0.0295841526,
-0.0336821452,
-0.0009785662,
0.0125187151,
0.0357479863,
-0.07143832,
0.022779895,
-0.0077580442,
0.0278728791,
-0.0012916366,
-0.0407003202,
0.0382345356,
-0.0035613133,
0.0234661903,
-0.0353768952,
0.0527583957,
-0.0235707611,
-0.004626052,
-0.0036912691,
-0.0343589075,
-0.039974831,
-0.0000875817,
0.0535265394,
0.0100203184,
-0.013206536,
0.0133706145,
-0.0055761943,
0.0638434887,
-0.0564011037,
-0.0151230115,
-0.0195262656,
-0.040944919,
0.0323446952,
0.0237027444,
0.0040338011,
-0.0185446739,
0.0100287963,
0.0338322334,
-0.0265955869,
0.0013069188,
0.0020067389,
0.0061494987,
-0.0383932628,
0.0410163924,
-0.0157179981,
-0.0463626236,
-0.0248785224,
0.022528002,
0.026686823,
-0.00416181,
0.0221511777,
-0.0444294773,
-0.0033896605,
-0.0551288389,
0.0203546081,
-0.0200836789,
-0.081323579,
0.003079585,
0.0317395627,
0.0010318188,
-0.0104001779,
0.078260459,
0.0028979019,
0.004609297,
0.0009771974,
-0.0073284395,
-0.0431198962,
-0.0153599102,
0.0044031856,
0.013473196,
-0.017292412,
-0.0026680382,
0.002234943,
-0.0325037949,
0.0231026057,
-0.0377563313,
0.0405788347,
-0.0219979547,
0.0501105078,
0.0699953362,
-0.0101580359,
-0.0106031979,
-0.053192243,
-0.010535677,
0.0202238876,
-0.0288308207,
-0.0318519399,
-6.376167151e-33,
0.0071287169,
-0.0311938543,
0.0433348827,
0.0433004722,
0.0054472513,
-0.0232616365,
-0.0326211676,
0.0123081617,
0.0304483157,
0.0036838406,
0.0043126452,
-0.0041047106,
0.0047570593,
0.0502071977,
-0.002552713,
-0.0104437387,
0.0558162481,
0.0377981812,
-0.0179553665,
0.0509259924,
0.0289264135,
0.044086691,
-0.0151124392,
-0.0489899628,
-0.0263139773,
-0.026624551,
0.0203381702,
-0.023118617,
0.0368935838,
0.0882822722,
-0.0283860043,
0.0387526639,
-0.0004590125,
-0.0121516334,
0.0109799933,
0.0075400849,
-0.0853377134,
-0.0046234257,
-0.0281357188,
0.0087864362,
-0.049843926,
-0.0616896898,
0.0238169394,
0.0057628327,
-0.0044887024,
-0.0200053919,
0.0266356654,
0.0092469146,
-0.0554405749,
-0.0656579509,
-0.0355008729,
0.0150293289,
0.0295937024,
-0.0155261634,
-0.0047070272,
0.0492820181,
-0.0157504398,
0.0304523185,
-0.0552041605,
0.0429578014,
-0.0516846851,
0.0316144116,
0.0142787965,
-0.0208040867,
-0.0269347075,
0.0639298633,
0.04367828,
-0.030663047,
-0.0243359786,
0.0381471477,
-0.0003643901,
0.0732648596,
0.0375791043,
0.0178673156,
0.0153151695,
-0.0075531378,
-0.0408970118,
0.0520742983,
0.0075765522,
0.0142452754,
0.0628680512,
0.0515460745,
0.012806192,
-0.0243685972,
0.0015523569,
-0.0274133626,
-0.055800043,
-0.0602458678,
0.011349841,
0.0541616343,
-0.0224934742,
-0.0086524887,
0.0422542095,
-0.0534773432,
-0.0153172892,
0.0302569028,
-0.035368938,
-0.0074859723,
0.0117111504,
0.014323445,
-0.0343272425,
-0.0463784449,
0.0527216904,
-0.0547919683,
-0.0338572673,
0.0241027661,
0.0474778153,
0.0397835225,
-0.0386515185,
0.0023811127,
-0.0273226704,
-0.0161802657,
-0.0051313336,
0.0257126745,
0.0082915509,
0.0494677834,
-0.0398072749,
0.0498090126,
0.0015500002,
0.0653769523,
-0.0053277393,
-0.0475698374,
0.0122398911,
-0.0155786257,
-0.0252990928,
-0.0039750612,
-0.0758810192,
0.0058804965,
0.0606633425,
-0.0765238702,
-0.0262637716,
-0.0182321239,
2.733e-7,
-0.0150216995,
0.0389233679,
0.0215542037,
0.0183503963,
0.0178857036,
0.0135167772,
0.0638279915,
0.0921704173,
0.0165741201,
0.0365073681,
0.0199686401,
0.0179295857,
-0.0203871094,
0.0106599396,
-0.0560369045,
0.0557960235,
-0.0786179826,
0.0142243309,
-0.0269362591,
-0.0288282875,
0.0065805437,
0.093021892,
0.0307688359,
-0.0176774841,
0.0377136841,
-0.0158680771,
0.0943997428,
-0.043345619,
-0.0155913318,
-0.0083040725,
0.0518173091,
0.0034092069,
-0.0020755171,
-0.0294718556,
-0.0135800829,
0.0045226174,
0.0081963958,
0.0193666779,
-0.0322372578,
-0.0751823783,
0.0322854929,
-0.0047361259,
-0.0097234277,
-0.0415780693,
0.0654965714,
-0.02569299,
0.0014132364,
0.0300529338,
-0.0815538615,
0.0230748076,
0.0055589643,
-0.0406860039,
-0.0220639724,
0.0190044586,
0.0442782864,
-0.0175119713,
-0.0059069465,
-0.0489709787,
0.0056922715,
-0.0287067965,
-0.0337619781,
-0.0117041115,
-0.0739693642,
0.0139738331,
-0.0050743013,
0.0086210305,
0.0141861979,
2.46090477e-34,
0.0089769196,
0.0578596257,
-0.0224066637,
-0.024013143,
0.0011171363,
-0.0251348596,
-0.0153572438,
0.0498615019,
0.0265685413,
-0.0647981837,
-0.0647385046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17448v1 | Dialect Adaptation and Data Augmentation for Low-Resource ASR: TalTech Systems for the MADASR 2023 Challenge | 2023-10-26T14:57:08 | 2023-10-26T14:57:08 | Tanel Alumäe, Jiaming Kong, Daniil Robnikov | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper describes Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) systems
developed for the ASRU MADASR 2023 Challenge. The challenge focuses on
automatic speech recognition of dialect-rich Indian languages with limited
training audio and text data. TalTech participated in two tracks of the
challenge: Track 1 that allowed using only the provided training data and Track
3 which allowed using additional audio data. In both tracks, we relied on
wav2vec2.0 models. Our methodology diverges from the traditional procedure of
finetuning pretrained wav2vec2.0 models in two key points: firstly, through the
implementation of the aligned data augmentation technique to enhance the
linguistic diversity of the training data, and secondly, via the application of
deep prefix tuning for dialect adaptation of wav2vec2.0 models. In both tracks,
our approach yielded significant improvements over the provided baselines,
achieving the lowest word error rates across all participating teams. | [
0.0035463027,
0.0553344972,
0.018706711,
0.0276039038,
0.0026716171,
0.0105566708,
-0.0158086885,
-0.0226249527,
-0.0224276986,
0.0094037484,
-0.0352652073,
-0.054131534,
0.0324038193,
0.0298702344,
0.0172637496,
-0.0384635553,
0.0436343737,
-0.0698636249,
-0.0197801124,
-0.0067599728,
0.0145484172,
0.02598962,
-0.054010231,
0.0048677316,
-0.0176346153,
0.0403927714,
0.0053556426,
0.0239060652,
0.0316191986,
-0.0344814658,
0.0117616393,
0.0016398529,
0.0143299205,
0.0326514319,
0.0000018943,
-0.0608983487,
-0.0390438363,
0.010502046,
-0.0647829324,
0.0237289108,
0.0164090935,
0.0145384986,
-0.019177461,
0.0410744585,
-0.0046487399,
-0.0290476866,
0.0880405083,
-0.008822347,
0.0377255045,
0.0883113444,
-0.0146245873,
-0.0176975522,
0.0218485612,
-0.0063948627,
-0.0456424505,
0.0060370509,
-0.0092024691,
-0.0412740484,
0.0159731731,
0.0002584736,
-0.0076045617,
0.0171897542,
-0.0187429674,
0.0043474766,
0.002567667,
-0.023450423,
-0.0557123609,
-0.0113353413,
-0.007423447,
0.028163299,
0.0115557406,
-0.0337128937,
0.0029920524,
0.0163793415,
-0.0651935264,
-0.0407798141,
-0.0263320692,
-0.0438962206,
-0.0107415896,
0.0163804423,
0.021565944,
0.0052318145,
0.0102176089,
-0.0233741421,
0.0210661609,
0.0519352816,
0.0211155433,
-0.0340956748,
-0.0042488221,
0.0089849327,
0.0162382107,
0.0114489626,
0.0450791493,
-0.0010934583,
-0.0179457199,
0.0271363184,
-0.019331459,
-0.0573804788,
-0.0085687581,
-0.0331127048,
0.0474377722,
0.0557673201,
-0.0518256351,
0.0048816563,
-0.0142437629,
0.011429036,
0.0215983428,
0.0053608525,
-0.0190849043,
-0.0314896591,
-0.0057271826,
-0.0013522815,
-0.0422672071,
-0.0085123628,
-0.0456865989,
0.0252472926,
-0.015054184,
0.0072995559,
0.0102133201,
-0.0210608523,
0.0659898221,
-0.0332499407,
-0.0873183683,
-0.0513807572,
0.0237876046,
0.0545665808,
-0.001675024,
0.0562135689,
-0.0176449269,
-0.105767943,
-0.0067538712,
0.0217109732,
0.0218434464,
-0.0210817978,
-0.0028245323,
0.0196921322,
-0.0108652785,
-0.0347449258,
-0.0740738735,
0.0577362552,
-0.0301699117,
-0.0285007209,
-0.0260793958,
-0.0476831831,
0.0262815058,
0.0022905809,
0.0139349857,
-0.0169388242,
-0.0153130842,
-0.0499953926,
0.013470388,
0.0635134652,
-0.0652348027,
-0.0017353089,
0.054791145,
0.0082400637,
0.0535195582,
0.0674486309,
0.0263845772,
-0.0174964312,
0.000006186,
-0.0430620424,
-0.0418380797,
0.0593711212,
-0.0011362811,
0.0169657674,
-0.0582204908,
0.0173089132,
0.0081170201,
0.015698472,
0.0401705913,
0.0432447158,
0.000083661,
0.0035245582,
0.0311864968,
0.0284771379,
0.0651838034,
0.0013737797,
0.011982074,
-0.0056442129,
0.0186803322,
-0.0306644253,
0.0176462345,
-0.0264426172,
-0.0073847049,
0.0181444827,
0.0230953023,
0.0614436418,
-0.0036068815,
-0.0012572425,
-0.0358330607,
-0.0001916092,
-0.0266462192,
0.0171448067,
0.0480969995,
-0.0012840913,
-0.0200849976,
0.0162124131,
0.0634490475,
-0.0226192102,
0.0487212166,
-0.0420410819,
-0.0178203564,
0.0076481509,
0.0067716823,
-0.0336418711,
-0.032510139,
-0.0185498912,
0.0053065973,
0.0194897614,
0.0611926243,
0.0014207747,
0.0371555686,
-0.087407507,
0.0059960447,
0.0350007787,
-0.0162143726,
0.04210696,
-0.033884801,
0.0176617485,
-0.0094658481,
-0.0060826945,
0.0178707466,
-0.0023483397,
-0.0233337227,
-0.0059883469,
0.0269045085,
0.0296560768,
0.0718773827,
0.0633787513,
-0.0187611263,
-0.0384424962,
0.0358667858,
-0.0103564858,
0.0763838366,
0.0315308794,
0.0033167924,
-0.0457040854,
0.0510238856,
-0.0201214496,
0.0461331718,
0.0400246829,
0.0270383488,
-0.0963499919,
0.0344385728,
-0.0415995829,
0.0610213913,
-0.0218464918,
0.0581141822,
0.0013509853,
0.0383825451,
0.0061158114,
-0.0095133772,
0.0222258642,
-0.0305525027,
0.0034300522,
0.004696561,
0.0242233165,
-0.073294118,
-0.00595862,
0.0218387824,
0.0054691038,
0.0130411666,
-0.0009846452,
-0.0357687809,
-0.0412137248,
-0.0058184946,
-0.1159073636,
0.0018787249,
-0.0337707549,
0.0378150754,
-0.0316712558,
0.0613368601,
-0.0129300337,
-0.0439263955,
-0.0254466813,
-0.0161529258,
0.011592309,
-0.0007195851,
-0.0332713276,
0.0037691714,
-0.0124362027,
-0.0194717776,
-0.0231369976,
-0.0029617515,
-0.0131846443,
-0.0238025784,
-0.0382515155,
-0.0503966808,
-0.0446797907,
0.0094968304,
0.0245600566,
-0.0077142986,
-0.0275774915,
-0.0444225036,
-0.0223231111,
0.0235382076,
0.0199031606,
-0.0047747861,
0.0031280406,
-0.0142081445,
0.0021632453,
-0.0222656969,
0.0030793766,
0.0281488076,
0.0035526596,
-0.0358671285,
0.0197054651,
-0.0453211516,
0.0396301858,
-0.0260339715,
0.0202417858,
-0.0490058549,
-0.0304978322,
-0.015879225,
-0.0010377696,
0.0203963723,
0.0109925959,
-0.0518601537,
0.0330716185,
-0.0378045626,
-0.0240356885,
0.0393744111,
-0.0893948004,
-0.0380183496,
-0.1085165143,
-0.046669066,
-0.0337341204,
-0.0246868432,
-0.0278265588,
0.006419227,
-0.0228842646,
-0.0316811092,
-0.0249429569,
-0.0050130342,
-0.0253122747,
-0.0362172499,
0.0237465538,
-0.0060372078,
0.0299838576,
-0.0240254272,
-0.022885846,
0.0091710193,
-0.0036886695,
-0.033420153,
0.0241956804,
0.0508190021,
-0.0210755542,
0.0273720101,
0.0536661409,
-0.0094624003,
0.0533833057,
-0.0080626262,
0.0306626093,
-0.0189032797,
0.0245882943,
0.0938297063,
0.0728385001,
-0.0125011541,
0.0029870623,
0.0035496149,
-0.0885008126,
0.0647216812,
-0.020306183,
-0.0369699411,
0.0186991151,
0.0510208942,
-0.0061352504,
0.0101543227,
-0.0034908019,
0.0576518141,
0.0044129058,
-0.0067122662,
0.0372759029,
-0.0011185193,
0.0015198897,
-0.0217701383,
-0.0300276987,
0.0471422561,
0.0088699711,
0.0044405251,
-0.063253969,
-0.0076872427,
0.0564776547,
0.0511888228,
0.0214095525,
0.0311068501,
-0.0369813405,
-0.0940804705,
-0.0011568853,
0.0249267779,
-0.0299025904,
0.0054560956,
-0.0390736833,
-0.0069721704,
-0.0489807725,
0.065995343,
0.0166172441,
-0.0310809016,
-0.0407333933,
0.072235696,
-0.0259100478,
-0.0699313283,
-0.0390954167,
-0.029654365,
0.0968646109,
0.0235168021,
-0.052633062,
-0.032213375,
-0.0366056114,
0.0107109454,
-0.0094626611,
0.0012783228,
-0.0090183467,
0.0010920755,
0.0055501638,
-0.0278347451,
0.0241039246,
0.0255440064,
-0.0049173119,
0.0326260105,
-0.0147917457,
0.0664103702,
-0.0004980305,
0.0388856716,
0.0186570045,
-0.0130692739,
0.0119970087,
0.0003040277,
0.0163772311,
-0.0233195852,
0.0316111967,
0.0106264437,
0.0451666526,
-0.0354715176,
0.0005773189,
0.0293862987,
-0.0175115112,
-0.0606248155,
0.011636964,
-0.0308455676,
0.0244081002,
0.0486956872,
0.0329575017,
0.0607464537,
-0.033067707,
0.0187682826,
-0.0551723614,
0.0302615296,
-0.032070525,
0.0375869162,
-0.0718865693,
-0.0401823558,
0.0314369537,
-0.0472251251,
-0.009805141,
-0.0277026631,
-0.0402763411,
-0.0601315536,
0.0433558114,
0.0299610365,
0.0215881169,
0.0713276938,
-0.0237648357,
-0.0740731061,
0.0152131272,
-0.0097984085,
0.0040912377,
0.0199307315,
0.0454155467,
-0.0237907227,
-0.026085116,
0.0074494192,
-0.0417915061,
0.0138243698,
-0.0186993219,
0.0127909463,
-0.0009676964,
-0.0454810895,
0.0086551383,
0.0209159199,
0.0511257201,
-0.0384566672,
-0.0407483801,
-0.0410655327,
0.0348529592,
0.0339080282,
0.0563257709,
-0.0120237414,
-0.0053224512,
0.0281176474,
0.034333311,
-0.00719593,
0.0253214259,
-0.0229783319,
0.0010608752,
0.0055784616,
0.0990644991,
0.027572291,
0.0715814084,
0.0510273762,
0.0197643619,
-0.0124835325,
0.0484608486,
0.022817092,
0.0204954948,
-0.0083232922,
0.0057569663,
-0.0139252795,
0.0176375136,
0.0247269683,
0.0481098033,
0.0305189677,
0.0105025098,
-0.0356254615,
0.0525648184,
0.0422060341,
-0.0126467012,
0.0638169721,
0.0073667066,
0.0149700539,
-0.0440945253,
-0.0022787713,
-0.0502059497,
0.0404871106,
0.0262420755,
-0.0036575682,
-0.0309761781,
0.0641509593,
0.0082204742,
0.0119874422,
0.0361093655,
0.0012707657,
0.0514962673,
-0.0258287415,
-0.0345874205,
0.0307397731,
0.0279083867,
-0.0175351873,
0.0045530912,
-0.0045808516,
-0.0889531076,
0.0066495142,
-0.0096152555,
0.0025491712,
-0.0153362453,
-0.0044742371,
-0.0135701848,
-0.0279158391,
0.0173474066,
0.004934045,
-0.0415166654,
-0.0010410941,
-0.0365094356,
0.0530036092,
-6.652041716e-33,
-0.0145704867,
0.0877266377,
-0.0210720561,
-0.0350925289,
-0.033541508,
-0.0063866777,
-0.0093085635,
-0.0000846925,
-0.0353283137,
-0.0233226307,
-0.0416063331,
-0.0126716485,
0.0357928872,
0.0232548937,
-0.0071206754,
0.0078975474,
0.0706243888,
0.0233504623,
0.0048318733,
-0.0337085016,
0.0181098264,
0.0430186167,
0.0597461015,
-0.0490004048,
-0.0309552215,
-0.0034477646,
0.0210117493,
0.0080964239,
0.032800559,
0.0637741014,
-0.0014264776,
0.0514931083,
0.0021696149,
-0.0248718038,
-0.0150565244,
-0.0055837119,
-0.1020671725,
0.0151565289,
0.0128472736,
0.0972340181,
0.0208011158,
-0.0209980328,
0.0434755497,
0.0141048245,
-0.0526016392,
0.0182672534,
-0.0048742127,
-0.0342430472,
-0.0122521799,
-0.0199258886,
-0.0282408334,
0.0555409081,
0.0005172052,
-0.0210623704,
0.0596273988,
-0.0016691586,
0.0035648698,
-0.0595704392,
-0.0496189259,
-0.0013625917,
0.0637564883,
0.0717215464,
0.0632638335,
0.0451284312,
-0.0564827956,
-0.018838862,
0.0501354747,
-0.0786373988,
0.065954268,
-0.0101033542,
0.0341844447,
-0.0209307447,
-0.0320066325,
0.0140102012,
0.0619266033,
-0.0804349855,
-0.0151481163,
-0.0063835718,
0.0504041612,
-0.0017169161,
-0.0351859033,
0.0216911677,
-0.061413005,
-0.0015515069,
0.0044909851,
-0.0130087314,
-0.0387259349,
-0.0494140871,
0.0701864734,
-0.0269633923,
-0.0076833982,
0.0766982958,
0.0578506328,
-0.0252462216,
0.0230864417,
0.0013893323,
0.0067922194,
-0.0176763963,
-0.0373179391,
0.0509836972,
-0.0422659628,
-0.0527637191,
0.0306640957,
0.0471235141,
0.0088890269,
-0.037256673,
0.0206978675,
0.0338651873,
-0.0571085885,
0.0015669515,
0.0148471743,
0.0276867598,
-0.0018326544,
0.0726427361,
0.0300764181,
-0.0100723971,
0.0147866094,
0.0469682105,
0.0129540078,
0.0010615856,
0.0071265288,
-0.0133884754,
0.0153187886,
0.0109950043,
-0.0021015301,
0.0320609584,
0.0051223445,
-0.0453965031,
-0.018129861,
-0.0123606287,
0.0210456382,
0.020020308,
2.808e-7,
-0.0352522843,
0.0353118554,
0.0556081831,
-0.1031272188,
-0.0405706614,
-0.0280329194,
-0.046489276,
-0.0069606821,
-0.0310487933,
0.0146317938,
0.0045439703,
-0.0013696019,
0.0704040825,
0.0049445471,
-0.0752130449,
-0.0370235145,
-0.079979986,
0.0457633808,
-0.0465239547,
0.0103086345,
0.0167790409,
0.1155024394,
-0.0030285427,
-0.0431056209,
0.0065612989,
0.0100915711,
-0.0094489614,
0.0244289842,
0.002495952,
0.0331507102,
0.0011584626,
-0.0205008499,
-0.0575063452,
-0.0188206136,
-0.0379272141,
0.0726889744,
-0.0013195785,
0.0435534306,
-0.0452816151,
-0.0311787706,
0.0285400264,
0.0558275767,
-0.0433593653,
-0.007095953,
0.0421700366,
0.0529079214,
-0.0370219313,
-0.0281259008,
-0.0476338901,
0.0094340937,
-0.0259311236,
-0.0142880995,
0.010302824,
-0.0208029691,
0.0303718988,
-0.0392739326,
-0.0514729433,
-0.0523852967,
0.0234043114,
0.0350568406,
-0.0200442001,
-0.0474099815,
-0.0013875116,
0.016154753,
0.0185941681,
-0.0006502788,
0.0288747195,
2.25659972e-34,
0.0477139987,
-0.0162783228,
0.0220597498,
-0.0079909135,
0.0015708766,
-0.0597121231,
0.0249168202,
0.0469288379,
-0.0087597808,
-0.0753197297,
-0.0410587043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17428v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17428v1 | ''Fifty Shades of Bias'': Normative Ratings of Gender Bias in GPT Generated English Text | 2023-10-26T14:34:06 | 2023-10-26T14:34:06 | Rishav Hada, Agrima Seth, Harshita Diddee, Kalika Bali | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language serves as a powerful tool for the manifestation of societal belief
systems. In doing so, it also perpetuates the prevalent biases in our society.
Gender bias is one of the most pervasive biases in our society and is seen in
online and offline discourses. With LLMs increasingly gaining human-like
fluency in text generation, gaining a nuanced understanding of the biases these
systems can generate is imperative. Prior work often treats gender bias as a
binary classification task. However, acknowledging that bias must be perceived
at a relative scale; we investigate the generation and consequent receptivity
of manual annotators to bias of varying degrees. Specifically, we create the
first dataset of GPT-generated English text with normative ratings of gender
bias. Ratings were obtained using Best--Worst Scaling -- an efficient
comparative annotation framework. Next, we systematically analyze the variation
of themes of gender biases in the observed ranking and show that
identity-attack is most closely related to gender bias. Finally, we show the
performance of existing automated models trained on related concepts on our
dataset. | [
0.0483406112,
0.0262842905,
-0.0123793008,
0.0141080841,
-0.0085961092,
0.0400412157,
0.0348543599,
-0.0136194602,
0.0351667926,
-0.1131159887,
-0.0003358173,
-0.0260151569,
0.0148365069,
-0.0278028343,
0.0363686047,
-0.0119796749,
0.0013424092,
0.059271019,
0.0487476736,
-0.0348373726,
0.0603487529,
0.0533831045,
0.0060832757,
0.0497134142,
-0.0145272948,
-0.0237524416,
0.0591807328,
0.0153717864,
0.0472859666,
-0.0243401099,
0.0521008894,
0.0661053136,
-0.0103564253,
0.0405510962,
0.0000017369,
-0.0701481551,
0.0148909437,
0.0116733918,
0.0331354253,
0.0004443036,
0.0272753816,
0.0054395534,
-0.0293889996,
0.0252398215,
-0.0318248309,
0.0049084788,
0.0213441662,
0.0363044702,
0.0645822957,
0.043710012,
-0.003921235,
-0.0035001761,
-0.0377386436,
0.0009171881,
-0.0055796127,
0.0160816852,
0.028228635,
-0.013222063,
-0.0630704537,
0.0360276513,
0.0090317857,
-0.0182594825,
-0.0176179558,
-0.0215236153,
-0.0010689095,
0.0248371195,
-0.0382736921,
-0.0464533493,
0.0196997393,
0.058434844,
0.035461314,
-0.0082405629,
0.0327338949,
-0.0269556809,
0.0221485458,
0.012962508,
-0.0241538901,
0.0629399568,
-0.0253639221,
0.0077624461,
0.01910403,
-0.034564022,
0.0210422613,
0.0763783082,
0.002970573,
0.0761858299,
0.0030527562,
-0.0350274816,
0.0335764065,
0.0133346645,
-0.0298520215,
-0.0577134192,
-0.0103332112,
-0.0137463193,
0.0236134976,
-0.0141634084,
-0.0179059859,
-0.0094913496,
0.0493414439,
-0.0611432344,
0.0092459405,
0.0184321385,
-0.0005444534,
-0.0135447541,
-0.0109309927,
0.0249914583,
0.0077679437,
0.0182296392,
0.0004589951,
0.0088476241,
-0.0258192793,
-0.0192447454,
0.0054618986,
0.0033231943,
0.0169766787,
0.0360934623,
-0.0624638349,
-0.0211313572,
-0.0547612458,
0.004177562,
0.0105417268,
0.0294752605,
-0.009810783,
0.0108905286,
-0.0106114475,
0.0038809099,
-0.0576620139,
0.0333864391,
-0.0395643301,
-0.0838990286,
0.0079492806,
0.0448108502,
-0.0189901199,
-0.032963708,
-0.0091080461,
0.0023258815,
0.0120143322,
-0.0145652406,
-0.037396457,
-0.048227977,
-0.0272813719,
-0.0485051908,
-0.0237869602,
-0.056301184,
-0.017353734,
0.0345196687,
0.005312054,
-0.0144461701,
0.0148613779,
0.0512221865,
-0.0093316082,
0.0378355868,
0.0527062044,
-0.0287126247,
0.0949628279,
0.0266568419,
-0.0160408095,
0.07114999,
0.0575788766,
0.0156116644,
0.0265896413,
0.0270625781,
-0.0028430461,
0.0317846499,
0.0217436552,
0.0381950587,
-0.0207390916,
0.0180605259,
-0.0441310741,
0.0225281361,
0.0541753992,
0.0229484048,
0.0059965472,
-0.0192879327,
0.0578467771,
0.0471054353,
-0.0108741298,
0.0583195202,
0.0392895862,
0.0209615473,
-0.0061008311,
0.0510900877,
-0.0558655858,
-0.0035338022,
-0.0269238781,
-0.0496511124,
-0.0001850174,
0.0248876493,
0.0111879744,
-0.0395208746,
-0.0365726128,
0.0090341028,
0.0028589938,
-0.0291033275,
-0.0062791863,
0.0316900574,
-0.0082314508,
0.0403645635,
0.0076490161,
-0.0595895313,
0.0103976699,
-0.0563206077,
0.0230417177,
0.0323215798,
0.0043454207,
-0.0272052009,
0.0031004513,
-0.0520060584,
0.0024089676,
0.0426738784,
0.0277712941,
-0.0213560127,
-0.0468290672,
-0.0431043841,
-0.013163398,
0.009010464,
0.0403712392,
0.0414968021,
0.03606309,
0.0171185769,
0.04599474,
-0.0171983689,
-0.0758663341,
0.0400265492,
0.0319139771,
-0.0436733365,
0.0175145529,
0.01355555,
0.0340566598,
0.0287280139,
-0.0356955044,
-0.0034305388,
-0.0030956969,
-0.0055807722,
-0.0155608198,
0.0088124108,
-0.0187715087,
0.0119598042,
-0.0077191135,
-0.084236145,
-0.0581484847,
0.0356034786,
-0.0356813893,
-0.0048878901,
0.0035790333,
-0.0248210318,
-0.0345103033,
-0.0531017222,
-0.0375030711,
0.011538011,
0.0066687786,
-0.0540179685,
0.0435345732,
-0.0288673975,
0.0088331224,
0.0362524651,
-0.0431063771,
0.0201298185,
-0.0533011965,
-0.0388340466,
-0.0117821274,
0.0319863521,
0.009190755,
0.0536652878,
-0.0217855684,
-0.0217789598,
-0.0387162194,
-0.0846118182,
-0.0257605277,
-0.0218494423,
0.00983069,
0.0315782093,
-0.027730234,
-0.0193698406,
0.0106740296,
-0.0566081293,
-0.0294328034,
0.0048115361,
0.0443956107,
0.071619913,
-0.0218226723,
0.0542555004,
-0.0315327607,
-0.0002036623,
-0.0526948087,
0.0451502316,
0.068986699,
-0.0093080858,
-0.0590530448,
-0.0000365618,
-0.0367914587,
-0.0369010605,
-0.0000442695,
-0.042899128,
0.0327482037,
0.0407131426,
0.0186882876,
0.0607018545,
0.0638336912,
0.0358410031,
0.0551491939,
0.0143337138,
-0.047193367,
-0.0380085818,
0.0150022004,
0.0323568694,
0.0221558455,
-0.0848913863,
0.0057913442,
0.0193404183,
0.0252320319,
-0.0321646519,
-0.0560295954,
0.0606385544,
-0.0512956269,
-0.0355906747,
-0.0137161529,
-0.03342361,
-0.0064225649,
0.0286512282,
-0.0079682115,
-0.0507547669,
0.0347140767,
0.0094688181,
0.0336969569,
-0.0191750769,
0.0009174218,
-0.0468093008,
0.0191520937,
0.0042343237,
0.0450648516,
0.0128369043,
-0.0246526022,
-0.0813797265,
-0.0300027281,
0.0610192716,
-0.0228413492,
0.0116802081,
-0.0362704732,
0.0220007617,
0.0056554354,
-0.030203145,
-0.0402412824,
-0.0411977731,
0.0049304976,
-0.0306622498,
0.0120754112,
-0.0062170071,
0.0208072197,
0.0168707855,
-0.02860168,
0.0070787785,
-0.0285396483,
-0.0137070827,
0.0157029983,
0.0164217483,
0.0256647374,
-0.0091689806,
0.0327820852,
0.0025888795,
-0.0379725657,
0.043797493,
-0.0251448713,
0.0350050703,
0.0022926098,
-0.000332221,
0.0240965951,
-0.0842267275,
-0.0373202898,
-0.0192444511,
0.0102773299,
-0.0510847531,
0.0141026368,
0.1074928716,
0.0236226413,
-0.0715205073,
-0.0102941738,
0.0024705266,
0.0457980894,
0.0300716422,
-0.0250114854,
-0.1030353978,
0.0216271896,
0.0034400739,
0.0340817906,
-0.0807651803,
-0.0576926768,
-0.0250262767,
-0.1038481966,
0.0032492541,
0.0216099899,
-0.0167574361,
0.0122362943,
-0.0147528052,
-0.0095763886,
-0.0364712961,
0.0179380067,
-0.001519603,
0.0102022421,
0.0432158634,
0.0133044189,
-0.0503554046,
-0.0295345951,
0.0128902616,
-0.0255364645,
0.044411961,
0.0255025681,
0.0758108348,
-0.019939106,
0.0007702757,
0.072930187,
-0.020580532,
-0.0051387153,
-0.0400392003,
0.0241603442,
-0.0502694361,
-0.0033235094,
-0.0515744947,
0.0578300282,
0.0557333939,
0.0073663187,
0.004308769,
0.0152526684,
0.0277430061,
-0.0077399332,
-0.0522903427,
0.0066734599,
0.0300185494,
0.0765064508,
0.0149841467,
-0.0230402891,
-0.0355930515,
-0.0719648823,
0.0345166028,
0.0259887706,
-0.0867966861,
-0.0064879828,
0.0181486458,
-0.0134056937,
-0.0650972798,
-0.0838516355,
0.0053398302,
-0.0186496247,
0.0220817421,
-0.0753001943,
-0.0041201641,
0.0078749387,
-0.0483805798,
-0.0026748474,
-0.0074405693,
-0.0125340736,
0.0096579753,
-0.0330015756,
0.016878562,
-0.0305192824,
-0.0265851431,
0.0262222234,
-0.0279020518,
-0.052076485,
0.0317736454,
0.0364847034,
0.0246021505,
0.0431117453,
0.015674971,
-0.0459133834,
0.0569275618,
0.0578501783,
-0.0202720445,
0.0212701503,
0.0270436909,
0.0458653048,
0.0039808969,
0.0397758484,
-0.0349091031,
0.0313720666,
-0.0358684398,
-0.0042707007,
-0.0292103663,
-0.0304198079,
0.0210998282,
0.0234224945,
0.0018642826,
-0.0701781809,
0.0242203921,
-0.0683962405,
-0.0045771096,
-0.0247240495,
-0.053461384,
0.0018010398,
0.0028039392,
0.0198391173,
0.0100383982,
-0.0613415912,
-0.0121055357,
-0.0496822223,
0.0434668511,
-0.0386442579,
0.0187931526,
0.0233642906,
0.0560099557,
-0.0227192603,
-0.0383872278,
-0.0170403402,
0.0048131468,
-0.023886133,
0.0400834903,
0.033148393,
0.0400528572,
0.0104770912,
0.0210998803,
0.0265200268,
0.0059935376,
-0.0357508771,
0.0132018216,
-0.0427066907,
-0.0080216955,
0.0047157197,
-0.0299827363,
0.0822829381,
0.0049072588,
-0.0198530797,
0.0112458318,
0.0145538701,
0.0129830195,
0.0093531543,
0.0157147441,
-0.0015479156,
-0.0156887751,
0.0022035432,
0.0434035584,
0.0474358276,
0.052362036,
0.0190645475,
-0.0677303299,
-0.0326667801,
-0.0440575667,
-0.0101492731,
-0.0179494135,
0.0265281592,
-0.0160795748,
-0.0862034336,
-0.0176651441,
-0.0030720427,
-0.0225214269,
0.0436986648,
-0.0263574198,
-0.0081098313,
0.0649831519,
-0.0265544746,
-0.019748671,
-0.0390823632,
-0.0083396453,
-0.0070896246,
-0.0149852065,
-0.0302171484,
-5.731846371e-33,
-0.0402030051,
-0.0730090439,
-0.0401572846,
0.0224333499,
-0.0198902357,
-0.001433125,
0.0129059637,
-0.0123248128,
0.0212569591,
0.0559798665,
0.0225346275,
0.0393976346,
0.0066604409,
0.0054712631,
0.021176463,
-0.0273702554,
0.0390979648,
0.0036779044,
-0.0568856969,
-0.0044218586,
0.0105746863,
0.0018579776,
0.0386034958,
-0.0690129772,
0.1231058761,
-0.025013946,
-0.043947693,
-0.0156933647,
-0.0399372131,
0.0128877144,
-0.0023423654,
0.0798763037,
0.0359086506,
-0.0120574702,
0.0326141678,
0.0717795044,
-0.024506852,
-0.0460495502,
0.0145784747,
0.0079348022,
0.0400220938,
-0.0264588408,
0.0313398279,
0.0051369402,
-0.0500386134,
-0.0246059727,
0.0809939876,
0.0045859916,
0.0694136545,
-0.0192758758,
-0.0571377128,
0.0388122909,
-0.0373125486,
0.0367170237,
0.0002275575,
0.0315321311,
0.0057611549,
0.0189459138,
-0.082965441,
0.0414200686,
0.0060318504,
0.0220228974,
0.0121095097,
-0.023504734,
0.0033581501,
0.047906667,
0.0413542874,
0.0380945019,
-0.0482578985,
-0.0360393114,
-0.0143411085,
-0.0423403494,
0.0250165481,
0.0899637863,
0.025915416,
0.0116687817,
-0.0793831795,
-0.0041102641,
0.0419785902,
0.0088690044,
0.0281332936,
-0.0557240248,
-0.064676255,
-0.0433468297,
-0.0325226672,
-0.0942447335,
-0.0269816555,
-0.0127689615,
0.0265527833,
-0.0162959266,
-0.0630559474,
0.0001882996,
-0.0424221791,
-0.0267025586,
-0.05803404,
0.009737025,
-0.0493263602,
-0.0407366082,
0.0241300743,
0.0116496021,
-0.036360994,
0.0173689593,
0.0130657675,
0.0309837274,
0.0413866974,
0.0054857726,
0.0137867117,
0.0145051349,
-0.0775087997,
-0.0227424614,
-0.0027361335,
0.011886294,
-0.0301948488,
0.0224940646,
0.0165199451,
0.0074399002,
-0.002677076,
-0.0010427051,
0.0520194508,
0.0396881662,
-0.0221690498,
-0.0124472231,
-0.0038445017,
0.0261830967,
-0.0273395274,
-0.0061284923,
0.0493511297,
0.0328188799,
0.018191414,
-0.0368586518,
-0.0012254373,
-0.0433882624,
2.405e-7,
0.0181610305,
0.0802157149,
0.0037402427,
0.0116691561,
0.0209730361,
0.0271260347,
0.0458326563,
0.0623437874,
0.0612618104,
-0.0391811021,
-0.0016765661,
-0.0000715518,
-0.0250646509,
0.0426623523,
-0.064858824,
0.0138922557,
-0.0645708144,
0.0291252453,
-0.0062928204,
-0.003895897,
0.0449029431,
0.0283624697,
0.0257668309,
-0.0019996534,
-0.0431236736,
0.0056226938,
0.063985087,
-0.006668455,
0.0142884701,
0.0207285713,
0.06305556,
-0.0003021966,
0.0207540113,
0.0265988633,
0.0055502816,
-0.0074478323,
0.0144178132,
0.0200494044,
0.0075034415,
0.0079474179,
0.0047275103,
-0.0013131836,
0.0268034358,
-0.0777721703,
0.056685593,
-0.0047235708,
-0.0281114858,
-0.0443668365,
-0.0500430912,
-0.0314041935,
0.0870593041,
-0.0358798541,
-0.0300643425,
0.0206782427,
0.0115163391,
0.0281549208,
0.0065764752,
-0.0554094948,
-0.0353406183,
-0.0276197903,
-0.0158812627,
-0.0626571402,
-0.0059607993,
0.0440589935,
-0.0035230294,
-0.0354588591,
0.0266419556,
1.90502543e-34,
0.0086844144,
-0.0012942414,
0.0178115405,
-0.002455509,
0.0150221707,
0.0457522012,
0.0063099866,
-0.0047001769,
0.0461670384,
0.0008975344,
-0.0076125613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17415v1 | PETA: Evaluating the Impact of Protein Transfer Learning with Sub-word Tokenization on Downstream Applications | 2023-10-26T14:20:44 | 2023-10-26T14:20:44 | Yang Tan, Mingchen Li, Pan Tan, Ziyi Zhou, Huiqun Yu, Guisheng Fan, Liang Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.BM | Large protein language models are adept at capturing the underlying
evolutionary information in primary structures, offering significant practical
value for protein engineering. Compared to natural language models, protein
amino acid sequences have a smaller data volume and a limited combinatorial
space. Choosing an appropriate vocabulary size to optimize the pre-trained
model is a pivotal issue. Moreover, despite the wealth of benchmarks and
studies in the natural language community, there remains a lack of a
comprehensive benchmark for systematically evaluating protein language model
quality. Given these challenges, PETA trained language models with 14 different
vocabulary sizes under three tokenization methods. It conducted thousands of
tests on 33 diverse downstream datasets to assess the models' transfer learning
capabilities, incorporating two classification heads and three random seeds to
mitigate potential biases. Extensive experiments indicate that vocabulary sizes
between 50 and 200 optimize the model, whereas sizes exceeding 800
detrimentally affect the model's representational performance. Our code, model
weights and datasets are available at
https://github.com/ginnm/ProteinPretraining. | [
0.0269057155,
0.0962658748,
0.014092681,
0.0016220289,
-0.0279263109,
-0.003444263,
0.0150609408,
0.0169713628,
-0.0172852594,
-0.0407033712,
-0.0007701673,
-0.0525693782,
0.0035770938,
0.068952404,
0.0112743545,
-0.0014426431,
0.0390789472,
0.0010981722,
0.004660063,
0.0231050607,
-0.0245006718,
-0.0137215741,
0.0393827781,
0.0121279042,
0.0209909137,
0.0312309004,
-0.0007989033,
-0.018839879,
0.0108651752,
-0.0244280975,
-0.021026073,
0.0252914634,
0.007436777,
0.0488218814,
0.0000017906,
-0.0439677499,
-0.0317296647,
0.0171783566,
-0.0054538273,
0.0538700707,
0.0333763473,
-0.0053675398,
0.0077021872,
-0.0060309744,
0.0264615584,
0.0093715824,
0.0881770477,
0.0533655658,
0.013584923,
0.0388922319,
-0.0100722564,
-0.0597226433,
0.0692458153,
-0.0310675502,
0.0236289781,
-0.0286498331,
0.0735849813,
0.0124201737,
-0.0088534374,
-0.0121345865,
-0.0106068561,
0.014595069,
-0.0255909916,
-0.0098781483,
0.0155414632,
0.0002026998,
-0.0309927259,
-0.0436356105,
0.0028928493,
0.0722373053,
-0.0451842099,
-0.0353878774,
-0.0612092875,
-0.0210540146,
-0.0122983055,
0.0062476322,
-0.0055289371,
-0.0098844972,
0.003330695,
0.0743979141,
0.0200133137,
-0.0161210485,
0.0397865921,
-0.0284302589,
-0.0528636351,
0.0185235236,
0.0238494817,
-0.0115814395,
0.0078585967,
-0.0242631864,
-0.0502547696,
-0.0149840154,
0.0318303071,
-0.0171247888,
0.0476846881,
-0.0020505723,
-0.0059834546,
-0.0547703654,
0.0321936868,
-0.0233949069,
0.0167910885,
0.0314738043,
-0.019853469,
0.0017750114,
-0.0655191615,
0.0074048676,
0.0220457837,
0.0353446566,
-0.0359498896,
0.0020667,
-0.0960802808,
0.0311446562,
-0.0209519751,
0.0382168144,
-0.0170322601,
-0.010574488,
-0.0479659252,
-0.0112821236,
0.0235251393,
-0.0692613274,
0.0188164394,
-0.0054819235,
-0.010046469,
0.038125854,
-0.022233028,
0.0472317711,
0.0446077138,
0.0038363168,
-0.0028959003,
-0.0724730939,
-0.0322324447,
-0.0305133648,
0.0234489739,
-0.0321099795,
0.0124576958,
0.0978920236,
-0.0314020179,
-0.072035864,
-0.0205887537,
0.0298546869,
-0.0358024128,
0.0033923469,
-0.0401227064,
-0.0137787061,
0.0532249846,
0.004419914,
0.0087672444,
-0.0332395956,
0.0289592948,
-0.0302836597,
-0.0755551085,
0.0871187598,
-0.0574364737,
-0.012761429,
0.0015206051,
-0.0059537655,
-0.0257064272,
-0.0043702414,
0.0338671058,
0.0274615809,
-0.0072164978,
-0.0433136486,
-0.0338507369,
-0.0080779698,
0.0110467514,
-0.0137357907,
-0.0355361998,
0.0040334808,
0.0753123909,
0.0283611026,
0.0151157519,
0.0077792048,
0.0092371218,
-0.0037708771,
0.036250595,
0.0941450968,
0.0167515986,
0.0086982334,
0.0313438326,
0.0509582236,
-0.0088228062,
-0.0523662195,
0.0100099677,
-0.0240352377,
-0.0392422676,
0.0198213644,
0.0426679775,
-0.0038070581,
0.0217304379,
-0.0089232,
-0.036155872,
0.0143451281,
0.0216956418,
-0.0609415546,
0.0335474126,
0.0187259279,
-0.0463844575,
0.0613586307,
0.085733898,
-0.05865895,
0.0055543375,
-0.0429450125,
0.0406452566,
0.0530046523,
0.0201141592,
-0.0343695953,
-0.0032102361,
0.0198763851,
-0.0025577531,
0.0301158819,
0.0444681086,
-0.0001936231,
0.0362912938,
0.0048273774,
-0.0233714692,
0.0021311562,
0.0330229513,
0.0028771998,
-0.0438142717,
0.0081626372,
0.0222563781,
-0.0548122153,
-0.0764458999,
0.0493646115,
-0.0220940411,
-0.0354686603,
0.0169127248,
-0.0032249619,
0.0626196563,
-0.0024846203,
-0.0091365948,
0.0243448671,
0.0414084271,
-0.0209804922,
0.0011758532,
-0.0399084613,
-0.0017432062,
-0.0240520164,
0.0645202473,
0.0339306071,
0.0215396304,
-0.0114497952,
-0.031066278,
-0.0230574068,
0.0526486672,
-0.0191912241,
0.0791054666,
-0.0076702903,
0.0461964197,
-0.0269930791,
0.0591045283,
-0.0336496793,
0.0208232794,
0.0191991646,
0.0000941404,
-0.0420622379,
-0.0533745587,
0.0535574816,
-0.0243560672,
0.0370236784,
0.0218178146,
-0.0236131009,
0.0050854711,
0.0163091403,
0.0181351788,
-0.0208859406,
0.0081700878,
-0.0126623064,
-0.0006481473,
0.0229472481,
0.074753046,
-0.0108816968,
-0.0114522129,
-0.0004906706,
0.0183121283,
-0.0476548448,
0.0152601535,
-0.0872573182,
-0.0138369165,
0.0321618542,
0.0083367927,
-0.0307095479,
-0.0606379099,
-0.0188633539,
-0.0451193042,
0.1171908453,
0.008811513,
-0.0481518023,
-0.0115956655,
-0.007743448,
-0.0040912996,
0.0177289322,
0.0167698152,
-0.0219768696,
-0.013723732,
-0.0003615278,
-0.0264978986,
-0.0341363102,
0.0216638055,
0.0022632268,
0.0650835186,
0.0265239589,
-0.0163878016,
-0.0196781158,
-0.0243541989,
0.0024280013,
-0.0087227644,
-0.0487756133,
0.0149482526,
0.0739178136,
-0.0118654892,
-0.0109374532,
-0.061346516,
0.0068269763,
0.0202337094,
-0.0210140608,
-0.0102578262,
0.0070244805,
-0.0087120095,
0.0217583869,
-0.0042189667,
-0.0245779622,
0.0416968651,
-0.0362199023,
0.0374567099,
-0.056872461,
0.0112310061,
-0.0406755432,
0.0356453098,
0.0185733493,
0.0451413803,
0.036350809,
-0.0005935766,
0.0447570235,
0.015454988,
-0.0265509225,
-0.0127414418,
-0.0120801311,
-0.0293636825,
0.0177325718,
0.0006675643,
-0.0027895183,
0.0137150101,
0.0465333462,
-0.0374452397,
0.0510395579,
0.0603010878,
-0.0281880908,
-0.056000594,
0.0744606629,
-0.0101076616,
0.0310134068,
0.0070750657,
0.0036250113,
-0.011043488,
-0.002954368,
0.0158926025,
-0.0215096641,
0.0224547368,
-0.0038251914,
0.0339199938,
0.0213367902,
-0.0007231347,
0.0110490154,
-0.0362528637,
0.0274406951,
0.0233555548,
-0.039120324,
0.0083721289,
0.0131373918,
0.0237603579,
-0.0116487434,
-0.0258542653,
0.0562456325,
0.0240104534,
-0.0595223121,
0.0284260735,
0.0012056074,
-0.0088835321,
-0.0297529027,
0.0403721109,
-0.0740905479,
-0.0741451085,
-0.0010073333,
0.0394853577,
0.0138436025,
-0.0471827239,
-0.018876601,
-0.0658790991,
0.0333546773,
0.0225699786,
-0.110150151,
-0.0232210383,
-0.082957536,
-0.0225995742,
-0.0467683226,
0.0407641307,
0.031724114,
-0.0393874757,
0.0096795354,
0.0384783894,
-0.0099815708,
-0.0626432747,
0.0280606207,
-0.0370113589,
0.0084366417,
0.055123426,
0.019379124,
0.0096224975,
-0.0338753313,
0.0548472032,
-0.0288950112,
0.0194465555,
-0.0032947694,
0.0560683757,
-0.0056224042,
-0.0321806744,
0.0140016219,
-0.0052227639,
-0.065012075,
-0.048243124,
-0.0103870789,
0.0932488814,
0.0476889983,
-0.0492365807,
-0.0500083044,
-0.0406526402,
-0.0367371291,
0.0482439436,
0.0516748726,
-0.0370912142,
-0.0561601371,
0.0017653276,
-0.0321281403,
-0.0431582965,
0.0189293679,
-0.0276430994,
-0.0496349186,
-0.0450247601,
-0.0766616091,
0.0318632387,
0.0505440906,
0.018249074,
0.0247138087,
0.0154346162,
-0.0189448502,
-0.035858158,
-0.0556246452,
0.032445129,
0.0011287299,
-0.0166136883,
-0.0849436373,
-0.0412289351,
0.061171677,
-0.0217383578,
-0.0474969596,
0.024073733,
-0.0393898673,
-0.0670089275,
-0.0189889148,
0.0491404943,
0.0131058702,
0.0160317589,
0.0155518549,
-0.0194444451,
0.0396831371,
0.0697240978,
0.0036478639,
-0.0476886258,
0.0118578803,
-0.0243540313,
-0.0290078428,
0.0038164719,
-0.0067022596,
0.012785431,
0.0332685225,
0.032462962,
0.0584255494,
-0.0392630622,
0.0346590579,
0.0306411628,
0.0492562316,
0.0095145153,
-0.0543447956,
-0.0316822305,
0.0182759967,
0.0046538836,
0.0221907664,
-0.0411296561,
0.0069565577,
0.0534981601,
-0.0091182506,
-0.001167029,
-0.0398842841,
-0.0174218919,
0.0290782508,
0.027519526,
0.015308287,
0.0241151527,
0.0183450095,
0.0444312319,
-0.0396327302,
0.0061089615,
-0.040551994,
-0.0218545627,
0.0159898773,
-0.0285610128,
-0.0440583825,
-0.0051656682,
0.0454156436,
-0.0476280265,
0.0338003188,
-0.0286849756,
-0.0078130215,
-0.0660988465,
-0.0225671865,
-0.0009757013,
-0.0362953246,
0.0537102334,
0.0249079317,
-0.0262392834,
-0.0282566696,
0.0482375845,
-0.0500350222,
-0.0076732165,
0.0466983393,
0.006232054,
-0.061465051,
-0.0281166583,
0.0744115338,
0.0643513203,
0.0514935255,
-0.0089397896,
-0.0354521051,
0.0022603213,
0.0157823879,
-0.0062371287,
0.0278531015,
-0.0375345908,
-0.0148090068,
-0.0254238825,
-0.0294379126,
-0.0148244696,
-0.0231941752,
0.017321147,
0.0649803728,
-0.0117991772,
0.0608589575,
0.0368264318,
-0.049641069,
-0.0137836626,
0.0024248613,
0.0205166414,
-0.0104109831,
0.0221466459,
-5.944428647e-33,
0.0066024479,
-0.0041707293,
-0.0309118237,
0.0127523746,
-0.008657096,
-0.0032857179,
-0.0507317036,
-0.0197331812,
0.0267171878,
0.0272755623,
0.0060096495,
-0.0411122367,
0.0012737322,
-0.0367140248,
0.0236087479,
0.0048288382,
0.032530874,
0.0348328575,
-0.0005063012,
0.0044296756,
0.035849236,
0.0560936965,
0.0673939437,
0.0039721946,
-0.0245606098,
0.0751345903,
0.0169019345,
-0.0491391569,
0.0086139208,
0.0022142406,
-0.0288904607,
0.0232859589,
-0.0185765382,
-0.0010416929,
-0.0392464511,
-0.0296546724,
-0.0368323661,
0.0097853215,
0.0215886105,
-0.0075535807,
0.0000244413,
-0.0301344581,
0.035486754,
-0.0063317893,
-0.0279470719,
0.013405934,
0.0365219004,
-0.0633655712,
-0.0708345547,
0.0111722266,
-0.0883826464,
0.0301298462,
0.0161058269,
0.0395947322,
0.044346232,
-0.010919068,
0.0271289553,
0.006921316,
0.0046827262,
0.0201984607,
0.0504668467,
0.0078743016,
0.0773447007,
0.0156718288,
0.0077410019,
0.0438156649,
0.0391737632,
-0.0222002324,
0.0588356853,
-0.0045363093,
0.0237583537,
0.0622535795,
0.0449541546,
-0.0392019078,
0.0496735051,
-0.0503780916,
-0.0726592019,
0.0275428519,
-0.0233838037,
-0.0124557307,
-0.0087056272,
0.0541350059,
-0.0054591736,
-0.021385977,
-0.0381820016,
-0.0334891006,
-0.0118190227,
-0.0414933637,
0.014444625,
-0.0489138439,
-0.0563149676,
0.0173535049,
0.0083553763,
-0.0273229685,
-0.0678514168,
0.0168843027,
-0.0461777225,
-0.0077161742,
-0.0210905336,
0.0042224233,
-0.0580836944,
-0.0733970329,
0.021479886,
-0.0294883624,
0.0317130983,
-0.0513008423,
0.0351417102,
0.0143599231,
-0.0282648373,
0.0092561543,
-0.0603120439,
-0.0176006854,
0.0222480521,
0.1138936281,
0.0156505927,
0.0282865521,
-0.0031022069,
0.0239757486,
0.0223538075,
-0.0053180386,
0.0239253417,
0.0700866133,
0.0092428159,
0.026174115,
-0.0677454323,
-0.008608887,
-0.0221128166,
0.0402808823,
0.0238747802,
-0.0343336724,
-0.0553770289,
0.0256697107,
2.611e-7,
0.0877735168,
0.0697903559,
0.0249916241,
-0.0364113599,
-0.0368575044,
0.0352716856,
-0.0430713706,
0.0258304849,
-0.023262037,
0.0215856135,
-0.002228176,
-0.0245302618,
0.0209860466,
0.0071981181,
-0.0293886457,
-0.0275415182,
-0.042338904,
0.0000116832,
-0.0391118117,
-0.0008666337,
0.0093312664,
0.084154956,
0.005796656,
-0.0162522774,
0.0471729524,
-0.049161125,
0.0183104277,
-0.0560826324,
0.0361854509,
0.0584365651,
-0.0304180253,
0.0268457793,
-0.0022239105,
-0.0039744182,
-0.0401164107,
-0.0166914072,
0.0132926824,
0.0124358153,
-0.0446613505,
-0.0063014287,
0.0531985983,
0.0203092713,
0.0410774648,
-0.0540708043,
0.0415685475,
-0.0419477262,
-0.0411675386,
-0.0265294723,
-0.0485540815,
0.0084261708,
0.0162884369,
-0.0051941867,
0.0580443032,
0.0287634041,
0.005085486,
0.0218542814,
-0.0667299628,
-0.0292711891,
-0.0282804985,
-0.0255387053,
-0.0178346485,
0.0134033635,
-0.0648483634,
0.0388229601,
0.031207351,
-0.0379943587,
0.0033219666,
2.352218149e-34,
0.0577121079,
-0.0262568519,
0.0087140063,
0.0294064265,
0.007007116,
-0.0102287745,
0.0413550772,
0.0416387506,
-0.0592910945,
-0.0516722314,
0.0113568893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17413v1 | Harnessing GPT-3.5-turbo for Rhetorical Role Prediction in Legal Cases | 2023-10-26T14:19:48 | 2023-10-26T14:19:48 | Anas Belfathi, Nicolas Hernandez, Laura Monceaux | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a comprehensive study of one-stage elicitation techniques for
querying a large pre-trained generative transformer (GPT-3.5-turbo) in the
rhetorical role prediction task of legal cases. This task is known as requiring
textual context to be addressed. Our study explores strategies such as zero-few
shots, task specification with definitions and clarification of annotation
ambiguities, textual context and reasoning with general prompts and specific
questions. We show that the number of examples, the definition of labels, the
presentation of the (labelled) textual context and specific questions about
this context have a positive influence on the performance of the model. Given
non-equivalent test set configurations, we observed that prompting with a few
labelled examples from direct context can lead the model to a better
performance than a supervised fined-tuned multi-class classifier based on the
BERT encoder (weighted F1 score of = 72%). But there is still a gap to reach
the performance of the best systems = 86%) in the LegalEval 2023 task which, on
the other hand, require dedicated resources, architectures and training. | [
0.0609841719,
0.0419603735,
-0.0084901722,
0.0290514398,
-0.0354472511,
0.0224040579,
0.0154612232,
0.0149983102,
-0.0541917123,
-0.0761034489,
0.0087403227,
-0.0377152301,
-0.052030392,
-0.0250777081,
0.0043189912,
-0.0579831861,
0.0198118985,
0.0137442518,
0.0755263492,
-0.0067514321,
0.0282193106,
0.0336117782,
0.0117593389,
0.0431651771,
-0.070029214,
-0.0254675485,
-0.0058660619,
0.0267583895,
0.0197911076,
0.0115671335,
0.0121759949,
0.0889960974,
0.0431394726,
0.0280497745,
0.0000018538,
-0.0502953008,
0.0073879925,
-0.0061708214,
-0.0120730102,
-0.0267769229,
0.0488600433,
0.0171623249,
-0.0122063803,
0.0279549062,
-0.0557099804,
0.0071544754,
0.0124976626,
0.0521524064,
0.0345921218,
0.1068016812,
-0.0152531294,
-0.0479392149,
0.0332911424,
-0.0340016596,
0.0311891735,
-0.0619521514,
0.008984779,
-0.0049358299,
0.0047706184,
0.0085310917,
-0.0026052231,
0.0091391169,
0.0613327473,
-0.0241319258,
-0.0467496738,
0.0259715691,
-0.0470461473,
0.0192922205,
-0.0157570317,
0.0148203727,
0.0729627684,
-0.0074699661,
-0.0224710461,
-0.0051958156,
0.0493069179,
0.0086151054,
-0.0052937367,
0.0676160455,
0.0052852267,
0.0015736943,
0.0340475887,
0.0396799073,
-0.035201624,
0.0023635498,
-0.0151103213,
0.0392993279,
0.0151631003,
-0.0409196019,
0.0142744211,
0.0401429683,
-0.0391590968,
-0.0426446572,
0.0080648465,
0.0290084332,
-0.0278083701,
0.0550510734,
-0.0324289165,
-0.0446245484,
0.0281375516,
-0.0380505212,
0.0011752315,
0.0207978226,
-0.023765495,
0.0447835438,
-0.0083858222,
0.027768027,
0.0067435554,
0.029996518,
-0.0039108256,
-0.0431586951,
-0.06078979,
-0.0501872227,
-0.0824743807,
0.0417194441,
-0.0694811568,
-0.0020071995,
-0.0160033628,
-0.00949506,
0.0052393791,
-0.0041669388,
0.0296931323,
0.0204076357,
-0.0562525131,
-0.010441523,
-0.0439562388,
-0.0120626921,
-0.0443918705,
0.009162168,
0.0216887482,
-0.0385269113,
-0.0082458258,
0.0023271283,
0.014955868,
-0.0307134334,
0.0005551799,
0.0519360676,
-0.0320125222,
-0.0305648297,
0.0019702872,
-0.0360014178,
-0.0508729145,
-0.0700608641,
-0.0392108932,
-0.017260693,
-0.0007273689,
-0.001022272,
0.010913997,
-0.022649698,
0.0125199333,
0.0480905958,
0.0261206906,
0.0705496371,
0.0653334409,
-0.0382826477,
0.001614878,
0.0278447084,
0.0337060243,
0.0622106791,
0.022557199,
0.0079976507,
0.0178083573,
0.0067078588,
0.0248557534,
0.0359016508,
-0.0080097131,
-0.0037358582,
0.0554983951,
0.016269559,
-0.0096424734,
0.028268978,
0.0112050856,
0.041948922,
-0.0088698631,
-0.0129594095,
0.0223005079,
0.045780044,
0.026660217,
0.0276859812,
0.0548072197,
0.0146282092,
0.0070203361,
-0.0003994829,
-0.0486350209,
0.0155717311,
-0.0170398876,
-0.0178037174,
-0.0811204165,
-0.0028076242,
-0.0268419906,
-0.0520922206,
0.0247099139,
0.0080479113,
-0.033921469,
-0.0027046518,
0.0225611832,
0.0504994653,
-0.0852325782,
0.0308461338,
0.0171594229,
-0.0962021202,
-0.0256913379,
-0.0235251598,
-0.0187740736,
-0.0059999991,
0.0401660986,
-0.0425872989,
-0.0382844172,
-0.0375754908,
-0.0208186004,
0.056900356,
0.0151491612,
0.0032283266,
-0.0093808435,
-0.0282680392,
-0.034986224,
-0.0210616905,
0.0296427347,
0.0315583125,
0.0173227564,
0.0087449485,
0.0507702827,
-0.05075505,
0.0279252697,
0.0388341397,
0.0108893337,
-0.0628561005,
0.0192242581,
0.0064844377,
0.0483249724,
0.030470334,
-0.0030910801,
-0.0298384316,
0.0086399326,
-0.0207869634,
-0.0159973465,
0.0252860226,
-0.0797207281,
-0.0430303439,
0.0141425543,
-0.0296948962,
-0.0500191711,
0.0009627432,
-0.0442546569,
-0.0398826264,
-0.0284154601,
-0.0386987403,
0.0145989899,
-0.088439934,
-0.0417355672,
-0.0054100989,
-0.0278298426,
-0.0253478847,
0.0679340288,
0.0588594265,
-0.0352928303,
0.0107699772,
0.044262249,
0.0432325229,
-0.024069868,
-0.0195485931,
-0.0224932767,
-0.0006134966,
-0.0150822299,
0.0469159931,
0.0081197973,
-0.0334457979,
-0.0482897907,
-0.119198285,
0.0009002328,
-0.0539011136,
0.0065011727,
0.0199745037,
-0.0198250748,
-0.0011328924,
0.0020555241,
-0.0534948483,
-0.0275755022,
-0.0182118528,
-0.029670909,
0.0187786743,
-0.0090744337,
-0.0040252469,
0.0149321286,
0.0207492691,
-0.0442116372,
0.0493456051,
0.0505049825,
0.0002925245,
0.0118789775,
0.0517994054,
0.0251390748,
-0.0076456005,
-0.0268729888,
-0.0042403778,
0.0126515245,
0.0185246114,
0.0429293588,
0.0254042018,
0.0498939678,
0.0334948115,
-0.0345875956,
-0.0029742634,
-0.0533528216,
0.0286932718,
0.0021374123,
-0.0298025906,
-0.0580702908,
0.0118725579,
0.0204453692,
0.0471262373,
0.0208418146,
-0.0082708169,
-0.0558444411,
0.020170927,
-0.0140676638,
-0.0170432851,
0.0133276926,
0.0014288636,
-0.0330836177,
0.0223164037,
-0.0058003869,
0.0034115769,
0.0800993592,
-0.0013693674,
-0.0118208304,
-0.0507651456,
0.0266794786,
-0.0261800438,
0.0985194966,
0.0316426009,
0.0186333861,
0.014788378,
-0.0622891821,
-0.0348566547,
-0.0220556501,
0.0539109409,
-0.033481963,
0.0395567678,
-0.0023300529,
0.0430006087,
-0.0427962169,
-0.0732798353,
-0.0438523293,
-0.0372488312,
-0.0043067979,
0.0462197736,
0.0079903351,
0.0051759961,
-0.0094995573,
-0.0276276134,
-0.0290062968,
0.0299203638,
-0.0031930483,
-0.0223357901,
-0.0407187119,
0.0439631194,
-0.0012488753,
0.002201776,
-0.0328744203,
-0.0226130839,
0.0119757615,
0.0183711629,
-0.0342415385,
0.005874766,
-0.015142248,
-0.0124654761,
-0.0021457367,
-0.0693999082,
-0.0030996238,
0.0175096896,
0.0450949371,
-0.0668722168,
-0.001729317,
0.1100235432,
0.0268116184,
-0.0225294493,
-0.0273578018,
0.0250641108,
0.0089179939,
0.0253359508,
0.0369768851,
-0.1317680776,
-0.0122964811,
-0.0078275725,
-0.0054316605,
-0.0511071198,
-0.0134068076,
-0.0061857724,
-0.1453469396,
0.0995260105,
-0.0324005112,
-0.0029254307,
0.0195319839,
0.0045761201,
-0.0105764559,
0.0012956,
0.0333226211,
0.0012809142,
-0.0035374509,
0.0078437328,
0.0134426551,
-0.0105718272,
0.0172275845,
0.0235393159,
-0.0184784178,
0.0300010554,
0.0361338407,
0.0468659252,
-0.0148076117,
-0.0070328792,
-0.0040595173,
-0.0211477336,
0.0141670443,
0.0078788232,
0.0702782273,
-0.0171782803,
0.005796086,
-0.0402543135,
0.0316587389,
0.0060273213,
-0.0330378823,
0.0320511982,
0.0494449213,
-0.0277053304,
-0.0133529892,
-0.0093579423,
0.0113455476,
0.00878736,
0.0624329187,
0.0283406656,
-0.0152083402,
-0.0523741171,
-0.0390470587,
0.0362431929,
-0.1158197224,
-0.0429918282,
-0.0179964434,
0.0225363895,
0.0200556833,
-0.021249732,
-0.0203973316,
0.0128196385,
0.063732937,
0.0122069772,
0.0136618009,
0.0080365418,
0.0141491396,
-0.0539229512,
-0.010577335,
-0.0370146818,
-0.0129875485,
-0.0001663272,
-0.0175593682,
0.0549984276,
0.0098251272,
-0.0379759111,
0.0141103109,
0.0093348511,
-0.014889013,
0.0044941194,
0.017822044,
0.0136404,
0.0308977216,
-0.0291917305,
-0.0295487717,
0.0913599581,
0.0468964353,
-0.021860823,
0.0185278729,
0.0420636162,
-0.0171994418,
-0.0313353427,
0.0124050993,
0.0070030019,
0.0474442057,
0.0221436843,
-0.0024618376,
-0.0299550258,
0.0220800564,
0.0347334594,
0.0245448649,
0.0572051704,
-0.0048813899,
-0.0023492258,
-0.045705162,
0.0049972115,
-0.0545866378,
-0.0299256854,
-0.0450662114,
-0.0010477541,
0.0107275359,
-0.0202006847,
-0.0326967835,
0.0312592164,
-0.0485580862,
0.0298169311,
-0.0384121612,
0.0229145326,
0.0607980862,
0.0062268497,
-0.0104300044,
-0.0208984092,
0.0112353433,
0.0033126564,
0.0332084894,
0.0586671233,
-0.005438277,
0.0506814569,
0.0255928673,
0.0147231957,
0.0240737759,
0.0014170209,
-0.0559088252,
0.0104219904,
-0.0224208087,
0.0319532454,
0.0188772082,
-0.0100287693,
0.0045362236,
-0.0226881877,
0.0010797158,
0.0434341691,
0.0350150317,
0.018447537,
-0.0355544016,
0.0434381664,
0.0057426081,
-0.0094140107,
0.0111054126,
0.0227776933,
-0.0236595385,
0.0336358324,
0.0135655068,
-0.0144522544,
-0.0377223566,
-0.0461530015,
-0.0210416205,
-0.0096144918,
0.013726037,
-0.0030284466,
-0.0564606339,
-0.0154593419,
-0.0290695503,
0.0056189965,
-0.0117900297,
0.0125785014,
0.0326870419,
0.0486000329,
-0.0163714401,
-0.0671921596,
-0.0380023718,
0.0012404454,
-0.0210807417,
-0.0107996296,
0.0007744643,
-6.007289309e-33,
-0.0782127604,
-0.0351390764,
0.013543074,
0.0525086038,
-0.0399666019,
0.0056586247,
-0.0230522342,
-0.0155094434,
0.0128160613,
0.0524937287,
-0.0249205884,
0.0266867969,
0.0199112706,
0.033852227,
-0.0088482667,
-0.0157954209,
0.0358657241,
0.0079122521,
-0.0321518071,
0.0501582213,
0.0183848944,
0.0251069665,
0.043279618,
-0.0894728601,
0.023403341,
0.0108916126,
-0.0366569422,
-0.0077994619,
-0.050985042,
0.0214027185,
0.0181652382,
0.0609979033,
0.0042978339,
-0.0762650594,
0.0086497916,
0.0780027434,
-0.0886768922,
-0.0201454852,
0.0281623863,
0.0014744275,
-0.0058483081,
-0.045375485,
0.0116642788,
-0.0184354112,
-0.0088051306,
-0.0113003384,
0.0545993857,
0.0049967109,
0.024659263,
-0.0774433464,
-0.0896385536,
0.0197422765,
-0.0151268393,
0.0172986258,
0.0051104291,
0.0424709804,
0.0247628056,
0.0276222657,
-0.0399197862,
-0.0172069576,
-0.0302459728,
0.0038683193,
-0.0115568163,
-0.0009566668,
-0.0203895532,
0.0458960831,
-0.004577151,
0.0079836948,
-0.0589074083,
-0.011390131,
0.0050020227,
0.0632719919,
0.0360163972,
0.0689424723,
0.0314637199,
-0.008901434,
-0.0847644061,
-0.0087947901,
0.0343810096,
-0.0034223557,
0.0226107333,
-0.0565089695,
-0.0202514585,
-0.0423773602,
-0.0451158173,
-0.0480871499,
0.0000706494,
-0.0114322752,
0.0222754031,
-0.0088344859,
0.0237639546,
0.0135076866,
0.0020932436,
-0.050233908,
0.0332388803,
0.009023861,
-0.0360478535,
0.0142749725,
-0.0357551649,
0.046384789,
-0.0164460558,
-0.0263231546,
0.0516487844,
0.0247729272,
0.0130884079,
-0.0283254068,
0.0605671145,
-0.006838134,
-0.0690740496,
-0.0126891751,
-0.0072748722,
0.054876443,
-0.0226286948,
0.0361933857,
-0.0197077692,
0.0510137603,
0.0126982564,
0.0028058619,
0.0055011865,
0.0020169774,
-0.043630477,
-0.0216440167,
-0.0021889219,
-0.0189024284,
-0.0202533286,
0.0057164757,
0.0353786685,
0.0377280042,
0.0475624874,
-0.0214000586,
0.0078007793,
0.0381689407,
2.643e-7,
0.1099418253,
0.0352307409,
0.0177878942,
-0.0183539912,
-0.0151112592,
0.034013737,
0.0232652407,
0.0407126844,
0.0461189933,
-0.0212597717,
0.0385170691,
0.0181791801,
0.0401963256,
0.0509448349,
-0.1052774861,
-0.0357447639,
-0.0475414097,
-0.0157672223,
-0.0554937012,
0.0542660058,
0.0795743242,
0.0660796165,
0.011868461,
-0.0274696182,
0.0038767122,
-0.023047464,
0.0675244406,
-0.0126615362,
-0.0153925372,
0.0227694772,
0.0310777109,
-0.02173982,
0.0215153452,
0.0593824349,
-0.0042095683,
0.0592757165,
-0.0518563241,
0.052861359,
-0.0096598454,
-0.0290560164,
-0.0257094316,
0.0112754498,
0.0056620087,
-0.0243517049,
0.058277145,
-0.0798801035,
-0.0237155575,
0.0109507861,
-0.0484044105,
-0.0230657794,
0.0114134401,
0.0519901924,
-0.0153640183,
-0.0069328733,
0.0344304368,
-0.0180943236,
-0.0006158644,
-0.107682839,
0.0119725447,
0.0342117883,
-0.0369324312,
0.0034803788,
-0.0035181921,
-0.0256667249,
0.0295006223,
-0.0582780614,
0.0265876707,
2.259829344e-34,
0.0366718397,
0.0147792557,
0.0137772746,
0.0151022319,
0.0442723446,
0.044457797,
0.0225476176,
-0.0124149378,
-0.0004718277,
-0.063786976,
-0.0040935203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17408v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17408v2 | Tackling the Matrix Multiplication Micro-kernel Generation with Exo | 2023-10-26T14:09:57 | 2023-10-27T08:28:03 | Adrián Castelló, Julian Bellavita, Grace Dinh, Yuka Ikarashi, Héctor Martínez | cs.MS | cs.MS, cs.CL, cs.PF | The optimization of the matrix multiplication (or GEMM) has been a need
during the last decades. This operation is considered the flagship of current
linear algebra libraries such as BLIS, OpenBLAS, or Intel OneAPI because of its
widespread use in a large variety of scientific applications. The GEMM is
usually implemented following the GotoBLAS philosophy, which tiles the GEMM
operands and uses a series of nested loops for performance improvement. These
approaches extract the maximum computational power of the architectures through
small pieces of hardware-oriented, high-performance code called micro-kernel.
However, this approach forces developers to generate, with a non-negligible
effort, a dedicated micro-kernel for each new hardware.
