id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15425v1 | The Mason-Alberta Phonetic Segmenter: A forced alignment system based on deep neural networks and interpolation | 2023-10-24T00:43:54 | 2023-10-24T00:43:54 | Matthew C. Kelley, Scott James Perry, Benjamin V. Tucker | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Forced alignment systems automatically determine boundaries between segments
in speech data, given an orthographic transcription. These tools are
commonplace in phonetics to facilitate the use of speech data that would be
infeasible to manually transcribe and segment. In the present paper, we
describe a new neural network-based forced alignment system, the Mason-Alberta
Phonetic Segmenter (MAPS). The MAPS aligner serves as a testbed for two
possible improvements we pursue for forced alignment systems. The first is
treating the acoustic model in a forced aligner as a tagging task, rather than
a classification task, motivated by the common understanding that segments in
speech are not truly discrete and commonly overlap. The second is an
interpolation technique to allow boundaries more precise than the common 10 ms
limit in modern forced alignment systems. We compare configurations of our
system to a state-of-the-art system, the Montreal Forced Aligner. The tagging
approach did not generally yield improved results over the Montreal Forced
Aligner. However, a system with the interpolation technique had a 27.92%
increase relative to the Montreal Forced Aligner in the amount of boundaries
within 10 ms of the target on the test set. We also reflect on the task and
training process for acoustic modeling in forced alignment, highlighting how
the output targets for these models do not match phoneticians' conception of
similarity between phones and that reconciliation of this tension may require
rethinking the task and output targets or how speech itself should be
segmented. | [
-0.042958349,
0.0645635873,
0.0258383229,
-0.021790985,
-0.0627551749,
-0.0257618874,
0.0495912619,
-0.0482051857,
-0.0223795641,
0.053410653,
-0.0190674458,
-0.0325012542,
0.0745544881,
-0.0400768854,
0.0158702619,
-0.0545669682,
-0.0041922582,
-0.033217717,
0.0441884547,
0.001896149,
0.0498042256,
0.0167573374,
-0.0645582825,
0.0327641182,
-0.0756329671,
-0.020864239,
-0.0145775843,
0.0177535657,
0.0252536908,
0.0035381843,
0.0038301565,
0.0016048587,
-0.0196903348,
0.0595192723,
0.0000015718,
-0.0353617445,
-0.0004184156,
0.0172117129,
-0.053872034,
0.0000999088,
-0.0429491512,
0.0062841438,
-0.0357731096,
0.0285036471,
-0.0067973393,
-0.0208301023,
0.0872364044,
-0.0161417294,
0.0203066524,
0.0340777375,
-0.0259929504,
-0.0716473833,
0.030766312,
-0.0054011624,
-0.0508941114,
-0.0263593197,
0.0169404373,
0.0019014741,
-0.0016678704,
-0.0973006561,
-0.007551719,
0.0631272197,
-0.0134682506,
-0.0212998521,
0.0052711321,
0.0016457073,
-0.0470715053,
-0.0476745665,
-0.0080164755,
0.0507856756,
-0.0389083624,
-0.0105624935,
0.0199124813,
0.0213939678,
-0.0110147307,
-0.0284232944,
-0.0067003905,
-0.0080528352,
-0.0058589703,
-0.0079497881,
-0.0074756304,
0.0265551619,
0.0329103582,
-0.0488446876,
-0.0735545382,
0.0148200225,
0.0343693495,
-0.0523964837,
-0.0186946932,
-0.0030170099,
0.0169752724,
0.0145243509,
0.0731663778,
0.0272560082,
-0.0104035009,
0.0057776645,
-0.0240902547,
-0.0485330783,
-0.0106654018,
0.0003895315,
-0.0192962587,
0.0340909325,
-0.0421603918,
0.0051969648,
-0.0145922014,
0.0391450562,
-0.0320740268,
0.0344443358,
-0.0177384149,
-0.017281007,
-0.0128517812,
-0.0026141028,
-0.0284251478,
-0.039357055,
0.0236903932,
0.0186307225,
-0.0600965545,
-0.0087575493,
-0.0325785391,
0.0418877192,
0.0358105674,
0.0189031884,
-0.034310393,
-0.0128305582,
0.0248780586,
0.0525974557,
-0.0336279124,
0.0423100516,
-0.011065837,
-0.0530220345,
0.018017441,
0.0447095446,
0.0375836566,
0.0093798293,
0.0140381409,
0.0253246296,
-0.03852598,
0.0230455492,
-0.0341813676,
0.0028845528,
-0.0605754778,
-0.0417162441,
-0.0315193348,
-0.071023196,
0.058934249,
-0.0363364816,
-0.0110481996,
-0.0392309912,
-0.0476849638,
-0.0442551635,
0.0188606884,
0.0721705332,
-0.0042982339,
0.0629927665,
0.0657441318,
-0.0339686014,
0.0410335176,
0.0155105693,
0.0711502433,
-0.047900632,
0.0116015989,
-0.0525634326,
-0.0270447452,
0.0689106658,
-0.0037800919,
-0.0329499356,
-0.0554736182,
-0.060416989,
0.0227726996,
0.0845073685,
0.0542435944,
0.0476579256,
0.0077433153,
-0.0211346615,
0.0437635854,
0.0773245469,
0.0795982406,
0.0458218902,
0.0167802852,
-0.005934523,
-0.0111695174,
0.0282654595,
-0.0253211558,
-0.0339954942,
0.031593807,
0.0584005862,
0.030442981,
0.0494175106,
-0.0238123834,
-0.0076423753,
-0.0073009138,
-0.0250094607,
-0.0001351086,
0.0075545935,
0.0404615961,
-0.0238030031,
-0.017731335,
0.0234208703,
-0.0391225442,
-0.0212275404,
0.0004039191,
-0.0130577665,
0.0063962275,
0.0591449365,
0.0020345724,
-0.0463401638,
-0.0450030603,
-0.0093019633,
-0.0363376103,
0.0419440418,
0.0206401274,
-0.0005393387,
0.0020712239,
-0.0885641798,
-0.0022615676,
0.0994384587,
-0.0017752232,
0.017476663,
0.0017511679,
0.0256806109,
-0.003734567,
-0.0074597439,
0.0284249205,
0.0161452442,
-0.0139249219,
-0.0042657498,
-0.0550602973,
0.0528449677,
0.0233971998,
0.0443489142,
-0.0070295297,
-0.002052045,
0.0420900509,
-0.017542718,
0.0785914063,
0.0178509932,
-0.0246217307,
0.012710439,
0.0802113861,
-0.0538564548,
-0.0319891758,
0.0146983135,
0.0281990282,
-0.079356119,
0.0076254224,
-0.0085978555,
0.0363473929,
-0.0357062705,
0.0545427613,
0.0132310502,
-0.0188003443,
-0.0197879858,
-0.0217398107,
0.0332798995,
0.0027460349,
0.0320171602,
-0.0292578861,
-0.035579145,
-0.0368196592,
0.0096197054,
0.028428413,
-0.0338288061,
0.0063415263,
-0.0433011875,
-0.0433332473,
-0.0077301199,
-0.0245031137,
-0.061311949,
0.0041619898,
-0.0175106172,
0.0266756471,
0.0011687827,
0.0007896964,
-0.0065691816,
-0.0109801851,
-0.0433587208,
-0.0321283266,
0.0080826394,
-0.0305162948,
-0.0051623075,
-0.0101374434,
-0.069041431,
-0.0531137213,
-0.0021270788,
-0.033700753,
-0.0103951143,
-0.0227558427,
-0.0446138419,
-0.0525323562,
-0.0444377549,
-0.0097929919,
0.0039003184,
0.0328711383,
-0.0316043869,
0.0016225316,
-0.0116848927,
0.0542983077,
0.0079798046,
-0.0225892253,
-0.0453231744,
-0.002356441,
-0.0171133149,
-0.0370952375,
-0.0044091106,
-0.00486991,
0.0572992302,
-0.0318741016,
-0.0057320548,
-0.0433236882,
0.0659549162,
0.0152605427,
0.0416869596,
-0.0319093801,
-0.0199456699,
0.0218201783,
-0.0150723942,
0.0184201989,
-0.0279507022,
-0.0419138968,
-0.0214425195,
-0.0521148182,
-0.0431679823,
0.0302150417,
-0.0793049335,
-0.0552748851,
-0.0347117893,
-0.0547334924,
-0.0029743752,
0.0087792175,
-0.0091302767,
-0.0115169017,
0.0203870423,
-0.053902518,
-0.0320681483,
0.0329884179,
-0.0168929771,
-0.0367788449,
0.0493755713,
-0.0258514639,
0.0029108913,
-0.008399616,
-0.000837658,
-0.02710885,
-0.0036859128,
-0.0338403322,
0.0467064641,
0.0339877754,
-0.0433921181,
0.0210881401,
0.06219621,
0.0015177361,
0.0536244586,
0.0145677328,
0.0431669056,
-0.0155395567,
0.0749226958,
0.014630246,
0.0390836149,
-0.0252768658,
0.01973233,
0.0327964239,
-0.0290280078,
0.0542250201,
0.0577868894,
-0.0698895305,
-0.0523655489,
0.0110181887,
-0.0386274792,
0.0178537909,
-0.0090019898,
0.019121442,
-0.0198776629,
0.0242956653,
0.0905155241,
0.0133442068,
0.0219151601,
-0.0126401987,
0.0196468197,
0.0576955341,
-0.0096864579,
-0.0073840455,
-0.0210587829,
-0.0072672614,
0.0520747602,
0.0199698713,
0.040596284,
0.0365801342,
0.016385654,
-0.0561185218,
-0.0024929938,
0.026272567,
-0.0338310264,
-0.000016362,
-0.003234247,
-0.0168070979,
-0.0284783132,
-0.0054780953,
0.0250793714,
0.0067279604,
-0.0557888858,
0.0568680353,
-0.0770729482,
0.017632477,
-0.0306452792,
-0.0933861881,
0.0502577089,
0.0466150269,
0.0259503275,
-0.015802443,
-0.0328487456,
0.0645799413,
0.0095121991,
-0.0007944755,
0.044880718,
-0.006114291,
0.0097709587,
-0.0205082595,
-0.0041945181,
0.0200501774,
0.0212006774,
0.0459707938,
0.005622624,
0.071122624,
0.0046508666,
0.0566479303,
0.0036867035,
0.0547209866,
-0.0305729322,
0.0357244648,
0.0250922162,
-0.0231775604,
-0.0190263875,
0.0146878744,
0.0701559931,
-0.0542493239,
0.0214599986,
0.0668983981,
-0.0299410317,
-0.0539893471,
-0.0365404077,
0.0050452566,
-0.0055151721,
0.0527554452,
0.0732519999,
-0.0508714654,
0.0249170437,
0.0160205215,
-0.0145558482,
0.0129968859,
-0.0071670744,
0.0370690748,
-0.0527503304,
0.0072263074,
0.0346556194,
-0.0287422389,
0.0359844752,
0.0230081733,
-0.0296648312,
-0.068393074,
0.0604200661,
-0.041940745,
0.0271773487,
0.0803183392,
-0.0644716844,
-0.0139520457,
0.0272417869,
-0.0032459856,
-0.0002276889,
0.0032047187,
0.0178489406,
-0.0298412498,
-0.0049710218,
-0.0015144496,
-0.029336568,
0.0079392344,
-0.0625508428,
0.0074016065,
-0.0673199296,
-0.0556012429,
0.0080802543,
-0.0102251917,
0.0772143304,
0.0013781423,
0.0271077957,
-0.0538744852,
0.0206326228,
0.052913174,
0.0552708693,
0.0090329079,
-0.0518854707,
0.0420609415,
0.0591960587,
-0.0019086045,
-0.0151533345,
0.012853994,
-0.0135107171,
-0.0121908011,
0.0357789546,
-0.0046441369,
0.0320831798,
-0.0191872045,
0.0074398862,
-0.010107873,
0.0896339118,
-0.0301056877,
0.0481050536,
-0.0012399432,
0.0017803074,
0.0027058518,
0.0252308585,
-0.0159230195,
0.0301820114,
0.0145819522,
0.0078128939,
-0.0108903237,
-0.0062798713,
0.0671512634,
-0.0092153931,
0.0021308726,
0.028313268,
0.0156523064,
-0.0116302008,
-0.0133174388,
-0.0494415015,
0.0258105434,
-0.0013435655,
0.0156597998,
-0.0358560607,
-0.0081365304,
-0.0152808977,
-0.0119970692,
0.0174425021,
-0.0340736508,
0.0012485279,
-0.0164769776,
-0.0391394235,
-0.0097525017,
-0.0165820085,
-0.0645036623,
-0.0804988518,
0.0009823329,
-0.0339106172,
0.0405331291,
0.023707334,
0.025601374,
-0.0022757212,
0.008391615,
-0.0100713316,
-0.0544455275,
0.021579409,
0.0522052795,
-0.0542324297,
-0.0038861078,
-0.0334116369,
0.0138911167,
-5.45921213e-33,
-0.0057044723,
-0.0069277487,
0.0276812688,
-0.0196318775,
-0.0761296675,
-0.0044583185,
0.0077293771,
0.001744946,
-0.0022930801,
-0.0039025787,
0.0091696298,
-0.0275555123,
0.027565537,
-0.010856811,
-0.0015441761,
-0.0365673751,
0.0849488825,
-0.0148440469,
0.0245021619,
-0.065899469,
0.0206123292,
0.0446023643,
0.0100678205,
-0.0144134732,
-0.0329981372,
0.0140674505,
-0.0053441478,
-0.0073087974,
0.0094026458,
0.028160153,
0.0226608012,
-0.0004419711,
-0.0137216542,
-0.0171044134,
0.0183773451,
0.0618081056,
-0.1374498159,
0.0162081122,
0.0058567775,
0.0860078633,
0.0327623934,
-0.0018736504,
0.0812294558,
-0.0067051132,
0.0024704051,
-0.0191794075,
0.0489845462,
-0.0421135053,
0.0299976077,
-0.0228189137,
-0.0217001624,
0.0318992585,
-0.0147612859,
-0.0390755162,
0.0773876458,
0.0535168722,
0.0103830472,
-0.0274096597,
-0.0831013247,
0.0286969692,
0.0253089368,
0.0279542375,
0.0722042248,
0.0517936721,
-0.0257280935,
0.0136314714,
0.0804138929,
-0.0751723871,
0.0234378818,
-0.0046887025,
0.0245974921,
0.0072618756,
0.0386885442,
-0.0431828909,
0.0259477533,
-0.0120471884,
-0.0316862948,
0.0078129461,
0.024716001,
-0.0332815498,
-0.0289234091,
0.0663006604,
-0.0647961125,
0.0168590099,
0.018649932,
-0.0542080253,
-0.0117014768,
-0.0050157919,
0.0231771767,
-0.0215525087,
0.0188041963,
0.0523581877,
0.0672538802,
-0.0042384616,
0.0479663946,
-0.0445996523,
0.0035222508,
0.0072695673,
-0.0361924618,
-0.0026665055,
-0.0462755151,
-0.0440868475,
0.0354561694,
0.0321644917,
0.0444277152,
0.0108897081,
0.0199072603,
0.0084479759,
-0.0532970242,
0.000442903,
-0.0007784151,
-0.0108565213,
-0.0362632945,
0.0246371552,
0.0681956857,
-0.0001015619,
0.0284133907,
0.0118477149,
0.0336459689,
0.0154208578,
0.0025152543,
0.0185421892,
-0.0306607839,
0.0061204843,
-0.0518410094,
0.0019292423,
0.0352164656,
-0.0304193608,
-0.0275652334,
-0.0366232023,
-0.0070787272,
0.0172688402,
2.383e-7,
-0.0118233617,
-0.0181103908,
0.1134749427,
-0.0361182466,
0.0115712192,
-0.0262871552,
-0.0173390955,
-0.0144113544,
-0.0247840844,
-0.027907189,
0.0572590195,
-0.0351347141,
0.0771363601,
0.0282066632,
-0.0934360251,
-0.018550666,
-0.044564683,
0.014620115,
-0.0455773212,
0.0344179496,
0.0048065442,
0.0511302166,
-0.0098872222,
-0.0444086343,
0.0272815507,
-0.0006991646,
-0.0589978024,
0.0151434764,
0.0123093929,
-0.0208145101,
0.0553302206,
-0.0080527589,
-0.0364596583,
0.0519209094,
-0.0149330851,
0.0346546061,
0.008748292,
0.01888901,
-0.0392696038,
0.0017508566,
-0.0046331435,
0.0262711626,
-0.0256388932,
-0.0259688348,
0.0249923412,
0.0324056596,
0.0208960101,
0.0093031265,
-0.0551679134,
0.0122371567,
0.0117573692,
0.0219840035,
0.0383288376,
0.0136956722,
0.0258536413,
-0.0237010457,
-0.0268280488,
-0.0107947113,
-0.0302466974,
0.0158622451,
-0.0391682461,
-0.0090805274,
-0.0038238619,
-0.0115094725,
0.0204460453,
-0.0228762887,
-0.0285911914,
1.758504307e-34,
-0.0321613327,
-0.0295350458,
0.049701903,
0.0326891802,
-0.0051708613,
-0.0368754566,
0.0116023514,
0.0433495753,
0.0033031842,
0.0008577608,
-0.0395141728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15421v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15421v3 | FANToM: A Benchmark for Stress-testing Machine Theory of Mind in Interactions | 2023-10-24T00:24:11 | 2023-10-31T17:58:30 | Hyunwoo Kim, Melanie Sclar, Xuhui Zhou, Ronan Le Bras, Gunhee Kim, Yejin Choi, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Theory of mind (ToM) evaluations currently focus on testing models using
passive narratives that inherently lack interactivity. We introduce FANToM, a
new benchmark designed to stress-test ToM within information-asymmetric
conversational contexts via question answering. Our benchmark draws upon
important theoretical requisites from psychology and necessary empirical
considerations when evaluating large language models (LLMs). In particular, we
formulate multiple types of questions that demand the same underlying reasoning
to identify illusory or false sense of ToM capabilities in LLMs. We show that
FANToM is challenging for state-of-the-art LLMs, which perform significantly
worse than humans even with chain-of-thought reasoning or fine-tuning. | [
0.0415454768,
0.0330569409,
-0.0531840883,
0.0647742823,
-0.0485458635,
0.0052600633,
-0.0093223546,
-0.0145982131,
-0.0066698608,
-0.0338083692,
-0.067695573,
-0.0482036658,
0.0207015462,
0.022430012,
0.0267799068,
-0.0244648457,
0.0347593278,
-0.0261853486,
0.0087027149,
-0.0023491066,
-0.0256480686,
0.0204046629,
-0.0220615976,
0.0051338407,
0.0073896125,
-0.0015071501,
-0.0384521298,
0.0285974052,
0.0381944254,
-0.0469469614,
-0.0021868823,
0.031806767,
0.0024739252,
0.0564132221,
0.000002008,
-0.0592824109,
0.0199169684,
-0.0121170133,
-0.0126919337,
0.0099584842,
-0.0054534632,
0.0100956978,
0.037526805,
0.0069387965,
-0.0432248786,
0.0115884617,
-0.0055544185,
0.0408054665,
0.0303366408,
0.0793489739,
-0.0094736228,
0.0465331823,
0.0068169404,
-0.0305713452,
0.033210393,
-0.0441043749,
0.0119601004,
-0.053910207,
0.0126762092,
-0.0394789539,
-0.0066055837,
0.0128163202,
0.0151989534,
0.0259846058,
-0.0164358933,
0.0341673009,
-0.0143467197,
-0.0214607418,
-0.0234709457,
0.1053685769,
0.0769030005,
0.0209691916,
-0.0162045509,
-0.0158747118,
0.0048872437,
-0.0025140843,
-0.0141234305,
0.023317147,
-0.0245471783,
-0.0233442634,
-0.0021312337,
0.0248631686,
-0.0119403359,
0.015737744,
-0.0061360011,
0.0153931472,
-0.0155799435,
-0.0191990416,
0.0230973084,
0.0016661921,
-0.0261287149,
-0.0723769516,
-0.0362488925,
0.0327223577,
-0.048412174,
-0.0058775931,
-0.0127561009,
0.0240629856,
0.0251962766,
-0.0419723913,
0.0616599545,
0.0377355255,
-0.006839083,
0.0330258682,
0.0381770581,
0.0581920557,
0.0072294995,
0.0085803699,
-0.027162984,
0.0178459678,
-0.0294553917,
-0.0149282515,
-0.0053595314,
0.0314668268,
-0.0004215879,
-0.0219859909,
0.0346340984,
0.0005704063,
-0.0093569607,
-0.0186934229,
-0.0246562343,
0.0186063219,
0.0090318508,
0.0398680903,
-0.0528559424,
0.0276385732,
-0.0699719191,
0.0085222637,
0.0193959568,
-0.0772781596,
-0.0343710855,
-0.0004624437,
-0.0267280303,
-0.0102257766,
0.0194904897,
0.0115106851,
0.0009692495,
-0.0281192716,
-0.0108458772,
-0.011473556,
-0.0150904413,
-0.0979048833,
0.0192057155,
-0.0043085478,
0.0489820316,
0.0094307782,
-0.0267597996,
0.0028286343,
0.0359759852,
0.0220596865,
-0.0402678251,
0.0680351928,
-0.0013339671,
-0.0070763929,
-0.0235564318,
0.0448458642,
0.0051650284,
0.0320023745,
0.0327732377,
0.0047616889,
0.040086206,
0.026788963,
0.0080107404,
0.025043115,
0.0178859793,
-0.0191568788,
0.016964877,
0.0417827405,
-0.0252697859,
0.0625052154,
0.0336598083,
0.0857391283,
-0.0166869108,
-0.0388211086,
0.0506310202,
0.0609004758,
-0.0849748477,
-0.0204352066,
0.0544457547,
0.0406245999,
0.033974275,
0.0498844795,
-0.0508483388,
0.0088156844,
-0.0396827087,
-0.0427225158,
0.0315534286,
0.0168524329,
-0.0500661246,
-0.0116933063,
-0.0261856299,
0.0026725365,
0.0302429795,
0.0081029935,
-0.0068426607,
-0.024982648,
-0.0188256372,
0.0223414339,
0.0146106072,
-0.0225549899,
-0.0278417785,
-0.0558635741,
0.0018983639,
0.0131990295,
0.0507748351,
-0.0013128113,
-0.0537372194,
-0.0043627699,
0.0015987939,
0.0775505528,
0.0918505266,
-0.000762117,
0.0272747744,
-0.0118773226,
0.0297559481,
-0.0481012315,
0.0195891224,
0.0233705528,
-0.0359333865,
-0.0098519521,
0.0070895078,
-0.0524601527,
0.0277487449,
0.0099455817,
-0.0380505547,
-0.048916135,
-0.0531951413,
0.0124599244,
0.0279776081,
0.0016285562,
-0.0200430453,
0.0003663457,
0.0399616398,
-0.0113186007,
-0.0102805225,
0.0397594087,
-0.0380877666,
-0.0228924267,
0.0323735364,
-0.0217566751,
-0.0452919528,
0.0836806893,
0.0129204551,
-0.0327260643,
-0.0160023626,
-0.0435375907,
0.0100909248,
-0.0198544078,
0.0183635969,
-0.0064618071,
0.0161857326,
-0.0093878927,
0.0674818978,
-0.0285506174,
0.0400249921,
0.0095974589,
-0.0580699854,
0.0422662571,
-0.0091346726,
-0.0086605446,
0.0146365725,
0.0208804905,
-0.0152985035,
0.0005070887,
-0.0233672336,
-0.0635055229,
-0.0246799234,
-0.1082671508,
0.0051534907,
0.007420402,
0.0129529499,
0.0153601337,
-0.012522405,
-0.0179904103,
0.0355552137,
-0.0607030243,
0.0477353632,
0.0230304487,
0.0181170106,
0.0284253638,
-0.0042151646,
-0.0002272446,
-0.0313795246,
0.0399560258,
-0.0502697118,
0.0118882013,
0.0001112941,
0.0335151926,
-0.0151076848,
0.0019355884,
-0.0888947397,
0.0298007708,
-0.0420464389,
-0.0319492333,
0.036229834,
0.0289240237,
0.0045153382,
0.0898791477,
0.0085771894,
0.0131660653,
0.0220833514,
-0.0157581139,
-0.0275462549,
0.0424646959,
0.0443757772,
-0.0265026689,
-0.0331951827,
-0.0888455585,
-0.0000544128,
0.0549146719,
-0.0043648332,
0.0214438252,
-0.0556912795,
0.0476390049,
0.005802515,
-0.0282524712,
-0.0014686373,
-0.0010224757,
-0.024178911,
0.0640698299,
-0.0273792706,
-0.0169246867,
0.088660039,
-0.0559495687,
-0.0001575474,
-0.0327649191,
0.0135646295,
-0.03870444,
0.1019729003,
0.0123789348,
0.0154410955,
0.070486486,
0.0115988441,
-0.0818276852,
-0.0472023077,
-0.0201998986,
-0.0247293264,
-0.0423557088,
-0.0300268605,
-0.0043442086,
-0.0051215808,
-0.0351335965,
-0.0532114059,
-0.0226394981,
-0.0528744273,
0.0101008574,
0.0231747199,
-0.0123444591,
-0.0115587721,
-0.0201661512,
0.0561852008,
-0.0140484869,
-0.0266572125,
-0.0197751168,
-0.0190423392,
0.0322723165,
0.0744631216,
0.0238020644,
0.0523796007,
-0.0230303053,
0.0443248525,
0.0678591207,
0.0256566647,
0.0563125089,
0.0163256638,
-0.0125090014,
0.0092302831,
0.0325844176,
-0.0270332545,
-0.0032760452,
0.0614591837,
-0.0018420717,
-0.0209405292,
0.1059390306,
0.032998912,
-0.0416048691,
0.0223001093,
-0.0326365642,
0.0577324033,
0.0172229446,
-0.0015898016,
-0.0641289651,
-0.0145975053,
0.0280717481,
0.0217729583,
-0.0447195843,
-0.0762748122,
-0.0212828498,
-0.1081285626,
0.0064882184,
-0.0412214845,
-0.0100370627,
-0.0122443065,
-0.0303661749,
0.0460738204,
0.0310367383,
0.0396761075,
0.0208137389,
0.0072222948,
0.0063519096,
-0.0237911846,
0.0021836739,
0.0048049251,
0.0713049173,
-0.0192445163,
0.0755437613,
0.0112946779,
0.0649205372,
0.0157436859,
-0.0440068617,
0.0435329862,
-0.0019086431,
0.0124944989,
-0.0362508185,
0.0534958616,
-0.013849848,
0.0171821378,
-0.0157628972,
0.0265638307,
-0.0349624343,
0.0181378834,
-0.0047000633,
0.0444366969,
-0.0157432556,
-0.0389486775,
0.0154153407,
0.0295497756,
0.0013589144,
0.098320365,
0.0508489609,
-0.0454530232,
-0.0174695849,
0.0026205534,
-0.0080782082,
0.0074676485,
-0.0651322454,
-0.0028280232,
0.0529837273,
-0.0069360752,
-0.0489069857,
-0.093180947,
-0.0095176985,
0.0220131408,
-0.0143531375,
-0.0290807392,
-0.009915255,
0.0162725039,
-0.0291529354,
0.0216816571,
-0.0410367921,
0.0279654786,
-0.0095004709,
0.0242185071,
0.0364246555,
-0.0382044166,
-0.0066499584,
0.0164301861,
-0.0434317701,
-0.0429859832,
-0.0060397009,
0.0125330584,
0.0248356536,
0.0238163061,
0.0042563016,
-0.0143222054,
-0.0020632406,
-0.0536427908,
-0.073879078,
0.0855567306,
0.0208920259,
0.0423732214,
-0.0092639718,
0.0563646369,
-0.016872745,
-0.0115770223,
0.0077391118,
0.0285553336,
0.009451922,
-0.0261193942,
0.0192293078,
0.0217971671,
0.0265176781,
0.0358429588,
-0.0200433806,
0.0026935092,
-0.0154762454,
-0.0072303833,
-0.0004883612,
-0.0487518869,
-0.0316070057,
0.0168546438,
0.0472849347,
-0.0273648482,
-0.0894856155,
-0.0306933057,
0.0493505187,
0.0034343796,
-0.0303373057,
-0.0080724526,
-0.005428405,
0.0039317315,
-0.002949843,
-0.0287409164,
0.0118233059,
-0.0196117349,
0.0667082146,
-0.0012921358,
0.0967516154,
0.0519343428,
-0.0285594687,
0.0096866181,
0.0078728972,
-0.0767276809,
-0.0617636144,
0.0431928113,
-0.0181328021,
0.005977408,
0.004175168,
0.0010614019,
-0.0270401258,
0.0292847827,
-0.0011177212,
-0.013383978,
-0.0135894977,
-0.0294309426,
0.0207197592,
0.0126207042,
-0.0224222969,
0.0548830889,
0.0577274747,
-0.0133984117,
0.044901263,
0.0120679904,
0.0061286176,
-0.0479922108,
0.0191805847,
-0.0204934198,
0.0625508502,
0.0184181854,
0.0315555632,
-0.0791031942,
-0.0680382326,
0.0351536795,
-0.007451497,
-0.0115201855,
-0.049491521,
0.0177666359,
0.0642253831,
0.006225659,
-0.0230734758,
0.0137172714,
0.006428401,
-0.0332462974,
0.00535896,
-0.0317180902,
-6.822472969e-33,
-0.0232819617,
0.0087130051,
-0.0116770919,
0.0429371782,
-0.0590436272,
0.0158443451,
-0.0511076972,
0.0355361439,
-0.0349120945,
-0.0152366431,
-0.0105580622,
0.0074548475,
-0.0109918155,
0.0212487411,
-0.0533155017,
-0.0360908322,
0.0115392655,
-0.0364941396,
-0.0506273657,
-0.0024722223,
-0.0195910744,
-0.0062915115,
-0.0010066376,
-0.0821072608,
0.0571491048,
-0.0087326104,
0.0125795081,
0.0447714813,
-0.0243765879,
0.0007860655,
-0.0218571089,
0.041268371,
0.0406582244,
-0.0158884022,
0.0349963009,
-0.0077922619,
-0.0338663012,
-0.0591066293,
0.0693424717,
-0.016382413,
-0.0245532338,
-0.0402144119,
-0.016733624,
-0.0231672954,
-0.0210705716,
-0.0166201498,
-0.0002154301,
0.0171371233,
0.0305314139,
0.0256233066,
-0.0633922294,
-0.0128720133,
-0.0132969758,
-0.0404241011,
-0.0407865755,
0.0592073761,
-0.0020191709,
-0.0334941521,
-0.0352958739,
-0.0236507226,
0.0231105462,
-0.0046096994,
0.0290563367,
-0.0345697775,
0.023045022,
0.0807025656,
0.0862418786,
0.0383549184,
-0.0627435967,
-0.0016004012,
0.0171526521,
0.0320810787,
0.065780133,
0.0391954221,
-0.0202547405,
-0.0238547698,
-0.0382114798,
0.0084302435,
0.0511906631,
0.0235590357,
0.0570290163,
0.0018040235,
-0.0398821048,
-0.0258356072,
-0.0765160099,
-0.0429732762,
-0.0344011858,
0.0017747213,
0.0161336865,
0.0112782158,
-0.0044987509,
-0.0627478287,
0.0344683342,
-0.0280644353,
0.0444029234,
0.0103502851,
-0.0125156371,
0.0359130576,
0.0118839061,
0.0278423782,
-0.0411926545,
0.0212633125,
0.0196263101,
0.0357213356,
0.0536727905,
0.0190463811,
-0.0077339951,
-0.0149535034,
-0.0225319397,
-0.0132757025,
-0.0286435317,
0.0318169855,
-0.0465005189,
-0.0274999365,
0.0301348493,
0.0260258149,
-0.0385308266,
-0.0406304821,
0.0061269179,
-0.0298494007,
-0.0595150962,
0.0275636371,
-0.0178833064,
-0.002605065,
-0.0423829332,
-0.0077104396,
-0.0062378431,
-0.0041433922,
0.0330305025,
-0.0336876437,
-0.0078892047,
-0.030415779,
2.732e-7,
-0.0037807364,
0.0484060086,
-0.0062676216,
0.0086799422,
0.0114970384,
0.0532470122,
-0.0172055028,
0.0126734003,
0.0498693027,
-0.0841256231,
-0.0211751256,
0.053749647,
0.0814309269,
0.0537224896,
-0.0537785701,
-0.0155736487,
-0.0102986898,
-0.0059531303,
-0.0287958179,
0.0302187093,
0.0497121811,
0.0355958194,
0.002157473,
-0.0056291847,
0.0169927459,
-0.0262010358,
0.0238976534,
-0.0767710134,
0.0042260299,
-0.0028683522,
0.0122845033,
-0.009441141,
0.0048256344,
0.0212798044,
0.0328356363,
0.0249085035,
-0.0221862029,
0.0296039861,
-0.009757543,
-0.1088170037,
0.0025861927,
-0.0140750464,
-0.0118673332,
-0.0693536028,
0.074942939,
-0.03584655,
-0.0562018007,
0.0098273801,
0.0316042043,
0.0095318491,
0.0090657715,
0.0295967981,
-0.0373195484,
0.0185292102,
0.015640581,
0.0061091809,
0.0074585793,
-0.0628171414,
-0.0024459744,
-0.0449135341,
-0.0207911339,
-0.0832030326,
-0.0347606465,
-0.0078079221,
-0.0131665533,
-0.0393755361,
0.012761605,
2.593748948e-34,
0.0376849435,
-0.0189875774,
0.0346224494,
0.0274146087,
0.0785620734,
-0.0035356535,
0.0120745106,
-0.0025121667,
0.0333631262,
-0.111655727,
-0.0013739883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15420v1 | Let the Pretrained Language Models "Imagine" for Short Texts Topic Modeling | 2023-10-24T00:23:30 | 2023-10-24T00:23:30 | Pritom Saha Akash, Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topic models are one of the compelling methods for discovering latent
semantics in a document collection. However, it assumes that a document has
sufficient co-occurrence information to be effective. However, in short texts,
co-occurrence information is minimal, which results in feature sparsity in
document representation. Therefore, existing topic models (probabilistic or
neural) mostly fail to mine patterns from them to generate coherent topics. In
this paper, we take a new approach to short-text topic modeling to address the
data-sparsity issue by extending short text into longer sequences using
existing pre-trained language models (PLMs). Besides, we provide a simple
solution extending a neural topic model to reduce the effect of noisy
out-of-topics text generation from PLMs. We observe that our model can
substantially improve the performance of short-text topic modeling. Extensive
experiments on multiple real-world datasets under extreme data sparsity
scenarios show that our models can generate high-quality topics outperforming
state-of-the-art models. | [
0.0228116959,
0.0154849421,
0.0037253806,
0.0349320211,
-0.0311729796,
-0.0166844744,
0.000557087,
-0.001770479,
-0.0779930577,
-0.0605940819,
0.0004213708,
-0.0283425767,
0.0089602098,
0.0676255077,
0.0130401468,
-0.0414457619,
0.0022391498,
-0.0217977315,
0.0332005844,
0.0213922709,
0.0401128009,
0.014079703,
0.033976756,
0.0194785334,
-0.0274724271,
-0.0097670564,
-0.0446765497,
-0.0190758016,
-0.0385245048,
-0.0271372292,
0.0247526243,
0.0391084142,
0.0312155578,
-0.026363479,
0.0000017142,
-0.0056143356,
-0.0098647745,
-0.029085394,
0.0483644642,
0.0249463245,
0.0572997741,
-0.0336630046,
0.0430103429,
0.0175824966,
-0.0258555561,
0.0077570858,
-0.0158436224,
0.100765653,
0.0352240689,
0.0980398729,
-0.031914603,
0.0253735073,
0.0196665693,
-0.0454495847,
0.0503867492,
-0.0227591377,
0.0031332609,
-0.0420583338,
0.0199840702,
0.0614651106,
0.0053648781,
-0.00144001,
0.0046001459,
-0.0001403549,
0.0208247174,
0.0334974751,
0.0041960608,
-0.0267449375,
0.010948929,
0.0696511716,
-0.0400031731,
-0.0326086208,
0.049260214,
-0.034640085,
-0.0284903422,
-0.0190547649,
-0.0424191467,
0.0388612375,
0.0140831377,
0.03670175,
0.0591166094,
0.0084636677,
0.026224779,
0.0187612083,
-0.028449636,
0.0027053584,
0.0253097769,
-0.0253747869,
-0.0544644445,
-0.0171063337,
-0.0115967337,
-0.0376871601,
0.0171911512,
0.0509313904,
0.0270731505,
0.0077648838,
-0.0584191605,
-0.0560030341,
0.0321643315,
-0.0488294363,
-0.0247070938,
0.0063517559,
-0.0383584537,
0.0497825556,
-0.0081020966,
-0.0330686606,
0.0147661129,
-0.0134609146,
-0.0403128453,
0.0030125612,
0.0090482123,
0.0097054066,
-0.0345785394,
0.0586873814,
-0.0077024568,
-0.0472184084,
0.0050017065,
0.0275873952,
0.044322826,
-0.0296034422,
-0.0260661524,
0.0186522938,
-0.0308638941,
-0.0208646823,
0.0083087888,
0.0190625042,
-0.0284635928,
0.0505696051,
0.0063146772,
0.0037844258,
-0.0062970622,
0.0598517358,
0.0482569337,
0.0000042664,
0.000391608,
-0.0081205182,
-0.003328721,
-0.0775486678,
-0.0656996742,
-0.0326320231,
-0.0098121352,
-0.0279734619,
0.0054313904,
-0.0912636667,
0.010582882,
0.0162349492,
-0.010180763,
-0.033219818,
0.0149817122,
0.0420335047,
-0.0593638904,
0.0372665524,
-0.0440093502,
0.0268571787,
0.0519950874,
0.0381742045,
0.0566937737,
0.0512736402,
0.0262792278,
0.0647092015,
0.0548602454,
0.0069033909,
-0.0084046843,
0.0094024455,
0.0372581519,
0.0032764836,
0.0259466153,
-0.0053032115,
-0.0322580151,
0.0075789192,
0.0392451063,
0.0566182844,
-0.01769685,
-0.0119974799,
0.043526344,
0.0671072751,
0.0398132056,
0.0322373845,
0.0373975486,
0.0319773667,
-0.0162013117,
0.0116254902,
0.0142388362,
-0.0169773847,
-0.0205190312,
0.0065205884,
0.0678536817,
0.0083749397,
-0.0611473098,
-0.0243828632,
-0.0027017156,
-0.0507155322,
0.0110815065,
-0.0409489907,
0.0772157237,
0.0244209841,
-0.0241408609,
0.0510562137,
0.0323308818,
-0.0510937423,
0.0335701182,
-0.0095679546,
0.0673274472,
0.0351166949,
0.0405718349,
-0.02944584,
-0.0221069753,
-0.0207295753,
0.0399180911,
0.0298207421,
0.0058071385,
0.0102588972,
0.0067498754,
-0.0272084493,
-0.0067201736,
-0.040902555,
0.033046253,
-0.0137194199,
-0.0162582789,
0.016324617,
0.0702591836,
-0.0113616167,
-0.0086310469,
0.0520014986,
-0.0441771373,
0.0041990872,
0.0301778466,
-0.0179258455,
0.0170495603,
0.0142807327,
0.0138593465,
0.0338050574,
0.0527350977,
-0.0450933389,
-0.0053022006,
-0.0339263938,
-0.0468648151,
-0.0370512903,
0.0324516632,
-0.0314303711,
0.0614612065,
-0.0096413083,
-0.0194232743,
-0.0383137949,
0.027998589,
-0.0313954651,
-0.0061500254,
-0.050083708,
-0.0040690801,
0.0065777078,
0.0090563241,
-0.0182694569,
0.0375025533,
0.0027105876,
0.0412167199,
0.0070015988,
0.0122015653,
0.0383162089,
-0.0550579689,
-0.0196806677,
0.0088311508,
-0.0073640603,
0.0068194899,
0.0639166012,
0.0255747139,
0.0201345291,
-0.0290272646,
-0.0860502571,
0.0147486711,
-0.0262295641,
-0.0278879721,
0.0259118155,
0.0129833156,
0.000517307,
-0.0215319321,
-0.0492392145,
0.0041707112,
0.0268149525,
0.0107113216,
0.035925027,
0.0139588993,
0.0348744541,
-0.067844145,
-0.0034552664,
0.0034116455,
0.0487542152,
0.0098280767,
-0.0225880817,
-0.0439537354,
0.065903537,
-0.0166878961,
-0.0270695388,
-0.0114584779,
0.0045408122,
-0.0153454095,
-0.0582038797,
0.0839093998,
-0.0165568013,
0.0447658375,
0.043083895,
0.0379590429,
-0.0165299792,
-0.0238133464,
-0.029935509,
-0.0522202961,
0.0716878548,
0.002297075,
-0.0250519179,
0.0306021329,
0.0565222129,
-0.0099012647,
-0.0062789232,
-0.0332667157,
-0.0041206889,
0.0013183877,
0.018707078,
-0.0371322259,
-0.0069135912,
0.0209834725,
0.0050374945,
-0.0320374295,
-0.0487711504,
0.0352057628,
-0.0432759076,
0.034537904,
-0.0450190939,
-0.0301133152,
-0.0765408278,
0.0324320495,
0.0218953267,
-0.0063655311,
-0.0232375022,
0.0040439595,
-0.0205418468,
0.0226552412,
-0.025283698,
-0.0104446523,
0.0593057461,
-0.0115118939,
0.0236396138,
-0.0137684746,
-0.0098786019,
-0.0255748723,
-0.1065911576,
0.0416289046,
0.0155595578,
0.0195792001,
0.0036610914,
-0.0154660139,
0.020407958,
0.0137294866,
0.061974436,
-0.0262428708,
0.0021167547,
-0.0156949777,
0.0522186644,
0.0805352926,
-0.0536496229,
-0.0163961872,
-0.0459967777,
0.0037151303,
0.0243332293,
0.0093711857,
-0.0177043825,
-0.052591119,
-0.0177841857,
-0.0074378657,
-0.0331111923,
-0.0281952731,
0.020822037,
0.0060524987,
-0.0476391986,
-0.0144696627,
0.1146170869,
0.0129630296,
-0.0539240502,
0.0025781568,
0.0049515762,
0.01750312,
-0.0103170434,
0.001371288,
-0.0526309907,
-0.0078761009,
-0.0182928927,
0.0113761937,
0.0256320387,
-0.021982111,
-0.0214004554,
-0.0433385521,
-0.0134153748,
0.016830733,
-0.006180644,
-0.0247222297,
-0.0787960663,
-0.0168220848,
0.0121552078,
-0.0205982029,
-0.0076318346,
-0.0494831912,
0.0095441015,
0.006503847,
-0.0328446627,
-0.0619098544,
-0.0292259697,
-0.039614208,
0.0250183567,
0.0144314785,
0.019460991,
-0.0020511688,
0.0358301736,
0.0067163999,
-0.0155450264,
-0.0130516803,
-0.0048480104,
0.0309144612,
-0.0362195708,
0.0150379343,
0.0157422572,
0.0283730999,
-0.0606575385,
-0.0305401888,
0.0139485626,
0.045509249,
-0.0566080511,
-0.0227555018,
-0.0347301252,
0.0121550169,
0.0178440325,
0.0863684416,
0.0499388464,
-0.0377365984,
-0.023197988,
-0.0136966389,
0.005985267,
0.0184056386,
-0.006834886,
-0.0368415602,
0.0032638153,
-0.0435866639,
-0.0785048082,
-0.0878594518,
0.0414552279,
0.0038646325,
-0.0086693745,
0.0333848074,
-0.0077713043,
-0.0399085432,
-0.0331048779,
0.0401619822,
-0.0150895892,
-0.0292180069,
-0.0726224035,
-0.0073045418,
0.0525982454,
-0.0528573878,
0.0091457162,
-0.0158955734,
-0.104194656,
-0.0487278998,
-0.014493214,
0.0164882056,
0.005594105,
0.0147366086,
-0.0154188033,
-0.0784798041,
0.0566653237,
0.0460026488,
-0.086929746,
0.0164508522,
-0.0117878355,
-0.0179002844,
-0.0024494668,
0.0083896285,
-0.0472905524,
0.0560626574,
-0.0005732441,
0.0418767668,
-0.0371481255,
-0.0705607086,
-0.0019480537,
-0.0184546597,
0.0635176077,
-0.0072981673,
-0.0010815931,
-0.0826878622,
-0.0273227785,
-0.02011301,
0.0250350554,
-0.0357333757,
0.0279523842,
0.0112220077,
0.0011500268,
-0.0366714597,
0.0206904113,
-0.0459934622,
0.0564950183,
-0.0087296981,
0.0164734516,
-0.0274863113,
0.0131863886,
-0.0162377022,
0.00189523,
-0.0121885389,
0.010815816,
-0.0605519488,
-0.0265757591,
-0.0361943059,
0.0260423385,
0.0202384125,
0.0023414542,
-0.0101071373,
0.0130212512,
-0.0622857288,
-0.0090160519,
-0.0414083265,
0.0312673189,
0.0462226123,
-0.0286678877,
0.0337760299,
-0.0361304097,
0.0019091967,
-0.0577999502,
0.0691396147,
0.0023869537,
-0.008793762,
-0.0014081624,
0.0249156691,
-0.047720015,
0.0140982624,
0.1056687683,
0.0549639314,
0.0031058604,
0.0536413267,
-0.0091200825,
-0.019789543,
0.0148168579,
0.0631322265,
0.0537175797,
-0.0422140323,
0.0252300501,
-0.0124153327,
-0.0006148773,
0.0287459921,
-0.0330407992,
-0.0212773196,
0.0100004766,
0.0551754646,
0.0884498954,
-0.0320650749,
0.0582698025,
-0.0621701367,
0.0268370919,
0.0086433645,
-0.0509551242,
-0.0233891383,
-6.305122476e-33,
-0.014388117,
-0.0303850174,
0.0204340238,
0.0469904616,
0.0101438612,
0.0136639718,
-0.0556179248,
0.0086959805,
0.0163107663,
0.0102180243,
-0.0093293535,
0.0226864275,
-0.0161884222,
0.0488308743,
-0.015697252,
0.0032089166,
0.0724832267,
-0.0119680287,
0.0001417741,
0.0588407442,
0.0297210682,
0.0533597581,
0.012453462,
-0.0543814935,
-0.0079003731,
-0.0470731892,
0.0234055351,
-0.0077171526,
0.0917336941,
0.0462248139,
-0.0283183083,
0.0295546968,
0.0666788295,
-0.0207490735,
-0.0337445401,
0.0368317105,
-0.0554559715,
-0.0340217724,
-0.0125792408,
-0.0689288676,
-0.0244412553,
-0.0450503528,
0.0233157836,
-0.0109997056,
0.0432703793,
0.0113051506,
0.0806333274,
-0.0185611118,
-0.0265917499,
-0.040331319,
-0.0512613207,
0.049131263,
0.0124018071,
-0.0189622641,
0.0143748699,
0.0013489545,
-0.0163427107,
0.0499094017,
-0.0266014058,
0.0378060639,
0.0160069,
0.0619048513,
-0.0112028942,
-0.0185631085,
-0.0206028707,
0.0411416888,
-0.04532988,
0.0379267819,
-0.0104592973,
0.0289826151,
0.039471522,
0.0416147299,
0.0337260999,
0.0098179057,
0.0521685109,
0.0046823341,
-0.0656725168,
0.0420032702,
-0.008643169,
-0.000223994,
0.0304138381,
-0.0184708405,
-0.0106144538,
-0.0213003121,
-0.0209275875,
0.0272275265,
-0.0152050154,
-0.0568993837,
0.0145162819,
0.0768971667,
0.0032268709,
0.0005336317,
0.0445658825,
-0.0053246538,
-0.0176354237,
0.0486698933,
-0.0317155384,
-0.014564855,
-0.0088519612,
0.0203859434,
-0.0937822312,
-0.0496894494,
0.034979403,
-0.0331101455,
-0.0255952738,
-0.0062399418,
0.0360155702,
-0.0008893805,
-0.0363558121,
-0.0095065208,
0.0003034467,
-0.0266278423,
-0.0137880594,
0.0261126738,
0.0021517435,
0.0194093939,
-0.0014816059,
0.086844705,
0.0032379727,
-0.00444989,
0.002250053,
-0.0921531543,
0.0161931962,
0.0357343704,
-0.0165592059,
0.0094643757,
-0.0402371176,
0.0245201718,
0.0447517373,
-0.0485436916,
0.0043749562,
-0.0101824617,
2.392e-7,
0.0346091315,
0.018879937,
0.009858449,
-0.0238051172,
0.0027742945,
0.0157222822,
-0.0234212838,
0.048053734,
-0.0274357442,
-0.0098170824,
0.0194585416,
0.0277157724,
0.0033412655,
0.006574403,
-0.0641232282,
0.034729708,
-0.0654631779,
-0.0115644867,
-0.0637187734,
-0.0351532623,
0.0358534418,
0.0920765549,
0.0280680899,
0.0036059816,
-0.0024636029,
-0.0470363945,
0.0950504616,
-0.0337661915,
-0.0577859357,
0.0440210961,
0.0743675604,
0.0322339609,
-0.0203344673,
-0.0733259022,
-0.0277137961,
0.0367477648,
0.028242413,
0.0555485524,
0.014810171,
-0.0219005961,
0.0378121808,
-0.018487459,
-0.0203340892,
0.0063307076,
0.0589660928,
-0.0651632696,
-0.0188290793,
-0.0232577249,
0.006845322,
0.0153943896,
-0.0012842716,
-0.0296404902,
-0.0084760468,
0.0092744743,
0.0072969492,
-0.0212733299,
0.0163483117,
-0.0593093485,
0.0134415291,
0.0145660974,
-0.0450324863,
0.0096057365,
-0.0746383891,
0.0042972672,
0.0509956479,
-0.0393798351,
0.0393975712,
2.320213938e-34,
0.0380615704,
-0.037694823,
-0.0587630644,
-0.012977154,
-0.0052500428,
-0.0167370122,
-0.0207195356,
0.0035029978,
0.0083368793,
-0.0535389259,
-0.0040228642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15415v1 | Mind the Gap Between Conversations for Improved Long-Term Dialogue Generation | 2023-10-24T00:12:38 | 2023-10-24T00:12:38 | Qiang Zhang, Jason Naradowsky, Yusuke Miyao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Knowing how to end and resume conversations over time is a natural part of
communication, allowing for discussions to span weeks, months, or years. The
duration of gaps between conversations dictates which topics are relevant and
which questions to ask, and dialogue systems which do not explicitly model time
may generate responses that are unnatural. In this work we explore the idea of
making dialogue models aware of time, and present GapChat, a multi-session
dialogue dataset in which the time between each session varies. While the
dataset is constructed in real-time, progress on events in speakers' lives is
simulated in order to create realistic dialogues occurring across a long
timespan. We expose time information to the model and compare different
representations of time and event progress. In human evaluation we show that
time-aware models perform better in metrics that judge the relevance of the
chosen topics and the information gained from the conversation. | [
0.033705093,
0.0787393153,
-0.0318038911,
-0.0111344364,
-0.0483591855,
-0.0005518944,
0.0302239601,
-0.0176648144,
0.0013927305,
-0.007502669,
0.0030681007,
-0.0602190495,
0.0285116974,
0.0568037368,
-0.0185929835,
-0.0925398469,
0.0398059711,
0.0023805236,
0.0287807193,
0.0205119029,
0.0141649498,
-0.0120149031,
-0.0290376488,
0.0585201979,
-0.006844393,
-0.0264199544,
-0.0614813827,
-0.0279016234,
0.0369943492,
-0.0244386904,
0.0035393361,
0.0467654988,
0.0084814392,
0.0168889891,
0.0000018834,
-0.0098172054,
0.0178525113,
-0.0550817624,
-0.035832487,
0.0058781886,
0.0260215551,
0.0288261343,
0.0226181448,
0.0417889357,
-0.0748800114,
0.0086637214,
0.0122514348,
0.0236740019,
0.0561210476,
0.0575491898,
-0.027127333,
0.0351746902,
0.0051934412,
-0.0438184142,
0.0498839691,
-0.0825971812,
-0.0295015816,
0.0296686124,
0.0374475531,
-0.0185728613,
0.012057961,
0.0095102312,
0.0252248272,
-0.0416504033,
0.0525688902,
0.0432546176,
-0.033638157,
-0.0025870756,
-0.0207267813,
0.085458748,
0.0320362076,
0.0003188544,
0.0126903933,
-0.0061832662,
0.0090044159,
-0.0503705777,
-0.0646850988,
-0.0164526179,
0.0131612485,
-0.0081185689,
-0.0161367208,
0.0713167787,
-0.0017803762,
0.0153593067,
0.0359446816,
0.0119147906,
-0.0015774422,
-0.0156804938,
-0.0630037263,
-0.0114436802,
0.012012613,
-0.1033911854,
0.0237577297,
0.038139686,
-0.0473911092,
0.0207687989,
-0.0555728748,
0.0851884186,
-0.0038590697,
-0.0135271093,
-0.0216162018,
0.0442043953,
0.0098540923,
0.0410133116,
0.047270909,
0.0341679342,
0.0177458543,
-0.0606630854,
-0.0267746951,
0.0121022202,
-0.0439481139,
-0.0216186922,
-0.0331352279,
-0.0189005584,
-0.0487018265,
-0.0487083644,
-0.0355449431,
0.0618793517,
-0.0041621849,
-0.0050196252,
0.0026920298,
0.0367743261,
-0.0327548385,
0.0165565722,
-0.0552217662,
0.0244530179,
-0.07046552,
0.0088730631,
0.0496113002,
-0.071004644,
-0.010958299,
0.0286472719,
0.0144549226,
-0.016738601,
-0.0443685241,
0.0441027842,
-0.0504451357,
0.0071566855,
-0.0206333492,
-0.0515039377,
-0.0283917338,
-0.0510673039,
-0.007090562,
-0.0099891974,
0.0489660054,
-0.0026743622,
-0.0343841612,
0.0124478778,
0.0028275258,
0.0001850772,
0.020281896,
0.0486899167,
0.0178122707,
0.0538415872,
0.0710180774,
0.0410164669,
0.0127155613,
0.0253727268,
0.0550276972,
-0.0089512933,
0.021985285,
0.0046467623,
0.0026740341,
0.0124751553,
0.0159847327,
-0.0123236468,
-0.0071628368,
0.0281940084,
-0.0114101246,
0.0570861772,
-0.0008940679,
0.0257731713,
-0.0420468226,
-0.0229922105,
0.0813350827,
0.0250559542,
-0.0199359562,
0.0178461708,
0.0261500608,
0.0074921674,
-0.0048314338,
0.0117249349,
-0.0163825601,
0.0454692282,
0.0246075522,
-0.0065878453,
0.0402872711,
0.0017921226,
-0.0403116457,
-0.0522324517,
0.0259668622,
0.014386883,
0.0512898713,
-0.001333556,
-0.0087020528,
-0.0068742847,
-0.0333813056,
0.0794777423,
-0.0265682358,
-0.0226798374,
-0.0193931591,
-0.0208331589,
0.0137687288,
0.0959377512,
0.0655007958,
-0.0057896846,
-0.0652533919,
-0.0223665088,
0.0390718468,
0.0202645343,
0.064677462,
-0.033373788,
0.0353894532,
-0.0427276567,
-0.0053612282,
0.0187230855,
-0.0101196961,
0.0159944519,
0.0263331626,
0.0544614382,
0.0102690002,
0.0060244491,
0.0148728425,
-0.0012576818,
-0.045984786,
0.011969218,
0.0094152791,
-0.009380606,
0.0118886074,
0.0166237857,
0.0042732675,
-0.0022629618,
0.0135850161,
-0.0298772641,
-0.0155485021,
0.0930981487,
-0.1017420068,
-0.037265826,
0.0306554418,
-0.0106574791,
0.0053958772,
0.0034088443,
-0.0007094385,
-0.0426266603,
0.0400364101,
-0.0411776751,
0.0505521633,
-0.021410482,
0.0304688979,
-0.0020427883,
0.0185694583,
-0.0257938206,
0.0402860753,
-0.0189594589,
-0.0045078653,
0.0354366712,
0.043069046,
0.0231870245,
-0.076750949,
0.030066615,
0.0603246354,
-0.0012942104,
-0.0100957891,
0.0244570412,
0.0085537368,
-0.0800243989,
-0.0319183059,
-0.1643617302,
0.0067697675,
0.0041971724,
-0.0080145011,
0.0141614312,
0.0079300813,
-0.0007603334,
-0.0310143009,
-0.0762740225,
-0.0029493109,
0.0292892922,
-0.0170514807,
0.0422857851,
0.0136873228,
-0.0113978283,
-0.0470382087,
0.0046387045,
0.0081533901,
0.045189511,
0.0022522577,
-0.0212791879,
-0.0065508708,
0.0015385376,
-0.0616494119,
0.0196123216,
-0.0224413369,
-0.0361470692,
0.0381656438,
0.0256332811,
0.0683717802,
0.0555736534,
0.0858944282,
0.0413543582,
-0.0072996584,
-0.0404819734,
-0.0277384222,
0.031098675,
-0.0252304003,
0.0362666771,
-0.0351734757,
-0.0172460172,
-0.0200425461,
0.007753036,
0.0109014297,
0.0503013805,
-0.0445803776,
0.0383016616,
-0.0037175131,
-0.0401122123,
-0.0132115399,
0.018675996,
-0.0273612794,
0.0230325852,
-0.0326216295,
-0.0412906297,
0.0627280697,
0.0264238287,
-0.0174789857,
0.0017803634,
-0.0074516577,
-0.0352082364,
0.095140405,
-0.0243185367,
-0.0143379671,
-0.0073494874,
-0.0273282826,
-0.045150131,
0.0084706461,
0.0334217586,
-0.0543046296,
0.0064889677,
-0.0409399569,
-0.0116151739,
0.0170861166,
-0.0240691435,
-0.076949887,
-0.0612893961,
-0.0329737924,
-0.0085073384,
-0.0310031939,
-0.0226178765,
-0.0579447225,
0.0235970262,
-0.0236433074,
0.0144295292,
-0.0432498679,
-0.0019502417,
-0.0065530161,
0.0634157062,
0.0556824915,
0.0060510305,
-0.0160843544,
-0.0319651738,
0.0611793287,
0.0156171983,
0.027492173,
0.0113425096,
-0.0155671593,
0.0026617812,
-0.0166262463,
0.0120724337,
-0.0002775995,
0.0209012982,
0.0496648066,
-0.0103428848,
-0.0256676171,
0.1187688336,
0.045318082,
-0.0253257509,
0.0051266029,
-0.0429546908,
0.0582979769,
0.0101065161,
-0.0004872066,
-0.0645829737,
-0.0212575123,
0.0112980912,
0.0028774112,
-0.0474860705,
-0.03683706,
-0.0113335429,
-0.076919511,
-0.0026668033,
0.0266822837,
-0.045915924,
0.0223481413,
0.02073735,
-0.0140130157,
-0.012191914,
0.0307448152,
0.0049980357,
0.0288954899,
-0.0023200589,
0.013485034,
-0.0596867874,
-0.0270075146,
0.0600390621,
0.0417738594,
0.103807427,
0.0468024351,
0.0891706422,
0.0595005937,
-0.0384399444,
0.0089855455,
0.0232418347,
-0.0091522112,
0.0066619078,
0.0521333739,
0.0076867612,
-0.0235601254,
-0.0305077713,
0.0536512472,
0.0038977484,
-0.0172074754,
0.032431528,
0.033844091,
-0.0541101247,
0.0103705674,
-0.0096924789,
0.035876371,
0.0635715201,
0.045242615,
0.0202943943,
-0.0531869531,
-0.0407456122,
0.0272450112,
0.0245277546,
-0.0574219227,
0.0087349387,
0.000406157,
0.0250789765,
0.0000478799,
-0.0698753223,
-0.0565818287,
-0.0230456982,
0.0021974549,
-0.0355225801,
-0.013813192,
-0.0051531922,
0.0359082595,
-0.049018573,
0.0152760185,
-0.0006256646,
0.0151271373,
-0.0391453579,
-0.0351191014,
0.0034918555,
-0.0307605471,
-0.006646032,
0.0552154481,
-0.1082728952,
-0.0412094295,
-0.020819407,
0.0008286433,
0.0308029875,
0.0462463275,
0.0081743104,
-0.0195366181,
-0.0027062688,
-0.0072158417,
-0.014780486,
0.0023011989,
0.0073665567,
0.0875091553,
-0.0163095836,
0.0366203561,
-0.0014086324,
0.0148430122,
-0.0560401492,
0.0203934386,
-0.0605333783,
-0.0597946569,
-0.0136031434,
-0.0333600976,
-0.0088546062,
0.025314318,
-0.0168894175,
0.0072744344,
0.0021997145,
-0.0470589325,
-0.000090612,
-0.0595148653,
-0.0177860241,
0.0075359098,
-0.003754203,
0.0028118356,
-0.0319770798,
-0.0389631614,
0.0061657825,
-0.0404973328,
-0.0398068167,
-0.0048398445,
-0.0073285825,
-0.0061236932,
-0.0096409554,
-0.0098634306,
-0.0086088981,
-0.0202129763,
-0.0068922811,
0.0092279483,
0.0804440379,
0.0008201144,
0.0050887889,
0.0429331958,
0.00601106,
-0.0778370276,
-0.0365507565,
0.000278676,
0.0254872777,
0.0296580344,
0.0143486168,
0.0481964312,
-0.0048818639,
0.0177150834,
-0.0273036771,
0.0720389709,
0.0027525993,
-0.0407857224,
-0.0049935346,
0.0235613771,
-0.0345777646,
0.0180220455,
0.0658996403,
0.0027215998,
0.0130737545,
0.0032487214,
-0.022039827,
-0.0341184288,
-0.0249526575,
-0.0133516248,
0.0052922079,
0.0145765357,
0.0067256377,
-0.0468985289,
-0.0156193562,
0.0241214409,
0.0310214832,
0.0143865235,
-0.0060314457,
0.038940303,
0.0420111865,
-0.0239560567,
-0.0261474643,
-0.0555592142,
0.0400498062,
-0.0022909476,
-0.0110148806,
-0.0803233311,
-5.942485041e-33,
-0.029966766,
-0.0630356744,
0.0373176932,
-0.0061093816,
-0.0954591334,
-0.0015659983,
-0.0584167913,
0.0168098323,
0.0134417135,
0.0067007565,
-0.0078219706,
0.0456245616,
0.0163597502,
0.0252126772,
0.0204054397,
-0.0336873345,
0.0482713655,
-0.0136905247,
-0.0075923577,
0.0769249871,
0.0414952077,
0.0070229098,
-0.0146253705,
-0.0479457155,
-0.0004204848,
-0.0003001166,
-0.0031380642,
0.0080078254,
0.0526634343,
0.049639862,
-0.0332168899,
0.0116049163,
0.0188279245,
-0.0424566492,
-0.0317803547,
0.0400530808,
-0.0561432466,
-0.0133939935,
0.0008255377,
0.0106494455,
-0.0284647159,
-0.0155791277,
-0.0109056709,
0.0093389368,
0.0048661586,
-0.0221413262,
0.0103077991,
-0.0305101164,
-0.033861991,
-0.0072733751,
-0.0327157676,
0.0319031663,
-0.0480003357,
-0.0790513381,
-0.0189266652,
0.0712040737,
0.0304925255,
-0.0492744781,
0.0017082432,
0.0366031416,
-0.0010798184,
0.0034300371,
0.0193887409,
0.0262414534,
0.0247296318,
0.0663329065,
0.0285656992,
0.0398274586,
-0.0163511131,
0.0059407777,
-0.0008760712,
0.0263431277,
0.0051792907,
0.0172520317,
0.0074603814,
-0.0485754162,
-0.0289453324,
0.0159228947,
0.0268061608,
0.0039212289,
0.0202510245,
0.013124425,
0.0047852127,
0.007481392,
-0.0122543136,
0.0152041661,
-0.0123338979,
-0.013674208,
0.0246765893,
0.0572328977,
0.0090772528,
-0.0241947901,
0.0353848673,
-0.0182218216,
0.0306786876,
0.0358081385,
-0.0605029017,
0.0110873515,
0.0113178231,
0.001665367,
-0.0288818814,
-0.021499861,
0.0370054245,
0.0322415046,
0.0377640091,
-0.0056677135,
-0.0203792155,
0.011324985,
-0.0256725401,
-0.0258741584,
-0.028521657,
0.0633497238,
-0.0205948595,
-0.0090785129,
0.0066500935,
-0.0224350784,
-0.0487807989,
0.0529400632,
-0.0297519919,
0.0053811646,
-0.0371937528,
-0.0481752716,
0.0299676564,
0.0150066586,
-0.051611416,
0.0013690994,
-0.0223351829,
-0.0063246256,
0.020768499,
-0.0080217933,
-0.0067628738,
-0.0385625623,
2.525e-7,
-0.0610945411,
0.0146355387,
0.0357177444,
0.0419046097,
0.0588376634,
0.0130367074,
0.01672321,
0.0395431332,
-0.0065480159,
-0.0211984999,
0.046151191,
0.0142715406,
0.0909868032,
0.0094953803,
-0.038966313,
-0.0590554699,
-0.1056240574,
-0.037699692,
-0.0266160592,
-0.0306328014,
0.0742026567,
0.0286962725,
0.0424240679,
0.0195172839,
0.0002868619,
-0.0163511448,
0.0736781508,
-0.0354358628,
-0.0500426888,
0.01523137,
0.06756372,
-0.0046489052,
-0.0242465232,
-0.0048928498,
-0.0139017506,
0.0062637702,
-0.0000776829,
0.0343584567,
-0.0030572847,
-0.0694480762,
-0.0367038473,
0.017431844,
-0.0167384762,
-0.0083026746,
0.0515251048,
-0.0410514921,
-0.0173935946,
-0.0200854428,
0.0154691981,
0.003891696,
0.0325284004,
0.0067269839,
-0.0342476442,
0.0141696529,
-0.0006818419,
0.0069811526,
0.0462255217,
-0.0783341527,
-0.0210961197,
0.0317959003,
-0.0866595954,
-0.0539906658,
-0.0675447807,
-0.0217143875,
-0.0217979252,
-0.0136071136,
-0.0059524286,
1.652011521e-34,
0.027208047,
0.010564886,
-0.0154386479,
0.0440737009,
0.0212215651,
-0.0231630858,
0.0361797698,
-0.025809221,
0.0457825661,
-0.0304738823,
-0.022259159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15405v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15405v1 | GPT-4 as an Effective Zero-Shot Evaluator for Scientific Figure Captions | 2023-10-23T23:24:57 | 2023-10-23T23:24:57 | Ting-Yao Hsu, Chieh-Yang Huang, Ryan Rossi, Sungchul Kim, C. Lee Giles, Ting-Hao K. Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is growing interest in systems that generate captions for scientific
figures. However, assessing these systems output poses a significant challenge.
