id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17054v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17054v1 | BOOST: Harnessing Black-Box Control to Boost Commonsense in LMs' Generation | 2023-10-25T23:32:12 | 2023-10-25T23:32:12 | Yufei Tian, Felix Zhang, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-3 have demonstrated a strong
capability to generate coherent and contextually relevant text. However, amidst
their successes, a crucial issue persists: their generated outputs still lack
commonsense at times. Moreover, fine-tuning the entire LLM towards more
commonsensical outputs is computationally expensive if not infeasible. In this
paper, we present a computation-efficient framework that steers a frozen
Pre-Trained Language Model (PTLM) towards more commonsensical generation (i.e.,
producing a plausible output that incorporates a list of concepts in a
meaningful way). Specifically, we first construct a reference-free evaluator
that assigns a sentence with a commonsensical score by grounding the sentence
to a dynamic commonsense knowledge base from four different relational aspects.
We then use the scorer as the oracle for commonsense knowledge, and extend the
controllable generation method called NADO to train an auxiliary head that
guides a fixed PTLM to better satisfy the oracle. We test our framework on a
series of GPT-2-, Flan-T5-, and Alpaca-based language models (LMs) on two
constrained concept-to-sentence benchmarks. Human evaluation results
demonstrate that our method consistently leads to the most commonsensical
outputs. | [
0.0501555987,
0.0443506241,
-0.00184426,
0.0194315109,
-0.0140224174,
-0.0025062207,
-0.0608784258,
0.0042906357,
-0.0065860189,
-0.0571275428,
-0.0094154188,
0.0011137517,
-0.0031255721,
0.0353433006,
0.0425847098,
-0.0525615439,
0.0389480069,
0.0002683598,
-0.0166532639,
-0.0068722963,
0.0126501089,
0.0442302413,
0.022238018,
0.0341646187,
-0.0279522035,
0.0037728709,
0.0104339868,
-0.0178706124,
0.0206094049,
0.0025017492,
-0.0014175628,
0.0569418296,
0.0094393101,
-0.0012759584,
0.0000022176,
-0.0253596846,
0.0065871025,
-0.0206529684,
0.0423061326,
0.0280878656,
0.0568639785,
-0.0190175194,
0.0041834158,
-0.0109025408,
-0.0452882536,
0.0261328053,
0.0191501714,
0.0263574291,
0.0624797679,
0.0443860814,
-0.0099584116,
-0.0196164884,
0.0077440683,
-0.01416751,
0.0255315602,
-0.0743734613,
0.0057309857,
0.0137846284,
0.001699892,
-0.0147756049,
-0.0001942297,
0.0475524813,
0.0442100242,
-0.0156363174,
0.0163924228,
0.0623515509,
-0.0538475588,
-0.0118948892,
-0.0288001318,
0.1145705357,
0.0036528653,
-0.0474668629,
0.0130127408,
-0.0086567057,
0.0153996721,
-0.0214151833,
-0.0023358145,
0.0254279096,
0.0355201066,
0.0344058126,
0.0733607709,
-0.0029470285,
0.0204428118,
0.0542664453,
-0.0104467934,
0.0303866044,
0.0063330526,
-0.0279119331,
0.0220578816,
0.044389993,
-0.0370440073,
-0.0504084192,
-0.003301512,
0.0377518609,
-0.0368285328,
0.0137652792,
-0.0612894446,
-0.0021542737,
0.0203336794,
-0.0572513565,
0.0540854968,
0.0271366145,
-0.0104688527,
0.0205900706,
-0.0320333615,
0.0216987189,
0.011136814,
0.0249227453,
-0.0375686698,
0.0120032793,
-0.0526811369,
-0.0214920193,
-0.0445183627,
0.0349512845,
-0.0587841757,
-0.0133623648,
-0.0382724442,
-0.0015045005,
0.0041586743,
0.0052113715,
-0.0092903906,
0.019283805,
-0.0377240703,
-0.0147924749,
-0.030060688,
0.0324264094,
-0.0515732355,
0.0275671165,
0.0252360757,
-0.0479539968,
-0.0130570307,
0.0173762906,
0.0026365055,
-0.0035337505,
0.0152028371,
0.0009017313,
-0.0549332649,
-0.0133212032,
-0.0484959707,
-0.0374513008,
-0.0095189307,
-0.0762197971,
-0.0317673758,
-0.0564804263,
0.0174446274,
0.0001152539,
-0.0010936545,
-0.0073205358,
0.0131033044,
0.0092286374,
-0.0233330261,
0.044573579,
-0.006334282,
-0.0032794212,
-0.0019318947,
0.021792613,
0.0362772234,
0.0774222538,
0.0218351744,
0.0076843062,
0.0072108577,
0.0083749946,
-0.0008308549,
0.0150614092,
0.045256786,
0.0105078453,
-0.0346556716,
0.0037270552,
-0.0373192802,
0.0314578004,
0.0497160628,
0.0592779145,
-0.02360815,
0.0537131354,
0.0671150684,
0.0323581807,
-0.0263891183,
0.0711626112,
0.0701389462,
0.0057684351,
-0.0112812491,
0.007317604,
-0.0455995537,
0.0294730701,
-0.0532811619,
0.0285099391,
-0.0133364564,
0.0275673568,
-0.0311075728,
-0.0229338817,
0.0173511226,
0.0061538797,
0.0079885693,
-0.037869826,
-0.0068738773,
0.0291953534,
-0.0614521466,
0.0729108751,
-0.0010222043,
-0.0759032667,
0.0365154222,
-0.032422062,
0.0308163669,
0.0622876771,
0.0472950749,
0.0271230564,
-0.0309809167,
0.0015530691,
-0.01779362,
0.1027263403,
0.0262526087,
-0.0086229676,
-0.0027957056,
-0.051574517,
-0.0057855253,
-0.0047082119,
0.0205515213,
0.0161155015,
0.0099829454,
0.0212632772,
0.0377619788,
-0.0436608009,
-0.0182249174,
0.0425604172,
-0.008057897,
-0.0042119822,
-0.019643452,
-0.0263115857,
0.0361403748,
0.0094452323,
-0.0027673624,
0.0080730729,
0.0196568202,
-0.0472608842,
-0.0374579467,
0.0609097742,
-0.0653425679,
-0.0714805797,
0.0288602021,
-0.0350630768,
-0.0206166562,
0.0285819024,
-0.0520643964,
-0.050575763,
0.0141060529,
-0.0162369963,
0.0286740474,
-0.0761397034,
-0.0164415818,
0.0189456008,
-0.0206608213,
-0.0034370688,
0.0921411887,
-0.0521125272,
0.0014892449,
0.0158810504,
-0.0041754041,
-0.0116465129,
-0.0180914085,
0.0101957507,
-0.0014111695,
0.0212595593,
0.0256984904,
0.0190894436,
0.079493165,
-0.0209859237,
-0.0265558884,
-0.0576077476,
0.002860833,
-0.0283878595,
-0.0130717782,
0.0286167022,
-0.0123102618,
0.003771842,
0.0213931073,
-0.0443685949,
0.0300323553,
0.0425869226,
-0.0169359483,
0.0355998278,
0.0299510546,
-0.0071931146,
-0.0157417729,
0.0267828293,
0.0202899091,
0.0111177489,
0.0218798555,
0.0511834882,
-0.0066979188,
0.066092968,
-0.0576287247,
-0.0104554929,
0.0033639283,
-0.0673539266,
-0.0053973254,
-0.0028498513,
0.0404991172,
0.0235257261,
0.0397621542,
0.0235468503,
0.0357909724,
-0.0081513729,
-0.0223938022,
0.0152542694,
-0.0277024973,
-0.0051752091,
-0.0242762286,
-0.0083230827,
0.0205172859,
0.0336875059,
0.0102677643,
0.0034140928,
-0.0934018046,
0.0247900747,
-0.000650126,
-0.0467129201,
-0.073166132,
0.0357730091,
-0.0272157025,
0.0117739635,
-0.0441257618,
-0.0229612011,
0.0645752773,
-0.0261426847,
0.014610487,
-0.0355612487,
0.0231346544,
-0.0097825201,
0.0473925024,
-0.001618519,
0.0226195753,
-0.0226896349,
0.0113492757,
-0.0544568375,
-0.0143179335,
0.0066340757,
-0.032219965,
0.0598707385,
-0.0437107943,
0.0274599679,
-0.0123232193,
-0.0458490886,
-0.0386250876,
-0.0308893677,
-0.0127586741,
0.0213012192,
0.0480105281,
-0.0117858844,
-0.0094576273,
-0.0029877846,
0.0172705967,
0.0695896745,
0.0001446048,
-0.0043029445,
-0.0255545788,
0.0178892501,
0.057302665,
0.026589442,
-0.004446873,
-0.0141904522,
0.0046756477,
0.0471044071,
0.0103232004,
-0.0258694887,
0.0165801067,
0.0290785171,
0.0099348836,
-0.0184066966,
-0.0336513259,
0.0437846482,
0.0486028455,
-0.0451695137,
-0.0586776659,
0.1116620302,
0.0319917537,
0.0122325746,
-0.0058432883,
0.0178977456,
0.0426394641,
-0.0027493231,
0.0211824179,
-0.0887703151,
-0.0481428839,
-0.0100200167,
0.0211014319,
-0.0163153466,
-0.0401475318,
-0.0202385653,
-0.1202823594,
0.0224417187,
0.0279861819,
-0.1066657156,
-0.0302976463,
0.0056835264,
-0.0537070334,
-0.014716764,
-0.0290086567,
0.0426856764,
-0.0020991971,
0.0200410075,
-0.0050644823,
0.0012394623,
-0.0545472018,
0.0170993526,
-0.0136638694,
0.0363549851,
0.0916719362,
0.0572562106,
-0.0169974957,
-0.0834479928,
-0.0126335099,
-0.0882960856,
0.0024182517,
-0.0095468927,
-0.0211489554,
-0.0362773091,
-0.0007355026,
-0.0197281893,
0.062482737,
-0.0543184094,
-0.0020319885,
-0.0019757871,
0.0509081595,
-0.0063459328,
-0.0215847939,
-0.0116966786,
0.025071837,
0.0313741416,
0.1208590344,
0.0504680648,
-0.0081780273,
-0.0445905998,
-0.0181542039,
-0.0192265101,
-0.080923453,
-0.0110683674,
-0.0180305522,
-0.0063625793,
0.0148890177,
-0.0929259583,
-0.0155400755,
0.0215671323,
0.0396664143,
-0.0059562372,
0.0275635496,
-0.0120314006,
-0.0132707767,
-0.0346322395,
0.0323855802,
-0.0435428657,
-0.0377328582,
-0.0575779341,
-0.0387690291,
0.0273007359,
-0.0372214615,
-0.028918799,
0.0802177042,
0.0055370918,
-0.0607909858,
-0.0155893154,
0.0719980523,
0.0192822795,
0.0237027165,
0.0108489208,
-0.0096082343,
0.0826983899,
0.0935627595,
-0.0340356417,
0.0409614407,
0.0071294047,
0.0008491749,
0.0084279478,
0.0514266007,
-0.0265945923,
0.0445658639,
-0.002064008,
0.0737285838,
-0.0021551205,
-0.0076790745,
0.0175104514,
0.0219415165,
-0.0194158945,
-0.0636667535,
0.0203674715,
-0.0357139632,
-0.0366170816,
-0.0373154804,
-0.0351845957,
-0.0784321576,
0.0216144249,
0.0231387373,
0.0056432728,
-0.0109507246,
0.0169581231,
-0.0371180736,
0.0570385382,
-0.0166250709,
-0.0443373993,
0.0191619638,
0.0317326188,
0.0178520046,
-0.0279037822,
-0.0278311037,
-0.0120382477,
-0.0363450199,
0.0290304422,
-0.0212757457,
0.083019048,
0.0338927209,
-0.0156461261,
-0.0095200315,
0.0364359058,
-0.0387515463,
0.0341299027,
-0.0530930571,
0.0607943758,
0.0673331842,
0.0112021612,
0.0708281547,
-0.0747604072,
-0.0221713297,
-0.0064264331,
0.0721784011,
0.0198144615,
-0.0549872257,
0.0222852081,
0.0128938155,
-0.0223917291,
-0.0278169699,
0.0744999945,
-0.0251023564,
0.0342529155,
0.0092770411,
-0.0007498168,
-0.0457728468,
-0.0218897462,
-0.0054347999,
0.0174492337,
0.0167067498,
0.0318230577,
-0.0752484649,
-0.0643502772,
0.0191684905,
0.0330378935,
0.0217838008,
-0.0268789399,
0.0585556664,
0.0552473292,
-0.0047427779,
-0.0273114964,
-0.0342882685,
0.0169810075,
-0.0584965385,
-0.0067583108,
-0.0366259217,
-7.031550802e-33,
-0.0767368004,
-0.0377013274,
0.0163957831,
-0.0190300811,
-0.0479264185,
0.0165307932,
-0.0494555719,
-0.0117578954,
0.033359386,
0.026163375,
0.0012698108,
0.0050599654,
-0.0043033585,
0.030794559,
-0.0220978986,
-0.0012357028,
0.0487771779,
0.0008432666,
-0.0448418856,
0.0398362987,
0.063369967,
0.0182031505,
0.0208792854,
0.0346969105,
0.0002919532,
-0.0348876715,
-0.0324795172,
-0.0078694411,
-0.0078606615,
0.0151508963,
-0.0285766702,
0.0485766977,
0.0232971851,
-0.0346066952,
-0.0176504925,
0.0146024963,
-0.064584963,
-0.0390396565,
0.0439211428,
-0.042031914,
-0.0159574579,
-0.0191774201,
0.0492358357,
-0.0038369822,
-0.0230211038,
0.0213295855,
0.0043876255,
-0.0316782258,
0.0160463862,
-0.053900864,
-0.0609366186,
0.0061025112,
-0.0069150273,
-0.0226528142,
-0.0318856426,
-0.0138205048,
-0.0399625637,
-0.0246063136,
-0.0421671644,
0.0202280749,
0.0568688996,
0.0197380763,
0.0511120036,
0.0082672536,
0.0123657975,
0.0398437083,
-0.0547132492,
-0.026972387,
-0.0710251182,
0.0375737585,
0.0327313319,
0.0374882407,
0.0435729958,
0.0956742391,
0.0362127572,
-0.0350483693,
-0.0547010489,
0.0457898267,
-0.0198668353,
0.030979801,
0.0287162028,
-0.0339573845,
-0.0224414337,
-0.0154772382,
-0.0452427156,
-0.0420338549,
-0.0044223568,
-0.0057262522,
0.0449731201,
0.0271965843,
-0.0362086222,
-0.0334340148,
0.0244560502,
0.0081064347,
0.0301181823,
0.0189862568,
-0.0650912598,
0.0014902658,
0.0032113432,
0.010982126,
-0.0786340758,
-0.0532292239,
0.0441011526,
0.0119171077,
-0.0071173124,
0.0405764766,
0.0234808791,
0.0159624256,
-0.0255488846,
0.0187761765,
-0.0159087703,
0.03012258,
-0.03104317,
-0.0318643264,
0.0228066277,
-0.014116561,
-0.0098632984,
0.0196764767,
0.001713188,
0.0040093064,
0.0088583371,
-0.0251182988,
0.0212088004,
0.0527565032,
-0.0385452658,
0.0347000957,
-0.0174740199,
-0.066065982,
0.0477327183,
-0.0421235822,
-0.0142473048,
0.0130144563,
2.887e-7,
0.0144049246,
0.0151576595,
0.004614017,
-0.0102766156,
0.0004967818,
0.0407343917,
0.0006737207,
0.0519269966,
-0.0159805864,
-0.0314979367,
0.0113019394,
0.0290028751,
0.0366374142,
0.0150333038,
-0.06226689,
0.0195661783,
-0.0528812222,
0.001409889,
-0.053146407,
-0.0237721279,
0.0393297188,
0.0438039154,
0.0083397701,
-0.0191247649,
0.0142803062,
-0.0409605019,
0.0744579807,
-0.0280506443,
-0.0178309307,
-0.0057024839,
0.0511445031,
0.0383954979,
-0.0155084552,
0.0333789699,
-0.0176721923,
0.0192277879,
-0.0096942829,
0.0750385374,
0.0184046831,
-0.0216442533,
0.0122849941,
-0.021782415,
-0.0021415604,
-0.0670198426,
0.0633804426,
-0.0758972764,
-0.0129400101,
-0.0194581412,
-0.0253667179,
-0.0037997495,
0.0035703147,
-0.022757493,
-0.0270355679,
0.0091937007,
0.0212744307,
0.0091469185,
-0.0093925623,
-0.0501876473,
-0.0231225379,
0.0041743927,
-0.0123935025,
-0.037571758,
-0.0589647852,
-0.0167044811,
-0.0017266938,
-0.0859011486,
-0.0113423802,
2.863124499e-34,
0.0186539702,
-0.0350698493,
0.0130447792,
-0.0176329985,
0.0311603099,
0.0235469136,
-0.0009565169,
0.0043854117,
0.0230375417,
-0.0496211052,
0.0079022255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17041v1 | On Surgical Fine-tuning for Language Encoders | 2023-10-25T22:42:30 | 2023-10-25T22:42:30 | Abhilasha Lodha, Gayatri Belapurkar, Saloni Chalkapurkar, Yuanming Tao, Reshmi Ghosh, Samyadeep Basu, Dmitrii Petrov, Soundararajan Srinivasan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Fine-tuning all the layers of a pre-trained neural language encoder (either
using all the parameters or using parameter-efficient methods) is often the
de-facto way of adapting it to a new task. We show evidence that for different
downstream language tasks, fine-tuning only a subset of layers is sufficient to
obtain performance that is close to and often better than fine-tuning all the
layers in the language encoder. We propose an efficient metric based on the
diagonal of the Fisher information matrix (FIM score), to select the candidate
layers for selective fine-tuning. We show, empirically on GLUE and SuperGLUE
tasks and across distinct language encoders, that this metric can effectively
select layers leading to a strong downstream performance. Our work highlights
that task-specific information corresponding to a given downstream task is
often localized within a few layers, and tuning only those is sufficient for
strong performance. Additionally, we demonstrate the robustness of the FIM
score to rank layers in a manner that remains constant during the optimization
process. | [
0.009673507,
0.0655345097,
-0.0080857817,
0.0510405935,
-0.0063312766,
0.031383805,
0.0010404608,
0.018710006,
-0.0783566162,
0.0035348239,
-0.0789045542,
-0.0211833287,
0.073660858,
0.028146537,
0.0437122546,
-0.0231624823,
0.0068275654,
-0.001310745,
0.0088845044,
-0.0160602797,
-0.0400071442,
0.0064484482,
-0.0179682579,
0.0443724766,
0.0093124546,
0.0254688244,
0.0057478948,
0.022706585,
0.0130167212,
0.018285064,
0.0184918214,
0.0604174025,
0.0199851301,
-0.0039583375,
0.0000023476,
-0.0254713818,
0.0172529593,
-0.0272371303,
-0.0376769118,
0.0355873927,
0.0040226514,
-0.0715538561,
-0.0105074309,
0.0009176595,
-0.0178101696,
-0.0527493283,
0.062935926,
0.0120360125,
0.0464031249,
0.0934353247,
-0.0142416293,
-0.0589996129,
0.0212671421,
-0.044401601,
-0.0217533782,
-0.0213012081,
0.002497497,
-0.002136762,
-0.0628952459,
-0.0287322477,
-0.0359743685,
0.0399131328,
0.048357632,
0.0074084997,
0.0100395717,
0.028284559,
-0.0289733205,
-0.0417477638,
0.0297899488,
0.0785192847,
-0.1205560565,
0.027241461,
-0.0582427345,
-0.0465150103,
0.0205494948,
-0.0193475354,
-0.0335878097,
-0.0168716423,
0.0467353761,
0.0274164882,
0.003607895,
0.0087489933,
0.0369490236,
-0.0115606561,
-0.0213967394,
0.0435225777,
0.0051436154,
0.0128347855,
0.0319132134,
0.009575366,
-0.0101739727,
0.0087761478,
-0.0076233079,
0.0195537824,
-0.0207739808,
-0.0242757276,
-0.0521182269,
-0.0089005111,
-0.017508015,
-0.0665356442,
0.0699342564,
0.0382174216,
0.0178958643,
0.0207136218,
-0.0565129034,
0.0539866127,
-0.0040613562,
0.0857347026,
-0.0396524183,
-0.0364899412,
0.0135752996,
0.0138322785,
-0.010740946,
0.0025916377,
-0.0273485836,
-0.0384774543,
-0.0501131639,
0.0082549769,
0.0210690219,
-0.0181747265,
-0.0201893486,
0.0061289337,
-0.0304264147,
-0.0454016663,
-0.0009259801,
0.0176481195,
-0.0283585638,
0.0512446351,
-0.0065482417,
-0.0157121383,
-0.0414879099,
0.041722469,
0.0136014456,
-0.0324265659,
0.025665693,
0.0358633548,
-0.0256928168,
0.0026710695,
-0.0222163871,
0.0038592431,
-0.0112002427,
-0.0585735254,
0.0505983606,
-0.0113653382,
0.0607711487,
-0.0154244965,
0.0143092657,
-0.0912859291,
-0.0257670358,
-0.0371215865,
-0.0264018811,
0.0488762558,
-0.0085404208,
-0.0256370045,
-0.0001246407,
0.0050261673,
0.0241860393,
0.056473773,
0.0495500676,
0.0644902214,
0.0020513081,
-0.05510455,
0.0060649887,
0.0363150947,
0.0152835827,
-0.0010253503,
-0.0464354195,
-0.0312380102,
0.0404461846,
0.0195666403,
0.0428288244,
0.0090685263,
-0.0454745404,
-0.0192461554,
0.0521108955,
0.0093324231,
0.0637619495,
0.0271361694,
0.0261526741,
-0.005265255,
0.0223746058,
0.0195390973,
-0.0387596004,
0.0642369613,
-0.0112986686,
-0.0149696516,
0.0206791833,
0.0253270306,
-0.0600609258,
-0.0383370444,
0.0140512204,
-0.0313909762,
-0.0116721308,
0.000598564,
0.0294680241,
0.0123753259,
-0.044552315,
0.0344602317,
0.0171697382,
-0.0290077422,
0.0339128375,
-0.0488373078,
-0.0605814792,
0.0612783581,
0.0265809167,
0.0021396349,
-0.0457682386,
0.0159499105,
0.0152962096,
0.0328742005,
0.0310876593,
-0.0121226767,
0.1013974473,
-0.0734093636,
-0.0241245423,
-0.0317213014,
0.0174459387,
0.0028599508,
0.0008612233,
0.0250061359,
0.0114859883,
-0.0139416782,
-0.0185420532,
0.0359122232,
0.0016973821,
-0.021079082,
0.0441214517,
0.0070463307,
0.0304894466,
-0.0291559957,
-0.0062200893,
-0.0274789277,
0.0244689938,
-0.0674964786,
-0.004331436,
-0.0031356313,
-0.0420259349,
-0.0030902666,
-0.0064230543,
-0.010410957,
0.007285668,
0.0477620326,
-0.0539643317,
-0.0270548705,
0.0275001768,
-0.0067579467,
0.0249180216,
0.002433375,
0.0131518757,
-0.0355524644,
0.0273957588,
-0.0185723361,
0.019708015,
0.0029003981,
-0.0073997136,
-0.0161782745,
0.0179605838,
0.0009932088,
-0.0252905004,
-0.0086680194,
0.022548113,
-0.0189533755,
0.0342522562,
0.0086391279,
0.0290652178,
-0.003540349,
-0.0750677958,
-0.0192551892,
0.013076433,
-0.033747986,
0.0075349323,
0.0308899432,
0.010194364,
-0.0065334248,
-0.0100787785,
-0.0132053597,
0.0563687384,
-0.0286190696,
-0.0089841746,
0.0092207082,
0.0060074516,
0.0047110305,
-0.0466358513,
-0.0485657491,
0.0591343977,
0.0486154631,
0.0198877957,
-0.0204944611,
-0.0642266646,
0.003220082,
-0.0294555984,
-0.0321648531,
-0.0038321761,
-0.1003815904,
0.0038114057,
-0.0143307028,
-0.0121762119,
0.0956774577,
-0.0089377891,
0.0362480581,
0.0566485375,
0.014018679,
-0.0385751761,
0.0107735638,
-0.0478755534,
-0.0282562934,
-0.0624873303,
0.0048127496,
0.0043516876,
0.0282072444,
-0.0113279102,
0.0279783364,
-0.0824185461,
0.0447248593,
0.0008079591,
-0.0108266566,
-0.0208176356,
-0.0126664275,
-0.0123681864,
0.0497912243,
-0.0039195158,
-0.014335636,
0.033485841,
-0.0058609149,
0.005120249,
-0.0147945145,
-0.0237953234,
-0.0021554851,
0.0516884513,
0.0107252365,
0.02783533,
-0.0091725821,
-0.0458157584,
-0.0379260257,
0.0157691762,
-0.0005129116,
-0.0282166116,
-0.0096405698,
-0.0139858332,
-0.023904508,
-0.0299254544,
-0.0335690714,
-0.0252599716,
-0.010929076,
0.0155256856,
0.0232338924,
0.0375802815,
-0.0186029002,
-0.0507852137,
-0.0172830056,
0.000169769,
0.0426692255,
-0.0317097008,
0.023718575,
-0.0317722075,
-0.0012235619,
-0.0030632911,
0.0514347665,
-0.0084530609,
-0.0156773627,
0.0083202692,
-0.0188875403,
-0.0335417315,
0.0277096853,
-0.0327128023,
0.0139402281,
0.0490367748,
0.0271241553,
0.0003953332,
-0.0011441648,
0.0675993785,
-0.0502140038,
-0.0002804116,
0.1230297387,
0.012026269,
-0.0581026711,
-0.0004781719,
0.0534689277,
0.0361418426,
0.009358014,
0.0087214243,
-0.0339939594,
-0.035117764,
0.0026707686,
0.023862293,
0.0443016328,
0.0090585286,
0.0032901287,
-0.0791400596,
0.0306553971,
0.0318953283,
-0.0362982303,
-0.1110391766,
-0.0374337696,
-0.0043428433,
-0.0347664021,
0.0542910472,
-0.0084494464,
0.0161959454,
-0.0148577131,
-0.0043783835,
0.0100985914,
-0.1229214221,
0.012030744,
-0.0142992828,
0.0279073026,
0.0549225099,
0.0037653907,
-0.0243510734,
-0.0359543264,
0.0729024187,
-0.031822212,
0.0036561892,
-0.0324120857,
0.098848708,
0.0271422639,
-0.0226619281,
0.0210096613,
-0.0012077744,
-0.0294723902,
0.0151654314,
-0.0346611291,
-0.0020367487,
-0.0367310643,
0.0035229272,
0.0497145131,
-0.0135887573,
-0.0236258078,
0.0567877777,
0.0655903667,
-0.0491535924,
0.0118101062,
-0.0387248583,
0.0104656834,
-0.088204056,
-0.0365132056,
0.040272411,
0.0287578888,
-0.0293881651,
-0.044566717,
-0.0215587039,
0.0324444845,
0.0147891501,
-0.0075426977,
-0.0349811241,
-0.0034836694,
-0.0053860615,
-0.0307034999,
0.0051841647,
-0.0110725481,
-0.0209122337,
-0.0357121304,
0.0001124477,
0.0465440787,
0.0162214208,
-0.0147813158,
-0.004159933,
-0.0333046578,
-0.0671985522,
-0.0076860911,
0.0512371212,
0.0178773776,
0.0666085258,
-0.0477401353,
-0.0783997998,
0.0327185355,
0.0243268888,
-0.0294658281,
0.0346154571,
0.055452887,
-0.1073292643,
-0.0156761501,
0.0461173654,
-0.0602683388,
0.0225554202,
0.0232601482,
0.0099824546,
0.0262193214,
-0.0530165285,
0.0127056399,
-0.004697348,
0.0540694706,
-0.0171211306,
-0.0174808763,
-0.029990159,
0.0198554732,
0.0061604078,
0.0204110872,
-0.0276719499,
-0.0477944277,
0.0611459203,
0.014348845,
-0.0027684001,
0.0336679853,
0.0235682055,
0.0084701367,
-0.0397388786,
0.0175686479,
-0.0257284194,
-0.0024630751,
0.0236864369,
0.0420549624,
-0.0365586393,
0.0685353726,
0.0258193649,
0.0244185738,
-0.0269662477,
0.000316323,
0.0149511546,
0.0643426999,
-0.0504928567,
0.0612169057,
-0.0364161059,
-0.1100803912,
-0.0480676033,
-0.0390005521,
0.0447331667,
0.0014449582,
0.0493408963,
0.0252386294,
-0.0125356149,
-0.0066498001,
0.030476125,
-0.0180635378,
-0.001484829,
-0.0116813872,
-0.0050490815,
-0.0145643624,
-0.0186254308,
0.062960811,
-0.007859665,
0.0526917987,
-0.0438448936,
0.0387946963,
-0.0198001098,
-0.0224147011,
-0.0130565558,
0.0352404863,
-0.0202556737,
0.0250072684,
0.0048965504,
-0.0736313388,
-0.0244817883,
-0.0149247264,
0.0180517491,
0.0259824432,
0.0362014286,
0.0162199456,
-0.0285497177,
0.0182815921,
0.0053438288,
-0.0521079563,
0.0121812727,
-0.0169833209,
0.0129998596,
-6.91428422e-33,
-0.0499006808,
0.0462306216,
-0.0116655529,
0.0355924852,
-0.0132624302,
0.0049847239,
-0.0332027823,
-0.0002868723,
-0.0529724658,
0.0155854234,
0.0160071421,
0.0135308467,
0.0070100897,
0.0359143205,
-0.0162037909,
-0.0033100874,
0.0396005586,
-0.023910502,
-0.024364382,
0.0298697706,
-0.0066068745,
-0.009443325,
0.0669450462,
-0.0145097589,
-0.0378146917,
0.0409966484,
-0.0219990481,
0.0292361099,
0.0003355642,
0.0430044085,
-0.0059638438,
0.0328097194,
0.0078775957,
-0.0434176177,
-0.0137280161,
-0.0279752892,
-0.0703646839,
-0.0565077625,
-0.0270320959,
0.0352190733,
-0.0482135341,
-0.0394536145,
0.0948691666,
0.0006353853,
-0.0549262762,
-0.02280448,
0.0177601483,
-0.0082319956,
-0.0115510486,
-0.0240461938,
-0.0515868664,
0.0009833234,
-0.0185455382,
-0.03776557,
0.0667637587,
0.04869885,
0.0070341635,
-0.0024158419,
-0.0687982664,
-0.0128609277,
-0.0117690144,
0.0575221032,
0.010973868,
0.0267668162,
-0.0284204017,
0.0671375245,
0.0171141978,
0.0232267734,
0.0436804555,
0.0231358465,
0.0600441322,
0.0257178526,
0.0870517641,
0.0093375435,
0.0480817854,
-0.0426689088,
-0.1110500097,
0.0356029309,
-0.0217574164,
-0.0057893628,
0.0153086269,
0.0216437317,
0.0216444228,
-0.0312316753,
-0.0666671842,
-0.0224304274,
-0.0226120148,
-0.0076060435,
0.0184482262,
0.0118315453,
-0.003878148,
-0.0143540204,
0.062459223,
-0.0200095885,
0.0598952398,
0.0052380557,
-0.0278341565,
0.0247512404,
0.0188954715,
0.0129944626,
-0.0336673371,
-0.0122710373,
0.0220574494,
0.0139847081,
0.0504791029,
-0.0216495153,
0.0529955849,
0.0393814631,
-0.0384805538,
-0.0111579075,
-0.0216417015,
-0.0033467307,
0.0366861597,
0.0413280278,
0.0417342521,
-0.0002720532,
-0.0285172928,
0.0211745556,
0.0000128464,
0.0040042368,
-0.0106466608,
-0.0409530811,
0.0417600349,
0.0168092679,
-0.0261058901,
-0.0140036931,
-0.0311583951,
-0.0305704866,
0.0152866878,
-0.0621849746,
-0.0353170149,
0.0097476467,
3.041e-7,
0.0478695631,
0.0361212939,
-0.0104634827,
0.0065390682,
0.0459233671,
0.011204876,
-0.0068721822,
-0.0138863744,
0.0155636575,
-0.0269572996,
0.0095845489,
0.038419053,
0.0642715022,
0.0020848622,
-0.0795131773,
0.0027093012,
-0.0228461288,
0.0229994524,
-0.0049519246,
-0.009704195,
0.0195050742,
0.0877822638,
-0.0003569193,
-0.0228320584,
0.0180049632,
-0.0325306021,
0.0403414369,
-0.046040453,
0.0156018045,
0.030769743,
-0.0391140543,
0.0728710294,
-0.0066335266,
0.0289397482,
-0.0438494645,
0.0162615962,
-0.0097480528,
0.0658455417,
-0.0426496752,
-0.0144566325,
0.0018987083,
0.064255856,
0.0047367103,
-0.0464548171,
0.0711026713,
-0.1058817506,
-0.0551845208,
0.0039589806,
0.0121888611,
0.0257477164,
0.0664177909,
-0.0351225138,
-0.0185225867,
0.022483537,
0.0491368733,
0.0113496436,
-0.0482769422,
-0.0909439623,
-0.0145452898,
0.060974963,
-0.0202586614,
-0.0087932646,
-0.0229971949,
-0.0538143218,
0.0476664379,
-0.0199703071,
0.0214908179,
2.414896335e-34,
0.0048296144,
-0.004765973,
0.0637478903,
0.0294722952,
0.011717815,
0.0065086307,
-0.0208592489,
0.0061160964,
-0.0034277926,
-0.0508869588,
-0.0229165275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18369v1 | Apollo: Zero-shot MultiModal Reasoning with Multiple Experts | 2023-10-25T22:36:40 | 2023-10-25T22:36:40 | Daniela Ben-David, Tzuf Paz-Argaman, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, I.2.7; I.5.4 | We propose a modular framework that leverages the expertise of different
foundation models over different modalities and domains in order to perform a
single, complex, multi-modal task, without relying on prompt engineering or
otherwise tailor-made multi-modal training. Our approach enables decentralized
command execution and allows each model to both contribute and benefit from the
expertise of the other models. Our method can be extended to a variety of
foundation models (including audio and vision), above and beyond only language
models, as it does not depend on prompts. We demonstrate our approach on two
tasks. On the well-known task of stylized image captioning, our experiments
show that our approach outperforms semi-supervised state-of-the-art models,
while being zero-shot and avoiding costly training, data collection, and prompt
engineering. We further demonstrate this method on a novel task, audio-aware
image captioning, in which an image and audio are given and the task is to
generate text that describes the image within the context of the provided
audio. Our code is available on GitHub. | [
0.0101607125,
0.0757740289,
0.0093330564,
0.0326923728,
-0.0174466688,
0.0071750297,
0.0805511996,
-0.0297965612,
-0.0381919444,
-0.0765496492,
-0.0640645325,
-0.0040135616,
-0.0149751045,
0.038509015,
0.0197844245,
-0.085623838,
0.008254258,
-0.0377900526,
0.0061348891,
-0.0093847262,
0.0290506091,
0.0329622142,
-0.055874221,
0.0458599478,
-0.0423000865,
-0.0208417159,
-0.0282040667,
0.0221959911,
0.0155079663,
0.0085208071,
-0.0232977103,
0.0569974743,
0.0611550435,
0.0197165236,
0.000001824,
-0.0145574082,
0.0077241436,
-0.0043246616,
0.0142125543,
-0.0508699715,
0.0071266685,
-0.0195137803,
0.0104365181,
-0.0180933587,
-0.0348979495,
0.0026673945,
0.0705743358,
0.0441254899,
0.0991557539,
0.0500249118,
-0.0152645158,
-0.0315502398,
-0.0169412773,
-0.0133476462,
0.01328348,
-0.0137758208,
-0.015572303,
0.0518738069,
0.0558563545,
0.0040144278,
-0.0293583926,
0.0345845558,
0.0286765788,
-0.0182554405,
0.0057464349,
0.0428736545,
0.0060163909,
-0.0402691215,
-0.018534882,
0.0823672861,
0.010200304,
0.0318256877,
-0.0032788266,
0.0180871971,
-0.0119916322,
0.0099129016,
-0.0594853386,
0.0532777868,
-0.0102024367,
-0.0168421641,
-0.0693056211,
0.0133881234,
0.0136121176,
0.0141572552,
-0.004819057,
0.0217254926,
-0.0039509265,
0.0388500988,
-0.0111490572,
0.0099110194,
-0.062199425,
-0.0715648383,
-0.0066645583,
0.034902215,
-0.0379273705,
-0.0132890996,
-0.0429954045,
-0.0244759042,
-0.0086904392,
0.0344779305,
0.038939707,
0.0076656351,
-0.0414766148,
0.092137143,
-0.0250285473,
-0.0140708983,
-0.0325118303,
0.0388217755,
0.0083375201,
-0.0158188622,
-0.1256784797,
-0.0353837535,
-0.0152666001,
0.0092575429,
-0.0497219712,
-0.0509557873,
0.0087370155,
0.011566788,
-0.0567385592,
0.0142153883,
-0.0154373618,
0.0570015758,
-0.027007848,
-0.0218023472,
-0.000535738,
0.0567699671,
-0.0560451858,
0.0385714248,
0.0124481739,
-0.0373743959,
-0.0195171405,
0.0386926644,
0.00005374,
-0.0100401016,
-0.0098633692,
0.07566607,
-0.0473034009,
0.0084218755,
-0.0083277049,
-0.0804606304,
-0.0129472418,
-0.0726647004,
0.0172696598,
-0.0678285062,
0.0119734425,
-0.024227092,
-0.0006195427,
-0.0305219945,
-0.0063744863,
0.014310631,
0.0101351328,
0.1238263026,
-0.023584405,
0.0000880582,
0.0326544382,
0.0455360189,
-0.0562370382,
0.083237201,
0.0268919803,
0.0246898476,
0.0074875401,
0.0180822685,
0.0143975187,
0.0112157166,
0.0010317808,
0.0060051535,
-0.0321468972,
-0.024425799,
-0.0280350894,
0.0420168526,
0.035183955,
0.009601282,
-0.0370403379,
-0.0159919839,
0.0653367415,
0.022290919,
-0.0057675308,
-0.0146562411,
0.0707286969,
-0.0040265839,
-0.0047591617,
0.0068082749,
-0.057676591,
0.0910219997,
0.0076453951,
0.0117215468,
0.0042765886,
0.0079312129,
-0.0283559877,
-0.0218165815,
0.0027167944,
-0.0156085659,
-0.0106095308,
0.0079251472,
0.0385402068,
0.0355600342,
-0.0282001253,
0.0141727766,
-0.0117580965,
-0.0330286548,
-0.0167203322,
-0.0093967663,
0.0087879421,
0.0423288792,
0.0220745802,
-0.0211260449,
-0.0340170264,
-0.0360979997,
0.0724263862,
0.0489735305,
-0.0061634434,
-0.0185810048,
0.0173890311,
-0.0515793413,
-0.0588022955,
-0.0621869825,
0.0067116953,
0.0362886451,
0.002730513,
-0.0260608681,
0.0203207899,
0.0030103968,
0.0426918529,
0.0052810358,
0.022231875,
-0.0004111687,
-0.030336393,
0.0439005904,
0.0042938669,
0.0194875915,
-0.0267385412,
0.0112256622,
-0.0238696523,
-0.0197636727,
-0.041695144,
0.0215709526,
-0.0512853675,
-0.0330215394,
0.0185115337,
-0.062942937,
-0.0042593461,
-0.0012085299,
-0.0388102457,
-0.0387789272,
0.0398238599,
0.0045833304,
-0.0248895884,
-0.0341920853,
-0.0478263125,
0.0417596512,
0.0070992038,
0.0134250578,
0.025702564,
0.0049682781,
-0.0351449028,
0.0353987999,
0.0364286937,
0.0163145587,
-0.0332277119,
-0.0291412622,
0.0076025338,
0.0201593544,
0.0285527129,
-0.0062017068,
-0.0026841196,
-0.0356064327,
-0.0014432502,
-0.1255926937,
-0.0165443029,
-0.0146388328,
-0.0494130254,
-0.0005600378,
-0.0007209128,
0.0205788463,
-0.03891965,
-0.0186386313,
-0.0005774233,
0.0033987975,
0.0284632612,
0.0027996746,
0.0288523585,
-0.0066564069,
0.0048855585,
0.0079549216,
0.0052013239,
0.0493136086,
0.0238272958,
0.0016187011,
-0.0079902261,
-0.0394203328,
-0.0624446049,
0.0393873602,
-0.0117208213,
0.0024417832,
0.0514391139,
-0.0298101846,
-0.0106656207,
0.0539081022,
-0.0222753547,
0.0314902328,
0.0287335627,
-0.0087555181,
-0.0362471752,
0.019894002,
0.0384004563,
-0.005295706,
-0.0064475639,
0.0085721733,
-0.0523330346,
0.0517173149,
0.0003825769,
0.0169158317,
-0.0533704497,
0.061075367,
0.0158476811,
-0.0608068928,
-0.0352309123,
0.0110280076,
0.0170904435,
0.0326896794,
-0.0503311455,
-0.0347696505,
0.0730230212,
-0.0309881978,
-0.0429283194,
0.0290139355,
-0.0092823645,
-0.0112442318,
0.0812384784,
-0.0288635362,
0.0228533205,
0.0167635567,
-0.009281964,
-0.0575287119,
-0.0109726479,
0.060122408,
0.0176934451,
0.036888957,
-0.0725034997,
0.0100334203,
-0.0214177482,
-0.0336806998,
-0.0061168023,
-0.0225844849,
-0.0616491549,
0.0283909291,
-0.0624282919,
-0.0138474703,
-0.038461674,
0.0135091189,
0.0234293956,
0.0258577559,
-0.0087337596,
-0.0102668954,
-0.0407832265,
0.0295428336,
0.0374908671,
0.0367397256,
-0.0588610396,
-0.0584325381,
0.0264869127,
0.0435249135,
0.0309154503,
-0.0248870123,
-0.0784542561,
0.0314012915,
-0.0178720001,
0.0189858563,
-0.0196620412,
0.0199832059,
0.052573055,
-0.0520156212,
0.0382215157,
0.0755157694,
0.0021120964,
-0.0260974094,
-0.0194943398,
0.0131460717,
0.0372152589,
0.0461236946,
-0.016689904,
-0.0821464062,
-0.0862261429,
0.0070361407,
-0.0031334278,
0.0513137244,
-0.0181613099,
-0.0221525021,
-0.0764629915,
0.0526796803,
0.0027389268,
-0.0237855166,
-0.0033357833,
0.0275797714,
0.0050357287,
-0.0017806556,
-0.0528760366,
-0.0083912974,
0.0072369613,
0.0161307827,
0.0302590672,
0.0658254251,
-0.0442841686,
0.0287144836,
-0.0260231625,
0.0431710295,
0.0319783986,
-0.0176185314,
0.0009276329,
-0.0299652778,
-0.0254305936,
0.0435100608,
0.0397442356,
-0.0014420184,
0.0729013905,
-0.0113908313,
-0.0343192331,
0.0252584592,
0.0340454616,
0.0010336338,
-0.0260297135,
-0.0035859433,
0.0421184413,
-0.0335250273,
0.014188434,
-0.0392886028,
0.040223062,
0.0252903234,
0.0475866348,
0.0126463603,
-0.0080099702,
-0.0484071374,
-0.0055710138,
-0.0516109988,
-0.0619533584,
-0.0193839353,
0.003637247,
0.009848916,
-0.0383389071,
-0.0526994951,
0.0101301493,
0.0548712015,
0.0923138335,
0.0038456933,
-0.0155614885,
-0.0242911819,
0.0461085327,
-0.0413503423,
0.066745095,
-0.0287162773,
0.027015416,
-0.0232204404,
-0.007365793,
0.0376384519,
-0.0454389416,
-0.0112692611,
0.0310231689,
-0.0487537459,
-0.0349813849,
-0.0607890487,
0.0785776675,
0.0224305578,
0.048173856,
0.0158477221,
-0.0673552677,
0.0217274185,
0.0152727216,
-0.0169388857,
-0.0049635218,
0.0575566106,
-0.0127136363,
-0.0092434064,
0.0236764811,
-0.0280227754,
0.0311446879,
0.0168856364,
0.0325924903,
-0.0212854724,
-0.0030168891,
-0.008593143,
-0.0190932248,
0.0129592,
-0.0399318039,
0.0435174294,
-0.0326949134,
-0.0212068688,
0.0027406802,
-0.0224025436,
-0.0743781626,
0.0485912822,
-0.0026883339,
0.0123088378,
0.0414933972,
-0.0079828622,
0.0301938653,
0.0281823557,
0.0058436613,
0.0216018036,
0.0343923084,
-0.0196635779,
0.0025913799,
0.0151814837,
-0.002363964,
0.0227317121,
0.0031418437,
0.0196943115,
-0.0177634042,
0.0918365568,
0.0403648466,
-0.0034526282,
-0.0247107688,
0.0217580348,
-0.0517731123,
-0.0425038859,
0.0013557547,
0.0524629131,
0.0716390982,
0.0285848584,
-0.0078389039,
-0.0122686634,
-0.0282307081,
0.014321751,
0.0693891272,
0.03161503,
-0.0227316245,
0.0385134108,
0.0338159427,
0.0315384939,
0.0011341005,
0.0672728121,
-0.0223058201,
0.0356421061,
-0.0092006847,
-0.0275336821,
-0.0571114384,
-0.0445281267,
0.0127856014,
0.025260197,
0.0053005521,
0.0241421331,
-0.0138732484,
-0.0650795698,
0.0018024199,
0.0280526169,
-0.0276440028,
0.0448411331,
0.0550361536,
0.0282218736,
0.0122595625,
-0.0074286284,
-0.008364589,
-0.0020678442,
0.0063296929,
0.0143545195,
0.0030071139,
-5.396709626e-33,
-0.0301018432,
-0.0395311229,
0.0418209434,
-0.0513381287,
-0.0017499109,
0.0060639391,
-0.0406571738,
0.0215646755,
0.0036241822,
0.0307625234,
0.0296091996,
-0.0279670898,
0.0030281828,
0.0147564504,
0.0453526862,
-0.0140051953,
0.0504844412,
0.0025005103,
-0.0251488928,
0.0131626707,
0.0504268557,
0.0070175305,
0.027673563,
-0.0556177832,
0.0002081529,
0.0133295925,
-0.0544680282,
0.0296472255,
-0.0253428724,
0.0678011999,
0.0053181471,
0.0101642432,
0.006958032,
-0.0427125581,
-0.0297113452,
0.0089037661,
-0.0604627542,
-0.016482057,
0.0188168045,
0.0109497877,
-0.0725129545,
0.0029763973,
0.0067524761,
-0.0158160217,
0.0194274634,
-0.0474346243,
0.0595379621,
-0.0039131059,
0.034292344,
-0.0037848577,
-0.0304767042,
0.0067080506,
-0.0429203808,
-0.0674351752,
0.0473316647,
0.0321598984,
0.0219552312,
0.0027699552,
-0.0143127274,
0.0192270353,
-0.0319622196,
-0.0095936535,
0.0881937519,
0.0336880907,
-0.0168600418,
0.0588772781,
-0.0041738725,
-0.0397901908,
-0.0735577866,
-0.0033441714,
-0.0090912571,
0.1077307165,
0.0207033269,
0.0795187727,
0.0088344533,
0.0369998291,
-0.0054383362,
0.0079311542,
-0.0225370601,
0.0471699536,
-0.0035106922,
0.0344703496,
0.0144476676,
0.0204373281,
-0.0322337374,
-0.0225849338,
-0.0385266952,
-0.0364554822,
0.0241314508,
0.0183539707,
-0.0314185768,
0.0335403867,
0.0604435094,
-0.0450217128,
0.0106640793,
0.0174247343,
-0.0165190436,
0.0587266311,
-0.0045322985,
-0.0008582613,
0.0003216868,
-0.0086541036,
0.0899964944,
-0.0015452629,
0.0404514559,
0.0116532352,
0.0634705424,
0.0491618626,
-0.0073135565,
-0.0276033152,
-0.0514358655,
0.0263279434,
-0.0115717836,
0.0277289711,
0.0182968173,
0.0023196461,
-0.0675553605,
0.0022621523,
-0.0392648615,
-0.0141101591,
-0.0203725994,
-0.026520757,
-0.0241515394,
0.0076807262,
-0.0326851644,
0.0239243712,
-0.0413998887,
-0.0945005417,
0.0028368009,
-0.0333920121,
-0.0135371778,
0.0491545498,
2.524e-7,
0.0000474116,
-0.0181239806,
0.0027406269,
-0.0158424675,
0.0328398384,
0.0602254011,
-0.0653533265,
0.0130123887,
-0.0081575671,
-0.0514213368,
0.0068377159,
0.0568317361,
0.0503465123,
0.0119601674,
-0.0624333248,
-0.0201673843,
-0.021943545,
0.0012673942,
-0.0592364781,
-0.008036877,
0.0558552556,
0.027898699,
0.0201307815,
-0.0230136234,
0.0311948806,
-0.0468427017,
0.0669461638,
-0.0001568376,
0.0098204389,
-0.0237151906,
0.0313266478,
0.0048468891,
-0.0178772639,
0.0394890904,
0.0028586844,
-0.0324585587,
0.0453390367,
0.0517198704,
-0.0194976162,
-0.0323472247,
-0.0525795184,
0.006828988,
0.0064337132,
-0.0077230642,
0.0765698627,
-0.0383132249,
-0.0316635445,
-0.0263166521,
-0.024245616,
-0.0254027471,
0.0013024863,
-0.0146298492,
-0.0409799442,
-0.0048286719,
0.0292537361,
-0.0136693586,
-0.0453532934,
-0.0880939364,
-0.0111583425,
0.0006440897,
-0.0616214611,
-0.0168317351,
-0.0141793778,
-0.0368386246,
0.046528738,
-0.0472934432,
-0.0666669682,
1.919649659e-34,
0.022850167,
-0.0137673514,
0.0139527041,
0.0110088326,
0.0202952102,
0.013783861,
-0.0602970123,
-0.0265232772,
0.0102911331,
-0.0418191664,
-0.0435913093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17034v1 | Follow-on Question Suggestion via Voice Hints for Voice Assistants | 2023-10-25T22:22:18 | 2023-10-25T22:22:18 | Besnik Fetahu, Pedro Faustini, Giuseppe Castellucci, Anjie Fang, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The adoption of voice assistants like Alexa or Siri has grown rapidly,
allowing users to instantly access information via voice search. Query
suggestion is a standard feature of screen-based search experiences, allowing
users to explore additional topics. However, this is not trivial to implement
in voice-based settings. To enable this, we tackle the novel task of suggesting
questions with compact and natural voice hints to allow users to ask follow-up
questions.
We define the task, ground it in syntactic theory and outline linguistic
desiderata for spoken hints. We propose baselines and an approach using
sequence-to-sequence Transformers to generate spoken hints from a list of
questions. Using a new dataset of 6681 input questions and human written hints,
we evaluated the models with automatic metrics and human evaluation. Results
show that a naive approach of concatenating suggested questions creates poor
voice hints. Our approach, which applies a linguistically-motivated pretraining
task was strongly preferred by humans for producing the most natural hints. | [
0.043470908,
0.0247453712,
-0.0366085134,
-0.0333927348,
-0.0175408665,
-0.0160803311,
0.0046984623,
0.0200056881,
0.0233777426,
-0.0253394656,
0.0083614597,
-0.0248076301,
-0.0184981953,
-0.0088546099,
0.0377699733,
-0.1002106443,
0.0278413203,
-0.045638822,
-0.0186662637,
0.0222856924,
0.0321607403,
-0.0071976013,
-0.0116791874,
0.0499306433,
0.0064512799,
-0.0120438244,
-0.0542634986,
0.0137156798,
-0.0256170034,
-0.03187529,
0.020641556,
0.0509935915,
-0.0029116806,
-0.0013708149,
0.0000015299,
-0.0569487326,
-0.0020132214,
-0.02049415,
-0.02684737,
-0.037508551,
-0.0267997421,
0.0374903642,
0.0210823063,
0.0461157486,
-0.0475043468,
0.0093887001,
0.0396548584,
0.04810993,
0.045317091,
0.0657975823,
-0.0049750167,
0.0056819278,
0.0310965646,
-0.0179552268,
0.0759346485,
-0.0197023712,
-0.0107672587,
-0.0189186893,
0.0502323844,
0.0387279242,
0.0403720774,
0.043297343,
-0.0008004372,
-0.0449921601,
-0.0037528297,
0.0069440594,
-0.0414705612,
-0.0384634733,
-0.0154429432,
0.0738244653,
-0.0102540329,
0.0148573741,
0.0204627849,
0.0114014316,
0.0404560827,
0.0399844423,
-0.0387941264,
-0.0287470315,
-0.0057537472,
-0.0534970537,
0.0183732882,
-0.008182656,
0.0001163367,
-0.0245407186,
0.042317953,
0.0223621354,
0.0289477985,
-0.0592232011,
-0.0062645576,
0.0186888147,
-0.0184727982,
-0.0867085531,
0.0336456895,
0.0102720782,
-0.0411200784,
0.0039034216,
-0.0458855629,
-0.0447828732,
-0.0018294058,
0.0127295321,
0.0626122952,
0.0267708153,
-0.0631308034,
0.0160382111,
0.0070645325,
0.0136392601,
0.0058665448,
-0.0175146498,
-0.0670370907,
-0.0089383498,
-0.0309615936,
0.0158321336,
-0.0633627251,
0.0318669938,
-0.0255207457,
-0.0115772514,
0.0037958587,
0.0351244248,
0.042408336,
0.0025433972,
0.0090399757,
0.007087687,
-0.0241256822,
0.0313181952,
-0.0236617401,
0.0062194103,
-0.0739718899,
0.0399617031,
0.06747251,
-0.0359685384,
-0.0249678772,
0.0109935673,
0.0585458651,
-0.0189416185,
-0.0075616329,
-0.0127248522,
0.0055579352,
-0.0769134462,
-0.0341001265,
-0.0347635821,
-0.0112243285,
-0.0097370846,
-0.0070194113,
-0.0187078174,
0.0309795663,
-0.0155967223,
-0.041382201,
0.027686378,
0.0080210287,
0.0843479335,
0.0233179331,
0.0492769815,
-0.0297046583,
0.0114524765,
0.0352620706,
0.0111497063,
-0.0453308411,
0.0251534674,
0.0136080403,
0.0362173803,
0.0620792471,
-0.0034402472,
0.0239861514,
0.0132760936,
0.003007272,
0.0064199325,
0.0159795731,
0.0569533221,
-0.0138359079,
0.0629782006,
-0.0213913601,
0.0611189418,
-0.0027410127,
-0.0088793011,
0.0733697787,
0.0840068609,
0.0205767248,
0.034955211,
0.0428608581,
0.0368588939,
-0.0055416562,
-0.0003740077,
-0.0158914961,
0.0267168134,
-0.0544584244,
0.0077734436,
0.0549232252,
0.001408887,
-0.0348080285,
-0.0404559076,
0.0087466044,
0.0012584784,
-0.0106813768,
0.0224069655,
-0.0033338123,
0.0502573811,
-0.0313114449,
0.0036437034,
-0.0132773649,
-0.0629610568,
-0.0029666894,
-0.0110238139,
0.0702119544,
0.0139829433,
0.0396682583,
-0.023546055,
-0.0383591913,
-0.0420860164,
0.0146360202,
0.0248159319,
0.0146391829,
-0.029561175,
0.0168999191,
-0.0305943321,
-0.0070429896,
0.0498281494,
-0.0204388946,
0.0009641485,
-0.0044486541,
-0.0052288026,
0.0341078416,
-0.0693301186,
0.0161016081,
0.0156124625,
-0.0072172522,
-0.0173593443,
0.0328673571,
0.0128076281,
-0.0123364069,
0.0514588431,
0.0266790967,
0.0148622468,
0.0400727019,
-0.0180487651,
-0.0197402518,
-0.0055537224,
-0.0407184437,
-0.0821456909,
-0.0100317122,
-0.0304518342,
0.0242458861,
0.0599470139,
0.006020525,
-0.0554296821,
-0.0284509081,
-0.0534994863,
0.0469765924,
-0.0392297171,
0.0101336353,
0.0463303179,
0.026572274,
-0.0211735517,
0.0264038052,
0.0138667384,
0.0201509334,
0.0292421952,
-0.0294062737,
0.0119653298,
-0.0702412128,
-0.0125025557,
0.0062986566,
0.0053179483,
0.0086532272,
0.0485723391,
-0.0054103704,
-0.0489246696,
-0.0084924139,
-0.1087603271,
0.0118368696,
-0.031014692,
0.0169891343,
0.0076031513,
0.0633666143,
-0.0086598899,
-0.0559285544,
-0.0761158019,
-0.0214589238,
0.0015047967,
0.0222463384,
0.0419501252,
0.0235502198,
-0.0200447626,
-0.0454793908,
-0.0101457015,
0.0032659657,
0.0020174666,
0.0198676027,
0.0354891345,
-0.0641931146,
-0.0120170079,
-0.0279947892,
0.014733267,
0.0001922944,
-0.0038023042,
-0.001413848,
-0.0332130045,
0.0190721322,
0.0464462973,
0.0382247493,
-0.0230647326,
0.0123640653,
0.0343987197,
-0.0276297443,
0.0312163811,
-0.0285362136,
0.0155351358,
-0.0073002535,
0.0112350099,
0.0273844656,
0.0057742982,
-0.0027550748,
0.0100766839,
-0.0321030505,
0.0081664668,
0.0191385075,
0.0059701107,
-0.0308432188,
-0.0087606125,
-0.0243714061,
0.0712738708,
0.0050580883,
-0.0285548214,
0.0759666935,
-0.0126681821,
-0.0435219184,
-0.1009172872,
-0.0448618345,
-0.0437915139,
0.0613445193,
-0.0163313597,
-0.0081588207,
0.0927427486,
-0.0573281199,
-0.0781933963,
0.0145564415,
0.0148660997,
-0.007697952,
0.0445171185,
-0.0189386737,
0.0070305825,
0.0342841409,
-0.0419695973,
-0.0665666461,
-0.0690364689,
-0.0250348579,
-0.0087353541,
0.0352304019,
-0.030689979,
-0.0132236946,
0.0084844427,
0.020316435,
0.0480491444,
-0.0016537015,
-0.0182429533,
-0.0140079353,
0.0782033056,
0.064673014,
0.0369652249,
-0.0123838373,
0.01048466,
0.0516501553,
0.0166929886,
0.0519190095,
-0.01175611,
0.0076018814,
0.0065369918,
0.0548146367,
-0.0564742982,
-0.043198809,
0.0429586805,
0.0400527753,
-0.0136011709,
-0.0281118155,
0.0989278927,
0.0408434831,
-0.0449080616,
0.008615776,
-0.0071787653,
0.0417043306,
0.0212262981,
0.0546762161,
-0.0611199401,
-0.0417225212,
0.0090186428,
0.0386544876,
0.0184427351,
-0.0194751527,
-0.0144954501,
-0.1107121259,
-0.0118840933,
-0.0298097748,
0.0064579947,
0.0264450423,
-0.0447410047,
0.0161381662,
0.017990429,
0.0032286455,
0.0005636429,
-0.0428471677,
0.00106857,
0.009526873,
-0.0413080938,
-0.01278657,
0.0204709116,
-0.0492576845,
0.0129969288,
0.1280631125,
0.0318267569,
0.0256331582,
-0.018333016,
-0.0163254719,
-0.0276665185,
0.013387694,
0.0214760769,
0.0459785499,
-0.0240446515,
0.0072152214,
-0.0244116932,
0.0541603528,
-0.037467178,
0.02548467,
0.055277165,
0.0376094021,
-0.0111866873,
-0.010970369,
-0.0167401582,
0.0339341015,
0.0370736644,
0.051716473,
0.0241893213,
-0.0473892093,
0.0339232311,
-0.0158013497,
0.0360595323,
-0.0248131789,
-0.0156257153,
-0.0106247673,
0.0169557482,
0.0071156938,
-0.1127410457,
-0.0709381178,
0.0221416634,
0.0078586405,
0.0078095156,
0.0014737942,
-0.0068730316,
0.036117807,
0.0150188804,
0.0118763633,
0.0381956249,
0.0099486234,
-0.0678864121,
-0.0240710713,
0.0219825357,
-0.0621561371,
0.00270274,
-0.026342649,
-0.088980712,
-0.0356459692,
-0.0228862315,
0.0576824248,
0.0157093387,
0.0380227827,
-0.0259510465,
-0.0487724356,
-0.0118430126,
0.0433394462,
-0.0201128852,
-0.0074955532,
0.0336768851,
0.0116692111,
0.0035995061,
0.0521021709,
-0.0530911125,
-0.0189961307,
-0.0587160289,
0.0510080457,
-0.0566685386,
-0.0950580984,
0.0510377921,
0.0084510744,
0.0496971682,
-0.0003674961,
0.0522168279,
0.0033609169,
0.0369057655,
-0.0102479607,
-0.0101311021,
-0.0538598858,
0.0278567504,
-0.0014132748,
0.0149271199,
0.0007887862,
0.0000259861,
-0.0729829296,
0.0162279326,
-0.053395886,
-0.0051815645,
0.0069475919,
0.0183758605,
0.0104161324,
0.0167154912,
0.0109896967,
0.034076415,
0.0198587775,
0.0573987104,
-0.022463236,
0.0543236658,
0.0135335801,
-0.0161948316,
0.0286962409,
0.040428631,
-0.0848393887,
-0.0562459826,
-0.0081127593,
-0.0000787216,
0.0285351668,
-0.0217472631,
-0.0094808228,
0.0055288519,
0.0249326769,
-0.0016122833,
0.0466158316,
-0.0385573506,
-0.0388698503,
0.0365104526,
0.0197035465,
-0.0149358986,
0.015036189,
0.0455871336,
-0.0314312689,
0.0083196536,
0.0256092697,
0.0080837542,
-0.0428832546,
-0.0080667622,
0.0261972677,
0.0638620779,
-0.0214495827,
-0.0078831986,
-0.0138410171,
-0.0181585234,
0.0429598726,
-0.0431568921,
-0.0018002464,
-0.0108824382,
0.0786682963,
0.0527538918,
-0.0263996068,
-0.0288251713,
-0.018691767,
-0.0357423052,
-0.062589623,
-0.0315230228,
-0.0044863541,
-5.267834302e-33,
0.007509748,
0.0021074011,
0.0039508515,
-0.008104586,
-0.0154897673,
-0.0410551168,
-0.0386322401,
0.0190478787,
-0.0255892444,
-0.0125126308,
-0.0500426926,
0.0051664617,
0.0088778352,
0.0525495969,
-0.0117015298,
-0.062545009,
0.039995227,
0.0150002111,
0.0066714631,
0.0255293045,
0.0132059688,
0.0422085747,
-0.0033379106,
-0.0348439999,
0.0148572484,
-0.0486227982,
0.0130447187,
0.0119334599,
0.033385776,
0.0525448248,
0.0068176514,
0.0265248921,
-0.0070021269,
-0.0111084171,
0.0000723781,
0.0528675988,
-0.0331886597,
-0.0666321963,
-0.0053718421,
-0.0177167505,
-0.0455745123,
-0.004236178,
-0.0235435329,
-0.0417258553,
0.0375856683,
0.04090482,
0.0496354289,
0.0042296425,
-0.0276775677,
-0.0337534361,
-0.0012650397,
-0.0201703608,
-0.0303491298,
-0.066514492,
-0.0199477263,
0.1270442754,
0.024793243,
-0.0421531014,
0.001038815,
0.0482933447,
0.0147701642,
0.0581321642,
0.019519696,
0.0024710936,
-0.0431038253,
0.0108794617,
0.0385323614,
-0.0239439625,
0.0119971484,
0.0230357181,
-0.0356577858,
0.0279785339,
0.0094596334,
0.0154966544,
0.0321108699,
0.0227704458,
-0.007775188,
0.042531129,
0.0382796861,
-0.009871711,
-0.0375445597,
0.0116407657,
-0.0569776408,
-0.0167418364,
-0.0494998544,
-0.0143270865,
-0.031273216,
-0.0612644814,
0.0630254224,
0.0250896942,
0.004117996,
0.0085785659,
-0.0010590116,
-0.0016750055,
0.0085361162,
-0.0394849889,
-0.0333948024,
-0.0084591107,
-0.013255517,
0.0158869606,
-0.0465902723,
0.0274377782,
0.050578557,
0.0048990999,
0.0055412529,
0.0254617184,
-0.0199730471,
0.0235635191,
-0.057171531,
-0.0291960537,
0.0012163669,
0.0094421245,
-0.0315301158,
-0.0077201184,
0.0346970521,
0.0560457446,
-0.0296500772,
0.0935605392,
-0.0074887951,
0.0022482723,
-0.0551803224,
-0.0679958314,
0.0195538253,
0.0104383705,
-0.0097874245,
-0.0081204455,
-0.0232774951,
-0.0020241137,
0.0335856341,
-0.0528698377,
-0.0085546542,
0.0112796128,
2.373e-7,
-0.0147428457,
0.0128798857,
0.0213592742,
0.0370198376,
-0.0453636274,
0.0349911451,
0.0299412496,
0.0265914779,
0.0306521021,
0.0031284364,
0.0219102167,
-0.0378717706,
0.022456402,
0.0009350645,
-0.1583287716,
-0.0729105622,
-0.0610971153,
-0.0034309742,
-0.0469384305,
-0.0388776809,
0.0746071786,
0.083167851,
0.0219871756,
-0.0080533316,
-0.0138077782,
-0.032137081,
0.0189077873,
-0.0069193277,
-0.0201865137,
-0.0023236505,
0.0427743085,
0.0155490302,
-0.0281496309,
0.0134480773,
-0.0490206107,
0.0054997206,
0.0352053605,
0.0056649684,
0.0058587249,
-0.0558467209,
-0.0319763757,
0.0372520871,
-0.0004056306,
0.0039203838,
0.0401963368,
-0.0217601154,
-0.0061514853,
0.0408688523,
-0.0415359028,
-0.0219381787,
0.003391651,
-0.0267787501,
-0.022458965,
-0.0104855821,
0.0224273615,
0.0233202614,
0.0166452825,
-0.0589386672,
-0.0009617371,
0.0189964864,
-0.0004176321,
-0.0372741856,
-0.068758972,
-0.0226431061,
-0.0245556347,
-0.0347082466,
-0.0157440808,
1.740307103e-34,
0.0093639838,
-0.0052627851,
0.016961325,
0.0556120761,
0.0055551049,
-0.0011301317,
0.0477626808,
-0.0041597779,
0.072992228,
-0.1011296511,
-0.0464701466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17022v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17022v3 | Controlled Decoding from Language Models | 2023-10-25T22:00:05 | 2024-06-03T20:50:26 | Sidharth Mudgal, Jong Lee, Harish Ganapathy, YaGuang Li, Tao Wang, Yanping Huang, Zhifeng Chen, Heng-Tze Cheng, Michael Collins, Trevor Strohman, Jilin Chen, Alex Beutel, Ahmad Beirami | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | KL-regularized reinforcement learning (RL) is a popular alignment framework
to control the language model responses towards high reward outcomes. We pose a
tokenwise RL objective and propose a modular solver for it, called controlled
decoding (CD). CD exerts control through a separate prefix scorer module, which
is trained to learn a value function for the reward. The prefix scorer is used
at inference time to control the generation from a frozen base model, provably
sampling from a solution to the RL objective. We empirically demonstrate that
CD is effective as a control mechanism on popular benchmarks. We also show that
prefix scorers for multiple rewards may be combined at inference time,
effectively solving a multi-objective RL problem with no additional training.
We show that the benefits of applying CD transfer to an unseen base model with
no further tuning as well. Finally, we show that CD can be applied in a
blockwise decoding fashion at inference-time, essentially bridging the gap
between the popular best-of-K strategy and tokenwise control through
reinforcement learning. This makes CD a promising approach for alignment of
language models. | [
0.0384093225,
0.10438779,
0.0087888082,
0.0051412657,
-0.0263665523,
0.0324063525,
-0.035576798,
0.0098218489,
-0.0611866787,
0.018634133,
-0.0323038399,
0.0182085428,
0.0025919115,
0.0095356898,
0.0082631763,
-0.0619157776,
0.0537210703,
-0.0241415836,
0.020062184,
-0.0165333878,
0.0195119083,
0.0041286075,
0.0153108062,
0.0593141317,
0.0042935866,
0.0008893195,
-0.0005831294,
-0.0025824625,
0.0026861967,
-0.0173363853,
0.0240660012,
0.0464439355,
0.0125944987,
0.0632830858,
0.0000019794,
-0.0310739409,
-0.0542175099,
-0.0201330837,
-0.0284175761,
-0.0031958499,
0.0197103359,
-0.0559912138,
-0.0130567187,
-0.0121073369,
-0.0190928727,
-0.0327233076,
0.1070327759,
0.0210114345,
0.0365164094,
0.0764276683,
0.0081246737,
-0.034881793,
0.0197158083,
-0.0075071971,
-0.0169656333,
-0.0937843695,
0.0044800499,
0.0384907462,
0.0091951173,
-0.0253967606,
-0.0516272523,
0.0341306217,
-0.017933473,
0.0138867339,
-0.0022746741,
0.0305007715,
0.0309524275,
-0.0201777369,
-0.0377472043,
0.0289126635,
-0.0335667245,
-0.0524563156,
-0.0031073545,
0.0046937387,
-0.0149994306,
-0.0381642208,
-0.0053078793,
0.0209158659,
0.0052466341,
0.033516746,
0.0726966411,
-0.003931324,
0.0465811789,
0.0024016045,
-0.0399585925,
0.0769196972,
0.0330296382,
-0.0596221127,
-0.023269739,
0.0510687605,
0.0234897844,
-0.0428394005,
-0.024059372,
0.012288467,
-0.0690169409,
0.0333828591,
-0.060248211,
-0.0426617377,
-0.0378827453,
0.017640207,
0.0255746264,
0.0584012605,
0.0280030556,
0.0329658464,
-0.0026257155,
0.0551132262,
-0.020425383,
0.0782107189,
-0.0503122397,
-0.0102132708,
-0.0322018862,
-0.019405771,
-0.0331230238,
0.0013498827,
-0.0068424698,
-0.0049007451,
-0.0479890816,
0.0335717835,
-0.0019301855,
0.0389571525,
0.0149214286,
-0.0132525489,
-0.0506669022,
-0.022311762,
0.0178940948,
0.0478808247,
-0.0245237686,
-0.0065746964,
0.01262205,
-0.0229082555,
-0.0283136088,
-0.0091738254,
0.0118952543,
-0.0336336978,
-0.0236052144,
0.0544278249,
-0.0437995605,
-0.0019515579,
0.0212894399,
-0.0051362505,
-0.0110995788,
-0.0410595462,
-0.0471282415,
-0.0644659624,
0.0342076346,
-0.0084410869,
0.0004255621,
-0.0731748194,
-0.0096556582,
-0.0436806343,
-0.0369337946,
0.0494084507,
-0.0095641492,
-0.000958043,
-0.0049400856,
-0.0222579893,
-0.0164992996,
0.1018347368,
0.0163389705,
0.0130880661,
0.0160223302,
0.0147694452,
-0.011695154,
0.0750969499,
0.0585217252,
0.0260329749,
-0.0317756459,
-0.0440700054,
0.0608578213,
0.024970945,
0.0536158346,
0.0192846898,
-0.0454448499,
0.013498567,
0.051280573,
0.0298139658,
0.0225378126,
-0.0033710902,
0.0021568346,
-0.0134639377,
-0.003981194,
0.0326938108,
-0.0095153172,
-0.0080715008,
-0.0391705893,
0.0167965032,
0.0141504947,
0.0232025273,
-0.0166937374,
-0.0259256251,
-0.0073546716,
-0.025033297,
0.0079329601,
0.0308459215,
0.1018818319,
0.0054606902,
-0.0722456127,
-0.0018929358,
0.0372231081,
-0.0187053792,
0.0420475081,
-0.0401007384,
0.0358723775,
0.0442486927,
0.055589553,
-0.0107229995,
-0.0352046303,
0.0222533289,
-0.0651433691,
0.0435091667,
0.035911385,
-0.0257710312,
0.0158911049,
-0.0277955104,
-0.056088984,
0.0384952091,
0.0221641138,
0.0361813568,
0.0172130782,
-0.0085297367,
-0.0383510813,
0.0120709371,
-0.0177673064,
0.0455770828,
-0.0302847866,
-0.0270700417,
0.0035728191,
0.0188814998,
0.015451258,
-0.0189862847,
-0.0256882701,
0.011912914,
0.0006694187,
-0.0260903575,
0.0021610651,
0.0098896669,
-0.0477193668,
-0.086629726,
0.021162346,
0.0036852274,
-0.0133521557,
0.0636218116,
-0.025253078,
-0.0402235352,
0.0555310734,
-0.0130332047,
0.0606808141,
-0.0113649834,
0.0203726254,
-0.0181584209,
-0.0154327117,
-0.0623445958,
0.0307079237,
-0.0087545319,
0.0171840042,
0.0049211839,
-0.0281022675,
-0.0119620562,
-0.02516146,
-0.0400266387,
0.0299049653,
-0.0296293199,
0.0497822613,
0.0477952585,
0.0166650433,
-0.0098290155,
-0.0241868962,
-0.0298353769,
0.0015232262,
-0.0331256241,
0.0108048124,
0.0125453426,
0.0351888724,
0.0046939836,
-0.0119675733,
-0.0347313024,
-0.0409744978,
0.0295490231,
-0.0111745428,
-0.001666602,
0.0300276652,
-0.0219780691,
-0.0454521291,
-0.0416994505,
0.0038323631,
0.0283485577,
-0.025129918,
0.0219099671,
-0.0858281925,
-0.0004725546,
-0.0236938763,
0.0377574302,
-0.0086611751,
-0.0274682492,
0.0091323489,
-0.0378672779,
-0.0006091475,
0.0852853954,
-0.0226996355,
0.0382436998,
0.0272016488,
-0.000937534,
-0.0811698809,
0.0002500084,
-0.0518380404,
-0.0758365393,
-0.0841636062,
-0.0191918556,
0.033025112,
0.12550053,
0.0071906582,
0.0049661417,
-0.1161076576,
0.0048378599,
-0.0101178559,
-0.0691028833,
-0.0450477749,
0.0040054051,
-0.0210350212,
0.0592678897,
-0.0417398922,
-0.0542603321,
0.0944522694,
-0.0001054856,
0.0079229232,
-0.0224096179,
-0.0088703064,
-0.0257560238,
0.0271799397,
-0.0322433375,
0.0368429795,
-0.0300915316,
-0.0651915967,
-0.0371482149,
-0.0289254803,
0.0345261618,
-0.0165095795,
0.0403417423,
-0.0237632487,
0.0079711806,
-0.0111208251,
-0.0386333428,
-0.0616828427,
0.0141684599,
-0.0227983836,
-0.0032861177,
0.0555091836,
-0.0091794487,
-0.0521361195,
-0.0006874932,
0.0122985421,
0.0128427865,
-0.0300422087,
0.0298133455,
-0.0496258996,
0.0112596508,
0.0698996261,
-0.0221721735,
0.0019863909,
-0.0512906834,
0.0157880913,
0.0302209426,
0.0514108539,
-0.0032436948,
-0.0035686323,
0.0106125139,
0.1028210372,
-0.0272879917,
0.0117377797,
0.0120301675,
0.0148750981,
-0.0433790237,
-0.0374535359,
0.1027357876,
0.041641362,
-0.0553166345,
-0.0134178447,
-0.0246467851,
0.0856843665,
-0.0087196883,
0.0482497588,
-0.0566245094,
-0.0130778141,
0.0177088082,
0.0276189614,
0.0100847688,
0.0127209648,
-0.0186123196,
-0.1024793461,
-0.0136391185,
0.0445562042,
-0.0650407597,
-0.019999925,
0.0118468972,
-0.0168907177,
-0.017369628,
0.0231619496,
0.0625443757,
0.0387862623,
-0.0103392992,
0.0290672407,
0.0212530196,
-0.0266958494,
-0.0190819427,
-0.0511897169,
0.0829303637,
0.1026489362,
0.0120231211,
0.0181016382,
-0.016527107,
-0.0283320043,
0.0221365932,
-0.0477693677,
0.0000314779,
-0.0136955446,
-0.0328173041,
-0.0186173953,
0.0443034694,
0.0100376001,
0.0081100771,
0.008344261,
-0.0220647268,
0.0671068728,
0.0117641436,
0.0094420267,
0.0163502712,
-0.0115505867,
0.0144100236,
0.0595334321,
-0.0135105774,
-0.0367735028,
-0.0539345816,
-0.0320335329,
-0.0380522236,
-0.0806653574,
-0.0249278136,
0.0192582682,
-0.0149792582,
-0.031444665,
-0.0689641982,
-0.0290215146,
0.0176625345,
0.0258920323,
-0.0067752539,
0.021120714,
-0.008335948,
-0.0125089157,
-0.0600966737,
-0.0134275928,
-0.042049855,
0.0096532004,
-0.0739112645,
-0.0169604067,
-0.0134878252,
-0.0422104523,
-0.0096431067,
0.02962007,
-0.0494995676,
-0.0809414089,
0.000293637,
0.0401497409,
0.0100124879,
0.0749473199,
-0.0216163564,
-0.0429549962,
0.0180689171,
0.003554519,
-0.0177765321,
0.0190473422,
0.0263537206,
-0.0302589945,
-0.002703093,
0.0413388871,
-0.0756522343,
0.0128584011,
0.0257370304,
0.061324615,
0.0158516169,
0.0223696828,
0.04072126,
-0.0206499416,
0.0285459924,
-0.0486624092,
-0.0406124331,
-0.0128852958,
-0.0238225739,
-0.0163898245,
-0.0249380954,
-0.0058849333,
-0.0175672788,
0.0370405652,
-0.009502288,
0.0193973538,
-0.0158706065,
0.0146992058,
0.0431215726,
-0.0334302075,
-0.0146211227,
-0.0209986065,
0.00198241,
0.029328391,
0.0326359607,
0.0036145775,
0.0205457434,
0.0080214208,
0.0433463566,
-0.0119890152,
-0.0126450704,
0.0518013909,
0.0370391309,
-0.0366667844,
-0.0213012844,
-0.0485153049,
0.0006569166,
-0.0014379055,
-0.0189070199,
0.0806391835,
0.0033441999,
0.0666089654,
-0.020200111,
-0.019532932,
-0.0040867738,
0.0062188916,
-0.0370675959,
-0.0434605218,
0.0353152305,
0.0105688879,
0.004999368,
-0.0310167354,
0.0480350927,
0.0339094922,
0.041814208,
-0.0448521599,
0.0055645062,
-0.0331230909,
-0.0120873135,
0.0430536196,
0.0264219996,
-0.0422648787,
-0.0053130616,
-0.0207288023,
-0.0565752797,
-0.0110134184,
0.0246283989,
0.0035290711,
0.0171827786,
0.0446903445,
0.0203705896,
-0.0325308144,
-0.0196460225,
-0.0535243787,
-0.0064597316,
0.0247812886,
-0.0588244945,
-0.0016882246,
-6.623457367e-33,
-0.0312288161,
0.0328734592,
0.0223046411,
-0.0207140166,
-0.0412744321,
-0.0016619253,
-0.0157340355,
0.0012170954,
0.0137774181,
0.0028673902,
-0.019730242,
-0.02291012,
0.0073649948,
0.0254906248,
0.0023221627,
0.0040615965,
0.022854533,
-0.0239973515,
-0.0323671997,
0.0012222982,
0.0329561159,
0.0434185639,
0.0702667907,
-0.0362941921,
0.0355711728,
0.0246319342,
-0.0259199217,
-0.0002623948,
0.0357640497,
0.0635867491,
-0.009872661,
0.0058651762,
0.0027809634,
-0.060718704,
-0.0282089561,
0.0103872707,
-0.0641968995,
0.005362513,
0.042667307,
0.0286147445,
-0.0565996841,
-0.0438525416,
-0.0006389468,
-0.0244136639,
-0.0349708274,
-0.0027946881,
0.0155030154,
-0.0155705903,
-0.0359018557,
-0.0141775189,
-0.0861451849,
0.0116502717,
-0.0153441876,
0.0110468818,
0.0657727793,
0.0219039712,
-0.0088492464,
0.0275400337,
0.029662909,
0.0616704784,
0.0028187199,
0.0738768354,
0.1072064638,
0.0759289786,
-0.0084027499,
0.0289804172,
-0.003145756,
-0.0363096632,
-0.005661346,
0.0092894239,
0.0618254133,
0.0250655562,
0.0223422311,
0.0293293856,
0.0162800085,
-0.0276738647,
-0.0138387503,
0.0179944932,
0.01268942,
0.0064486493,
0.0488051847,
0.0545113981,
-0.0459515303,
-0.0207247175,
-0.0694845542,
-0.0088246213,
-0.0316730328,
-0.0334983356,
0.041557204,
0.0339556634,
-0.0361207537,
-0.0436044559,
0.0680966601,
-0.0639324039,
0.0141775003,
0.0615358651,
-0.0227813311,
0.0309873894,
-0.0399977751,
0.0178266987,
-0.0620674975,
-0.0165474582,
0.0139741646,
-0.0330420397,
-0.0052848021,
0.024814982,
0.0076202634,
0.0011907334,
-0.0476219505,
0.0186664332,
-0.0449399725,
0.0103662424,
0.0143851098,
0.0172976367,
0.0736545175,
-0.0094315922,
0.0040121973,
-0.0107935062,
0.0430000499,
-0.0302750804,
-0.0222215578,
-0.0174222216,
0.0009593156,
0.0274107475,
-0.0243045725,
0.0204239748,
-0.0431900136,
-0.009092804,
0.003603651,
-0.0381617844,
-0.0033315043,
0.0238416251,
2.694e-7,
0.0154079283,
0.0520915128,
0.0567704253,
0.0444660001,
0.0024276911,
0.0056377025,
-0.0231162012,
0.0442733206,
0.0112620713,
0.0141675239,
0.0147203514,
0.0171048678,
0.04538849,
-0.0113725606,
-0.0621651523,
0.0229691286,
-0.0308282357,
0.0525290258,
-0.0266253073,
-0.0295770876,
0.0231942497,
0.1068888158,
0.0181766357,
0.0071942359,
0.0163901486,
0.0184057392,
0.0513365939,
-0.0049293088,
-0.0102271326,
0.0419699289,
-0.0044072685,
-0.0044061961,
0.0048689526,
-0.0122247031,
0.003967321,
0.0205792617,
0.00523932,
0.0657332391,
-0.0184947662,
-0.0402996652,
-0.0161063913,
0.0306363869,
-0.0010114957,
-0.0503240414,
0.0189316086,
-0.0163734816,
-0.0082430327,
-0.0255212318,
0.0016474617,
-0.0041104681,
-0.0181149039,
-0.0326413251,
-0.0233880971,
0.0548558533,
0.0485870577,
0.0532398075,
0.0007135943,
-0.0576091856,
-0.0260504335,
0.0121652372,
-0.0179187488,
-0.0410919711,
0.0008437418,
0.0298473332,
-0.0217134133,
-0.0687548667,
-0.0134167969,
2.703145687e-34,
0.0130675966,
-0.0030229397,
0.0027807346,
0.0384273604,
0.0022276198,
-0.0184162837,
0.0046341633,
0.0585471056,
0.0589978583,
-0.0494389534,
-0.0077145258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17019v1 | Conditionally Combining Robot Skills using Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T21:46:34 | 2023-10-25T21:46:34 | K. R. Zentner, Ryan Julian, Brian Ichter, Gaurav S. Sukhatme | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.RO | This paper combines two contributions. First, we introduce an extension of
the Meta-World benchmark, which we call "Language-World," which allows a large
language model to operate in a simulated robotic environment using
semi-structured natural language queries and scripted skills described using
natural language. By using the same set of tasks as Meta-World, Language-World
results can be easily compared to Meta-World results, allowing for a point of
comparison between recent methods using Large Language Models (LLMs) and those
using Deep Reinforcement Learning. Second, we introduce a method we call Plan
Conditioned Behavioral Cloning (PCBC), that allows finetuning the behavior of
high-level plans using end-to-end demonstrations. Using Language-World, we show
that PCBC is able to achieve strong performance in a variety of few-shot
regimes, often achieving task generalization with as little as a single
demonstration. We have made Language-World available as open-source software at
https://github.com/krzentner/language-world/. | [
0.012725587,
0.0596918873,
0.0004112792,
0.0147935245,
-0.0405939743,
0.0002293382,
-0.0052075447,
-0.0185230263,
-0.0015347666,
-0.00975715,
-0.0462318733,
0.0105186775,
-0.0259525981,
0.0482818969,
0.027399471,
-0.0596740283,
0.0410221629,
-0.0574667677,
-0.0259573497,
0.0069186008,
-0.0343112946,
-0.0019664522,
-0.0243582856,
0.0392887965,
0.0211451631,
0.0270617492,
-0.0419446006,
0.0010965682,
0.0245961491,
-0.044240348,
-0.0156590585,
-0.0088298833,
0.0731222779,
0.0190523025,
0.0000020278,
-0.063518405,
-0.0037919406,
-0.0158771742,
0.0047078566,
-0.0539742708,
0.024151165,
-0.0004730921,
-0.0018621954,
0.0392666198,
-0.043308083,
-0.0397558734,
0.0214064289,
0.0287043322,
0.0501863472,
0.0922919214,
0.0125313485,
-0.0241229869,
-0.0089788511,
-0.0070517394,
0.0372905247,
-0.0661780015,
0.0294591188,
0.0268961526,
0.0836605877,
-0.0033602519,
0.0071133398,
-0.0224564336,
0.053151764,
-0.0304615423,
-0.0675582588,
0.0463344119,
-0.0154772187,
-0.0170441438,
0.0209431928,
0.0314738862,
-0.0512831137,
-0.0221426915,
0.0217645448,
0.0024978875,
0.0347467735,
0.0054636127,
-0.0358378105,
0.0367484875,
0.0103699006,
0.0123503506,
-0.0298185833,
-0.0313979499,
0.0246938206,
0.0107030105,
-0.0279291514,
0.0915371627,
0.0016158402,
-0.0280088075,
0.0129953455,
-0.0037525569,
0.0321116596,
-0.0759534538,
-0.0108029721,
0.0656100512,
-0.0623634309,
0.0043513156,
-0.0668928027,
0.0148392925,
-0.0338285156,
0.015709918,
0.0394069776,
0.0359735377,
0.0049171951,
0.0456357598,
-0.0309884157,
0.0737156197,
-0.0279587675,
0.0302844457,
-0.0439902395,
-0.0016813243,
-0.0877334327,
0.0253702439,
-0.0363526866,
0.0354131944,
-0.0203722976,
-0.0388419777,
0.0101326043,
0.0375134572,
-0.0113947857,
0.0398497097,
-0.0148285506,
0.0093926666,
-0.0423487686,
-0.0069384505,
-0.0485239513,
-0.0239234678,
-0.0252373498,
0.022871621,
0.0161659904,
-0.0046538413,
-0.0193364024,
0.0218136422,
-0.0169107486,
-0.0134670027,
0.0366626494,
0.0986551866,
-0.0207621139,
-0.0007076436,
0.0057854336,
-0.029645253,
0.0129707903,
-0.0583610535,
0.0507739,
-0.0614592731,
0.0230359621,
-0.0435551889,
-0.0173024815,
-0.0199014116,
0.0060722521,
-0.0095342249,
0.0105649643,
0.0812416524,
0.0203805231,
0.0154733183,
-0.0169642158,
-0.0219181702,
-0.0184380673,
0.0650761127,
0.045329757,
0.0230949949,
-0.0389813036,
0.0387341604,
0.001007219,
0.0447459258,
-0.0395634063,
0.0004634201,
-0.0195906479,
-0.0312795117,
0.0467724726,
0.058203958,
0.0388591178,
0.0100016743,
-0.0467499234,
0.0342603624,
0.0206291284,
0.0189262256,
-0.006705198,
-0.0224376451,
0.0662095323,
0.0266321823,
0.0071067694,
-0.0387890674,
-0.0640372336,
0.0348082706,
0.0022608512,
0.0216075759,
-0.0390161909,
0.0003007488,
-0.0371218175,
-0.0265185479,
0.0136758909,
-0.0228779931,
0.0317013934,
0.0088329948,
0.0582639053,
0.028903285,
-0.0746593401,
-0.0458505936,
-0.0021328514,
-0.0140475938,
0.0183878057,
-0.0504331812,
0.0024896567,
0.0563115031,
0.0160074644,
-0.061109677,
-0.0330703445,
0.0077118129,
-0.0155266486,
0.0439470857,
0.0119843585,
-0.0211360697,
0.0121805239,
-0.0083861249,
-0.0424401127,
-0.0417750925,
-0.0117457993,
0.0394262187,
0.025609063,
0.002812115,
-0.0217034258,
0.0026695672,
0.0022351854,
0.037697468,
-0.0345854126,
-0.0100012273,
0.0112838196,
-0.0132422429,
0.0417490192,
-0.0306058004,
-0.037286669,
0.0151712764,
0.0219164584,
-0.0214133132,
-0.0341072157,
0.0168174636,
-0.0489619486,
-0.0556844659,
0.0432628319,
-0.0307621453,
-0.0233277567,
0.068572931,
-0.0311753042,
-0.0479966737,
-0.0233002789,
-0.009990911,
0.0520511754,
0.0217117816,
0.0226776823,
0.001623534,
-0.0464433171,
-0.0258144867,
0.0227448288,
-0.0140046412,
-0.0253833141,
0.0317344144,
0.0283761006,
-0.0121667478,
-0.0626851544,
-0.005450251,
0.0361878537,
-0.0125238206,
0.0164166,
0.0416254513,
0.0637229383,
-0.0190813672,
-0.0494174957,
-0.0566326417,
0.0098814489,
-0.0148074748,
-0.0250840839,
0.0042364164,
-0.0240664426,
-0.0033196162,
-0.0211841371,
0.0065284972,
0.0195739157,
-0.0049440535,
-0.0105902227,
0.0200183988,
0.0321505629,
-0.0169770345,
-0.0347498581,
-0.0022942752,
-0.0252134278,
0.006830188,
0.0088779302,
0.044821959,
-0.0492817089,
0.0574118234,
-0.0135039873,
0.0721297041,
-0.0104246661,
-0.0208506845,
0.0616550557,
-0.0460930429,
0.0086473385,
0.0777796581,
-0.0372025184,
-0.023742862,
0.0872702301,
0.0057958523,
-0.0427372754,
0.0390306413,
-0.0235497467,
-0.042862542,
-0.0821090937,
-0.0011574458,
0.0018303463,
0.0421176925,
-0.0137390755,
0.019560473,
-0.073801972,
0.0072529153,
0.0072051277,
-0.0731682032,
-0.0042212554,
0.0002743377,
-0.0538956709,
-0.0148816714,
-0.0399414897,
-0.0186836403,
0.0552634411,
-0.0094945058,
-0.0169994272,
-0.0042759329,
-0.00904945,
-0.0043565258,
0.0542975366,
0.0437122844,
0.0105152475,
-0.0193298981,
-0.0294659808,
-0.0519084036,
-0.0097741224,
-0.0089453347,
-0.0098891193,
0.0131789986,
-0.0921699554,
0.0246087909,
0.0149064148,
-0.0565738045,
-0.050532233,
0.0416896641,
-0.047349982,
0.0665551275,
-0.0124960402,
-0.0721658245,
-0.031724859,
-0.0375671722,
0.0524555147,
0.0720583126,
-0.0038130281,
-0.012764019,
-0.0514883399,
-0.0356023312,
0.0721822158,
0.0455359668,
-0.0356516615,
-0.0376763232,
0.0033675854,
0.0021963778,
0.0806670263,
0.0028460459,
-0.0560390726,
0.0125318198,
-0.0019626652,
-0.0173771568,
0.0135915978,
0.0588681586,
0.0297978222,
-0.0490453169,
-0.0315558128,
0.0972637534,
-0.0046826606,
-0.0082609272,
-0.0034934648,
-0.0160197075,
0.0316825397,
0.0535673536,
0.050471805,
-0.0089474982,
-0.0380108319,
0.0251626223,
0.0163570829,
0.032372918,
-0.026596548,
0.0021530685,
-0.1618656665,
0.0026534477,
-0.0108163748,
-0.0964265019,
-0.053160809,
-0.0214423724,
-0.0037185354,
-0.0240198057,
-0.0099401865,
0.010128486,
-0.0014449264,
-0.0123484926,
0.0033264789,
-0.0290738195,
-0.0414264016,
0.029268831,
-0.0231081843,
0.0256002713,
0.0759799629,
0.0179592483,
-0.0165894218,
0.0044845203,
0.0301925205,
0.0479506515,
0.0200768132,
-0.0000690223,
0.0171129052,
-0.0099443467,
-0.0267319847,
0.010466978,
0.059790954,
-0.0235744882,
-0.0343235768,
-0.0114991339,
0.0567575693,
-0.0217269138,
-0.0190138966,
-0.020152133,
-0.0254200194,
0.0237136502,
0.0361805782,
-0.0175578389,
-0.0518410057,
-0.0488896519,
0.000490321,
-0.0824653879,
-0.0495750904,
-0.0583518855,
0.0038287712,
-0.0030530107,
-0.0003979833,
-0.0529382117,
-0.0450348407,
0.0559906848,
0.0354972742,
-0.0010734712,
-0.0225767978,
0.0345096588,
0.0143690938,
-0.0198424235,
-0.00019502,
-0.0469311401,
0.0052665523,
-0.0424355641,
-0.02089216,
0.0322023109,
-0.0315377377,
-0.0250295103,
-0.0170087479,
-0.0413009897,
-0.0516463965,
-0.0156689845,
0.0701337382,
0.011011363,
0.0500089973,
0.0048734141,
-0.0172699653,
0.0292388331,
0.0253946465,
-0.000625926,
0.0324523523,
0.0301537868,
0.002625105,
0.0200961996,
0.0314962454,
-0.0874819085,
0.0014271943,
0.0039569838,
0.0249244627,
-0.033860188,
0.0197875127,
0.0443301164,
-0.0106790913,
0.012979202,
-0.0010328509,
-0.0099323224,
-0.0357399657,
-0.0125453817,
-0.0096245417,
-0.0233241357,
-0.0547550321,
0.0169263892,
0.0190697908,
0.0177243762,
0.0841765255,
0.0040813345,
0.0213733464,
0.0138608608,
0.010230667,
-0.0187547226,
0.0324081518,
0.0265329741,
0.0374689773,
0.0217984635,
0.0192454588,
0.0013192149,
-0.0153666595,
0.0408893898,
0.0114016272,
0.0198144931,
0.0395053253,
0.0094676092,
-0.0277014282,
-0.0017740563,
-0.0482028313,
-0.1116200686,
0.0251735747,
0.0215321127,
0.050009463,
-0.018819226,
0.0321066156,
-0.086714074,
0.017535938,
-0.0180939641,
-0.0054734475,
0.0024412619,
-0.0085995635,
0.0375105441,
0.0386791006,
0.0206226241,
-0.0096174013,
0.0589781404,
0.0130385645,
0.0869351253,
-0.018828636,
0.0350326486,
-0.0458574928,
-0.0436094888,
0.0600421503,
0.0243613981,
-0.0143266516,
-0.0155827953,
-0.0154862106,
-0.0487290062,
-0.0310070459,
0.0599655211,
-0.0203182865,
-0.0013419242,
0.0644437447,
0.0235806759,
-0.0254356787,
-0.0222557858,
-0.0056173941,
-0.0213580281,
0.0538456216,
-0.0442096666,
-0.0082571628,
-5.490928069e-33,
-0.0177521259,
-0.0106085325,
0.066250436,
-0.0424552374,
-0.02070776,
-0.0096195946,
-0.0320831724,
-0.0006825394,
-0.0379889198,
0.0345734842,
-0.0174086336,
-0.0066994363,
0.0061180503,
0.0102815591,
0.0384161323,
-0.0149060311,
0.0420913547,
-0.0058737709,
-0.0335256867,
0.013035452,
0.0338485613,
-0.0015443198,
0.0358857773,
-0.0424081646,
0.0013302764,
0.0165823493,
-0.0277451593,
0.0529823601,
-0.0171078518,
0.0427127071,
0.023308754,
-0.0161371659,
0.0045106718,
-0.0275109932,
-0.0550501794,
0.0225789286,
-0.0368650667,
-0.0485698469,
-0.0060558813,
0.0011246138,
-0.0787343979,
-0.0146548888,
0.0587218851,
0.001482963,
-0.0323775485,
0.0081679663,
0.0299711283,
-0.0072314907,
-0.0068403506,
0.0353548303,
-0.0532747433,
-0.0036067234,
0.0012846279,
-0.0625972077,
0.030751491,
0.0494979285,
-0.0098742731,
-0.0047092228,
-0.0137319062,
0.0189989805,
-0.0150211053,
0.0193494819,
0.0575594679,
0.0294051059,
0.0461641364,
0.0649779886,
0.016275743,
-0.0033915727,
0.0317421108,
-0.0012696101,
0.0431291945,
0.0790175125,
-0.0095944759,
0.0430498719,
0.0159893185,
0.032597091,
-0.0423790105,
0.0246299803,
-0.0055350112,
0.1067735776,
0.0096844649,
0.0259438902,
-0.0190049019,
0.0038219462,
-0.0455350056,
0.024601195,
0.0053761322,
0.0096938163,
0.0496801734,
0.0284775887,
-0.0002105743,
-0.0449763387,
0.0579750203,
-0.0370171294,
-0.0097013563,
0.0535885394,
-0.0509936847,
0.0303121042,
-0.0214786101,
0.0197877064,
-0.0556045845,
-0.0884290487,
0.016820306,
-0.0137946345,
0.0151219293,
0.0404866859,
-0.0180044677,
0.0826610699,
-0.0524275973,
0.006331278,
-0.0381423011,
-0.0129470611,
0.0512110367,
0.0010278805,
0.0592443906,
-0.0129854791,
-0.0053505017,
0.0234350245,
0.0048346827,
-0.1254115701,
-0.0002694968,
-0.008139479,
-0.0072591631,
-0.0029899091,
-0.015024459,
0.0197220258,
-0.0501687527,
0.0114442063,
0.008303728,
-0.0243478119,
-0.0008020555,
0.0345583595,
2.766e-7,
-0.0114952372,
0.0088507533,
-0.0027754202,
0.0774152279,
0.0155932158,
0.0473982058,
-0.0336041562,
0.0436974503,
-0.0121003576,
-0.0041349661,
0.0054566409,
0.0714966878,
0.0043345923,
-0.0276019108,
-0.0756057352,
0.0253348127,
-0.011190122,
-0.0292759482,
-0.0549376458,
-0.0458149016,
0.0156649686,
0.0856111944,
0.0146154882,
0.0005541121,
0.0367422551,
-0.0515755937,
0.0361145325,
-0.0227923654,
0.0023996467,
0.0090491818,
-0.039787516,
0.0282303914,
-0.0225446019,
0.0159256011,
0.0085553136,
0.0227744393,
0.0038281507,
0.0597698428,
-0.0232996065,
0.0041053761,
-0.0002357794,
0.000863143,
-0.0016023733,
-0.0116994269,
0.0694594011,
-0.07147412,
0.0290763006,
-0.0319158658,
0.0179850943,
-0.0225803629,
-0.0142298248,
-0.0022017914,
0.0008706612,
0.0060909907,
0.0031652944,
0.0284901224,
-0.020291375,
-0.0578441471,
-0.0011041266,
0.0251901783,
-0.060452342,
-0.0386087112,
-0.0180708338,
-0.0135294432,
0.0000779185,
-0.0289048292,
-0.0183467735,
2.367892173e-34,
-0.0166668259,
0.0146481777,
0.0238457136,
0.0245103426,
0.0171491988,
0.0039970367,
-0.0217032023,
0.0410727113,
0.045992855,
-0.0349614732,
-0.047720734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17017v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17017v1 | An Integrative Survey on Mental Health Conversational Agents to Bridge Computer Science and Medical Perspectives | 2023-10-25T21:37:57 | 2023-10-25T21:37:57 | Young Min Cho, Sunny Rai, Lyle Ungar, João Sedoc, Sharath Chandra Guntuku | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mental health conversational agents (a.k.a. chatbots) are widely studied for
their potential to offer accessible support to those experiencing mental health
challenges. Previous surveys on the topic primarily consider papers published
in either computer science or medicine, leading to a divide in understanding
and hindering the sharing of beneficial knowledge between both domains. To
bridge this gap, we conduct a comprehensive literature review using the PRISMA
framework, reviewing 534 papers published in both computer science and
medicine. Our systematic review reveals 136 key papers on building mental
health-related conversational agents with diverse characteristics of modeling
and experimental design techniques. We find that computer science papers focus
on LLM techniques and evaluating response quality using automated metrics with
little attention to the application while medical papers use rule-based
conversational agents and outcome metrics to measure the health outcomes of
participants. Based on our findings on transparency, ethics, and cultural
heterogeneity in this review, we provide a few recommendations to help bridge
the disciplinary divide and enable the cross-disciplinary development of mental
health conversational agents. | [
0.0903126001,
0.017459739,
-0.0439668037,
-0.0337837785,
-0.0268547386,
-0.0003824582,
0.065684393,
-0.0032834017,
0.0902709439,
-0.0092402771,
0.016079437,
-0.0122929662,
0.0050528259,
0.043217048,
-0.0030603067,
-0.0904761255,
-0.0038485962,
0.0187681746,
0.0728815868,
0.0141186686,
0.0108159427,
-0.0119300159,
-0.066532284,
0.082048662,
-0.0225785505,
-0.0179355443,
-0.0134001654,
0.0286048781,
0.0161076188,
-0.0701636896,
-0.0009209516,
0.0104891798,
-0.0230078939,
0.008092694,
0.0000021344,
-0.0249295197,
-0.023774391,
0.030918546,
-0.0052895551,
-0.0889385566,
0.0456699803,
-0.0433416925,
-0.0099902498,
0.0417004935,
-0.0231366884,
0.0140141416,
0.0575263463,
0.0624598227,
0.0311941039,
0.0392024405,
-0.0315838121,
0.0488264449,
0.0495117456,
-0.0008827306,
0.0114163337,
-0.0078181745,
0.0250033438,
0.0460866429,
0.0479075573,
-0.0523970835,
-0.0124115702,
0.0113948723,
-0.0391103663,
0.0295805577,
0.0097591486,
-0.0053457427,
-0.0137241557,
-0.0599354357,
-0.0134386038,
0.0803261772,
0.0533510819,
0.0677017868,
0.0360388458,
-0.0117456988,
0.0270605572,
-0.0033072445,
-0.0496390536,
-0.0037911432,
-0.0188878849,
-0.0053171949,
-0.0022763135,
-0.0105613274,
0.0129358228,
-0.0178465918,
0.0311302468,
0.0259489454,
-0.004399328,
-0.0214529652,
0.0062536849,
-0.0210666005,
0.012743202,
-0.0657901466,
0.0137779769,
0.0599142462,
-0.0676390678,
0.008572978,
-0.0069809603,
-0.0169875398,
0.0333135314,
-0.0095877191,
0.0034928655,
0.0500479378,
-0.0070359004,
-0.0312404633,
0.0572725423,
0.0194757935,
0.0104045533,
0.0576916113,
-0.0171357002,
0.010478952,
-0.0467952676,
0.0046621147,
-0.0074123894,
0.0095412778,
0.015871942,
-0.0255906619,
-0.0809182674,
0.0348259509,
-0.0385377556,
0.0026894212,
-0.0460547842,
-0.0158134904,
0.0060986481,
0.0282044727,
-0.0181761831,
-0.0107972901,
-0.0288572796,
0.0201497581,
0.0330863222,
-0.0747679919,
0.0105614979,
0.0007867166,
-0.0179422256,
-0.006147013,
0.0182067491,
0.0853581131,
0.0200150665,
-0.0574848391,
0.0040342384,
-0.0090717748,
-0.0303299539,
-0.0243613794,
0.0450948998,
-0.0249575824,
0.0334656127,
-0.0215524435,
0.0067352694,
-0.0305583067,
0.040389888,
-0.021473961,
-0.0247431602,
0.0638132989,
-0.0713877976,
-0.0144159794,
0.0177213978,
0.0391057767,
-0.0432381667,
0.0113755371,
0.0200070422,
-0.0064381161,
0.0495630056,
-0.0288385507,
0.0485089049,
-0.0282078926,
-0.0244584549,
-0.0607215911,
0.0358859934,
-0.0152927628,
-0.0227179807,
0.0713306814,
-0.0387944728,
0.0196264964,
-0.0366763994,
0.0329627395,
0.0427847914,
0.0811442882,
0.0210180841,
0.0261399299,
-0.0278796293,
0.0257598311,
0.0069610304,
-0.0115409447,
-0.0509255752,
0.0334916525,
-0.012137508,
-0.0290259719,
-0.0077985693,
0.0076283705,
-0.0434917547,
-0.0693248659,
-0.0186590645,
-0.0696897507,
0.0244632382,
0.0207205527,
-0.0115584396,
-0.036961522,
0.0221027303,
0.0044207727,
0.0231521595,
-0.0076695262,
-0.0634982586,
-0.0950469822,
0.0260520373,
0.1033361778,
0.0408491157,
-0.0503813997,
-0.0521617047,
-0.0251719058,
-0.0150809074,
0.0176325236,
-0.005020434,
0.011162498,
0.0410541296,
-0.0133044049,
-0.0133905131,
0.0127810072,
0.005415841,
0.0018255129,
-0.0099037569,
0.0196737181,
-0.0441521145,
0.0188996699,
0.0147356763,
0.0504865013,
-0.0160888527,
0.0011798432,
-0.0010446403,
-0.0149964914,
0.0775731802,
0.017440144,
0.0064745755,
0.0175119806,
0.0201198701,
0.0044716313,
-0.0529413074,
0.0324549004,
0.0305086877,
-0.0204947852,
0.0200143494,
-0.0291691683,
0.0152863441,
0.0412588939,
0.000004864,
-0.0172914602,
0.0114456164,
-0.0594976731,
0.0448445342,
-0.0078695081,
0.015409424,
0.0027368783,
0.0361099727,
-0.0255119652,
-0.0445159711,
-0.0065376237,
-0.00264095,
0.001082607,
-0.0336473212,
-0.0444185063,
-0.0244153086,
-0.0174695421,
0.0161511246,
-0.0216481406,
0.0064751771,
-0.0267545655,
0.0082699982,
-0.0510692112,
-0.0355754755,
-0.1276751161,
-0.0084299045,
0.0350450389,
-0.055120606,
-0.0269287433,
-0.0128627662,
-0.0089703053,
-0.0283446442,
-0.0440149233,
0.0355587006,
0.0665477514,
0.0255937278,
0.027385978,
0.022512868,
-0.0652084872,
-0.0532727428,
0.0025495943,
-0.004644311,
-0.0161551405,
0.001478028,
0.0000338989,
-0.0167453326,
-0.0283181425,
-0.0645931885,
0.0225116294,
-0.0353298858,
-0.033542864,
0.0418409109,
0.0182622187,
0.0125537179,
0.0626352876,
0.0111305388,
0.0306022707,
0.044868581,
0.0082172481,
-0.0266307835,
0.0097177448,
-0.0184812639,
0.0238240492,
-0.0196707007,
-0.0840444192,
0.0181838181,
0.010709418,
0.0127598923,
0.0503215194,
-0.0339687243,
0.0184644535,
0.0400055647,
-0.0129383234,
0.0294289421,
0.0060738404,
-0.0172059387,
0.0401323251,
0.0029008347,
-0.0332539715,
0.0674414411,
-0.0009383293,
-0.0031138849,
-0.0120105008,
-0.0381723046,
-0.0423454642,
-0.0111584794,
-0.0253075417,
0.0056246235,
0.0226186197,
-0.0002883957,
0.0200175587,
-0.0516868718,
-0.0317167901,
-0.0478878319,
0.0163255036,
-0.045022171,
-0.0083771935,
0.0080081951,
0.00493214,
-0.0589231402,
0.0049673938,
-0.0584318824,
-0.0168566201,
0.0143615836,
0.015895471,
-0.0612812825,
-0.0285346992,
0.0465392247,
0.0085792467,
0.0025450559,
-0.0339808874,
0.0034382432,
-0.0434600152,
0.0316776447,
0.0241689831,
0.051815033,
0.0236262027,
0.0763440207,
0.0429447182,
0.003621927,
0.0406277552,
0.0134503776,
-0.0271444879,
-0.0088934079,
0.020245783,
0.0120026451,
0.0297714751,
0.0502419062,
0.0073416689,
0.0068197655,
0.0904291272,
0.0013339602,
-0.0217798799,
0.0275690462,
-0.0809145272,
-0.0331760272,
-0.0474051349,
-0.0220315326,
-0.0175365526,
-0.0179046243,
-0.0122143263,
0.0542644337,
-0.0842487738,
-0.0262492243,
0.0094374539,
-0.004480226,
0.0392963961,
-0.0228390545,
0.0022754525,
0.0033723961,
-0.0287007801,
0.0421059392,
-0.0233777892,
0.0110678859,
-0.0415902883,
0.0238016937,
-0.0171984062,
-0.011991512,
-0.0846430138,
-0.0053571812,
0.0369540192,
0.0072752573,
0.1186606437,
0.048229035,
0.059999276,
0.0025423442,
-0.0343592055,
-0.0358840786,
0.0689858347,
0.0152903404,
0.0164674576,
0.0702045113,
0.0102567505,
0.0405327417,
-0.0686525553,
0.0379690602,
-0.019129768,
-0.0189672671,
0.0385020189,
0.0428116322,
-0.0502928197,
-0.0034900955,
-0.0515976511,
0.0591003411,
0.0356013104,
0.0334444493,
-0.0049000513,
-0.0644770414,
-0.0264650807,
0.0144379139,
0.0534401909,
0.0102622621,
-0.0268931855,
-0.0133221401,
-0.0204399973,
-0.0065068253,
-0.0554586202,
-0.0727521703,
0.0392148942,
-0.0317263491,
-0.0239372756,
-0.00996836,
0.0522490814,
0.0448275842,
0.0007519227,
0.0087097455,
0.0197532754,
0.0105435969,
-0.0222910959,
0.0006695489,
0.004317835,
-0.0574681498,
0.0216961578,
0.0270835329,
-0.0055735707,
0.0088244639,
0.0459273197,
0.0625216961,
0.0162071101,
-0.0126237227,
0.0040087556,
-0.0024570699,
-0.0225707553,
0.0002638383,
-0.0099034803,
-0.0049504666,
0.0320389345,
0.0728268102,
-0.0158826821,
0.0154139977,
-0.0256042723,
0.0459873937,
0.0002331675,
-0.0020417355,
-0.0182424542,
-0.0201364644,
0.0037306333,
0.0355803929,
0.0086171972,
-0.0031962383,
-0.0244445596,
0.0454439819,
-0.0042590201,
-0.0596495382,
0.0504787154,
-0.0557326339,
-0.0365940109,
-0.0130719524,
0.0074751144,
0.0221592989,
-0.0488609336,
-0.1042117104,
-0.0112578198,
-0.0128666954,
0.0330097787,
-0.0263115652,
0.0082409,
-0.0101236943,
-0.0032721555,
-0.0120487241,
0.0612943843,
0.0002690771,
0.0152846808,
0.0133182239,
0.0618614629,
-0.0233263113,
-0.0285539683,
0.0208592061,
0.0616374649,
-0.0910480618,
-0.1185047552,
0.0134679507,
0.0178868733,
0.0019822477,
0.0995666385,
0.028006386,
-0.0013462421,
0.0209606625,
-0.0106611298,
0.0397107564,
-0.0256519634,
0.0039754412,
-0.0044851829,
-0.0009657525,
-0.0294607878,
-0.0688664392,
0.010424275,
-0.0511311889,
-0.0020845723,
-0.0216645692,
-0.0413237736,
-0.0334638245,
-0.0360130109,
-0.0139395604,
0.017885631,
-0.0255234186,
-0.0151911974,
-0.0510475561,
-0.0303795934,
0.0376406386,
-0.0339630097,
-0.0401321687,
-0.079459317,
0.0201840196,
0.0215796642,
0.0268769655,
-0.0209959242,
-0.0265361387,
0.0164964441,
-0.0382853299,
-0.008435105,
-0.0102278711,
-5.383139645e-33,
0.0106565859,
-0.0184939634,
0.0111027388,
0.0193397999,
-0.0220732987,
-0.0112312511,
-0.0462442189,
0.0395118222,
-0.0248999223,
-0.0006306465,
0.0184721276,
0.0716359094,
-0.0005089667,
0.0226824246,
0.0137240663,
-0.0086493315,
0.0147953946,
-0.0148854554,
-0.0078777364,
0.0171173662,
-0.0496272445,
0.0353973173,
0.0033082073,
-0.0971352309,
0.04483575,
0.0343724452,
-0.0042919321,
0.0081537543,
0.0092109479,
0.0245205332,
-0.0201762374,
0.0635505319,
0.0523050986,
0.0413965657,
0.0134674096,
0.0175748169,
-0.0056029204,
-0.0168328881,
-0.0002900116,
-0.0249396134,
-0.0595765039,
-0.0216602422,
0.0205715019,
-0.0189789552,
-0.0283217207,
-0.0172099862,
0.0409718864,
-0.047512833,
0.0263687447,
0.0217156056,
-0.02996286,
-0.008298479,
-0.0270368904,
-0.0225839484,
-0.0343023315,
0.0925641134,
-0.0300186332,
0.0206271037,
-0.0214532837,
0.0218403246,
0.0262068342,
-0.047280129,
-0.0162153766,
-0.0301307049,
0.0172943529,
0.0325891078,
0.0631322861,
0.0242865868,
-0.0552126877,
-0.026638886,
-0.0050478852,
0.0500071459,
0.0775663778,
0.0287613999,
-0.0379378684,
-0.0135523453,
-0.042854432,
0.0261130203,
0.0256178174,
-0.0131329484,
0.0222028028,
0.0132253822,
-0.0456994995,
0.0005470999,
-0.0091571901,
-0.0041610105,
-0.0173243247,
-0.0571064092,
0.0336580612,
-0.013284904,
0.0183809362,
-0.0541707054,
-0.021876527,
-0.0289309435,
0.026793953,
-0.027328182,
0.0254567713,
0.0216161869,
-0.0034489208,
-0.0370746441,
-0.0348954611,
-0.0096441954,
0.0449491516,
0.0288881101,
0.0813340098,
-0.0293414723,
-0.0134655209,
-0.0226045754,
-0.0208886247,
-0.0071058986,
0.0093645966,
0.0770922154,
0.034723714,
-0.0046371701,
-0.0473330542,
0.0122639742,
-0.0320923328,
0.025801478,
-0.0079577882,
0.0174294692,
-0.0854084119,
-0.0089794053,
-0.0289499108,
0.0167744886,
-0.0425953455,
-0.0305627231,
-0.0462795496,
0.0110003008,
0.0434544496,
-0.0387918502,
-0.0151072042,
-0.063121438,
2.877e-7,
-0.0048276489,
0.0315582976,
-0.0098562595,
0.0315014757,
0.0303222165,
0.0433929376,
-0.000830813,
0.0412188321,
0.0388098732,
-0.0144840842,
0.0242411289,
0.0276439898,
0.0516201295,
0.0423063636,
0.0112026744,
-0.072425358,
-0.00368805,
-0.0263781082,
-0.0054661524,
0.0121093504,
0.0734209642,
0.0119756414,
-0.0055724564,
-0.0237817615,
-0.0135252932,
0.0241668429,
0.0189889222,
-0.0643732846,
0.002507682,
0.0554154739,
0.0207753293,
-0.0250362586,
0.0517985113,
0.0187864285,
0.0238727424,
-0.0164249446,
-0.0232022591,
0.0742599666,
-0.0570171438,
-0.045183748,
0.0292787515,
0.0418107286,
0.0108548459,
-0.0072239456,
0.0288758464,
-0.0715873986,
-0.0760147572,
-0.0143263042,
-0.0224093162,
-0.0337867364,
0.0584827289,
-0.0336428955,
-0.0284182969,
0.0281229764,
0.0061888262,
0.0248171706,
0.0540238284,
-0.0055025136,
0.0002734742,
-0.0039181337,
-0.06162389,
-0.0627754033,
0.0065409942,
-0.0283703953,
-0.0340617895,
-0.0569859929,
0.0206601582,
2.101147479e-34,
0.0152390422,
0.0406397544,
0.0161681809,
0.0663754866,
0.0164182801,
0.0295581538,
0.0020132633,
0.0223906506,
0.022558907,
-0.0526699275,
-0.0253749788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17015v3 | Data Augmentation for Emotion Detection in Small Imbalanced Text Data | 2023-10-25T21:29:36 | 2023-10-30T13:33:16 | Anna Koufakou, Diego Grisales, Ragy Costa de jesus, Oscar Fox | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion recognition in text, the task of identifying emotions such as joy or
anger, is a challenging problem in NLP with many applications. One of the
challenges is the shortage of available datasets that have been annotated with
emotions. Certain existing datasets are small, follow different emotion
taxonomies and display imbalance in their emotion distribution. In this work,
we studied the impact of data augmentation techniques precisely when applied to
small imbalanced datasets, for which current state-of-the-art models (such as
RoBERTa) under-perform. Specifically, we utilized four data augmentation
methods (Easy Data Augmentation EDA, static and contextual Embedding-based, and
ProtAugment) on three datasets that come from different sources and vary in
size, emotion categories and distributions. Our experimental results show that
using the augmented data when training the classifier model leads to
significant improvements. Finally, we conducted two case studies: a) directly
using the popular chat-GPT API to paraphrase text using different prompts, and
b) using external data to augment the training set. Results show the promising
potential of these methods. | [
0.0526297204,
0.0658440068,
-0.0197629146,
0.026779037,
0.0044443836,
0.0256253444,
-0.0338298976,
-0.0081299795,
0.0408149064,
-0.0748654753,
-0.0368790887,
0.02405289,
-0.0237632971,
-0.0005683141,
-0.0068598925,
-0.0762470141,
0.0037817054,
0.08758495,
0.0244150981,
0.0042473213,
0.0564908944,
0.0173780415,
-0.0074031851,
0.0344644636,
-0.0362915769,
0.0101374295,
-0.01303994,
0.0573065206,
0.0482590497,
-0.0370372981,
0.0489988327,
0.0509368628,
0.0208620913,
0.0272287,
0.0000019875,
-0.0251148641,
-0.0096601676,
0.0035319624,
-0.0449259207,
0.0012742198,
0.1142545119,
-0.0383718722,
0.0028467642,
0.0078906501,
-0.0177187994,
-0.0419226773,
0.0631676838,
0.0762502477,
0.0701809824,
0.0666600764,
-0.0372098796,
-0.0016199284,
-0.0019662622,
-0.0040572379,
0.0133078545,
0.0269886516,
0.0378786474,
0.0013805394,
0.0189348664,
-0.0240549278,
-0.0469672196,
0.0015323282,
0.0100647341,
0.0393413454,
0.0295952726,
0.014931743,
-0.0571536645,
-0.0148072224,
-0.0318367183,
0.0847578272,
-0.0296919737,
0.0044258027,
-0.0275454354,
-0.0297317728,
0.0166793261,
-0.026865676,
-0.0246737935,
-0.0182972159,
0.0176579859,
0.040449366,
-0.0075184247,
0.0156833045,
0.0124988016,
0.035209503,
0.0301645044,
0.0015515677,
-0.0122211687,
-0.0360117294,
-0.0052774823,
0.0383944772,
-0.054473035,
-0.0034229455,
0.0105572036,
0.0027871842,
0.0437989309,
0.0206260011,
-0.0681931898,
-0.067922473,
0.0335479304,
-0.0172409602,
-0.0296662841,
0.0427470207,
-0.0548951291,
0.0193106364,
0.0091755185,
-0.0088889897,
0.0434546843,
0.0350977629,
-0.0191887226,
-0.0098198298,
-0.0446243212,
0.0308193583,
-0.0214807168,
0.0294621326,
-0.03218624,
-0.0246611368,
-0.1159015149,
-0.0036499237,
-0.0252106488,
-0.0220759716,
0.0074728034,
0.0104623763,
-0.0153040215,
0.0252744686,
-0.0000554249,
0.0187938791,
-0.0216111261,
0.0481793918,
0.0040314016,
-0.1139772609,
-0.0045198076,
-0.0039659091,
0.0213489253,
-0.0246522091,
0.0322658122,
0.0373315513,
0.027408516,
-0.0802171901,
-0.0518341586,
0.0080901133,
-0.0107439104,
-0.0364257284,
-0.0332945623,
-0.0430873819,
0.0415773205,
-0.0182373505,
0.0008124096,
0.0161440689,
0.023553744,
0.0054354309,
-0.0380768925,
0.0766370967,
-0.0523404889,
-0.028790934,
0.0002131642,
0.0029128133,
-0.025826415,
0.0716282502,
0.0280337799,
0.0204748902,
0.0571819767,
0.0143796587,
0.0289178882,
0.0110159852,
0.0216592811,
0.0010637819,
-0.0096383011,
-0.0241552182,
-0.0653167889,
0.0131200161,
0.0358665586,
0.0134008368,
-0.047017701,
-0.0163578168,
0.0354472809,
0.0376324952,
-0.0199667774,
0.0069276844,
-0.0313411281,
0.0191001296,
0.023479227,
-0.0414274931,
-0.042477116,
0.0166190751,
-0.0336046182,
-0.0098764151,
0.0154370135,
0.0249848925,
-0.019255355,
-0.0591555126,
-0.0148028452,
-0.0297974292,
0.0191074349,
0.0311337598,
0.0330433063,
-0.0096545927,
-0.0077440538,
-0.0275732465,
0.0457363725,
-0.0757662281,
-0.0122412723,
-0.0205547288,
-0.0194927547,
0.0835567638,
0.0414664075,
-0.064771302,
-0.0453381389,
-0.0539531671,
0.0116497828,
0.0128269456,
0.034189418,
0.0319449715,
0.0196532998,
-0.0656288937,
0.0133295618,
-0.0014815304,
0.0267438386,
0.0076664835,
0.0225047916,
0.0660261065,
-0.0081941048,
-0.0300402697,
-0.026264213,
0.0239583459,
-0.0055581937,
-0.0390461758,
0.0322359614,
0.0321813934,
-0.002922405,
0.0294437036,
-0.014746503,
-0.0321062468,
0.0181643181,
-0.0006173932,
-0.0451438129,
0.0217546895,
0.0164746139,
-0.076863125,
0.0470969267,
-0.0056740106,
-0.0162227545,
0.0362329669,
-0.0729350746,
-0.0158395506,
0.0215290152,
-0.0311868433,
0.0318937637,
-0.0376572683,
0.0210683402,
-0.0220964551,
0.0786741674,
-0.0119370874,
0.0424987674,
0.0039411094,
0.0092458436,
-0.0244981572,
-0.0108620981,
0.014019805,
-0.0349204987,
-0.0579595529,
-0.0295830946,
0.0444846377,
0.0205209404,
-0.0118571995,
-0.0388680287,
-0.0772271529,
-0.0173235144,
-0.0994609743,
0.0104734404,
0.0146962479,
0.0042090011,
0.0021578274,
0.0352684595,
-0.0373847,
-0.0121079227,
-0.0253849737,
-0.003416932,
0.02487115,
0.0250791349,
0.021150725,
-0.0111268815,
-0.0045872801,
-0.0676547587,
0.0163318049,
-0.011702436,
0.0119294692,
0.0225030631,
-0.0032851032,
0.0029381646,
-0.006233789,
-0.0081937555,
0.0541346855,
-0.0047676945,
-0.0724833384,
-0.042230919,
0.0132907797,
-0.0038773655,
0.0369111262,
-0.0111505138,
0.0591745153,
0.0006065893,
0.0334579013,
-0.0338065997,
0.0262036994,
-0.0094748642,
0.0049874862,
0.0240392853,
-0.0325860195,
-0.0447452143,
0.0301974136,
-0.0139656952,
-0.0119845318,
-0.0239334498,
-0.0072390153,
-0.0004278456,
-0.0121658621,
-0.0177854374,
-0.0284775645,
-0.0086423643,
-0.0211079884,
-0.036023926,
-0.0622550696,
0.0493909717,
0.0204760022,
-0.0321833976,
-0.0922003984,
-0.0247828234,
-0.0409253202,
0.0287874453,
-0.0136950919,
0.0112231057,
-0.0478940606,
0.0070853527,
0.0059463056,
-0.028901333,
-0.0236367323,
-0.0581466071,
0.0345843472,
-0.0002624513,
-0.0213305764,
0.0133843413,
-0.0460302569,
-0.0538954921,
-0.0789443702,
-0.0441047326,
-0.0197560973,
0.012239757,
-0.0257365815,
-0.0065567079,
-0.0473240875,
0.0093497019,
-0.0060319118,
-0.0156281255,
-0.0370513424,
0.0070968964,
0.0028799626,
0.0557789654,
0.0065026642,
0.0193244796,
-0.0076316055,
-0.0021503565,
0.0257864408,
0.0267646741,
-0.0230076145,
-0.0219262876,
0.0231104326,
-0.0073989304,
-0.0036416019,
0.0035588189,
-0.0488333851,
0.0145356599,
-0.026021421,
0.0409310013,
0.0961206704,
0.0252467878,
-0.0499118827,
0.0214478076,
-0.0412326343,
0.0075423275,
0.035946466,
0.0289012846,
-0.0674339533,
-0.0424806103,
-0.009440816,
0.0292178411,
-0.0302772578,
-0.0189459901,
0.0005800096,
-0.1336016953,
0.036896579,
0.001869904,
-0.0261389613,
-0.0499711074,
0.0160037428,
0.032301385,
-0.0080248928,
0.0220908113,
-0.0655538812,
-0.0018457023,
0.0181121156,
0.0328184776,
-0.0204925053,
-0.0677029714,
-0.0139312288,
-0.0445442088,
0.0587320477,
-0.0008126075,
0.0780543759,
-0.0084041022,
-0.002533843,
0.0504883491,
0.0281418897,
0.000291922,
0.0100282039,
0.1119443104,
-0.0204206556,
-0.0255413167,
-0.0173076186,
0.0423619002,
-0.0246081892,
0.009925304,
-0.0098785069,
0.0530893132,
0.0102014896,
0.0414620228,
-0.0440197289,
-0.0024696884,
0.0600429177,
0.0672975704,
0.0238084588,
-0.0230658576,
-0.0256075505,
-0.0022243208,
0.0172228534,
-0.0187171921,
0.0206459779,
0.0304112937,
-0.0095285708,
-0.0773988217,
-0.0502349511,
-0.080970034,
0.019233441,
0.0219054222,
0.0038947028,
0.0036045196,
-0.0443479829,
0.0139310742,
-0.0501109473,
0.0299464036,
-0.0018342361,
0.0264814943,
0.0230264217,
-0.0342833921,
-0.0255459528,
-0.0582311787,
0.0002628517,
-0.0274285283,
-0.0306729376,
-0.045510985,
0.0085229659,
0.0188799836,
0.0156435519,
0.0317083858,
-0.0278264582,
-0.0438327417,
0.0468401499,
0.1201563925,
-0.0445116721,
0.0034331097,
0.0199719649,
0.0561105683,
0.00785843,
-0.0040756208,
-0.0374990776,
0.0284831859,
0.0102742165,
0.0027460826,
0.000871157,
-0.0079695433,
-0.0005349586,
0.0288375244,
0.0510200858,
0.0103509482,
-0.0345604159,
-0.0294916928,
-0.009891198,
-0.0142832836,
0.0000439638,
-0.0320067741,
-0.0168461241,
-0.0013346528,
0.0131196156,
-0.0697391704,
-0.0484386384,
-0.0179698709,
0.010016649,
-0.0364872329,
0.0256749243,
0.0383555889,
-0.004857685,
0.0079987487,
0.047195632,
-0.0082996702,
-0.0054119471,
-0.0055442294,
-0.0043937885,
-0.0109247128,
0.0170731451,
0.0208073463,
-0.0154294958,
-0.0291985422,
0.0300802756,
-0.0273069795,
0.0441724434,
-0.0081297243,
0.0258191004,
0.0363042392,
-0.0559905693,
0.0541693605,
-0.0533480942,
0.0040130545,
-0.0003656613,
-0.0070718112,
-0.037460763,
-0.0435390137,
0.0081252567,
0.0031331379,
-0.0254047085,
-0.0046947664,
0.0386068746,
-0.0632841364,
0.0982587785,
-0.0112413671,
-0.0269668102,
-0.0322869346,
0.0262476802,
0.0978582799,
0.0148674557,
0.0046712528,
0.0515216924,
-0.0581599474,
-0.0710368603,
0.0055379812,
-0.0439582504,
-0.0110182082,
-0.0057418896,
0.0124858441,
0.0183265451,
-0.0262751337,
0.0156269632,
-0.0313569941,
0.0219104458,
-0.0701574236,
-0.0302150119,
-0.0033502851,
-5.755885598e-33,
0.0180357266,
0.0121181272,
-0.0446839146,
0.0094397161,
-0.0227408577,
0.0363767296,
0.0176628064,
0.0067523383,
-0.0002071652,
0.0473413244,
-0.0315546654,
0.0362216234,
0.0097460775,
0.0113069527,
-0.011464892,
-0.0276036207,
0.0305035766,
0.0068858843,
-0.0056121172,
0.0046782419,
0.0230878778,
0.0470252633,
0.0750610679,
-0.0892664492,
0.0175692458,
0.0095154978,
-0.0240145978,
-0.0046849675,
0.0593087152,
0.0554807745,
-0.0017455702,
0.1068709269,
0.0203888509,
0.0089722509,
0.0163325872,
0.0131198429,
-0.0226141885,
-0.0233192015,
-0.0175959989,
0.0475241877,
-0.036308974,
-0.0024568613,
0.0384311005,
0.0061884639,
-0.0018963475,
0.0115978606,
0.0416308828,
-0.0355980583,
0.0169233009,
-0.0278634988,
-0.0344376452,
0.0240999237,
-0.0101581709,
-0.0232596733,
0.0061011771,
0.0322690345,
0.0070276777,
0.0202651117,
-0.0686198696,
-0.0024897074,
0.0155940158,
-0.0196941383,
-0.0052690883,
-0.005895745,
0.0074948841,
0.0858619735,
0.0097634448,
0.0123639097,
-0.0176093932,
0.0486468077,
0.0097157387,
-0.0038866017,
0.0231564865,
0.0725339279,
0.055307705,
0.0029561897,
-0.0091335531,
0.0476650335,
0.0878125131,
-0.0139323026,
0.0599730536,
0.0063754022,
-0.0801914036,
0.0073639587,
0.0130089307,
0.0103056058,
-0.0381188802,
-0.0373736322,
0.0422827005,
0.0215912759,
-0.000080638,
0.0154040782,
-0.0363656729,
-0.0450128019,
-0.0579580888,
0.0491596051,
-0.0197724048,
0.0296641327,
-0.000405148,
-0.0298343562,
-0.0043681641,
-0.0076482566,
0.0544729084,
0.0450202227,
0.020595286,
-0.0186300594,
0.0507972911,
0.0197801422,
-0.0761222094,
0.0040761037,
-0.0205523707,
0.0647790506,
-0.0116717834,
0.0055273268,
-0.0262881499,
0.0262597855,
-0.0222809315,
0.0284670833,
0.0437615402,
0.0503246114,
-0.0160926729,
-0.0252176952,
-0.0195662118,
-0.00831562,
-0.0308674667,
-0.0025431789,
0.0401370749,
-0.0470487326,
-0.0133203026,
-0.0552496128,
0.0096599683,
-0.0461674854,
2.749e-7,
0.0254779141,
0.0432128124,
0.0208204873,
-0.0502402298,
0.0148475254,
0.0340849794,
-0.0051027136,
0.0391507186,
0.0187967587,
-0.0340484753,
0.0228095762,
0.0293945335,
0.023737317,
-0.0126307923,
-0.0872963294,
-0.0185921211,
-0.0097993296,
0.0309816338,
-0.0052588899,
0.024023721,
0.1150091141,
0.1170517132,
0.0822076797,
-0.0222357493,
0.0084302025,
0.0205647629,
0.0155435577,
-0.0325465575,
-0.004770109,
0.0162842087,
0.0480402857,
0.0298749562,
0.0104456376,
0.0156892743,
-0.0099103963,
-0.0045212996,
0.0258037094,
-0.0007126532,
-0.0327929817,
-0.0050731483,
0.016052084,
0.0401568003,
-0.0264588743,
-0.0289437659,
0.0519511625,
-0.0578892194,
-0.0309644938,
-0.0312997401,
-0.0527168103,
-0.0032529109,
0.0534858145,
-0.0269877892,
-0.060850922,
0.0271800272,
0.0296800565,
-0.0136312377,
-0.0502330922,
-0.095508039,
-0.0057109417,
0.0103903804,
-0.0445077568,
-0.0235956814,
-0.0251212679,
0.0485722795,
0.023925487,
-0.0500251837,
0.0104340725,
2.415147275e-34,
0.0158690996,
-0.002359835,
0.0145653244,
0.0111260014,
0.0121553605,
0.0154987983,
0.0279840492,
-0.0021749442,
0.0254452135,
-0.0409421995,
0.0177800227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.17010v1 | This Reads Like That: Deep Learning for Interpretable Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-25T21:18:35 | 2023-10-25T21:18:35 | Claudio Fanconi, Moritz Vandenhirtz, Severin Husmann, Julia E. Vogt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prototype learning, a popular machine learning method designed for inherently
interpretable decisions, leverages similarities to learned prototypes for
classifying new data. While it is mainly applied in computer vision, in this
work, we build upon prior research and further explore the extension of
prototypical networks to natural language processing. We introduce a learned
weighted similarity measure that enhances the similarity computation by
focusing on informative dimensions of pre-trained sentence embeddings.
Additionally, we propose a post-hoc explainability mechanism that extracts
prediction-relevant words from both the prototype and input sentences. Finally,
we empirically demonstrate that our proposed method not only improves
predictive performance on the AG News and RT Polarity datasets over a previous
prototype-based approach, but also improves the faithfulness of explanations
compared to rationale-based recurrent convolutions. | [
0.0216730554,
0.0768476948,
-0.0183754414,
0.0291812848,
-0.0044149524,
0.0400213338,
0.0371023044,
-0.0136099001,
-0.0407711081,
0.0109349769,
0.0027412691,
-0.0481201783,
-0.0190645736,
0.0690133497,
0.0104541192,
-0.0581675693,
0.0045878319,
0.0457752608,
-0.0046537346,
0.0181018803,
0.0091269994,
0.0193612818,
-0.0103049427,
0.0700212419,
0.0342560597,
-0.022593528,
-0.0251991283,
-0.0200875308,
-0.0160688292,
-0.0147871738,
0.0253975522,
0.0219294112,
0.0332853459,
0.0346408151,
0.0000020777,
-0.0136878323,
-0.0135080479,
-0.0208633021,
-0.0219524428,
-0.0175737757,
0.0602278933,
0.0015816242,
0.0190784167,
0.0207220186,
-0.0287694968,
-0.0347389206,
0.05801728,
0.0721218884,
-0.0042918953,
0.0400260873,
-0.013579729,
-0.0341232717,
0.0419773571,
-0.0133804018,
0.0191130005,
0.0248498898,
-0.024016913,
-0.0335874259,
-0.0707055554,
-0.0377302542,
-0.0063885618,
-0.0084356004,
0.057417661,
-0.0184223577,
0.0046423692,
-0.0043161158,
0.0381507054,
-0.0311975628,
0.007283214,
0.0682674199,
-0.0204076711,
-0.0423966981,
-0.0021340745,
-0.0176687911,
-0.0194743145,
0.0030542987,
-0.0334481411,
-0.0402796827,
0.006968888,
0.0324678421,
0.0357305855,
0.0616848022,
0.0574453212,
0.021393124,
-0.0400576293,
0.0787297264,
-0.0220369492,
0.0171578173,
-0.0193845034,
0.0358723253,
0.0211259834,
-0.0196755435,
0.0224743728,
0.0000103917,
0.0099801356,
0.0088432916,
-0.0251770113,
-0.0210470315,
-0.01713112,
-0.022094762,
0.0232006107,
0.0169716068,
-0.0127935084,
0.0363412425,
0.0034899232,
0.0340383947,
-0.0350535884,
0.0355119258,
-0.0293463264,
-0.0266416091,
-0.070835188,
-0.0463280007,
0.0081659146,
0.0220784601,
-0.0086509781,
-0.0241521969,
-0.0324640982,
0.0088746427,
-0.0323538668,
-0.0084784236,
-0.0233221278,
0.0486657135,
-0.0492950007,
-0.0487168729,
-0.0533575751,
0.0206952766,
-0.0335046388,
0.0538754761,
0.0175225027,
-0.0318516493,
0.0082838349,
0.0299440641,
0.0194342528,
0.0213890336,
-0.0038322813,
0.062753275,
0.0136465402,
-0.0151286162,
-0.025197817,
-0.028525956,
-0.0047625224,
-0.0355558209,
0.0110196276,
-0.048101142,
-0.0062895459,
-0.0127577474,
-0.0105259437,
-0.0594620295,
-0.0337861702,
-0.0015754711,
-0.007718049,
0.0959720984,
0.0154357068,
-0.0394938849,
-0.0562058873,
0.0122637087,
-0.0042641554,
0.0498481356,
0.0188053846,
0.048989132,
0.022990521,
-0.0153772179,
0.0196221508,
-0.0221574958,
0.0154109793,
-0.0153722614,
-0.0425519682,
-0.0173785724,
-0.0719182566,
0.0136209475,
0.0365224332,
-0.0319530517,
-0.0238861796,
-0.0019356512,
0.0520948432,
0.0682527944,
0.0483975932,
0.0968452394,
0.0540508479,
0.0306920409,
-0.0461924374,
0.0122746862,
-0.0574999489,
0.0296153408,
-0.017023338,
-0.0102188112,
-0.0323466919,
-0.0116275121,
-0.037464451,
-0.0539305769,
0.0422236435,
-0.0149421552,
0.0040571233,
-0.002787774,
0.0455404259,
0.0118351309,
-0.0420495868,
0.0131383743,
0.0188825801,
-0.0323143564,
0.0034190975,
-0.0395180508,
0.0463537872,
0.0807110891,
0.0045431764,
-0.0192302428,
0.0201035924,
-0.0500159673,
0.0005848453,
0.0277199782,
0.0374139063,
0.0074370266,
0.0562434196,
-0.049939733,
-0.0444806479,
-0.0556467623,
0.0328234918,
0.0351277925,
-0.0219091401,
-0.0138249649,
0.0207214952,
-0.0784329996,
-0.0180881787,
0.008253023,
0.0019853476,
-0.0189912375,
0.0209248643,
0.0449975692,
0.046040602,
0.0445196517,
0.0191594418,
-0.0021617752,
0.0066276719,
-0.0282870494,
-0.0463803485,
0.0435501412,
-0.0467988513,
-0.0269676093,
-0.0167843904,
-0.056089513,
0.00280926,
0.0507773422,
-0.036257647,
-0.0340440273,
0.0636940226,
0.004304619,
0.0515096001,
-0.0531250685,
-0.0338415168,
-0.027243657,
0.0135770226,
-0.0127787217,
0.0463148654,
-0.0041454756,
0.005747756,
-0.021370478,
-0.0044924491,
0.0237209685,
0.0055136513,
-0.0015132109,
0.0014938519,
-0.0156935975,
-0.0064553171,
-0.0027358322,
-0.0318022929,
-0.0250663813,
-0.0208310019,
-0.0193273406,
0.0219762251,
-0.0201357286,
-0.0052548065,
0.0195525158,
-0.0029438292,
0.0404742323,
0.0087753469,
-0.0165249351,
0.0326715522,
0.0010382108,
-0.0167295597,
0.0631794855,
-0.0269682724,
-0.0251086932,
-0.0136419488,
-0.0197586361,
-0.0235044528,
0.0980288461,
-0.0006439399,
0.0357306786,
-0.0239683725,
0.0172475446,
0.0000693893,
-0.0070679239,
-0.0181922372,
-0.0600695871,
0.0079555027,
-0.0149134193,
-0.034510389,
0.0564841442,
0.0039392617,
0.0975586995,
-0.0025332579,
0.0651876405,
-0.0387785174,
-0.0315814838,
-0.0567373186,
0.0320812277,
-0.0498412214,
-0.0152836377,
-0.0116096335,
0.0500391498,
0.0054211337,
-0.0008599289,
-0.0465347245,
0.0407268964,
0.02842848,
-0.0296434816,
-0.0024037759,
-0.032814566,
0.0014422807,
0.0308873504,
-0.04853471,
-0.0843013227,
0.0817678198,
0.0005553423,
-0.0041326154,
-0.0223132148,
-0.0564333908,
-0.0236491598,
0.0724904537,
0.0167383123,
-0.0267750416,
-0.0076733655,
-0.0228647627,
-0.0054565668,
-0.0360534638,
-0.0085372645,
0.0025729984,
0.0562001988,
-0.0109480638,
-0.0245836843,
0.0221238602,
-0.0237709321,
-0.0259527788,
-0.0224816222,
-0.0303308312,
0.0034982592,
0.0072616078,
-0.025120398,
-0.0552996621,
-0.0181020759,
0.0125638703,
0.0231048763,
-0.0017071069,
0.0176534075,
-0.0168638099,
0.0371375345,
0.0163937993,
0.0088107474,
0.0255703721,
0.0037569688,
0.0683083683,
0.0068033226,
-0.0002463699,
-0.016415637,
-0.1013923585,
0.0282148365,
-0.0219553877,
0.0269185212,
-0.0337999798,
0.0150708994,
0.0261984505,
-0.0663722381,
0.0183956474,
0.0878456086,
0.0039084125,
-0.0499571934,
0.0116228834,
0.0324391089,
0.0190187227,
0.0360235199,
-0.0075081987,
-0.0238083489,
-0.0426188074,
0.0053293547,
0.0041131857,
0.0169454552,
-0.0342583694,
-0.0123457508,
-0.0596779771,
0.0200001951,
-0.0320870467,
-0.0677023456,
-0.0532646738,
-0.0413338244,
-0.0350589715,
-0.0269309077,
-0.0211300161,
0.0060505057,
0.0297629647,
0.0345356353,
0.0345724672,
-0.0703631192,
-0.0211139433,
0.0003856148,
-0.022090964,
0.025310481,
0.054419376,
0.0592207499,
-0.0192572605,
0.0146621373,
-0.0325143188,
-0.0936051309,
0.0037050932,
-0.0047713323,
0.0942498818,
-0.0207472201,
-0.0283132941,
-0.0291652847,
0.0786821097,
-0.0588780046,
-0.026060503,
-0.0398741774,
0.0572637506,
-0.0287308246,
-0.0420879945,
-0.0077368016,
-0.0017735198,
0.0404375382,
0.0635681301,
0.0508079939,
-0.0215981938,
-0.0536766164,
-0.0455396771,
0.0131329214,
-0.1049888805,
-0.0105970595,
-0.0355506279,
0.066057384,
-0.0027282224,
-0.0236865282,
-0.0597209819,
-0.0263077747,
0.0324041434,
-0.0149172554,
0.0268930346,
-0.0153294513,
-0.0188022107,
-0.0651402697,
0.0611150563,
0.0368376672,
-0.01079934,
-0.0121318409,
-0.0204763506,
0.0327678323,
-0.0478649139,
-0.0609666556,
-0.0275508743,
-0.0119229024,
-0.0045317835,
0.0041333665,
0.0170183703,
0.0224709734,
0.030159235,
-0.022274714,
-0.0386715904,
0.0371341556,
0.0200308263,
-0.0158742182,
-0.0528201461,
0.0800917968,
0.0259314682,
0.0212425403,
0.0597103573,
-0.0091812257,
0.0512810461,
0.0235586353,
-0.0459525846,
-0.0081474949,
-0.0486091226,
0.009618259,
-0.0424391516,
0.0583663061,
0.020970922,
-0.0228557624,
-0.047315143,
0.0016557334,
0.0355808772,
0.0061370665,
-0.0550222583,
0.008459419,
0.0169262905,
-0.0178947169,
-0.029857656,
-0.0469698757,
-0.01078502,
0.0196749736,
0.0159016252,
0.0663628578,
0.012120516,
0.0288329944,
-0.029549038,
0.0398074128,
-0.0253861621,
0.0474217013,
-0.0507710688,
0.0343408771,
-0.0058217337,
0.0120823747,
0.0269684866,
0.0149436342,
-0.038414944,
0.000514489,
-0.090573296,
-0.039218314,
-0.01825816,
0.0294152666,
0.002098341,
-0.0368150547,
0.0036063306,
-0.0087994039,
-0.0008882764,
0.0112773525,
0.0650275648,
0.0110150212,
-0.0380319692,
0.0415777862,
0.0002861046,
-0.0306587312,
-0.0112303933,
0.0596372113,
0.0314919204,
0.0271186121,
0.0167410392,
-0.0264190119,
-0.0223419145,
-0.0270653889,
0.06342832,
0.0442982204,
-0.0080252429,
0.0222844891,
-0.0022531969,
-0.0503888018,
0.0332339369,
0.0019056298,
0.013318114,
-0.0052164434,
0.0167194288,
0.0863404423,
-0.0139578478,
-0.0237842426,
-0.0144903585,
0.0403659083,
-0.0210795589,
0.0096120415,
0.0064205965,
-6.292504279e-33,
0.0220932253,
-0.0316982679,
-0.0172653999,
-0.0194504857,
0.008670127,
0.0381168202,
-0.0460946932,
-0.0294158291,
-0.0205851365,
0.059435606,
0.0076931682,
0.0519265458,
0.0139134498,
0.0370888785,
-0.0206450131,
-0.0506477132,
0.0482159331,
0.0205286443,
0.0319960043,
0.0118271252,
0.0500677638,
0.0502277724,
0.0608822182,
-0.0506691001,
0.0020976309,
0.006385244,
-0.0014623367,
-0.0008004053,
0.0019234638,
0.0587686934,
-0.0119004622,
0.0219977796,
0.0308254249,
-0.0576455928,
-0.0172930546,
0.0664397851,
-0.0713389143,
-0.0221307911,
-0.0019519383,
0.0021912449,
-0.0320160352,
-0.0203936342,
0.0396888331,
0.0155700697,
0.0118770022,
-0.0378260426,
0.0337912627,
-0.0512828007,
-0.0116200391,
-0.0187502876,
-0.01235379,
0.0222696122,
-0.0382905416,
0.0190876555,
0.0372671038,
0.0338337421,
-0.0040855794,
0.056959413,
-0.070314467,
-0.0104115903,
-0.0374397859,
0.0373466387,
0.0321944691,
-0.0085834367,
-0.0174556114,
0.0821374133,
0.0354342721,
-0.0374739729,
-0.0600938983,
-0.0097349621,
0.0090610534,
0.0424916297,
0.0623363554,
0.0617760308,
0.0562301539,
-0.0183963943,
-0.0853077993,
0.0266392473,
0.0089474339,
0.0206293687,
0.0588034652,
0.01623163,
-0.0344314091,
-0.0075478493,
-0.039382562,
-0.0844561085,
-0.0438809022,
-0.0514789075,
0.025716871,
-0.0109933987,
-0.0597554296,
0.04588902,
-0.0023861236,
-0.0816174597,
0.0301740598,
0.0644053742,
-0.0162536334,
0.0147925755,
0.0094775083,
0.0014547955,
-0.0301226526,
-0.0188059639,
-0.0019175959,
0.0379796661,
0.0426930785,
-0.0049440484,
0.0498299859,
-0.0062435013,
-0.0404082872,
-0.0148355151,
-0.0340709165,
-0.0344160125,
-0.0271273106,
0.024597086,
0.0022710569,
0.0184935033,
-0.0320342295,
0.029760018,
-0.0033992203,
0.0019858181,
0.0130617516,
-0.0214280598,
-0.0072362241,
0.0502312556,
-0.0481913015,
-0.0621400699,
-0.0273053907,
-0.0152811632,
0.0473192818,
-0.0658095479,
-0.0189495422,
-0.0033590209,
2.711e-7,
0.0338643193,
0.0177814662,
0.0204562228,
-0.0397791751,
0.0328457952,
0.0655542389,
0.0322195701,
0.017134143,
-0.015709646,
-0.0193781629,
0.0384468101,
0.0432648621,
0.0407176539,
0.003152359,
-0.0395352319,
-0.0041399249,
-0.0463406406,
-0.0161566772,
-0.0254569277,
0.0106147202,
0.0715347156,
0.0934938416,
0.0605825,
-0.0333512574,
0.060173206,
-0.0206551347,
0.0107063381,
-0.0500867367,
0.0359903984,
-0.0170865376,
0.0514436588,
0.0058154031,
0.0085915616,
0.0254536513,
-0.0055419253,
0.0285663344,
-0.014011154,
0.0264627393,
-0.0114332894,
-0.0141398571,
-0.0332082361,
-0.0470515303,
0.0111123966,
-0.0689753667,
0.0797871873,
-0.0521104634,
-0.047877796,
-0.004503225,
-0.0449305847,
-0.0428345241,
0.0170901325,
0.009767931,
0.0149178859,
-0.0092722988,
-0.0076782154,
-0.0510690361,
0.0031974243,
-0.0729456469,
-0.018860992,
0.0072984337,
-0.0345005728,
0.0385642014,
-0.0450896807,
0.0033229098,
0.0988143384,
-0.0467387252,
0.0311016962,
2.446779323e-34,
0.0236464571,
0.0393072776,
0.0172220375,
-0.009804152,
0.0425476395,
-0.0018775704,
0.0549428277,
-0.0160818454,
0.0514691211,
-0.0445413701,
-0.0057454854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16995v1 | Quality > Quantity: Synthetic Corpora from Foundation Models for Closed-Domain Extractive Question Answering | 2023-10-25T20:48:16 | 2023-10-25T20:48:16 | Saptarshi Sengupta, Connor Heaton, Shreya Ghosh, Preslav Nakov, Prasenjit Mitra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain adaptation, the process of training a model in one domain and applying
it to another, has been extensively explored in machine learning. While
training a domain-specific foundation model (FM) from scratch is an option,
recent methods have focused on adapting pre-trained FMs for domain-specific
tasks. However, our experiments reveal that either approach does not
consistently achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA) results in the target domain. In
this work, we study extractive question answering within closed domains and
introduce the concept of targeted pre-training. This involves determining and
generating relevant data to further pre-train our models, as opposed to the
conventional philosophy of utilizing domain-specific FMs trained on a wide
range of data. Our proposed framework uses Galactica to generate synthetic,
``targeted'' corpora that align with specific writing styles and topics, such
as research papers and radiology reports. This process can be viewed as a form
of knowledge distillation. We apply our method to two biomedical extractive
question answering datasets, COVID-QA and RadQA, achieving a new benchmark on
the former and demonstrating overall improvements on the latter. Code available
at https://github.com/saptarshi059/CDQA-v1-Targetted-PreTraining/tree/main. | [
0.0673705041,
0.0634732619,
-0.0081936112,
-0.0035066325,
-0.000409038,
0.0157286953,
-0.0104697384,
0.0109881721,
-0.0447726957,
-0.0181024615,
-0.0678444803,
-0.0515905768,
-0.0382762775,
0.042398192,
0.0067027328,
-0.0367087014,
0.0550088547,
0.0031476805,
-0.0075463094,
-0.0069057699,
0.0004916172,
0.0141756842,
-0.0054073166,
-0.0073020183,
0.0228432082,
-0.043366909,
0.0278141126,
-0.0158263724,
0.0171856955,
-0.0054355911,
0.0568863042,
0.067141667,
0.0340194777,
0.007471608,
0.000001817,
-0.0499720983,
-0.0262021255,
0.0105466349,
-0.051560279,
0.0005604808,
0.0139331901,
-0.0343241133,
0.0259254854,
0.0198321082,
-0.0619745031,
-0.0611002222,
0.0279808901,
0.0256313961,
0.0777269676,
0.0787649453,
0.0060251988,
-0.0467873886,
0.0467073768,
-0.0310803279,
-0.0425603092,
-0.0262811687,
0.0277296025,
0.0382306091,
0.0253150053,
0.0187103022,
-0.0069104522,
0.0144800982,
0.030769743,
0.0299145821,
0.0125532458,
0.0213850774,
-0.0573456623,
-0.0001709788,
0.0003669304,
0.1102331877,
0.0357667021,
-0.0274005774,
0.0172563177,
0.0326149203,
-0.016589107,
0.0065187924,
-0.0536659211,
-0.0115539003,
-0.0094622942,
0.0033177524,
0.0204155669,
0.0195794404,
0.0049018664,
0.0204053391,
-0.0195942279,
0.0243776981,
0.0170596689,
-0.0406974256,
0.0163710993,
0.0432943068,
-0.0270278994,
-0.0421259999,
-0.007816514,
0.0463419333,
-0.0169667657,
0.012461016,
-0.0627204627,
-0.024320906,
0.0359796435,
-0.0006523514,
0.0112837963,
-0.0010558239,
-0.0135660525,
0.0421649553,
-0.019024564,
0.0032172909,
-0.0424680188,
0.0355073437,
-0.0423243232,
-0.0336737521,
-0.0536346026,
-0.022091521,
-0.041521579,
0.0345150195,
-0.034781076,
0.014948979,
-0.0157240294,
-0.0018321474,
0.0276748519,
-0.0531682186,
0.0261654537,
0.0238448214,
-0.0607846826,
-0.0108048934,
-0.0087755313,
0.0305530317,
-0.0778126344,
0.038444113,
0.0055948491,
-0.072977297,
-0.0534675755,
0.010979251,
-0.0098193595,
-0.0371907353,
0.0326283947,
0.0654577538,
-0.0020097585,
-0.0181840993,
-0.0066375406,
-0.0245710276,
0.0217884555,
-0.074899368,
0.0315626934,
-0.047677733,
0.0356001407,
0.0034906259,
-0.0205959212,
-0.0321474411,
-0.0116761709,
0.0223177634,
-0.013405838,
0.0576186255,
-0.0499698855,
0.0013789248,
0.0282323454,
0.0146598713,
-0.0310225282,
0.0661235303,
0.029177215,
-0.0187603142,
0.0329253972,
0.0057829302,
0.0084695406,
0.0084603466,
0.0483404845,
0.0091599086,
0.036855571,
0.0681642666,
-0.039986629,
0.0249606706,
0.0410801731,
0.0155049246,
-0.0276622195,
-0.0151054477,
0.0057272497,
0.0364495404,
0.0547655523,
0.0332747996,
0.0508663468,
-0.0154884784,
0.0272171982,
0.0159259681,
-0.0337166004,
-0.0008076185,
0.0096814251,
0.0218651593,
-0.024538083,
0.0267595183,
-0.0479455777,
-0.0146356095,
0.0367605425,
0.0008457979,
-0.0407431088,
-0.0009786776,
0.0476234928,
0.0539170019,
-0.0122051062,
0.0340017453,
0.0486104712,
-0.0327247828,
0.0177834537,
-0.0236648303,
0.0451991223,
-0.012179167,
0.0460086502,
-0.0510924719,
-0.0570473075,
-0.0004800702,
0.0199785549,
0.0362785831,
0.0225419141,
-0.033278089,
0.0259225015,
-0.0422784202,
0.0021393481,
-0.021762494,
0.0096261846,
0.0154040027,
0.0361688063,
0.0311211478,
0.0101502091,
-0.0696169287,
0.0036351976,
0.0511776395,
-0.0744066834,
-0.0429614373,
0.000870741,
-0.0083963023,
0.0289135203,
0.0179008171,
-0.0446119569,
0.0141114453,
0.0331545994,
-0.0538924076,
-0.0345271416,
-0.0143984398,
-0.0448638722,
-0.0597117729,
-0.0001738824,
-0.0561440997,
-0.0195371788,
0.0492143817,
-0.0555900261,
-0.0191399641,
-0.0038205115,
-0.0090355817,
0.0016817345,
-0.0453138314,
-0.0346693657,
0.0198883247,
0.0326651335,
-0.0478152633,
0.0457807817,
0.0123134376,
0.0004165455,
0.0039319354,
-0.0337981544,
0.0157193784,
-0.0173032153,
0.0366982296,
-0.0091934707,
-0.0058551193,
0.0294998661,
-0.0007575966,
0.0282124802,
-0.0477198586,
-0.0136652319,
-0.0459652245,
0.0265914202,
-0.0264854524,
0.0383300446,
0.0775748491,
0.02948354,
-0.0325593501,
-0.0336154588,
-0.0591007359,
-0.0302285273,
0.0174539275,
0.0189691857,
0.0533918329,
0.0326398276,
0.0349794552,
-0.0503381193,
-0.015384594,
-0.0253925323,
0.0389312282,
-0.0165699851,
-0.0062789773,
-0.0361579023,
0.0088371178,
-0.0054825996,
0.0290993508,
0.0023611432,
-0.023507677,
-0.0036745684,
-0.0153323142,
-0.0156167801,
0.057500869,
0.0048074988,
0.0094916373,
0.0034480381,
0.0385053791,
-0.0164305773,
0.0243968647,
-0.0513471179,
0.0320196599,
-0.0130090006,
-0.0080779791,
0.0659543797,
0.0612377003,
-0.0099705392,
-0.0137867704,
-0.0448263846,
0.0252754297,
-0.0082343845,
-0.0110141328,
0.0063921362,
0.0509559512,
-0.0098050367,
0.0399723426,
-0.014847408,
-0.0227168016,
0.081050314,
-0.0104019782,
-0.0122932764,
-0.0909252912,
-0.0017855882,
-0.0664494187,
0.0026951707,
-0.0158754457,
-0.0008073686,
0.0487702154,
-0.008157758,
-0.0477045067,
0.0187139846,
-0.0244105104,
-0.0171567257,
0.0319654904,
-0.0213572383,
0.0103814472,
-0.0080861058,
-0.0530198924,
-0.0545238927,
-0.0504258499,
-0.0069507263,
0.0285974592,
-0.0341583826,
-0.0033818833,
-0.0405117124,
-0.0073655806,
-0.0071561323,
0.0392079912,
-0.0350330397,
0.0070326789,
-0.0234619565,
0.082017161,
0.074313879,
0.0569503233,
-0.0117109455,
-0.0315395668,
0.0189463049,
0.0535916425,
0.0038807064,
0.0143235782,
-0.0088869883,
-0.0045372671,
0.0122547708,
-0.0321680047,
-0.0039858236,
-0.0149728935,
0.0692723319,
-0.0202528425,
-0.0507091098,
0.1024867818,
0.0147889666,
0.0077016656,
0.0047857589,
-0.0000849976,
0.0450762957,
0.0138742859,
0.0631306693,
-0.0835459083,
-0.0499633886,
-0.0522417128,
0.0479852371,
0.0235763323,
-0.0248774346,
-0.0092809852,
-0.1007325798,
0.0160591956,
-0.0297662187,
-0.0651229545,
-0.0273163617,
-0.0088790227,
0.0258631855,
-0.0208834782,
-0.0341485329,
-0.0121734794,
-0.0086519672,
0.0352120511,
0.0535878912,
-0.004551061,
-0.0635576248,
0.0159254577,
-0.0229629874,
0.0210689977,
0.0675662607,
0.0083426321,
-0.0107234679,
-0.021174904,
-0.0287958309,
-0.0639477,
-0.003295921,
-0.0003901623,
0.0903756842,
-0.011721421,
-0.0106426263,
-0.0010515997,
0.0474537052,
-0.0614727251,
-0.001703747,
0.0374385267,
0.0520351306,
-0.0026387486,
-0.0274124779,
-0.0702776462,
0.0020538287,
0.0147126233,
0.0723599568,
0.039547082,
-0.0587319247,
-0.0367951393,
0.002925887,
0.0072733494,
-0.0669344217,
-0.0458025113,
0.0095771234,
-0.0076709273,
0.0296614133,
-0.094003506,
-0.0571189374,
0.0002090073,
0.0536628403,
-0.0184838325,
-0.0143078081,
0.0042228093,
0.0142951002,
-0.0417163,
0.03942338,
-0.0291633029,
-0.022754319,
-0.0756904334,
-0.0355303064,
0.0550266914,
-0.0185626,
-0.0559622608,
-0.0028055746,
-0.0217376128,
-0.0280020181,
0.0091585834,
0.053995382,
0.0239571705,
0.0224160049,
-0.0392352752,
-0.0168517604,
0.0685482025,
0.0058620959,
-0.0541256964,
0.0075848494,
0.0531359278,
-0.0731242225,
-0.0190808829,
0.0376077667,
-0.0178829655,
0.0599647872,
0.0251758993,
0.0454720892,
-0.0307022873,
-0.0011005303,
0.0269844588,
0.0109373927,
0.0402541049,
0.0119646396,
0.0249632727,
-0.0246821549,
0.0034439666,
0.0048209494,
0.0126846777,
-0.0335163251,
-0.0092776408,
0.027180532,
-0.0191831421,
0.0027892645,
0.015414821,
-0.0685507357,
0.0529180728,
-0.0382772982,
-0.0105147948,
0.0848853737,
0.0485533439,
-0.0075558005,
-0.0320020728,
-0.0059349085,
-0.0119677316,
0.0071103633,
0.0631109998,
-0.0296801571,
0.0237332266,
0.0285017509,
0.0102073895,
0.0153097371,
0.0510922819,
-0.0943254903,
-0.033082813,
-0.0287382249,
0.003949434,
0.0175053068,
-0.0100229755,
0.0266948231,
0.0101846382,
-0.0101769166,
-0.0300239623,
0.0052143671,
0.0009587237,
0.0565809011,
0.0667543635,
0.0289790742,
-0.0145499175,
-0.0083494624,
0.1001447514,
-0.0014765951,
0.0867230818,
-0.021221105,
0.0135277202,
-0.0389117524,
-0.023832025,
-0.0222246144,
-0.0250210147,
-0.0011091764,
0.0309942886,
-0.0656800866,
-0.0562833659,
0.0417634696,
-0.0257712062,
-0.0107509363,
0.0056387754,
0.057223741,
0.0354665667,
-0.0079620983,
-0.0151344817,
-0.0456415266,
0.0433186814,
-0.0150797712,
-0.03958093,
0.0091953194,
-6.511772179e-33,
-0.015835084,
0.0344304927,
0.0193301551,
-0.0228982195,
-0.0065221773,
0.0146223456,
-0.0390805602,
-0.0213062018,
-0.0470269471,
0.0093639791,
-0.0257976055,
0.0021764438,
0.0046990248,
0.0504117943,
-0.0534946211,
-0.017559886,
0.0090676676,
-0.0072874096,
-0.0365581252,
0.0110183749,
0.0080023129,
0.0634279847,
0.0541269705,
-0.0670013428,
-0.0130873937,
-0.0231601465,
0.0117760468,
0.0206798874,
0.0118381232,
0.0641504526,
-0.0255512223,
0.0413229316,
0.0386146419,
-0.0619157329,
0.0161869656,
0.0520539768,
-0.1053809449,
-0.0452477857,
0.0124045704,
-0.0103781521,
-0.0504216924,
-0.0300541576,
0.0075994921,
-0.0162417367,
0.0444351509,
-0.0272329953,
0.0251462292,
-0.0282080285,
0.0101674078,
-0.048925411,
-0.0711068735,
0.0179938897,
0.0180077683,
-0.0162061639,
-0.0353558846,
0.0544088334,
-0.0309002511,
0.0582357533,
0.0018121147,
0.0009327214,
0.0355371013,
0.0526469946,
0.0148514397,
0.0084387669,
-0.0144883255,
0.0468964651,
-0.0120033445,
-0.0312826745,
0.0097037023,
0.0133449696,
-0.0154004004,
0.016638875,
0.0119515145,
0.08386942,
0.0321742296,
0.0202952959,
-0.1132586598,
0.0422144197,
-0.0454990566,
0.0189601313,
-0.0301781632,
-0.0427607447,
0.002487788,
0.0151082398,
-0.0305826738,
-0.0006030226,
0.0116890064,
-0.0279435143,
0.0410409681,
-0.0244326685,
-0.0565518625,
0.0162219573,
-0.0012479405,
-0.0668791831,
0.0253715981,
0.0292304642,
-0.0436150283,
0.0031030017,
0.0181563236,
0.0294197258,
-0.0521770492,
-0.0065809875,
0.0397791937,
0.0036494434,
0.0264354479,
0.01205872,
0.0481797457,
-0.0170616712,
-0.0361161791,
-0.0158409495,
-0.0070725102,
0.0481444001,
-0.0040316405,
0.0628311038,
-0.0055723866,
0.0534411855,
-0.0206161216,
0.0461180322,
0.0077471402,
0.0122991055,
-0.0341322683,
-0.0073156273,
0.0326968059,
0.0609950274,
-0.0482852496,
-0.0241456646,
-0.0173143055,
0.0295774676,
-0.0177341551,
-0.0809815302,
-0.0220380351,
0.0074696327,
2.553e-7,
0.0925788283,
0.0249505844,
0.040210437,
-0.0070547275,
0.0284761172,
0.0199637748,
0.0111014098,
0.0469491556,
0.0045652874,
-0.0279046707,
-0.0115035344,
0.0266654026,
0.0339583158,
0.0261650961,
-0.0906157568,
-0.0003426672,
-0.0412361138,
-0.0111881346,
-0.0170424189,
-0.0221490022,
0.0111913793,
0.0908828974,
-0.0099362666,
-0.0460470319,
-0.0249579158,
-0.0238910187,
0.0536352322,
0.0254536644,
-0.0223604608,
0.0501268767,
-0.0192096792,
0.0085494211,
-0.0060947016,
0.0084267082,
-0.032500919,
0.0200473908,
0.0271221772,
0.0652679279,
-0.0089201052,
-0.0266341604,
0.0173314624,
-0.0033036629,
0.0377470031,
0.0039580921,
0.0671117529,
-0.0567460582,
-0.0319236591,
-0.024676742,
-0.0303562358,
-0.0037956228,
0.0180855133,
-0.0396974981,
-0.0055117058,
0.035891559,
0.040201582,
0.0044676671,
-0.0114923371,
-0.0477894098,
0.0119205266,
0.0418184139,
-0.0332443342,
-0.0309899189,
0.0076611284,
-0.0271191578,
0.0067432341,
-0.0788699687,
0.0404384471,
2.316651869e-34,
0.021435868,
0.0058295773,
0.0117606595,
0.0363043584,
-0.0077119675,
-0.0181193072,
0.0039299321,
-0.0326514505,
0.0218669791,
-0.0773761272,
0.0130984914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16992v1 | How well can machine-generated texts be identified and can language models be trained to avoid identification? | 2023-10-25T20:43:07 | 2023-10-25T20:43:07 | Sinclair Schneider, Florian Steuber, Joao A. G. Schneider, Gabi Dreo Rodosek | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rise of generative pre-trained transformer models such as GPT-3,
GPT-NeoX, or OPT, distinguishing human-generated texts from machine-generated
ones has become important. We refined five separate language models to generate
synthetic tweets, uncovering that shallow learning classification algorithms,
like Naive Bayes, achieve detection accuracy between 0.6 and 0.8.
Shallow learning classifiers differ from human-based detection, especially
when using higher temperature values during text generation, resulting in a
lower detection rate. Humans prioritize linguistic acceptability, which tends
to be higher at lower temperature values. In contrast, transformer-based
classifiers have an accuracy of 0.9 and above. We found that using a
reinforcement learning approach to refine our generative models can
successfully evade BERT-based classifiers with a detection accuracy of 0.15 or
less. | [
0.0587801598,
0.0464896336,
-0.0084302863,
0.025196882,
-0.0233340319,
0.0399015173,
0.0180916078,
0.0312971212,
0.0179840252,
-0.0618223883,
-0.0068046548,
-0.0007000226,
-0.0193978176,
0.0259358808,
0.0147050554,
-0.0420462303,
0.0101558762,
0.0046523544,
0.035682831,
0.0021079674,
0.0259482637,
0.026526073,
0.0438167788,
0.0213229749,
-0.0089551602,
0.0025699961,
0.0221013688,
0.0054577854,
0.0077394503,
0.0080281803,
0.0447019525,
0.0967156887,
-0.0017701413,
0.1243048236,
0.0000017704,
-0.025277067,
-0.0385807343,
-0.0296859015,
-0.0011083297,
-0.0363803953,
0.078122519,
-0.0486175492,
-0.0279292241,
0.0376468152,
-0.0462597497,
-0.0351850875,
0.0507791042,
0.0862232223,
0.0204956438,
0.0960455239,
-0.0249912757,
0.0094575454,
0.0389320068,
0.0050713099,
0.0319764204,
-0.0241751783,
0.0104378266,
-0.0831446797,
-0.0113863172,
-0.0011822751,
0.0346435197,
0.0296747275,
0.0020627596,
-0.0130684096,
-0.036812488,
0.0408377759,
-0.0256623495,
-0.0285410341,
-0.0154334772,
0.0098084537,
-0.044162102,
-0.0701848418,
0.039403975,
-0.0058865999,
0.0153147951,
0.0211910233,
0.0151154567,
0.0444746502,
-0.0250255689,
0.0056285593,
-0.0049039754,
-0.0080731874,
0.0185982808,
0.0376630612,
0.0097481171,
0.0303379819,
0.0093950732,
-0.0414388143,
-0.0288484711,
0.0398417711,
0.0011038007,
-0.0623885579,
0.0223011356,
0.0009331717,
-0.0353149883,
-0.0109298881,
-0.1135636419,
-0.0528181717,
0.0016244898,
-0.0355745777,
0.0218116082,
0.0083030788,
0.0143953357,
0.0014093239,
-0.0424470827,
0.0257022213,
-0.0149212824,
0.0334563069,
0.0075594559,
0.0053088395,
-0.0176932905,
-0.0330729671,
-0.0286973808,
0.0021736308,
0.0183784943,
-0.0032364768,
-0.0608425625,
0.031028768,
-0.0141368154,
-0.0059743021,
-0.0315096229,
-0.0006042088,
-0.0525852665,
0.0133261532,
-0.0072887829,
-0.0143916495,
0.0010055373,
0.0242495779,
0.0069336165,
-0.0742733181,
0.0041000289,
0.04029819,
0.0605810434,
-0.0148566244,
0.0082630804,
0.0567926764,
-0.0256000236,
-0.0531610511,
-0.0385141596,
-0.0378806442,
-0.0045334916,
-0.0478958525,
0.0163183734,
-0.0602410361,
-0.0294761695,
0.0048801028,
-0.0158250295,
-0.0226103347,
-0.0044482467,
0.0373126604,
-0.0332572162,
0.0429081209,
-0.0293130111,
-0.0004126173,
0.0308389235,
0.0045214323,
-0.000061023,
0.0452427603,
0.0443318784,
0.0892097279,
0.0330379196,
-0.0336848013,
0.058165364,
0.0474022515,
-0.0036738096,
0.0036153703,
-0.000367518,
-0.0574329123,
-0.0361173786,
-0.0089510828,
0.0021229675,
0.0839250907,
0.0009596595,
0.0095418831,
0.098015368,
0.0487041324,
-0.0014670491,
0.0331798382,
0.0529945306,
0.0419837721,
-0.0008856755,
0.0307006277,
-0.0404695943,
-0.0138933193,
-0.0504092872,
0.0012590769,
0.0097962189,
-0.0009929198,
-0.0076952614,
-0.0195585452,
0.0036118904,
-0.0450069271,
0.0175261367,
-0.0424060039,
0.0502097867,
0.0169360023,
-0.0405883156,
0.007904863,
-0.0126565527,
-0.0540643372,
0.0130368508,
-0.0514094196,
0.0280322805,
0.053359516,
0.0247432049,
0.0054093944,
0.0290942974,
-0.0468917973,
-0.0252244826,
0.0708677545,
0.0263044573,
0.0192050431,
-0.0211556144,
-0.0036540001,
-0.0161606334,
0.0149575947,
0.02472586,
0.0113683473,
0.0313990712,
0.0087437332,
0.0170061383,
0.0020223951,
-0.0310503021,
0.03674604,
-0.0257606003,
-0.049982287,
0.0244559757,
0.0032073432,
0.010846681,
0.0207280982,
-0.0204051454,
-0.0008405059,
-0.0025313399,
-0.0187413413,
-0.0396655388,
0.0240129512,
-0.0292255394,
-0.0001509318,
0.0005244456,
-0.0231565032,
-0.0495959707,
0.0440928265,
-0.0278231502,
-0.0171833262,
0.035246186,
-0.0699939579,
0.0369861238,
-0.0743388608,
0.0055262423,
-0.0469367057,
0.0063195424,
0.0057907081,
0.0780113339,
-0.0097229425,
0.0132380705,
-0.0080899177,
-0.044426322,
0.0327453688,
-0.0249758605,
-0.0091918129,
-0.0249739066,
-0.0381326787,
0.0251014996,
0.0484988652,
0.0348798968,
-0.0232407339,
-0.0464666486,
-0.063009344,
-0.0006288459,
-0.0363313854,
-0.000775493,
0.0229827184,
0.0116088549,
-0.0198750943,
0.0165566728,
-0.0240778495,
-0.0349716432,
0.0413395464,
0.011575968,
0.0238007922,
-0.0298495423,
0.0232899897,
-0.0148394834,
0.0061488603,
-0.0436519384,
0.0574675985,
0.0419358537,
-0.0212792158,
-0.0374301523,
0.0351265632,
0.0001473288,
0.0254180245,
0.0232169013,
-0.0468344651,
0.0098699844,
-0.0037950622,
0.0356586985,
0.0420243852,
0.055943992,
0.040382728,
0.0040668468,
0.0370243341,
-0.0247359723,
-0.0067072595,
-0.0392161831,
-0.0039489469,
-0.0315720141,
-0.0645905659,
0.0256244112,
0.0707817897,
-0.006549241,
0.009064259,
-0.0332779177,
0.0714892969,
0.0115161734,
-0.0411623679,
0.0221145861,
-0.0035381129,
-0.0433209464,
0.015547893,
-0.0350539349,
-0.0810964853,
0.0859273672,
-0.0245860666,
0.0270151738,
-0.0580182001,
-0.0494921915,
0.0228253584,
-0.0163449068,
0.0313500129,
0.0415952541,
0.02512284,
-0.0273060389,
-0.0220935699,
0.0033981486,
0.036212422,
-0.026424937,
0.0255213268,
0.0178172458,
0.0026917148,
-0.0006457206,
-0.0145625686,
-0.0641896278,
-0.06093999,
-0.020724332,
-0.0026039521,
0.0470480174,
-0.0689542815,
-0.0420889184,
-0.0094414875,
0.025948545,
0.0429556742,
-0.0141441552,
-0.0217620023,
-0.0388366319,
0.0554411188,
0.0347969383,
-0.0278712586,
0.0168925244,
-0.0361914374,
-0.0288107172,
0.0370222107,
0.0119678136,
0.0074453391,
-0.0176802725,
-0.0096688475,
0.0080892304,
-0.0180790126,
0.0024238841,
0.024299914,
0.0152024636,
-0.0228877869,
-0.017104229,
0.1206267253,
0.0103183463,
-0.045832485,
-0.0126375128,
0.0283705778,
0.0520349964,
-0.0138297724,
0.0149779757,
-0.0761918947,
-0.0068405066,
0.0129757877,
0.041876182,
-0.0710698217,
-0.0090943808,
-0.0025174189,
-0.0966563448,
0.0224100761,
-0.0106353434,
-0.028194366,
-0.0038596331,
-0.0194948167,
-0.0229248032,
0.0241081938,
-0.0100518009,
-0.0420684144,
-0.0272428952,
0.0121260844,
0.0125599178,
-0.0240492094,
-0.0622506887,
-0.0103331273,
-0.0481498502,
0.0063734674,
0.0676518455,
0.0287384205,
-0.0507056974,
-0.0355813839,
0.0057688239,
0.0037402206,
-0.0154988868,
-0.0089460174,
0.0434960499,
-0.0143175432,
-0.0020554315,
-0.0331070237,
0.0415963307,
-0.01246145,
-0.0230836887,
-0.0443574302,
0.0559120513,
-0.0035086758,
-0.0853664353,
0.0087750629,
-0.0111095747,
0.0271530282,
0.061587967,
0.0346401893,
-0.0470532812,
-0.077042006,
-0.0533414856,
0.0626251623,
-0.0607912652,
-0.0405920073,
-0.0068753222,
-0.0210900474,
-0.0956350416,
-0.0682889447,
-0.0111301076,
-0.0107225794,
0.0198853463,
-0.0002266014,
0.0028168173,
0.0191641618,
0.0138310762,
-0.0553023927,
0.005394415,
-0.0127735604,
0.001148125,
-0.0522703826,
-0.0246767923,
0.0040066065,
-0.0303612445,
-0.0028294558,
0.0032014665,
-0.0479135253,
-0.047671631,
0.0146425003,
0.0354150236,
0.0267895907,
0.0063823964,
-0.0163014922,
-0.0710347444,
0.0589392222,
0.1197440997,
-0.0208864715,
-0.0059176232,
0.0296412893,
-0.0081192702,
-0.0108178249,
0.0095065217,
-0.0341239497,
0.0247269385,
0.036689233,
-0.0386044681,
-0.0332452543,
-0.0049566529,
0.03143695,
-0.0113612395,
0.0330500975,
-0.0212299172,
-0.0099441642,
-0.0327051729,
-0.0576733574,
0.0040119444,
-0.0081021124,
-0.0353868492,
-0.0336094312,
0.0314878225,
0.0496755354,
-0.0216016136,
0.032500308,
-0.0364711769,
0.0573417619,
-0.0459550098,
0.0205233507,
0.0331688821,
0.0677131712,
-0.0046183467,
-0.0214960556,
-0.0085457191,
0.0330687352,
0.0170887597,
0.0271021537,
-0.0067550731,
0.0293403156,
0.0055488693,
-0.0176297333,
-0.0149931135,
0.021930743,
-0.0653854981,
0.0064421436,
-0.0734326988,
0.0236577764,
0.0398609415,
-0.0194937643,
0.0256692003,
-0.0392630473,
-0.0079297461,
-0.0186842624,
0.0297234152,
-0.0074261837,
-0.027877951,
-0.0115283746,
-0.0123502733,
-0.0458222926,
0.007183732,
0.0718596801,
0.0508034825,
0.0382398628,
0.0078165084,
-0.0441719405,
-0.0312867016,
-0.0099819982,
0.0248297937,
-0.00860707,
-0.0012279284,
0.0093351873,
-0.0343577266,
-0.0653563738,
0.0325894877,
-0.0113944011,
0.054938823,
-0.0092191333,
-0.0130640687,
0.071376048,
-0.0307629872,
-0.0103045302,
-0.0532393232,
0.0122259976,
0.0170127712,
-0.0479596592,
-0.0183775611,
-6.10923369e-33,
0.0242576003,
-0.0663660318,
-0.0345786251,
-0.008659347,
0.0039236206,
0.0002348515,
-0.0341932513,
0.0066960771,
0.0179386716,
0.0280199591,
-0.0156389382,
-0.0002008361,
0.0141528081,
0.0306064729,
-0.012541295,
-0.0076295966,
0.0488406755,
-0.0168647673,
-0.0323712677,
0.0406371206,
0.0587126948,
0.022877194,
0.0343835875,
-0.084302865,
-0.0068015279,
-0.0469386615,
-0.0256551467,
-0.0017055601,
0.0056361435,
0.0533280894,
-0.0298875421,
0.0169766899,
0.0360983238,
-0.0072134249,
-0.0082032792,
0.0872001648,
-0.0274000745,
-0.0082423706,
-0.0310470108,
-0.0036901559,
0.0050759427,
-0.0717928931,
0.0699277595,
-0.0374347344,
-0.0435729362,
0.0241257381,
0.0462534465,
0.0071319607,
0.020651944,
-0.0661926195,
-0.0589802861,
0.0247648172,
0.020070402,
0.0037877155,
0.030331729,
0.035173513,
0.0153525211,
0.0231939163,
-0.061327368,
0.0393531695,
0.0351863168,
0.0082995659,
0.0415838137,
0.0171893667,
-0.0354806259,
0.0398269929,
0.0232626926,
0.0326972865,
-0.0119322361,
-0.0232523438,
0.0277194697,
0.0293786414,
0.0615473315,
0.0916794911,
0.0417731889,
-0.0364643596,
-0.0329419971,
0.0489020459,
-0.0101238545,
-0.0056348247,
0.0482883118,
-0.0328001827,
-0.0257038102,
-0.0067182076,
-0.0139171788,
-0.0508969575,
-0.0363197364,
-0.0004131182,
0.0071662767,
0.0106223412,
-0.0381164104,
-0.02051563,
0.0387880467,
-0.0669343546,
0.0153565537,
0.0125811724,
-0.0232283939,
0.0318118446,
-0.0008364892,
0.0123049375,
-0.0313777514,
-0.0563068353,
0.0384864695,
0.013302546,
0.0125746205,
0.0164876059,
0.0508108996,
0.0370082632,
-0.0555807203,
0.02863295,
0.0029916111,
0.0551295429,
-0.0086230421,
0.0039746487,
0.0059424611,
-0.0377915353,
0.0175304469,
-0.0188144371,
0.0453338735,
0.0166505426,
-0.0257387143,
0.0296963174,
-0.0280973781,
0.009309114,
-0.0077854428,
0.0075850226,
-0.0334229134,
0.0506774671,
0.0283252914,
-0.0708764046,
0.0275439769,
-0.0192972068,
2.601e-7,
-0.0037463803,
0.0636195317,
0.0282292254,
-0.0187877566,
0.0322070681,
0.082648918,
0.0353446975,
0.0455682464,
-0.0047676419,
0.0185430571,
-0.0141877737,
-0.0301468205,
0.0572591759,
0.0353640988,
-0.0683138222,
-0.0085531147,
-0.0886634886,
0.0363307223,
-0.0530808419,
0.0078330338,
0.052973263,
0.0729267001,
0.0342148691,
-0.0216792449,
0.0279650223,
-0.0835630968,
0.073619619,
-0.0216561146,
0.0310544167,
0.0438758284,
0.0839983076,
-0.000169592,
0.0374281965,
-0.012568024,
-0.0442615449,
0.0062555098,
-0.0050253528,
0.0376047641,
0.0313657969,
-0.0043045431,
0.0110819424,
-0.0329521634,
0.0326367579,
-0.0692520961,
0.0293509644,
-0.0487392545,
-0.026815787,
-0.0049157236,
-0.0155441379,
-0.0624459833,
-0.0267598834,
-0.0364137329,
-0.0264183264,
0.0213603247,
0.0068628211,
0.0116125587,
0.0043032444,
-0.0600588247,
-0.014235368,
-0.0224842969,
-0.0420000292,
-0.0134476358,
-0.0406327285,
-0.0115181031,
0.0606509969,
-0.0134676294,
0.0515343472,
2.333016265e-34,
0.010424572,
-0.011409835,
-0.0200811867,
-0.0015151351,
0.0145264957,
0.0485254377,
0.0571303256,
0.0259306896,
0.0335163809,
-0.0386727527,
0.0211303029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16990v1 | STEER: Semantic Turn Extension-Expansion Recognition for Voice Assistants | 2023-10-25T20:41:30 | 2023-10-25T20:41:30 | Leon Liyang Zhang, Jiarui Lu, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Aditya Kulkarni, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Tien Dung Tran, Nicholas Tzou, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the context of a voice assistant system, steering refers to the phenomenon
in which a user issues a follow-up command attempting to direct or clarify a
previous turn. We propose STEER, a steering detection model that predicts
whether a follow-up turn is a user's attempt to steer the previous command.
Constructing a training dataset for steering use cases poses challenges due to
the cold-start problem. To overcome this, we developed heuristic rules to
sample opt-in usage data, approximating positive and negative samples without
any annotation. Our experimental results show promising performance in
identifying steering intent, with over 95% accuracy on our sampled data.
Moreover, STEER, in conjunction with our sampling strategy, aligns effectively
with real-world steering scenarios, as evidenced by its strong zero-shot
performance on a human-graded evaluation set. In addition to relying solely on
user transcripts as input, we introduce STEER+, an enhanced version of the
model. STEER+ utilizes a semantic parse tree to provide more context on
out-of-vocabulary words, such as named entities that often occur at the
sentence boundary. This further improves model performance, reducing error rate
in domains where entities frequently appear, such as messaging. Lastly, we
present a data analysis that highlights the improvement in user experience when
voice assistants support steering use cases. | [
0.0317965038,
-0.0219750144,
-0.011071207,
0.0136190206,
-0.0133025516,
-0.0126315607,
-0.039408654,
0.006289837,
-0.0287505779,
-0.062285196,
0.0278547276,
-0.0218007062,
-0.0043637883,
-0.0118159959,
0.0035548145,
-0.0721506104,
0.0456381701,
-0.0356411636,
-0.0062289769,
0.0285843238,
0.0257702135,
0.0249327049,
-0.0188356023,
0.098342225,
-0.0784171596,
0.0024536108,
-0.0332268663,
0.0500162542,
0.0088268965,
-0.0524311811,
-0.0046254881,
0.0187313706,
0.0184662733,
0.0553551428,
0.0000019446,
-0.0674815699,
-0.0170714185,
-0.0286257844,
-0.0803404301,
-0.059517324,
0.023977045,
0.0377039388,
0.0014310849,
0.0267280955,
-0.0105266962,
0.0190356318,
0.0231632236,
0.0605878197,
0.0401448309,
0.0452784151,
-0.0223910976,
-0.0203707926,
-0.0111963283,
0.0228052139,
0.021373922,
-0.0530110858,
-0.0046005105,
-0.039638821,
0.0019567003,
-0.0161158051,
-0.0073237862,
0.031178752,
0.0164355729,
-0.0057838457,
-0.0348093808,
0.0574955158,
0.0002466423,
-0.0093489969,
-0.016233217,
0.0737665445,
-0.0119255027,
-0.0187069662,
0.0247339141,
-0.0231026355,
-0.0175784752,
0.0062052468,
-0.0113999685,
-0.0488731079,
-0.001114635,
-0.0327206589,
-0.0076458976,
0.0279889982,
0.0194089431,
-0.0237181317,
-0.0261783954,
0.064185366,
0.0092125656,
-0.0498719923,
0.0332041457,
-0.0033842863,
0.0076028551,
-0.0275586117,
0.0286404379,
0.0059359861,
-0.0425379276,
0.032850869,
-0.0445906259,
-0.0012019081,
0.0073961485,
-0.0149782691,
0.0235581473,
0.0307622496,
-0.0338511057,
0.0360072106,
0.0192411542,
-0.0231282394,
0.0287847072,
0.0230471175,
-0.0160626117,
-0.0039316355,
-0.0334334671,
0.0337345935,
-0.0750192851,
-0.0079233423,
-0.0165125951,
-0.0225999746,
-0.0381565914,
0.0361845046,
0.0206240676,
-0.00093821,
0.0299695469,
0.0202081036,
0.0108719533,
0.0318197981,
0.0164674781,
-0.0136051588,
-0.0502889939,
0.0524744801,
0.0096419128,
-0.0427440889,
0.0002248544,
0.0135616353,
0.0316272564,
-0.0019647309,
-0.0067874142,
0.0719530508,
0.0109573798,
-0.0917932093,
-0.038086053,
-0.0401939154,
-0.0358469374,
-0.0222064853,
-0.0505913273,
-0.0477817431,
0.0419132039,
0.0067194849,
-0.0170801766,
0.0362514369,
-0.0083994092,
0.0313424245,
-0.0227275155,
0.0367962979,
-0.0305788051,
0.0501321554,
0.0309342276,
0.0054993951,
-0.0299023911,
0.0292747729,
0.0445600823,
0.018439034,
0.0758481622,
-0.0126900524,
0.0207488667,
0.0626378581,
-0.0108967694,
0.0073609632,
0.0228041708,
-0.0091978684,
-0.076291427,
0.0348208621,
-0.0113881957,
0.0138079124,
-0.0380536057,
-0.0269707479,
0.0118947877,
0.0946818814,
-0.002492713,
-0.0334200226,
0.0571779646,
-0.0103598079,
-0.0577659197,
-0.0070928745,
-0.0400196351,
-0.0383393355,
-0.0398678929,
-0.0044591464,
-0.0069466983,
-0.0306156576,
-0.0363766029,
-0.0197623353,
0.0077702533,
-0.038097769,
-0.0020745147,
-0.0074292081,
0.0269793943,
-0.0072117224,
-0.0331440717,
0.0121381124,
-0.0111448234,
-0.0726962462,
0.0048861913,
-0.0401722081,
0.0460101105,
0.09425883,
0.0433684289,
-0.0097944411,
-0.046866782,
-0.0259527992,
-0.000675917,
-0.0130707975,
-0.0124178845,
-0.0308695715,
0.0273685846,
-0.0227065515,
-0.0388545468,
0.0833895952,
-0.0125772329,
-0.0033727405,
-0.0173764639,
0.0070102476,
0.0453222021,
-0.0325696617,
0.021179596,
0.0270957425,
0.0538564101,
-0.0226291139,
-0.0007013446,
0.028242847,
0.0129304267,
0.050274536,
0.0012821044,
-0.0319654197,
0.0308804773,
-0.0021187551,
-0.0153211039,
0.0297670178,
-0.0614035055,
-0.0113227516,
0.0165881086,
-0.018335443,
-0.0256508235,
0.0085472269,
-0.0002540393,
-0.0675819367,
-0.0218842663,
-0.0438974462,
0.0762552917,
-0.0157368984,
0.041403275,
0.0502253026,
-0.0027473713,
0.010223723,
0.0260408483,
-0.0163226109,
0.0275708474,
0.0012776254,
-0.0287029427,
0.0244657416,
-0.0374934673,
-0.0212543979,
0.0207456965,
-0.0186104048,
-0.0178482067,
0.0262595508,
-0.0041552596,
-0.0723230392,
0.0334403887,
-0.1083557084,
-0.0131641785,
-0.044622805,
0.0108361263,
0.0203177519,
0.0473827906,
-0.0227484573,
-0.0338913053,
-0.0021906542,
-0.010006899,
0.003524547,
0.0044289748,
-0.0201449003,
-0.0020754349,
-0.0614436679,
-0.0504235141,
0.0207889993,
-0.0372338295,
-0.0147803156,
-0.0151258018,
-0.0300761275,
-0.0452180021,
-0.0147137875,
0.0045994292,
0.0476303548,
-0.0161483679,
-0.0192970745,
0.0157266818,
0.0058046011,
0.0283952244,
0.0278724991,
0.0080110682,
-0.01465197,
0.0032942716,
-0.0298555065,
-0.0602715872,
0.0064822743,
-0.0317837261,
0.0196579546,
-0.0434661172,
0.0015972673,
0.047616221,
0.0330115184,
0.0284938607,
0.0613957867,
-0.0297037903,
-0.0861564949,
-0.0298710354,
-0.0597863011,
-0.0016941575,
0.0258747526,
-0.057396628,
0.0590023547,
0.0141754383,
-0.0182012282,
0.0475961342,
-0.051005777,
-0.0404950269,
0.0013697818,
-0.0271466002,
0.008702849,
0.0467420556,
0.0048581879,
0.006525958,
-0.0061003072,
-0.0452512428,
0.0131665468,
-0.0009285733,
-0.0259754676,
-0.0086858775,
0.0848313794,
-0.0378405228,
0.0088141738,
0.0253370684,
0.0065008667,
-0.0443377458,
-0.0774287432,
-0.0135503644,
-0.0298658144,
0.0371664613,
-0.0477423482,
0.0128785605,
0.0232214313,
-0.0000588148,
0.0942423567,
0.0195051003,
-0.0033330419,
-0.0161688179,
-0.0055877226,
0.0635718554,
0.0329778455,
-0.0319818445,
0.0003548018,
0.0528405532,
0.0268711783,
0.0615632012,
-0.0474798232,
-0.0301748849,
-0.0282177515,
0.0454901829,
-0.0370377339,
-0.0492693409,
0.0629855841,
0.0630744696,
-0.0236135349,
0.0100661926,
0.1372613162,
0.0338849872,
-0.0274829715,
0.0190963633,
-0.0200927071,
0.0353815742,
0.0328473188,
-0.0084529612,
-0.0702197179,
-0.0670672432,
0.0156119894,
0.0527088046,
-0.005972988,
-0.0127786016,
0.0247626547,
-0.1137292907,
0.0229367409,
-0.0400760472,
-0.0658891052,
0.0416043922,
-0.0148989158,
0.0433327928,
-0.0063516474,
0.0032852751,
-0.0292449445,
-0.0259746742,
-0.0286733266,
0.0186732393,
-0.0425737947,
-0.008612941,
0.0498706438,
-0.0346204638,
0.0181203149,
0.0797854215,
0.0120823728,
0.0288310628,
-0.0362486765,
0.0050271945,
-0.0418192856,
0.0342296548,
-0.030290667,
0.0604512021,
-0.0492465682,
0.0296126548,
0.0343606398,
0.0407845154,
-0.0218354724,
0.0164713692,
0.0625432059,
0.0605027713,
-0.0455276184,
0.0229246598,
-0.0141898291,
0.0146446079,
0.0234214924,
0.0470668972,
0.0057454389,
-0.0366887972,
-0.0214243606,
0.0066570886,
-0.000372926,
-0.0074091777,
-0.018945083,
-0.0084056323,
-0.0253993478,
-0.0455015488,
-0.0412060879,
-0.0572553538,
0.051641304,
0.0304758083,
0.0134017775,
0.0193630867,
-0.0121414186,
0.0153688639,
-0.0022064541,
-0.0391720422,
-0.0065586013,
0.0666693896,
-0.0506905243,
0.0206263401,
0.0247647073,
0.0268921498,
-0.0019672937,
0.0450338535,
0.0004746385,
-0.0573239438,
0.0399273857,
0.0276828595,
0.0186270941,
0.0569681078,
-0.0411093608,
-0.0324355364,
-0.0256554559,
0.0258692596,
-0.0625686944,
0.0083715701,
0.0615602396,
0.0568559691,
-0.0153892152,
0.034046758,
-0.0582425818,
0.0251144767,
-0.0447422862,
0.0009016959,
-0.1166840196,
-0.0300687384,
0.0106556341,
0.0019700029,
0.077870436,
-0.020395508,
0.0713365525,
0.0012777941,
0.0521145053,
-0.0146686044,
0.0124164494,
-0.0227773096,
0.0001236384,
-0.0576650202,
0.0028813474,
-0.0050103865,
-0.0045190081,
-0.0764926597,
-0.021683896,
-0.0700854883,
0.0571863502,
0.0554676168,
0.0496354625,
-0.0135964416,
-0.0188097786,
0.0035104756,
-0.0003795423,
0.0346831232,
-0.004635232,
0.0120140146,
0.0545619801,
0.0017169006,
-0.0069523216,
-0.0184857417,
0.0144055206,
-0.0510537401,
-0.0158607326,
0.0140329003,
0.0441690534,
0.0398556329,
-0.0540655516,
0.0549091958,
0.0101956278,
0.033303123,
0.0061700521,
0.0407279581,
-0.0214695986,
-0.0447165631,
0.0313616917,
0.0212202519,
-0.0218540821,
-0.0065861233,
0.01976832,
-0.0301877111,
0.0407730378,
-0.0022982608,
0.0221221615,
-0.062619023,
-0.0418214239,
0.054912556,
0.0373840928,
-0.0145752579,
0.0017584875,
-0.0504164994,
-0.0342654996,
-0.0097909085,
-0.0036378275,
0.0419476964,
-0.0046793316,
0.0804237127,
0.0101024546,
-0.0147773093,
-0.0409439765,
-0.0106946705,
-0.0883887485,
-0.0196619295,
-0.0100724651,
-0.0594777837,
-5.800314876e-33,
0.0048795673,
-0.0092383204,
0.0231978092,
0.0087018134,
-0.0165342633,
-0.0023589008,
-0.0134346588,
0.0085749868,
0.0102935126,
-0.0266172867,
-0.0392668657,
0.0260834396,
0.0260918513,
0.0215295963,
0.005335418,
-0.0378246382,
0.0780395344,
-0.0114821224,
-0.0195999369,
0.0385554694,
0.076043956,
0.0086172316,
0.0500122346,
-0.1195200235,
0.0032967271,
-0.0050173732,
-0.0127087524,
0.0121221766,
0.0259876586,
0.0190251581,
0.0286498237,
0.0257040504,
0.0005928064,
-0.0491371118,
0.0013123589,
0.0161454659,
-0.0294229556,
-0.0345712118,
0.0152593777,
0.0237509888,
-0.0700376481,
0.0189813524,
0.0316860378,
0.000511421,
-0.0338884294,
0.0523343571,
0.0427748524,
0.0116200764,
-0.0157963932,
-0.0044501652,
-0.0476758927,
0.0172783304,
-0.0189763699,
-0.045034904,
0.0088275112,
0.0557857268,
0.0248924736,
-0.0343623385,
-0.0377134457,
0.0014711065,
-0.026046766,
0.0101255272,
0.0500143804,
0.0317102335,
-0.012842821,
0.0438337587,
-0.0191574376,
-0.0381699353,
-0.0129367374,
0.0013900851,
-0.0099991625,
0.0889641941,
-0.0158460047,
0.0054180678,
0.0482177287,
-0.0605998412,
0.0038285782,
0.0062269876,
0.0403747708,
0.0320685133,
-0.0078999521,
-0.0027776191,
-0.09549997,
0.0035852895,
-0.0166995805,
-0.0278022736,
-0.0098124165,
-0.0421406999,
0.0669151172,
0.0029381514,
0.0247026961,
-0.0168947354,
0.024273105,
-0.0107248733,
0.0200153068,
-0.0180239491,
-0.0184694305,
0.0104107549,
-0.0043154065,
-0.0309675131,
-0.0312722698,
-0.0377491526,
0.0392864048,
-0.0040498958,
0.0405584425,
-0.024390772,
0.0205987059,
0.0325406976,
-0.043575529,
-0.0066087176,
0.0168732442,
0.0339321569,
-0.0599743873,
-0.0011286341,
0.0706979558,
0.010322134,
-0.0406103991,
0.0546318926,
-0.0065461327,
-0.009989948,
-0.0238312259,
-0.0840048566,
0.0036340852,
0.0096742269,
-0.0521700643,
-0.0234463662,
0.0204128735,
-0.0467999056,
0.0469794087,
-0.0566221364,
0.0028383476,
-0.0008479506,
2.771e-7,
0.0061361128,
0.0312206782,
0.0219203793,
0.0064100865,
-0.0076327412,
0.0221562702,
0.0008756232,
0.0260224771,
-0.0243662335,
0.0028420317,
0.048111707,
-0.0468938388,
0.0193902608,
0.0018126065,
-0.1092380658,
-0.0463082753,
-0.0495720953,
0.014566469,
-0.0329433307,
0.0416642465,
0.1148663908,
0.1008150578,
0.0349399298,
-0.01997637,
-0.0093280943,
0.0098558757,
0.0009807416,
-0.0468164608,
0.0466562919,
-0.0153458109,
0.0233066026,
0.0174939279,
0.0082004415,
0.0266807396,
-0.0274859443,
0.0442874916,
0.0028235696,
0.0379692055,
-0.0348121896,
-0.0418823175,
-0.0060593975,
-0.0095232558,
0.0003753794,
-0.0072683189,
0.0497027934,
-0.0233414285,
-0.0015645262,
0.000551656,
-0.0160078201,
0.022545496,
-0.0211586747,
0.0142694982,
0.0279748924,
0.0177060831,
0.0150419902,
-0.0141858691,
-0.0261855591,
-0.0880696848,
0.0150372218,
0.02562204,
-0.0014793472,
-0.0076054656,
-0.0088746063,
0.0328164138,
-0.0079804435,
-0.04096945,
-0.0255237818,
2.072114146e-34,
0.0169459451,
-0.008696354,
0.0236434676,
0.0224861205,
0.0224523544,
0.0122701973,
0.0636021867,
0.0078503229,
0.0182356797,
-0.0262608025,
-0.0297950879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16968v1 | Understanding Social Structures from Contemporary Literary Fiction using Character Interaction Graph -- Half Century Chronology of Influential Bengali Writers | 2023-10-25T20:09:14 | 2023-10-25T20:09:14 | Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Mohammed Eunus Ali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Social structures and real-world incidents often influence contemporary
literary fiction. Existing research in literary fiction analysis explains these
real-world phenomena through the manual critical analysis of stories.