In this work, we present a step-by-step procedure for generating
micro-kernels with the Exo compiler that performs close to (or even better
than) manually developed microkernels written with intrinsic functions or
assembly language. Our solution also improves the portability of the generated
code, since a hardware target is fully specified by a concise library-based
description of its instructions. | [
0.0334093794,
-0.0419367589,
-0.0551834777,
0.0837216228,
-0.0126237916,
0.0300624799,
0.058767397,
-0.0072909966,
0.0107815797,
0.0094435588,
-0.0075254696,
0.0567903072,
0.0136030987,
0.0345966518,
-0.0149760293,
0.0014196237,
0.0182854906,
0.0174423475,
-0.0827753469,
-0.0205069147,
0.0191816762,
0.0084594535,
-0.0170250665,
-0.0153294373,
-0.0057134554,
-0.0261767749,
0.0175548475,
0.0383104496,
0.0291108601,
0.0833641887,
0.0067605078,
-0.0551961921,
-0.0410633869,
0.0228441637,
0.0000021545,
0.0223446563,
0.0275702551,
0.0384473987,
0.0336442143,
0.0625183135,
0.0441032983,
0.040235851,
0.0095471544,
0.0081455698,
0.0361889303,
-0.0234670527,
0.0410080664,
-0.0237814356,
-0.0025267156,
-0.0032556164,
-0.005405962,
0.0118692275,
0.0089671705,
0.0221602507,
0.0223381128,
0.0129910177,
0.005697669,
0.0050369636,
0.0274067223,
0.0060076681,
0.013165446,
0.0491328128,
-0.0071059647,
-0.0167551041,
0.0487289801,
0.0251290184,
-0.0065837698,
0.0149485394,
-0.0577403978,
0.0247692913,
-0.0543935597,
-0.0352092907,
0.0041069742,
0.018964,
-0.0107969586,
-0.0240632445,
0.0112450961,
-0.0109205367,
-0.0063241026,
-0.041648075,
-0.0077581401,
-0.0550680906,
0.0115798134,
-0.001243887,
0.0130222235,
0.1089444757,
0.068685025,
0.0166808218,
-0.0444165803,
-0.0207875315,
0.0212826431,
0.0135573111,
0.0117277224,
-0.0369984545,
0.0141443387,
0.002935173,
-0.0619482659,
0.0277486444,
0.0074499953,
-0.0858395174,
0.0565641075,
0.0246199071,
0.0615802333,
-0.0165499896,
-0.0485764369,
-0.0307831038,
-0.0665623844,
-0.0082272571,
-0.0067804935,
0.0311971325,
0.0226568636,
0.0216722135,
-0.0194512401,
0.0165779069,
-0.0452049933,
0.0314177983,
-0.0814660117,
0.0334420428,
-0.0090968888,
-0.0136584016,
-0.0964839682,
0.0007666454,
0.0602990612,
-0.0644903779,
0.0026567432,
-0.0328288339,
-0.0240761191,
0.0085958065,
-0.0712521449,
0.0032943725,
-0.0142238764,
0.036883492,
-0.0395256318,
-0.0201776475,
0.0145026147,
-0.0128536457,
0.0429647937,
-0.0503883399,
-0.006156703,
0.0002407002,
-0.033866372,
-0.0176799614,
-0.0050527952,
-0.0073487847,
0.0321507417,
0.00488966,
0.0120520368,
0.0574216507,
0.0262532346,
0.0052577364,
-0.0278835054,
0.0323762894,
0.0126396175,
-0.0214447603,
0.0096228486,
-0.020597348,
0.0346469618,
0.0338952877,
-0.0098492652,
0.0151958261,
-0.0214573015,
0.0066566761,
-0.0097531304,
0.0004984228,
0.0158336442,
-0.0017279283,
0.0156575404,
0.0378519967,
-0.0046622306,
0.0353764705,
-0.0350115299,
0.0298605766,
-0.0051357993,
0.0053765974,
-0.0190779194,
0.0202612691,
-0.0402527377,
0.061726097,
0.0654132366,
-0.0153242797,
0.0182370022,
-0.0426073,
0.0282563064,
0.036121089,
0.0148557462,
-0.0724050477,
0.0284015872,
0.0776976421,
0.0119584203,
0.0455068648,
0.0348236598,
0.0144899283,
-0.0666043684,
0.0261960253,
0.0079949005,
-0.0355356634,
-0.0561683364,
0.0185018443,
0.0104243103,
-0.0737139061,
-0.0695756078,
-0.0614928864,
0.0171682369,
-0.0240124036,
0.0359316356,
0.0219606329,
0.0049240631,
0.0088397702,
-0.0384849086,
-0.0487991273,
0.0063926475,
-0.0060188961,
-0.008046004,
-0.0020220613,
0.0226135068,
-0.0046964218,
-0.0281254034,
0.0488982238,
0.0315960012,
-0.0166506674,
0.0025360913,
-0.0052308491,
-0.0155289797,
-0.0388487354,
0.028254969,
-0.0150702083,
0.069533132,
0.0043937112,
-0.0105518484,
0.0184731185,
0.0135005014,
-0.0229689963,
0.0360756367,
-0.013447105,
0.0143350502,
-0.0840221345,
-0.0035532841,
0.0159169976,
0.0295371711,
-0.0251489598,
-0.0119489552,
-0.0062743095,
-0.0037937763,
-0.0123166367,
0.0627761781,
0.01304028,
0.0109007144,
-0.0371948816,
-0.0002510087,
-0.0179748069,
0.0050984891,
0.0100669432,
0.0235426575,
0.0226412509,
0.022589663,
0.0016749853,
-0.0026056648,
0.0203361399,
0.049578812,
-0.0508812517,
-0.0566791445,
0.0020968805,
0.0249293707,
-0.0230605993,
-0.0428884663,
0.0315810442,
-0.0208883025,
-0.0387143977,
0.0484236181,
-0.0191133097,
-0.0160573591,
0.0537231639,
0.0514928848,
0.0597959012,
0.0078176744,
0.0435113646,
0.1017322913,
-0.0606162697,
-0.0632612482,
-0.0599915124,
0.0006591213,
-0.0782229155,
0.0042864149,
-0.0534623824,
-0.0148326503,
0.0278556254,
-0.0396501124,
0.1082042903,
-0.0305973068,
-0.0243510883,
0.0227785408,
0.026331678,
-0.0351310447,
-0.0076645408,
-0.0326568857,
-0.0250228047,
0.0538645908,
0.0178944729,
-0.0510095693,
0.0452938937,
0.0202652439,
0.0105199749,
0.008688597,
0.0608860664,
-0.0145987924,
-0.0169807989,
0.0310378969,
0.0328975879,
0.0067155473,
-0.0143168811,
0.0177293476,
-0.0492902771,
-0.0003460773,
-0.0312412307,
0.0342604145,
-0.0323245563,
-0.0308847241,
-0.0118807256,
-0.0420542844,
-0.0364687145,
-0.0092171878,
0.0031068074,
0.0012828916,
0.0053051538,
-0.0411098786,
-0.0510515682,
-0.0154619189,
-0.018219376,
-0.0525154993,
0.0028960013,
0.0212903973,
-0.0754790753,
0.0441079699,
0.0798213407,
0.0482883304,
-0.0062696673,
-0.0425493531,
0.0371349342,
0.0433723256,
0.003424091,
0.0410323702,
-0.010094109,
0.0065674935,
0.0365916677,
0.0155560551,
-0.0292854514,
0.0377170779,
-0.0519217029,
-0.0104208151,
0.0120423408,
0.0594779886,
-0.0089817224,
-0.0142656239,
-0.046711497,
0.0108918799,
-0.0184661634,
-0.0032722508,
-0.0583628081,
-0.0338288136,
0.03822878,
0.0215074811,
-0.0147592248,
0.0575027131,
0.002110977,
-0.0695958585,
-0.0152009353,
0.054141812,
0.0263499804,
-0.0448844545,
0.0297555365,
0.006957877,
-0.0158880781,
-0.0397950895,
-0.0530681908,
0.0410210006,
-0.0349923447,
-0.0216427576,
0.0120504675,
0.046166487,
0.0489149988,
0.053255301,
-0.0526906662,
0.0021596099,
0.0000482643,
0.0022136697,
-0.0080460878,
0.0100614317,
-0.0046408675,
-0.0501584187,
0.0446305797,
0.0257088356,
-0.035147395,
-0.0171603803,
-0.0343443416,
-0.0039926306,
0.0396780111,
-0.0453314446,
0.0337148905,
-0.0493218638,
0.0349870212,
-0.0447267815,
-0.00932125,
0.0280118864,
0.0172182862,
0.041386012,
-0.0068627666,
0.017128123,
-0.0008509067,
-0.0094808219,
-0.0778657645,
0.0428212434,
-0.0334209055,
-0.0209239759,
-0.0654472932,
0.0237992126,
-0.0192694515,
-0.040865913,
-0.0749348551,
0.0042967903,
0.0147484625,
0.0541449711,
-0.008466688,
0.0711756945,
-0.0122429216,
0.0195404552,
-0.0206816271,
-0.0257783551,
0.0123356599,
0.0104962094,
-0.0434776209,
-0.005585908,
-0.0316743851,
-0.0343643203,
-0.0654067621,
-0.072036393,
-0.0260385424,
-0.0053650122,
-0.0212984178,
0.044231236,
0.0626690686,
0.0631744117,
0.0254767463,
0.0139299203,
-0.0028493998,
-0.0920910388,
-0.0279538706,
-0.0647288561,
-0.0928183794,
-0.0530103706,
-0.0055233631,
0.0359957367,
0.0357332714,
0.010867957,
0.0262448136,
0.0492051505,
0.0286482684,
0.0642127097,
-0.0428761579,
-0.0301244818,
-0.0083175199,
0.0884576589,
0.0040682792,
-0.0224697348,
0.0464427732,
0.028283136,
0.0398504473,
0.0116604976,
0.0158844441,
0.0401012562,
-0.0338314921,
-0.0647421405,
-0.0035504289,
-0.0113663469,
-0.0022238092,
-0.0216609277,
0.0945813805,
-0.0284186825,
0.0157493539,
-0.0143346433,
-0.0488392822,
-0.0325616859,
0.0044992622,
-0.0036098249,
-0.0205889307,
0.0136825871,
0.0165707301,
-0.021103261,
0.0480953828,
-0.0510140136,
-0.037786223,
0.003982441,
0.0114988228,
-0.0228272695,
0.0343197808,
0.0405423157,
0.0203776117,
-0.0011582392,
-0.0292171091,
-0.0201760344,
0.0096042221,
0.0393967852,
0.0439998321,
-0.0216330327,
0.0165756252,
0.0511898287,
0.0379209481,
-0.0261453595,
-0.0051856977,
0.0020515989,
0.0105036506,
-0.0264708735,
-0.0254711825,
-0.0150139686,
-0.0462608561,
-0.025730513,
0.0011402951,
0.0190511625,
0.0113384193,
0.0485713482,
-0.0143822366,
-0.0013052223,
-0.0665791035,
0.0236641765,
-0.0799931735,
0.020339882,
-0.0108899018,
0.0030168653,
0.0021467123,
-0.0081954775,
0.0061386833,
-0.0394330285,
0.0028769183,
-0.0249473769,
0.0131724635,
-0.0382253341,
0.0162835214,
-0.0002069356,
0.0187609028,
0.0178074799,
-0.0089546097,
-0.0258195028,
-0.0131947258,
-0.0141869346,
0.0138286576,
0.0187175944,
-0.0185747072,
0.0239901505,
0.0173026491,
0.0658425763,
-0.0382142775,
0.0175906047,
-0.0161470827,
-0.020079704,
-0.0451174453,
0.0551946163,
-5.370048312e-33,
-0.0092930375,
0.0030753114,
-0.003933995,
0.0889545083,
0.008946497,
0.0166500937,
0.0033365132,
0.0284632631,
-0.0074155997,
-0.0114622433,
0.0075714425,
-0.0180029981,
0.0079787271,
-0.0371786766,
0.0125386976,
0.0954452008,
0.0403597727,
0.0095820548,
0.0050409134,
0.0441260189,
-0.011514172,
0.0436619259,
-0.0743895844,
-0.0247591268,
-0.00678067,
-0.0016969764,
0.026223246,
-0.0169126876,
-0.0390285552,
-0.035106685,
-0.0602824613,
0.0108492086,
-0.0352845117,
0.030276088,
0.0144500192,
-0.0011499752,
-0.0910936669,
0.0304382462,
0.0564815365,
0.0148417456,
-0.0591459274,
-0.0364575088,
-0.0141540971,
0.0890829563,
-0.0528502613,
-0.0279832575,
-0.0143068442,
0.0433336049,
0.0047980691,
-0.0080923066,
-0.0416896082,
0.0016966377,
0.0265879631,
0.0581198633,
0.0770664811,
-0.086791046,
-0.0727737099,
-0.0445016026,
0.0297358837,
-0.0043420522,
-0.0036815323,
-0.0070559834,
0.0231824312,
0.0240382347,
-0.0204362348,
0.0186250135,
0.1003116295,
0.0291971825,
0.0083115185,
-0.0077250809,
0.0468947999,
0.0082179196,
-0.0216668043,
0.0521799885,
0.0458232313,
0.0069303364,
-0.0484940149,
0.0152891194,
0.0066801873,
-0.0011886922,
0.0123446751,
-0.0340739302,
-0.0095524881,
-0.0434343778,
0.0091122417,
0.0689884648,
-0.0684740692,
0.0021317611,
-0.0056133936,
-0.0099945348,
-0.0288991481,
0.0532644391,
0.0004906236,
-0.0091349306,
0.0820049793,
-0.0200951193,
0.0347896181,
-0.0029123218,
0.0554064065,
0.0085667772,
0.007719697,
-0.0389805138,
-0.0590458922,
-0.0419306345,
0.0523872264,
-0.0148730176,
0.0050926548,
0.0183936507,
-0.0602661669,
0.0249513928,
-0.0426238328,
-0.0488152914,
-0.0128731644,
-0.01121468,
-0.0622536652,
0.027903365,
0.0053423988,
0.0148602519,
0.0039281789,
0.0144682275,
-0.0021746063,
-0.0580388419,
0.0354892462,
0.0478385352,
-0.0545145422,
0.0050257142,
-0.0135242352,
0.0115977693,
0.0143643664,
-0.0337570123,
-0.0554482006,
-0.0405567847,
2.83e-7,
-0.0127949063,
0.0159815438,
0.0011573184,
0.0297466479,
-0.0226385146,
0.0185499508,
0.0508845374,
0.0514920205,
-0.0001960248,
0.0086401226,
-0.0084370254,
0.0006804118,
0.0267300047,
-0.0469589569,
0.0268866532,
0.0617390983,
0.0551693961,
0.0385658965,
-0.0207714401,
0.000104471,
-0.0008865262,
-0.0295663197,
0.0359745175,
-0.0196397752,
0.0056657013,
-0.0692735463,
0.0502419136,
0.0429265425,
0.009852156,
-0.0324169919,
-0.0289560631,
0.036828611,
-0.0544208847,
-0.0225931611,
0.0169357341,
-0.0064164936,
-0.048489552,
0.0510592982,
0.0004336236,
-0.0145297516,
0.0537612177,
0.0019164308,
-0.0685016513,
-0.0282159429,
0.0310077947,
0.073460646,
0.0202994198,
-0.0645631477,
0.0181198101,
0.0012153347,
-0.0089956503,
-0.0554728881,
0.0702434182,
0.0194199178,
-0.0105940159,
-0.0260228328,
-0.0026622484,
0.0015901118,
-0.0062839519,
0.08123862,
-0.0168171097,
-0.0570099466,
-0.0208174139,
0.0173150226,
-0.0115219038,
0.0057120691,
0.045493219,
2.477814899e-34,
0.0522793047,
-0.00968403,
0.0075896531,
0.0541372858,
-0.0204774626,
-0.0440756828,
-0.0771339908,
-0.0579442419,
-0.0431056805,
-0.0483157113,
-0.057104975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17407v1 | Meaning and understanding in large language models | 2023-10-26T14:06:14 | 2023-10-26T14:06:14 | Vladimír Havlík | cs.CL | cs.CL | Can a machine understand the meanings of natural language? Recent
developments in the generative large language models (LLMs) of artificial
intelligence have led to the belief that traditional philosophical assumptions
about machine understanding of language need to be revised. This article
critically evaluates the prevailing tendency to regard machine language
performance as mere syntactic manipulation and the simulation of understanding,
which is only partial and very shallow, without sufficient referential
grounding in the world. The aim is to highlight the conditions crucial to
attributing natural language understanding to state-of-the-art LLMs, where it
can be legitimately argued that LLMs not only use syntax but also semantics,
their understanding not being simulated but duplicated; and determine how they
ground the meanings of linguistic expressions. | [
0.0360630825,
0.0155493906,
-0.0467704199,
0.0518413968,
-0.0487163924,
0.0310213361,
-0.0411316119,
0.0054084901,
-0.012390133,
-0.0659960583,
-0.0204318836,
-0.0345925726,
-0.0031575859,
0.022782838,
0.0298309159,
-0.0282032918,
0.0255326256,
-0.0339546725,
-0.0187285729,
0.0058545219,
-0.0264700316,
-0.0165732298,
0.0237638168,
0.0071112313,
0.008638816,
-0.0043893885,
-0.0264084339,
-0.035266716,
-0.0266177133,
-0.0004973289,
-0.0880535841,
-0.0266973339,
0.0637108907,
0.0241499059,
0.0000018385,
-0.0825032219,
0.0052743829,
0.0155113246,
-0.0729345679,
0.0181282926,
0.0329443775,
-0.0307497252,
-0.0025715542,
-0.0229223631,
-0.0633231178,
0.0231873542,
0.0164783914,
0.0145158088,
0.0051789461,
0.0473065823,
0.0056170779,
-0.0535258763,
0.0128097041,
0.0011767801,
0.0277382191,
-0.0590814091,
0.058996696,
0.0745871887,
0.0265118089,
-0.002990002,
-0.0663158596,
0.0287762415,
0.0260629226,
0.0005544123,
-0.0190015715,
0.0309004914,
0.0151308235,
-0.0155526288,
0.0301403608,
0.0129534928,
0.0171397608,
-0.0157501847,
0.0006436684,
0.0085590985,
-0.0221052151,
0.0186971594,
-0.0552962311,
0.0720355883,
-0.0186556987,
0.0448918492,
0.0590785854,
-0.0246609114,
0.0445393026,
0.0198472161,
-0.0496914536,
0.0983874723,
-0.0201079044,
-0.0319755077,
-0.0194212571,
0.0076772734,
-0.0376163647,
-0.0639089942,
-0.0391494036,
0.0371933319,
0.0001199124,
0.0541183017,
0.012925447,
0.0104003483,
0.0039758524,
-0.0573959425,
0.0334030464,
0.0169429984,
0.0131082637,
0.0437010117,
0.0005947989,
0.0449076742,
-0.0355945826,
-0.0070173331,
-0.0553264879,
-0.0073082121,
-0.0579745732,
-0.0515691712,
-0.0321435966,
0.045178134,
-0.0211928897,
-0.0178011134,
0.0068498631,
0.031240683,
0.0068616639,
0.0219960473,
-0.026517719,
-0.0159728006,
-0.0584151596,
0.0072885174,
-0.0745797828,
-0.015667988,
-0.0308497269,
0.0259026699,
-0.0399851426,
-0.087878339,
-0.0079621961,
0.0259138159,
-0.0119206123,
-0.0108938795,
-0.011886036,
0.0682092756,
0.0528644584,
-0.0053532943,
-0.0265003014,
-0.0198207907,
-0.0396304131,
-0.0487572998,
0.0420104675,
-0.0052193059,
-0.0019314137,
0.0488722995,
0.0003898736,
-0.0368068777,
-0.0114063453,
-0.0235756803,
-0.0189587977,
0.0816338062,
0.0090933917,
0.0221165568,
0.0078826007,
-0.0063933902,
-0.003564883,
0.042026028,
0.0381905027,
0.0151873566,
0.0029876651,
0.001845743,
0.0166904889,
0.0135668265,
-0.0403374732,
-0.0256606005,
-0.0647510141,
-0.0052217157,
-0.0012315174,
0.0354118869,
0.0085538654,
0.0435321182,
-0.0003643612,
0.0177468341,
0.0416377075,
0.026435636,
0.0004786814,
0.0603086725,
0.1201997548,
0.0091314418,
0.0031657554,
0.0537790246,
-0.0455393977,
-0.0040186406,
-0.0339357778,
0.0235340279,
-0.0461811461,
-0.0172216427,
0.0072054048,
-0.0548796169,
-0.023106195,
-0.0017953151,
-0.0001898468,
0.0166445486,
0.0763999298,
-0.0175994951,
0.0048157102,
-0.0039137495,
0.0260729007,
0.0007814906,
0.0295748506,
-0.0935503915,
0.0160392374,
0.0485911109,
0.022383485,
-0.0037375311,
0.0043451115,
-0.008054697,
-0.0235188659,
0.0355096273,
0.0299142133,
-0.0071771881,
-0.0386191942,
-0.0273639075,
-0.0088917678,
-0.0433128886,
0.0200182553,
0.0189612024,
-0.0639776215,
-0.0332154892,
0.0056281653,
-0.0332212597,
-0.0112928338,
0.0452356711,
-0.0287658684,
-0.0258396436,
-0.0654548481,
-0.0003497516,
0.0391435623,
0.0074624955,
-0.0346297435,
0.0253971871,
0.04745977,
-0.0490137525,
0.0072648921,
0.0392619334,
-0.0250160545,
0.0291034114,
0.0085279197,
-0.0243344642,
0.0120082889,
-0.0127450554,
-0.0049855318,
-0.0424104892,
0.0303975288,
-0.0648854822,
0.0631818324,
-0.0531634986,
0.0259343311,
-0.0472020134,
-0.0158722736,
-0.0285824854,
0.0921315849,
0.0228896104,
0.0064472407,
0.0137253609,
0.0205017291,
0.0282774791,
-0.0324856378,
-0.0312615745,
0.0420027785,
0.0263849329,
-0.0051357518,
0.0181775931,
-0.0379520766,
-0.0340088494,
-0.0440513492,
-0.0435728282,
0.0075053205,
-0.0067522828,
0.010726952,
0.0414070562,
-0.0231912564,
0.0028292036,
0.0183200538,
0.020956086,
0.0208075829,
0.0246858895,
0.0008110026,
0.0413173847,
0.0037511999,
-0.0461699553,
0.0239194408,
0.0168336201,
-0.056234315,
0.0385346748,
0.0391299687,
-0.0008052015,
-0.0756825507,
0.0429561324,
-0.0340469889,
0.0145165399,
-0.0207050666,
0.0025294181,
0.0240880214,
0.0076243398,
0.0181250498,
0.0756795555,
0.0037109242,
0.0993549153,
0.0483410135,
0.0041671153,
-0.0284367595,
-0.0046058665,
-0.023670081,
-0.0567447171,
-0.0718948245,
-0.0475749783,
-0.0260974541,
0.0799985901,
0.015678348,
0.0013532041,
-0.0250327457,
0.0635455027,
-0.0660132542,
-0.0423584767,
-0.026982449,
-0.0371790901,
-0.0355054587,
0.0433331355,
-0.0243672673,
-0.0198367946,
0.0489679649,
-0.0112557206,
-0.0082022967,
-0.0290707145,
-0.0198277794,
-0.0172224622,
0.108668454,
0.021741841,
0.0258302372,
0.0389489718,
-0.0149774915,
-0.0237337574,
-0.0206811428,
0.0068390686,
-0.0121425362,
0.0316142403,
-0.0528487302,
0.0190477706,
0.0127328895,
-0.0249619484,
-0.0497098155,
0.004351336,
-0.0652664676,
0.0194733497,
0.0160279442,
0.0178601202,
-0.00977867,
0.0192099921,
0.0502847023,
-0.0323242247,
0.0123927537,
-0.0249715801,
-0.0516608916,
-0.0257876851,
0.0293346029,
0.0046720132,
0.0331164934,
0.0017575618,
0.0349835344,
-0.0022889341,
0.0111377193,
0.0170541555,
-0.0299245305,
0.0301856901,
0.0063992478,
-0.0346080102,
-0.0627797171,
0.0193580203,
-0.0036727241,
-0.0626989156,
-0.0397093259,
0.1191083789,
0.0100911791,
0.0111348955,
0.0286405478,
-0.0492123365,
-0.0422539115,
0.036510624,
0.0300976671,
-0.0689028054,
0.0068460908,
0.0020685494,
-0.0059900978,
-0.0090957554,
-0.0480158329,
-0.0166605692,
-0.0930283591,
0.0492641069,
-0.027105242,
-0.0583266579,
-0.0272510108,
-0.0333843753,
-0.0166385733,
0.0102036176,
0.0219490994,
0.0247027967,
-0.0028112025,
0.0005583396,
0.0316146761,
0.0195179936,
-0.0523733757,
0.0088136401,
-0.0256668683,
0.0402744599,
0.071808733,
0.0648477003,
-0.029791411,
-0.0153729385,
0.0165784769,
-0.0097683324,
0.0245555509,
-0.0066403546,
-0.0325972624,
0.0114117144,
-0.0176340528,
-0.0134809101,
-0.0036128834,
-0.0307141766,
-0.0026685391,
-0.0087642958,
0.070943892,
-0.0571474545,
-0.0450665988,
0.0093042236,
-0.0096384222,
-0.0233730599,
0.1011427268,
0.0537570454,
-0.0247092042,
-0.0226817243,
-0.0491210446,
-0.0052022454,
0.0343321562,
-0.0519647039,
0.0301160906,
0.0193862692,
-0.0040546567,
-0.0267001651,
-0.0472363718,
0.0285104327,
0.009584249,
0.0385937691,
0.0339393392,
0.0356065296,
-0.0319745615,
-0.0051964214,
0.0093489764,
-0.042379681,
-0.0143463016,
-0.0041047023,
-0.0138253858,
0.0557901189,
-0.0569882877,
-0.0335193761,
0.0015356457,
0.00938797,
-0.054878559,
0.0309168622,
0.027473839,
0.0427897796,
0.0152649581,
-0.0000866601,
-0.0218992438,
-0.0184268672,
-0.0012982029,
-0.0166461058,
0.0757986009,
-0.0183065776,
0.0138401464,
0.0163320936,
0.048264686,
-0.0197782516,
0.0431832857,
-0.0037618419,
0.037208721,
-0.0352250077,
-0.0197995491,
0.0494655445,
0.0472102426,
0.0097162072,
0.0113327447,
-0.0283517856,
0.0070890896,
-0.0287686046,
-0.0325558707,
-0.0262857657,
-0.0246805102,
-0.0106547549,
0.0119494153,
0.0280310363,
-0.0198185276,
-0.0073585147,
-0.0414707959,
0.0430049598,
0.0231554918,
-0.0142867584,
0.0105676334,
-0.0140167726,
0.0132851433,
0.0112754731,
0.0238245372,
0.0378924385,
-0.0112847341,
0.0386994779,
-0.000773948,
0.0514567792,
0.0350416563,
0.0140869645,
-0.0280521493,
-0.0263510533,
-0.0598306619,
-0.1012877673,
0.0420544744,
0.0458438434,
0.0510985851,
-0.0300886296,
0.0434881859,
-0.050092876,
0.0108935796,
0.0060217287,
0.0068306206,
0.0362322815,
-0.0634241253,
0.0480815321,
0.0355414674,
-0.0397144854,
-0.0206515621,
0.0426605605,
0.0030772253,
0.0829718336,
-0.0021919394,
-0.0115879085,
-0.0401869752,
-0.0543510541,
0.0156593416,
-0.0192085914,
0.0107456381,
0.0340058841,
-0.066868104,
-0.0717317164,
-0.0106646419,
0.0417899676,
0.0438140221,
-0.0701989606,
0.0305246823,
0.0714261755,
-0.0049838489,
-0.0334903672,
-0.0362017751,
0.0495269895,
-0.0068559265,
0.0049338783,
-0.0118272072,
-5.582600466e-33,
-0.0473081991,
-0.0352642238,
0.046574682,
-0.019645676,
-0.0298348777,
-0.0103172464,
-0.0580745824,
-0.0141302003,
-0.0342585854,
0.0235741455,
-0.0196229592,
-0.0031893982,
0.0138145648,
0.0043778098,
0.0170010999,
-0.0203805938,
0.0256608501,
-0.0317672119,
0.0148914875,
-0.011505411,
0.0308288932,
-0.0049380683,
0.0284523759,
-0.0370657668,
0.051092688,
-0.0257106554,
0.0013682822,
0.0442128517,
-0.0033756408,
0.041459661,
-0.039772585,
0.0287789758,
0.0479537807,
-0.0470200926,
-0.0029920707,
0.01715165,
-0.0272395778,
-0.0087144738,
0.0799838901,
0.0251234062,
-0.0057571689,
-0.0332676321,
0.0641991496,
-0.0126226628,
-0.0475724079,
0.0566011444,
0.020213848,
-0.0397257321,
-0.0048963805,
-0.0093727829,
-0.0795183107,
-0.0098604364,
-0.0125545654,
-0.0131772757,
0.0260837562,
-0.0256680846,
-0.0222007185,
0.0168559887,
0.0016182901,
0.0128173083,
0.0023014399,
0.0002535788,
0.0763377696,
0.0243971199,
0.0446678847,
0.0449363403,
0.0204516686,
-0.0053486135,
-0.0415196121,
-0.0162818488,
0.022212293,
0.0382125676,
-0.0307448637,
0.0247913562,
0.0139407599,
0.0293744896,
-0.0767286271,
-0.0168662779,
-0.0135923857,
0.0452845655,
0.0581956431,
0.0132814413,
-0.0286878608,
-0.0227482263,
-0.0606969222,
0.0050224508,
-0.0147086037,
-0.0254330002,
0.0208953582,
-0.0284456331,
-0.0153853735,
0.0066420976,
0.0284299403,
-0.1035658345,
-0.0097958352,
0.0029061215,
0.0070038014,
0.0154394181,
0.0088163242,
0.0209612753,
-0.0097010573,
-0.0668549538,
-0.0306356065,
0.0150725916,
0.0063167424,
0.0230546594,
-0.0186077729,
-0.0076581142,
0.0259720553,
-0.0094340146,
-0.0503189974,
-0.0317600407,
0.0025927671,
-0.0244205203,
0.0656823292,
0.0559541844,
0.0114679523,
-0.0040575811,
0.0434787162,
-0.0169222392,
-0.0137296412,
0.0231090244,
-0.0337138399,
0.0179541707,
-0.0667770058,
-0.022046769,
-0.0005536994,
0.04116771,
0.0616837889,
-0.0335870869,
-0.0118141389,
-0.0043075723,
2.683e-7,
0.0792841613,
0.0593281575,
0.0092881732,
0.0454144068,
0.0231470633,
0.0294335857,
-0.022342084,
0.0115683805,
0.015804274,
-0.0398290865,
0.0062771607,
0.0638154149,
-0.0263800323,
-0.000702805,
-0.0451063067,
0.0269184187,
-0.0125691714,
-0.0039292891,
-0.0415588357,
0.0623542517,
0.044655595,
0.0744593963,
-0.0051081274,
-0.0037487827,
-0.0197395571,
-0.0550185218,
0.0387157984,
-0.0447014868,
0.007861577,
0.0278618131,
0.0297273658,
0.0213629827,
-0.0107807247,
0.0412409231,
0.0475984514,
0.0218464937,
0.0136662684,
0.0663094595,
-0.0044789594,
0.0369847454,
-0.0280005801,
-0.0616043918,
0.013670898,
-0.0751925036,
0.0556116141,
-0.0907452032,
-0.0547844656,
-0.0279292148,
0.0136015853,
-0.0218613017,
-0.0402621888,
0.0125480024,
0.0212647859,
0.0085470686,
-0.0025553179,
-0.0250291284,
0.0026952636,
-0.0373258442,
0.0216619428,
0.0140976449,
-0.0639439523,
-0.0444345064,
-0.0176996198,
0.0219901614,
0.0632859617,
-0.0414116047,
-0.0167019349,
2.042995866e-34,
0.0175374635,
0.0097117387,
0.0392070226,
0.0438508689,
0.0518262833,
0.0217849482,
-0.0246963762,
0.0557676889,
0.0110637844,
-0.0961678848,
-0.0150907086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17389v1 | ToxicChat: Unveiling Hidden Challenges of Toxicity Detection in Real-World User-AI Conversation | 2023-10-26T13:35:41 | 2023-10-26T13:35:41 | Zi Lin, Zihan Wang, Yongqi Tong, Yangkun Wang, Yuxin Guo, Yujia Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite remarkable advances that large language models have achieved in
chatbots, maintaining a non-toxic user-AI interactive environment has become
increasingly critical nowadays. However, previous efforts in toxicity detection
have been mostly based on benchmarks derived from social media content, leaving
the unique challenges inherent to real-world user-AI interactions
insufficiently explored. In this work, we introduce ToxicChat, a novel
benchmark based on real user queries from an open-source chatbot. This
benchmark contains the rich, nuanced phenomena that can be tricky for current
toxicity detection models to identify, revealing a significant domain
difference compared to social media content. Our systematic evaluation of
models trained on existing toxicity datasets has shown their shortcomings when
applied to this unique domain of ToxicChat. Our work illuminates the
potentially overlooked challenges of toxicity detection in real-world user-AI
conversations. In the future, ToxicChat can be a valuable resource to drive
further advancements toward building a safe and healthy environment for user-AI
interactions. | [
0.0576548018,
0.0379594453,
-0.0316091105,
-0.0215072092,
0.0023285148,
0.0116224578,
-0.0006127866,
0.0440145321,
0.0880865827,
-0.020167876,
-0.042531427,
0.0165564138,
-0.0516564623,
0.0393499546,
-0.0125524243,
-0.0158977304,
0.0234629996,
0.0321297944,
-0.0007821483,
0.0415647291,
0.0563266166,
0.0194154773,
-0.0046501257,
0.0687246993,
-0.0532042161,
-0.0531677529,
0.0087741772,
0.0242965389,
0.047604993,
-0.0347529426,
0.0320261791,
0.0164970644,
-0.0194725618,
0.0653662905,
0.0000017319,
-0.0013730394,
0.0037328035,
0.0085155824,
-0.021731304,
-0.0673907697,
0.0842875242,
-0.0017916359,
-0.0211790781,
0.0705441311,
-0.0578451902,
0.0201731119,
0.0710363239,
0.0170024764,
0.0829003304,
0.0670385659,
-0.0398142338,
0.0454122387,
0.0196651202,
0.0274973344,
0.00336157,
-0.0213323925,
0.0497713014,
-0.0179104879,
0.0089860614,
-0.0316488557,
-0.0088310502,
0.0157082994,
0.0101438928,
-0.0105631705,
-0.0072267232,
0.0064426847,
-0.005676473,
-0.0620771237,
0.0115643581,
0.1148597226,
-0.0436333679,
-0.0025630528,
-0.0019651034,
0.0165640041,
-0.0011567314,
-0.031493064,
-0.031571582,
-0.0051091202,
-0.0281401258,
-0.003269451,
-0.0336733237,
0.0406387821,
0.0285541359,
0.0413628854,
0.0209471062,
0.013890937,
-0.0000494303,
-0.0266916547,
0.0235273018,
-0.0257534627,
-0.0138016893,
0.0093810111,
0.0353230946,
0.0022972906,
-0.07113076,
0.0195304081,
-0.0560813844,
-0.0324449167,
0.016988473,
-0.1029671207,
-0.000757039,
0.0109472824,
-0.0372688733,
0.0419155173,
0.0470174402,
0.0068579451,
0.0149345053,
0.0387664475,
-0.0157629158,
0.0006295255,
-0.0135446871,
-0.0003336672,
-0.039604824,
-0.0063337032,
0.022490846,
0.0030221334,
-0.0360184945,
0.045716729,
-0.0571856759,
-0.0096126385,
0.0088931043,
0.0313820727,
-0.0433035307,
0.0389698818,
-0.0059495275,
-0.0275710933,
-0.0240744893,
0.0194285903,
0.0182022117,
-0.0939178392,
-0.0105071962,
0.0305003673,
-0.0307586342,
-0.032084249,
-0.0156240817,
0.1192804202,
0.0420299582,
-0.0270435791,
-0.0147624779,
-0.0429194719,
-0.0291761272,
-0.0343449526,
-0.0184322409,
-0.0087082358,
0.0471935458,
-0.0155520262,
-0.0094333515,
-0.0740595236,
0.0189532526,
0.022013776,
-0.0423938893,
0.0624858551,
-0.0144603737,
-0.0026738048,
0.0062013222,
0.0549995005,
-0.0459442362,
0.0652848035,
0.0143896118,
0.0498700216,
0.0304711834,
0.0005926677,
0.0187971331,
0.023282256,
0.0143202804,
0.0159290917,
-0.0320728682,
0.0031629503,
-0.0359237194,
0.0217214134,
-0.0349786803,
0.0578583181,
-0.0140012708,
-0.0374099165,
0.077292107,
0.0443323813,
-0.0335619673,
0.0051245652,
0.0349654481,
0.0132458666,
-0.0114222867,
-0.016734574,
-0.0738821253,
-0.0026285092,
-0.038728267,
-0.0748877153,
0.0335112102,
0.0071698851,
-0.0135762831,
-0.0583717562,
0.0003720816,
-0.0216758884,
0.0552104302,
-0.0319200903,
0.0071122185,
-0.0096820891,
-0.0571790449,
-0.0079735108,
0.047612939,
-0.0435458012,
-0.0349923261,
-0.0263238437,
0.0377164856,
0.0976452753,
0.0582614057,
-0.0271309521,
-0.0126914652,
-0.0429603271,
-0.0269335713,
0.0042769122,
0.0005480773,
0.0075275791,
0.038603697,
0.0182713922,
0.0004992126,
0.0421889201,
-0.0032933063,
-0.0401569568,
0.0217670202,
0.047326833,
-0.028034972,
-0.0026975696,
-0.0457093455,
0.0480039418,
-0.0085311448,
-0.0189226381,
-0.0161632728,
0.025737986,
0.0525319204,
-0.0060719773,
0.0016574521,
-0.0420465693,
0.0227941703,
-0.0113005657,
-0.0457494557,
0.0090911658,
-0.0204863418,
-0.0065191602,
0.0338287391,
-0.0170873161,
-0.0246679652,
0.0764440149,
-0.0243595149,
0.0332676657,
0.0200417973,
-0.0402261466,
-0.0066355867,
0.0019743571,
-0.0103667406,
-0.0202892069,
0.0530587919,
0.0008075991,
0.0388760976,
-0.0164557807,
-0.0422720648,
-0.0376274697,
-0.0152684133,
-0.0245412923,
-0.0258556549,
-0.0248092562,
-0.0289238095,
-0.0175483152,
0.021012105,
0.0246751718,
0.0055049458,
-0.0606573373,
0.0184459351,
-0.0848541707,
-0.0183421429,
-0.0307538789,
-0.0280694198,
0.0081308056,
0.011925892,
-0.0004108881,
0.0047078007,
-0.0233026166,
0.0013488177,
0.0154761113,
0.0422908477,
0.0126456004,
-0.0151612023,
0.0043240059,
-0.0609892048,
0.0175075121,
-0.033183217,
0.0353042819,
-0.0021480955,
-0.0565740019,
0.0404077545,
0.0199113172,
-0.0274094027,
0.0220749807,
-0.003647225,
-0.0793931335,
0.0239510462,
0.0110806208,
0.0038827059,
0.0949851051,
0.0645118952,
0.0833771601,
0.0213781092,
0.0499694273,
-0.0426090099,
0.0321249068,
-0.0231054556,
-0.0048318543,
-0.0195171945,
-0.0430212766,
0.0192486923,
0.0404086374,
-0.0098668886,
0.0096373959,
-0.0655796602,
0.0660808384,
-0.0223877672,
-0.0515566804,
-0.0244416259,
-0.0448877923,
-0.0092751142,
-0.0194480158,
-0.0201539863,
-0.0708887652,
0.0628474429,
0.0195342228,
0.0359025933,
0.0067470255,
-0.0507088006,
0.0135191046,
0.0261414498,
0.0103785228,
0.0326828472,
0.0215076245,
0.0299476814,
-0.0053166999,
-0.0150158247,
0.0251300558,
-0.0515076667,
-0.0113833826,
-0.0191010665,
-0.0122889997,
0.0419286378,
-0.0629426092,
-0.0668649003,
-0.0286977571,
-0.0343495086,
-0.0179835949,
-0.0049424968,
-0.0244587921,
-0.0369669534,
0.0306194294,
-0.0181518923,
-0.0422755666,
0.0107446648,
-0.0316528305,
0.0185774732,
-0.030892361,
0.0754218027,
-0.0078286408,
0.0341918692,
0.0095110154,
0.0837867633,
0.103022404,
-0.0003556439,
-0.0193731748,
-0.0088036144,
-0.0123906685,
-0.0182053447,
0.0140639339,
0.0216089264,
0.0070946296,
-0.0062116114,
-0.0038877917,
-0.0116243502,
0.0561849922,
0.0160739999,
-0.0392000824,
0.0541739948,
-0.0175192021,
-0.0089264316,
0.0026792823,
-0.010135822,
-0.0940019861,
-0.0233965516,
-0.0168546159,
0.0299711861,
-0.0658656806,
-0.0605510771,
0.0061081368,
-0.0849523768,
0.0046112095,
-0.0016313139,
-0.0558715016,
-0.0367791466,
-0.0257428922,
-0.0006788317,
-0.0710295141,
0.0586771742,
-0.0452793352,
0.0101022394,
-0.0419733413,
-0.0014447761,
-0.0467148907,
-0.0189974327,
0.0218630321,
-0.0459763594,
0.0522570387,
0.0173883736,
0.0785428584,
0.0050491118,
0.0327169262,
0.0091062393,
0.0388501473,
-0.0122694299,
-0.0128000686,
0.0912081003,
-0.0227772351,
-0.0136292148,
-0.0294394214,
0.0278319325,
-0.0243666731,
0.0203418396,
-0.0053674919,
0.0354146659,
-0.0203138739,
-0.0123148626,
-0.0478148013,
0.0471139625,
0.0673897043,
0.080121778,
0.0232440419,
-0.0580693111,
-0.0381321386,
-0.0347663127,
-0.0117836036,
-0.0200696122,
-0.0598201118,
-0.0358552076,
-0.0338855423,
-0.0529706329,
-0.0776152089,
-0.0294899065,
-0.0072552296,
-0.0052072792,
-0.0258868951,
-0.0205097813,
-0.0145811886,
0.017831821,
0.019972844,
0.0394486412,
0.0226214863,
0.0316073783,
-0.037180014,
0.0298160631,
-0.0226359591,
-0.0173516739,
-0.0037967106,
0.0667273104,
-0.0305154696,
-0.0467093848,
0.0476654731,
0.0727260336,
0.0111042457,
0.0104786167,
-0.0411628932,
-0.0292571429,
0.0112839723,
0.0456832796,
-0.0430471711,
-0.0335657336,
0.0636383817,
0.0229489468,
0.0274318047,
0.0211979412,
-0.0607112125,
0.0107031092,
0.0058017951,
-0.0163007788,
-0.0734734833,
0.0003541318,
0.0311451498,
0.0224477239,
0.0390354618,
0.0269111861,
-0.0157655515,
0.0142707257,
-0.0082218684,
-0.0080213128,
-0.0147928502,
-0.0019394244,
0.009551446,
0.0330240875,
0.0067219795,
-0.0375254378,
0.0097923586,
-0.053302478,
0.0392553806,
-0.0368676335,
-0.0256163087,
0.0324216373,
-0.0052630468,
0.0436060689,
0.0097614415,
0.0085865958,
0.0311639085,
-0.0050575472,
0.0157270581,
-0.025063388,
0.0132209985,
-0.0080354139,
0.0235241987,
0.0220387354,
0.0689444914,
-0.0195789505,
-0.0443237759,
-0.0125609981,
0.008311687,
0.0081641339,
0.0127305398,
0.0439865775,
-0.0341457091,
0.0036874218,
-0.0275847334,
0.0076585039,
-0.0422221385,
-0.0305021387,
-0.0295297801,
0.0011566007,
-0.0185604878,
0.0134849064,
0.0746334791,
0.0125862416,
0.0423308499,
0.0107107572,
-0.0466400646,
0.0094820075,
0.0006695752,
0.0408057645,
0.0219548419,
-0.0039909869,
-0.0086752409,
-0.0437404104,
-0.0523597598,
-0.0111026857,
-0.0282863677,
0.0067726579,
-0.0008204922,
0.015630817,
0.0449641012,
0.0193495229,
0.0091560297,
-0.0340425782,
-0.0177233592,
-0.0243959501,
-0.0411135368,
-0.0011806637,
-5.200930674e-33,
0.0317842141,
-0.0396198146,
-0.010386114,
0.0205334332,
-0.0193725191,
-0.0211674999,
0.0067030932,
0.0056868363,
-0.0429281928,
0.0189189278,
0.004068892,
0.045239035,
-0.0114179756,
-0.0193490032,
-0.0234975517,
-0.038057372,
0.0218650512,
-0.0111238444,
-0.0237937327,
0.0461529568,
0.0488497391,
0.0252728928,
-0.0156325735,
-0.0922299623,
-0.0064660241,
0.0105403261,
-0.0239918493,
0.020717537,
-0.0036328346,
0.0628020465,
0.0048469305,
0.099571906,
0.0226414241,
0.0253718924,
0.0141939409,
0.0271754768,
-0.0283534881,
-0.0062971306,
-0.0251736548,
-0.0258035399,
-0.0604580268,
-0.0296433605,
0.0639060438,
0.0203999802,
-0.0148279956,
-0.013312568,
0.0157245882,
0.0036082966,
0.0272102822,
-0.0091298027,
-0.0465387814,
-0.0027106476,
-0.0487443693,
-0.0353318714,
-0.0152538698,
0.0880049393,
0.0146705639,
0.0311267879,
-0.0413304009,
-0.0040299031,
-0.0651509985,
-0.0334661044,
0.0104945684,
-0.0187488496,
0.0304383356,
0.0541521013,
0.0300334487,
0.062286742,
-0.0284034442,
-0.0138432449,
-0.0066933278,
0.0408292115,
0.0428149402,
0.0176881384,
-0.0012598295,
-0.0556693003,
-0.0798060447,
0.019272387,
0.0446703061,
0.0409484021,
-0.0094085466,
-0.0164313503,
-0.0866939127,
-0.0100949574,
-0.0006553583,
0.0157974903,
-0.0353054516,
-0.0427862033,
0.0143774748,
-0.0072221365,
-0.0092928316,
-0.0496240519,
-0.0130569367,
-0.0726466477,
0.0392964333,
0.0211984608,
-0.0024056013,
-0.02667135,
0.0026079083,
0.0234323107,
-0.0270893518,
0.0048199561,
0.039466802,
-0.0367761813,
0.0325595178,
-0.0177608766,
0.0622838475,
0.0208580792,
-0.0135475136,
-0.0195796788,
-0.0160093214,
0.0756535456,
-0.0010457351,
0.0550550409,
-0.0103776827,
0.018433556,
-0.0037275774,
0.0278483089,
0.0395664871,
0.0544010326,
-0.0268544145,
-0.022318881,
-0.0209685862,
-0.0268712882,
-0.0236127973,
-0.0259745307,
-0.0441235416,
0.0163130369,
0.0326843634,
-0.089669697,
-0.0141033372,
-0.0616323054,
2.406e-7,
0.0243162382,
0.0373855606,
0.01527787,
0.0324999541,
0.00775208,
0.0369257964,
0.0420207307,
0.0782772899,
-0.0264558196,
-0.0216007531,
0.0199280418,
0.0284620654,
0.0543368272,
0.0496374257,
-0.0142967887,
-0.0117279319,
-0.0937792733,
-0.0295660216,
-0.044875402,
-0.0048039975,
0.0554967597,
0.0732673481,
0.0209953114,
-0.0537023507,
0.039061904,
-0.0334486961,
0.0270887334,
-0.0508244932,
-0.009431757,
0.0200759824,
0.0594936237,
0.0206854325,
0.0150932986,
0.0068498962,
-0.0159975886,
-0.015297086,
0.0142123587,
0.0358767733,
-0.0255112015,
-0.0656366795,
0.0324147157,
-0.019559361,
0.0037055796,
-0.0143634276,
0.0701442584,
-0.0229505897,
-0.0090385703,
-0.0270267166,
-0.0062914519,
-0.0323450156,
0.065315403,
-0.0429898165,
-0.0310009774,
0.0152707966,
0.0203843936,
0.005225406,
0.0083391462,
-0.0546375737,
-0.0046022767,
-0.0245822631,
-0.0382595137,
-0.0766470432,
-0.0057912078,
0.0146498075,
0.0079240995,
0.0024038865,
0.0261323024,
1.564150321e-34,
0.015412976,
-0.0167590361,
0.021746764,
0.003657537,
0.049104359,
0.032056421,
0.0222046059,
-0.0280807596,
0.0246809237,
-0.0373403281,
0.0263762511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17372v1 | Dialogue-based generation of self-driving simulation scenarios using Large Language Models | 2023-10-26T13:07:01 | 2023-10-26T13:07:01 | Antonio Valerio Miceli-Barone, Alex Lascarides, Craig Innes | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | Simulation is an invaluable tool for developing and evaluating controllers
for self-driving cars. Current simulation frameworks are driven by
highly-specialist domain specific languages, and so a natural language
interface would greatly enhance usability. But there is often a gap, consisting
of tacit assumptions the user is making, between a concise English utterance
and the executable code that captures the user's intent. In this paper we
describe a system that addresses this issue by supporting an extended
multimodal interaction: the user can follow up prior instructions with
refinements or revisions, in reaction to the simulations that have been
generated from their utterances so far. We use Large Language Models (LLMs) to
map the user's English utterances in this interaction into domain-specific
code, and so we explore the extent to which LLMs capture the context
sensitivity that's necessary for computing the speaker's intended message in
discourse. | [
0.0037069253,
0.0118537759,
-0.0272096358,
0.0573166907,
-0.0346927755,
-0.0295616258,
0.0254764743,
-0.02189162,
0.0294155981,
-0.0483354144,
-0.0052277399,
-0.0133011937,
-0.0061267642,
0.0443438068,
0.0206779651,
-0.0523487963,
0.0163425673,
-0.1086123437,
-0.0330478698,
-0.0083246799,
-0.0119355898,
0.0028526045,
-0.0467485227,
0.0455023013,
-0.0354982093,
-0.0211216491,
-0.0496696271,
0.0256750509,
-0.0054456145,
-0.0140653318,
-0.0382193439,
0.0666937307,
0.080360651,
0.0010265625,
0.0000021644,
-0.0482711196,
0.0358729586,
0.0032663031,
0.0050494913,
0.009974489,
0.0695136711,
0.0599431843,
-0.0193426311,
0.0112216547,
-0.0512631945,
0.0091273272,
0.0348919518,
-0.0243877135,
0.0961447582,
0.0117056957,
-0.0007815688,
-0.0047487193,
-0.0369029045,
0.0620042309,
-0.0215692297,
-0.0386445485,
0.011237964,
0.053701669,
0.0865869224,
0.0044961195,
-0.0186227001,
0.0337837152,
0.0589098297,
-0.0596147217,
-0.0189730115,
0.0521009974,
0.0393045507,
-0.0204131175,
-0.0272880774,
0.0384663567,
0.0130564757,
-0.0298109427,
0.0131740374,
0.0265185181,
-0.027014276,
-0.0046217535,
-0.031090891,
-0.0206761491,
-0.0103096087,
-0.0158728007,
-0.0399868675,
-0.0003724757,
-0.0213322155,
0.0052231895,
-0.0373027362,
0.0503030159,
0.0185695868,
-0.0093464674,
-0.0336992927,
-0.0063800439,
0.0136502078,
-0.0835485011,
-0.0023771126,
0.0492270328,
-0.0639057755,
-0.0062662577,
-0.0443534069,
0.0053150556,
-0.0142246038,
-0.0725559667,
0.0455067046,
0.022987267,
-0.0331322029,
0.0316482633,
0.033433605,
0.0460194163,
-0.0109335845,
-0.0059677558,
-0.0149114076,
0.0004327507,
-0.0325424336,
-0.0187759046,
-0.0588109344,
-0.0026024873,
-0.0589182787,
-0.0124581335,
-0.006098236,
0.0841534883,
-0.0142850997,
0.0206361618,
-0.0597834177,
0.0237662103,
-0.0203764625,
-0.0136906896,
-0.0255053155,
-0.0134020206,
-0.0186799951,
0.0158045609,
0.014265174,
-0.060932707,
0.0261461362,
0.0264660213,
-0.0292408671,
-0.0141006438,
-0.0137868868,
0.1203789786,
-0.0149427718,
0.0146429883,
-0.0149020003,
-0.0639617965,
-0.0244760308,
-0.0420083329,
-0.0100841047,
-0.0970779434,
0.0062922458,
0.0144116888,
-0.0203483626,
-0.0671219602,
0.0069243605,
0.0019811792,
0.026562592,
0.0906363279,
-0.0336564705,
0.0357879475,
0.0607175976,
0.0006891287,
0.0270519499,
0.0482970327,
0.0469824485,
0.0034168179,
0.0190636087,
-0.0015961443,
0.0333912857,
0.0480546281,
-0.0388809107,
0.0233085323,
-0.0244588163,
0.0046722624,
-0.008037976,
0.0662838519,
0.0197161585,
0.0235893391,
-0.0285915229,
0.0183797535,
0.0614785217,
0.0464567877,
-0.0034016366,
0.0219960418,
0.0602276362,
0.0428570583,
0.000930283,
0.0131625999,
-0.0232509207,
0.0296858847,
-0.0031499944,
0.0058213947,
0.0196633935,
0.026249269,
-0.0115259243,
-0.0426681302,
0.0334041677,
-0.0025856113,
0.0350678302,
-0.0255939793,
0.0190073978,
-0.0157210939,
0.0079666702,
-0.0241051521,
-0.0175840128,
-0.0158722736,
0.0100199301,
-0.040058922,
-0.0043465928,
0.092091836,
0.0398963131,
-0.034766864,
-0.0380969159,
-0.000522784,
0.0245680865,
0.0197488721,
0.0311558358,
-0.0058282269,
0.0002227467,
0.0048847483,
-0.0399227515,
-0.009554565,
0.0016377288,
0.0058860476,
-0.01373496,
0.0071754279,
0.0058611273,
0.0085879508,
0.0252889805,
0.0207558218,
-0.0189324189,
-0.0256872028,
-0.0143277701,
-0.0020275784,
-0.004610043,
0.013315008,
-0.0425440259,
0.0272880066,
0.0312492419,
-0.0020503376,
0.0053999578,
0.0371859036,
-0.0435830057,
0.01796446,
0.0613923334,
-0.039959386,
0.0085991798,
0.0109195933,
-0.0101556545,
-0.0370490514,
-0.0067081996,
-0.0218616836,
-0.0068149618,
-0.017467143,
-0.0016281124,
0.0268648975,
0.0087992577,
-0.0043079173,
0.0046885647,
0.034409713,
-0.0043067676,
0.0762190744,
0.0410310701,
0.0127244825,
-0.0359757096,
-0.0154673532,
0.0234062895,
0.0080108605,
0.0156341586,
0.0231873039,
0.0135907847,
-0.0230992232,
0.0037838523,
-0.094129689,
-0.0177558344,
-0.0225920938,
-0.0107907346,
0.0185957216,
0.0253464468,
-0.021305196,
-0.0242402125,
0.0287663098,
0.0052416348,
0.0104541183,
-0.0109550441,
0.0233491436,
0.0006919409,
-0.0348037072,
-0.0091393944,
0.0060524554,
-0.028751513,
0.0296357684,
0.0169892386,
0.0010743678,
-0.0921963602,
-0.0086140847,
-0.0237673726,
0.0696507692,
0.02090469,
-0.0397260636,
0.0487526394,
0.0108621791,
0.0749751702,
0.0586334467,
0.0044491584,
0.0041618259,
0.0568321459,
-0.0502231382,
-0.0668915361,
0.0202617478,
0.0118719731,
-0.0330978371,
-0.056613151,
-0.005183008,
0.0119991489,
0.0569480918,
0.0167748611,
0.0135475108,
-0.0183554981,
0.0309938528,
-0.0299867764,
-0.0496032834,
-0.0043481402,
-0.0175216738,
-0.0545804314,
0.0708963946,
0.0044425782,
-0.0370675288,
0.0720972866,
-0.0530723371,
-0.0090449424,
0.0043180068,
-0.0175777711,
0.0173895098,
0.08012335,
-0.0012774531,
-0.015602448,
0.0312872045,
0.0248613805,
0.0084013147,
0.0164966807,
-0.0184683744,
-0.0037456937,
0.0571539514,
-0.1117836982,
0.0121100936,
0.0032612109,
-0.052619271,
-0.0192648377,
-0.028476391,
-0.0499414355,
0.0024590327,
-0.0028897135,
-0.0207731389,
0.0173967872,
0.0103671234,
0.045726344,
0.0896510631,
0.0219683275,
-0.0243129153,
-0.0322956964,
-0.0275198314,
0.0632502511,
0.037793912,
-0.0470643938,
-0.0148168961,
0.0733712018,
0.0177147724,
0.0274627395,
0.0108460812,
-0.0895464197,
-0.0192220304,
0.0171987172,
0.0016896939,
-0.0031375021,
0.0878357366,
0.0338028334,
-0.0587159805,
-0.0546497852,
0.0941483453,
0.0038466183,
-0.0135812201,
0.031882748,
-0.0589938909,
0.0228560157,
0.0197509732,
0.0498040803,
-0.0969214514,
-0.016067395,
0.0045253932,
-0.0060223718,
0.0007075928,
-0.0223562811,
0.0131475851,
-0.0891458839,
0.0478321835,
-0.0107832095,
-0.038531214,
-0.0099529671,
-0.0075072367,
0.0091303084,
0.0294076819,
-0.0047811773,
0.0292406157,
0.0050025312,
-0.0235182717,
0.0012818088,
-0.0246394742,
-0.0407047644,
0.0238530803,
-0.0285287332,
0.0496984608,
0.0626383573,
0.0195935313,
-0.0065309969,
0.0023907132,
0.017211834,
0.0225150343,
0.0350389108,
-0.035850361,
-0.0137269842,
-0.0037972485,
-0.0076424619,
-0.0114316614,
0.0207489673,
-0.0089934692,
-0.0303793345,
0.0208651032,
0.0722859055,
-0.0812646076,
0.0038823364,
-0.0574163012,
0.0213371627,
0.0402343422,
0.0110338023,
0.031077506,
-0.0694990009,
-0.0316202529,
-0.0279458445,
-0.0400398187,
-0.0004912545,
-0.0610065944,
-0.0487329811,
0.0194541179,
-0.0089916335,
-0.009599641,
-0.0478313044,
0.0376080759,
0.0162938442,
0.0068460647,
0.0020030802,
0.0532804802,
-0.0122166937,
-0.026927514,
-0.0192103125,
-0.0133242235,
0.041684866,
0.0098886201,
0.0273520704,
0.0463617072,
-0.0440339595,
-0.0151249599,
0.0318301395,
-0.0071564498,
-0.0762489885,
0.0150123965,
0.0789854601,
0.0247379933,
0.0383143239,
-0.0155143095,
-0.0688413307,
-0.0116085866,
0.0043506701,
-0.0408729874,
0.0261892732,
-0.0076136743,
0.0367154516,
0.0046551721,
0.0192382727,
-0.0485683866,
0.017259188,
-0.0371647589,
0.0031915086,
-0.0298477393,
-0.1009573489,
0.0347768366,
0.0187811777,
0.036873363,
-0.0153212799,
0.0254197717,
-0.0065817661,
0.0054007419,
-0.0287971236,
-0.0336042754,
-0.0584952943,
0.0253637806,
-0.0529979356,
-0.0070757396,
0.035175696,
-0.0403159522,
-0.0357206278,
0.0096244942,
0.0281679034,
0.0335843116,
0.0625831038,
0.0270477403,
0.0276082624,
-0.0212460142,
0.0152223269,
0.0102046365,
0.0083618164,
0.0479750708,
-0.0145862922,
0.0814515352,
0.0231358279,
-0.0418467186,
0.0125993229,
0.0327510238,
-0.0193222892,
-0.0751891658,
-0.0210646596,
0.0666852742,
0.0512492582,
0.0266955514,
0.0153095294,
-0.0985472575,
0.0230027363,
-0.0408117659,
0.0637881681,
0.0375910066,
-0.0421108641,
0.0376184694,
0.0048707533,
-0.0149949631,
-0.0364552438,
0.0320657045,
-0.002665567,
0.0250344165,
0.03183176,
-0.0177132282,
-0.0688087568,
-0.0436273813,
0.0057473821,
-0.0018048486,
-0.0260420423,
-0.016115794,
-0.0465117358,
-0.055296775,
0.0063600056,
0.0804856569,
-0.0096926251,
-0.0580184609,
0.0341952965,
0.015143699,
0.0251140241,
-0.0213195961,
0.0115469871,
0.0099575976,
-0.0198642034,
-0.0283277649,
-0.0478883795,
-5.90017606e-33,
-0.0492310822,
-0.0380661935,
0.0745536909,
-0.0170623902,
-0.0375611112,
-0.0615463592,
-0.0491294339,
0.0254332088,
0.0285215005,
0.0160204489,
-0.0004921069,
-0.0214095991,
0.009333157,
-0.0082860598,
0.018559467,
-0.0068133543,
0.0437866077,
0.0088531924,
-0.0334518589,
0.0087827314,
0.0029702266,
0.0042963531,
-0.0034806372,
-0.0889426097,
0.0350290611,
-0.0263427459,
-0.015865732,
0.0279745348,
-0.0185642093,
0.039712809,
-0.0200679749,
0.0751204789,
0.0091019105,
-0.0353295431,
-0.0328173935,
0.0564695001,
-0.0011635146,
-0.0309787635,
0.0354737304,
0.0267718807,
-0.0484389663,
-0.0214940012,
0.0440898687,
0.0013501605,
-0.0688444003,
0.0292977169,
0.0255517382,
-0.0115104262,
0.0084821014,
0.0006285347,
-0.0992842615,
0.0121605173,
-0.0046763807,
-0.065300025,
0.0345957056,
0.0522522815,
-0.0139628761,
-0.0717430636,
0.0062472485,
-0.0023877693,
0.0003908517,
0.018419655,
0.0949617997,
0.0050688167,
0.0417928845,
0.0241569113,
-0.0039551649,
-0.0091553684,
-0.0609409437,
-0.0163828023,
0.0099169509,
0.057469625,
-0.017978115,
0.0946204066,
-0.0309601258,
-0.006715327,
-0.017908901,
0.0072800429,
-0.0566453263,
0.0453831516,
0.0301244594,
0.0172267146,
-0.038314037,
0.0114700161,
-0.0545303226,
0.0607431605,
-0.0118574696,
-0.0576070398,
0.0348350145,
-0.0265808646,
-0.0036041301,
-0.0412613302,
0.0399348773,
-0.0404169038,
-0.0234541818,
-0.0345459357,
-0.0284637567,
0.0075257192,
-0.0224523973,
0.0238361824,
-0.0173318628,
-0.0037057588,
-0.0055779279,
-0.0119378222,
0.0486779697,
0.0220927596,
-0.0721864998,
0.045722913,
-0.0469520204,
0.0019511842,
-0.0466661453,
0.0133954762,
0.0321304165,
0.0296595301,
0.0417385697,
0.0057611279,
-0.0334751308,
0.0112239486,
-0.0227535684,
-0.0905046314,
-0.0282342993,
-0.0246978924,
0.0040868819,
-0.0052595981,
-0.0328005999,
0.0046131248,
-0.0494079553,
-0.000719983,
0.024034474,
-0.0294844434,
-0.0154653555,
0.0219405349,
2.817e-7,
-0.0001530321,
0.0385519601,
0.0153329168,
0.0151035143,
0.019348409,
0.0612941161,
-0.0123511525,
0.0489591211,
-0.001932899,
-0.019401798,
-0.0122154038,
0.0396447629,
0.0341942087,
0.0030731056,
-0.0438565463,
0.0173458904,
-0.0165940505,
0.0409384407,
-0.0691973716,
0.0071836766,
0.0661646724,
0.0362780504,
-0.018224109,
0.021417344,
0.0282424092,
-0.0067814789,
0.0287741963,
-0.0566480458,
0.0178582575,
0.0128051024,
-0.0035949536,
0.0043703243,
-0.0084342808,
0.0402991511,
0.0061828932,
-0.0261242762,
-0.0333774351,
0.0702963546,
0.0027160249,
0.0019178566,
-0.0059575732,
-0.0522430316,
-0.0105268713,
-0.0513517447,
0.0035197316,
-0.0604446754,
0.0253070146,
-0.0418044515,
0.0043286216,
-0.0383633636,
-0.0064919256,
-0.0235310923,
0.0197869353,
0.0058950214,
0.0158301704,
-0.0011061915,
0.0047596279,
-0.0177823324,
-0.029417159,
0.0015589212,
-0.0436352044,
0.0017291309,
-0.0336349346,
0.0218797177,
0.0303597264,
-0.0575775243,
0.0049797869,
2.030379964e-34,
0.0129676266,
0.0161907654,
0.0175789613,
0.0308758691,
0.0279495064,
0.0217525251,
0.0204810668,
0.0456390902,
0.0340355746,
-0.0497687496,
-0.0395182073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17369v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17369v2 | Language and Mental Health: Measures of Emotion Dynamics from Text as Linguistic Biosocial Markers | 2023-10-26T13:00:26 | 2023-11-04T17:19:29 | Daniela Teodorescu, Tiffany Cheng, Alona Fyshe, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research in psychopathology has shown that, at an aggregate level, the
patterns of emotional change over time -- emotion dynamics -- are indicators of
one's mental health. One's patterns of emotion change have traditionally been
determined through self-reports of emotions; however, there are known issues
with accuracy, bias, and ease of data collection. Recent approaches to
determining emotion dynamics from one's everyday utterances addresses many of
these concerns, but it is not yet known whether these measures of utterance
emotion dynamics (UED) correlate with mental health diagnoses. Here, for the
first time, we study the relationship between tweet emotion dynamics and mental
health disorders. We find that each of the UED metrics studied varied by the
user's self-disclosed diagnosis. For example: average valence was significantly
higher (i.e., more positive text) in the control group compared to users with
ADHD, MDD, and PTSD. Valence variability was significantly lower in the control
group compared to ADHD, depression, bipolar disorder, MDD, PTSD, and OCD but
not PPD. Rise and recovery rates of valence also exhibited significant
differences from the control. This work provides important early evidence for
how linguistic cues pertaining to emotion dynamics can play a crucial role as
biosocial markers for mental illnesses and aid in the understanding, diagnosis,
and management of mental health disorders. | [
0.0242652018,
0.0722495764,
-0.0467503034,
-0.0534709916,
-0.0074878125,
0.0089456271,
-0.0052193925,
0.0275166593,
0.0638893098,
-0.0085327458,
0.0078993114,
-0.0211606473,
-0.0132845882,
0.0219521523,
-0.0177256055,
-0.0592959896,
-0.0222442113,
0.0541495495,
0.0875942409,
0.0176593885,
0.0264423359,
0.0402306914,
-0.0186860301,
0.0066456529,
-0.0161486492,
-0.0136614377,
0.0319002979,
0.0016646372,
0.063120231,
-0.0554960594,
0.0160103329,
0.0410681367,
-0.0248634908,
-0.0104207443,
0.0000018394,
-0.0132138897,
-0.0335481353,
-0.037505541,
0.0624425858,
-0.0116752265,
0.0966169536,
-0.039149344,
-0.0020235714,
0.0038041419,
-0.0138321156,
-0.0148280775,
0.0281985085,
0.053956572,
0.0360081345,
0.0360899679,
-0.0389533974,
0.0289100073,
-0.0306170825,
-0.0090316916,
-0.0043505258,
0.0467439517,
0.0323146097,
-0.0222238619,
-0.0103845876,
-0.0687741414,
-0.0195756033,
0.0407492854,
-0.0467239544,
0.0507972576,
-0.0439947471,
0.008495152,
-0.0113580162,
-0.0252875015,
0.0323913433,
0.0521291867,
0.0500336327,
0.009658182,
0.0497841164,
0.0051118592,
0.0238466784,
0.0200044829,
0.0009615967,
-0.0071530202,
-0.0030504612,
-0.0105588241,
0.0098853968,
0.0331014059,
-0.0244605355,
0.0032121837,
0.0030376473,
0.0685954839,
-0.0195479114,
-0.046074979,
0.0090832477,
-0.0202184822,
-0.0041146483,
-0.0619022287,
0.036776498,
-0.0059406087,
-0.0019903195,
0.0204913486,
-0.0333119407,
-0.1045520306,
0.0005502334,
-0.0578644983,
-0.0548511893,
0.0192900486,
-0.0640581474,
-0.0376494676,
0.0817964152,
0.0045548594,
0.0064752391,
0.00076745,
-0.0153317284,
0.0303824097,
-0.0489414632,
0.0165549014,
0.0118857902,
-0.010739034,
0.028969733,
-0.0272067245,
-0.1025547683,
-0.0008594922,
-0.0305509716,
-0.0634282529,
-0.0585126355,
-0.0207015704,
0.0260700434,
0.0217546076,
0.0199689865,
0.01992785,
-0.0352142975,
-0.0144228041,
-0.0104946028,
-0.0188723262,
0.0536150709,
-0.0192359388,
0.0156523511,
-0.0317054428,
0.031338837,
0.0139136864,
0.0157641862,
-0.0310266074,
0.0016192257,
-0.0129287476,
-0.0646641552,
-0.0239356589,
-0.023642635,
-0.0209934879,
0.0346356034,
0.0601389147,
0.0094239134,
-0.0260704271,
0.0243134927,
-0.010308505,
-0.0481557325,
0.0012059567,
-0.0616645105,
0.0292834714,
-0.020832533,
0.0154964719,
0.0412187949,
0.007361365,
0.0402229317,
0.0321889669,
0.0548522919,
-0.0333979018,
0.0212750528,
0.0049288855,
-0.0056366944,
-0.0180670414,
-0.021189576,
-0.037911728,
-0.023625331,
-0.0095901582,
-0.0208285097,
0.0134784942,
-0.009810742,
0.0529899001,
0.0494135469,
0.0827235878,
0.0156104295,
0.0280575082,
-0.0558818765,
0.0220604241,
0.0139899924,
-0.0185928252,
0.0015687959,
-0.0259259697,
-0.0229780748,
-0.022802759,
0.030369794,
0.0099305678,
-0.0162048619,
-0.0290463008,
-0.0396602489,
-0.0089658201,
0.020598812,
0.0084788296,
-0.0240909513,
-0.0401025787,
0.0293863658,
0.0409729034,
0.0570891574,
-0.0534636267,
-0.0208995659,
-0.0128595987,
-0.0073246355,
0.0901271477,
-0.0100394404,
-0.0102657555,
-0.0037163312,
-0.0137675265,
0.0230302997,
0.0266194232,
-0.0367697254,
0.0500237569,
0.0098665804,
0.0135432985,
0.053926222,
0.0148818502,
0.0219703782,
-0.0156198926,
-0.0206039567,
0.0737124681,
-0.0514344797,
-0.0127598075,
-0.0117479973,
0.0055932407,
-0.0139726168,
-0.0283189733,
0.0172825139,
-0.0029322761,
0.0307308435,
0.0240567718,
-0.0266305432,
-0.0225738902,
-0.0102317249,
0.0109886695,
-0.0534109399,
0.0723110288,
0.0076983185,
0.0297738798,
0.0007559084,
0.0295973942,
-0.0230778567,
-0.0107032731,
-0.0091591123,
0.0043108021,
0.0820725635,
-0.0509732813,
0.0226630475,
0.0328492112,
-0.0262408201,
-0.0347318798,
0.062429443,
0.0079011694,
0.0074878871,
-0.0256220885,
0.018758161,
-0.0498067103,
-0.0803956389,
-0.0175804887,
0.0179489534,
-0.0485460572,
-0.0084012253,
-0.0119359223,
-0.0004968293,
-0.0295600574,
-0.0288382433,
-0.0575871915,
-0.0407665893,
-0.1188742816,
0.0134270377,
0.0022799929,
-0.0049937903,
0.0167559572,
0.004251692,
-0.0415425338,
0.0207119752,
-0.0034722756,
0.0061996193,
0.0473329872,
0.058680594,
-0.0094519397,
-0.0115943225,
0.0173286404,
-0.0787631869,
-0.011644871,
-0.0771199614,
0.0163451228,
-0.0001994153,
-0.0426642001,
0.0136750378,
-0.0271916501,
-0.097612828,
-0.0262802914,
-0.0048173475,
-0.0644035786,
0.0114864176,
0.0095274802,
0.0613101311,
0.0345208682,
0.0429522023,
0.0922269151,
0.0235793646,
-0.0424668342,
-0.0206258595,
0.007169981,
-0.017295735,
0.0064223791,
-0.0166309029,
-0.059887778,
0.0172972102,
0.0492807925,
0.0347042158,
0.0267147291,
-0.0399965383,
-0.0332445838,
-0.0032853375,
-0.0031145297,
-0.0022289448,
-0.0166712012,
-0.0166063216,
0.0173198972,
0.0212436151,
-0.0547153316,
0.0280880108,
0.0499575697,
-0.0015877525,
-0.0373227857,
-0.0334655195,
-0.0026811548,
0.0394493937,
-0.0092249364,
0.0080841752,
0.0796988681,
0.002455716,
0.0459585972,
-0.0559657402,
-0.042834416,
-0.0534746088,
0.0346521288,
-0.0289115012,
-0.0294445679,
0.0407960787,
-0.0104879718,
0.0003277184,
-0.0286774002,
-0.0692129359,
-0.0471655391,
-0.0248605665,
-0.0428449064,
-0.0203669779,
-0.0473937131,
0.059372019,
-0.0433033518,
-0.0209275316,
-0.0318933316,
0.0344790034,
0.0180669297,
0.0566209368,
-0.0252537262,
0.002266221,
-0.0308446884,
-0.0126396539,
0.034830723,
0.0019592843,
0.0325192623,
0.0197386146,
0.000964597,
-0.0179700274,
0.016501205,
0.0197494831,
-0.0025147838,
0.0118369218,
0.0025130298,
-0.0039012539,
0.0894125551,
0.0014410348,
-0.0053753369,
0.0272983778,
-0.0167579427,
0.0041018892,
0.0015457913,
-0.016154699,
-0.0318648033,
0.0011892245,
-0.0304645095,
0.0140855834,
-0.0243988056,
-0.0145429112,
-0.0095037678,
-0.0062011997,
-0.0195268225,
-0.0036147975,
0.0054539517,
0.0299227759,
-0.013532185,
0.043539118,
0.0301420726,
-0.0291808229,
-0.0532406755,
0.0151994554,
0.009769178,
0.0093896035,
-0.072718367,
-0.0333743058,
0.0360109322,
0.0162564144,
0.0297505669,
0.0026815427,
0.1159480885,
-0.0076085236,
-0.0420964248,
0.0010445291,
0.0500718579,
-0.002083454,
0.0094329016,
0.0684031695,
0.0229218472,
0.0221472178,
-0.0782741085,
0.030583268,
-0.0476759449,
0.0110387094,
-0.0261547267,
0.0692347437,
0.0185937267,
-0.0637213886,
-0.0149139678,
0.036133375,
0.0298904944,
0.0115822209,
0.0059256256,
-0.0833656862,
0.0034397352,
0.0233477354,
0.0627319068,
-0.0102381269,
-0.0715749785,
-0.0386945494,
-0.0145560121,
-0.0465686321,
-0.0744668841,
-0.040186543,
0.0043243282,
-0.0253923871,
-0.0142130861,
-0.0403886437,
0.0168911312,
-0.0133252805,
-0.0421731919,
0.0421796888,
0.0683422014,
0.0272069406,
0.0068954052,
0.0040159291,
0.0233646668,
0.0265001785,
0.0033551042,
0.0314825587,
-0.0368697867,
-0.0220956691,
0.0856446922,
-0.0352828093,
0.0048664622,
-0.0177273508,
0.0318877101,
-0.0280649569,
0.0006228896,
0.0509896614,
-0.0248560142,
0.0199991167,
-0.0127467467,
0.0727413595,
0.0102131795,
0.0065389834,
0.0062878421,
0.015417668,
0.0452519283,
-0.0394012593,
-0.0025410312,
-0.0288609844,
-0.0125605073,
-0.005359388,
0.0427708738,
-0.0227519795,
-0.0788572133,
0.0166394487,
-0.0763984397,
-0.0006718914,
-0.0116107818,
0.0008487529,
-0.0594153106,
0.0158087499,
0.0138879111,
-0.0903010443,
-0.0151573401,
-0.030930981,
0.0120828049,
-0.0195474438,
0.0009893302,
-0.0152486218,
0.009418983,
-0.0214836989,
0.0083197104,
0.0177502874,
0.0040249969,
-0.0306399371,
0.0019819068,
-0.0194400121,
0.0566986687,
-0.002100795,
-0.033708144,
0.0427652337,
0.035892617,
-0.0250140429,
-0.0319636241,
0.017817704,
-0.053667333,
-0.0001365402,
0.0078171482,
0.090847455,
-0.0406630225,
0.0123229912,
-0.0344205946,
-0.0310370624,
-0.0579009131,
-0.041970484,
0.0085277166,
-0.0122081414,
-0.0241034329,
0.0043024882,
0.003052887,
-0.0560048074,
0.0189252999,
0.0438211262,
-0.015526386,
-0.0212438572,
0.0223410651,
-0.016748827,
-0.0055306512,
-0.0273950193,
0.0350958109,
-0.0732085928,
-0.0439085439,
0.1164417118,
-0.0674250796,
0.017773062,
-0.0405535586,
-0.0062202816,
0.0525673479,
-0.0041341074,
0.0093758479,
-0.0291111488,
0.0586227886,
-0.0380119458,
-0.0332043841,
-0.0495596565,
-5.052741979e-33,
0.0226945821,
-0.0185945369,
-0.035801623,
-0.0004576157,
-0.0333301947,
0.0084271291,
-0.0122630168,
0.0570813753,
0.0235064421,
0.0516423546,
-0.0108162956,
0.0768886283,
-0.0004859518,
0.0416630395,
0.0235292763,
0.0068764463,
-0.0018197759,
-0.014819297,
-0.015900081,
0.0271032862,
0.0307196155,
0.0359195843,
0.0518171489,
-0.1333188117,
0.0275474302,
0.0579023547,
-0.0033398184,
-0.0249404758,
0.0686642975,
-0.008629634,
-0.0358182117,
0.0984198675,
0.0423258469,
0.0613454916,
0.0113051934,
0.0374610163,
0.0153074171,
-0.0519648306,
0.0012006016,
-0.0172023233,
-0.0247653872,
0.0012341904,
0.0136694862,
0.0040281364,
-0.0331790745,
-0.0332628563,
0.0358113982,
-0.0059256945,
0.0823032483,
-0.0532449186,
-0.0081674783,
0.0147171328,
0.0028618781,
-0.0016240166,
-0.0192199927,
0.0518242195,
-0.0097879963,
0.0232043993,
-0.0415818095,
0.0040931264,
-0.012756397,
0.0108989971,
-0.0326889865,
-0.0443635955,
0.0111605152,
0.0685477257,
0.0340389274,
0.0388154462,
-0.0148101533,
0.0648958236,
0.011116894,
0.0200905502,
0.0272868555,
0.0274793468,
0.0034942157,
-0.0489490926,
0.0193981808,
-0.0139188748,
-0.0000564533,
-0.026562456,
0.0395106934,
-0.0006101866,
0.0164056402,
-0.005035365,
0.012739717,
0.0188903417,
-0.014718785,
-0.0193843804,
-0.0135609163,
-0.0366793051,
0.0097351884,
-0.0596526712,
-0.0011094625,
0.0138501665,
-0.0512387417,
0.0194945578,
-0.0459389687,
0.0662643239,
0.0327827968,
0.0157754198,
0.006272627,
0.0115028135,
-0.005123795,
0.0634291992,
0.0767732114,
-0.0163080804,
0.00937571,
-0.0095734671,
-0.0590471253,
0.0000379634,
0.0310470946,
0.0537612624,
-0.0194997713,
-0.0149567463,
-0.0318516083,
0.0324889645,
-0.0088176932,
-0.0159356538,
0.0730652139,
0.014891102,
-0.0410091616,
0.0013676072,
-0.0280615799,
0.0205985159,
0.0030251485,
-0.0231383052,
-0.0223530922,
-0.0009794364,
0.0149787199,
-0.0513509549,
0.0055718184,
-0.0246264767,
2.652e-7,
0.0099499431,
0.1191916764,
0.0008234425,
-0.0034369514,
0.0393920876,
0.0330195166,
0.0033248891,
0.0109590935,
0.068167232,
-0.0099397358,
-0.0417194963,
-0.0038422784,
0.0522628315,
0.048493281,
0.0212544762,
-0.0112156915,
-0.036192175,
-0.0035346325,
-0.0522732548,
-0.0079254257,
0.0765636414,
0.015410048,
0.018923521,
-0.0116749462,
0.0035037799,
0.0273036063,
0.044553332,
-0.033267837,
0.0161860045,
0.0594779961,
-0.0068444661,
-0.0486356542,
0.0157147497,
-0.0273546465,
0.0004904597,
-0.0307737682,
-0.0170360506,
0.0084939552,
0.0052605313,
0.0029745877,
0.0101922611,
0.0229067095,
-0.0293010958,
0.000690753,
0.026322037,
-0.0533108078,
-0.0477413908,
-0.0173945613,
-0.0126144439,
-0.0388537534,
0.0665531829,
-0.0198321827,
-0.0740625039,
0.0675062016,
0.0214254614,
0.027452793,
0.0084424699,
-0.0853275508,
-0.0198352393,
0.0253466032,
-0.0366170853,
0.0024431031,
-0.0171524454,
0.0527406521,
-0.0059748301,
-0.0579259992,
0.056656044,
1.59345388e-34,
-0.0029537375,
0.0341530815,
-0.0013162398,
-0.0083704153,
0.0370792784,
0.0118153933,
-0.0341586471,
0.0100883758,
0.0114217149,
-0.0526723117,
0.0103054373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17353v1 | Cultural Adaptation of Recipes | 2023-10-26T12:39:20 | 2023-10-26T12:39:20 | Yong Cao, Yova Kementchedjhieva, Ruixiang Cui, Antonia Karamolegkou, Li Zhou, Megan Dare, Lucia Donatelli, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Building upon the considerable advances in Large Language Models (LLMs), we
are now equipped to address more sophisticated tasks demanding a nuanced
understanding of cross-cultural contexts. A key example is recipe adaptation,
which goes beyond simple translation to include a grasp of ingredients,
culinary techniques, and dietary preferences specific to a given culture. We
introduce a new task involving the translation and cultural adaptation of
recipes between Chinese and English-speaking cuisines. To support this
investigation, we present CulturalRecipes, a unique dataset comprised of
automatically paired recipes written in Mandarin Chinese and English. This
dataset is further enriched with a human-written and curated test set. In this