Human evaluation requires academic expertise and is costly, while automatic
evaluation depends on often low-quality author-written captions. This paper
investigates using large language models (LLMs) as a cost-effective,
reference-free method for evaluating figure captions. We first constructed
SCICAP-EVAL, a human evaluation dataset that contains human judgments for 3,600
scientific figure captions, both original and machine-made, for 600 arXiv
figures. We then prompted LLMs like GPT-4 and GPT-3 to score (1-6) each caption
based on its potential to aid reader understanding, given relevant context such
as figure-mentioning paragraphs. Results show that GPT-4, used as a zero-shot
evaluator, outperformed all other models and even surpassed assessments made by
Computer Science and Informatics undergraduates, achieving a Kendall
correlation score of 0.401 with Ph.D. students rankings | [
0.0402114354,
0.0641418248,
-0.0031814228,
0.0244983062,
-0.0278277788,
0.0140869962,
0.0423955247,
0.006606183,
0.0180067923,
-0.0577687696,
-0.0502691232,
-0.0029517096,
0.0370981246,
0.0227673762,
0.0381022245,
-0.07330589,
0.0146622453,
-0.0291368682,
0.0238132067,
-0.0027660707,
0.0177209154,
-0.0187696647,
-0.003982774,
0.0409485996,
0.0165906753,
-0.0368365608,
0.0349326208,
-0.0105718262,
0.0409470834,
-0.0509096645,
-0.0413598493,
0.0965823755,
0.0100302221,
0.0460767001,
0.0000015383,
-0.0358452462,
0.0041543478,
0.0426327623,
0.03802808,
0.0794330537,
0.0826881751,
-0.0168938115,
-0.0093944017,
-0.0486610569,
-0.0194722619,
-0.0161329191,
0.0824268982,
0.0307005886,
0.079550378,
-0.0007673916,
-0.014116317,
-0.0569258071,
-0.0129179182,
-0.0090747569,
0.0013692093,
-0.0341643989,
0.0040232441,
0.0620506778,
-0.0022543392,
0.0608837567,
0.0075124269,
0.060023319,
-0.028937893,
-0.0283062477,
0.0115089752,
0.060747575,
-0.0780373812,
-0.0153778158,
-0.0025557685,
0.0873015672,
0.0504845344,
0.0109996777,
-0.0192561578,
-0.0061176512,
-0.0059364517,
0.0521454215,
-0.0791348889,
-0.0003103987,
0.0218132082,
-0.0232058931,
-0.0276197828,
0.0186075699,
-0.0179259609,
0.0115375677,
0.0092776362,
0.0149321035,
0.0172822755,
-0.0162215997,
-0.0039559929,
0.0066837878,
-0.0801626593,
-0.0405286737,
0.022823235,
-0.0042083384,
0.0498066321,
0.0037864554,
-0.0132326046,
-0.0414154977,
0.0412858836,
-0.0339285508,
-0.0153339272,
-0.0133172506,
-0.0174068268,
0.063362591,
-0.0211890489,
0.0797747895,
0.012077135,
0.0235480797,
0.0016975788,
0.035805244,
-0.0640546307,
-0.0082195802,
-0.006962182,
0.0104351342,
-0.0205239896,
-0.0250137616,
-0.0670129284,
-0.0358761661,
-0.016731862,
0.019338876,
-0.0006287384,
0.0205289517,
-0.014489782,
0.0212855432,
-0.0471996181,
0.0483217314,
0.0127915032,
-0.0102840886,
-0.0366696268,
-0.0165291969,
0.0042922758,
0.0465209559,
0.0346432738,
-0.0158131216,
-0.001035904,
0.0648681894,
0.027205348,
-0.0330851153,
0.0499676466,
-0.0409407578,
-0.0472160876,
-0.045228947,
0.0028919275,
-0.0354288928,
0.003249811,
0.019813627,
0.0309034325,
-0.0487825722,
0.0097085023,
0.0279104821,
-0.0146368258,
0.0855246559,
-0.0021664659,
-0.0016306093,
0.0027693072,
-0.0032773246,
-0.024249047,
0.0151548749,
0.0300574712,
0.0255387258,
0.016408613,
-0.0539821312,
0.0536548309,
0.0205548797,
-0.0094749434,
0.0072709071,
-0.0038226894,
0.0036204786,
-0.0076669911,
0.0471454374,
0.0268456228,
0.0522720963,
-0.0107274102,
0.032454513,
0.066320546,
0.0645747632,
-0.0083596269,
0.0254952647,
0.0145624997,
-0.0071902354,
0.0257183295,
-0.0009579704,
-0.023151705,
0.0643526763,
0.0222663581,
0.0277678818,
0.0122156097,
0.0052140532,
0.0056580775,
-0.0273318458,
-0.0122684455,
0.0175911095,
-0.0172295161,
-0.0358692333,
0.0436501689,
-0.0219982937,
-0.0677983239,
-0.0037404213,
-0.0282123089,
-0.0547250807,
-0.0010784874,
-0.0326576941,
0.0021713208,
0.0733434036,
0.0791190863,
0.0006327481,
-0.0067391866,
-0.004808221,
0.0224265419,
0.0607187226,
0.0189664327,
0.000165367,
-0.0410145409,
-0.026978489,
-0.0235798117,
-0.017786976,
0.011301701,
0.0328743607,
-0.0176254828,
0.0216374621,
0.0329505205,
-0.0276226085,
-0.0953030288,
0.0279947314,
0.026454024,
-0.0432952233,
-0.0483031832,
0.0072292788,
0.0123960888,
0.0167532377,
-0.0377561487,
0.0406568162,
0.0052189189,
-0.0043529966,
0.012339904,
0.0378759503,
0.0061529451,
-0.0358262509,
0.0390402898,
-0.1116012409,
-0.0297356769,
-0.0086603845,
-0.0098278932,
-0.0317128785,
0.0227877405,
-0.057974942,
-0.0192937944,
-0.0406267382,
0.0133459987,
-0.0295390077,
0.0064324155,
-0.0274869874,
0.0454645865,
0.0166859794,
0.0380093306,
0.0629095882,
-0.0575040132,
0.0316709653,
-0.0342928879,
-0.0695594326,
-0.0163778272,
0.052691441,
0.0230389182,
0.0152492905,
0.0455353595,
-0.0300250985,
-0.0110698147,
-0.068418853,
-0.035889782,
0.0203899089,
0.0006762805,
0.0005289622,
-0.0619653575,
0.0152734993,
0.0226110201,
-0.0085695125,
-0.0500351638,
-0.0196167249,
0.0011873971,
0.0678517595,
0.0032850583,
-0.0258433167,
-0.0461711921,
-0.0149846766,
-0.0312872641,
0.0660113692,
0.0967720896,
0.0058848867,
-0.0415680856,
0.0589803383,
-0.0207085125,
-0.0412355401,
0.0177480206,
-0.0327579677,
0.0312485956,
0.0075521693,
-0.0132411812,
0.0414147004,
-0.0087900944,
-0.0116901929,
0.0427610725,
-0.016969705,
-0.0238715094,
-0.0282586701,
0.0010529972,
-0.0560670458,
0.0585195497,
-0.0413176194,
0.0103350822,
0.0156568401,
-0.0320255831,
0.0220279619,
-0.0537631474,
0.0477873646,
-0.0382903777,
-0.0330011733,
-0.0459881388,
0.0150979599,
0.0043405122,
0.0432415232,
0.013424173,
-0.0277387016,
0.0610400513,
-0.0711098313,
-0.0315343812,
-0.0262145139,
0.052753713,
-0.0373323336,
0.0373690352,
0.0197789669,
0.0143698351,
0.0293770861,
-0.0093041752,
-0.0106717367,
0.027711736,
0.0288131889,
-0.0499832444,
0.0239197165,
-0.0547425933,
-0.0051821158,
-0.0281867497,
0.0006353735,
0.0132087953,
-0.0070855087,
-0.0397855602,
-0.0225482713,
-0.0014763197,
-0.0467921309,
-0.031774532,
0.0711388662,
0.0524257608,
0.0007034403,
-0.0286998395,
-0.0079769939,
-0.003631413,
0.0278094709,
0.0575216822,
0.0121414755,
-0.0266980454,
-0.0298469756,
0.0051562604,
0.0032982226,
-0.0128535042,
0.0258077029,
-0.0345328711,
-0.0156868231,
0.0081241019,
0.0139401006,
0.0109171914,
-0.0045441343,
0.055489663,
-0.0318013728,
0.0227032695,
0.092326127,
0.0160446465,
-0.0447261222,
-0.0460592583,
0.0109946039,
0.0021450387,
-0.0046512797,
-0.0120581007,
-0.0669821128,
-0.026710989,
-0.0305410624,
0.0152745657,
-0.0138484091,
-0.0022370496,
-0.0084838346,
-0.0901561975,
0.0709662959,
0.0308970083,
-0.0787662044,
-0.0481383912,
-0.0291062444,
-0.0011020883,
-0.0207736231,
-0.0299781449,
0.0094591202,
0.0031243421,
0.0330748409,
0.0029404005,
-0.0166001711,
-0.054842148,
0.0259525832,
-0.0314251296,
0.0085710771,
0.0356577858,
0.0596158803,
-0.0337049253,
-0.0534322448,
-0.0333132148,
-0.0079558427,
0.0074646603,
0.0087985992,
0.0690957308,
-0.0001781768,
-0.0232855864,
-0.0293418895,
0.0200746916,
-0.0271496531,
-0.000547077,
0.0106892399,
0.0512761101,
0.0218890179,
-0.009186035,
-0.0655833632,
0.0268385597,
-0.0269676056,
0.0608113594,
0.0521383509,
-0.0227933228,
-0.0331816897,
-0.0153406458,
0.040707089,
-0.0660862103,
-0.055768773,
-0.0104777543,
-0.0218530428,
-0.0344595015,
-0.0693227425,
-0.0125319753,
0.0523484424,
-0.0003266778,
0.0420417376,
0.0040057013,
-0.0210430864,
0.045070935,
-0.0364514291,
0.0409403965,
-0.0255481191,
0.0085280193,
-0.0222392008,
-0.0115193054,
0.0616706349,
0.0197275393,
-0.0491397269,
0.0674749091,
0.002250972,
-0.0319183916,
-0.0339412838,
0.0529755764,
0.0256577116,
-0.0441738479,
0.0127942003,
-0.0426051766,
0.0223403722,
0.0788900778,
0.0400963463,
0.015284542,
-0.0183550641,
0.0147128785,
-0.0309264623,
-0.0262476411,
-0.0099772243,
0.0002767889,
-0.0121263387,
0.0119004268,
-0.012327482,
-0.0645439625,
0.0040214569,
0.062094219,
0.0238121655,
-0.0694375038,
0.0172133893,
0.0205779728,
-0.0231359936,
-0.0230348967,
-0.0040491028,
-0.0294397306,
0.0133276964,
0.0238706023,
0.020312354,
-0.0191287752,
0.0166500993,
-0.0470026545,
0.0274207722,
-0.0112294136,
0.0341624208,
0.0517839715,
0.0051840278,
0.0028406084,
-0.0211281925,
-0.0189687982,
-0.060419932,
-0.02916901,
0.032888189,
0.0011679915,
0.0256012138,
0.0200985894,
-0.0041214554,
0.0236157142,
0.0715250224,
-0.0506017916,
0.0010535693,
-0.0464127883,
0.0375020765,
0.052539248,
0.0285839327,
0.0654111728,
-0.0393143184,
-0.0164574534,
-0.0153185222,
0.0407227725,
0.0132762361,
0.0088244928,
0.0375409164,
0.0213054288,
0.0164244324,
-0.029173689,
0.0647806525,
0.0372089818,
0.003061543,
-0.0131067736,
-0.0710059032,
-0.0304631479,
-0.0074699237,
-0.0901683792,
-0.0390709825,
0.0169286747,
0.0080189584,
-0.0898485184,
-0.0610038787,
0.0140738506,
0.0210884642,
0.0026177331,
-0.005268232,
0.0220226552,
0.0187945813,
-0.015598896,
-0.0344128795,
-0.0241094138,
0.0270677824,
-0.0316816866,
-0.0146780657,
-0.0486060642,
-4.767205952e-33,
-0.021977853,
-0.0593887158,
-0.0091216993,
0.0042545549,
-0.0183154307,
0.0066349399,
-0.0680100471,
0.0153978784,
0.0283140168,
0.0161964409,
0.0134561453,
-0.0536917076,
0.0014290563,
-0.0162256621,
0.0163475797,
0.0130985826,
0.0368418433,
-0.0020999485,
-0.041421093,
0.0369679183,
0.0033872428,
-0.0250352602,
0.0334707536,
-0.0660713091,
0.04782084,
-0.0012964435,
-0.0126254559,
-0.0546334758,
0.0477496274,
0.0570392534,
-0.0325079784,
0.0151959006,
0.0142450398,
-0.0427546501,
-0.0068586865,
0.0031452696,
-0.0353577621,
0.015770819,
0.0555003956,
0.0122371875,
0.0061972989,
-0.0279370081,
0.0321431607,
-0.0376009047,
-0.0394805446,
-0.0156711992,
0.0803738311,
-0.0200003367,
0.0023198603,
-0.0095223188,
-0.0332796834,
0.0207948908,
-0.0416551344,
0.0103582069,
0.0446211249,
0.0409330726,
-0.0058647566,
0.085162729,
-0.0278465506,
0.0677906126,
0.039995987,
-0.0050592548,
0.0629177392,
0.0039038027,
0.0472122356,
0.0393151492,
0.0112687871,
0.0059373919,
-0.0263007712,
-0.0191252399,
0.0326074921,
0.0395678841,
0.0905384868,
0.0733800456,
0.0541080646,
0.0004902902,
-0.0268243495,
0.050942637,
-0.0920391083,
0.0354503915,
0.0218451545,
-0.0015973662,
-0.0345640108,
0.0132717947,
-0.043141894,
-0.0313545056,
-0.0388199873,
-0.0403947122,
0.0156081533,
-0.0388379768,
-0.0538044311,
0.0278767124,
0.0359597467,
-0.0318460315,
-0.0427287668,
-0.0263107885,
-0.0082135778,
0.0887598172,
-0.0249026436,
-0.0284648854,
-0.0226472765,
0.0042913533,
0.030852221,
0.0622934923,
0.0639903918,
-0.0210115388,
0.0341922715,
0.0028989192,
-0.0161054619,
-0.0149109839,
-0.0129549606,
-0.0629873723,
-0.035862539,
-0.0101613645,
0.0087628542,
0.0283161364,
-0.0399417505,
-0.022096334,
-0.0150568411,
0.0399950147,
-0.0178992078,
-0.0250447765,
0.0033610209,
0.0103464518,
-0.0371163003,
-0.0163098741,
0.0177031048,
-0.0163688734,
-0.0008346889,
-0.0608747452,
-0.0105545605,
-0.0031393706,
2.272e-7,
0.051600609,
0.059094429,
0.0153438579,
-0.0025507931,
0.0286720656,
0.0360846594,
-0.0422148332,
-0.0170495734,
0.0218212456,
-0.025017662,
0.0340443328,
-0.0104006771,
0.0216628276,
0.0065513728,
-0.0622667968,
-0.0284618586,
-0.0319693461,
-0.0248857792,
-0.034169618,
0.0034590396,
0.0720011517,
0.013681707,
-0.0288656726,
-0.0142101916,
-0.0013101202,
-0.064646028,
0.077005811,
-0.0318052508,
0.0146292197,
0.0088882651,
0.0165200364,
0.0380878858,
-0.0195311215,
0.054003451,
0.0065411897,
-0.0265430324,
0.0957022086,
0.0327801853,
-0.0209798701,
0.0075471886,
-0.0071467585,
0.0311157517,
0.0105632069,
-0.0401195958,
0.0457056053,
-0.0432156771,
-0.0293872878,
-0.0121412296,
-0.0488670729,
-0.0219537262,
0.0519555435,
-0.0294358265,
-0.0355655439,
0.0475778989,
-0.0046373666,
-0.0104242954,
-0.0236852486,
-0.0277356002,
-0.0128283789,
0.007733555,
-0.0269082934,
-0.0613014996,
-0.0409029759,
-0.0397085808,
0.0051084375,
-0.0252990834,
-0.0028230005,
1.791866421e-34,
0.0702663437,
-0.0377640463,
0.0203682892,
0.0146219777,
0.0295732636,
0.0060021533,
-0.0016302388,
-0.0023161995,
0.0090840394,
-0.0712527633,
0.0071184915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15398v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15398v2 | "One-Size-Fits-All"? Examining Expectations around What Constitute "Fair" or "Good" NLG System Behaviors | 2023-10-23T23:00:34 | 2024-04-03T07:20:15 | Li Lucy, Su Lin Blodgett, Milad Shokouhi, Hanna Wallach, Alexandra Olteanu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Fairness-related assumptions about what constitute appropriate NLG system
behaviors range from invariance, where systems are expected to behave
identically for social groups, to adaptation, where behaviors should instead
vary across them. To illuminate tensions around invariance and adaptation, we
conduct five case studies, in which we perturb different types of
identity-related language features (names, roles, locations, dialect, and
style) in NLG system inputs. Through these cases studies, we examine people's
expectations of system behaviors, and surface potential caveats of these
contrasting yet commonly held assumptions. We find that motivations for
adaptation include social norms, cultural differences, feature-specific
information, and accommodation; in contrast, motivations for invariance include
perspectives that favor prescriptivism, view adaptation as unnecessary or too
difficult for NLG systems to do appropriately, and are wary of false
assumptions. Our findings highlight open challenges around what constitute
"fair" or "good" NLG system behaviors. | [
0.0844215751,
0.0695926398,
-0.0258145779,
0.0114833117,
-0.0118094506,
0.0185536705,
0.0440151133,
-0.0179454237,
-0.0222441368,
-0.0595805347,
0.0091086803,
-0.01524489,
0.0395704843,
-0.0111257313,
0.0215418208,
-0.0399030112,
0.0104581248,
0.0156756584,
0.0230626911,
-0.0371283032,
0.0461064763,
0.0593270548,
0.0113673769,
0.0686221048,
-0.0170717519,
0.0323333368,
0.0539406203,
0.0113053909,
-0.0066140085,
-0.0126941679,
0.0198998768,
0.0454827212,
-0.0362174772,
0.0210762285,
0.0000016804,
-0.0920629352,
0.0235416293,
-0.0003567653,
-0.0164795648,
0.0306298099,
0.010213878,
-0.0129785826,
-0.0217825603,
-0.0050333599,
-0.0285141151,
-0.0192582812,
0.071272999,
-0.0079017458,
0.0000775214,
0.0160713252,
-0.0050294991,
-0.0176471192,
-0.0739734545,
0.001261207,
-0.0259312987,
0.000928123,
0.0166411065,
-0.05775382,
0.0018589792,
-0.0478026271,
-0.0079577537,
0.0483333394,
-0.0254490077,
0.0038184277,
0.000034236,
-0.0097714961,
-0.0199043266,
-0.0291044656,
0.0385996886,
0.0510270298,
0.0526015908,
-0.0177579261,
0.0059850174,
-0.0069653131,
0.027256785,
0.0234678611,
-0.007087104,
0.0146843204,
-0.0139719499,
-0.0104493191,
-0.0465497114,
-0.0044205119,
-0.0082133012,
0.0121540828,
-0.0100324107,
0.0895216614,
-0.0027577546,
-0.0200830474,
-0.0627737045,
0.0271945614,
-0.0200843606,
-0.0647083297,
0.0140713211,
0.0136513859,
-0.0124253146,
0.0303676818,
-0.0129469559,
0.0117056174,
0.0387396552,
-0.0067715016,
0.0330716632,
0.0228762496,
0.0021169886,
-0.0152517892,
0.0349655598,
0.0179685429,
0.0176336039,
-0.0045896159,
-0.0115139661,
-0.0120854545,
-0.0274823848,
-0.0169115607,
-0.0114649916,
0.0051964587,
0.0002846429,
0.0723324195,
-0.0039023578,
-0.0088349143,
-0.0310916584,
0.0270546544,
-0.0044992184,
0.0166802648,
-0.0177089833,
-0.0072023394,
-0.0298820939,
0.019781908,
-0.0375974104,
0.0102294153,
-0.0330344178,
-0.0401446149,
0.0474054106,
-0.0356598981,
0.0046507502,
-0.0225264989,
-0.010348076,
0.0379168205,
0.032665085,
-0.0084164161,
-0.0295149647,
-0.0040063681,
-0.036806643,
0.0148619553,
-0.044839751,
-0.0410653651,
-0.0181402713,
0.0729325786,
-0.013268535,
-0.0847486183,
-0.0188507456,
0.0139833745,
-0.0542867258,
0.0373176746,
0.0381214283,
0.0212888792,
0.0395828672,
0.0056315581,
0.0208996627,
0.0412517935,
0.0438855104,
-0.0423786007,
0.0745776892,
-0.0412693955,
0.0314438641,
0.0362412706,
-0.0326781869,
-0.0007531176,
0.0239735376,
0.0079481341,
-0.0182204731,
-0.0193043482,
0.0512419231,
0.0612391867,
0.0373847261,
-0.051479388,
0.0618430041,
0.1167179421,
0.0009485919,
0.0230719652,
0.0031116509,
0.0253740996,
-0.0247782227,
-0.0138242738,
-0.0345863365,
-0.0430214629,
-0.0200744029,
-0.0047690528,
-0.0729581341,
0.0805310309,
-0.0152070168,
-0.0242092889,
-0.0314993598,
0.0234967489,
0.0580605529,
-0.0011446377,
-0.0097244456,
0.044777371,
0.045339454,
0.0308572892,
0.025471,
-0.0699521303,
0.0204492807,
-0.033912912,
0.0000571972,
0.0637911484,
0.0417205095,
0.0195431728,
0.054381188,
-0.0067482148,
0.0112953437,
0.0408011042,
0.0737944916,
0.0071609425,
-0.017413782,
-0.0165621806,
0.0023927591,
0.093825765,
-0.0069519659,
0.0332707576,
-0.0054172748,
0.041218359,
-0.0151564162,
0.030980397,
-0.0591556802,
0.0151404254,
-0.0361508764,
-0.0546485893,
-0.02525164,
0.0036380512,
-0.0185204726,
0.0118075395,
-0.023509685,
0.0018050462,
-0.0507471636,
0.0159100834,
0.0141882412,
0.0936553031,
-0.0520070791,
0.0260191206,
0.0167724174,
-0.0217959415,
0.0119762467,
-0.0053705927,
0.0284613986,
0.0100971777,
0.0494037122,
-0.0173740089,
0.0245676041,
-0.0054906844,
-0.0006755361,
-0.0372253284,
0.0060596671,
-0.0939335749,
-0.0501139536,
0.0121001089,
-0.0270814653,
-0.0429499447,
-0.0212038159,
0.018447319,
-0.0181901213,
-0.0562757142,
0.0718308315,
-0.0189466365,
0.0117947944,
0.023598535,
0.0056594843,
-0.0153834159,
0.0196185932,
-0.0622058176,
-0.0394591205,
0.002957467,
0.0232119076,
0.017571222,
0.0458637699,
-0.0360587426,
-0.022220118,
-0.0117410589,
-0.0663461909,
0.0122553259,
0.0218569525,
0.0363435671,
0.0061087441,
-0.0418214984,
-0.0149854254,
-0.0313544087,
-0.0276828632,
0.0397748202,
-0.0196213871,
-0.0067529408,
-0.0759535953,
-0.0520615652,
-0.0399318337,
0.0040664147,
0.0079642367,
-0.0219900589,
0.0286913123,
0.0700437576,
0.0395137705,
0.023897225,
0.0220125131,
0.0082404399,
-0.0091678882,
0.0077258125,
-0.0329680555,
-0.0360350423,
0.0168290976,
-0.0026929041,
0.0109087555,
-0.0547246374,
0.0020060844,
0.041179169,
0.0193665158,
-0.0202861056,
-0.0390950143,
0.0637173578,
-0.0756339431,
-0.0631946921,
-0.0155925155,
-0.0655078366,
-0.0320207253,
0.0132672861,
-0.0085581709,
0.0038399405,
0.0435375758,
-0.0114919739,
-0.0326697119,
-0.0100612063,
-0.0188048836,
-0.0196426865,
0.0443017483,
-0.0119082285,
0.0460333377,
0.0924206302,
-0.06076717,
-0.0493209437,
-0.019451458,
0.0492540598,
-0.0389272682,
0.0557682067,
-0.0295619722,
-0.0087482678,
0.008864739,
-0.05857585,
-0.0292582009,
-0.0335224979,
-0.0345907286,
-0.0029079881,
0.0392262861,
-0.0420610234,
0.0336749814,
0.0155295385,
0.0502162017,
-0.005003734,
-0.0076176445,
-0.0014058584,
0.0113450522,
-0.0297964737,
0.0006346407,
0.061185468,
0.0144699132,
0.0545468777,
-0.021829769,
0.0023908687,
0.004728463,
0.006680829,
0.0606734119,
0.0090139937,
0.0619740002,
-0.0486521721,
-0.0497562699,
0.0128227323,
0.0709288567,
-0.0111848805,
0.0263899732,
0.0592894666,
0.0012865493,
-0.0167614706,
0.0292210877,
-0.0406732112,
0.0620075539,
0.0153443785,
0.0237446278,
-0.0774795189,
0.0212258268,
-0.0079198163,
0.0486321412,
-0.0477719903,
-0.0312325973,
-0.0234788638,
-0.0506626666,
-0.0078351591,
0.0376548357,
-0.0439486392,
-0.0212178845,
0.0227381736,
0.0283562541,
-0.0193246752,
0.0525241196,
0.0116364416,
-0.0422089696,
0.0132006416,
0.0500254259,
-0.1008851007,
-0.0150896255,
-0.0166666675,
-0.051258605,
0.0268381275,
0.0442473181,
-0.0071778097,
0.0114430394,
-0.0759019703,
-0.0087331822,
-0.0340033099,
0.0223457292,
-0.0238448232,
-0.0015740914,
-0.0123562813,
0.0013169772,
-0.0615442209,
-0.0212466493,
-0.0237100236,
0.0008972932,
-0.0070546465,
0.0149118649,
0.0089742169,
-0.0433021784,
-0.0262765791,
-0.024577776,
0.0148953628,
0.0811893567,
0.0404813401,
-0.0765501857,
0.0048886389,
-0.0592874289,
-0.0094681364,
-0.0034252184,
-0.0999010354,
0.0258088466,
0.0048866123,
-0.0295989718,
-0.0502857752,
-0.0782192796,
-0.0128660258,
0.0282953512,
0.0392171331,
-0.0485256314,
0.023828648,
-0.0004539918,
-0.0278627686,
0.0193769503,
-0.0565153733,
0.0108744213,
0.0126759419,
-0.0220795572,
0.01337888,
0.0069107153,
0.0046325028,
-0.0060350429,
0.053992752,
-0.0658706799,
0.0825225562,
-0.0192934386,
0.0304233376,
0.0389252193,
-0.0050240867,
-0.0737722218,
0.0132432887,
0.0518726148,
0.0428740159,
0.0464642197,
0.0469981842,
-0.0034355458,
-0.0077995164,
0.005219379,
-0.0026067835,
0.0211869404,
0.0336021073,
0.0062540085,
-0.0344935842,
-0.0463139117,
-0.0074787615,
0.0534548722,
-0.0219097771,
-0.0508917086,
-0.0125407502,
0.0104129184,
-0.0429582186,
0.010235508,
0.0053402795,
-0.0040204497,
-0.0644785985,
-0.0072240648,
0.0335491262,
-0.0274500512,
0.0375803113,
-0.0432721674,
0.0303839184,
-0.0270217303,
0.0253365338,
-0.0121146794,
0.0716067851,
0.0139800841,
0.0297977868,
-0.0085965972,
0.0214455333,
0.0041444451,
0.0279710516,
-0.0103032114,
0.0385755077,
0.0137126809,
-0.0135282222,
-0.0424211137,
0.0466943718,
-0.0224534217,
-0.0222024117,
0.0027212002,
-0.0215915274,
0.018351851,
-0.0478734896,
0.0548376963,
0.0203244202,
0.0312764905,
0.0101683689,
0.0091954153,
0.0184761044,
0.0205868967,
-0.0008237794,
0.0039347913,
-0.0397961177,
-0.0129107526,
0.0183888096,
-0.0175620243,
0.0367126204,
-0.0568326488,
0.0045241318,
-0.01287481,
-0.014808421,
0.0209060442,
-0.0089004189,
-0.0288980212,
-0.0461016372,
-0.1255709678,
-0.0482853241,
-0.0456512384,
-0.0239557978,
0.0374561884,
-0.0156225571,
0.018385563,
0.0148389479,
0.0001974746,
-0.0534230061,
0.0095069651,
-0.0051794806,
-0.0300711803,
-0.0204761121,
0.0215603523,
-5.536464516e-33,
-0.0055939578,
-0.0226959176,
-0.0088006789,
0.0128158387,
-0.0053716018,
-0.0626418665,
0.0021593471,
0.0447941944,
-0.0182425156,
-0.0102030495,
-0.0486601554,
-0.0272432193,
0.0156255569,
0.0006357398,
0.0268949233,
-0.0157779083,
0.0421277806,
0.0234688502,
-0.0423780158,
-0.0188048426,
0.0370147862,
-0.0122520179,
0.0803418905,
-0.1040131748,
0.0503203943,
0.0011507929,
-0.0171647612,
-0.0177897401,
0.0081028426,
0.0224283133,
0.0063732746,
0.0717579499,
0.0198169909,
-0.0201073792,
-0.0113851,
0.0659927353,
-0.0501229912,
-0.0184399951,
0.0326438062,
0.0545386076,
0.053160239,
-0.0423488505,
0.0436069071,
-0.0215344355,
-0.0818452984,
0.0576133691,
0.0284675937,
0.004143469,
0.0552481152,
0.0414159223,
-0.0381225459,
-0.0112050865,
0.0024026427,
0.0497932099,
-0.0077723465,
0.0170785431,
0.0211977139,
-0.0236101355,
-0.0299805123,
-0.0057169609,
-0.0365267061,
-0.0194626227,
0.0855582878,
0.0290241074,
0.00367216,
0.0292647406,
0.031726446,
0.0695993602,
-0.0406068861,
-0.0383354314,
0.0589324571,
-0.0312621109,
0.012075413,
0.0662524775,
-0.0064546331,
-0.0679812208,
0.019988399,
-0.001117164,
-0.0021552881,
-0.0422284193,
-0.0013351535,
0.027141951,
-0.1012374759,
-0.0581399426,
-0.0071402062,
-0.0543132387,
0.0020998879,
-0.0571165085,
0.021217389,
-0.0574605875,
-0.0170765817,
0.0369729996,
0.017153604,
-0.019057136,
-0.0693935975,
-0.0160265733,
-0.0136064021,
-0.0204536244,
0.0183457974,
-0.0382133387,
-0.0397085734,
0.0145791043,
-0.0137215527,
0.0464276522,
0.0238430258,
0.0160400718,
0.0222042128,
0.0149359526,
-0.0701755658,
-0.0015770937,
0.0367667861,
0.0717190057,
0.0085990718,
-0.0539451167,
0.0140386336,
0.0044818227,
0.0049583558,
-0.0285431836,
0.0787390694,
-0.0534630157,
-0.0558404475,
0.0181573946,
-0.0283013061,
0.0028724656,
-0.0345067158,
-0.0246364307,
-0.0009440331,
0.0474281497,
0.0846217498,
0.0179310832,
-0.0207936987,
-0.0658787265,
2.364e-7,
0.0227065329,
0.0522468947,
-0.0028409616,
-0.0346038043,
0.0280420873,
0.0307621602,
0.0354927033,
0.0404716097,
0.0387523323,
-0.0033529892,
-0.0045392332,
-0.0067575872,
-0.0110501805,
0.0356606953,
-0.0454396605,
-0.0391367339,
-0.0403264314,
0.0645250753,
-0.0331188366,
0.0471760705,
0.0366636142,
0.0072342395,
0.026412569,
0.0014616757,
-0.0539400913,
-0.0576826297,
-0.0194980353,
-0.0464536548,
0.0466216914,
0.011610046,
0.052748125,
-0.0284057185,
0.0684116408,
0.001846681,
0.0254167728,
0.0004589572,
0.0004265583,
0.0258018021,
-0.0263686609,
0.0116273826,
-0.0419667773,
-0.0045679733,
0.0056225979,
-0.0678900704,
0.0176490359,
0.0091771586,
-0.0264915191,
-0.0297360029,
-0.0054977001,
-0.0360545553,
-0.0084713902,
0.0203561373,
-0.0287586655,
0.0149245532,
0.0370221995,
0.014532689,
-0.0078861918,
-0.0512855798,
-0.0273339003,
0.0404514298,
0.0380029157,
-0.0408664681,
0.0135219255,
0.040819943,
-0.0316203721,
-0.0111141466,
0.0299106464,
1.716736605e-34,
-0.0367112234,
0.0151619092,
0.0431111269,
-0.007202758,
0.0257688705,
0.0259830579,
0.0043404228,
0.0054005054,
0.03567525,
-0.0025225123,
-0.0267941616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15393v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15393v2 | DoGE: Domain Reweighting with Generalization Estimation | 2023-10-23T22:51:58 | 2024-02-05T16:33:05 | Simin Fan, Matteo Pagliardini, Martin Jaggi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The coverage and composition of the pretraining data significantly impacts
the generalization ability of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite its
importance, recent LLMs still rely on heuristics and trial and error to
increase or reduce the influence of data-domains. We propose DOmain reweighting
with Generalization Estimation (DoGE), which optimizes the probability of
sampling from each domain (domain weights) in a principled way. Our approach is
a two-stage process consisting of (i) training a proxy model to obtain domain
weights using a bi-level optimization algorithm; (ii) training a larger base
model by sampling training domains according to the learned domain weights. In
our experiments, we extensively show how DoGE improves the generalization of
the base model to any target data mixture. On the SlimPajama dataset, our base
model gets better perplexity and few-shot reasoning accuracies across $6$ tasks
compared to baseline methods. Moreover, aiming to generalize to out-of-domain
target tasks, which is unseen in the pretraining corpus (OOD domain), DoGE can
effectively identify inter-domain dependencies, and consistently achieves
better test perplexity on the target domain. | [
0.0287971944,
0.0572905056,
-0.006573061,
0.0152377672,
-0.0090200342,
0.040619269,
0.004691524,
0.0027599575,
-0.0200433917,
-0.0430699848,
-0.0572627001,
-0.0359683596,
-0.0241697002,
-0.0052740993,
0.0332097784,
-0.0558232404,
0.0120725706,
-0.0161294118,
-0.0332092047,
-0.0073881485,
-0.0100671509,
0.0306129213,
-0.0267360713,
0.0292817075,
0.0107224071,
-0.0074931411,
-0.0115786595,
0.0163102373,
0.0025550155,
-0.0307508446,
0.004536239,
0.0497641824,
0.0559623055,
0.0120754568,
0.0000021042,
-0.0535963401,
-0.0221168455,
-0.0014978403,
-0.0200335961,
-0.0154839568,
0.0242547244,
-0.0369271263,
0.0381032452,
0.0229323525,
-0.0268914625,
-0.0804462954,
0.0338426381,
0.0564747937,
0.0410739221,
0.0949900821,
-0.0104368078,
-0.0648357347,
-0.0079254247,
-0.0518355966,
-0.0081177484,
-0.0870484263,
0.0199582353,
0.0527465232,
0.00197113,
-0.0243219957,
-0.0224169735,
-0.0004643835,
0.0369210131,
0.0233421568,
-0.037062265,
0.0072571347,
0.0025730862,
-0.019816231,
0.0289291684,
0.0891010612,
-0.0141294654,
-0.0189260505,
0.0012444486,
0.004864892,
0.0117545119,
0.026193168,
-0.0321766697,
0.0038010094,
0.0130929509,
0.0172615685,
-0.0002527331,
-0.0067209741,
0.0528789759,
-0.0045678206,
-0.0735817254,
0.0679190457,
0.0153206773,
-0.0034450786,
0.0337966308,
0.0396404676,
-0.0877525657,
-0.0329501145,
0.0056342632,
0.0285644699,
-0.0530808941,
0.0187651031,
-0.0486971699,
-0.0554610007,
-0.0056042708,
0.0319571607,
0.0514445677,
0.02415202,
-0.0271813609,
0.0565561503,
0.0095074531,
0.0316379741,
-0.0406141728,
0.0188863035,
-0.0543825179,
-0.0186864231,
-0.0709861219,
-0.0122784264,
-0.0364406146,
0.0497276075,
-0.0055715721,
-0.0139525468,
-0.0264616124,
0.0068842634,
-0.0048491391,
-0.0457495861,
0.045177862,
-0.004694365,
-0.040876355,
-0.0397384949,
0.0099758524,
0.0375881344,
-0.0611162372,
0.0803180411,
0.0176731516,
-0.0295862369,
-0.0242083967,
-0.000546522,
0.0036459491,
-0.0481084511,
0.0152053293,
0.0698372573,
-0.002258972,
-0.0379209407,
-0.0479467623,
-0.0062785069,
-0.005545306,
-0.0858721435,
-0.0060477727,
-0.0362662785,
0.0310271084,
0.0025334712,
0.0152753983,
-0.0402058214,
-0.0119219376,
0.0093134372,
-0.0071901381,
0.0741869658,
0.0062563471,
0.024041554,
0.0175738465,
0.0040871049,
-0.020054739,
0.0988826007,
-0.0029016708,
-0.0296790674,
0.0108135054,
0.0140147153,
0.0091185011,
0.0355704799,
0.0259232353,
0.0124684134,
0.0239306167,
-0.0021412086,
-0.0023898922,
0.0050590253,
0.0539160371,
0.0007036704,
-0.0558867343,
-0.0041866107,
0.0239647608,
0.0149087524,
0.0217636023,
-0.0252312124,
0.0583333299,
0.0044587781,
0.0006897964,
0.0438878462,
-0.0615625679,
-0.0250236616,
0.0019361521,
-0.0026993505,
0.0092305494,
0.0182074588,
-0.0579381846,
-0.0106736002,
0.0126307374,
-0.0277948324,
0.0096499184,
0.0356596336,
0.1100240499,
0.0715236515,
-0.0134937111,
0.06296435,
0.060166046,
-0.0308279917,
0.0121942991,
-0.0237107575,
0.006981696,
-0.004494458,
0.0020355307,
-0.0439701527,
-0.0064643049,
-0.0002272464,
0.0840737298,
0.0040257629,
0.015978422,
-0.0100607574,
0.0541602112,
-0.0419536941,
-0.0232053027,
-0.0298803356,
0.0321951769,
0.0266732946,
0.0495436005,
-0.0140022701,
0.0377487093,
-0.093976289,
0.0270613171,
0.0371808968,
-0.05162628,
-0.0225670356,
0.0259023272,
0.0169425756,
0.0462981686,
-0.0005548019,
-0.0283345804,
-0.0007705758,
-0.010614546,
-0.0498504043,
-0.0216374937,
-0.0140795754,
-0.0086160814,
-0.0468925387,
0.0417743623,
-0.0424203984,
-0.0073721292,
0.0514477715,
-0.053934671,
-0.034607362,
0.0304515641,
0.0119333286,
0.0387945212,
-0.0386716835,
0.0267752744,
-0.0178733356,
0.0151003441,
-0.0593288913,
0.0481620096,
0.0214569755,
-0.0082632974,
-0.0213901699,
0.0110019958,
0.0426111184,
-0.02585526,
-0.0339735858,
-0.0257426891,
-0.0336774476,
0.0136421118,
0.0024267968,
-0.0074773929,
-0.0324729159,
0.0006409989,
-0.0870354772,
-0.0014886347,
-0.0273611955,
0.0109057417,
-0.000694849,
0.0436043441,
-0.0003390961,
-0.0370333232,
-0.0045887632,
-0.0234875884,
-0.0150860688,
0.0246838499,
0.0001940593,
0.0003619702,
0.0140651669,
-0.0111986184,
-0.0188918579,
-0.0152720325,
0.0653649718,
-0.0259472392,
0.0237083863,
-0.0752510205,
0.0771965832,
-0.026104752,
0.0266818572,
-0.0189963486,
-0.0040891427,
-0.0083425771,
-0.0127321146,
0.0017023813,
0.0727984011,
-0.0420814529,
-0.01909885,
0.0483150259,
0.0302653555,
-0.0370401666,
0.0164146535,
-0.0297145825,
-0.0215575397,
-0.0351756811,
0.0119933877,
0.0109221358,
0.0713835955,
-0.0171903484,
-0.0150513966,
-0.0421409421,
-0.0022066105,
-0.0254190098,
-0.020660786,
-0.0261158645,
0.0158909913,
0.0020668046,
0.0428317264,
-0.0219794214,
-0.0268435087,
0.0753642619,
-0.0102700498,
-0.0043392684,
-0.0739955232,
-0.0072008232,
-0.0472143702,
0.0522681363,
-0.0110382168,
-0.0000700124,
0.0424901173,
-0.0450645983,
-0.0781737193,
0.0000525283,
0.0061330502,
-0.0050315126,
0.0757468864,
-0.0530296713,
0.0325961933,
-0.0026925213,
-0.0742816254,
-0.0236338153,
-0.0095121823,
-0.0558702722,
-0.0162339546,
-0.0349588729,
-0.0084246481,
-0.0590358004,
0.0030165352,
0.0197302736,
0.0342223532,
-0.0152155021,
0.0108348224,
-0.0166171417,
0.0311367307,
0.0452786945,
0.0069379713,
-0.010638915,
-0.0270848237,
0.0015475119,
0.0146620534,
0.011705745,
-0.0106484331,
-0.0338570811,
0.014471963,
0.0244335141,
-0.0022605532,
-0.0192825347,
-0.0057183057,
0.0453026034,
-0.0161596052,
-0.0067834812,
0.1122241691,
0.0174860414,
-0.0520836301,
0.0098291347,
0.0029476234,
0.0065439879,
0.0417837165,
0.0545378029,
-0.089248009,
-0.0777911022,
0.0165017676,
-0.018367948,
0.034580417,
-0.0130317872,
0.0121096773,
-0.159733206,
0.0041645011,
-0.0123309344,
-0.0163608659,
-0.0110032223,
-0.0390640087,
0.0003640683,
-0.0101189055,
0.0346108712,
-0.0082502272,
0.0118738087,
-0.0034146286,
0.031134706,
0.0097742761,
-0.0502056815,
0.0191599522,
-0.0570886582,
0.0100988345,
0.0662030876,
0.0007505013,
0.0069169323,
0.007983801,
0.0455449559,
0.0014156962,
-0.0035620362,
0.0054713967,
0.0586662926,
0.0151397903,
-0.0337663554,
0.0192553177,
0.0397039428,
-0.0574709214,
-0.0120879207,
0.0203520078,
0.0613657385,
0.0003083194,
-0.003269837,
-0.0121384198,
-0.0241196323,
-0.0063360929,
0.0427093729,
0.0216141529,
-0.0586628169,
-0.000694197,
-0.0063542444,
-0.026288975,
-0.0472187027,
-0.0056231469,
0.0080571668,
-0.002829347,
-0.026236508,
-0.0521284491,
0.0198868122,
0.0461924076,
0.0737781972,
0.0192057062,
0.0044516264,
0.0027267996,
0.0147970226,
-0.045916453,
0.0348256752,
-0.0558318198,
0.0300654788,
-0.0414557643,
-0.0062030428,
0.0455362797,
-0.0237117354,
-0.0414021164,
-0.0019682019,
-0.0595797449,
-0.0639091507,
-0.0291383658,
0.0215941612,
0.02586901,
0.0457622483,
-0.0419795029,
-0.0523415767,
0.0350468084,
-0.0119540589,
-0.034754727,
0.025882788,
0.0301507544,
-0.0542915463,
0.0201514792,
0.0509270765,
-0.0725038126,
0.0264955256,
0.0560875013,
0.0184085593,
0.0110852551,
0.0335482769,
0.00442447,
-0.0083912816,
0.0580784343,
0.0046942648,
0.0097585665,
-0.0155567694,
0.0198761877,
-0.0071186158,
-0.0211835057,
-0.0565855652,
0.0288891103,
0.0557549968,
0.0085389707,
0.0154755926,
-0.0114436317,
-0.0241337344,
0.047037892,
-0.0119952811,
-0.0092348363,
-0.0073286248,
0.0252382122,
0.0489901975,
0.0047404869,
0.0230891332,
0.0050783688,
0.0202752519,
0.0007509217,
-0.013511057,
0.0193724036,
0.0235579684,
0.0167416353,
-0.0630359203,
0.0002630406,
-0.0525753461,
-0.0032254527,
-0.0078954985,
-0.0030242831,
0.0750617981,
-0.0264538098,
0.0294248704,
0.0210082512,
-0.0132990284,
-0.0170161054,
0.0329783149,
-0.014565533,
-0.0138408551,
0.0302822758,
0.0106119001,
-0.019873362,
0.0217206348,
0.1183789521,
0.0307242014,
0.0502824932,
0.0080121364,
0.01355159,
-0.0199061222,
-0.0357933193,
0.0154849682,
0.0570518263,
-0.0441679321,
0.017555872,
-0.0237701051,
-0.1040070057,
-0.0096361414,
-0.0426510051,
-0.0431535766,
0.0114160609,
0.0283071268,
0.063995108,
-0.0051090838,
-0.0239298642,
-0.0159916487,
-0.0399560481,
-0.0138500249,
-0.0376386084,
0.0152515136,
-6.379355679e-33,
0.0095887287,
0.0189450905,
0.0120994737,
-0.008438345,
-0.0165712126,
-0.0024551835,
-0.0257591773,
0.0239551757,
-0.0327210166,
0.0236649066,
-0.0226337053,
0.0292386618,
0.0174445286,
0.0329332724,
0.0067534884,
-0.0135802347,
0.0287288092,
0.0073641646,
-0.0121313147,
0.0046201195,
-0.0015339804,
0.0486767553,
0.0648151413,
-0.061004661,
-0.0224447791,
0.0252755415,
-0.0167317782,
0.0302348491,
0.0139742512,
0.0405787267,
0.0011502664,
0.0198177397,
0.0286665056,
-0.0543811247,
-0.0231583379,
0.0030418364,
-0.0780041367,
-0.0133040566,
0.0353885219,
0.0183416922,
0.0093921311,
-0.0309503097,
0.013244994,
0.0012121381,
0.019167481,
-0.0367564522,
0.014704816,
-0.0294028111,
-0.0236318037,
0.0035271135,
-0.0388236567,
0.0108617702,
0.0040688179,
-0.0279854033,
0.0004397132,
0.0263441484,
-0.0117749432,
0.0239473227,
-0.0157221667,
0.0141648296,
-0.0009528709,
0.0182777569,
0.0255564302,
0.0328043103,
0.0064885225,
0.044538036,
0.0071493019,
-0.0144504309,
-0.0108281719,
-0.0170330778,
0.0323338024,
0.0457521789,
-0.013175874,
0.0641838908,
0.0594670512,
-0.0113995057,
-0.1109918505,
0.0056578559,
-0.0098026693,
0.0265442338,
0.0275556482,
0.01885348,
-0.0080562914,
-0.0278911721,
-0.0440453552,
0.0121374726,
-0.0340298302,
-0.0436286107,
0.0277592652,
0.0189422201,
-0.0169949103,
0.0110342419,
0.0306402575,
-0.0773887932,
-0.0305452216,
0.0088473745,
-0.0067053242,
0.0122788642,
-0.0065800427,
0.0081709316,
-0.0172568839,
-0.0528364629,
0.0232507493,
0.0254969224,
0.0284237806,
-0.0121144252,
0.0682655498,
-0.0118499566,
-0.0529258847,
-0.0251007564,
-0.0306378379,
-0.0167405009,
0.0240165554,
0.1062756777,
0.0243139639,
0.0392000526,
-0.0104840882,
0.0440638587,
0.0209941864,
-0.0497857146,
-0.0313365497,
0.0061392924,
0.0242029298,
0.0250206273,
-0.0335949324,
-0.0345585681,
-0.0110115781,
-0.0443422124,
0.0503123142,
-0.0560900122,
-0.0358803533,
-0.0039318283,
2.841e-7,
0.0545723028,
0.0077768001,
-0.0125223249,
0.0076396172,
0.0010076145,
0.0340927057,
-0.0171379261,
0.0263792686,
0.0140942521,
-0.0182000026,
0.0003769578,
0.0438945331,
0.0574487709,
0.0053203818,
-0.1424241215,
0.0118403193,
0.0242968481,
-0.0163632948,
-0.0241124071,
-0.0179420989,
-0.0177798532,
0.1451448053,
0.0374783687,
-0.0362861119,
0.008468356,
-0.0604058355,
0.0717319623,
-0.0015634821,
0.002087154,
0.0262683239,
-0.0266608857,
0.0447638668,
0.0251767803,
0.0348537639,
-0.0123595893,
0.0478615165,
0.0245852023,
0.0484954529,
0.0067256168,
0.0158472732,
-0.0165384673,
-0.0103360983,
0.0127455313,
-0.0200990308,
0.0853269175,
-0.084888339,
-0.0535867102,
-0.020735357,
-0.0074070334,
-0.0369824693,
-0.0101796901,
-0.00545651,
0.0289618596,
0.0355850086,
0.0393139236,
-0.0080768997,
-0.0251138136,
-0.0941819176,
-0.0309084598,
0.0009647071,
-0.0632489994,
-0.0231770296,
-0.0095060049,
-0.044567056,
0.0518207066,
-0.0784748048,
0.0393159501,
2.648608489e-34,
0.0395413898,
-0.0013186266,
0.0167441163,
0.0468020812,
0.0363386013,
-0.0411031283,
-0.0270635709,
-0.0106261009,
0.0070778816,
-0.0791741088,
0.0256341398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15389v1 | Irreducible Curriculum for Language Model Pretraining | 2023-10-23T22:41:33 | 2023-10-23T22:41:33 | Simin Fan, Martin Jaggi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Automatic data selection and curriculum design for training large language
models is challenging, with only a few existing methods showing improvements
over standard training. Furthermore, current schemes focus on domain-level
selection, overlooking the more fine-grained contributions of each individual