Conventional Natural Language Processing (NLP) methodologies, including
sentiment analysis, narrative summarization, and topic modeling, have
demonstrated substantial efficacy in analyzing and identifying similarities
within fictional works. However, the intricate dynamics of character
interactions within fiction necessitate a more nuanced approach that
incorporates visualization techniques. Character interaction graphs (or
networks) emerge as a highly suitable means for visualization and information
retrieval from the realm of fiction. Therefore, we leverage character
interaction graphs with NLP-derived features to explore a diverse spectrum of
societal inquiries about contemporary culture's impact on the landscape of
literary fiction. Our study involves constructing character interaction graphs
from fiction, extracting relevant graph features, and exploiting these features
to resolve various real-life queries. Experimental evaluation of influential
Bengali fiction over half a century demonstrates that character interaction
graphs can be highly effective in specific assessments and information
retrieval from literary fiction. Our data and codebase are available at
https://cutt.ly/fbMgGEM | [
0.0481382795,
0.0194679014,
-0.0385273807,
0.0402131639,
-0.0373063534,
-0.0093493741,
-0.0241946094,
-0.0152939828,
0.0735367984,
0.0205631275,
0.0558403097,
-0.0046175071,
0.0598258413,
0.0655071065,
0.0033935681,
-0.0318796486,
-0.0062098308,
0.0471282266,
0.0478400961,
0.0516254939,
0.0088539328,
0.0846677274,
0.014412974,
0.049610775,
0.0238409974,
-0.0395485163,
0.0226367116,
0.0275514405,
0.0171471778,
-0.0384207256,
-0.0281112809,
0.0239966512,
0.0211087596,
-0.0023348357,
0.0000016413,
-0.0275984816,
0.0080861608,
-0.0267554391,
0.0347750336,
-0.0291781407,
0.0628759935,
0.0146638621,
0.0171185322,
-0.0078560608,
-0.0307534132,
0.0012517753,
0.0263005998,
0.0549217314,
0.0426634029,
0.0447160304,
-0.00749732,
-0.0674372539,
-0.0422631577,
0.0240100343,
-0.0252087396,
0.0112068933,
0.0134516228,
0.0179324262,
0.0525199622,
0.0058203819,
-0.0422747284,
0.00026711,
-0.0571577772,
-0.03138135,
0.0471487269,
0.005967685,
0.0106245158,
0.0023211704,
0.0318733193,
0.0601413846,
0.027154047,
-0.022759296,
0.0301541723,
0.0044743507,
-0.0399247333,
0.0581979118,
-0.0197782908,
-0.0144388415,
-0.0491054319,
0.0343600847,
0.0387687646,
0.00459219,
0.0117027462,
-0.0095695732,
0.0307195075,
0.0055310475,
-0.0331473574,
0.0271366276,
-0.0237594508,
-0.037370339,
-0.0188306104,
-0.0422047712,
0.0152776539,
0.0197207797,
0.0109027736,
0.0296945162,
0.0237350482,
0.0100523634,
0.0003027921,
-0.0428692549,
0.0025971194,
-0.0035301021,
0.0272890199,
0.0099358158,
0.0866342038,
-0.0254513044,
0.0247105043,
-0.0218145549,
-0.0038489448,
0.0044456418,
-0.0367088579,
-0.0330291279,
0.0077508162,
0.0045030997,
-0.0445931628,
-0.0257411487,
-0.017069716,
-0.0060573537,
0.0088384617,
0.0090384753,
-0.0008151193,
0.0404133759,
0.0352566801,
0.0067607374,
-0.0547877997,
-0.0009619808,
-0.0693303049,
-0.028340321,
-0.0445709601,
0.0142536378,
0.0270803999,
-0.0317154117,
0.0352872871,
-0.0190687925,
-0.0069393637,
0.0690597743,
0.0265195016,
-0.0419919267,
-0.0340062529,
-0.0017851553,
0.009937847,
-0.0361310318,
-0.0145640597,
-0.028765412,
0.0487111285,
0.0049341959,
0.0021828979,
-0.0198605973,
0.0156357493,
0.0363301039,
-0.0437451303,
0.0355624892,
-0.0099244202,
-0.0033035001,
0.0407107063,
0.0203141496,
0.0512353852,
-0.0289402734,
0.0552112497,
-0.0154986437,
0.0634307414,
-0.0119766751,
0.0108323824,
-0.0219561197,
-0.0208171438,
-0.0288893823,
-0.00694096,
-0.0052891253,
-0.0488154143,
0.0036500832,
-0.0275003929,
0.0293443352,
-0.0369085222,
-0.0285261422,
0.0224171709,
0.1061151177,
0.0265544429,
0.0574330315,
0.014346539,
0.0285926349,
0.0432502218,
0.0350921899,
-0.0304694977,
-0.0099765956,
0.0274096131,
-0.0178688969,
-0.0635466352,
0.005225244,
0.0376026444,
0.0100460881,
-0.0157915987,
0.0314747989,
0.0723513141,
-0.0331316777,
0.0343597718,
0.0008902528,
-0.0300019942,
-0.0843801871,
0.0778712034,
-0.0632838979,
0.016875701,
0.0294188857,
-0.0022393011,
0.0977100208,
0.0773186013,
-0.0245458297,
0.0436132923,
-0.0007819953,
-0.0197568815,
0.0089231674,
-0.0265471898,
-0.020622896,
0.001627531,
-0.0116846347,
0.0453357324,
0.0057097585,
-0.0076335194,
0.0252518747,
-0.046779424,
-0.0099550039,
-0.035115879,
0.0090414006,
-0.0460716225,
0.0237455703,
-0.0129347388,
0.0398501679,
-0.0424885266,
-0.0103786569,
-0.002239279,
0.0494168997,
-0.0324600637,
-0.0234772582,
0.0283052884,
-0.0449169464,
-0.0217955802,
0.0555594154,
0.0002943902,
-0.0043428456,
0.0052713738,
-0.1083821431,
-0.0159226581,
0.0145253446,
0.0310731791,
-0.0364162326,
0.0751371831,
-0.0235099345,
0.0532787591,
0.0219849218,
0.0051617268,
-0.0150015978,
-0.0023294238,
-0.0600822382,
0.0496165529,
0.0207854863,
0.008507601,
-0.0494193248,
-0.0179970842,
0.0198143944,
0.0178943034,
0.0293868929,
0.0221661609,
0.0672242194,
-0.0089473212,
0.0345212519,
-0.0293092486,
-0.0219606739,
-0.0308903903,
-0.0777354166,
0.0085889418,
0.011564767,
0.004412394,
0.0148755489,
0.0154146468,
-0.0334390663,
0.0093413666,
-0.0211453252,
0.0224320702,
0.0040256977,
-0.0618420914,
0.0531840101,
0.0075267572,
0.0184034463,
-0.0232928153,
0.0068985256,
-0.0575161651,
0.1096890569,
0.0394374765,
-0.0604134277,
0.0293473788,
-0.0351164527,
-0.0262263566,
-0.0057629747,
-0.0516920686,
-0.0226989072,
0.0135159725,
-0.0084096026,
-0.0034140646,
-0.0037270004,
0.0076611456,
0.0448568873,
0.0008459903,
-0.0969070494,
0.0112188775,
0.0014240227,
-0.0025529834,
0.074051179,
-0.0260604583,
-0.0573940352,
-0.0030159603,
0.0123093128,
-0.0001987878,
0.0011723071,
-0.0105426731,
0.015155741,
-0.0019969475,
0.0268158503,
-0.010342095,
-0.0382876061,
-0.0026618396,
0.0476889461,
0.0026927772,
0.013165473,
0.0370220467,
-0.024828691,
0.0411230363,
-0.0372612253,
-0.0135445911,
-0.0480725504,
0.1047418937,
0.0322357342,
0.0273881312,
0.0241942555,
-0.043992456,
0.0054041115,
-0.0047102999,
0.0432401262,
-0.0048271767,
-0.0010603598,
-0.0272155944,
-0.0138876932,
-0.0001654829,
0.0428465083,
-0.0085171163,
-0.0304900091,
-0.0398696437,
-0.0342630669,
0.0423742421,
-0.0572570786,
0.0619801283,
0.0305684321,
-0.0187842082,
-0.0682947561,
0.0119651826,
-0.013723528,
0.006363479,
0.0293085165,
0.0274660662,
-0.0182068814,
0.0072388859,
0.0261689425,
-0.020034967,
-0.0044904985,
-0.0826947466,
-0.0166504104,
-0.0179800633,
0.0212530009,
-0.0022581413,
-0.0326860398,
-0.0047576595,
-0.0562973768,
0.0107513955,
-0.0628488064,
0.0293740258,
0.0808240399,
0.0518165305,
-0.0303920228,
0.0284647793,
0.0123007698,
-0.0431618132,
0.0137801738,
0.0148919281,
-0.0436488129,
0.0431893803,
0.0013940294,
-0.0018276895,
-0.011024978,
-0.0839538574,
-0.0334524326,
-0.0715432838,
-0.0234325659,
-0.0045832926,
0.0150115471,
-0.0299203172,
-0.0356446765,
-0.0147259058,
-0.0046148025,
-0.0428440236,
-0.0284094289,
-0.0261022467,
-0.0061748559,
-0.0485165082,
-0.0254190397,
0.048635561,
0.0238538384,
-0.0326993056,
0.0135600297,
-0.0222507175,
0.0735590458,
-0.0177507363,
0.0471736304,
-0.0256968476,
-0.0063628084,
0.0113653168,
-0.0143611021,
0.0570993349,
-0.0254057385,
0.0040634666,
-0.0642870963,
-0.002725766,
0.0061996975,
-0.0316004753,
0.0183066819,
0.0168342274,
0.0051418901,
-0.0353720523,
-0.0468559265,
0.066337049,
0.012130348,
-0.0066985232,
0.0219858103,
-0.0111277699,
-0.0242564231,
-0.0302246995,
0.0286028329,
-0.034644302,
-0.1016706228,
-0.0169599652,
-0.0379891284,
-0.0223359466,
-0.019645432,
-0.0755991191,
-0.029628057,
0.0222929623,
0.0441490375,
0.0377676189,
0.0578807145,
-0.0018945911,
-0.0250955708,
-0.0135868369,
-0.0339264125,
0.0037535983,
0.0737510771,
0.0025403213,
-0.007124315,
-0.0119108539,
0.0189504009,
-0.0186331905,
-0.026954921,
-0.0398636349,
0.0121006845,
-0.0718804225,
0.0209892299,
0.0276530422,
-0.0275464952,
-0.0636755377,
0.0262072925,
0.0111507326,
-0.0610283166,
0.0127083361,
-0.0682703331,
0.0365077779,
-0.0339178704,
0.0034651351,
0.0019889756,
0.0220564939,
-0.0515160635,
-0.0202755183,
-0.0624317415,
-0.0192031115,
-0.0134985466,
-0.0127311153,
0.0206917953,
-0.027831763,
-0.0142133171,
-0.0626720414,
-0.0588273928,
-0.0432842784,
-0.0416451618,
0.0171908904,
-0.0346266143,
-0.0125882197,
-0.0274522472,
-0.0376162678,
-0.0267998949,
-0.0384134501,
0.0651149899,
-0.0199417211,
0.0716852844,
0.0463275239,
0.0234081503,
-0.0195737369,
0.0039673904,
0.0136311185,
-0.0241352115,
-0.0295351166,
0.0183377434,
0.0330111831,
-0.0078459503,
0.0086989971,
-0.0212365668,
-0.0206717215,
0.0438753143,
-0.0172690209,
0.0053251134,
0.0511124209,
-0.0072870445,
0.0378519706,
-0.0163504854,
0.0557847545,
0.0042180857,
0.0046617426,
0.0227444377,
0.0260296315,
-0.0180212762,
0.0225772895,
0.0103691369,
0.0344998688,
-0.0068776701,
0.0687549636,
0.0168675799,
-0.0219693184,
-0.0363839418,
0.1061071977,
-0.0704307556,
-0.0086362092,
-0.0393842086,
0.0082878275,
0.0567807816,
0.0363837741,
0.0122437002,
-0.100268051,
-0.0443833955,
0.0613000654,
-0.0318529606,
0.0206620432,
-0.0070001907,
0.0148513606,
0.010265003,
0.0623610392,
0.0311041586,
-0.0630844682,
0.0514585562,
-0.0532743372,
-0.0200812668,
0.0368868373,
-5.458721728e-33,
-0.0508949049,
-0.0714225695,
0.0106694913,
0.0518625267,
-0.0981708393,
-0.0020276976,
-0.0247148667,
-0.0073974747,
-0.0392760076,
0.0360072404,
-0.0217728466,
0.0456972905,
-0.0059318505,
-0.0415743999,
-0.0058287061,
0.004242877,
0.0133623872,
0.0606462546,
-0.0060285297,
0.0212721098,
0.0577306598,
0.0200966503,
0.0238177571,
-0.089965567,
0.0504326411,
-0.0693447813,
-0.0073836506,
-0.0224399827,
0.0757648274,
-0.0136753973,
-0.0168010797,
0.0419193022,
0.0205945708,
0.0223775338,
0.0016382794,
0.0230374541,
-0.0647600368,
-0.0250409804,
-0.0064879945,
0.017383527,
0.0175087005,
-0.0171304233,
0.0153257046,
0.0104094194,
0.0189724509,
0.0008071327,
0.0930753127,
0.0147013571,
-0.0082785487,
0.0423134454,
-0.0434478074,
0.0314894393,
-0.0470672883,
0.0396005325,
-0.0174219627,
-0.0141080879,
0.0259635132,
0.0008965801,
-0.051648967,
-0.0059866072,
0.0010639244,
-0.0112722581,
-0.0602403097,
0.0212080963,
0.0102196019,
0.0568466261,
0.0150017384,
-0.0023319898,
-0.002220904,
0.0836541951,
0.0205662884,
0.0046375948,
-0.0264859572,
0.0562969521,
-0.0227935594,
-0.058170341,
-0.0570592694,
0.0083414167,
0.0447324738,
0.0170624908,
-0.0176321659,
0.0080039529,
-0.009249839,
-0.0742988288,
0.0404961221,
-0.0357593037,
-0.0032915506,
-0.0192041025,
-0.0561272129,
-0.0656515062,
-0.0144047765,
0.0459315814,
-0.0025429924,
-0.0420575738,
0.0014359236,
0.0294576529,
-0.0286624692,
0.0386079475,
0.013626406,
-0.0148043251,
0.0035138538,
0.0041628703,
-0.037374787,
0.0128180161,
0.0467876829,
-0.0164328609,
-0.0176524669,
-0.0066215731,
-0.0311461445,
-0.051163435,
0.0115202339,
-0.0229630526,
-0.0365683921,
0.014148429,
-0.004870825,
-0.0088600488,
-0.005005382,
0.0005053066,
0.0470523238,
0.0717286244,
0.0308662448,
0.0118792718,
-0.0126228295,
-0.0347030349,
-0.0022635884,
0.0040379371,
-0.0054513146,
0.0535198785,
0.0214516781,
-0.0652341247,
-0.0222186856,
-0.0506999716,
2.489e-7,
0.0467352383,
0.0534234419,
0.0526741147,
0.0248767417,
0.006745467,
0.0185523871,
-0.001656482,
0.0469365232,
-0.0283051059,
-0.0338716134,
0.0382527299,
0.0181052163,
-0.0209984668,
0.1100988463,
-0.0793364868,
0.0230814274,
-0.0267331433,
-0.0895476118,
-0.035684716,
0.007091335,
0.0251730103,
-0.0030349216,
0.0477211475,
-0.0092872418,
-0.0102634076,
-0.0184725542,
0.0096846428,
-0.0451435782,
-0.0576185845,
0.016755987,
-0.0254574604,
0.0006335878,
-0.0186305884,
-0.0147224348,
-0.0009035784,
0.0305615421,
0.0139157595,
-0.0254467446,
-0.0135434689,
0.0250955857,
0.0315279774,
-0.0340276174,
-0.0062876693,
-0.0020274378,
0.0712514222,
0.0397088788,
-0.0485353433,
-0.014025012,
0.0097773885,
-0.0084527051,
0.0468681492,
0.0072444542,
-0.050948482,
0.0292946659,
-0.0102434279,
-0.0505321622,
0.0040110121,
-0.0572855398,
0.0090399757,
0.0589877106,
0.0196953826,
-0.0243800096,
0.0270578898,
0.0226778053,
0.0074242149,
-0.0254442971,
0.0329909921,
2.246973523e-34,
0.0440065898,
-0.0034642697,
-0.0134683158,
-0.0036576435,
0.0765061155,
-0.0248574354,
-0.0383699946,
0.0045687025,
0.0467502363,
-0.0589179955,
-0.0153548261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16964v1 | Critic-Driven Decoding for Mitigating Hallucinations in Data-to-text Generation | 2023-10-25T20:05:07 | 2023-10-25T20:05:07 | Mateusz Lango, Ondřej Dušek | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Hallucination of text ungrounded in the input is a well-known problem in
neural data-to-text generation. Many methods have been proposed to mitigate it,
but they typically require altering model architecture or collecting additional
data, and thus cannot be easily applied to an existing model. In this paper, we
explore a new way to mitigate hallucinations by combining the probabilistic
output of a generator language model (LM) with the output of a special "text
critic" classifier, which guides the generation by assessing the match between
the input data and the text generated so far. Our method does not need any
changes to the underlying LM's architecture or training procedure and can thus
be combined with any model and decoding operating on word probabilities. The
critic does not need any additional training data, using the base LM's training
data and synthetic negative examples. Our experimental results show that our
method improves over the baseline on the WebNLG and OpenDialKG benchmarks. | [
0.00279396,
0.0982346833,
0.0199316144,
0.0085911993,
-0.0106991474,
0.0157360844,
-0.0221895557,
0.0121132312,
-0.0446035676,
-0.0239295587,
-0.0124011692,
-0.0698385611,
0.0118165826,
0.0077024437,
0.074701637,
-0.0175037161,
0.0121171176,
-0.0094548827,
-0.023194449,
0.0114009716,
-0.0012467954,
0.0212866683,
0.0049145985,
0.0498407707,
-0.0000743438,
-0.0254373029,
-0.0072361464,
0.0387169011,
-0.0038749708,
-0.0211674441,
-0.0044303103,
0.048676163,
-0.021610193,
0.0400003828,
0.0000019967,
0.0012527187,
-0.0326713175,
-0.0132592414,
0.0248390231,
-0.0301542599,
0.0713173151,
-0.0276818611,
-0.0235001873,
0.0380581766,
-0.0285890885,
-0.0324336477,
0.0436786935,
0.0697459355,
0.06134535,
0.0971049517,
-0.0019339763,
-0.0161663517,
0.0418819189,
-0.0163513515,
0.0283690747,
0.019923253,
-0.0082548447,
0.0104819033,
-0.0232963134,
-0.0192508362,
-0.0114853308,
0.0288246255,
0.0182803515,
-0.0033681004,
0.0073868707,
0.0392384641,
-0.017228011,
-0.0215931349,
0.0032913343,
0.061807353,
-0.0336791947,
-0.0704485178,
0.0103039071,
-0.005189281,
-0.0010305187,
-0.051398281,
0.0065438296,
0.0476043373,
-0.0318853632,
0.0431126729,
0.0440118946,
0.0015812324,
0.033019837,
-0.0053599449,
-0.0282993466,
0.0103459265,
0.0232372973,
-0.0311262626,
0.0122710876,
0.0455505885,
0.0281619336,
-0.037581753,
0.0326019824,
0.0304099321,
-0.022341786,
-0.000799186,
-0.083545126,
-0.0443345569,
-0.0162766967,
-0.0446101539,
0.0623564944,
0.0459922254,
-0.0204181522,
-0.0144933416,
-0.0455225743,
0.0254463498,
-0.0103220046,
0.0716891736,
-0.0246360172,
0.024023341,
-0.021671677,
-0.0050302357,
-0.039318528,
0.0072497479,
-0.00855585,
-0.0299005955,
-0.0087882495,
-0.0052204845,
-0.0127299782,
0.0054146773,
0.0153396735,
0.0204868,
-0.0501161031,
-0.0156413037,
-0.0094493488,
-0.0075007482,
0.0038473182,
-0.0282421391,
0.0510148257,
-0.0637701452,
-0.0254967194,
0.0283694584,
0.0057917419,
0.0168784205,
-0.01007766,
0.0490788706,
-0.018256586,
0.0164609812,
-0.0329144448,
-0.0305040404,
-0.0113952709,
-0.0558595583,
0.0134267705,
-0.061178267,
0.016024569,
-0.0088691153,
-0.0224822834,
-0.0769665465,
0.0364364013,
0.0245277174,
-0.0037395081,
0.0652843863,
-0.0605551153,
-0.0088196527,
0.0435814336,
0.0215202961,
-0.0053609665,
0.0517477393,
0.0277681481,
0.0329442136,
-0.0301261023,
0.0213621631,
0.0563554242,
0.0414813086,
0.0451917388,
-0.0140846623,
-0.0507431291,
-0.0406032205,
-0.0114629911,
0.0145594263,
0.0688838586,
0.0616134927,
-0.0400974378,
0.0329118632,
0.0570407957,
-0.017770512,
0.0467653051,
0.0387535729,
0.0289481152,
0.0255356077,
-0.0245427154,
0.0242765583,
-0.0329594798,
0.0201738346,
-0.0161175169,
0.0468166359,
0.0527918749,
0.006509617,
-0.0134839956,
-0.0514304154,
0.0199475829,
-0.0157255307,
0.0083466852,
-0.0229221955,
0.0236025583,
0.0627664179,
-0.1081712618,
0.0127390157,
0.0364930034,
-0.0364273563,
0.0622544028,
-0.0424020775,
0.0086640418,
0.1075575501,
0.0682895333,
0.0333217531,
-0.0015987051,
-0.0154083073,
-0.0033179068,
0.0855980292,
0.0159925614,
0.0257159267,
0.0149940373,
-0.0668545365,
-0.0189876184,
0.0134581383,
0.0235214308,
0.0229783487,
-0.0182576198,
0.0175446235,
0.0448493436,
0.0099568591,
-0.0641752183,
0.0635460019,
-0.0167635847,
-0.0384892933,
0.0058818003,
-0.0212088637,
-0.0037582619,
-0.0090764733,
-0.03908097,
0.0578235574,
-0.0089968238,
-0.0595734976,
-0.0331097767,
0.006839755,
-0.0598182678,
-0.0802484378,
0.0037191755,
-0.0259420704,
0.0258348212,
0.0093490165,
0.0058171293,
-0.0488536693,
0.0095449965,
-0.036228288,
0.022559585,
-0.0628519207,
0.0260122512,
0.0393791497,
0.0137364166,
-0.0256327707,
0.0425194092,
-0.0359125026,
-0.0026385484,
0.0101920301,
0.0745479241,
-0.0032680165,
-0.0328994729,
-0.0149755953,
0.0107512344,
-0.0197356027,
0.0260938518,
-0.0076946556,
0.018000681,
-0.0381282121,
-0.0395857245,
-0.0383077152,
0.0082737412,
-0.0315783136,
0.0117629254,
0.0434290767,
-0.028323641,
-0.0009354338,
0.0014726145,
-0.0529532135,
0.0328552574,
0.0450833142,
-0.0293890238,
0.0247559585,
0.0072717639,
0.0017588617,
-0.0348773785,
0.0026033917,
0.0046385932,
0.0338625051,
-0.0255438685,
-0.00675504,
-0.1061177477,
0.0294568464,
-0.0261064488,
0.0072722523,
0.0163600557,
-0.0463910736,
0.0153956357,
-0.0322704054,
0.0533943661,
0.0239013247,
0.0236371215,
-0.0053010792,
0.0341243111,
0.0078986268,
-0.0361637324,
-0.0081143677,
-0.0222333353,
0.0037009749,
0.0055181989,
-0.0514587127,
0.0095978053,
0.0504364371,
0.0357560739,
0.027849555,
-0.0814788193,
0.0296578761,
-0.0141047863,
-0.0483163483,
0.0065377452,
0.0006410012,
-0.0270269606,
0.0346206985,
-0.0333814062,
-0.0351886898,
0.0594152175,
-0.0414053649,
0.0150605999,
-0.0061687417,
0.0100204591,
0.0152392779,
0.0158492401,
0.0017637097,
0.0382834487,
-0.0035588683,
-0.0159423854,
-0.0394302346,
0.0060653645,
-0.018517727,
-0.0512778759,
0.0155211128,
-0.0409972295,
-0.0120192142,
-0.009284433,
-0.0102372626,
-0.0653798357,
-0.0035903566,
0.0091491435,
-0.0257391017,
0.0062519568,
0.0055137235,
0.0047161332,
0.0115294177,
-0.0600437224,
0.0533720925,
-0.0519457683,
-0.0251236428,
-0.0163772851,
0.0312260427,
0.0497224666,
-0.0374442413,
0.0106293885,
-0.0517766587,
0.0209834464,
0.0543601364,
0.0241183527,
0.0504443422,
-0.0311044902,
-0.0203201883,
0.0151191847,
0.034299694,
-0.0065016071,
0.0354859158,
0.0256754328,
-0.0504819155,
-0.0634090528,
0.0979432017,
0.0091771204,
-0.0428095907,
-0.0027864829,
-0.0205473378,
0.0891742334,
-0.0170439519,
0.0326193161,
-0.0561218485,
-0.0123129264,
0.001351122,
0.0620289557,
0.0162764993,
-0.0075179259,
-0.0235826038,
-0.0928402096,
0.0263651796,
0.0591764487,
-0.009215204,
-0.042795863,
0.0293299668,
-0.0580713041,
0.0171207041,
0.0090403836,
0.0392324366,
0.0219354723,
0.0259854253,
0.0355046205,
-0.0157821663,
-0.026179783,
-0.0561390817,
-0.0319188572,
0.057863377,
0.1006214693,
0.0097150179,
0.0347886309,
-0.0098280283,
0.0147449337,
-0.0043964889,
-0.0021900965,
0.0015659867,
0.0463265665,
-0.0001353389,
-0.0050053811,
0.0010912952,
0.0223045368,
-0.0457769707,
0.0132965902,
-0.000546478,
0.0158109423,
-0.0412307344,
-0.0394169055,
-0.0043666712,
0.0408489443,
0.0582219698,
0.0656976625,
0.0390725471,
-0.0433709957,
-0.0711270198,
-0.0384421051,
0.0591951124,
-0.1171534657,
-0.0180657487,
0.016291691,
0.0519187748,
-0.0591166168,
-0.1089333743,
-0.0437781997,
-0.0186512172,
0.0522364341,
0.0016410591,
0.013669271,
-0.0161816943,
-0.0216509923,
-0.0331779048,
-0.0134512093,
-0.0243179724,
-0.0042138561,
-0.0226338897,
-0.0341270976,
0.0161350965,
-0.0418994464,
0.0130012529,
0.0455660224,
-0.1207838878,
-0.0537350401,
0.0025802511,
0.0521643385,
0.0207336545,
0.040035259,
-0.0280622952,
-0.029802613,
0.0436632559,
0.0395262651,
-0.0442995019,
0.0017817778,
0.0190293621,
0.0052777678,
0.0008146391,
0.0222170632,
-0.0221385285,
0.0071011703,
0.0203500055,
0.0429541841,
0.0093990443,
0.0133223431,
0.054688558,
-0.0351557583,
-0.0027437331,
-0.0746982098,
-0.0005079668,
-0.0349276401,
-0.0189703815,
-0.0280955695,
0.0020228527,
-0.0599534698,
0.017315425,
0.0545620993,
-0.0360071696,
0.0082576638,
-0.0199281648,
-0.0106849009,
0.0508835688,
-0.0272513945,
-0.042147249,
0.0114540281,
0.0229922198,
0.0409859121,
-0.014344018,
-0.0315728746,
0.0182664022,
-0.0039021166,
0.0193591174,
-0.0260569341,
0.0483970754,
0.0307733361,
0.0018979178,
-0.0059639588,
0.0151324021,
-0.0319016576,
-0.0171642676,
-0.0800385699,
-0.0044877823,
0.0422389507,
0.0527167283,
0.0628438145,
-0.0339227021,
0.0140328771,
-0.0071642241,
0.0307720229,
-0.0001600071,
-0.0317387469,
0.0059896694,
-0.0112218447,
-0.0072361534,
-0.0625294447,
0.0942541882,
0.0410087146,
0.0119802384,
-0.0009966065,
0.0136678535,
-0.0494960435,
-0.0447990894,
-0.0323366597,
0.0151323732,
-0.0186370667,
-0.0269898102,
-0.0083304178,
-0.0597545542,
-0.0287516527,
0.0257983133,
0.0177274868,
-0.0047921366,
0.0321656689,
0.0141942371,
-0.0560330674,
-0.0062398892,
-0.0328206271,
0.0178427603,
0.0298749227,
-0.0120138014,
-0.0290508885,
-6.131894282e-33,
-0.041743543,
-0.0370078571,
0.0164732039,
-0.0378770418,
-0.0391150229,
-0.0496930443,
-0.0451974198,
-0.0090315621,
0.0454618223,
0.0012302337,
-0.0169372484,
0.0154510476,
0.0238698125,
0.0502598882,
-0.0165484902,
-0.0135831563,
0.0696770325,
-0.0286145844,
-0.0314432755,
0.0539144501,
0.0109850531,
0.053148441,
0.0261497088,
-0.0677525401,
0.0141780209,
-0.0349032208,
-0.0471411496,
-0.0342236124,
0.0260895938,
0.0190071668,
-0.0312077906,
0.0259081107,
0.0120053869,
-0.0243826006,
-0.0469105095,
0.0031126856,
-0.0568533614,
-0.0006625578,
-0.0402025543,
0.0258883461,
-0.0312344264,
-0.0355290994,
0.0534907542,
-0.0239663608,
-0.0264267027,
0.0126809441,
-0.0008156612,
-0.0474306978,
-0.0390655175,
-0.0146561498,
-0.0675259233,
0.0166567694,
0.0218950137,
-0.0200587194,
0.0160352346,
0.0330977924,
-0.0433297195,
-0.0321690291,
-0.0743471906,
0.031114893,
0.0318313576,
0.0250717122,
0.0553467907,
0.0573557131,
-0.0167330801,
0.0561822765,
0.053791482,
0.0018315252,
-0.0432623774,
-0.0266162325,
0.0241193622,
0.0255688988,
0.025313871,
0.029092811,
0.0643407628,
-0.0420733802,
-0.0277908891,
0.0381992422,
-0.026712887,
-0.034257181,
0.0609628074,
-0.014428677,
-0.0195847582,
-0.0440806225,
-0.026758505,
-0.0444437973,
-0.0164010171,
-0.041871272,
0.0567742437,
0.0553944036,
-0.0333007202,
-0.035760235,
0.0258360151,
-0.0415301137,
0.0303463731,
0.0367615931,
-0.0545070171,
-0.0124130957,
-0.0288481135,
-0.0159776621,
-0.0256759189,
-0.035483826,
0.0463986322,
0.0342284143,
0.0031285335,
0.022916669,
0.0185956284,
0.0132411616,
-0.0659128428,
0.0140661811,
-0.0535239987,
0.0463028215,
0.0477949306,
0.022310514,
0.0455522425,
-0.0539499186,
-0.0092425756,
0.0212376118,
0.0193859003,
0.0266530272,
0.0060202302,
-0.0011910195,
0.0153625561,
0.0185763203,
-0.0353263766,
0.0015042194,
-0.0242393427,
-0.0052553583,
0.0381693318,
-0.0488349162,
-0.0106256818,
0.0066065579,
2.564e-7,
0.0135724256,
0.0334895514,
0.0360395163,
0.0046630157,
0.0147301648,
-0.0027303062,
0.0007173091,
0.0456208065,
0.0064362092,
-0.0090498049,
0.0034150765,
0.0005434506,
0.0833477005,
0.0336711295,
-0.0678809062,
0.0217690356,
-0.0353272744,
0.0563102663,
-0.0582003668,
-0.0532568842,
0.0679606199,
0.0656086802,
-0.0389363989,
-0.0283477698,
0.0537107587,
-0.0192801803,
0.0681842417,
-0.0077752424,
0.0063063474,
0.0246674493,
0.0634199083,
0.0178412087,
-0.0043694796,
-0.0004646659,
-0.0385376215,
-0.0378307179,
0.0130095929,
0.0372725874,
-0.0017986516,
-0.0502940379,
0.0122677349,
-0.0014160009,
0.0104872473,
-0.0475645736,
0.0353694595,
-0.0153450072,
-0.0000509831,
0.0191570017,
-0.013329912,
-0.0151924659,
0.0091735721,
-0.0482884273,
-0.0255143307,
0.0058192993,
0.0347548686,
0.0353497788,
-0.0057603158,
-0.0393670611,
-0.0494397208,
-0.0184929818,
-0.0161737893,
-0.010884284,
-0.0426161215,
0.0390372053,
0.0192782804,
-0.0645227507,
0.010098042,
2.459646165e-34,
0.020881772,
-0.0174121056,
0.0168417618,
0.004148196,
0.0321804844,
0.0085060792,
0.0702299252,
0.0332712531,
0.0050564343,
-0.0287568104,
-0.0487960167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18368v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18368v2 | Muslim-Violence Bias Persists in Debiased GPT Models | 2023-10-25T19:39:58 | 2023-12-09T18:11:06 | Babak Hemmatian, Razan Baltaji, Lav R. Varshney | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Abid et al. (2021) showed a tendency in GPT-3 to generate mostly violent
completions when prompted about Muslims, compared with other religions. Two
pre-registered replication attempts found few violent completions and only a
weak anti-Muslim bias in the more recent InstructGPT, fine-tuned to eliminate
biased and toxic outputs. However, more pre-registered experiments showed that
using common names associated with the religions in prompts increases
several-fold the rate of violent completions, revealing a significant
second-order anti-Muslim bias. ChatGPT showed a bias many times stronger
regardless of prompt format, suggesting that the effects of debiasing were
reduced with continued model development. Our content analysis revealed
religion-specific themes containing offensive stereotypes across all
experiments. Our results show the need for continual de-biasing of models in
ways that address both explicit and higher-order associations. | [
0.0516526401,
0.0420755483,
-0.0503579415,
0.0178494658,
-0.0247645825,
0.0445698798,
0.0668677017,
-0.0261468031,
0.0568857715,
-0.016377015,
0.0276378077,
0.0052781277,
-0.0087277116,
-0.008362649,
0.0040326496,
-0.0466798618,
0.0680836961,
0.0422528163,
0.0326015465,
-0.0113013424,
0.0241262745,
0.0435674898,
0.0052313795,
0.0215267446,
-0.0353095867,
-0.010956266,
-0.0080443351,
-0.0102010313,
0.0588931628,
-0.0092027076,
0.0089769848,
0.0566207878,
0.0027109559,
0.0166789871,
0.0000018755,
-0.0632527918,
0.0012821383,
-0.0153227532,
-0.0012265419,
-0.0156708714,
0.0484007932,
0.0259033088,
0.0241530742,
0.0142242089,
-0.0044289557,
0.0087172799,
0.0324473493,
0.0825558007,
-0.0021477132,
-0.0132366112,
0.001025015,
-0.0425429195,
-0.0224335883,
0.0012555389,
0.0443458296,
0.0622835346,
0.0220812019,
-0.026385406,
-0.0662889183,
0.0416418687,
-0.0380213559,
-0.0087327641,
0.040578451,
0.0509514846,
-0.0103411023,
-0.0218917467,
-0.0313835517,
-0.0253899265,
0.0155637134,
0.0216147061,
0.0166942477,
0.0164201614,
0.0229536854,
-0.0179615673,
0.0396901779,
0.0201456305,
-0.0060167061,
-0.0136029646,
-0.0333223529,
-0.0172800776,
0.0014944674,
0.0127565339,
0.0244482048,
0.0415342972,
0.0182651151,
0.0575786009,
0.0299401283,
-0.0120235691,
-0.0023999093,
0.0094301691,
-0.0111817652,
-0.0212222598,
-0.0229445286,
-0.0486193895,
-0.0057425071,
-0.005195505,
-0.0226224493,
0.0340107791,
0.0107802702,
-0.0242016762,
0.0014156332,
0.0807035938,
-0.0248021074,
-0.0175345689,
0.0354300961,
0.0298238453,
0.0056563052,
0.010741814,
0.0162636768,
0.0352878384,
-0.0193310697,
0.0067917742,
0.0245172065,
0.0049128914,
0.0442960262,
0.0817439258,
-0.0609011054,
-0.0223647542,
-0.0410112068,
-0.0051933425,
-0.0414911844,
-0.0249611028,
-0.0391116627,
-0.0145542389,
-0.0302750096,
0.0119522447,
-0.1025568172,
0.0031923603,
-0.0321263485,
-0.0895225629,
0.012258999,
0.009115356,
-0.0236920845,
-0.051115375,
-0.0014705503,
0.0639098063,
0.0077839079,
0.0029348037,
-0.0064590694,
-0.0167716946,
-0.004868425,
-0.0694399402,
0.018848313,
0.0041738506,
0.058280386,
0.0216235314,
-0.0250884779,
-0.0522235446,
0.0146921063,
0.0483647175,
-0.0532105342,
0.0744185373,
0.0460480526,
0.0118410867,
0.0485897101,
0.0574534386,
-0.0332100913,
0.0431944728,
-0.0055868947,
0.0379857868,
-0.0062558223,
-0.0245786458,
0.0238917917,
-0.0083080307,
0.0348305665,
-0.0042651114,
-0.0229153223,
0.0272088684,
0.0182959903,
-0.0123354215,
0.0268939994,
0.0214353111,
-0.0448540486,
-0.0214854237,
0.0171105489,
0.0459932946,
-0.0599749163,
0.0400206745,
0.010096482,
0.0211777687,
-0.0253337845,
0.0404743627,
-0.1117665395,
-0.0089510232,
0.0103268316,
-0.0077765761,
0.0224983022,
0.1134011149,
-0.0362490863,
0.0125856353,
-0.0077485344,
0.0090717832,
0.0523237847,
0.0015702237,
0.0001244103,
-0.0085369935,
-0.0210873745,
-0.0159958247,
0.0467279106,
-0.0221065562,
0.0062102433,
-0.039871309,
0.0363539085,
0.0058778021,
0.0147057138,
0.0290171169,
-0.0332380012,
-0.067963168,
-0.0009779555,
0.0365618765,
0.0335776657,
0.018392656,
-0.0036758638,
-0.0118355043,
-0.0441592708,
0.032623034,
0.0076801274,
0.0409005098,
0.0654480755,
0.0038058306,
0.0184099954,
-0.0063377414,
0.0097734686,
0.0094287852,
0.0204298496,
-0.0324562974,
-0.0503629111,
-0.0023530757,
0.0818284974,
-0.0002730171,
-0.0064135003,
-0.0537836291,
-0.0224345159,
0.0146220038,
-0.0141082471,
0.0095096445,
-0.0762889758,
0.0340504274,
-0.0450750142,
-0.0263210367,
-0.0428155139,
0.0325041488,
-0.0147391045,
0.0567623563,
0.0490165018,
0.0433135219,
-0.0070425919,
-0.0254000537,
-0.0344468988,
-0.0653267875,
-0.0128137404,
-0.0195034258,
0.0639174879,
-0.0162918661,
0.0062667816,
0.0297869574,
-0.0701202005,
0.0400038958,
0.0203881674,
-0.0251712147,
-0.0054758377,
-0.0170267001,
-0.0105158687,
0.0065759541,
-0.0512613505,
-0.0177983548,
0.0091009168,
-0.0415064506,
-0.00443066,
0.0260712057,
-0.0208673924,
-0.0020233996,
0.0019508916,
-0.0396861248,
0.0324923694,
-0.0269127153,
-0.0428695567,
0.0597566292,
0.0847500861,
-0.0208507404,
-0.0666642934,
-0.0135168983,
-0.0334736332,
-0.0092635006,
-0.0316119157,
0.01362014,
0.0314775705,
-0.0255146958,
0.060495764,
-0.0328358635,
-0.0780559629,
-0.0145712961,
-0.0030877953,
-0.0455466323,
0.0343217403,
0.0572111495,
0.0193545073,
0.0269841906,
0.0496098176,
0.035501793,
0.0103562428,
-0.0122837955,
-0.0395201258,
0.0089988373,
-0.0428892411,
-0.0457767025,
0.0270681269,
-0.0890951008,
-0.0691803172,
0.0349395424,
0.0732885525,
-0.0071667014,
-0.0813107193,
0.0443709604,
-0.0662352964,
-0.0411566906,
-0.0287937317,
-0.0773729682,
0.005418411,
0.0295134317,
-0.0566585585,
-0.0615545027,
0.0240314845,
0.0444900915,
0.0253452249,
0.0116572725,
0.0659529939,
0.0181724466,
0.0043545687,
0.0265440792,
0.0330422297,
0.0160592794,
-0.0018441261,
-0.0463551991,
-0.0639269948,
0.0165424589,
-0.0213119928,
-0.0185036529,
0.0192510411,
-0.0138266739,
-0.0321074799,
-0.0152915306,
-0.0495858975,
-0.0196376573,
-0.0070185955,
-0.0338358097,
-0.0078011537,
0.0561617799,
0.0023992551,
0.0051287794,
0.0429016836,
-0.05605039,
-0.0302806571,
-0.0132224793,
0.0190759655,
-0.071080856,
0.0003931989,
-0.0268774573,
0.0439810008,
-0.0096950168,
-0.0149485469,
0.0357330143,
-0.0546993501,
-0.0146065997,
-0.023559263,
0.0265514478,
-0.0008630407,
0.0062508238,
-0.0029075264,
-0.0005824098,
0.0310972277,
0.0095167514,
0.0427019075,
0.0738681629,
-0.0239984542,
0.0017780593,
-0.0073242527,
0.0394840762,
0.0154393762,
0.011984515,
-0.0162985157,
-0.1289301515,
0.0234501287,
0.0227655843,
-0.0080506168,
-0.101354301,
-0.063456431,
0.022236554,
-0.0615717024,
0.0298072957,
0.0011907675,
0.0018306242,
-0.043204505,
-0.0080528213,
0.0378577709,
-0.0247642267,
0.0213778317,
-0.008852399,
0.0290223882,
0.0433743037,
-0.0293647945,
-0.0112640457,
-0.0175794438,
-0.0033415852,
-0.0171980783,
0.0097049735,
0.044555556,
0.0106832776,
-0.03601937,
0.011075452,
0.046060726,
0.0027468714,
-0.0265469104,
-0.0214685425,
0.0398130454,
-0.0145364478,
-0.002547509,
-0.0583698228,
0.028369166,
0.0190806389,
-0.0173035916,
0.0105355782,
0.0382363573,
0.01937926,
0.0021167132,
-0.0330793336,
0.0129052671,
-0.0034597018,
0.07592801,
0.0208734833,
-0.0267839916,
0.0299138613,
-0.0701647028,
-0.0086919628,
0.0368781574,
-0.0678535998,
-0.0425174758,
0.0184051953,
0.0107659483,
0.04490491,
-0.0838421956,
0.0064550303,
-0.0421001092,
0.0268091075,
-0.028570639,
-0.024974931,
-0.0085824039,
-0.0236162767,
0.0124712,
0.0143182166,
-0.0055955076,
0.0378305912,
0.0220243279,
-0.0474214442,
-0.0398867093,
-0.0229139049,
0.0344628915,
-0.0217202194,
-0.0200744458,
0.1251251847,
0.0488335676,
0.026710419,
0.0010061166,
0.0160694532,
0.0275223162,
0.0175639968,
0.0253861621,
-0.0002828957,
0.0254951138,
-0.0024034281,
0.0564015731,
0.0197825711,
-0.0143999197,
0.0364725851,
0.052067779,
0.0512780435,
-0.0767624155,
0.0040900637,
-0.0142043522,
0.0086870221,
-0.0465088822,
0.0505242385,
-0.002946771,
-0.0253714323,
-0.0554621145,
-0.0305485185,
-0.0553645752,
-0.0236796606,
0.0186677519,
-0.0325535163,
0.0258677471,
0.0505682975,
-0.0228454862,
-0.0850858092,
-0.0678086728,
0.0143724065,
-0.0724199042,
-0.0276210196,
0.0028955587,
0.0148912407,
-0.008544527,
0.0110857142,
-0.0233377572,
0.0354533046,
-0.0255897436,
-0.0058818962,
-0.0241630692,
0.0545337424,
0.0207193233,
0.0501121879,
0.0553377271,
-0.0054863379,
-0.0305788983,
-0.0296736769,
-0.0245399382,
-0.0049665803,
-0.0281856861,
-0.0232688915,
-0.0253652316,
0.0218649544,
-0.0109477313,
-0.0189398844,
0.0201450307,
0.0230631903,
-0.0228500403,
0.029523626,
-0.0016995523,
-0.0221280102,
-0.0251637343,
0.039899718,
-0.0334966257,
0.0696863234,
0.0200191438,
-0.048372075,
-0.0071269637,
-0.0233131275,
0.016975658,
0.0017939543,
-0.0076643028,
0.0160574522,
-0.0602051653,
-0.028344715,
-0.0218909066,
-0.0310256016,
0.0289197229,
-0.0374846682,
0.0251708236,
0.0572211854,
-0.0402829833,
-0.037689168,
0.0384815261,
0.0395218134,
-0.0227407757,
-0.0570815429,
-0.0174173079,
-5.548178318e-33,
-0.0450202897,
0.0212113522,
-0.0057653445,
-0.0289325546,
-0.0151798958,
-0.0376684405,
0.032352116,
0.0302164257,
-0.057947509,
0.0263110865,
-0.0129680829,
0.0291992482,
0.0166864377,
-0.0202958863,
0.0466918498,
-0.0701327622,
0.0476613156,
-0.0190655794,
-0.0125019494,
0.0295934174,
-0.0178397391,
-0.0071628108,
0.0298066419,
-0.0787866116,
0.0242829248,
-0.0357032046,
-0.0221589524,
-0.0499366634,
-0.0019455807,
0.0323844627,
-0.0445926078,
0.0385219567,
0.0450628139,
-0.0223167446,
0.0180012863,
0.0609342232,
-0.0122649381,
-0.0330475643,
0.0500714667,
-0.0384425111,
-0.0088961078,
-0.0366082415,
-0.0359025374,
-0.0158723071,
-0.0820627585,
-0.0177130494,
0.0244090464,
-0.0019742828,
0.0428138934,
-0.0082328767,
-0.0702227801,
-0.0182853863,
0.0110696172,
0.0360879488,
-0.0529142246,
0.0599443205,
0.0395537317,
0.0423817337,
-0.0043559661,
0.0074888496,
0.0410225429,
-0.0351289399,
-0.0040603816,
-0.0051860129,
0.0093905628,
0.0367612876,
0.0272946376,
0.0491712242,
-0.0358705372,
-0.0225009695,
0.0081527876,
-0.0479129516,
0.0488121137,
0.1057450548,
0.0090061277,
-0.0362120084,
-0.0168881733,
-0.017478589,
0.035631761,
0.017436929,
0.0305176284,
-0.0314554572,
-0.0402506888,
-0.0301236417,
-0.0218093377,
-0.1017175168,
-0.0204478148,
-0.0564804971,
0.0627242103,
-0.0110272383,
-0.0049484703,
0.0002812387,
0.0438497066,
0.0219180174,
0.0098311305,
0.0208246969,
-0.0181015301,
-0.0205149539,
0.0047123376,
0.019816637,
-0.0469595455,
0.0308590215,
0.004398555,
-0.0075782798,
0.0401773714,
0.0168537404,
0.0013318604,
-0.0023511525,
-0.0798062235,
0.0036196171,
0.0053442628,
0.030014826,
0.0158582963,
0.014236019,
0.0544689782,
0.0563670881,
0.0238421708,
-0.0524497144,
0.0765853971,
-0.0385655053,
-0.0478088707,
-0.0128142908,
-0.0407698825,
0.0134893572,
0.0412483998,
-0.0057343664,
-0.0107680755,
-0.0115875835,
0.0126895485,
-0.0729454756,
-0.0276606884,
-0.0427377634,
2.497e-7,
-0.0122246891,
0.0059988527,
-0.0167912953,
0.0541827194,
-0.0139452554,
0.0095481621,
0.0730160326,
0.030755287,
0.0770309269,
-0.0148704518,
-0.0160079449,
0.023856258,
0.0074560489,
0.032221254,
-0.0136686275,
-0.0124668684,
-0.0213606283,
0.0137893502,
-0.0692140758,
0.0118039586,
0.0111316107,
0.0355146416,
0.0337333865,
0.0170357991,
-0.0345688909,
0.0321579911,
0.0146253025,
-0.0551616587,
-0.0106437895,
0.0066578379,
0.0528144091,
0.0160504337,
0.0473917946,
0.0660808384,
0.0155555755,
-0.0224628057,
0.0268579554,
0.0107575478,
0.0323041268,
0.0315179192,
-0.0041355561,
0.0074448735,
-0.0121439956,
-0.0952400565,
0.0372270308,
-0.0172255915,
0.0240391009,
-0.0244197194,
-0.0501530133,
0.0013844273,
0.0504462086,
0.0284059662,
-0.0393540822,
-0.0188347585,
0.0456962585,
0.0437333584,
0.0049414267,
-0.0139947711,
0.0067049102,
-0.0403888375,
-0.0257849786,
-0.0636674762,
-0.0040538581,
-0.0256111342,
-0.0011358639,
0.012903613,
-0.0024813726,
2.178618526e-34,
0.0467099957,
-0.0117762377,
0.0518901609,
-0.0658926591,
0.0584989488,
0.0217219274,
-0.0124661336,
-0.0294364318,
0.0092469007,
-0.0217619408,
-0.0189841576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16944v1 | Zephyr: Direct Distillation of LM Alignment | 2023-10-25T19:25:16 | 2023-10-25T19:25:16 | Lewis Tunstall, Edward Beeching, Nathan Lambert, Nazneen Rajani, Kashif Rasul, Younes Belkada, Shengyi Huang, Leandro von Werra, Clémentine Fourrier, Nathan Habib, Nathan Sarrazin, Omar Sanseviero, Alexander M. Rush, Thomas Wolf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We aim to produce a smaller language model that is aligned to user intent.
Previous research has shown that applying distilled supervised fine-tuning
(dSFT) on larger models significantly improves task accuracy; however, these
models are unaligned, i.e. they do not respond well to natural prompts. To
distill this property, we experiment with the use of preference data from AI
Feedback (AIF). Starting from a dataset of outputs ranked by a teacher model,
we apply distilled direct preference optimization (dDPO) to learn a chat model
with significantly improved intent alignment. The approach requires only a few
hours of training without any additional sampling during fine-tuning. The final
result, Zephyr-7B, sets the state-of-the-art on chat benchmarks for 7B
parameter models, and requires no human annotation. In particular, results on
MT-Bench show that Zephyr-7B surpasses Llama2-Chat-70B, the best open-access
RLHF-based model. Code, models, data, and tutorials for the system are
available at https://github.com/huggingface/alignment-handbook. | [
0.0558774844,
0.0128004737,
-0.0080152089,
0.0293692797,
-0.0343392156,
-0.0049760882,
-0.0203266982,
-0.0408806354,
0.0296424106,
-0.0055342969,
-0.0841748267,
-0.0422736555,
0.0133680748,
0.0294107888,
0.0229125265,
-0.0555906557,
0.0397706702,
0.0073401881,
0.0223749876,
0.0079309596,
0.0493295453,
0.0249192528,
-0.0260727294,
0.0431910492,
0.011696917,
-0.0303824935,
-0.0495990515,
0.0286388211,
0.0225716345,
0.0303532314,
0.0355423503,
0.062900953,
-0.0111329248,
0.0280455761,
0.0000021629,
-0.0570834316,
-0.0298961103,
-0.0354840681,
-0.0513241217,
-0.0186175779,
0.0422396399,
0.0256126169,
-0.0242314525,
0.0465604514,
-0.0390729755,
0.0556522459,
0.050901711,
0.0058936547,
0.0444607809,
0.1019957811,
0.0051156464,
-0.0083296271,
0.0138845062,
-0.0231893305,
0.0151866134,
-0.0281939749,
-0.0049059908,
-0.0095430547,
-0.0125892144,
0.0311580021,
-0.0151038757,
0.0410665125,
-0.0186032802,
-0.0339491405,
0.0408829004,
0.0001530039,
-0.0127522284,
-0.0568610802,
-0.008026232,
0.1121253595,
-0.0059529161,
-0.0216141827,
0.0039609717,
-0.0229250789,
0.0156808961,
-0.0506849289,
-0.024164822,
-0.0162231699,
0.0052345567,
0.0170267317,
0.029417444,
-0.0095576318,
-0.0047241491,
0.0003966771,
-0.0006042803,
0.0158436634,
0.002468864,
-0.0401429944,
0.0068650544,
-0.0162685681,
0.005618359,
-0.0529303588,
0.0000137096,
0.0128176929,
-0.0731691271,
0.0256744381,
-0.0662809908,
0.0046718619,
0.0221616291,
-0.0513131917,
0.004807163,
0.0977518857,
0.0095144911,
0.0264832899,
0.0542297252,
0.0733182728,
-0.0002399296,
0.0460178442,
-0.0595493242,
0.02789413,
-0.0297212936,
0.0028232012,
-0.0185493883,
0.0103736501,
-0.0219220873,
-0.0349429175,
-0.0662547648,
0.0573168583,
0.0042207115,
0.0368567593,
0.0139489025,
0.0055499147,
-0.0746506527,
0.0103421453,
-0.0298201926,
0.0712625831,
-0.0148943197,
0.0062343297,
0.0348778665,
-0.0513709672,
-0.0067481273,
0.0299658421,
-0.0080178799,
-0.0250460468,
-0.0216616914,
0.0350426771,
-0.0262978878,
-0.0314545892,
0.0204417128,
-0.0128205856,
-0.0359903798,
-0.076602377,
-0.0224535931,
-0.035193067,
0.0440667942,
0.0056366129,
-0.0048202467,
-0.0489908159,
-0.00065113,
0.015484767,
-0.0188739095,
0.0648986474,
-0.0053890436,
0.027148908,
0.0109681943,
-0.0173491016,
-0.0383987837,
0.0723202452,
0.0268314406,
0.050435558,
0.0247023422,
-0.0287881643,
-0.0183603372,
0.0462551564,
-0.0019711577,
-0.0188692696,
-0.0086429659,
0.0276225507,
-0.0085741915,
0.0581586361,
0.0309167784,
0.0346918665,
0.0052492879,
-0.0073334477,
0.0762811974,
0.0351472497,
0.035156507,
-0.0117881745,
-0.0049098721,
0.0643009543,
-0.0053539751,
0.0244938694,
-0.071510829,
0.0400413722,
-0.0305304881,
0.0295846965,
0.0696908757,
0.0137587329,
-0.0265526976,
-0.0527708232,
0.0079093752,
-0.0181918498,
0.0042717182,
0.0204488039,
0.0313270874,
-0.0012212392,
-0.0444546677,
0.036682114,
0.0328706503,
-0.0344948173,
-0.0271495823,
-0.0341185778,
0.0289242435,
0.0948758274,
0.0436405353,
-0.0314201526,
-0.0768684521,
-0.0232024193,
-0.0227179844,
0.0464336611,
0.0645299852,
-0.0097609414,
0.0034354089,
-0.0627126917,
-0.0211911425,
-0.0134604387,
-0.0176768303,
-0.02688233,
0.0240599103,
-0.0221345983,
-0.0096462928,
-0.0088897198,
-0.0484249331,
0.0243120566,
-0.0208250582,
-0.0293352529,
-0.0257975962,
0.0433337465,
0.0491977222,
0.0164598804,
0.0198743194,
-0.0125137838,
0.0155745493,
0.0231759436,
0.0442557633,
-0.0151426429,
-0.0517309345,
-0.0400554352,
0.0668306649,
0.0044350224,
-0.0436833799,
0.0638827309,
-0.0526386425,
-0.0495960154,
-0.0068520405,
0.0079998709,
0.0325844251,
-0.0043076356,
0.0470926128,
-0.0036760657,
-0.0351387784,
-0.0506211556,
0.0184217282,
0.0206939895,
-0.0010598566,
0.0023097349,
-0.0063192369,
-0.0065644309,
-0.0333998874,
-0.007061983,
0.0107874321,
-0.0336869173,
0.0155909192,
0.019247273,
0.0355045088,
-0.0627873167,
-0.0398750529,
-0.0747903064,
0.0374047346,
-0.0330561213,
0.0045593637,
0.0418891534,
0.041859597,
0.0042877216,
-0.0227762721,
-0.0662391558,
0.014722622,
-0.0142418575,
-0.0107814372,
0.0421543345,
-0.0105211204,
-0.0318022668,
-0.1032187045,
0.0242851339,
-0.0069066277,
-0.0235874206,
-0.0056859441,
0.0001943105,
-0.0369077772,
0.0414359905,
-0.0323464982,
0.0185333434,
-0.020660501,
-0.0646498129,
0.0024920378,
-0.0012400351,
0.0215894543,
0.0905930474,
0.0373537876,
0.0092189442,
0.0162944943,
0.0533017144,
-0.1015062779,
0.0147412522,
-0.0419729203,
-0.0395814292,
-0.0469689146,
-0.0145393908,
0.0001029675,
0.0588401891,
-0.0063453359,
0.0214287695,
-0.0902418867,
-0.0123128621,
0.0315662958,
-0.0060534962,
-0.0071420358,
0.0279940236,
-0.0442744792,
0.0095075918,
-0.0475694239,
-0.0760199204,
0.0952431187,
-0.0215988886,
-0.0323444828,
-0.0637334436,
-0.0304147396,
-0.0253693685,
0.0108710239,
-0.0251491573,
0.0374118201,
0.0404517874,
-0.0184968095,
-0.061998371,
-0.0044584791,
0.035456717,
-0.0452856794,
0.0556194894,
-0.0118954536,
0.0138623333,
-0.0121325143,
-0.050414525,
-0.0627834052,
-0.0765019432,
-0.0114205275,
-0.0146876844,
0.0368690602,
-0.0308336709,
-0.0259986296,
0.0105897319,
0.005517513,
0.0232627839,
-0.0250842199,
-0.0009906271,
-0.0213624202,
-0.0014692057,
0.0882025585,
0.0066438681,
-0.0377295837,
-0.0104436679,
0.0276659224,
0.019096652,
0.037673004,
-0.0240095146,
0.0009023629,
-0.0228894036,
0.050874602,
-0.0195761025,
-0.0024003056,
0.0120596047,
0.0691689104,
0.0140705975,
-0.0183662791,
0.1241011098,
0.0332358032,
-0.0535283871,
-0.0046471036,
-0.0157460328,
0.0674861968,
0.0194479655,
0.0229724608,
-0.0651374906,
-0.051596351,
0.0026983041,
0.0476028919,
0.0276331268,
0.0215052627,
-0.0092331553,
-0.0977993608,
-0.0121389702,
0.0220523514,
-0.0504440516,
-0.0161853023,
-0.0302808844,
0.013255842,
-0.0481845178,
0.049083285,
0.0051757493,
-0.0036343511,
-0.016449092,
0.0140058044,
-0.0072469274,
-0.0384659581,
0.0158521254,
-0.027992798,
0.0938722268,
0.0755732358,
0.0399470851,
0.0279078446,
-0.0187188033,
0.0140243927,
0.0442384891,
-0.0092792585,
0.0038794365,
0.037390966,
-0.0336059295,
-0.0002215928,
-0.016404001,
0.054431431,
-0.0136640314,
0.0194168929,
0.0008890316,
0.0235982481,
-0.0127794733,
0.0504276194,
0.0153439753,
0.040375866,
0.0431893952,
0.084228918,
0.027266372,
-0.058230184,
0.0080595063,
-0.0369352512,
-0.0070179962,
-0.0043934085,
-0.0236546677,
-0.0080304081,
-0.0452812761,
-0.0172680337,
-0.0448075496,
-0.0446384773,
0.0223278571,
0.0252663791,
0.021720985,
-0.0080522932,
0.0045955777,
-0.0115113202,
0.0089416848,
0.0495448075,
-0.0155470129,
0.0238233525,
-0.0754645988,
-0.0298081376,
-0.002240875,
-0.0550246872,
0.0232797302,
0.0041876822,
-0.0591975078,
-0.1026358008,
0.0000057493,
0.0650557131,
0.0214224532,
0.0852511674,
-0.0252475347,
-0.0083755739,
-0.0233781859,
0.0209130403,
-0.01960117,
0.0015457141,
0.026229037,
0.0199204776,
-0.008901624,
0.0429501161,
-0.0283300504,
-0.0173360761,
0.0239695832,
0.0304149166,
-0.0388549529,
-0.0921096057,
0.02827706,
0.0324011818,
0.0559636652,
0.00099159,
-0.048694592,
-0.0353663191,
0.0206791013,
0.0039625871,
-0.0249011461,
-0.0304382462,
-0.0528300107,
0.0308744628,
-0.0250319485,
0.019024834,
-0.0079879723,
-0.0476986505,
0.0225564558,
-0.0273277871,
0.0062051597,
-0.029536536,
-0.0029862202,
0.0318789743,
0.0276471637,
-0.0385638252,
0.0467833914,
0.0302779507,
0.0487216488,
0.003931216,
0.0701580271,
0.0262383223,
0.0023471704,
0.0026988566,
0.046805352,
-0.0188714173,
-0.0539798141,
-0.0301500447,
0.0172416903,
0.0457366779,
0.0003391009,
0.0676775873,
0.0015758785,
0.0099688508,
-0.0256649684,
0.0599205531,
-0.0278558806,
-0.0138395317,
0.0226297528,
0.0102391802,
-0.034291584,
-0.0028048772,
0.0546894036,
-0.0336115472,
0.0192838609,
-0.001495491,
0.0139485458,
-0.0531389527,
-0.0024222198,
0.0354780778,
0.0389873907,
-0.0289938767,
-0.0254434459,
-0.0330084115,
-0.0493717156,
-0.0098954774,
0.0006509925,
-0.0200132187,
-0.019457344,
0.0537681319,
0.052350942,
-0.0458937585,
-0.0069167595,
-0.0361836515,
-0.045205567,
-0.03145824,
-0.0205616131,
-0.038622506,
-6.803137556e-33,
-0.0331536159,
0.0072902073,
0.0127012227,
0.0067938031,
-0.0496008955,
-0.0189239178,
-0.0164168254,
0.0166786723,
-0.0477621369,
-0.0218518674,
-0.0202033613,
0.0062938244,
0.0152298491,
0.0093991002,
0.0006957196,
-0.0063953344,
0.0344104357,
-0.008514747,
-0.0452029742,
0.000366764,
0.0364089161,
0.0134401824,
0.0251400098,
-0.0444215834,
0.0184583534,
-0.0048220442,
-0.0350547805,
0.0331900567,
-0.026816288,
0.0639180541,
0.003076053,
0.0199366231,
-0.0159772914,
-0.0307582952,
-0.0062798127,
0.0462552905,
-0.0377893113,
-0.0243551247,
0.0414246097,
0.0223343633,
-0.028524546,
-0.0248337928,
0.04276843,
-0.0200002491,
-0.0178359877,
0.0020290124,
0.0331626646,
-0.0037193904,
-0.0056938124,
0.0476494059,
-0.073289983,
-0.0080410521,
-0.0384223349,
-0.0816349909,
0.0099504283,
0.0548995174,
0.0052893716,
0.007450006,
-0.0525900051,
0.0324517824,
-0.001433404,
0.0299548116,
0.0742812902,
0.0495723374,
-0.008561383,
0.0437950157,
0.0191201884,
0.002483035,
0.0385714397,
-0.0431824476,
0.0019149107,
0.0437456407,
-0.0036121153,
0.0343042016,
0.0072763935,
-0.0167677719,
-0.0361215286,
0.0372490361,
0.044864662,
-0.0167862568,
-0.0081021739,
0.0345251188,
-0.0762787536,
-0.0185961854,
-0.0183532108,
0.0045837951,
-0.031188203,
-0.0471010767,
0.0091883214,
0.0207008198,
-0.0119805606,
-0.0285132155,
0.0211500414,
-0.0315209106,
0.0303903874,
0.0029719721,
-0.0424660183,
0.0158405229,
-0.0109380661,
0.0109596783,
-0.0604345463,
-0.0316072181,
0.0195036866,
-0.0055998503,
0.0025357187,
0.0534483269,
0.0434348397,
0.0106079811,
-0.0325076915,
0.0111117717,
-0.0303823594,
0.004807564,
-0.0221636314,
-0.000985438,
0.046137955,
-0.0101815965,
-0.0275136866,
0.0939907953,
0.0126701687,
0.0023170633,
-0.0331038162,
-0.0485484786,
-0.0009565608,
0.0015076618,
-0.0409094729,
0.0131178843,
-0.0037948398,
-0.009223057,
-0.013186235,
-0.0255929474,
-0.0187901985,
-0.0061013782,
2.896e-7,
0.02079021,
0.0381657071,
0.0308297724,
0.0443724059,
-0.0325661078,
0.0686385185,
-0.0017716419,
0.0378352217,
0.0397538394,
0.0185952038,
0.0226105079,
0.0187844411,
0.0565912761,
-0.0264692847,
-0.1023158506,
-0.0133916428,
-0.0532779023,
-0.0014472213,
-0.0279922374,
0.0184912086,
0.0490794145,
0.1107644215,
0.0322260298,
0.0051576844,
-0.0042406572,
0.0068552112,
0.0155630317,
-0.0432100631,
-0.0308835432,
0.0465319082,
0.022284165,
-0.0343264639,
-0.0418622419,
-0.0071930452,
-0.0079687843,
0.0179830939,
-0.0316218846,
0.0962140039,
-0.0274742767,
-0.0389007628,
0.000179855,
0.0346497521,
0.010822325,
-0.0699792355,
0.0403842144,
-0.0345476493,
-0.028460227,
-0.0094258711,
-0.0166296046,
0.0030059558,
0.0233207289,
-0.011183599,
0.0077454774,
0.0111545026,
0.0130357118,
-0.0079502538,
-0.0368768498,
-0.0446743146,
-0.0151407663,
-0.0029697747,
-0.0209573619,
-0.0504368953,
-0.0154201612,
0.0045187874,
0.0108196903,
-0.0378097631,
0.0178303476,
2.574577829e-34,
0.0067660511,
-0.0151715521,
0.0457088463,
0.021452412,
0.0289578605,
0.0008594548,
0.0187002979,
0.0191697869,
0.0653916597,
-0.068512626,
-0.0258775465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16937v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16937v2 | Learning Transfers over Several Programming Languages | 2023-10-25T19:04:33 | 2024-03-25T20:14:07 | Razan Baltaji, Saurabh Pujar, Louis Mandel, Martin Hirzel, Luca Buratti, Lav Varshney | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.5 | Large language models (LLMs) have become remarkably good at improving
developer productivity for high-resource programming languages. These models
use two kinds of data: large amounts of unlabeled code samples for pre-training
and relatively smaller amounts of labeled code samples for fine-tuning or
in-context learning. Unfortunately, many programming languages are
low-resource, lacking labeled samples for most tasks and often even lacking
unlabeled samples. Therefore, users of low-resource languages (e.g., legacy or
new languages) miss out on the benefits of LLMs. Cross-lingual transfer uses
data from a source language to improve model performance on a target language.
It has been well-studied for natural languages, but has received little
attention for programming languages. This paper reports extensive experiments
on four tasks using a transformer-based LLM and 11 to 41 programming languages
to explore the following questions. First, how well does cross-lingual transfer
work for a given task across different language pairs. Second, given a task and
target language, how should one choose a source language. Third, which
characteristics of a language pair are predictive of transfer performance, and
how does that depend on the given task. Our empirical study with 1,808
experiments reveals practical and scientific insights, such as Kotlin and
JavaScript being the most transferable source languages and different tasks
relying on substantially different features. Overall, we find that learning
transfers well across several programming languages. | [
0.0015403812,
0.0528961718,
-0.054737173,
0.0236607958,
-0.009247792,
0.0011229936,
0.0094438307,
-0.0014863695,
-0.0105997613,
0.0006078762,
-0.0315360315,
0.0529326424,
-0.0047923191,
0.0126210647,
0.0174562912,
-0.0742518678,
0.046981968,
-0.070238255,
-0.0508799516,
0.011385248,
-0.0185231045,
0.003308367,
0.0080659008,
0.0521558076,
0.0248440672,
-0.0015740524,
0.0199742932,
0.003385474,
-0.0194666609,
0.0088930819,
-0.0017226161,
0.0079921801,
0.0125110261,
0.0014443547,
0.0000019861,
-0.0384170413,
-0.0135426102,
0.0102133919,
0.0297008678,
0.0326707512,
0.0363574214,
-0.0155719528,
-0.0116082765,
0.0193334594,
-0.0081459191,
-0.0308183189,
0.0730303973,
-0.0368689299,
0.0430119559,
0.020761665,
0.0119072953,
0.0088119712,
0.0043112347,
0.0333638825,
0.0335075445,
-0.0405373611,
0.0027800945,
0.0357749611,
0.0056930445,
0.0064764544,
-0.0265065245,
0.0188899618,
-0.0135701736,
-0.0066661518,
0.0314192139,
0.026600644,
-0.058602307,
-0.0035749523,
-0.0005998607,
0.01728075,
-0.05420186,
-0.0237070285,
0.0162547454,
0.0040149866,
-0.0115437265,
0.0308904815,
-0.0606634356,
0.0137236696,
0.0216463823,
-0.0161341205,
0.0217826143,
-0.0377326459,
0.0029907653,
-0.0272236373,
-0.0119278515,
0.0335289203,
0.0112562403,
0.0057901475,
0.004893587,
-0.0014735353,
0.0252165701,
-0.025389079,
-0.0061894967,
0.0229337178,
0.02190952,
0.0135710612,
-0.0199370924,
-0.0246255547,
0.0074742548,
-0.0227541849,
0.0151473619,
0.036838755,
-0.03904121,
0.025085913,
-0.0668935254,
0.0620142333,
0.0224884767,
-0.0146687413,
-0.0301857162,
-0.0242495779,
-0.0946304277,
0.0029951124,
-0.0461508445,
0.0164667554,
0.0284544528,
0.0366154015,
-0.020575637,
0.0531236902,
0.0109068388,
-0.0089186858,
-0.0061463537,
-0.0653632656,
-0.0202653557,
0.0372433439,
0.0176426563,
0.0429403707,
-0.0007360539,
-0.0145997489,
0.0064762654,
-0.0649709329,
0.0169118978,
-0.004818629,
-0.0390352085,
-0.0377721451,
0.0202820636,
0.0955734178,
-0.0290872473,
0.050399188,
-0.0400895067,
0.0078138122,
0.0299482718,
0.0136922328,
0.0177940819,
-0.112710163,
-0.0389217697,
0.058179535,
0.0246269312,
-0.0607609488,
-0.0234627593,
0.0075681531,
-0.0172354784,
0.0339696594,
-0.0148502383,
0.0452929027,
0.0492804572,
0.009604306,
-0.0583628155,
0.0712331608,
0.0108207716,
0.0139711956,
0.0189670883,
-0.0944470614,
0.0199364685,
0.0408375673,
-0.0245721191,
0.0172093548,
0.0054438552,
-0.0032355711,
0.0763709024,
-0.0153507804,
0.0260640197,
0.0119056478,
-0.0120660672,
0.0487575121,
0.0361661576,
0.0451529399,
0.0232974906,
0.0463922136,
0.0442251861,
0.0272782315,
-0.0107031018,
-0.0591611601,
-0.044431638,
0.0519240648,
-0.0146815917,
0.0022662485,
-0.0347492844,
0.071128659,
-0.0026532724,
-0.0242037047,
-0.0006213084,
-0.0070179212,
-0.0127186226,
0.0065948721,
0.0698165074,
0.0260918196,
-0.033279147,
0.0798038244,
0.0373187177,
-0.0503309704,
-0.0339460149,
-0.043035835,
-0.0027226892,
0.0193624068,
0.009603193,
-0.0480284095,
-0.0240676608,
-0.0172049776,
0.023373533,
-0.0523398891,
0.0689474791,
0.0044157188,
-0.0027974613,
-0.0188489128,
-0.0172610711,
-0.0266590677,
-0.0140326964,
0.0635835156,
-0.0018645937,
0.022990305,
0.0067582214,
-0.0457677245,
-0.0582673103,
0.0286264699,
-0.0549913123,
-0.0130499583,
0.0132712256,
-0.0042476659,
-0.0051560388,
-0.0733729005,
-0.0011249966,
-0.0426186733,
0.0315031596,
-0.0207373109,
0.0086851316,
0.0146637876,
-0.0176728666,
-0.0011339891,
0.0046046786,
-0.030375354,
-0.0033165144,
0.0091833547,
-0.0315260962,
-0.0005402488,
0.0616438203,
0.0260275435,
0.0309525859,
0.0374523029,
0.0429233275,
-0.0497915968,
-0.0046331384,
-0.0247453246,
0.0222489815,
0.0663440675,
-0.001577707,
-0.0192628838,
-0.0047506616,
0.0082702162,
0.0306574982,
-0.0078432169,
0.0333885774,
-0.0490269028,
0.0355416872,
0.0098031685,
0.041151803,
-0.0444935486,
-0.0265192613,
-0.0689103976,
0.0125074312,
0.0031357857,
0.0294020418,
0.0134935733,
0.033594735,
0.0099542588,
-0.0016517096,
-0.0342006274,
0.0057411389,
-0.0233758762,
0.0384108685,
0.0068168431,
-0.0159169026,
-0.0310862362,
-0.0225638337,
-0.0168634206,
-0.0190890022,
0.0500591025,
-0.027152976,
-0.0229224619,
-0.0515774675,
0.0841087997,
0.0114110513,
-0.0212997813,
-0.0369588472,
-0.0067318557,
-0.036826048,
-0.0094390074,
0.0573347434,
0.0332511738,
-0.0525873899,
-0.0078507168,
0.0555346683,
-0.0272233207,
-0.0359286964,
-0.0033637986,
0.0279055443,
-0.0730289146,
-0.0172410253,
-0.0506008416,
0.0206185654,
0.071624063,
-0.0429984704,
-0.0197199993,
-0.0252386574,
-0.0165473726,
-0.0574654005,
0.0101908091,
-0.0117166629,
0.0186635684,
0.0231926031,
0.0243352074,
-0.0084232902,
-0.0658025965,
0.0370456129,
-0.0235938933,
-0.0082552284,
-0.042407617,
-0.039116431,
-0.0608117543,
0.0316383243,
-0.0022554358,
0.0097815646,
-0.0220033191,
-0.0213061981,
-0.0253565498,
0.0263550039,
0.0218057521,
-0.0273997858,
0.0461110063,
-0.0346702412,
-0.0102055892,
-0.0174602345,
-0.0384154655,
-0.012530528,
0.0411414951,
-0.0106337434,
0.0077110622,
0.0189535897,
-0.0056866244,
0.0116818054,
0.0181427468,
0.0215058085,
0.040017724,
0.0510853678,
-0.044066675,
0.0033131479,
-0.0748210177,
-0.0411174074,
-0.040241003,
-0.0253633391,
-0.0555580296,
-0.0084764697,
-0.0080140764,
0.0683689937,
-0.0133447442,
-0.0366870016,
-0.00684621,
0.0614343546,
-0.046113994,
-0.0760929137,
0.0435329489,
0.0621812567,
-0.0615957864,
-0.0240444951,
0.0437057056,
-0.0006547209,
-0.0378901288,
-0.0097698271,
-0.0439784527,
0.0263361912,
0.0654862672,
0.0774398819,
-0.0606311895,
-0.0334119052,
0.0056789527,
0.0224698074,
0.0022743912,
-0.0087857358,
0.0057986826,
-0.0945992321,
-0.0069732936,
0.0016883611,
-0.0821493641,
0.0047726352,
-0.0586429238,
0.0195422247,
-0.0249764398,
-0.0163392182,
-0.0008776245,
-0.0362127014,
0.0225618575,
0.0449002646,
-0.0647261366,
-0.0377515033,
0.0165692475,
-0.0134143103,
0.0040478618,
0.0672219917,
0.0117032882,
-0.0247137547,
-0.0225348696,
0.0402313322,
0.0075238324,
0.0022877862,
-0.0232507344,
0.0415470488,
0.0326362252,
-0.0245765802,
0.0796407685,
-0.0186820235,
-0.0378198847,
-0.0118840523,
0.0707428902,
0.0819270611,
0.033593148,
-0.0394197367,
0.0072448514,
-0.0278259348,
0.0052148239,
0.0361567661,
0.0152646909,
-0.0269550066,
-0.0302389786,
-0.057867948,
-0.0480846539,
-0.0011136002,
-0.0247710571,
0.0004883673,
-0.0222251341,
-0.0354856476,
-0.0431158505,
0.028568659,
0.0416957252,
0.0355311185,
0.0535119846,
0.0165034123,
0.0181119312,
0.0119204735,
-0.0500220023,
0.0184347332,
-0.0264741853,
0.023756953,
-0.0456002578,
-0.0305108372,
0.0158702936,
-0.0422170796,
-0.0157220718,
-0.0326859243,
-0.0838003084,
-0.0373767279,
-0.0192568041,
0.0823837668,
0.008264415,
-0.0003067158,
0.0013769737,
-0.0445221625,
-0.0359292626,
0.03255165,
-0.0370921046,
-0.0014833863,
0.0301390607,
-0.0216122437,
0.0122379577,
-0.0177905429,
-0.0648850575,
-0.0044567408,
0.0430827513,
-0.0465680212,
-0.0235044844,
0.0067374841,
-0.0010082879,
0.0317609124,
0.0228752177,
0.0553475469,
-0.0279632546,
0.0118147656,
-0.0183925088,
0.0443914868,
-0.0061278595,
-0.0482240431,
-0.0157548245,
0.0208145231,
0.0342274643,
0.0590231232,
0.0479049683,
0.0311157126,
0.003055105,
-0.0222816654,
0.0710865334,
0.0039194245,
0.0870686322,
0.0478550754,
0.0489504859,
-0.0113502648,
-0.045047801,
0.0348091573,
0.0628280044,
-0.0306444019,
0.0274017565,
0.0018759419,
0.0448349863,
0.0449904054,
-0.0095657473,
-0.0378280208,
-0.1003977805,
0.0110361818,
-0.0022360224,
0.0160216819,
-0.0047026854,
0.0634158924,
-0.0145429615,
0.0201292243,
-0.0267248135,
0.0337648913,
-0.0132366968,
0.0031104423,
-0.0123375766,
-0.003109236,
-0.0016291406,
-0.0318449251,
0.0815050602,
0.0008348149,
-0.0092923492,
-0.0294859428,
-0.0250758156,
0.0022198611,
0.0524755977,
0.0921592638,
-0.0360610522,
0.0022083714,
-0.0336349644,
-0.0126701109,
-0.0448683538,
-0.0092375586,
-0.0468373783,
0.0449395105,
-0.0252487101,
0.037913084,
0.1103255153,
0.0054723104,
-0.0152301202,
-0.032620322,
-0.002578971,
0.0319545157,
-0.0071904296,
0.0166306905,
-5.053484377e-33,
-0.0232895557,
0.0231734384,
0.0387627371,
0.0658861771,
0.0007445106,
-0.0059188372,
-0.0260307174,
0.0171051193,
-0.007748561,
-0.0226892196,
-0.0005650659,
-0.0206847638,
0.0022140199,
-0.006016552,
0.0718989372,
0.0418061838,
0.0557761081,
0.0426172614,
-0.0420592614,
0.0330749117,
-0.0068994183,
0.0585614964,
0.0652283505,
-0.0839154869,
-0.0459723882,
0.0344275795,
0.0575992763,
-0.0384258144,
0.0572488829,
0.0020387955,
0.0343544111,
0.0020050062,
-0.0062702014,
-0.079833217,
-0.0491427556,
-0.0471602157,
-0.0273466092,
-0.0142225083,
0.0239142682,
0.0379133187,
0.0279157609,
-0.0449476242,
0.0454071239,
-0.0065231225,
0.003022091,
-0.0051157745,
0.0402088612,
-0.0318076462,
-0.0279889908,
-0.0350079797,
-0.0890743285,
0.0194673184,
-0.0373736694,
0.0076944237,
0.0172941349,
0.06291724,
-0.0360502712,
-0.0003749244,
0.0069812541,
0.0098990444,
-0.0186823625,
0.0585755482,
0.1115326285,
0.038680166,
-0.008116113,
0.0095552951,
0.0443372913,
0.03997197,
0.0214699376,
-0.0015098669,
0.0655497238,
0.0770920888,
0.0116674826,
0.0028221626,
0.0256205648,
-0.0406995751,
-0.0116062872,
0.0028979641,
0.0024296448,
-0.0029227308,
-0.0127118109,
0.0536381491,
-0.0161382928,
-0.0344802886,
-0.043149665,
0.024025118,
0.0186221674,
-0.0388961844,
0.0451467186,
-0.0269705672,
-0.0162424352,
0.008718499,
0.0368280746,
-0.0409144647,
-0.0261673685,
0.0068972474,
-0.0612291433,
0.0372317359,
-0.0210316069,
0.0203695707,
-0.0744930282,
-0.0431818701,
-0.0395399332,
-0.006740022,
0.0877926126,
-0.0078712478,
0.0353319384,
0.0031964513,
-0.0758511573,
-0.0025089742,
-0.0508538261,
-0.0151205333,
0.0065628858,
0.0407816358,
0.0150392717,
0.0011555451,
0.0099002151,
0.0045238561,
0.0117676584,
-0.0721648708,
-0.0545391925,
-0.0280761234,
-0.0019045738,
-0.0200478323,
-0.0414904617,
-0.0471862182,
-0.0602733307,
0.0204542261,
0.0069360011,
-0.0318989046,
-0.0653793067,
0.0147073912,
2.656e-7,
-0.0128723299,
0.037635453,
-0.0498072952,
-0.0102809472,
-0.0101985913,
0.0295455009,
-0.0385337733,
0.0047725518,
0.0564898439,
0.0347963944,
-0.0624490827,
0.0364568904,
0.0630307496,
0.0381589383,
-0.0516346917,
-0.0446558669,
0.0037026235,
0.025341345,
-0.0515383519,
0.0229413174,
0.0071156975,
0.023887381,
0.0118365474,
0.0026437761,
0.0367869399,
-0.0431512296,
0.0204263236,
-0.0486946441,
0.0111407675,
0.0616745688,
-0.0315224268,
0.0331219137,
-0.0126284882,
0.0164149906,
-0.0161453262,
-0.0545751974,
0.0389147736,
0.0205766242,
0.0142870704,
0.0792235285,
0.0357229561,
0.0051269634,
-0.0202574246,
-0.0463827327,
0.0399183333,
-0.0335970409,
-0.0097923614,
-0.0172686242,
-0.0215362608,
-0.0230923966,
-0.0011570968,
0.0024273393,
0.0172661655,
-0.0096420441,
0.0135130621,
-0.0050257007,
-0.0982472003,
0.0097262096,
-0.0041309209,
0.054632891,
0.0000664106,
-0.0369307436,
-0.0663786754,
0.0165698584,
-0.007208941,
0.0100931646,
0.0514403023,
2.615583985e-34,
-0.0014726823,
-0.0225348156,
0.031129295,
0.0140162902,
0.016080061,
-0.0189076122,
0.0045302543,
0.0114020808,
-0.0119805373,
0.0249602292,
-0.0007724723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16931v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16931v1 | CL-MASR: A Continual Learning Benchmark for Multilingual ASR | 2023-10-25T18:55:40 | 2023-10-25T18:55:40 | Luca Della Libera, Pooneh Mousavi, Salah Zaiem, Cem Subakan, Mirco Ravanelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modern multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems like Whisper
have made it possible to transcribe audio in multiple languages with a single
model. However, current state-of-the-art ASR models are typically evaluated on
individual languages or in a multi-task setting, overlooking the challenge of
continually learning new languages. There is insufficient research on how to
add new languages without losing valuable information from previous data.
Furthermore, existing continual learning benchmarks focus mostly on vision and
language tasks, leaving continual learning for multilingual ASR largely
unexplored. To bridge this gap, we propose CL-MASR, a benchmark designed for
studying multilingual ASR in a continual learning setting. CL-MASR provides a
diverse set of continual learning methods implemented on top of large-scale
pretrained ASR models, along with common metrics to assess the effectiveness of
learning new languages while addressing the issue of catastrophic forgetting.
To the best of our knowledge, CL-MASR is the first continual learning benchmark
for the multilingual ASR task. The code is available at
https://github.com/speechbrain/benchmarks. | [
-0.056793604,
0.0565758795,
0.0013822345,
0.0413392931,
-0.0205884576,
0.0174660999,
0.0144487536,
-0.0563897304,
-0.0087826131,
0.0377361029,
-0.0667199269,
-0.0469787568,
0.0030202919,
0.0101216603,
0.0200121477,
0.0092879962,
0.042383831,
-0.0687201917,
-0.0420597903,
-0.0230466668,
-0.0062842262,
-0.0049017323,
-0.0358848833,
0.0358117819,
-0.0061495127,
-0.013885011,
0.0111160846,
-0.0136236651,
0.0422215462,
-0.026622517,
-0.022420302,
-0.0278616436,
0.0057598413,
0.0594572574,
0.0000019508,
-0.0462957695,
-0.0158664826,
0.0095636481,
-0.0465840399,
-0.0285966154,
0.0241284035,
0.0046533602,
-0.031482961,
0.0375172421,
-0.0151652498,
-0.0242340919,
0.0644831881,
-0.0340610556,
0.0298430864,
0.0280322209,
-0.0148059037,
-0.0256741103,
0.0409670398,
-0.0437425487,
-0.0139211994,
-0.0546006709,
-0.0101853022,
-0.0235827751,
-0.0556058772,
-0.0443625376,
-0.0029145083,
0.0792945325,
0.0467611887,
-0.0060375733,
-0.0020063824,
-0.0026642454,
-0.0030688483,
-0.0381513946,
-0.0171280932,
0.031204069,
-0.0386953801,
-0.0239311922,
0.0020366421,
0.0268547721,
-0.0724042878,
-0.0960224271,
-0.0322894864,
0.0255035255,
-0.011892003,
0.0023271623,
0.004868262,
0.0343218111,
0.0387129821,
-0.0065248576,
-0.0300587136,
0.0083248178,
0.0294024795,
-0.0102765961,
0.0482370108,
-0.0253689904,
0.0230676197,
0.0107262358,
0.0535119586,
0.0355303809,
-0.0584139451,
0.0045271264,
-0.0074301739,
-0.0341951512,
0.0215736758,
-0.0556304641,
0.0613722764,
0.071944952,
-0.0473694541,
0.0691262037,
-0.0192586351,
0.0703274757,
0.0284644589,
-0.0124658374,
-0.0028169882,
0.001279075,
-0.0176761393,
0.0049773958,
-0.0163569637,
0.01353609,
0.0062747584,
-0.0358999409,
-0.0106764538,
0.0299808048,
-0.0179049876,
0.0550870709,
-0.0249130856,
-0.0592959225,
-0.0760919452,
0.0071257325,
0.0393368676,
0.0526689589,
0.0092652831,
0.0133948578,
0.002009602,
-0.0209796056,
-0.0192513168,
0.0231545437,
-0.0029939655,
-0.0046683173,
0.0326322131,
0.0745787397,
-0.0281293094,
-0.0133609287,
-0.0183485076,
0.0422454178,
-0.0018464192,
-0.0773395896,
-0.0112019358,
-0.0395217687,
0.0700243637,
0.0001988342,
0.0055696624,
-0.0474316739,
-0.0147020696,
-0.0483648665,
0.0479104407,
0.0744855627,
0.0373197794,
-0.0102615645,
0.0265716314,
0.0090600913,
-0.0054829135,
0.0909698755,
0.0182033405,
-0.0120144645,
0.0215718951,
-0.014783619,
-0.0006748555,
0.084756583,
-0.0141185019,
0.034437988,
-0.0252082869,
-0.0016470625,
0.0510260947,
0.0195240788,
0.0171632227,
0.0448215157,
-0.0372026414,
-0.0133775305,
0.0312230308,
0.0191085394,
0.0068407948,
0.0313969962,
0.046322681,
-0.0314788818,
0.0376907215,
-0.0009463548,
-0.0088481978,
0.00423055,
0.0239775497,
0.0364372097,
0.0023050883,
0.0489336327,
-0.0406983234,
0.001529234,
0.0172994658,
-0.030621497,
-0.027028149,
0.0407955311,
0.0759638995,
0.0070025707,
-0.0565444864,
0.0562084578,
0.0203100797,
-0.068485491,
0.0276356936,
-0.0208388604,
-0.0136596831,
0.0355524011,
0.0119477035,
-0.0698160902,
-0.0796612352,
-0.0330774151,
-0.0118753808,
0.0314627551,
-0.0032076174,
0.0075092223,
0.1295988411,
-0.0717648119,
0.0043423786,
0.0188058168,
-0.0046716291,
0.0791606009,
-0.0229771324,
0.0599723831,
-0.0141780181,
-0.0235077552,
-0.024206426,
-0.0049029957,
-0.0851094946,
0.0195384454,
0.0270828176,
0.0005013103,
0.0311658084,
0.0368661694,
-0.0388827473,
-0.0181809943,
0.0532658473,
-0.0477119125,
0.0262350664,
0.0784747526,
-0.072503306,
-0.0182822328,
0.0810689628,
0.0049402784,
-0.0217223968,
0.0135055324,
-0.0172446091,
-0.0438898206,
0.020571867,
-0.010317957,
0.0557717048,
-0.0401081927,
0.0562824532,
-0.0134386532,
0.0069451993,
0.0283048954,
-0.0332386978,
0.0101425676,
0.0056610527,
0.0031496482,
-0.0129419388,
0.0157914609,
-0.0992206186,
-0.021425074,
0.043106202,
-0.0214945357,
0.0084655387,
0.0030516142,
0.0045518819,
-0.0033049169,
-0.0271599032,
-0.0746397376,
-0.0148778474,
-0.0290461946,
0.0117968051,
-0.0309380218,
0.0177056734,
0.0183628015,
-0.0453886203,
-0.0015182733,
-0.0188861992,
-0.0201766808,
0.0209527258,
-0.0445319302,
-0.007411343,
-0.0161313452,
-0.0324088223,
-0.005796216,
0.0527441204,
0.0172280706,
-0.0372353382,
-0.0236858614,
-0.0702170134,
-0.003811863,
-0.01426268,
0.0197899863,
-0.0311376788,
-0.0225252528,
-0.0209900793,
0.0018105221,
0.0579473898,
0.037500944,
-0.0320948176,
0.0027603013,
0.0381036289,
-0.0073221484,
-0.0258597713,
-0.0031984046,
0.0002927549,
-0.0146786766,
-0.0259902608,
0.018944975,
-0.0243488383,
0.0174635146,
-0.0104268398,
0.0221092608,
-0.0240352694,
-0.0311561022,
-0.0325185061,
-0.0408886895,
-0.0529679321,
0.0015300947,
-0.0229850505,
0.0058499901,
-0.003732533,
-0.0324595496,
0.0220274795,
-0.0536255725,
-0.044596605,
-0.0220313892,
-0.0402440317,
-0.0307112802,
0.021029545,
-0.0208984837,
0.0211338867,
-0.017775733,
-0.0646426082,
-0.0018756328,
0.0154567678,
0.0563371629,
-0.0140407532,
0.045735471,
-0.0177571792,
-0.005254596,
-0.0074020289,
-0.0606360808,
-0.0295052603,
0.0361156687,
-0.0132300165,
0.0243502054,
-0.0082172854,
-0.0299106799,
-0.0548880734,
0.0221055243,
0.0343076326,
0.0689539462,
0.0220103525,
0.0144678587,
0.001990844,
0.0178525932,
0.0021662994,
0.0203247629,
0.0091200657,
-0.0429364257,
0.0322380103,
-0.0011342299,
0.0877375156,
-0.0102940965,
-0.056929525,
0.0159474779,
0.050316181,
0.0154361762,
0.0481077433,
-0.0162308142,
0.0262585171,
-0.0081082946,
-0.0110777318,
0.0706905574,
-0.004574677,
-0.0624305047,
-0.0095017869,
-0.015447896,
0.0351987593,
0.0225827079,
-0.0063398569,
-0.069079414,
0.0043503037,
0.0585199296,
0.0360156894,
0.0451352671,
0.0136377402,
-0.0138913458,
-0.0644306093,
-0.0090421131,
0.0285166539,
-0.080525659,
0.0049831625,
-0.0723075345,
-0.0547988378,
-0.0497758389,
0.0356901586,
0.0097757913,
-0.0023734127,
-0.0411942713,
0.0127309533,
-0.0487140343,
-0.0375835635,
0.0174815394,
-0.0316423737,
0.0576340631,
0.0301632769,
0.0219358895,
-0.0045190477,
-0.0283912737,
0.0679255575,
0.0225572884,
-0.0276622996,
-0.0212501921,
0.0289845187,
0.0317373648,
-0.0336265825,
0.0480762608,
0.0149153639,
-0.0126007656,
0.0164938234,
0.0458664931,
0.0219718292,
0.0142549397,
0.0313811563,
0.0483971797,
-0.000297665,
0.0021338204,
0.0503421798,
0.0107647199,
0.0016668385,
-0.0089494362,
-0.0038743939,
0.0371892117,
-0.0371198654,
0.0192480721,
-0.0198541991,
-0.0433036797,
-0.0301619582,
-0.007878596,
-0.0111564863,
-0.0013459183,
0.031966839,
0.0393252075,
0.0107820779,
-0.0127613209,
-0.0017746383,
-0.0583025254,
-0.0071020359,
0.0158641059,
0.0502797067,
-0.0726600289,
-0.0059193969,
0.0401154086,
-0.0188507549,
-0.0011378769,
-0.0012563063,
-0.0926609784,
-0.0745249167,
0.0086490689,
0.0369878821,
0.0169159435,
0.0711982399,
-0.021677237,
-0.0363948829,
0.0186688229,
-0.0100797927,
-0.0544196106,
0.0229780935,
0.0918687358,
0.0097639458,
-0.0093365116,
0.0285553783,
-0.0278649982,
-0.0089211753,
0.005819092,
0.0367947109,
0.006337883,
0.0000237466,
-0.0314046554,
0.0071108867,
0.0131332306,
-0.0388790704,
-0.0049334085,
-0.0409268104,
0.0323961899,
0.0065167327,
0.0369897,
-0.0346930139,
-0.0081675695,
0.0373011641,
0.0241474472,
-0.0216604639,
0.0303411037,
0.0207113642,
-0.0394208357,
-0.0174359102,
0.0392462276,
0.0334839672,
-0.02916269,
0.0422104262,
0.013882908,
-0.0564516485,
0.042064596,
0.003277791,
0.0325483344,
-0.0103904046,
0.0137910349,
0.0042766687,
0.0041532177,
0.0256781951,
0.0239973404,
-0.0105614038,
-0.0721790567,
-0.0022142343,
0.044664517,
0.091443941,
0.0245691538,
0.0890721753,
0.0017102832,
0.0103586782,
-0.0480323285,
0.0179878473,
-0.0389522351,
-0.0127439545,
-0.009056651,
-0.0001889527,
0.0051811687,
0.0760314316,
0.0624943785,
-0.0198022686,
0.0127073359,
-0.0059726969,
0.0504805185,
-0.0412701182,
-0.0172916986,
-0.0136592733,
-0.0050337347,
-0.0131193483,
-0.0165306758,
0.0107376594,
-0.0806837976,
0.0777822062,
0.0141296824,
0.0118817911,
0.0150888637,
-0.0213545021,
0.0349881947,
-0.0191488415,
0.0405810364,
0.0009627612,
-0.01851945,
0.019306194,
-0.0082978383,
0.0279545467,
-5.922224293e-33,
0.0054254206,
0.0248694327,
0.0156659819,
0.0356431007,
-0.060591206,
0.0005487627,
-0.0591793992,
0.0173293632,
0.0187179111,
-0.0225305781,
-0.0005817013,
-0.0190168116,
0.0358861014,
0.0248174425,
0.0113159763,
-0.0016762796,
0.0805930793,
0.0261883605,
-0.0076382481,
0.0127825951,
0.0336741284,
0.0495187007,
0.0350801796,
-0.0259028301,
-0.0430798791,
0.0283588134,
0.0055216583,
0.0244890545,
0.0212041531,
0.0537103228,
-0.0127795245,
0.057423003,
-0.0218985546,
-0.0204245765,
-0.021299554,
-0.0504716188,
-0.1001702249,
-0.0201997664,
-0.0239346381,
0.0587657019,
-0.0171202496,
-0.0046308083,
-0.0204479508,
-0.027908653,
-0.0219225939,
-0.0273037367,
0.0088937739,
-0.0401194692,
-0.0571694188,
-0.045077078,
-0.031501051,
0.0290164389,
-0.0177636314,
0.0073439851,
0.0805949867,
0.0195665006,
-0.0182274915,
-0.0470637567,
-0.110455282,
0.0084227063,
-0.0356637239,
0.0470863804,
0.0588687621,
0.0360616706,
-0.0036024128,
0.0265620872,
0.0860354677,
-0.0440195836,
0.06910377,
0.0133478269,
0.0525863208,
-0.0076640067,
0.0072962297,
0.0193445813,
0.0136927227,
-0.0164206047,
-0.0142004518,
-0.042892728,
0.0545912571,
0.0312479101,
0.0294998214,
0.0112947784,
-0.0036719055,
-0.0155818965,
-0.0703109726,
0.0006922344,
-0.0507803112,
0.0170482658,
0.0599977672,
0.0339485817,
0.0146888308,
0.0010063876,
0.056163568,
-0.0131895356,
0.003677781,
0.0216970537,
-0.0090378392,
0.0036699816,
-0.0093198204,
0.0755857229,
-0.0418167971,
-0.0204612929,
-0.0271468963,
0.0168195292,
0.0092810616,
-0.0477200001,
0.0393956788,
0.0741085634,
-0.0410653986,
0.0108107235,
-0.0258173384,
0.0278923772,
0.0316697918,
0.0255340803,
0.0372369625,
-0.0292531792,
-0.0190020744,
0.0475456193,
0.0113369944,
0.005626081,
-0.0357109234,
0.0337198637,
0.0180172585,
0.0463822372,
-0.0423486419,
0.0144452453,
-0.0250337459,
-0.0259250812,
0.0134855034,
-0.0676713139,
-0.0063450662,
-0.0104017444,
2.551e-7,
-0.0442729704,
0.0008841275,
0.0445335172,
-0.0204545408,
0.013629945,
0.0006869207,
-0.09120702,
-0.032486245,
0.004421127,
0.0850335658,
-0.0369130559,
0.0237116907,
0.0872481242,
0.0259479154,
-0.0496528521,
-0.0219940674,
-0.049265936,
0.033402063,
-0.020102948,
-0.0092494087,
-0.0263833255,
0.0502687246,
-0.0112215895,
-0.0206929632,
0.014293544,
-0.0692944005,
0.0663148388,
0.0027731357,
0.018650569,
-0.0062728678,
-0.0361113101,
0.0089571895,
-0.0213743728,
-0.0286105443,
-0.0433233827,
-0.0118145142,
0.0118230497,
0.028157156,
-0.0083583109,
-0.0947152153,
0.0296025053,
0.0516759045,
-0.0461242273,
-0.0273930989,
0.0326004326,
-0.0249663722,
-0.0094780531,
-0.01010809,
-0.031309735,
0.0092864484,
0.0503034852,
-0.0316015445,
-0.0136393281,
0.0137941111,
0.0311405789,
0.0076430668,
-0.0239042621,
-0.0481070168,
0.0153303677,
-0.0005216547,
-0.0378522016,
-0.0293517672,
-0.0320414342,
0.0065683634,
-0.0237596072,
-0.0223279689,
-0.0011657701,
1.878067924e-34,
0.0520058125,
-0.0523085557,
0.0407358296,
0.0190945864,
-0.0053359019,
-0.0630812719,
-0.0188071057,
0.0219306555,
-0.0316115282,
-0.0344386287,
-0.0509827435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16924v1 | Physician Detection of Clinical Harm in Machine Translation: Quality Estimation Aids in Reliance and Backtranslation Identifies Critical Errors | 2023-10-25T18:44:14 | 2023-10-25T18:44:14 | Nikita Mehandru, Sweta Agrawal, Yimin Xiao, Elaine C Khoong, Ge Gao, Marine Carpuat, Niloufar Salehi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | A major challenge in the practical use of Machine Translation (MT) is that
users lack guidance to make informed decisions about when to rely on outputs.
Progress in quality estimation research provides techniques to automatically
assess MT quality, but these techniques have primarily been evaluated in vitro
by comparison against human judgments outside of a specific context of use.
This paper evaluates quality estimation feedback in vivo with a human study
simulating decision-making in high-stakes medical settings. Using Emergency
Department discharge instructions, we study how interventions based on quality
estimation versus backtranslation assist physicians in deciding whether to show
MT outputs to a patient. We find that quality estimation improves appropriate
reliance on MT, but backtranslation helps physicians detect more clinically
harmful errors that QE alone often misses. | [
0.0364636742,
0.0384025574,
-0.0204763766,
-0.032212317,
0.0010442026,
0.0274426956,
-0.0117413625,
0.034518186,
-0.0453557372,
0.0371272229,
0.0084457053,
-0.0280385129,
0.0638381541,
0.0276697986,
0.0149096139,
-0.0231880788,
0.0167490467,
0.0310455356,
0.0002160768,
0.0291178934,
-0.0052688578,
0.0160439946,
-0.0167704504,
0.0647258237,
0.0096317576,
0.0101781506,
0.0367360897,
0.0301334057,
0.0471941046,
-0.0704627186,
-0.0504952967,
0.0233748648,
-0.0171034653,
0.0191136431,
0.0000018955,
-0.030849468,
0.0002120238,
0.0144640915,
-0.0449350849,
-0.0321854614,
0.0402228758,
-0.0925067589,
-0.0299710259,
0.0054400233,
-0.0175858196,
0.0006257368,
0.0316091366,
-0.0154776368,
0.0202415027,
0.0433349945,
-0.0168940183,
0.0688948706,
-0.0150637748,
-0.0133338068,
-0.0026344897,
-0.0502056591,
-0.0165138636,
0.0040565212,
0.0046281018,
-0.0004478146,
0.0069116727,
0.0654387176,
0.0225337427,
0.0087476606,
-0.0483553782,
0.0298032034,
0.0088548474,
-0.0372999236,
-0.02127745,
0.0598589592,
0.026232237,
0.0359765254,
-0.0130082862,
-0.0283820219,
0.005816502,
-0.0076133781,
-0.0046123769,
-0.008311417,
-0.0178000126,
-0.0206623916,
-0.0411678888,
0.0172404386,
0.0170905348,
-0.0146054821,
0.0059823422,
-0.0576255694,
-0.0108753517,
-0.0428513996,
0.0224454682,
0.0425411016,
-0.022509519,
0.0056004017,
0.0497298799,
-0.0231767818,
-0.0510723479,
0.021563407,
0.0178169589,
-0.0399190858,
0.0534510054,
-0.0648415014,
0.0133616552,
0.0255562682,
0.0009046504,
-0.021294307,
-0.0031208,
0.0410121158,
-0.0447423942,
0.0381854363,
-0.0630142763,
0.0553679653,
-0.0077347667,
0.011225421,
-0.0165578183,
-0.0505663529,
0.0092419237,
0.0193807334,
-0.1026310697,
-0.0337068141,
-0.0162794273,
0.0621410087,
-0.0102278171,
0.0227795076,
-0.0657565892,
-0.0098239603,
-0.0320116654,
0.037639726,
-0.0011872089,
0.0109399585,
0.0038334227,
-0.027963547,
0.020580288,
0.0110957772,
-0.0350851305,
0.0207321551,
-0.0046516405,
0.0710189715,
-0.0055782804,
0.0001694751,
0.0260281134,
-0.0431585759,
-0.0697936714,
-0.0410762094,
0.0373358168,
-0.0353653878,
0.0142618055,
0.0118886493,
0.022312751,
-0.0193831474,
0.0055905269,
0.0049679829,
-0.0180721078,
0.0169027075,
-0.0506963208,
0.0170459617,
-0.0028575687,
0.043824207,
-0.0432117097,
0.0080097495,
0.0148201482,
0.0026596317,
0.0013920012,
-0.0410571024,
0.0128023066,
0.0000183001,
-0.0020190128,
0.0182670951,
-0.0536774136,
-0.0043355934,
-0.0212452859,
0.0692587048,
-0.0071997317,
0.0707187653,
-0.0211224873,
0.072035186,
0.0341628641,
0.0493956842,
0.0166832954,
-0.0201217216,
0.0261170212,
-0.0341499858,
-0.0384759158,
0.0289362464,
0.0029773272,
-0.0177003294,
0.0218339358,
-0.0246198252,
0.0208452456,
0.0004021401,
-0.0031663768,
-0.0566822216,
-0.0408063754,
-0.0215396639,
0.0000196066,
-0.0195801556,
0.0187256578,
0.0075444928,
-0.0153412335,
0.0030785888,
0.0017441913,
-0.0019187519,
-0.0224147532,
-0.0388918072,
-0.040626891,
0.0983177796,
0.0318740495,
0.022025723,
0.0353902131,
-0.051574029,
-0.002731947,
0.0178784113,
0.0301628355,
0.0110314945,
0.0104478272,
-0.0142649366,
-0.0347549804,
0.0794072077,
0.0198905747,
-0.0312517285,
-0.0209614411,
0.0528958328,
-0.0004571603,
-0.0571375079,
-0.0770542845,
0.0363536924,
-0.0110432664,
-0.0347432494,
0.0245018229,
-0.0072189569,
0.0203200355,
0.0147324614,
-0.0151025467,
0.0146379014,
0.0238215216,
0.0107872924,
-0.0448772199,
0.0633108169,
-0.0397606008,
0.0014497339,
-0.0118702231,
-0.0450115763,
-0.040083468,
-0.0436709486,
-0.024847351,
-0.0048188269,
-0.0476029553,
-0.0865305215,
-0.0007774376,
0.0090936413,
0.0339997001,
0.0079501513,
-0.0278682541,
-0.0351653844,
-0.0119874934,
-0.0442550592,
0.0208086241,
0.0067802491,
-0.0651804954,
0.0044118627,
-0.0001704552,
-0.0238233358,
0.0343583152,
0.0001425864,
0.0504520275,
0.0095509021,
0.0462303311,
-0.0354893208,
-0.0026521157,
-0.0424827114,
-0.0235558935,
0.0274766758,
0.0064781802,
0.0311973039,
-0.0072288732,
0.0108495429,
-0.0041567311,
0.0139203323,
-0.0402070843,
0.0466774516,
0.0345034525,
0.0073729153,
0.0480407029,
0.0275876522,
0.0022693672,
-0.0273498762,
-0.0391148366,
0.0470968485,
0.022934515,
-0.0261023659,
-0.0485129841,
-0.0204457156,
-0.0055008484,
-0.0367460288,
0.031294141,
-0.0586508326,
0.0625685155,
0.0201904736,
0.0128966123,
0.0392768942,
-0.0167130157,
0.0001773357,
0.0472890995,
0.0327893943,
-0.0363351554,
-0.0327089392,
-0.0241546184,
-0.0619376898,
0.0362911187,
-0.0851333067,
0.0168017838,
0.0355352573,
0.0260699745,
0.0432432219,
-0.0416557267,
0.0158481319,
-0.0243902989,
-0.0375900194,
0.002810484,
-0.0199733526,
-0.024466848,
0.0803059861,
0.0215087812,
-0.0406245254,
0.0988208354,
0.0088065602,
0.0262282416,
-0.0397851914,
0.0193757694,
0.0216454603,
-0.0324469693,
-0.0504827648,
0.0178554207,
0.0100941453,
-0.0241191164,
0.040937148,
0.0011018843,
0.0230151117,
-0.0380075164,
0.0257795975,
-0.0648773015,
-0.0129158264,
0.0131931389,
-0.025699418,
-0.0256487001,
0.0258813724,
-0.0167891737,
-0.0239746217,
0.0113621466,
0.0150065199,
-0.0295450613,
-0.0177860316,
0.0486374423,
0.0192803964,
0.0140151214,
-0.039029628,
0.0263512451,
-0.054159794,
-0.0148450732,
-0.0248043835,
0.0324054249,
-0.0736250803,
0.0469338112,
0.0735502243,
-0.0043566972,
0.0266147312,
-0.0057551619,
-0.0160599481,
-0.0116236499,
0.0158143304,
-0.0292013902,
0.0422067493,
0.0541161634,
-0.0356722921,
-0.0058075069,
0.0602946319,
0.0002835002,
-0.071671769,
0.0295114927,
-0.0345018767,
-0.0457102694,
-0.0369625017,
-0.0128775844,
-0.0631313324,
-0.019986473,
-0.0125930095,
0.0901755616,
-0.0171665978,
0.0000646387,
0.0151294013,
-0.0231998749,
0.0503680557,
0.0369073004,
-0.0394635051,
-0.0831668526,
-0.0240407288,
-0.0003712081,
-0.0267416518,
0.040968284,
-0.0218520723,
0.0102935219,
-0.0043428293,
0.0210585687,
-0.041690141,
-0.0744929835,
0.0095849149,
-0.0250648931,
-0.0008922723,
0.0856688842,
0.0111389495,
-0.0172122177,
-0.0585991628,
-0.0114635238,
-0.0227975994,
0.0182779133,
0.0029856074,
0.0658756196,
0.0180410221,
0.0155505296,
-0.0390953831,
-0.0047481204,
0.0261575282,
-0.003744106,
-0.0224443693,
0.0567509569,
-0.052138336,
-0.0271141473,
-0.0164150782,
0.0349307805,
0.0353152007,
-0.001619957,
0.0429956093,
-0.037142057,
-0.0086282911,
-0.0074578174,
0.0441956148,
-0.0148919849,
-0.0355815068,
0.001131663,
-0.044513911,
-0.0415266007,
-0.0861824825,
-0.0292305611,
0.0116188759,
0.0289251674,
0.012143068,
-0.016439734,
0.01885782,
0.0011045404,
-0.0000107555,
0.0746272132,
0.0368424468,
0.0331387594,
-0.0385581627,
0.0246364605,
-0.0056411638,
0.0366347767,
0.0068882969,
0.0427026562,
0.0453983359,
-0.0110836066,
0.0140848476,
0.0872826204,
0.029108312,
-0.020984903,
-0.0041590133,
0.0109523451,
0.0034872771,
0.0142663224,
-0.0270540584,
-0.0313668735,
0.0319083408,
0.0150663555,
-0.0226478763,
-0.004433542,
0.0142376702,
0.0058491435,
0.003022216,
0.0334740505,
-0.03648597,
-0.0604952797,
0.0285549294,
0.0249544382,
0.059588287,
-0.0747964755,
-0.0329825506,
-0.0086743897,
-0.0218804348,
0.0010218485,
0.0084892567,
-0.0162179396,
-0.0067748283,
0.0455528907,
-0.0221983828,
0.0095020887,
-0.0082668513,
-0.0968178585,
-0.0819471031,
-0.0152724935,
0.0400015675,
-0.0198501907,
0.0580238812,
0.0379085988,
0.0186730959,
-0.0089704813,
0.025898613,
-0.0242663305,
0.0409700684,
0.0021243431,
0.0460773148,
-0.0259093568,
0.0127687249,
0.0384591594,
0.0611748807,
-0.0002412488,
-0.0431788415,
-0.0258385744,
-0.000792956,
0.0245454032,
0.0045752255,
0.0533200018,
-0.0082639949,
0.0116084432,
-0.0375515819,
0.0234475695,
-0.0200406499,
0.0382629782,
-0.0105727343,
-0.0147690447,
-0.0049471911,
-0.0266219657,
0.0496425293,
-0.0552424118,
0.0071124234,
-0.0701068416,
-0.0538871996,
-0.0183343757,
-0.0178926922,
-0.0048225769,
-0.0423578024,
-0.0650705248,
-0.0260729622,
-0.0730421096,
-0.0377240218,
0.0016453745,
0.0247271787,
0.0015661496,
-0.0388149396,
0.0193808693,
0.0456840135,
-0.0230337791,
-0.0054779788,
-0.0313844532,
0.0466135107,
0.0259391125,
0.0183106828,
-0.0138952481,
-5.092631645e-33,
0.0039448761,
-0.0659616888,
-0.0154422242,
-0.0491281301,
0.0249303542,
0.0274167992,
-0.0404055417,
0.0325085446,
0.0330327898,
0.0524916723,
0.0067132674,
-0.0095278928,
0.0149588445,
-0.0192992687,
0.0546016917,
-0.0044205161,
0.0343666971,
0.0228887219,
-0.035336636,
0.0014638628,
-0.0206593759,
0.0078003588,
0.0860298052,
-0.0912812576,
0.037137758,
0.0355992131,
-0.0094866427,
-0.0267338492,
-0.0491408296,
0.0368167162,
0.0302178543,
0.019177597,
0.0201862175,
-0.0461017601,
-0.0411187038,
0.0106766541,
0.0022676508,
0.0186887663,
0.0127805714,
0.0024940779,
-0.0543985739,
-0.003931825,
0.0499071516,
-0.0257979389,
-0.0439948849,
0.0315198638,
-0.0027191662,
-0.01941319,
-0.0187688936,
-0.0272582304,
-0.014461901,
0.0408204012,
-0.0117954481,
-0.0275250133,
0.0021120897,
0.0801498964,
-0.0606066994,
-0.0232876837,
-0.0561184697,
-0.0050748023,
0.0393177532,
-0.025820123,
0.041493196,
-0.0656605661,
-0.0346562266,
0.0249663182,
0.0207327046,
0.0128110936,
-0.0301102363,
0.0175489355,
-0.0021754049,
0.0032442836,
0.0968385562,
0.0322652124,
0.0304931886,
-0.0584474765,
-0.0306227729,
0.0601735227,
-0.1240052953,
0.0603414848,
0.0294431094,
-0.012197963,
-0.0783342272,
-0.0271839518,
-0.0188249033,
-0.0333106071,
0.0055731763,
-0.028961258,
0.0005532143,
0.0069995341,
0.0073215384,
-0.0147121297,
0.0365762077,
-0.0008304172,
0.0682021081,
-0.0755579025,
0.0080219889,
0.0184014123,
-0.0303057898,
-0.0195595883,
-0.0501157492,
-0.0015677151,
0.042185422,
0.0299328938,
0.0650365204,
-0.0163725261,
0.0138505101,
-0.0354656689,
-0.02359543,
0.0410068668,
0.0123349968,
0.0169946142,
0.0126098543,
-0.0295614805,
0.0494760014,
-0.0032392037,
-0.0215053502,
0.0479489975,
-0.008255207,
-0.0077823196,
-0.0497227125,
-0.0032465332,
0.0027919051,
0.0406202413,
-0.0697084591,
-0.0045762425,
-0.0220109597,
0.0873028487,
0.0589349195,
-0.030554574,
-0.0208295248,
-0.00936672,
2.603e-7,
0.0811190531,
0.044058986,
0.0316860564,
-0.0014215194,
0.0037605537,
0.0517269857,
-0.0298694037,
0.0055772401,
0.030230213,
-0.028908167,
0.0743825212,
0.0046515823,
0.0579178184,
0.0535854138,
0.0101551646,
-0.0631694272,
-0.08631327,
0.0282435361,
-0.00152799,
-0.0237600394,
0.0555438213,
0.0009797359,
-0.0661421046,
-0.0367106237,
0.0018613602,
0.0135080609,
0.0285058022,
-0.0155388964,
0.0225612931,
-0.0240743421,
0.0761725232,
-0.0035095271,
0.0165525693,
0.040331196,
-0.0222249757,
-0.0560656302,
0.0042615021,
0.0990175456,
-0.0464930274,
0.0074948086,
0.018496342,
-0.0054040174,
0.0459345654,
-0.0056621237,
-0.008309749,
-0.0602930523,
-0.004867516,
0.0148993544,
-0.0162050147,
-0.0089008175,
0.1299577802,
-0.0362377092,
-0.0472459272,
0.0455666669,
0.0324159116,
0.0821766481,
-0.0387378857,
-0.002743423,
-0.0070206271,
0.0360114761,
0.0109417336,
-0.0575845875,
0.0301090851,
-0.0100873196,
-0.0535059609,
-0.0590500198,
-0.0185270905,
1.864793562e-34,
0.0421616286,
0.009366259,
0.0485962741,
-0.0267592408,
0.0493700877,
0.0028854494,
0.0157408863,
-0.0200961791,
0.0443807319,
-0.0035866916,
-0.0249762069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16897v1 | Divide et Impera: Multi-Transformer Architectures for Complex NLP-Tasks | 2023-10-25T18:00:15 | 2023-10-25T18:00:15 | Solveig Helland, Elena Gavagnin, Alexandre de Spindler | cs.CL | cs.CL | The growing capabilities of transformer models pave the way for solving
increasingly complex NLP tasks. A key to supporting application-specific
requirements is the ability to fine-tune. However, compiling a fine-tuning
dataset tailored to complex tasks is tedious and results in large datasets,
limiting the ability to control transformer output. We present an approach in
which complex tasks are divided into simpler subtasks. Multiple transformer
models are fine-tuned to one subtask each, and lined up to accomplish the
complex task. This simplifies the compilation of fine-tuning datasets and
increases overall controllability. Using the example of reducing gender bias as
a complex task, we demonstrate our approach and show that it performs better
than using a single model. | [
0.0503515601,
0.0947931111,
-0.029905431,
0.0085526621,
-0.0150094265,
0.0061424738,
0.0428756736,
-0.0262299292,
-0.018775614,
-0.0749933124,
-0.0029268032,
0.0208621975,
0.0004915735,
-0.0027370935,
-0.0019971533,
-0.0802063793,
0.0193253793,
0.0264360812,
-0.0112246079,
-0.013689639,
0.0023687577,
0.0158892367,
0.0130639551,
0.0731330365,
-0.002117275,
-0.0311665181,
0.0280170478,
-0.0156714823,
0.0080899,
0.0258428659,
0.0323464423,
0.070691593,
-0.0324269608,
0.0133697446,
0.0000021037,
-0.0133047737,
-0.043216642,
0.0236496013,
-0.0106078526,
-0.0507234,
0.0243160091,
-0.043454919,
-0.009612767,
0.0348791927,
-0.0189773701,
-0.0209625959,
0.0485139638,
0.0849541053,
0.0952772051,
0.0576508529,
-0.0126166949,
-0.0117053147,
-0.0187800564,
-0.0176750533,
-0.0440453142,
-0.012273564,
0.030417202,
-0.0514495783,
-0.0414929576,
-0.0141619621,
-0.0220968928,
0.0158651154,
0.0105590718,
0.0272421837,
0.0027436588,
-0.0060070478,
-0.0553271808,
-0.062260408,
-0.0338339619,
0.0411542431,
-0.049229078,
0.0121999849,
0.0092668757,
-0.0177001879,
0.0369774997,
0.0120206932,
-0.0430715531,
0.0432022661,
-0.020251058,
-0.0066011795,
-0.0180623699,
-0.0038171967,
0.0094414372,
0.0201249681,
-0.0252020825,
0.0526821092,
-0.0023383435,
-0.0191216245,
0.0166307017,
0.0326737165,
-0.0211732443,
-0.0441872627,
0.044579953,
0.0112713566,
-0.0611175038,
0.0087618809,
-0.0251008924,
-0.0343946591,
-0.0009341068,
-0.0007443842,
0.0336892642,
0.0522217229,
0.0073119304,
0.0178368874,
0.0027101708,
0.0288330596,
-0.0289542433,
0.0066697332,
-0.0235959459,
-0.0454267785,
-0.0402881168,
-0.0133116208,
-0.0464373529,
0.029848069,
-0.062074963,
0.0286660492,
-0.053826794,
-0.0024588706,
-0.0753418282,
-0.0185964108,
0.067380324,
0.0367993601,
-0.0402186997,
0.0276889205,
0.0073438771,
0.0568713285,
-0.050216835,
0.0095672272,
-0.0145037659,
-0.0813894495,
-0.0085544549,
-0.0052907206,
0.0097517595,
-0.0402202159,
0.0042032371,
0.0460300036,
0.0218284409,
-0.050287433,
-0.0231927484,
-0.0293860491,
0.0070020137,
-0.0581399351,
0.0154648414,
-0.062049266,
0.0457261167,
0.0237339344,
0.0444158986,
-0.0362815969,
-0.0096243173,
0.0331137665,
-0.0407289192,
0.0829408765,
0.0711868778,
-0.0032083842,
0.0362806693,
0.0122515578,
-0.0303176343,
0.1102141142,
0.0285886228,
0.0061670365,
0.0422706231,
-0.0108288089,
0.0177379828,
0.036344979,
0.0111877564,
-0.0137974909,
0.0233041774,
-0.0186982304,
-0.0434079319,
0.0092161223,
0.0149142472,
0.0442679152,
0.0069348267,
0.0020370882,
0.0515489317,
0.0397236757,
0.0744575858,
0.0572641827,
0.0105710085,
0.0028389306,
-0.0224875417,
0.0103530949,
-0.0626463965,
0.0242609438,
-0.0007624932,
-0.0380336121,
-0.0331271999,
0.0774641186,
-0.0279890783,
-0.0405019037,
-0.0149302259,
0.0041378369,
0.0037167741,
0.0078608161,
0.0350949802,
0.059766531,
-0.0350349955,
0.1124835983,
0.0297900587,
-0.0425871536,
-0.0141914394,
-0.0477173999,
-0.0299918372,
0.0172148626,
0.0220345464,
-0.0614213645,
-0.0058324174,
-0.0260758549,
-0.012520181,
0.0256757904,
0.0481260531,
-0.0073284893,
0.0106686465,
-0.043895416,
-0.0333901308,
0.0212022997,
0.0340503044,
-0.0291227605,
0.0687862486,
-0.012395246,
-0.0116255069,
0.0234614797,
-0.0130746877,
0.0488429517,
-0.017142795,
0.0088291746,
0.0225649048,
0.0197061654,
-0.0009623427,
0.0129639227,
-0.0134011311,
-0.0056720055,
0.0098474603,
-0.0252218321,
-0.0555324629,
-0.0139806308,
-0.0037405654,
0.0226640068,
0.0084594702,
-0.0739863738,
-0.0238247234,
0.067350015,
-0.029711714,
-0.006190571,
0.0304163955,
-0.043678984,
0.0129458494,
0.0207980908,
0.0085595734,
0.0032778014,
0.0244186278,
-0.0391367637,
0.0366056263,
-0.0137855308,
-0.0209334586,
0.0206865948,
-0.0709318295,
-0.0414407291,
-0.0437787846,
-0.0532389767,
-0.0094145006,
-0.0066881017,
0.0032118242,
0.0319874734,
-0.0107213492,
-0.02149757,
-0.0604647957,
-0.0400667116,
0.0156772472,
-0.0146033652,
-0.0111615397,
0.009159511,
0.0443138666,
0.0229082685,
0.0133090485,
0.0002320313,
-0.0049705701,
0.0215369686,
0.0344308503,
0.011551301,
-0.0325236432,
-0.0070026815,
-0.0040228227,
-0.044389952,
-0.0368721783,
0.0832412094,
0.0120969657,
-0.007374452,
-0.0388689563,
-0.015331951,
0.0121210106,
0.0375946946,
0.0011713592,
-0.0299693197,
-0.0040740576,
0.0300793052,
0.038072098,
0.0797681734,
0.0076458966,
0.0646037012,
0.0252409764,
-0.0128832906,
-0.0428920686,
0.0109641347,
-0.033693444,
0.0228375904,
-0.00092463,
-0.0217751507,
0.0002937214,
0.0637897477,
0.0196690783,
-0.0222178083,
-0.0685002208,
0.0526260026,
-0.0356502756,
-0.0237036161,
0.030148413,
-0.0288891681,
-0.0041610301,
0.0043035639,
-0.0184706412,
-0.0122614829,
0.050361257,
0.0184026118,
0.0129037024,
-0.0452399701,
0.0131707042,
-0.0603341311,
0.0540353768,
-0.0041231895,
0.0209728777,
0.0308820177,
0.0061404705,
-0.054979451,
0.0001919045,
-0.0082390495,
-0.0435971618,
0.1038641483,
-0.030411819,
-0.0138820298,
-0.012593423,
-0.0915734693,
-0.0368405432,
0.0014851287,
-0.0170180704,
0.0418070704,
0.0692172721,
-0.0298458207,
-0.1058447808,
0.0038440467,
0.0030893134,
0.0291444231,
-0.0176167544,
-0.0282199476,
-0.0171095673,
0.0292259566,
0.0359910242,
0.0477182567,
0.0482685119,
0.0009773085,
-0.0036319769,
0.0555716418,
0.0081346612,
-0.0016419525,
-0.0019569644,
0.0055183792,
0.0472875647,
-0.0717067569,
0.0162159167,
-0.0329581052,
0.0419723429,
-0.0600947253,
-0.0116674546,
0.0915199369,
0.0210574903,
-0.050207302,
0.0190554895,
0.0116836978,
-0.0136420066,
0.0477019399,
0.0390349329,
-0.0928384662,
-0.0220865104,
0.0228563622,
0.0100478223,
-0.0445067436,
-0.0311048497,
-0.0187341981,
-0.1082402989,
0.0269799884,
-0.0139941983,
-0.0033241923,
-0.0194758717,
-0.0349453017,
0.001256626,
-0.0898466408,
0.0070817615,
-0.0254022889,
-0.0126035186,
-0.0145216007,
-0.0021566898,
-0.0261967797,
-0.0421533734,
0.0115796356,
-0.0569438115,
0.0434642322,
0.0220553894,
0.0156132989,
-0.0187150035,
-0.0100052739,
0.0186767913,
-0.0102716079,
0.0074291276,
-0.0171053205,
0.0551623553,
-0.0132951913,
-0.0263693705,
-0.0310677867,
0.026378762,
-0.0280872006,
-0.0174696017,
-0.027023185,
0.0591783151,
0.0190193802,
-0.0139946761,
-0.0275942013,
-0.0043321359,
-0.0000901637,
0.0930069163,
-0.0113112964,
-0.0345373154,
-0.0418618545,
-0.053462103,
-0.0136949988,
-0.0394005105,
-0.0858130604,
0.0259447806,
0.018100867,
-0.0425942317,
-0.0181083698,
-0.024774557,
0.0421087332,
0.0191305466,
0.0120683573,
-0.0817645565,
0.074443087,
0.0231305379,
-0.0724237934,
0.029616015,
-0.009127791,
0.0161979888,
-0.0135784158,
-0.034972474,
0.0273959115,
-0.0163950287,
-0.0271247383,
0.0226745047,
-0.091724582,
-0.0348384641,
0.0622690693,
0.0685912594,
0.0281558298,
0.0398037918,
-0.0006114951,
-0.0706326887,
0.0120283999,
0.0680384636,
-0.0729520395,
0.0011049511,
0.0328420252,
-0.0242887028,
-0.0011754847,
0.040450003,
-0.0208317097,
0.0542262271,
0.0267515853,
0.0291588847,
-0.0173047297,
-0.008062779,
0.0170564521,
-0.0135224815,
0.0266794898,
0.0026264871,
0.0072001065,
-0.0385915004,
0.0033859205,
-0.0093982369,
-0.0524906479,
-0.0344154686,
-0.0141084874,
0.0089311702,
0.0093368553,
-0.0225750376,
0.0184377208,
0.0116807874,
-0.0054475884,
-0.0755974725,
0.0513117611,
0.0260167941,
-0.0356745124,
-0.004356531,
0.0035582762,
0.0089343851,
0.0030397973,
0.0111405309,
0.0326789133,
-0.0070470157,
0.0212736912,
0.020036323,
0.0249709338,
-0.0634960756,
0.0032531405,
-0.0502985343,
-0.0238515828,
-0.0128214257,
-0.0272121336,
0.0106935166,
-0.0189985484,
0.0314668193,
0.0142721208,
-0.038764555,
0.0204750858,
-0.00702945,
0.0138733266,
0.041435238,
0.0500471331,
0.0222676639,
0.0159896463,
-0.0549980551,
0.0351601318,
-0.0407005921,
0.0627270564,
-0.0250755586,
-0.0504387282,
-0.042446997,
-0.0464632474,
-0.0256321263,
-0.0364464521,
-0.0003870439,
-0.0136851082,
-0.0917555317,
-0.0220012404,
0.0203398317,
-0.0221390519,
0.0414197817,
-0.0082472246,
0.021644868,
0.0337959826,
0.00877304,
-0.0592389517,
-0.0285391193,
-0.0218798667,
0.0116872694,
-0.0191148464,
0.0011079342,
-6.877615409e-33,
-0.0205197092,
-0.0381540805,
0.0142350523,
0.0150206229,
0.0041637644,
0.0183039587,
0.0098362267,
-0.0099654598,
-0.0240210686,
0.0117290262,
-0.0244830791,
0.025440732,
0.0127995089,
0.0171044152,
0.0163727645,
0.017667193,
0.0864028633,
0.0095514217,
-0.0447379164,
-0.0100697046,
-0.0039434098,
0.0314308964,
0.0541833565,
-0.0481534638,
0.0163413826,
0.037586417,
-0.0082276454,
0.0216624103,
-0.0195374768,
0.0697971508,
-0.0060070157,
0.0686468109,
0.05370887,
-0.0982276723,
0.0019375784,
0.0468781553,
-0.1036812812,
-0.0126611684,
-0.0084195836,
0.0568954349,
0.0126837632,
-0.0186881889,
0.0609560981,
0.0276848171,
-0.0216239598,
-0.0850515738,
0.0493532456,
-0.0021386785,
0.0356068686,
-0.0177527592,
-0.0568511263,
0.0145815331,
-0.0188674591,
-0.0174583457,
0.0097961845,
0.0170003418,
-0.0094664469,
0.0410673916,
-0.088221617,
0.0073002661,
0.0029996333,
0.0226714537,
0.0340831466,
0.0031369755,
-0.0250918511,
0.0191443898,
0.0290872306,
0.018349411,
-0.0270317197,
-0.0489386842,
0.0098085189,
0.0247200038,
0.0490360856,
0.0151015474,
0.047261022,
-0.0030660792,
-0.0327223875,
-0.0049647996,
0.0075444328,
0.0507995225,
0.039035216,
0.0059462884,
-0.017086776,
-0.0167279318,
-0.0135292867,
-0.0453495868,
-0.0396942422,
0.0162559301,
-0.0118707521,
0.0330228582,
-0.0471833684,
0.076095283,
0.0023782502,
-0.0588104837,
0.0065162149,
0.0287054498,
0.0086539835,
0.0053449948,
-0.0007817357,
-0.0265776571,
-0.0346796885,
-0.0039474629,
0.0302220341,
0.0372832455,
0.0331001841,
0.0049650003,
0.0303281881,
0.0266531538,
-0.0936508477,
-0.0074745989,
-0.0357917883,
0.0525499769,
0.0004357564,
0.05555062,
0.0115588689,
0.0524144694,
-0.0175883584,
0.0079897651,
0.0387974121,
-0.0113629466,
-0.0338918567,
0.069530569,
0.0379052833,
0.0068752449,
-0.0028493002,
-0.0291484203,
-0.0097275143,
0.0036877457,
0.0230153631,
-0.0699642971,
-0.0310924966,
-0.0269913282,
2.75e-7,
0.0322062224,
0.0656598434,
0.0282047819,
0.033876922,
0.0143979983,
0.0178557131,
0.0359091833,
0.0238198284,
0.0140725793,
0.0146289282,
-0.0324184708,
0.0321590602,
0.0070296209,
0.0459685288,
-0.0565910861,
-0.0132307345,
-0.0584526099,
0.014206755,
-0.0142966155,
0.002769351,
0.0336148366,
0.1044318601,
0.0447107069,
-0.0042174063,
-0.0312219765,
0.0351038538,
0.0264026057,
0.0086667435,
0.0282279048,
0.035540998,
0.0039938046,
-0.0019576531,
0.015666632,
0.04313742,
0.0036520031,
0.0206190497,
-0.0080466997,
0.0581832267,
-0.007601948,
0.0085461847,
0.0086404933,
0.0013752928,
-0.0330636501,
-0.0190225616,
0.0479230471,
-0.0820567682,
-0.0438177846,
-0.0435509495,
-0.0237565711,
0.0167582724,
0.0133342138,
-0.0099761039,
0.0016426513,
0.0325404368,
0.0254445989,
0.0283150133,
-0.0130648557,
-0.0738145486,
-0.0261630937,
0.0074638841,
-0.0338402912,
-0.0390729457,
-0.0023908918,
-0.0424974114,
0.0021054919,
-0.0396588035,
-0.0338594466,
2.871715939e-34,
-0.008970689,
0.0439553037,
0.0092066564,
0.0256862883,
0.0279695373,
-0.0320328809,
-0.0269120187,
-0.0113857714,
0.0095566502,
-0.053629335,
-0.0197995882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16836v1 | LLM-FP4: 4-Bit Floating-Point Quantized Transformers | 2023-10-25T17:59:32 | 2023-10-25T17:59:32 | Shih-yang Liu, Zechun Liu, Xijie Huang, Pingcheng Dong, Kwang-Ting Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.AR, cs.CV | We propose LLM-FP4 for quantizing both weights and activations in large
language models (LLMs) down to 4-bit floating-point values, in a post-training
manner. Existing post-training quantization (PTQ) solutions are primarily
integer-based and struggle with bit widths below 8 bits. Compared to integer
quantization, floating-point (FP) quantization is more flexible and can better
handle long-tail or bell-shaped distributions, and it has emerged as a default
choice in many hardware platforms. One characteristic of FP quantization is
that its performance largely depends on the choice of exponent bits and
clipping range. In this regard, we construct a strong FP-PTQ baseline by
searching for the optimal quantization parameters. Furthermore, we observe a
high inter-channel variance and low intra-channel variance pattern in
activation distributions, which adds activation quantization difficulty. We
recognize this pattern to be consistent across a spectrum of transformer models
designed for diverse tasks, such as LLMs, BERT, and Vision Transformer models.
To tackle this, we propose per-channel activation quantization and show that
these additional scaling factors can be reparameterized as exponential biases
of weights, incurring a negligible cost. Our method, for the first time, can
quantize both weights and activations in the LLaMA-13B to only 4-bit and
achieves an average score of 63.1 on the common sense zero-shot reasoning
tasks, which is only 5.8 lower than the full-precision model, significantly
outperforming the previous state-of-the-art by 12.7 points. Code is available
at: https://github.com/nbasyl/LLM-FP4. | [
-0.0561548881,
0.0222028177,
0.0077588619,
0.0319480114,
-0.0021277198,
0.0096699642,
0.0285669677,
-0.0015268188,
-0.0584633537,
-0.0399333909,
-0.0341787785,
-0.0267091654,
0.0070835147,
-0.0067552296,
0.0318295993,
-0.0227972995,
0.0357891209,
-0.0264046695,
-0.0192729421,
-0.0269063786,
-0.0166061129,
-0.0165718812,
-0.0307312328,
0.0340382457,
-0.0124735096,
-0.0025762534,
-0.0043831952,
0.0117315101,
0.0311323628,
-0.016261572,
0.0017988168,
0.0256498251,
0.0434425659,
0.0129049271,
0.0000020615,
-0.0074138818,
-0.0002348819,
-0.0019649011,
-0.0352079272,
0.0167161059,
-0.0099367434,
-0.0269461442,
-0.0362132266,
0.0233808868,
-0.0138166482,
-0.0314804465,
0.0671170875,
0.0303369854,
0.0643108487,
0.0621008053,
-0.0135910194,
-0.065692015,
0.0600282848,
-0.0082920166,
0.0288018137,
-0.018850496,
0.0066142292,
0.0509052947,
-0.0152773932,
-0.0104689281,
-0.0318799503,
0.00958852,
0.0389261842,
0.0253478792,
-0.0279214401,
0.0304727722,
-0.0696614683,
0.0105138142,
-0.0255159438,
0.040263515,
-0.0642613918,
-0.040883664,
-0.0029580826,
0.0247866325,
-0.0380210243,
-0.0903843492,
-0.0455795228,
0.0252741016,
0.0300996378,
0.040563114,
-0.0401629433,
-0.0102075273,
0.0388923772,
0.0069606723,
-0.0597600043,
0.0641965494,
0.0210156757,
0.0025155749,
-0.0020043342,
-0.0242422689,
-0.0851857811,
-0.02067223,
0.0027599086,
0.0330085456,
0.0141979549,
-0.0152842896,
-0.057235457,
-0.0046295244,
-0.0260158423,
-0.0285241548,
0.0005197386,
0.0859259441,
-0.0191807281,
0.0260449946,
-0.0538216531,
0.0626855418,
-0.0435973965,
0.0944583789,
-0.0264289249,
0.0060872962,
-0.016949093,
-0.0055925436,
-0.0414075926,
0.0396161452,
-0.0097841555,
-0.0199232716,
-0.0672803596,
-0.001853848,
-0.0124779101,
-0.031148335,
0.0173774902,
-0.0004423348,
-0.036003802,
-0.022658905,
0.0114731351,
0.0501393341,
-0.0110644456,
0.0127999289,
0.0028709967,
-0.0758055598,
-0.0107002566,
0.0210111067,
-0.0090671005,
-0.0294009279,
0.0430827141,
0.0262978245,
-0.0114690587,
-0.0561941862,
-0.0225256551,
0.0345685333,
0.0010885976,
-0.0417393185,
0.0109347813,
-0.0752566531,
-0.0164432377,
-0.003897371,
-0.0007181617,
0.0058481456,
0.0309802778,
0.0176884998,
0.0401415192,
0.0762282461,
-0.0003435505,
-0.0141724776,
0.0214832798,
-0.0002216033,
0.0021105204,
0.0871038884,
0.0555419959,
0.006447609,
-0.0083976332,
0.0097177448,
0.0083492417,
0.0528586842,
0.0127162319,
-0.0238877721,
-0.0313603058,
-0.0460598543,
-0.0545060672,
0.0344826505,
0.0810313597,
0.0738674626,
-0.081217438,
-0.0376748256,
0.0227435958,
0.0315041468,
0.0180315878,
-0.0007043078,
0.0116599007,
-0.0289613772,
0.0055863275,
-0.020066509,
-0.0568559617,
0.0487516485,
0.0124944346,
-0.0069696312,
0.0060593276,
0.0495984852,
-0.039794527,
-0.0309030972,
-0.0207296815,
-0.001320934,
-0.0011028541,
0.0152514763,
0.0261151325,
0.0131366942,
-0.0132859927,
0.1614555418,
-0.0160515625,
-0.0483041555,
-0.0117465146,
-0.0939056277,
-0.0160574187,
0.0038291747,
0.0372994319,
-0.0076535465,
-0.0130727235,
0.0019084635,
-0.017206626,
0.008168526,
-0.0114620049,
0.0222446658,
0.017936511,
-0.0700056851,
-0.0284610633,
-0.0249956585,
-0.0008154752,
-0.0169320125,
0.0317523144,
0.0038835083,
-0.017074775,
-0.0666003749,
0.0258242879,
0.019441504,
0.0547767952,
-0.062313389,
0.0304529928,
0.0017705671,
0.0149104381,
0.0048648254,
-0.0055522453,
0.0043635336,
0.0374867395,
-0.0471558459,
0.0126713524,
-0.0145518156,
-0.0085372897,
0.0029680082,
0.0621530451,
-0.0226881187,
0.0282497369,
0.0603303164,
-0.0477802418,
-0.0342959538,
0.0082118511,
-0.0298084896,
0.0355653837,
-0.0268966891,
0.0360827819,
0.0089587914,
0.0307996031,
-0.0312821157,
0.022598194,
-0.0255666561,
-0.0060522961,
-0.0023065009,
0.0100727445,
0.0166317541,
-0.0370806232,
-0.0359148607,
-0.0042435089,
-0.0115794083,
0.0163997393,
-0.0155801997,
-0.0212888923,
0.0054967902,
-0.0126932515,
-0.1118277535,
-0.0024559516,
-0.0556588732,
0.0308352187,
0.026423784,
0.0254439432,
0.023681337,
0.0001581841,
-0.0445879102,
-0.0350778811,
-0.0282308236,
0.0151766967,
-0.0006038811,
-0.0256144293,
-0.0242771171,
-0.0053951298,
-0.0488683395,
0.0055388967,
0.0404115915,
-0.041062057,
-0.0172371082,
-0.0684850663,
-0.0167283826,
-0.0118615441,
0.0292979684,
-0.0155935958,
-0.0283371639,
0.0235715192,
-0.0086374283,
0.013738269,
0.074817732,
0.0054480163,
-0.0022817818,
0.0638134032,
0.0244376045,
-0.0435841046,
0.0511264838,
-0.0065064756,
-0.0437079072,
-0.017678285,
-0.0001790526,
-0.0269468315,
0.0625417233,
-0.0515888669,
0.009987154,
-0.0429816842,
-0.0054264916,
0.0122702755,
-0.0153076733,
-0.0073771295,
0.0126329735,
-0.0273234397,
0.0478852056,
-0.0090962378,
-0.0388530828,
0.0171807501,
-0.0270019416,
-0.0007491557,
-0.0207509156,
0.0282244887,
-0.0109877763,
0.0575031303,
0.0097523341,
0.0185551532,
-0.0138080735,
-0.0145860137,
-0.0473249704,
-0.0242000539,
-0.0032432657,
-0.0385303982,
0.0748971254,
-0.0116518484,
0.0422240533,
-0.050864514,
-0.0385129862,
-0.0059485538,
0.0510620363,
-0.0327860117,
0.0472187251,
0.0022646668,
-0.0369763263,
-0.0098391492,
0.0530691631,
0.0282593928,
0.0358955637,
-0.0168668739,
-0.0133690648,
-0.0212167203,
0.0488628894,
0.0111190537,
0.0247363504,
0.0493278876,
-0.0100866575,
-0.0626162216,
0.0236408487,
0.0384266935,
0.0562923513,
-0.0853202492,
0.0052521452,
0.0384464338,
0.001964432,
-0.0139541151,
0.0033786872,
0.0842348263,
-0.0339931287,
0.006648629,
0.0492018163,
0.0067198882,
-0.0387762226,
0.0133322114,
0.0013536265,
0.011848296,
0.018065393,
0.0201948863,
-0.1238644645,
-0.0392172113,
0.0313671529,
-0.0087751308,
0.0247973222,
-0.0000845184,
0.0024907058,
-0.0758610144,
0.0064923065,
0.0167055968,
0.0375958644,
-0.0653948933,
-0.0019685349,
-0.0153664872,
-0.0536380187,
0.0583369285,
0.0260513127,
-0.003333746,
-0.0102363052,
0.0153822238,
0.012049865,
-0.0381430425,
0.0606323071,
-0.0115281753,
0.0326117501,
0.0545338318,
0.0011761616,
-0.0075890762,
-0.0654709637,
0.0050064763,
-0.0072588399,
-0.0061460999,
0.0311416574,
0.0155540565,
0.016361434,
-0.0216032807,
0.0102445111,
-0.0004366444,
0.0142513709,
-0.0164022967,
-0.0579617172,
0.0256710798,
-0.0196451135,
-0.0030720476,
0.0128845973,
-0.0210542269,
-0.0419889055,
0.030920811,
0.0060730949,
0.0167248603,
-0.0729120374,
-0.0204292797,
0.0261488352,
-0.0383694582,
-0.040675059,
-0.0036663555,
0.0057128542,
-0.0569255091,
-0.0414713733,
0.0372868925,
0.0151792252,
0.035515558,
-0.0122009991,
-0.0948861167,
0.0166759025,
0.0380081758,
-0.0730188936,
0.0137066655,
-0.0332995616,
0.0577164926,
-0.0682775825,
0.0066562644,
0.0236826036,
-0.0149836447,
-0.0040729293,
0.004598517,
-0.1239546761,
-0.0433526859,
0.0133491997,
0.0411983803,
0.0223078858,
0.0320596881,
0.007489149,
-0.0543409027,
0.0769009367,
0.0619267002,
-0.0334171951,
0.0604429618,
0.0466918685,
-0.0058430126,
-0.0064140223,
0.0334911682,
-0.0468686298,
0.0556932464,
-0.0074455715,
0.065272063,
-0.0766117051,
-0.012738429,
-0.0070663514,
-0.0097962832,
0.0888325647,
-0.0034174398,
0.0189839508,
0.031230839,
0.0417346433,
0.0108838668,
0.0451047421,
-0.0399956405,
0.0051953718,
0.011685241,
-0.0003067176,
0.0140360678,
-0.0016745417,
0.033982221,
-0.0273060016,
0.0576683618,
0.0192446243,
-0.0399100371,
0.0097929491,
0.0108213192,
-0.0226391889,
-0.0348002277,
0.0098400451,
0.0085843811,
0.04219063,
-0.0209245514,
0.039202705,
-0.0034206528,
0.0187892485,
-0.0408844426,
0.0327945836,
-0.0250500441,
-0.0515420586,
-0.0197510831,
-0.0113358637,
0.0524884127,
0.0622240566,
0.0208967589,
-0.0097610345,
-0.0198158417,
0.0045701084,
0.0067227362,
0.0112923644,
0.0182507336,
0.063090764,
0.0394996889,
0.012938167,
-0.0294291023,
0.0298087019,
-0.0557135753,
0.0226230808,
-0.0008685818,
0.027163852,
-0.0099648712,
-0.0651790127,
-0.0623253994,
-0.0099003166,
0.0107558444,
-0.0216243155,
-0.0173014197,
-0.0335565023,
0.0337743759,
-0.0026683647,
-0.0041353959,
-0.0450654067,
0.0268341191,
0.0336124711,
-0.0091672251,
-0.0579900146,
-0.0022264887,
-0.0455134884,
0.016968539,
0.0186621808,
-0.0149601456,
-6.108558148e-33,
-0.0151185142,
0.0365914144,
0.0460301228,
0.023410935,
-0.0178408567,
0.0290089585,
-0.0066001937,
0.0112784682,
-0.0426985063,
-0.0256024394,
-0.0152076716,
0.0063704015,
0.0291264467,
0.0126203364,
-0.0318378173,
-0.0197378527,
0.0724820569,
-0.0144048836,
-0.030478565,
0.0141183101,
0.0103336181,
0.0006566998,
0.0616380796,
0.0313704573,
-0.0527557246,
0.0491015948,
-0.0276651308,
0.0061090491,
0.0093763415,
0.0369957574,
-0.0163123682,
0.0294430126,
0.0049066879,
-0.0307856761,
0.0034180186,
-0.0234867763,
-0.0694603473,
0.0030969535,
-0.0066285077,
0.0593009926,
0.0076109394,
-0.0278687291,
0.0734105185,
0.0117495358,
-0.0565638989,
-0.0509188473,
-0.0152660487,
-0.0130319819,
-0.0285507161,
-0.0775655359,
0.0046170657,
0.0364912525,
0.0397714339,
-0.004675651,
0.059346959,
0.0169709176,
-0.0413292684,
-0.0028943461,
-0.08422447,
-0.0021677839,
0.0254136547,
0.0669265166,
0.0426237956,
0.0536266081,
0.039910309,
0.0336477794,
0.041840557,
-0.0499520563,
-0.0343726985,
0.0215976816,
0.0635652542,
0.0319830142,
0.0271534882,
0.0343961008,
0.1265403479,
0.0049603609,
-0.0494773202,
-0.0047360319,
0.0180144459,
0.0643348917,
0.0287173912,
0.0490643904,
-0.0156358108,
-0.0125240488,
-0.0092149321,
0.0232887454,
-0.0504147708,
-0.0410367996,
-0.0063685034,
0.0302900989,
-0.0143397776,
0.0317290314,
0.0413800851,
-0.0268972386,
-0.0060175681,
0.003148529,
0.0207304936,
0.0560485646,
-0.0078444304,
0.0023041486,
-0.0110008046,
-0.013326508,
0.027522454,
0.0074882996,
0.0331207551,
0.0071326103,
0.0242975615,
0.0781443119,
-0.0514796786,
-0.0452327169,
-0.0341148861,
0.0018236934,
0.0045932336,
0.05919661,
0.0267527327,
0.0244164523,
0.0068699578,
-0.0037462884,
-0.0684150904,
0.0079984283,
-0.0122645386,
0.0351784565,
0.0243538618,
0.0652655736,
-0.0555703826,
0.0069733411,
-0.0597461499,
0.0458059534,
0.0112735881,
-0.0760453492,
-0.0496561602,
0.0329411589,
2.833e-7,
0.038453266,
0.0010243412,
0.02301386,
0.0010644962,
-0.0106110983,
0.0031256431,
0.0241562445,
0.0184159745,
0.0091534071,
-0.0394664332,
-0.0095621515,
0.0406757072,
0.0055728559,
0.0142802326,
-0.0563235655,
0.0069001815,
-0.0010950102,
0.0217296239,
-0.0024876283,
-0.041285228,
0.0382504761,
0.1022643521,
-0.0084913522,
-0.001266335,
0.0649365112,
0.0148853194,
0.0490471125,
0.0020891821,
0.0488220155,
0.0154593857,
0.0147808464,
0.0185791496,
-0.0045510186,
0.0135875922,
0.0151776234,
-0.0131683275,
-0.0289485026,
0.0673269257,
-0.0203668308,
-0.0653999373,
-0.0257751178,
-0.0039685681,
-0.0356660113,
-0.0410699435,
0.0657218993,
-0.08101096,
-0.0290381666,
-0.0562734269,
-0.0455778278,
-0.0039845952,
0.0000291968,
-0.0051215985,
-0.0002163939,
0.01553238,
0.0151673444,
-0.0134453662,
-0.0178846847,
-0.0995852277,
-0.0293834545,
0.0067516007,
-0.0282583684,
-0.0339203179,
-0.0541616753,
-0.0464918762,
0.015077428,
-0.0222757813,
-0.0033558684,
2.56361313e-34,
0.0229294244,
-0.0240091551,
0.0287098885,
0.0131665543,
-0.0276328195,
-0.0216144174,
0.0017422793,
0.0005966232,
-0.0185580887,
-0.0480710007,
-0.0114800567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16834v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16834v3 | Discrete Diffusion Modeling by Estimating the Ratios of the Data Distribution | 2023-10-25T17:59:12 | 2024-06-06T21:06:44 | Aaron Lou, Chenlin Meng, Stefano Ermon | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite their groundbreaking performance for many generative modeling tasks,
diffusion models have fallen short on discrete data domains such as natural
language. Crucially, standard diffusion models rely on the well-established
theory of score matching, but efforts to generalize this to discrete structures
have not yielded the same empirical gains. In this work, we bridge this gap by
proposing score entropy, a novel loss that naturally extends score matching to
discrete spaces, integrates seamlessly to build discrete diffusion models, and
significantly boosts performance. Experimentally, we test our Score Entropy
Discrete Diffusion models (SEDD) on standard language modeling tasks. For
comparable model sizes, SEDD beats existing language diffusion paradigms
(reducing perplexity by $25$-$75$\%) and is competitive with autoregressive
models, in particular outperforming GPT-2. Furthermore, compared to
autoregressive mdoels, SEDD generates faithful text without requiring
distribution annealing techniques like temperature scaling (around
$6$-$8\times$ better generative perplexity than un-annealed GPT-2), can trade
compute and quality (similar quality with $32\times$ fewer network
evaluations), and enables controllable infilling (matching nucleus sampling
quality while enabling other strategies besides left to right prompting). | [
-0.0145632755,
0.0827679262,
0.0118738972,
0.0222756732,
-0.0299181752,
0.0052981074,
0.0053242445,
0.0103076883,
-0.0287876856,
0.025930861,
-0.0404314697,
-0.0818365663,
0.0132061681,
0.0157080665,
0.0581548996,
-0.0108769462,
0.0132079907,
-0.0287479535,
-0.0431872793,
-0.036306303,
0.0154009303,
0.0076005338,
0.0226534009,
0.0091466391,
0.0241489317,
-0.0173443854,
-0.0090048676,
0.0335075483,
0.0340677723,
-0.017093949,
-0.0058516851,
0.0845904127,
0.0330929607,
0.0050943536,
0.0000019251,
0.003693861,
0.0018108238,
0.0233497731,
-0.0019175361,
0.0212819129,
0.0578108914,
-0.0118427584,
-0.0204843562,
-0.0007869161,
-0.0117009124,
-0.016069511,
0.0960443169,
0.0445611626,
0.0418146141,
0.0726030767,
-0.0208053347,
-0.0746926144,
0.0622368753,
-0.0803310052,
0.0331407078,
-0.0259278193,
0.0211969595,
0.0393325128,
0.0065872115,
-0.0052316999,
-0.0493116789,
0.0410077944,
0.0194367804,
-0.0016291901,
0.0415244401,
0.0656079799,
0.0544086657,
-0.0018565491,
0.0109259235,
0.0944573879,
-0.0300767832,
-0.0151420915,
0.0298659801,
-0.0209201071,
-0.0279461481,
-0.0025508571,
-0.0356390402,
-0.0098029459,
0.0084313499,
0.0487768389,
-0.0167703815,
-0.0141585087,
0.0673335046,
0.0007020137,
-0.0204624962,
0.0356183648,
0.0457441173,
-0.0161149483,
-0.0210592896,
-0.0123201478,
-0.0566989593,
-0.0406517722,
-0.0110208513,
-0.0280944258,
0.0040178266,
0.0018695261,
-0.0448743813,
-0.0299791973,
0.0025972927,
0.0243856367,
0.0544616058,
0.0033447826,
0.0483773425,
0.0251256078,
-0.0041032401,
0.0129609574,
-0.0318140015,
0.0151666952,
-0.0635335445,
-0.00711824,
-0.0235881042,
0.0125941662,
-0.0242584199,
0.0164068714,
-0.0003748751,
-0.0161459651,
-0.0316576175,
0.0264165401,
-0.0046131848,
-0.0474255197,
0.0723217577,
0.0087344376,
-0.0528865308,
-0.0044856868,
0.0245284494,
0.0205308441,
-0.0377644897,
0.0022330023,
0.0527412742,
0.0016273163,
-0.0446941555,
0.0133733172,
0.0202757586,
-0.0361271426,
-0.0061194999,
0.0410376377,
-0.0204352923,
0.0000288835,
0.0174203087,
0.0116487918,
-0.0256548189,
-0.0634750649,
0.0043912814,
-0.1004230231,
0.0261066202,
-0.0007633708,
-0.0104771564,
-0.0450530015,
0.0042410023,
0.0194065198,
-0.0320241526,
0.04363323,
0.0317302197,
0.0181567892,
0.0054259938,
-0.0089197243,
0.0691610947,
0.0510674566,
0.0349702537,
-0.0113753416,
-0.0155494027,
0.0030643214,
-0.0176762547,
0.0470388122,
0.0763948634,
0.044283431,
-0.0218866505,
-0.0113369757,
0.0185605232,
0.0438420735,
0.1086400673,
0.0553814694,
-0.0782486573,
-0.0307104662,
0.0856985003,
0.0376177579,
0.0152638275,
0.0027098306,
0.0258847494,
-0.0039731348,
-0.0599931367,
0.0199815147,
-0.0185820386,
0.0256126411,
0.0371568091,
0.0094975457,
0.095767498,
0.0057679745,
-0.0616066009,
-0.0249459241,
0.0148624452,
0.0061511495,
0.0321436785,
-0.0140247717,
0.0318167694,
0.0154810706,
-0.0383840986,
0.039402578,
0.0155150006,
-0.0434146076,
-0.0010110937,
-0.0448859334,
0.0097600203,
0.0626883805,
0.0711945817,
0.0266758967,
0.0226207972,
-0.0085660825,
-0.0271315947,
0.0283691548,
0.0246760901,
0.0006349378,
0.0209843647,
-0.0350391455,
-0.0096448166,
0.0174990706,
0.0163867921,
0.0315836668,
-0.0107869525,
0.0068953345,
0.0119078113,
-0.0948126093,
-0.0094897337,
0.0075191641,
-0.0314286053,
-0.022835888,
0.0433559604,
-0.0278554652,
0.0270963553,
-0.0225392301,
-0.0475806519,
0.025746813,
-0.0162145775,
-0.0234680176,
-0.0365402699,
-0.0359616615,
-0.0725729764,
-0.0713967755,
0.0207477566,
-0.0302800983,
-0.0039649862,
0.0422353595,
-0.0559962727,
-0.0172194056,
0.0485369079,
-0.0445011221,
-0.0184317306,
-0.0770029575,
-0.0114318458,
0.0261232723,
0.0475770421,
-0.0469522513,
0.0606793687,
-0.0292026866,
0.027233975,
-0.034497045,
-0.0040002908,
0.0045385691,
-0.0111386785,
-0.012533417,
-0.0145068644,
0.006854244,
0.0356382094,
0.0051215445,
-0.0099204043,
-0.009356237,
-0.0102257328,
-0.0834615231,
0.0351970717,
-0.041762244,
0.0056238608,
0.0516409054,
0.0485543571,
0.0185504463,
0.0304478779,
-0.0597723499,
-0.0254047345,
0.0134163862,
0.0153331636,
0.0314842425,
-0.013079511,
-0.0243725888,
-0.0322782621,
-0.057978984,
-0.0036629457,
0.0362656191,
-0.0481971838,
-0.0031469187,
-0.0402096771,
0.0729080886,
-0.0315094739,
0.0176843461,
-0.0189844705,
-0.0083918683,
-0.0080294916,
-0.0214877669,
0.0678776428,
0.0455703773,
0.0207837056,
-0.0257927086,
0.0071488032,
-0.0196438748,
-0.0275832936,
-0.0175041594,
-0.0505807623,
0.0393858105,
-0.0395460501,
-0.0478783958,
-0.0107809482,
0.0593733266,
0.0234006178,
-0.0303212851,
-0.0370102227,
-0.0075988714,
-0.0104053924,
-0.00837956,
-0.0205324665,
0.0329310074,
-0.0046762433,
0.0045433776,
-0.0567180067,
-0.033773642,
0.0806165636,
-0.036113143,
0.0063318899,
-0.0681460127,
-0.0082294429,
-0.0054746787,
0.0236586258,
0.0268253833,
0.02595325,
0.0050974498,
-0.001561511,
-0.0611721165,
-0.0349095426,
0.0523195192,
-0.0213011242,
0.0422680154,
-0.0067711864,
0.043660976,
-0.0118489591,
-0.0288397502,
-0.0018278791,
-0.0727177039,
0.0576974601,
0.0291200541,
0.0157846734,
-0.0176724698,
0.0000140526,
0.0257636141,
0.0017821337,
0.0500289127,
-0.0116860652,
-0.0090470323,
-0.0142422896,
0.0713013262,
0.0868203938,
0.0014641354,
0.0166444443,
-0.0358859822,
0.0138289118,
0.0417553484,
0.0341997407,
0.0368257798,
-0.0155478558,
0.007778869,
-0.0062952084,
0.0025856907,
-0.0203238074,
0.0200929493,
0.0877093896,
-0.0129233077,
-0.0287001356,
0.0830263048,
-0.012506688,
-0.0328755267,
0.0024951762,
0.0109703606,
0.0979636014,
-0.0171325505,
-0.0005181341,
-0.0615213253,
-0.0077890856,
-0.0015183799,
0.0211354382,
0.0144382315,
-0.0302397031,
0.0090258541,
-0.108449474,
0.0578043684,
0.0375984125,
-0.0097537301,
-0.026041504,
-0.0504447445,
0.0019990229,
-0.0083255749,
0.0111209853,
-0.0259798989,
0.0209344085,
0.003120081,
0.0265973601,
0.0412456281,
-0.0687969103,
0.0294972267,
-0.052198451,
0.0523855127,
0.1123955101,
0.024923116,
0.0194263402,
-0.0707504153,
0.0302851927,
-0.0149864769,
-0.0453993082,
0.0156702381,
0.0338614844,
0.0324442126,
-0.0023970236,
-0.019097697,
0.0198901091,
-0.0190485623,
0.0109154778,
-0.0364864916,
0.0672940686,
0.0097600436,
-0.0453269593,
-0.0221294463,
-0.0228609405,
0.0347649194,
0.0652226433,
0.0432120413,
-0.0278289504,
-0.0585354753,
-0.031309139,
0.0539948381,
-0.0091276951,
-0.0469484851,
0.0144845322,
0.0101536373,
-0.0969355777,
-0.0877243504,
-0.0166422091,
-0.0318564959,
0.0570372157,
-0.010908599,
0.0237687826,
-0.0057712062,
-0.0466677845,
-0.0464954413,
-0.0165605042,
-0.0618973374,
0.0310540125,
-0.0383509845,
-0.0185026228,
0.007054389,
-0.0092216022,
-0.035871949,
0.0113438768,
-0.1232864186,
-0.0613368414,
-0.0350155942,
0.0005781716,
0.0194266457,
0.0577378906,
-0.0329375379,
-0.035931509,
0.06558723,
0.0308710095,
0.0141617628,
0.0383130498,
0.0179431625,
-0.0530222096,
0.0099844374,
0.050405629,
-0.0257588252,
0.0555713587,
0.0237691272,
0.0723923445,
-0.0009389647,
0.0011143992,
0.0084310798,
-0.0013670314,
0.0085927127,
-0.0014566148,
0.0393687598,
-0.040219672,
0.0005977984,
-0.0103934193,
-0.0077686911,
-0.0547412932,
-0.0273621473,
0.0843865871,
0.0148465699,
-0.0272966735,
0.0139355706,
0.0300369449,
0.0322995596,
-0.0337081663,
-0.0316855423,
0.0014890026,
0.008254678,
0.0284939483,
0.0065570544,
0.0031583852,
0.0090327756,
0.0064838212,
0.0406688824,
-0.0084281499,
0.0029766539,
0.0140836006,
0.000080482,
-0.0231732018,
0.0434050076,
-0.0489383601,
-0.036974445,
-0.0611173362,
-0.0156483389,
0.0484750979,
0.032146208,
0.0592182614,
-0.0068314741,
0.008433965,
-0.0490170009,
-0.0172994211,
0.0037047267,
-0.0035922744,
0.0364184938,
0.0183947962,
0.0086553786,
-0.0029241547,
0.0750118718,
0.0114560537,
0.0379726142,
-0.0230301525,
0.00055915,
-0.012816675,
-0.0154564455,
-0.058011435,
-0.0203490146,
0.0096193561,
-0.0021728242,
-0.0115044275,
-0.093373552,
-0.0278872605,
0.0070693051,
-0.0010668755,
-0.0109594529,
0.0433805883,
0.0501380637,
-0.0186449494,
0.0104513504,
-0.0414708294,
0.0116231712,
-0.0031788794,
-0.0423756167,
-0.029422041,
-6.633645964e-33,
-0.0285520889,
0.0002646985,
-0.0021751719,
-0.0351865105,
-0.0451384708,
-0.0444503166,
-0.0737787485,
-0.0071750786,
-0.0212406833,
0.0196868312,
-0.0153170219,
0.0258770324,
0.001892379,
0.0366156027,
-0.0211420991,
-0.021272013,
0.0559344217,
-0.0244775452,
-0.0285374001,
0.0450645015,
-0.0158019084,
0.0072149271,
0.0207547471,
-0.0110287638,
-0.0047230367,
-0.0217222814,
-0.0132804541,
-0.0383170508,
0.0212658923,
0.003157316,
-0.0304388255,
0.0173136871,
0.0076257987,
-0.052185528,
-0.056691695,
0.0055267075,
-0.0790361986,
-0.0187814198,
0.0057326425,
-0.0369207859,
-0.0181438699,
-0.0322416537,
0.0511904471,
-0.0007393989,
-0.0039623235,
-0.0228498038,
0.0314666405,
0.0153999804,
-0.0251327194,
-0.0125817452,
-0.0264007635,
0.0403130241,
0.0113094663,
-0.0135006774,
-0.0208439454,
-0.0472032875,
-0.0047016097,
0.0265089534,
-0.0501913317,
0.0022153531,
0.010473799,
0.0768494233,
0.0304529704,
0.0180770792,
0.0502436608,
0.0340010487,
0.0350820534,
0.0079457825,
0.0109842503,
-0.0153758135,
0.0330338478,
0.0226990767,
0.0107037006,
0.0114782853,
0.0423996486,
0.0086381575,
-0.0854509994,
0.0243598986,
-0.0386421792,
-0.0142584741,
0.0166454762,
0.0345344245,
-0.0209702384,
-0.0221169423,
-0.0335380547,
-0.0460149124,
-0.0088386126,
-0.0330273174,
0.0192025155,
-0.0025755304,
-0.0195485614,
-0.0285744295,
0.0396197289,
-0.0266279876,
-0.0573840737,
0.0170928817,
-0.0139427008,
0.0284071825,
0.0301552005,
0.0405373648,
-0.0508002602,
-0.0137240076,
-0.0042862277,
0.0471143499,
-0.0202715732,
0.0091839274,
-0.0041682445,
0.0250225663,
-0.0564713813,
-0.0104861092,
-0.0501127131,
0.0135923484,
-0.0257913657,
0.0536457188,
0.0014538767,
-0.0037920531,
0.0056691174,
0.0193674769,
0.0170593522,
0.0021569482,
-0.0124787409,
0.0503479801,
0.0046967738,
0.0246540401,
-0.0168483928,
-0.0069702626,
-0.0446349755,
0.0183862932,
0.0642931908,
-0.0457523055,
-0.0333249532,
0.0317283645,
2.729e-7,
0.0441604257,
0.0004375781,
-0.0065067983,
0.0097044585,
0.0281119477,
0.0344948955,
-0.0092114843,
0.0346037932,
-0.0002633236,
-0.0336018316,
0.0171764214,
0.0268952623,
0.0161503498,
0.007730349,
-0.085878849,
0.0451861508,
-0.0587989576,
0.0563344248,
-0.0134046786,
-0.0380175449,
-0.0331415236,
0.1094457507,
0.0124956099,
-0.0088648936,
0.0401682816,
-0.0279730931,
0.0749149323,
0.012008748,
0.0103154667,
0.0464742705,
-0.0001321264,
-0.0442351475,
0.0008899922,
0.0087544154,
-0.0200489573,
0.0271213669,
0.0315279588,
0.0415111668,
-0.0161741972,
-0.0646480843,
-0.0044628386,
-0.0165213663,
0.0198828895,
-0.0519430377,
0.064596884,
-0.0033244127,
-0.0195569545,
-0.0106262527,
-0.041845426,
0.0061036856,
0.0437724404,
0.0019373108,
-0.0356049053,
0.0097557046,
0.0250416771,
-0.0110718478,
0.0049260445,
-0.0412921384,
-0.0191567298,
-0.0341821946,
-0.055597309,
-0.0785701796,
-0.0614678226,
0.002284989,
0.0434355065,
-0.0098114805,
-0.0163792819,
2.616561344e-34,
0.068984963,
-0.0148775121,
0.0105361817,
-0.0050124126,
0.0100526661,
-0.0122194402,
-0.01036782,
0.001538081,
0.0076416372,
-0.0887767747,
-0.0368445963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16822v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16822v1 | Prompt Me Up: Unleashing the Power of Alignments for Multimodal Entity and Relation Extraction | 2023-10-25T17:51:56 | 2023-10-25T17:51:56 | Xuming Hu, Junzhe Chen, Aiwei Liu, Shiao Meng, Lijie Wen, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | How can we better extract entities and relations from text? Using multimodal
extraction with images and text obtains more signals for entities and
relations, and aligns them through graphs or hierarchical fusion, aiding in
extraction. Despite attempts at various fusions, previous works have overlooked
many unlabeled image-caption pairs, such as NewsCLIPing. This paper proposes
innovative pre-training objectives for entity-object and relation-image
alignment, extracting objects from images and aligning them with entity and
relation prompts for soft pseudo-labels. These labels are used as
self-supervised signals for pre-training, enhancing the ability to extract
entities and relations. Experiments on three datasets show an average 3.41% F1
improvement over prior SOTA. Additionally, our method is orthogonal to previous
multimodal fusions, and using it on prior SOTA fusions further improves 5.47%
F1. | [
0.036683578,
0.0450602435,
0.0489224568,
0.0567658581,
-0.0000131414,
0.025937574,
-0.0023148202,
0.0018040732,
0.0295378547,
-0.0367591865,
-0.0496281423,
0.023022281,
-0.0324203745,
0.0086507853,
0.0140265636,
-0.0769629404,
0.0275091007,
0.0081589604,
-0.0027042357,
0.0253372081,
0.0404930562,
0.03192541,
-0.0596405044,
-0.0257440805,
-0.0995995924,
-0.0211768541,
0.000605274,
0.0297529977,
0.0380298272,
-0.0440387167,
-0.0166777484,
0.0356362388,
0.0160613898,
0.0000133654,
0.0000015907,
-0.0283745378,
-0.0074081789,
0.0219005477,
-0.0089573795,
-0.0253364146,
0.0063274307,
-0.0676889718,
0.002630359,
-0.0443855673,
-0.0163614545,
-0.04789019,
0.0581916384,
0.0747765303,
0.0509836264,
0.0557508469,
-0.0488302745,
-0.024523126,
0.0081582777,
-0.0227287132,
-0.027229825,
-0.0339225009,
0.0005564519,
-0.0182105545,
-0.027864743,
0.0117696496,
-0.0026718187,
0.0552844182,
-0.0113233803,
0.0060213902,
0.0184661299,
0.0708368793,
-0.0262225308,
-0.0440463349,
-0.0423474945,
0.1209608763,
0.0089470502,
0.0404719189,
-0.007283696,
-0.0005865654,
-0.0067147366,
0.026256375,
-0.0120103927,
-0.0054004658,
-0.0211854652,
0.0113886064,
-0.0422530919,
-0.0002903494,
0.0057933941,
-0.016285412,
0.0123625873,
0.0143639548,
0.0135742072,
0.0057783215,
0.0417339504,
0.0361351855,
-0.0139410933,
-0.034618035,
0.0041586822,
0.0397642851,
0.001834352,
-0.0046907966,
-0.068247281,
-0.0252231285,
-0.0157380942,
-0.0368396416,
-0.0147783021,
-0.0207148101,
-0.0705750734,
0.092228651,
-0.0297450442,
0.0029143121,
-0.0298748855,
0.0605682172,
-0.0002677076,
0.0116256643,
-0.0181951821,
0.0205226336,
-0.0249762703,
0.0385014638,
-0.0363706164,
-0.0376008227,
-0.0110138562,
-0.00796788,
0.0128862523,
0.0304042269,
-0.0237338226,
-0.0042275735,
-0.0174725093,
0.0067640361,
-0.0116171902,
0.0381247811,
-0.0415476896,
0.0030518917,
-0.0112712476,
-0.0084766811,
-0.004192913,
0.0044425884,
0.0597865321,
-0.0511196069,
0.0184529442,
0.0988877267,
-0.0590552539,
-0.0589627251,
-0.0188868251,
-0.0327484123,
-0.0367537029,
-0.0475937948,
0.0271509606,
-0.0108318822,
0.0762022361,
-0.0079951296,
-0.0023131466,
-0.0137461992,
0.0232062154,
-0.0211164486,
-0.0392445847,
0.0979997441,
-0.0568208694,
0.0194208436,
0.0258137938,
0.0008498685,
-0.0028184569,
0.0733846277,
0.0224302299,
0.0384860784,
0.0688373893,
0.0064238366,
-0.0088572484,
0.0764451325,
-0.0165959187,
-0.0188840721,
0.006701678,
0.0099656126,
0.0262180977,
-0.0020362996,
0.0459132902,
0.0222545844,
-0.0070079383,
0.0165219735,
0.0494408533,
0.0128035285,
-0.0000518208,
0.0006179587,
0.0130669605,
-0.0205287468,
0.0236658715,
0.0233744681,
-0.0843396783,
0.0474380329,
0.0046092328,
0.026083583,
-0.0000097131,
0.0482251085,
-0.0070796395,
0.0238853153,
0.0346829295,
-0.0031692598,
-0.0315093286,
-0.0115489271,
0.0716847479,
0.009421871,
-0.070208624,
0.0530009456,
0.0147800986,
-0.0240061954,
-0.0032799498,
0.0441992655,
0.0088994782,
-0.0013603099,
0.0274071507,
-0.042636171,
-0.0223616492,
0.0242754072,
0.0054504378,
0.0475871079,
0.0060466295,
-0.0104005486,
0.028299598,
-0.0220063366,
-0.0519739315,
-0.0006915652,
-0.0304253455,
-0.0018961193,
0.0219057687,
0.0257219151,
0.0203119442,
0.0131311966,
-0.0016072569,
0.0546121672,
0.0575921759,
-0.0058364104,
-0.044767186,
0.0805911198,
0.0022801498,
0.0381185189,
-0.037947461,
-0.0205746107,
0.0010684022,
-0.0240105819,
0.0307571702,
-0.0013428786,
-0.0443899147,
-0.0601299964,
0.0100945886,
-0.0206721909,
-0.0412021503,
-0.037495181,
-0.0402632095,
-0.0214203708,
-0.0367463231,
0.005013932,
0.009490788,
-0.0167064089,
0.0079271672,
0.0543515421,
0.0175503716,
-0.0177349634,
0.0662164837,
0.02976395,
-0.0140763242,
-0.0191576201,
-0.0316285975,
-0.001960072,
-0.0140652759,
-0.01659704,
0.0044156597,
-0.0113776084,
-0.0188021827,
0.0153102819,
0.021235887,
-0.0602622554,
-0.0088946251,
-0.0916987732,
-0.0032557922,
0.0002809327,
0.0096735908,
0.0040926593,
0.0046371859,
-0.0098816995,
-0.0560078584,
-0.0229451414,
0.0143856909,
-0.0307329688,
0.0184180252,
0.052042339,
0.0407773107,
0.0109061254,
-0.0310059302,
-0.0046575842,
-0.0367335081,
0.0384719633,
0.0219744723,
-0.0484491326,
-0.0144920526,
0.0007308018,
-0.0436033681,
0.03475767,
0.0133345043,
-0.0070562693,
0.0086285044,
0.0114895403,
0.0527614504,
0.043148417,
-0.014235381,
0.0356453732,
-0.0457578488,
-0.0309988856,
-0.0116625484,
0.0367523655,
-0.0148566449,
0.002078508,
0.0237438511,
0.0154209314,
-0.0059924829,
0.0292049274,
-0.0182844922,
0.0343984291,
-0.0258829147,
-0.010365623,
0.0301940031,
-0.0109792054,
-0.0473066047,
0.0369727761,
0.0182408784,
0.0032553929,
-0.0927761272,
-0.0149946157,
0.060843572,
-0.0475724377,
-0.0403338112,
0.0366185568,
-0.0210122913,
-0.0347519852,
0.092494078,
0.0119065,
0.0352035835,
0.0151951909,
-0.0318909697,
-0.0370487086,
-0.0125481244,
0.016248066,
-0.011959346,
0.0135375476,
-0.0040216297,
0.0480162241,
-0.0315532237,
-0.0266279839,
-0.0214522891,
-0.0599869899,
-0.0029013208,
-0.0363445058,
-0.0668358803,
0.0047800979,
0.0173197016,
0.0325152464,
0.0151497899,
0.0305767059,
0.0010969206,
-0.0083219111,
-0.0178069435,
0.09152814,
0.0626691803,
0.0094137732,
-0.0637417287,
-0.0198513884,
0.0053943857,
0.0219902098,
0.0181517359,
-0.0306748711,
-0.0170960464,
0.0230688192,
-0.0028474925,
-0.0007487665,
0.0025523463,
-0.0012422923,
0.0788602903,
-0.026201671,
0.0032734468,
0.0542780347,
-0.0003751029,
-0.0127403075,
-0.0191880185,
0.0906896219,
-0.0023752493,
0.0252234824,
0.0005218798,
-0.0703394338,
-0.0508850329,
-0.017156573,
-0.0177994706,
0.0500468463,
-0.0135419546,
-0.0179917384,
-0.0745669976,
-0.0060826228,
-0.0022457503,
-0.0657493025,
-0.029069677,
-0.0410103388,
0.0317550674,
-0.0194714516,
-0.0328772962,
-0.0175669566,
-0.0153573807,
-0.0098887468,
-0.0042821332,
0.0496422686,
-0.0279426184,
-0.0129149593,
-0.0639821216,
-0.0086971791,
0.0314512663,
0.0371499844,
-0.0085440259,
-0.0137552954,
0.0242301561,
-0.0052836258,
-0.0105733853,
0.0121870385,
0.079666391,
-0.0689075291,
-0.0556809865,
-0.0143520907,
0.0279499162,
0.003350544,
-0.0056677745,
-0.0174071584,
0.0329617299,
0.0124373455,
-0.004525085,
-0.0197516456,
0.0020784561,
0.0186046623,
0.0241964106,
-0.0054620425,
-0.0117805311,
0.0038336983,
0.0285048094,
0.0450630151,
-0.0225201771,
-0.0041645709,
0.0124065429,
-0.0997181684,
-0.0168665443,
-0.0383703895,
-0.0485108867,
0.0351100825,
0.072623238,
0.033488173,
-0.0142996022,
0.0047814935,
0.0413643345,
-0.0404454283,
0.0763280615,
-0.0267587025,
0.0033896551,
-0.0097324466,
0.0025406729,
0.0397045463,
0.0192336626,
-0.0131205665,
0.0145698227,
-0.0483249165,
-0.0333070457,
-0.0341899991,
0.0428407006,
0.0073698186,
0.0148825729,
0.0127684819,
-0.0032890707,
0.0153589472,
0.0961040109,
-0.0560397021,
-0.0295263473,
-0.0210117549,
-0.0231614243,
-0.0258634631,
-0.0056634592,
-0.0335590243,
0.0267568212,
-0.0027013205,
0.0366425365,
-0.0553206913,
-0.0724982172,
-0.0028395546,
0.016112987,
0.0778908432,
-0.0371121988,
0.002443088,
-0.0582627095,
-0.0078790775,
0.001535165,
-0.0147402314,
-0.0284762941,
0.0028228646,
-0.0184040964,
0.0231731143,
-0.0010071816,
0.0082872519,
0.0353185311,
0.0457009971,
-0.0143942526,
-0.0448972806,
0.0121213226,
-0.0078841001,
-0.0172998253,
0.003771275,
0.0056681628,
0.0503891297,
0.0423378237,
0.0197548065,
-0.0262263305,
0.070653908,
0.0354914404,
-0.0081778662,
-0.0052377312,
0.0230211169,
0.0123980381,
0.0578443594,
-0.0527040139,
0.041509524,
0.0643979833,
-0.0226055589,
0.0231318977,
0.000850227,
-0.0306724831,
0.0316749699,
0.0294262841,
-0.0236733947,
-0.0056114346,
0.0545271076,
-0.0039389697,
-0.0056156497,
-0.0019109953,
0.0370491557,
-0.0396618396,
0.0277841296,
0.0317879729,
-0.0060684108,
-0.0655504316,
-0.0188113358,
0.0093274396,
-0.0132127395,
-0.0106483623,
0.0149988234,
-0.0154893454,
-0.0294404533,
0.0215757824,
-0.0009746075,
-0.0582787991,
0.0668700933,
0.0271245595,
0.0248033218,
0.0260550324,
-0.0355899893,
-0.0053872429,
-0.0131817907,
-0.0102532301,
-0.0025897953,
0.0277866609,
-6.165624358e-33,
-0.0709128454,
-0.0578049868,
0.0284429323,
-0.0081759952,
-0.058951579,
0.0354523808,
-0.0098993964,
0.0105903968,
-0.0254819877,
0.0158811994,
0.0025953036,
-0.0490792282,
0.0300750416,
0.0255127531,
-0.0412681699,
-0.0011664635,
0.0131453266,
-0.0011456814,
-0.0024544469,
-0.0180861056,
0.0152084604,
0.0541951209,
0.0729626492,
-0.1093322784,
0.0207008272,
0.0315078571,
-0.030996507,
0.0151549522,
0.0718777105,
0.0204396304,
-0.0347427204,
-0.0010448323,
-0.0010731902,
-0.0119450809,
0.0153120058,
0.0484950356,
-0.1589299142,
-0.0115475161,
0.0210717209,
0.0427643172,
-0.0473879054,
-0.0115445936,
0.0129307928,
-0.0371888392,
0.0491648242,
-0.0253832545,
0.0537791438,
-0.0022038484,
0.029947618,
-0.0247542765,
-0.0517502874,
0.0069889878,
-0.0068220408,
-0.0000446253,
0.0532673784,
0.0002876417,
0.0639013723,
-0.0050286069,
-0.0527501442,
-0.0093321921,
-0.0155816013,
-0.0048069758,
0.0498840176,
0.0566150211,
-0.027458787,
0.0666219741,
-0.004287242,
-0.0480612591,
-0.0322782248,
-0.0057732752,
0.0251549426,
0.0854334384,
-0.0138132377,
0.059854731,
0.0208763666,
0.0362830348,
-0.0739817917,
0.0386145413,
-0.0223159902,
-0.0007739057,
-0.0462505221,
0.0164629873,
-0.0121284267,
0.0424562171,
0.0005315972,
-0.0113964034,
-0.0228496138,
-0.0410166457,
0.0026754208,
0.0374900699,
-0.0385097973,
0.105588071,
0.0447297394,
0.0153713822,
-0.0508721881,
-0.0396236666,
0.010914105,
0.0416490771,
-0.037936803,
-0.0355321802,
-0.0555156693,
-0.0655572712,
0.0518033691,
0.011741274,
0.0411862507,
0.0028267626,
0.0495832935,
-0.0056286431,
-0.061160244,
-0.0120485807,
-0.0238226671,
0.0073580658,
-0.0279546529,
-0.0248294342,
0.0466630086,
0.0025937918,
-0.0587961562,
0.0377254561,
0.0341913067,
0.0332344063,
-0.014435689,
-0.0030737214,
0.0149071813,
0.0355638117,
0.0210857,
0.0122236535,
-0.0101059983,
-0.0524084568,
-0.0126144439,
-0.0672389716,
-0.0201392937,
0.0081465207,
2.394e-7,
0.0367289148,
-0.0011206738,
0.0773013011,
0.0255273525,
-0.018318519,
0.0445006192,
0.0000523928,
0.0324842148,
-0.033874698,
-0.048199039,
0.0197017305,
0.0126120243,
0.0169699751,
0.0239455588,
-0.0396477617,
-0.0365858935,
-0.0456606373,
-0.0276830271,
-0.0868044049,
0.0100732567,
0.0768087804,
0.0580055714,
0.0130563248,
-0.0173236877,
-0.0348658301,
-0.0247305054,
0.0536326692,
-0.0060684024,
0.0021041799,
0.0087289298,
-0.0019843937,
0.0265054516,
-0.0531484298,
0.0730833858,
-0.0051074531,
-0.0123377908,
0.0778131932,
0.0074707377,
-0.0285769347,
-0.0326130278,
-0.0127009181,
0.0265435074,
-0.006867459,
-0.0016422444,
0.0751001015,
-0.0636585876,
-0.0335756019,
-0.0138949342,
-0.0698768198,
0.0195950083,
-0.0095229996,
-0.0149722127,
-0.0258485302,
0.0667863414,
0.0511584282,
-0.001731969,
-0.0739160478,
-0.0760511681,
-0.0078507466,
0.0592314526,
0.0256852061,
0.0063771061,
-0.0210688226,
-0.0236452743,
0.0090977345,
-0.0822297186,
-0.0383533798,
1.694386371e-34,
-0.0310607441,
0.015753841,
0.0194524787,
0.0256587062,
0.0252511464,
-0.0316028185,
-0.0491847359,
-0.0281155165,
-0.0287847091,
-0.023637196,
0.016014168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16810v1 | Can GPT models Follow Human Summarization Guidelines? Evaluating ChatGPT and GPT-4 for Dialogue Summarization | 2023-10-25T17:39:07 | 2023-10-25T17:39:07 | Yongxin Zhou, Fabien Ringeval, François Portet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study explores the capabilities of prompt-driven Large Language Models
(LLMs) like ChatGPT and GPT-4 in adhering to human guidelines for dialogue
summarization. Experiments employed DialogSum (English social conversations)
and DECODA (French call center interactions), testing various prompts:
including prompts from existing literature and those from human summarization
guidelines, as well as a two-step prompt approach. Our findings indicate that
GPT models often produce lengthy summaries and deviate from human summarization
guidelines. However, using human guidelines as an intermediate step shows
promise, outperforming direct word-length constraint prompts in some cases. The
results reveal that GPT models exhibit unique stylistic tendencies in their
summaries. While BERTScores did not dramatically decrease for GPT outputs
suggesting semantic similarity to human references and specialised pre-trained
models, ROUGE scores reveal grammatical and lexical disparities between
GPT-generated and human-written summaries. These findings shed light on the
capabilities and limitations of GPT models in following human instructions for
dialogue summarization. | [
0.076138787,
0.0188541766,
0.0088933455,
0.0007580853,
-0.0158897098,
-0.0052529634,
-0.0190245155,
-0.0258355867,
-0.0032390424,
-0.0256244615,
-0.0243378095,
-0.0545684956,
0.0196440015,
0.0052891215,
0.0219477806,
-0.0924010277,
0.0334557071,
-0.0147002824,
0.0106746014,
-0.0121052209,
0.0305727459,
0.0217616204,
0.0265359543,
0.0490814671,
0.00850162,
-0.0081615644,
-0.0313985236,
0.0234145187,
0.0234514419,
-0.0023306368,
0.02141257,
0.0589675754,
0.0100085167,
0.0315597691,
0.000001699,
-0.0641409606,
0.0175090842,
-0.0155443894,
0.005585413,
0.06970869,
0.0191147272,
-0.0046959599,
-0.0015458305,
0.0392836556,
-0.0024481409,
-0.0082316874,
0.0002885134,
0.0686657876,
0.093111068,
0.0671993345,
-0.0101396861,
-0.0264980067,
0.026769951,
-0.0375848822,
-0.0341505483,
-0.0365827233,
-0.0124958595,
0.013381985,
0.033372581,
0.0063288994,
0.0406938232,
0.0045497506,
0.0062264875,
-0.0274789743,
-0.0332407579,
0.0139381485,
-0.0522818565,
-0.014370569,
-0.0194655564,
0.0454291627,
0.049158819,
-0.0052315569,
0.0037738725,
0.0045058369,
0.0390660651,
0.0147521291,
-0.073863551,
0.0540532917,
-0.0278384686,
0.0030586759,
-0.0263887607,
0.0232318621,
-0.017329162,
0.0049572997,
-0.0059891711,
0.0231197495,
0.0141268969,
-0.0415098667,
-0.0089766318,
0.0019855034,
-0.0468979254,
-0.0528747365,
0.0068942588,
0.0129580135,
-0.0369445607,
-0.0087900059,
-0.0150166182,
0.0303300414,
0.0400757454,
-0.0104994727,
-0.0120375426,
0.0238266829,
-0.0069326758,
0.0164579824,
0.0283066388,
0.0565861613,
0.0170572586,
-0.0029090678,
-0.0643885285,
-0.0110189244,
-0.0552059002,
-0.0281872544,
-0.0747573152,
0.0185778886,
-0.0227438174,
-0.0261827856,
-0.0366313942,
0.0325945877,
0.0306651928,
-0.0090997396,
0.0239701588,
0.0080283526,
-0.001918153,
-0.0057221097,
-0.0203895066,
0.0106675168,
-0.0493387505,
-0.0299494304,
0.0241433978,
-0.0375325531,
-0.0082790181,
0.0250139907,
-0.020765895,
-0.0055666156,
-0.0278955493,
0.0225211531,
-0.0312989354,
-0.0199560318,
0.0238033906,
-0.0260735862,
-0.0417435542,
-0.0629918054,
-0.0287373085,
-0.0421445705,
-0.0030012475,
-0.0038379573,
-0.0231866576,
0.013282516,
-0.0142712984,
0.032840129,
-0.0457224138,
0.0238552876,
0.0071813539,
0.0442925654,
0.0626251325,
0.0003855717,
-0.0088722045,
0.0264770761,
0.0351338238,
0.0237799082,
0.0363854244,
-0.0125159025,
0.0139493356,
0.0510804951,
-0.0085746255,
0.0103999274,
0.0170248374,
0.000151301,
0.0169294197,
0.0114852171,
0.0447968207,
0.1155266017,
-0.0376039185,
0.0185078643,
0.0856797025,
0.078000024,
-0.0279630106,
0.0292802677,
0.0411722399,
0.0667480454,
0.0482194051,
0.0875127316,
-0.0532376133,
-0.0212854128,
-0.0375390537,
0.0676627159,
0.061668057,
0.02446579,
-0.0201871339,
-0.0091946926,
-0.004482083,
0.0114345178,
0.0044956491,
-0.0194178857,
-0.0083799483,
-0.0155412229,
-0.0659713224,
0.029315941,
-0.0068352628,
-0.0660798028,
-0.0276560318,
-0.0362807587,
0.022357028,
0.0716446713,
0.0518774427,
-0.0155001031,
-0.0359957479,
-0.0284801703,
0.0030425785,
0.0322874971,
0.0746741146,
-0.0158563592,
-0.0195129719,
-0.0262066163,
-0.0124747101,
-0.0005541046,
0.0008713029,
0.008481116,
0.024469886,
-0.0258592386,
0.0417020209,
0.0113280648,
-0.0403089561,
0.0084786154,
-0.0133983828,
-0.0106703863,
-0.0274247956,
-0.0407498889,
0.0084104249,
0.0472115204,
-0.0163999964,
0.0182588622,
-0.0026383922,
0.0030558982,
-0.0019398837,
0.0225696173,
-0.0976550505,
-0.0339250639,
0.0207673479,
-0.0177707486,
-0.0084993169,
0.0068928339,
-0.0108537357,
-0.0680936873,
-0.0194562692,
-0.0723365396,
0.0144013958,
-0.0647657663,
0.0150107807,
0.026108304,
-0.0140888058,
-0.022077987,
0.0419341251,
0.0254608802,
-0.0214559566,
0.0742408261,
0.0077012093,
0.0115227755,
-0.0575907379,
-0.002951286,
0.0366308764,
0.0281284545,
0.0164435115,
0.0697195157,
0.0282841381,
-0.0287212748,
-0.0367680751,
-0.1639484465,
0.0124676879,
-0.0209699329,
0.0144773051,
0.0312169157,
0.0219855104,
-0.0504796915,
-0.0033315939,
-0.0533530004,
-0.0567523725,
0.0448368005,
0.0154875973,
0.0317196175,
0.0224066023,
0.0069658123,
-0.0591669194,
-0.0112337442,
-0.0009494947,
0.0305706337,
0.0108362967,
-0.02684737,
-0.0377396978,
0.0154411122,
-0.0106090643,
-0.0058155041,
0.003610204,
-0.0425657779,
0.0149040949,
0.0130988294,
0.1035238877,
0.0313361883,
0.0588331074,
0.0091786114,
-0.0043025399,
0.0054333843,
-0.0155960815,
0.0117217023,
-0.0304374266,
-0.0449270718,
0.0043127178,
-0.0196554381,
0.0346478894,
0.039152205,
0.0253595579,
0.0146759385,
-0.0526696928,
0.0235121958,
-0.0082918359,
-0.016312791,
-0.0351345837,
-0.044277098,
-0.0555162132,
0.0310375169,
-0.0191541743,
-0.0388570577,
0.0689223334,
-0.0373456851,
-0.0167418215,
-0.0376712978,
-0.0249930918,
-0.0538313724,
0.0487533435,
0.0202411599,
0.0210560374,
0.0097699612,
-0.040768303,
-0.0520967878,
-0.0267311987,
0.0567699298,
-0.004112462,
0.0633964539,
-0.0569349863,
-0.0064099119,
-0.0171671622,
-0.0287582669,
-0.0210786145,
-0.0586866699,
-0.0281291623,
0.0453961715,
0.0326448828,
-0.0103520909,
-0.0020888546,
0.0385656692,
0.0292075928,
0.0691679865,
-0.0441801995,
0.0035814131,
-0.0123339063,
0.0522478335,
0.0434564017,
0.012796171,
0.0018960836,
-0.0491915084,
0.050287351,
-0.0086762467,
-0.0076227123,
-0.0260104984,
0.0049635796,
-0.0140500339,
-0.0094312178,
-0.0623592362,
-0.0567174591,
0.0136228548,
0.0794624984,
-0.0376461297,
0.0202837419,
0.1320241094,
0.0096271718,
-0.0322629884,
-0.0204630196,
-0.013258975,
0.063320674,
-0.0110135265,
0.0140467016,
-0.0328113958,
-0.0207274798,
0.0151969017,
0.0222565029,
-0.0033617301,
-0.0013622208,
-0.0307261888,
-0.1059878618,
0.0396742225,
-0.0017315042,
-0.0507130139,
0.0239519868,
-0.015143564,
0.001745305,
-0.0063393419,
0.0420791656,
0.0265339836,
-0.0512800999,
0.0063517755,
0.0127370628,
-0.0874428079,
0.021582244,
0.0041688667,
-0.0287054628,
0.0254404824,
0.0798037872,
0.0331956744,
0.0040674224,
0.0235870127,
0.0733501613,
-0.0383566916,
0.0216535777,
0.0307904296,
0.0481201522,
-0.00988968,
0.017012747,
-0.0490902252,
0.0409905799,
0.0149778975,
-0.004360293,
0.0312951356,
0.0140296724,
0.0006117326,
-0.029384952,
-0.0360545628,
0.0669180006,
-0.0231217593,
0.0938762203,
0.0570727922,
-0.0152404271,
-0.0638123676,
-0.0175984092,
0.0101945475,
-0.0113514829,
-0.0162503533,
-0.014110947,
-0.0267886352,
-0.0212181639,
-0.0640659258,
-0.1070465818,
0.025592709,
-0.0239890721,
-0.0068554035,
0.0056998404,
-0.0242236927,
0.0437732264,
0.0182955563,
0.0266013239,
-0.0052435719,
-0.0065200673,
-0.0862204805,
-0.013657636,
0.054950092,
-0.0343062617,
-0.0093472619,
0.0355346687,
-0.0339381024,
-0.0582127087,
-0.0420572273,
0.0390262119,
0.0336253233,
0.0615660436,
0.0313898958,
-0.0164255705,
0.0024511372,
0.0275010671,
-0.0090573961,
0.0225664508,
0.0186765511,
0.0624006726,
-0.0345983952,
0.0236363076,
-0.0181338526,
0.0486189015,
-0.0539546497,
0.0372001193,
-0.0174012855,
-0.1060288548,
0.0236242972,
0.043403808,
0.0150855212,
-0.0233112797,
0.0142492587,
-0.0397724025,
-0.0260230899,
-0.0266174655,
0.007231032,
-0.0400205106,
0.0197942834,
-0.0269999169,
-0.0107819214,
-0.0001203587,
-0.0107487487,
-0.0460836515,
0.0202276353,
-0.055437047,
-0.0190870706,
-0.024842428,
-0.0068080602,
-0.0165227484,
-0.0236780941,
-0.0342455506,
0.008753147,
-0.0379191898,
0.017425308,
-0.0047581471,
0.0793056861,
0.0271703824,
-0.0094572548,
0.0634299517,
0.0486831665,
-0.083192952,
-0.04142664,
-0.0299021862,
0.0433846973,
0.0272811484,
-0.0216873605,
0.0705660656,
-0.0070371442,
0.009723288,
-0.0399244316,
0.0320447795,
0.028965272,
0.0099518867,
-0.0203835461,
0.0321121179,
-0.0194496978,
-0.0056774598,
0.0786908716,
0.0283922609,
-0.0049416563,
0.0228332132,
-0.0213206131,
-0.0311272684,
-0.052571401,
0.0112435604,
-0.0078378068,
-0.0065533579,
-0.0157201011,
-0.0699882954,
-0.0107906535,
-0.0090342909,
0.0044252793,
0.0116968909,
-0.0485432409,
0.0543604419,
0.0289426241,
-0.0345677584,
-0.0237553287,
-0.0232572649,
0.0080314055,
-0.012411152,
0.0114109637,
-0.0296483319,
-5.666533334e-33,
-0.0500009395,
-0.0141240098,
0.004670715,
0.0232579429,
-0.0689505562,
-0.0167246796,
-0.048102539,
-0.0088548316,
0.0390568599,
0.0135152955,
-0.0447558686,
0.0186790768,
0.0144645935,
0.023108745,
-0.0001122486,
-0.0116380565,
0.0621606372,
-0.0011774615,
-0.0552985556,
0.0598322786,
-0.0073062624,
0.0101059731,
0.0246320777,
-0.0060183629,
0.0396805741,
-0.0599393994,
-0.0097785415,
-0.0028512571,
0.0266815554,
0.0262759067,
-0.0228513088,
0.0230086967,
0.0297517478,
-0.0388779491,
-0.0266654659,
0.0565569922,
-0.0506738313,
-0.0202164873,
0.0664894655,
-0.0384664498,
-0.0209734216,
-0.0282545425,
0.0109267067,
-0.0365970805,
-0.0072136461,
-0.0089731012,
0.030110741,
-0.015431704,
-0.0187758356,
-0.0336913168,
-0.0431362875,
0.0263490938,
-0.0197747573,
-0.0341131948,
-0.0080422834,
0.0476042479,
-0.0042525581,
-0.0057668081,
0.0157704018,
0.0074653835,
0.042651251,
-0.0026477233,
0.0090974346,
0.0069322912,
-0.0004809576,
0.0436169691,
0.0159572177,
0.0094001656,
-0.0380648077,
-0.0376183987,
-0.0150595186,
-0.0103745712,
0.0037583327,
0.0271286517,
-0.0086786989,
0.0270984992,
0.0015918686,
0.0532683507,
0.0133556807,
0.0051895985,
0.0153715219,
-0.0197831299,
-0.0047939541,
-0.0386269428,
-0.0249553844,
0.0096168807,
0.0094589591,
-0.018150555,
0.023993833,
-0.004052972,
0.007104334,
-0.0295498725,
0.0240331516,
-0.0036228886,
0.0407979414,
-0.0096852183,
-0.0442935824,
0.0171152242,
-0.0135475276,
0.033356797,
-0.0443635508,
0.015891498,
0.0300037861,
0.037238244,
0.0007874802,
0.0168616064,
0.0041297018,
-0.0024518899,
-0.0320227109,
0.0148935439,
0.0081137819,
0.0714059472,
-0.0754640326,
-0.0062575005,
0.0093743438,
0.0149820587,
0.0130862202,
0.0461976938,
-0.0139288334,
-0.018238429,
-0.0427649841,
-0.0121983336,
0.0214166287,
0.0108377635,
-0.0227854419,
0.0393534079,
0.0125918835,
0.0264945123,
0.0300381575,
-0.0027701408,
-0.0131308213,
-0.0066121677,
2.364e-7,
0.0185458045,
0.0497460552,
0.0850181505,
0.0174979661,
-0.0015987173,
0.0188775454,
0.0060319966,
0.039418105,
0.04343649,
-0.0139611736,
0.0449497104,
0.0210122019,
0.0462008305,
0.0001573273,
-0.1282163411,
-0.0286010187,
-0.1151780561,
-0.0374934934,
-0.054816395,
0.0062161949,
0.0577687547,
0.0438462086,
-0.0343772247,
-0.0047482676,
-0.0354880989,
-0.021895105,
0.048159454,
-0.0532918833,
-0.0537128635,
0.0379180126,
0.0860902146,
0.0072975461,
-0.000676275,
0.0368494503,
0.0305100624,
-0.000971893,
0.0549110323,
0.0545610413,
0.0311530028,
-0.0101664448,
-0.0059285774,
-0.0274106115,
0.013159412,
-0.0492603295,
0.0452810451,
-0.0397372581,
-0.000561498,
-0.0092966259,
-0.0391589738,
-0.0574939027,
-0.0017735423,
-0.0361295156,
-0.0270848796,
0.0547639988,
-0.0203585513,
-0.0151198599,
0.0421134196,
-0.0555680133,
-0.0166686084,
0.0204708837,
-0.0195945743,
-0.0500206724,
-0.0207234975,
-0.0142963361,
-0.0119214533,
-0.0532204024,
0.0121925818,
2.139296863e-34,
0.0987338498,
-0.0193050541,
-0.0021771705,
-0.0089099808,
0.0515746064,
-0.0049840799,
0.0324648097,
0.0018253156,
0.0270733405,
-0.0633457303,
-0.0236931965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16803v1 | Language Agnostic Code Embeddings | 2023-10-25T17:34:52 | 2023-10-25T17:34:52 | Saiteja Utpala, Alex Gu, Pin Yu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, code language models have achieved notable advancements in
addressing a diverse array of essential code comprehension and generation
tasks. Yet, the field lacks a comprehensive deep dive and understanding of the
code embeddings of multilingual code models. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive study on multilingual code embeddings, focusing on the
cross-lingual capabilities of these embeddings across different programming
languages. Through probing experiments, we demonstrate that code embeddings
comprise two distinct components: one deeply tied to the nuances and syntax of
a specific language, and the other remaining agnostic to these details,
primarily focusing on semantics. Further, we show that when we isolate and
eliminate this language-specific component, we witness significant improvements
in downstream code retrieval tasks, leading to an absolute increase of up to
+17 in the Mean Reciprocal Rank (MRR). | [
-0.0155306226,
0.0460843854,
-0.0429260805,
0.0642075762,
0.0022860786,
0.0481178276,
-0.0139369247,
0.0016750465,
0.0293670353,
0.0311129373,
-0.0261364114,
0.0194771271,
-0.0096889362,
0.0204441547,
0.0860505551,
0.0081707686,
0.0366074815,
-0.0348087065,
-0.0288570225,
0.0175364427,
0.0026292154,
0.0184926447,
0.0565534122,
0.0607193336,
0.0350079015,
-0.0179947205,
0.002013962,
0.0063918154,
0.0170724932,
-0.0211081877,
-0.0029391604,
0.0055999695,
0.030775154,
0.0075396812,
0.0000018832,
-0.0005412606,
-0.0150342816,
-0.0081218379,
0.0265297629,
0.0377483256,
-0.0004521332,
-0.047244247,
0.0047776704,
0.0113344304,
-0.0273627602,
-0.0317787305,
0.0719630495,
-0.05768447,
0.0233223028,
0.0353718475,
0.018769417,
-0.0102038225,
0.0074614529,
-0.0300589502,
0.0409348682,
-0.0028137506,
-0.0282771382,
0.0494536273,
-0.0130680455,
0.0589522906,
-0.0059858961,
0.0485047735,
0.0367374606,
0.0138797937,
-0.0111102341,
0.0465322584,
-0.0157063697,
0.0066736718,
0.0298624244,
0.0296418816,
-0.071455501,
-0.041786842,
0.0123100867,
0.0044095884,
-0.0110732643,
-0.0508737005,
-0.0604605451,
0.0340680256,
0.041768223,
0.0095059983,
0.0209402982,
0.0040818234,
0.0402114913,
-0.0082595963,
-0.0115247918,
0.0212979391,
0.0187995378,
-0.0235651545,
-0.0425950959,
-0.0205784962,
0.0090920059,
-0.0283455476,
0.0093438402,
0.0116213532,
0.034441717,
0.0169528369,
0.0155180935,
-0.0395133346,
0.0444455147,
-0.0339922905,
0.0391084589,
0.0763227716,
-0.0225381143,
0.0098993508,
-0.097737886,
0.0755564347,
-0.0173886642,
0.0094597926,
-0.017000895,
-0.0000464884,
-0.0599070415,
-0.0494548641,
-0.0372245163,
0.0252876058,
-0.0009476911,
0.0048824861,
-0.0120733203,
0.0629351735,
0.0080679702,
0.0458290838,
-0.0530111454,
-0.0394165888,
-0.0379333906,
0.0367404483,
0.0726675689,
-0.0026452604,
-0.0336726755,
-0.0707816854,
-0.0047266735,
-0.0519301556,
-0.0264154244,
0.0284922179,
-0.0343139358,
-0.0196696799,
0.0039914777,
0.0414861813,
0.0044019497,
0.0146854278,
-0.0032680212,
-0.0331007689,
0.0170120411,
0.0140726203,
0.0228788573,
-0.0863146931,
-0.0007706247,
0.0302176662,
0.0100908503,
-0.0611691996,
0.005762124,
0.0162839722,
-0.0085763112,
0.0383449085,
-0.0176394228,
-0.0116285319,
-0.0044578896,
0.0314750113,
-0.0198567435,
0.0477946736,
0.0042860718,
-0.0038588212,
0.0388725288,
-0.0499467179,
-0.0098646376,
0.0267297998,
-0.004644915,
0.0017228257,
-0.0033563045,
0.0276630204,
0.0422694869,
-0.0110330395,
0.0477482714,
-0.0001332645,
-0.0531608649,
-0.0089005623,
-0.0297392048,
0.0311310198,
0.0147309462,
0.0319635868,
0.0971932411,
0.0020147455,
-0.0397914276,
0.0016306791,
-0.0240363069,
0.0526575968,
0.0155861834,
0.0268128123,
0.0184059218,
0.0409517325,
-0.0045493175,
-0.0445249267,
-0.0078113098,
-0.0059832311,
0.0190895945,
-0.0091721499,
0.0004855454,
0.0029947266,
-0.0253851712,
0.030521566,
0.0026774125,
-0.0866440609,
-0.017709367,
-0.0262108352,
-0.0094011417,
0.0355249643,
0.0406984724,
-0.0215216503,
-0.0150644975,
0.0115368022,
-0.0150021017,
-0.0111153256,
0.020348506,
-0.0104234908,
0.0520562157,
-0.0593041629,
-0.0032918446,
-0.0576060712,
0.0014175744,
0.0943202302,
0.0045858072,
-0.0112511506,
0.0587915964,
-0.0293692611,
-0.0274981428,
0.0224393997,
-0.0686729625,
0.0250096004,
-0.0054949182,
0.0039951238,
-0.0292069037,
-0.0060926466,
-0.0394697636,
0.0440794155,
0.0089821713,
-0.0398722291,
0.0023721512,
-0.0112600327,
-0.0337245986,
-0.0453781635,
0.0104521401,
-0.0472683907,
-0.0170142949,
0.0440312624,
0.0027228389,
-0.0057662204,
0.0627724901,
-0.0319640823,
0.0461058877,
-0.0354918577,
-0.0038213418,
-0.029045254,
-0.0068230089,
-0.0055031064,
0.0232761186,
-0.017589096,
0.081401512,
0.0326634496,
0.0640536249,
0.0492493808,
0.0063222977,
-0.0399072617,
0.0309027042,
-0.0281124692,
0.0273618605,
0.0085197901,
0.0410408229,
0.0051776511,
-0.0274333004,
-0.0918846205,
0.0156790949,
-0.0287553966,
0.0243073441,
0.0261264332,
0.0058915545,
0.0173887946,
-0.0208971258,
-0.0452040769,
-0.0319471285,
-0.0271377061,
0.0616820753,
0.0206212737,
-0.0203043073,
-0.0375337042,
-0.0260277484,
-0.0102751432,
-0.009392594,
0.0689460039,
-0.0481546484,
0.0069727609,
-0.0636488646,
0.0679065883,
-0.0613187328,
-0.0459430441,
-0.0330478214,
-0.0690870881,
0.0147834299,
-0.0257673692,
0.0992244482,
0.0356568582,
-0.0439876355,
-0.0138348881,
0.067488648,
0.002260746,
-0.0588144697,
-0.0006734725,
0.0419419482,
-0.026742598,
0.0189472176,
-0.0580073893,
0.0286043473,
0.082693398,
0.0098316995,
-0.0084861154,
-0.0597802289,
-0.0049025104,
-0.007630148,
-0.0108448593,
-0.0303416271,
-0.0260808207,
0.0058511221,
0.0584892519,
-0.0294396672,
-0.0777829066,
0.063875623,
-0.0276087485,
-0.0531550907,
-0.0223249439,
-0.0127730481,
-0.0352275968,
0.0529813245,
-0.0202720538,
0.0566491336,
-0.0235260315,
-0.0482071154,
-0.0231598392,
0.0314237922,
-0.0176555328,
-0.0297667123,
0.0283548776,
-0.0097675249,
-0.036300268,
-0.0199376717,
-0.0397830568,
-0.027022399,
0.0135012679,
0.0225983337,
0.0174078513,
0.0474590585,
0.0107141538,
0.0432013422,
-0.0130549148,
0.0421130173,
0.0346474349,
0.0112394309,
-0.0226922631,
-0.0154346153,
-0.0175752714,
-0.0377790034,
-0.0702028275,
0.0039948644,
0.0004287586,
0.0062133041,
0.0018525325,
0.0419240408,
0.0114724627,
-0.0339248553,
0.0030394469,
0.0305982865,
0.0044142869,
-0.0719252974,
0.0339624248,
0.0283788797,
-0.0320477001,
-0.0256191492,
0.0509443171,
0.0375397205,
-0.0400685742,
-0.0004373031,
-0.0722811446,
0.0704816207,
0.0680651814,
0.0195998941,
-0.071828045,
0.0221620072,
0.0052932533,
-0.0009246727,
0.0112491343,
-0.0044661066,
-0.0092803594,
-0.0778724253,
0.0171315502,
0.0159148946,
-0.0405890681,
-0.0859400257,
-0.0500909649,
-0.0518689007,
0.0403843634,
-0.0268778969,
0.0269532464,
0.0031171134,
0.0222736299,
-0.0053916634,
-0.0300078578,
0.0105089666,
0.0137329455,
-0.0303878766,
-0.0153779406,
0.0930331126,
0.0490258001,
0.0272636842,
-0.0182596855,
-0.0171700362,
-0.0461983569,
0.0087053021,
-0.0089530954,
0.0197621286,
0.0285933968,
-0.0411433391,
0.0250899661,
-0.019889662,
-0.0306150075,
-0.0101103587,
0.0029150308,
0.0609648675,
0.0052757463,
0.008538248,
-0.0137683945,
0.0046880282,
-0.0207668394,
0.0320477299,
0.0692007914,
-0.0017696732,
-0.0260503404,
-0.0822429955,
0.0577935688,
-0.0650556684,
-0.0208696499,
-0.0111918962,
0.02357658,
-0.0121645033,
-0.0446490534,
-0.0408742093,
0.0008117658,
0.0217285696,
-0.008566021,
-0.0071939388,
-0.026968386,
-0.0368022695,
-0.0700584427,
0.002163152,
-0.0377960801,
0.010086922,
0.0070468215,
-0.014356995,
0.0049824123,
-0.0144431153,
-0.0200321954,
-0.0243244637,
-0.0729423836,
-0.0397424363,
-0.0767908171,
0.03847792,
0.0027425922,
-0.0025898146,
0.004737467,
-0.038815394,
-0.0528097488,
-0.0262199808,
-0.0294732992,
0.0114968298,
0.0593429245,
0.0209187306,
0.0275670327,
0.0402741022,
-0.061191313,
-0.0078567564,
0.0136852628,
0.0092744073,
-0.010636786,
0.0282865111,
0.0126748439,
0.0029423698,
0.0088298786,
0.0166191217,
-0.0230693072,
-0.018009834,
-0.0060939807,
-0.0204880498,
-0.0373161435,
-0.0466594435,
0.0213173982,
0.0411834233,
-0.0171690695,
0.0227773786,
0.041379679,
0.0284491181,
0.0536822826,
-0.0261725634,
0.0519490391,
0.0089107072,
0.023116041,
0.0344458669,
0.0319976397,
-0.0526862256,
0.0042977007,
-0.0287184566,
0.0188338272,
-0.0528608598,
0.0308809225,
-0.0119082863,
0.0052591483,
0.0295569692,
0.0154034328,
-0.0441394784,
-0.0659027174,
0.0581318699,
-0.043882601,
0.055333145,
0.0177602042,
0.0626495183,
0.0031103159,
0.0103016356,
-0.0039480953,
0.0363786109,
0.0026622643,
-0.0780321881,
0.004121792,
0.0265431609,
-0.0214452017,
-0.0346626416,
0.0901721492,
-0.0148390159,
-0.0012301691,
-0.0266794432,
-0.0078050452,
-0.0220352858,
0.0113826832,
0.1045095101,
0.0315212384,
-0.0247703996,
-0.0122492276,
-0.0315079428,
-0.0752180293,
0.0036246118,
0.0418896005,
-0.0067210388,
0.0035845458,
-0.001225897,
0.130709663,
-0.0130275534,
-0.0173729546,
-0.0417718105,
0.0329044312,
0.0022582433,
-0.0496883132,
-0.0302232038,
-5.363604766e-33,
-0.0214004554,
0.0024812366,
-0.0168912858,
-0.0154976211,
0.0206578169,
0.0170128495,
-0.0716354027,
0.0134315332,
-0.0221411418,
-0.0305245593,
0.0406103283,
0.0262584388,
-0.0198374633,
-0.0348867476,
0.0428545512,
0.0314047001,
0.0219464917,
0.0462630764,
-0.0289740283,
0.0408918709,
0.0015822791,
0.0496072806,
0.0304982513,
-0.0277775023,
0.0071114395,
-0.0331990905,
0.0418374315,
-0.0295605324,
0.0385780707,
0.0674627721,
-0.0218504369,
0.0055807964,
0.0133107565,
-0.0029319313,
-0.0631179884,
-0.0328454897,
-0.0195276681,
-0.0316996612,
0.0203706268,
-0.0093197972,
0.010046334,
-0.0771010146,
0.0464596823,
-0.029670408,
0.0102071082,
-0.0149511388,
0.0147822695,
0.0114310617,
-0.0236427225,
-0.031314753,
-0.0797168389,
0.0388569273,
-0.0499701537,
0.0098208552,
0.0526471101,
0.0525419004,
0.0266131833,
0.0755707398,
-0.0279076211,
0.0294365752,
-0.0466178916,
0.0707280114,
0.0690429658,
-0.0277195759,
-0.0097939372,
0.0236648005,
0.0513393767,
0.0082689319,
0.0126124835,
0.0235158242,
0.0668879822,
0.0056918082,
0.0369225293,
0.0191439744,
0.016535366,
0.0037231094,
-0.0354154333,
-0.0094999503,
-0.0026533243,
-0.0000490795,
0.0202262048,
0.059196569,
-0.0604151897,
-0.0150498981,
-0.0399816893,
-0.0337962545,
-0.0408636294,
-0.0791907087,
0.0555603243,
0.001347414,
-0.0064082076,
-0.0005383613,
0.0451833121,
-0.0302725825,
-0.0002040505,
0.0588393845,
-0.0372984111,
0.0253596585,
0.0092379358,
0.0726618469,
-0.0204501692,
-0.016892042,
0.000351868,
-0.0333231352,
0.0533380173,
0.0136431623,
0.0458788089,
0.011110398,
-0.0765474066,
-0.0154937282,
-0.0392006636,
-0.0402160361,
-0.0219999179,
0.037270084,
0.0021648523,
-0.0088169342,
0.0210406799,
0.0225229245,
0.0421022065,
-0.0302865338,
-0.0733061954,
-0.0134474812,
-0.01952889,
0.0382519253,
-0.0292014908,
-0.0110629369,
-0.0678442419,
0.0434396118,
0.0234688204,
-0.0166137777,
-0.0533452444,
0.020326063,
2.562e-7,
0.0245923083,
0.0042960108,
0.0116423629,
0.0381261483,
-0.0011145015,
0.0126371458,
-0.0462202169,
-0.0074054389,
0.0010867224,
-0.0018404789,
-0.0583682992,
0.0242953375,
0.0285260547,
0.0236905832,
-0.0403894931,
0.0465636328,
-0.0146537106,
-0.0130795091,
-0.0472276174,
-0.0083319033,
0.0153510207,
0.0625611544,
-0.0565389358,
0.0492850915,
0.0005532132,
-0.0268955175,
0.0388428085,
-0.0167386774,
0.0056195012,
-0.0065777954,
-0.0753249004,
0.0412055366,
-0.0019068624,
-0.0431448109,
-0.0156252645,
0.0061855097,
0.050178986,
0.0711410344,
0.0053603631,
0.0552022085,
0.029006632,
-0.0212826189,
-0.0184238814,
-0.1099488214,
0.0336823948,
-0.0112195602,
0.0000498677,
0.0007133618,
-0.0014268456,
0.0582065172,
0.0478013083,
-0.0234666094,
-0.0222509615,
0.0340556502,
0.0089506665,
-0.0266180206,
-0.0052398173,
-0.038024798,
-0.0492753163,
0.0096190497,
-0.0180919021,
-0.0365934148,
-0.0712253153,
0.0066039013,
0.0229366403,
0.0002895845,
0.0126916384,
2.564878623e-34,
0.0079783639,
-0.0229093283,
0.039795626,
0.0098741055,
0.0725212246,
-0.0397459492,
-0.0062644202,
0.0244905856,
-0.0081192516,
0.0042700027,
-0.0398925394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16790v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16790v1 | Improving a Named Entity Recognizer Trained on Noisy Data with a Few Clean Instances | 2023-10-25T17:23:37 | 2023-10-25T17:23:37 | Zhendong Chu, Ruiyi Zhang, Tong Yu, Rajiv Jain, Vlad I Morariu, Jiuxiang Gu, Ani Nenkova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | To achieve state-of-the-art performance, one still needs to train NER models
on large-scale, high-quality annotated data, an asset that is both costly and
time-intensive to accumulate. In contrast, real-world applications often resort
to massive low-quality labeled data through non-expert annotators via
crowdsourcing and external knowledge bases via distant supervision as a
cost-effective alternative. However, these annotation methods result in noisy
labels, which in turn lead to a notable decline in performance. Hence, we
propose to denoise the noisy NER data with guidance from a small set of clean
instances. Along with the main NER model we train a discriminator model and use
its outputs to recalibrate the sample weights. The discriminator is capable of
detecting both span and category errors with different discriminative prompts.