intricate task of cross-cultural recipe adaptation, we evaluate the performance
of various methods, including GPT-4 and other LLMs, traditional machine
translation, and information retrieval techniques. Our comprehensive analysis
includes both automatic and human evaluation metrics. While GPT-4 exhibits
impressive abilities in adapting Chinese recipes into English, it still lags
behind human expertise when translating English recipes into Chinese. This
underscores the multifaceted nature of cultural adaptations. We anticipate that
these insights will significantly contribute to future research on
culturally-aware language models and their practical application in culturally
diverse contexts. | [
0.0434044488,
0.0834542066,
-0.0250230227,
0.0069686524,
-0.0161071848,
0.0445949286,
-0.0241891537,
0.0405147299,
0.0018222505,
0.0024856804,
-0.05712929,
-0.0478318222,
0.0017432732,
0.0112998877,
-0.0200783852,
-0.0452191904,
0.0292809568,
0.0151829794,
-0.01591116,
0.0098942472,
-0.0079803439,
0.0177368093,
0.02915374,
0.0144453617,
0.0098797642,
0.0127008827,
0.0288367253,
0.0291627236,
0.0361536294,
-0.0263365209,
0.0144576514,
0.0436222292,
-0.0053901793,
0.0169706792,
0.0000018359,
-0.0028116545,
-0.0249192212,
-0.0139387269,
0.0150353462,
0.0608102344,
0.0533043668,
-0.0236442927,
-0.0275241695,
-0.0094451224,
-0.0399125628,
-0.005982704,
0.0492683873,
0.0457917154,
0.0004636253,
0.0839768499,
-0.001820108,
-0.0953980014,
-0.0591902323,
-0.0326904617,
0.0074509196,
-0.0015617439,
0.0172954462,
0.0029254109,
-0.0035688595,
-0.0022646629,
-0.0237315018,
0.0265032053,
-0.0000154375,
0.0354188494,
-0.0841348171,
0.0383278765,
-0.0417398997,
-0.0208997261,
0.0215019006,
0.068827346,
0.0133208502,
-0.0127585726,
0.0059290067,
0.0034868137,
-0.0508441366,
0.0064880126,
-0.0197029803,
-0.0624706857,
-0.0173472445,
0.0413174853,
0.0128438678,
-0.0265454557,
0.0523442291,
0.0163501445,
0.0361733213,
0.087000899,
0.0338059328,
-0.0134086134,
-0.0543599129,
0.0101014674,
0.0011736329,
-0.0464968942,
0.043095205,
0.0193297565,
0.0250897333,
0.0258379914,
0.0264029186,
0.0372874141,
-0.0069338321,
-0.0108871534,
0.0267189778,
0.0740870461,
-0.0376266278,
0.0183424149,
-0.0202042311,
0.0519287996,
-0.0259540081,
-0.0186965875,
-0.1000251621,
-0.0096670343,
-0.085212186,
0.0106170913,
0.0116780791,
-0.0306146666,
-0.0376317613,
-0.0012524754,
-0.028375458,
-0.0045828745,
-0.0048478427,
-0.016156394,
0.0256604757,
0.0108209653,
-0.0384935588,
0.0045588175,
-0.0418261439,
0.0688126683,
-0.0227979906,
-0.0024241321,
-0.035019096,
-0.0004577466,
-0.0066144136,
-0.0339464061,
0.0008516461,
0.0134777538,
0.0238384046,
0.027861705,
-0.0268569849,
-0.0164631307,
-0.0274066832,
0.0348310098,
-0.0455382876,
-0.0463734195,
0.0138685573,
-0.0786108524,
0.0664136335,
0.0008032167,
0.061380595,
-0.0602062754,
0.0089323856,
0.0346983634,
-0.0479552224,
0.0559906848,
0.0920293331,
0.0330194607,
0.0443782434,
0.008423117,
-0.0342583843,
0.0351381153,
0.0375821851,
0.0095269717,
0.0373030081,
-0.0086739957,
-0.0206208937,
0.0017134321,
-0.0238750726,
0.0689313933,
-0.0647681653,
0.0353053324,
0.044665169,
0.015955817,
-0.0156649221,
0.0749884918,
0.0071768556,
0.0124809183,
0.0916700214,
0.051697541,
0.0103913816,
0.079603523,
0.0593253188,
0.0063713621,
-0.00568503,
0.0231880341,
-0.0050770268,
0.0217676926,
-0.0813749284,
-0.0273497328,
0.0255269576,
0.0428124592,
-0.0354927592,
-0.0393962786,
-0.0068295645,
0.0075152013,
0.0700911507,
0.0003930981,
0.0425635837,
-0.0276594833,
-0.0102710426,
-0.0191781241,
0.0184828751,
-0.0594049245,
0.0186478216,
0.0147674344,
0.0631546453,
0.0995343104,
0.0326906145,
-0.0089917192,
0.0479579419,
0.0333343595,
0.0241759308,
-0.0057267467,
0.0400245376,
0.0027700814,
0.010221472,
-0.0209790543,
-0.0290782936,
0.0075816629,
0.0197573695,
-0.0170625336,
0.0538335331,
0.0505721755,
0.0282392967,
-0.0170298424,
-0.0447346754,
-0.0108624771,
-0.0618905611,
-0.0108001754,
0.0409356728,
-0.0311765615,
-0.0185295753,
0.0579365976,
-0.0048663239,
0.0120768063,
-0.0378292575,
-0.0508974157,
-0.02172371,
0.0560948327,
0.0065508583,
-0.0069119628,
0.014700314,
-0.0609410591,
0.0063556517,
-0.0208497141,
-0.0359446444,
-0.0509337857,
0.0144347018,
0.0149652259,
-0.0092580458,
-0.0462054536,
-0.0059398236,
0.0167486016,
0.0409488752,
-0.002179059,
0.0495441221,
0.0040801,
0.0074403766,
-0.0520884395,
-0.0064252075,
-0.0181626584,
-0.0316464268,
-0.0127166938,
0.0093162954,
0.0416139551,
0.0311933886,
0.0271289516,
0.0463423803,
-0.0434802435,
-0.0408703126,
-0.0859651044,
0.0221199635,
-0.0323262624,
0.0074519124,
0.0068552797,
0.0233362187,
-0.019649107,
0.0066644042,
-0.0450614318,
-0.0131657496,
-0.0401891805,
0.0317683779,
-0.0262925606,
-0.0148184234,
0.0209181271,
-0.0220955499,
-0.0216948427,
0.0342345908,
0.0157624204,
-0.0338799097,
0.0025016074,
-0.0598613173,
-0.0668559372,
-0.0677695125,
-0.018277213,
0.0119142989,
-0.0453727879,
-0.0450576246,
0.0108505543,
0.0437829569,
0.0312390737,
-0.0112875188,
-0.0104151079,
0.0723973811,
-0.0220696405,
-0.0324527398,
-0.0060934159,
-0.0161046628,
0.0077621755,
0.0073077814,
-0.0939691141,
-0.0203558933,
0.0039326213,
0.007684025,
0.0243360251,
-0.0710305721,
-0.0030645614,
-0.0401448086,
-0.0289815944,
-0.0199052114,
0.0440456159,
0.0047292714,
0.0471346378,
-0.0127247758,
-0.0306298304,
0.0646650195,
-0.0317825563,
0.0319830589,
-0.0471521169,
-0.0205713771,
-0.0370265394,
0.0321737826,
-0.004994113,
0.0356302224,
-0.0351818651,
0.0257157311,
-0.0329551697,
0.0063310983,
0.0204812903,
-0.0827439725,
0.0899552032,
-0.0620335676,
-0.0384683087,
-0.0171939358,
-0.0052999463,
-0.0140924389,
0.0165950991,
-0.0311465766,
0.0162096135,
0.0204783957,
0.0081247874,
-0.0079492666,
0.0385650396,
0.0142205153,
0.0342444219,
0.0227350853,
0.0066934149,
0.0142291067,
-0.0152863842,
0.0250229407,
-0.0016316734,
-0.0467761867,
-0.0198220126,
0.0171515774,
-0.0127546452,
0.02980032,
-0.0357768871,
0.0160219483,
0.0488468781,
0.0467405245,
0.0045374073,
-0.0322665088,
-0.0064995852,
0.0283202957,
-0.0118068242,
-0.0146863963,
0.0824608058,
0.036993172,
-0.0823536217,
0.0110583697,
0.0002986859,
-0.0149519891,
0.0120994607,
0.0629650429,
-0.1169710159,
0.0201863218,
0.0021325478,
0.0156923514,
-0.0198942907,
0.0006738986,
-0.037927404,
-0.0917739496,
0.0113099236,
0.0310536418,
-0.0840038881,
-0.0719260201,
-0.0262020193,
-0.0043023457,
-0.037900202,
0.0226870738,
-0.028852189,
-0.0128861731,
0.0101073338,
-0.003523055,
-0.0182395056,
-0.0581695512,
0.0396090597,
-0.0679391846,
0.0500334948,
0.0781862736,
0.0340385251,
0.0026060976,
-0.0294225551,
-0.0239022709,
-0.0097714029,
0.0128686456,
-0.0076251258,
0.004244647,
0.0132041899,
-0.0131088588,
0.028922189,
-0.0049213404,
-0.0281156991,
-0.0252696201,
0.0225032456,
0.0247727241,
0.0103963176,
-0.0045647486,
0.0032151975,
-0.0128072882,
0.0308153983,
0.0635024831,
0.0093927076,
-0.0260703713,
-0.012114075,
-0.033185862,
-0.0970680118,
-0.0263089128,
-0.0121532334,
0.0876189694,
-0.0847335085,
-0.0338907503,
-0.0717122629,
0.003032865,
-0.025189627,
0.0101377107,
0.0407943167,
-0.0002285669,
-0.0151934763,
0.0617333278,
-0.006971179,
0.0254844297,
-0.037648268,
0.0059016631,
-0.0499180481,
-0.0452417582,
0.043909017,
-0.0487648584,
0.0161453169,
0.0012100904,
-0.0787534267,
-0.051773686,
-0.0134861609,
0.047628358,
0.0093554566,
0.0516568571,
0.0167266317,
-0.0404436998,
0.0132326931,
-0.0024607496,
0.0300669782,
-0.0263899881,
-0.0074983439,
-0.0027961903,
0.0100077074,
0.0330541581,
-0.0432460643,
0.0575130619,
0.0008398777,
0.073540397,
-0.0079447497,
-0.0553355105,
0.046028845,
-0.0134785781,
-0.0060572652,
-0.0317933224,
-0.0272389278,
-0.0354046933,
0.0130432071,
-0.0283554103,
-0.0167158749,
-0.0309537202,
-0.0388000086,
0.0818637162,
-0.0151775423,
-0.0279222894,
-0.0312495623,
0.0007791356,
0.0132453982,
-0.0783339888,
0.0054000444,
0.0017650174,
0.0334936492,
-0.0099423276,
0.0211634152,
-0.0068264864,
0.0447976328,
-0.023311466,
0.00354418,
-0.0499717742,
0.0768388584,
-0.013720151,
0.0226247814,
-0.0241881143,
0.0332427993,
-0.0258676056,
-0.0124275731,
0.0079901675,
-0.0331711546,
0.0989543572,
-0.0801852718,
0.0764049217,
-0.0069467304,
-0.0247182399,
-0.0662141442,
0.0483196862,
0.0062593175,
-0.0026856095,
0.0208130777,
0.0048223254,
0.0109109795,
0.0190446451,
0.090492934,
-0.0351826772,
0.030860791,
0.0300098322,
-0.0164253712,
0.0196367167,
-0.0032606998,
0.0144650638,
-0.0226960815,
-0.0449228846,
-0.0409672447,
-0.0287425015,
-0.0441841818,
0.003714303,
-0.0039777262,
0.0128405029,
-0.024511205,
-0.0107332766,
0.0761196762,
-0.023143908,
0.0179777015,
-0.0358379818,
-0.0059510968,
-0.0225416105,
-0.0076322085,
0.0222081915,
-6.37679751e-33,
-0.0101906005,
-0.0263818223,
0.0106215198,
0.0229555741,
0.0043475628,
-0.0169304479,
-0.048989065,
-0.0229343958,
0.017520126,
-0.002408263,
0.0135221574,
0.0136411395,
0.0237938389,
-0.0273065548,
0.0182174481,
-0.0247119479,
0.0225391053,
0.0430748053,
-0.0104098152,
0.00430146,
0.0168092325,
0.0229658373,
0.0265014768,
-0.0601186454,
0.0060972292,
-0.0050198506,
0.0177783761,
-0.0205018148,
0.0208163615,
0.0552939326,
-0.043142233,
0.048612494,
0.0332674459,
0.0055047604,
0.0044163633,
-0.0349778906,
-0.0715309829,
-0.0086283516,
-0.0196572188,
-0.0193411466,
0.0192426201,
-0.06808801,
0.0160811804,
0.0069214958,
-0.0136087202,
0.0466576032,
0.0343292058,
-0.0599045381,
-0.0217961259,
0.008325615,
-0.0409437604,
0.0392971486,
0.0219677147,
0.0365227722,
0.0372404754,
0.0538272113,
0.0150309941,
-0.0126769291,
-0.0335392319,
0.0307513177,
0.0003489586,
0.0310970917,
0.0663137361,
0.0165321603,
-0.0070469235,
-0.0004455182,
0.0109189553,
0.0040200832,
0.0165703017,
-0.0342975669,
0.0154455667,
0.0203466378,
0.0262815803,
0.063882716,
-0.0082584517,
-0.0531767048,
-0.0048548719,
0.0213601999,
0.0259899627,
-0.0775236189,
-0.0265104808,
0.0406509899,
0.0209412612,
0.0018794256,
-0.0045215464,
-0.0039258813,
-0.0342814773,
-0.0457650274,
0.0073488536,
0.0328567959,
-0.0326533169,
-0.0016486202,
0.0310476236,
0.0083299503,
0.0308286957,
-0.0171401463,
-0.0076358616,
-0.0580307804,
-0.0062425518,
0.0331190377,
-0.0724213868,
-0.0844921097,
-0.0036017122,
0.0013160695,
-0.0045574605,
-0.0129851652,
0.0003789394,
0.0495225042,
-0.0415930413,
-0.0064484156,
-0.0243846998,
-0.0453359969,
-0.0077604661,
-0.0029299329,
0.0086277388,
0.0119873388,
0.0193721093,
0.021035092,
0.0479027182,
-0.0074769752,
-0.018818954,
-0.0423259698,
0.0341625884,
-0.0194221959,
-0.0345739797,
0.0291636959,
0.0066473675,
-0.0071627656,
0.0292140637,
-0.0185375027,
-0.0191966575,
-0.0002839934,
2.683e-7,
0.0623086207,
0.0255653616,
-0.021051513,
0.0134804565,
-0.0007162038,
-0.0226346236,
-0.0257634576,
0.0586530454,
-0.0047029452,
0.0314087346,
0.0744037032,
0.0199239254,
0.0607947484,
0.0667773858,
-0.0215734579,
0.0010562036,
-0.0643614829,
0.0454401113,
-0.043317724,
-0.0019816984,
0.0091891829,
0.0514432266,
0.0219129995,
0.0214126892,
-0.0516377687,
-0.0057031051,
0.0659121647,
-0.0883286521,
0.006090682,
-0.0136087276,
0.0061409534,
0.0189237557,
-0.0067933872,
-0.0261356663,
-0.0347644947,
-0.0167396683,
0.0876481086,
0.0630076528,
-0.0162698217,
-0.0097120656,
-0.0077220746,
0.0101895314,
-0.008250474,
-0.099068366,
0.0499999076,
-0.0244992916,
0.0078843227,
0.0643413365,
-0.002156599,
0.0109544452,
0.0259090047,
0.0108585637,
0.0248914231,
0.0311280079,
0.0349094011,
0.038724754,
-0.0086066956,
-0.0258937757,
-0.028875187,
-0.0031808142,
0.0028368374,
-0.026070755,
-0.0002515348,
-0.0210032854,
-0.085851796,
0.0025780601,
-0.0116124973,
1.939174e-34,
0.0181802679,
0.0106811337,
-0.0353516005,
-0.0349943005,
0.046718996,
-0.0118046245,
-0.0268959664,
-0.0001024722,
-0.0191046298,
-0.0656739697,
-0.0329601057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17342v1 | ACT-SQL: In-Context Learning for Text-to-SQL with Automatically-Generated Chain-of-Thought | 2023-10-26T12:16:25 | 2023-10-26T12:16:25 | Hanchong Zhang, Ruisheng Cao, Lu Chen, Hongshen Xu, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently Large Language Models (LLMs) have been proven to have strong
abilities in various domains and tasks. We study the problem of prompt
designing in the text-to-SQL task and attempt to improve the LLMs' reasoning
ability when generating SQL queries. Besides the trivial few-shot in-context
learning setting, we design our chain-of-thought (CoT) prompt with a similar
method to schema linking. We provide a method named ACT-SQL to automatically
generate auto-CoT exemplars and thus the whole process doesn't need manual
labeling. Our approach is cost-saving since we only use the LLMs' API call once
when generating one SQL query. Furthermore, we extend our in-context learning
method to the multi-turn text-to-SQL task. The experiment results show that the
LLMs' performance can benefit from our ACT-SQL approach. Our approach achieves
SOTA performance on the Spider dev set among existing in-context learning
approaches. | [
0.0013779799,
0.0393201895,
-0.0261909552,
0.0078374529,
-0.0230896212,
0.0179081596,
0.0063498891,
-0.0191262681,
0.0453823172,
-0.0571197011,
-0.0275036041,
0.0058014928,
-0.0287476443,
0.0482922904,
0.0446641892,
-0.0307356194,
0.0166166369,
-0.027240362,
-0.0286530145,
0.0143569708,
-0.0360095948,
0.0103930579,
0.0000685445,
-0.0074477708,
-0.0100216419,
-0.0475593396,
-0.0322971754,
0.0190428216,
-0.0005104975,
-0.0383389629,
-0.02571062,
0.0477913134,
0.0004472845,
0.046908468,
0.0000022051,
-0.0693372712,
-0.0584788322,
0.0189083554,
-0.0742025599,
-0.0053499006,
-0.0000345643,
-0.0081936326,
0.0155803356,
0.0538830608,
-0.0516994745,
0.0121661173,
0.0350596234,
-0.0110119088,
0.0473400429,
0.0525898822,
-0.0105297109,
-0.0444701612,
0.0002051619,
-0.0102238329,
0.0226142667,
-0.0586408041,
-0.0290588289,
0.0100312876,
0.0563744083,
0.0218820926,
0.0010196433,
0.0475404449,
0.0093392618,
-0.0194583889,
0.0083376877,
0.0018728889,
-0.0344988219,
0.0149609605,
-0.0061323387,
0.05707087,
-0.0130256414,
-0.0281761661,
-0.0063356292,
0.0164448954,
-0.0037992338,
0.0041014631,
-0.0106266569,
0.0152987419,
0.0070990524,
-0.0118542714,
-0.0130673982,
-0.0057513225,
-0.0036041567,
-0.0286163967,
-0.0618902259,
0.0356925838,
-0.0070818495,
-0.0031846806,
0.0305599589,
-0.0317154154,
0.0031883509,
-0.0374596119,
0.0021001182,
0.0675864965,
-0.111924991,
0.0309025254,
-0.0136635834,
-0.0040489477,
0.0134067824,
-0.0269787274,
0.0339026712,
0.0631240457,
-0.0159474108,
0.0405246727,
-0.0438738428,
0.0142183797,
0.0322609432,
0.0165328495,
-0.0391911678,
-0.0363016017,
-0.0830847323,
0.0093365069,
-0.0732256621,
0.0477254428,
-0.0761383474,
-0.023270797,
-0.0176873878,
0.0592821687,
0.0171863772,
0.0631872118,
0.0093770977,
-0.0098877354,
-0.0058619478,
-0.0202352647,
-0.0486465618,
-0.0023410947,
0.0264951829,
-0.0181638654,
0.0040697278,
-0.0517622195,
-0.0251062121,
-0.0158463176,
-0.0185660534,
-0.016070392,
0.0091760028,
0.0970882326,
-0.0232976247,
-0.0016987247,
-0.1057741642,
-0.0681484416,
0.0321220756,
-0.018564824,
-0.0475564674,
-0.050427679,
0.0343932025,
0.0233249273,
-0.0244780593,
-0.0322936364,
-0.0125747295,
0.0363147482,
0.0221327692,
0.076699093,
-0.0399136506,
0.0081959842,
0.0303723272,
0.0080889426,
-0.0182305779,
0.1023837477,
0.0059451805,
0.0603747293,
0.0101887621,
0.0189494696,
-0.0110648759,
0.0244725719,
0.0321419276,
0.0219720621,
-0.036666777,
0.051465217,
0.042301394,
0.0444872268,
-0.0127257835,
0.0563293472,
0.0149016688,
0.0279805232,
0.0301115233,
0.0030119671,
0.0603354834,
0.0104717771,
0.0616715178,
0.030028237,
-0.0137761608,
-0.0360820517,
-0.0432035141,
0.0331478976,
-0.0285796262,
0.0260048695,
0.0128448959,
0.0199916251,
-0.0303561557,
-0.0375760309,
0.0123911034,
-0.002451038,
-0.0732528567,
0.0339373462,
0.0013934051,
0.044724822,
-0.0364636108,
0.0454909988,
0.0059028044,
-0.0004628272,
-0.0213704519,
-0.0276611783,
-0.0145848598,
0.0594712757,
0.0277240984,
-0.0634363815,
-0.0216769073,
-0.0201038662,
0.0475528985,
0.0573991463,
0.0065339808,
-0.0473386087,
-0.038728442,
-0.0162675735,
-0.0155950943,
0.0393073075,
0.0153788636,
-0.0046750917,
-0.0042338055,
-0.0017736673,
0.0262560714,
-0.0097549474,
-0.0336442143,
0.024425013,
-0.0412750766,
-0.0422713943,
0.0305516087,
0.0414573699,
0.0006097459,
0.0128478073,
-0.0020018083,
0.0325007737,
0.0342791937,
-0.0092251776,
-0.0240794718,
-0.0349299386,
-0.0194633454,
-0.0448880866,
0.0112648727,
-0.0086218677,
-0.013184594,
-0.0971860439,
-0.0596713312,
-0.0452348329,
-0.0271306243,
-0.0318596214,
0.001823666,
-0.0179968495,
0.0298885591,
0.0195465628,
-0.0232440084,
-0.0609701052,
0.071282059,
0.0140477289,
-0.006576525,
0.0225221235,
0.0063396823,
0.0163050368,
-0.0388292521,
0.0423175693,
0.0027040942,
0.0028919403,
0.019813858,
-0.0381754041,
0.0317191705,
-0.0556898862,
-0.0114201317,
-0.0419194065,
0.005378569,
-0.0170997623,
0.0217865556,
0.0214320403,
0.0330643766,
-0.0124272089,
-0.0330900587,
-0.0532553755,
-0.0045521976,
-0.0430469587,
0.0185032263,
0.0271167718,
0.0083640777,
-0.021135252,
0.0048701116,
-0.010573538,
-0.0468387008,
0.0614181124,
-0.0380611978,
-0.0165542606,
-0.0375286452,
0.0406743586,
0.0131968213,
0.0206653532,
0.0008091771,
0.0314719491,
-0.0076806438,
-0.0085138436,
0.0359721482,
0.0435981564,
0.0065483069,
-0.0513316318,
0.0325887538,
0.0027863407,
-0.0447482951,
0.0124173146,
0.0084144641,
0.0065393252,
0.0252125505,
-0.0144501096,
0.0318000056,
0.0223404076,
-0.0173633583,
-0.0297216717,
-0.0239465199,
-0.0150310127,
0.0358074233,
0.0139114587,
-0.0506371669,
0.0004407979,
0.0236880723,
0.039423801,
0.0146114277,
-0.023027692,
0.0601630732,
-0.0390264504,
0.0153555255,
-0.0747574121,
-0.0015774567,
-0.0663912147,
0.0903690681,
0.0053742467,
0.0222919043,
-0.0202501565,
-0.0710397884,
-0.0616008416,
0.0017143408,
0.0133131668,
-0.0092825685,
0.0973929986,
-0.0361528806,
0.0138898296,
-0.0238315072,
-0.0203257147,
-0.0459050648,
0.0317580625,
-0.0594450198,
0.0402364694,
0.0242396034,
0.0146677336,
0.0209317897,
-0.0042780191,
0.0094872853,
0.0728789717,
0.0212244149,
-0.0350578092,
-0.0045186011,
-0.040141467,
0.0285526905,
0.0100089973,
-0.0095740277,
0.008104329,
0.0730396286,
0.0098313382,
0.0423608422,
-0.0780500621,
-0.0013046247,
-0.0057659606,
-0.0052879285,
-0.0431817509,
-0.0127397766,
0.0411866866,
-0.0343696028,
-0.046030663,
-0.0377019048,
0.0939035639,
0.0408060141,
-0.0225951765,
0.0082628811,
-0.0058847833,
0.0281511266,
0.0421654433,
0.0502218008,
-0.1336760819,
-0.0479575209,
-0.0176970754,
-0.000440579,
0.025839122,
-0.0366499163,
-0.0395709649,
-0.1421413124,
0.0198602844,
-0.0393608361,
-0.0477363989,
0.0086845839,
-0.002130724,
-0.0152101498,
0.0048904424,
-0.0024042279,
0.0729247183,
-0.0351679139,
-0.0004228337,
0.0109272758,
0.0364638679,
-0.0279567856,
0.0131138135,
-0.0451092049,
0.0047195978,
0.0173511915,
0.0053410963,
0.0562916473,
-0.0391359702,
0.0492123067,
-0.0121821882,
0.0132987266,
-0.037980143,
0.0649431273,
-0.0106845396,
0.0013669258,
0.0474282429,
0.015354149,
-0.0409332141,
0.013443877,
0.0187246278,
0.1170589775,
-0.0419801436,
0.0334216878,
-0.0190859269,
-0.0368576236,
0.0114070708,
0.041731298,
0.0011687808,
-0.0315871313,
-0.0350843407,
-0.0134415617,
-0.0379404053,
-0.0236643776,
-0.0038840622,
0.0435904451,
-0.0383690819,
-0.0419239216,
-0.0393943824,
-0.0114911748,
0.0542760678,
0.1020343825,
0.0385598615,
0.0473995991,
0.029449394,
0.0105185686,
-0.0314674377,
-0.0472502001,
-0.0611023828,
0.0157564282,
-0.0443301685,
-0.0137332762,
0.0562960654,
-0.0588252619,
-0.0162643325,
-0.0241252463,
-0.0461592972,
-0.0337870046,
-0.0018815546,
0.0043382961,
0.0295144916,
0.015341456,
-0.0173750501,
-0.0586643219,
0.0243554115,
0.0989310592,
-0.0620344616,
-0.0615202263,
-0.0004597149,
0.0431079455,
-0.0073450329,
0.0416475162,
-0.0556203797,
0.0010047521,
-0.0271351095,
0.0051533892,
-0.0169744641,
0.0131274713,
0.0490725674,
0.0406798907,
0.0098404745,
0.0200295318,
-0.0074661174,
-0.0117018428,
0.0733456686,
-0.0414015874,
-0.0486438759,
-0.0316937193,
0.0568555817,
-0.0072440235,
-0.0100329788,
0.0356013626,
-0.0278987885,
0.0164112877,
0.0541156158,
0.0262432043,
-0.0027089647,
0.0113266781,
0.0515250824,
0.0425341725,
-0.0340554006,
0.0081843454,
0.002807342,
0.0526792146,
0.0651639476,
-0.0200820398,
0.0427787565,
0.0602831393,
0.0110084116,
-0.0370300077,
0.0171730556,
-0.043392498,
-0.0618008971,
-0.0193295013,
-0.0033829208,
0.0293223448,
-0.0059205513,
0.0026341213,
-0.0206623971,
-0.0120267188,
-0.0025907781,
0.0255555883,
0.0422483236,
-0.0220930614,
0.0340890624,
0.0093756197,
-0.0147681395,
-0.032186348,
0.0747897699,
-0.0068264208,
-0.0042022523,
-0.0084436266,
-0.0483997762,
-0.0550776087,
-0.0257331356,
-0.0063059218,
-0.0297244973,
-0.021666415,
-0.0093090516,
-0.0673718229,
-0.0357176661,
0.0164062679,
0.0050365878,
-0.0013165425,
-0.0010327394,
0.065191932,
0.0841640234,
0.0838424861,
0.000455074,
-0.0071600052,
0.0122838197,
0.0078820745,
-0.0683550835,
-0.0086226482,
-6.075274393e-33,
-0.0340682641,
-0.0534426756,
0.0569638237,
0.0176279731,
0.0325813256,
-0.0299906284,
-0.0432822183,
-0.000327179,
-0.0335785449,
-0.005899589,
-0.0376306549,
0.0165727306,
0.0350155942,
0.0429241434,
0.0222971998,
-0.0456776246,
0.0259383321,
-0.0047170068,
0.0149149531,
0.0211127233,
0.0399275944,
0.0343424343,
0.0110240467,
-0.0368563086,
-0.0156317335,
0.0104120402,
0.008876048,
0.024899032,
0.004470455,
0.0229475442,
-0.0087972451,
0.0258276295,
0.0153705403,
-0.025973076,
-0.0043629934,
-0.029357193,
-0.0616529658,
-0.0417919941,
0.0096603874,
-0.0147268567,
-0.0171779804,
-0.0311593376,
0.0300468989,
-0.0363673344,
-0.0216497276,
-0.0177331232,
0.0176289808,
-0.0352931246,
-0.0417056531,
-0.0700467005,
-0.0677767098,
0.0161727555,
0.0448445007,
-0.0103725884,
0.0155389793,
0.0272622183,
0.0130178798,
0.022541916,
-0.0423712283,
0.0233930573,
-0.001958027,
0.0611729212,
0.0546685643,
0.0370815955,
-0.0020247027,
-0.0026866561,
0.0079443287,
0.0159261245,
-0.0204262696,
0.0708468109,
-0.004434885,
0.0448076278,
0.0266814027,
0.0238950495,
-0.0133844744,
-0.0210256595,
-0.0829885677,
0.0235908031,
-0.0207981057,
-0.0045029423,
0.0007878149,
0.0127071673,
-0.0480565913,
-0.0285249334,
-0.045078259,
0.0065842425,
-0.0386355072,
-0.0014207304,
0.0313895792,
-0.0043552429,
0.004367772,
-0.0124015007,
0.0196707901,
-0.0071501774,
-0.0517546944,
0.007623014,
-0.0345859304,
-0.0296676643,
0.0017893474,
0.026864443,
-0.0423111208,
-0.0343624875,
0.0059709395,
0.0403068103,
0.018785039,
0.0333249755,
0.0456119329,
0.0329576433,
-0.0888534412,
0.0322180353,
-0.0461445451,
0.0514723249,
-0.0183037091,
-0.0023136528,
0.0067662993,
-0.0139322076,
0.0195838157,
0.0566934198,
-0.0017700518,
-0.0469045825,
-0.0074185585,
0.045060806,
0.0054333624,
0.0213173144,
0.0021006332,
0.0229265634,
0.0054940414,
-0.0003960274,
0.0373330787,
-0.0538161136,
-0.0051307902,
0.0426506214,
2.909e-7,
0.0412051566,
0.0403353572,
0.0082734236,
0.0562846363,
0.0127640208,
0.0351700597,
0.0111257546,
-0.0053831809,
0.0282459036,
-0.0394584648,
0.0151055269,
-0.0139414901,
0.0395358577,
0.0420237854,
-0.1078881174,
0.0023595993,
-0.0201176181,
0.0091103762,
-0.0554529391,
-0.0032798857,
0.0635753423,
0.0885862708,
-0.0432567149,
-0.0108881248,
0.0241273642,
-0.0323859975,
-0.0091785667,
0.0098351892,
0.0156039512,
0.0542572252,
0.0085460786,
-0.0076996,
-0.0111848256,
0.0564953201,
-0.0320668481,
0.0120733185,
-0.0057208585,
0.028459277,
0.0188150704,
0.0026493578,
0.0271590929,
-0.0938643813,
0.0272027161,
-0.0264162738,
0.0642922521,
-0.0255956501,
-0.0032347625,
0.0667911991,
-0.0086088218,
-0.0228422135,
0.0048777442,
-0.0004438767,
0.0153301973,
-0.0219326001,
0.0255479608,
0.0084374715,
-0.0011573141,
-0.0577129498,
-0.0339713991,
0.0596072301,
-0.0141023034,
-0.0103326188,
-0.0151243852,
0.0116074523,
-0.0071869167,
-0.0404506251,
-0.0092470711,
3.17425168e-34,
0.0288583748,
-0.0150117781,
0.0345658325,
0.035943158,
0.0387993753,
-0.0004023097,
-0.0099945143,
-0.005547442,
0.0241256636,
-0.0668610409,
-0.0350471959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17333v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17333v2 | Arabic Fine-Grained Entity Recognition | 2023-10-26T11:59:45 | 2023-12-18T18:55:49 | Haneen Liqreina, Mustafa Jarrar, Mohammed Khalilia, Ahmed Oumar El-Shangiti, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional NER systems are typically trained to recognize coarse-grained
entities, and less attention is given to classifying entities into a hierarchy
of fine-grained lower-level subtypes. This article aims to advance Arabic NER
with fine-grained entities. We chose to extend Wojood (an open-source Nested
Arabic Named Entity Corpus) with subtypes. In particular, four main entity
types in Wojood, geopolitical entity (GPE), location (LOC), organization (ORG),
and facility (FAC), are extended with 31 subtypes. To do this, we first revised
Wojood's annotations of GPE, LOC, ORG, and FAC to be compatible with the LDC's
ACE guidelines, which yielded 5, 614 changes. Second, all mentions of GPE, LOC,
ORG, and FAC (~44K) in Wojood are manually annotated with the LDC's ACE
sub-types. We refer to this extended version of Wojood as WojoodF ine. To
evaluate our annotations, we measured the inter-annotator agreement (IAA) using
both Cohen's Kappa and F1 score, resulting in 0.9861 and 0.9889, respectively.
To compute the baselines of WojoodF ine, we fine-tune three pre-trained Arabic
BERT encoders in three settings: flat NER, nested NER and nested NER with
subtypes and achieved F1 score of 0.920, 0.866, and 0.885, respectively. Our
corpus and models are open-source and available at
https://sina.birzeit.edu/wojood/. | [
0.0252168253,
0.0283745062,
0.0251819547,
0.0447715037,
0.0263478421,
0.0595312379,
0.0104316361,
-0.0066935699,
-0.0265265591,
-0.0538773835,
-0.0410271846,
-0.023223104,
0.0463344008,
-0.0149211455,
0.0381843187,
-0.0449504294,
0.0191148706,
-0.038078472,
0.0355591699,
0.0103914198,
0.0281299967,
0.0195997879,
-0.0290978253,
0.0408866592,
0.0111846207,
0.0074517601,
-0.0249981415,
-0.0035240906,
0.0705919936,
-0.0352638327,
0.0527497865,
0.0546490364,
-0.0093240254,
0.0059398711,
0.0000021926,
-0.0587922633,
-0.0367483087,
0.0187806338,
-0.0240622181,
-0.0220308583,
-0.0269163791,
-0.0790762752,
-0.0543481149,
-0.0171254538,
0.0175702423,
-0.0324015021,
0.0496911369,
0.0761211589,
0.0286533181,
0.0732438862,
0.0002622889,
-0.066625312,
0.0144209266,
0.0120315431,
-0.0376770496,
0.010461105,
-0.00415739,
-0.0218019616,
-0.0258054156,
0.037377473,
0.0274217501,
-0.0219742842,
-0.0178561676,
0.0001325457,
0.0079393219,
0.0191746186,
-0.0749358386,
0.0000069526,
0.0487951301,
0.0487137847,
0.0152551699,
0.0299647022,
0.028446259,
0.0209092777,
-0.0064435354,
-0.0219591726,
0.0025903122,
0.0015846525,
-0.0603622571,
0.0038878412,
0.0647734851,
0.0163050499,
-0.006439839,
0.0019197012,
-0.047684405,
0.0286560711,
0.0218984876,
-0.0494853146,
-0.0000552997,
0.008448896,
-0.0041919732,
-0.0488574356,
0.0449930988,
0.0045757419,
0.0368051827,
-0.0120164985,
-0.0135915969,
0.039434623,
0.0314554647,
-0.0381424204,
-0.0084862346,
0.047523044,
-0.0292475838,
0.0093927989,
-0.0471342318,
-0.0202874318,
0.0298408642,
0.0216803681,
0.0270083528,
-0.0109489216,
-0.0305467993,
0.0273759551,
-0.0388868116,
0.0644020885,
-0.0514434613,
0.019402802,
-0.0510852933,
-0.0176117681,
-0.0197316874,
0.0835369304,
0.0135079632,
-0.0449506715,
0.0118631646,
-0.0178127047,
-0.0423735492,
0.0359305441,
-0.0513006449,
0.0082819471,
-0.0579499491,
-0.0388720892,
0.0179356653,
-0.0205417909,
0.0403349288,
0.0056182058,
0.0056524528,
0.0137180947,
0.0258896947,
-0.0864874795,
-0.0796033368,
0.0282485038,
-0.0147880856,
-0.0393143706,
-0.016558066,
-0.048700843,
0.0451974683,
-0.0056741112,
0.0054889447,
-0.0155327693,
0.0042701443,
-0.017364867,
-0.0018039469,
0.0795283914,
-0.0212465283,
-0.0390323885,
0.0470878519,
-0.0051168059,
0.0593387783,
0.0378244184,
0.0682747662,
-0.0072394148,
0.0242464468,
-0.0069590556,
-0.0327024646,
0.0438558832,
-0.0245441832,
0.0081999069,
0.0313935615,
-0.032668747,
-0.0450568646,
0.0384203084,
0.0130460244,
0.0288583003,
-0.0076212743,
-0.0172002632,
0.0403664112,
0.0042359596,
-0.0051653325,
0.0012185567,
0.008945372,
0.0265566334,
0.0377295166,
0.0004477338,
-0.0123211611,
0.0216924548,
-0.0105700437,
0.0434906743,
0.0511865579,
0.0904792398,
-0.0122757051,
-0.0359588414,
-0.0143393781,
-0.0068415781,
-0.0180359837,
-0.036771059,
0.096688062,
-0.0088225119,
-0.0816730857,
0.0246960055,
0.0349739119,
-0.0130932434,
0.0202376433,
-0.0211128742,
-0.0185444839,
0.0554408059,
0.0150311496,
0.0005501466,
-0.0426447242,
-0.0460974127,
-0.0759620294,
0.0507282168,
0.0173512828,
-0.0225046035,
0.0281488504,
-0.0358651541,
-0.0196833145,
0.0183342285,
0.021467356,
0.00721286,
0.0036091991,
0.0581101663,
-0.000301698,
-0.0531879142,
-0.0068456549,
0.0261586718,
0.0098873572,
0.0294596776,
-0.0224626046,
0.0390808843,
0.0089631211,
0.0739534795,
-0.0068417774,
-0.0221059956,
0.0004799649,
-0.0326858312,
0.0091635194,
-0.0493034534,
0.0102491314,
-0.0181201473,
0.0012829957,
-0.0114283497,
-0.022807382,
-0.024649974,
-0.0205066632,
-0.0339244902,
-0.0266315974,
0.0248889811,
0.0420838818,
-0.0463587232,
0.042611599,
0.0008982641,
0.0253878776,
-0.0105618741,
0.0583922565,
-0.0575852953,
-0.0161298811,
-0.0140002025,
-0.050034374,
0.0426749699,
-0.0080096042,
-0.0466761962,
-0.0044512502,
-0.0056284093,
-0.0237140022,
0.0394594297,
-0.005886605,
-0.0366932489,
-0.0547745302,
-0.0759975314,
0.0112024583,
-0.0318498127,
0.0694735721,
-0.0224597231,
0.0117679816,
-0.0245283358,
0.0062031569,
0.0141914375,
-0.017358426,
-0.0558788329,
0.0114024309,
0.0431102067,
-0.0258750543,
-0.0088405889,
-0.0190384537,
0.009982462,
-0.014071675,
0.0030806172,
0.0307199061,
-0.0782661289,
-0.016666593,
-0.0121598523,
-0.0305037666,
0.0007028392,
0.0281889178,
-0.0186818875,
0.0394467004,
0.0349154659,
-0.0103997905,
0.0174128208,
-0.0000205209,
0.0496154428,
-0.0316432677,
-0.0022674988,
-0.0465272665,
0.0254353955,
0.0262918435,
0.0206493735,
-0.0446190014,
-0.051884532,
-0.0135510052,
0.0380549319,
-0.036885418,
0.0169025827,
-0.0373660773,
-0.0083481204,
-0.0143817514,
0.0003412214,
0.0398271307,
0.0127028115,
0.0002316878,
0.0473872609,
-0.0046577882,
-0.0195532758,
0.0190918241,
-0.0362521335,
0.0163898021,
0.0218387358,
0.0231723413,
-0.0418436825,
-0.0013734254,
-0.0241787396,
0.0136915538,
0.0483303778,
-0.1052044258,
0.0264289621,
0.038129691,
-0.007299542,
-0.0244634729,
0.0229082182,
0.0179849844,
-0.0018708946,
-0.0306044985,
-0.0434497371,
-0.0046540094,
0.0468304344,
-0.0614996776,
0.0429008789,
0.0053691887,
-0.025067199,
-0.0168242157,
0.074152112,
-0.0112080416,
0.0159370061,
0.0026064995,
0.0093586175,
-0.003050644,
0.0380554907,
0.0456246436,
0.0377559885,
0.0094358167,
-0.0014084217,
-0.0448953733,
-0.0044498518,
-0.0993217826,
-0.0085111801,
-0.0471060611,
-0.0311290212,
0.0490795746,
-0.0729099363,
-0.026294101,
-0.0611312799,
0.0354570486,
-0.0495503247,
0.0233074017,
0.1145357937,
0.0211233441,
-0.0138665903,
-0.0037041907,
0.0152563145,
0.0114023574,
-0.003826027,
-0.0174098797,
-0.1102406383,
-0.0275719818,
0.0511222966,
-0.018044509,
-0.0125692887,
-0.0557261147,
0.0435073338,
-0.1083262116,
0.0092404513,
-0.0144154364,
-0.0482443944,
-0.0336608738,
-0.0569912232,
0.0203636046,
-0.0333991535,
-0.010333335,
-0.0743075088,
-0.0103661371,
0.0210855938,
0.0411610939,
-0.0356343947,
-0.0694436282,
0.0154239293,
-0.0589428507,
0.0499313995,
0.0155219631,
0.0380997844,
-0.0515945815,
-0.0142904399,
-0.0042036022,
-0.0466235057,
-0.0330097824,
0.0147641636,
0.0381050482,
-0.0717267022,
-0.0247016326,
-0.0277849007,
-0.0325723551,
0.0052555325,
0.0039378172,
-0.032667432,
0.0074181589,
-0.0012540246,
0.0448414646,
-0.0034721384,
-0.0077600237,
0.0077435425,
0.0610615872,
-0.0268338639,
-0.0370073169,
0.0173719712,
-0.0015076983,
-0.0119713442,
-0.0127525637,
0.039944429,
0.0349701829,
-0.0168076474,
-0.0010375,
-0.048845876,
-0.0878435597,
0.0526161008,
0.0076225679,
0.013141227,
0.0170058534,
0.0388550386,
0.0194086898,
-0.0289258286,
0.0109256972,
0.0051956056,
-0.0101420796,
-0.0492373556,
-0.0363348089,
-0.0094916997,
0.0104773147,
-0.0113790864,
-0.0183372945,
-0.0318331197,
-0.0230753236,
0.0190853719,
0.0152121373,
0.0060585444,
-0.0069543663,
0.0091357827,
-0.0220668055,
0.0510653071,
0.0204470232,
-0.0164812934,
-0.009151102,
0.0085307956,
0.008750244,
-0.0311458353,
0.0213873796,
-0.0001315715,
0.001765063,
-0.0123475268,
0.0177801419,
-0.0085619465,
-0.0652009547,
-0.0089188768,
-0.0200587381,
0.0077051944,
-0.0474169105,
-0.0418891646,
-0.0624266826,
0.0155463442,
-0.0020933871,
0.035318438,
-0.0073153791,
-0.0339597464,
0.0058675441,
0.0068015447,
-0.0032639592,
0.0447082482,
-0.00718146,
0.0159868505,
-0.0415015258,
0.0537176542,
0.0174730346,
0.0511491634,
-0.0344980173,
-0.0190478638,
-0.0059306463,
0.0023693922,
0.0158243049,
0.0361845978,
-0.0553240925,
0.0167774949,
-0.0174322091,
0.0244303271,
-0.0013703781,
0.0613694452,
0.0387965851,
0.0282607507,
-0.0450071879,
0.0613567643,
0.0400177017,
0.0026612086,
0.0463477895,
0.0141563518,
0.0099702794,
0.0098678414,
0.0179950595,
-0.0323136002,
-0.0325264819,
0.0259130113,
0.011724419,
-0.0130249197,
0.0161552131,
0.0167345852,
-0.0009154429,
0.011318705,
0.0256151129,
0.008108926,
-0.0122662317,
0.0209706873,
0.026147265,
-0.0043936898,
-0.0435473472,
0.0168570336,
-0.0739980191,
-0.0346782729,
0.0106704496,
-0.0127921999,
-0.0288106743,
0.0371570401,
0.0055840081,
0.0010194515,
0.0098911738,
-0.0424997173,
-0.051033631,
-0.0503358208,
-0.0264340639,
-0.0173616279,
0.0277944189,
-6.531912071e-33,
-0.0248967428,
-0.0369272046,
0.0160456412,
-0.0509103909,
-0.0080205491,
0.0181546044,
-0.0098087797,
-0.0222228039,
-0.0213525705,
0.0035711466,
-0.0221110247,
-0.004886521,
0.0443810783,
0.0003567511,
0.040780656,
-0.0317700654,
0.0485850871,
0.050877694,
-0.0333665833,
-0.0035507099,
0.0415631719,
0.0263092183,
0.1356504411,
-0.0711014718,
0.07476978,
-0.0019122651,
-0.0549991019,
-0.0067489487,
0.0586028285,
0.1063897833,
-0.0516265444,
-0.0001302646,
0.0178097766,
-0.0458999239,
0.0473854467,
0.0064299968,
-0.1381106824,
0.0195947085,
-0.014996293,
0.0465758666,
0.0013742887,
-0.0446175262,
-0.0255604964,
0.0113091692,
-0.0205254126,
0.0281510632,
0.0241273344,
-0.0123593565,
0.0156907998,
0.0124962879,
-0.1116817892,
0.055137448,
-0.0036447616,
0.0326763056,
0.0396893658,
-0.0112571567,
0.0352335349,
-0.0184519608,
-0.0689596832,
-0.0098286504,
0.0418591984,
-0.018754147,
0.0500600524,
0.0030004617,
-0.0560885593,
0.0325624384,
0.0128919184,
0.0274602864,
0.0265320372,
-0.0263435543,
0.0374600142,
-0.0185284428,
-0.0394317545,
0.0643568337,
0.0508192815,
-0.0111210644,
-0.0689982995,
0.0869007409,
-0.0404309742,
0.0571876504,
-0.0233998895,
-0.0265944786,
-0.0616157055,
0.0070905332,
-0.0138705596,
-0.063878864,
-0.0304566957,
0.017911002,
0.0081894901,
0.008257932,
-0.0121591929,
0.0791164488,
0.0096907411,
0.0281494204,
-0.0029179747,
0.0016485613,
0.0448227115,
-0.0058313282,
-0.0208170619,
0.01983588,
-0.0504714996,
-0.0636301339,
0.0107476236,
0.0125690028,
0.0372471996,
0.0193100143,
0.0644260496,
0.0135075264,
-0.0881930217,
0.0271901116,
-0.0093652569,
0.0102688344,
-0.041670002,
0.025637079,
0.0109623689,
-0.032108888,
0.0092861298,
0.0050977715,
0.0633946061,
0.0121350605,
0.0034657742,
0.0372322947,
0.0148133356,
0.0084669879,
0.028983254,
0.0313046873,
-0.0103417095,
-0.0021294733,
-0.0015240876,
-0.0185215529,
0.0155284498,
-0.0202368796,
2.856e-7,
0.039605502,
0.0278651435,
0.039056357,
-0.0237526651,
-0.034358263,
0.0153435282,
0.0451839305,
0.0602634102,
-0.0251835715,
0.0480022356,
0.0048534954,
-0.0436730571,
0.0460736156,
0.0039824564,
-0.1276150495,
-0.0158979204,
-0.0078498274,
0.0103229471,
-0.0714069605,
0.0572281145,
0.0287803318,
0.0753509179,
-0.0350266732,
-0.0094635691,
-0.0360490866,
-0.0319132283,
0.0555557311,
0.0008155036,
0.0143375481,
0.043288853,
0.0150141576,
0.0008028755,
0.0149512105,
0.0288722049,
-0.0294439979,
0.0121491086,
0.0250923745,
0.0749332979,
-0.0133502176,
0.0349974558,
0.0048841722,
-0.0390201807,
0.0130959386,
-0.0691437796,
0.0552099161,
-0.0116985282,
-0.0474141799,
0.0372200049,
-0.0303064995,
0.0310430899,
0.0169591662,
-0.0208071768,
-0.010599995,
0.0104796076,
0.0436884165,
-0.0189179443,
-0.0141107515,
-0.0306508429,
0.0490681417,
0.0267365091,
0.0408589803,
-0.0113093415,
0.0220899936,
-0.0699192584,
0.0324790068,
-0.0368980281,
-0.0208706167,
2.561270177e-34,
-0.0029059532,
-0.0051226211,
-0.0260256119,
0.0552087277,
0.0447578914,
-0.0138537996,
-0.039795287,
-0.0061243172,
-0.0076193726,
-0.0042757676,
0.0216317121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17315v1 | Nabra: Syrian Arabic Dialects with Morphological Annotations | 2023-10-26T11:23:05 | 2023-10-26T11:23:05 | Amal Nayouf, Tymaa Hammouda, Mustafa Jarrar, Fadi Zaraket, Mohamad-Bassam Kurdy | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents Nabra, a corpora of Syrian Arabic dialects with
morphological annotations. A team of Syrian natives collected more than 6K
sentences containing about 60K words from several sources including social
media posts, scripts of movies and series, lyrics of songs and local proverbs
to build Nabra. Nabra covers several local Syrian dialects including those of
Aleppo, Damascus, Deir-ezzur, Hama, Homs, Huran, Latakia, Mardin, Raqqah, and
Suwayda. A team of nine annotators annotated the 60K tokens with full
morphological annotations across sentence contexts. We trained the annotators
to follow methodological annotation guidelines to ensure unique morpheme
annotations, and normalized the annotations. F1 and kappa agreement scores
ranged between 74% and 98% across features, showing the excellent quality of
Nabra annotations. Our corpora are open-source and publicly available as part
of the Currasat portal https://sina.birzeit.edu/currasat. | [
0.0070920601,
0.0522917956,
0.0002428724,
-0.0047505833,
-0.0369106866,
0.0113530597,
0.0222323313,
-0.0233718622,
-0.0634612665,
-0.0422637612,
-0.0248539746,
-0.0387702622,
0.0560438856,
-0.007454087,
0.0667656958,
-0.0476836972,
0.0076868567,
-0.0435936823,
-0.0185580403,
0.0257326253,
0.0717462972,
0.0463485792,
-0.0368573964,
0.0284689423,
-0.0703539103,
0.0056773145,
-0.0267211553,
-0.0032935604,
0.0505990721,
0.0022490111,
-0.0341934785,
0.0650169849,
-0.0272312965,
0.0176095963,
0.0000016691,
-0.0571619272,
-0.0149318585,
-0.0025569436,
-0.0214057025,
-0.0059242104,
0.0790178999,
-0.0414574519,
-0.0438461974,
0.0020244299,
-0.0032281321,
0.0362722129,
0.0835033432,
0.010807381,
0.0555634722,
0.0371085703,
-0.0157155748,
-0.0674708709,
0.001969279,
0.0123267779,
-0.065365009,
0.0553130396,
-0.0249334164,
-0.0125813978,
-0.0135537963,
-0.0075707673,
0.0188133568,
0.0457932651,
-0.0228425432,
-0.0461667739,
-0.0298060365,
-0.0131553616,
-0.1126931831,
-0.036552839,
0.0628074855,
0.0332573354,
0.00095798,
-0.0371447802,
-0.0053050742,
0.0195564888,
-0.0064396583,
0.0065756976,
-0.0300752316,
0.0174560081,
-0.0444360636,
0.034654554,
0.0261833165,
-0.0082561178,
0.0046343803,
-0.0321301073,
0.0049809772,
0.0169547964,
0.0409603603,
-0.0032043976,
0.0027644073,
0.0207424201,
-0.0014409602,
-0.0093931947,
0.032973472,
-0.0151357995,
-0.0121070659,
-0.002275975,
-0.0170399807,
-0.0298605505,
0.0441030003,
-0.0402262956,
0.0431088135,
0.0006438168,
-0.0532121696,
0.0197617598,
-0.0373391956,
-0.0387087837,
0.0760198459,
0.0077129756,
-0.025809871,
-0.0217156,
-0.0396903418,
0.0244833361,
-0.0309975911,
0.0201499593,
-0.0095110983,
0.0220074486,
-0.0554873794,
0.0079895854,
0.0196428858,
0.0363840498,
0.0169903766,
-0.0265684444,
-0.031734623,
-0.0049853683,
0.009254057,
-0.0118343784,
-0.0229056701,
0.0159786157,
-0.0682050809,
-0.0705451146,
0.0298196804,
0.0519779548,
0.0467381552,
0.0278395116,
-0.0085370988,
0.0137233166,
-0.000668928,
-0.067738384,
-0.0207824539,
-0.0012619003,
-0.0304554813,
0.028629167,
-0.052771721,
-0.054418046,
0.0252331868,
-0.0192817785,
-0.0332947485,
0.0063927956,
0.0034835851,
0.0040737619,
0.0494230501,
0.0589007735,
-0.0067331721,
-0.0183557607,
0.0285165552,
-0.013183319,
0.0103792567,
0.0318489112,
0.0285744108,
-0.0006336173,
0.0294747371,
0.0093315765,
0.0059732953,
0.0357400514,
-0.0415480547,
0.0154106859,
-0.0788634568,
-0.048641365,
-0.0166033693,
0.0532133654,
-0.0096987868,
0.063249819,
-0.0038469189,
-0.0257732049,
0.0371124968,
0.0726036429,
-0.0117300684,
-0.006101409,
0.0179026145,
0.0571627803,
0.0435575061,
-0.0110692913,
0.0094660679,
-0.0066750529,
-0.010480959,
0.0206836481,
-0.0037991151,
0.061795719,
-0.0012532247,
-0.0356740505,
-0.0560856424,
-0.0482196324,
-0.0254831463,
-0.0120220007,
0.0697586387,
-0.0058942721,
0.0043824976,
-0.0315062813,
0.0523660928,
-0.0324148573,
0.020490218,
-0.0069190282,
-0.0099498583,
0.0299320854,
0.0065158312,
-0.025242351,
-0.0733690187,
-0.0192521401,
-0.010751375,
0.0431210995,
-0.035014458,
-0.0563730039,
-0.00444671,
-0.0458664298,
0.0213793535,
0.0276620947,
0.0243477598,
-0.0152556309,
-0.0510838926,
0.0246646982,
-0.0095814364,
0.007043906,
-0.0388223454,
0.0344858468,
0.0229412075,
0.0267617628,
-0.0223876312,
-0.0041127312,
-0.0013328562,
0.0498220958,
-0.0420566946,
0.016387336,
0.0173220579,
-0.0495306663,
0.0378813744,
0.0556332096,
0.0036676789,
-0.0111081982,
0.0577673875,
-0.0317183286,
-0.0206654146,
-0.0307382755,
0.0197360758,
-0.0528175235,
0.0495279655,
-0.0330202952,
0.0760619938,
-0.0548225977,
0.028821623,
-0.0054579149,
0.0214892216,
-0.0145045891,
0.0150126796,
0.0056328704,
-0.0447649583,
-0.0418127328,
-0.0529684275,
0.0304047149,
0.0071506319,
0.0027302257,
0.0020836201,
0.0155671565,
-0.0007767858,
0.0143836848,
-0.0369540155,
-0.0222946871,
-0.0353052542,
-0.1019637734,
-0.0174399614,
-0.0410081632,
0.0799700916,
0.0005928298,
0.0209385753,
-0.0038082066,
-0.0279540718,
-0.0055002873,
-0.0097064245,
-0.0208071601,
0.0047805412,
0.0337085649,
-0.0150487209,
0.0108349035,
-0.0644432902,
0.0101851132,
-0.0067307707,
0.0399578586,
0.0480986014,
-0.0540846959,
0.0373473428,
-0.0894643441,
0.0043651923,
0.0204177797,
0.0310688652,
-0.028252881,
0.0463489667,
-0.0071339235,
0.0459792204,
0.0137037262,
-0.0097498484,
0.0018162269,
0.0205803514,
-0.0179320704,
-0.0222521741,
-0.0330744535,
0.0287664011,
-0.0118169365,
-0.0655303374,
-0.035997007,
-0.0240797512,
0.0625882447,
-0.023008801,
-0.0090684108,
-0.0067758611,
0.0338137858,
-0.0458895005,
0.0254656244,
0.0325225145,
0.0445710458,
-0.0400434919,
0.0727403089,
0.0109337484,
-0.0140242651,
0.037394926,
-0.0424944051,
-0.0185575541,
-0.0112726511,
-0.0452740714,
-0.0451476499,
-0.0044207503,
-0.0332491025,
0.0041233604,
0.0456596762,
-0.0467975996,
-0.0053541665,
0.0240405053,
0.0352135375,
0.0093339905,
0.0120605668,
-0.0428472273,
-0.0017933768,
-0.0132050561,
-0.013466794,
0.0142374011,
-0.0391719006,
-0.057008598,
0.0329889506,
0.0347191431,
-0.0385884829,
0.0015719988,
0.0350467972,
-0.041118715,
0.0346719138,
-0.0076905363,
0.0234711803,
0.0067229299,
0.0009060127,
0.0499903634,
0.00818766,
-0.0358879678,
0.0505082309,
0.021917589,
0.0074783685,
-0.0758168697,
0.0003343835,
-0.0521693155,
-0.0202630367,
0.0312147513,
-0.0593708493,
-0.0593945347,
-0.0677586272,
-0.0046953992,
-0.0031216899,
0.0090550371,
0.092828691,
0.0396990404,
-0.0144771449,
0.0234015938,
-0.0339961089,
0.0063112257,
0.0155710299,
-0.0218253676,
-0.0853134021,
0.0027532736,
0.0252647046,
0.0089140143,
0.0194266234,
-0.0044362554,
0.0475107469,
-0.0561149083,
-0.0154694868,
-0.0161112919,
-0.055779051,
0.0187577438,
-0.0211145822,
0.0233818479,
-0.0500194617,
-0.0176811572,
-0.0405378789,
-0.0110519845,
0.0330259204,
0.075063318,
-0.0518652201,
-0.0826295316,
-0.0232526623,
-0.0396426022,
0.0182765014,
-0.0228197798,
0.0218175184,
-0.0451336652,
-0.0338172801,
0.0193499289,
0.0076302756,
-0.0375044234,
0.0247710701,
0.0067241522,
0.0049132542,
-0.0432309918,
-0.054092966,
-0.0240785312,
-0.0396936052,
-0.0116634546,
-0.0338493846,
0.0631775409,
0.0113343894,
0.0874300003,
0.0137425633,
0.0146798398,
-0.0315370634,
0.0124292355,
-0.0137827573,
-0.0461022779,
-0.0033872665,
-0.0168243609,
-0.036439769,
-0.0114558041,
-0.0396534689,
0.008957088,
-0.005305009,
0.0048554526,
-0.1014987454,
-0.0782996193,
0.0626081526,
0.0203412641,
0.0208580289,
0.0001406729,
-0.0005775578,
-0.0128404042,
-0.0150659103,
-0.0167811215,
0.01974345,
-0.024869727,
-0.0435866416,
-0.0478867218,
0.0602913015,
-0.0022907103,
0.0274291597,
-0.0167906713,
-0.0139554394,
-0.0344801992,
0.0395119116,
-0.0281869527,
0.0105097434,
-0.0027066527,
-0.0337022394,
-0.0337192751,
0.0097286133,
-0.0184200909,
0.0419383906,
0.0018379542,
0.0495986901,
-0.0037227564,
-0.0234767068,
0.0388224274,
0.0209051017,
-0.0059347986,
-0.0211241115,
-0.0007701609,
-0.0657017902,
-0.0431697778,
0.0187922772,
-0.0378248617,
0.0299236756,
-0.0513325483,
-0.0234892499,
-0.0481111817,
-0.0266786069,
-0.0196712948,
0.003970122,
0.00644864,
0.0329617299,
0.0568808615,
0.0072705629,
-0.0123455971,
0.0055538863,
-0.0437451713,
0.0088086287,
0.0171080045,
0.042739965,
0.0804134905,
-0.0096174041,
-0.0352091156,
0.0377193093,
-0.0001403081,
-0.0236500781,
-0.0401933789,
0.0307820998,
-0.0373265073,
-0.0364548527,
-0.0487772748,
-0.0294236951,
0.0354419611,
0.0608090758,
0.0626419857,
0.0377048999,
-0.0334551856,
0.0902350098,
0.062117435,
-0.034435302,
0.0567269027,
0.0058898791,
0.0143733751,
-0.0040348801,
0.054724846,
-0.0368027352,
-0.0379542895,
-0.0249065403,
-0.0103185317,
-0.0381946713,
0.0224824566,
0.0525702536,
-0.0002212439,
0.0023974921,
0.0408986174,
0.0053597461,
-0.0077117779,
-0.0074169869,
-0.0089427158,
0.0226389226,
-0.0201064311,
0.0237178411,
-0.071996659,
-0.0594880953,
0.0110113937,
0.0208433028,
0.0073820683,
0.0411670394,
0.0109412139,
0.0147003746,
0.0088452175,
0.0291875061,
-0.0567916334,
-0.022168301,
-0.0004607944,
-0.0267262198,
0.0124438843,
-5.684898596e-33,
-0.014885895,
-0.0000746937,
-0.0221552718,
-0.0126737589,
0.0154094361,
-0.0149314497,
0.0095588006,
0.0324222706,
0.0026473328,
0.0112087531,
-0.0368142948,
0.0122406892,
0.0234370157,
-0.0068363282,
0.0948921144,
-0.0170884635,
0.0124353906,
-0.0058815759,
-0.0157044642,
0.0000155742,
0.0458169095,
0.0295677911,
0.1560068429,
-0.0454251654,
0.0160955787,
0.0170664378,
-0.0042107268,
0.0121812588,
0.0233674943,
0.0959403813,
-0.0347358175,
0.0619980618,
0.0003177835,
0.006586764,
0.006209604,
-0.0254954807,
-0.0257490147,
-0.00949708,
0.0252725817,
0.0640654638,
-0.0335926227,
-0.0355950929,
-0.0417868048,
-0.0540891252,
-0.0198472515,
0.0510976911,
0.0256103147,
-0.0144787552,
0.0072431872,
0.0054471069,
-0.0945840403,
0.0620559491,
-0.0036920896,
-0.0023514836,
0.0775436386,
0.0153769273,
0.0259923097,
-0.0345703587,
-0.018185012,
-0.0142154368,
-0.0111942831,
0.0471279137,
0.0574478768,
0.0186611097,
-0.0753257275,
0.0346572772,
0.0018471271,
-0.0503101498,
0.0961245224,
0.0266760997,
0.0176531896,
-0.0214378592,
-0.0057944939,
0.0634759888,
0.0211408604,
0.0122163184,
-0.012436213,
0.003259097,
0.0084088314,
0.0467728749,
-0.0367686599,
0.0038852706,
-0.0141311586,
-0.0013674123,
-0.0028413949,
-0.0669871718,
0.0054342411,
0.0076591186,
-0.0323296301,
-0.0217184499,
-0.004390426,
0.1254869699,
0.0128009357,
0.0467230044,
0.0148709798,
-0.0317628644,
0.017169809,
0.0305345561,
-0.0230159946,
0.040511921,
-0.0096705779,
-0.0067755263,
0.0284533557,
0.0349549204,
0.0652913377,
0.0033239448,
0.0831441432,
0.0385675468,
-0.056510292,
0.000941174,
-0.0147779426,
0.0133774523,
-0.0477342717,
0.0398974419,
0.0457578972,
0.0191261303,
0.0015728303,
0.0196171533,
0.0358568765,
0.015942594,
-0.0031459888,
-0.0029540253,
-0.0442144796,
-0.0520193763,
0.0143404361,
0.0351151861,
-0.0162621569,
0.0024243947,
0.0191084426,
-0.0063855816,
0.0136122964,
0.0073372689,
2.503e-7,
0.0576843545,
0.0452766046,
0.0240940303,
-0.0447879396,
0.0252108984,
-0.0129953753,
-0.0054947506,
0.0034214489,
-0.0130201615,
0.0105526233,
0.0174187869,
-0.0539701246,
0.0330521837,
0.016826598,
-0.1079376638,
-0.0502530448,
-0.0596370474,
-0.0054810327,
-0.048187118,
0.0190831833,
0.0624255724,
0.1286530346,
-0.0201857518,
-0.019645486,
-0.0322276577,
-0.0132879196,
0.0418572985,
-0.0195801556,
-0.0146135613,
0.0318576433,
0.0717178658,
-0.0533877239,
0.0114163617,
-0.0059872754,
-0.0226799976,
-0.0002688638,
0.0362862572,
0.0582042895,
-0.0092377625,
-0.0250600465,
0.0086695086,
-0.0127207944,
-0.0103856716,
-0.0193035193,
0.0436545387,
0.038486369,
-0.0403680317,
-0.0483557731,
-0.0162172429,
0.0430738144,
0.0159629323,
-0.0196972396,
-0.0043792203,
0.0232960153,
0.028780967,
-0.0312757567,
-0.0323441997,
-0.0324417762,
-0.0019088043,
0.056869518,
0.0124539537,
0.0027325447,
0.0431627706,
-0.0041870056,
-0.0186722241,
-0.008587501,
0.008959027,
1.881138559e-34,
0.0082364492,
0.0175040737,
0.0518113263,
0.0528272651,
0.012890189,
0.0139720691,
-0.0149925994,
0.0449797735,
-0.0091470797,
-0.0124956323,
-0.0087985592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17312v1 | An Ensemble Method Based on the Combination of Transformers with Convolutional Neural Networks to Detect Artificially Generated Text | 2023-10-26T11:17:03 | 2023-10-26T11:17:03 | Vijini Liyanage, Davide Buscaldi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Thanks to the state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs), language
generation has reached outstanding levels. These models are capable of
generating high quality content, thus making it a challenging task to detect
generated text from human-written content. Despite the advantages provided by
Natural Language Generation, the inability to distinguish automatically
generated text can raise ethical concerns in terms of authenticity.
Consequently, it is important to design and develop methodologies to detect
artificial content. In our work, we present some classification models
constructed by ensembling transformer models such as Sci-BERT, DeBERTa and
XLNet, with Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs). Our experiments demonstrate
that the considered ensemble architectures surpass the performance of the
individual transformer models for classification. Furthermore, the proposed
SciBERT-CNN ensemble model produced an F1-score of 98.36% on the ALTA shared
task 2023 data. | [
0.0678813308,
0.0934951752,
-0.0015415787,
0.0700740144,
-0.0446591377,
0.0140222358,
0.0434678718,
0.0038961985,
0.0030521194,
-0.0416943431,
-0.0149954259,
-0.014957862,
0.0063710413,
0.0259512719,
0.019266244,
0.0253261626,
0.0098776231,
0.0376395732,
-0.0273069832,
0.0012771088,
-0.0012915618,
0.0223628115,
0.0302510522,
0.0442857668,
-0.026873868,
-0.0157588087,
0.025034558,
0.0157040078,
0.0272142626,
0.0185828973,
0.037535619,
0.0930403695,
-0.0279744267,
0.1242785156,
0.0000018692,
-0.0229184367,
-0.0304319635,
-0.0132302856,
-0.0291640516,
0.0101172226,
0.0166194793,
0.0136087565,
-0.0360460691,
0.0235804711,
-0.0371086672,
0.0242696032,
0.0229122136,
0.0690026656,
0.0593795292,
0.0746112242,
-0.0252312049,
-0.004679264,
0.0396266915,
0.015270316,
-0.0358476229,
0.0333919674,
0.0200799014,
-0.0378632918,
-0.0076637962,
0.0281979144,
0.0195740089,
0.0253046006,
0.041639857,
-0.0592817925,
0.027910376,
-0.002901633,
-0.0596802495,
-0.0519862808,
-0.001806,
0.0493793376,
-0.0679114908,
-0.0463075042,
0.0195642486,
-0.0128080919,
0.0158115905,
0.0091746133,
0.0403822102,
0.0665556192,
-0.0256453287,
0.0251595471,
-0.0080108,
0.0095030079,
0.0192566309,
0.067578271,
-0.0047595166,
0.01593972,
0.0096067851,
-0.0149501693,
-0.0321577191,
0.00476288,
0.0003750081,
-0.0449538827,
0.050850749,
0.0239883605,
0.0047409688,
-0.0209058523,
-0.0839081407,
-0.0926452279,
0.0152741009,
-0.0290051419,
0.0342100933,
0.0107218809,
-0.0359486453,
0.0054416093,
-0.0692858994,
0.0814348832,
-0.0317990817,
0.0315815657,
-0.0160643514,
0.0241734516,
-0.015967533,
-0.0033709269,
-0.0355295092,
0.0353250466,
-0.035087958,
-0.0159850419,
-0.0389110632,
0.0208594706,
-0.0150897447,
0.0034785441,
-0.0036948635,
0.0407339633,
-0.0249359924,
-0.0020448903,
0.0076105711,
-0.029082248,
0.0273108687,
0.0133950207,
0.0028878031,
-0.0659286976,
0.015688071,
0.0648883879,
0.0020614844,
0.0028510818,
0.0224395171,
0.0139622726,
-0.0375179313,
-0.059975557,
-0.0130416686,
-0.0347259343,
-0.0421586074,
-0.0447727367,
0.0160644092,
-0.0612722598,
-0.021654347,
-0.0344394967,
-0.0198188368,
-0.0390719101,
-0.0022620324,
0.0304290298,
-0.0095773712,
0.0199409295,
-0.0287955627,
-0.0066778925,
0.0587830245,
0.0042932909,
0.016942706,
0.0076404493,
0.0452346392,
0.097968407,
0.0108839925,
0.0146087781,
0.0589333847,
0.0460750014,
0.0132587058,
-0.0066949036,
-0.0434699915,
-0.0375636965,
-0.0407931693,
0.0080416929,
-0.0055497792,
0.0733662322,
-0.0109997597,
-0.0364738293,
0.0808587894,
0.0329469591,
0.0013117536,
0.0552381426,
0.0320743881,
0.0368413031,
0.028306596,
0.0167316459,
-0.0114738019,
0.0247104242,
-0.0261888728,
-0.0434394889,
0.0000719806,
0.0380108543,
0.0080308337,
-0.0338998064,
0.0037694629,
-0.031404946,
-0.0161638651,
-0.0392578989,
0.0237639956,
0.0320177674,
-0.0417607352,
0.0038196542,
-0.0166868698,
-0.0493000932,
0.0119571844,
-0.0932671353,
0.0678096935,
0.0498190299,
0.0556044281,
0.013310262,
0.027441116,
-0.057503216,
-0.0243742093,
0.0899512321,
-0.0197941083,
-0.0119544603,
-0.0370658599,
-0.0231994279,
-0.0335321501,
-0.0122853685,
-0.0053763152,
-0.0023861702,
0.0263483971,
-0.0002015777,
0.0237918925,
0.0037934454,
-0.0404272303,
0.0464775898,
-0.0246928968,
-0.022254264,
0.0320584178,
0.0105793513,
0.0178064369,
0.001328386,
-0.0519184209,
0.0109514967,
0.0203333981,
-0.0321344659,
-0.0750349239,
-0.0117480988,
-0.0140723977,
-0.0275085252,
0.0109656053,
-0.0465945899,
0.0076376391,
0.0478332825,
-0.0052013244,
-0.0092385542,
-0.0004898068,
-0.0721756294,
-0.0010263637,
-0.0929305404,
0.0008616733,
-0.0249888729,
0.0300601292,
-0.0054276055,
0.0735583529,
-0.0185934249,
-0.0105269095,
0.0077520884,
-0.0174703002,
0.0487878546,
0.0019351996,
-0.0185709335,
0.0049021244,
-0.0353067145,
0.0134031754,
0.0375141464,
0.0132502001,
0.0166718625,
-0.0563112833,
-0.0482870191,
-0.0144140916,
-0.0203943737,
0.0107864607,
0.0155711472,
-0.0295267403,
0.0115330964,
0.02563053,
-0.0336819105,
-0.0333805494,
0.0404161885,
-0.0141331637,
0.0224028677,
-0.0495288707,
-0.000130754,
0.0104890754,
0.010656218,
-0.006718521,
0.0745500028,
0.0434129164,
-0.0472754501,
-0.0536056682,
0.002597491,
-0.0028903824,
-0.0097184582,
0.0001388886,
-0.0717448145,
-0.0163164176,
0.0094466098,
0.0233091675,
0.0654165521,
0.066624172,
0.0138202682,
0.0125185996,
0.0704779476,
-0.0011837074,
-0.0399858691,
-0.0317177735,
0.0505424552,
0.0077531077,
-0.0329171941,
0.0305280555,
0.0385618508,
0.0080871237,
-0.0104480004,
-0.0016316553,
0.0324411467,
0.0007730535,
-0.0397238843,
0.0153994886,
-0.0752440095,
-0.0279219821,
0.0067962119,
-0.0350090228,
-0.0702691376,
0.0443553589,
-0.0352696665,
0.0054982114,
-0.0313266255,
-0.0081141004,
-0.0066651409,
-0.0001445133,
0.0318009555,
0.0518783778,
0.0392885506,
-0.0018582062,
-0.0269082319,
0.0248366818,
0.0440212488,
-0.0522644371,
0.0247569103,
-0.0011855739,
0.0299110971,
0.0043782103,
-0.0149266208,
-0.102859132,
-0.071452193,
0.0298406631,
-0.0008775566,
0.0404624939,
-0.055167716,
-0.052185256,
-0.0189138558,
0.0289711896,
0.0628856421,
-0.0256571434,
0.0036267859,
-0.0154598579,
0.0863609165,
0.0148052294,
-0.0123905232,
0.0524399728,
-0.034283638,
-0.0101200631,
0.0571801253,
-0.024637172,
0.0403339416,
-0.021508811,
-0.0154922418,
-0.0031760226,
0.0162935909,
0.0084263505,
-0.0043321764,
0.00997038,
-0.0214051381,
0.0017920743,
0.0878155231,
0.0056323623,
-0.0228247456,
0.0016665669,
0.0221639369,
-0.026871508,
-0.0072939238,
0.0026703873,
-0.0694160014,
-0.006201332,
0.0038938173,
-0.0162443407,
-0.0776999518,
-0.0105754603,
0.008247504,
-0.084945105,
0.037087813,
0.0085683381,
-0.032928355,
-0.0128021995,
-0.0127816871,
-0.0350331664,
0.0200531445,
-0.0098475022,
-0.0405091718,
0.0138489353,
-0.0161197055,
0.0010971989,
0.0012022582,
-0.0543809906,
-0.0448656641,
-0.0338969603,
0.0247977246,
0.0710330084,
0.0501153171,
-0.0372481309,
-0.0562551431,
-0.0102529302,
-0.018296415,
-0.0275299549,
0.0114524597,
0.0650060847,
-0.0089043202,
-0.0113441739,
-0.0234763026,
0.059233807,
-0.018485127,
-0.0173987094,
-0.0327363983,
0.055133149,
-0.0112938574,
-0.0592475981,
-0.0338462666,
-0.0109380148,
0.0351936817,
0.0593497045,
0.0230002198,
-0.0533494428,
-0.0170042496,
-0.0239552036,
0.0055668391,
-0.0686370656,
-0.0063416879,
0.0411590971,
0.0354174264,
-0.0403930619,
-0.1001533046,
-0.0069769258,
-0.035162393,
-0.0119079407,
0.0104826866,
-0.0217509083,
0.0185321681,
-0.0094811013,
-0.0592009984,
-0.0023902676,
0.0119035365,
0.0375785455,
-0.0472441651,
-0.0099371951,
0.0156366061,
-0.050285615,
-0.0156851728,
0.0117964707,
-0.074930422,
-0.0267619751,
0.0218091756,
0.0358899944,
0.0124911033,
-0.0104098506,
0.0029443379,
-0.0451850519,
0.1097318232,
0.094658114,
-0.0252728779,
-0.0165780243,
0.0073748655,
-0.0482913442,
-0.0367534794,
0.0197110809,
0.0032061078,
0.0591339469,
0.0333104953,
-0.0282019973,
-0.0288094599,
-0.0341479406,
0.0244811457,
0.001237112,
-0.0182256717,
-0.0582864136,
0.0087052612,
-0.0458225533,
-0.0275413003,
0.0019861336,
-0.0071676611,
-0.0381584093,
0.0266924594,
0.0397157744,
0.0139156282,
0.0115181757,
0.0670490265,
-0.0043067834,
0.0156312641,
0.0009068136,
0.012006104,
-0.022799179,
0.0461141318,
0.0132655902,
0.0284255128,
-0.0164419599,
0.0253698174,
-0.0033609674,
0.0174606014,
0.001649462,
0.0466786623,
0.039755024,
-0.0129657984,
0.0212431718,
0.0338022113,
-0.0522792414,
0.0267389175,
-0.0708855316,
0.0211551636,
0.037813101,
-0.0024387166,
0.0337107331,
-0.0312500782,
-0.0024641794,
-0.0331387594,
0.0362472869,
0.0042235912,
-0.021753272,
-0.0407834612,
-0.011598574,
-0.0401433259,
0.0106147612,
0.064553082,
-0.0010333303,
0.0249213707,
0.0175746437,
-0.0077396743,
-0.0589096807,
-0.0061291656,
-0.0059188264,
-0.0401305929,
-0.0187144019,
0.0285676029,
-0.0150839696,
-0.0189378057,
0.0577444062,
-0.0004719655,
0.0364961773,
-0.0005516649,
-0.0107015343,
0.053234905,
-0.0093104886,
0.0180932451,
-0.0312427767,
0.0142514324,
-0.0110118063,
-0.0093594566,
-0.0277241897,
-5.580252783e-33,
0.0273875836,
-0.098179847,
-0.0326753333,
0.0179549027,
0.0115199452,
0.0198202133,
-0.0177402124,
-0.0310473852,
-0.0015804316,
0.0344219431,
-0.0004116182,
0.0110731972,
0.0025704543,
0.0540380441,
-0.0453953296,
0.0032162899,
0.0594811738,
-0.018730402,
-0.0464597754,
0.043826133,
0.0587852076,
0.0212851502,
0.0316102207,
-0.0523611568,
-0.0301224217,
-0.0356079936,
-0.0210525636,
-0.0099822003,
-0.0463329367,
0.0620315969,
-0.0203109514,
0.0131829204,
0.0254320558,
-0.0129035339,
0.0070175421,
0.0463690907,
-0.0011999775,
0.0220463909,
-0.0647914186,
0.0168221984,
-0.0328702405,
-0.0538703389,
0.04975041,
-0.0202557482,
-0.0422487259,
0.0014177922,
0.0643243641,
-0.0278073978,
-0.0141933011,
-0.0973328575,
-0.0738534629,
0.014810103,
0.0138226468,
-0.0210277345,
0.0159479193,
0.0573582351,
0.0138305239,
0.0091269463,
-0.0636195615,
0.0211027879,
-0.0078077149,
0.0041658129,
0.031010095,
0.000065173,
-0.0247414615,
0.0556799471,
0.007512806,
-0.0026621148,
-0.0596761517,
-0.0212831441,
0.0306047648,
0.0326224193,
0.0982598513,
0.0611655004,
0.0109764086,
-0.0339064561,
-0.0535061322,
0.0541017279,
0.0128815491,
-0.0312592462,
0.0364563875,
-0.0497488081,
0.0014977005,
0.0244395323,
0.000164752,
-0.0497579575,
-0.0177890677,
0.0167004764,
0.0132802958,
0.0202936456,
-0.0580563843,
-0.0106665101,
0.009707897,
-0.068913281,
0.0157257076,
0.0438739695,
-0.0300698206,
0.0070010624,
0.0278679878,
0.0463337302,
-0.0195147488,
-0.0178424381,
0.0476728044,
0.0197309703,
0.0122990748,
-0.0036085513,
0.0718292743,
0.0491183214,
-0.0455309302,
0.0326555036,
-0.0182930157,
0.041200228,
0.0247379653,
0.0612048991,
0.0023016653,
-0.026582174,
-0.0049329028,
-0.0169930682,
-0.025471244,
0.0489746816,
-0.0187266208,
0.0044627846,
0.0149630103,
0.0194853507,
-0.0260929614,
-0.0063054669,
-0.055292204,
0.0320743211,
0.0243214183,
-0.0739650279,
0.0339768007,
-0.0049973018,
2.55e-7,
-0.019404266,
0.042597387,
0.041028697,
-0.0379732139,
0.0160373952,
0.0310883317,
0.0297287647,
0.0405151471,
-0.0348103866,
-0.0252372213,
-0.0244932566,
-0.0077784555,
0.067773439,
0.0164827444,
-0.0450447761,
0.0027464088,
-0.0889555439,
0.0190476943,
-0.053149268,
0.0045468528,
0.0632867739,
0.0744464546,
0.0173260197,
-0.0608533062,
0.0269002877,
-0.0415148176,
0.0517404489,
0.023755664,
0.022037914,
0.0171465855,
0.0554455854,
-0.0119579211,
0.0062898896,
0.0271007027,
-0.0470158607,
0.0100723812,
0.0065098605,
0.0443574227,
0.0189420823,
0.0208430532,
-0.0070763524,
-0.024213234,
0.0158738047,
-0.043284826,
0.042765595,
-0.0256168321,
-0.0029684701,
-0.0239800327,
-0.0192548465,
-0.0262664352,
0.0282681566,
-0.0613820478,
0.0262313932,
0.0304345135,
0.0159622021,
0.0022317483,
0.0288956445,
-0.0493857823,
-0.0112205278,
-0.0437065251,
-0.0690709725,
0.011655719,
-0.0663167536,
-0.0240723137,
0.0537321642,
-0.027095573,
0.0234231222,
2.242598021e-34,
0.001579858,
-0.0319469348,
-0.0057797572,
-0.0076661827,
-0.01663238,
0.0106040053,
0.0245180316,
-0.0232571922,
-0.0216665138,
-0.0290516149,
0.012945218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18371v1 | In-Context Ability Transfer for Question Decomposition in Complex QA | 2023-10-26T11:11:07 | 2023-10-26T11:11:07 | Venktesh V, Sourangshu Bhattacharya, Avishek Anand | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Answering complex questions is a challenging task that requires question
decomposition and multistep reasoning for arriving at the solution. While
existing supervised and unsupervised approaches are specialized to a certain
task and involve training, recently proposed prompt-based approaches offer
generalizable solutions to tackle a wide variety of complex question-answering
(QA) tasks. However, existing prompt-based approaches that are effective for
complex QA tasks involve expensive hand annotations from experts in the form of
rationales and are not generalizable to newer complex QA scenarios and tasks.