training point. It is difficult to apply traditional datapoint selection
methods on large language models: most online batch selection methods perform
two-times forward or backward passes, which introduces considerable extra costs
with large-scale models. To mitigate these obstacles, we propose irreducible
curriculum as a curriculum learning algorithm for language model pretraining,
which prioritizes samples with higher learnability. Specifically, to avoid
prohibitive extra computation overhead, we simulate the sample loss along the
main model's training trajectory using a small-scale proxy model. Our
experiments on the RedPajama-1B dataset demonstrate a consistent improvement on
validation perplexity across all 7 domains compared to random uniform baseline
and the anti-curriculum strategy. Our method also reduces the sharpness of the
network and illustrates a better 5-shot accuracy on MMLU benchmarks. | [
0.0061375662,
0.0753547922,
-0.0224014726,
0.0300930478,
-0.0366773456,
0.0448977649,
0.0500071235,
-0.0276108515,
-0.0330202915,
-0.0493491925,
-0.0376124047,
-0.0336026996,
-0.0165711325,
-0.0233285315,
0.0366114378,
-0.0528013892,
0.0292227082,
-0.0407582782,
-0.0108693829,
-0.0261278767,
-0.0207066126,
0.0398198552,
-0.0309174228,
0.0270857271,
0.0045509264,
-0.0305689275,
0.0059452588,
0.0091548655,
-0.0126037495,
-0.0474829301,
0.0519427992,
0.0679493472,
0.0225028265,
0.0276625287,
0.0000024038,
-0.0575613379,
-0.0248296801,
-0.0084186643,
-0.0447028391,
0.0252879728,
0.0575954057,
0.0474311002,
-0.0031745746,
0.0390130915,
-0.0077455454,
-0.0043426044,
0.0644413903,
0.0013167819,
0.0503609888,
0.0583885461,
-0.0032589021,
-0.0547677279,
-0.008100275,
-0.0316834971,
-0.053660199,
-0.0305454042,
0.042239476,
0.046954941,
-0.0190431811,
0.0061750752,
-0.0453007296,
0.0010406577,
0.0099781081,
-0.017414134,
-0.0040466911,
0.0269075166,
-0.0383050591,
-0.0349275172,
0.0193841718,
0.0726093426,
-0.0388067812,
-0.052214276,
-0.0025795414,
-0.0285785738,
-0.0269324612,
-0.031814266,
-0.0276131276,
-0.0009778354,
0.0229398813,
0.0481927022,
0.0337031856,
-0.0149594191,
0.030900253,
0.0250538159,
-0.020311052,
-0.0104572959,
0.044070974,
-0.0157283265,
0.0515796468,
0.0292481314,
-0.0391908213,
-0.015121283,
-0.0088190259,
0.017198123,
-0.044929605,
0.0263957698,
-0.0336698331,
-0.0360729136,
0.0110444026,
0.0040523503,
0.0616006702,
0.0149305081,
-0.0201991666,
0.0652924627,
0.0058999304,
0.0464371555,
0.00871218,
0.0724885613,
-0.0310917664,
0.0121300779,
-0.0250041876,
-0.003078443,
-0.0397892594,
-0.0116917016,
0.014025881,
0.0219630525,
-0.0375245214,
-0.0140440483,
-0.0225531235,
-0.0259641558,
0.0541807674,
-0.0341334902,
-0.0769745708,
0.0022426513,
0.0226930771,
0.0614862032,
-0.0358868688,
0.0281534437,
-0.0094379066,
-0.0523350015,
-0.0131183984,
0.0012892198,
-0.0129821394,
-0.0233005472,
0.0328718089,
0.0571197383,
-0.0020536731,
-0.0417210013,
-0.0678638071,
0.0198040698,
-0.0109782983,
-0.0841444358,
0.0307884831,
-0.0751419365,
0.0093041444,
-0.0180506688,
0.0158897694,
-0.0447008237,
-0.0157808326,
-0.0093563013,
0.0167896226,
0.0400723256,
-0.0315441079,
-0.0004179622,
0.0270436816,
-0.0139914053,
0.0266376622,
0.0989271626,
0.0094577279,
-0.0114728799,
0.0383919366,
-0.0216750242,
-0.0206693169,
0.0552141815,
0.0417079702,
0.0159316529,
-0.0522399843,
-0.0061903507,
0.037732888,
0.0141078737,
0.0582676493,
0.0072111799,
-0.0379883461,
-0.0069162319,
0.0289012752,
0.039380122,
0.0303059183,
0.0044016223,
0.0297791827,
0.0338285118,
0.0397741087,
-0.0096388226,
-0.020783538,
-0.0171369705,
0.0427212901,
-0.0185436849,
0.0027296836,
0.0275938772,
-0.0556533486,
-0.034979552,
0.0316333473,
-0.0073588365,
-0.0183781739,
0.0043025478,
0.0785080269,
0.0274216998,
-0.026545791,
0.0124631375,
0.1005695462,
-0.0251906123,
0.0369752273,
-0.0206678919,
-0.000687405,
0.0196120366,
0.0322028287,
-0.040683113,
-0.051799424,
-0.0186844971,
0.0556585006,
0.0213761516,
0.0488210768,
-0.0363205113,
0.0292164609,
-0.0718304217,
-0.0274910778,
0.0004350125,
0.038928017,
0.0334066339,
0.0115748802,
-0.0095448941,
-0.0024023177,
-0.0279347692,
-0.0522869863,
0.0614722259,
-0.0681411028,
-0.0476484261,
-0.0151754869,
0.0211894438,
0.0380568542,
-0.0119605726,
-0.0153605957,
-0.0415826403,
0.0150500583,
-0.0051233121,
0.0478092805,
-0.016163554,
-0.0659427494,
-0.053834483,
0.0618086495,
-0.0053366041,
-0.0241839383,
0.0892802775,
-0.0605480336,
-0.0322070383,
0.0048328964,
0.0089267241,
0.0276277475,
-0.044214543,
0.0486061797,
-0.037263833,
0.0136971492,
-0.0615552962,
0.0188459735,
0.0213576015,
0.0130706867,
-0.0016609263,
0.0074235834,
0.0202297214,
-0.0401856713,
-0.0288111158,
0.002571149,
-0.0148005094,
0.0477945656,
-0.0199171193,
0.0179181211,
-0.0515390523,
-0.0176599678,
-0.0659435093,
-0.0240668654,
-0.0483287126,
0.0067823231,
0.0042843916,
-0.0019911602,
-0.0091930702,
-0.0259056296,
-0.0010315038,
0.014706756,
-0.0359032229,
0.017482806,
0.0139962006,
-0.0012576181,
-0.0091417041,
-0.037543647,
-0.0523293652,
0.0044778329,
0.0891539007,
0.0098432703,
0.0488030799,
-0.0587297343,
0.0370234735,
-0.0163464136,
0.0113404384,
-0.0196519941,
-0.0489136055,
-0.0152168255,
-0.0246614404,
-0.0173981953,
0.0562326685,
-0.002490466,
0.0211643968,
0.0475999601,
0.0135127716,
-0.0522347279,
0.0032711967,
-0.0217885934,
-0.0401911624,
-0.0307409465,
0.0224092323,
-0.012998974,
0.0462004654,
-0.0292231347,
-0.0149169704,
-0.0399928391,
-0.0149859646,
-0.0288815368,
-0.0048158588,
-0.0443265848,
0.0269955173,
-0.0223210156,
0.0184691213,
-0.0147195309,
-0.0372997522,
0.0548199527,
-0.0295050479,
0.0040369136,
-0.0754738674,
0.0074256966,
-0.0121421609,
0.0043628165,
0.0037566104,
-0.0062126601,
0.0194803812,
-0.0286613554,
-0.0731942058,
-0.0023918913,
0.0274017081,
-0.019848749,
0.018756913,
-0.0658924431,
0.0071629095,
0.0074667861,
-0.0183483288,
-0.028637005,
0.000422761,
-0.0077570169,
0.0152138695,
0.0038985747,
0.0285516549,
0.0051656631,
-0.0246272534,
-0.0305452049,
0.0717709884,
-0.0100371111,
0.0190716218,
-0.0013714895,
0.0158025213,
0.0379831344,
0.0054522147,
0.0003667781,
-0.0496525392,
0.0191377364,
0.0189931896,
0.0716895014,
-0.0180234611,
-0.0328508504,
0.027391063,
0.037284933,
-0.0216221735,
-0.0090532331,
0.0262256302,
0.023524493,
-0.0565202869,
-0.0316924043,
0.0950699374,
0.0034789201,
-0.0709978119,
-0.0103236251,
0.0107684555,
0.0490590408,
0.0326509289,
0.0401296355,
-0.0500102602,
-0.02235852,
-0.0009667801,
0.0367022119,
0.0330068916,
-0.0079055522,
-0.0254209954,
-0.1004893705,
0.0249194056,
0.0154396156,
-0.0410811529,
0.0271878205,
-0.0725816339,
-0.0119349761,
-0.0377069563,
0.0564232394,
0.0154192355,
-0.0165411644,
-0.0168191697,
0.0529562719,
0.003632623,
-0.0786642358,
0.0461730324,
-0.0415439866,
0.0521081723,
0.0285770129,
0.0304565895,
-0.0206945799,
-0.0034357142,
0.0659171045,
-0.0442603603,
-0.0222681314,
0.0008863243,
0.0681418478,
0.0095065832,
-0.0381607972,
0.0347148404,
0.0290833283,
-0.0100191543,
0.008472994,
0.0109147727,
0.0833145678,
0.0136809135,
-0.0054870932,
0.0237322841,
-0.0244940091,
0.0313720033,
0.0430642925,
0.0324980319,
-0.0818002969,
-0.0229908023,
-0.0007819578,
-0.0176664796,
-0.0367792323,
-0.0387714058,
0.0231215786,
-0.0118376976,
-0.0603625812,
-0.0395855717,
-0.0202587619,
0.0449770875,
0.0741633996,
0.0124857081,
-0.0085365484,
0.0273138359,
0.0226727128,
-0.0387411639,
0.0485046208,
-0.0670758709,
0.004065644,
-0.0917663053,
-0.0208927095,
0.0172145087,
-0.0390915126,
-0.0458173826,
-0.0155303655,
-0.0936367139,
-0.064971976,
0.0312364176,
0.0456479751,
0.0145048071,
0.0668213889,
-0.0082908804,
-0.0509192683,
0.0650561675,
-0.01222743,
-0.0175641365,
0.0161031131,
0.0714600682,
-0.0708613992,
-0.0273591038,
0.0204466842,
-0.0428983383,
0.0596361794,
0.0530677848,
0.0246430729,
0.0316225775,
0.0533042178,
0.0028692326,
0.0157746952,
0.0735300258,
-0.0217152257,
-0.0233616736,
-0.0810740218,
0.024950901,
0.0173335765,
-0.003362593,
-0.0246844217,
-0.0030682418,
0.024014201,
0.0013472461,
-0.0241865255,
-0.0579249412,
0.0069150757,
0.0250690635,
-0.0109572047,
0.0073459172,
-0.0352704115,
0.0632843897,
0.0458747298,
0.0130005088,
-0.0144938268,
0.0113717243,
0.0066653746,
0.027387701,
-0.0501796231,
0.0411521457,
0.0059945686,
0.0348387212,
-0.0219534487,
0.0126724867,
-0.0234244373,
0.0039706039,
-0.0347743668,
-0.0045864498,
0.0778437853,
-0.0640873611,
0.0411553681,
-0.0339914337,
-0.0104527418,
-0.0348666608,
0.0288918391,
-0.0111119151,
-0.0470199287,
0.0419339165,
0.0143538062,
-0.0074406639,
0.0210827868,
0.0652511418,
0.0352698974,
0.0478201695,
0.0224826299,
0.0357591398,
-0.0484651811,
-0.0424493551,
0.0090936162,
0.0268250629,
-0.0088242888,
0.0147696091,
-0.0232473183,
-0.0750623122,
-0.0072181863,
-0.0106663927,
-0.0217368361,
-0.0023268552,
0.0424756669,
0.0525883175,
-0.0509280153,
0.0303587876,
-0.0355215035,
-0.0082746288,
0.0152803659,
-0.0132999485,
-0.0105002131,
-6.829145368e-33,
-0.0045917933,
0.0129666533,
0.0170724764,
0.0178684443,
-0.0194092058,
0.0155055337,
-0.0357043594,
-0.0070554423,
-0.0252905414,
0.0340228565,
-0.0147632686,
0.0146775022,
0.0182314683,
0.0436340906,
-0.0190190878,
-0.0117177973,
0.0527035743,
-0.0203208681,
-0.005320996,
0.0389156193,
-7.16e-8,
0.0242315792,
0.0711063668,
-0.047547821,
-0.0319599956,
0.0164391212,
0.0022630612,
0.0152652552,
0.0030215364,
0.0560141131,
-0.0041542691,
0.0580995604,
0.0132135144,
-0.0574817769,
-0.0176546294,
-0.0457593687,
-0.0728045404,
-0.0400318056,
-0.0229222625,
0.0395868123,
0.0078992965,
-0.0448382236,
0.0144376038,
-0.0024919335,
0.0002483764,
-0.0352526642,
0.0256360639,
-0.0172922295,
-0.0502105094,
0.0233955476,
-0.0592006557,
0.0243530497,
-0.0198580455,
-0.0070425249,
0.0263035297,
0.0196425766,
0.0025946146,
0.0216473192,
-0.0137286829,
0.0285947118,
0.0400297754,
0.0616234317,
0.0415397957,
0.0320780426,
0.005464213,
0.0761729032,
0.0001896161,
0.0016929727,
0.0508204699,
-0.0134922452,
0.0806455314,
0.029701801,
0.0110730566,
0.0512898006,
0.0412337035,
-0.0361384414,
-0.0999374017,
-0.004927258,
-0.0266285688,
0.0274474286,
-0.000060751,
-0.0071134628,
-0.0265640337,
-0.0426746421,
-0.0333353616,
-0.0295502543,
-0.020335285,
-0.0024449767,
0.0291031841,
-0.0020047261,
-0.0389967412,
0.0118601285,
0.0170388315,
-0.040291056,
-0.0447305106,
0.058441706,
-0.0242550857,
0.0128110591,
-0.0128437104,
0.0352855362,
-0.0668124408,
-0.0521006323,
0.000464395,
-0.010425726,
0.0278333817,
0.0075783306,
0.0580039173,
0.0237835795,
-0.0591666885,
-0.0183940884,
-0.0347717442,
-0.0082377233,
0.0457189754,
0.0616131425,
0.038298849,
0.0169399809,
0.0091831349,
0.0554104559,
0.057275705,
-0.0728656799,
-0.0119063435,
-0.0151329152,
0.0212199017,
0.0442045443,
-0.037417952,
-0.0268838853,
-0.0375996567,
-0.009008023,
0.0369521305,
-0.0744536966,
-0.0130768148,
-0.0129634431,
2.962e-7,
0.0343257636,
0.0716016814,
-0.0025307026,
-0.0112301586,
0.0061625871,
0.0140956417,
-0.0454586782,
-0.0014799177,
0.0140577927,
0.0276849177,
0.0159038845,
0.0313413776,
0.0774869397,
0.0291445367,
-0.0843712091,
0.016050173,
-0.0297872815,
0.0315706655,
-0.054050725,
-0.033659976,
0.0106657622,
0.0977314934,
0.0374920741,
-0.0222994033,
-0.0138369873,
0.0168599337,
0.0388298519,
-0.0050725434,
0.0298196077,
0.0396857895,
-0.0306669194,
0.0278256759,
-0.0124092568,
0.011789565,
-0.0469940752,
0.0252198279,
-0.008788066,
0.0663178936,
-0.0095874732,
-0.0054344493,
0.0137558784,
0.0073684966,
-0.0248826519,
-0.0478031263,
0.0437570326,
-0.0565852225,
-0.0001017827,
-0.0205301996,
-0.026291037,
-0.0219363719,
0.0251132809,
-0.0266398191,
-0.0101212421,
0.0136452438,
0.0216476414,
-0.0273847673,
-0.014239559,
-0.0654692054,
-0.0017203831,
0.0018952168,
-0.0228924584,
-0.036973618,
-0.0138333989,
-0.0270571038,
0.0387843251,
-0.0529018976,
0.0560694411,
2.767211966e-34,
0.0493009984,
-0.0237502754,
0.0315248184,
-0.0078331735,
-0.0057364427,
-0.0281458534,
0.0528011099,
0.0069237463,
0.0058152727,
-0.0556802936,
-0.0040739132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15383v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15383v1 | GD-COMET: A Geo-Diverse Commonsense Inference Model | 2023-10-23T22:03:56 | 2023-10-23T22:03:56 | Mehar Bhatia, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing integration of AI into everyday life, it's becoming
crucial to design AI systems that serve users from diverse backgrounds by
making them culturally aware. In this paper, we present GD-COMET, a geo-diverse
version of the COMET commonsense inference model. GD-COMET goes beyond Western
commonsense knowledge and is capable of generating inferences pertaining to a
broad range of cultures. We demonstrate the effectiveness of GD-COMET through a
comprehensive human evaluation across 5 diverse cultures, as well as extrinsic
evaluation on a geo-diverse task. The evaluation shows that GD-COMET captures
and generates culturally nuanced commonsense knowledge, demonstrating its
potential to benefit NLP applications across the board and contribute to making
NLP more inclusive. | [
0.0642722473,
0.0742784515,
-0.0288869739,
-0.0039265514,
-0.0283946004,
-0.0017694877,
0.0213953853,
-0.0177124031,
0.0746580437,
-0.0272858869,
0.014867899,
0.0084820129,
0.0172267482,
-0.0122132357,
0.0052312547,
-0.0785451457,
0.0252295062,
-0.000301777,
-0.0060799015,
-0.0137076983,
-0.0110478727,
0.0480825379,
-0.0275491197,
0.0665594637,
-0.014393758,
-0.0143530304,
0.0417332724,
-0.0268617179,
0.0471840389,
-0.0079081561,
-0.0284956545,
0.0370971859,
-0.0123252543,
-0.0031243614,
0.0000019416,
-0.0343257487,
0.036974214,
-0.0254445858,
0.0385124236,
-0.0228494238,
0.0464011244,
0.0056791352,
-0.0000203768,
-0.0236368366,
-0.0571388565,
0.0348472185,
0.0470845364,
0.0075280252,
0.002235336,
0.01431619,
-0.0066304309,
-0.0109603209,
-0.0514647402,
0.0011408065,
-0.0036025441,
-0.0532570444,
0.010939802,
0.0245649312,
0.037239939,
-0.0383184515,
-0.0077751083,
0.0333307795,
0.0295189172,
0.0068976772,
-0.0506168716,
0.0322501436,
-0.0626880899,
0.0046829809,
-0.0038583125,
0.0614733174,
0.0752505586,
-0.0085564377,
0.0033087288,
0.0287777316,
0.0112464298,
0.0190958455,
-0.0517858453,
0.0411095098,
-0.0156894047,
0.0222683344,
0.0414516926,
0.0292301439,
0.00287106,
0.0727126077,
0.0153073454,
0.0710981265,
-0.014626761,
-0.0018703771,
-0.0243400447,
0.0281913131,
0.0100278035,
-0.0420669504,
0.0371255241,
0.0177676007,
-0.0036914453,
0.0072069564,
-0.0100202784,
0.0086218547,
0.0158055257,
-0.03918745,
0.0181414932,
0.0331931524,
-0.0396705084,
0.0452395417,
-0.0055247387,
0.0019441965,
0.0148847457,
0.0008271632,
-0.0104460549,
-0.0529598556,
-0.051484555,
0.0116893798,
0.0290708765,
0.0015991251,
-0.048598025,
0.0201574806,
-0.04744187,
-0.0126176346,
-0.0363085903,
0.0136161456,
-0.0061686891,
0.01371988,
-0.0510636009,
-0.0382019244,
-0.052175764,
0.0399547964,
-0.0961819962,
0.0354852974,
-0.0044528088,
-0.056276679,
0.0014686087,
0.0052271043,
0.0013590783,
-0.0114304069,
-0.0172025189,
0.0187473372,
0.0061628455,
0.0109986635,
-0.0728406608,
0.0116846804,
0.0145444274,
-0.0298666097,
-0.0087813875,
-0.0836460292,
0.0339284427,
0.013799686,
0.0168268438,
-0.0532585941,
0.0065724747,
0.0317382924,
-0.022429781,
0.0270843357,
0.0020705699,
0.0275029261,
0.0367674865,
0.0214190613,
-0.0091099581,
0.0932165161,
-0.0147537077,
0.028739376,
0.0671811923,
0.024337383,
0.0018039893,
-0.0193556845,
-0.0053003412,
0.0068433862,
0.0027941177,
0.0140362903,
-0.0404013842,
0.0023463995,
0.0375681296,
0.0204498898,
-0.0139501309,
0.023113627,
0.0223881174,
0.1098752767,
-0.051611539,
0.0586175732,
0.0564272143,
0.0207864232,
-0.0238639936,
0.0011186656,
-0.0682354793,
0.0187519435,
-0.0351343453,
-0.0235320013,
-0.0238351058,
0.0933082774,
-0.0245109592,
-0.0187508091,
-0.0091323312,
-0.0031487015,
0.0573710836,
0.008914453,
0.0198588166,
-0.0052423179,
0.0626855344,
0.0504409112,
0.0509019084,
-0.0591182113,
0.0111788064,
-0.0144832768,
0.0140349185,
0.0317955837,
0.0040040556,
-0.0099456282,
-0.0165201444,
0.0114813587,
0.0170534328,
0.0427958481,
0.0434263349,
0.0011298904,
0.0181127526,
-0.0389795713,
-0.0193931945,
0.0456060246,
0.0098729739,
0.0068626218,
0.0679859295,
0.0517734028,
0.0092817619,
-0.0416484922,
0.0103725698,
0.0067402311,
-0.0070041995,
-0.0022427654,
0.0062674074,
0.010199707,
0.0081242025,
0.0306047406,
0.012124138,
-0.011762877,
-0.0131763378,
-0.0435633808,
-0.0289341528,
0.0799055696,
-0.0462552533,
-0.0530750044,
0.0262049921,
-0.0785531178,
-0.053732872,
0.0165180899,
-0.0067696832,
-0.0212766845,
0.0351164564,
0.0128639685,
0.0046888157,
-0.0544289462,
-0.0541449003,
0.0027574112,
-0.0049150852,
-0.0017037961,
0.0937374085,
-0.0565908551,
-0.0156562123,
0.0001721732,
-0.0228291713,
0.0179845411,
-0.0200896841,
-0.0197248273,
-0.0157669522,
-0.0202368814,
-0.0082015507,
0.0200203601,
0.0482116602,
-0.0152989626,
0.0079428935,
-0.1131102219,
-0.0232974272,
-0.0106167411,
-0.0181839429,
-0.0149417762,
0.0220672321,
-0.0341549143,
-0.0354838111,
-0.0346924625,
-0.031842757,
0.0126509881,
0.0393615775,
0.0242089517,
-0.0357923172,
0.0351977162,
0.0265223272,
-0.0008675951,
-0.0273979027,
0.0368537121,
-0.0092147095,
0.0250202846,
-0.0138380006,
-0.0569551997,
-0.0726918578,
0.0077738436,
-0.0020444223,
-0.0512126051,
0.0081245396,
0.0030517033,
0.0032350302,
0.0462293848,
-0.0119013283,
-0.0155960359,
0.0364368036,
-0.0314773805,
-0.0377611145,
0.0124577163,
0.0031106062,
0.0421301015,
0.0102625247,
-0.0622416437,
-0.0247505214,
0.0369839929,
0.0237255897,
0.003049718,
-0.0524701513,
0.0217795316,
-0.0458976366,
-0.0447222851,
-0.0362623706,
0.0328693092,
0.000634991,
0.0729209408,
-0.0200612973,
-0.0182206444,
0.0855473951,
0.0170299653,
0.0199677479,
-0.0533407182,
-0.0000501041,
-0.0381027572,
0.0680419877,
-0.0727841109,
0.0345610604,
-0.0207569469,
-0.018180633,
-0.0105735306,
-0.0155767929,
0.0185504332,
-0.0208817571,
0.0324811526,
-0.0541883893,
-0.0053223511,
-0.027021287,
-0.0470955484,
-0.0321935043,
-0.0024085208,
-0.0098204408,
0.0258896276,
0.0156314597,
-0.027478449,
-0.0030485366,
0.0194218177,
0.0302146561,
0.0156330988,
-0.018321041,
0.0077199587,
0.011635961,
0.0221741162,
0.0455176085,
0.0587191358,
-0.0013931283,
0.0550270006,
-0.0421349145,
0.0315271094,
0.0522210002,
-0.0228087157,
0.0400239117,
0.0487551279,
0.0357764065,
-0.0213686675,
-0.0010795821,
0.0034564114,
0.0778876394,
-0.0301771313,
-0.0004812301,
0.0530868657,
0.0333148874,
-0.0519385934,
0.0031125259,
-0.0543329418,
-0.0008959429,
0.0094769811,
0.0467310213,
-0.1258516014,
-0.027462082,
-0.0191971213,
-0.04157326,
-0.0210624821,
-0.0702939853,
0.0244959928,
-0.0991459042,
0.0270859227,
0.000760888,
-0.0681261048,
-0.0596511886,
-0.0243046749,
0.0035034867,
-0.0050941212,
-0.021892339,
-0.0282357708,
0.0062659979,
0.0093338871,
0.0046526119,
-0.0391651653,
-0.087096639,
0.021909086,
-0.0478273332,
0.0238151271,
0.0371973924,
0.0624660775,
0.0096565401,
-0.0715257823,
-0.0730169192,
-0.0517602675,
0.0183393508,
-0.0353717655,
-0.04019963,
0.0036671034,
-0.0114248721,
-0.015155416,
0.0279953033,
-0.0483321659,
-0.0227090325,
0.0345127732,
0.0799691305,
-0.0074437801,
0.0146406945,
-0.0441755429,
0.0217951257,
0.0610812902,
0.0803924575,
0.0295620263,
-0.0048267618,
-0.0089367041,
-0.0373949483,
-0.0459470302,
-0.0390506797,
-0.0510098673,
0.0360408053,
0.0017854237,
-0.0652703792,
-0.0584556647,
-0.0495340265,
0.0270034652,
0.0225526877,
0.0075727967,
-0.0237401314,
0.0166381262,
0.0359196626,
-0.0183227137,
0.0576782525,
-0.044636894,
-0.0001973448,
0.0274912063,
-0.0142170675,
0.0018161725,
0.0110118017,
-0.0164918285,
0.0693978444,
-0.0239693671,
-0.0180139635,
0.026173871,
0.0493602119,
0.0126202684,
-0.0050384835,
-0.0470736548,
-0.0162320212,
0.0101303495,
0.0401321091,
-0.0174780879,
-0.0210882109,
0.0122498237,
0.0328520648,
0.0250871815,
0.066878587,
0.0029220188,
0.0337869637,
0.0006447593,
0.053206645,
-0.0480937697,
-0.003170266,
-0.0114160581,
-0.0206973702,
-0.0199754536,
-0.0372953825,
-0.0096151587,
-0.0252212286,
-0.0379213355,
0.0021466608,
-0.0410797633,
-0.0014215354,
0.0078014052,
0.010245909,
-0.0066118101,
0.0006338973,
0.0550854206,
-0.0156526305,
0.0063162106,
-0.0525981486,
0.0158701111,
0.0716155618,
0.0690156519,
-0.0442960486,
-0.0055981404,
-0.0356370062,
-0.0031071019,
-0.0408281051,
0.0466310345,
-0.0189982671,
0.0713587701,
0.0244498029,
-0.0454350077,
0.0158655159,
0.0112877646,
-0.0370849743,
0.0011795216,
0.0344039723,
0.0726691261,
0.0838147625,
-0.01191107,
0.0007158791,
0.004392751,
0.0019471348,
0.043561548,
0.0321852453,
0.0391753241,
-0.0382842608,
0.0233592447,
-0.0056585027,
-0.0067913826,
-0.0009369727,
0.0412899218,
-0.1100549623,
0.0185833555,
0.0149380621,
-0.0596060529,
-0.0231979582,
-0.0595651306,
-0.0069747586,
0.0229689199,
0.0007322755,
0.0543714762,
-0.0944963098,
-0.042736195,
-0.0146197286,
0.0070783421,
0.0148589285,
0.0122956168,
0.0049247001,
0.0943023041,
0.0055283308,
-0.0809842497,
-0.0307281651,
0.0242079943,
-0.12641792,
-0.0053934189,
-0.0459921472,
-6.424073689e-33,
-0.0325817131,
-0.0279346798,
0.0098264953,
-0.0430845656,
-0.0013009263,
-0.0260360632,
-0.0382728912,
-0.0061129001,
-0.0502008162,
0.0218309928,
-0.0395701528,
0.0098132761,
0.0270389803,
0.0116964886,
0.0208383482,
0.0164956022,
0.0087300939,
0.0588581488,
-0.0189284701,
0.0136935525,
0.0647590756,
-0.0056446032,
0.0694648623,
-0.0667334571,
0.0224807281,
0.0173381716,
-0.0095505444,
0.0204996727,
0.015614612,
0.0446200445,
-0.043221008,
0.0491246358,
0.0308433659,
0.0259390622,
0.0200996436,
0.0084281564,
-0.0738751963,
-0.0686295927,
0.0307954699,
0.0010750266,
-0.0021568919,
-0.0313082039,
0.0029861385,
0.0010645149,
-0.0114124091,
0.036263153,
0.0442056768,
-0.0282618888,
0.0080235666,
-0.028294161,
-0.0283426624,
0.0418557525,
0.0009752613,
0.0143361939,
-0.0542797111,
0.024931943,
-0.0235087778,
-0.0256054029,
-0.0440677181,
0.0284295194,
0.0341899544,
0.0063690762,
0.0696055517,
-0.0414637886,
0.0058888351,
0.030923238,
-0.0364488736,
-0.0068364763,
-0.0697066113,
-0.018895356,
0.0271033756,
0.010465214,
-0.0055880509,
0.1146642044,
-0.0211528298,
-0.005483076,
-0.0195712429,
0.0615549721,
0.0539952517,
0.041566588,
0.015140377,
-0.0192321707,
-0.0522978827,
-0.0013777717,
0.0049282247,
-0.0599646978,
0.004246044,
-0.030486647,
0.0120116519,
-0.0186223965,
-0.040975865,
0.0847829729,
0.0102006402,
-0.024271002,
0.0095748156,
0.0316743143,
0.0290632118,
-0.0360796489,
0.0290439874,
-0.0074206782,
-0.0631333143,
0.0010169956,
-0.0095031103,
0.0117136063,
0.0025211612,
0.0327093787,
0.0247679334,
0.0179441813,
-0.0260580163,
-0.0236820001,
-0.008352139,
0.025029432,
-0.0434476919,
-0.0087546157,
0.0462663844,
0.020181654,
-0.0228600018,
0.0018916916,
0.0443985574,
0.0485910177,
-0.0047269217,
-0.0225330945,
-0.0115783392,
0.0318822041,
-0.0420534387,
-0.0022543205,
-0.0630244464,
-0.0188128855,
-0.0003320448,
-0.0203481577,
-0.00856758,
0.0189332701,
2.495e-7,
0.0013953062,
0.0073834429,
-0.0122386236,
0.0074807452,
-0.0247232579,
0.0188965593,
0.0276756715,
0.0145261036,
-0.0105197048,
0.0194014125,
0.0128947785,
0.0528194793,
0.0447520129,
0.0771016255,
-0.0979042202,
0.0225014724,
-0.0347706228,
0.0078217108,
-0.0545560978,
-0.0041302061,
0.012611608,
0.048388496,
0.0347581394,
-0.0151493363,
0.0044682436,
-0.0379396044,
0.0102384938,
-0.0214476231,
-0.0134995142,
-0.0165086742,
0.0282764155,
-0.0314472318,
0.0195843764,
0.0265733711,
0.0096183531,
0.0045197294,
0.0202875249,
0.0542643592,
-0.0080920942,
-0.0009252993,
-0.0270143133,
-0.0452627391,
-0.0017780452,
-0.0881405771,
0.0601063035,
-0.0177922342,
-0.0200575721,
-0.0306563526,
0.0213691592,
0.0063627665,
0.025208978,
-0.0023342865,
-0.0404373743,
-0.0070673814,
0.0228211526,
-0.0211614743,
-0.0202913787,
-0.0628295243,
-0.0058858208,
-0.0018892321,
0.0166083854,
-0.0294903126,
-0.0078044026,
-0.0441143066,
-0.0235603042,
-0.0473928601,
0.0073892721,
1.98324861e-34,
-0.0198728442,
0.053836789,
-0.0378059112,
-0.0001333204,
0.08006078,
0.0105916467,
0.0232426189,
0.0074605239,
0.0203546844,
-0.0010485863,
-0.0053456146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18355v1 | Health Disparities through Generative AI Models: A Comparison Study Using A Domain Specific large language model | 2023-10-23T21:24:05 | 2023-10-23T21:24:05 | Yohn Jairo Parra Bautista, Vinicious Lima, Carlos Theran, Richard Alo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Health disparities are differences in health outcomes and access to
healthcare between different groups, including racial and ethnic minorities,
low-income people, and rural residents. An artificial intelligence (AI) program
called large language models (LLMs) can understand and generate human language,
improving health communication and reducing health disparities. There are many
challenges in using LLMs in human-doctor interaction, including the need for
diverse and representative data, privacy concerns, and collaboration between
healthcare providers and technology experts. We introduce the comparative
investigation of domain-specific large language models such as SciBERT with a
multi-purpose LLMs BERT. We used cosine similarity to analyze text queries
about health disparities in exam rooms when factors such as race are used
alone. Using text queries, SciBERT fails when it doesn't differentiate between
queries text: "race" alone and "perpetuates health disparities." We believe
clinicians can use generative AI to create a draft response when communicating
asynchronously with patients. However, careful attention must be paid to ensure
they are developed and implemented ethically and equitably. | [
0.0496903732,
0.1069227457,
-0.0245439541,
-0.017752504,
-0.0290678293,
0.0232135188,
0.0534429103,
0.0050897151,
0.0424571373,
-0.0505477786,
0.0437734053,
-0.0487429835,
0.0038632553,
0.031036213,
0.0043031555,
-0.067767024,
0.0009214361,
0.0506040603,
0.0233189575,
-0.011890552,
-0.0103147402,
0.0236957856,
-0.0210304875,
0.0885538831,
-0.0107292384,
-0.0075561325,
0.0209758449,
-0.001017503,
0.0039036416,
-0.0547499582,
0.0113258846,
0.0570682473,
-0.0225171782,
0.0083826222,
0.0000019935,
-0.0598679483,
0.0115838554,
0.0481375046,
-0.0244234931,
-0.0597521253,
0.0417894535,
-0.0510003977,
0.0000054226,
0.0327008255,
-0.0418171063,
0.0039178752,
0.0515580475,
-0.0001278873,
0.0248782001,
0.0266201496,
-0.0204865411,
-0.0020290746,
-0.0139507009,
-0.0045272182,
0.0072209188,
-0.0090870187,
0.0405955203,
-0.0221306812,
0.0491481014,
-0.04429131,
0.005550086,
0.0395742618,
-0.0064004329,
0.0080692023,
0.0258195288,
0.0436075963,
-0.0398687311,
-0.0191735886,
0.0066578593,
0.0615260154,
0.0172886681,
0.0139881549,
0.0450470857,
0.0182348378,
0.0119856996,
0.0157818608,
-0.0306652598,
0.0079499017,
-0.0286228042,
0.0104027493,
-0.0148645956,
0.0080602067,
0.017665891,
0.0118287662,
-0.011646973,
0.0257552695,
0.0309299044,
-0.0425832272,
-0.0369485915,
-0.0105436156,
0.0362714827,
-0.0581008159,
0.0417813323,
0.0384663381,
-0.0772705451,
0.0330855437,
-0.0192813389,
-0.0691949949,
0.0887611359,
-0.0520851165,
0.0201381594,
0.0381920151,
0.0022673409,
-0.0007543057,
0.0576139987,
0.0109227281,
-0.0093138898,
0.0248669907,
-0.0261536743,
0.0062270984,
-0.034482237,
-0.017728664,
-0.0149836345,
0.0216698162,
-0.0327042975,
0.0372988731,
-0.0636281967,
-0.00434815,
-0.0409251079,
0.0135856168,
0.0007078862,
0.0430538319,
-0.0446294583,
0.0095053073,
-0.0218475573,
-0.0254437849,
-0.0102251666,
0.0229820572,
-0.0157200117,
-0.0715747848,
0.0319645293,
-0.0041967859,
-0.0098421257,
0.0024592462,
-0.0174494833,
0.0576627553,
0.0104051931,
-0.0102124801,
-0.0211447924,
-0.0346385613,
-0.0178159755,
-0.0159169417,
0.002302239,
-0.0666998252,
0.0502377674,
0.0203747544,
-0.0002910184,
-0.0744137615,
0.0158722028,
0.0338994339,
-0.0666427836,
0.0562935956,
-0.0292647053,
0.0444266722,
0.0771581382,
0.0477199107,
0.0383094028,
0.0387773514,
0.0175752044,
-0.0256475341,
0.0155164497,
-0.0313669443,
-0.0150004253,
-0.0077568372,
0.0245594475,
-0.0193500929,
-0.0140402084,
0.0178787429,
-0.0051417337,
0.057551492,
-0.0490673073,
0.0874331146,
0.0063733156,
-0.0232177004,
0.0184833035,
0.1365435869,
0.0156122269,
0.0303570479,
0.0438773595,
0.0193127077,
-0.0402757898,
-0.0220767893,
-0.026141718,
-0.035393551,
0.0039326814,
-0.0265845452,
0.0438555591,
0.0195297804,
-0.0313011631,
-0.0417788066,
-0.0368491039,
-0.0278504472,
0.0115138553,
-0.0114819556,
0.0247614197,
-0.0185484122,
-0.0063523091,
0.0405279435,
0.0504399985,
-0.0292005204,
-0.014058846,
-0.0936489254,
0.0031164784,
0.1224390045,
0.0347399674,
-0.0416447558,
-0.0112730954,
-0.0194985271,
-0.0266935788,
0.0331867337,
0.0277256146,
-0.0035985743,
-0.0078623751,
-0.0297466852,
-0.0154972244,
0.0599132776,
0.0271058399,
-0.0001408372,
0.0113240005,
0.0582072847,
0.0018216646,
-0.0224612281,
-0.0138660111,
0.0338825732,
-0.0554206222,
0.0016611434,
0.0060532219,
-0.0142635824,
0.0446307771,
0.0526467487,
-0.0192250088,
0.0397012457,
-0.035606768,
-0.023451522,
-0.0334199332,
0.0043779747,
-0.0545263104,
0.0162630379,
0.0008060572,
-0.0654229,
0.0250261799,
0.0245069228,
0.0088030128,
-0.0032871123,
0.0050645163,
-0.0443001464,
0.0175247751,
-0.0162286591,
0.0291465931,
0.0282348897,
0.0002918841,
-0.0335277654,
0.0172967408,
-0.0355410501,
-0.0089869387,
0.0106086796,
-0.007368098,
0.0081561552,
-0.0503433384,
0.0116361156,
0.0289912783,
-0.0038205364,
0.0205003768,
0.0026555285,
0.020322321,
0.0096335178,
0.0052253278,
-0.1054124534,
-0.0125889573,
-0.0012796847,
-0.0438417792,
-0.0043842876,
0.0354241244,
-0.0113882534,
-0.0110696219,
-0.0298052784,
-0.0302932709,
0.0589403473,
0.0290823877,
0.0035828198,
-0.0004056727,
-0.0070190993,
-0.0346529856,
-0.0346198827,
-0.0494429059,
0.0490948185,
0.0552900471,
-0.0129207317,
-0.0042125345,
-0.0211740043,
-0.0345785283,
0.0142165935,
0.0120994728,
-0.0362247601,
0.0193593726,
0.0007530382,
0.0237999633,
0.0069034747,
0.0344315544,
0.0381517708,
0.0270211976,
-0.0083511136,
-0.032895837,
0.0084015867,
-0.0186550319,
0.0261507295,
0.0229961071,
-0.1014557034,
0.0346917287,
0.0707266852,
0.0525299795,
-0.0279566441,
-0.0441840589,
0.0236634556,
-0.043863371,
-0.0297304764,
-0.0452677421,
-0.0224820264,
-0.0207778942,
0.0251912139,
0.0004354711,
-0.0411726348,
0.066141203,
0.0210738443,
0.0621085539,
-0.0959561169,
-0.0027806032,
-0.0533843078,
0.0008714073,
-0.0144329136,
0.0406956896,
0.0078873057,
-0.0270422399,
0.0243305471,
0.014285,
-0.0161077678,
-0.0628700405,
0.053902097,
-0.038471546,
0.008482459,
0.0013136081,
-0.0490931943,
-0.0622429326,
-0.0307926238,
-0.0106905606,
0.0226945877,
0.0512383357,
-0.0025397083,
-0.0484865829,
0.0208636764,
-0.0044346652,
0.0654647201,
0.0305315647,
-0.0244364217,
0.009041355,
-0.025767697,
0.0192845818,
-0.0025349029,
-0.0117848879,
0.0046985685,
0.0482523255,
0.027517857,
0.0218421482,
0.0186456107,
0.0215301588,
0.0090351952,
0.0101026529,
-0.0257489309,
-0.0174569245,
0.0337801836,
0.0102070458,
-0.0123318415,
0.0063698338,
0.0991240889,
0.0305203181,
-0.0454282761,
0.0326236151,
-0.0530531481,
-0.0488101467,
-0.0289806277,
0.0008923816,
-0.1087045074,
0.0078198947,
-0.0072500156,
0.0553305931,
-0.0631077513,
-0.0306338854,
0.0232797172,
-0.0622850135,
0.027904002,
-0.0118333548,
0.009977621,
-0.0577037819,
-0.0030240675,
0.0110275606,
0.0327095501,
-0.0128563093,
-0.0498210676,
0.0114275888,
0.0036542402,
-0.0074600899,
-0.0730635896,
-0.083216913,
0.0078199292,
0.0072794184,
0.0188299716,
0.0983974412,
0.0667884201,
-0.0127158519,
-0.0353747196,
-0.0090682972,
0.0023628534,
0.0020029652,
-0.0195908714,
0.0564733334,
0.0369765237,
0.0047468967,
-0.0677050427,
0.059838295,
-0.0102380393,
-0.0270935632,
0.0264772587,
0.0413300432,
-0.0472153649,
-0.0353812128,
-0.0704046115,
0.0398413502,
0.042460233,
0.0621223673,
0.0251812413,
-0.0054532201,
-0.0211763252,
-0.0218554419,
0.0509689786,
0.0031575647,
-0.0120780971,
0.0214932822,
-0.0026955886,
-0.0284523051,
-0.033120472,
-0.0326902382,
0.0037033823,
-0.0276736598,
0.0203650612,
-0.0248347856,
0.0550941043,
-0.0163072515,
-0.0382491052,
0.008788703,
0.0137412725,
0.0266903527,
-0.0099742552,
-0.0767976716,
0.0148640564,
-0.0103123765,
-0.0171192735,
-0.002856439,
-0.0083095133,
-0.0239503402,
0.0372021608,
0.0163796041,
0.0241346844,
-0.0138323465,
-0.0049115377,
-0.0256726034,
0.0135382637,
0.0757898986,
-0.0262217037,
-0.0201820806,
-0.0329001136,
0.0088383667,
-0.0015644287,
0.0050570993,
0.0089880386,
0.0471967496,
0.0055829901,
0.0262075439,
-0.0436243117,
-0.0241805967,
-0.0110980552,
0.0282885879,
-0.003521838,
-0.0043360563,
-0.0170546249,
-0.0436500013,
-0.0066865045,
-0.044775594,
-0.0039699376,
-0.0297453199,
-0.0329701416,
-0.0139072658,
0.0126278978,
-0.0230156463,
-0.0036945203,
-0.0747318566,
-0.0107615795,
-0.0692377985,
0.0911244825,
0.0017964802,
0.0282738917,
0.030989388,
-0.0484446287,
0.0141649004,
0.043254897,
-0.0246255919,
0.0279446375,
0.0068827253,
0.0728783682,
0.0075412309,
0.0121785058,
0.0130623635,
0.0096980697,
-0.0182935242,
-0.0819223896,
-0.0092036529,
0.0604723841,
0.0170326009,
0.033870887,
-0.024101248,
-0.0057291402,
-0.0066262092,
0.00080884,
0.015923677,
0.0225001499,
0.0139123136,
0.0570069738,
-0.0147844488,
-0.005255308,
-0.0439118892,
0.0871073306,
-0.0023872729,
0.0490215234,
-0.0116189281,
-0.0547707081,
-0.0213099141,
-0.0418147668,
0.048383601,
0.0003358439,
-0.0388082713,
0.0045445743,
-0.078317605,
-0.0406339653,
0.0142403161,
-0.0223816056,
0.0151579361,
-0.0029022878,
0.0431814864,
0.0453150421,
-0.0044058589,
-0.04650563,
-0.0072963382,
0.0725195557,
-0.0670890585,
-0.0445262492,
0.0233989172,
-5.933388551e-33,
-0.0209058523,
-0.0642651469,
0.0101636397,
-0.0604915693,
-0.0068281949,
0.0070554311,
-0.0284991469,
-0.0174092632,
-0.0093747685,
0.0234252829,
0.0129605867,
0.0201463718,
0.0046478403,
0.0507215634,
0.0137752881,
-0.038565699,
0.0388853177,
0.0184074733,
0.0001317422,
0.03858665,
-0.0561680943,
0.0356707349,
-0.0149151776,
-0.0841817856,
0.0319923274,
-0.0279549789,
0.032737352,
0.0050416435,
0.0014826896,
0.0353174806,
-0.0381785743,
0.0681559294,
0.0414740406,
-0.0173311047,
-0.0004561214,
0.0748519525,
-0.0334521569,
-0.0371453427,
0.0127404556,
-0.0544996224,
-0.0354163125,
-0.0513210632,
0.0321248248,
0.0182979573,
-0.0694103464,
-0.0035821828,
0.0558674484,
-0.0460599326,
0.0282165222,
-0.0422348157,
-0.0353648029,
0.0306092929,
-0.0465518534,
0.0250284318,
-0.0497074686,
0.0141627453,
-0.0317257829,
0.0352079198,
-0.0075229467,
-0.0078982739,
0.0742807686,
-0.0352708511,
0.0418798067,
-0.012957315,
0.0196758248,
0.0183435138,
0.0292070024,
-0.0212808345,
-0.0650460571,
-0.0330724306,
-0.035785418,
-0.0126061896,
0.0258938484,
0.0452068187,
-0.0088759884,
-0.0409097932,
-0.0593958162,
0.0464591682,
-0.0763180852,
0.0102697834,
0.0475558303,
-0.0230830926,
-0.0846722871,
-0.0251829065,
-0.0267530028,
-0.0114240106,
-0.0177132022,
-0.0326827206,
0.0406767763,
-0.0108075282,
0.0314901732,
0.0564841442,
-0.0115826018,
-0.0164897852,
-0.0000429773,
0.0040215789,
0.0529745035,
-0.0569951683,
-0.0385186188,
-0.0115822395,
-0.0717662126,
0.0257939305,
0.0210660007,
0.0392915159,
0.0401458442,
0.0270926729,
-0.0182402618,
-0.0540724099,
-0.055517491,
-0.0062695467,
0.0316618308,
0.0351193808,
0.0026798323,
0.0088071469,
0.0365926698,
0.0200713668,
0.0104186134,
0.0640756488,
0.0098150726,
-0.0113533325,
-0.0627198294,
-0.0342338756,
-0.0238117315,
0.0029090708,
-0.0719291121,
0.0172121655,
-0.0321761072,
0.0459756926,
0.0338482894,
-0.035904482,
0.0048382529,
-0.0518576428,
2.653e-7,
0.0539469272,
0.0279382393,
-0.0048547857,
-0.0089834919,
0.0192020983,
-0.0006273711,
0.0524118915,
0.0191031992,
0.0101670232,
0.017970752,
0.0195363965,
0.0334639773,
0.020821156,
0.0546795391,
-0.0256610829,
0.0288671702,
-0.0930258632,
-0.0320958644,
-0.0586027391,
0.0163589418,
0.0699826553,
0.0328055471,
-0.0185155608,
-0.0307924282,
-0.0098610725,
0.0129049681,
0.0064647165,
-0.0408622995,
-0.0005851139,
0.0355728641,
0.0323162489,
-0.0046751513,
0.0393008068,
0.0494848564,
-0.0229011178,
-0.0041708057,
0.0061068526,
0.0633547679,
-0.0476680733,
0.0405074134,
0.0115034208,
-0.0220095031,
0.0046367678,
-0.054712452,
0.0541076623,
-0.0118529312,
-0.0422975123,
-0.0169357937,
-0.0022537278,
-0.0401949435,
0.0332409218,
-0.0346248336,
-0.031294968,
0.0194131173,
0.0198380947,
0.004672165,
0.0415661484,
-0.0377714187,
-0.0057236576,
-0.0045743696,
-0.0463219211,
-0.0439517796,
0.0279936008,
-0.003231542,
-0.0151804453,
-0.0140424361,
0.06023084,
2.442927972e-34,
0.028931709,
0.0419853143,
0.0003466537,
-0.0017398358,
0.0288573317,
0.0203603655,
0.0007698023,
-0.0020309049,
0.0241904892,
-0.0366633348,
-0.0166164264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15373v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15373v1 | Semantic Data Management in Data Lakes | 2023-10-23T21:16:50 | 2023-10-23T21:16:50 | Sayed Hoseini, Johannes Theissen-Lipp, Christoph Quix | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | In recent years, data lakes emerged as away to manage large amounts of
heterogeneous data for modern data analytics. One way to prevent data lakes
from turning into inoperable data swamps is semantic data management. Some
approaches propose the linkage of metadata to knowledge graphs based on the
Linked Data principles to provide more meaning and semantics to the data in the
lake. Such a semantic layer may be utilized not only for data management but
also to tackle the problem of data integration from heterogeneous sources, in
order to make data access more expressive and interoperable. In this survey, we