Results on public crowdsourcing and distant supervision datasets show that the
proposed method can consistently improve performance with a small guidance set. | [
0.0466132089,
0.0419184342,
0.0286155548,
0.0536507219,
0.0711157322,
0.0447634235,
0.0104638143,
0.0231271442,
0.0146636553,
-0.0248752851,
-0.0367975011,
-0.0007840703,
-0.015917819,
-0.0330245569,
0.0311268922,
-0.0099040819,
-0.0064261612,
-0.0216941647,
0.0645252913,
0.0078907833,
0.0047191856,
-0.0010785864,
-0.0097681731,
0.0025129635,
-0.0138165569,
0.0465382598,
-0.0164068304,
0.0339601189,
0.0393858962,
-0.0781892538,
0.0476121642,
0.0527067557,
-0.0138834184,
0.0326153636,
0.000001864,
-0.0540918708,
-0.0276221316,
0.0361463465,
-0.0381868631,
-0.0297681373,
0.0067579919,
-0.0329683051,
0.0039433148,
-0.0133609716,
0.0287381243,
-0.0559518375,
0.0289774761,
0.0901123807,
0.0603920929,
0.0816437826,
-0.0014014059,
0.0006073159,
0.002631383,
-0.0021227479,
0.0024863889,
-0.0395534523,
0.0596680827,
-0.028311912,
-0.0037461659,
-0.0097321374,
0.0088115875,
0.0099552916,
-0.0308299139,
-0.0017668508,
0.0458495654,
0.0224594008,
-0.0410068259,
0.0116540408,
-0.007692805,
0.0767334774,
-0.0097279092,
0.0122044105,
0.0641365573,
-0.0029824697,
-0.0125200646,
-0.0345997363,
0.0021815267,
-0.0024040053,
-0.033406768,
0.0173618905,
-0.0091266213,
0.0061686411,
0.0207711905,
-0.011497478,
0.0215596929,
-0.0249903351,
0.0075059896,
-0.0574582629,
0.0162443835,
0.0535584763,
-0.0160199311,
-0.0484563373,
0.0473184511,
0.0039283764,
-0.0169894826,
0.0093078688,
-0.0441464037,
-0.0319807529,
-0.0168123841,
-0.0115049966,
-0.0018344638,
-0.0127248829,
-0.0137154385,
0.0511446707,
-0.0322738029,
-0.0098105865,
0.0223219264,
0.0110380463,
0.0337695368,
-0.029092541,
-0.058047276,
0.0367197804,
-0.0495099612,
0.0447744429,
-0.0187114812,
0.0058511724,
-0.0280244481,
-0.0095772035,
-0.0268054605,
0.0277571511,
0.0288173668,
-0.0143272709,
-0.0030546952,
0.0001263199,
-0.0174982436,
0.0302330591,
-0.0090220021,
-0.0152837066,
-0.0153853269,
-0.0637128353,
0.0080339052,
-0.0133545743,
0.0458227061,
-0.0223949868,
0.0170141552,
0.0578807518,
0.0243413001,
-0.0767228752,
-0.0998319089,
-0.0104396129,
-0.0001953392,
-0.0101943575,
-0.0233065914,
-0.0044004833,
0.021051636,
-0.0261967331,
0.0120736239,
-0.0496240631,
0.0196290724,
-0.0260782018,
-0.0443395711,
0.0847836509,
-0.0831847563,
-0.0180359203,
0.0365540385,
-0.0073427428,
0.0384583734,
0.0415811986,
0.0298835374,
-0.0370454341,
0.0487856381,
-0.0026830577,
0.0058752894,
0.0172208399,
0.0485011302,
-0.0128664877,
0.0086876061,
0.003421424,
-0.0299575403,
0.0149059575,
0.049418401,
0.0503662415,
-0.0069048861,
-0.0146549698,
0.0214272793,
-0.0044431067,
-0.0031342639,
-0.0098680621,
-0.0263694301,
0.0205332302,
-0.0130211487,
-0.0378669351,
-0.0348279811,
-0.0146620572,
-0.0510618053,
-0.004869069,
0.0486600399,
0.024313312,
-0.0316445418,
0.003078304,
-0.0081639383,
0.001952067,
-0.0408828184,
0.0213072356,
0.0682227314,
0.007681164,
-0.046640195,
0.0623029955,
0.0455115996,
-0.028455561,
0.0420221463,
-0.0098860832,
0.0700986534,
0.0452480204,
0.027020704,
-0.0437869802,
-0.0302963611,
-0.0544061363,
-0.0375266746,
0.0565803275,
-0.0049434388,
-0.0369289592,
0.0365503505,
-0.0478104763,
-0.0390979648,
0.0435025729,
0.0215624608,
0.0178077314,
0.0272679701,
0.0308335759,
0.0291897822,
-0.039465908,
-0.0757301003,
0.0487724431,
0.0067021828,
-0.0406780466,
-0.0021209419,
0.0451731719,
0.0171870571,
0.051316034,
-0.0100542922,
-0.0490005948,
0.00818008,
-0.0133664785,
-0.0199743379,
-0.062871106,
-0.0027239355,
-0.0357116759,
0.0234338362,
-0.0429301001,
-0.028727062,
0.0173296351,
-0.0282098688,
-0.0487270243,
-0.0641745999,
-0.0074220402,
-0.0216698032,
-0.0184742846,
0.0165194571,
0.0203262735,
-0.0067643682,
-0.0078727724,
0.044203613,
-0.0086416909,
0.0388809368,
0.0309519153,
-0.0252227373,
0.0219704043,
-0.0502369329,
-0.0655545518,
-0.0132085308,
0.0059885243,
-0.0036772494,
0.03068153,
-0.0117701553,
-0.0669672117,
-0.009379291,
-0.0387348197,
-0.0224873126,
-0.026957009,
0.0253945645,
0.0023398255,
0.0082283067,
-0.0073348503,
-0.0443258844,
-0.0237348452,
-0.0058394587,
-0.0244692042,
0.0141552128,
0.0336886309,
0.0086248405,
-0.0409638397,
0.0127286781,
0.0087334635,
-0.004157444,
-0.0202893689,
0.0381505154,
-0.0707707033,
-0.0867718309,
0.0581523143,
-0.0168492757,
0.0409776047,
0.0171232838,
0.0304590277,
-0.0106625166,
0.0283313394,
-0.0259972382,
0.011074136,
-0.0375757068,
0.0093480917,
-0.0135615319,
0.001437515,
-0.034097258,
0.027932642,
0.0051991865,
0.0360035002,
-0.041104313,
-0.0421583168,
0.0163930114,
0.0727215484,
-0.0333636776,
0.0144140404,
-0.060137704,
-0.0170729607,
-0.0414769687,
-0.0332229659,
-0.042079825,
0.0123531381,
-0.0002139172,
0.0185801983,
-0.0219348054,
0.0107351141,
0.0699630678,
-0.0336772427,
-0.0239895377,
0.0222662073,
-0.0135683957,
-0.0250812471,
-0.0130250398,
0.0059001064,
0.0010617718,
0.0693561807,
-0.0832851157,
-0.0001213597,
0.0212819073,
0.0122841727,
-0.0230053775,
0.0125912102,
-0.0143316668,
0.0461572371,
-0.0207839459,
-0.0433295183,
-0.0407738574,
-0.0121579031,
-0.043740321,
-0.0131082786,
-0.0096586896,
-0.0190439522,
-0.0021623897,
0.0568930879,
-0.015313386,
0.0568812601,
0.0288406368,
-0.020412242,
-0.007180532,
0.0520805307,
0.0193725992,
0.0201465543,
0.0039073094,
-0.030210793,
-0.0267741159,
0.0209402945,
-0.0116821593,
-0.0052358834,
-0.0083412072,
-0.0017631385,
0.0268354136,
-0.0252742209,
-0.0016881347,
-0.0147533128,
0.0549209192,
-0.0232600868,
-0.0059858346,
0.110257782,
-0.0293204989,
-0.0106426599,
-0.0294889119,
0.0218764152,
0.0223908033,
0.0286580306,
0.0112098986,
-0.0845636055,
-0.0436526053,
0.0275447983,
0.0574855767,
0.0120175006,
-0.0689359903,
0.0198098365,
-0.114562735,
0.0035305489,
-0.0185298547,
-0.0736349002,
0.0224863868,
-0.0618758723,
0.0280423108,
-0.0668789148,
0.010436926,
-0.0356238522,
0.0040007061,
0.0079234559,
0.0454738624,
0.0211270116,
-0.0638271347,
-0.0209257025,
-0.0467229262,
0.099238582,
0.0112539884,
0.0131477397,
-0.0090076635,
-0.0399513356,
0.0151633406,
-0.0345849432,
-0.0223843828,
0.0011587454,
0.0874480531,
-0.0476571172,
-0.0366198272,
-0.0044698538,
-0.0030167594,
-0.0425307564,
0.015064951,
0.0100888815,
0.0253666546,
0.0303049106,
0.0041568642,
0.01325012,
-0.0387291834,
0.045101162,
0.0768158287,
0.0189583432,
-0.0060015963,
-0.0130194826,
0.031295985,
-0.0030626541,
0.0038827648,
-0.0325873494,
0.0428224131,
-0.0691550151,
-0.091892615,
-0.0198134016,
-0.0768572018,
0.053457398,
0.0469652936,
0.0209985338,
-0.0228144284,
0.0395984687,
0.0207867008,
-0.0209341701,
0.0397185683,
-0.0493132472,
-0.0028067075,
-0.0654590875,
-0.0001811813,
-0.016306594,
0.0534315109,
-0.042501457,
0.0057078241,
-0.0518177971,
-0.0487146601,
-0.0014606913,
0.0101925973,
0.0119752819,
0.0356988385,
-0.0111677377,
-0.0517377369,
0.0350333601,
0.0728901401,
-0.0484201759,
-0.0150893005,
0.011630347,
0.0174782872,
-0.013935904,
0.0284695514,
-0.0573189333,
0.038500376,
0.0438504219,
0.0273567773,
-0.0488711223,
-0.0419603437,
0.0072434293,
0.05450904,
0.0527141802,
-0.0162588451,
-0.0121567529,
-0.0608555302,
0.0066278637,
0.0260394923,
-0.006597965,
-0.0191494636,
-0.0161813162,
0.0298597924,
-0.0223738439,
-0.0228757523,
0.082142517,
0.0031120544,
0.0284995195,
-0.081104964,
-0.0057543078,
0.0420796424,
0.0535707958,
0.0176063105,
-0.0220362321,
0.0019831909,
0.0372669846,
0.1015187651,
0.053230051,
-0.0060470123,
0.0009210314,
0.0120368302,
0.0296748932,
0.0127587765,
-0.0223475136,
-0.0312136523,
-0.0106232632,
-0.0342780128,
0.0523602441,
0.030978499,
0.0143118845,
0.0598904453,
0.0109185968,
-0.0099575929,
-0.0033258139,
-0.018739203,
0.0075158132,
-0.0149578601,
0.0359116979,
0.0216385722,
0.0007858276,
0.0017623302,
0.0699882284,
0.0079907002,
0.0384590998,
-0.0088414876,
0.0024536089,
-0.0699678287,
0.0048846919,
0.0282580107,
-0.022704592,
-0.035422083,
0.02171335,
0.0080510434,
-0.0481220856,
0.000727254,
-0.0457235053,
0.0021351494,
0.0133333458,
0.0301020406,
-0.0349057019,
-0.0040992568,
-0.0318683349,
-0.0041007902,
-0.020725565,
0.0207915455,
-0.0223954841,
-0.0241193976,
-6.267479474e-33,
-0.0302901044,
-0.0338025838,
-0.0015646092,
-0.0360452309,
0.0034390367,
0.0271985717,
-0.0173544083,
-0.0092112701,
0.0250170827,
-0.0063626436,
-0.0067484281,
0.0351432003,
0.028024219,
0.0026375158,
0.0014904138,
-0.045140367,
0.1143060103,
0.0100854691,
-0.0051838825,
0.004761179,
0.0325901136,
0.0703162849,
0.0456937477,
-0.1196429878,
0.0656390861,
-0.0042397846,
-0.0346295349,
0.0096605495,
0.0955325365,
0.0250660442,
-0.0458920263,
0.0116473204,
0.0113330325,
-0.0578148477,
-0.0038971596,
-0.0299958009,
-0.147881493,
0.0307284985,
-0.0558771677,
0.0653296337,
-0.0357734039,
-0.0136655085,
0.0513065867,
-0.0028470233,
0.0294676889,
0.0336351283,
0.0438960567,
-0.0263303537,
0.0008341335,
-0.0172544997,
-0.0088858046,
0.0548037365,
-0.0195397288,
0.0332327671,
0.0606778786,
-0.0252121445,
0.0352030061,
-0.0065817442,
-0.0924412385,
-0.0196679961,
0.0254872255,
-0.0174256135,
0.0023261046,
0.0301686786,
-0.0381959751,
0.0362414941,
0.0437816121,
0.0001950399,
0.0010120359,
-0.0407260917,
-0.0109425411,
0.0246871151,
0.0127114458,
0.0547594838,
0.0705310777,
-0.0290531833,
-0.035348814,
0.0429129973,
-0.0347673371,
0.0117655508,
-0.0210920312,
-0.0163143706,
-0.0619948953,
0.0081723155,
0.0068843337,
-0.0585614927,
-0.0630528405,
0.0241095629,
0.018914612,
0.0520554073,
-0.0524797961,
0.0134786787,
-0.0163130704,
-0.0173871052,
-0.0492858104,
-0.0147880912,
0.0685668066,
-0.0014079679,
-0.010569063,
-0.0162849873,
-0.0527794622,
-0.0390654355,
0.0151054664,
0.0124802096,
0.0302938335,
-0.0241808705,
0.0724253803,
0.0008370305,
-0.0862903073,
0.0131617747,
-0.0020218918,
0.0408613831,
-0.0124505553,
0.0281604826,
0.0102826506,
-0.0360531695,
-0.0066197827,
0.0150331249,
0.0672256947,
0.0232137647,
0.0271115992,
0.045616664,
0.0427148342,
0.0014171235,
-0.0080866404,
-0.0227239039,
0.0131070726,
-0.0204498004,
0.0204290152,
-0.0332897231,
0.0215445776,
-0.0346490778,
2.579e-7,
-0.0260035545,
-0.0043207933,
0.0304459538,
-0.0240925979,
-0.010440479,
0.0146499779,
0.0060755154,
0.0416497402,
-0.041941639,
-0.019863775,
-0.0008705442,
-0.040978387,
0.0345482416,
0.0326585062,
-0.1049416363,
-0.0389102586,
-0.0056186542,
0.0014100868,
-0.0442960821,
0.0398129262,
0.0246076882,
0.0576878972,
0.0091595696,
-0.0317035466,
-0.0063742567,
-0.0387976505,
0.0379317887,
0.00084166,
0.0465839803,
0.0387545824,
0.0693037882,
0.0665858388,
-0.0050355457,
0.0299997982,
-0.0150616029,
0.023451671,
-0.0062111556,
0.0599793047,
-0.00382079,
0.0213646572,
-0.0017531693,
-0.0120908385,
0.0265564844,
0.0187960863,
0.0507264547,
-0.0149671528,
-0.0151063111,
0.0201995,
-0.0336807929,
-0.04358574,
0.0183894504,
0.0239677671,
-0.0051138564,
-0.005820855,
0.0315296873,
-0.0360342264,
-0.0071066893,
-0.0745888725,
0.0427048989,
-0.003406099,
0.006073535,
-0.0147842551,
0.0218311604,
-0.0126418285,
0.0088658324,
-0.0604682378,
0.0188205801,
2.06935449e-34,
-0.0003887277,
-0.0044494672,
-0.0081221145,
0.0263095461,
0.0031911852,
-0.0142079201,
-0.0799354762,
-0.0409021042,
-0.0006737123,
-0.0352752097,
0.0116720544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16789v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16789v3 | Detecting Pretraining Data from Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T17:21:23 | 2024-03-09T22:26:06 | Weijia Shi, Anirudh Ajith, Mengzhou Xia, Yangsibo Huang, Daogao Liu, Terra Blevins, Danqi Chen, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Although large language models (LLMs) are widely deployed, the data used to
train them is rarely disclosed. Given the incredible scale of this data, up to
trillions of tokens, it is all but certain that it includes potentially
problematic text such as copyrighted materials, personally identifiable
information, and test data for widely reported reference benchmarks. However,
we currently have no way to know which data of these types is included or in
what proportions. In this paper, we study the pretraining data detection
problem: given a piece of text and black-box access to an LLM without knowing
the pretraining data, can we determine if the model was trained on the provided
text? To facilitate this study, we introduce a dynamic benchmark WIKIMIA that
uses data created before and after model training to support gold truth
detection. We also introduce a new detection method Min-K% Prob based on a
simple hypothesis: an unseen example is likely to contain a few outlier words
with low probabilities under the LLM, while a seen example is less likely to
have words with such low probabilities. Min-K% Prob can be applied without any
knowledge about the pretraining corpus or any additional training, departing
from previous detection methods that require training a reference model on data
that is similar to the pretraining data. Moreover, our experiments demonstrate
that Min-K% Prob achieves a 7.4% improvement on WIKIMIA over these previous
methods. We apply Min-K% Prob to three real-world scenarios, copyrighted book
detection, contaminated downstream example detection and privacy auditing of
machine unlearning, and find it a consistently effective solution. | [
0.0574551485,
0.0910134315,
-0.0048232535,
0.0753491446,
-0.0438286923,
0.0205991454,
-0.0019132303,
0.0488083325,
0.0060924985,
-0.0453819521,
-0.0099718999,
0.0231986213,
-0.0259883832,
0.0283985082,
0.0124953203,
0.0602394044,
0.0538038202,
-0.0116227753,
0.0322152302,
-0.0237365514,
0.0053180456,
0.0193876419,
0.0130742984,
0.0188573301,
-0.029902555,
-0.0324801356,
0.0017239379,
-0.0165006258,
0.0053205723,
-0.0058562127,
-0.0014012472,
0.0500884987,
-0.0112451008,
0.0957035497,
0.0000019314,
-0.0434217863,
-0.0500139147,
0.0182470568,
-0.0635151938,
0.0404074676,
0.0344073512,
0.0206077732,
-0.0007471216,
0.0310054943,
-0.0279472973,
0.0214540828,
0.0245909672,
0.044982221,
0.0522106811,
0.0893560871,
-0.007787182,
0.0279290639,
0.034126319,
0.011179409,
-0.0066635902,
-0.0305106714,
0.0306437071,
-0.021053724,
-0.0446866266,
-0.0075357412,
0.0101635735,
0.0604574941,
0.0033402608,
0.0054933252,
-0.0417783856,
0.0034762807,
-0.0573480614,
-0.0142515618,
-0.0018862188,
0.0405023172,
-0.0342226364,
-0.0612379946,
0.0314225443,
-0.011886552,
0.0244093034,
0.0099897441,
0.0355092771,
0.0710524842,
-0.0236280449,
0.0154656591,
-0.010533249,
-0.0224958435,
0.0508640334,
0.0254093017,
0.01356088,
0.0661743432,
0.0171847641,
-0.0230129734,
0.0054732268,
-0.0066308761,
0.0004491053,
-0.0662194788,
0.0344292223,
-0.0154252993,
0.0252922289,
0.0250834879,
-0.0836888924,
-0.0265089571,
0.0414114483,
-0.0626302958,
0.0387347154,
-0.0058353241,
-0.0529397801,
0.0663960949,
-0.0298214462,
0.0145448558,
-0.0120535064,
0.0313462391,
-0.007818508,
0.0166512989,
0.0127370339,
0.0005511961,
-0.0227397159,
0.0207900237,
-0.0093588028,
-0.0131067494,
-0.0188649595,
0.0175353922,
-0.0023721794,
0.025280701,
-0.0319572389,
-0.030525323,
-0.0008275777,
-0.0162796769,
-0.0143256802,
-0.0450368486,
0.0058447509,
0.0330174156,
-0.019123571,
-0.0822225437,
-0.0047876155,
0.0203646999,
0.0130713731,
-0.0076066637,
0.0322798379,
0.0536409728,
0.0243382845,
-0.0357707404,
-0.0562284291,
-0.0801741555,
-0.0001171381,
-0.030170491,
-0.0140387276,
-0.0522323959,
-0.0213056803,
-0.0111614661,
0.0022064818,
-0.0103922486,
-0.022726085,
0.0075160176,
-0.0465819426,
0.0503596254,
-0.0267486461,
-0.010295731,
-0.0083494699,
0.0001989195,
-0.0249500237,
0.0698706731,
0.0146181583,
0.0288472306,
0.0950321928,
0.0067680501,
0.0356136858,
0.0554852188,
0.0573740751,
0.0235258173,
-0.0089083957,
-0.0050628143,
0.0358867198,
-0.0333721191,
-0.0065560313,
0.0192033015,
-0.0027075245,
-0.03857648,
0.0656758845,
0.0482148044,
-0.0385766774,
-0.0166878402,
-0.0059247697,
0.0159921423,
0.0267871264,
0.0302503128,
-0.0406773314,
-0.0487114079,
-0.0820990875,
-0.0251866858,
0.0059999712,
0.0347357504,
0.0128925759,
-0.0161123239,
-0.0354711227,
-0.0530696064,
-0.0174401458,
-0.0026618207,
0.0371621437,
0.0228937473,
-0.0374929421,
0.0550052933,
0.030629687,
-0.0502755716,
0.0120729357,
-0.0680762008,
0.0419663638,
0.0298913214,
0.070171155,
-0.0304704718,
0.0634501129,
-0.0333586074,
0.0029256095,
0.0042013116,
0.0094420854,
-0.0127205309,
0.0437803715,
-0.0278511159,
-0.0385669582,
0.0055699134,
0.049085658,
0.0041194069,
0.0226755459,
0.0131414495,
0.0246887561,
-0.0669180527,
-0.0459296815,
0.0482788794,
-0.0099969283,
-0.0178845022,
-0.0039781434,
0.0019533189,
0.0235623848,
0.0089714415,
-0.0373894721,
-0.0040504141,
0.0377563387,
0.0048130415,
-0.0147079099,
0.010562948,
0.0227002166,
0.0031784207,
0.0543290861,
-0.0298343189,
-0.0184846893,
0.0694357529,
-0.0291058682,
-0.0032311075,
-0.0086459126,
0.0000843247,
0.0690964609,
-0.0516113229,
0.0355839394,
-0.0458727106,
0.0248687714,
-0.0019774372,
0.0428268239,
-0.0127109941,
0.0209002942,
-0.0327144861,
-0.054577399,
0.0555653945,
-0.0146564273,
-0.0458640978,
-0.0059056738,
-0.0407203361,
0.0398714244,
0.0278026331,
-0.016483428,
-0.0487568229,
0.0141933532,
-0.0485265553,
-0.0130095594,
-0.0125248749,
0.0227145907,
0.0077363146,
-0.0308242626,
-0.0327754207,
-0.0225575268,
-0.0010783204,
-0.0303939935,
0.0224344172,
0.0216400754,
0.0153600927,
-0.0026039917,
0.0174842887,
-0.0096495003,
0.0029983518,
-0.0025945494,
0.0470186509,
0.0196040086,
0.0104489233,
-0.0315551274,
0.035119269,
-0.0048260661,
0.0310832132,
0.0081114601,
-0.0316891149,
-0.0071493201,
-0.0153162535,
-0.0516190268,
0.0511983372,
0.0227584559,
-0.0116514182,
0.0540821515,
0.0169487596,
-0.0494881533,
-0.0329388492,
0.0113376239,
-0.0361599736,
-0.0321593583,
-0.001537823,
0.0570607111,
0.0206237976,
0.0088939937,
-0.0340650678,
-0.0140428636,
0.0144957453,
-0.0304029621,
-0.0264036898,
-0.0164874922,
-0.0342901275,
-0.0303346738,
0.0379561335,
0.007963445,
-0.0740668178,
0.0487050526,
-0.0561365113,
0.0395662934,
-0.0223053154,
-0.0180898346,
0.0293640085,
0.0078552561,
0.0087777777,
0.0455204882,
0.0060583763,
-0.0169738419,
0.0019454429,
0.0137715116,
0.0729034618,
-0.039601922,
-0.0075240522,
-0.0124111045,
0.0126269404,
0.0006144167,
-0.0148100117,
-0.0638198033,
-0.0851968452,
-0.0189273506,
-0.0398400389,
-0.0147466036,
-0.0026407952,
-0.0360617377,
-0.0168827754,
-0.0068412712,
0.0634412244,
0.0056042401,
0.0097660981,
-0.0122947199,
0.0451221131,
0.027651811,
-0.0736549273,
0.0415348224,
-0.0419036038,
-0.0345983319,
0.0658513829,
0.036050871,
0.0322447605,
0.0012082262,
-0.0377236567,
0.0159925483,
-0.0284603052,
0.0270877574,
0.0281223673,
-0.0155025031,
-0.0495433919,
0.0022387234,
0.0977960154,
0.0256373007,
-0.0414387323,
-0.013273241,
0.0401683599,
-0.0523149073,
0.0102260793,
-0.0157904997,
-0.1285755485,
-0.0066673206,
0.0258080587,
0.024901608,
-0.0428948551,
-0.0323036611,
-0.0089783538,
-0.1070108041,
0.0114299608,
0.0055681216,
-0.0025239289,
-0.0075832889,
-0.0234932248,
-0.0200866461,
-0.0093028322,
-0.0008782659,
-0.0370260961,
0.02368013,
0.0170237273,
-0.0076037543,
0.0008269872,
-0.0723800361,
0.0210246108,
-0.0641028136,
0.038063135,
0.0525145493,
0.0059956731,
-0.0399022102,
-0.0441539027,
0.0426367335,
0.0153322602,
-0.0404246897,
0.016852716,
0.0788718089,
-0.0158605222,
-0.0151007958,
0.019091405,
0.022682175,
-0.0167064518,
0.013098048,
0.0261488669,
0.0444033109,
0.0150638185,
-0.029680742,
-0.0009165466,
-0.041799847,
0.0292853247,
0.0761363134,
0.0003670451,
-0.005818021,
0.0033772918,
-0.0126975179,
0.0352379531,
-0.0092414953,
0.0098988404,
0.0122698834,
-0.0118003767,
-0.0007130814,
-0.0708900541,
0.0064536938,
-0.0417901464,
0.0416421443,
0.0125552909,
0.0036301804,
0.0208526533,
-0.0161308013,
-0.0537659638,
0.0299848095,
-0.0870342404,
0.0234064702,
-0.078112103,
0.0043525766,
-0.0009152654,
0.0268666297,
-0.0312108211,
0.0201709755,
-0.0676134899,
-0.0759939551,
0.0193952527,
0.0167774707,
0.0255941022,
0.0421268865,
-0.0445831418,
-0.0342871174,
0.0681282878,
0.0458909348,
-0.088869065,
0.0097939176,
0.0496478602,
-0.0658746958,
-0.0145091843,
0.02207537,
-0.0441232994,
-0.0099731386,
0.0439289175,
-0.0633411035,
-0.0126664313,
0.0061391951,
0.0103064384,
0.0622885898,
0.040714778,
-0.0113240629,
0.0127354404,
-0.0509757362,
0.0147382794,
0.0144282728,
-0.0235431343,
-0.0333105512,
0.0262802746,
0.0374203324,
-0.0263400953,
-0.0031138069,
0.019382894,
-0.0180773176,
0.0546061248,
-0.0428907946,
-0.0085677048,
0.0392694697,
0.0415689684,
0.0487032533,
-0.030251788,
0.0017082307,
0.021954231,
0.0104524484,
0.043285124,
-0.0241607781,
0.0088250451,
0.0254440289,
-0.0154865859,
0.0038820924,
0.0253728759,
-0.0439260267,
-0.0068171769,
-0.0352520607,
0.0510514304,
0.0461055301,
-0.0441469811,
0.0214547943,
-0.0365130678,
-0.0353906825,
-0.0202778634,
0.0107766241,
-0.0006139842,
-0.0416538715,
-0.005870529,
0.0004072936,
-0.0575493164,
0.066983752,
0.0650486499,
0.0088524316,
0.0668591931,
-0.0185040887,
-0.0470319688,
-0.0244602263,
-0.0122471927,
0.0166626908,
0.0199970622,
-0.025848709,
0.0214971844,
-0.0455115512,
-0.0864421278,
-0.0288832542,
0.0240207743,
0.0165526941,
0.0215353109,
-0.0265889317,
0.082062833,
0.0219310764,
0.0146761816,
-0.0538185686,
-0.0043992796,
0.0111779589,
-0.0058726533,
-0.005996875,
-5.770371729e-33,
0.0197665412,
-0.0520838983,
-0.0614831783,
-0.0041453596,
0.034890417,
0.0464349315,
0.0097738504,
-0.040717531,
-0.0297019128,
-0.0016678076,
-0.0189715251,
0.0444381163,
0.0172643233,
0.000676879,
-0.0188058037,
-0.0029004561,
0.0506559573,
-0.0135222264,
-0.0721941143,
0.0073613669,
0.0434794314,
0.0121294111,
0.059847381,
-0.0703007206,
0.0310940836,
-0.022845665,
-0.0536133759,
0.0160643198,
-0.0526916943,
0.0643556491,
-0.0107668256,
0.0193478428,
0.0029528944,
-0.017229436,
0.0003428874,
-0.0337049104,
-0.0250354838,
0.0066528851,
0.0092844116,
0.031581331,
0.037242379,
-0.0065155383,
0.0513517112,
-0.0256763287,
-0.016629504,
0.0275738295,
0.0129339509,
-0.0293938722,
-0.009852956,
-0.0170643982,
-0.0209741294,
0.0326832458,
-0.0103313606,
0.0242381897,
0.0586173609,
-0.0042278259,
0.0260494519,
-0.0109774973,
-0.0758097023,
0.0209309291,
0.0689361915,
-0.0047633154,
0.0488752499,
0.0066163605,
0.0020761974,
0.0457900316,
0.0220357627,
-0.0100463685,
0.0586135201,
0.0108433189,
0.0403919443,
0.0057004173,
0.0332200378,
0.0756235197,
0.0505681559,
-0.0446188301,
-0.0330621116,
0.0128842322,
0.0008923951,
-0.0209065061,
0.0229996983,
-0.0189523324,
-0.0623566024,
-0.0106685869,
-0.064467825,
-0.0494566485,
-0.0420064889,
0.0180475041,
0.0203730725,
0.039850343,
-0.0475958064,
-0.0349241868,
0.0056132185,
-0.0599990375,
-0.0327551812,
0.038429454,
0.0003578668,
-0.0151629932,
0.0002800518,
0.0291473083,
-0.0422558673,
0.0006793501,
0.0171744209,
-0.0351516344,
0.0252794586,
-0.0079916362,
0.0537784025,
0.0369346254,
-0.068276532,
0.0566668622,
-0.0126545429,
0.0085539073,
0.0472764969,
-0.0055775922,
0.0319361985,
-0.0130976364,
0.0099727055,
0.0256307423,
0.0292999968,
0.0175307151,
-0.049829945,
-0.0020070097,
-0.0128607219,
0.0095200045,
-0.0203496367,
-0.0356844403,
0.0041451328,
0.0379686877,
0.0865453929,
-0.0335386358,
0.0218895543,
-0.006330166,
2.626e-7,
0.0140462806,
-0.0121237831,
0.0166351013,
-0.0219336431,
-0.0137500484,
0.0684037879,
-0.0184406396,
0.0253244862,
-0.0167388786,
-0.0230055936,
-0.0321451612,
-0.0119251702,
0.0539482944,
0.0265793037,
-0.062797606,
-0.0117557608,
-0.0645522922,
-0.01010984,
-0.0787456781,
-0.0118759358,
-0.009675446,
0.0842442587,
0.0681792796,
-0.0508011542,
0.0132852923,
-0.0924425349,
0.0233452935,
-0.0155101046,
-0.0242300667,
-0.009111817,
0.0734391734,
0.0303844213,
0.0091360277,
-0.0032312309,
-0.0392964594,
0.0335718691,
-0.0385189578,
0.0488821305,
0.0344912671,
0.0195209682,
-0.0401754044,
-0.0498217754,
-0.0086812368,
-0.0344477594,
0.0747070462,
0.0580108389,
-0.0106968507,
-0.0840749964,
-0.0051679313,
-0.0884252042,
0.0215335879,
-0.0251264498,
-0.0084424652,
0.0355140157,
-0.0146873118,
0.0104739694,
-0.0040281294,
-0.0588675253,
-0.0092361486,
-0.0486609861,
-0.0231915656,
-0.0364008397,
0.0116219986,
0.00578178,
0.0182009712,
-0.0741699338,
0.0812188983,
2.593801065e-34,
0.0292391907,
-0.0301892031,
0.0024825849,
0.0131783253,
0.0512348786,
0.0098758228,
0.0211097784,
-0.0142302811,
-0.0291374363,
-0.0371411555,
0.0135937398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16787v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16787v3 | The Data Provenance Initiative: A Large Scale Audit of Dataset Licensing & Attribution in AI | 2023-10-25T17:20:26 | 2023-11-04T19:10:06 | Shayne Longpre, Robert Mahari, Anthony Chen, Naana Obeng-Marnu, Damien Sileo, William Brannon, Niklas Muennighoff, Nathan Khazam, Jad Kabbara, Kartik Perisetla, Xinyi Wu, Enrico Shippole, Kurt Bollacker, Tongshuang Wu, Luis Villa, Sandy Pentland, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The race to train language models on vast, diverse, and inconsistently
documented datasets has raised pressing concerns about the legal and ethical
risks for practitioners. To remedy these practices threatening data
transparency and understanding, we convene a multi-disciplinary effort between
legal and machine learning experts to systematically audit and trace 1800+ text
datasets. We develop tools and standards to trace the lineage of these
datasets, from their source, creators, series of license conditions,
properties, and subsequent use. Our landscape analysis highlights the sharp
divides in composition and focus of commercially open vs closed datasets, with
closed datasets monopolizing important categories: lower resource languages,
more creative tasks, richer topic variety, newer and more synthetic training
data. This points to a deepening divide in the types of data that are made
available under different license conditions, and heightened implications for
jurisdictional legal interpretations of copyright and fair use. We also observe
frequent miscategorization of licenses on widely used dataset hosting sites,
with license omission of 70%+ and error rates of 50%+. This points to a crisis
in misattribution and informed use of the most popular datasets driving many
recent breakthroughs. As a contribution to ongoing improvements in dataset
transparency and responsible use, we release our entire audit, with an
interactive UI, the Data Provenance Explorer, which allows practitioners to
trace and filter on data provenance for the most popular open source finetuning
data collections: www.dataprovenance.org. | [
0.0145370448,
0.1077241674,
-0.0299625397,
0.0478098616,
-0.0542843007,
0.0143518802,
0.054009594,
0.0060632601,
-0.0249067899,
-0.0072691939,
-0.0184017457,
0.0311040003,
0.0158343446,
0.0404236726,
0.0024317179,
-0.0060442532,
-0.005569363,
-0.0040010675,
0.0076626334,
-0.0177928656,
-0.0275869537,
0.033422675,
-0.0095199486,
0.0583001673,
-0.0059792371,
-0.0359828547,
0.0198943652,
-0.0216142982,
0.0228400212,
-0.0045825997,
0.0032347599,
0.046857819,
0.0369635709,
0.1022490263,
0.0000017904,
-0.0435030609,
0.0015717043,
0.0319900103,
-0.0331128463,
0.0245240871,
0.0417801552,
0.0285071451,
-0.0195039213,
-0.0172851216,
-0.0467493907,
0.0202054903,
0.0587858856,
-0.0465635024,
0.0415887684,
0.0605248772,
-0.0189220086,
-0.0346913561,
0.0263090879,
-0.0217685737,
0.0032358919,
0.018739365,
0.0168961473,
0.017678421,
0.0052884696,
-0.0253653377,
0.0133889513,
0.0485498309,
0.04670633,
-0.0092578493,
-0.0373858325,
0.0343244225,
-0.0442617424,
-0.0369497351,
0.0142223267,
0.0651297346,
0.0454847813,
-0.0469774753,
0.0188449528,
-0.0060649267,
-0.0088937031,
-0.0050537335,
-0.029422598,
0.1045894027,
-0.0155966664,
0.0382118225,
0.0081362221,
-0.0376667865,
0.0232586153,
0.0292846076,
0.0236352235,
0.0269339625,
-0.0183409806,
-0.0255172737,
0.0122457035,
-0.0025348542,
0.0414984375,
-0.0491349958,
0.0080640633,
-0.019540878,
0.0382531732,
0.013689965,
-0.0692006052,
-0.0392978191,
0.0422508642,
0.0057763499,
0.0319725573,
-0.0147850141,
-0.0776010528,
0.0428480208,
0.0080282521,
0.0243585669,
0.0050491472,
0.0525202006,
0.0169388782,
0.0063885069,
-0.024648495,
0.0022893655,
-0.0040777149,
-0.0264786631,
-0.0405370966,
0.023069378,
0.0049465983,
0.0177135672,
-0.0631207526,
0.0416824147,
-0.002365052,
0.024724815,
-0.00555526,
0.0268319212,
-0.0180945992,
-0.036443729,
-0.0034880764,
0.0784722641,
0.0317239165,
-0.0618092045,
0.003742663,
0.0145469056,
-0.0005943077,
-0.0286251344,
0.0719168335,
0.0424833111,
0.0277446769,
0.0166747477,
-0.0257845968,
-0.0473178811,
0.0069271745,
-0.048700083,
0.0201684404,
-0.05538477,
0.0314421952,
0.0042465059,
-0.0232534204,
-0.0811807066,
-0.0369161107,
0.0469043218,
-0.044608362,
0.0504454635,
-0.0790756494,
0.0002863176,
-0.002416868,
0.0048013977,
-0.0125998352,
0.0093493275,
0.0377879404,
0.0246016122,
0.0542282797,
-0.0047941208,
0.0359463617,
0.0119127911,
0.0276269484,
0.0214106366,
-0.0511083826,
0.0319510251,
-0.0358837917,
-0.0150782736,
0.0067711473,
0.0514247306,
-0.0097122341,
-0.0240325853,
0.0590235032,
0.0919373482,
-0.0112134703,
0.0445676073,
0.0148802558,
-0.0025631136,
0.0488616116,
-0.0607867837,
-0.0450689718,
-0.0159263555,
0.0227742735,
-0.0143974023,
-0.0633029118,
0.03868673,
0.0076156058,
-0.0407910198,
0.0038030737,
-0.0095100822,
0.0066540027,
0.0168781746,
0.0265763868,
0.0010009968,
0.0014625757,
0.0007198604,
0.0081592901,
-0.0678180829,
-0.0214507747,
-0.0515003763,
0.0348679759,
0.0519428663,
0.0258469023,
-0.0375312343,
0.0124748927,
-0.0341392569,
0.0467641391,
0.0274013095,
-0.0033622419,
-0.0189054739,
0.0463632159,
-0.0189164765,
-0.0271794256,
-0.0468510762,
0.0012171024,
0.00652397,
-0.0114412885,
0.0340576321,
-0.0161299724,
-0.0473273881,
-0.0708535165,
0.0306459013,
-0.0129806027,
-0.0157664251,
-0.0180359147,
0.0081758685,
0.0045439643,
0.0336356349,
-0.0381071866,
-0.0047087995,
0.0498502292,
0.021843385,
0.0122105991,
0.0193792954,
0.048178874,
0.0486174747,
0.0327487886,
-0.0711929426,
0.0015622659,
0.0127888694,
-0.0574874431,
0.0106294164,
-0.010171094,
-0.0120095303,
-0.0025049592,
-0.0140435956,
-0.0181307271,
-0.0530899726,
0.0234004706,
-0.0113657564,
0.039574869,
-0.0266211946,
0.0193558466,
0.0147022149,
-0.034223415,
0.0657019764,
-0.0122914072,
-0.0289099794,
0.0268717632,
-0.0451067239,
0.0659168065,
-0.0067003793,
0.0041295136,
-0.0236837007,
0.0382327251,
-0.0015181609,
-0.0103093209,
-0.012751882,
0.0160473082,
0.001933128,
-0.0514361337,
-0.0387015864,
-0.0063356627,
-0.0055888016,
-0.0731501803,
-0.0102852369,
-0.0071829702,
0.0220738705,
-0.0102412002,
-0.0135909365,
-0.0058725718,
-0.0178587902,
-0.0014494422,
0.0434615724,
0.0205409676,
0.0302587617,
-0.0441605784,
0.0103798015,
-0.0459282994,
0.034410689,
-0.0211437363,
0.0142386816,
0.0279943533,
0.0070845913,
-0.0667494535,
0.055315841,
-0.0328514837,
0.0237145741,
0.0586887226,
0.027019022,
-0.0176810995,
-0.0065772417,
0.0242925044,
-0.0201680437,
-0.0146725131,
-0.0191051345,
0.0097822305,
-0.0058036121,
-0.007123475,
-0.0077321245,
-0.0087274378,
0.0279336832,
-0.0027906427,
-0.024725901,
-0.0075246198,
-0.0075843032,
-0.0325831957,
0.0613307431,
-0.0327901728,
-0.0896371529,
0.0540192686,
-0.0285390187,
0.013195904,
-0.0130169773,
-0.0421423465,
-0.0092634792,
0.079473123,
-0.0180702936,
0.0184617247,
0.0185464025,
0.0081354752,
-0.0245799404,
0.0130072087,
0.0681946203,
-0.064352937,
0.0397161767,
-0.0335579254,
0.020933792,
0.0135746347,
-0.0336803608,
-0.0197423808,
-0.0094347959,
-0.0247082487,
-0.0070410706,
0.0208690986,
-0.0329060331,
0.0056461813,
-0.0596243143,
0.0511881113,
0.0642043129,
0.0457141474,
0.0154176075,
-0.0123832328,
-0.0007950485,
0.0219145454,
0.0073922169,
0.00950321,
0.0003559563,
-0.0490888022,
0.0140667912,
0.028846506,
0.0233026426,
-0.0165586602,
0.0289602149,
0.0044521652,
-0.0018545802,
0.00754763,
0.0310879033,
-0.0012705212,
-0.0443877168,
0.0019567267,
0.0313019194,
0.0140540088,
-0.0547454134,
-0.0018095749,
0.0030778323,
-0.0129836416,
0.0338841043,
0.0110575799,
-0.1267026961,
0.0182662923,
-0.0031815262,
0.0532636009,
-0.0467740186,
-0.0422141142,
-0.0134790633,
-0.0654172003,
0.0829064921,
-0.0234396122,
-0.0645517558,
-0.0337299518,
-0.05224346,
-0.034233585,
-0.0573316179,
0.0119873472,
-0.0334674306,
-0.002588579,
0.0145568112,
0.0376481228,
0.0209993776,
-0.0620775521,
0.0181194972,
-0.0430664644,
0.0680357143,
0.061874751,
0.0353964828,
-0.0335583501,
-0.0415370688,
-0.0014341595,
0.0156890247,
-0.0074078077,
0.013960788,
0.069883056,
0.0274556875,
-0.0159138162,
-0.0356551856,
0.0420379415,
-0.0364521183,
-0.0404775701,
-0.0078867795,
0.0839030966,
-0.0198529381,
0.0006422133,
-0.0088510532,
-0.0575434864,
0.0314466879,
0.0433145836,
0.0265401248,
-0.0122733228,
-0.0076356283,
-0.0434686728,
0.0068601398,
-0.030652659,
-0.0233295243,
0.0245450269,
-0.0403038226,
-0.0504119471,
-0.0350581482,
-0.0176543463,
-0.0083658202,
0.0314620659,
0.0221486054,
-0.0115641505,
0.0211278368,
-0.0413822494,
-0.1018460914,
0.0544865876,
-0.0248953197,
0.0237601642,
-0.0351081677,
-0.0499867164,
-0.0065867663,
0.0190489274,
-0.0389134698,
0.0250517484,
-0.0712909177,
-0.0212234557,
0.0132991169,
0.0382815674,
0.0279209111,
0.0223856699,
0.0152397603,
-0.0627854317,
0.0447198078,
0.0792955011,
-0.0398641229,
0.003749338,
0.0283002015,
-0.0460528769,
-0.0100265518,
0.0029056792,
-0.0426777601,
-0.0278406385,
0.0413681343,
-0.0503584296,
-0.0040054875,
0.0312722512,
0.0255689807,
0.0278919823,
0.0345340408,
-0.041085761,
-0.0120623689,
-0.0348313414,
-0.0094556212,
0.0324805304,
-0.0249272268,
-0.0459714904,
-0.0004556348,
0.0282298531,
-0.0319179371,
-0.0202155635,
0.0690164194,
0.0353779159,
0.0134226019,
-0.0865628496,
0.0635014623,
0.0207410045,
0.0736842081,
0.0337094106,
0.0217314214,
0.0017607707,
0.0511715598,
-0.0513133183,
0.0616806708,
0.0192758869,
0.0106000872,
0.0173931904,
0.0094397236,
0.0301601831,
0.0488193296,
-0.0627833158,
-0.0694671646,
0.0032122531,
-0.0067791934,
0.0588875748,
0.0109797679,
0.0300301891,
-0.0059236363,
-0.0050118864,
-0.0133546768,
0.0325104408,
-0.0103376051,
-0.0598056093,
-0.0336109363,
-0.0025908272,
-0.0387653336,
0.0321178213,
0.0708127171,
-0.002989867,
0.0700493231,
-0.0344666466,
0.0015268559,
0.0049398146,
-0.0374837965,
0.0032375343,
-0.0451576486,
-0.0004524429,
-0.0444491394,
-0.0361738801,
-0.0999746174,
-0.0230897516,
0.0218567215,
0.0059513068,
-0.0028995359,
0.0207185708,
0.0427256748,
-0.0036322947,
-0.0326575004,
-0.0259509068,
0.0099947061,
-0.0318630859,
-0.058234375,
-0.0362815335,
-5.501485111e-33,
0.0472384579,
0.007405167,
0.0115944585,
0.0130874887,
-0.0197218098,
0.0302197151,
-0.021544002,
-0.0307919942,
-0.0410288833,
0.0199630037,
-0.0376424678,
0.027836984,
0.0080998838,
0.0068332143,
0.0303238109,
-0.0440375917,
0.0144358017,
-0.0273896437,
-0.0272349473,
0.031667944,
0.0046450528,
-0.0036131942,
0.0877699256,
-0.1300216764,
0.0503230542,
0.0130045041,
-0.0247432813,
0.0044279299,
-0.0621179789,
0.0706895366,
0.0089741144,
0.0470227785,
0.0123616429,
-0.0413620248,
-0.0179433376,
-0.0452324413,
-0.0341416784,
-0.016464889,
-0.0072296471,
0.0024462065,
0.0201007575,
-0.0181133263,
0.0867551416,
-0.0232980754,
-0.0193238091,
0.0176322889,
0.053385295,
-0.0489309952,
-0.0183056667,
-0.0503663421,
-0.0123009793,
0.0112360157,
-0.0478510857,
0.0145829404,
0.0452404581,
0.0234646425,
-0.004990763,
0.0070901103,
-0.085621722,
0.0346325673,
0.0339519717,
-0.0419111103,
0.0932282507,
0.002606554,
0.0485037938,
0.0489142165,
0.0577830933,
0.0013769588,
-0.0181385279,
0.0052756495,
0.0105429925,
0.1117048934,
0.005390116,
0.0290866159,
0.004958075,
-0.0394293517,
-0.0179361496,
0.0243544355,
0.0028547295,
-0.0216009393,
-0.0312397555,
-0.0118264025,
-0.0392162353,
-0.0337430388,
-0.0465098806,
-0.0742211044,
-0.0069509814,
0.0264677089,
0.0184435844,
-0.0201683678,
0.0049401135,
0.0104511417,
0.0033019069,
-0.0776354596,
-0.028776776,
0.0167256687,
-0.0122041572,
0.0355601721,
0.0342777781,
-0.011859295,
-0.0804210827,
-0.0204523373,
0.0181316976,
0.0047942875,
0.0924667194,
0.0067588282,
0.0566219166,
0.0621443167,
-0.0313180648,
0.0333068892,
-0.0353196561,
0.0018449848,
0.0598119833,
0.0362441838,
0.0304736439,
0.0198258553,
0.0261542648,
0.0039280597,
0.0284093171,
0.0185928438,
-0.0300487783,
-0.0031639556,
-0.0348454155,
-0.0069052433,
-0.0186006632,
-0.0336452648,
-0.0214617159,
0.0337608755,
0.0821779966,
-0.046330452,
-0.0099641588,
-0.0136792744,
2.575e-7,
0.0309115015,
0.0036293827,
0.022902023,
-0.0005836841,
-0.0081077572,
0.0294962954,
-0.021165153,
0.0415798537,
-0.0406350717,
-0.0020379769,
0.0108620236,
-0.0086086653,
0.0538164265,
0.0445686951,
-0.0312319342,
-0.0331747197,
-0.0599366985,
-0.0029865967,
-0.0883464217,
0.034113422,
-0.0019777464,
0.0449399911,
0.0541858077,
-0.0501638465,
0.0221741069,
-0.0371785983,
-0.0123519795,
-0.0490050465,
0.0740800127,
-0.0159867778,
0.0204261243,
0.0311784502,
-0.0126090134,
-0.0012177541,
-0.0108806398,
0.0347611271,
-0.0525595136,
0.0350263864,
-0.0004108503,
0.0006637261,
-0.015702473,
-0.0712186471,
-0.0080548367,
-0.0382590629,
0.0446922146,
0.0343393609,
-0.0260392632,
-0.0208260473,
-0.013287494,
-0.0390696935,
0.0303342063,
-0.02029429,
0.0434015542,
-0.0231361818,
-0.0005943225,
-0.0283406284,
-0.0068795984,
-0.069257237,
-0.0028520476,
0.004801807,
-0.0307837371,
-0.0151823331,
-0.0186747368,
0.0178379994,
0.0279183052,
-0.0361396112,
0.0515194274,
2.320260774e-34,
-0.018088514,
-0.0410399549,
0.0118062999,
0.0028050372,
0.0237938147,
0.0112708863,
0.0386516489,
-0.0118444422,
-0.0407170393,
-0.0123655163,
-0.0161517318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16781v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16781v3 | Kiki or Bouba? Sound Symbolism in Vision-and-Language Models | 2023-10-25T17:15:55 | 2024-04-02T05:50:21 | Morris Alper, Hadar Averbuch-Elor | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Although the mapping between sound and meaning in human language is assumed
to be largely arbitrary, research in cognitive science has shown that there are
non-trivial correlations between particular sounds and meanings across
languages and demographic groups, a phenomenon known as sound symbolism. Among
the many dimensions of meaning, sound symbolism is particularly salient and
well-demonstrated with regards to cross-modal associations between language and
the visual domain. In this work, we address the question of whether sound
symbolism is reflected in vision-and-language models such as CLIP and Stable
Diffusion. Using zero-shot knowledge probing to investigate the inherent
knowledge of these models, we find strong evidence that they do show this
pattern, paralleling the well-known kiki-bouba effect in psycholinguistics. Our
work provides a novel method for demonstrating sound symbolism and
understanding its nature using computational tools. Our code will be made
publicly available. | [
-0.018621305,
0.038396854,
-0.0643132851,
0.048432216,
-0.0614464581,
-0.0024138729,
-0.0225540735,
0.0551449843,
-0.0412338711,
0.0060465201,
-0.0445636213,
-0.0189825781,
0.0771166682,
0.0454728156,
0.0321011208,
-0.0774618983,
-0.0129057253,
-0.0445830747,
0.0224164259,
-0.0210919343,
-0.0112924073,
-0.0179582965,
-0.0243452992,
0.0395638235,
-0.0202398933,
-0.0212062374,
-0.0143729663,
-0.0012421373,
0.0025373334,
0.014298615,
-0.0834672004,
0.0150873251,
-0.0057606762,
-0.0070998888,
0.000001916,
-0.028558718,
0.0789761916,
0.0040111458,
0.00752758,
0.0209841635,
0.0285101794,
-0.0233314894,
-0.038783405,
-0.0429333709,
0.0011320674,
0.0555614531,
0.0591224134,
-0.0261235926,
-0.0240693763,
-0.0116424309,
-0.0017490842,
-0.0306381825,
0.0013634642,
-0.0000933153,
0.0689436272,
0.0369642228,
0.0513561517,
-0.0066144681,
-0.0118002351,
-0.0315859616,
-0.0700336099,
0.0195916817,
0.0043551056,
0.0563165247,
-0.0181136765,
0.0247295089,
0.0036440131,
-0.0468710177,
-0.0040451344,
0.0542683601,
0.042858772,
-0.0227584988,
-0.0173375625,
0.0245551411,
-0.0177738406,
0.0385572203,
-0.0232391302,
-0.0030871073,
0.0225714073,
-0.0065792506,
-0.0044788308,
0.0091263466,
0.0136259804,
-0.0342752375,
0.0224606544,
0.0503739528,
0.0306423735,
-0.0094752116,
0.0149024054,
-0.0614391007,
0.0049969275,
-0.0666813999,
-0.0136069935,
0.0110500352,
0.0705473498,
0.0113414014,
0.031658899,
-0.0119367158,
-0.0007464263,
-0.0509693213,
0.0331618972,
0.0334231965,
-0.0347877033,
0.048428636,
-0.0282711107,
0.0090985922,
-0.0347771607,
0.003883956,
-0.0177651756,
0.0218483098,
-0.0562491342,
-0.0412074998,
-0.0194494184,
-0.0177156702,
-0.0146817686,
-0.0598674379,
-0.0311653987,
-0.0137291169,
-0.0413550511,
-0.0263956673,
-0.0341660045,
-0.0183426514,
0.006105938,
-0.0015224136,
-0.0121047823,
0.023989372,
-0.0442676581,
0.0545622446,
-0.0593694188,
-0.022765575,
0.0077592647,
0.0219126735,
-0.0065755262,
-0.0010411178,
-0.0081289615,
0.0746839046,
0.0335545801,
0.0183470491,
0.0278554838,
-0.0407317132,
-0.0416653939,
-0.0092746029,
-0.0281517506,
-0.044859767,
-0.01386113,
0.0058487966,
-0.0053535299,
-0.0723307431,
0.0049652588,
-0.0204119962,
-0.0390521772,
0.0767742693,
-0.0005116083,
0.0270091686,
-0.0218333025,
0.0336626023,
-0.010365163,
0.0543796383,
0.0285968687,
-0.0400409289,
-0.019272944,
-0.0352073424,
-0.0225807186,
0.036221467,
0.0098025361,
0.0075748721,
-0.0856516957,
-0.0548738204,
0.0029740604,
0.0263794772,
0.0329792537,
0.0236141793,
-0.0176694524,
-0.0674049035,
0.0085921697,
0.1030795351,
-0.0160538349,
-0.0200017039,
0.0448675193,
-0.0147533501,
-0.0096308403,
0.0268721431,
0.0432060696,
0.0180133954,
-0.0141774938,
0.0018387361,
-0.0073786699,
0.0171352606,
-0.0210287701,
-0.005495524,
-0.0272555426,
0.0209691413,
0.0014052632,
-0.0050929291,
0.0368264839,
0.019145567,
-0.0028133341,
0.0274582021,
0.0286897756,
-0.00743812,
-0.0091324765,
-0.0251502078,
0.0602844767,
-0.002990043,
-0.0101075685,
-0.0129657043,
0.0724845454,
0.0343135744,
-0.0199939329,
0.0496039502,
-0.0240990166,
0.016808372,
0.014033108,
0.0018054809,
-0.0023632678,
0.02023503,
0.03551732,
0.0369406044,
-0.0507792719,
0.0747284889,
0.0017668183,
-0.0571833439,
0.0415099673,
-0.0170176495,
-0.0071332664,
0.0173917338,
-0.0304192398,
0.0049495553,
0.0142023815,
0.0145157501,
-0.027625924,
0.0569591261,
0.0111089461,
-0.0292780306,
0.0375360101,
0.1004075184,
-0.0098082693,
0.0287006963,
0.0494533554,
-0.0661100075,
0.0305262171,
0.0038003083,
0.0413571447,
-0.0191936996,
0.1056878865,
-0.0109941447,
0.0616902076,
-0.022786472,
-0.0119727841,
-0.0356808528,
0.0364564732,
0.0309066586,
0.034789484,
0.0359053463,
-0.0140195275,
-0.0282158423,
0.0008468309,
0.0401676334,
-0.0042912466,
-0.0199645087,
0.0207838658,
-0.0180024076,
-0.021853717,
-0.0546637662,
-0.0760326535,
-0.0516489334,
0.0141367037,
-0.0596472248,
-0.0454450175,
0.0083229868,
-0.0383600667,
-0.0000426577,
-0.0360844396,
-0.0256826412,
0.0063760788,
-0.0047107111,
0.0367246605,
-0.0205757245,
0.0286272038,
-0.0274172351,
-0.0174877588,
-0.0930884704,
-0.0027611847,
-0.0163113717,
-0.0176385418,
0.0376551263,
0.0030359796,
-0.0440393686,
-0.0001472566,
0.0084865512,
-0.0683340356,
-0.0419790857,
0.0027552214,
0.0009313329,
0.0361801609,
-0.0032689134,
0.056040965,
-0.012146079,
-0.028731253,
0.0337155499,
0.0211173818,
-0.0541365594,
-0.0005995234,
-0.036458157,
-0.01516636,
0.068569243,
-0.0073098708,
-0.03788203,
-0.0172216985,
0.103084743,
0.0527784638,
-0.0157533959,
-0.0450032167,
0.0460113324,
-0.0480704196,
-0.0445724428,
-0.0796858668,
-0.0352945849,
-0.0165900961,
0.0790641159,
-0.011650471,
-0.013653948,
0.0288669616,
-0.0085634058,
0.0179355294,
0.0118502639,
-0.007696731,
-0.0148072848,
0.0992164165,
-0.0298051648,
0.0027114176,
0.068941921,
-0.0059987712,
-0.0377911776,
-0.0411579199,
0.0315388702,
-0.0335828178,
-0.019751979,
-0.0421849415,
-0.0110903904,
0.0178528912,
0.016888177,
-0.0065259668,
0.0242303871,
-0.0443579182,
-0.0002681891,
-0.0290666632,
0.0235413034,
0.0491441563,
0.0540468507,
0.039661862,
-0.0583353341,
0.0328373984,
-0.0054210429,
0.0048201489,
0.0295913443,
0.045017492,
-0.0279229283,
-0.0112560019,
-0.024640128,
-0.0389278643,
0.007301874,
0.013271519,
0.0856237188,
-0.0381358489,
0.0288023409,
0.0297320858,
0.0076960162,
-0.0379358381,
0.0311538782,
0.0239454247,
-0.0304430332,
0.0135579612,
0.0299669076,
0.0342527218,
-0.0226017479,
0.0535656847,
-0.0426874571,
0.0289956536,
0.0097704548,
-0.0069067534,
-0.0763207823,
-0.0212148521,
0.0162057076,
-0.0488281325,
0.0053276741,
-0.0142986104,
-0.0080279699,
-0.0866453275,
0.0306671876,
0.0190283954,
-0.0607829206,
0.007405533,
-0.0009474636,
0.048789788,
0.0332788788,
-0.0176024474,
0.006022789,
0.0049347505,
0.000714276,
0.0167003591,
-0.0022328401,
-0.0517308749,
0.0014986289,
-0.0019419636,
0.0252238568,
0.0143580772,
0.0298537109,
-0.0483869761,
-0.0669387951,
-0.013767641,
0.0141047332,
0.0360713713,
0.0004416518,
0.0011173107,
0.0535879284,
-0.020965375,
-0.0313849822,
0.0099281566,
-0.0175954252,
-0.0460416973,
-0.0047107534,
0.036087051,
0.0118694175,
-0.0340149961,
-0.0273078252,
0.0359865576,
-0.0111427391,
0.0883815885,
0.0456029363,
-0.0524559394,
0.0230405461,
-0.0293528531,
0.0233242046,
0.0778835341,
-0.1161849499,
-0.0317784138,
0.0633330792,
-0.0394707285,
-0.0799244419,
0.0107593061,
-0.0143655976,
0.0424437486,
0.0478398353,
0.0237948634,
-0.0308435448,
-0.0500900298,
-0.0513303131,
0.0040808865,
-0.0447468236,
0.0504411943,
-0.0097127585,
0.0124785611,
-0.0118407197,
-0.0663403496,
-0.0245340206,
0.0216951706,
-0.0765565187,
-0.075170517,
-0.0156243201,
0.0158336032,
0.0358214825,
0.010937579,
0.0053751259,
-0.0077583417,
0.0635298193,
0.01755004,
0.0373756997,
0.0529520214,
-0.0136245163,
-0.0290506929,
0.0268740579,
0.0232206509,
0.0089431852,
0.0374374986,
0.0067872871,
0.0123876594,
-0.0180801544,
0.0478705019,
0.0109536434,
-0.019823147,
0.0278419722,
0.0006908315,
-0.0547208451,
-0.0001224615,
-0.0141860666,
0.0005846159,
0.008500021,
-0.0164957475,
-0.044150833,
0.0595879927,
0.019856615,
-0.0140172122,
-0.0723020062,
0.0043567643,
-0.0089348713,
0.0314958803,
-0.0153495092,
0.0414893851,
-0.0293443892,
0.0137118865,
0.020662114,
0.0221813601,
0.0432997495,
-0.0691355914,
0.0568415709,
0.0225110203,
-0.0135078067,
0.0014131078,
-0.0112272901,
0.0227371268,
-0.0278683156,
0.0108906915,
-0.0392779969,
0.0721193478,
0.0143321166,
0.0734175667,
-0.0402914956,
0.0321158022,
-0.0696468353,
0.0138489716,
0.0039327024,
0.0141208861,
-0.0424483344,
-0.0060944362,
0.0178677123,
0.0376691073,
0.0018927015,
-0.0170040224,
0.0327010117,
-0.0798153728,
0.0094036078,
-0.0258431733,
-0.0064682923,
-0.0033959143,
0.0206828602,
0.0223665684,
0.0234544668,
0.0091045741,
0.0290004257,
-0.0952442139,
-0.0887839049,
0.0115312561,
-0.0278948173,
0.0379490219,
-0.0021467397,
0.0359362066,
0.0210647769,
0.0272106007,
0.0274943337,
0.019985402,
-0.0445636287,
-0.0569082536,
-0.0032203216,
0.0501855239,
-5.944622971e-33,
-0.032594122,
-0.0032654738,
-0.0190876778,
0.0283074137,
-0.0059372559,
0.0344361775,
-0.0419765115,
0.0006376516,
-0.0292830113,
0.0235912036,
0.0476609431,
-0.0134442812,
0.0057431064,
-0.0371724181,
0.0238114092,
0.0250532273,
-0.0111996988,
0.0295916516,
-0.0039888206,
-0.0671762601,
0.0519612096,
-0.0073573971,
0.0356510356,
-0.0211746134,
0.0081812646,
0.0302267857,
-0.0037179841,
-0.0174496211,
0.0207923688,
0.0359932221,
-0.0499901921,
0.0455664359,
0.001870299,
0.0127194393,
-0.0030272673,
-0.0209211316,
-0.0122698108,
-0.0374420211,
0.0669758245,
0.0249758996,
-0.0276997685,
0.014760186,
0.0486550592,
-0.0160638411,
-0.023059722,
-0.0005763947,
0.0431431904,
-0.034720663,
-0.0052335737,
0.0007113009,
-0.073783882,
-0.0129545275,
-0.0152790565,
-0.0034655835,
0.0467352718,
-0.0046695066,
-0.0276195444,
-0.0211513527,
-0.0661568716,
0.0933380127,
-0.0021086577,
0.0097120842,
0.0491870344,
0.0215363353,
0.0437936187,
0.0475408807,
0.080666922,
-0.0598639883,
-0.0062696589,
0.0189631842,
0.0536844097,
0.0231881775,
0.0219138898,
0.0220246296,
0.0722407028,
-0.0280119777,
0.0128307426,
-0.0369992852,
-0.000876927,
-0.0128534148,
0.0517999008,
0.0283042546,
-0.039660383,
-0.0246910248,
-0.0398435481,
-0.0066600614,
-0.0383726396,
-0.0375139713,
0.0186685249,
-0.052806098,
0.0320628211,
0.0073920446,
0.0380940959,
-0.0144561771,
0.018218901,
-0.0276172478,
-0.0177344102,
0.0528589264,
0.0327944309,
-0.0172877125,
-0.0048315809,
0.0234428197,
0.0235483851,
0.0063077053,
0.0640986189,
0.0213942733,
-0.0236818846,
-0.0042187641,
-0.0177395511,
-0.0289458465,
0.0063979975,
-0.0509498045,
0.0617679358,
-0.0663195103,
0.0670025572,
0.0293373894,
-0.0272417367,
-0.0516114756,
0.0340203606,
-0.0025448615,
-0.0037921902,
0.0281598326,
-0.1132701635,
0.041633185,
-0.042180568,
-0.0284408685,
-0.0092840251,
-0.0427646488,
0.073118329,
-0.0288406778,
-0.0545383655,
0.0094144586,
2.911e-7,
0.0114423027,
0.0254750736,
0.0342951864,
0.0825491399,
0.0470820144,
0.0046438454,
-0.0316807106,
-0.004077876,
0.0412966236,
-0.0759415999,
-0.0072994181,
0.030992927,
0.0340311117,
0.012529131,
-0.0633277595,
0.0054204618,
0.0204266347,
-0.0160092581,
-0.0507174693,
0.0327409804,
0.005983863,
0.0124961603,
0.0082442891,
-0.0289966129,
0.0016821034,
-0.0020413126,
0.064420931,
-0.0379100218,
0.056385003,
-0.0201311409,
-0.0509222597,
-0.0506558456,
0.00357903,
0.0494237095,
0.0090599116,
-0.0128521603,
0.0588094182,
-0.0313782841,
-0.0198517069,
0.0102336435,
-0.0358645469,
0.0494339652,
-0.0206403658,
-0.0263319481,
0.0582965575,
-0.0077804388,
-0.0422269516,
-0.0042026849,
-0.0167292841,
-0.0152859017,
0.056985978,
0.0119330054,
-0.0075183013,
-0.0192196071,
0.0099727139,
0.0138783269,
-0.0424914174,
0.0005840878,
-0.012217775,
-0.0225123912,
-0.0110682826,
-0.0086580943,
-0.0217764229,
-0.0627050996,
-0.0001459395,
-0.0595378466,
-0.064913474,
2.082116409e-34,
0.0194022693,
-0.001036669,
0.0301921573,
-0.0170297716,
-0.0153211998,
-0.0017024401,
-0.0012803616,
0.0168302543,
0.0494728871,
-0.0159016401,
-0.0194681324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16776v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16776v5 | DEFT: Data Efficient Fine-Tuning for Pre-Trained Language Models via Unsupervised Core-Set Selection | 2023-10-25T17:06:42 | 2024-06-13T02:31:28 | Devleena Das, Vivek Khetan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances have led to the availability of many pre-trained language
models (PLMs); however, a question that remains is how much data is truly
needed to fine-tune PLMs for downstream tasks? In this work, we introduce
DEFT-UCS, a data-efficient fine-tuning framework that leverages unsupervised
core-set selection to identify a smaller, representative dataset that reduces
the amount of data needed to fine-tune PLMs for downstream tasks. We examine
the efficacy of DEFT-UCS in the context of text-editing LMs, and compare to the
state-of-the art text-editing model, CoEDIT. Our results demonstrate that
DEFT-UCS models are just as accurate as CoEDIT, across eight different datasets
consisting of six different editing tasks, while finetuned on 70% less data. | [
0.0406716876,
0.0371549837,
-0.0237292144,
0.0139016798,
-0.0050672526,
0.0151226977,
0.0199423693,
0.0153566655,
-0.0160764549,
-0.0626030043,
-0.0742591396,
-0.0066684275,
-0.0053161024,
0.0006189439,
0.0350543894,
-0.0183182675,
0.0659181252,
-0.02590473,
-0.0127449241,
0.016988026,
0.0199619904,
0.0316395164,
0.0105008502,
0.0347872041,
0.0068849409,
-0.0323848277,
-0.0127933631,
0.0319825076,
-0.0252165161,
0.0386900045,
0.050580848,
0.1063304171,
0.0247857794,
0.0571222007,
0.0000019797,
-0.0377712585,
-0.0466508158,
-0.0308428966,
-0.0128676109,
0.0373093747,
0.0420371927,
0.0097020958,
-0.029145414,
0.0086687356,
-0.0289075002,
0.0015667848,
0.0412656777,
0.0096997712,
0.0634566918,
0.0840777904,
-0.0124978879,
0.0171893779,
-0.0274498053,
-0.052667357,
-0.0314665958,
-0.027644977,
0.0374140739,
-0.0092784259,
-0.0251271892,
0.0029802716,
-0.0105636036,
0.021111628,
-0.0269364864,
-0.0623093769,
0.0018135011,
0.0136847785,
-0.0666852146,
-0.0201552995,
0.0043968116,
0.0747803599,
-0.0562154837,
-0.043287389,
0.0001186584,
-0.0298761893,
-0.0084680459,
-0.0222816858,
-0.0355077088,
-0.0253009722,
0.0084887762,
0.0148351723,
-0.0125551363,
-0.0623858571,
0.0228976496,
0.0224944651,
0.0102762487,
0.0105498666,
0.0268671848,
0.0013561717,
-0.0110384887,
-0.0025765006,
-0.0306878686,
-0.0815393552,
0.0214550551,
0.0146449143,
-0.0331501625,
-0.0145322019,
-0.0874483809,
-0.0319747366,
-0.0013572916,
-0.0059335222,
0.0880683884,
0.003763302,
-0.0106426291,
0.0650144443,
-0.0146239074,
0.0193855409,
0.0081484672,
0.0521049574,
-0.008389269,
0.0244858079,
-0.0484859273,
0.00422,
-0.0596472733,
0.0081396727,
-0.0454328172,
0.0090619903,
-0.0186539721,
0.0093503008,
0.0247138906,
-0.0360185653,
0.0422350541,
-0.0227600634,
-0.050456427,
-0.0295963753,
0.0307233371,
0.0199580584,
-0.0034776018,
0.0593528859,
0.0044851308,
-0.0588101894,
-0.0056309239,
-0.0063118772,
0.0457119942,
-0.065039672,
0.0256327018,
0.0253350921,
-0.0313414335,
-0.0399815962,
-0.0402032994,
-0.0129956445,
0.0086898357,
-0.0451646559,
-0.0370676368,
-0.0565826818,
0.0403693505,
0.0109124482,
0.0004680109,
-0.0836094245,
-0.0235099047,
0.0148303388,
-0.0378193222,
0.0545672365,
-0.0549684465,
0.0395987779,
0.0348438881,
-0.0156651847,
0.0117495181,
0.0645496398,
0.0287829451,
0.0364864618,
0.073520489,
-0.0094789173,
0.0204844773,
0.07542862,
-0.0041418117,
0.0078916922,
-0.0136357965,
-0.0112048006,
-0.0074525522,
0.0009051535,
0.0207409915,
0.0262467377,
-0.0187798142,
0.0194114484,
0.0921301469,
0.0472177006,
0.0530930534,
0.0264908131,
0.0001198376,
-0.0074609248,
0.0255264658,
-0.0022714788,
-0.0430866331,
0.0352393501,
-0.0393561535,
-0.0099562118,
0.0271886103,
-0.0108006969,
-0.0274799224,
-0.025263818,
-0.0135037191,
0.0017494487,
-0.0096559767,
-0.0231209621,
0.0378577113,
0.0046105878,
-0.0424131453,
0.001522742,
0.0095790355,
-0.0747778788,
0.0146186268,
-0.0437161699,
-0.0250850618,
0.0669822171,
0.0709673092,
-0.0447454378,
-0.053017322,
-0.0277305022,
0.0773198158,
0.0063014291,
0.0632544234,
-0.0294861328,
0.028721571,
-0.0503356531,
-0.0374261402,
-0.04161622,
0.0238666814,
-0.017669769,
0.0350970216,
-0.0170887522,
0.0252139736,
-0.0352729037,
-0.0534922965,
0.0470203236,
-0.029433772,
-0.0168946423,
0.0080318274,
0.0182634145,
-0.0267413445,
-0.0368546098,
-0.0428014956,
-0.0102614677,
-0.0156478509,
0.0035530466,
0.0341163501,
-0.0286337472,
0.0154254483,
0.0051878439,
0.021144893,
0.0100811627,
-0.0122528477,
0.032678321,
-0.0555741861,
-0.0391754359,
-0.0356823877,
0.0050149988,
0.0166193489,
-0.0612998977,
0.0275803823,
-0.0411216468,
-0.0226217657,
-0.0303991977,
-0.0009305999,
0.0166187398,
0.00357061,
0.0078006424,
0.0239212494,
0.0151971728,
-0.0119797727,
-0.0500521287,
-0.016739795,
0.0019848095,
0.0102859782,
0.0208571535,
0.0561570004,
-0.029595403,
-0.037383683,
-0.0615588352,
0.0103650624,
-0.0597602017,
-0.0002049982,
0.0622108094,
0.0190582909,
-0.0397383347,
-0.0189960878,
0.0242756251,
-0.0016528445,
0.0045820544,
0.0398147218,
0.0295026451,
-0.0173681993,
0.0286452342,
-0.0893770233,
-0.0229624454,
0.0203777645,
-0.0037718804,
0.0061491854,
-0.0424642861,
-0.0188211184,
0.0454682186,
-0.0107416827,
0.0366286077,
0.0003231607,
-0.0711518824,
-0.0165901482,
-0.0346688703,
0.0332293771,
0.0829397738,
0.0023955111,
0.0013093336,
0.0523444116,
-0.0044084443,
-0.0124474773,
-0.0055960352,
-0.0018111804,
-0.0430464707,
-0.021367684,
0.0216401089,
0.0277244914,
0.0824049115,
-0.0100133829,
-0.0257553644,
-0.0440132432,
0.0493954383,
-0.0044989665,
0.0252364371,
-0.0170408785,
0.0127163269,
-0.0319790468,
0.0724186525,
-0.05417303,
-0.0818889514,
0.0453874059,
-0.0323235914,
0.0109752845,
-0.0032080712,
-0.0049135732,
-0.0038729487,
0.0196560938,
0.0141403116,
0.0052760257,
-0.0033825752,
-0.0191012677,
-0.0846669227,
0.0228101145,
0.0296579748,
-0.0171104725,
0.0533606745,
-0.0564105287,
0.0325854383,
-0.0338718519,
-0.0275090709,
-0.0229222849,
-0.0239681937,
-0.0391060188,
0.0029072075,
0.0423613377,
-0.0039425031,
-0.0047988715,
0.0159459114,
-0.0102632754,
0.1217213571,
-0.0259566028,
-0.0010860055,
-0.0206179395,
-0.0012579502,
0.0461151078,
-0.0159178637,
-0.0153037515,
-0.0291174911,
0.0202771332,
0.0098685957,
0.0154372491,
-0.0311245862,
-0.0085443268,
0.0165762026,
0.0238734093,
-0.0584580749,
-0.0303683691,
0.0057803234,
0.0673688054,
-0.0252434406,
-0.0455397852,
0.1400383115,
0.0293913148,
-0.0564092658,
-0.0156839173,
0.0213320162,
0.0001130728,
0.0530032814,
0.0316435583,
-0.0404323898,
-0.0608171076,
0.0275352485,
0.0341046266,
0.019140413,
-0.0401000455,
-0.0168900713,
-0.0621285811,
0.0341467895,
0.0072061354,
-0.0387488455,
-0.00871001,
-0.0209179576,
0.0495737307,
-0.0349018872,
-0.0361131094,
0.023475904,
-0.0346654467,
-0.0050604665,
-0.0080037601,
-0.0316677727,
-0.0778006464,
0.0277216677,
-0.0227184203,
-0.0036668237,
0.0674467012,
0.0185796488,
0.020580234,
0.0230809059,
0.085052833,
-0.0077718333,
0.0194263086,
-0.036248982,
0.0495102666,
-0.0050801765,
-0.0004130594,
0.0250964966,
0.0408726074,
0.0199791696,
-0.0220175777,
0.0034378523,
0.0580499656,
-0.0275224652,
0.0219340809,
0.0386780612,
-0.0582462437,
0.0063354359,
0.0490290001,
0.0561804324,
-0.0446297228,
-0.0255699717,
-0.0276118889,
-0.0227004252,
-0.0563120842,
-0.0366937704,
-0.0172087364,
-0.0281414799,
0.023065472,
-0.0525875948,
-0.0202493202,
0.0900359601,
0.0157163776,
0.03621573,
0.0248199664,
0.0357830673,
-0.004433034,
-0.0496483408,
0.0230249576,
-0.0415803008,
0.0087251719,
-0.0972559825,
-0.046104297,
0.0391054749,
-0.0033439442,
-0.0028888478,
-0.000800665,
-0.067395784,
-0.0627664998,
0.0067299129,
0.0544728301,
0.0174451005,
0.0228154566,
-0.0154008409,
-0.1137815118,
0.0247753989,
0.0258433316,
-0.0464998409,
0.0175389759,
0.0181131512,
-0.0631379932,
-0.0287297387,
0.0598365292,
-0.0448461138,
0.0292501133,
0.0635817572,
0.0132620679,
0.0156075796,
-0.0617890209,
-0.0109398728,
0.0094676595,
0.0680179,
0.0005131152,
0.023194205,
-0.0822245181,
0.0302118175,
-0.0078946762,
-0.008934103,
-0.0431302935,
-0.0053138603,
-0.0120603498,
-0.012831253,
-0.0359827429,
0.028461514,
-0.0414388664,
0.0394045226,
-0.0550077818,
0.018389998,
-0.003566928,
0.0444650427,
0.0603490211,
-0.0000851394,
0.0055853948,
0.0431485176,
0.0092404746,
0.0103056775,
-0.0333130471,
0.0450765565,
-0.0030945737,
0.0310623702,
-0.0309452787,
0.0583941378,
-0.046406813,
-0.0339542367,
-0.0619860813,
0.0080754682,
0.0517953411,
-0.0632113144,
0.0617334172,
-0.0126438225,
-0.0387167893,
-0.059906479,
0.0605373383,
0.0383548252,
0.0029686764,
-0.0263056327,
-0.0034475182,
-0.0187221374,
0.0145912971,
0.1000883579,
-0.0054804054,
0.054467123,
0.0224014632,
-0.0062232423,
-0.0228132289,
-0.026079338,
0.005470485,
-0.0078371176,
-0.0138044059,
-0.002981005,
-0.0067910547,
-0.0433208309,
0.0112511553,
-0.0036600311,
-0.031398017,
0.020249933,
0.0211429987,
0.055643186,
-0.0223732032,
0.0331819244,
-0.0392749608,
-0.0147530502,
-0.0053625419,
-0.0078533972,
-0.0111819021,
-5.991492869e-33,
-0.0266148411,
0.0077897222,
0.0147370975,
0.0199275669,
0.0032811963,
0.005585521,
-0.041657079,
-0.0007047316,
0.0155974124,
-0.0209142268,
-0.0505208671,
0.013117685,
0.0026901702,
0.020317914,
0.0110406075,
0.0418848284,
0.0709999129,
-0.0340097211,
-0.0447920524,
0.0171003044,
-0.010273817,
0.0488634855,
0.074099876,
-0.0079829972,
-0.0382372588,
0.0188750289,
-0.0068625533,
0.0243316218,
-0.0077020554,
0.0484465621,
0.0211897157,
0.0058573722,
0.0129442988,
-0.0127983121,
-0.0460644178,
-0.0106547847,
-0.0372761786,
-0.0311194658,
-0.0082787834,
0.0160767548,
0.0296815075,
-0.0220134016,
0.0274332948,
-0.0259879306,
-0.0140860034,
0.0017324279,
0.0333874859,
-0.0286172647,
0.0084768785,
-0.0033545748,
-0.0458902568,
0.0254609957,
0.006537721,
-0.0407379046,
0.0485564731,
-0.0043972894,
0.0076841568,
-0.002266909,
-0.0597729646,
0.0191218946,
0.0535600632,
0.0668950677,
0.0616487451,
0.0160753503,
0.0077698394,
0.046767965,
0.0019449319,
0.0412863381,
0.0159608033,
0.0393355265,
0.0383561514,
0.0670466051,
0.016391011,
0.0736309141,
0.001298136,
-0.0327182822,
-0.0481652953,
0.0373101681,
-0.0390355177,
0.0071474472,
0.0073689832,
0.0287071932,
0.036237143,
-0.0240687653,
-0.0425457545,
-0.0010720114,
-0.0282051526,
-0.0052998993,
0.039046701,
0.0009630441,
-0.0215983763,
-0.0218884442,
0.0478702225,
-0.0006282115,
-0.0293901004,
-0.0009194355,
-0.0450426824,
0.0380828492,
-0.0076507209,
-0.0092569664,
-0.0265241601,
-0.041658245,
0.0416653901,
0.0113302898,
0.0216327887,
0.0015629241,
0.0563695692,
0.0342256315,
-0.0570121929,
0.0142299822,
-0.0101354411,
0.0248674806,
0.0079777101,
0.0287809465,
0.0081262216,
-0.0226391517,
0.0041524735,
0.0424897037,
0.0252523907,
-0.023767978,
-0.0423547328,
-0.028211046,
0.0304317158,
0.0384058505,
-0.0168170538,
0.001683395,
-0.0449765362,
-0.0010092398,
0.0327212848,
-0.0334213562,
-0.0024062975,
-0.018711023,
2.494e-7,
0.0551697016,
0.0680423602,
0.0132112997,
-0.0125664743,
0.0262382813,
0.0233110562,
-0.0501813479,
0.0143312356,
0.0105494317,
-0.0017667139,
0.0305918697,
0.0335803106,
0.0582593083,
-0.0006780816,
-0.0405435376,
0.0280882195,
-0.0559443273,
0.0633942261,
-0.0585691668,
-0.052691862,
-0.0106951967,
0.0568494424,
0.0127273547,
-0.0120371003,
-0.0109261256,
-0.0130616631,
0.0521912053,
-0.0385404192,
0.0099957045,
0.0433930717,
0.0012230719,
0.0548258834,
-0.0228157528,
-0.0010677204,
-0.0430202,
-0.0017305632,
0.01744348,
0.0878742039,
-0.0401464142,
0.0234237053,
0.0166994724,
0.0081948889,
-0.0081042461,
-0.0401613526,
0.101049982,
-0.061121285,
0.0272299405,
-0.0397546329,
0.0198466312,
0.0035298853,
0.0162774976,
-0.0378394723,
0.0078838645,
0.0452258475,
0.0274877548,
0.0299404897,
-0.0461946651,
-0.0707803145,
-0.0148537839,
0.016201539,
-0.0115095777,
-0.0318299048,
-0.0828986987,
-0.0198455565,
0.0061530704,
-0.0308167301,
0.0144700818,
2.222368498e-34,
-0.0051416615,
0.0067512714,
0.0363622196,
-0.0204591602,
0.0104550514,
0.0008337856,
0.0270349234,
-0.0091262637,
-0.0212522484,
-0.0668810606,
-0.0345041268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16763v1 | SuperHF: Supervised Iterative Learning from Human Feedback | 2023-10-25T16:52:00 | 2023-10-25T16:52:00 | Gabriel Mukobi, Peter Chatain, Su Fong, Robert Windesheim, Gitta Kutyniok, Kush Bhatia, Silas Alberti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While large language models demonstrate remarkable capabilities, they often
present challenges in terms of safety, alignment with human values, and
stability during training. Here, we focus on two prevalent methods used to
align these models, Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning
from Human Feedback (RLHF). SFT is simple and robust, powering a host of
open-source models, while RLHF is a more sophisticated method used in top-tier
models like ChatGPT but also suffers from instability and susceptibility to
reward hacking. We propose a novel approach, Supervised Iterative Learning from
Human Feedback (SuperHF), which seeks to leverage the strengths of both
methods. Our hypothesis is two-fold: that the reward model used in RLHF is
critical for efficient data use and model generalization and that the use of
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) in RLHF may not be necessary and could
contribute to instability issues. SuperHF replaces PPO with a simple supervised
loss and a Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence prior. It creates its own training
data by repeatedly sampling a batch of model outputs and filtering them through
the reward model in an online learning regime. We then break down the reward
optimization problem into three components: robustly optimizing the training
rewards themselves, preventing reward hacking-exploitation of the reward model
that degrades model performance-as measured by a novel METEOR similarity
metric, and maintaining good performance on downstream evaluations. Our
experimental results show SuperHF exceeds PPO-based RLHF on the training
objective, easily and favorably trades off high reward with low reward hacking,
improves downstream calibration, and performs the same on our GPT-4 based
qualitative evaluation scheme all the while being significantly simpler to
implement, highlighting SuperHF's potential as a competitive language model
alignment technique. | [
0.0371982865,
0.05666795,
0.0202156194,
0.0158822741,
-0.013473128,
0.0269621592,
-0.0465321988,
-0.0060390285,
-0.0442093499,
-0.0127326977,
-0.104071252,
-0.0310090892,
0.0086817779,
0.001274151,
0.043725878,
-0.0729750246,
0.0306530129,
-0.0562617593,
0.0217210744,
-0.0109276213,
0.0280964989,
-0.0085589709,
-0.0134733245,
0.0412640236,
0.000464878,
0.0092097223,
0.0160147436,
0.0268880483,
0.0533963889,
-0.017326707,
0.0254504699,
0.0612077974,
0.0313907154,
0.0614813194,
0.0000021136,
-0.0272894297,
0.0049696802,
0.0029471472,
-0.007533351,
-0.0029822232,
0.0337741449,
-0.0022408317,
-0.0322455987,
0.0177562479,
-0.0225762799,
0.0109425737,
0.0446358509,
0.0484979562,
0.0821766853,
0.0931479335,
0.0195879638,
-0.014357008,
0.0073136506,
-0.038133055,
-0.0101821627,
-0.0424203835,
0.0034834321,
0.0403991863,
-0.0119880866,
-0.0084060468,
-0.02167622,
0.0123551684,
0.0163099989,
-0.0005600136,
0.0159950536,
0.0433471091,
-0.0039945641,
-0.0280581918,
-0.020298345,
0.0626769587,
-0.027163649,
-0.0311364196,
0.0104035325,
-0.0146983862,
-0.0153125878,
-0.0269459896,
-0.0213015862,
0.0226390902,
0.0282005239,
0.0337147564,
0.0131692728,
-0.0246317051,
0.0370710641,
0.0290388279,
0.0163937975,
0.0437568724,
0.0085152416,
-0.0496487543,
0.0268715061,
0.0078501627,
-0.0491492525,
-0.0363639183,
-0.0135070588,
-0.0051731481,
-0.0745362118,
-0.0038297393,
-0.0561779849,
-0.0174400713,
0.0008316129,
-0.0143387066,
0.0755509883,
0.0376129523,
0.0272288695,
0.0411673971,
0.0245254487,
0.0262456145,
0.0187019128,
0.0633294582,
-0.0200062208,
0.0419996046,
-0.0510326587,
-0.0065293196,
-0.0185823832,
-0.0065445742,
-0.0092190225,
-0.0118248826,
-0.0512418598,
0.0202414859,
-0.0221451353,
0.0190822575,
0.0048534181,
0.0112717059,
-0.044249177,
0.0090444302,
0.0089705959,
0.028886443,
-0.0493921265,
0.0090884604,
0.0406814516,
-0.0237029921,
-0.0178121179,
0.0262413789,
-0.0186597817,
-0.0110164145,
0.0077610509,
0.0862350687,
-0.0146402959,
-0.0337684453,
-0.0042618397,
-0.0208788998,
-0.0223229919,
-0.080553852,
-0.0164971352,
-0.040950112,
-0.0093208039,
-0.0403862335,
-0.0201671869,
-0.0488679931,
0.004607596,
-0.0121691516,
-0.0175872073,
0.066483058,
-0.0194442179,
-0.0081961825,
0.0188890435,
-0.0085854186,
-0.0126121333,
0.0631187856,
0.0522735827,
0.0213307906,
0.0101021938,
-0.0005947122,
-0.0008167161,
0.0439870916,
0.0551916696,
0.0465896465,
-0.0427111126,
-0.0108630192,
-0.0001604382,
0.0704054385,
0.0595323145,
0.0284237079,
-0.0609409101,
0.0464470834,
0.1001550704,
0.0336199142,
-0.0128674675,
0.0179086402,
-0.0175978616,
0.0287333261,
0.0010337873,
-0.0118489144,
-0.0700072497,
0.0307238866,
-0.0290704686,
-0.005558765,
0.0307441428,
-0.004736674,
-0.0409147628,
-0.0391009338,
-0.0055351113,
0.0083658099,
0.0344139673,
0.0271333978,
0.0522388183,
-0.0045951032,
-0.0264514498,
-0.0016944178,
0.0599579327,
-0.0210732315,
0.0150540611,
-0.0459332056,
0.0580308959,
0.0749196485,
0.0392661393,
-0.011263432,
0.0063962229,
-0.0332171917,
0.0000704157,
0.035280697,
0.0227798503,
-0.0196761079,
-0.0072518187,
-0.0339153484,
-0.0478776656,
0.0153295072,
0.0084237186,
0.0232819561,
0.035365019,
-0.0296307951,
-0.0008664639,
-0.0103728836,
-0.0410981439,
0.0305171888,
-0.0058069457,
-0.0392080806,
0.0083561754,
0.0138419401,
0.0341286622,
-0.0024297014,
-0.0243651848,
0.0031976732,
0.0129025653,
0.0049513159,
-0.0006206224,
-0.0024933121,
-0.0396313556,
-0.0213123038,
0.0440107211,
-0.0129381288,
-0.0074041379,
0.0654243827,
-0.0384954028,
-0.0336286612,
0.0363975652,
-0.0089306654,
0.0171474554,
-0.0379798599,
0.0074460129,
-0.0322533362,
-0.0074173571,
-0.0525809079,
0.0062590213,
0.0040510115,
0.0043601068,
-0.0415936336,
0.021366097,
-0.0188542865,
-0.0546188802,
-0.0286207013,
0.0110884933,
-0.0219238065,
0.0583957285,
0.0239762831,
0.0540967025,
-0.0627030581,
-0.018249169,
-0.0677944422,
-0.0118658701,
-0.0561472587,
0.0286723338,
0.0366989486,
-0.0043055047,
-0.0328027122,
-0.0194913112,
-0.0037712913,
-0.0330448635,
-0.004535412,
0.0191023517,
0.0157492664,
0.0135077955,
0.0195997693,
-0.0622899197,
-0.0232397933,
0.014366392,
-0.0049962173,
-0.0027595472,
0.0388852768,
-0.0656072944,
-0.0064374022,
-0.0239730086,
0.010672112,
0.0024684491,
-0.0511281565,
0.0380542539,
-0.0092572365,
0.0239407159,
0.0919086635,
0.010578719,
0.0210094657,
0.0092327883,
0.0129628498,
-0.0674086735,
0.0111075975,
-0.0395431928,
-0.0784219801,
-0.0254350565,
0.0463826954,
0.0029396249,
0.0683196709,
-0.0124706076,
0.0316581912,
-0.0807865113,
0.028840065,
-0.0288901553,
-0.0358903147,
-0.0454200804,
0.0224190634,
-0.0542473495,
-0.0134499781,
-0.0146727897,
-0.0576320104,
0.0972452834,
-0.01174899,
0.0146777937,
-0.0438109413,
-0.03040196,
0.0113460841,
0.0151602589,
-0.023584133,
0.0125184916,
-0.0023978294,
-0.0115010524,
-0.0515083298,
-0.0435278937,
0.0371781625,
-0.0113706887,
0.0151306847,
-0.0358549543,
0.0028803241,
-0.0048156125,
-0.0601802319,
-0.0244553369,
-0.0530551486,
-0.0208991431,
0.0146810059,
-0.0171243679,
-0.047077246,
-0.0059756795,
-0.0006649495,
0.0122755254,
0.0178752895,
-0.0425588898,
-0.0263848659,
-0.0257222578,
-0.004328737,
0.0759634376,
0.0068230866,
0.0251747873,
-0.0340555869,
-0.0037842963,
0.0343666784,
0.0952481553,
0.0456529781,
-0.0093524158,
0.0148465903,
0.0197969545,
-0.0240159538,
0.0207991842,
0.04105689,
0.0672383606,
-0.0552314296,
-0.0406555235,
0.0937335044,
-0.0015745662,
-0.0573214851,
0.0060943686,
0.0101961037,
0.0818148404,
-0.0009390353,
-0.0005549262,
-0.0504036434,
-0.0617346652,
0.0124767963,
0.0743746907,
0.0193874408,
-0.015245148,
0.016760109,
-0.0794240534,
0.0128773516,
0.025471488,
-0.0606079362,
-0.0175051,
-0.0432533622,
0.0108913668,
-0.0540040694,
0.0213058852,
0.0336224437,
0.0134835904,
0.0051250621,
0.0344966948,
0.0351650454,
-0.087882705,
0.0432701968,
-0.0658365339,
0.0474171229,
0.122324869,
0.0053190994,
0.0163035821,
-0.0156296324,
0.0218188837,
-0.0010662229,
-0.0153921293,
-0.0090767806,
-0.0021802234,
-0.0377174579,
-0.0156865604,
-0.0005709641,
0.0968554541,
-0.0266770218,
0.0112404181,
-0.0173383318,
0.0509986468,
-0.0065267542,
0.0091801072,
0.0156549308,
0.000365815,
0.0610440038,
0.055004701,
0.0087829176,
-0.0598428659,
-0.0360471122,
-0.0201547369,
-0.0063774385,
-0.0212820042,
-0.0240338463,
-0.0055426438,
0.0427025966,
-0.0216740798,
-0.0459870175,
-0.0286854561,
-0.0104738176,
0.0272830911,
-0.0058684759,
-0.0322075188,
-0.0140191363,
0.0122642787,
-0.0264593866,
0.046056252,
-0.0597801283,
0.0368127525,
-0.0789505839,
-0.0123989126,
-0.0043951315,
-0.0269585326,
-0.016636163,
0.0227923375,
-0.1070653051,
-0.0832865313,
-0.009729201,
0.0554625839,
0.0081537841,
0.0848365501,
-0.0249345656,
-0.0711486936,
0.0691535622,
0.0373995528,
-0.0368372947,
0.0163862929,
0.0279289074,
-0.0004504423,
0.0028197139,
0.0457802266,
-0.0367190167,
0.0086107953,
0.0569978952,
0.0442013927,
0.0086814631,
-0.0012366276,
0.0101971412,
-0.0040287245,
0.0841924399,
-0.0360735022,
-0.0449862219,
-0.0145899411,
-0.0081784781,
0.0111181447,
-0.0158259347,
-0.0389854759,
-0.0116123697,
0.03485322,
-0.0148663195,
-0.0133768367,
0.0070702429,
0.027044557,
0.0307609402,
-0.0568645149,
0.01533389,
-0.0059917131,
0.0024735336,
0.0238695983,
0.0269473419,
0.0025431933,
0.0200472269,
-0.0002768793,
0.0282385144,
-0.0070405207,
0.0526009761,
0.0507560633,
0.0017742747,
0.0020477057,
0.0278490502,
-0.0599931404,
-0.056924101,
-0.0676994994,
0.0416068025,
0.0779629126,
0.0211798418,
0.0345814638,
-0.0451086983,
-0.0168082211,
-0.0152278012,
0.0138250124,
-0.0603542961,
-0.0133553725,
0.0377481617,
0.0265182387,
-0.0163522772,
-0.0045259199,
0.0479693115,
0.0179615915,
0.0377775729,
-0.0290513579,
0.0112515818,
-0.0269225426,
-0.0279719643,
0.0076427041,
0.0135162463,
-0.0137295639,
0.0071691573,
-0.0050060651,
-0.0602585524,
-0.0725577697,
0.0599922836,
-0.0085831163,
-0.0136581017,
0.0663673654,
0.031930387,
-0.0760835931,
-0.0137485405,
-0.0304228049,
-0.0439152457,
0.0095029622,
-0.0276697967,
-0.0334133022,
-6.759529654e-33,
-0.0264789425,
0.0090262108,
0.0148975225,
0.0146044604,
-0.0454506204,
-0.0388286859,
-0.0142060518,
0.003293311,
-0.0067471904,
0.0086933486,
-0.014505242,
0.0051255766,
0.0178146474,
0.0286487248,
0.0078576431,
-0.0134845674,
0.047855448,
-0.0306352042,
-0.0672902465,
0.0301363412,
0.0157979149,
0.0273347385,
0.078670837,
-0.0222830027,
0.0252682846,
0.0259407423,
-0.0568569973,
0.0400197655,
-0.0087746223,
0.0375410169,
-0.0029399879,
0.0164085161,
-0.0215830561,
-0.0450274572,
-0.0136739546,
0.0119207324,
-0.0740520135,
-0.0206505433,
-0.0094426684,
0.0130767589,
-0.0407830104,
0.0002511705,
0.0513841324,
-0.0337649547,
-0.032492958,
-0.0120070986,
-0.0020686442,
0.0016266195,
-0.0351237357,
-0.0076701194,
-0.0382950231,
0.0318142064,
-0.0170719884,
-0.0398362726,
0.0228226576,
0.0023318653,
-0.0225048177,
0.0151196849,
-0.0670789778,
0.0274390969,
0.0195483584,
0.0429209359,
0.0708351582,
0.0693973228,
0.037964046,
0.0436660685,
0.0031316476,
-0.0106151262,
0.0111281602,
-0.0220986828,
0.0490309894,
0.0035005312,
0.0326651037,
0.0208918415,
0.0195582025,
-0.0133081619,
-0.042361062,
-0.0007660303,
-0.0277709644,
0.0398929231,
0.021236755,
0.0517770536,
-0.0711429119,
-0.0160532501,
-0.0594956055,
-0.0291340649,
-0.0151448734,
-0.0404434688,
0.0392471068,
0.0297425948,
-0.0307198185,
-0.0076747946,
0.0105669387,
-0.0391388386,
0.0118415765,
0.0229197014,
-0.0305452831,
0.0075944662,
-0.0137212984,
-0.0067070671,
-0.0894839764,
-0.0242641177,
-0.0004983002,
-0.0014459317,
0.0033731787,
0.0116660278,
0.0456066579,
0.0471456945,
-0.0392264016,
0.0142762726,
-0.0097925635,
0.0315644443,
0.0142629705,
-0.0009641052,
0.0470973328,
-0.0181619506,
0.0091563165,
0.0434615389,
0.0340015776,
-0.000154764,
-0.0155828306,
-0.01932339,
-0.0215008855,
0.0110429041,
0.0007344261,
0.0146495458,
-0.0250232983,
-0.038915202,
0.0080933571,
-0.0513565689,
-0.0097372457,
0.0171951633,
2.841e-7,
-0.0229825396,
0.0665132701,
0.0059950468,
-0.013389633,
0.0211073682,
0.0847663507,
-0.0258456897,
0.01259463,
0.0133435354,
0.0146725895,
0.0361871943,
0.029535491,
0.0687279552,
0.015591844,
-0.0827163979,
0.0064603346,
-0.1109529436,
0.0286374092,
-0.0220475346,
-0.0407188907,
0.0336072147,
0.0916612148,
0.0434176661,
-0.0303557366,
0.0333983228,
-0.0147877224,
0.0748137385,
-0.0282282829,
-0.031911362,
0.0239903536,
-0.0049056518,
0.0223809723,
-0.0119220857,
-0.009871386,
-0.0207989961,
0.0091405679,
-0.039692916,
0.0618943162,
-0.0214712359,
-0.0311246421,
-0.0366588607,
0.0146451807,
0.0381116234,
-0.0544974767,
0.0439926013,
-0.0711697415,
-0.0125968996,
-0.0343048573,
0.0241686385,
-0.0637625605,
0.0506182052,
-0.0551030859,
-0.0385897122,
0.0064966176,
0.0125213983,
0.0451839678,
-0.0212331936,
-0.0725969896,
-0.0253896005,
0.0538565889,
-0.0302672237,
-0.0331872702,
-0.0529270656,
0.008222674,
0.0042074947,
-0.0505232848,
-0.0022946703,
2.397240501e-34,
0.0346307084,
-0.0244844817,
0.0137408786,
-0.0201045647,
0.0279077366,
0.0459975228,
0.0412848927,
-0.0007460235,
0.0460300297,
-0.0346307978,
-0.0128317773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16761v1 | IntenDD: A Unified Contrastive Learning Approach for Intent Detection and Discovery | 2023-10-25T16:50:24 | 2023-10-25T16:50:24 | Bhavuk Singhal, Ashim Gupta, Shivasankaran V P, Amrith Krishna | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying intents from dialogue utterances forms an integral component of
task-oriented dialogue systems. Intent-related tasks are typically formulated
either as a classification task, where the utterances are classified into
predefined categories or as a clustering task when new and previously unknown
intent categories need to be discovered from these utterances. Further, the
intent classification may be modeled in a multiclass (MC) or multilabel (ML)
setup. While typically these tasks are modeled as separate tasks, we propose
IntenDD, a unified approach leveraging a shared utterance encoding backbone.
IntenDD uses an entirely unsupervised contrastive learning strategy for
representation learning, where pseudo-labels for the unlabeled utterances are
generated based on their lexical features. Additionally, we introduce a
two-step post-processing setup for the classification tasks using modified
adsorption. Here, first, the residuals in the training data are propagated
followed by smoothing the labels both modeled in a transductive setting.
Through extensive evaluations on various benchmark datasets, we find that our
approach consistently outperforms competitive baselines across all three tasks.
On average, IntenDD reports percentage improvements of 2.32%, 1.26%, and 1.52%
in their respective metrics for few-shot MC, few-shot ML, and the intent
discovery tasks respectively. | [
0.038899675,
0.0671686903,
-0.0063574933,
0.0207315665,
-0.014401379,
0.0076994719,
0.0268507283,
-0.0251433719,
0.0509249531,
-0.0351407863,
-0.0505198836,
-0.055132132,
-0.0219146293,
0.031551078,
-0.0058508916,
-0.0390732959,
0.0478523746,
-0.0078305723,
0.0617852136,
0.0238221083,
0.0055393516,
0.0139446408,
-0.0406083912,
0.0452562198,
-0.0067909267,
-0.0329689644,
-0.0427287817,
0.0251363479,
0.0286218412,
-0.0421629511,
0.0624160282,
0.0585262626,
0.0290270019,
0.0230717566,
0.000002138,
-0.0498934425,
-0.0184152126,
-0.020062821,
-0.0557147749,
-0.0177137367,
0.0265525784,
0.0072652451,
0.014818321,
0.0269167665,
-0.0270084571,
-0.008490568,
0.0428191684,
0.0471717604,
0.0265783668,
0.0553162768,
-0.0253956746,
-0.0605285056,
0.0034528994,
-0.0040853187,
0.0224018171,
-0.0610493198,
0.0055029532,
0.0130973756,
-0.023713965,
0.0417862199,
0.0125842392,
0.0379079692,
-0.0201859102,
-0.0203205273,
0.0171343107,
0.0268799402,
0.0515233949,
-0.0276215971,
-0.0432399362,
0.0850430951,
0.0148361931,
0.0369459465,
-0.0033162595,
-0.0249229241,
-0.0360686332,
-0.0516763441,
-0.0188993663,
-0.0136540355,
-0.0147261713,
0.0077315546,
0.0457428172,
0.0339638032,
-0.0230859667,
0.0200310387,
-0.0028972968,
-0.0140772834,
-0.0200934783,
-0.0221325029,
0.0040321224,
-0.0055588009,
-0.0254447386,
-0.0465862714,
0.0201896653,
0.0002847344,
-0.087994568,
0.0194952823,
-0.0260878727,
-0.0339943878,
0.0251672119,
0.0061143534,
0.034652058,
0.0384641476,
-0.0519184694,
0.06658943,
0.0377904922,
0.0223966781,
0.0052745305,
0.0038426656,
-0.0626251176,
0.0014399812,
-0.0582534634,
0.0262584891,
-0.0640864,
0.0605979674,
-0.0588689074,
-0.0216098484,
-0.0091932248,
0.0415982455,
-0.0006972327,
-0.022632651,
0.0457796529,
-0.0002568306,
-0.037026044,
0.0165771134,
0.003626446,
0.0660653263,
-0.0021107034,
0.0416344367,
0.0102058696,
-0.0286423489,
-0.0366232991,
0.0440636352,
0.0253979601,
-0.035310667,
0.0025769274,
0.0576773323,
-0.0502101779,
-0.0814805627,
-0.0524576642,
-0.0140720336,
-0.0540088862,
-0.0329429284,
-0.0353402868,
-0.0039369091,
0.0370542668,
-0.0129326396,
-0.0054953429,
-0.0351974815,
0.0026822772,
-0.0188277289,
0.0004020399,
0.0725011751,
-0.0034202512,
-0.0184377301,
-0.0187487565,
0.0115054576,
-0.0632601157,
0.0466984808,
0.010994371,
0.0223040432,
0.0072855903,
-0.0042818617,
0.0042769765,
-0.0060912827,
0.0022274889,
-0.015498993,
0.0274767671,
0.0323759094,
0.002501497,
0.0028133853,
0.036442589,
0.0472290628,
-0.039743904,
-0.0270794798,
0.0555051453,
0.0422419049,
-0.0235168319,
-0.0092122648,
0.0246171355,
0.0844941735,
-0.0244317874,
-0.0020666628,
-0.0064612757,
0.0237267409,
-0.023616612,
-0.0203950945,
0.0833035037,
-0.0094592664,
-0.0585009344,
-0.0318137668,
-0.000872369,
-0.0162642468,
0.0431333072,
-0.0073696245,
0.0368690677,
0.0034391009,
-0.077487953,
0.0359733142,
-0.0034007665,
-0.0329033211,
-0.0346571617,
-0.064331457,
0.0252962559,
0.0478432439,
0.015087341,
-0.0329473801,
-0.0515109226,
-0.061015971,
-0.0153336823,
0.0296395179,
-0.0047188182,
-0.0322777927,
0.0789470598,
-0.0517527722,
-0.0425062925,
-0.0295411758,
-0.0132063059,
0.0215762388,
-0.0318216272,
-0.006811698,
-0.028457636,
-0.0143517489,
0.0245963465,
-0.0056311786,
0.0207540318,
-0.0322972536,
0.0621234588,
0.0061965454,
0.0607119612,
0.044357527,
0.011917254,
-0.0486033671,
0.019444149,
-0.003677465,
-0.0021505689,
0.0189733822,
-0.0305009019,
-0.0895186141,
0.0204986185,
0.014318509,
-0.0339486599,
0.0300940815,
-0.0284551978,
-0.0386846028,
0.0360187478,
-0.0483157337,
0.0256168488,
-0.0503983684,
-0.0208538454,
0.0255838651,
0.0234643035,
0.0080849845,
0.0532385856,
0.0023677032,
-0.0188721623,
0.0424697101,
-0.0077189291,
0.0363112316,
-0.0190613829,
0.008188026,
-0.0326382592,
-0.0496175624,
0.0004011245,
0.0098523628,
0.036110267,
-0.0455184393,
-0.0071719326,
-0.0696057826,
0.0164978299,
-0.0326733328,
-0.012229071,
0.0136912642,
0.0086543309,
0.0238043778,
-0.0102008171,
-0.0167974047,
-0.0189090539,
-0.0167978611,
-0.0143655809,
0.0076888944,
0.0030501934,
-0.0142777087,
-0.0142945126,
0.041442588,
0.0160290506,
0.0052977665,
-0.0351752974,
-0.0207228772,
-0.0513431542,
0.060171593,
0.0034981507,
0.0101352893,
-0.015796097,
-0.0639010519,
0.0221490934,
0.0040701381,
-0.0017927043,
0.0499209724,
0.0334706791,
0.0434355326,
0.0005278322,
-0.0096587157,
-0.0654544383,
0.0498977527,
-0.0194505341,
0.020792529,
-0.0212843921,
-0.0201402903,
-0.0068683447,
0.1058313921,
0.0381953269,
0.0309353396,
-0.0390237495,
-0.0619670115,
0.0296291262,
-0.0482453071,
-0.022383377,
0.0262942202,
-0.0187669862,
-0.0038845909,
0.0024794887,
-0.0377046987,
0.0868282169,
0.0133420713,
-0.0625107661,
-0.0766063407,
-0.053452611,
0.012917472,
0.0464576893,
-0.0563979149,
0.012687359,
0.0625662357,
-0.0535337888,
0.0084236348,
-0.0304714236,
-0.032563176,
-0.0187194981,
0.0430165157,
-0.0093058757,
0.0069924048,
0.0043253778,
-0.0453537293,
-0.0663062334,
-0.0770587921,
-0.0105691887,
0.0310238786,
0.0306447987,
-0.0266784839,
-0.0414556153,
0.0337859355,
0.0132516231,
0.0383715518,
0.0214871578,
-0.0205433611,
-0.0204298329,
0.0541490093,
0.0241067857,
0.0018720514,
-0.0247640349,
0.0223431811,
0.0599197857,
0.0542133637,
0.0068556424,
-0.0271599963,
-0.0190252326,
0.0132901855,
0.0318516754,
0.0293624215,
0.0002999083,
0.0069466848,
0.0784974545,
0.0113946181,
-0.0112150693,
0.1138785705,
0.0342317,
-0.0297737774,
-0.0163774211,
0.0107892714,
-0.005204279,
0.0168555118,
-0.0067259772,
-0.0762743056,
-0.0785501599,
-0.0012349376,
0.0218065232,
0.0064581553,
-0.0113014616,
-0.0108541688,
-0.0620216988,
0.0499181896,
-0.0025669776,
-0.054899659,
0.0010943705,
-0.0500135794,
0.014145623,
-0.051754456,
0.0057428945,
-0.0249510054,
0.0348074622,
-0.0379309058,
0.0194397233,
-0.0127080139,
-0.0478732139,
0.0317567028,
-0.0017269815,
0.0593767427,
0.0187873244,
0.0442317538,
0.0386469886,
-0.0519233644,
-0.0153787266,
-0.0682616532,
-0.0098843183,
-0.0621073768,
0.0441220589,
-0.0334802903,
-0.00548136,
0.0070095826,
0.050013449,
-0.0621488132,
-0.0418099314,
-0.0099457214,
0.0548804663,
-0.0555975512,
0.0197157077,
-0.0015886498,
0.0185079444,
0.091280885,
0.1010896489,
-0.0161100589,
-0.0418022163,
0.022991037,
-0.014386286,
0.0132961338,
-0.0447182432,
0.0263010859,
-0.023523109,
0.0180446841,
0.0358761251,
-0.01650309,
-0.0591891445,
0.0252417512,
0.0010259437,
-0.0312149618,
0.0039676819,
-0.0372749008,
0.0049225655,
-0.0444751903,
0.0107042165,
-0.011437932,
0.0215901081,
-0.0379324891,
-0.0930327699,
0.0452221036,
-0.0561808199,
-0.0339525938,
0.025982853,
-0.0385850631,
-0.0472075827,
-0.0232408233,
0.0347011872,
0.0038412006,
0.0572910495,
-0.011028748,
0.0159164481,
0.0132500716,
0.0188836157,
-0.0150213437,
-0.0198508352,
0.0823192373,
0.0473342836,
-0.001497542,
0.0185002442,
-0.015076207,
0.0502399132,
0.0121537801,
0.0260750689,
-0.0609935038,
-0.0991572067,
0.0171667784,
-0.0079668611,
0.1024044156,
0.002473746,
-0.0238600373,
-0.0368147008,
0.0305866376,
0.0293049179,
0.0033283569,
-0.0587260872,
-0.0049013975,
0.0151203899,
-0.014058847,
-0.028036477,
0.0657208934,
-0.047626067,
-0.0062690959,
0.0013549237,
0.0072084204,
0.019770762,
0.0077649406,
-0.0256127603,
0.0119644757,
-0.0286782384,
0.0175299477,
0.021690663,
0.0241506882,
0.0266971905,
0.1052830741,
0.0129807452,
-0.0207454991,
0.0325908437,
0.0412761606,
-0.0421668664,
-0.0072735199,
-0.0267978404,
-0.0060706958,
0.0087348009,
0.0015484658,
0.0064771632,
-0.0260634944,
0.0455694534,
-0.0151982233,
0.080692336,
-0.0432198457,
-0.0310296733,
0.033663772,
0.022077173,
-0.0192120299,
0.0149797015,
0.0498031303,
-0.0957915187,
0.0231866296,
0.0095007904,
0.0162329227,
-0.0725545809,
-0.0135274278,
0.0288647879,
0.0464419872,
-0.0076620323,
0.0024556811,
0.0049771834,
-0.0256918631,
0.0331640691,
-0.0171247683,
0.000503578,
0.0109416461,
0.0507988483,
0.0307028331,
-0.020144226,
-0.0341550298,
-0.0304695759,
-0.0404035971,
-0.0359025784,
0.0150291482,
-0.0254748948,
-6.272509855e-33,
0.0071304734,
0.0005455904,
0.0131638991,
-0.0316111408,
0.0136699704,
0.0125393709,
-0.0316688418,
-0.0192680527,
-0.008969632,
0.0124989152,
0.016515065,
0.0242863297,
0.0120072644,
0.0416622907,
-0.0137866121,
-0.0179302208,
0.0566036925,
-0.0143461116,
0.022075614,
0.034062922,
0.0357164741,
0.0117901014,
0.0361193046,
-0.0835024789,
-0.0144491531,
0.0456369594,
-0.0104317013,
0.0457498096,
0.0359607004,
0.0525620393,
-0.0465590693,
0.034669511,
0.0049456563,
-0.0316480845,
0.0019706595,
0.0204763561,
-0.061874155,
-0.0044599716,
0.005295156,
-0.0030310799,
-0.0555470772,
-0.0324361064,
-0.0334068574,
-0.0028374258,
-0.0185509361,
-0.0287890658,
-0.0014736493,
0.000763,
0.0268006139,
0.0398648679,
-0.0364734158,
-0.0003428785,
-0.0358509123,
-0.0530245267,
0.0189272109,
0.0824496076,
0.0442496464,
-0.0150810815,
-0.0591516979,
0.0119479969,
-0.0716479495,
-0.0125504453,
0.0058880779,
0.0370327048,
-0.0072476417,
0.0748059452,
0.0593164526,
-0.0165219605,
0.0502279922,
-0.0229407474,
-0.0337064229,
0.0289957002,
0.0089006862,
0.014866353,
0.0180132482,
0.0107451035,
-0.0380627923,
0.0225508027,
0.0098495055,
-0.0191946775,
0.0175145939,
0.0503729843,
-0.0408596024,
0.0100592459,
0.0067474791,
-0.0479954109,
-0.029061906,
-0.0126781845,
0.0210045166,
0.0348043442,
-0.0027104882,
0.0207276773,
0.0652317703,
-0.0282212067,
0.0348447189,
0.0240673628,
-0.0105450908,
0.0210420266,
0.010451911,
0.0111027388,
-0.0795332715,
-0.0237621851,
0.0633423999,
0.0270886682,
-0.0030131431,
0.0255173799,
0.0152789755,
0.0022890822,
-0.0109408554,
-0.0036355664,
-0.0152684646,
0.0411469862,
-0.0655846074,
0.0137713291,
0.0176442042,
0.0264727604,
-0.0350825675,
0.0813231319,
0.0026685647,
-0.0159196276,
-0.0315089598,
-0.0256535187,
0.0056479126,
0.0317544825,
-0.0114170592,
0.0046741557,
0.0140145319,
-0.0480076447,
-0.0023397806,
-0.044860892,
-0.0057752021,
-0.002440678,
2.92e-7,
-0.0028124705,
0.0079487897,
0.0292406734,
0.0250777882,
0.0124107441,
0.0747886673,
-0.0043657846,
0.0240920186,
0.0077353194,
-0.0392379239,
0.0441279598,
0.0196745601,
0.057696119,
-0.001720055,
-0.1117047966,
-0.0070765326,
-0.0144374957,
-0.035413567,
-0.0291007459,
0.0277080461,
0.0888828933,
0.086158894,
0.0191911142,
-0.018017849,
0.0320972614,
0.0022323777,
0.021797521,
-0.0069228415,
0.0269653164,
-0.0200905334,
-0.015508133,
-0.02955251,
-0.0154554499,
0.0343080088,
-0.0135070449,
0.0007591383,
-0.0119423764,
0.0659532323,
-0.0062066703,
-0.0786102265,
-0.027634941,
0.0408060476,
0.0083899619,
0.0115243522,
0.056838505,
-0.0388887711,
-0.027046755,
-0.0069108792,
-0.0393114239,
0.0111741964,
0.0101225087,
0.0064895526,
0.0017010834,
0.0065411394,
-0.0039017864,
0.0114767607,
-0.0099848127,
-0.0882776603,
0.0306675378,
0.0352288671,
-0.0377497636,
-0.0304001048,
-0.0088134194,
-0.0003667696,
0.0310109127,
-0.0679713488,
-0.0152538149,
2.19708366e-34,
0.0268031769,
-0.0236708224,
0.0272474755,
0.0243401341,
0.0007378324,
-0.0203000009,
-0.0576579683,
-0.0343116708,
0.0569715872,
-0.0841136128,
-0.007420816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16755v1 | HI-TOM: A Benchmark for Evaluating Higher-Order Theory of Mind Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T16:41:15 | 2023-10-25T16:41:15 | Yinghui He, Yufan Wu, Yilin Jia, Rada Mihalcea, Yulong Chen, Naihao Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Theory of Mind (ToM) is the ability to reason about one's own and others'
mental states. ToM plays a critical role in the development of intelligence,
language understanding, and cognitive processes. While previous work has
primarily focused on first and second-order ToM, we explore higher-order ToM,
which involves recursive reasoning on others' beliefs. We introduce HI-TOM, a
Higher Order Theory of Mind benchmark. Our experimental evaluation using
various Large Language Models (LLMs) indicates a decline in performance on
higher-order ToM tasks, demonstrating the limitations of current LLMs. We
conduct a thorough analysis of different failure cases of LLMs, and share our
thoughts on the implications of our findings on the future of NLP. | [
0.0491746292,
0.0718105808,
-0.0153082246,
0.0353359096,
-0.0377213769,
0.0097442884,
-0.0113183754,
0.0010376537,
0.0448896438,
-0.0553415604,
-0.0296727885,
-0.0342717469,
0.0077601476,
-0.0101109995,
0.0260527059,
-0.0466921329,
0.0325827003,
-0.0353851691,
0.0190320611,
-0.0166116823,
-0.0416465253,
0.0138712553,
-0.0101144006,
-0.0017398394,
-0.003594073,
0.0019276529,
0.0074045369,
-0.0149109801,
0.0253175292,
-0.0529758707,
-0.0344292633,
0.0189338364,
0.011853571,
0.0831573233,
0.0000019278,
-0.0750708133,
-0.0006440723,
0.0092464145,
-0.016086841,
0.0096946135,
-0.0085215997,
0.0128253838,
-0.0022651411,
0.0194330178,
-0.0305729806,
0.0203788485,
-0.0110982824,
0.0891861245,
0.0304461401,
0.0587824956,
-0.0000247021,
-0.0611143932,
0.0369444527,
-0.0208184309,
0.0513695218,
-0.0745875165,
0.0328378603,
0.0128291128,
0.0317186266,
-0.0149685647,
0.0238198098,
0.0037158071,
-0.0012197365,
-0.0042305416,
-0.0445784032,
0.0157349166,
0.0033456408,
0.0009285223,
-0.0023208072,
0.0637664944,
0.0788561329,
0.0096497284,
-0.0326533876,
0.040538542,
0.0127878645,
0.0332150683,
-0.0198315345,
0.0507716909,
-0.0128567964,
-0.017468987,
0.0495268218,
0.0140231494,
0.0065568979,
0.0094503611,
-0.0655536205,
0.116526179,
-0.0050900574,
-0.0396227129,
0.032919798,
-0.0130587481,
-0.0536627658,
-0.0389875323,
-0.0422881171,
0.02588013,
0.0083459159,
0.0065297782,
0.0171365552,
0.0371300206,
0.0015070633,
-0.0278759748,
0.0734127536,
0.0323057733,
0.0222059079,
0.0416454077,
-0.0211404637,
0.0499279462,
-0.0353393331,
0.0341344178,
0.0076919538,
0.021161383,
-0.0613392368,
-0.0075557809,
-0.0130430413,
0.0754850656,
0.0224857833,
-0.0211153142,
-0.0325817689,
-0.0362490453,
-0.02923356,
-0.0139944963,
-0.0200648326,
-0.0210370589,
0.0234377477,
-0.0237563401,
-0.0606566183,
0.0297634918,
-0.0450575128,
0.0187536925,
0.0121063879,
-0.0537333526,
-0.0000459755,
-0.032205306,
-0.0152031183,
0.0048925974,
0.0138714006,
0.0507843643,
0.0436614305,
-0.0227421746,
-0.0074715349,
-0.0265357792,
-0.0074215424,
-0.0938502848,
0.0009048927,
-0.0426848419,
-0.0084739458,
0.017483661,
-0.0048369225,
-0.0165113956,
0.0319847427,
-0.0038006143,
-0.0974026695,
0.0502240323,
-0.0192088708,
0.0044092988,
-0.0288949031,
0.0031064572,
0.0126168374,
0.0312336273,
0.004083252,
-0.0256328303,
0.0161880646,
0.0317150652,
-0.0062461253,
0.0082796011,
-0.0116223609,
-0.0240589231,
-0.0255786143,
-0.0058202455,
0.0006346123,
0.0665996373,
-0.0104002096,
0.065030247,
-0.0090206377,
0.0018243894,
0.0305629242,
0.0573876761,
-0.0402031168,
-0.0431099534,
0.0451853015,
0.0103807887,
0.0550138019,
0.0212230776,
-0.0710906014,
0.0018619684,
-0.0695692748,
-0.0365357473,
0.0243803281,
0.027306214,
-0.0187050067,
-0.0309613626,
-0.0458536446,
0.0184552725,
0.0113708442,
-0.0164574962,
0.028406499,
0.0003577047,
0.0182048697,
0.0213046204,
0.0390299261,
-0.0465548784,
-0.0340931267,
-0.0628165081,
0.0065789539,
0.0196111444,
0.0437663794,
-0.0364508741,
-0.0044556614,
-0.0022258605,
-0.0077426489,
0.051465001,
0.067981638,
0.0246520024,
-0.0367778614,
-0.0107103325,
-0.0007326317,
-0.0272756051,
0.0316451304,
0.0055959756,
-0.0230656378,
-0.0278027244,
-0.0084468676,
-0.0200785641,
0.0156867169,
0.0192846339,
-0.006160317,
0.0019396858,
-0.0706079304,
0.0302470028,
0.04621334,
0.0113701606,
-0.0041942019,
0.0227038898,
0.0132026114,
-0.0081813876,
-0.0260508638,
0.0487269163,
-0.0137562277,
-0.0248336587,
0.0396746285,
-0.0100082261,
-0.0486635827,
0.0557781495,
-0.0096805347,
-0.0036771779,
0.0300900172,
-0.019766856,
0.0353959724,
-0.0192740429,
0.0310993623,
-0.0349951833,
-0.0072060055,
-0.0052904179,
0.0989777595,
-0.0320668779,
0.0209717304,
-0.0045687268,
-0.0610778965,
0.0115620233,
-0.0044295457,
-0.0215495452,
0.0081462795,
-0.0003884331,
-0.0223647114,
0.0019888282,
0.0083174175,
-0.0320561603,
-0.0188611504,
-0.0693751499,
-0.0248543546,
0.0092763528,
-0.0027276592,
-0.0070727095,
-0.0116212973,
-0.0018007853,
0.0455359891,
-0.0344022773,
0.0679267645,
0.0410604477,
0.0452720635,
0.033366885,
-0.0262696091,
-0.0093591148,
-0.0166611057,
0.0139858965,
-0.0827423036,
0.0467314422,
0.0007405754,
0.0147412736,
-0.0114381304,
0.0225681122,
-0.100281924,
0.0309586599,
-0.0150909042,
-0.0181804113,
0.0441511013,
-0.0238785371,
0.002732204,
0.0846390352,
0.002868233,
0.0187000409,
0.0270703379,
0.0232069995,
-0.0470664762,
0.0189730991,
0.0097765885,
-0.0254080165,
-0.0521465018,
-0.026045952,
-0.0279807933,
0.0824954957,
0.0145742111,
-0.0200986732,
-0.0650304183,
0.0861376673,
-0.0114735849,
-0.0087804813,
-0.0008500115,
-0.0187050514,
-0.0106611941,
0.0409157835,
-0.0261121225,
-0.0305859577,
0.0689598545,
-0.0143386293,
0.0064990842,
-0.019566521,
0.0574584119,
-0.0449004434,
0.0649326444,
0.0390978158,
0.0329896435,
0.0229108743,
-0.0144379018,
-0.0391773805,
0.0061917808,
-0.0141078923,
-0.0105170365,
0.0050047035,
-0.0307516269,
-0.0050382032,
0.01509309,
-0.0180535913,
-0.022769656,
0.0162381083,
-0.0731569976,
0.0129776876,
-0.0050207153,
0.0068681943,
-0.042445574,
-0.0306518395,
0.0371718667,
-0.0079528447,
0.0005155798,
-0.0368588939,
-0.0301766265,
0.0240110233,
0.0056485566,
0.0012299265,
0.0813970864,
-0.0140841156,
0.0313124247,
0.0634753779,
0.0408675447,
0.0444875509,
0.011850955,
0.0262258817,
0.0182745904,
0.0290136468,
-0.0307347402,
0.0307534467,
0.0836227536,
-0.0148478774,
0.0239126328,
0.1155276895,
0.0269954316,
0.0047159316,
0.0156149985,
-0.0043530185,
0.015105363,
0.0438744165,
0.0048151426,
-0.0703084245,
-0.0156978462,
0.0129500441,
-0.0194616001,
-0.0167974662,
-0.1026763469,
0.0012003351,
-0.1065262407,
0.0034587558,
-0.0087036006,
0.0136954663,
0.0176499877,
-0.0458869189,
0.0571853295,
0.0403317325,
-0.0448805019,
0.0390784182,
-0.0038808058,
0.0059038335,
-0.0180233661,
-0.0273482949,
-0.0368530154,
0.0807933062,
-0.0236511994,
0.0519687682,
0.0235036481,
0.0509030409,
-0.0171428137,
-0.0593677834,
0.0207105875,
0.0321639068,
0.0069484208,
-0.0131787295,
-0.0193830617,
-0.021102611,
0.0155933332,
-0.0162790064,
0.0366916247,
-0.030698847,
0.0378390588,
-0.023710873,
0.0876566991,
0.0137325497,
-0.0734707266,
0.0079619884,
0.0423833206,
-0.0565825067,
0.0722424388,
0.0297575518,
-0.0251000822,
0.0053349808,
-0.0207507052,
-0.0434202217,
0.0315265618,
-0.0623329356,
0.0273537729,
0.0473797508,
-0.0052850829,
-0.0593704656,
-0.0328909643,
0.0001904589,
0.0115398904,
0.0152949886,
-0.0148085691,
0.0020454039,
0.0089816526,
-0.0155002018,
0.0066530164,
-0.0262070317,
0.0022258658,
-0.0601795204,
0.0200212542,
0.0190644339,
-0.0148068424,
-0.0214688499,
-0.0187072046,
-0.0186525881,
-0.0631803721,
0.0011182694,
0.0299172793,
0.0273933336,
0.0028017871,
0.0128243361,
-0.02081131,
-0.025992807,
-0.0473703593,
-0.0350236036,
0.0570969172,
0.0369395651,
0.0507658385,
0.0222239364,
0.0686039627,
0.0009333655,
0.0280363578,
0.0397504456,
0.0160554722,
0.0081695644,
-0.0399906747,
0.0208660904,
0.0628108829,
0.0229790285,
0.0309125315,
0.010370438,
-0.010404855,
-0.0221184101,
-0.0821742564,
-0.0281428955,
-0.0481788367,
0.0052464288,
0.0371495485,
0.0428519286,
-0.0238128528,
-0.0902640671,
0.0157516375,
0.0169048458,
0.0184475929,
0.013855028,
-0.0191154238,
0.0197377857,
0.033323098,
-0.0108362501,
-0.0015644353,
-0.0198190026,
-0.048297856,
0.0447836444,
-0.0177499224,
0.0968741775,
0.0337438807,
-0.0337787271,
-0.0332834497,
0.0007970716,
-0.0708185285,
-0.0950232297,
0.0505460985,
-0.0371363461,
-0.0068751113,
0.0167290345,
0.0258182455,
-0.0525273681,
0.0078665959,
0.0093623893,
0.0200546589,
0.0192806385,
-0.0570660755,
-0.0023477154,
0.0025075923,
-0.0012087608,
0.0347981006,
0.0267992727,
-0.0189210251,
0.0181145053,
0.0105304951,
0.0132372798,
-0.0316325277,
0.0319664776,
-0.0251767393,
0.0710524619,
0.0102528427,
0.06898202,
-0.115070574,
-0.0183719173,
0.0517653562,
0.0123998811,
-0.0121182073,
0.0062124529,
0.0163913108,
0.088654466,
0.0163307842,
-0.0364050008,
-0.0145407068,
-0.0440409109,
-0.0324986354,
-0.0140913604,
0.0051646726,
-6.084322026e-33,
-0.0360930488,
-0.0097640399,
0.0052656969,
0.0088437442,
-0.0413343795,
-0.0129746106,
-0.0343256183,
0.0366870984,
-0.0290685035,
0.0280784927,
-0.0252397601,
0.0017910493,
-0.0187360607,
0.0035831493,
0.0044869017,
0.0241063684,
0.0089461626,
-0.0219135694,
-0.0558922552,
-0.0308268033,
0.0325041525,
-0.0202477537,
0.0499897711,
-0.0646722242,
0.028302066,
0.0320986956,
0.0323201902,
0.0507441573,
-0.0643287003,
-0.0244258139,
-0.0258883424,
0.0168333668,
0.0373066403,
-0.0223744828,
0.014792636,
-0.0115303742,
-0.044635877,
-0.0430214405,
0.058168713,
-0.0352318622,
-0.026758844,
-0.0254228562,
0.0179999433,
0.0073499465,
-0.0661077648,
-0.0316463411,
0.01684683,
-0.0124375382,
0.0173048638,
0.0424874835,
-0.0747600868,
-0.0125262523,
0.0031907111,
-0.0024758535,
-0.0197053775,
0.0125711346,
-0.0144608608,
-0.0397532769,
-0.05997153,
0.0395386368,
0.0098784622,
-0.0135631412,
0.0318101943,
-0.0722485334,
0.0226612929,
0.0827465653,
0.0684055835,
0.0474882536,
-0.0540532283,
-0.0064301291,
0.0244205687,
0.0666821823,
0.0372243412,
-0.0007415408,
-0.0135138556,
-0.014574755,
-0.0372262485,
0.0016109076,
0.0363176391,
0.0592422038,
0.0565049127,
-0.0109477574,
-0.0597225092,
0.0041340906,
-0.0655244365,
-0.0176311079,
-0.0372387506,
-0.0098330099,
0.0021648563,
-0.016067706,
-0.0053913016,
-0.0524382517,
0.0213929247,
-0.0370999649,
-0.0103895981,
0.019874109,
-0.0007708328,
0.008317857,
-0.018553229,
0.0256346632,
-0.051433865,
-0.0012429425,
-0.0337374173,
0.008918914,
0.0292065497,
-0.0135323908,
-0.0016300308,
-0.019880224,
-0.0529045276,
-0.0145014022,
-0.0320794433,
-0.0025535391,
-0.0083700111,
-0.0134277176,
0.0461337604,
0.0106076635,
0.0032949054,
-0.0111595485,
-0.0086263111,
-0.0433994345,
-0.0593232326,
0.0542234033,
0.0116768535,
0.0028003568,
-0.0037906729,
-0.0057310448,
-0.0409227833,
0.00907782,
0.0144933583,
-0.0254380722,
-0.0206887312,
0.0061526289,
2.762e-7,
-0.0106212413,
0.0944820568,
-0.006358596,
-0.0214684159,
0.0392277539,
0.039550215,
-0.0116267838,
-0.0310304239,
0.0247944389,
-0.0333789214,
-0.0536389016,
0.0379826576,
0.0427007563,
0.0328176208,
-0.0283820815,
-0.0314319991,
0.0075030643,
-0.0275722016,
-0.0274142828,
0.0102135697,
0.0367991403,
0.0495999642,
0.0332940817,
-0.0064765243,
-0.0021702694,
0.00027758,
0.0483554266,
-0.0122239655,
-0.0062836763,
0.0002818452,
0.0232240465,
-0.0028249407,
0.0288769007,
0.0178435817,
0.0585853346,
0.0281630438,
-0.0192902554,
-0.0020779897,
-0.0220527072,
-0.0238145888,
-0.0134619363,
-0.0184683856,
-0.0341109633,
-0.0521298759,
0.062388137,
-0.06258367,
-0.0869212225,
0.0332740434,
0.0026252293,
-0.0277386401,
-0.0104851434,
0.033946339,
-0.017734196,
0.0073427362,
0.0149491318,
-0.0223624855,
0.0117556378,
-0.093459703,
0.0066540791,
-0.0120611545,
-0.0068512177,
-0.0671581179,
0.0031779995,
-0.0248875152,
0.0171799716,
-0.0725027099,
-0.0172123574,
2.59463011e-34,
0.0313493051,
-0.0192825254,
0.0511386879,
-0.0259179752,
0.0791607797,
-0.0136670759,
0.0095387194,
0.0088079153,
0.0311582163,
-0.1332531422,
0.0085050547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16753v1 | PROMINET: Prototype-based Multi-View Network for Interpretable Email Response Prediction | 2023-10-25T16:39:00 | 2023-10-25T16:39:00 | Yuqing Wang, Prashanth Vijayaraghavan, Ehsan Degan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Email is a widely used tool for business communication, and email marketing
has emerged as a cost-effective strategy for enterprises. While previous
studies have examined factors affecting email marketing performance, limited
research has focused on understanding email response behavior by considering
email content and metadata. This study proposes a Prototype-based Multi-view
Network (PROMINET) that incorporates semantic and structural information from
email data. By utilizing prototype learning, the PROMINET model generates
latent exemplars, enabling interpretable email response prediction. The model
maps learned semantic and structural exemplars to observed samples in the
training data at different levels of granularity, such as document, sentence,
or phrase. The approach is evaluated on two real-world email datasets: the
Enron corpus and an in-house Email Marketing corpus. Experimental results
demonstrate that the PROMINET model outperforms baseline models, achieving a
~3% improvement in F1 score on both datasets. Additionally, the model provides
interpretability through prototypes at different granularity levels while
maintaining comparable performance to non-interpretable models. The learned
prototypes also show potential for generating suggestions to enhance email text
editing and improve the likelihood of effective email responses. This research
contributes to enhancing sender-receiver communication and customer engagement
in email interactions. | [
0.0739231631,
0.0382499993,
-0.0295133013,
0.0214486439,
-0.0139395967,
0.0125293424,
0.0084844902,
-0.0056659854,
0.0082174856,
-0.0487637073,
-0.0023543208,
-0.0337474979,
-0.0402630344,
0.1064496636,
-0.0062624956,
-0.0302112401,
-0.0160594657,
0.0078750504,
-0.0109168803,
0.0502409674,
0.0269313622,
0.0085422257,
0.0192287043,
0.0238677412,
0.0032846266,
-0.0232162941,
-0.0266225412,
0.0330000632,
-0.0129494984,
-0.0159685109,
0.0406337976,
0.0398792811,
0.0254836641,
0.0139743034,
0.0000019624,
-0.0627064109,
-0.0257871356,
-0.0124220252,
-0.0262005553,
0.0065662661,
0.1110074148,
-0.0084202019,
0.0177281499,
0.0514133386,
-0.0535564646,
0.0504704975,
0.0559577979,
0.0942301676,
0.0415163562,
0.0543314628,
-0.0504123718,
-0.026519414,
0.0307479873,
-0.0414934978,
0.0238948651,
0.0101557318,
0.022026008,
-0.0448872335,
-0.0674544647,
0.0295572598,
0.0015390257,
0.0200406089,
-0.0155433398,
-0.0323832221,
0.0022940794,
0.0295066554,
0.039308548,
0.0121000689,
-0.0140451556,
0.0485323668,
0.0023927181,
0.0363789499,
-0.0084093222,
-0.0263681132,
0.016797347,
0.0021603662,
-0.0322278403,
-0.0557961687,
0.007204006,
0.0023940785,
-0.047026135,
0.0399753824,
-0.0012582926,
0.0083320141,
-0.0096712811,
-0.0048831361,
-0.0282435603,
-0.0168805607,
-0.0226515438,
0.0320990756,
0.062233191,
-0.0095349839,
0.0308247544,
-0.0279446188,
0.0359602533,
0.0527370125,
0.0244381446,
-0.0223212317,
0.0204647053,
-0.0947764888,
0.0322614498,
0.009524812,
0.0451880284,
0.028446991,
-0.0346022174,
-0.0403168723,
-0.0267961379,
0.0087390654,
-0.0478868373,
-0.0017245084,
-0.1227895021,
-0.054657843,
-0.0312620252,
0.0850612,
-0.0196161792,
-0.029508261,
-0.0851660743,
0.0049238191,
-0.0187745169,
-0.0166723803,
0.0026154818,
0.0270806681,
-0.0288334955,
-0.009795595,
-0.0411440097,
-0.0084668677,
-0.0387663879,
0.0378442816,
-0.0076381532,
-0.0237068553,
0.0023985379,
0.0103942147,
-0.0132787237,
-0.0295041669,
-0.0072224154,
-0.0114683919,
-0.0189215299,
-0.0577630438,
-0.0167756472,
-0.0507967658,
-0.0163896121,
-0.0052601746,
0.0007746242,
-0.0310905781,
0.0105021289,
0.0291475803,
-0.0392230339,
0.0258921422,
-0.0252435859,
-0.005160958,
-0.039894741,
0.0534456074,
0.028494345,
-0.0139241386,
0.0082312701,
0.0157222264,
0.0310415905,
0.0105690928,
-0.0038884364,
0.075858891,
0.0094474908,
-0.0044608503,
0.0265847761,
0.0236842539,
-0.0024751117,
-0.0147921201,
-0.0046835705,
0.0146824047,
-0.0322652571,
-0.0106430976,
-0.0108913034,
-0.0239453968,
-0.0431351513,
0.0004229325,
0.061298877,
-0.0070620086,
0.0101353452,
0.0552969128,
0.0014964662,
0.0238121729,
-0.021546308,
-0.0354076773,
0.0136106303,
0.0266082697,
0.0014705284,
-0.005522395,
-0.0437248051,
-0.0229533594,
-0.0699190497,
-0.0342532061,
0.0261551719,
-0.0271144081,
-0.0144986073,
-0.0073026069,
0.0789147466,
0.015866207,
-0.0744885579,
0.0623734333,
-0.0247636009,
-0.0284147933,
-0.0166834071,
-0.0051388829,
-0.0346160829,
0.044941958,
0.0328341983,
-0.0304802656,
-0.0157113019,
-0.0443251096,
-0.0191137195,
0.0267388113,
0.03202473,
-0.0008564391,
0.0043061194,
-0.0254849736,
-0.0129708797,
-0.0235540718,
-0.0002888752,
0.0453757681,
-0.0521082655,
-0.023339197,
0.0249476042,
-0.0241316147,
0.0073766257,
0.0194880683,
0.0149566,
0.0280259605,
0.036697451,
0.003663514,
0.0493768863,
0.0569836944,
0.0019172727,
-0.0056437557,
0.0399829596,
-0.0414070413,
-0.0055478034,
-0.0166948847,
-0.0404517688,
-0.0018680147,
-0.0353880264,
-0.0235727523,
-0.0120107625,
0.0442595929,
-0.0557484366,
-0.039545998,
0.0249716695,
0.0128433751,
0.0708041117,
-0.0886290818,
-0.0481128134,
-0.0162959415,
0.0002525457,
-0.0037902792,
0.0252419841,
-0.0247471556,
0.0052832328,
0.0207716711,
-0.0479867235,
0.0015637504,
0.027173534,
-0.0080787698,
0.0055077113,
-0.0240176078,
-0.0176655892,
-0.0161163677,
-0.0199454129,
-0.0320590101,
-0.057231795,
-0.0758823305,
-0.005827711,
-0.0067571783,
0.0418548137,
0.039435789,
0.0277947187,
0.0363627113,
-0.0287497584,
-0.0275486652,
0.0701828897,
-0.0170510486,
-0.0121695921,
0.0623650551,
0.0107905194,
-0.0013575435,
-0.0082302522,
-0.0263182633,
-0.0113508049,
0.0708618686,
0.0537076592,
-0.0344751365,
-0.039686773,
-0.0018751646,
-0.0051162923,
0.0157763306,
-0.0390571989,
-0.0280098561,
-0.0480196252,
-0.0170176048,
-0.022289509,
-0.0043801656,
0.0499758571,
0.0440356508,
-0.0225325879,
0.0552548207,
-0.0776813626,
-0.0039137146,
-0.0589963421,
0.0120005794,
-0.0731571466,
-0.0220318437,
0.0312686227,
0.0091685457,
0.019390827,
-0.0282504037,
-0.0305563211,
0.0596377105,
0.058945965,
-0.048707325,
-0.056490507,
-0.0381036289,
-0.0082542533,
0.0074577411,
0.0052376711,
-0.0511296578,
0.0540384874,
0.0113303326,
-0.0029482665,
0.0104846675,
-0.0221625604,
-0.0260712467,
0.0367266722,
0.0103794336,
0.0126359826,
-0.026719477,
-0.0419930741,
-0.0303425919,
-0.0202532578,
0.0026357018,
0.0065322025,
0.0197186582,
0.0265910998,
0.0142748272,
0.0149386702,
-0.0188654102,
-0.0388596207,
-0.0449041091,
0.0298011098,
0.0134107443,
0.0250368323,
0.0359904841,
-0.0859539583,
0.0260992106,
-0.0380631573,
0.037434116,
0.0032188082,
-0.0619045533,
-0.0056257872,
0.0183882136,
0.0258576237,
-0.0270244963,
0.0190582555,
-0.0449938066,
0.0159925967,
0.050263714,
-0.0290554557,
-0.042313721,
-0.0457095504,
-0.0147923641,
-0.0205106772,
-0.0375750698,
0.0185378939,
-0.0364121608,
-0.0013975591,
0.0121517405,
-0.0201617852,
0.0704108402,
0.0483245738,
-0.066543363,
-0.0112586981,
-0.0145984823,
0.0326011851,
0.0101682702,
0.0723547786,
-0.0080830883,
0.0137197729,
-0.0371082798,
0.0233548339,
0.0107641518,
-0.0359263457,
0.0093977004,
-0.1038281545,
0.0363544784,
-0.0447919294,
-0.0075442945,
-0.0084569175,
-0.034104988,
-0.0342268236,
-0.0178616662,
-0.0584757403,
-0.0122888777,
-0.0063615842,
-0.0225334186,
0.008038003,
-0.0202356186,
-0.0207851175,
0.0180395544,
0.0015468785,
-0.0120229367,
0.0225629769,
0.0099458247,
-0.0520530976,
0.0271002539,
0.0411421619,
-0.0494216494,
0.0277664904,
0.0015627567,
0.1228362173,
-0.0028050311,
0.0400244705,
-0.0034527578,
-0.0003925337,
-0.0701221302,
-0.0058548041,
-0.006020146,
0.0383788012,
-0.0116402954,
-0.0188307911,
-0.0389383025,
-0.0305652507,
0.005626081,
0.0537005588,
-0.0178206023,
-0.067963101,
-0.0457940325,
-0.0153437303,
0.0190303028,
0.000597487,
0.0635112971,
-0.0071584242,
-0.0014114969,
-0.0140670612,
-0.0529670045,
-0.0278085861,
0.0032593647,
0.0411717929,
0.0091386298,
0.012529064,
-0.0388358608,
0.0002521199,
-0.0334275141,
0.0044778064,
0.0574500896,
0.0163094606,
-0.0301984344,
0.0163415447,
0.0449104048,
-0.0893682092,
-0.0382211655,
-0.0320151523,
-0.0276969671,
-0.0055406038,
-0.0229004994,
0.0456059314,
0.0257476475,
0.0366045311,
-0.0108046159,
-0.0645988137,
0.0212309454,
0.0499316379,
0.0125589641,
-0.0460800901,
0.0384197012,
-0.0028801602,
-0.0067186798,
0.0233405922,
-0.0276840162,
0.0407610647,
0.0449421741,
-0.0177908577,
-0.0237619225,
-0.0237526204,
-0.0083726523,
-0.0190572981,
0.0448653437,
0.0698024258,
-0.0154699776,
-0.0749354139,
0.0059699491,
0.0135604823,
0.0265035816,
-0.0736467838,
0.0127598774,
0.0088199507,
-0.0218742322,
-0.0394539423,
-0.0331203006,
-0.043894358,
-0.0001619177,
-0.0180003773,
0.0011784383,
0.0092170816,
0.0095387101,
0.0014908862,
0.0140572861,
0.0005292163,
0.0054050339,
0.003645021,
-0.0024665319,
-0.0166093148,
0.0559073575,
0.0091369729,
0.0202452186,
-0.054953374,
0.0329085588,
-0.0612465255,
0.0247682035,
-0.0670087859,
0.0081973653,
-0.0341687053,
-0.0036954868,
0.023163937,
-0.078935042,
0.020682523,
-0.0237548873,
0.0457679294,
0.0114424648,
-0.0340853259,
0.0429985039,
-0.0039558224,
-0.0168109834,
-0.0111299343,
0.0433502905,
-0.0313684084,
0.023129588,
-0.0295615643,
-0.060595192,
-0.0634684488,
0.0056823227,
0.0992890447,
0.0531735085,
-0.0239813589,
0.0068439371,
-0.0304221045,
-0.0254490785,
0.0539614856,
-0.0305500329,
0.0260314811,
0.0087593328,
0.0439380296,
0.0818957388,
0.0174915325,
0.0022874274,
-0.060386546,
-0.0316473618,
0.0024924988,
-0.0324683003,
-0.0102398917,
-5.883350328e-33,
0.0401904993,
-0.0371095948,
-0.0218978226,
0.0457098372,
-0.0037615534,
0.0282206051,
-0.01959268,
0.0041967435,
0.014758924,
0.0162283741,
0.0041519795,
0.0247466508,
0.007594503,
0.0220618136,
0.0413016677,
0.0205622707,
0.0729166046,
0.0045341835,
0.0304351412,
0.0063707591,
0.0586551242,
0.0683621466,
0.058231432,
-0.0668658316,
0.0345840007,
0.0023859665,
-0.0467289574,
0.0170938317,
0.0316859633,
0.076523751,
-0.0068380791,
0.0533317439,
0.0544831045,
-0.0167962965,
0.0055944766,
0.016369069,
-0.0266912747,
-0.0626824871,
0.0127212061,
-0.0081747929,
-0.0032982386,
0.0008134886,
0.0464261472,
-0.011084999,
0.0298557039,
-0.0111902626,
0.0576471537,
-0.006238672,
0.0127233928,
-0.0293643903,
-0.0073446566,
-0.0020208359,
-0.0064442432,
0.0284856521,
0.0257951356,
0.0754656941,
-0.000648897,
0.0532196946,
-0.064779304,
0.0131615428,
0.0135137169,
-0.0324104019,
0.0401870944,
0.028933879,
-0.0195503458,
0.0503465533,
0.0340971239,
0.0451354794,
0.0135879628,
-0.0463623218,
0.0084506441,
0.0427212603,
0.0266903173,
0.0837559402,
0.0049382588,
-0.0154017201,
-0.0353841819,
0.0290562324,
-0.0035642828,
0.0084726233,
0.069189243,
0.0100266282,
-0.0000511629,
0.0063202055,
-0.013517715,
-0.0017430229,
-0.0457044952,
-0.0189621653,
0.0361000337,
0.0197463296,
-0.0276113711,
0.048795905,
0.0447015874,
-0.0547285341,
-0.0252208449,
0.0144357802,
-0.0115992371,
0.0498700961,
0.0127181578,
-0.0398144461,
-0.0190356933,
-0.0158458613,
-0.0214132778,
-0.0089962389,
-0.0152286598,
-0.0121528544,
0.0539087653,
-0.0501269065,
-0.023574939,
-0.0074904463,
0.0361944921,
-0.0232791249,
-0.0299631394,
0.0037224938,
-0.0191097204,
0.0236342959,
-0.0269865301,
0.050212387,
0.0331459232,
0.0022875506,
-0.0026883404,
-0.0031032572,
0.0177400485,
0.0172981862,
-0.0200926457,
-0.0043211398,
0.0002593925,
-0.0142981531,
0.0741846934,
-0.0261610392,
-0.0133460173,
0.0579030104,
2.615e-7,
0.1030975655,
0.040093109,
-0.0216570906,
0.0022278083,
0.061848525,
0.0559671521,
-0.0010126767,
0.0455214605,
0.001003953,
0.0206391755,
0.0777889118,
-0.0414489433,
0.023055179,
0.0176802371,
-0.0747780874,
-0.0099337054,
-0.0365172848,
-0.0022748399,
-0.0575171299,
0.0606560148,
0.117326282,
0.0397272632,
0.0052500828,
-0.000466942,
-0.0038635265,
0.027665507,
0.0770577118,
-0.0730537847,
0.015947409,
0.0090976646,
0.0096952505,
-0.0419483744,
0.0035161376,
0.0329399295,
-0.0436778292,
0.0243351515,
-0.0070041399,
0.0369404964,
-0.0161985792,
-0.0007011586,
0.0369727872,
-0.0024399061,
0.0364297964,
-0.1003367081,
0.0079670027,
-0.1133899912,
-0.0361224823,
0.0431135483,
-0.0170217566,
0.00010505,
0.0239355918,
0.0232830551,
0.0219763368,
0.0249046031,
-0.0089246724,
-0.0514339618,
0.0141346361,
-0.0416537784,
0.0820498392,
-0.0006415904,
-0.0456513278,
-0.0038860303,
-0.0387315489,
-0.0065119588,
0.0526603423,
-0.0420613997,
0.0094565284,
2.162872871e-34,
0.0391392298,
0.0025393504,
0.0025244947,
0.0374369249,
0.0104462029,
-0.0022781035,
0.0393725969,
0.0195792224,
0.0266543198,
-0.1069859117,
-0.01466705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16749v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16749v1 | DISCO: A Large Scale Human Annotated Corpus for Disfluency Correction in Indo-European Languages | 2023-10-25T16:32:02 | 2023-10-25T16:32:02 | Vineet Bhat, Preethi Jyothi, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Disfluency correction (DC) is the process of removing disfluent elements like
fillers, repetitions and corrections from spoken utterances to create readable
and interpretable text. DC is a vital post-processing step applied to Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) outputs, before subsequent processing by downstream
language understanding tasks. Existing DC research has primarily focused on
English due to the unavailability of large-scale open-source datasets. Towards
the goal of multilingual disfluency correction, we present a high-quality
human-annotated DC corpus covering four important Indo-European languages:
English, Hindi, German and French. We provide extensive analysis of results of
state-of-the-art DC models across all four languages obtaining F1 scores of
97.55 (English), 94.29 (Hindi), 95.89 (German) and 92.97 (French). To
demonstrate the benefits of DC on downstream tasks, we show that DC leads to
5.65 points increase in BLEU scores on average when used in conjunction with a
state-of-the-art Machine Translation (MT) system. We release code to run our
experiments along with our annotated dataset here. | [
0.0136057548,
0.0169771668,
-0.0324256718,
0.0093035446,
-0.0416775532,
0.0038650569,
-0.0082456013,
-0.0161284953,
-0.0132236797,
-0.0191040225,
-0.0137441894,
-0.0512786657,
0.0950763598,
-0.0004023862,
0.0461041331,
-0.0438522473,
0.0615236498,
-0.0446462445,
0.0032607494,
0.0008830939,
0.0309443288,
0.0152865285,
-0.0503616929,
0.0140835848,
-0.0232251659,
-0.0138747515,
0.0059154881,
0.0487037785,
0.0176265612,
-0.0062745824,
-0.0101384325,
0.0441436954,
-0.0348261744,
0.0603745021,
0.0000020025,
-0.0594824813,
-0.017559424,
-0.0131037273,
-0.0194812659,
0.0199637525,
0.0337487869,
0.0127551015,
-0.0119340103,
0.0234893598,
0.022970723,
0.0131839914,
0.0745638013,
0.0135430628,
0.0162839517,
0.0723044723,
-0.0169984773,
-0.0266570561,
0.0129462257,
-0.0048303842,
-0.0393944122,
0.0357910022,
0.0077408161,
0.0270269942,
-0.0044858004,
-0.0491130874,
-0.027444236,
0.030273661,
-0.0303785671,
-0.0034467708,
0.0052663232,
-0.023735784,
-0.0373264141,
-0.0582643487,
0.0155871194,
0.0711247846,
-0.0198223423,
-0.0435258597,
0.0117252888,
0.017207006,
-0.0189025812,
-0.0187049527,
-0.0008377649,
-0.0293647628,
-0.0132151218,
0.0037171869,
0.0527395532,
-0.0108737713,
0.0357801989,
-0.0166082345,
0.0063457587,
-0.0038352523,
0.0273997709,
-0.0370546952,
-0.0303555336,
-0.0107889809,
-0.0375992656,
-0.0256502368,
0.0633776933,
-0.0190152302,
-0.0246128663,
0.0053380425,
-0.0509572737,
-0.0745075718,
0.0237218458,
0.0148899127,
0.0060723368,
0.0481331497,
-0.0800492987,
-0.0080617387,
-0.003347157,
0.0774635747,
-0.0136613585,
0.0370616987,
-0.026730489,
0.0010160425,
0.0092247603,
0.0201217923,
-0.0028840236,
-0.0342631564,
-0.0433097184,
0.0292117689,
-0.0528114438,
-0.0187060852,
-0.0173125435,
-0.0155924764,
0.0310032032,
-0.0472648107,
-0.0646257475,
-0.0203235745,
0.0111972746,
0.0431108736,
0.003388582,
0.0209127907,
0.0142281456,
-0.0935094059,
-0.0124052791,
-0.0030358182,
0.0057799141,
-0.0292974189,
-0.0066551194,
0.0176275466,
-0.0166502297,
-0.0124676051,
-0.0329775512,
0.0270012058,
-0.046400629,
-0.062270686,
-0.059747383,
-0.0560952276,
0.0199302286,
-0.0183937587,
0.0206359811,
-0.0537301116,
0.0137395775,
0.0029359143,
-0.0151390834,
0.0913309604,
-0.0747989714,
0.0294339042,
0.0590197518,
0.0033835538,
-0.0049681659,
0.0048105158,
0.0447116569,
-0.0539746657,
0.0449679233,
0.0090262322,
0.0312287677,
0.0440469831,
-0.0153167369,
0.0005803308,
-0.0454242565,
-0.0396421142,
-0.0259331223,
0.02268387,
0.0894808397,
0.0517724156,
-0.0232587513,
0.0168308802,
0.0621792041,
0.0163420383,
0.0335898176,
-0.0012044994,
-0.0425981022,
0.0178075731,
0.0063130683,
0.0307873189,
-0.0203081202,
-0.018603757,
-0.0035268641,
0.0313821211,
0.0546098128,
0.0360718518,
0.0075458335,
0.0005223716,
-0.0081488686,
-0.0231028683,
0.0614581965,
-0.0141926752,
0.037884783,
0.0283586998,
-0.0410396494,
0.0132725174,
0.0411764383,
-0.0655219704,
0.0480101779,
-0.0372121371,
-0.0075990031,
0.0718412474,
0.0779641718,
-0.0309545584,
-0.0297028944,
-0.0116027556,
-0.0201776735,
0.0233576,
-0.0028875663,
0.0080564404,
0.0671327785,
-0.0880410895,
0.0174040385,
0.0462654084,
-0.0079275547,
0.0121510103,
-0.0297188219,
0.0015695532,
0.0018233552,
-0.0364021398,
-0.0343617387,
0.0314595327,
-0.001990255,
0.0238245763,
0.0127437906,
0.0065123038,
0.0338095017,
0.033457242,
-0.0449522547,
-0.0069804029,
0.0076721944,
-0.0204992928,
0.0223636571,
0.0488847606,
-0.0138845239,
-0.0443537533,
0.041527357,
-0.0400479548,
-0.0202297848,
0.0560901947,
0.0176486969,
-0.0883430913,
-0.0148005961,
-0.0308824163,
-0.0024705972,
-0.0342573598,
0.0599830486,
0.0206080191,
0.00140539,
-0.0031405033,
-0.0090687666,
-0.0012167786,
-0.0183110666,
-0.0109967478,
-0.0011884614,
0.0165344849,
-0.0859831125,
-0.0407360382,
0.0425864086,
-0.0130660431,
0.0156128323,
0.0130385617,
-0.0031829008,
-0.0416456908,
0.0020800957,
-0.0563027635,
-0.010177427,
-0.0236112494,
0.0303276796,
0.02381129,
0.0349560343,
-0.0164521914,
-0.0445601456,
0.0153833758,
-0.0306761302,
0.0405054726,
0.0008664202,
0.0273498036,
-0.0138331447,
-0.02834953,
-0.0235111695,
0.0035682083,
0.0095874267,
-0.0248490106,
-0.0154139576,
-0.0775862336,
-0.0546285473,
0.0413391776,
0.0002242366,
0.0040822676,
0.0081251441,
-0.0837437734,
-0.0318493284,
0.0305008311,
0.0591235533,
0.0010218309,
-0.0374579094,
-0.0227463059,
-0.0033509901,
-0.0229512509,
-0.0281102881,
-0.0209317841,
0.0206569023,
0.0451164059,
-0.0269154403,
-0.0310928039,
-0.0190376975,
0.0198855326,
0.0083174594,
0.015651308,
-0.0255311951,
-0.0440098085,
-0.0246789139,
-0.0168021955,
-0.0201046579,
-0.0298076533,
-0.0421400443,
0.0575137548,
-0.0465142392,
-0.0455918685,
0.0465852246,
-0.0623956025,
-0.0205873698,
-0.0549237467,
0.0228205808,
0.0211519077,
-0.0097924853,
-0.0168697797,
0.0089741107,
0.0058219079,
-0.0808146521,
-0.0471957512,
0.0472936034,
0.0223077051,
-0.0424866006,
0.0485021248,
-0.0924650803,
-0.0057469169,
-0.0039637587,
-0.0250241999,
-0.0080176909,
-0.0126674632,
0.0079888888,
-0.0272410139,
-0.0038003668,
-0.0281948317,
-0.0441642106,
0.0158430152,
-0.0282980241,
0.0710792169,
-0.0152060855,
0.0499846227,
-0.0054199672,
0.032870125,
0.004523179,
0.0606345572,
0.0147034563,
-0.0496888533,
-0.0142926723,
-0.0068320567,
0.0347108096,
-0.0109698754,
-0.0009772915,
-0.0196101628,
0.0369822569,
-0.0078357626,
-0.0405579135,
-0.0137388008,
0.067475304,
-0.0241681281,
0.0036925359,
0.0795410872,
-0.0134230787,
-0.0219035707,
-0.0149714313,
-0.0227171108,
0.0272493139,
0.0253663175,
-0.0117973564,
-0.1360336542,
-0.0285236202,
0.0744198337,
0.0351137482,
0.0132591017,
0.0228907745,
-0.0083158873,
-0.1003258154,
0.018147992,
0.0492542982,
0.00722257,
-0.0445110761,
0.0212514121,
-0.0136943264,
-0.0242822822,
0.0299791265,
0.0370042101,
0.0214894935,
-0.0168640092,
0.0393888503,
-0.0344479941,
-0.0878862515,
-0.032442756,
-0.0122400355,
0.1122421101,
0.0521948896,
0.0017026117,
-0.0015225585,
-0.0165642109,
0.0466283895,
-0.0278430413,
0.0098410305,
0.0027853714,
0.0583809391,
0.0280443542,
-0.0233683269,
-0.0019485696,
0.0404781029,
-0.0015243798,
-0.0331150442,
0.0156308077,
0.0087616481,
-0.0081043178,
0.0640215278,
0.0197495855,
-0.0043577827,
0.0277412068,
0.0273503605,
0.0304699801,
-0.0201254934,
-0.008279915,
0.001151578,
0.033873722,
-0.0453160703,
0.0437665544,
0.0302814357,
-0.0560095683,
-0.0553303026,
-0.0458874814,
-0.0414249264,
0.0155835962,
0.0007304511,
0.0384303406,
0.010906525,
-0.0123690227,
0.049503997,
-0.0246141087,
0.0188646819,
-0.0059629083,
0.0451947264,
-0.0843000039,
-0.0126694394,
-0.0646484196,
-0.0386541709,
-0.0228642207,
-0.0243606176,
-0.0508417971,
-0.0686082095,
0.0807161853,
0.043860469,
0.0265627541,
0.0597009473,
-0.0295747183,
-0.0863182917,
-0.0046544308,
0.0056549991,
-0.0422932915,
0.0158300567,
0.0185630731,
-0.038069237,
-0.0029685302,
0.0183941387,
0.0041216481,
0.0152469063,
-0.0205908008,
0.053428933,
0.0124015985,
-0.0429558642,
0.0198090263,
0.0493405275,
0.0725189,
-0.0610957816,
0.0544783883,
-0.0799771771,
0.0160774048,
0.0289328452,
0.0148648182,
-0.0027278983,
-0.000316065,
0.0624769181,
-0.0145290513,
-0.0123815648,
-0.0392011143,
-0.0689362511,
-0.0140021034,
-0.00284042,
0.0224697441,
0.0334124416,
0.0451774038,
0.0248343516,
0.0328467526,
0.0289995875,
0.0648236647,
0.0113286134,
0.0357975625,
-0.0052418374,
0.0501989797,
-0.0181085281,
-0.0046832748,
-0.0006031557,
0.025408335,
0.0241720676,
0.0577170663,
0.0058169989,
0.0105333785,
0.0492531136,
0.0398398787,
0.1194694638,
0.0104399938,
-0.0034970676,
-0.0349405296,
0.0193148926,
-0.0352456346,
0.0503626466,
-0.0161091574,
-0.0004576704,
-0.0109595368,
0.0188441277,
0.0583963208,
-0.0410647951,
-0.0119210416,
-0.0215800945,
0.008552664,
-0.0137073705,
-0.0489005186,
-0.0500819497,
0.0095105106,
-0.0333279409,
-0.0346730687,
-0.0306588411,
-0.0578274541,
0.0318725444,
0.0134379156,
0.0420913994,
-0.0292198434,
-0.0180627313,
-0.0065563279,
-0.0349241868,
0.0027119049,
-0.0277650673,
-0.0140166283,
-0.0062934202,
-0.011396124,
0.0130068231,
-5.867155322e-33,
-0.0089721261,
0.0169948824,
-0.0270458162,
-0.0375119708,
-0.0490013584,
-0.0031554794,
-0.023041619,
-0.0005570244,
0.0300771855,
0.0373319723,
-0.0059371451,
0.0153641673,
0.0315381661,
-0.0089276759,
0.0157367587,
0.0199892595,
0.0996250287,
0.0296405945,
-0.0082604149,
-0.0020890713,
0.0635984093,
0.0473221168,
0.0528769046,
-0.040328145,
0.0246304814,
-0.0437024869,
-0.0423401706,
0.0261753481,
0.01851275,
0.0265153516,
0.0163541883,
0.0391322784,
0.017461,
0.0295008589,
-0.0347796269,
0.0091944085,
-0.1126143187,
0.0431880318,
0.0240873937,
0.0895230696,
0.0069817379,
-0.0215888321,
0.038724903,
-0.0310705528,
-0.0201996472,
0.0342294425,
-0.01314261,
-0.0486909375,
0.0009094714,
0.0297183078,
-0.0561888479,
0.0453179404,
-0.0271923635,
-0.0165546387,
0.0347928852,
0.0652006641,
-0.0373002999,
-0.0412975363,
-0.0809192955,
0.0223679971,
0.0123633603,
0.049203828,
0.0391307436,
-0.0080369394,
-0.029359363,
0.0192170721,
0.0701809078,
-0.0062416047,
0.0595976375,
-0.0386005938,
0.0182099249,
-0.0103347311,
-0.0176366717,
0.0657825172,
0.0799699649,
-0.096285291,
0.0099626221,
0.0033410047,
-0.0386175811,
0.0317969695,
-0.0245225281,
0.0243459512,
-0.0455166362,
-0.0271234531,
-0.0135367326,
0.0030497557,
-0.0183883756,
-0.0117554329,
0.0522007942,
-0.0392559059,
-0.0118117314,
0.0036783905,
0.0557036065,
-0.0074992366,
0.050724417,
-0.044554051,
-0.0212934464,
0.0243863557,
-0.0314990357,
0.021147823,
-0.0336197615,
-0.0367477871,
0.0182295144,
0.0837812275,
-0.004359955,
-0.0447456166,
0.0322084278,
0.0091397278,
-0.0607606247,
0.0187100694,
0.0021335871,
0.0370151848,
-0.0063849897,
0.0562792718,
0.0445742048,
-0.0050613652,
-0.0054037534,
-0.0043172804,
0.0351093225,
0.0278706718,
-0.0127222352,
0.0088681979,
0.0209486913,
-0.0008199621,
-0.0331347845,
0.0034884887,
-0.0006538227,
-0.0354755372,
-0.0000240661,
-0.0467782281,
0.0133149913,
-0.0087949475,
2.641e-7,
-0.0109631214,
0.0712555051,
0.0615817197,
-0.0384196974,
0.0132467598,
-0.0165119879,
-0.0489937998,
-0.0208655205,
0.0077736541,
0.0432668813,
0.0225233063,
-0.0291032139,
0.095987536,
0.0141140372,
-0.0378753655,
-0.0016625668,
-0.0544784442,
0.0043555456,
-0.0132707171,
0.0040537394,
-0.0523258261,
0.0278187487,
-0.0279433616,
-0.0340354107,
0.0164256953,
0.0143667022,
0.0029008994,
0.009118177,
-0.0012362383,
-0.0022809068,
0.0412071534,
-0.0080209104,
0.0043317941,
0.0290828049,
-0.0322616324,
0.011457541,
0.0356569253,
0.0689964145,
-0.0341075957,
0.0230158586,
-0.0045081582,
0.0442815498,
-0.0365779363,
-0.0282894857,
-0.0034929337,
0.0205125771,
-0.0105228424,
-0.0439277664,
-0.0512307063,
-0.0157970153,
0.047490295,
-0.0283322427,
-0.0055484935,
0.0261580124,
0.0297635365,
-0.008146205,
-0.0409699492,
0.003660497,
-0.0425233133,
0.0230155084,
-0.0205181185,
-0.0078669973,
0.0251032598,
-0.0001991093,
0.0180011187,
-0.0353261568,
-0.0118492646,
2.063921731e-34,
0.0660603791,
-0.0216750968,
0.0212034993,
-0.0147741651,
0.0143530322,
-0.0449622273,
0.0012741025,
0.0285277609,
-0.0176853202,
-0.0121235969,
-0.0428907052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16746v1 | HANSEN: Human and AI Spoken Text Benchmark for Authorship Analysis | 2023-10-25T16:23:17 | 2023-10-25T16:23:17 | Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Adaku Uchendu, Thai Le, Mattia Setzu, Fosca Giannotti, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Authorship Analysis, also known as stylometry, has been an essential aspect
of Natural Language Processing (NLP) for a long time. Likewise, the recent
advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has made authorship analysis
increasingly crucial for distinguishing between human-written and AI-generated
texts. However, these authorship analysis tasks have primarily been focused on
written texts, not considering spoken texts. Thus, we introduce the largest
benchmark for spoken texts - HANSEN (Human ANd ai Spoken tExt beNchmark).
HANSEN encompasses meticulous curation of existing speech datasets accompanied
by transcripts, alongside the creation of novel AI-generated spoken text
datasets. Together, it comprises 17 human datasets, and AI-generated spoken
texts created using 3 prominent LLMs: ChatGPT, PaLM2, and Vicuna13B. To
evaluate and demonstrate the utility of HANSEN, we perform Authorship
Attribution (AA) & Author Verification (AV) on human-spoken datasets and
conducted Human vs. AI spoken text detection using state-of-the-art (SOTA)
models. While SOTA methods, such as, character ngram or Transformer-based
model, exhibit similar AA & AV performance in human-spoken datasets compared to
written ones, there is much room for improvement in AI-generated spoken text
detection. The HANSEN benchmark is available at:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/HANSEN-REPO/HANSEN. | [
0.0270804018,
0.0613260046,
-0.0164574478,
0.0496755205,
-0.0518090948,
0.0011500382,
0.0670842528,
-0.0270799417,
0.0081981504,
-0.0081303427,
-0.0347247235,
-0.0421245322,
0.0670146495,
0.016640434,
0.0155339129,
0.0471093655,
0.0061681536,
-0.0003549239,
0.0433930643,
0.0207920764,
0.0029196218,
0.0053810701,
0.0131692076,
0.046379976,
-0.0244942792,
-0.0404609665,
0.0316866785,
0.0235016271,
0.0331202,
0.004388046,
0.0286428556,
0.0673904568,
-0.0476248674,
0.0792510211,
0.0000018025,
-0.0288831685,
0.0126484567,
-0.0031211115,
-0.0303586517,
0.0155532733,
0.0884951875,
0.0598476566,
-0.0280081406,
0.0484845378,
-0.0271309465,
0.0051083947,
0.0126073537,
0.044106476,
0.0152485147,
0.0880226716,
-0.0326864794,
-0.0613245405,
0.0528106764,
-0.0121175982,
-0.0344017334,
0.0210550595,
0.0332040414,
-0.050680954,
0.0054738657,
-0.0183404945,
0.0079705445,
0.0464952923,
-0.0190765858,
-0.0035911181,
0.0047107828,
0.0124677168,
-0.0533120818,
0.0031679522,
0.0262218006,
0.031586498,
0.0056035556,
-0.0616353415,
0.0426999144,
0.0094688479,
-0.0071245381,
0.0013348848,
0.0315755531,
0.0145198153,
-0.0642526075,
-0.0176178124,
0.0165612772,
0.0097363731,
0.0114564262,
0.0308929887,
0.0364511758,
0.0403928794,
-0.007567578,
-0.0217453055,
-0.024350943,
-0.0131346062,
-0.0057194149,
-0.0274295844,
0.0679614171,
-0.0031845933,
0.0095617212,
-0.0272997934,
-0.0375821069,
-0.0723081157,
0.0048867469,
-0.0311736967,
0.0292750765,
-0.0068701422,
-0.0369072296,
0.0088381674,
-0.0281659588,
0.0719280764,
-0.0018765641,
0.0248862877,
-0.0101772388,
-0.039455004,
-0.0266146362,
-0.0112042297,
-0.0272260234,
-0.0306926481,
0.0016498503,
-0.005921327,
-0.048740048,
-0.0152563378,
0.0205454361,
0.0087238103,
0.0067908177,
-0.0288707372,
-0.0073935529,
0.0336024575,
0.01417368,
0.0012976307,
0.0092188399,
0.0437548906,
-0.0158430915,
-0.0149780475,
-0.0087737245,
0.0669578984,
0.0556861982,
-0.0330268554,
0.0564613156,
0.014105184,
-0.0075185299,
-0.0768479109,
0.0088257641,
-0.0337492228,
-0.0321776643,
-0.0560435019,
-0.0368880071,
-0.0544283688,
0.0440664738,
-0.0348405875,
-0.0176753011,
-0.0610354356,
-0.0142602408,
0.0398520455,
-0.0248760264,
0.0667339489,
0.0162700433,
0.0441190973,
0.0640981495,
-0.0110614514,
-0.0172511172,
-0.0433612876,
0.0552184023,
0.0500954725,
0.0444781929,
-0.0045010326,
0.0732149556,
0.0595006943,
-0.0124310423,
-0.0093004508,
0.0348536745,
-0.0142100155,
-0.0430062823,
0.020593917,
0.0136608239,
0.0682978481,
0.0117855901,
-0.0529898703,
0.0738275871,
0.0914968252,
0.0015545528,
0.0278880186,
0.0217705928,
0.047328826,
0.0615951866,
-0.031557329,
-0.0247431118,
0.0046959128,
-0.0013979075,
-0.0191502385,
-0.0217534192,
0.0497843921,
-0.0024633671,
-0.0004701642,
0.0054241009,
-0.0125305383,
-0.0018144578,
-0.0016790127,
0.0042908639,
-0.0268898197,
-0.0331318043,
-0.0328941643,
-0.0080507947,
-0.0883905515,
-0.0118732387,
-0.0320759341,
0.0125357928,
0.0386234447,
0.0684580281,
-0.0338963605,
-0.0143985506,
-0.0647301301,
-0.0158902816,
0.0590834245,
-0.0186802596,
0.0052388106,
0.0123252682,
-0.0246598721,
0.0287748948,
0.027553916,
-0.0042043664,
0.054426644,
0.0373348258,
0.0384413302,
0.0168673601,
-0.0125818104,
-0.0315746963,
0.0519173853,
-0.0406546257,
-0.0216185097,
0.0465224311,
0.0034133445,
0.0474852622,
0.0280436706,
-0.0416313633,
-0.0128807183,
0.0091396729,
-0.0625102073,
-0.0286495145,
0.0344031192,
-0.0042596706,
-0.0454510152,
0.0486092195,
-0.034538731,
-0.0071553979,
0.0588995814,
-0.0063569774,
-0.0620236509,
0.0076826815,
-0.0113022048,
-0.0500422008,
-0.0526939295,
0.0282982886,
-0.0149285654,
0.0435059592,
-0.0258737244,
0.0337687992,
0.029288182,
-0.0009491643,
-0.0238908157,
-0.025093887,
0.0651276782,
-0.0539768711,
-0.0416471995,
-0.0054028486,
-0.0325064771,
0.0402468406,
0.0174441878,
-0.0077729668,
0.0015984201,
-0.0465662926,
-0.0631039292,
-0.0073189544,
-0.0058263806,
0.0494810045,
-0.0127519574,
-0.0212126859,
-0.0375064909,
0.0112832058,
-0.0400981605,
-0.0455973484,
-0.0360068381,
-0.0282127764,
0.0236788858,
-0.0159837659,
-0.0204478521,
-0.0569768548,
0.0089746816,
-0.0320891365,
0.0138112288,
0.0331083089,
-0.0235985406,
-0.0358056836,
0.0216043498,
0.0054376917,
0.0059834686,
0.001159525,
-0.0344963782,
-0.0176005233,
-0.0063012894,
0.0404741466,
0.0696841106,
0.008605279,
-0.0138547663,
-0.0163438674,
0.0158496778,
0.0115779722,
0.0233171023,
-0.003526604,
0.050766293,
-0.0043270923,
-0.0474745035,
0.0270465687,
0.0373025686,
0.0196001381,
-0.0138420602,
-0.0136983357,
-0.0032390817,
0.0215354767,
-0.0110025108,
0.0359731093,
-0.0475925133,
-0.0176187791,
-0.0219003893,
-0.0550845638,
-0.0245210025,
0.0202896055,
-0.1026386246,
-0.019118065,
-0.0301897079,
-0.025483435,
-0.053819254,
0.0490891337,
0.0149691841,
0.0117218634,
0.0056279604,
-0.0230248049,
-0.0021892753,
0.0037922878,
0.0488947369,
-0.0475477353,
-0.0014843576,
-0.0194196701,
0.0119283702,
0.0099143516,
-0.0296180118,
-0.0205297824,
-0.0745192096,
-0.0471222848,
0.0048562335,
-0.0027269605,
-0.066849865,
-0.0145383375,
-0.0611684397,
0.0461847708,
0.0604403429,
-0.0036000484,
0.0086539099,
-0.0195307415,
0.0614270866,
-0.0293824542,
-0.0281329118,
-0.0216188189,
-0.0124848634,
0.0157745145,
-0.001655652,
0.0157387145,
0.0258842986,
-0.004911799,
-0.0503380597,
0.0115807755,
-0.0079190154,
-0.0669015795,
-0.0073911091,
0.0713920966,
-0.0319301113,
0.0034991158,
0.127267316,
-0.0048106574,
-0.0419521444,
-0.0295198932,
-0.0005073353,
0.0141773839,
0.0147312544,
0.0384886079,
-0.0558508784,
-0.0382790305,
0.0074924952,
0.0377889127,
-0.0119083067,
-0.0277382936,
-0.0327769145,
-0.0655243099,
0.0471391231,
-0.0295621697,
-0.0615341105,
0.0331306569,
-0.0411966443,
-0.0402541347,
-0.030668376,
-0.0319877081,
-0.0413704067,
0.003346764,
0.0092829289,
-0.0047679236,
-0.0310358983,
-0.008655997,
0.0595581159,
-0.0413176417,
0.0286580678,
0.034246996,
0.106285125,
-0.0384494253,
-0.0365147814,
0.0010381818,
-0.0186321866,
-0.003665624,
-0.0132701257,
0.0527807288,
-0.0347243249,
-0.0079778973,
-0.0131676625,
0.0590752661,
-0.0327813439,
-0.013129863,
0.041546192,
0.0186219737,
0.0124002798,
-0.0217032991,
0.0162063446,
-0.0011538983,
0.013174748,
0.0901800022,
-0.0017593701,
-0.0478298292,
-0.0612061806,
0.0017078962,
0.0252278186,
-0.0297774188,
-0.0448065735,
-0.0053381142,
0.0328104571,
-0.0448599197,
-0.0772117078,
-0.0192693938,
-0.0443089157,
-0.0109765111,
0.0099547049,
0.0430467203,
0.0224803761,
0.002129388,
-0.0473900177,
0.0047630356,
-0.0436217375,
0.0799358636,
-0.0412540324,
0.0372765362,
0.0355316512,
-0.0280512013,
-0.0058334647,
0.0264536627,
-0.0815585107,
-0.030364804,
0.0171000138,
-0.0166599005,
0.017236637,
0.0248008482,
-0.0451345295,
-0.0384502225,
0.0454377495,
0.0375708006,
-0.0211034343,
0.0432366133,
0.0230859872,
0.0023076891,
-0.0475641116,
0.0009048934,
0.0052476577,
0.0251099374,
0.034010414,
-0.0446216464,
0.0008830683,
-0.0331512392,
-0.0261262432,
0.0367276929,
0.0256510619,
-0.0452011414,
-0.0004974386,
-0.0288751647,
-0.0061890534,
-0.0051257946,
0.0178800318,
-0.0145997219,
-0.0361589603,
0.0499402024,
0.0090509877,
-0.0374348685,
0.0548262484,
-0.0172150508,
0.0663072318,
-0.0136140762,
0.0540901907,
0.0023910676,
0.0551161543,
-0.0442601442,
-0.0093481336,
0.0274681784,
0.0040943748,
-0.0069251386,
0.0686562657,
0.0021487202,
0.0084137823,
-0.0156417191,
-0.0043934728,
-0.0031189849,
0.0529308133,
-0.0922984704,
0.0108903637,
-0.0367615111,
-0.0020749622,
0.0327296443,
-0.015333863,
0.0734079629,
-0.0186774191,
0.0213725194,
-0.0360729024,
0.0576405562,
-0.0255500209,
0.0130250165,
-0.0566829778,
-0.0124526443,
-0.0272792187,
0.0304945242,
0.0787892714,
0.0538828336,
0.0296990667,
0.0040060775,
-0.0402996466,
-0.0380456597,
-0.0427855514,
0.0301979128,
-0.02241024,
0.0059351143,
-0.0124918735,
-0.0569516756,
-0.0265993793,
0.1017024815,
-0.039756041,
0.0445363522,
-0.0135474075,
-0.0281780344,
0.0187816117,
-0.0330158547,
0.0144569017,
-0.0456454232,
-0.0252800342,
0.0128706619,
-0.0369073004,
-0.0062328018,
-5.391393085e-33,
0.0200808998,
-0.0258647073,
0.0065297331,
0.0695881173,
-0.0122972652,
0.010640448,
-0.0209139399,
-0.0207582749,
-0.0076000243,
0.0019202435,
-0.0383025967,
0.0253174845,
0.0194505677,
0.0294302572,
-0.0261126682,
0.0119264796,
0.0377772711,
-0.028982209,
-0.0363188162,
0.0249660201,
0.0263279974,
0.0132527165,
0.0322128832,
-0.0805340335,
-0.0091150235,
-0.0398041978,
-0.0527905002,
-0.0140428841,
-0.0285825059,
0.0182707123,
-0.0192891303,
0.0253570918,
0.0158069599,
-0.0061347694,
0.0077642743,
0.0687586293,
-0.0681135729,
0.0086722746,
-0.0349969491,
0.0260745175,
0.0308322068,
-0.0482021421,
0.0108454367,
-0.0267330706,
-0.0151872607,
0.0080589242,
0.0688990727,
-0.0045100781,
0.0028271284,
-0.0609061718,
-0.0419626907,
0.0312133674,
-0.0204574205,
-0.0165406689,
0.0348627195,
0.0354278348,
-0.0040079677,
-0.0120310001,
-0.0833181664,
0.005336714,
-0.0378340706,
-0.0155291473,
-0.024012899,
0.0356886722,
-0.0110019539,
0.0363075584,
0.0631451458,
0.0365918986,
-0.0278781485,
-0.0073257862,
0.0451379195,
0.0278805029,
0.051883705,
0.0923066363,
-0.0029240255,
-0.01315937,
-0.0354439653,
0.0349798799,
0.0282904077,
-0.0369549729,
0.0113603473,
-0.0083185704,
-0.0710940361,
-0.0320406668,
-0.0361795425,
-0.0750919133,
-0.0214237776,
0.0461956076,
0.0241536815,
0.0045458525,
-0.0220377631,
-0.0059990548,
0.021556152,
-0.0580357574,
0.0063029961,
0.0002705343,
-0.02571702,
0.0723347291,
0.0038086784,
0.012923806,
-0.0486290827,
-0.028200686,
0.0201866608,
0.0626814067,
0.0407380685,
-0.0136813186,
0.0775706843,
0.0443166904,
-0.0690006912,
0.0038697601,
0.0049805767,
0.0439122096,
0.0077900593,
0.0378645882,
-0.0116832228,
0.0082636382,
0.0306488015,
0.0308373831,
0.0315028206,
0.0359823182,
-0.0364057682,
-0.0308637694,
0.0069448482,
-0.0099221533,
-0.0238560326,
0.0083937785,
0.0223893132,
-0.0298058037,
0.0120236613,
-0.0144208847,
0.0293391589,
-0.0519204102,
2.289e-7,
0.0376974642,
0.0185269155,
0.0600075275,
-0.0199675895,
0.034669973,
0.037058048,
0.0368877351,
0.0321019627,
-0.0233966447,
0.0205811504,
0.0311086588,
0.0273730345,
0.1051328853,
-0.0073530287,
-0.0891270116,
0.0174634624,
-0.0484951884,
0.0033711956,
-0.053505674,
-0.0074101756,
0.0370194651,
0.0679978281,
0.0313264988,
-0.0544648245,
-0.0345657133,
-0.0895682648,
0.0491709635,
-0.0038374935,
0.0244832095,
0.0443149805,
0.0205589775,
0.0072166268,
0.008012197,
0.00791167,
-0.021466475,
0.0215472337,
0.0040195887,
0.0759326369,
-0.0074885534,
-0.0043587061,
-0.0146562001,
-0.0070742024,
-0.0308768172,
-0.0048842267,
0.0334998779,
0.0496837161,
-0.0207879394,
-0.0120376674,
-0.0145447729,
-0.0082841059,
0.0076384055,
-0.0003820615,
0.0080392165,
0.0383595042,
0.0128047122,
-0.0435529873,
-0.0305434894,
-0.0448734164,
-0.0415246151,
-0.0188125763,
-0.0455133133,
0.0191490706,
-0.0304706618,
0.0153102949,
0.0480294824,
-0.0931546167,
0.0257728081,
2.112924463e-34,
0.0136599736,
0.0029326198,
-0.0260585714,
0.0195890535,
0.0310092997,
0.0145941479,
0.0425895564,
0.0063920007,
-0.0272229575,
-0.0424593575,
0.0092995297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16738v1 | Improving Conversational Recommendation Systems via Bias Analysis and Language-Model-Enhanced Data Augmentation | 2023-10-25T16:11:55 | 2023-10-25T16:11:55 | Xi Wang, Hossein A. Rahmani, Jiqun Liu, Emine Yilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Conversational Recommendation System (CRS) is a rapidly growing research area
that has gained significant attention alongside advancements in language
modelling techniques. However, the current state of conversational
recommendation faces numerous challenges due to its relative novelty and
limited existing contributions. In this study, we delve into benchmark datasets
for developing CRS models and address potential biases arising from the
feedback loop inherent in multi-turn interactions, including selection bias and
multiple popularity bias variants. Drawing inspiration from the success of
generative data via using language models and data augmentation techniques, we
present two novel strategies, 'Once-Aug' and 'PopNudge', to enhance model
performance while mitigating biases. Through extensive experiments on ReDial
and TG-ReDial benchmark datasets, we show a consistent improvement of CRS
techniques with our data augmentation approaches and offer additional insights
on addressing multiple newly formulated biases. | [
0.0488701463,
0.0621456057,
-0.0110527165,
0.0358999297,
-0.0026943707,
-0.0027238473,
0.0162715036,
-0.0308260098,
0.0469115153,
-0.0155953271,
-0.0565621965,
-0.0167615954,
0.0079290783,
0.0556249171,
-0.0003246433,
-0.0274358168,
0.0199752338,
-0.0258405283,
0.0286794938,
-0.0322666615,
0.0433417931,
0.0350415446,
0.0131480861,
0.035169784,
-0.0002182824,
0.0285782535,
0.0037136769,
0.0080180429,
-0.0202734247,
-0.0077880695,
0.0141355991,
0.0574949905,
0.0174905974,
0.0604540035,
0.0000019947,
-0.0355670452,
-0.0114170276,
-0.0330734104,
-0.0167453643,
-0.0287528764,
0.0875972733,
0.0270225201,
-0.004134736,
0.0171879437,
-0.0374769792,
0.0046837563,
0.0440785326,
0.0238162652,
0.0052844011,
0.0369986966,
-0.02000314,
-0.0006925807,
-0.006691047,
-0.037263155,
0.0703486428,
-0.016550554,
0.016944509,
0.0144179668,
0.0188607294,
0.0228759944,
-0.0261964984,
0.0099783149,
-0.0269382894,
-0.0633834824,
0.027334692,
0.0333377682,
-0.0316345878,
-0.0271753464,
-0.0063824398,
0.0985973403,
0.0014125927,
-0.0260271113,
-0.0125548244,
-0.0001691727,
0.0094832014,
-0.0209022705,
-0.0588015728,
-0.0540809892,
0.0160103999,
0.0334580354,
-0.0242773201,
-0.0063920105,
0.0565362908,
0.0020746011,
0.0195778161,
0.0647011772,
0.0330862962,
-0.029167572,
0.0141554466,
0.0109032867,
0.0495348051,
-0.0385985114,
0.0391667448,
-0.0405102149,
-0.0617312789,
0.009020688,
0.0026696089,
0.0309690069,
0.0188285988,
-0.061801482,
0.0013213607,
0.0160053223,
0.007458474,
0.0454211794,
0.0255682543,
-0.0217384826,
0.0138870366,
-0.033547204,
-0.0362733155,
-0.0310033336,
-0.0023671358,
0.0282814708,
-0.0153900022,
0.0076569598,
-0.0301669911,
-0.0272963326,
-0.0489223935,
0.0340432748,
0.0012420681,
0.0077310973,
0.0025342957,
0.0417796597,
-0.0067872815,
0.0117820669,
-0.0347811021,
0.0429351069,
-0.0591915287,
0.0121210925,
0.0119669279,
-0.071707353,
0.0166410916,
0.0081395637,
0.0313334204,
-0.045146279,
-0.0205715969,
0.0241812654,
0.0122784087,
-0.0392538272,
0.0056633605,
-0.0002259573,
-0.0192707386,
-0.0447167866,
-0.0388986729,
-0.0538809411,
0.0861999318,
0.0213951543,
-0.0014379208,
-0.0116355615,
-0.0002669013,
-0.0013234336,
-0.0505030714,
0.068681024,
-0.0155664906,
-0.0151424557,
0.0103303278,
0.0149866585,
-0.005879988,
0.0542593077,
0.0146965235,
0.0364892632,
0.0766945854,
-0.0172760747,
0.03403005,
0.0431238748,
0.0175072923,
0.0162406545,
0.0019738264,
0.0115248188,
-0.036391262,
0.0108164977,
0.0443723314,
0.0342255235,
-0.0646625906,
-0.0141394362,
0.0521563329,
0.0113056032,
0.0096826144,
0.0429454967,
0.0123354169,
0.019906193,
-0.051112432,
-0.0197524335,
-0.018828392,
0.0200198479,
-0.021571476,
-0.0317160897,
0.0717249736,
0.0173802581,
-0.0407107323,
-0.0357065573,
0.0417374,
-0.0132744042,
0.0435549952,
0.0246720836,
0.0161263887,
-0.0024069969,
-0.0262975749,
0.0295148175,
0.0739836916,
-0.0631171986,
-0.0031779308,
-0.0017318146,
0.0305334851,
0.0791114494,
0.0608353652,
0.0021578646,
-0.0168249104,
-0.0121702952,
-0.0286023021,
-0.0138592422,
0.0576401278,
-0.0431099795,
0.0388042107,
-0.0769647062,
-0.0425760411,
0.0645356253,
-0.0005362472,
0.0593878999,
-0.0229209736,
0.0039606122,
-0.0052216831,
-0.0350562893,
-0.0243224353,
-0.0458793752,
-0.0033295858,
0.001950941,
0.0312579311,
-0.0188393984,
0.0318378173,
0.0134625537,
-0.002459141,
-0.0232621431,
0.013146773,
0.0179407578,
0.0088141784,
0.0309598632,
-0.0228238311,
-0.0900040418,
0.023653416,
-0.0359200388,
-0.0330892093,
0.0286852885,
-0.0175493732,
-0.0405794047,
0.0452484787,
-0.0119958837,
0.0808457062,
-0.0214002542,
0.0152090611,
0.0070061251,
0.05413986,
-0.0132260071,
0.0293797441,
-0.0112862028,
0.0103715099,
0.0128502138,
-0.004145477,
0.010169087,
-0.0593007468,
-0.0379133523,
0.0072239274,
0.0162567664,
-0.0078143477,
0.0422552601,
-0.0382930078,
-0.0453059524,
-0.0295509081,
-0.0921004564,
-0.0053632474,
0.0045920508,
-0.0180394463,
-0.0078686904,
0.0562950969,
0.0038999578,
-0.0467388667,
-0.0449284762,
-0.0148477964,
0.0116161788,
0.0372174121,
-0.0148232402,
0.0144374659,
-0.0401104018,
-0.0755147114,
-0.0228574332,
0.0070625213,
0.0385293104,
0.0200138949,
0.0212166589,
0.000870123,
-0.0526925363,
-0.0579699874,
0.0022799207,
-0.0581449457,
0.0150911994,
-0.0228955373,
0.0044890065,
0.0397607945,
-0.0247499831,
0.0073237228,
0.0235878415,
0.0054308041,
-0.0386512317,
-0.0788702071,
-0.0132060023,
-0.048468817,
0.0168665722,
-0.0279391073,
-0.0451395959,
-0.0075828065,
0.0080950679,
-0.0146881398,
0.0041892217,
-0.0204238538,
0.0093297018,
0.0408404619,
-0.0079317652,
-0.0291786753,
-0.0074282507,
-0.0232902411,
0.0407209098,
-0.0275119822,
-0.0533348434,
0.065568611,
-0.0287785437,
-0.0483016334,
-0.0421609133,
-0.0084716855,
-0.020203121,
-0.0379252993,
0.032715708,
0.0112351356,
-0.0261318479,
-0.0363867991,
0.0091439635,
-0.008618922,
0.002972004,
-0.041530747,
0.0349396393,
0.019036673,
-0.0043493174,
0.0483200662,
-0.0310222134,
-0.026262382,
-0.0488460995,
0.0023416097,
-0.0074711372,
0.0568325557,
-0.0102001186,
-0.0357501768,
-0.0305408258,
-0.0332259387,
0.025832653,
0.0067243571,
-0.0174480323,
0.0010190842,
0.0259061195,
0.0734802932,
-0.0345178396,
0.0249726102,
0.0052657519,
0.0294838026,
0.0352398641,
0.0366592333,
-0.04498671,
-0.0170806497,
0.0071967845,
0.0567307509,
0.0198320169,
0.0000536002,
0.0290228687,
-0.001797743,
0.039155826,
-0.0171298888,
0.0911261812,
0.0195694026,
-0.116506353,
0.0203078128,
-0.0098563815,
0.0762724876,
0.0073385667,
0.0316415094,
-0.0833611935,
0.0037488053,
-0.0071990932,
0.0380792432,
0.0199265778,
-0.0374209993,
-0.0133785782,
-0.1319414377,
0.0580491461,
-0.0002105747,
0.0009283982,
0.0058066398,
-0.0431500077,
0.0012659158,
-0.0238730945,
0.0363979749,
-0.0097413203,
0.0139838094,
-0.0015507535,
-0.0087730391,
-0.0097217364,
-0.0696616024,
0.0338622034,
-0.0195211023,
0.0695427135,
0.0576520935,
0.0475105718,
0.0206584223,
0.0107922945,
0.0438360423,
0.0369647481,
-0.0373633578,
-0.040937081,
0.0561459661,
-0.0143872323,
0.0117220432,
-0.0333654992,
0.0223416518,
0.004422266,
0.0016600492,
-0.0102994042,
0.0278446916,
-0.0043052342,
-0.0264330655,
-0.01644722,
0.0270596948,
0.0761140957,
0.0804505497,
0.0401112251,
-0.0517546944,
0.0037710452,
-0.0781529918,
0.008808665,
-0.0273079667,
-0.026295403,
-0.049483344,
0.0292373672,
-0.0119253602,
-0.0585342124,
-0.0363578387,
-0.021653669,
0.0101700444,
0.0001847447,
0.0512878858,
-0.0203241277,
-0.0356285907,
0.0683788136,
0.0132390745,
0.0042531341,
-0.0049545891,
-0.0477234311,
-0.0260055922,
-0.0066681169,
-0.0816032812,
-0.016673699,
-0.015558972,
-0.0796645731,
-0.0639949515,
-0.0079103755,
0.0502170958,
0.0297262948,
0.0833153129,
-0.0619510151,
-0.0917624012,
0.0036555587,
0.0287965741,
0.0035082607,
-0.022672601,
0.01613212,
0.0355041437,
0.0122528439,
0.038695544,
-0.0488591082,
0.0247080773,
0.0008159294,
-0.0044414583,
-0.047420565,
-0.0315902941,
-0.0193030052,
-0.005267146,
0.0584249869,
-0.0095034214,
0.0534219332,
-0.0322044902,
0.0169664957,
-0.0367218293,
-0.0252049901,
-0.0596440434,
-0.001953247,
0.0483354032,
-0.0123571958,
-0.0302650072,
-0.0432933569,
-0.0689494014,
0.0045145918,
-0.0716970563,
0.0170894749,
0.0400638506,
-0.0420522653,
0.0573777668,
0.0004519265,
0.0141345132,
0.0341311805,
0.0212960411,
0.045144964,
-0.0015266598,
0.0267888065,
0.0014337228,
-0.0528253317,
0.0018524993,
0.0322398171,
-0.0482469536,
-0.0006098851,
-0.0101298122,
0.020755263,
0.0283484682,
-0.0564788245,
0.0731190369,
0.0154739441,
0.0190302078,
-0.0272054672,
0.0345418267,
-0.0008901349,
-0.0669177473,
0.0125410492,
0.0207381975,
-0.0001860931,
0.0556395091,
0.0866737589,
-0.0372825675,
0.000971857,
-0.0091867298,
-0.0406562127,
-0.0015521023,
-0.017982468,
-0.0224644151,
0.0592254736,
-0.0369677655,
0.0061738663,
-0.0357729197,
-0.0720035732,
-0.0185684022,
-0.0337290391,
0.023000814,
-0.0010989552,
0.0509828739,
0.0463185646,
-0.0141454209,
0.033453729,
-0.073804386,
-0.0086047715,
-0.0271803346,
-0.0219861213,
-0.0269988347,
-6.428143103e-33,
0.0271169133,
0.0136184487,
-0.0190746803,
0.0044631665,
-0.0185776632,
-0.0299674924,
-0.0452121906,
0.0132284854,
-0.0056111179,
0.0157756489,
-0.0214967411,
0.0126782767,
0.013233887,
0.0496447124,
-0.0001982503,
-0.0157852471,
0.0615751073,
0.0509717949,
-0.0313330218,
0.0433973446,
0.030724084,
0.0473561734,
0.0278319772,
-0.0867057815,
0.0498523638,
-0.0328408666,
0.0002294227,
0.0214824658,
0.0384590328,
0.0753761679,
-0.0074654804,
0.0668287128,
0.0015433573,
-0.0203396417,
-0.0263990723,
-0.0044523864,
-0.0512955412,
-0.0130348913,
0.0491570421,
0.016087858,
0.0268621799,
0.006374401,
0.0244437177,
-0.0099481167,
-0.0194046833,
0.0089002792,
0.0228177868,
-0.0119356476,
-0.0533930697,
0.0513816588,
0.0078728851,
0.0246108808,
-0.0311616939,
-0.0095609026,
0.0119705768,
0.0341440625,
0.0211270396,
0.0637560785,
-0.065737009,
0.0434605666,
0.0108768186,
-0.0063971747,
0.0188825037,
0.0048661479,
-0.0129446294,
0.0572395399,
0.0364114307,
0.0083864685,
0.0036531386,
-0.0262195915,
-0.0223955791,
0.0602130964,
-0.0225755256,
0.061376024,
0.0260049757,
0.0070363535,
-0.035247352,
0.0377867147,
0.0576995127,
-0.0249755811,
0.0250423346,
0.0166263394,
-0.0731385276,
-0.0529187135,
-0.015834108,
-0.0200383998,
-0.0468443185,
-0.0495309196,
0.0103402659,
0.0399057232,
-0.0062795826,
0.0088714724,
0.0253662225,
-0.0587438233,
-0.0750530958,
0.0509477854,
-0.0307973493,
-0.0153312935,
0.0218915641,
-0.0076908628,
-0.0643913075,
0.0088717919,
0.0085502826,
-0.0224540867,
-0.0443453714,
0.007376025,
0.0189808346,
0.0157240462,
-0.0428771973,
0.0056206635,
-0.0031668765,
-0.0207701027,
-0.0159644093,
0.0143775269,
0.0444767848,
0.0174311753,
-0.0350627787,
0.0775967985,
0.0322824046,
0.0805515945,
-0.0158153549,
-0.0584366359,
-0.0084305787,
0.0103936726,
-0.0419253819,
-0.0452700332,
0.0038996802,
-0.039971374,
0.0667150393,
-0.0301246233,
-0.0342047699,
-0.0465525575,
2.697e-7,
0.0112263309,
0.0219806302,
-0.0164387841,
-0.0204175226,
0.0447295345,
0.0360796861,
-0.0025149141,
0.0348252356,
0.0463958085,
0.0363547243,
0.0113683697,
-0.0067573083,
0.0253703874,
0.0230471548,
-0.0514458269,
-0.0060813585,
-0.0868458599,
0.0155227752,
-0.0214840882,
-0.0211728755,
-0.0125183249,
0.0973981097,
0.0505768806,
-0.009353756,
-0.0004794637,
0.009104697,
0.0457484946,
-0.0682254583,
-0.0253405795,
0.0388791822,
0.0150136678,
-0.0062394394,
-0.012633645,
-0.0154363327,
-0.0463450551,
0.020270396,
0.0028847875,
0.0212888848,
0.0046776133,
-0.0328758657,
0.0125504704,
0.0156574976,
0.0015844881,
-0.0568754859,
0.0685058907,
0.0196260493,
-0.0171736106,
-0.04325765,
-0.0313244276,
0.0037393365,
0.0349563546,
-0.0309157036,
-0.04557788,
-0.0033639011,
0.016990982,
0.0067396029,
-0.030396929,
-0.0692107528,
0.0001364921,
-0.0102263503,
-0.0467836373,
-0.0568112656,
-0.0214413032,
0.0050243842,
-0.009160107,
-0.0190149583,
0.0611357838,
2.243214237e-34,
0.0585800782,
0.0051011378,
0.0082625011,
-0.0001581175,
0.045301348,
-0.0285844393,
0.0542419069,
0.0076556071,
0.0668510124,
-0.0784363747,
-0.0190401599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16731v1 | Disentangling Extraction and Reasoning in Multi-hop Spatial Reasoning | 2023-10-25T16:00:47 | 2023-10-25T16:00:47 | Roshanak Mirzaee, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Spatial reasoning over text is challenging as the models not only need to
extract the direct spatial information from the text but also reason over those
and infer implicit spatial relations. Recent studies highlight the struggles
even large language models encounter when it comes to performing spatial
reasoning over text. In this paper, we explore the potential benefits of
disentangling the processes of information extraction and reasoning in models
to address this challenge. To explore this, we design various models that
disentangle extraction and reasoning(either symbolic or neural) and compare
them with state-of-the-art(SOTA) baselines with no explicit design for these
parts. Our experimental results consistently demonstrate the efficacy of
disentangling, showcasing its ability to enhance models' generalizability
within realistic data domains. | [
0.0256285686,
0.0622965731,
-0.013387234,
0.0629026294,
-0.0687565058,
0.0449285507,
0.0331342481,
-0.0205796827,
0.0213594679,
-0.034081649,
-0.022823086,
0.0242327452,
0.0303733628,
0.0386100188,
0.012960433,
-0.0630482659,
0.030354619,
-0.0501062497,
0.0188208576,
0.0010466047,
-0.0313316397,
0.030681083,
-0.0166423954,
0.0063199713,
-0.028177375,
-0.0153864725,
-0.0120223872,
-0.0367065631,
0.0226869769,
-0.0315730684,
-0.0146087185,
-0.0001798259,
0.043995671,
0.0219414979,
0.0000018712,
0.0260317437,
-0.0069538215,
0.0355644487,
0.0009356965,
-0.0099682165,
-0.0571482517,
-0.043011345,
0.0309725292,
-0.0307621695,
-0.0153122218,
-0.0155107314,
0.0269950237,
0.0500565358,
0.0219429899,
0.043398574,
-0.0186302625,
-0.0679991767,
-0.0003622813,
-0.0106129609,
0.0049021579,
0.0237739459,
0.0026935067,
0.004900259,
0.0049090432,
0.0591239966,
-0.0314791612,
0.0237584021,
0.0526506044,
0.0473297052,
-0.0232174434,
0.0633716434,
0.0015369076,
0.0166391786,
-0.0108026303,
0.0654478967,
0.0106870756,
-0.0140788546,
0.0456557162,
0.0142644495,
0.0067613688,
0.0178948175,
-0.0696324334,
0.0003141107,
-0.0217383001,
0.0278339759,
-0.0079788528,
0.0007708258,
0.0394662879,
0.0089369779,
-0.0497124642,
0.0940588713,
0.0017317076,
-0.0323841833,
-0.0256327409,
-0.0022466073,
-0.0136453761,
-0.0458116159,
0.0154555943,
0.0620810986,
-0.0082762875,
0.0315248668,
0.0356575362,
0.0548996367,
-0.0113761686,
-0.0462272204,
0.0317258053,
0.0289124697,
-0.0127323046,
0.0777979642,
-0.0652196929,
0.0451930352,
-0.0315650702,
0.0832541138,
0.0136138899,
-0.0158986282,
-0.037849281,
-0.0191406813,
-0.0192894377,
0.0561260246,
-0.0738175213,
-0.030316174,
0.0353324674,
0.0004035242,
-0.0210663639,
0.0120538687,
-0.0412532948,
0.0562557988,
0.0012374894,
-0.0488484576,
-0.0024582359,
0.0181425251,
-0.0346910506,
0.0180970076,
0.0052198642,
0.0039990977,
-0.0268365629,
-0.0054806196,
0.0286123417,
-0.0450681932,
-0.0325039737,
0.0659117401,
-0.0042746319,
-0.0203791428,
-0.0192365721,
-0.0300459005,
-0.020916922,
-0.0815954208,
0.0515023991,
-0.0390600972,
0.025030246,
0.006724332,
-0.0442963727,
-0.0538283512,
-0.0135773662,
-0.0117915394,
-0.057168819,
0.0539843887,
0.0176684465,
-0.0007253661,
0.0526702218,
0.0168234725,
0.0063369619,
0.0758135319,
0.0214499049,
0.0837656483,
0.0086834207,
0.0195167288,
-0.0019002937,
-0.0017943615,
0.0238734614,
0.0058491225,
-0.0662442222,
0.0155434255,
-0.0252980571,
0.020039754,
0.0070347949,
0.0573771484,
-0.0520452596,
0.0017623092,
0.0231394544,
0.0901659355,
0.021561753,
-0.0283383392,
0.0540154055,
0.0125595722,
-0.0165785942,
-0.0058168313,
-0.0788736045,
0.0403683707,
-0.0148152923,
0.0037093412,
0.0134367887,
0.0413004644,
-0.0328030363,
-0.0518819503,
-0.0376692936,
-0.0026999274,
0.0098102633,
0.0141575309,
0.0680981725,
0.0097735273,
-0.0227372386,
0.0452937633,
0.0316244513,
-0.0112586822,
0.0041542458,
-0.0124832317,
0.0416175015,
0.0069684694,
0.0217712093,
-0.0008953206,
0.0045036785,
-0.0027187753,
0.0195742343,
0.0218186919,
0.0482281111,
-0.0145409545,
0.0349179842,
-0.0385069959,
-0.0605336539,
-0.0041242726,
0.0570967942,
0.0026348257,
0.0538192727,
-0.016565863,
0.0294865239,
-0.0647800639,
0.0249438994,
0.0136856083,
-0.015423649,
-0.0250324495,
-0.0632511228,
0.0346743055,
-0.0120654078,
-0.0279119071,
0.0073958398,
-0.0050018411,
0.0124664586,
-0.0130627407,
-0.0250002164,
0.0205086451,
-0.0587287173,
-0.0668623373,
-0.0020287402,
-0.0013291077,
-0.019387627,
0.0012540091,
-0.0513268933,
-0.0118178427,
0.034996517,
-0.0296575222,
0.0263402537,
-0.0045520277,
-0.0173507556,
0.0392753892,
-0.0166359637,
-0.0459861383,
0.0703367367,
-0.0176910236,
0.0045438623,
-0.0225393735,
0.0339543819,
0.0234807897,
0.011983823,
0.0451050289,
0.0063352045,
-0.0160107631,
-0.0083361063,
-0.0498685613,
-0.007558105,
-0.0359100215,
-0.0370845459,
-0.0296405647,
-0.0113036446,
-0.0209887177,
0.0231593885,
0.0118547883,
-0.0463637225,
-0.0168593321,
-0.0295024775,
-0.0012907119,
-0.0231794454,
-0.0448805876,
0.0391393751,
0.0512280315,
-0.0484549552,
0.0121479612,
-0.0352818035,
-0.0286676697,
-0.0493399203,
0.0719178841,
-0.0005354715,
-0.0301499739,
-0.0280050002,
-0.0185799729,
-0.0361904688,
0.0075532147,
-0.0080660433,
-0.0011185551,
0.0381024256,
-0.0479168743,
-0.0118018072,
0.0509212688,
-0.0447078161,
0.0151356189,
0.0125980107,
-0.0420697555,
-0.0665932894,
0.0264481958,
-0.0575815476,
0.0631562397,
-0.004141774,
-0.0129678193,
-0.0119557101,
0.0727481619,
-0.0169778001,
-0.0058736508,
-0.035084676,
0.0233134199,
-0.0210044403,
0.0085007157,
-0.0524113029,
0.0057377908,
0.0299787372,
0.0733520016,
-0.06651631,
-0.0344017334,
0.0462092347,
-0.0290998407,
0.0262795594,
-0.0448125079,
0.0300535914,
-0.0341798365,
0.1225337684,
-0.0038855467,
0.0210794862,
-0.0076253652,
-0.0427319892,
-0.0052024373,
-0.0670856684,
-0.0218923613,
0.0084721288,
0.0326089039,
-0.0660882443,
0.010704346,
0.0171124116,
-0.0255461521,
-0.0150940455,
-0.0015737502,
-0.0441407673,
0.0106433919,
-0.0367567055,
-0.0214794669,
0.0411139168,
0.0351775996,
0.0320415497,
0.0494323783,
-0.0548234098,
-0.0177268311,
-0.043656148,
0.0432977565,
0.0581575893,
0.0565769784,
-0.0265565794,
-0.0201497693,
-0.0134414183,
0.0325073078,
-0.053446658,
-0.0173632186,
-0.0057095792,
0.0548250228,
0.0305634681,
-0.0017314971,
-0.0137868756,
0.0062195524,
0.0623232536,
-0.0776115134,
-0.0802301094,
0.0556879565,
0.0697102249,
0.014620956,
-0.0059313714,
-0.0300753918,
0.0300293136,
0.0118813338,
0.0001485308,
-0.0023439415,
-0.0435890444,
0.0247000512,
-0.0601587035,
0.0481210686,
-0.0054419888,
0.009052597,
-0.0746880546,
0.0576968156,
0.004414578,
-0.0954765156,
-0.0773690715,
-0.0334047824,
0.0008971688,
0.0306573045,
-0.0160861779,
-0.0152131049,
0.0071739098,
0.0176305845,
0.0240250845,
-0.0263689552,
0.0084065376,
0.0053742677,
-0.0183128659,
0.0149740959,
0.022979144,
0.0682109147,
0.0357055813,
-0.0769638047,
0.0308496486,
0.0141078988,
0.0347355083,
-0.0337272957,
0.0680422634,
0.0368979163,
-0.0001599946,
-0.0108018853,
0.0112273479,
-0.0481656417,
-0.0404264331,
-0.0272406135,
0.0650718138,
-0.0248996709,
0.011858277,
-0.0201991908,
0.0422827005,
-0.025028972,
0.0410419926,
0.0309696496,
0.0302797295,
-0.1000705138,
-0.0419885144,
-0.0302139781,
-0.0705510154,
0.0040739714,
0.0238528736,
0.0176419411,
-0.0046074158,
-0.0445226729,
-0.0527951866,
0.0068105035,
0.058620397,
-0.0052871695,
-0.0132295657,
0.0035599065,
-0.0346892066,
-0.0407489017,
0.0601987392,
-0.0447980501,
0.0016420129,
0.0762248337,
0.0380960628,
-0.0057557807,
-0.040025916,
-0.0253567155,
0.0073446184,
-0.0608654022,
-0.0570791885,
-0.0001689753,
0.0337153748,
0.0226419531,
0.0430809148,
-0.0253283847,
-0.0007769485,
0.0278974343,
0.0127578583,
-0.0138357198,
0.0022201454,
0.0327400416,
0.030152861,
0.0058674025,
0.0150532452,
0.0008295334,
0.0402014777,
0.0579381734,
0.0080994889,
-0.0560316555,
0.0837372541,
-0.0041335761,
-0.0143947834,
0.0784740299,
0.0461986512,
-0.0352107324,
-0.0304936543,
-0.0028815134,
-0.045777332,
-0.0032238269,
-0.0102149798,
0.024404157,
0.0262334552,
0.0388952643,
-0.0225428808,
-0.0182478335,
0.0640513822,
0.0218533892,
0.0042556766,
-0.0766830668,
0.0177440662,
0.0064936266,
-0.0030521313,
0.0093295071,
-0.0338922143,
0.0253618695,
-0.0334504023,
0.0512382351,
-0.0246052798,
0.0294753797,
0.0445886515,
-0.0179394856,
-0.0569363832,
-0.0002029193,
-0.0828456655,
-0.0463314541,
0.0124944113,
-0.0059506893,
0.0374333113,
-0.0112549579,
0.0009446591,
0.0037462569,
-0.0067444071,
0.05166924,
0.017425444,
0.0365725905,
-0.0209879894,
0.0240288991,
0.0125887301,
-0.0224550813,
-0.038259618,
0.0147768036,
-0.0238330048,
0.0431964956,
-0.0077798413,
-0.0141420309,
-0.019558711,
-0.0221828744,
-0.0121296309,
0.0168151353,
0.0022804495,
-0.0033874628,
-0.0582983606,
-0.0714422688,
-0.0214156359,
0.035085693,
0.0056401775,
0.0243627857,
0.0141228233,
0.0295824651,
0.0020732018,
-0.0686554685,
-0.0382256433,
0.0038301051,
0.0112572983,
-0.0176747795,
-0.016970247,
-6.243025518e-33,
-0.0176820699,
-0.0463228822,
0.0646910146,
-0.042960301,
-0.0155393761,
0.0174622554,
-0.0418621972,
-0.0442225114,
-0.0317791253,
0.0237584319,
-0.0016612677,
0.0260096733,
0.0178548656,
0.041254662,
0.0167225841,
-0.0086822389,
0.0184070729,
0.0219944511,
-0.0131875779,
-0.00026032,
0.0760607794,
-0.0025455523,
0.0302252565,
-0.0459453762,
0.004147687,
0.0319851078,
-0.0148151359,
0.01958948,
-0.0583375655,
0.0345988125,
-0.0342597365,
-0.0310090911,
0.0342329144,
0.0036637406,
-0.0161070637,
0.0177070741,
-0.102643609,
-0.0452426001,
0.0104303788,
0.0034148195,
-0.0473747253,
-0.0313754193,
0.0299196057,
0.0038342243,
0.035375189,
-0.0415521413,
0.0268949829,
0.0140673378,
-0.0467889905,
0.0351896845,
-0.0601858646,
0.0257144235,
-0.0094435662,
-0.0134123517,
0.026288107,
0.013134527,
0.0263857767,
0.0414376818,
-0.0516747721,
-0.0084580937,
0.0268851966,
0.0094233807,
0.0322329998,
0.0253795702,
0.0090626162,
0.0784272328,
0.0317704827,
-0.0358023793,
-0.0783871412,
-0.0073983837,
0.0465881303,
0.0621869415,
0.0267515089,
0.0029625674,
0.0606933013,
0.0016070977,
-0.0679330975,
-0.010498778,
-0.051231388,
0.010491712,
0.0113349585,
0.0029195843,
-0.0372488163,
-0.0139474524,
-0.0272208117,
-0.0355291925,
-0.0098515311,
-0.0074154539,
0.0225823559,
0.0074381419,
0.0357840024,
0.0367147066,
0.0095539847,
-0.0250033792,
-0.0021630083,
0.016013328,
-0.0031710907,
0.0183947627,
-0.0055041388,
0.0384588838,
-0.0438024811,
-0.0358090587,
-0.0214712769,
0.0427238047,
-0.0047219279,
0.02358176,
0.0502744503,
0.0130493566,
-0.046005521,
-0.0207998604,
-0.0682889372,
-0.0197282732,
-0.0005754217,
-0.0125769414,
0.048745539,
0.02703733,
-0.0153142866,
0.0478297994,
0.0042684879,
0.0162549801,
-0.0000651269,
0.0344858766,
-0.046823591,
0.0350742862,
0.0348340087,
-0.0231162384,
-0.0166465025,
-0.0149848647,
0.0256797224,
-0.0757314265,
-0.0015103493,
0.0397694856,
2.614e-7,
0.0373824164,
0.0313182883,
0.041615624,
-0.0194627196,
0.0022231869,
0.0248068273,
-0.0053011165,
-0.0235054847,
-0.0039491048,
0.0026300608,
-0.0104805874,
0.0899315402,
0.0521554984,
0.0440961085,
-0.0534931645,
0.0472565927,
-0.0310708582,
-0.0419565737,
-0.0513158925,
-0.0177241303,
0.070691824,
0.0133089917,
0.0130526945,
-0.0074699949,
-0.0121250274,
-0.0176631026,
0.0294363238,
-0.0176712889,
0.0253323689,
0.0346330293,
0.0222516358,
-0.0558670275,
0.0205852818,
-0.0040810034,
0.0083889952,
-0.0171186998,
0.0100104408,
0.0722914115,
-0.0201444756,
-0.0526620895,
-0.0493717492,
-0.0494413227,
-0.0025952416,
-0.0667384639,
0.0819509476,
-0.1005080938,
-0.0337295942,
0.0167217385,
-0.0069935066,
0.0290708877,
0.0070226891,
0.0282936729,
-0.0025776832,
-0.005532823,
0.0079978406,
-0.0007335582,
0.0038141767,
-0.1298404783,
-0.03579133,
0.0428482741,
-0.0130878519,
0.0075501669,
-0.0181030091,
-0.0015320362,
0.0551304184,
-0.0321752578,
-0.0652639493,
2.01115053e-34,
-0.0095661907,
0.008249538,
-0.011076089,
0.0008005512,
0.0195199829,
-0.0226372052,
-0.022893915,
-0.0010619711,
0.0209058188,
-0.0404171273,
0.0214935485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16713v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16713v2 | SkyMath: Technical Report | 2023-10-25T15:34:55 | 2023-10-26T09:01:16 | Liu Yang, Haihua Yang, Wenjun Cheng, Lei Lin, Chenxia Li, Yifu Chen, Lunan Liu, Jianfei Pan, Tianwen Wei, Biye Li, Liang Zhao, Lijie Wang, Bo Zhu, Guoliang Li, Xuejie Wu, Xilin Luo, Rui Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown great potential to solve varieties of
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, including mathematical reasoning. In
this work, we present SkyMath, a large language model for mathematics with 13
billion parameters. By applying self-compare fine-tuning, we have enhanced
mathematical reasoning abilities of Skywork-13B-Base remarkably. On GSM8K,
SkyMath outperforms all known open-source models of similar size and has
established a new SOTA performance. | [
-0.0214545131,
0.1079525575,
0.0004777191,
0.0498354845,
-0.0406453758,
0.0107489899,
0.0236132294,
-0.0037195552,
-0.0348111093,
-0.0461828411,
-0.0408839025,
-0.002829615,
-0.0195597801,
0.0517849848,
0.0262711551,
-0.0108463466,
0.0477354452,
-0.0865848735,
0.0233020019,
-0.0261237826,
-0.024244504,
0.0098392582,
-0.0188443605,
-0.0079008276,
-0.0072065564,
-0.0570370555,
0.0333454795,
-0.0607552081,
-0.0013760432,
-0.0333867706,
-0.0139003033,
0.0604069605,
0.0095212497,
0.0750583783,
0.0000021521,
-0.0361139551,
0.0037325444,
0.0303643011,
-0.0790669173,
0.0634889901,
0.0112195238,
-0.0340917483,
-0.0020305833,
0.0174665116,
-0.0581695512,
0.0165008325,
-0.0027771872,
0.0260619,
0.1082520187,
0.0586037524,
0.0039243139,
-0.0634327978,
0.0421538018,
-0.0307394546,
0.0212125927,
-0.0517595373,
0.0073699444,
0.0332322009,
0.0174008626,
0.0339917615,
-0.0134036914,
0.0499959588,
0.0244017821,
0.0064987768,
-0.0207781699,
0.0138098216,
-0.0808239579,
0.0159869902,
-0.0091761323,
0.0519134142,
-0.0210835207,
-0.0360481776,
0.0058932845,
0.0032564483,
-0.0490823053,
-0.0073241028,
-0.057757251,
0.0170520823,
-0.0028643892,
-0.003023159,
0.0211039912,
0.003031373,
0.0313840099,
0.0210695434,
-0.030267261,
0.1118617207,
0.0149307577,
-0.0164053645,
-0.0149646858,
-0.016201308,
-0.0613885596,
-0.043834161,
0.0465303808,
0.0337190256,
-0.0096815396,
0.0091127846,
-0.0395538211,
-0.0515902899,
-0.0025364351,
-0.0761992186,
0.0452366285,
0.0547141992,
0.0391795859,
0.0816245377,
-0.0432506204,
0.0163725279,
-0.023102263,
-0.0081957886,
0.0115092304,
-0.0113546886,
-0.0036100876,
-0.0209655911,
-0.0295648295,
0.0261542015,
-0.0387669876,
-0.023411233,
-0.0110624265,
0.0149017423,
-0.0219537523,
0.0137355076,
0.0483394898,
-0.0135067962,
0.0103231007,
-0.0571687222,
-0.0282182023,
-0.0254676547,
-0.0403266773,
0.0010624795,
-0.0182656776,
-0.059400782,
0.0090098958,
0.0002378601,
0.0079786703,
-0.0186062083,
0.0408715829,
0.056220714,
0.0360468887,
0.0013775073,
-0.0083205467,
-0.0146118188,
0.024702495,
-0.0965099782,
-0.0238055065,
-0.0947162732,
0.0286036506,
0.0436909795,
-0.0295651127,
-0.0314895511,
0.0064097517,
0.0280697737,
0.0110051865,
0.0631041154,
-0.0118592205,
0.0072141453,
0.0214948449,
-0.0177482497,
-0.0094000576,
0.0614849515,
0.0041069742,
-0.0225433949,
0.022676032,
-0.0216407869,
0.0218366962,
0.0141986562,
0.0141074993,
-0.0266639143,
-0.0358120203,
0.0467541926,
-0.0118736736,
0.0602655075,
0.0132262493,
0.0567171201,
-0.0537168495,
-0.0236838758,
0.0007071128,
0.0755867809,
0.0295339804,
0.0567751937,
0.0009791756,
0.0155384475,
0.0479606651,
-0.0793278664,
-0.0549051762,
0.0308507197,
-0.0131378919,
0.0012142189,
0.0144076981,
0.0245515909,
-0.0022435854,
-0.0518213324,
-0.013852722,
0.0131666455,
-0.0372424163,
0.0148057258,
0.0412540026,
-0.0365207158,
-0.0025956894,
0.0992000401,
0.0100531001,
-0.0460657477,
-0.0314836092,
-0.01248316,
0.0442029946,
0.0263350327,
0.0453182682,
-0.0517672747,
-0.0266684275,
-0.0188508518,
0.0091276886,
0.056764219,
0.0554396734,
0.025892254,
0.0018788608,
-0.0467636958,
0.0261735097,
-0.0275568683,
0.0307477843,
-0.0001414061,
0.0324032679,
-0.0046689161,
0.0240535494,
-0.0147115942,
-0.0059616538,
0.0148565471,
-0.0344554409,
-0.035949558,
-0.0002368638,
-0.0105079375,
-0.0001466853,
0.0052724034,
0.0023885327,
0.0583151653,
-0.0022597539,
-0.0390783399,
-0.008227448,
-0.0563013516,
-0.0731542483,
-0.059701249,
0.0417202413,
-0.0213425551,
-0.012798233,
0.0445178971,
-0.0219608527,
-0.0219924878,
0.0868524835,
-0.0299849901,
0.0396578573,
-0.0290521383,
0.0153012667,
-0.0030588612,
0.0196997467,
-0.015421398,
0.0537199304,
0.0172595419,
0.005864643,
-0.0325678885,
0.0511283688,
0.0337632261,
-0.0047506024,
-0.0087256012,
0.0015153411,
-0.0148299504,
0.02802076,
-0.0354907624,
-0.0247509275,
-0.0185774155,
-0.0374850892,
-0.0420250557,
-0.0003907511,
-0.0108349035,
0.0534964539,
0.0072024185,
-0.0383698456,
-0.0118385945,
0.0003850603,
-0.0144276796,
-0.0044272859,
0.0027099019,
-0.012531722,
0.0236263759,
-0.0172301456,
-0.0242152847,
-0.0347184092,
-0.0539000556,
-0.0443494357,
0.0710438862,
-0.008926753,
0.0368571691,
-0.053151127,
0.0007327039,
-0.0732081458,
0.0237496272,
0.0115635367,
0.0132248411,
0.0346214473,
-0.0412838049,
0.0350356363,
0.0811495408,
0.0001225919,
-0.0205728691,
0.0275897272,
-0.0305363443,
-0.0382631421,
0.005917218,
-0.0073453765,
0.0039201868,
0.0118721928,
0.0309306867,
-0.0212789644,
0.0625532493,
-0.0365024172,
-0.030779466,
-0.0267342404,
0.0740332082,
-0.0062033297,
0.0323128998,
-0.0337080359,
0.0157129299,
0.0006471258,
0.0438165329,
-0.0060170726,
-0.0307669286,
0.019712735,
-0.0399583317,
0.0029944081,
-0.0502833351,
0.016113149,
-0.0622847602,
0.0486531407,
-0.0292165875,
0.0007910105,
-0.0163240768,
-0.0085850284,
0.0189670771,
0.0024633382,
0.0187793486,
-0.0203487463,
0.0421390682,
-0.014457454,
0.0512007773,
-0.0109804757,
-0.0450527072,
-0.0122746788,
0.0016647389,
-0.0681323409,
0.0321263038,
-0.0147285499,
-0.0222040042,
0.0086722327,
0.006497643,
0.0131686758,
0.0409655645,
-0.0315437913,
-0.0089526251,
-0.0407212004,
-0.0166851338,
0.032804206,
0.006291959,
0.0782003403,
-0.0026880787,
0.0224683154,
-0.002311314,
0.0259028915,
0.0299146473,
-0.0253875814,
0.0075155296,
0.0017781638,
-0.0461030379,
-0.0398652405,
0.0040114401,
-0.0059878132,
-0.0981158093,
0.0196929704,
0.1080948412,
0.0297247842,
0.0082232086,
0.0093870508,
-0.0708429739,
-0.0091771977,
0.0228665005,
0.0441061184,
-0.0552283786,
-0.0269015338,
0.0087787146,
-0.0379135013,
0.043949075,
-0.0350803845,
-0.0128309578,
-0.1008977368,
0.0255990997,
0.0226360764,
-0.0300679654,
-0.0078490619,
-0.0194544978,
-0.0099385744,
-0.0264315959,
-0.0137722967,
0.0567910187,
-0.0070236432,
0.0112407785,
-0.022875933,
0.0166901462,
-0.0020238736,
0.0633694753,
-0.0358684696,
0.0113797057,
-0.031259574,
0.0199847165,
-0.0209231973,
-0.0608250238,
0.0344389305,
0.0295367893,
-0.0109089185,
-0.0091395266,
0.0190241486,
-0.0002608303,
-0.0229247939,
-0.0283792969,
0.0260985754,
-0.0887126848,
-0.0061633908,
-0.0147126298,
0.0970399231,
-0.0153152468,
0.0028460557,
-0.002645503,
-0.0120586613,
-0.0776639357,
0.0493847765,
-0.007250132,
0.0152108418,
-0.0793490037,
-0.0431604944,
-0.0417558253,
-0.0165716875,
-0.0457601994,
-0.0019523123,
0.0814916641,
-0.0322565883,
-0.0379770547,
0.0106874071,
0.0102745052,
0.0553972051,
-0.0255354606,
0.0032961941,
0.0266906191,
-0.0035508918,
-0.0229286086,
0.0452646427,
-0.049555447,
0.0364428684,
-0.0673567951,
0.0470705666,
0.0450102426,
0.0298584364,
-0.0295070149,
0.0023268049,
-0.0891908705,
-0.0495518483,
0.0075138975,
0.0195945147,
0.020545233,
0.0055926614,
-0.0145554673,
-0.0201202165,
0.0219941791,
0.0206545591,
-0.0701883733,
0.0486014225,
0.0384789295,
-0.0030698397,
0.0079153404,
0.0359818488,
0.0319293961,
0.0183309522,
-0.0134707093,
0.0381591879,
-0.0079079038,
0.0059721954,
-0.0123797311,
0.039084658,
0.0027324113,
0.0497479402,
0.0032888979,
-0.0130973021,
0.0272024088,
-0.0453826711,
0.0053537884,
-0.024835363,
0.0151113858,
-0.0127757564,
-0.0248589609,
-0.0067251027,
-0.0160208978,
0.0324375406,
0.0230566692,
0.0431694798,
0.0519172959,
-0.0275730677,
0.014052649,
0.0295925122,
-0.0320729986,
0.0018901376,
0.0050048027,
-0.0187423155,
0.0348138995,
-0.0372274406,
0.0298403595,
-0.0074922787,
0.0012023367,
-0.0408527814,
0.0079053435,
-0.0429255553,
-0.1323881,
-0.0030671414,
0.009846475,
0.0129667632,
0.0341097973,
0.0060702665,
-0.0379093029,
-0.0242331531,
0.0006799213,
0.0111837499,
0.0050090505,
0.0092303846,
0.0329241678,
0.0341077372,
-0.004443767,
-0.0342979506,
0.0508224517,
0.001011982,
0.0261784513,
0.0361408405,
0.0126839308,
-0.0360776111,
-0.021606911,
-0.0391906574,
0.003700716,
-0.0102372319,
0.0342861712,
-0.0301833693,
-0.0790158287,
-0.0025447654,
0.0085315602,
-0.0434152,
-0.0163626727,
0.0280843806,
0.0741402507,
-0.0230141543,
-0.0117801894,
-0.0014252946,
0.0270349476,
-0.0324354172,
-0.0169076584,
-0.0069187507,
-6.379232987e-33,
-0.0069782571,
0.0037643318,
0.0551589616,
0.0086249914,
-0.006687745,
-0.0149691002,
-0.0187386498,
0.0126298834,
-0.0285882168,
-0.0206470676,
-0.0140432585,
0.0502048619,
0.0074374489,
0.0181865226,
-0.0036913471,
-0.0088081295,
0.0188151617,
-0.0050985571,
-0.0082098236,
-0.0142245274,
0.0082818689,
0.0240826737,
0.0650871471,
-0.061820779,
-0.0350067057,
0.0247176755,
-0.0163289104,
0.0123840841,
-0.0435512848,
0.0536849312,
-0.0383179151,
0.0294623338,
0.0004610702,
-0.0251182411,
-0.0090724537,
0.0127247572,
-0.0164327677,
-0.0474151447,
0.0098191015,
0.0046289889,
-0.0088429032,
-0.0441254079,
0.0489732623,
0.0231644101,
-0.0431907289,
-0.0129855173,
-0.0025142415,
-0.0387841277,
-0.0186875444,
0.0166841261,
-0.040817976,
0.058664009,
0.0206222665,
0.0164370779,
0.0308013707,
-0.0165387001,
-0.0509809293,
0.0278920848,
0.0227187742,
0.0015729447,
0.0406593382,
0.0722496584,
0.0199593958,
-0.0156607218,
0.0372533686,
0.0324252285,
0.0233586282,
-0.0299359821,
-0.0018915915,
-0.0036126694,
0.0568267629,
0.068144761,
0.0682501644,
0.0166618507,
0.0326468386,
0.0104564447,
-0.0333271623,
-0.0446963124,
-0.0189497322,
0.0416337661,
0.0238411278,
0.0184950996,
-0.0178614911,
-0.0149506582,
-0.0561974049,
0.0085588889,
-0.071068421,
-0.0182927027,
0.0175339952,
-0.010938853,
-0.0180743411,
0.0422882512,
0.0009212125,
-0.0415772051,
-0.0256835986,
0.0467094034,
0.0031201916,
0.0059542642,
0.0056790672,
0.0296595208,
-0.0653337166,
-0.0117450086,
-0.0417140014,
0.0000443887,
0.0237815846,
-0.0080140047,
-0.0079446845,
0.0343079604,
-0.0825814903,
-0.0252258647,
-0.0288599152,
-0.0222981442,
0.0456354953,
0.0445027538,
0.0311874021,
0.0199478753,
0.0193536375,
0.0649528876,
-0.0217285827,
-0.0125732515,
-0.0229579788,
-0.0029592342,
0.0026741873,
0.0540152416,
-0.0186302848,
-0.0277249608,
-0.0542054102,
-0.0506451316,
0.0641180277,
-0.0757823139,
-0.0083895009,
0.0119255623,
2.848e-7,
0.035075672,
0.0877497941,
-0.0008389314,
0.0053796717,
0.0223279223,
0.0147851063,
0.0025023157,
-0.0249785464,
0.0010776066,
0.0113326833,
-0.0042977305,
0.0391794518,
0.0288251266,
0.0412123837,
-0.0301003214,
0.0403641984,
-0.0617689267,
-0.0002085717,
-0.0832729414,
-0.0086431699,
0.0329495482,
0.1382156909,
0.0229640864,
-0.0024275915,
0.0109036462,
-0.0357368179,
0.0577777177,
0.0022674501,
-0.0050352947,
0.0186661314,
-0.0252622776,
0.0190364812,
-0.0029399595,
-0.001268134,
0.0037833138,
0.0331449136,
0.0258328952,
0.1007312685,
0.0045913165,
0.0521500967,
0.0064059077,
-0.0632271022,
-0.0251281951,
-0.0530897677,
0.0758421868,
-0.033828184,
-0.0423401706,
-0.0474799946,
-0.006710175,
-0.0318623967,
0.0114230793,
-0.0202048067,
0.0153163364,
-0.0200854968,
0.019173963,
-0.0272249561,
0.0086829131,
-0.0926839039,
-0.0393483415,
0.0482314713,
-0.0358812772,
-0.016279107,
-0.0523745716,
-0.0012807745,
0.074094601,
-0.008451852,
0.0193382408,
2.792209817e-34,
0.0569432713,
0.0050301412,
0.0272321831,
0.0147617711,
0.0427983776,
0.0137214409,
-0.0185999908,
0.0221798588,
0.0219109058,
-0.0905517638,
-0.0042677452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16712v1 | LLM Performance Predictors are good initializers for Architecture Search | 2023-10-25T15:34:30 | 2023-10-25T15:34:30 | Ganesh Jawahar, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Laks V. S. Lakshmanan, Dujian Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have become an integral component in solving a
wide range of NLP tasks. In this work, we explore a novel use case of using
LLMs to build performance predictors (PP): models that, given a specific deep
neural network architecture, predict its performance on a downstream task. We
design PP prompts for LLMs consisting of: (i) role: description of the role
assigned to the LLM, (ii) instructions: set of instructions to be followed by
the LLM to carry out performance prediction, (iii) hyperparameters: a
definition of each architecture-specific hyperparameter and (iv)
demonstrations: sample architectures along with their efficiency metrics and
'training from scratch' performance. For machine translation (MT) tasks, we
discover that GPT-4 with our PP prompts (LLM-PP) can predict the performance of
architecture with a mean absolute error matching the SOTA and a marginal
degradation in rank correlation coefficient compared to SOTA performance
predictors. Further, we show that the predictions from LLM-PP can be distilled
to a small regression model (LLM-Distill-PP). LLM-Distill-PP models
surprisingly retain the performance of LLM-PP largely and can be a
cost-effective alternative for heavy use cases of performance estimation.