We propose, icat (In-Context Ability Transfer) which induces reasoning
capabilities in LLMs without any LLM fine-tuning or manual annotation of
in-context samples. We transfer the ability to decompose complex questions to
simpler questions or generate step-by-step rationales to LLMs, by careful
selection from available data sources of related tasks. We also propose an
automated uncertainty-aware exemplar selection approach for selecting examples
from transfer data sources. Finally, we conduct large-scale experiments on a
variety of complex QA tasks involving numerical reasoning, compositional
complex QA, and heterogeneous complex QA which require decomposed reasoning. We
show that ICAT convincingly outperforms existing prompt-based solutions without
involving any model training, showcasing the benefits of re-using existing
abilities. | [
-0.0373850502,
0.0388285443,
0.0002446816,
0.0269574896,
-0.0062456056,
0.0396099426,
0.0133087737,
-0.0233059358,
-0.0124706924,
-0.0002014973,
-0.0234321896,
0.0037084369,
-0.0540682748,
-0.02385916,
0.022918487,
-0.0649378821,
0.0257650036,
-0.0508082211,
-0.0054007894,
-0.0032657026,
-0.0153494282,
-0.0026388539,
-0.0298676211,
-0.0164708216,
-0.0043179621,
-0.0589468218,
-0.0409934223,
-0.0049066232,
0.0170619227,
-0.0215771589,
-0.0264212359,
0.0498831831,
0.0572741553,
-0.057655178,
0.0000021839,
-0.0399572402,
-0.0530848838,
-0.00531758,
-0.0809106529,
-0.0129025653,
-0.0339255631,
0.0314554386,
0.0300434344,
0.0225394331,
-0.077741459,
0.0335528702,
0.008448205,
0.027720917,
0.0579485148,
0.0481197014,
0.012217056,
-0.0033348463,
0.0166665874,
-0.0033374787,
0.0043082586,
-0.0597832799,
-0.0057408544,
0.0087587051,
0.0159013197,
0.0532153286,
-0.010853122,
0.0225770473,
0.0606338009,
-0.0265471321,
-0.0012722178,
0.0094273444,
0.0273177791,
0.0202499647,
-0.0028771104,
0.0876281261,
0.0037177056,
0.0258277468,
-0.0116439983,
-0.0098958937,
0.0307269227,
0.0506200083,
-0.0810735524,
0.0551742017,
-0.0060351281,
0.0058259754,
-0.0025861962,
-0.0068175807,
-0.0100592216,
-0.0082499282,
-0.0131818224,
0.0696486384,
0.0038650185,
-0.0296021737,
0.0419396274,
-0.0041387607,
-0.0613746159,
-0.0633729324,
-0.0148453051,
0.0951506495,
-0.0452024192,
0.0242488496,
0.0004064724,
-0.0033004088,
-0.0085807992,
0.0414654762,
0.0160724763,
0.0469406359,
0.0171253718,
0.0401648954,
-0.004766284,
0.0229124576,
-0.0193632226,
0.0191966593,
-0.0562250912,
-0.015219775,
-0.0622028038,
-0.0349473767,
-0.0386074968,
0.0769588947,
-0.0799802169,
0.0224927794,
-0.0336529911,
0.0391789079,
-0.0191144031,
-0.0161175728,
0.0044160131,
0.0496357158,
-0.0100267706,
-0.0087553496,
-0.0654668137,
0.0152451899,
-0.0813991725,
0.0426947698,
0.0574104302,
-0.036567241,
-0.0606664158,
0.0183303263,
0.007274589,
-0.0286702123,
0.0076854941,
0.0326958671,
-0.0561675653,
0.001991821,
-0.0466231853,
-0.0515846014,
0.0129375253,
-0.0449210592,
0.0240220986,
-0.0720471665,
0.0397750437,
-0.0056569264,
-0.0329015329,
-0.0334856063,
0.0009295011,
0.0337737091,
0.0280807484,
0.0803901106,
-0.0167913251,
0.0096558435,
0.02153657,
0.025474811,
-0.0519389622,
0.0455969162,
-0.0013813489,
-0.0056396341,
0.0178010873,
-0.0060297386,
0.0441153087,
0.0179633796,
0.0220228918,
0.0121310754,
-0.0082368553,
0.0560434945,
-0.0202933103,
0.0097079268,
0.0420659482,
0.014229551,
-0.0160233919,
0.0180288218,
0.0184022151,
0.0784725323,
-0.0148438131,
0.0221667495,
0.0177323334,
-0.0008146209,
0.034160763,
0.0337825157,
-0.0585565493,
0.066957444,
-0.0397618189,
-0.0133274198,
-0.0065651792,
0.0085899429,
-0.0392082632,
-0.0442352965,
0.0350909382,
0.020789912,
0.0068825013,
0.026702499,
0.0121184289,
0.0177562423,
0.0089736534,
0.0474662296,
0.0064181145,
-0.0342582762,
-0.0101595055,
-0.0428980514,
0.047746636,
0.0100059053,
0.0014003399,
-0.0687334239,
-0.0362765193,
-0.0158762299,
0.0545168445,
-0.0057228021,
0.0022182122,
-0.0333130583,
0.0099964999,
-0.0254500825,
-0.0209456626,
-0.0557403415,
0.005645249,
-0.0037287937,
0.0248749517,
-0.0021779086,
-0.0053140125,
-0.049836833,
0.0497790314,
0.0152571406,
-0.038888704,
-0.0538235195,
0.0071776053,
0.0088417623,
-0.0056689139,
0.0339080542,
0.0249218848,
0.0243071746,
0.0117894607,
-0.0385223478,
-0.0519906767,
0.0086996723,
-0.0610456914,
-0.0672040954,
0.0352586918,
-0.0456824079,
-0.0491293371,
0.0135678872,
-0.0526030809,
-0.0411820598,
0.0076493383,
-0.0134633565,
-0.0258937851,
-0.0389815755,
-0.0374894068,
0.0224697012,
-0.0087182578,
-0.0439151414,
0.0921931565,
-0.0060625239,
-0.0278182421,
0.0782473236,
0.004616037,
-0.0174835548,
-0.0261675883,
0.0504154377,
-0.0090594068,
-0.0031696064,
-0.0137349023,
-0.0191645995,
0.0203989595,
-0.0535453856,
0.0127326595,
-0.0507103652,
0.0512927547,
-0.0253126584,
0.0494571514,
0.0450097546,
-0.0021128156,
0.0037427754,
0.0009735372,
-0.0825700462,
0.017352121,
0.0218221731,
0.0058343741,
0.057064306,
0.000250082,
0.0349944942,
-0.0051604928,
0.0116951056,
-0.0190736316,
0.0355200097,
0.0173358265,
0.0206821989,
-0.0215810891,
0.023273129,
0.0058651213,
0.0096992478,
0.0014397657,
-0.0113523174,
0.0234928187,
-0.0099420855,
-0.0014823754,
0.0756869167,
-0.0081893774,
0.013139301,
0.0323509611,
-0.0122966953,
-0.0520003438,
0.0586603023,
-0.0108296275,
0.0003635823,
-0.0282372404,
-0.0308709834,
0.0136640538,
0.0403044894,
-0.0070133647,
-0.0054391478,
-0.0271915905,
0.0513166785,
0.0207648687,
0.0007659834,
-0.0249742009,
-0.0074412427,
-0.0074006612,
0.0747059956,
-0.0102648595,
0.0175552722,
0.067913726,
0.0176763702,
-0.0240893085,
-0.0321800262,
-0.0157999229,
-0.0671598464,
0.0612156242,
-0.0548527054,
-0.0210308079,
-0.0126770427,
0.0090328213,
-0.0797218457,
-0.021128485,
0.0046563838,
-0.0107609788,
0.0484171808,
-0.0682197288,
-0.0178727284,
-0.0260172803,
-0.0453538559,
-0.0474167205,
-0.0008151363,
0.0069957664,
0.0498041362,
0.0169039816,
-0.0126399985,
0.019826524,
-0.0313469209,
0.0446837433,
0.0076201097,
-0.0168861169,
-0.0208793059,
-0.032478407,
0.0597729646,
0.059670154,
0.0989284962,
0.0623018853,
-0.0304216798,
0.0799105763,
0.0630563572,
0.0468809679,
-0.00930255,
0.0174731724,
0.0240560863,
0.0033685633,
-0.0342046097,
0.0026184644,
0.026896961,
0.0914299488,
-0.0630853027,
-0.0234676823,
0.0847055614,
0.032003805,
-0.0286125392,
-0.0147387208,
-0.0401774161,
0.0113242147,
0.034595672,
0.0474754125,
-0.0844624713,
-0.0470414422,
-0.0044976501,
0.030546546,
-0.0155037511,
-0.0571992993,
-0.0004982564,
-0.1397266537,
0.0671812743,
-0.0176176745,
-0.0451926552,
-0.0136638079,
-0.0345455222,
0.0346412547,
0.0269686989,
0.0118909236,
0.0094264634,
-0.0160901118,
0.0167217217,
0.0474769436,
-0.0141188819,
-0.0052214549,
0.0268300492,
0.0001132293,
0.0195949189,
0.011709176,
0.0121982433,
-0.0100590941,
-0.0351843238,
0.0342819393,
-0.0437232144,
0.0162292924,
-0.0057314718,
0.0210665446,
0.0312198177,
-0.0028566299,
-0.0206605606,
0.087055631,
-0.0382039286,
-0.0413371623,
0.050079383,
0.1129739806,
-0.0323591866,
0.0025292612,
-0.0129649332,
-0.0195491668,
0.009628051,
0.0526662916,
0.0499774031,
-0.0352323763,
-0.0550656952,
-0.0423081815,
-0.0199172162,
-0.0588743798,
0.0050421464,
0.0276652426,
0.0291749574,
0.0212671701,
-0.0686732903,
-0.0201579742,
0.0548700318,
0.0517592318,
-0.0064604115,
-0.0000070722,
0.0219882876,
0.0029506595,
-0.0284326095,
0.0383554883,
-0.0396878235,
0.0075754719,
0.0007894991,
0.019735489,
0.01509507,
-0.0491372235,
-0.0148994494,
-0.0258908309,
-0.0677335188,
-0.0331314951,
-0.0349717252,
0.0417666286,
0.0243050065,
0.0384087041,
-0.0129660117,
-0.0465558246,
0.0183587633,
0.0080366256,
-0.0412064902,
0.0078986241,
0.0421340466,
0.0377570949,
-0.005787645,
0.0370266289,
-0.0274097305,
0.0069628214,
0.0102144126,
0.0531909168,
-0.059292119,
-0.0438991375,
0.0424443111,
0.0168489069,
-0.0235804748,
0.0308770519,
-0.0024012038,
-0.0295654275,
0.03790747,
-0.0084928609,
-0.0163198169,
-0.0384602286,
0.002268329,
0.0075361496,
-0.0304483604,
0.0237704366,
-0.0030509781,
0.0134392139,
0.0254017618,
-0.0107658301,
0.029551357,
0.0230930913,
0.0090320567,
-0.0061343326,
-0.0018340078,
0.00103874,
-0.0018839745,
0.0012522025,
0.0597514138,
0.0094139557,
0.0609908178,
0.0371199548,
-0.0041864095,
-0.0503100157,
-0.0131870434,
-0.0802982971,
-0.084657982,
0.0123246741,
0.0276036952,
0.0071628108,
0.0240872465,
-0.0201422833,
-0.0012104068,
-0.0101037119,
0.029108109,
0.0034992208,
0.0299837906,
0.0203190632,
0.0665257871,
0.0503435954,
0.0078906203,
-0.0073674917,
0.0338012986,
-0.0465461798,
0.0307837017,
-0.0392720141,
0.0271207523,
-0.0139754359,
-0.0502896942,
-0.0271467175,
0.0162308328,
0.0186022203,
0.0113053462,
-0.0440601967,
-0.0516691022,
0.0181424282,
-0.0156012429,
-0.0364215039,
-0.024224991,
0.0430304818,
0.0480105169,
0.0044770679,
-0.044574108,
0.0141461818,
0.0195825491,
-0.0198299028,
-0.0315609165,
-0.010885126,
-6.550311496e-33,
-0.0305992328,
-0.0691228807,
0.0572883561,
-0.0408693925,
-0.0140345562,
-0.0128576215,
-0.0345227867,
0.0159390215,
-0.0278201904,
0.0204988383,
-0.0519809052,
-0.0062841037,
-0.0069261212,
0.0306126196,
0.0103192786,
-0.0477804802,
-0.0160317719,
0.0025060256,
-0.0355715044,
0.01896438,
0.0203270651,
-0.0067801732,
0.0163580589,
-0.0243061092,
0.0034665437,
-0.0014554056,
-0.0142412791,
0.0662953407,
-0.0439447276,
0.0428044349,
-0.0157824289,
-0.0081677716,
0.0316316374,
-0.0739997402,
0.005259057,
0.0659191087,
-0.0807989836,
-0.0482959934,
0.021384472,
-0.0289161,
-0.0848469362,
-0.0544167049,
0.0134106036,
0.0146054998,
0.044275973,
-0.0298568606,
0.0262091905,
-0.028002819,
0.0354680829,
-0.0365733691,
-0.0015715143,
0.0010387424,
-0.0750912279,
-0.0211150255,
-0.0091453111,
0.0576132387,
-0.023109043,
0.0283241384,
0.005947534,
-0.0392612405,
0.0340666845,
-0.004542049,
0.0501059033,
-0.0104289139,
-0.012542678,
0.0385631323,
0.0083876085,
-0.0188113861,
-0.0472244546,
-0.0254885945,
-0.0317050591,
0.0836181045,
0.0512634628,
0.0553223975,
0.0235162731,
0.0321415737,
-0.0862059742,
0.0504977219,
0.0031048148,
0.0068483432,
-0.0123095252,
-0.0002620551,
0.0245800223,
-0.0148376096,
-0.0687088743,
0.0291753486,
-0.0373226069,
-0.0016487056,
0.0335339494,
-0.0291180406,
-0.0451007746,
-0.0224102698,
0.0189429875,
-0.0120214662,
0.0217335112,
-0.0214665774,
0.005703914,
0.0321387649,
0.0190624166,
0.0324993432,
-0.0044652992,
0.003481074,
0.0217526127,
-0.0332632586,
0.0184669252,
0.0203336254,
0.0222793985,
0.0035440542,
-0.0449630171,
-0.0131579209,
-0.0600515977,
0.054520946,
-0.0077513489,
0.0175619256,
0.0027756169,
0.0383829437,
-0.0186157413,
0.0131393233,
-0.0234864745,
0.0013140363,
-0.0103490809,
0.0100167915,
0.0001229236,
0.0038882792,
-0.0150184622,
-0.0017294392,
0.0029619958,
-0.0084451353,
-0.0298693106,
-0.0657908693,
-0.0015764452,
0.0615667067,
2.845e-7,
0.0463918373,
0.0034918266,
0.0102171432,
0.0262374766,
0.0263236072,
0.0097787576,
-0.0200929474,
-0.029650569,
0.0204050634,
-0.0514128767,
0.0070378231,
0.0719348565,
0.0422277562,
0.0646318942,
-0.0758014098,
-0.0223923847,
-0.0116558829,
-0.032923039,
-0.0423755422,
-0.0066609844,
0.0910043567,
0.0205518752,
-0.0037502372,
-0.0108555341,
-0.0112895044,
-0.0053250245,
0.0291954596,
-0.0169801489,
0.0075772209,
-0.000241216,
-0.0008863152,
-0.0092360377,
0.0145523697,
0.0515538789,
-0.0101146922,
0.0085374014,
0.0073400498,
0.0969588608,
0.0196215305,
-0.060827516,
-0.0135097532,
-0.0388745703,
0.0596712865,
-0.0114512593,
0.093488954,
-0.0693201125,
-0.0249564406,
-0.0124087017,
-0.037038777,
-0.0318301693,
-0.0054037278,
0.0015835011,
0.0495050699,
-0.0011313193,
-0.0050500054,
0.0022083896,
-0.0062486785,
-0.0796649382,
-0.0036759838,
0.0285138395,
-0.0282959659,
-0.0286868494,
-0.0261335243,
-0.021034766,
0.0355028436,
-0.03529796,
-0.0050028795,
2.698033435e-34,
0.0093254959,
0.0129108215,
0.0329332128,
0.074188821,
0.0385564864,
-0.0089421412,
-0.0321787335,
-0.0069565568,
0.0432429314,
-0.0859085694,
0.0019040253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17680v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17680v3 | CodeFusion: A Pre-trained Diffusion Model for Code Generation | 2023-10-26T11:06:15 | 2023-11-01T17:30:47 | Mukul Singh, José Cambronero, Sumit Gulwani, Vu Le, Carina Negreanu, Gust Verbruggen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | Imagine a developer who can only change their last line of code, how often
would they have to start writing a function from scratch before it is correct?
Auto-regressive models for code generation from natural language have a similar
limitation: they do not easily allow reconsidering earlier tokens generated. We
introduce CodeFusion, a pre-trained diffusion code generation model that
addresses this limitation by iteratively denoising a complete program
conditioned on the encoded natural language. We evaluate CodeFusion on the task
of natural language to code generation for Bash, Python, and Microsoft Excel
conditional formatting (CF) rules. Experiments show that CodeFusion (75M
parameters) performs on par with state-of-the-art auto-regressive systems
(350M-175B parameters) in top-1 accuracy and outperforms them in top-3 and
top-5 accuracy due to its better balance in diversity versus quality. | [
-0.0035504876,
0.0782865062,
-0.0221010577,
-0.016787786,
0.0027992614,
-0.0283625294,
-0.0388209857,
-0.0008772687,
0.0081027532,
0.0197969936,
0.013683293,
-0.0015542356,
0.0084724063,
0.0903161466,
0.0466776229,
-0.0128393602,
0.0314294472,
-0.0215139501,
-0.0218370184,
0.0160243958,
0.0104701081,
0.0301370118,
0.0153803723,
0.0481194109,
-0.0034111154,
-0.0227032863,
-0.0074700536,
-0.0047791498,
-0.0039454591,
-0.0095812455,
0.0134877823,
0.0777618289,
0.0185245462,
-0.0128394431,
0.0000021351,
-0.0318102911,
-0.0228831433,
-0.0055862358,
0.0175674856,
0.0136447847,
0.0186683033,
0.0128681445,
0.0000122512,
0.0204474535,
-0.0618207604,
-0.0105610974,
0.0550986528,
-0.0359816104,
0.134612456,
0.074329406,
0.0006974961,
-0.0505294576,
0.0089224884,
-0.0073856097,
0.0453420021,
-0.0174212698,
0.0040859152,
0.0404553451,
0.007298972,
-0.0693125203,
-0.0103830127,
0.0134080956,
0.0500801913,
-0.0305617265,
0.0498706065,
0.0447555818,
-0.0049902694,
-0.0127493171,
-0.0030261956,
0.06954889,
-0.0937376618,
-0.0350962095,
0.0158390719,
-0.0165913217,
-0.0062685725,
-0.0601138957,
-0.0122446157,
0.0094772922,
-0.031277433,
0.0122551778,
0.007982132,
-0.0167897455,
0.0060704257,
0.0069869319,
-0.0331038311,
0.0215290189,
0.008454971,
-0.0045768591,
-0.058667738,
-0.0070066126,
0.0116722211,
-0.075156346,
0.0293662585,
0.0414809473,
-0.0310817789,
-0.012847553,
-0.0540935211,
-0.0276351459,
-0.0001248865,
0.0171859283,
0.0104319369,
0.0372362696,
0.0196854658,
0.0071003484,
-0.0501951538,
0.0028831686,
-0.0124456333,
-0.048011329,
-0.0125546791,
0.0306161884,
-0.0554987453,
-0.0030905525,
-0.0489741713,
0.0856909081,
-0.0444014929,
0.0433311127,
-0.061551705,
0.0209331028,
0.0059214039,
0.0265456177,
0.0072309226,
0.0042685424,
-0.0306819119,
0.0033681274,
0.0191704147,
-0.0169476792,
-0.014672094,
-0.0595622323,
0.0118211117,
-0.0403907001,
-0.0150411343,
0.0079152547,
-0.0170104038,
-0.0185279418,
0.0107563837,
0.0715464056,
-0.0136757363,
0.0446807295,
-0.0660122186,
-0.0590627268,
0.0241974127,
-0.0313827954,
-0.0123000471,
-0.1078883559,
-0.0417043753,
0.0098454673,
-0.0217086785,
-0.0854100138,
0.004909121,
-0.0022926084,
0.0253781173,
0.0339270569,
-0.0816514716,
0.006458981,
0.0142995575,
-0.0150919314,
0.0076774224,
0.0298678055,
0.0413739383,
-0.0005751828,
-0.0244259164,
-0.0530987829,
0.0555589348,
0.0144644836,
0.0117712105,
-0.0149011258,
-0.0063362732,
0.0122009721,
0.018333545,
0.021432139,
0.0612648986,
0.0395925753,
-0.0321217105,
0.0002917468,
0.0071533453,
0.0189346354,
0.0373573303,
0.0422573499,
0.1133956686,
0.0288570337,
-0.0266421046,
0.0181606524,
-0.017102221,
0.0329285823,
0.0039129942,
0.0337427445,
0.0190920699,
0.0504871756,
-0.011468431,
-0.1053068191,
0.0381055325,
-0.0124071706,
0.0294954348,
-0.0663932785,
0.005415183,
0.0253979992,
-0.0628008842,
0.007747741,
-0.0017076352,
-0.0796654001,
-0.0156912245,
-0.0612485744,
0.0339230821,
0.0732322633,
0.0465791337,
-0.0496285446,
-0.0010739354,
-0.0425142087,
-0.0035220322,
-0.026790265,
0.0159900114,
0.0036856877,
0.0380679779,
-0.069480747,
0.0115032932,
-0.0296647027,
-0.0049624853,
0.0510917418,
-0.0105670709,
-0.0037526609,
0.0241064765,
0.0240383204,
-0.0637391657,
0.0449203774,
0.006405164,
-0.0245899167,
0.0540682413,
-0.0293605365,
0.0143369418,
-0.0358346589,
-0.0625077188,
0.0359186716,
-0.0058355941,
-0.0153942062,
-0.0414649621,
-0.0315713733,
-0.0641420409,
-0.0595225058,
0.0126284929,
-0.0464211553,
-0.0559322648,
0.0065852632,
-0.0296365675,
-0.0034096956,
0.055632215,
-0.022244351,
0.0422303751,
-0.0077080061,
-0.0025712436,
0.015095734,
-0.0091644628,
-0.0022904412,
0.0326054059,
-0.0073630651,
0.0229872912,
-0.0078665325,
0.0329251289,
0.0214384869,
-0.0048253168,
0.0365909338,
-0.0664373562,
-0.0459723994,
0.0417715237,
-0.008796352,
0.066018559,
-0.0126559893,
-0.0025406159,
-0.0524520054,
0.020739045,
-0.0214603115,
-0.0198670216,
0.0188325085,
0.0434700847,
-0.019523913,
-0.0367728211,
-0.0346377306,
-0.0216335878,
-0.0144632906,
-0.0164734814,
0.0432777181,
-0.0242791194,
-0.0492059849,
-0.0617270246,
-0.0172662586,
-0.0340471007,
0.0295951311,
0.0150727779,
0.009252768,
-0.0559408329,
0.0710378289,
-0.0005662996,
0.0232133958,
0.0049856333,
-0.0306305941,
0.0109641915,
-0.0456239767,
0.0670485124,
0.046277944,
0.0054923575,
-0.0114236837,
0.0374522917,
-0.0263341498,
-0.0226091519,
0.0312457681,
0.0061810184,
0.000238246,
0.0189716928,
-0.0319653451,
0.0556937717,
0.0846779943,
0.0485473685,
-0.0131760919,
-0.056065809,
0.021192953,
0.0153619051,
-0.0461805798,
0.0036957017,
-0.0339050218,
0.0105527779,
0.0368408225,
-0.0270165559,
-0.082924746,
0.0897324309,
-0.018719716,
-0.0033206828,
-0.0360703059,
-0.0187694728,
-0.0165215638,
0.0018349563,
0.0026246214,
0.0062541533,
0.0437252522,
-0.0419153683,
-0.0306884367,
0.0006393056,
-0.0016335195,
-0.0122716362,
0.0472375005,
-0.0581812821,
0.0163439978,
0.0024636011,
-0.0154441949,
-0.0399140865,
-0.0650188252,
0.0153039647,
-0.0112619158,
0.0504835173,
-0.0064224731,
0.0235968009,
0.005481788,
0.0017694134,
0.0570356548,
0.0316621065,
-0.0534532703,
0.0079068467,
0.004465891,
-0.0240965541,
-0.0395844802,
-0.0389254242,
-0.0036574444,
-0.007542043,
-0.005234824,
0.0006083549,
0.0499175303,
-0.0684828833,
0.0194039475,
-0.0218499433,
-0.0250283312,
-0.0243035331,
0.0529003479,
0.0782453418,
-0.0295569059,
-0.0027456437,
0.0890118033,
0.015026792,
0.0022176628,
0.0098534245,
-0.0129158013,
0.0798148066,
0.0527327619,
0.0218852907,
-0.0705123171,
-0.0291955043,
-0.002316429,
0.0388643816,
-0.0035432791,
-0.0303001571,
-0.0133332284,
-0.1060929224,
0.0313238613,
0.0257685855,
-0.0254110917,
-0.0259021632,
-0.0474669151,
-0.0409273915,
-0.0246675555,
-0.0496634766,
0.0136230877,
-0.0075321328,
0.0473810323,
-0.0001332488,
-0.0610702112,
-0.0114077069,
0.0111953039,
-0.037904717,
0.0074283425,
0.0992871821,
0.0062535754,
0.0066453428,
-0.0193461068,
0.0203898419,
0.0323739164,
0.0235372651,
-0.0290616509,
0.0425509363,
0.0197412521,
-0.0093374234,
0.0115989204,
0.0165256262,
-0.0610405691,
-0.013174017,
0.0217746291,
0.0596387573,
0.0006957921,
-0.0472438596,
-0.0292912554,
0.014803865,
0.0365862735,
0.0228740312,
0.0616425164,
-0.0390418507,
-0.054845836,
-0.0841993019,
0.0412875228,
-0.0721832588,
-0.0397553518,
-0.0322077386,
-0.0044472669,
-0.0470407046,
-0.081063658,
-0.0005253013,
-0.004074275,
0.0804614797,
0.0076307501,
-0.0131586697,
0.0155743454,
-0.0129111344,
-0.0540637448,
0.0056763226,
0.0024099897,
0.0064604133,
-0.0375136323,
-0.0239987485,
-0.0254561398,
-0.0029873697,
-0.0188919865,
0.0290567819,
-0.0659046471,
-0.0584715493,
-0.0286108404,
0.0832140297,
0.0234364849,
0.029374253,
-0.0364309102,
-0.0333670042,
0.0018321562,
0.0432197563,
-0.0181640163,
0.0025210076,
0.0358716585,
-0.0330684632,
0.0368510894,
-0.0157378819,
-0.0466477089,
-0.0027386106,
0.0279777255,
0.0170609653,
-0.020985445,
0.0518668741,
0.0570142083,
0.0136753134,
-0.0059207729,
0.0026630098,
0.0082967654,
-0.0185206309,
-0.022171177,
0.033313904,
-0.0216940306,
-0.0466611013,
0.0322603881,
0.0265563689,
0.0071454342,
0.0427866466,
-0.0031578727,
-0.035674762,
0.0276014302,
-0.015971968,
0.0202309135,
0.0422776788,
0.0666278154,
0.0845265314,
-0.0331279486,
-0.0041142665,
0.0144417211,
-0.0045924652,
0.0152086765,
0.0066556018,
0.0296876021,
0.0055980212,
0.0360675342,
0.001184787,
0.0244388878,
-0.0373599194,
-0.0572576076,
-0.0194332805,
-0.0101024518,
0.0524635911,
0.042652674,
0.0191329718,
-0.0060669603,
0.0473171659,
-0.0307657197,
0.0880966559,
-0.002146411,
-0.0099176439,
-0.0113248285,
0.0147752743,
-0.0264875982,
-0.0553251728,
0.0957741141,
-0.0282898098,
0.0122131826,
-0.0123101436,
-0.0036063513,
-0.0454218611,
0.0058079637,
-0.0020956434,
-0.0056439461,
0.0063186977,
0.0039608427,
-0.0149586117,
-0.0575265996,
0.01811428,
0.04785062,
0.0243539661,
0.0111692389,
0.0679635108,
0.0804854631,
0.0019259133,
0.0000414557,
-0.0122694066,
0.057425607,
0.0176272728,
-0.0636772066,
-0.0440619402,
-6.099473413e-33,
-0.0148085374,
-0.0191394687,
-0.0027343438,
-0.0128062787,
0.013384128,
-0.0240083337,
-0.0666350871,
0.0068353615,
0.0218848512,
-0.0134986844,
0.0103501314,
0.0236884467,
-0.0065438957,
-0.0261014625,
0.0374442004,
0.0268360805,
0.0511633679,
0.0291943997,
-0.056777522,
0.0314874388,
-0.0448619612,
0.0499563962,
-0.0008349331,
-0.0489821509,
-0.050644137,
0.0208036005,
0.0352023058,
-0.0084795682,
0.0248237476,
0.0204634406,
-0.0044194343,
0.0316046886,
0.0090544177,
-0.0247592628,
-0.0681749359,
-0.0033498122,
-0.0167593397,
-0.0538563281,
0.0094057117,
-0.0236124545,
-0.021434065,
-0.0424703136,
0.0980582759,
-0.0112851197,
-0.0342965834,
0.028993275,
0.0619129315,
0.0199443419,
0.0153146423,
-0.0168189425,
-0.0656769723,
0.0545979962,
-0.0504979603,
-0.0293508079,
-0.0580881462,
0.0048821303,
0.0031270005,
0.0157764144,
-0.0072495998,
-0.0026973956,
0.0237111244,
0.073840946,
0.0404590666,
-0.0309282392,
0.0472813249,
0.0246215183,
0.0526123382,
0.0481418259,
-0.0471829623,
0.0438067168,
0.0278567318,
0.0160179511,
0.0190345012,
0.0140370587,
0.0401427858,
-0.0278129391,
-0.0611673705,
0.0243823789,
-0.0667495802,
0.0442220718,
-0.0220983662,
0.0428372845,
0.0180489197,
-0.0099821202,
-0.0096245287,
-0.0417179503,
0.0065704775,
-0.0432488546,
0.0234175101,
-0.0105264774,
0.008210062,
-0.0307831634,
0.0182728749,
-0.0012269346,
-0.0089819068,
0.0133975046,
-0.0442426875,
0.0147124212,
-0.0055375807,
0.0153042907,
-0.0262773652,
-0.0075545385,
0.0205802433,
0.0186730064,
0.0825361609,
0.026686132,
-0.0008166929,
0.0255765021,
-0.0519630872,
-0.0055525736,
-0.0370662846,
0.015087246,
0.0121702952,
0.0286536478,
0.0039806864,
0.0019170226,
0.0034353088,
0.0252110418,
-0.0067077284,
-0.0253994688,
-0.0482634827,
-0.0122890566,
0.0213397779,
0.0382196903,
-0.0534714349,
-0.0476173311,
-0.0447467342,
0.0598865524,
0.031537924,
-0.0244744532,
-0.0584915988,
0.0196757298,
2.86e-7,
0.030289676,
0.0023079952,
0.0140969446,
0.0458655097,
-0.0175478868,
0.0333537683,
-0.0385924466,
-0.0029160634,
-0.0084626749,
-0.0229611341,
-0.0329947621,
0.0006615715,
0.0215674657,
0.0311373323,
-0.0625526458,
0.0060390136,
-0.0281740949,
0.0249040406,
-0.0515509658,
0.0019539718,
0.0228629876,
0.0751519501,
0.0097882859,
0.0039255265,
0.0405531861,
-0.0265993662,
0.0055992645,
0.0197956264,
0.0181072783,
0.0281949583,
-0.0276186187,
-0.0055253771,
-0.0138202803,
-0.0198432468,
-0.020832194,
-0.0081449402,
-0.007280726,
0.0544514619,
-0.0482039377,
0.0594982766,
0.0603937134,
-0.0126055572,
0.0066417488,
-0.0639171451,
0.0470495373,
0.0067666401,
0.0127491364,
-0.0009000101,
-0.0270610452,
0.0026561441,
0.0349029638,
-0.0184725653,
-0.0230976101,
-0.0046923556,
0.0120908441,
0.0081996154,
-0.0205605514,
-0.0142741762,
-0.0365200415,
0.0015947055,
-0.0153132286,
-0.0296668746,
-0.0483007133,
0.0334432907,
0.0431539491,
0.0157431383,
0.0207703635,
2.742923543e-34,
0.0524320267,
-0.0448211133,
0.0429890752,
0.024562262,
0.0567482635,
0.0046394435,
-0.0421269871,
0.0204069763,
0.0272136647,
-0.0206246134,
-0.0442829542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17306v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17306v3 | FormaT5: Abstention and Examples for Conditional Table Formatting with Natural Language | 2023-10-26T11:05:15 | 2023-11-01T17:31:30 | Mukul Singh, José Cambronero, Sumit Gulwani, Vu Le, Carina Negreanu, Elnaz Nouri, Mohammad Raza, Gust Verbruggen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.PL | Formatting is an important property in tables for visualization,
presentation, and analysis. Spreadsheet software allows users to automatically
format their tables by writing data-dependent conditional formatting (CF)
rules. Writing such rules is often challenging for users as it requires them to
understand and implement the underlying logic. We present FormaT5, a
transformer-based model that can generate a CF rule given the target table and
a natural language description of the desired formatting logic. We find that
user descriptions for these tasks are often under-specified or ambiguous,
making it harder for code generation systems to accurately learn the desired
rule in a single step. To tackle this problem of under-specification and
minimise argument errors, FormaT5 learns to predict placeholders though an
abstention objective. These placeholders can then be filled by a second model
or, when examples of rows that should be formatted are available, by a
programming-by-example system. To evaluate FormaT5 on diverse and real
scenarios, we create an extensive benchmark of 1053 CF tasks, containing
real-world descriptions collected from four different sources. We release our
benchmarks to encourage research in this area. Abstention and filling allow
FormaT5 to outperform 8 different neural approaches on our benchmarks, both
with and without examples. Our results illustrate the value of building
domain-specific learning systems. | [
0.0104907295,
0.0589707047,
-0.003912387,
-0.0146650048,
-0.0295412727,
0.0107020522,
-0.0281647965,
0.0177905709,
-0.0278066881,
-0.0088545484,
-0.0095688682,
-0.0118243583,
0.0015362914,
0.0483135767,
0.0296689663,
-0.0362366661,
0.007041493,
0.0364230126,
-0.0293501299,
0.0727933273,
0.0080916071,
-0.0161153153,
-0.0010035447,
0.0134022068,
-0.0364611261,
-0.0110029327,
-0.0296769235,
0.0102119735,
-0.0505653955,
-0.0011357241,
0.0313269086,
0.0894050896,
0.0020797066,
0.0017436233,
0.0000020827,
0.0009370565,
-0.0522137284,
-0.0347368568,
-0.0055631227,
0.0022614144,
0.020492116,
-0.056782607,
0.012791438,
0.0010953915,
-0.072966367,
-0.0225457363,
0.0347611494,
0.062347848,
0.0786135718,
0.024015652,
-0.0088379355,
-0.0120305102,
-0.0256960783,
-0.0200945977,
0.0568037331,
-0.0109864296,
0.0026607676,
0.0259010866,
-0.003213323,
-0.0653805807,
0.0169236492,
0.0310510099,
0.05841529,
-0.0493036918,
0.0066560572,
0.0152727151,
-0.0290110223,
0.0230350159,
-0.0024100947,
0.0820253193,
-0.023589557,
-0.0200915206,
-0.0073377411,
-0.0127587486,
0.0417897627,
-0.0374455936,
-0.0458651595,
-0.007153471,
-0.0171410218,
-0.01735067,
-0.0198627785,
0.0246858932,
-0.0019035266,
0.0031493569,
-0.0050837868,
0.0228284076,
-0.0252187308,
-0.0371464044,
-0.0275059249,
0.0060892617,
0.0036079877,
-0.0636832789,
0.0255838763,
0.0312945805,
-0.0260584205,
-0.0140062757,
-0.032067623,
-0.0484415703,
0.0180996582,
-0.0179817621,
0.0659401864,
0.0505499989,
-0.0219464134,
-0.0020384663,
-0.0465839207,
0.0212870799,
-0.0373936482,
-0.0276207607,
-0.0261201542,
0.0005419948,
-0.0197845325,
0.0015791975,
-0.030185163,
0.0115770102,
-0.0804552063,
0.0109058311,
-0.0131968027,
-0.0123487152,
-0.0435996354,
0.059916541,
0.0268190429,
0.0243358631,
-0.0480630435,
-0.0149070024,
-0.0438876785,
0.0067408932,
-0.0283681713,
-0.0308793467,
0.01171696,
-0.0630911961,
-0.0114609674,
0.0013293725,
-0.0008196476,
-0.0177138224,
0.012014851,
0.0995480418,
-0.0158036556,
0.0688821673,
-0.0499790348,
-0.0630138367,
-0.0052025546,
-0.0125943311,
0.0314836241,
-0.0477128178,
-0.0151884547,
0.0129394345,
-0.0224456806,
-0.0830620378,
0.0050168619,
0.042264618,
0.0423719622,
0.0839955509,
-0.0299279951,
-0.0193722043,
-0.0263138227,
-0.0322772674,
-0.0283894017,
0.030502066,
0.0460656434,
0.0214488227,
-0.0247287806,
-0.0382489488,
0.0576374382,
0.0317613333,
0.0243627224,
-0.0324762389,
-0.0097809751,
0.0255272202,
0.0284629297,
0.0408302359,
0.0193729252,
0.0054643792,
-0.0153560732,
-0.0094127953,
0.0356870107,
-0.0124568194,
0.0408670418,
0.0970894247,
0.058883559,
0.0150747122,
0.0186098199,
-0.0024243039,
-0.0356128365,
0.0480153225,
0.0266252253,
0.0391214713,
-0.0360341519,
0.0150093324,
-0.0217845365,
-0.0939385667,
0.0085840216,
-0.0022419223,
0.0294406973,
-0.0298692528,
0.0214322191,
0.0459324829,
-0.071876727,
0.0358848013,
-0.0022427705,
-0.0604129285,
-0.047317896,
-0.0087617803,
0.0025628745,
0.065797016,
0.022660967,
-0.0649347678,
-0.0381158739,
-0.033980988,
0.0191736855,
0.0203575026,
0.027162822,
-0.0434651412,
0.0022707533,
-0.0472872853,
-0.002590433,
-0.0097333919,
0.0109994765,
-0.0270351991,
0.0115017444,
-0.0467310213,
0.0185462236,
-0.0360244215,
-0.0313122123,
0.0413228609,
0.0393955447,
-0.0306006782,
0.0483047515,
0.005059639,
0.0181569289,
0.0195323937,
0.0110648982,
0.0248980727,
-0.0026895846,
-0.0158312134,
-0.0030673821,
-0.0226606932,
-0.0666660964,
-0.0155348768,
0.003638057,
0.0141545488,
-0.0691720247,
-0.0128269782,
-0.0590019114,
-0.0007240606,
-0.0070180488,
-0.0022195322,
-0.0431697555,
-0.0093973512,
0.0007446785,
0.0294697974,
-0.0121176504,
-0.0000678556,
0.0750621334,
-0.0169244558,
0.0145401703,
0.00216085,
-0.0477431379,
0.0630034134,
-0.0216727201,
0.0443728045,
-0.080373019,
-0.0593288802,
0.027358247,
-0.0142006474,
0.0396704227,
-0.0441373177,
0.0149144214,
-0.0460990593,
0.0128732957,
-0.005208327,
0.0030837241,
0.0204056744,
0.0213156864,
-0.0074720224,
-0.0630618781,
-0.0528797396,
-0.0383502543,
-0.0489221625,
-0.0293379072,
0.067982845,
-0.0032468361,
-0.0356755927,
-0.0342190415,
-0.0123049105,
-0.0573312975,
0.0130325528,
0.0183219928,
-0.0132293953,
-0.0082554081,
-0.0103821903,
0.025043413,
0.0362897664,
0.0298621394,
0.002107494,
0.0028489304,
-0.0339498855,
0.0209019855,
0.060355857,
-0.0179983359,
0.0164072253,
0.0005182027,
-0.0034337528,
-0.0345558934,
0.0444685705,
-0.0130593255,
0.0467500947,
0.0237837899,
-0.0330519527,
0.0301386509,
0.0681319311,
0.0036461463,
0.0104248086,
-0.0570026711,
0.0279851034,
0.0306112412,
0.0126092313,
-0.0166544896,
0.0557885952,
0.014325399,
0.0405837186,
-0.0332145169,
-0.0185843743,
0.0499084629,
-0.0054557431,
0.0083553391,
-0.0076459944,
0.0091891764,
-0.0490024239,
0.0195752382,
0.0159698389,
-0.0246102829,
0.0360726193,
-0.0015097972,
-0.0437789895,
-0.0057757525,
0.0118343774,
-0.0185862221,
0.1038854644,
-0.0728341416,
-0.0030936918,
-0.0143566914,
-0.0545457937,
-0.0346439295,
-0.0344914049,
0.0090684136,
0.038375441,
0.0310328547,
-0.0225819703,
-0.0460942909,
-0.0415493548,
0.0091840075,
0.0649189726,
0.0217337571,
-0.0575278699,
-0.0023840044,
0.0165882986,
-0.0119306874,
0.0035715748,
-0.0597884357,
-0.0180213004,
-0.0068054018,
0.0267405361,
-0.0402315706,
0.0213080868,
-0.0436047018,
0.0325927399,
-0.0031901069,
-0.013648496,
-0.0103742387,
0.0740116015,
-0.0019844449,
-0.054854162,
0.009951978,
0.0726818889,
0.0257515442,
0.019508956,
-0.0097717866,
-0.0297285095,
0.0391557105,
0.0385778844,
0.0684794188,
-0.1048401371,
-0.0185256433,
-0.0069941236,
0.0273145232,
0.0286809858,
-0.0344313346,
-0.020166738,
-0.077349104,
0.0503131039,
-0.0272950046,
-0.0553649291,
-0.0590899549,
-0.0273715872,
-0.0105953543,
-0.0616884939,
0.012440538,
0.0206056684,
-0.0020442514,
0.0150784496,
0.0053616134,
-0.0914828032,
-0.0386752859,
0.0003569675,
-0.0465726219,
0.0081305141,
0.0775071159,
0.0124155423,
-0.0225479286,
-0.0315330811,
-0.0280293971,
0.0597122796,
0.0203843489,
-0.0237419978,
0.1112203971,
0.0334519483,
-0.020076789,
-0.0260837898,
0.0241621826,
-0.0421839654,
-0.015385638,
0.0229180716,
0.0628965423,
0.0016735555,
-0.008465426,
0.022374345,
-0.0100405598,
0.0244772024,
0.0484764092,
0.0674165338,
-0.0431413539,
-0.0499032624,
-0.0768629164,
0.0083265407,
-0.1047222391,
0.0061213342,
-0.0026904179,
-0.0259875599,
-0.0121075278,
-0.0592435524,
-0.0104308501,
0.0696844757,
0.0595575683,
0.0332234651,
-0.0046387105,
-0.0119415531,
-0.0388925821,
-0.0432904027,
-0.0084182741,
-0.0177481025,
0.0076588411,
0.0163673442,
-0.0517241023,
0.00132968,
0.0021917431,
-0.0122322012,
0.0111973528,
-0.0340278298,
0.0218276475,
0.0131212249,
0.0340183675,
0.0197258182,
0.0245561674,
0.0015802699,
-0.0088138785,
-0.0527797714,
0.0527975447,
-0.0399099067,
-0.0705588683,
0.0199208334,
-0.0306600705,
0.0294263139,
0.0103960121,
-0.0277329292,
-0.0035993892,
0.007976667,
0.0047699823,
-0.0219517834,
0.074131228,
0.0727093294,
-0.0042266115,
0.0006954265,
0.0316412039,
-0.0666736662,
0.0118754832,
-0.0056079528,
-0.0419308171,
-0.0656386316,
-0.0154822264,
0.0053357473,
0.0099713095,
0.051893726,
0.0099754743,
0.0388103798,
-0.0015609629,
0.0218056608,
-0.0458699726,
-0.0096866004,
0.0538780615,
-0.0016177288,
0.0218242723,
-0.0188874491,
-0.0083485693,
-0.0102982894,
0.0323117748,
0.0249982625,
0.0006815058,
0.0367533527,
0.0229179412,
0.0230500344,
-0.0378453285,
0.0269676745,
0.0043315426,
-0.0195901245,
-0.0180003904,
-0.0226663835,
-0.0155699141,
-0.0232082959,
-0.025441898,
-0.0159305129,
-0.0040442566,
0.0328940675,
0.0775628164,
0.0243005622,
0.0122716585,
0.022746034,
-0.0046300632,
-0.0170464981,
-0.0770023689,
0.0963797346,
0.0066859205,
0.02592263,
-0.0445894003,
-0.0250426065,
-0.0752406418,
0.0128390091,
0.0355267711,
-0.0340461098,
-0.004729358,
-0.042447865,
-0.0497997701,
-0.0379815027,
0.0483424328,
0.0615323596,
0.0065927384,
0.0202963594,
0.0283599515,
0.0603178479,
0.0427092239,
-0.0492668673,
-0.0031270671,
0.0301126875,
0.0298591126,
-0.0652363226,
-0.0674705952,
-6.09468658e-33,
-0.0294659697,
-0.0050212382,
0.0288201142,
0.0099641327,
0.0430827998,
-0.0261703413,
-0.0483073033,
-0.0357825123,
0.0204801504,
0.0291863848,
-0.0167120807,
0.0119968019,
0.0122555718,
-0.0179203115,
0.0404498726,
-0.04016665,
0.0655667111,
-0.0095018307,
-0.0132480022,
-0.0146267693,
-0.0425448939,
0.0292611439,
0.0018583905,
-0.0867045969,
0.0218848661,
0.0214449912,
0.0017719335,
0.0079696691,
-0.0141832074,
0.0232065823,
0.0003719456,
0.0020878632,
0.0252919421,
-0.04820925,
-0.063968502,
0.0081443423,
-0.1271508634,
-0.0482400954,
-0.0233910978,
0.0283233002,
-0.0526320972,
-0.0309008006,
0.0788460001,
-0.0167925842,
-0.0194026344,
-0.0057456465,
0.0457746945,
-0.004516447,
0.0184879508,
0.0020385105,
-0.0311189983,
0.0181982256,
-0.0111544998,
-0.0060599046,
0.0038612559,
0.0515090227,
0.0182118285,
-0.0141044576,
-0.0372133479,
-0.0001344925,
0.01990119,
0.0211825427,
0.0677856579,
-0.0044031991,
0.0179898329,
0.0160801765,
0.0187493581,
0.057221856,
-0.0467192009,
0.0149598606,
-0.0223044511,
0.0678625181,
0.0783169419,
0.0150262658,
0.0432099439,
0.0144217974,
-0.0262425281,
0.0724461526,
-0.055394046,
0.033483699,
-0.0369412117,
0.005098749,
-0.0253475942,
-0.0179077331,
0.0250025857,
-0.0221791808,
-0.0103841024,
-0.0162504874,
0.0184623189,
-0.0169597063,
0.0175657887,
0.0281708259,
-0.0213588383,
0.0101039596,
0.0041477261,
0.0213609487,
-0.0012206155,
0.0059965369,
-0.0029124531,
-0.042746,
-0.0218237452,
-0.017347673,
0.0017032441,
0.0202705022,
0.0686186925,
0.0523462817,
0.075202994,
0.0350248478,
-0.0660331324,
0.0041791704,
-0.001113228,
0.035273049,
0.0491992049,
-0.0051508569,
-0.0011996607,
0.0263326261,
-0.0345982462,
0.0179041848,
0.0268934406,
-0.0334917493,
-0.01416591,
0.0009683057,
0.0139412954,
-0.0012818468,
0.0086654965,
-0.0330731533,
-0.0399499387,
0.0043340009,
0.0215919949,
0.0108311065,
-0.0149938762,
0.0211928375,
2.562e-7,
0.0824386701,
0.0080901077,
0.0708442926,
0.0259561129,
-0.0102713387,
0.0377988517,
0.0005478455,
-0.0302420482,
-0.0357553549,
0.0031215812,
0.0329933129,
-0.0278062262,
0.0518059507,
0.0394679382,
-0.0308716204,
-0.0163774919,
-0.015819937,
-0.0141325966,
-0.0216586441,
0.0067709945,
0.0496022254,
0.0646301582,
-0.0322291814,
0.0177641492,
0.0268062819,
-0.0337894484,
0.0231065806,
-0.0598212853,
0.0607999377,
0.0190415997,
0.0311355311,
-0.0336283632,
-0.0153830862,
0.058619909,
-0.0292101558,
-0.0125871561,
0.0046794503,
0.0733801201,
0.0035212948,
0.0822923258,
0.0049818694,
-0.049407579,
0.0410633571,
-0.0573073402,
0.0503051095,
-0.0608690493,
-0.007131217,
0.0665574074,
-0.0260955095,
0.049625136,
0.0029413004,
0.0110694021,
-0.021695897,
0.002386898,
0.0222841986,
0.0083700949,
-0.0318698734,
-0.0069224467,
-0.0517336689,
0.0153439464,
0.0005324684,
0.0210674051,
-0.0206108131,
0.0018728008,
-0.0133067723,
0.0083246231,
-0.0081768539,
2.734810796e-34,
0.0457158536,
-0.0143548604,
0.044571504,
0.0418046862,
0.0817906782,
-0.0281244721,
0.004217227,
0.047172118,
0.0193808582,
-0.0530368648,
-0.0157327503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17300v1 | Comparing Photorealistic and Animated Embodied Conversational Agents in Serious Games: An Empirical Study on User Experience | 2023-10-26T10:45:26 | 2023-10-26T10:45:26 | Danai Korre | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, I.2.1; H.5.2; K.3.1 | Embodied conversational agents (ECAs) are paradigms of conversational user
interfaces in the form of embodied characters. While ECAs offer various
manipulable features, this paper focuses on a study conducted to explore two
distinct levels of presentation realism. The two agent versions are
photorealistic and animated. The study aims to provide insights and design
suggestions for speech-enabled ECAs within serious game environments. A
within-subjects, two-by-two factorial design was employed for this research
with a cohort of 36 participants balanced for gender. The results showed that
both the photorealistic and the animated versions were perceived as highly
usable, with overall mean scores of 5.76 and 5.71, respectively. However, 69.4
per cent of the participants stated they preferred the photorealistic version,
25 per cent stated they preferred the animated version and 5.6 per cent had no
stated preference. The photorealistic agents were perceived as more realistic
and human-like, while the animated characters made the task feel more like a
game. Even though the agents' realism had no significant effect on usability,
it positively influenced participants' perceptions of the agent. This research
aims to lay the groundwork for future studies on ECA realism's impact in
serious games across diverse contexts. | [
0.0617466345,
0.0246056523,
-0.0511479639,
0.0400279127,
0.0429293253,
0.0144035136,
0.0432206839,
0.001153911,
-0.0259561688,
0.0030612161,
-0.0410771593,
-0.0219323337,
0.0149550699,
0.0312971883,
0.0334565528,
-0.0876033232,
-0.0415156074,
-0.0251415391,
0.0255401824,
0.0368923619,
0.0297508948,
0.0179611761,
-0.0540793613,
0.0568306297,
-0.0136543997,
-0.0394784845,
-0.0511954688,
0.0185143314,
0.0355123095,
-0.0283313505,
-0.0088766608,
-0.0539390966,
0.0215517003,
-0.0135643715,
0.000002017,
-0.0117103877,
0.0658137649,
-0.0103381481,
-0.0266245622,
0.0543976575,
0.02922206,
0.0411349311,
0.0102341501,
-0.0432721861,
0.0008956814,
-0.0269871037,
0.0941336676,
0.0456473827,
0.053678479,
0.0120154843,
-0.0196599513,
0.0104437592,
-0.0279676989,
0.0342251658,
-0.0199489277,
0.0299983677,
-0.0485749692,
0.0162569676,
0.0807836279,
-0.0263200682,
-0.0098653194,
0.0075809052,
-0.0039406805,
-0.0096423551,
-0.0094073517,
0.0600823686,
-0.0159511808,
-0.0366280414,
0.0196537543,
0.0627600327,
0.0170203093,
0.0364998356,
-0.0111453002,
-0.0046070963,
0.0186406374,
0.0081271157,
-0.006466907,
0.0185588077,
-0.0197881963,
-0.0134231849,
-0.078425616,
0.0102988742,
0.0009147797,
-0.0287765991,
0.0313075334,
-0.0063648061,
-0.008474851,
0.0075440286,
-0.0123288231,
-0.0200375132,
-0.0009059034,
-0.0233858805,
-0.0207783449,
0.0213735029,
-0.0206589606,
0.0368366502,
-0.0015910064,
0.0371202715,
-0.0299658403,
-0.0656757727,
-0.0119639114,
0.0200656317,
0.0235786792,
-0.0203960501,
0.0403627157,
0.0460943989,
0.0174516626,
0.0020297614,
0.014673165,
0.055722028,
-0.0008373219,
-0.0290708374,
-0.054418128,
0.0187238529,
-0.0590207577,
-0.0411505476,
-0.017427478,
0.0269761067,
-0.0171246026,
0.0086934259,
-0.0338309109,
0.0211588107,
0.0262535587,
0.0682800114,
-0.0311764199,
-0.0090394383,
-0.0688043684,
0.0653361678,
-0.0125121567,
-0.0959046856,
0.0194288138,
-0.0270037856,
0.0223988574,
0.0018847757,
0.000669033,
0.0175886247,
0.0143929766,
-0.0102879005,
0.0342055298,
0.0167281479,
0.0217413437,
-0.0319452919,
-0.0257101357,
0.012836244,
0.0067859842,
-0.0388012081,
0.0353353135,
0.0088081658,
0.0012101256,
0.0231482331,
0.0595777631,
0.0556487888,
0.010446962,
0.0455928072,
0.0392856002,
0.0102145923,
-0.0237096455,
0.0027308913,
0.0684270412,
-0.0083044749,
-0.0089838021,
-0.0420562476,
0.0369600952,
0.029549215,
-0.0438344702,
-0.0109153325,
0.0555319227,
-0.0147943161,
-0.0200567581,
0.0796253905,
0.0151549205,
0.0411824733,
-0.0478614606,
0.0232912265,
0.0567798652,
0.0162569452,
0.0124774398,
0.0069311177,
0.015939245,
0.0124861095,
0.0559674241,
-0.00240245,
0.0515320785,
0.0182092171,
0.0355501734,
-0.0160750598,
-0.0412938744,
0.0076617226,
-0.0236443337,
-0.0237865113,
0.0575558692,
-0.0003902156,
0.0635669827,
-0.0093922978,
-0.026585253,
-0.0000948188,
-0.0237393789,
-0.0257701389,
-0.0361981317,
-0.0932325944,
0.0073354715,
-0.0618931353,
-0.0079602236,
0.0767153725,
-0.0076524941,
0.025585793,
-0.02303572,
-0.0019746479,
0.0079965778,
0.0670111999,
-0.0237251893,
0.0019337044,
0.0404159166,
0.0053038071,
0.0270835739,
-0.0767220408,
-0.0188641548,
0.0375879034,
-0.0743426532,
0.0766009465,
0.0228543729,
0.0570352376,
-0.0004233098,
-0.0099099735,
-0.040050339,
-0.0251729749,
-0.0425132923,
0.0060958867,
-0.0164963081,
0.0025190359,
-0.0409661457,
-0.0080925329,
-0.0092443526,
0.0100177471,
0.0375215113,
0.0900396258,
0.0096650049,
0.026731886,
0.0441101193,
-0.0643565208,
0.0092662061,
-0.0021145628,
0.0458433256,
0.03582206,
0.0619888082,
-0.0489764847,
0.0226850938,
0.0042767362,
0.0232817661,
-0.0120568862,
0.0216259006,
0.0265277959,
-0.0339189097,
0.0108071761,
-0.0320761986,
0.0437926091,
-0.0244617332,
0.0034484046,
-0.057051871,
0.0176067222,
0.0867266804,
0.015166129,
0.02940505,
-0.0230421349,
-0.0389239751,
-0.0905459821,
0.0242190883,
-0.0829846337,
-0.0559165329,
0.0273340456,
-0.0384136401,
-0.0071111419,
-0.0282294918,
-0.040964637,
-0.0036413146,
-0.0585708097,
-0.0160963386,
-0.0121799912,
-0.0073490185,
0.0340910666,
0.0247109849,
-0.0239072144,
-0.0635247603,
0.0190663766,
0.0163354706,
0.0136112226,
0.0177225359,
0.0040809819,
-0.0038345712,
0.0291693602,
-0.0297386963,
-0.0035353645,
-0.0104094306,
-0.0600793436,
0.0593653247,
0.004255903,
0.0116820028,
-0.0039058458,
0.005851611,
0.0307795443,
0.0376120023,
-0.0788705125,
0.0069361101,
0.0101795318,
0.0574983098,
0.0334242471,
0.0078011956,
-0.0456791036,
0.072791256,
-0.0039661671,
-0.0225223135,
0.0566168427,
-0.0476727448,
0.0574305877,
0.0287436061,
-0.0790229738,
0.0409299247,
-0.0320619717,
-0.0056944476,
-0.0090005687,
-0.020232426,
0.0541774966,
0.0228587929,
-0.0379189663,
-0.0767960176,
0.0508015901,
0.0251672845,
0.0236346461,
0.0228241831,
-0.0410584398,
0.0154332733,
0.0282142404,
-0.0284636691,
0.007281146,
-0.0273007527,
0.0108886696,
-0.0495863222,
0.0111147491,
-0.0569178201,
-0.0295442976,
0.0100750318,
0.0008800233,
0.0093694702,
-0.0043409402,
-0.039162796,
-0.0345173106,
0.0003951483,
0.0148003763,
-0.0546719469,
-0.01272415,
0.0000073962,
0.0007109764,
0.0298180804,
-0.0034521336,
0.010529479,
-0.0461131334,
0.0804358646,
0.1081279069,
-0.013493157,
-0.0147128114,
0.0692041442,
0.0174976606,
-0.0400013775,
-0.0270565618,
-0.034776032,
-0.0149823111,
0.0047291867,
-0.0115389125,
-0.048220519,
-0.0104438905,
0.0388442837,
-0.0150235537,
0.0466544852,
0.0544112027,
-0.0132879429,
0.0484020114,
0.0311339833,
0.0205357224,
-0.0069569438,
-0.0162158385,
-0.0126408758,
-0.0233131722,
0.0296144709,
0.0058788965,
0.004474136,
-0.0342376418,
-0.0062126284,
-0.0027811681,
-0.0789543316,
0.0197865013,
-0.0038215537,
-0.0297952704,
-0.0007521796,
0.0306241196,
0.0220753178,
0.0363925733,
0.0384853221,
0.0196195971,
-0.0036849829,
-0.0009972674,
0.032456778,
-0.0409969166,
0.0390429832,
0.0049334937,
-0.0189524107,
0.0745010152,
-0.0038666397,
0.1052469909,
0.0012925707,
-0.0811469331,
-0.0332594961,
0.0206036102,
0.0219396185,
0.008172214,
0.0174285471,
-0.0520009547,
-0.0295050386,
-0.0693630129,
-0.0192819312,
0.040358644,
0.0036356531,
0.0103879552,
0.0035334777,
-0.0094464319,
-0.0153779192,
-0.0364313275,
0.0161138959,
0.0072421259,
-0.0265526883,
0.0141867651,
-0.0528987609,
0.0061673503,
0.0267634466,
0.0348355435,
0.0165540874,
-0.0570558459,
-0.0123066138,
0.0113665257,
0.0287068076,
-0.0645950511,
-0.081399031,
0.0197018199,
0.0563454218,
-0.0314299278,
-0.0081914747,
-0.0142751094,
0.0472756512,
0.0115421629,
-0.0098102773,
-0.0014738712,
0.0102934698,
-0.00980548,
-0.0137143303,
-0.0185507499,
-0.044467099,
0.0380467139,
-0.0395925306,
0.0589220077,
-0.0182282683,
-0.0143918516,
0.0302654486,
0.00791544,
-0.0287172608,
0.03886934,
-0.0313254781,
-0.0275622047,
-0.0190262068,
-0.0269565061,
0.0136814443,
0.0166781507,
0.0316403694,
0.0221242532,
-0.0193074085,
0.0254407488,
-0.0236572567,
-0.0426015779,
0.0270819478,
-0.0128461979,
-0.0570161082,
-0.0122146625,
0.0798033327,
0.0190257803,
0.0000212416,
0.013505755,
0.0061564217,
0.0179421194,
-0.0850845501,
0.0205722116,
-0.0438565277,
-0.042957969,
-0.0111839436,
0.0442938879,
0.0175245255,
0.0128482617,
-0.0496692769,
-0.0020414975,
0.0060163969,
0.0115018263,
0.0258458089,
-0.0198432542,
-0.0382248536,
0.0356845297,
0.0320413522,
0.0506278388,
-0.017804293,
0.0558960252,
0.0347045474,
0.0223332681,
-0.0137931993,
-0.0752296075,
0.0143262139,
0.0196834058,
0.0442216806,
-0.017916603,
0.0369017757,
0.0303168818,
-0.0194765776,
0.0003858915,
0.0211581718,
0.0256099198,
0.0368605405,
-0.0173583906,
-0.0324557014,
0.0274817087,
-0.0413603485,
-0.0237784479,
-0.0019042724,
-0.0429871939,
-0.0537424423,
-0.0430208333,
-0.0411576629,
-0.0028205449,
-0.0393208154,
-0.0269814264,
-0.020257296,
-0.0051503638,
-0.0437758304,
-0.0249724314,
-0.0136594707,
-0.0225390363,
-0.0608728491,
-0.0464398451,
-0.0285865422,
0.0221402235,
-0.0309952162,
-0.0653419122,
0.0151804676,
-0.0240804013,
0.0190995689,
0.012183778,
-0.0205619801,
-0.0116305295,
-0.0464239493,
-0.0021113232,
-0.023164425,
-4.946126845e-33,
-0.0259454176,
0.0078207767,
0.0361924805,
-0.0081734713,
-0.0739256069,
-0.0094043361,
-0.0678537637,
0.0185553599,
-0.008893311,
-0.0000983002,
0.0134508442,
-0.0449650995,
-0.0188319404,
-0.0298665073,
-0.0247488283,
-0.0253476743,
0.0447239019,
0.0665683597,
-0.0308454111,
0.0130080394,
-0.0121064186,
-0.0353768766,
-0.0024638344,
-0.0555903949,
0.0112713305,
-0.0035941424,
-0.030727949,
-0.0832558423,
0.0563904122,
0.0495821126,
-0.0064155483,
-0.0019789708,
0.0270854179,
0.050613977,
0.0196490325,
0.0396037102,
0.0044710007,
-0.0147495577,
0.0002057299,
0.0435891151,
-0.0306977276,
-0.0306420065,
-0.004262642,
0.0165900625,
-0.0389858223,
-0.0171931945,
0.0425731428,
-0.0192503463,
0.0327033736,
-0.0113448799,
-0.0786228329,
-0.0392661318,
-0.0423946492,
-0.0416990109,
0.0105833458,
0.0812311321,
-0.019513607,
-0.0168321468,
-0.0296527054,
0.0372099988,
-0.0211068075,
-0.0805065632,
0.035297554,
0.0315678827,
0.0519047566,
0.0345983729,
0.022642754,
0.0391797312,
-0.1049339101,
-0.0028294232,
0.0809270665,
0.0442958511,
0.0184804089,
0.0520451516,
-0.0203683749,
-0.057324633,
0.0133195817,
0.0143947983,
0.0049155103,
0.0537071601,
-0.0159196984,
0.0942502618,
-0.0871133134,
0.0294456724,
-0.0146428319,
0.0454785377,
-0.0199200828,
-0.0890666246,
0.0301143043,
-0.0436462648,
0.0115715228,
-0.0423874557,
0.0061700321,
-0.0276224446,
-0.0248390492,
-0.0817213729,
-0.02801935,
0.0128544271,
-0.0037560214,
-0.0424665548,
0.0431303047,
-0.006585788,
0.0607508942,
0.0524173565,
0.0498910956,
0.020203663,
-0.0555702373,
0.0373891816,
0.0086502191,
-0.0161672495,
0.0106742168,
0.0272889938,
0.0430992767,
-0.0034905372,
0.0157349352,
-0.0254139751,
-0.0366740599,
-0.0205903295,
-0.0359279104,
-0.025576327,
-0.0287146643,
0.0158995166,
-0.0540917665,
-0.0289331842,
-0.058032237,
-0.0369709954,
-0.008925627,
-0.0106255272,
0.0377652831,
-0.0474678315,
-0.0372500718,
-0.0540644564,
3.068e-7,
-0.0589823313,
-0.0019681389,
-0.0057131965,
0.0032879163,
0.0109471101,
0.0458407104,
0.0264965966,
0.0274704769,
0.0297432598,
-0.0472190566,
0.0507299267,
0.025027005,
0.0293244105,
-0.016729109,
-0.0473398529,
-0.0218490269,
-0.0149481352,
0.0467522107,
0.0105107939,
0.0732952803,
0.0743896663,
-0.005088096,
0.0027875623,
-0.013342631,
0.0106868893,
0.0149423154,
-0.0163161941,
-0.0809257329,
0.0016701843,
-0.0368454978,
-0.0296823606,
0.0129208723,
0.006382891,
-0.0366706662,
0.0049510752,
0.0068521076,
0.0606179088,
0.0401959382,
-0.0353421308,
0.017690381,
0.0037575611,
0.0150804147,
-0.016133735,
-0.0131085161,
0.0213599559,
0.0041047721,
-0.0284631047,
0.0111400904,
-0.0654220507,
-0.0024881517,
0.0058332398,
-0.0608462282,
-0.0487632044,
0.0055855862,
-0.0068382276,
-0.0445316732,
-0.0075778114,
0.001737993,
0.0331764929,
-0.0129323639,
-0.0130640659,
-0.0167832356,
-0.0414855704,
-0.048687242,
0.0162681285,
-0.0338427648,
0.0081476774,
1.298371278e-34,
-0.0367421582,
0.0236540511,
0.0370497964,
0.0219159517,
0.0572408065,
0.0563813038,
0.0500668064,
0.0207551066,
0.0774406195,
-0.0294318795,
0.0167041048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17284v1 | Learning to Abstract with Nonparametric Variational Information Bottleneck | 2023-10-26T10:04:31 | 2023-10-26T10:04:31 | Melika Behjati, Fabio Fehr, James Henderson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Learned representations at the level of characters, sub-words, words and
sentences, have each contributed to advances in understanding different NLP
tasks and linguistic phenomena. However, learning textual embeddings is costly
as they are tokenization specific and require different models to be trained
for each level of abstraction. We introduce a novel language representation
model which can learn to compress to different levels of abstraction at
different layers of the same model. We apply Nonparametric Variational
Information Bottleneck (NVIB) to stacked Transformer self-attention layers in
the encoder, which encourages an information-theoretic compression of the
representations through the model. We find that the layers within the model
correspond to increasing levels of abstraction and that their representations
are more linguistically informed. Finally, we show that NVIB compression
results in a model which is more robust to adversarial perturbations. | [
-0.0283782016,
0.0957467631,
-0.011318964,
0.0294579547,
-0.025125118,
0.0049196626,
0.0045977901,
0.0043323501,
-0.0358864702,
-0.0173835102,
-0.0198742207,
-0.0362133794,
-0.0043081106,
0.0186114628,
0.069323957,
-0.0804538876,
0.0084002689,
-0.0031419138,
-0.0050026323,
-0.0003001768,
0.013297068,
0.0003391973,
0.0230682865,
0.0328840464,
0.0024870872,
-0.0469881743,
-0.0259446222,
0.0074086012,
-0.00930796,
-0.0098254178,
0.0077373143,
0.0501966476,
0.0406045765,
0.0266057402,
0.0000020743,
0.0337428339,
-0.0004201707,
-0.0039836811,
-0.0347116366,
-0.0024206743,
0.0422034897,
-0.0896470472,
0.0021684514,
-0.0055132871,
-0.0007954602,
-0.0670677051,
0.0432674997,
0.1107899994,
0.0601351559,
0.0650404245,
-0.0119659519,
-0.0371519439,
0.0059951195,
-0.0752535835,
-0.0359268636,
-0.0188782383,
-0.0114388885,
-0.0329669081,
-0.0598154552,
0.0412751175,
-0.0752633289,
0.0310689732,
0.0631149784,
0.0089377342,
0.0327989385,
0.0635824278,
-0.0211559013,
-0.0124679133,
0.0013717687,
0.0600941144,
-0.0799833238,
-0.0479285382,
-0.0357380025,
-0.0028079015,
0.0038041135,
0.0030118464,
-0.0308793578,
0.0220997017,
0.0236388892,
0.0223370846,
0.0012200291,
0.0516949594,
0.0258327313,
-0.0103722662,
-0.0449038744,
-0.022082977,
0.0098520638,
-0.0260089226,
-0.0040850043,
-0.0216017254,
-0.0366100967,
-0.0141810104,
0.003093705,
0.014499221,
0.0191382244,
0.0004931758,
-0.0494223051,
-0.0704878867,
0.0059949793,
-0.0583692268,
0.0229166392,
0.0329567529,
0.0439612903,
0.032830216,
-0.0127290748,
0.047391735,
-0.0341198258,
0.0350893587,
-0.0385683589,
-0.0310546588,
-0.008077316,
-0.0294238031,
-0.0526425689,
0.0353841186,
-0.0468612611,
-0.0008456719,
0.0108985184,
0.0282610673,
-0.0279418491,
-0.0022206625,
-0.0299920756,
0.0355327092,
-0.042877432,
-0.0170166381,
0.0169117432,
0.0250418335,
-0.0597157516,
-0.0130573818,
0.0136075476,
-0.0293163396,
-0.0628071129,
0.0446545929,
0.0171675701,
-0.0226667318,
0.0080045937,
0.0768530741,
-0.0309430789,
-0.0078497129,
0.0033294472,
0.0164153129,
0.012575699,
-0.0452698395,
0.0099193119,
-0.0363446958,
0.062537469,
-0.0140374443,
-0.0192589909,
-0.0377746522,
-0.0231188294,
0.0369808003,
-0.0228727721,
0.0803184137,
0.0551173799,
-0.0394203514,
0.045135919,
0.0300057307,
0.0009664419,
0.0497393906,
0.0227772947,
0.0222968068,
-0.0232018605,
-0.0325769149,
0.0104444679,
0.0153191527,
0.0591660179,
0.0100119673,
-0.0311827809,
-0.0249460898,
-0.0411191471,
0.013986228,
0.0812717453,
0.0837508664,
-0.0605037175,
-0.0569415502,
0.0399028882,
0.0420276821,
0.0238359664,
0.0673438534,
0.0294921175,
0.0445561185,
-0.0163701531,
0.0198540036,
-0.0396523625,
0.0623379536,
0.0212103073,
0.0007501663,
0.0077014817,
0.0033788588,
-0.0609909967,
-0.0192293394,
0.0209492072,
-0.0156897232,
0.0509674065,
-0.0263506696,
0.0179949049,
0.0434527025,
-0.0228035543,
0.0599288084,
0.0008443699,
0.0065011284,
-0.0027902985,
-0.0016447203,
-0.0069135129,
-0.0071668653,
0.0192487389,
0.0011870132,
0.0197733007,
-0.0201664343,
0.0067207287,
0.0736750513,
0.0240666326,
0.0034039146,
0.0174597222,
-0.0332362242,
0.0025664715,
-0.0425598286,
-0.0098188352,
0.0285048261,
-0.0226962529,
-0.0141365053,
0.0271546058,
-0.0412733331,
0.0009663946,
0.0438739546,
-0.0060669393,
-0.0295103174,
0.0095766326,
0.0352043323,
0.0359147266,
-0.0033525371,
-0.0096993344,
0.0178577937,
0.0335246101,
-0.0686775297,
-0.0511829779,
-0.0072824247,
-0.0762207434,
-0.0663970485,
-0.007910518,
-0.0764029101,
0.0045087859,
0.0530481264,
-0.037525557,
-0.0446720868,
0.05439464,
-0.0466895141,
0.0705200508,
-0.0424592271,
-0.0110860411,
0.0268804841,
0.0494190529,
-0.0219128076,
0.0670797154,
-0.0428434834,
0.0176216178,
-0.0042137783,
0.0368187204,
0.019796798,
-0.0018581598,
-0.011193946,
0.023051884,
-0.0019454492,
0.0127598057,
0.0158010498,
-0.0200561397,
-0.00694911,
-0.0049157753,
-0.068962656,
-0.0186358579,
-0.0380397998,
-0.0082779108,
0.0216751434,
0.0263953339,
0.0354855284,
-0.0144285327,
-0.0308221783,
-0.017527651,
-0.0452341698,
0.0231502187,
0.0320755243,
-0.0252132658,
0.0294773299,
-0.0250863545,
-0.0427934267,
0.0038100008,
0.0766883418,
-0.0379958712,
-0.0095107807,
-0.0244724713,
-0.036093358,
0.0097849518,
0.0528399013,
-0.0340497382,
-0.0618058369,
-0.0098988255,
0.0013099076,
0.0469068885,
0.0562077761,
0.0296274666,
0.0501931086,
0.0628948212,
0.0788308606,
-0.0502708107,
0.0279531553,
-0.0297938269,
0.0318952464,
0.0009836346,
0.005266503,
0.0075974124,
0.1000356749,
0.0029178357,
0.0075635333,
-0.0853918493,
0.0003731653,
0.0136676189,
-0.0318769775,
-0.0150711192,
-0.009712127,
-0.0270822588,
-0.0019174748,
-0.0475427024,
-0.0146208499,
0.0716829672,
-0.0109940432,
-0.033229854,
-0.0447661839,
-0.0253298283,
-0.0147942305,
0.0484939069,
0.0538576841,
0.0449481532,
0.0369901732,
-0.057912536,
-0.0578234605,
0.0279761795,
-0.0247595068,
0.0063614328,
0.0321183279,
0.025699826,
-0.0103764534,
-0.0092339385,
-0.0412353203,
-0.0292964336,
-0.0498136692,
0.0279260129,
0.0234862808,
0.0473855361,
-0.0083992919,
-0.0655440763,
-0.0184573065,
0.0159822516,
0.054616943,
0.0054483321,
-0.0148889311,
-0.0308695044,
0.0362785533,
0.0525188595,
0.0434937254,
0.0327268243,
-0.0270860605,
0.0621633902,
0.0661184415,
-0.007730017,
0.0242246725,
-0.0302780662,
0.0087512443,
0.0092294496,
-0.0234394819,
0.0138584115,
-0.0130808204,
0.0342111774,
-0.035457585,
-0.0327752344,
0.098767899,
-0.0055097123,
-0.0700681582,
0.0368183367,
-0.039284233,
0.0820253417,
0.0163927525,
0.0177139733,
-0.0323130339,
-0.017630579,
-0.0189916436,
0.0100477366,
0.0438123047,
0.0001162714,
0.0112012867,
-0.0703599304,
-0.0016750809,
0.0145380758,
-0.0451976396,
-0.0287492946,
-0.0393097661,
-0.0205131415,
0.0024776307,
0.0390911028,
-0.0082843471,
-0.0009066427,
-0.0322917998,
0.0076169432,
-0.0340339728,
-0.0235404186,
-0.0029635385,
-0.0408678576,
0.0051107537,
0.0091577964,
0.0269168094,
-0.0238382276,
-0.012002293,
0.0276911817,
-0.0555590652,
-0.0132682621,
0.0096433982,
0.072139211,
-0.0125061702,
-0.01049753,
-0.0116763236,
0.0181772504,
-0.023269726,
-0.0349835344,
-0.0480581336,
0.0534596145,
-0.0211895406,
-0.0237495508,
-0.0246408451,
-0.0244708546,
-0.0356162861,
0.0787081197,
0.0508340783,
-0.052075509,
-0.036904037,
-0.0280245617,
0.0427125692,
-0.0339771658,
-0.0121490825,
0.034267921,
0.0429411568,
-0.0458746552,
-0.0589221157,
-0.046551697,
-0.0063539399,
0.0302198082,
-0.0199013613,
-0.0163590107,
0.0130589288,
-0.0384302102,
-0.0321996249,
0.0024269263,
0.000597344,
-0.0315027423,
-0.0120105911,
-0.0196254216,
0.0104315728,
-0.008991695,
-0.0242933556,
-0.0062476979,
-0.050591927,
-0.055144906,
-0.0277590975,
0.0194933582,
0.0048999321,
0.0898919255,
-0.0401017182,
-0.0539947562,
0.0909150541,
-0.0194165166,
-0.0116324062,
0.0004387422,
0.0284557343,
-0.0415797941,
0.0080631329,
0.0559156165,
-0.012076647,
0.0052185012,
0.0079175467,
0.0240694936,
-0.0404648297,
0.0361764729,
0.0283187255,
-0.0563399345,
0.0069332323,
-0.0141798612,
0.0061497116,
0.0055365129,
0.0031127511,
-0.0124881603,
-0.0099803414,
-0.0355505086,
-0.0081452141,
0.0283754971,
-0.0060632895,
0.0010615303,
0.0018808339,
0.0415612236,
0.0128260385,
0.0057851523,
0.0228670016,
-0.0316645615,
-0.005916554,
-0.0049521537,
0.0379379205,
-0.0214841235,
-0.0275217071,
-0.0204127729,
0.0185396299,
-0.0308566336,
0.0156135978,
0.0394675396,
0.0217473153,
-0.0463498756,
0.0290229116,
-0.0750552416,
-0.0314676799,
-0.0183003172,
-0.0230922289,
0.0394870676,
-0.0286733229,
0.0276165418,
-0.0144122494,
0.0003464101,
0.0014499422,
0.0006653418,
-0.0192600358,
-0.0433293767,
0.0287953559,
0.017439561,
-0.0164609291,
-0.019663712,
0.0706147924,
0.012932458,
0.0191789158,
-0.0151087455,
0.0245619975,
-0.0545055345,
0.0015244944,
0.0076990728,
0.0646879002,
-0.0033935071,
0.0047919317,
0.0061639082,
-0.0728971362,
0.020674007,
0.0069648754,
-0.0041897539,
0.0041921884,
0.0516291335,
0.0264703874,
0.00147041,
-0.020345239,
-0.0268630292,
0.0241717044,
0.0327012576,
-0.0215753857,
-0.0376271382,
-6.799785193e-33,
-0.0438002311,
0.0052496362,
-0.0337076411,
-0.0119053777,
-0.0407101735,
0.0230745766,
-0.0635610446,
0.0029452401,
-0.0316136479,
0.0277354531,
-0.0307898913,
0.0355383232,
-0.013002296,
0.0521798693,
0.0000929126,
-0.0328871533,
0.0554441176,
-0.0032357564,
-0.0120829362,
0.0176158883,
0.0224531237,
0.0204845332,
0.0573072135,
-0.0534677878,
-0.0135630229,
-0.0066294423,
0.0185788162,
0.0024326246,
0.0409514159,
0.0570885614,
-0.0425966196,
0.0261422526,
0.0250753425,
-0.0512084849,
-0.0193350054,
0.0214457959,
-0.1035819277,
-0.053054858,
-0.0160254557,
0.0362799726,
-0.0596852824,
-0.0305343084,
0.0998067632,
-0.0153647624,
0.0324418172,
-0.0455380306,
0.0183194391,
0.0111880461,
-0.0309613254,
-0.0135723343,
-0.0523510203,
-0.0063426746,
-0.0174183901,
0.0066881739,
0.0337107964,
0.0354092717,
-0.0008562399,
0.0250141937,
-0.0779079795,
-0.0386014357,
-0.0160945766,
0.0511346273,
0.0390371643,
0.0291690659,
0.0038668653,
0.0455131717,
0.0058626365,
-0.0032546162,
-0.0474520884,
0.0132920006,
0.0429937802,
0.0194304958,
0.057695087,
-0.0159434807,
0.0475554913,
0.0034539178,
-0.066846773,
0.0094231246,
-0.0335703976,
0.0813727826,
0.0072552818,
0.0293034203,
-0.0191092454,
-0.0173500385,
-0.0267473459,
-0.0320919454,
-0.0164142977,
-0.0368950553,
0.0099070156,
0.0120216059,
-0.006383515,
0.0044268174,
0.021008864,
-0.0283323899,
-0.0103071621,
0.0426162556,
0.0197566338,
0.0224689115,
0.0283679385,
0.0228158273,
-0.0423154458,
0.0062571629,
0.0108966064,
0.0109314416,
0.0266295709,
0.0241331346,
0.0588756874,
0.0179880317,
-0.0554613955,
-0.0257775839,
-0.0329013541,
-0.0300828256,
-0.0262583513,
0.0501586087,
0.0452265926,
0.0166388843,
-0.0216594227,
0.0073112277,
0.0032419437,
0.0066607371,
-0.0171648394,
0.0402920246,
0.0100180693,
0.0460504815,
-0.0250939634,
-0.0315010138,
-0.0493490957,
0.0013838599,
0.072400406,
-0.0857313201,
-0.011941853,
0.0230878405,
2.768e-7,
0.0288049225,
0.0376444682,
0.0264310259,
0.0127724223,
0.0216637347,
0.0405764654,
0.015692642,
0.0538481288,
-0.0438797101,
-0.0265411884,
0.0131176813,
0.03655155,
0.0280807242,
-0.0017912327,
-0.1110496074,
0.0160779003,
-0.0578317568,
0.0077091926,
-0.0050783437,
0.0056455215,
0.0733996406,
0.154726252,
-0.0061093755,
0.0118903881,
0.014141175,
0.0075633395,
0.0798088312,
-0.0072375974,
0.022345094,
0.0160447489,
0.0034551506,
0.0171522666,
-0.0030770088,
0.0049855495,
-0.0334036313,
0.0163822304,
0.0226160865,
0.0436235629,
-0.0281247348,
-0.0543290637,
0.0099852588,
-0.0112808486,
-0.0116122272,
-0.0341379717,
0.0687730163,
-0.0541030765,
-0.0494925827,
0.021745611,
-0.0345003083,
0.051083684,
0.0168629549,
0.0022992874,
-0.0436102711,
-0.0000017952,
0.0237342771,
-0.0023884221,
-0.0022044962,
-0.0863551497,
-0.0136741055,
0.0086494852,
-0.0541885607,
0.0470651388,
-0.054828532,
-0.0141335791,
0.0632534549,
-0.0189025998,
-0.0321157612,
2.357904374e-34,
0.0197561886,
-0.0007004389,
0.0132157942,
0.0460460521,
-0.0064295903,
-0.0438806824,
0.0059608105,
-0.0109537821,
0.0118684275,
-0.062636286,
-0.0130315591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17279v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17279v2 | Automatic Logical Forms improve fidelity in Table-to-Text generation | 2023-10-26T10:00:24 | 2024-01-09T10:23:20 | Iñigo Alonso, Eneko Agirre | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table-to-text systems generate natural language statements from structured
data like tables. While end-to-end techniques suffer from low factual
correctness (fidelity), a previous study reported gains when using manual
logical forms (LF) that represent the selected content and the semantics of the
target text. Given the manual step, it was not clear whether automatic LFs
would be effective, or whether the improvement came from content selection
alone. We present TlT which, given a table and a selection of the content,
first produces LFs and then the textual statement. We show for the first time
that automatic LFs improve quality, with an increase in fidelity of 30 points
over a comparable system not using LFs. Our experiments allow to quantify the
remaining challenges for high factual correctness, with automatic selection of
content coming first, followed by better Logic-to-Text generation and, to a
lesser extent, better Table-to-Logic parsing. | [
0.0123146297,
0.047295507,
-0.0044325613,
-0.0029994315,
-0.0588274039,
0.0027167781,
-0.0200821441,
-0.0078969318,
-0.0005273129,
-0.0365176275,
0.010839276,
0.0051663574,
0.0260276739,
0.0436451659,
0.0492267236,
-0.0119708544,
0.0638286769,
0.0153750107,
-0.0430378132,
0.0549353138,
0.0061153304,
0.0439443626,
-0.010553997,
0.0036696172,
-0.0303576607,
0.0148735931,
-0.0381078236,
-0.0103000794,
-0.0045606336,
-0.0344040617,
-0.0436387323,
0.0534245558,
-0.0033492553,
-0.0515615419,
0.0000019134,
-0.0217388235,
-0.0476388671,
0.0103344582,
-0.0063454872,
-0.0111789964,
0.0369180292,
-0.0302895643,
-0.0090000425,
0.0023476044,
-0.0373075828,
0.0316298679,
0.0312262531,
0.0396802537,
0.0710777864,
0.0541850738,
-0.0182267763,
-0.0186066553,
-0.0097611556,
0.0216951296,
0.0329741314,
0.0119029852,
-0.0408144034,
0.018015001,
0.0183365401,
-0.0268687382,
0.0539078787,
0.0149820475,
0.016263308,
-0.0448205732,
0.034114182,
0.0275257938,
-0.0319269635,
-0.0228183512,
0.0229294058,
0.0745325834,
0.0155346654,
-0.0299943127,
0.0268040933,
-0.0115163988,
0.0084631173,
-0.0413159877,
-0.0071602729,
0.0505313613,
-0.0333488286,
0.0075496193,
0.0544646457,
-0.0269776266,
-0.0014227304,
-0.0020878979,
-0.0137281036,
0.063440986,
-0.0153586902,
-0.0443181358,
0.0280958079,
0.0188299324,
-0.0005726835,
-0.0851525292,
0.0219900217,
0.0258185733,
-0.065899305,
0.0103109283,
-0.0753389746,
-0.0383947231,
0.0065262318,
-0.0555780753,
0.0332978927,
0.056197796,
0.0006862231,
-0.0154235391,
-0.036264088,
0.0073003881,
0.0182363186,
0.0400608703,
-0.0346692502,
0.0193547849,
-0.0363475345,
0.019003747,
-0.0414518788,
0.0538383871,
-0.0780204982,
-0.0071010459,
-0.0001581351,
-0.0051180087,
-0.0069436943,
0.04717388,
0.0099177193,
0.0126354359,
-0.0379251987,
0.0193814542,
-0.0410444327,
0.0003499738,
-0.0223151445,
0.0002703607,
0.0423298366,
-0.0592789911,
-0.0072143329,
-0.0006783403,
0.0308210049,
0.0060963025,
0.0048648072,
0.0474443436,
-0.0796995908,
0.0309097283,
-0.0901986659,
-0.06318672,
-0.0161460023,
-0.0532085598,
-0.0095750755,
-0.0525080189,
0.0401103906,
0.0175357293,
-0.0273476932,
-0.0417490564,
0.0215759426,
0.0573221706,
0.0120565146,
0.0375420451,
-0.0380730592,
0.0158156157,
-0.012842129,
-0.0465431474,
-0.0215991456,
0.0367255583,
0.0378002338,
0.0318423323,
-0.0113020828,
0.0089660343,
-0.0467608385,
0.0062457519,
0.0270082951,
-0.00854808,
-0.0194853451,
0.0486890152,
-0.026391428,
0.0448324196,
0.0431399383,
0.0368433297,
-0.0087866886,
0.0905273482,
0.0498649403,
-0.0163164083,
0.0672313869,
0.0738792196,
0.0487908311,
0.0276759528,
0.0164220091,
0.0460486971,
-0.0554835647,
0.0409948491,
0.0116058411,
0.0385768004,
0.0438076407,
0.0030092061,
0.0192194358,
-0.0463965498,
-0.0045258608,
0.0116634481,
0.0287952553,
-0.0130206747,
-0.0134998569,
0.0540979281,
-0.0569962263,
0.0424368009,
0.0083042942,
-0.0690600052,
0.017454993,
-0.0166502558,
0.0356445983,
0.0560067296,
0.0084562479,
-0.0180725586,
0.0115204165,
-0.0075043505,
0.0163401347,
0.0403051265,
0.0583106801,
-0.0211766083,
-0.0006078861,
-0.0030750132,
-0.013260629,
0.0131117394,
0.0139331706,
-0.0157368518,
-0.0074722664,
0.0090895128,
0.0286396109,
-0.0285051111,
-0.0364667252,
0.033677768,
0.0439933799,
0.0076218634,
0.0177507624,
0.0058428762,
0.0199766885,
0.0276155081,
-0.0174121745,
0.0415444672,
-0.0190270934,
0.0066491798,
-0.0184545442,
0.0024620041,
-0.0383327529,
-0.0108111892,
0.0046060658,
-0.0222936869,
-0.0675023347,
-0.0224352516,
-0.0460528545,
-0.042226404,
-0.0082089575,
-0.0742163807,
-0.0465416498,
-0.0281841885,
0.0041212607,
0.0450570956,
-0.0371753648,
0.0124537488,
0.0792900845,
0.0218564831,
-0.026636105,
0.0377630815,
-0.0439797267,
0.0332622044,
-0.0708922222,
0.1102564633,
-0.0146081401,
-0.022528952,
0.0030737694,
0.0260234214,
0.0417868309,
-0.0672911406,
-0.0102941738,
-0.0596554391,
-0.0037950666,
-0.0277222898,
0.0197252091,
0.0335487686,
-0.0075941007,
0.0124832531,
0.0208294019,
-0.0711723492,
-0.0368733332,
0.0373871587,
-0.0094267922,
0.0791214108,
0.0017043912,
0.015362313,
-0.0501543432,
-0.0058942097,
-0.0298464689,
-0.0206708126,
0.0509564318,
-0.0174465012,
-0.030114824,
0.0217335448,
-0.0229099579,
0.0025270737,
0.0433614925,
-0.008822565,
-0.0073620006,
-0.0087128654,
-0.0030965293,
0.0520131998,
0.0140843866,
-0.006869039,
0.0256763101,
0.001081759,
-0.0226253904,
0.0187109187,
0.002518174,
0.0572263747,
-0.0027110779,
-0.1027080417,
0.0594039932,
0.0051576542,
0.0268162414,
0.0235760994,
-0.0211881679,
0.0346793458,
-0.0116548566,
-0.0023361116,
-0.0085477326,
0.0209443718,
0.0036112568,
0.0421104208,
-0.0276059415,
0.0016812857,
0.035222128,
-0.0226500761,
0.0164379124,
-0.0415402129,
0.0197960474,
-0.0393500254,
0.0273745954,
0.0046036397,
0.0100591537,
0.0136174057,
-0.0383901708,
-0.0709760934,
-0.0237996206,
0.0637790114,
-0.0049073724,
0.0928229988,
-0.0855830759,
0.033188317,
-0.0338399485,
-0.0399491824,
-0.0172712486,
-0.016259132,
-0.0088090058,
0.0397117808,
0.0254999194,
-0.0091307238,
-0.0023372464,
-0.047156252,
0.0362377129,
0.0262005348,
-0.009118353,
-0.0305680744,
-0.0296213515,
0.0039013464,
0.0257036928,
0.0271155071,
-0.0179970767,
0.0114833154,
0.0025459542,
0.0421787314,
-0.0402348936,
0.0097292829,
-0.0002589102,
0.0270220283,
-0.0212927014,
-0.0376830436,
-0.0383801274,
0.0491618365,
-0.0067581707,
-0.0534699969,
-0.0224527344,
0.0803026259,
0.0222050678,
0.0769503117,
-0.0161989629,
0.0148070818,
0.0267554075,
0.0007483184,
0.0356185734,
-0.1017370448,
-0.0321456529,
0.0185102262,
0.0265550911,
-0.0157213025,
-0.0353494957,
-0.0077149584,
-0.1214265004,
0.0557151139,
-0.0030408688,
-0.0541907214,
-0.0866911039,
-0.0244258661,
-0.0282359328,
-0.0034155753,
0.0168071762,
0.0496572368,
-0.0431042537,
0.0173625629,
-0.0032228536,
-0.0630099475,
0.0133550847,
-0.0289604738,
-0.0352458842,
0.016615944,
0.0925510824,
0.0534597524,
0.0079291472,
-0.0226652883,
-0.0039179362,
0.0206347015,
0.0158259887,
-0.0267468076,
0.0410484895,
0.0198698007,
0.0225195512,
-0.0029391623,
0.0012800664,
0.0143330134,
0.0195826292,
-0.0034656823,
0.0245714635,
-0.0391916297,
-0.0155744832,
-0.0061454237,
0.022859389,
0.0177032631,
0.0440196395,
0.0294000097,
0.0130472807,
-0.0686152428,
-0.0486251637,
-0.0215659235,
-0.0965155438,
0.0022022799,
0.066273883,
-0.0503130965,
-0.0409694463,
-0.0887463614,
-0.0252424758,
0.0277609881,
0.0489822328,
0.013628142,
-0.0039027997,
0.0205535069,
-0.0029436362,
-0.0067316643,
-0.0103177195,
-0.0233568028,
0.0192722753,
-0.0262184497,
-0.0294809733,
-0.0340575129,
-0.0405740812,
-0.0059155403,
0.0223565884,
-0.0073298523,
-0.0093685593,
0.003285184,
0.0221363679,
0.0211066827,
0.0047806888,
0.0319296941,
0.0022596577,
-0.0143994559,
0.0243207384,
-0.0510903783,
-0.0239593517,
0.0005389957,
-0.0030068525,
0.0111750029,
0.0330166183,
-0.0386964642,
-0.0019698297,
-0.024540104,
0.0505523905,
0.0461090729,
-0.0021952188,
0.0721214339,
0.0501747765,
-0.0153347142,
0.0016314604,
-0.0047061527,
-0.0115048699,
0.0122832814,
-0.0927546024,
-0.0485449731,
-0.0411487333,
0.0343648531,
0.0000323435,
0.0403593294,
0.0244488716,
-0.0075599332,
-0.0453000404,
0.0442744754,
0.0117589226,
-0.0114160702,
0.026259657,
0.0120172314,
0.0503374599,
-0.0345029831,
-0.0470452681,
-0.0096028214,
0.0072659063,
0.039056588,
-0.0301127359,
0.0379037,
0.035646975,
-0.0152618205,
-0.0459139422,
0.0002794324,
-0.0178010538,
-0.0110174026,
-0.0180819239,
-0.0350101367,
0.0417883806,
0.0042927661,
0.0641780421,
-0.0666354373,
-0.0063701947,
0.0174622945,
0.0726445392,
0.0618395396,
-0.0401455015,
-0.009640553,
-0.0337159038,
-0.0127967801,
-0.0855755061,
0.0385901295,
0.0004831518,
-0.0318725109,
-0.026883686,
-0.0385490842,
-0.0409648456,
-0.0345461108,
-0.0363266505,
-0.0264116395,
-0.0219781641,
-0.0551016144,
-0.0413454026,
-0.0442708805,
0.0561129004,
0.0533448793,
0.0044203643,
-0.0292282682,
0.0630274862,
0.0544102713,
0.0459924005,
-0.0650061667,
-0.0282177441,
0.0366337597,
0.0046129557,
-0.0448878482,
-0.0654120371,
-5.823303872e-33,
-0.0609365031,
-0.0117052495,
-0.0015079149,
-0.0058362475,
-0.0032516387,
-0.0424857363,
-0.0698382258,
0.0054616388,
0.0108609684,
0.0525034927,
-0.0242613927,
0.0190571062,
0.0329317264,
0.0097243628,
0.0025795607,
-0.0648961067,
0.0612631664,
-0.0176173691,
-0.0341545194,
0.002842705,
0.006828425,
-0.020304624,
-0.0084184837,
-0.0229086597,
0.0447900631,
0.0165732857,
-0.0060302662,
-0.0327504314,
-0.0241956413,
0.0025211927,
0.0419466197,
0.0210923869,
0.0167392157,
-0.0155345956,
-0.0420358106,
0.0259362012,
-0.0922982469,
-0.016143417,
0.0026443719,
-0.017373642,
-0.0436540395,
-0.0262853466,
0.0213117767,
-0.0265608355,
-0.0222024117,
-0.0350360945,
0.0305675864,
-0.0155012179,
0.0014077033,
-0.0495058037,
-0.0632891729,
0.0168401375,
0.0068473844,
0.0038485364,
0.0076913894,
0.0553242452,
0.0042960308,
-0.0500853918,
-0.0229244027,
0.0144525068,
0.0017554646,
0.0082210414,
0.052844815,
-0.0402738862,
-0.0211770535,
0.0155303553,
0.0302493386,
0.0314561315,
-0.0522289835,
0.068483308,
-0.0441105291,
0.0799874365,
0.0350222252,
0.0366615653,
0.0174092371,
-0.0131649924,
-0.0772691071,
0.0467075706,
-0.0510955714,
0.0120706344,
-0.0391330421,
-0.0394650809,
-0.0138082365,
-0.0242904034,
-0.0296357162,
0.0383632481,
-0.0049702153,
-0.0260543264,
0.0215859972,
0.0054551535,
0.0166336279,
-0.0608334728,
-0.0024385736,
0.0350338183,
-0.0379622728,
-0.0058577517,
-0.0417333506,
0.0125766583,
-0.0179674271,
-0.00001155,
-0.0432284884,
-0.0306198131,
0.0227414034,
0.0285649933,
0.0526828207,
0.0385315493,
0.0188059509,
0.0385120958,
-0.0481397323,
0.0261745099,
-0.0343054682,
0.0619372725,
-0.0204240717,
-0.0015032658,
0.0222120676,
-0.0087234676,
0.0032545822,
0.0303287711,
-0.0272351373,
-0.0128268572,
-0.0462583527,
0.0232565459,
0.0318348259,
0.0127579849,
0.008946456,
0.0254077297,
-0.0552986823,
0.0061587337,
0.0249871816,
-0.0154941734,
-0.0042490214,
0.0088788047,
2.505e-7,
0.0494610816,
-0.0025836979,
0.0445766374,
0.112422809,
-0.0162739251,
0.0303487852,
0.0192493796,
0.0271337777,
-0.0082009351,
0.0021020307,
0.0054987441,
-0.0366188027,
0.063440375,
0.0612560213,
-0.026781667,
-0.0267775431,
-0.0317310616,
0.0082360739,
-0.034521725,
0.00815045,
0.0636982173,
0.0352990106,
-0.0731195137,
0.0045720167,
0.0205680858,
-0.0125112431,
0.0217080321,
0.0049115801,
0.0271407552,
0.0211015958,
0.0590331033,
-0.0507579558,
-0.024424864,
0.0432822704,
-0.0689828023,
-0.0531553775,
-0.005190501,
0.0563402735,
0.0134975091,
0.0067363968,
-0.0209686738,
-0.0662226379,
0.0420106202,
-0.0270161647,
0.0687466189,
-0.0669780821,
0.0194494408,
0.0755824223,
-0.0247512497,
0.0251997728,
-0.0274894424,
0.0056578172,
-0.0203966778,
0.0064465757,
0.0557422116,
0.0242267903,
0.0116202757,
-0.0174418073,
-0.0434055887,
0.026416678,
-0.0051225787,
-0.0263613053,
-0.0111239254,
0.0344977714,
0.0207170211,
-0.0210147332,
-0.0538784415,
2.141847134e-34,
0.0246025138,
-0.0015899471,
0.0431942008,
-0.0270007495,
0.0924439207,
0.0039295363,
0.0093411701,
0.0185346473,
0.0017784957,
-0.0356510244,
-0.027231209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17271v1 | Understanding the Role of Input Token Characters in Language Models: How Does Information Loss Affect Performance? | 2023-10-26T09:47:50 | 2023-10-26T09:47:50 | Ahmed Alajrami, Katerina Margatina, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding how and what pre-trained language models (PLMs) learn about
language is an open challenge in natural language processing. Previous work has
focused on identifying whether they capture semantic and syntactic information,
and how the data or the pre-training objective affects their performance.