review recent approaches with a specific focus on the application within data
lake systems and scalability to Big Data. We classify the approaches into (i)
basic semantic data management, (ii) semantic modeling approaches for enriching
metadata in data lakes, and (iii) methods for ontologybased data access. In
each category, we cover the main techniques and their background, and compare
latest research. Finally, we point out challenges for future work in this
research area, which needs a closer integration of Big Data and Semantic Web
technologies. | [
-0.0094072698,
0.007101465,
-0.0196050163,
0.00275639,
-0.0127944238,
0.0013106167,
0.0014184488,
-0.0167780034,
0.0673531368,
-0.0330491923,
-0.0259716623,
0.0376471914,
-0.0076812464,
-0.002998871,
-0.0472763889,
-0.0561690517,
0.0510492586,
-0.0192218777,
-0.0549561866,
-0.0141901542,
-0.0102566518,
0.0111634033,
0.0455013514,
-0.0311672799,
-0.0268902872,
0.0113405278,
-0.0220314357,
0.0124738021,
0.0205573626,
-0.0357873365,
-0.0304455031,
0.0253106598,
0.0064689787,
0.0553594194,
0.0000020745,
-0.0394384935,
-0.0371877998,
0.0443317145,
-0.0095190033,
-0.0101827802,
0.0322077796,
-0.0060060713,
0.0350327156,
-0.0200249813,
0.0184173547,
0.0051189461,
0.0671221912,
0.0136520751,
0.078267023,
-0.0687630475,
-0.0200571865,
-0.0379630476,
0.0130068073,
0.0462471992,
0.0587301888,
-0.0065431697,
0.0439671315,
0.0859972909,
0.0725294054,
-0.0100031979,
-0.0114953863,
0.0281003658,
-0.0360319614,
0.0428048894,
0.0156863965,
0.0181743018,
0.0093779564,
0.0212102085,
-0.0215482488,
0.0203400254,
0.0731086954,
0.0064675556,
0.0246970523,
0.0126670823,
-0.0477070175,
0.050287772,
-0.0307159815,
-0.0226399787,
0.0102216108,
-0.0051806988,
-0.0173121132,
-0.0063951025,
0.0445224196,
0.0303755421,
-0.0720268637,
0.0712252855,
0.0141465031,
0.0145160062,
-0.0619129613,
-0.0462326817,
0.0255980715,
-0.0063893213,
-0.0032651117,
0.0459261946,
-0.0170431715,
0.017465651,
-0.026486259,
0.0011339843,
0.0241582282,
-0.0249595828,
-0.0284168012,
-0.0083547654,
0.0131153818,
0.0776108652,
0.070062466,
-0.0501042418,
-0.0470583215,
-0.0156106614,
0.0058359317,
-0.1009434313,
-0.1060314775,
-0.0121275811,
0.0307242256,
0.019097222,
-0.0115457792,
-0.0004210886,
-0.0016866259,
0.0760900006,
-0.0349955522,
0.0467136838,
-0.0128709665,
-0.0438487455,
0.0111310175,
0.0060764304,
-0.0782373622,
-0.000359432,
0.0225633942,
-0.000877951,
-0.0169870034,
-0.0475929976,
0.0373003818,
-0.0212990083,
0.0404807664,
-0.0085031809,
-0.0027797199,
0.0505758598,
0.0885188505,
0.0463494062,
-0.0915109962,
-0.0884697512,
0.0541629046,
0.0036206413,
-0.0340091884,
-0.0432322882,
0.0663104951,
-0.0121820346,
-0.0017431264,
-0.0043558162,
-0.0196188521,
0.0074996394,
-0.0692418516,
0.0522900522,
-0.1093446538,
0.0173725635,
0.0494553968,
0.015023604,
-0.0056002224,
0.0511483513,
-0.0012981414,
0.0001874754,
-0.0088883024,
-0.0032269657,
-0.0024326432,
-0.0461500473,
0.0235148892,
-0.02654876,
-0.0025586828,
0.0688111931,
-0.0009292423,
-0.0168961547,
-0.0640399009,
0.0234120153,
-0.0251504071,
0.0022498681,
0.0400687903,
0.0227628276,
-0.0087471325,
0.0009777555,
-0.02275455,
0.0411196314,
-0.0095320102,
-0.0303185973,
-0.0249807183,
0.0530551895,
0.0279106796,
-0.0528361797,
-0.0115512749,
0.003665007,
-0.0303167216,
-0.0294318851,
0.0050571123,
0.0117522581,
-0.0510044321,
-0.0149728237,
0.0189391822,
-0.017003376,
0.0722048506,
0.0458278768,
0.0121330693,
0.0189506449,
-0.003765974,
0.0068322206,
0.0213571209,
0.0771680698,
0.0246947687,
-0.0587827303,
-0.0557161756,
-0.0067302715,
0.0269432198,
-0.0040760087,
0.0305726621,
-0.0081268884,
-0.0380777121,
-0.0406175852,
-0.0455048867,
0.0713093355,
0.0072566839,
-0.0322037153,
-0.0201085657,
0.0244385004,
-0.0171043146,
-0.0785669982,
0.0173968654,
-0.0057437797,
0.0602635853,
0.0532775968,
-0.0038614669,
0.007010065,
0.0387055799,
0.0005657776,
0.0162148271,
0.0027382402,
0.015606801,
0.0338897593,
-0.0792298838,
0.0101945121,
0.0510808006,
0.0646485612,
-0.0185486134,
-0.031723775,
0.0396255404,
-0.0167686753,
-0.0420947298,
-0.0403416418,
-0.0255527124,
0.0294594541,
0.0315423124,
0.002017752,
-0.0040944037,
0.0030954811,
0.0085389074,
-0.0305936355,
0.0339652151,
0.0044476739,
0.000148273,
-0.0026563546,
-0.0302231237,
0.0298885349,
-0.0617524497,
0.0155564789,
0.013139179,
-0.0075182952,
0.0291362647,
0.0143775307,
-0.0394338742,
-0.0522672497,
0.085553579,
-0.000944016,
0.0568880513,
0.0421348959,
0.0306854248,
0.0160062555,
0.0472453311,
-0.004846273,
-0.00004292,
-0.0155612724,
0.0134820323,
0.0033557378,
0.0216406658,
0.0383041389,
0.0311354958,
-0.0083624925,
0.0222412553,
-0.0262478199,
-0.0057356646,
0.0268502273,
0.0000326793,
-0.0575009324,
0.009443298,
-0.01265366,
-0.1403002441,
-0.0183372702,
0.0221540108,
0.0988167822,
-0.0305927508,
-0.0259054415,
0.0197101999,
-0.0227204766,
-0.0626516193,
-0.016063476,
-0.0017160592,
-0.0348850712,
-0.0276825037,
-0.0081570055,
-0.0003346794,
0.0356426463,
0.0150676612,
0.0268138386,
0.0118372785,
-0.0791010112,
-0.0243036542,
-0.0267318487,
0.004033871,
0.0200773925,
-0.0172871258,
0.0293609593,
-0.0460902154,
0.0010926676,
0.0539135896,
0.0400217697,
-0.0343566984,
-0.0265477598,
-0.0025817526,
0.0292874649,
0.0616622157,
0.0033983879,
-0.009429316,
-0.0517796762,
0.0507292934,
-0.0035335752,
0.0248805992,
-0.0609354377,
-0.0183851011,
-0.0123739587,
-0.0125757102,
0.0276335906,
-0.0469417758,
-0.0301863141,
0.0103123533,
0.0144239087,
0.0161927976,
0.010758847,
-0.0476328954,
0.086297214,
-0.0390629731,
0.0062177884,
-0.0177165605,
0.0177380349,
-0.021174401,
-0.029113071,
0.0239055734,
-0.025468953,
0.0346634649,
-0.0365990549,
-0.0184225924,
0.0141771222,
-0.0207921863,
-0.0017624049,
0.0151006551,
0.0362455063,
0.0530827455,
0.0560389869,
-0.0337740704,
-0.0895942971,
0.0194368791,
-0.0204548109,
0.0127784861,
-0.0371839739,
0.0033373218,
0.0058123511,
-0.0494765937,
-0.0546416827,
0.0272000339,
0.0224852171,
0.0479495525,
0.0316950902,
-0.019346891,
0.0076078698,
-0.0154672191,
-0.0015977524,
0.0140849231,
-0.1123877913,
-0.0221061595,
-0.0001348155,
-0.0238600764,
0.0130459219,
-0.058974728,
-0.0092217363,
-0.0045680981,
0.05210701,
-0.0078156507,
-0.0358205549,
-0.0442944132,
-0.0577444695,
0.0339485966,
-0.0207164083,
-0.0660865232,
-0.0293754414,
0.018813869,
-0.0068605649,
-0.0208443291,
0.0062922318,
-0.0010196889,
-0.0224486627,
-0.0346301496,
0.0342182666,
-0.0280291345,
0.0392977558,
-0.0143173756,
-0.0202795286,
0.009232292,
0.0313805304,
-0.0613344498,
-0.0691424459,
-0.0115859853,
0.003416138,
-0.0040181675,
-0.0497048981,
0.0004832536,
0.0218625646,
0.0024223339,
-0.0285574719,
0.1402514279,
-0.0509792492,
0.0278754365,
-0.0426896214,
-0.0396761112,
0.0064992472,
0.0600272641,
-0.0291788839,
0.0390525721,
0.0107070282,
0.0183501933,
-0.0263950117,
0.0297577474,
0.0232547242,
0.0823876783,
-0.059069559,
-0.0101365717,
-0.0087634111,
-0.0195750054,
0.0194560625,
-0.0296801813,
0.0181626137,
0.0179112703,
0.0349670686,
-0.0388419814,
-0.066491574,
0.0101803923,
-0.0818808377,
0.0385980383,
0.0231700372,
-0.03137023,
0.0306526814,
-0.0234905519,
-0.0312829167,
0.0348226689,
0.0116986018,
-0.0333658382,
0.03083908,
-0.007154448,
0.011432033,
-0.0192410871,
0.0193269439,
-0.0086137848,
0.0711166859,
0.0731663257,
-0.0545133129,
-0.0796099529,
-0.0159881618,
0.0851226673,
0.004341241,
0.0060192724,
-0.0174478032,
0.0391349606,
-0.0196676571,
-0.0288737174,
-0.0148866121,
-0.0009340629,
0.0142403422,
0.0359864682,
-0.0269296691,
0.0730513856,
-0.0420237929,
-0.0138260955,
0.0272275358,
-0.0067936578,
-0.0269623902,
-0.0082955547,
0.0155199869,
-0.0483326502,
0.0083443113,
-0.0147431558,
0.0211350191,
0.0541437306,
-0.0099187745,
-0.0482594259,
-0.0105645051,
-0.0100100273,
-0.0457953997,
0.0042821378,
0.0022372419,
0.0032722433,
-0.0043429774,
0.0113951312,
0.0244109593,
-0.0171532277,
0.0083317691,
0.0520566516,
0.0114506185,
-0.0219156891,
0.0161078908,
-0.0651632324,
-0.0459278487,
0.0680210367,
0.0033643267,
0.0174597315,
0.0647591576,
-0.0060584461,
-0.0486688018,
-0.0148309581,
-0.0008074316,
0.0083688824,
0.0234989394,
-0.0228549019,
0.0121061662,
0.0234923065,
0.0104571274,
-0.0177726038,
-0.0100103281,
-0.0471435413,
0.0188179817,
-0.0713929683,
-0.0711327791,
-0.0363910012,
-0.0094488841,
0.0550726727,
0.0658175051,
-0.0260163881,
-0.0192686319,
-0.053583838,
-0.0380002409,
-0.0024274976,
0.0470695347,
-0.0261071064,
-0.0003868786,
0.0043724682,
-0.0510679223,
0.03664314,
-0.0174576212,
-0.0129734538,
-0.0060735485,
-0.0718133599,
-0.021921074,
0.0285409391,
-5.157791134e-33,
-0.0046142288,
-0.0096298745,
0.0260316208,
0.050044924,
-0.0098396186,
-0.0381321833,
0.0400650799,
-0.0491309799,
-0.0031877966,
0.0063455324,
0.0179545805,
0.0397397131,
0.0162278619,
0.0157591142,
-0.0320566669,
-0.0463294052,
0.0426367894,
0.0111546516,
0.0190587342,
-0.0102172475,
0.0459663197,
-0.0036876895,
-0.001286621,
-0.0066775512,
0.0155341215,
-0.0253040716,
-0.0201341677,
0.0433513857,
0.0061627137,
0.028225502,
-0.014332247,
0.0658403561,
0.0126325674,
-0.0323267616,
-0.0319482237,
-0.0270287078,
-0.0840502307,
0.0007198214,
-0.0093118064,
0.0265910868,
0.0091864225,
0.0055374862,
0.0042978837,
-0.0205314402,
0.0581432916,
-0.0091177141,
0.0063309739,
-0.0065565915,
-0.0429440811,
-0.0481161736,
0.025083283,
0.038829945,
-0.01852143,
0.0248079617,
0.050089132,
-0.0605317876,
0.0366796404,
0.0134974364,
-0.0550389402,
0.0610001497,
-0.0411786996,
-0.0334837101,
0.0024835486,
0.0075576226,
0.057349842,
-0.020457387,
0.0445154533,
-0.0048550167,
0.0580188334,
0.0522127412,
-0.0457428582,
0.0546312332,
-0.0355931967,
-0.0223641526,
-0.0337872356,
-0.0084729772,
-0.0697070211,
0.0510024428,
-0.0503750257,
-0.0238488708,
-0.0561783016,
0.0017825679,
-0.031163048,
-0.0080733392,
-0.0221479591,
0.036276415,
-0.0128380973,
0.0661870018,
0.0096131619,
-0.0268142875,
-0.034689948,
0.087201111,
0.0271953885,
-0.0333843008,
-0.0414895453,
0.0211253557,
0.0513322242,
-0.0155229196,
0.0170465466,
0.0085443342,
0.0089301057,
-0.0203424934,
0.002884431,
-0.0144482981,
-0.0052276892,
0.0131474743,
0.0325930156,
0.0197123606,
-0.0494766273,
0.0209229123,
-0.0029212821,
-0.0361882448,
-0.0618848167,
-0.0787761435,
0.0230452344,
0.0300758891,
0.0562061369,
0.0259656608,
0.0640044957,
0.0247618388,
-0.0146674309,
-0.0016646448,
-0.0549218357,
-0.0157902632,
0.0473348498,
0.006759014,
-0.016897615,
-0.0738337338,
0.0494112484,
0.0031419157,
0.0032381935,
0.013811809,
2.772e-7,
0.0273021385,
-0.0158533175,
-0.0349476337,
0.0379345678,
0.0508793183,
-0.0206205584,
0.0002642328,
0.0053520622,
-0.029621413,
-0.0246081073,
0.0623123273,
0.0213486273,
-0.0173248928,
0.0395489521,
-0.0266525242,
-0.0197331458,
0.0342722051,
-0.0713540614,
-0.0712246224,
-0.0077577773,
0.0420075618,
0.0138345733,
0.002085306,
-0.0015367636,
0.0012531844,
0.0367128067,
0.0049357503,
-0.0183014534,
0.0332979448,
0.0358489752,
0.0635713637,
0.0083125494,
0.0236871485,
0.0357752778,
-0.0054587247,
0.0219812877,
-0.0233878791,
0.0034417424,
-0.0116989901,
0.034706708,
-0.0371782966,
-0.07481841,
-0.0038948122,
0.0260221045,
0.0572274104,
-0.0011504008,
-0.0396593362,
0.0231188275,
-0.0231735222,
-0.0061713131,
0.0114645278,
0.0344547182,
-0.0345655568,
-0.0016423638,
-0.0085941507,
0.0281455182,
0.0181912333,
-0.0124719692,
0.0310894791,
-0.0267636348,
-0.0183205307,
-0.0289061125,
0.0023891826,
-0.0070244647,
0.0360641181,
-0.0308187865,
-0.0109104356,
2.22872581e-34,
-0.0086829988,
0.0101265432,
-0.0028838546,
-0.0258483849,
-0.0263171569,
0.0041840626,
0.0179063175,
-0.0199111961,
0.0236793738,
-0.0377490185,
0.0220533479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15372v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15372v2 | EpiK-Eval: Evaluation for Language Models as Epistemic Models | 2023-10-23T21:15:54 | 2024-02-22T20:59:54 | Gabriele Prato, Jerry Huang, Prasannna Parthasarathi, Shagun Sodhani, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the age of artificial intelligence, the role of large language models
(LLMs) is becoming increasingly central. Despite their growing prevalence,
their capacity to consolidate knowledge from different training documents - a
crucial ability in numerous applications - remains unexplored. This paper
presents the first study examining the capability of LLMs to effectively
combine such information within their parameter space. We introduce EpiK-Eval,
a novel question-answering benchmark tailored to evaluate LLMs' proficiency in
formulating a coherent and consistent knowledge representation from segmented
narratives. Evaluations across various LLMs reveal significant weaknesses in
this domain. We contend that these shortcomings stem from the intrinsic nature
of prevailing training objectives. Consequently, we advocate for refining the
approach towards knowledge consolidation, as it harbors the potential to
dramatically improve their overall effectiveness and performance. The findings
from this study offer insights for developing more robust and reliable LLMs.
Our code and benchmark are available at
https://github.com/chandar-lab/EpiK-Eval | [
0.0338939801,
0.0366277508,
-0.0130424853,
0.044218421,
-0.0476322137,
0.0100796605,
-0.0144823967,
-0.0183140952,
-0.0274167825,
-0.0560017452,
0.016753098,
-0.0305750892,
-0.0064998479,
0.0247578118,
-0.0045957295,
-0.0468766876,
0.0198833719,
-0.0467700846,
0.0262201764,
-0.0164753664,
0.0086232405,
0.0496794917,
-0.0077866097,
0.0284729227,
0.0097941393,
-0.0056049186,
-0.0178627204,
-0.0300731845,
-0.0005423418,
0.0101375682,
0.008476764,
0.0024598753,
0.0172942188,
0.0467072055,
0.000002139,
-0.069819726,
0.0043402012,
-0.0034325479,
-0.0506218709,
0.0350729786,
0.0197281633,
-0.0295334905,
0.0136437071,
-0.0158150867,
-0.0234195087,
-0.0018378979,
0.0018979959,
0.0626082793,
0.0796645135,
0.0623597838,
0.016865395,
-0.0535390377,
0.0371896029,
0.0082513262,
-0.007993645,
-0.033016447,
0.0278784595,
0.045994658,
0.0053839954,
-0.0172339715,
-0.0043107001,
0.0400074869,
0.0491843112,
0.0001917342,
-0.0117920311,
0.0222131163,
-0.0514740348,
-0.0038232526,
-0.0156936552,
0.0535520427,
0.0462431088,
-0.0274741706,
-0.0201443303,
0.0181014761,
0.0011216967,
-0.0027835274,
-0.0651968867,
0.0585200302,
-0.0113449078,
0.020179674,
0.0185065027,
-0.006590941,
0.0403598323,
0.0123153115,
-0.0239912309,
0.0842474252,
0.021897899,
-0.0291898344,
0.0050008507,
-0.0214614756,
-0.0177703034,
-0.0746692047,
-0.0164508261,
0.0724127293,
-0.0112969885,
0.0288732108,
-0.0154915806,
0.0251552667,
0.0305108484,
-0.0306132454,
0.0106887016,
0.0303835645,
0.0347641222,
0.066261977,
-0.0242807288,
0.0676287785,
0.0183828473,
0.0307179186,
-0.0692569688,
-0.0427780524,
-0.0899025798,
-0.0317722745,
-0.0164543539,
0.0624815933,
-0.0197753236,
-0.0224417336,
-0.0083937924,
0.024434289,
0.0013204588,
-0.0082722902,
0.0060923561,
0.0159316566,
0.0205858033,
-0.0053191083,
-0.0824107975,
0.0194911417,
-0.0562691055,
0.0097757364,
-0.0011059653,
-0.0445455462,
0.000327856,
0.0212398693,
-0.0479786918,
-0.0056426213,
0.0009772775,
0.0253546219,
0.0155059639,
0.0162661653,
-0.0367647298,
-0.0232617464,
-0.0313127562,
-0.0858455002,
-0.0074293418,
-0.0841766074,
0.0520539284,
0.0037124846,
-0.0108089829,
-0.0241409801,
0.0081526404,
0.0029949644,
-0.0218257122,
0.0586339831,
-0.0009876863,
0.0324604474,
0.0474369712,
0.0407960676,
0.0258298498,
0.0671494529,
0.0575085096,
-0.0007837284,
0.045608148,
0.0072929752,
-0.0070573534,
0.0150717776,
0.0158321448,
0.0066293203,
-0.0054920013,
0.055163078,
0.0113790417,
0.0168571658,
0.0149964457,
0.073949948,
-0.0109115187,
-0.0466394052,
0.0413533822,
0.042285908,
-0.0009160631,
0.0103859166,
0.0723660961,
-0.0047325767,
0.0410609953,
0.0220139995,
-0.0322109386,
-0.002184744,
-0.0199526772,
0.0358541198,
0.0138602676,
0.0374623835,
-0.0305312425,
-0.0453790054,
-0.0358865261,
0.0077033769,
-0.0313766114,
0.0305811446,
0.0360449404,
0.0029651318,
-0.0251580961,
0.082856372,
0.0351914503,
-0.0417917222,
0.0034097882,
-0.0464651138,
0.0498284437,
0.0492239557,
0.0372461863,
-0.0158858187,
-0.049274683,
0.0034169955,
0.0041451375,
0.0219379645,
0.0577893443,
-0.0526735336,
0.0265432652,
-0.0132128252,
0.0007783421,
-0.0661767796,
0.0079292171,
0.0232851356,
0.0238392502,
-0.019489456,
0.0204323474,
-0.0878039598,
-0.0275695194,
0.0396210887,
-0.0390051752,
-0.0166350082,
-0.0468299985,
-0.0089284955,
-0.0002212176,
0.0269205756,
-0.0010880613,
0.020037422,
0.0470888577,
-0.0169540551,
-0.0322141908,
0.0197396278,
-0.0440416895,
-0.0461443961,
0.0620001033,
-0.0566826053,
-0.0274550933,
0.0203378741,
-0.0248878282,
-0.0540333055,
0.011187382,
-0.051225882,
0.0483063199,
-0.0432123877,
0.0234841593,
0.006496748,
-0.0306541473,
-0.0406208783,
0.069710888,
-0.0121684177,
-0.0035960269,
0.0420927256,
-0.0011928024,
0.0353396162,
-0.0419092104,
0.0010483683,
0.031935256,
0.0039526047,
0.0069470326,
0.0272058416,
-0.0172726307,
-0.0612865314,
-0.0423826277,
-0.1101503819,
0.0086343894,
-0.0203393809,
0.009891469,
0.026154222,
-0.0295056514,
0.0036452461,
0.0158096049,
-0.0435749814,
-0.032338731,
0.0270929188,
-0.0092338091,
0.010017992,
0.0220172592,
-0.0261516832,
-0.025324339,
0.0036072358,
-0.0410847887,
0.0485845394,
0.0005976758,
0.0198610704,
-0.0407020114,
-0.0265072174,
-0.0578489304,
-0.0056449352,
-0.0184597187,
-0.0072734402,
0.0177706424,
-0.0089401705,
0.0252624862,
0.018641578,
-0.0020512277,
0.0112515269,
0.0467268899,
-0.0391270779,
-0.0451238118,
0.0108882086,
-0.0069472613,
0.0097037237,
-0.0616938956,
-0.0575820804,
0.0018180861,
0.0581620373,
0.0244421959,
-0.0031322595,
-0.0624718219,
0.0389722176,
-0.0218669493,
-0.0462664142,
-0.04325426,
-0.0117655965,
-0.0070538549,
0.0385840833,
-0.0253057349,
-0.0355919525,
0.0837018117,
-0.054274302,
-0.0006526968,
-0.0296949074,
-0.0312217921,
-0.0662427694,
0.066046685,
-0.0266223215,
0.0218137484,
0.0034591262,
0.0208950583,
-0.0363227539,
-0.0184125695,
-0.0215989016,
-0.0166406874,
0.0424495004,
-0.0697064251,
0.0167746302,
0.0102266697,
-0.0140192397,
-0.0382276997,
-0.0279464014,
-0.0290418174,
0.0547233187,
0.0096533988,
0.012506023,
-0.0319013335,
-0.0030854817,
0.033627145,
-0.0301749837,
-0.0038730027,
-0.0118697062,
-0.009605512,
0.0460643731,
0.0756710917,
0.0120573705,
0.0397340357,
-0.0303444304,
0.0640420467,
0.0523886904,
0.0562579855,
0.0393052995,
-0.0174384974,
-0.0072603836,
0.0052452628,
-0.0664871857,
0.0081681078,
-0.0072017615,
0.0363801159,
-0.0758115426,
-0.0091639161,
0.145495519,
0.0477939472,
0.0102567002,
-0.0028190948,
-0.035689842,
0.0238760132,
0.0206022244,
0.0181637146,
-0.0619108006,
-0.0111938454,
-0.0077288058,
0.0227966048,
0.0050563887,
-0.0193257388,
-0.0095088976,
-0.1194201112,
-0.0074544065,
-0.0099950247,
-0.061861068,
-0.0096016685,
-0.0459472872,
-0.0155024948,
0.0073279031,
0.0291698352,
0.0251688734,
-0.0253363252,
-0.0016003589,
-0.0095775463,
-0.0274259187,
0.0005307917,
0.0701555237,
-0.0309548508,
0.0612164475,
0.0374334753,
0.0469855852,
-0.0160889402,
-0.0161529984,
-0.0095248129,
-0.0434867255,
-0.0246284362,
0.0174863171,
0.0293589532,
-0.0195668377,
0.0189093258,
-0.0074122902,
0.0138167851,
-0.029100081,
-0.0217606667,
0.0302734692,
0.07826709,
-0.0101662455,
-0.0300984569,
-0.0260950029,
0.017744923,
-0.0433636159,
0.1274239421,
0.0343900658,
-0.0091681639,
-0.0487733372,
-0.0220941082,
-0.0251613725,
-0.0380005799,
-0.0321138799,
0.0591483936,
0.0181082897,
0.0500902794,
-0.0664927065,
-0.0855167881,
0.0278603882,
0.0167748388,
0.0111341411,
0.0044373521,
-0.0160345193,
-0.0159077346,
-0.0181904864,
0.0287371147,
-0.0605456382,
0.0050375117,
-0.0368882045,
0.0082194349,
0.021512039,
-0.0276721492,
0.0005497235,
0.0157130882,
-0.059390679,
-0.0637194514,
0.0021913429,
0.0389670096,
0.0234157033,
0.02568461,
-0.0168170482,
-0.0347592868,
0.0542386696,
-0.0302038528,
-0.0437348224,
0.0415131673,
0.0123788435,
0.0129754758,
0.0004528449,
0.0412006713,
-0.0557221472,
0.0088992184,
-0.0270855986,
0.043473091,
-0.0446935408,
-0.0549792349,
0.0348654352,
0.0164317191,
-0.0302676763,
-0.0056436472,
-0.0201270264,
-0.0016387383,
0.00953539,
-0.0404799059,
-0.0261049252,
-0.0146711608,
0.020674305,
0.0260167532,
-0.0176001359,
0.035644304,
0.0303518306,
-0.0080576688,
0.0234431252,
-0.0302424859,
-0.0383409113,
0.0234961119,
-0.0194150303,
-0.0002398234,
-0.0052743438,
-0.0200794935,
0.0051690913,
-0.0417574681,
0.0553017594,
-0.007301738,
0.058256153,
0.0220492873,
-0.0211107321,
-0.0058497838,
0.0135988668,
-0.0897096172,
-0.049624946,
0.016322976,
0.0207694229,
0.0451537296,
-0.0086592278,
0.0606614277,
-0.0149748931,
-0.0174169857,
-0.0212620236,
-0.0262256879,
0.0283219293,
0.0133047104,
0.0449530855,
0.0407367945,
-0.0208663195,
0.0414460227,
0.0537002161,
0.004333613,
0.0691556707,
0.0097952569,
-0.0043986505,
-0.0329409093,
-0.0614076816,
-0.0124537544,
0.0266201925,
-0.0315236934,
-0.0209803265,
-0.0643623099,
-0.0487806387,
0.0121647958,
0.0324593857,
-0.0180308092,
-0.0218512658,
0.0321550034,
0.0655537993,
0.0208853595,
-0.0221317615,
-0.0390948951,
0.0043815635,
-0.0295536462,
0.0197754446,
0.0077895052,
-6.501207424e-33,
-0.0301614851,
-0.0132874288,
0.0455634519,
-0.0277692322,
-0.0372105949,
0.0315230414,
-0.0212361868,
-0.0203018412,
-0.047232829,
0.0170001574,
0.0112515809,
0.0202651098,
-0.0027231134,
0.0158988107,
-0.0278433282,
-0.0174255129,
0.0071323034,
0.02089292,
-0.0364514813,
0.0027274145,
0.0302026011,
-0.0086777983,
0.0222208444,
-0.0451719798,
0.0623140372,
-0.0069699916,
0.0069060866,
0.0359409563,
-0.0351751968,
0.0928663239,
-0.037795715,
0.0342189968,
0.0232009031,
-0.0567388274,
-0.0002920296,
0.0032302402,
-0.0677362159,
-0.0159583017,
0.076335229,
-0.0193493776,
-0.0588185452,
-0.0462275557,
0.0415300876,
0.0071187234,
0.025737511,
-0.0244301092,
0.033967521,
-0.0132550485,
0.0072392435,
0.0098854201,
-0.0644877553,
0.0163817462,
-0.0306352228,
-0.0068145255,
-0.0005319678,
0.0178133808,
0.0215930715,
0.0206266716,
-0.0437744334,
-0.0025299923,
0.0247049239,
0.0119631421,
0.0697577745,
-0.0000044819,
-0.00264931,
0.0630044416,
-0.0045818151,
-0.0190664157,
-0.0561259277,
-0.0021925003,
0.0050117625,
0.0407823212,
0.0501063503,
0.0356778465,
-0.0426857322,
0.0399762802,
-0.0733978748,
0.0332469307,
0.0198259298,
0.0539590456,
0.0157124028,
-0.003344862,
-0.0346310064,
-0.0095694112,
-0.0877647772,
0.00121072,
-0.0233571343,
-0.0133020077,
0.0325866938,
-0.0112267574,
-0.019704055,
-0.0127174687,
0.0118103819,
-0.0652880371,
0.0189129338,
0.0240367074,
-0.0265567601,
0.0214266554,
0.0056571546,
0.0664296672,
-0.0538278073,
0.0484830588,
0.0155979665,
0.0105145844,
0.006744334,
0.0065174834,
0.0122907367,
0.0001436927,
-0.0051078615,
0.0180381574,
-0.0361423232,
-0.0167476535,
-0.035343688,
-0.0116622066,
0.0183937643,
0.0648379996,
-0.0145301381,
0.0119312247,
0.0262669828,
-0.004097525,
-0.0211177841,
-0.0323674195,
0.0227172896,
0.0092715481,
-0.0321580693,
0.0141357221,
-0.019074209,
0.0071048085,
0.0160448924,
-0.0106942598,
0.0004397221,
0.0454232208,
2.674e-7,
0.0557069257,
0.0273487698,
0.0552334674,
0.0281690042,
0.0024439897,
0.0147292456,
-0.0055403048,
-0.0057481057,
0.0060787657,
-0.0645307228,
-0.021985637,
0.0941511765,
0.0469979718,
0.0548292845,
-0.0640666783,
0.0054764766,
-0.0509880967,
-0.0526399389,
-0.0658467636,
0.0354426093,
0.0600408465,
0.0565021746,
0.0284871385,
-0.0224609543,
-0.0261815116,
-0.0430399813,
0.0627475455,
-0.0314114019,
-0.0461752303,
0.0581399538,
0.0139588434,
0.0265140999,
0.0082175871,
0.01035849,
0.0292964038,
0.0238474179,
-0.0008649217,
0.0727931634,
0.0104688741,
-0.0502277203,
-0.0165306199,
-0.0563735925,
0.0133043993,
-0.0903379098,
0.1079669148,
-0.0383021235,
-0.021742288,
-0.0217564553,
0.0063026748,
-0.0002012948,
0.0129679097,
-0.0202143099,
-0.0095691029,
0.0202044901,
-0.0176969711,
-0.015397381,
0.0124447504,
-0.0511822812,
-0.0179756712,
0.0232016351,
-0.0291336328,
-0.0535535365,
-0.0125590023,
-0.0121340984,
-0.0071511399,
-0.1024559364,
0.0163880587,
2.546512901e-34,
0.0311141089,
0.0052470542,
0.0019254696,
0.0352687798,
0.0474151634,
-0.015166468,
-0.0307206288,
-0.0208088327,
0.0021272691,
-0.0886511132,
0.0074275164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15355v1 | Why LLMs Hallucinate, and How to Get (Evidential) Closure: Perceptual, Intensional, and Extensional Learning for Faithful Natural Language Generation | 2023-10-23T20:35:52 | 2023-10-23T20:35:52 | Adam Bouyamourn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | We show that LLMs hallucinate because their output is not constrained to be
synonymous with claims for which they have evidence: a condition that we call
evidential closure. Information about the truth or falsity of sentences is not
statistically identified in the standard neural probabilistic language model
setup, and so cannot be conditioned on to generate new strings. We then show
how to constrain LLMs to produce output that does satisfy evidential closure. A
multimodal LLM must learn about the external world (perceptual learning); it
must learn a mapping from strings to states of the world (extensional
learning); and, to achieve fluency when generalizing beyond a body of evidence,
it must learn mappings from strings to their synonyms (intensional learning).
The output of a unimodal LLM must be synonymous with strings in a validated
evidence set. Finally, we present a heuristic procedure, Learn-Babble-Prune,
that yields faithful output from an LLM by rejecting output that is not
synonymous with claims for which the LLM has evidence. | [
0.0328976661,
0.0678878725,
-0.0254759621,
0.0223432519,
-0.0717187002,
-0.0091039399,
-0.062399365,
0.0025091774,
-0.0168365128,
-0.0306551922,
-0.0133068841,
-0.012836691,
0.0235576816,
0.007441448,
0.0604322851,
-0.026373582,
0.0597825274,
-0.0199048314,
-0.0084833503,
-0.0269864574,
-0.0121782077,
-0.0245864335,
-0.0001858967,
0.010554322,
-0.0427064225,
0.0436121933,
-0.0058915336,
-0.0258280486,
-0.014371017,
0.01496532,
-0.0239739828,
0.0141554708,
0.0182813015,
0.0272804219,
0.0000016507,
-0.0675110072,
-0.0042212778,
-0.0376508348,
0.0059802723,
-0.0283512976,
0.0055268789,
-0.0165825915,
0.0170919374,
-0.0167574678,
-0.019227542,
0.0262036547,
0.0387034602,
0.0044274046,
0.0384314619,
0.0815364048,
0.0219294522,
-0.0008677316,
0.0254318547,
-0.0281285979,
0.0542145558,
0.0166572183,
0.0112751452,
0.0120896939,
0.0133168679,
-0.0218697619,
-0.0450065471,
0.0303606,
0.0197699592,
0.0092535568,
-0.0321048498,
0.0497137196,
0.0059220032,
-0.0394057408,
0.0173153579,
0.0272864439,
-0.0213051792,
-0.0581989065,
0.0064538284,
-0.0079104137,
0.0128264213,
0.0000965017,
-0.0238557365,
0.1017821878,
-0.0334417149,
0.0488074347,
0.0274645947,
-0.0140132476,
0.0287609398,
0.0044447882,
-0.0096541736,
0.066365853,
0.0097888988,
-0.027273247,
-0.0009243396,
0.0268755648,
-0.0117611727,
-0.0452109687,
-0.0119989412,
0.0257766992,
0.0015763458,
0.0491907932,
-0.0587813333,
0.0434891768,
0.0226433761,
-0.0122360094,
0.0011753531,
0.032347519,
-0.0243984126,
0.0175375491,
-0.0730639547,
-0.0061776438,
-0.0128466645,
0.0545079485,
-0.0134914704,
0.0054528764,
-0.0334341712,
-0.0176796149,
-0.0003824795,
0.0618573576,
0.0144338356,
-0.0113646016,
-0.0278998818,
0.0115314014,
-0.0127582205,
0.0314661711,
-0.0332120955,
0.0037190127,
-0.0304494034,
-0.0119966408,
-0.0724291652,
-0.0121542411,
-0.0172748417,
0.0630170256,
0.0236383621,
-0.0508215539,
-0.0206467435,
0.064034082,
-0.0140181333,
0.0315210409,
0.0087617952,
0.0668166429,
-0.0096357809,
-0.0275557432,
-0.1056761146,
-0.0638201386,
-0.0319762118,
-0.0634725466,
0.0273611229,
-0.0449951887,
0.010926703,
-0.0205355883,
-0.0223601125,
-0.0656468719,
0.005874129,
0.0098135211,
-0.0168193839,
0.0437382869,
-0.0220205765,
0.0071957624,
0.0053085745,
0.0106287757,
-0.0025070549,
0.0143117681,
0.0107561881,
0.0539204888,
-0.0001169156,
0.019157555,
0.0258122757,
-0.0047795633,
0.050011415,
-0.0038839525,
-0.0625676587,
-0.0602149889,
-0.0107876863,
0.0234510582,
0.0697563812,
0.0661757067,
-0.0618864782,
-0.0410697609,
0.0792851523,
-0.0239096154,
0.0020266147,
0.0032765979,
0.0861753523,
-0.0549807511,
0.0037917113,
0.1031709388,
-0.0565365963,
0.0296708141,
-0.0369183347,
0.0181727465,
0.0454902537,
-0.0081360498,
-0.0232122689,
-0.0539530814,
0.0188015681,
-0.0162323974,
-0.0264208149,
-0.0313704275,
0.0117277354,
0.0566191599,
-0.0257270765,
0.0351978876,
0.020205617,
-0.0226849671,
0.0605532788,
-0.0582585186,
0.0636359975,
0.0129437279,
0.0280909315,
0.0026809273,
0.007186769,
-0.0028778536,
-0.0059827757,
0.0848925859,
0.0081355581,
0.0088248635,
0.011918637,
-0.0123143755,
-0.015036054,
-0.0406932198,
0.0303962491,
0.0066813729,
-0.0184704959,
-0.029977506,
-0.0011256391,
-0.0200695619,
-0.0067932312,
0.0702036694,
-0.0257658716,
-0.0323083885,
-0.0034233152,
-0.025903834,
0.0455276668,
-0.0224386938,
-0.0102693085,
0.0581164099,
0.0178540163,
-0.0221842304,
-0.0276172981,
0.0415922701,
-0.0275608972,
-0.0235212911,
0.047193367,
-0.0553471446,
0.0310539491,
-0.0304335449,
-0.0175373014,
-0.0446295552,
0.0317092016,
-0.0756081194,
0.0323580466,
-0.0648285896,
0.0257022083,
0.017601816,
0.0110534662,
-0.0284372903,
0.083751224,
-0.04911476,
-0.0044662249,
0.0400815345,
0.0316778049,
0.0098543279,
-0.0332010016,
-0.0007143796,
-0.0094261067,
0.0295025371,
0.02097244,
0.024600273,
-0.0150881056,
-0.0498271845,
-0.0531454161,
-0.0227716826,
0.0027335437,
0.01303994,
0.0016889538,
0.032015726,
-0.0374861956,
0.004685591,
-0.020223679,
-0.0277057942,
0.0369642079,
0.0617129616,
-0.0000184513,
0.0415908359,
-0.0070149642,
-0.0125111062,
-0.0333410837,
0.0268593598,
0.0085167643,
0.0206887927,
-0.0065273596,
-0.0217749998,
-0.0980041847,
0.0180838034,
-0.0779634714,
0.0120432219,
0.0044523492,
0.009977337,
0.0400281586,
0.0056991219,
-0.0117387325,
0.0440829769,
0.0230910368,
-0.0275611617,
0.0661234632,
0.0141843995,
-0.0505484156,
-0.0165073872,
-0.061655242,
-0.0110290833,
-0.0029014796,
-0.0582024865,
0.0065253251,
0.0443790592,
0.0653657615,
0.0021234073,
-0.0327506848,
0.0614017732,
0.0415791795,
-0.0593910515,
0.0515958183,
-0.0402419232,
-0.0455370694,
0.0261852294,
-0.0292964876,
-0.0977215245,
0.0476339087,
-0.0449684225,
0.049145136,
-0.0203712955,
0.0001390364,
0.0234143808,
0.0417861901,
0.0450795367,
0.0247817114,
0.0155518353,
-0.0043811225,
-0.0497042872,
-0.0210062396,
0.0186207667,
0.0084556248,
0.028043244,
-0.0314031541,
0.0166396722,
0.0163006112,
0.0160461944,
-0.0864021629,
-0.0127893668,
0.0117356209,
-0.0250472166,
-0.033367373,
0.0266482569,
-0.0190275479,
-0.0091433357,
0.0639281943,
0.0263342913,
0.0222153962,
-0.0189524274,
-0.0551873371,
0.024943985,
0.0287062898,
0.0263485443,
0.0341843292,
-0.0300122481,
-0.0528114997,
0.0659345761,
-0.0521379821,
0.0695558861,
-0.0417194888,
0.0141888484,
-0.0089407526,
-0.0022280535,
-0.0444268547,
0.0266521182,
0.0109228166,
-0.0219230913,
-0.0141024459,
0.0635183007,
0.0115176206,
0.0009934887,
0.0337935686,
-0.012749848,
0.0462949984,
0.0117467493,
-0.0025995832,
-0.0514577441,
-0.0009779823,
0.0058873687,
-0.0077957548,
-0.0356073193,
-0.04122141,
-0.0279878061,
-0.0828298181,
0.0206695441,
0.030236857,
-0.0165364537,
0.0003807259,
-0.0079091843,
0.0018042673,
0.0348997712,
0.0039486466,
0.0393836685,
0.004557197,
0.0246239956,
0.0241991933,
0.0240007583,
-0.0433588289,
-0.039118778,
-0.0271841977,
0.0505481362,
0.0448450483,
-0.0171627942,
-0.0025516078,
-0.0676498562,
0.0534195118,
0.0201399606,
0.0130023127,
-0.0283067413,
0.0177902784,
0.0220199563,
0.0032190692,
0.0104438402,
0.0332424119,
-0.0076646744,
-0.0212085489,
-0.0076391604,
0.0591311008,
-0.043723654,
-0.0577095598,
-0.0106609426,
0.048547525,
-0.0218813568,
0.0626976788,
0.0579713769,
0.005235685,
0.0014181896,
-0.0235107187,
0.0149135198,
-0.0082275616,
-0.0209149439,
0.0601866543,
0.01924292,
-0.0085861664,
-0.1021974459,
-0.016532585,
-0.0239675678,
0.0646414161,
0.0052875038,
0.0105397655,
-0.0137997791,
-0.0635780096,
0.00936177,
0.0088179074,
-0.0494503044,
-0.0553389043,
-0.0158582386,
-0.0069528567,
0.0247426052,
-0.0501839072,
0.0067087896,
0.0362368599,
-0.0508357771,
-0.0827212706,
-0.0319613777,
0.0670808032,
0.0381209068,
0.0271554533,
0.0345846973,
-0.0548363477,
0.0153916832,
0.0242726374,
0.0209000353,
0.0672882572,
-0.0001556264,
-0.0021786692,
-0.0069957413,
0.0339448489,
0.0170684271,
0.0162466466,
0.0462562554,
0.042283427,
0.012085015,
-0.0024400037,
0.074340418,
0.0246825852,
-0.0122540174,
-0.057099212,
0.0124273552,
-0.0456442311,
-0.046967648,
0.0208833758,
-0.0074912226,
-0.0329980552,
0.0330776609,
0.0206560716,
0.0371480323,
0.0085759778,
-0.0723529905,
-0.0358921848,
0.0732005537,
0.0243754536,
-0.0783096552,
0.0309973378,
0.0083135385,
-0.0177157428,
-0.0110795405,
-0.0181830991,
0.0340592228,
-0.0477484018,
0.0287410747,
-0.0138305407,
0.0346443579,
0.0428223535,
0.0125280423,
-0.0557499975,
-0.0155315958,
-0.018734606,
-0.0294959918,
-0.0290524252,
0.0548182689,
0.0531931445,
0.0310704987,
0.0157108922,
-0.0548619144,
0.01709654,
-0.008368724,
0.0427916721,
0.0360344164,
-0.0300648268,
0.0352070667,
0.001783439,
-0.0436449088,
-0.0017728374,
0.071943596,
-0.0225803908,
0.0516167432,
-0.034379147,
0.0283507332,
-0.0451025851,
-0.0849572495,
-0.0011449479,
0.0242823325,
-0.0126888063,
0.0088757854,
-0.0160048418,
-0.0667773709,
0.0085419621,
0.0526626445,
0.0236689448,
-0.0203714818,
0.0176512226,
0.0510305576,
0.0029175412,
0.0049159089,
-0.0115879504,
0.0046967715,
0.0732907653,
0.0059239622,
0.0060606017,
-5.828382375e-33,
-0.0476482287,
-0.036846865,
0.0419692919,
-0.0231067631,
0.0077001057,
-0.0047091041,
-0.0259933043,
0.0218988974,
-0.0033284286,
-0.0053399196,
0.0268368106,
-0.0197856259,
0.0012789161,
0.001168725,
-0.0029458096,
-0.0148162935,
0.0238864068,
0.0012087035,
-0.0403013192,
-0.0061244853,
0.0480889827,
-0.0118213966,
0.0519108586,
-0.059648782,
0.0390218385,
0.0248801149,
-0.0610647202,
0.0265404265,
-0.0467168652,
0.0182104893,
-0.0394174047,
0.0119465841,
0.0357864685,
0.0037791173,
-0.0418377072,
-0.0149505651,
-0.020748252,
-0.0384336114,
0.0734356195,
-0.0426333025,
-0.0940191075,
-0.0177274067,
0.0964440629,
-0.0332003981,
-0.0328082033,
0.0462162308,
0.011875486,
-0.0366129428,
-0.0311060324,
0.0216818545,
-0.0590482801,
0.0084948456,
0.0636783093,
-0.0063434704,
-0.0656952113,
-0.0134319775,
-0.0243504476,
0.0128231542,
-0.0499712601,
0.025714267,
-0.0122523718,
0.0317841992,
0.0442059003,
-0.0124754664,
-0.0028595808,
0.0848812312,
0.0422361754,
-0.0065182,
0.0173296202,
-0.0019541876,
0.0275729094,
0.0319658853,
0.0346201621,
0.0655616075,
0.006157761,
-0.0057781739,
-0.0590053089,
-0.0054882234,
0.0566502549,
0.0078447396,
0.0189969111,
-0.0301098805,
0.0222825818,
-0.0164677519,
-0.0588275269,
-0.044363942,
-0.016906891,
-0.023534786,
0.0248746425,
0.0562112778,
0.0070827804,
-0.0339760222,
0.0170120336,
-0.0059087994,
0.0124905547,
-0.0129939271,
-0.0550348908,
-0.0081774807,
0.021918945,
-0.0145234484,
-0.0388220288,
-0.0500432402,
-0.0225768462,
-0.0245037396,
0.0086147133,
0.0181330927,
0.0207154602,
0.037321113,
-0.020553425,
0.0275330935,
-0.0489055775,
0.0294401366,
0.0149064884,
-0.0483749062,
0.0588304512,
-0.0134161254,
-0.0348256007,
-0.0061616749,
0.0029761465,
-0.0303979777,
0.0050687506,
0.0213211253,
-0.0003171511,
0.0818124712,
-0.0295639001,
-0.0172571242,
-0.0173012801,
-0.0232438687,
0.0240401886,
-0.0813864991,
0.013567212,
0.0298694633,
2.641e-7,
-0.0024700013,
-0.0092179924,
0.0216259882,
0.0024769085,
0.0425978862,
-0.0088799354,
-0.0359509252,
0.0258954689,
-0.0095941536,
-0.0811283588,
-0.026823217,
-0.0072299847,
0.0196041595,
0.0164221209,
-0.0372435264,
0.0072976188,
-0.0262429956,
0.0029724652,
-0.0283222366,
-0.0060775611,
0.0430701897,
0.0605582371,
0.0053138612,
-0.0350432023,
0.0228368286,
-0.0931508169,
0.09234339,
0.0165979229,
-0.0089023132,
0.0093370713,
0.075845249,
0.0004740342,
0.0031937102,
0.0236266572,
0.0293598156,
-0.0038610969,
-0.0169417486,
0.0409805737,
0.0442953706,
-0.0376083963,
-0.012036995,
-0.0261235815,
0.0170933157,
-0.0449086614,
0.0344615653,
-0.0397580974,
-0.016434323,
-0.0046880511,
0.0042638499,
-0.0060051475,
-0.0074216574,
-0.0096289003,
-0.0465972908,
0.0067273527,
0.0185709447,
0.0676432401,
-0.0327842049,
-0.0432859994,
-0.0211342033,
-0.0487858541,
-0.0748917088,
-0.0431162789,
-0.0099672209,
-0.0103993881,
0.0487398095,
-0.0760737881,
-0.0220270567,
2.421685962e-34,
0.0305859875,
-0.0456680208,
0.0482967682,
-0.0140379909,
0.0144946622,
0.0046771364,
0.0074248514,
0.0205844957,
0.0287488978,
-0.0321377032,
-0.0384445228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18354v1 | A Review of Reinforcement Learning for Natural Language Processing, and Applications in Healthcare | 2023-10-23T20:26:15 | 2023-10-23T20:26:15 | Ying Liu, Haozhu Wang, Huixue Zhou, Mingchen Li, Yu Hou, Sicheng Zhou, Fang Wang, Rama Hoetzlein, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning (RL) has emerged as a powerful approach for tackling
complex medical decision-making problems such as treatment planning,
personalized medicine, and optimizing the scheduling of surgeries and
appointments. It has gained significant attention in the field of Natural
Language Processing (NLP) due to its ability to learn optimal strategies for
tasks such as dialogue systems, machine translation, and question-answering.
This paper presents a review of the RL techniques in NLP, highlighting key
advancements, challenges, and applications in healthcare. The review begins by
visualizing a roadmap of machine learning and its applications in healthcare.