Specifically, for neural architecture search (NAS), we propose a Hybrid-Search
algorithm for NAS (HS-NAS), which uses LLM-Distill-PP for the initial part of
search, resorting to the baseline predictor for rest of the search. We show
that HS-NAS performs very similar to SOTA NAS across benchmarks, reduces search
hours by 50% roughly, and in some cases, improves latency, GFLOPs, and model
size. | [
0.0210354291,
0.0783770829,
-0.0042254059,
0.039267052,
-0.0144614084,
-0.0170947202,
0.026026845,
0.0001131852,
-0.0084550241,
-0.0039440673,
-0.0510560088,
-0.0291585904,
0.0045461655,
0.0176138524,
0.024515273,
0.0089391582,
0.0153945824,
0.0194499567,
-0.0067884764,
-0.0035730759,
-0.0293827374,
0.0323034376,
0.0093079377,
0.0620481893,
-0.0022310005,
0.0174384993,
-0.0198977813,
0.0840916112,
-0.0095919129,
-0.0404865779,
0.0274642054,
0.0079060914,
0.0242139716,
0.0326193012,
0.0000023338,
0.0013067799,
-0.0367548019,
0.0121835126,
-0.0509335622,
0.0368382409,
0.0197867602,
0.0038476819,
-0.0026748707,
0.0263022203,
-0.02474357,
-0.0649050027,
0.0310472585,
0.0239002444,
0.0230569746,
0.0858636796,
0.0056151971,
-0.0209155511,
0.0150853368,
-0.0524510369,
-0.0312401392,
-0.0829516947,
-0.0442795604,
-0.0555917956,
-0.026637543,
0.0559620298,
0.0074543646,
0.0437014215,
0.030043507,
0.0501257516,
-0.0153431566,
0.0200187266,
-0.0635250956,
-0.0097840372,
-0.0106562413,
0.0601048544,
-0.0665674359,
-0.014547484,
0.015526698,
-0.0199261699,
-0.0457779095,
-0.0363468714,
-0.0227904096,
0.0053056884,
0.028934909,
0.0127555383,
0.004718564,
0.0189897642,
0.0776598677,
0.0203405246,
-0.0142109711,
0.0572546124,
0.0285259131,
-0.0074052401,
0.0105048027,
-0.0096831052,
-0.0445225723,
-0.0373322368,
0.0146221463,
-0.0040767905,
-0.0480615944,
0.020526601,
-0.0269554369,
-0.0107118385,
-0.0253899228,
-0.0271843411,
0.0591053031,
0.0660072565,
-0.0138207702,
0.0271694846,
-0.0646701455,
0.0944671705,
-0.0656318665,
-0.0266550984,
-0.0450058952,
-0.0172903072,
-0.0301586241,
-0.006209956,
-0.0357390568,
0.0225355029,
-0.0365300402,
-0.0564079881,
-0.0464886278,
0.0004180915,
0.0013885495,
-0.0078299418,
0.050159432,
0.0049663819,
-0.0319091007,
0.0150315799,
-0.0286033861,
0.01846903,
-0.0140051199,
-0.0156248594,
-0.0149507131,
-0.0682947785,
-0.0053939004,
0.020539606,
-0.018526515,
-0.0316860788,
0.0480854772,
0.0908165947,
-0.0064296597,
-0.0284524504,
-0.0122007532,
-0.0246899519,
0.0213659182,
-0.0506926216,
0.0417769998,
-0.0276360046,
0.053381104,
-0.0168016795,
0.0211329572,
-0.0197086185,
0.0040559657,
0.0282073859,
0.0258597992,
0.0398254506,
0.0319329761,
-0.0029408839,
0.0084553333,
-0.0064090909,
-0.0258351136,
0.0968940258,
0.0313525461,
0.0572052151,
0.0364658311,
-0.0031553947,
-0.0467507653,
0.0644258708,
0.0203776807,
-0.0103582125,
0.0150714498,
0.0014738141,
-0.0062546115,
0.0402156301,
0.0112054106,
0.0291928444,
0.0065126498,
0.009121621,
0.0542735234,
0.0583586134,
0.0604072958,
0.0391956195,
0.0481316075,
0.0032841782,
-0.0384828709,
-0.035930343,
-0.0342854001,
0.0370418504,
-0.0047127418,
-0.0166504439,
0.0354332887,
0.0664551258,
-0.0314467438,
-0.0210218411,
-0.0139277307,
0.0079541411,
-0.0506126769,
0.0331537724,
0.0243383683,
-0.0170633737,
-0.0927703232,
0.0396494269,
-0.0301769059,
-0.0363401584,
0.0227657538,
-0.077035524,
-0.017169185,
0.0626811385,
0.0586611852,
0.0036728818,
0.007378425,
0.0244484227,
-0.0048730168,
0.0142079536,
0.0407721847,
0.0226959791,
0.0284875873,
-0.0524360053,
-0.016595263,
0.0087807914,
0.0048891292,
0.0175272692,
0.0588931777,
0.0272702221,
0.0574264787,
-0.0162900351,
-0.0679226443,
0.0512568653,
-0.0349848196,
-0.015879117,
0.0534963869,
0.0154757258,
0.0399058089,
0.0247004889,
-0.0056969612,
-0.0091036549,
0.021492824,
-0.0347892381,
-0.0465613902,
-0.0133528216,
-0.0388672948,
-0.0464883,
-0.0007580783,
-0.0151821775,
0.0603046082,
0.0416755006,
-0.0413457789,
-0.0616318062,
0.0420114323,
-0.0387953073,
0.0323628411,
-0.0087906234,
0.0255631674,
-0.0093130022,
-0.015274385,
-0.022617219,
0.0389025062,
0.0105831521,
0.003377707,
0.0120647121,
0.0002696374,
0.00525006,
-0.0214495175,
-0.0475400463,
0.0154995099,
-0.0170041844,
0.0123568634,
0.0267094672,
0.013358484,
-0.0137700485,
-0.0308383182,
-0.1060469225,
0.0717718154,
-0.0397057123,
0.0007714654,
0.0276820194,
0.030390393,
0.0227346718,
-0.0109594204,
-0.0144498805,
0.0148908272,
-0.0039478899,
0.0082216673,
-0.0304737985,
0.0204141103,
-0.0263069328,
-0.048791077,
-0.0514666736,
-0.0082243374,
0.027993368,
-0.0297491774,
-0.009730814,
-0.0104292696,
0.0062171351,
-0.0041217469,
0.0397273861,
-0.0358291119,
-0.0408323519,
-0.0036351623,
-0.0286643039,
-0.025387831,
0.0749726966,
-0.0130905425,
-0.0028421197,
0.010246993,
0.006585517,
-0.0795149952,
0.0329155289,
-0.0246121939,
-0.0027795252,
-0.0032134918,
-0.0382674076,
0.0263151433,
0.0556089059,
0.0053951107,
-0.005383431,
-0.0653136,
0.0028495074,
-0.0093520433,
-0.0104118492,
0.0025933522,
0.009653748,
0.0487825759,
0.0356411003,
-0.0119347358,
-0.0642041713,
0.0452897176,
-0.045732867,
-0.0085532153,
-0.0045876708,
-0.0021668733,
-0.0476714224,
0.0455425009,
0.0011586443,
0.0119809778,
-0.0350098088,
0.0034691528,
-0.0267457403,
0.0376637466,
-0.0163158569,
-0.0455098189,
0.0405701287,
-0.0368476212,
0.0171531923,
-0.0079720085,
-0.0639065281,
-0.0157570317,
-0.0006657714,
-0.0160709545,
0.034861248,
0.0153116975,
-0.0351298302,
-0.0427004956,
0.0100883748,
-0.0367488489,
0.0799665302,
-0.0265441313,
0.0091352668,
-0.0414419174,
-0.0224508904,
0.0321820751,
-0.0412987024,
0.0207782462,
-0.0354608074,
0.0197523497,
0.0041038804,
0.0030768684,
0.0032689332,
-0.0980791673,
-0.0268884581,
0.0424698554,
-0.0058543393,
-0.0574761257,
0.0231927,
0.0374865606,
-0.0835291222,
0.004142764,
0.1065112501,
0.0092461025,
-0.0276981238,
-0.0209925957,
0.0513441935,
0.0415052101,
0.0413748622,
0.0597739555,
-0.0313303135,
-0.0321761332,
0.0215384457,
0.0487326346,
-0.0180079155,
0.009918401,
-0.0231125522,
-0.0911474302,
0.0089071998,
-0.015019523,
-0.0029378124,
-0.0066519836,
-0.0175556764,
-0.0248030107,
-0.0505305268,
0.0038275244,
0.0022199959,
0.0347945504,
-0.0160806961,
0.0059590009,
-0.0582143366,
-0.0414136387,
0.010468686,
-0.0435939692,
0.0344591327,
0.1009348482,
0.0229774937,
0.0009789573,
-0.0154775577,
0.0381556042,
-0.0155896991,
0.0310131274,
-0.0283934064,
0.049963437,
-0.0309145246,
-0.018882215,
-0.003530791,
0.0022841347,
-0.03884352,
0.0572311729,
0.0251885131,
0.0635946542,
-0.0047093951,
-0.0030600561,
-0.0262813196,
-0.0431533046,
-0.0043225619,
0.0572591983,
-0.0039858995,
-0.0468763448,
-0.0306927245,
0.0064874394,
0.0137840593,
-0.0945357978,
-0.0087078521,
-0.0157864522,
-0.0235229805,
0.0211458765,
-0.0492329113,
0.0084660286,
0.0054550725,
0.0416599624,
0.0287837125,
-0.0111707812,
-0.0027870389,
0.0144860772,
-0.0515022054,
0.0298460368,
0.0092630507,
0.0294915326,
-0.06033694,
0.0275851917,
0.0745471939,
0.0024358372,
-0.0146864811,
0.0278000962,
-0.0827990547,
-0.0538042001,
-0.0559417345,
0.0711385682,
0.015287648,
0.0058741649,
-0.0161845833,
-0.0722392052,
0.022669632,
-0.0118652834,
-0.0098850997,
0.010162578,
0.00597035,
-0.0476178303,
-0.0206557866,
0.0229928177,
-0.0208625309,
0.0233093519,
0.0162894018,
0.0530832782,
0.0278552528,
-0.0107580898,
0.0085425917,
-0.0083905887,
0.0481754094,
-0.0369865708,
-0.0242007468,
-0.0093208207,
0.0273088664,
0.0207492802,
-0.0047121956,
-0.0604123808,
0.0124464286,
0.0408616513,
0.0120841116,
-0.0016251761,
0.0005328729,
0.0329834186,
0.025153093,
-0.0448999554,
-0.0062141633,
-0.0097402902,
-0.0090946769,
0.0105280252,
0.0169385318,
-0.0024954013,
0.0110103935,
0.0100359526,
0.0373544581,
-0.0574041642,
0.0259540789,
0.0227657016,
0.0279264189,
-0.0105231339,
0.0257472899,
-0.0371385738,
-0.0862104893,
-0.0245046765,
-0.0232933015,
0.0573067889,
-0.0070844688,
0.0647774488,
0.0026641295,
0.0083638057,
-0.0440592319,
-0.010285804,
0.0055320552,
-0.0203262251,
0.0458943844,
0.0183089823,
-0.0085230619,
-0.0196352415,
0.0614256077,
0.0055961274,
0.0330731049,
-0.0111374445,
-0.0143318521,
-0.0112457229,
-0.0380640551,
0.0123601006,
0.0384807251,
-0.0308080241,
-0.002029048,
0.0195377283,
-0.03529571,
-0.0163164064,
-0.0120630292,
0.0069091874,
-0.0210187398,
0.0191674288,
0.1134761274,
-0.0103559261,
-0.0458359122,
-0.0327684991,
-0.047025729,
-0.0233937241,
-0.0110088596,
-0.033653751,
-6.870792399e-33,
-0.0221215878,
-0.0030965731,
0.0345865525,
-0.0391822197,
-0.044250045,
0.0522019379,
-0.0339626558,
-0.0077081276,
-0.0595209748,
-0.0188045129,
-0.0374485403,
0.0217254926,
0.013757267,
0.0364968143,
0.0076218396,
0.0040264963,
0.0691229999,
-0.0252603516,
-0.0351075977,
0.0060064788,
0.0095981499,
0.0284926556,
0.0297336373,
-0.0072678886,
-0.0355146639,
0.0052188034,
-0.0068970029,
0.0172269642,
0.017228825,
0.0440715328,
0.0054622181,
0.0050340206,
0.0225036498,
-0.0326544493,
-0.0105240839,
-0.004981189,
-0.021446215,
0.0015068398,
0.0299381725,
0.0341225304,
-0.0368305594,
-0.0004499381,
0.0420983694,
-0.007677149,
-0.0337152518,
-0.0327839032,
0.0143180937,
0.0093966685,
-0.0391070358,
-0.0449956134,
-0.0339040048,
0.0077335471,
0.0227478053,
-0.0000693702,
0.0631637126,
0.0574744307,
-0.0190874543,
0.023015162,
-0.0660609826,
0.0035445478,
-0.0451587699,
0.0993984416,
0.0722459704,
0.0759421512,
-0.0049819509,
0.0361078903,
0.0481618233,
-0.0017151658,
-0.0129105262,
-0.0313492343,
0.0644206554,
0.0367147177,
0.0658148825,
-0.0237801597,
0.0584893115,
0.0086651789,
-0.058897011,
-0.0176039413,
0.06182044,
0.0124062523,
0.0776999146,
0.0257868879,
-0.0520867966,
-0.0086138947,
-0.0669829994,
-0.0128829023,
-0.04883058,
-0.0503701232,
0.041024439,
0.0706551224,
0.0031455071,
-0.0147183603,
0.0583034232,
-0.0497531183,
0.0377812497,
0.0124069173,
-0.0347844325,
0.0080103045,
-0.013046572,
0.0635033995,
-0.0224163588,
-0.0519267805,
-0.0098325387,
0.0090307603,
0.0238455329,
-0.0351896249,
-0.0198581275,
0.0408537053,
-0.0585770868,
-0.0208203662,
-0.0597864203,
0.008476031,
-0.0122675616,
0.0237123184,
0.0269360263,
0.0166804846,
-0.0136802709,
0.0500387736,
0.003283052,
0.0230378341,
-0.038430132,
0.0197347179,
0.0213853437,
0.0140225105,
-0.0517122969,
0.0006598401,
-0.0285715088,
0.0062983842,
0.0054047685,
-0.0818037838,
-0.0550291725,
0.027107209,
2.987e-7,
-0.0061549982,
0.0462720878,
-0.0274414048,
0.0473192632,
0.0124413408,
0.0030565171,
0.0182018317,
-0.0095850611,
-0.0186690837,
-0.0184387993,
0.0228754953,
0.0203513205,
0.0861185342,
0.004258432,
-0.0765381157,
-0.0200043879,
-0.0558847487,
0.0310518816,
-0.0658291206,
-0.0452704579,
0.0068552834,
0.1108434871,
0.0077821887,
-0.012359648,
-0.0191475507,
0.0166388322,
0.0498899035,
-0.0142475981,
-0.0091742761,
0.0189290028,
0.0310740266,
0.0432257243,
-0.0716328472,
0.0154467477,
-0.0233442187,
0.0201635137,
0.0191603117,
0.059628576,
0.0391769707,
-0.049735669,
0.0499677993,
-0.0099955425,
-0.0181307867,
-0.0525404103,
0.0708522052,
-0.0063611972,
-0.0110807205,
-0.0221356023,
-0.0156231886,
-0.0076922788,
0.0037822186,
-0.0242609326,
0.0264323875,
0.0282825902,
0.0249272622,
-0.0414538793,
-0.0319020487,
-0.0877208039,
0.0015453667,
-0.0086466288,
-0.0411729179,
-0.0283751376,
-0.0858775824,
0.0219994914,
-0.0046008495,
-0.0339906588,
0.0006988334,
3.157193467e-34,
0.0484968536,
-0.0203995388,
0.0322263986,
0.0450025015,
0.0265525319,
0.0091132103,
-0.0384526066,
0.000894978,
-0.019299617,
-0.0689843222,
-0.0333394036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16685v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16685v1 | Detection of news written by the ChatGPT through authorship attribution performed by a Bidirectional LSTM model | 2023-10-25T14:48:58 | 2023-10-25T14:48:58 | Amanda Ferrari Iaquinta, Gustavo Voltani von Atzingen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The large language based-model chatbot ChatGPT gained a lot of popularity
since its launch and has been used in a wide range of situations. This research
centers around a particular situation, when the ChatGPT is used to produce news
that will be consumed by the population, causing the facilitation in the
production of fake news, spread of misinformation and lack of trust in news
sources. Aware of these problems, this research aims to build an artificial
intelligence model capable of performing authorship attribution on news
articles, identifying the ones written by the ChatGPT. To achieve this goal, a
dataset containing equal amounts of human and ChatGPT written news was
assembled and different natural processing language techniques were used to
extract features from it that were used to train, validate and test three
models built with different techniques. The best performance was produced by
the Bidirectional Long Short Term Memory (LSTM) Neural Network model, achiving
91.57\% accuracy when tested against the data from the testing set. | [
0.0768724754,
-0.0123577947,
-0.0129943481,
0.0611663125,
-0.0922089443,
0.0141365565,
0.0378975309,
0.0045031779,
0.0634442419,
-0.0509036407,
-0.0151411761,
-0.042650044,
-0.025563553,
0.0428657383,
0.0138338367,
0.0355830602,
0.0195017122,
0.0416020267,
0.0535722785,
-0.0028521791,
0.0163761862,
0.0298298448,
0.0061535607,
0.0179887023,
-0.0411020331,
-0.0669180676,
0.0265301261,
0.0339731127,
0.0235876143,
0.0225099251,
-0.0135498261,
0.04427623,
0.0001928097,
0.0971753672,
0.000001798,
-0.0053014732,
-0.0229941811,
-0.0121780355,
-0.0276146326,
-0.0397455394,
0.0739968047,
0.0175143257,
-0.0496603474,
0.044577878,
-0.0384514816,
0.0052360152,
0.0161504559,
0.0789364427,
0.0777605698,
0.1365590096,
-0.0275502,
-0.0182533283,
0.0567214191,
0.0320769064,
0.0285353158,
-0.0067080786,
0.0269391648,
-0.0196947977,
-0.0200814903,
0.0239778981,
0.0069536441,
0.0448784046,
0.0327805132,
-0.0448049083,
-0.0300773978,
-0.0091691324,
-0.0004709864,
0.011491592,
0.0105491709,
0.0019666415,
-0.0417958833,
-0.0642274842,
0.0223319419,
0.0218017194,
-0.010376784,
0.0322331637,
-0.0113288835,
0.0412662439,
-0.050360471,
-0.0130336303,
0.0160735976,
-0.0403057709,
0.003436265,
0.0515864938,
0.0613540262,
0.0113599505,
0.0225266125,
-0.0229966119,
-0.032528583,
-0.0112615274,
0.020779565,
-0.0589752756,
0.0617134944,
0.0415449589,
0.0199972875,
0.0094854664,
-0.0326952115,
-0.0541956462,
-0.0063714925,
-0.1154865474,
-0.0518102981,
-0.0078402767,
-0.0232053399,
0.0583103001,
-0.0388116986,
0.0122692995,
-0.0060860054,
0.0422390588,
-0.002486381,
-0.021475533,
-0.0386968218,
-0.0324657001,
-0.0167797245,
0.0228377376,
0.0320043266,
-0.0037460353,
-0.0724427104,
0.0072145271,
0.0181802586,
-0.0163031034,
0.0225409269,
0.0052348753,
-0.0359913185,
-0.0084400363,
0.0177350659,
0.0072652968,
0.0087799234,
0.0266809408,
-0.0293169748,
-0.0233485531,
-0.0061746719,
0.0579090305,
0.0148212565,
-0.016850993,
0.0169481803,
0.0619570725,
-0.0104393158,
-0.0393329002,
-0.049433697,
-0.0617897324,
-0.0181340165,
-0.0294493809,
-0.0002966729,
-0.053045731,
-0.0042838594,
-0.0090691578,
-0.03113655,
-0.0307289138,
-0.0316456035,
0.0265011229,
-0.0216862038,
0.0278638788,
0.0174178164,
-0.0021135902,
0.0746701211,
0.0073445351,
0.0052773422,
0.0144120231,
0.0718231723,
0.1137394607,
0.0328048579,
0.0139472149,
0.0445915461,
0.0109777916,
0.0258239713,
0.0000601073,
0.0388757475,
-0.024592407,
-0.0196657237,
-0.0015231947,
-0.0134379901,
0.029389739,
-0.0070578116,
-0.0371395722,
0.0811904743,
0.0022490011,
0.010372771,
0.0506524071,
0.0429692306,
0.0279944818,
0.0165670402,
-0.0182022396,
0.0011347288,
0.0371043608,
-0.0451187305,
-0.0397956222,
-0.0501954742,
0.0380018577,
-0.0200759806,
0.0095393928,
0.0187915042,
-0.0300740842,
0.0471765511,
-0.0242556799,
0.0201289244,
0.0022071998,
-0.0496836193,
-0.0098359715,
-0.0201250035,
-0.0169491898,
-0.005517609,
-0.0749803111,
0.0340379812,
0.0156725254,
0.0418170951,
-0.0004660343,
-0.0084069092,
-0.0610525422,
0.0083218785,
0.0601830482,
-0.0038465324,
0.0041744336,
-0.0514532141,
-0.0016254785,
-0.0219543334,
-0.0012948017,
-0.0152811576,
0.0515132025,
0.0185532495,
0.0659966469,
0.0277450345,
0.0238029491,
-0.0360076688,
0.0251884609,
-0.0140778571,
-0.0258858819,
-0.0151364012,
0.0121547226,
0.0554125868,
0.0427381769,
0.0048428611,
-0.0134926317,
0.0176720563,
-0.0254839323,
-0.0869304687,
0.0308715478,
0.0069011804,
-0.0440113172,
0.0182301607,
-0.0470294394,
-0.0026069172,
0.060591571,
-0.0276299845,
-0.0393479429,
0.0408616178,
-0.0358686186,
-0.0226353202,
-0.0794938281,
0.0157091003,
-0.0162648987,
0.0000146465,
0.0080283685,
0.0658373982,
0.0215019658,
-0.0101256333,
-0.0219865385,
0.0096211182,
0.0317391753,
0.012477478,
-0.0226663016,
-0.0231449455,
-0.0256763194,
0.0244782567,
0.0460154489,
0.0164760873,
-0.0222303737,
-0.045317281,
-0.0685958266,
0.0049452865,
-0.0130079417,
0.0203870125,
0.0142297549,
-0.0203315765,
0.0001378174,
0.0077350577,
-0.0530698709,
-0.0197884068,
0.0018990414,
0.001121917,
0.0351236463,
-0.0154744936,
-0.0278888643,
-0.0025842232,
0.0389316268,
-0.0300706569,
0.0080277184,
0.0493496321,
-0.0453361385,
-0.0299008191,
0.0291569568,
-0.0173731502,
-0.0103434771,
-0.0098401345,
-0.0638406947,
0.0026822083,
0.0046187933,
-0.006317168,
0.0650169775,
0.0535744466,
0.0072346418,
-0.0372718945,
0.0210833047,
-0.0201129373,
0.0064263949,
-0.0396796465,
0.0290586725,
0.0086462544,
-0.0342814103,
0.0070833354,
0.0153405927,
0.0351806432,
-0.0104311472,
-0.0053597433,
0.0220292509,
0.0048475075,
-0.0024621929,
0.0526337475,
-0.0271610003,
-0.0118665257,
-0.034749046,
-0.0428891741,
-0.0437313654,
0.0672270283,
-0.0372912735,
0.0322294049,
-0.0316435322,
-0.0253492948,
-0.0436512306,
0.0489742346,
-0.0149842622,
0.0444116034,
-0.0191367138,
-0.0345180929,
-0.0192292295,
-0.0131161017,
0.0620600209,
-0.0083119329,
-0.0242366921,
0.0055194302,
0.030971285,
0.0077166152,
0.0007704918,
-0.039254602,
-0.0842892677,
-0.0044273157,
-0.0331474952,
0.0164191388,
-0.0437781662,
-0.0319686085,
0.0046771443,
0.0479966477,
0.0311190132,
-0.0406613052,
0.0208587497,
-0.0079592168,
0.0185044874,
0.0094092824,
-0.0295222271,
0.0021114391,
0.0298377164,
0.013604166,
0.0351709984,
-0.0173266977,
0.0224521756,
-0.0204364825,
-0.0383401662,
-0.0377374813,
-0.0338818058,
-0.0391446911,
-0.0337260924,
0.042535942,
-0.0628128052,
0.0031987657,
0.1290535629,
0.0106373066,
-0.0264100581,
-0.0411727056,
0.010443694,
-0.0678513199,
-0.0103889285,
0.00744372,
-0.0655913875,
-0.0123077771,
-0.0295363609,
-0.0246791746,
-0.0336352661,
-0.0113701215,
-0.0347580835,
-0.0337292738,
0.0138685172,
-0.0093491524,
-0.0600676164,
-0.020401286,
-0.0405531265,
-0.0588712096,
0.0090663861,
-0.0083586862,
-0.0221536327,
0.0210328475,
-0.0222476535,
-0.0069582737,
-0.0496880971,
-0.0070373071,
0.0394583903,
-0.0494576879,
0.0363138057,
0.0512918979,
0.0987988934,
-0.0240694899,
0.0232212935,
-0.0068283831,
0.0069113905,
-0.023786867,
-0.0104726553,
0.0494304486,
-0.0643471777,
0.0104610259,
-0.0430923104,
0.0562520735,
-0.0232983641,
0.0327440575,
0.0001479254,
0.0413079113,
-0.0194233675,
-0.0550861396,
-0.0054345974,
0.00790527,
0.0402225368,
0.0754942447,
0.0116166994,
-0.0119041074,
-0.0593873635,
-0.0065887813,
-0.0117384391,
-0.0168897342,
-0.0476108529,
-0.0108700087,
-0.0337026864,
-0.040060889,
-0.0907994509,
-0.0317026153,
-0.012753441,
-0.0215521697,
0.0143978931,
0.0543241985,
0.0366575122,
-0.0289662667,
-0.0239552446,
-0.030014718,
-0.0365334786,
0.0491799302,
-0.0296510346,
0.0225690268,
0.0291420221,
-0.0448147245,
0.0042760083,
0.0378422625,
-0.1082513705,
-0.0167785045,
-0.0006768501,
-0.0207519438,
0.0166894644,
0.0457553528,
-0.0397674032,
-0.0405159183,
0.0729762167,
0.0315540172,
-0.0047057434,
-0.0196545459,
0.0216043256,
0.0233517624,
-0.0097626075,
0.0109426603,
-0.0155032827,
0.0534460805,
0.0548720136,
-0.0771617666,
-0.0236740001,
0.0164545756,
0.0008612704,
0.0290581752,
0.0166445579,
-0.0019262613,
0.0079721892,
-0.0576699525,
-0.0102829868,
-0.0312897004,
0.0128008844,
-0.015134369,
0.018677678,
0.0323759876,
-0.0124640865,
-0.0387395434,
-0.0021872791,
-0.0191559512,
-0.0027501611,
-0.0128965881,
0.0277219247,
-0.003367963,
0.0509312823,
-0.0394837111,
0.0069092028,
-0.0073833615,
0.0172745455,
0.0073785884,
0.0288187824,
0.0127856433,
0.0108605586,
0.0195411202,
-0.0000903212,
0.0216005817,
0.0270115379,
-0.0918188691,
-0.0025109479,
-0.0272437874,
0.0421884842,
0.0599776953,
-0.0120147839,
0.0381405614,
-0.0404154956,
0.0243676733,
-0.0027518698,
0.0700758696,
0.010493964,
-0.0117343627,
-0.0482722223,
-0.0068277312,
-0.0410790481,
0.0173236076,
0.0640342236,
0.0181916449,
0.0295875333,
0.0448896028,
-0.0812752694,
-0.0203875173,
-0.007754216,
0.0331686884,
-0.0217777602,
0.0080669625,
-0.0026440625,
-0.0190223362,
-0.0488879085,
0.0442255102,
-0.0139810974,
0.0384691469,
-0.0114991199,
0.0057403939,
0.0748719722,
0.0095854569,
0.0070176208,
-0.0350605287,
0.0099202236,
-0.0147006204,
-0.0366708562,
0.014258014,
-5.505483261e-33,
0.0084233806,
-0.054474391,
0.0102316355,
0.0649572164,
-0.0226869471,
0.028238846,
-0.0358572975,
-0.0451618992,
-0.0391935185,
0.0235004239,
-0.0111990562,
0.0633508489,
0.0037499168,
-0.0006577488,
-0.0129554458,
-0.0099567221,
0.0315435342,
-0.0154960724,
0.0036696917,
0.035508927,
0.0717535987,
0.021012878,
0.0673508868,
-0.0692965239,
0.0355149992,
-0.0566139705,
-0.0674759522,
-0.0016006841,
-0.0069135469,
0.0276978388,
0.0090431515,
0.0253698397,
0.0364805311,
-0.0437367521,
0.0132922865,
0.0583060719,
-0.019870894,
-0.0584837161,
0.0007252218,
0.0207116995,
0.0008538246,
-0.0246083885,
0.0567825288,
-0.0144891655,
0.0046617161,
0.0231941994,
0.0535066202,
-0.0010189451,
0.0080592586,
-0.030346185,
-0.0706296936,
-0.0005380152,
-0.0059187035,
-0.0261771064,
-0.0159603804,
-0.0019613248,
0.0095147397,
-0.0262147784,
-0.1193650663,
-0.015580466,
-0.0403936021,
-0.0006825936,
0.0217051171,
0.0153767709,
-0.0160458423,
0.0471291319,
0.0172225181,
0.0380660854,
-0.0232202597,
0.0283608139,
0.0128011964,
0.0178078301,
0.0948017463,
0.0761656463,
0.0275528356,
-0.0375998057,
-0.0836884528,
0.0479005538,
0.1019941941,
0.0077705435,
0.0197022334,
-0.0295113716,
-0.0502932407,
-0.0039883866,
0.0216373056,
-0.0220930912,
-0.0287915133,
-0.05290078,
-0.0010295891,
0.0043222192,
-0.0226753559,
-0.0104335276,
0.0299708601,
-0.0538477562,
0.0192205254,
0.0068959589,
-0.0292408168,
0.0153254503,
-0.0061458861,
0.0459712818,
-0.0307933427,
-0.0102189705,
0.0346773453,
0.0265156478,
-0.0009294803,
0.0002666172,
0.0760976076,
0.0487038419,
-0.0416421779,
0.0008881457,
0.0087840715,
0.0188662,
-0.0014172703,
0.0251033995,
-0.0178452078,
0.0147024402,
-0.0061705206,
0.0219572969,
0.0167750865,
0.0307261813,
-0.0297704488,
-0.0232303496,
-0.0175601393,
-0.0380601622,
-0.0263495483,
0.0001579343,
-0.010810405,
-0.0012230269,
-0.0075130467,
-0.099646762,
0.0030772074,
-0.0313380621,
2.63e-7,
0.022573052,
0.0264184996,
0.0165936071,
0.032470759,
0.018538326,
0.0256854203,
0.0468119122,
0.030902762,
-0.0080543915,
-0.0367603861,
0.0293330066,
0.0190340821,
0.0363670178,
0.0174300373,
-0.1196945012,
0.0018141188,
-0.0659002662,
-0.0049836566,
-0.0465649441,
0.0249192473,
0.0530075394,
0.0577934198,
0.0581014976,
-0.0521614999,
-0.0242609698,
-0.0542221777,
0.0390576981,
0.0297604147,
-0.0240249932,
0.0223077387,
0.0744580179,
-0.0020672297,
0.0248795412,
0.0210093278,
-0.0138041005,
0.0077682901,
-0.0181197505,
0.0127806179,
-0.0124565819,
-0.007085626,
0.0121163046,
-0.0276869684,
0.0193226915,
-0.0235910974,
0.0771149397,
0.0079624159,
-0.0373461358,
-0.0491240881,
-0.002864718,
-0.0372482315,
0.0435784981,
-0.0176564753,
0.0008313235,
0.0203514528,
-0.0151417926,
-0.0156087279,
0.0166544616,
-0.0571135953,
-0.0073251878,
-0.0460411049,
-0.0558398962,
0.0011400437,
-0.0158071462,
0.0036940346,
0.0713119581,
-0.0632558614,
0.0447876006,
2.23286231e-34,
0.0385679156,
0.0146973822,
-0.0191703252,
0.0189108141,
0.0425949283,
0.0444091149,
-0.0081959087,
0.0076275691,
-0.0139577892,
-0.0241059922,
-0.027127102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16681v1 | BabyStories: Can Reinforcement Learning Teach Baby Language Models to Write Better Stories? | 2023-10-25T14:45:48 | 2023-10-25T14:45:48 | Xingmeng Zhao, Tongnian Wang, Sheri Osborn, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models have seen significant growth in the size of their corpus,
leading to notable performance improvements. Yet, there has been limited
progress in developing models that handle smaller, more human-like datasets. As
part of the BabyLM shared task, this study explores the impact of reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) on language models pretrained from scratch
with a limited training corpus. Comparing two GPT-2 variants, the larger model
performs better in storytelling tasks after RLHF fine-tuning. These findings
suggest that RLHF techniques may be more advantageous for larger models due to
their higher learning and adaptation capacity, though more experiments are
needed to confirm this finding. These insights highlight the potential benefits
of RLHF fine-tuning for language models within limited data, enhancing their
ability to maintain narrative focus and coherence while adhering better to
initial instructions in storytelling tasks. The code for this work is publicly
at https://github.com/Zephyr1022/BabyStories-UTSA. | [
0.0503631979,
0.0545155928,
-0.043862395,
-0.0255313814,
-0.0471868105,
0.0299290661,
-0.020472968,
0.0082309972,
-0.0401915349,
-0.0528968126,
-0.0126453806,
-0.061291378,
0.0340785086,
0.0453351699,
0.0094295684,
-0.0748109296,
0.0369065404,
-0.0423473939,
0.0630860925,
-0.0026021567,
-0.0207461659,
0.0254559182,
-0.0177180581,
0.0552183501,
-0.016148204,
0.0216559749,
0.0011193188,
0.0088666286,
0.0099711055,
-0.0303194001,
0.0198381301,
0.0540739782,
0.0727164671,
0.0392324738,
0.0000020894,
-0.0477702804,
0.0038336224,
-0.0296165459,
0.0124898534,
-0.0243166313,
0.0630726591,
0.0016392759,
-0.0245986469,
0.0165740568,
-0.013618594,
-0.002874502,
0.0608083606,
0.0546779111,
-0.0047092577,
0.0784006566,
-0.0027521206,
-0.0132802296,
0.0104784546,
-0.0144325187,
0.05724084,
0.0256873984,
-0.0273509268,
0.0159688815,
0.0895121917,
-0.073554337,
-0.0454720855,
0.0149507457,
0.0335038044,
0.0054011047,
-0.0497837253,
0.0589993373,
-0.0050102579,
-0.0361459143,
-0.0342025906,
0.0237345453,
-0.001386205,
-0.0338255987,
-0.0225936379,
-0.0224980116,
-0.0104263322,
0.004098082,
-0.0442485064,
0.0635266826,
0.0016204917,
0.0328200087,
-0.0205283482,
-0.0357011519,
0.0261988081,
-0.0234965943,
0.0343107767,
0.0507691093,
0.0025679665,
-0.0327642895,
-0.0059161666,
0.0492860712,
0.0147901224,
-0.0515407845,
-0.0127653787,
0.007904158,
-0.0230353996,
0.0294549689,
-0.0624645688,
0.0532526337,
0.0086589577,
-0.0188524816,
0.0407350436,
0.0145663302,
-0.010419487,
-0.0029171123,
0.0296851508,
0.0400851108,
0.0402648039,
0.0229519289,
-0.0122837443,
0.0415899679,
-0.0529889502,
-0.0207289923,
-0.0258615948,
0.0095726829,
-0.0041431994,
-0.0139954071,
-0.0297060981,
-0.0075294743,
0.0127178347,
-0.0130684804,
-0.0237284973,
0.0162485447,
-0.052043099,
0.0227196086,
-0.0342948362,
0.0226912685,
-0.0391597711,
0.0074377898,
0.0328373313,
-0.0443243496,
-0.0235573258,
-0.0147987502,
0.0343873762,
-0.0053986921,
0.0078737754,
0.0176148545,
0.0014332442,
-0.0535193607,
-0.0392208807,
0.0128661897,
0.0013116358,
-0.11606659,
-0.0329060517,
-0.0548278093,
0.0123950932,
-0.0148804253,
0.0183391999,
-0.0654375851,
-0.0111255506,
0.0100297322,
-0.0155782588,
-0.0003375347,
-0.0102980966,
0.0125580914,
-0.0018876719,
-0.0008233043,
0.0127501274,
0.0798726678,
0.101733841,
-0.0134216854,
0.0099770157,
-0.0167761892,
-0.0016959683,
0.0039056537,
-0.0191657115,
0.0081490371,
-0.0197826326,
-0.0209256243,
-0.0199621003,
0.04504833,
0.0457063243,
0.0398192108,
-0.0321149826,
0.0627311915,
0.1180412471,
0.085071303,
-0.0058317124,
-0.0027710805,
0.0667097047,
0.0210969765,
0.0209584478,
0.0337085202,
-0.0392099991,
0.010880054,
0.0231432505,
0.0142798088,
-0.0104319965,
0.0119720828,
-0.0098019252,
-0.0214467049,
-0.0259325281,
0.0044840118,
0.0203775335,
0.0123304147,
0.0139800478,
0.0322902687,
-0.0548445098,
-0.0154433865,
0.0658000782,
-0.0616412759,
0.0246092584,
-0.0377855673,
0.0563774481,
0.0846989974,
0.0278690569,
-0.0138849476,
-0.0196403395,
-0.0427759215,
-0.0517299883,
0.0448732078,
0.0339504443,
0.0167222116,
0.0058063432,
-0.0046227779,
0.0149115324,
-0.0463200882,
0.0338239372,
0.0058038449,
0.0038397559,
0.0229168441,
-0.0325542465,
0.0199069865,
-0.0738089308,
0.0336197466,
-0.0667673796,
0.0114624137,
-0.0055855894,
-0.004689387,
-0.0099299531,
-0.0019975672,
-0.0376514792,
-0.0105185434,
0.017828811,
0.0237016026,
0.0217732117,
0.0496966317,
-0.0717298687,
-0.0477293059,
-0.0071875532,
-0.0094419839,
-0.0153621808,
0.0288291741,
0.0245412067,
0.0011948879,
0.0376859941,
-0.0618270896,
0.0753908083,
0.0002190865,
0.0146918697,
-0.0694542006,
-0.0231450535,
-0.0201069415,
0.0042383014,
0.0198480822,
0.0091681955,
-0.0491325445,
-0.0162442513,
-0.025480343,
-0.0443595685,
0.0131292846,
0.0384346172,
0.0161408558,
0.0230107792,
0.0375983156,
0.0316728093,
-0.064413242,
-0.0238225516,
-0.0594320372,
0.0003893971,
-0.0014650901,
-0.0097338995,
0.0262063742,
-0.006721722,
-0.0464683399,
0.0097359633,
-0.0341467969,
-0.0101198489,
-0.0016350271,
0.0104307104,
0.0155966682,
0.0148886172,
-0.0016659496,
-0.0622684658,
0.0047233165,
0.002363136,
0.0254572835,
0.0463859551,
0.0158487316,
-0.0372799672,
-0.0015929167,
-0.0236401446,
0.008905354,
-0.002387255,
-0.0155992648,
0.0539867766,
0.0000387136,
0.0738475695,
0.0638472959,
-0.0167180672,
0.0489876345,
0.0581660196,
-0.0431775972,
-0.0236728098,
0.024755979,
-0.0196481608,
-0.0235459395,
-0.048663035,
-0.0143957436,
-0.0097508635,
0.089199163,
0.0070553762,
0.0055317478,
-0.0669078231,
0.0336646251,
-0.0099550318,
-0.0309720095,
0.0159266386,
-0.0410359539,
-0.0278335754,
0.0692912266,
-0.0219118837,
-0.0844799504,
0.0799525306,
-0.0172969308,
-0.021213131,
-0.0561199076,
-0.0029570034,
-0.0270991027,
0.0617121346,
0.0273542255,
0.0356638692,
0.0005038881,
-0.0142621296,
-0.079405278,
-0.0060457657,
0.0292735007,
-0.0045936177,
0.0140720867,
-0.0364285447,
-0.0145294955,
0.0222502332,
-0.0612818822,
-0.0343413576,
-0.0262252241,
-0.0252440758,
0.0000891538,
0.0005691035,
-0.0562748164,
-0.0513769463,
0.0053081876,
0.03733797,
0.0388924703,
-0.0083217584,
-0.0212771781,
-0.0109851845,
-0.0256766751,
0.0562371127,
0.0023826445,
0.0216247421,
-0.0674888566,
0.0254313592,
0.0052603562,
0.0184445083,
0.0166708436,
-0.0018065807,
0.0520382747,
0.0349458419,
-0.028699005,
-0.0258134343,
0.0396652706,
0.062881507,
-0.087265268,
-0.0392044634,
0.0858516097,
0.0212445129,
-0.0128333066,
0.0323624648,
-0.0144088082,
0.0914047435,
0.0050294749,
0.0176844504,
-0.0460741073,
-0.0121974116,
0.0376334153,
0.052283477,
-0.0046757068,
-0.0255217068,
-0.0229244307,
-0.1199748069,
0.037580397,
0.0070504704,
-0.0576201789,
0.0021849524,
-0.0038105424,
-0.0169992708,
0.0223313868,
0.0174394194,
0.0381284431,
-0.0562168434,
-0.0034057498,
-0.0074177827,
-0.002780362,
-0.0543596745,
0.0175016653,
-0.0471387729,
0.0559475496,
0.0786265135,
0.0277966894,
-0.0048660301,
0.0328051038,
-0.0269046947,
0.0411658064,
-0.000061641,
-0.0011066019,
0.0175304394,
-0.0193807371,
0.003768693,
-0.015486218,
0.0500167198,
0.0328114443,
-0.0372637883,
-0.0010581346,
0.0374564193,
0.0126320003,
-0.0763438493,
0.0146762859,
0.0393239744,
0.0181645416,
0.0543064661,
0.0445148237,
-0.0828259066,
-0.0307511259,
-0.0179292634,
-0.0304291826,
-0.020631982,
-0.0432210453,
-0.0047487784,
-0.0031743965,
0.0059360187,
-0.0813902617,
-0.0572533123,
0.0360456482,
0.0233227182,
0.0221833382,
0.0019491939,
0.0156102059,
0.0167796016,
-0.0347287245,
0.0379954539,
0.0007228863,
0.0004127448,
-0.0822450146,
-0.0400388017,
-0.0060569253,
-0.062890701,
0.0011776162,
-0.0080445288,
-0.0763278008,
-0.0511990264,
-0.0040102899,
0.020137595,
0.0227209833,
0.0733209178,
0.0216075368,
-0.0635340884,
0.0265503936,
0.0224638358,
-0.0725342631,
0.0557124764,
0.0042145452,
0.0107409637,
0.0075457362,
0.0231117271,
-0.0261855107,
-0.0014966144,
0.0035624814,
0.046769172,
0.0330648199,
0.0078288503,
0.0113668181,
-0.0242124181,
0.0400991775,
-0.0375045463,
-0.0292703379,
-0.0769511759,
-0.0046779043,
-0.0226501115,
0.0112295998,
-0.0461649895,
-0.0115132751,
0.0166735221,
0.0251639467,
-0.0257373005,
-0.0161358397,
-0.0498752631,
0.0235426985,
-0.0367194936,
0.0296199843,
0.0270772707,
0.0348842032,
0.0171868708,
0.0408759341,
-0.0043161432,
0.019322807,
-0.0464486219,
0.0547863841,
0.0074949381,
0.0349273831,
-0.0066188243,
-0.0067566261,
0.0146777108,
-0.0044139456,
-0.0468339995,
-0.0269734636,
-0.0221497454,
-0.0042538512,
0.0358498096,
-0.0149711482,
0.0669717267,
-0.03862058,
0.01363366,
-0.0187089983,
-0.0133358622,
-0.0218706839,
0.000334668,
-0.0177223887,
0.0016870942,
-0.03551507,
0.0217284486,
0.0434836112,
0.0362472013,
0.0772653371,
-0.0313732736,
0.0315684788,
-0.0013581084,
-0.0192633998,
0.0403129309,
0.0080974316,
0.0073229643,
0.020340912,
-0.0596602336,
-0.0335703529,
-0.0479610562,
-0.0052779461,
-0.0166127589,
-0.0264899861,
0.0462748036,
-0.0039158445,
-0.0446005017,
-0.0080518816,
-0.0455174297,
-0.0422970764,
0.0173255689,
-0.0122950375,
0.0133149549,
-6.329608758e-33,
-0.0340436585,
-0.0079659922,
0.0220301244,
0.0042943414,
-0.0331488326,
-0.0113568641,
-0.0357789025,
0.0149997231,
0.0213844068,
0.0189512111,
-0.0121783055,
-0.0226042718,
-0.003058546,
0.0144749582,
-0.003615075,
0.0314114653,
0.0369221047,
0.005713196,
-0.0494375713,
0.0171462148,
0.0116466461,
0.0241619628,
0.0594981685,
-0.0222991928,
0.0063357633,
-0.0160779431,
-0.0309192315,
-0.0050022481,
-0.0016729988,
0.0600023158,
-0.0107323462,
0.0129669076,
0.0075856321,
-0.0077559324,
-0.0455906987,
0.0397212356,
-0.0574261397,
-0.0364550538,
0.0369398966,
-0.0107875811,
-0.050034605,
-0.0088729877,
0.0306944326,
-0.0136288479,
-0.0065404531,
-0.0226902794,
0.013101114,
-0.0150504922,
0.0137415323,
0.0106744468,
-0.0951715484,
0.0053251511,
-0.0114793945,
-0.0301201437,
0.0013168204,
0.043216072,
-0.0286055841,
-0.0135663841,
-0.0069337767,
0.0421860404,
0.0455362685,
0.0450737439,
0.0249640755,
0.0074099074,
0.0061918055,
0.0646136925,
0.0149837257,
0.0113810152,
-0.0068788049,
0.0349190012,
0.065346092,
0.0190962777,
0.027131889,
0.0391866267,
0.0096561592,
0.0036212429,
-0.0376032554,
0.0058271377,
-0.0098784929,
0.0456908606,
0.047301013,
-0.0016927634,
-0.0400018692,
-0.0278785415,
-0.090080604,
-0.0157654565,
0.0097387424,
-0.0471322685,
0.0370233245,
0.020529978,
-0.0165073313,
0.001911841,
-0.0078350902,
-0.0110328579,
-0.0132861352,
-0.0100120166,
-0.081828095,
0.0259682331,
0.0021937974,
0.007493936,
-0.0457414314,
-0.0175850168,
0.0376790091,
0.032479737,
0.0384023488,
0.0230354145,
0.0449110754,
0.0712138563,
-0.0808096603,
0.0317327157,
-0.0126206223,
0.0592270494,
0.0176693499,
-0.0467035249,
0.0198272057,
-0.0140845021,
-0.0132325683,
0.0372341312,
0.0172474124,
-0.0374203064,
-0.0447473936,
0.0174278021,
-0.0293050483,
0.0196811296,
-0.0388298482,
0.0032750298,
-0.0176651012,
0.0446189716,
0.0557864308,
-0.0357403979,
-0.0196056087,
-0.0016618905,
2.842e-7,
-0.0071391072,
0.0798715726,
0.0092993239,
-0.0016645334,
0.0244479477,
0.0352420323,
-0.0265128184,
0.0150778564,
0.0312003791,
0.0243490636,
-0.0004297584,
0.0234693177,
0.0622305572,
0.0225773174,
-0.0815677792,
0.0096467212,
-0.1025890857,
0.0126670031,
-0.0622552745,
-0.0291010123,
0.0022993886,
0.0580054484,
0.0419766493,
-0.0346743278,
0.042907659,
-0.0223550647,
0.0399698503,
-0.0530266017,
-0.0031031591,
0.0066566491,
-0.0626725107,
0.045570869,
-0.0017813275,
-0.0629114509,
-0.020285029,
0.0257399343,
-0.0558922514,
0.0355517939,
-0.0155787617,
-0.0049939896,
0.037234094,
0.0472256504,
-0.0379522294,
-0.0828262866,
0.0448525362,
-0.045298934,
-0.0258377455,
0.0140063334,
0.060760323,
-0.0341550596,
0.0185594186,
-0.0613092817,
-0.0258955974,
0.0297014639,
0.0023092744,
0.0247595888,
-0.0134079717,
-0.0390527584,
-0.0017231187,
0.0520249754,
-0.0111990469,
-0.0497204624,
-0.0454008169,
0.0054890923,
-0.0556227714,
-0.0629520342,
0.0290737189,
2.522923806e-34,
0.0273211673,
-0.0391833223,
0.0286237057,
0.0026929344,
0.0430450253,
0.0386955068,
0.0222454984,
-0.0007284283,
0.0605953671,
-0.0232543629,
-0.0210881997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16676v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16676v3 | SSLCL: An Efficient Model-Agnostic Supervised Contrastive Learning Framework for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-10-25T14:41:14 | 2023-12-11T04:51:49 | Tao Shi, Xiao Liang, Yaoyuan Liang, Xinyi Tong, Shao-Lun Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion recognition in conversations (ERC) is a rapidly evolving task within
the natural language processing community, which aims to detect the emotions
expressed by speakers during a conversation. Recently, a growing number of ERC
methods have focused on leveraging supervised contrastive learning (SCL) to
enhance the robustness and generalizability of learned features. However,
current SCL-based approaches in ERC are impeded by the constraint of large
batch sizes and the lack of compatibility with most existing ERC models. To
address these challenges, we propose an efficient and model-agnostic SCL
framework named Supervised Sample-Label Contrastive Learning with Soft-HGR
Maximal Correlation (SSLCL), which eliminates the need for a large batch size
and can be seamlessly integrated with existing ERC models without introducing
any model-specific assumptions. Specifically, we introduce a novel perspective
on utilizing label representations by projecting discrete labels into dense
embeddings through a shallow multilayer perceptron, and formulate the training
objective to maximize the similarity between sample features and their
corresponding ground-truth label embeddings, while minimizing the similarity
between sample features and label embeddings of disparate classes. Moreover, we
innovatively adopt the Soft-HGR maximal correlation as a measure of similarity
between sample features and label embeddings, leading to significant
performance improvements over conventional similarity measures. Additionally,
multimodal cues of utterances are effectively leveraged by SSLCL as data
augmentations to boost model performances. Extensive experiments on two ERC
benchmark datasets, IEMOCAP and MELD, demonstrate the compatibility and
superiority of our proposed SSLCL framework compared to existing
state-of-the-art SCL methods. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/TaoShi1998/SSLCL}. | [
0.0097856047,
0.0820371136,
0.0129587501,
0.0144477934,
-0.0293481834,
0.0470435098,
0.0096806446,
-0.0388331711,
0.0614737421,
-0.0334915593,
-0.0433676988,
-0.0245276913,
-0.0045380793,
0.0010219426,
0.0012944682,
-0.0655536354,
-0.0106797209,
0.0473542325,
0.0399730578,
0.0056837592,
0.0290654171,
0.019430181,
-0.0253006332,
0.0147089651,
-0.0561692305,
-0.0245381612,
-0.0325004607,
0.0395597741,
0.0579669364,
-0.0204777569,
0.0379415937,
0.0598296113,
0.0135912141,
0.0130814211,
0.0000023332,
-0.0145853637,
0.0046142163,
0.0060720537,
0.0000385987,
-0.0245357286,
0.0643770397,
-0.0137993395,
-0.024759436,
-0.0060606329,
-0.002642259,
-0.0272038393,
0.0909493044,
0.1186608002,
0.0527485982,
0.0672247186,
-0.0404088125,
-0.0275734104,
0.0038750903,
-0.001167834,
0.0032584236,
-0.028918514,
0.0165662766,
0.010837744,
0.0082914969,
0.0098869083,
-0.0264124293,
0.0175927561,
0.0092095667,
0.0064098556,
0.0257406309,
0.0225932449,
0.0030892096,
-0.0175213777,
-0.0036560716,
0.1007831618,
0.0204525776,
0.0279526822,
-0.0127706332,
-0.0074693053,
-0.0187649522,
-0.0413737148,
0.0084427604,
-0.0324130505,
-0.0079337861,
0.0341009572,
0.0053026606,
0.0438085943,
-0.0082483012,
0.0187927932,
0.0175474603,
-0.0267229266,
-0.0149082402,
-0.0210521966,
0.0265809372,
0.0080048302,
-0.0088944361,
0.0186854377,
-0.0148033556,
-0.0410895571,
-0.0306606069,
-0.001206363,
-0.0246694125,
-0.065315485,
-0.009831422,
-0.0300168097,
-0.0093174344,
0.0166093353,
-0.0681255758,
0.0651093423,
0.0237947423,
0.0420309193,
-0.0170380548,
-0.029014783,
-0.0126880445,
-0.023601139,
-0.0402962454,
0.0341140516,
-0.019563891,
0.0159181692,
-0.0381669514,
-0.0392792225,
-0.0687883198,
0.0078695975,
-0.0349307097,
0.0250106286,
0.011650621,
0.0293457992,
-0.0148330303,
0.0141833611,
0.0341452286,
0.0543511994,
-0.0113394894,
0.0096228188,
-0.0059487629,
-0.0957103446,
0.0058819158,
0.0112872897,
0.0302436464,
-0.0321387276,
0.0302034821,
0.0483580008,
-0.0300147906,
-0.0785582438,
-0.0359348096,
0.0080683092,
-0.0601169243,
-0.0394143015,
-0.001432644,
-0.0549155846,
0.0612090416,
-0.0222253874,
0.0184280053,
-0.0178174675,
0.0024973147,
-0.0389108919,
-0.0434567481,
0.0935823321,
-0.0045059896,
-0.0476850644,
-0.0006672358,
0.0035116179,
-0.022903733,
0.0493062735,
0.0029437102,
0.0044192751,
0.0182264838,
-0.0178768355,
0.016295271,
0.0096498495,
-0.0141658401,
-0.0217412245,
-0.0165826716,
-0.0316582061,
0.0276718438,
0.0134905893,
0.0517438613,
0.0483122878,
-0.0385442413,
-0.0533351749,
0.0600433387,
0.0318700895,
-0.0363246165,
0.033402767,
-0.0251788218,
0.058540944,
0.0094851973,
0.0004871486,
-0.0231572241,
0.0224426705,
0.0068702199,
-0.0181430671,
0.044254452,
0.0228529964,
-0.0524592102,
-0.0280177742,
0.0115028275,
-0.0365585163,
0.0069817612,
0.0341166928,
0.0457437895,
-0.0090447133,
-0.0507721156,
0.022833921,
0.0541973375,
-0.019656213,
-0.0569662601,
-0.0161366053,
-0.0167771578,
0.0545116812,
0.0051141111,
-0.0349622145,
-0.0114758359,
-0.0378074087,
-0.0115489084,
0.0657197013,
0.0282453131,
0.010088996,
0.0857556686,
-0.0538731813,
-0.019054221,
-0.0352143645,
0.0130459731,
0.0532171465,
-0.0075343195,
0.0261338968,
-0.0047685285,
-0.0048407712,
0.0197075997,
-0.0124848224,
-0.0174093638,
-0.0332983024,
0.0261330083,
0.0192561969,
0.034081053,
0.0056907004,
-0.0569830723,
-0.0362069979,
0.0038884371,
-0.0248260908,
-0.0103028677,
0.0053876257,
-0.0663101673,
-0.0943378359,
0.031781394,
-0.029379962,
-0.0105324015,
0.0537611246,
-0.0875636488,
-0.0013382261,
0.0384374596,
-0.0298272893,
0.0401036292,
-0.0409904979,
-0.0165335611,
-0.0096010035,
0.0464635193,
0.0019027601,
0.0405522846,
-0.0063442187,
-0.0215084106,
-0.0086829439,
0.0143465074,
0.0053532324,
-0.0261517763,
-0.0670230314,
-0.0070845024,
0.0182073265,
0.0270842426,
-0.0102848392,
0.0258573815,
-0.0697880983,
-0.0435056835,
-0.0970124155,
-0.0507599004,
-0.006121859,
-0.0396810919,
0.0059202099,
-0.0001035634,
-0.0119820368,
-0.0063314843,
-0.0033246225,
-0.042659238,
0.0001966078,
0.006165015,
-0.0052441536,
0.0037493538,
-0.0094010513,
-0.0500640571,
0.0160682816,
0.027079735,
0.0426892489,
-0.0384258218,
-0.0252885725,
0.0123373056,
0.0201371834,
-0.0262081567,
0.0477534011,
-0.0080850152,
-0.0273271538,
-0.0235429183,
-0.0142501881,
0.0068172589,
0.0670082197,
0.0116379969,
0.0626726374,
-0.0443065837,
-0.050647717,
-0.0291360077,
0.0496358685,
-0.0139962286,
0.0300683286,
-0.0243772697,
-0.0234616213,
-0.0459007733,
0.0808908865,
-0.0043171947,
0.0332541019,
-0.017414296,
-0.042524647,
0.0502113923,
-0.0581264459,
-0.0028978908,
0.0129115228,
-0.0134131433,
-0.0331152268,
-0.0321074948,
-0.0424007662,
0.0571451411,
0.0047826343,
-0.0376197845,
-0.0663276687,
-0.051414337,
-0.0101219732,
0.0290759448,
-0.0345366523,
0.0051471908,
0.0120157283,
0.0062889978,
-0.0185537506,
-0.0566054247,
-0.0231746566,
-0.0388403572,
0.0015549738,
0.0089994827,
-0.0070321066,
0.0521247946,
-0.0791146532,
-0.0381411277,
-0.0174891558,
-0.0708194673,
0.0101429168,
0.0097546177,
-0.0198390931,
-0.0282995161,
-0.0202472638,
0.0208419915,
-0.0316084176,
0.0221842881,
-0.0078114192,
0.0110705923,
0.0894758254,
0.0401658379,
0.0089031961,
0.0183525663,
0.001566035,
0.0749969408,
0.0708276182,
0.0538528934,
-0.0083707618,
-0.0447044335,
0.0243154839,
0.012868138,
0.0632575154,
-0.0251166858,
-0.0068086986,
0.0118934819,
-0.0186207313,
0.0298476983,
0.1160313562,
0.0002633082,
-0.0434268489,
-0.0065815602,
-0.0149235306,
0.0442367755,
0.0135997795,
0.0177218709,
-0.012936525,
-0.0597252287,
-0.0175197124,
0.0102212951,
-0.0071686655,
-0.031368386,
0.0072188824,
-0.058497455,
0.0420183428,
-0.004002789,
-0.0399691984,
-0.0380632095,
-0.0336952209,
0.0375747494,
-0.0344950221,
-0.0154722808,
-0.057620436,
0.033225093,
-0.0383352377,
0.0165014062,
-0.0018624108,
-0.0600756481,
0.035374634,
-0.0074253478,
0.0098342951,
0.0276999678,
0.0591854416,
0.0131403152,
-0.041988764,
0.0241134875,
-0.0421451442,
-0.0284238253,
-0.0312011745,
0.0535009168,
-0.044372201,
-0.0411670133,
-0.0039418126,
0.0101037361,
-0.0001457828,
-0.0154362815,
-0.0354335494,
0.0672112331,
-0.0110971909,
0.0099256476,
-0.0249677002,
0.0276982933,
0.0512222089,
0.0602639653,
0.0353346653,
-0.0584527552,
-0.018785432,
0.0188343134,
0.0303498022,
0.0129764676,
0.0275913347,
-0.006281707,
0.0266042352,
-0.0007017111,
0.0042034038,
-0.0642207712,
-0.0110066039,
0.0178792197,
-0.0664296299,
-0.0386878811,
-0.0369542055,
0.0122802351,
-0.052526094,
0.0441707596,
0.0006998321,
0.013439673,
-0.0304841548,
-0.0318601839,
0.0645078272,
-0.0163536314,
-0.0147021934,
0.0183751136,
-0.06248511,
-0.0614541322,
0.0107636265,
0.0150653664,
-0.0024068023,
0.0422045328,
0.0314108729,
-0.0234807543,
0.0413720794,
0.0518965162,
-0.0389897116,
0.0236182753,
0.0453399122,
-0.0086304024,
-0.0144175058,
0.0071969056,
-0.0356936343,
0.049045369,
0.0257161912,
0.0261062477,
-0.0284193438,
-0.0689790323,
-0.0103764841,
-0.0312716179,
0.0733680129,
0.0244164169,
0.0060951142,
-0.0123878261,
-0.0218369998,
0.017426325,
-0.0012993596,
-0.0701828301,
-0.0209942572,
-0.0155388648,
0.0518024862,
-0.0404492207,
-0.0017908196,
0.0255112275,
0.0307841152,
0.0340474136,
0.0035168771,
-0.0075679282,
-0.0406863242,
0.0001483951,
0.0276568215,
-0.0137845827,
0.0297231153,
0.0239917897,
0.0016323221,
0.0255431961,
0.077140145,
0.0398640446,
-0.0360047743,
-0.0045765103,
0.0229285937,
-0.0072314148,
-0.0130503932,
-0.0452922024,
0.0079864971,
0.0415633917,
-0.0415310748,
0.0227462184,
-0.0505982861,
-0.0071640266,
-0.0337190107,
0.0059114019,
-0.0383337997,
-0.0367529988,
0.0337916985,
0.0241882745,
-0.0157665554,
0.0264111869,
0.0067181652,
-0.0468724146,
0.0257089473,
-0.0103623169,
0.0175016839,
-0.0544091761,
0.0087209288,
0.1010272577,
-0.0162993576,
0.0255956408,
0.0135677503,
-0.0376135819,
-0.0742499754,
0.0865701288,
-0.0324868225,
-0.0385129191,
0.0340024121,
0.0563814379,
0.0415424928,
-0.0004726445,
0.0207605883,
0.0040598037,
-0.0198663976,
-0.0078098653,
-0.0448713116,
0.003873853,
-6.418011811e-33,
0.012860477,
-0.0113129225,
-0.0428457446,
-0.001570065,
-0.0054905326,
0.0464827865,
-0.0067187152,
-0.016896084,
-0.0137057202,
0.0498901121,
0.001748868,
0.0303041264,
0.0048120115,
0.0546802059,
-0.0227757413,
-0.0359010249,
0.0489554442,
-0.0117526231,
0.0246584155,
0.0296586361,
-0.0037287467,
0.047039412,
0.063620165,
-0.1366443634,
-0.0356352665,
0.0179713629,
-0.0033491116,
0.0226312485,
0.06145126,
0.0443867519,
-0.0376443528,
0.0529248379,
0.009702228,
-0.0526419729,
0.0042650294,
0.0287762135,
-0.0775748119,
0.0108293621,
-0.0433124714,
0.0124743879,
-0.0627259165,
-0.0123367766,
-0.0115108332,
0.01883219,
0.0041282168,
-0.0388854258,
0.027402306,
-0.0045640422,
0.0219627786,
-0.0286015328,
-0.0050035552,
0.035586372,
-0.0274147782,
0.0194050595,
0.0228385199,
0.0631904081,
0.0223456174,
0.0639989749,
-0.053656362,
-0.0002255685,
-0.0104697831,
-0.0265650768,
-0.0031758042,
0.0360410027,
0.009719965,
0.0793052167,
0.0648282617,
-0.0376466811,
0.0381469987,
0.0109488666,
0.0124439923,
0.0262966249,
-0.0045097475,
0.0794004127,
0.014651279,
0.0238782689,
-0.0259749815,
0.0095383963,
0.0213171579,
0.0062684081,
0.0160033572,
0.0035090295,
-0.0357725173,
-0.0202999059,
-0.0048388066,
0.0010334156,
-0.023873793,
-0.0255230553,
0.0388100557,
0.0058912351,
0.0114522744,
0.0100742336,
0.0113515407,
-0.0356929079,
-0.0188937001,
0.0478170961,
-0.0208886787,
0.038977351,
0.0159707721,
-0.0167440176,
-0.0623314269,
-0.035219606,
0.0383548886,
0.0160229206,
0.0279481038,
-0.0126113202,
0.0255042613,
0.0198243987,
-0.0583193041,
0.004473337,
0.0155943315,
0.0189511683,
-0.0277392082,
0.0094710924,
-0.0079622688,
0.0041584708,
-0.0191197395,
0.0387943834,
0.0197868831,
0.0556147397,
-0.0123653794,
-0.0468226634,
0.0079599852,
0.0344547331,
0.0063288026,
-0.0086196167,
-0.0075608087,
-0.0463169701,
-0.0095318062,
-0.0300460216,
0.0030259001,
-0.0079634618,
3.057e-7,
-0.0320605859,
-0.0087008988,
0.0335921273,
-0.0635440722,
0.0417565927,
0.0866889134,
0.0137144402,
0.0194282159,
0.0407225639,
-0.0684806854,
0.0569925569,
0.0416209586,
0.0700575411,
0.0088799717,
-0.094269976,
0.0112202177,
-0.0306666009,
-0.0291481912,
-0.0238517839,
0.025329968,
0.0950979292,
0.0948028788,
0.0526478961,
-0.027227208,
0.0134576065,
0.0122670205,
0.0488428809,
-0.0309712738,
0.0128708361,
-0.0181537997,
0.0052595111,
-0.019889487,
-0.0093902946,
0.0105718235,
0.0187348519,
0.0273167361,
0.0157259293,
0.0299094617,
0.0235141832,
-0.088609606,
-0.0037385297,
0.0477988794,
-0.040780995,
-0.0055863173,
0.0199559424,
-0.0735474154,
-0.0329533666,
-0.0240674037,
-0.0537257567,
-0.0017045533,
0.0430291481,
-0.0249776263,
-0.0410477482,
0.0106711667,
-0.0046771462,
-0.0322170407,
-0.0637286529,
-0.0646450669,
0.0273996666,
0.0523227304,
-0.0541831031,
-0.0367969424,
-0.0033090243,
0.0197347868,
0.0583259836,
-0.0147439586,
0.0105323382,
2.306382135e-34,
0.0263081267,
-0.0049111028,
0.014829671,
0.0581751093,
0.0048199329,
-0.0160982125,
-0.0539478995,
-0.0346529707,
0.044319205,
-0.0634220392,
0.0188745763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16654v1 | ChatGPT is a Potential Zero-Shot Dependency Parser | 2023-10-25T14:08:39 | 2023-10-25T14:08:39 | Boda Lin, Xinyi Zhou, Binghao Tang, Xiaocheng Gong, Si Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models have been widely used in dependency parsing task
and have achieved significant improvements in parser performance. However, it
remains an understudied question whether pre-trained language models can
spontaneously exhibit the ability of dependency parsing without introducing
additional parser structure in the zero-shot scenario. In this paper, we
propose to explore the dependency parsing ability of large language models such
as ChatGPT and conduct linguistic analysis. The experimental results
demonstrate that ChatGPT is a potential zero-shot dependency parser, and the
linguistic analysis also shows some unique preferences in parsing outputs. | [
0.0288547594,
0.0455247723,
0.004155288,
0.0392111577,
-0.0531204268,
0.0182823706,
0.000475417,
0.0126271741,
-0.0071838023,
-0.0685911104,
-0.0240080524,
0.0075893723,
-0.0444159098,
0.0175233167,
-0.0183374267,
-0.0463340618,
0.0536049604,
0.0322915167,
0.0003705777,
0.0247704741,
0.0184398945,
-0.001062897,
0.0008203469,
0.0215497315,
-0.0498769656,
-0.0416908562,
0.0090373848,
-0.0102069955,
-0.027059583,
-0.0516455285,
0.0216886979,
0.0335807949,
-0.0080290604,
0.0178026501,
0.0000017909,
-0.04712018,
-0.0224093068,
-0.0158082861,
-0.0206274427,
0.0173474737,
0.0034658199,
-0.0645813644,
-0.0245122761,
-0.0134512708,
-0.0344445407,
-0.0577927902,
0.027718775,
0.0411475375,
0.0565257892,
0.1028421745,
-0.0306282155,
-0.0678832158,
0.0094169714,
-0.0161867607,
0.0112933852,
-0.0383313037,
0.0113066304,
0.0449971929,
-0.0083251139,
0.0065016984,
-0.0213755164,
0.0052274019,
0.0029372957,
0.0090657193,
-0.0118442653,
0.0423130877,
-0.0717097074,
-0.0084867626,
-0.0001069732,
0.0644734204,
-0.0639089271,
-0.0290068556,
0.0035382216,
-0.031531509,
-0.0209631603,
0.0003831528,
-0.0507251546,
0.0321090631,
0.0090737026,
0.0460381322,
0.0361337885,
0.0308737345,
-0.0162615236,
-0.0221184082,
-0.0290286969,
0.0919965804,
-0.0033806993,
-0.022602465,
-0.0134604294,
0.0276250131,
-0.0477047414,
-0.0570432656,
0.0071952888,
-0.0132718971,
0.0333290882,
0.0202043317,
-0.0476071052,
-0.0099992137,
0.0028218105,
-0.0442518182,
-0.0113220038,
0.0514755808,
-0.0591172613,
0.0561888218,
-0.0205317866,
0.0299705658,
-0.0005564725,
-0.0349947773,
-0.0196214709,
0.0389970616,
-0.0681014583,
0.0012744389,
-0.0718055591,
0.0596860014,
-0.0236256216,
-0.0432416536,
-0.0090609966,
0.0059926049,
0.0373273976,
-0.000890617,
0.0165869966,
-0.0157050919,
-0.0387848467,
-0.0061722789,
0.0040428997,
0.0599906929,
-0.0135504492,
-0.01601227,
-0.0352082923,
-0.0865496248,
-0.0150103848,
0.0178002678,
0.01881372,
-0.0575429685,
-0.0101540778,
0.0361330658,
0.0322551429,
-0.043115221,
-0.0273479465,
-0.0028083578,
0.0119207203,
-0.0444427505,
0.0081927674,
-0.059711419,
-0.0019438502,
0.033154916,
0.0376683027,
0.0171281975,
-0.0030329998,
0.0191316381,
-0.0170814376,
0.0636166409,
0.0127992798,
-0.0246381145,
-0.0252816454,
-0.0235417839,
-0.0073817535,
0.0873403326,
-0.0168647151,
-0.0045091887,
0.0040624384,
0.0062032645,
-0.0029700783,
0.0283470545,
-0.0302714873,
-0.0352782421,
-0.0064014918,
-0.0092855208,
-0.011593828,
-0.0223829094,
0.0437177494,
0.0307956133,
-0.0493836738,
-0.0054866835,
0.0031323552,
0.0582190007,
0.0257022604,
0.0089041954,
0.069834128,
0.0495164357,
0.0111236339,
0.0532654561,
-0.0571689196,
-0.0247856732,
0.0024247817,
0.0027854345,
-0.08157368,
-0.0044477615,
-0.0139115034,
-0.0134578794,
-0.0063626943,
-0.0565827638,
-0.0196174923,
-0.060980171,
0.0561070591,
0.0132712554,
-0.0480642542,
0.0488874093,
0.0466886312,
-0.0185212716,
-0.045854263,
-0.0210696291,
-0.0013036806,
0.0326660834,
0.056476485,
-0.0312110353,
-0.0439608395,
0.0144524882,
0.0031208827,
0.0350097269,
0.0154163335,
0.0155537287,
0.0172517188,
-0.0358523764,
0.0183390025,
0.0017566907,
0.0316960849,
0.027252974,
-0.0379645936,
-0.015024215,
0.0069300262,
0.0726190358,
0.009481404,
0.0265029576,
0.0131072728,
0.0170948878,
0.0160033479,
-0.025701195,
0.0295473617,
-0.003053881,
-0.0395215042,
0.0288728457,
0.0070408885,
-0.0499101952,
-0.0099521372,
0.0425919294,
-0.0746570379,
-0.079381302,
0.0088430317,
-0.0359928645,
-0.0007496976,
-0.0117184697,
-0.0144464504,
-0.032014519,
0.0142027158,
0.0186638609,
0.0883382037,
0.0007940354,
0.0113396747,
0.0385296121,
0.0231195819,
-0.0441258401,
0.0685173273,
-0.0014403393,
0.0153293731,
-0.0677197725,
0.0463346839,
0.0504354611,
-0.0119738812,
-0.0475178026,
0.0118828611,
-0.0053707962,
-0.0499187671,
0.0026357805,
0.0082001854,
-0.0185811203,
-0.0054457597,
-0.0912216529,
-0.0004963302,
-0.0188032668,
0.0361820832,
0.045126047,
-0.0033587629,
-0.008612847,
-0.0160373785,
0.0129831685,
0.0285112355,
0.0043710568,
-0.0079845795,
0.0180297755,
0.0153252427,
-0.0035518238,
-0.0443973467,
-0.0117499884,
-0.0328628086,
0.0213268362,
0.0207714494,
-0.0371875502,
-0.0074397218,
0.0669073313,
0.0065442361,
0.0454111099,
0.027997056,
-0.0573662557,
0.0424063578,
-0.0446329527,
0.0328533277,
0.0270828996,
-0.0449245833,
-0.0068881195,
0.0095244693,
-0.0440612137,
-0.0261735357,
-0.0075406637,
0.0105528673,
0.0178146809,
-0.0264776722,
0.014237524,
-0.0241196733,
0.0875065923,
0.0142901242,
-0.0026184791,
-0.05897462,
0.0108772144,
-0.0446546189,
0.0116823856,
0.0212204773,
0.0025659017,
-0.0121413171,
0.016139945,
-0.0208482053,
-0.0022462299,
0.0141317751,
-0.0329471342,
-0.0339538939,
-0.0339922607,
0.0441505797,
-0.0360338278,
0.0497817807,
0.0642417893,
-0.0287628565,
0.0381745249,
-0.0599760599,
0.0220727362,
0.0199534912,
0.0265722033,
0.020076124,
0.0121698193,
-0.0507246889,
0.0502265915,
-0.0215806551,
-0.0222716462,
-0.0291672572,
-0.0616753921,
-0.0390343927,
0.0086764516,
-0.0040824441,
0.0131460689,
0.0252455119,
0.0188151635,
-0.0291622262,
0.0534555838,
-0.0015225316,
-0.000119895,
-0.0359920263,
0.0280336458,
0.0305312984,
-0.0310099944,
-0.0336114056,
0.0475267097,
0.0306765679,
0.0523954853,
0.0412835144,
0.0173119437,
-0.0468686149,
-0.0003098002,
-0.0155443503,
-0.0017781212,
-0.0624534264,
-0.0399091132,
0.0018782704,
-0.0349264406,
-0.000625708,
0.1122953817,
0.0609131679,
-0.0166793447,
0.0338201597,
0.002970739,
0.0225144979,
0.0189435482,
0.0158884749,
-0.1238483191,
-0.0365562811,
-0.0044533182,
-0.051882714,
-0.0176446922,
-0.0267213024,
-0.0015725469,
-0.1228637099,
0.0089622093,
0.0030649637,
0.0283040572,
0.0445779599,
0.0109877512,
-0.0279297382,
-0.067949459,
-0.014835177,
0.0065795537,
-0.0166827887,
0.0024059261,
0.0072295261,
-0.0614545383,
-0.0589942038,
0.0263621267,
-0.011390402,
0.0523433015,
0.0643821508,
-0.0133964662,
-0.0472158603,
0.0501648076,
0.0770219341,
-0.0256309975,
0.0075623412,
-0.0168868508,
0.044275336,
-0.0074276328,
-0.0296271555,
0.0134464623,
-0.0135210678,
-0.0098064188,
-0.0003207996,
-0.0175789278,
0.0316258818,
-0.0264274478,
0.026178848,
0.0335918739,
-0.01288174,
-0.0067986874,
0.0600627623,
0.0230971724,
-0.0157080181,
-0.0609533191,
-0.027192058,
-0.0287982486,
-0.0600964725,
-0.0524556488,
0.0100102834,
-0.0052560349,
-0.0544919446,
-0.084116213,
-0.064950265,
0.0439267606,
0.0126934657,
-0.0528972261,
-0.0130609535,
0.0316884406,
-0.0034886778,
0.0582431033,
0.0443090461,
0.0161392894,
-0.0264112707,
-0.0821056366,
-0.0200496446,
0.0667778105,
0.0169119313,
-0.0270448904,
-0.0111335274,
-0.0520598143,
-0.0484454036,
0.0423126891,
0.0574755482,
0.0217712633,
0.0073203426,
-0.0846829638,
-0.0377365313,
-0.0389952622,
0.0513937883,
-0.0638131723,
0.0111499,
0.0322530568,
0.0145884557,
0.0254728906,
0.021266032,
0.0373376347,
0.0587823391,
-0.0085659642,
0.0305415746,
-0.0436693616,
0.0287769996,
0.0745420679,
0.0285447761,
0.0653290153,
0.0187597666,
0.0578048751,
-0.008165163,
0.013310032,
-0.1092601418,
-0.0039043708,
-0.0624707602,
-0.0182180796,
0.0367078856,
-0.0113798855,
-0.0168770906,
-0.0391297378,
-0.091267772,
0.0302585214,
-0.0065816827,
0.0101974905,
0.0515710935,
0.0016951239,
0.0277026109,
-0.014707569,
-0.0206712484,
-0.0195081532,
0.0034796169,
0.0058717281,
-0.0453038998,
0.0355398506,
0.0136159863,
-0.0121866399,
-0.0352097861,
-0.0047711106,
-0.0151809007,
0.028440414,
0.0289562047,
0.0283222217,
0.0845727399,
-0.0641692057,
0.1003908291,
-0.0242008977,
0.0243761502,
-0.0089727696,
0.0349679068,
0.0141461147,
-0.0067015891,
0.0139982905,
-0.004571951,
-0.0349388868,
0.0132589564,
0.1042119637,
0.0109138368,
0.0521715134,
0.01650705,
0.0255858246,
-0.0267228521,
0.0006674299,
-0.0271127708,
0.0046876711,
-0.024675373,
0.0688046291,
-0.0450377241,
-0.0287858732,
-0.0181822311,
0.0099925175,
-0.0015638005,
0.0017318032,
0.0228043422,
0.0403864793,
0.0152549995,
-0.0101299044,
-0.0106445178,
0.0143145677,
0.0007750228,
-0.0297841709,
-0.0351697244,
-6.199934099e-33,
-0.0263029374,
0.0322681777,
0.0075188,
0.0304405019,
-0.0032601533,
0.0048489156,
-0.0265008714,
0.0335228257,
-0.0055012372,
-0.0055829645,
-0.0375205018,
-0.0131136337,
0.0244758818,
0.0295242164,
0.0444998071,
0.000619508,
0.0119182998,
-0.0389697365,
0.0083233742,
-0.0169615727,
0.0432756878,
0.0530049689,
0.0566993169,
-0.0225367844,
-0.0217573922,
-0.0465944186,
0.0034217895,
0.0033179489,
0.0081857787,
0.0479417965,
-0.0123378709,
-0.0330647863,
0.0437250845,
0.0016003597,
-0.0346728973,
-0.0117450878,
-0.0707003549,
-0.0130656352,
0.0307911448,
0.0297026243,
-0.0151393376,
-0.0000559057,
0.0263800398,
-0.02104876,
0.0377805233,
0.0285109021,
-0.0004219628,
-0.0295681767,
0.0098535521,
0.0446915068,
-0.086573936,
0.0495507531,
-0.0069610388,
0.0159652941,
0.0568441711,
0.0744890794,
-0.0026926652,
0.0132836336,
0.0111225443,
-0.0090891887,
-0.0182558037,
0.0714892969,
0.0111232903,
-0.0327590443,
0.0152322892,
0.0415471867,
-0.0105060358,
-0.0446559712,
-0.021805957,
0.0369401984,
0.0219312906,
0.0162905119,
-0.0105480319,
-0.0129416864,
0.0583504066,
0.0156287327,
-0.0641688928,
-0.0267011747,
0.0829838291,
0.0564340763,
-0.0339162201,
0.0354507081,
-0.0271586999,
-0.0042379024,
0.0360550284,
-0.027925631,
-0.0141843176,
-0.066960454,
0.0141466521,
-0.0151613522,
0.0153868599,
0.0156224985,
0.0703552589,
-0.0230436642,
-0.0166967027,
-0.012254999,
-0.0257177688,
0.0543073975,
-0.0326740295,
0.0052618971,
-0.0733636469,
-0.0243024733,
0.0109605026,
0.0096094972,
0.0317273699,
0.0081159342,
0.0604460649,
0.0023183115,
-0.0392779224,
-0.0041887383,
-0.0369219817,
-0.015425222,
-0.0204024222,
0.05796979,
0.0302603543,
0.0164052974,
-0.0285066422,
0.0408659093,
0.0120223584,
-0.0126434742,
-0.0220239908,
-0.0024014048,
0.0023057812,
0.0287956242,
-0.0344496258,
-0.021512283,
-0.0091622788,
0.0243985094,
0.0141634271,
-0.0198511314,
-0.0168103017,
0.0231982637,
2.533e-7,
0.0530682206,
0.0293837413,
0.0254584551,
-0.0248826705,
0.0338901207,
-0.004092033,
-0.046743542,
0.0328572243,
-0.0115069347,
-0.0057001938,
-0.0116536329,
-0.0077837678,
0.0078488598,
0.0145064965,
-0.0919471681,
-0.0062728007,
-0.0329515599,
-0.0493940115,
-0.0285080522,
-0.0206042733,
0.0617245771,
0.1071717963,
-0.0067771506,
0.0387910716,
0.0030839257,
-0.0043458361,
0.0221310202,
0.0197243541,
-0.0517801344,
0.0232313443,
-0.0021402568,
0.0254213866,
-0.0213390719,
0.0192293543,
0.0136834066,
0.0303102061,
-0.0003558333,
0.0615171865,
-0.0124542983,
0.0164131988,
0.034428928,
0.0217584297,
-0.0205696281,
-0.0008686389,
0.1023882851,
-0.0725364387,
-0.0150462762,
0.006204024,
-0.0549858324,
0.0323243588,
-0.0229241699,
0.0107321274,
-0.0406870209,
0.0226154905,
0.0381105132,
-0.0215758625,
-0.0640145913,
-0.0355738103,
-0.0420310199,
0.0213805195,
-0.0233445149,
0.0101832794,
0.0124118803,
-0.0078210058,
0.01824346,
0.0027401019,
-0.0226671193,
2.278257514e-34,
0.0304390267,
-0.0002727541,
0.0392631516,
0.0222895015,
0.0321786739,
0.006371534,
-0.0489404909,
0.0646083057,
-0.0303186048,
-0.0750156417,
0.0016196769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16621v1 | ArTST: Arabic Text and Speech Transformer | 2023-10-25T13:20:54 | 2023-10-25T13:20:54 | Hawau Olamide Toyin, Amirbek Djanibekov, Ajinkya Kulkarni, Hanan Aldarmaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | We present ArTST, a pre-trained Arabic text and speech transformer for
supporting open-source speech technologies for the Arabic language. The model
architecture follows the unified-modal framework, SpeechT5, that was recently
released for English, and is focused on Modern Standard Arabic (MSA), with
plans to extend the model for dialectal and code-switched Arabic in future
editions. We pre-trained the model from scratch on MSA speech and text data,
and fine-tuned it for the following tasks: Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR),
Text-To-Speech synthesis (TTS), and spoken dialect identification. In our
experiments comparing ArTST with SpeechT5, as well as with previously reported
results in these tasks, ArTST performs on a par with or exceeding the current
state-of-the-art in all three tasks. Moreover, we find that our pre-training is
conducive for generalization, which is particularly evident in the low-resource
TTS task. The pre-trained model as well as the fine-tuned ASR and TTS models
are released for research use. | [
-0.0282263383,
0.0739864111,
0.0213315766,
-0.0207256097,
-0.0364895537,
-0.0115701118,
0.0403424948,
-0.0183990709,
-0.0648423731,
-0.0496872179,
-0.0701580271,
-0.0420756117,
0.0668162256,
0.0384389199,
0.0232633315,
-0.0358611606,
0.0095061455,
-0.100518845,
-0.0407654606,
0.0104167182,
0.0466698073,
0.0507426113,
-0.0074598114,
0.0219910275,
0.0097758379,
0.0024614895,
-0.0370554775,
-0.0001819345,
0.014013838,
0.0472068153,
-0.0069737276,
0.0272412952,
0.0140948882,
0.0229751803,
0.0000020464,
-0.0319422521,
-0.0601969212,
-0.0110266889,
-0.0173664,
0.0029540209,
0.0714672655,
-0.0427202433,
-0.0422492363,
0.0378187895,
-0.0135633191,
0.0077549801,
0.0523668751,
0.0525094531,
0.0380932167,
0.0550738163,
-0.0111692641,
-0.0674861819,
0.0185151249,
-0.0030001001,
-0.0472554192,
0.0129315825,
-0.0529356934,
-0.055523362,
0.0094616525,
0.0047933068,
-0.0195085052,
0.0527357608,
-0.0080815712,
0.001438722,
-0.0479939766,
-0.0359904692,
-0.0424154289,
-0.0318333842,
-0.0090541076,
0.0434801318,
-0.0046337405,
-0.0376570374,
-0.0066006207,
0.006788549,
-0.0068101822,
0.0110056549,
0.0111242104,
0.0441732816,
-0.0264561139,
-0.0063181254,
0.0202257466,
0.0307855345,
-0.0047270493,
-0.0389695801,
-0.0380922072,
-0.0082647754,
0.0194038842,
-0.0278850645,
0.0048813559,
-0.0397255085,
0.0216153003,
-0.0029727435,
0.06867937,
-0.0098140463,
0.0120153464,
-0.0263536535,
-0.0576726496,
-0.0467582792,
-0.0425036103,
-0.0121675972,
0.026688138,
0.0767694488,
-0.0486483835,
-0.02331076,
-0.0321777612,
0.0006847402,
-0.0005794696,
0.0450535342,
-0.0641032904,
-0.0074202497,
-0.0607909635,
0.0254439637,
-0.0417311452,
0.0105798813,
-0.0651125461,
-0.0111221485,
-0.0322801881,
0.0024557239,
-0.0039518015,
0.0077003101,
0.0484298654,
-0.0111216241,
-0.0482914634,
-0.0668498129,
0.0221584365,
0.016180722,
0.0428869836,
0.041082643,
-0.044395607,
-0.0879142657,
-0.0025651893,
0.0395984091,
0.0605535544,
0.0497300774,
-0.0041613788,
0.0432220809,
-0.0336768627,
-0.0509838685,
-0.0557121299,
0.0246474855,
-0.0272398852,
-0.0118126757,
-0.0170278084,
-0.0604306981,
0.0319059864,
0.0170669965,
-0.0224863198,
0.0014619642,
-0.018017998,
-0.0053372574,
0.0539548956,
0.0678473935,
0.0150041254,
0.0139604714,
0.0673133135,
0.0151666822,
0.0380014814,
0.0521185733,
0.049957864,
-0.0142725175,
-0.0253745299,
-0.0223919377,
0.0086573698,
0.0788410082,
-0.0208889134,
0.0251785535,
-0.0329160541,
-0.0441192798,
-0.0212907139,
0.0479270928,
0.0151279345,
0.0379366837,
-0.0170234796,
-0.0040894896,
0.0815116316,
0.0021360146,
0.0408384688,
0.0655430779,
0.0499667116,
0.0499306843,
0.0390244871,
-0.0093952119,
0.0265852697,
-0.0011976823,
0.0002778437,
0.0247631762,
0.0254308544,
0.0951946452,
-0.0340314358,
-0.0243905094,
-0.005627803,
-0.0444296971,
-0.0090966802,
-0.0067469417,
0.0734233633,
0.0297034271,
-0.0716581047,
0.0514733195,
-0.0044224714,
-0.0391089767,
0.0040075062,
-0.0526946262,
-0.0401382744,
0.0197321326,
0.0156385433,
-0.0209495481,
-0.0043384018,
-0.0684423819,
-0.0340437144,
0.0446311347,
0.0175640564,
0.0066111754,
0.0323967934,
-0.0615312643,
0.0145012503,
0.0389549881,
-0.0048227143,
0.0236370228,
-0.030872507,
0.0742878467,
-0.0012584437,
-0.0182367116,
0.0446906574,
0.0071448833,
-0.0187596679,
0.0125569133,
0.0438023023,
-0.0027905735,
0.0411249213,
0.0319832563,
-0.0317581184,
0.016618602,
-0.0140857091,
-0.0445104428,
-0.008597075,
0.04937163,
-0.0564058237,
0.005570448,
0.0457469076,
-0.0000603168,
0.0385873616,
0.0660728216,
0.0277538057,
-0.0957456157,
0.1204151958,
-0.0213519465,
0.0633625314,
-0.0244473908,
0.0535430685,
0.0440490432,
0.0091831116,
0.0301112868,
-0.0085227005,
0.0011011759,
-0.0542734824,
0.0239341985,
-0.0030562894,
0.0437274724,
0.0154845966,
0.0138042085,
0.000221135,
-0.0296587218,
0.0303145573,
0.0256225448,
0.0006149513,
0.0043787761,
-0.0556053035,
-0.0826264843,
0.0040844409,
-0.0267558321,
0.0405406468,
-0.0007814268,
0.0441602357,
-0.0147087146,
-0.0084895501,
-0.0162314549,
-0.0277941767,
0.0056146691,
-0.0369048566,
-0.0229772478,
-0.0183694661,
-0.0102467528,
-0.0478767343,
0.024524359,
0.030418219,
0.0144718634,
-0.003774289,
-0.0294315591,
-0.005766789,
-0.0285102148,
0.0450938605,
0.0435408056,
0.0023837185,
-0.0274623949,
0.0169016216,
-0.0109341694,
0.0663393885,
0.0142121837,
0.0023691482,
-0.0112585844,
0.012496097,
-0.0215408225,
-0.0360932276,
-0.0038016646,
0.0211004503,
-0.0251275357,
-0.0249774158,
-0.0429190136,
-0.0243273173,
0.0200053174,
0.0459151715,
0.0388924517,
-0.0356207341,
-0.0217581354,
0.0250111315,
0.0126795303,
0.0584669635,
0.0220414959,
-0.0268887524,
0.034971945,
0.0119672446,
-0.0381294973,
-0.0284503251,
-0.074363187,
-0.0355279483,
-0.0055515948,
-0.0027991033,
-0.0219369065,
-0.0247141737,
-0.036587555,
0.0211790949,
-0.0133543424,
-0.031198455,
-0.0345749073,
0.012001262,
0.0124614649,
-0.0464216247,
0.0169360749,
-0.0514237061,
0.010251292,
-0.0455211513,
-0.0137974098,
0.0243109763,
0.0242310539,
-0.0657049045,
0.0222273339,
0.034512613,
-0.0396646261,
0.0036827102,
0.0258215964,
0.0273479782,
0.1006736457,
0.0023605281,
-0.0004734768,
-0.0132214287,
0.0075737797,
0.0135756005,
0.0220515653,
0.000776039,
-0.0058607333,
0.0288069714,
-0.0154147316,
-0.0073506841,
-0.0064596599,
-0.0893074572,
-0.0342513584,
0.0439278483,
-0.0086667659,
-0.0339203477,
-0.0160510261,
0.0194903705,
-0.0099375052,
0.0380916409,
0.0928761363,
-0.0044804546,
0.0014327151,
-0.0411136188,
0.0050123339,
-0.0050267437,
-0.0341820605,
-0.025037257,
-0.1208814755,
-0.0456067845,
0.0600183532,
0.0556991398,
0.0323081464,
0.0496954434,
0.0106195658,
-0.064061448,
0.0294392947,
0.0092234882,
-0.0469454788,
-0.0704304948,
-0.0149826901,
-0.0367399119,
-0.0337308608,
-0.0103650764,
-0.0376831926,
-0.0312549211,
0.0139921503,
0.034203954,
-0.015981555,
-0.0600958392,
0.0011241029,
-0.0130911199,
0.0820832625,
0.0053945468,
-0.001865844,
-0.0222089291,
-0.0464698523,
-0.0286273099,
-0.015930282,
-0.0199909881,
-0.0103209466,
0.0012271866,
0.0087202219,
0.0004620892,
-0.0119575951,
-0.0027610704,
-0.0499260016,
0.0106417583,
-0.0142277665,
0.0193095002,
-0.0138861313,
0.01264052,
0.0394947492,
0.0317038894,
-0.0247139521,
0.0152716022,
-0.0416930206,
-0.0328727476,
-0.0443180427,
0.0173711609,
0.0265939962,
-0.0577065051,
-0.0446007587,
-0.0005911834,
0.0254568029,
-0.0273596235,
-0.0537189767,
0.0229746159,
0.0046565635,
0.0341653787,
0.0252150614,
0.008890871,
0.017813839,
0.0514319502,
-0.0289283451,
-0.0295201205,
-0.002197505,
0.0120825414,
-0.0721202344,
-0.0356215313,
0.0315618962,
-0.109603785,
0.0275154766,
0.0041981791,
-0.0641529113,
-0.0304936375,
0.0366624929,
-0.0160695277,
0.0167896897,
0.0396556705,
-0.0077344086,
-0.0017019965,
0.0277934894,
-0.0205165185,
-0.0164097007,
0.0321258008,
0.0822573751,
-0.0022535557,
-0.0430840515,
0.0206848048,
0.0002309941,
0.021796992,
0.0028764748,
-0.041134242,
-0.0067722891,
-0.0772287622,
0.0110829175,
-0.0240732022,
0.0119225644,
-0.0261898004,
0.006704588,
-0.0488470122,
-0.0032746615,
-0.0028716999,
0.0633991361,
-0.0548910946,
0.0249315146,
0.0427718945,
0.04279254,
0.0202439316,
0.0456981175,
-0.007920756,
-0.0214934554,
0.0288405009,
0.059848547,
0.0357588679,
0.031937331,
0.0193852987,
0.0099537615,
-0.0070365393,
0.0007663182,
-0.0066583203,
0.0192052666,
-0.0266951788,
0.0417129137,
-0.0461927839,
0.0142178684,
0.0373658463,
0.0714310706,
-0.0005538821,
-0.0253164042,
-0.0399227738,
0.0604974851,
0.0088590486,
-0.0230768919,
0.0872797444,
-0.0034762311,
0.0347321965,
-0.0179051924,
0.0224351734,
-0.0309201889,
0.0174428839,
-0.053953182,
-0.0371330865,
-0.0069728643,
0.0575506315,
0.0576675311,
-0.0188431032,
0.0021419863,
0.0031974525,
0.0172511097,
-0.0136836544,
-0.0244318247,
0.0120900767,
-0.0314407684,
-0.039838247,
-0.0011694304,
-0.0287284087,
-0.0553302802,
0.0279091038,
-0.0008194221,
0.0099454634,
-0.029640004,
0.0082106106,
0.0253893733,
-0.0277286563,
0.0049157385,
-0.0363040976,
-0.0186328255,
0.0243933406,
-0.0238069594,
0.0116682276,
-5.938183833e-33,
0.0044348403,
0.0409422033,
-0.0049715936,
-0.003325155,
-0.0059703374,
-0.0436946563,
-0.0153560331,
0.0261743627,
-0.0068323975,
-0.0254974011,
-0.0417786278,
0.0065313303,
0.0244674124,
0.0105598345,
0.0213622712,
0.0064671705,
0.0563105084,
-0.0443014055,
-0.0050788494,
0.038461104,
0.0371164829,
0.0089337602,
0.0759671777,
-0.0693823695,
-0.050352633,
-0.0063222949,
-0.0397655517,
-0.0371534117,
-0.006818925,
0.0308714714,
0.0131830135,
0.0427668691,
-0.009367181,
-0.0355053619,
-0.0048492877,
0.0163798016,
-0.0261448622,
0.0283638109,
-0.0077602179,
0.0639981106,
0.0184928533,
-0.0345619991,
-0.0022509038,
-0.0126527101,
-0.0728191063,
-0.0013302829,
-0.0212662499,
-0.0233812314,
0.0276270043,
-0.0259654783,
-0.079881072,
0.0611826479,
-0.0171429999,
-0.0400350951,
0.0603009649,
0.069766283,
-0.0220755991,
-0.0411963575,
-0.0224878341,
0.0115782171,
0.0325729921,
0.0232841298,
0.045096118,
0.0182828717,
-0.0680888295,
-0.0061796801,
0.0173882358,
-0.0505386814,
0.0435418524,
0.0019886466,
0.0477896854,
-0.0150835058,
0.0343281142,
0.0858460441,
0.0107273748,
-0.022951819,
-0.0145850899,
0.0058871824,
-0.0040999493,
-0.0116198007,
-0.0051606726,
0.0233185794,
-0.0243698116,
0.0164464172,
-0.0232599359,
-0.0538486093,
0.0111532286,
-0.0048362594,
0.0360739268,
0.0321466736,
0.0117213847,
0.0183525383,
0.0319379531,
0.0335217528,
0.0721195489,
-0.0206787251,
-0.0365088023,
0.01047251,
-0.01742764,
0.0365870073,
-0.0415555649,
-0.0332359746,
0.0766022131,
0.023189567,
0.005941493,
-0.0175186098,
-0.0234265253,
0.0990325883,
-0.0716652274,
0.0195111744,
-0.0038244117,
0.055678416,
0.0071251378,
0.0426036529,
0.0207065158,
-0.0313832462,
0.0114024067,
0.0223147981,
-0.0257499386,
0.0181388203,
-0.011876421,
-0.0353276245,
-0.0005053945,
-0.0014680327,
-0.0278563797,
0.0456020869,
-0.027302701,
-0.0493122227,
0.0089191003,
-0.0196425784,
-0.0097864494,
0.0067224856,
2.846e-7,
0.0018715094,
0.0074572233,
0.0427758843,
-0.0526066609,
0.0108032497,
0.0277838204,
0.021450039,
0.0193802752,
0.0280354414,
0.035148602,
0.0080930982,
-0.030248357,
0.0752741769,
0.012751353,
-0.0965103805,
-0.0386491902,
-0.0281338021,
0.0432823524,
-0.0044144713,
-0.0081272507,
0.0291846506,
0.1331945956,
-0.0903072432,
-0.0098733939,
-0.0173948333,
-0.0235023256,
0.0477225594,
-0.0108800996,
-0.0063604084,
0.0050248057,
0.029767219,
-0.0548254699,
-0.0348108821,
-0.0553717874,
-0.0476054363,
0.0213174224,
0.0296090487,
0.091145739,
0.014596032,
-0.0325372405,
0.0179536976,
0.0000664119,
-0.0524348505,
-0.0033837073,
0.0662219822,
0.0259608123,
0.0074031334,
-0.0225117076,
-0.038211178,
0.0508986488,
-0.0209668186,
-0.0481150858,
0.0071049724,
0.0184316635,
0.0353768989,
0.0133140394,
0.0072124884,
-0.0246970952,
0.0239274725,
0.0024648509,
-0.0126189003,
-0.0001944744,
-0.0265792329,
-0.0234862715,
0.0304371361,
-0.009250829,
0.0086926809,
2.199343043e-34,
0.0224797688,
-0.0155533962,
0.0203972943,
-0.021585701,
0.0051467237,
-0.0366030633,
-0.0291620251,
0.0381731316,
0.0069257952,
-0.0238735825,
-0.0427672192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16616v1 | Context Does Matter: End-to-end Panoptic Narrative Grounding with Deformable Attention Refined Matching Network | 2023-10-25T13:12:39 | 2023-10-25T13:12:39 | Yiming Lin, Xiao-Bo Jin, Qiufeng Wang, Kaizhu Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Panoramic Narrative Grounding (PNG) is an emerging visual grounding task that
aims to segment visual objects in images based on dense narrative captions. The
current state-of-the-art methods first refine the representation of phrase by
aggregating the most similar $k$ image pixels, and then match the refined text
representations with the pixels of the image feature map to generate
segmentation results. However, simply aggregating sampled image features
ignores the contextual information, which can lead to phrase-to-pixel
mis-match. In this paper, we propose a novel learning framework called
Deformable Attention Refined Matching Network (DRMN), whose main idea is to
bring deformable attention in the iterative process of feature learning to
incorporate essential context information of different scales of pixels. DRMN
iteratively re-encodes pixels with the deformable attention network after
updating the feature representation of the top-$k$ most similar pixels. As
such, DRMN can lead to accurate yet discriminative pixel representations,
purify the top-$k$ most similar pixels, and consequently alleviate the
phrase-to-pixel mis-match substantially.Experimental results show that our
novel design significantly improves the matching results between text phrases
and image pixels. Concretely, DRMN achieves new state-of-the-art performance on
the PNG benchmark with an average recall improvement 3.5%. The codes are
available in: https://github.com/JaMesLiMers/DRMN. | [
0.0243781842,
0.0255557355,
0.0251969211,
0.0418564714,
-0.0147993574,
-0.0096234791,
0.00292524,
-0.0079770898,
-0.0375103429,
-0.0361626744,
-0.0087053059,
-0.0091068326,
0.0379517078,
0.055849202,
0.0036423849,
-0.0891166106,
-0.0092295175,
0.0128247757,
-0.0092213163,
0.0159673933,
0.0429688618,
0.0259215087,
-0.0170347132,
-0.0013870036,
-0.0540107414,
-0.0185638703,
-0.0008456013,
0.0287801623,
0.0673319399,
-0.0509861708,
0.0361273363,
0.0277385879,
0.0556525365,
0.0094566876,
0.0000021156,
0.0099243959,
-0.0002913662,
-0.0148883881,
0.0110712247,
-0.0080802459,
0.0549208038,
-0.0348312706,
0.0141059328,
-0.0398962311,
-0.0093332278,
-0.0061386805,
0.0644165948,
0.1035892218,
0.0661288127,
0.0553562194,
-0.0292770937,
-0.0688055977,
0.0157299414,
-0.0168897379,
-0.004686614,
-0.0198658016,
0.0046270671,
0.0343268029,
-0.0067436947,
-0.0314368941,
-0.0551895387,
0.0215305313,
0.0035630935,
0.0175927114,
0.025537869,
0.0673477203,
-0.0341680609,
-0.0060570999,
-0.0204027779,
0.1145379245,
-0.0269463956,
-0.0177562796,
-0.027907107,
-0.0208109841,
-0.0062558684,
-0.0384220593,
-0.0450991094,
0.0246675443,
-0.0172875281,
0.0545391329,
-0.0707449242,
0.0397363417,
-0.0069233314,
0.0003005002,
-0.0294838995,
-0.0548779443,
0.0183794629,
0.017619662,
-0.0314697213,
0.0222690925,
-0.0632527247,
-0.0600075722,
0.0753902048,
0.0145151904,
0.0371318571,
-0.0038337817,
-0.0701586008,
-0.0299868155,
-0.0204455461,
-0.0372166932,
-0.0053229649,
-0.0015375399,
-0.0528998859,
0.0589038581,
-0.025714593,
0.069971092,
-0.0142329931,
0.0503334664,
-0.0381577089,
-0.0202253181,
-0.0106224064,
0.0002938566,
-0.0478192754,
0.0142740523,
-0.0424044766,
-0.046800673,
0.007288116,
-0.0122434665,
-0.0158605445,
0.0179664083,
-0.0296652634,
0.0682618245,
-0.051410988,
0.004315767,
-0.0125564178,
0.0299106296,
-0.0658731833,
0.0138645507,
0.0112974355,
-0.0048154197,
0.0080801025,
0.010407432,
0.0567491762,
0.0005826157,
0.0315342024,
0.0224480331,
-0.0423082039,
-0.0547879003,
-0.0291452184,
0.0030697822,
-0.0507281944,
-0.0109686656,
0.0077731698,
-0.0457962751,
0.0353591777,
-0.0458662808,
-0.0080406582,
-0.0049405913,
0.0208070409,
0.0313293189,
-0.0416560806,
0.0633319989,
-0.0062549207,
-0.0205599405,
0.0012570982,
0.027306797,
0.0380947068,
0.0567390844,
0.0752274618,
0.0841654912,
0.0109562874,
0.0297895297,
0.0288438462,
0.0177543685,
-0.0001833711,
0.0120872296,
-0.0379536003,
-0.0009906122,
-0.0166798607,
0.0455726795,
0.0536567234,
0.0202560294,
-0.0231159832,
-0.0503477342,
0.112175934,
0.0673773736,
-0.0431379788,
0.0338922739,
0.0052083177,
0.0163308997,
-0.0389739126,
0.0142244752,
-0.0554836914,
0.0519753471,
0.0547290035,
0.0044728429,
-0.0114906449,
0.0183983408,
-0.0448311195,
-0.0181204807,
0.0195920039,
-0.0065447581,
0.0186118726,
-0.0102656232,
0.0312500373,
0.0217237528,
-0.0654113665,
0.042275928,
-0.0138395298,
-0.0490640774,
-0.0146006336,
0.0178699754,
0.0097891428,
0.0557404906,
0.0465089045,
-0.0229437649,
-0.072079584,
-0.004257062,
0.0796451941,
0.0670060813,
-0.0378175788,
0.0208244491,
0.0228074379,
-0.07941892,
-0.0094580427,
-0.0131155187,
-0.0245894399,
0.030649595,
0.025792988,
0.0222385135,
0.0002102484,
-0.0275887437,
-0.0360511914,
0.0575611964,
0.0604252294,
-0.0006674186,
-0.0582954027,
0.0338976309,
-0.0223762542,
0.012203604,
-0.0211927257,
-0.0294519216,
0.0301509332,
-0.0245400351,
-0.0062734457,
0.0293972827,
-0.0990055054,
-0.0453786552,
-0.003967796,
-0.1072585732,
-0.0301488582,
-0.0216550939,
-0.030135911,
-0.0254289657,
0.0309703425,
-0.0005289247,
0.025782397,
-0.0275946688,
0.0020441439,
0.025117984,
0.0246442575,
-0.0355695784,
0.0756739303,
-0.0275965948,
-0.0133879697,
-0.0437397882,
0.0117273955,
-0.0147244874,
-0.0345298275,
0.0147332093,
-0.0194061771,
-0.0025280463,
-0.0016761514,
0.0080654845,
0.0091212736,
-0.0492710285,
-0.0363020524,
-0.0759550557,
-0.0281026885,
-0.0039405879,
-0.0422480032,
0.0222288277,
-0.0074429205,
-0.0096217617,
-0.0407321565,
-0.0426378809,
-0.0071810023,
-0.0004634069,
-0.0143816825,
0.0398051217,
0.0165944211,
0.0014847671,
-0.0350546166,
0.0176100675,
0.0210759696,
0.0349500962,
0.0362325832,
-0.0522023849,
-0.0301319715,
0.0120191108,
-0.0060990029,
0.0206821542,
-0.0194793288,
0.0071131489,
0.0008486169,
0.0237348974,
0.0226611476,
0.0995483994,
0.0168627761,
-0.0436842442,
-0.0096523175,
-0.0384130552,
-0.0173952784,
0.0133330105,
0.011127295,
-0.0177394152,
0.0166411269,
-0.0100332061,
0.0207906123,
0.0144124739,
-0.0232904218,
0.0474466868,
-0.0473718643,
-0.020642465,
0.0431912802,
0.0004160494,
-0.0072249253,
0.0084379241,
-0.0113368891,
0.0126756318,
-0.0908255875,
-0.0365484469,
0.0433127694,
-0.0466558412,
-0.0398890637,
-0.0186490398,
0.028028423,
0.0015995771,
0.0386251286,
0.0230788197,
0.0438720025,
-0.0000917881,
-0.0255229399,
-0.027601609,
-0.0311613269,
0.001839383,
0.0137400003,
0.1148116365,
-0.0202114191,
0.0160853527,
-0.0222195573,
-0.0186268482,
-0.0266150422,
-0.0151222469,
-0.0276160464,
-0.0198816899,
-0.0758413002,
0.0056406693,
-0.0606255047,
0.0395870954,
-0.0088337129,
0.0617228523,
-0.0061994339,
0.0046714139,
-0.0134156412,
0.0268351249,
0.0205575302,
0.0489746816,
-0.0382806957,
-0.0272785407,
0.0230075289,
0.0541536212,
0.0380709581,
-0.0333585441,
-0.024044456,
0.0340965688,
0.0086840177,
0.0188404266,
0.0476783328,
0.0003238494,
0.0713811442,
-0.0694174916,
-0.0225530583,
0.0571636409,
0.0077966237,
-0.0526719205,
-0.0272627976,
0.0150695294,
0.0361215696,
0.0287576094,
-0.009604373,
-0.0612570941,
-0.0639689714,
-0.0022260572,
-0.0125724785,
0.0533958897,
-0.0222767293,
-0.0315838158,
-0.0326202251,
0.041767776,
0.0165481102,
-0.0388290137,
-0.057160642,
0.0110880276,
0.0342104249,
-0.0030562142,
-0.0044177999,
-0.0210508797,
0.0073142634,
-0.0210325494,
-0.0197190959,
0.0159615353,
0.0245433021,
0.0113734594,
-0.0758739039,
-0.0252818167,
0.0627998486,
0.0268640928,
-0.0035433492,
-0.0036710154,
-0.0383561999,
0.0069865719,
0.0039994847,
0.0230508074,
0.0708328113,
-0.0526006408,
-0.0230356529,
0.0155027406,
0.0226583648,
-0.0358325727,
-0.0368294716,
0.0008258539,
0.020792773,
0.0161462575,
0.0160646196,
-0.0272530708,
0.0363513455,
0.0051549361,
0.0451348498,
0.0424809232,
0.0049959649,
-0.0438216738,
-0.0058740363,
0.0366629697,
-0.0668037012,
-0.0013254621,
0.0081654582,
-0.0288731176,
-0.0065787472,
-0.0689841658,
-0.0296039414,
0.0459767208,
0.049244877,
0.0204170775,
-0.036974825,
0.0173127707,
-0.0009778745,
-0.070674859,
0.0402487889,
-0.0602777675,
0.0169047695,
-0.0595706552,
0.0214497019,
0.015143767,
-0.028232256,
-0.0051885801,
0.0305965785,
-0.0819692835,
-0.0082464321,
-0.0029735721,
0.0125240115,
-0.0012532172,
0.0660957992,
-0.0065675694,
-0.0126691852,
0.0418450683,
0.0100211184,
0.0063259415,
0.0430558734,
-0.0178582612,
-0.0016560833,
-0.0120291766,
0.0080882711,
-0.0435837619,
0.0510283932,
0.0154467337,
0.0200892128,
-0.0129794236,
-0.0066173463,
-0.0035094777,
-0.0335950367,
0.0430978201,
-0.0115306731,
0.0259511843,
-0.0618272871,
-0.0027885323,
0.0321954377,
-0.0021727523,
-0.0435839109,
0.032555908,
-0.0375881903,
0.012768534,
0.0071257446,
0.011477109,
0.0003782386,
0.0037964331,
-0.0441971868,
-0.0419712029,
-0.0071423547,
-0.0136920819,
-0.0362252407,
0.0282342117,
-0.0089539709,
0.0042412733,
-0.0453981124,
0.0935638845,
-0.0176754929,
0.0477804579,
0.0313792489,
-0.0448733307,
-0.0611038879,
0.0583406053,
-0.0200338513,
0.0041966932,
-0.0658719689,
0.0557556562,
0.0525219738,
-0.0508341528,
-0.0342263021,
0.0036607273,
-0.0027954951,
0.0013236109,
-0.0278575867,
-0.0059682182,
-0.0429522134,
0.008299591,
0.0235711988,
0.003940539,
0.0220432766,
0.0132519975,
-0.0118286265,
0.0497721918,
0.0108347852,
-0.0318244696,
-0.0533923134,
-0.0175517313,
-0.0154729392,
0.0061900457,
0.0012328055,
0.0267453529,
-0.0160670914,
-0.038892962,
0.0273161158,
-0.0044230837,
0.0069073103,
0.0255316105,
0.0453918688,
0.0099111758,
0.0084909918,
0.0166711714,
0.028217271,
-0.0128645878,
0.0014044895,
-0.0252358839,
-0.0121179214,
-5.95787667e-33,
-0.0535462126,
-0.0275323857,
0.0066259042,
-0.0052971104,
-0.0470394753,
0.0281431507,
-0.0225647837,
0.0028011519,
-0.0097599197,
0.0231523328,
0.0102555696,
0.006955584,
0.0236075949,
0.0433839709,
-0.0662522912,
-0.0302472059,
0.0516659841,
0.0031006725,
-0.0360256694,
0.026203664,
0.0266102515,
0.0195454266,
0.0714414492,
-0.049663458,
-0.0386141762,
-0.0107515221,
-0.0074300114,
0.0120399324,
0.0694531873,
0.0242646728,
-0.0058190217,
-0.0026097989,
0.0196708851,
-0.0016553201,
-0.0350642391,
0.01993322,
-0.0940004513,
0.0041556405,
-0.0005049248,
0.0254746675,
-0.0110407621,
-0.0124552716,
0.0669011027,
-0.0284213796,
0.0300176162,
-0.0198466294,
0.0586875342,
-0.0255762972,
-0.0073188352,
0.0460325181,
-0.0470100753,
0.001088687,
-0.0119419321,
-0.0466453023,
0.012645782,
-0.0133719891,
0.0651532859,
0.0465330109,
-0.0560851619,
0.0168060921,
0.0193175338,
0.0407298096,
0.0555546992,
0.0815108195,
-0.0057987696,
0.1010972187,
0.0149959549,
-0.0304728653,
-0.045393452,
0.0167438667,
0.0237970315,
0.0392759033,
0.0531302877,
0.0400254764,
0.0353802107,
0.0226713661,
-0.0665655136,
0.0111943167,
-0.0711913705,
0.0455043428,
0.0181515943,
0.0264963154,
-0.0274753273,
-0.00322016,
-0.0187987126,
-0.0022766392,
-0.0392938666,
0.027099207,
0.0380935632,
0.0516637117,
-0.0139295021,
0.0558739267,
0.0429161862,
0.0047223358,
0.0668204874,
0.0034844226,
-0.0024971545,
0.0346045494,
0.0117081748,
-0.0024166324,
-0.0391253829,
0.0091033904,
0.0536911525,
0.0144980671,
0.0069584055,
0.018513184,
0.0575049669,
-0.0050478624,
-0.0128961848,
0.0027681496,
-0.0168672036,
-0.0082223006,
-0.0476718843,
0.0312816054,
0.0200648457,
0.0087033492,
-0.0324532837,
0.0496091284,
0.004729121,
0.0047700214,
-0.0264981147,
-0.039766863,
-0.0148798274,
0.0408322215,
-0.0302710999,
0.014605171,
-0.0109314527,
-0.0262988601,
0.018091226,
-0.0765703321,
-0.0090964809,
0.0514049195,
2.692e-7,
-0.0211579092,
0.0204888042,
0.0717660189,
-0.0585407801,
-0.006558442,
0.0498924181,
-0.0110834837,
0.0313353725,
-0.0143269589,
-0.1015341207,
0.034898404,
0.0624415539,
0.0262393896,
-0.0042383401,
-0.0555854626,
0.0412295274,
-0.0307455007,
-0.0228709932,
-0.0531175509,
-0.0553678796,
0.0285330005,
0.0551468916,
-0.0087763304,
-0.0037722168,
0.0540379956,
-0.0605117567,
0.0488744304,
-0.0122216959,
0.0304677468,
-0.0002648682,
-0.0210770182,
0.0236137826,
-0.0584514961,
-0.0008248819,
0.015154033,
0.0161911529,
0.0661325231,
0.0338802338,
-0.0467895418,
-0.0236235019,
-0.0517506897,
-0.0014838496,
-0.0060552256,
-0.0355441384,
0.0531101823,
-0.0451996885,
-0.0206460543,
-0.0300060883,
0.0046894243,
0.0246684123,
0.0139088696,
0.000089105,
-0.062010847,
0.0137956357,
0.0417407379,
-0.0053162798,
-0.051110737,
-0.1125680208,
-0.0098630441,
-0.0172167849,
-0.0195173919,
0.013659481,
-0.089091517,
-0.0051554693,
0.001350328,
0.0002889622,
-0.0183583945,
2.272239534e-34,
-0.0070425672,
-0.0069852406,
-0.0296218637,
0.0002368746,
0.0171060394,
0.0050272723,
-0.0158645678,
-0.0353715792,
-0.0078324787,
-0.0380834341,
-0.0176284779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16609v1 | Back Transcription as a Method for Evaluating Robustness of Natural Language Understanding Models to Speech Recognition Errors | 2023-10-25T13:07:07 | 2023-10-25T13:07:07 | Marek Kubis, Paweł Skórzewski, Marcin Sowański, Tomasz Ziętkiewicz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | In a spoken dialogue system, an NLU model is preceded by a speech recognition
system that can deteriorate the performance of natural language understanding.
This paper proposes a method for investigating the impact of speech recognition
errors on the performance of natural language understanding models. The
proposed method combines the back transcription procedure with a fine-grained
technique for categorizing the errors that affect the performance of NLU
models. The method relies on the usage of synthesized speech for NLU
evaluation. We show that the use of synthesized speech in place of audio
recording does not change the outcomes of the presented technique in a
significant way. | [
0.0464980975,
-0.0071435845,
-0.0106900819,
0.0276084431,
0.0256028697,
0.0163929705,
0.0344583578,
-0.020015914,
0.0316470675,
-0.0761112943,
-0.0092760511,
-0.0497465245,
0.0461407825,
0.0075795334,
0.0065840343,
-0.0508279018,
0.079687953,
-0.0825843513,
-0.0127368486,
0.0194584262,
-0.0201820601,
0.0039755185,
-0.0221602786,
0.027338054,
0.0196659472,
0.0021584672,
-0.0155574102,
0.0267542955,
-0.0252903886,
-0.0323192179,
-0.058739759,
0.0263628643,
0.0407949872,
0.0092845205,
0.0000017114,
-0.0651122704,
-0.0124751125,
-0.0080946125,
-0.0861264244,
0.0012528604,
0.0099628856,
0.0513412058,
-0.0242643766,
0.0489613265,
0.01173303,
-0.0215787292,
0.0033691609,
0.0598893724,
0.0215316769,
0.0164999291,
0.0141997114,
-0.0247943848,
0.0013904842,
0.0105414614,
-0.0481672697,
-0.0461094007,
0.0085011134,
0.0446104035,
0.0345581248,
-0.0542417467,
-0.0200270712,
0.0273177009,
-0.0428440124,
-0.0353756435,
-0.0287790578,
-0.0066538388,
-0.0224869624,
-0.0576100871,
-0.0447673313,
0.0518296435,
0.0299087651,
0.023479389,
-0.0284603816,
0.0017260666,
0.0183619279,
-0.0151929026,
-0.018299235,
-0.0049028127,
-0.0476297364,
-0.0372082368,
-0.0129791787,
0.0091926791,
0.0406445414,
-0.0236201286,
0.0194706153,
0.0224526972,
0.003134703,
-0.0403967574,
-0.0216579102,
-0.0245566573,
0.0048085526,
-0.016793713,
0.0417460538,
0.0141619369,
-0.044454515,
0.0510960743,
-0.008950321,
-0.0012044028,
-0.0168213546,
-0.0582334511,
0.0198328849,
0.0357616208,
-0.0471361578,
0.0229826495,
0.0062242071,
0.1207383648,
0.021240484,
-0.0232428554,
-0.0025884074,
0.0153444586,
-0.0469577163,
-0.0213822611,
-0.045801606,
0.0522101223,
-0.0414960273,
0.0001817112,
-0.0303648096,
0.0239500906,
-0.001660998,
0.0264775604,
0.0306446888,
0.0116346516,
-0.0394228883,
0.0141016413,
-0.0261610374,
-0.0026416483,
0.0224299021,
0.0506101176,
-0.0266339108,
-0.0904347599,
0.0169935897,
-0.0006947867,
0.0193665624,
0.0032105658,
-0.0334555618,
0.0634119883,
0.0344987474,
-0.0225710385,
-0.0517552383,
0.0019176169,
-0.0386270657,
-0.0424734466,
-0.0322371423,
-0.0079732928,
-0.0032187458,
-0.0050336686,
0.006931596,
-0.001691623,
0.0265047625,
-0.0193768013,
-0.0337563679,
0.0744890794,
-0.0237549208,
0.0152406441,
0.0417948924,
0.0134823648,
0.0161003545,
0.0311595201,
0.0263536647,
-0.0553009361,
0.0266079586,
-0.0367884189,
0.0122870812,
0.0094697876,
-0.0384188145,
-0.0215764269,
-0.0368074551,
0.0189930759,
-0.0363161452,
0.0232426431,
0.0083240736,
0.0593899004,
-0.0375026427,
0.0424393378,
0.0415663719,
0.0550034083,
0.0266116317,
0.0130051235,
0.0296260081,
0.0162732173,
-0.0016469934,
0.0370453447,
-0.0198872592,
-0.0494617075,
-0.0489982925,
0.0257851034,
0.0259182621,
0.0132749211,
-0.0137497392,
-0.061226517,
-0.0441469997,
0.0018657198,
-0.0011493976,
0.0145785511,
0.0455204211,
0.0108504714,
-0.057600487,
0.025414424,
-0.0406575464,
-0.0582887009,
0.0377349742,
-0.0428789519,
-0.0101436423,
0.1059864163,
0.0407197811,
0.0027385869,
-0.0128307799,
-0.0514136367,
-0.0677759126,
0.0199563671,
0.0281676743,
-0.0105550326,
0.0259105824,
-0.0333404727,
0.0053552077,
0.0179148838,
-0.0017689092,
0.0341982879,
-0.0884490535,
-0.0131839029,
0.0152918007,
-0.001486844,
-0.0327643417,
-0.000609825,
0.0094592059,
-0.03393545,
-0.0403196104,
-0.0059692282,
0.0700337961,
0.0666778684,
-0.0377502255,
-0.0125542963,
0.0060986425,
0.0178472251,
0.0186991692,
0.0735330954,
-0.0152881378,
-0.0482310988,
0.0395056233,
0.0009268502,
-0.0598726608,
0.0234019849,
0.0039700149,
-0.0924603716,
0.0527495705,
-0.0496621206,
-0.0046061855,
-0.060131032,
0.0578509383,
0.0225792192,
-0.0206733532,
-0.0279396661,
0.0083001629,
-0.0019593958,
0.0144939413,
0.034309566,
-0.0016931264,
0.0431073122,
-0.0864982605,
-0.02439899,
0.065350309,
-0.0425434895,
0.0100706043,
-0.0069962973,
-0.0500086434,
-0.0385218114,
0.013357508,
-0.0755019411,
-0.0205845442,
-0.0272527765,
0.0249862559,
0.018119961,
0.0212754402,
-0.0382413864,
-0.0444699377,
0.0393603854,
-0.0381029285,
0.0232939459,
-0.0385332927,
-0.0034144248,
0.0264373161,
-0.041055765,
-0.0471862331,
0.0296033379,
-0.0312831737,
0.018195346,
-0.0030273246,
-0.057958506,
-0.0887739658,
0.0224131625,
0.0101625854,
0.0566284657,
0.004364158,
-0.0446735397,
0.0174163599,
0.0412793942,
-0.0018672631,
0.0404284112,
0.0162826125,
0.0359859765,
0.0333654955,
-0.0505353175,
-0.0162805822,
0.0475633517,
0.0248890538,
-0.0069610248,
-0.0200942066,
0.003920706,
-0.0353039987,
0.0282221027,
0.0717528015,
0.041609928,
-0.0270401239,
-0.0182852279,
-0.0281030741,
-0.0272678323,
-0.0327236243,
-0.0741576403,
-0.0372840725,
0.0584944971,
0.0003197204,
-0.0035217062,
0.0285168029,
-0.103867121,
-0.0086097931,
-0.038742315,
-0.0230099,
0.0009699649,
0.0015388965,
-0.0485113934,
-0.0014745329,
0.0179935955,
-0.0842839032,
-0.0088367509,
-0.029794544,
0.0156211182,
-0.0383439288,
0.04206229,
-0.082124345,
0.0084679518,
-0.0027000993,
-0.0207107812,
-0.0643718764,
-0.0076386724,
-0.0274002254,
-0.0005470802,
0.0120003456,
0.0231932066,
-0.0086791776,
0.07474529,
-0.0125191845,
0.0355642959,
-0.002342717,
0.0021407735,
-0.024885565,
0.0075708409,
-0.0029868297,
0.0323678777,
0.0077748965,
0.00673453,
0.0645106658,
-0.0175654162,
0.0496027134,
0.0165718216,
-0.051026728,
0.0374965072,
0.0316407941,
-0.0248565506,
-0.0669479296,
0.0344831683,
0.054864902,
-0.0432001986,
-0.0345758721,
0.1124977916,
0.0147997504,
0.0244671628,
-0.0207555238,
-0.018670015,
-0.027269518,
0.0245241076,
0.0006331867,
0.0153788375,
-0.0256181899,
0.032741379,
0.0574229211,
0.0097885635,
0.0315368958,
-0.000723707,
-0.0894359797,
0.066414848,
0.0126561578,
-0.0622129403,
-0.0446405634,
-0.0231449977,
0.0109001929,
0.0016549978,
0.0772095323,
0.0012482806,
-0.0051542134,
-0.02377294,
0.0549659431,
-0.0823424459,
-0.0727356672,
0.0037466616,
0.009187608,
0.095056586,
0.0646189004,
0.0317935981,
0.0151558425,
0.0021201211,
0.0421227477,
-0.0109766778,
0.0616783053,
0.0058459095,
0.0267655794,
0.0095754359,
0.0164223481,
0.0136379367,
-0.0173895229,
-0.0109679159,
0.006643598,
-0.0247060526,
0.0343775749,
-0.072561197,
0.0227361154,
0.0076248394,
0.0272324346,
0.0269529428,
0.0398919545,
0.0384148136,
-0.0010456466,
-0.0454821885,
-0.0119447028,
0.0079983938,
-0.0345517918,
-0.0125070633,
0.0343051516,
-0.005011112,
-0.0333921947,
-0.0098834168,
-0.0786600038,
-0.0139371213,
0.0279914252,
0.0148023702,
0.0332337357,
0.0149389273,
0.0591179691,
0.0137769422,
0.0107790828,
0.0314034782,
0.0096161803,
-0.0508640185,
0.0153680257,
0.0202044044,
-0.0158210155,
-0.0334497094,
0.0362634771,
-0.0095381821,
-0.0559485443,
0.0639472306,
0.0133153405,
0.0383124277,
0.0637343377,
-0.0262034107,
-0.0236457437,
-0.0308944527,
-0.0218491107,
0.0095964242,
-0.0017496079,
0.0252302177,
0.0128817363,
-0.0247429851,
0.0255290139,
-0.0361853279,
0.0014808796,
-0.0562379733,
0.0200597122,
-0.0236455817,
-0.1000147983,
-0.0167021435,
0.0552707128,
0.05175649,
0.0071998164,
-0.0039494205,
-0.0522774085,
0.0512283407,
0.0042271912,
0.0029993888,
-0.0038145445,
0.0066540213,
-0.0102425935,
-0.0303388666,
-0.0005967169,
-0.0249550212,
-0.0985747874,
0.0059760688,
0.0053114663,
0.0409488939,
0.068178907,
0.0231286362,
-0.0215503592,
-0.0203549378,
-0.0267457403,
0.0521486737,
0.0256295521,
0.0304052513,
0.0373007655,
0.0775237307,
-0.0455414653,
0.0122747887,
0.0190919824,
0.0121122925,
-0.041701179,
-0.0593803748,
-0.0235771667,
0.0265642162,
0.0091757188,
-0.0260974057,
0.034903992,
0.0160191357,
0.0496297106,
-0.0311648734,
0.0167686362,
0.0139274541,
0.006514621,
0.0628463626,
0.0174701791,
-0.0109968288,
0.0014585182,
0.0344920047,
0.0345259011,
0.0346914567,
-0.0455319211,
0.0082355225,
-0.0502219833,
-0.0423634276,
-0.0198094863,
0.0109409653,
-0.0290537719,
0.016570542,
-0.0344285816,
-0.0589032546,
0.0275214277,
0.0193163212,
0.0510871522,
-0.0213916488,
0.0082268678,
0.022332564,
-0.0030388457,
0.0143587878,
-0.0118445195,
-0.0372855924,
-0.0088593718,
0.0364937223,
-0.0184616409,
-5.845050885e-33,
-0.0783150718,
-0.0283316132,
0.007796648,
-0.0240534339,
-0.0060152863,
-0.0361002013,
-0.0396392643,
0.0252772365,
0.0022615525,
-0.0273747649,
-0.0160881486,
0.0421683639,
0.0315545499,
-0.0217976756,
-0.0134747894,
-0.0242689047,
0.0742015764,
0.0188235939,
-0.0246648546,
-0.0346270837,
0.063998349,
0.0521804765,
0.0487332493,
-0.0766225606,
0.0487168469,
0.0137188816,
0.0069103478,
0.0050924574,
0.0198549181,
0.045748692,
0.0026277392,
0.0287752803,
0.0047081192,
-0.0513678789,
-0.0299881622,
0.0015651232,
-0.0553966388,
-0.0395392142,
0.071802631,
0.0701878071,
0.0293082334,
0.0254689809,
0.0213719998,
0.0000514847,
-0.048030898,
-0.0018962575,
0.0077912738,
-0.0258824583,
-0.018702941,
-0.0000222818,
-0.0112124123,
0.035168469,
-0.0492701977,
-0.0035774168,
0.0414500982,
0.0515151583,
-0.022555925,
-0.0220239889,
-0.0377149694,
0.0059345998,
0.0209593028,
-0.0204453375,
0.1016077474,
0.0059429021,
-0.0430634059,
0.034449406,
0.0008326165,
-0.0137342978,
-0.0298624504,
-0.0827430412,
-0.014226011,
0.013139002,
0.0287825335,
0.04320902,
0.0196358282,
-0.024479948,
-0.0191260092,
-0.0019945828,
-0.0206124168,
0.0360403694,
0.022857327,
0.055509124,
-0.0722299218,
-0.0074437479,
-0.0869560391,
-0.0021126219,
-0.022883689,
-0.0076883705,
0.0564906932,
-0.0351102687,
-0.0074894307,
-0.0334139615,
0.0431681573,
-0.0067783101,
0.0246477872,
-0.0262205787,
0.034993358,
-0.0149855008,
-0.0123811308,
0.0309348945,
-0.010735089,
-0.0470481925,
0.0636358708,
0.053815864,
0.0558806211,
-0.025629323,
-0.0390856192,
0.0264466591,
-0.0431711674,
-0.0044796825,
0.0003756646,
0.0141751207,
-0.0313120633,
0.0226040948,
0.0753140152,
-0.0049933745,
-0.0257129259,
0.0389280692,
-0.0122779207,
5.016e-7,
-0.0113450205,
0.0163171198,
-0.0178766306,
0.0096804649,
-0.0567814372,
-0.0130114378,
0.0474300124,
0.0119085722,
0.0121622346,
-0.0168954842,
0.0094204657,
0.0342376083,
2.676e-7,
0.0076264194,
0.0326038375,
0.0351157784,
-0.0023927516,
0.0213861763,
0.0207499005,
-0.0221790336,
-0.0095933657,
0.0420579128,
0.0083214398,
0.0508728027,
-0.0330904387,
0.0586859807,
0.0249992963,
-0.0646399707,
-0.0568531416,
-0.0413212068,
0.0307519939,
-0.0079559144,
0.0208173767,
0.0483627766,
0.0586129613,
-0.0479550287,
0.0057740468,
-0.013948434,
-0.0445487052,
-0.0116599193,
-0.0063310293,
0.0056281686,
-0.0206082053,
0.0608594902,
0.0471758321,
0.0049041077,
0.0680709928,
0.0025343946,
0.0220293719,
0.022702558,
0.003777704,
-0.0509644002,
-0.0450507663,
-0.0195662528,
0.0294578597,
-0.0028651222,
-0.0138155017,
0.0126429312,
-0.0078497445,
-0.008280905,
-0.0272501856,
-0.0138011798,
-0.0179576669,
0.0042452053,
0.0270898081,
0.0606224798,
0.0170843266,
-0.0149854934,
-0.0231972765,
-0.0052421656,
-0.0581351072,
0.0255103521,
0.015500837,
-0.0385952108,
-0.0419960134,
-0.0060543665,
-0.0106600299,
0.0428917818,
-0.0526256151,
-0.0234156102,
1.85564755e-34,
0.0410256162,
0.0227445327,
0.0138281127,
0.0307231881,
0.0683873072,
-0.0158459004,
0.0136345085,
-0.0029391288,
0.0272122342,
-0.0575287566,
-0.0296332147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16607v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16607v2 | On the Interplay between Fairness and Explainability | 2023-10-25T12:59:51 | 2023-11-13T15:20:43 | Stephanie Brandl, Emanuele Bugliarello, Ilias Chalkidis | cs.CL | cs.CL | In order to build reliable and trustworthy NLP applications, models need to
be both fair across different demographics and explainable. Usually these two
objectives, fairness and explainability, are optimized and/or examined
independently of each other. Instead, we argue that forthcoming, trustworthy
NLP systems should consider both. In this work, we perform a first study to
understand how they influence each other: do fair(er) models rely on more
plausible rationales? and vice versa. To this end, we conduct experiments on
two English multi-class text classification datasets, BIOS and ECtHR, that
provide information on gender and nationality, respectively, as well as
human-annotated rationales. We fine-tune pre-trained language models with
several methods for (i) bias mitigation, which aims to improve fairness; (ii)
rationale extraction, which aims to produce plausible explanations. We find
that bias mitigation algorithms do not always lead to fairer models. Moreover,
we discover that empirical fairness and explainability are orthogonal. | [
0.0543682277,
0.1148775518,
-0.0196457747,
0.0275384188,
0.0000103951,
0.0232668016,
0.0517322831,
-0.0065677031,
-0.031694822,
-0.0692145079,
0.0307204928,
-0.0174461659,
0.0196366031,
-0.0069437218,
-0.0129469875,
-0.0551581681,
-0.006179207,
0.0235633235,
0.0422590151,
-0.0367571861,
0.0313772969,
0.0310044456,
0.0224343073,
0.0690353513,
0.0223110933,
0.0228797272,
0.0375815444,
-0.0137399565,
-0.0171828158,
0.0456550196,
0.018813692,
0.0726548284,
-0.0200660508,
0.0199818145,
0.0000017609,
-0.0537587777,
-0.0024414903,
0.0409826525,
-0.0543068834,
0.0148217697,
0.0404327661,
-0.0133731896,
0.0075423922,
0.0202753842,
0.0007949464,
0.0438606627,
0.0246833414,
0.0403616056,
0.0455069095,
0.020894533,
0.0064953309,
-0.0318052731,
-0.0524681844,
-0.0135425525,
-0.001632929,
-0.0079702418,
0.0087336311,
-0.0309411641,
-0.0667960346,
-0.0047104768,
-0.0169417169,
-0.0199603494,
0.020195175,
-0.0268485006,
0.0207740013,
-0.0114576127,
-0.0110231778,
-0.0438971967,
0.027403051,
0.048525285,
-0.0017190916,
-0.0362209156,
0.0187276043,
-0.0143241985,
-0.0017258484,
0.0251216777,
-0.0378317237,
0.0513725765,
-0.0070206025,
0.0280039925,
0.0484440625,
0.0103802327,
0.0544380769,
0.0672700107,
-0.0043873168,
0.0767744705,
-0.0232420377,
-0.0194615275,
-0.0216956232,
0.0292872004,
0.0000644244,
-0.0388675332,
0.0116524417,
0.0025980859,
0.0094008502,
0.0168087687,
0.0038073463,
0.014361144,
0.0376369134,
-0.0174543671,
-0.024674587,
0.0064729932,
0.0092175677,
0.0144681921,
0.0156264585,
0.0025803407,
0.0244181454,
0.0425274931,
0.0022869844,
-0.0364077874,
-0.0547606237,
-0.0073657739,
0.0190050509,
0.0085742529,
-0.0684121549,
0.0646663383,
-0.0499025621,
-0.039546106,
-0.0505646244,
-0.0088816313,
0.0529120453,
0.0236329436,
-0.0238939505,
-0.0018491057,
-0.0595588908,
-0.0231809746,
-0.0376281552,
0.0229437668,
-0.0186806023,
-0.0509610549,
0.0010121068,
-0.0010759793,
-0.0196339171,
-0.0290620793,
-0.0140440464,
0.0356145389,
0.0415074676,
-0.0340257436,
-0.0532510877,
-0.0404977724,
0.0037632065,
-0.0344594568,
-0.0322951898,
-0.010368281,
-0.0033945697,
0.009172406,
0.0104092127,
-0.05147212,
-0.013065367,
0.0186801478,
-0.0709450245,
0.0866942331,
0.0216454566,
0.0051107467,
0.0189636033,
0.0116951233,
-0.0078920098,
0.0697252825,
0.0256674774,
-0.0479051918,
0.0827183276,
-0.0318335742,
0.0133184325,
-0.0173879452,
0.0370188095,
0.007482701,
0.0184834953,
0.0189017765,
-0.0474427976,
0.0153077515,
0.0536217466,
0.0010185656,
0.0092376545,
-0.0242134929,
0.0248159096,
0.0718674809,
0.0305013414,
0.0130683417,
0.0282734483,
-0.0006881769,
-0.0675671175,
0.04238455,
-0.098023057,
-0.0214388203,
-0.0181277506,
-0.046952378,
0.0092077237,
0.017336186,
-0.0245490689,
-0.0687466562,
-0.0086088488,
-0.0104820132,
0.0477057062,
0.0316060819,
0.0293764919,
0.0001438852,
0.0206471365,
0.0562249906,
0.061635226,
-0.0526324362,
0.0210668165,
-0.0739748254,
0.0363947712,
0.0371942669,
0.003598463,
-0.0163985938,
0.0444036722,
-0.0326915458,
-0.0032965173,
0.0214437395,
0.0443347283,
-0.0101121711,
0.0587409474,
-0.04815723,
-0.0403039902,
-0.0053103203,
0.0537090898,
-0.0083265714,
0.0409465954,
0.0003795332,
0.0104614208,
-0.0780981928,
-0.0762140155,
0.0579509884,
0.0103333564,
-0.0480133854,
0.0245885588,
0.0035190773,
0.0257769395,
0.0300375726,
0.0023047933,
0.0012903232,
-0.0246993899,
-0.0044026156,
-0.0034676285,
0.0232799388,
-0.0296324622,
-0.0159450807,
-0.0053347438,
-0.0143363634,
-0.0225754231,
0.027456956,
-0.0218568761,
-0.0121429805,
0.0241639148,
-0.000839672,
-0.0086253183,
-0.0213076565,
0.0253387243,
-0.0273119826,
0.0202795751,
-0.0638599768,
0.0358243994,
0.0003643762,
0.0099493144,
-0.016109826,
-0.0506479293,
0.0126630012,
-0.0426923074,
-0.0085491352,
0.0517899692,
0.0088133821,
-0.0056822901,
0.0408992544,
-0.0256178081,
-0.0107154083,
0.0281174406,
-0.0341447368,
0.01437956,
-0.0354978815,
-0.0132052889,
0.0056776153,
0.0134332096,
0.0059280754,
-0.0112828063,
-0.009574431,
-0.0448356308,
0.018492654,
0.0343732424,
0.041624181,
-0.0315943584,
0.0059836018,
-0.0281290989,
-0.0553026982,
-0.023674354,
0.0986297131,
0.0259004086,
0.0437250696,
-0.0416448377,
-0.0251751672,
-0.0037063123,
0.0004193288,
-0.0151532246,
-0.0087020285,
-0.0227600671,
0.0530593991,
-0.0512858517,
0.0405902974,
0.0333268754,
0.061218977,
0.0255895052,
0.0387214608,
-0.0463566557,
-0.034299165,
-0.0161343534,
0.0286852121,
-0.0052780984,
-0.0685959235,
0.0244116355,
0.0691731721,
0.0065224129,
-0.0489429198,
-0.073134087,
0.0453502573,
-0.0508648679,
-0.0354497842,
-0.0389905907,
-0.0548553988,
0.0070865443,
0.0556455739,
-0.0392787643,
-0.0663559735,
0.0567766875,
-0.027346639,
0.0310897361,
-0.043897815,
-0.0425497554,
-0.0501768775,
0.0336747542,
-0.0236249305,
0.0056648869,
0.0481850058,
-0.0228306092,
-0.0080574602,
-0.0606223904,
0.0721917152,
-0.0074388552,
0.0435096845,
-0.058122389,
-0.0057419837,
-0.0108219702,
-0.0495100953,
-0.0316325985,
-0.0956497267,
-0.0126951365,
0.023710575,
0.0363646224,
-0.0239763204,
-0.0012142044,
0.0227943528,
0.0193102136,
0.0230493415,
-0.0222833194,
0.0045302636,
0.0314590968,
0.0018577559,
0.0117663359,
0.0303923748,
0.0352786928,
-0.0176494922,
0.0124403816,
0.0067493832,
0.0156226102,
0.0058596591,
0.0256977156,
0.0269205142,
0.0082238689,
-0.0798726752,
-0.040978469,
-0.0170222837,
0.0782680139,
-0.0520932414,
0.0277916677,
0.1071179211,
0.0144162299,
-0.0385140032,
0.014814348,
-0.0016848755,
-0.008023439,
0.018338684,
-0.0184871331,
-0.0284833983,
-0.0233789701,
0.0249743387,
0.045988705,
-0.0524138846,
-0.0303229447,
-0.0051138802,
-0.0875667185,
0.0204789396,
-0.0194508228,
-0.0272803381,
-0.0328961238,
-0.0734692886,
-0.0144409807,
-0.0466110669,
0.0398648754,
-0.0259726811,
0.0344783105,
0.0462600589,
0.0540886037,
-0.0574566498,
-0.0370674133,
0.0208594184,
-0.0534708984,
0.0268320069,
0.0204468723,
0.0436461829,
-0.0123873865,
-0.0387036428,
0.0057031414,
-0.0540340506,
0.0063084033,
-0.0307159629,
0.0779274553,
-0.005685953,
-0.0037968757,
-0.0653664246,
0.0645310581,
-0.0020676118,
-0.0040185489,
-0.014373607,
0.0182544142,
0.0202413257,
-0.0319330692,
-0.0441617407,
-0.0317033865,
-0.0095375068,
0.1039585322,
0.0189185329,
-0.0377160907,
-0.0344679169,
-0.075199075,
-0.0061179195,
-0.0620426796,
-0.063886933,
0.0290054344,
0.0165946838,
-0.0524028987,
0.0007321622,
-0.0715672597,
-0.023180224,
0.0278361365,
0.0001650325,
-0.0181101952,
0.0033729349,
-0.0196047258,
-0.032409627,
0.0485660546,
-0.0139367962,
0.0066863047,
0.00427779,
-0.0319790803,
-0.0304815918,
-0.0575201921,
-0.0174961183,
-0.0423336141,
0.0330721997,
-0.0222350545,
0.0331549495,
-0.0137804532,
0.0247076955,
0.0648418665,
-0.0122977002,
-0.079650484,
0.0171824079,
0.0289282184,
-0.018432932,
-0.0215979144,
0.0325860828,
-0.0042183669,
0.0203328412,
0.0283992235,
-0.0278698616,
0.0161142498,
0.0235171784,
0.0114190336,
-0.0291047841,
-0.0039110435,
0.0135002676,
0.0211712532,
0.042687241,
-0.021728348,
-0.0387432314,
-0.0551871732,
-0.0263144765,
0.0148094725,
-0.0384178422,
0.0001268351,
-0.0025009189,
0.0266036596,
0.0118469233,
-0.0513920486,
-0.024885837,
-0.0573474988,
-0.0030053763,
-0.0267243981,
0.0565633141,
-0.0102348551,
0.0443658456,
-0.0377757624,
0.0161621477,
-0.0011915155,
0.0146400537,
-0.0175976157,
0.05358411,
0.0239863005,
0.0370458588,
0.0175588168,
0.010208508,
0.0037036163,
-0.0272495318,
-0.0726085082,
0.024058545,
0.0153379384,
-0.0194664747,
0.0225637164,
-0.0691888407,
0.0395942777,
0.0432815254,
-0.0121961236,
0.0277205184,
0.0516069941,
0.0838766173,
0.001484533,
0.0250026938,
-0.0040188907,
-0.0304774456,
0.0044333511,
0.0580736548,
0.0304562282,
0.0244821087,
-0.0085373018,
-0.0652367175,
-0.0002287036,
-0.0259422101,
0.0150277289,
0.0272967163,
-0.0102590993,
-0.0242550205,
-0.0722982138,
-0.0380580947,
-0.0218587071,
-0.014607789,
0.0364315435,
-0.0179601852,
-0.0062927227,
0.0862284675,
-0.0237583499,
-0.0447441153,
-0.0532396361,
0.0102234213,
-0.0428774841,
0.0240966789,
-0.0106361397,
-5.641940522e-33,
0.0147511754,
-0.053265702,
-0.0626833215,
-0.0245657582,
0.0234945212,
0.0178103298,
-0.0036309538,
-0.0308615528,
-0.0395719595,
0.0431442149,
0.0022914479,
0.0360001251,
0.0208483599,
0.0133347847,
0.0151001634,
-0.0380029008,
0.0391972698,
0.0414730646,
-0.0235284623,
0.0067533171,
-0.0029256481,
0.0179651715,
0.0383339785,
-0.0491697416,
0.1146246418,
0.0289175455,
0.0172575507,
0.0361158848,
-0.0376555659,
0.0504142009,
-0.0077583478,
0.0947405025,
0.0420692563,
-0.0501201339,
0.0278461929,
0.0152673125,
-0.0764211342,
0.0054757381,
0.0424098372,
0.0322371759,
0.0098972367,
-0.031685017,
0.0439095907,
0.0334567688,
-0.0455815978,
-0.0334543213,
0.0632638112,
0.0185722429,
0.017371349,
0.0202957056,
-0.0019950301,
0.0550635159,
-0.0474243239,
0.0102631887,
0.0136084799,
-0.0183258969,
0.0057014781,
0.0522104912,
-0.0158433281,
-0.0187974591,
-0.0022344482,
-0.0041737831,
0.0361374617,
-0.0325313397,
-0.0138193155,
0.0635561645,
0.0448117405,
0.0349989533,
-0.0808125958,
-0.0326715484,
0.0072288467,
-0.0096961632,
0.052948419,
0.081811443,
0.0543903038,
-0.003311022,
-0.0712752193,
0.0043738307,
0.0022951374,
-0.0128314821,
0.0299580637,
-0.0129268374,
-0.0813144743,
-0.0546833612,
-0.0383496545,
-0.0590610541,
-0.0217579342,
0.0182424467,
0.0090795159,
-0.003610054,
-0.0449791886,
0.0115608107,
-0.0141974017,
-0.0472724624,
-0.0076623783,
0.033175908,
0.02133164,
-0.0614984371,
0.0082446039,
-0.0289877281,
-0.0139218485,
0.0001408801,
-0.0059817741,
0.0205589812,
0.0324151069,
0.009834474,
0.0196096897,
0.002727465,
-0.0313499048,
-0.0077357139,
-0.0494165383,
0.0181743801,
-0.0333331227,
0.0350857712,
0.0148084341,
0.0397324823,
-0.0289119054,
0.0153678767,
0.0348975398,
0.0194228087,
-0.0072343322,
-0.011691167,
-0.0079420954,
0.0192241557,
-0.0058115418,
-0.0370918661,
0.0386522114,
0.0056493138,
0.0368805304,
-0.0320100635,
-0.0057131625,
-0.0494418144,
2.216e-7,
0.0381358452,
0.0419925228,
0.0143342707,
-0.0455459915,
0.0044240975,
0.0557496212,
0.0521868318,
0.0025011743,
-0.0044576786,
0.0135171078,
-0.0458435751,
0.0196485501,
0.0193234421,
0.0158203673,
-0.0247195512,
-0.0306099672,
-0.0486030988,
-0.0048017842,
-0.0101013929,
0.0433960371,
0.0389722474,
0.0520825721,
0.0418008715,
-0.00770661,
-0.0052146828,
-0.0110656051,
-0.0050532226,
-0.0589890555,
0.0050984123,
0.0046011242,
0.0441893786,
-0.0216825865,
0.0469401218,
0.0336307585,
-0.0202484354,
0.0420854315,
-0.0032820988,
0.0499251075,
-0.0294716451,
-0.0009110225,
-0.0426954664,
-0.0253459159,
0.0127850091,
-0.0726025105,
0.0680455714,
0.041764155,
-0.0847919807,
-0.0327756852,
-0.0196442958,
-0.0304519292,
0.0241944008,
0.0184608418,
0.0017229202,
0.014184678,
0.0014273311,
0.0035430882,
-0.0046771942,
-0.0933568403,
-0.056524124,
-0.0158122294,
0.0044222693,
-0.0001537796,
0.0287133157,
0.0151765551,
0.0452942811,
-0.0442416817,
0.014101305,
2.116318244e-34,
-0.0050246469,
0.0509118475,
0.013835771,
-0.0225355104,
0.0557516292,
0.0407134481,
0.0243653376,
-0.0256749559,
0.0517221317,
0.0044029374,
-0.0127359033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16582v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16582v2 | Tailoring Personality Traits in Large Language Models via Unsupervisedly-Built Personalized Lexicons | 2023-10-25T12:16:33 | 2024-01-06T14:17:40 | Tianlong Li, Shihan Dou, Changze Lv, Wenhao Liu, Jianhan Xu, Muling Wu, Zixuan Ling, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personality plays a pivotal role in shaping human expression patterns, thus
regulating the personality of large language models (LLMs) holds significant
potential in enhancing the user experience of LLMs. Previous methods either
relied on fine-tuning LLMs on specific corpora or necessitated manually crafted
prompts to elicit specific personalities from LLMs. However, the former
approach is inefficient and costly, while the latter cannot precisely
manipulate personality traits at a fine-grained level. To address the above
challenges, we have employed a novel Unsupervisedly-Built Personalized Lexicons
(UBPL) in a pluggable manner during the decoding phase of LLMs to manipulate
their personality traits. UBPL is a lexicon built through an unsupervised
approach from a situational judgment test dataset (SJTs4LLM). Users can utilize
UBPL to adjust the probability vectors of predicted words in the decoding phase
of LLMs, thus influencing the personality expression of LLMs. Extensive
experimentation demonstrates the remarkable effectiveness and pluggability of
our method for fine-grained manipulation of LLM's personality. | [
0.0540668555,
0.071141243,
-0.0459362976,
0.0254032742,
-0.0173166879,
-0.0114807384,
0.0164344534,
-0.0255545862,
0.0001439423,
0.0233837888,
-0.0631202534,
0.0179716572,
-0.0293141473,
0.0196588915,
0.0069378885,
-0.0641394481,
0.055580359,
-0.0086938292,
0.0175101925,
-0.0121136773,
0.0057647638,
0.0519015566,
0.0118133882,
0.0252844803,
0.0102813123,
-0.0272890478,
0.0187590998,
-0.0047376002,
0.0295524839,
-0.012421337,
0.0345431864,
0.0786012337,
-0.0031221255,
-0.0210714471,
0.0000019577,
-0.0431936011,
-0.0062015322,
-0.0415041894,
0.0178094562,
0.0094231442,
0.0819350928,
0.0837297216,
-0.01338524,
0.0323932879,
-0.0586086735,
-0.0278081801,
0.0165384747,
0.0214828886,
0.0596877374,
0.0364489779,
0.0027842871,
-0.0215131771,
-0.0456206277,
0.0021932786,
0.0404809043,
-0.0084397243,
0.009280757,
-0.0269072745,
-0.0304996055,
0.000173685,
-0.0191086158,
0.0022375826,
-0.0240253024,
0.0133451521,
0.0120555619,
-0.0310646147,
-0.0256512892,
-0.0057578329,
-0.0016219867,
0.0467606708,
0.0593914613,
-0.0164949168,
-0.0315469876,
-0.0119250407,
0.0445762426,
0.0296860486,
0.0312058553,
-0.0043093837,
-0.0084290467,
-0.0112410085,
0.0138973696,
0.0253237393,
-0.0205668267,
0.0144375367,
-0.0374417938,
0.0794771537,
0.0052385991,
0.0045001642,
-0.0074242442,
-0.0125607345,
0.0403177962,
-0.0372618474,
0.0085592177,
-0.0060027405,
-0.0207437314,
0.0261833873,
-0.05752334,
0.0327216163,
0.009124632,
-0.0277317408,
0.0242607947,
0.0233902335,
-0.0148809087,
-0.0104559846,
0.0424984396,
0.0038087175,
0.0236569997,
0.0202306714,
-0.0204823725,
0.0103536202,
-0.0639230311,
-0.0005572381,
0.0119333062,
-0.0231344048,
0.0011417829,
0.0150280716,
-0.0734158829,
0.0549099855,
-0.016021423,
-0.0137347504,
0.0175578464,
0.0175950192,
-0.004271375,
0.0115513261,
-0.0856570154,
0.005061713,
-0.0546646267,
-0.024782734,
-0.0039647571,
-0.017296657,
0.0340789966,
-0.0187875107,
0.0402877517,
-0.0261315517,
0.0483875126,
0.0344941132,
0.0171870925,
-0.068669945,
-0.0379730538,
-0.0371039808,
-0.0189514775,
-0.0281395093,
-0.0184113346,
-0.0374789424,
0.0196154397,
-0.0060263029,
0.0047050654,
-0.0699393451,
-0.0137148341,
0.0248659272,
0.0000503403,
0.0858766884,
-0.0131644402,
0.0089186709,
-0.0202800427,
0.0004923319,
0.0233160481,
0.0340435356,
-0.0082006259,
0.0303511228,
0.0464445651,
-0.0352869183,
0.0426101089,
0.0503353253,
-0.0229484029,
0.0045143529,
-0.0467074104,
-0.0236351211,
0.012075685,
0.0028031133,
0.0686161593,
0.0178996958,
-0.0025586635,
-0.0026373959,
0.0878471285,
0.0605909005,
0.0349234268,
0.0568160415,
0.0005006285,
0.0430603325,
0.0245251115,
0.0053084181,
-0.024836475,
0.0146556552,
-0.0434711911,
-0.00025213,
-0.0168746412,
0.0393023677,
-0.0055547967,
-0.0506818332,
-0.0034072583,
-0.0001438591,
0.0628780127,
0.0342021696,
-0.0244521555,
0.016775135,
0.0027664457,
0.0063070636,
0.062771067,
-0.071859546,
-0.0086549502,
-0.0536831655,
0.017772913,
0.1483722329,
0.040395014,
-0.0056632557,
-0.0186919514,
0.0154923564,
-0.0754948258,
0.0308223851,
0.0393963642,
-0.0239781309,
0.0034712285,
-0.0463109612,
-0.0008857394,
0.0112110553,
-0.0199829992,
0.0133384727,
0.0163884498,
0.0006400456,
-0.010503334,
0.0065043396,
0.0020875314,
0.0013403516,
-0.0719479397,
-0.0691543892,
0.0293878671,
0.0197038502,
0.0234794579,
0.0074456134,
0.02266532,
-0.0293248668,
-0.0077311634,
0.01531146,
-0.0050119739,
0.023724908,
-0.006777382,
-0.0121061802,
0.0097158095,
-0.0111383032,
-0.0110780746,
0.0153966136,
0.0165063795,
-0.0023470637,
-0.0175443571,
-0.0339709073,
0.0599145107,
-0.0252034329,
0.0024414579,
-0.0405449383,
0.0689995438,
-0.0203207768,
0.0299872346,
-0.0196869671,
-0.0446297415,
0.0052439817,
0.0085695665,
-0.0553907715,
-0.0351294391,
-0.0065247812,
-0.037842866,
0.0311931856,
0.0182434209,
0.0165306218,
0.0303708725,
-0.0443022512,
-0.0637734532,
-0.0444067493,
-0.0084932651,
0.0237826463,
0.0006064394,
0.012554585,
0.010485244,
-0.0497055687,
0.012777728,
-0.0434985124,
-0.0041086921,
0.0105883302,
0.0105653042,
0.0286483169,
-0.0127182994,
-0.016125204,
-0.0506697446,
-0.0019551939,
-0.0208550841,
-0.0046619275,
-0.0508176647,
0.042176716,
-0.0202860907,
0.0123676006,
-0.0447436534,
-0.0038158312,
0.0066218697,
-0.0644286871,
0.0176355243,
-0.0140102385,
0.0439070389,
0.0527047701,
0.0397851132,
0.0433099754,
0.0243934616,
-0.0145768784,
-0.0390940048,
0.0056769028,
-0.0111424373,
0.004307182,
-0.0385097377,
-0.0565706976,
0.0155258058,
0.0316804796,
0.0165782478,
0.0101798251,
-0.0675704703,
0.0660848767,
0.0461694784,
-0.0522041619,
0.0596842729,
0.0348941274,
-0.0326938853,
0.0534427315,
0.0506648086,
-0.0199890267,
0.0687437132,
-0.0017148326,
0.012233193,
-0.0103591327,
-0.0400133207,
-0.0204555616,
0.0557636283,
-0.0175066534,
-0.0083295526,
0.0145222964,
-0.0117872702,
-0.0238059647,
-0.0511431284,
0.0121206716,
-0.0524833463,
0.0334812328,
0.0005176925,
-0.0687123388,
0.05718676,
-0.0246127807,
-0.0252885874,
-0.0485727414,
-0.0396482423,
-0.0536114722,
0.0767383799,
-0.0434775203,
-0.0143460687,
-0.0299415793,
0.007862214,
-0.0244703926,
-0.0365691483,
-0.0168337189,
0.0049446905,
-0.0427308343,
0.0475087427,
0.0379055068,
0.0173068829,
-0.0280568954,
-0.0417255908,
-0.0000727057,
-0.0458429269,
-0.0217636079,
0.0163009912,
0.0184056219,
0.0507448278,
-0.0131408945,
0.0164397806,
0.0187984724,
0.0376679748,
-0.0146778086,
-0.009977188,
0.1116401255,
0.0453871377,
-0.0427521877,
0.0209109634,
0.000764808,
0.0193127338,
0.0451720431,
0.0716817155,
-0.0166218914,
-0.0278623141,
-0.0091555519,
0.056692034,
-0.045721896,
-0.0214542523,
-0.0329687931,
-0.092394121,
0.021668084,
0.0415739454,
-0.0070105055,
0.0138202598,
-0.0132755861,
0.0122664655,
-0.0433365926,
0.0079397373,
-0.0209642164,
-0.0143149095,
-0.0124057885,
-0.0406036824,
-0.0716946051,
-0.0543099679,
0.0824820399,
-0.0174060818,
0.0538906939,
0.0339514539,
0.0419118591,
-0.0002249354,
-0.0748023242,
-0.0821824744,
0.0215930659,
0.026522221,
-0.0141083533,
0.0463397205,
-0.0326590538,
0.009837186,
-0.0963736996,
0.036034964,
-0.0072835288,
0.0103420131,
0.0079887463,
0.0139760524,
-0.0043631191,
-0.0149615481,
-0.0440837368,
0.0011980999,
0.0296662897,
0.0464582369,
-0.0163851157,
-0.1288217455,
0.0220580772,
-0.0210694186,
-0.015789343,
-0.0341034532,
-0.0929421857,
-0.004831898,
0.0009239336,
-0.0210282374,
-0.039172478,
-0.0789627805,
0.0068742638,
0.0347500257,
-0.0106494594,
-0.0341546685,
-0.0188903026,
0.047511287,
-0.03066645,
0.0273952093,
-0.0327181853,
0.0027552354,
-0.048201073,
-0.0489797704,
0.0518204831,
-0.063398093,
0.018860409,
0.0365588665,
-0.0062171803,
-0.0492421947,
0.0469616577,
0.0266701132,
0.0129485046,
0.0541403256,
0.0121807819,
-0.0994917527,
0.0695611537,
0.018054625,
-0.0052501452,
0.0211729463,
0.001112638,
0.053873688,
-0.0044677346,
0.0161523763,
-0.0028407283,
0.0494835079,
-0.0057862215,
-0.0198370311,
-0.0246758405,
-0.1116622388,
0.0190079175,
0.0217064228,
0.015995156,
-0.0208344292,
-0.019378582,
-0.0051078298,
-0.0199213978,
-0.0353316218,
-0.0273950808,
0.0076000653,
-0.0748011544,
0.0190447457,
-0.0396236368,
-0.0253152065,
-0.0265623201,
-0.0506048314,
0.0029612035,
-0.0429312475,
0.0347520299,
0.0177949145,
0.0131672714,
-0.0113849016,
0.0237283092,
-0.008665923,
-0.0039591631,
-0.0049549625,
0.0506724492,
-0.0069648209,
0.0617486984,
-0.0340791456,
-0.0002267871,
-0.0452615544,
0.0539229438,
-0.0254456569,
0.0256341603,
0.0029288908,
-0.0027950055,
-0.0326325782,
-0.005023465,
0.0281857196,
-0.0309892874,
0.0088035855,
-0.020888688,
0.0065300246,
-0.0104587255,
0.0018015403,
-0.0003384918,
0.0152034992,
-0.0290960483,
-0.069034487,
0.0172009617,
0.0095920926,
-0.0220304672,
-0.0282996148,
-0.0362782553,
-0.058015395,
0.0045818482,
0.0143387327,
0.0192710031,
-0.0225458331,
-0.0253322329,
-0.0980467647,
-0.0650563017,
0.0470970385,
0.0307335313,
-0.0090139071,
-0.0300875101,
0.0163834114,
0.0456721336,
-0.0247711968,
-0.0312626511,
-0.0320803002,
-0.0031684823,
-0.0255534444,
-0.0101561258,
0.0002022731,
-5.78001666e-33,
-0.036414437,
-0.0132472832,
0.0108278552,
-0.0080693029,
0.0151889483,
-0.0596711636,
0.003899355,
0.0413566679,
0.01477856,
-0.0072476007,
-0.0673383176,
-0.0165412556,
0.0102890357,
-0.0118516171,
0.0309296045,
0.0315471664,
0.0663295835,
0.0200997796,
-0.0272207111,
0.0155466888,
0.0332021974,
0.0078466553,
0.0467893034,
-0.073545143,
0.0070084264,
-0.0068837232,
-0.008899088,
-0.0071926797,
0.0256608706,
0.0624547265,
0.0085262274,
0.0458173789,
0.0012261707,
0.0177919175,
-0.0293226261,
0.0217843223,
-0.041409567,
-0.0500450507,
0.0190081298,
0.0181800667,
-0.0037353237,
-0.0590607934,
0.0019308008,
-0.0049532391,
-0.0691493601,
0.0016525669,
0.0461021028,
-0.0081937695,
0.0320596397,
0.023694586,
-0.0190271959,
0.005689715,
0.0015560648,
-0.021084154,
0.0073747514,
-0.0183714908,
-0.0199169554,
-0.0106799724,
-0.0540452451,
0.0547005124,
-0.0184204821,
-0.0201832205,
0.0355373062,
0.0487837121,
0.0069924081,
0.0430164859,
0.043407023,
0.0622096024,
0.0219303928,
-0.0193437114,
0.0670151785,
0.056616731,
-0.0215241034,
0.098482497,
-0.0016667979,
-0.0676150993,
0.0544651523,
0.031555742,
0.0886348486,
-0.056530416,
0.0425722189,
0.0229454637,
-0.0517283753,
-0.0279339384,
-0.0049231593,
0.0050607068,
-0.0117297061,
-0.0274510384,
0.0060410053,
-0.0224244259,
-0.0607706606,
-0.0394631587,
0.0110191554,
-0.0285386611,
-0.0082609253,
0.0157183781,
-0.049920667,
0.021612538,
-0.0156299528,
-0.0313997306,
-0.0081051327,
0.0106685935,
0.0147701576,
-0.0140706934,
0.0281279851,
0.0305528045,
-0.0170349237,
0.0445295945,
-0.0873503685,
-0.0294883214,
0.0322351828,
0.0265874341,
-0.0399468131,
-0.0090203537,
0.0408387631,
0.0100126574,
-0.02784965,
0.0002518522,
0.0241339281,
0.0274080057,
-0.0305235423,
-0.021072017,
0.0375412814,
0.0076358565,
-0.0040053139,
-0.009213658,
-0.0587032177,
-0.0033754497,
0.0437987521,
-0.0306660552,
0.0207565185,
0.0197978262,
2.666e-7,
-0.0247342754,
0.093633689,
-0.0448881648,
0.0541761182,
0.0357443392,
0.0527823903,
0.028781781,
0.0121080745,
0.0324684754,
-0.045939818,
0.0220100041,
0.0374564715,
0.0230488311,
0.0374344848,
-0.0582361035,
0.0343335159,
0.0277171899,
0.044811748,
-0.0309270304,
0.0181995872,
0.0744248256,
0.052842129,
0.0586546548,
-0.0095717562,
0.0424445532,
0.0345606804,
0.0105608311,
-0.0097089084,
-0.0341705419,
0.0261610262,
-0.0438924581,
-0.0117769055,
0.0097250156,
0.0345177352,
-0.0119230188,
-0.0029761619,
-0.0484044664,
0.0751867145,
-0.0285464507,
-0.0283462759,
0.0032056607,
0.0360310525,
-0.0192474741,
0.0246044397,
0.0364467986,
0.0076300758,
-0.0370377712,
-0.0368151814,
0.0007881622,
-0.016314961,
0.0168964062,
-0.0232411288,
-0.0326758921,
0.0372976027,
0.0143702552,
-0.0145856924,
-0.0223370045,
-0.063581869,
0.0281544589,
-0.0112868864,
-0.040661253,
-0.0553645454,
-0.019938143,
0.0210305247,
0.0196310021,
-0.0363213941,
0.0460641123,
2.213647799e-34,
-0.0057073557,
0.0657976717,
0.0211181249,
-0.0691047534,
0.0602118522,
0.0255134795,
0.0248479024,
0.0322281569,
0.0763806254,
-0.0810415819,
-0.0080516273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16579v1 | WSDMS: Debunk Fake News via Weakly Supervised Detection of Misinforming Sentences with Contextualized Social Wisdom | 2023-10-25T12:06:55 | 2023-10-25T12:06:55 | Ruichao Yang, Wei Gao, Jing Ma, Hongzhan Lin, Zhiwei Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, we witness the explosion of false and unconfirmed
information (i.e., rumors) that went viral on social media and shocked the
public. Rumors can trigger versatile, mostly controversial stance expressions
among social media users. Rumor verification and stance detection are different
yet relevant tasks. Fake news debunking primarily focuses on determining the
truthfulness of news articles, which oversimplifies the issue as fake news
often combines elements of both truth and falsehood. Thus, it becomes crucial
to identify specific instances of misinformation within the articles. In this
research, we investigate a novel task in the field of fake news debunking,
which involves detecting sentence-level misinformation. One of the major
challenges in this task is the absence of a training dataset with
sentence-level annotations regarding veracity. Inspired by the Multiple
Instance Learning (MIL) approach, we propose a model called Weakly Supervised
Detection of Misinforming Sentences (WSDMS). This model only requires bag-level
labels for training but is capable of inferring both sentence-level
misinformation and article-level veracity, aided by relevant social media
conversations that are attentively contextualized with news sentences. We
evaluate WSDMS on three real-world benchmarks and demonstrate that it
outperforms existing state-of-the-art baselines in debunking fake news at both
the sentence and article levels. | [
0.0342731662,
0.018774448,
0.0266818982,
0.0696510151,
-0.0262324251,
0.0266057514,
0.0286157969,
-0.0198026318,
0.002893223,
-0.0414046198,
-0.0386400633,
0.0060750246,
-0.0064619165,
0.0426460765,
0.0186761934,
0.0223618336,
0.0838867798,
0.0334857367,
0.0348205641,
-0.0184218381,
0.0586476736,
0.0404570885,
-0.0323378928,
0.0265551284,
-0.0571242124,
-0.0283005238,
0.0520693436,
0.0117706461,
0.071055688,
-0.0539855324,
0.0495407097,
0.0279912278,
0.0617442988,
0.0814151391,
0.0000014591,
-0.0110187624,
-0.0133745996,
-0.0010287394,
-0.0547068045,
0.0007068755,
0.0251163654,
-0.0439809412,
0.0238585379,
0.0008392886,
-0.001914726,
-0.0448257774,
0.0157730784,
0.1002782732,
0.1039435267,
0.091428563,
-0.009677751,
-0.022016095,
-0.0155827962,
-0.0254774615,
0.0056231688,
-0.0743550584,
0.0583103709,
-0.0082422905,
-0.0666098297,
0.0473625883,
0.0383679867,
0.0035554275,
0.0405636169,
-0.0167127401,
-0.0288004186,
0.0146705136,
-0.0734476671,
-0.0067959181,
-0.0099169407,
0.0313511342,
0.0303208809,
-0.0629747137,
-0.0246941093,
0.0179575179,
0.0107142376,
0.0295550488,
-0.0118993474,
-0.0258978121,
-0.0296831951,
0.0253080875,
0.0076785814,
0.0044605732,
0.0158223864,
0.0689327568,
0.0693731979,
0.0391501375,
-0.0310974773,
-0.0388456434,
0.0044993288,
0.0116437525,
-0.0152705302,
-0.00426069,
0.0448391102,
-0.0045025456,
-0.0252500493,
0.0180560816,
-0.0537476167,
0.0006671268,
0.0447940752,
-0.1175025851,
-0.0129440269,
-0.0342821181,
0.0130140046,
0.0560760573,
0.0111288428,
-0.0400109552,
-0.015676111,
-0.0311326999,
0.0103490166,
-0.0180849824,
-0.0238309056,
0.0145644741,
-0.0228711553,
0.0421093851,
-0.012769117,
0.0034684131,
-0.0583582856,
-0.0540672317,
-0.0169009473,
0.0107314456,
-0.0365496464,
0.0323730558,
-0.0303611178,
-0.0328700803,
-0.0141474633,
0.04464579,
-0.0107903937,
0.0417451262,
-0.003409605,
-0.0171450265,
-0.0455725528,
0.0196184274,
-0.0038846536,
0.0186934844,
-0.0043439511,
-0.0079132225,
0.0034233788,
0.0115479175,
-0.02589068,
-0.0132560236,
-0.0348619297,
-0.0346501879,
0.0102645122,
-0.0659931153,
-0.0026189296,
-0.0209375508,
0.0001001138,
0.0101280902,
-0.0018031982,
0.015050903,
-0.041684527,
0.0457260199,
0.0110280616,
-0.0149776759,
0.0525050573,
0.0326054543,
0.0269944258,
0.0541195236,
-0.003999914,
0.068241246,
0.0529857837,
0.0327792987,
0.0165808555,
-0.0179833714,
0.0583913475,
0.0159236006,
0.0183351375,
-0.0211001411,
-0.0441743135,
-0.0160256121,
-0.0062667951,
-0.0124079017,
-0.009311514,
-0.025839569,
0.0862268582,
-0.0601638891,
-0.0456380658,
-0.0285288878,
0.0647324324,
0.0194173791,
-0.0017823338,
-0.026556246,
-0.0449359976,
0.022389276,
-0.0592239201,
-0.0326093547,
-0.0027940494,
0.0554376803,
-0.0211301818,
-0.0277550463,
0.0064596329,
0.0103397034,
-0.0509092174,
-0.003603121,
-0.0298114568,
0.0348189361,
-0.0177249275,
0.0598705001,
0.043821428,
0.0039568702,
-0.0581575744,
-0.0365412273,
0.0162628777,
0.0000581849,
-0.000464449,
0.0087117013,
-0.0217627622,
-0.0253961682,
0.0325191058,
0.0650644079,
0.0480852984,
-0.0443422012,
0.0078113344,
-0.0050564776,
0.0084760906,
-0.0394764394,
0.0339000635,
-0.0023470647,
0.0629359111,
0.0199962221,
0.0021443099,
-0.0385331549,
-0.0293479618,
0.0162158981,
0.0122882333,
-0.0056308839,
0.0027457341,
0.010654849,
0.0260426104,
0.0018930284,
0.0032554287,
-0.0408940874,
0.0464272387,
0.0085733281,
-0.0381331071,
-0.0124082128,
-0.0221639443,
-0.0703595951,
0.0048628412,
-0.0071171327,
-0.0797064677,
0.0319110379,
-0.0512225032,
0.026607465,
-0.0032427197,
-0.0121692102,
-0.0230018366,
-0.0370531268,
-0.0353259817,
-0.0086275851,
0.0174579564,
0.0151859485,
0.0862294361,
-0.0468969867,
-0.0127929216,
-0.0296660755,
-0.0083196582,
0.0044691511,
0.0127324909,
-0.0038982595,
-0.0366170406,
0.0141503727,
0.0055665458,
0.019831812,
-0.0040174085,
-0.0170903392,
0.0004702489,
-0.0716819093,
0.0022153067,
-0.0232179891,
-0.0248806328,
0.0250433236,
-0.0083369259,
0.0077028619,
-0.0397397168,
-0.011272165,
0.0107556386,
-0.0123321479,
-0.0049021305,
0.0185300354,
-0.0167013686,
0.0428550392,
-0.0268988032,
0.0348929651,
-0.0073303371,
0.0521429032,
-0.0014172476,
-0.0549520664,
-0.0174573213,
0.0235248692,
-0.0506491661,
0.0153539879,
-0.0206966307,
0.004071529,
0.0268999729,
0.0548817813,
0.0103892181,
0.0583924353,
0.046442356,
0.0533923656,
-0.0130565008,
0.0596283861,
-0.0115557211,
-0.0046672006,
-0.0210177489,
0.0552665144,
-0.062159881,
-0.0313270353,
0.0231150854,
0.0501389951,
0.016716361,
-0.0013978439,
0.0149918338,
0.0679525957,
0.0150742065,
-0.053500589,
0.0252596699,
-0.0106935343,
0.0054732738,
-0.0292037614,
-0.0881317332,
-0.0422521047,
0.0794364214,
-0.0148703037,
0.0438354164,
-0.0186067261,
-0.0378335901,
-0.0111791044,
-0.002248869,
-0.0225819778,
0.0199355856,
-0.0366826132,
0.0313168578,
0.0204175971,
-0.0269711483,
0.0566846468,
-0.0047861766,
-0.0201030001,
-0.0287662223,
0.0205745474,
0.0349854752,
-0.0512007289,
-0.0330242701,
-0.0735176504,
-0.0074386215,
-0.0370573811,
-0.0506956913,
0.0022845364,
-0.1022983044,
-0.0576679297,
0.0511679463,
0.0241246577,
-0.0121173123,
-0.0125800269,
0.0310827419,
0.0407950617,
0.0438530892,
-0.00535001,
0.0511568375,
-0.0221039969,
0.0057402486,
0.0649508759,
-0.0259066131,
0.0276974887,
-0.0268677138,
-0.0353545137,
-0.0152060827,
0.0149682872,
-0.0081794625,
-0.0477107987,
0.0531928092,
-0.0461442918,
-0.0136778597,
0.0743384287,
0.0120591894,
0.0002349385,
0.0142676961,
0.0472392514,
-0.0276963599,
0.0405645706,
0.0035810499,
-0.0428421721,
-0.0042732107,
-0.0467283055,
-0.0115346415,
0.0149258161,
0.004495095,
-0.0123751834,
-0.079925999,
0.0216137003,
-0.0365789086,
-0.0616790764,
-0.0130545972,
-0.0252872314,
0.007525784,
0.0002239885,
0.0157441981,
-0.0022422727,
0.0291430503,
-0.0111877732,
0.0159488935,
-0.005443187,
-0.0316934958,
0.0386176109,
-0.0047196983,
0.0382321142,
0.0239738282,
0.0419430956,
-0.0126865972,
-0.0050786785,
-0.0040699705,
0.0342173874,
-0.0459017642,
-0.0178419668,
0.0715632141,
-0.0802692845,
-0.0295265,
-0.0469734408,
0.0406320356,
0.0069265077,
-0.0417402014,
-0.021638399,
0.0072667105,
0.0264783874,
-0.0601771586,
-0.0299364738,
0.0204429477,
0.0215963777,
0.0417004041,
-0.0058549689,
0.0137158763,
0.0159196071,
-0.0200715121,
-0.0241045561,
-0.0351732858,
-0.0194228813,
0.0487585738,
-0.0045386273,
-0.0340123735,
-0.0325595438,
-0.0123303095,
0.0001264287,
0.0521558709,
-0.040858604,
-0.0100447731,
0.029326072,
-0.000657498,
-0.0363994762,
-0.0113864336,
-0.0349361263,
0.0315508656,
0.041809991,
-0.0137659227,
0.0372636877,
0.0033456602,
-0.0205677208,
0.0483102277,
-0.0580898263,
-0.0455021858,
0.0015902595,
0.0442262068,
0.0070688757,
0.0601052232,
0.0009687195,
-0.0375153609,
0.0684901401,
0.0629793778,
-0.00607862,
0.0516896769,
0.0209476911,
-0.020041585,
0.0464648753,
0.0332546383,
0.0044459254,
0.0760815889,
0.0416586027,
-0.0041088737,
-0.0815472975,
0.018320214,
0.0124171544,
-0.023527896,
0.0204182882,
0.0034117759,
0.0065951729,
-0.0250536613,
-0.0154514108,
-0.0150941266,
-0.0657958686,
0.0079593519,
0.032340426,
0.0173545722,
-0.0210586563,
-0.0171923935,
-0.005091961,
-0.0032012074,
0.061931774,
-0.0320233479,
-0.0448659845,
0.0456268936,
0.0102548674,
-0.021481894,
-0.0054798536,
-0.0390463211,
-0.0106682256,
0.0029887103,
0.0069715292,
0.0099593634,
0.0240971707,
0.0266825035,
-0.0017483914,
0.0077170613,
-0.0340707414,
-0.0439733863,
0.0292505715,
-0.0559597202,
0.0380345061,
-0.0000117921,
-0.034196347,
0.0289031211,
-0.000974506,
-0.0274222158,
0.0071048448,
-0.0177830458,
0.0110857338,
-0.0390353873,
0.0030590829,
0.034726914,
-0.0372400358,
0.0675662756,
0.0391398109,
-0.0116748875,
0.0381104462,
0.0412228182,
-0.0873872563,
-0.0484551787,
-0.0256273765,
0.0017081966,
0.0523774326,
0.0224897154,
0.0118385479,
-0.0518326797,
-0.0484572016,
0.0134933498,
0.0173976664,
0.0508278385,
0.0381639935,
-0.0417235605,
0.1077267006,
0.0358278528,
-0.0046748724,
-0.026790902,
-0.0290039033,
-0.0206375103,
-0.0196344312,
0.0059520295,
-5.493027796e-33,
-0.001163792,
-0.0461206846,
-0.0374433734,
-0.0148677388,
0.0025410156,
0.0594183244,
-0.0082679242,
-0.0342761427,
-0.0352573507,
0.0908108279,
0.052699402,
0.056142129,
-0.006371134,
0.0053542322,
-0.0357991569,
0.0251769982,
0.0432774499,
-0.0061661308,
-0.0184248351,
0.0131052062,
0.0663930848,
-0.0040766103,
0.060223639,
-0.0770442635,
0.0382604674,
-0.0339160338,
-0.0470818505,
0.0395638533,
-0.0368087143,
0.0299619883,
-0.0417299755,
0.0427523069,
0.0376424342,
-0.0304468479,
0.0204759277,
0.0034694474,
-0.0715911016,
-0.0101594664,
0.0223496258,
-0.0230223257,
-0.0160595868,
0.0343935564,
0.0142787481,
0.0044633998,
0.0275513418,
0.0094507365,
0.0093013449,
-0.0254588127,
0.020768065,
-0.0480858274,
-0.065289408,
-0.0003791496,
0.0080226315,
-0.025847232,
-0.0943526253,
0.0067022881,
0.0063345679,
0.0104945619,
-0.0569356382,
-0.001360431,
-0.0728108138,
0.0022739428,
-0.0264463741,
-0.0323736072,
-0.0387018211,
0.0692300424,
0.0141643146,
0.0583575591,
-0.0141354213,
0.0086448975,
0.0023428157,
0.0422809683,
0.0520036109,
0.1010079458,
0.0446678735,
-0.0293160807,
-0.0988247171,
-0.0024437252,
0.0347249843,
-0.0163757037,
0.0283163395,
-0.0029348042,
-0.0311286245,
0.0214856379,
-0.0027929868,
-0.0019117132,
-0.0262047052,
-0.0010519129,
-0.0062744305,
0.0487508327,
-0.0612087585,
0.0989765599,
-0.0102780415,
-0.03678881,
-0.0109242881,
0.0029785302,
-0.0147297746,
-0.0190183502,
0.0171168242,
0.0355452411,
-0.064500019,
0.0236087311,
0.0275006536,
0.0243537258,
-0.0074518351,
-0.0104107577,
0.1098154783,
-0.0172318649,
-0.0554360785,
0.0408381969,
-0.0183637571,
0.0241827965,
-0.0305510052,
-0.0228035133,
0.0161685422,
-0.003792109,
-0.0302158371,
-0.0166196823,
-0.009992783,
-0.0129247364,
0.0017631773,
-0.0161424074,
-0.0330509469,
0.0396197848,
-0.0081454823,
-0.005418377,
-0.034462925,
-0.0107136853,
-0.0301025696,
-0.0834691077,
0.0265382081,
0.014411455,
2.328e-7,
-0.003043653,
0.0393221043,
0.0227390788,
0.0028823586,
0.023632966,
0.048292622,
0.0189793259,
0.0259828344,
-0.0040722825,
-0.0891045928,
-0.0466698967,
0.0788937733,
0.0147761516,
0.0390172154,
-0.0399445184,
-0.0147342542,
-0.0480620079,
-0.0161417946,
-0.053357292,
-0.0077251359,
-0.0005485141,
0.0653232411,
0.0515182093,
-0.0300650168,
0.0103236511,
-0.0363647528,
0.0756518394,
0.0505656712,
-0.0543075688,
-0.0074845138,
0.0104899649,
-0.0189675018,
0.0017892856,
0.0147203878,
-0.0207127295,
-0.0126778567,
0.0056472146,
0.0121222464,
-0.004705274,
-0.0003792281,
-0.0131525267,
0.0078235408,
0.0338889919,
-0.0195085481,
0.0447960533,
-0.0683932304,
-0.0349636599,
-0.057136748,
-0.0311473366,
0.0302584749,
0.0154174622,
0.0010462672,
-0.0140309222,
0.0149965053,
-0.0145707214,
-0.0035457378,
-0.010982967,
-0.0462454557,
-0.0041614268,
0.0133539494,
-0.0518093966,
-0.0240347236,
0.0402303003,
-0.0268292762,
0.0637188703,
-0.0288661588,
0.0242351312,
1.632401658e-34,
0.0321846046,
-0.0185600184,
-0.0136030605,
-0.0212348588,
0.0484167635,
0.0203472991,
-0.070483461,
-0.0387541279,
0.0058980547,
0.0162145942,
0.0219956897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16570v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16570v2 | Give Me the Facts! A Survey on Factual Knowledge Probing in Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-10-25T11:57:13 | 2023-12-04T19:23:33 | Paul Youssef, Osman Alperen Koraş, Meijie Li, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) are trained on vast unlabeled data, rich
in world knowledge. This fact has sparked the interest of the community in
quantifying the amount of factual knowledge present in PLMs, as this explains
their performance on downstream tasks, and potentially justifies their use as
knowledge bases. In this work, we survey methods and datasets that are used to
probe PLMs for factual knowledge. Our contributions are: (1) We propose a
categorization scheme for factual probing methods that is based on how their
inputs, outputs and the probed PLMs are adapted; (2) We provide an overview of
the datasets used for factual probing; (3) We synthesize insights about
knowledge retention and prompt optimization in PLMs, analyze obstacles to
adopting PLMs as knowledge bases and outline directions for future work. | [
0.041746527,
0.0340304188,
-0.0165866632,
0.0413545482,
-0.0196672026,
0.0086883213,
0.0193003248,
-0.01690083,
-0.0186747983,
-0.0631390661,
-0.0270370394,
-0.0237359274,
0.0000711361,
0.0342526883,
0.0213629827,
0.0063270503,
0.0544037484,
-0.021213308,
0.0224246942,
-0.0129588256,
-0.0107408026,
0.0097277276,
-0.0183227174,
-0.0018278124,
-0.0499415323,
-0.0145443603,
-0.0378303602,
-0.0373975374,
-0.0191680733,
-0.0008742209,
0.0144604379,
0.0656017885,
0.0262664296,
0.0406061448,
0.0000017765,
-0.0606701411,
-0.0021421812,
-0.030056309,
-0.0900210291,
0.0539833866,
0.019739354,
0.0339011289,
-0.003294087,
0.0124424743,
-0.0531736277,
-0.0550899915,
0.0123486994,
0.0259831734,
0.0539759286,
0.0857817829,
0.0073359744,
-0.0129853934,
-0.0223072413,
-0.0041041095,
-0.004695225,
-0.0187776871,
0.0427428186,
0.0136062261,
-0.0343673602,
0.0285884179,
0.00019672,
0.0233246926,
0.0043836245,
0.0020681049,
0.0027340057,
0.0556005463,
-0.0115770921,
-0.0412718989,
0.0203309823,
0.0689259768,
-0.0080837198,
-0.0446009859,
0.0011156565,
-0.0191070549,
-0.0230414122,
0.0162773151,
0.0076108286,
0.0169665739,
0.0036416831,
0.0290493332,
0.0094026476,
-0.0015286156,
0.0388860777,
0.0044205096,
-0.0468744934,
0.0709510595,
-0.0081964461,
-0.0389407426,
0.0238530245,
0.0173752103,
0.032147605,
-0.0620587096,
-0.013169582,
0.0225513745,
0.0021953322,
0.0435609259,
-0.0350491963,
0.0200699978,
0.0117118964,
-0.0376833752,
0.0334204175,
-0.0034743685,
-0.079750821,
0.0691532195,
-0.0274814125,
0.0213842764,
0.0387576483,
0.0385518633,
-0.0279745329,
0.0146447048,
-0.0466389768,
0.0062740627,
-0.0349116698,
0.0085219946,
0.0300019998,
0.0211385656,
0.0167947002,
0.0052926014,
0.0079277577,
0.0406130888,
-0.0157275647,
-0.025605619,
-0.0126112951,
0.0214807615,
-0.0664712116,
0.0300360397,
-0.02505829,
0.0361024253,
-0.0246261638,
-0.0642237514,
-0.0170811191,
0.0128367497,
0.0090099145,
-0.0151291024,
0.0358507559,
-0.020336261,
-0.0007160961,
-0.0550484881,
-0.0661087334,
-0.0176997595,
0.0275310297,
-0.0893044323,
0.0046415594,
-0.0361600444,
0.0452059954,
-0.0058549088,
-0.0154869165,
-0.0458633974,
-0.0028736154,
0.0115006734,
-0.0266165882,
0.0906176567,
-0.0154689895,
0.0266663767,
-0.0077268458,
-0.0108316122,
0.0137851546,
0.0531400479,
-0.0113288658,
0.0253721233,
0.0684275031,
-0.0086059086,
0.0238671992,
0.0213629752,
0.0580814071,
-0.0127026848,
0.034421362,
0.0317269601,
0.0027948278,
0.0103638498,
0.0177682918,
0.0180266183,
0.0069129039,
-0.0033212907,
0.0761538744,
0.0298261959,
0.0006904808,
0.0147212232,
0.0634164587,
-0.0117894402,
0.0747474208,
0.0257134326,
-0.0543091223,
-0.0298438594,
-0.0478340685,
0.0125047434,
-0.0178246908,
0.0268947296,
-0.0483150631,
-0.0482766032,
-0.0204631351,
-0.0010640856,
-0.0269700252,
0.0226344224,
0.058115948,
0.0160040576,
-0.0238068458,
0.0627687722,
0.0249449592,
-0.0539696775,
0.0255447142,
-0.0248096809,
0.0309345424,
0.0105993981,
0.0339092463,
-0.077522777,
-0.0413406007,
0.012410501,
0.0195020027,
-0.0010469004,
0.0762688965,
-0.0224343296,
0.0166069027,
-0.0109381601,
-0.0069703427,
-0.0370901152,
0.0491617285,
0.0052104504,
0.0457726158,
0.0002694452,
0.0018005002,
-0.0725874007,
-0.0293369647,
0.0596989654,
-0.0475367121,
-0.0002610151,
-0.0062705213,
0.0150474124,
0.0088189365,
0.0314518623,
-0.0313401818,
0.0054840702,
0.059042152,
0.007713798,
0.0212444365,
0.0093249772,
-0.0048084413,
-0.0571622327,
0.0444542952,
-0.0016519674,
-0.0308315251,
0.0157637484,
-0.0403947532,
-0.0248979181,
-0.0073371669,
0.0278564505,
0.0584207103,
-0.065878354,
0.0184411183,
-0.0014940611,
0.0109131448,
0.0049176752,
0.0786046237,
-0.0018703162,
0.0097260373,
0.000927453,
-0.0035281279,
0.0242876913,
-0.0227591675,
-0.047671169,
-0.0083686542,
0.0001898765,
0.0136726163,
0.0170220118,
-0.0065670563,
-0.0471806191,
0.0261212885,
-0.0882199556,
0.0089899041,
-0.0337825119,
0.0063270149,
0.0189310275,
-0.0204835366,
-0.0376218408,
-0.0202251505,
-0.0326327831,
-0.0208980478,
-0.0088398326,
0.0141093582,
0.0417101085,
0.0119305514,
0.0537744872,
-0.0362581126,
0.0242787786,
-0.0038496919,
0.0371379219,
-0.0045716143,
0.0084363511,
-0.0185582638,
0.074067615,
-0.0752045587,
0.042809248,
-0.0247865766,
-0.0243137535,
0.0076729534,
-0.018403437,
0.0178897642,
0.0388338119,
-0.0152587006,
0.0404164419,
0.0739636198,
-0.0037198002,
-0.0184995048,
0.0178338476,
-0.0371127017,
-0.0256811399,
-0.0184210595,
0.007541222,
0.0241949186,
0.0586951636,
0.0081555648,
-0.0462073274,
-0.0188587029,
0.0187158082,
-0.0313335806,
-0.0090790205,
-0.062391296,
0.0208962616,
0.0059995982,
0.0714869201,
-0.0217413455,
-0.0458355471,
0.0786001086,
-0.0636056289,
0.0082045849,
-0.0232748538,
-0.0127760153,
-0.0006212478,
0.055358205,
0.0022523708,
-0.0266092364,
0.0257452335,
0.0238710809,
-0.0423152037,
0.026906427,
0.0375107713,
-0.0541822091,
0.0341400057,
-0.0509777777,
0.0340390876,
0.0301090702,
-0.004585892,
-0.0748215467,
-0.0895563141,
-0.0129377581,
-0.0183805004,
-0.0240264945,
0.0097351428,
-0.0133560393,
0.0036975183,
0.0058091395,
0.0660094395,
0.032168787,
0.0080826506,
-0.0084816478,
-0.0078618564,
0.039997682,
0.0164087489,
0.0406952687,
-0.0204879306,
-0.0121144988,
0.0312454887,
0.0062771337,
-0.0297172219,
0.00324877,
-0.0011126725,
0.0119679533,
-0.0366976932,
-0.005683728,
-0.0009912837,
0.0165313985,
-0.0307789147,
-0.0353212282,
0.1348706931,
0.0440822355,
-0.0144638037,
-0.0031382246,
0.0211486742,
-0.0200558733,
0.0256159268,
0.0227670688,
-0.0803019702,
-0.001257419,
-0.0000905613,
-0.0064413319,
-0.0097725959,
-0.0345013738,
-0.0673209354,
-0.1374564171,
0.0023875383,
-0.0347822495,
-0.0033118038,
-0.0330399089,
-0.0352584682,
0.0089396732,
-0.0209838599,
0.0020225819,
-0.0010003963,
0.0032045464,
0.0166622214,
0.0207092222,
-0.0415762998,
-0.101139091,
0.0530461632,
-0.0461817347,
0.071621567,
0.0275710896,
0.0124141658,
-0.0066243089,
-0.0132223964,
-0.0072716386,
-0.0087385327,
-0.0041841366,
0.0032375176,
0.0470636971,
-0.0434707329,
-0.0178886596,
0.0351929292,
0.0267675892,
-0.0320348367,
-0.0067262119,
0.020533219,
0.0624050014,
-0.0105891163,
-0.0261738617,
0.0231779385,
0.0017825592,
0.0050723124,
0.1257956177,
0.0458378643,
0.0030245194,
0.0059268977,
-0.0319238901,
0.0188777912,
0.0106456317,
-0.050879389,
0.0421514735,
-0.015436695,
0.0019698641,
-0.0571853966,
-0.0413920432,
0.0694158524,
0.0400766023,
-0.0103398189,
-0.0088788336,
0.0492631271,
-0.0285388939,
-0.0485122167,
0.0487463064,
-0.0516522713,
-0.0102700079,
-0.0370175987,
-0.0523546375,
0.0209958032,
-0.0358327925,
-0.0123125669,
-0.0455522873,
-0.0848000199,
-0.0581817962,
0.0288078673,
0.0658294633,
0.0220243838,
0.0538833477,
-0.0432672873,
-0.0275944155,
0.082526736,
0.0045122374,
-0.063023977,
0.0217591804,
0.0449959524,
-0.0417739712,
-0.0054245931,
0.0226762816,
-0.0322963409,
-0.0075393645,
0.0356232747,
0.009970828,
-0.0238440037,
-0.060622368,
0.0378394686,
0.0064893775,
0.1123102009,
0.0092787296,
-0.0101320362,
-0.0851182863,
0.0011903185,
-0.0198970996,
-0.0387338847,
-0.0227736551,
-0.0177156944,
0.0102671152,
0.0215477403,
-0.0226442404,
-0.0161496457,
-0.0643182024,
0.0612300001,
-0.0169212837,
-0.0391169153,
0.0251578763,
0.0012809526,
0.0275762305,
-0.0110835424,
-0.0104974946,
0.0387756713,
-0.0035429425,
0.0226390827,
-0.0097222701,
0.0387511402,
0.0241010264,
0.0216609798,
-0.00205438,
0.0066294014,
-0.0416383855,
-0.0094523961,
-0.0058853193,
0.0517932475,
0.0785470977,
-0.0545819961,
0.0237411503,
-0.0412354842,
-0.0055735926,
-0.0138933612,
0.0277439244,
0.0311729666,
-0.0308151674,
0.012825002,
-0.000907163,
-0.0451756045,
0.0364133976,
0.0925982147,
0.014347502,
0.0713731945,
0.005863471,
-0.0154278297,
-0.0321420692,
-0.0147257419,
-0.0053471187,
-0.0148908133,
-0.0393234976,
0.0404348113,
-0.0976994708,
-0.0901845098,
-0.0066614598,
0.0181489307,
-0.0370802768,
-0.0098406132,
0.0273179319,
0.0907051861,
0.0165421441,
0.0286556017,
-0.043987222,
0.0103999497,
0.0011060493,
-0.0074985283,
0.0090932343,
-6.38220111e-33,
-0.0531291068,
-0.0072581908,
0.0352509618,
-0.0097856158,
-0.0218434017,
0.0415756963,
-0.0158143118,
0.0042847898,
-0.0395687185,
0.0142555814,
-0.027825281,
0.0191217232,
0.0117034316,
0.0103374282,
-0.0458295047,
-0.0352551639,
0.0493715852,
-0.022579588,
-0.0490524955,
-0.0041295416,
0.0275251865,
0.0342715792,
0.0741854236,
-0.003710045,
0.0330237336,
-0.0022232949,
-0.0016423654,
0.052609574,
-0.0317049399,
0.0460612662,
-0.0420772955,
0.0371260941,
0.0189060103,
-0.0287445467,
-0.0183227323,
-0.0155695453,
-0.0847182125,
-0.066240415,
0.0531196669,
0.015900502,
-0.0001152558,
0.0234886203,
-0.0030384557,
-0.024451321,
0.0276930965,
0.0061652577,
0.0317045897,
0.0028105513,
-0.0143947909,
-0.0142736128,
-0.0137191731,
0.0082872417,
-0.0052118357,
-0.0323336311,
0.017796902,
-0.0111350305,
0.0120860273,
-0.0304975193,
-0.0872364268,
0.0184151344,
0.0386144258,
0.0305389911,
0.0527614765,
-0.0002274717,
0.027887024,
0.0690183342,
-0.021296097,
0.0357543975,
-0.0592992641,
0.0310333986,
0.0758406669,
0.0007884614,
-0.0046761218,
0.050358519,
-0.0013716735,
-0.0170474648,
-0.0546447337,
0.0220718496,
0.0380960666,
0.0112477066,
0.0011637352,
-0.0300724041,
-0.0013352687,
-0.0305790845,
-0.0739190504,
0.0229103249,
-0.0138012487,
-0.0039429814,
0.0118863834,
0.0070459819,
-0.0310526174,
-0.0291285813,
0.0137829687,
-0.0272839535,
-0.0081438944,
0.0168230981,
-0.0234574825,
-0.0082326941,
-0.0089199152,
0.0447600856,
-0.0923744142,
-0.011246453,
0.0084848804,
-0.026403375,
0.0045999889,
0.0098738289,
0.0223539826,
0.0397996269,
-0.015682729,
0.0083307931,
-0.0366495624,
0.0062514176,
0.0144854225,
0.0149620706,
0.027319828,
0.042412322,
-0.0126348659,
0.0184328053,
0.0432103425,
-0.0081614247,
-0.0423850827,
-0.0069025257,
0.006918224,
0.0415834375,
-0.0272014532,
-0.0186771192,
-0.0442504697,
-0.010400706,
0.0287611,
-0.0422265381,
0.0153595582,
0.0077000139,
2.463e-7,
0.0432298295,
0.0262176115,
0.0051456769,
0.0458310358,
0.0034355803,
0.0411192477,
-0.0410153754,
0.0183202773,
-0.0019512261,
-0.0601101071,
0.0246807225,
0.0277416557,
0.0350485481,
0.0155277476,
-0.0897131562,
-0.0269619599,
-0.0427751914,
-0.0311508812,
-0.0570782013,
-0.0336198844,
0.0119472407,
0.0893978626,
0.0566345118,
0.0029406582,
-0.0322138481,
-0.0329461321,
0.0390967615,
-0.014275521,
-0.0438906774,
0.0294706188,
0.0772531331,
0.0278896224,
-0.0152324121,
0.0365553796,
-0.0136435013,
0.0341048203,
-0.003358756,
0.0380310044,
0.0445827059,
-0.030150244,
-0.0457806699,
-0.0172735304,
-0.0295720845,
-0.0615641773,
0.1022436246,
-0.0425144732,
-0.0041469708,
-0.0212878454,
0.0061140116,
-0.0166024864,
0.0147508243,
0.0082218815,
-0.0276492499,
0.0288537722,
0.0082195206,
-0.0033820395,
-0.0191273633,
-0.0626126975,
-0.0193821639,
0.0208303947,
-0.0215951651,
-0.0653952062,
0.0120161632,
-0.0477085523,
0.023313392,
-0.0631825849,
0.0307466984,
2.219908913e-34,
0.0338095874,
-0.0056324592,
-0.0204116739,
-0.0172386244,
0.0410120934,
-0.0198270287,
-0.0166432448,
-0.02134436,
0.0021757644,
-0.0643317029,
0.01332667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16568v1 | 1-PAGER: One Pass Answer Generation and Evidence Retrieval | 2023-10-25T11:51:22 | 2023-10-25T11:51:22 | Palak Jain, Livio Baldini Soares, Tom Kwiatkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present 1-Pager the first system that answers a question and retrieves
evidence using a single Transformer-based model and decoding process. 1-Pager
incrementally partitions the retrieval corpus using constrained decoding to
select a document and answer string, and we show that this is competitive with
comparable retrieve-and-read alternatives according to both retrieval and
answer accuracy metrics. 1-Pager also outperforms the equivalent closed-book
question answering model, by grounding predictions in an evidence corpus. While
1-Pager is not yet on-par with more expensive systems that read many more
documents before generating an answer, we argue that it provides an important
step toward attributed generation by folding retrieval into the
sequence-to-sequence paradigm that is currently dominant in NLP. We also show
that the search paths used to partition the corpus are easy to read and
understand, paving a way forward for interpretable neural retrieval. | [
0.0305652767,
0.0636774674,
0.0061814529,
0.0125165656,
-0.0208534505,
-0.0040216693,
0.0278462432,
0.0078740176,
0.0011227789,
-0.0165836215,
0.032695733,
0.0004508554,
-0.027207071,
0.03218133,
0.0172084421,
-0.0010642286,
0.0312581621,
-0.0100692576,
0.0221633464,
0.0103454003,
0.0134702465,
0.0117951492,
0.017578721,
0.0460026525,
-0.0105989492,
-0.0421716198,
-0.0378466249,
-0.0269906707,
0.0021466226,
0.0061879111,
0.0079230573,
0.0466264039,
0.0298846085,
0.034685377,
0.0000017134,
-0.0194663741,
-0.0349157155,
0.0250326563,
-0.0646690577,
-0.0660668388,
0.0005759283,
0.0312498752,
0.0552998111,
0.0275051687,
-0.0653591454,
-0.0232541058,
0.0351085663,
0.0609902665,
0.0698849931,
0.0629503578,
0.0134535003,
-0.0735875368,
0.0677273571,
0.0031767436,
0.0667911321,
0.0067495434,
-0.0105850156,
-0.00258549,
0.0272658132,
0.0607020445,
-0.0094846282,
0.0591996424,
0.0660243109,
-0.0378371067,
0.0095032277,
0.0305513404,
0.0051626884,
-0.0162978694,
0.0078940587,
0.0432073064,
0.017136205,
-0.0636370853,
0.0063043777,
0.0005183899,
0.0178795066,
0.0268586874,
-0.0323072635,
0.0601938218,
-0.0474153832,
-0.0143372398,
0.0424712524,
0.0158614181,
-0.0035957273,
0.0065350337,
-0.0118481694,
0.0460952967,
-0.0004089865,
-0.0298766345,
-0.0152978059,
0.0347162932,
0.0179671161,
-0.0453845374,
0.0230085701,
0.0565654449,
-0.0154390717,
0.0058099367,
-0.0298982169,
-0.0404373258,
0.0332620181,
-0.0092091504,
0.0148944007,
0.0091696801,
-0.0115710283,
0.0410034843,
-0.0052132797,
0.0328794271,
-0.0116699822,
-0.0115921702,
-0.0807071179,
-0.0115266256,
-0.0259080268,
-0.0552066267,
-0.0522091277,
0.0568553843,
-0.034030579,
-0.0240843371,
0.0256168433,
0.0059989863,
0.0336744376,
-0.0001492784,
0.0478158481,
0.0439719893,
-0.0425230712,
0.0079572592,
-0.0005548017,
0.0292782672,
-0.0484069623,
0.0088420715,
0.0467119254,
-0.0500576086,
-0.0299201235,
0.0232760236,
0.0082617942,
-0.0181186274,
0.0125029525,
0.0409492515,
-0.038440574,
-0.0259794816,
0.0154846683,
-0.081764169,
-0.0002918572,
-0.0530419983,
0.0342199951,
-0.0545078479,
0.0504546277,
0.0444796011,
-0.0438553654,
-0.0158458892,
-0.0038868927,
0.0749755204,
-0.0290461294,
0.0310014114,
0.0148461172,
-0.010987157,
0.045240324,
-0.0011491124,
0.0025145931,
0.0234311931,
0.022572184,
0.0448010564,
0.0450238809,
0.0117949229,
0.0314396434,
-0.0267730746,
0.0465092808,
-0.0261013154,
0.0673974007,
0.0326645076,
-0.0131404744,
0.002362184,
-0.0020731271,
0.0430279933,
-0.0444270223,
-0.047029797,
0.0369240753,
0.0076125329,
0.0174393896,
0.0016791051,
0.0272281952,
0.0256966613,
0.0076141264,
0.0063773757,
-0.036401432,
0.040528778,
0.0231031403,
0.007042632,
0.0204802565,
0.0044116764,
-0.0319087803,
-0.0342384987,
0.0011835288,
0.0175367612,
-0.0018536309,
0.0272217151,
0.0028912572,
0.0445608608,
-0.0336100794,
0.0802627057,
-0.0001670747,
-0.0331015177,
0.0098382588,
-0.0522716865,
0.0469535664,
-0.0013101521,
0.0676587746,
-0.0182383358,
-0.0161893964,
-0.0278378632,
0.0389663801,
0.0436685607,
0.0194091313,
-0.0087958826,
-0.0031500871,
-0.0314141922,
-0.0024454482,
-0.0192911625,
0.0017700257,
-0.0059591234,
0.0260259826,
-0.0046181302,
0.0172046255,
-0.0445672013,
-0.0065893666,
0.0492380336,
-0.0415709987,
-0.0569543876,
0.0096480232,
-0.0171109792,
-0.0016092915,
0.0336391553,
-0.0138051296,
0.0298480019,
0.0387258753,
-0.0190332662,
-0.046003852,
0.0164422076,
-0.0498967469,
-0.0533322468,
-0.0039901007,
-0.0567606762,
-0.0147605855,
0.000322382,
-0.0336954743,
-0.0600532442,
-0.0433835275,
-0.0687044784,
-0.0011134329,
-0.0466471389,
-0.0139025636,
0.0549022108,
0.0024258744,
-0.0402730517,
0.0593271181,
0.005920229,
0.0337559246,
-0.0162766185,
-0.0063460246,
0.0219709054,
-0.0265599117,
-0.01063901,
-0.0162550211,
-0.021655431,
-0.0020521968,
0.0522790737,
0.0078375917,
-0.0238857325,
-0.048724927,
-0.0384914204,
0.0154197915,
-0.0056450129,
-0.0037286743,
0.0012807609,
0.0133714825,
0.0458318554,
-0.0233684983,
-0.0956158116,
0.0064380476,
0.0417641401,
0.0287107117,
0.028703399,
0.0221642535,
0.0140528753,
-0.019052757,
-0.0189974364,
-0.0027264291,
0.0446373932,
0.0383365192,
0.0307888705,
-0.0940841287,
-0.0347620584,
-0.0140345246,
0.0174715761,
-0.0090422723,
-0.0000580413,
0.0551557019,
-0.0578916073,
-0.0075905533,
0.0698586479,
0.0343247093,
0.0095402701,
-0.0119017726,
-0.0074409554,
-0.0902159736,
0.0186479017,
-0.0637937561,
-0.009073562,
0.0227512736,
-0.0203710217,
-0.0033545827,
0.0588288605,
0.0058352505,
-0.0072250403,
-0.0297564287,
0.0286592189,
0.0165069047,
-0.032756798,
-0.0251350589,
0.0025556746,
-0.0061374404,
0.0126697486,
-0.0092639215,
-0.0174726322,
0.0849713981,
-0.0101037724,
-0.0126997642,
-0.0416534618,
0.0158129372,
-0.029490944,
0.0641277283,
0.017814422,
0.0126773082,
0.0142969796,
-0.025928393,
-0.0281365123,
0.0053832168,
0.0365628786,
-0.0636894703,
0.0287151653,
-0.0240322333,
0.0140719265,
-0.023569813,
-0.0723317713,
-0.0592713282,
-0.0501748398,
0.0224008057,
0.0117163621,
-0.0108418642,
-0.0126530286,
-0.1047953665,
-0.0075307908,
0.0546543226,
0.0431534573,
-0.0371966623,
-0.0131482277,
-0.0189435165,
0.0667302459,
0.0685329437,
0.0149640003,
0.0226912759,
-0.0187156685,
0.0256135929,
0.0902109966,
0.003607149,
0.0127456207,
0.0069419909,
-0.016307598,
0.0307503249,
-0.0467659123,
0.0032403425,
-0.0087067764,
0.0333078876,
-0.0678863302,
-0.0585935153,
0.0795582905,
0.0435743816,
-0.0400785543,
-0.034894757,
-0.0480781645,
0.0084419185,
-0.0052844784,
0.0424058735,
-0.0810903758,
-0.0216182992,
-0.0044028615,
0.0457477458,
0.0154245384,
-0.0374587812,
0.0025955841,
-0.0795103908,
0.0416097492,
-0.0253650695,
-0.0186051745,
-0.0247909706,
-0.0695805773,
-0.0425928421,
-0.0091101006,
-0.0156355668,
0.0474388041,
0.0035780391,
0.0346207917,
-0.0077503212,
0.0303642079,
0.0500981919,
0.0240851417,
-0.0311211068,
-0.0040946379,
0.0346270092,
0.0071838754,
0.002556433,
-0.0426493399,
-0.059832979,
-0.0387994871,
-0.0045875171,
0.0015968502,
0.0639352277,
-0.0037370101,
0.0000966486,
-0.0445625,
0.0412417389,
-0.0444268286,
0.0009280017,
0.0187614337,
0.0423257016,
-0.0238944981,
-0.0182084013,
-0.039848689,
-0.0139060831,
0.0221491475,
0.0896775648,
0.0021776257,
-0.0338419937,
-0.0721670687,
-0.032114841,
0.0333075412,
-0.0582287647,
-0.03462933,
0.0001973398,
0.0334281884,
-0.0032411299,
-0.0877330899,
-0.0537745394,
-0.0169776846,
0.0308357161,
-0.025206754,
-0.0087749911,
0.0147505589,
-0.0287581198,
-0.066887252,
-0.0137909045,
-0.0150358779,
0.0009048358,
-0.0408744924,
0.0007292767,
0.0328484289,
-0.0363879725,
-0.0285278093,
0.0514166169,
-0.0271570161,
-0.0076488703,
0.0240712017,
0.0585010089,
0.0229708124,
0.0344959572,
-0.03738866,
-0.02171381,
0.0290837102,
0.0097322622,
-0.013201558,
-0.0040866318,
0.0279021859,
-0.0341340192,
-0.0178862624,
0.0229101032,
-0.0391540937,
0.0323269963,
-0.0013207701,
0.0297167525,
-0.0307111833,
-0.0320142917,
0.0292628519,
0.0203766041,
0.0325751752,
0.0078066657,
0.0238047857,
-0.0039443509,
0.0205175951,
-0.035011895,
0.0043517752,
-0.0278238077,
0.0321023613,
0.0102436058,
-0.0392099023,
0.0077161258,
0.0294122323,
-0.0030624897,
0.0464280248,
-0.018778285,
0.0020176659,
0.0051688459,
-0.0002383592,
-0.003846932,
-0.015896216,
-0.0480306037,
0.0023433564,
0.020208396,
0.0871343911,
-0.0099911001,
0.0662991181,
0.053644985,
0.0239357892,
0.0156664234,
0.0185887422,
-0.1049890593,
-0.0293738022,
-0.0342206657,
-0.0097484738,
-0.0085016601,
0.0185662862,
0.0357405879,
0.0035274818,
-0.0150774289,
-0.0081230383,
0.0320812501,
0.0326475203,
-0.0325847231,
0.0077378461,
0.0178468395,
-0.0103496714,
-0.0205265153,
0.092755869,
-0.0037868083,
0.0248210486,
-0.0124573177,
-0.0292836297,
-0.0466601104,
-0.0435484052,
-0.028799979,
-0.0057132351,
0.0166327655,
-0.0155195752,
-0.025524294,
-0.0365943648,
-0.001886463,
0.0369420648,
0.0169161949,
0.0087468205,
0.0247658547,
0.0628584698,
0.0238164607,
-0.0760126337,
-0.064940311,
0.0737618282,
-0.0487493165,
-0.0317109153,
-0.0119535346,
-5.872555984e-33,
-0.0139083173,
0.0038959982,
0.0321222991,
0.0125858709,
-0.0020334919,
-0.0191484746,
-0.0543890446,
-0.0104604745,
-0.0462345816,
0.0175177846,
-0.0353255197,
0.0145473927,
0.0084727136,
0.0431382693,
0.0218414236,
-0.0195617098,
0.0380794369,
-0.0088616721,
-0.0439144149,
0.0507260486,
0.0871094242,
0.0115897674,
0.0140434625,
-0.0335363597,
0.0081437556,
-0.0391898528,
0.019632509,
0.0304246433,
-0.0440272205,
0.0431647785,
-0.0078154849,
0.0271334555,
0.0273119826,
-0.0890885219,
0.004943518,
0.0324970931,
-0.1401445121,
-0.0578757226,
-0.0026925949,
-0.0001780833,
-0.0162438694,
-0.0249259546,
0.0198353063,
-0.0268332511,
0.0319825038,
-0.0309448093,
0.0215706788,
0.0029745372,
-0.00543404,
-0.0582589395,
-0.0133065358,
-0.0012560021,
0.0226408429,
-0.0116244182,
-0.0205200016,
0.0626352057,
0.0190835986,
-0.0015846775,
-0.0737818703,
0.0099996086,
0.0047783037,
0.0333313383,
0.0087896734,
0.0054600998,
-0.0326400697,
0.0376024507,
0.0383978225,
-0.0558189377,
-0.0453903601,
0.0182748139,
-0.040455386,
0.0307835713,
0.0845874101,
0.028881833,
0.0341577493,
0.0211290922,
-0.0418442376,
0.0469712541,
0.0317086652,
0.0581432916,
0.027058227,
-0.025165353,
-0.0465371534,
-0.0223915,
-0.0385564044,
0.0105630709,
-0.0332809724,
-0.0167330652,
0.0398723632,
0.038526427,
-0.0541998185,
0.0243292563,
0.0754464492,
-0.033910729,
0.0077728406,
0.0664108694,
-0.0039069783,
-0.0144023467,
-0.0195415616,
0.0198748615,
-0.0607948303,
0.0033422727,
0.0475787185,
0.0013918404,
-0.0269519035,
0.0501900502,
0.0371917002,
0.006997054,
-0.0404544622,
0.0095361117,
-0.005552744,
0.0293120965,
0.0007005951,
0.0024255489,
0.0444878265,
0.0385027751,
-0.0196609665,
0.0093304077,
-0.0040140124,
0.0160067882,
-0.050871823,
-0.0287061408,
0.0275996588,
-0.0022871909,
-0.0230575819,
0.0245286021,
-0.0394339338,
0.0195907857,
-0.0198243521,
-0.0720313936,
0.0126719959,
0.076021567,
2.44e-7,
0.0499312058,
-0.0032695585,
0.0397723131,
0.0312048923,
0.0006679608,
0.0084033972,
0.0585720874,
0.0261437148,
0.0223354399,
-0.050475236,
-0.0405701585,
0.0281442795,
0.0441813879,
0.0280608032,
-0.0951856673,
-0.0254435856,
-0.0466537513,
-0.0059378822,
-0.0185489357,
-0.0218595937,
0.078863889,
0.0743763745,
-0.0038991205,
-0.00683052,
-0.000541464,
-0.0203533582,
0.0356801935,
0.0337440148,
0.0160358176,
-0.0028972242,
0.0989395678,
-0.0198042896,
0.0104614021,
0.006484298,
-0.0143675618,
0.0090534342,
-0.0096012577,
0.0323393345,
0.0156920217,
-0.0494275913,
-0.0404008739,
-0.0587600805,
0.0346226282,
-0.0724557787,
0.0662879199,
-0.0592838936,
-0.0031304632,
-0.0047488241,
-0.0655921996,
-0.0059650312,
-0.0433558561,
0.0035817383,
-0.0152432779,
0.0251899324,
0.0094965221,
0.0063905679,
0.0255329777,
-0.0732755736,
-0.038800437,
-0.0153792696,
-0.0629692972,
-0.0095508173,
-0.0333498418,
-0.0260903426,
-0.0023648753,
-0.0648175701,
-0.0216427613,
2.099972215e-34,
0.0332631469,
0.0069959504,
0.0044401968,
0.0245493222,
0.0270337425,
0.008859315,
0.0332495123,
0.00406776,
0.0189163275,
-0.1170084327,
-0.0508655682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18366v1 | A Multilingual Virtual Guide for Self-Attachment Technique | 2023-10-25T10:50:18 | 2023-10-25T10:50:18 | Alicia Jiayun Law, Ruoyu Hu, Lisa Alazraki, Anandha Gopalan, Neophytos Polydorou, Abbas Edalat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this work, we propose a computational framework that leverages existing
out-of-language data to create a conversational agent for the delivery of
Self-Attachment Technique (SAT) in Mandarin. Our framework does not require
large-scale human translations, yet it achieves a comparable performance whilst
also maintaining safety and reliability. We propose two different methods of
augmenting available response data through empathetic rewriting. We evaluate
our chatbot against a previous, English-only SAT chatbot through non-clinical
human trials (N=42), each lasting five days, and quantitatively show that we
are able to attain a comparable level of performance to the English SAT
chatbot. We provide qualitative analysis on the limitations of our study and
suggestions with the aim of guiding future improvements. | [
0.0814258009,
0.0397291332,
-0.0208603144,
-0.0537072793,
0.0078250095,
0.022050228,
0.0579430275,
-0.0052674054,
0.0919306651,
0.0278680325,
-0.0093694301,
-0.0215144027,
0.023914149,
0.0245231595,
0.0306962375,
-0.0687111616,
0.0076344172,
0.047599826,
-0.0049205893,
-0.0173595939,
0.036595054,
0.0079245036,
-0.0366174132,
0.030480992,
-0.0187047124,
-0.0365645252,
-0.0083755078,
0.0521873608,
0.0310624894,
-0.0590250045,
-0.0084864041,
0.0231146943,
0.006843416,
-0.0006222907,
0.0000025412,
-0.024216745,
-0.0232102759,
-0.0048628231,
-0.0113850357,
-0.0550186373,
0.0997091532,
-0.0567607321,
-0.0161590707,
0.0194369536,
-0.0019935244,
0.009022586,
0.047772903,
0.021972362,
0.0670021102,
0.0552301221,
-0.0371424332,
0.0531429723,
-0.0049100188,
-0.0022408194,
0.0078912033,
-0.0161588173,
-0.0154585624,
0.0513329431,
0.0279398449,
-0.038498193,
-0.0605395101,
0.0250005964,
0.0173537489,
-0.0060484335,
0.0208584089,
0.017977694,
-0.0401492566,
-0.0800334811,
-0.0398698412,
0.0480219312,
0.0410637595,
0.0359081216,
-0.0152379228,
-0.0011772396,
0.0407699943,
0.0138119329,
-0.0108409049,
-0.0186685696,
0.0226460304,
-0.0146285808,
0.0087442044,
0.0021380347,
-0.039876502,
-0.0224196427,
0.0115100928,
-0.0476963706,
-0.0085343095,
0.0206682533,
0.0346154906,
-0.003500635,
0.0376119539,
-0.058649566,
0.0422829054,
0.0380763449,
-0.0245485492,
-0.0009070281,
-0.0586866774,
-0.0252099335,
-0.006597084,
-0.0596990101,
-0.0129071288,
0.0551640727,
-0.049393937,
-0.0088246288,
0.0013149603,
0.0232688524,
0.0256303456,
-0.0079923365,
-0.071913898,
0.05018555,
-0.0413816124,
0.0055384198,
-0.0167330019,
-0.0143645508,
-0.0102631692,
-0.0189229902,
-0.0793895125,
0.0214606188,
-0.0079647489,
-0.0299630463,
-0.0346357673,
0.0277776066,
-0.044510968,
-0.0071574231,
-0.0365478694,
0.0538888313,
-0.0469213985,
-0.0123020662,
0.0040827179,
-0.0724109635,
-0.0124677531,
0.0351768099,
-0.0128545938,
-0.0301798284,
0.0125278952,
0.0465357304,
-0.0201120991,
-0.0079421382,
0.0478002578,
0.0020007598,
-0.0646763593,
-0.0623850264,
0.0232703239,
-0.039559558,
0.0184543543,
-0.0330632254,
0.014650139,
-0.085674651,
0.0279179141,
-0.0245463494,
-0.020623574,
0.0332928561,
-0.0210893471,
0.0234606266,
-0.0277687237,
0.004103967,
-0.0079953205,
0.0012561331,
-0.0297538731,
0.0197129566,
0.0180960651,
-0.048986502,
0.0471844114,
-0.0338328145,
0.0059143794,
-0.0007348452,
-0.0215116832,
-0.0343618877,
0.0296825357,
0.0356644131,
-0.0102373436,
0.0290864389,
-0.0009954902,
0.0415566824,
0.0371348113,
0.0655436292,
-0.0196536928,
0.036402069,
-0.084299013,
0.0189175643,
-0.0063245189,
0.0056565264,
-0.0513702519,
0.0821231604,
0.0037529566,
0.0025408266,
0.0052773478,
0.0208272096,
-0.0368907973,
-0.0527327992,
-0.0108402902,
-0.0394231454,
0.0506396405,
0.0278281458,
0.0259265471,
-0.0067509622,
0.072989516,
-0.0231422372,
0.0266730729,
-0.0442252234,
-0.0532544516,
-0.0269092247,
-0.0298222229,
0.0747350603,
0.004471954,
-0.0047937664,
-0.0653602928,
-0.0018293149,
0.0511727855,
0.0344710834,
0.0143297901,
0.0397073627,
-0.0012178273,
0.0005444957,
-0.02005996,
0.0479771942,
-0.0271657724,
0.0292977057,
-0.0375325195,
0.078251116,
-0.0819158629,
0.0316348635,
0.0055230623,
0.0502743162,
-0.0768011063,
-0.0541630909,
0.047309313,
0.0018691203,
0.0055732755,
0.0424657762,
-0.0120687811,
-0.0104035959,
0.0255969539,
-0.0228958689,
-0.0048086685,
0.0678356141,
-0.010847888,
0.0005020974,
0.0245326106,
0.0007421474,
-0.0488527492,
-0.0189599432,
-0.0273422915,
-0.0398310274,
-0.0007855794,
-0.0065058717,
0.0452361219,
-0.0089183059,
0.0548418462,
-0.0081655597,
0.0586570092,
0.0113074789,
-0.0359492898,
0.0252291113,
-0.0316669121,
-0.0160746928,
-0.0303745531,
-0.006466541,
-0.0468545295,
-0.0510885343,
0.0089790393,
-0.0377225131,
0.0244884361,
-0.0089289537,
0.059542086,
-0.0603224672,
-0.0251933578,
-0.0826107338,
0.0261075888,
0.0159285553,
-0.0041153082,
-0.0045186938,
0.0032810713,
-0.0151403788,
-0.0209064297,
-0.0458129011,
0.0292750988,
-0.0029994147,
0.0043026512,
0.0044279955,
-0.0148265511,
-0.0029235811,
-0.0531337634,
0.0051363348,
-0.0136425514,
-0.0557222664,
-0.0005582161,
-0.0037853478,
-0.0052244603,
-0.0274479631,
-0.0466949306,
-0.005099942,
-0.0246215519,
-0.0952372253,
-0.0060537555,
-0.0020511174,
0.0096308365,
0.0789791495,
-0.0013548161,
0.0127912583,
0.0810232013,
0.0171074644,
-0.0502688512,
0.0049053207,
0.0091410214,
-0.0536450595,
0.0141418763,
-0.0489710681,
-0.0543420054,
0.0043844916,
-0.0308159459,
0.0105699552,
-0.0479865968,
-0.0060346378,
0.0086116493,
-0.0535710454,
0.0090214135,
0.0373611636,
-0.0087074302,
-0.0238908585,
0.0326674208,
-0.0373344533,
0.0654122904,
0.0405279174,
-0.0175464042,
-0.0143905682,
-0.0248203985,
0.0320343785,
0.0866005793,
-0.039435897,
0.0237237345,
0.0488640107,
0.0124441301,
-0.0041249692,
-0.0099328887,
-0.0395709164,
-0.0105103236,
-0.0646626875,
-0.0396376699,
-0.0244721733,
0.0092396522,
-0.0115951365,
-0.0337843411,
0.0026560258,
-0.0273040552,
-0.0678125843,
-0.0208950415,
0.010845053,
-0.013992968,
0.003658493,
0.0533448793,
0.0074364115,
-0.0127004012,
-0.0120505057,
0.0181797668,
-0.0807189122,
0.01919071,
0.0395345986,
0.0277111642,
0.0087993303,
0.0717364997,
0.065281637,
0.0194718074,
0.0177584849,
0.048543714,
0.0005790647,
-0.0142623987,
0.0198843144,
-0.0071312212,
0.018821191,
0.0462398157,
-0.0061439173,
-0.0076680952,
0.0805089548,
0.0063227345,
-0.0298295971,
0.0002286793,
-0.0671268255,
-0.020188652,
-0.009382505,
-0.0000668116,
-0.0510446019,
-0.0010692255,
-0.0042493744,
0.0166391842,
0.0009904505,
0.0201302543,
0.0332869105,
-0.0296814423,
0.0518838726,
0.0099522397,
-0.052361425,
-0.0207363926,
-0.0303573161,
0.0189673286,
-0.0149969207,
-0.0085378513,
-0.0237450376,
-0.0151225142,
-0.0186672937,
-0.0130504603,
-0.0524160489,
0.0128336661,
0.0054685576,
-0.0377659947,
0.0709941089,
0.0015347155,
0.0861312598,
0.0306850579,
-0.0069932104,
-0.0101148989,
0.0761267394,
0.0046413727,
0.0075040832,
0.0665087998,
0.0083111571,
0.0359333456,
-0.0116431303,
0.0563051254,
-0.057787884,
0.0040601646,
0.0389090143,
0.0202658046,
0.0107883839,
0.0018716293,
-0.0067504286,
0.0285306629,
0.0025408459,
0.0300772805,
-0.0211775471,
-0.0596200787,
-0.0108533027,
0.0028632784,
0.0309244487,
0.0583565012,
-0.0444436967,
0.0166909043,
-0.0632965341,
-0.0569428839,
-0.1090821102,
-0.0664832145,
0.0121606579,
0.0456009284,
0.0271269791,
0.0310777202,
0.0218357015,
0.0426800959,
0.0196512975,
0.0287901349,
0.0053171339,
0.0210158601,
0.0062672445,
0.0138822496,
-0.0182050299,
-0.0404578149,
0.0356658846,
-0.0006295101,
0.0914329067,
0.002797795,
0.0218913481,
0.0469491519,
0.018922545,
0.003959036,
-0.0080306875,
0.0340594053,
-0.0039483085,
0.0386775546,
-0.0422466695,
0.002848584,
0.0330280885,
0.0230154768,
0.0004585635,
0.0028681783,
0.0020712649,
0.003980034,
-0.0059429524,
0.0150625352,
0.0140958475,
-0.0289827213,
0.0411707312,
0.053348843,
-0.0011726534,
-0.020029828,
0.0440268181,
-0.0019355438,
0.0133037185,
-0.059274409,
0.0060552037,
-0.054671254,
-0.0215025023,
0.0053003212,
0.0186340138,
0.0298156254,
-0.0521629453,
-0.0449191518,
-0.0526585132,
0.0067596612,
-0.0018261633,
-0.01102331,
0.011825053,
-0.0072456109,
0.0530449934,
0.0019470778,
-0.0220570322,
0.0016622206,
0.038114842,
-0.0320349075,
0.0558827333,
0.0097171254,
-0.0372774005,
0.0289942827,
0.0525510795,
-0.0170002393,
-0.074242577,
-0.0162636377,
0.003589394,
0.0110699087,
0.000660461,
0.0398608111,
-0.0091205966,
-0.0089935241,
-0.0189221725,
0.0116417492,
-0.0246610325,
-0.0220565703,
-0.0576995164,
-0.0205766018,
-0.0128942262,
-0.008822917,
0.010862872,
-0.0984873325,
0.0257112253,
-0.0043058265,
-0.0140900835,
-0.0361273251,
-0.0140853934,
0.0232464746,
-0.0257651154,
-0.0249389522,
-0.020170724,
-0.0308911614,
-0.0904492363,
-0.0181136094,
0.012049634,
-0.0474582203,
-0.045268096,
0.0303238258,
-0.0187802576,
0.0021575834,
-0.0244835876,
-0.0361239463,
0.0190688912,
-0.0279624835,
0.0041079493,
0.0273216683,
-6.278975074e-33,
0.0047204224,
0.0208710823,
-0.0218988154,
0.0187130515,
-0.0049690921,
-0.027198242,
-0.0618292578,
0.0673851892,
0.0170776192,
0.0162065439,
-0.0135111259,
0.004228245,
0.0154948905,
-0.000193647,
0.0429223143,
0.0559067763,
-0.0041701603,
-0.002567966,
-0.0218985528,
0.0188601017,
0.0105458032,
0.0347377099,
0.0320449062,
-0.0795976445,
0.039692767,
0.0213946216,
0.0056732921,
0.0052432101,
0.0655038208,
0.0076658227,
-0.0206875298,
-0.010295989,
0.0172939766,
0.0267917961,
0.0070865527,
0.0328131542,
-0.073264122,
-0.0265142508,
-0.0737758949,
-0.0299779493,
-0.0871382058,
0.010606138,
0.0063281539,
-0.0189079251,
0.0086109415,
0.001746723,
0.0157325435,
-0.0246694684,
0.0134397475,
0.0795365423,
-0.0187924244,
-0.0053909668,
-0.0303528011,
-0.0695430636,
0.0204829834,
0.0914592966,
-0.0748435855,
-0.0401245169,
0.0044647022,
-0.0025206849,
-0.0255225468,
-0.020770561,
-0.0066885925,
-0.0720604286,
0.0324373432,
0.0091903182,
0.0626680106,
-0.0322755836,
-0.0344073549,
0.0107852621,
0.0552064702,
0.0075925766,
0.0622844547,
0.0472533926,
-0.0232377499,
-0.0409635827,
-0.0174306873,
0.0391582102,
0.0030739813,
0.0285074152,
0.0007049346,
0.0659464747,
-0.0264911074,
0.0177978557,
-0.0096102441,
-0.0092443265,
0.0073502529,
-0.0935360789,
0.0154739451,
-0.0025797128,
-0.0458372869,
-0.0944568217,
0.0247588847,
-0.0203668438,
0.0396987721,
-0.0834860057,
0.0203645043,
0.0424089208,
0.0323196799,
-0.0191297475,
-0.0248006638,
0.0293781627,
0.012599281,
-0.0040976941,
0.0782120302,
-0.007652563,
-0.0277956352,
0.0210611876,
-0.0373798087,
0.0115370518,
-0.0011460265,
0.0248890109,
0.0427538306,
0.0042190501,
-0.0148513755,
0.015422307,
-0.0076635373,
0.046906054,
0.0349171609,
0.0329735875,
-0.109026961,
0.0092860237,
-0.0147820571,
-0.0267791431,
-0.0444231629,
0.0209167078,
-0.0482258312,
0.0292930044,
0.0597224571,
-0.0508863218,
-0.0159564205,
-0.0381801799,
3.204e-7,
-0.0602322891,
0.0361175165,
0.0342388302,
-0.0001188432,
0.0140115088,
0.0320801027,
-0.0127693554,
0.0581883863,
0.012748871,
-0.0446331613,
0.0411236547,
0.0353621505,
0.0697846934,
0.0006908072,
-0.0287281089,
0.0263084657,
-0.0154113676,
-0.0080741532,
0.0179503839,
0.013605278,
0.0183692686,
0.0503573231,
-0.0027479485,
-0.0197483469,
0.0315595493,
0.027168544,
0.0098548066,
-0.0598163679,
0.0040814681,
0.0221338999,
-0.0090138344,
0.0239748731,
-0.0225019939,
-0.0079072826,
0.0002341677,
-0.0315778777,
0.021773845,
0.0689280629,
-0.0460437126,
-0.0256024823,
0.030738594,
0.0807832479,
0.0073715756,
-0.0131958937,
0.0316314176,
-0.0868317485,
-0.0363803543,
0.0079047075,
-0.0029263643,
-0.003183075,
0.1262769848,
-0.0065463269,
-0.033507634,
0.053117808,
0.0028290227,
0.0531656556,
0.0099122236,
-0.0163426585,
0.0062525896,
-0.0054490822,
-0.0117304102,
-0.0328066833,
0.0264769439,
-0.0105116935,
-0.0586992204,
-0.0345580876,
-0.0056082634,
2.008552274e-34,
-0.0006502984,
-0.0010098595,
-2.811e-7,
-0.0104862554,
0.0715278685,
0.0050416552,
0.0179664791,
0.0202425905,
0.0381361432,
-0.0389684699,
-0.0498483144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16538v1 | FedTherapist: Mental Health Monitoring with User-Generated Linguistic Expressions on Smartphones via Federated Learning | 2023-10-25T10:35:09 | 2023-10-25T10:35:09 | Jaemin Shin, Hyungjun Yoon, Seungjoo Lee, Sungjoon Park, Yunxin Liu, Jinho D. Choi, Sung-Ju Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Psychiatrists diagnose mental disorders via the linguistic use of patients.