However, to the best of our knowledge, no previous work has specifically
examined how information loss in input token characters affects the performance
of PLMs. In this study, we address this gap by pre-training language models
using small subsets of characters from individual tokens. Surprisingly, we find
that pre-training even under extreme settings, i.e. using only one character of
each token, the performance retention in standard NLU benchmarks and probing
tasks compared to full-token models is high. For instance, a model pre-trained
only on single first characters from tokens achieves performance retention of
approximately $90$\% and $77$\% of the full-token model in SuperGLUE and GLUE
tasks, respectively. | [
0.0398433581,
0.0629776642,
-0.0198410768,
0.0133907283,
-0.036345467,
-0.0137257958,
0.0365360864,
0.0224358346,
-0.0587489381,
-0.0350653455,
-0.0218837913,
-0.0690351501,
0.0204237811,
0.0290994905,
0.0640875995,
-0.0330655351,
0.0836805478,
-0.0438098796,
0.0232486799,
-0.0025425081,
0.0085657146,
-0.0028643622,
0.0223682225,
0.0409694538,
-0.078534089,
0.0096727666,
-0.0017931624,
0.0156578552,
-0.0470359102,
-0.0276953112,
-0.002270445,
0.0411797203,
-0.0022383928,
0.0093836198,
0.0000018531,
-0.055579979,
-0.0057278206,
-0.0326939486,
-0.05965285,
0.0442400761,
0.0421557426,
-0.0076531055,
-0.0123440493,
0.0320978314,
-0.0016183091,
-0.0320620015,
0.0343821682,
0.0388615057,
0.0020963866,
0.0552503206,
-0.003578116,
0.0150073562,
0.0158705935,
-0.0311902314,
0.0174731296,
0.005312107,
0.0238373093,
-0.049124673,
-0.0396651775,
-0.0384882987,
-0.0151617033,
0.0232935976,
0.0112363547,
0.011346329,
-0.0251900889,
0.0658102408,
-0.0297071617,
-0.0469859689,
-0.0273937061,
0.0274472721,
-0.097295396,
-0.0364492536,
-0.0327032618,
-0.0185798313,
-0.004408428,
-0.0271259453,
-0.0321602821,
0.0061157644,
0.0330211073,
0.0174499787,
-0.0008401536,
-0.003287138,
0.0552771799,
0.0052483547,
-0.0544950403,
0.0589838512,
0.0164143555,
-0.0196873657,
0.0184646659,
-0.0189215019,
-0.0376863591,
-0.0454175733,
0.0014440023,
0.0147037823,
0.0018140745,
0.0246584602,
-0.036027316,
-0.0289020892,
0.0333452374,
-0.0173524357,
0.0262226835,
0.0506771058,
-0.0160720348,
0.018691007,
-0.0760956332,
0.0553376526,
0.0267229248,
0.0687801093,
-0.0210505556,
-0.0205760263,
-0.0139953028,
-0.0687504783,
-0.0282343607,
0.080720976,
-0.0127620995,
-0.0236204993,
-0.0002491917,
0.0005416098,
0.0187030882,
-0.0069876639,
-0.0153350737,
0.0097453464,
-0.0313248411,
0.0133051602,
-0.0405638218,
0.0127344504,
-0.0420256555,
0.0615897849,
0.0058820574,
-0.0736023039,
-0.0529742241,
0.022527229,
0.0086968103,
-0.0367088951,
0.0410157815,
0.0915287584,
-0.0036627741,
-0.077285111,
-0.0309995059,
-0.0051410021,
-0.0029792467,
-0.0671079159,
-0.0030123913,
-0.0481650643,
0.0439316295,
0.0127986092,
-0.010066459,
-0.0642243773,
0.0032394629,
0.0142170312,
-0.0151991835,
0.0790030137,
-0.0152819566,
0.0035769714,
0.0044948864,
-0.012879543,
0.0182323121,
0.0415970609,
-0.0051082843,
0.0572947785,
0.0318756066,
-0.0297066327,
-0.004663893,
0.0468778759,
0.035302788,
-0.0187641084,
-0.0294924024,
-0.0073846742,
0.0420210883,
0.0250120312,
0.0575412847,
0.0751554072,
-0.0378575921,
-0.0106722713,
0.0621149279,
0.1057366356,
0.0063493913,
0.009678877,
0.0325146578,
-0.0128796613,
0.0260927211,
-0.0079118675,
-0.0766362026,
-0.0258825123,
0.0230383053,
0.0213454161,
0.0215345137,
0.0055231475,
-0.0314455815,
-0.0352815315,
-0.0186820105,
-0.0437296852,
0.0112678166,
-0.0322601534,
0.0562235042,
0.0131538548,
-0.0638218448,
0.0818933696,
0.0301930383,
-0.0480720438,
0.0337346755,
-0.0315685309,
0.0111668175,
0.0304076653,
0.0332756303,
-0.0340378024,
-0.0181069244,
0.0174644366,
0.0042074835,
0.0017920333,
0.020836914,
0.0136185968,
0.0617178455,
-0.0217440929,
0.0305971596,
0.0071015903,
0.0102662249,
0.0343729481,
0.0152569851,
-0.0125427088,
0.0174241867,
-0.047290124,
-0.0256075636,
0.0685610622,
-0.0177340675,
-0.0220624171,
-0.0039016677,
-0.0123195527,
0.0256559048,
0.00452501,
-0.005887846,
0.0392031297,
0.0637287349,
-0.0465353504,
0.0125405909,
-0.0030835648,
-0.0815611258,
-0.0218276009,
0.0641259253,
0.0055385791,
0.0282543469,
0.0385703854,
0.0131764123,
-0.0395860113,
0.0078166397,
-0.0085761705,
0.107610628,
-0.0368326753,
0.0295487456,
-0.0017396363,
0.0206310414,
-0.0311866291,
0.0478629284,
-0.0114192283,
0.0358536653,
-0.0249466468,
0.0216667037,
0.0239442866,
-0.0313759334,
-0.0024403075,
-0.0055894828,
-0.0415299349,
-0.0055925259,
0.0157460775,
-0.0456759036,
-0.033967372,
-0.0071493234,
-0.0826004148,
0.0091023026,
-0.0215003025,
0.0350444801,
-0.0098138014,
0.0047572129,
-0.0392078198,
-0.0345217362,
0.0033330487,
-0.0381295532,
-0.0205810461,
0.0159380175,
0.0323282965,
0.015764581,
0.0100067509,
-0.0661289543,
-0.0174321141,
-0.0061196769,
0.0498035438,
-0.0391417816,
-0.0362784155,
-0.0108835334,
0.0238639526,
-0.0138380751,
0.0133739579,
0.0002701934,
-0.0768947303,
0.0129371937,
-0.0196936689,
0.042715095,
0.04654314,
-0.0047590164,
0.0270055663,
0.023648845,
-0.0180960912,
-0.0522201918,
0.0025636235,
-0.0262170397,
0.0243321396,
-0.0416931398,
-0.0025934009,
-0.0008662475,
0.0738734454,
-0.0051987804,
0.0127282599,
-0.0280118305,
0.022971835,
-0.006314571,
-0.0261806361,
-0.0270404108,
-0.0184220225,
-0.053172484,
0.0217952076,
-0.0357213505,
-0.0606767423,
0.0172948912,
-0.0729872137,
-0.0052995137,
0.0007526749,
0.0045309202,
-0.0051803123,
0.0578535572,
0.0639477968,
-0.0041351863,
-0.0132483644,
-0.0557636209,
-0.0226104185,
0.0351851769,
-0.0095234606,
-0.0126691274,
0.0060427026,
-0.0283227973,
0.0042974236,
-0.0094276266,
-0.0174721684,
-0.0269210171,
-0.0465923212,
-0.0220944844,
0.0299577713,
0.0310001709,
-0.0003537936,
-0.0133385919,
0.0080718827,
0.0025740163,
0.0579219125,
-0.0015840243,
0.0275151506,
-0.0329254456,
-0.0058936067,
0.0038583507,
-0.0144465109,
0.0148821296,
-0.0529790819,
-0.0005949102,
0.0371023566,
0.0428185537,
-0.0133805536,
-0.0092516411,
0.0087055592,
0.0266282093,
-0.0255848486,
-0.0081823729,
0.0202597585,
0.0597224385,
-0.0646175146,
-0.0149130356,
0.1071246043,
0.0502948165,
-0.0052435971,
0.017373614,
0.0443189293,
0.0411970355,
0.0297394209,
-0.0317450799,
-0.0346407481,
-0.0455359221,
0.0351689942,
0.0065670498,
-0.0172251575,
-0.0049944646,
-0.0007539029,
-0.0965652764,
-0.0420164429,
-0.0042711128,
-0.0775185376,
0.0097678797,
-0.059397269,
-0.0061569721,
-0.0139467139,
0.0648046806,
-0.00791818,
-0.0287042707,
0.0116382223,
0.045678515,
-0.0409396216,
-0.05336871,
0.0040255319,
-0.063042745,
0.0504817702,
0.0466966629,
-0.0044581955,
-0.0218006186,
-0.0015876632,
0.0841615945,
0.0228702147,
0.0439876653,
-0.0219897199,
0.0553876981,
-0.0040981169,
0.0104601504,
0.0217108093,
0.0155305862,
-0.0435759239,
-0.0294451434,
-0.0181776267,
0.0176818147,
0.0116929244,
-0.0006706694,
0.0070582065,
-0.0454539768,
-0.0307185184,
0.0889251381,
0.0490122251,
-0.041475784,
-0.0556003675,
-0.0238382556,
0.023890879,
-0.0501552522,
-0.0305510294,
-0.0080430657,
0.0102369292,
-0.0156601276,
-0.0316797234,
-0.0479988493,
0.0616977587,
0.0490522012,
-0.0149287488,
0.0231720097,
-0.0460446812,
-0.0104150213,
-0.035778258,
0.0520094968,
-0.013699959,
-0.0056382334,
-0.0997614413,
0.0126184123,
-0.0116211353,
-0.0126109254,
-0.0294226836,
-0.0263652094,
-0.0812287033,
-0.0646944419,
0.0330762602,
0.0742316172,
0.0269277245,
0.0279122852,
0.0022859646,
-0.0434516147,
0.0381336883,
0.0524179488,
-0.0683214515,
0.009088547,
0.0318494067,
-0.0645308569,
0.0089086546,
0.0205068067,
-0.0104269087,
0.0078950599,
0.0486076288,
0.0142724933,
0.0253216177,
0.0160717238,
0.0431943014,
0.0307077188,
0.08033517,
-0.0131942108,
0.002875237,
-0.0179177485,
0.0380102918,
-0.0136018582,
0.0139185209,
-0.0013024369,
-0.02645096,
0.0092433412,
0.03680126,
-0.0241496339,
-0.0207264666,
-0.0041422364,
0.0794708133,
-0.0007637108,
-0.0245576799,
0.0088635217,
0.0221705232,
0.0416307114,
-0.0003502192,
0.0006088753,
0.0026289492,
-0.0326653942,
0.0033593161,
-0.0465713367,
-0.0289437082,
0.0123659344,
0.0326317362,
-0.0366199017,
0.0179784205,
-0.030895168,
-0.0591650493,
-0.0311903991,
-0.0019255209,
0.0307117477,
-0.0668728501,
-0.0122168865,
-0.0235677604,
-0.0025648447,
-0.0467698686,
-0.011336701,
0.0049590454,
-0.0000079615,
0.0267005973,
0.0010850955,
-0.0469458662,
-0.0223800056,
0.096613653,
0.0371235535,
0.0509440303,
-0.014827461,
0.0087886667,
-0.0227607153,
0.0348936059,
0.0275096204,
0.0440948457,
-0.028500963,
0.0120118475,
-0.0477884226,
-0.0725766048,
0.0049909693,
-0.010998942,
0.0230646208,
0.0037271562,
0.0417862982,
0.0561466701,
-0.0010281879,
0.0157195665,
0.0017154933,
-0.0058566243,
0.0470237173,
0.0005073896,
0.0221429188,
-6.507168649e-33,
-0.0060314983,
0.0010193898,
-0.0048950743,
0.0032448801,
-0.0062524113,
0.0324178152,
-0.0313247629,
0.0094799688,
-0.0200567134,
-0.0085493131,
-0.0233739112,
0.0054810327,
0.0344552211,
0.0243974142,
0.0021280404,
0.0002306534,
0.0675215423,
-0.0069385641,
-0.0289916638,
-0.0168324411,
0.0276707336,
0.0611172058,
0.043209184,
0.0266698785,
-0.0159345046,
-0.0048680138,
0.0104886834,
0.019280415,
0.0125643611,
0.0482786335,
-0.0314278714,
0.0324232318,
0.0213512816,
-0.0200299527,
-0.0499905087,
0.0189495608,
-0.0942656249,
-0.0474846214,
0.0297944043,
-0.0016968107,
-0.0198001657,
-0.0207932293,
0.055065237,
-0.0118755158,
0.0022345772,
0.0299817901,
0.0060133478,
0.0095789088,
-0.0575053282,
-0.0042681787,
-0.0750805959,
0.0240150206,
-0.0007569505,
0.0149890855,
0.0499125645,
-0.0114963027,
0.0134676965,
0.0224481635,
-0.0536054298,
-0.0126708345,
0.0115492707,
0.083636947,
0.0152055724,
0.0096956128,
-0.0232880414,
0.0639034957,
0.0471782982,
0.00082833,
-0.0059797773,
0.0219188053,
0.0913474634,
-0.0170266349,
0.046460662,
-0.0155141279,
0.05859318,
-0.077575013,
-0.0747012645,
-0.0197848883,
0.0225717071,
0.0462176427,
0.0199173056,
0.0537897907,
-0.0067404495,
-0.0084302062,
-0.0611855723,
-0.0000842439,
-0.0150035461,
-0.03377942,
0.0351019837,
0.0330028236,
-0.0189307872,
0.0068376842,
0.0206494723,
0.0048868353,
-0.0128320018,
-0.024247352,
0.0218810607,
-0.0145430388,
-0.0081479056,
0.0310342349,
-0.1104135066,
-0.0534279644,
0.0101445187,
0.0018142014,
0.0256691147,
-0.0139801903,
0.03199986,
0.0258916877,
-0.0871070325,
-0.0077917324,
-0.0426752865,
0.0021506888,
0.0275992304,
0.0170193352,
0.0642563403,
0.0339253582,
0.0028809344,
0.0036930575,
0.0166662373,
-0.0531715564,
-0.0369725749,
0.0109185548,
0.0095659802,
0.0390284061,
-0.0371422246,
-0.0308041796,
-0.0543060228,
-0.0037832926,
0.0312302355,
-0.0528387167,
-0.0122243613,
0.0059141973,
2.592e-7,
0.0561216399,
0.0450914949,
0.050756719,
-0.00749317,
0.006301098,
0.0135438032,
-0.0431652628,
0.0062258076,
-0.0093220538,
0.0105985831,
-0.0134503068,
-0.0059271664,
0.0209573861,
0.0075682756,
-0.1093403846,
0.0348662063,
-0.0482752919,
0.0030215888,
-0.0508217849,
0.01039482,
0.0060738767,
0.1186964214,
-0.011038349,
-0.0213530045,
-0.013688297,
-0.0462124199,
0.0422329605,
-0.034471482,
-0.0027601698,
0.0107230544,
0.0038023766,
0.0426428951,
0.0053405492,
0.0418340676,
-0.0352281258,
0.0167243518,
0.0324864723,
0.0105787534,
-0.0313858017,
-0.0405227765,
0.01807498,
0.0067770812,
-0.0203089379,
-0.0561426245,
0.0873599946,
-0.0292868763,
0.0036862209,
-0.0234760661,
-0.0036311867,
0.0262460113,
0.0200411957,
0.0033309374,
-0.0320802927,
0.0525490642,
0.0320502222,
0.0152935227,
-0.0361720026,
-0.0910500735,
-0.0275859889,
0.0004626497,
-0.0301131643,
-0.0280434322,
-0.0669988096,
0.0120555302,
0.0329263881,
-0.0664835647,
-0.0172500405,
2.371867043e-34,
0.03030142,
-0.0411471613,
0.0123113282,
0.0598390177,
0.0264263973,
-0.0246997476,
0.0177565832,
0.0299258083,
-0.0240006167,
-0.0281226542,
-0.0055414136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17238v1 | Joint Entity and Relation Extraction with Span Pruning and Hypergraph Neural Networks | 2023-10-26T08:36:39 | 2023-10-26T08:36:39 | Zhaohui Yan, Songlin Yang, Wei Liu, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Entity and Relation Extraction (ERE) is an important task in information
extraction. Recent marker-based pipeline models achieve state-of-the-art
performance, but still suffer from the error propagation issue. Also, most of
current ERE models do not take into account higher-order interactions between
multiple entities and relations, while higher-order modeling could be
beneficial.In this work, we propose HyperGraph neural network for ERE
($\hgnn{}$), which is built upon the PL-marker (a state-of-the-art marker-based
pipleline model). To alleviate error propagation,we use a high-recall pruner
mechanism to transfer the burden of entity identification and labeling from the
NER module to the joint module of our model. For higher-order modeling, we
build a hypergraph, where nodes are entities (provided by the span pruner) and
relations thereof, and hyperedges encode interactions between two different
relations or between a relation and its associated subject and object entities.
We then run a hypergraph neural network for higher-order inference by applying
message passing over the built hypergraph. Experiments on three widely used
benchmarks (\acef{}, \ace{} and \scierc{}) for ERE task show significant
improvements over the previous state-of-the-art PL-marker. | [
0.0341297239,
0.0281515028,
0.0198394433,
0.0541784316,
-0.0087116044,
0.0375825427,
0.0035715916,
0.0009780879,
0.0457130373,
0.006231253,
-0.0099593857,
0.0058036097,
-0.03831641,
-0.0109469285,
-0.0064421506,
-0.0542947538,
0.0126864109,
0.020865785,
0.0694630221,
0.017654879,
-0.0023068152,
0.0307772085,
-0.0412017815,
-0.0336168744,
-0.0601544641,
-0.0007663611,
-0.0076997317,
0.0246220306,
0.0332506597,
-0.0618868917,
0.0145155247,
0.0394593813,
0.0080283191,
-0.0079825297,
0.000001963,
-0.0196557511,
-0.0262363963,
0.0127541944,
-0.0487414189,
-0.0155200576,
-0.0266012549,
-0.0542973839,
0.0053416267,
-0.0434446558,
-0.0096714469,
-0.0971303061,
0.0334805474,
0.0866569281,
0.0241287444,
0.0776003227,
-0.0232347157,
-0.0235919748,
0.06302955,
-0.0489898846,
-0.0059515797,
-0.0431058519,
0.0569685586,
-0.0169385988,
-0.0312393885,
-0.0151946228,
0.0048734942,
0.0285163317,
0.0286729168,
-0.0088274302,
-0.0032964181,
0.0293635633,
0.0051589175,
-0.0034945991,
0.0020461523,
0.1362444311,
-0.0482107662,
0.0356946923,
0.0555339754,
0.0047444431,
-0.0009975,
-0.019924093,
-0.0059390874,
-0.0089197224,
-0.0276076458,
-0.0066529266,
-0.0115930205,
-0.0386143662,
0.0300572049,
-0.0102427173,
0.0004092865,
0.0425264463,
0.0039629377,
-0.0094376365,
0.0237382054,
0.0047965716,
0.0138835292,
-0.0043905163,
0.0556923859,
0.032955762,
0.0132495789,
0.0104771424,
0.0088451449,
-0.02172512,
-0.0348178111,
-0.0157934744,
-0.0180264637,
0.0055947332,
0.0046478896,
0.0452107564,
-0.0454999581,
0.015265001,
-0.0209469404,
0.0266719311,
0.0249449164,
-0.0130149955,
-0.0189843252,
-0.0037306703,
-0.0413727053,
0.0992043987,
-0.0463373661,
-0.0172447767,
-0.0376429223,
-0.0026845552,
-0.035858281,
0.0301900469,
0.013286029,
-0.0019585697,
0.0098421192,
-0.0124869468,
0.0064177322,
0.0470076799,
-0.0344768614,
-0.0074977065,
-0.0043303478,
-0.0028968663,
-0.0105848676,
-0.0055228644,
0.0386273824,
-0.0408850051,
0.016842084,
0.1054153144,
0.0332844481,
-0.0596279129,
-0.0416518003,
-0.0257374924,
0.0221752562,
-0.0576690435,
0.0481587276,
-0.0404555351,
0.0891541839,
0.0023513054,
-0.0192160401,
-0.0514556356,
0.0147398775,
-0.0135249663,
-0.076549843,
0.013208583,
-0.0006120523,
-0.0072836019,
-0.0035792841,
0.0153898383,
-0.004952983,
0.0211993381,
0.0390214883,
0.0112464456,
0.0382097661,
0.0037347949,
-0.0095062545,
0.036263112,
0.0162489917,
-0.0555681698,
-0.0113312667,
-0.0351748988,
0.0128325094,
0.0016446448,
0.0493189171,
0.0761127248,
-0.0587432235,
-0.026623955,
0.0217822883,
-0.0102214823,
0.0309343599,
0.0179093145,
0.0632823184,
-0.0199091192,
0.0326734334,
0.0257518701,
-0.0725796074,
0.0365774333,
0.0055645881,
0.0111368047,
-0.0340125039,
0.0422622226,
-0.0188393444,
0.0028761546,
0.041902028,
-0.0031894399,
-0.0116572641,
0.0138848508,
0.0685338154,
0.004216976,
-0.0371617712,
0.0702201054,
0.0665822402,
-0.0113784745,
0.0070749656,
0.0334701277,
-0.0019363172,
0.0342608541,
0.0261165295,
-0.0514759794,
-0.007974579,
-0.0092602186,
-0.0444295704,
0.0158088487,
0.0481188372,
-0.0394827053,
0.0368215702,
-0.0139426971,
-0.0091379713,
0.0108924881,
0.0140470648,
0.0159383509,
0.0294913948,
-0.0024510026,
0.0093736881,
0.023353966,
-0.0043926816,
0.0312235821,
-0.0288727805,
0.0109376488,
-0.0199082233,
0.0310380049,
-0.0323001593,
0.0499216169,
-0.0084816851,
-0.0157065671,
0.0342476889,
-0.0186090264,
0.0087506622,
-0.061833106,
-0.0489698909,
-0.0909021869,
0.0500011742,
-0.0029792283,
-0.0405409932,
0.0089823613,
-0.0369689986,
-0.015783539,
-0.044666294,
0.0098392675,
0.0704074502,
-0.0012352379,
0.0138372611,
0.0431934707,
-0.0024120917,
-0.0131291989,
0.0606255755,
-0.0084696924,
0.0131903039,
0.016191192,
-0.0484624654,
-0.0391206443,
-0.0439823382,
-0.0542923845,
0.0578980371,
0.0241368618,
-0.0374185555,
0.0042851493,
-0.0126425643,
-0.0561846644,
-0.0334265567,
-0.0257059354,
0.0056519434,
0.0049411636,
0.0527749695,
-0.0045937584,
0.0221398138,
-0.0157023538,
-0.0349639468,
-0.0077840504,
0.0264724791,
-0.0270762388,
0.002628827,
0.0396701768,
0.0244453251,
-0.033801835,
-0.0215934217,
-0.0483407378,
-0.0413591824,
0.0457468033,
0.0092923827,
-0.0582147241,
-0.0066729798,
0.0299703293,
-0.0310650021,
0.0253954139,
0.0050995131,
0.0215923097,
-0.0376006477,
-0.0182736777,
-0.0185818337,
0.0419656597,
-0.040865317,
0.0601654276,
-0.0197662599,
0.0002092312,
-0.0230624098,
0.024655778,
-0.0721735284,
0.0852598175,
-0.0100455042,
0.0148439026,
-0.0366759039,
0.0413751788,
-0.0080140745,
0.0250889547,
0.0074426467,
0.005224938,
0.0417443514,
0.0031564264,
0.0128122512,
-0.0024049501,
-0.0093319491,
-0.0354958549,
-0.0741515309,
0.0103874411,
0.0645825788,
-0.000876453,
-0.0106238043,
0.0435043797,
0.0084195426,
-0.0421574265,
0.0157526825,
0.0440801308,
0.0239037573,
-0.0186343286,
-0.0755400658,
-0.0293029733,
0.0184218697,
0.0065568704,
-0.0250458699,
0.0207434725,
-0.0291616917,
0.0072560948,
-0.0103430199,
0.0002057198,
-0.0254515558,
-0.0202988759,
0.0053219944,
0.0407355689,
-0.0448387302,
-0.016944889,
0.0030264268,
0.0025498173,
0.0043088174,
0.0488341711,
-0.0153552806,
0.0134941386,
-0.0432120301,
0.09690772,
0.0355137885,
-0.0194531567,
0.0557859018,
0.0014240437,
0.0239394084,
0.0519753434,
-0.0282348488,
-0.006895727,
-0.0002684816,
0.0162685812,
-0.015819883,
-0.0691098422,
0.0072006076,
-0.0071394215,
0.0010355613,
-0.0780981854,
0.0260558594,
0.074245885,
-0.0000121752,
-0.0345506221,
0.0006366891,
0.0882810131,
0.0347759165,
0.0069388347,
0.019117754,
-0.0510282107,
0.0183098242,
0.0064786724,
0.0017507429,
0.0263068844,
-0.0914702564,
0.0251192469,
-0.0832073092,
-0.0214544535,
-0.0113822864,
-0.052390527,
-0.012908401,
-0.0561291836,
0.0371549092,
0.0152453734,
0.0048790826,
0.0191288162,
-0.0062837224,
-0.0203279685,
0.0074923565,
0.0251663867,
-0.0631440431,
0.0053676842,
-0.0289964862,
0.0489892662,
-0.0128902216,
0.0370089263,
-0.0171976965,
0.0098419907,
0.0331767909,
-0.0288106948,
-0.0306696445,
-0.0142691536,
0.1013405994,
-0.0314001963,
-0.0245928671,
-0.0471941568,
0.0051443274,
-0.0507919788,
0.0127104791,
-0.0448703468,
0.061553672,
0.0179784633,
-0.0325940996,
0.0229940377,
-0.0479134656,
0.009336831,
0.0452705696,
0.0195275676,
0.003445813,
-0.0440093875,
0.0016704643,
-0.0150734773,
-0.0334555916,
0.0073945848,
0.0137804141,
-0.0612502024,
-0.0220836755,
-0.0271027442,
-0.0629045516,
0.0259371381,
0.03791897,
-0.0103395991,
-0.0139694633,
0.0358407609,
-0.0035876078,
-0.0260185767,
0.0279692542,
-0.0076281545,
-0.0092818709,
-0.002262014,
0.0046959035,
0.0170798246,
0.0310357884,
-0.0290813129,
-0.0186845511,
-0.05804874,
-0.0538940057,
-0.0252218731,
0.0312032327,
0.008675646,
0.0442016833,
-0.0117787747,
-0.0087562306,
-0.0415496007,
0.0315697864,
-0.075209178,
-0.0194211286,
-0.0160341095,
0.003106778,
-0.0359246135,
0.024145877,
-0.026165504,
0.0330282487,
0.0498985201,
0.0683823302,
-0.0403163284,
-0.0640780851,
0.0133593641,
0.0370280854,
0.0229457077,
0.0453530774,
-0.0069903443,
-0.0823138878,
0.0230608974,
-0.034556672,
-0.0044382066,
-0.0053622583,
0.0306775421,
-0.0201216396,
0.0175831877,
-0.0133157521,
-0.0230744891,
0.0631374568,
0.0362774879,
-0.0501444228,
-0.0219836459,
-0.015037179,
-0.0064361021,
0.0224459246,
-0.0191335976,
-0.0253352039,
0.03144769,
0.0233938694,
0.0295286011,
-0.0609283075,
0.0220776927,
0.0214304291,
-0.0387531891,
-0.0219002627,
-0.0161717962,
-0.0170790479,
0.0279225409,
-0.0357648693,
0.033582177,
0.0493950993,
0.0008772223,
0.0459192321,
-0.0062019266,
-0.027142873,
-0.0026969016,
0.0293731317,
-0.0004130607,
0.0013874721,
0.0396626145,
0.0268667601,
0.0048736269,
0.0009842762,
0.0270185638,
-0.0005258594,
0.0580923893,
0.017406648,
-0.0158435088,
-0.0528061129,
-0.0299445875,
0.0097200749,
0.0138194319,
-0.0158376005,
0.0001715607,
-0.0490543097,
-0.0477990061,
0.0267210733,
-0.0150008537,
-0.0105757788,
0.002125008,
0.0198025201,
-0.0082355933,
0.0166620649,
-0.0509355813,
-0.0404177606,
0.0246488266,
0.0068955664,
-0.0082050534,
-0.0258892663,
-5.88104893e-33,
-0.0429844148,
-0.0303033628,
0.023747595,
0.0149085028,
-0.0872191116,
0.0436506495,
-0.0562113561,
-0.0177407954,
-0.0351566561,
0.0288719125,
0.0014757533,
-0.0096500246,
0.0081290416,
0.0017390453,
-0.0403112136,
-0.0273069404,
0.0299122129,
0.0057393382,
0.0208311249,
0.0409225412,
0.0538386144,
0.0660304427,
0.0788740069,
-0.110947527,
0.0063937185,
-0.0013300151,
0.0342455134,
0.0265915897,
0.0423165634,
0.0403893478,
-0.0251409896,
0.0036897811,
0.0411930569,
-0.0286957324,
0.0268152561,
0.0116624786,
-0.2034740001,
-0.014303376,
-0.0454561152,
0.016633831,
-0.0380229652,
-0.0386078879,
0.0602849908,
-0.0053003673,
0.0432208814,
-0.0331019685,
0.0525430255,
-0.0173775554,
-0.0360110253,
-0.0583872013,
-0.0394913144,
0.0379503518,
0.006807731,
0.0456448123,
0.0413295962,
0.0098816482,
0.0193343256,
-0.0045980639,
-0.1042527407,
-0.0307426788,
-0.0532326289,
-0.0231907666,
0.0059723747,
0.009904786,
0.0157919303,
0.0518092737,
0.028729083,
-0.0094214408,
-0.0072882031,
0.0404723585,
0.018879801,
0.0403022543,
-0.0175831541,
-0.0173130427,
-0.0082312431,
-0.0254748669,
-0.0946751833,
-0.0053871679,
0.0187268145,
0.0428707674,
-0.0256316271,
-0.0046709576,
-0.032171756,
-0.0007487033,
-0.0068678693,
-0.0112742651,
-0.0067489622,
-0.0343207419,
-0.0098827202,
0.0121331792,
-0.0178310722,
0.0468101539,
-0.004415263,
-0.018903356,
-0.0547322072,
0.0457835756,
0.0140837375,
0.0330156982,
-0.0083244983,
0.0145803215,
-0.0533444881,
-0.0268547591,
-0.0089803683,
-0.0430632122,
0.0251299143,
0.0309338178,
0.0606086105,
-0.0372092947,
-0.0591634549,
-0.0099644624,
-0.0456685983,
0.0172728971,
0.012312483,
0.031250339,
0.0185274053,
-0.0073232283,
-0.0134268152,
0.0457678176,
0.0518609919,
0.0441042036,
-0.0120628951,
0.1029269546,
0.0311351046,
0.0341238007,
-0.0040180329,
0.0018499119,
0.0031621959,
0.0045954743,
0.0248543359,
-0.0595931448,
0.0083435206,
0.0389872193,
2.555e-7,
0.0312336348,
-0.0171759408,
0.0940276086,
0.007721873,
0.0169279911,
-0.0158907417,
0.0094694691,
-0.0019972951,
-0.0152822575,
-0.0365048945,
-0.0114298137,
0.0228177104,
-0.0184629876,
0.0172978472,
-0.0704959482,
-0.0068669948,
0.0116118249,
-0.0693100467,
-0.0488781705,
0.023145128,
0.0506800339,
0.0403464288,
0.028368596,
0.0046060188,
-0.0620114319,
-0.0116123622,
0.0174450818,
0.0266006943,
0.0123016564,
0.0405685417,
0.0246330313,
-0.0099740848,
-0.0185574908,
0.0726506338,
0.0111649968,
0.041604016,
0.0306646135,
0.0776785836,
-0.002346507,
-0.0270597748,
0.0381397307,
-0.03320406,
0.0140534518,
-0.0073013548,
0.0531740189,
-0.0466209203,
-0.0241382122,
0.0296201687,
-0.0298029818,
-0.003681794,
-0.0304543879,
0.0137039097,
0.0211071037,
0.0327469893,
0.0423333384,
-0.0356760696,
0.000692882,
-0.0814502761,
0.0222897362,
0.0485979542,
-0.0078992518,
-0.0460288674,
0.0371571071,
-0.0337990671,
-0.0064109094,
-0.0651223138,
-0.0252345689,
2.540359234e-34,
-0.0298678912,
0.0011558703,
-0.0269504711,
0.0443873592,
0.0451974459,
-0.0222770758,
-0.0783969611,
-0.0012912803,
-0.0130484793,
-0.1083820313,
0.0187612325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17233v1 | EMMA-X: An EM-like Multilingual Pre-training Algorithm for Cross-lingual Representation Learning | 2023-10-26T08:31:00 | 2023-10-26T08:31:00 | Ping Guo, Xiangpeng Wei, Yue Hu, Baosong Yang, Dayiheng Liu, Fei Huang, Jun Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Expressing universal semantics common to all languages is helpful in
understanding the meanings of complex and culture-specific sentences. The
research theme underlying this scenario focuses on learning universal
representations across languages with the usage of massive parallel corpora.
However, due to the sparsity and scarcity of parallel data, there is still a
big challenge in learning authentic ``universals'' for any two languages. In
this paper, we propose EMMA-X: an EM-like Multilingual pre-training Algorithm,
to learn (X)Cross-lingual universals with the aid of excessive multilingual
non-parallel data. EMMA-X unifies the cross-lingual representation learning
task and an extra semantic relation prediction task within an EM framework.
Both the extra semantic classifier and the cross-lingual sentence encoder
approximate the semantic relation of two sentences, and supervise each other
until convergence. To evaluate EMMA-X, we conduct experiments on XRETE, a newly
introduced benchmark containing 12 widely studied cross-lingual tasks that
fully depend on sentence-level representations. Results reveal that EMMA-X
achieves state-of-the-art performance. Further geometric analysis of the built
representation space with three requirements demonstrates the superiority of
EMMA-X over advanced models. | [
0.0001782598,
0.0172559544,
-0.0253835302,
0.0634645298,
-0.0358501486,
0.0438561551,
-0.0215187613,
-0.0356748961,
-0.0110972803,
-0.0385635756,
-0.0351811685,
-0.0362451971,
-0.0115260566,
-0.0250594337,
0.0012538516,
-0.0424312353,
0.0498432964,
0.0252403952,
-0.0293437243,
-0.063626878,
0.0044418122,
0.024172198,
0.0093793785,
0.0372843295,
-0.0464884937,
0.0038579716,
-0.0079154074,
-0.0277077481,
0.0387913026,
-0.0160094108,
0.0086046094,
-0.0002745915,
0.0460377708,
0.0311135296,
0.0000020337,
-0.0517615266,
-0.0344764106,
-0.0389681645,
0.0220774282,
-0.0168076754,
0.0052972208,
-0.1016825661,
0.0244189724,
-0.0236918703,
-0.0064406181,
-0.0293350723,
0.0632567778,
0.0319371596,
0.036611218,
0.0614101663,
-0.0380628034,
-0.0513955429,
0.0233366191,
-0.0444375202,
-0.0095739644,
-0.0240515415,
-0.0011374304,
0.0175075214,
-0.019266801,
0.0141345244,
-0.0365505181,
0.0322187878,
0.0405985117,
0.070916459,
-0.0256691575,
0.0228994358,
0.0003402489,
-0.0041571688,
-0.0227425881,
0.0891788304,
-0.0037040424,
-0.0107946172,
-0.0202302672,
-0.0048965123,
-0.0434321761,
-0.0027403962,
-0.0128267501,
0.0364027694,
0.0244398825,
0.0445741899,
0.0339423269,
0.0174922813,
0.0251695644,
-0.0224421918,
-0.0371075124,
0.0500071906,
0.0444453172,
-0.0254354663,
0.030643139,
0.0382208824,
-0.0278940927,
-0.0008830599,
0.0047571836,
-0.0101055168,
-0.0288575757,
-0.0022077174,
-0.0103384992,
-0.075762555,
0.0212108269,
-0.0497762375,
0.0412009843,
0.0564803295,
0.0140501587,
0.0486700311,
-0.0401366651,
0.0249545053,
-0.0264633615,
0.0326749086,
-0.0463023633,
-0.0529143922,
-0.0352898613,
-0.0059776385,
-0.0202670079,
0.0195821058,
-0.0390798226,
-0.0437863842,
-0.0549777448,
0.0090367049,
-0.004194512,
-0.0145352948,
0.0054666507,
-0.0191933811,
-0.0332303494,
-0.0064663859,
-0.0262952335,
0.0362558179,
-0.05799409,
-0.0114629734,
-0.05696062,
-0.0095409127,
-0.0149105787,
0.0020821758,
0.0131956777,
-0.0413616523,
0.0199260172,
0.0700795799,
-0.003572149,
-0.0320807546,
-0.0197693948,
-0.0028221584,
-0.0067386213,
-0.0534812622,
0.025559308,
-0.0585248768,
0.0711050928,
0.0261831656,
0.0218314398,
0.0021556232,
0.0023757319,
-0.0180185009,
-0.0354108624,
0.0342574939,
0.0229682494,
-0.0174246877,
-0.0002007851,
-0.0150101269,
0.0333104506,
0.1010621041,
0.0026164181,
-0.0075916094,
0.0512448512,
0.0194613934,
-0.0706643611,
0.0401586145,
0.0233349446,
0.0045711785,
-0.0332148895,
0.0148561941,
0.0588819236,
0.0299922284,
-0.0013143411,
0.0298449118,
-0.0319062956,
-0.0339294337,
0.0057784175,
0.0072150412,
-0.0110531999,
0.0421454012,
0.0813850984,
-0.0165162254,
-0.0442640223,
0.0155670559,
0.002721563,
0.0172147304,
0.0194163378,
-0.0191675425,
0.0177280642,
0.0324902795,
-0.0611157492,
0.0167471617,
0.0369932912,
-0.0558731966,
-0.0004091455,
-0.0077654892,
0.0616309308,
0.0008912986,
-0.0382604711,
0.0799425319,
0.0880888849,
-0.0591127835,
0.001690577,
0.0199737251,
0.0088207945,
0.0506190062,
-0.029891504,
-0.0090126377,
0.0023621246,
0.0072112074,
0.0208855029,
0.0381041877,
0.0359352008,
-0.0173797719,
0.0630318671,
-0.0436375588,
-0.0424481891,
-0.0609824844,
-0.0164927486,
0.0427557267,
-0.0056285327,
0.0485423096,
0.0397570878,
-0.0248683169,
0.0329963118,
0.0252379999,
-0.0321475752,
0.0014183359,
0.0334055685,
0.0509078652,
0.006277333,
0.0031403245,
-0.0071331789,
-0.0075484184,
0.0328113697,
-0.0896309614,
-0.0149125457,
0.0319092423,
-0.0606446303,
-0.0746674612,
0.0446569808,
-0.0782212019,
-0.0147254001,
0.0580180399,
-0.0111212879,
-0.0269549545,
0.0087316744,
-0.0061375271,
0.0935324878,
-0.0495611057,
-0.0185531918,
-0.026933074,
0.040034391,
0.0147377392,
0.0589853749,
0.0098459171,
0.0373855941,
0.0106383711,
-0.022900736,
0.04616886,
-0.0083590634,
-0.0466882065,
0.0181549303,
0.0555067696,
0.0094561633,
0.0470638685,
-0.0067283632,
-0.0210248958,
-0.0126491552,
-0.1263014227,
-0.0056366576,
-0.0372109562,
0.0172856804,
0.0396254659,
0.0329671353,
0.0058042603,
-0.021718394,
-0.0389694609,
0.0376403369,
0.0002681182,
0.0344166197,
0.0255629756,
-0.0141252913,
-0.0040689097,
0.0207620561,
-0.0348065495,
-0.013742893,
0.0747683868,
-0.019252643,
0.0180993341,
-0.022041183,
0.0147456275,
-0.0319207236,
0.0060325875,
-0.0089252712,
-0.0074982024,
-0.032290455,
-0.0028752571,
0.0377875939,
-0.0043072067,
-0.0178089887,
0.0078961877,
0.0505008884,
0.0003040053,
-0.0238767248,
0.0116691263,
-0.0318160728,
0.0286523513,
-0.0415518545,
0.0020509514,
-0.011392233,
0.0656361133,
-0.0202543773,
-0.0265546832,
-0.0605822839,
-0.0326158106,
0.0220376458,
-0.0230864603,
-0.0285283159,
0.0159507263,
0.0174116474,
-0.0079582203,
-0.0349448845,
-0.0088441325,
0.0586505905,
-0.019539414,
0.0014804942,
-0.0620454885,
-0.0073484397,
-0.0445251092,
0.049647253,
0.0136678023,
0.0610833094,
-0.0575913936,
0.0123574194,
-0.0414698645,
0.0070536872,
-0.0057724048,
0.0423691012,
-0.0268271901,
0.0122147482,
0.0069036903,
-0.0079098446,
-0.034222424,
-0.0215269513,
-0.0584931523,
-0.0265608095,
0.0266619492,
-0.0034225788,
0.0424690954,
-0.0356321335,
-0.0263468288,
0.0008954422,
-0.0102166617,
-0.0040190383,
0.0084414342,
-0.0126108341,
0.0472780317,
0.0306305233,
-0.0019094697,
-0.0087316241,
-0.0635541975,
0.0147389863,
0.0126818381,
-0.0094294529,
-0.0247789808,
-0.0083605237,
0.0315298438,
0.016170606,
-0.0066830413,
-0.0239840932,
-0.0255462229,
0.0229455028,
-0.0004002992,
0.016531907,
0.0701895654,
0.0143244173,
-0.040719945,
0.0086448118,
-0.0015566035,
0.0391105823,
0.0238103177,
0.0242378749,
-0.0794568062,
-0.0419735834,
-0.0255851392,
-0.0569191799,
0.02497923,
-0.0220924579,
0.0059874714,
-0.1016559377,
-0.0410238579,
0.0102390023,
-0.0788007677,
0.0009837658,
-0.0241526626,
-0.0182395484,
-0.0060414961,
0.027972864,
-0.0304672029,
-0.0020114554,
-0.0046559516,
-0.0320471004,
0.0291101523,
-0.0366257019,
0.021349486,
-0.0687872022,
-0.0355493464,
0.0036347164,
0.0313672237,
-0.0075555011,
-0.044421982,
-0.0091790324,
-0.0125149004,
-0.0067001772,
-0.0094580613,
0.0288511906,
-0.0317308791,
-0.048561845,
0.0126865888,
-0.0030036047,
-0.0530513562,
0.0046173362,
0.0220218953,
0.0987113565,
0.0206617434,
0.0266738962,
0.0058589801,
-0.0071643796,
0.014058941,
0.0465242937,
0.0032535393,
-0.0477900207,
-0.0279115774,
0.0147322649,
0.0276623499,
-0.0580957793,
-0.0022081228,
0.0279840585,
-0.0215408336,
-0.0291400962,
-0.0324665532,
-0.0714630336,
0.0153698875,
0.030231066,
0.0238670837,
-0.0146105159,
-0.0080484468,
0.016903732,
-0.0473751239,
0.0000706837,
-0.0084527517,
0.0171408467,
0.0198020395,
0.0151504334,
0.0264445115,
0.0052174036,
-0.0100715915,
-0.0128656812,
-0.0688953549,
-0.0622807108,
-0.031234514,
0.0639451519,
-0.0046017822,
0.0536253639,
0.0266269166,
0.0036527386,
0.0795752555,
-0.003055441,
-0.0611014403,
0.0315579809,
0.0549158864,
0.0038913018,
-0.0052853925,
0.0654311851,
-0.0266125295,
0.0276806001,
0.0356362537,
0.0626156777,
0.0086982585,
-0.032131359,
0.0288585778,
0.0004542246,
-0.0151563156,
-0.015559826,
-0.0023325768,
-0.040354833,
0.0314214565,
-0.051026389,
-0.0068482966,
-0.0456183404,
-0.0061428482,
0.0057060644,
-0.0173265524,
0.0070308298,
0.006595281,
0.0180690791,
-0.0244677197,
-0.0178635195,
0.0131938988,
0.0118601881,
0.0156507064,
-0.0141934706,
0.053183727,
-0.0036995963,
-0.0153817525,
0.0117525691,
0.0088100955,
-0.0592744015,
0.0255916137,
-0.000410769,
-0.0030107363,
-0.0401057266,
0.0195489395,
-0.0207416974,
-0.0025096629,
0.0093709668,
0.0119969454,
0.0820531622,
-0.0372467451,
0.0412139855,
-0.000399692,
-0.0296629369,
-0.0167166349,
0.0467776507,
-0.0356394425,
-0.0136687988,
0.0155434236,
-0.0133679807,
-0.0326919258,
0.0046676104,
0.0781262517,
-0.0607879832,
0.0515158474,
0.0298393071,
0.0032873603,
-0.0442963652,
-0.0170255564,
0.0514649451,
0.0094251623,
-0.0161557384,
0.0114420233,
-0.0132915294,
-0.0679305345,
0.0334024318,
0.009118313,
-0.0652503967,
0.0217208881,
0.0407106392,
0.0582301803,
0.0205428284,
0.0188771766,
-0.0326347016,
-0.0118690189,
-0.018154189,
0.0061562983,
0.0095147882,
-5.830581284e-33,
0.0163787305,
0.0686241016,
-0.0287704226,
0.0013930066,
0.0049041277,
0.028002305,
-0.0165188834,
0.0031760898,
-0.0017994714,
0.0203813072,
0.0208984502,
-0.0032399588,
0.0011289432,
0.0434562489,
0.0117405597,
-0.0044198069,
0.0382182114,
-0.0054404736,
0.0068630171,
0.030884346,
0.0672397986,
0.0702501461,
0.0703619048,
-0.050202325,
0.0137902219,
-0.0010922733,
0.0344537869,
0.02666834,
0.0426728614,
0.0479103811,
-0.0414206982,
0.0698619708,
0.0122247078,
-0.0361548997,
-0.0078548845,
0.0054326584,
-0.0933298841,
-0.0631639287,
-0.0059373924,
0.0090296026,
-0.0462996028,
-0.0407193787,
0.0242483616,
-0.0244852863,
0.0213529784,
-0.0242383499,
0.0350186005,
-0.0012688321,
-0.0036304528,
-0.0061138254,
-0.0502149574,
-0.0117714331,
-0.0237986464,
0.0091374032,
0.0524773188,
0.0638064295,
0.0312151853,
0.0318468958,
-0.0287057701,
0.023377018,
-0.0731983185,
-0.0067466097,
0.0296279229,
-0.03130389,
0.043156486,
0.0819190443,
0.0309439432,
-0.0026292126,
0.0216744654,
0.0312142987,
0.0165774841,
0.0113800392,
-0.0104386983,
0.0943083912,
0.0229315553,
-0.0243883599,
-0.134305805,
0.0405215696,
0.0357698649,
0.0187137183,
-0.0055540288,
-0.0202749223,
0.0149245057,
-0.0183150303,
-0.0121012256,
-0.0093618268,
-0.0201854371,
-0.0470958911,
0.0118524358,
0.0004793165,
-0.0047119185,
0.0268264208,
0.0278642178,
-0.064861998,
-0.02970195,
0.0313696638,
-0.033443667,
-0.03228705,
0.0408127867,
0.0320034847,
-0.032474298,
-0.0618809909,
-0.0194342528,
-0.0284040812,
0.0337484032,
-0.0082678422,
0.0663220882,
0.0012566946,
-0.044700589,
0.0040946919,
-0.0357768498,
-0.047701735,
-0.0090751546,
0.0037998168,
0.0083896304,
0.0187542886,
-0.0214492064,
0.0180505197,
0.0334158465,
-0.0058526061,
0.0042318469,
-0.0761855319,
0.0398213528,
0.0846907124,
-0.0130244428,
-0.0490229763,
-0.032530956,
-0.0002869758,
0.0465286784,
-0.0781217888,
-0.01883379,
-0.0146022849,
2.693e-7,
0.0536657125,
-0.0209692139,
0.0104530053,
-0.0179313738,
-0.0076399217,
0.0321198218,
-0.0582889728,
0.0767050311,
-0.0279661771,
-0.0141096171,
0.0210435577,
0.0433624424,
0.0328554213,
0.0162508171,
-0.0776745602,
0.0462996699,
-0.0362173058,
0.0005112647,
-0.0416739024,
0.0416322798,
0.0640161857,
0.0869287923,
0.0211529434,
-0.0101972176,
-0.0445759818,
-0.0337776728,
0.1166715994,
-0.0637083054,
-0.0380211249,
-0.0089751873,
-0.0721596181,
0.0272421855,
-0.0318660624,
0.0258234646,
-0.0197702553,
0.0789248645,
0.0414544977,
0.0271595307,
-0.0090744533,
-0.0057860496,
0.0479382277,
0.0095953168,
-0.0517121255,
-0.01203408,
0.0849765167,
-0.0673577264,
-0.0267192852,
-0.0070821373,
0.0038515504,
0.0249830429,
0.0886492208,
-0.0082533741,
-0.0361629389,
-0.0158447865,
0.0440689065,
-0.0012572921,
0.0003822863,
-0.0469488315,
0.0043568029,
0.0492854491,
-0.0220191739,
-0.0181444269,
-0.0048807953,
-0.0146723762,
0.0472281352,
-0.0378158465,
0.0265870169,
2.073751114e-34,
0.0024518482,
-0.0122320382,
0.0007613416,
0.0101383524,
-0.0068953806,
-0.094408907,
0.0085020624,
-0.0315584689,
0.0050988118,
-0.0381834023,
-0.017257588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17230v1 | Codebook Features: Sparse and Discrete Interpretability for Neural Networks | 2023-10-26T08:28:48 | 2023-10-26T08:28:48 | Alex Tamkin, Mohammad Taufeeque, Noah D. Goodman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Understanding neural networks is challenging in part because of the dense,
continuous nature of their hidden states. We explore whether we can train
neural networks to have hidden states that are sparse, discrete, and more
interpretable by quantizing their continuous features into what we call
codebook features. Codebook features are produced by finetuning neural networks
with vector quantization bottlenecks at each layer, producing a network whose
hidden features are the sum of a small number of discrete vector codes chosen
from a larger codebook. Surprisingly, we find that neural networks can operate
under this extreme bottleneck with only modest degradation in performance. This
sparse, discrete bottleneck also provides an intuitive way of controlling
neural network behavior: first, find codes that activate when the desired
behavior is present, then activate those same codes during generation to elicit
that behavior. We validate our approach by training codebook Transformers on
several different datasets. First, we explore a finite state machine dataset
with far more hidden states than neurons. In this setting, our approach
overcomes the superposition problem by assigning states to distinct codes, and
we find that we can make the neural network behave as if it is in a different
state by activating the code for that state. Second, we train Transformer
language models with up to 410M parameters on two natural language datasets. We
identify codes in these models representing diverse, disentangled concepts
(ranging from negative emotions to months of the year) and find that we can
guide the model to generate different topics by activating the appropriate
codes during inference. Overall, codebook features appear to be a promising
unit of analysis and control for neural networks and interpretability. Our
codebase and models are open-sourced at
https://github.com/taufeeque9/codebook-features. | [
-0.0121576926,
0.1075666025,
-0.0197195858,
0.0382921137,
-0.0020824054,
0.0212559178,
0.037425071,
0.0211639497,
-0.0198738277,
0.0081783663,
-0.0111528067,
-0.0147907501,
-0.0045727841,
0.0755318701,
0.0141544919,
-0.0279851742,
0.0273305643,
0.009054577,
-0.0149569428,
-0.0214919746,
-0.0071060476,
-0.0010558943,
-0.0130475769,
0.0569398925,
-0.00836631,
-0.0214692578,
-0.0234237537,
-0.0038963405,
-0.001726656,
0.0096572898,
0.0023929812,
0.0393672585,
0.0462455899,
0.0318879895,
0.0000021975,
-0.0008202789,
-0.013323416,
-0.0232966822,
-0.0693924725,
-0.0072455113,
-0.024804635,
-0.0724096447,
0.0048766993,
-0.042480845,
-0.0377303474,
-0.0447706021,
0.0873947218,
0.034827929,
0.0585602596,
0.0701329112,
-0.0089514218,
-0.0252309479,
0.0358957201,
-0.0235859361,
0.0035417969,
-0.0067548282,
-0.0058165649,
0.0034162437,
-0.0223053489,
-0.0056054653,
-0.0653047115,
0.009416434,
0.0746420249,
0.0256227981,
0.0227888133,
0.0430483408,
-0.0232016798,
-0.0366129912,
-0.0087739658,
0.0504257716,
-0.0710961744,
-0.0252576526,
0.0240234844,
-0.014643264,
-0.0265655704,
-0.051980935,
0.0079522785,
0.0059334841,
0.0187003724,
0.0476509482,
-0.0009419025,
0.047516875,
0.0561751612,
0.0375628136,
-0.0527618043,
0.0317563377,
-0.0317469873,
0.0102061555,
-0.021014953,
-0.0135900909,
-0.027030291,
-0.0236955322,
0.0084702149,
0.0168414786,
0.0294215549,
0.0045420025,
-0.0295437593,
-0.0394923426,
-0.021021286,
-0.0160753634,
0.0562009923,
0.0640514642,
-0.0332918018,
0.0405973792,
-0.0017678704,
0.0546254441,
-0.0263086222,
0.0035659273,
-0.0109532466,
0.008097061,
-0.0492617637,
-0.0157571044,
-0.0126049519,
0.0399607718,
0.002408538,
-0.0149387857,
-0.03551751,
0.0007070533,
-0.0400132537,
0.0167022534,
-0.0277684405,
0.0338272899,
-0.0225444678,
-0.0258955415,
0.0108641488,
0.0253833812,
-0.0316619724,
0.0095772455,
0.0002055595,
-0.0567538515,
-0.0082517685,
0.0004063536,
0.0073403153,
-0.0158585198,
0.0104597248,
0.0310594793,
0.0054108542,
-0.0207099989,
-0.0223723669,
-0.0353479944,
-0.0092212269,
-0.0208247863,
0.0314300954,
-0.0545666851,
0.0253775008,
0.0079044364,
0.032472197,
-0.1018204689,
0.0095932921,
-0.0390582941,
-0.0064714691,
0.0936947241,
-0.0129428692,
-0.0349035934,
-0.0148067968,
0.0281511135,
0.0213730875,
0.0634735301,
0.0391895175,
0.0522240661,
0.0187146664,
-0.0172139294,
0.0147905732,
-0.0042924131,
0.0311407093,
0.0026795815,
-0.0637948662,
-0.0469837189,
-0.0177285261,
0.012854483,
0.0330439582,
0.0287485272,
-0.0531653315,
-0.0415057391,
0.0430187173,
0.0473634414,
0.049059689,
0.0837362781,
0.0071498933,
0.0066305869,
0.0000938017,
-0.003060776,
-0.0277600605,
0.0591354333,
-0.0074743764,
-0.0263337605,
0.0025586372,
-0.0122453412,
-0.0379032679,
-0.0861335248,
0.0155332554,
-0.0167858303,
0.0634342954,
0.0096828071,
0.0503085516,
0.0167383514,
-0.0142559633,
0.0457034335,
0.0016755487,
-0.0425007306,
-0.0000557726,
-0.0607795902,
0.0128780166,
0.056359794,
0.0160383563,
-0.0168594085,
-0.0098811416,
-0.0168797467,
-0.0186044164,
0.0010601878,
-0.0052121053,
0.0123692844,
0.0733192936,
-0.0626840293,
-0.0081401467,
-0.0092879785,
0.0420445204,
0.0275981408,
-0.0246894658,
-0.0156626254,
-0.0138711287,
0.0195046701,
-0.0006324216,
0.0148835341,
-0.003660748,
-0.0307113677,
0.0353974737,
0.0042956909,
0.0429346785,
-0.003577865,
-0.0041458164,
0.0000102406,
0.0157609247,
-0.0671947598,
-0.0134746088,
-0.0465497412,
-0.0486749597,
-0.0327803269,
-0.0124605549,
-0.0229090378,
0.0221744347,
0.0614646636,
-0.037281353,
-0.0235747229,
0.0455819033,
-0.0479220636,
0.0308439638,
-0.0147279324,
-0.0319480784,
-0.0012065523,
0.0518145971,
0.0117901424,
0.0284524821,
-0.0418390632,
0.008136509,
-0.0356854498,
-0.0038636252,
0.010813307,
-0.015104698,
-0.0237885807,
0.0016959248,
-0.018065447,
0.0031310339,
-0.002984164,
-0.0205827039,
-0.0079547474,
-0.0365386158,
-0.0902974233,
-0.0299650915,
-0.037040107,
-0.0306995232,
-0.0026172989,
0.0106161116,
0.0466324277,
-0.0063610687,
-0.0302981362,
0.0026972105,
-0.0318250135,
0.0084452936,
0.0216827989,
0.0071804821,
-0.0415290892,
-0.0436623879,
-0.058324229,
-0.0031779748,
0.0594362766,
-0.0228974167,
-0.0056673195,
-0.0403636768,
0.0353355445,
0.0271879621,
0.0112238741,
-0.0482841693,
-0.0539863072,
0.020218607,
-0.0244573057,
-0.0283763688,
0.0720883906,
-0.0162689481,
0.0888666138,
0.0496163331,
0.0202093609,
-0.0465680137,
0.020925153,
-0.0387944728,
0.0097822575,
-0.0430079363,
-0.0265521295,
-0.0146669317,
0.0729920343,
0.0080447011,
-0.0170823373,
-0.0894621313,
0.0350423045,
-0.0037216728,
-0.0371482596,
-0.0356434695,
-0.0053577535,
0.0015864734,
0.0853281915,
-0.0035336921,
-0.0590510853,
0.0451442637,
0.0121559445,
-0.0137899211,
0.0059996983,
-0.039068561,
-0.0326530635,
0.0809296593,
0.0106965071,
0.0079715019,
0.0279973876,
0.0090202736,
-0.0486179478,
-0.01559019,
-0.0323506147,
-0.0272545703,
0.0571046807,
-0.0332628004,
-0.0165092107,
0.0046180701,
-0.0259301066,
-0.0395191088,
-0.0277939942,
-0.0080737444,
0.0305205006,
0.0387727097,
-0.0226053614,
0.0079989042,
-0.0183231179,
-0.0019937812,
0.0277698282,
0.0039008523,
-0.0238544382,
-0.0067919586,
-0.00251074,
0.0283340104,
0.0280970819,
0.0422702841,
-0.0197295714,
-0.0254562628,
0.0221078824,
-0.027314987,
0.066215001,
-0.0640646815,
0.0676976815,
0.0248357859,
0.0213289689,
-0.0152133591,
0.0092961127,
0.0253490414,
-0.0791737884,
-0.0217096657,
0.0869069025,
0.0141333072,
-0.0637456402,
0.0360695608,
-0.0008881756,
-0.0093155773,
-0.0015983938,
0.0247334111,
-0.0612825342,
-0.0081510087,
-0.0323501639,
0.0185241848,
-0.0195723455,
-0.0193248335,
-0.0060094055,
-0.0420527495,
-0.0087106656,
0.026368212,
0.004835519,
-0.0664740354,
-0.0019966101,
-0.0296374094,
-0.0221047383,
-0.0061485893,
-0.0117989024,
0.0458671451,
-0.0212326944,
0.0026954352,
0.0179803129,
-0.0326921977,
0.0376355425,
0.0296586137,
0.0398811437,
0.0811158568,
0.0290786419,
-0.0368392505,
-0.035716176,
-0.0493413471,
-0.0243458617,
-0.0028187966,
0.0038809583,
0.0289933048,
0.0271610841,
-0.0380509309,
0.0230752248,
0.0452438481,
-0.0184533317,
-0.008380414,
-0.0485192835,
0.0419852436,
-0.0377906337,
-0.041812323,
0.0085419463,
-0.0278308857,
0.0026160022,
0.0512186401,
0.0457938947,
-0.0473621003,
-0.0247963015,
-0.0172498934,
0.0371478051,
-0.0470913947,
-0.0435908623,
-0.0155915506,
0.0336542092,
-0.0456491672,
-0.0381927416,
-0.0026798928,
-0.0143694999,
0.0181430243,
0.0058631371,
-0.0309267659,
0.0590881146,
0.0005253665,
-0.0467951633,
0.03594606,
0.0206790455,
0.0055902922,
-0.0175417028,
-0.0710897744,
0.0435958803,
-0.0178187527,
-0.0297286995,
-0.0153734516,
-0.0856080204,
-0.027358463,
0.044523526,
0.0210824125,
0.0216383655,
0.0274956673,
0.006716311,
-0.076366663,
0.004843994,
0.0590968244,
-0.049578812,
0.014620956,
0.0733655691,
0.0250462778,
-0.0139638996,
0.059267167,
-0.0210089702,
0.0508506484,
0.0142965587,
-0.0008384749,
-0.1083747223,
-0.0005425081,
-0.0064197923,
-0.0760246217,
0.0590337366,
0.0262034256,
-0.0071379542,
0.001023408,
0.0028620425,
0.0346616991,
0.0195066854,
-0.0823604241,
-0.0389084965,
0.0379856639,
0.0096940445,
-0.0401840694,
-0.0197178237,
0.0649482161,
-0.0087725194,
-0.0021423807,
0.037247315,
-0.0103300167,
0.0085961493,
0.0167976487,
0.0056117587,
-0.0431904495,
0.0611756258,
-0.0133442273,
0.0142429322,
-0.0116526736,
0.0474591665,
0.0227497388,
0.008809763,
-0.0543650948,
0.0311701596,
-0.0421074294,
-0.05634192,
0.0123431124,
-0.0296987947,
0.0442757085,
0.0192794465,
-0.0008493505,
-0.0518857874,
0.0183691792,
-0.006346073,
0.028487226,
0.0139802191,
-0.007167222,
0.0277296118,
0.0405559726,
-0.0025414042,
-0.0251687076,
0.0674756691,
0.0266073942,
0.0238984022,
0.0045916238,
0.0557155423,
-0.0353022069,
0.0034725033,
0.0242206734,
0.0475574359,
0.0211900882,
0.0417013317,
-0.0304625686,
-0.0510975048,
0.0523891263,
-0.0156456456,
0.0421651714,
-0.0353726037,
0.0456003845,
0.0125666074,
-0.0161214434,
0.012625467,
-0.0337838903,
0.0148027018,
0.0471553206,
-0.0354594328,
-0.0609310903,
-7.171721156e-33,
0.0019273027,
-0.0354864113,
-0.0120106144,
0.0092920801,
-0.0038224906,
0.0065581272,
-0.0627727732,
0.0020739294,
-0.0279219393,
0.0021460401,
-0.0175397042,
0.0480097309,
0.0030502151,
0.04088936,
0.0131640248,
-0.0430542901,
0.0641665831,
0.0072454144,
0.0147619415,
0.0183270238,
0.0389186032,
0.0372588187,
0.0414322875,
-0.0844096392,
-0.0023606459,
-0.0107847303,
-0.009725431,
-0.0094866166,
0.0049541411,
0.0357802622,
-0.034036316,
0.0178764183,
0.0183877572,
-0.041906476,
-0.0114989849,
-0.0213681683,
-0.0478015356,
-0.0479833335,
-0.0217898842,
0.0263646375,
-0.0145351421,
-0.0713157579,
0.0796459019,
-0.0202326737,
-0.0158153065,
-0.027722396,
0.0117150964,
-0.0296786949,
-0.0299292691,
-0.0963553861,
-0.0198024288,
0.0246905796,
-0.0149538405,
-0.0056637726,
0.0362880789,
-0.0040109213,
-0.0346850343,
0.0104540791,
-0.0866788924,
-0.0189332943,
0.0143918386,
0.0655088723,
0.0246464517,
0.0077533321,
0.0312024616,
0.0433083698,
0.0690559149,
-0.0215691365,
-0.06016526,
0.0407655053,
0.0655737445,
0.0325774029,
0.0834023207,
0.0114536658,
0.1035942137,
-0.0266595483,
-0.0350587741,
-0.0334988423,
-0.0261428971,
0.0258244555,
0.0704825521,
0.0221998207,
-0.0286045857,
-0.0343016796,
-0.0222910997,
-0.0147139467,
-0.0401891209,
-0.0193244908,
-0.0048229201,
0.0078064627,
-0.0219051465,
0.0183457024,
0.021417737,
-0.0667404458,
0.0107767517,
0.0581056997,
0.0434413515,
0.0547276661,
0.0369391441,
-0.0042802622,
-0.030468246,
-0.0341656618,
0.0076418454,
0.0001168027,
0.0663719922,
0.0249155536,
0.0293659531,
0.0448674299,
-0.0210983921,
-0.0531430729,
-0.0256353635,
-0.0120882215,
0.0016696461,
0.0426271968,
0.0206959154,
0.022038674,
-0.0245844815,
-0.0061306367,
-0.0200456623,
0.0324536301,
-0.0344067775,
0.0113301622,
-0.0180766378,
0.048534859,
-0.0430598333,
-0.0766362101,
-0.047974173,
0.0285403915,
0.0620959848,
-0.0489006974,
-0.010961337,
0.0462204143,
2.993e-7,
-0.0026101319,
0.0218459219,
-0.0332072005,
-0.0113053638,
0.0518936999,
0.0385342874,
-0.0032320751,
0.0051251766,
-0.0288954582,
-0.0390255712,
0.0205099974,
0.0465886891,
0.0461346433,
0.0204933342,
-0.045445893,
-0.0007279428,
0.0094714668,
0.0320913717,
-0.0211906303,
0.0031458815,
0.0726598054,
0.143175289,
0.0394769572,
0.0273190606,
0.0942956433,
0.0351057462,
0.0272078384,
-0.0313315243,
0.069308877,
-0.0123447552,
-0.0123711396,
0.0268427394,
-0.0133393947,
-0.027531486,
0.0205181744,
0.0252593067,
-0.0325663574,
0.0806602463,
0.001111313,
-0.0395909697,
-0.0192102455,
0.0105699841,
-0.0235625971,
-0.0334787853,
0.0579605028,
-0.0803297833,
-0.0488856956,
0.0181644019,
0.0247909445,
0.017749127,
0.0136617105,
0.0005210036,
-0.0217988789,
0.0117475074,
-0.0113140987,
-0.0222615339,
0.0218941271,
-0.0761656165,
0.0013523916,
-0.0011605412,
-0.0485164896,
-0.0267401412,
-0.0754091963,
-0.000674053,
0.0302350968,
-0.0018424749,
-0.0024465518,
2.887454706e-34,
0.0170945972,
-0.0254250355,
0.0159390699,
0.0369953252,
0.0058793542,
-0.0109053589,
-0.0211773012,
0.0039143511,
0.0402225889,
-0.0515561402,
-0.0233000014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17228v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17228v2 | TST$^\mathrm{R}$: Target Similarity Tuning Meets the Real World | 2023-10-26T08:27:36 | 2023-10-28T08:24:06 | Anirudh Khatry, Sumit Gulwani, Priyanshu Gupta, Vu Le, Ananya Singha, Mukul Singh, Gust Verbruggen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Target similarity tuning (TST) is a method of selecting relevant examples in
natural language (NL) to code generation through large language models (LLMs)
to improve performance. Its goal is to adapt a sentence embedding model to have
the similarity between two NL inputs match the similarity between their
associated code outputs. In this paper, we propose different methods to apply
and improve TST in the real world. First, we replace the sentence transformer
with embeddings from a larger model, which reduces sensitivity to the language
distribution and thus provides more flexibility in synthetic generation of
examples, and we train a tiny model that transforms these embeddings to a space
where embedding similarity matches code similarity, which allows the model to
remain a black box and only requires a few matrix multiplications at inference
time. Second, we show how to efficiently select a smaller number of training
examples to train the TST model. Third, we introduce a ranking-based evaluation
for TST that does not require end-to-end code generation experiments, which can
be expensive to perform. | [
0.0236458573,
0.0438063554,
-0.0063938936,
0.0365991779,
-0.0112172589,
0.0204418227,
-0.0110947229,
0.0227027424,
0.0025371553,
-0.0333361588,
-0.0051989569,
0.0264877155,
-0.0227590036,
0.0236580893,
0.0804970413,
0.0228317101,
0.0132316034,
-0.0134655731,
-0.0942717567,
0.0220803134,
0.0216896702,
0.0495339446,
0.0442957617,
0.0630273595,
0.0178009849,
-0.0020343242,
0.0164132025,
0.0067493259,
0.0341983289,
-0.0220744126,
0.0132217743,
0.0213369802,
0.0210866518,
-0.0070118578,
0.0000019687,
-0.0117535843,
-0.0230331086,
-0.0079953736,
0.0151776606,
0.0309725516,
0.0398608036,
0.0045298263,
0.011124162,
0.0586815476,
-0.029449407,
-0.0313082226,
0.0671043545,
-0.0240195375,
0.0625526458,
0.0814881697,
-0.0058708023,
-0.0112356078,
-0.013846375,
-0.0114435516,
0.0189110264,
-0.0259381253,
-0.0027255781,
0.0550516248,
0.0248667914,
0.0249822419,
0.0009501113,
0.0235482566,
0.0151266158,
-0.007330751,
0.0270536412,
0.0493716151,
-0.0583271049,
0.0249133073,
0.0131962718,
0.0577256121,
-0.0687186942,
-0.0755443126,
0.0419726595,
-0.0060683698,
-0.0437716991,
-0.0541382767,
-0.0048545017,
0.0215128325,
0.0002760439,
0.0525487736,
0.0288001299,
-0.0030790528,
0.0176420044,
-0.0055679842,
-0.038093403,
-0.0143065425,
0.0459609665,
-0.0243398827,
-0.0415400378,
-0.0203275029,
-0.0017566836,
-0.0333335586,
-0.0045263423,
-0.0020862916,
-0.0328915231,
-0.0111159477,
-0.0820579827,
-0.0185651109,
-0.0003853396,
-0.041144032,
0.0816591009,
0.0500353537,
0.0259154737,
0.0170434173,
-0.0728557929,
0.0618560873,
-0.0084121572,
-0.0058482992,
-0.0611711144,
0.0158717856,
-0.0750667751,
0.0064514307,
-0.0493267551,
0.0508946851,
-0.0098140733,
-0.022192467,
-0.022385126,
0.0559665337,
0.0297941715,
0.0299539678,
-0.0043994258,
-0.0028982626,
-0.0407862179,
0.0115710208,
0.0594438054,
-0.0218226966,
-0.0193060599,
-0.0519208908,
-0.034932036,
-0.0664023235,
-0.0060568689,
0.03642774,
0.0032175127,
-0.0340518728,
0.0177543126,
0.0540106744,
-0.0149002299,
-0.0188823175,
-0.0225678794,
0.0226014014,
0.0226279516,
-0.0203164332,
-0.0071184896,
-0.0744172409,
-0.0161638018,
0.0136097949,
0.0076649175,
-0.0489508957,
0.0117880767,
0.0264602788,
-0.0280029736,
0.0486199781,
-0.0063489792,
0.0053089228,
-0.0227288287,
-0.0184209328,
0.0327183232,
0.0443453602,
0.0549679995,
0.0011572536,
-0.0044796965,
-0.0131955454,
0.0168232769,
0.0630964413,
-0.0193380397,
0.0077623129,
-0.0097345924,
0.0288320892,
0.0239036269,
0.0365138799,
0.0518810414,
0.0271588396,
-0.0273087844,
0.0327752605,
0.0048921024,
0.0140124848,
0.0227414947,
0.0531797558,
0.0988790542,
0.044812914,
-0.0642824322,
-0.0228894725,
-0.0070978175,
0.055195,
-0.0224785097,
0.0152661856,
0.047302492,
0.0799064413,
-0.0262010712,
-0.0110851405,
-0.0005169178,
-0.012223159,
-0.0093394807,
-0.0204914715,
-0.0166695639,
0.0110815596,
-0.0755153298,
0.0543699712,
0.0053751632,
-0.0699565858,
-0.0391525812,
-0.0523229949,
-0.0050759912,
0.0374096781,
0.0688252747,
-0.0044007334,
-0.0011092853,
0.0035579235,
-0.0121603748,
0.0217078291,
0.0463021658,
-0.0009228462,
0.0135641303,
-0.0812106803,
-0.0177106522,
-0.0306546204,
-0.0180060957,
0.0317262001,
0.03495932,
-0.008487151,
0.0599085502,
-0.0189104322,
-0.0445750654,
0.0430408269,
-0.0178604089,
-0.0128088854,
0.0269487649,
-0.0062256306,
0.0418125615,
-0.0433704518,
-0.0437437631,
0.0252560675,
-0.0066721137,
-0.0503272228,
-0.0218043923,
-0.0213127062,
-0.0150964037,
-0.0701663569,
-0.0001807409,
-0.0765544847,
-0.0068085496,
0.078445375,
-0.0495954417,
-0.0092897983,
0.0196899455,
-0.0644950345,
0.0274243876,
-0.0272491369,
0.024335485,
-0.0143311787,
-0.0031697254,
-0.0233037472,
0.0286732763,
0.0203454103,
0.0277852416,
-0.0223015752,
0.0367930271,
0.0030981011,
-0.0062117535,
-0.0123492852,
0.0008250059,
-0.0041518784,
0.0458293557,
0.0377756581,
0.0798828229,
-0.006203007,
-0.0582323894,
-0.076931484,
0.0569867678,
-0.006070381,
-0.0111061987,
0.0359784439,
0.0294627342,
0.0039133104,
-0.0029964552,
-0.039192155,
-0.0176081918,
-0.0126214689,
0.0164221004,
0.0300961528,
-0.0292174648,
-0.0774337351,
-0.056561593,
0.0193580855,
-0.0049919114,
0.0772310421,
-0.0187614337,
0.0067941309,
-0.0978427455,
0.1196437106,
-0.0221938565,
0.0095445961,
0.004909236,
-0.0558724515,
-0.0059323334,
-0.0265073311,
0.0697386786,
0.0281037763,
0.0096287997,
-0.0087042982,
0.0621996634,
0.0305898432,
-0.0571850091,
-0.0053224689,
0.0053694434,
-0.0396539904,
-0.0139897484,
-0.0531510413,
0.0732342079,
0.0309931859,
0.0250339266,
-0.0069910246,
-0.058964204,
0.030388061,
0.0153756458,
0.0100576598,
-0.0146489833,
-0.018028833,
-0.0052785985,
0.0049433615,
-0.0075805909,
-0.0803395808,
0.0560273416,
-0.0334723629,
-0.0171817038,
-0.067390874,
-0.0223758481,
-0.0537796468,
0.0215343088,
0.015016933,
0.0396388583,
-0.0183877442,
-0.0063869129,
-0.0213793442,
0.0153808082,
-0.0128015568,
-0.020903958,
0.0364031941,
-0.0219505299,
0.0106038759,
0.0020390372,
-0.0499000214,
-0.0526136905,
-0.0275742821,
-0.0181679446,
-0.0126454337,
0.0510179624,
0.0070581124,
0.0019012198,
0.0075778598,
-0.0011432212,
0.036559362,
0.0103407195,
-0.0358193666,
-0.0161875356,
0.0095542148,
0.0044819396,
-0.0577753298,
-0.0282890927,
0.0120598236,
0.0119647989,