And then it explores the integration of RL with NLP tasks. We examined dialogue
systems where RL enables the learning of conversational strategies, RL-based
machine translation models, question-answering systems, text summarization, and
information extraction. Additionally, ethical considerations and biases in
RL-NLP systems are addressed. | [
0.1051472127,
0.0611706674,
-0.0113174925,
-0.026160799,
-0.0627739727,
0.0259931963,
-0.0292675719,
0.0002529883,
-0.0046125771,
-0.0075202575,
0.015968442,
-0.0231883228,
0.0108756116,
0.0272031706,
-0.0309777036,
-0.0870268419,
0.0461831577,
0.0170594286,
0.0655219927,
0.028136367,
-0.0211340263,
0.0151269212,
-0.0431381986,
0.0526966192,
0.0240652934,
0.0148800798,
0.0098601226,
-0.0451988876,
0.047528591,
-0.0552936271,
-0.0044181836,
0.0006793389,
0.0088949623,
0.0095169265,
0.0000018675,
-0.0693416446,
-0.0446938202,
0.0083374484,
-0.0286113955,
-0.0910280198,
0.0578740723,
-0.0717819408,
-0.0065193796,
0.0425533466,
-0.0440055616,
-0.0122426022,
0.0520692244,
0.0697759613,
0.0537948348,
0.070222348,
-0.0030571101,
0.0028569035,
0.0049433438,
-0.0092273364,
0.0133497594,
-0.0428750664,
0.0202651583,
-0.0121296197,
0.0379663259,
-0.0502915829,
0.0125770429,
0.0368333757,
-0.0054411581,
0.0199548099,
-0.0279332548,
0.0464333855,
0.0016523883,
-0.0159626137,
-0.0413883105,
0.0527896434,
-0.0002436052,
0.0160527173,
0.0407089591,
-0.0101648699,
0.0009384459,
0.001104195,
-0.0123880589,
0.0311168376,
-0.0222643465,
0.0068262029,
-0.0025316642,
0.0083858687,
1.024e-7,
0.0162802618,
-0.0091057019,
-0.0048515177,
-0.0188231841,
-0.0431972668,
0.0197509173,
0.0114507396,
0.0261146855,
-0.0412476957,
-0.0007166881,
0.0517445728,
-0.0899367854,
0.0364188477,
-0.012819468,
0.013828082,
0.0743053183,
-0.043542631,
-0.0004306088,
-0.0020741979,
0.0635531321,
0.0207203142,
0.0343665667,
0.0217370205,
-0.0124725429,
0.0329497345,
-0.0464543328,
0.0218784846,
-0.0434449725,
-0.0012496611,
-0.0304955337,
0.03741825,
-0.0391235761,
-0.0002787839,
-0.0729025528,
0.0068865605,
-0.0023652385,
0.0291892271,
-0.0151169188,
0.0464568026,
-0.0313401446,
0.0221419372,
-0.0850325599,
-0.0127526326,
-0.0177425314,
-0.0208186451,
-0.0018838679,
-0.0294520501,
0.0133309914,
-0.0284154937,
0.0096769109,
-0.001015239,
-0.0042337268,
0.112171635,
-0.0159339514,
-0.0146519989,
0.0169894379,
-0.0215024985,
-0.0296659153,
-0.0453382581,
0.0137591576,
-0.0571135208,
0.0219639875,
-0.0309595559,
-0.0174499843,
-0.0140960813,
0.0317890011,
0.0348926969,
-0.0531648956,
0.0611964986,
-0.0045203683,
0.0038796284,
0.0247752443,
0.0031560434,
0.0121381488,
0.0288116019,
0.0408584066,
-0.0343428291,
0.0066605713,
-0.0252879802,
0.0072622364,
-0.030348409,
0.0344773978,
-0.0425314866,
0.0147131048,
0.0201651827,
-0.0047338004,
0.0695399791,
-0.0576355122,
0.0829860494,
-0.0223068465,
0.012862483,
0.0225815177,
0.0829726234,
-0.0149990525,
-0.0034872943,
0.0078555467,
0.0062549738,
-0.0140281487,
0.0080953026,
-0.015517748,
0.0068782326,
0.0230857097,
0.0129046543,
0.0027733101,
-0.0057872147,
0.0012544006,
-0.0769271702,
-0.0108654946,
-0.0179370791,
0.0424202867,
0.0260046255,
0.0076014651,
0.0134937111,
-0.04581552,
-0.0262287911,
0.0383953489,
0.0249721296,
-0.0343405642,
-0.0716984197,
-0.0105003761,
0.070775792,
0.0530607589,
-0.0599351376,
-0.0264387149,
-0.0687106326,
-0.0148557751,
0.0404516347,
0.0449763201,
-0.0203945227,
0.0045791757,
-0.013526612,
-0.0048997761,
0.0304894149,
-0.0105825309,
0.0062802164,
0.0111844316,
0.0265541114,
-0.0379640236,
0.053655941,
-0.0399502739,
0.0483861342,
-0.0168322232,
-0.0422143936,
0.0460483804,
0.0063092574,
0.055311285,
0.0152227767,
-0.0124179181,
0.022659244,
0.0128560569,
0.0162344072,
-0.0377291664,
0.0193121172,
-0.0425657332,
-0.0686873496,
-0.0069679781,
-0.0211733934,
-0.0099231349,
-0.039568428,
-0.036955338,
-0.018277796,
-0.0257729646,
-0.0806483552,
0.0207923874,
0.0033018158,
-0.007458366,
0.0275313072,
-0.0192465708,
-0.0889835656,
0.0404796414,
-0.0320528336,
0.0229374804,
0.0241625365,
-0.0485996306,
-0.0139176091,
-0.0650293231,
0.0226715636,
0.0181600992,
0.0054507307,
0.0280035287,
0.037060339,
0.0699366629,
-0.0134665295,
-0.0197160617,
-0.0520811751,
-0.0077008749,
0.0128030581,
-0.0073478222,
-0.0018262581,
0.0329272449,
-0.0088197859,
-0.056607224,
-0.0197432637,
-0.0275487322,
0.0848082826,
-0.0092309369,
0.0484450869,
0.0631259158,
0.0086642802,
-0.0292271562,
-0.0174667742,
-0.0221319143,
0.0116466386,
0.0181078166,
-0.0050897631,
-0.0149348835,
-0.0531022996,
-0.0269439556,
0.016725719,
0.0066875042,
-0.0214414783,
0.0300090685,
-0.0001071952,
-0.0075833262,
0.0471759588,
0.0173102543,
0.023463726,
0.0144070275,
0.0176251456,
-0.0381861925,
0.0531440303,
-0.0795482397,
-0.0413302779,
-0.0074217087,
-0.0415725149,
0.0333383121,
0.0657505244,
0.030977698,
0.0168257896,
-0.0217973385,
0.0356856845,
0.0010110381,
-0.0350368433,
-0.0330330208,
0.0185850468,
-0.0397154093,
0.0745996311,
-0.0007931142,
-0.0321962982,
0.127992779,
0.0557949767,
0.0448168851,
-0.1392804682,
-0.0269262716,
-0.035499271,
-0.0310391374,
-0.0000871481,
0.0366370678,
0.0177296773,
-0.0323783979,
0.0105009293,
-0.0324283764,
0.0070869443,
-0.0499145836,
0.0587017015,
-0.014995357,
0.0095480764,
0.0141539369,
-0.0615359098,
-0.0725226626,
0.0031692388,
-0.0156650655,
-0.0280933417,
0.0115655428,
0.0234977957,
-0.0649515763,
-0.0208645519,
0.008195091,
0.0464501418,
0.0311187822,
-0.0276049394,
-0.0206247736,
0.0114028212,
0.0338602364,
0.0142785544,
0.0178558454,
0.019526992,
0.0492804945,
0.0384428389,
0.031670332,
0.0014724977,
0.0194204468,
0.0144536039,
-0.0144739766,
-0.073829703,
0.0342397392,
0.0630823597,
-0.01609868,
-0.0460447483,
-0.0016517325,
0.0854062885,
0.0596716776,
-0.0352055468,
-0.0013885167,
-0.0232743621,
-0.0141506987,
-0.0245720036,
0.0533329546,
-0.060027983,
-0.0109708756,
-0.0240368415,
0.0428402387,
-0.0354954228,
-0.031661246,
0.0128670568,
-0.0750691965,
0.0259217527,
-0.0204154011,
-0.0703908429,
-0.0321047045,
-0.0309949089,
-0.0037190632,
-0.0187662244,
0.0049993461,
-0.0198830198,
-0.0432470217,
-0.028074706,
0.0065449057,
-0.0484789461,
-0.040168643,
-0.0005274564,
-0.0058599608,
0.0224131625,
0.1015564725,
0.0681362227,
-0.0007957728,
0.0048029344,
-0.0196217876,
0.0269248541,
0.0146911442,
-0.0263599418,
0.0713018924,
0.0064969035,
0.0034499357,
-0.0733502656,
0.0224348027,
0.0186725128,
-0.0362616554,
0.008259248,
0.0635439679,
-0.0387499779,
-0.0072677243,
-0.0485838763,
0.0610399731,
0.0492521897,
0.0216081198,
-0.0256116819,
-0.0191180091,
-0.0771702901,
-0.0101592271,
0.0209638812,
-0.0344468579,
-0.0025410075,
-0.0238049664,
-0.0287808347,
0.0019524674,
-0.0963404477,
-0.0368853807,
0.0099598002,
-0.0226703398,
0.0119688967,
-0.0013654386,
0.0550642423,
0.0473607257,
-0.04556733,
-0.0251230262,
0.0190900657,
0.0016166713,
-0.0301029719,
-0.0313411132,
0.0169966221,
-0.0348333977,
-0.035079848,
-0.0230847821,
0.0187854134,
-0.0144893341,
-0.037601795,
0.1005146056,
0.010857014,
0.0641167089,
-0.0088432906,
0.0151017364,
0.0253450088,
0.0214122739,
-0.0489140451,
-0.0419349633,
0.0124892378,
0.0677527711,
-0.0175479166,
0.002112363,
-0.015258274,
0.0206600819,
-0.0318389907,
0.0245803446,
-0.0404151268,
-0.0248036273,
0.0256060548,
-0.002713704,
0.0034243367,
-0.0025862183,
-0.0228275396,
-0.0126605928,
0.0182922035,
0.0057642469,
-0.0235489476,
-0.016221853,
-0.0112546925,
-0.011591848,
0.0247827563,
0.0250388831,
-0.0159997195,
-0.060559012,
-0.0316723101,
0.0136011802,
0.045777481,
0.0659651086,
0.0124544734,
-0.007566133,
0.015399497,
0.0100807454,
0.0334545821,
0.0203525349,
0.0634996369,
0.0293437522,
0.0761277378,
0.0257115345,
0.0079532154,
0.0079971487,
0.0259222016,
-0.0600407384,
-0.059372656,
0.0045138928,
0.0177637395,
0.0108072041,
0.0195098631,
0.0012851463,
-0.023552319,
-0.004591764,
0.0064158128,
0.0222121496,
-0.0304738451,
0.0215471331,
0.0313904583,
0.0213102307,
0.0019195095,
-0.0223190971,
0.0493990481,
0.0015171163,
0.0081408564,
-0.0158173237,
-0.0474764854,
-0.0621940494,
-0.0289459825,
-0.0149955796,
0.0187845547,
-0.0261836499,
0.0131603181,
-0.0415206775,
-0.0057536829,
0.0001323985,
0.0206680391,
-0.0054905056,
-0.0397315137,
0.0822048634,
0.0045456826,
0.0335385241,
-0.0208516419,
-0.0661924332,
0.0334130861,
-0.0271301493,
-0.0109721478,
-0.0006253728,
-5.110420548e-33,
0.0071675507,
-0.0324948281,
0.0421162695,
-0.0152671393,
-0.0157474075,
0.0112293828,
-0.0249984656,
-0.0170783177,
0.0050482368,
0.0098240394,
-0.0194753818,
-0.0240631644,
-0.0023693421,
0.0246101357,
-0.000925123,
-0.0573788732,
0.013425447,
-0.0029506478,
-0.0245096684,
0.0098638302,
-0.0324742533,
0.0318558551,
0.0432746336,
-0.0650234148,
0.0154686989,
0.035063453,
0.0297116842,
0.0397986062,
-0.0354986377,
0.051970616,
-0.0139200836,
0.0125629697,
0.0313775577,
-0.0460652523,
0.0021627857,
0.0528675094,
-0.1113519892,
-0.0358635448,
0.0199401043,
-0.0033847939,
-0.0873963162,
-0.009496172,
0.047221899,
-0.0016872793,
0.0004147284,
-0.0034778158,
0.026444139,
-0.0259413589,
0.0013304114,
0.0089409668,
-0.0425823107,
0.0237118211,
-0.0176626518,
-0.0235138983,
-0.0000469431,
0.0411783755,
-0.0560017824,
0.0194543321,
-0.0057113832,
0.0161909834,
0.0315159746,
-0.005926548,
0.0037168772,
-0.0062238555,
-0.006519685,
0.035183955,
0.0051860115,
-0.0320864134,
-0.0475346483,
0.0214839038,
-0.0598407388,
0.0352726392,
0.033168003,
0.0383391418,
-0.0079238014,
0.02817077,
-0.0599426366,
0.0252526905,
-0.0209314357,
0.0776300654,
0.0395466201,
-0.0301509742,
-0.0576444492,
-0.0047636521,
-0.0439924635,
0.0160659663,
-0.001412655,
-0.0279597398,
0.0302930474,
0.0301198289,
-0.0180076733,
0.0177613553,
-0.0164158456,
-0.0192047544,
0.0356136672,
-0.0050882143,
0.0359641463,
-0.0217344444,
-0.0434365198,
-0.0458221175,
-0.0725263581,
0.0220151767,
0.0104923025,
-0.023810979,
0.0326876119,
0.0041893008,
-0.0005647216,
-0.0327929519,
-0.0403927937,
0.0357779711,
0.031674847,
0.0822288319,
-0.022991037,
0.0608814918,
0.0350975618,
0.0129075618,
-0.0019264984,
0.0518291518,
-0.0080776308,
-0.0306832064,
-0.0408355668,
-0.0322375074,
-0.006650399,
0.0067123575,
-0.07261464,
0.0183736347,
-0.0277205054,
0.0780774802,
-0.0204336289,
-0.0531565323,
0.009565088,
-0.0024530531,
2.6e-7,
0.0474738441,
0.0692713261,
0.0564944781,
0.0016370398,
0.0326722674,
0.024958238,
0.0171079896,
0.0168510415,
0.0140588293,
0.0091423001,
0.0542037785,
0.0057841479,
0.0053865612,
0.0120181646,
-0.0877524763,
-0.0423444211,
-0.0996478945,
-0.0248372145,
-0.0282026846,
-0.0406311937,
0.0370036252,
0.0528506711,
-0.0242812689,
-0.0327590257,
-0.0096527683,
0.0295424648,
0.0096920785,
-0.0299877599,
-0.0057633035,
0.0277287625,
0.0199899841,
-0.0007889161,
0.0127264205,
0.0124688148,
-0.0092297494,
0.0046146265,
0.0041516926,
0.0679737255,
-0.0295873769,
-0.0232181307,
0.005709385,
0.0201285053,
0.0264483355,
-0.0083743604,
0.0419942029,
-0.0686546788,
-0.0315709002,
-0.0117485197,
0.0124111455,
-0.0379669704,
0.0647220686,
-0.0243571289,
-0.0507834703,
0.0312092584,
0.0195622426,
0.043046385,
0.0207527969,
-0.0771072805,
-0.0069577894,
0.0458912253,
0.0177470222,
-0.0030465301,
0.0267885607,
0.0189466495,
-0.0175302103,
-0.0765986666,
-0.0195798501,
1.999275052e-34,
0.0205865521,
0.0037259669,
-0.0121656982,
0.0137639623,
0.0212414488,
0.0284249578,
-0.0102604078,
0.018053839,
0.0668137595,
-0.0300079063,
-0.0065267105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15337v1 | Moral Foundations of Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T20:05:37 | 2023-10-23T20:05:37 | Marwa Abdulhai, Gregory Serapio-Garcia, Clément Crepy, Daria Valter, John Canny, Natasha Jaques | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Moral foundations theory (MFT) is a psychological assessment tool that
decomposes human moral reasoning into five factors, including care/harm,
liberty/oppression, and sanctity/degradation (Graham et al., 2009). People vary
in the weight they place on these dimensions when making moral decisions, in
part due to their cultural upbringing and political ideology. As large language
models (LLMs) are trained on datasets collected from the internet, they may
reflect the biases that are present in such corpora. This paper uses MFT as a
lens to analyze whether popular LLMs have acquired a bias towards a particular
set of moral values. We analyze known LLMs and find they exhibit particular
moral foundations, and show how these relate to human moral foundations and
political affiliations. We also measure the consistency of these biases, or
whether they vary strongly depending on the context of how the model is
prompted. Finally, we show that we can adversarially select prompts that
encourage the moral to exhibit a particular set of moral foundations, and that
this can affect the model's behavior on downstream tasks. These findings help
illustrate the potential risks and unintended consequences of LLMs assuming a
particular moral stance. | [
0.0310132373,
0.1130306646,
-0.0201553833,
0.0256213527,
-0.0709666833,
0.0208273642,
0.0262348428,
-0.0122956345,
0.0227184072,
-0.0325090699,
-0.0092570586,
-0.0454333015,
-0.0035361839,
-0.051664494,
-0.0101510426,
-0.0285271257,
0.0263464283,
0.0417924635,
0.0842037201,
-0.0313640498,
0.0120301889,
0.0539416485,
0.0513211973,
-0.0004855819,
0.0157938581,
0.0061534662,
0.0306311883,
-0.027988987,
0.0375882983,
-0.0273900535,
0.0116046118,
0.0458447747,
0.0128697166,
-0.0168109573,
0.0000018473,
-0.0586735383,
0.0315797888,
-0.0119833965,
0.0395639837,
0.0352506936,
0.1046442613,
-0.004041499,
-0.0013901131,
0.0040544323,
-0.0415515192,
0.0303460043,
0.0120684188,
0.0631780848,
0.0102374861,
0.02934861,
0.0038709007,
-0.0128758419,
-0.0048584929,
0.0132911419,
-0.0105080269,
0.0042492356,
0.0551491864,
0.0423090979,
-0.0502347238,
0.0233273339,
-0.0243525654,
-0.0177519508,
0.0136340018,
0.0137135182,
-0.0525386445,
-0.0309215654,
-0.0189110078,
-0.0246479008,
0.0047745565,
0.0483443178,
0.0202841461,
-0.0212635808,
0.0511636473,
-0.0036651115,
0.0041701705,
0.028008502,
-0.006500592,
0.0627564043,
-0.0219878983,
0.0136695104,
0.0593203641,
-0.0141578354,
0.0206920728,
0.0944845378,
0.0326507464,
0.0334479883,
-0.0158128813,
-0.0178265497,
0.023289701,
-0.0054582288,
-0.0487125628,
-0.0170265492,
0.024975393,
-0.0167229287,
0.0176733956,
0.0364483707,
-0.0290647969,
0.0482059158,
0.0568388179,
-0.064618215,
0.0181009118,
0.0384602882,
-0.0132060992,
0.0257608183,
0.0324768573,
0.0075020688,
-0.0131677501,
0.0477242544,
-0.0241487268,
0.0345483646,
-0.0032746524,
0.0182719287,
0.0519319028,
0.0059546321,
0.0162522607,
0.0611816682,
-0.0520810224,
-0.0235450845,
-0.0642881244,
-0.0199611504,
-0.0474278405,
-0.0141086653,
0.0145826619,
-0.007453721,
-0.0453496389,
0.0236892756,
-0.0689682662,
0.0352272205,
-0.0403739251,
-0.028360242,
0.0538312122,
-0.0041536083,
-0.0277223624,
-0.003826438,
0.030264264,
0.0687767714,
0.0161765832,
-0.0045732455,
-0.0262505878,
0.0018035969,
-0.0281822085,
-0.0379613526,
-0.0188947637,
-0.0272587836,
0.0189940799,
0.0081749149,
-0.0077532302,
-0.0777908787,
0.0458857268,
0.043556273,
-0.0536601581,
0.039136041,
0.0473787822,
0.0115790879,
0.0073644789,
0.035945043,
-0.009882099,
0.0506231226,
0.0079050595,
0.031065112,
0.03625606,
-0.0076686344,
-0.0249710139,
-0.0093700932,
-0.0238426197,
0.031682346,
-0.0454022288,
0.0252856351,
-0.0133842435,
-0.0128111411,
0.0087680798,
0.0591033511,
0.0003214236,
-0.0114467377,
0.0626162812,
0.1108312234,
0.0005355139,
0.0206967257,
0.0048135906,
0.0085978853,
0.0101672262,
0.013967623,
-0.07400617,
-0.025013607,
0.0041387714,
-0.0519701056,
-0.0656832904,
0.082160227,
-0.0023562599,
-0.0171152651,
-0.0219719224,
0.0106589776,
0.0533887073,
0.0173911024,
0.0129607115,
-0.0232678652,
0.0046744188,
-0.0573072024,
0.0702396557,
-0.0451103263,
0.0090753622,
-0.0327312872,
0.0629441664,
0.0646500513,
0.0269246567,
0.0142269395,
0.0098404633,
-0.0351756811,
0.0120988498,
0.0206204131,
0.031163564,
-0.0313521251,
-0.029651504,
-0.0323426612,
-0.0427016057,
0.0176793411,
-0.0089970278,
0.0287811123,
0.0027563556,
-0.0097439699,
0.0175897367,
0.0041132849,
-0.0322826132,
0.0454649478,
0.0124337655,
0.0191091187,
-0.0540069006,
0.0290631298,
0.0288526136,
-0.0033651746,
-0.0006331553,
-0.0427862927,
-0.0072339443,
0.0041755247,
-0.0054388484,
0.0046324413,
-0.0488515049,
0.0503335595,
0.0084908511,
-0.0609579496,
0.0074722744,
0.0258857347,
-0.0210283659,
0.0567331314,
-0.0161220469,
-0.0037858458,
0.0091852378,
-0.0449202843,
-0.0170109309,
-0.0811147168,
-0.0162931383,
-0.0249429885,
0.0571599454,
-0.0309837088,
0.0180186685,
-0.0072221737,
-0.0192435104,
0.0301356502,
0.0052824193,
-0.0240492783,
-0.0102251843,
-0.0325479656,
0.0496302396,
0.0451141186,
0.032647118,
-0.0366426073,
-0.0369582474,
-0.0395769067,
-0.0297252499,
0.005960959,
0.0022029097,
-0.0038833322,
-0.0260327104,
-0.00859283,
0.0384029709,
-0.0390378349,
-0.023917865,
-0.0011311159,
0.0348168984,
0.0026647432,
-0.0397478715,
-0.0251135491,
-0.008459446,
0.0032445516,
-0.0485888198,
-0.0031270827,
0.0251250938,
-0.0186161567,
-0.0067953253,
0.0277022012,
-0.0795205608,
-0.0272317212,
-0.0029098284,
-0.0705274418,
-0.0105824033,
0.0448927358,
-0.0268800184,
0.0628223792,
0.0632283166,
0.0258176476,
0.0447769277,
0.0642652959,
-0.0402520373,
-0.0535797887,
-0.0189325996,
0.0166702885,
-0.0117760552,
-0.0729671717,
-0.0347736068,
0.0622159131,
0.0266043823,
0.0091166412,
-0.0319206826,
0.0537354685,
-0.0815683752,
-0.0654905513,
-0.0150749339,
-0.0569122843,
-0.0098445099,
0.0347667225,
-0.0320715494,
-0.0610472597,
0.03775445,
0.0490158126,
0.0445393398,
0.0095832022,
0.0121126445,
0.0015766831,
0.0182460845,
0.0010396733,
0.0499107614,
0.0251993872,
-0.0155356098,
-0.0323045999,
-0.0122757917,
0.0456274413,
-0.0584589653,
0.0336291976,
-0.0216059145,
0.0108363368,
0.0224914867,
-0.0610978417,
-0.0498678945,
-0.0774510205,
-0.0223686825,
-0.0282947514,
0.0091131199,
0.0055790246,
0.0573305562,
-0.0111338831,
0.0310063399,
-0.055295568,
0.0002772408,
0.0335995816,
0.0109458743,
-0.0491365977,
0.0196886919,
-0.0418794826,
0.0558015443,
0.008415468,
0.0304544531,
0.0165742263,
-0.00147525,
0.0227395445,
0.0203908496,
0.0458481945,
0.0179587528,
0.0125881424,
0.0233571995,
0.0294047538,
0.0436956882,
0.0111464653,
0.0310781505,
0.0797201619,
0.0126797901,
-0.028349055,
0.0043155695,
0.0145389866,
-0.0474269725,
0.0286026169,
-0.0268964022,
-0.0979436785,
0.0147166057,
-0.0146532711,
0.0190582946,
-0.0933415368,
-0.050161507,
0.0266382992,
-0.0778966993,
0.0061274972,
0.0299511384,
0.0079031261,
-0.0039837924,
-0.0404363088,
0.0082363579,
-0.0319741704,
0.042427022,
0.0138953133,
0.0065996703,
-0.0369366966,
-0.0202471316,
0.0177817941,
-0.0208215564,
0.0532981232,
-0.0287733562,
0.0511265993,
0.0383064933,
0.056783732,
-0.0346763544,
-0.0363291278,
0.0286235716,
0.0037625066,
-0.0321906358,
0.0101052327,
-0.0102373743,
-0.0184511673,
-0.0071562002,
-0.0632064044,
0.0309332516,
0.0275012217,
-0.0272596143,
-0.0074234377,
0.0590241849,
0.0166583303,
-0.0558507815,
0.0109248823,
0.0193628222,
0.012273496,
0.0635208115,
0.0022232693,
-0.0470686518,
0.0421529897,
-0.0542050116,
-0.0492247269,
0.0160918348,
-0.0855220482,
-0.0131565733,
-0.0261971913,
-0.0080959834,
-0.0462626219,
-0.0454912707,
-0.0401576906,
-0.0305594075,
0.0705627799,
-0.0568048432,
0.0368730649,
0.0074824025,
-0.0176587608,
0.0208004508,
-0.0252961144,
-0.0212447308,
0.0160047468,
0.0099557266,
0.0153465075,
-0.0254878961,
-0.0059297192,
-0.0299050175,
0.0177208744,
-0.0382819735,
0.081030786,
0.009295065,
0.005067843,
0.0130749913,
-0.0231968556,
0.012722509,
0.023913661,
0.0377779119,
-0.0730047002,
0.0402781777,
0.0391535722,
0.0085609239,
-0.0095627867,
-0.0088260649,
-0.0178720411,
0.0460093729,
0.0463308431,
-0.0157150105,
-0.0301680267,
-0.0023302389,
0.0398651809,
0.036646761,
0.0215231292,
-0.0078832526,
-0.0125395786,
-0.0331899188,
-0.0694265738,
-0.0142851183,
-0.0556667671,
0.0130320927,
0.0071108933,
0.0539878868,
-0.0270441677,
-0.0213225111,
0.0199947078,
-0.0625316575,
0.018181609,
-0.0164078418,
0.016817173,
-0.016601691,
0.0695452392,
-0.0198223013,
0.000044466,
-0.0336865075,
0.0410592034,
-0.0099762175,
0.0243745763,
-0.020253554,
0.0743433684,
0.0023285882,
0.0096290531,
0.0050169402,
-0.0051829997,
-0.0648586601,
-0.0209555887,
-0.0347508043,
-0.0206869207,
-0.0093381023,
-0.0050428971,
0.008604194,
0.0038061759,
-0.0144108273,
-0.0380758606,
0.0107929353,
-0.0037918158,
-0.0403910838,
0.025039522,
0.0062329667,
-0.0301761087,
0.0077834423,
0.0014877865,
-0.0529812686,
0.0322767422,
0.0491284877,
-0.0349707082,
-0.008576652,
-0.040801771,
0.037371248,
-0.0341840871,
-0.0288142245,
-0.0141871683,
-0.0780158564,
-0.0265811365,
-0.0228116121,
0.001250823,
0.0165687297,
-0.0448184945,
-0.0214650333,
0.077656284,
-0.0425609834,
0.0518425182,
-0.0351508223,
0.0262791999,
-0.0460335203,
0.0113192005,
-0.0520922579,
-5.189596337e-33,
-0.0107720736,
-0.0139452741,
-0.0444669686,
-0.0257696547,
-0.0061548208,
-0.0194129571,
0.020252401,
0.0472049676,
-0.0655581877,
0.052742444,
-0.0125955287,
0.020316422,
-0.0014164631,
-0.019250568,
0.0117897121,
-0.0739098862,
-0.0046620304,
-0.005931674,
-0.023209298,
0.0012715129,
-0.0086937584,
-0.0114737926,
0.0317217074,
-0.0838908851,
0.0571955256,
0.019951392,
-0.0131957196,
-0.0382911414,
-0.010317795,
0.0144646522,
-0.0090642786,
0.0546852797,
0.0175971556,
-0.0104934061,
0.0065552671,
0.1020110846,
0.0003694217,
-0.006456757,
0.0690478235,
-0.0182066839,
0.0008132069,
-0.0364721678,
-0.0211714804,
-0.0162582789,
-0.0656683519,
0.0063816821,
0.0385727659,
-0.0245582368,
0.0333367772,
-0.0217808336,
-0.0282133427,
-0.0174323712,
-0.0279980376,
-0.0078261886,
-0.0703292713,
0.0544896126,
-0.0112608308,
0.0647463277,
0.0425025709,
0.0479658507,
-0.0074265227,
-0.0135768745,
0.0177782476,
-0.0321178697,
0.0274297558,
0.1100452244,
-0.0046844338,
0.0358114652,
-0.0451841131,
-0.0252672024,
0.0379263386,
-0.0118337199,
0.0539693683,
0.0949466303,
-0.0069757397,
-0.0527840629,
-0.0380122475,
-0.0441854484,
0.0740105659,
-0.0011190232,
0.0242968667,
-0.0289460346,
-0.0127162756,
-0.0161321107,
-0.0684750155,
-0.1093274802,
-0.011814029,
-0.0167074222,
0.0194093157,
-0.0205892175,
-0.0505125299,
-0.0185331199,
-0.0025906675,
-0.034470778,
0.0084578488,
0.042634964,
-0.0085028196,
-0.0299834535,
0.0020420176,
0.0271409955,
-0.0325893648,
-0.0035923168,
-0.0172816645,
-0.0246887095,
0.0549112856,
-0.0091193002,
0.0480746962,
-0.0084598949,
-0.0172584914,
-0.0310698282,
-0.0069383099,
0.0009691177,
0.0225186739,
-0.0089736711,
0.0465128869,
0.0487475321,
0.0205086935,
-0.0119045526,
0.0508184843,
-0.0136177884,
-0.0457753129,
-0.0487155132,
-0.0262506101,
0.0545122735,
-0.0431135446,
-0.021501245,
-0.0432285331,
0.0478033014,
0.0386901796,
-0.0522938818,
-0.0360254087,
0.0138111785,
2.384e-7,
0.0051067006,
0.0507643893,
-0.0196697395,
0.0247833226,
-0.0479404479,
0.0343520939,
0.0476624109,
0.0348158292,
0.0169618912,
-0.0799430311,
-0.0189853106,
0.0094406186,
0.0620268099,
-0.0048331162,
-0.0151921092,
0.0161472615,
-0.0234245583,
-0.0061153937,
-0.0276427809,
0.0391560346,
0.0008232727,
0.0498757362,
0.0205007195,
0.0105210058,
-0.0086498056,
0.0297196619,
0.0369123034,
-0.0895829648,
-0.036893338,
-0.0191513654,
-0.0355425104,
-0.0260284357,
0.0066058859,
0.0154502476,
0.0302789696,
-0.0222847648,
0.0243234225,
0.0907607973,
0.0011440086,
-0.0123104528,
-0.0397938788,
-0.0279248841,
-0.0140602225,
-0.0081616761,
0.0721280128,
-0.0140150022,
0.0041632256,
-0.0485223532,
0.0042173518,
-0.0256524999,
0.0215240382,
-0.008897122,
-0.0432027467,
-0.0070982692,
0.0188210271,
0.0249688718,
0.030275207,
-0.0274770651,
-0.011119063,
-0.0195590258,
0.0175085571,
-0.0999322161,
0.0391162075,
0.0255341474,
0.0213772673,
-0.0395987555,
0.0044579352,
1.908867368e-34,
0.0251766611,
-0.0331793427,
0.0214386005,
-0.0138964476,
0.0452204086,
0.0411444493,
0.0127064828,
0.0022084969,
0.0107063707,
-0.0445956066,
0.0068696211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15326v1 | Specialist or Generalist? Instruction Tuning for Specific NLP Tasks | 2023-10-23T19:46:48 | 2023-10-23T19:46:48 | Chufan Shi, Yixuan Su, Cheng Yang, Yujiu Yang, Deng Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | The potential of large language models (LLMs) to simultaneously perform a
wide range of natural language processing (NLP) tasks has been the subject of
extensive research. Although instruction tuning has proven to be a
data-efficient method for transforming LLMs into such generalist models, their
performance still lags behind specialist models trained exclusively for
specific tasks. In this paper, we investigate whether incorporating
broad-coverage generalist instruction tuning can contribute to building a
specialist model. We hypothesize that its efficacy depends on task specificity
and skill requirements. Our experiments assess four target tasks with distinct
coverage levels, revealing that integrating generalist instruction tuning
consistently enhances model performance when the task coverage is broad. The
effect is particularly pronounced when the amount of task-specific training
data is limited. Further investigation into three target tasks focusing on
different capabilities demonstrates that generalist instruction tuning improves
understanding and reasoning abilities. However, for tasks requiring factual
knowledge, generalist data containing hallucinatory information may negatively
affect the model's performance. Overall, our work provides a systematic guide
for developing specialist models with general instruction tuning. Our code and
other related resources can be found at
https://github.com/DavidFanzz/Generalist_or_Specialist. | [
0.0824061036,
0.0567820072,
-0.0157783087,
0.0087323589,
-0.0526280068,
0.0326334387,
0.0190641508,
-0.0145775033,
-0.0165258255,
-0.0745533109,
-0.0264000408,
-0.0229420774,
-0.0210358631,
-0.0087928949,
0.0246143695,
-0.0545775332,
0.0496716015,
-0.0332241841,
0.0010002254,
0.0066415989,
-0.02609233,
0.0244328268,
-0.029637821,
0.0219834484,
-0.008525704,
0.0085098576,
0.0171744693,
-0.0056458465,
0.0014773956,
0.0035350774,
0.0293355305,
0.0528090633,
0.0613191091,
0.0169693679,
0.0000019322,
-0.0392667688,
0.0214179698,
-0.0049906308,
-0.0285947472,
0.0004603295,
0.0487138554,
-0.0269935876,
0.0395802334,
0.0312580541,
-0.0209067054,
-0.0184956715,
0.0205533169,
0.0710675567,
0.0413207635,
0.113200523,
0.0074080662,
-0.0627057701,
0.0283381753,
-0.0064373598,
0.0385171808,
-0.0487263761,
0.0234045666,
0.0536660254,
0.0292925313,
0.0169372093,
-0.0148094743,
0.0244034249,
0.0135624586,
0.0412948765,
0.0447262749,
0.0206783228,
-0.0540650822,
-0.0292300917,
-0.0208373461,
0.0246832874,
-0.0478974432,
-0.0031412663,
-0.0268416032,
0.0043265489,
-0.0068475781,
0.0130138248,
-0.0331596024,
0.029347416,
-0.0134427035,
0.0073247859,
0.0441254601,
-0.0164979622,
0.0232643709,
0.0271485727,
-0.0425610468,
0.076066345,
0.0016339439,
-0.044881016,
0.0482418723,
0.035669446,
-0.0476270318,
-0.0234264694,
0.0189804994,
0.0239272155,
-0.0480460599,
0.030309543,
-0.0217019916,
0.0038029789,
0.0269454457,
-0.0438681096,
0.056322474,
0.0610891879,
-0.0201075226,
0.0546676219,
-0.0461959951,
0.0275144055,
-0.0017299968,
0.0716976374,
-0.0069865547,
-0.0248476453,
-0.1208253577,
-0.0229276977,
-0.0342643969,
0.0057349368,
-0.037323121,
-0.0145867541,
-0.022595048,
0.0059202975,
0.0113116251,
-0.0145810684,
0.0350696295,
0.0012678825,
-0.0599078871,
-0.009912163,
-0.0445179082,
0.0114106471,
-0.0564397611,
0.037443731,
-0.0122525534,
-0.0471707843,
-0.0016033124,
0.0065114759,
0.0102403378,
-0.0329179242,
0.0358863175,
0.0387363881,
0.0004283154,
-0.0286843665,
-0.0564082228,
0.0038625766,
-0.0043410878,
-0.1071030423,
0.0105691021,
-0.0372694768,
0.0288412776,
0.0057208859,
0.0182362087,
-0.031916298,
0.0035021733,
0.0008208122,
-0.0516883023,
0.0766165331,
0.0279400889,
0.029915832,
0.0241309609,
0.0108818924,
-0.0202401485,
0.096451208,
-0.0053328052,
0.0052080536,
0.0187950432,
-0.0242993459,
0.0298422594,
0.0069863889,
-0.0389860943,
-0.0065446533,
-0.0054215165,
0.0187800024,
-0.0109436093,
0.0205432698,
0.0318865851,
0.0232814811,
-0.0253381785,
0.019933207,
0.0421474837,
0.0134079223,
0.0466288626,
0.0275412388,
0.0624238439,
0.0275681429,
0.0123064471,
0.0105949463,
-0.0841221809,
-0.005770396,
-0.019712843,
0.0106309224,
-0.0071730725,
0.0085217375,
-0.0244951788,
-0.0349052176,
-0.0350583568,
0.0160591584,
0.0214315038,
0.0302781854,
0.0423911102,
0.0095984414,
-0.0349011309,
0.042192407,
0.0495225303,
-0.0021606931,
0.018307725,
-0.0564787649,
-0.0379466563,
0.0830828473,
0.022844715,
-0.0325254612,
-0.025069721,
-0.0152040068,
0.0130126039,
0.0487837233,
0.0416923836,
0.0084246565,
0.0241053104,
-0.0564521626,
-0.0278835967,
-0.061393816,
0.0531831123,
0.0101687396,
0.0614556,
-0.0170501862,
0.0170786697,
-0.0476381816,
-0.0635645017,
0.047140047,
-0.0464776307,
-0.0435470827,
-0.0304634459,
-0.0043068328,
0.0005787382,
-0.0082350885,
-0.0220545493,
-0.0076340316,
-0.0153067615,
-0.0255106222,
-0.0250924136,
-0.0230546687,
-0.0305330586,
-0.0022613222,
0.0117177861,
-0.0270723291,
-0.0115175769,
0.04334075,
-0.0447484404,
-0.0175137464,
0.0018006354,
-0.0294848457,
0.0350784771,
-0.0158499908,
0.0053503206,
-0.0204518382,
-0.0003012463,
-0.036001306,
0.0667195246,
0.0143054929,
-0.0107480418,
0.0075610299,
-0.010118423,
-0.0279461108,
-0.023921879,
-0.0038366907,
-0.0090529742,
0.0063419114,
0.0179113839,
-0.000428605,
0.0043284437,
-0.0687243566,
-0.0501602776,
-0.0915290415,
0.0211201757,
-0.055766467,
0.0008748367,
0.0505701825,
-0.0099933213,
-0.0364884846,
0.0043274113,
-0.0194108039,
-0.026146831,
0.0084597822,
0.0354588218,
-0.0035249158,
0.0165469777,
-0.0184876099,
-0.0250397138,
-0.0064965114,
-0.0072076097,
0.0056998362,
0.0091922199,
-0.0024218969,
-0.0670868829,
0.0555302426,
0.0048844619,
0.0228334218,
0.00061181,
-0.0202784054,
-0.0072776047,
-0.0035276467,
0.0098491693,
0.0860956013,
-0.0102137914,
0.0184025317,
0.050121747,
0.0011879292,
-0.0384745337,
0.0433524102,
-0.010704251,
-0.0456066243,
-0.0689163283,
-0.0415771417,
-0.0166087449,
0.0690014139,
0.0080983052,
0.0002973839,
-0.0593842529,
-0.0216865446,
-0.0326323211,
-0.0414981768,
0.0031600024,
0.0047227908,
0.015236509,
0.0284227692,
-0.033257626,
-0.0574372672,
0.0542955361,
0.0017736185,
-0.0182070341,
-0.0919577852,
-0.0261789169,
-0.0617287755,
0.0473108217,
0.0155724129,
0.0115336739,
-0.0215930026,
-0.0327578895,
-0.0516199805,
0.0032303073,
-0.0049393568,
-0.0069708307,
0.0363746211,
-0.0513831861,
-0.0074132918,
0.0130431559,
-0.0133769717,
-0.0433294177,
-0.0176057965,
-0.0192234106,
0.0237380546,
0.0208449904,
-0.0157141909,
-0.0756759122,
-0.0204019789,
0.0091559784,
0.0365145542,
0.0039273677,
-0.0236820765,
-0.0177768692,
-0.0523106307,
0.0472498052,
0.0116069987,
-0.0012209198,
-0.0366089754,
-0.0112869861,
0.0160065889,
0.0297850743,
-0.0007220889,
-0.017212145,
0.035365101,
0.0164138824,
-0.0715103522,
-0.0011763352,
0.0308407079,
0.0886995271,
-0.0889928117,
-0.0092843845,
0.1193216443,
0.0348164774,
-0.0101272371,
0.0160210747,
0.0121094687,
-0.0046057403,
0.0443585142,
0.0329081714,
-0.051981207,
-0.0279721711,
-0.0202687997,
0.0136207277,
-0.0159068145,
-0.0193194617,
-0.0121208727,
-0.0981691256,
0.0074678166,
0.0144446781,
-0.0104832249,
-0.0259835087,
-0.0490821935,
0.01459892,
-0.0477388538,
0.0433964692,
-0.01924989,
-0.0386352055,
-0.0102054356,
0.0414948799,
0.0041834698,
-0.0742535964,
0.0461671501,
-0.0306312293,
0.0428080745,
0.0481647253,
-0.0257898774,
-0.0013841973,
0.005991078,
0.0225806739,
0.0292474981,
0.0539252609,
-0.0053817863,
0.0531739071,
-0.0179810002,
0.0237914082,
0.0095769139,
0.0239240769,
-0.0171508025,
0.0123923467,
0.008648132,
0.059879344,
0.003871426,
-0.0358982272,
-0.0019837946,
-0.0071325693,
0.0169655364,
0.086177595,
0.0109261675,
-0.0309461579,
-0.0420558415,
-0.0219046697,
-0.0267951656,
-0.0696118101,
-0.0546755977,
0.0552150868,
0.0008578344,
-0.0148594435,
-0.0143693052,
-0.0339643359,
0.0660311282,
0.0215172078,
0.0161632057,
-0.0022784255,
-0.0055201026,
0.0114289364,
-0.008280484,
0.0665415302,
-0.047452122,
0.0023722039,
-0.0504601747,
-0.0714070275,
0.0226543117,
-0.0136339692,
-0.0170936286,
-0.0237188935,
-0.0943602249,
-0.0813154802,
0.0246106014,
0.0287202802,
0.0292682517,
0.0712167621,
-0.0016979938,
-0.0687371343,
0.0113398107,
0.0003185684,
-0.0663078651,
0.0065064179,
0.0331217572,
-0.0153230159,
0.0068391915,
0.0232728049,
-0.0074711223,
0.029732205,
0.0635028929,
0.0385183208,
-0.0055381758,
0.0311767459,
0.0233391542,
0.0160224251,
0.0210868996,
-0.0029221354,
0.0225830115,
-0.0250056759,
-0.0040453845,
0.0119172465,
0.0060328813,
-0.0154027371,
-0.0202022064,
0.0479839817,
-0.0090062572,
0.0050492445,
0.0044543035,
-0.0242800675,
0.0276284739,
-0.0492294319,
0.0188652761,
-0.005985518,
-0.0187043585,
0.0282940399,
0.0079835868,
-0.0508073978,
0.0176861268,
0.0147018302,
0.0397579744,
0.0165758375,
0.0494150072,
-0.0143963024,
0.0205155183,
-0.057364542,
-0.0197463445,
-0.071746096,
-0.0697161183,
-0.0006075541,
0.0266171098,
0.053114906,
-0.0653596073,
0.0092638917,
-0.0421535522,
-0.0015196149,
-0.0069652679,
-0.0042553763,
0.0256910659,
0.0008689911,
-0.0025651574,
0.020685114,
-0.0114732999,
-0.0300360844,
0.0702461079,
0.0300053246,
0.0959304646,
-0.015991373,
-0.0147340288,
-0.0395509973,
-0.0309934262,
-0.0063646035,
-0.0030755198,
-0.0290500019,
0.0584277138,
-0.0347948596,
-0.0528128706,
-0.0210096743,
-0.0472214147,
0.0278944746,
-0.0195812378,
0.0278646592,
0.068156749,
-0.0391636156,
-0.029302571,
-0.0204315335,
-0.0208837353,
0.0859330744,
-0.0004799882,
-0.027709255,
-6.640929621e-33,
0.0035490177,
0.0218538009,
0.0364205353,
-0.0558027104,
0.0224644747,
-0.0078257071,
0.0070661036,
0.0117514394,
-0.0363056101,
-0.0141407223,
-0.0099212267,
0.010378493,
0.0220037755,
0.0275485795,
0.0287025236,
-0.0002038095,
0.0680746585,
0.0244227126,
-0.0246455725,
0.0033654841,
0.0172114633,
0.0187221225,
0.0897167325,
-0.0565358251,
0.0142867947,
0.0220332388,
0.0142555181,
0.0141861346,
-0.0195059665,
0.0445441082,
0.002727292,
0.0437186882,
0.0544264503,
-0.0629171431,
-0.0262892842,
-0.0034892105,
-0.0516913235,
-0.0273389798,
0.0580585636,
0.0159129314,
-0.0260093249,
-0.0295775831,
0.0502889305,
-0.0074648014,
0.0022234009,
-0.0600829646,
0.0285973083,
-0.0401458479,
0.0011752414,
0.0223881099,
-0.0789417773,
0.0204944219,
0.0065211891,
0.0058326982,
0.0005434731,
0.0223871581,
-0.017932009,
0.0031549851,
-0.0322693139,
0.0011954099,
0.0320791677,
0.0392392017,
0.0342696086,
0.0025341564,
-0.0214577839,
0.0382461734,
0.0121989045,
0.032097701,
-0.0437126271,
-0.0278738402,
0.0212299749,
0.074771665,
0.0147262001,
-0.0066609886,
0.0707786456,
0.001964649,
-0.075575985,
-0.0246964935,
0.0146075012,
0.0702626482,
0.0346938074,
0.0277190004,
-0.0509685799,
-0.0040888744,
-0.0449075177,
0.0412768237,
-0.0229377057,
-0.037012469,
0.0377745442,
0.0490361862,
-0.0123452712,
0.0233524852,
0.0290554948,
-0.0515885688,
0.0242324565,
0.0078345602,
0.001358205,
0.0107681733,
-0.0185177643,
0.0026570505,
-0.0644916445,
-0.0627772361,
0.0230872855,
-0.0024232499,
0.0227463581,
-0.0133107509,
0.0441605747,
0.0139955916,
-0.0671545714,
0.004923204,
-0.0390990973,
0.0318894088,
0.0330279507,
0.0446651354,
0.0499428026,
0.0360718891,
-0.0183596928,
0.0277916957,
-0.0004790468,
-0.0321120024,
-0.0277682636,
-0.0036623364,
0.0070571578,
0.0236663166,
-0.0027718733,
-0.0073830904,
-0.0279338118,
-0.078125909,
-0.011337338,
-0.0378844216,
-0.0234479681,
0.0019912715,
2.719e-7,
0.0284993406,
0.055261068,
-0.0344630517,
0.0352791362,
0.0042312657,
-0.0060166856,
-0.0055264258,
-0.0004302333,
0.0213957466,
-0.0494877249,
-0.028203629,
0.066455476,
0.0542277321,
0.0244949143,
-0.0615013801,
-0.0421268307,
0.0035641848,
0.0261523575,
-0.0691165552,
0.0104267988,
0.0451627411,
0.0875051469,
0.0156212822,
-0.0008925836,
-0.0034057528,
-0.0670071617,
0.0487603247,
-0.0103422329,
-0.0021299089,
0.0584649481,
0.0197588131,
0.0784781724,
0.0328188948,
0.0681881383,
-0.0190833993,
0.0189234298,
-0.0179804061,
0.0954483002,
-0.0186491106,
-0.0039155921,
-0.0130051086,
-0.0036510867,
-0.0185692757,
-0.0470255204,
0.0655788183,
-0.0738133565,
-0.0233004317,
0.0100093111,
-0.0040749805,
0.0098795025,
0.0268355049,
-0.0152005618,
0.0087482175,
0.0114163039,
0.0235135052,
-0.0049859681,
-0.0355338454,
-0.0836398602,
-0.0129210539,
0.0421040393,
-0.0475156195,
-0.0283970945,
-0.0166069344,
-0.0126148667,
0.0398232006,
-0.0695753172,
0.0044131801,
2.636105086e-34,
0.0414610654,
0.0218507648,
0.0307000596,
0.0078176279,
0.0375652015,
0.0015014311,
-0.0437786393,
0.0096437884,
-0.0032437781,
-0.0823303834,
-0.0043098591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15325v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15325v1 | LXMERT Model Compression for Visual Question Answering | 2023-10-23T19:46:41 | 2023-10-23T19:46:41 | Maryam Hashemi, Ghazaleh Mahmoudi, Sara Kodeiri, Hadi Sheikhi, Sauleh Eetemadi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large-scale pretrained models such as LXMERT are becoming popular for
learning cross-modal representations on text-image pairs for vision-language
tasks. According to the lottery ticket hypothesis, NLP and computer vision
models contain smaller subnetworks capable of being trained in isolation to
full performance. In this paper, we combine these observations to evaluate
whether such trainable subnetworks exist in LXMERT when fine-tuned on the VQA
task. In addition, we perform a model size cost-benefit analysis by
investigating how much pruning can be done without significant loss in
accuracy. Our experiment results demonstrate that LXMERT can be effectively
pruned by 40%-60% in size with 3% loss in accuracy. | [
-0.0166786648,
0.0622664765,
-0.021822568,
0.060577549,
-0.0249995291,
-0.0147843054,
0.0204090811,
0.04883397,
0.0052978368,
-0.0391593613,
-0.072821252,
-0.0440867245,
-0.0158864222,
0.0319196023,
0.0342302248,
-0.0425812565,
0.0388699919,
-0.0155918943,
-0.026096506,
-0.0388869718,
0.0526022166,
-0.0330303423,
0.0334403589,
0.0319472365,
0.023397252,
-0.025204137,
-0.0140579864,
0.005008453,
-0.0054688738,
0.004919251,
-0.0041303765,
0.0320937186,
0.0429733843,
0.0204088669,
0.0000017037,
0.0093957027,
-0.0169375204,
0.0068529127,
-0.0263522677,
0.0401087701,
-0.0248919819,
0.0109906113,
0.0167313498,
0.0395007208,
-0.0263886061,
-0.0508879237,
0.0645950809,
0.0513882712,
0.0650222823,
0.0507517494,
-0.0063018515,
0.026411958,
0.014720791,
-0.0252044722,
0.0216468703,
-0.0402655043,
-0.0159122478,
0.0222439002,
-0.0066107768,
-0.0096174069,
-0.0473653078,
0.0410563797,
0.0558520146,
0.0275188684,
-0.0339720584,
0.0381126031,
-0.0046249554,
-0.0037407279,
-0.0120727904,
0.0630423799,
-0.0126428921,
-0.0062570362,
-0.0334221423,
-0.0273534376,
-0.0056427503,
-0.0153156482,
-0.0570612177,
0.0352252647,
0.014820233,
0.0024023689,
-0.0304757524,
0.0028782359,
-0.0007890636,
0.0071843364,
-0.0077453693,
-0.024785839,
0.0349546,
0.0193763785,
-0.0280399136,
0.0169570819,
-0.0540618412,
-0.0751518086,
-0.0574946813,
0.0307738949,
0.0074740006,
-0.01401689,
-0.0510964096,
-0.0182102211,
-0.0211568158,
-0.0124575095,
0.0606158413,
0.0439115204,
-0.0296974089,
0.0474981107,
-0.0186068919,
0.0573003888,
-0.0207972024,
0.028007634,
-0.0471638069,
-0.02373592,
0.008309097,
-0.0290089417,
-0.0714582205,
0.0058951313,
-0.0603152923,
-0.0295595378,
-0.0384878479,
-0.0133420955,
-0.0064406409,
-0.0439419411,
0.0142244417,
0.0348960608,
-0.0278748218,
-0.0094530368,
-0.0523217544,
0.0687254518,
-0.010935788,
0.031748306,
-0.0233360864,
-0.0567978323,
-0.0231375434,
0.031262774,
0.0129649648,
-0.027866913,
0.0146151055,
0.0698695481,
-0.0450177006,
-0.0650081486,
-0.0360854417,
-0.0382980295,
0.0038713573,
-0.0302301794,
0.0466713831,
-0.0717468634,
0.0284491051,
-0.0362830125,
0.006850536,
0.0049863975,
-0.0150447693,
0.028309295,
-0.0283916779,
0.0770240426,
-0.0137176458,
-0.0006561328,
0.0030631332,
0.0069776666,
0.0472761281,
0.0906110927,
0.0146387424,
0.0469665639,
0.0485279709,
-0.0293531045,
0.0316886753,
0.0347678177,
0.0561175719,
-0.00381861,
-0.0272606909,
0.0211247746,
0.0160803553,
-0.0011636432,
0.0278215017,
0.0209152978,
-0.0867524222,
-0.0644742101,
0.0678837672,
0.0523368977,
0.0401802287,
0.0365390293,
0.0238334723,
-0.008894451,
0.0124419061,
-0.0119730541,
-0.0523208007,
0.060195148,
-0.0315697007,
-0.004650922,
0.0174978655,
0.004347248,
-0.0681403652,
-0.0440542921,
0.0053401534,
0.0060715433,
0.0124154789,
0.0393818319,
0.0278641526,
0.0011723856,
-0.0244836938,
0.0502244942,
0.0107422294,
-0.0185005851,
-0.0332219005,
-0.0563041903,
0.0157119315,
0.0198422875,
0.0136968978,
0.0046278643,
0.0262749884,
0.0331700034,
0.0102331983,
-0.0275156796,
0.0377574936,
-0.0072452831,
0.0487393141,
-0.0286246743,
-0.029131081,
-0.0327461213,
-0.0116965789,
-0.0327650942,
0.0435591377,
0.0073625133,
-0.0178204551,
-0.0455810502,
0.0474152155,
0.0139797824,
-0.0159394406,
-0.0129457368,
0.000377977,
0.0321991332,
0.0020544312,
-0.0399058722,
-0.0396403931,
0.0054852702,
0.021164922,
-0.0350930355,
-0.0259850342,
-0.0370374322,
-0.0218713339,
-0.0298712887,
0.0446961969,
-0.0582623892,
0.052920036,
0.0714359581,
-0.0372057408,
-0.0227504168,