Still, due to data privacy, existing passive mental health monitoring systems
use alternative features such as activity, app usage, and location via mobile
devices. We propose FedTherapist, a mobile mental health monitoring system that
utilizes continuous speech and keyboard input in a privacy-preserving way via
federated learning. We explore multiple model designs by comparing their
performance and overhead for FedTherapist to overcome the complex nature of
on-device language model training on smartphones. We further propose a
Context-Aware Language Learning (CALL) methodology to effectively utilize
smartphones' large and noisy text for mental health signal sensing. Our
IRB-approved evaluation of the prediction of self-reported depression, stress,
anxiety, and mood from 46 participants shows higher accuracy of FedTherapist
compared with the performance with non-language features, achieving 0.15 AUROC
improvement and 8.21% MAE reduction. | [
0.0359457619,
0.0543291308,
-0.0341798961,
-0.0246948134,
-0.010879796,
-0.0023374425,
0.0717825666,
-0.0106924986,
0.0934935287,
-0.0420603082,
-0.0103689693,
-0.0071236142,
0.0144389309,
-0.0161014665,
-0.0157959964,
-0.0075991191,
0.0120929014,
0.0076151509,
0.018334873,
0.009128727,
0.0143719316,
0.0201649517,
-0.0235120524,
0.041787412,
-0.0510679968,
-0.0486242175,
-0.00071531,
0.0030389456,
0.0094868485,
-0.0854454264,
0.014003153,
0.0418774411,
-0.0324379243,
0.0369719565,
0.0000019261,
0.0101630976,
-0.0121427886,
0.0204450283,
0.0116272205,
-0.0323292203,
0.0551636443,
-0.0272616334,
0.0270670988,
0.0292980466,
-0.0563897006,
-0.0672472715,
0.0036927133,
0.0540241189,
0.0485688373,
0.0517614558,
-0.0270871725,
0.0182213709,
0.0003740249,
-0.0060938061,
-0.046869766,
-0.0030264384,
0.0069821393,
-0.0327977799,
0.0324918628,
-0.0375844426,
0.0200522635,
0.0185390878,
-0.0077511761,
0.0603743233,
-0.0287227724,
-0.0253551882,
-0.0326013714,
-0.0234413873,
-0.0401391499,
0.0767445937,
0.0218797531,
0.027340766,
0.0120414346,
-0.0113899391,
0.0010481661,
-0.0013962388,
-0.0075983214,
-0.0285002999,
-0.0319136642,
0.0375495888,
0.0150767341,
0.0064453054,
0.0361369699,
-0.0271175355,
0.0187489949,
0.0549645387,
-0.0330047086,
-0.016368812,
-0.0170486532,
0.0021535684,
-0.0203054324,
-0.0521702915,
0.055876065,
0.0055524735,
-0.0617873333,
0.0022608056,
-0.0570142269,
-0.1210103482,
0.0102845412,
-0.0157526545,
-0.0431385562,
0.0079758614,
-0.0236009676,
-0.0250467025,
0.0339785628,
-0.021350652,
0.0365708917,
0.0016586051,
-0.0117420154,
0.0224658139,
-0.0537557416,
0.0255827606,
-0.0124204624,
0.0350209288,
-0.0088216616,
-0.0465943329,
-0.0759988651,
0.0144069977,
-0.0100143366,
-0.0111506125,
-0.0175254196,
0.0163848717,
0.0297071449,
0.0222791452,
0.0443087034,
-0.0070444411,
0.0020896476,
0.0247863159,
0.0071919048,
-0.0550096445,
0.0342772491,
-0.0449625663,
0.0069799824,
-0.0129921688,
0.0016471908,
0.0272202622,
0.0498893522,
-0.0419342443,
-0.0551002175,
-0.0347835496,
-0.0348373242,
-0.0248193834,
-0.0101064211,
-0.0468286015,
0.0047435053,
-0.0036404259,
0.0155746453,
-0.0443668887,
0.0495831259,
-0.0105796028,
-0.0552479513,
0.0528441258,
-0.0424424075,
-0.0280219968,
0.0101956092,
0.020604888,
0.022195695,
0.0822540149,
0.0203013849,
0.0029701071,
0.0483860001,
-0.0205129031,
-0.0156169105,
0.0076047811,
0.0429211557,
-0.0381284095,
0.0104476325,
-0.0322826542,
-0.0591383204,
0.0152151482,
-0.0575546101,
0.0296033341,
0.0191017147,
0.0629772469,
0.0580497943,
0.1202311069,
0.0502594449,
0.0064008166,
-0.0837556869,
0.0157356001,
-0.0122220647,
-0.0355793238,
-0.0371673107,
-0.0270876829,
-0.0753046945,
-0.0210858956,
-0.0141516645,
0.0241572969,
-0.0273675881,
-0.0682426766,
-0.062778376,
-0.0821720213,
-0.0087762354,
0.0429148413,
-0.0167171694,
-0.0158539079,
0.0596311167,
0.0583499707,
0.0377487056,
-0.014630164,
-0.0568500087,
-0.0298783761,
0.0313782394,
0.0952708721,
0.0074146735,
-0.0470879972,
-0.0125059858,
-0.0225064829,
0.0276769157,
-0.0040280353,
-0.0133277383,
0.0166500323,
0.0852042213,
-0.011702179,
-0.0222821087,
0.0510426499,
0.0362646133,
-0.0579074882,
-0.0286455508,
0.0752706677,
-0.0195900183,
-0.0208362397,
-0.0218109246,
0.0345825888,
0.0157186482,
-0.0471816882,
0.0721205398,
0.0280248858,
0.0314475074,
0.0340605974,
0.0188825931,
0.0128681799,
0.003028597,
-0.0481327474,
-0.0112532414,
0.0181640089,
-0.0084255077,
-0.034050338,
0.0173460934,
0.0129112201,
0.0251406115,
0.0499249995,
-0.0345917493,
-0.0057223327,
-0.0069683138,
-0.041981332,
0.0781875327,
0.008685424,
-0.010040924,
0.0073207789,
0.0571718067,
-0.0055808863,
-0.0117135849,
-0.0398578905,
-0.0038939416,
-0.0173889585,
-0.0432989933,
-0.0131207556,
0.0175205227,
0.008331052,
-0.0196203738,
-0.0022536733,
0.0291754566,
-0.0236277189,
0.0293786861,
-0.0129271615,
0.0018709281,
-0.1008667871,
0.0198601149,
-0.0352725983,
-0.0129920375,
0.0149802063,
0.0611250065,
-0.0128093371,
-0.0619121045,
-0.0226807799,
0.0213910248,
0.0089507718,
0.0504788794,
-0.0222973321,
-0.0181905832,
-0.0078557013,
-0.0191669464,
-0.0055015236,
-0.0364414714,
0.02585111,
-0.021360049,
-0.0241089109,
-0.0109476326,
-0.0458796844,
-0.0191002358,
0.0125060743,
0.0202612393,
0.0013083098,
0.0056253672,
-0.0034196258,
-0.0140198665,
0.0310577899,
0.0007849361,
0.0356423333,
0.0183133706,
-0.0039707748,
-0.0169997811,
-0.0015245902,
-0.0017868496,
-0.0149475429,
-0.0011776426,
-0.0211861748,
0.0071147173,
0.0334606692,
0.0203570146,
0.0189819653,
0.0013542213,
0.0177866537,
-0.0240299944,
-0.0481743291,
-0.0221231915,
0.063282229,
-0.0053922138,
0.0327350236,
0.0091791889,
-0.0567493327,
0.0226253849,
0.021287689,
0.019849889,
-0.0644436106,
-0.0539362468,
-0.0093319975,
0.0318680666,
-0.0396837518,
0.0345835909,
0.0611558892,
-0.0527791455,
0.0589459501,
-0.0179801509,
-0.0288693607,
-0.0720727369,
-0.0081106722,
-0.0480872244,
-0.0266416352,
0.0504947752,
-0.0530364104,
-0.0327686407,
-0.0456234701,
-0.0867278799,
-0.017002264,
-0.0459970646,
0.005024692,
-0.0050500203,
-0.0051303809,
-0.0220309645,
0.0221344549,
0.0178798474,
-0.0251023397,
0.0285040028,
0.0239280257,
0.0393351056,
-0.0105862301,
0.0182878263,
0.0137251057,
0.0195394531,
0.0529325828,
0.0138927307,
0.0539468825,
0.0329230614,
-0.0053310404,
-0.0130871255,
0.0052236724,
-0.0408364758,
0.0368887447,
0.0446239896,
-0.0259997547,
0.0073267375,
0.1073434129,
0.0222461428,
-0.0467349105,
0.0390715636,
-0.0264232159,
0.00520571,
-0.0272377003,
-0.0029463375,
-0.0468012765,
-0.0528223626,
-0.0170355476,
0.0753409564,
-0.0015170897,
-0.0066217156,
-0.009017759,
-0.0201595966,
-0.010087762,
0.0263518225,
0.0047833705,
0.0168296695,
-0.036254175,
0.0320409499,
0.0028090894,
0.0011836963,
-0.0762481466,
0.007634514,
-0.0147697562,
-0.0110833067,
-0.137416929,
-0.0603148043,
0.0307934638,
0.0110370005,
0.0247607883,
0.0200657416,
0.0352665707,
0.0109852925,
-0.0601397529,
-0.0305145495,
0.0548634045,
0.0251303241,
-0.0440212935,
0.0436778776,
0.0131702377,
0.0123381438,
-0.0372413285,
0.0894089043,
-0.0646948218,
-0.0073942319,
0.0341316909,
0.0546852387,
0.0135148736,
-0.005183226,
-0.029972624,
-0.0000268532,
0.0939518884,
0.0088031236,
0.001051486,
-0.0822179317,
-0.0311867464,
0.0351360328,
0.0310035832,
0.0159327984,
-0.011231035,
0.0242233202,
0.0072952476,
-0.0844535604,
-0.0512884445,
-0.0377876945,
0.0207652058,
0.0206688996,
0.016812522,
0.0287044477,
0.0746691376,
0.0094361575,
-0.0568670183,
0.0363633633,
0.0389563069,
0.0493950769,
-0.0419315696,
-0.0085704308,
-0.0014807044,
0.0089179287,
0.0207990855,
0.0371049382,
-0.072754398,
-0.0470582284,
0.052666083,
0.0104209445,
0.0101795048,
0.0178672951,
-0.0306923874,
-0.0097134756,
0.0280414168,
0.0525922701,
-0.0958905816,
0.0343936123,
0.0514627807,
-0.0118522681,
-0.0171130318,
0.0331837945,
0.0092948563,
0.0254624411,
0.0419488363,
-0.0017732952,
-0.0329370983,
-0.027188981,
0.0118974447,
0.0243626777,
0.0913822278,
-0.0055281441,
-0.0149277961,
0.0129413577,
0.0121089332,
-0.0096426178,
0.0083755078,
-0.0187182855,
-0.0235319324,
-0.0232235007,
-0.00425296,
-0.019459065,
-0.0344156064,
-0.0174381901,
-0.0593483783,
-0.0096449871,
0.0271599367,
-0.0088806348,
0.0136549771,
0.0199594069,
-0.0087959114,
-0.0184181575,
0.0514146462,
-0.0086921966,
0.0351389386,
-0.0182599984,
0.0631270632,
-0.03938777,
-0.0037859904,
-0.0113610281,
0.061941091,
-0.0449482203,
-0.0810833797,
0.0015581616,
0.0028504361,
-0.0058613429,
0.0071385959,
0.0431147888,
-0.0040674214,
0.0056432053,
-0.035839431,
0.0408707112,
-0.0488817655,
0.0036176599,
-0.009647524,
-0.0209981035,
-0.0184304211,
0.0058684349,
0.0442804992,
-0.016932806,
0.0079648457,
0.0146684926,
-0.0246329959,
-0.0623036958,
0.0175097175,
0.0307788998,
0.0449927785,
-0.0484987162,
0.0271822084,
-0.0281007811,
-0.0757746845,
0.0520038344,
-0.0424195826,
-0.012036847,
-0.0448368117,
0.0349182859,
0.0049997726,
0.0110669807,
-0.000100684,
-0.0544734299,
0.0152794635,
-0.027700441,
-0.0330221206,
-0.0358370021,
-5.270295861e-33,
-0.0101958029,
0.0045898412,
-0.0230058562,
0.0253615957,
0.0080660759,
0.0499309227,
0.0022753668,
0.0593398511,
0.0272036325,
-0.0181023702,
-0.0053385384,
0.0422825068,
0.0101337153,
0.0466325618,
0.01734896,
0.016314229,
0.0291008521,
-0.0225962121,
-0.0057896753,
0.0165958591,
0.0392563045,
0.0817452446,
0.0462035574,
-0.1017824486,
-0.0088562435,
0.0449880473,
0.0024433504,
-0.0273902118,
0.017483687,
0.0040537608,
-0.0363235809,
0.0567434728,
0.0218771864,
0.041742228,
0.0021535093,
0.0295346212,
-0.0661087409,
-0.0479250476,
-0.0302670747,
0.0408972576,
-0.0511166826,
-0.0069146464,
0.0442196801,
-0.0210001338,
-0.0131170312,
-0.0170254782,
0.0410976708,
-0.0231302753,
-0.0260226,
-0.0154513158,
0.0284261573,
0.0004749214,
-0.005481238,
0.0015888767,
-0.0262195691,
0.0412417725,
-0.0604167171,
-0.0351283439,
-0.0446246415,
-0.0025037825,
-0.0114092808,
-0.0027201083,
-0.0041742115,
0.0035960078,
0.0206151064,
0.0756073147,
0.0686480403,
-0.0381822139,
-0.0377308913,
0.036384102,
-0.0094136298,
0.0363485292,
0.0271424167,
0.0130930729,
0.0247214362,
-0.0625741631,
-0.0442228802,
-0.0127630206,
0.0501986779,
-0.0409772433,
0.0282026175,
0.0135038393,
-0.0231286213,
-0.0135335848,
-0.0064134044,
0.0444525592,
-0.0201646462,
-0.0255983416,
0.032122016,
0.0104998406,
-0.018510377,
-0.0470793657,
-0.0147124045,
-0.0257093906,
-0.0240255743,
-0.032119602,
0.0846508741,
0.0192345306,
-0.0042600012,
-0.0026458781,
-0.0303725991,
0.0223272108,
-0.0240948927,
0.0463414043,
0.0759939775,
-0.0119387675,
0.042802617,
0.0202389304,
-0.040622659,
-0.0310402159,
0.0187366046,
0.0470257476,
0.0008478388,
0.0491944999,
0.0354229584,
-0.015883524,
-0.0129466709,
0.0566542782,
-0.0187272597,
0.0107001318,
-0.0694791898,
-0.0206899643,
0.0355086029,
0.0038551777,
-0.0124856671,
-0.0529038608,
-0.0503913462,
-0.0020089298,
0.0703664422,
-0.0417335108,
0.0111198798,
-0.0284966957,
2.658e-7,
0.0025259657,
0.0129776178,
-0.0583087541,
-0.0307822675,
0.0232367404,
0.0357689373,
0.0094215544,
0.0441368446,
0.0162235871,
0.0037894761,
-0.0348188356,
-0.010335655,
0.068140395,
0.0569544733,
-0.000738515,
-0.0324314348,
-0.0107784551,
0.0659316778,
-0.0430723839,
0.0209526978,
0.0553011969,
0.0574617572,
0.0299379174,
-0.0559212789,
0.0188487601,
0.0001601626,
0.0179443713,
-0.0209829919,
0.0074251741,
-0.0195269343,
0.0301531889,
0.044784449,
0.0319548994,
-0.0294403862,
-0.0200036,
-0.0126188714,
-0.0367827825,
0.0464856699,
-0.0462080985,
0.0036706056,
-0.0109113157,
0.0085513983,
-0.023696024,
0.0399541259,
0.0744424909,
-0.0558041595,
-0.0404745378,
-0.0407569148,
0.0344513319,
-0.0545690469,
0.0310118161,
0.0057723043,
-0.0261936616,
0.032222718,
0.0290520117,
0.0176076759,
0.0120713115,
-0.0633803084,
-0.0361570902,
0.0055116299,
-0.0031022602,
-0.0093068052,
-0.0193095319,
0.0465725474,
-0.036324814,
-0.0569010116,
0.0259147845,
2.095470668e-34,
-0.0051324624,
0.0209632833,
0.0123816775,
0.0202542916,
-0.0000808496,
-0.006169687,
0.0485544018,
0.0009238369,
0.0322603397,
-0.0419218019,
-0.0187378805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16535v1 | R$^3$ Prompting: Review, Rephrase and Resolve for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Large Language Models under Noisy Context | 2023-10-25T10:34:02 | 2023-10-25T10:34:02 | Qingyuan Tian, Hanlun Zhu, Lei Wang, Yang Li, Yunshi Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the help of Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting, Large Language Models
(LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance on various reasoning tasks.
However, most of them have been evaluated under noise-free context and the
dilemma for LLMs to produce inaccurate results under the noisy context has not
been fully investigated. Existing studies utilize trigger sentences to
encourage LLMs to concentrate on the relevant information but the trigger has
limited effect on final answer prediction. Inspired by interactive CoT method,
where intermediate reasoning steps are promoted by multiple rounds of
interaction between users and LLMs, we propose a novel prompting method, namely
R$^3$ prompting, for CoT reasoning under noisy context. Specifically, R$^3$
prompting interacts with LLMs to perform key sentence extraction, variable
declaration and answer prediction, which corresponds to a thought process of
reviewing, rephrasing and resolving. The responses generated at the last
interaction will perform as hints to guide toward the responses of the next
interaction. Our experiments show that R$^3$ prompting significantly
outperforms existing CoT prompting methods on five reasoning tasks under noisy
context. With GPT-3.5-turbo, we observe 3.7% accuracy improvement on average on
the reasoning tasks under noisy context compared to the most competitive
prompting baseline. More analyses and ablation studies show the robustness and
generalization of R$^3$ prompting method in solving reasoning tasks in LLMs
under noisy context. | [
0.0537453257,
-0.0084577156,
-0.0109156389,
0.0261062104,
-0.0541384928,
0.0216932446,
0.0144762276,
-0.0063794255,
-0.0016698038,
-0.0360884368,
-0.0249516964,
-0.0292248782,
0.0135317016,
0.0015073126,
-0.0019199706,
-0.0609748736,
0.0548839308,
-0.0845871344,
0.0308468603,
-0.0090197884,
-0.0020636308,
0.007752419,
-0.017374035,
0.0388549715,
-0.0035516876,
-0.0362352245,
-0.0614322796,
-0.0151243787,
0.0059467298,
-0.0528071746,
-0.0070090988,
0.1045616567,
0.0194021072,
0.0396464393,
0.000002251,
-0.0506119803,
-0.0154193984,
-0.0074029849,
-0.053950727,
-0.0166601539,
-0.0124670202,
0.0482059941,
0.0470358543,
0.0294718258,
-0.0449796394,
0.0104262037,
0.0147608751,
0.0497268848,
0.0494743586,
0.0124139087,
0.0036607489,
-0.0100968126,
-0.0118511179,
-0.0146500766,
0.0370452665,
-0.0503721833,
0.0126925921,
0.0189302284,
0.0424520001,
0.0387041643,
-0.0073467917,
0.0327087194,
0.0457180515,
-0.0132773845,
-0.0112436442,
0.0347201712,
-0.0190819763,
-0.028624814,
-0.0401084274,
0.069864288,
0.0283576064,
0.0063847955,
-0.00642242,
0.0132701267,
0.0107954647,
0.0092570204,
-0.0335194729,
0.0064934306,
-0.0331112407,
-0.0159105603,
-0.0229695309,
0.0163759496,
-0.0031450675,
0.0073459009,
-0.0047619012,
0.063042827,
0.0019937619,
-0.0658480749,
0.0149007048,
0.0198194329,
0.0047753057,
-0.0736331418,
0.0012880277,
0.0360418819,
-0.0779981539,
0.0239331853,
-0.0071085081,
-0.0033084727,
0.000304492,
0.0047054891,
-0.0052202493,
0.049593199,
-0.0133563383,
0.0541854091,
-0.0404443145,
0.0419853888,
-0.0095700426,
-0.0118674645,
-0.024338996,
0.018204838,
-0.0642009005,
-0.013692908,
-0.0499060154,
0.071105659,
-0.0549185611,
-0.0168949477,
-0.022120757,
0.0449987538,
0.0367664769,
0.0110722054,
-0.0007049483,
0.011116703,
0.0106190844,
-0.0097682187,
-0.0721584335,
0.035265442,
-0.058263205,
0.0235255305,
0.0515856035,
-0.0391007401,
-0.011728134,
-0.02035865,
0.0126373274,
-0.0264629554,
0.0111397766,
0.0410051346,
-0.0317210034,
-0.0146619026,
-0.0133973369,
-0.0448597446,
-0.0063989903,
-0.0693762153,
-0.0201502442,
-0.0677479878,
0.0194733553,
0.0311249215,
-0.0429024063,
0.024220489,
0.0446230136,
0.0477748737,
-0.0223293304,
0.0552245155,
-0.0200688131,
0.018211849,
-0.0114785898,
0.0197516549,
-0.0493033901,
0.0309368297,
0.0183126032,
0.0312579945,
0.0051699094,
0.0028361373,
0.0223256163,
0.0079688728,
0.0021467807,
0.0026747314,
0.038305521,
0.0286733452,
-0.0103242956,
0.0434424169,
-0.0210276973,
0.0539473519,
-0.0333166979,
0.0248228312,
0.0673240051,
0.0505516715,
-0.0198722277,
0.0189540461,
0.0297418386,
-0.0056946119,
0.0144890808,
0.0307145249,
-0.0629712194,
0.0373091809,
-0.0665610135,
0.0367395803,
0.0267240331,
0.0123271439,
-0.0226169918,
-0.0432305411,
-0.0016336406,
0.0572812371,
0.0028974474,
0.0589215681,
0.0225493778,
-0.0052084951,
-0.0408879668,
0.0139382528,
0.0092121623,
-0.0248591024,
-0.0275763366,
-0.0679551214,
0.057948377,
0.0674500614,
0.0320874304,
-0.0040287585,
-0.0467576981,
-0.0371860899,
0.0429919511,
0.0431123115,
0.0071764733,
0.0127722826,
-0.0205311365,
-0.0297792722,
-0.0370727926,
0.0104153436,
-0.0181478038,
0.0177564919,
0.0345423706,
-0.0002543735,
0.0019027976,
0.0071891537,
0.0510049798,
0.002200909,
0.0180384982,
-0.0135233989,
-0.0153578036,
0.0098266955,
-0.0020707669,
0.0012043153,
0.0005769806,
0.0134234149,
0.0062476811,
-0.0222233329,
-0.0158421211,
0.0079860343,
-0.0682237893,
-0.0668274462,
0.0144221652,
0.0316740721,
-0.0495991372,
-0.0326913036,
-0.0193867981,
-0.0315851718,
-0.013461112,
0.0069266409,
0.0174835008,
-0.0278604757,
0.02111651,
0.031065857,
-0.0271637775,
-0.0460273586,
0.0995471403,
-0.0121699926,
0.0253933631,
0.066087909,
0.0090391804,
0.0059127212,
-0.0324805602,
-0.0164890923,
-0.0029624682,
0.0109645417,
-0.0149679994,
0.0280719697,
0.0412432998,
-0.0718069822,
-0.0417596772,
-0.0760238543,
-0.0040788804,
-0.0160372406,
0.0195248127,
-0.0022866502,
0.0161856711,
-0.0153095759,
-0.0190202817,
-0.0595714748,
0.0039938521,
0.0024906814,
0.0320774578,
0.0211690906,
0.0028614514,
-0.0140723484,
-0.0107278209,
-0.0091475388,
-0.0165112037,
0.0432471484,
0.0144101903,
-0.045914907,
-0.0734928325,
0.0432176664,
-0.0410097763,
0.0198072419,
-0.0118176825,
0.0101961223,
0.0362889208,
-0.031808082,
0.0991313681,
0.0546443276,
-0.0053199553,
-0.0299274847,
0.0431591645,
-0.0051908917,
-0.0436391458,
0.0377484225,
-0.0115526114,
-0.0276097097,
0.0122575443,
-0.0230485797,
-0.0002957978,
0.0357263125,
0.0200995915,
0.0154838413,
-0.0451696441,
-0.0089000408,
0.0096189221,
-0.0105890278,
-0.0912145823,
-0.029779613,
-0.0151484134,
0.0837806314,
-0.0225052424,
-0.0111239888,
0.1095246971,
-0.0159338433,
-0.0158065837,
-0.0471158549,
0.0056912024,
-0.0109978979,
0.0791113302,
-0.0384497009,
-0.0014130553,
-0.002408772,
-0.0310322978,
-0.0667849779,
-0.0403120331,
-0.0001206052,
-0.050214801,
0.0466515012,
-0.0372529775,
0.0056607802,
0.0010312939,
-0.0635794997,
-0.0564582422,
-0.0326522551,
-0.0435430445,
-0.0028192494,
-0.0131184608,
0.0068958197,
0.0367317572,
0.0157499202,
0.0728618205,
0.040123634,
-0.0304445345,
-0.0272439476,
-0.0312011335,
0.0551848859,
0.0641019568,
0.0131684486,
0.0206844918,
-0.0349371247,
0.0819720179,
0.0546326935,
0.0525870509,
-0.0038125359,
-0.0149144335,
0.0013752014,
0.0163064022,
0.0043984787,
-0.0055916235,
0.0337584764,
0.0488640182,
-0.0624562129,
-0.0079566576,
0.1096481532,
0.0293557458,
-0.0714597553,
-0.0243694521,
-0.0668449104,
0.0510255322,
0.0200670883,
0.0465538912,
-0.0887075812,
-0.0410206392,
0.0281116441,
-0.0304579623,
-0.0033921942,
-0.0440033674,
0.013288863,
-0.1257964969,
0.0177480429,
-0.0383647382,
-0.0056785434,
-0.0143840024,
-0.0047979364,
0.0200347789,
0.0776415691,
0.0139282662,
0.0522190556,
-0.0036891992,
-0.0019496571,
0.0087166261,
0.005484411,
-0.0034514526,
0.0385420769,
-0.0230207853,
0.0006864336,
0.0447481684,
-0.0161849037,
0.0277747903,
-0.0468124747,
0.0469171591,
0.0016917768,
0.0340424106,
-0.0333704464,
0.0020084721,
0.0098621473,
0.0033598356,
-0.0632122234,
0.0263581146,
0.0092591438,
-0.0185886305,
0.0573734455,
0.0927476585,
-0.0307889115,
-0.0099589955,
-0.0026711591,
0.0355125964,
0.0013665454,
0.0641257763,
0.0392123237,
-0.046788007,
-0.0326315574,
-0.0139609016,
-0.036519099,
0.0025412878,
-0.0230377372,
0.0095318565,
0.0263749436,
0.0263209119,
-0.0405494012,
-0.037134219,
0.0717135072,
0.0529487878,
0.0063300226,
0.060966,
-0.0078790337,
0.0375144631,
0.0108159743,
0.0169621967,
-0.0248759314,
0.0152527727,
-0.0351694897,
0.0389718339,
-0.0161460992,
-0.0438940711,
-0.008415415,
0.0192832798,
-0.0788213536,
-0.0346513763,
-0.0560978651,
0.0440498255,
0.0297882948,
0.0178759843,
-0.0045216563,
-0.0271592643,
0.0054874853,
0.0118954508,
-0.0237752777,
0.0040170099,
-0.0081952605,
0.0647814199,
-0.0022235431,
0.0312031936,
-0.0433126204,
-0.0184537601,
-0.0141940126,
0.0631154776,
-0.0467723943,
-0.0235633776,
0.0418844484,
0.0204461962,
0.0400003754,
-0.0044611795,
-0.0026197932,
-0.0213278159,
0.0389156602,
-0.0276961233,
-0.0251672063,
-0.0383039452,
0.0200616885,
-0.0157618243,
-0.0294205528,
0.0291187521,
-0.0538159758,
-0.0049821492,
-0.0016263394,
-0.0212506689,
-0.0165274534,
-0.0058216704,
0.0506361164,
0.0659063533,
-0.0025303119,
-0.030998569,
-0.0014131977,
0.0176680256,
0.0310569368,
-0.0002811355,
0.1112768427,
0.0466964468,
-0.0478979982,
-0.0260875076,
0.0261345878,
-0.0738737509,
-0.0537775718,
0.0419801325,
0.0315157212,
0.0095631713,
0.0504287332,
-0.006454058,
-0.0422011279,
-0.0139937922,
0.0220866185,
0.0397593528,
0.0296255182,
-0.0358467698,
0.0429306515,
0.0293543413,
-0.0033051695,
-0.0047022402,
0.033978153,
-0.048331257,
-0.0173109006,
0.0364580117,
-0.0258825254,
-0.0349243097,
-0.0115243206,
-0.0567909367,
0.0059616803,
-0.0066050626,
0.0216261055,
-0.0757769048,
-0.036499273,
-0.0301661137,
0.0059760357,
-0.0069824946,
-0.0482946821,
0.0390932783,
0.0567411706,
0.0188486166,
-0.0601558834,
-0.0179605056,
0.0351521075,
-0.0182217229,
-0.0455881804,
-0.0408411175,
-6.692945246e-33,
-0.0297143273,
-0.0430867262,
0.0437742434,
0.0127901426,
-0.0291764624,
0.0008174547,
-0.0538075082,
0.0424000546,
-0.0129947793,
0.0005187016,
-0.0433756299,
-0.0062474888,
0.0075293588,
-0.0045285062,
-0.0035872131,
-0.0481809862,
0.0354024321,
-0.0012374638,
-0.0132257948,
0.0097449971,
0.0259358548,
0.022624664,
0.0091233086,
-0.0378284827,
0.0318541341,
-0.0133376615,
-0.0077093174,
0.0452444367,
-0.0477005765,
0.0347504616,
-0.0219682064,
0.0214179978,
0.0194644015,
-0.0273445696,
-0.0041712481,
0.0575836077,
-0.0790407211,
-0.0310387202,
0.0521272011,
-0.0235144179,
-0.0790378228,
-0.0066333851,
0.0118030673,
-0.000587063,
0.0053649987,
-0.00956818,
-0.0009464613,
-0.0113015696,
-0.0471020602,
-0.018073475,
-0.0322762951,
0.0011527403,
-0.0013701333,
-0.0442594998,
0.0074238405,
0.0880745202,
-0.0264145918,
0.0058282949,
-0.0311300345,
-0.0102009717,
0.0311438795,
0.02613727,
0.0276504997,
0.0357158668,
0.009061343,
0.049109254,
0.0010036736,
-0.0059077386,
-0.0729497597,
-0.0060637216,
-0.0129913548,
0.0398122072,
0.0609235913,
0.0258481316,
0.0185247995,
0.0426593237,
-0.05444986,
-0.016215276,
0.0361183211,
0.027593486,
0.0522383861,
-0.0288437363,
-0.0362078473,
-0.022557715,
-0.0670601055,
0.0218596663,
-0.0714070648,
-0.0361949727,
0.0561519302,
0.0097295353,
0.015604673,
-0.0432716906,
0.0353172831,
0.0086770728,
0.0114937732,
0.0331153125,
-0.0118977707,
0.0463501029,
-0.0134569751,
0.023658419,
-0.0185380299,
0.0303593017,
-0.0105201397,
0.0072132354,
0.0128457481,
0.0147565715,
-0.0015249229,
-0.0090448717,
-0.0592219755,
-0.0021157069,
-0.0581743792,
0.0655782074,
0.0028802722,
-0.0396781228,
0.0447346903,
-0.0092943525,
-0.0174404904,
0.0484367199,
-0.009010883,
-0.0096027646,
-0.0237191264,
0.012051424,
-0.0028195579,
0.0079517849,
-0.0068587507,
-0.0018489648,
-0.0320825763,
0.0218058266,
0.0190222319,
-0.0423926227,
-0.0033775507,
0.0611556955,
2.954e-7,
-0.0181629956,
0.0413190089,
0.014715503,
0.0212432239,
-0.0101776682,
0.0284542385,
0.0084571233,
-0.0176648591,
0.0656122789,
-0.0510739051,
0.0017684955,
0.0340472683,
0.0421942323,
0.0299596339,
-0.12191993,
-0.0491825379,
-0.072624974,
-0.015867874,
-0.0452612117,
0.0027513281,
0.0897669122,
0.0419750251,
-0.0014389218,
-0.0014485399,
-0.0175813939,
-0.0296646506,
0.0218844693,
-0.0247117449,
-0.0081143053,
-0.0158214793,
0.024491502,
-0.0380000584,
0.0164899267,
0.0470156074,
0.0343802162,
-0.0018787801,
-0.0202433076,
0.0302012693,
0.0315734074,
-0.0148704378,
-0.01957714,
-0.0052462015,
0.0040930542,
-0.0567305945,
0.0788680837,
-0.0297352783,
0.0019585683,
0.0061305575,
0.0120820794,
-0.0650895387,
-0.0130661549,
-0.0042833593,
-0.0067227171,
0.0123979039,
-0.0016937983,
-0.0027564776,
-0.0038571935,
-0.0566263534,
-0.0180115178,
0.023984367,
-0.0246380866,
-0.0379733853,
-0.0567603186,
-0.0095432298,
0.0091694258,
-0.0518248789,
-0.0100648282,
2.760874857e-34,
0.0395722762,
-0.0265960358,
0.059596654,
0.0546502583,
0.0455359444,
0.0123986453,
-0.011521888,
0.0030460651,
0.0579777397,
-0.1147596315,
-0.0318018906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16534v1 | An Early Evaluation of GPT-4V(ision) | 2023-10-25T10:33:17 | 2023-10-25T10:33:17 | Yang Wu, Shilong Wang, Hao Yang, Tian Zheng, Hongbo Zhang, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we evaluate different abilities of GPT-4V including visual
understanding, language understanding, visual puzzle solving, and understanding
of other modalities such as depth, thermal, video, and audio. To estimate
GPT-4V's performance, we manually construct 656 test instances and carefully
evaluate the results of GPT-4V. The highlights of our findings are as follows:
(1) GPT-4V exhibits impressive performance on English visual-centric benchmarks
but fails to recognize simple Chinese texts in the images; (2) GPT-4V shows
inconsistent refusal behavior when answering questions related to sensitive
traits such as gender, race, and age; (3) GPT-4V obtains worse results than
GPT-4 (API) on language understanding tasks including general language
understanding benchmarks and visual commonsense knowledge evaluation
benchmarks; (4) Few-shot prompting can improve GPT-4V's performance on both
visual understanding and language understanding; (5) GPT-4V struggles to find
the nuances between two similar images and solve the easy math picture puzzles;
(6) GPT-4V shows non-trivial performance on the tasks of similar modalities to
image, such as video and thermal. Our experimental results reveal the ability
and limitations of GPT-4V and we hope our paper can provide some insights into
the application and research of GPT-4V. | [
-0.0054635154,
0.0301905312,
-0.0377402976,
0.0707995072,
-0.0432642177,
0.0194039121,
0.0479699783,
0.0312655047,
0.0201484635,
-0.0304436125,
-0.008970269,
-0.0066294558,
0.0013783184,
0.0030201052,
-0.0051518325,
-0.0612020493,
0.0552246906,
0.0231422782,
0.0160265211,
-0.0313990302,
-0.0102273989,
-0.0148025649,
-0.0193511825,
0.0274410099,
-0.0275814626,
-0.0248697326,
-0.0244236402,
-0.0286025032,
0.0550613627,
-0.0452275164,
-0.0118805571,
0.0554770753,
0.0157667976,
0.0454693437,
0.0000020131,
-0.0319387726,
0.0238755923,
-0.0056333626,
0.0164977666,
-0.0189936385,
-0.0023589255,
-0.0128803803,
0.0143425679,
0.0090469224,
-0.0830290541,
-0.0376434959,
0.0665570721,
0.0697498769,
0.0184185691,
0.0465535931,
-0.0143483495,
0.0052773785,
0.0166061632,
-0.0028130861,
0.0566652194,
-0.0876442418,
-0.0276885778,
-0.0140593983,
0.0059260046,
0.00803906,
-0.0379481129,
0.0178859737,
0.0724547282,
0.0334053822,
-0.0397439972,
0.0718767941,
-0.0730827078,
-0.0091760298,
-0.0374821834,
0.0736710206,
0.0375826284,
0.001873166,
-0.0466788597,
0.0180851407,
0.0114744687,
0.0178152006,
-0.0439154319,
-0.0131307365,
-0.0152410353,
-0.0252251048,
-0.0605420955,
-0.00070973,
-0.0209088102,
0.0032538245,
0.0233986489,
0.0509532019,
0.0193591695,
-0.0068494608,
0.0276119784,
0.0067934664,
-0.0276155882,
-0.0326972678,
0.0063749482,
0.021609107,
-0.0198012125,
0.0003528653,
-0.0308475103,
-0.0013514291,
-0.0096276868,
-0.0163644198,
0.0085896924,
0.0625474155,
-0.0472539216,
0.0365702994,
-0.0076851458,
0.1033100039,
-0.012647002,
0.0080199251,
-0.02884431,
0.0003005987,
-0.0881608054,
-0.0217075348,
-0.0474735238,
0.0088754874,
-0.0261245817,
-0.0375649668,
-0.0222141389,
-0.015592007,
-0.0165846236,
0.0205760654,
-0.0210007094,
0.0323618613,
-0.02972533,
0.0217806064,
-0.0570848212,
0.0498303585,
-0.0620809533,
0.004268859,
-0.0076337247,
-0.0504399464,
-0.0038582738,
0.0039864727,
0.0223833136,
-0.0504256189,
0.0132011948,
0.027443951,
-0.0348382965,
-0.0357062109,
-0.001477354,
0.0135748973,
0.0259633046,
-0.0934357941,
0.0529563874,
-0.0352999568,
0.0059224879,
0.0090685403,
-0.0115533685,
0.017347835,
0.0019455447,
0.0268020108,
0.0215545166,
0.0964350626,
0.0252044667,
-0.0245176926,
0.0092096962,
0.0369443335,
-0.013617726,
0.0526509732,
-0.005461188,
0.0053181639,
0.016045358,
-0.0371434689,
0.0360246673,
0.02116061,
-0.0099034449,
0.0132216811,
-0.0055640689,
0.0211091116,
-0.0038668085,
0.0276441127,
0.0239559337,
0.0458772779,
-0.000637622,
-0.0259813536,
0.0957331806,
0.0727104247,
-0.0363519415,
0.0028955394,
-0.0268250126,
-0.0115804141,
0.0189752132,
0.0374479294,
-0.0987609625,
0.0778080001,
-0.055020567,
-0.0082388371,
-0.0423066281,
0.0186765436,
-0.0212182179,
-0.0151612414,
-0.0077321185,
0.0373660177,
0.0597400852,
0.0506275147,
0.0314987153,
-0.0520455353,
-0.0071163243,
-0.0188056547,
-0.0320349224,
-0.0375921279,
-0.0402467661,
-0.0704547614,
0.0547618866,
0.023232406,
0.0154678551,
0.0035661082,
-0.0220081639,
0.0178080015,
0.0066793612,
0.0403461345,
0.0708852261,
0.0341638327,
0.0169172231,
-0.0407913104,
-0.0342343561,
-0.0140124774,
-0.0204948876,
0.0386461355,
0.0341356657,
0.042105183,
0.021152053,
-0.0316444747,
0.0520029366,
0.0097490149,
0.0502218194,
-0.0258933902,
-0.017026728,
0.0219035316,
0.0450228713,
0.0136410203,
0.0175616462,
-0.0371936634,
0.0104059931,
0.0079367524,
0.0210855547,
0.0227724742,
-0.0498860069,
-0.0179710537,
0.038571775,
-0.0882627666,
-0.0362621695,
0.0839401707,
-0.0259062629,
-0.0265264194,
0.0354319178,
-0.0213519055,
-0.0187702607,
-0.0637080669,
-0.0326870009,
0.0029049434,
0.0072148303,
0.0104017984,
0.1060165316,
0.0026988906,
0.0047374419,
-0.0433937497,
-0.0115185631,
0.0349208415,
-0.0750486478,
-0.0153055442,
0.004992771,
0.0049031614,
0.0111158872,
0.0013604263,
0.0391790271,
-0.0575170703,
0.0333362743,
-0.0994156152,
0.0262707453,
-0.0167459771,
-0.0044499245,
-0.0057296809,
0.0025339695,
-0.0093697868,
-0.0327876136,
-0.0681606978,
0.0450894535,
0.0091408566,
0.0402927026,
-0.009268296,
0.016122764,
0.0197309069,
0.0132399937,
-0.0105384644,
-0.0237624552,
-0.0171689503,
0.0237947572,
0.0299006328,
-0.0144292684,
0.0066396422,
-0.0276488997,
0.0370447785,
-0.0116229877,
-0.0634200275,
0.0457708426,
-0.0130426977,
-0.0036127728,
0.0803620592,
0.0117999883,
0.0162096657,
0.0104038808,
-0.0073490865,
-0.0152265253,
0.0518177561,
-0.0020231674,
-0.0077929567,
0.0244418252,
-0.0023216892,
-0.0537520647,
-0.0221308731,
0.0183217395,
-0.0003731414,
-0.0924468115,
0.0542137213,
-0.0102607096,
-0.0489271991,
-0.0478959382,
0.0284614358,
-0.0173371509,
0.0254129432,
-0.0408010595,
-0.0534639545,
0.0424467288,
-0.0201639552,
-0.0142247221,
-0.0531730689,
0.0165117234,
-0.0028639522,
0.0878894404,
0.009121133,
0.0209899396,
0.0043205777,
-0.0437539555,
-0.0631047115,
-0.0088396613,
0.0121498713,
-0.0208097138,
0.0764545798,
-0.0466703586,
0.0136178266,
-0.0523117445,
-0.0439312607,
-0.0246354975,
0.0188846923,
-0.0155090457,
-0.0002927817,
-0.0181546938,
-0.0306104179,
-0.0079775872,
0.0166405085,
0.0367798954,
0.0136428289,
-0.0312094837,
-0.0065204944,
-0.0133582,
0.0059914538,
0.0403214507,
0.0828612521,
0.0171686895,
-0.0277656373,
0.0080555174,
0.051931221,
0.0238339193,
-0.0492063276,
-0.0426361002,
0.0600118861,
-0.0020703929,
0.0137801953,
-0.0330345146,
0.0137254409,
0.0775067732,
-0.0679887682,
0.0022651572,
0.0613154285,
0.0088796262,
-0.0563651808,
-0.0070029297,
0.0061543058,
-0.0247079413,
0.0226603299,
0.0113134282,
-0.0847928673,
-0.0331305824,
0.0035482019,
0.0184945315,
-0.0051333588,
-0.0188347585,
0.0045406595,
-0.0943766907,
0.0560903586,
-0.0057368218,
-0.0826185346,
-0.0547405072,
0.0192921124,
0.0077021136,
0.00869771,
0.0463233143,
-0.0269456264,
0.0193648431,
0.0053880452,
-0.0225099064,
0.0217352491,
-0.0178149715,
0.0726930201,
-0.0074490281,
-0.0220308807,
0.0588840134,
0.0155115454,
-0.0380613543,
-0.1004150063,
-0.0087775113,
-0.0240498185,
0.0192572791,
-0.0361163206,
0.0581338145,
0.0109800398,
-0.0107948901,
-0.043299593,
0.0552047379,
0.0054439972,
-0.0111853033,
0.028959699,
0.0390475616,
-0.0257277116,
-0.0288544241,
-0.0201839972,
-0.0126554156,
0.0081013665,
0.0569550432,
0.014174439,
0.0280359685,
-0.0676037148,
0.0034789881,
0.0170816202,
-0.0529963039,
-0.0294525363,
0.010910999,
0.0577727817,
-0.014312611,
-0.0409161076,
-0.0439401232,
0.0293372907,
0.0564076751,
0.0023882315,
-0.0331259258,
-0.0389800146,
0.0754130557,
-0.0354897231,
0.0662052482,
0.0199813172,
0.0126595581,
-0.0450942628,
-0.017587157,
-0.0099930195,
-0.070719108,
-0.0193877798,
0.0134086097,
0.0155425342,
-0.0282385256,
-0.0105814869,
0.0563894212,
0.034324728,
0.0125009213,
-0.0059039784,
-0.0099211633,
0.0028382181,
0.0100400057,
-0.0197242033,
0.0105309868,
0.0092525901,
-0.0084566176,
-0.0139454864,
0.0127052804,
-0.0002566565,
0.0324776769,
-0.0198550075,
0.0148219243,
-0.0052366378,
0.0048261262,
0.0213987529,
0.0334229134,
0.0428126082,
0.0081956871,
0.0260555074,
-0.007875761,
0.0057622422,
0.0049727224,
0.0271007717,
-0.0375909656,
-0.0341256186,
0.0102469353,
-0.0059877788,
-0.0002251715,
-0.0160464309,
0.0162318014,
-0.0164088085,
-0.0503036231,
0.0118840029,
0.020255968,
-0.0101737399,
-0.0122646689,
-0.001313301,
0.0049573318,
-0.0196520369,
0.0116824536,
0.0681219101,
0.0208940376,
0.1039969549,
0.0179979857,
-0.0333106779,
0.0042751771,
0.0334640518,
-0.0531203151,
-0.0350832045,
0.0123501411,
0.0286885891,
0.0365953185,
0.0055946494,
-0.035909459,
-0.0336133204,
0.0054966304,
-0.0076461723,
-0.0119322361,
0.0526453517,
-0.0118869711,
0.0540388748,
0.0313912742,
0.0211365223,
-0.0526371859,
0.0390577391,
-0.0146890515,
0.0235626586,
0.0080166031,
-0.015702799,
-0.0515137613,
-0.0264871549,
0.0220681988,
0.0291611291,
-0.0118222404,
0.0347268693,
-0.0683322251,
-0.0350560918,
-0.0516473912,
0.0326322466,
-0.0082654618,
0.0170385763,
0.0455720127,
0.0553419329,
-0.0240643136,
-0.1238412857,
0.031396918,
-0.0167527776,
-0.0642778054,
0.0231821761,
0.0026377249,
-6.258176171e-33,
-0.0414400287,
-0.0286561958,
0.0353873111,
0.0149945496,
0.0070815329,
-0.0215460882,
-0.0346601121,
0.0148347002,
-0.0436737761,
0.0060807797,
-0.0193568747,
-0.0067002364,
0.0210071988,
0.0057965554,
0.0074498276,
-0.0457237773,
0.0162890945,
-0.0128694037,
-0.0482970737,
0.0124123013,
0.0282312334,
-0.0192583371,
0.0913374424,
-0.0569228828,
-0.0295318831,
0.0280798394,
-0.0109353652,
-0.005159948,
-0.0547252148,
0.0438045375,
-0.0237476416,
0.050552737,
0.0359602347,
-0.0069540921,
0.0151219582,
0.0418241024,
-0.0711704344,
-0.0469875075,
0.0185539126,
0.0360495746,
-0.0685183331,
-0.035249915,
-0.0001831271,
-0.043883536,
-0.0387259573,
-0.0394203886,
0.0405169018,
-0.0221916661,
0.0219069794,
0.012769524,
-0.0377335772,
-0.0040639988,
0.0096125947,
0.0024843379,
-0.004307196,
0.022968784,
-0.0086673461,
0.0073135709,
-0.0674122423,
0.0039466443,
0.0050843167,
-0.008077044,
0.0379405469,
0.0098548932,
0.0251929406,
0.0251905061,
0.0362334363,
-0.0704135224,
-0.0095121702,
-0.0629485622,
0.048520796,
0.0379589237,
0.0724456981,
0.052531451,
0.0551918447,
-0.0183387473,
-0.0316103026,
0.0292749796,
0.0174027383,
0.0649466366,
-0.0042602452,
-0.0176523272,
-0.053553924,
0.0190413576,
0.0031841213,
0.0191121493,
-0.0563979149,
-0.0548324808,
0.0733596608,
0.0052698287,
0.0197209232,
0.0093870573,
0.0627903938,
-0.0277895518,
0.0405028872,
-0.0003563132,
0.0179779883,
0.0227865744,
0.0355511494,
0.0023539637,
-0.0436049849,
0.00748125,
0.03619859,
0.0395501666,
0.0068165129,
-0.0064819441,
0.0101393927,
0.0398218744,
-0.0206384491,
-0.0104113966,
-0.0160041805,
0.0361812599,
0.0027285549,
-0.0138805816,
0.0176343899,
-0.0048525031,
-0.0053197043,
-0.0426621027,
-0.0164321661,
-0.0170950461,
-0.0769928694,
-0.0326068252,
-0.007027139,
0.0011150949,
-0.0115737235,
0.0097417152,
-0.0226618163,
-0.0312419813,
0.0007970841,
-0.0312570333,
-0.0025044521,
0.0802126601,
2.737e-7,
-0.0203269739,
0.027743347,
-0.0139677003,
0.0099007515,
-0.003139562,
0.0376783758,
-0.0373762026,
0.0078100995,
0.0119398339,
-0.0267007817,
0.0187026076,
0.050936684,
0.0367487594,
0.0344701409,
-0.0363516361,
0.0200030599,
0.0448495783,
0.0032694442,
-0.0525037088,
0.0335877165,
0.088577345,
0.0558956414,
0.0088952519,
0.0118382415,
0.0501663052,
-0.031229496,
0.0351104774,
-0.004537513,
0.0267956927,
-0.0583273955,
-0.0028135187,
0.0234634746,
0.0008741433,
0.0706568956,
-0.0010639917,
-0.0048473882,
0.0117909452,
0.0149497651,
-0.0326396301,
-0.0696284622,
-0.0408244729,
0.0165661369,
0.0129140522,
-0.0961644053,
0.1039674506,
0.003316056,
-0.0260594562,
0.0185970329,
-0.0580196828,
-0.0553011,
-0.0013129717,
0.0105362339,
-0.0217245072,
0.0080198413,
0.0000208422,
-0.0279935151,
-0.0219423827,
-0.0575150996,
0.035513822,
-0.0082218638,
-0.0390241072,
-0.0683993474,
-0.0474363156,
0.0009714065,
0.0387848653,
-0.0071836747,
-0.0602843687,
1.998943067e-34,
-0.0086427582,
-0.0038135045,
0.042502284,
-0.0150935594,
-0.0177883226,
0.0394087397,
-0.0147563284,
-0.0181137864,
0.0247139838,
-0.0370933339,
0.0080586616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16528v1 | CUNI Submission to MRL 2023 Shared Task on Multi-lingual Multi-task Information Retrieval | 2023-10-25T10:22:49 | 2023-10-25T10:22:49 | Jindřich Helcl, Jindřich Libovický | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Charles University system for the MRL~2023 Shared Task on
Multi-lingual Multi-task Information Retrieval. The goal of the shared task was
to develop systems for named entity recognition and question answering in
several under-represented languages. Our solutions to both subtasks rely on the
translate-test approach. We first translate the unlabeled examples into English
using a multilingual machine translation model. Then, we run inference on the
translated data using a strong task-specific model. Finally, we project the
labeled data back into the original language. To keep the inferred tags on the
correct positions in the original language, we propose a method based on
scoring the candidate positions using a label-sensitive translation model. In
both settings, we experiment with finetuning the classification models on the
translated data. However, due to a domain mismatch between the development data
and the shared task validation and test sets, the finetuned models could not
outperform our baselines. | [
0.041786205,
-0.0154216085,
0.0005168823,
0.0394263081,
-0.0118536642,
0.0372915566,
0.0237475578,
-0.0210219547,
0.0228236299,
-0.0293969084,
-0.0477496125,
-0.0512073785,
-0.0150056304,
-0.0380039811,
0.0212558247,
0.0063030589,
0.0236326773,
-0.000713019,
-0.0039051219,
-0.0038122244,
-0.0131822806,
0.0143213049,
0.0152961826,
0.0077472017,
0.0278279558,
-0.0075185527,
0.0182918236,
0.0184392296,
0.0356930643,
-0.0049321014,
0.0447346047,
0.0384316035,
-0.0010778231,
0.045970954,
0.000001668,
-0.0549539998,
-0.0498178191,
0.0007676724,
0.0215193555,
-0.0615000986,
0.0111423787,
-0.0219161287,
0.0187903475,
-0.0046466631,
-0.0311156474,
-0.0376099199,
0.0239887536,
0.0307563897,
0.0516119935,
0.065695703,
-0.0048543913,
-0.0036521554,
-0.0072072968,
-0.0364136398,
0.0238152128,
-0.0730405748,
0.0179403815,
0.0326028429,
0.0180041026,
0.0551677458,
0.0230933968,
0.0523953885,
0.0058390205,
0.0359178334,
-0.0148248579,
0.0036963986,
-0.0257940702,
-0.015339735,
0.024738308,
0.0345132612,
-0.0062050829,
-0.0361503437,
0.0147274286,
0.0136791607,
-0.0083138039,
-0.0290000495,
-0.0399952494,
0.0046234354,
-0.0303951371,
-0.0088752536,
0.0528346784,
0.0143228406,
0.0174463913,
0.0310230423,
-0.0005610742,
0.0693139434,
0.0223465171,
-0.0291968528,
0.0114105912,
0.0463786088,
-0.0386218242,
-0.0065212492,
0.028196834,
-0.0029241596,
-0.0074468087,
0.0185451563,
-0.0093243318,
-0.0816390067,
0.016756162,
-0.0698750913,
-0.0222197529,
0.0165581293,
-0.0185244493,
0.0770749301,
-0.0679122806,
0.0373183638,
-0.0023474493,
-0.0017423631,
-0.0613537692,
-0.0833159834,
-0.0517187417,
0.0022255525,
-0.040456254,
0.0307551194,
-0.0327228829,
0.0420824401,
-0.0237569176,
0.0147253852,
-0.006704655,
-0.0067283805,
0.0298592057,
-0.0113962404,
-0.0527790189,
0.0076393951,
-0.0333358459,
0.0532396585,
-0.0463047139,
-0.011617111,
-0.0214146171,
-0.0566853471,
-0.0166899282,
0.0078150136,
-0.0126815196,
-0.0821523517,
0.0254631545,
0.0416134708,
-0.0027047282,
-0.0306086745,
-0.0119043691,
0.0006414895,
-0.0130064543,
-0.0729320645,
0.0421778709,
-0.0678808838,
0.04219421,
0.0211265367,
0.0239118896,
-0.0375134274,
0.0160028692,
0.0169802886,
-0.0364790224,
0.0863702372,
0.0242258087,
-0.0251380615,
0.0366078578,
0.0144041153,
0.0095191579,
0.0913805887,
-0.0109468317,
-0.0018323491,
0.0825418979,
0.0207909513,
-0.0247032326,
0.0299842823,
0.0177735779,
0.0196452998,
0.0493767187,
0.0443560705,
0.0545395836,
-0.0138891144,
-0.0112401415,
-0.0217770822,
0.0251247082,
0.0166389439,
0.0063315732,
0.0100749638,
-0.0293724015,
-0.0117114205,
0.0248951036,
-0.0114355478,
-0.0312949754,
0.0136716729,
0.0022068247,
0.0285161603,
-0.0091615478,
0.0023117713,
0.0270730834,
0.0375628248,
-0.0551350899,
-0.0220548771,
-0.0004876494,
-0.0136186592,
0.0000834757,
0.0184053369,
0.0838256851,
0.0128406901,
-0.0396208949,
0.0554336943,
0.0168361068,
-0.0244288053,
0.0309543256,
-0.0225720201,
-0.020058604,
0.0174253955,
0.0016218794,
-0.0568726584,
-0.0424909405,
-0.0068944911,
0.0502952486,
0.0281663109,
0.0397704355,
-0.0320720561,
0.0260016043,
-0.0164759811,
-0.0179425441,
0.0270214248,
0.004132573,
0.0106136771,
0.011143486,
0.0316861495,
0.0345552601,
-0.0980799645,
-0.0358670913,
0.0144249639,
-0.0241989009,
-0.010819993,
0.0389410369,
0.0314787179,
0.0012557587,
0.0234951489,
0.0287491325,
0.0002711235,
0.0432598703,
-0.0403067768,
0.018640954,
-0.0240364075,
0.0075621312,
-0.0562961213,
0.0205654502,
-0.020897435,
-0.0283918511,
0.0312274769,
-0.0387669392,
-0.0572894588,
-0.02218448,
0.011259838,
-0.0297026448,
-0.0275961664,
0.0098987455,
0.0063417647,
-0.0164094623,
-0.0739427581,
0.0691497549,
0.0293650422,
0.1018234789,
0.0167158153,
-0.0584162995,
0.0419534668,
-0.0320561379,
-0.0661926046,
0.0259396099,
-0.023126753,
0.0016045118,
0.0589015856,
0.0254612286,
-0.0498213395,
0.0070125456,
-0.0950974822,
0.0337176733,
-0.0377513804,
0.0616263114,
0.0350767188,
0.0363226905,
-0.0021099579,
-0.0339414217,
-0.0385272913,
-0.0262438171,
0.0307723936,
0.020755006,
0.0310285687,
0.0278155785,
0.0237672012,
-0.0191302989,
-0.0112348972,
-0.0105173262,
0.0237542745,
0.001456023,
-0.0522819646,
-0.059770193,
0.0175857674,
-0.0492264554,
0.0342108831,
0.0185191203,
-0.0186843053,
-0.0142899649,
-0.0039713811,
0.0484785363,
0.0473924242,
-0.0334006362,
-0.0313634314,
0.005038165,
-0.0033930945,
-0.0539255142,
0.0365028828,
-0.0190733764,
-0.0106488857,
-0.0260955747,
-0.0332265943,
0.0187056996,
0.058002729,
-0.0248283725,
-0.0453088731,
-0.0479975902,
-0.0013133294,
-0.0381662324,
-0.0019975586,
-0.0153022269,
0.0819945186,
0.0257590916,
0.0384129174,
-0.0299117677,
-0.0076933843,
0.0823621452,
-0.0242435299,
-0.016523445,
-0.0869259238,
-0.0045941444,
-0.0292778872,
0.0630494654,
-0.0197912157,
0.0256588887,
0.0159947909,
-0.0161966421,
-0.0438351482,
0.0431317165,
0.0304687452,
-0.0244257487,
0.0116898688,
-0.0404918306,
0.0244648643,
-0.0265636742,
-0.0291495621,
-0.0199306607,
-0.0161980391,
-0.0120488983,
0.0233724806,
-0.0236132722,
0.0201631971,
-0.0288849622,
0.0250344351,
0.020512104,
-0.0001364511,
-0.0240813233,
-0.0010467122,
-0.0123688998,
0.0415027812,
0.0328816697,
-0.010844945,
-0.0188304428,
-0.0110422205,
-0.0036855743,
0.0126763163,
0.0316198952,
0.0029013269,
0.0140293781,
-0.0254056286,
0.0806155205,
-0.0404103063,
-0.0241842605,
-0.0269562341,
0.0631501675,
-0.0129938414,
-0.0418718867,
0.096509397,
0.0211873446,
-0.0214823075,
-0.0506825,
-0.02293179,
0.0153316911,
0.036250487,
0.0395030826,
-0.058403939,
-0.0222487133,
0.0005282393,
0.0173692405,
0.0197950695,
-0.0187248234,
0.0114590172,
-0.1197317168,
0.0034254969,
-0.0405173227,
-0.0549630411,
-0.0332472101,
-0.0406268425,
0.0058995634,
-0.0170552656,
-0.0306997653,
-0.0336233079,
0.0231093895,
0.021896638,
0.0152532738,
0.0356500298,
-0.0590540916,
0.0434117466,
-0.0565346256,
0.0034862962,
0.0539395101,
0.052973628,
-0.0138500854,
-0.0015348459,
0.0205284469,
-0.0567134842,
-0.0377339758,
-0.0142985201,
-0.0006227441,
-0.0109958136,
-0.0339003392,
0.0031520005,
-0.0183103364,
-0.0378046185,
0.0163667649,
0.0130571108,
0.1003826261,
-0.0057768277,
0.0290336683,
0.0239961855,
-0.0313063972,
0.0153384898,
0.0809057951,
-0.0068057361,
-0.027546363,
-0.0208001789,
0.0040379935,
0.0228134412,
-0.0469246805,
-0.0068572485,
0.0296842642,
-0.0672551468,
-0.014226024,
-0.0642484874,
-0.0767764673,
0.0607526526,
0.0359492637,
-0.010154577,
0.0254264157,
-0.0117417499,
0.0045754113,
-0.0537143424,
0.0347915739,
-0.0407081805,
0.0203684084,
-0.017247092,
-0.002316724,
0.04053431,
-0.0059949602,
-0.0261872578,
0.0230623111,
-0.1082962304,
-0.033517085,
-0.0534810871,
0.0413394533,
0.0114285108,
0.0148933111,
-0.0637507886,
-0.0185897443,
-0.0414204039,
-0.0211797319,
-0.0442553535,
-0.0238806475,
0.0467339568,
-0.0153079992,
-0.0384471714,
0.0621498227,
-0.0540425107,
0.0127538918,
0.0156584755,
0.0714824498,
0.0019471034,
-0.0694685504,
0.0294640884,
0.0299509931,
0.0578500405,
-0.0209965426,
-0.022824144,
-0.0332222618,
0.0160657894,
0.0268950779,
-0.0493364595,
-0.0062183645,
0.007689036,
0.0303097889,
-0.0204931479,
0.0065761437,
0.076425001,
-0.0004876151,
0.0319036767,
-0.0382254608,
0.0018226942,
0.017283529,
0.0255048294,
-0.0159283243,
0.0127516733,
-0.0178577751,
-0.0058711157,
0.0552819744,
0.0644614697,
-0.043806497,
0.0369447619,
0.0087650698,
0.0003998548,
0.0212524012,
0.0239965543,
-0.031125823,
0.0027464516,
-0.0278220084,
0.0264122467,
0.0828179568,
-0.0117734009,
0.0483076721,
0.0174412187,
-0.0347392485,
-0.0277564824,
-0.0035216145,
0.0086798491,
0.0013785789,
0.0188023839,
0.0110553745,
-0.0021524623,
0.0097336331,
0.089290306,
-0.0066057649,
0.0079223234,
0.0133424662,
-0.0370107442,
-0.0095023559,
-0.0140025597,
-0.0060883807,
-0.016764896,
-0.0149623398,
-0.0078640971,
0.0093197674,
-0.0623374358,
0.0109839914,
-0.0119168423,
-0.0429845043,
0.004045621,
0.0146427164,
0.0835542977,
0.0279192999,
-0.0219301041,
-0.0628629103,
-0.005230146,
-0.0046635708,
0.0024433252,
-0.0312655382,
-5.864227606e-33,
-0.02814674,
-0.0054680547,
-0.0075542438,
-0.0325545408,
0.0204151068,
0.0038971847,
-0.0119883176,
-0.0165028796,
-0.0355824567,
-0.0135139823,
0.0131632704,
-0.0018915036,
0.0363191403,
0.0309248641,
0.0039097001,
-0.0417651609,
0.0133942636,
0.022323994,
-0.0229753125,
0.0108847823,
0.0170867965,
0.044083979,
0.110073477,
-0.0429664142,
0.0916094556,
-0.0418193676,
0.0079689706,
0.0251118969,
0.0339822844,
0.0632023141,
-0.0017935064,
0.0417733565,
0.0419625677,
-0.0982650146,
0.0143154608,
0.0110354219,
-0.1551743001,
-0.0283387695,
0.0077884584,
0.0372619592,
-0.0225106869,
-0.0178019628,
-0.0103942305,
-0.0179351196,
0.0371742658,
0.0118153114,
0.0519125052,
-0.0345133394,
0.0191987734,
-0.0320486836,
-0.043979615,
0.0107779624,
0.0155196078,
0.0068638748,
0.0238521826,
0.1031865999,
0.0364127569,
0.0147002107,
-0.0793065131,
0.0059861089,
-0.06848602,
0.0447208099,
0.0602335036,
0.0147828786,
-0.0181632489,
-0.0043087457,
-0.0091918996,
0.0429201126,
0.0302549489,
-0.0197979752,
-0.0034584247,
-0.0061944965,
0.0222984478,
0.0516565181,
-0.0113262357,
0.0204829052,
-0.0807907581,
0.0602920428,
0.0040073046,
0.0185560826,
-0.0151802404,
-0.0183855053,
-0.046797134,
-0.0243204236,
-0.0458103977,
0.0147247678,
-0.0385732017,
-0.0272122845,
0.03783774,
-0.0056234859,
-0.0332521759,
0.054288879,
0.0591095723,
-0.0340509266,
-0.0133820269,
-0.0074944892,
0.0112199811,
0.0015849022,
0.0026836866,
0.0726128966,
-0.0220766347,
-0.0198750086,
-0.0027744295,
-0.0158595648,
-0.0046923878,
0.0089080753,
0.0366488807,
-0.036404226,
-0.0484073982,
0.0038901565,
-0.0417154618,
0.0073820683,
-0.0517227016,
0.0901340917,
-0.0059924242,
0.0211766362,
0.0016881576,
0.0516692623,
0.0667006001,
0.0014458793,
-0.0280360747,
-0.0158300959,
-0.0061806659,
0.0003060458,
-0.0014638633,
0.0052004424,
-0.0185697917,
0.0478982739,
-0.0297979768,
-0.031543538,
0.0036224055,
0.0046050609,
2.52e-7,
0.06800998,
-0.0069431984,
-0.0022286256,
0.0103866877,
-0.0319482982,
0.034571968,
-0.0246391371,
0.0299246795,
0.0105589628,
-0.0221662447,
-0.0107959192,
0.0046049384,
0.0329515226,
0.0554962382,
-0.0969591215,
-0.0352440104,
0.0082731368,
-0.0079549886,
-0.0246882737,
0.0224532597,
0.0278499722,
0.0833972171,
-0.0051482012,
0.0098042432,
-0.0512681603,
-0.042859938,
0.0671009943,
-0.0081863822,
-0.0379030034,
0.0340982266,
0.025709575,
0.0539475642,
-0.0082404753,
0.0250863992,
-0.0319373384,
-0.0007117034,
0.0734727383,
0.0346545987,
0.004668456,
-0.0122734895,
-0.0302129742,
-0.0453248918,
0.0135983815,
-0.0313515328,
0.0817738995,
-0.0492257662,
-0.0007178069,
0.0400537997,
0.0056630489,
0.03311757,
0.0117452806,
0.0111616468,
-0.0324575193,
0.0227202997,
0.0199399777,
-0.0117624039,
-0.0222641174,
-0.0368154831,
0.0027937561,
0.0364415571,
-0.020449644,
-0.0283003878,
0.0125624118,
-0.0108612413,
-0.0155422725,
-0.0649834275,
0.0180511288,
1.889167047e-34,
-0.0082559651,
0.0173941329,
-0.0281837918,
0.0067001055,
0.0167002436,
-0.0537407063,
-0.101835385,
-0.0111405067,
0.0042855884,
-0.0259009339,
-0.0163222495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16523v1 | Improving Diversity of Demographic Representation in Large Language Models via Collective-Critiques and Self-Voting | 2023-10-25T10:17:17 | 2023-10-25T10:17:17 | Preethi Lahoti, Nicholas Blumm, Xiao Ma, Raghavendra Kotikalapudi, Sahitya Potluri, Qijun Tan, Hansa Srinivasan, Ben Packer, Ahmad Beirami, Alex Beutel, Jilin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A crucial challenge for generative large language models (LLMs) is diversity:
when a user's prompt is under-specified, models may follow implicit assumptions
while generating a response, which may result in homogenization of the
responses, as well as certain demographic groups being under-represented or
even erased from the generated responses. In this paper, we formalize diversity
of representation in generative LLMs. We present evaluation datasets and
propose metrics to measure diversity in generated responses along people and
culture axes. We find that LLMs understand the notion of diversity, and that
they can reason and critique their own responses for that goal. This finding
motivated a new prompting technique called collective-critique and self-voting
(CCSV) to self-improve people diversity of LLMs by tapping into its diversity
reasoning capabilities, without relying on handcrafted examples or prompt
tuning. Extensive empirical experiments with both human and automated
evaluations show that our proposed approach is effective at improving people
and culture diversity, and outperforms all baseline methods by a large margin. | [
0.0540131927,
0.0757064596,
-0.020070143,
0.0385170281,
-0.015802579,
0.0168068837,
0.0355635397,
-0.0240992978,
-0.013824041,
-0.0310904738,
-0.0051797,
-0.1053603217,
0.0102757793,
0.0133306002,
0.0216694381,
-0.0604909472,
0.0161755085,
-0.0266677402,
0.0193521287,
-0.0553448424,
-0.0063181636,
0.0411813036,
0.0151936384,
0.0644455701,
0.0045869276,
-0.0365471728,
0.0079816114,
-0.0088719903,
0.0263726059,
0.0087687634,
0.0083894357,
0.0902705789,
-0.0235822555,
0.0732316226,
0.0000018895,
-0.0508823991,
0.0068037338,
-0.0058818082,
-0.0063712243,
0.0053519341,
0.059277121,
0.063247636,
-0.0086084362,
0.0218467265,
-0.0516467877,
-0.0001729466,
0.0341727883,
0.0027864133,
0.0549416132,
0.032197047,
0.0138447182,
-0.0118143996,
-0.0416099541,
-0.0105534736,
-0.0191214923,
0.0201909188,
0.0006343499,
0.0135592362,
0.0192613471,
0.0102431849,
-0.0160737447,
0.0167722534,
0.0345720425,
-0.057457272,
0.0351149552,
0.0098874653,
-0.0216845647,
-0.0313199908,
0.0178783499,
0.0777223408,
0.0443056598,
0.0072242585,
-0.0146190654,
-0.0071582273,
0.0106180422,
0.0171463527,
-0.0482420363,
0.0230884589,
0.0055357437,
0.0068287314,
-0.015426551,
0.0124233477,
0.0191559251,
0.0222805347,
0.0007072131,
0.0627230108,
0.0293844286,
0.0128399022,
-0.0577660948,
0.008751004,
-0.0063204849,
-0.0506985337,
0.0026110481,
0.021928614,
-0.0690004304,
0.0065423977,
-0.0079605039,
-0.040604867,
0.037104167,
-0.0062179347,
0.0436420366,
0.0052803075,
-0.0063437754,
0.0398047157,
0.019086007,
0.0097473068,
-0.0029935562,
-0.007976396,
-0.0403696932,
-0.0268240031,
-0.0317739695,
-0.0321534052,
-0.0063084043,
-0.0175778922,
-0.0062308623,
0.0436954387,
-0.0362792872,
0.0143973306,
-0.0673287511,
-0.0115512786,
-0.0003141636,
0.0371878147,
-0.0129040871,
-0.0395073891,
-0.056405019,
0.0637860894,
-0.068543829,
-0.0162819922,
0.02387085,
-0.0770218,
0.0163864847,
0.0053472654,
-0.0211066492,
-0.0231480468,
-0.0241775773,
0.0109198755,
0.0112857809,
0.0248755068,
-0.0043650549,
-0.0214168746,
-0.0183663685,
-0.0402334109,
-0.0106871352,
-0.1014091372,
0.0447911285,
0.0153407557,
0.015070186,
-0.033712633,
-0.0091328202,
0.0138485981,
0.0042334422,
0.0407088511,
0.0034830621,
0.0477552675,
0.0594382063,
0.0052137887,
-0.0271998681,
0.0919635072,
0.0309092794,
-0.0115931714,
0.0426621586,
-0.0195208862,
0.0271469802,
0.0362277888,
-0.0305667724,
0.0185304713,
-0.0108146919,
0.0199023876,
-0.0149640506,
0.014506327,
0.0368156955,
0.0787445232,
-0.0058191153,
-0.0312792622,
0.0548482202,
0.090059258,
-0.0021789847,
0.0276658349,
0.0520324484,
0.0028226476,
-0.0145722488,
0.0144064976,
-0.0212538727,
0.0408076979,
0.0014892186,
-0.0287106838,
0.0404529423,
0.0622599237,
-0.0212134533,
-0.0444601178,
-0.0135208042,
0.0253652986,
0.0246465001,
0.0177493133,
0.0373818316,
0.0079209954,
0.0262382347,
0.0314347968,
0.054590635,
-0.0664327294,
0.0085917627,
-0.0549165867,
0.0782851428,
0.0619773902,
0.0185903125,
-0.0009767861,
-0.0115639633,
-0.0203860011,
-0.0014366235,
0.0486721769,
0.0846595839,
-0.0238873251,
-0.0120003987,
-0.0513949096,
-0.0188182108,
0.0219541024,
-0.0014431142,
0.0622136481,
0.0508644693,
-0.0212992318,
0.0111583713,
-0.0217633527,
-0.0374649651,
-0.0035990239,
-0.0147605883,
0.0097485157,
0.0290691219,
0.0113092996,
0.0162171181,
0.0598758012,
-0.0015436001,
0.0185526628,
-0.0326666757,
-0.0271841194,
-0.0236277394,
0.0104287779,
-0.0912965015,
-0.0212946255,
0.0282385442,
-0.0633256882,
-0.0414505266,
0.0135710277,
-0.0016492346,
-0.032483872,
0.0757699981,
-0.0056297951,
-0.0340002999,
-0.0402725115,
-0.0041497871,
-0.0135640837,
-0.007175724,
-0.0553843193,
0.081551142,
0.0171602555,
0.0134953633,
0.0138976453,
0.02318234,
0.0160678439,
-0.0643296167,
-0.065766409,
0.0353771001,
0.0029356543,
0.0163689833,
0.0429358259,
0.0072442577,
-0.0420242622,
-0.0162934866,
-0.0864862055,
-0.0333955102,
-0.0451914631,
-0.0084644658,
0.0041460712,
0.0067468933,
-0.009455218,
-0.01553516,
-0.0554499626,
-0.0105023412,
0.0317265242,
0.0342001244,
0.0183593798,
-0.0137008242,
0.0062681902,
0.0095607182,
-0.0378621519,
-0.0101113468,
0.0589193553,
0.0071673999,
0.0378833897,
-0.0447294898,
-0.0527480915,
-0.0622134656,
-0.021899512,
-0.0019969274,
-0.0170246363,
0.0454946719,
-0.0094233807,
0.0832047239,
0.0020963103,
0.0360634997,
0.0150461327,
0.0504726917,
0.0044915271,
-0.0564068258,
-0.0053747972,
-0.0194876548,
0.0346977524,
0.0298423991,
-0.0724172741,
0.0100078881,
0.0632939935,
0.0156696904,
-0.0449122898,
-0.0958919004,
0.0423308387,
-0.0696538538,
-0.0567816459,
-0.0606807657,
-0.0508914255,
-0.0128940465,
0.0194591563,
-0.0253869388,
-0.0474630557,
0.0780451447,
-0.0032027403,
-0.0096820686,
-0.0081125023,
0.0034121426,
-0.0652198493,
0.0649222806,
-0.0235757697,
0.026434537,
0.0433964543,
-0.0047443905,
-0.0548968166,
0.0109873395,
0.030259395,
-0.0560323186,
0.0837591738,
-0.0563026406,
-0.0148975383,
-0.0049902699,
-0.0288923066,
-0.0460016169,
-0.0425454006,
-0.006330403,
0.010192561,
0.036853645,
-0.0132902144,
0.0163082741,
0.013920798,
0.0232920684,
-0.0071937693,
-0.0371952392,
0.0256632846,
0.0133671798,
0.0093195494,
0.0467580594,
0.0524853803,
0.0497458205,
-0.0522143245,
0.0400018208,
0.0255084913,
0.0415925756,
-0.0185757391,
-0.0188306458,
-0.004008064,
0.0411937349,
0.0104125636,
-0.0082800277,
0.006295844,
0.0777532607,
-0.0210403111,
0.0291446373,
0.0799529031,
0.026596304,
-0.069004178,
-0.0045782356,
-0.076178059,
0.0569424108,
0.0238551293,
0.0406168848,
-0.0569978915,
0.0270143244,
-0.0014881309,
0.0111923022,
-0.0157881398,
-0.0321676433,
-0.0196504593,
-0.1326885521,
0.0429563709,
0.0278187543,
-0.033705201,
0.0051439963,
0.0040094052,
0.0041603092,
0.0069439844,
0.0258387011,
0.0084533188,
0.019561341,
0.0240047835,
0.0366713926,
-0.0582045056,
-0.0568327457,
0.0192072783,
-0.0322166719,
0.0689007789,
0.0582488403,
0.0213891361,
0.0080854539,
-0.0281382762,
0.0156709161,
-0.0191562269,
-0.0013001962,
-0.0004410438,
-0.0261575356,
0.0360716432,
-0.0171683505,
-0.0350336805,
0.0124902464,
-0.0015314129,
-0.0403113402,
0.0215232503,
0.044392962,
0.0077715297,
-0.0156113533,
-0.0361915864,
0.0101642301,
0.0118007725,
0.0816483647,
0.068975009,
-0.0503026582,
0.0134043759,
-0.0724806711,
-0.0112733906,
-0.0540814213,
-0.0536416024,
0.0269030202,
0.0134000136,
-0.0315701105,
-0.049621582,
-0.0449033789,
0.0273902584,
0.0178684797,
0.0051259035,
-0.0381700322,
-0.001881053,
-0.0022769696,
0.0362345576,
0.0500207245,
-0.0393547826,
0.028539421,
-0.0436439402,
-0.0496046953,
-0.0336957425,
-0.0311308149,
0.0042063105,
-0.0110374019,
-0.0579447784,
-0.070473291,
0.0283863377,
0.0415496603,
0.0213011689,
0.0050105271,
-0.0074242498,
-0.090673469,
0.0486379191,
0.0301023852,
0.0260185283,
-0.0145006459,
-0.0342923775,
0.029117804,
-0.0110786334,
0.0516136512,
-0.0214115642,
0.0168934874,
0.012117045,
0.0572999641,
-0.0324992761,
-0.0033759868,
0.0021793018,
0.0059077153,
-0.0243001189,
-0.038446188,
-0.0208691843,
-0.0509092771,
-0.0389139168,
-0.0358903185,
-0.0406463742,
-0.0315144807,
-0.021669805,
0.0096653486,
-0.0535776354,
0.0051055308,
-0.0108324923,
-0.0013297362,
0.0485545062,
-0.0548858382,
0.0527066626,
0.0241219811,
0.005270557,
0.027304614,
0.0149814254,
-0.0056482209,
0.0281130821,
-0.0392877162,
0.0256414879,
0.0217426103,
0.0530946553,
0.0012651804,
-0.0174562167,
-0.0044494714,
0.0073143882,
-0.0503629968,
-0.0447821729,
0.0103169857,
0.0266014449,
0.0245540161,
-0.0000708515,
0.0477583744,
0.0259585101,
-0.0234096497,
-0.014970188,
0.0022623159,
0.0382996313,
-0.0379697271,
0.0190282371,
0.026941441,
-0.0023027062,
-0.0461819731,
0.0664718747,
-0.0415929519,
-0.0090255151,
0.0036350221,
-0.0034444157,
-0.0329877809,
-0.0145239988,
-0.0226217397,
-0.018494172,
-0.025829697,
0.0112603633,
-0.0868909582,
-0.0498219505,
-0.0199119579,
0.034516748,
0.0136280349,
0.0186809748,
0.0214764681,
0.0710890442,
-0.0297636706,
-0.0058723334,
-0.0561921336,
0.0264018569,
-0.0363904573,
0.0090004401,
-0.0251029655,
-6.666869108e-33,
-0.0238183867,
-0.0473638624,
-0.0103401532,
-0.0970823988,
-0.0132179661,
-0.0160723906,
-0.0294130258,
0.032675229,
0.0021198397,
0.0357119627,
-0.0321729481,
-0.0051341685,
0.0102300709,
0.0312445443,
0.0356187411,
-0.0243264474,
0.0391474329,
0.0124033103,
-0.0463347249,
0.0086900713,
0.0181744173,
-0.0111156646,
0.0143849794,
-0.0053469413,
0.0733001977,
-0.0267274491,
0.0040718913,
0.0374695063,
-0.0125858784,
0.0599548779,
-0.0236252155,
0.0721589699,
0.0266557448,
-0.0446539372,
-0.0341552384,
0.0323411785,
-0.0263539441,
-0.0395973139,
0.0173307713,
-0.0072895391,
-0.0216977764,
-0.0466555282,
0.0125892069,
0.0030513632,
-0.0214640591,
-0.0159585346,
0.0421487093,
-0.0044755307,
0.0246784519,
0.005138359,
-0.0341881588,
0.0275545381,
-0.0277260672,
0.006498293,
-0.0429262854,
0.0426329151,
-0.0182594992,
0.0010303814,
-0.0247128103,
0.0520347655,
0.0523514561,
0.004209762,
0.063866958,
0.0383738354,
0.0000555023,
0.0347670503,
-0.0004323513,
0.0398209877,
-0.0730039477,
-0.0646154881,
0.0036481407,
-0.0091857351,
0.0358265042,
0.0968778059,
0.0047695911,
0.0052848384,
-0.0117044058,
0.0172703397,
0.0042937128,
-0.0040052021,
0.0617605634,
-0.0078045619,
-0.0375184715,
-0.0191952363,
-0.0211899597,
-0.0429029427,
-0.0347229578,
-0.0324372649,
0.0088702468,
-0.0128178671,
-0.0751207396,
-0.03014227,
0.0419052914,
-0.0413662456,
-0.0238336716,
0.0033501352,
-0.0048186076,
-0.0217209179,
0.038348157,
0.0268697068,
-0.0184199736,
0.021648502,
0.013407114,
0.0115434695,
-0.0057706949,
0.0208830256,
0.0044768611,
0.0206989311,
-0.0695513189,
0.0101275081,
-0.0311397295,
0.0342158973,
-0.0284176432,
-0.0018479774,
0.0327829048,
0.019439213,
-0.0153378714,
0.0189341214,
0.0201328322,
0.0179909747,
-0.0232518725,
0.0199656468,
-0.0409930423,
0.0109033287,
-0.039058961,
0.01466092,
-0.0037586256,
-0.0012783635,
0.0762088895,
0.0207454506,
-0.025789259,
-0.0147043364,
2.427e-7,
0.0330187902,
0.0373607427,
-0.0069088475,
-0.0002321354,
0.0257185698,
0.0354256146,
0.006814498,
0.0058785821,
0.0386340134,
0.0051515652,
-0.0070088203,
0.0488288589,
0.0607153997,
0.0636253059,
-0.0815730095,
0.0452700928,
-0.0856182203,
0.0313517228,
-0.0286384597,
0.0038043088,
0.0344305038,
0.0593247041,
0.0080780489,
-0.0013916483,
-0.037895292,
0.0120018711,
0.0478473678,
-0.0476360098,
-0.0384457037,
0.024765268,
0.0615988672,
-0.0618444532,
0.0435339659,
0.0010378602,
0.0087173115,
-0.0034105787,
0.015011427,
0.0121446084,
0.0044002943,
-0.019512156,
-0.0172026828,
-0.0026233399,
0.0099734636,
-0.0782644749,
0.047394596,
-0.0032806834,
-0.0405822992,
-0.074273333,
-0.0029100913,
-0.0166886542,
0.0370456353,
-0.0372468196,
-0.041941829,
0.0275433585,
0.0164855048,
-0.0310765374,
-0.0015594237,
-0.0569810271,
-0.0397516601,
-0.0429572985,
-0.0443579406,
-0.0611461625,
-0.0077419383,
0.0195927341,
-0.0080367541,
-0.0118442243,
0.0457178615,
1.876648262e-34,
0.0323420987,
0.0350527316,
0.0016836543,
-0.014804625,
0.0427151509,
0.0083253393,
-0.0024770356,
-0.0105955051,
0.0426313318,
-0.0586433075,
-0.0489301421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16517v1 | OccuQuest: Mitigating Occupational Bias for Inclusive Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T10:06:17 | 2023-10-25T10:06:17 | Mingfeng Xue, Dayiheng Liu, Kexin Yang, Guanting Dong, Wenqiang Lei, Zheng Yuan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized natural
language processing tasks. However, existing instruction-tuning datasets suffer
from occupational bias: the majority of data relates to only a few occupations,
which hampers the instruction-tuned LLMs to generate helpful responses to
professional queries from practitioners in specific fields. To mitigate this
issue and promote occupation-inclusive LLMs, we create an instruction-tuning
dataset named \emph{OccuQuest}, which contains 110,000+ prompt-completion pairs
and 30,000+ dialogues covering over 1,000 occupations in 26 occupational
categories. We systematically request ChatGPT, organizing queries
hierarchically based on Occupation, Responsibility, Topic, and Question, to
ensure a comprehensive coverage of occupational specialty inquiries. By
comparing with three commonly used datasets (Dolly, ShareGPT, and WizardLM), we
observe that OccuQuest exhibits a more balanced distribution across
occupations. Furthermore, we assemble three test sets for comprehensive
evaluation, an occu-test set covering 25 occupational categories, an estate set
focusing on real estate, and an occu-quora set containing real-world questions
from Quora. We then fine-tune LLaMA on OccuQuest to obtain OccuLLaMA, which
significantly outperforms state-of-the-art LLaMA variants (Vicuna, Tulu, and
WizardLM) on professional questions in GPT-4 and human evaluations. Notably, on
the occu-quora set, OccuLLaMA reaches a high win rate of 86.4\% against
WizardLM. | [
0.0709272474,
0.0717013031,
-0.0245206114,
0.0129479943,
-0.0050704894,
-0.0007477662,
0.0268692449,
0.0029442294,
0.0443918519,
-0.0279172659,
-0.0453660674,
-0.0296243392,
-0.01431215,
0.0005388485,
0.0241622478,
-0.0514592975,
0.0086373286,
-0.0066611725,
0.0055325688,
-0.0131921982,
-0.0014697743,
0.0302312635,
-0.0228365585,
0.0773852468,
0.04521624,
-0.035696134,
0.0430108123,
0.0210786611,
-0.0116091426,
0.0211197101,
0.0512587838,
0.0571024232,
0.0007937109,
0.0203192923,
0.0000022017,
-0.043607831,
0.0126084974,
0.0055576148,
-0.0497938283,
-0.0314677618,
0.0543054417,
0.0332266539,
0.0121030156,
0.0724788606,
-0.0313959122,
0.0113702128,
0.0015547816,
0.0161276069,
0.0236958358,
0.0568530038,
0.011841692,
0.0232277196,
-0.001370911,
-0.0464850403,
-0.0032171046,
-0.0360552482,
0.0024958844,
-0.049289234,
0.0295481123,
0.0331777409,
-0.0171618816,
-0.0027857118,
0.0106809922,
-0.0328295082,
0.0203321036,
0.0345241912,
-0.0036011126,
0.0013351821,
0.0035501926,
0.0735121295,
0.0164500717,
0.0055415882,
-0.0074945674,
-0.0047799018,
0.0477317795,
0.0274242479,
-0.0663608983,
0.057069473,
-0.0213399492,
-0.0434070155,
0.0001985961,
0.036595989,
-0.018056456,
0.033610452,
-0.007003698,
0.0513126589,
0.0214622486,
-0.0319123045,
0.0252698492,
0.0085719386,
0.0265655667,
-0.0502840132,
0.0313349552,
0.0209422242,
-0.0776649117,
-0.0021027233,
-0.0327168405,
0.0196547564,
0.0551864915,
-0.0137539264,
-0.0034105075,
0.0497992598,
-0.0343074985,
0.0569361784,
0.0382877402,
0.0368430242,
-0.0129369497,
0.0231870729,
-0.0543200634,
-0.0328134373,
-0.0660211742,
-0.0136474809,
-0.0299558155,
-0.0020615123,
-0.0660390034,
0.021247983,
-0.0342170484,
0.0119882952,
-0.0226100478,
-0.0105294138,
0.0458869487,
0.0190774165,
-0.0562606081,
0.0138919652,
-0.0711419135,
0.038265124,
-0.0236773845,
0.0369791128,
0.0002397805,
-0.0716608688,
-0.0013053878,
0.0191421341,
0.008720872,
-0.044128783,
0.0150162615,
0.0248548612,
0.0227004252,
-0.0223687664,
0.0119592464,
-0.042604994,
0.0159311444,
-0.0385230295,
0.0015075399,
-0.0428678505,
0.0535275899,
-0.0053685354,
0.0105840089,
-0.0088560525,
-0.0055850204,
0.0783370957,
-0.0516097806,
0.0537282377,
-0.0289372858,
0.0198223591,
0.0715620518,
0.0309116486,
-0.0149166882,
0.0454134978,
0.0000036502,
0.0282102954,
0.0311921388,
-0.0249066297,
0.0319111831,
0.0274524428,
-0.0314033292,
-0.0327357166,
0.033809904,
0.0632591918,
0.0232337918,
0.0429558493,
0.0474871881,
0.0282004848,
-0.0356030986,
-0.020576451,
0.0334350653,
0.0548714139,
0.0201231986,
-0.0018385284,
0.0179718584,
0.0311562084,
0.012186191,
-0.0032941492,
-0.0542493761,
0.0239538178,
-0.0466203094,
-0.0263178628,
-0.0100938221,
0.0340873189,
-0.0243828092,
-0.034434285,
0.0115862321,
0.0297414996,
-0.0302037336,
0.0417403542,
0.0055981264,
-0.0026103794,
-0.0487504676,
0.0199845564,
0.0306027755,
-0.0411799476,
-0.0027251369,
-0.0530054197,
-0.0116782179,
0.0852462277,
0.0608636849,
-0.0345301665,
-0.0675380677,
-0.0257182997,
0.0097075244,
0.0746596679,
0.0471805893,
-0.0134482384,
-0.0178753398,
-0.0607658662,
-0.0330113731,
0.0099381218,
-0.0010354157,
-0.0094977729,
0.0477117673,
0.026783824,
-0.001758538,
-0.0428680778,
-0.0292744003,
0.031407509,
-0.0442700125,
-0.0433468223,
-0.0112630827,
0.0028199016,
0.0181232635,
0.027173873,
-0.0026107347,
0.0282719471,
0.0035700561,
-0.0359729044,
-0.0154276956,
-0.0302197076,
-0.0705663338,
-0.0254620779,
0.0289349258,
-0.0125545599,
-0.0285650995,
0.0251178108,
-0.0277887322,
-0.0094057014,
-0.0065820888,
-0.0012943138,
0.0265748426,
-0.0280127041,
-0.0327900089,
0.0128429579,
-0.0084724054,
-0.0644251555,
0.0564901531,
0.0153520787,
-0.0045662834,
0.0382877253,
-0.0016511609,
-0.0172750968,
-0.081018135,
0.0058256453,
-0.0056909937,
-0.0041810567,
0.0339302197,
-0.0033400098,
0.0105730481,
-0.0674380362,
-0.063361086,
-0.1343509257,
0.013567267,
-0.0208699908,
0.0208297614,
0.017740095,
-0.0147958826,
-0.0384372175,
-0.0065272753,
-0.0404415913,
-0.030333139,
-0.00083468,
0.0243356843,
0.0360641219,
-0.0224159192,
-0.0233374704,
-0.0512992814,
-0.0309800487,
-0.0293302592,
-0.0072933985,
0.020802062,
0.0325257108,
-0.022916289,
0.0018636602,
-0.0146394949,
-0.0031064216,
-0.0027559018,
-0.0200876705,
-0.0044398,
-0.0092582237,
0.0010972369,
0.0532006249,
0.0051134103,
0.0025741099,
0.021145504,
0.0039892769,
-0.0242212024,
0.0240043998,
0.0059058191,
-0.0486794636,
0.0010637228,
-0.0306715481,
0.0075144647,
0.037641339,
-0.003664677,
-0.024305081,
-0.0325898342,
-0.0005088725,
-0.0332193859,
-0.0008009071,
-0.0314925313,
0.0016873289,
-0.0055808402,
0.020467842,
-0.020078266,
-0.0096169207,
0.025221115,
-0.0105163604,
0.0109821446,
-0.0864250585,
-0.0170002989,
-0.0741612837,
0.0547112711,
-0.0226155389,
0.0006509136,
0.0215088408,
-0.0485615171,
-0.0587011091,
0.0078981472,
-0.0036192057,
-0.055753015,
0.0081929862,
-0.0370457843,
0.0167485811,
-0.000647118,
-0.022435477,
-0.031466186,
-0.0366406851,
-0.0118200127,
0.0443364158,
0.0187388565,
0.00679914,
-0.0304707624,
-0.0225387625,
-0.0204371139,
0.040427085,
-0.0095787691,
-0.0040725102,
-0.0316058956,
0.0380225182,
0.0589027144,
0.0918305591,
-0.0088753225,
-0.0266660824,
-0.0112852342,
0.0454745144,
0.0407298468,
-0.0366854593,
0.0293605346,
-0.0153531432,
0.0557460003,
-0.0779377297,
0.0007506582,
0.0221310966,
0.038391307,
-0.0578319095,
0.0007703398,
0.110184215,
0.0226673111,
-0.054926157,
-0.0112834312,
-0.0338583477,
0.0265950616,
0.0535975769,
0.0513807312,
-0.0656496882,
-0.0202529188,
0.0092810132,
0.0440174639,
-0.0128100393,
-0.0307703186,
0.0260284916,
-0.1585647017,
0.072300978,
-0.0260152817,
-0.0225620288,
-0.0023934592,
-0.0108482745,
0.007296768,
-0.012111702,
0.0443084873,
0.0189962089,
-0.0264549181,
-0.0065716114,
0.050260365,
-0.0076026036,
-0.0569119826,
0.0671269,
-0.0516865738,
0.0710427463,
0.0331287682,
0.0143687343,
-0.0208213646,
-0.0049790381,
-0.0050224829,
-0.0198831782,
0.0069774771,
0.0163089149,
0.0435846075,
-0.0335048586,
0.0028476771,
-0.045493532,
0.04704744,
-0.047165215,
0.0311548933,
0.043756295,
0.061263483,
0.0002765143,
0.0090173259,
-0.0412492976,
0.0127335098,
0.0044507426,
0.0781979039,
0.0233456474,
-0.0497659519,
-0.0230228156,
-0.0253243223,
-0.0135417962,
0.0215237308,
-0.0237710252,
0.0224642828,
0.0056463913,
-0.0266832616,
-0.0241317954,
-0.0671818033,
0.0983688012,
0.0060758344,
-0.0042860061,
0.012162487,
0.0124064228,
0.0009512054,
-0.0334030315,
0.0605359562,
-0.0676992983,
0.0462261103,
-0.0635987744,
-0.0327092707,
0.0065995795,
-0.0285710394,
-0.0292435829,
0.0107832681,
-0.080268681,
-0.0171676762,
-0.0052305171,
0.0351571552,
0.0196146145,
-0.0095055019,
-0.0110313334,
-0.0683902577,
0.0043206248,
0.0506419986,
-0.0712780282,
0.0150573878,
-0.0106546814,
0.0108319605,
-0.0114060221,
0.0245186798,
-0.0319801308,
-0.0035213816,
0.0039819027,
0.0650098845,
0.0300154816,
-0.0381046534,
0.0185275674,
0.0174606349,
-0.0146162827,
0.0306916479,
0.0078314282,
-0.0656502992,
0.0485024191,
-0.0037498644,
-0.0096654175,
-0.0207020734,
-0.0341970958,
0.0445817597,
-0.0285550412,
0.0137250582,
-0.0188768301,
-0.0411683656,
0.0368116945,
-0.0906391516,
0.0241431687,
-0.0267266706,
-0.0171240512,
0.0034580415,
-0.0221151747,
-0.0140043134,
-0.0073111025,
0.0029014137,
0.0630263463,
0.0174896792,
0.0507502295,
0.0174806528,
0.0402720831,
0.0075119068,
0.0276726726,
-0.0239479877,
-0.0810349733,
0.015526264,
0.0769991502,
0.0463826321,
-0.0328371525,
0.0035312825,
-0.0044575804,
0.0030679565,
-0.0029436268,
-0.0171420425,
0.0223213378,
0.0021204364,
0.0703078136,
0.01494125,
-0.0031655033,
-0.0343634225,
0.1021392047,
0.0266219024,
0.0528487302,
0.0037662101,
-0.0060269227,
-0.0265608132,
-0.0331817195,
0.0330109224,
0.0453034341,
-0.02720684,
0.0278341528,
-0.0806199461,
-0.0618000664,
-0.0123197585,
-0.0347127914,
-0.0170323886,
-0.0453681275,
0.0479466654,
0.0593643822,
-0.005916731,
-0.0411318019,
-0.0233652648,
-0.0049955403,
0.0019137892,
-0.0130289951,
-0.0051735658,
-7.092947607e-33,
-0.0310652088,
-0.0365051776,
0.0380199254,
-0.0226951689,
0.0071360413,
-0.0168722831,
0.0105710663,
-0.0130636282,
-0.0347989276,
-0.017331278,
-0.0451342054,
0.0251953807,
0.0133879846,
0.0364462994,
0.043436721,
-0.0220844932,
0.036644198,
0.0013520567,
-0.0118905948,
0.0345937125,
-0.0456816256,
0.0133790793,
0.0406240895,
-0.0513793305,
0.0229157452,
-0.0180412289,
0.0394443907,
0.0159073379,
-0.0464360304,
0.0754641667,
-0.0268464014,
0.0622634292,
0.0344424956,
-0.0205040816,
0.0190503206,
0.0142252296,
-0.0603137203,
-0.035067711,
0.0327811278,
-0.0174975898,
-0.0230713803,
-0.0363508239,
0.0310782026,
0.013012154,
-0.0272399187,
-0.0408700854,
0.0458550006,
-0.0181627553,
0.0128984433,
0.0441564098,
-0.0363265797,
0.0079849456,
-0.0061510489,
-0.0297115184,
-0.04007921,
0.0083280588,
0.0024905736,
0.0356472991,
-0.0487793572,
-0.0014600478,
0.0228539761,
0.0313703381,
0.0380632617,
-0.016898388,
-0.0405207723,
0.0169112682,
0.0180709828,
0.0723329335,
-0.025241442,
-0.0644302815,
-0.0161718652,
0.0274817869,
-0.0119650131,
-0.0016171179,
0.0372964554,
0.0121355858,
-0.0587115586,
0.0301240534,
0.0342849903,
0.0510416403,
0.0235036481,
-0.0123497741,
-0.0618758872,
-0.0343716294,
-0.0282492545,
0.021595059,
-0.0418827832,
0.0241734106,
0.0546437129,
0.0075918683,
0.0109318607,
0.0005343474,
-0.0144310677,
-0.0388201736,
0.0011676319,
-0.0071968767,
-0.0146223288,
-0.0044140415,
0.0069567445,
0.0271252375,
-0.1021323651,
0.0035061827,
-0.001742475,
-0.0290481038,
0.006026004,
0.0519745573,
-0.0172346141,
-0.0028196052,
-0.0656904131,
-0.0102581289,
-0.0340949483,
0.0193506572,
-0.0275383722,
0.0524376854,
0.0505940542,
0.0287505612,
0.0214043837,
0.035753455,
0.022805104,
-0.0060200677,
-0.0627816021,
-0.0394393913,
0.0092938244,
-0.0307001304,
-0.0178644378,
0.0116690611,
0.0063137556,
-0.0269543305,
-0.009213876,
-0.0326222219,
-0.0133693535,
-0.0472683348,
2.914e-7,
0.035354536,
0.0797504038,
-0.0186104625,
0.0835439041,
0.0078641865,
-0.0060039647,
0.0003774639,
0.0530086793,
0.0264866911,
-0.0061301608,
-0.0042227791,
0.0017826157,
0.0366892219,
0.0012314544,
-0.103686966,
-0.0209451057,
-0.0484986603,
0.0056603854,
-0.0701900274,
-0.0306152236,
0.0717932135,
0.0889343694,
0.0132121872,
-0.0311991945,
-0.0147001725,
-0.0135156736,
0.044429291,
-0.0032738664,
-0.0024987063,
0.0518970303,
0.0488346927,
0.0435013101,
0.007040645,
0.0581782945,
-0.0018598923,
0.0243348777,
0.0313903503,
0.0839211494,
-0.0326764435,
-0.0022918596,
0.0099688265,
-0.0110461451,
-0.0031305715,
-0.0585410856,
0.0499282889,
0.0121270707,
-0.0278552771,
0.0037355183,
-0.0224699061,
-0.0345930085,
0.0253288224,
-0.001369842,
-0.0255751498,
-0.0108568687,
0.0271983594,
-0.0099048074,
-0.0363660976,
-0.0495673604,
0.0141150085,
-0.0102157248,
-0.0503927842,
-0.0880037174,
-0.0095212301,
-0.0225285105,
0.0097576138,
-0.0438673422,
-0.0074057053,
2.896131783e-34,
0.0372105874,
0.0535230935,
0.0412709266,
0.0402280651,
0.0446719043,
0.0222656839,
0.0298805665,
0.0076704603,
0.0195155106,
-0.0876387283,
-0.0163369756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16484v1 | Subspace Chronicles: How Linguistic Information Emerges, Shifts and Interacts during Language Model Training | 2023-10-25T09:09:55 | 2023-10-25T09:09:55 | Max Müller-Eberstein, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Representational spaces learned via language modeling are fundamental to
Natural Language Processing (NLP), however there has been limited understanding
regarding how and when during training various types of linguistic information
emerge and interact. Leveraging a novel information theoretic probing suite,
which enables direct comparisons of not just task performance, but their
representational subspaces, we analyze nine tasks covering syntax, semantics
and reasoning, across 2M pre-training steps and five seeds. We identify
critical learning phases across tasks and time, during which subspaces emerge,
share information, and later disentangle to specialize. Across these phases,
syntactic knowledge is acquired rapidly after 0.5% of full training. Continued
performance improvements primarily stem from the acquisition of open-domain
knowledge, while semantics and reasoning tasks benefit from later boosts to
long-range contextualization and higher specialization. Measuring cross-task
similarity further reveals that linguistically related tasks share information
throughout training, and do so more during the critical phase of learning than
before or after. Our findings have implications for model interpretability,
multi-task learning, and learning from limited data. | [
0.0259278119,
0.0257817674,
-0.0273459181,
0.040234834,
-0.0215749945,
0.0333368555,
-0.0047602933,
-0.0149245001,
-0.0536842905,
-0.0573271848,
-0.0426613688,
-0.0404667296,
0.0068894518,
-0.0052201976,
0.0500888973,
-0.0398601033,
0.0553622209,
-0.0195976514,
-0.0082533471,
0.0055644521,
-0.0071034417,
-0.0121593233,
-0.0337584391,
0.0546516515,
-0.0234503355,
-0.049888771,
-0.0097935889,
-0.0446876548,
-0.0405173302,
-0.0159875993,
-0.0105810845,
0.0512254126,
0.0596965924,
0.0213182531,
0.0000018106,
-0.0575463772,
-0.0073523331,
-0.0116500892,
-0.0586532168,
0.0151150608,
0.0258695707,
-0.0006649831,
0.009901111,
-0.009022614,
-0.0493517555,
-0.0494975708,
0.0543830283,
0.0391565822,
-0.0052707256,
0.0287549328,
-0.0130160134,
0.0062083909,
-0.0109580792,
-0.0199166927,
0.026576953,
-0.0276942682,
-0.007110619,
0.012288087,
-0.0196326952,
0.0161102451,
-0.0427535512,
0.0072289971,
0.0168508776,
0.0261975303,
0.009042725,
0.0710944533,
0.0178372711,
-0.0121355969,
-0.0074430369,
0.0139484461,
-0.0285199769,
-0.0291406345,
-0.0387504138,
0.0077848719,
-0.0173506215,
-0.0161654539,
-0.0490926467,
0.0242492948,
0.0088494336,
0.0418543629,
0.053860534,
-0.0146090593,
0.0251945052,
0.0012183964,
-0.0035409774,
0.0831406042,
0.0031334944,
-0.0219806544,
0.0203578379,
0.019145593,
-0.0343524031,
-0.0269774366,
-0.0452094302,
-0.0266487561,
0.014297761,
0.0332604833,
0.0023837558,
-0.0275136493,
0.0197612327,
-0.0032062209,
0.0576847754,
0.0348860398,
0.0030447324,
0.0197053757,
-0.0156515427,
0.027458882,
0.0037013718,
0.0316994712,
-0.034865059,
-0.0016149587,
-0.1051474214,
-0.0461677387,
-0.0044180355,
0.0253657643,
-0.0223010927,
0.0002175826,
-0.0056031658,
0.0167715102,
-0.0192349367,
-0.0284009017,
-0.0057557123,
0.0237054862,
-0.0381078012,
0.0354260765,
-0.0406993628,
-0.0049636941,
-0.0183943622,
0.0630911142,
-0.0348900855,
-0.0310310479,
-0.0640445799,
0.0279301461,
-0.0092468811,
-0.0365193821,
-0.0396927819,
0.040734075,
-0.0272773299,
-0.0479215942,
-0.0330099538,
-0.0260028113,
-0.0152964443,
-0.0525094718,
0.034681242,
-0.0345399342,
-0.0026657397,
0.0499413759,
-0.0171882343,
-0.0519619323,
-0.019972818,
-0.0042128693,
-0.0145045985,
0.0931105688,
-0.0040110047,
0.0063194451,
-0.0189642888,
-0.0030260077,
0.0189563613,
0.0711549893,
-0.0057280636,
-0.0290921722,
0.0023718723,
0.0030451762,
-0.0065285019,
0.0230007935,
0.0042349733,
-0.0083884457,
-0.0490743108,
-0.0119669102,
0.0492444038,
0.0036095306,
0.0557117909,
-0.0108594606,
-0.0413368866,
-0.0026094411,
0.0229877979,
0.1069467887,
0.0301361736,
0.014029555,
0.0450570807,
0.0104742795,
-0.0037661165,
0.0054674461,
-0.060304828,
0.0048099956,
-0.012183411,
0.003589395,
-0.0255416408,
-0.0050198389,
-0.0141364951,
-0.0165047813,
-0.055253379,
-0.0141945593,
0.0269939732,
-0.0118685523,
0.0479142107,
0.0330617279,
-0.0033722573,
0.0919561759,
0.0509587824,
-0.0548424534,
-0.0112632578,
-0.0047448352,
0.0081107244,
0.0387807451,
-0.0202791989,
-0.0701743141,
-0.0138953021,
0.0064801681,
0.0120481597,
0.026309263,
0.0290799383,
-0.0245737918,
0.0541162267,
-0.0132661266,
-0.0240340345,
-0.0618819818,
0.0417919084,
-0.0063199354,
-0.0078605656,
-0.0646477789,
-0.0216754973,
-0.0811305419,
-0.0192322768,
0.0513231456,
-0.0530512147,
-0.0177834686,
-0.0420702994,
0.0118621476,
0.0142230857,
-0.0096312743,
-0.0088097285,
0.0237299949,
0.022202095,
-0.0423273183,
0.0182366986,
0.0518409014,
-0.0432407446,
-0.0353510566,
0.0357760973,
-0.0098813716,
-0.0130414255,
0.0332653411,
0.0056313723,
-0.0336809084,
0.0492679141,
-0.0270884223,
0.0688450336,
-0.0426212884,
0.0031044008,
-0.039916385,
0.0157497916,
-0.0413083434,
0.0856876373,
0.0093959579,
0.0234951936,
0.007617034,
-0.0081631048,
0.0306326002,
0.014816626,
0.0076608821,
-0.0194887817,
-0.008599624,
-0.0071134241,
-0.0069226758,
-0.0186956879,
-0.0561426319,
-0.0076260399,
-0.1057333574,
0.0088621704,
-0.0143919652,
0.0479377359,
0.0522078052,
-0.0285924952,
0.0029747796,
-0.0012457025,
-0.0004175423,
0.0062972577,
-0.0177765246,
0.0168802403,
0.0332221836,
0.0035668374,
0.0020921603,
-0.0657698959,
-0.0047362074,
-0.0583674163,
0.0845617354,
0.0004592011,
0.0109047629,
-0.0364341326,
0.0524179339,
0.0092261964,
0.0207779966,
0.007502974,
-0.0155143235,
0.036600668,
-0.0218336415,
0.0012541366,
0.024994269,
-0.0356215127,
0.0882200524,
0.0758997574,
-0.0049611982,
-0.0508123934,
0.00397103,
-0.0224732347,
0.0170200914,
-0.055431053,
0.0135930153,
-0.0186423007,
0.1181678474,
0.0111462353,
-0.0358489603,
-0.0297867637,
0.0095442394,
-0.048966784,
-0.0330330022,
-0.0342518501,
0.0013904776,
-0.0173517745,
0.061610844,
-0.0619186461,
-0.0365892425,
0.0425663888,
-0.0293323807,
-0.0240507461,
-0.0715172961,
-0.0174132045,
-0.0077695241,
0.1070876271,
0.0114872931,
-0.0021572015,
0.0647399053,
-0.0524974652,
-0.0519317873,
0.0162732992,
0.0065366207,
0.0122551648,
0.0503752045,
-0.0581673235,
0.0038041133,
0.0139059322,
-0.0077589708,
-0.0354314335,
-0.0432946868,
-0.0091388263,
0.0374958366,
0.0136438236,
0.0066565345,
0.0103625832,
-0.0233412907,
0.020332532,
0.0150503293,
-0.0030341691,
-0.0208144579,
-0.0362419039,
0.011718398,
-0.0124052567,
0.0424352325,
0.0129905734,
-0.0273459218,
-0.0065842336,
0.030836476,
0.0517286621,
0.0461239405,
-0.0303106606,
0.0306868684,
0.0237152427,
-0.0268469285,
-0.0446228087,
0.0099435188,
0.0547601171,
-0.0391887091,
-0.0467101857,
0.1009270847,
0.0583582483,
-0.0296102129,
0.0321052596,
-0.0235977266,
0.0133718094,
0.0717788339,
-0.0037613378,
-0.0576062091,
-0.0207306445,
-0.0083171995,
-0.0180210918,
0.0097744251,
-0.0199259371,
-0.013390203,
-0.0795078278,
-0.002306367,
-0.0212605745,
-0.0683065727,
0.0128559582,
-0.0603073537,
0.0130136898,
0.0087716114,
0.0471384265,
-0.0093373321,
-0.0294829328,
0.032771606,
0.0316522568,
0.0111738592,
-0.0635833964,
0.0441402756,
-0.0420835018,
0.0516666397,
0.0405805148,
0.0207357705,
-0.0231893025,
0.0032722321,
0.0230162274,
0.0062160259,
0.0222883057,
-0.0048930966,
0.0649543703,
0.0403886251,
-0.015062619,
0.0076751835,
0.0151462881,
-0.0576644689,
-0.0435283482,
-0.0225421991,
0.0869622454,
-0.017576145,
0.0085799042,
0.0410036109,
0.0088243326,
0.0149612231,
0.0706429332,
0.0694286153,
-0.0307912324,
-0.0273432638,
-0.0164363664,
0.0465162769,
-0.0300560798,
-0.0429885052,
0.0371791981,
0.0310303438,
-0.0175696015,
-0.0349537134,
-0.0396251008,
0.0462511033,
0.0115320804,
0.0043391753,
0.0292104725,
0.0097365817,
-0.0597242266,
-0.0710926801,
0.0615752675,
-0.0071898326,
-0.0082926014,
0.0075196358,
-0.0461679474,
-0.0010538468,
-0.0261194892,
-0.0436337925,
-0.0190249961,
-0.0876163617,
-0.052478686,
-0.0065171099,
-0.0039740996,
0.0237447675,
0.0394459255,
0.0023395168,
-0.0343562923,
-0.0237773508,
-0.0209085364,
-0.026738802,
0.0494968668,
0.0330419168,
-0.0374098048,
0.0274874698,
0.0437364615,
-0.0077960119,
0.0037065614,
0.0540680066,
0.0062846113,
0.0056502619,
0.0056695552,
0.0368393771,
-0.0167420153,
0.0952987149,
0.0324121267,
-0.0281027798,
-0.0505325384,
-0.0279274434,
-0.0241580065,
0.002399412,
-0.0054848529,
-0.0269727353,
0.0318633504,
0.027206229,
0.0171626005,
0.0157503188,
-0.0003518452,
0.0592133589,
-0.056686569,
-0.0290583707,
0.000799651,
0.0020153245,
-0.0060384287,
0.0463619344,
0.0055312114,
-0.0038979405,
-0.029074261,
-0.0105729513,
-0.0055943322,
0.0140613355,
0.0065282155,
0.0143860718,
-0.0491315946,
-0.0005991635,
-0.0571367815,
-0.0407631062,
0.0380876921,
-0.0181863401,
0.0713934526,
-0.0733010471,
0.0686675161,
-0.0296280533,
0.0114580188,
0.0076285489,
0.0276920646,
-0.0121735362,
-0.0258774217,
0.037636701,
0.0226223804,
-0.0140414592,
-0.0187645499,
0.1069065109,
0.0168260448,
0.0637095124,
-0.0203684755,
-0.0163715035,
-0.0264350139,
-0.0189304408,
0.0165523421,
0.0688731074,
-0.0330888703,
0.0599040724,
-0.0520102084,
-0.0449020825,
0.0126553131,
0.0084461188,
-0.0167267323,
-0.0175814703,
0.0507195517,
0.0761436373,
0.0028752054,
-0.0289717689,
-0.015790103,
-0.0404314101,
0.060205549,
-0.0162250344,
-0.0165917929,
-6.274734478e-33,
-0.0144218104,
0.0000801605,
0.0021685492,
0.0059602042,
-0.019183591,
0.0270683337,
-0.0335654132,
0.0407043174,
-0.0201570634,
0.0186400916,
0.0125490297,
0.0290322714,
0.0034053049,
0.0479145795,
0.0375037119,
0.0046868264,
0.0260592122,
-0.0116353091,
0.0027992565,
-0.0094935,
0.0655829087,
0.0278570578,
0.0784703493,
-0.0660095587,
0.0218207091,
0.0502304137,
0.0411336645,
0.0320316777,
-0.030001428,
0.042790018,
-0.0368252583,
0.0668697059,
0.0505144447,
-0.093041651,
-0.0339926854,
-0.0147124194,
-0.0508485176,
-0.0612664185,
0.0531471968,
-0.003900734,
-0.0570337772,
-0.0197705533,
0.0516334288,
-0.0064518922,
0.0105708502,
-0.0257488862,
0.0426838584,
0.0013340061,
0.0064834566,
0.0480805412,
-0.1058239788,
-0.0248090196,
-0.0391294323,
-0.0262888372,
0.0688282251,
-0.0120631969,
0.0039228154,
-0.0324041136,
-0.051333189,
-0.0156058241,
-0.0284971111,
0.0541782416,
0.0452476107,
0.012069515,
0.0135258632,
0.0832691044,
0.0242296122,
0.0074629667,
0.0099117272,
0.0020363522,
0.0619438961,
0.034865994,
-0.0146167381,
-0.0178798325,
-0.0044836001,
-0.0072944476,
-0.0658276007,
-0.0193909537,
0.0269194636,
0.018411044,
0.0171045996,
0.0227741115,
0.0173756666,
-0.036378067,
-0.0688324943,
0.0007998238,
-0.0295772646,
-0.0158667509,
0.0205617882,
-0.0200247765,
0.0165134985,
0.0095280968,
0.0006242571,
-0.0263562147,
-0.0149572641,
0.021649573,
-0.0150183225,
0.0313322619,
0.0157931019,
0.0311539918,
-0.0690009892,
-0.050904531,
0.0027639861,
0.0010523935,
0.0218446497,
0.0118278768,
0.0436928682,
0.0019895346,
-0.0334607847,
-0.0047425972,
-0.0540578291,
-0.0244222581,
0.0234552659,
0.0491767265,
0.0347743966,
0.0368403941,
-0.01839968,
0.0218177959,
0.0568516701,
-0.0121863382,
-0.0296305753,
-0.0218300279,
-0.0288819596,
0.0080947485,
-0.0034535041,
-0.0455481149,
-0.0467132814,
-0.0137929199,
0.0555153564,
-0.0214457102,
-0.0236692335,
0.0069514695,
2.598e-7,
0.0790428296,
0.0646183565,
-0.0044505908,
0.0152422395,
0.0447211266,
0.0316789225,
-0.0280471072,
0.0228318926,
-0.0120286029,
-0.0302378144,
-0.0472113714,
0.0340004265,
0.0104097985,
0.0248282421,
-0.0464602262,
-0.0072056782,
-0.0137711493,
0.0176956933,
-0.0313066654,
0.0190650802,
0.0744120106,
0.0816705525,
0.0046416633,
0.0006994973,
-0.0194417667,
-0.0246300027,
0.060824167,
-0.0322748125,
0.0208919421,
0.0125499954,
-0.0059312861,
0.0126028014,
0.0316554308,
0.0569891967,
0.0004507514,
0.0257244222,
-0.0277768206,
0.0070652459,
-0.0068488396,
0.0011270822,
-0.0027908548,
0.0153866773,
-0.0115317581,
-0.0578453541,
0.0557865351,
-0.0868888125,
-0.0553735346,
-0.0336039253,
0.0300255865,
0.0310278516,
0.0020715301,
0.0217210073,
-0.0000269921,
0.0123691484,
-0.0081691444,
-0.0115869567,
-0.0320803113,
-0.0671568215,
-0.0420573354,
0.0538007431,
-0.0489869639,
0.0123608783,
-0.0005280695,
-0.0492541902,
0.0630479455,
-0.0640592948,
0.0088244816,
2.494212816e-34,
-0.0309846196,
0.0258197859,
0.0457510352,
0.0411657616,
0.0239852183,
-0.0349934362,
-0.024517782,
-0.0036765481,
-0.0039102687,
-0.056876801,
0.0054804413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16450v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16450v3 | CLEX: Continuous Length Extrapolation for Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T08:13:02 | 2024-03-24T17:14:11 | Guanzheng Chen, Xin Li, Zaiqiao Meng, Shangsong Liang, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs) are pioneering advances in
many natural language processing tasks, however, their exceptional capabilities
are restricted within the preset context window of Transformer. Position
Embedding (PE) scaling methods, while effective in extending the context window
to a specific length, demonstrate either notable limitations in their
extrapolation abilities or sacrificing partial performance within the context
window. Length extrapolation methods, although theoretically capable of
extending the context window beyond the training sequence length, often
underperform in practical long-context applications. To address these
challenges, we propose Continuous Length EXtrapolation (CLEX) for LLMs. We
generalise the PE scaling approaches to model the continuous dynamics by
ordinary differential equations over the length scaling factor, thereby
overcoming the constraints of current PE scaling methods designed for specific
lengths. Moreover, by extending the dynamics to desired context lengths beyond
the training sequence length, CLEX facilitates the length extrapolation with
impressive performance in practical tasks. We demonstrate that CLEX can be
seamlessly incorporated into LLMs equipped with Rotary Position Embedding, such
as LLaMA and GPT-NeoX, with negligible impact on training and inference
latency. Experimental results reveal that CLEX can effectively extend the
context window to over 4x or almost 8x training length, with no deterioration
in performance. Furthermore, when evaluated on the practical LongBench
benchmark, our model trained on a 4k length exhibits competitive performance
against state-of-the-art open-source models trained on context lengths up to
32k. Our code is available at https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/CLEX. | [
0.0189902186,
0.0652384609,
-0.008334402,
0.0351964943,
-0.0082305856,
-0.002061751,
0.0144946128,
-0.004569632,
-0.0325525329,
-0.0189433265,
-0.0137679884,
-0.052954983,
0.0014896196,
0.0213919263,
0.0283270366,
-0.0447403751,
0.0107531603,
-0.0329185389,
-0.0306532662,
0.005287746,
0.0019993228,
-0.0187115576,
0.0237326548,
0.0578379445,
0.0097694509,
0.0083167749,
-0.0387862548,
-0.0298084524,
0.0400178432,
-0.0063276999,
0.0040939548,
0.0184751395,
0.070149079,
0.0276851803,
0.0000019547,
-0.0109352972,
0.0004147276,
0.0033932424,
-0.0147179868,
0.0215187352,
0.0354382098,
-0.0602729209,
0.0022927478,
0.026418779,
-0.0318438932,
-0.0463415608,
0.0262465328,
0.0131533509,
0.0385781154,
0.0744574592,
-0.0071042203,
-0.0609245375,
0.0547054783,
-0.0767093226,
-0.020253526,
-0.0373902246,
0.0265528783,
0.0011387657,
0.0339941531,
0.0577306189,
-0.044603169,
0.0372499377,
0.0574301556,
-0.0044898596,
-0.0359836891,
0.0565561689,
0.0131562231,
0.0037418487,
-0.0116611021,
0.0592702925,
-0.068955116,
-0.013996263,
-0.0052035898,
-0.0088006835,
-0.0029600619,
-0.0349673852,
-0.0666683018,
0.025199635,
0.0516134091,
0.0047989455,
0.0093780113,
0.0123479934,
0.0404601879,
0.0136163188,
-0.0733834133,
0.0337193459,
0.0119239846,
-0.0171328112,
-0.046802476,
-0.0330603682,
-0.0533168837,
-0.0010385157,
0.0197617821,
0.0498282015,
-0.003645129,
0.0288231783,
-0.0346998647,
-0.0126886796,
0.0109059969,
-0.0488824844,
0.0049307914,
0.0573590212,
0.0067784851,
0.0420290083,
-0.0523994192,
0.0603778809,
-0.0613525845,
0.0078510232,
-0.0574577078,
-0.0104967766,
-0.0155781405,
-0.027936833,
-0.0358188227,
-0.0180463754,
-0.043123059,
-0.0616627075,
-0.0337557979,
0.0373036712,
0.021417642,
-0.0192155913,
0.0367608517,
0.0272971243,
-0.0296953656,
-0.0202350412,
0.0224635489,
0.0637804195,
-0.0326958895,
0.0219108742,
0.0076367096,
-0.0130631076,
-0.0330986753,
0.0113330036,
0.0085180514,
-0.0368485861,
-0.002923016,
0.0538539365,
0.0301141962,
-0.0597288199,
-0.0006962446,
0.0178706404,
-0.0449437015,
-0.0537538715,
-0.0066113402,
-0.091587916,
0.0414891504,
-0.0009750451,
0.0101387203,
-0.0041990667,
0.0304629244,
0.0262524914,
-0.0188436769,
0.0845541656,
0.0207666382,
0.0198299494,
-0.0058094868,
0.0067956895,
0.0279920232,
0.0805303976,
0.0374142081,
-0.0105333254,
0.0297609288,
-0.0001108594,
-0.0272808466,
0.0427019112,
0.0040066261,
-0.0053774617,
-0.0395364016,
-0.0013436618,
0.029175587,
0.0511659645,
0.0396880507,
0.0105085783,
-0.040102385,
-0.0432913266,
0.0379057378,
0.06560947,
0.0213737153,
0.0029775284,
0.0462163649,
-0.0025133423,
-0.0199794658,
-0.0142957615,
-0.0435149111,
0.0144334054,
0.0471554808,
0.0330262259,
0.0075741764,
0.0700134635,
-0.0131180063,
-0.014941752,
-0.0189026296,
-0.0182777401,
0.0181587078,
-0.0122502418,
0.0261825398,
-0.007342523,
-0.0404111333,
0.0698109865,
0.0073162843,
-0.0320621096,
-0.0120801628,
-0.0168618504,
-0.0409302376,
0.0629151389,
0.0210306961,
-0.0235894229,
-0.0582085773,
-0.0234114602,
-0.0024321873,
0.0261010434,
0.0053575756,
0.0095086629,
0.0089350231,
-0.0408581868,
-0.0235218294,
0.0273806993,
0.0211651865,
-0.0166564826,
0.0777434185,
0.0415085815,
0.0506586656,
-0.0436635911,
0.0198815744,
0.0341269895,
-0.0548411049,
-0.0239795819,
-0.0122087905,
-0.0078936778,
-0.0004044039,
0.0063056988,
-0.0091962814,
0.0115733072,
0.0478092656,
-0.056683749,
-0.0002048234,
0.006785457,
-0.0952143595,
-0.0417834893,
0.0769665316,
-0.0014787388,
0.0305582788,
0.0359165221,
-0.055656638,
-0.0370569155,
-0.0048882184,
-0.0220919158,
0.0616316833,
-0.0122907842,
0.0318922214,
0.0016691954,
0.0397997871,
-0.0310390778,
0.0313110836,
-0.0220773201,
0.032941889,
0.0294051748,
0.0274438187,
-0.0185987782,
-0.0196994282,
-0.0431556441,
0.028609788,
-0.0009647296,
-0.011238059,
-0.015345999,
-0.0296314005,
-0.0095704747,
-0.041585695,
-0.0942843407,
-0.0040478138,
-0.0244041365,
0.0151504548,
0.0199736636,
0.0450126678,
-0.0103755854,
0.0065759979,
-0.0243508946,
-0.0237635057,
-0.0032016886,
0.0111806905,
0.0172014758,
0.0126311835,
-0.0466529764,
-0.0397346132,
-0.0209170599,
-0.0015715621,
0.0641122609,
-0.0379213206,
-0.0018748681,
-0.065357022,
0.0056125754,
0.0155046945,
0.0356608406,
-0.044564601,
-0.0264886506,
-0.0322163925,
-0.0311588775,
0.0392974354,
0.0398246273,
0.0304186102,
0.0092365677,
0.0185569488,
0.0078378506,
-0.0505888872,
0.007699064,
-0.0627319068,
-0.0050081862,
-0.0659878179,
0.0311321877,
-0.0353132486,
0.0814525411,
-0.0400777571,
-0.0312597714,
-0.0321885496,
-0.0176388845,
-0.0111854821,
0.0184081085,
0.0074663572,
-0.0044011325,
-0.0443983488,
-0.0138449827,
-0.0204600375,
-0.0614907518,
0.0445902459,
-0.0491490439,
0.0044988254,
-0.0202106666,
-0.0352128111,
-0.0568249412,
0.0696130097,
0.0318268947,
-0.0059286393,
-0.0179612394,
-0.0019382488,
-0.0211620107,
0.0330166854,
-0.0379730798,
-0.0249244161,
0.0678576902,
-0.0072038202,
0.0145618422,
-0.0175616052,
-0.039597854,
-0.0342106521,
-0.0481045581,
-0.0183777232,
0.007423467,
0.0198085047,
-0.0569428876,
-0.0003569785,
0.0260727722,
0.0092520379,
0.0750662237,
-0.0009552183,
0.0281755812,
-0.0388749801,
0.0284701493,
0.0658477098,
0.0317217447,
0.0136268176,
-0.0205796473,
0.0222013742,
0.0399853662,
0.0150381597,
0.0091759041,
-0.0697766915,
-0.0151153021,
0.0083594667,
-0.0405139774,
-0.0248717219,
0.0010216825,
0.0317694508,
-0.0779725164,
-0.0156910326,
0.1060496718,
0.0080024516,
-0.0477144793,
0.0239461809,
0.0157479234,
0.0541014187,
0.025065111,
0.0259064864,
-0.0637473688,
-0.0150400018,
0.0262901783,
-0.0224326756,
0.0220913813,
-0.0102429194,
-0.0262556206,
-0.1198336035,
0.0236091241,
0.0123900957,
-0.009067487,
-0.0204562359,
-0.0573182069,
0.0015324048,
0.0137726404,
0.0049811718,
0.0274090935,
-0.0162630156,
-0.0270612072,
-0.0032371548,
-0.034339156,
-0.0526015796,
0.0154310903,
-0.0222611688,
0.0292747878,
0.009689413,
0.0115270754,
0.0154768089,
-0.0265719034,
0.0484950244,
-0.0218694806,
0.0130251199,
0.0298515614,
0.0175847691,
-0.0223985985,
-0.0034902836,
0.0189954266,
0.0434610806,
-0.0355623253,
-0.0130640725,
-0.0317559727,
0.1061513498,
0.0179002769,
0.0068347342,
-0.022303436,
-0.0252778549,
-0.0300054234,
0.0333867818,
0.0350603536,
-0.0338958874,
-0.0465311967,
-0.0022516025,
-0.022714559,
0.0225485582,
-0.0264217295,
-0.0137227681,
0.0301490705,
-0.0181960631,
-0.0460808799,
-0.0044285739,
0.0195558313,
0.0489553623,
-0.0048973514,
0.0115598505,
-0.0109429471,
-0.0123668769,
-0.0685871989,
0.0159287099,
-0.0046579894,
0.042585399,
-0.0300544519,
0.0749729201,
0.0562515371,
0.0218215622,
-0.0132347587,
0.0243382119,
-0.1174647957,
-0.0732863769,
-0.0209312905,
0.0049527897,
0.0172448717,
0.0682868287,
-0.0111778146,
-0.017431654,
0.0579027981,
0.0311942548,
-0.0217605773,
0.0035437851,
0.026330078,
0.0045291861,
0.0148114748,
0.0378939584,
-0.0130538633,
0.0057207588,
-0.0362352319,
0.0451214649,
-0.0279789995,
-0.0326569565,
-0.0038407994,
-0.0359222181,
0.0496543348,
0.0022169219,
0.0410479568,
-0.0075990241,
0.0461684838,
-0.0343899541,
0.0157926641,
-0.0375142284,
0.0265511498,
0.0413250253,
0.0159193072,
0.0143264318,
-0.0112710791,
0.0435985029,
-0.0218052436,
-0.0100595634,
0.022617409,
-0.0004692326,
-0.0498550087,
0.0387046002,
0.0241563171,
-0.013902274,
-0.0156320818,
-0.0172896907,
0.034442652,
-0.0516430289,
0.0244875755,
0.0175582729,
-0.014777828,
-0.0379697867,
0.0196283981,
-0.0772798955,
-0.0313735157,
-0.0435962975,
0.030839093,
0.042904254,
-0.0227560736,
0.0394705459,
-0.0048429202,
-0.0251404177,
-0.0002586087,
0.017031325,
-0.0344543792,
-0.0227212161,
0.0391306616,
0.0468677878,
-0.0160461087,
0.0280587375,
0.0624918453,
0.0279535726,
0.0391996913,
0.0044318889,
-0.0027849537,
-0.0010598026,
-0.0400446244,
-0.0254202038,
0.0058186632,
-0.0044140266,
0.020747982,
-0.0154574635,
-0.0765196905,
0.0163393822,
-0.0093198856,
-0.036548242,
-0.0392760634,
0.0141459899,
0.033113692,
-0.0090804873,
-0.0242058169,
-0.0150642404,
0.0009641145,
0.0506009124,
-0.0356585719,
-0.0029321746,
-5.93942251e-33,
-0.0068322523,
-0.0029955078,
0.0173660181,
-0.0178047754,
-0.0841211379,
0.0125954254,
-0.0080591366,
-0.0009113806,
-0.016119834,
0.001619625,
-0.0184238218,
0.0078501469,
0.003767285,
0.036684256,
-0.0127212079,
-0.0056368136,
0.0247764383,
0.0027123787,
0.0200923495,
-0.0102169048,
0.0168875977,
0.0610471405,
0.0524445698,
-0.0080773961,
-0.0020197961,
0.0164070334,
0.0137466667,
0.0351589806,
0.0038468733,
0.0618117787,
-0.0401376598,
0.0405321121,
0.0225635897,
-0.0689623356,
-0.0337297656,
0.0233090222,
-0.0944400504,
0.0107580181,
-0.0054788496,
0.0160040334,
-0.0044046077,
-0.0087457476,
0.0739125684,
-0.007500696,
-0.0002907572,
-0.0348129347,
0.0172009617,
-0.0475546159,
-0.0282021035,
0.00097625,
-0.0350122303,
0.030967623,
0.0300462041,
0.0109521449,
0.0375787988,
0.0357920304,
-0.0067281411,
0.036912892,
-0.0501506254,
-0.0231481772,
0.0304744374,
0.0711240768,
0.0541802123,
0.0115090944,
0.0380525291,
0.0433201827,
-0.0107543189,
-0.0398726538,
-0.0473607108,
-0.0165180434,
0.0267800447,
0.0335619114,
0.0214438289,
0.0096484087,
0.0401450433,
-0.0066305581,
-0.0409220271,
-0.0387954377,
0.0008058421,
0.0357886739,
0.0459614545,
0.0259683225,
-0.0422956124,
-0.0311233364,
-0.0423628055,
-0.0038262513,
-0.0010436431,
-0.0232832022,
0.0441940352,
0.0516315773,
0.0018618038,
0.0129180355,
0.0511484593,
-0.0603238493,
-0.0216909647,
0.0272383373,
-0.0043184641,
0.0313459784,
0.0018515456,
0.0427282378,
-0.023982631,
-0.0252436474,
-0.0182608329,
0.0032341792,
-0.0033099963,
-0.0376267061,
0.0139449593,
0.0375995152,
-0.0899980068,
-0.0221049767,
-0.0378426202,
-0.0105966972,
0.0183610991,
0.0444880538,
0.0647436827,
-0.0027139047,
-0.0053144139,
0.0876539275,
0.0153688099,
0.0148071954,
0.0074333497,
-0.0127346218,
0.0117866388,
0.0362526067,
-0.0326737799,
-0.0056463857,
-0.020612523,
0.0315121375,
0.0280925855,
-0.0866746083,
-0.0255505387,
0.0268112291,
2.721e-7,
0.0387904942,
0.0260072313,
0.072167635,
-0.0107889315,
0.0300893132,
-0.0062287431,
0.018034514,
0.0391579643,
-0.0108356001,
-0.0159960054,
-0.0061126719,
0.0164920893,
0.0261708852,
-0.0116163036,
-0.0947897062,
0.0082073752,
-0.0753754228,
0.0006619071,
-0.0442702733,
-0.0381966606,
0.0116560739,
0.156920597,
0.0048807198,
0.0153543055,
0.0108369635,
-0.0325090401,
0.0598475188,
-0.0285282657,
0.0112200798,
0.0025114717,
-0.0035009086,
0.0275569558,
-0.010964077,
-0.022745721,
0.0120926043,
0.0767776892,
0.0016812386,
0.0918096825,
0.0210331883,
-0.0004333686,
0.0222220719,
-0.0453885682,
-0.0390759557,
-0.0764119327,
0.0622990951,
-0.0865669847,
0.0034655773,
-0.0538360551,
-0.0268802848,
-0.0230227634,
0.0182662196,
-0.0090059163,
0.033169169,
0.0243719723,
0.0212491695,
-0.0291498285,
-0.0093162078,
-0.12670739,
-0.0519300401,
0.0141900843,
-0.0820476413,
0.007445917,
-0.0571696423,
-0.0327047445,
0.0624902397,
-0.02440002,
-0.0046241586,
2.79718225e-34,
0.0301689766,
-0.0068881121,
0.0003593789,
0.040473491,
0.000918969,
-0.0266598966,
0.032877095,
0.018440498,
0.0230262652,
-0.118649736,
-0.0435955189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16446v1 | Diversity Enhanced Narrative Question Generation for Storybooks | 2023-10-25T08:10:04 | 2023-10-25T08:10:04 | Hokeun Yoon, JinYeong Bak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Question generation (QG) from a given context can enhance comprehension,
engagement, assessment, and overall efficacy in learning or conversational
environments. Despite recent advancements in QG, the challenge of enhancing or
measuring the diversity of generated questions often remains unaddressed. In
this paper, we introduce a multi-question generation model (mQG), which is
capable of generating multiple, diverse, and answerable questions by focusing
on context and questions. To validate the answerability of the generated
questions, we employ a SQuAD2.0 fine-tuned question answering model,
classifying the questions as answerable or not. We train and evaluate mQG on
the FairytaleQA dataset, a well-structured QA dataset based on storybooks, with
narrative questions. We further apply a zero-shot adaptation on the TellMeWhy
and SQuAD1.1 datasets. mQG shows promising results across various evaluation
metrics, among strong baselines. | [
0.0329639353,
0.0190607365,
-0.017681282,
0.0016667991,
-0.0267130323,
0.0096349372,
0.0555706359,
-0.0312495977,
-0.0229354333,
-0.0086816894,
0.0195907131,
-0.0573694631,
0.0115945237,
0.0485118851,
0.0366608314,
-0.0338642709,
0.0317176729,
-0.0085549261,
-0.0027739871,
-0.0017709489,
-0.0188210644,
0.0429376215,
-0.0247461013,
0.0413614959,
0.0029499182,
-0.0484488755,
-0.0392886251,
0.0200293586,
0.0501999184,
-0.0321262367,
0.0302994829,
0.0234932303,
0.0282911435,
-0.0033895946,
0.0000019392,
-0.0544700027,
-0.0445437692,
-0.0026380615,
-0.0254697111,
-0.0426107794,
0.0143876383,
0.044993341,
0.0498136692,
0.0165596846,
-0.0257904436,
0.0294596571,
0.0299946815,
0.0394807868,
0.0499351658,
0.0678014979,
0.0063251834,
-0.0309821162,
0.0109789092,
0.0110436874,
0.0708494037,
-0.0125433886,
-0.0344954245,
0.0418364927,
0.0469835587,
-0.012792943,
-0.0147192394,
0.0020214599,
0.0285318475,
0.0101847965,
0.0150575871,
0.0422307961,
0.0108701326,
0.0103470897,
-0.0201543029,
0.1187745035,
0.0096542034,
-0.0000987479,
-0.0186492372,
-0.003609336,
0.0448792614,
0.0220304579,
-0.0737252608,
0.0424479693,
-0.0224449374,
-0.0232890975,
-0.0182814002,
0.0235982947,
0.0128786676,
-0.001588179,
0.0174179934,
0.0031423955,
0.0225244518,
0.012188036,
-0.0642494708,
-0.0046856827,
-0.0221348703,
-0.0529788472,
-0.0008013422,
0.0507520661,
-0.0449106805,
0.02817134,
-0.0578214861,
0.000927098,
0.006903016,
0.0082730716,
0.0131412698,
0.0285782497,
0.001649693,
0.0217570104,
0.0027330632,
0.0255835298,
0.0193755087,
-0.0217069555,
-0.0692934245,
-0.003027119,
-0.0306203403,
-0.0099799624,
-0.0339231305,
0.0432208031,
-0.0343401395,
-0.0324626118,
-0.0118355714,
0.0168764424,
0.0498999991,
-0.0158058088,
-0.0128996847,
0.0422994196,
-0.06411881,
-0.0024218573,
-0.0208404791,
0.0145131182,
-0.0839025229,
0.014742489,
0.0504561514,
-0.0504536144,
-0.0181612633,
-0.003635566,
0.0466120765,
-0.0212050844,
0.0171322152,
0.0093907872,
-0.0327405855,
-0.027730288,
-0.0310382657,
-0.0631563589,
-0.0017259376,
-0.0585243888,
-0.025973184,
-0.0633249357,
0.0438706167,
-0.0000810594,
-0.0036539561,
-0.0041094637,
0.0183617622,
0.0398032404,
-0.0058201724,
0.0317348689,
0.0070320414,
-0.0026196497,
0.0592507608,
0.0230619386,
-0.0127648544,
0.0589410849,
0.0902488455,
-0.0165075324,
0.0609728545,
0.0043201926,
0.0311743915,
-0.0128611494,
-0.0097026723,
-0.0092755836,
0.013002119,
0.0166447442,
0.0140169859,
0.0318882428,
-0.0384114906,
0.0409835577,
-0.0238362607,
-0.0104083735,
0.044747375,
0.0512126349,
0.022503119,
0.0028333426,
0.0621008687,
0.0062481752,
-0.0019442255,
0.0306823011,
0.0011081354,
0.0436624512,
0.0128602786,
0.0064154733,
0.0338754356,
0.0512658916,
-0.0105106784,
-0.026390411,
0.0077612493,
0.0310566425,
-0.0053997794,
0.0341510475,
-0.0105496999,
0.0115034757,
-0.0556372404,
0.0225559324,
-0.0077217319,
-0.1129665077,
0.0361253284,
-0.0237759519,
0.1061761677,
0.0366143771,
0.0725770891,
-0.0062077092,
-0.0900095478,
-0.0546705797,
-0.0029692876,
0.0173043832,
0.0299159642,
-0.033569064,
0.0616268888,
-0.0718184561,
-0.0113419807,
-0.0497661605,
-0.0001276562,
0.0346326679,
-0.0001279475,
0.019466836,
0.0124890236,
-0.0461476445,
-0.0400161333,
0.0526297688,
-0.0439555831,
-0.030025823,
0.0211705491,
-0.0075741098,
-0.0308362786,
0.0311905146,
-0.0099788066,
-0.0166389216,
0.0255748611,
-0.0189337246,
-0.0115662087,
0.0447873957,
-0.0788726062,
-0.0973124802,
0.0287032556,
-0.0627486482,
-0.0032078528,
-0.0102874171,
0.0098993657,
-0.0564268157,
0.0132509246,
-0.0166656673,
-0.0156843625,
-0.0283473451,
0.000455507,
0.0022815063,
0.006774189,
-0.0506422929,
0.0611049011,
0.0406011567,
0.0093152979,
-0.0254400689,
0.0461371057,
0.032012172,
-0.0390594527,
0.0049954182,
0.0278521106,
-0.0144305648,
-0.0021571761,
0.0271049198,
0.0161539931,
-0.0633027926,
-0.0268225837,
-0.0716034845,
0.0530448556,
-0.0202190895,
-0.0154360002,
0.0388699025,
0.0222522635,
-0.0220387429,
0.0012549761,
-0.0935461968,
0.010911108,
0.0179531258,
-0.0019756758,
0.0279328022,
0.0270603504,
0.0251347963,
-0.015898902,
0.0176599771,
-0.0025420992,
0.0789447948,
0.0505561307,
0.0863776132,
-0.0218916554,
-0.0179912727,
-0.0587984025,
-0.0237717051,
0.0057081101,
0.0011917162,
0.0455496311,
-0.0080619324,
0.0592879504,
0.0365745388,
0.0189878345,
-0.0134885479,
0.0294837616,
-0.026201617,
-0.027730437,
0.0488419309,
-0.0004000139,
0.0225962438,
0.028324414,
-0.0606277883,
0.0027550354,
0.0272805467,
0.0186202023,
-0.0300470162,
-0.0607390553,
0.0440674424,
0.0177778024,
-0.0279891696,
-0.0622914322,
-0.0222337972,
-0.0147590414,
0.0311369784,
-0.026377257,
-0.0097067365,
0.0497163907,
-0.0134032546,
-0.030639125,
-0.0817097351,
0.0292741433,
-0.0440151803,
0.081348896,
-0.0156406928,
0.0367249735,
0.0319734924,
0.0005645372,
-0.082840085,
0.0110236956,
0.0198140219,
-0.0221196916,
0.0437435433,
-0.0550839901,
-0.0369753651,
0.0079589589,
0.0179525372,
-0.0667123646,
-0.0166162215,
0.013324026,
-0.0310838837,
0.0059236703,
-0.0068595172,
-0.0536031909,
-0.0006398588,
0.0292661842,
0.0417987071,
-0.0514714718,
-0.0215702709,
0.0173048321,
0.0736483559,
0.090385668,
0.02957692,
0.0431775078,
-0.079846032,
0.067623049,
0.0321542881,
-0.0065599871,
-0.0132523272,
0.0536081493,
0.0098353866,
0.0011629027,
-0.0241263304,
0.0198259931,
0.0270122737,
0.0780359581,
-0.0510626324,
-0.0455810688,
0.0826566964,
0.0588031448,
-0.0198686346,
0.0118444767,
-0.0317564048,
0.0446712486,
0.001653168,
0.0280359574,
-0.0513093285,
-0.0200989917,
-0.0105559053,
0.0213843193,
-0.0280987192,
-0.0423109643,
-0.0465294831,
-0.1046703309,
0.0185440239,
0.0085179275,
-0.0797841847,
0.0085725803,
0.0290634278,
-0.0193123631,
0.0402733795,
0.0134198247,
0.0141158625,
0.0039488478,
0.0448112115,
-0.0119342208,
0.0142385988,
0.0049002813,
-0.0126782218,
-0.0284288228,
0.0292571001,
0.0516733304,
0.0240710992,
0.0025382442,
0.0249554999,
-0.047363963,
-0.0173427127,
-0.0204193071,
0.0245757829,
0.0457699075,
-0.0149191543,
-0.0039981287,
-0.011091195,
0.0751162693,
0.0044601872,
-0.0240968242,
0.0549899749,
0.0057043564,
0.0208193511,
-0.0338268131,
-0.0139172459,
0.0479353778,
-0.0018722138,
0.0849705264,
0.0364451446,
-0.0359917134,
0.0184755176,
-0.0507505909,
0.0111555699,
-0.1385586411,
0.0003548207,
0.0097700972,
0.0154391564,
0.0510924347,
-0.0938772634,
-0.0667868257,
0.0306439679,
0.0357151963,
-0.0102214813,
-0.0103751644,
-0.0189932566,
0.0207938347,
-0.0136252353,
0.0088940337,
0.0004769104,
-0.0120254103,
-0.0428972878,
-0.0133848563,
-0.0095609091,
-0.0988507271,
-0.009168596,
0.0040217242,
-0.0815345943,
-0.0298950765,
-0.0229595434,
0.0100332405,
0.0099900374,
0.0113328584,
0.0194065962,
-0.0182435606,
0.0378987417,
0.0073789451,
-0.027712686,
0.0118665667,
-0.0378634557,
0.0253685862,
-0.0036065185,
0.0044946447,
-0.0354936309,
0.0033353472,
-0.0261201262,
0.0571448244,
0.0080520324,
-0.0404047407,
0.0135101695,
-0.009256972,
-0.0451186486,
-0.0277496539,
-0.0297629833,
-0.0477414988,
-0.0013452953,
-0.023734333,
-0.0186169371,
-0.0445352085,
0.0136757875,
0.0019860666,
-0.0325053595,
-0.0132964794,
-0.0154853202,
-0.0294494927,
0.0519629307,
-0.0579910949,
-0.0072283666,
0.0124758985,
-0.0168707501,
-0.0073792054,
0.0040680692,
-0.0215594303,
-0.0012825513,
-0.0346192792,
0.0574048758,
0.0373655669,
0.0784007907,
0.0031842145,
-0.0173408687,
-0.0040747938,
0.0093635637,
-0.081724152,
-0.0026206879,
0.0006534649,
0.0407120213,
-0.0004526172,
0.0188456848,
0.0069644735,
0.028809322,
0.0085953297,
-0.0042022699,
0.0012187876,
0.0289486665,
0.0038182086,
0.0151701374,
0.0112082735,
0.0006401513,
0.0126747284,
0.0546214059,
-0.0344708823,
0.0592923574,
0.0102348775,
0.0190138593,
-0.0459342487,
-0.0156262051,
0.0164852645,
0.0546800643,
0.0251388308,
0.0381326713,
-0.0587473921,
-0.0092987707,
0.0405057855,
0.0283688605,
0.0223612376,
-0.0201646574,
0.0083925053,
0.052676782,
-0.0270412024,
-0.0127179688,
-0.0560731776,
0.0184715707,
-0.0484481938,
-0.0113973096,
-0.0095374538,
-5.739450718e-33,
-0.0150521835,
-0.0410947464,
0.0212969985,
-0.0460098721,
-0.0490242727,
-0.0121403355,
-0.0253897458,
0.0039444584,
-0.0253331214,
0.0055880831,
0.0078019775,
-0.007080528,
-0.0190680698,
0.0423922762,
-0.0288993269,
-0.0271901041,
0.01885584,
0.0040230057,
-0.0542130359,
0.0534720607,
0.039481692,
0.0233734474,
0.0048615658,
0.0254960302,
0.0132927392,
-0.0728583261,
-0.0115352431,
0.0048346771,
-0.0068635675,
0.0512486324,
-0.0260664765,
0.0100222258,
0.0266407467,
-0.0196201056,
0.0200832114,
0.0288985297,
-0.005163481,
-0.0513579622,
0.0105551323,
-0.0287971348,
-0.0404076539,
-0.0648672804,
0.0079523278,
-0.0082145715,
0.0480720587,
-0.0548574105,
0.0341459289,
0.0007321795,
0.0065546948,
-0.0273045655,
-0.0676676631,
-0.0011005766,
-0.0291640051,
-0.0707143769,
-0.0716371536,
0.1300873607,
0.0345834792,
0.0161004998,
0.0038318387,
0.044617597,
0.030481752,
-0.0078338068,
0.003363241,
0.034153726,
-0.0408698954,
0.0446529426,
0.0070634894,
-0.0134959584,
-0.021716699,
0.0124985576,
-0.0183874276,
0.0092383781,
0.0611236952,
0.1098052561,
0.0139075583,
0.0437436812,
-0.0818744376,
0.0847329497,
0.0254733991,
-0.0383840799,
0.0163961537,
-0.0400893129,
-0.0255627073,
-0.0062929508,
-0.0444757082,
0.0242608432,
-0.0224470273,
-0.00780953,
0.0421017148,
-0.0343351439,
-0.0662541687,
0.0048225098,
0.0263950154,
-0.0135858962,
0.0278093405,
0.0219784994,
-0.05859337,
0.0252652429,
0.0028941324,
0.0321024284,
-0.0296819843,
0.0380823389,
0.0707164705,
0.0107469866,
-0.0013527512,
0.0269982107,
0.0238130558,
0.017445948,
-0.0410548672,
0.002306551,
-0.002004189,
0.0361224003,
-0.0223031174,
0.0273876023,
-0.0197634827,
0.007515532,
-0.0240513589,
0.0338846333,
0.0034223457,
-0.0346120186,
-0.0413587391,
-0.0709663257,
-0.0259059705,
0.0127230957,
-0.0397425145,
0.0231651701,
-0.0034438372,
-0.0203354172,
-0.0075310585,
-0.0345762856,
-0.0165013168,
-0.0038790782,
2.48e-7,
-0.0066261799,
-0.0001285049,
0.0094561959,
0.0195624642,
-0.0151716238,
0.0333369412,
0.011344105,
0.0246706214,
0.0191092473,
-0.0222631637,
0.0176252127,
0.0366240852,
0.0292474274,
0.0303412955,
-0.0613246858,
-0.0211592838,
-0.0492272861,
0.0161933247,
-0.0410721488,
-0.0151962033,
0.0853305161,
0.035620831,
0.0010711364,
-0.016824875,
0.0167905875,
-0.0217685774,
0.0368371494,
-0.0121570257,
-0.0357699059,
0.0552855246,
-0.0091486126,
0.0035968188,
-0.0098831607,
-0.0234450828,
-0.0118881371,
0.0401531905,
0.0067832498,
0.0222652871,
0.0137743466,
-0.0379063562,
0.0119235646,
0.0252772793,
0.0047461176,
-0.080847837,
0.0834963843,
0.0031972814,
-0.0199994501,
0.0136757614,
-0.0121851061,
0.0092842532,
-0.0022795442,
-0.0377854556,
-0.0261902455,
0.0114867436,
0.0102226669,
-0.0046302485,
0.0281300843,
-0.0504998043,
-0.0143589545,
-0.0227931626,
-0.0293132048,
-0.0235721357,
-0.0238620006,
-0.0347900838,
-0.058601141,
-0.0450644679,
0.0085416306,
1.957638675e-34,
0.0088028535,
-0.0121339234,
-0.0087942211,
0.0048818854,
0.024895411,
-0.0304430332,
0.0160070974,
-0.0359226763,
0.0463959984,
-0.0760263726,
-0.0359704942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16436v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16436v2 | DDCoT: Duty-Distinct Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Multimodal Reasoning in Language Models | 2023-10-25T08:03:10 | 2023-10-26T04:16:52 | Ge Zheng, Bin Yang, Jiajin Tang, Hong-Yu Zhou, Sibei Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | A long-standing goal of AI systems is to perform complex multimodal reasoning
like humans. Recently, large language models (LLMs) have made remarkable
strides in such multi-step reasoning on the language modality solely by
leveraging the chain of thought (CoT) to mimic human thinking. However, the
transfer of these advancements to multimodal contexts introduces heightened
challenges, including but not limited to the impractical need for
labor-intensive annotation and the limitations in terms of flexibility,
generalizability, and explainability. To evoke CoT reasoning in multimodality,
this work first conducts an in-depth analysis of these challenges posed by
multimodality and presents two key insights: "keeping critical thinking" and
"letting everyone do their jobs" in multimodal CoT reasoning. Furthermore, this
study proposes a novel DDCoT prompting that maintains a critical attitude
through negative-space prompting and incorporates multimodality into reasoning
by first dividing the reasoning responsibility of LLMs into reasoning and
recognition and then integrating the visual recognition capability of visual
models into the joint reasoning process. The rationales generated by DDCoT not
only improve the reasoning abilities of both large and small language models in
zero-shot prompting and fine-tuning learning, significantly outperforming
state-of-the-art methods but also exhibit impressive generalizability and
explainability. | [
0.0343662538,
0.0169272367,
-0.0282840449,
0.0477648601,
-0.0652267933,
0.0311707277,
0.0445865169,
-0.0190753974,
-0.0039957394,
-0.0691704825,
-0.0441825949,
-0.0345380642,
0.003714001,
0.0219882149,
0.0502767228,
-0.0692451149,
0.0447649881,
-0.0449694917,
0.0078007048,
-0.0220246725,
0.0347902067,
0.0293567553,
-0.0621770173,
0.0418854877,
-0.0407468416,
-0.0254712142,
-0.0423800386,
0.0128853535,
0.0152167771,
-0.0391994044,
-0.0353107303,
0.0505215488,
0.0458642244,
0.0401761122,
0.0000022651,
-0.0730202347,
0.0030884491,
-0.0195389204,
-0.0186881796,
-0.046359662,
-0.01550443,
0.0019687742,
0.0265003331,
-0.0033895301,
-0.033727657,
0.0164396875,
0.0595009811,
0.043029204,
0.0684649795,
0.0141709372,
-0.008019343,
-0.0308754966,
-0.0220232438,
0.0089342492,
-0.0128359748,
-0.0237130728,
-0.0242608692,
0.0327369757,
0.0463052988,
0.006266275,
-0.0500991344,
0.0403918885,
0.029711483,
-0.0297202878,
-0.0269487333,
0.0254058652,
-0.0062415837,
-0.0580775477,
-0.0326240063,
0.083680518,
0.0172822475,
-0.0072655487,
-0.0052896263,
0.0132119879,
0.00882194,
0.0222931653,
-0.0703787282,
0.0694441721,
-0.0239862762,
0.0027999023,
-0.0262652654,
0.0082137594,
0.0067656226,
0.0154856993,
-0.0243062768,
0.0397736579,
-0.0186968092,
-0.0045138397,
0.028520342,
0.0171950292,
-0.0194716435,
-0.0597015396,
-0.0153663382,
0.0569215566,
-0.0361121893,
0.0046533085,
0.0143817551,
-0.0120338742,
0.0113519561,
0.0107339835,
0.0579811148,
0.0351417102,
-0.0594136342,
0.0637519211,
-0.0288532525,
0.0169522688,
-0.026244672,
0.064768143,
-0.0103132101,
-0.020951055,
-0.0604253933,
-0.026662983,
-0.0250742696,
0.008068799,
-0.0217222124,
-0.0342959948,
0.015673345,
0.0159478206,
-0.0299133174,
0.00752975,
0.0074599963,
0.012583931,
0.0229015145,
-0.0213140864,
-0.0459115058,
0.0638035014,
-0.0523989946,
0.0218794458,
0.0242137667,
-0.0355979949,
-0.0115814721,
0.0117550148,
-0.0010669277,
-0.0217691492,
0.0064136498,
0.0902151391,
-0.0298076011,
0.0043248311,
-0.017905131,
-0.0580749288,
-0.0253812596,
-0.0835570097,
0.0517341383,
-0.0364192165,
0.002005236,
0.0217942297,
0.0123986648,
0.0005966761,
0.0030839744,
0.0023663,
-0.0199292284,
0.0979595035,
-0.0169044454,
0.0191935673,
0.0191607699,
0.0161626004,
-0.0385861211,
0.0601898991,
0.0374446735,
0.0127967382,
0.0280155782,
0.0081839217,
0.0165852588,
0.0243859794,
-0.0070412494,
0.0028142668,
-0.0250737388,
-0.0177825224,
-0.0338568948,
0.0450705588,
0.0063855657,
0.0322076567,
-0.0159608908,
0.0096984785,
0.0460447669,
0.0378081091,
-0.0057765106,
-0.0426939018,
0.0685156807,
-0.0146078402,
-0.0014240897,
0.0129088834,
-0.0315156244,
0.1007799804,
-0.0321814232,
-0.021882616,
0.005784817,
0.0248244796,
-0.0198489036,
-0.0292086229,
-0.024069028,
0.0184607562,
0.0224326625,
0.0267296676,
0.0389448479,
0.0276709665,
-0.0203812197,
-0.0142957326,
0.0227644313,
-0.0502553843,
-0.0405826494,
-0.0608845428,
0.0227580257,
0.0516963378,
0.0229553096,
-0.0011403881,
-0.036464043,
-0.0221096408,
0.0733060092,
0.051779002,
0.006838399,
-0.0059350808,
-0.0231022127,
-0.0537320673,
-0.0388023369,
-0.0069498671,
0.005224505,
0.0182312131,
-0.0481865853,
-0.0094333366,
-0.0220791101,
-0.0056699626,
0.0221315436,
0.0188355986,
0.0360926613,
0.0269557796,
-0.059226431,
0.0573286489,
-0.0154043613,
0.008819419,
0.0131446216,
0.0025421749,
-0.0024613217,
-0.0419629253,
-0.0157337431,
0.0431389175,
-0.0434894189,
-0.0242876653,
0.0126572344,
-0.0655570626,
-0.0074449549,
-0.0189728215,
-0.0161522124,
-0.0323535651,
0.0216232054,
-0.0115039647,
-0.0168058071,
-0.0514987558,
-0.0139453234,
0.0088009564,
0.0003864257,
-0.0277739372,
0.0517083146,
-0.0383770913,
-0.0303011667,
0.0324396044,
0.0186624154,
0.0296429433,
-0.0096587958,
-0.0130490419,
0.0574522279,
0.0098950602,
0.0111143207,
-0.012812675,
0.0206245873,
-0.0442724377,
0.003431242,
-0.0884929672,
-0.0283802282,
-0.0074290116,
-0.0378608257,
-0.0085732602,
-0.0309184454,
0.0075933496,
-0.0236331392,
-0.020128563,
0.0575175509,
0.0198624004,
0.0195034072,
0.0498378426,
-0.0131720705,
0.008232289,
0.0153127434,
0.0061077322,
-0.0193163753,
0.0803888068,
0.0010438263,
-0.0144820027,
-0.0401185267,
-0.0121155092,
-0.0601706095,
0.0035280837,
-0.0099401074,
-0.028013153,
0.0715240762,
-0.022929145,
0.0180989243,
0.0602371134,
-0.0034750262,
0.0146078737,
0.0593858138,
-0.0230596475,
-0.0362567306,
0.0220050886,
0.0252380501,
-0.0012083879,
0.0162308291,
-0.0110640563,
-0.0387465656,
0.0715741292,
-0.0170334484,
-0.0033411237,
-0.081852667,
0.0503909439,
0.0110285329,
-0.0427718759,
-0.0516341589,
-0.0303705353,
-0.0001930353,
0.0830726326,
-0.0242793597,
-0.0341558009,
0.0758735687,
-0.0352557451,
-0.0171028227,
0.01260552,
0.0185202733,
-0.0200733263,
0.1122970879,
-0.016382983,
0.0189886261,
0.0408406034,
0.0264861733,
-0.0734027997,
-0.0048107421,
0.0270809643,
-0.0017185583,
0.0426049791,
-0.053868819,
-0.0088948701,
-0.0093538631,
-0.0231500361,
-0.032586351,
0.0317775831,
-0.0721695125,
-0.0057049524,
-0.0549687706,
0.0078615583,
0.0088459989,
0.0183739066,
0.0525037907,
0.0144474367,
0.0017019255,
-0.0086987605,
-0.0238549616,
0.0065364842,
0.0321476795,
0.0554919466,
-0.0008259173,
-0.0449150503,
0.0239915065,
0.0447022133,
0.0116817439,
-0.0053065396,
-0.0283082779,
0.0334488638,
0.0189142786,
0.0625366345,
-0.0269406904,
-0.010043107,
0.06559439,
-0.0553352684,
0.0126659302,
0.0845248029,
0.0140084745,
-0.0574243031,
0.0112610981,
-0.0382838771,
0.0418160446,
0.0562511608,
0.0021088598,
-0.0854112953,
-0.0677607805,
0.0194538198,
-0.0228462368,
-0.0068108565,
-0.038676165,
-0.0355692655,
-0.1038193479,
0.0567847788,
-0.0395191684,
-0.0151783274,
0.0169733446,
-0.0121713877,
0.0098435171,
0.044429522,
-0.0315195881,
0.0199302696,
0.0281124767,
-0.0038372765,
0.022483727,
0.037660636,
-0.0202902891,
0.0354892686,
-0.0399337672,
0.0127913887,
0.007327809,
0.0243635513,
0.0301686265,
-0.063554734,
0.0539543405,
0.0031618068,
0.033516597,
-0.0357323959,
0.0280369166,
-0.0091268122,
-0.0254173838,
-0.0199579559,
0.0311540086,
0.0199954323,
-0.0385264568,
-0.0207043625,
0.0920676664,
-0.0540473573,
-0.0015729158,
-0.043796815,
0.0500079766,
-0.0188976731,
0.0519883744,
0.0436595045,
-0.0619985163,
-0.0136668598,
-0.015200627,
-0.0170550328,
-0.0381937884,
-0.0515120253,
0.0235902146,
0.0300954916,
0.0117352549,
-0.0692382976,
-0.0169840194,
0.0201721806,
0.090722844,
0.0102656642,
-0.0119817248,
-0.035275463,
0.0408676229,
-0.0198316127,
0.0374406278,
-0.0251749251,
0.0336756073,
-0.0076124282,
0.0178239457,
0.0009188743,
-0.0522797853,
-0.0251369085,
0.021347994,
-0.0519293398,
-0.0427710526,
-0.0502493307,
0.0652195811,
0.0338778272,
0.0127802929,
0.0338026732,
-0.0661455616,
0.0013475753,
0.0226074327,
0.0375025868,
0.0059388299,
0.0283538345,
0.0060977861,
0.0063322522,
0.0454046316,
-0.0256053749,
0.014527156,
-0.0016015583,
0.0415681154,
-0.016938312,
-0.0023795883,
0.0209558997,
0.0037876545,
0.0175792072,
-0.0286658518,
-0.0107489349,
-0.0459964685,
0.0172982141,
0.010644353,
-0.0449312329,
-0.0598131791,
0.0345974155,
-0.0259670373,
-0.013584381,
0.0213883091,
-0.0549935959,
0.0304741692,
0.0157741159,
0.0095997909,
0.0170427561,
0.0567590334,
0.0140655627,
-0.0331375189,
0.0196150318,
0.0075177224,
0.0267840251,
-0.0202868059,
0.0189220924,
-0.0248781312,
0.1441992223,
0.0553460233,
-0.0433170944,
-0.0456649326,
0.0383039303,
-0.0289232954,
-0.0439415239,
0.0487722382,
0.0310636163,
0.071526736,
0.0205785129,
0.0267458893,
-0.0251144897,
-0.0042910893,
0.0425595306,
0.0506529734,
0.0251597576,
-0.0434005298,
0.03424678,
0.0227385554,
0.0183353741,
0.0032777961,
0.0326253101,
-0.0621291846,
0.0258652791,
-0.0187077057,
0.0067618391,
-0.0457417853,
-0.0369939022,
-0.0052470546,
0.0242665093,
0.0196120422,
0.0409834981,
-0.0956731364,
-0.0666356236,
-0.0261938944,
0.0155850081,
-0.0092436317,
-0.0038379587,
0.0420765206,
0.0487919897,
0.0127289146,
-0.0291172136,
-0.0156781189,
-0.0225954019,
0.013481305,
0.019865904,
-0.0044526341,
-6.755945131e-33,
-0.0113538746,
-0.04863289,
0.0393116064,
-0.0236675348,
-0.0387345068,
-0.0044315117,
-0.0429740399,
0.0128468173,
-0.0240960717,
0.0352848656,
0.0067148404,
-0.03763346,
-0.0065998039,
0.0116833346,
0.0282726008,
0.0054388875,
-0.0016006024,
0.0121420398,
-0.0351258107,
-0.0023764842,
0.0581311695,
0.0002068328,
0.0180650931,
-0.0388139039,
0.0265009739,
0.0189457554,
-0.0437671617,
0.0568598621,
-0.0408513024,
0.0492347926,
-0.0292127803,
0.0009818915,
0.0377665088,
-0.0112671889,
-0.0000173592,
0.0315992571,
-0.0639095306,
-0.0117832441,
0.0423139073,
0.0013807872,
-0.0824147537,
-0.0107644135,
0.0132809067,
-0.0137357926,
-0.0050559365,
-0.0138659105,
0.034902703,
-0.0175388474,
0.022227576,
0.0343385115,
-0.060933385,
-0.0138883842,
-0.0313162357,
-0.0671613365,
0.0196019225,
0.0518408604,
0.0032997178,
0.0176576767,
-0.0241526626,
0.0442150496,
-0.0358997881,
-0.0393771641,
0.1059959456,
0.0207061078,
-0.0098197088,
0.0789448768,
0.0235506836,
0.0002731551,
-0.0529473051,
-0.0098054139,
0.0277209152,
0.0540812574,
0.0393803082,
0.0616061799,
0.0046988945,
0.0256553292,
-0.0443908572,
-0.018090643,
-0.0414769128,
0.0565486327,
0.0402014144,
0.0074961353,
-0.0123018473,
-0.0056543108,
-0.0333268158,
-0.0437677614,
-0.0473844074,
-0.0031577882,
0.0203459058,
-0.0095851626,
-0.0302697718,
-0.011334409,
0.0726801828,
-0.035503719,
-0.0025520041,
-0.0092669325,
-0.0106012095,
0.0561507083,
0.0051742964,
0.0068649137,
0.0103235021,
-0.0094684483,
0.0316984728,
0.0223060716,
0.0319823548,
0.019735286,
0.0636793375,
0.0259823501,
-0.0077046831,
-0.0011572359,
-0.0823752284,
0.014374109,
-0.0340272821,
0.0108163832,
0.021984702,
0.0126292901,
-0.056059774,
0.0169797111,
0.0075524119,
-0.0187813584,
-0.0134074502,
-0.0107739791,
-0.0435115658,
0.0068319445,
-0.0475538634,
0.0080226148,
-0.0462134555,
-0.040891964,
0.0275742654,
-0.0779566094,
-0.0160449985,
0.0360371619,
2.946e-7,
0.0164220575,
0.043455828,
-0.0149234021,
-0.0086442977,
0.0423172191,
0.0481728539,
-0.0420558825,
-0.0093037346,
0.0071699214,
-0.0578686632,
-0.0139085008,
0.0596880428,
0.0635814369,
0.0193413701,
-0.0388980918,
-0.0196306314,
-0.0263525061,
-0.0348071307,
-0.0537715182,
0.0412443615,
0.0773776099,
0.0176242385,
0.0020590296,
-0.0534367934,
0.0123537919,
-0.0295317657,
0.0465009324,
-0.0138361771,
0.0447676592,
-0.0304384269,
0.0209995378,
-0.0087057436,
0.0077360123,
0.0208990648,
0.0310252514,
-0.0343322158,
0.022293875,
0.0193932783,
-0.0202290919,
-0.035162203,
-0.016645737,
0.0024994742,
-0.0166975781,
-0.0756987855,
0.0962994546,
-0.04064795,
-0.0245663449,
-0.0201552007,
0.0255076196,
-0.0343185514,
0.0085016442,
-0.0159342047,
-0.0328193456,
0.0283658132,
0.0015459029,
-0.0204636343,
-0.0200490635,
-0.0943449885,
-0.0315626115,
0.0127014313,
-0.0297699831,
-0.0086013516,
-0.0100819468,
-0.0324883424,
0.0443231389,
-0.0529273562,
-0.0549523942,
2.582144156e-34,
0.0187796261,
-0.0281769689,
0.0391427428,
0.0105429376,
0.0324875861,
0.0049701612,
-0.0285778921,
-0.0233336594,
0.0203967039,
-0.0554459654,
-0.0457074158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16427v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16427v2 | PromptAgent: Strategic Planning with Language Models Enables Expert-level Prompt Optimization | 2023-10-25T07:47:01 | 2023-12-07T14:39:22 | Xinyuan Wang, Chenxi Li, Zhen Wang, Fan Bai, Haotian Luo, Jiayou Zhang, Nebojsa Jojic, Eric P. Xing, Zhiting Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Highly effective, task-specific prompts are often heavily engineered by
experts to integrate detailed instructions and domain insights based on a deep
understanding of both instincts of large language models (LLMs) and the
intricacies of the target task. However, automating the generation of such
expert-level prompts remains elusive. Existing prompt optimization methods tend
to overlook the depth of domain knowledge and struggle to efficiently explore
the vast space of expert-level prompts. Addressing this, we present
PromptAgent, an optimization method that autonomously crafts prompts equivalent
in quality to those handcrafted by experts. At its core, PromptAgent views
prompt optimization as a strategic planning problem and employs a principled
planning algorithm, rooted in Monte Carlo tree search, to strategically
navigate the expert-level prompt space. Inspired by human-like trial-and-error
exploration, PromptAgent induces precise expert-level insights and in-depth
instructions by reflecting on model errors and generating constructive error
feedback. Such a novel framework allows the agent to iteratively examine
intermediate prompts (states), refine them based on error feedbacks (actions),
simulate future rewards, and search for high-reward paths leading to expert
prompts. We apply PromptAgent to 12 tasks spanning three practical domains:
BIG-Bench Hard (BBH), as well as domain-specific and general NLP tasks, showing
it significantly outperforms strong Chain-of-Thought and recent prompt
optimization baselines. Extensive analyses emphasize its capability to craft
expert-level, detailed, and domain-insightful prompts with great efficiency and
generalizability. | [
0.0790225714,
0.0211201347,
-0.0057930839,
0.0018690476,
-0.0376433246,
-0.0162650757,
-0.0152322315,
0.0035357769,
-0.0057878993,
-0.0177355967,
-0.0230614804,
0.0000330406,
-0.022046173,
0.0575424582,
0.0010869687,
-0.0515813902,
0.0342555009,
-0.0528438836,
0.0621567704,
-0.0102646938,
-0.0039620497,
-0.0181687269,
-0.0264868885,
0.0332093425,
-0.0243324004,
-0.0000960099,
-0.066590555,
0.0264425538,
0.0150908167,
-0.0565362126,
0.020749636,
0.0494611189,
0.0270200185,
0.0087867798,
0.0000022241,
-0.0598634928,
-0.0246696007,
-0.0447527319,
-0.044122871,
-0.0316165239,
0.0221964195,
-0.0033415304,
-0.0131527074,
-0.0035274669,
-0.049632553,
0.0113139823,
0.0372857898,
0.0425544828,
0.0699962378,
0.0776391029,
0.017818315,
0.0233062562,
-0.009649408,
-0.0162635949,
-0.0018728763,
-0.0995279551,
0.0073108296,
-0.0216471311,
0.0239468943,
0.0513031185,
0.0020132188,
0.0040128855,
0.0096033812,
-0.0237191357,
-0.0103488639,
0.0371373631,
0.0643322319,
-0.0274739452,
-0.045180589,
0.0366366059,
-0.021534713,
-0.0041047032,
0.0237784553,
-0.0270529054,
0.012413389,
0.0033435205,
-0.0037478835,
0.0420709215,
-0.0181809869,
-0.0032986198,
0.0113190394,
0.0106328623,
0.004065007,
0.0066190022,
-0.003015568,
0.0811643079,
-0.0081416015,
-0.0395806842,
0.051874239,
-0.0138724791,
0.0025124943,
-0.0914973542,
0.0115568163,
0.0479495041,
-0.1255144924,
0.0262860358,
-0.0039584292,
0.0059044287,
-0.013117916,
0.0547239669,
0.0601091869,
0.058736559,
0.0007297021,
0.037431743,
0.0159393437,
0.0494767465,
-0.0055107987,
-0.0193646792,
-0.0412216336,
0.0147285806,
-0.0507023744,
-0.0095839147,
-0.0754873976,
0.0049927849,
-0.0382220633,
-0.0246966314,
-0.0082357526,
0.0402442813,
-0.0278360173,
0.0449322648,
0.0154411662,
0.0459048375,
-0.035108272,
-0.0305937156,
-0.0815824196,
-0.0238667428,
-0.0930483863,
-0.0040539918,
0.0385214053,
0.0042659701,
-0.0093257669,
0.0178713184,
-0.0167245027,
-0.0073476196,
0.0232441239,
0.0821360424,
-0.021399444,
0.0059558353,
-0.0192160998,
-0.0446369648,
-0.0048196041,
-0.043096181,
0.012162664,
-0.0359793305,
0.0341880545,
-0.0215105973,
-0.0155719332,
-0.0381540507,
0.0197043028,
0.0012544757,
0.0194363613,
0.0650609136,
0.0062909662,
0.0274004582,
0.017018253,
-0.004196594,
-0.0373856425,
0.0553638749,
0.0141189685,
0.0959499776,
0.0231035892,
0.0186102446,
0.0355211124,
0.0491171777,
-0.0260211527,
-0.0000540974,
0.0103264842,
0.0084692808,
-0.0138459038,
0.0858817548,
0.0129896943,
-0.0037370124,
-0.0181999262,
0.0400870331,
0.0209052563,
0.0229146089,
-0.0271767825,
-0.0133837704,
0.0866413265,
0.01626225,
-0.0356575511,
-0.0275196061,
-0.0490237884,
0.0332961306,
-0.0307997763,
0.0019738467,
-0.0136312023,
-0.0077074892,
-0.0013211026,
-0.0380349346,
0.017953638,
0.0379290096,
-0.0034901691,
0.031829711,
0.0217610691,
0.0034822777,
-0.077977255,
0.0194154475,
-0.0090094395,
0.0249169432,
-0.0202605594,
-0.0656655133,
0.0051672384,
0.0870183855,
0.0330023766,
-0.0500763915,
-0.0315846764,
0.0079984013,
-0.0093777217,
0.0454725437,
0.026734937,
-0.0448069908,
-0.0294959415,
-0.0374373384,
-0.0555997528,
-0.0324322395,
0.0190687533,
0.0544774123,
0.0261145309,
-0.0121739861,
-0.0036430978,
0.0168911256,
-0.0110406363,
0.0243238248,
-0.0258213319,
-0.0547963381,
0.0149196843,
-0.0069891028,
0.0241182689,
0.0212884545,
-0.0111643309,
0.0334553719,
0.0237505864,
-0.0054030535,
-0.018968571,
-0.0411161222,
-0.0359579846,
0.009778671,
0.0254078936,
-0.0247911736,
-0.0227828342,
-0.0033103384,
-0.0263893567,
-0.0411011353,
-0.0170821957,
-0.0257790852,
-0.014749852,
0.0032560802,
0.0247747041,
-0.0083982097,
-0.0616054386,
-0.0480216742,
0.0707950816,
0.0238307845,
-0.0234360266,
0.0707798377,
0.0142740859,
0.0062205046,
-0.0625581741,
0.0011899616,
0.0052844542,
0.0082192905,
-0.0003520354,
0.0694955438,
0.048042804,
-0.0492039174,
-0.0602666251,
-0.1063954085,
0.0142958872,
-0.0361442976,
-0.0111217285,
0.0213155393,
-0.0079533653,
-0.0253245253,
-0.0077087255,
-0.0157328807,
0.0215494297,
-0.0117349988,
0.0128548285,
0.0334135033,
0.0391102955,
0.0021636721,
-0.0295666941,
0.0017766084,
-0.032507237,
-0.028502157,
0.0109997112,
-0.0046021617,
-0.0666626394,
0.043226067,
0.0003505552,
0.037519116,
-0.0071472814,
-0.0139685962,
0.0442689247,
-0.0376546755,
0.0477059931,
0.0626220554,
0.0113741914,
0.0498948209,
0.0545560829,
-0.0382058695,
-0.0730436146,
0.0580543429,
-0.0333003625,
-0.0278529506,
-0.0499686711,
-0.0378227942,
0.0534276627,
0.0858947858,
0.0004982679,
0.0223874263,
-0.065708451,
0.0182475895,
0.0061754491,
-0.0321530513,
-0.0126843425,
-0.0123789096,
-0.0136738606,
0.0792002156,
-0.0108961537,
-0.015036596,
0.0986951888,
-0.0029652838,
-0.014941508,
-0.0173970927,
-0.0287335012,
-0.0254367664,
0.0672347248,
-0.0111256549,
0.0149399089,
0.024766583,
-0.0110110082,
-0.0415200852,
0.0257158875,
0.0202619545,
-0.003749348,
-0.0121271266,
-0.0486834645,
-0.0144819962,
0.0150081636,
-0.0481029861,
-0.0452682339,
-0.013483542,
-0.0568289533,
-0.0036453602,
0.054441046,
-0.0261577349,
-0.0379503034,
-0.0174619108,
0.0395940952,
0.04896117,
-0.0105370125,
-0.0300285704,
-0.0370052122,
-0.0246946234,
0.0748188198,
0.0279287118,
0.0327371769,
-0.0239244699,
0.0255070794,
0.0060196365,
0.0234340224,
-0.0185529497,
-0.0236443561,
0.0088511072,
0.0386543833,
-0.0413804501,
-0.0060105813,
0.0680735484,
0.0247520581,
-0.0538830459,
-0.0214338843,
0.090781346,
0.0389814414,
-0.0434599333,
0.0142853297,
-0.0383602045,
0.025969062,
0.0229818188,
0.0601739436,
-0.0489655584,
-0.0475910641,
0.0087601542,
0.0227197092,
-0.0246803593,
-0.0465941615,
-0.0085037211,
-0.1334581524,
0.0348180495,
-0.0342323668,
-0.0204230603,
-0.0001907275,
-0.0136819184,
-0.0113105914,
0.008894871,
-0.017201839,
0.0202039611,
0.0095048184,
0.0005638963,
0.0169190224,
0.001737483,
-0.0345552862,
0.0318341292,
0.0030306613,
0.0429363288,
0.1008341834,
-0.0024619428,
0.0025410657,
0.0009211706,
0.0296912901,
0.0274697095,
0.0383645371,
-0.0182864759,
-0.0159019753,
-0.0232572742,
0.0111269709,
-0.0008476747,
0.0242542475,
-0.0040633734,
-0.0231773052,
0.0545151457,
0.0762816221,
-0.0388099402,
-0.0295460075,
-0.0078967065,
0.0136743542,
0.0489697196,
0.0535529181,
-0.0155408662,
-0.0503896363,
-0.0444166772,
-0.047284402,
-0.0016197885,
-0.0641226247,
-0.0420071371,
0.0011689491,
0.0086653233,
0.0214812886,
-0.0461446308,
-0.0660197735,
0.0661229193,
0.0485918485,
0.0276311934,
-0.0457372256,
-0.0312160645,
0.0172439218,
-0.0050175474,
0.0172646958,
-0.0235583168,
0.0047559063,
-0.0681562498,
-0.0190094355,
0.0023180943,
-0.0576515496,
-0.0016970866,
0.0089155007,
-0.0149472812,
-0.0491253845,
-0.023031,
0.0820516795,
0.0233827941,
0.0163442381,
-0.0165732577,
-0.0426242501,
0.0542749055,
0.0065436452,
-0.0583927557,
-0.0091187265,
0.0233805943,
0.0295137223,
-0.0099335341,
0.0207531899,
-0.063522622,
0.0106897829,
0.0195709374,
0.0626976863,
-0.0020702237,
-0.0556872338,
0.029647436,
0.0110850353,
0.0255627129,
-0.0430440232,
-0.0304509122,
-0.0137034087,
-0.0068425792,
-0.0003093043,
-0.0428733341,
-0.0436377823,
0.0326643921,
0.0125416704,
-0.0280024391,
0.0698102117,
0.0150237493,
-0.0005098629,
-0.0156638045,
-0.0250540301,
0.0070069572,
0.0234265458,
0.0221545473,
0.056911774,
-0.0111742169,
0.0031407357,
0.0297026113,
0.017435234,
0.0517713651,
0.0208595674,
0.0841532052,
0.0469503142,
-0.0376178846,
-0.0397362038,
0.0132852765,
-0.0394974388,
-0.0937086865,
0.0168722756,
0.057998091,
0.0657114983,
0.0233009569,
-0.0034313414,
-0.077542901,
0.0146445073,
0.0188091807,
-0.0382081233,
0.0315609947,
-0.0605052784,
0.0368049815,
0.0497281663,
0.0023205241,
-0.016578231,
0.0243806299,
-0.0029221049,
0.0512459427,
0.0040654796,
-0.0080673099,
-0.0461172089,
-0.0117297322,
0.0086138528,
0.0254626255,
-0.0328533947,
0.000336755,
-0.0745153278,
-0.0057060039,
-0.0143802539,
0.0480000116,
-0.0268820915,
-0.0145337461,
0.0752207488,
0.0395981222,
-0.0324815623,
-0.0071801264,
-0.0353543535,
-0.0048216591,
-0.0027258012,
-0.028853599,
-0.0500768796,
-6.099626227e-33,
-0.0074090273,
-0.0595043451,
0.0663293973,
-0.0636408627,
-0.0091442,
-0.007813694,
-0.047325518,
0.0225269888,
0.0185636338,
0.0301738661,
-0.056066595,
-0.0332758948,
0.0143574383,
-0.0116518959,
0.0439059511,
0.0025126496,
0.0315985568,
0.0057813721,
-0.0688227639,
0.0067167268,
-0.0029240749,
0.009157123,
0.0062590335,
-0.0271110181,
0.0325702205,
0.0172503162,
-0.0431681983,
0.0734534636,
0.0177628435,
0.0131517695,
-0.0086769294,
0.0129518341,
0.0005210154,
-0.0917469487,
-0.0139679024,
0.0239677764,
-0.0368445404,
-0.0635130703,
0.0139213186,
-0.0396689363,
-0.0674737841,
-0.0243839175,
-0.0225462895,
0.0039004104,
-0.0327976197,
0.033244621,
0.0106911119,
0.0135232341,
0.0213464852,
-0.0127082178,
-0.0378781594,
-0.0107717672,
-0.0162659399,
-0.0191610008,
0.0392695218,
0.0343495756,
0.0115101989,
-0.0173718091,
0.0077994089,
0.0326504484,
0.017240718,
0.000201861,
0.0604216568,
0.0257110521,
0.0091732331,
0.0349266976,
0.0457945317,
0.0374493785,
-0.0021637944,
-0.0045153373,
-0.0108007276,
0.0488281325,
0.0096723568,
0.0419178791,
0.0070241424,
0.0150378123,
-0.0091725299,
0.0421852954,
0.0376370586,
0.0324805044,
0.0275317039,
0.0168580022,
-0.0246846825,
-0.0240971744,
-0.0378637426,
0.0373309478,
-0.0162858833,
-0.0266810115,
0.0272091124,
0.0255023353,
-0.0044256216,
-0.0182857774,
0.0126080569,
0.018511625,
0.0145414341,
0.0037761445,
-0.0204373803,
0.0327317268,
-0.016220266,
0.0294143967,
-0.0116709322,
-0.045145113,
0.0165558755,
-0.0461768135,
0.0242691096,
0.0408239476,
-0.0593417101,
0.0253301356,
-0.0319766887,
0.0083252285,
-0.0394609123,
0.0444701985,
0.0044890158,
-0.0234675799,
0.0168261603,
0.0044096839,
-0.0049775615,
0.0178859755,
0.0237098243,
-0.0628757551,
-0.0039692461,
0.0390502699,
0.0096235666,
-0.0008330308,
-0.0208165292,
0.0165736135,
-0.0268312339,
0.0225665011,
-0.0291033126,
-0.0299516693,
-0.0070512318,
0.0331235155,
2.92e-7,
-0.0235613734,
0.0724356025,
0.0022717321,
0.0360003114,
-0.0025202807,
0.0595710985,
0.0018847954,
-0.0028087154,
-0.0138562247,
-0.054689765,
0.0515834503,
0.0480557866,
0.0097246552,
0.0244559497,
-0.109466441,
-0.0373144895,
-0.0176250227,
-0.0054986058,
-0.0752601251,
0.0189599469,
0.0560753942,
0.0487442091,
-0.006890086,
0.0163771771,
0.0161113087,
-0.0283871274,
-0.003425197,
-0.0471723191,
0.0263787173,
0.0394431911,
0.0179724451,
-0.0414205715,
-0.0341546312,
0.0319020823,
0.0115882307,
0.0137007786,
-0.0083974935,
0.0800099671,
0.0139158862,
-0.0256133508,
-0.014918901,
-0.0181414951,
0.0067088483,
-0.0415300392,
0.0326631926,
-0.0327943601,
-0.0072824336,
-0.0241880026,
0.0141068855,
-0.031439513,
-0.0382318608,
-0.0390755087,
0.0011770073,
-0.0069129677,
-0.0121907955,
0.0264658481,
-0.0017077902,
-0.0557794198,
0.0174966324,
0.0039839293,
-0.0452696458,
-0.0343089961,
-0.0467436872,
0.0221303143,
0.0200920589,
-0.0779338405,
0.0000624651,
2.867360641e-34,
0.0249529649,
-0.021104753,
0.0068374649,
0.0158115309,
0.0672395229,
0.0359494872,
-0.0520195328,
0.0370523296,
0.0583583787,
-0.0600600839,
-0.0644307286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16417v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16417v1 | Enhanced Simultaneous Machine Translation with Word-level Policies | 2023-10-25T07:10:42 | 2023-10-25T07:10:42 | Kang Kim, Hankyu Cho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have seen remarkable advances in the field of Simultaneous
Machine Translation (SiMT) due to the introduction of innovative policies that
dictate whether to READ or WRITE at each step of the translation process.