-0.0093442304,
0.0364027061,
0.0644903183,
-0.0796380118,
0.0248491559,
0.0361060239,
-0.0109352237,
-0.0217978992,
0.0590198226,
0.0424452387,
-0.0041122739,
-0.0280062929,
0.1143729165,
0.0523254946,
-0.0204869453,
0.012815333,
0.0132929608,
0.0697187483,
0.0582530312,
0.0656346306,
-0.0461723693,
-0.0227442831,
-0.0038693841,
0.0196360722,
-0.0188838951,
0.0066295024,
-0.0524332784,
-0.1270097941,
0.0180475861,
0.0411365665,
-0.0214924421,
-0.0601830669,
-0.0154904565,
-0.0314916372,
0.002401188,
-0.0326007679,
0.0233000759,
-0.0382275246,
0.0180570967,
0.0007824413,
-0.040511135,
-0.0235984661,
0.0192934703,
-0.0532560721,
0.0434728935,
0.0931210965,
0.0405008607,
0.03938495,
-0.0101105105,
-0.0024896399,
-0.0112848654,
0.0117088072,
-0.0273520853,
0.0175501816,
-0.007084962,
-0.0249965861,
0.0087341787,
0.0366682298,
-0.0439830273,
0.0073857321,
0.0190310627,
0.0471518673,
-0.0048355092,
-0.0309788547,
-0.004052938,
0.0158700943,
-0.0043755872,
0.0524332784,
0.0784046575,
-0.0356086195,
-0.0193686709,
-0.0302404966,
-0.006795194,
-0.0750181749,
-0.042613171,
-0.0197295137,
0.0063312571,
0.0186834577,
-0.0590926148,
0.0063274885,
0.0305918753,
0.0299852956,
-0.0013090065,
0.0058212029,
-0.0084165065,
-0.0110293832,
-0.0216164365,
-0.0043399655,
-0.0489513651,
0.0137731731,
-0.0058717863,
0.0008704934,
0.0494354703,
-0.0358747989,
-0.0209252518,
-0.0145844026,
-0.1009814367,
-0.0572477467,
-0.0674247816,
0.0334491841,
0.0078852866,
0.0445634387,
-0.0132947033,
-0.0355229862,
-0.0175295323,
0.0391774885,
-0.014134163,
0.0141517334,
0.0262513664,
-0.01926318,
0.0234248172,
0.0239972752,
-0.0626562536,
0.0335169099,
0.035712719,
0.0292398296,
-0.0171156321,
0.0083045783,
0.0567563102,
0.0246069487,
-0.0066613047,
-0.0047083721,
-0.0182773322,
-0.01288951,
0.000283229,
-0.0015871297,
-0.0234760847,
-0.0592622831,
0.0254214052,
0.0072196187,
0.0094597004,
0.0012358517,
-0.0187081676,
-0.0294697396,
0.0561579913,
-0.0156495757,
0.0423292927,
-0.0147711979,
0.0362805612,
0.052984152,
-0.019332435,
-0.0369995348,
0.01117553,
-0.000203338,
-0.0043814317,
-0.0411429815,
0.016570488,
0.01516663,
0.0132814655,
-0.0100103384,
0.034280818,
-0.0354131311,
-0.0370982327,
-0.0482615754,
-0.0047188792,
0.0811420828,
0.0159229916,
0.0455534048,
-0.0161825288,
0.0194749031,
-0.0054592039,
0.0569179505,
-0.0240562409,
-0.0493523516,
0.010654469,
0.0213666651,
-0.0311816931,
-0.0188913923,
0.0927739888,
0.023929147,
0.0302456059,
0.0096627334,
-0.0237862375,
-0.0502657816,
0.0130162463,
0.0395083763,
-0.002768086,
0.0154765137,
-0.0046513355,
-0.0017024999,
-0.0454741418,
0.001786237,
0.0383520462,
0.0038822214,
0.0095053371,
0.0455168448,
0.0660940856,
-0.0296550635,
0.0125968056,
-0.0350561738,
-0.0228094347,
0.0093701333,
-0.0746941864,
-0.038516324,
-6.17399902e-33,
-0.0154860998,
-0.0073201181,
0.0066090119,
0.000795972,
-0.0128224827,
-0.00564607,
-0.0516194291,
-0.0287781265,
0.0242763478,
-0.0313434415,
0.0341425352,
-0.0014171242,
-0.0100766383,
-0.0136424536,
-0.0012987896,
0.0307560693,
0.0572059676,
0.0151232518,
-0.0337467529,
0.0474812835,
-0.0236180238,
0.0252597071,
-0.0049632578,
-0.0203262474,
-0.0735231638,
-0.0205538291,
0.0115290396,
-0.0311394949,
0.0423021279,
0.0467371941,
-0.0124846287,
0.0190541651,
-0.0033502511,
-0.0245663878,
-0.0375722162,
-0.0099860011,
0.0096189156,
-0.0280566271,
0.0162029248,
-0.0449089259,
0.0374960341,
-0.0692645609,
0.0342681929,
-0.0297340583,
-0.0462236106,
-0.0039163372,
0.0202520005,
-0.0109252324,
-0.0140217487,
-0.0356364138,
-0.0789778084,
0.0351031795,
-0.0278156362,
-0.0128615256,
-0.0070467293,
0.0366193578,
-0.0095749721,
0.0402858034,
0.0136489663,
0.0263576712,
-0.0020246445,
0.0636478662,
0.0399613604,
-0.0119730057,
0.0076753753,
0.0532864742,
0.0078663873,
-0.0305099413,
-0.0055769794,
-0.0065965042,
0.0175452121,
0.0437952057,
0.043980483,
0.0448393561,
0.0294701476,
-0.0082610091,
-0.0619728342,
0.0100464532,
-0.0117750494,
-0.0106967939,
0.0693700239,
0.0344085395,
-0.0537314601,
-0.0206768215,
-0.0407318734,
0.0046240902,
-0.0403032266,
-0.0442852825,
0.0756880045,
0.014931961,
-0.0457734205,
0.0026115316,
0.0247429516,
-0.0449798778,
0.0102070542,
0.0344551392,
-0.0624098666,
0.0097973971,
-0.0099765453,
0.021921007,
-0.0069902777,
-0.0513325632,
0.0531471781,
-0.0397558399,
0.0604159944,
0.0035708495,
0.0241286643,
0.0138460547,
-0.0849196315,
-0.0149446419,
-0.0472271778,
-0.0436863676,
-0.0289252568,
-0.0096935946,
-0.0158540495,
0.0112795262,
0.0029120853,
0.0137462001,
0.0118997013,
-0.0605146438,
-0.0451853126,
-0.0196492039,
0.0019048627,
0.0478390604,
-0.0325650387,
0.0027920792,
-0.063190192,
0.0485418141,
0.04497879,
-0.048696287,
-0.0814276189,
0.006457713,
2.785e-7,
0.0112216724,
0.0437249728,
-0.0137705021,
0.0284893159,
-0.0080748741,
0.0232883189,
-0.0105285374,
0.0478684939,
0.0193670485,
0.0286941547,
-0.0049644983,
0.0125809573,
0.0480024852,
0.0159619544,
-0.0736359581,
0.0677924752,
-0.053756319,
-0.0190061107,
-0.0855119899,
-0.0320801288,
0.0324191339,
0.1009344682,
-0.0055799326,
0.0057896427,
0.0047006402,
-0.0372777842,
0.0244110972,
-0.0292873699,
-0.0072136982,
0.0086954115,
-0.0446314886,
-0.0010787118,
-0.0193427987,
-0.0118966615,
-0.011873221,
0.0008419913,
0.0225781575,
0.0388744511,
-0.0027187187,
0.0534735806,
0.0328703076,
-0.0054959226,
-0.0145905232,
-0.0664847419,
0.0473966412,
-0.0646111444,
0.0083442675,
-0.026406927,
0.0090273656,
0.0207535755,
-0.0130348131,
-0.0301647894,
-0.012078288,
0.0193260945,
0.0387404338,
-0.0172395222,
-0.0161965303,
-0.0440933593,
-0.0004679953,
0.0115497857,
-0.0318524167,
-0.0461644195,
-0.066151239,
0.01829556,
0.0481943823,
-0.0100769671,
0.041508358,
3.052993928e-34,
0.0121865207,
-0.0157517064,
0.0317370407,
0.0036275866,
0.0600477606,
0.0011347828,
0.0077744825,
0.0203961246,
0.0035575656,
-0.0688491315,
-0.0173192006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17217v1 | Beyond MLE: Convex Learning for Text Generation | 2023-10-26T08:08:43 | 2023-10-26T08:08:43 | Chenze Shao, Zhengrui Ma, Min Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) is a statistical method used to estimate
the parameters of a probability distribution that best explain the observed
data. In the context of text generation, MLE is often used to train generative
language models, which can then be used to generate new text. However, we argue
that MLE is not always necessary and optimal, especially for closed-ended text
generation tasks like machine translation. In these tasks, the goal of model is
to generate the most appropriate response, which does not necessarily require
it to estimate the entire data distribution with MLE. To this end, we propose a
novel class of training objectives based on convex functions, which enables
text generation models to focus on highly probable outputs without having to
estimate the entire data distribution. We investigate the theoretical
properties of the optimal predicted distribution when applying convex functions
to the loss, demonstrating that convex functions can sharpen the optimal
distribution, thereby enabling the model to better capture outputs with high
probabilities. Experiments on various text generation tasks and models show the
effectiveness of our approach. It enables autoregressive models to bridge the
gap between greedy and beam search, and facilitates the learning of
non-autoregressive models with a maximum improvement of 9+ BLEU points.
Moreover, our approach also exhibits significant impact on large language
models (LLMs), substantially enhancing their generative capability on various
tasks. Source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/ictnlp/Convex-Learning}. | [
0.041910693,
0.0873429105,
0.0207277201,
0.0039821789,
-0.0072010877,
-0.0104203522,
0.0088678077,
0.0083143413,
-0.0609465204,
-0.0194935352,
-0.0050837682,
-0.0715080053,
0.016642902,
0.0296247602,
0.0654427707,
-0.0648828894,
-0.040517699,
-0.0084453439,
-0.010400123,
-0.0367942527,
0.00363563,
0.0258515216,
0.0074925334,
0.0251814388,
-0.035946209,
0.0326698385,
0.0235440973,
0.0427657515,
0.0363700911,
-0.0049450905,
0.0073033157,
0.0151688904,
0.0159650892,
0.0177138038,
0.0000019694,
0.0090833874,
-0.0230064075,
-0.0317797028,
0.0064393468,
-0.0146949124,
0.0191527978,
-0.0646331683,
-0.0105484659,
0.0276371911,
-0.0037623467,
-0.0163881648,
0.0584954619,
0.0195078645,
0.0302347448,
0.1008593366,
0.0014277649,
-0.0461825542,
0.0203542039,
-0.0712752789,
0.036789801,
-0.0279379729,
-0.0058432459,
-0.033220537,
0.0004082698,
0.028571872,
0.001252496,
0.0475479513,
0.0181892179,
-0.0261936188,
0.0275328793,
0.0723991692,
0.0040781684,
-0.0239208806,
0.0022683812,
0.0422578342,
-0.0391653106,
-0.0478273034,
0.0238440689,
-0.0395161435,
-0.0234683566,
-0.031344045,
-0.0230056029,
0.0568902157,
-0.0058147414,
0.0328185558,
-0.0133086499,
-0.009501826,
0.0214023832,
-0.0024732682,
-0.0035251928,
-0.0139609361,
0.0296349414,
-0.0031279114,
-0.0397265926,
0.0194567367,
-0.0433951057,
-0.0111176074,
0.0052411286,
0.051204972,
-0.0042654644,
0.019757079,
-0.0631394684,
-0.010486491,
0.0004779288,
0.0002890351,
0.0470755957,
0.0228855908,
0.0326462612,
-0.0025588872,
-0.0506090671,
0.0265311673,
0.0079622269,
-0.0343016833,
-0.0373143032,
0.0015449502,
-0.0129562281,
-0.0071539683,
-0.001337942,
0.008815459,
-0.0095266476,
-0.0192321055,
-0.0539127812,
0.0030066983,
0.0040844441,
0.0217839573,
0.0234891567,
0.0425065868,
-0.0780304074,
-0.0269666929,
0.0146591449,
-0.0033325139,
-0.0239971019,
-0.0136737768,
0.0325554945,
-0.0468039922,
-0.0161652565,
0.0512269028,
0.0347971171,
-0.0014598062,
-0.0126334699,
0.0470131002,
-0.028084686,
-0.0134742465,
-0.0278740432,
-0.0383490957,
-0.0416980647,
-0.0647816658,
0.005813417,
-0.0831949338,
0.0223932974,
-0.0035831626,
-0.0200553183,
-0.0179062318,
0.055775322,
-0.014042818,
-0.0137964301,
0.0200838987,
-0.0072041834,
0.0013254128,
0.0847625732,
-0.0011252549,
0.0196786337,
0.0392849445,
0.0341811962,
0.0673985556,
0.0098723788,
0.0336015671,
0.0390074514,
0.0432364531,
0.0350416824,
0.0020521421,
0.0028431097,
-0.038799163,
-0.0585685559,
0.0463119037,
0.0442799851,
0.0467583016,
-0.0087286467,
0.0144094471,
0.0877280235,
0.0070248209,
0.0326003991,
-0.0136544667,
0.0539891347,
-0.0034637933,
-0.0166044738,
0.0330503397,
0.0108582452,
0.0410683937,
-0.0291828811,
0.0400439166,
0.0177631509,
0.0100327618,
-0.0386270061,
-0.0257885158,
0.0054827733,
-0.0424893983,
-0.037178766,
-0.0234459359,
0.0483710244,
0.0236473884,
-0.0718265176,
-0.0045386436,
0.0141615449,
-0.0453483686,
0.0570513457,
-0.0120152915,
0.0210006908,
0.0203089956,
0.0419842638,
-0.0027614294,
0.0088926982,
-0.0327923223,
-0.0259499308,
0.0650919825,
0.0073346477,
0.0097111305,
0.0019052656,
-0.0364438854,
-0.0181244444,
-0.0054245144,
0.0049934844,
0.0317425951,
0.0040460941,
0.0117005249,
0.0585541949,
0.0010693028,
-0.0500665084,
0.0318713225,
-0.0155568952,
-0.0419578366,
0.0431181937,
0.0260782447,
0.0007455652,
-0.0103854844,
-0.0183018111,
0.0287160017,
-0.0005988771,
-0.064428784,
-0.0388252735,
0.0228362083,
-0.0230245627,
-0.0588540956,
-0.0081496648,
-0.0583572388,
0.014665517,
0.0075951163,
0.0069022104,
-0.070343487,
0.0079828762,
-0.071918346,
0.0099171642,
-0.0365812853,
0.0260351598,
0.0459608622,
-0.0056268661,
-0.0527569912,
0.0534610897,
-0.0321915261,
0.0201894995,
-0.0339452401,
0.0104570584,
0.0231787134,
-0.0595918335,
-0.0007166099,
0.0043612286,
0.0035180277,
0.0084838523,
0.0834775716,
0.0208783597,
0.0126793785,
-0.0353184156,
-0.0168972183,
0.0298995506,
-0.0344780236,
0.0065810014,
0.0195712913,
0.0289416183,
-0.0049212095,
-0.0159852169,
-0.0408171974,
0.0422424227,
0.021562431,
-0.0026052047,
0.0526686236,
0.0233137924,
0.0294391215,
-0.0233650599,
-0.0241040178,
0.0070544686,
0.0294462629,
0.0123660862,
0.0040037553,
-0.0459876098,
0.0867347345,
-0.030449843,
-0.0097606555,
-0.0017378033,
-0.0173780974,
0.0044010747,
-0.0360632278,
0.0812288672,
0.0396369174,
0.0759450793,
0.007968301,
0.0027700749,
0.0365700722,
-0.0301291477,
-0.0006308705,
-0.0916913822,
-0.0377248004,
0.0014579087,
-0.0592775829,
0.0424984694,
0.0342869796,
0.0502461903,
0.0008875001,
-0.0653118044,
0.0291524157,
0.0146125061,
-0.0374592245,
-0.0430614874,
0.0257708114,
-0.0163567327,
0.0401288904,
-0.0196368787,
-0.0708684474,
0.0403330252,
-0.0343955122,
0.0379785895,
0.0099796532,
0.0117354877,
-0.0225921422,
-0.0033108811,
0.0422721617,
0.0608420037,
-0.024705926,
-0.0166620295,
-0.0344907567,
0.0504428931,
0.0567624383,
0.0021136373,
0.0225022323,
-0.0386452898,
-0.0211798809,
-0.0289771631,
-0.0482350066,
-0.0389616415,
-0.0342471711,
0.0585672446,
-0.0333752148,
0.0409911461,
-0.0214536786,
-0.0439036675,
-0.0205809902,
0.0160629041,
0.0438632816,
-0.0281475522,
-0.0311135277,
-0.0166322999,
0.0459029078,
0.0604520962,
-0.0371275917,
0.0009057655,
-0.086853005,
-0.0451942012,
0.0132490005,
0.0092636002,
0.0538146384,
-0.0022720317,
-0.0145200798,
0.035009753,
-0.0136556132,
-0.0388219841,
0.0042551365,
0.0693923756,
-0.0242396276,
-0.0163934585,
0.1040760949,
0.0072681126,
-0.0141445752,
-0.0043534236,
0.0451591425,
0.0823410898,
0.0052669053,
0.0161240101,
-0.0849474519,
0.0042323307,
-0.0442070998,
0.066435568,
-0.0143317375,
-0.0175864454,
-0.0451199524,
-0.1078506559,
0.0237947386,
0.0139751136,
0.0044516581,
-0.0477533229,
0.0048628636,
-0.0274253115,
-0.0181550086,
-0.0396693051,
0.0092995409,
0.0003479251,
0.0370779335,
0.0444420055,
-0.0222505927,
-0.0545855016,
-0.0557168536,
-0.0463856496,
0.034824349,
0.0540446937,
0.056555219,
0.0183848608,
0.0146171041,
-0.0426464453,
0.007100218,
-0.0039386214,
0.0036977488,
0.0381923169,
0.0031194263,
-0.0133769279,
0.0045648669,
0.0594204441,
-0.0085573588,
0.0221475828,
0.0216617826,
0.0099362107,
-0.0269461926,
-0.0216393657,
0.0147435153,
0.0059925206,
0.050149329,
0.0530310161,
0.0220047049,
-0.0473347567,
-0.0369808562,
-0.0360150449,
0.0120163076,
-0.0729373991,
-0.0097665405,
-0.0208320674,
0.0136894407,
-0.0456421189,
-0.1246582791,
-0.0119297849,
-0.0119366953,
0.0463718697,
-0.0067076315,
-0.0170532912,
-0.0346497521,
-0.0300532766,
-0.0084226523,
-0.0163686853,
-0.0062718401,
-0.0131049743,
-0.0467624217,
-0.0134886308,
0.0242901314,
-0.0701550692,
-0.0075120409,
0.0328336209,
-0.1109200269,
-0.0767733827,
-0.0582052246,
0.062253572,
0.0160903595,
0.0467220806,
0.0037843923,
-0.0443749018,
0.0481403247,
0.0690492317,
-0.0120644113,
0.012761049,
0.0218336172,
0.0281029698,
-0.0309125502,
0.044351723,
-0.0155234858,
0.0162075497,
-0.0049232831,
0.0341341086,
0.0048480998,
-0.0769803077,
0.0180099923,
-0.0058058952,
-0.0058498946,
-0.1197016761,
-0.0652208999,
-0.0623098835,
-0.0303203054,
0.0004331816,
0.0113119837,
-0.0207736325,
0.0200599153,
0.0587616116,
-0.0097942576,
-0.0328874849,
0.0062601711,
0.0200536679,
0.070608452,
-0.0596638843,
-0.0065451898,
-0.0263918657,
-0.0124443593,
0.0478030778,
-0.001287979,
0.001964604,
0.0510352142,
-0.0031337142,
0.0091186985,
-0.0002448552,
0.0438958667,
0.0130041894,
0.0153046176,
0.0204636604,
-0.0021409912,
-0.0566008985,
-0.0441189557,
-0.0705636442,
0.0344489664,
0.0643115565,
0.0152448984,
0.0686030313,
-0.0495640747,
-0.0192534234,
-0.0448722392,
0.051044587,
-0.0040734634,
-0.0325142443,
0.0076365224,
-0.0174957495,
-0.0027841004,
-0.0090093352,
0.1119212061,
0.0091321599,
0.0225798767,
-0.0069561582,
0.0268703494,
-0.07058011,
-0.0209924318,
0.0122581478,
0.0251234937,
0.0127449101,
0.0225236416,
0.0010134362,
-0.0255589131,
-0.0057861311,
0.0003078152,
0.0031878375,
-0.0064049554,
0.0693136677,
0.0326954387,
-0.0527124107,
0.0526309498,
-0.1022347957,
0.0426499508,
0.0114684487,
0.0168107655,
-0.0276946183,
-6.165631705e-33,
-0.0192810502,
-0.028459182,
-0.0206748396,
0.0694612786,
-0.0137999859,
-0.0029933853,
-0.0486100465,
0.018888548,
0.0210673623,
-0.0246893186,
0.0041165259,
-0.0114195123,
-0.0071993973,
0.0415964499,
-0.0037522658,
0.0165327843,
0.0474364087,
-0.0104924412,
-0.0618541054,
0.0497899577,
0.0449108295,
0.0236615222,
0.0410289951,
-0.0511160679,
-0.0069023976,
-0.0283570923,
-0.0524438396,
0.0202696137,
0.034879569,
0.0340672657,
-0.0184890665,
0.0463484228,
0.00441512,
-0.0374891311,
-0.0113977427,
-0.027538076,
-0.0139858713,
-0.0020326225,
-0.0299521238,
-0.0001828409,
-0.0468064472,
-0.0422705524,
0.0274257306,
-0.0351751149,
-0.0082471557,
-0.0188249983,
0.0434543043,
0.0035906413,
-0.0288333185,
-0.0465870351,
-0.0718762502,
0.0254542977,
-0.0099824602,
-0.0356001817,
-0.0026182584,
0.0411414728,
0.0261409953,
-0.0077386666,
-0.0322483145,
0.0483174101,
0.0100096902,
0.0784709156,
0.0470977277,
0.026812939,
-0.0016563188,
0.0501663014,
0.0220368057,
0.0042598969,
-0.030481793,
-0.0278141107,
0.0154147279,
0.0166069847,
0.0435947739,
0.0554905161,
0.0102556087,
-0.0191841312,
-0.0475080051,
0.0602407306,
0.001456761,
-0.0266094003,
0.020105781,
0.0179631636,
0.0059710899,
-0.0088360654,
-0.0391576514,
-0.0305532478,
0.0022429982,
0.0114314863,
0.0017840778,
0.0655718744,
-0.0236810017,
-0.0088307383,
0.0225880407,
0.0048498674,
-0.0020680663,
0.0297954865,
-0.0432015434,
0.0099911839,
-0.0102643538,
0.0191999562,
-0.0592577904,
0.0013890278,
0.0135782007,
-0.007094542,
-0.0171054956,
0.0293214489,
0.0402919054,
0.0459922515,
-0.0362116136,
0.0036785037,
-0.0779919177,
0.0444856137,
0.0074453396,
0.0432012454,
0.0433964469,
-0.0397228599,
-0.0101937614,
0.0175445788,
0.0147037599,
0.0228761118,
-0.0187289529,
-0.0248859432,
0.0058116163,
0.0027854727,
-0.0488711484,
0.0266040638,
-0.0173902381,
0.000917134,
0.0456921458,
-0.0666413382,
-0.0295554474,
-0.0151861869,
2.551e-7,
0.0463475212,
0.0168019757,
0.0171318781,
0.048595082,
0.0236215536,
0.0314784758,
-0.001173634,
0.0365917608,
-0.0095913308,
-0.0090064537,
0.0093088904,
-0.0101563102,
0.0725314245,
0.0070373532,
-0.0977259055,
0.0459709875,
-0.0492042266,
0.0095317177,
-0.0311619267,
-0.029996803,
0.0442639031,
0.0432916135,
-0.0141744679,
-0.0275974739,
0.046514757,
0.0048484486,
0.1065096036,
-0.0088854572,
-0.0315607078,
0.0293405,
0.0724004731,
0.0276988894,
-0.0300256629,
-0.0284370612,
-0.0495919473,
-0.0231685005,
0.0184635073,
0.0381417945,
0.0149205578,
-0.0309792478,
0.0398118831,
-0.0054611797,
0.0089068115,
-0.0209206268,
0.0229861718,
-0.0073211771,
-0.0048340484,
0.0021928577,
0.0279079992,
0.0160922706,
0.017244624,
-0.0809758678,
-0.0418112054,
0.0029743658,
0.0099070184,
0.024423046,
0.0133948764,
-0.0296420511,
-0.029020397,
-0.0038222894,
-0.0632399991,
-0.0195322186,
-0.0464999452,
0.0443464592,
-0.0118511617,
-0.064303562,
-0.0134765767,
2.378630727e-34,
0.0093704192,
-0.0117871733,
-0.0398391932,
-0.0188742951,
0.0310492311,
0.0062922523,
-0.0312209614,
0.0172707401,
0.007694372,
-0.0244611725,
-0.0370426774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17207v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17207v1 | Efficient Data Fusion using the Tsetlin Machine | 2023-10-26T07:49:25 | 2023-10-26T07:49:25 | Rupsa Saha, Vladimir I. Zadorozhny, Ole-Christoffer Granmo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We propose a novel way of assessing and fusing noisy dynamic data using a
Tsetlin Machine. Our approach consists in monitoring how explanations in form
of logical clauses that a TM learns changes with possible noise in dynamic
data. This way TM can recognize the noise by lowering weights of previously
learned clauses, or reflect it in the form of new clauses. We also perform a
comprehensive experimental study using notably different datasets that
demonstrated high performance of the proposed approach. | [
-0.0236303844,
0.0207939185,
-0.0185999218,
-0.004696866,
-0.0309202299,
0.0416121297,
-0.0351092964,
-0.0413740762,
0.0114092575,
-0.0141367083,
0.0325493738,
0.0119635416,
0.0203398764,
0.0779028013,
0.0210782774,
-0.045075696,
0.0388355479,
-0.0074249702,
-0.0071665249,
0.0198996309,
0.0041023237,
-0.0005129488,
-0.0167431086,
-0.0080250539,
0.001470112,
-0.0102519449,
-0.0551602393,
0.00298944,
0.0664540306,
0.0456739143,
-0.052187711,
-0.0092635807,
0.024021389,
0.0503105298,
0.0000017598,
0.0142771564,
-0.0320617631,
0.0084064417,
-0.0426644199,
-0.0121629974,
-0.01731457,
0.0029448236,
-0.0055029299,
0.0240685213,
-0.0621885583,
-0.00220618,
0.0605634376,
0.0378838256,
0.1187775061,
0.0776731372,
0.0033124182,
0.0002488736,
0.0184517317,
-0.0137474351,
0.0424006395,
-0.007373604,
0.018574154,
-0.0017105193,
-0.0076038954,
-0.0400608666,
0.0459945686,
-0.0025386193,
0.0436074287,
-0.0265178904,
0.0133782635,
0.0302767865,
-0.0228701886,
0.009204302,
-0.0080892732,
0.0659282506,
0.0278456137,
-0.0115411868,
0.0102961669,
0.0052671162,
0.006164602,
-0.0079039903,
-0.0263844244,
-0.0249623898,
-0.0192248449,
0.0136194043,
-0.0149672655,
-0.033840511,
0.0284857787,
0.0168143194,
-0.0700179562,
0.0111839017,
-0.0288393442,
-0.0370250084,
-0.0280169677,
-0.0100451438,
0.018428538,
-0.0766358301,
-0.0202202443,
0.0603835247,
-0.0700925142,
-0.0014122466,
-0.0278026331,
-0.0173849799,
-0.0012988754,
-0.0682153702,
-0.0062009147,
0.0248444397,
0.0001195621,
0.0459644683,
-0.0257959794,
0.012776088,
-0.0263648983,
0.0387451835,
-0.0629262403,
-0.0396493711,
-0.105452545,
0.0085733328,
0.0018340617,
0.0658620968,
-0.0091325948,
-0.0072988737,
-0.0694036111,
0.0552433804,
-0.0405282751,
0.0264761504,
-0.041873645,
0.0043287366,
0.0134347817,
-0.0262595676,
-0.0687683076,
0.0030612438,
-0.031304758,
0.0439137965,
0.0286984481,
-0.0147104152,
-0.0234630257,
-0.0140267331,
-0.0024062111,
0.0047219736,
0.00301844,
0.0709716752,
-0.0322048962,
0.0237688608,
-0.0590878986,
-0.054312963,
0.023694057,
-0.0462351479,
-0.0228456184,
-0.0202970095,
0.0239058565,
-0.0482557788,
-0.0274324473,
-0.0151257263,
0.0020483944,
-0.0009951248,
-0.0345277078,
0.0590395555,
-0.0139963608,
-0.0046921251,
-0.04755193,
-0.0419053249,
-0.0545106232,
0.0631222501,
0.0059933644,
0.0128927408,
-0.0221779514,
-0.0063259061,
-0.0168513805,
-0.0245006587,
0.0302877557,
-0.023680035,
-0.0841827542,
0.0236597955,
-0.0048239925,
-0.0021591547,
-0.0116754808,
0.0159320552,
-0.0223010425,
0.0470031723,
0.0197531153,
-0.0393248722,
0.0023109936,
0.0110843787,
0.0099530322,
0.0033437759,
-0.0044993386,
0.0641331375,
-0.0506199002,
0.0301508754,
-0.0862673149,
0.0063987286,
0.0524082854,
0.0275944453,
-0.0228512548,
-0.0854162797,
0.0014714495,
-0.0080097076,
0.0399714038,
0.0091844946,
0.0506206788,
0.0152091496,
-0.0142583326,
0.0541679487,
0.0383575261,
-0.018757822,
-0.0518555604,
-0.0485268161,
0.0274040066,
0.0490116663,
0.009614611,
-0.0523433127,
-0.023471836,
-0.0064463099,
-0.0242251568,
0.0163442008,
0.0176021606,
-0.0094093997,
0.0105192307,
-0.0540377423,
-0.0659466758,
0.0302186012,
0.0307478998,
0.0585976355,
-0.0134709505,
-0.0240814406,
0.0194625109,
-0.0184335466,
-0.0118850172,
0.0233191922,
0.026572397,
0.0004906491,
0.0200592689,
0.0077667548,
0.0532241799,
0.0154459327,
-0.0217452757,
0.0246330444,
0.0312112961,
0.0086643286,
-0.0738662258,
0.0624996088,
-0.0027023859,
-0.0273585897,
0.0501891486,
-0.0373064093,
-0.0784709305,
-0.0107115898,
-0.0812951103,
-0.0537510999,
0.0517037325,
-0.0657322556,
-0.0256433673,
-0.0289289895,
-0.0080791032,
0.0069231554,
-0.0146162929,
-0.0256934576,
0.1238306537,
-0.0068437876,
-0.02513282,
0.0006813727,
-0.0418488979,
0.0059661935,
-0.0255337264,
0.0966574401,
-0.0282919966,
-0.0163684208,
-0.0104639903,
0.0070616426,
-0.0429971553,
-0.0033592032,
-0.0549200252,
-0.0203439351,
-0.0186149292,
0.0150566865,
-0.0063768188,
-0.0022953949,
-0.0086997962,
0.026745718,
-0.0203630365,
-0.0323354527,
0.0341100171,
0.0323873796,
-0.0028354253,
0.0402149856,
0.0231174473,
-0.0137376692,
-0.0167283285,
-0.0135167809,
-0.0556910522,
0.023865195,
-0.0003187899,
-0.0370584019,
-0.0165547635,
-0.0227142088,
-0.0194289461,
0.040944878,
0.0044364184,
-0.0191653408,
0.0098087927,
-0.0574241765,
0.0002048839,
0.0438990444,
-0.0198365785,
-0.02575377,
0.0271118023,
-0.0395762771,
-0.0166613944,
0.0424083993,
-0.0177341234,
0.0421996489,
-0.0166214854,
-0.0681667775,
-0.0337930247,
0.0484368242,
-0.0196198039,
-0.0085755195,
-0.0499671511,
0.0128219919,
0.0572204776,
-0.027943572,
-0.0217619762,
-0.0233405754,
-0.0035425441,
0.0522523671,
-0.0478797629,
-0.020459177,
0.1095466837,
0.0102558201,
0.0087839905,
-0.053092394,
-0.036352966,
-0.0348084271,
0.0165443532,
0.0197033156,
0.0124003533,
0.0558681972,
0.0110127991,
-0.0377176479,
-0.0585568175,
0.0662376806,
-0.0295148417,
0.0564669631,
-0.052341938,
0.0133891208,
0.0125937015,
0.0191563088,
-0.0439100154,
-0.0220036823,
-0.0220190566,
-0.0118507007,
-0.0609090067,
-0.020684002,
-0.0397076681,
-0.0660518259,
0.0204177611,
-0.0137953162,
0.0033450562,
-0.0236802995,
-0.0492409393,
-0.023476813,
0.0182213541,
0.0545247905,
0.0090253018,
-0.0095866043,
0.0478984974,
0.0288289264,
0.0524359941,
0.0094798869,
-0.0429067798,
-0.0105500063,
-0.0337967575,
0.0235801283,
0.0005678091,
0.0038125273,
-0.013067035,
-0.0610723458,
0.0249534454,
0.081382446,
0.0014447067,
0.0339866355,
-0.0353257917,
0.0070799454,
-0.0078266785,
-0.0063618133,
0.0244639758,
-0.0557494313,
-0.0098267868,
0.0206767078,
0.0034184677,
-0.0337244049,
-0.0254072361,
0.0126447016,
-0.0908289477,
0.0151529647,
0.0160202999,
-0.0010211428,
-0.0285276305,
-0.0374278724,
-0.0283329934,
-0.0351117887,
-0.005752576,
-0.0308762491,
0.0165895429,
-0.0022372107,
0.0272791162,
0.020069208,
-0.0275316853,
-0.0030325286,
-0.0046682544,
0.0367347673,
0.0670563951,
0.0702589974,
-0.0527617335,
-0.1026649922,
0.0442541577,
0.0524489097,
-0.0201973729,
0.0041744933,
0.0451084599,
0.0543524809,
-0.0080533577,
-0.001617438,
0.0230017845,
-0.0058415011,
-0.0018801993,
-0.0025446445,
0.0658670515,
-0.0052928291,
0.0363579616,
-0.042024307,
0.0392975695,
-0.0035081287,
0.0456936993,
-0.0006752206,
0.0230902676,
-0.0230741501,
-0.0060613346,
-0.0340271033,
0.0003921184,
0.031574741,
0.0524090938,
-0.0095083537,
-0.043109104,
-0.052962482,
-0.0272612516,
-0.0135625433,
0.0761429071,
0.0062982282,
0.0381649621,
-0.0050325543,
-0.0000081856,
-0.0348808989,
0.0388191454,
0.0172073711,
0.0335524343,
0.025347976,
0.0108494433,
-0.0107679879,
0.013448297,
-0.012355905,
-0.0218263231,
-0.0444652885,
-0.0882203281,
-0.0099578844,
-0.0048840516,
0.0333322734,
0.0363590233,
-0.0339378081,
0.0251757801,
0.017702125,
0.0349476859,
0.0088113407,
-0.0300140493,
0.0726046041,
-0.0290573053,
-0.0048397933,
0.0091285259,
-0.0432874002,
-0.0154893296,
-0.0127943447,
-0.0586388297,
-0.1029497981,
0.0125471028,
0.0495432094,
0.0006801261,
0.0602182224,
0.0505942442,
-0.0238015633,
-0.0219041575,
0.0307630207,
-0.0260401499,
0.0126764504,
-0.0482586436,
0.0121001555,
0.035521619,
0.0003392467,
0.0369755737,
0.0219151117,
0.0232434534,
-0.000095008,
-0.0140418392,
-0.0216128174,
0.0167053305,
0.0206203107,
-0.015191406,
-0.0085911974,
-0.020022843,
0.0416349657,
0.0228777118,
0.0395569094,
0.0139057739,
0.0157614648,
0.0667025596,
0.0116212126,
-0.0131829623,
0.0006321943,
-0.1077789143,
-0.0460004881,
0.0328499153,
-0.0333451405,
0.0392882973,
0.0148374867,
0.0194499865,
-0.0083452901,
-0.0018889387,
0.0142590608,
0.0355524532,
0.0223418996,
0.0212766659,
0.0058457861,
0.0143026067,
-0.0197467692,
-0.0316585824,
0.0428917892,
-0.0347868949,
0.0439345203,
-0.0130323889,
0.0121858288,
-0.0363810956,
-0.0090274261,
-0.0278133471,
0.0364585891,
0.005663747,
0.0587306507,
-0.0182291213,
-0.0387316868,
0.0298681501,
0.0546217151,
-0.0029073637,
-0.002264845,
0.020867588,
0.0560101904,
0.0328634232,
0.0037943195,
-0.008461006,
-0.0130494628,
0.0319725871,
-0.0016512478,
0.017155895,
-5.954866302e-33,
-0.0497322902,
0.0104575902,
0.0010673751,
0.0058952672,
-0.0209866334,
-0.0167492144,
-0.014788691,
-0.0048176646,
-0.0317394473,
0.0374618433,
0.0008105402,
0.0781063661,
0.0290457346,
-0.0300719254,
0.0180776622,
-0.028038254,
0.0488349944,
0.0277246479,
0.0328261666,
0.0025162138,
0.0319109261,
-0.0192041937,
0.0048468052,
-0.0789149031,
0.0410295948,
0.0536007956,
-0.0524845831,
0.0519455373,
-0.0485943928,
0.0093791727,
0.021101201,
-0.0030674436,
-0.0120508345,
-0.0021031492,
-0.0610819049,
0.0198295582,
-0.0549023412,
-0.0202632807,
0.0002341133,
-0.0026247464,
-0.0341575593,
-0.0559082963,
0.0495133996,
0.0168298949,
0.0152704027,
-0.0442129076,
0.0263118148,
-0.0549370274,
-0.0253869705,
-0.0297910012,
0.0034483843,
0.046761319,
-0.0231722742,
-0.0186403245,
-0.0071588308,
0.0408294201,
0.0506567284,
-0.0486632027,
-0.0223220233,
0.019222023,
0.0726077259,
-0.008179184,
0.0019812146,
0.0168131422,
0.0041931295,
0.0642948225,
0.0195023734,
-0.0075061074,
-0.0438410975,
0.0190847162,
-0.0116557227,
0.0728296563,
0.0660861731,
0.0610143952,
0.0107811205,
0.0351550207,
-0.0757740214,
0.0710227937,
0.0624717399,
0.0679457709,
-0.010621109,
0.0091620712,
-0.0244428311,
0.0126488768,
-0.0112547288,
0.0280879773,
-0.029177798,
0.0023582175,
-0.0316144042,
0.0195479579,
-0.03238561,
-0.0375280604,
-0.0239616819,
-0.0513481498,
0.039962668,
0.0114157116,
0.0266614817,
-0.052835118,
0.0260567553,
0.017085528,
-0.0087869782,
-0.0416778289,
0.01313412,
0.040616449,
0.0298720486,
0.0132806022,
0.0120528303,
0.0209007189,
-0.0318843164,
0.008746936,
-0.0177167784,
0.0128391068,
-0.0347493254,
-0.0526640974,
0.0501784831,
0.0199811347,
-0.0164009351,
0.0057073855,
-0.0416458137,
-0.0028569142,
-0.0350094736,
0.0565720648,
0.0165526308,
0.0547127165,
0.0273857154,
-0.0413195156,
-0.0133146951,
-0.0483669229,
0.0624656491,
0.0073647345,
-0.0296377838,
0.0054364763,
2.554e-7,
-0.0134975389,
0.0046618595,
0.045680359,
0.0756085068,
0.0032627403,
0.0632035136,
-0.0485930443,
0.0087055778,
0.0394038521,
-0.0438198969,
0.0301753711,
0.0119100967,
0.0511554033,
0.0826295987,
-0.0219881609,
-0.0787237287,
-0.0351097994,
-0.0300874151,
-0.0262713414,
0.0589844175,
0.0935166627,
0.0863448009,
0.0427415222,
-0.0326953009,
0.0591952577,
-0.0460180938,
0.025941832,
0.010631728,
-0.0179097224,
0.0107091051,
0.0327152796,
0.0033152923,
0.0060174884,
0.0342387743,
-0.0255781896,
0.0156187117,
-0.0404856279,
0.0291359983,
-0.0045315227,
-0.0320092328,
-0.0163183436,
-0.0389965922,
0.0269872472,
0.003690355,
0.0653485805,
-0.0590404905,
-0.0348086432,
-0.0108953211,
-0.0080354679,
-0.0236999039,
0.051397007,
0.0582892373,
-0.0179690924,
0.0051532397,
-0.0173877031,
-0.0091191242,
0.0106702056,
-0.1146088615,
-0.0302922558,
0.0248819329,
-0.0618140511,
-0.0097894464,
0.0249445532,
-0.0046004932,
0.0385685936,
-0.0427845307,
-0.0175301135,
2.099731376e-34,
0.0538519509,
-0.0072546452,
0.0124025661,
0.0141835837,
0.0296961777,
-0.0062337299,
-0.0253959429,
0.0021783672,
0.0458093882,
-0.0572490357,
0.012889537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17191v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17191v2 | How do Language Models Bind Entities in Context? | 2023-10-26T07:10:31 | 2024-05-06T10:09:48 | Jiahai Feng, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | To correctly use in-context information, language models (LMs) must bind
entities to their attributes. For example, given a context describing a "green
square" and a "blue circle", LMs must bind the shapes to their respective
colors. We analyze LM representations and identify the binding ID mechanism: a
general mechanism for solving the binding problem, which we observe in every
sufficiently large model from the Pythia and LLaMA families. Using causal
interventions, we show that LMs' internal activations represent binding
information by attaching binding ID vectors to corresponding entities and
attributes. We further show that binding ID vectors form a continuous subspace,
in which distances between binding ID vectors reflect their discernability.
Overall, our results uncover interpretable strategies in LMs for representing
symbolic knowledge in-context, providing a step towards understanding general
in-context reasoning in large-scale LMs. | [
0.014484155,
0.0098898513,
-0.0456064567,
0.0721923858,
-0.0108895618,
0.0124170789,
0.0149033954,
0.0128210122,
-0.0010187753,
-0.037175063,
-0.073864758,
-0.0209584571,
0.0237974729,
0.0095752319,
0.0212105364,
-0.0161902644,
0.0192666873,
-0.0108736204,
-0.0004755546,
-0.0238626488,
-0.0311374273,
0.0053568496,
0.0045872475,
0.0021583934,
0.0005070258,
-0.0277574491,
-0.0061346865,
-0.0277489889,
0.0096767424,
-0.0272492561,
-0.0350588672,
0.0135801705,
0.0127683189,
0.0120617421,
0.0000020689,
-0.0575219058,
-0.00398417,
-0.0206395797,
-0.0216310918,
0.0277214106,
-0.0073750578,
-0.0393778868,
-0.0141539881,
-0.0536851361,
0.0065525072,
0.004565862,
0.0705494881,
0.0487111732,
0.0177762844,
0.0284845177,
-0.003461621,
-0.0140129756,
0.0260502361,
-0.0282495469,
0.0361830741,
-0.0320326276,
0.0218129419,
-0.0204089023,
-0.0030826086,
-0.0065615154,
-0.0511502773,
0.0282011945,
0.0386757627,
0.0082558878,
0.0021929734,
0.0219991263,
0.028132176,
-0.0025318644,
0.0279038455,
0.0416391827,
-0.0036805554,
-0.0329194181,
-0.0045354026,
-0.0026899381,
-0.0273680892,
-0.0006356085,
-0.0320820399,
0.0141840056,
0.0142985582,
0.0254858583,
0.0401008837,
0.0295374878,
0.0634415895,
0.0307203848,
-0.04611459,
0.0706167817,
0.0020956129,
0.0153802056,
-0.0607461818,
-0.0134019312,
-0.0485672019,
-0.0644229576,
-0.0021504296,
0.0583771653,
-0.0229286309,
0.0598916598,
0.0065238215,
0.0403556488,
0.0062415279,
-0.0757403076,
0.0040108487,
0.06180989,
0.0109338341,
0.0552870296,
-0.0473105647,
0.0696944892,
-0.0525586419,
0.0728439391,
0.0038470621,
-0.0071322317,
-0.0365000777,
-0.044076018,
-0.0084425155,
0.0138561735,
0.0017879069,
-0.0291466545,
-0.0054992186,
0.0630077198,
-0.0444149263,
-0.0066114562,
-0.0518734232,
-0.0303184986,
-0.010238938,
-0.0096558593,
-0.0662899837,
0.0102257654,
-0.0368592702,
0.0312754139,
-0.032206703,
-0.0501775891,
0.0019198075,
-0.0283185411,
-0.0209588446,
-0.0349327065,
-0.0017009412,
0.1008560136,
0.024473941,
-0.0406047888,
-0.0635355487,
-0.0522583686,
0.0096895844,
-0.0591664128,
0.015094718,
-0.0588355921,
-0.0238937605,
0.0580726936,
0.007156332,
-0.1058089361,
0.0127003724,
-0.0234507471,
-0.0091497153,
0.0890099257,
0.0033303192,
0.0150498804,
-0.0173015632,
0.016680805,
0.0364114679,
0.0685922205,
0.0374875888,
0.0050545745,
0.009172189,
-0.0080841826,
-0.007460651,
0.0206389204,
0.0384527519,
0.0266626757,
-0.0683945194,
-0.004387944,
0.0333340019,
0.0252159778,
0.0350548513,
0.019868385,
-0.0037280982,
-0.0201019645,
0.0573454611,
0.0628207624,
0.0132253729,
0.0234019756,
0.0149479173,
-0.0569368936,
-0.010309292,
0.0000093316,
-0.0854864195,
0.0526578873,
-0.0113649163,
-0.0106679909,
-0.0064285886,
0.0082271723,
-0.0271590278,
-0.0339451469,
-0.0235155486,
0.0181234516,
-0.0156581812,
-0.0050704274,
0.0363619551,
0.019859761,
0.0380158089,
0.0508284718,
0.0268249549,
-0.0146022309,
0.0143179344,
-0.0217977185,
0.0532479323,
0.0604004487,
0.0255440176,
-0.0396522284,
-0.011530662,
0.0241316408,
-0.0015489664,
0.0502201468,
-0.016578285,
-0.026535295,
-0.0126464721,
0.0042787287,
-0.0212486163,
-0.0315594003,
0.0136541473,
0.0295054149,
-0.0510681048,
-0.0101864748,
-0.0105144363,
-0.0308447257,
0.030529527,
0.0278991479,
-0.0376735702,
-0.0185034648,
-0.0471979901,
0.0294167548,
0.0190753918,
0.0062766266,
0.0111847231,
0.0119144022,
0.0164195932,
-0.0517734922,
-0.0093311509,
0.0543083921,
-0.0401203297,
0.0155867497,
0.0322152786,
0.0112033682,
0.0034766973,
-0.0535372831,
0.0070028356,
-0.0388528295,
0.057028085,
-0.0220429525,
0.0817548931,
0.0001063065,
0.0060755629,
-0.0310743563,
0.0058088102,
-0.0066057299,
0.0927852318,
-0.0093620187,
-0.0022906768,
0.039952904,
0.0808761567,
0.0138381757,
-0.0225766674,
0.0329860747,
0.0451381728,
0.0338000059,
0.0078563076,
-0.0140128164,
-0.0449948311,
-0.0191117972,
0.0033118089,
-0.0279783756,
-0.0101519907,
0.0029975988,
0.0066468683,
0.0412701555,
-0.0199243445,
0.0032505223,
-0.0024273414,
0.0023864897,
-0.0309929326,
-0.0167338438,
0.0545021296,
0.0255947672,
-0.0073211542,
-0.0618142039,
-0.017046323,
-0.0249190573,
-0.0245596617,
0.0735060349,
0.0081793573,
-0.0148099782,
-0.0493828617,
-0.0017621767,
-0.0499475226,
0.0080818674,
-0.0183127653,
-0.0126228165,
0.0316707641,
0.0035430044,
0.0227911454,
0.054196544,
-0.0344961956,
0.0672052205,
0.0574159548,
-0.0241321549,
-0.0656445101,
-0.0173511934,
-0.0137661118,
0.0359004922,
-0.020694837,
-0.0095750885,
-0.0252303984,
0.101601325,
-0.0065412223,
-0.0242647566,
-0.0514857844,
0.0494866967,
0.0064268671,
-0.0277243927,
-0.0420893542,
-0.0287738573,
0.0026201636,
0.1082445532,
-0.0312023368,
-0.0648934618,
0.0394447818,
-0.0210567582,
0.034448076,
0.0150437569,
0.0150308516,
-0.0465531498,
0.1033084244,
0.0213219635,
0.0110405106,
0.0097341705,
-0.0500022657,
-0.0462238118,
0.0356083848,
-0.0034747974,
-0.0079483343,
0.0587548763,
-0.0365680829,
0.0274866968,
-0.0046491073,
0.0056528035,
-0.0347278826,
0.0643457845,
-0.0370475687,
0.0111518502,
-0.0119238747,
-0.0012270723,
0.0223547257,
0.0200483054,
0.0313188024,
-0.0358703732,
-0.0075909472,
0.006283436,
-0.0515395179,
-0.0354863741,
-0.0082324771,
0.0142551344,
0.0258375499,
-0.0258754119,
-0.0175928231,
0.0131118586,
-0.0104436353,
-0.0388687439,
-0.0024022022,
0.0440509506,
0.0456509627,
-0.0155414175,
-0.0531164445,
-0.0310598779,
0.0560198091,
-0.0686326772,
-0.0372386388,
0.0842159092,
0.0524247438,
-0.0514904894,
0.0468549095,
-0.0489635803,
-0.0094121899,
0.0604249388,
0.004389836,
-0.0651468262,
-0.0162691269,
0.0296241026,
-0.0517350361,
-0.0237332322,
-0.0229040254,
-0.0082051931,
-0.0793001801,
-0.0185715929,
0.0042716353,
-0.0882713795,
-0.0671554357,
0.0063592759,
0.0481651165,
-0.0003280287,
0.0327917263,
0.0177962501,
-0.0165015105,
0.0139549701,
-0.0059471065,
0.0665563717,
-0.0290178359,
0.0252705663,
-0.0095903445,
0.0443834998,
0.042950321,
0.0165664777,
0.0020590285,
-0.0650432408,
0.0190839693,
-0.0138289714,
0.0175926667,
-0.0185226146,
0.0082504321,
0.0336699858,
-0.0335536338,
-0.0029957267,
0.0185563546,
-0.0187096354,
-0.0644886494,
-0.0633535013,
0.0588575713,
-0.0328452513,
0.0084373709,
0.0150311366,
-0.0298936758,
-0.0166944433,
0.0495003723,
0.0527875237,
-0.0416191928,
-0.0221527014,
-0.0533306599,
-0.0046284706,
0.0633085445,
-0.0769263208,
-0.0049033705,
-0.0137824379,
-0.0529921055,
-0.0543365739,
-0.00120371,
0.0409435332,
0.0106911333,
0.0241081193,
0.0105542503,
-0.0212927908,
-0.0247776546,
-0.0171391945,
0.0417085066,
-0.0227106214,
0.0411910564,
-0.030425556,
-0.0019095523,
0.0155936694,
-0.049193196,
-0.0153495912,
0.0254751313,
-0.0247077215,
-0.0688610002,
0.0118391132,
-0.0070625157,
0.0351037346,
0.0179329012,
-0.0143036814,
-0.0549727641,
0.0142454971,
0.0150504345,
0.0023154407,
0.0401755981,
0.0001239371,
0.0406429097,
0.0190343224,
0.0642510206,
-0.0368095674,
0.0328958295,
0.0556218103,
0.0285874829,
-0.0569845103,
0.0162938461,
0.0313249193,
-0.0325380787,
0.0037386951,
0.0131163374,
-0.0612814873,
-0.0321494117,
0.0132888043,
-0.0067550279,
-0.0180545431,
-0.0149854105,
-0.0045958394,
0.0045792917,
0.0236240923,
0.0015817538,
-0.0427623093,
0.043024499,
0.0529038757,
0.0310536735,
0.0288173091,
0.0344203115,
0.0237966012,
0.0160875637,
0.0454563312,
0.0178822018,
0.0267924555,
-0.0333624668,
0.0421776064,
-0.0205906685,
0.0249769427,
0.0409267209,
-0.0033286482,
-0.0455786511,
-0.0144174313,
-0.0180358551,
-0.0077872197,
0.0409542546,
0.0181048624,
0.05357299,
-0.0103694024,
0.0246029627,
-0.0187247023,
-0.0164707974,
0.0076422649,
0.0338616669,
0.0344830081,
-0.0404139608,
0.0470212847,
0.0288940407,
0.0004348253,
-0.0231022034,
0.0634160042,
-0.0319206044,
0.067589961,
-0.0201658774,
0.0026894903,
0.0066807731,
0.0083628381,
0.0107820807,
0.0370079987,
-0.0235159248,
0.0305605177,
-0.0774262249,
-0.0736535266,
0.0264805872,
0.0025387879,
-0.0319811776,
-0.0402394757,
-0.0151245398,
0.0180670358,
0.035141293,
-0.0285808668,
-0.0152489729,
0.009354963,
-0.029597668,
0.001363878,
0.017203195,
-6.399084883e-33,
-0.0598533973,
-0.0514240414,
-0.0018528887,
0.0173617303,
0.0058420417,
0.0072714142,
-0.0610574521,
0.0193088688,
-0.0210975185,
0.025081357,
0.0087267812,
0.0022371905,
-0.0056666886,
-0.0079508713,
0.016893765,
-0.041300483,
-0.0075634355,
0.0340989977,
-0.0215492174,
0.0265414063,
0.0776651874,
-0.0128356563,
0.0598349422,
-0.0767753199,
0.0434126854,
0.0046610562,
-0.0206207708,
0.0384079739,
-0.0617296211,
0.0484913439,
-0.0217192583,
-0.0011857194,
0.032184884,
-0.0414018705,
-0.0133049982,
0.0379365496,
-0.0545072593,
-0.0415613092,
0.0476815775,
0.0293023232,
-0.0457428619,
-0.0905695334,
0.073430039,
0.0033683875,
0.0139964139,
0.0003075942,
0.0255783852,
-0.0634058192,
-0.0227526575,
-0.0112600662,
-0.0881016701,
0.0105891498,
-0.0066403961,
0.0066468967,
0.0237200484,
-0.0667699575,
-0.0015560637,
0.0344046764,
-0.0600326806,
-0.0045051938,
0.000469795,
0.0059269797,
0.0433368124,
0.0593140684,
0.0309676845,
0.0475707725,
0.0028780869,
-0.0098726759,
-0.0352627821,
0.0318443663,
0.0194518454,
0.0539553873,
0.0391496457,
0.0148609113,
0.0217712987,
-0.0106981508,
-0.0477708988,
-0.0533043668,
0.0195055772,
0.004448148,
0.0402932838,
0.0317316018,
0.0034551942,
-0.0049901675,
-0.0636966899,
-0.0578176454,
-0.0578917079,
-0.0232228711,
0.00028045,
-0.0287328307,
-0.0247566346,
0.0300902948,
-0.0007315264,
-0.0433548763,
-0.0740295649,
0.0090508321,
0.0159145929,
0.0412442721,
0.0184018835,
-0.0044424688,
-0.0372368544,
-0.0069565373,
-0.0309767798,
-0.0325145945,
0.0208040886,
0.0095013604,
0.0427415892,
0.0278785061,
-0.0410722792,
-0.0047718026,
-0.0699564442,
-0.0243329387,
0.0057119755,
-0.0249783285,
0.0323661864,
-0.0055266363,
-0.0180307832,
0.0006657136,
0.0445932671,
0.0113959583,
-0.0072799246,
0.0378431678,
-0.0783054829,
0.0078630522,
-0.0559720546,
-0.0558536686,
-0.0519462004,
0.0303448066,
0.0854028016,
-0.0349173062,
-0.0025479149,
-0.006329007,
2.915e-7,
0.0786452368,
0.0406704023,
0.0147047695,
0.0499341786,
0.0672572926,
0.0179328248,
-0.0190436803,
0.0266376678,
0.0255655441,
-0.0458609164,
-0.0111815697,
0.0223985743,
0.0079235286,
0.0157304388,
-0.0176978242,
0.0566541292,
0.0037327833,
0.0036581845,
-0.0075242752,
0.0227976404,
0.0095322179,
0.0762580857,
0.0358150713,
-0.0181240682,
-0.0054858555,
-0.0349606164,
0.0645209625,
-0.0417806357,
0.0947738066,
0.0173360053,
-0.0281875692,
-0.0087251998,
0.0034941388,
0.0267935861,
0.0348362625,
0.04175191,
-0.0175951719,
0.026488442,
0.0084782019,
-0.0105882641,
-0.0411947966,
-0.0523520187,
0.0067272116,
-0.0450298712,
0.0894662961,
-0.0553306565,
-0.0615121238,
-0.0111240167,
0.0425758325,
-0.0016201806,
-0.0419523679,
0.0341788828,
-0.0166163146,
0.019634936,
-0.0210811496,
-0.0216131452,
-0.0287224371,
-0.089533776,
-0.0487259068,
-0.0382917449,
-0.0322707854,
-0.0036810359,
-0.0278183799,
-0.016205078,
0.0226276238,
-0.041356463,
-0.0258125421,
2.57838464e-34,
-0.0185243245,
-0.0247507151,
-0.0046368786,
0.0672749057,
0.0149093168,
-0.0350773819,
-0.0078093624,
0.0243781619,
0.0421216041,
-0.0585459881,
-0.0075000585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17166v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17166v1 | X-SNS: Cross-Lingual Transfer Prediction through Sub-Network Similarity | 2023-10-26T05:39:49 | 2023-10-26T05:39:49 | Taejun Yun, Jinhyeon Kim, Deokyeong Kang, Seong Hoon Lim, Jihoon Kim, Taeuk Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual transfer (XLT) is an emergent ability of multilingual language
models that preserves their performance on a task to a significant extent when
evaluated in languages that were not included in the fine-tuning process. While
English, due to its widespread usage, is typically regarded as the primary
language for model adaption in various tasks, recent studies have revealed that
the efficacy of XLT can be amplified by selecting the most appropriate source
languages based on specific conditions. In this work, we propose the
utilization of sub-network similarity between two languages as a proxy for
predicting the compatibility of the languages in the context of XLT. Our
approach is model-oriented, better reflecting the inner workings of foundation
models. In addition, it requires only a moderate amount of raw text from
candidate languages, distinguishing it from the majority of previous methods
that rely on external resources. In experiments, we demonstrate that our method
is more effective than baselines across diverse tasks. Specifically, it shows
proficiency in ranking candidates for zero-shot XLT, achieving an improvement
of 4.6% on average in terms of NDCG@3. We also provide extensive analyses that
confirm the utility of sub-networks for XLT prediction. | [
-0.024507653,
0.0468542576,
-0.0153424488,
0.042474363,
-0.0411367081,
-0.0050274953,
0.0203425735,
-0.019189937,
0.0151710473,
-0.0050917575,
-0.0837718695,
-0.0244862717,
-0.00510106,
0.0178551376,
0.0155272707,
-0.0130537525,
0.0618641041,
-0.0084052719,
-0.054386571,
-0.0193317402,
-0.0050657252,
0.0355328918,
0.0200821534,
0.0104098422,
0.0467414372,
-0.0020186899,
0.0357765891,
0.0117234252,
0.0206064433,
0.0165123716,
0.0061949431,
0.0299703069,
0.0173012912,
0.0318045653,
0.0000020391,
-0.0298205819,
-0.0417083129,
-0.0087411851,
0.0153960483,
-0.0010029195,
0.0352769867,
-0.0299443249,
-0.0130430376,
0.015360456,
-0.0183374546,
-0.0390876718,
0.0648507774,
0.008836464,
0.0155104678,
0.0742210969,
-0.0305142235,
0.0161661413,
0.0070388215,
-0.0348050185,
-0.0056457832,
-0.0717195347,
0.0311663635,
0.0323491432,
-0.0172475837,
-0.002357288,
-0.0317626931,
0.044211939,
-0.0204412099,
0.0022995071,
-0.0080489526,
0.0116399871,
-0.0126103917,
0.0180734769,
-0.0078253206,
0.0818318874,
-0.0658374578,
-0.0401603691,
-0.0205686893,
-0.010881695,
-0.021501096,
0.0296355132,
-0.068697013,
-0.0606740266,
0.0042377426,
0.006355308,
0.0387823172,
-0.0026668285,
0.0375515446,
0.0032545661,
-0.0232034773,
0.0641468093,
0.0549247973,
-0.0090932678,
0.0283456631,
0.0054708719,
0.0491166674,
-0.0530229993,
0.0149576636,
-0.0126987733,
-0.0182465371,
0.0236802232,
-0.0433794148,
-0.0024729478,
-0.0103989523,
-0.0124855125,
0.0683543906,
0.0480141863,
-0.0011019635,
0.0456438027,
-0.068026036,
0.042794995,
-0.0294506401,
0.0117538357,
-0.0612292439,
-0.0525487773,
-0.0767104775,
0.0193042737,
-0.0204781014,
-0.0127753317,
-0.0165307969,
-0.0074142497,
-0.0315239504,
0.0124034388,
0.0023626017,
-0.0331951678,
0.0621437393,
-0.0272305403,
-0.0427852161,
-0.0068849223,
0.0035037224,
0.0972387344,
-0.0026328182,
0.0127372239,
-0.0308205411,
-0.0264467467,
0.0003237553,
0.0179632157,
0.0009540743,
-0.0719811022,
0.015465633,
0.0914133042,
-0.0386121497,
0.0084807966,
-0.0353484675,
0.0322642736,
-0.0051879291,
-0.0477976203,
0.0343436524,
-0.0620487146,
0.0351944938,
0.0171365533,
0.0165720917,
-0.0392499529,
-0.0262841731,
0.0024498086,
-0.0517857075,
0.0202760231,
-0.0221642349,
0.0193131547,
-0.0155512122,
-0.0380601361,
-0.00779142,
0.0633558109,
0.0165346731,
-0.007126994,
0.0599453636,
-0.0238364469,
-0.0508343428,
0.0613601953,
0.0178092476,
0.0144922761,
-0.0209617224,
-0.0143389888,
0.0496399328,
-0.009297722,
0.0464552045,
-0.00994757,
-0.005965346,
-0.0193292983,
0.0431995541,
0.0456437021,
0.0535796769,
0.0451662242,
0.0608879365,
0.0020833835,
-0.0347413197,
0.0240216702,
-0.0365307964,
0.0416413359,
-0.0046671876,
0.0036224232,
-0.0103615923,
0.0914986581,
-0.0434583426,
0.0128153972,
0.0084176296,
-0.0176386647,
0.0167544764,
-0.0145576326,
0.0520094596,
0.0221734066,
-0.0313845053,
0.0585825928,
0.0503470749,
-0.0524600968,
0.0223009288,
-0.0058662686,
-0.004275152,
0.0513470843,
0.0019141338,
0.0173144266,
-0.035915684,
0.0367849469,
0.0345034525,
-0.0231886189,
0.08104112,
-0.0176067166,
0.02174953,
-0.0597397499,
-0.0227706954,
0.01739645,
-0.005262787,
0.0727256536,
-0.0143628698,
0.0488616452,
0.0201879218,
-0.0590360276,
-0.0391313918,
0.0136480918,
-0.1065121144,
0.0119808083,
0.0218243469,
-0.0059841569,
0.0143113937,
0.0254950617,
-0.0119336061,
-0.0079223346,
-0.0309682023,
-0.0268655065,
-0.0169053972,
0.045881547,
-0.0510853715,
-0.0218375847,
0.021274887,
-0.0199256111,
0.0271237437,
0.0428991169,
-0.0227219891,
-0.0403215922,
0.0567773618,
0.0291685648,
0.0304893181,
-0.042874489,
0.0067301462,
-0.0165475532,
0.0138609894,
0.0068273102,
0.0191332344,
0.0532105379,
0.0198390856,
0.0148931993,
-0.0278224237,
0.0445151068,
-0.0310925767,
-0.0105375145,
0.0426991954,
-0.0176817253,
0.0054275277,
0.0148736108,
0.0324127004,
-0.0233071502,
0.0119512323,
-0.0706163123,
0.0297652241,
-0.0087640742,
0.0428391397,
0.0352474339,
0.0368338488,
-0.0015403255,
-0.0061500189,
-0.0486801639,
0.0319904648,
0.0069756228,
0.0107377842,
-0.0096950131,
-0.0146309966,
0.0120502068,
-0.0627165511,
-0.0305549577,
0.0069572241,
0.0637615845,
-0.0375491343,
-0.0494944714,
-0.0289910827,
0.0627538785,
-0.0572414398,
0.0113849351,
-0.0296224542,
-0.0323848724,
-0.0456320979,
0.003083044,
-0.0090828836,
0.0132760033,
-0.0331053399,
-0.0751161277,
0.0429116525,
-0.0408349335,
-0.0531982407,
-0.0176030193,
-0.0052294708,
-0.0175799318,
-0.0531953722,
-0.0253554117,
-0.0268127806,
0.0725455061,
-0.0080714142,
-0.0489570796,
-0.0786766186,
-0.0248846877,
-0.0321669206,
0.0322147757,
-0.0180149823,
0.0255328976,
0.0236336775,
0.0267756041,
-0.0271679163,
-0.0036183654,
0.0692341253,
-0.0404306725,
0.0067018471,
-0.0475174524,
-0.0248258095,
-0.0604440384,
-0.0013446773,
-0.0117046041,
0.0133860344,
0.0157666598,
0.006981106,
-0.0770555735,
-0.0002672923,
0.039779827,
-0.0084857075,
0.002195318,
-0.0159247685,
0.0098634511,
-0.0022212847,
-0.0369097628,
-0.0016519283,
0.0106285037,
-0.0068444894,
0.0472824723,
0.0037010519,
-0.0119751925,
-0.033053685,
0.0192430634,
0.0062548243,
0.0534597225,
-0.0174339283,
0.0253886096,
-0.0129717151,
0.0530630611,
0.017057525,
-0.007419154,
-0.0196356513,
-0.0303405188,
0.007610769,
-0.0028885973,
0.0093060378,
-0.0064286427,
-0.0295158029,
0.0248491783,
0.0543939993,
-0.0031537923,
-0.0484461151,
-0.0071592964,
0.0666698813,
-0.0097908657,
-0.0034718984,
0.0646988824,
-0.0173454899,
-0.034464363,
-0.0128251892,
-0.053289447,
0.0315286517,
0.042531617,
0.0442745648,
-0.0499844737,
-0.0291633066,
-0.007499225,
0.0098866383,
0.0680552423,
-0.0143922195,
-0.0184956286,
-0.116229713,
0.0118525922,
0.0358544178,
-0.1027652323,
0.0139993457,
-0.0381905846,
0.0366967618,
-0.0559327044,
0.0153559512,
-0.031906534,
-0.0104494523,
-0.0243941434,
0.0206275191,
-0.0205913149,
-0.0845981166,
0.036748793,
-0.0414833203,
0.04292842,
0.0245545879,
0.035486646,
-0.010679313,
-0.0314581618,
0.0447981656,
-0.0442063548,
-0.0064337235,
-0.019949818,
0.0272564031,
-0.007415887,
0.0116564892,
0.0487126969,
-0.0144221196,
-0.0137307672,
-0.0038553262,
0.0062587745,
0.1129056588,
0.0514916852,
-0.0528941341,
-0.0024100044,
-0.0103768306,
0.0272339862,
0.0626479387,
0.0189318173,
-0.04681376,
0.0012448684,
0.0159654766,
-0.0175850093,
-0.0512911826,
-0.0254944246,
0.0031470412,
-0.0653853416,
-0.0393522009,
-0.0703519136,
-0.0191987306,
0.0117024658,
0.0062745633,
0.0330299512,
0.021054633,
-0.0093576135,
-0.0284020994,
-0.0154152345,
-0.000351922,
-0.0257602725,
0.0398051627,
-0.0268966779,
0.0116057694,
0.0522112995,
-0.0293262023,
-0.0177030712,
-0.0318964496,
-0.0524774604,
-0.0672912523,
-0.0479503311,
0.0367647782,
0.0124075636,
0.0670196414,
-0.0194171052,
-0.046176251,
0.0122770425,
-0.0027370672,
0.0148827359,
-0.0174152981,
0.036089547,
-0.0492581055,
-0.0102015333,
0.041326981,
-0.0338450298,
0.0347977914,
0.0295676813,
0.0241135675,
0.0008859489,
-0.0530643836,
-0.0146427732,
0.0015016411,
0.0078141671,
-0.0062522581,
-0.039424099,
-0.0663480014,
0.02757084,
-0.0007029274,
0.0061710454,
-0.0444038883,
-0.0317641348,
0.0526545905,
0.0146390758,
0.0233706795,
0.0093249865,
-0.0199690592,
0.0256211553,
-0.0334369987,
0.0042007584,
0.0029312682,
0.0576488376,
0.0101537127,
0.0143604567,
-0.0075205951,
-0.0419515073,
0.0263321847,
0.0315953307,
-0.078145273,
0.0092666717,
0.0051685921,
0.0016940184,
0.0045996015,
0.0338973887,
-0.0421346165,
-0.0310972854,
-0.0473475754,
-0.0247731693,
0.0742953196,
-0.0543267876,
0.1048797742,
-0.0041311565,
-0.0154370163,
-0.0478766225,
0.0357708819,
-0.0135795856,
0.0051671262,
0.0223505236,
0.0082220463,
-0.0112278108,
0.0267871153,
0.0631965324,
0.0195279811,
0.0012258001,
-0.0260756388,
-0.0164778605,
0.0116095003,
-0.0077360692,
0.0316744633,
0.0060119955,
-0.0294565745,
-0.0097356327,
-0.0382001065,
-0.090240635,
0.0324906148,
-0.0101134749,
-0.023708038,
0.0221716035,
0.0143937534,
0.0843593627,
-0.0107344147,
0.037690904,
-0.00732646,
-0.0410404801,
0.0000300027,
-0.0102729462,
-0.0261646584,
-6.100299933e-33,
-0.0182647221,
0.0089867739,
0.0210925993,
-0.0231314301,
-0.0166482143,
-0.0070465412,
-0.0483263582,
-0.0219757222,
-0.0347281955,
-0.0000255319,
-0.0120293619,
-0.0168484431,
0.0194622111,
0.0199133307,
-0.0004487096,
0.023685962,
0.0410598926,
0.0144971171,
-0.0151600083,
0.0230735429,
0.0407217555,
0.0529356636,
0.1168958023,
-0.0840795934,
0.0067236372,
0.0074074692,
0.057931371,
-0.0079256352,
0.0332103558,
0.0481153466,
0.0141121801,
0.0402833596,
0.0374272279,
-0.0452325381,
-0.0253207702,
-0.0070496723,
-0.04989646,
-0.0437657163,
0.0492380261,
-0.0018480077,
0.0094873914,
-0.0062504536,
0.0028023045,
-0.0372292064,
-0.0063139894,
-0.0526034199,
0.0558419563,
-0.0332431868,
-0.0157996099,
0.0199689381,
-0.0826706812,
0.0141372867,
0.0007932783,
0.0130642122,
0.0338357128,
0.0894665569,
0.0080612265,
-0.0184195135,
-0.0343332887,
0.0383468792,
-0.0471255444,
0.0585335121,
0.1122962087,
-0.0036417791,
-0.0192290843,
0.023971796,
0.0382942222,
-0.0120667843,
0.0664158165,
-0.0139953531,
0.0571654178,
0.0283984691,
0.0465411283,
0.0720290542,
0.0006808822,
-0.0248217843,
-0.0869923681,
0.0327348746,
-0.0190502927,
0.011979036,
-0.0096469987,
0.0419538692,
0.0016152533,
-0.0323312655,
-0.0190138593,
-0.053425964,
-0.0115252603,
-0.064616777,
0.0230554491,
-0.0450171605,
0.0002024312,
-0.0037325695,
0.0777528882,
-0.0522785522,
-0.0443727523,
0.0319944397,
-0.0350827016,
-0.0037402941,
0.0019816211,
0.0607157014,
-0.0777545199,
-0.0584395453,
-0.0324356481,
0.0001471378,
0.0356320366,
0.0027935593,
0.0293410905,
0.0231665839,
-0.0336397924,
-0.0171484351,
-0.0392691195,
-0.0238348059,
-0.0069059455,
0.0687517375,
0.019139545,
0.0231943578,
-0.0031880299,
0.0145692611,
0.0412110202,
-0.0217650589,
-0.0162918139,
-0.0163123664,
0.0351492167,
0.0308303814,
-0.0323551446,
0.0024145062,
-0.0417590626,
0.0109633682,
0.020458851,
-0.0244590454,
-0.0367252566,
0.028823819,
2.761e-7,
0.0351857655,
0.0177801363,
-0.0233605634,
-0.0189565253,
0.0055508916,
0.0112773804,
-0.077223897,
0.0400155373,
0.0419460163,
0.0067374627,
0.0172971264,
0.0196208321,
0.0784841329,
0.0398599021,
-0.0756207108,
0.0007713743,
-0.0409208499,
0.0173917823,
-0.0212105922,
0.0077448059,
-0.0114909969,
0.0580456853,
0.0000385212,
-0.0011819178,
-0.0137297381,
-0.0271229818,
0.061364904,
-0.0639714524,
-0.0117893331,
0.0230173562,
-0.0112032369,
0.0042172098,
-0.0454525575,
0.0396220051,
-0.0405759066,
0.0466338173,
0.0577209331,
0.0335415602,
0.0019176039,
-0.0028491972,
0.010416789,
-0.0004044594,
-0.0056162272,
-0.0478458963,
0.0740577653,
-0.0268417597,
-0.0094240969,
-0.0081307003,
-0.0219523944,
0.0453406349,
0.0310142022,
-0.0050239554,
-0.0354690142,
0.0140253436,
0.0512484163,
0.0254211538,
-0.0786172152,
-0.0112227425,
-0.0057961349,
0.0466280393,
-0.025797775,
-0.0621175431,
-0.0210036356,
-0.0215633903,
0.033165779,
-0.0336738043,
0.0551593229,
2.315263546e-34,
0.0014598581,
0.0074279439,
0.0314646363,
-0.0132409912,
0.0059741493,
-0.0407332778,
-0.0016271808,
0.0222026519,
-0.0167845171,
-0.0459161215,
-0.0081329532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17143v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17143v2 | Techniques for supercharging academic writing with generative AI | 2023-10-26T04:35:00 | 2024-02-13T05:31:19 | Zhicheng Lin | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Academic writing is an indispensable yet laborious part of the research
enterprise. This Perspective maps out principles and methods for using
generative artificial intelligence (AI), specifically large language models
(LLMs), to elevate the quality and efficiency of academic writing. We introduce
a human-AI collaborative framework that delineates the rationale (why), process
(how), and nature (what) of AI engagement in writing. The framework pinpoints
both short-term and long-term reasons for engagement and their underlying
mechanisms (e.g., cognitive offloading and imaginative stimulation). It reveals
the role of AI throughout the writing process, conceptualized through a
two-stage model for human-AI collaborative writing, and the nature of AI
assistance in writing, represented through a model of writing-assistance types
and levels. Building on this framework, we describe effective prompting
techniques for incorporating AI into the writing routine (outlining, drafting,
and editing) as well as strategies for maintaining rigorous scholarship,
adhering to varied journal policies, and avoiding overreliance on AI.