0.0230190698,
-0.0678279921,
0.0198372919,
-0.0560090132,
-0.0439357273,
0.0350863598,
0.0379450321,
-0.0119612943,
0.0179816131,
-0.0034914545,
-0.0073499018,
0.0010581808,
-0.0191024877,
0.0421180464,
-0.0220104307,
-0.0198353138,
0.0122125437,
-0.0152127668,
0.0252883565,
-0.005696116,
0.0204319358,
0.0033723754,
-0.0147200618,
-0.0824739859,
0.006533341,
-0.0343144834,
-0.0056066718,
0.0296767,
0.0254920758,
0.0176975094,
-0.01647125,
-0.0372984558,
0.0366247483,
0.0484886244,
0.039124053,
0.0360436887,
-0.0144411512,
-0.0020825467,
-0.028152572,
-0.0706586912,
0.0397720598,
0.0816879198,
-0.0376293398,
0.015948562,
-0.0018450026,
0.0441060252,
-0.0366424769,
0.0546326786,
-0.0119176712,
-0.0392303988,
-0.0264398474,
0.0070205051,
0.0045187124,
0.0786668584,
-0.0108619519,
0.0403282717,
0.0303844418,
0.0014882727,
-0.0255165435,
0.0142992837,
-0.0072783544,
-0.0633052066,
-0.0331279859,
-0.0101240724,
-0.0522272922,
0.0381206833,
-0.0456223711,
-0.0179618709,
-0.071234487,
0.0039632581,
0.0199089739,
-0.0393552706,
-0.0516968779,
0.0185726676,
0.0353345014,
0.0667783171,
-0.0185196083,
-0.0802864134,
0.0083851079,
-0.0281668063,
0.0131796356,
0.0074913576,
-0.0209354013,
-0.040441595,
0.0886287838,
0.0457242355,
0.0317186639,
0.0132917874,
0.007934968,
-0.0639717057,
-0.064676851,
0.0047446061,
-0.0207544398,
0.0620778985,
-0.0189438649,
0.0323382653,
-0.0798449069,
-0.0306216348,
-0.0064134435,
-0.0479658097,
-0.037265107,
0.0256825145,
-0.0074339192,
-0.0045650764,
0.0038737464,
0.0224816427,
0.0112966867,
0.0166894905,
-0.009193507,
-0.0013739703,
0.0075811204,
0.08234974,
0.0460069999,
0.0766669959,
0.0408121571,
-0.0199422874,
-0.005065572,
0.0588385426,
0.037501771,
0.0199317075,
-0.0501479581,
0.0206805132,
0.0402679369,
0.0201024637,
-0.0404948331,
0.0096940016,
0.0881815478,
-0.0449829549,
0.0098131616,
0.0267433859,
0.001160773,
-0.0147183258,
-0.0122529892,
0.0193157401,
0.0275428034,
0.0337468646,
0.0350996852,
-0.0866084024,
-0.0458933525,
-0.0176996086,
-0.0079837916,
-0.0028918509,
0.0347637385,
-0.0476869605,
-0.0711277127,
0.0435227863,
-0.0197004639,
-0.0193853304,
-0.0122610256,
0.0193270072,
-0.0286958478,
-0.047145851,
-0.0068573439,
-0.0143485498,
-0.0374482907,
0.0022782492,
-0.0199511573,
0.00263597,
0.0135650467,
0.0311225429,
-0.0247579254,
0.014389189,
0.0056868987,
0.000554493,
-0.0277815536,
-0.0754734725,
0.0309989564,
-0.0639369711,
-0.0027178077,
0.0160113033,
0.0848872811,
-0.0175749753,
-0.0428750031,
0.0074349456,
0.017613627,
0.0192534495,
-0.039421238,
-0.0209959559,
0.0394652523,
0.0171990003,
-0.0126275849,
-0.0183769073,
0.013079185,
-0.0674670413,
0.0380396321,
0.0321363956,
-0.0064878855,
-0.0539069548,
0.0102660339,
-0.0099978717,
-0.0340254158,
-0.0603143238,
0.0024228618,
0.0456647091,
-0.0040366813,
-0.0346255191,
0.0015623495,
0.0427877828,
0.0709249154,
-0.0763837993,
-0.0341282971,
-0.0244978555,
0.0663318932,
-0.0499722511,
0.0685505867,
-0.0435764641,
0.0506535359,
-0.0209720526,
0.0398876481,
0.0129506346,
-0.0678339154,
-0.023438219,
-0.0242214147,
-0.1212071478,
-0.0195224918,
-0.0633036196,
0.0437645391,
0.0173265208,
0.0462020375,
0.0320881307,
-0.0548359677,
0.02136405,
0.0083203502,
0.0272799246,
0.0479703583,
0.0274061356,
-0.0388119556,
-0.0070592863,
0.0490186848,
-0.0151917012,
0.0052436176,
0.045538377,
0.0090442812,
-0.0164813902,
-0.0099392096,
0.0251003206,
0.0498097278,
0.0028461777,
0.0164527874,
0.0349492766,
-0.0110837417,
0.021106882,
0.0291687045,
0.0230658147,
-0.0753971264,
0.0004904927,
0.0006084073,
0.0134813832,
-0.0107838502,
-0.0091798808,
0.0316568464,
0.0020706623,
-0.0011893515,
0.0017800528,
0.049043823,
-0.0221564248,
-0.0121292183,
0.0082227951,
-0.0097763529,
-0.0290875658,
-0.0074904757,
0.0300367959,
-0.0124957627,
0.0372442715,
0.0071459594,
-0.0116330106,
-0.0687724501,
0.0410814136,
-0.0434417166,
-0.1022072136,
-0.0464033149,
0.0812900513,
0.0564500801,
0.0060041626,
-0.0484793484,
-0.0050318399,
-0.0281051397,
-0.0013356396,
0.0048219711,
0.0281201191,
0.0167511702,
0.0920612291,
0.033246614,
-0.0104322517,
-0.0433055535,
0.0853017345,
0.038032677,
0.0381870084,
-0.0174708255,
0.0040267366,
-0.0223675277,
-0.04922916,
0.0298936199,
-0.0056569809,
0.0090762209,
0.015206337,
-0.0190950204,
-0.0595576949,
-0.0122104464,
0.0597590767,
-0.008828735,
0.0035673054,
0.0283922534,
0.0442065187,
0.068239592,
-0.0006774362,
0.0080426503,
-0.0162932966,
0.0096330196,
0.0218091663,
0.0431562886,
-5.904422166e-33,
-0.0231929403,
0.0189724397,
0.0551140383,
0.0040228902,
-0.0407362916,
0.0440083258,
-0.0012478854,
-0.0089565115,
-0.0465388782,
-0.0254674032,
-0.0090487013,
0.0009897016,
0.0081077609,
0.0350776352,
-0.0434765592,
-0.026992375,
0.0326636992,
-0.0418699458,
-0.0113861104,
0.0073197372,
-0.0392117426,
-0.0174463745,
0.0212411229,
0.0033127933,
-0.0539640523,
0.0028296346,
-0.0080409851,
0.0265361201,
-0.0176235549,
0.0633299574,
-0.0626219511,
0.0059331427,
0.0189299714,
-0.0428490452,
-0.0071902303,
0.0162312221,
-0.054587733,
-0.0087536965,
0.0119773671,
0.0053336569,
-0.0834098011,
0.0200935416,
0.034509562,
-0.0097920531,
0.0241085887,
-0.0451133512,
0.011685296,
-0.0185745601,
-0.011837204,
0.0047440031,
-0.0090681314,
0.0098579079,
0.0041601979,
-0.0274652783,
0.0375014767,
0.0476597324,
0.0032810613,
0.0355863981,
-0.0000798298,
-0.0005613213,
0.0228901003,
0.0570890754,
0.0530227832,
0.0214736592,
0.0116537986,
0.0306239817,
0.0476215445,
-0.0289290268,
-0.0129579715,
-0.0089001311,
0.015389774,
0.0410077311,
0.0675995722,
0.095139116,
0.061992608,
-0.0022818518,
-0.0684617385,
-0.0125485519,
-0.0432121791,
0.0268389005,
-0.0228494667,
0.0151517987,
0.0401067436,
0.0044622333,
-0.044276312,
-0.0225216132,
-0.0240108836,
0.0028436154,
0.0313689262,
0.0571840927,
-0.0293446183,
0.0106270928,
0.0542560481,
-0.0709031895,
0.0178103503,
0.0123383729,
-0.0046191481,
0.0426345095,
0.0287285522,
0.034330532,
-0.0335022956,
0.017148491,
0.0131947165,
-0.0232958198,
-0.0161916278,
-0.0109485313,
0.0261694733,
0.0329258963,
-0.0640905797,
-0.0120804459,
-0.035731025,
-0.0029057437,
0.0032872946,
0.0482399538,
0.0229377672,
0.0135651659,
-0.0274679996,
-0.0160592739,
-0.0236781519,
-0.0180229917,
-0.0250896718,
-0.043318212,
0.0318889618,
0.040618185,
-0.0155752972,
0.0043007517,
-0.0632844418,
-0.0083651505,
-0.0103349565,
-0.0625320524,
-0.0359078161,
0.0577377714,
2.466e-7,
0.0314643756,
-0.03835655,
-0.003480606,
0.0025095141,
0.0168566238,
0.0582743809,
-0.0142059894,
0.0298611131,
-0.0164545979,
-0.0287716445,
0.0113168834,
0.0509874411,
0.0203855466,
0.0069462801,
0.0157305561,
0.0437855124,
-0.0323364735,
-0.0287196934,
-0.0176847279,
-0.0271743611,
0.0532946698,
0.1149955764,
-0.0178852845,
-0.0175139327,
0.0474666469,
-0.0311523937,
0.0698264763,
-0.0148875322,
-0.0050274646,
-0.0211107433,
-0.0248837527,
0.0224784017,
-0.0233453494,
0.0318511054,
0.0135811977,
0.0020128181,
0.0278030951,
0.0632731095,
-0.0026531594,
-0.0327672586,
-0.0251444746,
0.0051665884,
-0.032478746,
-0.0153940478,
0.0876553878,
-0.0195804033,
-0.0111109205,
-0.0586290844,
-0.027103493,
-0.009229945,
0.0677114725,
-0.0187791213,
0.0193937477,
0.0241995305,
0.0118520912,
-0.033225283,
-0.0084602116,
-0.091917567,
0.0141456388,
-0.0147099076,
-0.0408694334,
-0.0311665814,
-0.065601401,
-0.0124325622,
0.0641287044,
-0.0014283119,
-0.0720973536,
1.858050311e-34,
0.0290475022,
-0.0335733779,
0.0077481964,
0.0066802069,
0.0019277374,
-0.0177725591,
0.0055759801,
-0.0425103605,
-0.0083409334,
-0.0652560368,
-0.0171790961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15319v1 | Hallucination Detection for Grounded Instruction Generation | 2023-10-23T19:36:28 | 2023-10-23T19:36:28 | Lingjun Zhao, Khanh Nguyen, Hal Daumé III | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We investigate the problem of generating instructions to guide humans to
navigate in simulated residential environments. A major issue with current
models is hallucination: they generate references to actions or objects that
are inconsistent with what a human follower would perform or encounter along
the described path. We develop a model that detects these hallucinated
references by adopting a model pre-trained on a large corpus of image-text
pairs, and fine-tuning it with a contrastive loss that separates correct
instructions from instructions containing synthesized hallucinations. Our final
model outperforms several baselines, including using word probability estimated
by the instruction-generation model, and supervised models based on LSTM and
Transformer. | [
0.0151763679,
-0.0041932957,
-0.0051115523,
0.0150517914,
-0.0022375146,
0.0164533202,
-0.0024472489,
0.0082108732,
0.0137967477,
-0.0522366352,
-0.0238126647,
-0.0273760576,
-0.0067006857,
-0.0476276726,
0.0193168111,
-0.0583329275,
0.0231292434,
-0.0296557639,
-0.0890418291,
0.0192056783,
-0.0277547669,
0.02507383,
-0.0266111735,
0.0485134423,
-0.0386914909,
-0.0160803422,
-0.0043572877,
0.0161271058,
0.0432258174,
-0.0641782805,
0.0291528981,
0.044370763,
0.0535743199,
0.0417486429,
0.0000018818,
-0.0177764744,
0.010091708,
-0.034245383,
0.0173105299,
-0.0562777631,
0.0528295822,
-0.0080823675,
0.0053637871,
0.0188517738,
-0.0233414993,
0.0039939089,
0.0499370284,
0.12837632,
0.0514353476,
0.0500980616,
0.0102003682,
-0.0497114807,
-0.0029448757,
0.0197240785,
0.0800156891,
0.0464098789,
0.0029965267,
0.0201380886,
0.0037813445,
-0.0045633111,
-0.0170181021,
-0.0058397651,
0.0417171866,
0.024694439,
0.0262769293,
0.0516086631,
-0.0385314636,
0.011738766,
-0.0138556277,
0.0845574141,
-0.0776425302,
-0.0350277685,
0.044098869,
0.0050450927,
-0.0080405185,
0.017039692,
-0.0098177996,
0.02773384,
-0.0045922049,
0.0295612048,
-0.0240598582,
0.0040007816,
0.0232978482,
0.0182138085,
0.0278224628,
0.0387132801,
0.0108550228,
-0.0115678571,
0.0158706903,
0.0198797267,
0.0004285875,
-0.0510800369,
0.0538561754,
0.0266434047,
-0.0396548323,
-0.0011242044,
-0.054059796,
0.0460233949,
0.0198402405,
-0.076005429,
0.0487303659,
-0.0053147459,
-0.0579184592,
0.0402132906,
-0.0345191658,
0.03123926,
-0.0437606573,
0.0720316023,
-0.0169807859,
0.0700279623,
-0.0352572724,
0.0221109428,
-0.0608672276,
0.0073812967,
-0.0652533621,
-0.037801493,
-0.0175286941,
0.0042091799,
-0.0358489417,
0.0188345667,
-0.0196185708,
0.0655704811,
-0.0332945436,
-0.0172135476,
0.0059182593,
-0.03902217,
-0.0196923353,
-0.0007934877,
-0.0102262199,
-0.037339557,
-0.0110989921,
0.0501249619,
0.0085297264,
0.0102860443,
-0.0114026619,
0.0250315461,
0.0158499591,
-0.0050735781,
-0.0709374472,
-0.0666518733,
-0.0139674209,
-0.0549715273,
0.0684206113,
-0.0560618415,
-0.016395703,
-0.0396538191,
-0.0142594473,
-0.0330404378,
0.0376165323,
0.0225833151,
-0.0283040833,
0.0571663827,
0.0105843944,
-0.022664316,
0.0630487055,
0.0462909639,
-0.0081661632,
0.0402752385,
0.0144242086,
0.0713110492,
-0.0218999833,
0.0114126215,
0.085729152,
0.003668726,
-0.0041025407,
0.0259233192,
-0.0036621676,
-0.0310847592,
-0.0082576592,
0.0314250179,
0.0068665142,
0.0553753152,
-0.0346638896,
0.0038510852,
0.023907857,
0.018731121,
-0.0387520939,
-0.0231754482,
0.0625852793,
0.0216324963,
-0.0480875708,
0.0398808122,
-0.0564877391,
0.041550763,
0.0059179682,
-0.0161072314,
0.0070658154,
-0.0307723768,
-0.0258520953,
-0.0158078447,
0.004397986,
-0.0234006532,
0.0329775847,
-0.0503156669,
0.0085460544,
0.0295777246,
-0.1141335219,
0.0690360069,
0.000546091,
-0.0124294376,
0.0212013926,
-0.0081942305,
0.0039846944,
0.1130114868,
0.025750367,
0.0310062245,
0.0494476072,
-0.0475616716,
0.0817339197,
0.0555044077,
-0.0160826668,
0.0119805494,
0.0190481264,
-0.0699471533,
-0.0396553949,
-0.010760434,
0.0544119775,
0.012095998,
0.0036041162,
0.0021555717,
0.0460212901,
-0.0070768702,
-0.0523473695,
0.0391338989,
0.0151506746,
-0.0269189961,
-0.05137657,
-0.0113693299,
-0.0327840149,
-0.0225779675,
-0.0173572917,
-0.0069846907,
0.0032442117,
-0.0211401582,
-0.0189838316,
0.0071178721,
-0.0804725215,
-0.0108313598,
0.0077742217,
-0.0647723824,
-0.0104892002,
-0.0086908787,
-0.0244757757,
-0.0046106372,
-0.0076657631,
-0.0565781668,
0.0289114341,
-0.0225054659,
0.0224891361,
0.0724801645,
0.0219431818,
-0.0126957307,
0.0722990111,
-0.049642019,
0.0232276283,
0.040460296,
0.0240924209,
-0.0066907774,
-0.0237894598,
-0.0026154211,
-0.0416238233,
-0.0147496955,
0.0185794365,
0.0024426631,
0.0193471331,
-0.0726174638,
0.0293373242,
-0.0586695634,
-0.0315246843,
-0.0345686786,
-0.0302057397,
0.0302589051,
-0.05265636,
-0.0006060525,
-0.026907023,
-0.0073810699,
0.0088099176,
-0.0139649566,
0.0088266162,
0.0213555712,
-0.0031737317,
-0.036765635,
-0.0210267883,
0.0265775528,
-0.0092268689,
0.0095254211,
0.0208539385,
-0.0050821444,
-0.0839788988,
0.0326839909,
0.012210438,
0.0455254652,
0.0176819302,
-0.025731517,
0.0118972892,
0.0336228348,
0.0849542543,
0.0308522768,
0.009732875,
0.0284894239,
0.0485344529,
-0.0495865345,
-0.0346081778,
-0.0115614804,
-0.020260524,
0.000825932,
-0.0019978269,
-0.0565442964,
0.0111704338,
0.0097276634,
0.0311311893,
0.0472287573,
-0.0658988878,
-0.0223060716,
-0.0406325571,
-0.0430418998,
0.0114552304,
0.0091441274,
-0.043039754,
0.0400680676,
-0.0276149362,
-0.0408989377,
0.0247590654,
-0.025884809,
-0.0002154144,
0.0192038976,
0.0419651084,
0.0358141698,
-0.0070980154,
0.0275612511,
0.0309073832,
0.003382104,
-0.0164326709,
-0.0352320038,
-0.0036904979,
-0.0096001755,
-0.0174487289,
0.043765597,
-0.0833155364,
-0.0197078716,
0.0243661534,
-0.0167474058,
-0.0577665232,
-0.0105206873,
0.0061084293,
-0.0428514443,
-0.0629891604,
0.0060227886,
-0.0493616983,
-0.0050844667,
-0.0250775889,
0.0499814004,
0.0107694818,
-0.0356875993,
-0.0073633147,
-0.0153244045,
0.0959078074,
-0.0037401386,
-0.009649788,
-0.0498938449,
-0.0049899742,
0.0559318624,
0.0161388386,
0.0248915795,
-0.0397362001,
0.0268152729,
-0.0077272155,
0.0094311219,
-0.0193940829,
0.0775505975,
0.0648346469,
-0.0407240987,
-0.0541956164,
0.0882039368,
0.0253997315,
-0.0361222811,
0.0105767297,
-0.0187619533,
0.0150636733,
-0.034151312,
-0.0276039764,
-0.045048181,
-0.0227111168,
-0.0305113513,
0.0073103048,
0.0036476732,
-0.0145365139,
0.0177865345,
-0.0682281032,
0.0526876338,
0.0375818945,
-0.0186792221,
-0.0559248142,
0.0231476761,
-0.0151418522,
0.0329708196,
-0.0045657102,
-0.0403194353,
-0.0012004164,
-0.010143063,
-0.0010428521,
-0.0363886245,
0.0008407371,
0.0233895127,
-0.0419269502,
0.0580930375,
0.0819396004,
0.0233423859,
0.0257610958,
-0.0947661251,
0.01075052,
0.0011192928,
0.0345034711,
-0.0031756507,
0.0388786606,
-0.0137607893,
0.0183395986,
0.031389039,
0.0510073118,
-0.0776483864,
-0.0457703508,
0.0096198888,
0.0463063717,
-0.0725512058,
-0.0318480022,
-0.0334256776,
0.075418286,
0.0499720462,
0.0633608103,
-0.0078358231,
0.0027198251,
-0.0335730277,
-0.0233499855,
0.0366227143,
-0.0393915698,
-0.0503430143,
0.0029800313,
-0.0286394488,
-0.0084455805,
-0.0962102711,
-0.06147594,
0.0120737031,
0.0358792096,
-0.0126785953,
-0.0312146731,
-0.0312561542,
-0.0040277317,
-0.0209337864,
0.0364453979,
-0.0447163545,
0.028202733,
-0.0441304669,
-0.0105588306,
0.0056688716,
-0.0006460602,
0.0063397009,
0.0567795373,
-0.0664347187,
-0.0394833051,
0.0522893146,
0.0812473074,
0.0223789718,
0.0480118655,
0.0106389998,
0.0399125069,
0.0219928399,
0.0238329824,
0.0234444011,
0.0049353531,
0.0084399935,
-0.0093852859,
-0.0068238755,
-0.0057119997,
-0.0310970154,
0.0291881133,
0.002762951,
0.0212987419,
-0.0515147448,
-0.0012733924,
0.0122586098,
-0.0597682372,
0.0588589609,
-0.0555109866,
0.0435429588,
0.0005887694,
-0.0050352341,
-0.0052832724,
-0.0132040335,
-0.0174296815,
0.0021023701,
0.0431500524,
-0.0033868977,
-0.003302804,
-0.0155906323,
-0.024735041,
0.0060767052,
-0.0263156872,
-0.0605334193,
0.0149314292,
0.0312554389,
0.0222598389,
-0.0072687618,
-0.0184383281,
0.0278139152,
0.002609255,
0.0670258328,
0.0538061969,
0.0840293691,
0.0097495411,
-0.0013877075,
-0.0237224177,
0.0162925385,
0.0144195994,
-0.0431154929,
-0.0723432526,
0.0449176133,
0.0447773114,
-0.010726627,
0.0220098048,
-0.0493326485,
0.02873764,
0.0041395044,
0.0232379902,
0.0500442088,
-0.0571637154,
0.0054343496,
0.0052885073,
-0.0080813626,
-0.0193507727,
0.0599236414,
-0.0127796615,
0.0722989142,
0.0027104178,
-0.0336463414,
-0.0392119139,
-0.0174489953,
-0.056508027,
0.0076938472,
0.0199891012,
0.0063640946,
-0.0221166722,
-0.0235599354,
0.0003112853,
0.0138230631,
0.0330844559,
-0.003087508,
0.0952483639,
-0.0146149425,
-0.0321716852,
-0.0331913307,
-0.0074151838,
-0.0250195861,
0.0293023922,
-0.0099479593,
-0.0691884086,
-5.878596555e-33,
-0.0211801436,
-0.0742517337,
0.052248355,
-0.0265307389,
-0.0106070535,
-0.044019524,
-0.024102129,
-0.0053499774,
0.0107105188,
0.0148614133,
0.0459456444,
0.0320674367,
0.0249813497,
0.0397206359,
0.0091599794,
-0.0296044871,
0.0582083687,
0.0044860956,
-0.0543825254,
0.0288602281,
0.0375103652,
0.0011530205,
0.0469080992,
-0.0870610774,
-0.0088093346,
-0.0430402644,
-0.0613840409,
0.0020280092,
0.0258489251,
0.0096591385,
-0.0412777029,
0.0104195289,
-0.0089960853,
-0.0501408651,
-0.0206553321,
0.0219466928,
-0.0029079607,
-0.0292606857,
-0.0214822739,
0.0374256,
-0.0508445576,
-0.053323973,
0.00604602,
-0.0183488186,
0.008012658,
0.0098440014,
0.048051089,
-0.0080675315,
0.0182804726,
0.0631876066,
-0.0790836588,
-0.0136063825,
0.0046965242,
-0.0552311987,
-0.006392017,
0.0443604924,
-0.0062044854,
-0.0437732451,
-0.0840805322,
0.0249365866,
-0.0002234845,
-0.001468098,
0.049949117,
0.0011946413,
-0.0019627102,
0.0645592734,
0.0257799644,
-0.0134612862,
-0.0396861024,
-0.0212049596,
-0.0057131746,
0.0890038982,
0.0193658061,
-0.0110827843,
0.0644904599,
0.0337251015,
-0.0077398107,
0.0370856151,
-0.0612983964,
0.045735877,
0.0311390627,
0.0085796556,
-0.0215840098,
-0.0125478171,
0.036116913,
0.0160429273,
0.0047805463,
-0.0609432608,
0.036110241,
0.0488267951,
-0.0153861502,
0.0017440479,
0.0441606157,
0.0001563474,
0.0043339133,
-0.0083957398,
-0.0075927945,
0.0041693123,
-0.0170215853,
-0.017020924,
-0.0241987146,
-0.054647129,
0.0797133148,
-0.0135487597,
0.0114683378,
0.040342968,
0.0112890564,
0.013097615,
-0.0529031195,
-0.0000458103,
-0.0191532448,
0.0004159231,
0.0189222004,
-0.0069856774,
0.0459706485,
-0.0264928434,
-0.0428303853,
0.0389928259,
-0.0242465083,
-0.0199004039,
0.0377791598,
-0.0016374335,
-0.0296976697,
0.0080226976,
-0.0243578944,
0.000148048,
-0.0492393449,
-0.0182715263,
0.0234499928,
-0.090782918,
-0.0078579253,
0.0014366783,
2.673e-7,
-0.0355781876,
0.0171004813,
0.0215512961,
0.0079998551,
-0.0318456553,
0.0045175371,
0.0378744565,
0.0236631911,
0.0096193524,
-0.0519776791,
0.0231487304,
0.0192091968,
0.0287119318,
0.0069788289,
-0.0439768992,
-0.0161469392,
-0.0258378778,
0.0340147614,
-0.0484473519,
-0.0541478507,
0.0515678935,
0.0318741873,
0.0033486856,
-0.0010681073,
0.0444654413,
-0.0171187893,
0.0445085242,
-0.0195373651,
0.0508709028,
-0.028071275,
0.0338022597,
0.027929103,
-0.0288778674,
0.0164338145,
-0.0469851121,
-0.0500136688,
0.0179439448,
0.0126226237,
-0.0258025713,
-0.0436427221,
0.0032104207,
-0.024514392,
0.0177902207,
-0.0133332154,
0.0209801346,
-0.0434321836,
0.0109549416,
0.0408999175,
-0.0463199802,
-0.0360754542,
0.0280907638,
0.0033196891,
-0.0443029404,
-0.0253767632,
0.0316503532,
0.0359707549,
-0.0105917705,
-0.0651711598,
0.0177506413,
0.0117894076,
-0.0115074674,
0.0022344985,
0.0012399044,
0.0040323548,
-0.040550001,
-0.026221497,
-0.0563179739,
2.012760865e-34,
0.0116888052,
0.0060241325,
0.0129827065,
-0.0048460029,
0.035338264,
0.0284063108,
0.0317775868,
0.0104728965,
0.0068771322,
-0.016998589,
-0.0176429078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15317v1 | Exploring the Potential of Large Language Models in Generating Code-Tracing Questions for Introductory Programming Courses | 2023-10-23T19:35:01 | 2023-10-23T19:35:01 | Aysa Xuemo Fan, Ranran Haoran Zhang, Luc Paquette, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | In this paper, we explore the application of large language models (LLMs) for
generating code-tracing questions in introductory programming courses. We
designed targeted prompts for GPT4, guiding it to generate code-tracing
questions based on code snippets and descriptions. We established a set of
human evaluation metrics to assess the quality of questions produced by the
model compared to those created by human experts. Our analysis provides
insights into the capabilities and potential of LLMs in generating diverse
code-tracing questions. Additionally, we present a unique dataset of human and
LLM-generated tracing questions, serving as a valuable resource for both the
education and NLP research communities. This work contributes to the ongoing
dialogue on the potential uses of LLMs in educational settings. | [
0.0274141375,
0.0206193998,
-0.0440361425,
0.0346886925,
-0.0279022735,
0.0030000547,
-0.0117413076,
-0.0071648899,
0.0055091162,
-0.0392028466,
0.0464730635,
-0.000383751,
-0.009104182,
-0.0002514797,
0.0456349477,
-0.0619728565,
0.0024598755,
-0.0424435809,
-0.0406363644,
0.0407145768,
0.0166528486,
0.0206336305,
-0.022610452,
0.0501549058,
-0.0115748923,
-0.0445755683,
-0.0382329188,
-0.0031059317,
-0.0280546229,
-0.0529209971,
-0.0169415288,
0.0198238362,
0.0199697204,
0.0197749417,
0.0000021713,
-0.0644590333,
0.0063414159,
0.0311682671,
-0.0526975356,
0.0825536177,
-0.0045998008,
0.068563275,
0.0086835651,
0.0289548747,
-0.0360221192,
0.0052651619,
0.0503521189,
-0.0564756505,
0.0850782022,
0.0306629501,
0.0313189216,
-0.0071433135,
-0.0033668764,
0.022530796,
0.0586744584,
-0.0266182907,
-0.0097535457,
0.0634764731,
0.0570374653,
0.0476534665,
0.0037384231,
-0.0027666904,
0.0448873155,
-0.0277264025,
0.0050347401,
0.000237657,
-0.0049739378,
0.011125735,
0.010212807,
0.0477003939,
0.0134496046,
-0.0341943316,
0.0072663743,
-0.0095513929,
-0.0013685535,
0.0177760981,
-0.0737624541,
0.0511160567,
-0.0077254223,
-0.032551311,
0.0015647009,
-0.0370070599,
0.0144774243,
0.0031714048,
0.0038843064,
0.0215212908,
-0.0025012242,
-0.0129772797,
-0.0392822698,
0.0359049737,
0.0303672701,
-0.0259393156,
0.0044315923,
0.0758007169,
0.0130683016,
0.0234991182,
0.0212386288,
0.0298509076,
0.047410138,
-0.0169253349,
0.0312427171,
0.0297734551,
0.0001668806,
0.0227044411,
-0.0367847905,
0.0534984134,
-0.0133648543,
-0.0491283759,
-0.0146788703,
0.0270143971,
-0.069243975,
-0.012909459,
-0.052856598,
0.0300676711,
0.0263070147,
0.0657716319,
0.0093609998,
0.034500625,
-0.0041526617,
0.0510029532,
-0.0345074572,
-0.0322977453,
0.0075768717,
-0.00204129,
-0.0059779044,
-0.0277139749,
-0.0544376187,
-0.0407164991,
-0.0086923568,
-0.0646266118,
-0.0097667798,
0.0317970961,
-0.0208750926,
-0.0085543375,
0.0152579444,
0.0664514527,
0.0269335378,
0.0366056263,
-0.0281858686,
-0.0693578944,
0.0533981174,
0.0006121979,
0.0070947632,
-0.1083051637,
-0.0575496368,
0.0397519171,
0.0040200623,
-0.0203179978,
-0.0117353592,
0.0362233892,
0.0280533899,
0.0349418893,
-0.0613446683,
0.0087576928,
0.0421143286,
0.0075556962,
0.0096260039,
0.0298655201,
0.0261447672,
0.0038205939,
0.0130305439,
-0.0721823499,
0.0825185478,
0.0150057469,
-0.0185039304,
0.0152210062,
-0.0286960099,
0.0360620879,
0.0444379598,
0.0191985667,
-0.004159322,
0.0345805548,
-0.0131204398,
0.0378541388,
-0.0216764584,
0.0586102717,
-0.0195996482,
0.0630730018,
0.1103355214,
0.0274055898,
0.0172274355,
0.0137792723,
-0.0118592391,
0.0391830243,
-0.0203454327,
-0.0003676068,
-0.0235215891,
0.0406395011,
0.0044415379,
-0.0452289097,
-0.005851862,
0.0277582649,
0.0068898858,
0.0146125089,
0.0122823054,
-0.0033999169,
-0.0168358441,
0.0520381555,
-0.0039810869,
-0.0540993921,
-0.0044254861,
-0.053059645,
0.0339247696,
0.0514292419,
0.0647937432,
-0.0381588154,
-0.0192640126,
-0.0329046249,
0.001290815,
-0.0340753011,
0.0680082366,
-0.0118351132,
-0.0240223743,
-0.039697472,
0.0040111402,
-0.0426209606,
0.00474812,
0.0148201063,
0.0429841131,
-0.0435685031,
0.0406362824,
-0.0344043709,
-0.0686274916,
0.0352458283,
-0.0151832318,
-0.04828538,
-0.0174930561,
0.0006947559,
-0.0528059825,
0.0287896302,
-0.0022087959,
0.0342736319,
0.0179045871,
-0.0052455491,
0.0064976849,
-0.0618079752,
-0.0248433184,
0.00530334,
0.0338513777,
-0.0599972792,
-0.0468202457,
0.0107265245,
-0.017062597,
-0.0170693286,
0.0384407751,
-0.0585326776,
0.0117341075,
0.0025893745,
-0.014508375,
-0.025085466,
-0.0502974615,
-0.0208864752,
0.0325463675,
0.066754669,
0.0743786022,
0.027955927,
0.0437819995,
0.0270195995,
-0.0243278481,
-0.0081598228,
0.0194292776,
-0.0239638127,
0.0327425785,
0.0295774117,
0.0232505985,
-0.0460809693,
0.0043071616,
-0.0515978225,
-0.0037291357,
0.0080462461,
0.0252516344,
0.0308855306,
-0.00448826,
-0.0103540737,
-0.0158220828,
-0.0614827983,
-0.0562022887,
-0.0366850905,
-0.0149948187,
0.0272112768,
0.0021534332,
-0.0424466319,
-0.0245992932,
-0.0028950125,
-0.0465089083,
0.0223620255,
0.035540387,
-0.0263380725,
-0.0774818286,
0.0653213635,
0.0246724635,
-0.0234627239,
0.0114627909,
-0.0267531294,
0.0227791518,
-0.0470955335,
0.0475015715,
0.0446858406,
-0.0483939387,
0.0223654173,
0.0328905135,
-0.0277828798,
-0.0470309667,
0.0005483835,
0.0415439084,
-0.0317406692,
0.0036262898,
-0.0702143833,
0.0064449674,
0.0461405255,
-0.0035465437,
-0.0100877583,
0.0054725367,
0.0368380323,
-0.0439475216,
0.0563122071,
-0.0350729786,
-0.0566056482,
-0.0245191269,
0.048673369,
0.0303025581,
-0.0871089399,
0.0747213662,
-0.0416192934,
-0.0269861929,
-0.0275255553,
-0.0232684109,
-0.0458001569,
0.0814438984,
-0.0053970679,
0.0135995736,
-0.0015603714,
-0.0215194076,
-0.0060432269,
0.0292321108,
0.0313998349,
-0.0352028683,
0.0393018238,
-0.0719271749,
-0.0302557833,
-0.0084037408,
0.012320444,
-0.0171990991,
-0.0236733444,
-0.0170214064,
-0.0252508521,
0.0214811023,
-0.0041726832,
0.0567998886,
-0.0156617742,
0.0416749977,
0.013567267,
0.0013828984,
-0.030999735,
0.0018572377,
0.0081612105,
-0.0263201874,
-0.061743889,
-0.0083336439,
-0.0430587158,
0.0507352911,
0.0251865108,
0.0598307699,
0.0664490089,
-0.0183546077,
-0.0020902259,
0.0336559527,
-0.0258735549,
-0.0287611168,
0.077682212,
0.0639696047,
-0.0973556936,
-0.0413704179,
0.0603690371,
0.0535424612,
-0.0559648797,
-0.0100719035,
-0.0201622695,
0.0099928211,
0.0616880246,
0.0499601625,
-0.0721191913,
0.0052037998,
-0.0026817939,
0.0299434643,
-0.0530576557,
-0.0173996855,
-0.0178978853,
-0.1033960506,
0.0041539981,
0.008648091,
0.0031277703,
-0.005972655,
-0.0534721501,
-0.029669404,
0.0220107622,
-0.031966228,
0.012932511,
-0.0089817084,
0.0315654129,
0.0388003699,
-0.0807966068,
-0.0117634907,
0.0457960516,
0.0163357891,
0.0448679663,
0.0711008161,
-0.0184887256,
-0.0215171371,
0.0156400185,
0.0305611007,
-0.0138949566,
0.000989569,
-0.0124968961,
0.0350028239,
0.020583041,
-0.0156587418,
-0.019180676,
0.016166199,
-0.0549248718,
0.0021135146,
0.0628330186,
0.064854838,
-0.0266860537,
0.0003355704,
-0.0193280783,
-0.0284033995,
-0.0094247349,
0.0420839787,
0.0706826523,
-0.0427284501,
0.0300212018,
-0.0858388916,
-0.0002880058,
-0.0293135289,
-0.0761545524,
-0.0273982007,
0.0128258718,
0.0433910228,
-0.0121753123,
-0.0353416689,
0.1050414145,
0.0340729915,
0.010045425,
-0.005909401,
0.0019993386,
-0.0100480132,
-0.0274004769,
0.045341868,
-0.0315277725,
0.032100115,
-0.0468677618,
-0.0291587487,
0.0016674646,
0.0074911606,
0.0068616392,
0.0578251742,
-0.0825543329,
-0.0326104984,
-0.0315763503,
0.0492702387,
0.0288945306,
-0.0283032078,
-0.0253734179,
-0.0316587947,
-0.1174106598,
-0.0093839653,
-0.0058918898,
-0.0317188688,
-0.0258740019,
0.0223201588,
0.0159661677,
-0.0320293754,
-0.0367680937,
-0.0256610978,
-0.0072679939,
-0.0055702464,
-0.0594131649,
-0.0276198164,
0.0708779171,
0.0347824581,
0.0054067769,
-0.0042658765,
-0.0106411399,
0.0275882296,
-0.0029349294,
-0.0258812513,
-0.0365503095,
-0.0227450412,
0.024151314,
0.016755959,
-0.0316286236,
0.0394397229,
-0.010089173,
-0.0527355447,
0.037481416,
-0.0464129038,
0.0727548748,
-0.0295346845,
0.0194462705,
0.042418275,
-0.0014336058,
-0.0333432779,
-0.0249724574,
0.0033254379,
0.0411479846,
0.0140391476,
0.0581960641,
0.013040009,
0.0500191897,
0.0618809313,
-0.0111412574,
-0.0109497523,
-0.1035364568,
0.0155505184,
0.0056466372,
0.0149733135,
0.0169477519,
-0.0148408189,
-0.0039045252,
0.0135801043,
0.0216874629,
0.0253162365,
-0.0049564461,
-0.0400524586,
0.0260553956,
0.055568967,
-0.0038496563,
-0.0579817928,
0.0747822821,
0.0091124056,
0.0134120705,
0.0038865397,
-0.025777556,
-0.02424266,
0.0202730149,
0.03742861,
-0.0117636276,
0.0113138203,
0.0027475376,
-0.0772832856,
-0.0749326348,
-0.0846207812,
0.0302017163,
0.0294874255,
-0.0173486862,
0.0473422073,
0.0642523617,
-0.0226741172,
0.0069811167,
-0.019445736,
0.0459814966,
-0.0099687688,
-0.0469654649,
-0.0124380793,
-5.949600822e-33,
-0.0353621393,
-0.0728106126,
0.0274283048,
-0.0033711742,
0.0183782391,
-0.0124845523,
-0.0350793041,
0.0358588584,
-0.0213869195,
-0.0161657743,
0.0295336917,
0.0186216235,
-0.017861275,
-0.0268328302,
0.0173209049,
0.0157940406,
0.0312165488,
0.0599030741,
-0.0283480994,
0.0264176186,
-0.0472814627,
-0.0153224999,
0.0266620219,
-0.0309077892,
0.0522299744,
-0.0706567615,
0.0131120859,
0.0016338821,
0.0164520964,
0.0325931422,
-0.002458849,
0.0074724322,
0.004868655,
-0.053806521,
-0.0185804348,
-0.0013071917,
0.0139864264,
-0.042139452,
0.0350796245,
-0.0279929712,
0.0118342191,
-0.0557044484,
0.0126409512,
-0.0042230603,
0.0135616772,
0.027074391,
0.0430543609,
0.0260340665,
0.0346648134,
0.0235904232,
-0.0403102376,
0.0299024694,
-0.085170351,
-0.0101120053,
0.0033151999,
0.0411839932,
-0.0103781763,
-0.0015189619,
0.0205001235,
0.008230906,
0.0332844444,
0.0406494774,
0.020996701,
-0.0204532128,
-0.0066939802,
-0.0114017185,
0.0167101342,
0.037151508,
-0.0380929112,
0.0133119794,
-0.0037247108,
0.0137180118,
0.0718908906,
0.0213967692,
0.0108232489,
0.0351860523,
-0.0308108181,
0.0221076086,
0.0290491004,
0.0022713838,
-0.016540397,
-0.025951812,
-0.0581687503,
-0.0309726577,
-0.0429227874,
-0.0081312237,
-0.0190935507,
-0.0383852534,
0.0318004973,
-0.052270133,
-0.0258495919,
-0.002009932,
-0.0138086351,
-0.0037580861,
0.0097463802,
-0.0124411648,
-0.0298205391,
0.0557370596,
-0.0164874736,
0.0246508401,
-0.026454607,
0.0325702541,
-0.015113486,
-0.023197379,
0.0884983987,
0.0233418755,
-0.0115586556,
0.0282668155,
-0.0599142015,
-0.0104205152,
-0.0498670116,
-0.0116582764,
-0.0246317647,
-0.0171466321,
0.0117526865,
0.033505071,
0.0011855522,
0.0267747343,
0.0099214511,
-0.0497739427,
-0.0320409089,
-0.0262548942,
-0.023027461,
-0.0085410001,
-0.0235901866,
-0.049509678,
-0.0343466811,
0.0511840954,
0.067258209,
-0.0320846774,
-0.0511227176,
0.0113387136,
2.805e-7,
0.0297554955,
0.0456349961,
0.0086201886,
0.0475962497,
-0.0161150526,
0.012841722,
-0.0209371354,
-0.0378160737,
0.0402939469,
-0.0256026071,
-0.0275717694,
-0.0057709841,
0.0198253691,
0.0237525143,
-0.0759054944,
0.014348249,
0.013195252,
0.0156753082,
-0.0688355044,
0.0364656113,
0.0919506252,
0.0101771699,
0.0197667275,
0.020894045,
-0.0062250765,
-0.0441553146,
-0.0054847305,
-0.0200785492,
-0.0058150957,
0.0427446365,
-0.0260466915,
0.0213874187,
-0.0088214036,
0.0117701581,
0.0026145184,
-0.0604155697,
0.0145496111,
0.0287430882,
0.0139483847,
0.0376219377,
0.0158809684,
-0.0478447862,
0.0143420398,
-0.1025854796,
0.0131185716,
0.0302243195,
-0.0037118499,
0.0323778577,
-0.0148918452,
-0.0248207115,
-0.0450915881,
-0.0102757961,
0.0208860859,
0.0085751871,
-0.0341447517,
-0.0200758968,
-0.0071888082,
0.0111891162,
-0.0364918858,
-0.007729745,
-0.0047954014,
-0.0613329858,
-0.0447171591,
-0.0248660333,
-0.0035301307,
0.0109868478,
0.020697644,
2.563967615e-34,
0.0191472489,
-0.0186246317,
0.0607662462,
0.0285790451,
0.0603610575,
0.0157221071,
-0.0089791184,
0.0234539136,
0.0098429695,
-0.0197705124,
-0.0236061774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15316v1 | Probing Representations for Document-level Event Extraction | 2023-10-23T19:33:04 | 2023-10-23T19:33:04 | Barry Wang, Xinya Du, Claire Cardie | cs.CL | cs.CL | The probing classifiers framework has been employed for interpreting deep
neural network models for a variety of natural language processing (NLP)
applications. Studies, however, have largely focused on sentencelevel NLP
tasks. This work is the first to apply the probing paradigm to representations
learned for document-level information extraction (IE). We designed eight
embedding probes to analyze surface, semantic, and event-understanding
capabilities relevant to document-level event extraction. We apply them to the
representations acquired by learning models from three different LLM-based
document-level IE approaches on a standard dataset. We found that trained
encoders from these models yield embeddings that can modestly improve argument
detections and labeling but only slightly enhance event-level tasks, albeit
trade-offs in information helpful for coherence and event-type prediction. We
further found that encoder models struggle with document length and
cross-sentence discourse. | [
0.0040511563,
0.0103903767,
0.0206436925,
0.0711635426,
-0.039812848,
0.0360307135,
0.0002527828,
-0.0182802025,
0.0378622562,
-0.0664879531,
0.0113173099,
0.0058430023,
-0.0333340578,
0.0535480306,
-0.0066526323,
-0.0251613781,
0.0327582918,
0.0193258133,
0.0326949172,
0.035571184,
0.0150632225,
0.004464421,
-0.0030235399,
0.032755699,
-0.0172781721,
-0.0381619111,
-0.026459476,
-0.0166093223,
0.0115989428,
-0.0183104407,
0.0233419463,
-0.0064537372,
0.0626276135,
0.0463935584,
0.0000017049,
-0.0249505322,
-0.0295196529,
-0.0143093141,
-0.0570343137,
0.0252786893,
0.0264657363,
-0.06424696,
-0.0143297343,
-0.0291793197,
-0.010592401,
-0.046202857,
-0.0111832973,
0.0867699385,
-0.0080740238,
0.0963062793,
-0.0195500217,
-0.034113463,
0.0620403774,
-0.0021115241,
-0.0036388591,
-0.0249041487,
0.0199384522,
-0.0353661813,
-0.0051641273,
0.0290226582,
-0.0042143459,
-0.0129876817,
0.0406703949,
0.0003720028,
-0.000188353,
0.0449976251,
-0.0043046819,
0.0031163208,
-0.0240264777,
0.0298666786,
-0.0108129075,
-0.0067667165,
0.0074104848,
-0.0152593041,
0.0040085111,
0.0163078047,
-0.0528866947,
0.0060203974,
-0.0010915297,
0.0395802855,
0.0748900548,
0.0149200913,
0.0188677218,
0.0229331423,
-0.0005967771,
0.0424094498,
-0.0098090488,
-0.0285528805,
0.0128085203,
0.0135875363,
0.0045822612,
-0.025463013,
0.0357580893,
0.0352817252,
0.0307347793,
0.024953546,
-0.0357089788,
0.0230800584,
0.0147997728,
-0.0879406855,
-0.0016070626,
0.0139177628,
-0.0199186597,
0.0777378306,
-0.0448561572,
0.0206137095,
-0.0243084412,
0.0207154173,
-0.0040474576,
-0.021755537,
-0.0359017886,
-0.010836523,
-0.0098567558,
0.0380319804,
-0.0496320277,
-0.0387208723,
0.0196006428,
0.0363471843,
0.0497344658,
0.0241670907,
-0.029291505,
0.0138450107,
-0.0407657102,
0.0023949519,
-0.0172634255,
0.0009357938,
-0.0450725444,
0.0183875393,
0.0111051993,
-0.0331449173,
-0.0504470617,
0.0315855853,
0.0343799442,
-0.0183386635,
0.006618984,
0.0256275311,
-0.0317503586,
-0.045380272,
-0.0613168739,
-0.0397631265,
0.0098608062,
-0.0253578983,
0.0186397396,
-0.0328874215,
0.0384904258,
-0.0187918153,
-0.0203162376,
-0.0545071661,
-0.0110134054,
-0.0145207951,
-0.0280163754,
0.0363348722,
0.0156400241,
-0.0530510582,
0.0319204405,
0.0119107915,
-0.0087400079,
0.0660442114,
0.0566875227,
0.0480986834,
0.0718361214,
-0.0057106675,
-0.0179791842,
-0.0051784264,
0.0045288098,
-0.0359913632,
0.0430140346,
-0.0212515518,
-0.014298507,
0.0028489185,
0.0568377115,
-0.0342759229,
-0.0499364696,
-0.0415449664,
0.0373317115,
0.0671804473,
-0.006588948,
-0.005449343,
0.040809758,
-0.0025111495,
-0.0038559947,
0.0384022631,
-0.0048451177,
-0.0353859179,
0.032655362,
0.0147917969,
-0.0168945044,
-0.0220301263,
-0.0319416821,
-0.0329813845,
-0.0090967976,
-0.0376128107,
0.005127898,
-0.0079051135,
0.0505454019,
-0.0099628735,
-0.0452063791,
0.0342086069,
0.0176754966,
-0.0286049917,
-0.001430849,
0.0054735076,
0.0163693558,
0.0087876236,
0.0166833848,
-0.0452456027,
-0.0249963868,
-0.012649362,
0.0475195944,
0.0437710695,
0.0563490242,
-0.0324467942,
0.0531122722,
-0.0490096323,
-0.0050822133,
-0.0728413537,
0.0319897756,
0.0079706721,
-0.0179219842,
-0.0251622219,
0.0050648893,
-0.0423571803,
-0.0224181321,
0.0485953502,
-0.0260126293,
-0.077273719,
-0.0139757497,
0.0026374601,
-0.0051411423,
0.0194252525,
0.0133687118,
-0.019558847,
0.0625669286,
-0.0710309818,
-0.0023039572,
0.0037244677,
-0.0015158369,
-0.053871233,
0.0017885588,
-0.0238977857,
-0.0320746228,
0.0242438652,
-0.054747548,
-0.0151309492,
0.0014326153,
-0.0242710654,
0.0105873113,
-0.0352676809,
-0.0223476179,
0.0044635609,
0.0280227978,
-0.0275747068,
0.0876625404,
0.005245571,
-0.0210045539,
-0.0164282471,
0.0203910824,
0.028992584,
-0.0296031721,
-0.0253513176,
0.0351323448,
0.0185126197,
-0.042209018,
0.004590678,
-0.0236319266,
-0.0414875373,
0.0060284683,
-0.0778135061,
0.0359473713,
-0.0394409895,
0.0736176372,
0.0240600388,
-0.0361039676,
0.0074297721,
-0.0009787681,
-0.0218904074,
-0.0807131007,
-0.0348591246,
0.00461936,
0.0686671957,
-0.0037559483,
0.0002969693,
-0.0533701293,
-0.0016204768,
-0.0613812953,
0.0892084464,
-0.0097464984,
-0.0316769779,
-0.0360692069,
-0.0035102528,
0.0232479237,
0.0168732312,
-0.0215941686,
0.0017433261,
0.0188958123,
0.0049898871,
0.002415454,
0.1370044798,
-0.0075986413,
0.1139580533,
-0.0177937709,
-0.0011154131,
-0.0752743781,
0.0075713932,
-0.0340649672,
0.0765406862,
-0.0427471027,
0.0053095752,
0.0339798741,
0.1020402387,
-0.0117774801,
0.0270818155,
-0.0101286182,
0.0048470101,
0.0112063009,
-0.0148659013,
0.0063482155,
-0.0313315541,
-0.0017731931,
0.0300034825,
-0.0388909318,
-0.0020051445,
0.078145355,
-0.0173619613,
-0.0085312296,
-0.0563666262,
-0.042100478,
-0.0397897027,
0.0680763796,
-0.0104757948,
-0.007335206,
-0.0120510431,
-0.0627908185,
0.0284209941,
0.0053437287,
0.0125735281,
-0.0138305584,
0.0090892101,
-0.0068998351,
0.0024008017,
-0.0109658223,
-0.0257360525,
-0.0359295495,
-0.0591077618,
-0.0024043566,
0.0236642845,
-0.0433561169,
0.0439061634,
-0.037042968,
0.0143606625,
-0.008040092,
0.0379389599,
-0.0355773494,
0.0016524922,
-0.0454619378,
0.0719811916,
0.0318137668,
0.0025521028,
0.0217828378,
-0.0065921498,
0.0393931046,
0.0833474472,
-0.0182362329,
0.0223497301,
-0.0399713963,
0.01864779,
-0.0146515798,
-0.059745416,
-0.0141463252,
-0.0515377,
0.0386228375,
-0.1048876494,
-0.0133223562,
0.0779449716,
0.0295382813,
-0.0100832861,
0.0067301444,
0.0062816124,
0.0075217444,
-0.0171526261,
-0.007395911,
-0.0514271371,
-0.0382068455,
-0.0072325775,
-0.0227088742,
-0.0007287536,
-0.0100856759,
0.02781762,
-0.0479355119,
0.0209695268,
-0.0194472726,
0.0237613712,
-0.0588530116,
-0.0722893775,
0.0213024747,
-0.0039721797,
0.0137553671,
-0.0042635198,
0.0068799746,
-0.0226622913,
0.007020704,
-0.036347419,
-0.0811405554,
-0.0007630071,
-0.0313483179,
-0.0076927296,
0.023903843,
0.0451494679,
0.0054074321,
0.0188905224,
0.0323741212,
-0.0228436738,
0.00177848,
0.0023970569,
0.0564215779,
-0.0511415713,
0.0214712527,
0.0167549942,
0.066620104,
-0.0275466982,
-0.0369995274,
-0.0251629036,
0.0813354775,
-0.0303870831,
-0.0181168243,
0.0026820011,
-0.0297492407,
-0.0054936442,
0.0830668807,
0.0345417857,
0.0096384101,
-0.0548426397,
-0.0126342727,
0.0324523076,
-0.0326617733,
0.0070066894,
0.014258652,
-0.0065472955,
-0.0143299988,
-0.031717509,
-0.1036019176,
0.0177427605,
-0.0189956911,
-0.0353817791,
-0.0049104481,
0.0138962287,
-0.0212370548,
-0.0346577428,
0.0721506476,
-0.0058224448,
-0.0113557158,
0.0325391665,
0.0212685857,
0.0211179703,
0.0356360562,
-0.028995689,
0.025937546,
-0.0372753069,
-0.0470447727,
-0.0234467946,
-0.0453017354,
0.0043380316,
0.0573552251,
-0.0126815671,
-0.0386407152,
0.031984359,
-0.0306291338,
-0.0001605633,
-0.0150555726,
0.0383709073,
-0.007846226,
-0.0050337045,
0.0180656705,
-0.0128156263,
0.037450701,
-0.0292371511,
0.0273867641,
-0.0564467497,
-0.0180361997,
-0.0049968623,
-0.0360238962,
0.0701282024,
0.0491821319,
-0.0426942557,
-0.0523143671,
0.0219413601,
-0.028804455,
0.0187823065,
-0.0240440164,
-0.0024122139,
-0.0020009375,
-0.0073449234,
-0.0337623395,
0.0379402116,
-0.0017355087,
0.0459922105,
-0.0538805239,
0.032237716,
0.0182845965,
0.0049199401,
-0.044144664,
0.0051054894,
-0.0646092445,
0.0304105375,
-0.0160153564,
0.032461673,
-0.0220816098,
0.0068150316,
0.0230057612,
0.0361617021,
0.0028865607,
-0.0133795878,
-0.0922725126,
0.0167531818,
-0.0172671601,
0.0114080897,
0.055612009,
-0.0557078794,
0.0364822,
-0.0084671853,
-0.0191696882,
0.032318037,
0.0154253673,
0.0257665757,
0.0361852385,
0.0514828116,
0.0446088016,
-0.0410643928,
0.0093538491,
0.0345229432,
0.0136645082,
0.078109026,
0.0036082505,
-0.0332102999,
-0.0519330874,
-0.0092276419,
0.0479514971,
0.0487742871,
-0.0183967501,
-0.0339254923,
-0.0360099077,
0.0191470794,
0.041267436,
0.018279653,
-0.0013246381,
-0.0195066426,
0.0051402743,
0.0684011057,
0.0113523761,
-0.0117876669,
-0.0034454509,
0.0341924131,
0.0056568957,
-0.0413530357,
-0.0375701524,
-6.006575197e-33,
-0.0324536599,
-0.0101261176,
-0.0028854939,
0.0746571198,
-0.0137864863,
0.0497082658,
-0.028002806,
-0.0293405484,
-0.02862381,
0.0389820524,
0.0034462477,
0.0117796427,
0.016793238,
-0.0057568057,
-0.0280117765,
-0.0453379042,
0.048283048,
-0.0119087966,
-0.013650855,
-0.0028831332,
0.0630935282,
0.0463424884,
0.0827506632,
-0.0837002546,
0.0582222678,