However, a common assumption in many existing studies is that operations are
carried out at the subword level, even though the standard unit for input and
output in most practical scenarios is typically at the word level. This paper
demonstrates that policies devised and validated at the subword level are
surpassed by those operating at the word level, which process multiple subwords
to form a complete word in a single step. Additionally, we suggest a method to
boost SiMT models using language models (LMs), wherein the proposed word-level
policy plays a vital role in addressing the subword disparity between LMs and
SiMT models. Code is available at https://github.com/xl8-ai/WordSiMT. | [
0.0503924266,
0.0216236059,
-0.0143230511,
0.0016088943,
-0.0643029436,
0.0050678649,
0.0414437987,
0.0288077556,
-0.0058993096,
-0.0241736509,
-0.0354142934,
-0.079108648,
0.014917966,
0.0065081776,
0.016006168,
-0.0669028014,
0.0756480172,
-0.0299073048,
-0.0279744193,
0.0044173296,
0.0285343919,
0.0231730863,
0.0308957603,
0.013475812,
-0.0145820007,
0.0032314481,
0.004428694,
0.0263784956,
0.036639601,
-0.0035432561,
-0.0049049174,
0.0115098432,
0.0352546312,
0.048414655,
0.0000022008,
-0.0130635276,
-0.0576764159,
0.0165616497,
0.0628365502,
0.0410669148,
0.0697233081,
-0.067849122,
-0.0015377505,
0.0612617582,
0.0032326109,
0.0246578585,
0.0475639924,
-0.0048531187,
0.0924867168,
0.061913535,
-0.0226558857,
-0.0387882516,
0.005840274,
-0.0811784714,
-0.0282519981,
-0.0384944044,
-0.0101767872,
0.014646858,
-0.0157177467,
0.0191635564,
-0.0096103139,
0.0767955855,
0.0167417713,
0.0062637227,
-0.0513593629,
0.0197866429,
0.0256289132,
-0.0495850518,
-0.0219686739,
0.0239870958,
-0.0842329189,
0.0129627129,
0.0014132402,
-0.0553366207,
-0.0489219092,
-0.0101927165,
-0.0262939371,
0.0154707767,
-0.017257046,
-0.0097464258,
0.0453556739,
0.0293285809,
0.0496673249,
-0.0084792487,
-0.052426897,
0.0225133095,
0.035810668,
-0.0694344789,
-0.0177651029,
0.0026519948,
0.0295045897,
-0.0269626509,
0.0622163676,
0.0141163152,
-0.0323198847,
0.0342418067,
-0.0596337318,
-0.0171057098,
0.013395709,
-0.0282825138,
0.0477171168,
0.1074922904,
0.0186620224,
0.034895774,
0.0228812192,
0.0492535718,
-0.0279865675,
0.0018160113,
-0.0544756353,
0.0095660333,
-0.0012741925,
-0.0103353886,
-0.0403114595,
-0.0041878996,
-0.05013014,
-0.0408832692,
-0.0250340234,
0.0189435817,
0.022734873,
-0.0232741237,
0.0426178239,
-0.0825483724,
-0.0801187232,
-0.0302277766,
0.0155204851,
0.0402426571,
0.0066213757,
-0.0026293062,
-0.0105773546,
-0.0201511811,
-0.0273294561,
-0.009299282,
-0.0141305774,
-0.0322051235,
-0.0112115517,
0.1111919731,
-0.0237561874,
-0.0351793244,
-0.0019682064,
-0.049497284,
0.008637853,
-0.0413826965,
-0.0108341919,
-0.0503465161,
0.0634099692,
-0.0150797972,
0.0400334559,
-0.0321410596,
-0.0062485682,
0.0165221989,
-0.0271070451,
0.0797523484,
0.00465596,
0.003114617,
0.0075868606,
0.0233617555,
0.00750014,
0.0567847155,
0.0678193793,
0.0191140361,
0.0357284956,
0.0146228839,
-0.0152526917,
0.1032589972,
0.0020174433,
0.0195994154,
-0.0119040906,
-0.0198172871,
-0.0044088708,
0.0191928074,
0.0278528873,
0.0658054799,
-0.020296203,
0.025829345,
0.0634227917,
0.044055827,
0.0077817654,
0.04565892,
0.0894406959,
0.0284473505,
-0.0321689174,
0.0280339122,
0.0047956822,
0.0113024386,
0.0515203811,
0.0185453501,
0.0518918298,
0.0490877517,
0.014853307,
-0.035712231,
0.0005092702,
0.0014298194,
-0.0218397137,
-0.0295268893,
0.0063112257,
-0.0068842848,
-0.0593014024,
0.0000792181,
0.0112275137,
-0.0413239263,
0.0125320833,
-0.0341811329,
-0.0482322872,
0.0939449966,
0.060409762,
0.0066776685,
-0.0104221366,
-0.0093733408,
-0.0075710686,
0.0592997856,
0.0574587584,
0.0082406551,
0.0113367513,
-0.0557347126,
-0.0231115464,
0.0613926016,
-0.0154804504,
0.0126707628,
0.0278496239,
0.025901068,
0.0438084193,
0.0468116291,
-0.0162708852,
0.0281959102,
-0.0467743874,
-0.0038432432,
-0.0007849249,
-0.0048134006,
0.0286062472,
-0.0056575183,
-0.0317180902,
0.0130845457,
0.0025201789,
-0.0197606739,
-0.0157133956,
0.037649788,
-0.0348122455,
-0.0078242356,
0.0238988642,
0.0234041512,
0.009971221,
-0.0086373026,
0.0010592595,
-0.039470844,
-0.0678185374,
-0.0312777907,
0.0066798534,
-0.0379720703,
0.0481769368,
0.0183705036,
-0.0364524722,
-0.0570716746,
0.0051973173,
-0.0426564291,
-0.0011511274,
0.0522903278,
-0.031513162,
0.0135683948,
-0.0438417792,
-0.0079750884,
0.0814868435,
0.0239865128,
0.0291226227,
0.0229811948,
0.0363605842,
0.0014637203,
-0.0349648632,
-0.0445369221,
0.0240088832,
-0.0176572111,
0.0376244597,
0.0103135677,
0.0589102991,
-0.0164207965,
0.0161695611,
0.0110708214,
0.0159568563,
0.0007278523,
0.0041555436,
0.0044258339,
-0.0223607123,
0.0019413298,
-0.0464234389,
-0.0402848572,
-0.000607403,
-0.0298216995,
0.0115118111,
-0.0081235999,
-0.0590536371,
-0.001331473,
0.0074146455,
-0.0053265053,
-0.0009983708,
-0.0433644764,
0.0092340102,
-0.0448263027,
0.0303512253,
0.0233351327,
-0.0180068165,
0.0098348986,
0.0428378098,
-0.012441027,
-0.042107638,
0.0298915915,
-0.0100607648,
-0.0015605725,
0.0094151255,
-0.0317443609,
0.001170081,
0.0616703629,
0.0087168952,
0.0055973437,
-0.0727329254,
-0.0091806045,
-0.0276063327,
-0.0390773267,
-0.0035065308,
-0.0037240682,
-0.0358036831,
0.003364827,
-0.0322937071,
-0.0718304366,
0.0446071513,
-0.0577719286,
0.0108988322,
-0.0737907216,
0.0028622453,
-0.0242645834,
0.0669307932,
-0.0124017317,
0.0095394179,
-0.0855246708,
-0.0206062701,
-0.0411022007,
0.0324495994,
-0.0018349384,
-0.0207741763,
-0.0013605847,
-0.0721282735,
0.0119491434,
-0.0313555896,
-0.0199938957,
-0.015300137,
-0.0372201242,
-0.0454157405,
0.0191133115,
0.0208419412,
-0.063816987,
0.0105084609,
0.0222824756,
0.0227663182,
0.0771082267,
-0.0124876546,
-0.0144070294,
-0.0396288149,
0.0067322338,
0.0080498727,
-0.0357470587,
-0.0629182756,
-0.0663949475,
-0.0064712479,
0.0090193292,
0.0108955,
-0.0314189307,
0.0064177755,
0.006925886,
0.065008454,
-0.0371047705,
-0.0221570004,
-0.0102244467,
0.0343824103,
-0.082517311,
-0.0107065225,
0.1137587875,
0.0440615304,
-0.0276585277,
-0.0058284104,
0.0155076915,
0.0433697924,
-0.0109360339,
0.029848,
-0.041387178,
-0.03326625,
0.0111938054,
0.055007901,
0.0207617767,
0.0496883132,
-0.0546077713,
-0.0588982441,
0.019702334,
0.0473460034,
-0.0536523238,
-0.0466940179,
0.0249443967,
-0.0247411132,
-0.0233925432,
0.0006883253,
0.0040671839,
-0.0139597757,
0.0066704419,
-0.0087624481,
0.0152299693,
0.0019588862,
-0.0095802192,
-0.0391341411,
0.021213593,
0.0905520022,
0.0034277725,
0.0042709368,
-0.0106011424,
0.0761390924,
-0.0025629904,
0.0112662911,
-0.0368789993,
-0.0264413971,
-0.0530952774,
-0.0099512786,
0.0034939565,
0.0006630874,
-0.0098711327,
-0.0178275332,
0.0223777834,
0.0402638204,
-0.0190830026,
-0.0067016669,
-0.031828288,
0.0031530503,
0.0320840068,
0.0472794361,
-0.0013803559,
-0.0603493042,
-0.0041932785,
-0.024733657,
-0.0264286082,
-0.061582651,
-0.032850109,
-0.0299114864,
-0.0654934794,
-0.0164397433,
-0.0527407303,
-0.0560267828,
0.0024472056,
0.0341258347,
0.021194011,
0.0182953775,
0.0274338108,
0.0167792346,
-0.013356586,
-0.0361240432,
0.0022193803,
0.0518153086,
-0.0330310538,
0.0137388492,
0.0117858984,
-0.0161318947,
-0.0280900896,
0.0396340154,
-0.080681242,
-0.0732571036,
-0.0051849666,
0.0469602607,
0.0319749229,
0.0294884592,
-0.0393965878,
-0.0634601861,
-0.0081612831,
0.0075539001,
-0.0113163674,
-0.012956921,
0.0119143259,
-0.0137730362,
-0.0108929453,
0.0219335482,
0.021379564,
-0.0206574444,
-0.0070815259,
0.0592425652,
-0.0110334475,
-0.055150073,
-0.0104667973,
-0.0056207515,
-0.0093034962,
-0.0189922322,
0.0146235134,
-0.0467518158,
0.0134768859,
-0.0295772962,
0.0101109529,
-0.0646022409,
-0.0156529117,
0.0455984697,
-0.0298954714,
-0.0457258858,
0.0137429675,
-0.0265319012,
-0.0511223003,
0.0211510733,
-0.0038329337,
-0.0467509516,
0.0520770773,
-0.002164226,
-0.0057156761,
-0.0094682248,
0.0330372043,
-0.0276309419,
-0.0325588696,
-0.0417139605,
0.0483884737,
0.009092004,
-0.0040083933,
-0.0202777982,
0.046934016,
-0.0276535396,
-0.0305618029,
-0.03032846,
0.0523914099,
0.0539151542,
-0.0053833751,
0.0841224119,
-0.0395509489,
-0.0127449539,
-0.0187938847,
0.0466384888,
0.0197818894,
-0.004680865,
-0.0118914992,
0.0129444273,
-0.0191709511,
-0.0072471807,
0.0677202269,
0.0196054876,
0.0018193021,
-0.0017401397,
-0.0346883088,
-0.0097736223,
-0.0172519628,
-0.0098928697,
0.0085556451,
-0.0325436667,
-0.0074861236,
-0.0854565725,
-0.0548485518,
-0.0210293699,
0.0753694549,
-0.0002227651,
-0.0270418487,
-0.0000526153,
0.0617922544,
-0.0534504876,
-0.0065278248,
-0.0482513271,
0.0173366945,
0.0083238445,
-0.0462301448,
-0.0238856003,
-6.295415832e-33,
-0.0269557852,
-0.0089579765,
0.0396916308,
-0.0158549938,
-0.0620012581,
-0.003514241,
-0.0175675601,
-0.0253395084,
0.0416206084,
-0.0049854969,
-0.0244196299,
0.0332909264,
0.0325488523,
-0.033538308,
0.0221603699,
0.0487254523,
0.0801286474,
-0.0082832268,
-0.0461593196,
0.0013342161,
0.0091746962,
0.027911922,
0.0509477705,
-0.0366275236,
0.0413863026,
-0.0115895541,
-0.0280279443,
0.0120588075,
-0.0409589224,
0.0268749725,
0.0033943201,
-0.0079335924,
0.0204102434,
-0.0293111727,
-0.0422365852,
0.0381325781,
-0.075194858,
0.0030916859,
0.0312762409,
-0.0030327034,
-0.0470027961,
-0.0620200448,
0.0313862674,
-0.032244917,
-0.0120843649,
-0.0230152067,
-0.0144273443,
0.0066871867,
-0.0222965125,
-0.0044316724,
-0.0664044693,
0.0453125648,
0.0059583718,
-0.0046709958,
0.0689369217,
0.0081289569,
0.027811598,
-0.0184321497,
-0.0141526908,
0.0314013548,
0.0347122513,
0.0571166053,
0.0663892552,
-0.0182872545,
-0.0300689097,
0.0115309954,
-0.0023678106,
-0.0140631087,
0.0491194017,
-0.0183855835,
0.0115371365,
0.0078911101,
0.0375157781,
0.0349845253,
0.0421693437,
-0.0271561984,
-0.0238176081,
0.0449997671,
0.0213671718,
0.0186883025,
0.0289632399,
0.0150817325,
-0.0408011749,
0.006494401,
-0.0297768731,
-0.0309491828,
-0.0246673506,
-0.0295255817,
0.0353879482,
0.0522242673,
-0.0022553806,
0.0343828462,
0.079155162,
0.0162549429,
0.0122899469,
-0.0123192761,
-0.0371592194,
0.0083567733,
-0.0184338987,
0.060866423,
-0.0238596983,
-0.0296297614,
-0.0072730388,
0.0273787081,
-0.0113318888,
-0.0165656973,
-0.0070889792,
0.0549916886,
-0.033320006,
-0.0026960417,
-0.020368576,
0.0049889791,
-0.014209155,
0.0026964147,
0.0321398377,
0.0014640184,
0.0060100807,
0.0154084992,
0.0425449535,
-0.0561452657,
-0.0234522913,
-0.0053125257,
0.0067437072,
0.0402503982,
-0.0189436488,
0.0433434173,
-0.0359249525,
0.0026371316,
0.0210667141,
-0.0429375358,
-0.0238767229,
0.0216786843,
2.743e-7,
0.0645693392,
0.0404533185,
0.0256668869,
0.0525499471,
0.0237788111,
0.0034833672,
-0.0375810564,
0.0576962158,
0.0042390493,
0.0632252321,
0.0495348461,
-0.0024461464,
0.0582034029,
-0.0099755945,
-0.0623386689,
-0.0423601344,
-0.0262469649,
0.060444694,
-0.0660192296,
0.0003829959,
0.0658922046,
0.0726142675,
-0.0186225343,
0.0130206039,
-0.0259295963,
-0.0105997464,
0.0799571052,
-0.0012800813,
-0.0164146796,
-0.0089858826,
0.0362035669,
0.0260535944,
-0.0216194913,
-0.0261855796,
-0.0442013778,
0.0298678111,
0.0747476667,
0.139514029,
-0.0089801364,
0.0110930819,
0.0370430388,
-0.009269652,
-0.0195677541,
-0.0289822873,
0.0595013611,
-0.0148836672,
0.0211423561,
0.0138757825,
0.0008530245,
0.0303067062,
0.0141507303,
-0.0215817168,
-0.0682690144,
0.0351020806,
0.0323275141,
0.0374041945,
-0.0230612997,
-0.0449087135,
-0.0421678051,
-0.0669798777,
-0.0329583548,
-0.0343398191,
-0.0371674895,
0.0229735989,
-0.0004435736,
-0.0187711548,
-0.0365681797,
2.792188925e-34,
0.0434025638,
-0.0448535904,
0.030098144,
0.0133062918,
0.0005323035,
-0.0114808735,
0.0136202611,
0.0456529297,
-0.0033415733,
-0.0482534543,
-0.0787704363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16411v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16411v1 | Decoding Stumpers: Large Language Models vs. Human Problem-Solvers | 2023-10-25T06:54:39 | 2023-10-25T06:54:39 | Alon Goldstein, Miriam Havin, Roi Reichart, Ariel Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This paper investigates the problem-solving capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) by evaluating their performance on stumpers, unique single-step
intuition problems that pose challenges for human solvers but are easily
verifiable. We compare the performance of four state-of-the-art LLMs
(Davinci-2, Davinci-3, GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4) to human participants. Our
findings reveal that the new-generation LLMs excel in solving stumpers and
surpass human performance. However, humans exhibit superior skills in verifying
solutions to the same problems. This research enhances our understanding of
LLMs' cognitive abilities and provides insights for enhancing their
problem-solving potential across various domains. | [
0.0113410056,
0.0630097389,
-0.0253777187,
0.029219456,
-0.0612565391,
0.0074123638,
-0.0034446372,
0.0164782833,
-0.0180817768,
0.0059579606,
0.0089703901,
0.0059894924,
-0.0079151802,
0.0157301091,
0.0263636522,
-0.052532725,
0.030795211,
-0.0873096436,
0.0499239452,
-0.0226831175,
-0.0378973372,
0.0036011785,
-0.0354760215,
0.0462767743,
0.0153570371,
-0.0383491814,
-0.0124340663,
-0.017759731,
-0.0040877294,
-0.049629055,
-0.0475334451,
0.0595528036,
0.0393900238,
0.0830554962,
0.0000020602,
-0.0419570915,
-0.0009641151,
0.0025689721,
-0.0988497138,
0.0245304424,
-0.0195925385,
0.003131879,
-0.0397278331,
0.0222664252,
-0.0422490835,
-0.0145455236,
0.0121700633,
0.0378885716,
0.0394131467,
0.0275543425,
0.0097090593,
-0.0015528196,
0.0292518213,
-0.0106995199,
-0.0012644512,
-0.1000805125,
0.0034968818,
0.035993468,
0.041867774,
-0.0422938727,
-0.02514573,
0.026509149,
0.0522896126,
0.0095386161,
-0.104449749,
0.0444776937,
-0.014686578,
0.0027393913,
-0.0319035873,
0.0402513817,
-0.0169319659,
0.0038478421,
-0.0460591242,
0.0188515633,
0.0246162787,
0.0334478654,
-0.0502360351,
0.0539722219,
-0.034773659,
0.0020115352,
-0.0081921704,
-0.0057098237,
0.0335306041,
0.0152032971,
-0.0089262938,
0.0992053822,
-0.0118082706,
-0.0363574773,
0.0500689037,
0.0052954732,
-0.0204875134,
-0.043945726,
0.041451972,
0.0258933976,
-0.0165181067,
0.0167753901,
-0.009594392,
-0.0065801302,
-0.0081311101,
-0.0027027703,
0.031519182,
0.0677162483,
0.0221692882,
0.0530697182,
-0.0347937047,
0.0718955323,
-0.0677312016,
0.0406950749,
0.0084550101,
0.0212986618,
-0.059327431,
-0.0441223271,
-0.0595240183,
0.0215534139,
-0.0222616624,
-0.0191634092,
-0.0193143263,
0.0080227666,
0.0117140189,
-0.0020433119,
-0.0419086777,
0.0127532212,
-0.0016939463,
-0.0366738588,
-0.0297366753,
0.0230334066,
-0.0422595404,
0.0221569799,
0.0096564125,
-0.0685393959,
-0.0231004264,
0.0059368946,
-0.0241921134,
-0.0347243361,
0.0303262826,
0.0048790891,
-0.0316563547,
-0.008577317,
-0.0010386826,
0.010141761,
0.0190555304,
-0.1125156656,
0.0148009481,
-0.0420190617,
0.0333079249,
0.0395669602,
-0.0026353684,
-0.0459328145,
-0.0004249844,
0.0041737049,
0.0076713758,
0.080326803,
0.0146211805,
0.0180654004,
0.0521100052,
0.0321259014,
-0.0530451611,
0.0563910976,
0.0180414002,
0.0386651903,
-0.0061059189,
-0.0214743502,
0.0179685503,
0.0369657502,
-0.0109100351,
-0.0095655685,
-0.0562902391,
0.0021260132,
0.0144920051,
0.0325424597,
0.0303139649,
0.0669455156,
-0.0320989788,
0.0172652286,
0.0529283546,
0.0642923638,
-0.0010052727,
0.0204792004,
0.0341258235,
-0.0065363492,
0.0544372909,
0.0237146504,
-0.0597181357,
0.0031887579,
-0.0433058888,
0.0125743449,
-0.0135257179,
0.0150077734,
-0.0176879186,
0.0063232956,
-0.0195580125,
0.0214241594,
-0.0017853265,
0.0091751041,
0.0555703193,
-0.0255085677,
-0.0636728853,
0.0181884617,
-0.0549534373,
0.0013747273,
-0.0297013,
-0.0839383453,
0.0306518637,
0.0251721125,
0.0618714727,
0.0103534656,
-0.0030057207,
-0.0006955183,
0.0048677851,
0.0333969258,
0.0002731856,
0.0304406378,
-0.0143319452,
-0.0130809126,
-0.007126404,
-0.0139479283,
0.005911306,
0.0219270252,
0.0506378487,
0.0243621897,
-0.0050436044,
-0.0293910634,
0.0461614914,
0.0197028499,
-0.0167562533,
0.0020308592,
-0.045328062,
0.0059637693,
0.0196490828,
0.0011534317,
-0.0185404792,
0.0204141866,
0.0295460485,
-0.0424210764,
-0.0237382688,
0.0256979503,
-0.0464410521,
0.0057492289,
0.0424165912,
-0.07210733,
-0.0525954589,
0.0526933037,
0.0168150887,
-0.012964298,
0.0335551463,
-0.0769837201,
0.0327578224,
-0.0301566627,
0.0357580781,
-0.0251999237,
0.0110806534,
0.0094685499,
0.0845640302,
-0.0156939588,
0.0057736193,
0.0112541374,
0.004100767,
-0.0151629373,
-0.0609324016,
0.012303859,
0.026738584,
-0.0003371786,
-0.0120132584,
-0.0239738971,
-0.0099530611,
-0.0467975885,
-0.0384780131,
-0.068752788,
-0.0177745782,
0.0155405179,
0.0369389243,
-0.0103447419,
-0.0497671813,
-0.0329154097,
-0.0211029984,
-0.007386799,
-0.039918188,
0.0255072601,
-0.0027609004,
-0.0119846482,
0.0046337624,
-0.0471721813,
0.0025085504,
-0.0008624723,
-0.0192495938,
0.0092889061,
0.0080344016,
-0.0237593837,
-0.0487494878,
0.0583849326,
0.0216890797,
0.021003101,
-0.0069501474,
-0.0320641287,
0.0417645723,
-0.0043554064,
0.0294821002,
0.0872975662,
-0.0062362966,
0.0549044907,
0.0440835543,
-0.0312729254,
-0.0408984758,
0.0056373761,
0.0256226659,
-0.0102118989,
-0.0314416215,
-0.0388680808,
-0.0114798993,
0.069473654,
0.0187572949,
0.0411523208,
-0.0231326818,
0.0639849603,
-0.013282638,
-0.0354841463,
-0.035295561,
-0.049424652,
-0.0325379744,
0.0524163544,
-0.034267813,
-0.0419931002,
0.0856452808,
-0.0175010022,
-0.0149490302,
-0.0170764029,
0.0146843195,
-0.0238655023,
0.0688604414,
-0.0341606103,
0.0065881098,
-0.0482313931,
-0.0450589173,
-0.0263825711,
-0.0085884007,
0.003588164,
-0.0236901324,
0.022393126,
-0.0626795068,
0.0094395513,
-0.0220105611,
-0.0728865117,
-0.0483830832,
-0.0015298165,
-0.0608825237,
0.0359199941,
0.0438546948,
-0.0197441094,
-0.080094032,
0.0197925419,
0.070034869,
0.0130724777,
-0.0134923747,
-0.0191496704,
-0.0193913057,
0.0057809236,
0.0130981999,
0.0558874495,
0.0618331358,
-0.0795126781,
0.0652866066,
0.059013892,
0.0823768228,
-0.0061693136,
-0.0092469407,
0.0366428159,
0.0324001238,
0.0077300821,
0.0052815494,
0.0444676131,
0.0191884842,
-0.0527788661,
0.0049627274,
0.095153451,
0.0438711271,
-0.0200934131,
-0.0051769055,
-0.0498239696,
-0.0208146945,
0.0138751585,
0.0189737938,
-0.0684463158,
-0.0479237773,
0.0378936566,
0.0223450921,
-0.016424045,
-0.0276807044,
-0.0112911519,
-0.1238265336,
0.0564855561,
0.0197534375,
-0.0629817024,
0.0098011578,
-0.0303186812,
-0.0193752926,
0.0209023338,
0.0397580937,
0.0294270348,
-0.0027821294,
-0.007159072,
0.003139541,
-0.0042460114,
-0.032498803,
0.0439077467,
-0.013615896,
0.037096329,
0.0638603643,
-0.0097142616,
-0.0242180303,
-0.0433704965,
0.0174768157,
0.01602282,
0.0452615283,
-0.0035626621,
0.003907043,
0.0045027523,
0.0160856694,
-0.0416482873,
0.0239621308,
-0.0453673862,
-0.0323707983,
0.0409466252,
0.0981127173,
-0.0150820883,
-0.0375946835,
0.0003323156,
-0.0042871549,
-0.0429402776,
0.0617367178,
0.0317031555,
-0.0258516781,
-0.0578324534,
-0.016956998,
0.0165823102,
-0.041836679,
-0.035582222,
0.0468320921,
0.0197245795,
-0.0230000075,
-0.0037788083,
-0.0145028513,
0.0583713315,
0.0623659752,
-0.0010488434,
0.0090205157,
-0.0131331207,
0.0226651561,
-0.0565053634,
0.0278806966,
-0.0146617293,
0.0384397507,
-0.1087702289,
0.0194205102,
-0.0189886689,
-0.0371969864,
-0.0053214501,
0.0495659523,
-0.0327848382,
-0.0355720259,
0.0229389071,
0.0057981457,
0.0388660282,
-0.0209840871,
-0.0024166596,
-0.0623425767,
-0.0138387112,
0.0346972235,
-0.0545590557,
0.0155233154,
-0.000971401,
0.0062093483,
0.0037659348,
0.0187109169,
0.0033222702,
0.0114125917,
0.0148263099,
0.0529328696,
-0.041726049,
0.003523234,
0.0456868112,
0.0546208993,
0.0293235034,
-0.0064925626,
0.0144919315,
0.0091973217,
0.0193187725,
-0.0159313343,
-0.0063073905,
-0.0268506035,
-0.0353573635,
0.0115596438,
-0.0181601401,
0.0385082327,
-0.0170386918,
-0.000681494,
0.0203565042,
-0.019493809,
0.0333760828,
0.0029126003,
0.0437766574,
0.0376796983,
-0.0076171751,
0.0030031181,
0.0231328905,
-0.0147405816,
0.059082415,
0.0294632949,
0.1030731127,
0.0231934208,
-0.0116768843,
-0.0182994381,
0.0077286768,
-0.0580001362,
-0.0877250284,
0.021402549,
0.0184406564,
0.0580044053,
0.0150336577,
-0.0229332875,
-0.0398782305,
0.0052383738,
-0.002551069,
-0.0321478359,
0.0057541477,
0.0022285134,
0.0495036654,
0.0513362959,
-0.0007398021,
-0.0106814569,
0.0315798298,
-0.0106819067,
0.0436154604,
-0.013024102,
-0.0218842104,
-0.0306935702,
-0.0445313454,
-0.0151468897,
0.0382989496,
-0.0080268132,
0.0280745253,
-0.0866450071,
-0.064515464,
-0.0381538793,
0.028161658,
0.0065785418,
-0.0174897388,
0.0099443458,
0.051169429,
-0.0176264588,
-0.0793267488,
-0.0043236953,
0.0381231792,
-0.030285731,
-0.0068849572,
-0.0049397592,
-6.34470431e-33,
-0.0391137749,
-0.0871877745,
0.0156868361,
-0.0513486117,
0.0107618673,
-0.0043496927,
-0.0546632893,
0.0418134928,
-0.0197248328,
0.0126286913,
-0.0517096072,
0.0134859774,
0.0285914,
-0.0347823575,
0.0010154975,
0.0277658738,
0.0193833411,
0.0080820927,
-0.0331472382,
-0.0252653621,
0.0180567633,
0.0046096039,
0.0123583432,
-0.0461082794,
0.0143231843,
-0.0012626585,
-0.0218851715,
0.0152794905,
-0.0236691013,
0.0559978597,
-0.0230493303,
0.0019341123,
0.0215982497,
-0.0354626626,
-0.0160118751,
0.011158661,
-0.0326453149,
0.0151301883,
0.0400057025,
0.0115931612,
0.0024660088,
-0.0338470787,
0.0194858126,
-0.0000349793,
-0.047044836,
0.0209603515,
-0.0046806186,
-0.0412551165,
0.0212426186,
0.0146259498,
-0.0264822319,
0.0193563234,
-0.0405344404,
-0.0325038992,
0.0466443039,
0.004200832,
-0.0515377186,
-0.0370796248,
-0.0647659972,
0.0231667049,
0.0208347216,
-0.0213846713,
0.0803218707,
-0.0245878715,
-0.0168661587,
0.0479880683,
0.0541684814,
-0.0546826012,
-0.0508149303,
-0.0578374267,
0.031402912,
0.0843231902,
0.0692096204,
-0.0006914512,
0.049742531,
0.0040049744,
-0.0230532456,
0.01244401,
0.0333362184,
0.0413268171,
0.0598393455,
0.0259177741,
-0.0762231871,
-0.0174591038,
-0.0206421223,
0.0075464677,
-0.0477312021,
-0.0391347893,
0.0409630984,
-0.0231268983,
0.0073209782,
-0.0510747507,
0.0447422341,
-0.0326299593,
0.024804214,
-0.0224910136,
-0.0018479927,
0.0357461646,
-0.0033030016,
0.0200722404,
-0.0563784465,
-0.024046272,
0.006192279,
0.0329915732,
0.034040425,
-0.0068984516,
-0.0376077145,
0.0087942677,
-0.0506334528,
0.0003086653,
-0.0364832655,
0.0116686467,
0.049796816,
-0.0330267958,
0.0554993078,
-0.0271009058,
0.000491226,
-0.0274102334,
-0.0176456887,
-0.051629968,
-0.0173002202,
0.0630021244,
-0.0215406157,
0.0223956257,
-0.0193050578,
-0.0175522715,
-0.0105388165,
-0.0050916802,
0.0108253984,
-0.0290717874,
-0.0076728784,
0.0153420689,
2.789e-7,
0.0067005982,
0.0620309375,
0.0425814539,
-0.0013883503,
0.0269140713,
0.0418499336,
-0.0493637733,
-0.0519252568,
0.0221774504,
0.009802185,
-0.0100824721,
0.0696340799,
0.049175147,
0.0376321003,
-0.0489022359,
0.0341627337,
-0.0226989109,
0.0161582083,
-0.0601609498,
0.0195335969,
0.0218636878,
0.0188152846,
0.016079206,
-0.0123440241,
-0.0072293342,
-0.0490750521,
0.017013723,
-0.0122527611,
0.0121019697,
-0.0172668323,
-0.0132119367,
-0.0017664849,
-0.005838519,
0.0816972852,
0.0211586021,
0.0239300281,
0.0230458491,
0.0678892732,
-0.0088390782,
-0.0040496499,
-0.0229359251,
-0.0030269807,
-0.0115028787,
-0.0548633747,
0.0548677444,
-0.0606288426,
-0.0741175488,
0.0128739029,
0.0077950293,
-0.0675018802,
-0.0027080863,
-0.0041746264,
0.0348174758,
0.0142144328,
0.0061880914,
-0.0179832242,
-0.0125093488,
-0.0363927931,
0.0116817653,
0.0086560445,
-0.06181591,
-0.0465269648,
-0.0562725961,
0.0108921835,
0.0266952403,
-0.0323010944,
-0.0032096286,
2.335066493e-34,
0.0324310102,
0.0171898976,
0.0385643244,
0.0577284135,
0.0586025342,
0.0195781905,
0.0223049931,
0.0106225573,
0.034317717,
-0.0542888716,
-0.018823659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16402v1 | Video Referring Expression Comprehension via Transformer with Content-conditioned Query | 2023-10-25T06:38:42 | 2023-10-25T06:38:42 | Ji Jiang, Meng Cao, Tengtao Song, Long Chen, Yi Wang, Yuexian Zou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Video Referring Expression Comprehension (REC) aims to localize a target
object in videos based on the queried natural language. Recent improvements in
video REC have been made using Transformer-based methods with learnable
queries. However, we contend that this naive query design is not ideal given
the open-world nature of video REC brought by text supervision. With numerous
potential semantic categories, relying on only a few slow-updated queries is
insufficient to characterize them. Our solution to this problem is to create
dynamic queries that are conditioned on both the input video and language to
model the diverse objects referred to. Specifically, we place a fixed number of
learnable bounding boxes throughout the frame and use corresponding region
features to provide prior information. Also, we noticed that current query
features overlook the importance of cross-modal alignment. To address this, we
align specific phrases in the sentence with semantically relevant visual areas,
annotating them in existing video datasets (VID-Sentence and VidSTG). By
incorporating these two designs, our proposed model (called ConFormer)
outperforms other models on widely benchmarked datasets. For example, in the
testing split of VID-Sentence dataset, ConFormer achieves 8.75% absolute
improvement on [email protected] compared to the previous state-of-the-art model. | [
0.0533598661,
0.0263699535,
0.0044205859,
0.030227242,
-0.0034428725,
-0.0321151763,
-0.0033456832,
-0.0021711111,
-0.017873494,
-0.0594622009,
-0.0351702608,
-0.0160203464,
-0.0281847268,
0.0337097533,
0.000377896,
-0.0627408922,
0.0453320406,
-0.0176886432,
-0.0010649477,
0.026307432,
0.0160919372,
0.0207477175,
-0.028761141,
0.0485406183,
-0.088910386,
0.0128625529,
-0.0012056709,
0.0206034184,
0.028280586,
-0.0131184133,
0.0005139843,
0.0187971517,
0.0670817122,
-0.0231594611,
0.0000018758,
0.0050580632,
-0.0393536389,
-0.0069522969,
0.0213904101,
-0.0029292493,
0.0560633987,
-0.0737457275,
0.0204101652,
0.0244321022,
-0.0467755906,
-0.0310939662,
0.0426980332,
0.0134070059,
0.0312227532,
0.0232496262,
-0.0465434231,
-0.0262216832,
0.0094806626,
-0.0131796822,
0.0515843481,
-0.0925450698,
-0.0064810859,
0.0249512773,
0.0238852855,
-0.011271893,
-0.0909537524,
0.056371633,
0.0196948964,
-0.0566876046,
0.0051799859,
-0.0052019763,
-0.032266099,
-0.0376622714,
0.0014194127,
0.0789326355,
0.0152224163,
0.050004743,
-0.0274982303,
0.0188127067,
0.0156627297,
0.0208540652,
-0.0301695056,
0.0273216404,
0.0332642719,
-0.001148658,
-0.0752547309,
0.049747739,
-0.0179242473,
-0.0130704539,
0.0277189612,
0.015041247,
0.0183588695,
0.025908934,
-0.0224590357,
-0.0150742885,
-0.0173945315,
-0.007077429,
0.0129853757,
0.0081217643,
-0.0093230391,
0.0220079124,
-0.0565155335,
-0.0146983331,
-0.0338707305,
-0.0077561527,
0.0330669917,
0.0272176135,
-0.0574184917,
0.0692976117,
-0.0316258669,
0.0909396857,
-0.0613942035,
0.0397527404,
-0.0415989198,
-0.0472002849,
-0.0746761262,
-0.0030979221,
-0.0515322573,
0.0114803826,
-0.0533797666,
-0.0220257472,
-0.032386817,
-0.0050997986,
-0.0494074561,
-0.0130656296,
-0.0211544875,
0.055385258,
-0.0065201651,
-0.0214910805,
-0.0329563282,
0.0235817172,
-0.0451002344,
0.0428505391,
-0.0398372747,
-0.0680974126,
-0.0275822505,
0.0317372605,
0.0212559924,
-0.036441654,
0.0205598772,
0.0522485748,
-0.0527081452,
-0.058363013,
-0.0081984969,
-0.0307570603,
-0.0833642334,
0.0085479971,
0.0484244786,
-0.0228298474,
0.0377349071,
-0.0005620424,
-0.0186882261,
-0.0436659977,
0.018348638,
0.0202890374,
-0.0404395871,
0.0606804118,
0.0597223677,
0.007850646,
-0.0304604918,
0.0061141546,
0.0169524476,
0.0460889898,
0.0352292843,
0.0163730979,
0.020702377,
0.0634348094,
0.050612621,
0.0117982151,
0.0008887366,
0.0411736295,
-0.1198628843,
0.0218858719,
0.0174529254,
0.0209090486,
0.0317948163,
0.0503047518,
-0.000344975,
-0.0703059062,
0.0236096531,
-0.0045659435,
-0.0671185777,
-0.0365270525,
0.036725305,
0.0544362217,
-0.0253670234,
-0.0161928423,
-0.0246091373,
0.0836159363,
0.0242266282,
-0.0026924952,
-0.0111909574,
-0.001431979,
-0.0584337413,
-0.0315628946,
0.0116662374,
0.0030684792,
0.0194634944,
0.013638217,
0.041327998,
0.0347425453,
-0.0393622592,
0.0609319396,
-0.0050873533,
-0.0299527049,
0.0173028,
-0.0163182076,
0.0143420985,
-0.000423268,
0.0141014438,
-0.024537744,
-0.0489096344,
0.0076523861,
0.0564920679,
0.0218061022,
0.0155880731,
-0.0099151004,
0.0419853665,
-0.0449511111,
-0.0405018665,
-0.0378701575,
0.0119587174,
0.0176518206,
0.0036836746,
-0.0010699905,
0.0150661319,
-0.0621499456,
0.001364548,
0.0491175465,
0.0956065208,
0.0068026031,
-0.0040634423,
0.0280591529,
0.0070411512,
-0.0018994543,
-0.0152566694,
-0.0147447428,
0.0222017933,
-0.0310453884,
0.0143297259,
0.0457251407,
-0.0397886671,
-0.0235887393,
0.0351214148,
-0.0873887017,
-0.026303757,
0.0043832553,
-0.0375259928,
-0.0476308502,
0.0513170995,
-0.0026408939,
0.0084672011,
-0.0338564888,
-0.0048785405,
0.0028284991,
0.0070572919,
-0.0099949334,
0.0152213117,
0.0048642023,
-0.0274851602,
0.0328013897,
-0.001870305,
0.027475236,
-0.0043953033,
-0.0237720069,
-0.0641128793,
-0.0208310876,
-0.0281190779,
0.0181110762,
-0.0161518995,
-0.0593564175,
-0.0630892292,
-0.0145926531,
-0.018440241,
-0.0155370813,
-0.0074904691,
0.0121702049,
0.0088281771,
0.0022180341,
-0.0640274286,
-0.0086330622,
-0.0103204958,
-0.005391472,
0.0195888244,
0.0364079215,
0.04053187,
-0.0125894658,
-0.021180585,
0.0305399746,
0.0196267478,
0.0315049291,
0.0206906293,
-0.0435950607,
0.0354191735,
0.0063774544,
0.0030857639,
0.0449622087,
-0.0194285605,
-0.0255702659,
-0.0006809081,
-0.0037441126,
0.0018687446,
0.0559108742,
-0.0097602867,
0.008091392,
-0.000309893,
-0.0530312918,
-0.0383227505,
0.0496863835,
-0.0101367747,
-0.0803895295,
-0.0301100258,
-0.0019834922,
-0.0240544174,
-0.0150766177,
-0.0089714061,
0.0241454169,
-0.0722934231,
0.0082746148,
-0.001271863,
-0.0230211411,
-0.057591103,
0.0212756824,
0.0006749039,
0.0244424846,
-0.0507068112,
-0.0243551992,
0.032217674,
-0.0306117442,
-0.0473840982,
-0.0005710376,
0.0237838458,
-0.0450677499,
0.0806115121,
0.0145702772,
0.0197338182,
-0.0096749319,
-0.0592256933,
-0.0901169032,
-0.0059729922,
-0.0138994129,
0.0216986611,
0.0360941924,
-0.0144034354,
0.0147524597,
-0.0105883237,
-0.0067682699,
-0.0386492983,
-0.0137208654,
-0.0359258875,
-0.0151099134,
-0.0238908753,
-0.0314095281,
-0.0510649532,
0.0092968233,
0.0369910337,
0.0376662053,
-0.0304188188,
0.0033555371,
-0.0164712537,
0.0023396276,
0.0527971052,
0.0526117757,
-0.0740117207,
-0.0261812452,
-0.0025371355,
0.0574803427,
0.0374800451,
-0.0401265733,
-0.0243270155,
0.0326733515,
0.0419409797,
0.0118725263,
-0.0033110317,
0.0119315013,
0.0393068977,
-0.0505968221,
-0.0015048014,
0.0760953501,
0.0067355293,
-0.0393976495,
-0.0353072882,
-0.0035470773,
0.0235020574,
0.0649767593,
0.0387771316,
-0.1169385239,
-0.0742959827,
-0.0075267698,
-0.0142118176,
0.0367386937,
0.004167526,
-0.031412676,
-0.1065442562,
0.0490182526,
-0.0155440234,
-0.0340084806,
-0.0572779439,
0.0350931697,
0.0311312247,
-0.0276615713,
-0.0078010298,
-0.0060923598,
-0.0120779881,
0.0237886328,
-0.0088798236,
0.0191569198,
-0.0071434462,
0.0384069011,
-0.0360872447,
-0.0095296754,
0.0228320584,
0.0289222673,
0.0064669629,
-0.0597609095,
-0.001239002,
-0.0171147604,
0.0262062326,
0.0158974174,
0.0607169978,
-0.0405301265,
-0.0347183757,
0.02736005,
0.0140768634,
0.004935408,
-0.0313554555,
-0.0220799427,
0.0653017759,
-0.0025399018,
0.0551829934,
-0.0451073982,
0.0315826312,
0.0103072571,
0.0714486539,
-0.0055837627,
-0.0204669423,
0.0063299942,
0.0303365886,
-0.0310484953,
-0.0216140114,
-0.0234919079,
-0.0068450775,
-0.00167428,
0.012031748,
-0.026364848,
0.0047808941,
0.0952867642,
0.0461255424,
-0.0053785047,
-0.0339086615,
0.0337475017,
0.0355266333,
-0.0664137155,
0.0702301189,
-0.028912317,
-0.0025223782,
-0.0559517741,
-0.0007184736,
0.0573908053,
-0.0308592804,
-0.0395903289,
0.0082220333,
0.0045119384,
-0.0200082436,
-0.0216518268,
0.0300718378,
0.0191468671,
0.0609431751,
-0.0060170619,
0.0132359453,
-0.0216861777,
0.0052748211,
-0.0341981761,
0.0139175458,
0.0066913106,
-0.0402477868,
-0.0222945604,
0.0452489294,
-0.0670632496,
0.0229072794,
0.0094493069,
0.0191861968,
-0.0348886624,
-0.0299888663,
0.0293478277,
-0.0543653481,
0.0561427288,
0.0073995851,
0.0164389703,
-0.0448327176,
0.0192638654,
0.0424351729,
0.0046521109,
-0.0820182785,
0.0410889573,
0.0139035862,
-0.0047441386,
0.0019989337,
0.010856729,
-0.0159941502,
0.0122059677,
0.0015378762,
-0.0258578137,
0.0094808238,
-0.0197234284,
-0.0096372608,
0.0452836193,
0.0460381061,
0.0290514268,
-0.0078634266,
0.0510355644,
0.02113856,
0.0456392802,
0.0058856448,
-0.0177856982,
-0.0485417806,
0.0286353547,
-0.0274392366,
0.0034846019,
-0.0100953821,
0.0325162262,
-0.0042648986,
-0.0570844337,
-0.0208460428,
0.0141337719,
-0.0151074203,
0.015888134,
0.0422678478,
-0.0000030753,
-0.0820675269,
0.0810931027,
-0.0035254958,
-0.0106633035,
0.0049746181,
0.048059389,
-0.0087710964,
0.034297552,
0.0175905097,
0.0061318292,
-0.0150061548,
-0.0077825626,
0.0321359672,
-0.0276144166,
-0.011235985,
0.0378634818,
-0.0279461052,
-0.0349766463,
0.0387092605,
-0.0411642194,
-0.0313170291,
0.0086972285,
0.0538544394,
0.0098322816,
0.0458482765,
-0.0427022353,
-0.0078121223,
-0.0489964969,
-0.0118449181,
-0.0286795292,
-0.0269220565,
-5.738381752e-33,
-0.0399891622,
0.002235787,
0.0050957389,
-0.0187841523,
-0.0050710002,
0.0268598646,
-0.0173001718,
0.0234746877,
-0.0394112132,
0.0584992506,
0.0081594996,
0.0225782841,
0.0372428708,
0.0434071645,
0.0177127942,
-0.0825719088,
0.0402069464,
-0.0269454606,
-0.0105369631,
0.0180229433,
0.0446245857,
0.0546773672,
0.0691288859,
-0.0929667428,
-0.0216426421,
0.0465186425,
-0.0266508255,
0.0476851314,
0.047842253,
0.048299592,
0.0431303605,
-0.0128762685,
0.006555215,
-0.0217037611,
-0.0166302361,
0.0179093387,
-0.0714176968,
0.0542492047,
0.0120544164,
0.0546160303,
-0.0553747043,
-0.00645382,
0.0327324346,
-0.0015202716,
0.0008287439,
-0.0288823508,
0.0240492318,
-0.0488277115,
0.0131199481,
-0.004810649,
-0.0352880657,
-0.0067818537,
-0.0196814854,
-0.056999851,
0.0467708856,
0.0332324989,
0.0528383218,
-0.0040426366,
-0.0638005435,
0.0042928108,
-0.0503591225,
0.0706117153,
0.0773452222,
0.0042520179,
-0.0022509997,
0.060724806,
-0.003410158,
-0.0811894313,
-0.0121729095,
-0.0124886632,
0.0207787678,
0.0605643205,
0.0315229073,
0.0314170681,
0.0265201181,
-0.0083064483,
-0.0396340452,
-0.0084358631,
-0.0404624343,
0.1001901627,
-0.0114150951,
0.0209053922,
0.0071868207,
0.0149720758,
-0.0117962183,
0.0125361336,
-0.0375931337,
0.0144126918,
0.0340961441,
0.0175788328,
-0.0084096799,
0.0085290894,
0.0670411959,
-0.0146219805,
0.0614542626,
0.0426334962,
-0.0142496508,
0.054795865,
0.0174342226,
0.0392984487,
-0.0330017172,
-0.0037590277,
0.0425486155,
-0.0195689332,
-0.0129484432,
0.0110781621,
0.009241445,
0.052089259,
-0.0496243797,
-0.02344843,
-0.0000639384,
0.0231003817,
-0.0591427125,
0.0352516286,
0.0188546833,
0.0290944315,
-0.0486343168,
0.0473809205,
-0.0434045568,
0.0294617862,
-0.0069272355,
-0.0283928402,
0.0132004218,
0.0194915254,
-0.0276283231,
-0.0114616258,
-0.0148750925,
-0.0271608103,
0.0257714204,
-0.065237835,
0.0075309472,
0.049769368,
2.748e-7,
0.0446471386,
0.0021385825,
0.0242569856,
0.0104542645,
-0.0080682607,
0.0450304225,
0.0134081636,
0.0363323428,
0.0376748033,
-0.0362708271,
0.0189300366,
0.0244577341,
0.0194577388,
-0.0180616695,
-0.080411762,
0.0233781431,
-0.0535156466,
-0.0341008008,
-0.0074718567,
0.0023398295,
0.015853107,
0.1342026591,
-0.0259253532,
0.0144806067,
-0.0069796946,
-0.0729948878,
0.0400878973,
0.0008960802,
-0.0008622065,
0.0149978204,
0.0267223604,
0.0115493368,
-0.0069909645,
0.0237438437,
-0.0030298561,
0.0283615813,
0.0435037203,
0.0362799466,
-0.0002089542,
-0.0436622314,
-0.0466734804,
0.046421472,
-0.0100922212,
0.0240198858,
0.0673587844,
-0.0612593964,
-0.0060791634,
-0.0255780183,
-0.017716676,
0.0388776548,
-0.0121758925,
0.0303988066,
-0.0111490479,
0.0191392098,
0.0455245934,
-0.024412876,
-0.0353196338,
-0.0876960009,
-0.0147011448,
-0.0397896655,
-0.0299648009,
0.0440234505,
-0.0221075602,
0.0095417937,
0.0160363503,
-0.0155326473,
-0.068535164,
2.023847705e-34,
0.0109791281,
0.0036335825,
-0.0061472477,
-0.01480023,
0.0116430894,
0.003900032,
-0.0679267421,
0.0035021745,
-0.0045401189,
-0.0333664343,
-0.0280312262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02089v1 | LlamaRec: Two-Stage Recommendation using Large Language Models for Ranking | 2023-10-25T06:23:48 | 2023-10-25T06:23:48 | Zhenrui Yue, Sara Rabhi, Gabriel de Souza Pereira Moreira, Dong Wang, Even Oldridge | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have exhibited significant progress in
language understanding and generation. By leveraging textual features,
customized LLMs are also applied for recommendation and demonstrate
improvements across diverse recommendation scenarios. Yet the majority of
existing methods perform training-free recommendation that heavily relies on
pretrained knowledge (e.g., movie recommendation). In addition, inference on
LLMs is slow due to autoregressive generation, rendering existing methods less
effective for real-time recommendation. As such, we propose a two-stage
framework using large language models for ranking-based recommendation
(LlamaRec). In particular, we use small-scale sequential recommenders to
retrieve candidates based on the user interaction history. Then, both history
and retrieved items are fed to the LLM in text via a carefully designed prompt
template. Instead of generating next-item titles, we adopt a verbalizer-based
approach that transforms output logits into probability distributions over the
candidate items. Therefore, the proposed LlamaRec can efficiently rank items
without generating long text. To validate the effectiveness of the proposed
framework, we compare against state-of-the-art baseline methods on benchmark
datasets. Our experimental results demonstrate the performance of LlamaRec,
which consistently achieves superior performance in both recommendation
performance and efficiency. | [
0.0557257459,
0.0605021007,
0.0168119483,
0.0164155886,
0.0278519224,
-0.0227100216,
0.0116480002,
0.0002947332,
0.0630711839,
-0.0407185443,
-0.0529612415,
-0.034216959,
-0.0030352655,
0.0373410806,
0.013748656,
-0.0386417545,
-0.0204635318,
-0.0624594726,
-0.0083336625,
-0.0146967731,
-0.0011228026,
0.0226714369,
0.0286381021,
0.0310627669,
0.0520026721,
0.0052240281,
-0.006776636,
-0.0042390898,
0.01171833,
-0.0550432876,
0.0073785363,
-0.0053916108,
0.0158126317,
-0.0101954285,
0.0000019999,
-0.0264370646,
0.013896537,
-0.0371146947,
0.0251319055,
0.0028279833,
0.0212574825,
0.0732210129,
0.0194920469,
0.0263950638,
-0.0371572077,
-0.0183083806,
0.001438286,
0.0375326239,
0.0261312593,
0.0289936755,
-0.0195698515,
-0.0033358354,
0.0224964824,
-0.0629264489,
0.0350612476,
0.0018003797,
0.0235691722,
-0.0372409858,
0.0498762466,
0.0515733026,
0.0156369042,
-0.0083425995,
0.0048909904,
-0.0621667951,
0.056169644,
0.0517556183,
-0.0060687964,
0.0080067832,
-0.0037481475,
0.1015211493,
-0.011303179,
0.0053290622,
0.0086352695,
0.0080507109,
0.0047523263,
0.0015666254,
-0.0453637615,
-0.0138282664,
-0.0077254637,
0.025705589,
0.0276857466,
0.0052295066,
0.0403935462,
0.0155316489,
0.0238111336,
0.0856302902,
0.0201699864,
-0.0168418009,
0.0283972472,
0.0069649364,
0.0288822036,
-0.0709000081,
0.0434898324,
0.0157929752,
-0.0529806651,
-0.0174495894,
0.0075938459,
0.063755855,
-0.0064059813,
-0.0366459042,
0.0215063542,
0.0230874475,
-0.0078106998,
0.0571430251,
-0.0310798176,
0.0364119038,
-0.0030005337,
-0.0452096723,
-0.0650006235,
0.0023084597,
-0.0034509816,
-0.0050571053,
-0.0064278082,
0.0370875485,
-0.0375151411,
-0.0362351276,
-0.0495069548,
0.0493356623,
0.02671168,
0.0293946993,
0.0159917604,
0.0383074507,
-0.0162621066,
0.0137605481,
-0.0648530573,
0.0079426104,
-0.0293575227,
0.0168972947,
0.0308850687,
0.0132107455,
0.0006278592,
0.0147122731,
-0.0041815382,
-0.0448644198,
0.0055775857,
0.006789926,
-0.0142255696,
-0.0256635565,
-0.0111338003,
-0.0281796493,
-0.0016727034,
-0.0521792881,
-0.0445253961,
-0.0695305765,
0.0418536291,
0.035647288,
0.0190490317,
-0.0060660955,
0.0389161818,
0.0044999891,
-0.032802958,
0.0486321077,
0.0331143439,
-0.0235943384,
0.0102559701,
0.0130434558,
0.0077500315,
0.0035746899,
-0.0255511757,
0.1100305095,
0.0428505987,
0.0447060913,
0.007162523,
0.0476949699,
-0.0200681444,
0.0338047445,
-0.0376148373,
0.028188644,
-0.0097065466,
0.0298868529,
0.0601273775,
0.0413548723,
-0.0578085482,
0.0024206094,
0.0538075715,
0.0291486327,
0.0133634023,
0.0385298654,
0.0652208999,
0.0098151201,
-0.0064758831,
-0.0370591842,
0.0082247229,
0.0465135649,
-0.0176132768,
-0.0446048453,
0.0882342532,
0.0288575832,
-0.0415649042,
-0.0279789772,
0.042166926,
-0.0375234932,
-0.0078290235,
0.0367751159,
0.0169522837,
0.0034044841,
-0.0315367989,
0.015139333,
0.0440895967,
-0.0168895368,
0.0048734494,
-0.022968607,
0.0552749,
0.1444256306,
0.0739763156,
-0.0095052579,
0.0164395552,
-0.016387539,
-0.0119710397,
-0.0300130155,
0.0346967578,
-0.0501630306,
0.0204594042,
-0.0473881215,
-0.0374600999,
0.0284988116,
-0.0242142025,
0.0588318408,
0.0015110635,
0.0409406312,
0.0157614332,
0.0038999908,
-0.0237047542,
-0.0018566631,
-0.0283684246,
-0.0360230356,
0.0730659813,
-0.0287316944,
0.0312161893,
-0.0038772218,
0.0279160161,
-0.0236994494,
0.0284048617,
-0.0522609353,
-0.0203901883,
-0.0139456363,
-0.0361345448,
-0.0441644527,
0.0277813934,
0.0060392017,
0.0344358832,
0.0443291888,
0.0013860526,
-0.0309644826,
-0.0284172613,
0.0082059596,
0.0316888653,
-0.0155094825,
0.0243553706,
0.0233042501,
0.0309137329,
-0.0370813943,
0.04980525,
-0.0062487526,
0.0153283486,
0.0289100874,
0.0002202968,
-0.0185788516,
-0.046058502,
-0.0573359095,
0.0330631882,
0.0349219069,
-0.0082798451,
0.0225868393,
0.0130415075,
-0.0147253294,
-0.0359987393,
-0.0988076329,
0.0200621281,
0.0082698353,
0.0019774279,
-0.0142977154,
0.0303543527,
0.0181248523,
-0.0281958003,
-0.0517510772,
-0.005456503,
-0.010511131,
0.0074016224,
0.0054380111,
0.0173675548,
-0.0156886857,
-0.0575356297,
-0.0223357808,
0.0139985858,
0.0438804775,
-0.0077629779,
0.0208253488,
-0.0729331896,
-0.0007560791,
-0.0527133979,
-0.0061795292,
-0.0356579199,
0.0046218163,
-0.0302051175,
-0.050129503,
0.0556363426,
0.0296502095,
0.0081743151,
0.0361710936,
0.0545392409,
-0.0048253229,
-0.0680104941,
-0.008448489,
-0.0095686466,
0.0168109406,
-0.0292726476,
-0.0065342784,
-0.0444696769,
0.0108400527,
-0.0229450725,
0.0132985134,
-0.0336698405,
-0.0115748048,
-0.0005047566,
0.02723708,
-0.0508528277,
-0.0124490531,
-0.0079581933,
0.0498528704,
0.0163052287,
-0.0328120962,
0.0703523457,
-0.0134037239,
-0.0056486609,
-0.0048051132,
-0.0310573839,
-0.0409755148,
0.0092760623,
0.0346245766,
0.0144555196,
-0.0763337761,
-0.0153886778,
-0.0031927456,
0.0113788452,
0.0064257621,
-0.0506203324,
0.0236263052,
-0.0119558712,
-0.0011510691,
0.0195292588,
-0.0729569048,
-0.0409709774,
-0.0778937936,
-0.0080935881,
-0.0121328756,
-0.0052639269,
-0.0337938517,
-0.0474200398,
-0.0073862374,
-0.0028523388,
0.0467345268,
-0.0298670437,
-0.0409850888,
0.0094789965,
0.0509356037,
0.0651383549,
-0.0620812662,
-0.0142659796,
-0.0086043859,
0.0505796261,
0.0499429964,
0.0377242044,
-0.0078988718,
-0.0225030035,
-0.0079357596,
0.0814459994,
-0.009551134,
-0.0387416966,
0.0378188267,
0.0021010439,
0.0205422211,
-0.008725578,
0.0945380032,
0.03308402,
-0.1051897481,
-0.0010128702,
-0.0077532479,
0.0286709312,
0.0208155066,
0.0540379137,
-0.0576559268,
-0.0064113061,
0.0142292148,
0.044831343,
0.0246070065,
-0.0380778834,
-0.0244960487,
-0.102355428,
0.0405697674,
-0.0019315557,
0.0212498531,
0.0179053098,
-0.0673477724,
-0.0035028935,
-0.0141153336,
-0.0274386853,
0.043074131,
-0.0197684653,
0.0085910698,
-0.0139977708,
-0.020695556,
-0.0061190743,
0.0654944405,
-0.016213797,
0.0255205892,
0.0462764874,
0.0545902029,
0.0091856113,
0.0013944405,
0.0087977638,
-0.021502655,
-0.0283981189,
-0.0248001814,
-0.00029186,
-0.0236226749,
0.0189668946,
-0.02346869,
0.031311363,
-0.0092094745,
0.0058438084,
0.0189179238,
0.0599232353,
-0.0256250612,
-0.0184580386,
-0.0029856989,
0.0028105879,
0.0184294153,
0.0585705191,
-0.0019156351,
-0.0658886209,
-0.0069157197,
-0.0613250025,
-0.0196315683,
0.031489674,
-0.03055593,
-0.0142391967,
0.0207147468,
0.0126010049,
-0.0661862269,
-0.0418501571,
0.0041930093,
0.0229053609,
0.0149448775,
0.0602633432,
-0.0358154066,
-0.0463426374,
0.0140835457,
0.0136997905,
0.0092486599,
0.0144320102,
-0.0565304235,
0.0084959064,
0.0449156389,
-0.0805409029,
-0.0183086451,
0.0057040281,
-0.0662605092,
-0.0563865714,
-0.0564732775,
0.0624779537,
0.0173896197,
0.0508511253,
-0.0438211225,
-0.097539939,
0.0431600288,
0.0221172441,
-0.0095148077,
-0.007588285,
-0.0378896557,
0.0671288148,
0.0053840773,
0.0357952528,
-0.0695665106,
0.0217088126,
-0.0446756147,
0.0043027769,
-0.015850991,
-0.0630924329,
0.0081029246,
0.0218618046,
0.0399679691,
-0.0346963927,
0.0321213603,
-0.0358724184,
0.0352297835,
-0.0322930925,
-0.0342753381,
-0.0593190342,
0.0328647234,
0.0745185688,
-0.0224943254,
-0.0349549688,
-0.0368841141,
-0.0140860602,
0.0338893607,
-0.0503034778,
0.0040819701,
-0.0303417314,
-0.0312545188,
0.058271572,
-0.0026551166,
-0.0000217649,
0.0020249528,
0.0334297121,
0.0500943772,
-0.0329132602,
0.0460071489,
0.0026340049,
-0.0297382548,
-0.0251750983,
0.0482042506,
-0.0386466905,
-0.0544909835,
-0.0004050137,
0.0211814493,
0.0548145846,
-0.0298355818,
0.0567654148,
-0.0134159662,
0.0035055948,
-0.0333743691,
-0.0034289237,
-0.0188465975,
-0.0547445677,
0.0351693928,
0.048213426,
-0.007673319,
0.0886336863,
0.0814002678,
-0.0011515582,
-0.0209767781,
0.0233654287,
-0.0396414287,
-0.0219418928,
-0.0029779782,
0.0095681157,
0.0438908525,
-0.0292585883,
-0.0304815006,
0.0169414654,
-0.028259933,
0.0099308779,
-0.0485187583,
-0.0134390071,
-0.0495851859,
0.0460294634,
0.0471087135,
0.0054416279,
0.0250107385,
-0.083085224,
-0.0232605562,
-0.0060519502,
-0.0437999107,
-0.0396808796,
-6.547712919e-33,
0.0049728039,
-0.0275097415,
0.0171747804,
0.0189362541,
-0.0173096284,
-0.0017589473,
-0.0075897635,
-0.0071636145,
0.0465751477,
0.0131090255,
-0.0203439463,
0.0198016092,
0.000854291,
0.0187823027,
0.0016880626,
-0.0081891706,
0.0437345095,
0.0234190356,
-0.02020685,
0.0524550043,
0.0422038324,
0.05833878,
-0.0185552984,
-0.0344128497,
0.0161816292,
-0.025004629,
0.0013545309,
-0.0166212767,
0.035244368,
0.0556253083,
-0.0228710994,
0.0530154668,
0.0008306613,
-0.0450156368,
0.0232368317,
0.022474559,
-0.0745197758,
-0.0038673547,
0.0112472419,
-0.0109022902,
-0.0230018366,
-0.0292885546,
-0.0021877841,
0.0046326956,
-0.0025655271,
-0.0014296207,
0.0283218566,
-0.0244727395,
-0.0626191124,
-0.0408672467,
0.0241695233,
0.0032239088,
-0.0274001565,
-0.0162860919,
0.0211116672,
0.0672861263,
-0.0161573347,
0.0396721177,
-0.0576711483,
0.0315104276,
-0.0435210504,
0.0417529307,
-0.0049022767,
-0.0034144681,
-0.0246973522,
0.0496809743,
0.0154432496,
-0.0365028791,
0.0127397757,
0.0093321903,
-0.0656323358,
0.0116295097,
-0.0372276567,
-0.0104610519,
0.0007610153,
-0.0051387139,
-0.0751852095,
0.0444090068,
0.0577597767,
-0.0063863387,
0.0372716263,
0.0132092144,
-0.0205090065,
-0.0342933238,
-0.0314099379,
-0.0201324802,
-0.0279863756,
-0.0319274813,
0.0286320169,
0.046184577,
0.0172750708,
-0.0423434041,
0.0300561562,
-0.0294089857,
-0.0534865782,
0.031060962,
-0.0518079251,
-0.0125721199,
0.0215816684,
0.037898045,
-0.0487625115,
0.0237577297,
0.0031899735,
-0.0739944503,
-0.0421161875,
0.0197214186,
-0.0009649625,
0.0137512758,
-0.0663316473,
0.0055670487,
0.0029463305,
-0.00782008,
-0.0136230746,
0.0435830615,
0.0352780856,
0.0289457943,
-0.0172824264,
0.086636506,
0.0096109267,
0.0096851401,
-0.0199549124,
-0.0553651005,
0.0266246852,
-0.0235367976,
-0.0287076682,
-0.0065637263,
-0.0342639163,
0.0283640325,
0.0360871293,
-0.0728845075,
-0.0262437314,
0.0011788813,
2.754e-7,
-0.0057993978,
0.0277006533,
-0.0543459579,
0.0048213974,
0.0253459923,
0.0077601257,
0.0360903703,
0.0560717471,
0.039531704,
0.0482548214,
0.0162856095,
0.0257283207,
0.0244786087,
0.0032375553,
-0.0900394917,
0.0114380587,
-0.0895544365,
-0.0195978954,
-0.0804550946,
-0.0773482248,
0.0151268477,
0.0945878923,
0.0335256644,
-0.0029896612,
0.0211512204,
-0.0289519746,
0.0787393674,
-0.0234466977,
-0.0478966869,
-0.0071384469,
0.0556477979,
0.0180398393,
-0.0421901271,
-0.0141712334,
-0.0180046856,
0.0135782119,
0.0045087468,
0.0599829629,
-0.0149331959,
-0.006241709,
0.0253126714,
0.0084847501,
0.0073237647,
-0.0456821099,
0.0859541222,
0.0019313315,
0.01090411,
-0.0006107852,
-0.0525650084,
-0.0314153396,
0.0564533174,
-0.0234117508,
-0.0110914344,
0.0019615884,
0.0124355014,
-0.0043189395,
-0.0123415058,
-0.052273266,
-0.0107997423,
-0.01525525,
-0.0156690758,
-0.0526219048,
-0.0494953729,
0.0176757313,
-0.0397205055,
-0.052776698,
0.038266398,
2.395596876e-34,
0.0266012289,
0.0248940513,
-0.0155080212,
-0.0142641226,
0.0272073597,
-0.0188626554,
0.000984522,
0.0316666141,
0.0515118092,
-0.0930404812,
-0.0281756651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16393v1 | ZGUL: Zero-shot Generalization to Unseen Languages using Multi-source Ensembling of Language Adapters | 2023-10-25T06:22:29 | 2023-10-25T06:22:29 | Vipul Rathore, Rajdeep Dhingra, Parag Singla, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL | We tackle the problem of zero-shot cross-lingual transfer in NLP tasks via
the use of language adapters (LAs). Most of the earlier works have explored
training with adapter of a single source (often English), and testing either
using the target LA or LA of another related language. Training target LA
requires unlabeled data, which may not be readily available for low resource
unseen languages: those that are neither seen by the underlying multilingual
language model (e.g., mBERT), nor do we have any (labeled or unlabeled) data
for them. We posit that for more effective cross-lingual transfer, instead of
just one source LA, we need to leverage LAs of multiple (linguistically or
geographically related) source languages, both at train and test-time - which
we investigate via our novel neural architecture, ZGUL. Extensive
experimentation across four language groups, covering 15 unseen target
languages, demonstrates improvements of up to 3.2 average F1 points over
standard fine-tuning and other strong baselines on POS tagging and NER tasks.
We also extend ZGUL to settings where either (1) some unlabeled data or (2)
few-shot training examples are available for the target language. We find that
ZGUL continues to outperform baselines in these settings too. | [
-0.0215875786,
0.0314330347,
0.0063335747,
0.0214411858,
-0.0006302155,
0.0206351709,
0.0349526219,
-0.0115094651,
-0.0177741665,
-0.0187794175,
-0.0743244439,
0.0093927346,
-0.0319283158,
-0.010051907,
0.0617669523,
-0.0152661903,
0.0528519228,
-0.0067954403,
-0.0282386914,
0.0167811085,
-0.0128740976,
0.0084519507,
-0.0030907055,
0.0068048653,
-0.0090285372,
-0.0042826035,
-0.0044117169,
-0.0057200738,
0.008834796,
-0.0115306396,
-0.0263980422,
0.0275988951,
-0.0115254233,
0.0206215568,
0.000001815,
-0.0335720591,
-0.0473887734,
-0.0177568663,
0.0058274986,
-0.051318109,
0.0354574956,
-0.0796880051,
-0.0135901868,
0.0169751532,
-0.0035415308,
-0.0787997246,
0.0674551204,
0.0559758618,
0.0205841977,
0.1109172851,
-0.0329324454,
-0.0039312369,
0.0069909017,
-0.0301466249,
0.0404412672,
-0.0527372658,
0.0119068259,
-0.0436221287,
-0.0179888289,
0.0009673153,
-0.0276437998,
0.0295745805,
0.0069531882,
0.0064484314,
-0.0069258902,
0.0261137038,
-0.0428344272,
-0.0181002561,
-0.0145311551,
0.0751440451,
-0.0543298982,
-0.017177267,
-0.0083541321,
-0.0061963121,
0.000808485,
-0.046681691,
-0.055729039,
0.0185621176,
0.0202487968,
0.0399945676,
0.0204356462,
-0.0236693472,
0.0436812676,
0.001056777,
-0.0131890075,
0.0784325376,
0.0305679496,
-0.0058173714,
0.0352640711,
0.0404473469,
-0.0007311152,
-0.0279532671,
-0.0173129365,
0.0107899541,
-0.0116605088,
0.0389383733,
-0.047687795,
-0.0286050197,
-0.0020671138,
-0.0051311175,
0.0728232041,
0.0487369932,
-0.0045516039,
0.0568172298,
-0.0836458728,
0.0069688307,
-0.0156633779,
0.0262425337,
-0.0408387296,
-0.079794094,
-0.0778484643,
0.0135537367,
-0.0226687994,
0.0248347148,
-0.0565332398,
-0.0044826767,
-0.0152543616,
-0.0138597889,
-0.0193841811,
-0.0106883412,
-0.0000850533,
-0.0200270172,
-0.0424389765,
-0.0079337442,
0.0071061258,
0.1014603451,
-0.0331908427,
0.0119309817,
-0.0001416439,
-0.0688127279,
-0.0505937412,
0.0428324081,
-0.0011198361,
-0.0546880662,
0.0017576108,
0.0780177116,
-0.024637077,
-0.041952759,
-0.0687663779,
0.0311689731,
0.0052453522,
-0.0417940542,
0.0463908464,
-0.052323278,
0.0449438728,
-0.0246955734,
0.0308979619,
-0.057768628,
-0.024871435,
0.0086545376,
-0.0339726694,
0.0847775862,
-0.0250529312,
-0.0114343828,
-0.0091462862,
-0.0114859287,
0.0113976635,
0.110387139,
-0.0023315698,
-0.0226878114,
0.0284867156,
0.0063192174,
-0.01223101,
0.0521336421,
0.0210507363,
0.0194450393,
-0.0334751941,
-0.0407591686,
0.0514525287,
-0.0087989988,
0.0706984997,
-0.007112999,
-0.0376294516,
0.003533141,
-0.011117937,
0.0124305561,
0.0343966447,
0.014498679,
0.0429873057,
-0.0236233193,
-0.0292831045,
-0.0142942173,
-0.0174983349,
0.038700249,
-0.025849916,
-0.0266826451,
-0.0010300538,
0.0324441232,
-0.0690447763,
0.0329794027,
-0.0011267383,
-0.0329450071,
-0.009509013,
-0.0192783922,
0.0804408416,
0.0558846369,
-0.014305043,
0.067760244,
0.0703753754,
-0.0126985395,
0.0485594869,
0.010932561,
-0.0120136831,
0.0213250369,
-0.004013211,
-0.0066800043,
-0.0328548364,
-0.0212496202,
0.0031804289,
0.0414137766,
0.0487751029,
-0.0166309346,
0.0868691728,
-0.0525774732,
0.0055169351,
-0.0252651758,
0.0211217497,
0.0577724986,
-0.0089307427,
0.0447851084,
0.0054430207,
-0.0333940461,
0.018829599,
0.0307755545,
-0.0945482701,
-0.0431885235,
0.0390532427,
-0.0166836325,
-0.0039822944,
0.0013739516,
-0.005138353,
-0.0168217979,
-0.001725941,
-0.0514354482,
0.0067067943,
-0.001455095,
-0.0351589508,
-0.0252920464,
0.0356067568,
-0.0299667343,
-0.0006395785,
0.0134360334,
-0.0315067805,
-0.0650606826,
0.0328406915,
0.054081481,
0.0339853019,
-0.0504038744,
0.0190523118,
-0.0000051032,
0.023908928,
-0.0137821119,
0.0000218814,
0.0455559716,
0.0313356332,
0.010877667,
-0.0362024456,
0.0282694269,
-0.0220290497,
-0.0386003032,
0.0375604592,
-0.0155091183,
-0.0113982521,
-0.0279341601,
0.0232907292,
-0.0550230965,
-0.005552901,
-0.090156883,
0.0456279293,
-0.0198436249,
0.039135769,
0.022533305,
0.0252250414,
-0.0047035404,
-0.026852306,
-0.0382472686,
0.03482363,
0.0208763257,
0.0285427663,
0.0433956236,
-0.0037441114,
0.0373339057,
0.0050731441,
-0.0065998412,
-0.0022683667,
0.0488560908,
-0.0600412861,
-0.0288217776,
-0.056774538,
-0.0071717086,
-0.0327798352,
0.0184647962,
0.0047398391,
-0.0172025096,
-0.0225290507,
-0.0153531022,
-0.0210452639,
0.0128015475,
-0.0643331409,
-0.031918034,
0.0116979331,
-0.0176080521,
-0.0607325546,
-0.0003119067,
0.0125469109,
-0.003144037,
-0.045867309,
0.0206134468,
-0.0086662611,
0.0617245995,
-0.043282792,
-0.0198446326,
-0.0534572341,
-0.0040464923,
-0.0177119933,
-0.0432294123,
-0.0264844671,
0.0411028527,
-0.0019101276,
-0.005085235,
-0.0435313322,
0.0022915765,
0.0062904162,
-0.0299730543,
-0.0437056497,
-0.0545324571,
-0.0034487729,
-0.0368614085,
-0.0086706467,
0.0068798307,
0.0206307229,
0.0400486216,
-0.0351993665,
-0.0313965231,
-0.0264938772,
-0.0145359421,
0.0153213227,
0.028550921,
-0.0260345973,
0.0093145976,
-0.0165952891,
-0.0110464888,
-0.021095125,
-0.0107858181,
-0.0054174843,
0.0622554831,
-0.0453346446,
0.0024026353,
-0.0346818231,
-0.0210883822,
0.0509666465,
0.083841756,
0.0045593162,
-0.0024975301,
-0.0178649649,
0.0335788094,
0.0422826037,
0.0032898295,
-0.0027229863,
-0.0137041193,
-0.0097002601,
0.0242307577,
0.0446533412,
0.0054659625,
-0.0127630886,
0.0437698103,
0.036538288,
-0.0202044044,
-0.0397017188,
-0.0250305366,
0.0451829098,
-0.012660834,
-0.0078189457,
0.0759535134,
0.0136263315,
-0.0562242642,
-0.006403184,
-0.0153648863,
0.02447192,
0.0232318155,
0.0492047109,
-0.0837358683,
-0.0386796594,
0.0023357291,
-0.0160226393,
0.0354705155,
-0.0302501395,
-0.0376425311,
-0.162422061,
-0.0135927163,
0.0022823443,
-0.051436469,
0.0065154061,
-0.0460675545,
0.0112500293,
-0.0208291076,
0.0216604769,
-0.0353582986,
0.0063492223,
-0.0195464771,
0.0189505946,
0.035988491,
-0.0680682957,
-0.0089065889,
-0.0459164754,
0.0872114152,
0.011984895,
-0.0070969877,
-0.0312530361,
0.0035511584,
0.0552319475,
-0.0406911299,
-0.0141156754,
-0.0180154797,
0.0626017526,
0.0037297322,
-0.0203279126,
0.0617259629,
-0.0161980111,
-0.0323664434,
-0.0172070563,
-0.0117821479,
0.0829677507,
0.0518301651,
-0.0109054428,
0.0522633269,
-0.0434790887,
0.0301546194,
0.0461021662,
0.0038131021,
-0.0240455642,
-0.0018543841,
0.0120783448,
-0.0272324532,
-0.0479719378,
-0.002297804,
0.0428845845,
-0.0414802358,
-0.0724211559,
-0.0378887765,
-0.072712265,
0.07119295,
0.0825054348,
0.0125952344,
0.0156071121,
-0.0278391726,
-0.0271429103,
0.0112895668,
0.0283727292,
-0.0536622405,
-0.0034517213,
-0.0060456004,
-0.008653176,
0.0283467174,
0.002093266,
0.0062445835,
-0.0399439856,
-0.014352154,
-0.0553670153,
-0.0208659545,
0.0578630865,
0.0162517689,
0.0472471938,
-0.0524678715,
-0.0506452546,
0.0377090573,
0.0219246373,
-0.0105237151,
0.0127816163,
0.0421569943,
0.0009902741,
0.0264659002,
0.057736747,
-0.0152500039,
0.0284658242,
0.032594949,
0.050410606,
-0.0184872486,
0.0118784579,
-0.0033616272,
0.002713508,
0.0378404297,
-0.0122281928,
0.0078138541,
-0.0367515124,
-0.0026558947,
-0.0392962918,
0.0067476928,
-0.0367368869,
-0.0241659433,
0.0513575338,
0.0127013838,
0.0025640209,
0.0202696137,
-0.0396908224,
0.0385308899,
-0.020484725,
0.0049277744,
0.0513534695,
0.0043582111,
-0.0247063581,
0.0554408245,
0.0068888245,
-0.0008245753,
0.014179931,
0.0413659066,
-0.0856659263,
0.0110006463,
0.0307794735,
0.0109729534,
-0.0163939502,
0.0164909251,
-0.0096799061,
0.0181332696,
0.0002144874,
0.0346516408,
0.0654189363,
-0.0325320363,
0.11360237,
0.0478420146,
-0.01874041,
-0.0115914987,
0.0159049798,
-0.0355664492,
-0.0201360434,
0.0112012029,
0.0077856109,
-0.0111256652,
-0.0062124482,
0.0612413064,
-0.0187704861,
0.0411977917,
-0.0022234488,
0.0432635583,
-0.0166631546,
0.0338767953,
0.0168861225,
-0.0209101904,
-0.0020619098,
0.0395572372,
-0.0197744891,
-0.0605098829,
0.0221146941,
-0.0507346801,
-0.0111136921,
0.0298850313,
-0.0006362514,
0.0277863108,
-0.0117753763,
0.0057584685,
-0.0410789922,
-0.0424925238,
0.0293991584,
-0.0157295596,
0.0007195172,
-6.180763256e-33,
-0.0271021146,
0.018485615,
0.0087644849,
-0.0263933204,
-0.0242894366,
-0.0206746757,
-0.0382340923,
-0.0116861537,
-0.0530114174,
-0.0056444639,
-0.020707164,
-0.0161768887,
0.0334215909,
0.0408859998,
0.0208243411,
-0.0101017887,
0.033826787,
0.0161869638,
-0.0115785934,
-0.0042654281,
0.0528861098,
0.055516053,
0.121075511,
0.0071242494,
-0.0025806879,
0.0216016062,
-0.0064393175,
0.0259639844,
0.0738922283,
0.0398779996,
0.0055376501,
0.0315263011,
0.0352170803,
-0.0485844091,
-0.0072051818,
-0.0116840359,
-0.091344893,
-0.0576424226,
0.0083295405,
0.033416342,
0.0066121356,
-0.0204365365,
0.0111185471,
-0.0312326495,
0.0505318865,
0.0124383746,
0.0099213514,
-0.0105643282,
-0.0350885205,
0.0498569719,
-0.0704919621,
0.0172223058,
0.0317325369,
0.0140401106,
0.0689239502,
0.0891540945,
-0.0104015451,
-0.0181592219,
-0.079027541,
-0.0146875605,
-0.0392617024,
0.0363519154,
0.0590736903,
0.0188437272,
-0.0283043105,
0.0551326461,
0.0438635722,
-0.0321668349,
0.0030864268,
-0.0034322431,
0.043116115,
-0.004031417,
0.0015020195,
0.0550520122,
0.059624128,
-0.0232799985,
-0.0348047502,
0.0134357354,
0.0285888016,
0.0137436287,
-0.0252518859,
0.0136278644,
0.0162823182,
-0.0346931405,
-0.021292422,
-0.0619395971,
-0.0530296788,
-0.0584218167,
0.0307025313,
0.0012450248,
0.0005616292,
0.0286616199,
0.0663180575,
-0.0219700765,
-0.0129881371,
0.0312743708,
0.0137779396,
0.0163115878,
0.0096063083,
0.0230000205,
-0.0947408155,
-0.0642503053,
0.0100501468,
0.0235871188,
0.0364777036,
0.0096160676,
0.0880578309,
0.0074112439,
-0.0734734833,
-0.0054509616,
-0.0598596968,
0.0236585755,
0.001394134,
0.0574581698,
0.0008446367,
0.0064367927,
-0.0235474575,
0.0249725245,
0.0484834239,
-0.0313965492,
0.0209953394,
0.00002491,
0.0111296838,
0.0098515581,
-0.0268071499,
0.0152837075,
0.0071538258,
0.0196041167,
0.0286804158,
-0.0400450118,
-0.0134841343,
0.0123045538,
2.686e-7,
0.0158038903,
0.0032765362,
-0.0116909426,
-0.0073514814,
-0.0166141242,
0.0217900127,
-0.0473244563,
0.0461727157,
-0.0079052029,
0.0077655418,
-0.0583766028,
0.0192328207,
0.0442164689,
0.0575691462,
-0.0920673534,
0.0104559707,
0.0291568171,
0.0432499312,
-0.0068937815,
-0.0039675599,
0.0013569336,
0.0817284286,
-0.0015373403,
-0.0120004974,
-0.003549611,
-0.0318905227,
0.0488857888,
-0.0127401985,
-0.0253303684,
-0.0098305456,
-0.0165143274,
0.0482374765,
0.0071916846,
0.0273893885,
-0.0331871919,
0.0382086337,
-0.003842032,
0.0543624237,
-0.018359255,
-0.0600612499,
0.0080993837,
0.0009771973,
-0.0255867615,
-0.0166394133,
0.0869464725,
-0.0400599912,
-0.018167045,
0.0189992078,
-0.0435933582,
0.0509690158,
0.0299478974,
-0.0148112094,
-0.0426838063,
0.0220111217,
0.0547317788,
0.0104788095,
-0.0731044412,
-0.0389906019,
-0.017458424,
0.0158584751,
0.0116093671,
-0.017910298,
0.0208281763,
-0.0451802909,
0.0015141978,
-0.0601895414,
0.0156216947,
2.134179559e-34,
-0.0064848992,
-0.0117151067,
0.0203248337,
0.0213707406,
-0.00420387,
-0.037030939,
-0.0440592095,
0.0077519603,
0.0005683646,
-0.0441477187,
-0.0030170756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16368v1 | Transformer-based Live Update Generation for Soccer Matches from Microblog Posts | 2023-10-25T05:12:35 | 2023-10-25T05:12:35 | Masashi Oshika, Kosuke Yamada, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL | It has been known to be difficult to generate adequate sports updates from a
sequence of vast amounts of diverse live tweets, although the live sports
viewing experience with tweets is gaining the popularity. In this paper, we
focus on soccer matches and work on building a system to generate live updates
for soccer matches from tweets so that users can instantly grasp a match's
progress and enjoy the excitement of the match from raw tweets. Our proposed
system is based on a large pre-trained language model and incorporates a
mechanism to control the number of updates and a mechanism to reduce the
redundancy of duplicate and similar updates. | [
0.0168057829,
0.0133306794,
0.0116732297,
0.008371585,
0.0218237769,
0.0051924326,
-0.0425802879,
0.0215758439,
-0.0380917862,
-0.033046525,
0.0202091541,
-0.0416981094,
-0.0299115442,
0.0756851286,
0.0124276457,
-0.0732268393,
-0.0034853686,
-0.0393041708,
-0.0232810155,
-0.0316385031,
0.0262619145,
0.0065016616,
0.0273709856,
-0.0135794189,
-0.0164494738,
0.0401803851,
-0.0441162437,
-0.0263947751,
-0.0100652603,
-0.0106005045,
-0.0153012993,
0.0457744747,
0.0368234478,
0.0253119245,
0.0000016386,
-0.0258580539,
-0.0073814928,
-0.0605312102,
0.0151487496,
0.0055754972,
0.0582490861,
-0.0470093787,
0.018701043,
0.0033332843,
-0.0393534377,
-0.0136979222,
0.0409750566,
0.0429125987,
0.0612924695,
0.0662403032,
-0.0403507054,
-0.0055485461,
0.0337262303,
-0.0300074834,
0.0405315198,
-0.0620530881,
0.0308916047,
-0.0113747483,
-0.0532837026,
0.0446546376,
0.0243523177,
0.0394647904,
0.0077071553,
-0.0104620717,
-0.0326396003,
0.0182870254,
-0.0354494601,
-0.003497387,
-0.0217941832,
0.0257167909,
-0.0707334504,
-0.0252733193,
0.0127325235,
0.0131152188,
-0.0199999139,
0.0147518618,
-0.0670571625,
0.0321835764,
0.020784229,
0.0462394878,
-0.0393068977,
0.0127121005,
-0.0001803043,
0.0334629752,
-0.0324599184,
-0.0063972524,
0.0353325121,
-0.0168794692,
-0.0721840709,
0.075594008,
0.0020159546,
-0.091717951,
0.031400159,
0.04447411,
-0.0510774851,
-0.0057545155,
-0.0298647042,
-0.0352241546,
-0.0363071337,
-0.0771159083,
0.0125491507,
0.0233944189,
0.0416354463,
0.0384913534,
0.0024435387,
-0.0350513533,
-0.0441287234,
-0.0254155751,
-0.0082749156,
-0.0176764876,
-0.0287923291,
-0.017922746,
-0.0091648996,
0.0357637778,
-0.0485801771,
-0.0049876566,
-0.0425785407,
0.063662827,
0.0388351679,
-0.0180087872,
0.0011549289,
-0.011925227,
-0.0113016898,
-0.0221361984,
0.0050768428,
0.0427462608,
-0.0194837358,
-0.0429723635,
0.0082176179,
-0.0449860059,
0.014968209,
0.0062388503,
0.0511553958,
0.0125864372,
-0.0225350726,
-0.0157896001,
-0.0191693623,
-0.0192808826,
-0.0086998204,
-0.0281717665,
-0.0154231675,
-0.0406575799,
-0.017963184,
-0.1020111814,
0.0354825854,
-0.0007996486,
-0.00369328,
-0.0017723584,
0.0048140306,
-0.004066431,
-0.0193757322,
0.0382638238,
-0.0646387637,
0.059127409,
-0.0063651334,
0.0104857655,
0.0449419543,
0.0718822032,
0.0311553441,
0.0369374119,
0.0585770495,
0.0154019501,
0.0139223477,
0.0632003322,
-0.0269850791,
0.0196942557,
-0.002769717,
-0.0492380634,
-0.0134311272,
0.0163821839,
-0.0409848876,
0.0231088605,
0.0004683896,
0.0293825064,
0.1034024432,
-0.008188514,
0.0471790619,
-0.0081630051,
0.0672108978,
0.0327797644,
-0.0225848462,
0.0304720066,
0.0104027484,
0.0539598875,
0.0013842591,
0.0194298942,
0.02725452,
0.0261324514,
-0.0765405744,
-0.049704425,
0.0639190152,
-0.0427208468,
0.0003882523,
0.0075007011,
0.0533116013,
-0.0139068114,
-0.0151088713,
0.0818925351,
0.0302586835,
-0.0486244969,
0.0604526252,
-0.0370972566,
-0.0413171574,
0.0846176594,
-0.0093629854,
-0.0007852709,
-0.0215554573,
-0.0113125807,
0.0284675155,
0.0803999975,
0.0217173304,
-0.0200981572,
-0.0080388682,
-0.029020587,
-0.0229196902,
0.0199029557,
0.0092023443,
0.0185428057,
-0.020001227,
0.0498491116,
0.0090773301,
0.0410130247,
-0.0457456671,
0.0040450864,
-0.0488375165,
-0.0291141272,
-0.0035746892,
-0.0176533107,
-0.0456581227,
0.0218924228,
0.0205879211,
-0.0090865362,
0.0268643703,
-0.0075651002,
-0.0228079651,
0.0594829507,
-0.0358828939,
0.0235613491,
0.0577935651,
-0.0049524265,
-0.0250959601,
0.0554653108,
-0.0231951121,
-0.0305052716,
0.0157282148,
0.009556639,
0.0264978576,
-0.0225298014,
0.016636692,
-0.029695563,
0.0179799274,
0.0319070928,
0.0160452202,
0.027862208,
-0.0060293428,
-0.0174964461,
-0.0340202264,
0.0071440772,
-0.0301541444,
-0.0069443854,
0.0481054708,
-0.0003565279,
0.0042015142,
0.0477575772,
-0.0018676197,
-0.0645951331,
-0.0242232066,
-0.0764584765,
-0.0260590147,
-0.0233647879,
-0.0103110028,
0.0535278842,
0.0826432332,
-0.0152334459,
-0.0062802625,
-0.0158103984,
-0.0139902271,
0.0393587835,
0.0222437978,
0.0004889424,
0.0152766071,
0.0234932322,
-0.0303909201,
-0.0005575697,
0.0028699178,
0.0496456623,
0.0152013702,
-0.0328741632,
-0.0797707886,
0.0014407457,
-0.011855687,
0.0338437483,
0.0194631349,
0.0069833668,
0.0077774706,
0.0022991339,
0.0438719764,
-0.0265419018,
0.0562630743,
0.0003469818,
0.0010130008,
-0.059086103,
-0.0239398256,
-0.0005164061,
-0.0743291676,
-0.0672103763,
-0.0761837289,
-0.0300574005,
0.0486519523,
0.0365176313,
-0.0370086469,
0.0125191547,
-0.0653036684,
0.004520983,
-0.0238302145,
0.019429924,
-0.0229559913,
-0.0156637356,
-0.043276988,
0.0219987016,
0.0279899538,
-0.0082947128,
0.0166328773,
0.0032211025,
0.0202556085,
-0.0552707613,
-0.0245463978,
-0.0227077492,
0.0180558041,
0.0192729626,
0.0598648749,
-0.0186086968,
-0.0089545175,
-0.0084411949,
-0.0210762974,
0.019240411,
-0.0368151478,
0.0230404679,
0.0636235252,
0.0232779551,
0.0110895373,
-0.031664867,
-0.0174953118,
-0.0746894479,
-0.0438247882,
-0.0270106345,
0.0370810293,
-0.0250094328,
-0.0492873453,
0.0181584787,
0.0149766356,
0.0040220865,
-0.0141617125,
-0.0567725338,
0.0119411834,
0.0577674061,
0.0310279615,
0.0168250632,
-0.0557932556,
-0.0539418757,
-0.0081094392,
0.073027499,
0.0470366105,
0.025820516,
-0.0270784404,
-0.0043071033,
0.041355066,
-0.029567901,
0.012589355,
-0.0267985426,
0.0405091196,
0.0194743592,
0.0207499322,
0.1452517509,
0.0434415415,
-0.0491677113,
-0.013445626,
0.0333207138,
-0.0194305088,
-0.0175566617,
0.0698539317,
-0.1039037257,
0.0180290863,
-0.0197197627,
0.0228061173,
0.0222512614,
-0.0168220066,
-0.0257004313,
-0.0644231141,
0.0118829068,
0.031076204,
0.0242758822,
-0.0394951813,
-0.046849478,
0.0162598398,
-0.0116697326,
-0.0370160639,
0.0415346622,
-0.0033682028,
0.0226056483,
0.0435702093,
-0.0197965186,
-0.0488858148,
0.0104064178,
-0.0574030206,
0.0221711602,
0.0121122319,
0.0238383338,
-0.0276266951,
-0.0064956062,
-0.0066974852,
0.0294649992,
-0.0140171936,
0.0057662469,
0.0401128121,
-0.0138113964,
-0.0050409581,
-0.0370154381,
-0.0167909227,
-0.0298932549,
0.0004702687,
0.0134668378,
0.041655194,
0.0334030539,
-0.011692795,
0.0117075983,
0.0188335832,
0.0465043522,
0.0153284213,
-0.0009953025,
-0.0717423186,
0.001472614,
-0.0248519257,
0.0286663286,
-0.0458004028,
-0.0874398053,
-0.0198095031,
0.0131588914,
-0.0894280225,
-0.0487608723,
-0.0067886529,
-0.0238848124,
-0.0056978427,
-0.0175506584,
0.0101924818,
0.0384719931,
-0.0506055877,
-0.0306349117,
-0.0163547657,
0.0022926801,
-0.0392148271,
-0.0009813881,
-0.0198529642,
0.0702517703,
-0.0162929911,
0.019840464,
0.0297543649,
-0.0883710384,
-0.0380314589,
0.0059527946,
0.0145360064,
0.0303587001,
0.0260642413,
-0.0073291725,
-0.0187248494,
-0.0411567986,
0.0450010151,
0.0046402295,
0.0264971368,
-0.005293075,
0.0170379188,
-0.0065532825,
0.0044666873,
-0.0225911234,
0.0418547504,
-0.0180256702,
0.0176224913,
-0.0470809378,
-0.0088561568,
0.0243909787,
0.0205229316,
0.0595394038,
0.0175397377,
-0.0488202907,
0.0172549505,
-0.0362955928,
-0.0241893847,
0.0068649598,
-0.0292110294,
0.0054081529,
0.0272925142,
0.0246265344,
-0.0061715734,
0.0388609208,
-0.0517743565,
-0.0432473868,
-0.0715989545,
-0.0130651677,
0.003690474,
-0.0376204997,
0.0100468472,
0.0066945171,
0.0279745962,
-0.0090324366,
0.0370522439,
0.0116914185,
-0.0294641387,
-0.0739698857,
0.0087021636,
-0.0071873269,
0.0116359377,
0.0284035336,
-0.0280634742,
0.0237910151,
-0.0398087837,
0.0308202673,
0.073617138,
-0.0265896209,
0.061767675,
-0.00372142,
0.0071636089,
-0.0115119517,
-0.0205106456,
-0.0052261916,
-0.0096419044,
-0.0395790786,
0.0080887685,
-0.0101755951,
0.0654921532,
0.0735988319,
-0.0260356981,
-0.011665564,
0.0544719249,
-0.056225948,
-0.0277899504,
0.040401224,
-0.0651330501,
-0.0173307434,
-0.0307821073,
-0.0132537168,
-0.0040355423,
-0.0081515489,
0.0580271669,
-0.0607745387,
0.0074289991,
0.0494178906,
0.0117161339,
0.0803206339,
0.0004835478,
0.0453139357,
-0.0320811979,
0.0442063287,
-0.0005364071,
-0.0507539995,
0.0185384769,
-5.958115442e-33,
0.0217159037,
-0.0549974702,
0.0085229762,
0.0224008374,
-0.0768055916,
0.0031635128,
-0.0298569538,
-0.0134073971,
0.00722236,
-0.0202167835,
-0.0001286084,
0.0079792412,
0.0289445836,
0.0153981932,
0.0385038145,
-0.0289493054,
0.0558607206,
-0.0456868373,
-0.0317478739,
0.0438926183,
0.0421763249,
0.0320120379,
0.0027472069,
-0.0792782903,
0.0004852576,
-0.0597617179,
-0.0161060467,
-0.0121604782,
0.1079930067,
0.0321495049,
0.0029185121,
0.0671783239,
0.0118772695,
-0.0554326326,
-0.0381957814,
0.0638124943,
-0.0289425775,
-0.0463431589,
-0.0140371379,
0.0104987202,
-0.0081030661,
0.0328040905,
0.0407527015,
-0.0080647832,
-0.0239333287,
0.0020474233,
0.0157213397,
-0.0243506078,
0.0313836187,
-0.0792201832,
-0.0404388756,
0.0363109335,
-0.0061118663,
-0.0356023759,
0.0510236882,
0.0391907915,
0.0257852618,
0.0139290905,
-0.0390602015,
0.0887019783,
0.0287305489,
0.0546815172,
0.0092918826,
-0.0271526836,
-0.0079639805,
-0.0005563792,
-0.0163179915,
0.0110197868,
-0.0312135145,
0.0156916995,
-0.0034162255,
-0.0011469234,
0.0299338009,
-0.0028771092,
0.0135584483,
-0.0176807269,
-0.0578427389,
0.0341819189,
0.0324539244,
0.047481738,
0.0175260175,
0.0250443853,
0.0222013909,
0.0088354405,
-0.0077423132,
0.00948851,
-0.000991003,
-0.1045201123,
-0.0180544257,
0.0407144204,
-0.0034239145,
0.0288013313,
0.0241556261,
0.0019563481,
-0.0433968455,
0.0138497474,
-0.0331505165,
0.0859040394,
-0.0335131288,
0.0267652497,
0.0206607506,
-0.0242211577,
-0.0057853349,
0.0234005041,
-0.0564509407,
0.0072292387,
-0.0066605494,
0.0722026154,
-0.0484492444,
-0.005081818,
0.030991653,
0.0142961852,
0.0136721516,
-0.0186117291,
0.0163845159,
0.0103621185,
-0.0222204067,
0.0185775589,
0.0142150316,
-0.0529174618,
0.0365615338,
0.0245752968,
0.0156226512,
0.0258108731,
-0.0237485953,
0.043794293,
-0.0361016952,
0.0540752932,
-0.001089996,
-0.0372657999,
-0.0318751782,
-0.0294721574,
2.551e-7,
0.0229905769,
0.0910937116,
-0.0255202837,
-0.0133509487,
0.0262639076,
-0.0082509071,
-0.0210416,
0.0503490902,
-0.0001574943,
0.032651145,
-0.0062358449,
0.0195046943,
0.032568045,
0.0519309379,
-0.0733178183,
-0.0381066799,
-0.0738656968,
-0.0170434806,
-0.0109190233,
0.0086641703,
0.0265646745,
0.0586253554,
0.0638520792,
0.025502909,
0.0169182997,
-0.0584785193,
0.0701515824,
-0.0269280225,
-0.0591520034,
0.0372947864,
0.0175385438,
0.0153708952,
-0.030726701,
-0.0350557156,
-0.0614361018,
-0.0087660737,
0.0597624779,
-0.0076375273,
0.0177086685,
0.0254510641,
0.015296476,
-0.0385864265,
0.0026761461,
-0.0251181293,
0.0471828431,
-0.0763282701,
-0.0414862856,
-0.0199221428,
-0.0487841703,
-0.0214447714,
0.0055260514,
-0.0188506581,
-0.0641140416,
0.032993082,
-0.0052253245,
0.0427930094,
-0.0080702631,
-0.0229104534,
0.039337825,
-0.0156516563,
-0.0285045225,
-0.0354089253,
-0.032766778,
-0.0488354824,
0.0206076279,
0.0087490445,
0.0583574474,
1.522991259e-34,
0.0262752883,
0.0439939834,
-0.0165322032,
-0.0152004743,
-0.0412301458,
-0.0069820178,
0.0119985193,
0.0466300137,
0.0345002748,
-0.0558421314,
-0.0125824846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16361v1 | InstructPTS: Instruction-Tuning LLMs for Product Title Summarization | 2023-10-25T04:56:07 | 2023-10-25T04:56:07 | Besnik Fetahu, Zhiyu Chen, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | E-commerce product catalogs contain billions of items. Most products have
lengthy titles, as sellers pack them with product attributes to improve
retrieval, and highlight key product aspects. This results in a gap between
such unnatural products titles, and how customers refer to them. It also limits
how e-commerce stores can use these seller-provided titles for recommendation,
QA, or review summarization.
Inspired by recent work on instruction-tuned LLMs, we present InstructPTS, a
controllable approach for the task of Product Title Summarization (PTS).
Trained using a novel instruction fine-tuning strategy, our approach is able to
summarize product titles according to various criteria (e.g. number of words in
a summary, inclusion of specific phrases, etc.). Extensive evaluation on a
real-world e-commerce catalog shows that compared to simple fine-tuning of
LLMs, our proposed approach can generate more accurate product name summaries,
with an improvement of over 14 and 8 BLEU and ROUGE points, respectively. | [
0.0724775046,
0.0064642164,
0.0149140069,
0.0297183823,
-0.0115569839,
0.0244319383,
0.0031829923,
-0.008862108,
-0.0200809631,
-0.0609817766,
-0.0262577664,
-0.0044146897,
-0.0089431051,
0.0025141148,
0.0043388149,
-0.0619221106,
0.0171494838,
0.0092302347,
-0.0100764092,
0.0050046579,
0.0297057889,
0.0324585922,
-0.0077759242,
-0.0074760849,
0.0377569869,
-0.014367138,
-0.002111994,
0.021902984,
0.0110553652,
-0.0185286589,
0.0780888498,
0.0171612389,
0.0003958727,
-0.0067974194,
0.0000015098,
-0.0852872506,
-0.0258083958,
-0.0425045788,
0.0125858858,
0.0409520529,
0.0743471682,
-0.0112821637,
0.0429935418,
0.0373025276,
-0.0036944677,
0.0245003272,
-0.0117876679,
0.085355781,
0.023436809,
0.0836982578,
-0.0045927716,
-0.0600504987,
0.0315940194,
-0.0269074701,
0.0143786706,
-0.0457962155,
0.0030261683,
-0.0279150028,
-0.0072993194,
0.0188747365,
-0.0054032938,
0.0392680913,
-0.0349460319,
0.0135881361,
0.0125882952,
0.0280140787,
-0.0159337372,
-0.0012141704,
-0.0178552289,
0.1022785753,
-0.0298747979,
0.0254954472,
0.0015033822,
-0.0012222619,
0.0204238836,
-0.0317257568,
-0.0430043228,
0.0321544334,
-0.0066923755,
0.0088149495,
-0.0322553478,
0.0294135083,
-0.0245190766,
0.0157480873,
0.0119796246,
-0.0006236045,
0.013101167,
-0.0372874811,
-0.0183733329,
-0.0084547484,
-0.0215413254,
-0.0320903622,
0.0091965608,
0.0496397018,
-0.0170310009,
0.0027598725,
-0.0103714066,
0.0126164127,
0.0288330987,
-0.0458560959,
0.0280073471,
-0.0127238175,
-0.0117840506,
0.0738352165,
-0.0563505925,
0.0263784844,
0.0766313896,
0.0209726319,
-0.0929991752,
0.0054734466,
-0.0393603407,
-0.0240469612,
-0.0222102646,
0.0222197156,
-0.0129802153,
-0.0067199063,
-0.0709747449,
-0.021047892,
0.0092949923,
0.0217302497,
-0.0178763922,
0.0251713917,
0.0151563082,
-0.0221613608,
-0.0399474427,
0.0049391086,
-0.0368674807,
-0.0170780532,
0.0025730403,
-0.0036540809,
0.0033457344,
0.0104007423,
0.0242590401,
0.0154676186,
0.0641557574,
0.0082421042,
-0.020134123,
-0.0772647336,
-0.0397861712,
-0.0407866463,
0.0008214011,
-0.0046364572,
-0.0017438749,
-0.0386768244,
0.0057168403,
-0.0118206013,
-0.0096082967,
-0.0066921646,
0.006616001,
-0.0030637155,
-0.0384664796,
0.0760302991,
-0.03622986,
0.0038066106,
0.0247831233,
0.0159695074,
0.0213677753,
-0.0059797633,
0.0247097444,
0.0720862225,
0.0676117167,
0.0159398504,
0.0556503832,
0.0160491392,
-0.022391405,
-0.0188445859,
-0.0157604367,
0.0054079201,
-0.0386256538,
-0.0000853031,
0.0417508334,
0.0566799119,
0.0005606135,
0.0093895392,
0.0813532844,
0.0622484945,
0.0086899754,
0.0455652513,
0.038389422,
0.0462510251,
0.0247184336,
0.0105949026,
0.0228144266,
0.0002918947,
-0.0552779175,
0.0679809153,
0.0406444035,
-0.0004642168,
-0.0441894419,
-0.0647177622,
0.0225656293,
-0.0210694335,
0.0016397462,
0.0316210538,
0.0114374058,
0.0181799904,
-0.0367904529,
0.0398662239,
0.0302750152,
-0.0492524952,
-0.001708378,
-0.026380863,
0.0088561028,
0.109457314,
0.0312985256,
-0.0431759283,
-0.0619224496,
-0.0059823892,
0.034383107,
0.0427659191,
0.0292687602,
-0.0319514312,
0.0004812382,
-0.0575567335,
-0.0290046185,
-0.0335074961,
0.014298724,
0.0201370679,
-0.0151499333,
-0.0549007021,
0.0562149398,
0.007917678,
-0.0526786074,
0.0241710115,
0.0081839813,
-0.0588623025,
0.0119905472,
0.0002500674,
-0.0313358828,
0.0175053719,
0.0204331633,
0.0030051528,
0.0290904846,
-0.0276125781,
-0.0237663314,
-0.0102163954,
0.0059498367,
-0.0121900951,
0.0583851151,
-0.0525476113,
0.0023087563,
0.002574435,
-0.0543341674,
-0.0590330213,
-0.0140767554,
-0.0404301547,
0.0081146499,
-0.0347839892,
0.0126590226,
-0.0157519672,
0.0128779327,
-0.049236197,
0.0366132893,
0.0181461815,
0.0406832322,
0.0136889014,
-0.0282616615,
-0.0338975713,
-0.0271622669,
-0.0019323102,
-0.0004104225,
0.0157077406,
0.0214604847,
0.0363940187,
0.0261517633,
-0.0326492414,
-0.0273860116,
-0.0860664099,
-0.0008526536,
-0.004556803,
0.0403892957,
0.0046708239,
0.0195161123,
-0.0396167785,
-0.0279619116,
-0.0398277342,
-0.0386642106,
-0.016102368,
-0.0085951118,
0.0743067414,
0.0095375357,
-0.0379398577,
-0.0311440155,
-0.0102459472,
0.0161447115,
0.0118156075,
0.0246901419,
0.0421939082,
-0.0683837682,
-0.0135965394,
-0.0448165238,
-0.0431175753,
0.0142897423,
0.014342986,
-0.061445009,
-0.0126750898,
0.0280361697,
0.0373312719,
0.0452505536,
-0.0362950079,
0.0519030131,
0.0037476253,
-0.0274054334,
0.001033227,
-0.0211641155,
-0.0339330882,
0.0176486,
-0.0178031679,
0.0359663926,
0.0593343377,
-0.0421760567,
-0.0086364718,
-0.0037790569,
-0.0152694909,
-0.0028750305,
0.0034489699,
-0.0470623411,
0.0204337835,
-0.0161831211,
0.0074237133,
-0.0267138071,
-0.0406927094,
0.0533419363,
-0.0493227355,
-0.0075736479,
-0.0509395301,
-0.0345188007,
-0.0787423402,
0.0158470161,
-0.0146038542,
0.0296360198,
-0.0206232928,
-0.0691676363,
-0.0078158248,
0.0196909662,
0.0385483168,
-0.0199578032,
0.0421792977,
-0.0445295274,
-0.0020837854,
-0.0400150493,
0.0072159083,
-0.012385441,
-0.0604218356,
0.0166227706,
0.0056820009,
0.0384030528,
0.0107848048,
-0.0758929104,
0.0129477717,
0.0331666395,
0.0521965884,
-0.0062712096,
-0.0414771102,
-0.0042292476,
0.0123026883,
0.0949887782,
-0.0076462887,
-0.006365912,
-0.0258655772,
-0.0123614091,
0.0051790378,
-0.0118866218,
-0.0307568703,
-0.0097130761,
0.0009612642,
0.0167205296,
-0.1092097014,
0.0223534238,
0.046087645,
-0.0046854685,
-0.0189119969,
0.0151515482,
0.1259230524,
0.0272904411,
-0.0512353815,
-0.0117292218,
0.0639524832,
-0.0143894227,
0.0257225651,
0.0179535411,
-0.0409447923,
-0.0036080864,
-0.0137662319,
0.0518634655,
0.02461542,
0.0131192664,
-0.0167667326,
-0.0962822288,
-0.0176721867,
0.0007892245,
-0.0149330841,
-0.0290266294,
-0.0214562118,
-0.0288346689,
-0.0168145839,
0.0826831982,
0.0277739801,
-0.0837959424,
0.0008185263,
0.0163730681,
-0.0269248355,
0.0015165469,
0.0026648291,
-0.0156093072,
-0.0171453934,
0.0557319112,
0.0099355346,
-0.0228030421,
0.0162966121,
0.0032898723,
-0.0158711839,
-0.0043669669,
0.00066519,
0.0473368503,
-0.0107479393,
0.0128074735,
0.0021948598,
0.0367908813,
0.0088779209,
0.0511879399,
0.0362685695,
-0.0243668407,
0.0332256071,
-0.0163544435,
-0.0362448879,
-0.0214230213,
-0.0551204495,
0.0477157384,
0.0154851824,
-0.0166594256,
-0.0208021607,
-0.0537458472,
-0.031839814,
-0.0379070044,
-0.005366568,
-0.0190974474,
-0.0773109272,
0.0058330628,
-0.094821237,
-0.052553799,
0.0391990505,
-0.0078570778,
0.0274971891,
-0.0275903139,
0.004019862,
0.0426529013,
-0.078154318,
0.0066454378,
-0.03016432,
0.0112745324,
-0.057491269,
0.0277288239,
0.093354851,
-0.0536709055,
-0.0274235141,
-0.0253142603,
-0.0056821043,
-0.0647471771,
-0.0456300117,
0.060534399,
0.012878255,
0.0586470738,
0.000376407,
-0.0702716038,
0.0314209126,
0.0664834678,
-0.0021773295,
-0.0127218608,
0.0192766581,
0.058510866,
-0.019863043,
0.0282241236,
-0.05835931,
0.0452693291,
0.0064459406,
0.0700692311,
0.0108809043,
-0.0278488379,
0.0255054068,
0.0374134816,
0.0338481776,
-0.0305829234,
0.0399245135,
-0.0220095869,
0.0393465795,
0.0012688665,
-0.0113923494,
-0.0117169563,
0.0588835925,
0.0054278653,
-0.0180259421,
-0.0344978347,
0.030486254,
-0.0064339838,
0.0080483854,
-0.0689527318,
0.0092245676,
-0.0728432313,
-0.0459085107,
-0.0496536084,
-0.0163344573,
-0.0226950292,
0.0269623529,
0.0115088737,
0.0019970096,
0.0012246628,
-0.000967037,
0.0402460806,
0.0445849709,
-0.1088997498,
0.0549706928,
-0.0165642817,
0.0263300333,
-0.0608297586,
0.0494268164,
0.0545389131,
-0.0507161841,
0.0259176325,
0.0051869801,
-0.0349513665,
-0.0170557108,
0.0300530959,
-0.0411322117,
0.0054439455,
-0.0294554979,
0.0381931998,
-0.0058865319,
-0.0231302548,
0.0574438646,
-0.0087805986,
0.0075003174,
0.0082152076,
-0.0244412608,
-0.0555475391,
-0.0139796082,
0.0233198497,
0.0194757208,
-0.0172946174,
0.0049546449,
-0.0300910268,
-0.0185493547,
0.0261058807,
-0.0082957391,
0.0541021265,
0.0073183719,
0.0657365918,
0.0358294956,
0.0244696271,
0.0075608119,
-0.015666062,
-0.0401288904,
-0.0062673716,
0.0034190144,
-0.0082543688,
-5.302742811e-33,
-0.0031675794,
-0.0385388471,
-0.022192508,
0.0634000227,
-0.0233715605,
-0.0031247719,
-0.0209099632,
0.0037878079,
0.0396130383,
0.0163563211,
-0.0246540271,
-0.001975056,
0.0148420874,
0.0475759283,
0.0601554736,
-0.0098086689,
0.0374031886,
0.0450067334,
-0.0188728664,
0.0453451015,
-0.0264698584,
0.0640863553,
0.0566341244,
-0.0077893324,
0.0300279967,
-0.0375704281,
-0.0125493351,
0.0256383251,
0.0321021266,
0.0359401554,
0.0098820264,
0.0280745085,
0.0358165056,
-0.0207053646,
-0.0076443725,
-0.0312730074,
-0.084729597,
-0.0030327386,
0.0245425552,
-0.0199495554,
-0.0140417721,
0.0032513691,
0.0695921928,
-0.0253053922,
0.0017839695,
0.0188023504,
0.0749013126,
-0.0694465041,
-0.0433396958,
-0.0942855477,
-0.0328146145,
-0.0014517141,
-0.0258379057,
-0.0168134142,
0.0655839741,
-0.011057687,
0.0135338902,
0.0174796004,
0.0280265156,
0.03117585,
0.0316180587,
0.0463524498,
0.0635008141,
0.0378029682,
-0.0124733895,
0.01618113,
0.0106196227,
0.0114753088,
0.0158974621,
0.0693323761,
0.0024140866,
0.0394693427,
0.0458862372,
0.0069107045,
0.0416347422,
0.0251780804,
0.0037340885,
0.069388099,
0.0037340706,
-0.0135600884,
-0.0295979958,
0.005631736,
-0.0387184061,
0.0037761391,
-0.0032865438,
0.0793695152,
-0.0507173836,
0.0114390189,
-0.0017285331,
0.0501137711,
-0.0774641037,
0.0061018765,
-0.0290096961,
-0.0183152016,
-0.0425006598,
-0.0527115539,
0.0279280655,
-0.001250291,
0.0053177713,
-0.0658534169,
-0.0089096716,
-0.0154261328,
-0.007965304,
-0.0523405671,
-0.0264888629,
-0.0181829184,
0.0530550741,
-0.0112464027,
-0.0491557084,
0.0401978716,
0.0490209684,
-0.0079842145,
-0.0481023826,
0.0077619674,
-0.012803738,
0.0202833898,
-0.0320647061,
0.047611963,
-0.0087084435,
-0.0058063469,
-0.0522978716,
-0.0069587044,
0.0230744481,
0.0390904583,
-0.0383966379,
0.0411660075,
-0.0111753382,
-0.0077891136,
0.032297723,
-0.0510293432,
-0.0328143984,
0.0085547185,
2.221e-7,
0.0230001658,
0.0894454047,
0.0376243927,
0.0387220979,
-0.0172837786,
0.0107420776,
0.0239524245,
0.0522420257,
0.02686169,
-0.0074910745,
0.0618808903,
0.0007849858,
0.0363229774,
-0.0204316918,
-0.0983248577,
-0.0239048768,
-0.040610712,
-0.0081976401,
-0.0426361822,
0.0082540987,
0.0451687202,
0.0505417511,
0.0135109238,
-0.0122848079,
0.0016524011,
-0.0354071297,
0.0258129388,
-0.0239418913,
0.0120448694,
0.0372033231,
0.107230708,
0.0385329947,
-0.0434701443,
-0.0467486605,
0.0009693027,
0.0188956335,
0.0485803485,
0.0601866134,
0.0086543579,
-0.0257515367,
-0.0046953768,
-0.0250180308,
0.0111824181,
-0.0068373038,
0.0291701294,
-0.0483572185,
0.0414467342,
-0.010551272,
-0.0380523764,
-0.0159173254,
-0.0126877893,
-0.0415631309,
-0.0014753509,
0.0390408635,
0.0038268282,
-0.0396542773,
0.006360061,
-0.0808127373,
-0.0091359699,
0.0277310424,
0.0129370326,
-0.0159452576,
-0.0018079828,
0.0395641439,
-0.0261473376,
-0.0648319125,
-0.0118113561,
1.888801427e-34,
0.0776308328,
-0.029856246,
-0.0286445767,
-0.0126153659,
0.0182436295,
-0.0048392601,
-0.0366509855,
0.0037572577,
0.0065130023,
-0.0896909758,
-0.0236711521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16358v1 | From Simple to Complex: A Progressive Framework for Document-level Informative Argument Extraction | 2023-10-25T04:38:02 | 2023-10-25T04:38:02 | Quzhe Huang, Yanxi Zhang, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level Event Argument Extraction (EAE) requires the model to extract
arguments of multiple events from a single document. Considering the underlying
dependencies between these events, recent efforts leverage the idea of
"memory", where the results of already predicted events are cached and can be
retrieved to help the prediction of upcoming events. These methods extract
events according to their appearance order in the document, however, the event
that appears in the first sentence does not mean that it is the easiest to
extract. Existing methods might introduce noise to the extraction of upcoming
events if they rely on an incorrect prediction of previous events. In order to
provide more reliable memory, we propose a simple-to-complex progressive
framework for document-level EAE. Specifically, we first calculate the
difficulty of each event and then, we conduct the extraction following a
simple-to-complex order. In this way, the memory will store the most certain
results, and the model could use these reliable sources to help the prediction
of more difficult events. Experiments on WikiEvents show that our model
outperforms SOTA by 1.4% in F1, indicating the proposed simple-to-complex
framework is useful in the EAE task. | [
0.0536376089,
0.0405332893,
0.0252682716,
0.0424344093,
-0.0358741544,
0.0329320617,
-0.0358632654,
0.0017004535,
0.034080483,
-0.068934381,
0.0310161561,
0.0152985491,
-0.0272009149,
-0.005937851,
-0.0162583869,
-0.0896843895,
0.0472309738,
-0.0270328317,
0.042844113,
0.0412537605,
0.0410499126,
-0.0059983926,
-0.0459242836,
0.017658487,
-0.0295031574,
-0.0411301292,
-0.0427605771,
-0.0285293907,
0.0400380865,
-0.0070581581,
0.0023799313,
-0.0070733773,
0.0092992317,
-0.0096094096,
0.0000018155,
-0.0463777184,
-0.0399685316,
-0.0120462142,
-0.049974896,
0.0235965885,
-0.0238726735,
0.0080134403,
-0.0300296359,
-0.0051743258,
-0.0190473665,
-0.0174701493,
0.0035870015,
0.0699407384,
0.0164081957,
0.0888026506,
-0.0194766689,
-0.0202193353,
0.0633785427,
0.0061601098,
-0.0032334886,
-0.0242237486,
0.0205283985,
-0.0511497334,
0.0116482303,
0.0072609135,
0.0416275226,
0.01858069,
0.0217403807,
0.0119717624,
-0.0234310962,
0.0315860324,
-0.0436633751,
0.0156604536,
-0.0406701975,
0.022265004,
-0.0167032238,
0.0016565827,
0.0446520709,
-0.0172749981,
0.025921898,
0.0213297959,
-0.0546550006,
0.0284101684,
-0.0508789495,
0.0126267662,
0.0946441814,
0.0475685149,
-0.00884555,
-0.0025793326,
0.0341150239,
0.0422968529,
-0.0040291371,
-0.0085357167,
0.01582665,
0.0011293917,
-0.0127628054,
-0.0356962755,
0.0593720898,
0.03424206,
0.012724896,
0.0421311669,
-0.0370372161,
0.002720281,
0.0018599256,
-0.1099347547,
0.0098059159,
-0.0080984924,
0.0052015847,
0.078184776,
-0.0187114514,
0.004155512,
-0.0062146545,
-0.0402389094,
0.0020586716,
-0.0027018967,
-0.0252918247,
0.0132339345,
-0.0281288754,
0.0591767021,
-0.0241497029,
-0.0402072631,
0.0203138497,
0.0120960847,
0.0047312975,
0.0151165687,
0.0046361368,
-0.0004159804,
-0.0386414528,
-0.0091150505,
0.0015593527,
-0.026270099,
-0.0343794413,
0.001983593,
0.0056653805,
-0.0249775853,
-0.0434221588,
0.0197489448,
0.042643331,
-0.0152147496,
-0.0272470973,
0.0274813473,
-0.0397227295,
0.0012389534,
-0.0706636682,
-0.0541201644,
0.0064414456,
-0.0137578463,
-0.0055628992,
-0.053901922,
0.0253476091,
-0.0005923592,
-0.0127128121,
-0.0099579915,
0.0055131912,
0.0068429816,
-0.0448161028,
0.0199561585,
0.0228102487,
-0.0414947048,
0.0326781645,
0.0074057495,
-0.0495465808,
0.0526316352,
0.0450349413,
0.0567420349,
0.0765252635,
0.0412191898,
0.0146908211,
0.0180264972,
0.0008009735,
-0.0121946801,
0.0829039961,
0.0041590487,
-0.0119372373,
-0.0488411672,
-0.0019909479,
0.012888385,
-0.0304382406,
-0.0222139973,
0.0436337478,
-0.0019622319,
0.0107816486,
-0.0218517408,
0.0595985577,
-0.0045394599,
0.0300844051,
0.0471927747,
-0.0055523217,
-0.0233264174,
-0.0231179893,
0.0043981937,
-0.0080864392,
-0.0236641001,
-0.0112797711,
-0.0324203931,
-0.0027669771,
-0.0570388511,
-0.0172831751,
-0.0215702411,
0.0445224158,
-0.019705154,
-0.0512667038,
0.0406226702,
0.0235922243,
-0.0506691299,
-0.0446824059,
-0.0074539776,
0.0304235704,
0.0112154484,
0.0120997904,
-0.0626459271,
-0.0312909,
0.0102398675,
0.0482037514,
-0.0091783116,
0.0526923761,
-0.0347732417,
0.0707919821,
-0.0238409657,
0.0148453685,
-0.0102425972,
0.0106558558,
0.0082390541,
0.01565025,
-0.0123964446,
0.0140615609,
0.0544027425,
-0.0278788619,
0.0211295672,
0.0013044775,
-0.0692633092,
-0.0261365566,
0.0037816791,
0.0363547318,
0.0111805545,
0.0080728047,
0.0125045646,
0.0388790295,
-0.037658371,
-0.0008671925,
0.0294764489,
-0.0426962487,
-0.0201825909,
-0.0004690808,
0.0175897069,
0.0120584359,
-0.0197262522,
-0.038366735,
-0.055439651,
-0.0041519958,
-0.0276512653,
0.0292724594,
0.0087475032,
0.0080959508,
0.0518028736,
-0.0151590547,
-0.0144568328,
0.0780920237,
0.0290329754,
-0.0212026145,
-0.022336375,
0.0268995091,
0.0012870507,
-0.0299922377,
-0.0140869468,
0.0041771992,
0.0034563842,
-0.0129985008,
0.0498384275,
-0.0401758552,
-0.0447154008,
-0.0253730863,
-0.0919437334,
0.0441255085,
-0.0093982928,
0.0518649258,
0.0214934703,
-0.0046745553,
-0.0145849762,
-0.0060070809,
-0.0282567162,
-0.0493777581,
-0.0453476422,
0.0095800757,
0.0296471696,
0.0403966866,
-0.0013991419,
-0.0596449822,
0.0104759112,
-0.0412529036,
0.0565922894,
0.0082517369,
-0.0565586351,
-0.0477299653,
0.011680264,
0.0315945372,
0.053407155,
-0.0179265551,
-0.010552749,
0.0052343411,
-0.0193205737,
0.0343995877,
0.1089070216,
0.0033209363,
0.0589320287,
-0.0297546629,
-0.0469269678,
-0.0587693043,
0.0244246107,
-0.0411218889,
0.0380186401,
-0.0094749145,
0.0060917391,
0.0349279493,
0.0759901702,
0.0019413076,
0.0465379991,
-0.0168446563,
-0.0047741593,
0.0167848151,
0.0098235542,
0.0312369298,
-0.0631611794,
-0.0386717245,
0.0036510702,
-0.0329975709,
0.0054608509,
0.0490071326,
-0.0314690135,
-0.0059474958,
-0.0500107408,
-0.0050523831,
-0.0083772885,
0.0481575578,
0.0003654139,
-0.0017067812,
0.0197127499,
-0.0339756943,
-0.0000908616,
-0.0137404185,
0.0449059941,
-0.0275819339,
0.0253812391,
-0.0471311733,
-0.0112591293,
-0.0258513428,
-0.0442343093,
-0.0455504768,
-0.0529327877,
0.0180926807,
-0.0122269131,
-0.0091035888,
0.0045003686,
-0.0357133597,
-0.0013909282,
0.012721682,
0.0598145127,
-0.0515584946,
-0.0103980582,
-0.0274190474,
0.062372338,
0.0270136334,
-0.0078589711,
0.0070260628,
0.0098533519,
0.0416811444,
0.1063343436,
0.0404854156,
-0.0171512552,
-0.036544513,
-0.0160875376,
-0.0032797642,
-0.0643955991,
-0.0332285427,
-0.0236200709,
0.027970558,
-0.0739087164,
0.0253155474,
0.0708591864,
0.0500999726,
-0.0199742019,
-0.0162352584,
-0.0090854056,
0.0156988781,
-0.0320658572,
0.0381868817,
-0.0259009656,
-0.0189489294,
-0.0037410876,
0.0295404717,
-0.0550601184,
-0.0361392871,
0.00419694,
-0.0613637008,
0.0402718782,
0.00387184,
0.0545343421,
-0.0093276072,
-0.050475657,
0.006477308,
-0.0164658669,
-0.04881249,
0.0385429896,
-0.0098482156,
-0.0007170182,
0.0158977807,
-0.0890797228,
0.003831805,
-0.0041716886,
-0.0200693067,
-0.0168517716,
0.0080067869,
0.0219493806,
0.0297506172,
0.045824375,
0.0015318206,
-0.0589544103,
-0.0138594639,
-0.0229725372,
0.0721844062,
-0.0044771028,
0.0082733911,
-0.0253975093,
0.0500323623,
0.0055446159,
-0.0562597215,
0.0469736569,
0.0656724349,
-0.0211768877,
0.0122041591,
-0.0074732923,
-0.0047077355,
0.0140848318,
0.0605634749,
0.0100696562,
0.0030657186,
-0.029871108,
-0.0356259681,
0.0193153843,
-0.0672104061,
0.028300561,
-0.0212173834,
-0.0033776101,
-0.0479564443,
-0.1131890342,
-0.0648996308,
-0.0047929035,
0.0507406741,
-0.0331124365,
0.0071935616,
0.0356464237,
0.0020129506,
-0.0253670346,
0.0022921856,
0.0117430724,
-0.0301556401,
-0.0115555804,
-0.005833392,
0.0443893299,
0.0257144235,
-0.0271796416,
0.0653365031,
-0.0392752215,
-0.0540773161,
0.003761942,
0.0300510675,
0.0162210204,
0.0636567324,
-0.0195127353,
-0.0041668201,
0.0065962411,
-0.0131214159,
-0.0200547464,
-0.0184246711,
0.0702043995,
-0.0017594736,
0.01310826,
0.0102778133,
-0.019901989,
0.0221086834,
-0.0414222479,
0.0216814615,
-0.0944111943,
0.0085063865,
0.0025876339,
-0.006895659,
0.0735043511,
0.0272636786,
-0.0602937639,
-0.0214194749,
0.0347689837,
-0.0502159148,
-0.0091110235,
-0.0266019236,
0.0659457818,
-0.046215035,
0.026299689,
-0.0160991997,
-0.0037221434,
0.0112298671,
0.0188989714,
-0.0245722197,
0.0112766949,
0.0606284216,
0.0026754318,
-0.0261242762,
-0.0052455822,
-0.0415981188,
0.0334930345,
0.0068147094,
0.034073215,
-0.0617100224,
0.0359843113,
0.0222375784,
-0.0198766291,
0.0054844068,
0.0144332321,
-0.0916854069,
0.0061725168,
-0.0086759012,
0.0059816022,
0.0403703637,
-0.0727122352,
0.1011388376,
-0.0298852101,
0.000622012,
0.0181334149,
0.0146434847,
0.0237876922,
0.0371109657,
0.0123579698,
0.0420133993,
-0.0146892555,
0.0342553891,
0.0488816276,
-0.0376926847,
0.0320681296,
0.0057321633,
-0.0361973643,
-0.0470649824,
-0.0399819314,
0.0209524147,
0.0364379175,
-0.0243351273,
-0.0479539223,
-0.0233586133,
0.0509550907,
0.0233958773,
-0.0007015725,
-0.0100019602,
-0.0257523935,
0.0429030173,
0.0645845458,
0.0020322716,
-0.0126041323,
-0.0687653273,
0.0394244604,
0.0251010619,
-0.0495890006,
-0.0042501562,
-5.93590668e-33,
-0.0382828005,
0.0239638295,
-0.0084976181,
0.0975320712,
0.0116220452,
0.0316776969,
-0.011589,
-0.0034025009,
-0.0086214282,
0.0224744398,
-0.0016223235,
-0.0365573056,
0.0375945717,
-0.0363826342,
-0.0009361351,
-0.0200789571,
0.0106544811,
-0.008853171,
-0.012167844,
0.0315544978,
0.0910381228,
0.0250290129,
0.0551601239,
-0.1217871085,
0.0303633418,
0.0080007482,
0.002314497,
-0.0239524953,
0.0481843352,
0.0654830113,
0.0222617555,
0.0037139517,
0.0050031813,
-0.0478444099,
0.0068265079,
0.0429756343,
-0.0950270966,
-0.0399473347,
0.0370268933,
-0.0110859675,
-0.0148144634,
-0.0433298387,
0.0046891267,
0.0176578965,
0.042077858,
-0.0352460891,
0.0234119408,
-0.0210361239,
-0.0198925082,
-0.0590970032,
-0.0624879226,
0.05800125,
-0.0061069285,
0.0075258147,
0.0189273879,
0.0326858014,
0.0275620241,
0.0362426974,
-0.0493535511,
-0.0306100436,
-0.0399647877,
0.0516269319,
-0.0195123311,
-0.0339038633,
-0.0492533669,
0.0571559966,
-0.0024232869,
-0.0320456512,
-0.0089928405,
0.0549903587,
-0.0333649032,
0.0602008775,
0.0154721923,
0.0115146106,
0.0440083407,
0.0452270769,
-0.0834176913,
0.0082576871,
0.0771652982,
0.0402983353,
-0.0103345606,
-0.0130392322,
-0.0830896646,
0.0106259454,
0.0209111571,
0.0198439974,
0.014752904,
-0.0119600156,
-0.0003542993,
0.0099498825,
0.0055527189,
0.0646529123,
0.0343530774,
0.0255156364,
0.0027827783,
0.0264085699,
-0.0248360839,
0.0421260633,
-0.0232689306,
0.0112734111,
-0.0379914008,
-0.039577961,
-0.0035114042,
-0.0008656362,
0.0303438455,
0.0312105231,
0.0248337127,
-0.0008069347,
-0.0447858535,
-0.0054154806,
-0.0099585596,
0.006740435,
-0.0325343572,
0.0126239453,
0.0193209723,
0.0009279827,
-0.0007584622,
0.070738934,
-0.0075579267,
-0.0024441564,
-0.0254133064,
-0.0728883594,
-0.0032862646,
0.0243489053,
-0.0141878175,
-0.0100882873,
0.0084735528,
0.0208992809,
-0.005322699,
-0.0378252938,
0.0249250159,
0.0379048735,
2.505e-7,
0.0335424915,
0.0196907688,
0.0445172712,
0.015887171,
0.0140367178,
0.017688252,
0.0145244421,
0.0055772257,
0.0213598795,
0.0077979532,
-0.0133338068,
-0.0045753662,
0.0319361053,
0.0527081639,
-0.1023399085,
-0.1016774774,
-0.0855495632,
-0.048368454,
-0.0599069446,
-0.029468976,
0.0729521513,
0.0863684341,
0.058262933,
0.0146729108,
-0.037056677,
-0.0275054574,
0.0369733237,
0.0002303066,
-0.0459302515,
0.0179756209,
0.0517400205,
-0.0231956877,
-0.0380248278,
0.0261309762,
-0.0384874083,
0.0263105594,
-0.0037241697,
0.0757248923,
-0.0081407363,
-0.0142321326,
0.0260264985,
-0.048863139,
0.0163364951,
-0.0158589687,
0.0702698305,
-0.0195954833,
0.0009201866,
-0.0054479521,
-0.0555971488,
0.0429553837,
-0.072136797,
0.0175051689,
-0.0241373982,
0.0456762537,
-0.0130409244,
-0.0159576051,
-0.0016998274,
-0.0701897591,
-0.0473216921,
0.0202392954,
0.0116141122,
-0.0387567952,
-0.0000148918,
-0.0385738201,
-0.0109966146,
-0.0541456454,
-0.0263006575,
2.468806985e-34,
-0.000031751,
0.0155305881,
-0.0046788887,
0.0533749312,
0.0442332141,
0.0071187308,
-0.0053798961,
0.0207472909,
0.0152544798,
-0.041213464,
-0.0138255907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16356v1 | A Multi-Modal Multilingual Benchmark for Document Image Classification | 2023-10-25T04:35:06 | 2023-10-25T04:35:06 | Yoshinari Fujinuma, Siddharth Varia, Nishant Sankaran, Srikar Appalaraju, Bonan Min, Yogarshi Vyas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document image classification is different from plain-text document
classification and consists of classifying a document by understanding the
content and structure of documents such as forms, emails, and other such
documents. We show that the only existing dataset for this task (Lewis et al.,
2006) has several limitations and we introduce two newly curated multilingual
datasets WIKI-DOC and MULTIEURLEX-DOC that overcome these limitations. We
further undertake a comprehensive study of popular visually-rich document
understanding or Document AI models in previously untested setting in document
image classification such as 1) multi-label classification, and 2) zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer setup. Experimental results show limitations of
multilingual Document AI models on cross-lingual transfer across typologically
distant languages. Our datasets and findings open the door for future research
into improving Document AI models. | [
-0.0208615642,
0.0429241247,
0.011046268,
0.0596855804,
-0.0179053154,
0.04908593,
0.0571691394,
0.0264609326,
0.012200919,
-0.0491521247,
-0.0688782856,
-0.0145938322,
-0.0036946044,
0.015258152,
0.0007068345,
-0.0453589708,
0.0315871798,
-0.0306888707,
-0.0077895154,
0.002162796,
0.0037878093,
0.0049476251,
0.0003894613,
-0.0191832185,
-0.0233705249,
-0.0402687714,
-0.0249724761,
0.005892884,
-0.0158321243,
0.0047074393,
-0.0055454937,
0.0275523234,
0.0316167697,
0.0411409922,
0.0000016686,
-0.0266920794,
0.0008521588,
0.0060327481,
-0.0001574125,
-0.02799467,
0.069961898,
-0.0730945989,
0.0142039498,
-0.0576268397,
-0.0146451322,
-0.0308873784,
0.0628257245,
0.069644548,
0.0306530707,
0.0691809952,
-0.0433955379,
-0.0306982901,
0.0453397222,
-0.0292066,
0.0751084834,
-0.0709989145,
0.0035965445,
-0.0059460169,
-0.0086362362,
0.0267072096,
-0.0286922827,
0.0143361026,
0.003749253,
-0.0322160423,
-0.0299112368,
0.0168587677,
0.0183902681,
-0.0176836066,
-0.0139700538,
0.0740300119,
-0.0059513678,
0.0079061966,
-0.0135256676,
-0.0033686636,
-0.0100027546,
-0.011021941,
-0.0638363734,
-0.004091904,
-0.0341925323,
-0.0144754462,
0.0416261926,
0.0177204758,
0.0127824498,
0.0181977358,
-0.004324242,
0.0226720888,
-0.0061131963,
0.003076324,
0.0416192673,
0.044425983,
0.0147554604,
0.0042468249,
-0.0115965148,
0.0246856119,
0.0265159067,
0.0042574177,
-0.0546815731,
-0.0698809177,
0.0490317866,
-0.0496338606,
0.0266278982,
-0.0195459239,
-0.0535649993,
0.116246663,
-0.0311639048,
0.0338578932,
-0.0256787091,
0.0334866643,
-0.0150532722,
-0.0434941351,
-0.0581359491,
0.0032233046,
-0.0245492402,
0.011155596,
0.005524551,
-0.0248265974,
-0.0150159439,
0.0004719174,
-0.0172639508,
0.0111844232,
-0.0053840373,
-0.0443467088,
-0.0381823964,
-0.0581952296,
-0.00730003,
0.0392262004,
-0.0235148091,
0.0405336097,
-0.0367687717,
-0.0128758512,
0.0243861992,
0.0415381193,
0.0220630113,
-0.0339686759,
0.0054013818,
0.0403331816,
-0.0438305438,
-0.0235911962,
-0.0160631109,
-0.0112112155,
0.0269610751,
-0.0632826388,
0.0544489846,
-0.0393727496,
0.0499003045,
-0.0027283451,
0.0173685551,
-0.0146275107,
-0.0288026147,
-0.0226619914,
-0.0282009505,
0.1222833768,
0.0051431176,
-0.0021778811,
0.0569432043,
0.0049462873,
-0.0278820992,
0.0742062405,
-0.025348492,
0.0210275818,
0.0522032082,
-0.0322656743,
0.0358724296,
0.0351218246,
-0.0005378012,
-0.0143015552,
0.0310696922,
-0.0113457069,
0.0139387241,
-0.0080401674,
0.0023436013,
-0.0397567302,
-0.0213838015,
-0.0154532213,
0.024559876,
0.0343153849,
0.0390936397,
-0.0031032818,
0.0179762226,
-0.0058869235,
-0.0156401545,
0.0157874189,
-0.0209490899,
0.0272305198,
0.013863733,
-0.0020825313,
-0.0234300122,
0.0183075331,
-0.0550188795,
-0.0162451323,
0.0144114373,
-0.0293316189,
-0.0053752288,
-0.0134433657,
0.0970858186,
0.0155500779,
-0.0133690611,
0.0128167607,
0.0380043983,
-0.0329776891,
-0.0093189869,
-0.038252566,
0.0431947373,
0.0194962565,
0.0204279311,
-0.0542623475,
-0.0063410117,
0.0058157863,
0.0541503653,
0.0140981823,
0.0636323839,
-0.0085728811,
0.0623109825,
-0.0652363077,
-0.0307999756,
-0.0307072923,
-0.0066932361,
0.0410907455,
-0.0617107786,
0.0408134349,
0.0168174412,
-0.0512199365,
0.0145317949,
0.0385329984,
0.0009078321,
-0.0423004292,
0.0270857327,
0.0377423353,
0.0072241714,
-0.0125267664,
-0.026059635,
-0.03393263,
0.0014670226,
-0.0466484651,
0.0337311253,
-0.0006762391,
-0.0111664031,
-0.0180509519,
0.0220064949,
-0.0273356624,
-0.0130867343,
0.009412922,
-0.055817686,
-0.0456561744,
0.0119013088,
0.0170004778,
-0.0217059087,
-0.0327917039,
-0.0029467791,
-0.01511571,
0.0754552558,
0.0062188148,
0.0334119014,
0.029277375,
0.0058567962,
-0.0164977424,
-0.0148322945,
0.0423362143,
0.0069570127,
-0.0171868186,
0.0464510359,
-0.0312164389,
0.0155877564,
0.008403305,
0.0600411892,
0.0030638413,
-0.0200993605,
-0.0928177983,
-0.0094541032,
-0.0148967188,
0.0096986201,
-0.0073852949,
0.002602451,
0.0061438209,
-0.0430559181,
-0.0714893714,
0.0370783247,
-0.0096115582,
0.0119574768,
0.0525387712,
0.0043550171,
0.040729098,
0.0077160327,
-0.0137116769,
0.0176055245,
0.0640370622,
0.0137068937,
-0.0438502692,
-0.02001765,
0.0156655535,
0.0018887676,
0.0160806719,
-0.0247753933,
0.0020293316,
-0.0118387965,
-0.0403387956,
-0.0189998448,
0.0716034472,
-0.0220804475,
0.0267451778,
0.0162795428,
-0.0011815821,
-0.0498488471,
0.0222101789,
0.0298689455,
0.0411411226,
-0.0177967288,
-0.0277537014,
0.0009042968,
0.0634793639,
-0.0423155911,
0.0021210192,
-0.0122517524,
0.0121100126,
-0.0017750683,
-0.0236345883,
-0.0856824219,
0.0262841359,
0.0500036888,
0.0347833373,
-0.0245160628,
-0.0373366289,
0.0360459983,
-0.0359500982,
-0.0203460697,
-0.0347810499,
-0.00592528,
-0.0573666431,
0.039510794,
0.0012420226,
0.0361193903,
-0.0007821946,
0.0088448618,
-0.0105621014,
-0.0127497483,
0.0295659006,
0.001809116,
0.0223127156,
-0.011155582,
0.0154183581,
-0.069925271,
-0.049917873,
0.0176369771,
-0.0307268482,
0.0097038252,
0.0034452914,
-0.0465062074,
0.0129597709,
-0.0577157885,
0.0159665532,
0.0398378074,
0.0741049349,
-0.0326315612,
-0.0280153509,
0.0140743088,
0.1047977433,
0.0343343504,
-0.0302641448,
-0.0374237448,
-0.0453769825,
0.0257409904,
0.0253712609,
-0.0085518556,
0.0049867188,
-0.0224351641,
0.0333684497,
0.0164494943,
0.0308046937,
-0.0420159064,
-0.0359724537,
0.0178565271,
-0.0497619212,
0.008014868,
0.0364277586,
0.0094696414,
-0.0975070372,
-0.0790020525,
-0.0568691567,
-0.0002357965,
0.0020705073,
0.0378009416,
-0.0823688954,
-0.0323047936,
-0.0197341274,
-0.0229772888,
0.0222677495,
0.0235434733,
-0.0090278862,
-0.0602849275,
0.0553578995,
-0.0153930178,
-0.0416139737,
-0.0089672571,
-0.0442855135,
-0.0022215911,
0.0008223443,
-0.0284863953,
-0.0567021407,
0.0078925714,
-0.0556507558,
-0.0028297387,
0.0195385776,
-0.0314184427,
0.0074912263,
0.0044766781,
-0.01039048,
0.0031343631,
0.0728887022,
-0.0357169397,
-0.054511141,
0.0327068195,
0.0125783533,
-0.0072202194,
-0.0038278159,
0.0742596611,
0.0156172151,
0.010209024,
0.0278856251,
0.0086903172,
-0.0429023243,
-0.0010930385,
0.02144791,
0.0522703715,
-0.0015406496,
-0.0428401083,
-0.0570948757,
-0.0432525463,
0.0000159942,
0.0198146999,
-0.0032646926,
-0.0577280372,
-0.0701603219,
-0.0295660477,
0.0296319202,
-0.0478198826,
0.0368495733,
0.0040366077,
-0.0582218468,
-0.0487629995,
-0.0474054217,
-0.0495568141,
-0.0059676706,
0.0203796308,
-0.012261034,
-0.0264281817,
-0.0548623241,
-0.0128257442,
-0.0071816263,
0.0316643417,
-0.0056038257,
0.0251586121,
-0.0364585072,
0.0216521602,
0.0496018492,
-0.0586440116,
-0.0097236782,
-0.0090906993,
-0.0475406162,
-0.0149719492,
-0.02555006,
0.0384131745,
0.0126255341,
0.0252286941,
-0.0148121053,
-0.0892351866,
0.0219127871,
0.0155015662,
-0.0091468738,
-0.0552508794,
0.0618617125,
-0.0270007644,
-0.0194223709,
0.0325699374,
-0.0497454815,
0.0512854867,
0.0330107808,
-0.0549234077,
-0.0414575525,
-0.0079291193,
-0.041904889,
0.0067738956,
-0.009868592,
-0.0059971046,
0.0119191287,
-0.031855803,
0.0330878012,
0.0072181895,
-0.0367087051,
-0.0170885809,
-0.0107116103,
0.0477322973,
-0.0216185711,
0.0030002014,
0.0531021729,
0.0204657987,
0.0252059549,
-0.0113638761,
0.0244827475,
0.0703269914,
0.0395904779,
-0.0223774463,
0.0260437224,
-0.0075623831,
-0.0030253544,
0.0154255023,
0.0516631864,
-0.0379084684,
0.0658679307,
-0.014707949,
0.004217735,
-0.0443313196,
0.0112373522,
-0.0449223295,
0.0041307975,
-0.0090847937,
0.0277643707,
0.0398247465,
-0.0249260738,
0.0341771618,
-0.0041672061,
-0.0350568444,
-0.0147120534,
0.0403451696,
0.0436197035,
-0.0087894583,
0.024938304,
0.0191305317,
0.0148623725,
0.0207008645,
0.0877311975,
0.0030264338,
-0.0083456812,
0.0045915246,
0.0019772847,
-0.0483762175,
0.0360112377,
0.065667063,
-0.0054267012,
-0.0047819167,
0.0219805576,
-0.0061749443,
-0.0301820617,
0.0464684814,
-0.0412289426,
-0.0041449917,
0.0421637073,
-0.0019221253,
0.1019173265,
0.033214163,
-0.0029952256,
-0.0533092916,
0.0033137752,
-0.0298651624,
0.0096022692,
-0.0078651346,
-4.992757237e-33,
-0.0020668381,
-0.0015996301,
0.0103258304,
0.0178888254,
0.032976374,
0.0176243298,
-0.0227740835,
-0.0235801656,
-0.0343836993,
0.0440037325,
-0.0278988034,
-0.0221978985,
0.0294691809,
0.0500664152,
0.0133010047,
0.0219834875,
0.0200468805,
-0.0090702828,
-0.0104755294,
0.052475404,
0.0446946882,
0.0101363584,
0.067687571,
-0.0814746842,
0.0268755816,
0.0263918079,
-0.0167754516,
-0.0192501899,
0.0272934902,
0.0607440621,
-0.0317617282,
0.020467516,
0.0583162308,
-0.0042419233,
-0.0138447899,
0.0560924485,
-0.0621603206,
-0.0119284354,
-0.0382346883,
0.0501680225,
0.0148575399,
-0.0473951809,
-0.0217868928,
-0.0142278951,
0.0429827236,
-0.0430337079,
0.0778313056,
-0.0310901534,
-0.0241756383,
-0.0303061716,
-0.0829455927,
0.0306359325,
-0.0200446732,
-0.0023011952,
0.0706071183,
0.0589926578,
0.0146338316,
0.0475790948,
-0.0723268613,
0.013988548,
-0.0222803336,
-0.022319017,
0.063980028,
-0.0010049585,
-0.0498311669,
0.0133083807,
0.0530929305,
0.0256723873,
0.006600501,
-0.0060919765,
0.0475463271,
0.0635530502,
0.0213407017,
0.0912900195,
0.0427884609,
-0.0236381888,
-0.0416498855,
0.05270366,
0.0069678258,
0.0361800268,
0.002557571,
-0.0108845001,
-0.0254987236,
0.012875,
-0.0230902582,
-0.0446102358,
-0.04488701,
0.0078641782,
-0.00858449,
-0.0040357872,
0.0157878641,
-0.0010640664,
0.0763134286,
-0.0389674008,
-0.0463813655,
0.0452933274,
-0.0241646189,
0.0781226605,
0.0008844103,
-0.0252373852,
-0.0126692699,
-0.0738219842,
0.0092954282,
0.0000690103,
0.0105145816,
0.0049111196,
0.1076238379,
-0.0057445802,
-0.0453969762,
-0.0149122374,
-0.0220862757,
-0.0266246293,
0.0199229456,
0.0722874925,
-0.0133870756,
-0.0183844175,
-0.0325321779,
0.074281916,
0.0041075759,
0.0053823027,
0.0058209812,
-0.079417035,
-0.0137522416,
0.0416952446,
-0.0245789234,
-0.0207785778,
-0.0484418757,
-0.0441576689,
0.0605197474,
-0.0412623622,
0.0135731567,
0.0431832783,
2.269e-7,
0.0402229615,
0.0182995535,
0.0051295049,
-0.0261729788,
0.0397117808,
0.0715478435,
-0.0603068769,
0.0469311662,
-0.0401094444,
0.0198933929,
-0.0109024309,
0.0073711122,
0.077546522,
0.0342499427,
-0.0393034145,
-0.0057965452,
-0.0375936925,
0.0032285377,
-0.0568356961,
-0.0043702754,
0.0168589372,
0.082186766,
-0.0329989791,
-0.0562747344,
0.0238467231,
-0.0791621506,
0.1020965204,
-0.0411936902,
0.0006766272,
0.020248441,
0.0327127799,
-0.0072515914,
-0.0185134877,
0.0156218605,
0.0000303599,
0.0260401033,
0.0586966313,
0.0483240671,
-0.0195906218,
0.0104892459,
-0.0051242635,
0.0058862348,
-0.0223156307,
-0.0523731671,
0.0794591233,
-0.0085364785,
-0.0356111005,
-0.0445352755,
-0.0130724646,
-0.0051539126,
0.0679264516,
-0.0310379807,
0.0021581356,
0.0475842915,
0.0316128172,
-0.047088746,
-0.041639071,
-0.045715306,
0.0157800708,
-0.0085779419,
0.0134565886,
0.0540626422,
-0.0335603319,
-0.0050434307,
0.058183562,
-0.0332173444,
0.0034781967,
1.252269629e-34,
0.0173049588,
-0.0350077264,
0.0040444741,
0.0043806829,
-0.0003577549,
-0.062762022,
-0.0182487294,
-0.0002340091,
-0.0092217531,
-0.0470508561,
0.0300682299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16350v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16350v2 | Unraveling Feature Extraction Mechanisms in Neural Networks | 2023-10-25T04:22:40 | 2023-10-26T03:26:30 | Xiaobing Sun, Jiaxi Li, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The underlying mechanism of neural networks in capturing precise knowledge
has been the subject of consistent research efforts. In this work, we propose a
theoretical approach based on Neural Tangent Kernels (NTKs) to investigate such
mechanisms. Specifically, considering the infinite network width, we
hypothesize the learning dynamics of target models may intuitively unravel the
features they acquire from training data, deepening our insights into their
internal mechanisms. We apply our approach to several fundamental models and
reveal how these models leverage statistical features during gradient descent
and how they are integrated into final decisions. We also discovered that the
choice of activation function can affect feature extraction. For instance, the
use of the \textit{ReLU} activation function could potentially introduce a bias
in features, providing a plausible explanation for its replacement with
alternative functions in recent pre-trained language models. Additionally, we
find that while self-attention and CNN models may exhibit limitations in
learning n-grams, multiplication-based models seem to excel in this area. We
verify these theoretical findings through experiments and find that they can be
applied to analyze language modeling tasks, which can be regarded as a special
variant of classification. Our contributions offer insights into the roles and
capacities of fundamental components within large language models, thereby
aiding the broader understanding of these complex systems. | [
0.0127630271,
0.0267011505,
-0.0203231853,
0.0983470008,
-0.0306683015,
0.0073772492,
0.0114594903,
-0.0260466002,
-0.0326443501,
-0.034670487,
-0.0595113859,
-0.0342414156,
-0.0045344485,
0.0287437495,
0.0566676594,
-0.0022894638,
-0.0004088853,
-0.0374471098,
-0.0197492354,
-0.0311016012,
-0.0091251237,
-0.0008566381,
0.0205285903,
0.0309436303,
-0.0508449413,
-0.0082675116,
-0.0006183448,
-0.0138435224,
-0.0376397669,
0.0214955453,
0.0215314589,
0.0124166245,
-0.0122754956,
0.044338312,
0.0000020016,
-0.0438934341,
0.0123829274,
-0.0116361091,
-0.0463715047,
0.0065448112,
0.0266172364,
-0.005149907,
-0.0017634536,
-0.0397445224,
-0.0388979353,
-0.0389986672,
0.05554666,
0.0613675043,
-0.0049168924,
0.0712618008,
-0.0031755895,
-0.074638702,
0.0277225431,
-0.0402261652,
0.0153305558,
0.0029667376,
0.0114084287,
-0.0343136117,
-0.0256538466,
-0.0078685097,
-0.0254879091,
0.0519275032,
0.0487961583,
0.021723276,
0.0372448862,
0.0792889446,
0.0073964554,
-0.024370309,
0.0282193683,
0.0820676237,
-0.0765178502,
-0.004846721,
0.0126014007,
0.0123705883,
0.0129565652,
-0.0077890838,
-0.0246840622,
-0.0278278552,
-0.0033796818,
0.0446001701,
0.0050332653,
-0.0086783906,
0.0551826619,
-0.0257764217,
-0.0461325496,
0.0355936252,
-0.0027089301,
-0.000225121,
0.0110750739,
-0.005465969,
-0.0121121146,
-0.0212469622,
-0.0021817156,
0.0114136357,
0.0698360577,
0.0093372921,
-0.0146902623,
-0.0349946581,
0.0057240832,
-0.0899428651,
0.0441183075,
0.0122511145,
-0.0595309809,
0.0204768144,
-0.0440471359,
0.0127880638,
-0.0228071418,
0.0303111374,
-0.0262113959,
0.0194384698,
-0.0354853123,
-0.0062766369,
0.0102216704,
0.0713833198,
0.0345399901,
-0.0156973191,
0.0198753215,
0.0193944983,
-0.0128692761,
-0.0183096509,
-0.0093174502,
0.0190302115,
-0.0168998372,
-0.0222196504,
-0.0111525804,
0.0007218975,
-0.0106889997,
0.017534133,
-0.0227160789,
-0.0190854445,
-0.0151863089,
0.0080274343,
0.03717779,
-0.0122130141,
0.0371264964,
0.0428010821,
-0.0138341011,
-0.0420971327,
-0.0267012455,
-0.0145958578,
-0.0534039177,
-0.0478045009,
0.0099068219,
-0.0704143718,
0.0419354104,
0.0150433611,
-0.0400959179,
-0.0684066638,
0.0069909859,
-0.0147535456,
-0.0617250726,
0.0595322102,
0.05336437,
0.0055797268,
0.0633096918,
-0.0243201628,
-0.001777457,
0.0330599733,
0.0037027183,
0.040829502,
-0.0012990484,
-0.0270604081,
-0.0046854797,
0.0447310433,
0.0572524294,
-0.0364248157,
-0.0321565084,
-0.0087326104,
-0.0112707717,
0.0023061403,
0.0469967537,
0.0515289307,
-0.0207500663,
-0.0720358118,
0.0832137093,
0.1051165089,
-0.0118780592,
0.070905745,
0.0533243231,
-0.013495042,
0.0273905918,
0.0469864793,
-0.0579618476,
-0.0035438507,
-0.0230455697,
0.0129212281,
0.0028810275,
0.0400375426,
-0.0410995372,
-0.0690321252,
0.0114234341,
-0.0052969404,
-0.0164625794,
0.0238515846,
0.0841949359,
0.0144373178,
0.0016673587,
0.0352084041,
0.0174435563,
-0.0061344299,
0.028209744,
-0.0243406948,
-0.0014150349,
0.0016055673,
-0.0009058152,
-0.0319912545,
-0.0241344031,
0.0233411137,
0.0146080395,
-0.019536946,
0.0423802398,
-0.0145343123,
-0.0033122019,
-0.0120152971,
0.0131035522,
-0.0495310538,
0.0342816003,
0.0572715066,
-0.061196357,
-0.0164744351,
0.0150134126,
-0.0154294334,
-0.0679694787,
0.0235368442,
0.0027017044,
-0.0605843998,
0.0045351461,
0.0151199568,
-0.0068157916,
-0.0119802468,
-0.0382912867,
0.0276024565,
0.0259686429,
-0.0635580868,
0.0006952449,
0.0068346206,
-0.0113266744,
-0.0085105756,
0.0548957512,
-0.009226704,
0.0119967312,
0.0046971557,
-0.0027117273,
-0.0271289889,
0.0825701579,
-0.0057913591,
0.0234896354,
-0.0349879675,
0.0227030721,
0.0113551039,
0.0461516753,
-0.018803576,
0.0687507465,
0.0014080413,
-0.0121742282,
-0.0241955984,
-0.0531260706,
-0.0030785133,
-0.0051933904,
-0.0143695893,
0.0211438425,
0.0090109333,
0.0190615412,
-0.0099048959,
-0.0454867072,
0.0191647522,
-0.0277920403,
-0.0752411708,
-0.0061738724,
-0.0428463295,
0.0442834795,
-0.0046848399,
0.0034879111,
0.0310171582,
-0.0213166792,
-0.0175031964,
-0.017595958,
-0.0593636334,
-0.0096367188,
0.0295760296,
0.0161842201,
-0.0116072576,
-0.0461929515,
-0.0489520989,
-0.0103754625,
0.0874488577,
-0.0002869052,
0.0032073364,
0.0078447061,
-0.001857196,
0.0108662657,
0.0668789893,
-0.0027206766,
-0.012730537,
-0.0138936527,
-0.0406544879,
0.0184949897,
0.0628761575,
-0.0099798227,
0.0680805743,
0.0283132922,
0.0288843289,
-0.0390645452,
0.0136469901,
-0.0666951165,
0.0003985375,
-0.0396822467,
-0.0128261587,
-0.0282615721,
0.0933426321,
0.0165310651,
-0.021339599,
-0.033699844,
0.0165975187,
-0.0185245108,
-0.0095863137,
-0.0510695651,
0.0440719724,
-0.0319164805,
0.0142841861,
-0.0317630582,
-0.0350899175,
0.0699098036,
-0.0043130904,
-0.0362639204,
-0.0207935628,
-0.0093413424,
-0.0113048991,
0.0708604679,
0.0556944944,
-0.0154040735,
0.0533837676,
0.0024141187,
-0.0328020304,
0.0261857416,
0.0149490517,
-0.0362058319,
0.0617403798,
-0.0004239761,
0.0006988894,
-0.0003407368,
-0.01432335,
-0.0332129598,
-0.0895770416,
0.0081836013,
0.000904074,
-0.0342519693,
-0.0202243701,
0.0301612578,
-0.0153472498,
0.0181183554,
0.0681152493,
-0.0196292251,
-0.0025376859,
-0.0167180393,
0.0265452042,
0.0365494788,
-0.0062544327,
0.0249550603,
-0.0083254781,
0.024358334,
0.0346051455,
0.0076857391,
-0.0079987552,
-0.0477173179,
-0.0189536642,
-0.0074131903,
-0.0140811289,
-0.0419834182,
0.0145749999,
0.0074777366,
-0.0699458793,
-0.0185964853,
0.0599648617,
-0.022766212,
-0.0428801142,
0.0226026066,
0.0388755016,
-0.0131148398,
0.0139168473,
0.0288540702,
0.0050550704,
-0.0018313363,
-0.0126046175,
-0.00115375,
0.0125629455,
-0.0133497706,
0.0124220038,
-0.0651143864,
0.0324358493,
0.0068553952,
-0.0504241139,
-0.0051716566,
0.010262724,
0.0010176335,
0.0142571852,
0.0092658782,
-0.022262942,
-0.0118094804,
0.01156158,
0.0408313349,
-0.0197918899,
-0.0423586704,
0.0375023261,
-0.0299818851,
-0.0073003443,
0.0420488119,
0.0152699035,
-0.0427876487,
-0.0601226464,
0.0468378365,
-0.0160619542,
0.021450229,
0.0240628403,
0.0653050169,
0.014809953,
-0.0365207829,
0.0354040787,
0.0515976958,
-0.0587232634,
0.0257340036,
-0.0362456776,
0.0742491707,
-0.0260794871,
-0.0177374557,
0.0208717883,
-0.0514843352,
-0.0109543996,
0.0448820069,
0.072383523,
-0.0805424377,
-0.0305143073,
-0.0081706354,
-0.005976289,
-0.0194762964,
-0.098117277,
0.0306115486,
0.0194847248,
-0.0630160272,
-0.0344391391,
-0.0231369995,
-0.0163946487,
0.0067812651,
-0.0031119182,
-0.0196413863,
0.0075107026,
-0.0291546639,
-0.0413568802,
0.082351096,
0.0124826198,
-0.0221242495,
-0.0120821279,
-0.0123767285,
0.0090630334,
-0.0540491939,
-0.0114875855,
-0.0193799343,
-0.0770399868,
-0.0696855858,
0.0188257881,
0.011680752,
0.014453317,
0.0138979387,
-0.0348841287,
-0.0647470653,
0.0437727943,
0.0509292446,
-0.0207668301,
0.0113920243,
0.0426447429,
-0.0750319511,
-0.0005526724,
0.0530440807,
-0.0262558516,
0.0449353307,
0.039301414,
-0.0472116582,
-0.0152773289,
0.0123094274,
0.0347866975,
-0.0095022609,
0.0867159516,
0.0135448799,
0.0022976913,
-0.0348584019,
-0.0107995784,
0.0301109832,
-0.0155860642,
-0.0535609536,
-0.0307920538,
0.0329023413,
0.0637878925,
-0.0191894025,
-0.0308753625,
0.0520162359,
0.0194904804,
-0.0362279154,
-0.0359261259,
-0.0028284686,
0.0165348127,
0.0236480124,
0.0105855512,
-0.0279844906,
0.0374761894,
-0.0137845222,
0.0200794041,
-0.000458453,
-0.0087885503,
0.0220283736,
0.0108630629,
-0.0834933594,
-0.0005322968,
-0.0813114941,
-0.0883117765,
-0.0267350059,
0.0187839437,
0.0704915076,
-0.0346559659,
0.0210246202,
-0.0389181711,
-0.0043517156,
-0.0386285894,
-0.0082964599,
0.0358520299,
0.0320997164,
0.0096962359,
0.0017025124,
-0.0276284758,
-0.0196270552,
0.0744907707,
-0.0143845743,
0.0305462386,
0.0163839813,
0.0244225375,
-0.0074339299,
0.013383884,
0.0052727237,
0.013012222,
-0.0224335287,
0.0071070376,
-0.061727792,
-0.0632732585,
0.0315347798,
-0.007273728,
-0.0004518011,
-0.0072614546,
0.0298171714,
0.0607202724,
-0.0019184354,
0.0144657493,
-0.0469744392,
0.0300965216,
0.0186768044,
0.0015449058,
0.0123174936,
-6.580541537e-33,
0.045995757,
0.0012584679,
-0.0472220778,
0.0983922482,
0.0121627683,
0.0173177253,
-0.0134631107,
0.0096126003,
-0.0384432636,
0.0290259402,
-0.0132087776,
0.0102725839,
0.0024392286,
0.0125332577,
0.0245601851,
-0.0477771461,
0.0309551526,
-0.0300587192,
0.0223349277,
0.0107536139,
0.0684212819,
0.0302279554,
0.0756066963,
-0.0818368942,
0.0310869627,
-0.0219821725,
0.0395603143,
0.0286192913,
-0.0001154429,
0.0489393733,
-0.0524782464,
0.0518366173,
0.0114717241,
-0.0656539872,
-0.0414825976,
-0.0346863717,
-0.0636312813,
-0.0347259752,
-0.0102479551,
0.0190936141,
-0.0363492928,
-0.0275432765,
0.1069898307,
-0.0051332754,
-0.0195887592,
-0.0357446633,
0.0390601121,
0.002791632,
-0.0206383746,
0.0094772,
-0.0654665455,
0.0161105637,
-0.0005090944,
-0.0239741988,
0.0996899307,
-0.0014574403,
-0.0204361267,
-0.0283539202,
-0.0498339571,
-0.0337900855,
-0.0232372135,
0.0227840338,
0.048066739,
0.0460105874,
0.0139611103,
0.0812877044,
0.0822590366,
0.0457859859,
-0.0298050884,
-0.0365671404,
0.0305655058,
0.0393811613,
0.0308602545,
0.0000299241,
0.0734816864,
-0.0164131504,
-0.0618905798,
-0.0304899998,
-0.0056727026,
-0.0052877404,
0.0185303297,
-0.0095376503,
-0.0329941027,
-0.0262673609,
-0.0389459543,
-0.0255616289,
-0.0334327891,
-0.0139122009,
-0.0150288735,
-0.0016618967,
0.0208214093,
0.0523903519,
0.0032801433,
-0.0254469384,
0.0100731347,
-0.0153100379,
0.0324416831,
0.0236476101,
0.0409814529,
-0.0120064756,
-0.0500000603,
-0.0181474444,
-0.0714113712,
-0.0104549257,
0.0301185362,
0.0403705277,
0.0304410197,
0.0255226195,
0.0122934375,
-0.0376022942,
-0.0563222244,
-0.0430020317,
0.0326497778,
0.055350326,
0.0510091484,
0.0146442102,
-0.022242872,
0.0309004672,
0.0537249371,
0.0220493376,
-0.0273625497,
0.0183968693,
0.034895882,
0.0078626862,
-0.023262376,
-0.0423756242,
-0.007354985,
0.0004316813,
0.0463492908,
-0.0436881632,
0.0026853767,
0.0015115235,
2.857e-7,
0.0498025864,
-0.0025934214,
0.0038070506,
-0.0339098722,
0.0420733057,
0.0452319272,
0.0060143247,
0.0338203795,
-0.0137503678,
-0.0507730246,
0.0120350979,
0.0303780492,
0.0457490087,
0.0181748662,
-0.0600765049,
-0.0349939838,
-0.0140946731,
0.0221151263,
-0.0036673141,
-0.0045703943,
0.0008135951,
0.0899100527,
0.0223629344,
-0.0015102171,
0.0220693741,
-0.0618867837,
0.0716090426,
-0.0235966798,
0.0361455381,
0.0049013286,
0.044297114,
-0.0473911241,
-0.0219309162,
0.0160740782,
-0.0058602123,
0.0475796126,
0.0208243076,
0.067816399,
-0.0076286974,
-0.0044970601,
-0.0275683589,
-0.0162898228,
-0.0094285747,
-0.0615311153,
0.0597977191,
-0.0603195988,
-0.0402998365,
-0.0424324833,
0.0417148583,
0.0226719249,
0.0302645303,
0.0190865323,
0.0354936607,
0.0242965221,
0.0060393228,
-0.0442594439,
-0.0134119783,
-0.0863438919,
-0.0495940074,
0.0647836253,
-0.0616192371,
-0.0203764755,
-0.0471649542,
-0.0151762171,
0.074911952,
-0.0034310913,
-0.0155622959,
2.325821873e-34,
0.0075297947,
-0.0019078372,
-0.0027463341,
0.0420508198,
-0.0163470861,
-0.049001947,
-0.0319181085,
0.0046671699,
0.0245122686,
-0.0571033619,
-0.0374300033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16343v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16343v2 | Evaluating, Understanding, and Improving Constrained Text Generation for Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T03:58:49 | 2024-03-21T08:29:35 | Xiang Chen, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Advancements in natural language generation (NLG) and large language models
(LLMs) have led to proficient text generation in various tasks. However,
integrating intricate constraints into neural text generation, due to LLMs'
opacity, remains challenging. This study investigates constrained text
generation for LLMs, where predefined constraints are applied during LLM's
generation process. Our research mainly focuses on mainstream open-source LLMs,
categorizing constraints into lexical, structural, and relation-based types. We
also present various benchmarks to facilitate fair evaluation. The study
addresses some key research questions, including evaluating, understanding and
improving constrained text generation for LLMs. Results illuminate LLMs'
capacity and deficiency to incorporate constraints and provide insights for
future developments in constrained text generation. Codes and datasets will be
released upon acceptance. | [
0.0425103903,
0.1035252288,
0.020456396,
0.0246932134,
-0.0304820929,
-0.0464952365,
0.0283648968,
0.0297216512,
-0.0172193777,
-0.0521219335,
0.0013351724,
-0.081508927,
0.0025204972,
0.0307062604,
0.0315693915,
-0.0402176119,
-0.0048935371,
-0.0292787738,
-0.0300723705,
0.0016067586,
0.010492349,
0.0169177372,
0.0096985605,
0.0224233996,
-0.0281584077,
-0.0066339322,
0.0117477458,
0.0004367813,
-0.0020251989,
-0.0325985886,
0.0166262984,
0.0718682259,
0.0022914312,
0.0175566375,
0.000001951,
-0.0557380281,
-0.0046815574,
-0.0149918543,
0.0225154087,
0.0449667089,
0.0460431501,
-0.0588939041,
0.0078298096,
0.0110900737,
-0.0210636407,
0.023776494,
0.0288687218,
0.0306265671,
0.0608858913,
0.0649361759,
-0.0116493162,
0.0047364356,
-0.0145355929,
-0.0452449471,
0.0035170501,
-0.0060452442,
0.0279031061,
0.0078150276,
0.0176568348,
0.0049192929,
0.0050118733,
0.0204154737,
0.0266355947,
-0.0093568508,
0.0237801075,
0.0442040041,
-0.0439264849,
-0.0465989783,
-0.0074995812,
0.0719010532,
0.0495237075,
-0.0286336765,
0.0230468605,
-0.0378958508,
-0.0211280994,
0.0040948214,
-0.028949853,
0.0884514526,
0.0022035781,
0.0309658758,
-0.0023793103,
0.0397679731,
0.0291552227,
0.0466396138,
-0.0065015508,
-0.004496247,
0.0335620418,
-0.0411876403,
-0.0213443264,
0.0105708633,
-0.0445814058,
-0.0630657822,
0.0145041114,
0.0237103384,
-0.0507243313,
0.0066961134,
-0.0919118375,
-0.0181864295,
0.0307971817,
-0.0217604749,
0.0357377231,
0.0143478718,
0.0247907713,
-0.0060322126,
-0.0162935518,
0.0715805516,
-0.0215544235,
-0.0323887058,
-0.0425201096,
0.0370717272,
0.0115751484,
-0.0378231518,
-0.058278624,
0.0187092144,
-0.0779251605,
-0.0423426218,
-0.0490468405,
0.0117561212,
0.0066973381,
0.0127936406,
-0.0104716308,
0.0304752067,
-0.0349125452,
-0.0224511195,
-0.0051393742,
-0.054548841,
-0.0142760165,
-0.0092540486,
0.0287164357,
-0.0204749089,
-0.0084849168,
0.0717284828,
-0.0162227936,
-0.0463173911,
-0.0270782486,
0.070387505,
-0.0095682563,
-0.0167023465,
-0.0161674619,
-0.0567976534,
-0.0401216559,
-0.0664384067,
0.0132350018,
-0.0560206249,
-0.025307022,
0.0035759562,
-0.0015513628,
-0.0539265424,
0.0403901599,
0.0111735761,
-0.0066412804,
0.0321032815,
-0.0111696376,
-0.0084079588,
0.002038578,
0.0302203316,
0.0547835045,
0.042857118,
0.042966824,
0.027189564,
0.0003477685,
0.0021974032,
0.0092073251,
0.0362561755,
0.0298689231,
0.0054857014,
-0.056630481,
-0.0266293921,
0.0219517983,
0.0742398649,
0.0424452648,
0.1036882252,
-0.0252037141,
-0.0058416743,
0.0687299445,
0.0114360405,
0.0130766053,
0.0519774519,
0.0788896456,
-0.0078167031,
0.0055002924,
0.0399900749,
-0.0198837388,
-0.0062218071,
0.0075643635,
0.030991096,
0.0348940752,
0.0421123728,
-0.0101039149,
-0.0350819863,
-0.0113359131,
0.0111342976,
0.003652649,
-0.0550680943,
0.0286748409,
0.0428137295,
-0.0635940582,
0.0644554198,
0.0081362445,
-0.0581568778,
0.0345387608,
-0.0278304238,
0.0065824431,
0.043406561,
0.0815745592,
0.0022384906,
-0.0022014359,
0.0260935612,
0.0091325315,
0.123712793,
0.0396485329,
0.0291373059,
-0.0001345012,
-0.062230099,
-0.0051351036,
-0.0217400454,
0.0138925612,
0.0081387274,
0.015002124,
0.0061652712,
0.0602847002,
0.0074854484,
-0.0437928252,
0.0460870862,
-0.0514695607,
-0.0346372835,
0.0306733008,
-0.030963691,
-0.0110275056,
0.0118840951,
-0.0342883207,
0.0424604416,
0.0122559955,
-0.0517213419,
-0.013645716,
-0.0006196768,
-0.0918192416,
-0.0051998585,
-0.0033986252,
-0.0499868952,
0.0203172043,
-0.0022042789,
0.008848602,
-0.0439705662,
0.0225011371,
-0.0222994387,
0.0136849089,
-0.0598681755,
0.0072302986,
0.0468532294,
0.0040050461,
-0.050673686,
0.0783117488,
0.0068771909,
0.0124034379,
0.0702134222,
-0.0236479454,
-0.0058796015,
-0.0407790095,
0.0114405928,
-0.016281832,
-0.0000387625,
0.0239011198,
0.027446935,
0.0655742809,
-0.0263877138,
-0.0370694213,
-0.0297256075,
0.0132002607,
-0.0033150378,
0.0121794334,
0.0275001377,
0.0056340857,
-0.0098258359,
0.0304769445,
-0.0313488953,
-0.0262547042,
0.0392724797,
-0.0125157461,
0.0385095589,
0.0268198363,
-0.0239616558,
-0.0216959435,
-0.0009643631,
0.0296986438,
0.0462764725,
0.0531084463,
-0.022207424,
-0.049614381,
0.0809910446,
-0.0310430173,
-0.0022040976,
-0.0019056036,
-0.0240205657,
0.0139378421,
0.0211078692,
0.0546892472,
-0.0162970722,
0.0155774057,
0.0285594333,
0.0529389232,
-0.0147293238,
-0.0048450311,
0.0031108055,
-0.0327274352,
0.0123756789,
0.0058677746,
-0.0242397264,
0.0401457511,
0.0771854892,
0.0160736982,
-0.0156538449,
-0.0640665367,
0.0363398753,
-0.0370309949,
-0.0427725874,
-0.0197730549,
-0.0030142101,
-0.0136258909,
0.0186245926,
-0.0292085949,
-0.0571535602,
0.0225330219,
-0.0555655919,
0.0268157627,
0.0154022109,
0.0062463265,
-0.0544550791,
0.0430630259,
0.0278673526,
0.0423360206,
0.0414942764,
-0.0029285254,
-0.0600166433,
0.0279055089,
0.0185672306,
-0.0130280079,
0.0263744853,
-0.0476282723,
0.0074129417,
-0.0223352425,
-0.0351452045,
-0.0523933657,
-0.0528225377,
0.011774499,
0.0148756653,
0.067948848,
-0.0187706221,
-0.0000327493,
0.0085513834,
-0.0036670221,
0.0376196243,
-0.009920571,
-0.0023037661,
-0.0363387614,
0.0439990722,
0.0484446995,
0.0160156544,
0.0081480192,
-0.0438449532,
-0.0115309693,
0.0133022331,
-0.0205362942,
0.0304117855,
0.0011793629,
0.0276136175,
0.0124783963,
-0.0069597489,
-0.0201654825,
0.0144152483,
0.0561998934,
-0.0471985266,
-0.0373498835,
0.0932423174,
0.0299264416,
-0.0129343644,
0.0326705873,
-0.0119092222,
0.0805840865,
0.0137787759,
0.0167149492,
-0.0791707635,
-0.0018456787,
-0.0024135096,
0.0443254635,
-0.0245376676,
-0.0242601149,
-0.0551333018,
-0.1090150177,
0.0137015637,
0.0434165299,
-0.0382966883,
-0.0151263215,
0.0139038283,
-0.0543326437,
-0.0053677117,
0.0134951938,
0.0138502177,
-0.0311554037,
0.0146421855,
0.0382597782,
0.000417429,
-0.0383552723,
-0.0254081599,
-0.0202280544,
0.0479193553,
0.0267825071,
0.002406094,
-0.0008742969,
-0.0099005708,
0.0476107113,
-0.0052895797,
0.0166387334,
-0.028975172,
-0.0079717562,
0.0329086334,
-0.0189364571,
-0.0421283431,
0.0429975353,
-0.0165971071,
-0.0329451971,
0.0000868077,
0.0507839397,
0.0020760854,
-0.0474385582,
-0.0196718369,
0.0124906553,
0.0199878495,
0.0768240094,
0.0500712544,
-0.0553327352,
-0.0478576683,
-0.0251181424,
0.038016431,
-0.1154782921,
0.0009211882,
0.0204508062,
-0.0227983519,
0.018749902,
-0.1025248468,
-0.0098135071,
-0.0206791498,
0.034318842,
0.0169508122,
-0.0095070805,
0.0165746622,
-0.0644164756,
-0.0329858735,
0.0049652038,
-0.0308144391,
-0.0094198007,
-0.0527728684,
-0.0177480783,
-0.0087760948,
-0.0752132908,
0.0024098419,
0.0379499681,
-0.0663583577,
-0.0652240366,
-0.0436373055,
0.0291302502,
0.0268223882,
0.0027752914,
0.0109403273,
-0.0715425089,
0.0023704721,
0.0815232545,
-0.008219339,
0.039678324,
-0.0113924723,
-0.016681239,
-0.0171767976,
0.0218433514,
-0.0284341201,
-0.0037069323,
0.0090938332,
0.0845255554,
0.014070888,
-0.0240200311,
0.0520254187,
0.0267592501,
-0.0192905385,
-0.0793990567,
0.0067050196,
-0.0453015752,
-0.0048580687,
-0.0454368666,
-0.0091564273,
-0.0672461763,
0.012687494,
0.0235671606,
-0.0082005439,
0.0049923323,
-0.0061576837,
-0.0073985946,
0.0602036044,
-0.0130919423,
-0.0086434428,
0.006707727,
0.0051418138,
0.0404827073,
-0.0195292588,
-0.0073088412,
0.0575562343,
-0.0582270995,
0.0171360224,
-0.0098319268,
0.0284956731,
0.0220786612,
0.0254057348,
-0.0132360021,
-0.0109789371,
0.0130456034,
0.0201264694,
-0.0526201688,
-0.0012159838,
0.044637993,
0.0208629072,
0.056312304,
-0.0409583002,
0.0066587254,
-0.0225427039,
0.0672817528,
0.0155726764,
-0.0367253758,
0.0175788943,
0.0052160667,
-0.016093554,
-0.0121379346,
0.1063242927,
0.0818926618,
0.0338590518,
-0.001392098,
-0.0024240441,
-0.036920324,
-0.0317748375,
-0.0065757646,
-0.0247485507,
-0.0117003052,
0.0021362661,
-0.0608443841,
-0.0650803074,
0.0159582198,
0.016489733,
0.020194551,
-0.0026875834,
0.0070697279,
-0.0018300147,
-0.0377306379,
-0.0040590079,
-0.0207719542,
0.0069875838,
-0.0445308238,
-0.0227286071,
0.0014483577,
-6.581281364e-33,
-0.0353314616,
-0.0774094239,
0.0446827412,
-0.0351333022,
-0.0515858084,
0.0321275368,
-0.0530879982,
0.002257728,
0.0741711929,
-0.0162969511,
0.0116108255,
-0.0382609591,
-0.0034055053,
0.0696200356,
-0.0230094306,
0.0161805376,
0.0245253891,
0.0006580321,
-0.0352182426,
0.0325358063,
0.0204550307,
-0.0020076216,
-0.0056622429,
-0.014912148,
0.011306854,
-0.035259448,
-0.0567808896,
0.0000241062,
-0.0281166043,
0.0494062677,
-0.0559339188,
0.0138348946,
0.0363000631,
-0.0075776926,
-0.02682258,
0.0340906605,
-0.0343951024,
-0.0242279489,
0.0179070774,
-0.0452667437,
-0.0503445268,
-0.058563076,
0.0395386592,
-0.0051128315,
-0.0321434438,
0.0257271137,
0.0039689359,
-0.0165346973,
-0.0342360847,
-0.0632627457,
-0.0634951442,
0.0280886423,
-0.0054413299,
-0.0114920214,
-0.0210685898,
0.0383860022,
-0.0369899943,
-0.0132817691,
0.0243926533,
0.0214751959,
0.0413259268,
0.0541797392,
0.0513853841,
0.0622779876,
-0.0132394182,
0.0483300462,
-0.0433545895,
-0.0171481781,
-0.048226703,
0.0034236871,
0.0041932883,
0.0489238575,
0.035192091,
0.0659004301,
0.0065620258,
-0.0061743483,
-0.0810209364,
-0.0029831531,
-0.0731840953,
-0.0041320077,
0.0318148285,
-0.004374132,
-0.006489058,
-0.0202174988,
-0.0612749271,
-0.0202788096,
-0.020809209,
0.0137152644,
0.0532816052,
0.0612446107,
-0.0475616567,
-0.0177075565,
0.008604805,
-0.0080222469,
-0.0053769792,
0.0105312988,
-0.0315796696,
0.0144206248,
-0.0272814147,
0.0020728854,
-0.0832880959,
-0.0393827967,
0.0498775393,
0.0114582051,
0.0246753283,
0.0148512265,
0.0097617898,
0.0056145536,
-0.0278873798,
0.0219789874,
-0.0349441692,
0.0605853014,
0.0151339909,
-0.0001075761,
0.0301281326,
-0.0353035852,
-0.0186884645,
0.0334801823,
0.0191183519,
-0.001824429,
-0.0058040172,
0.0076893186,
0.0242513567,
0.0426352099,
-0.0282125566,
0.0184925441,
0.0056586121,
0.0323844366,
0.0526329018,
-0.0307259075,
-0.0236051995,
-0.0094589591,
2.608e-7,
0.0141534312,
0.0579535514,
0.0285549592,
0.0332355797,
0.0085519524,
0.008916961,
0.0143499412,
0.0342677347,
-0.048504781,
-0.0253469907,
0.0185823292,
-0.0068113096,
0.0648922175,
0.0308459979,
-0.0349266268,
0.0368738361,
-0.065499723,
0.0125989094,
-0.0504971333,
-0.0287424717,
0.0813135952,
0.0287948456,
-0.0469809398,
0.001202615,
-0.0078607667,
-0.1046944261,
0.0860925168,
-0.0292212944,
-0.0065912763,
0.0066925404,
0.037121769,
0.0043487716,
-0.0163707938,
0.0089931199,
-0.0152416797,
-0.0092357798,
0.0342790298,
0.0632800013,
0.0442592688,
0.0050377743,
0.0311242435,
0.0119691333,
-0.0114398347,
-0.0367107764,
0.0311267506,
-0.0175353102,
-0.0086302962,
-0.0119652962,
0.0202198084,
-0.0145379333,
0.0014602171,
-0.0445914455,
-0.0110105304,
-0.0071790493,
0.0116292592,
0.0233093295,
-0.0348657146,
-0.0232579634,
-0.0334513113,
-0.018263828,
-0.0505452193,
-0.0072867298,
-0.0763352364,
0.0150676966,
0.0069639036,
-0.0504336804,
-0.001038159,
2.531800855e-34,
0.031685248,
-0.034235321,
-0.0089107463,
-0.0087320758,
0.0385190137,
0.0044401656,
-0.0424248241,
0.0198826063,
-0.0128419362,
-0.0990439504,
-0.0184983071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16340v1 | RCAgent: Cloud Root Cause Analysis by Autonomous Agents with Tool-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-10-25T03:53:31 | 2023-10-25T03:53:31 | Zefan Wang, Zichuan Liu, Yingying Zhang, Aoxiao Zhong, Lunting Fan, Lingfei Wu, Qingsong Wen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Large language model (LLM) applications in cloud root cause analysis (RCA)
have been actively explored recently. However, current methods are still
reliant on manual workflow settings and do not unleash LLMs' decision-making
and environment interaction capabilities. We present RCAgent, a tool-augmented
LLM autonomous agent framework for practical and privacy-aware industrial RCA
usage. Running on an internally deployed model rather than GPT families,
RCAgent is capable of free-form data collection and comprehensive analysis with
tools. Our framework combines a variety of enhancements, including a unique
Self-Consistency for action trajectories, and a suite of methods for context
management, stabilization, and importing domain knowledge. Our experiments show
RCAgent's evident and consistent superiority over ReAct across all aspects of
RCA -- predicting root causes, solutions, evidence, and responsibilities -- and
tasks covered or uncovered by current rules, as validated by both automated
metrics and human evaluations. Furthermore, RCAgent has already been integrated
into the diagnosis and issue discovery workflow of the Real-time Compute
Platform for Apache Flink of Alibaba Cloud. | [
-0.0102115301,
0.0338071883,
-0.0189302303,
0.016805524,
-0.0471551381,
-0.0390456058,
0.0181015283,
-0.0233646762,
0.0286115725,
-0.0102345478,
0.0857360661,
0.0111532984,
-0.0431450419,
0.0804317892,
0.0102665788,
0.012955959,
0.0368943922,
-0.0271454304,
-0.018586725,
-0.0022385314,
-0.0118662333,
0.0160382688,
0.0099551203,
0.0407041796,
-0.0106829451,
-0.0154394032,
-0.021645721,
0.0094411531,
0.0279132426,
0.0275960658,
-0.0106386635,
-0.02072425,
0.0310060438,
0.0612879619,
0.0000022848,
-0.0476523452,
-0.032872811,
0.0300233588,
-0.0410425626,
0.0047685923,
-0.0004232208,
0.0089425882,
-0.0404474698,
0.0312316008,
-0.0165134147,
0.0202109702,
0.0285166353,
0.0204391852,
0.0691670477,
0.0430897102,
-0.0233878642,
0.0176150557,
-0.0049871141,
0.0094511248,
-0.0411029197,
-0.041832231,
0.0213322379,
-0.0117931636,
0.0342691466,
-0.0288582649,
0.0066291704,
-0.0333156101,
0.0150036318,
-0.0366604961,
-0.0292188786,
0.0649701133,
0.0101691941,
-0.011593313,
-0.0133102657,
0.0205309149,
0.0446462482,
-0.0148650352,
0.023900358,
-0.003095929,
-0.0245725997,
0.0270387679,
0.0108180037,
0.0593186542,
-0.0230880398,
0.0099373367,
0.0619737655,
-0.0113025904,
0.0103323441,
0.0012753358,
-0.0358938538,
0.1200689524,
-0.0121292612,
0.0034590582,
-0.0533981696,
-0.0383794941,
0.0349315368,
-0.0505716093,
0.0025027778,
0.0356124751,
-0.0841035768,
-0.0056350753,
0.0484699346,
-0.007351039,
0.0285205673,
-0.030819023,
0.0095841102,
0.0196837634,
-0.0121325394,
0.0089237951,
0.0439613909,
0.0659038872,
-0.0462331064,
0.0124320826,
0.0331193469,
-0.0265923217,
-0.0260454696,
-0.008913436,
-0.0071667191,
-0.0285037104,
-0.0304512028,
-0.0130259236,
0.0063970587,
0.058072228,
-0.016001856,
0.0399815515,
-0.0276222881,
-0.0343179777,
-0.0067893942,
0.0360096768,
-0.0183291286,
-0.0040837871,
-0.036186602,
0.0174739808,
-0.0208483264,
-0.0274125673,
-0.0154651599,
0.011447778,
0.0017030929,
-0.0079476293,
0.0168948583,
0.0357101448,
0.0399676114,
0.0489397272,
0.0097948788,
-0.0617976189,
0.0085652908,
-0.064277254,
-0.1067213938,
-0.0285821464,
-0.0264225882,
0.0131601561,
0.0129455505,
-0.0371797271,
-0.0177959483,
-0.0440649837,
-0.0261006057,
0.0240446124,
-0.0760424361,
0.0278284177,
-0.0105789276,
0.0360597409,
-0.0204347838,
0.0031016818,
-0.0053447327,
0.0125427926,
0.0178605225,
-0.0355349593,
0.1006153524,
-0.0071538514,
-0.0066029113,
-0.0041168677,
0.015319705,
0.0103670806,
-0.012833884,
0.0129728485,
-0.007258242,
-0.0229602084,
0.0681565851,
-0.0054741115,
0.0363261849,
0.0307863299,
-0.0688484088,
0.0068169804,
0.0076557496,
0.0181465186,
-0.0476832092,
-0.0285519566,
-0.0257347506,
0.0061409306,
-0.0366881713,
-0.0308004636,
-0.0141958315,
0.0600383207,
-0.0039827507,
-0.0285765827,
-0.0341256633,
-0.0023424462,
-0.0796205178,
-0.0101880515,
0.0336575694,
-0.0057401704,
0.016745517,
-0.0325186886,
-0.021544056,
-0.0087144226,
-0.0450853966,
-0.0643652305,
0.0551093891,
0.0582475588,
0.0529624447,
-0.0487150103,
-0.096343331,
-0.0358692966,
-0.0078331577,
-0.0046555512,
-0.0422311053,
0.0085796835,
-0.0273069553,
-0.005706287,
-0.0260545015,
0.0260899123,
0.0372575037,
0.0176152624,
-0.0551018193,
-0.0147154918,
-0.0325132348,
-0.020520281,
-0.0529705621,
-0.0003574159,
-0.000508053,
-0.0141574256,
0.0038836785,
0.0225616675,
0.0606158823,
-0.0073364256,
-0.0294929035,
0.0077468501,
0.019332163,
0.0163175706,
-0.0820952132,
0.0781856179,
0.046844542,
0.0417356156,
-0.0138722267,
0.0066078282,
0.0289551131,
0.0214626007,
-0.0462732874,
-0.0777019858,
0.0410441309,
-0.0014487224,
-0.0264584068,
-0.0080738831,
-0.0174888875,
-0.0098076602,
0.0224156994,
0.0120212846,
0.0110687427,
0.0719080418,
-0.0364923291,
-0.0122248204,
0.0584434308,
0.0343100838,
0.0109397853,
0.0153113445,
0.0082966266,
-0.0250891075,
0.0133269401,
0.0517232455,
-0.032323733,
-0.0051577301,
0.0406726673,
-0.0440190583,
0.0090756686,
-0.007533866,
-0.0164694116,
0.0084228702,
0.0294674747,
-0.0334631838,
0.0087501677,
0.0095378188,
0.0110631045,
0.039555233,
0.0294566005,
0.0495650731,
0.0130400155,
-0.056432534,
0.0088718804,
0.010416544,
-0.0506755561,
0.0270137377,
0.0562700778,
0.0141894445,
-0.0504184365,
0.0840322077,
-0.0406571627,
-0.0116572054,
-0.03090013,
-0.050609652,
-0.0249752067,
-0.0697977468,
-0.0138645377,
0.0883506238,
-0.0624816306,
0.0326626748,
0.0214116871,
0.0093146861,
-0.0482776277,
-0.0056212894,
-0.0288098808,
-0.0214260835,
-0.0119151454,
0.0011823849,
-0.0080629801,
0.0551589951,
0.0055428958,
-0.0584420487,
-0.0062612155,
0.0087672295,
-0.0338610858,
0.0184652545,
-0.0236317124,
-0.0918333903,
-0.0105187381,
0.0865639448,
-0.0002965968,
-0.0801563486,
0.0443879142,
-0.0009907485,
-0.018862959,
-0.04431694,
-0.089868851,
-0.0680458695,
0.0419675857,
0.0001107768,
0.0248634424,
-0.0018266641,
-0.0082919123,
0.0214826073,
-0.0249980204,
0.0360967144,
-0.0004120283,
-0.0394510776,
-0.0380425528,
0.0357330553,
0.0437234603,
-0.0545471571,
-0.0002774343,
-0.022886524,
-0.0142486747,
0.0049836426,
-0.0309584513,
-0.0258184969,
0.0263073258,
0.033686813,
0.0621746704,
0.0567180589,
0.0520688631,
-0.0141557064,
-0.0075352127,
-0.0480053909,
-0.0446472913,
-0.0155961169,
0.0409449264,
0.0289708469,
0.0698042437,
0.0012439721,
0.1089741811,
-0.071091935,
-0.0120403692,
0.0101772873,
-0.0347299762,
-0.0001657425,
-0.0052010952,
0.0166088473,
0.0115238167,
-0.0587280318,
-0.0284066293,
0.048562739,
0.0097142877,
-0.0329241417,
-0.0034596703,
-0.0036035366,
-0.0262981448,
0.025652729,
0.0624619573,
-0.0486862808,
0.0081806937,
0.0095746182,
0.0172461942,
-0.0362207629,
-0.0293571837,
0.00645395,
-0.0636454076,
0.0720877349,
-0.0110622039,
-0.0146671869,
-0.0227017086,
-0.0916941389,
0.0102234473,
-0.0302755535,
-0.0114151146,
-0.0288104694,
0.0345460549,
-0.0201910045,
0.0119504286,
-0.0548431687,
-0.0522792451,
0.0015519197,
-0.0458910652,
0.043175634,
0.0452675223,
-0.0270424057,
-0.0283489935,
0.050301645,
0.0067611407,
0.0494059697,
0.014831027,
-0.0335530974,
0.0037159433,
0.0569750853,
-0.0094818696,
-0.0052965507,
0.0482551791,
-0.0849044845,
-0.0045714467,
0.0060503935,
0.1470041424,
-0.0517166443,
-0.0080708098,
-0.0099724112,
-0.0362584144,
0.0522901155,
0.0334490463,
-0.0163904335,
-0.0211896989,
-0.0380542241,
0.0124309929,
-0.0025080759,
0.0077884234,
-0.0016429728,
0.0073063048,
-0.0047640898,
-0.051964771,
-0.0128512783,
-0.0313630588,
0.0393778309,
0.0309944768,
0.0232222453,
-0.0075140395,
0.0118280342,
0.033860378,
-0.0108466437,
0.0004962549,
-0.0221519414,
0.0609088317,
-0.0079136435,
0.0190023202,
0.060963694,
0.0316082872,
-0.0319735929,
0.0209923945,
0.0198877454,
-0.0386768654,
0.0569746941,
0.0189617425,
0.0280052274,
0.0136864353,
-0.0127968201,
-0.0114447614,
0.0453386605,
-0.0276997145,
-0.0537864193,
0.0083767846,
0.0193718057,
-0.041963581,
-0.0072078514,
-0.0125652533,
-0.051899787,
0.0302130654,
-0.0061450256,
0.0075184111,
-0.0522072986,
-0.0261767805,
0.0313609578,
0.0277597755,
-0.0134082185,
-0.0033150439,
-0.0124764945,
-0.0312038269,
0.0173267983,
0.0003848201,
-0.0022463519,
-0.003133636,
0.0772460774,
-0.0449446701,
-0.0396365263,
0.03469586,
0.0357771218,
-0.0176985208,
-0.055031348,
0.0011265657,
0.0245126672,
0.0170442611,
0.016146617,
0.073084496,
0.0149702625,
0.0429182649,
-0.0098462608,
0.0361553803,
0.060441725,
0.0120839328,
0.0368551053,
0.0134823881,
0.0169586521,
-0.0241297465,
-0.0160420425,
-0.0497793332,
-0.0469449125,
0.0424756259,
-0.0251576193,
0.069301106,
0.0158506203,
-0.001613647,
-0.062985599,
0.0046125022,
0.0093176719,
0.0210439228,
0.0055899927,
0.0146198636,
0.0104102036,
-0.0145498402,
-0.0266775861,
0.0147952465,
0.0513557196,
0.0347231999,
0.049631197,
-0.0366180092,
-0.0540751591,
-0.0167948697,
-0.0135597736,
-0.006943142,
-0.0024804526,
-0.003126835,
-0.0181019325,
-0.076712437,
-0.0251431204,
-0.0257269666,
-0.0073311972,
-0.0376254581,
-0.0470654666,
-0.0075238068,
0.070055373,
0.0362510979,
0.0380853042,
-0.030164957,
0.0018684838,
-0.0898503065,
-0.0143546388,
0.0181574393,
-6.318189565e-33,
0.0025929047,
-0.0776580498,
0.0171063375,
0.0285397731,
0.02245735,
0.0226108246,
-0.0460237712,
0.0019472796,
0.0507544726,
0.063168332,
0.0013509581,
0.0199410319,
0.0289118085,
-0.0190141089,
0.0410504639,
0.0209819376,
0.0147666391,
0.0341393277,
-0.0064126332,
0.0794352219,
0.071253255,
-0.0062557478,
-0.0272219963,
-0.0993322283,
0.0119378185,
-0.031644132,
-0.0088878768,
0.0482356064,
-0.0597210117,
0.0425721966,
0.0108971791,
0.0162282679,
-0.0160023458,
-0.0403035656,
-0.0040751798,
-0.0246408693,
0.0109155495,
0.0111634275,
-0.0166900288,
-0.0575560555,
-0.0075282203,
-0.0506439917,
-0.0411865562,
0.0132633541,
-0.0250530578,
0.0560939386,
0.0408046618,
-0.0092090666,
0.0212733541,
-0.0506108776,
-0.0001671062,
-0.0171683468,
-0.0561845414,
0.0125715407,
0.0026046149,
-0.0100848814,
0.0093938056,
0.0236430224,
-0.0365055092,
0.0358550586,
0.0177709907,
-0.0393323787,
0.0390476994,
0.0065543177,
-0.0407295525,
-0.0139740892,
0.0052651092,
-0.0116014928,
-0.0387802087,
0.0237111542,
-0.0488744713,
0.0814579278,
0.046666272,
0.0396775007,
-0.0353873447,
-0.0226210915,
-0.035146784,
0.0720676556,
0.0482240692,
0.0220741089,
0.0643497035,
-0.0212998688,
-0.0553499423,
-0.02220417,
-0.0160084907,
0.0204756986,
-0.0544493869,
0.0236080661,
0.0239871964,
0.0135130472,
-0.0201455466,
-0.000087396,
0.0602392852,
-0.0242356751,
0.0028805204,
0.0177211761,
0.0170824919,
-0.0219271686,
0.0108586783,
0.0301777162,
-0.013782111,
0.0154641541,
-0.0695806071,
0.013198697,
0.0611092485,
-0.0054768664,
-0.0061615305,
0.0386691391,
-0.0249445438,
0.0309694633,
-0.0689080507,
0.0290074106,
-0.0432890505,
-0.021922132,
-0.0100772688,
0.0204778854,
0.0302925017,
0.0715172365,
0.049594678,
0.0126279891,
-0.0195859876,
-0.0105884429,
-0.037922807,
-0.0308500417,
-0.0416473188,
-0.0019121983,
-0.0042874478,
0.0362986811,
0.0519287065,
-0.018542394,
0.008888321,
0.0016922583,
3.11e-7,
-0.0078647966,
0.0370299257,
0.0440955758,
0.0000025832,
0.0425743684,
0.0685987473,
-0.0136254365,
-0.0168451089,
-0.0261213016,
0.026605906,
0.0145852854,
-0.0280638877,
0.0401865393,
0.0295850057,
-0.0047960333,
-0.0197419878,
-0.0133663239,
0.022656519,
-0.1171352938,
0.0084160678,
0.0506727211,
0.0620020144,
0.0245968737,
-0.0383573845,
0.0188833792,
-0.0373896584,
-0.0078652855,
-0.0164941885,
0.0296271313,
0.0152816614,
-0.030161798,
0.0601632744,
0.0115947714,
0.0128364787,
-0.0064881286,
0.0002851086,
-0.08310844,
0.0259722471,
0.0335586555,
-0.0069089783,
-0.0350433923,
-0.0547457263,
0.0276255067,
-0.0496309288,
0.0257093962,
-0.0068214862,
-0.0431087352,
0.0437004976,
0.0093856994,
-0.0658444315,
-0.0003785909,
-0.0210815948,
-0.0048968727,
0.0142998723,
-0.0544392206,
-0.0303992275,
0.0313304812,
-0.0666161925,
-0.0075272848,
-0.0187808871,
-0.041710373,
-0.0218750127,
0.0042000441,
-0.0084036449,
0.0517696328,
0.0205134731,
0.035384655,
3.373441264e-34,
0.0086569963,
0.0223737489,
-0.0185723547,
0.0485327244,
0.0351388901,
0.0247563105,
-0.0255054459,
0.0280254893,
0.0416099727,
-0.0548671633,
-0.018786408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16338v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16338v2 | Generative Pre-training for Speech with Flow Matching | 2023-10-25T03:40:50 | 2024-03-25T18:18:40 | Alexander H. Liu, Matt Le, Apoorv Vyas, Bowen Shi, Andros Tjandra, Wei-Ning Hsu | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Generative models have gained more and more attention in recent years for
their remarkable success in tasks that required estimating and sampling data
distribution to generate high-fidelity synthetic data. In speech,
text-to-speech synthesis and neural vocoder are good examples where generative
models have shined. While generative models have been applied to different
applications in speech, there exists no general-purpose generative model that
models speech directly. In this work, we take a step toward this direction by
showing a single pre-trained generative model can be adapted to different
downstream tasks with strong performance. Specifically, we pre-trained a
generative model, named SpeechFlow, on 60k hours of untranscribed speech with
Flow Matching and masked conditions. Experiment results show the pre-trained
generative model can be fine-tuned with task-specific data to match or surpass
existing expert models on speech enhancement, separation, and synthesis. Our
work suggested a foundational model for generation tasks in speech can be built