Ultimately, the prudent integration of AI into academic writing can ease the
communication burden, empower authors, accelerate discovery, and promote
diversity in science. | [
0.0582392104,
0.0364299901,
-0.0214985255,
-0.0369823799,
-0.053850323,
0.004738471,
0.04153594,
-0.0179140121,
0.0142410472,
-0.0562035851,
0.0150785446,
-0.0284844805,
0.0044626375,
0.0548494533,
0.0173515417,
-0.0368743166,
0.0041173748,
-0.0075243432,
0.0822025612,
-0.0046992437,
0.0152867781,
0.0172792543,
0.0106602134,
0.0499978997,
-0.0073584714,
-0.0474112034,
-0.0018608244,
-0.0041353204,
-0.0177185666,
-0.0098019177,
0.002301503,
0.074351415,
0.0343898684,
0.0421046726,
0.0000020357,
-0.043492686,
0.0258411653,
0.0297929384,
0.0083979769,
0.0044969376,
0.0397233665,
0.0012742322,
-0.0099097406,
-0.0017024591,
-0.054562714,
0.0258954205,
0.0509807952,
0.0054724701,
-0.0255526882,
0.0486210138,
-0.008873838,
-0.0219002664,
0.0771782771,
0.011187681,
-0.0084047224,
0.0494455099,
0.0394796729,
-0.0010237209,
0.0155636752,
0.0255613849,
-0.0107104201,
0.0364996418,
0.0176125448,
-0.086526297,
0.0607091263,
0.0421921983,
0.0081397677,
-0.0065413923,
0.0273789298,
-0.0127071189,
0.0765277818,
-0.0213237796,
0.0251795258,
-0.0030225983,
-0.019874176,
0.0458989628,
-0.0520985425,
0.0388185345,
-0.0214203019,
-0.0204219297,
0.0515247844,
-0.0093500512,
0.0153588234,
0.0562856346,
0.0079367477,
0.0110792378,
0.0058307042,
-0.0362768173,
-0.0092689311,
0.0248905141,
0.0061628325,
-0.0654444098,
-0.0114660114,
0.0558574237,
-0.0241307337,
0.0060617388,
-0.0289381351,
-0.0651326776,
-0.0005130512,
0.0168847833,
0.067329444,
0.0208954904,
0.0389918908,
-0.0188478883,
0.0377879813,
0.0025304817,
-0.0210489091,
0.0084332898,
0.005090368,
0.0398267023,
-0.0460912064,
-0.0458683632,
-0.0320619456,
0.0140770543,
-0.0057514613,
-0.0392188281,
-0.0129775684,
-0.0086974725,
-0.0069646509,
0.0023437089,
-0.0326793715,
0.0177779812,
-0.0772393644,
0.0029477463,
0.0163891166,
0.0083272858,
-0.0089661274,
0.0204154253,
0.0090986164,
-0.0138542764,
0.0013120681,
0.0191638879,
-0.0067548347,
-0.0296751205,
-0.0144649735,
0.0281214751,
0.015194797,
-0.0153541518,
-0.0065789553,
-0.0396600403,
0.0140920458,
-0.0539855771,
0.0228322633,
-0.0383420326,
0.0317050628,
0.0214624461,
-0.010885275,
-0.0991183147,
-0.0136983898,
0.0087121977,
0.0212832168,
0.0220236052,
-0.0548276752,
0.0198020265,
0.0657177046,
-0.0050284909,
0.0026570871,
-0.0173469409,
0.0845601633,
0.0018859004,
0.0228754915,
0.0110322358,
0.0614522919,
-0.0214007515,
-0.0335992351,
0.007459559,
0.00146125,
-0.0197526384,
-0.0073416624,
0.0594762713,
0.0055802339,
0.0595847294,
-0.0081905806,
0.0706418976,
0.0954964682,
0.0702744126,
-0.021009231,
0.065803729,
0.0602971837,
-0.0004631811,
0.0196941737,
0.0445221364,
0.0106549766,
0.0570547991,
0.0416398048,
0.0153415604,
0.0066906987,
0.0309212264,
-0.0077702422,
-0.0734244585,
-0.0056345654,
0.0323723517,
-0.0121077625,
-0.021242924,
0.0163021497,
-0.0216783583,
0.0057855002,
-0.0656179041,
0.011706477,
-0.0459830463,
0.032353282,
-0.0209917743,
0.061589811,
0.1053785682,
0.0655370206,
-0.0255781282,
0.0207533557,
-0.0533320047,
0.0281085726,
0.0756048933,
-0.0088357972,
-0.0018874039,
-0.0531112216,
-0.0298157912,
0.0027619372,
-0.0534607247,
-0.000596551,
-0.027274657,
-0.0080491137,
0.0160273351,
0.0049808314,
0.0238745958,
-0.0837828517,
0.0524665862,
-0.1059666499,
-0.0104883183,
-0.0027071666,
-0.0213543642,
-0.0116865858,
0.0275530685,
-0.0546058901,
0.030613957,
0.0048631788,
-0.0369397961,
-0.0265059453,
0.0270071719,
0.0138775269,
0.0592811853,
0.0047941171,
-0.0591224283,
0.0347395465,
-0.0071417419,
0.0240755323,
-0.0085650645,
0.0103788394,
-0.0324835777,
0.0031051575,
-0.0266742092,
-0.0114335138,
-0.0268798023,
-0.0052663763,
-0.0165342856,
0.0172875673,
-0.0053471592,
0.0176427234,
0.0301211551,
-0.0128819589,
0.0034180933,
0.0013480617,
-0.0042261137,
0.0324685946,
0.0448849984,
-0.0007034264,
0.0273904558,
-0.0460410528,
-0.031850215,
-0.0399818793,
-0.0392380357,
-0.0053774402,
-0.0073527987,
-0.0060406458,
0.0035659594,
-0.0305566676,
-0.0075394455,
0.0561050214,
0.0107479906,
-0.0432885252,
-0.0184948575,
-0.0082820198,
0.0426595137,
-0.0088576386,
0.0182522349,
-0.0237213075,
0.0005718939,
-0.0130279763,
0.0140622538,
0.109439984,
-0.0312811621,
-0.0605462715,
0.0264717918,
0.0012717701,
-0.0448811986,
-0.01448227,
-0.0191672035,
0.0255683511,
0.0009655887,
0.0578362085,
0.0922888741,
0.0134707009,
0.0561918467,
0.0921024308,
0.0322779417,
-0.0075717308,
0.0000395111,
0.0049202079,
0.0354347453,
0.0123082781,
-0.0479005165,
0.0113147981,
0.0034403764,
0.0182857011,
-0.0178764667,
-0.0164038092,
0.0665450394,
-0.0569740981,
-0.0450525805,
0.0321478508,
-0.0510874912,
-0.0291335508,
0.0350250639,
-0.0186009109,
-0.0401169918,
0.051349625,
0.0164219607,
-0.0030577434,
-0.0331760906,
0.0021783181,
-0.0286951456,
0.0575316362,
-0.0056491382,
0.0053655491,
0.0267551132,
0.0348132439,
-0.0608696714,
-0.0072588054,
0.0102624968,
0.0073724836,
0.0115005895,
-0.041198384,
0.0049852496,
0.0009095608,
-0.0077389395,
0.0035535349,
-0.0071499567,
-0.0161070619,
0.0565980189,
0.0460526757,
-0.0516904518,
-0.0194488429,
-0.0409350954,
0.0691894516,
0.0624689907,
-0.0373741202,
-0.0251647942,
-0.0377023593,
-0.0107135074,
0.0561040118,
-0.026339788,
-0.0185726658,
-0.0306325853,
0.0306444634,
0.0192636978,
-0.0391082019,
0.0303400867,
-0.0206055027,
-0.0502310358,
0.0184521563,
-0.0582945533,
-0.0248860475,
0.0122071868,
0.0331189744,
-0.0254886225,
-0.0479755029,
0.1142917871,
-0.0084876996,
-0.0719527528,
-0.0056877024,
-0.0623738728,
0.0074561681,
0.0011547263,
0.0635342449,
-0.0564439036,
0.0328567177,
-0.0013443007,
0.0271687657,
-0.056813132,
-0.0425681658,
-0.0062917355,
-0.0589568838,
0.0648011118,
-0.005567566,
0.0109852375,
0.0145692406,
-0.0309535135,
-0.0097849863,
0.0245108791,
-0.0174091961,
-0.0154932328,
0.0147065278,
0.0292009935,
0.0382343531,
-0.0077827703,
-0.0481551327,
-0.0480986126,
-0.0469277687,
0.048999045,
0.0288838241,
0.0659401044,
-0.0296975896,
-0.0188523605,
-0.0452648699,
0.0380002074,
0.0222864635,
-0.0034610135,
0.0261837002,
-0.0069006421,
0.0355968773,
-0.0502849221,
0.0525228716,
-0.016492825,
-0.0485996306,
0.0398738496,
0.0879889429,
-0.0375267975,
-0.0127728321,
-0.0625784472,
0.0061329566,
0.0320977159,
0.0320637673,
0.0358867832,
-0.0618293956,
-0.0235586334,
-0.021407621,
0.051076781,
-0.0538121574,
-0.0187608134,
-0.0431490578,
-0.0307289921,
0.0009069931,
-0.058421541,
-0.0879695639,
0.0167510975,
0.0324093252,
0.0666567907,
0.0319773071,
-0.0230461285,
-0.0237355698,
-0.0405815467,
-0.0063402453,
-0.0028780696,
0.0299196485,
-0.0015284831,
-0.065676935,
-0.0202338938,
-0.04677907,
0.0107770264,
0.0018484005,
0.0074439631,
-0.0679578707,
0.0202583633,
0.0313283801,
0.0183790196,
-0.0004372018,
0.0138286119,
-0.0685817823,
-0.0152886594,
0.0332669392,
0.0118766446,
0.033700671,
-0.0043991813,
-0.0250867866,
-0.0083044451,
-0.0030810479,
0.0084118564,
0.0107962731,
0.0142350718,
-0.002851285,
-0.0305066481,
-0.0493733212,
0.0247941483,
0.0111045316,
0.0008287213,
-0.0637773052,
0.0000381032,
-0.0607065745,
-0.0228765365,
-0.0592123196,
-0.0296046734,
-0.0333081819,
-0.0035769818,
0.0214772634,
0.051605437,
-0.0200337768,
0.0578386113,
-0.0480480529,
-0.0027747368,
-0.0361223817,
0.0440604016,
-0.031477429,
0.0693716034,
0.015218595,
-0.0069957417,
-0.034566652,
0.0238304771,
-0.0581859015,
0.0325996056,
0.027881369,
0.0403246991,
0.041289635,
-0.0010891529,
0.0117861228,
-0.0064103366,
-0.0997694805,
-0.025026409,
-0.0105950506,
0.0110378684,
0.0235869549,
0.0211633034,
0.0230176542,
-0.038936615,
-0.0018038364,
-0.0134807304,
0.0730711594,
0.0369497351,
-0.0282187779,
-0.018965926,
0.0018902378,
-0.0113028446,
-0.0575428009,
0.0527836382,
-0.0138611514,
0.0323735327,
0.0051668575,
-0.0389987491,
0.0042317905,
-0.059750516,
-0.0032161414,
0.005484425,
0.0473342612,
-0.0052826451,
-0.0595777407,
-0.021726558,
0.0273450837,
-0.0167451408,
-0.0053903135,
-0.0883546993,
-0.0164776761,
0.0201053061,
-0.0251873415,
-0.0343864635,
-0.0546534844,
0.0693102926,
-0.046407599,
-0.0342139862,
-0.0404050276,
-5.588645813e-33,
0.0138097163,
-0.0857647583,
0.0335346684,
0.0253821854,
-0.0639679655,
0.0238757767,
-0.0509654656,
-0.0049842144,
0.0086712372,
0.0596018173,
-0.0664817765,
-0.0067107477,
-0.0146616409,
0.0142275225,
0.0503066219,
0.0468494818,
0.0675936639,
-0.0245026406,
-0.0192375444,
0.0022362315,
0.0012416936,
0.0033616591,
-0.0029955679,
-0.047117874,
0.0805696845,
-0.0857439861,
-0.0228878409,
-0.0253093559,
-0.0112472568,
0.0150334146,
-0.0248072129,
0.0203220937,
0.022598993,
-0.0140494555,
-0.0142328851,
0.0500981733,
-0.0282490682,
-0.0182810165,
0.0364764854,
-0.0142284781,
-0.0151334191,
-0.097485967,
0.0195290539,
-0.026038602,
-0.0537859127,
-0.015910197,
0.0733120739,
-0.02060901,
-0.0354026556,
-0.0520410985,
-0.1089182347,
0.0073567443,
-0.0115349805,
0.0184141863,
-0.0172030348,
0.0074006245,
0.0071308441,
-0.0008681359,
-0.0110225109,
0.024824379,
0.005335486,
0.0057689529,
0.008452056,
0.0174935907,
0.0110933539,
0.0509531535,
0.0101821357,
0.0573792346,
-0.0489875264,
-0.0292309485,
-0.0013514052,
-0.0038704858,
0.0527361818,
0.0842079967,
0.0053422959,
-0.0131909102,
-0.0267583951,
0.0234710649,
-0.0051397937,
-0.0268900245,
0.0432910658,
-0.0174256209,
-0.0282079577,
-0.0738619193,
-0.0097124306,
-0.0229223948,
0.0129121402,
-0.0396683253,
0.0017591988,
-0.0351430811,
-0.0063378969,
0.0053567956,
-0.0239152927,
-0.0290514752,
0.016591534,
0.034292981,
-0.0217132457,
0.0710980669,
-0.0187932383,
-0.0134607162,
-0.0597349815,
-0.0095481062,
-0.0027069517,
0.0622401647,
0.0431198515,
0.023940349,
0.0466690846,
0.0246335063,
0.0121893883,
-0.024208257,
-0.0338491723,
0.0468610041,
0.0563929118,
-0.0322047174,
0.0047250548,
0.031264931,
0.0070674345,
-0.0049223439,
0.0420936011,
0.020312475,
-0.0033294649,
-0.0012262687,
0.0008838736,
0.0062586637,
-0.0284624472,
0.0116837248,
-0.0202746131,
0.0313301422,
0.0224013571,
-0.054164242,
-0.0201360974,
-0.0356469303,
2.762e-7,
0.0547526032,
0.040261738,
0.0001484459,
-0.0015272018,
0.0067100865,
0.0021910463,
-0.0053504365,
0.01745045,
-0.0040158844,
0.0358185172,
0.0504312031,
0.0344808921,
0.0099186134,
0.0155664114,
-0.0920095891,
-0.0198014062,
-0.0636604428,
-0.0161948632,
-0.0680913702,
0.0137108872,
0.046193324,
-0.0598189868,
0.0203516129,
-0.0230752323,
-0.0260389168,
-0.040785782,
0.0393964387,
-0.0077956254,
0.034887962,
0.0282335188,
0.0008570495,
0.0145472288,
0.0075183338,
0.0148601932,
-0.0184884388,
-0.0299553443,
0.007652428,
0.0720619038,
-0.0123510836,
0.029303167,
0.0654113889,
0.0249472652,
0.0063395831,
-0.0333540142,
0.0322162919,
-0.0248076562,
-0.0338908173,
-0.055811394,
-0.0117808925,
-0.0142871048,
0.0067219171,
-0.0267782379,
0.0199326742,
0.0185187776,
-0.0125657758,
0.000999518,
0.0167894326,
-0.0001615813,
-0.0087970393,
-0.0122368364,
-0.0308265742,
-0.0268942043,
-0.0281757154,
-0.0276024118,
0.0226083994,
-0.0706488639,
0.019487381,
2.438413569e-34,
0.0464507602,
-0.0207698941,
0.0095331054,
0.0645285472,
0.0300078671,
0.033719141,
-0.0087343743,
0.010542905,
0.031003911,
-0.0311058946,
-0.0355654284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17140v1 | Symbolic Planning and Code Generation for Grounded Dialogue | 2023-10-26T04:22:23 | 2023-10-26T04:22:23 | Justin T. Chiu, Wenting Zhao, Derek Chen, Saujas Vaduguru, Alexander M. Rush, Daniel Fried | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) excel at processing and generating both text and
code. However, LLMs have had limited applicability in grounded task-oriented
dialogue as they are difficult to steer toward task objectives and fail to
handle novel grounding. We present a modular and interpretable grounded
dialogue system that addresses these shortcomings by composing LLMs with a
symbolic planner and grounded code execution. Our system consists of a reader
and planner: the reader leverages an LLM to convert partner utterances into
executable code, calling functions that perform grounding. The translated
code's output is stored to track dialogue state, while a symbolic planner
determines the next appropriate response. We evaluate our system's performance
on the demanding OneCommon dialogue task, involving collaborative reference
resolution on abstract images of scattered dots. Our system substantially
outperforms the previous state-of-the-art, including improving task success in
human evaluations from 56% to 69% in the most challenging setting. | [
0.042653773,
0.0321016721,
-0.0249642972,
0.0313350335,
-0.0225595031,
-0.008963692,
0.0108867502,
-0.0059840614,
-0.012182205,
-0.0252629034,
-0.0163631886,
0.0148495808,
-0.00130756,
0.0597888641,
0.0016862722,
-0.0342141092,
0.0246215574,
-0.0429842956,
-0.0042490461,
-0.0228450559,
0.0050668027,
0.0160876643,
-0.0142436558,
0.0513116084,
-0.0240649339,
-0.006842732,
-0.0513098985,
0.0131476456,
-0.0010153807,
-0.0291412286,
-0.0508785956,
0.0445347615,
0.0295584649,
0.0185372699,
0.0000022159,
-0.0330128185,
0.0090121441,
-0.0376873165,
-0.0070773172,
-0.0087867333,
-0.0267567579,
-0.015992336,
-0.0114375725,
-0.0027648821,
-0.0564508326,
0.0200524274,
0.0573831461,
0.0812485889,
0.106553629,
0.0297857989,
0.0062839095,
-0.014247844,
0.0214283336,
0.0265260264,
-0.0127544645,
-0.0174725391,
-0.0171497148,
0.0876570866,
0.0302141551,
0.0192192215,
0.0001631499,
0.0359066539,
0.0380615406,
-0.0349474363,
0.006652731,
0.0478449464,
-0.0175675116,
-0.0248406436,
-0.0475340448,
0.0882453173,
0.0162346251,
0.0028046027,
0.0323138162,
-0.0022005001,
-0.0302825645,
-0.0315672457,
-0.0371299163,
0.0210058596,
-0.0238424912,
0.0263140239,
-0.0237506684,
-0.003292365,
-0.0181908235,
0.0148930624,
-0.0168824792,
0.0778305456,
-0.0160138104,
-0.0046519111,
0.01246568,
0.0046082265,
-0.0023220265,
-0.0822906718,
0.0570714176,
0.0409119166,
-0.0336121768,
0.0240136366,
-0.0381163508,
0.0024739958,
-0.0072184647,
-0.0183590539,
0.0758221,
0.0535925068,
-0.0115566058,
0.0494862236,
-0.000133266,
0.0726094693,
-0.0049097189,
0.0132911634,
-0.0069688889,
0.0440449864,
-0.0222184286,
0.0126683377,
-0.0761743486,
0.0407537408,
-0.100344032,
-0.0430717655,
0.0115956478,
0.0546324141,
0.0080226073,
0.021475669,
-0.0000290523,
0.0103587518,
-0.0307315458,
-0.0130582331,
-0.0123964073,
0.0171129461,
-0.0573941022,
-0.0180315841,
0.0088127134,
-0.0525013655,
0.0005093649,
0.0258811358,
0.0236940291,
0.0124053834,
-0.0175052173,
0.0549916551,
-0.0285809413,
-0.0035756093,
0.0097340886,
-0.0518750139,
-0.0430931002,
-0.0806647018,
0.0070767659,
-0.0626082644,
0.0085175512,
0.0120553663,
-0.0160485972,
-0.045868922,
0.0595588125,
0.0068623759,
0.0094352243,
0.071046643,
-0.0080721322,
0.0108474949,
0.0344143584,
0.0256160386,
-0.0200338289,
0.0668673813,
0.071176976,
0.0201687217,
-0.0034629591,
-0.0054549044,
0.0009329289,
0.0283036903,
0.0080871442,
0.0076582823,
-0.0113307377,
0.0122120297,
-0.0209263116,
0.020345781,
0.0110794092,
0.0621891357,
-0.0296297707,
0.0024189632,
0.0399378762,
0.0703010336,
-0.0773382485,
0.0016507166,
0.0437800586,
0.0246248264,
-0.029301824,
0.0194749795,
-0.0408721976,
0.0466825329,
-0.0116397534,
-0.003805079,
0.0040569743,
-0.0079021519,
-0.0227339342,
-0.0444216318,
0.0065541258,
0.0171892177,
0.0598734953,
-0.0370916575,
0.0190299749,
0.0130739575,
-0.0698283017,
0.0639587194,
-0.0220687669,
-0.0573824272,
-0.0293707754,
-0.0093976036,
0.0398665182,
0.0683739781,
0.0430109166,
0.0102314167,
-0.0260665789,
-0.0211546924,
0.0439153463,
0.0565303862,
-0.0217792653,
-0.0093299672,
-0.0012324199,
-0.0452240631,
-0.0174668562,
-0.0138495378,
-0.0120779769,
0.0559623502,
0.0245258193,
-0.0108080972,
0.0165342353,
-0.0037371647,
0.0093759429,
0.0256841481,
-0.006634953,
0.0031076972,
-0.0191680547,
0.0046720323,
0.0376934148,
0.0307865962,
-0.0274058599,
-0.0060629081,
0.0449057184,
-0.014044838,
-0.0020504517,
0.0359028317,
-0.0520811528,
-0.004804411,
0.0281660575,
-0.0468693413,
-0.0127462801,
0.017551126,
0.000152646,
-0.0458570905,
0.0566960424,
-0.0437778533,
-0.0019796612,
-0.0341838002,
0.01450333,
0.0394607969,
-0.0104515105,
-0.0103134606,
0.0247700568,
-0.0090036746,
-0.0079999007,
0.0515973121,
0.0494095944,
0.0107978489,
-0.0798207894,
0.0298411604,
0.0240456946,
0.0057184855,
-0.0085183568,
-0.0124956463,
0.0512319431,
-0.0393146574,
-0.0390236638,
-0.1118787676,
-0.0291566886,
-0.0251255222,
-0.0414436087,
-0.0047370605,
-0.0146904727,
0.0073171896,
-0.0317059159,
-0.0112159047,
0.0467039458,
0.0593210086,
-0.0105606485,
0.0123855174,
0.0274419338,
-0.043706689,
-0.0322019458,
0.0164661482,
0.0011758412,
-0.0021632793,
0.0316413082,
-0.0262521449,
-0.0799190402,
0.0543027185,
-0.0363183767,
0.0496484339,
-0.0033031395,
-0.0036791144,
0.0428783521,
-0.0250686742,
0.0495160148,
0.0415468067,
-0.0503401533,
0.0568498485,
0.0206040647,
-0.0711064935,
-0.1026128531,
0.0354890302,
0.0248602517,
0.0184425302,
-0.0137901874,
-0.0074502286,
0.0013762139,
0.0749887973,
0.0307404064,
0.0575186945,
-0.0675181895,
0.0365661979,
0.0163290873,
-0.0387495421,
-0.030554099,
-0.0359309018,
-0.0287237223,
0.0603891984,
-0.0345203206,
-0.0630253106,
0.0745428354,
-0.0533861481,
-0.0307873469,
0.0037054284,
-0.0058574998,
-0.015296964,
0.0855585635,
-0.0303731598,
-0.0055386024,
0.0122966198,
-0.0366050191,
-0.0174797531,
0.0058608144,
-0.0442931205,
-0.0193508137,
0.0718734637,
-0.1078924835,
0.0092669977,
-0.0126513904,
-0.0272871833,
-0.0482524298,
0.026119411,
-0.0703205764,
0.0010964253,
-0.028138103,
-6.838e-7,
0.0072258627,
0.0288544372,
-0.0022756895,
0.0287041329,
0.0068147532,
-0.0022735915,
-0.0543601625,
-0.017618604,
0.011465108,
0.0260296836,
-0.0398469716,
-0.0000296932,
0.0357335843,
0.0289263949,
0.0451858006,
-0.000233204,
-0.0345589705,
-0.0100782281,
0.0259065274,
0.0250068698,
-0.0056921039,
0.0334892757,
0.087189354,
-0.030645309,
-0.0404011719,
0.0914618149,
0.0162489973,
0.0045013735,
0.0058952942,
-0.0516013913,
0.0215408877,
0.0217887294,
0.0129174031,
-0.0672695562,
-0.026460154,
0.0055098855,
-0.0149407219,
0.0385912769,
-0.0506835617,
-0.0138021763,
-0.0960389078,
0.0410481654,
0.0268826708,
-0.0521058328,
-0.0587607659,
0.0090478174,
-0.0045543085,
0.0544726923,
-0.0084360698,
0.0313513279,
0.0350549258,
0.0116286213,
-0.012018064,
0.0335222222,
0.0412674434,
0.0154874781,
-0.0058470652,
0.0459249876,
0.0880859569,
0.0344256088,
0.0398824215,
-0.0274981763,
-0.0094984854,
0.0126759047,
0.0272401422,
-0.0418380015,
-0.0349700302,
0.0229830034,
-0.0229760539,
0.0117733562,
0.0374800563,
-0.0666101873,
-0.0272198003,
0.045091521,
0.0602182187,
-0.0645256415,
0.018683739,
-0.016880624,
0.0701296702,
0.0274492707,
0.0481804125,
0.0451873466,
-0.0215889979,
-0.0593947433,
-0.0444855876,
0.0094790934,
-0.0656049773,
-0.0331199355,
-0.0343554392,
0.0136716757,
0.0394494422,
-0.0975590572,
-0.0408193953,
0.06559214,
0.0468945578,
-0.0005912936,
-0.0550147258,
-0.010942664,
0.0160709172,
-0.0284644123,
0.0206187032,
-0.0320272483,
0.0268924478,
-0.0564173274,
-0.0132014584,
0.0015412662,
-0.0230625961,
0.0055786842,
0.03644979,
-0.0568555966,
-0.0516034514,
-0.0335352719,
0.0593538806,
0.0255171508,
0.0048372927,
-0.0128124543,
-0.0141919935,
-0.0378536545,
-0.0045610745,
-0.0316699222,
0.0309528057,
0.0214370918,
0.0495015085,
0.0094247973,
0.0303323418,
-0.0363953598,
0.0269807205,
-0.0062921192,
0.0413196795,
-0.0679867938,
-0.0805306062,
0.0074914768,
0.0236844607,
0.0573483892,
0.0004380127,
-0.0212966558,
0.0030009665,
0.0304855164,
-0.0356190093,
-0.0162984859,
-0.0874469206,
0.0224502031,
-0.0434850827,
-0.0169227943,
0.034804862,
-0.0367383845,
-0.0448320732,
0.0666313171,
0.0139166927,
0.0122864516,
-0.0086265663,
-0.0266024694,
0.0283742603,
-0.00012426,
-0.0326885246,
0.01918667,
0.0060773906,
0.0521249212,
0.0109018758,
0.0919518173,
0.0065255822,
-0.0340028629,
0.0140223643,
0.0121250423,
-0.031202225,
-0.0708262622,
0.0075598164,
0.0262350217,
0.0377666466,
0.0605289564,
0.0415269285,
-0.0628351048,
0.0120456284,
-0.001608782,
0.0355185606,
0.0223665312,
-0.0561286286,
0.0339788944,
0.038532991,
0.0102020837,
-0.0370568819,
0.0440032408,
-0.0410465598,
0.0103257177,
-0.0037787515,
0.0138193863,
-0.0769463703,
-0.0237465501,
-0.0213688593,
0.0124462955,
0.0092126019,
0.022149574,
-0.0416615903,
-0.0351569876,
0.0199319087,
0.0634798333,
-0.0077182157,
-0.0530888774,
0.0617280826,
0.0235271193,
0.0059900773,
-0.0007854466,
-0.0202336404,
0.0291551109,
0.0085927183,
-0.0350477695,
-0.082842648,
-6.15466875e-33,
-0.0800672621,
-0.0649006963,
0.0449404791,
0.0037448155,
-0.0156497918,
-0.0013621453,
-0.0575737655,
0.0334464237,
0.0306881517,
-0.0171045624,
0.0017599298,
0.0033135277,
0.0053488892,
0.0010573616,
-0.0091719246,
-0.0062578698,
0.0426836498,
0.0065406375,
-0.0262495764,
0.009902196,
0.0144866649,
-0.0004716782,
-0.0129085854,
-0.0998370871,
-0.0190227944,
0.0336007327,
-0.0096364124,
0.0138019454,
0.0133016082,
0.0262350477,
0.0002532393,
0.0234337114,
-0.0102400407,
-0.0207513217,
-0.0249688681,
0.0446531773,
-0.0608997047,
-0.0225933529,
0.0402768403,
0.0190384854,
-0.0235170126,
-0.032238543,
0.0149721308,
-0.0277100559,
-0.0244171657,
0.0105378274,
-0.0023615963,
-0.0199867543,
-0.0113743488,
0.0113671981,
-0.0675322488,
0.0110224094,
-0.0241659917,
-0.0346416719,
-0.0048133321,
0.0576500371,
-0.0051904148,
-0.0266910996,
-0.027506547,
0.0502189994,
0.0075083086,
-0.0135822147,
0.0456255488,
0.0084787598,
0.0178220421,
0.0646749213,
0.0477630086,
-0.0054144887,
-0.0428478941,
-0.028530268,
0.0046856427,
0.0463352576,
0.0388929397,
0.0209703147,
-0.0277240761,
0.0441803299,
-0.0064115771,
0.0045812097,
0.0188157484,
0.0460123755,
0.0199310686,
0.0477992035,
-0.0425479151,
0.0012787641,
-0.0052207438,
0.007754799,
-0.0159346741,
-0.0704553574,
0.0344808027,
0.0102986889,
-0.054682076,
0.0023495837,
0.0574869886,
-0.0156691764,
0.0033796197,
-0.0040090466,
0.0033797571,
0.0219468195,
-0.0200828705,
-0.0012570008,
-0.0447083935,
-0.0217486806,
0.0462887324,
-0.0030013092,
0.053162653,
0.036497131,
-0.0325381197,
-0.0020991515,
-0.051597815,
-0.0012204318,
-0.0424913913,
0.0195899978,
-0.005079824,
-0.0001624634,
0.0186436623,
-0.0242654588,
-0.0381015465,
0.0275331922,
-0.0131131439,
-0.0791477412,
-0.040156927,
-0.0241927952,
0.009585184,
0.0074467426,
-0.0615964904,
0.004599934,
-0.0181674846,
-0.0007606376,
0.0271855723,
-0.0240900069,
-0.0351348035,
0.0243146308,
2.992e-7,
-0.0170853753,
0.0313961282,
0.0402699336,
0.0266841874,
0.0045158551,
0.0172268897,
-0.0004972991,
0.0197133869,
0.0185326729,
-0.0721931607,
-0.0079469839,
0.0252583213,
0.0291976817,
0.0194866862,
-0.0909107253,
0.0064702332,
-0.0120819109,
-0.0365213305,
-0.0541683473,
0.0190149397,
0.0394004174,
0.0359662548,
-0.0011010719,
0.0316821225,
0.0048383172,
-0.0144624645,
0.0136253806,
-0.0404860005,
0.0299188774,
-0.0474656597,
-0.0346291028,
-0.049764324,
-0.0223178845,
0.0242132489,
0.0212390218,
0.0000949865,
0.0292926636,
0.0827985108,
-0.0304035991,
-0.0103170713,
-0.0135159642,
-0.0343486704,
-0.0074394387,
-0.0205628611,
0.0303565729,
-0.0385824777,
-0.0010906872,
0.0252978522,
0.0216530208,
-0.0347261429,
-0.0333556198,
0.0055494653,
-0.0156866331,
0.0108717922,
0.0049504726,
-0.0181628074,
0.0350885652,
-0.0274927281,
-0.0037000908,
-0.0256608892,
-0.0459161997,
-0.0314950496,
-0.0389550589,
-0.055162251,
-0.017614061,
-0.0289313588,
-0.0394360311,
2.785382078e-34,
0.0263300836,
0.0089421757,
0.0301304962,
0.0553525202,
0.0477500148,
0.0107932081,
-0.0346435308,
0.0303639695,
0.0643344447,
-0.037800733,
-0.0436495282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17133v1 | Incorporating Probing Signals into Multimodal Machine Translation via Visual Question-Answering Pairs | 2023-10-26T04:13:49 | 2023-10-26T04:13:49 | Yuxin Zuo, Bei Li, Chuanhao Lv, Tong Zheng, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents an in-depth study of multimodal machine translation
(MMT), examining the prevailing understanding that MMT systems exhibit
decreased sensitivity to visual information when text inputs are complete.
Instead, we attribute this phenomenon to insufficient cross-modal interaction,
rather than image information redundancy. A novel approach is proposed to
generate parallel Visual Question-Answering (VQA) style pairs from the source
text, fostering more robust cross-modal interaction. Using Large Language
Models (LLMs), we explicitly model the probing signal in MMT to convert it into
VQA-style data to create the Multi30K-VQA dataset. An MMT-VQA multitask
learning framework is introduced to incorporate explicit probing signals from
the dataset into the MMT training process. Experimental results on two
widely-used benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of this novel approach.
Our code and data would be available at:
\url{https://github.com/libeineu/MMT-VQA}. | [
0.0345219448,
0.0207026843,
-0.0335737057,
0.0497873724,
-0.0106338263,
0.0105377352,
0.0255382378,
0.0135720968,
-0.0140224854,
-0.039771691,
-0.0598907359,
-0.0493809246,
0.0037965886,
0.0296206232,
0.0581144318,
-0.0478353426,
0.0321241654,
-0.0398732945,
-0.0527409092,
-0.0031660525,
0.0276763346,
0.0241813995,
-0.0199319124,
0.035729304,
-0.044354558,
-0.01680189,
-0.0511142202,
0.0458184481,
0.0062611061,
-0.01218013,
-0.0423856303,
0.0268863626,
0.0589507893,
0.0393127725,
0.0000019044,
-0.0070969495,
0.0036572127,
-0.0046719192,
0.0503405221,
-0.0377887003,
0.0440706573,
-0.055940114,
0.0451595224,
0.0133635905,
-0.042041298,
-0.0274503678,
0.0707061514,
0.00661253,
0.1114385948,
0.0310299788,
-0.0173960477,
0.019816909,
0.0081654591,
-0.0132636493,
0.0335059874,
-0.0394929722,
-0.016586246,
0.042753309,
0.0063312664,
0.0297276843,
-0.0417007394,
0.0743860602,
0.0283967759,
-0.0206931792,
-0.0329268575,
0.0461625755,
0.0307385102,
-0.0518906526,
-0.0559264161,
0.1002754569,
-0.0073115514,
0.0156213213,
-0.0261729769,
-0.0026010375,
0.0027794577,
0.0426020809,
-0.0686548054,
0.0107759871,
-0.0180592071,
-0.0148361512,
-0.0497620218,
-0.0221412387,
-0.0151371425,
-0.0185060911,
-0.0121023646,
-0.0404251516,
0.0260899924,
-0.0096228318,
-0.0306472592,
0.0183134452,
-0.0378627218,
-0.0416929051,
-0.0055208053,
0.0500103757,
-0.0111813834,
0.0109502412,
-0.0364305563,
-0.068703033,
-0.0099430364,
-0.0123675251,
0.0489759669,
0.049604442,
-0.0602251105,
0.0474160016,
0.0019374539,
0.0378252752,
-0.0603982285,
0.0141492551,
-0.0619800687,
-0.0287416894,
-0.0498470999,
-0.0220371969,
-0.0407282822,
-0.0252891425,
-0.0647628382,
-0.036849767,
0.0092842123,
0.0631848276,
0.028940212,
-0.0048265555,
0.0069799307,
-0.0048810169,
-0.0598646104,
0.014053056,
-0.0243393518,
0.0800579861,
-0.0280768741,
0.0229566414,
-0.0017163431,
-0.0313735008,
-0.0375404172,
0.0415713005,
0.0160926469,
-0.0559291206,
-0.0003943058,
0.0929757431,
-0.0516010337,
-0.0093121743,
0.009334662,
-0.0343424082,
-0.0318771042,
-0.0419191159,
0.0483164117,
-0.019147424,
0.0678496286,
0.0143179595,
0.0034183711,
0.026594298,
-0.0032198422,
0.0360029787,
-0.0148958731,
0.1036464497,
0.0095287561,
0.0127895633,
0.0576162301,
0.0021663907,
-0.0114120087,
0.0770518705,
0.049656257,
0.0338736288,
0.0283198748,
-0.0249252245,
0.0134996595,
0.0469908789,
0.0177806001,
0.0274310838,
-0.0271796864,
0.0259879287,
0.0247115847,
0.0477131307,
0.0231399722,
0.0612587407,
-0.0394102819,
-0.0120619182,
0.0832597166,
0.0277517475,
0.0068764603,
0.0003716612,
0.0519015044,
0.0071416423,
-0.0002598181,
0.0186882522,
-0.0267526079,
0.0782361403,
0.0061756773,
0.0012129797,
0.0473801456,
0.0152096506,
-0.0392183065,
-0.0162517503,
-0.0019016752,
0.0173931308,
0.0053584441,
0.0257293079,
0.0303503796,
0.0321649015,
-0.0666988418,
-0.0103498474,
-0.0358460657,
-0.0335921198,
0.0051516928,
-0.0302843861,
0.0248947274,
0.0284176208,
0.034489844,
0.0076090842,
-0.0105534066,
-0.0335922241,
0.0167445615,
0.0403768569,
0.0163118243,
-0.0049773068,
0.0464391708,
-0.0519792773,
-0.0275893863,
-0.0190585684,
-0.0189494099,
0.0123906843,
-0.0244187228,
0.000294708,
-0.0053912592,
-0.0371735878,
0.0418386795,
0.0374132916,
0.038769193,
0.0137372883,
-0.0052929139,
0.0195378456,
-0.0019971821,
-0.0102804694,
-0.0274540074,
0.0074258279,
0.032548584,
-0.054134056,
0.0227578208,
0.0286299642,
-0.023319561,
-0.0619456023,
0.0077894586,
-0.0406072102,
-0.0149471788,
0.0248549506,
-0.0185914561,
-0.0410137512,
-0.0227181688,
-0.0435775444,
-0.0398265421,
-0.0644470751,
-0.0314640775,
0.0340638757,
0.0177355502,
-0.039301604,
0.0131103173,
-0.0209536795,
0.001740853,
0.0046410263,
0.0054102652,
0.0255976226,
-0.0234706756,
-0.0116737392,
0.0321694352,
0.0174154863,
0.0303536281,
-0.0187394507,
0.0215094797,
-0.0386054292,
-0.0364965089,
-0.0897492543,
0.0072654681,
-0.018234659,
0.0107295066,
0.0470881201,
0.0288705025,
-0.0007789008,
-0.043711938,
-0.0391850211,
0.0445312336,
0.0395693704,
0.0250025894,
0.0528451875,
0.0149346096,
0.0513441265,
-0.013188052,
-0.0097075384,
-0.0033116939,
0.0554425456,
0.0078269374,
0.0152071342,
-0.0408704542,
-0.0352990329,
-0.0257724579,
0.0075122747,
-0.00424603,
-0.0309592541,
0.0251000375,
-0.0417789891,
0.0374399424,
0.0544989817,
-0.0088698193,
0.0179907419,
0.0204657298,
-0.031526655,
-0.0297437869,
0.0426288396,
0.0168094467,
-0.0194690414,
-0.0011733084,
-0.025309056,
-0.0206710715,
0.0396313146,
0.0102937836,
0.0034725626,
-0.0521181338,
0.0391878784,
0.0352133997,
-0.0454030298,
-0.0621719137,
0.038556587,
0.0040591424,
0.0362070091,
-0.0246295705,
-0.0617000982,
0.0582802892,
-0.0456497893,
-0.0573423095,
-0.0084357783,
0.0258308388,
-0.0209468212,
0.1036222726,
-0.0073207514,
0.0163419191,
-0.0207860321,
-0.0160060916,
-0.0946273878,
-0.0153253125,
-0.007014785,
-0.016509179,
0.0337122679,
-0.0556315742,
-0.0057584527,
-0.0552244708,
-0.0047919969,
-0.0166598056,
-0.0116528235,
-0.0097427946,
-0.0244509596,
-0.0283052381,
-0.0033497359,
0.0112161878,
0.0407321341,
0.0274216421,
0.0158460978,
-0.0148885706,
-0.0195787996,
-0.0408021733,
0.0924519002,
0.0532023273,
0.0407977551,
-0.0518032946,
-0.0884953588,
0.0193933826,
0.0479402542,
0.0169923138,
-0.001392269,
-0.0111568049,
0.0192349236,
0.020964887,
0.0329913497,
-0.0119420644,
-0.0022537007,
0.0541157015,
-0.0484031476,
-0.0105082691,
0.0492725372,
0.0127993422,
-0.0540978797,
-0.0290944725,
0.0086424034,
0.04585151,
0.0425878838,
0.0533285886,
-0.1060988978,
-0.0504852682,
-0.0175720192,
0.0090735182,
0.0411501415,
0.0241547842,
-0.0358166993,
-0.0689655021,
0.0356097072,
-0.0180106256,
-0.0551194698,
-0.0115289157,
0.0209120791,
-0.0111891162,
0.0025764049,
0.0263556335,
-0.0075127543,
-0.000226457,
0.0042604795,
0.00632222,
0.0802027136,
-0.0232521333,
-0.0072970754,
-0.0330804698,
-0.0131325005,
0.0350836888,
0.0242959373,
-0.0186592229,
-0.048916962,
0.0069370721,
-0.0309076644,
0.0093164667,
-0.0090426188,
0.0457054488,
-0.0341425464,
-0.0295631085,
0.0078972252,
0.0171845723,
0.0267991964,
0.0223123487,
0.0231856927,
0.0348604843,
-0.0366745777,
0.0093007265,
-0.0123457117,
0.0036075353,
0.013323565,
0.047468774,
0.0230566487,
-0.0822024196,
-0.0159895532,
-0.0141735058,
-0.0147293797,
-0.0661720037,
-0.0311957225,
-0.0086063258,
0.0109138852,
0.0209367052,
-0.068484731,
-0.0267427005,
0.0669394433,
0.0651207566,
-0.0079727648,
0.0161807779,
-0.0216733813,
0.0343536437,
-0.0505798608,
0.0641330481,
-0.0024706728,
0.0400040001,
-0.0216815472,
0.0215732995,
0.0105541917,
-0.0768879056,
-0.0038725298,
0.0097078914,
-0.1232767031,
-0.0509633794,
-0.0810153037,
0.0642563477,
0.0131943794,
0.029824147,
0.0133870924,
-0.0380136929,
-0.0091982186,
0.0026582088,
-0.0218137763,
-0.012844326,
-0.0025623511,
-0.0137229562,
-0.0103732338,
0.0053413762,
-0.0184136685,
-0.0140458429,
-0.0089164423,
0.0639020503,
-0.027451992,
-0.0285819266,
0.02976848,
0.0061410139,
0.0177949183,
-0.0046244739,
0.0072963834,
-0.022381125,
0.0152853159,
0.0172121897,
-0.0154643552,
-0.0957307518,
0.0012274,
0.0131719075,
-0.0267246049,
0.0106640719,
-0.01229975,
0.000877503,
0.0236983225,
-0.0257750042,
0.016642319,
-0.0092225317,
0.0115831671,
-0.0061451523,
0.0129555613,
0.0017377033,
0.0051531158,
-0.0048876945,
0.0269503463,
0.0020564243,
0.114380084,
0.0148655176,
-0.0406645685,
-0.0074741552,
0.0618753619,
-0.0464050993,
-0.0273409914,
0.0067523364,
0.0429645777,
0.0518766753,
0.0398684889,
0.036536403,
0.0065821521,
-0.0203306414,
-0.0058769067,
0.0695353821,
0.016475983,
-0.0115794986,
0.0836160779,
0.0067065796,
0.0130923092,
0.004364708,
0.0588241741,
-0.0260634236,
0.0075477068,
0.0028254103,
-0.0047421381,
-0.0387317464,
-0.0034334869,
0.0608949699,
-0.0006735522,
-0.0069604521,
0.0156433154,
0.0097300978,
-0.0659689754,
-0.0090242783,
0.0470223762,
-0.0319492631,
-0.0156153273,
0.0261191297,
0.0556845404,
0.0229557455,
-0.017635284,
-0.0360393636,
0.0091641983,
0.0054250038,
-0.0166953672,
-0.0088722296,
-5.840921961e-33,
-0.037610881,
-0.0304149259,
0.0504951514,
-0.042990502,
-0.0450264104,
-0.0046333722,
-0.0188360885,
0.0020437264,
-0.0223202426,
-0.0120370546,
0.0159047693,
-0.0066928971,
-0.0008016725,
0.0295674466,
-0.0028795877,
-0.002040769,
0.0260953009,
-0.0115432059,
-0.0113763688,
0.0225644708,
0.0114813093,
0.0126119498,
0.0484815612,
-0.0321347862,
-0.0031507111,
-0.0001546456,
-0.0233476013,
0.0394103937,
-0.0305477697,
0.06704209,
-0.0427418761,
0.0106698452,
0.0158017073,
-0.0026171219,
-0.0172751658,
0.039358411,
-0.0620711632,
0.0164626874,
0.0156900492,
0.0388496555,
-0.0972213373,
0.0117906928,
0.0271310713,
-0.049467016,
0.0272459015,
-0.0139341224,
0.0306236614,
-0.0071887951,
-0.0097173024,
0.0210787617,
-0.016822366,
-0.015123589,
-0.0223973673,
-0.0574862026,
0.0246599372,
0.0973069966,
0.0288409628,
0.0061268448,
-0.039449621,
0.008438075,
-0.0357582793,
-0.0013660727,
0.0756270364,
0.0596685819,
0.0052655316,
0.0016168536,
0.0197694972,
-0.0223471783,
-0.0012476784,
0.0001800196,
0.0188893825,
0.0353078879,
0.0512894504,
0.0748330429,
0.0041253655,
0.0258612651,
-0.0240698382,
0.0373786874,
-0.0090708854,
0.0376265012,
-0.0056272727,
-0.0103361318,
0.0211374518,
0.0098852655,
-0.0545710325,
0.0072014653,
-0.0503975712,
-0.0078249816,
0.0464782938,
0.0179335568,
-0.0128108254,
0.0026632294,
0.0973825529,
-0.0354986005,
0.024186777,
-0.0093425168,
-0.0462608561,
0.0534316376,
-0.001515428,
0.0320163742,
0.0117743574,
-0.0077954778,
0.0534976162,
-0.0089690471,
0.0061419979,
0.0101699652,
0.0268277507,
0.0116720311,
-0.0468813069,
-0.0103295855,
-0.039747145,
0.0086168125,
-0.0367624797,
0.0206071604,
0.0325086676,
-0.0191441886,
-0.0502777956,
-0.006281083,
-0.0013065728,
-0.0115861148,
-0.0497661047,
-0.0728276968,
-0.0059534297,
0.037773218,
-0.0325414613,
0.0230728723,
-0.0264369026,
-0.0614067093,
0.0034140141,
-0.082439132,
-0.0258974843,
0.0687869042,
2.588e-7,
0.0469718166,
0.026802795,
-0.0074284053,
0.036378663,
0.0214410815,
0.04148205,
-0.0478233099,
0.0375100784,
0.0298051313,
-0.016855916,
0.0051241922,
0.0258056223,
0.0593280122,
0.0138109624,
-0.0403438509,
-0.0277987532,
-0.0185884405,
0.0449430682,
-0.0546020456,
0.0212693736,
0.0856510773,
0.0396996625,
-0.0534666665,
-0.0136747891,
0.0221725795,
-0.0522237681,
0.0967594087,
-0.0022006929,
-0.0136834336,
-0.0333239287,
0.0017910495,
-0.0147068445,
-0.004424639,
0.0209124424,
0.0116630113,
-0.020310089,
0.0400513709,
0.0260369945,
-0.0008457345,
-0.0483892262,
-0.0164026823,
0.0174223203,
-0.0276286621,
-0.0530544706,
0.0823677629,
-0.0424962118,
-0.0219913274,
-0.0185751393,
-0.0013418189,
-0.0160491113,
0.0301449094,
-0.0347952321,
-0.0397081822,
0.0172614511,
0.0666290447,
-0.0127153406,
-0.02185403,
-0.0294715054,
-0.0235677082,
-0.0121699218,
-0.0466595516,
-0.0261252802,
-0.0625017211,
-0.02460788,
0.004349866,
-0.036291685,
-0.0827772394,
2.023032436e-34,
0.0294011757,
-0.0369512849,
0.0364683494,
0.0207669158,
0.012514255,
-0.0174472891,
-0.0261963699,
-0.022462856,
0.0194122382,
-0.1038098484,
-0.040080376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17130v1 | M2C: Towards Automatic Multimodal Manga Complement | 2023-10-26T04:10:16 | 2023-10-26T04:10:16 | Hongcheng Guo, Boyang Wang, Jiaqi Bai, Jiaheng Liu, Jian Yang, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal manga analysis focuses on enhancing manga understanding with
visual and textual features, which has attracted considerable attention from
both natural language processing and computer vision communities. Currently,
most comics are hand-drawn and prone to problems such as missing pages, text
contamination, and aging, resulting in missing comic text content and seriously
hindering human comprehension. In other words, the Multimodal Manga Complement
(M2C) task has not been investigated, which aims to handle the aforementioned
issues by providing a shared semantic space for vision and language
understanding. To this end, we first propose the Multimodal Manga Complement
task by establishing a new M2C benchmark dataset covering two languages. First,
we design a manga argumentation method called MCoT to mine event knowledge in
comics with large language models. Then, an effective baseline FVP-M$^{2}$
using fine-grained visual prompts is proposed to support manga complement.
Extensive experimental results show the effectiveness of FVP-M$^{2}$ method for
Multimodal Mange Complement. | [
0.0374532565,
0.0496522859,
0.0105428752,
0.0655126274,
-0.017631704,
0.0361258686,
0.0164124295,
-0.0089831846,
0.0075874827,
0.0078686494,
0.0015759091,
0.0103305355,
0.0012085445,
0.0138195455,
-0.0047172965,
-0.0641540363,
-0.0193842743,
-0.0074397861,
0.0199563783,
0.0171841886,
0.0543135256,
0.0073838206,
-0.0322689563,
0.0273272526,
-0.0088209389,
-0.0645304322,
-0.0150778005,
0.0016094918,
0.0355108418,
-0.036821641,
-0.0181271713,
-0.0100157848,
0.0478058532,
0.0085025104,
0.0000018131,
-0.0439903885,
-0.0100345016,
0.0019548263,
0.0591283105,
0.0217015818,
0.0065936269,
-0.0466885157,
-0.0103224488,
-0.0670751855,
0.0131383911,
0.0491399132,
0.069868885,
0.1149161458,
0.0882794708,
0.0396480039,
-0.0346682444,
-0.0150852213,
-0.0009045741,
-0.0038122039,
0.0137134539,
-0.0355403125,
-0.0183481611,
0.0396462418,
0.0225299615,
0.0075186263,
-0.0358567238,
0.0279620774,
-0.0022565932,
-0.0203903969,
-0.0439681783,
0.0325188898,
0.0295159966,
0.0054274579,
-0.0248455722,
0.0456834361,
-0.0421054065,
0.0032989858,
-0.0039550113,
-0.0220644884,
-0.0352262035,
0.0982389152,
-0.102865085,
0.0311959516,
-0.0550643802,
0.002580618,
-0.0313012674,
-0.0124025624,
-0.0059373658,
-0.0306071769,
0.0012061608,
0.0468253419,
0.0145458998,
0.019859774,
-0.0018177854,
0.0091221854,
-0.0572802983,
-0.0389125571,
0.0532736033,
0.034997493,
0.0571328029,
-0.0086259814,
-0.0084456578,
-0.0632232949,
0.0001241622,
-0.0466714464,
-0.0004159936,
0.0010578088,
-0.0659115091,
0.0826448426,
-0.0039402777,
-0.0150015447,
-0.0202641971,
0.0203918722,
-0.0074922061,
0.0269480422,
-0.0180822629,
-0.0112452796,
-0.0511887707,
-0.022872502,
-0.0565661415,
-0.0543083213,
-0.0066074245,
0.0134861916,
0.015485134,
-0.0141371517,
0.0110544935,
0.0005801785,
-0.0362472795,
-0.0087075792,
-0.0470504463,
0.0433293842,
-0.0835159943,
0.005858175,
-0.0242184643,
-0.0138282161,
-0.0186040644,
-0.0024092114,
0.0280144606,
-0.0297511853,
-0.0030300124,
0.0978377834,
-0.042899549,
-0.0082813399,
-0.0636098757,
-0.0253206324,
-0.0187108144,
-0.053023003,
0.0474497154,
-0.0316704474,
0.055891443,
-0.0291747637,
0.0569038838,
-0.0028531293,
0.0042433045,
-0.019435605,
-0.0002943293,
0.0642115176,
-0.0068397541,
-0.0089170765,
0.0447110571,
0.0234362055,
-0.0239727665,
0.0280201342,
0.0285449661,
0.0278123543,
0.045989085,
0.0144921141,
-0.0358875021,
0.022952266,
-0.0001623623,
0.017278282,
-0.0070952293,
-0.0169797465,
-0.0274809562,
0.0340566859,
0.0194903836,
0.0003332804,
-0.0556089282,
-0.0587214939,
0.045427721,
0.0170875471,
0.0091431038,
0.0135209877,
0.0233754292,
-0.002307818,
0.0225530192,
0.0543900691,
0.0060484041,
0.0228819717,
-0.0125750219,
-0.0169138554,
-0.0087560136,
-0.0002715637,
-0.0078208987,
-0.0133231524,
0.0197203308,
0.0021241612,
0.0366327912,
-0.0302420743,
0.0557066984,
0.0492966622,
-0.045322746,
-0.0177058131,
-0.0051021548,
-0.0326595046,
-0.0082061766,
0.0123357195,
0.0806173086,
0.025404593,
0.0478244759,
-0.0305874757,
-0.0055506523,
0.0032740475,
0.0659489259,
0.0343651474,
-0.0457825586,
-0.0159708019,
0.03604066,
-0.0435948186,
0.0052798847,
-0.0563067123,
-0.0077094296,
0.0576614588,
-0.01269993,
0.0041084099,
-0.0237551946,
-0.0460148938,
-0.0321829505,
0.0345242471,
0.0101568298,
0.0033986706,
-0.0660396144,
0.0534609146,
-0.0019441764,
0.0095126461,
-0.0388730541,
-0.0072460421,
0.023052359,
-0.0794836357,
-0.0224958248,
0.0549544618,
0.00175168,
-0.0694158226,
0.0627580136,
-0.0954098627,
-0.0198197439,
-0.014724588,
0.0152868591,
-0.0041344599,
-0.015284868,
-0.0188071374,
-0.0272164084,
-0.0481088385,
-0.0006431598,
0.0339094885,
0.0064688958,
-0.0392308421,
0.0617635138,
0.0076051103,
0.000548094,
0.0338776261,
0.0292016789,
0.0269210842,
-0.0209889505,
-0.0180301499,
0.046069026,
0.0347020589,
-0.0119429165,
0.0257836804,
-0.0152207706,
0.0009011534,
-0.000955612,
-0.069405362,
-0.0142583922,
0.0292691682,
-0.0080166906,
0.0011568642,
-0.0123523399,
-0.0126930848,
-0.0159416664,
-0.035798192,
0.006356529,
-0.0227089655,
0.0475358181,
0.0386548787,
0.0323178768,
0.0580592826,
0.0268667024,
-0.0093815858,
-0.0100824973,
0.0670114085,
0.0659355,
0.0088399034,
-0.0128072053,
0.0303170308,
-0.0267781317,
-0.0048488202,
-0.0436080433,
-0.0298371557,
0.0383399986,
-0.0707706511,
0.0202501584,
0.033490818,
0.021812072,
0.0269954316,
0.0320639089,
-0.0805412158,
-0.0068273419,
0.0210355055,
0.0199295525,
0.0137599045,
0.0366018116,
0.0071624313,
0.0179520864,
0.0651404709,
-0.0186643582,
0.0373748355,
-0.0532407947,
0.0126807103,
0.0417845324,
0.0051190872,
-0.0495687686,
-0.0134684844,
0.0091719143,
0.0620521791,
-0.0185321532,
-0.0116119971,
0.053660702,
-0.0572128855,
-0.0272298865,
-0.0077349567,
0.0348964259,
-0.0356096886,
0.0666169077,
-0.0226418991,
0.0598356016,
-0.0329292491,
-0.0264448356,
-0.0406853482,
0.0383193307,
0.0896558166,
0.0102365613,
0.0008747092,
0.0007947091,
0.0062450389,
-0.024197774,
-0.0011358977,
-0.0101962108,
-0.003370598,
-0.0316796675,
-0.0877273381,
-0.0668763444,
-0.0354522392,
-0.0114757707,
0.0504135713,
-0.0136008272,
0.007825369,
-0.0046276911,
-0.0251924172,
0.0301790759,
0.0515167452,
0.0564926751,
0.0277310051,
-0.0415183306,
-0.0669139251,
0.0017398462,
0.0560513698,
-0.0549227707,
-0.008280823,
-0.018107567,
0.035665106,
-0.0123211108,
0.0239837971,
0.023976298,
-0.0398481116,
0.0516317151,
-0.0879572108,
0.0135445129,
0.0335700922,
0.0292035658,
-0.0252464954,
-0.0285836253,
0.0021855081,
-0.0498259291,
-0.0076151621,
-0.0203813221,
-0.0716110989,
-0.0300127789,
-0.0149749946,
0.002551727,
0.0189281646,
-0.0261845961,
-0.0014066026,
-0.0460542515,
0.0713859275,
0.0121421134,
-0.0425388031,
-0.022179395,
-0.0214904919,
0.0384818725,
0.0233592279,
-0.0435036458,
-0.0154042291,
0.0312642641,
-0.0025056407,
-0.03925303,
0.049797412,
-0.0236505084,
-0.0275870133,
-0.015333849,
-0.0317807645,
-0.0240266472,
0.0596334226,
0.0070885471,
-0.0115602212,
0.0016949109,
0.0076866094,
-0.0040699816,
-0.0071514891,
0.0629762635,
-0.0088128708,
-0.0280824825,
-0.0383161865,
0.0316568613,
0.0448177718,
-0.0789092705,
0.0152710853,
0.0057925931,
-0.0107547622,
0.0082740569,
-0.05268915,
0.0321406797,
-0.0052441983,
0.0408361405,
0.055477079,
-0.0450665317,
-0.0120799094,
-0.0175662432,
0.0220969133,
-0.0723622367,
0.0107348869,
-0.0147470757,
-0.0002406258,
-0.0683546066,
-0.0591313913,
-0.0233949963,
0.0000402435,
0.0608258545,
0.0424092077,
-0.0157890301,
0.0065141455,
0.0178831015,
-0.0498209596,
0.0213344209,
-0.0034552556,
-0.0043702386,
-0.0251203552,
0.0144229773,
-0.0253336262,
-0.0625035986,
-0.0334149711,
0.0471175388,
-0.0940726623,
-0.0404468775,
-0.033949431,
0.0171794221,
0.0115797771,
0.0078856749,
-0.016537616,
-0.0583920963,
-0.0090134246,
0.0508837514,
-0.0054802876,
-0.0208362173,
0.0023818256,
0.0294015706,
-0.0221931487,
-0.009030872,
-0.0012867183,
0.0303998496,
-0.0197874643,
0.0320793167,
-0.0356128626,
-0.0345339999,
-0.0124413269,
0.018856965,
0.028889956,
-0.0316155963,
-0.0195159595,
-0.0668195337,
-0.0234292056,
0.0079745399,
-0.0211972315,
-0.0432403274,
0.024042964,
0.0155072482,
-0.0338568613,
-0.0216840133,
0.0271499772,
0.0242391247,
0.0733149573,
-0.0398283564,
0.0254898556,
0.0544058755,
0.0300298799,
-0.0024687119,
0.0393837951,
0.0352538303,
0.0178957377,
-0.0086871516,
0.0473826006,
0.0043764403,
0.0935691148,
0.0413707271,
-0.0103403646,
0.0000894647,
0.0389231704,
-0.0570302643,
0.0182674974,
0.0129771084,
0.0229462627,
0.0657698512,
-0.038818486,
0.0589469746,
-0.025523046,
-0.0348642841,
-0.001237896,
0.0511909015,
0.0383034721,
-0.003663532,
-0.0058846599,
0.0274475012,
0.0124630956,
-0.0089842733,
0.0410488881,
-0.0514033213,
-0.0033264747,
0.0295608006,
-0.0460647345,
-0.0509851016,
-0.0017736983,
-0.0260813851,
0.0477534086,
0.0325916372,
-0.0029028184,
-0.0272688493,
-0.0126869995,
0.0196621865,
0.0032457795,
-0.0174595509,
0.0455874056,
0.0301401559,
0.042842146,
0.0023067363,
0.0322771706,
-0.0278541297,
0.0492095947,
0.020325955,
-0.0029847112,
-0.0152247678,
-5.245323953e-33,
-0.0369079374,
-0.0575758927,
-0.0226571485,
0.0181207862,
-0.0206885301,
-0.0366749987,
-0.0722685009,
-0.021616254,
0.0465576425,
0.044840131,
0.0295446273,
-0.0122535117,
0.0085756779,
-0.0367644168,
-0.0112911435,
0.007399621,
0.0651449114,
0.026305614,
-0.0545295328,
0.0000194239,
0.042144388,
0.0455168262,
0.0323550478,
-0.0990785956,
-0.0047999546,
-0.0143853696,
-0.0304180868,
-0.0092252577,
0.0613670908,
0.083632417,
-0.0177550297,
0.0120816305,
0.0300079938,
0.0354344286,
0.0011449471,
0.0213455297,
-0.1157225147,
-0.0071241949,
0.0102341892,
0.0334339999,
-0.0194217637,
-0.0136017334,
-0.0023830587,
0.0003880794,
0.0720516294,
-0.0445050113,
0.0585530922,
-0.04078421,
0.0200023707,
-0.0147930309,
-0.0355697908,
0.0113409143,
-0.069340542,
-0.0383768789,
0.0703326911,
-0.0045887972,
0.0461890697,
0.0371635929,
-0.0403295681,
0.0162716843,
-0.0278399289,
-0.026945617,
-0.0079307994,
0.0023703557,
-0.0102930488,
0.0862258449,
-0.004591905,
-0.0158117767,
-0.0248809438,
0.0830612034,
0.0485285074,
0.0171596184,
0.0040003271,
0.0436237194,
0.0472377799,
0.0216116235,
-0.0577659197,
0.0437280685,
0.0201935172,
0.0612333976,
0.0130896568,
0.020373093,
-0.0169726387,
0.0148517024,
0.014329074,
-0.076099962,
-0.0334855467,
-0.0306929126,
0.003955943,
0.0153170852,
-0.0400924161,
0.0351631083,
0.0304160863,
0.0057381731,
-0.0204366408,
0.0096780052,
-0.0187872741,
0.0276431255,
-0.0045673698,
-0.0039878758,
0.0008117427,
0.0216507576,
0.041850239,
-0.0145727945,
0.0281528607,
-0.0354849249,
0.0341333523,
0.0372357592,
-0.0323759615,
0.0041338159,
-0.0282728989,
-0.025623465,
-0.0101755261,
0.0837468654,
0.0146022066,
-0.0387327261,
-0.0574014224,
0.0438138172,
-0.0213857573,
0.0177919287,
-0.0450070985,
-0.0779398009,
0.0190381054,
-0.0159485247,
-0.0093233334,
-0.0099142333,
0.0269398149,
-0.0238070134,
0.0160564035,
-0.0956460163,
-0.012674856,
0.0161013436,
2.447e-7,
0.0188120492,
0.0021011725,
0.0545506217,
0.0358596966,
0.0111285765,
0.0024795169,
-0.0618713722,
-0.0043415041,
0.0103081642,
-0.0139795858,
-0.0017147895,
0.0286427606,
0.061658904,
0.0621143766,
-0.068579264,
-0.0412803218,
-0.0293185469,
-0.0139729464,
-0.0382109657,
0.007201198,
0.0691927075,
-0.0199019071,
0.0144021083,
-0.0368619114,
0.0705896541,
-0.0407573394,
0.0799121559,
0.0034168465,
-0.022391798,
-0.0129185906,
0.032530535,
0.0269703213,
-0.0298170429,
-0.0258637592,
-0.0127142668,
0.0200053174,
0.0882722884,
0.0456094928,
-0.0055700708,
0.0185295083,
-0.0040701544,
0.044052314,
-0.033447355,
0.0037811683,
0.05833501,
0.0244258828,
-0.0171001125,
-0.0123522691,
-0.0423542969,
-0.0405737571,
-0.0020585088,
-0.0380343348,
-0.0568220988,
0.0206618253,
0.0209503695,
-0.0190486554,
0.0043051708,
-0.0542152487,
-0.0259147864,
0.0078332862,
-0.0360880233,
-0.0014376021,
-0.0342670865,
-0.0568485968,
0.0133614633,
-0.0581667311,
-0.0493952818,
2.205525638e-34,
0.0215890277,
-0.004467078,
-0.0148592433,
0.0022026855,
0.0227054004,
-0.0051761516,
-0.0090703396,
-0.0056268601,
-0.0014861852,
-0.0298922434,
-0.0238599982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17121v1 | Test-time Augmentation for Factual Probing | 2023-10-26T03:41:32 | 2023-10-26T03:41:32 | Go Kamoda, Benjamin Heinzerling, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factual probing is a method that uses prompts to test if a language model
"knows" certain world knowledge facts. A problem in factual probing is that
small changes to the prompt can lead to large changes in model output. Previous
work aimed to alleviate this problem by optimizing prompts via text mining or
fine-tuning. However, such approaches are relation-specific and do not
generalize to unseen relation types. Here, we propose to use test-time
augmentation (TTA) as a relation-agnostic method for reducing sensitivity to
prompt variations by automatically augmenting and ensembling prompts at test
time. Experiments show improved model calibration, i.e., with TTA, model
confidence better reflects prediction accuracy. Improvements in prediction
accuracy are observed for some models, but for other models, TTA leads to
degradation. Error analysis identifies the difficulty of producing high-quality
prompt variations as the main challenge for TTA. | [
0.0457524583,
0.0517458506,
-0.0292013604,
0.0654195324,
-0.0279126409,
0.0099243959,
0.0003102277,
0.0179211292,
0.015065222,
-0.0357223339,
0.0212779325,
-0.049278114,
-0.0004447836,
0.057263732,
0.0022867015,
-0.0141200861,
0.1029542387,
-0.0158889126,
-0.0043075103,
0.0135059562,
-0.0318533219,
0.0014598519,
-0.0169016328,
-0.0035843309,
-0.0337583981,
-0.0189818088,
-0.064054288,
-0.0106665352,
0.0274055284,
-0.0183896944,
0.0019956706,
0.0872986317,
0.0040982626,
0.0494720228,
0.0000021957,
-0.0569263212,
-0.0157490056,
-0.0018591373,
-0.0760042965,
0.030853942,
0.0100111598,
0.0157081336,
0.0198832974,
0.0407650433,
-0.0472753048,
-0.0121882139,
0.0139103774,
0.0121551678,
0.0149909705,
0.0892112181,
0.0114773912,
0.0689787567,
0.0018812522,
-0.0148398913,
0.0273340829,
-0.031139208,
0.0172111876,
-0.0056033758,
0.0213415883,
0.0414223932,
-0.0161533188,
0.0153532438,
0.0340675786,
-0.0067562456,
0.0212823711,
0.0299531315,
0.0139350584,
-0.0212961957,
0.0030492593,
0.0087044798,
0.0395850725,
-0.0369348824,
-0.0229101442,
-0.0177131295,
0.0210283715,
0.0381637998,
0.0334443711,
-0.0051618074,
-0.022763012,
-0.0052537499,
0.0230336953,
-0.0107607711,
0.0192119181,
0.0038652704,
-0.0272397306,
0.1148850098,
0.0124917869,
-0.0368979163,
-0.0326910838,
0.0370187648,
0.0213814098,
-0.0793873146,
-0.0336913876,
0.0308967717,
-0.0632799268,
0.0195056107,
-0.0324890912,
0.0125428047,
0.0317305736,
0.0028577,
-0.0272928439,
0.0376880765,
-0.0590388738,
0.0371191278,
0.0054578115,
0.0668059587,
0.0544909388,
-0.0190148242,
-0.0527000725,
0.0034541455,
-0.0335717238,
-0.0013657868,
-0.0161942225,
-0.015980931,
-0.0281435642,
0.0379355885,
-0.0228979718,
0.0353082605,
0.003098503,
0.0564871766,
-0.0455308072,
-0.0208104718,
-0.0629651546,
0.019447349,
-0.0532156713,
0.0231877789,
-0.0305326264,
-0.0169079844,
-0.0097603723,
-0.0505731478,
-0.022451628,
-0.0193950143,
0.0138919,
-0.019953737,
-0.0188764483,
0.0286635291,
-0.0251848307,
-0.0635166317,
-0.0087016225,
-0.0534699634,
-0.0071165273,
-0.036371544,
0.002125958,
-0.0369538888,
0.0194391832,
0.0035353326,
0.002148055,
-0.0295783561,
-0.0112183532,
0.0021905666,
-0.0204885006,
0.0612979755,
-0.0132537,
0.0031966453,
-0.0202331282,
0.0025870514,
0.0318758786,
0.0922858939,
0.0064771962,
-0.0037708248,
0.0520085841,
0.009470542,
0.0082561541,
0.0510154776,
0.0338809267,
0.0141082192,
-0.016708171,
0.0198034998,
0.0451096706,
0.0208579414,
0.0139249815,
0.0091086244,
0.0116138048,
-0.0030797124,
0.0257174578,
-0.03621139,
-0.0055306004,
0.0118356161,
0.0569230169,
-0.0222017672,
0.0167984832,
0.0576749109,
-0.0847522095,
0.0001125305,
-0.0927946419,
0.0348644704,
-0.0352993421,
0.0318465605,
-0.0071434658,
-0.050262522,
-0.0238876082,
0.0037139547,
0.017861763,
0.0146355238,
0.0538483523,
0.0232453644,
-0.0156294089,
0.055475913,
0.0487963669,
-0.0286551397,
0.0170889087,
-0.053874664,
0.0487194583,
0.046237532,
0.0318554789,
-0.0710000545,
-0.0461503267,
-0.0044374913,
-0.013252764,
0.0504502691,
0.0813069269,
-0.0368398502,
-0.0031824626,
-0.0000259242,
-0.0341160148,
-0.0067401137,
0.0296164751,
0.024477262,
0.0317819975,
0.0216293838,
0.0182626918,
-0.0610030293,
-0.0065274448,
0.0349375643,
-0.0471896529,
-0.0155844167,
-0.006049301,
0.0272769164,
-0.0163739156,
0.0356590115,
-0.0116398903,
-0.006188855,
0.0245197657,
-0.0110055963,
0.0050467695,
0.0079121478,
-0.0157747027,
-0.0658932999,
0.0306901354,
0.0246446561,
-0.0697439536,
0.0186748896,
-0.0442634635,
-0.0357325412,
-0.0348381847,
0.0091760363,
0.0544276759,
-0.0388600528,
0.0388978496,
-0.045235917,
-0.009051255,
-0.0228674468,
0.0729470402,
-0.0043377071,
0.0116285551,
0.0074540428,
-0.0149261635,
0.0051977956,
-0.0361380726,
-0.0564648658,
0.0071630487,
-0.003330275,
-0.0109308138,
0.0489127897,
0.0136620188,
-0.0660832748,
0.0001727005,
-0.0955897868,
0.0014413008,
-0.0200503655,
0.037761949,
0.0147803985,
0.034424182,
-0.02254414,
-0.0327038243,
-0.0431401394,
-0.0231794938,
-0.0021523822,
0.0384162404,
0.0420465283,
0.0213861074,
-0.0055157542,
-0.0248649772,
0.0152590163,
-0.0449749902,
0.0528267063,
0.030674912,
0.0173154771,
-0.0517035499,
0.0508560501,
-0.0579429455,
0.0215547495,
-0.0098052416,
-0.0124291815,
-0.0014249124,
0.0130256694,
-0.0137341497,
0.0549010858,
0.0342590995,
0.0121186953,
0.0564091355,
0.0129603269,
-0.034506537,
0.0326594599,
0.0127489474,
-0.0256006345,
0.0096474607,
-0.0601113141,
-0.0103855599,
0.0711180121,
-0.0173556246,
-0.0354688987,
-0.0385444388,
0.0236290675,
-0.051388476,
-0.0224496983,
-0.0256196633,
-0.0016143511,
-0.0021959932,
0.0507169105,
-0.0309569519,
-0.0334057845,
0.1237105355,
-0.0399600789,
-0.0055612111,
-0.0484444164,
-0.0016799691,
-0.014801275,
0.0515096597,
0.0120854583,
-0.0059471088,
0.0485605635,
-0.0196948797,
-0.0508750528,
-0.0245847646,
0.0447524153,
-0.0337322205,
0.0370414741,
-0.0499534942,
-0.0049131424,
0.0172655992,
-0.0494322218,
-0.079891786,
-0.0447001271,
-0.0269026943,
0.0027443792,
-0.0469919778,
-0.0299086478,
0.0111818854,
0.0028159148,
0.0037092261,
0.0502297245,
-0.0322366543,
-0.0127599165,
-0.0274341274,
0.0024701268,
0.0677095652,
0.0239262935,
0.0160327423,
-0.0195710566,
0.0179550629,
0.0095714144,
0.003072446,
-0.0096103037,
-0.0288231261,
-0.0023426986,
-0.0200442001,
-0.023143746,
-0.0344968699,
0.0210219752,
0.0202374272,
-0.0609001257,
-0.0568955392,
0.1331553906,
0.0558828115,
-0.0066759451,
0.0193972476,
-0.0215791427,
0.0233115405,
0.0271216817,
0.0603574589,
-0.0931079611,
0.001190279,
0.0228367206,
-0.0023333107,
-0.0336876176,
-0.0431193486,
-0.0180241447,
-0.1325809807,
0.001439554,
-0.0212093685,
-0.0273327753,
-0.0200058054,
-0.0245577693,
0.0271691289,
-0.0033968997,
0.0658441857,
0.0091944626,
0.0034041347,
0.0265765693,
0.0191132948,
-0.0084700864,
-0.076519236,
0.041018568,
-0.0191601235,
0.0566073917,
0.0515397191,
0.0249588341,
-0.0249970909,
-0.0131378798,
-0.0080764322,
0.0257065687,
0.0267124921,
-0.0098425318,
0.0311030876,
0.0127190668,
-0.0160353445,
0.0198725536,
0.0084612481,
0.0223726816,
-0.0068499199,
0.0321572237,
0.0702040195,
0.0174021516,
-0.0066531454,
-0.006387406,
-0.0288247708,
0.0379319079,
0.0653086975,
0.0222566426,
-0.0382174663,
0.0253611021,
-0.0289179217,
0.005011518,
-0.0154295228,
-0.0127987089,
0.004681624,
-0.0198687278,
0.0059533399,
-0.0647793114,
-0.0564886518,
0.0224715881,
0.0452550724,
0.0103117488,
-0.0200889427,
0.0083045848,
-0.0086481944,
-0.059038762,
0.0466215536,
-0.0325310007,
0.0175880529,
-0.0181658827,
0.0051237615,
-0.009098961,
-0.0463451855,
-0.0213268939,
-0.0302566625,
-0.0635991842,
-0.0727282017,
0.0094576525,
0.0234700628,
0.0245350748,
0.0864565969,
-0.0376084521,
-0.0182507373,
0.0458108112,
0.0299431458,
-0.0401913747,
0.045544859,
0.0236401856,
-0.0288517382,
-0.0188275352,
0.0279614739,
-0.051457528,
-0.0259475429,
-0.0011869866,
0.0037634568,
-0.0096734641,
-0.0748882294,
0.0375118889,
0.0324269123,
0.0815080851,
0.0167772211,
-0.006231775,
-0.0358677916,
0.0246355943,
-0.0466540791,
-0.0309580639,
-0.0099982079,
0.0323545225,
-0.0313719325,
-0.0031985324,
0.0110892542,
-0.0353049971,
-0.0423585624,
0.038643904,
-0.0308940839,
-0.0255744029,
0.0131504089,
0.0225723218,
0.0425756685,
0.0109520266,
-0.0208173525,
-0.0113593461,
0.0080671413,
0.0520645715,
-0.0065187165,
0.0458891056,
0.0397554561,
-0.0057669976,
-0.0261695571,
-0.010964145,
-0.047111772,
0.0265800655,
-0.0110147418,
0.0580438711,
0.0339162275,
-0.0457626358,
0.0332781971,
-0.0403124467,
0.0016236099,
0.001707465,
0.0074350028,
0.0166508798,
-0.0559306964,
0.021243766,
0.0114089632,
-0.0086408099,
0.0239937678,
0.0481137149,
-0.0149905225,
0.07549119,
0.0002963254,
-0.0189784411,
-0.0421539731,
0.0178008992,
-0.0003226282,
-0.0076400274,
-0.0471858345,
0.0275540724,
-0.0940642282,
-0.0870204493,
0.0293940511,
0.0467091314,
-0.0106979329,
-0.0045951912,
0.0050896215,
0.0630155429,
0.0041551851,
-0.0247878339,
-0.0301088598,
-0.0136477267,
0.0139811486,
0.0025982456,
0.0035181043,
-6.940494071e-33,
-0.0632750615,
-0.0400164202,
0.0125648407,
-0.0481119528,
0.0005857088,
0.0603184104,
-0.0306673907,
0.018296387,
-0.027307855,
0.0298063066,
-0.0532026105,
0.0130313756,
0.0187596083,
-0.0130176386,
0.0093351509,
-0.0043469626,
0.0626603663,
0.0032224418,
-0.0600443967,
-0.0079431292,
0.040002618,
0.0075433603,
0.0804793611,
-0.0316574425,
0.0455752276,
-0.0055369902,
-0.0230578817,
0.0547706001,
-0.0572290942,
0.0456247441,
0.0048160311,
0.0306393839,
0.0131441886,
-0.0102194203,
-0.0101736058,
-0.0181505866,
-0.0972765163,
-0.0974269807,
0.0410901196,
0.0251915976,
-0.0207316615,
0.0133981742,
-0.0220876578,
-0.0383351482,
0.0195925683,
-0.0088826595,
0.0195783526,
-0.0219328571,
-0.0156057412,
0.0141967051,
-0.0369998179,
-0.0019990657,
0.0062638945,
-0.0323475786,
0.0049919863,
0.054702349,
0.0351963341,
-0.0729746744,
-0.0442649685,
0.0150912143,
0.0736216679,
0.02450395,
0.078325741,
0.0246551111,
-0.0302798953,
0.0564293638,
-0.0244808886,
0.0248296708,
0.0022038931,
0.013410571,
0.0512146391,
-0.0341552794,
0.012633034,
0.0916721374,
0.0161777362,
0.0001883002,
-0.0329254232,
0.0277873911,
0.0876490176,
0.0049435361,
0.009251467,
-0.0088070398,
-0.0729109049,
-0.0287915692,
-0.0524727926,
0.0352890417,
-0.0314592794,
-0.0423307531,
0.0238573793,
0.0208964795,
-0.0438071117,
-0.0220922604,
0.0095328912,
-0.0319217406,
-0.007261598,
0.0184526574,
-0.0358773395,
-0.0084476722,
-0.0202419218,
0.0349549018,
-0.000893245,
-0.0244854987,
0.0209240858,
-0.0159396939,
0.0161042027,
0.0173416659,
0.0089731179,
0.0295321867,
-0.0546748713,
0.0247953422,
-0.030977102,
0.0107413176,
0.0031620178,
-0.0322479717,
0.0221077707,
0.0092757242,
-0.0079296203,
0.0362443253,
0.0479594246,
-0.0119742714,
-0.0786664933,
0.0410742611,
0.0052571641,
0.0456546247,
-0.0057512359,
-0.0396238863,
0.0035531027,
0.015128009,
0.0332821086,
-0.0360821448,
0.0005901155,
0.0155342175,
2.902e-7,
0.0075525558,
0.0605571233,
0.0067501455,
0.0398207009,
0.0037356832,
0.0522670224,
-0.0018869655,
0.0272651557,
0.033018034,
-0.0291949604,
0.005735538,
-0.0068202708,
0.0130934371,
0.0411866792,
-0.0951125026,
-0.0191704202,
-0.0430325195,
-0.0236390177,
-0.0536207333,
-0.0223917644,
0.0231655072,
0.0656101555,
0.0383530483,
0.0092146546,
-0.0200293306,
-0.032400988,
0.0070032035,
-0.0111270016,
-0.0449868999,
0.0362810344,
0.0471457876,
0.0132034002,
0.0293954536,
0.0823347867,
-0.0216095615,
0.026886424,
-0.0277745314,
-0.0147607494,
0.0148004936,
0.0111296466,
-0.0284895655,
-0.0061675659,
0.0000514514,
-0.0688437745,
0.0818350315,
0.0021827864,
0.0184387323,
-0.0336259939,
0.005192955,
-0.0153937032,
0.003311848,
0.0016602582,
-0.0126947146,
0.0224984176,
0.0049242098,
0.0309663564,
-0.0225800797,
-0.0345576629,
-0.040946003,
0.0325668715,
-0.0308573153,
-0.0756950304,
0.0093261264,
-0.0444540977,
-0.0250299145,
-0.0980784073,
0.0138350986,
3.096388725e-34,
0.023292562,
0.0099714724,
0.0014798198,
0.0041689742,
0.0468342118,
-0.0200469568,
-0.007970918,
0.0160434637,
0.0357328393,
-0.0560441017,
-0.0244642422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17120v1 | Topic Segmentation of Semi-Structured and Unstructured Conversational Datasets using Language Models | 2023-10-26T03:37:51 | 2023-10-26T03:37:51 | Reshmi Ghosh, Harjeet Singh Kajal, Sharanya Kamath, Dhuri Shrivastava, Samyadeep Basu, Hansi Zeng, Soundararajan Srinivasan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Breaking down a document or a conversation into multiple contiguous segments
based on its semantic structure is an important and challenging problem in NLP,
which can assist many downstream tasks. However, current works on topic
segmentation often focus on segmentation of structured texts. In this paper, we
comprehensively analyze the generalization capabilities of state-of-the-art
topic segmentation models on unstructured texts. We find that: (a) Current
strategies of pre-training on a large corpus of structured text such as
Wiki-727K do not help in transferability to unstructured conversational data.