0.0105883172,
0.0257355589,
-0.010017151,
0.0505070128,
0.0595281497,
-0.0136292744,
0.0229895674,
0.0402729847,
-0.0649020374,
0.0045837848,
0.060192205,
-0.1058944836,
-0.0366519727,
-0.0051610055,
0.0082352431,
-0.0199781694,
-0.0676556006,
0.0373626798,
0.0212787855,
0.0359008275,
-0.0344141573,
0.032415729,
0.0111458488,
-0.0176430121,
-0.0435044579,
-0.078645505,
0.0544862971,
-0.0059558596,
0.0069746692,
0.0507147163,
0.0064157541,
0.0282847472,
0.0789384618,
-0.0491161533,
-0.0551515855,
-0.037696626,
0.0288885776,
-0.014178087,
-0.0392177887,
-0.0431012213,
0.0768840611,
-0.0162741859,
-0.0126415249,
-0.0305719581,
0.022227861,
0.0325170234,
0.0464421324,
0.0093237758,
0.045435559,
0.0379055813,
0.0199788604,
-0.1114244163,
0.028935425,
0.0733834282,
0.0094907591,
0.0057993149,
0.0072482801,
-0.0424489044,
0.0096713258,
-0.0281659588,
-0.0105367284,
0.0062356126,
-0.0172758941,
-0.0065454766,
0.0003065427,
0.0014822334,
0.05751957,
0.0193477757,
-0.0263842866,
0.0126776164,
0.0293855369,
-0.0074910726,
0.0160907023,
0.0196402166,
0.0046992223,
-0.0419952869,
-0.0281367041,
-0.0166825354,
-0.0229869634,
0.0543063805,
0.0003884682,
0.0489333048,
-0.0313851796,
-0.0085927565,
0.0069607012,
-0.0214969926,
-0.018461002,
-0.023972109,
0.0717705563,
0.0205325317,
0.0127208102,
-0.0132821351,
0.0524840578,
0.0061579547,
0.0591165498,
-0.0045980602,
-0.0532379635,
-0.0167837795,
0.0325056016,
-0.0067467866,
-0.0243504215,
-0.0218562353,
0.0434543975,
-0.002085872,
-0.0523040332,
0.021309182,
0.0305974353,
2.433e-7,
0.0479022563,
0.0449959971,
0.061928127,
0.0230648424,
0.0186012723,
0.0334662087,
0.0229112264,
0.0367801972,
0.0052353321,
-0.062385235,
-0.0161475893,
0.0281335004,
0.0437096022,
0.031542629,
-0.0746484399,
-0.0486882702,
-0.0486770384,
-0.0132679781,
-0.0547229052,
-0.0116871335,
0.0624405593,
0.0804124698,
-0.0011348519,
-0.0033906186,
-0.0053057163,
-0.0117654745,
0.0549634546,
-0.0156795382,
-0.0390472077,
0.0253440458,
0.0282061212,
-0.0116290562,
-0.0278625656,
0.0551805571,
-0.0121411625,
0.0748779774,
-0.0175259896,
0.0641230717,
-0.0113925189,
-0.0228586551,
-0.0174273066,
-0.0433391817,
-0.0086770812,
-0.0318249948,
0.0820022002,
-0.0575470738,
-0.045018021,
-0.0377408601,
-0.0380451865,
0.0084984293,
-0.0001100204,
0.0065420074,
-0.0203162692,
0.0186169464,
-0.0023599048,
-0.040163219,
0.0019827015,
-0.0583679602,
0.0111262426,
0.0272571445,
-0.0223218519,
-0.0184504408,
0.0023829564,
-0.046427574,
0.0372601599,
-0.0635776371,
-0.0264789034,
2.131312226e-34,
0.0178306606,
0.0365374759,
-0.0018170928,
0.0464513935,
0.0354642905,
0.0030034792,
-0.0071654068,
-0.0298106615,
0.0163862426,
-0.0621377379,
0.0073078247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15302v1 | Toward a Critical Toponymy Framework for Named Entity Recognition: A Case Study of Airbnb in New York City | 2023-10-23T19:09:07 | 2023-10-23T19:09:07 | Mikael Brunila, Jack LaViolette, Sky CH-Wang, Priyanka Verma, Clara Féré, Grant McKenzie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Critical toponymy examines the dynamics of power, capital, and resistance
through place names and the sites to which they refer. Studies here have
traditionally focused on the semantic content of toponyms and the top-down
institutional processes that produce them. However, they have generally ignored
the ways in which toponyms are used by ordinary people in everyday discourse,
as well as the other strategies of geospatial description that accompany and
contextualize toponymic reference. Here, we develop computational methods to
measure how cultural and economic capital shape the ways in which people refer
to places, through a novel annotated dataset of 47,440 New York City Airbnb
listings from the 2010s. Building on this dataset, we introduce a new named
entity recognition (NER) model able to identify important discourse categories
integral to the characterization of place. Our findings point toward new
directions for critical toponymy and to a range of previously understudied
linguistic signals relevant to research on neighborhood status, housing and
tourism markets, and gentrification. | [
0.0127531439,
0.0831913576,
-0.0305501428,
0.0184148885,
0.016392542,
0.0187101681,
0.0175567549,
-0.0009738732,
0.0204136074,
-0.0405656099,
-0.0085362876,
0.0107869674,
0.0439103581,
0.0048234221,
0.0221930891,
0.0042830002,
0.0181602389,
0.035555765,
0.0200554915,
0.006393618,
-0.009008701,
0.0525035076,
0.0053820601,
0.0480461679,
0.0057644001,
0.0389743112,
0.0482927337,
0.0208020806,
0.0244035535,
-0.0387930125,
0.038279213,
0.0314214751,
-0.0280059017,
0.0660277233,
0.0000017442,
-0.0162801631,
-0.0301893838,
-0.0375073925,
0.0147270476,
-0.0309189372,
0.0146136452,
-0.0154280663,
0.00008685,
-0.0587735102,
-0.0158211514,
-0.0549685881,
0.0384644903,
0.0049943612,
-0.0201620124,
-0.009424394,
0.0065517421,
-0.0568681695,
-0.016650388,
-0.0027231791,
-0.0433868356,
0.0269146878,
0.0454815812,
-0.0178837571,
-0.0242562462,
0.0036194371,
-0.0156275295,
-0.0167507045,
-0.0313708484,
0.0151425581,
0.0043622595,
0.0575923547,
-0.0246634725,
0.0376604535,
0.0159546472,
0.0472444445,
0.0334599726,
-0.0056838123,
0.0792285278,
0.0524529032,
-0.0489596352,
0.0067101968,
-0.0385105908,
-0.0128006879,
-0.016835453,
0.0223889034,
-0.0198231116,
-0.0222201031,
0.0395086408,
0.0688925013,
0.0289057679,
0.0411708914,
-0.005176241,
0.0025935336,
-0.057820674,
-0.0114675518,
0.0104140937,
-0.0642318875,
0.0240780152,
0.001191161,
-0.0148625225,
0.0226729773,
0.0299061928,
0.0541511923,
0.0009897758,
-0.0425730273,
0.0206042547,
-0.0030125172,
0.003522417,
0.0166692156,
0.0125980955,
-0.0017561376,
-0.0094296811,
0.0271335207,
0.0017830483,
0.0147601375,
-0.0458571352,
0.013964626,
0.0028284204,
0.0048866589,
-0.0622529238,
0.0190910883,
0.0007675589,
-0.0106037473,
-0.0222715959,
0.0149222901,
-0.0779097527,
0.0391012542,
0.0079314038,
-0.0192714836,
-0.0259757377,
-0.0259343963,
-0.0382582396,
0.0206858609,
-0.0367207639,
0.0295630284,
0.0511773638,
-0.0069241598,
0.016482817,
-0.0117362486,
-0.0207718443,
0.0249454621,
0.0579913594,
0.0111748576,
-0.0418660045,
-0.0130625684,
0.0039367941,
-0.0114035336,
0.0212205797,
-0.0456675887,
-0.02714964,
0.031715624,
-0.0204240065,
-0.0877260938,
-0.0191587321,
0.0001461971,
-0.0871224031,
0.0336124972,
-0.0379768237,
-0.0005989136,
0.1193049252,
0.0043119574,
0.03041525,
0.0070868977,
0.0515735075,
0.0244012475,
0.0706679076,
0.0142842373,
-0.0148295239,
0.0073213242,
0.017642241,
0.0168117844,
-0.0298422985,
0.0197493602,
-0.0108441999,
-0.0321244039,
0.0036211435,
0.0285340045,
0.0211677514,
-0.0329887047,
0.0397300087,
0.0718782991,
-0.0672004595,
-0.0082734032,
0.0141736893,
0.0404736958,
-0.0776688457,
-0.0249560028,
-0.0197170284,
-0.0377512909,
0.0031264469,
-0.0188287906,
0.02633637,
0.0268326569,
-0.0010760748,
-0.0130487029,
-0.0205825809,
0.0404842868,
0.010150305,
-0.0047564674,
0.0114595704,
-0.0365242697,
-0.0096979067,
0.0707577243,
0.045868706,
0.0368804671,
0.0237163045,
-0.0175351314,
0.0231022481,
0.0529503673,
-0.0091611473,
0.0371373333,
0.088441439,
-0.0224020928,
0.0289408676,
0.0346962549,
0.0163992513,
0.0015316341,
-0.0181113947,
-0.0222302154,
0.0128061241,
0.0479807295,
0.0428388193,
0.0279724523,
0.0206440184,
0.0181739591,
0.0189409107,
-0.038882006,
-0.0303043276,
-0.0305855703,
0.0298172943,
-0.0222864579,
-0.0541888364,
0.007542544,
-0.0471273661,
0.0114896251,
-0.0206816718,
-0.0377092436,
0.0185377765,
-0.0174659714,
-0.0077389204,
0.00003422,
0.0361572504,
0.0557424389,
0.0141482409,
-0.0247664731,
-0.034078978,
-0.0057178461,
0.0076740799,
-0.0301461462,
0.021692602,
-0.0080690272,
0.0450380072,
-0.006364658,
-0.0059062182,
-0.0102054095,
0.0359164029,
-0.0416692235,
0.0814934224,
-0.0437438264,
0.0284947604,
0.0241191648,
-0.0184362568,
0.0155120306,
0.0278534032,
0.0010620633,
-0.0107997293,
-0.0272053611,
0.0213594437,
-0.0149692697,
-0.0036775125,
-0.0004576138,
0.0227679927,
-0.0873817503,
-0.0016507757,
-0.0076873912,
-0.0020827006,
0.0055132704,
-0.0165291615,
-0.0370182544,
-0.0077156723,
0.020778425,
-0.0583632775,
-0.0636586919,
-0.0073019918,
0.0275183376,
-0.0426762588,
-0.0430129878,
-0.0136237508,
-0.0242389962,
-0.0477742404,
0.0609726384,
-0.0136715602,
-0.0182631034,
0.0409271009,
-0.028432725,
-0.023364611,
-0.0398320705,
0.0439049117,
0.0042897831,
-0.0010365323,
0.0606451929,
0.0408266112,
-0.005890029,
0.0096865054,
0.0166730564,
-0.008948382,
-0.0415422134,
-0.0163575448,
-0.0102863461,
-0.0296082776,
0.0189496055,
0.0086206608,
-0.0805030018,
0.0007270296,
0.0515546501,
-0.0002628493,
0.0029626237,
0.0118654519,
0.0864759088,
-0.0662991256,
0.0102095371,
-0.010708659,
0.0260912869,
-0.027388528,
0.0956128016,
-0.0465229228,
0.0069128913,
0.0093716728,
-0.0403597578,
0.0238367897,
0.0724423379,
0.0104051949,
0.007613509,
0.042288553,
0.0128831267,
0.0444697663,
0.0242439546,
-0.0965789407,
0.0225656498,
-0.0352545083,
-0.0322444625,
-0.0244699493,
0.0415717587,
-0.0213721432,
0.0086636832,
0.0652285665,
-0.0471548252,
0.0050672125,
0.0060109003,
-0.0620400384,
0.0266778264,
0.0066710818,
-0.0313120112,
0.0648751482,
0.0783414021,
-0.0201585051,
-0.0208514277,
0.0369010977,
-0.0155404462,
-0.033846084,
0.0464891568,
0.0312904902,
0.0756960884,
0.01512885,
0.0796615779,
-0.1242657974,
-0.023379501,
-0.0091929911,
0.0751988217,
0.041913446,
0.0082457382,
0.0033914172,
-0.067159541,
-0.0118891113,
-0.0187136028,
-0.0246504042,
-0.0076466743,
-0.0248947497,
0.0458540134,
0.0250811893,
0.0138482703,
0.0200967472,
-0.0071810936,
-0.003970562,
0.0408088975,
0.0184197817,
-0.0764680654,
0.0361143425,
0.0143686747,
-0.0088213617,
-0.0382820554,
-0.0621476881,
-0.0103873257,
-0.0603439435,
0.0016217957,
-0.0260949191,
-0.0450682193,
0.0313686505,
-0.0106839631,
0.0412389338,
-0.0013662856,
-0.0233459249,
-0.060591951,
-0.0283072684,
0.00632504,
0.0453828499,
-0.0311768148,
-0.0201415345,
0.0034245015,
-0.0418351665,
0.0533909313,
-0.0169167388,
0.0654120967,
0.0007701946,
0.0061344625,
-0.0510305017,
-0.0124758873,
0.0002638929,
-0.0538293123,
-0.0286564119,
-0.0135676032,
-0.0143760704,
0.0202639829,
0.0018806277,
-0.0521051325,
-0.0050633554,
0.0103962962,
-0.0065882052,
0.0132365376,
0.0067684622,
-0.024579294,
0.060844291,
0.0311112944,
0.0167441014,
0.0465324931,
0.0214252286,
0.009663118,
-0.0656369179,
-0.000446176,
-0.0035363911,
-0.0655119196,
0.0117042996,
-0.0168566145,
-0.0512447804,
-0.0263886023,
-0.0570347421,
-0.0110001294,
0.0446308665,
0.0237952508,
0.0038697806,
0.0292504709,
-0.0424627364,
-0.0553572476,
0.0109778102,
-0.0317265801,
-0.0056378539,
0.0167352315,
-0.0054709199,
0.0425887592,
0.0076538846,
-0.0551826544,
0.0207517967,
-0.0099972943,
-0.0392112508,
0.0652975217,
-0.0108767292,
0.0216055866,
-0.0146062328,
-0.014630395,
-0.0036325532,
0.0563308559,
0.0171816219,
-0.0100859506,
-0.0188384186,
0.0146671347,
0.0188030154,
-0.0049942355,
0.0238736309,
-0.0005266882,
0.0813724771,
0.0336925238,
0.028340416,
-0.105439581,
0.0948636904,
-0.0126457009,
-0.0536112897,
0.0785588101,
-0.0180677623,
-0.007584332,
-0.0255130827,
-0.0628881603,
0.0108554848,
0.0209392868,
0.029027883,
-0.0344713144,
0.0303513128,
0.0476821922,
-0.0725066811,
0.0303780697,
0.0115686478,
0.045314908,
-0.0318310037,
-0.0605603606,
-0.0083229151,
0.015531294,
0.0021558304,
-0.0112133678,
0.0207334645,
0.0728724599,
0.0176499113,
0.0340134874,
-0.003650968,
-0.0228364859,
0.0130857723,
-0.0168066602,
-0.0434317514,
0.0160595514,
0.0216966104,
-0.0256599449,
0.00166511,
0.0265992042,
0.0212145317,
-0.0256388374,
0.0130355638,
0.0377033688,
-0.0150046358,
0.0097599998,
-0.0021889044,
0.004182959,
-0.0993476436,
-0.0049204072,
0.0109125506,
-0.0309960414,
0.018704379,
0.0099406512,
0.0213660151,
0.0034831304,
0.0302708447,
-0.0527501255,
0.0227247346,
-0.0200950634,
-0.0317090861,
-0.0076089953,
0.0154705308,
0.0097753089,
-0.0947448611,
-0.0501868241,
0.026093293,
-0.0203084871,
0.0389620215,
-0.015320491,
-0.0033138411,
0.0474959835,
0.0222284086,
-0.0195506327,
-0.0418346934,
-0.0263862181,
-0.0459037535,
-0.0489782207,
0.0029796918,
-6.33871737e-33,
-0.0233072955,
-0.1358639896,
0.0370736718,
-0.0087709157,
-0.0306272451,
0.0248611867,
0.0001699708,
0.0308051482,
0.0114620402,
-0.0245747026,
-0.0037061479,
0.0104616145,
0.0122887772,
0.0246565398,
0.0226325337,
-0.0188344829,
-0.0050627324,
0.0349002369,
-0.0156310033,
0.0037801084,
0.0328175575,
0.0211550817,
0.0332241207,
-0.0761875436,
0.0297479909,
-0.0008539737,
-0.025138475,
0.0100219278,
0.074301511,
0.0172145478,
-0.0323529653,
0.0511215068,
0.0236599427,
-0.054585807,
0.0028099827,
-0.0095562385,
-0.0789570585,
0.0211192369,
0.0411420017,
0.0117069939,
0.0661858693,
-0.0275664739,
0.0344659686,
0.0258626547,
-0.0099345809,
0.0360583514,
0.0354053788,
0.0063293325,
-0.0452046841,
0.0223675594,
-0.0718519315,
0.0067349649,
-0.0248890482,
0.0597749315,
0.0268114153,
-0.0517017804,
0.038523268,
0.0095287506,
-0.0773400441,
-0.0005792303,
0.0133515093,
-0.0002969814,
0.0471108928,
0.0124012157,
-0.0005435416,
0.0372065045,
0.0316092111,
0.0067047775,
-0.011047747,
-0.0010872845,
0.0788297132,
0.0341658853,
-0.0806622133,
0.0417178534,
-0.0254490431,
-0.0472042821,
0.0079670446,
-0.0248213634,
0.0103676431,
-0.0747758821,
0.0237560347,
-0.0108028995,
-0.0475793555,
-0.0332907513,
-0.0351054072,
-0.0839977562,
-0.0215825848,
-0.0167564359,
-0.0030404986,
0.0053435308,
-0.0437604114,
0.0980598405,
-0.004320262,
-0.04200444,
-0.0867288932,
-0.0303589962,
-0.0029151628,
-0.0071851485,
-0.0114913583,
0.0527258031,
-0.0315687843,
-0.0117437597,
-0.0427349433,
0.039239753,
0.0256770495,
0.0143905664,
-0.0223355778,
0.0055622053,
-0.0297189485,
-0.016709486,
0.0434698127,
-0.0119600417,
-0.0346073918,
-0.0345884524,
0.0243856367,
0.0016293136,
0.0184558816,
0.0042359754,
0.0725329146,
0.0517775007,
0.0576566607,
0.0089356955,
-0.0549515076,
0.0587219782,
-0.023387678,
-0.0114654573,
0.019893663,
-0.0161515716,
0.0423496999,
-0.0416154414,
-0.0109718014,
-0.073219493,
2.349e-7,
0.0034659489,
0.0720954016,
-0.0207375586,
-0.0147909038,
-0.0157033857,
0.0087371171,
0.0689078197,
0.0296361241,
-0.0411002077,
-0.0250417199,
-0.0105549647,
0.0046186298,
0.0251092538,
0.0367180482,
-0.0968798697,
0.0258917436,
-0.0846395716,
0.0266536828,
-0.100804925,
0.0127282506,
-0.0275710374,
0.0494814068,
0.033583574,
-0.0189011544,
-0.0345596857,
-0.0232510902,
-0.0344280638,
-0.0739923418,
0.0094217164,
0.0414395221,
0.0091460757,
0.0088702058,
0.0041611814,
-0.0675823763,
-0.0107801398,
0.0179290678,
0.0474343374,
0.0051182923,
0.0219694693,
0.0031864899,
-0.0067545264,
-0.0813045725,
0.0195467938,
-0.0620555766,
0.0358314291,
-0.0002418201,
-0.0169641953,
-0.0185000747,
-0.0036259,
-0.0113345673,
0.0287566204,
-0.0122978417,
-0.0412981287,
-0.0007461078,
0.0012537281,
0.0004304364,
0.0134325605,
-0.0886751413,
0.0568246134,
0.0291930214,
0.0076169483,
0.0324865356,
0.0165265314,
-0.0500521846,
-0.0223480035,
0.0081990594,
-0.0072043692,
1.753181751e-34,
-0.0278175343,
0.0137422923,
-0.0425241925,
0.0076015075,
0.0515474491,
-0.002406016,
0.0117662223,
-0.022731794,
-0.0240518451,
-0.0121500893,
0.0195781589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15298v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15298v2 | TaskDiff: A Similarity Metric for Task-Oriented Conversations | 2023-10-23T19:03:35 | 2023-10-25T06:10:07 | Ankita Bhaumik, Praveen Venkateswaran, Yara Rizk, Vatche Isahagian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The popularity of conversational digital assistants has resulted in the
availability of large amounts of conversational data which can be utilized for
improved user experience and personalized response generation. Building these
assistants using popular large language models like ChatGPT also require
additional emphasis on prompt engineering and evaluation methods. Textual
similarity metrics are a key ingredient for such analysis and evaluations.
While many similarity metrics have been proposed in the literature, they have
not proven effective for task-oriented conversations as they do not take
advantage of unique conversational features. To address this gap, we present
TaskDiff, a novel conversational similarity metric that utilizes different
dialogue components (utterances, intents, and slots) and their distributions to
compute similarity. Extensive experimental evaluation of TaskDiff on a
benchmark dataset demonstrates its superior performance and improved robustness
over other related approaches. | [
0.0567492545,
0.0211998709,
-0.0386907011,
0.006745717,
-0.0666243657,
0.001533609,
0.0189354848,
-0.0093789948,
0.0041703293,
-0.032318823,
-0.0460604988,
-0.0269243028,
0.004386222,
0.0382671468,
-0.0112408632,
-0.044526659,
0.0153419673,
0.0101233134,
0.0227680635,
0.0310876314,
0.0369600877,
0.0161881,
-0.0291132294,
0.089117676,
0.0013829324,
-0.0441242047,
-0.0274371896,
0.0145074083,
0.0341893658,
-0.0128095457,
0.0371720046,
0.0311723482,
-0.0012627236,
0.0431173407,
0.0000018826,
-0.0617175139,
-0.0089292126,
-0.0369702131,
-0.0184575059,
-0.037544433,
0.0439036489,
0.063265793,
0.0059278994,
0.0480839759,
-0.0340334624,
-0.0039557978,
0.0507740118,
0.0501151457,
0.0455583259,
0.0637478083,
-0.0280070584,
0.032977473,
-0.0019610617,
-0.002455275,
0.0302556977,
-0.0319240168,
-0.0331363082,
0.0379472077,
0.0117576206,
0.0321774706,
0.0370615423,
0.0058665993,
-0.0023947116,
-0.0199322235,
0.0000176478,
0.0200016145,
-0.0136523163,
-0.0018146599,
-0.0248144977,
0.0847282112,
-0.0101462658,
-0.0335236862,
0.0118710548,
-0.0115028657,
0.0034288531,
-0.0102148494,
-0.0618824512,
-0.0184990522,
-0.0220492948,
0.0081376778,
0.0011392197,
0.0692719147,
-0.021630479,
-0.008984074,
0.0213755704,
0.0115517788,
0.0276729874,
-0.0377840884,
-0.0241593197,
-0.0232504494,
0.0134116979,
-0.0706660599,
0.0161752235,
0.0000569429,
-0.0870603397,
-0.0070665921,
-0.0515484437,
-0.042269662,
0.0365348831,
-0.0262121856,
0.0345036276,
0.050122302,
-0.0250403248,
0.039735131,
0.0226834323,
0.0735675171,
0.0259357132,
-0.0121562714,
-0.0634444132,
-0.0300940685,
-0.0965297222,
0.001318088,
-0.031282533,
0.00967653,
-0.0168363228,
-0.0496218838,
-0.0142388949,
0.0612309091,
-0.0157680102,
0.0118404357,
0.035769619,
0.0172371697,
-0.0340989754,
0.0099730436,
-0.0187568367,
-0.0219737776,
-0.0638902485,
0.0317934081,
0.014822823,
-0.0407887921,
-0.0001131828,
0.0413543768,
0.0236497335,
-0.0068466878,
-0.0416254066,
0.0154058915,
-0.0223517846,
-0.0426542088,
0.0178045556,
-0.0269217882,
-0.0330076106,
-0.0514033884,
-0.0609177127,
-0.0558258295,
0.0548905395,
-0.0173069313,
-0.0186892673,
0.0089951148,
0.0036274069,
0.0350007042,
0.0198874976,
0.062962763,
-0.0013822174,
0.0473170206,
0.0375198796,
0.0248795152,
-0.0490202755,
0.0199893173,
-0.0094514247,
0.0210175142,
0.072117053,
0.0270273201,
-0.0074080555,
0.0104228323,
-0.0283776876,
0.0036030153,
0.0358405039,
0.0343910418,
0.0167391058,
0.0145364162,
0.0055097477,
0.0379259437,
-0.0279850345,
-0.0089816544,
0.088346839,
0.0763557926,
0.011813581,
0.0111320885,
0.0249916539,
0.0780167505,
-0.0279772207,
0.0171094928,
-0.0181851387,
0.006545742,
-0.0013147161,
-0.0108867381,
0.0669879615,
0.0138964774,
-0.0495614856,
-0.0151273524,
0.0252876859,
-0.0211583879,
0.0185823869,
-0.0274295416,
-0.0285761487,
-0.0027875451,
-0.0377394743,
0.0243331678,
-0.000340936,
-0.0615063272,
-0.0582074597,
-0.0294782761,
0.0335134454,
0.0643841699,
0.0576844178,
-0.0447052643,
-0.0656610131,
-0.0124277622,
0.0112218242,
0.0100679798,
0.0345353484,
-0.0202742573,
0.0328885689,
-0.0466720238,
-0.0058050957,
-0.0119830882,
-0.0038747662,
-0.0039998125,
-0.0059712832,
0.0214643646,
0.0401092358,
-0.032739751,
-0.0036080128,
0.0035694616,
0.0015308926,
0.002012453,
0.0442069806,
0.0281569511,
0.0336459205,
0.0539242327,
0.0086417319,
0.0131713962,
0.0047565382,
-0.0336478092,
-0.0163926557,
0.0434350371,
-0.0529096462,
-0.0293741189,
0.0383086614,
-0.0393283889,
0.0223415866,
0.0497840159,
-0.0040885168,
-0.0466613472,
-0.005481692,
-0.0416262783,
0.0231160074,
-0.0432802886,
0.0447643027,
0.0055465056,
0.0104797455,
-0.0044588652,
0.0282572433,
0.0225887708,
0.0278027635,
0.0145484954,
0.0276833288,
0.0343164653,
-0.0413895063,
-0.0012917953,
-0.0074218703,
-0.0126883192,
0.0067200386,
0.0450242311,
0.0136427442,
-0.0573336594,
-0.0428377315,
-0.1488154978,
0.0247418173,
-0.0339073129,
0.0224232078,
0.0452884734,
0.0576867945,
-0.0188617334,
-0.0391540304,
-0.0737048611,
0.0046923696,
0.035187304,
0.0049113641,
0.0408023819,
0.0017282276,
-0.0178933442,
-0.0604845546,
0.0281970594,
0.0137869539,
0.0271074716,
-0.0120190978,
0.0041042971,
-0.0396262221,
0.0297625884,
-0.0187116042,
0.0052905078,
-0.0215886068,
-0.020381812,
0.0197116416,
0.0075109699,
0.0769394785,
0.0026355495,
0.0512425043,
-0.0131148361,
0.0138068572,
-0.0360450819,
-0.0682036877,
0.008582375,
-0.0260862354,
-0.0011023756,
-0.0067001246,
-0.0456166938,
0.061496567,
0.0048883455,
0.01330062,
0.0105972122,
-0.0529726073,
-0.0055384859,
0.0064556012,
0.0025865526,
-0.0124228643,
-0.0159112792,
-0.0218129996,
0.0072111906,
-0.0167596117,
-0.0551171079,
0.053158287,
-0.0495020486,
0.0120068444,
-0.0790737197,
-0.0475313328,
-0.0337558985,
0.0950499177,
-0.0431416705,
0.0212144237,
0.0282513555,
-0.021723913,
-0.0192844607,
0.049083747,
0.0298642386,
-0.0163351279,
0.0407085568,
-0.0275057945,
0.0007142108,
0.0186316501,
-0.0331903994,
-0.053822998,
-0.043675106,
0.000587398,
-0.0022536807,
0.0227197669,
-0.0199100766,
-0.0581295751,
0.0067607621,
-0.0323526338,
0.0390644521,
-0.0068502035,
-0.0118029211,
-0.0266875848,
0.0485669114,
0.0568404533,
0.0214250106,
-0.0468578599,
0.0131924665,
0.0779589415,
0.0295557454,
0.0162780322,
-0.0228767935,
-0.001408867,
-0.0444872566,
0.0078131985,
-0.042077262,
-0.0201321039,
0.0343650728,
0.0746026635,
0.0117570907,
-0.0248696711,
0.1462937444,
0.0497951843,
-0.0581231005,
0.0043736892,
-0.0361112207,
0.05216676,
0.0048969402,
-0.0019355797,
-0.052054774,
-0.0529539399,
0.0104356576,
0.0220928136,
-0.0264375564,
-0.0344156139,
-0.0095333327,
-0.0784888044,
0.0033506684,
-0.032276459,
-0.0308059882,
-0.030866446,
-0.0323932208,
0.0369896814,
0.0101384036,
-0.0098715844,
-0.0327144861,
0.0027030034,
-0.0155826127,
-0.0053166775,
-0.0163570847,
-0.0132422075,
0.0368330553,
-0.0381158106,
0.0645337477,
0.030131571,
0.067974411,
0.0642439052,
-0.0062814308,
-0.0293462705,
-0.0052933577,
-0.0122173503,
0.0259888843,
0.0462138057,
-0.0105742477,
0.0127358371,
-0.041111391,
0.0375145078,
-0.0297625121,
-0.0174844842,
0.0477840081,
0.0120087303,
-0.0517352596,
0.0122139938,
-0.0360767357,
0.0169407912,
0.0813734755,
0.1000317484,
0.0415764526,
-0.0286418013,
-0.0227555782,
0.0174280554,
0.0328219645,
-0.0095565962,
0.0296238698,
-0.0365906097,
0.0052870102,
0.0076823379,
-0.086050652,
-0.0586806424,
-0.0166575462,
-0.0171964578,
-0.0162836462,
-0.0039978186,
0.0097404551,
-0.0124790864,
-0.0416000113,
-0.0037716434,
-0.0064612203,
0.0532994531,
-0.0445347838,
-0.0253215134,
0.0071188789,
-0.0210741721,
-0.0223128349,
0.0063015129,
-0.1273034215,
-0.024333369,
-0.0581245199,
0.0170436148,
0.0094741993,
0.011232459,
-0.0213903505,
-0.0042669773,
-0.0277538523,
0.0074620466,
-0.0392266698,
-0.0196640342,
0.026640268,
0.027888637,
0.0020426649,
0.0467890464,
-0.0416108705,
0.016883608,
-0.025969293,
0.0473318584,
0.0028964488,
-0.110744819,
0.009869419,
0.0158063509,
0.0328921229,
0.0418682396,
-0.005510685,
-0.028122263,
0.0281856786,
-0.0089978948,
-0.0193242021,
-0.0454829894,
-0.0004290735,
-0.0125396252,
-0.0011145484,
0.0098301051,
0.025532281,
-0.0664546937,
0.0310477745,
-0.0634493381,
-0.0071593639,
0.0005312954,
0.0253023207,
-0.0084935604,
-0.0292909201,
-0.0290099625,
-0.0226312857,
0.038696114,
0.0089880498,
-0.0109149413,
0.0802348256,
0.013853739,
-0.0274234004,
0.0087220026,
0.0834616274,
-0.0581959449,
-0.0544021651,
0.0075800875,
0.0291917603,
0.0065525677,
-0.0132818259,
0.0452108905,
-0.0300815497,
0.0313784704,
-0.0263287947,
0.0378943421,
-0.0042810165,
0.0085763428,
0.0142479492,
0.0021026311,
-0.0063419007,
0.0232567284,
0.0767105967,
-0.0568657406,
0.0167469922,
0.0104857152,
-0.0427485108,
-0.0436828434,
-0.0302639082,
0.0244789924,
0.0698802993,
-0.0052655414,
-0.0064430879,
-0.0245692581,
-0.0154581433,
0.0246608313,
-0.0200983658,
-0.0073086312,
0.0183509402,
0.066170685,
0.0576200001,
-0.0376019478,
-0.00040648,
-0.0387137718,
-0.0342237875,
-0.0308802947,
-0.0131064132,
-0.0701369047,
-5.446136959e-33,
0.0142600667,
-0.0171589535,
0.0025501465,
-0.0024890203,
-0.0364540927,
-0.0007449556,
-0.0247882791,
-0.0133158751,
0.0033207827,
-0.0004429652,
-0.0006848231,
0.0227329973,
0.0139435958,
0.0203603227,
-0.0222580414,
-0.0202304088,
0.0527626984,
0.0027616106,
-0.0145498347,
0.0833510607,
0.0152319521,
-0.0050002323,
0.0033177668,
-0.0656593889,
0.0376481786,
-0.0199593194,
0.0204470586,
0.00268383,
0.066131942,
0.0475106053,
-0.0168130323,
0.0602175593,
0.0312399399,
-0.0269064754,
-0.0145744095,
0.0710200071,
-0.0140484944,
-0.0740410909,
0.0258721225,
-0.0533781387,
0.0086731613,
-0.0137191648,
-0.0364254229,
0.0072068968,
-0.0117333326,
0.00807063,
0.0254447348,
-0.0053791851,
0.0190472733,
0.0088619562,
-0.0627774373,
0.0142351678,
-0.0521264412,
-0.0687840357,
-0.0164149124,
0.0964113623,
0.015011861,
-0.0152998883,
-0.0355723761,
0.06096204,
-0.0462921597,
0.0042236596,
0.0167006273,
-0.0100357868,
0.0097119175,
0.067107223,
0.033685796,
0.0039118659,
-0.0204142649,
-0.0035574574,
-0.0376748443,
0.057739336,
0.0052624028,
0.0192006715,
-0.0060708649,
0.0104189934,
-0.0191903394,
0.0707474053,
0.0409224816,
0.0157617964,
0.0273446832,
0.0242268983,
-0.0766142905,
0.0056188279,
-0.0019639938,
0.0119513059,
-0.0286170468,
-0.0136709753,
0.059010338,
0.0000568665,
0.0037560703,
-0.031532757,
0.003898195,
-0.0339785293,
0.0349288508,
0.0166925788,
-0.0427941717,
0.0021382994,
-0.0096680177,
-0.0118292449,
-0.0284977239,
-0.0158206671,
0.0593470372,
0.0313617997,
0.0293362457,
-0.0014017863,
-0.0041430518,
-0.0156799816,
-0.045962736,
0.0077599054,
-0.0020749688,
0.0194497108,
-0.073543936,
0.0319001414,
0.0136305159,
0.0076331673,
-0.0307855848,
0.0758053437,
0.01572196,
-0.0202032812,
-0.04116676,
-0.0497326516,
0.0119371312,
-0.0266955793,
-0.0122025991,
0.010295514,
-0.0439618602,
-0.0292070433,
-0.01565836,
-0.006060496,
-0.0087043438,
-0.0329338089,
2.493e-7,
-0.0197091755,
0.0246054735,
0.0173926037,
0.0181635525,
0.0060127061,
0.0620372593,
0.018225193,
0.0596128739,
-0.0025331124,
0.005219758,
0.0410452373,
0.0010308574,
0.0589358173,
0.011198123,
-0.0749565437,
-0.008782695,
-0.0956004858,
-0.0527696013,
-0.0614746958,
0.0028564951,
0.1127619073,
0.0501289368,
0.0216141995,
0.0048136646,
0.0102841025,
-0.0260161664,
0.0082719503,
-0.0488802455,
-0.0013784837,
0.0392106585,
0.0569844581,
-0.0395709984,
-0.0054893075,
0.0167067014,
-0.0188399274,
0.0218718331,
0.044188939,
0.0385229699,
0.0125543335,
-0.0508144014,
-0.0399491563,
0.007655988,
0.0201366395,
-0.0662740618,
0.0607914254,
-0.0106543209,
-0.0130749233,
-0.0480671115,
-0.0110465465,
0.0057998756,
0.0470187329,
-0.0211679898,
-0.0475074835,
0.0191324931,
0.0271472726,
-0.0026952052,
0.0006024032,
-0.0655582398,
-0.0090505993,
0.0053978045,
-0.0392893702,
-0.0497428626,
-0.0651145652,
-0.0006469196,
0.011307315,
-0.0359320976,
0.0513050966,
1.995401431e-34,
0.0053773173,
0.0341445878,
0.0113544716,
0.0100135645,
0.0124434233,
-0.0019580249,
-0.0002643888,
0.0093450835,
0.0306800064,
-0.063846536,
0.0012525242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15296v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15296v2 | DeTiME: Diffusion-Enhanced Topic Modeling using Encoder-decoder based LLM | 2023-10-23T19:03:04 | 2023-12-23T07:05:20 | Weijie Xu, Wenxiang Hu, Fanyou Wu, Srinivasan Sengamedu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | In the burgeoning field of natural language processing (NLP), Neural Topic
Models (NTMs) , Large Language Models (LLMs) and Diffusion model have emerged
as areas of significant research interest. Despite this, NTMs primarily utilize
contextual embeddings from LLMs, which are not optimal for clustering or
capable for topic based text generation. NTMs have never been combined with
diffusion model for text generation. Our study addresses these gaps by
introducing a novel framework named Diffusion-Enhanced Topic Modeling using
Encoder-Decoder-based LLMs (DeTiME). DeTiME leverages Encoder-Decoder-based
LLMs to produce highly clusterable embeddings that could generate topics that
exhibit both superior clusterability and enhanced semantic coherence compared
to existing methods. Additionally, by exploiting the power of diffusion model,
our framework also provides the capability to do topic based text generation.
This dual functionality allows users to efficiently produce highly clustered
topics and topic based text generation simultaneously. DeTiME's potential
extends to generating clustered embeddings as well. Notably, our proposed
framework(both encoder-decoder based LLM and diffusion model) proves to be
efficient to train and exhibits high adaptability to other LLMs and diffusion
model, demonstrating its potential for a wide array of applications. | [
-0.0157200266,
0.0033890416,
0.0011582419,
0.033840362,
0.0015293187,
-0.0161499716,
0.0124302134,
0.0025125076,
-0.0224287137,
-0.0248214081,
0.0068006823,
-0.0176320039,
-0.0088489056,
0.0321725234,
0.026580235,
-0.0287925806,
0.0115096681,
-0.0094641047,
-0.0333120003,
-0.0017742126,
0.0131021217,
0.0179336444,
0.0305853039,
0.0125919711,
-0.0156282838,
-0.011377248,
-0.0412056036,
-0.0007846428,
0.024578752,
-0.0451013893,
0.006772046,
0.0352422409,
0.0876308605,
-0.0102875149,
0.0000019176,
-0.0039607012,
-0.0147182466,
-0.0212506484,
0.0400904343,
-0.0019655137,
0.0673122257,
-0.0631930679,
0.0265834294,
0.01918591,
-0.0127262613,
0.0093152067,
0.0088410294,
0.0589585304,
0.0782241598,
0.0763870925,
-0.0211895257,
-0.0503483489,
0.0578188114,
-0.0412520617,
0.0229080394,
0.0025143374,
-0.0073269634,
0.062988691,
-0.0063098222,
0.0552465133,
-0.0505721904,
0.0040699011,
0.0227703452,
-0.0108378362,
0.0776350647,
0.0628737137,
0.0335630588,
-0.0175477695,
-0.0107191512,
0.0651708841,
0.0045967,
-0.0048212199,
0.0524356179,
-0.0007544631,
-0.0332549624,
0.0012297941,
-0.0466828011,
0.0450860858,
0.0115190893,
0.0565283671,
0.0695355311,
0.0066674934,
0.0407473184,
-0.007634609,
0.0213204511,
0.0206843521,
0.0404894873,
-0.0038827716,
-0.0720522329,
0.0184986535,
-0.0045915279,
-0.0410408601,
0.0301928055,
0.0475942567,
-0.0050144494,
0.0012241298,
-0.056163054,
-0.0390564315,
0.0086354828,
-0.0104608182,
-0.0209761281,
0.0233620871,
0.0301811639,
0.0194773916,
-0.0248380322,
-0.0002766826,
-0.0278492309,
-0.0633525774,
-0.0512882657,
-0.0074436879,
-0.0286618862,
-0.0059359218,
-0.024737617,
0.043815054,
-0.0473817363,
-0.0311544742,
-0.0389725789,
0.0580319799,
-0.0022798199,
-0.0123582436,
0.0134649975,
0.0175246485,
-0.0296767484,
-0.0130129242,
0.0025646831,
0.0304285586,
-0.0573812313,
0.0066089714,
0.0467180051,
0.060182184,
-0.0144152138,
0.0455843136,
0.0327879153,
-0.0017731052,
-0.0299247019,
0.0087349769,
-0.0329529084,
-0.0088368934,
-0.0561680533,
-0.0326323733,
-0.0192931239,
0.0040104073,
0.0168566126,
-0.1048744842,
0.0296195857,
0.0061708819,
-0.0163008366,
-0.0375082493,
0.0170729533,
0.0320807397,
-0.0207915101,
0.0169724282,
-0.0470532998,
-0.0035538166,
0.0780835301,
0.0280794315,
0.0274356157,
0.0653573349,
0.0084676472,
0.0567015782,
0.0187055394,
0.0116588548,
-0.0211452805,
-0.0283414666,
0.0193327256,
0.0188194625,
-0.0076386281,
-0.020910345,
-0.0076178769,
0.0314411223,
0.0823378935,
0.0623530447,
-0.0539736152,
0.0083174296,
0.044468198,
0.0611175261,
-0.0007429868,
0.0172303375,
0.0436135158,
0.025981186,
-0.0665375069,
0.0117618106,
0.0391759574,
0.0259326454,
0.0015537711,
-0.003906138,
0.0785947815,
0.0347333141,
-0.0511506498,
-0.0315984115,
0.0142183881,
-0.0371525064,
0.0390364788,
-0.0594261922,
0.0356795155,
0.0281530712,
-0.0209156517,
0.070446685,
0.0159640051,
-0.0354123302,
0.060052976,
-0.0111182472,
0.0489673391,
0.0680195391,
0.063867256,
-0.0035188461,
-0.0098289102,
-0.0181449614,
0.0118061285,
0.0366381109,
-0.0038722104,
-0.0148427729,
-0.0308759697,
-0.0762960911,
0.0082335966,
-0.0545192808,
0.0325220563,
-0.0137982303,
-0.0097288061,
0.0198355746,
0.0501864366,
-0.0251020808,
0.0296629071,
0.0310028624,
-0.0387995876,
0.0124907568,
0.01957413,
-0.036273241,
0.0083665727,
0.0145285744,
0.0122558493,
0.009818092,
0.0277675781,
-0.0566585772,
-0.0397196785,
-0.0265236162,
-0.05565634,
-0.1037129089,
-0.004833376,
-0.0512277707,
0.0139331315,
-0.0193458237,
-0.0464335792,
-0.0395864733,
0.0274307337,
-0.0430162773,
0.0039969012,
-0.0573071614,
0.001527136,
0.0257367995,
0.0331531279,
-0.0067842389,
0.0773661211,
-0.0403979309,
0.000469176,
0.0184134096,
0.0349525586,
-0.0149281966,
-0.0331766047,
0.0032318828,
-0.0170898717,
0.0143888164,
0.023822125,
0.0245077629,
0.0070659551,
-0.0120710209,
-0.0485084578,
-0.0885067806,
0.0233676303,
-0.0465881974,
-0.0198507067,
0.0587035827,
0.00911103,
0.0386289693,
0.017215332,
-0.0541782007,
0.0106097162,
0.0241157617,
0.0168785639,
0.054010734,
-0.0446689948,
-0.0097292485,
-0.0344676822,
-0.0150956847,
0.0120552164,
0.0594230592,
-0.0232633147,
0.0040026531,
-0.0779750496,
0.0476024188,
-0.0131392777,
-0.0575978234,
-0.0296154544,
0.0204800889,
0.011306108,
-0.0041172612,
0.1008036733,
-0.0003945594,
0.0434230715,
0.0910867229,
0.0344844572,
-0.0280933864,
-0.0096908659,
-0.0197623521,
-0.0436093546,
0.0689365864,
-0.0089357411,
-0.0478575714,
0.026224209,
0.0650810823,
0.0239135586,
-0.0202214047,
-0.0353297703,
-0.007063963,
-0.0204407349,
-0.0089950627,
-0.052584935,
-0.0278363023,
0.0088012982,
-0.0119733429,
-0.0439523347,
-0.0542696044,
0.0484200902,
-0.0278340075,
0.0191807058,
-0.0373932309,
-0.0489094518,
-0.0532160923,
0.0011541365,
0.0113684852,
0.0168606974,
-0.0265567191,
-0.0162535626,
-0.0176467765,
0.0364914499,
-0.0255170409,
-0.0033922491,
0.063275151,
-0.0262442417,
0.0019257515,
-0.0017529582,
0.0083693173,
-0.0216568951,
-0.0488975681,
0.0450002477,
0.0251990054,
0.0144401584,
0.0049532615,
0.005331004,
0.015983073,
0.0240874719,
0.0083644735,
-0.0058497591,
-0.012999923,
-0.0309567899,
0.0888167396,
0.0698275268,
-0.0408017449,
-0.0223619994,
-0.0426772945,
0.0200765487,
0.0704741105,
0.0075254464,
-0.0160296652,
-0.0450139381,
0.0183983929,
-0.020127872,
-0.0223264676,
-0.0128925666,
0.0102161607,
0.0730257034,
-0.0217422526,
-0.0359848477,
0.1079066768,
0.026418997,
-0.0509118736,
0.0018415035,
-0.0066305152,
0.0706056282,
-0.0059538046,
-0.0104167266,
-0.0375312194,
-0.0196262691,
-0.0140438387,
0.0190161057,
0.0439562574,
-0.0288029034,
0.0038845346,
-0.0418876745,
0.0272637922,
0.0375729129,
-0.0094427187,
-0.0321496502,
-0.0850788429,
-0.0460427478,
0.0170817748,
0.0159572344,
0.0029388992,
0.0084228078,
0.0065447506,
0.0091144796,
-0.0209490471,
-0.0665720478,
-0.0370897092,
-0.044565849,
0.0360218659,
0.0189141743,
0.0200007334,
0.0182301328,
0.0062991544,
-0.0177462418,
-0.0293133203,
-0.012983324,
-0.0028746242,
0.0199394599,
-0.021977149,
0.0201854836,
-0.003936782,
0.041424267,
-0.0678248405,
-0.0429502688,
0.0097950045,
0.0837948248,
-0.0402015969,
-0.0283073671,
-0.0232453421,
-0.0061716316,
0.0147780878,
0.0628493205,
0.0496039875,
-0.0349875353,
-0.0203831773,
-0.0237871259,
0.0485537797,
0.0423106365,
-0.0085787373,
-0.0300894845,
-0.00735095,
-0.0392995998,
-0.1049633175,
-0.0483030789,
-0.0067381319,
0.0110961003,
-0.0163825471,
0.0132195214,
0.0408320539,
-0.0891665071,
-0.0662303939,
0.027043378,
-0.035197068,
-0.0342337564,
-0.0254097618,
-0.0189896747,
0.0498480164,
-0.0325463451,
0.0092663728,
-0.0064749052,
-0.095451504,
-0.070946008,
-0.0512904115,
-0.0137360506,
0.0006941032,
0.0312248338,
-0.0210603494,
-0.0448750332,
0.0725479499,
0.0119813383,
-0.0098058637,
0.0441367067,
-0.0416010097,
0.0080255037,
-0.0019913928,
0.006020071,
-0.0381059684,
0.0405645929,
-0.0629941374,
0.0436371081,
-0.0608161241,
-0.0069107465,
-0.0225800276,
-0.0335554145,
0.0306841377,
-0.0117491027,
0.0151560288,
-0.0696188435,
-0.0378181636,
-0.039001938,
-0.002575268,
-0.0348282903,
0.0090232184,
0.0356315784,
0.0012721686,
-0.0287760515,
0.0201556757,
0.0104712751,
0.0192057211,
0.0174144879,
0.0061919019,
-0.0110384366,
0.0158329681,
0.0069500781,
0.007852518,
-0.0247830562,
-0.0196488015,
-0.0524272658,
0.0156288128,
-0.047670573,
0.0571230911,
-0.0068962397,
-0.0037954994,
-0.0192194879,
0.0431898125,
-0.0537178963,
0.0117445355,
-0.0345780924,
0.008708003,
0.0564463735,
0.0203779079,
0.0568223521,
-0.004019611,
-0.0056395293,
-0.027046496,
0.0701768845,
-0.0020960437,
-0.0376317687,
0.0268858094,
0.0261459276,
-0.0312835462,
0.0192985088,
0.0755893365,
-0.0165399816,
-0.0165581889,
0.0135856876,
-0.0143445628,
-0.0288215578,
-0.0127999932,
0.0074905325,
0.0156715829,
-0.0039003617,
0.016581174,
-0.0040322645,
-0.0254895445,
0.0214818865,
-0.0160152782,
-0.0051470776,
0.0001543965,
0.0507929996,
0.0652035624,
-0.0226172358,
0.0298707895,
-0.0555901639,
0.0374088697,
-0.020457074,
-0.0440416783,
-0.0369282365,
-6.455398409e-33,
-0.0273254365,
-0.0594322309,
0.0338511243,
-0.0479165539,
-0.0504448526,
0.0099009359,
-0.0773041546,
0.001085491,
0.0425414406,
0.0107296323,
0.0128368977,
0.0249081422,
-0.0259733163,
0.060170617,
-0.0228338148,
0.0016855983,
0.0702660605,
-0.0056605036,
-0.0094721867,
0.0448411554,
0.0479839332,
0.0226449687,
-0.0085816756,
0.0159322117,
-0.027422376,
-0.0248929076,
0.0379915163,
-0.0012448833,
0.0695277378,
0.0095928991,
-0.0506752059,
0.0451021343,
0.0549762398,
-0.0257183351,
-0.0220093522,
0.0260471664,
-0.0432399251,
-0.0401357785,
-0.0494984761,
-0.0590683781,
-0.024002796,
-0.0668577626,
0.0530344397,
0.005862603,
0.0250418875,
0.0285179745,
0.0418880582,
0.0012108932,
-0.0390311629,
-0.0176773053,
-0.0456293635,
0.0347622223,
-0.0101603568,
0.015085564,
-0.0121971499,
-0.036070846,
0.0095563326,
0.0385334268,
-0.0660931841,
0.0276731644,
-0.0309643224,
0.0527658872,
0.0309904236,
-0.0121105844,
-0.0142936427,
0.0642517135,
-0.0104434434,
0.0356629863,
-0.0381696559,
0.0560757779,
-0.0096227843,
0.0510110408,
0.0160689801,
0.0224807635,
0.0172777567,
0.0017206096,
-0.0495899171,
0.0564719066,
-0.0397362038,
-0.016156517,
0.0573662668,
0.0357508473,
0.0012919091,
-0.0456701554,
-0.0238516629,
0.008346376,
0.007780639,
-0.0430660397,
0.0081042247,
0.042578876,
-0.0147759207,
-0.0211979188,
0.0312162451,
0.0092429314,
0.0180246923,
0.0180664212,
-0.0108401002,
0.0219029039,
0.0189638529,
0.0193429012,
-0.0611489043,
-0.0458111279,
0.029221708,
-0.0133578777,
-0.0146279046,
0.0107713742,
-0.011641277,
-0.0287335794,
-0.024230592,
0.0147498082,
-0.0248356089,
-0.0021610463,
-0.0330883078,
0.009683311,
0.0077195321,
0.0101192081,
-0.0154464981,
0.0712687075,
0.0124599924,
0.0308819786,
0.004917576,
-0.0533435978,
-0.0027646627,
0.0518406071,
-0.0194094516,
0.0438928418,
-0.0400719047,
0.0511323996,
0.0789336786,
-0.0629946738,
-0.0215832554,
-0.0136223687,
2.591e-7,
0.0318233781,
0.0479840897,
0.0042430386,
-0.0097602913,
0.0291952137,
0.0280067716,
-0.0157349855,
0.0379703082,
-0.0070154821,
-0.0567673296,
0.0205007829,
0.0697556064,
0.0048675509,
0.029395353,
-0.0672788322,
0.0464928746,
-0.0481236205,
0.022176329,
-0.0260463152,
-0.0320570469,
0.0164979193,
0.0641613603,
-0.0004208013,
0.0139477132,
0.0135100177,
0.0157053154,
0.1073110178,
-0.0077614137,
-0.0545482635,
0.034815114,
0.0190688707,
-0.0116994558,
-0.0060926224,
-0.0418710858,
-0.0306443609,
0.0225051213,
0.0021083683,
0.0514944866,
0.0180307254,
-0.0343832523,
0.0509562902,
-0.0085410038,
-0.0160130709,
-0.0177623928,
0.037840914,
-0.0428302139,
-0.0216569602,
-0.0187033154,
-0.0485311486,
0.0170676243,
0.0276874583,
-0.0209328625,
-0.0368702337,
0.0099066496,
-0.0060549174,
0.0091557903,
-0.0022725451,
-0.05328051,
0.0010549058,
-0.0002124825,
-0.0825552344,
-0.0416581333,
-0.0283540171,
-0.0080494722,
0.032714773,
-0.0101242149,
0.0231564716,
2.541683502e-34,
0.0448936336,
-0.0193587895,
-0.0255472511,
0.0164201744,
0.0174059346,
-0.027282577,
-0.0736429244,
-0.0119349146,
0.000077559,
-0.058643207,
-0.012634892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15294v1 | Adaptive End-to-End Metric Learning for Zero-Shot Cross-Domain Slot Filling | 2023-10-23T19:01:16 | 2023-10-23T19:01:16 | Yuanjun Shi, Linzhi Wu, Minglai Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently slot filling has witnessed great development thanks to deep learning
and the availability of large-scale annotated data. However, it poses a
critical challenge to handle a novel domain whose samples are never seen during
training. The recognition performance might be greatly degraded due to severe
domain shifts. Most prior works deal with this problem in a two-pass pipeline
manner based on metric learning. In practice, these dominant pipeline models
may be limited in computational efficiency and generalization capacity because
of non-parallel inference and context-free discrete label embeddings. To this
end, we re-examine the typical metric-based methods, and propose a new adaptive
end-to-end metric learning scheme for the challenging zero-shot slot filling.