with generative pre-training. | [
-0.023317229,
0.1053959802,
0.0051736278,
-0.0115542077,
-0.0013528338,
-0.0207713917,
0.0482224487,
0.0122731123,
-0.0854106024,
0.0117923655,
-0.0489752702,
-0.0472748913,
-0.0315849707,
0.0783179626,
0.0288983919,
-0.0683307201,
-0.016006168,
-0.0292298626,
-0.0343787819,
-0.0138310362,
0.0066650365,
0.0290699508,
-0.0585232228,
0.0082982127,
-0.0173831396,
-0.005238893,
-0.0040976442,
0.0134026986,
0.0128672859,
0.013361223,
-0.0017241294,
0.0358564556,
0.0443571433,
0.0021184892,
0.0000019876,
-0.0351635404,
0.0142496973,
0.000624528,
-0.0395344496,
-0.0059992364,
0.0071984017,
0.0328170918,
-0.0337147936,
0.0329234041,
-0.0254674554,
-0.0581343435,
0.0378525853,
0.0147892646,
0.059226267,
0.064328216,
-0.0296059754,
-0.0497665815,
0.0031040409,
-0.0287877582,
0.0117722182,
-0.0050710901,
-0.0091701867,
-0.0391294584,
-0.011192549,
-0.0611862354,
-0.0238456093,
0.0340998508,
0.0471419282,
-0.00183792,
0.0621546097,
0.0435812064,
-0.0116563495,
-0.0301880948,
0.0094629312,
0.0869110599,
-0.0427548625,
-0.0151626598,
0.0048139957,
-0.0354285315,
-0.0447473899,
-0.0289028473,
0.0255126189,
0.0073495479,
0.0256253928,
0.0135495914,
-0.0425139442,
0.0190984514,
0.0040441905,
-0.0404074974,
-0.0215755887,
-0.0243282598,
0.0269971937,
0.0076420624,
-0.0091357743,
0.0065905168,
0.0116152307,
-0.0629689842,
0.0494352765,
0.0073621972,
-0.0023110472,
-0.0415355824,
-0.0687562004,
-0.0477392413,
-0.0571622662,
0.017563032,
0.0341440625,
0.0283398554,
-0.0253293347,
-0.0187637024,
-0.009357457,
0.014631914,
-0.0286449585,
0.024604978,
-0.0425171964,
0.0031787325,
0.0114813466,
0.0145447366,
-0.0427636169,
0.0022027099,
-0.0722532943,
-0.0243874937,
-0.0268927552,
-0.0052438974,
-0.032392066,
-0.0130544649,
0.0404872,
0.0376638025,
-0.0409315787,
-0.0519254692,
0.0202205461,
-0.0425135866,
-0.0072146454,
0.0536916107,
0.0080854492,
-0.0548254438,
-0.0234681331,
0.0297051519,
0.0453763418,
0.0002660572,
0.035643436,
0.0565276593,
-0.0081021339,
0.0210850164,
-0.032386262,
-0.0047400994,
0.0326211229,
-0.0684828311,
0.0108120814,
-0.0599186905,
0.042262882,
-0.0273706745,
-0.0034511511,
-0.0220876858,
-0.0216856264,
-0.0544913039,
0.0249231607,
0.023745114,
0.0088769188,
0.0448989868,
0.0265986845,
-0.0197236761,
0.056022007,
-0.0096375775,
0.0596314818,
-0.0250931252,
-0.0323115848,
-0.0438409559,
0.0419359431,
0.0660496205,
0.0153626502,
-0.0156140868,
0.013071782,
-0.0116787683,
-0.0387101993,
0.017348025,
0.1143371239,
0.0064098248,
-0.0430094898,
0.0007572083,
0.06964311,
0.0163690262,
0.0659750029,
0.0402322114,
0.0971686393,
0.0142969247,
-0.0079703042,
0.0016008561,
0.0098712416,
0.0230839364,
0.011571805,
0.0259912293,
0.0383933857,
0.0603749938,
-0.0639813617,
-0.0360609926,
0.072610043,
-0.0271337796,
-0.0555567406,
0.005353888,
0.0280299503,
0.0277037378,
-0.0458301455,
-0.0120089147,
-0.0050358665,
-0.0950205177,
0.0498189591,
0.0018558509,
-0.0004690591,
0.0708196759,
0.0120986281,
0.0098540541,
-0.0156159094,
-0.0269642603,
-0.0335567109,
0.0454762951,
-0.0023110416,
0.019018719,
0.0742781311,
-0.0311869942,
-0.0393214077,
-0.0046220878,
0.0017107287,
0.0481699482,
-0.0201172829,
0.0113206767,
0.0286294706,
0.0131540615,
0.0224543661,
0.0147851286,
-0.0865221098,
-0.0305261817,
0.0475000776,
0.0151999528,
0.0769442245,
0.0031759443,
-0.0502006188,
0.0266920831,
0.0090498002,
-0.0363537259,
0.0059108711,
0.0481851511,
-0.0866385028,
-0.0212857705,
-0.0144727919,
-0.0257809591,
-0.0013788944,
0.040661376,
0.0047606826,
-0.0679800361,
0.0422040112,
0.0495558977,
0.034669783,
-0.0307121016,
0.0319262445,
0.0467277579,
0.0171116404,
0.0328597575,
0.0093927262,
0.0399438366,
0.0093988618,
0.0116393268,
0.0498456769,
-0.0040303245,
-0.0362893231,
0.007244878,
0.0062312023,
0.001509976,
0.0210437588,
0.0050382088,
-0.0033609236,
-0.0248018615,
0.0407068878,
-0.0263855904,
0.0434294716,
0.0005367616,
-0.000729201,
0.0425285473,
0.0166675542,
-0.0303719174,
0.0221465956,
-0.0558657758,
-0.0150915645,
0.0417998694,
-0.0620211214,
-0.0536165945,
-0.0199812148,
0.0029552665,
-0.0280541815,
0.0206743758,
0.0298047345,
-0.0065738526,
-0.0075466707,
-0.0347192697,
0.0139965722,
0.0834006816,
0.0098781306,
0.0681704208,
0.0195257217,
-0.0345494263,
-0.0246911291,
0.0010515113,
0.0926247835,
0.0150539484,
0.0158326328,
-0.0787525922,
0.0191274714,
-0.0240884367,
-0.0238377117,
0.0112288557,
-0.0404449888,
0.0206864197,
-0.0219999887,
0.0114691863,
0.0215087719,
0.0419843607,
0.0621454939,
0.0166397113,
-0.0659751445,
-0.017268097,
0.0185809806,
-0.0176282302,
0.0272565652,
-0.0165313222,
-0.0180361848,
0.0167138539,
-0.0495777614,
-0.0181890633,
0.0281533934,
-0.0499035493,
-0.0400644019,
-0.0072645736,
-0.0251551438,
0.0024941657,
-0.0088490769,
0.0121506015,
0.0165655576,
0.0045669717,
-0.0101911426,
-0.0434512831,
0.0379807875,
0.036503002,
-0.0414270945,
-0.0142198624,
-0.0332722105,
0.0002362936,
-0.0045069703,
-0.0185709633,
-0.0543938354,
-0.0147412317,
0.0284362324,
0.0032583552,
0.0388503559,
-0.0412803181,
0.0120801553,
0.0097123208,
-0.0080815675,
0.0813039318,
0.0267078131,
0.0031387452,
-0.0312171262,
0.0640525892,
0.03111385,
-0.025970079,
-0.0134293269,
-0.0089697568,
0.0206705909,
-0.0077297436,
0.0635249466,
0.0321835354,
-0.0646293163,
0.0085033197,
0.0166111123,
0.0152363181,
-0.0012340316,
0.0224333983,
0.035325028,
0.0004090485,
-0.0158868656,
0.0919443369,
-0.0099695576,
-0.005106499,
-0.0010242219,
0.0634430721,
0.0239013936,
-0.010735184,
-0.0096288044,
-0.0497578084,
0.0045038708,
0.0089257946,
0.0184868798,
0.0168175232,
0.021826053,
-0.0195427872,
-0.0937715843,
0.0578912385,
0.0526762493,
-0.0087554241,
-0.0073435386,
-0.0132428976,
-0.0125161959,
-0.0400460958,
0.0152700841,
-0.0138554545,
0.0082714921,
0.0213097483,
0.0631596372,
-0.0285976864,
-0.0747583434,
0.0129456129,
-0.0582097471,
0.0525046401,
0.0643902719,
0.0167350918,
0.006089794,
-0.0124302739,
0.0262149721,
0.0085498225,
-0.0270393398,
0.01931886,
0.0507711358,
0.0209444389,
-0.0034555704,
0.0003551397,
0.0570119843,
-0.0446248278,
0.0055453149,
0.0057831774,
0.002025489,
-0.0088714967,
-0.021456765,
-0.0035640365,
0.0319732837,
0.0081191165,
0.0452770442,
0.0144939637,
-0.0207306072,
-0.0340118073,
-0.0034380213,
0.0538100787,
-0.0949343219,
-0.0641690642,
-0.0054500094,
0.0170325655,
-0.0677736923,
-0.0499596782,
0.0070422771,
-0.0033223422,
0.0601027198,
0.0064653861,
-0.0045514861,
-0.0012607046,
-0.0347691961,
-0.0268267244,
0.0195330754,
-0.0121623632,
0.0296063125,
-0.0480349436,
-0.0769854635,
0.0119626652,
-0.032654345,
-0.0288100075,
0.063097693,
-0.0552517287,
-0.0591522641,
-0.0040349262,
0.0010348157,
0.0156958289,
0.0628443211,
-0.0343924612,
0.028137967,
0.0524331369,
0.0231836252,
-0.0558973402,
0.0168939494,
0.0530386083,
-0.0294579938,
0.0115287807,
-0.0090341941,
-0.0201733597,
0.0833285451,
0.0016970969,
0.0143019529,
-0.0036076305,
-0.0557912253,
0.0224691238,
-0.0098870518,
0.0436016098,
-0.0118552018,
0.0660658777,
-0.0720579401,
-0.0157096013,
-0.0060093678,
0.0317334197,
-0.0666518733,
-0.0484584533,
0.0585244521,
0.0252645127,
-0.0108268643,
0.0391786359,
-0.0260994602,
0.0170089174,
-0.034951739,
-0.0284644254,
0.0149585521,
0.005716865,
0.0060618892,
-0.0041082543,
0.0485383794,
0.0099401101,
0.0097870976,
-0.0070048431,
-0.0175212026,
0.0130278999,
0.0019080068,
0.0331862159,
0.0133962398,
-0.0070862542,
-0.0579230748,
-0.0408375748,
-0.0677318573,
0.0235836264,
0.052336067,
-0.042330265,
0.0534344092,
-0.0014934721,
0.0397469252,
-0.0163633823,
0.0383232869,
-0.0275451932,
-0.0253863186,
-0.0251978133,
-0.0152780954,
-0.0180963054,
-0.0439354181,
0.0658476576,
0.0146503206,
0.0485598259,
-0.0306527987,
0.0381112136,
-0.0204660855,
-0.0462049618,
-0.0300613958,
-0.0352106802,
-0.0119198086,
0.0063760988,
-0.0027558119,
-0.0548015125,
-0.0125831496,
-0.0227988735,
0.0163184907,
-0.0098668775,
0.0617125109,
-0.003316002,
-0.0664638206,
0.0082408786,
0.0001704348,
-0.0415016077,
-0.0128630577,
-0.0000337644,
-0.0139665557,
-5.966794998e-33,
-0.0457904488,
0.0521480031,
0.0351906195,
-0.0156649724,
-0.0352441259,
-0.0559745543,
-0.0556899272,
-0.0130265327,
-0.0030763401,
-0.0151221734,
-0.0162422843,
0.0317478962,
0.0080352724,
0.0373462625,
-0.0321918428,
0.0487775393,
0.1036706343,
-0.0424419194,
-0.0082827071,
0.0329330452,
0.031921085,
0.0051322593,
0.0274664629,
-0.0431659035,
-0.0770896673,
-0.0635208637,
-0.0291302707,
-0.0191342812,
0.0199777409,
-0.0203808974,
-0.0187477078,
-0.0020174661,
-0.0278015211,
-0.0241055582,
-0.0370082371,
0.0051506739,
-0.0535126328,
-0.0141987372,
-0.0181043893,
0.0187369511,
-0.0638045669,
-0.013993565,
0.0323333405,
0.0034764621,
-0.0318204761,
0.0001592297,
0.0585578866,
-0.0209771413,
0.0152051002,
-0.0888158754,
-0.0479713492,
0.0007172388,
-0.0391908847,
-0.0524622239,
0.0432647951,
0.038612213,
-0.0368153118,
-0.0548239835,
-0.0328928269,
0.0775834247,
0.0425098687,
0.0516202003,
0.0312073305,
0.0175364017,
0.0609326214,
0.0071745645,
0.0113891987,
-0.0601380654,
0.0086276634,
0.067746073,
0.0266791936,
0.0552656688,
-0.0107073756,
0.0205603112,
0.0306098312,
-0.0271008927,
-0.0343580581,
0.0503909029,
-0.0697338283,
-0.0141244084,
-0.0085354466,
0.0132464115,
0.0426266938,
0.0047342754,
-0.062884517,
-0.0538233854,
0.0110367285,
-0.0060294624,
0.0423284844,
0.0394439735,
0.0168995243,
-0.0371671207,
0.0413853563,
0.007039567,
0.0158354379,
0.0091221081,
-0.0691491663,
-0.0280033462,
0.0028628511,
0.0303276237,
-0.0462731794,
-0.0590267666,
0.1006565839,
0.0394149274,
-0.009462689,
0.0074670338,
-0.0194738749,
0.0455655493,
-0.0219221115,
0.0030632857,
-0.0586080775,
0.0661847144,
0.0378501266,
0.0037917255,
0.0113599123,
-0.0031738642,
-0.007943077,
0.0446688682,
-0.037819311,
-0.0064268853,
-0.0014043873,
0.0289673675,
0.0086105233,
0.045933295,
-0.045278132,
0.0115053356,
-0.0222585872,
0.0024965398,
0.0884004086,
-0.0174842663,
-0.0309754405,
-0.0240689553,
2.639e-7,
-0.021057548,
-0.0537795536,
0.0169943552,
0.0197454784,
0.0191836935,
-0.0038284175,
-0.0222359151,
0.0018769143,
-0.0194025375,
-0.0118803056,
0.0446885675,
0.0382844694,
0.0560980476,
-0.0040780129,
-0.0319609456,
-0.0337098464,
-0.0430037454,
0.0130020846,
-0.0237710793,
-0.0551440045,
-0.0207001455,
0.0439927429,
-0.020904094,
-0.0217262469,
0.0588678792,
0.0091356533,
0.0330126099,
-0.0145576587,
0.0072432975,
0.0120974611,
-0.025400579,
-0.0080727208,
-0.007974322,
0.0067878175,
-0.0595395006,
0.0237894803,
0.0265619513,
0.0774475932,
0.0196054373,
-0.0359986089,
-0.0015111562,
0.0440428108,
0.0078949118,
0.0141471522,
0.0228668619,
-0.0027500987,
0.0229927152,
-0.0260668024,
-0.1029113904,
0.0303199962,
-0.0007465957,
0.0036179265,
0.0225732885,
0.0018581646,
0.0335162766,
0.0269044992,
-0.003806578,
-0.0243181586,
-0.0193387344,
-0.0074884444,
-0.0699715838,
0.0052771447,
-0.0249926057,
-0.0025885175,
0.0447477885,
0.0252318531,
-0.0339895487,
1.781580042e-34,
0.0009636584,
0.009252267,
0.0405754447,
-0.0369144753,
-0.0128130643,
-0.0149550661,
0.0074632498,
0.0133889439,
-0.0051720161,
-0.0030705323,
-0.0494124889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16329v1 | CoheSentia: A Novel Benchmark of Incremental versus Holistic Assessment of Coherence in Generated Texts | 2023-10-25T03:21:20 | 2023-10-25T03:21:20 | Aviya Maimon, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Coherence is a linguistic term that refers to the relations between small
textual units (sentences, propositions), which make the text logically
consistent and meaningful to the reader. With the advances of generative
foundational models in NLP, there is a pressing need to automatically assess
the human-perceived coherence of automatically generated texts. Up until now,
little work has been done on explicitly assessing the coherence of generated
texts and analyzing the factors contributing to (in)coherence. Previous work on
the topic used other tasks, e.g., sentence reordering, as proxies of coherence,
rather than approaching coherence detection heads on. In this paper, we
introduce {\sc CoheSentia}, a novel benchmark of human-perceived coherence of
automatically generated texts. Our annotation protocol reflects two
perspectives; one is global, assigning a single coherence score, and the other
is incremental, scoring sentence by sentence. The incremental method produces
an (in)coherence score for each text fragment and also pinpoints reasons for
incoherence at that point. Our benchmark contains 500 automatically-generated
and human-annotated paragraphs, each annotated in both methods, by multiple
raters. Our analysis shows that the inter-annotator agreement in the
incremental mode is higher than in the holistic alternative, and our
experiments show that standard LMs fine-tuned for coherence detection show
varied performance on the different factors contributing to (in)coherence. All
in all, these models yield unsatisfactory performance, emphasizing the need for
developing more reliable methods for coherence assessment. | [
-0.0028332272,
0.0329734236,
0.0054213535,
-0.0007513515,
-0.0633019209,
-0.001050846,
-0.0018627685,
-0.0225535557,
-0.0065790983,
-0.0466447175,
0.0221575294,
0.0013951153,
0.026401436,
0.0327824019,
0.0040206383,
-0.0539734215,
0.0566695929,
-0.0050239554,
0.0051535284,
0.0238752682,
0.0092727486,
-0.0073650801,
-0.0032110808,
0.0216160025,
-0.0314205438,
-0.0692421645,
-0.0172183178,
0.0321336091,
0.0179909188,
-0.0420640819,
-0.0069678961,
0.0576553419,
-0.0199424867,
0.004219051,
0.0000020942,
-0.0490536317,
-0.0301819909,
-0.0063936375,
-0.0186385363,
0.0094928481,
-0.0168177448,
-0.0206874739,
-0.0202559065,
-0.0140295587,
-0.0317077786,
0.059628129,
-0.0071092262,
0.0301868301,
0.0872098505,
0.0773231834,
-0.0263424329,
-0.0095860502,
0.0251630284,
0.0127795162,
-0.0190822128,
0.0126162795,
-0.0288320016,
0.0501263514,
-0.0096399104,
0.014425938,
0.0000763375,
0.0143147195,
0.0316913575,
-0.0479780547,
0.0398059301,
0.0066953111,
-0.0673601478,
-0.0412554853,
0.0132757341,
0.0212269165,
0.0101340897,
-0.0058044926,
0.0260382537,
-0.0080546308,
-0.0060114521,
0.0092998687,
-0.011529956,
0.0452678241,
-0.0365884975,
0.0349997394,
0.0464692414,
0.0046845623,
-0.0149231069,
0.0170190483,
0.0397034883,
0.0712737814,
-0.0004046001,
-0.0299479757,
-0.0189195238,
0.0608412102,
-0.0449007228,
-0.0613357238,
0.0186853167,
0.0320064165,
-0.0584132634,
-0.0063985265,
-0.0653569549,
-0.0205257479,
0.0551728457,
-0.0751248598,
0.0073048067,
0.0159887988,
-0.0351334997,
0.0394497737,
-0.0020352486,
0.0386935659,
0.0595220402,
0.0129504185,
-0.025109319,
0.0078573497,
-0.0322951339,
0.0112884585,
-0.0216988157,
0.0484456681,
-0.0149277644,
-0.0271220002,
-0.0607523508,
0.0199153218,
-0.0041974448,
0.053211432,
-0.0423113368,
-0.0255242307,
0.0014125222,
-0.0092898477,
0.0042500459,
0.0123162391,
-0.0474958308,
-0.0119072916,
0.0069378456,
-0.0366891101,
0.0017665583,
0.0523221046,
-0.0139346328,
0.0142261377,
-0.0358475782,
0.000297832,
-0.0052014743,
-0.0146278013,
-0.0361975804,
-0.0806969181,
-0.0297756083,
-0.0559939519,
-0.0314101316,
-0.0642489493,
-0.0322034247,
0.0115506537,
0.0134908874,
-0.0262549594,
-0.0074854586,
0.028479455,
-0.0065890355,
-0.0022440748,
-0.0560763255,
0.0217503943,
0.006759664,
0.013377253,
0.0271957833,
0.0461518876,
0.033717081,
0.0372443199,
0.047000844,
0.0152550684,
0.0104198437,
-0.0128705176,
-0.0364258029,
-0.0161674693,
0.0068126717,
-0.0100292275,
-0.0294961873,
0.0396729521,
0.0255466066,
0.0538572297,
-0.0214455537,
0.0057558529,
0.0527751409,
0.0276367534,
0.0392256379,
0.0001312549,
0.0346152037,
0.0292383749,
0.0493225977,
0.0960433111,
-0.0070548588,
0.0131670916,
-0.0095233265,
0.0567974374,
0.0724070519,
0.0253914185,
0.0041625532,
-0.0786246881,
-0.0380087011,
-0.0063307439,
-0.0454042479,
-0.0367480777,
0.0213006269,
0.0157639831,
-0.0120132593,
-0.041563753,
0.0283403378,
-0.0881918967,
0.0279953144,
0.0280738901,
0.0706608146,
0.0897333771,
0.0319416262,
-0.0201802049,
-0.0111665707,
-0.0039608409,
0.0254609026,
0.0875879452,
-0.0224641133,
-0.0129454872,
0.0281784926,
-0.0364874229,
0.0008921285,
-0.0291753691,
0.0291058272,
-0.0141677354,
-0.0500167608,
-0.0225832611,
0.0074962918,
0.0025579226,
-0.0202576816,
0.050620757,
-0.0053493693,
0.0626344606,
-0.0104302857,
-0.0048360173,
-0.0091629261,
0.0603394061,
-0.031305369,
0.0275511108,
0.0290847328,
-0.0215744022,
-0.0128796846,
0.0088763526,
-0.0314884596,
-0.0230588354,
0.0063940142,
-0.0675169602,
-0.0838315487,
-0.0330956839,
-0.0023184097,
-0.0371537022,
0.007156271,
-0.0408722311,
-0.0397472046,
-0.0542451851,
0.037343882,
0.0225923341,
-0.0036387499,
-0.0318480246,
0.0481133275,
0.0093722846,
0.0114710424,
0.016897548,
-0.0258001909,
0.0352736004,
-0.0529702865,
0.0172588285,
-0.0130706299,
-0.0035984402,
-0.0119213508,
0.0332720652,
0.0161387194,
-0.0538989231,
-0.0650418699,
-0.0820908397,
0.0250266697,
-0.034728203,
0.0055940892,
0.0414421894,
-0.0403952599,
0.0016065306,
-0.0174494442,
0.0010111424,
-0.022772219,
0.0328862071,
0.0152054094,
0.0759729668,
-0.0528992712,
0.0288731158,
-0.0631565005,
0.0168028213,
-0.0086419443,
0.0518972538,
0.0674195364,
-0.0207592081,
-0.0644478425,
-0.0001121734,
-0.0339025185,
-0.0576498099,
0.0584123135,
-0.0472157374,
0.0505899973,
0.0269149337,
0.0705743954,
0.0536822379,
0.0492787287,
0.0340543874,
0.046046786,
-0.0260429997,
0.0035783113,
0.008203811,
-0.0113905203,
0.0436307639,
0.0143299038,
-0.0376566313,
0.0340906121,
0.0502968878,
0.0101661393,
0.0052335099,
-0.0301150158,
0.0047869338,
-0.031960316,
-0.0052290992,
-0.0497726649,
-0.0344539806,
-0.0094995564,
0.0173514113,
-0.027176179,
-0.0503907688,
0.0460694432,
-0.0581238158,
0.0097043132,
-0.0336137637,
-0.0076455032,
-0.0524416454,
0.0059200437,
0.0082895244,
0.0090213493,
0.0106470855,
-0.0127329193,
-0.0314637609,
0.033519268,
0.0470920056,
-0.0043880586,
0.0302739982,
-0.0568219982,
-0.0129477875,
-0.0047898204,
-0.0382863432,
-0.0441002995,
-0.0462350287,
0.0000364153,
0.0041252733,
0.0149759166,
0.0086199678,
-0.0095559424,
-0.0158374943,
0.0359197184,
0.0189217087,
0.0068379175,
-0.04112757,
-0.0158959888,
0.0426803455,
0.0598451123,
0.0717179403,
0.0086511942,
-0.0344460234,
0.0154880229,
0.0570347682,
-0.0468352027,
0.0221982449,
-0.0345021673,
0.0050320509,
-0.0427496396,
-0.0344046094,
-0.0403466448,
-0.0029059954,
0.0373026617,
-0.0385906585,
0.0028576215,
0.1266480535,
0.0008539116,
0.0209170133,
-0.0252128541,
-0.0342070572,
0.0372435972,
-0.0041601807,
-0.0105255423,
-0.0512086079,
-0.0238527004,
0.009153313,
0.0024719161,
0.0101646632,
-0.0354801118,
0.0135982037,
-0.0290606096,
0.0362932794,
-0.007747856,
-0.0004403063,
0.0045929211,
-0.0435407013,
0.0125714364,
0.021766251,
0.0006772786,
0.0002461844,
-0.0084458962,
0.0353693031,
0.0255938098,
-0.0804733187,
0.0060522761,
-0.0856228694,
-0.0537564941,
0.0405413061,
0.0756381229,
0.0442784429,
0.0101660872,
-0.0260236543,
0.020968372,
-0.0279503316,
0.002105582,
0.023736652,
0.0714803636,
-0.0303735416,
0.0127695883,
-0.0362100899,
0.0159176104,
0.0054687234,
-0.0525177754,
0.0175525751,
0.0285491832,
-0.0362243578,
-0.0024355794,
-0.0166071542,
0.0442241542,
-0.0138502689,
0.0923357457,
0.0515042134,
-0.0194886588,
-0.0596418194,
-0.0270444732,
0.0455146991,
-0.0329960994,
0.0177445076,
0.0288464427,
0.0004717601,
0.0013701154,
-0.1189629734,
-0.0745091662,
-0.0040824665,
-0.0092450725,
0.0120432386,
0.0379042812,
0.0429491028,
-0.0480988994,
-0.0052044932,
0.0061931969,
-0.0017563644,
-0.0233496875,
-0.0871253759,
0.0025914852,
-0.0312898904,
-0.0273414887,
-0.00330379,
0.0256556664,
-0.0303455405,
-0.0550488569,
0.0502565764,
-0.0135784568,
0.0136280842,
-0.0116385603,
-0.0086016627,
-0.0248846747,
0.0008619418,
0.0233615395,
-0.0453056656,
0.0795726925,
0.0157593787,
0.0332288891,
-0.0080622863,
0.034781415,
-0.0023006739,
0.0097509716,
-0.0136006558,
0.0535556078,
0.0174024459,
-0.0505220331,
0.0031196894,
0.0311095435,
0.0584330373,
-0.0108184293,
0.0624732785,
-0.0244000237,
-0.0275739897,
-0.0520660169,
-0.0273257885,
-0.0152872344,
0.030584354,
-0.0148262512,
-0.0215698946,
-0.0200376641,
0.0872229114,
-0.040223062,
0.0582168177,
-0.0172440875,
-0.0159520376,
-0.0206302982,
-0.0115522528,
-0.0542778894,
-0.0225631483,
-0.01252608,
0.003458692,
-0.0528909415,
0.0270245373,
0.0044727176,
0.0274302624,
0.0261099264,
-0.0123252776,
0.0160946883,
0.0423529409,
-0.0470646769,
0.0231404454,
-0.0100515243,
0.0224238448,
0.049700927,
0.0142209372,
0.1214022115,
-0.0284884907,
0.0025028288,
-0.0356055461,
0.1016973704,
0.0661401749,
-0.0240612607,
-0.0596551001,
0.0223158579,
-0.0445595048,
0.0170761924,
0.0777614787,
-0.063835606,
-0.0352340788,
0.0152827911,
-0.0308887679,
-0.029508654,
-0.0226534866,
-0.0279586874,
0.0238704365,
-0.0215343628,
0.0028217314,
-0.0498111621,
0.0178735312,
0.0641067997,
0.0498541929,
0.0329576656,
0.019371178,
-0.0084873298,
0.0327240378,
-0.0049879034,
0.0085219545,
-0.0374858789,
0.0095183421,
-0.0258019362,
-0.0056940867,
0.0016332588,
-6.406840207e-33,
-0.0579815581,
-0.0550196171,
-0.0212886613,
0.0116294501,
-0.0259200223,
0.0239752848,
-0.072671406,
0.0350136943,
0.0237290841,
0.0616329014,
0.0181581974,
0.0155667448,
0.0260377117,
0.0184968486,
0.011338897,
-0.0166624188,
0.0481616855,
0.0373166129,
-0.0515305437,
-0.0064225863,
0.0633403361,
-0.0239195172,
0.0300730802,
-0.0414504595,
0.0296900962,
-0.0278025139,
-0.0244909041,
0.0007839521,
0.0004067372,
0.0404728837,
-0.017775923,
0.0285470523,
0.0399785414,
0.0045519061,
-0.0114397705,
0.0186005682,
-0.0433053747,
-0.0508997329,
-0.0047822972,
-0.0302062016,
-0.1048473865,
-0.0202284269,
0.0238209032,
0.0081455829,
0.0280140359,
-0.0096728951,
0.0613555387,
-0.0142619768,
-0.0177140031,
-0.0223793425,
-0.0866917744,
0.0496959537,
-0.0560655594,
-0.026090553,
0.0030378252,
0.0207016785,
0.0106738275,
-0.0221366808,
-0.0459844396,
0.0147638544,
-0.0278001279,
0.0564112887,
0.0048862407,
-0.0395301729,
-0.0401670672,
0.1000902653,
-0.0049126274,
0.0249422956,
-0.0493785776,
0.0487546325,
-0.0037707563,
0.0053964467,
0.0598195121,
0.0412344038,
0.0318115205,
0.0115449782,
-0.0693686008,
0.0805504024,
-0.0184002295,
0.0291158408,
0.0187028777,
-0.0015246803,
-0.0246686805,
0.013977034,
-0.0393420197,
-0.0380662009,
-0.0131254131,
-0.0291500334,
-0.0146905445,
-0.006459231,
-0.0212795846,
-0.0190701969,
0.0006896624,
0.0292864591,
0.0069918674,
-0.0178276971,
-0.0629049763,
0.0414300598,
0.0133943139,
-0.0047807214,
-0.016103005,
-0.0022662103,
0.00679419,
0.0584818609,
0.048780065,
-0.0141799478,
0.0716883466,
-0.021045208,
-0.02549682,
0.0190808177,
-0.0029941071,
0.0165879726,
-0.0463336296,
-0.0596462376,
0.0275625698,
-0.0090545053,
-0.0278958231,
0.0572273172,
-0.0219047833,
0.0166547056,
-0.0383896902,
-0.0168898571,
0.0333123133,
-0.0080285743,
0.0065589063,
0.0298515465,
0.0013152311,
0.0092076538,
0.0198832303,
-0.0204057358,
0.0076878439,
0.0138034709,
2.666e-7,
0.0319244526,
0.0578926876,
0.057821285,
-0.0205374453,
0.0004019017,
0.0076054884,
-0.0419267453,
0.0088132471,
-0.0229253117,
-0.0487843677,
-0.0261193775,
-0.0054864869,
0.081861563,
0.0514710844,
-0.0477937162,
0.0122676911,
-0.0833264068,
-0.0338429809,
-0.0526192896,
0.0120206857,
0.0887482986,
-0.0075641777,
-0.0160209276,
0.0141523797,
0.0126887821,
0.0137967486,
0.0269991029,
0.0064045698,
-0.0284050815,
0.0230639279,
0.0525174849,
-0.0174198076,
0.0078735799,
-0.0026501808,
-0.0279564448,
-0.0257147346,
0.0341542438,
0.0502277687,
0.034999162,
0.0081716264,
0.0069271652,
0.0001408514,
0.0273979101,
-0.0145533718,
0.0481976047,
-0.036848072,
-0.0408865698,
-0.0144476183,
-0.0312855206,
-0.0149014853,
0.027129963,
0.0061703627,
-0.0396391414,
0.0151397781,
0.012731133,
-0.0198013484,
-0.030531995,
-0.0235956069,
-0.0717423484,
0.0053106868,
-0.031715516,
0.006867276,
-0.0336874649,
0.0016035875,
0.0382440835,
-0.0799149647,
0.0020037142,
2.225048946e-34,
0.0544203706,
-0.0353514515,
0.0235997587,
0.0082730288,
0.036525581,
-0.002942295,
-0.0475137942,
0.0033387428,
-0.015709525,
-0.0402740464,
0.0265394077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16322v1 | Samsung R&D Institute Philippines at WMT 2023 | 2023-10-25T03:10:52 | 2023-10-25T03:10:52 | Jan Christian Blaise Cruz | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we describe the constrained MT systems submitted by Samsung
R&D Institute Philippines to the WMT 2023 General Translation Task for two
directions: en$\rightarrow$he and he$\rightarrow$en. Our systems comprise of
Transformer-based sequence-to-sequence models that are trained with a mix of
best practices: comprehensive data preprocessing pipelines, synthetic
backtranslated data, and the use of noisy channel reranking during online
decoding. Our models perform comparably to, and sometimes outperform, strong
baseline unconstrained systems such as mBART50 M2M and NLLB 200 MoE despite
having significantly fewer parameters on two public benchmarks: FLORES-200 and
NTREX-128. | [
0.0171997324,
0.0911178142,
0.0125259943,
-0.0138682043,
0.0361594856,
0.0107362708,
-0.0123380823,
-0.0052203555,
-0.1001066789,
0.0027598876,
-0.0429475494,
-0.0485710762,
0.0427648239,
0.0084195966,
0.0245472752,
-0.0378049016,
-0.0201368071,
-0.0274852682,
-0.0714949146,
0.0140965618,
-0.0492137671,
0.0213217102,
0.0076283244,
0.0405224897,
0.009438877,
0.0335570239,
0.0063499417,
0.0179939475,
0.0341092572,
-0.0500040799,
-0.0267440416,
0.0575293936,
0.0295540504,
0.0714672506,
0.0000019003,
-0.0011682089,
-0.0311686434,
-0.0211255327,
-0.037914902,
0.0078699617,
-0.0095486315,
-0.0810108706,
-0.0449929535,
0.0105421236,
-0.008271412,
-0.0432601087,
0.0294821654,
-0.0229638219,
0.079276748,
0.0712332278,
-0.0078388005,
-0.0215222109,
0.0052077007,
-0.0579601154,
-0.0163514558,
-0.0299326573,
0.000713526,
0.0114808818,
-0.0161730889,
0.0138940942,
-0.0073133651,
0.0408862568,
0.0277821459,
0.0200690497,
0.0000355933,
-0.0130552473,
-0.0576748326,
-0.0361019969,
-0.0075667948,
0.073502019,
0.000880066,
-0.045159217,
0.0086270021,
0.0241521038,
-0.0506905913,
-0.0665427595,
-0.0195321366,
0.0402666181,
-0.0016957255,
0.0080676284,
-0.0442581773,
0.0661260635,
0.0441746712,
-0.018715784,
-0.090106301,
0.0102984197,
0.0079781068,
-0.045970194,
-0.0126640201,
0.0230509024,
0.0073480927,
0.0143218432,
0.039832551,
-0.0046144528,
0.00270746,
0.0010476125,
-0.0191312805,
-0.0436658598,
-0.0420747325,
-0.0384506024,
0.0082228947,
0.0936746448,
0.0065080649,
0.0011325675,
-0.0006938538,
0.0359237604,
-0.0275144875,
-0.0171205271,
-0.0490983278,
-0.005011362,
-0.0188158341,
0.0207288694,
-0.0230018701,
-0.0143869342,
-0.0679100826,
-0.0034326275,
-0.0234886389,
-0.0087117879,
0.0713377818,
-0.0211324971,
0.0568667762,
-0.0132373953,
-0.0971138626,
-0.0268398672,
0.0328631029,
0.042304989,
0.0485501476,
-0.0320985466,
0.005970363,
-0.0589815751,
-0.023815589,
0.029907411,
-0.0176987275,
-0.0152555052,
-0.0006150979,
0.0706500262,
-0.0281374659,
-0.0495828688,
0.0259671751,
0.030090848,
-0.0295416676,
-0.0401434116,
0.0144094722,
-0.0407705978,
0.034835875,
-0.0126461266,
0.0029221214,
0.0095272353,
0.0102702212,
-0.0132589731,
0.0035922173,
0.0545433797,
0.0595243648,
-0.0085718697,
0.0267967246,
0.0386618301,
0.0162755903,
0.0521430001,
0.0343737639,
0.0363636874,
-0.0115240179,
0.0047911364,
-0.034238752,
0.0718671083,
0.0105538042,
0.0335288271,
-0.0141304452,
-0.0200042967,
-0.0006610441,
0.0288926605,
0.0176712647,
0.0449333936,
-0.0273684673,
0.0281443018,
0.0747294649,
0.0157237984,
0.0673640743,
0.0246341396,
0.0509790182,
-0.0120557379,
-0.0272663664,
-0.007722686,
0.0083900234,
0.0255423244,
0.007072275,
0.0164395384,
0.0386616476,
0.0647984967,
-0.0244171824,
-0.0029189689,
-0.0053244294,
-0.0132374093,
-0.034324076,
-0.0302206986,
0.0510306805,
0.0071106954,
-0.0532544106,
0.089713119,
-0.0236905199,
-0.0407335237,
0.0183692705,
-0.0247074366,
-0.0620025545,
0.0026646836,
0.046127826,
0.0318730064,
-0.0410858318,
-0.0298881456,
-0.010800764,
0.0723303035,
0.0162248984,
0.0304613821,
0.0440101959,
-0.0542143695,
-0.0319705755,
0.0892579108,
0.0133260777,
0.0244234242,
-0.0064545558,
0.0269198585,
0.0470344536,
-0.0217374917,
-0.0041857334,
0.0200549103,
-0.0239024274,
-0.0179793853,
0.0330865011,
0.0368973836,
0.0510651655,
0.0428614728,
-0.0097982166,
0.0134409647,
0.0457649529,
-0.0545406267,
-0.0226800349,
0.0382744297,
-0.0959943235,
-0.0334721915,
0.0351197906,
-0.0310261901,
0.009805317,
0.0472001433,
-0.0023367307,
-0.0698918998,
0.0030187601,
-0.0344930328,
-0.0168906059,
-0.0262080971,
0.0611864105,
0.0350995585,
0.0341933221,
-0.0102349306,
0.0020265281,
-0.0403681248,
0.0198458545,
0.0225576535,
-0.0672126114,
0.0041180034,
-0.0486051962,
0.0186896268,
0.0459253974,
0.0044887122,
0.0113337226,
-0.0106770247,
0.0172331817,
0.0036040873,
-0.0220487528,
0.0060084471,
-0.0029804697,
-0.0385525711,
0.0594877079,
0.0151227256,
0.0471125543,
-0.0099356975,
-0.004693462,
0.0157542564,
-0.0257633869,
0.0136311036,
-0.033789441,
-0.005393004,
0.0396375842,
0.0132853044,
0.0007818907,
-0.0177927837,
0.0193922147,
0.0340784341,
-0.0381718092,
-0.0729142204,
-0.0669069588,
-0.0201085657,
0.0022513946,
0.0006894803,
-0.0237213559,
-0.0504095852,
0.0191565156,
-0.0007058099,
0.0293270051,
0.0069395578,
-0.0065887063,
0.0169287603,
-0.0022537701,
-0.0045844186,
-0.0287606306,
-0.0086717987,
0.0058793719,
-0.0221745912,
-0.0311173592,
-0.0463060811,
0.0073012258,
0.0876606554,
-0.0165662132,
0.0235387553,
-0.0762723833,
-0.0204122588,
0.0068997508,
-0.0323925205,
0.0066117072,
0.0141422516,
-0.0211814977,
0.0264512189,
-0.0049505681,
-0.0282639153,
0.0513423793,
-0.0731335357,
-0.0519641712,
-0.0812561437,
-0.004885505,
-0.032077644,
0.0011633863,
-0.0383414142,
0.0041653905,
0.0041594137,
-0.0412138999,
-0.0383963436,
0.0334216133,
-0.0181340184,
-0.0249564555,
0.0142180957,
-0.0161871761,
0.0015147103,
-0.0515419766,
-0.0159076024,
-0.0065981597,
0.0468314886,
0.0011839821,
0.0113821644,
0.0240776725,
-0.0224605855,
-0.0556759425,
0.0713126585,
-0.0062197209,
0.0584031604,
0.0124141909,
0.0056607891,
-0.039493449,
0.0524977222,
0.0196011346,
0.0087928167,
0.0148798134,
-0.0237074532,
0.0229901932,
0.0081527205,
0.0121071218,
0.0017982571,
-0.0182373766,
-0.0011174867,
0.0572401434,
0.0141017009,
0.0050244997,
0.0146965496,
0.0403871872,
-0.0312487967,
-0.0052015688,
0.0976456404,
0.021640949,
-0.0559162721,
0.0092993341,
0.0453598984,
0.04466727,
-0.0185000002,
0.0069222078,
-0.0657916814,
-0.0061732573,
0.0247356761,
0.0457076654,
0.0192365628,
0.0181376711,
-0.0377728976,
-0.1024269536,
0.0217253845,
0.0571987517,
-0.0409256853,
-0.0675345436,
-0.0308031496,
-0.0721459836,
-0.0379079171,
0.0552805811,
0.0233082958,
0.0228200983,
-0.0196778495,
0.0312794186,
0.0113384202,
-0.0655749962,
-0.0161143858,
-0.0256551281,
0.0512589179,
0.0452597216,
-0.0009852687,
0.0182910282,
-0.0150653524,
0.0299825817,
-0.0246900525,
0.0058172918,
-0.0136516271,
-0.0351245515,
-0.0355351716,
-0.0154433493,
-0.009908529,
0.0278297812,
-0.0432291739,
0.0320116691,
-0.0470149219,
0.0661346167,
-0.0211939141,
-0.0061621573,
0.0251516346,
0.0057379734,
-0.002221429,
0.0427836813,
-0.0017034374,
-0.0317051113,
0.0116614616,
-0.0315444618,
0.0466797873,
-0.0250489339,
-0.0205277428,
0.0079988195,
-0.0061656251,
-0.0661235601,
-0.0799856335,
-0.0311510451,
-0.0239839349,
0.071327962,
-0.0027483683,
0.0055212094,
0.0236067511,
-0.0015469177,
-0.0299814753,
0.018045228,
-0.0190852787,
0.0076763476,
-0.0647482127,
0.0104942787,
0.0264443569,
-0.0155891264,
0.0243633315,
0.0268883388,
-0.1063156873,
-0.0458911806,
-0.0568856299,
0.0429661535,
0.0364228711,
0.0288169384,
0.0010803267,
0.0148879932,
-0.0057774037,
0.0072536925,
-0.0308358334,
0.0097347638,
0.0431331731,
-0.010455817,
-0.0308533609,
0.0192144234,
-0.02369418,
0.0164530594,
-0.0040233023,
0.0679745376,
0.0042493204,
-0.0675724447,
0.0379622951,
-0.030830564,
0.0624866001,
-0.0376790613,
-0.0461206026,
0.0179803297,
0.0516744293,
-0.0105585754,
0.0363829434,
-0.0269672293,
0.0288137663,
0.080719389,
0.0450754911,
0.0028452571,
0.0102012521,
0.0199359022,
-0.0235647969,
-0.0116078425,
0.0258738138,
-0.0228550583,
-0.0044282377,
0.0254772417,
-0.0120140659,
-0.0204342771,
0.0194154102,
0.0067241588,
0.0157122705,
-0.0350066274,
0.0237808097,
-0.0075240545,
0.057228405,
0.0093538715,
0.0604985394,
-0.0037283651,
0.0214988105,
-0.0478067063,
-0.0050777211,
0.0813019872,
0.0198076311,
0.0842319205,
0.0101146447,
0.0102591291,
-0.0079759061,
0.0157129616,
-0.0159772392,
0.0195294563,
-0.0088277049,
-0.0120237283,
-0.0097590014,
0.0420437604,
0.0451157428,
0.0149628753,
0.0198394358,
0.0162957385,
0.002432616,
-0.0159817338,
-0.0214108378,
-0.0178374331,
-0.0309780426,
-0.0429724641,
-0.0112114269,
0.0093121585,
-0.0461163446,
0.001641551,
-0.0113162724,
-0.0095108571,
-0.0147203207,
0.0070570596,
0.0211035665,
-0.0285252947,
-0.0101813972,
0.0025758694,
-0.0219678655,
-0.0075136786,
-0.0229289513,
0.0068027731,
-6.642993348e-33,
-0.0209164377,
0.0310001858,
-0.0181069374,
-0.0288146157,
-0.051453609,
-0.0394728519,
-0.0401144698,
-0.0360624492,
0.0094199302,
-0.0508135445,
0.0022270556,
0.0081108836,
0.0341097005,
0.029904237,
-0.0225100163,
0.0384160541,
0.0772168711,
0.002524754,
-0.0706857443,
-0.0141164325,
0.0044928608,
0.0390691161,
0.0671987161,
0.0088190241,
-0.0280374624,
-0.0243755579,
0.0161032174,
0.0050803521,
0.0090407673,
0.0283671245,
0.0014676582,
0.0153479883,
-0.0009180324,
-0.0881085396,
-0.0409116894,
-0.0075847269,
-0.097571224,
0.0484489053,
-0.0359469503,
0.0486448184,
0.0319098979,
-0.0232094061,
0.0190474484,
-0.0171732679,
-0.0409680456,
-0.0266600214,
-0.0144477729,
-0.0404633358,
-0.0434834324,
-0.0308406055,
-0.0027177022,
0.0311133321,
0.0014476278,
-0.0192318559,
0.0399756208,
0.0582536049,
-0.0252659284,
-0.021695843,
-0.0765806511,
0.0219792426,
0.0064434651,
0.0760380179,
0.0953462273,
-0.0073312046,
-0.0043207603,
-0.0163045619,
0.0056168637,
-0.052812282,
0.0258544777,
0.0231730193,
0.0179251172,
-0.0029734995,
0.0266834907,
-0.0125809927,
0.024509253,
-0.0199216884,
-0.0320833586,
0.0421209149,
0.0002985913,
0.0405031182,
0.0161430836,
0.0499593988,
-0.0378651135,
0.0164794978,
-0.0041526686,
-0.0533005595,
-0.0001347332,
-0.0370582491,
0.0340343677,
0.053297285,
-0.030128995,
0.0242610704,
0.0997263938,
-0.0226683468,
0.0271318834,
0.0152190747,
0.0007275734,
0.007904361,
-0.0492533967,
0.033859849,
-0.0599594899,
-0.0197613351,
0.0714361966,
0.032460954,
-0.0059505794,
-0.0315951146,
-0.009953632,
0.0513828583,
-0.0333524905,
-0.0129527207,
-0.0255629197,
0.0211034026,
-0.0242107976,
0.064232856,
0.0360527039,
-0.0468152277,
-0.0021534846,
0.0274572428,
-0.0325747989,
0.0021780108,
-0.0109347897,
0.0543590933,
0.058250647,
0.0078372266,
0.0092632966,
0.0378924236,
-0.0316047445,
0.0378288329,
0.0513095632,
-0.0311205499,
-0.0386172645,
0.0348220766,
2.705e-7,
0.0322212093,
0.0484493971,
0.0705143437,
-0.0231982302,
0.0130394865,
0.0025060156,
-0.0696337819,
0.0169010088,
-0.0164561551,
0.021906957,
0.0349178426,
-0.0178082511,
0.0852291733,
0.0071652378,
-0.0762362629,
-0.0307969805,
-0.0476032719,
-0.0000985861,
-0.0444917791,
-0.0551505424,
0.0484078266,
0.1030864567,
-0.0688517466,
-0.0057153432,
0.0285663977,
-0.0344071686,
0.0326592848,
0.0098917484,
-0.0010924847,
0.006218845,
0.0490389019,
-0.0384302773,
-0.0486370623,
-0.026412636,
-0.0247398634,
0.0261950623,
0.0363487974,
0.0709829777,
0.0318327993,
-0.074365139,
0.0279553849,
0.0350119434,
-0.017884085,
-0.0249646585,
0.0195006002,
-0.0376759917,
-0.0412847586,
0.0324829929,
-0.0414604805,
0.0242491458,
-0.0424954407,
-0.0293865297,
0.0215597637,
0.0155852763,
0.0440533645,
0.0218374636,
-0.0032468815,
-0.0432107411,
-0.021157017,
-0.0246350877,
-0.0330667831,
-0.0379160605,
-0.0506782494,
0.0064666597,
0.0254488289,
0.0003467195,
-0.0366736948,
2.388566639e-34,
0.0266623124,
-0.0105980169,
0.0179878287,
-0.0057869428,
-0.0050981436,
-0.0355669297,
-0.0043034935,
0.0155813908,
-0.045033101,
-0.071428813,
-0.0361089855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16319v1 | DiQAD: A Benchmark Dataset for End-to-End Open-domain Dialogue Assessment | 2023-10-25T03:04:57 | 2023-10-25T03:04:57 | Yukun Zhao, Lingyong Yan, Weiwei Sun, Chong Meng, Shuaiqiang Wang, Zhicong Cheng, Zhaochun Ren, Dawei Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue assessment plays a critical role in the development of open-domain
dialogue systems. Existing work are uncapable of providing an end-to-end and
human-epistemic assessment dataset, while they only provide sub-metrics like
coherence or the dialogues are conversed between annotators far from real user
settings. In this paper, we release a large-scale dialogue quality assessment
dataset (DiQAD), for automatically assessing open-domain dialogue quality.
Specifically, we (1) establish the assessment criteria based on the dimensions
conforming to human judgements on dialogue qualities, and (2) annotate
large-scale dialogues that conversed between real users based on these
annotation criteria, which contains around 100,000 dialogues. We conduct
several experiments and report the performances of the baselines as the
benchmark on DiQAD. The dataset is openly accessible at
https://github.com/yukunZhao/Dataset_Dialogue_quality_evaluation. | [
0.0367133878,
0.0464323983,
0.0077206036,
0.0561432689,
-0.0188865289,
0.0011782141,
-0.0077400738,
-0.0209580213,
0.0000572493,
-0.0207249578,
-0.0630555227,
-0.0357610434,
0.0146154398,
0.0563136451,
-0.0256107468,
-0.0762464106,
0.0441304073,
0.0031114779,
0.0210551172,
0.0173257366,
0.0221301969,
-0.0045842687,
-0.0483578742,
0.0565733053,
-0.0191428661,
-0.0388607606,
-0.0163191929,
0.0045432528,
0.0189055651,
0.0017928353,
0.0034567358,
0.0345648229,
-0.0020860385,
0.0112261875,
0.0000015494,
-0.0394430384,
0.0112745902,
-0.0408418253,
-0.0343675613,
-0.0084228311,
0.0084172478,
0.0246392097,
-0.00722154,
0.0255638137,
-0.0592125207,
0.000740219,
0.0267645363,
0.0459125601,
0.1198073179,
0.0751514733,
-0.0096849306,
-0.0088862721,
0.0064173075,
-0.0021170592,
-0.0455996804,
-0.0560347587,
-0.0268069562,
0.034653917,
-0.0034204505,
-0.0130790658,
0.0189838931,
-0.0028413567,
0.0326870494,
-0.0631893799,
-0.0085841436,
-0.029848367,
-0.07535512,
-0.0301234741,
-0.0135000516,
0.1203938872,
0.0831993148,
0.0586403906,
-0.0095594712,
-0.003910799,
0.02362247,
-0.0426162146,
-0.0243219268,
-0.0198728777,
-0.0231808182,
0.0022438043,
-0.04820944,
0.044614546,
-0.012813963,
0.0203772578,
0.0287011638,
0.0443901345,
-0.0187512673,
-0.0035793462,
-0.0140866525,
-0.0109911086,
-0.036472261,
-0.0264901035,
-0.0073130112,
0.0155679034,
-0.0714561269,
0.0110160699,
-0.0681252629,
0.0159233473,
0.0225477405,
-0.0189369302,
0.0369226076,
0.0166428275,
-0.0139599387,
0.05508985,
0.020433519,
0.0526164398,
0.0163039323,
0.0203571245,
-0.0076231244,
-0.0198556036,
-0.0531319305,
0.0500079468,
-0.0261990409,
0.0196376294,
-0.0575323179,
-0.0289311912,
-0.0300771426,
0.0245765895,
-0.0056785704,
0.0254077315,
0.0262970701,
0.0106710494,
-0.0136771565,
-0.0089506367,
-0.0457433574,
0.0412352867,
-0.0474394858,
0.0183279477,
0.0583076701,
-0.0449070893,
-0.008825412,
0.0544240437,
-0.0012490028,
0.0139286788,
-0.0532811135,
0.0623465888,
0.0190613903,
-0.0085314121,
-0.0274474155,
-0.0550101399,
-0.0288750343,
-0.0430032536,
-0.0367303044,
-0.0174077339,
0.0137965865,
-0.0138600199,
-0.0245679356,
-0.0404881164,
0.0015663806,
0.0067550237,
0.0391141511,
0.0157963391,
-0.0362272076,
0.0031250927,
0.0361357331,
0.026963897,
-0.0140762543,
0.0458691567,
0.0494562201,
0.0111963972,
0.0737940967,
0.0179143827,
0.0167748556,
0.0141292633,
-0.0029456157,
0.0259255562,
0.0443711802,
0.0556540042,
-0.0231060889,
0.0512280911,
0.0237696376,
0.0536531657,
-0.0614872016,
-0.0411997736,
0.0547027737,
0.0309621263,
0.0363275446,
-0.0076839696,
0.0284582805,
0.0417500176,
0.0284266956,
0.0171803068,
0.0085727377,
0.0211825389,
0.0611897409,
0.0000892173,
0.0893165246,
0.0036507819,
-0.0127189616,
-0.104016766,
0.0127449092,
0.0086299833,
-0.0022256854,
-0.0318644457,
-0.0061226515,
0.0391711071,
-0.0469804928,
0.0304502733,
0.0052208477,
-0.0820366889,
-0.0159449857,
-0.0313562937,
0.0295435172,
0.0416305363,
0.0247453805,
-0.0165264904,
-0.0360688232,
-0.0421465933,
0.0141191678,
0.0532796197,
0.0572022274,
-0.0482722633,
0.0483045727,
-0.0689935833,
-0.0257044584,
-0.007769838,
0.0096330512,
0.0116294483,
-0.006001676,
-0.0167684704,
0.0206538644,
-0.0178258121,
-0.0000382741,
0.0018064183,
-0.004096542,
-0.0043101092,
0.035277281,
-0.0097477958,
0.0469153523,
0.0519476756,
-0.0257186107,
-0.0250310637,
0.0166362077,
-0.0153338509,
-0.0263576061,
0.0179183576,
-0.0688873529,
-0.0285242219,
0.0201562159,
-0.0353388973,
-0.017101597,
0.0348963737,
-0.0499278381,
-0.0622651838,
0.0377299264,
-0.0366233774,
0.0089214351,
-0.0637727827,
-0.0165297445,
0.0204551499,
0.0085291341,
-0.0048370119,
0.0215720385,
-0.0095183887,
0.0097612916,
0.043083787,
0.0209140759,
0.0753296763,
-0.0588307939,
-0.0038049903,
-0.0014489209,
-0.0323947445,
0.0577954687,
0.0036834057,
0.0014695687,
-0.0811833739,
-0.0121148713,
-0.1148680821,
0.0233328827,
-0.0241270568,
0.025835922,
0.0082169417,
-0.0036500061,
-0.0014374328,
-0.0211402308,
-0.0396674201,
-0.0157102942,
0.0318969302,
-0.0096696522,
0.0456897616,
0.0201382637,
0.0195962023,
-0.0224176906,
0.0186279528,
0.0347750597,
0.0325555652,
-0.0159133375,
0.0273148883,
-0.0371488482,
0.0047981376,
-0.056138061,
-0.0049958094,
0.0137111833,
-0.049059771,
0.0350095481,
0.0512556955,
0.0083821118,
0.0506512634,
0.0305434633,
0.0156532172,
-0.0138592292,
-0.0023575549,
-0.0229570158,
0.0137180472,
-0.0001485498,
0.0135901254,
-0.0163895562,
0.0315214805,
0.0290044583,
0.0101215802,
0.016933864,
0.0393297933,
-0.0483443514,
0.0192782059,
-0.043998953,
-0.0201329049,
-0.0080694631,
-0.0029486811,
-0.0392935723,
0.0542039163,
-0.0195281561,
-0.0455382802,
0.0619131811,
-0.0321726613,
-0.0065183463,
-0.052746702,
-0.0063392944,
-0.0434721038,
0.0128621422,
-0.0658468008,
0.0175168663,
0.0165822245,
-0.037195228,
-0.0216503013,
-0.0062465686,
0.0451073572,
-0.0486498512,
0.0278827101,
-0.0469128191,
-0.0177094936,
0.0084389076,
-0.0523450375,
-0.0591968931,
-0.0132768517,
-0.0245702062,
-0.0030832537,
-0.0034823087,
-0.0254762191,
-0.015855005,
-0.0053756889,
-0.0258549377,
0.0144419195,
-0.0039863214,
0.0093240757,
0.0048877895,
0.047296375,
0.038647294,
0.0599901006,
0.0081932349,
-0.0051047737,
0.063326478,
0.0418005511,
-0.0089934003,
-0.0113725979,
-0.0160871539,
-0.0117713688,
-0.0175810512,
-0.0044390485,
-0.0122350641,
-0.0075851404,
0.0834737346,
-0.0348285027,
-0.0201215427,
0.1086422205,
0.0046301261,
-0.0008384055,
-0.0126003772,
-0.0281756315,
0.033062391,
0.0077394843,
-0.017993411,
-0.1236367896,
-0.058997456,
-0.0150555307,
0.0377472788,
-0.0121128345,
-0.0488056205,
-0.0065732622,
-0.0975724906,
0.0167835876,
-0.0173819698,
-0.0143317711,
-0.0167058855,
-0.025924474,
0.0164626818,
-0.0442017838,
0.0395933911,
-0.010984987,
0.0415662937,
-0.005095141,
0.0203181524,
-0.0228494462,
-0.0167595427,
0.0213184878,
-0.0156616233,
0.0712016821,
0.0593771078,
0.0682989061,
0.0533452481,
-0.036228925,
0.0082907369,
-0.0332485735,
-0.0306394808,
0.0305168014,
0.0807187259,
0.0000312462,
-0.016069049,
-0.0376723409,
0.0248448979,
-0.0261348095,
-0.0125542702,
0.0116090104,
0.0004084384,
-0.0367182568,
0.0458531752,
-0.0115063041,
0.0587392412,
0.0221936852,
0.0654182062,
0.036347907,
-0.0336680897,
-0.0048127123,
-0.0247069355,
-0.0351879038,
-0.0512948111,
0.0029913324,
0.0102678547,
0.0187067203,
0.0222073961,
-0.112728402,
-0.0427839123,
-0.0067539243,
0.0030821555,
-0.0419827439,
-0.0237025432,
-0.0122198593,
0.0271605365,
0.0175528843,
0.0237708222,
-0.0079856347,
0.0152778877,
-0.0922434926,
0.0280276965,
0.0394726694,
-0.002603204,
-0.0217649881,
0.0464878492,
-0.0433534123,
-0.0446414091,
-0.0150395203,
0.0137558579,
0.0161805376,
0.033066906,
-0.0125769088,
-0.0189740844,
-0.0118546458,
-0.0098541742,
-0.0336412489,
-0.0141297095,
0.0888170674,
0.0550916642,
-0.0260750223,
0.0644910559,
-0.0196388792,
0.017498292,
-0.0375279225,
0.0220376104,
-0.0300860871,
-0.0965911746,
-0.0045193522,
-0.0059510409,
0.0447277538,
0.0379553251,
-0.0107672019,
-0.0134051619,
0.0285622049,
-0.012828703,
-0.034167368,
-0.0532589965,
0.022340849,
-0.0036900821,
-0.0496983491,
-0.0041726613,
0.0284508523,
-0.0605682246,
0.0353769027,
-0.0196190048,
0.0086312266,
0.0423056297,
-0.0123541625,
-0.0170181133,
-0.0161219481,
-0.0303994752,
0.0137182949,
0.0059614009,
0.0478253253,
0.0305157769,
0.081106782,
0.0037940135,
0.0112179052,
0.0843185931,
0.0574028268,
-0.0573423021,
-0.0029287152,
-0.0150875924,
0.0206518546,
0.0082650129,
0.0341626965,
0.0747377425,
0.0057591391,
0.0170728154,
-0.0189463664,
0.0831984058,
0.0022848614,
-0.0164927114,
0.0026062678,
0.0165437534,
-0.0363875702,
0.019603787,
0.0660910606,
-0.0578033589,
0.0095684193,
0.0047106892,
0.0248892531,
-0.0479739048,
-0.0288771074,
-0.0196690839,
0.0259314701,
0.0213149823,
-0.0060735177,
-0.0398460552,
-0.0233290475,
0.0103302728,
0.0309578367,
0.0182424821,
0.0084813265,
0.027942704,
0.0141928913,
-0.0221177712,
0.0064807474,
-0.0511088185,
-0.0459987372,
-0.032924559,
0.0013598639,
-0.017295707,
-5.096506001e-33,
-0.01780596,
-0.0194343626,
-0.0029847929,
0.0060523897,
-0.0317463502,
-0.018187508,
-0.0143995304,
0.0216094144,
-0.0339695811,
0.0243677422,
0.0185703281,
0.0464958549,
0.0160169415,
0.0383532159,
-0.0514669865,
-0.0444675945,
0.0369602367,
-0.01082265,
-0.0383875817,
0.0530528687,
0.042446319,
-0.0264980365,
0.0035753853,
-0.0792100877,
0.0298575535,
-0.0000338888,
-0.0242685732,
0.025013173,
0.0435048118,
0.0726823509,
0.0086586792,
0.0780051351,
0.0065219458,
-0.0424789265,
-0.0197233986,
0.0150867412,
-0.0233566482,
-0.0050203046,
-0.005464586,
-0.0091791004,
-0.0410284698,
0.004261611,
-0.0100066531,
0.0131974667,
0.01621796,
-0.0344818383,
-0.0005079606,
-0.0322598107,
0.000922752,
0.0022622417,
-0.0312534682,
0.051168967,
-0.0440549403,
-0.0968285501,
-0.0178821497,
0.05077013,
0.0155669777,
-0.0557738245,
-0.0199457183,
0.0480872281,
-0.034928754,
-0.0164136514,
0.038127128,
-0.012339334,
-0.022222314,
0.0612935014,
-0.0098912055,
0.035464637,
0.0294225812,
-0.0281158518,
-0.0350838564,
0.0495943725,
0.0360003747,
0.0905834436,
-0.0145435929,
-0.0146540077,
-0.0368879363,
0.0635590926,
-0.0285133496,
0.0257022996,
-0.0261217859,
-0.0133872582,
0.0015574547,
0.0133860558,
-0.0449020118,
0.0138568394,
-0.0166151337,
-0.0232948195,
0.0218666177,
-0.0324278995,
-0.0271749012,
-0.0429465547,
0.0321868248,
-0.0388456173,
0.0234631654,
0.0326738358,
-0.0336918198,
0.0102467192,
-0.0155106736,
0.0074083731,
-0.0237565432,
0.0143162273,
0.0426635109,
0.0559514165,
0.0231038947,
-0.0415114239,
0.0382415466,
-0.0199059155,
-0.0420900807,
0.0201672111,
-0.0046975752,
0.0713763982,
-0.0441530645,
0.0529985651,
-0.0018227004,
-0.0209461935,
-0.0622398593,
0.1058075801,
-0.0360751338,
0.0162190925,
-0.0367282294,
-0.0526717715,
0.0415003598,
-0.0148159899,
-0.0512196571,
-0.0081840418,
-0.0087263118,
-0.0326562971,
-0.0038737461,
-0.0212656278,
-0.0059792846,
-0.019813953,
2.181e-7,
-0.0093887402,
0.005504427,
0.0336909592,
0.0232541393,
0.0052627726,
0.052351024,
0.0083435681,
0.0420116223,
-0.0013864745,
-0.0297297332,
-0.0070386878,
-0.0036533203,
0.0811040476,
0.0260724071,
-0.1111996025,
-0.024886718,
-0.0731234178,
-0.0328851864,
-0.0136088962,
-0.0003182226,
0.0842010975,
0.0469859801,
-0.0165718626,
0.0101314997,
0.0051394035,
-0.0119723072,
0.0262208544,
-0.0023669691,
-0.0302380268,
0.0154661741,
0.0479411036,
-0.0134891765,
0.0118186474,
0.0024394274,
-0.0222751312,
-0.0032892525,
0.0293763094,
0.0663731173,
0.035732422,
-0.0949589089,
-0.0130108641,
-0.0073787286,
0.0141900415,
0.0133623816,
0.0359488353,
-0.0495124422,
-0.0429045185,
-0.0137649151,
-0.0158276223,
-0.021427175,
0.0614615045,
-0.0166365094,
-0.0257352199,
0.0166974254,
0.0108698402,
-0.0013679048,
0.0262977574,
-0.044354789,
-0.0103849042,
-0.0180633795,
-0.01494011,
-0.071551688,
0.0032127346,
-0.0309452154,
0.0091039166,
-0.031508211,
0.0206271913,
1.181774636e-34,
0.0464680009,
-0.0128620444,
0.031961672,
0.0050172801,
0.044711709,
-0.0223609824,
0.0096595678,
-0.0380611569,
0.0462171286,
-0.0397391319,
0.0364559963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16303v1 | URL-BERT: Training Webpage Representations via Social Media Engagements | 2023-10-25T02:22:50 | 2023-10-25T02:22:50 | Ayesha Qamar, Chetan Verma, Ahmed El-Kishky, Sumit Binnani, Sneha Mehta, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Understanding and representing webpages is crucial to online social networks
where users may share and engage with URLs. Common language model (LM) encoders
such as BERT can be used to understand and represent the textual content of
webpages. However, these representations may not model thematic information of
web domains and URLs or accurately capture their appeal to social media users.
In this work, we introduce a new pre-training objective that can be used to
adapt LMs to understand URLs and webpages. Our proposed framework consists of
two steps: (1) scalable graph embeddings to learn shallow representations of
URLs based on user engagement on social media and (2) a contrastive objective
that aligns LM representations with the aforementioned graph-based
representation. We apply our framework to the multilingual version of BERT to
obtain the model URL-BERT. We experimentally demonstrate that our continued
pre-training approach improves webpage understanding on a variety of tasks and
Twitter internal and external benchmarks. | [
0.0438349396,
0.0293766968,
-0.0037397691,
0.0202728212,
0.0246551037,
0.0502055362,
-0.0156549551,
0.0107671097,
0.0427143313,
-0.0498953871,
-0.0148649383,
-0.0347365215,
-0.0238524769,
0.0173433796,
0.0436601341,
-0.0636696965,
0.0158964749,
0.0238265507,
-0.0103976447,
-0.0159715209,
0.0168951228,
0.0318141319,
0.0214738026,
0.0130419238,
0.0101890815,
0.0084774299,
-0.009491411,
0.0683723018,
0.0140752401,
-0.0224972535,
0.0367695019,
0.0581130832,
0.0676311329,
0.0384984463,
0.000001424,
-0.0327406675,
-0.006392228,
-0.0294870567,
0.0313203409,
0.0193662345,
0.0122279376,
-0.0120226163,
0.0342633091,
0.0308499075,
-0.0033276838,
0.0531610996,
0.0413759314,
0.0743409842,
0.0299860612,
0.0908987075,
-0.019679673,
-0.0328688398,
-0.0183473881,
-0.0188538246,
0.0009309355,
-0.0418498106,
0.0188115779,
-0.0105957547,
-0.0226782802,
0.0120648406,
-0.0235522427,
0.0004438219,
0.0120326309,
-0.0057368595,
0.0356647633,
0.0317203403,
-0.0353082307,
0.0087369336,
0.0129974978,
0.1286343038,
-0.022554839,
-0.0335995331,
0.0173703115,
0.0264928006,
0.0031217765,
0.0209451988,
-0.0714800209,
-0.026648663,
0.0069965944,
0.038518481,
-0.039216768,
-0.011387635,
0.0292921755,
-0.0024951783,
-0.0262902267,
-0.0156907812,
0.0079382267,
-0.0317279696,
0.0278160535,
0.0563880317,
-0.0105069559,
-0.0227359086,
0.0490133576,
0.0162595976,
-0.000632244,
0.0264467169,
-0.0465141907,
-0.0281995926,
0.0169817358,
-0.0994505137,
-0.0090321563,
-0.0118642747,
-0.0099930195,
0.0521717072,
-0.0287598912,
0.0140554719,
-0.0508088544,
0.0427261926,
-0.0118622286,
0.0036747449,
-0.0744385943,
0.030359121,
-0.0336431526,
0.031146124,
0.0294485837,
-0.0228363257,
-0.0092810998,
0.0558993667,
0.0065306714,
0.0185665525,
0.0034938976,
0.0428808331,
-0.0222634394,
-0.0113371368,
0.0242562536,
0.0402474739,
-0.0627914816,
-0.0088713421,
-0.0208275691,
-0.00240505,
0.0009669267,
0.0063691358,
0.0804044381,
-0.0537812859,
-0.0188935362,
0.0434150361,
0.0234937351,
-0.055546619,
-0.0451448262,
-0.0159107689,
0.0251598116,
-0.0167609379,
0.0159840118,
-0.0730816051,
0.0478274263,
0.0362753458,
0.0026290282,
-0.005674425,
-0.0013291402,
0.0252871383,
-0.0674433634,
0.0248670392,
-0.0173826199,
-0.0130162183,
-0.0150115825,
0.0221534055,
0.0241117794,
0.0547702238,
-0.0123365913,
0.0646642148,
0.050699506,
-0.0108164093,
-0.0284144375,
0.011467197,
0.0545713864,
0.0150295282,
0.026136905,
0.0103502227,
-0.020729946,
-0.0075613819,
0.0248217098,
0.0497164801,
-0.0277343951,
-0.0224915855,
0.0710335448,
0.0282445308,
0.0033691199,
0.039918229,
0.0413390882,
0.0445909798,
0.0021056179,
0.0199039243,
-0.0347906463,
0.0160034727,
-0.0151447328,
0.0009086864,
0.0537928231,
0.0345675051,
-0.0589008778,
0.0255340375,
0.0130496528,
-0.0556629635,
0.0498121157,
-0.0118793985,
0.0561292171,
-0.028419571,
-0.0503440537,
0.0700087771,
0.0402669162,
-0.0266924948,
0.0306934528,
0.0097031342,
-0.0192619432,
0.0699885562,
-0.0024359245,
-0.0247061923,
-0.0405993722,
-0.043792028,
0.0134536335,
0.0017601871,
0.0521273017,
-0.030231569,
0.0002351399,
-0.0356222205,
-0.0613405965,
-0.0313342772,
-0.0165272001,
0.0060358313,
0.0300284065,
0.0121982992,
0.0188099798,
-0.1013327688,
-0.0062896889,
-0.0100976089,
0.0129138958,
0.0201782994,
-0.0271117743,
0.0287610479,
-0.0071828486,
0.0691297278,
-0.0047502108,
-0.0221479908,
0.0064380593,
-0.0187607184,
-0.0256760884,
0.0003848301,
-0.0218682941,
-0.0529899262,
0.0516312607,
-0.0455711223,
-0.0465506427,
0.0712145045,
-0.052269537,
-0.0118319429,
0.0632440224,
-0.0505717508,
0.0788329989,
-0.0059071751,
-0.0279020276,
-0.035468109,
0.0097556449,
0.0108638937,
0.0568628199,
0.0000114356,
-0.0128537891,
0.0182449985,
-0.0454816595,
0.0029359588,
-0.0199181009,
-0.0547587089,
-0.0147694293,
-0.0142459515,
0.0259857792,
0.0654967129,
0.0000199403,
-0.0886014774,
0.0101357233,
-0.1164402589,
-0.0168931,
-0.0448288918,
0.0167997517,
0.0275270194,
0.0204804912,
0.0166907571,
-0.0331049673,
-0.0218569357,
-0.0128063923,
-0.0401871316,
0.0295282714,
0.0303979833,
-0.0072928178,
-0.018577965,
-0.0353475027,
-0.0287210084,
-0.0159017183,
0.0631043762,
0.0114404699,
-0.044793535,
-0.0005470252,
-0.0228324179,
-0.0242108759,
-0.0115652084,
-0.0194621738,
-0.0196549259,
-0.0295059104,
0.0011994182,
0.0172192696,
0.02600611,
0.0153669603,
0.0689195544,
0.0003498235,
0.0111860698,
-0.0566741675,
-0.0080827866,
-0.0390320309,
0.02497226,
-0.0875160098,
-0.0023778672,
0.0383802094,
0.0254337415,
-0.0195867494,
0.0057049636,
-0.0500588082,
-0.0349401608,
0.0080625964,
0.0148684513,
-0.0490105934,
-0.0110508045,
-0.0073199463,
-0.0148613825,
-0.0095191337,
-0.0232678857,
0.0775319189,
-0.0008153479,
0.017026443,
-0.0190319214,
-0.0168267768,
-0.0308680348,
0.0223252624,
0.0097263306,
0.0497501045,
-0.0223848466,
-0.0442208648,
0.016874468,
0.0417984501,
0.0049087247,
-0.0379319042,
0.001794364,
0.0641888082,
0.0197839178,
0.0003095653,
-0.0427800603,
-0.0149797397,
-0.042754259,
-0.0328932069,
0.0089274393,
-0.0289587099,
-0.042604845,
-0.0256779939,
-0.0070420043,
-0.0001597095,
-0.0187939629,
-0.0141111547,
-0.0273008645,
-0.0086391354,
0.0589349531,
0.0594985113,
-0.0182925202,
-0.0126432646,
-0.0261346083,
-0.0014993126,
0.0199681353,
0.0343464836,
-0.0461347066,
-0.0271414984,
0.0061684283,
0.0213443451,
-0.064075321,
-0.0098734973,
0.0068647536,
0.055094257,
0.0159253366,
0.0050220187,
0.1423593163,
0.0316904373,
-0.0323464647,
-0.0222766455,
-0.010470151,
0.0174129494,
0.0007294678,
0.0206944123,
-0.0588930734,
-0.0026976096,
-0.0146049261,
0.0065190759,
0.0688948482,
-0.005825703,
0.0298811961,
-0.0882353485,
-0.0168383289,
0.0140350955,
0.0578122847,
-0.0273535103,
-0.0855263397,
-0.0022357746,
-0.0133141642,
0.0118741402,
-0.0115918787,
-0.0304061174,
-0.0073080519,
0.0459367484,
0.0055964855,
-0.0523436368,
0.0394524783,
-0.0623356439,
0.0101729706,
-0.0133485934,
0.0521353558,
-0.0070622293,
-0.0291989353,
0.0361824855,
0.0318291597,
-0.0335348248,
-0.0188253,
0.0458190404,
-0.0267074686,
0.0120772272,
-0.0376603119,
0.0103408126,
-0.0260183811,
-0.0236429386,
-0.0693382472,
0.076374501,
-0.0080481898,
-0.0285830218,
-0.0115428921,
-0.0351667665,
-0.0264326707,
0.0528964624,
0.06109225,
-0.0261392053,
-0.0414947532,
-0.0313225165,
-0.0019856223,
-0.0650623366,
-0.0165189598,
-0.0110245077,
-0.0475825369,
-0.0361475684,
-0.0594338104,
-0.052189339,
0.0411575139,
0.0035640846,
-0.0185451973,
-0.0396097861,
0.0498355441,
-0.0286550559,
-0.0615236834,
0.0251832064,
-0.0434986278,
0.0270349048,
-0.0114010703,
-0.0441735275,
0.0223095883,
-0.022598194,
-0.0204634797,
-0.025870299,
-0.0436683744,
-0.077428937,
-0.0252512638,
0.0096928151,
0.0124827754,
0.0530750155,
-0.0538875572,
-0.0339558348,
0.0367349721,
-0.0061711483,
0.0104293628,
-0.0205136798,
0.0262311641,
0.0280302539,
0.0015804876,
0.0326998271,
-0.0720422715,
-0.0391533785,
-0.0078034014,
0.0255327001,
-0.0168783516,
-0.0395831093,
0.016238559,
0.0081721172,
0.0475250445,
0.0217262655,
-0.0102193533,
-0.0670949817,
-0.0137005253,
0.0229032151,
0.0027436861,
-0.0102149751,
-0.0054125939,
0.0440148115,
-0.0152428877,
-0.0318978466,
0.0015660411,
-0.007227818,
0.0108050918,
-0.08339376,
0.0147307497,
0.0185745284,
-0.0029700343,
-0.0017433856,
0.004367549,
-0.0001902627,
-0.0007492689,
0.0633007064,
-0.0055449023,
-0.0311235487,
0.0142607139,
-0.0065603615,
0.0015445385,
-0.0080751935,
0.037744239,
-0.0352781042,
-0.0060478058,
-0.0511516482,
-0.0146510145,
0.0565950423,
-0.0453609265,
0.0544929132,
0.0077748853,
-0.0069236695,
0.0011579493,
0.0078066741,
-0.019914763,
-0.0597823635,
0.0356510878,
0.004262337,
0.0098364251,
0.0117616262,
0.075640738,
0.0025705923,
0.0398452543,
0.0114449933,
-0.019616086,
-0.0299560707,
0.0153785385,
0.0310859233,
0.0653136,
-0.0193861164,
0.0211510286,
0.0280070119,
-0.0693256631,
0.055907812,
-0.0512839071,
-0.002985667,
0.0339037813,
0.0540900566,
0.0554029532,
-0.00542829,
0.0275902282,
-0.0341847613,
0.0064576929,
-0.0117288064,
-0.053854052,
-0.0238205753,
-6.125555061e-33,
0.0092486739,
-0.0045382045,
-0.0336674638,
0.001949441,
-0.0333699472,
0.0127200987,
-0.045553077,
0.0070538488,
-0.035917975,
-0.0096205845,
0.0194394905,
0.0090039438,
0.0004151376,
0.0336652212,
-0.0212006122,
-0.0406760238,
0.053589575,
0.0250872616,
-0.0037504656,
0.0483100936,
0.0266418289,
0.0350376777,
0.0799285397,
-0.0480783731,
0.0065907664,
-0.0175846461,
0.0056550573,
0.0014458705,
0.1136560217,
0.0498712696,
-0.0163733736,
0.0372997858,
0.0368134789,
0.0030573872,
0.0153476521,
0.0649299473,
-0.1172144264,
-0.0385942608,
-0.001807132,
0.0297792107,
-0.025094904,
-0.0122959428,
0.0263765343,
-0.0098026972,
0.038508337,
-0.0009833901,
0.03638684,
0.0546688512,
0.0026810584,
-0.0160403606,
-0.0489272065,
0.0405505002,
-0.051783286,
-0.011038891,
-0.0056966632,
0.0034272547,
0.0458200611,
0.039171461,
-0.027232457,
0.0009300037,
-0.0453647301,
-0.0111991521,
0.0376370139,
-0.015825443,
-0.0131646264,
0.0720379055,
-0.0310116094,
0.0325016528,
0.0009318339,
0.0085973097,
0.005221549,
0.0342471935,
-0.0088607436,
0.0221163146,
-0.0502309278,
-0.0286999475,
-0.0663274303,
0.0573916696,
0.0713536739,
0.0260575805,
0.0111041293,
0.03416555,
0.0127498955,
0.0030515662,
-0.0224439986,
-0.0193673018,
-0.0409300327,
-0.0272356551,
-0.0065682586,
0.0156572536,
-0.0463266447,
0.0491309576,
0.0322940648,
-0.0375355631,
-0.0423318222,
0.0767050311,
0.0030916205,
0.0367841795,
0.0178317819,
-0.0199825149,
-0.0111256428,
-0.0285456423,
0.0234316736,
-0.0422714539,
-0.0025075893,
-0.0155685283,
0.0492047593,
-0.0194654278,
-0.0165963806,
0.0068276008,
-0.0572790541,
-0.0337513313,
-0.0317429379,
-0.0048638433,
0.0557890199,
0.0515427738,
-0.0429833718,
0.0434820987,
0.0564503185,
0.0281618778,
-0.0145466672,
0.0129279969,
0.0175255742,
0.0214188416,
-0.0202557035,
-0.0400738083,
-0.0331061967,
0.0387317948,
-0.010268962,
-0.0865578353,
-0.0339251086,
-0.0281258151,
2.363e-7,
0.0524559692,
0.0705131069,
0.0501832925,
-0.001649359,
0.012434612,
0.0191009231,
0.0054569505,
0.0737382099,
0.0074738003,
-0.0328260437,
0.0100979293,
0.0437850319,
-0.0171226878,
-0.0022656671,
-0.0639597028,
0.0305457339,
-0.0975333676,
-0.0379555486,
-0.0285701435,
0.0301466193,
0.0272125173,
0.0649432018,
0.0229982957,
-0.0089528253,
0.0041130837,
-0.0534441955,
0.0744915605,
-0.0051638647,
-0.0168349128,
0.0013627498,
-0.0247955192,
0.019738758,
0.0160371363,
-0.0278515946,
-0.0480060466,
0.0325338691,
0.0343140289,
0.0233805198,
0.0014197443,
-0.0383166224,
-0.0022510493,
-0.0479806475,
0.0159515366,
-0.0605385825,
0.0568313003,
0.0015791252,
-0.0458027385,
0.0002224098,
-0.0118738422,
-0.0075349291,
0.0410323702,
-0.0264583826,
-0.0312533081,
0.0229935125,
0.0106821442,
0.0127143506,
-0.0187224783,
-0.1176439151,
0.012273524,
0.0024326227,
-0.0404996388,
0.0101564322,
-0.0165762622,
0.0028687983,
0.052305948,
-0.0088685853,
0.0389618985,
1.431430006e-34,
0.0348704644,
-0.0102257729,
-0.0117594581,
0.012672578,
0.0175538789,
-0.0147635834,
-0.0229030289,
-0.0201736894,
0.0538874343,
-0.084915489,
0.0197427683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16301v1 | Is ChatGPT a Good Multi-Party Conversation Solver? | 2023-10-25T02:18:40 | 2023-10-25T02:18:40 | Chao-Hong Tan, Jia-Chen Gu, Zhen-Hua Ling | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as influential instruments within
the realm of natural language processing; nevertheless, their capacity to
handle multi-party conversations (MPCs) -- a scenario marked by the presence of
multiple interlocutors involved in intricate information exchanges -- remains
uncharted. In this paper, we delve into the potential of generative LLMs such
as ChatGPT and GPT-4 within the context of MPCs. An empirical analysis is
conducted to assess the zero-shot learning capabilities of ChatGPT and GPT-4 by
subjecting them to evaluation across three MPC datasets that encompass five
representative tasks. The findings reveal that ChatGPT's performance on a
number of evaluated MPC tasks leaves much to be desired, whilst GPT-4's results
portend a promising future. Additionally, we endeavor to bolster performance
through the incorporation of MPC structures, encompassing both speaker and
addressee architecture. This study provides an exhaustive evaluation and
analysis of applying generative LLMs to MPCs, casting a light upon the
conception and creation of increasingly effective and robust MPC agents.
Concurrently, this work underscores the challenges implicit in the utilization
of LLMs for MPCs, such as deciphering graphical information flows and
generating stylistically consistent responses. | [
0.0515569896,
0.0529666916,
-0.0138748987,
0.0461611226,
-0.0791965201,
0.0022591499,
0.0182758868,
-0.0139562506,
0.0228235852,
-0.0530653968,
-0.0413494743,
-0.0388039425,
-0.0091311894,
0.0120367557,
0.0073474231,
-0.0571535639,
0.008365836,
-0.0196702257,
0.0335196778,
-0.005809987,
0.0154729942,
0.023895083,
-0.0135216601,
0.0770453438,
-0.030955391,
-0.0431082472,
-0.0284351055,
0.0102797346,
0.0094954818,
-0.0118603446,
-0.0060400176,
0.0379396155,
0.0209049322,
0.0499766879,
0.0000019774,
-0.0097012278,
-0.0047330461,
-0.0118005006,
-0.0011176142,
0.0234485231,
0.0447183363,
-0.006886241,
-0.0214151777,
-0.0044100345,
-0.0637301207,
-0.0465005301,
0.0293312501,
0.0667122155,
0.0757826045,
0.0852085128,
-0.0237571578,
-0.0315129906,
0.01190867,
-0.0236784946,
0.0217336882,
-0.0935765207,
0.0212517623,
0.0046905885,
0.0011948206,
0.0005758813,
-0.0270738266,
0.0271890238,
-0.0046610828,
-0.0188585576,
0.0047117956,
0.0560066178,
-0.0259294957,
-0.0080444664,
-0.0324244015,
0.101366058,
0.0090965051,
0.0270221327,
0.0158941336,
-0.0078923358,
-0.0049750819,
0.0057076914,
-0.0636072978,
0.018486185,
-0.0142304581,
0.014086511,
-0.0397318266,
-0.0010564965,
-0.0075891796,
-0.0200372636,
-0.0219738912,
0.0443282872,
0.0013312831,
-0.020494435,
-0.0236405749,
0.0055858903,
-0.0206569023,
-0.0757912844,
-0.0061193057,
0.0256883055,
-0.0212086774,
0.035924267,
-0.0231104959,
0.0175897386,
-0.0096441377,
-0.0414112806,
0.0314782038,
0.0294848531,
0.0208426826,
0.0464427359,
-0.0029535661,
0.0468083099,
-0.027707886,
0.0158732869,
-0.0042079897,
-0.0239321087,
-0.0863707289,
-0.0273751859,
-0.0744825974,
0.016894497,
-0.0319387838,
-0.0614429675,
-0.0147940852,
0.0483266711,
0.0061754598,
0.0077321371,
0.0182074849,
0.0037868728,
-0.0190890599,
-0.0125240888,
-0.0339246169,
0.0650655627,
-0.0217417013,
-0.0104619274,
-0.0034275609,
-0.0615869276,
-0.0047129057,
0.0432952046,
0.0177675411,
-0.033701539,
-0.0232198201,
0.0759546831,
-0.0263782684,
-0.0474200584,
0.0065175775,
-0.0145759135,
-0.0564885922,
-0.09383858,
0.0048820521,
-0.0302660149,
0.0568477437,
0.0022782802,
-0.0057195649,
-0.0307600703,
0.0276605953,
0.0128862606,
-0.0489074886,
0.0682948604,
0.0502558872,
0.0287154857,
0.0362001918,
0.0142147429,
-0.0123726409,
0.0723889098,
0.0699849948,
0.0170597099,
0.0127081675,
-0.0013135377,
0.03412164,
0.0510961413,
-0.0014887507,
-0.0011657978,
0.035267435,
0.0037135505,
0.0166693795,
0.0328437053,
0.0016315503,
0.078257218,
-0.0605144463,
-0.0269504543,
0.0744071379,
0.050136622,
0.0028133905,
0.0414534435,
0.0579996258,
0.0375739597,
-0.0146732517,
0.0394871198,
-0.0174191091,
0.0326475613,
-0.0200013667,
-0.0072871335,
0.0131321186,
-0.0048215268,
-0.032075014,
-0.0189306587,
0.0117453337,
0.0095623182,
0.0075995391,
-0.0020877153,
0.0417452194,
-0.0034324962,
-0.0856884941,
0.0073523615,
-0.0079012671,
-0.0471168011,
-0.0547633842,
-0.0336259827,
0.0072267493,
0.0925360546,
0.0786439627,
0.018458873,
-0.0417102203,
-0.0170184951,
-0.0119948797,
0.0475318804,
0.0348988809,
-0.0098571125,
0.0260064043,
-0.0462954231,
-0.0209788512,
-0.0167658813,
-0.0210020468,
0.0764413178,
0.013300484,
-0.0082375826,
0.0033032638,
0.0314406268,
0.0373261645,
0.0052504744,
-0.0259952862,
-0.0024597191,
0.0197989903,
0.0051710983,
0.0203889478,
0.0024782068,
-0.024977373,
-0.017468499,
0.0068534827,
-0.0073611876,
-0.0053727995,
0.0361976586,
-0.0621125922,
-0.0642637461,
0.0232599396,
-0.0274384264,
-0.0136556868,
-0.0204773303,
-0.0373417959,
-0.0453245267,
0.0465121195,
-0.0364134721,
0.0259006526,
-0.0632384643,
0.0085375477,
0.0301292315,
0.0129141528,
-0.0120670982,
0.0572185628,
0.0199736636,
-0.0415135212,
0.0054874029,
0.0297344234,
0.0018728166,
-0.0693595707,
0.0125282891,
0.0294150617,
0.0281661246,
0.0117687183,
0.0001584997,
0.0223991703,
-0.0169333406,
-0.0639757887,
-0.1199586987,
0.0150317131,
-0.0039667827,
-0.0116697727,
0.0054949387,
0.000521035,
-0.0245275907,
0.0001518799,
-0.0532603413,
0.0269570109,
0.0520066582,
-0.005536125,
0.0379870646,
0.0207961146,
-0.031973552,
-0.0334470272,
0.0231742095,
-0.019772172,
0.04319603,
0.0170837846,
-0.0631325841,
-0.012927047,
0.0140255382,
-0.0341896303,
0.0490077585,
-0.024183698,
-0.0290778968,
0.0055690091,
-0.0258853063,
0.0554421432,
0.0371767469,
0.0102114109,
0.057232324,
-0.0216739085,
-0.0559624285,
-0.0594201684,
0.057844203,
-0.033111535,
-0.0062326603,
-0.0310027972,
-0.0240690932,
0.0107854661,
0.0866529197,
0.0101571139,
0.0203814059,
-0.0756394193,
0.0270991381,
0.0515257679,
-0.0280638542,
0.005490209,
-0.0205543246,
-0.0115057463,
-0.0049947323,
-0.0275384374,
-0.0153450416,
0.0661166683,
-0.0593466535,
-0.0428681113,
-0.0132910376,
-0.0146590676,
-0.0739666373,
0.0595735051,
0.0126733007,
0.0103568248,
0.0044950647,
-0.0314062051,
-0.0403842106,
-0.0112978695,
0.0366735458,
-0.0078627979,
0.0328321159,
-0.0479425378,
0.0369121954,
-0.0042370418,
-0.0352862328,
-0.0108895926,
-0.0473995134,
-0.0269558784,
0.0046419511,
0.0228895396,
-0.0107043423,
-0.04253456,
0.0468593203,
-0.008375451,
-0.0004430341,
-0.0064822333,
-0.0060903979,
-0.0450509861,
0.0324428268,
0.0255168285,
0.0021818099,
-0.052226387,
-0.03367294,
0.0537566021,
0.0615637787,
0.0015287879,
0.0237660483,
-0.0071334187,
-0.0221121386,
-0.0122727882,
0.0110886479,
-0.0245726369,
-0.0098181507,
0.0397799723,
-0.0378525294,
-0.0094390158,
0.0995031521,
0.0257691164,
-0.0286731981,
-0.0377646685,
0.0129792523,
0.0429405607,
-0.0167938601,
0.0308583584,
-0.1032261997,
-0.0356044024,
-0.0160865784,
-0.0109143555,
-0.018088663,
-0.0358112417,
-0.032088507,
-0.1198937371,
0.0574356057,
-0.0009789201,
-0.0314955264,
0.025952911,
0.0023658264,
-0.0033949388,
-0.0015722301,
0.0038263814,
-0.0221126769,
0.0066972161,
-0.0132995239,
-0.0096319532,
-0.0449464656,
-0.0235084333,
0.0173249021,
-0.0055794655,
0.0464407392,
0.0664359555,
0.0530458093,
0.0418013297,
0.0073181097,
0.0137639223,
0.0143676195,
0.0080689657,
-0.0084830942,
0.042995207,
-0.0369149782,
0.0004125033,
-0.0137644028,
0.0252244584,
0.0188327935,
-0.0114763891,
0.0202356316,
0.0335777402,
-0.0437440723,
-0.016769588,
0.0021937115,
0.0696939081,
0.0373748168,
0.0934183002,
0.0510436781,
-0.0174719412,
-0.0906540975,
-0.0433453768,
0.0038743159,
-0.0612621009,
-0.0249316394,
0.0051946002,
0.016063787,
0.0165799391,
-0.0536335185,
-0.0586488433,
0.0514239147,
0.0087430589,
-0.0209328607,
-0.0005062601,
-0.0112438845,
0.0171316843,
0.0085493745,
-0.0237524807,
-0.047851868,
0.0091106081,
-0.0455545969,
-0.0295278542,
0.0200013481,
-0.0248181373,
0.0034168034,
0.035567183,
-0.0932582393,
-0.0647718683,
-0.0509275272,
0.0441837199,
0.0179009102,
0.0429867245,
-0.0105293449,
-0.0394839235,
0.0195987672,
0.0525460877,
-0.0212455541,
0.0094674891,
0.0126181208,
0.0582314655,
0.0017242625,
0.0306893662,
-0.0046898122,
0.0514136814,
-0.0027965095,
0.062606886,
-0.0323586389,
-0.0575849339,
0.008082943,
0.0064311549,
0.0222100187,
0.0203607082,
-0.004918715,
0.0038553528,
0.0025460662,
-0.0670182407,
-0.0149383182,
-0.0699620768,
-0.0441368967,
0.0097362744,
-0.0251318868,
0.0065066856,
-0.0223475173,
-0.0535995103,
0.0626604557,
-0.0370319225,
0.0033673153,
0.0200414341,
-0.060056638,
0.0245424174,
0.0004463073,
-0.0038681312,
0.0222826246,
0.0097469715,
0.0060444158,
0.0187350865,
0.0989555195,
0.0094596976,
-0.0337084047,
0.0101572247,
0.0176414847,
-0.0986505523,
-0.0196037702,
-0.0018742924,
0.0964424238,
0.0482283942,
0.0423781686,
0.0560162738,
-0.041421257,
0.0109733166,
-0.013263965,
0.0471513495,
0.0054991459,
-0.0455360822,
0.0362165645,
0.0236004647,
-0.0151936105,
-0.0289793666,
0.0877725407,
0.0210093968,
0.0166359488,
0.0051879971,
-0.009281924,
-0.0596996285,
-0.0585998148,
0.0182526503,
-0.0196669325,
0.0253957212,
0.0092431009,
-0.0707520768,
-0.0170664713,
-0.0094382996,
0.0014711296,
0.003093078,
-0.0171198789,
0.0170654617,
0.0344815403,
0.0066028005,
-0.016461432,
-0.0441384763,
0.01989034,
-0.0214716364,
-0.012679778,
-0.0269977599,
-5.944337914e-33,
-0.0564778969,
-0.0326438062,
0.0550228134,
0.0338169187,
-0.0383277349,
-0.00608679,
-0.0382936634,
-0.0028735332,
0.0111255068,
0.0053065391,
-0.0199774094,
0.0159050189,
0.00582651,
0.0192366764,
-0.0294914469,
-0.0105061447,
0.0490707606,
-0.0177867264,
-0.0307937004,
0.0402488224,
0.0340763554,
0.0207372773,
0.0294222664,
-0.043098487,
-0.0176425446,
-0.0175677072,
-0.0205489453,
0.0148648852,
0.0260206144,
0.0510915071,
-0.0268676542,
0.0123789143,
0.0191497169,
-0.0087163579,
-0.0168946553,
0.0616941154,
-0.046512749,
-0.0058629797,
0.0223567151,
0.01065805,
-0.0214666035,
-0.0297166165,
0.0081771668,
-0.0194018949,
0.0108761312,
-0.0200091284,
0.0304603186,
-0.0056631574,
-0.0331043489,
-0.0050248411,
-0.0420086272,
0.0281490423,
-0.0350755975,
-0.0393591821,
0.0252937805,
0.0390018374,
0.0181403197,
-0.0067194612,
-0.03425752,
0.0497444794,
0.0002233385,
-0.0314272158,
0.0217492897,
0.0241718255,
0.0427728333,
0.054744117,
0.0421028025,
0.0236250069,
-0.0654656813,
-0.0270873643,
-0.0186380055,
0.0568520129,
0.003843125,
0.0613917522,
-0.0281552318,
0.0193871073,
-0.0215272065,
0.0189852286,
0.0392263159,
-0.0078741089,
0.0256221145,
0.0212781858,
-0.0272571873,
-0.0364608467,
-0.0024124659,
0.0013073863,
-0.0195227303,
-0.0409374349,
0.0395212546,
0.0218855962,
0.0219784025,
0.0009300978,
0.0718671679,
-0.0625013188,
-0.034080293,
0.0044911155,
-0.0350736119,
0.0433539376,
-0.0140677728,
0.0255122893,
-0.0424847305,
-0.0289117042,
0.0601688325,
0.0284677558,
0.0106734075,
0.0061814063,
0.0173997469,
-0.017147921,
-0.0371305458,
-0.0166919157,
-0.0321159437,
0.0475972444,
-0.051529102,
0.0134473639,
0.0152127501,
-0.0034317658,
-0.0238600876,
0.0286715999,
0.0044345702,
0.0157296006,
-0.0142124062,
-0.0244826935,
-0.02635701,
0.0045756595,
-0.0335453078,
0.0317368656,
-0.0073411828,
-0.0423041731,
0.035751652,
-0.043019481,
-0.0029392838,
-0.0019930466,
2.622e-7,
0.0082791466,
0.0464696288,
0.0472639836,
0.0188362841,
0.0418429822,
0.0306407325,
-0.0286652818,
0.0309576206,
0.0107992962,
-0.0098904008,
0.0448929034,
0.0523060001,
0.0519911982,
0.0296684504,
-0.0904289559,
0.0231113769,
-0.0591382347,
-0.0425896719,
-0.0722258389,
0.0070448592,
0.0808076859,
0.0432607457,
0.0128364246,
0.0041640368,
-0.004464183,
-0.0262203347,
0.0985628739,
-0.047507599,
-0.0437997691,
0.0422502682,
0.0214524642,
-0.0169043168,
-0.0067444108,
0.0308625326,
0.0337116718,
0.0062224385,
0.0016623634,
0.0812797397,
0.0088885035,
-0.0398419127,
0.0055038687,
0.0032139099,
-0.0024637047,
-0.0360245146,
0.0849257335,
-0.086284101,
-0.0355833545,
0.005916744,
-0.0261652824,
-0.0301219244,
0.0137220044,
-0.0055668983,
-0.0296352673,
0.0347321145,
0.020590201,
-0.0280767884,
0.0228987001,
-0.0658226684,
0.0267655235,
-0.030039398,
-0.0573591702,
-0.0340877324,
-0.0184889715,
-0.0252572615,
0.0296284761,
-0.0334355384,
-0.0221373532,
2.226956599e-34,
0.0449315645,
-0.006672794,
-0.0021707134,
0.0268201157,
0.0383603312,
0.0052079903,
0.001238009,
0.0213834699,
0.0274109002,
-0.0895815268,
-0.0147522548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03707v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03707v2 | Multi-label Text Classification using GloVe and Neural Network Models | 2023-10-25T01:30:26 | 2024-05-21T09:14:04 | Hongren Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study addresses the challenges of multi-label text classification. The
difficulties arise from imbalanced data sets, varied text lengths, and numerous
subjective feature labels. Existing solutions include traditional machine
learning and deep neural networks for predictions. However, both approaches
have their limitations. Traditional machine learning often overlooks the
associations between words, while deep neural networks, despite their better
classification performance, come with increased training complexity and time.
This paper proposes a method utilizing the bag-of-words model approach based on
the GloVe model and the CNN-BiLSTM network. The principle is to use the word
vector matrix trained by the GloVe model as the input for the text embedding
layer. Given that the GloVe model requires no further training, the neural
network model can be trained more efficiently. The method achieves an accuracy
rate of 87.26% on the test set and an F1 score of 0.8737, showcasing promising
results. | [
0.0488455035,
-0.0151541857,
-0.0093941176,
0.0246145986,
-0.0398977958,
0.0036362847,
0.0292540137,
-0.0043673492,
0.0415590331,
-0.0648771673,
-0.0303441063,
-0.0085581122,
-0.0238952506,
0.0470217317,
-0.0254619811,
-0.0101518603,
0.0403841957,
0.0357429683,
-0.0129123945,
0.0121310893,
0.0181122515,
0.0306961741,
0.009189425,
0.0260318797,
-0.0509491563,
0.0015497074,
0.0244819615,
0.0069744755,
-0.0099700941,
-0.0068156752,
0.0430158116,
0.0362205133,
0.0205504708,
-0.0120076779,
0.0000019272,
-0.0205103699,
-0.0199961886,
-0.0128979543,
0.0388126969,
-0.0096962117,
0.0617734902,
0.0105319526,
0.0282462034,
0.0235107616,
-0.0077793952,
0.0118305394,
0.0364175774,
0.1283315569,
0.0243487339,
0.0401470661,
-0.0061157695,
-0.0002295761,
0.0180239882,
0.0200884659,
-0.0461443514,
-0.0207568817,
0.0249559674,
-0.0395013802,
0.0095462902,
0.0191478152,
-0.0255781151,
0.052303765,
0.0417597145,
0.0146660283,
0.0349405892,
0.0286666267,
-0.0004124316,
0.0099044936,
0.0258285254,
0.0622692257,
-0.0774022862,
-0.0166552477,
-0.0319076739,
-0.0194077697,
0.0254359599,
0.0318768136,
0.0094958171,
-0.0125896037,
-0.0054773865,
-0.0194795579,
-0.0131256049,
0.0593373626,
0.0065239794,
0.0516214855,
0.0402569808,
0.0280775167,
-0.0154155456,
-0.0353181586,
-0.016067015,
0.0046400526,
0.0295247138,
-0.0018123451,
0.0448735692,
0.0231302585,
0.0266679786,
0.0100565255,
-0.041165065,
-0.0706247166,
0.0303011462,
-0.0761792883,
-0.0207055695,
-0.0201084819,
-0.0573201254,
0.0149675682,
-0.0024491607,
-0.0505465493,
0.0229753871,
0.0494168662,
-0.0209752321,
0.0018799468,
-0.0417101867,
-0.0373352207,
-0.0380614512,
0.059791036,
0.0325445682,
-0.0438300408,
-0.0467481092,
-0.0174615942,
0.0033038696,
-0.0430572182,
0.0172002837,
0.0358543955,
0.0106197773,
0.0056387954,
-0.0282904189,
0.0004823996,
-0.0188144352,
0.0523547642,
-0.0376831889,
0.0118709933,
-0.0074697873,
0.0326665752,
0.0117845936,
-0.0244693402,
0.0415814929,
0.0131360954,
-0.024887925,
-0.0700303987,
-0.0479959026,
-0.0305230562,
-0.0460726991,
-0.0135938041,
0.0086986916,
-0.058971595,
0.0075655142,
-0.0345596485,
-0.0042406376,
-0.003506511,
-0.0044717574,
0.0219591707,
-0.0390568413,
0.0656093583,
-0.0053236503,
-0.0214194972,
0.1078007966,
0.0189275686,
0.0237851627,
0.0085229604,
0.0071229995,
0.0390292294,
0.0612347797,
0.0130045302,
0.0744674802,
0.014077778,
-0.0374881029,
-0.0170283634,
-0.0144490926,
-0.0311186742,
-0.0150176864,
0.0397249833,
-0.0303666294,
0.0134870512,
-0.0166369453,
-0.0027445394,
0.0409213044,
0.0505844466,
0.0228462964,
0.0288110636,
0.0188341737,
0.0191235598,
0.0030390664,
-0.0499038734,
-0.0027300718,
0.0273273475,
0.0026566458,
-0.0078495555,
0.0318762287,
0.0114285937,
-0.0180292614,
-0.0416292697,
0.0060947877,
-0.0473950393,
0.0235986449,
-0.02310187,
0.0675170422,
-0.0251861233,
-0.0365839228,
0.0134407692,
0.0120118577,
0.0088993479,
-0.015488591,
-0.0166547578,
-0.0215537678,
0.01266101,
0.0254054498,
-0.0317870751,
0.0154427774,
-0.0551614575,
0.0015786513,
0.0259887222,
0.054207176,
0.0289922133,
-0.0280676298,
-0.0657244995,
-0.0209278446,
-0.0023168342,
0.0154598989,
0.017826004,
-0.0491210036,
0.0520417877,
0.0348544046,
0.0108448146,
-0.0130379805,
0.045025833,
0.0220373739,
-0.0404562913,
0.04302264,
0.0192543417,
0.0429733843,
0.0247963779,
-0.018272154,
-0.0037324075,
0.033682812,
-0.0282311123,
-0.0777650028,
-0.0610725321,
-0.0443853922,
-0.0235379748,
0.0184570197,
0.0080127707,
0.0088641141,
0.0562733561,
-0.0022831073,
-0.0496931821,
-0.001464639,
-0.0017329716,
-0.0306126494,
-0.0494966395,
0.0062401448,
-0.0084831845,
0.0090205651,
-0.0564261824,
0.0285250545,
0.0173304733,
0.0294031352,
-0.1116430536,
-0.0252756178,
0.0527975596,
-0.0226671305,
-0.0254371911,
0.0298507828,
-0.0167932678,
0.01490176,
0.0307358522,
0.0393190533,
0.008261703,
-0.0217878204,
-0.1006045118,
0.0112230498,
0.0024001359,
-0.035221573,
-0.0522364527,
-0.0172361098,
0.0025262216,
-0.0023462286,
-0.0632853359,
-0.0131048635,
-0.0132714994,
-0.0088090338,
0.0323742107,
-0.0328014009,
-0.0051295864,
0.0040169102,
-0.0132861631,
-0.0379845165,
0.0480057895,
0.0160179399,
-0.0604444817,
0.0017058252,
-0.0252259746,
-0.037060298,
0.0225635506,
0.0084339529,
-0.0126439519,
-0.023875352,
0.0108755156,
-0.013166545,
0.0358489193,
0.047567457,
0.0403781235,
0.0482519455,
0.0331476592,
-0.0267233644,
0.0318957046,
-0.0245866459,
0.0318328999,
0.0146124167,
-0.0104874326,
-0.0106081842,
0.0407856442,
0.0023753443,
-0.002073542,
-0.0297635682,
-0.05239233,
-0.0007409757,
0.0172457453,
-0.0497734882,
-0.0208651237,
-0.0236713346,
-0.029210683,
0.0049987407,
-0.0272021107,
0.0415368415,
-0.0249300674,
0.0257309508,
-0.0814240947,
-0.0591640621,
-0.0346286334,
0.059799064,
-0.0125591727,
0.04373331,
-0.0027688988,
0.0496867858,
-0.0274902955,
-0.0092667704,
-0.0123977493,
-0.0269111842,
-0.0070670708,
-0.0053389156,
0.0036460799,
-0.0211418103,
-0.0162938684,
-0.0033141116,
-0.0643362105,
-0.0390823931,
0.0021806112,
-0.0034497047,
0.0062567461,
-0.0590690896,
-0.0042731804,
0.01843323,
0.0493148975,
-0.0163879059,
-0.0186058059,
0.0126495529,
0.0341814086,
0.049620185,
-0.0548900776,
-0.0238199215,
-0.0126772197,
-0.0173796993,
0.0179947838,
-0.0312195066,
0.0283201113,
-0.0253197793,
-0.008259424,
0.0108917011,
-0.0235218108,
-0.0306730662,
0.0119320657,
0.0277447551,
-0.033886034,
0.0296220742,
0.0722126365,
0.0339279734,
-0.0653470382,
0.0016037829,
0.0414890386,
-0.0449758545,
0.005194881,
0.0380193554,
-0.0271308552,
-0.0409426354,
-0.0255493987,
-0.0077608698,
-0.034424115,
-0.0035689655,
-0.0217786636,
-0.0736103058,
-0.0138847558,
0.0101889968,
-0.0112199811,
-0.0196906459,
-0.0386793874,
-0.0466786362,
0.0174256042,
0.0071318354,
-0.0619975068,
0.0371750183,
-0.0299177244,
0.0207118336,
-0.0084694,
-0.0204728395,
0.041878771,
-0.0080327867,
0.0259399153,
-0.0123870848,
0.0439573973,
-0.0784227625,
0.0182018168,
0.0690591708,
0.0218514409,
-0.0199949443,
0.0006141877,
0.0434658788,
-0.0625848323,
0.0025521377,
0.0063532419,
-0.0091246543,
-0.052767843,
0.0169221871,
0.014445005,
0.0524677746,
-0.0085971011,
-0.0123188281,
-0.0921929181,
-0.0375830159,
-0.021261964,
0.0450673662,
-0.0254089087,
-0.096059002,
0.009869704,
-0.016580252,
-0.0510664843,
0.0197128914,
-0.011011662,
0.0223633349,
-0.0459323339,
-0.0741718039,
-0.0343641005,
-0.0526044704,
-0.0027221795,
0.0232230686,
0.0032530425,
0.0359676853,
0.0010249849,
0.0339423493,
-0.0559068061,
0.0266563687,
0.0137684839,
0.0597446933,
-0.0335371271,
0.0617497414,
0.0612009354,
-0.0766632333,
-0.0382658727,
0.0004222562,
-0.0033032827,
-0.0180632602,
-0.0292139631,
0.027271498,
0.003921248,
-0.0247900616,
-0.0180637185,
-0.0754353106,
0.020380469,
0.0632418469,
-0.0433802381,
-0.0326402895,
-0.00762675,
-0.0249846876,
-0.0205279924,
0.0003081606,
-0.0226254929,
0.0735122636,
0.0046627088,
-0.0297128707,
-0.0465079993,
-0.0592024811,
-0.0367920324,
-0.0261835363,
0.0708865151,
0.0095454175,
-0.0062237284,
-0.0525648035,
-0.0041023046,
0.0268065911,
-0.0348085687,
-0.0110283066,
0.005124819,
0.0307604484,
-0.0064507411,
-0.0612898692,
-0.0086244904,
0.0378219411,
0.0613660887,
0.0773644149,
-0.0168487485,
0.0014163837,
0.0432431735,
-0.026823286,
0.0102188243,
-0.0347182602,
-0.0117194001,
-0.0117544569,
-0.01218904,
0.0115736239,
0.0301696099,
0.0189172793,
0.0006100661,
-0.0407831334,
0.0313402116,
-0.0299231764,
0.024303358,
-0.0400895178,
-0.0036500865,
0.0031870692,
-0.0381424278,
-0.0344219655,
-0.0164387114,
-0.0215038285,
-0.0295576863,
0.035810791,
-0.0001005797,
0.0275291204,
0.0384975262,
0.0216871072,
-0.0379738659,
0.0133203072,
0.00976157,
0.0456913747,
0.0094029875,
0.0102485027,
-0.0783770606,
-0.030651724,
0.0352823026,
0.0664301738,
0.087986894,
0.0039001973,
0.0113099115,
-0.0386206731,
-0.0029532874,
0.0676143616,
-0.0411651023,
0.0227057319,
0.0233237445,
0.0431541763,
0.061229296,
0.0205823313,
0.036983002,
-0.0271936208,
-0.0246972553,
0.0090464875,
-0.0382501595,
-0.0210295767,
-5.620624769e-33,
0.020226242,
-0.0399996378,
-0.0018420215,
-0.0017478527,
-0.0168544538,
0.0031088893,
0.0093135806,
0.0092013357,
-0.0488794632,
0.034659598,
-0.0053427597,
-0.0035613889,
-0.0048898244,
0.0251984112,
0.0270414148,
-0.0093111722,
0.0014163714,
-0.014949006,
0.0278100073,
0.0002943847,
0.0178836286,
0.0595979542,
0.0598474331,
-0.1418515295,
0.0127688507,
-0.0179724507,
-0.0262738857,
0.018992966,
0.006207935,
0.0574858785,
-0.0229024235,
0.0629666746,
0.0507177375,
-0.0231702421,
0.0629145205,
0.0418188572,
-0.0330827646,
-0.0394584648,
-0.0630546585,
0.0083969161,
0.0054737646,
-0.0101912506,
0.0237650778,
0.0406655297,
0.0009215208,
-0.0071714479,
0.0983506963,
-0.0078798104,
-0.050965637,
-0.1229608655,
-0.0013811373,
0.0334808528,
0.0207290538,
-0.0467035174,
0.0253608096,
0.0037109288,
0.007795658,
0.0340673402,
-0.0291754063,
-0.0087842718,
-0.0270718355,
-0.0169826262,
-0.0107797235,
0.0032918949,
-0.0371100977,
0.0462845303,
-0.0022396692,
0.0065488713,
-0.0061582206,
-0.0441544838,
0.0445939861,
0.0182567202,
0.0626151785,
0.0597757958,
0.0621803589,
0.0073220343,
-0.0671600923,
0.0242675245,
0.0465164781,
-0.0050621964,
0.0005375718,
-0.0031702069,
-0.055492226,
-0.0025889946,
-0.0286936983,
-0.0134132737,
-0.0236218292,
0.0010961799,
0.0216616411,
0.028781442,
0.0091888215,
0.0433941446,
0.0109145269,
-0.0363302603,
-0.0442099646,
-0.0135920728,
-0.0070793177,
0.057052426,
0.0178555828,
0.0029458487,
-0.0563922301,
-0.040747799,
-0.0140122836,
0.0271365121,
-0.014464872,
-0.0191206615,
0.0723580644,
0.0056552272,
-0.0655964017,
-0.0024311929,
0.0333906263,
-0.0542237125,
0.0306947529,
0.0485893786,
-0.0210846532,
0.0006033176,
0.0034756602,
0.0779521167,
0.0301344004,
-0.0278809518,
0.0019376356,
-0.0580089837,
-0.0011421976,
0.0032836699,
-0.0152257076,
-0.0284864958,
-0.0066844607,
-0.0216391478,
0.0391475372,
-0.062867187,
0.0347904302,
-0.0052078851,
2.542e-7,
0.0534926765,
0.0258263797,
-0.0276410803,
-0.0477044843,
0.0164922494,
0.0697615072,
0.0498314425,
0.0662196428,
-0.0610558689,
0.0272835102,
0.0394917019,
0.0034311435,
0.0315256193,
0.0080481004,
-0.0686796308,
-0.0424057655,
-0.0649855956,
0.0287499931,
-0.0476818122,
0.0172389131,
0.0881292596,
0.1143122315,
0.0927801654,
-0.0431036875,
-0.0137200709,
-0.0534214191,
0.0307844505,
-0.0166790094,
0.0385831036,
0.0020660984,
0.0469105951,
0.0324422531,
-0.0186718497,
0.0318756774,
-0.0316134654,
0.0410404131,
0.0375383459,
0.0355874561,
-0.0405636728,
0.0004528429,
0.0613499135,
0.0243663378,
-0.027811747,
-0.0220158193,
0.0665493384,
-0.0244191196,
-0.0034799229,
-0.0093491906,
-0.0039346772,
-0.0020128551,
0.0897093341,
0.0091696596,
0.0041899648,
0.0310757738,
0.0177295581,
-0.0407575741,
0.0103113437,
-0.1137056276,
0.0003168338,
0.0459347777,
-0.0283836704,
0.0528304726,
-0.0269542802,
0.0051806131,
0.0929635763,
-0.0635953695,
0.020070903,
2.057489344e-34,
0.0260927957,
-0.0394803137,
0.0005717571,
-0.0097471615,
-0.0113505609,
0.0092012594,
0.0080598816,
0.0114509566,
0.0039178887,
-0.0231107157,
0.0172376595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16278v1 | XFEVER: Exploring Fact Verification across Languages | 2023-10-25T01:20:17 | 2023-10-25T01:20:17 | Yi-Chen Chang, Canasai Kruengkrai, Junichi Yamagishi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces the Cross-lingual Fact Extraction and VERification
(XFEVER) dataset designed for benchmarking the fact verification models across
different languages. We constructed it by translating the claim and evidence
texts of the Fact Extraction and VERification (FEVER) dataset into six
languages. The training and development sets were translated using machine
translation, whereas the test set includes texts translated by professional
translators and machine-translated texts. Using the XFEVER dataset, two
cross-lingual fact verification scenarios, zero-shot learning and
translate-train learning, are defined, and baseline models for each scenario
are also proposed in this paper. Experimental results show that the
multilingual language model can be used to build fact verification models in
different languages efficiently. However, the performance varies by language
and is somewhat inferior to the English case. We also found that we can
effectively mitigate model miscalibration by considering the prediction
similarity between the English and target languages. The XFEVER dataset, code,
and model checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/nii-yamagishilab/xfever. | [
-0.0055739013,
0.0160158388,
0.0299546905,
0.0717139095,
-0.0548944995,
0.0162107926,
0.0259329304,
-0.0259633642,
0.00167532,
-0.0218085907,
0.0148162656,
-0.0449982956,
0.0251755472,
0.01151249,
0.0050889677,
-0.0038543611,
0.0631349832,
0.0146490596,
0.0411436372,
-0.027607901,
-0.0080678575,
0.0430182293,
-0.0328711979,
0.0046534669,
-0.0563348643,
-0.0254192837,
0.0186881945,
-0.0346983261,
0.0629534125,
-0.0282805786,
-0.0008339355,
0.0186472479,
-0.0014037383,
0.0563763119,
0.0000020513,
-0.0571848005,
-0.005658967,
0.0397152305,
-0.0495013632,
-0.0151351988,
0.0320689976,
-0.0244596265,
-0.0246827006,
0.0133598084,
-0.0313988142,
-0.0651039705,
0.0289101657,
0.0765407756,
0.0411751457,
0.0995869711,
-0.0158761516,
-0.0579867139,
0.0106994594,
-0.0127704609,
-0.0253967382,
-0.0141663458,
0.0276687816,
0.0474053472,
-0.0386187434,
-0.0051672552,
0.0176755376,
0.0432255566,
0.0148380408,
0.0232216548,
-0.0751726702,
0.0384711362,
-0.0360822268,
-0.028733816,
0.0119440435,
0.05170976,
-0.0107458141,
-0.0405912735,
-0.0215449184,
-0.0116869425,
-0.0117136799,
0.0263332669,
-0.0037090327,
0.0389447957,
-0.0394491889,
0.0115197273,
0.0383995064,
0.0069960128,
0.0346306562,
0.0008357306,
-0.0238684546,
0.0454028547,
-0.0033970114,
-0.0489655919,
0.0117913559,
-0.0113709159,
0.0235735364,
-0.0774055645,
-0.0091510853,
0.0121410051,
0.0045407931,
0.0212987196,
-0.0161884576,
-0.0083761271,
0.0525980927,
-0.1081987694,
-0.0142231574,
-0.0058180974,
-0.0969386175,
0.0697959661,
-0.0381160304,
0.0341282748,
-0.0040847557,
-0.0109749408,
0.0092875082,
-0.0327842832,
-0.0302567892,
0.0524397083,
0.0079190638,
0.001118355,
-0.0016142476,
0.0417091884,
-0.0546870828,
-0.0338592269,
0.002873749,
0.0795089006,
-0.0079321517,
-0.0527633242,
-0.0001625404,
-0.0194111429,
-0.0328074247,
0.0613336824,
-0.0265985876,
0.002803697,
-0.022111766,
-0.0507280827,
0.0052647442,
0.0024323442,
-0.0052387235,
-0.0088692717,
0.0340806469,
0.024101438,
0.0125516038,
-0.0067889653,
-0.0427541472,
-0.0225091279,
0.0021999346,
-0.1283810586,
-0.0254823044,
-0.0931327716,
0.0330575183,
-0.0071328292,
0.0092533519,
-0.0102486452,
-0.0071977251,
0.0239248257,
-0.0301890038,
0.0333953127,
-0.013401947,
-0.0249023512,
0.0133631937,
-0.0212090667,
0.0241642613,
0.0791425407,
0.0184292179,
0.0142948078,
0.0655450225,
0.0271214545,
0.0012970958,
0.0130024999,
0.0440007299,
0.0031625899,
0.0347691849,
0.0229435693,
0.04123028,
-0.0046231467,
-0.0146888765,
0.0015575207,
-0.0291180927,
-0.0165215191,
0.027605556,
-0.014369891,
-0.0073096501,
-0.013628711,
0.0392886885,
-0.0234688707,
0.0373110846,
-0.0092907147,
-0.0092156827,
0.010649872,
0.0079094293,
0.0116756251,
-0.029605018,
0.0795020312,
-0.0241956096,
-0.0445993915,
-0.0383718573,
-0.015133067,
-0.0409914292,
0.0217436645,
0.0600186214,
0.0124570839,
-0.0248303451,
0.062551856,
0.0503931791,
-0.0579936467,
-0.041389104,
-0.0136864083,
0.0236137472,
-0.0101614371,
0.032099124,
-0.021806825,
-0.0053893072,
-0.0337841623,
0.0356919728,
0.0317398235,
0.0736444592,
-0.0073251836,
0.0294421278,
-0.0310317092,
-0.0123694632,
-0.0240945946,
0.0180805326,
0.0046463041,
0.0262858011,
0.0688329488,
0.0160303563,
-0.0073056468,
-0.0597793609,
0.0379334874,
-0.0185484458,
0.0015822439,
0.0161995105,
0.0128991837,
0.0134330597,
0.0286606029,
-0.0341252424,
-0.0418693498,
0.0148490528,
-0.0059056766,
0.019530993,
0.0651611686,
0.0482772961,
-0.0671346486,
0.0635515153,
-0.0193702597,
-0.0304516796,
-0.0135237779,
-0.0562173314,
-0.0016689289,
-0.0286455378,
0.0242201984,
-0.0112683661,
-0.0286272168,
-0.0145123843,
-0.0144948093,
0.0296120252,
0.0329452232,
0.0717064738,
0.0095453495,
-0.0102543961,
-0.0164709892,
-0.0432443433,
0.0696185157,
-0.0233865324,
-0.0000562346,
0.0432995595,
-0.0199792534,
0.0065852399,
0.0368137732,
0.000134542,
0.0024882269,
0.0220147334,
-0.0651303753,
0.0205982905,
-0.0091241887,
0.0275568236,
0.0118141379,
-0.0097738355,
-0.0049340134,
0.0092157917,
-0.0225040726,
-0.0152896745,
0.0056818509,
0.0071333176,
0.0366913788,
-0.0301803704,
0.0160630476,
-0.0232461933,
0.0255711675,
-0.0131549416,
0.0555298738,
0.0271846987,
-0.0391344912,
-0.030817287,
0.0093478095,
-0.0744343549,
0.0208276473,
-0.0168357696,
-0.0155518893,
0.0099180583,
0.0308272392,
0.0092089828,
0.0398885272,
-0.0173550416,
-0.0212429259,
0.0332576856,
-0.0021611515,
-0.0147392042,
0.0383667164,
-0.0287634749,
0.015332453,
0.0024322276,
-0.0517676696,
0.0075695156,
0.0191073604,
0.0080078477,
-0.0048360275,
-0.0073921317,
-0.0112148225,
-0.0369650051,
-0.0169570111,
0.0102026043,
0.0578700081,
0.0107029742,
0.0539523512,
-0.0234994348,
-0.0091825537,
0.0708877668,
-0.0266462173,
0.0092357378,
-0.0661745891,
0.0019174152,
-0.00899815,
0.0078807957,
-0.010065713,
0.0228956267,
0.0004167785,
0.0362391397,
0.0056224391,
-0.0330304839,
0.0669612512,
-0.0312316921,
-0.0168012884,
-0.0086322417,
0.0145841921,
-0.0005417226,
-0.0270950478,
-0.0394131579,
-0.0384824239,
-0.018702738,
-0.0155813964,
-0.0874404982,
-0.0225528572,
-0.0854733586,
-0.0145267975,
0.0463368669,
0.0480849892,
0.0082878042,
-0.0028680183,
0.0188467074,
-0.0040360992,
0.0106514841,
-0.0136629539,
0.03208277,
-0.0110855084,
0.0110567743,
0.0542657934,
-0.052818507,
-0.025768403,
-0.0150564285,
-0.0381421112,
-0.0185027905,
-0.0250243396,
0.0115351556,
-0.0147123476,
0.0411545299,
-0.0560216866,
0.0154359238,
0.0711072609,
0.0086281803,
0.0455621518,
-0.0144142993,
-0.0262711979,
-0.0292712282,
0.0100320252,
0.018199414,
-0.1272500455,
-0.0103665236,
-0.0087133236,
-0.0115868356,
-0.0210839305,
0.0229123086,
-0.0334979109,
-0.1060453057,
0.0490030013,
-0.0009778184,
-0.0243522841,
-0.0433142632,
-0.0542057008,
-0.0210390445,
-0.0438098013,
-0.0060622022,
0.0063385535,
0.020684123,
-0.026614856,
0.0015302988,
-0.0127974721,
-0.0712282509,
0.0598632917,
-0.0495418087,
0.0055467174,
0.0122867906,
0.0405326746,
-0.013334481,
-0.0362846851,
-0.0106212609,
0.0094410535,
-0.0426121987,
0.0016096462,
0.0632822141,
-0.010185481,
-0.0120743597,
0.0062680054,
0.0022985642,
0.0184593778,
-0.0243171621,
0.0217749421,
0.0810533613,
0.016277412,
-0.0334534831,
-0.0119476067,
0.0115093132,
-0.0097288471,
0.0694826916,
-0.0178754311,
0.0358361155,
-0.0087243011,
-0.017356623,
-0.0463750139,
-0.044145003,
-0.019725604,
0.0520214364,
-0.0608292259,
-0.068522729,
-0.0577907674,
-0.0216304436,
0.0027712802,
0.0493914746,
-0.0092844572,
-0.0168209504,
0.0149762323,
0.016056709,
-0.0235392135,
0.0167701058,
-0.0442959853,
0.0343115292,
0.0010501212,
0.0183504559,
0.0350629166,
-0.023067873,
-0.0056782058,
0.0368920565,
-0.0330355763,
-0.0743008703,
-0.0336470753,
0.0276413392,
0.0176468901,
0.0849878043,
-0.0306241009,
0.0013949623,
0.0269424617,
0.0511278473,
-0.0216410905,
-0.0211776085,
0.0521520227,
-0.0391087495,
-0.0067957859,
0.0007941138,
-0.0085171536,
0.030953465,
0.0020236899,
-0.0183064602,
-0.0526136272,
-0.0213160422,
0.0404603295,
0.0555174127,
0.0350045152,
-0.0128196105,
-0.0475443415,
-0.0556630269,
0.0076537351,
-0.0412566774,
-0.0247676522,
-0.0067628492,
0.0336440131,
-0.0111452192,
-0.0333871208,
-0.0031655976,
-0.0186072998,
-0.0331554711,
-0.028205242,
-0.0095166713,
0.0043896134,
0.0015550755,
0.0704899877,
-0.0138659095,
-0.0274524428,
-0.0477480181,
-0.0010585962,
-0.0150931356,
0.0151686845,
-0.0054058395,
0.0147119183,
0.0182039887,
0.0096406741,
0.0146280434,
-0.0469685234,
-0.0206061695,
0.0213743336,
-0.0605879314,
0.0147397509,
0.0874746069,
0.0003158023,
0.0511548184,
-0.0295419972,
-0.0155557459,
-0.0031057554,
0.0197354965,
-0.0155740073,
-0.0019751058,
0.0061757807,
-0.0015086444,
-0.0395257585,
-0.0034595877,
0.0660093948,
0.0089045875,
0.0634553209,
0.0091154501,
-0.0239558797,
-0.0367278419,
-0.0327572972,
-0.0132887326,
-0.0254796203,
-0.0156124746,
-0.0219341125,
-0.0606823228,
-0.0600136891,
0.0258741248,
0.0557406284,
0.023561744,
0.038449537,
-0.0244150888,
0.0956852287,
0.0356163792,
-0.0271151904,
-0.0370070711,
0.0218559466,
0.0302459113,
0.0039383089,
0.0114498921,
-6.166739608e-33,
0.0002719157,
0.0031671645,
0.0167261939,
0.0196906719,
0.021165682,
0.0220798124,
-0.0139633641,
-0.0286453106,
-0.0577517711,
0.0750904754,
0.0290544201,
0.0055888835,
0.0361096784,
-0.0305061638,
-0.0147344898,
0.0024198974,
0.0604435764,
0.0123455403,
-0.0298397858,
0.0113853179,
0.0715091527,
-0.012707701,
0.1327655315,
-0.0870529115,
0.0564677529,
-0.0228503309,
-0.0193779971,
0.0103383195,
-0.0001815743,
0.0230933037,
0.0009458686,
0.0308819413,
0.013304593,
-0.0504901186,
0.0032038514,
-0.0515933558,
-0.0936449468,
-0.0262812842,
0.0686636642,
0.0334741622,
0.0085585015,
0.0007558379,
0.003953224,
-0.0158991758,
-0.0060525266,
-0.0144849643,
0.0362895727,
-0.0494939201,
0.0013715933,
-0.0241799839,
-0.0766529441,
0.0613155514,
0.0266787671,
0.0056201764,
0.0174581464,
0.0645159036,
0.0095017245,
-0.0295479298,
-0.0928552523,
0.0140495431,
-0.0238662623,
0.0062478664,
0.0602134727,
-0.0393393002,
-0.0436301753,
0.0397170559,
-0.0097926697,
0.0108952913,
-0.0108514577,
0.0519651771,
0.0083813127,
0.0428776592,
0.0468155146,
0.1375197619,
0.0327424817,
-0.0258536469,
-0.1453944594,
0.0320972428,
0.0388648398,
0.0242507178,
-0.0015053001,
-0.0547829308,
-0.0460462384,
0.0077350391,
-0.0088350577,
0.0201279689,
-0.0160105303,
-0.0026207012,
-0.0150055671,
0.0204569548,
0.0016619141,
0.0333723351,
0.0208350364,
-0.0291125346,
0.0038483543,
0.0393404849,
-0.0407276191,
-0.0122114951,
-0.0142039713,
0.0174781196,
-0.063667044,
-0.0199033506,
-0.0235308744,
0.02613011,
0.0206729416,
0.0249416586,
0.0892557651,
-0.0132304626,
-0.0382664315,
0.0263017155,
-0.0216543153,
0.0201191492,
0.0092977425,
0.0292731728,
0.0138117466,
0.0175863802,
-0.0149390362,
0.0066067721,
0.0218494423,
-0.0099522267,
-0.0225304849,
0.0190784894,
0.0184554327,
0.040772289,
-0.0167307295,
-0.0020332164,
-0.0351432785,
-0.006409517,
0.0015016412,
-0.0648038089,
0.0001093106,
0.0451804399,
2.73e-7,
0.0053165518,
0.0271431264,
0.0020555677,
0.0132921394,
-0.0206215084,
0.0424950048,
-0.0350639112,
0.0032896893,
0.0050761602,
-0.0568381101,
-0.0221919212,
0.0283987503,
0.0595768616,
0.0802395865,
-0.0703517869,
-0.0194770135,
-0.051929649,
-0.0173543189,
-0.0587959699,
-0.0103025781,
0.0028859046,
0.0645530745,
0.0378525481,
0.0019190158,
0.0042571537,
-0.0123195192,
0.0595065542,
0.0296046454,
-0.0766974017,
0.0163884796,
0.0839043185,
0.0233517159,
0.0051330593,
0.0241969302,
-0.0427731201,
0.0153246159,
-0.0109017342,
0.0247258358,
0.0053295167,
0.0391184464,
-0.0021789412,
-0.0372838303,
-0.0270504858,
-0.0526017509,
0.0615326129,
-0.0262625497,
-0.0287897214,
-0.0704932734,
-0.0322625414,
0.0431587063,
0.06599316,
0.0018223227,
-0.0136932088,
0.0159626231,
0.0205898155,
-0.0063154446,
-0.0298877917,
-0.002997651,
-0.0384940132,
0.0375559218,
0.0025955064,
-0.0434817448,
0.0520895608,
-0.0280732866,
0.0112329219,
-0.0666531622,
0.0341993906,
2.263882274e-34,
0.0539322942,
-0.006172203,
-0.023252314,
-0.0313893072,
0.0321928449,
-0.0078184437,
-0.0410390906,
-0.0270142928,
-0.0244828481,
0.0275909938,
0.0154794576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18365v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18365v2 | Using GPT-4 to Augment Unbalanced Data for Automatic Scoring | 2023-10-25T01:07:50 | 2023-11-18T02:05:27 | Luyang Fang, Gyeong-Geon Lee, Xiaoming Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Machine learning-based automatic scoring can be challenging if students'
responses are unbalanced across scoring categories, as it introduces
uncertainty in the machine training process. To meet this challenge, we
introduce a novel text data augmentation framework using GPT-4, a generative
large language model, specifically tailored for unbalanced datasets in
automatic scoring. Our experimental dataset comprised student-written responses
to two science items. We crafted prompts for GPT-4 to generate responses
resembling student-written answers, particularly for the minority scoring
classes, to augment the data. We then finetuned DistillBERT for automatic
scoring based on the augmented and original datasets. Model performance was
assessed using accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score. We incorporate varied
amounts of augmented data to examine scoring performance, and our findings
revealed remarkedly improved model performance. The average maximum increase
observed across two items is: 3.5% for accuracy, 30.6% for precision, 21.1% for
recall, and 24.2% for F1 score. Notably, using just 5% of the augmented data
led to substantial improvements: 2.6%, 29.2%, 15.1%, and 19.6%. Interestingly,
the extent of improvement varied depending on specific datasets. Moreover, we
found that a varying amount of augmented data (5%-40%) was needed to obtain a
stable improvement. We also compare models trained with GPT-4 augmented data
and those trained with additional student-written responses. The findings
indicate that former ones match or even exceed the performance of the latter.
Specifically, there is an average difference of 1.7%, 1.9%, 11.0%, and 7.8% for
four metrics separately. This research underscores the potential and
effectiveness of data augmentation techniques utilizing GPT-4 in addressing
unbalanced datasets within automated assessment. | [
0.0237888712,
0.0299002249,
-0.0201513208,
-0.0157466456,
-0.0121244267,
0.0116990339,
-0.010537128,
-0.0208015889,
0.0250398088,
-0.0745658353,
-0.0026219878,
-0.0144967856,
-0.0320531763,
0.0555736087,
0.0238870662,
-0.0426070318,
0.0088792397,
0.0040058368,
0.0190853067,
-0.0212756451,
-0.0125894099,
0.0051154993,
-0.023764478,
-0.0086115748,
0.0138305714,
-0.0164078977,
0.0222120043,
-0.0070469747,
0.0333073214,
-0.0302396175,
0.0369450785,
0.1003992558,
0.0041305623,
0.0317924768,
0.0000022363,
-0.0736447126,
-0.0057398211,
-0.001153656,
-0.0255579557,
0.0252006184,
0.0303783435,
0.0316207595,
0.0211819001,
0.0229321364,
-0.0741346776,
-0.0539029613,
0.0266944058,
0.0189317167,
0.0525931418,
0.0300139263,
-0.00545076,
-0.0290491246,
0.044723969,
0.0094870394,
0.0539606772,
0.0284462199,
0.0252586994,
0.0595430061,
0.007994161,
0.0294119529,
-0.0403811596,
0.0136729795,
0.0234464072,
0.0040903101,
0.0732731596,
0.0502604693,
-0.0693057552,
0.0357506089,
0.0152219106,
0.0597724803,
0.0069091949,
-0.0161840487,
-0.0439074673,
-0.0407947116,
0.0279309768,
-0.0045691524,
-0.084762685,
-0.0014168135,
0.0039486201,
-0.0046910248,
0.0091560474,
-0.0103470888,
0.0094724596,
0.0256275013,
0.0094748475,
0.030038042,
0.0280102175,
-0.0516383871,
-0.0185578726,
0.0255076531,
-0.0313867405,
-0.032463558,
0.003342462,
0.0324640311,
-0.0072800526,
0.0185609013,
-0.010291486,
-0.0316056907,
0.0478926264,
0.0221380461,
0.0522679538,
0.0312909856,
-0.0204525702,
0.0185358878,
-0.0223757364,
0.055116754,
0.0613740757,
0.0084413867,
-0.0227161776,
0.0065876869,
-0.0576361455,
-0.0341664851,
0.0080454256,
0.0295093581,
0.0281864759,
0.0541247129,
-0.0837683007,
-0.0179214515,
-0.0367754549,
-0.0225698203,
0.0309272576,
0.0086462656,
-0.0219046809,
0.045542229,
-0.0394405797,
0.0488880537,
-0.0207925495,
0.0029013078,
0.0354461521,
-0.0318051912,
-0.0039944248,
-0.0182661861,
0.0082919681,
-0.0119377943,
0.0290459804,
0.0154292332,
0.0089876521,
-0.0288545638,
0.0029045013,
-0.0184999499,
-0.0106442906,
-0.0593425818,
-0.0098708393,
-0.0652889237,
0.0079780724,
0.0439114124,
-0.0008704938,
0.0162805878,
-0.0006938222,
0.0304698311,
0.0158210509,
0.0381127559,
0.0058884057,
-0.0038714129,
0.029327536,
0.010059014,
0.0014154981,
0.0253322534,
0.0462220758,
-0.0058364919,
0.0180196762,
-0.0555625558,
0.036116235,
0.0098232431,
0.0016675021,
0.0155296307,
0.0326197334,
0.0062745917,
0.010803639,
0.006239234,
-0.0201578643,
0.0194089971,
0.0197752398,
0.0353736244,
0.0582412817,
0.0319920965,
0.0095681371,
0.02898518,
-0.0140556321,
-0.0058490918,
0.0261925664,
0.0402443111,
-0.0447717011,
0.0285738837,
-0.0426872708,
0.0185427889,
0.0364882313,
0.0356216691,
-0.0022255303,
-0.0754879415,
-0.0277188998,
0.022297604,
0.0143534187,
0.0393231399,
0.0634120628,
-0.0261120982,
-0.0082909511,
-0.0112339444,
0.018068064,
-0.0817845017,
0.0662480518,
-0.0369855389,
0.0332025774,
0.0559093356,
0.0627191439,
-0.0534212291,
-0.0280163027,
-0.0280265603,
-0.008522748,
0.0103942528,
0.0460296758,
-0.0180347916,
-0.0349314399,
-0.0472385399,
-0.0485897548,
0.0031518443,
0.0141824251,
0.0156225665,
0.0047068815,
0.0055354289,
0.0128900977,
-0.0268084221,
-0.0849976912,
0.0213077683,
-0.0224784836,
-0.0622882023,
0.0176596567,
-0.0560612828,
0.0119386334,
0.0387988463,
0.0005062815,
0.0083624404,
0.0188101884,
0.0112024089,
-0.0299907792,
-0.070869714,
-0.0440529026,
0.0169338938,
0.0660018921,
-0.0198151805,
-0.0181501471,
0.0465545096,
-0.0486990735,
-0.0599381998,
0.0004324054,
-0.0246332157,
-0.0407680497,
-0.0291877426,
0.0096984971,
-0.0161376875,
-0.0217056237,
-0.0573561564,
0.0515099317,
0.0428253673,
0.0657353178,
-0.0640364438,
-0.0148339374,
0.0423748866,
-0.0207020659,
-0.0303639062,
-0.0187762696,
0.0067216256,
0.0333327875,
0.034582004,
-0.0252678487,
-0.0788296387,
0.0175651852,
-0.0882055163,
0.0199838392,
0.0095393006,
0.0082810232,
0.0184690207,
0.0006471311,
-0.015874682,
0.0248043723,
-0.0627279654,
-0.0377287865,
0.0438244678,
0.0153410872,
0.0177915953,
0.0064900136,
0.0336600728,
-0.0327919573,
-0.0239187405,
-0.0709027871,
-0.0102168471,
0.0892065987,
0.0303409901,
-0.0228970535,
0.0265524834,
-0.0279283728,
-0.0015643084,
0.0182080884,
-0.0302902423,
0.0065759406,
-0.0002885502,
0.0567908287,
0.0532275848,
0.0193123557,
-0.0186684448,
0.0521491319,
-0.0023296434,
-0.0467975922,
0.0033356966,
-0.0254879761,
-0.0130868461,
0.0169938225,
-0.0534504801,
-0.0104966192,
0.0339110047,
0.0144637302,
-0.0682341456,
-0.0259908456,
0.028266741,
-0.0531534255,
-0.0003292184,
-0.0548515134,
-0.01326878,
-0.0157406628,
0.0148259085,
-0.0076210797,
-0.0371122062,
0.0848075151,
0.0070968894,
0.0065452256,
-0.0825875029,
0.0314402469,
-0.0104826894,
0.023665905,
0.033104647,
-0.027729122,
-0.0417603068,
0.0362181365,
-0.0557235628,
-0.0122683775,
0.0319602527,
-0.0606952459,
0.063894026,
-0.0415487327,
-0.0440854505,
-0.0170053598,
-0.0062298956,
-0.038633775,
0.0005388389,
0.0282909144,
0.031857308,
-0.014896756,
-0.0277094636,
-0.0232913792,
-0.0378320813,
0.0163724087,
0.0372009315,
-0.0709633008,
-0.0169186946,
-0.0000479514,
0.0165460501,
0.0412231795,
-0.0332514681,
0.011402146,
-0.0420019552,
-0.0047627166,
0.0231008604,
0.0432670526,
-0.0108529534,
0.0255143661,
0.0072703739,
0.0317336135,
-0.0490666553,
0.0141650615,
0.0132628772,
0.0273959674,
-0.0650170073,
0.0244743247,
0.1097543165,
0.0311508309,
-0.0249047596,
-0.020993555,
-0.0378315225,
0.0114576705,
0.0204273239,
0.040053241,
-0.0687694699,
0.0032653413,
-0.0265093949,
0.0590691604,
-0.043858882,
-0.0395729728,
0.0200717747,
-0.1368436366,
0.0298380926,
0.0175829176,
-0.0332338512,
-0.0410795175,
-0.0436612628,
-0.0149555989,
-0.0238191262,
-0.0035757036,
-0.0135393152,
0.0149581702,
0.0517552085,
0.0374614,
-0.0100295497,
-0.0601610392,
0.0303191561,
-0.0211307313,
0.05130044,
0.0458649099,
0.0285618864,
-0.0510476641,
-0.0340249129,
0.0308632907,
-0.0259633586,
-0.0295678303,
0.0098634977,
0.0573680103,
-0.0112844957,
0.0375009328,
-0.0328858979,
0.0485845581,
0.0032073148,
0.0036488639,
0.0526810549,
0.0982875675,
0.0265779961,
-0.0001918706,
-0.0470781326,
-0.0322558731,
0.0007548789,
0.0803515017,
0.0334377177,
-0.0413210988,
0.0209713504,
-0.0694368258,
0.0280876625,
-0.0508231148,
-0.0079139248,
0.0410466008,
-0.038741421,
-0.0204223357,
-0.0185075551,
-0.0836569741,
0.0502329133,
-0.0260701161,
0.0148651525,
0.038598951,
-0.0598197505,
0.0021586267,
-0.0535339974,
0.0386693105,
-0.0233608466,
-0.0064249635,
-0.017373668,
-0.0591017716,
0.0081260763,
-0.035448771,
-0.0393924229,
0.005663191,
-0.0317924134,
-0.0317651518,
0.0361200795,
0.0715392232,
0.0167563073,
-0.0133365802,
0.0146107432,
-0.0328345634,
0.0249533784,
0.0348223671,
-0.0320634171,
-0.0054316861,
-0.0356499106,
-0.0325708464,
0.0005502616,
-0.037471246,
-0.0175713468,
0.0262683071,
0.0482162125,
0.0498275384,
0.0036743251,
-0.0157434251,
0.0356585868,
0.0704137236,
0.0807395056,
-0.0142044602,
-0.0299094599,
-0.0171353519,
0.0072660544,
-0.0216106251,
-0.0236932598,
0.0023155038,
-0.0224045124,
0.0464909934,
-0.0051998748,
-0.0375283957,
-0.0028724698,
-0.0722626448,
0.0640671775,
-0.0569885634,
0.0450642966,
0.007517755,
0.0232534353,
0.0194130111,
-0.021424707,
-0.0395047143,
-0.0306396056,
0.02675814,
0.0331664123,
0.0028406803,
0.0588729307,
0.0082344664,
0.0130271493,
0.0375836156,
0.0134266103,
-0.0651395172,
0.0424050242,
-0.0538940355,
0.0002057322,
-0.0109581426,
0.0122589413,
0.0276727974,
-0.0105386227,
-0.0067425538,
-0.050671123,
-0.0122708231,
0.0251315758,
0.0033391519,
0.0214571524,
0.0301426891,
0.0141036566,
-0.0160052013,
0.0352017581,
-0.0259239916,
0.0475000553,
-0.0217332151,
-0.015934471,
-0.0235743579,
0.0074201161,
0.0246048365,
0.0181717724,
0.0007076308,
0.0027508312,
-0.0667578056,
-0.0522781275,
0.0085345116,
0.0579124764,
0.046494849,
-0.017891638,
0.0010401296,
0.0299545061,
-0.0936855376,
-0.0261288453,
-0.0281270389,
0.05048915,
-0.0473415889,
-0.0313909948,
-0.0067565078,
-6.059063958e-33,
-0.03050863,
-0.0274629258,
0.0122886859,
0.0323751532,
-0.0013182675,
-0.0039666374,
-0.000460675,
0.0120217176,
0.0026241702,
0.010672125,
-0.0102972202,
0.0104624163,
0.0051099057,
0.0518378243,
0.0358227342,
-0.0088103218,
0.0229046233,
0.0070027481,
-0.0424930193,
0.0324584171,
-0.0111613581,
-0.0047235391,
0.0733071193,
-0.043780826,
0.0593191646,
-0.0486310422,
0.0087371897,
-0.0246295054,
-0.0642153919,
0.0384222008,
-0.015967831,
0.0936058909,
0.0297424011,
-0.0330761708,
-0.0030689649,
0.0117320158,
-0.0383864902,
-0.0369683243,
0.0190704707,
-0.010180952,
0.0111824656,
-0.030636562,
0.0142869623,
-0.0000785957,
-0.0575417913,
-0.0606347136,
0.0761648566,
-0.0453689098,
0.004985197,
-0.0403966606,
-0.0295295008,
0.0071572755,
-0.0079616793,
0.0208911151,
-0.0463404283,
0.0777802095,
0.0173062701,
0.0431009531,
-0.0300506335,
0.0340780281,
0.0651330575,
0.0381329246,
0.0427626558,
0.0429577753,
-0.005534342,
0.0518149808,
0.039489802,
0.0090879099,
-0.015307324,
-0.050996162,
0.0227475148,
-0.0834493712,
0.1201081648,
0.0874519199,
0.0615742095,
0.0036608127,
-0.0588526316,
0.0686147287,
-0.000337866,
-0.0205465648,
0.0074349106,
-0.0248346757,
-0.0292955004,
-0.0298499316,
-0.061693199,
-0.0178264268,
-0.0399314016,
-0.0290843043,
0.0332017168,
-0.0487288646,
-0.0325438604,
0.0108564952,
0.0183228943,
-0.0189278405,
-0.0452728458,
-0.0014952522,
0.0038540568,
0.0315028876,
-0.0182291418,
0.0016854478,
-0.0172903147,
0.0403700434,
0.0274121203,
0.0065728594,
0.0041429237,
0.00705784,
0.039529074,
0.0071330606,
-0.0300642289,
-0.0157967471,
-0.0170454849,
-0.0125439251,
0.0330302566,
0.0296326652,
0.005912533,
0.0448273979,
0.0186776947,
0.034574803,
0.019863762,
-0.0124314651,
-0.0384723954,
-0.0364812724,
-0.0222114325,
-0.0186403859,
0.0038263465,
-0.0006937404,
0.0165954307,
-0.0160282012,
-0.010570663,
-0.0212148447,
0.0099373693,
-0.015327163,
2.651e-7,
0.0694117248,
0.0462133512,
-0.0093895094,
-0.0413246751,
-0.0318866298,
0.0111209666,
-0.0225355588,
-0.0042656967,
0.1010047719,
0.0135461455,
-0.0098112943,
0.0124447094,
0.0130896829,
0.0284765717,
-0.0658880919,
-0.0097424071,
-0.0066417726,
-0.0250507407,
-0.0166923068,
0.0393126272,
0.0871938765,
0.0432877615,
0.0378332883,
-0.0256090052,
-0.0116775502,
-0.0110015133,
0.026479274,
-0.0328863375,
-0.0344909318,
0.0322736092,
0.0228993371,
-0.0004226363,
0.0212712344,
0.0807318315,
-0.0441080444,
-0.0129816979,
0.0120797409,
0.0017397203,
-0.0190743934,
0.0062196273,
0.0078963498,
0.0221916083,
0.0056238109,
-0.0864318088,
0.0318788402,
-0.0427353755,
-0.0140688317,
0.0249881428,
-0.0707810745,
-0.0252865814,
0.0311138872,
-0.0243209917,
-0.0245259665,
0.0035327971,
0.0092258658,
0.0064409771,
-0.0001320003,
-0.0218492821,
-0.0271611698,
0.01697037,
-0.0208063759,
-0.0727939382,
-0.019517893,
-0.0340181813,
-0.0082807979,
-0.0792998448,
-0.0204176195,
2.547903061e-34,
0.0504264906,
-0.0065866518,
0.0399069265,
-0.0475162379,
0.006553255,
0.0121883396,
0.029228799,
0.0200652871,
0.0269915257,
-0.0568062253,
-0.0349466056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16271v1 | CycleAlign: Iterative Distillation from Black-box LLM to White-box Models for Better Human Alignment | 2023-10-25T01:05:03 | 2023-10-25T01:05:03 | Jixiang Hong, Quan Tu, Changyu Chen, Xing Gao, Ji Zhang, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models trained on large-scale corpus often generate content that is
harmful, toxic, or contrary to human preferences, making their alignment with
human values a critical concern. Reinforcement learning from human feedback
(RLHF) with algorithms like PPO is a prevalent approach for alignment but is
often complex, unstable, and resource-intensive. Recently, ranking-based
alignment methods have emerged, offering stability and effectiveness by
replacing the RL framework with supervised fine-tuning, but they are costly due
to the need for annotated data. Considering that existing large language models
(LLMs) like ChatGPT are already relatively well-aligned and cost-friendly,
researchers have begun to align the language model with human preference from
AI feedback. The common practices, which unidirectionally distill the
instruction-following responses from LLMs, are constrained by their bottleneck.
Thus we introduce CycleAlign to distill alignment capabilities from
parameter-invisible LLMs (black-box) to a parameter-visible model (white-box)
in an iterative manner. With in-context learning (ICL) as the core of the
cycle, the black-box models are able to rank the model-generated responses
guided by human-craft instruction and demonstrations about their preferences.
During iterative interaction, the white-box models also have a judgment about
responses generated by them. Consequently, the agreement ranking could be
viewed as a pseudo label to dynamically update the in-context demonstrations
and improve the preference ranking ability of black-box models. Through
multiple interactions, the CycleAlign framework could align the white-box model
with the black-box model effectively in a low-resource way. Empirical results
illustrate that the model fine-tuned by CycleAlign remarkably exceeds existing
methods, and achieves the state-of-the-art performance in alignment with human
value. | [
0.0527261384,
0.0466122031,
-0.0010546435,
0.0131656071,
-0.0445312448,
0.0381815843,
-0.0255755652,
-0.0360164121,
0.024331253,
-0.0371283367,
-0.0875684023,
-0.0211838689,
-0.0027484058,
0.000048491,
0.0026263783,
-0.0596024543,
0.0656016245,
0.0080931149,
0.0019981295,
0.0048928163,
0.0374248587,
0.0196526013,
-0.0297919214,
0.0342077501,
0.0376869962,
-0.0136359017,
-0.027319571,
0.0005036063,
0.0817779452,
-0.0272744056,
0.0175624602,
0.0492627211,
0.0171174314,
0.0392883047,
0.0000020721,
-0.0481042527,
-0.0052784691,
-0.0131178768,
-0.0195128638,
-0.0096758548,
0.0517689064,
0.0556163564,
-0.0291448217,
0.0124507835,
-0.0421155132,
0.0371490531,
0.0625408739,
0.0395122096,
0.0790804625,
0.0758451074,
0.0162056386,
0.0097703375,
-0.0077900644,
-0.0365033522,
-0.0299667828,
-0.0223226156,
0.0097330948,
-0.0230674911,
0.0204897001,
0.0130159138,
-0.0321328305,
0.0155614289,
0.0242505893,
-0.0133172143,
0.0063637821,
0.01017405,
-0.045334965,
-0.0305912457,
-0.0079321647,
0.1018961444,
-0.0100145284,
-0.0210180804,
-0.0148007665,
-0.0121851368,
0.0280820969,
-0.0145741403,
-0.0124024861,
-0.0110868867,
0.0077131283,
0.0261100866,
0.0131146805,
-0.0162834805,
0.014248495,
0.027547095,
0.0266958401,
0.0771817639,
-0.0233107656,
-0.0501128621,
0.0354765579,
-0.0057062521,
-0.0155261634,
-0.0610246845,
-0.0114390319,
0.0062118825,
-0.0626533106,
0.0306229629,
-0.0263818074,
0.0410852246,
0.0248018317,
-0.0501191504,
0.0175884031,
0.0480359457,
0.0053915149,
0.049416054,
0.0268597994,
0.058798071,
-0.0331896767,
0.045459114,
-0.0631868243,
0.0564295016,
-0.0299815871,
-0.0220823251,
-0.0087243747,
0.0136465002,
-0.0071037086,
-0.0178096686,
-0.0776946247,
0.0178456753,
-0.0466139801,
0.0392615721,
0.0084117325,
0.0185748823,
-0.0331906788,
-0.019770341,
-0.0327072367,
0.0562833995,
-0.0051560104,
0.0279021822,
0.0144386897,
-0.0276312772,
0.0036460801,
0.0139817996,
-0.0348544195,
-0.0160681903,
0.0000965859,
0.0666290298,
-0.026440572,
0.0001043161,
-0.0026374841,
-0.0091144545,
-0.0338703766,
-0.0753541365,
-0.0333746336,
-0.04383469,
0.0237836372,
-0.004540585,
-0.0133841857,
-0.0496498495,
0.0096728103,
0.010556153,
-0.0119661679,
0.0710819364,
0.0310103148,
-0.0159839336,
0.0016888424,
-0.0113075543,
-0.0069278888,
0.0528761409,
0.0503762178,
0.0461514443,
-0.0147312516,
-0.0256460402,
-0.0378273986,
0.0396685116,
0.0128521528,
0.0086038429,
-0.0339586437,
-0.0034018436,
-0.0003064634,
0.0549599454,
0.0485223308,
0.0247976799,
-0.0158056524,
-0.0046820459,
0.086449258,
0.0055400128,
-0.0100481538,
-0.0130047426,
0.007797298,
0.0452799425,
-0.0169773549,
0.0175987985,
-0.0531675406,
0.0278645325,
-0.0186775085,
0.0095980335,
0.0458117314,
0.0265168063,
-0.0045894473,
-0.0563713387,
0.0178087391,
0.000786082,
0.0597253628,
0.0245345365,
0.0389501825,
0.0021291834,
-0.0568125099,
-0.0076124095,
0.0727682263,
-0.0219906513,
-0.0203057528,
-0.0343609415,
0.0545404889,
0.0688449815,
0.0387081243,
-0.0069244727,
-0.0422613434,
-0.0343042016,
-0.0169509202,
0.0556081571,
0.0258599631,
-0.0243980885,
-0.0372760743,
-0.0206380915,
-0.0807224736,
0.0137600256,
-0.0310075376,
0.0301037431,
0.0159424841,
-0.0420816205,
-0.0360573828,
0.0143236909,
-0.0601664744,
0.0244408809,
0.0137520991,
-0.0235950146,
-0.0271120537,
0.0193230864,
0.0880169943,
0.017714303,
0.0051301359,
-0.0070486027,
0.0335828327,
-0.0057524373,
0.0085356552,
0.0259708632,
-0.0542799197,
-0.0182326026,
0.043507427,
-0.0202767812,
-0.0423407294,
0.0400210805,
-0.0599520802,
-0.027225744,
-0.0157088879,
-0.0181584638,
0.0219171327,
0.0045855353,
0.0086782929,
-0.0193720218,
-0.018435644,
-0.0822174251,
0.035287682,
-0.0182797592,
0.0056420788,
-0.0075386832,
0.0065382519,
-0.0222252905,
-0.0362953283,
-0.0112302816,
0.0171539709,
0.0192572717,
0.0298542082,
0.0405931361,
0.0311071537,
-0.0592722036,
-0.0153758274,
-0.0769587755,
-0.0071060713,
-0.0141791273,
0.0121302772,
0.0290255342,
-0.0201604795,
-0.0129027925,
-0.0217767395,
-0.0283716302,
-0.0038778165,
-0.0089783501,
0.0155086862,
0.0339494124,
0.0056281798,
-0.0277036224,
-0.0608211569,
0.0120685091,
-0.0006448071,
-0.0077392915,
0.0301867314,
0.0160394646,
-0.067976363,
0.0292693451,
-0.0280086435,
0.0177850965,
-0.0109246355,
-0.0496974289,
0.0302764643,
0.0396971218,
0.0290803872,
0.1036454812,
0.0325880125,
0.022789659,
0.0425524227,
0.0420786142,
-0.1005345881,
0.0119738569,
-0.0298121516,
-0.0613524206,
-0.047057122,
-0.0123285679,
0.0232747458,
0.0890017003,
-0.0081959069,
0.0178381391,
-0.0682645738,
-0.0062359334,
0.0136203859,
-0.0279364064,
-0.0209493656,
-0.0484050997,
-0.0624669157,
0.0169299655,
-0.0318871662,
-0.0617151819,
0.0886804089,
0.0117316609,
0.0093722036,
-0.0358373076,
0.0032431695,
-0.0079032844,
-0.0149915619,
0.0235804301,
0.0412681513,
-0.0019013447,
-0.0108245807,
-0.0743243173,
-0.0146243563,
0.0414077863,
-0.0587429665,
0.0161136165,
-0.0196570884,
0.0119863143,
-0.0087463865,
-0.0726486519,
-0.0668145344,
-0.0062727951,
-0.0218556169,
-0.0212245379,
0.0056434455,
-0.015657343,
-0.0252393931,
-0.0039696256,
0.0482422523,
-0.0069411867,
0.0049607898,
0.0050979452,
-0.0130302487,
0.0078588398,
0.0864758939,
0.0151664177,
0.0035822277,
-0.0085655041,
-0.0074114455,
0.0479491651,
0.0513562709,
0.0231366958,
-0.0065613766,
-0.0017225452,
0.0444269665,
-0.0196795221,
0.0042319959,
0.0294526201,
0.0262007639,
-0.0195461735,
-0.0096275853,
0.0889692083,
0.0204342231,
-0.0810703039,
0.0120175192,
0.0008264408,
0.0643848777,
0.0073057516,
0.0344817042,
-0.0463121347,
-0.0115140211,
-0.0064683906,
0.0407351181,
-0.0080182645,
0.0026345435,
0.006003472,
-0.1483435184,
-0.0008940854,
0.0359374098,
-0.0623407364,
-0.0229104534,
-0.0206168275,
0.0253105108,
-0.0524332747,
0.0490452833,
0.0394722521,
0.0010887063,
-0.0144159133,
0.0290486962,
0.0230432115,
-0.0379669107,
0.0143704116,
-0.0295411777,
0.0656632185,
0.0927568898,
0.0130229415,
-0.0102979373,
-0.0291381329,
0.0394695103,
0.0333748497,
-0.016474219,
0.0042870203,
0.0025145682,
-0.0369690768,
0.0011560759,
-0.0295489095,
0.0648747757,
-0.0018086596,
-0.0126867127,
-0.033283174,
0.063067615,
0.006038799,
0.0393610187,
0.0002156563,
0.0201356616,
0.0241312645,
0.0540068969,
0.0086671812,
-0.1016119495,
-0.0170446951,
-0.0319890901,
-0.0055552488,
-0.0277516041,
-0.0338748842,
0.0068178745,
-0.0246251207,
0.021711845,
-0.0741740391,
-0.0314468518,
-0.017471008,
0.0263955612,
0.007951133,
-0.0136128003,
0.0377719738,
-0.019905962,
-0.001373836,
0.0432555936,
-0.0048792441,
0.0139853181,
-0.0728307962,
-0.0191038307,
0.0021346097,
-0.0524955243,
-0.0332325995,
-0.0059457794,
-0.0340360366,
-0.0873699486,
0.0259119794,
0.0531537198,
0.0125599885,
0.0875062644,
0.0293339957,
-0.0389228277,
0.0019061023,
0.0470403545,
0.0109113837,
-0.0008001042,
0.0087337866,
0.061073564,
-0.0314378031,
0.0217652209,
-0.0356036872,
0.0047490383,
0.0433471724,
0.0160818491,
-0.0657205209,
-0.0436430871,
0.0567250326,
-0.0125335706,
0.0260663684,
-0.0449557751,
-0.0180389881,
-0.0284339506,
0.0136304982,
0.0183517598,
-0.0527230799,
-0.0273683406,
-0.022875363,
0.0234244522,
-0.0500678383,
0.0071076034,
-0.0197873916,
0.0012729059,
0.0329136327,
-0.0280989781,
-0.0066150911,
-0.0011655096,
0.0084899487,
0.0122408587,
0.0273310877,
-0.0085413717,
0.0238051694,
0.0113591338,
0.0621387064,
0.0155837433,
0.1058734804,
0.0658136532,
0.0033702219,
0.0036931941,
0.0541845411,
-0.0108500365,
-0.0058487067,
-0.0545757487,
-0.0212600529,
0.0170542728,
0.0042546457,
0.0642491058,
-0.0168230291,
-0.0137599194,
-0.0100215767,
0.0238229297,
-0.062985532,
-0.0056343335,
0.0347797871,
0.0385767892,
-0.0080817286,
0.0291292872,
0.0403034203,
-0.016851671,
0.0088773826,
-0.0380577482,
0.014868102,
-0.0511513911,
-0.0150063271,
0.0128056537,
0.0147222774,
-0.0234211069,
0.0131650502,
-0.0418413579,
-0.0321085416,
-0.033155255,
0.0328370556,
-0.014419632,
-0.032405071,
0.0494101532,
0.038373366,
-0.0429055616,
-0.0091185905,
-0.0313988589,
-0.0146845039,
-0.0060372222,
-0.0226822533,
-0.0582626872,
-6.594524043e-33,
-0.0574274063,
-0.0426430851,
-0.0015390179,
0.0107925944,
-0.0454872921,
-0.0496054031,
0.0244696885,
0.0229352806,
0.0052715386,
0.0318971761,
0.0148504768,
-0.0258041788,
0.0054163048,
0.0078576477,
0.0328379385,
-0.0215401482,
0.0148802316,
-0.0095933452,
-0.0600367785,
0.0209246539,
0.0278998576,
0.0065062502,
0.0483221672,
-0.0846641958,
0.0357768312,
0.0073371739,
-0.0251311418,
0.0047992063,
-0.0502059832,
0.0610293001,
-0.0014516837,
0.0152944922,
0.004557136,
-0.0228469316,
0.0165289361,
0.0555324033,
-0.0469185561,
-0.0071724062,
0.0261932462,
0.0099219624,
-0.0397061892,
-0.0060873805,
0.0599851385,
-0.0071915942,
-0.047913231,
0.0046116263,
0.0142781073,
-0.0396635048,
-0.0088218581,
0.0204459168,
-0.0744113326,
0.0086593097,
-0.0286032241,
-0.0427289195,
-0.024814643,
0.0820038244,
-0.0271269809,
0.0527726002,
-0.0745283365,
0.0404254273,
-0.0059455698,
0.0064787692,
0.0892802477,
0.0354765244,
0.0075044939,
0.049250789,
-0.0078333644,
-0.0079076663,
0.018825233,
-0.0105247535,
0.0030281106,
0.033180289,
0.026081983,
0.0578506775,
0.018854795,
0.0424527191,
-0.0184190292,
0.0264043864,
0.0018659572,
0.04344365,
0.0206720736,
0.0385390893,
-0.0726283565,
-0.0147555908,
-0.0230193306,
-0.0425980464,
-0.0061569274,
-0.0425873511,
0.0209956542,
0.0181474891,
-0.0239603017,
-0.0287752207,
0.0047456198,
-0.027812466,
-0.0154332966,
0.0033119491,
-0.0235185176,
0.022618223,
0.0089621125,
-0.0092900535,
-0.0915140808,
-0.0130467312,
-0.0103346063,
-0.0117508732,
0.0110263005,
0.0049751829,
0.0494922213,
0.0232429933,
-0.0694513693,
0.0291903391,
-0.0097141154,
0.0157730766,
-0.009955327,
-0.0480132438,
0.0677171275,
-0.0110087208,
-0.0257434044,
0.0775773674,
0.0280291587,
-0.0286426004,
-0.0281632002,
-0.0353731066,
-0.0446039811,
0.0060567688,
-0.0147396028,
0.0184182916,
0.0244132485,
0.0251951851,
-0.001143808,
-0.0485402793,
-0.0162000954,
0.0151596647,
2.896e-7,
0.027782673,
0.03726165,
0.025978433,
0.0112510696,
0.0075882939,
0.0602883436,
-0.0139747933,
0.0332450382,
0.0342867374,
-0.007004742,
0.0481164753,
0.0141068036,
0.0600190461,
-0.0300664566,
-0.041603893,
-0.0078934012,
-0.0989239439,
0.0109986346,
-0.0337508991,
0.0035965322,
0.0476348139,
0.0788802877,
0.0123445587,
-0.0137687577,
0.012729805,
0.0175873339,
0.0725911781,
-0.0514697805,
-0.0128841018,
0.0138183916,
0.0000179167,
-0.037289571,
-0.0334456936,
-0.0031448412,
0.0190425199,
0.0357508957,
-0.0301366393,
0.0521080866,
-0.0199694335,
-0.0372582935,
-0.0174873192,
0.0257705078,
0.0005475748,
-0.0768883601,
0.0436883979,
-0.0947806761,
-0.0337752774,
-0.0565533377,
-0.0280099269,
-0.0118819447,
0.020462675,
-0.0165069252,
-0.022754889,
0.0070539881,
0.0165774748,
0.0093542188,
-0.0335578807,
-0.0497496426,
-0.0337550156,
0.020030586,
-0.0532708168,
-0.0313672535,
0.0001759575,
0.0274617113,
-0.017290201,
-0.0402491242,
-0.0084478026,
2.556672203e-34,
0.0064156936,
-0.0525801145,
0.0450759791,
0.0418166965,
0.003527865,
0.0307019185,
-0.0002235481,
0.0247040652,
0.0544027872,
-0.0586222447,
-0.0006617047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16270v1 | Attention Lens: A Tool for Mechanistically Interpreting the Attention Head Information Retrieval Mechanism | 2023-10-25T01:03:35 | 2023-10-25T01:03:35 | Mansi Sakarvadia, Arham Khan, Aswathy Ajith, Daniel Grzenda, Nathaniel Hudson, André Bauer, Kyle Chard, Ian Foster | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs) are the state-of-the-art for
natural language tasks. Recent work has attempted to decode, by reverse
engineering the role of linear layers, the internal mechanisms by which LLMs
arrive at their final predictions for text completion tasks. Yet little is
known about the specific role of attention heads in producing the final token
prediction. We propose Attention Lens, a tool that enables researchers to
translate the outputs of attention heads into vocabulary tokens via learned
attention-head-specific transformations called lenses. Preliminary findings
from our trained lenses indicate that attention heads play highly specialized
roles in language models. The code for Attention Lens is available at
github.com/msakarvadia/AttentionLens. | [
0.045719035,
-0.0021526075,
-0.0176925529,
0.0211118646,
0.0109520853,
0.0027063126,
-0.0390555896,
-0.0033461042,
0.0282545164,
-0.0112926019,
-0.0396829508,
-0.0054874364,
0.0031594271,
0.0120477593,
0.0285565965,
-0.0251894314,
0.0385161117,
-0.0189433079,
-0.0509521626,
0.0388095975,
-0.0125064077,
0.0158447828,
0.0556116812,
0.0599167831,
0.0356675386,
0.003230249,
0.0108070588,
0.0149890073,
-0.0162995979,
0.0568041131,
0.0176196303,
0.0295868032,
-0.0027808214,
0.0436518826,
0.0000019124,
-0.0126636783,
-0.006687453,
-0.021055229,
-0.004424464,
0.0216847155,
0.0226363763,
-0.0302356072,
0.0164008196,
0.0044735433,
0.0065292795,
-0.0069012698,
0.0432855822,
0.0505488142,
0.0128211463,
0.0300378166,
0.0115877548,
-0.0328954943,
0.0495425239,
-0.041760087,
0.0915820375,
-0.044153329,
0.0390220471,
-0.0224691331,
-0.0107789692,
0.0442777537,
-0.0234180689,
0.0520323664,
0.0027473706,
0.0067308294,
0.0672667548,
0.0379178077,
-0.0056408574,
-0.0417565405,
0.0134065179,
0.0359191,
-0.0215655752,
-0.0555923618,
-0.0168576408,
0.0107169058,
0.0029186548,
0.0474169888,
-0.06041684,
0.0376291424,
-0.0083363187,
0.0132863317,
0.0080888709,
-0.0410819724,
0.0213862676,
-0.0201826729,
-0.0797171965,
0.0459249429,
0.0113838278,
-0.0136416545,
-0.00328368,
-0.0186889432,
-0.0104857115,
-0.0289183576,
0.0326491483,
0.0348649286,
0.0034298943,
0.0047055306,
0.0091206646,
-0.032752689,
0.0213531181,
-0.0533122756,
0.0115111135,
0.0438404009,
-0.0377977155,
0.0428215936,
-0.0444297157,
0.0159555003,
-0.0490979739,
0.0088107986,
-0.0526757538,
-0.0348494016,
-0.0120671727,
-0.0359925628,
-0.0395324491,
0.0084400084,
-0.0255294535,
-0.0622534193,
0.0161055643,
0.0269863904,
0.0275046825,
-0.0318056233,
0.0115794549,
0.0161584374,
-0.034004122,
-0.0181094147,
-0.0255593304,
0.0659477562,
-0.0096522002,
-0.006333007,
-0.0114671914,
0.0066242521,
-0.0352575667,
0.0246944111,
-0.0037857685,
-0.0484008826,
0.00531008,
0.0468468852,
-0.0114510506,
-0.0503225029,
-0.0224708281,
-0.0024790792,
-0.0237079412,
-0.0219309777,
0.0203750264,
-0.0342589878,
0.028529929,
0.0387145802,
-0.004526631,
-0.0060816822,
0.0242598001,
0.0701657608,
-0.0680573806,
0.0297510363,
0.0206387714,
0.0341370553,
0.0343174711,
0.0020754491,
0.0018380124,
0.0467253402,
-0.0088364007,
0.0715881586,
0.0185533091,
-0.0675313398,
0.0041828947,
0.0348019712,
0.019047359,
-0.0096331462,
-0.0449313074,
0.0109599829,
0.0100742802,
0.0053411,
0.0374248661,
0.037694972,
-0.0316168182,
-0.0225475784,
0.0672437027,
0.0434304513,
0.0376146547,
0.0252994243,
0.0141860312,
-0.0098248282,
-0.0151769444,
0.0376034714,
-0.0576470196,
0.0578274727,
-0.0523470119,
0.0067561022,
0.0291627403,
0.0241962932,
-0.0161359049,
-0.0260549057,
0.0081673861,
0.0088120336,
-0.0106676854,
0.0148187,
0.0697656497,
0.0269429032,
-0.0487533621,
0.0699400902,
0.026710283,
-0.0283162482,
0.0212314595,
-0.0458714589,
0.0238260254,
0.0396951884,
0.0488702878,
-0.0200042073,
-0.0136273084,
0.0028212238,
0.0161538906,
0.0475259013,
-0.0026347549,
0.0210380014,
-0.037650682,
-0.0462068357,
0.0134701412,
0.0040473333,
0.0130254934,
-0.017931018,
0.0003840024,
-0.0251961835,
0.0447845459,
-0.0581042357,
-0.0435703397,
0.0448904671,
-0.0245826989,
-0.0356243216,
-0.0130582983,
0.0017952202,
-0.0251264814,
-0.0175815653,
0.0144460481,
0.048166167,
0.0606461875,
-0.0250162836,
0.00874044,
-0.0147753684,
0.0016740706,
0.0304687861,
0.0015895679,
-0.0489721783,
0.0147286002,
0.0481340252,
0.0299759991,
-0.0319073573,
0.0374684632,
-0.0461135916,
0.0702987388,
-0.0160017796,
0.0358978882,
0.0082883164,
0.0403928868,
-0.0640131757,
0.0609945394,
-0.0088234358,
0.0261106007,
0.0126732979,
-0.0171568226,
-0.0261826031,
0.011383458,
-0.0029316749,
0.0015976494,
0.0042948234,
-0.0222109631,
0.031800922,
-0.0602910891,
-0.0287904628,
-0.062287461,
-0.0630530491,
-0.0047820378,
-0.0147869447,
-0.0191895198,
0.0202716682,
0.0248479657,
0.0165997427,
-0.0073032933,
0.0203588679,
0.0400160216,
-0.0236183088,
-0.0010999264,
0.0148346722,
-0.0237959698,
-0.0077527352,
-0.0629873425,
-0.0526413769,
-0.0310401376,
0.0705245212,
0.0056872936,
-0.0498126559,
-0.0604853071,
0.001307294,
0.0100686522,
0.0115475459,
-0.0394642502,
-0.0155744571,
0.0154206362,
-0.0533580258,
0.0619368665,
0.1117569357,
0.0566082858,
0.0069521633,
0.0408517905,
-0.0010806695,
-0.051774662,
0.0147323329,
-0.0422132351,
-0.0360355303,
-0.0425684489,
-0.0422384292,
0.039123904,
0.0780924782,
0.0219197813,
-0.0009176441,
-0.0679857358,
-0.0133995758,
0.0167502295,
-0.0048052827,
-0.0106385602,
0.0268399119,
-0.0457960777,
0.0431142785,
-0.0301588774,
-0.0514905266,
0.0486594364,
-0.0262735337,
-0.0365887955,
0.0039183483,
0.025088869,
-0.0558398776,
0.0592940934,
0.0429085121,
0.0139570031,
0.0134064276,
-0.0499209762,
-0.0195559226,
0.0367776901,
-0.0212052073,
-0.0248440485,
0.0902002081,
0.0422419719,
-0.0170027632,
0.0030075847,
0.0168708023,
-0.012890555,
-0.0195324291,
-0.0193621907,
-0.0110268975,
0.0231472924,
-0.0091506885,
-0.1011711061,
0.0054171332,
0.0665440559,
0.0208762884,
-0.0180315655,
-0.0242356956,
-0.032946296,
-0.0033784043,
0.068506293,
-0.008243395,
0.0191798005,
-0.0244358946,
-0.0065769181,
0.059766978,
0.0273467489,
0.0187303163,
0.004376512,
-0.0469363444,
0.0870145485,
-0.0537356623,
-0.0162727553,
0.0026133044,
0.0164965317,
-0.0749266967,
-0.0282754842,
0.1084785759,
0.0308807716,
-0.0999283716,
-0.0015853427,
-0.0438337587,
0.0062538031,
0.0493933633,
0.0312274564,
-0.0534383021,
-0.038513504,
0.003903026,
0.0347592421,
0.0502719507,
0.0000428009,
0.027231602,
-0.086864315,
0.0568739958,
0.0009195922,
-0.0231518988,
-0.0451147147,
-0.0517861247,
0.0264438055,
-0.007077673,
-0.0150038106,
0.0512531474,
-0.0344732143,
-0.0109917,
-0.0030078047,
0.020378964,
0.0223061647,
0.0243491232,
-0.0289754402,
0.0121685807,
0.0805315673,
-0.0013258922,
-0.0287254639,
-0.0618357137,
0.0130366152,
-0.0318783484,
0.0198628604,
-0.0062556956,
0.044775404,
-0.035047207,
0.0105628287,
-0.0247674007,
0.0152827855,
-0.0211411696,
-0.0239791889,
0.0066886321,
0.0930131227,
0.0025069204,
-0.0288501661,
-0.0369762778,
-0.003815009,
-0.0306042023,
0.0746697709,
0.0490286686,
-0.0601151809,
-0.0106246211,
-0.0261205789,
0.0173292067,
-0.0156942122,
-0.0785131827,
0.0241403282,
0.0520696938,
-0.0170561969,
-0.0312087778,
-0.0044204919,
0.0479034483,
-0.0097555416,
0.0071400953,
0.0075248522,
-0.0138993217,
-0.0579247586,
-0.0411731414,
0.0563068949,
-0.0169222672,
0.0017409992,
-0.0932046175,
-0.0072441981,
0.019541515,
-0.0625995696,
0.000276972,
0.0357291959,
-0.046252057,
-0.0312302932,
0.001278876,
0.0200642031,
0.0167130865,
0.0136931725,
-0.0405538678,
-0.0535039417,
-0.0162805468,
-0.014406994,
-0.0272385515,
0.0252682865,
-0.0125073558,
-0.0212372411,
-0.0218565669,
0.0218374711,
-0.0400585942,
0.0075157555,
0.0082337707,
0.0250039604,
0.0180100538,
-0.051483117,
0.0401153378,
-0.003156289,
0.0964651257,
0.0098380838,
0.0193923842,
-0.0256509222,
-0.0056548319,
0.0156770609,
-0.0154862031,
-0.0258870292,
-0.0104013737,
0.0638926327,
-0.0020596171,
0.027464943,
0.0171104185,
-0.0102867549,
0.0305725597,
-0.0710306242,
0.030693505,
-0.0431543067,
-0.0312537402,
0.0290508904,
0.0019631099,
-0.0076247454,
-0.0279139243,
-0.00586204,
0.0684916675,
-0.0024150461,
0.0408043228,
0.0128295189,
0.0048911958,
-0.0444912277,
0.0049183536,
-0.085587725,
-0.0475279018,
-0.0098057929,
0.000086941,
0.0217532981,
-0.0574843138,
0.0429922491,
-0.0037526165,
-0.0210059006,
-0.0273085274,
-0.0241887681,
-0.0187623594,
-0.00229244,
0.007129279,
0.0139370132,
-0.0156791061,
-0.0439183414,
0.0783651993,
0.0057080244,
0.0205343124,
0.0075957528,
-0.0284906421,
-0.009222839,
-0.0253744498,
0.0090129888,
0.0215727631,
-0.0431835167,
0.0014670496,
-0.0287098754,
-0.0440114662,
0.0075315987,
-0.022646511,
-0.024502214,
-0.0528559126,
-0.0062498981,
0.0887433961,
0.0360740535,
-0.0269082021,
-0.0506926365,
0.0195860993,
-0.0170683023,
-0.0051746974,
-0.0096709374,
-6.512423844e-33,
-0.0266452543,
-0.0336721279,
-0.0216567963,
-0.0061093373,
-0.0401754789,
-0.0029043569,
-0.0278953891,
-0.0046539004,
-0.0266311206,
-0.0145084793,
-0.0178888366,
0.0262259804,
-0.0068720961,
0.0158778168,
0.0366159305,
0.0233286396,
0.0184855573,
0.015944954,
-0.0400483944,
0.0102464613,
0.0197143145,
0.0340169594,
0.0338671952,
0.0088291047,
0.0027379633,
-0.0128974319,
0.0426738337,
0.0102551654,
-0.0250833873,
0.0839170292,
-0.0078908131,
0.0503229313,
0.0193701703,
-0.0659326464,
-0.0117650656,
0.0676720813,
-0.0729430616,
-0.003153773,
0.0425253473,
-0.0072455159,
-0.0383777842,
-0.0228141621,
0.0822069049,
-0.0138958469,
0.0151131935,
-0.0585052818,
0.0474664345,
-0.0087230038,
-0.0714508221,
0.0427386351,
-0.076744318,
0.0046477369,
-0.0038365987,
-0.0139676016,
0.0165540725,
0.0593066998,
0.0145173455,
0.0650253594,
-0.0366911069,
0.0141641917,
-0.026196802,
0.0578882098,
0.0146238673,
0.061117202,
0.0174638219,
0.0437433161,
0.0433594696,
0.0175457075,
-0.083350569,
-0.0328558162,
0.0301266722,
0.0548950545,
0.0190978535,
-0.0195714477,
-0.0007911924,
-0.0322563089,
-0.0203558654,
0.0093231052,
-0.0202649795,
0.1018638834,
0.0635182038,
0.0165631715,
-0.0099174408,
-0.017404722,
-0.0346516781,
-0.0073151942,
-0.0557777435,
-0.0084713381,
0.016220402,
0.025653068,
-0.0179333668,
-0.0042680241,
0.0346922539,
-0.0363617875,
0.0631440207,
0.0396480858,
0.0004657804,
0.0300947297,
-0.0024564641,
0.0266917534,
-0.0545268655,
-0.0000421148,
0.0065137553,
-0.0146975676,
-0.0191157348,
0.0467273369,
-0.0098142559,
0.0058266628,
-0.0326580219,
-0.0245440211,
-0.0482150353,
-0.024313014,
-0.0241638068,
0.0184156708,
0.0612308569,
-0.0004413172,
-0.0195722114,
0.0183712617,
0.0058106566,
0.0141227888,
-0.0420272835,
-0.0227789823,
0.0207413044,
-0.0024801835,
-0.0384560488,
-0.001599835,
-0.0437215641,
0.0363652818,
0.0536972284,
-0.0411736108,
-0.0218153186,
0.0371004939,
2.738e-7,
0.0655782744,
0.0815294981,
0.0060664327,
0.0443717912,
0.0058156378,
0.0050530289,
0.0084863259,
0.0205484983,
0.0665658638,
-0.0205890033,
0.0013331258,
0.0110668484,
0.0377789885,
-0.0163460486,
-0.0963298157,
-0.0378041938,
-0.0208579116,
0.0203307439,
-0.0247230027,
-0.0300093237,
-0.0008804854,
0.0989697278,
-0.0168066993,
0.0004413264,
0.0142915873,
-0.0310927778,
0.0600936264,
-0.0378987342,
0.0029751759,
0.0112287104,
0.0220635254,
0.0155794518,
0.002253036,
0.013861062,
-0.0062180329,
0.0211467445,
0.0320846923,
0.0425131395,
-0.0211095456,
-0.0303228162,
-0.0012533903,
-0.0240683407,
0.0189684704,
-0.0940785185,
0.0511088856,
-0.0390083678,
-0.0211988688,
-0.0180037338,
-0.0325486884,
0.0298694633,
-0.0170149095,
-0.0081531499,
0.003674756,
-0.0261962675,
0.0127634974,
0.0119857602,
-0.0198882502,
-0.0951708406,
-0.04784422,
0.0051485393,
-0.0608791672,
-0.0118787894,
-0.0741965398,
-0.0768600628,
0.0043531982,
-0.037201602,
-0.0189328566,
2.460997983e-34,
0.0303323045,
0.0094073741,
0.014885949,
0.0235641524,
0.0477327891,
-0.0373399034,
-0.0188149419,
0.0294526331,
0.005952056,
-0.1320694089,
-0.0440815613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16269v1 | Multilingual Coarse Political Stance Classification of Media. The Editorial Line of a ChatGPT and Bard Newspaper | 2023-10-25T01:01:28 | 2023-10-25T01:01:28 | Cristina España-Bonet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Neutrality is difficult to achieve and, in politics, subjective. Traditional
media typically adopt an editorial line that can be used by their potential
readers as an indicator of the media bias. Several platforms currently rate
news outlets according to their political bias. The editorial line and the
ratings help readers in gathering a balanced view of news. But in the advent of
instruction-following language models, tasks such as writing a newspaper
article can be delegated to computers. Without imposing a biased persona, where
would an AI-based news outlet lie within the bias ratings? In this work, we use
the ratings of authentic news outlets to create a multilingual corpus of news
with coarse stance annotations (Left and Right) along with automatically
extracted topic annotations. We show that classifiers trained on this data are
able to identify the editorial line of most unseen newspapers in English,
German, Spanish and Catalan. We then apply the classifiers to 101
newspaper-like articles written by ChatGPT and Bard in the 4 languages at
different time periods. We observe that, similarly to traditional newspapers,
ChatGPT editorial line evolves with time and, being a data-driven system, the
stance of the generated articles differs among languages. | [
0.0454562046,
0.0279290657,
0.0109399408,
0.0246076211,
-0.0450340994,
0.0392424092,
0.0226905756,
-0.0487441421,
0.0178875569,
-0.076606147,
-0.0033011013,
-0.0070156245,
-0.0245117247,
-0.0037985856,
-0.0467549004,
-0.0184945874,
0.033459004,
0.0248351786,
0.0767794549,
-0.0385064185,
0.0650912821,
0.056656979,
-0.0240271352,
0.0219018087,
-0.0220902953,
-0.0078506041,
0.0069210012,
-0.032108739,
0.0520207211,
-0.0021890088,
0.0335796475,
0.0444621518,
-0.0073266462,
0.0222485214,
0.0000013263,
-0.0155392345,
-0.0148831522,
-0.0229122471,
0.0635964796,
-0.0489485674,
0.0898411795,
-0.0465505198,
-0.0223837513,
-0.0019651074,
-0.0502927676,
-0.0071608801,
0.0577073991,
0.017311411,
0.072368212,
0.0804485232,
-0.0141931288,
-0.0156617966,
-0.0198190454,
0.0117590744,
-0.0091990521,
-0.0239397921,
0.0158422738,
-0.019561993,
-0.0790578574,
0.0308830757,
-0.0136802439,
0.0009384648,
0.0275224783,
-0.0127448253,
-0.0681717917,
-0.0070311865,
-0.0419147052,
-0.0468148217,
0.002670733,
0.0086697452,
0.0276295058,
-0.0658480152,
0.0215840768,
-0.0024548462,
-0.0046647289,
0.0154557014,
-0.0031324234,
0.0314742476,
-0.0296371579,
0.0453031547,
0.0721243769,
-0.0157649796,
0.0005710029,
0.0694477558,
0.0054739281,
0.0693749562,
-0.0225522071,
-0.0277511962,
0.0500228964,
0.0478023477,
0.0267484281,
-0.02776541,
0.0285014194,
0.0103361113,
0.0023099415,
0.0158984084,
-0.0117559265,
-0.0101246536,
0.0027588389,
-0.0950059742,
-0.0421582535,
0.0165755488,
-0.0234961342,
0.0828634202,
0.0259229112,
-0.0521003753,
0.010402767,
0.0259459354,
-0.0021799738,
0.0035993506,
-0.0212098956,
0.0190727618,
0.0170810893,
0.0291167088,
-0.0125847226,
0.0036614868,
-0.0252177678,
-0.0077607925,
-0.0281932279,
0.0004956844,
0.0062693818,
0.0001952033,
-0.0117826806,
0.0061007738,
-0.0417239293,
0.0610266961,
-0.0395859741,
0.0132649606,
-0.0322042517,
0.0144282756,
0.0322002172,
0.0354987755,
-0.0309341624,
-0.0105384281,
0.0329530761,
-0.0061962996,
-0.0208527967,
0.0170953479,
-0.0098660458,
-0.0063476982,
-0.0213866066,
-0.0819069296,
0.009225795,
-0.0698205754,
0.0243221689,
0.0106133446,
0.0027792233,
-0.0345594734,
0.0060596755,
0.0267312359,
-0.0208803006,
0.0490192212,
0.0104644233,
-0.0100907944,
0.0502593443,
0.0190288164,
0.0214403067,
0.1115260795,
-0.008248576,
0.0364106111,
0.0604244396,
0.0127722118,
-0.0202813148,
0.0203987788,
0.0043656672,
0.0078228815,
-0.0226224158,
0.0058663236,
-0.0700411871,
-0.0116519639,
0.0172019061,
0.0265189297,
0.0166459624,
-0.0070637632,
0.0664861277,
0.007560092,
-0.0138800358,
0.0063422574,
0.0282940716,
-0.0035094006,
0.0015560903,
0.0471213274,
-0.0251392033,
0.0305435639,
0.0103587089,
-0.0219209734,
-0.0078719631,
0.0336460657,
-0.0178181697,
-0.0447723456,
0.0265717693,
-0.0032421185,
0.0309377704,
-0.01839431,
0.0386514142,
-0.0167458709,
-0.0020478189,
0.0099923005,
0.0464896262,
-0.0202499796,
0.0287056919,
-0.0272082612,
0.0674688816,
0.0078339428,
-0.0112826843,
-0.0326043218,
-0.006656718,
-0.0260285474,
0.0423548408,
0.0603520758,
0.0925572962,
-0.0417743623,
-0.0386890806,
-0.0098217307,
-0.019941641,
-0.0070289643,
0.0211481508,
0.0703337044,
-0.0261554848,
0.059491802,
-0.022003511,
0.0222915988,
-0.0180793982,
0.024388643,
0.0242432933,
-0.0179456528,
0.0067580091,
0.0378586501,
0.0195243675,
0.0694328845,
-0.0041221827,
-0.0459803045,
0.0421906821,
0.0029411009,
-0.0316307209,
0.0063512931,
-0.0176601503,
-0.007997877,
0.0049430639,
-0.051058989,
-0.0065193675,
0.0170442704,
-0.0101961726,
0.0045470237,
0.0273447204,
0.0143050067,
-0.0301211439,
-0.061286401,
-0.0194072258,
-0.0504057854,
-0.0055741165,
-0.0472676046,
0.0659912229,
-0.0000750769,
0.0449188948,
0.0236114897,
-0.0731604472,
0.0113679571,
-0.0017735874,
-0.0081989393,
0.0294417776,
0.0254026521,
0.0319455415,
0.0706884637,
0.002595485,
0.0089729335,
-0.0255342685,
-0.0562968664,
0.0160309672,
-0.0408930033,
0.0403755866,
0.0453896634,
-0.0348935053,
-0.0023400662,
0.0178072676,
-0.0478606261,
-0.0305361245,
-0.0257619713,
0.0288943015,
0.0073812632,
0.0123822195,
0.0047753877,
0.0013983959,
0.0151343457,
-0.0424255468,
0.0133368876,
0.0449940749,
-0.0104188807,
-0.0568520948,
-0.0304263122,
-0.0366980396,
-0.0048138681,
-0.0155148627,
-0.0308255721,
0.0067959828,
0.0194545723,
-0.0398333669,
0.0879712403,
0.0471714325,
0.0712200105,
0.0576177537,
0.038696669,
-0.0432680286,
-0.0132578127,
-0.0395039953,
0.0412339866,
-0.0487294756,
-0.0311544426,
0.0443288088,
0.0303360913,
0.0071921223,
0.0097254431,
-0.0228833277,
0.0584255755,
-0.0416783728,
-0.008966743,
0.0303483438,
0.0134718623,
0.0091996193,
0.0500937104,
0.0112331258,
-0.0137796747,
0.0656520054,
0.0262162741,
0.0624096915,
-0.0732751191,
-0.0230406132,
-0.0260053258,
0.0190263279,
-0.0221796781,
0.0495430045,
-0.0468981713,
-0.0044748401,
-0.0283207279,
-0.0418509319,
0.0643712655,
-0.0039000192,
0.0174232256,
-0.035850469,
-0.004213274,
-0.0118831992,
-0.0363247134,
0.0011096105,
-0.0524203219,
0.0057874578,
-0.0058071413,
0.0346333832,
-0.0044305576,
-0.0137296077,
0.0343155973,
0.0119851055,
-0.0024213656,
-0.0404477529,
0.0196093135,
0.0284013823,
0.0215551183,
0.0121636502,
-0.0288002659,
0.004912334,
0.0084467111,
-0.0132564632,
0.0303594097,
-0.0486409701,
0.0610758848,
-0.0074733328,
-0.0190674886,
0.0340949483,
-0.0513786748,
-0.0314211734,
-0.0599786155,
0.037707381,
-0.0314399302,
0.0173995458,
0.0928687304,
0.0426998213,
-0.1025872752,
-0.0292875003,
0.0353540815,
-0.0488648452,
0.0226984341,
0.0117671732,
-0.1057163104,
0.0415396914,
-0.0044903285,
0.0243295953,
-0.0516014993,
-0.005137152,
-0.0252958685,
-0.0695344135,
-0.0092116455,
-0.0172091424,
-0.0625677258,
-0.0150508871,
-0.0826896802,
0.0067554251,
-0.0665137097,
-0.0338141993,
-0.0129541103,
0.0289380811,
0.0219453964,
0.0029338661,
-0.0325130485,
-0.0547500812,
-0.0116887363,
-0.0179800726,
0.0260602906,
-0.010014168,
0.0669987127,
-0.0267419126,
-0.0022210714,
0.0307402201,
-0.0112047512,
-0.0362662748,
-0.0346110016,
0.0343401097,
-0.0364808999,
-0.0265867691,
-0.0146345422,
0.0494708531,
0.0353363678,
0.0170318652,
0.0052455873,
0.0168762393,
0.0088939425,
-0.0153904567,
-0.0047797952,
0.0172633026,
0.0700245053,
0.047808025,
-0.0084525384,
-0.0656407177,
0.000564242,
-0.0505732335,
0.0119749093,
-0.0507058017,
-0.0367711745,
-0.0068804021,
-0.0673658997,
-0.0599527098,
-0.036786329,
-0.0621232912,
-0.0275535975,
0.041436471,
0.0349156782,
-0.0122715952,
0.0398932286,
0.0074586961,
-0.0162710082,
-0.0076289196,
0.0188681446,
-0.0022453587,
0.002113268,
-0.0591254197,
0.0119596366,
-0.0071958997,
-0.0461478643,
-0.0195331089,
-0.0434606113,
-0.0524971262,
0.0199262481,
0.0240738168,
0.0167768821,
0.0226194467,
-0.0281020515,
-0.0050152964,
0.0277120154,
0.0829026178,
-0.031260252,
-0.0135363471,
0.0085188858,
0.0154846162,
-0.0055608796,
0.0181420073,
-0.0121612484,
0.0388718396,
0.0257094279,
-0.0450965315,
-0.0434712432,
0.0032671317,
0.0133748315,
-0.0119830715,
0.0250449982,
-0.0221088026,
-0.0419722572,
-0.0586150065,
-0.0265539698,
-0.0166442264,
-0.0410782844,
0.0193473883,
-0.0064632562,
0.0178687181,
-0.0418260619,
-0.0560039133,
0.0351160578,
-0.0323394202,
0.0477593914,
-0.0705274642,
0.0374827422,
0.0392810106,
0.038221579,
-0.0373411141,
-0.015026575,
-0.0297080427,
0.0347656719,
-0.0029993411,
0.018609751,
-0.0271017682,
0.029524792,
0.030491339,
0.0065350574,
0.0372611657,
-0.014771536,
-0.0226185955,
0.0319686718,
-0.0357632525,
0.0317497328,
0.0548853055,
-0.0471385419,
0.0198589228,
0.0091782697,
-0.0398925766,
-0.0059063644,
0.0152905146,
0.0353178456,
-0.0354691558,
0.0310130883,
0.0135314511,
-0.0256427377,
0.0247403309,
0.0393781178,
-0.0322591923,
0.0060466705,
0.0674147233,
-0.0696889237,
-0.0318780243,
-0.0139217824,
0.0329499878,
-0.022136651,
-0.013564554,
-0.0290799998,
-0.0391581766,
-0.0166651048,
-0.0025527971,
-0.000428251,
0.0243991017,
0.0062256716,
-0.0270307362,
0.1005394682,
-0.0015938486,
0.0441677645,
-0.078396067,
0.0214817207,
-0.0814039335,
-0.0226947423,
-0.0193088278,
-5.53495768e-33,
0.005735145,
-0.0084235016,
-0.0169102382,
0.0336240306,
0.0247849617,
0.0010875526,
0.000571404,
0.0139557477,
-0.0216437504,
0.0493249446,
0.0316439867,
0.0149309319,
0.0110808257,
-0.0211481042,
-0.0076380293,
-0.0357706286,
0.0094135432,
-0.0088821528,
-0.0540006682,
0.0132750561,
0.0314929299,
-0.0391246416,
0.0735653713,
-0.1017722338,
0.070419021,
-0.0062174494,
-0.0492474101,
-0.018903764,
0.0272256322,
0.062890172,
0.0260827355,
0.0343013145,
0.0605063885,
-0.05322228,
0.0363046601,
0.0715251938,
-0.0224182811,
-0.0229337327,
0.0382531434,
0.0360590778,
0.042411413,
-0.0236959234,
0.0002313678,
-0.0022639418,
-0.0297613069,
0.0130500486,
0.0618709996,
-0.0301191993,
0.0396189839,
-0.0416601375,
-0.0372108631,
0.0131357647,
-0.0426709503,
-0.0295800846,
-0.0181850009,
0.0107701095,
0.0321982764,
0.0262233038,
-0.0490930863,
0.029247012,
-0.0765271485,
0.022150306,
0.0171770826,
-0.0487993062,
-0.0275905672,
0.0611175857,
0.0070882458,
0.0508345924,
-0.0337399021,
0.0139178028,
0.0253068302,
-0.0372006483,
-0.0009444848,
0.0814973265,
0.0384587683,
-0.0323874056,
-0.0811588615,
0.0375753902,
0.0933911502,
0.0022917916,
0.028406648,
-0.0439301282,
-0.0150167933,
-0.0070131412,
-0.0179779381,
-0.0837007463,
-0.0307957567,
-0.0347422436,
-0.0312343352,
0.0080311447,
-0.0530327298,
0.0524422899,
0.0247635003,
-0.0290586371,
-0.0115339616,
0.0579208545,
-0.0444376022,
0.0090929968,
-0.0110833617,
0.0225347504,
-0.0780246109,
-0.0148470867,
-0.0321923234,
0.0366385579,
0.0293660145,
-0.0004693693,
0.0837247297,
0.0184774119,
-0.0490243286,
-0.0181460418,
0.0001837638,
0.0089110117,
-0.0088866279,
0.0949466154,
0.01949111,
0.0105623202,
-0.0002846217,
0.0227278024,
0.0151505778,
0.0175037272,
-0.0144036375,
-0.0250605494,
-0.043310035,
0.0252334531,
-0.0300644785,
-0.0385852791,
0.003245774,
0.0031763457,
-0.0388062336,
-0.0598383211,
-0.0144105768,
-0.0306230541,
2.248e-7,
0.0357931517,
0.0363342762,
-0.0412601419,
0.0248644836,
0.0309031531,
0.0083814636,
0.0028013298,
0.034089487,
-0.0314137302,
-0.0539210662,
0.0041493191,
0.0234118998,
0.0002281292,
0.048845645,
-0.101884909,
0.0333190002,
-0.0328469835,
0.0200042222,
-0.0478727594,
0.0413779579,
0.0195376202,
0.0378597304,
0.0232700389,
-0.0028932823,
-0.0171293616,
0.0005026628,
0.0459950455,
0.0173046533,
-0.0425626673,
0.014366095,
0.0425904542,
-0.0151008572,
0.0096476786,
0.0082100434,
-0.0056017893,
0.0056077112,
0.0090944134,
0.0611942858,
0.0140145263,
0.0116737662,
0.0128070228,
-0.0201850589,
0.0131603004,
-0.0280494001,
0.0728536695,
-0.0347503461,
-0.0300904512,
-0.116319418,
-0.0429746285,
-0.0276142489,
0.0613274314,
-0.0264627058,
-0.020987466,
0.0289877467,
-0.0104666948,
-0.0077502402,
0.0241307635,
-0.0200146735,
-0.0238875486,
0.0179424174,
-0.0018246045,
-0.0423850268,
0.048964493,
0.0033127251,
0.0188105311,
-0.0663767532,
0.0392965786,
1.43068522e-34,
0.0428387821,
-0.0063274559,
-0.0432099029,
-0.0157770719,
0.0297206156,
0.0229482464,
-0.0155653218,
-0.0129683958,
0.0028600316,
0.0064312108,
0.0151752476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16263v1 | Enhancing Large Language Models for Secure Code Generation: A Dataset-driven Study on Vulnerability Mitigation | 2023-10-25T00:32:56 | 2023-10-25T00:32:56 | Jiexin Wang, Liuwen Cao, Xitong Luo, Zhiping Zhou, Jiayuan Xie, Adam Jatowt, Yi Cai | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large language models (LLMs) have brought significant advancements to code
generation, benefiting both novice and experienced developers. However, their
training using unsanitized data from open-source repositories, like GitHub,
introduces the risk of inadvertently propagating security vulnerabilities. To
effectively mitigate this concern, this paper presents a comprehensive study
focused on evaluating and enhancing code LLMs from a software security
perspective. We introduce SecuCoGen\footnote{SecuCoGen has been uploaded as
supplemental material and will be made publicly available after publication.},
a meticulously curated dataset targeting 21 critical vulnerability types.