(b) Training from scratch with only a relatively small-sized dataset of the
target unstructured domain improves the segmentation results by a significant
margin. We stress-test our proposed Topic Segmentation approach by
experimenting with multiple loss functions, in order to mitigate effects of
imbalance in unstructured conversational datasets. Our empirical evaluation
indicates that Focal Loss function is a robust alternative to Cross-Entropy and
re-weighted Cross-Entropy loss function when segmenting unstructured and
semi-structured chats. | [
0.0228615776,
0.0186928026,
0.0209870785,
0.0280105565,
-0.0445125327,
0.0249019582,
0.0109295873,
0.0036323359,
-0.0330152251,
-0.059377715,
-0.026079813,
-0.0341933034,
0.0013559068,
-0.0146289617,
-0.0136653921,
-0.0658869594,
0.0231709164,
-0.0224520396,
0.0358821228,
0.0449462682,
0.0336898305,
-0.0136242434,
-0.0057942797,
-0.0164189208,
-0.0013996148,
-0.0179789476,
-0.0320664495,
0.001915044,
-0.0177593771,
0.0092008198,
0.0481166504,
0.0491253398,
0.0035484142,
-0.0031071191,
0.0000017278,
-0.0349847078,
-0.0431311429,
-0.0607191697,
-0.0155013856,
0.0291536637,
0.0619114414,
-0.0559410267,
-0.0124482214,
0.0267047044,
0.0002674173,
0.0021319173,
0.0039569964,
0.1188192591,
0.0684417859,
0.1019349843,
-0.0308212638,
-0.0345076062,
0.0741397366,
-0.0122132767,
0.0113957813,
-0.0366339423,
0.0124420747,
0.023976896,
-0.0863358676,
0.0024223963,
0.0222215634,
-0.0095309867,
-0.0095564583,
-0.0214198753,
0.0490623899,
0.007031206,
-0.0664111748,
-0.0356547721,
-0.0234598927,
0.0781819448,
-0.0233824048,
0.0135377906,
0.0506868549,
-0.0042013279,
-0.0032962034,
-0.0471725762,
-0.0546315014,
0.0193721,
0.0159723107,
0.0303932521,
0.0421815626,
0.0304056611,
0.0164897237,
0.0017163642,
-0.0083877724,
0.0441995114,
-0.0038141143,
-0.0457501747,
0.0060020168,
0.015992498,
0.0097021535,
-0.0353233516,
0.0333538242,
0.0170535371,
-0.0015338815,
0.0378544629,
-0.0367872566,
-0.0233693309,
-0.0020909423,
-0.0625956953,
-0.0525467768,
-0.023900114,
0.0203564372,
0.0559107512,
0.0511944331,
-0.0436908193,
0.0182840899,
0.0150745977,
-0.0457522534,
-0.023875121,
-0.0566624962,
0.009593552,
-0.0336089171,
0.0262114294,
-0.0288319606,
-0.0272747241,
-0.029727703,
0.0100535611,
0.0214917772,
-0.0276545156,
0.0274063069,
-0.0365451872,
-0.0266786423,
0.017501073,
0.0356740169,
0.0259832125,
-0.0448774733,
0.0297617503,
0.0175539237,
-0.0071915705,
0.010871225,
0.052945815,
0.0050823321,
-0.0141256358,
-0.0430367999,
0.0161084905,
-0.0297922976,
-0.0632458553,
-0.0422233008,
-0.0266213994,
-0.0160217471,
-0.0351585187,
0.0243068505,
-0.0461699218,
0.0333690941,
-0.0061899414,
-0.0284576435,
0.0189488418,
-0.0075304559,
0.0066633024,
-0.0182253886,
0.0491309278,
-0.0070009995,
0.0349982604,
0.0814008415,
0.0283298008,
0.0694263875,
0.0906758085,
0.020016877,
-0.0039606388,
0.0955516547,
0.0169512704,
-0.0109648891,
0.0221751705,
0.0091097448,
0.0003728723,
0.0404695235,
-0.0091156838,
-0.0003212083,
-0.0102297673,
-0.0014067297,
0.0305459313,
-0.0382178985,
-0.0183054451,
0.0120092044,
0.0664331466,
0.001868292,
0.0318723656,
-0.0214020275,
0.0673844665,
-0.0025439863,
0.0510614626,
-0.0235633403,
-0.0627016723,
0.0118236057,
-0.0080614649,
0.0675940216,
-0.0165352337,
-0.0596157126,
-0.0501481704,
-0.0118346596,
-0.0256478284,
0.0375587903,
-0.0247721095,
0.0754910111,
0.0339016095,
-0.0079901451,
0.0906676576,
0.031045679,
-0.0722422078,
-0.0031854024,
-0.001883532,
0.0029590318,
0.0217556227,
0.0150850397,
-0.0640825406,
-0.0254427381,
0.0003693825,
0.0702564269,
0.0183992404,
0.0395764224,
-0.0116483476,
0.041207388,
-0.0589517727,
0.0220239423,
-0.0155576728,
0.0295623764,
-0.0448304117,
0.0031689201,
-0.0000465562,
0.0239875689,
-0.0440964773,
0.033371862,
0.0347835496,
-0.0163398534,
0.0038193485,
-0.018640887,
-0.0301089846,
0.0104628047,
0.0196914542,
-0.0157930236,
-0.0180224031,
0.0312429406,
-0.0149902608,
0.0123074222,
0.00090792,
-0.0536265746,
-0.0739403516,
0.0118815154,
-0.0300639439,
-0.0255002715,
-0.0083619906,
-0.0439175479,
-0.0257923417,
0.0433920473,
-0.0011904722,
0.0370012261,
-0.0267305151,
0.0296935048,
0.0289105047,
0.0071373153,
-0.0167572033,
0.0320105813,
-0.0004698246,
-0.0182395708,
-0.0306899138,
-0.0698379725,
-0.0254684743,
-0.0655266047,
0.0266695786,
0.0421364382,
-0.0380195491,
0.0028780117,
-0.00187264,
-0.0048179128,
-0.0457783602,
-0.0155075397,
-0.1253641397,
0.0242305622,
-0.0517000668,
0.0339303501,
0.016808331,
0.0207068641,
-0.0063008424,
0.0085213063,
-0.0455030426,
0.0323786102,
0.0201340932,
0.0013033007,
0.0482924245,
-0.0130389864,
0.0267360043,
-0.0606081039,
-0.0356392711,
-0.0062051876,
0.0652973354,
-0.0024893617,
-0.0183470622,
-0.0449393764,
0.0476068556,
0.0006006738,
-0.0101865493,
-0.0121472143,
-0.0015985644,
-0.0387399048,
-0.0270556398,
0.0306868367,
0.0199425165,
0.0439789183,
0.0478544906,
-0.0362760015,
-0.0409994945,
0.0063083405,
-0.0106514934,
-0.0225342438,
0.0316589437,
-0.0152315563,
-0.0243123937,
0.0767044798,
0.0995372459,
-0.0222794935,
0.027404068,
0.0056201573,
-0.0677413344,
-0.0260657817,
-0.006574925,
-0.0220784713,
0.0150974309,
-0.0008711422,
0.0065244636,
-0.0230673868,
-0.0198447928,
0.0327463597,
-0.031191498,
-0.0167910047,
-0.0856597424,
-0.0616878085,
-0.042598594,
0.0271731205,
-0.004885511,
-0.0231521055,
0.0409043394,
-0.0261648577,
-0.0095926197,
-0.0128226699,
0.019513648,
0.0397026762,
0.0485079847,
-0.0244467165,
0.0178227834,
0.0005194066,
0.0129438676,
-0.0026053947,
-0.0508707687,
0.0179353692,
0.0048131607,
0.0386649482,
0.0290380716,
-0.009427174,
0.0287135541,
-0.0196543895,
0.0552282184,
0.0024363566,
-0.0039058623,
-0.0126093803,
0.0939311981,
0.0373888016,
-0.0507985726,
-0.0195527859,
-0.0559799038,
0.0471853428,
0.0593857914,
0.054035183,
-0.0301911607,
0.0069890916,
-0.0248898603,
-0.0036610647,
-0.0516370051,
-0.0240833741,
-0.0215357561,
0.0635268763,
-0.0334406719,
-0.0124947773,
0.1177572235,
0.0625041127,
-0.0338745303,
-0.0080998847,
-0.004718178,
0.0180947594,
-0.036814373,
-0.0285873171,
-0.0318476446,
-0.0360770747,
-0.0208766162,
0.0156798083,
0.0087292241,
-0.0367895849,
0.0123700378,
-0.0496559553,
0.000956003,
-0.0004159309,
-0.0245891586,
0.0013168214,
-0.0771429688,
-0.0041841734,
-0.0218361933,
-0.0029716825,
-0.0314162411,
-0.0119083757,
-0.0357756801,
0.0149941193,
-0.0684247464,
-0.0204870012,
-0.0044854754,
-0.0129653383,
0.0243129749,
0.0045410404,
0.0444495641,
0.0190589838,
0.0505889989,
0.0986369103,
-0.0477877893,
-0.0488254614,
0.0084708435,
0.0717095584,
-0.0313660242,
0.0534348786,
-0.0088726329,
0.0141875427,
-0.0267633218,
-0.0170103777,
0.0228500497,
0.0337204933,
-0.020500686,
-0.0284589157,
0.0014993174,
0.0150322122,
0.003904586,
0.0785520822,
0.0304831639,
-0.0214334894,
-0.0524265878,
-0.0148289083,
0.0539122745,
0.0190792419,
0.0081467601,
-0.0213637091,
-0.0168690123,
-0.0578026213,
-0.0812408105,
-0.079529494,
-0.0037426292,
-0.013534477,
-0.0507513247,
-0.0170028564,
0.0217768271,
-0.0007907952,
-0.018220555,
0.0167604014,
-0.0369439684,
-0.0377266668,
-0.0577291809,
-0.0281565413,
0.0074415267,
-0.0214675274,
0.0084109521,
-0.0059104362,
-0.0806025788,
-0.0695902556,
-0.0339385718,
-0.0137273744,
0.0114873573,
0.0326294862,
-0.0301806685,
-0.031220099,
0.0156232268,
0.0015437447,
-0.0765425786,
-0.0116841672,
0.0502810776,
0.0416018479,
0.0212696344,
0.0395768695,
-0.015272106,
0.0517574809,
-0.0224969722,
0.0027356313,
-0.061979305,
-0.0334254913,
-0.0630432144,
-0.0010297024,
0.0848105848,
0.0556910709,
-0.0223804377,
-0.0457785353,
0.015823815,
0.0067095342,
-0.0008582543,
-0.0215612464,
0.0185273178,
0.0263467804,
0.0091987485,
-0.0295445845,
0.039925985,
-0.0507593229,
0.0140566053,
-0.0222225171,
0.0212778226,
0.0333270133,
0.0054691145,
-0.0147007704,
-0.0127578517,
0.0053298762,
-0.0037737235,
0.0097358515,
0.0090938248,
-0.0056830905,
0.0567864329,
-0.0040297867,
-0.0237432029,
-0.0004568523,
0.0277459379,
-0.0711370334,
0.0257723257,
-0.0142203532,
0.0575557314,
0.0106972959,
-0.0170776006,
0.0642389506,
-0.0084644575,
0.0007351357,
-0.0276354179,
0.0665824711,
0.0110783884,
-0.0079331743,
-0.0188580919,
0.0222959351,
-0.0505870432,
0.0289884675,
0.0537163466,
0.0013852429,
-0.0009871532,
0.061199408,
-0.0231909119,
-0.0463703275,
0.0057972302,
0.0227226447,
0.0248928089,
-0.0216054488,
0.0251086187,
-0.013525744,
-0.009469416,
-0.0039613117,
-0.0614567697,
0.0204399396,
0.0268259887,
0.0602394678,
0.1009772122,
-0.0188122336,
0.026900718,
-0.0414157547,
-0.0014434496,
0.0050348211,
-0.0275245868,
-0.0131504266,
-5.964092096e-33,
0.0167046636,
0.0100941062,
-0.0051793051,
0.0311188865,
0.0018989898,
0.0054355208,
-0.0403347649,
0.0238032453,
-0.0030317607,
-0.0067190859,
-0.0160723627,
0.0445721038,
0.0269862283,
0.0426129773,
-0.0471318439,
-0.0529874787,
0.0453048162,
-0.001857225,
-0.0408395566,
0.0472578555,
0.0172452535,
0.0314329676,
0.0491436422,
-0.0506019741,
0.0274546053,
-0.0315782987,
0.0318294764,
0.0185706299,
0.0924520269,
0.0168865323,
-0.0303249434,
0.0438330881,
0.0455409102,
-0.0462451577,
0.0016199633,
0.0496096052,
-0.0461905822,
-0.0182955451,
-0.0327120163,
-0.0110314023,
-0.0149728833,
0.0011445757,
0.0367409922,
0.0096253678,
0.048724357,
-0.0388015397,
0.0677786469,
0.0290583726,
-0.00929166,
-0.020011669,
-0.079981491,
0.0675713718,
-0.0283149872,
-0.0591332465,
0.0333566703,
0.0280933324,
0.0263672844,
-0.0058619394,
-0.0271114539,
0.0427410416,
0.0207630601,
0.0103757568,
-0.0119522847,
-0.0346635431,
-0.0444509313,
0.0279538669,
0.0165654309,
0.0341789797,
0.0131870415,
-0.0080734501,
-0.0214807633,
0.037863493,
0.0031701706,
-0.0103685614,
0.0086052697,
-0.0020833081,
-0.0673250258,
0.0215853304,
0.045900654,
-0.0005030199,
-0.0039502806,
0.04234007,
-0.0505385585,
-0.0348026045,
0.0304029491,
-0.0195245817,
0.0239250399,
-0.0008244874,
-0.0083437124,
0.0140168183,
-0.024546437,
0.0071810484,
0.0398576707,
-0.0094304271,
-0.0150260134,
0.0594181418,
-0.0020319172,
0.0364919938,
-0.0273124389,
-0.0289237648,
-0.0902038962,
-0.0311597399,
0.0345776007,
0.0033780616,
-0.005886605,
-0.0017266503,
0.0214572139,
-0.0427066833,
-0.0082570426,
-0.0202430189,
0.0187040698,
0.0048918561,
-0.0410438478,
0.1057272553,
0.0224873945,
0.0021778939,
-0.0250175875,
0.0987510756,
0.0250021257,
0.0090155378,
-0.03183062,
-0.0226015821,
-0.0387017541,
0.0218099002,
-0.0101695089,
0.0135980332,
0.0015877142,
-0.0151395146,
0.0421243124,
-0.0586533621,
-0.0021438894,
-0.0322060697,
2.481e-7,
0.0201386809,
0.0672359243,
0.0300561581,
-0.0369122513,
0.0185109302,
0.0472016744,
0.0183703508,
0.03896356,
-0.0144828381,
-0.0338634998,
0.0059226532,
0.0301110297,
0.0400028713,
0.0227568354,
-0.0928239748,
-0.0474000312,
-0.0535907708,
-0.0168409385,
-0.0419543013,
-0.0239047017,
0.0015173808,
0.1135762185,
0.01865362,
0.010382114,
-0.0304906294,
-0.0224084966,
0.0217794403,
-0.0635554567,
-0.0477108955,
0.0505233407,
0.0255074035,
0.0070502381,
-0.0087431669,
-0.0070828893,
-0.0110305883,
0.0006111338,
0.0499411449,
0.0781755149,
0.0220519956,
0.0007428452,
0.0025374065,
-0.0015634199,
-0.0196356829,
0.0069928337,
0.0372557528,
-0.0406548455,
-0.0280861296,
0.0153054148,
0.0227749627,
-0.0066180839,
0.0235171728,
-0.0089899339,
-0.0166734494,
0.0496841148,
-0.0028043403,
-0.0190545619,
0.0067615816,
-0.0529090501,
-0.0150770405,
0.0173790101,
-0.0290580057,
-0.0205242988,
-0.0192624889,
-0.0170979425,
-0.0084879715,
-0.0554568842,
0.0240761526,
2.134238793e-34,
0.0409904569,
-0.0175802894,
-0.0590284467,
0.0285094324,
0.0294143464,
-0.0194462724,
-0.0298104156,
-0.0132134436,
-0.010130601,
-0.0403745882,
0.0499418639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17119v1 | FLEEK: Factual Error Detection and Correction with Evidence Retrieved from External Knowledge | 2023-10-26T03:28:30 | 2023-10-26T03:28:30 | Farima Fatahi Bayat, Kun Qian, Benjamin Han, Yisi Sang, Anton Belyi, Samira Khorshidi, Fei Wu, Ihab F. Ilyas, Yunyao Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting factual errors in textual information, whether generated by large
language models (LLM) or curated by humans, is crucial for making informed
decisions. LLMs' inability to attribute their claims to external knowledge and
their tendency to hallucinate makes it difficult to rely on their responses.
Humans, too, are prone to factual errors in their writing. Since manual
detection and correction of factual errors is labor-intensive, developing an
automatic approach can greatly reduce human effort. We present FLEEK, a
prototype tool that automatically extracts factual claims from text, gathers
evidence from external knowledge sources, evaluates the factuality of each
claim, and suggests revisions for identified errors using the collected
evidence. Initial empirical evaluation on fact error detection (77-85\% F1)
shows the potential of FLEEK. A video demo of FLEEK can be found at
https://youtu.be/NapJFUlkPdQ. | [
0.0712198317,
0.0218910631,
-0.0012404067,
0.0346490815,
-0.051736936,
0.0118258046,
-0.015397693,
-0.0245143808,
0.013913366,
-0.0864115283,
0.0171255432,
-0.0124781765,
0.0541566983,
0.0104848118,
0.0478975959,
-0.0237756353,
0.0470739715,
-0.0140028046,
0.0692500174,
-0.0002581242,
-0.0018255961,
0.0419112928,
-0.0500245504,
0.0120147131,
-0.0531362258,
-0.0381281078,
0.0105533507,
-0.0244331062,
0.0537188649,
-0.0071035936,
0.0172851514,
0.0333559923,
-0.0370145105,
0.0910320058,
0.0000018553,
-0.047280401,
-0.0002167039,
0.0264896378,
-0.0063258661,
0.0333465897,
0.0504962504,
0.0237971265,
-0.0549348816,
-0.0093531152,
0.0022750825,
-0.0091530718,
0.0177966431,
0.0772961676,
0.0567210391,
0.0817933604,
0.007209029,
-0.008512862,
0.0363047794,
0.0314180627,
-0.0189858824,
0.0255762339,
0.0537946001,
0.0150241405,
-0.0319532901,
-0.0012019761,
0.0186976828,
0.0289565697,
-0.0189758185,
-0.0511241294,
-0.02126408,
0.0381368324,
-0.0212615505,
-0.0239186008,
-0.0021741176,
0.0297311712,
0.0015915938,
-0.0528908223,
-0.0021284949,
-0.0071391584,
0.025863668,
0.0186351091,
0.0136572849,
0.0681983382,
-0.0628858432,
0.0009180424,
0.0255597588,
-0.0586836375,
0.0135749578,
0.03747743,
0.0323976986,
0.030911427,
0.0049976008,
-0.0624363497,
-0.0030975407,
0.0286574215,
0.0295895822,
-0.0914999172,
0.0271126181,
0.0114765996,
-0.0004304579,
0.0054831654,
-0.0433400832,
-0.0348024257,
0.0515324622,
-0.0739358217,
0.0058446778,
-0.0325048678,
-0.0716587156,
0.0679548383,
-0.0165839847,
0.008409977,
0.026863236,
-0.0062910756,
0.0348861292,
0.0162403025,
-0.0063692164,
0.0003272317,
0.0178943835,
-0.0050381809,
-0.0188158005,
0.0274277274,
-0.0188352726,
-0.0397891365,
-0.0188559499,
0.0619521737,
0.004172626,
-0.008533244,
-0.0146180801,
-0.0415135063,
-0.0617137849,
0.0221443363,
0.020268416,
0.0697169453,
-0.0120147262,
-0.0216966476,
-0.0039712237,
0.0112158265,
0.0037665635,
0.004838896,
0.0057765525,
-0.0260428712,
0.0050927778,
0.001042223,
-0.0589456707,
-0.0196742751,
-0.0300416797,
-0.0457409658,
-0.0690676495,
-0.0685900301,
-0.0141431214,
-0.03293835,
-0.0156123806,
-0.0040173982,
0.0245809015,
0.0563925616,
-0.0522222891,
0.0182078388,
-0.0947806463,
0.0031190496,
0.056975171,
-0.0089587485,
0.021746425,
0.0240184274,
0.0231113806,
0.0201168451,
0.0645610243,
0.0701247528,
0.0235177148,
-0.0048877001,
-0.0139084216,
-0.0062966472,
0.0561015382,
-0.0172823071,
0.0088590132,
-0.0011597504,
0.0327723809,
0.0721311346,
-0.0037132963,
-0.0192284696,
0.0881679058,
0.030542342,
-0.0237338096,
-0.0134327281,
0.0371607915,
-0.016048586,
0.0684749857,
-0.0344130732,
-0.0464397743,
-0.0213128664,
-0.0306527093,
-0.0189482272,
0.0171328243,
0.0824930221,
0.0448969267,
-0.0398257971,
-0.0315472856,
-0.003303265,
-0.0137094855,
-0.0306038447,
0.0352763087,
0.0284722336,
-0.0193618722,
0.0104542468,
0.0391098112,
-0.0323957019,
-0.0070403344,
-0.0164157115,
0.0436676666,
0.0293225665,
0.045514565,
-0.0052276705,
0.0142640145,
-0.0383334458,
-0.0244471915,
0.0360478498,
0.0753502324,
-0.0397573337,
-0.0176929198,
0.020059986,
0.0154007422,
0.0033852037,
0.0492548048,
-0.0426253825,
0.039700821,
0.0174673721,
0.0112333009,
-0.0096688541,
-0.0407430567,
0.0396226645,
0.0057393308,
0.0038209769,
-0.0263107009,
-0.006861527,
-0.0057144943,
0.0221085865,
-0.0389250629,
0.0042980625,
-0.0003583352,
0.0235846601,
-0.0501973554,
0.0101354336,
0.0664952248,
-0.0300369821,
0.070455566,
-0.0280892588,
-0.0718131587,
-0.011487511,
-0.0219567921,
0.0017090699,
-0.0154198511,
-0.0346097462,
-0.0059297411,
-0.0294149593,
0.0133334594,
0.0164457653,
-0.0145205287,
0.0084149865,
0.0781213865,
0.0059893308,
-0.0095306914,
-0.0269777458,
-0.0312739871,
-0.0209723879,
-0.0112366434,
0.0074318168,
0.0017008861,
0.0110245412,
0.0274149664,
0.0147807458,
-0.0290602446,
-0.0635891333,
0.0146292672,
-0.0462276377,
-0.0057628476,
-0.0038227485,
0.0273202751,
0.0234382804,
-0.0312732011,
-0.0287560187,
-0.0014612062,
0.0102393031,
-0.0046452479,
0.0043743155,
-0.0132756522,
0.0582738481,
-0.0100042829,
0.005199316,
-0.0439353511,
0.0427705199,
-0.0342970043,
-0.0026826425,
0.0649844334,
-0.0252131131,
-0.0761250779,
0.017576037,
-0.0523943901,
0.0193847846,
0.0151881343,
-0.0057829376,
-0.0226955879,
0.0039605731,
0.0127137322,
0.0404072963,
0.0266367588,
-0.0081229815,
0.023171816,
-0.0208219849,
0.0050849412,
-0.0121094966,
-0.0051403195,
0.0235435441,
0.0062525771,
-0.0246624444,
0.0429539792,
0.0181210861,
0.0238109473,
-0.0025578444,
0.0120814415,
0.0221243519,
-0.0513965935,
-0.0112113506,
0.0174643099,
-0.0067912624,
-0.013179129,
0.0624637306,
-0.0326632932,
-0.0107919071,
0.0701057911,
-0.0292938985,
0.0316471905,
-0.0269790553,
0.0090330942,
0.0041583721,
0.0157359112,
0.0005875205,
0.0289996695,
0.0029254407,
0.003554736,
0.0097450931,
-0.0360821374,
0.0754194036,
-0.0239453856,
0.03179124,
-0.0721347556,
0.0301049482,
0.0298232585,
-0.0253160428,
-0.0214364063,
-0.0884490609,
-0.0077359849,
-0.0601119362,
-0.0376096554,
-0.0123621682,
-0.0783002898,
-0.056220144,
0.0595546961,
0.0403420776,
0.0205836091,
-0.0222983137,
0.0182150304,
-0.0088714249,
0.016083315,
-0.0161018241,
0.0459704772,
-0.0187036414,
0.007094434,
0.1016612127,
-0.0561280176,
0.0135299945,
0.009354637,
-0.0505266301,
-0.0268089157,
-0.0297336299,
-0.0115988217,
-0.030069584,
0.0563068241,
-0.0505108014,
-0.0114241838,
0.0771990567,
0.0346411988,
-0.0014889478,
0.00163584,
-0.0416970178,
-0.0408689417,
0.0188638065,
0.0085223624,
-0.0785797387,
0.0198974945,
0.0059232539,
0.0083592078,
-0.0342259109,
-0.0272247549,
0.0139856366,
-0.1175700799,
0.06325344,
0.0302193668,
0.0228250343,
-0.0350592211,
-0.0466183648,
0.0308034942,
-0.0091803204,
-0.0009325898,
0.0505811498,
-0.0024904092,
-0.0076921191,
-0.0098701827,
-0.0534037575,
-0.0426519401,
0.0203624722,
-0.0303456821,
0.0493637435,
0.0149477748,
0.0364475921,
-0.0134278676,
-0.0272299498,
-0.0236784834,
0.0192906745,
-0.0523460731,
0.0104477433,
0.0652770624,
-0.0072915782,
0.0086717866,
-0.0418319702,
0.0163036436,
0.0155029539,
-0.0406966917,
0.0133200102,
0.0811305046,
-0.0009569051,
-0.0256941691,
0.0185231958,
0.0083357235,
0.0207174271,
0.0507031307,
-0.0124954404,
0.0484211892,
-0.0232699271,
-0.0517479777,
-0.0464490838,
-0.0245441105,
-0.0574729964,
0.0616015084,
-0.0154577838,
-0.0715493411,
-0.0988009125,
-0.0246501677,
0.0089350156,
-0.0026746977,
0.0069834185,
-0.0208023116,
0.0549354441,
0.0037275287,
-0.0206189118,
-0.0099131586,
-0.0120363655,
0.040165253,
0.0008725207,
0.013073368,
-0.0103424797,
0.0082771648,
0.0076339529,
0.0208583213,
-0.0115688723,
-0.0541177653,
0.0323997997,
0.0019924371,
0.0154904965,
0.0376493968,
-0.0542109273,
-0.000730003,
0.0336638354,
0.0566078015,
-0.0454771183,
0.0346466415,
-0.0155780502,
-0.0281848721,
0.0011186277,
-0.0031910921,
-0.028748814,
0.0225821845,
-0.0424599051,
0.0146834617,
-0.0457054041,
-0.0316173807,
0.042710498,
0.0541104414,
0.0458159298,
-0.0053634327,
0.0278740432,
-0.0575739518,
-0.0248096902,
-0.0506014936,
-0.0551799424,
0.0212910119,
0.079910256,
-0.0066651576,
-0.0053766863,
-0.0168744512,
-0.0178916976,
-0.0352362059,
0.00279413,
-0.0137729757,
-0.0046650963,
0.0162163191,
0.0575838424,
0.005837772,
-0.0559494868,
-0.0286991373,
-0.0214783251,
-0.0138074318,
0.0544500574,
0.0012362226,
0.0029822774,
0.0184351131,
-0.0119359419,
-0.0159726758,
-0.0499501452,
-0.0466676354,
0.004393897,
-0.055439014,
0.0038839791,
0.0379533544,
0.0106051266,
0.0679046288,
-0.0452387407,
-0.0476871915,
-0.0001030807,
-0.0098150335,
-0.0022326184,
-0.0179402921,
-0.0022493696,
-0.0080922171,
-0.048326157,
-0.0006511638,
0.0176216662,
-0.0258453507,
0.0652158782,
0.0175517071,
-0.0815373436,
-0.0343448073,
-0.0582527779,
-0.0713178068,
-0.026790604,
-0.0076186717,
-0.0162026919,
-0.0658988357,
-0.0432862826,
0.0181649495,
0.0674971566,
0.0203507263,
0.0143082328,
-0.0488429591,
0.0621109456,
0.0511705615,
-0.0029589203,
-0.0799771622,
0.0496722981,
0.003040144,
0.0014001015,
0.0041181063,
-6.010772446e-33,
-0.0429223701,
-0.0481585488,
-0.0066379276,
0.017440116,
-0.0247160085,
0.0229015816,
-0.0251859408,
-0.0173491873,
-0.0095592318,
0.09580639,
0.0219232645,
0.0493914858,
0.0097605409,
-0.0348281078,
0.0275789034,
0.0267587975,
0.0502535403,
0.0221741069,
-0.0243270453,
-0.0251300074,
0.0640933067,
-0.0121388547,
0.0576150492,
-0.0864043832,
0.0774196535,
0.0172822326,
-0.0580403544,
0.028107604,
-0.0384359397,
0.0233197473,
0.000223911,
0.0322208032,
-0.0115894973,
0.0148679465,
-0.0080076493,
-0.0160810333,
-0.0700709969,
-0.0032672442,
0.0302407667,
0.0058153328,
0.0105499327,
0.0051157465,
0.0104792845,
-0.0005118067,
-0.0141389035,
-0.0085031912,
0.0485261232,
-0.0494329967,
0.0459628664,
-0.0103528854,
-0.0548834801,
0.0403459035,
0.0228564069,
0.0237692539,
-0.0485438704,
0.0225438904,
0.0107810134,
-0.012904048,
-0.1053565964,
0.0142134186,
-0.0173540339,
-0.0019136054,
0.0143282181,
-0.0545538478,
-0.0337414257,
0.0650001392,
-0.0536032803,
-0.0019454783,
-0.0641240627,
0.0240192171,
-0.0340601504,
0.0258569904,
0.0304450728,
0.1070542559,
0.0129164467,
-0.0440503769,
-0.0728669688,
0.0132961199,
0.0295318216,
0.0232495889,
-0.0115759764,
-0.0433558226,
-0.0478113368,
-0.0075869337,
-0.0120025463,
0.0172186699,
-0.0127851376,
0.0343005657,
-0.0147777665,
0.0318340771,
0.0222761054,
0.032224156,
-0.0537381694,
-0.0184835363,
0.0193515308,
-0.0214255024,
-0.0390915945,
-0.0084298104,
-0.015043593,
-0.0099955043,
-0.0391466022,
0.0199369378,
-0.0180803314,
0.053499233,
0.0231908429,
0.0283585358,
0.0528230071,
-0.0109626045,
-0.0657729208,
0.0252492223,
0.014843463,
0.0375116765,
0.0223448593,
-0.0356951617,
0.0205488652,
-0.0004148688,
-0.0070560076,
-0.0084194485,
0.0217430945,
0.0290790591,
-0.0259749852,
-0.0010460113,
-0.0003282682,
-0.0084183663,
-0.0099662114,
-0.0059956848,
-0.017770052,
-0.0230105463,
0.0286508296,
-0.0575890504,
0.0155779161,
-0.0025692456,
2.581e-7,
0.0337867849,
0.0794516802,
-0.0018419771,
-0.011713271,
0.0056298962,
0.0389692225,
-0.0161925014,
0.0224341881,
0.0001840055,
-0.0316873975,
-0.0265539922,
0.0136221163,
0.0398259126,
0.0703651085,
-0.0315297246,
-0.0354339182,
-0.0345785469,
-0.0504578613,
-0.0534600504,
-0.0200705118,
0.0332659483,
0.0131926211,
0.0629757196,
-0.0162314847,
-0.021328602,
-0.0433108173,
0.0513701774,
0.0240812246,
-0.0514424741,
0.006841335,
0.0964814276,
-0.0135096489,
0.0282366797,
0.0072579253,
-0.0337812677,
-0.0060418472,
-0.0063665994,
0.0347051322,
0.0034009293,
0.0537465177,
-0.0548579171,
-0.0370823517,
0.0291008893,
-0.051033441,
0.0232691858,
-0.002573261,
-0.007081883,
-0.0659544021,
-0.0413873605,
0.0368787386,
0.0134197082,
-0.0135561293,
-0.0115046781,
0.0163983051,
-0.0000264083,
0.0480197594,
-0.0134739159,
-0.035577599,
-0.0005897774,
0.0313238017,
-0.0132933343,
-0.0510682799,
0.0651018545,
0.0099924151,
-0.0115772383,
-0.0770586506,
0.0456134267,
2.051771666e-34,
0.0435808748,
0.0036561268,
0.0013598811,
-0.028357273,
0.0824006572,
0.0389075354,
0.0184005387,
-0.0162783824,
-0.0106814438,
-0.0384118408,
-0.0020781076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17086v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17086v2 | Transformers Learn Higher-Order Optimization Methods for In-Context Learning: A Study with Linear Models | 2023-10-26T01:08:47 | 2024-05-31T20:37:54 | Deqing Fu, Tian-Qi Chen, Robin Jia, Vatsal Sharan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Transformers excel at in-context learning (ICL) -- learning from
demonstrations without parameter updates -- but how they do so remains a
mystery. Recent work suggests that Transformers may internally run Gradient
Descent (GD), a first-order optimization method, to perform ICL. In this paper,
we instead demonstrate that Transformers learn to approximate higher-order
optimization methods for ICL. For in-context linear regression, Transformers
share a similar convergence rate as Iterative Newton's Method; both are
exponentially faster than GD. Empirically, predictions from successive
Transformer layers closely match different iterations of Newton's Method
linearly, with each middle layer roughly computing 3 iterations; thus,
Transformers and Newton's method converge at roughly the same rate. In
contrast, Gradient Descent converges exponentially more slowly. We also show
that Transformers can learn in-context on ill-conditioned data, a setting where
Gradient Descent struggles but Iterative Newton succeeds. Finally, to
corroborate our empirical findings, we prove that Transformers can implement
$k$ iterations of Newton's method with $k + \mathcal{O}(1)$ layers. | [
-0.0254510362,
0.0925190747,
0.0048706192,
0.0215816069,
0.0258275736,
-0.003424735,
0.036912024,
0.0083081685,
-0.0437551364,
0.0149012757,
-0.0244945474,
0.0245860536,
0.0336469896,
-0.0507301241,
0.020494543,
-0.0409124121,
-0.013011341,
0.0077708447,
-0.0744147226,
-0.0239641294,
-0.0183137991,
-0.0339412838,
0.0073263096,
0.0321332924,
-0.0384113938,
-0.0051933825,
-0.0203298051,
0.0017071149,
0.0415618345,
0.0047720429,
0.0447917953,
-0.0082374634,
0.0295660309,
0.0781726763,
0.0000021455,
0.0084652323,
0.0122235855,
-0.0027429389,
-0.014389934,
0.006823774,
0.0000584613,
-0.033411786,
0.0023808267,
0.0220875442,
-0.0447702818,
-0.0330952816,
0.0309120212,
0.0377387479,
0.0540469326,
0.0511130169,
0.0046530673,
-0.0144087831,
0.0012950088,
-0.0329585411,
-0.0385101102,
-0.0035205265,
-0.0144831091,
-0.0506227612,
-0.0578917451,
-0.0169731304,
-0.0073354328,
0.0260361359,
0.0549423136,
0.0202668738,
-0.0094376085,
0.0570799969,
0.0087940227,
-0.0125881983,
-0.0340151414,
0.0130785583,
-0.0519630834,
-0.0043991646,
-0.0125087677,
0.0134739038,
0.0115823932,
-0.007627856,
-0.0188540816,
0.0236145537,
-0.0020206547,
0.012483472,
-0.0940608755,
0.0012340844,
0.0286564175,
-0.0049546533,
-0.0238025133,
0.0620439872,
-0.0161266867,
-0.0010750542,
0.0263834056,
0.0113907494,
0.0239369851,
-0.0194480475,
-0.014294778,
0.0243497249,
-0.0511145927,
-0.0110389329,
-0.0132252369,
-0.0332257822,
-0.0335234143,
-0.0065068756,
0.0836710408,
0.0114563061,
0.0123027349,
0.003351649,
-0.0310983248,
0.0608666278,
-0.0610146336,
0.0496458113,
-0.0131981708,
0.047588136,
-0.0236703083,
0.01035982,
-0.0246761329,
0.0399079546,
-0.0190853011,
-0.0045121699,
-0.0474675223,
0.0157390684,
-0.0000219857,
-0.0206628516,
-0.0037220982,
0.0429539643,
-0.0506703407,
0.005714999,
-0.0217434876,
0.0076339007,
0.0014463437,
0.0369792879,
0.0247945134,
-0.0165509004,
-0.0303782094,
-0.0322777927,
0.0063909804,
0.0381049775,
0.0206808187,
0.0682795271,
-0.0155291203,
0.0102762943,
-0.0164559409,
0.002330537,
0.0476402082,
-0.0237368066,
0.042703554,
-0.0507446341,
-0.0113630993,
0.0166243743,
0.0277135856,
-0.0555490665,
0.0087551409,
0.0097342255,
0.0260736383,
0.0787669271,
0.0212102532,
-0.0086903879,
0.0456465371,
-0.0019555299,
-0.0577580109,
0.0426627137,
-0.0060633034,
0.0203808825,
-0.0362199321,
-0.0198709611,
0.0385812931,
0.0517523587,
0.0238215607,
-0.0067673335,
-0.0086258966,
-0.0452578403,
-0.0404122509,
0.0480719842,
0.0020173762,
-0.0024087769,
-0.042451892,
0.0128611401,
0.0410261489,
0.0209074356,
0.052974496,
0.0486820042,
-0.0093726963,
0.0117828753,
0.0218543187,
-0.0104968054,
-0.073056303,
0.0373721756,
0.0009326366,
-0.0130569628,
-0.072666496,
0.0231333598,
-0.0365366228,
-0.0546645746,
0.0290187318,
-0.0333717838,
-0.0145925209,
0.0178503245,
0.0307431277,
0.0412813164,
-0.0633584484,
0.0518430546,
0.0141956769,
-0.0338161178,
-0.0442421176,
-0.0620266423,
-0.0287694577,
-0.0370175764,
-0.0239012633,
-0.0321053602,
-0.0222930163,
-0.0315152816,
0.0351779461,
0.0163163058,
-0.0402494967,
0.001917675,
0.0442437194,
0.0059454893,
-0.0419804715,
0.0101442076,
0.0062189926,
0.0080833221,
0.0311070662,
-0.0309155416,
-0.0005336782,
-0.0156350452,
0.0142391166,
0.0342381671,
-0.0889087096,
-0.0100205643,
0.0417657942,
0.0024875675,
0.0159650967,
-0.0191100221,
-0.0039299121,
-0.0344732739,
0.0256924964,
-0.0221343618,
-0.0371649452,
0.0296266247,
-0.0407707579,
-0.0203472544,
0.0148619637,
-0.0572265871,
0.0047005732,
0.077880919,
-0.0220810566,
-0.0061917109,
0.005770287,
-0.0201452393,
0.0742855817,
-0.0159215219,
-0.0046909358,
-0.0229407176,
0.0142400665,
-0.0154074728,
0.0201888159,
-0.0235307403,
-0.0363799594,
0.0349933468,
0.0249425471,
-0.0045340629,
0.0426033027,
0.0170579292,
-0.0109203206,
-0.0369350985,
0.0343643725,
0.0121125933,
0.0050808867,
0.0043976358,
0.0030658732,
-0.0609439686,
-0.0047535263,
-0.0605279729,
-0.0144908708,
0.0172136165,
-0.0002616769,
0.0207303669,
-0.0011458065,
0.0357420221,
0.0621324591,
-0.0263016857,
-0.0187667459,
0.0042055626,
0.016590016,
-0.0228071455,
0.0079826862,
-0.03005361,
0.004695917,
0.0684579834,
-0.0072989059,
0.040364638,
-0.0587700531,
-0.0094128009,
0.038092576,
0.0033724152,
-0.0134107713,
-0.0132424086,
-0.009711463,
-0.0114303725,
-0.0292773154,
0.1077810973,
0.0300549325,
0.0547754206,
-0.0043405639,
0.0403512083,
-0.0452402458,
0.0050239861,
-0.0437935218,
-0.0438401103,
-0.062604323,
0.0207244642,
0.0265120286,
0.052314695,
-0.0341503695,
0.0103623848,
-0.0238417722,
0.0279464535,
0.0088471696,
-0.0548953451,
-0.0269111693,
0.0121997437,
-0.040260464,
0.0074405195,
0.0201683994,
-0.0271855537,
0.0509912223,
0.0256586615,
0.0144975502,
-0.0036825354,
-0.0113147534,
-0.0047802627,
-0.0126960566,
0.0054756082,
0.0227219835,
-0.0077519002,
-0.030179318,
-0.0125473794,
0.0433186144,
0.0429976732,
-0.0168396868,
0.0655566752,
-0.0288579594,
-0.0326521508,
-0.0048597185,
-0.0709179938,
-0.059676107,
-0.0328815542,
0.0031969363,
0.0185933001,
-0.0093054967,
-0.0608410351,
-0.0625440031,
-0.0396835245,
0.0347556956,
0.0723258033,
-0.0158692077,
-0.0619555265,
-0.0061456319,
0.021847738,
-0.0289749056,
0.0314957872,
0.0259316526,
-0.0538811795,
0.0610060468,
0.0213721357,
0.0788631141,
-0.0130519615,
-0.090471901,
-0.0040789354,
0.0162481088,
0.0019110945,
0.0106272334,
0.0525956526,
0.0218173265,
-0.0203249454,
-0.0209450647,
0.0417597666,
-0.0179858487,
-0.0891060531,
0.0010686922,
-0.01182405,
0.0270971619,
0.032038752,
0.0281071272,
-0.0229642559,
-0.0225424338,
0.0168600138,
0.0404824093,
0.0107298726,
-0.0039338884,
0.0138632879,
-0.0662804097,
0.0198208019,
-0.0188286621,
-0.0599627607,
-0.0056606373,
-0.0335103348,
-0.0113136731,
-0.0456390083,
0.0097499508,
0.0320491493,
-0.0483366698,
-0.0325413421,
0.0401170664,
-0.0024845246,
-0.0469626896,
-0.0329528786,
-0.029641252,
-0.0753384382,
0.0678455979,
-0.0164911393,
-0.0311318394,
-0.0119221676,
0.0435614139,
0.0272602495,
0.0430873856,
-0.0053815786,
0.050761316,
0.0229982361,
-0.0084240232,
-0.0111283539,
0.0930484459,
-0.0535878576,
0.0245355703,
0.0133321248,
0.0172280408,
0.0120731518,
-0.00811214,
-0.0041402169,
-0.0377766266,
0.0202176161,
-0.0386161916,
-0.0107019749,
-0.0866693035,
-0.039793741,
-0.0473603532,
0.0209956467,
0.045062948,
-0.0554419793,
0.0151929129,
0.025684217,
-0.0330401361,
-0.0261354838,
0.0089117549,
-0.0375468917,
0.0727854744,
0.0212927014,
-0.0904049501,
0.0378461219,
0.0399164669,
-0.062996462,
0.0092081279,
0.0388976298,
0.0260791238,
-0.0425718054,
0.0438990034,
0.075010471,
-0.0306734331,
-0.0269360784,
0.0030547911,
-0.098999992,
-0.0402195565,
0.0286914017,
0.0540480167,
0.0086286142,
0.0757756978,
0.0183329619,
-0.006331861,
0.0960369036,
0.0725398064,
0.0159467869,
0.0504016839,
0.0915896669,
-0.0771285072,
-0.007085768,
0.0077625816,
-0.0358592309,
0.0461458042,
0.0213914327,
-0.0207421593,
-0.0245415736,
0.0163288284,
0.0578400269,
-0.0463628061,
0.0854755715,
-0.0235473774,
-0.0007420426,
0.0168282948,
0.0440382548,
0.0480372459,
-0.0020148577,
-0.0223851968,
-0.0154847298,
0.0097788582,
0.036983408,
0.0142721049,
0.039352376,
0.1180603951,
0.01757228,
-0.0466458797,
0.0047285669,
-0.0052234563,
-0.0040205927,
0.0423898399,
0.0241285004,
0.0175790545,
0.0094781928,
0.0276021548,
0.027214922,
-0.0076475684,
0.0469955802,
0.0315442011,
0.0131135462,
-0.0561681949,
-0.0075842803,
-0.0863770619,
-0.0502972491,
-0.0532870367,
-0.0149071245,
0.037304461,
-0.0046953377,
-0.0018401262,
-0.0399521515,
-0.0055032242,
-0.0117530664,
0.0203117784,
-0.0382103249,
0.0095170457,
0.0097976523,
-0.005176459,
0.0376685373,
0.0176218655,
0.0466521569,
-0.0192181729,
0.0183208305,
-0.0399547629,
0.0356532857,
-0.031269826,
-0.0002302223,
0.0304472148,
0.0018912052,
0.0320993364,
-0.0268623829,
0.0119532458,
-0.015273354,
0.0544579998,
-0.0251321271,
0.02616027,
-0.0783619434,
0.0318507217,
0.0367967971,
0.0147921862,
-0.0124132624,
0.0191936605,
-0.0152609665,
-0.0177406762,
-0.0118299592,
-0.0047995192,
-5.772282642e-33,
0.0018757087,
-0.0205029193,
-0.0284307264,
0.0504998453,
0.000904954,
0.0168292746,
-0.0168696474,
-0.0078636585,
-0.0075128083,
0.0212086588,
-0.0416944958,
0.0202320535,
0.0097895376,
0.0317649692,
0.01946426,
-0.0160533357,
0.0495792255,
-0.0257584434,
-0.0227250941,
0.0128279794,
-0.0105135357,
0.0436870009,
0.0376818478,
-0.0385233201,
-0.0825681239,
0.0032607743,
-0.0295998994,
-0.0155216502,
-0.0475058183,
0.0248008203,
-0.0200613979,
0.0037714273,
-0.0083632637,
-0.0817673877,
-0.0151028596,
0.0156223206,
-0.0885928199,
0.0338403955,
-0.0731092468,
0.0390851684,
-0.0231823381,
0.0224387869,
0.062296886,
-0.0037727291,
-0.0872916654,
-0.0408398993,
0.0477441512,
0.0019346551,
-0.0338989161,
-0.0676610768,
-0.0375703126,
-0.0070489342,
-0.0165125616,
-0.0513069257,
0.026457008,
0.0943747088,
-0.0207652375,
0.024381984,
-0.0583433211,
0.0353014357,
-0.0261429343,
-0.0158584025,
0.0317596458,
0.0593357794,
0.0164361969,
0.0443925411,
0.0282906238,
-0.0205305777,
-0.0398196056,
-0.0780243799,
0.0285465494,
0.0535498261,
0.0031468959,
0.0257502776,
0.0379209518,
-0.0268145949,
-0.0641522259,
0.0113138929,
-0.0438081063,
0.0234640501,
0.0246481281,
-0.0203210078,
0.0220064018,
-0.0151969241,
-0.0385403931,
-0.0033889653,
0.0056601255,
0.0033630945,
0.0165964961,
0.0303133801,
-0.002557284,
0.0030271159,
0.0122238901,
-0.0566897765,
0.0304418001,
0.0468367003,
0.0024603214,
0.0401522107,
0.0136100324,
0.0004936612,
-0.0525440164,
-0.0119881388,
-0.0703557283,
0.0263266116,
0.0475238971,
-0.0119000571,
0.0336049646,
0.0686951801,
-0.04229597,
-0.0145534929,
-0.0455708727,
0.0351074822,
0.0167654715,
0.0150170568,
0.0718447939,
-0.0203993823,
-0.0038003668,
0.0307983626,
-0.0470729619,
-0.0002088685,
-0.0516667515,
0.0563262217,
-0.0095196506,
0.00402922,
-0.0161676854,
-0.02626043,
-0.0380324982,
-0.0109000811,
-0.0262556337,
-0.0844551474,
-0.0264368821,
-0.0067580645,
2.827e-7,
-0.0595366284,
0.0512494147,
0.0039671315,
-0.0146304918,
0.0339907296,
0.019834118,
-0.0161994975,
0.0226804763,
0.0083072521,
-0.0123557448,
0.0198437963,
0.0011162917,
0.0565994792,
0.0108077889,
-0.0710118338,
-0.052161362,
-0.0594200678,
0.0334106907,
-0.0081609646,
-0.0034657931,
-0.0554868504,
0.0497162007,
-0.0029967523,
-0.026868334,
0.0209793355,
0.0059548127,
0.0931199342,
-0.0192556437,
0.0530153178,
-0.006299302,
-0.0120621901,
0.0209752973,
0.0020811672,
-0.0089132246,
-0.015025869,
0.0372176133,
-0.0192608368,
0.0292050242,
0.0017773974,
-0.0230708569,
0.0177279618,
0.0714496672,
0.0241123587,
0.0018296721,
0.0124345319,
-0.076438427,
0.0012223198,
-0.052822236,
0.0092530232,
-0.0459656976,
0.0295744557,
-0.0401575193,
0.063146174,
-0.0141969183,
-0.0185331404,
0.0042039687,
-0.02670376,
-0.0630107746,
-0.0429994166,
0.0493532456,
-0.0394772962,
-0.0121523058,
-0.022644069,
-0.0074432055,
0.0411527604,
0.0372797549,
-0.0190210678,
2.11482454e-34,
0.0128530627,
-0.0197648853,
0.0240507033,
0.0495916195,
-0.0136143966,
-0.0371234827,
0.0707172304,
0.0135722887,
0.0598096214,
-0.0313846618,
0.0128570395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17064v1 | math-PVS: A Large Language Model Framework to Map Scientific Publications to PVS Theories | 2023-10-25T23:54:04 | 2023-10-25T23:54:04 | Hassen Saidi, Susmit Jha, Tuhin Sahai | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO | As artificial intelligence (AI) gains greater adoption in a wide variety of
applications, it has immense potential to contribute to mathematical discovery,
by guiding conjecture generation, constructing counterexamples, assisting in
formalizing mathematics, and discovering connections between different
mathematical areas, to name a few.
While prior work has leveraged computers for exhaustive mathematical proof
search, recent efforts based on large language models (LLMs) aspire to position
computing platforms as co-contributors in the mathematical research process.
Despite their current limitations in logic and mathematical tasks, there is
growing interest in melding theorem proving systems with foundation models.
This work investigates the applicability of LLMs in formalizing advanced
mathematical concepts and proposes a framework that can critically review and
check mathematical reasoning in research papers. Given the noted reasoning
shortcomings of LLMs, our approach synergizes the capabilities of proof
assistants, specifically PVS, with LLMs, enabling a bridge between textual
descriptions in academic papers and formal specifications in PVS. By harnessing
the PVS environment, coupled with data ingestion and conversion mechanisms, we
envision an automated process, called \emph{math-PVS}, to extract and formalize
mathematical theorems from research papers, offering an innovative tool for
academic review and discovery. | [
-0.0124309296,
0.1087732911,
-0.0106185228,
0.038885083,
-0.0531267636,
-0.0047250031,
-0.0048109461,
-0.0278474949,
-0.0301381778,
-0.0185443945,
0.0122375209,
0.0195413046,
-0.0045519718,
0.0549758486,
0.022030184,
-0.0352166407,
0.0228025541,
-0.0415502116,
0.0427748375,
-0.0107818507,
-0.0290823337,
-0.0087029878,
0.0024876914,
-0.0230159275,
-0.0010123994,
-0.0427028798,
0.0192768089,
-0.0524172708,
-0.0183324497,
-0.0304751806,
-0.0847312585,
0.0191346128,
0.0079000564,
0.0777457207,
0.0000018316,
-0.0699067861,
-0.0469175391,
0.0757459849,
-0.0274702962,
0.0268548634,
-0.0228880495,
-0.0393084697,
0.0022130781,
-0.009614571,
-0.0442324504,
-0.0150071969,
0.0305820853,
-0.0039636297,
0.0396262519,
0.04481842,
-0.0081042899,
-0.0691689253,
0.0796024799,
0.0236114617,
0.0357942656,
-0.0517770536,
0.0225470457,
0.0152266044,
0.0652967542,
0.0119163021,
0.0340288691,
0.0586748905,
0.0315256193,
-0.0688927025,
-0.002773531,
-0.0094502512,
-0.0344421007,
0.0044633411,
0.0102367131,
0.018015027,
0.0472416729,
-0.0574571081,
0.0197174419,
0.0445187539,
-0.0312693045,
0.0627597049,
-0.0555453561,
0.0531249233,
-0.0234629512,
-0.0317632556,
0.0394909456,
-0.0367120653,
0.0633106306,
0.0178689864,
-0.0455880575,
0.1258884668,
0.0328722075,
-0.0674960315,
-0.0301172063,
0.0050885351,
-0.0652159303,
-0.0672166124,
0.0358642824,
0.042914331,
0.0277413819,
0.0031943009,
0.009337672,
-0.0487389266,
-0.011595876,
-0.0005220922,
0.0189672429,
0.0129049877,
0.0272536371,
0.0344107375,
-0.0015058359,
-0.0182471164,
-0.0512447767,
0.031442713,
-0.0073824809,
-0.0054244301,
-0.0308253765,
-0.0284137763,
-0.0116220964,
0.0309612881,
0.0248142127,
0.0232534055,
-0.0073280209,
0.0294319633,
-0.055989325,
0.0621608905,
-0.0392842852,
-0.0614225008,
-0.0082189469,
-0.0336512886,
-0.007393552,
0.004923048,
0.0033065456,
0.0105455024,
-0.0388025381,
-0.0210280381,
-0.0189161804,
0.0285886191,
0.0005325822,
0.0047056307,
0.0412417538,
0.0536795035,
0.0639639273,
0.0257491451,
0.0206354726,
-0.0254045557,
0.0184290763,
-0.0493611395,
-0.0073999343,
-0.07431674,
0.0352825187,
0.0227794666,
-0.0385320149,
-0.0248859916,
-0.0319730416,
0.0238443445,
0.0476259999,
0.0668080077,
-0.0466345064,
0.0179284979,
0.0282926355,
-0.0195216425,
-0.0393060669,
-0.036493171,
0.027212631,
-0.0264172498,
0.0482011922,
-0.0132872043,
0.0250215307,
0.0262680855,
0.0216407776,
-0.0239224415,
-0.0337619893,
0.0472140461,
0.0273837168,
0.0277581476,
-0.0544978343,
0.0669296384,
-0.0175877903,
0.0022831103,
0.0191859771,
0.0860323459,
-0.0311869998,
0.0328894779,
0.0230900366,
-0.0087346528,
0.0615133084,
-0.0248944238,
-0.0279954839,
0.0007571256,
-0.0373637527,
0.0063356566,
-0.0084868222,
0.0214874242,
0.0147661529,
-0.0613297001,
-0.0238322951,
-0.0008439039,
-0.0590195768,
-0.0036837447,
0.086292088,
-0.0046260939,
0.0633055419,
0.0326868668,
-0.0000325785,
-0.0202558171,
0.0193626564,
-0.0221914239,
0.0594455265,
-0.0264820233,
0.0650278702,
-0.0828329772,
0.0381123237,
-0.0303750411,
0.0050479658,
0.0509188809,
0.0076027848,
-0.036217697,
-0.0829568356,
0.0186344981,
0.0260456204,
-0.0126069561,
0.0172728244,
-0.0260040313,
0.0176592413,
-0.0077132857,
0.0056274892,
-0.0359921753,
-0.0202287752,
0.0262388475,
-0.035891749,
-0.017611634,
0.0078641623,
-0.0119389333,
0.0200846605,
0.0146532143,
-0.0302238055,
0.0789918303,
0.0347484723,
-0.0368921869,
-0.0149111608,
0.0068939053,
0.0622694381,
0.0303263254,
0.0370773673,
-0.0505471528,
-0.0080055464,
-0.010710584,
-0.0226953924,
0.0079941656,
0.0454678647,
-0.04124723,
-0.0138336914,
0.0087548513,
0.0079355808,
-0.0283920038,
-0.0077315019,
0.0146565922,
0.0393557064,
0.034866415,
0.0091275536,
0.0380471721,
-0.0396193787,
0.0107246591,
0.0072290809,
-0.0196314864,
-0.0044017928,
0.015961634,
0.0081286933,
0.0278003011,
-0.0355601609,
0.0195226949,
-0.0044829044,
0.006640702,
0.0107972762,
0.0023520202,
0.0408936068,
0.0089883786,
-0.0395608731,
0.0050411574,
0.0153276166,
0.0244389549,
-0.027263809,
0.03593098,
-0.0218992792,
0.0525739826,
0.0187499169,
-0.0236147922,
-0.012915113,
-0.0101104537,
-0.0607225075,
0.0303684659,
0.0277960096,
0.029214846,
-0.0293565132,
0.0101549774,
-0.0103725102,
0.0098883985,
-0.0078281825,
0.0584606864,
0.0230206046,
-0.0409254916,
-0.0198101252,
0.0886394903,
-0.0029635774,
0.0258971546,
0.0236412771,
-0.0170593858,
0.0005567247,
-0.0147610167,
-0.0366865471,
0.0110674575,
-0.0065931976,
0.0044560819,
0.0408946425,
-0.0281939898,
-0.0373495035,
-0.0206709392,
0.0017622863,
0.0562064648,
-0.0326391086,
0.015570079,
0.0291099101,
-0.0108240144,
-0.0083756819,
0.0363249592,
0.0149566373,
-0.0511106215,
0.0234215166,
-0.0440524258,
-0.0014631279,
-0.0779152885,
-0.0138543537,
-0.0840708762,
0.0391401723,
0.0025548243,
-0.0030393053,
-0.0153100267,
0.0571358651,
0.0199512504,
-0.0161782466,
0.0257950295,
-0.0055180378,
0.0173560269,
-0.0459242538,
0.0299766716,
0.0050268257,
-0.01735829,
0.0017412371,
0.0164847244,
-0.032725051,
0.0143224616,
-0.0444469266,
-0.0503147468,
-0.0285005011,
0.013826984,
0.0580749325,
0.0097721284,
-0.0183659624,
-0.0196733605,
-0.0092340494,
-0.0455533564,
0.0095106028,
-0.0265446398,
0.0486469232,
-0.0381979197,
0.0044735107,
0.0505990647,
-0.0151135726,
0.0508174971,
-0.0070098913,
-0.0277999714,
-0.0283596944,
-0.0358113758,
-0.0097041549,
-0.0012832736,
-0.0555942729,
-0.049159646,
-0.0110529931,
0.0716567859,
0.0079535432,
-0.0412956178,
-0.0035589118,
-0.0479935221,
-0.0119028725,
0.000068574,
0.0328956805,
-0.0978853032,
0.0409807041,
0.0126881143,
0.0006150037,
0.0078976359,
-0.0130581362,
-0.0211830866,
-0.0877620876,
0.0600209124,
0.0215336643,
-0.0001894545,
0.0153898168,
-0.0675943196,
0.0350287855,
-0.0011189362,
-0.0380549319,
0.0015225603,
0.0001769031,
0.0311048273,
-0.0040260404,
-0.0050334958,
-0.0762380585,
-0.0070975525,
-0.0438214391,
-0.0242045205,
-0.0153010366,
0.0584601387,
-0.0633584037,
-0.0605803393,
-0.0384291746,
0.0762132928,
-0.0523065031,
0.0041835946,
-0.0245930348,
-0.0052956142,
0.0257282592,
-0.0145403966,
0.0533513986,
-0.0418705307,
-0.0483468883,
0.087117292,
0.1093369648,
-0.0034896387,
-0.0251575932,
-0.0554352961,
-0.011818246,
-0.0377304479,
0.0790403113,
-0.0117867533,
0.0036563938,
-0.0255602431,
-0.0230082292,
-0.0373117179,
-0.0094322925,
-0.0547817536,
-0.0255178325,
0.0135655412,
-0.0249790605,
-0.0255152863,
0.0230185278,
-0.0091502052,
0.0375318117,
0.0360824764,
0.0106212115,
0.0382223129,
0.0001568285,
-0.0345681421,
0.0356660038,
-0.0407836512,
0.0389988199,
-0.0215024222,
0.0448747613,
0.0148033025,
-0.0040780096,
-0.035749618,
-0.008445235,
-0.0376013331,
-0.0448562279,
-0.0073956442,
0.0063057095,
0.0187033042,
0.0163066592,
-0.0051645464,
-0.022164654,
0.0313166752,
0.0503596775,
-0.0428121015,
-0.0038359954,
0.018237723,
-0.03759709,
-0.0154045634,
-0.0025815065,
0.0050354316,
0.0029505449,
-0.0253910888,
0.0158376582,
0.0027208338,
-0.0490898304,
0.0129033551,
0.0872678906,
-0.0239551999,
0.0291796681,
-0.0234313607,
0.0338367932,
-0.0011119015,
-0.0459273569,
-0.0165061764,
-0.0306907352,
0.0232096314,
-0.0153802717,
0.0034402923,
-0.0180259366,
0.0378804132,
0.025838539,
0.0128842741,
0.0191152673,
0.0696600601,
-0.0060675382,
0.0517010055,
0.0403298996,
-0.0424428806,
0.0347120501,
-0.0270176735,
-0.0571368635,
0.063625209,
-0.0457230657,
-0.0172023214,
0.0669198632,
0.0134376781,
-0.0173161402,
0.0148950629,
-0.075022541,
-0.1117323264,
0.0074350098,
0.0182355531,
0.0212429333,
0.049279172,
0.0018353148,
-0.0673124939,
-0.0410680175,
0.007157254,
0.0183433425,
0.0284708273,
-0.0018547539,
0.0077029234,
0.0261834152,
-0.0222830325,
-0.0401262976,
-0.0137624107,
-0.0359576643,
0.0333853588,
0.0092745358,
-0.0187879689,
-0.0103687951,
-0.0389664099,
-0.0518462174,
0.0115531646,
-0.0025054442,
-0.0131665962,
-0.0668769926,
-0.052683726,
0.057170637,
0.0335768424,
-0.0390379429,
0.0098590581,
-0.02128038,
0.0756215602,
0.0131363347,
-0.0301887859,
-0.0022671209,
0.0718135834,
-0.0627326071,
-0.0640824959,
0.0131691396,
-5.097109911e-33,
0.0002547627,
-0.0371651389,
0.0117456643,
0.034635894,
-0.0022160595,
-0.0227902103,
-0.0492444225,
-0.0542441607,
0.0030334049,
0.0518497229,
-0.0263814311,
0.0353288352,
-0.0089057581,
0.0005449783,
0.0164465234,
0.0464506969,
0.0330490284,
-0.0191462245,
-0.0217407774,
-0.010114898,
0.028020611,
-0.034736,
0.050680466,
-0.0546519049,
0.0289063975,
-0.0228822771,
-0.0051075374,
0.0559761859,
-0.044582583,
0.0764490962,
-0.0191576369,
-0.0085206851,
-0.0214170981,
0.0066820644,
-0.0014936281,
0.0268170219,
-0.0168957915,
0.0134777203,
0.0208916627,
-0.0022216446,
-0.0133156786,
-0.0159196239,
0.040573068,
0.005009288,
-0.0188721884,
-0.0004316832,
0.0377256013,
-0.03070358,
0.0053117564,
-0.0343512036,
-0.0521540791,
0.0346426219,
-0.0354737192,
0.0409379527,
0.0571152978,
-0.0242160354,
-0.013100245,
-0.0023803248,
-0.0062734825,
0.0319315456,
-0.0195378251,
0.00255584,
0.0018815297,
-0.0381396934,
0.0240687206,
0.0109684402,
0.0060240636,
-0.0155016165,
-0.0042957137,
0.0092546418,
0.0436246991,
0.0659848899,
0.0510542281,
0.0462272391,
0.0497670881,
0.057602331,
-0.0355960838,
0.0119554466,
-0.0165787805,
0.0397155322,
0.0604492463,
-0.0128676454,
-0.0241294634,
-0.0092276577,
-0.0462340713,
-0.01947538,
-0.022941215,
0.0029183945,
-0.0148965493,
-0.0300533082,
-0.0559280924,
0.0104872826,
0.0131501099,
-0.0655424222,
-0.0518237874,
0.039707426,
0.0128090521,
0.0012634464,
0.0103445053,
0.0224598274,
-0.0707154199,
-0.0153782833,
-0.0453750342,
0.0316004753,
0.0363909453,
0.0228048917,
0.007333247,
0.0340562873,
0.0116895186,
-0.0083911037,
0.0015116555,
-0.0264459513,
0.0258126706,
0.0414717905,
0.026380511,
0.0663559288,
0.04070995,
0.011039,
0.0155241536,
0.0406670906,
-0.0281345993,
0.0949339941,
0.025073478,
0.016801564,
0.0053699207,
-0.0304001588,
-0.0300971903,
0.0047983769,
0.0425488688,
-0.0706559941,
0.0309069231,
-0.0008935828,
2.757e-7,
0.0485413671,
0.0353211537,
0.0211760458,
0.0385293216,
0.0248942152,
0.0087614618,
-0.009860849,
-0.0282125622,
0.022426052,
-0.0099775232,
0.0116862999,
0.0498177223,
-0.0076266536,
0.0375295505,
-0.0671531633,
0.0005496851,
-0.0529509895,
-0.0357071459,
-0.0512557812,
0.0008762978,
0.0423877127,
-0.0006300378,
0.0450958237,
-0.001116346,
-0.0227750596,
-0.0486965068,
0.0350658223,
0.0240370687,
0.0188400503,
0.0665084496,
0.0113467071,
-0.0228140727,
0.0127814403,
0.008575337,
-0.0133113051,
0.0689178705,
-0.0210604537,
0.0344058909,
0.0115979295,
0.0897637904,
-0.0570953824,
-0.0591410473,
0.0145536186,
-0.0410741679,
0.0515907556,
-0.0472103134,
-0.0579028986,
-0.0786520615,
-0.0202821624,
-0.0589987189,
0.0075940532,
-0.018645104,
0.0151713453,
0.0045677782,
-0.0068688788,
0.0011971977,
0.0054257964,
-0.0663482845,
-0.0050181891,
0.0341336094,
-0.0644002706,
-0.0249200128,
-0.0194180105,
-0.0065152566,
0.0083598103,
-0.0261149593,
0.0189680066,
2.950315415e-34,
0.066804938,
-0.0167480856,
0.0157832764,
0.0173520707,
0.054481823,
0.0130737135,
-0.0201869272,
0.016537495,
-0.0041520852,
-0.0993002504,
-0.0090614595
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.