SecuCoGen comprises 180 samples and serves as the foundation for conducting
experiments on three crucial code-related tasks: code generation, code repair
and vulnerability classification, with a strong emphasis on security. Our
experimental results reveal that existing models often overlook security
concerns during code generation, leading to the generation of vulnerable code.
To address this, we propose effective approaches to mitigate the security
vulnerabilities and enhance the overall robustness of code generated by LLMs.
Moreover, our study identifies weaknesses in existing models' ability to repair
vulnerable code, even when provided with vulnerability information.
Additionally, certain vulnerability types pose challenges for the models,
hindering their performance in vulnerability classification. Based on these
findings, we believe our study will have a positive impact on the software
engineering community, inspiring the development of improved methods for
training and utilizing LLMs, thereby leading to safer and more trustworthy
model deployment. | [
-0.0030215913,
0.1024601385,
-0.0210068934,
0.0186375398,
-0.0328289606,
-0.0347951017,
0.0103969835,
-0.0171756204,
0.0214641597,
-0.0222169645,
0.0205123313,
0.011785564,
0.0195484012,
0.0264747366,
0.0647017956,
0.001054581,
0.0562515296,
-0.0861782804,
-0.0385580137,
0.0182131622,
-0.0145538552,
0.0162672792,
-0.0081396783,
0.0267941486,
0.0309586301,
-0.0191707294,
-0.0169978719,
0.0481596254,
-0.0004346392,
-0.016235264,
0.0178664885,
0.0347312577,
-0.0109956991,
-0.0218846854,
0.000002509,
-0.0352032259,
-0.006581028,
0.055789344,
0.0182597041,
0.0362047441,
-0.0233914349,
-0.0455717221,
-0.006783036,
0.0442101732,
0.0095835067,
0.0097403591,
0.0390789136,
-0.0016056122,
0.0814021677,
0.0491782799,
0.0314410999,
0.0029867259,
0.0411200188,
0.0118775954,
0.0489655919,
-0.013728736,
0.0032631711,
0.0342714563,
-0.00002746,
0.0349539109,
0.0194025263,
-0.0234371256,
0.0194732528,
0.0009003725,
0.0221925676,
0.0332742855,
-0.0479701646,
-0.017621465,
-0.0005715201,
-0.0039398042,
-0.0538765974,
-0.0256829597,
0.0020977007,
-0.0153840119,
-0.0052002035,
0.0231217593,
0.024787847,
0.0333058871,
0.0171042122,
-0.0066191023,
0.0079228375,
-0.033723969,
0.0130563173,
0.0051900255,
0.0142601468,
0.0305033345,
0.0051983544,
0.0068986029,
-0.0361708552,
-0.0565966964,
-0.00166869,
-0.0410962924,
-0.0355800688,
0.0291701946,
0.0429130904,
0.0084019173,
-0.0420197137,
-0.0174926147,
0.0907201916,
-0.0599473231,
-0.0357385278,
0.0111732595,
-0.0205849428,
-0.0211120564,
-0.0488848016,
0.0326335765,
0.009222337,
0.0092421714,
0.0407579169,
0.0493093021,
-0.0360175967,
0.0057392917,
0.0042492454,
0.0326436311,
0.0127443923,
0.0711392686,
-0.0339305885,
0.0370537266,
-0.0051128087,
0.091295734,
-0.0271506105,
-0.0424917005,
-0.0053599775,
0.0276248157,
0.0440279022,
-0.0587841198,
-0.0051236739,
-0.0115203233,
-0.039128866,
-0.090366438,
0.0036164639,
0.0041884645,
-0.0681887195,
-0.0259929858,
-0.0002474061,
0.1005510241,
0.0362777449,
0.0410713553,
-0.084318772,
-0.0951718315,
-0.0227516368,
0.0293294657,
-0.0052657058,
-0.1057483181,
-0.0638725683,
0.002058042,
-0.0047007455,
-0.0806450918,
0.0133078331,
-0.0098299412,
-0.0468455218,
0.0295696445,
-0.0624509752,
0.0250067431,
0.0193881746,
0.0565153994,
0.0223605745,
0.0079093566,
0.0179940145,
0.0176946186,
0.0256800912,
-0.0568517074,
0.076378271,
-0.0028615717,
-0.0225741062,
0.0455553718,
0.0266596712,
0.0402422287,
0.063724108,
-0.0409058146,
-0.004974545,
0.0419705585,
-0.0045246915,
-0.0139654065,
0.0544841662,
-0.0030522395,
-0.0189859997,
0.0520639904,
-0.0057027591,
0.0402279012,
0.0087000616,
-0.058493115,
-0.049289953,
0.0313280225,
-0.0423960909,
-0.0209264345,
-0.0590995774,
0.0588211529,
-0.0122170672,
-0.000832887,
-0.018845357,
-0.0298347827,
-0.0341307595,
0.0027769143,
0.0202195831,
0.0223057047,
0.011027175,
0.0442616679,
0.0281941742,
-0.0839029253,
-0.0283605736,
-0.0740784481,
0.0122975232,
0.0499739647,
0.036456041,
-0.0483045541,
-0.0632252321,
-0.0311889052,
-0.0038440742,
-0.0441609845,
0.019065598,
0.0169836264,
0.009997081,
-0.0427501649,
0.0077056875,
-0.045819141,
0.0091744764,
0.0179979447,
0.0141397929,
-0.0375479758,
0.0319558494,
-0.0006067725,
-0.0487843566,
0.0401366614,
-0.0039183027,
-0.0017029785,
0.028724689,
-0.011809906,
-0.0017383761,
-0.0176432151,
-0.0184698608,
0.0323286764,
0.0375937335,
0.0329274461,
-0.0049547097,
-0.0203231256,
0.0259808227,
0.0350340754,
0.0122652035,
-0.0249022301,
-0.0001414757,
0.0020472291,
-0.0628650784,
0.0250930991,
0.074252218,
-0.0201753322,
-0.0375670418,
0.0045197066,
0.0179725159,
-0.0203626473,
0.0039957389,
-0.022346992,
0.0057563744,
0.0172973629,
-0.0025850337,
-0.0383908115,
0.0734148845,
0.0196546875,
-0.0135292653,
-0.0402485766,
-0.0043706889,
-0.0590822324,
0.0500182398,
0.0244480483,
0.0572379269,
-0.0079140672,
-0.0518308282,
-0.0164882168,
0.0090423645,
0.0014346418,
0.0308269877,
0.0300330743,
0.0173571855,
-0.0316252299,
0.0035192643,
-0.0064953533,
-0.0368704461,
-0.023297783,
0.0045825103,
0.0128899058,
-0.0483980924,
-0.0526277684,
-0.0011137376,
0.0005713007,
-0.0214586221,
0.056870956,
-0.0281305518,
0.0149397273,
-0.0410549901,
0.0737511516,
0.0052070338,
-0.0177958831,
-0.0154850846,
-0.0704560801,
-0.0260452405,
0.0008744455,
0.0354954079,
-0.0063646804,
0.0154533517,
-0.0083409417,
0.0757320449,
0.0098620616,
-0.0082156723,
-0.0228903648,
0.0483684503,
-0.0777092874,
-0.0037368725,
-0.0555239879,
0.0253142323,
0.0210402161,
0.0139611997,
-0.0418582261,
-0.0323938541,
0.0101070227,
-0.0002085885,
0.0156787802,
0.0104681281,
-0.0584563166,
0.0219424292,
0.0174722411,
-0.0421897136,
-0.0879243165,
0.0121538322,
-0.035268791,
0.0288925413,
-0.056854248,
-0.0513732471,
-0.0454409309,
0.0450698882,
-0.0237310659,
0.0175886918,
0.0189879611,
-0.010048517,
-0.0478046015,
-0.0417678729,
0.0023750453,
-0.0239815749,
0.0297594368,
-0.040228907,
-0.0316911489,
-0.0230936874,
-0.0168603025,
-0.0296236239,
-0.0176889095,
-0.0100472337,
-0.0192514751,
-0.003643153,
0.0225204378,
0.0460355245,
-0.0072903032,
0.0289450977,
0.0010072729,
0.0318221897,
-0.0347018242,
-0.0091924639,
-0.0502818003,
-0.0407884531,
-0.1153498217,
-0.0241314005,
-0.0113385236,
0.0231875703,
0.0519960485,
0.065574564,
0.0524092652,
-0.0908159539,
-0.0148296952,
0.0091582537,
-0.0358864889,
-0.0085663814,
0.0672631785,
0.0322372206,
-0.0290048439,
-0.0270632505,
0.0450080745,
0.0296225622,
-0.0079105599,
0.0277739782,
-0.0296564531,
0.0354969986,
0.0498517491,
0.0361609161,
-0.0830211043,
0.0102099339,
0.0262491889,
0.026646968,
-0.025480574,
0.0074797748,
0.0140286349,
-0.0970782638,
0.0575774759,
0.0239667818,
-0.0360143557,
-0.0316407271,
-0.0672363415,
-0.0035578359,
-0.0017732227,
-0.0265702028,
0.041667331,
0.0017013835,
0.0041435892,
0.0048668664,
-0.0653691813,
-0.0250266772,
0.023973519,
-0.0403298289,
0.0063401484,
0.0707083121,
0.000062593,
-0.0059047011,
0.0356664732,
0.0654378682,
-0.0193509702,
0.0103675639,
0.0088712759,
0.054721836,
0.0318663269,
-0.0004527763,
0.0742900521,
0.0495051183,
-0.0544421226,
-0.0608931109,
0.067430675,
0.0090703396,
-0.0322133899,
0.0151255606,
-0.0510784127,
0.0012534423,
0.0364499353,
0.0169908237,
0.0470577069,
-0.0090884063,
-0.0129554337,
-0.042441573,
0.0153730549,
-0.0440426767,
-0.0021216155,
0.0084756911,
0.0064978353,
-0.0289949942,
-0.0257213823,
0.003866845,
-0.0297711454,
-0.0161840878,
0.0683582649,
-0.052152168,
0.0155808171,
0.0206274651,
-0.0298758671,
0.0045641679,
-0.0474581942,
0.0446409881,
-0.0142067187,
0.0019726243,
-0.0110932803,
-0.0219344832,
-0.0307926964,
0.0049323589,
-0.0715772659,
-0.06256558,
-0.0238460116,
0.097282894,
0.0171404295,
-0.0599312186,
-0.0347361192,
-0.0701771006,
0.0101581076,
0.0124917272,
-0.056188006,
-0.0021717115,
0.0305453632,
-0.0431376435,
0.0381228626,
-0.0441985019,
-0.0435949154,
-0.0263182875,
0.0654850677,
-0.0482480898,
-0.0112574361,
0.0130655188,
0.0005210232,
0.0301876329,
0.0177771691,
0.0225084834,
0.0235410295,
0.0163975433,
0.0007908141,
-0.0026646915,
-0.0144535601,
0.0052604792,
0.0359011367,
0.0188185927,
-0.0176578145,
0.0441782437,
-0.0112935137,
-0.0189379733,
0.041347038,
0.027086677,
0.0761406869,
0.040545091,
0.0640646592,
0.0638870671,
0.0034080478,
-0.0203997288,
0.0089965444,
-0.023894636,
-0.011805444,
0.0168918334,
0.0260482635,
-0.0324542597,
0.0441733934,
0.0037270514,
0.0174995083,
-0.0431007892,
-0.0558767803,
0.0319296904,
0.0331204012,
0.0108671151,
0.0692360848,
0.0128468378,
-0.005705975,
0.0016192796,
-0.074447155,
0.0580776185,
-0.0238542967,
-0.060777586,
0.0079851458,
-0.0124147683,
-0.0173145961,
-0.0434445255,
0.1009146944,
-0.0053328229,
0.0304783005,
-0.0178882219,
-0.0359805226,
-0.0171828289,
0.0053714956,
0.0477110781,
-0.0211462397,
-0.0426024422,
-0.0754003003,
-0.0333063491,
-0.0850376487,
0.0038884634,
-0.0103997774,
0.0746854469,
0.0496835932,
0.0038162838,
0.0701107308,
0.0001096912,
0.0113422377,
-0.0526391268,
-0.0036525812,
-0.0004880933,
-0.0487844534,
-0.0016686125,
-5.568402331e-33,
0.0254228525,
-0.0002917027,
-0.0332226455,
0.0167585444,
0.0357640795,
0.004912938,
-0.0399745777,
0.0046501057,
-0.007252784,
-0.0276992507,
0.06108943,
0.0134418895,
-0.0027496251,
-0.0063999626,
0.0373295918,
0.0202837419,
0.0121383676,
0.03269656,
-0.0451893322,
0.0493121743,
-0.0153602408,
0.0024493013,
-0.0156506151,
-0.0693547279,
0.0007967692,
-0.0156296752,
-0.0067466358,
-0.0364944004,
-0.0039047846,
0.0554364547,
0.0328604244,
0.018986674,
-0.0040503452,
-0.0057103876,
-0.0180925559,
-0.0082867434,
0.0124086877,
-0.0109553989,
-0.0287144426,
-0.0240758173,
0.0472463965,
-0.1060627699,
0.0232158843,
-0.0058967336,
0.0083878953,
-0.0224660262,
0.0129010482,
-0.0163893979,
0.0258327965,
-0.0580829419,
-0.0020950763,
0.0321543068,
-0.0716251433,
0.0208906494,
-0.031009594,
0.0206554737,
0.0072435173,
0.0046911025,
0.0511122271,
0.0391418599,
0.0538482629,
0.0121345213,
0.0327971987,
-0.0060856887,
-0.0403863005,
-0.0048230514,
-0.0038475194,
0.0010122412,
0.010785046,
0.0335320234,
0.0159196127,
0.0463474058,
0.0535216294,
0.0685854629,
0.006052597,
-0.0449097939,
-0.0674255341,
0.0211580731,
-0.0316501111,
0.0347906947,
0.0325448848,
0.0123926057,
-0.0372984,
0.0086153001,
-0.0569474921,
-0.0238593016,
-0.020708032,
-0.0270196274,
0.0137979984,
-0.0191565044,
-0.0393395275,
0.0281487051,
0.0042238003,
-0.0231237039,
0.0064730048,
0.0549197719,
-0.0218391176,
-0.0144429179,
-0.0474591702,
0.0256462302,
0.0079261791,
-0.0400201008,
0.0143540325,
-0.0379275531,
0.0540727489,
-0.0024152133,
0.0279707704,
0.0181321297,
-0.0655061752,
0.0040563415,
-0.0340755582,
0.0197775438,
-0.0094698742,
0.062302988,
-0.0063351453,
-0.0096912952,
0.0384500287,
0.005735958,
0.0178445987,
-0.0266747195,
-0.0464987084,
0.0462801456,
-0.0115939751,
0.0285107289,
0.0218111686,
-0.0143787581,
-0.0075158826,
0.0109491488,
0.0345698856,
-0.0309145655,
-0.0439896844,
0.0033945264,
3.212e-7,
0.0034208668,
0.0098977145,
-0.0168114714,
0.0207835287,
0.0080253687,
0.0387989134,
-0.0230495166,
0.0372343846,
0.0165065937,
-0.0030558249,
-0.0483726002,
0.0040059332,
0.0701886341,
0.0359937102,
0.0134321544,
-0.0014611833,
-0.038136337,
0.01312909,
-0.075275965,
0.022737341,
0.0329221636,
0.0525918305,
-0.0107498243,
-0.0173891373,
-0.0305926614,
-0.0547506846,
-0.0021002886,
-0.02917994,
0.0008162776,
0.065667212,
-0.0354744196,
0.0660619289,
0.0360891372,
0.0230199378,
-0.0567312799,
-0.0559246987,
-0.040668916,
0.0408544652,
0.0361082777,
0.0493616983,
0.0122541282,
0.0010989241,
-0.0099540381,
-0.0602543578,
0.0382947624,
0.0013103191,
-0.0227609742,
0.0022931043,
-0.0201177876,
-0.005563519,
0.0327109955,
-0.0322718471,
0.0018130792,
-0.013998976,
-0.0089875842,
0.0037132537,
-0.0119058928,
-0.017253492,
-0.0460662022,
-0.0056805774,
-0.0295098517,
-0.0281614531,
0.0164489187,
0.0548554994,
0.0111825513,
-0.0002524998,
0.0516653545,
3.170722442e-34,
-0.0056709475,
-0.0755322352,
0.0068405187,
-0.0138509078,
0.0403166823,
-0.0197198875,
-0.017454436,
0.0350666717,
-0.0324546248,
0.076476492,
-0.0206430536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16261v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16261v1 | The Distributional Hypothesis Does Not Fully Explain the Benefits of Masked Language Model Pretraining | 2023-10-25T00:31:29 | 2023-10-25T00:31:29 | Ting-Rui Chiang, Dani Yogatama | cs.CL | cs.CL | We analyze the masked language modeling pretraining objective function from
the perspective of the distributional hypothesis. We investigate whether better
sample efficiency and the better generalization capability of models pretrained
with masked language modeling can be attributed to the semantic similarity
encoded in the pretraining data's distributional property. Via a synthetic
dataset, our analysis suggests that distributional property indeed leads to the
better sample efficiency of pretrained masked language models, but does not
fully explain the generalization capability. We also conduct analyses over two
real-world datasets and demonstrate that the distributional property does not
explain the generalization ability of pretrained natural language models
either. Our results illustrate our limited understanding of model pretraining
and provide future research directions. | [
0.0277674869,
0.0809629634,
-0.02471737,
0.0287168007,
-0.0349998809,
0.0231397599,
0.0247493032,
0.0280675013,
-0.0525624193,
-0.070165053,
-0.0427824855,
-0.0324181505,
0.0060980353,
0.0295785163,
0.0316770226,
-0.0617227331,
0.0355136581,
0.0290255826,
-0.016726451,
-0.0152049651,
0.0026586805,
-0.0118684964,
0.0281925891,
0.0110795973,
-0.0110708382,
0.0170774087,
0.0324398503,
-0.0234293062,
-0.0058835573,
-0.0188616272,
0.0305783302,
0.0482932366,
0.0271280538,
0.0136512201,
0.0000017808,
-0.0560808182,
0.0016147462,
-0.013699377,
-0.0295609552,
0.0195021424,
0.0633149296,
-0.0602923296,
0.0084751472,
0.0161341224,
-0.0268664733,
-0.046003677,
0.0610720962,
0.0417279638,
0.0030188677,
0.0650669932,
-0.0236522648,
-0.056351956,
-0.0111877974,
-0.0256524906,
-0.0362576544,
-0.0235196482,
0.0390894376,
0.0225904975,
-0.0212325733,
-0.0107701048,
-0.0282644983,
0.0369417183,
-0.000592522,
0.0656056032,
0.0021454501,
0.0522725023,
-0.0315690897,
-0.0085725132,
0.0158443302,
0.045619078,
-0.0570902787,
-0.0527020805,
0.0126950946,
-0.0159129314,
-0.0223613717,
0.0617976934,
0.0052002254,
0.0168988742,
0.0164016467,
0.0374538265,
0.0320473835,
0.0347625017,
0.0411172956,
-0.0038206917,
-0.0681665391,
0.0789212584,
0.0145260775,
-0.0363936499,
0.0019966178,
-0.0081891892,
-0.0618250966,
-0.0526118539,
0.0045218929,
-0.0116617186,
0.0218112748,
0.0314386785,
-0.0655147582,
-0.0901503265,
0.0143481391,
-0.0214057919,
0.0439917259,
0.0147227757,
-0.0198860224,
0.0202492978,
-0.024637796,
0.033950951,
0.0002021248,
0.0484964624,
-0.0545884967,
-0.0159079246,
-0.0445607305,
-0.017114969,
-0.0557032861,
0.0390704572,
-0.0321985371,
-0.0095215663,
-0.0198627375,
0.0187049191,
0.0012867555,
-0.0312334448,
-0.0122808376,
-0.0255284626,
-0.040982388,
0.008576748,
-0.0043771169,
-0.0487057455,
-0.0290859621,
0.0382835791,
-0.0475642905,
-0.0521188043,
0.0223601311,
-0.0003129118,
0.0184642728,
-0.0228648242,
0.0230596382,
0.0228728857,
-0.0011674205,
-0.0398469307,
-0.0229396448,
0.0261916947,
0.002772748,
-0.0252067391,
-0.0074403617,
-0.0614837781,
0.0174993481,
0.0219907835,
0.0069131721,
-0.0278216042,
-0.0279092025,
-0.0007639437,
-0.0623200685,
0.0780274943,
-0.0064596804,
0.0363461748,
0.0299389306,
-0.0072215372,
0.0247153696,
0.0642018169,
0.0034034774,
-0.0375856422,
0.0452801883,
-0.0272334665,
0.0227683112,
0.0541735813,
0.0431309491,
0.0201390032,
0.0125756059,
-0.007415236,
0.0033057102,
-0.0309252422,
0.0469938219,
0.0201374646,
-0.0381963477,
-0.0437272936,
0.0246979631,
0.0552469492,
0.0168142505,
-0.001467348,
0.0260870066,
0.0051120738,
-0.0086048367,
0.051001735,
-0.0273876302,
-0.071241416,
-0.0459575877,
0.0222029146,
-0.0314235911,
0.0139907328,
-0.0449538566,
-0.0180524699,
-0.0332032442,
-0.0078269737,
0.0442653187,
-0.02027197,
0.0531133898,
0.0397403501,
-0.0185408946,
0.0487675965,
0.0442283861,
-0.0132555859,
0.0042431457,
-0.0434919149,
-0.0056688273,
-0.0190410111,
0.0128928488,
-0.0239852071,
0.0305210967,
0.0165381823,
0.0031015463,
0.008626827,
0.0314266309,
-0.0008553782,
0.0285912026,
-0.022406254,
-0.0168644134,
-0.0291014295,
0.0414283425,
0.0443807915,
0.0016020339,
-0.013547672,
0.0272211395,
-0.0735897571,
0.0035793677,
0.0579802431,
-0.0279176198,
-0.0337942205,
-0.0121397059,
-0.0007519472,
0.0306263529,
-0.0195242856,
-0.0516319685,
0.0225250423,
-0.0119997002,
-0.0436937287,
-0.0160617828,
-0.0110039283,
-0.0315269232,
-0.0483306162,
-0.0020521937,
-0.049935855,
0.0240113419,
0.1061361879,
-0.0262523871,
-0.0173394568,
0.0045274617,
0.0206191782,
0.0894198716,
-0.0549007058,
0.0520824678,
-0.024950318,
0.0351946242,
-0.0446323901,
0.0539544001,
-0.0079022832,
0.0361280553,
-0.0279981159,
0.0165425856,
0.0428714976,
-0.0099289669,
-0.019559877,
0.0052804374,
-0.0012794024,
0.0203289818,
0.0219829567,
-0.0099565228,
-0.0156722534,
-0.0016912234,
-0.0713836625,
0.0172447767,
-0.0421517938,
-0.0175651517,
0.0520130359,
0.0142485825,
-0.0378449224,
0.0015688777,
-0.0261373948,
-0.0594504066,
0.0242344998,
0.0318563506,
0.0137037002,
-0.0035853023,
-0.0225944817,
-0.0274408944,
-0.025294723,
-0.002125364,
0.0630440414,
-0.0185625292,
-0.0352667607,
-0.041177623,
0.0875946283,
-0.0266317669,
0.0502217859,
-0.0253280979,
-0.025522897,
-0.0241850428,
0.0152383354,
0.0384456739,
0.0173865184,
0.0021166492,
-0.0057080565,
0.0511200093,
0.0294566192,
-0.044267267,
-0.0252719875,
-0.0539451763,
-0.0550045557,
-0.0193422306,
-0.0587849803,
0.0510525219,
0.0781711861,
0.0577270761,
-0.0424566306,
-0.0432253219,
0.006000184,
-0.0478563718,
-0.0240515023,
-0.0621004514,
-0.0017240255,
0.0080372905,
0.0423164442,
-0.0230449103,
-0.0457885936,
0.0407463573,
-0.0382250398,
-0.0007278495,
-0.0524489582,
-0.047275275,
-0.0166211165,
0.0325094424,
0.027293954,
0.0267762709,
0.0354076959,
-0.0246761162,
-0.0489188358,
-0.0215653405,
0.0160123445,
-0.0052188947,
0.0029714548,
-0.0164439995,
0.0046682274,
0.0172183253,
-0.0218660943,
-0.0476543829,
-0.1140169725,
0.0103611508,
0.0176540129,
0.0425233468,
0.0235217735,
-0.0074362876,
0.0409797728,
-0.0254176203,
0.0470944643,
0.0232293401,
-0.0086724823,
-0.0128381122,
0.0073734247,
0.0446655191,
-0.0307317059,
0.0048259259,
-0.0165114328,
-0.0128706004,
-0.0105418097,
0.0652571619,
0.0356629789,
-0.0152553609,
0.0180173405,
0.0265852157,
-0.0323351026,
-0.051424358,
0.011662255,
0.0239456464,
0.0056360294,
0.0134267826,
0.1184127927,
0.0255373698,
0.0285544544,
0.0111767761,
0.0176323187,
0.0573106967,
0.0148317814,
0.0020766342,
-0.0811157823,
0.0215055365,
0.0094117569,
-0.0070010177,
-0.0341269709,
-0.0099298395,
-0.0146827111,
-0.1045670137,
-0.011665578,
0.0003682838,
-0.0697585195,
-0.0226769894,
-0.0516537726,
-0.0013671733,
-0.0106336288,
0.0249229409,
-0.0200217664,
0.005081743,
0.0027025593,
0.0280128829,
-0.0290613715,
-0.065749906,
0.012698845,
-0.0563083664,
0.0148411943,
0.051596906,
0.0229250304,
-0.0210609473,
-0.0268063862,
0.0123544196,
-0.0386657231,
-0.0024608558,
-0.0053664031,
0.0740286782,
-0.0217141286,
-0.0323505551,
0.0189488214,
0.0150644891,
-0.01212255,
-0.00855429,
-0.0129334796,
-0.0001124067,
0.0010351936,
-0.041135665,
-0.0031508137,
-0.0103945695,
0.0102140699,
0.093869634,
0.0162324794,
-0.0152580598,
0.0047092205,
-0.0086785797,
0.0258089285,
0.0111731915,
-0.022080062,
0.0523764193,
-0.0440788269,
-0.0262530036,
-0.075646989,
-0.0356490836,
-0.0056981919,
0.0387439989,
0.0283399206,
0.013245617,
-0.003437442,
-0.0404824242,
-0.0384521894,
0.0320216119,
-0.06207335,
0.0080422498,
-0.0351417772,
-0.0620537624,
0.024401132,
0.0027151261,
-0.0538875982,
-0.0174120739,
-0.056267906,
-0.0637891144,
0.0213364344,
0.0022550651,
0.0283252541,
0.0419992916,
0.0008238869,
-0.0646329224,
0.0733188242,
-0.0071431664,
-0.0181522612,
0.038263198,
0.0696160942,
-0.0675753355,
0.0172820166,
0.0194979552,
-0.0238562301,
0.0464910604,
0.0724692792,
-0.0099397236,
-0.0387711078,
-0.0093205161,
0.0316580273,
0.0310035553,
0.0693635419,
-0.0142988078,
0.0081404531,
-0.033357136,
-0.0061584823,
-0.0213197172,
-0.0238066223,
-0.0144096073,
-0.0206948947,
0.0455474667,
0.0446955748,
-0.043115098,
0.0433287881,
-0.0426845998,
0.06722866,
-0.0287727062,
-0.00139802,
0.0096775563,
0.0116315251,
0.0235005543,
0.0165722053,
-0.0040078848,
0.0054522697,
-0.0044369339,
0.0248571821,
-0.0021221279,
0.0174525212,
0.0072603328,
0.0140827578,
-0.037620537,
0.014676149,
-0.0705866665,
-0.0199020803,
-0.0091628088,
0.0138747077,
0.0320653543,
-0.0663238913,
0.0036997076,
-0.0286476221,
-0.0060059298,
-0.0156612471,
0.027232904,
0.001965727,
-0.0178427622,
0.0531037301,
-0.0099178124,
-0.0474742167,
0.0221874751,
0.090605028,
0.059920352,
0.0527456626,
-0.0076365848,
-0.0158290733,
-0.0478300154,
0.022017803,
0.0587434731,
0.0482348949,
0.006423743,
0.0074471398,
-0.0536674485,
-0.0750840232,
0.0154873636,
-0.0181695633,
0.0035221577,
0.0097987466,
0.0220149606,
0.0677589104,
-0.0208771229,
-0.0041376818,
-0.0520927683,
-0.0048276237,
0.0400742106,
0.015355438,
-0.0299975481,
-6.136488261e-33,
-0.0213989373,
0.0102504771,
-0.0116605731,
-0.0060525239,
0.033816874,
0.0096343253,
0.0064912764,
-0.0004951747,
-0.0469400994,
0.013738527,
-0.0220748577,
0.0027746214,
0.0256924015,
0.0146798743,
-0.0651059896,
-0.0135292076,
0.0408086702,
0.0051708585,
-0.0357751176,
-0.0469953194,
0.0025222637,
0.0477662198,
0.0495097749,
-0.0622022524,
0.0133877266,
-0.0337650739,
0.0096550649,
-0.0112816682,
0.0216040649,
0.039844431,
-0.0422044098,
0.0431493632,
0.0337909982,
-0.0244479962,
-0.038918905,
0.0300322399,
-0.0638749078,
-0.0414938591,
0.0636883155,
0.0111821555,
0.021350231,
0.0025832842,
0.0382327922,
-0.031600222,
-0.0346834771,
0.0249084067,
0.0486368984,
-0.0314351842,
-0.0260417722,
-0.0322445817,
-0.0453830026,
0.0267073736,
0.0177089106,
0.0019650508,
0.0290597882,
0.0125766862,
-0.0071610427,
0.0077876486,
-0.0333813354,
0.007463112,
0.0559607968,
0.0227993298,
0.0438373983,
0.0543877557,
0.0471467152,
0.0450344868,
0.030824149,
0.009800896,
-0.0061836089,
0.0105794938,
0.0903687105,
-0.0051095416,
0.0295782387,
0.0512034893,
0.0411454476,
-0.0341396779,
-0.0523343459,
0.0236976407,
-0.0603964143,
-0.069862105,
0.0273993779,
0.0467601605,
-0.0478351004,
-0.0575821325,
-0.0780021921,
0.0016794241,
-0.0263834782,
-0.0051142499,
0.0483589582,
-0.0007197675,
-0.0179909095,
0.0333377123,
0.0157790799,
-0.0540579595,
-0.0331965722,
0.0163052976,
0.0069828685,
0.0181110669,
-0.0080502275,
0.0080217524,
-0.0624177717,
-0.0381633528,
0.010805591,
0.0355293714,
0.0218278784,
-0.0080876183,
0.0353122577,
0.0085119428,
-0.0716318041,
-0.0049251397,
-0.0112527553,
-0.0292471144,
0.0165686011,
-0.0091865817,
0.0359795839,
0.0351057388,
0.0001339565,
0.0125785423,
0.0588804297,
-0.052570533,
-0.0269253999,
0.0571603104,
-0.0110970726,
0.0597593896,
-0.0191291012,
-0.0063232654,
-0.0230727121,
0.0266771857,
0.1081694067,
-0.0211771242,
-0.0177544951,
-0.0316200629,
2.383e-7,
0.0774783045,
0.0045786095,
-0.0101181269,
0.020957347,
-0.0229142159,
0.0258206557,
0.0023007798,
0.0204047356,
0.0214341078,
-0.025429301,
0.0180588569,
-0.0096493382,
0.0199437849,
-0.0057252818,
-0.0387716591,
-0.0218328089,
-0.03391698,
-0.0057201548,
-0.0410564691,
0.0214887708,
0.0254016574,
0.1251783222,
0.0567760877,
0.0008023275,
-0.0232896395,
-0.0717767403,
0.0573981553,
-0.0628051385,
-0.0225098953,
0.0350365266,
0.0062726499,
0.0532588288,
0.0237470996,
0.0568917468,
-0.0166323986,
0.0417454764,
0.0447551496,
0.0464263,
-0.0036998456,
0.0214749873,
-0.0167224556,
-0.0139322476,
-0.0639092997,
-0.0653208941,
0.0759560838,
-0.0539441705,
-0.0157325175,
-0.0251369458,
-0.0214112345,
0.0431462303,
0.0226660259,
-0.0122783231,
-0.0221881252,
0.0251344964,
0.0514376685,
0.007006817,
-0.0216928143,
-0.0657126829,
-0.0275923181,
0.0374145173,
-0.0297268629,
-0.0373103544,
0.0017094846,
-0.0366430394,
0.0512471162,
-0.0584422462,
0.0339736082,
2.470277042e-34,
0.0217750818,
0.0130450167,
0.0103081977,
-0.0001845385,
0.0492396206,
-0.0257986356,
0.0222522821,
0.0317286253,
-0.0037473699,
-0.0674832985,
0.0316131189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16251v1 | Speakerly: A Voice-based Writing Assistant for Text Composition | 2023-10-24T23:53:15 | 2023-10-24T23:53:15 | Dhruv Kumar, Vipul Raheja, Alice Kaiser-Schatzlein, Robyn Perry, Apurva Joshi, Justin Hugues-Nuger, Samuel Lou, Navid Chowdhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present Speakerly, a new real-time voice-based writing assistance system
that helps users with text composition across various use cases such as emails,
instant messages, and notes. The user can interact with the system through
instructions or dictation, and the system generates a well-formatted and
coherent document. We describe the system architecture and detail how we
address the various challenges while building and deploying such a system at
scale. More specifically, our system uses a combination of small, task-specific
models as well as pre-trained language models for fast and effective text
composition while supporting a variety of input modes for better usability. | [
0.0058039571,
-0.006886309,
0.0168552659,
-0.0284699444,
-0.0355395377,
-0.0269303899,
0.0536584333,
-0.0287413038,
-0.0061277524,
-0.0397830643,
-0.0270660575,
-0.04547121,
0.0329689793,
0.0637305379,
0.0029342035,
-0.0830579549,
-0.0096905166,
-0.034913227,
0.0324765928,
0.0266690478,
0.0489050001,
0.0286859386,
-0.0606573746,
0.0657570958,
-0.0387623124,
-0.0623441786,
-0.0454068258,
0.0168119296,
-0.0373367295,
0.0247782916,
-0.0044441288,
0.073488839,
0.0192467514,
0.0059326757,
0.0000017486,
-0.0190206077,
0.0116037307,
-0.0219402835,
0.0279724281,
-0.0053535751,
0.0515934862,
0.0107386019,
-0.0407858826,
0.0537926853,
0.0041242619,
0.012081556,
0.0442110077,
0.0539995655,
0.0538322702,
0.0703254715,
-0.0331106558,
0.0079676211,
0.0095574986,
-0.017013019,
0.0114728073,
0.0241147727,
-0.019066643,
-0.0271754954,
0.037686944,
-0.0243166778,
0.0379600525,
0.0381253995,
-0.0092247874,
-0.0835977122,
0.0119766658,
0.0302079823,
-0.0166799538,
-0.0090254396,
-0.0026229818,
0.0536488444,
0.0124888914,
0.0030109645,
0.014377824,
-0.0046573514,
0.0004567166,
-0.0202438105,
-0.0478193313,
0.0029698545,
-0.0279639307,
-0.0223639905,
-0.0086397137,
-0.0112239579,
0.0030124807,
-0.0065589249,
0.0537381768,
-0.0190647673,
0.0190255381,
-0.0193102639,
-0.0000515324,
0.0125781232,
0.0200720746,
-0.0934436843,
0.0761376843,
0.0558199696,
-0.0090205083,
-0.0211303756,
-0.0809000134,
-0.0787828192,
-0.0301156882,
-0.044355236,
0.0804540887,
0.0094824592,
0.0250602365,
-0.0033076878,
0.0207668077,
0.0335591696,
0.001574896,
-0.0153831216,
-0.0039800396,
0.0139971515,
-0.0122593641,
-0.0211736504,
-0.0681951493,
0.0271186084,
-0.0206023417,
-0.0606574938,
-0.0363662131,
0.0272424445,
0.0101704104,
0.0146221938,
0.0441061817,
0.0122883413,
-0.0264627077,
0.002348654,
0.0315719843,
0.001301233,
0.005593894,
0.0542929433,
0.0259316582,
0.0178372208,
0.0241451524,
0.0170976594,
0.0483367294,
0.0240815915,
-0.0119669121,
0.0399243757,
-0.0226303022,
-0.017612366,
-0.0137050087,
-0.0158802439,
-0.0383688137,
-0.0590132959,
-0.0571995936,
-0.0756900609,
-0.0037886875,
0.0210373104,
-0.0246179346,
-0.0284297988,
0.0161468778,
0.040192686,
0.0194107369,
0.0153688481,
-0.0241206102,
0.0220798384,
0.0776165202,
-0.0204888228,
-0.0265449509,
0.0244076867,
0.0737323016,
0.0287229307,
0.0045547253,
-0.0047356416,
0.0575314239,
0.040032316,
-0.0274410229,
-0.0138501804,
0.0040328987,
-0.0507403724,
-0.022079682,
0.0331632346,
-0.0169495959,
0.0738071501,
-0.0017092867,
0.0638480559,
0.1237540096,
0.0431514122,
0.035973601,
0.0142339971,
0.0338703692,
0.0340889283,
-0.0183949564,
0.0045768586,
-0.0301691014,
0.0509048551,
-0.0084500657,
0.0490998738,
0.042874705,
-0.014870028,
-0.0290475562,
-0.0533851199,
-0.0319404081,
-0.0292018484,
-0.0235916693,
-0.0278795063,
0.0319016874,
-0.0013814348,
-0.0523276143,
0.0477193855,
-0.0173877776,
-0.1184321195,
0.0180999935,
0.0160610788,
0.0110952053,
0.0993754417,
0.0349920765,
-0.0263697766,
0.0122563355,
-0.056731075,
0.0573398657,
0.0568998158,
0.0162476357,
0.0051141689,
0.0172734,
-0.0217197984,
0.0345513821,
-0.0246543046,
-0.0068551884,
-0.0272040516,
0.0001084391,
0.0448904745,
0.0284356717,
0.0032205591,
-0.0313582271,
0.0238824878,
-0.0151825342,
-0.0510845967,
0.0014118426,
0.0194396917,
-0.0319947377,
0.015194471,
-0.0447240397,
0.022849584,
-0.0012635891,
-0.0310196579,
0.0027318972,
0.0241222456,
-0.0530824102,
0.0007845609,
0.0034030818,
-0.0353859514,
0.0448293798,
0.0201470889,
0.02010669,
-0.0582691468,
0.0009583788,
-0.0347035602,
0.0116803572,
-0.0311538316,
0.0290897526,
0.0044003949,
-0.0504315235,
0.0318388566,
-0.0060704486,
0.0249634925,
-0.0198200792,
0.0019370742,
0.0232860353,
0.0132109625,
-0.0303784646,
-0.0340481624,
0.0171781965,
-0.012593247,
0.0375732444,
-0.0069648148,
0.0027326918,
-0.0190658811,
-0.0629101396,
-0.1222139597,
0.0112410951,
-0.0223069526,
-0.0348987281,
0.0482673049,
0.0286135525,
0.0062354482,
-0.0243714973,
-0.0558540411,
-0.016274238,
0.0148818335,
-0.0078801308,
0.0155289695,
-0.0264275204,
0.0254918523,
-0.0615208857,
0.0030155559,
-0.000482906,
-0.0001778322,
0.0428736657,
-0.0470614918,
-0.0478687584,
0.0377385989,
0.0119584007,
0.0080142142,
0.0237888247,
-0.0285215396,
0.0158148743,
-0.0161302797,
0.067403473,
0.0687139258,
0.0424109548,
0.0242985506,
0.0609226637,
-0.0000884731,
0.010272597,
0.0149544673,
-0.010766902,
0.0454719886,
-0.0055871247,
-0.0176149663,
-0.0096568,
0.0572528616,
0.0386753641,
0.0347847007,
-0.0457736589,
0.017208511,
-0.0331658274,
-0.0065541253,
0.0055653434,
-0.0269205533,
-0.0561212674,
0.0017459586,
-0.0150140487,
-0.0673765168,
0.0150459884,
-0.0557949767,
-0.0324640945,
0.005703697,
-0.0477993004,
-0.0188109707,
0.0577166453,
-0.0253834818,
0.019186575,
-0.0087374588,
-0.0361160375,
-0.0458984934,
0.0259049926,
0.0379443206,
-0.0219222493,
0.0055717533,
-0.0442066938,
0.0247174483,
-0.0115008373,
-0.0654388815,
-0.0191265512,
-0.0189683307,
-0.0401806422,
0.0130820498,
0.0424779058,
-0.0395192839,
-0.0268388838,
0.0389398597,
0.0297913235,
0.091947861,
-0.0254417602,
0.0207839664,
-0.039875254,
0.0083452836,
0.036532823,
-0.0242632236,
-0.065650858,
-0.0511674844,
0.039623756,
0.0109011773,
0.0394064188,
0.0164559763,
-0.0114487968,
-0.0321921892,
-0.0008214946,
-0.0436205789,
-0.0308017116,
0.003569935,
0.077328369,
-0.0301507246,
-0.0114991171,
0.1312235445,
0.0012326624,
-0.0503687523,
-0.0301344171,
0.0015233753,
0.0301866941,
0.0209797136,
0.0444951132,
-0.0525216348,
-0.0226928648,
0.0407967158,
0.0410117954,
0.0352149568,
0.0132072102,
-0.0205722358,
-0.0428158976,
0.0267357603,
0.0190961454,
-0.0138446288,
0.0080632847,
-0.0189469364,
-0.0145553881,
0.0318255201,
-0.022534579,
-0.0076936362,
-0.0483972132,
-0.0135250166,
-0.0058494974,
-0.0692365989,
0.0174917076,
-0.0137761813,
-0.0158403423,
0.0327739231,
0.0606838278,
0.0725156665,
0.0218316056,
-0.0281376801,
-0.0029558183,
0.0239623319,
0.0126781035,
0.0050207064,
0.0248617399,
-0.0160151683,
0.0035455737,
-0.0370405614,
0.0598773323,
-0.0129596917,
0.0032549996,
0.0353083573,
0.0129397511,
-0.0280645061,
-0.0001177601,
-0.0197507888,
0.0475028753,
0.0629028231,
0.0212251022,
0.0261124205,
-0.103641808,
-0.0827608183,
-0.024493631,
0.0067186267,
-0.0683185235,
-0.0100491112,
-0.0140546048,
-0.0114030708,
0.0018464198,
-0.0731777251,
-0.0333454907,
0.0595657751,
0.0525606349,
0.029553039,
0.0180486813,
0.018607771,
0.0279162824,
-0.0548778512,
-0.0364568271,
0.0358360335,
0.0621652752,
-0.0943935588,
-0.0498610735,
-0.0212919973,
-0.0321307145,
0.0171744637,
-0.0029730238,
-0.0782419667,
-0.0727535337,
0.0139482738,
0.0216735024,
0.0124352286,
0.035936188,
-0.0256614182,
-0.0491653457,
0.0428926423,
-0.002110529,
-0.0195081569,
0.040104147,
0.0269345362,
0.0032339939,
0.0150486119,
0.0275794677,
-0.045139309,
-0.0046904045,
0.0013768848,
0.0124145839,
0.0024370837,
-0.0655905381,
-0.0269903485,
-0.0118686799,
0.0145297674,
-0.0132117039,
0.0124972751,
-0.0581576191,
0.0232897773,
-0.0340439081,
-0.0056097261,
-0.0473657846,
0.020021949,
-0.0168990903,
0.0342749879,
0.0105898762,
0.0196131095,
-0.0347992256,
0.0102718025,
-0.0018492518,
0.0369781479,
-0.0230166502,
0.0127111059,
0.0483034812,
0.0019515023,
-0.0294509605,
0.0542509779,
-0.0266809296,
0.0178599134,
0.0026917763,
0.0375340134,
-0.0023225255,
-0.0013660042,
0.029864667,
0.0209404994,
-0.0612759739,
-0.0254736375,
-0.0385914892,
0.0308888666,
0.0395240895,
-0.007228421,
0.0550410487,
-0.0240223221,
0.022258075,
-0.0527331941,
0.0802324414,
-0.0002689092,
-0.029095538,
-0.0449650809,
-0.0250330027,
0.0058075972,
-0.0278384201,
0.0853330866,
-0.0038064686,
0.0009667123,
0.0242000744,
0.0053729815,
-0.0432896949,
-0.0191328712,
-0.0019702106,
0.0586592071,
0.0067323409,
-0.0187927578,
-0.0136779081,
-0.020510463,
0.0709544346,
-0.0150585119,
-0.0318764299,
-0.0576949865,
0.0170698967,
0.0136255277,
-0.0219127797,
0.0104321009,
-0.0516941473,
-0.0047521018,
-0.0340110026,
-0.0140203265,
0.0086320443,
-4.800449667e-33,
-0.0250386018,
-0.0686552301,
0.0172066204,
0.0401825123,
0.0073182015,
0.0113245752,
-0.0084361937,
0.047986798,
0.0349833257,
-0.0046674041,
-0.0239346381,
0.0067453478,
0.0146557372,
0.0508214161,
-0.0291859433,
0.0479724109,
0.0754956082,
-0.0212344546,
-0.0093176402,
0.04965638,
0.0294863321,
0.0254779626,
0.0180710461,
-0.0743291676,
0.0036666545,
-0.0459325649,
-0.0075746262,
-0.0222788081,
0.0273152962,
0.0099759679,
0.0107842386,
0.0301409382,
-0.0113745704,
0.020674007,
-0.0164724682,
0.0932490528,
-0.0045006853,
-0.0221479908,
-0.0158858951,
0.0139598157,
-0.0414410792,
-0.0250659436,
-0.0089427568,
-0.0056573073,
0.0057804333,
-0.0111086946,
0.0705421716,
0.0122661451,
-0.0208291151,
-0.0459673218,
-0.0720202699,
0.0073799645,
-0.0063115926,
-0.0538922548,
-0.0015309046,
0.0396679007,
-0.0028423122,
-0.0533042699,
-0.06714499,
0.0460560471,
-0.0042989179,
0.0246819183,
0.0370874368,
0.0254733097,
-0.0309521277,
0.0637927726,
0.0008723909,
0.0168862622,
-0.0334936008,
0.0087107271,
0.0073254602,
0.0411814116,
0.042040579,
0.0361930169,
-0.0115370899,
-0.0132554285,
0.0147853075,
0.0166458674,
-0.0052518379,
-0.0461250767,
0.0387929603,
0.0157246552,
-0.0240017772,
-0.0062256479,
-0.0587110296,
0.0041415086,
-0.0153224096,
-0.0459315702,
0.0478621237,
0.0145195974,
0.0237871818,
-0.032464195,
0.002374582,
0.0342549272,
-0.0363743715,
-0.0089213261,
-0.0386971459,
0.043515563,
-0.0351178274,
-0.0095813619,
-0.0312863477,
0.0090238582,
0.0284024626,
0.0654966682,
0.0356759652,
0.027817497,
0.0032731374,
0.0379888415,
-0.0631539747,
0.0017514967,
-0.0053070947,
0.062380936,
0.0183543209,
0.0215625409,
0.0368772037,
-0.0297051501,
-0.0328192078,
0.0618466362,
-0.0273882039,
-0.0158103276,
-0.0374131463,
-0.0762910098,
-0.0102762664,
0.0049032774,
-0.0443506725,
0.0210648514,
-0.0083053913,
0.0099198092,
0.0366498902,
-0.0212128945,
0.0129384054,
-0.0260153282,
2.297e-7,
0.0143499058,
0.0241838787,
0.0311058424,
0.0150842592,
0.0167089961,
0.0326791964,
-0.013867205,
0.0444607101,
-0.0320123322,
0.047444731,
0.0010070604,
0.0099244928,
0.0923754722,
0.0104230139,
-0.1239121333,
-0.0217446629,
-0.0948303193,
0.0395611599,
-0.0639336854,
0.0139004895,
0.0429829471,
0.011783842,
0.0093102995,
-0.0191128291,
0.0164954811,
-0.0460303575,
0.0545651503,
-0.0181982294,
0.0333199129,
-0.0319473818,
0.0163020678,
-0.0292684492,
-0.0270292144,
-0.0188144762,
-0.0512801073,
-0.0346689001,
0.0300698988,
0.0886212662,
-0.0290019196,
-0.0027830878,
0.029381102,
0.0329951979,
-0.0239364542,
-0.0154024288,
0.0399980098,
-0.0074168867,
0.0117044738,
-0.0479877293,
0.0049751708,
-0.0301558021,
-0.0153683266,
-0.0072086416,
0.0133895613,
0.0179384816,
-0.0058432096,
-0.028040465,
-0.0021165302,
-0.0319230407,
-0.0351909846,
0.017825583,
-0.0086304191,
0.0067899278,
-0.0974769741,
-0.0178199839,
-0.0038730521,
-0.0413171872,
0.008859871,
1.727295506e-34,
0.0033030175,
-0.0070050601,
0.0097832279,
0.0364150517,
0.0193563104,
0.0314794406,
0.0474581011,
0.0036965106,
0.0270829927,
-0.0552746765,
-0.0398622304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16248v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16248v3 | GlotLID: Language Identification for Low-Resource Languages | 2023-10-24T23:45:57 | 2024-07-02T23:34:35 | Amir Hossein Kargaran, Ayyoob Imani, François Yvon, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several recent papers have published good solutions for language
identification (LID) for about 300 high-resource and medium-resource languages.
However, there is no LID available that (i) covers a wide range of low-resource
languages, (ii) is rigorously evaluated and reliable and (iii) efficient and
easy to use. Here, we publish GlotLID-M, an LID model that satisfies the
desiderata of wide coverage, reliability and efficiency. It identifies 1665
languages, a large increase in coverage compared to prior work. In our
experiments, GlotLID-M outperforms four baselines (CLD3, FT176, OpenLID and
NLLB) when balancing F1 and false positive rate (FPR). We analyze the unique
challenges that low-resource LID poses: incorrect corpus metadata, leakage from
high-resource languages, difficulty separating closely related languages,
handling of macrolanguage vs varieties and in general noisy data. We hope that
integrating GlotLID-M into dataset creation pipelines will improve quality and
enhance accessibility of NLP technology for low-resource languages and
cultures. GlotLID-M model (including future versions), code, and list of data
sources are available: https://github.com/cisnlp/GlotLID. | [
0.0144749777,
0.0811869726,
-0.0121103199,
0.0655962676,
-0.0363713205,
0.0179154407,
0.0112094386,
0.0011865908,
-0.0191614069,
0.0032147469,
-0.0280829631,
-0.0353858992,
0.0329265855,
0.0235211682,
0.0157445129,
-0.0165515617,
0.0655853227,
-0.0305122565,
0.0173004158,
0.0096471207,
0.0088539999,
0.0113597671,
0.0080386102,
0.0228791293,
-0.0174807087,
-0.003659925,
0.030424621,
-0.0010984681,
0.0193197019,
-0.0089773089,
0.020317968,
0.0546140149,
-0.0330158509,
0.1182114109,
0.0000019625,
-0.0553392619,
-0.0421828404,
-0.0332542099,
-0.0408785902,
0.0018910583,
0.0384327993,
-0.0314966142,
-0.004887478,
0.005573954,
0.0197776277,
-0.0874455422,
0.0976415426,
-0.0168836005,
-0.0011510198,
0.0306039099,
0.0056158979,
0.0082096439,
-0.0280197654,
0.0207201391,
-0.0222680159,
-0.0067913709,
0.0074057449,
-0.0279270485,
-0.0085714739,
-0.0324024409,
0.003117963,
0.0324284248,
-0.0433483347,
0.0098403618,
-0.0484251082,
0.0030242312,
-0.1066325754,
-0.0572570637,
0.0145250391,
0.0433909819,
-0.0205939468,
-0.0780020356,
0.0066621122,
0.030802507,
-0.0281787142,
-0.0150487395,
-0.0086731734,
0.0395828597,
-0.030821668,
0.0015623874,
0.0645954683,
0.0345274098,
0.0243931487,
-0.0095891738,
0.0093121901,
0.0201089326,
0.0216161273,
0.0081056673,
0.015049885,
-0.005254535,
-0.0018919682,
-0.0188615564,
0.0130905034,
-0.0166638363,
-0.0045010126,
-0.0143667273,
-0.0111528682,
-0.0391697325,
0.028064115,
-0.0233592205,
-0.0132390419,
0.0045666499,
-0.0639713034,
0.0432555862,
-0.0529699139,
0.0260313638,
0.0320802703,
-0.0520278402,
-0.0054463213,
-0.0334555395,
0.012960704,
0.0222721584,
-0.0087841591,
-0.0146669867,
-0.0139986444,
0.0317841806,
-0.0271225162,
-0.0089476025,
-0.0084074102,
0.0329171643,
-0.0759913921,
-0.0568108484,
-0.0072831786,
0.0317687243,
0.0300757177,
0.0337617919,
0.0135085015,
-0.0238996781,
-0.0582901314,
-0.1077772602,
-0.0253923628,
0.0525508747,
0.0157835241,
-0.0187042486,
0.0461008102,
0.0443948619,
0.0032085553,
-0.0542328581,
-0.0611668937,
-0.0069283517,
0.004011794,
-0.0426977873,
0.008988481,
-0.0929252356,
0.0192755274,
0.0273186937,
0.0493384786,
-0.0314378627,
-0.0183449686,
-0.0093386667,
0.0213895459,
0.0597577319,
-0.0659136325,
0.0074250926,
0.0043379785,
-0.0157120805,
0.0114568323,
0.0857145563,
-0.0316537917,
-0.0032776853,
0.0874980241,
-0.0208238792,
0.0035902651,
0.0585029721,
-0.0116891209,
0.0353090689,
0.012039124,
-0.0182834379,
0.0310977548,
-0.0319837891,
0.0495766401,
0.0404408015,
0.0213657636,
-0.0007750819,
0.0363287181,
0.0573665984,
-0.0205582734,
0.0182048082,
0.0070873885,
0.0216269903,
0.0234626941,
-0.0285130441,
0.0222597644,
-0.0239877831,
-0.0484049134,
-0.0183311366,
-0.0024999694,
0.0543926768,
-0.0130865863,
0.0077505703,
-0.0523713939,
-0.0480947047,
-0.0235507302,
0.0096786832,
0.0574578829,
-0.0310443789,
0.0283450596,
0.0467232615,
0.0543396845,
-0.0015627248,
-0.0057762982,
-0.0329252854,
0.050870005,
-0.001551601,
0.0306859165,
-0.0476938114,
0.0038411338,
-0.0313719548,
0.0011170893,
0.0695817694,
0.0185910072,
-0.0393535309,
0.0350087322,
-0.0449161269,
0.0219103266,
0.0276733153,
0.0344108157,
0.030769933,
0.0212693959,
0.0205267631,
-0.0056474851,
-0.0485800654,
-0.025871953,
0.0162970945,
-0.0225375723,
-0.037575677,
0.0241083503,
0.0051585375,
0.0174424201,
0.0253677163,
-0.0160564184,
-0.027715493,
-0.0276033822,
-0.0031273637,
0.0287536569,
0.0085871574,
-0.000354424,
-0.033171583,
0.0461972766,
0.0046129925,
-0.0676818639,
0.0465088636,
-0.0058839293,
-0.0268111639,
0.0234812088,
-0.0283405408,
0.0142855328,
-0.0351813473,
0.0483948328,
-0.0214501619,
0.0185974482,
-0.01265206,
0.045714736,
-0.0076883463,
0.0461366251,
0.0091924723,
-0.0375143252,
0.0783641413,
-0.0585058592,
-0.0624190904,
0.0124052614,
-0.0562236421,
0.0165253654,
0.0233744793,
0.055069454,
0.0130017065,
0.0300642475,
-0.0383061059,
-0.009839274,
-0.0470407754,
0.0210082084,
-0.0128667857,
0.0203365702,
-0.0161843169,
-0.0200352594,
-0.0020918616,
-0.0027415555,
0.0096163135,
0.0230206233,
0.0081747118,
-0.0314524435,
0.0026226814,
-0.005062608,
0.0091006858,
0.0349519923,
0.0400302336,
0.0117148021,
-0.0754762292,
-0.0174435601,
0.0049007647,
-0.0179749858,
0.0307329036,
0.0162329618,
-0.0188184232,
-0.0503567643,
-0.0222846884,
-0.0077346982,
-0.0125633869,
-0.0788188204,
-0.0028602548,
0.0428431109,
0.0141891176,
-0.0278202742,
-0.0269282348,
-0.0127064483,
-0.0203855541,
0.0138034904,
-0.0578651801,
0.0101356003,
0.0397704877,
-0.0229898561,
-0.0074923919,
-0.0093229301,
-0.0146583887,
-0.0297852959,
0.0262490772,
0.0117153255,
0.0352808349,
-0.0005332234,
0.0479649454,
-0.0140763829,
-0.0809098929,
0.0471358225,
-0.0455221273,
-0.0328780189,
-0.05417265,
-0.021194024,
-0.0359861888,
0.015886724,
-0.0180680677,
0.0294080526,
0.0338901468,
-0.0618968755,
0.026803093,
0.0592953898,
0.0371955819,
-0.0284349285,
0.0540432073,
-0.0478571467,
0.0240545701,
-0.0431480631,
-0.0450596288,
-0.031797938,
-0.0090702372,
-0.0233691987,
0.0205134265,
-0.0011261414,
-0.0262416378,
0.0000783385,
0.0200174619,
0.0321021006,
0.0497775301,
0.0067385668,
0.0461775176,
-0.0009709521,
0.0683417097,
0.0120121269,
-0.0191301517,
0.0771948546,
0.017183423,
0.0078668753,
0.0182901155,
0.0375401601,
0.0104081389,
0.0172610227,
-0.0012850553,
0.0423559807,
-0.0043694004,
-0.038045086,
0.0071039451,
0.0362796709,
0.0021092475,
-0.024950983,
0.0886725783,
0.0121636447,
-0.077795133,
0.0029032812,
-0.0061520492,
0.0171605386,
0.0128877517,
0.0007343888,
-0.0755891725,
-0.0244108234,
0.0508864522,
0.0466584601,
-0.0300819091,
-0.0266732778,
-0.0055108429,
-0.1261485517,
0.0086569833,
0.0207847636,
-0.0207282361,
-0.0529196523,
-0.0526005365,
-0.0058365557,
-0.0254513212,
0.0028141669,
-0.0125088319,
0.0010542672,
-0.0045457743,
0.0096469475,
-0.0478828438,
-0.1006037742,
0.0321427509,
-0.0425966829,
0.065384604,
-0.0008190432,
-0.0126686012,
-0.0732926428,
0.0263041779,
0.0332121067,
-0.0249771588,
-0.0854131728,
-0.0553710125,
0.0521211028,
0.0519163571,
-0.0305684619,
0.0167977735,
-0.013169772,
-0.0231823251,
-0.008353984,
0.0287952032,
0.0496616177,
0.0279860757,
-0.0278751664,
0.0539938249,
-0.0162253696,
0.0254276656,
0.0620114356,
0.0363175273,
-0.020288419,
-0.0033464311,
-0.0316606909,
-0.0121820858,
-0.0174323041,
-0.0354246832,
0.0351038203,
-0.010609895,
-0.0685050637,
-0.030893052,
-0.0413806103,
0.0251190625,
0.0292163417,
0.0334405079,
0.0232455283,
-0.0155061558,
0.0094112074,
-0.0619287454,
0.0577954873,
-0.0134462286,
0.0093340734,
-0.0889148265,
-0.0356466547,
0.0344238617,
-0.0053530037,
0.0039115977,
0.0517845824,
-0.0800427347,
-0.0386084169,
0.007743876,
0.009164948,
0.0223666057,
0.0091135697,
-0.0021271571,
-0.0530873537,
0.0109817861,
0.032422781,
0.0026306983,
0.0148922363,
0.0291312076,
-0.0246094745,
-0.0297451615,
0.0354861617,
-0.0384277105,
-0.0101026762,
0.0590224005,
0.0040445542,
-0.0318516828,
0.0228474662,
0.0294400826,
0.0563556775,
0.0372487381,
-0.0550598912,
-0.0044493666,
-0.0583918393,
-0.0482409112,
0.0317383409,
0.008025106,
-0.0203954745,
-0.0085976869,
0.04699504,
0.0167027004,
-0.0173654258,
-0.008867505,
0.0094796298,
0.0482418239,
-0.0295733158,
0.0457056426,
0.0152910324,
0.0567212552,
0.0200627614,
-0.0033616063,
-0.0347421542,
0.0436409898,
0.0146008395,
0.0654134899,
-0.0316838436,
0.0090433657,
-0.0117622325,
-0.031632036,
-0.008002175,
0.0280632619,
0.0267852675,
0.00321356,
-0.0127336942,
0.0043908507,
0.0801451132,
-0.029802179,
0.0904736742,
-0.0307131335,
0.0019351237,
-0.0614415258,
0.0184459202,
-0.0028673364,
-0.0310821999,
-0.0009289137,
-0.0044334098,
-0.0640845075,
0.0146894101,
0.0652375221,
0.0509638414,
0.0038804193,
0.0078442572,
-0.0146412021,
-0.0075296974,
-0.0110461786,
0.0067454278,
-0.004111269,
-0.0512345769,
0.0159808118,
-0.0749822631,
-0.0855350941,
0.0237834305,
-0.032422889,
0.0332334526,
0.0383027457,
-0.031797193,
0.0383518524,
0.01151546,
0.0014752469,
-0.0705419704,
-0.0004401033,
-0.0193090905,
0.0012515831,
-0.0110043315,
-5.772744391e-33,
0.0025760892,
-0.0188311413,
-0.0389454663,
-0.0049094697,
0.0662611276,
0.0279203206,
-0.0325948708,
0.0101393359,
-0.0293054245,
-0.017786609,
0.0016061254,
-0.0355108604,
0.0319068059,
0.0082879355,
0.0014907554,
0.0210270397,
0.0053739417,
0.021733487,
-0.0097630611,
0.0293490533,
0.0523529798,
0.0006731979,
0.0852379203,
-0.083937563,
-0.0020120412,
-0.0210962202,
0.0104816044,
0.022396639,
0.0056490921,
0.0538693145,
-0.0432030894,
0.0515417904,
0.0241390038,
0.0186447017,
-0.0184407197,
-0.0283595622,
-0.0863311589,
-0.0307518933,
-0.0135290949,
0.0698281452,
0.0459861867,
-0.0204646178,
-0.014550345,
-0.0357968658,
-0.0389282368,
0.0258374251,
0.0093529988,
-0.0261517577,
-0.0249758214,
-0.0296129137,
-0.0322463885,
0.0599362403,
0.0160710681,
0.0214784704,
0.0719917193,
0.0548028052,
-0.0186393596,
-0.0210394133,
-0.0760146752,
0.0139140058,
-0.003473571,
0.025125185,
0.0542452298,
0.0530923493,
-0.0262893252,
0.0257803556,
0.0456645302,
-0.0265454985,
0.0603889227,
0.0323029272,
0.0501351357,
-0.042535089,
0.0290329084,
0.0558092445,
0.0202747583,
-0.0375850163,
-0.0300269425,
-0.0038277782,
0.0645032972,
-0.0167530049,
0.0093258554,
-0.0353319272,
-0.0752893835,
-0.0250732396,
-0.029636668,
-0.0679857954,
-0.0275778063,
0.0170186032,
0.0438721441,
-0.0117281461,
-0.000353642,
-0.005392916,
0.0740648881,
-0.0177126881,
-0.0012747174,
0.0014614956,
0.03959544,
0.0420580879,
-0.0075811096,
0.0542551763,
-0.0468332507,
-0.0396391787,
-0.0115177697,
-0.0258378498,
0.0415589735,
-0.0032122226,
0.0567919947,
0.0309687927,
-0.0570886545,
0.0323894396,
-0.0388408154,
0.0129121831,
0.0172815919,
0.0439121872,
0.0126715144,
-0.0288243014,
0.016541196,
0.0127575798,
0.0976715013,
-0.0067196153,
0.0174656045,
-0.0195402317,
-0.0386516638,
-0.0052224505,
-0.0194812864,
0.0021092987,
-0.0258974526,
0.0387005061,
-0.0053259032,
-0.0050744447,
0.0419338569,
-0.0210833531,
2.704e-7,
0.0125166262,
-0.0042621503,
0.0073962542,
-0.0037459983,
0.0028324898,
0.0181234982,
-0.0329517685,
0.0016489235,
-0.03320048,
0.0322406515,
-0.0447393842,
-0.0347723104,
0.1030490845,
0.0340432003,
-0.0796373188,
0.0161858257,
-0.0078006005,
0.0118842842,
-0.0472656563,
0.0003304243,
-0.0311925132,
0.1216766685,
-0.0080737341,
-0.0245879162,
-0.0067801145,
-0.0740378872,
0.0144888982,
-0.0065743881,
-0.010695505,
0.0362463258,
0.0326435082,
0.0312173348,
0.0024785525,
-0.0338964798,
-0.0404786877,
0.0030740001,
-0.0276650991,
0.0487392358,
-0.005671849,
-0.015858693,
0.0147449384,
-0.0249871612,
-0.0145945987,
-0.0562015325,
0.050308153,
0.0723857209,
-0.0235091932,
0.0171593465,
0.0115252072,
-0.0059219329,
-0.0198679231,
-0.0262030959,
-0.0473456196,
0.0437234677,
0.0103995744,
-0.0444016233,
-0.0550649092,
-0.0450232625,
-0.0162921492,
0.0210422147,
-0.0277849995,
-0.0300377607,
0.0516464859,
-0.0172562264,
-0.0004679931,
-0.0175461695,
0.0296431258,
3.012454985e-34,
-0.0016161348,
-0.0050030733,
-0.0226232689,
0.0343147144,
0.0131990435,
-0.041301053,
-0.0124118021,
0.0440051407,
-0.0341918916,
0.0181479547,
0.0208285265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16242v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16242v2 | ZzzGPT: An Interactive GPT Approach to Enhance Sleep Quality | 2023-10-24T23:30:17 | 2024-05-07T00:20:30 | Yonchanok Khaokaew, Kaixin Ji, Thuc Hanh Nguyen, Hiruni Kegalle, Marwah Alaofi, Hao Xue, Flora D. Salim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This paper explores the intersection of technology and sleep pattern
comprehension, presenting a cutting-edge two-stage framework that harnesses the
power of Large Language Models (LLMs). The primary objective is to deliver
precise sleep predictions paired with actionable feedback, addressing the
limitations of existing solutions. This innovative approach involves leveraging
the GLOBEM dataset alongside synthetic data generated by LLMs. The results
highlight significant improvements, underlining the efficacy of merging
advanced machine-learning techniques with a user-centric design ethos. Through
this exploration, we bridge the gap between technological sophistication and
user-friendly design, ensuring that our framework yields accurate predictions
and translates them into actionable insights. | [
0.0395983756,
0.0442099907,
-0.0260040406,
-0.017332742,
-0.0391723886,
0.0154931145,
0.0158693399,
-0.0185674112,
-0.0087839682,
-0.0189724639,
0.0027927149,
-0.0349636301,
0.0046344209,
0.0274812281,
0.0533842593,
-0.0156966168,
0.0138388351,
-0.0178418122,
0.0017989859,
0.0007511252,
-0.0311927777,
0.0242240503,
-0.0395784602,
0.0761574209,
0.020252591,
0.0038703817,
-0.0457059331,
-0.0259913821,
0.016281696,
-0.0512277111,
-0.0201251265,
0.071245268,
0.0174080674,
0.0361280702,
0.0000021843,
-0.020287931,
0.025401894,
0.0301913749,
0.0307475012,
-0.0025956582,
0.0555252731,
0.0021212872,
0.0248058178,
-0.0174445994,
-0.0020506911,
-0.0208615046,
0.067354992,
0.0093804086,
0.0260694232,
0.0478414707,
-0.0185577869,
0.0119185168,
-0.030136846,
-0.043889001,
0.0905456766,
0.011801837,
0.0482703447,
0.0190559886,
0.0281430744,
-0.0480718836,
-0.0067212121,
0.0392155945,
-0.0344584845,
0.023191724,
0.0406583063,
0.0085866172,
-0.0487605073,
-0.0675959438,
-0.0320691913,
0.0332097486,
0.0167514104,
0.013558019,
-0.0215154514,
0.0063704988,
-0.0172560271,
0.0026552198,
-0.0809801593,
-0.0187312216,
-0.0012607015,
0.0514218509,
0.0343274437,
-0.0013766699,
0.0653222427,
-0.0350300781,
-0.0402648747,
0.0348551273,
-0.0194584802,
-0.0278644376,
0.0312819332,
0.056600593,
0.0144563196,
0.0059159594,
0.0208132975,
-0.0384446308,
-0.0658416077,
-0.0144038759,
-0.0032854469,
-0.0288606156,
0.044876311,
-0.0156489667,
0.039700456,
0.050149098,
-0.0047592297,
0.0332355872,
-0.0130590387,
0.0356846526,
-0.0098602613,
-0.0187997837,
-0.0429469086,
-0.016354043,
-0.0659051389,
-0.0181602631,
-0.0198715758,
-0.0394848585,
-0.0006950513,
-0.0339044556,
-0.0698375851,
0.0110560525,
-0.0040973183,
0.0079737678,
0.0409404002,
0.0141822817,
-0.0071261846,
-0.0055190143,
-0.0180865321,
0.0086513404,
0.0471821092,
0.0066438229,
-0.0020077857,
-0.0376961902,
0.0093911244,
0.0251776483,
-0.0364073254,
0.0179339629,
-0.0212455634,
0.0271868482,
0.0400177725,
-0.0027277502,
-0.011042932,
-0.0006387903,
-0.0034050271,
-0.0058651483,
0.0040903701,
-0.0823691338,
-0.0098632891,
-0.0565495901,
0.0040129013,
-0.0147187114,
0.0003556175,
0.0136617161,
-0.0089768739,
0.0530713089,
-0.0322900824,
0.0051794304,
0.0121861286,
0.009181384,
0.0427974947,
0.0662592053,
0.0581331104,
0.0090870727,
0.0160135534,
-0.0826431811,
0.0387417078,
0.0427603386,
0.0018736589,
-0.0478942394,
0.0039934041,
-0.0093509275,
0.0097810235,
0.0308046583,
-0.038217701,
0.0271129031,
0.0261465162,
0.0167196728,
0.1286415458,
0.0586326271,
-0.0114663588,
0.0698393062,
-0.0128491437,
-0.0104330331,
-0.0365272053,
-0.044432044,
-0.0143420435,
0.0172164384,
-0.0239641927,
-0.0032057099,
0.0398844071,
0.0314475521,
-0.0084255459,
-0.0726211593,
-0.0244408455,
-0.010747809,
0.0263912622,
0.0597170517,
0.0611048713,
-0.059751492,
-0.0372323841,
0.0251727886,
0.029959958,
-0.0178113896,
-0.0236209985,
-0.0340060741,
0.0217834506,
0.0841150358,
0.0293641724,
-0.0092226285,
-0.0136846993,
-0.0135749104,
-0.0050674323,
0.0339055359,
0.0062652621,
0.0227173176,
0.0361386724,
-0.0346445739,
-0.0418864451,
0.0322874673,
-0.0079045538,
-0.0145614147,
0.0157771092,
0.0444662124,
0.00067566,
-0.0253357962,
-0.055588264,
-0.0066235182,
-0.0275070146,
0.0050905421,
0.03760124,
0.0174923986,
0.0198524203,
0.0395142399,
0.0050503444,
-0.0246129241,
0.0326295607,
-0.0508588813,
-0.0322823152,
0.0172797404,
-0.0411612652,
0.0549255982,
-0.0031328225,
0.0130651416,
0.0399979539,
0.0296967793,
-0.035643138,
-0.0030508321,
0.0148613844,
-0.0453671068,
0.0847242102,
-0.03048365,
-0.0203239694,
0.0027444276,
0.0456888825,
-0.0472713746,
0.000219464,
0.0057007908,
0.0073392591,
-0.0197103601,
-0.0198272504,
-0.0317902118,
-0.0500197746,
-0.0112894159,
0.0635946244,
-0.0326189138,
0.0195512623,
-0.0117669469,
0.0334849842,
-0.0430415832,
0.019397486,
-0.1122291833,
-0.0155967502,
0.0198760256,
-0.0021240232,
0.0171068218,
-0.007877619,
-0.0233618766,
-0.0222687554,
-0.0601640083,
0.0076324381,
0.0163932163,
-0.0090806969,
-0.0097850589,
0.0199614689,
-0.0713573769,
-0.0377495363,
-0.0201662648,
-0.0324232765,
-0.0154952658,
0.0018619739,
-0.0321355201,
-0.0462410524,
-0.0308705457,
-0.0252965875,
-0.0195404366,
0.0000590732,
-0.0296660438,
0.0156743042,
-0.0327284597,
0.0545800515,
0.0369726457,
-0.0008473503,
0.0026132835,
0.0716589019,
-0.0265414603,
0.0208875407,
-0.0024416239,
-0.0376291983,
-0.0387094319,
-0.021357581,
-0.0882872194,
-0.0501257814,
0.0914158151,
0.0368742608,
0.0016675043,
-0.0290368516,
0.0253506079,
-0.0282748044,
0.0202570986,
-0.0435668491,
0.0241441224,
-0.0130064311,
0.0673853457,
0.0193955284,
-0.0683362558,
0.0570676662,
-0.0250833239,
-0.0215204917,
-0.0458469279,
-0.0527485088,
0.0122100748,
0.0522276573,
-0.0229446981,
0.0084261391,
0.0120977974,
-0.0123416511,
0.0060093594,
-0.0349481031,
0.0120313307,
-0.0147590404,
0.0077273957,
-0.0795136243,
-0.048447907,
0.0026834945,
-0.0455928557,
-0.0249427892,
-0.0161087476,
-0.0657888725,
-0.06598901,
0.0181693565,
-0.0169116762,
-0.0239737947,
0.0051815505,
0.0150357168,
0.0002353273,
0.0124907242,
-0.0194240045,
0.0202693846,
-0.0154976062,
0.068994619,
0.0498160534,
-0.0108551942,
0.0322071686,
-0.0142327975,
0.0409360044,
-0.0179139823,
0.0507087484,
-0.0240278542,
0.0496210232,
0.0289974418,
0.0293957964,
0.0059689814,
0.0320013426,
0.0508346744,
-0.0524782613,
0.0438598208,
0.1155546084,
0.0196595304,
-0.0365991332,
0.0059099076,
0.0028011363,
0.0345765129,
-0.0287425332,
0.033191625,
-0.0776895136,
-0.0147925951,
-0.0026632831,
0.0646287426,
-0.0314775407,
-0.0011198909,
0.0127769634,
-0.0180182699,
0.0630906597,
0.0324348211,
-0.0360741504,
-0.0421773233,
-0.0762800425,
-0.0054852497,
-0.041886732,
-0.0122708082,
0.0035943124,
0.0128282886,
-0.0011850322,
-0.0014391643,
-0.0818924159,
-0.0165113285,
0.0561066419,
0.0069184201,
0.0549377054,
0.1019691527,
0.0234409589,
0.022506848,
-0.031766817,
-0.0151745481,
-0.023139419,
-0.0119189331,
-0.0212401245,
-0.0272041634,
0.0504251719,
-0.0330921039,
-0.0497817546,
0.0716644078,
-0.0478582159,
-0.0032146887,
0.039453093,
0.075767763,
-0.0201781858,
-0.0214693956,
-0.0261442345,
0.0621420667,
0.0603385493,
0.0715147257,
0.0316024721,
-0.072340332,
-0.0133520374,
-0.0251482837,
-0.033938434,
-0.0111379689,
-0.0461240336,
0.010203531,
0.0186293926,
-0.0360646062,
-0.0256953072,
-0.0169299133,
0.0546814352,
-0.0204895083,
0.0339683332,
0.0762681067,
0.0053748805,
0.027005136,
-0.0276289955,
0.0322402008,
0.0394154377,
-0.0053259805,
-0.0396301113,
-0.0875649527,
0.0202141013,
-0.0151058482,
0.0252785888,
0.0621447898,
-0.0546492301,
-0.0117364256,
-0.0035057012,
0.0843387321,
0.0233420879,
0.0470966399,
0.0147643713,
0.0238846075,
0.0745393187,
0.0637972504,
0.0221161526,
0.022209473,
0.0157269426,
0.0308888033,
0.0299654305,
-0.0053756996,
-0.0055134078,
-0.01552903,
-0.0327845886,
-0.0093534617,
0.0169732124,
-0.0265798438,
0.0163576659,
-0.0058514792,
0.0525810346,
-0.0318685472,
0.0158825964,
-0.0136763314,
0.009889992,
-0.0542152599,
0.028198855,
-0.0609025396,
-0.0359798633,
0.036593169,
-0.0132055935,
0.0143321883,
0.0668359473,
-0.0419541039,
-0.0627972037,
-0.0742652863,
0.0198188704,
-0.0376268886,
0.0320660248,
0.0519113019,
0.0334476195,
-0.0470623262,
-0.04516197,
-0.0269242339,
0.0218436588,
0.015043024,
0.0688578859,
0.0001955843,
-0.0124610215,
-0.031389147,
0.0849642381,
-0.0134312604,
-0.0617068596,
-0.0321986824,
-0.0051267319,
0.0002352853,
-0.008104369,
0.0474149473,
-0.0346226469,
-0.0077731819,
-0.0239560101,
0.0736822039,
-0.0201156661,
0.0160237849,
-0.019278245,
-0.018152263,
-0.03649275,
-0.0203865841,
0.0755400583,
0.0150223151,
-0.0001270407,
0.0297167916,
-0.0471286774,
-0.0152368443,
-0.0183441415,
0.0107602561,
-0.0151324803,
-0.0486881807,
-0.0121172844,
-0.0320730843,
-0.0700501055,
0.0024448307,
-0.0035569165,
0.0145442076,
0.0109155281,
0.0064765844,
0.0498738214,
-0.0330257453,
-0.0352549925,
-0.0244612265,
0.0089202961,
-0.0355658047,
-0.0426528677,
-0.0078727761,
-6.278231574e-33,
-0.0150460918,
-0.016193483,
0.0389767662,
-0.001364455,
-0.0047947238,
-0.0143514536,
-0.0437235609,
0.049219545,
0.0299431253,
-0.0055275271,
0.0040492238,
-0.0245541222,
0.0069701923,
0.0456391461,
0.0368872061,
0.011039204,
0.0095142117,
-0.0056674266,
-0.0004671843,
0.0534443669,
0.0040067253,
0.0098218266,
0.0623253286,
-0.0891383737,
-0.0000239643,
-0.0045678173,
-0.0073298779,
-0.0225163177,
-0.0048377612,
0.041171357,
-0.0790662766,
0.069974266,
0.0318468995,
0.0208794419,
-0.0137111908,
0.0245963242,
-0.0026765692,
-0.0110710319,
0.0205188561,
-0.0038325971,
-0.0225106645,
-0.0185603295,
0.0399213284,
-0.0067377295,
0.010972918,
0.0087638889,
0.0404205881,
-0.0580329709,
-0.0282145906,
0.0169389602,
-0.0225512721,
-0.0122172507,
-0.019804731,
-0.0148765324,
-0.0254675653,
0.0469177999,
-0.0526336096,
0.0187701564,
-0.0608700179,
0.0235681701,
0.0264105611,
0.0503741316,
0.0518651567,
0.0176427495,
0.0536091849,
0.0443747826,
0.0255628843,
-0.0132019669,
-0.0477701649,
0.0236903988,
0.0395797603,
0.0173428115,
0.0389020219,
0.0338893309,
0.0288890135,
-0.0146849314,
-0.0547462925,
0.0044779014,
0.0017934078,
-0.0458212234,
0.0528121814,
0.0233006552,
0.0148222018,
-0.0073139016,
0.007109696,
0.0133753531,
-0.0230171811,
-0.0204001423,
0.005266008,
0.0379827991,
-0.0364281014,
-0.0185396131,
0.0084145684,
-0.0615371689,
0.0519829914,
-0.0515092239,
-0.0351868235,
-0.0056308685,
0.031087283,
-0.0414486639,
0.0051865093,
0.0139898807,
0.0021454613,
0.0237370748,
0.0300792009,
-0.0048349262,
0.0084254453,
0.0559829511,
-0.000396453,
-0.0116543649,
-0.0164458156,
0.0120246876,
0.047662273,
-0.0504592694,
0.0377087928,
-0.0359144248,
-0.0090981983,
0.066924721,
-0.0327756181,
-0.0027362416,
-0.0259667654,
0.0098016672,
0.0054911394,
-0.0010855643,
0.0097002909,
-0.0116776181,
-0.0584532768,
-0.0261307377,
0.0538333021,
-0.0308514219,
-0.0272554085,
-0.0298931487,
2.824e-7,
-0.0125539238,
0.0199211463,
-0.0308077186,
-0.0094494782,
0.0618972592,
0.0188251473,
-0.006247384,
0.0124398908,
0.0390400104,
-0.0179164521,
0.0310065374,
0.0135987932,
0.0774342418,
0.01858183,
-0.0803560615,
-0.0415700935,
0.0087249326,
0.0160609651,
-0.0912573859,
0.0059748907,
0.0479670689,
0.0497952476,
0.0131553644,
-0.0029516926,
0.0312259942,
-0.0653558895,
0.0221961141,
-0.0728818849,
0.0124365138,
-0.0402285792,
0.0235614255,
0.0315896533,
-0.0105668819,
-0.0277313441,
-0.0402125455,
-0.0370787494,
-0.0357783176,
0.0690056607,
0.0026124967,
-0.0450523011,
-0.0087916646,
0.0149995228,
-0.0178543758,
-0.0730809644,
0.0464921705,
-0.0653447956,
-0.0545117408,
0.0239792448,
-0.0142330891,
-0.0649992973,
0.0351643376,
-0.0427665189,
-0.014434576,
-0.0036545831,
0.0132241938,
0.0133054368,
0.015834447,
-0.0013249003,
-0.0026751661,
0.0290809236,
-0.0809935629,
-0.0269319136,
-0.0243479572,
-0.049318932,
-0.0536369123,
-0.0180235319,
0.0300965998,
2.344093693e-34,
-0.0062550688,
0.0125493538,
0.0284409728,
0.0224661417,
0.026436571,
0.006228196,
0.0384853035,
0.0353625454,
-0.0131455632,
-0.0727049783,
-0.0487649962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16240v1 | Mixture-of-Linguistic-Experts Adapters for Improving and Interpreting Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-10-24T23:29:06 | 2023-10-24T23:29:06 | Raymond Li, Gabriel Murray, Giuseppe Carenini | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we propose a method that combines two popular research areas by
injecting linguistic structures into pre-trained language models in the
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) setting. In our approach, parallel
adapter modules encoding different linguistic structures are combined using a
novel Mixture-of-Linguistic-Experts architecture, where Gumbel-Softmax gates
are used to determine the importance of these modules at each layer of the
model. To reduce the number of parameters, we first train the model for a fixed
small number of steps before pruning the experts based on their importance
scores. Our experiment results with three different pre-trained models show
that our approach can outperform state-of-the-art PEFT methods with a
comparable number of parameters. In addition, we provide additional analysis to
examine the experts selected by each model at each layer to provide insights
for future studies. | [
0.0375611931,
0.0233668871,
-0.0191944148,
0.0237583257,
-0.0010162716,
0.0176578145,
0.0326980762,
-0.0410415493,
-0.0309914537,
-0.053164918,
-0.0578589812,
-0.0165644959,
0.0066482713,
0.028081743,
0.0355947129,
-0.0346723981,
0.0478715114,
-0.0442715064,
0.0118332617,
-0.0092318458,
0.0261186976,
0.0183192026,
0.0010887395,
0.0686922073,
0.0017202178,
0.0437713973,
-0.0226588808,
0.0078731896,
0.0123787476,
0.0224546231,
0.0189009383,
0.0867538601,
0.0207219161,
0.0075077084,
0.0000020937,
-0.011707684,
-0.0403975546,
-0.0155128492,
-0.0124992402,
0.01720565,
0.0445508324,
0.000752748,
-0.0351283699,
0.0186670739,
-0.0182663873,
-0.0342509858,
0.080223687,
0.0336794481,
0.0669642612,
0.1071554422,
-0.0044268798,
-0.041492369,
0.0312261861,
-0.0166551005,
-0.0249690842,
-0.0277824607,
0.0091033289,
0.0096754627,
-0.011229312,
-0.0266600121,
-0.0253506731,
0.0207253713,
0.0066993055,
0.0219024047,
0.017021168,
-0.0085595241,
0.0150091173,
-0.0179010276,
-0.0278355889,
0.0804376751,
-0.1000502408,
-0.031515047,
-0.0147172445,
-0.0442809053,
-0.0286493581,
0.0135420347,
-0.001881853,
-0.0075475909,
0.0255889464,
0.0253570545,
0.0385207422,
-0.0025511545,
0.0348729417,
0.0300577935,
-0.0755288973,
0.0539265722,
0.0131194014,
0.0153015899,
-0.0028715548,
-0.0245894324,
-0.0139363986,
-0.0036871652,
0.0216907524,
-0.0002933657,
-0.0061200438,
0.0138898026,
-0.0617251322,
-0.0517207384,
-0.0279864669,
-0.0508782119,
0.0598261133,
0.060055919,
0.0011386377,
0.0491912365,
-0.0563158095,
0.0237550884,
0.026700858,
0.0259599891,
-0.0532376468,
-0.0073052524,
-0.0513425991,
0.0128380032,
-0.0689867288,
0.0159788579,
-0.0278795976,
-0.0273387283,
-0.013282177,
0.0049756449,
-0.023791166,
-0.0348387547,
0.0276171695,
0.0071262298,
-0.0429884158,
-0.0481573045,
-0.0224510804,
0.0539162792,
-0.0360146239,
0.016933281,
-0.0215872955,
-0.0618524253,
0.0061362223,
0.0080137737,
0.0371629819,
-0.0191727821,
0.0224058386,
0.0135355312,
-0.0203445144,
-0.0647060424,
-0.0323132724,
-0.0057459511,
-0.0102374526,
-0.0589700863,
-0.0018103558,
-0.0663317963,
0.034084402,
-0.0002047752,
0.0231614094,
-0.0727390647,
-0.005894307,
-0.0185371768,
-0.0405642055,
0.0612873808,
-0.0387199931,
0.0157468542,
-0.0011941929,
-0.0140492637,
0.0044522285,
0.0804671869,
0.0361476392,
0.0113716889,
-0.0216743499,
-0.0330568105,
-0.0058864816,
0.0322799981,
-0.0147936912,
-0.0038967326,
-0.0364073254,
-0.0204529557,
-0.0076215551,
-0.0135439672,
0.0192054529,
0.0316003263,
-0.0477644801,
0.0399608538,
0.0451054312,
-0.0050858948,
0.0588495284,
0.0526916832,
0.0460526273,
-0.0195858367,
0.0367552526,
-0.0039735818,
-0.0550801232,
0.021821972,
-0.0354100764,
-0.0128876492,
0.0174597166,
0.0699426457,
-0.0179822613,
-0.0321293361,
0.0364068076,
-0.0242360309,
0.0121800704,
0.0010994055,
0.0571143664,
0.0049532978,
-0.0583938882,
0.0341294147,
0.0535941534,
-0.0141490903,
0.0122720674,
-0.0585166663,
-0.0269832723,
0.0732901171,
0.0053720851,
-0.0291385651,
-0.0348809585,
0.0055155861,
-0.0171129759,
-0.019685125,
0.06345696,
0.0310564023,
0.0204247441,
-0.0672713891,
-0.0294905528,
-0.0210399721,
0.0345823802,
0.0489761308,
-0.0054175216,
0.000430228,
0.0359427147,
0.02120075,
-0.0441632494,
0.0105922753,
0.0078466469,
0.0159845054,
0.0252853446,
0.0087822191,
0.0228026211,
-0.0068558552,
-0.0288444255,
0.0131220194,
0.0014550495,
-0.0126250051,
0.0218125414,
-0.0181663651,
-0.0760513321,
-0.0148248142,
0.0340225659,
-0.0096839992,
0.0448332764,
-0.003119207,
-0.0140217477,
-0.0760317668,
0.0252953433,
-0.0236915071,
0.0621024743,
-0.0617343001,
0.0233905353,
-0.0221010633,
0.028215846,
-0.034028396,
0.0347091556,
0.0350686871,
-0.0051965755,
0.0181604363,
0.0066087083,
0.0216245502,
0.0021052493,
-0.0435370505,
-0.0085639283,
0.0050909538,
0.0318763182,
0.0154621815,
0.005169875,
-0.0323402397,
-0.0715679675,
-0.1044500172,
0.0010457648,
-0.0434843488,
0.0051414832,
0.0285924282,
0.0222991779,
-0.0016461334,
0.0049868026,
-0.0056263921,
0.0266883578,
0.0044462574,
-0.0041401586,
-0.029958697,
0.0237817038,
-0.043077834,
-0.0419883803,
-0.0259764493,
-0.0066357702,
0.0470436476,
-0.0146156894,
-0.0336029269,
-0.0438080803,
-0.0441459268,
-0.0082073119,
0.026923053,
0.0088882977,
-0.0761934295,
-0.0079192361,
-0.0423525199,
0.0330118984,
0.0677393153,
-0.0135703264,
0.0297500174,
0.0574722216,
-0.0261736754,
-0.0402859375,
0.0280480981,
-0.026695475,
0.0064269416,
-0.0518489145,
0.007873957,
-0.0436348356,
0.059720777,
-0.0059456588,
-0.0230495054,
-0.0903580859,
0.0517485105,
-0.009420028,
-0.0435588285,
0.0187859721,
-0.0004350548,
-0.0018556789,
0.0391870178,
-0.0208492447,
-0.0624887682,
0.0614046566,
-0.0513238907,
-0.0150804762,
-0.0356989987,
-0.0340504609,
-0.0179759674,
0.0029073635,
0.0310985949,
0.0459433347,
0.025896823,
0.0089629358,
-0.0479715727,
0.0188127775,
0.0170139149,
-0.0238592904,
0.0306904186,
-0.0192235652,
0.0132985171,
0.0081910044,
0.0050199265,
0.0066536609,
-0.0308322124,
-0.0369894244,
0.0419110619,
0.0457180887,
-0.0228757225,
-0.0338986591,
0.0488397703,
-0.000933075,
0.0270627365,
-0.0367250368,
0.0165382531,
-0.0340074524,
-0.0165717322,
0.053085655,
0.0429140627,
0.0315070637,
-0.0183038618,
0.016051745,
-0.0454919674,
0.0081792977,
-0.0124852192,
-0.0724552572,
0.0333192348,
0.0110793766,
-0.0246426817,
-0.0243228432,
0.0159559008,
0.0448604971,
-0.0794138238,
0.0142355105,
0.1375358105,
0.0211885516,
-0.0426995754,
0.0137852672,
0.0360045768,
0.0199891776,
-0.0029869124,
0.0412765555,
-0.0197711028,
-0.0466206819,
-0.0061719874,
-0.0023517353,
-0.0045683025,
0.0027739261,
-0.0116598271,
-0.081456244,
-0.0018382606,
0.0436249971,
-0.0346227475,
-0.0257806219,
-0.0100968098,
0.000414182,
-0.003547407,
0.0156870838,
0.0091141276,
0.0206727963,
-0.0026106453,
-0.0004412733,
0.0078959996,
-0.0867023468,
0.0014759488,
-0.0216109473,
0.0838284492,
0.0379893854,
-0.0329310559,
-0.0145361871,
0.0075908424,
0.0150609268,
-0.0416930243,
0.0247619487,
-0.0212327205,
-0.0025563987,
0.0118027348,
-0.0462302752,
0.0216858871,
-0.0081981122,
-0.0151045453,
0.0083280476,
-0.0403423347,
0.068588607,
-0.0314915739,
-0.0151119782,
0.0118910046,
-0.0188358407,
-0.0085287169,
0.0294438284,
0.0357076302,
-0.05862372,
0.0104947016,
-0.0347033776,
-0.0327285379,
-0.0031717308,
-0.0380895995,
0.0030444472,
-0.0119297588,
-0.028980894,
-0.0283635817,
-0.0270958841,
0.055012662,
0.05747265,
0.0074810712,
0.0020636953,
0.0269248653,
0.007848762,
-0.0112407841,
0.062826626,
-0.0126048895,
-0.0001388917,
-0.0794125348,
-0.0438587517,
0.0557583161,
-0.016496975,
-0.0110180797,
0.0013960934,
-0.0405430794,
-0.0718077719,
0.0004859488,
0.0863034129,
0.0167774502,
0.0214270391,
-0.0342937782,
-0.0924372077,
0.0332453214,
0.0146516142,
-0.0521449782,
0.0323507376,
0.0560879149,
-0.0569618233,
-0.0265167505,
0.030109439,
-0.0264545996,
0.0166429356,
0.0283811223,
0.025062887,
-0.0145830316,
-0.0883692726,
0.0097652329,
-0.021522468,
0.0343394019,
0.0010571909,
0.0077925744,
-0.0550507195,
0.0251184348,
0.0065360814,
-0.0087825647,
-0.063979283,
-0.0209319517,
0.0212938227,
0.0140838772,
-0.0033578053,
-0.0216606855,
0.0173950046,
0.0042768586,
0.032141272,
0.0490194745,
0.0094928034,
0.0122860111,
-0.0052636862,
0.0030861476,
-0.0104918955,
0.0353157669,
0.0231566951,
-0.0090584978,
-0.052767083,
0.0225654244,
-0.0066410201,
-0.0038384802,
-0.0690912902,
0.0452780016,
-0.0145551749,
-0.0765927806,
-0.0435260274,
0.0214305539,
0.0705619752,
-0.0145531297,
0.081122078,
-0.0040842439,
-0.0096685244,
-0.0295988396,
0.0291936416,
0.043403659,
0.0280598626,
0.0173277687,
0.0253334437,
-0.0076993331,
-0.0103174644,
0.0301983785,
0.0199309867,
0.0343089588,
0.0121369921,
0.0134559441,
-0.0103953574,
-0.0253857728,
-0.008674819,
0.0397895463,
-0.0306549333,
0.0251457114,
-0.0064882752,
-0.0438279361,
-0.0079697045,
0.0038041207,
-0.0194199868,
-0.0077285497,
0.0490189083,
0.0050520445,
-0.0415693298,
0.0204299036,
-0.0268189386,
-0.0600512438,
0.0236311313,
0.0084674219,
0.0165687148,
-6.507539665e-33,
-0.0513625108,
0.0218709521,
-0.0126450127,
-0.030514583,
0.0084332041,
-0.0151298754,
-0.0202711895,
0.032288447,
-0.0300971456,
-0.0003402288,
-0.0058664577,
-0.0132012637,
0.020513624,
0.0032789912,
-0.0342704877,
0.034625005,
0.0595410578,
0.0159513485,
0.0156658366,
0.0183833223,
-0.0120624918,
0.027536938,
0.0822586566,
-0.0570004918,
-0.040905118,
0.0451502912,
-0.0433579236,
-0.00305224,
-0.0019511133,
0.0675083324,
0.0097348839,
0.042363964,
0.0139835291,
-0.0405659825,
-0.0397559702,
-0.0228802972,
-0.0560090356,
-0.0371443368,
0.0378648899,
0.010472904,
0.0181712303,
-0.0259855445,
0.0788813755,
-0.0125200404,
0.014504781,
-0.0014892181,
0.0330433287,
-0.0331511647,
0.0121154534,
-0.0117805181,
-0.0498336591,
0.0344990194,
0.0036221207,
0.0117545165,
0.053678453,
-0.0204613507,
-0.0305442903,
-0.0144144371,
-0.0035466184,
0.0001474128,
0.0699502155,
0.0818526968,
0.039810013,
0.0419113562,
-0.0023613065,
0.0163876805,
0.041139707,
-0.0174819026,
0.0101749655,
-0.0057474789,
0.1099936068,
0.0382564925,
0.0555712767,
0.0335347615,
0.0380649492,
-0.0019617251,
-0.0558975786,
0.0076812748,
0.0213158038,
0.0402382277,
0.0259752404,
0.0214208495,
-0.005272306,
-0.0173073802,
-0.0819556713,
0.0078357048,
-0.0419388376,
-0.05875884,
0.0158912167,
0.0123163871,
-0.0555720069,
0.0007869898,
0.0571805388,
-0.051765956,
0.0045542624,
0.0005639439,
-0.0186394621,
0.0221785177,
0.0022560852,
0.0509524681,
-0.0485347956,
-0.0749035254,
0.029670082,
-0.0249267761,
0.0142521104,
-0.0184664242,
0.0048538074,
0.0591980778,
-0.0661793202,
0.0025786569,
-0.0124542965,
-0.0305181872,
0.0183418412,
0.0796717107,
0.0265423115,
0.0182680115,
-0.0253295749,
0.0161258485,
-0.0014920911,
-0.0189395901,
-0.0111084869,
-0.0281706564,
0.0346652046,
0.0518653952,
-0.0311306901,
0.0036315748,
-0.0640225932,
-0.037502557,
0.0435953885,
-0.0339927897,
-0.0184832495,
0.0310260821,
2.856e-7,
0.0522388965,
0.0404371619,
-0.0377187729,
0.0006100523,
0.0107682357,
0.0174974147,
-0.005395188,
-0.0151998829,
0.0113788536,
-0.0083855493,
0.052568417,
0.0554646403,
0.0024203372,
-0.014729606,
-0.0809105411,
0.0215706006,
-0.0103309983,
0.054501202,
-0.0447317213,
0.006743609,
0.0214113388,
0.1445848346,
0.0132676326,
0.004082636,
-0.0015127057,
-0.0359957106,
0.0308060441,
-0.0299621001,
0.0137653435,
0.0509014428,
0.0327464975,
0.0404824428,
-0.039247673,
0.0439961664,
-0.0023011032,
0.0640681013,
-0.0060617612,
0.0654218346,
-0.0358072072,
-0.021899825,
0.0478046164,
0.0089648673,
-0.0106219398,
-0.0539041981,
0.0794409961,
-0.0673252121,
-0.0075039067,
-0.0247520711,
-0.011537265,
-0.0197211131,
0.0045098546,
-0.05189123,
-0.0308349486,
0.038356524,
0.0286254734,
-0.0256321188,
-0.0188058242,
-0.0735815316,
0.0044945809,
0.0353320502,
-0.0109597826,
-0.0409561321,
-0.0312397499,
-0.0270341951,
0.0627609193,
-0.0273561981,
0.0175720155,
2.737052041e-34,
0.0425099842,
-0.0179958232,
0.0359214582,
0.0123312194,
0.0577133372,
0.0113598118,
-0.0512676947,
0.0185052194,
0.0112656606,
-0.108727172,
-0.047830198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16226v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16226v3 | TiC-CLIP: Continual Training of CLIP Models | 2023-10-24T22:41:14 | 2024-03-21T04:47:27 | Saurabh Garg, Mehrdad Farajtabar, Hadi Pouransari, Raviteja Vemulapalli, Sachin Mehta, Oncel Tuzel, Vaishaal Shankar, Fartash Faghri | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Keeping large foundation models up to date on latest data is inherently
expensive. To avoid the prohibitive costs of constantly retraining, it is
imperative to continually train these models. This problem is exacerbated by
the lack of any large scale continual learning benchmarks or baselines. We
introduce the first set of web-scale Time-Continual (TiC) benchmarks for
training vision-language models: TiC-DataComp, TiC-YFCC, and TiC-Redcaps.
TiC-DataComp, our largest dataset, contains over 12.7B timestamped image-text
pairs spanning 9 years (2014-2022). We first use our benchmarks to curate
various dynamic evaluations to measure temporal robustness of existing models.
We show OpenAI's CLIP (trained on data up to 2020) loses $\approx 8\%$
zero-shot accuracy on our curated retrieval task from 2021-2022 compared with
more recently trained models in OpenCLIP repository. We then study how to
efficiently train models on time-continuous data. We demonstrate that a simple
rehearsal-based approach that continues training from the last checkpoint and
replays old data reduces compute by $2.5\times$ when compared to the standard
practice of retraining from scratch. Code is available at
https://github.com/apple/ml-tic-clip. | [
0.0135199893,
0.0880044252,
0.0164182037,
0.0206681658,
-0.0219517406,
0.0070713381,
-0.0047585918,
0.0221452098,
-0.0345483497,
-0.0309268665,
-0.0384454615,
-0.0090389289,
0.0232673064,
0.0712462664,
-0.0393134393,
-0.0591529757,
0.0347122289,
-0.0174830053,
-0.033149831,
0.0197956841,
0.0094679995,
-0.0105247078,
-0.0169554669,
0.0458795242,
-0.0170130469,
-0.0420958363,
-0.0076282793,
-0.0202974491,
0.0246632099,
-0.0286065601,
0.0200234391,
0.0205096714,
0.0148576191,
0.0107750557,
0.0000020425,
0.0079799527,
0.0045910254,
0.0146838389,
-0.0265560318,
-0.0116821388,
0.0453343242,
-0.0235510021,
-0.0036822152,
0.0003023106,
-0.048338335,
-0.0074732816,
0.0367899053,
0.0099105174,
0.0687697604,
0.0514080897,
-0.0151719553,
0.0061851381,
0.0589737408,
-0.0426743291,
-0.0100358753,
-0.0153827108,
0.0110165356,
-0.0062483074,
-0.0149871418,
-0.0177459996,
-0.012876031,
0.0387182459,
0.0438687839,
0.0006657441,
0.0354349464,
0.0613921434,
-0.1026825532,
-0.0276754163,
-0.0150774829,
0.0647078827,
-0.0031856878,
-0.0253914893,
-0.0255026389,
0.0252425354,
-0.0212739743,
-0.0174179859,
-0.0517383367,
0.0241714418,
0.0449913181,
0.0402486697,
-0.0501323529,
0.0041555092,
0.0222427603,
0.0327322148,
-0.0254951268,
-0.0328236036,
-0.0019567788,
0.0159983058,
-0.0080967164,
0.0001051975,
-0.0016651322,
-0.0206113569,
-0.0219879299,
0.0348609127,
0.0012504085,
-0.0218511522,
-0.0655156597,
0.0048168628,
-0.0125136925,
-0.0600447766,
0.0337740332,
0.0575220473,
-0.0583852045,
0.0934915841,
-0.0460846685,
0.037206348,
0.0048502665,
0.0101438109,
-0.0034110108,
-0.0140288975,
-0.0549286753,
0.0131626809,
-0.025236642,
0.0245171394,
-0.0140790986,
-0.0486895964,
-0.022320563,
0.0107990885,
-0.0424242355,
0.0024117515,
-0.0031775734,
-0.0070144054,
-0.0611975119,
-0.0001331242,
0.0195284132,
0.0210382771,
-0.0097793927,
0.0188762061,
-0.0057490957,
-0.0933199152,
-0.0364744142,
0.0320317671,
0.0035370851,
-0.0091655916,
0.0099098897,
0.0236406438,
-0.0424153991,
-0.0569629408,
-0.0382795595,
-0.012899017,
-0.0242532827,
-0.0440882444,
-0.0140088471,
-0.0587762147,
0.0129135875,
-0.0389254093,
0.0214100536,
-0.0400434509,
0.0261273477,
0.0286233611,
-0.0500197895,
0.1155009866,
0.0185804013,
0.0012988384,
-0.0074565206,
0.0085292729,
0.0169192292,
0.0661800429,
0.0209670272,
-0.0095303897,
0.0174951907,
0.0520784222,
-0.0092404466,
0.034950003,
0.0403761007,
0.0331420675,
-0.1279015392,
0.0047772988,
0.0422032103,
0.0116497464,
0.0145266252,
0.0387838595,
-0.040400885,
-0.0227584094,
0.0490169339,
0.027472537,
-0.0316706821,
-0.0104025025,
0.0162066836,
-0.0341920294,
0.0243661273,
-0.031323418,
-0.0569003634,
0.0174544938,
-0.0048348866,
0.0061618583,
-0.0239279121,
-0.0187988151,
-0.0377296582,
-0.0186207276,
0.0045015486,
-0.0136537552,
-0.022584416,
0.0246033389,
0.0669003576,
0.0066944482,
0.0100826304,
0.0588999167,
0.0023703873,
-0.0322721601,
-0.0356565118,
-0.0459714979,
-0.005507465,
0.0265027191,
0.0423402749,
-0.0199731849,
-0.0521116331,
-0.003561293,
0.0258665886,
0.021857677,
0.008127545,
-0.0280987471,
0.051016435,
-0.0378447883,
-0.0268753339,
-0.0153933158,
-0.0048033982,
-0.0163453016,
0.0470325612,
0.0687227249,
0.0151165808,
-0.0162340999,
-0.0378824808,
0.0434708074,
-0.0125598013,
-0.0078261988,
0.0057040537,
0.0077099581,
-0.0081493268,
-0.0008957497,
-0.0704644397,
0.0001746918,
0.0417218544,
-0.0482686795,
0.0362799242,
0.0378277749,
-0.0165411327,
-0.0164308138,
0.0748219565,
-0.031407062,
-0.0166979805,
0.0268826671,
-0.0402960293,
-0.0214487948,
0.004819368,
0.0220307223,
0.0288173929,
-0.0462389439,
0.0219505727,
-0.017008096,
0.0370414369,
-0.0105886376,
0.0363913104,
-0.0386312678,
-0.0233498514,
0.0601329431,
-0.0011415869,
0.0204043407,
-0.0528128371,
-0.0103864698,
0.0308223777,
-0.010202866,
-0.0144159738,
0.0127588715,
0.035232123,
-0.0396218821,
-0.0026989747,
-0.1008253321,
-0.0205009952,
-0.0324134901,
-0.0286877044,
-0.0267962515,
-0.0146594485,
-0.0037334231,
-0.0628477409,
0.0230530612,
-0.0020488484,
-0.0364273489,
0.0304982588,
-0.0116906147,
0.0359651223,
0.0176184215,
-0.0304946601,
-0.0322045162,
0.0306308921,
0.068236053,
-0.030792864,
-0.0614857487,
0.0178528242,
0.0197682902,
-0.0238178689,
0.0452955477,
-0.0280960295,
0.016531093,
0.0114975395,
-0.046685297,
0.031667307,
0.0720771253,
0.0337194577,
0.0373038277,
0.0061453204,
0.0161684118,
-0.0615148209,
0.013910708,
0.013591704,
-0.0264233928,
0.0004833926,
0.0080142254,
-0.0083262715,
0.0116751567,
-0.0480853058,
0.0234134812,
-0.0629795045,
0.0284036975,
-0.049152948,
-0.0207557324,
-0.0754052475,
0.0300184358,
-0.0281598903,
-0.0015969547,
-0.0296763834,
-0.0762797967,
0.009250978,
-0.0073924302,
-0.0006971147,
0.0382664017,
-0.0368583947,
-0.0285256859,
0.1035204828,
0.0058412841,
0.0013175064,
0.0079093631,
0.0007695978,
-0.0503167026,
-0.0006548209,
0.020364739,
-0.0246165339,
0.052630242,
-0.0128267501,
0.0491119362,
-0.034258686,
-0.0669873431,
-0.0480207764,
-0.0267811324,
-0.0357023329,
-0.0047413125,
-0.0729205236,
-0.0177791156,
-0.0293768141,
0.0257997606,
-0.0102506438,
0.0558720417,
-0.0208401289,
-0.020792501,
0.0314487778,
0.0565744527,
0.0688515157,
0.0098339636,
-0.0154345073,
-0.0204986073,
-0.010634752,
0.0688578933,
0.0700801909,
0.0234027617,
-0.0708311647,
0.0069864839,
0.033212319,
0.0276053585,
0.0268826764,
0.017273169,
0.0011441751,
-0.0426256359,
-0.0404827595,
0.0583298132,
0.0188530404,
-0.0666577592,
-0.0415249765,
0.0176956616,
0.0134889483,
0.0201819781,
0.0043632127,
-0.065546073,
-0.0313830152,
0.0150446817,
0.0469742902,
0.0221931115,
-0.001823327,
-0.0427554734,
-0.103602536,
0.0450645164,
0.0023672814,
-0.0100781256,
-0.0105345612,
0.010254547,
-0.0062800646,
-0.0139533114,
-0.0136507815,
0.0216374192,
-0.0149486726,
0.0008000018,
0.0210819598,
-0.0128893098,
-0.0552818663,
0.036977727,
-0.028401766,
0.0266820136,
0.0596973449,
0.0208497513,
0.0156342462,
-0.0639236793,
0.0944811404,
-0.0001119937,
-0.0030666308,
0.011183206,
0.0745624602,
-0.037078362,
-0.0250932798,
0.0367768519,
0.051723294,
-0.0002166391,
-0.0177225452,
-0.0163846463,
0.0296722706,
-0.0242794417,
0.0116543295,
-0.0525837056,
-0.0404376835,
-0.0087893633,
0.0436990261,
0.001244737,
-0.0134606063,
-0.0216444209,
0.0139491726,
0.0026739934,
-0.0761404112,
-0.0225258023,
0.0009209694,
0.0075732917,
-0.0036381355,
-0.0444588698,
-0.0283647031,
-0.0128838941,
0.0602292567,
-0.0172792282,
-0.0378599167,
-0.0209593382,
0.0363042392,
-0.0852314532,
0.0500880182,
-0.0470222011,
0.0300209317,
-0.068975538,
0.0238498859,
0.0368414372,
-0.0018274031,
-0.0019008857,
0.0400821529,
-0.1276622415,
-0.0275455415,
-0.0157039016,
0.0637290403,
0.0183465481,
0.0536236875,
-0.0034082746,
-0.0247167591,
0.0340202823,
0.0466952808,
0.0188911129,
0.0236391593,
0.0227272529,
-0.0505159087,
-0.0102965264,
0.040767327,
-0.0506613702,
-0.0039156196,
-0.0084319925,
0.0344556645,
0.0235471576,
0.0495254993,
0.0178553704,
-0.030269919,
0.06244554,
0.0105069252,
0.0458738543,
-0.0039750137,
0.0112703685,
0.0229531806,
-0.0039258734,
-0.0535932146,
0.0438416675,
0.0282719806,
0.0094688404,
-0.0117924567,
0.0213129744,
0.0199826043,
0.0156617928,
-0.0554598682,
-0.0475157127,
0.009211801,
-0.0323996246,
0.0222031772,
-0.0016099637,
-0.0216621496,
0.0405327901,
-0.0334067792,
0.0179949012,
-0.0122865522,
0.0237660632,
0.0472220443,
0.0396331064,
-0.0202968642,
0.0148826558,
-0.054868184,
-0.0381421447,
-0.022172913,
0.0251531284,
0.0721824765,
0.0025417563,
0.024888061,
-0.0226768814,
-0.0271331016,
-0.0272405781,
-0.0001760716,
0.022269465,
-0.0539852493,
0.0081746615,
0.0171360113,
0.005557762,
0.0358155593,
0.0902349725,
-0.0086640278,
0.0074770763,
0.0096164951,
-0.0085309502,
0.0016547416,
-0.0081278859,
-0.0359880067,
0.0010597081,
-0.0160769243,
0.0093643749,
-0.0109969387,
-0.0468623638,
0.0355741717,
0.0076205325,
0.0113858273,
0.0211188868,
0.0219466072,
0.0270979088,
0.0384272449,
0.0148206763,
-0.0270593613,
0.0179363005,
0.0142088039,
-0.0149096018,
-0.0064832945,
-6.467484695e-33,
0.0121213021,
0.0310035888,
0.0185080823,
0.0060140495,
-0.0684240162,
0.0588816218,
-0.040490292,
0.0115415026,
-0.027198568,
-0.0026444625,
-0.0188592169,
0.0489251129,
0.0281125195,
0.0441311225,
0.0205968264,
-0.001225705,
0.0369021259,
-0.0133466804,
-0.0271797553,
0.0054158312,
0.027788138,
0.0373214521,
0.0252486058,
-0.0187524334,
-0.0254473016,
0.0336708464,
-0.012056224,
0.0271584466,
0.0573496111,
0.055457931,
-0.0149938464,
0.003256544,
0.0182396993,
-0.0355424993,
-0.0319599137,
-0.0344397873,
-0.1186334118,
-0.0210277215,
-0.039375376,
0.0297461264,
-0.0849208832,
0.0210412201,
0.0206879936,
0.0002479555,
-0.017689269,
-0.0256843641,
0.0118293911,
-0.061126221,
-0.0493437648,
-0.0425682627,
-0.0063124662,
0.0195223,
0.005460572,
-0.016236065,
0.0459100716,
0.0281747207,
0.0091738999,
0.0129909357,
-0.0802148283,
-0.0054520173,
0.0003757551,
0.0238003209,
0.0409970619,
0.0431877561,
0.0300156176,
0.0662297159,
-0.0115478691,
-0.0377174541,
0.0097012008,
-0.0538611636,
0.0591801964,
0.0286445376,
-0.0052373698,
0.0039214175,
0.0791758075,
-0.0340691432,
-0.0114481561,
0.0061531286,
0.0486063696,
0.0658853799,
0.035731297,
0.0178761333,
-0.0027702993,
0.0179656465,
-0.0157411527,
0.0026571522,
-0.0516150631,
0.0163364075,
0.0593580715,
0.087793909,
-0.0070685549,
0.0152927218,
0.0742525086,
-0.0284247585,
0.0085977623,
0.0393939354,
-0.0267711878,
0.0260783732,
0.0140351821,
0.029476393,
-0.0366664343,
-0.0040794467,
0.0071536,
0.0007485879,
0.0206169467,
-0.0289023351,
0.0597141981,
0.0475723855,
-0.0356372483,
-0.0169812106,
-0.0116624888,
0.0370128788,
0.0060641109,
0.0502402708,
0.0527972952,
0.0227154288,
-0.0113678314,
0.0463704355,
-0.0023405934,
0.0136901755,
-0.0348980539,
-0.0070208032,
0.0522384644,
-0.0080554476,
-0.0190905128,
-0.0058191661,
-0.0552387647,
0.0416723564,
-0.0069033336,
-0.0822462663,
-0.0252097417,
0.0503455214,
2.696e-7,
-0.0032967674,
-0.016599765,
0.0318670534,
0.0289755277,
0.0193612035,
-0.0060932497,
-0.0296162087,
0.0130809573,
-0.0173568763,
0.0313745104,
0.0083564874,
0.0378941819,
0.0743350834,
0.005481238,
-0.0199433826,
-0.0207270253,
-0.0708706006,
-0.0133386115,
-0.0504479408,
-0.0604865998,
0.0016366689,
0.1048856899,
0.0082794894,
-0.0051907091,
0.0558335967,
-0.0729020312,
0.0967735201,
0.0026069409,
0.041061338,
-0.0358534418,
-0.023637848,
0.0666536465,
-0.0566844568,
-0.0118613457,
-0.0247560777,
-0.0025120392,
0.033196453,
0.0262492113,
-0.0259535573,
-0.0102619939,
-0.01112983,
0.030619476,
-0.0218596682,
-0.0391709283,
0.0929230526,
-0.0655997396,
0.0035330381,
-0.0495256521,
-0.0053101946,
0.025048919,
0.0252820551,
-0.0041184509,
-0.0179855395,
0.0309280492,
0.0196518321,
0.0104482314,
-0.0444857217,
-0.1152922139,
-0.0092104133,
-0.0286067557,
-0.0132787963,
0.0148945441,
-0.0622062609,
-0.0297334827,
0.0015378457,
-0.019120967,
-0.0521756895,
2.100503253e-34,
0.0275461376,
-0.0053145005,
0.0009798609,
0.0209421217,
-0.0152876992,
-0.0186565481,
0.0343040973,
-0.0078568384,
-0.0204008576,
-0.0559362322,
-0.0318618156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16225v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16225v1 | CleanCoNLL: A Nearly Noise-Free Named Entity Recognition Dataset | 2023-10-24T22:34:43 | 2023-10-24T22:34:43 | Susanna Rücker, Alan Akbik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The CoNLL-03 corpus is arguably the most well-known and utilized benchmark
dataset for named entity recognition (NER). However, prior works found
significant numbers of annotation errors, incompleteness, and inconsistencies
in the data. This poses challenges to objectively comparing NER approaches and
analyzing their errors, as current state-of-the-art models achieve F1-scores
that are comparable to or even exceed the estimated noise level in CoNLL-03. To
address this issue, we present a comprehensive relabeling effort assisted by
automatic consistency checking that corrects 7.0% of all labels in the English
CoNLL-03. Our effort adds a layer of entity linking annotation both for better
explainability of NER labels and as additional safeguard of annotation quality.
Our experimental evaluation finds not only that state-of-the-art approaches
reach significantly higher F1-scores (97.1%) on our data, but crucially that
the share of correct predictions falsely counted as errors due to annotation
noise drops from 47% to 6%. This indicates that our resource is well suited to
analyze the remaining errors made by state-of-the-art models, and that the
theoretical upper bound even on high resource, coarse-grained NER is not yet
reached. To facilitate such analysis, we make CleanCoNLL publicly available to
the research community. | [
0.0197705161,
0.0461327136,
0.0330296457,
0.0213978309,
0.0361637771,
0.0573527776,
0.0170099158,
-0.0246946793,
0.0161499325,
-0.0435069352,
-0.0186794754,
0.0179116838,
0.0230278522,
-0.0132331001,
0.0439859815,
-0.0075158887,
0.0292507447,
-0.0018821238,
0.0420418344,
0.0343011469,
0.0074495682,
-0.0147043634,
-0.0026427186,
0.0105915107,
-0.0148833962,
0.0217918213,
-0.0028179178,
0.0203069188,
0.0420242362,
-0.0686537623,
0.0157231875,
0.0606944934,
-0.0372597277,
0.0852837339,
0.0000018419,
-0.0798533335,
-0.0528055504,
0.0360673591,
-0.0398022197,
-0.0052924096,
-0.0020470561,
-0.022740325,
-0.0237939004,
-0.0025787321,
-0.0023752139,
-0.0310039595,
0.0421525985,
0.0579980575,
0.044900272,
0.064851813,
0.0015140504,
-0.0166791715,
0.0367369018,
-0.0120655801,
-0.0092380261,
-0.0376696289,
0.0338173248,
-0.0067865807,
-0.0229089577,
-0.0068978672,
0.0060273679,
0.0437870286,
-0.0205604676,
-0.0167114343,
-0.0138601912,
0.0203127377,
-0.052497033,
-0.0079778675,
0.0288002007,
0.0585672818,
-0.007917352,
-0.002644086,
0.0467861854,
0.0072330222,
-0.0090871993,
-0.0549173057,
-0.0185843129,
0.0154437376,
-0.0418122038,
0.0062227538,
0.0193055831,
-0.0014185576,
0.0498456657,
-0.0107091926,
0.0219799615,
0.032834515,
-0.0036579012,
-0.0390868373,
0.023310896,
0.0468401611,
-0.0084399022,
-0.0451375507,
0.0266353935,
-0.0226561427,
0.00328194,
0.0333113112,
-0.0424647555,
-0.0295426808,
0.0074317958,
-0.0502328314,
-0.038672667,
-0.0142050432,
0.0023318615,
0.0340986215,
-0.0477277599,
-0.0078668604,
0.0224305764,
0.0235121939,
0.0466129519,
-0.026756255,
-0.0437694564,
0.034620285,
-0.0327451564,
0.0347910561,
-0.0388950147,
0.0308750849,
-0.0463472009,
-0.024847582,
-0.0416414179,
0.0607487597,
0.0203060843,
-0.0193376057,
0.0156194558,
0.010471453,
-0.0266291425,
0.0011154852,
0.0073138364,
-0.0241553281,
-0.0080224248,
-0.0694974214,
0.0174245853,
-0.0374263674,
0.0098397713,
-0.0409256145,
0.024471933,
0.0545193031,
0.0241233874,
-0.0765141025,
-0.0668447465,
-0.0249881595,
0.0013580626,
-0.0377430655,
-0.0330457054,
-0.0198702924,
0.0114840455,
-0.0078956429,
0.0248144064,
-0.0886075944,
0.0264539197,
-0.0046446803,
-0.0512111746,
0.1041318551,
-0.0938512608,
-0.039388217,
-0.0093366746,
0.0103673367,
0.0502724461,
0.0150788128,
0.0559252016,
-0.0290111043,
0.0591260903,
0.0246614888,
-0.0260849372,
0.0157726686,
0.0277081653,
-0.0311806276,
0.0443115868,
-0.0124599785,
-0.0107573513,
0.0140687982,
0.0274669677,
0.0353548713,
0.0050019124,
-0.0408175141,
0.0293280035,
-0.0191356111,
0.0141606294,
-0.0372920111,
0.0114821978,
-0.0065212133,
0.0301222689,
-0.0470578559,
-0.0639850348,
-0.0215533692,
-0.0375515781,
0.0286544468,
0.0374574997,
0.0490288138,
-0.0025491337,
-0.028221678,
-0.0235718898,
-0.0109085524,
-0.0332519561,
-0.0056833555,
0.0465446301,
0.010188085,
-0.0495705716,
0.042051632,
0.0366756283,
-0.0208807644,
0.0112010082,
0.0013962537,
0.0172813479,
0.0464340076,
0.0463693328,
-0.0160239041,
-0.0651080832,
-0.0726808831,
-0.0177868512,
0.058541622,
0.0111096939,
-0.0296822768,
0.0477931164,
-0.02599301,
0.0000939553,
0.0549328178,
0.0220052339,
0.031198388,
0.0361082368,
0.0150750214,
0.0198728275,
-0.02848568,
-0.0476539955,
0.0495623164,
-0.0179822538,
-0.0421503335,
0.0025943597,
0.0183362216,
0.0160410199,
0.0740393177,
-0.0156015009,
-0.0201218426,
0.0225505922,
-0.0024581866,
0.0183678921,
-0.0150879426,
0.0368133336,
-0.027092034,
0.0256914012,
-0.0092921006,
-0.0441087857,
-0.0044784038,
-0.0501012281,
-0.0605195202,
-0.0567164719,
0.0158259515,
0.0340651572,
-0.0226621963,
0.0249346364,
0.0428216867,
0.0130566154,
-0.0336243473,
0.0368928164,
-0.0261115097,
0.0408822186,
0.024599798,
0.0032195491,
0.0028764496,
-0.0276122093,
-0.0856331065,
0.0024204715,
-0.0200842153,
-0.0205277819,
0.0097599365,
0.0022455801,
-0.0690198913,
0.0087578651,
-0.0454951189,
-0.0010824802,
-0.0061456114,
0.0477912948,
0.00124495,
0.0086789923,
-0.0275390409,
-0.0233348869,
0.0153041892,
-0.0213750843,
-0.0220614318,
0.0015444944,
0.0400351621,
0.0048204302,
-0.026975207,
-0.0275505148,
0.0024447194,
-0.033674825,
0.0032235319,
0.0517965034,
-0.0698116273,
-0.076878503,
0.0343563855,
-0.0288331062,
0.0154273044,
0.0073222918,
0.0447350144,
-0.011955604,
0.044822786,
-0.0239746179,
0.0111786043,
-0.0276594162,
0.0100220833,
-0.0179347117,
-0.0116511071,
-0.0372008868,
0.0310387854,
0.0056285355,
-0.0008421123,
-0.0257132649,
-0.0619463809,
0.0289779548,
0.0746045113,
-0.0655530691,
0.0128172394,
-0.037593659,
0.0007945102,
-0.0170398857,
-0.016601596,
-0.0341106541,
0.0362051353,
-0.0109301051,
0.0190237891,
-0.0230304245,
-0.0103625087,
0.0331019945,
-0.0646205097,
-0.0122511182,
-0.0010599992,
0.0204529893,
-0.0061621275,
0.0339806043,
0.0070597953,
-0.0168807451,
0.0993115008,
-0.0629989281,
0.0224125609,
0.021132879,
0.028842967,
-0.0224639848,
0.047722172,
-0.0174830705,
0.0423984677,
-0.00965467,
-0.0105820727,
-0.0264432188,
-0.0096951462,
-0.06251847,
0.0017792402,
0.0028522382,
-0.0359802321,
-0.0087549752,
0.0296985898,
-0.0102738403,
0.0404909179,
0.0102987178,
-0.0267310441,
-0.0081771081,
0.0392667726,
0.023103701,
0.0301136207,
0.0606089085,
0.0017878764,
-0.0328451581,
0.0141610038,
0.0104160607,
0.0237448663,
0.012431724,
-0.0139110442,
0.0059048175,
-0.079232879,
-0.0189346727,
-0.0132472161,
0.0436766073,
-0.0400011353,
-0.0226567201,
0.1275494993,
-0.0000186029,
-0.0229505468,
-0.0234432239,
0.0472997352,
0.0211562291,
0.0237660669,
0.0076086414,
-0.0837525055,
-0.0465661585,
0.0265280865,
0.0357260145,
-0.0005202994,
-0.1022700816,
0.0025822932,
-0.1201724187,
0.0103388056,
-0.030873239,
-0.054789234,
0.0086017493,
-0.0792411342,
0.0042804428,
-0.0756619647,
0.0066949232,
-0.0187695511,
-0.0024961566,
0.0058144233,
0.0284193289,
-0.0014796392,
-0.0677757114,
0.0124551449,
-0.0583468787,
0.1097151637,
0.0198361538,
0.0338483863,
-0.0285635795,
-0.01286171,
0.0288760178,
-0.0244330894,
-0.0522251129,
-0.0085945912,
0.0859676749,
-0.0402149968,
-0.0116296113,
-0.0213286616,
-0.0187538173,
-0.0254283883,
-0.0002064159,
-0.0095732724,
0.0147189703,
0.0284378286,
0.0290369634,
0.0177226737,
-0.0260941852,
0.0128510091,
0.0675621927,
0.0020316995,
-0.0067750858,
-0.0172548816,
-0.0015913185,
0.0170027558,
-0.0263103433,
0.0234893225,
0.0236944892,
-0.083646059,
-0.0619991235,
-0.0391059443,
-0.0871121287,
0.0401628017,
0.0481445454,
0.0136052566,
0.0006066993,
0.0224965177,
0.0176548697,
-0.0787627548,
0.035472963,
-0.0226162318,
0.0277516097,
-0.0573951229,
-0.0011479796,
-0.0063912291,
0.0435894988,
-0.0439618379,
0.0327892154,
-0.0710402504,
-0.0380707309,
0.0286544841,
0.0263764448,
0.0188950375,
0.0444519743,
-0.0215132572,
0.001101393,
-0.0175509844,
0.055919636,
0.0001033355,
-0.006820153,
0.0271233972,
0.0198845323,
-0.0176914278,
0.0122909443,
-0.0408407561,
-0.0025007788,
0.0065664388,
0.0424708836,
-0.0363866128,
-0.0185833648,
-0.0151184173,
0.0420071222,
0.0620353259,
-0.0239236802,
-0.0059124064,
-0.0442480408,
0.0089413747,
0.0268054903,
0.0091620674,
-0.0070950082,
-0.0052665169,
0.0177962147,
-0.0000940238,
-0.0366014987,
0.0695109963,
-0.0072323354,
0.027425345,
-0.0479978099,
-0.0068225092,
0.0125279091,
0.0722586513,
-0.016326217,
-0.0441331267,
0.0048251967,
0.0635210499,
0.0820603743,
0.0775898397,
-0.0121711548,
-0.0250852127,
0.0041731964,
0.019985931,
0.0024506373,
0.0211544186,
-0.0231539998,
0.0460295379,
-0.0501629636,
0.0451555774,
0.0543334298,
0.0117317513,
0.1224660575,
-0.0147969108,
-0.0015114013,
0.0027481322,
-0.0001662596,
0.0080721769,
-0.006328335,
0.014487803,
0.0002003957,
-0.0150952265,
-0.0147061488,
0.052997645,
0.012856775,
0.0408728011,
0.0008476214,
-0.0244294722,
-0.0470737442,
0.0027579737,
-0.0260724798,
0.0041523101,
-0.0073426543,
-0.0387971252,
-0.040986415,
-0.0651095882,
0.0470697396,
0.000425876,
0.0114077237,
0.0374727286,
-0.0015617438,
-0.0242477544,
0.0299867336,
-0.0263660699,
-0.0314239003,
-0.0341308042,
0.0100012589,
-0.048880998,
-0.0148668382,
-5.971507996e-33,
-0.0562681444,
-0.0261340197,
-0.0021899322,
-0.0444598049,
-0.0194367561,
0.0368172303,
-0.0315606967,
-0.0130973123,
-0.0030327241,
0.0002193834,
-0.0057732258,
0.0034029179,
0.0363624133,
0.0073636156,
0.0010476531,
-0.0518038683,
0.0546693318,
0.0378798917,
-0.0175520349,
0.0027700965,
0.0559795089,
0.0515976325,
0.1012920886,
-0.0935348868,
0.103060618,
0.0184625201,
-0.0382255837,
0.0078128185,
0.0568747148,
0.0502866656,
-0.0001637964,
0.0042888564,
0.0138542391,
-0.0415822826,
-0.0029712461,
-0.0192315057,
-0.1822363883,
0.0037661516,
-0.0064980038,
0.0378428325,
0.0116643328,
0.0056757149,
0.0228538178,
-0.0048232814,
0.0082308417,
0.0123875123,
0.043485254,
-0.011928332,
-0.0050333394,
-0.0506211519,
-0.0262897424,
0.0726867542,
0.0049827364,
0.038882181,
0.0373670012,
0.0041061542,
0.0255692098,
-0.0153250936,
-0.083834745,
-0.0326928943,
0.0242402684,
-0.0095234355,
0.0302675124,
0.020026803,
-0.0083989846,
0.0407556519,
0.0412779972,
0.0291002002,
-0.0284510888,
0.0060640816,
0.0309797488,
-0.0000175731,
-0.0035503332,
0.066379562,
0.0460197516,
-0.0233081374,
-0.0495397486,
0.0388857648,
-0.0004776171,
0.0108031891,
-0.0378814116,
-0.041245006,
-0.0653780922,
-0.0078669535,
-0.0309960935,
-0.0391268469,
-0.0259078592,
0.0176142175,
0.0294663887,
-0.0031697291,
-0.0481832437,
0.0583207756,
-0.0082965735,
-0.0082529653,
-0.0468475968,
-0.0027490656,
0.0789739415,
0.009711327,
-0.0218936577,
-0.0061540217,
-0.0561699942,
-0.024194248,
-0.0094297677,
0.0152063612,
0.0276773386,
-0.0202633571,
0.0770334601,
-0.0081228707,
-0.0700260699,
-0.0013327198,
-0.0058799204,
0.0543393008,
-0.0193994753,
-0.0018972518,
0.0152753731,
-0.0230680536,
0.0008043785,
-0.0171113983,
0.0834539458,
0.0098039666,
0.0119847702,
0.0420570485,
0.0459758937,
-0.0012136676,
0.020255629,
-0.0052345409,
0.0176173002,
0.0165169891,
0.0136219747,
-0.0655801669,
0.0254825931,
-0.0065982239,
2.48e-7,
0.0265195556,
0.0208630171,
0.0387525558,
-0.0138611514,
-0.0206847861,
0.0005886153,
0.0318686999,
0.0296366457,
-0.0334322825,
-0.0042454405,
-0.0211041793,
-0.0566346906,
0.0401236825,
0.0415048636,
-0.0808818862,
-0.0610329174,
-0.0252548344,
-0.0065432717,
-0.0286242124,
0.0321520045,
0.0099063888,
0.0599947497,
0.0252387188,
-0.0293289572,
-0.0219196379,
-0.0137070473,
0.0133815985,
-0.0107305869,
0.0284016859,
0.0291247666,
0.0592888929,
0.0422132164,
-0.0064189625,
0.0329486392,
-0.0380451679,
-0.002932722,
-0.0123195043,
0.0505915731,
-0.0087564252,
-0.0015973895,
-0.0193534382,
-0.0502136573,
0.0277416762,
-0.0104938569,
0.0439005569,
-0.0066610053,
-0.0059776246,
0.0026281599,
-0.0440816432,
-0.0140298456,
0.0090440558,
0.0270394757,
-0.0212232657,
0.0289451126,
0.010399458,
-0.0266809985,
-0.0219945703,
-0.0721733868,
-0.0123381643,
0.0339791998,
0.0318045318,
-0.0199441314,
0.0120670637,
-0.0456366055,
0.0082834223,
-0.0706848279,
-0.0058148042,
2.025244294e-34,
0.0026782663,
0.0100763543,
-0.0080736363,
0.0263957195,
0.0221164208,
0.0012835565,
-0.0047269682,
-0.0137836039,
-0.0272793751,
-0.0307694618,
0.0246658567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16218v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16218v3 | Knowledge Editing for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2023-10-24T22:18:13 | 2023-12-14T21:49:59 | Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Haochen Liu, Zaiyi Zheng, Chen Chen, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have recently transformed both the academic and
industrial landscapes due to their remarkable capacity to understand, analyze,
and generate texts based on their vast knowledge and reasoning ability.
Nevertheless, one major drawback of LLMs is their substantial computational
cost for pre-training due to their unprecedented amounts of parameters. The
disadvantage is exacerbated when new knowledge frequently needs to be
introduced into the pre-trained model. Therefore, it is imperative to develop
effective and efficient techniques to update pre-trained LLMs. Traditional
methods encode new knowledge in pre-trained LLMs through direct fine-tuning.
However, naively re-training LLMs can be computationally intensive and risks
degenerating valuable pre-trained knowledge irrelevant to the update in the
model. Recently, Knowledge-based Model Editing (KME) has attracted increasing
attention, which aims to precisely modify the LLMs to incorporate specific
knowledge, without negatively influencing other irrelevant knowledge. In this
survey, we aim to provide a comprehensive and in-depth overview of recent
advances in the field of KME. We first introduce a general formulation of KME
to encompass different KME strategies. Afterward, we provide an innovative
taxonomy of KME techniques based on how the new knowledge is introduced into
pre-trained LLMs, and investigate existing KME strategies while analyzing key
insights, advantages, and limitations of methods from each category. Moreover,
representative metrics, datasets, and applications of KME are introduced
accordingly. Finally, we provide an in-depth analysis regarding the
practicality and remaining challenges of KME and suggest promising research
directions for further advancement in this field. | [
0.0475765765,
0.0640865788,
-0.0263519902,
0.0410411581,
-0.0409743637,
0.0001805266,
-0.0209045745,
-0.0211852528,
-0.0215093642,
-0.0829970464,
-0.0355928987,
0.0175406784,
-0.0109653855,
0.0222729761,
0.0317800045,
-0.0409508608,
0.0584073924,
-0.0340062529,
-0.0010972109,
-0.0016079491,
-0.005639771,
0.0049130381,
0.0238865614,
-0.0110428715,
0.0154060125,
-0.0179890245,
-0.0192881152,
0.0046384418,
0.021439258,
0.0385316424,
-0.022765914,
0.0750419125,
0.0222050063,
0.0423012972,
0.000002192,
-0.0526145212,
-0.0674070045,
0.0149376625,
-0.0398587622,
0.0516147688,
0.0306401141,
-0.0200357288,
-0.0330323689,
-0.0264373198,
-0.031552583,
0.0242725872,
0.0574527718,
0.0278030559,
0.0765707791,
0.083899051,
-0.0036473642,
0.006022431,
0.0141530167,
-0.0146249738,
-0.0201641023,
-0.0165654514,
0.0758652538,
0.0549959876,
-0.0400321782,
0.0207534134,
-0.0146342218,
0.0645018145,
0.0054826741,
-0.0453228429,
0.0255126823,
-0.0137955109,
-0.0230918359,
0.0195992347,
0.0079926671,
0.0460272543,
-0.0091934614,
-0.0319801345,
-0.0147595573,
0.0008503117,
0.0039329375,
0.0266561769,
-0.0227861647,
-0.0233320892,
0.0383002572,
0.0067497641,
0.004272534,
-0.0727794245,
0.0356937386,
0.0215560813,
-0.0436033867,
0.059532389,
0.044530265,
-0.0356589705,
-0.018222468,
-0.0297456123,
-0.0467647724,
-0.0706354529,
-0.0066447267,
0.0374851674,
0.0117070731,
0.0322434641,
-0.0634399056,
-0.0308216084,
-0.0120349173,
-0.0512449667,
0.0478962623,
0.0268737543,
0.0110788029,
0.059277229,
-0.0051686238,
0.0212068539,
0.0123707708,
-0.0096761985,
-0.0458727479,
0.0286991429,
-0.0635521561,
-0.0274593327,
-0.0539656244,
-0.0039973008,
-0.0392674953,
0.0312421899,
-0.0122278025,
0.0500087626,
-0.0130837411,
0.0270592384,
-0.0024196864,
-0.0191941317,
-0.0069827507,
-0.0471773855,
-0.0162429102,
0.02797102,
-0.0042146398,
0.009478868,
-0.0158156659,
0.0001214233,
-0.0021207023,
-0.0097137345,
0.0189863462,
-0.0154055674,
-0.0066551827,
0.0419222191,
-0.0116710942,
-0.0062552975,
-0.0375997573,
-0.0645428598,
0.0015711446,
-0.0569739901,
-0.0086503541,
-0.0448372886,
0.0307028256,
-0.0205560233,
-0.0251510777,
-0.0732528418,
-0.0064415364,
-0.0358538628,
-0.0336917639,
0.0884728432,
-0.0411201902,
0.0304901041,
0.0240483526,
0.0110167023,
-0.0352978483,
0.066122584,
0.0289488714,
-0.0211268924,
0.0679992139,
-0.0266739111,
-0.0207115132,
0.0411490202,
0.0154115781,
0.0230408628,
-0.02312156,
0.0100385854,
0.0147025874,
0.0187742021,
0.0008176228,
-0.0090013454,
-0.0311638545,
0.0151902456,
0.0726731345,
-0.0137652475,
0.0224306006,
0.0480684116,
0.0502943397,
-0.0130294077,
0.0302112903,
0.0041737552,
-0.0183143523,
-0.0254021119,
-0.0521455705,
0.0315310843,
-0.0125100017,
0.0317292064,
-0.0090650683,
-0.048656743,
0.003919485,
0.0083564529,
0.001315337,
0.0169578716,
0.0619333349,
0.0220948756,
-0.0161635894,
0.0557458736,
0.0332685597,
-0.0305172373,
0.0299764648,
-0.0496231951,
-0.0051656673,
0.0655959919,
0.0629688203,
-0.0663631558,
-0.0618521348,
0.0163485277,
-0.0155544337,
-0.0098328236,
0.0481330268,
-0.0349709652,
-0.0183850676,
-0.0353023522,
-0.0224266555,
-0.0370613486,
0.0317469761,
0.0090182861,
0.0440943725,
-0.016746249,
0.040496625,
-0.0409325249,
-0.0203158893,
0.0063693319,
-0.0611015633,
-0.0192040987,
-0.0028403569,
0.0008806909,
0.0161518268,
-0.0005524486,
-0.03726485,
-0.0067482651,
0.0192327872,
0.0064106518,
-0.0061213509,
0.0029164143,
-0.0123508032,
-0.0436589569,
0.0502719395,
0.0201476049,
-0.0122192809,
0.0021878283,
-0.038282346,
-0.022404125,
-0.0049727564,
0.0089705018,
0.0784063935,
-0.0451753847,
0.0499922261,
-0.0261565819,
-0.0510322154,
-0.0256727487,
0.0460400544,
0.0133735063,
-0.0388061553,
0.0302352607,
-0.0369930007,
-0.0116545632,
-0.0161929242,
-0.0275838114,
0.0116086425,
0.0237881709,
0.0039932202,
0.007597771,
-0.0032743176,
-0.0314005762,
-0.0286872238,
-0.0918467417,
0.0077970996,
-0.0148386918,
0.0107910056,
0.0459545515,
0.0222945642,
-0.0307200477,
0.0210444499,
0.0035403674,
-0.0062003303,
-0.0144376904,
0.0162254348,
-0.0042103413,
0.029673893,
-0.0064174123,
-0.0143700493,
0.0022566165,
0.0078817196,
0.0628487915,
0.005233034,
-0.0103668924,
-0.0728622526,
0.0631901547,
-0.0672726259,
0.0250353925,
0.0036168681,
-0.0122331176,
-0.045715183,
-0.0102735264,
0.0675350875,
0.0235904064,
-0.0343703367,
0.0101212822,
0.075105451,
-0.0476635657,
-0.0024939368,
0.0110897897,
-0.0158220753,
-0.0239246022,
-0.0456179045,
-0.0074273576,
0.0129122175,
0.0515283532,
-0.0126757035,
-0.073919639,
-0.0360768735,
0.0260002427,
-0.0188068897,
-0.0551877506,
-0.051455874,
-0.0065400726,
0.0140068997,
0.0357818529,
-0.0295814518,
-0.0344994664,
0.0776995718,
-0.038123548,
0.0410522111,
-0.0372723788,
0.0056566773,
-0.0278477371,
0.0457139201,
-0.0081355162,
0.0340278558,
0.0040640393,
0.0354514681,
-0.0621470697,
-0.0149736675,
0.0317095146,
-0.0108263651,
0.0335555151,
-0.0904481113,
0.0158965997,
0.0235261116,
-0.0071380702,
-0.0212047249,
-0.0048666205,
-0.0106334072,
0.0249909274,
0.0262802057,
-0.0287611037,
-0.0088849692,
0.0130215744,
0.0254069306,
0.0396134332,
-0.0063069388,
-0.0054394864,
-0.0346442498,
0.0207442418,
0.0556517392,
0.0198434442,
0.020567501,
-0.018351201,
0.0284374766,
0.0491632782,
-0.0074363709,
-0.0508658029,
-0.0038947233,
-0.0038663724,
-0.007553949,
-0.0888192505,
0.0015195911,
-0.005799579,
0.0320794396,
-0.061006438,
-0.0027689363,
0.1244891584,
0.04093007,
-0.0126636671,
0.0053746994,
-0.0232683793,
0.0197279025,
0.0179093126,
0.064898394,
-0.072661221,
-0.0161754824,
0.0175303239,
0.008551714,
-0.0263187736,
-0.0411685258,
-0.0337327048,
-0.0909430161,
0.0195392296,
0.0289773084,
-0.0286277458,
-0.0631406456,
-0.0299184937,
0.0110042766,
0.0035682472,
-0.0054678996,
0.0253407639,
-0.0016436781,
-0.0019135877,
-0.0227102637,
-0.0141405445,
-0.0797441974,
0.0012759069,
-0.0181768835,
0.051475659,
0.0276368186,
0.01286224,
0.0177389067,
0.0224977154,
0.0043028472,
0.040854089,
0.0183778163,
-0.0269373432,
0.0128656439,
-0.0099574486,
0.0112450831,
0.0181133989,
0.0346302986,
0.0016752222,
-0.0449517109,
0.036946021,
0.1038493067,
-0.00754584,
0.0158255864,
0.0191541314,
-0.0219717566,
-0.0018898533,
0.0673935041,
0.0384432748,
-0.0096197212,
0.0283687469,
-0.0480918698,
-0.0157970116,
-0.0028207873,
-0.0131531106,
-0.013133402,
-0.0607553385,
0.013454821,
-0.0642831698,
-0.0256143771,
0.0635472238,
0.0035272976,
0.0619800314,
0.0100728758,
0.0345825739,
-0.0232500378,
-0.0552222729,
0.0089533329,
-0.0879020393,
-0.0188104734,
-0.0258176327,
-0.0255830809,
0.0028353045,
-0.0427957177,
-0.0108704446,
-0.0121736545,
-0.0490184911,
-0.0847186893,
-0.0079106009,
0.0477563217,
0.0162426662,
0.0849484727,
-0.0129392277,
-0.062975429,
0.0705667436,
-0.0008556964,
-0.0325049981,
0.0445502587,
0.0333614349,
-0.0276775192,
-0.0140410559,
0.0390860215,
-0.0393713228,
0.0003711513,
0.0343079939,
0.0182525646,
-0.0310646053,
-0.0431790352,
0.0232374873,
0.0428493284,
0.0015643445,
0.0086183446,
-0.0067257704,
-0.0547130778,
0.0568630919,
-0.0590113513,
-0.0452342704,
-0.0383579694,
0.0010412047,
0.0101423515,
0.0053292429,
-0.0134043461,
0.0044801915,
0.0026640645,
0.0403233655,
-0.0038525276,
-0.0134527618,
-0.0032719804,
0.0179235078,
0.067411676,
0.0002360463,
0.0069678542,
0.0444193222,
-0.0165687613,
0.0201239791,
-0.028586464,
0.0331410579,
0.0253467746,
-0.0299263149,
-0.0631170347,
0.0218325164,
-0.0531067736,
-0.0645692945,
-0.0332063772,
0.0372066237,
0.0585027598,
0.0064338171,
0.0405461676,
-0.061762061,
-0.0548274145,
-0.0226839539,
0.0456871092,
0.042125836,
-0.0103434967,
-0.0086014699,
0.0058110529,
-0.0137877157,
0.0282098036,
0.0593717992,
0.0153620169,
0.1155639216,
-0.0430587083,
-0.0569073632,
-0.0410426408,
-0.0282836389,
0.0126002589,
-0.0155185275,
-0.0340602137,
0.0034263546,
-0.05306454,
-0.0738132149,
0.0150981322,
0.0000883778,
-0.0445093066,
0.014154016,
0.024103716,
0.0495405346,
-0.0098012481,
0.0035527502,
-0.0310780555,
0.0015833991,
-0.0039234287,
-0.0156754609,
0.0275310706,
-6.056356648e-33,
-0.026499819,
0.0044366647,
0.0329010226,
-0.0110066747,
-0.0378663354,
-0.0098813688,
-0.019965658,
-0.0219478421,
0.0348421857,
0.0235318206,
-0.0076133017,
-0.011259431,
-0.0061816233,
-0.000647128,
-0.028908588,
0.0146532329,
0.0640878752,
0.0315483287,
-0.0051783742,
0.026131954,
0.0294321962,
0.0398830585,
0.0871829689,
-0.0213043522,
0.039703317,
0.020836195,
-0.0078784414,
0.0444797054,
-0.0363962017,
0.0478859954,
-0.0296679959,
0.0200767498,
0.0057166261,
-0.0337825716,
-0.0493884124,
-0.0301097613,
-0.0448732227,
-0.0033695514,
0.027484769,
0.0327540897,
0.0079882545,
-0.0597031824,
0.0252494346,
0.003178806,
0.014685831,
-0.0182264876,
0.0193751343,
-0.0509069897,
-0.0000614561,
-0.025785042,
-0.0712631419,
0.0361924544,
-0.0142652607,
-0.0158697739,
0.0310044717,
-0.0043796087,
0.0317265131,
-0.0153336274,
-0.0413429812,
0.0287800655,
0.1000538692,
0.0604311265,
0.0619886294,
0.0047812532,
0.0195117425,
0.0148833618,
-0.0389136635,
0.009350338,
-0.0003509962,
0.015394765,
0.0269936137,
0.0389968529,
0.000656111,
0.0548568405,
-0.0066538611,
-0.0150062144,
-0.0687182471,
-0.0060510244,
-0.061399933,
0.0283319931,
-0.0126915351,
0.0288555678,
0.0023074795,
-0.0009307028,
-0.0872913897,
-0.0000482501,
-0.027619794,
-0.0138820112,
0.0072742393,
0.0090098688,
-0.0553537719,
0.0079375589,
0.028110005,
-0.055143889,
-0.0019065615,
0.0043926444,
-0.021698039,
0.0484330021,
-0.0155413011,
0.0140468339,
-0.0423510484,
-0.0156975053,
0.0553534813,
-0.0437611304,
-0.0079605076,
-0.01563875,
0.0286993384,
0.0482862256,
-0.0332059078,
0.0248533394,
-0.0127646504,
0.0123309428,
0.0415606424,
-0.0093247145,
0.0030028115,
0.0273173153,
0.0165222399,
0.0066679209,
0.0884328708,
-0.0065969815,
0.0018235409,
0.0255996492,
0.0189518221,
0.0187140033,
-0.0081714634,
0.0122586247,
-0.0099769374,
-0.0346919112,
0.0181097686,
-0.0265770704,
-0.010027362,
0.0086907037,
2.871e-7,
0.0634627342,
0.0585566796,
0.009182509,
0.0030443512,
0.0305955689,
0.0311946031,
-0.0152667817,
-0.0110623892,
0.0395972244,
-0.0231972281,
0.0576627925,
0.0326398537,
0.030503653,
0.0022665116,
-0.0761293247,
-0.0225205105,
-0.0181692932,
-0.0170337278,
-0.0577608645,
-0.0344418921,
0.0468111075,
0.0629649758,
0.0381660387,
0.0074085575,
-0.0269208048,
-0.0469264537,
0.0750152916,
-0.050987307,
-0.0405876748,
0.060812097,
0.0542783551,
0.0122901723,
-0.0215122774,
0.0333976634,
-0.0404380038,
0.0099567259,
-0.0385189913,
0.0863644853,
-0.0082662581,
0.0515393019,
0.0011641135,
0.0071581258,
-0.0082167694,
-0.0550885573,
0.0876870453,
-0.0462904386,
-0.0052880389,
-0.0305467211,
-0.0159951691,
-0.0296749212,
-0.0117675681,
-0.0450898856,
-0.0024615445,
0.02657656,
0.0187757593,
0.0433226228,
-0.0391019732,
-0.0582145788,
-0.0158330128,
0.0180749111,
-0.0301747508,
-0.0648619607,
-0.0224050228,
-0.0626587048,
0.0483971015,
-0.0945828259,
0.0300021525,
2.963255495e-34,
0.0371123441,
0.0017751195,
0.0116863037,
0.038317848,
0.0613942184,
-0.0202559251,
-0.0116767641,
0.0136323124,
-0.0044510993,
-0.1096227914,
-0.007692067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16197v1 | Background Summarization of Event Timelines | 2023-10-24T21:30:15 | 2023-10-24T21:30:15 | Adithya Pratapa, Kevin Small, Markus Dreyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating concise summaries of news events is a challenging natural language
processing task. While journalists often curate timelines to highlight key
sub-events, newcomers to a news event face challenges in catching up on its
historical context. In this paper, we address this need by introducing the task
of background news summarization, which complements each timeline update with a
background summary of relevant preceding events. We construct a dataset by
merging existing timeline datasets and asking human annotators to write a
background summary for each timestep of each news event. We establish strong
baseline performance using state-of-the-art summarization systems and propose a
query-focused variant to generate background summaries. To evaluate background
summary quality, we present a question-answering-based evaluation metric,
Background Utility Score (BUS), which measures the percentage of questions
about a current event timestep that a background summary answers. Our
experiments show the effectiveness of instruction fine-tuned systems such as
Flan-T5, in addition to strong zero-shot performance using GPT-3.5. | [
0.0242636092,
0.0177153386,
0.0141005386,
-0.0006373486,
-0.0141443266,
0.0224377383,
-0.0173830055,
-0.0127442162,
-0.0156603567,
-0.0253133643,
0.0522598289,
-0.0195678081,
-0.0083795916,
0.0176704023,
-0.0351109579,
-0.1324777156,
0.0479253717,
0.008641798,
0.0241597034,
0.0294088647,
0.0235462058,
0.0135689806,
-0.0224527568,
0.0158132557,
0.0010902541,
-0.0085474635,
-0.0295391884,
-0.0275797658,
0.0498521738,
-0.0550331436,
-0.0150746368,
0.0284513254,
0.058713682,
0.0121481149,
0.0000018192,
-0.048455961,
-0.0003893561,
-0.0110040409,
-0.0080374051,
0.0327420272,
-0.0003202132,
-0.0069901277,
0.0192286894,
-0.0103351278,
-0.0475802161,
-0.0092960075,
-0.003561419,
0.0519574881,
0.1082241684,
0.0481646173,
0.0002364281,
-0.0133521073,
0.0082835732,
0.0051922337,
0.0285557341,
-0.0654804334,
-0.0283317696,
0.012914408,
0.0292753801,
-0.005912987,
0.0137632247,
0.0156496,
0.019391017,
-0.0136165554,
-0.0189901497,
0.0509011932,
-0.0471446179,
0.0267445594,
0.0030083545,
0.0687403232,
0.0360607095,
0.0110496804,
0.0107640894,
0.0038700958,
0.0046670842,
-0.0334771499,
-0.1064286828,
0.0432642922,
-0.0114868665,
-0.0117434282,
0.0171851739,
0.0077114208,
-0.0318565033,
0.0323703475,
0.0280023254,
0.0297485627,
0.0066891564,
-0.0042116987,
-0.0543151163,
0.0052269353,
0.0124246636,
-0.0962265134,
0.0138908364,
0.0739199221,
-0.0366794877,
-0.0113681192,
-0.0318786427,
0.0111975819,
0.0037642217,
-0.0447900444,
-0.0407885909,
0.0210657399,
-0.0072657405,
0.0654028058,
0.0081902565,
0.0323645286,
0.0174841993,
-0.0533196181,
-0.0212158039,
-0.0031845784,
-0.0634040236,
0.0295548495,
-0.0571294464,
0.0291850585,
-0.0502027348,
-0.0018175123,
-0.004764087,
0.0300528239,
0.0390729569,
-0.0084070908,
-0.0047143884,
0.0236199107,
-0.0420877039,
-0.0026504437,
-0.0405459292,
0.0244907252,
-0.1075006649,
-0.0319365859,
0.0274991896,
-0.0371586345,
-0.0278090797,
0.0044259932,
0.0357227959,
-0.0020923838,
-0.0189600047,
-0.0100362599,
-0.0273094885,
-0.0168246608,
-0.0539933667,
-0.0334875025,
0.0123390341,
-0.0334382616,
-0.024478307,
-0.0523744822,
0.0051185605,
-0.0089309067,
-0.0432100147,
0.0300102923,
-0.0050060833,
0.0491744615,
-0.0332330018,
0.0402502231,
-0.0278775059,
0.0064496859,
0.0472597294,
-0.0000694409,
0.026547322,
0.0843658298,
0.0630648956,
0.0462360047,
0.0612154119,
0.0198628549,
-0.0175403655,
-0.0057159192,
-0.002334917,
0.0080756657,
-0.0105774067,
0.0242408849,
-0.049581971,
0.012345098,
0.0364045091,
0.0135719907,
-0.0112224165,
0.0202594344,
0.0472506881,
0.0396486111,
-0.0379021317,
0.0022577443,
0.046618022,
0.0319392979,
0.0149948681,
0.0631709918,
-0.0127916122,
0.0648440495,
-0.0347184017,
0.0366512276,
0.038910415,
0.0107780229,
-0.040505629,
-0.0305790342,
0.0249909721,
0.0068932273,
0.0203329753,
0.0189328436,
-0.0004427792,
0.0063761636,
-0.0585734062,
0.0472894683,
-0.0015658269,
-0.0578128807,
0.0432239734,
-0.0044902512,
0.0240100697,
0.0758036077,
0.0430455506,
-0.0114534954,
-0.0486552417,
-0.0259850398,
0.0682969689,
0.0157837905,
0.0535588413,
-0.0280708056,
0.0165226907,
-0.0271029845,
-0.0441305973,
-0.0320711508,
0.0179912522,
-0.0049305013,
0.0291678812,
0.0022944857,
0.0183133744,
-0.02397459,
-0.0319396667,
0.0261236746,
-0.0126531469,
-0.0441595875,
-0.0162633285,
-0.0119004985,
-0.0256137215,
0.0635108277,
0.0060113291,
0.0090745911,
0.0267805252,
-0.0127585297,
0.0141421901,
0.042086035,
-0.0325421356,
-0.0272002462,
0.017906921,
-0.044029709,
-0.0518179983,
0.0338256583,
-0.04920258,
-0.0755449757,
0.0152950464,
-0.0373103209,
-0.0270096678,
-0.0313307233,
-0.025364114,
0.0112097822,
-0.0206497405,
-0.0462005474,
0.0967787653,
0.0304199755,
0.0012271518,
0.0393848233,
-0.0070150206,
0.0115107102,
-0.0580351874,
0.0008547616,
0.0287467465,
0.0131667387,
-0.010372417,
0.0579008609,
-0.0221886318,
-0.0705125928,
0.0383021086,
-0.1182213128,
0.0479450934,
-0.0501175337,
0.0219245814,
0.0684885681,
0.0354052484,
-0.0161525626,
-0.0213635471,
-0.0334805287,
-0.0304097068,
0.0197370257,
0.0208679885,
0.0413942114,
0.0671818033,
0.0314346142,
-0.0729671642,
-0.0011814762,
-0.0257246718,
0.0175276939,
0.0471428372,
-0.0234740693,
-0.0195392948,
-0.024434315,
-0.0121124471,
0.003681822,
0.0035206119,
0.0169432461,
0.0386825912,
-0.0117277009,
0.0170651674,
0.0555130765,
0.05475327,
0.0162686463,
-0.0019100556,
-0.0270267315,
-0.028151365,
0.0262851864,
-0.0381417014,
0.0050889771,
0.0014689892,
-0.0267241448,
0.0053167245,
0.0321326219,
-0.0040180339,
0.0205302723,
-0.0473536551,
-0.0110156024,
-0.0180789288,
0.0215084702,
-0.0363904834,
-0.0110125728,
-0.0307462234,
0.0492540188,
-0.0348058753,
0.0045899972,
0.0472185723,
0.0125328572,
0.0088186674,
-0.0260855965,
0.0000834531,
-0.0707242861,
0.0779736191,
-0.0206113812,
0.0078350278,
-0.0159806274,
-0.0573202334,
-0.0261116084,
-0.0414496735,
0.0370046869,
-0.0221162196,
0.0500453226,
-0.0523777604,
-0.0008640459,
-0.0339961275,
0.0135564059,
-0.0401833504,
-0.0655441359,
-0.0384451225,
0.0125554847,
-0.0360202603,
-0.0006181414,
-0.0230051409,
0.015728306,
0.031368956,
0.0496785082,
-0.035747949,
-0.0105764167,
-0.0069995518,
0.0812547877,
0.0711687505,
0.0029827068,
0.0151736792,
-0.0103037553,
0.0369107984,
0.0252858326,
0.0801635161,
0.0288009942,
-0.0014657155,
0.0021069602,
-0.0099269347,
-0.0821991935,
-0.0078775994,
0.0152900917,
0.0615377463,
-0.0559957772,
-0.0008227444,
0.1320357174,
0.0512229167,
-0.0136333518,
-0.0104460614,
0.0538346991,
-0.0105564706,
0.0218610559,
0.0216154326,
-0.0546441488,
-0.0135494126,
-0.0099067716,
0.0348594449,
0.0075755743,
-0.0661315843,
-0.033926852,
-0.0921613723,
0.0125333825,
-0.007370003,
-0.0419727303,
-0.0005539669,
-0.0789918527,
0.0092861466,
-0.0246055443,
0.0021033413,
0.0238198042,
-0.0221121795,
0.0217868444,
-0.00169595,
-0.0537278205,
-0.0263574049,
0.0295452066,
-0.0121773444,
0.017281618,
0.034610264,
0.0424513742,
-0.0043450058,
0.0314890034,
0.0172002576,
-0.0530366749,
0.0092450995,
0.0126930438,
0.0783562139,
-0.0256497338,
0.0049469997,
-0.027969718,
0.0104894973,
0.0401942171,
0.0043159663,
0.0219816081,
0.0395317748,
-0.006709774,
0.0169110876,
-0.0194786992,
0.0211354885,
0.0189207774,
0.0798868164,
0.0585807003,
-0.0059775729,
-0.0287624262,
-0.0230123121,
0.0133864414,
-0.1252504885,
-0.0217871387,
-0.0081624296,
-0.0515139885,
-0.0362586901,
-0.0695444494,
-0.0833993405,
0.0200980194,
-0.0065576369,
-0.0346045122,
0.0088951904,
0.0009063366,
0.0183290243,
-0.0630308166,
0.0261336528,
-0.0069654724,
-0.0091580031,
-0.0194790028,
-0.021613583,
0.0078029959,
0.0232571904,
-0.012336161,
0.07331945,
-0.0790887028,
-0.0162203629,
-0.0010406764,
-0.0074422811,
0.0244109165,
0.0262898616,
-0.0059585953,
-0.014233483,
-0.0096835596,
0.0294009764,
0.0188754536,
-0.0284891669,
-0.0323257297,
0.007085694,
-0.0115917111,
0.0042347433,
-0.0665700659,
0.0127331074,
-0.0615962595,
0.0504288264,
-0.0752417818,
-0.0132603273,
0.0085823908,
0.0028820504,
0.0277387258,
-0.014619723,
-0.0258604996,
-0.0085428795,
-0.043561846,
-0.0615344681,
0.0082004713,
-0.0101736011,
0.0217378009,
-0.0275323838,
-0.0208448339,
-0.0096831769,
0.0769561976,
-0.0485277995,
0.0173042938,
-0.082982108,
-0.0169979166,
-0.0022915236,
0.0261234548,
-0.0608744547,
-0.0006752787,
-0.0459533222,
-0.0237534996,
0.0021429518,
0.0234566145,
-0.0071221008,
-0.0134655163,
0.0066012843,
0.0314321406,
0.0231413562,
0.0151535515,
-0.1382224411,
-0.0027624692,
-0.0303335618,
0.0325351954,
0.0687550455,
-0.0405626968,
0.0735269859,
0.029623257,
-0.0102488417,
0.0053838929,
-0.0037696743,
0.0268438868,
-0.0259535871,
-0.0130911386,
0.0410166457,
0.0016363922,
0.0401806645,
0.0736527219,
-0.0228678547,
0.0491658933,
0.0392859317,
-0.0278507639,
-0.0291124322,
-0.036831554,
-0.0405101553,
0.034791287,
0.0101334788,
-0.0076930914,
-0.0617934503,
0.0054651238,
0.0308624469,
0.0082968576,
0.0122252693,
0.010232971,
0.0520834439,
0.0055926922,
0.0265384857,
-0.0283901468,
-0.0343574844,
0.0327775702,
-0.0456735753,
-0.0188059248,
-0.0385230295,
-6.24885597e-33,
-0.0486344919,
-0.0309821032,
0.0021157395,
-0.0101032192,
-0.0524228849,
0.0176818259,
-0.0677961633,
-0.0114829978,
-0.0264410265,
-0.0137255648,
-0.0178414546,
0.0239069592,
0.0186271127,
-0.0071758553,
0.0008029399,
-0.0190040767,
0.052004125,
-0.0166093335,
-0.0350180306,
0.0651892498,
0.0425401814,
0.0126404492,
0.0454064459,
-0.0198632721,
0.0426436886,
-0.0270240698,
-0.0122090885,
-0.0090264929,
0.0918805525,
0.0350176245,
0.0075544026,
0.0078798393,
0.0350955464,
-0.0450861603,
-0.0496575013,
0.0375482701,
-0.0817858353,
-0.0338735804,
0.0324683115,
-0.0095010567,
-0.0354976282,
-0.0254003853,
0.0189697687,
-0.0197098982,
0.0200104639,
-0.0289698541,
0.0577222332,
-0.0367075615,
-0.0026700618,
-0.0316571668,
-0.0038698621,
0.0189764965,
-0.0520643666,
-0.0158420056,
0.0180239696,
0.0487930104,
0.0452910848,
0.0273426306,
-0.0293952227,
0.0431812443,
0.0017057674,
0.0335687436,
0.0350602232,
-0.0271620136,
0.0040596449,
0.043855302,
-0.0050694356,
0.0186227337,
-0.0250677299,
0.0418411642,
-0.0265693869,
0.0170386881,
0.0260288361,
0.0562379174,
0.0656634644,
0.0250360426,
-0.0525872894,
0.0955725983,
0.023748884,
0.0364567563,
-0.0364304073,
0.0050859763,
-0.0027438255,
0.0188210029,
-0.0293596797,
0.0070933742,
-0.0196818076,
-0.0139687974,
0.0056234929,
0.0097045721,
-0.0222121999,
0.0105384393,
0.0140276887,
-0.0106350994,
0.0160903577,
0.0399296097,
-0.0242663696,
0.0423582681,
0.0356943309,
0.0064193374,
-0.0360612161,
0.0504460968,
0.0496676005,
0.0300768614,
0.0152400844,
-0.0048577688,
0.0200037099,
0.0135351969,
-0.0241657495,
0.0002875616,
0.0056832568,
0.0354280546,
-0.0488247573,
-0.0301551018,
0.0094448747,
0.0123842517,
-0.0065846709,
0.0409399904,
0.0058500739,
0.0089166919,
0.0144013092,
-0.0512598827,
0.0152238114,
0.0329728164,
0.0155196106,
0.0106437067,
0.0087791691,
0.0532192811,
-0.0060744532,
-0.0354399793,
-0.0311901141,
0.0147701483,
2.499e-7,
0.0246087201,
0.0410505272,
0.0762173757,
0.0662294403,
-0.0284803938,
-0.0026859287,
0.0061013554,
0.0203146823,
0.0228833891,
-0.0062498776,
0.028583711,
0.0286700614,
0.0146457376,
0.0524262711,
-0.056887053,
-0.0685703009,
-0.0525836535,
-0.0098862574,
-0.0648914278,
0.0038284198,
0.1019008905,
0.0145047661,
0.0023825555,
-0.0063786204,
-0.0087024951,
-0.0274926238,
0.0255154744,
-0.0038368267,
-0.0757094547,
-0.0069641308,
0.0234877709,
0.0300084818,
-0.0291839093,
-0.0069422447,
-0.0243653338,
-0.010656381,
0.0129841706,
0.0172385201,
0.0112432428,
-0.0532441027,
-0.0042538573,
-0.0257522091,
0.0195896123,
-0.0202468093,
0.085464932,
-0.0166165251,
0.0110871838,
-0.011657075,
-0.0750731826,
0.0256181117,
-0.0059682783,
0.0152557353,
-0.0438364334,
0.0165201873,
-0.0260435957,
-0.0009538697,
-0.0033342722,
-0.0578189977,
-0.0313673802,
0.035563536,
-0.0021052479,
-0.0101331072,
-0.0197373386,
-0.0316785611,
-0.0066586081,
-0.0164853353,
0.0112546803,
2.045998427e-34,
0.0486186408,
0.0305370484,
0.0008857942,
-0.0258629303,
0.0223738737,
0.0035062046,
-0.043124184,
-0.0388421416,
0.0347047076,
-0.0474291593,
-0.021987563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16193v1 | Length is a Curse and a Blessing for Document-level Semantics | 2023-10-24T21:23:53 | 2023-10-24T21:23:53 | Chenghao Xiao, Yizhi Li, G Thomas Hudson, Chenghua Lin, Noura Al Moubayed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, contrastive learning (CL) has been extensively utilized to
recover sentence and document-level encoding capability from pre-trained
language models. In this work, we question the length generalizability of
CL-based models, i.e., their vulnerability towards length-induced semantic
shift. We verify not only that length vulnerability is a significant yet
overlooked research gap, but we can devise unsupervised CL methods solely
depending on the semantic signal provided by document length. We first derive
the theoretical foundations underlying length attacks, showing that elongating
a document would intensify the high intra-document similarity that is already
brought by CL. Moreover, we found that isotropy promised by CL is highly
dependent on the length range of text exposed in training. Inspired by these
findings, we introduce a simple yet universal document representation learning
framework, LA(SER)$^{3}$: length-agnostic self-reference for semantically
robust sentence representation learning, achieving state-of-the-art
unsupervised performance on the standard information retrieval benchmark. | [
0.0319681801,
0.0654708892,
-0.0080208415,
0.0404417478,
-0.0711494163,
0.0077774227,
0.0275182594,
-0.0036135886,
-0.0192658678,
-0.0433632508,
-0.0153296422,
-0.0299995206,
0.0060299453,
-0.0128296688,
0.036603149,
-0.0527572706,
0.0339235999,
-0.0114614414,
-0.004573626,
-0.0026949961,
0.02466942,
-0.0202611387,
0.0332405828,
-0.0233548917,
-0.000924068,
-0.0232052039,
-0.018867515,
0.0220791437,
-0.0108458465,
-0.0312534757,
0.0388278551,
0.0401423983,
0.0180702042,
0.0383410938,
0.0000017192,
-0.0375085697,
-0.0451441146,
0.0136721134,
0.0323052704,
0.0156078208,
0.0912568793,
-0.0585991032,
0.0188346319,
0.0005935657,
-0.0206995197,
-0.0326147079,
-0.0006944989,
0.069704026,
0.0246076267,
0.1168750897,
-0.0194785073,
-0.0441565029,
0.0339492112,
-0.0583805442,
0.0027329833,
-0.0091258818,
0.0146288965,
-0.0340229906,
-0.0075501017,
0.051728569,
-0.046434585,
0.0331161357,
0.0133662457,
0.0239772722,
-0.0116901398,
0.0164500531,
-0.0278108753,
0.0245819781,
0.0249537379,
0.0634074062,
-0.0101539008,
-0.0125215473,
-0.0001606161,
0.0009239536,
0.0166827682,
0.0137477871,
-0.0085264519,
-0.0005844314,
0.0217746962,
0.025916256,
0.0341319181,
0.0513203442,
0.0181456357,
-0.0204039402,
-0.0307406038,
0.0003079182,
0.0277585778,
-0.0464866944,
-0.0070656268,
-0.0095516071,
-0.0049990267,
0.0183043331,
-0.0108730821,
-0.0160853826,
0.0181101952,
0.0159719456,
-0.0381136574,
-0.0802088827,
0.0599145219,
-0.0473227762,
0.0420608856,
-0.0138929803,
-0.0290663317,
0.0444434881,
-0.0349971019,
0.0295593534,
-0.0168918204,
0.0340089612,
-0.0568785183,
0.0148095824,
0.0027885158,
-0.0113671022,
-0.0204684939,
0.0242915526,
-0.043315921,
-0.0234007239,
-0.0044083991,
0.0247786846,
0.023431398,
0.008053028,
-0.0253096409,
-0.0015295543,
-0.047458753,
-0.0258431882,
-0.009505094,
0.0371496268,
-0.0139268264,
0.0156226102,
-0.0182432346,
-0.0545672774,
-0.0241889376,
0.0196683798,
-0.0054391203,
-0.0536461063,
0.0132962847,
0.0690023676,
-0.0276554767,
-0.0981254503,
-0.0180128925,
0.002247246,
-0.0536063164,
-0.0405161157,
0.0090475651,
-0.0719984621,
0.0125858607,
-0.0070476858,
-0.009052312,
-0.0677336007,
-0.0120633235,
0.0187253673,
-0.0555432327,
0.0906894431,
0.0075248061,
-0.04185801,
-0.0126381461,
0.0051600514,
0.0524721518,
0.0386250392,
0.0177756865,
0.0112003349,
0.0708572343,
0.0228858031,
-0.0074257026,
0.0021606379,
0.0503770448,
0.0029013173,
-0.0129832719,
0.023630036,
0.0409802943,
-0.0123465071,
0.0129574351,
0.063487187,
-0.0091370661,
-0.0953299627,
0.0633853301,
0.0627273321,
0.0155955618,
0.0336827859,
0.0204151645,
0.0126587301,
-0.0595909916,
0.0594109185,
-0.0230914745,
-0.0205905717,
-0.0111007309,
0.0262184385,
0.0494093895,
0.0145325158,
-0.0568953939,
-0.0105977757,
-0.0079185814,
-0.0458023958,
0.0295919571,
-0.0570050515,
0.0472356454,
0.0439251103,
-0.0096087828,
0.0431206152,
0.017806733,
-0.0645985082,
-0.006019176,
0.0157805849,
-0.0106685366,
0.0382040888,
0.060830377,
-0.0719863772,
0.0300977752,
-0.0118839229,
-0.005300907,
0.0664784983,
0.0482356772,
-0.0010744458,
0.0294729322,
-0.033704374,
-0.005943283,
-0.0689952075,
0.0247490555,
-0.0134932436,
0.0235529225,
0.0232022554,
0.0330024809,
-0.082697995,
-0.0300286375,
0.0310457647,
-0.038171038,
-0.0620186441,
-0.0095114335,
0.0243962221,
-0.0088332277,
-0.0293648429,
-0.0279259514,
0.031528987,
0.0030358934,
-0.0339986049,
0.0036835442,
-0.0287475809,
-0.0426400751,
-0.066696845,
0.0388218276,
-0.057911519,
0.0159725361,
0.067436941,
-0.0478780083,
-0.0158514287,
0.0386185944,
-0.0424002707,
0.0318837278,
-0.0134706041,
0.0172321815,
-0.0014983177,
0.0431698598,
-0.0365898684,
0.0428078249,
-0.0179984346,
0.0155914249,
-0.048757948,
0.0084017329,
0.034644518,
-0.0192981157,
-0.0480446145,
0.000497583,
0.0268724356,
0.0104670189,
0.0445294194,
-0.0212299414,
-0.0275056101,
-0.04064928,
-0.0404035971,
-0.0138688097,
-0.0132200848,
0.0398881286,
0.0112450952,
0.0072478093,
-0.0031714854,
-0.0408199765,
-0.0515784249,
-0.0322895087,
-0.0187379792,
0.0337918922,
0.0548215359,
0.0021571717,
0.0076404163,
-0.0426563509,
-0.0517014489,
-0.0079435576,
0.0957787186,
-0.0437137447,
-0.008149486,
-0.0280295089,
0.0802355632,
-0.0021591657,
0.0392666906,
-0.0227562487,
-0.0043664756,
-0.0237380415,
-0.0323220007,
0.0330956727,
0.0872137696,
0.0625111461,
0.0353160314,
0.0354895629,
0.0131546333,
-0.021491468,
-0.0065270872,
-0.0509113558,
0.0269396007,
-0.0393710695,
-0.0183121581,
0.0215336569,
0.0642384961,
-0.0265612379,
-0.0116512785,
-0.0236260314,
-0.01984578,
0.0332307369,
-0.0224890765,
0.0253653228,
0.0362311229,
-0.0117591079,
0.0024814392,
-0.0342345051,
-0.0580226295,
0.0424513519,
-0.0400035493,
0.0227617715,
-0.0453548096,
-0.0231627822,
-0.0529656075,
0.0966008902,
0.0210387614,
0.0072976095,
0.0037594158,
-0.013063916,
-0.0522839092,
-0.010002871,
0.0218155552,
-0.0122905681,
0.0270075407,
-0.0186201259,
0.0156356655,
-0.013392793,
-0.0877675936,
0.0048912782,
-0.1003550664,
0.0161063429,
0.0008378328,
0.0063395468,
-0.0041963002,
-0.0116890445,
-0.004211742,
0.0141133619,
0.0667487681,
-0.0421351753,
-0.0108398395,
-0.0244937818,
0.0973805562,
0.0442300849,
-0.055062782,
0.041317977,
-0.0315644145,
0.0105813714,
0.0677776411,
-0.0097571239,
0.0001072976,
-0.0503503382,
-0.004537594,
-0.0107808281,
-0.0250092223,
-0.0409956165,
-0.0103763817,
0.0224586558,
-0.0295875538,
-0.0448385179,
0.0879680514,
0.0055082245,
-0.0608744621,
-0.0100945113,
-0.0114656072,
0.0400557257,
0.0092020342,
-0.0112010362,
-0.0569294058,
-0.0267305449,
-0.013888442,
0.0258410815,
0.0250069574,
-0.0233627353,
-0.0072369445,
-0.0829866007,
0.0027030949,
0.0162912402,
-0.0156864058,
-0.016363902,
-0.0280517284,
0.0054378659,
0.0074002147,
0.0136246663,
0.0223924872,
-0.0568157397,
0.0118734436,
-0.0131335966,
-0.0234971941,
-0.0311612822,
-0.016848363,
-0.0211915988,
0.0060104174,
0.0242298357,
0.0238403901,
0.0055365544,
-0.0285796821,
0.0211448986,
-0.0583664998,
0.0005226165,
0.0064917319,
0.1053639948,
-0.0309186839,
0.0025819808,
-0.0044523585,
0.0278014801,
-0.0204637442,
0.0027229108,
-0.0195003692,
0.0252750441,
0.0039709299,
-0.0043043918,
-0.0355069265,
-0.0211532917,
-0.0104901493,
0.0789640918,
0.0341371335,
-0.0090582715,
-0.0603254549,
-0.012866009,
0.0092490464,
-0.0199649129,
-0.0090528205,
-0.0092885913,
0.0037242202,
0.0214030091,
-0.0508748665,
-0.0691825673,
-0.0473887883,
0.027267253,
-0.0432864018,
-0.0050806915,
-0.0529586747,
-0.0206330363,
-0.0625818223,
0.0016198568,
-0.0347397588,
-0.0021155686,
-0.0281699039,
0.0355381817,
0.0268129036,
-0.0158508476,
-0.0091183195,
-0.0133634508,
-0.0776877925,
-0.0688436404,
-0.0112717692,
0.0226646252,
0.0041264393,
0.0865804181,
-0.0040483889,
-0.0121341124,
0.0896020457,
0.0372417755,
-0.0519100837,
0.0358291604,
0.0525327995,
-0.0279102121,
0.0124717597,
0.0573929921,
-0.033232756,
0.0105924774,
0.0514608175,
0.0153463176,
-0.0057577658,
-0.0312457103,
0.0035619235,
0.0044239121,
0.0638165548,
0.009240347,
0.0585795492,
0.0000057904,
0.0258104745,
-0.0408035442,
0.0007919319,
-0.0243108775,
0.0177821014,
0.0170604978,
0.0347260237,
-0.0247015078,
0.0678556636,
-0.0040531321,
0.0369461589,
-0.0208157916,
0.019792879,
0.0212980602,
0.0030069044,
-0.0153919794,
0.0274550579,
-0.0263616107,
0.0056994813,
-0.0405130647,
0.0454455018,
-0.0142022846,
0.0103514288,
0.0505968072,
0.007560187,
-0.055669792,
0.0450989045,
-0.0773319155,
0.0260264836,
-0.0400359817,
-0.0252458081,
0.0156376082,
-0.0611849166,
0.0125783533,
-0.032298103,
-0.0134237194,
-0.023642499,
-0.007651092,
0.0016436559,
0.0090937968,
-0.0029174949,
0.0272711199,
-0.0213823114,
0.0357475765,
0.0971659943,
-0.0085819196,
0.0270733777,
0.0254721213,
-0.0189181697,
-0.0365536921,
-0.0131703038,
0.0148246642,
0.0298846457,
0.0003461763,
-0.0188710261,
-0.020785816,
-0.0669262707,
0.040634241,
0.0235958695,
0.0170419589,
0.0272369813,
0.0316013098,
0.0748000816,
0.0101472437,
0.0169173516,
-0.0298064034,
-0.0034879416,
0.0157049932,
-0.0070196604,
-0.0015753114,
-5.789482329e-33,
0.0107309083,
0.0292073358,
-0.0205348358,
0.0101891011,
0.0102543198,
0.0335673094,
-0.0196543243,
-0.0164579563,
0.0001189654,
0.036150977,
-0.0193610545,
0.0244919211,
-0.0151549326,
0.0491199791,
-0.0184773132,
-0.0082238996,
0.0434482247,
-0.0076634628,
-0.0283974186,
0.0092456872,
0.0534161627,
0.0216456018,
0.0339020751,
-0.0612121448,
0.0178944115,
0.0033127626,
-0.0024079091,
0.0247094855,
0.0465107895,
0.0514760017,
0.0009713762,
0.0179805141,
0.0443345532,
-0.0384861901,
-0.0318028219,
0.017852135,
-0.1162918508,
-0.0284145419,
-0.002591827,
-0.0205752384,
-0.0578404292,
-0.0396031588,
0.0213872511,
-0.022359971,
0.0070998869,
-0.07032305,
0.038511999,
-0.0201305747,
0.0005802536,
-0.0037584736,
-0.0391971171,
0.0401798338,
-0.0008486804,
0.0171843134,
0.0386070609,
0.00970772,
0.0152246365,
0.06004446,
-0.0241827648,
0.0060701915,
-0.0098729283,
0.0531143323,
-0.0061045922,
-0.0028003834,
0.0019424603,
0.0503361896,
0.0210740734,
-0.0190130565,
0.0240048431,
-0.0302376989,
0.0195061564,
-0.0208224747,
0.0463925414,
0.0739564374,
0.0381056257,
-0.0128350472,
-0.0782923251,
0.0207283404,
-0.0214137863,
0.0144646438,
0.0111424662,
0.0281623118,
-0.0596753098,
-0.0152790863,
-0.0106747486,
-0.0367272161,
-0.0073167323,
-0.0321749002,
0.0078709805,
0.0240194574,
0.0259269606,
0.0122569241,
0.0243784208,
-0.0073217512,
-0.0188976377,
0.0389397293,
-0.0291915573,
0.003825132,
0.014402586,
-0.0052845445,
-0.0286757089,
-0.0115194414,
0.0069607492,
0.0061932234,
-0.0178172756,
0.0090597095,
0.0846893713,
0.0035738898,
-0.0816363692,
-0.0163528807,
0.0098488759,
-0.0320599861,
0.0135580385,
-0.0062790713,
0.0290595368,
0.0035830371,
-0.0058908653,
0.0863334313,
0.029110048,
0.0184503663,
-0.0283468403,
-0.0229793545,
-0.0168864559,
0.0409998782,
-0.0148136988,
-0.0311744455,
-0.033205878,
0.0595629923,
0.0387054384,
-0.070771046,
0.0191934872,
-0.0090214442,
2.491e-7,
0.0581675395,
0.0101543125,
0.0680246055,
-0.0143104428,
0.027316276,
0.0379759632,
0.0104498649,
0.0782473311,
-0.0535356738,
0.0129627967,
0.0085648531,
0.0138986688,
0.0319238938,
0.0112299584,
-0.0722929165,
0.0701975822,
-0.0764892548,
-0.002925524,
-0.0344051719,
-0.0108956601,
0.0564174913,
0.1036149338,
0.0170115195,
0.0048645847,
-0.0140950661,
-0.0634031296,
0.0741863772,
-0.034483362,
-0.0122561064,
-0.0109270075,
0.0288211145,
-0.0168536454,
-0.0014007421,
0.0032817894,
-0.0105535509,
0.0706130415,
0.0097704129,
0.0235041529,
0.0249066409,
-0.0362150595,
0.0085955262,
-0.0407590121,
-0.0306540728,
-0.0287679136,
0.0733059123,
-0.0465626828,
-0.0190651268,
-0.028159691,
-0.0604447238,
0.0026936803,
0.0292154271,
0.0076874648,
-0.0164577384,
0.017019378,
0.0159960631,
0.0320737213,
0.0151375541,
-0.0938891619,
-0.0004966416,
0.0331938416,
-0.0077910558,
-0.0049327221,
-0.0323133357,
0.0303287823,
0.0253824051,
-0.0700387135,
0.0210699439,
2.257934089e-34,
0.0486394167,
0.0124491062,
-0.0220994409,
-0.0326867849,
0.013810467,
-0.0581655838,
-0.0210768078,
-0.0122531755,
0.0323459134,
-0.0931731388,
-0.0176877044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.16183v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.16183v2 | BLP-2023 Task 2: Sentiment Analysis | 2023-10-24T21:00:41 | 2024-02-22T02:32:06 | Md. Arid Hasan, Firoj Alam, Anika Anjum, Shudipta Das, Afiyat Anjum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | We present an overview of the BLP Sentiment Shared Task, organized as part of
the inaugural BLP 2023 workshop, co-located with EMNLP 2023. The task is
defined as the detection of sentiment in a given piece of social media text.
This task attracted interest from 71 participants, among whom 29 and 30 teams
submitted systems during the development and evaluation phases, respectively.
In total, participants submitted 597 runs. However, a total of 15 teams
submitted system description papers. The range of approaches in the submitted
systems spans from classical machine learning models, fine-tuning pre-trained
models, to leveraging Large Language Model (LLMs) in zero- and few-shot
settings. In this paper, we provide a detailed account of the task setup,
including dataset development and evaluation setup. Additionally, we provide a
brief overview of the systems submitted by the participants. All datasets and
evaluation scripts from the shared task have been made publicly available for
the research community, to foster further research in this domain. | [
0.020654982,
0.0928381234,
0.0189235732,
0.0654704049,
-0.0390011407,
0.0285074227,
-0.0134089421,
0.0057947845,
-0.0024596802,
-0.0692350343,
-0.0329286046,
-0.0181661304,
-0.0189489182,
0.0356527045,
-0.0266141631,
-0.0325554423,
0.0109760379,
0.05398174,
0.0434470922,
-0.0011854942,
0.0365311205,
0.0386303514,
-0.0072474233,
0.0128509644,
-0.022591101,
-0.0013207744,
0.0343836509,
0.0221783593,
0.0178283826,
-0.0361447185,
0.0328540243,
0.04662361,
0.013902667,
0.0316391997,
0.0000018062,
-0.0361207277,
0.0187066961,
-0.0075805141,
-0.0035736433,
-0.0144398101,
0.0743426755,
-0.0380511843,
0.0117247542,
0.0211646352,
-0.0438132286,
-0.0379185267,
0.0460275039,
0.050011795,
0.0457973704,
0.0795508251,
-0.0369149931,
-0.019432798,
-0.0528996587,
-0.0065146517,
0.000515061,
-0.0345280319,
0.0237239581,
-0.0223061852,
0.004085796,
0.0079536885,
0.0166204739,
-0.0028090014,
-0.0008304093,
0.00335999,
0.005927599,
-0.0068864911,
-0.0348501317,
-0.0198298544,
-0.0042010681,
0.0691843629,
0.0183739457,
-0.0318219364,
0.0012064076,
-0.0213074144,
-0.0301439445,
-0.0667484105,
-0.0079439851,
0.0091718463,
0.0243813451,
0.0529563129,
0.0045346986,
0.0301140994,
0.0464775003,
0.0724281743,
0.0130105391,
0.0676801503,
-0.008227841,
-0.0244810935,
-0.0052879732,
0.0795677826,
0.0141733326,
0.0200450476,
0.0128727658,
0.0124081485,
0.0049891477,
0.0257597137,
-0.0118107116,
-0.020093523,
0.0327433795,
-0.0639188588,
0.0405883752,
-0.0305825565,
-0.0031628739,
0.0721805319,
-0.0074240318,
-0.0212283414,
0.015841905,
-0.0355955474,
0.0009963694,
0.0023595172,
-0.0342657231,
0.0511355996,
-0.0167537462,
0.0221636295,
-0.0148345288,
-0.0115100378,
-0.0509865098,
0.0044542965,
-0.0006683847,
0.0297375023,
0.0096187778,
-0.0167274531,
0.0150893973,
-0.0152494721,
0.0199707616,
0.0609940067,
-0.0252113864,
0.0236664806,
-0.0536703952,
-0.0448288023,
-0.0088341339,
0.0335307792,
0.0229538623,
-0.0253038369,
0.022590125,
0.0380613208,
0.0531932302,
-0.0742433965,
-0.0408513881,
0.0037784551,
-0.0167198367,
-0.0864432976,
-0.0327921472,
-0.0729104355,
0.0399855971,
0.0049510929,
0.0047682994,
0.0022822483,
0.0110304039,
0.0130936038,
-0.0368488729,
0.0602890141,
-0.0452639461,
0.0068963845,
0.0033665285,
0.0151627278,
0.027476266,
0.0863567218,
-0.0042808303,
0.0610754825,
0.0579549484,
0.0005885782,
0.0169809312,
0.0378422253,
-0.0018115266,
-0.000121865,
-0.0168980844,
-0.0077840011,
-0.0383855999,
0.0084735481,
-0.0156832542,
0.020504307,
0.0042264415,
-0.0019539881,
0.0551770255,
0.0302552506,
-0.0050273468,
0.02591254,
0.0016523671,
0.0111208661,
0.0309160817,
-0.0774140805,
-0.0250935592,
-0.0070361849,
-0.0263161696,
-0.0252177361,
0.0009132835,
0.0194715522,
-0.0329211466,
-0.0360493399,
-0.0337800682,
-0.0309340768,
0.0160438642,
0.0033909602,
0.0671020001,
-0.013639247,
-0.0610688478,
-0.0036448,
0.0431981646,
-0.0590365641,
0.0094693461,
-0.0212926529,
0.0524373837,
0.0742604584,
0.0129015697,
-0.0236310363,
-0.0087047266,
-0.0253591835,
0.0186580177,
0.0547049902,
0.0097776083,
0.0109741595,
0.0195619836,
-0.0378978513,
0.0090314206,
-0.0014652374,
0.0129897268,
-0.0238945857,
0.0180446897,
0.0393792465,
0.0158340447,
0.0182956867,
-0.0195375681,
0.0010198074,
0.0278445035,
-0.017734142,
0.0171378106,
0.0128241908,
0.0446212068,
0.0379492305,
-0.0307658166,
-0.0327098854,
0.0317829028,
-0.0185432732,
-0.0162931252,
0.0012356123,
0.0071425294,
-0.062136557,
0.0252214931,
-0.0014498413,
-0.0187320933,
0.0496685691,
-0.0679619908,
0.000997467,
0.0307770465,
0.0105558643,
0.0171063822,
-0.0149159161,
-0.0161533616,
-0.0482377037,
0.0266215578,
-0.0154327024,
0.0218354315,
0.0221310463,
-0.0362417512,
-0.0357386991,
-0.0327002406,
0.0183751453,
0.0088364184,
-0.0731638372,
0.0315897055,
0.0264724772,
0.0243365932,
0.0431455411,
0.0201627389,
-0.0525710694,
-0.0251944494,
-0.1058513671,
-0.0218766835,
-0.0239527207,
0.0307787154,
0.0212957803,
-0.0014946451,
-0.0298949257,
0.0025706077,
-0.0171219409,
0.0223971885,
0.0296526402,
0.0061534913,
0.0433433764,
-0.0018377092,
0.0411629938,
-0.0500249863,
-0.0061532483,
0.0001086768,
0.0025232411,
0.0260953736,
-0.0300510377,
-0.0202283859,
0.054427959,
-0.0191362202,
-0.0054093767,
0.0170159508,
-0.0419622771,
-0.0275384709,
-0.0346312225,
-0.0160386749,
0.0526316874,
-0.0101631926,
0.0470540226,
-0.0035670791,
0.0156370569,
-0.0125154657,
0.0170630924,
-0.0460566357,
0.0148767382,
-0.0184248947,
0.0009121217,
-0.0135571025,
0.0664477795,
-0.0343138352,
0.0010029852,
-0.0355859436,
0.0054977201,
-0.0361006558,
0.0007880301,
-0.002235855,
0.0093261404,
0.0216512308,
-0.0163619723,
-0.0171407275,
-0.0341080688,
0.0407472998,
-0.0037235038,
-0.002879099,
-0.065391548,
-0.0416726135,
-0.057864733,
0.0423923135,
-0.0178408735,
-0.0023667242,
-0.0324864872,
0.0455270037,
0.0107018556,
-0.0475322455,
-0.0266120061,
-0.0219666176,
0.0230753236,
0.0114610707,
0.0001180298,
0.0118360715,
-0.0414092205,
0.0069711306,
-0.0613935404,
-0.0811966807,
-0.01970925,
-0.0020970639,
-0.0308813881,
-0.0113298064,
-0.0319991559,
-0.0513428152,
-0.0308729112,
-0.0068618148,
-0.0047137463,
0.0113305822,
0.0127675068,
0.0783298537,
-0.051345855,
0.0381972045,
0.0094217379,
-0.002421655,
0.06164404,
0.0244158506,
0.0298973583,
-0.0308737252,
-0.0303107742,
0.0344277322,
-0.0061658192,
0.0276743025,
-0.0493689477,
0.0524517745,
-0.0583009422,
0.0160137098,
0.1491406113,
0.003242691,
-0.0670065731,
-0.0160638075,
0.0180881899,
0.0034536459,
0.0330814347,
-0.0003019616,
-0.039613232,
-0.0473582558,
-0.0484164134,
0.007881579,
0.0034302133,
-0.0265181661,
0.0101741403,
-0.1073694676,
0.0126870265,
0.0007670695,
0.0124575337,
-0.0363367088,
-0.0590101555,
0.0012022896,
-0.0448167175,
0.0007100519,
-0.0768313333,
0.0020846077,
0.0004412476,
-0.0251106117,
-0.0351291746,
-0.038722638,
0.0677473769,
-0.0225967225,
0.0363971591,
0.0454615988,
0.0522696264,
-0.0168268215,
-0.0087164165,
0.0268513951,
-0.0330750011,
-0.0287336111,
-0.0377190635,
0.0470383838,
-0.0488228649,
-0.0395882986,
-0.0167069789,
0.0048134606,
-0.0693952441,
0.015851222,
0.0033952447,
0.0553305186,
-0.0039609163,
-0.0569668598,
-0.0224002488,
0.0553228594,
0.0496589467,
0.063345708,
0.011928062,
-0.0725155175,
-0.0149811022,
0.0228447393,
-0.018331537,
-0.0723960921,
-0.0160087887,
-0.0396036245,
0.0008230613,
0.0186005142,
-0.0445519239,
-0.0419239886,
0.0490468629,
0.0360273607,
-0.0423754901,
-0.0193731226,
-0.0069544581,
0.0027714949,
-0.0323012732,
0.0471695028,
-0.0188510902,
0.0361768603,
-0.0367655233,
-0.034945406,
0.0612445064,
0.0107129114,
-0.0081357341,
-0.0033177708,
-0.1196873933,
-0.0353006534,
-0.0078578833,
0.0630654395,
0.0098383892,
-0.0060456209,
-0.0190345328,
-0.0496685617,
0.0489932261,
0.0207309648,
-0.0195528995,
0.0104529057,
0.0436093844,
0.0384585299,
0.0059798956,
0.0402007364,
-0.0286461283,
0.0220743492,
0.0438465327,
-0.0198787674,
-0.0132565573,
-0.0054484201,
-0.0273990333,
-0.0050990325,
0.071216844,
0.0118949274,
-0.036763493,
-0.0170651693,
-0.032771524,
-0.0109645873,
-0.031805329,
-0.0557441637,
-0.0317721963,
0.0354116708,
0.017334599,
-0.0814952254,
0.0039305869,
-0.0173947234,
0.0225528665,
-0.0200084932,
0.0843241215,
0.039290674,
-0.0001884867,
0.025955176,
0.0184371471,
-0.0088697448,
0.025916677,
-0.0244450755,
-0.0297497194,
-0.0005163173,
0.0316150151,
-0.0084955841,
0.0039489144,
-0.0224203058,
0.0383328982,
0.005379003,
0.0085336706,
-0.0026475035,
0.0290446673,
0.0455963239,
-0.0377859958,
0.0677316487,
-0.0379327722,
0.0085298112,
-0.0261829551,
0.0301767681,
-0.060451474,
-0.020921709,
0.0065143886,
0.001829594,
-0.0342482999,
0.0176099129,
0.0567319244,
-0.0335437693,
0.0429526754,
0.0875418633,
0.0164883379,
-0.0215149354,
0.0002545678,
0.0436793752,
0.01267312,
0.0074481284,
0.067470938,
-0.0411859453,
-0.0589559674,
0.0470199324,
-0.0837662667,
0.0002649201,
0.026119763,
-0.0068812589,
0.0642630905,
0.0115520898,
0.0667200089,
-0.0645396933,
-0.0169312172,
0.0026312738,
-0.0332080536,
-0.0171032213,
-6.713066036e-33,
0.0199831594,
-0.0160024855,
-0.0391320437,
0.0174681488,
-0.0210567024,
0.0179877672,
-0.006779294,
0.0095466012,
-0.0280054361,
0.0426061787,
-0.0023567926,
0.0395008586,
-0.0072302981,
0.0624270141,
0.0233170837,
-0.0300576705,
0.0236503202,
-0.0127638169,
-0.0120897526,
0.023198504,
0.0161484294,
0.0247396398,
0.056859903,
-0.0857389569,
-0.0044929483,
-0.0251940154,
-0.0314035416,
0.0432755165,
0.0436978042,
0.0491305478,
-0.0222140849,
0.0833968148,
0.0475541316,
-0.0193892773,
0.0036121504,
0.0351371728,
-0.0083068768,
-0.0009306617,
-0.003246058,
0.0219099075,
-0.0159670822,
-0.022619104,
0.0039161062,
-0.013053502,
-0.0537113473,
-0.0011605759,
0.021673521,
-0.0109378612,
0.0244543571,
-0.0341350771,
-0.0590374134,
0.0261767115,
-0.003844437,
-0.0195717551,
0.0246364307,
0.0385548845,
0.0085315695,
0.0677689835,
-0.0625492856,
0.0341303721,
-0.034889698,
0.0014405766,
0.0046358905,
-0.0362051427,
0.0174347013,
0.0439293236,
-0.0033952428,
0.029370511,
-0.0203708131,
0.0214770921,
0.0004177122,
0.0261140261,
0.0260164998,
0.0592151582,
0.0285828095,
-0.0212360807,
-0.0465440489,
-0.0200256277,
0.0583853684,
0.0338775404,
0.0447162613,
-0.0048192968,
-0.0282146633,
-0.0096621923,
0.0185514148,
-0.0353759751,
-0.0341842808,
-0.0260216258,
-0.0111449109,
0.0075108269,
-0.0052717626,
0.0085744783,
0.0128729362,
-0.0830142274,
-0.0250822604,
0.0641675368,
-0.0134398686,
0.017756762,
0.0079435324,
0.0240548681,
-0.0861417502,
-0.0171278417,
-0.0091997487,
0.0346531756,
0.0004182665,
-0.0158290192,
0.0408175513,
0.049665153,
-0.0609559789,
-0.0101497555,
-0.0354766324,
0.0287345201,
-0.0144791882,
0.0700478107,
-0.0196044128,
-0.002792479,
-0.0110693779,
0.0753379762,
0.0060074562,
0.0310667418,
0.0374004059,
-0.0076286881,
-0.0085911509,
-0.0053435233,
-0.0091029117,
-0.0334097967,
-0.0057791201,
-0.0425267816,
-0.0001134533,
-0.0372200757,
0.0115052843,
-0.0563865788,
2.6e-7,
0.0207579341,
0.0748774707,
-0.0366374813,
-0.0224411134,
0.0309191346,
0.0450473167,
-0.0189525113,
0.0207507107,
-0.0300069023,
0.0312562212,
0.0298611894,
0.0461031161,
0.055683732,
-0.0093431463,
-0.1024107561,
0.0027116502,
-0.048312258,
-0.0164247919,
-0.0388300791,
0.0064801988,
0.0603733882,
0.1199739724,
0.05836384,
-0.0178314,
-0.0172909219,
-0.033329878,
0.0351989456,
-0.0532640517,
-0.0221898463,
0.0154015981,
-0.0356071144,
0.0023750388,
-0.0150403026,
-0.0482222326,
0.0028277168,
0.0175768677,
0.0067858393,
0.0822686777,
0.0138842221,
-0.037108019,
0.0190529246,
0.0369491987,
0.0037052142,
-0.0133551639,
0.0512914434,
-0.0447648205,
-0.0715932697,
-0.0834306851,
0.0193380099,
-0.0066215796,
0.0541910455,
-0.0230944213,
-0.0237701815,
0.0166238844,
0.0264007244,
-0.0549322367,
-0.083705768,
-0.0947798789,
0.027405953,
0.0258500595,
-0.0313244388,
-0.0117869247,
0.003255825,
-0.0129804211,
0.0307492651,
-0.0431965441,
0.0323457047,
2.306205122e-34,
0.0572399944,
-0.0527484119,
-0.01189774,
0.0310819671,
0.0102696195,
0.0249672253,
-0.0681102276,
-0.0246725958,
0.0309520941,
-0.0577820837,
0.0676980987
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.