Considering simplicity, efficiency and generalizability, we present a
cascade-style joint learning framework coupled with context-aware soft label
representations and slot-level contrastive representation learning to mitigate
the data and label shift problems effectively. Extensive experiments on public
benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of the proposed approach over a series
of competitive baselines. | [
-0.0110877883,
0.0316877589,
0.010171202,
-0.0031227996,
0.0174488593,
0.035273727,
0.0327938572,
0.0055173682,
-0.0115775168,
-0.0613813028,
-0.0190769602,
-0.0324319042,
-0.0189114381,
0.0080452198,
0.01984776,
-0.0254405327,
-0.0143421805,
0.0111583984,
-0.01422003,
0.0212764554,
-0.0572700761,
0.0030985544,
-0.0481056124,
0.0340352133,
0.0014316887,
-0.0292337667,
-0.0111439545,
0.0293084905,
0.0280277282,
-0.0300091337,
0.0175340008,
0.0264753141,
0.0233712737,
0.0417298414,
0.000002346,
-0.0249427613,
-0.0217441469,
-0.0028301072,
-0.0285350829,
-0.0366675444,
-0.0342732146,
-0.0392241292,
-0.0016344324,
-0.021942215,
0.0012193599,
-0.0970741585,
0.0704026893,
0.0174224805,
0.00582034,
0.0337980352,
-0.019317586,
-0.0379226878,
-0.019888116,
-0.0541197583,
0.0162918344,
-0.0799703449,
0.0462101176,
0.0019524985,
-0.039296262,
-0.0226387382,
-0.0406549871,
0.0262126233,
0.0164991822,
-0.0133716445,
0.072089538,
0.0413465202,
-0.0101322997,
0.004637416,
0.0005365928,
0.0881789625,
-0.0493741184,
0.0081686247,
0.010787122,
-0.0651587993,
0.0112391831,
-0.0296044666,
-0.0189392027,
-0.034985356,
0.0101057123,
-0.001867,
-0.0833500028,
0.0191116501,
0.0325075537,
-0.0428709276,
-0.0014148435,
-0.0311531927,
-0.0130016804,
-0.0012726415,
-0.0265227966,
0.0239948314,
-0.0187277161,
-0.0662854016,
-0.0093832798,
0.0012557812,
-0.0112105627,
0.0013819761,
-0.0199698508,
-0.0111669991,
0.0016787405,
0.0044677719,
0.0584916286,
0.0202674996,
-0.0534934066,
0.0654557273,
-0.0529470034,
0.0336668603,
-0.0292619374,
0.0293636732,
-0.0285125412,
0.0171359982,
-0.0416805744,
-0.0185996573,
-0.0246348791,
0.0095845619,
0.0355648287,
-0.007110097,
-0.0284453053,
-0.001000443,
-0.0256085247,
0.0069032772,
0.0469918624,
0.0177915506,
-0.0329825804,
-0.0132490639,
-0.0256569646,
0.0730333924,
-0.0099256998,
0.0325802602,
-0.0208130479,
0.03152325,
-0.0187503304,
0.0278383326,
-0.0031048916,
-0.0320749879,
-0.0010642994,
0.0680225194,
-0.005540336,
-0.0149793504,
-0.0521036759,
0.0262091327,
-0.0165573806,
-0.0640173405,
0.0358634479,
-0.0287192762,
0.0226902179,
-0.0010672582,
0.0464588553,
-0.0313267894,
0.0029569732,
-0.0146756712,
-0.0010177405,
0.0820521712,
0.0214579962,
-0.0356883444,
0.0012567423,
-0.0136039928,
-0.0378638245,
0.0831663385,
0.0207357891,
0.0152734676,
-0.0242312234,
0.0240067728,
-0.0098384237,
-0.0003292862,
0.0168472584,
0.0079238592,
0.0192975011,
-0.0093005644,
0.0755427927,
0.0528988391,
0.0609012023,
-0.0636291206,
-0.031883195,
-0.0523271523,
-0.0187380947,
-0.0283537004,
0.0813438669,
-0.048086267,
0.0819834545,
-0.0150435986,
-0.0564590469,
-0.0208622348,
-0.006263576,
0.0559577607,
0.0851196721,
-0.0096817017,
0.0167375803,
0.0022503377,
-0.0365238562,
-0.0139107658,
0.0316468142,
-0.0253029317,
-0.0120904325,
-0.0183824338,
0.0920587927,
0.0029435821,
-0.0207200516,
0.0479370244,
0.034315899,
0.0470443331,
-0.0189324021,
-0.0110732652,
-0.0344883427,
0.0057467036,
-0.0190918949,
-0.0606961846,
-0.0516861826,
-0.0244481303,
0.0408605933,
-0.0146746356,
0.0263889618,
0.0058031683,
0.0488547795,
-0.0336313322,
-0.0634018332,
-0.0154066896,
0.0118751861,
0.0456984118,
-0.013524428,
0.0208607707,
0.0390595086,
-0.0338017456,
0.0754205734,
0.0078346124,
-0.0135660795,
-0.0287683271,
0.0792451724,
0.056979049,
0.0076314691,
0.0035055149,
-0.0002424695,
-0.0408180095,
-0.0033333343,
-0.0312608443,
-0.0388170332,
-0.0405302085,
-0.0515482798,
0.0060334527,
0.0564114824,
-0.0223387424,
-0.0052711619,
-0.0392198861,
-0.0399445295,
-0.0096310731,
0.0254265256,
0.0466454104,
-0.0073107569,
-0.0228142776,
0.0029452785,
0.01630597,
0.0059221168,
-0.0216814093,
0.062399175,
0.0411778279,
-0.0018835636,
-0.0000730046,
-0.0072470591,
0.0336348601,
-0.024465967,
0.0043872953,
-0.0193797369,
-0.033549957,
0.0130372876,
-0.0197097454,
-0.0061962851,
-0.0291613489,
-0.0095484182,
-0.0284645576,
0.0198519304,
0.0237016939,
-0.0018928281,
-0.0121722445,
0.0020584159,
0.0235689972,
-0.0312333722,
-0.0261507556,
-0.0263924245,
-0.0599036999,
-0.0263928063,
0.0130595798,
0.0363886356,
-0.0056565846,
0.0517658666,
0.0205771625,
-0.0376573578,
0.025440665,
-0.0430944785,
-0.0315471962,
-0.0169405788,
0.0094801662,
0.024816921,
0.0030441927,
0.0129432799,
0.0157297794,
-0.0040031374,
0.0247719213,
-0.0584326088,
0.0634020641,
-0.0487691946,
-0.020826688,
0.0087845484,
-0.0240625702,
-0.0175005868,
0.0151842125,
0.0025672987,
0.0026954471,
-0.0258959811,
0.0614084378,
-0.0210565329,
0.0150997257,
-0.0438767038,
0.0047004339,
-0.0696153045,
0.0085407626,
-0.0069725215,
-0.0287499893,
-0.0516812354,
0.0199980438,
0.0002430048,
-0.0239304341,
-0.053182628,
0.0187239721,
0.0226795096,
-0.0109340772,
-0.0057414528,
0.003823664,
0.0084952749,
-0.033168301,
-0.0147187514,
-0.0131362127,
0.0097503783,
0.0875811949,
-0.0500824414,
-0.0351775549,
0.0054233717,
-0.0061421292,
0.0073459428,
-0.0133611523,
0.0251319129,
0.0237714089,
-0.0535385236,
-0.0510045066,
-0.0197627693,
-0.0295576304,
-0.0057029636,
0.0100870775,
-0.0802945867,
-0.0270138066,
-0.0703815669,
0.0072764261,
0.0004776262,
0.0497893654,
-0.0046422142,
-0.0010449174,
-0.008692353,
0.0587686673,
0.0098746363,
0.0088424729,
-0.0718282238,
-0.0061104945,
0.0008203236,
0.0357862189,
-0.0130530754,
0.0455408953,
-0.0366793461,
0.0492423438,
0.0227323193,
0.0224629864,
-0.0005175063,
0.0019878866,
0.0327578075,
-0.0143245393,
0.0163262822,
0.0484923646,
0.0009239644,
-0.0678464621,
-0.0314362906,
0.0334373266,
-0.0105813928,
0.0139413625,
0.0085788062,
-0.1272792816,
-0.0577206239,
0.0350584574,
0.0264422204,
-0.0045083617,
-0.01800129,
-0.0044527086,
-0.0981672332,
0.0359907635,
0.0102144908,
-0.0658731982,
-0.0011104089,
-0.0226471182,
0.0363136493,
0.0280886404,
-0.025755072,
-0.028197173,
0.0047136764,
-0.0430611596,
0.0452272594,
0.0587148964,
-0.0262855086,
-0.0171559248,
-0.0255969837,
0.028914392,
-0.0156671777,
0.0435728841,
0.0376275517,
0.0149123715,
-0.0062755314,
-0.0334763229,
-0.0104060173,
-0.0186214894,
0.0622342862,
-0.0344584733,
-0.0435362756,
0.0667411759,
0.026421085,
-0.0353389308,
-0.0191171933,
-0.0295672882,
0.0658812746,
0.0292659737,
0.0530675054,
-0.0203556642,
-0.0518812202,
0.0379358009,
0.0148785729,
0.0207338929,
-0.0303906072,
0.0102378828,
0.0061152754,
0.0268829819,
-0.0344566144,
0.0038781101,
-0.0008327993,
-0.0178816244,
-0.0929128751,
0.0114029413,
0.0377961956,
0.0334055386,
0.071057491,
0.0155441025,
-0.0272243898,
-0.0222057719,
-0.0005709172,
-0.063741453,
-0.0159215946,
-0.0505608097,
0.0400422402,
-0.0365034156,
-0.0067164009,
0.0369348936,
-0.0168317035,
-0.0532171242,
0.0096128499,
-0.0784973279,
-0.0182200186,
-0.017572118,
0.0115308259,
0.0040943236,
-0.0067716641,
-0.0273787566,
-0.0063331458,
0.0710306764,
0.1039633378,
-0.0243601147,
0.0174939819,
0.0450419709,
-0.0516230613,
-0.0111025702,
0.009424611,
-0.051922407,
0.0123737035,
0.0458188765,
-0.0200079959,
-0.0041390229,
0.0213669967,
0.0002864899,
-0.0557422005,
0.0615073517,
0.0061756228,
-0.0036798157,
-0.0255129132,
0.0429330133,
0.0031853314,
-0.0084610796,
-0.0362875983,
-0.0389120765,
0.0170959588,
0.0065260869,
0.0025882693,
-0.0205328148,
0.0498345569,
0.0565741062,
-0.0280726124,
-0.0257170033,
0.0638655052,
0.0357629135,
-0.0162257105,
0.0212246962,
0.0234554578,
-0.0131113138,
0.0513316281,
0.024841236,
-0.0165122375,
0.0072212825,
0.0440856554,
0.0392572619,
-0.0307940822,
0.0302235559,
0.011793172,
-0.0015977785,
-0.0386126041,
-0.0168572478,
0.0457117334,
-0.0066515543,
-0.0198742803,
0.0293723214,
-0.0264522135,
-0.0232211761,
0.0240706895,
-0.0017592966,
0.0161838457,
-0.0075019379,
0.0203547869,
0.0151770683,
0.0268011838,
0.0672625676,
-0.0028619701,
0.0266694687,
-0.0074388296,
0.0390119813,
-0.0222070329,
0.0130791664,
0.0355731435,
0.043195609,
-0.0005027817,
-0.0041880747,
-0.0354284048,
-0.045952294,
-0.0207617525,
-0.0531739742,
-0.0314049572,
0.065192312,
-0.0272444841,
0.0027385082,
0.0181523077,
-0.0335569531,
-0.022296153,
-0.0395011492,
0.0254375804,
0.0083719809,
-0.0098691275,
-6.229679249e-33,
-0.0191293582,
0.0058023748,
-0.0150122307,
-0.034610685,
-0.0298674107,
0.0406244472,
0.027663948,
-0.013428377,
0.0094564259,
0.0041034608,
0.0032629964,
-0.016226951,
0.0228069369,
-0.0056625521,
0.0191262793,
0.0017178354,
0.0482341237,
-0.0306764711,
-0.0039169583,
0.0190854277,
0.0192567464,
0.0434192047,
0.0203186199,
-0.0858863965,
-0.0185647905,
0.063055031,
-0.015139333,
0.0251592323,
0.068972744,
0.0296077523,
-0.0138076786,
0.0072514061,
-0.010953784,
-0.0730454102,
0.0042329114,
0.026942946,
-0.1180863678,
-0.0082234675,
-0.0461229645,
0.0515473671,
0.0524454303,
-0.0422123075,
0.0072255288,
0.0502206832,
0.0369525142,
-0.0775604993,
0.0068921745,
-0.0257561728,
-0.0070343763,
-0.0427400284,
-0.0286294576,
0.0341993831,
-0.0354519896,
-0.0439624228,
0.0255078766,
0.0285994131,
0.0406214632,
0.0426786765,
-0.0881255865,
0.0174479838,
-0.0634769872,
0.0130855506,
0.0100071998,
0.049649559,
0.0330994017,
0.062686719,
0.0529201552,
0.0102287456,
0.0416508354,
-0.0310174767,
0.027139714,
-0.0037695642,
-0.035590101,
0.0181500129,
0.1140224189,
-0.0029420876,
-0.0684755147,
0.0081620431,
-0.0650673732,
0.0187125448,
-0.0083771665,
0.0447930656,
-0.0305968393,
-0.0197112802,
0.0049429634,
-0.0706303492,
-0.0285704751,
-0.0207729004,
0.0135905491,
0.0345383584,
-0.0493161641,
0.0532321557,
0.0488219857,
-0.0382412784,
-0.0237490702,
-0.0267553423,
0.0228285193,
0.0533200093,
0.0141385673,
-0.0281255227,
-0.0298113469,
-0.0663928241,
0.0507638082,
0.059940692,
0.0475493558,
-0.0108585749,
0.0478238873,
0.032792531,
-0.0433035418,
-0.0188219547,
-0.0462795347,
-0.0016587563,
0.0278891306,
0.0545121171,
-0.0067369845,
0.0083619412,
-0.0064618243,
0.0905428976,
0.0184678417,
-0.0271503273,
0.0260612648,
0.0126110259,
0.004869794,
0.0237826016,
-0.0182585828,
-0.0153829698,
-0.0003111755,
-0.0092899203,
0.0649384037,
-0.0610271357,
-0.005150585,
-0.0143829165,
3.078e-7,
0.0033388902,
-0.0107911872,
-0.0014552571,
-0.0399727896,
0.0010953142,
0.0644172877,
-0.010205674,
0.0444876626,
0.0382580534,
0.0122530023,
0.0321215764,
0.0141495978,
0.0047670119,
0.0255781468,
-0.1362514645,
0.0926363319,
0.0200117324,
0.0443855934,
-0.0542465188,
0.026454905,
0.0003915628,
0.0957548544,
0.0362903625,
-0.0182878971,
0.0533867851,
-0.0429430343,
0.0293123778,
0.024915522,
0.0628804043,
-0.0205974579,
0.0112654138,
0.0383818224,
-0.0083980411,
0.0628654584,
-0.0053899572,
0.0221789498,
0.0389822349,
-0.0291908216,
0.0001145105,
-0.0377460159,
-0.0046539311,
0.0383326858,
0.0240600687,
-0.0343553796,
0.0644897595,
-0.1228520647,
-0.0411457904,
-0.0460004993,
-0.0744990557,
-0.0133162076,
0.0182374287,
0.0373629145,
0.0209938213,
0.0229614861,
0.0291774571,
-0.0146405557,
0.0063488735,
-0.0616007,
-0.01336521,
-0.0210607853,
-0.0187073182,
0.0182469357,
0.0084889699,
-0.0565775484,
0.0090584494,
-0.0179621652,
-0.002819834,
2.611215371e-34,
0.0109183965,
-0.0114621092,
0.0323470943,
0.0193455163,
-0.0036308831,
-0.0019744716,
-0.0351016819,
-0.0211267881,
0.0261305813,
-0.0172427408,
0.0033965246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15285v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15285v1 | On the Dimensionality of Sentence Embeddings | 2023-10-23T18:51:00 | 2023-10-23T18:51:00 | Hongwei Wang, Hongming Zhang, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Learning sentence embeddings is a fundamental problem in natural language
processing. While existing research primarily focuses on enhancing the quality
of sentence embeddings, the exploration of sentence embedding dimensions is
limited. Here we present a comprehensive and empirical analysis of the
dimensionality of sentence embeddings. First, we demonstrate that the optimal
dimension of sentence embeddings is usually smaller than the default value.
Subsequently, to compress the dimension of sentence embeddings with minimum
performance degradation, we identify two components contributing to the overall
performance loss: the encoder's performance loss and the pooler's performance
loss. Therefore, we propose a two-step training method for sentence
representation learning models, wherein the encoder and the pooler are
optimized separately to mitigate the overall performance loss in low-dimension
scenarios. Experimental results on seven STS tasks and seven sentence
classification tasks demonstrate that our method significantly improves the
performance of low-dimensional sentence embeddings. | [
0.0082539637,
0.0150325596,
-0.0053751562,
0.0568031967,
-0.0279426165,
0.025926223,
0.0116515141,
-0.0320570581,
-0.0076831118,
-0.0695999786,
0.0027685489,
-0.0340394862,
0.0157319661,
0.0082345782,
0.0164593346,
-0.043372944,
0.029435819,
0.03926998,
-0.0007069648,
0.0213474911,
0.018581938,
0.0042766114,
0.004407844,
0.0284619704,
-0.0258381367,
-0.0180249289,
0.0091147721,
-0.0250275154,
0.0206046328,
-0.0446085893,
0.051517535,
0.0278185364,
0.0801928267,
0.0034470265,
0.0000016666,
0.0112596108,
0.0326162279,
-0.0416110344,
-0.0052426145,
0.0310916714,
0.0188184716,
-0.0723660812,
0.0265878774,
0.0127300266,
-0.0154075511,
-0.0103701428,
0.0203828868,
0.0684034675,
0.0377478227,
0.0789578855,
-0.0075444966,
-0.0369165055,
-0.0004050027,
-0.0297214035,
-0.0256682206,
-0.0050849551,
0.0131633701,
-0.0359847732,
-0.0160578582,
0.0373840816,
-0.0332973115,
0.0076882718,
0.0169413164,
0.0381139182,
0.0644531697,
0.0424546786,
-0.0121854814,
0.0276135392,
0.0102727897,
0.0658061653,
0.010377733,
0.0198284946,
-0.0354768634,
-0.004723384,
0.0080892509,
-0.0133624356,
-0.0419910401,
-0.0078298589,
0.0491056181,
0.0550347157,
-0.0386533141,
0.0527017787,
0.0148132537,
0.0039287605,
-0.0170851182,
0.0167166349,
-0.0000585674,
-0.0708234012,
-0.0241205022,
0.015431284,
0.0011745967,
0.0428126715,
-0.0116839921,
-0.0288069677,
0.0056366012,
-0.0170294046,
0.0050470284,
-0.0337825231,
0.020200517,
-0.0861864015,
0.0315728039,
0.0055709006,
0.0087661734,
0.031690985,
-0.0337284952,
0.0634998009,
0.0106913634,
0.0297485907,
-0.0512276478,
0.0009837239,
-0.043253243,
-0.008226051,
-0.0444647968,
0.057658799,
-0.0229941849,
-0.0768900886,
-0.0570397973,
0.0162623078,
0.000638,
0.0061840112,
-0.010922634,
0.0427586138,
0.0046491297,
0.0144443829,
-0.0088478392,
0.0428462327,
-0.0458448753,
0.0458803326,
-0.0042887996,
0.003637203,
-0.0567173958,
0.0098861065,
0.0520982631,
-0.0252292193,
0.0000779326,
0.0416526459,
0.0168460049,
-0.0691566914,
-0.0076643848,
0.0104061477,
-0.0377759151,
-0.0456984937,
-0.0203556195,
-0.0372039899,
0.0488339551,
-0.0136590106,
0.0076527828,
-0.0341661982,
0.0020271048,
0.0278436672,
-0.024082562,
0.0476700589,
0.0336705185,
-0.0487288274,
-0.035635341,
0.0206068568,
0.0474820994,
0.0664896443,
0.0337692983,
0.0301863812,
0.0127423368,
-0.0136890197,
-0.0068355263,
-0.0193345007,
-0.0133619336,
0.0025048344,
-0.0040718196,
-0.0014182334,
0.0173969083,
0.0621254668,
0.0244841166,
-0.0062390151,
-0.0421723016,
-0.0147424061,
0.0262555629,
0.0652865395,
0.0310496595,
0.0197751801,
0.0357328318,
0.0187515132,
-0.0335761569,
0.0093284724,
-0.0386105403,
0.0160889383,
0.0233700331,
-0.0041122651,
0.0349291787,
0.0052439985,
-0.0546795428,
-0.0058949948,
-0.0085238637,
-0.0443362519,
0.0172190201,
-0.03011721,
0.027480267,
0.0013024092,
-0.0432332791,
0.0548863225,
0.0237054918,
-0.058219824,
-0.0225134138,
0.0583649427,
-0.0142880026,
0.0695775598,
0.0251696259,
-0.0149302157,
0.0105867609,
-0.0353454016,
0.0271819253,
0.03426921,
0.0200147107,
-0.0081654135,
0.0485301204,
-0.06029246,
-0.0364022888,
-0.0533312075,
0.0377385281,
0.0099974554,
-0.0141283143,
0.0142607968,
0.0376630984,
-0.031908825,
0.0089049973,
0.02780612,
0.0336093828,
-0.0517572314,
0.0426194705,
0.037049558,
0.0269459896,
0.0067330166,
-0.0013080717,
0.0174498279,
0.0158597138,
-0.0754779875,
-0.0601092316,
-0.0128945243,
-0.0770748854,
-0.1059832349,
-0.0124075208,
-0.0629327595,
0.0020649645,
0.0446683802,
-0.0732072592,
-0.0038520026,
0.0202221517,
-0.054785002,
-0.0304695126,
-0.0447346009,
-0.0285187308,
0.0044764476,
0.0461377576,
-0.0110935774,
0.0699508116,
-0.026991047,
0.0373148806,
-0.0393559225,
0.0067860316,
0.0509530418,
-0.0426141284,
-0.0213236026,
-0.0428549126,
-0.0035357077,
0.0382826813,
0.0216522999,
-0.0267838482,
-0.0092845978,
-0.0160349626,
-0.0475552753,
0.0085025216,
-0.0077745887,
0.0235707853,
-0.0154551081,
0.0040078629,
0.0223606322,
-0.0310551524,
-0.0325067639,
-0.0216554627,
-0.0356166661,
0.0456053838,
0.0622600503,
-0.023051152,
-0.0243045576,
-0.0152872093,
0.0093642408,
-0.0179726761,
0.0728342682,
-0.0691879243,
0.0006094014,
-0.0423507392,
0.0188940577,
-0.0017586732,
-0.02644144,
0.0172420982,
-0.0391716957,
-0.0083038984,
0.0021922959,
0.0202984251,
0.0422298871,
0.0228429418,
0.0662471503,
0.0452981815,
0.0493868031,
-0.018875638,
0.0113883242,
-0.0448306166,
0.0781482384,
-0.027829431,
0.005820238,
0.0112557625,
0.0715576187,
0.0070469771,
0.0087734303,
-0.0414842814,
0.0216323324,
0.0086863451,
0.027422512,
-0.0511683077,
-0.0163275916,
-0.0223589633,
-0.0305182822,
-0.0244935323,
-0.0041085659,
0.0383330919,
-0.0252089947,
-0.0028407548,
-0.0684962049,
-0.0321296938,
-0.0194530264,
0.0169373266,
0.0100827385,
0.0184199959,
-0.0005467266,
-0.0040245322,
-0.0147802373,
0.0160165541,
0.0300120357,
0.0193645786,
-0.0043702316,
0.0457460321,
-0.0056806831,
-0.0423581302,
-0.050107576,
-0.0207967535,
-0.0742574707,
-0.0222731382,
0.0249379687,
-0.0330207497,
0.0324325673,
-0.0421566516,
-0.0265383422,
0.0020001507,
0.0143671092,
-0.0077250539,
0.0060906424,
-0.0373366177,
0.0567672662,
0.0309695415,
0.013945017,
-0.0206980724,
0.0022824223,
0.0568233877,
0.0494837388,
-0.0069864066,
0.030058831,
-0.042162355,
0.0081676664,
-0.0124395881,
-0.0202583335,
0.0080022048,
0.0362382419,
0.0303938147,
-0.027824929,
-0.0296789631,
0.110134095,
0.040791411,
-0.0130167147,
0.0162037797,
0.0614687614,
0.0128749944,
0.0355685726,
-0.0322623029,
-0.0754895508,
-0.0292439014,
-0.0246424749,
-0.0321513452,
0.0250941757,
-0.0064358371,
-0.0138130374,
-0.081897378,
-0.0005203817,
0.0172842965,
-0.0019901919,
-0.0572736003,
-0.073741734,
-0.029207876,
0.0195595678,
0.038721431,
-0.0411302783,
-0.009372361,
-0.0240744818,
0.0161027107,
-0.0517310724,
-0.063139841,
0.0145422425,
-0.0393491574,
0.0065782205,
0.0083578834,
0.0588287823,
0.0002417392,
-0.0227122027,
0.0076350677,
-0.0401298329,
-0.0075617135,
0.0181241408,
0.0672028661,
-0.0326112099,
0.0021512702,
-0.0041596075,
-0.0044868658,
-0.0592610613,
-0.0185971428,
-0.0048815305,
0.1071239933,
-0.0087129334,
-0.0210503098,
-0.0150481891,
-0.0052952501,
-0.0184258744,
0.0801801309,
0.0624977164,
-0.028507961,
-0.0415572673,
-0.0063319127,
0.005282789,
-0.0474218652,
-0.0045307861,
0.0156104909,
0.057015758,
0.0273783412,
-0.05165473,
-0.08905074,
0.0077798059,
0.0037669933,
-0.0282120649,
0.0297938399,
-0.0230890214,
-0.0113285892,
-0.0072677312,
0.0045803515,
-0.0293113403,
0.0299002901,
0.0369822495,
0.0305343121,
0.0079912441,
0.042013932,
-0.0351949818,
-0.0814531818,
-0.0558343865,
-0.0433737822,
-0.0643747896,
0.0025561412,
-0.0061392044,
-0.0017754111,
-0.0054186587,
-0.0061687427,
0.0775057375,
0.0026934987,
-0.0431317538,
0.0059481217,
0.0506560244,
0.0203723237,
0.0091313068,
0.0602932796,
-0.0336371101,
0.0252760742,
-0.0116185481,
0.0263244249,
-0.0019623062,
-0.0236901864,
-0.0059322268,
-0.0361695476,
0.0597823486,
0.0198911484,
-0.0195240006,
-0.021107886,
0.0112517606,
-0.0544739626,
-0.001366535,
-0.0146251787,
-0.0072248881,
0.0276765786,
0.0125386063,
-0.0244195722,
0.0316130221,
0.0001360014,
0.0007446888,
-0.0353773311,
0.0155802537,
0.0495770201,
-0.0313575715,
-0.0024149108,
0.0506978668,
-0.062094029,
-0.0201495886,
-0.0368689224,
-0.0230655819,
-0.0042387657,
-0.0070329905,
0.0027226151,
0.0096844872,
-0.0713533387,
0.0212347154,
-0.0689153373,
0.0465505235,
0.0083988449,
0.006030499,
0.0559076667,
-0.0420363545,
-0.0083045913,
0.0062446301,
-0.0114607811,
-0.0065782769,
0.0438303091,
-0.0206840206,
-0.027762549,
0.0360884219,
0.0080179544,
-0.0520773195,
-0.0193734653,
0.0754182786,
0.0229239408,
0.041886732,
0.0052804979,
0.01011944,
-0.0525238439,
-0.0128010642,
-0.0062733404,
0.0763515085,
-0.0077508059,
0.0457618944,
-0.0288342535,
-0.0350222513,
0.0289346129,
-0.0373794995,
0.001603194,
-0.0155198704,
0.0385619737,
-0.0000079562,
-0.0022796236,
0.0158652365,
0.0033976722,
-0.0154253012,
-0.0224777386,
-0.0417134166,
-0.0261786785,
-5.465196498e-33,
0.0189312566,
0.0293721743,
-0.0213697553,
-0.0184787437,
-0.0222090036,
0.0064288345,
-0.0210655909,
0.0115355449,
-0.0288495403,
0.0437701046,
0.0237803385,
-0.0097726872,
-0.0077425861,
0.0416565239,
0.0136813102,
0.0078579141,
0.0612579696,
-0.0245867856,
-0.0374147408,
-0.0002188662,
0.0393317081,
0.03154286,
0.034811195,
-0.0040424159,
-0.0212843027,
-0.0102263745,
0.0112448707,
0.0300550014,
0.0663895831,
0.0360420272,
-0.0356438458,
0.0763598979,
0.044963479,
-0.0285608955,
-0.0163226742,
0.0751169026,
-0.0538428761,
-0.0643560961,
-0.0412408337,
0.0053490447,
-0.022643581,
-0.0546027906,
0.0038186528,
-0.0020081403,
0.0260612573,
-0.0338055044,
0.037786752,
-0.0124748619,
-0.0422770679,
0.0035097825,
-0.0795905665,
0.0018500579,
-0.0141994096,
-0.0018082919,
0.0431321934,
0.0392559282,
0.0241730586,
0.0171432626,
-0.0188672207,
-0.0186329465,
-0.0590420291,
0.0475282334,
-0.0397102609,
-0.0257121176,
-0.0363580771,
0.0803196281,
-0.0038230012,
-0.0233951453,
-0.0487564467,
-0.0018212334,
0.0075068949,
0.0155298719,
0.0558269769,
0.0608814843,
0.0246311761,
-0.0217996761,
-0.1083557308,
0.0076056998,
0.0208610948,
0.0258578118,
0.0600930601,
0.0070384978,
-0.0465333946,
-0.0358115099,
-0.0068912455,
0.0135128284,
-0.0154310204,
-0.0210157968,
0.0503066592,
0.0408368185,
0.0292224437,
-0.0140097262,
0.0232457723,
-0.0658759922,
-0.0143918497,
0.0526986606,
-0.0139387613,
-0.0158941839,
0.0475753695,
-0.0013522884,
-0.0545407869,
-0.0308130812,
0.0042688386,
0.0210673362,
0.0088559696,
-0.0139109595,
0.1145086139,
-0.0303359758,
-0.0609989539,
-0.0062886504,
-0.0167281013,
-0.0475296937,
-0.0307336226,
0.0625574365,
-0.0025630896,
0.0287348069,
-0.0160229579,
0.0495438203,
-0.0219165999,
-0.0008198924,
-0.0039734268,
-0.0150173958,
0.0152885653,
0.0461246595,
-0.0042351177,
-0.0108597502,
-0.0588923506,
0.0304403417,
0.0318602249,
-0.0528970063,
-0.0129376249,
-0.019032063,
2.26e-7,
0.0106605012,
0.0208615121,
0.0205668285,
-0.0423656367,
0.0354915075,
0.0446006805,
-0.0201917905,
0.07043349,
-0.053654056,
0.0156642441,
0.0277235284,
0.0315621756,
0.0391688645,
-0.006943028,
-0.1192982271,
0.0565860085,
-0.066408217,
0.0039926581,
-0.0278638788,
0.0032894062,
0.0783057734,
0.0962276459,
-0.0062840707,
0.0139984982,
-0.007488199,
-0.0259157494,
0.0627906099,
-0.0140364468,
0.0199662186,
-0.0136784064,
-0.047259964,
0.0598057508,
0.011758483,
-0.0159560125,
-0.033462517,
0.0602242872,
0.0017637035,
0.04400618,
-0.0153775718,
-0.0263184328,
-0.0070853797,
0.0260396749,
-0.0182823073,
0.0041698324,
0.0554493517,
-0.0862186253,
-0.0374741592,
-0.0406564809,
-0.0001879904,
0.0161020663,
0.0776877701,
0.0291527677,
-0.0373755842,
-0.0252427533,
0.0461683124,
-0.019713765,
0.0115576219,
-0.0976439565,
0.0063488418,
0.0366294235,
-0.043146804,
-0.0082069095,
-0.0310768541,
0.0187481064,
0.1080249697,
-0.0314606987,
0.0116310362,
1.777013981e-34,
0.019955514,
-0.0067268279,
0.0343348831,
0.0320193321,
0.0007908053,
-0.0428953692,
0.0137871224,
-0.0418096557,
0.0534778461,
-0.0655784234,
0.0134766791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15276v1 | Efficient Algorithms for Recognizing Weighted Tree-Adjoining Languages | 2023-10-23T18:26:00 | 2023-10-23T18:26:00 | Alexandra Butoi, Tim Vieira, Ryan Cotterell, David Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | The class of tree-adjoining languages can be characterized by various
two-level formalisms, consisting of a context-free grammar (CFG) or pushdown
automaton (PDA) controlling another CFG or PDA. These four formalisms are
equivalent to tree-adjoining grammars (TAG), linear indexed grammars (LIG),
pushdown-adjoining automata (PAA), and embedded pushdown automata (EPDA). We
define semiring-weighted versions of the above two-level formalisms, and we
design new algorithms for computing their stringsums (the weight of all
derivations of a string) and allsums (the weight of all derivations). From
these, we also immediately obtain stringsum and allsum algorithms for TAG, LIG,
PAA, and EPDA. For LIG, our algorithm is more time-efficient by a factor of
$\mathcal{O}(n|\mathcal{N}|)$ (where $n$ is the string length and
$|\mathcal{N}|$ is the size of the nonterminal set) and more space-efficient by
a factor of $\mathcal{O}(|\Gamma|)$ (where $|\Gamma|$ is the size of the stack
alphabet) than the algorithm of Vijay-Shanker and Weir (1989). For EPDA, our
algorithm is both more space-efficient and time-efficient than the algorithm of
Alonso et al. (2001) by factors of $\mathcal{O}(|\Gamma|^2)$ and
$\mathcal{O}(|\Gamma|^3)$, respectively. Finally, we give the first PAA
stringsum and allsum algorithms. | [
0.0086360034,
0.0474930294,
-0.0213579349,
0.0910760835,
-0.0339170024,
0.0152346976,
-0.0593903698,
0.0249298103,
-0.0361420214,
0.0037702878,
-0.0107577424,
-0.0249295942,
0.0116375778,
0.0051856893,
-0.0050985767,
-0.0342249051,
0.0332111344,
-0.0447661579,
-0.0077349353,
0.0381741077,
-0.0128895277,
-0.0068062032,
0.0042768787,
-0.0549947806,
0.0060354443,
-0.0457818322,
-0.0295718424,
-0.0204107389,
0.0292103607,
0.0003096386,
-0.0507179685,
-0.0001287126,
-0.0638796389,
0.0631385073,
0.0000018872,
-0.0070377174,
-0.0367169715,
0.0082329791,
-0.0504564308,
0.0459342971,
0.0145667512,
0.0253630541,
-0.0044510062,
0.0330995806,
0.008867817,
-0.0178406164,
0.0590657443,
-0.0567275919,
0.0262537207,
0.0314816087,
-0.0096636955,
-0.056890294,
0.0098905796,
0.0310764108,
0.00474319,
-0.0216320548,
0.0103134932,
-0.0140996696,
-0.0032023443,
-0.0267505124,
-0.0014725704,
-0.0795386508,
-0.0277840942,
-0.0541507788,
-0.0638755485,
-0.0043798219,
-0.011344579,
0.0225926172,
0.0007507422,
-0.008608616,
-0.0051088282,
-0.0353537127,
0.0134872859,
-0.0114388764,
0.0016858586,
-0.0465524495,
-0.0176308136,
0.06234283,
-0.0071304482,
0.0213417951,
0.0718092918,
0.0149534848,
0.0068284534,
-0.051483877,
-0.04406799,
0.0805516541,
0.0478225313,
-0.0410391167,
-0.0412263796,
-0.0364727043,
0.0027510102,
-0.0784796476,
0.0120194443,
0.0246186294,
0.0171726216,
0.0325361304,
-0.0139709609,
-0.0276881512,
0.0199579503,
-0.0268323533,
0.0190332811,
0.0599311367,
0.031728249,
0.0017290462,
-0.031766735,
0.0603644736,
0.0227291845,
-0.0310054906,
-0.0247879829,
0.0344918892,
-0.0009568122,
-0.0253291484,
-0.0845837891,
0.0594364032,
0.0071740663,
0.01225043,
-0.0342879407,
0.024132546,
0.0060045794,
0.0004949655,
-0.0407728441,
-0.0712917075,
0.0451967753,
0.0728655756,
0.0461560488,
0.0048906058,
-0.0073187524,
-0.0474834591,
-0.0413502045,
0.0013436198,
-0.0219379179,
0.081852369,
0.0149762062,
-0.0026743985,
0.0136007313,
0.0182582419,
0.0267658252,
-0.0170578901,
0.000381492,
-0.0189496465,
-0.0019292579,
-0.0148174725,
0.0314160511,
-0.0162823275,
-0.0308361258,
-0.0160613488,
-0.0085349241,
0.0116493497,
-0.0214492027,
0.0135960719,
0.0140065551,
-0.0322312415,
-0.0274477247,
0.0010964101,
-0.0462171957,
0.0106775491,
0.0045092171,
0.0106213968,
0.006922543,
0.0454740226,
0.0157288313,
-0.0198587608,
-0.0116174677,
0.0352546461,
-0.0284647774,
-0.0075589861,
-0.0326918624,
-0.0161307957,
0.0150546227,
-0.0609247722,
0.004707756,
0.0805057511,
-0.0191563461,
-0.0030939775,
-0.0660109147,
0.0119530028,
0.0285875984,
-0.0053839777,
0.0530683994,
-0.0042463066,
0.0277286451,
0.0754243955,
0.0302011929,
-0.051667463,
-0.0887153298,
-0.0038306704,
-0.0098092118,
-0.01067138,
0.0189818107,
-0.0051413612,
-0.0484173633,
-0.014181939,
0.0321732461,
-0.0470971391,
0.0046487176,
0.0063988795,
0.0018304954,
-0.0081434222,
0.0041133403,
-0.0326592922,
-0.0232204832,
-0.0403295532,
0.0264427066,
-0.0248931069,
-0.0187104903,
-0.0694849864,
-0.0073447041,
0.0734055415,
0.0215014759,
0.028528031,
-0.0474339016,
-0.0187096652,
0.0068143634,
0.0170086101,
0.0076699983,
0.0445087776,
0.0298485216,
0.0746555254,
-0.0571278594,
0.0028801374,
-0.0183735527,
0.0181721747,
-0.0334250107,
0.0146312546,
0.0400968194,
-0.0185878538,
0.0531448685,
-0.0031941107,
0.0696612224,
0.0353550874,
-0.03567506,
0.0624899529,
0.0245390944,
0.0052143489,
-0.0211208295,
-0.0017436427,
-0.0122302147,
-0.0265424196,
0.0604337491,
0.0596446991,
-0.0220698304,
-0.0459778011,
-0.0348801278,
-0.0277325939,
0.0795085356,
-0.0508209206,
0.0480884351,
-0.0202392805,
0.0428774916,
-0.0109434621,
-0.0209992249,
0.0062721404,
0.0981067419,
-0.0244421083,
0.0462910421,
0.0212735757,
-0.0069911354,
0.0616239756,
0.018099457,
-0.0239356533,
-0.0069817551,
-0.0432743467,
-0.0232760049,
0.0180089958,
0.020907307,
-0.0065014744,
-0.0246255025,
-0.0226666443,
0.0221696664,
-0.0226402469,
0.1246265024,
-0.00637687,
0.059415821,
-0.0040592463,
-0.0259734076,
-0.0418738499,
0.0282747447,
-0.0030251571,
0.0244164523,
0.0158655439,
0.0042958609,
-0.055553101,
-0.0292260852,
-0.0225770287,
-0.0394177735,
0.0144016966,
-0.0182274617,
-0.0611158833,
-0.0266681984,
-0.0370848961,
-0.0458055027,
0.0297810528,
0.0170610603,
-0.015293316,
0.0005884534,
-0.0358089879,
-0.0184339099,
0.0074041937,
-0.0091915336,
-0.0301205572,
0.0132116359,
0.0491247699,
0.0479270816,
-0.0284124818,
0.0327134207,
-0.0102878483,
0.0209459085,
0.006848109,
0.0503572822,
0.1262402833,
-0.0382521115,
-0.0441551059,
0.0022301236,
-0.041988492,
0.03579247,
0.0327965394,
0.0127317421,
-0.0757792592,
-0.0141234584,
0.0155337295,
0.0040009478,
-0.0351383239,
-0.0007652171,
-0.070496656,
0.0039494317,
-0.0237223301,
-0.0208108034,
-0.0601279475,
0.0668144748,
0.0464242361,
0.0415048674,
0.0157737397,
-0.0688026249,
0.0558870733,
0.0261759572,
0.0377180874,
0.0169326495,
-0.0651197955,
-0.023304671,
0.0500972271,
-0.0258276723,
-0.0360241346,
-0.0145587306,
0.0270382613,
0.0157640409,
-0.0027333733,
-0.0094946986,
-0.0327839479,
0.039597109,
0.0380832404,
-0.028813608,
0.0422525927,
0.0487826616,
0.0410372615,
0.0172598846,
0.0057875253,
-0.0541772731,
-0.0269838069,
-0.0200284179,
0.0158155691,
-0.0012945278,
0.0189445224,
0.0192314796,
0.0032084021,
-0.0140610384,
0.0081378287,
0.0362347923,
-0.0442691073,
-0.0539997742,
0.0437374152,
-0.0510254093,
0.0032087595,
-0.002361655,
0.043644473,
0.0576334186,
-0.0356089883,
0.056090828,
-0.0701873228,
0.0103974734,
0.0280708093,
0.0335085914,
-0.1172140315,
-0.0122877024,
0.0134962024,
-0.0572400652,
-0.0402908996,
-0.0242291056,
0.0249418095,
-0.0797284618,
0.0231575016,
0.0026840116,
-0.019777121,
0.018805407,
-0.0370302834,
0.0080718147,
0.0448496081,
-0.0833180845,
0.0296662152,
-0.0268434398,
0.002015806,
0.0341039374,
-0.0501237735,
0.0054471344,
-0.0020121853,
0.0238633063,
-0.0561598577,
0.0195712838,
0.0607225932,
-0.0110915164,
-0.0636508837,
0.0477572642,
-0.006918177,
-0.0023260186,
-0.0494569167,
-0.0681379065,
0.0309370235,
-0.0058189696,
0.0148353539,
0.0215597488,
0.0158800613,
0.0123575935,
0.0108491266,
0.0726808384,
0.0492290407,
-0.0298972204,
0.0126358438,
-0.0432479382,
0.0192029066,
-0.0106716659,
0.0174167678,
0.0178490616,
0.0061409315,
-0.0588285401,
0.0116058607,
0.0612676144,
-0.0229122322,
-0.0137600591,
-0.0033270747,
-0.0494947359,
-0.0517628118,
0.0593624748,
0.0108764358,
0.0341676995,
-0.0431566052,
0.027265925,
-0.0172448717,
-0.0624138266,
-0.0215646476,
-0.0626697093,
-0.0838170052,
0.0315457582,
-0.0282084364,
-0.0111037446,
-0.0011684671,
0.0727629587,
-0.0649618953,
-0.0250059217,
-0.002108241,
-0.0217511561,
-0.0022027334,
0.0507361181,
0.0243403874,
-0.06595283,
-0.0182185695,
0.0099587264,
-0.0636071935,
0.0329400301,
-0.0059438851,
0.0145910066,
0.0102194902,
-0.0742001981,
0.0167893078,
0.0047767586,
0.0249674171,
0.0290278196,
0.0157401022,
-0.0248783398,
-0.0058435174,
0.0313174427,
0.0460223258,
0.1149285808,
-0.0179380346,
0.0231447779,
-0.0185705349,
0.036826022,
0.0075257965,
-0.0502438135,
-0.0174212661,
-0.0436921231,
0.0163848661,
-0.0266406275,
-0.004211497,
-0.0045630108,
-0.0412673466,
0.0047922265,
0.0186442714,
0.0097901998,
0.0478057265,
0.0102965031,
0.0424553156,
-0.0077633616,
0.0062896758,
0.0234943833,
-0.0362356566,
0.0478067696,
0.0245158393,
-0.0213706437,
-0.0386183113,
0.024876941,
0.0395274982,
-0.0052694725,
0.0293329936,
-0.0067342394,
0.0246926416,
0.0223936401,
-0.0051881913,
0.0544785224,
0.0121180899,
0.0096806139,
-0.0183412824,
0.0367966406,
-0.0223496705,
-0.012465205,
0.0373478569,
-0.0887062401,
-0.0331518799,
0.0264998209,
-0.0085197436,
0.0359555073,
0.0818889737,
0.0169722475,
0.0358741246,
0.0233168267,
-0.0308884624,
-0.0285626724,
-0.0203702543,
-0.0104634231,
0.0349087082,
-0.022233583,
0.0023761804,
-0.0559956171,
-0.0466732979,
-0.004674939,
0.0132987946,
0.0507623851,
0.0063366988,
0.0393423848,
-0.0047327545,
0.0327121019,
0.0042702327,
-0.0155966552,
-0.0527247265,
-0.0390706062,
-0.0156707093,
0.0228009261,
-4.683641528e-33,
-0.0464902185,
0.0037481543,
-0.0471385941,
0.0303771738,
0.0160771534,
0.0414975062,
-0.0338785127,
0.0534679666,
0.0370254777,
-0.0236021169,
0.0034093319,
0.018714508,
0.0086810878,
-0.0397783034,
-0.0344363116,
0.0237356275,
-0.0120610688,
0.0021721697,
-0.0362151712,
-0.0003458692,
0.0338265449,
-0.0597648993,
0.0351073146,
-0.0115585923,
0.0161869563,
-0.0305787995,
-0.0034634599,
0.0293668527,
-0.0565665141,
0.0241797045,
-0.0110533163,
-0.0268593263,
0.0084341299,
0.026135426,
-0.0260641351,
-0.0031844852,
-0.0172905494,
-0.0735230222,
0.0583070405,
-0.035851635,
-0.0258737635,
-0.0234388094,
0.0131045831,
0.020998219,
-0.0285121985,
0.0356652997,
-0.0568064526,
-0.0133892642,
-0.0195668153,
0.0153597677,
-0.0167008787,
0.0193293635,
0.0097982325,
0.0436265878,
0.0172866005,
-0.0462439358,
-0.0146380123,
0.026281476,
0.0395758525,
0.0186161175,
0.0459553637,
0.0327451006,
0.0189380944,
-0.0157646649,
-0.0008877863,
-0.0021587494,
0.0449759737,
-0.0151260123,
0.0074505196,
0.0395135395,
-0.0411088094,
-0.0001058952,
0.0214598104,
-0.0202606916,
0.1256304383,
0.0234291442,
-0.0669419169,
-0.0034114306,
0.03177635,
0.0441752523,
-0.0336057357,
-0.0192811415,
-0.0134849166,
-0.0599586777,
-0.0271055531,
0.0023890375,
-0.0274362694,
-0.0014788214,
0.0094605833,
-0.008734745,
-0.0381209739,
0.0248747747,
0.0174689516,
0.0037611714,
-0.025781462,
0.0304889083,
-0.0046876245,
0.013375503,
-0.0111211631,
0.0381508693,
0.0415008105,
-0.0413603038,
-0.0435728654,
-0.0472725928,
0.0634476542,
-0.0014142884,
0.0176173225,
0.0570975319,
-0.0162074398,
0.0047326302,
-0.0026364871,
0.0104555944,
-0.0561857149,
0.0883636922,
0.0285959262,
0.0056326161,
0.0423730798,
-0.007306898,
0.0249925219,
-0.0252321716,
0.0250342079,
-0.0222825631,
-0.0131774703,
0.0252382904,
-0.0137492828,
-0.0280152373,
0.0056582401,
0.012007243,
0.06073495,
-0.0079359887,
0.002667123,
0.0039165826,
2.783e-7,
0.0236865915,
0.0001344208,
0.1018833965,
0.0137326149,
0.0531557947,
-0.0185471717,
0.0092428811,
0.021369582,
-0.0584092289,
0.0256556049,
-0.0479743816,
-0.0336334892,
-0.0301458891,
-0.0281464159,
-0.032201644,
0.0417506061,
-0.0669010058,
-0.0260779765,
0.0098510459,
-0.0152426036,
0.011769413,
0.0146665331,
-0.0464090817,
-0.0119190877,
-0.0200645626,
-0.0364329852,
-0.0044841659,
0.0355982482,
0.0524361879,
-0.028224932,
0.029417349,
-0.0153102195,
0.0037650922,
0.0087783728,
0.0002247261,
0.0576178804,
0.0099609951,
0.0278120302,
-0.0352071449,
0.1347319484,
0.044350557,
-0.0339761972,
-0.0065824585,
0.0660444573,
0.0368858613,
0.0614048541,
-0.0684027448,
0.0101756239,
-0.0287388954,
0.0006199615,
-0.0765493289,
0.0576654188,
-0.0288423151,
0.026889611,
0.0019547301,
-0.0298984516,
0.0018226585,
-0.0239799283,
-0.0532195307,
-0.0326773338,
-0.0106080053,
0.0136630842,
-0.0322692692,
0.069579564,
0.0027916364,
-0.0479448996,
-0.018097125,
3.067078049e-34,
0.0185593385,
-0.0327627547,
-0.0018656977,
0.0409775563,
-0.0024478023,
-0.0163436458,
-0.02765131,
0.02536886,
0.0116729895,
-0.0507784672,
-0.0043797386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15269v1 | GradSim: Gradient-Based Language Grouping for Effective Multilingual Training | 2023-10-23T18:13:37 | 2023-10-23T18:13:37 | Mingyang Wang, Heike Adel, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen, Hinrich Schütze | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Most languages of the world pose low-resource challenges to natural language
processing models. With multilingual training, knowledge can be shared among
languages. However, not all languages positively influence each other and it is
an open research question how to select the most suitable set of languages for
multilingual training and avoid negative interference among languages whose
characteristics or data distributions are not compatible. In this paper, we
propose GradSim, a language grouping method based on gradient similarity. Our
experiments on three diverse multilingual benchmark datasets show that it leads
to the largest performance gains compared to other similarity measures and it
is better correlated with cross-lingual model performance. As a result, we set
the new state of the art on AfriSenti, a benchmark dataset for sentiment
analysis on low-resource African languages. In our extensive analysis, we
further reveal that besides linguistic features, the topics of the datasets
play an important role for language grouping and that lower layers of
transformer models encode language-specific features while higher layers
capture task-specific information. | [
0.0100563942,
0.0667187646,
0.0032320262,
0.0831353366,
-0.0244373642,
0.0230364297,
0.0445090905,
-0.0219756551,
-0.0067319879,
-0.0323549695,
-0.0674504489,
-0.0796329826,
0.0249375217,
-0.0371653363,
0.0243438389,
-0.0502450317,
0.0432028659,
0.02124363,
-0.0313767195,
-0.0018336801,
0.0007646801,
0.0395991169,
0.002405908,
0.0287562888,
-0.0000759286,
0.0014839469,
0.0215577148,
-0.0221801829,
0.0404798314,
0.0163788237,
0.0038456877,
0.0302989688,
-0.0160128493,
0.0346359126,
0.0000021082,
-0.0295840204,
-0.0499296896,
-0.0007972497,
0.0325140432,
-0.0323598497,
0.0557861328,
-0.0539827049,
-0.0183051992,
0.0439950116,
-0.03888046,
-0.045089189,
0.0553360432,
0.0382510424,
0.0488897376,
0.0873797834,
-0.0238410514,
-0.0299483966,
0.0246913396,
-0.0269412454,
-0.0260215737,
-0.0318677761,
-0.0172261372,
-0.0092964368,
-0.0351487026,
-0.0000776522,
-0.0238092542,
0.0027175513,
0.0169516467,
0.0242069513,
-0.0294149425,
-0.002811763,
-0.0459712483,
-0.0355278999,
-0.0201979503,
0.0208752118,
-0.0861615762,
-0.0059703733,
-0.02570468,
-0.0116988374,
-0.0221139211,
-0.0061153625,
-0.0245810039,
0.0204776675,
0.0033428345,
0.0516386367,
0.0417674594,
0.0568365976,
0.0241526049,
0.0119605046,
-0.0138776274,
0.0287872758,
-0.0191077385,
-0.0211530682,
-0.0025218448,
0.0568413846,
-0.0037957504,
0.019462388,
-0.037548285,
-0.023652235,
0.0022805638,
-0.0012609103,
0.0077157705,
-0.0476434901,
0.0201410819,
-0.0636138543,
0.0517283604,
0.0368875302,
-0.0497324951,
0.0549522415,
-0.028316455,
0.0425680429,
-0.0166483298,
-0.0026006892,
-0.0210859608,
-0.0611944012,
-0.0565146506,
-0.0153485499,
0.0246403012,
0.0047851019,
-0.0607144386,
0.0276447982,
-0.0568986759,
-0.023225965,
-0.0393417552,
-0.0406482443,
0.0150892278,
-0.0208141357,
0.028398646,
-0.0091354847,
0.0125134001,
0.0361477882,
-0.0261580814,
0.0381000526,
-0.0325229131,
-0.055850286,
0.0237748288,
0.0226586349,
-0.0167846642,
0.0054751444,
0.0194375329,
0.043533612,
-0.0039177821,
-0.0319929905,
-0.0811857879,
0.0028163828,
0.0009047902,
-0.0516487546,
0.0107524181,
-0.0798803866,
0.0768357515,
0.0201644525,
0.0209848434,
-0.0200817157,
-0.0351750068,
-0.0169948768,
0.0012995459,
0.0551573224,
0.0174807571,
-0.0136786234,
0.0585720502,
0.015576601,
0.0003218982,
0.0718181953,
-0.0009878726,
0.0108030662,
0.0589433424,
0.002356841,
-0.0286736526,
0.0333353207,
-0.0240591541,
0.0026570531,
0.018301677,
-0.0283998903,
-0.0232350193,
-0.0466140583,
0.0400899611,
0.0094148321,
-0.0182386972,
-0.0175489951,
0.0138248727,
0.0586504154,
0.0019747487,
0.0559367388,
-0.0049063559,
0.0175535958,
-0.0199343879,
-0.0210211724,
0.008879533,
0.0124859242,
0.0285393801,
-0.0109906467,
0.0427099839,
0.107025966,
-0.0290743951,
-0.0204468966,
0.0146724284,
-0.0546294302,
0.0471442156,
0.0031403294,
0.0384011567,
0.0132700661,
-0.024457423,
0.0286185239,
0.0823731422,
-0.0769644454,
-0.0214345139,
-0.0323023722,
-0.0018864839,
0.0137003725,
-0.0353607237,
0.0106330067,
-0.0228450224,
-0.0025608733,
0.0145602664,
0.0438513458,
0.0388441384,
0.0009269482,
0.0436919332,
-0.0739462525,
-0.0094966823,
0.0003270812,
-0.005111692,
0.0433676541,
-0.0013914088,
0.0475193933,
0.0136870435,
-0.0053864801,
-0.0391856395,
0.0105422214,
-0.0380178206,
0.0235590097,
0.0313546173,
0.0185328722,
0.0350513682,
0.0147931771,
-0.002154286,
-0.0112839453,
-0.0085982811,
-0.0769262314,
-0.0216732491,
0.0306529962,
-0.0361914262,
-0.059861999,
0.0052620992,
-0.0477643535,
-0.0162293389,
0.0537149124,
-0.0291285738,
-0.0229019336,
0.0487881638,
0.0095263785,
0.0775195733,
-0.0391296558,
0.0293492526,
-0.0342396274,
0.0207146946,
0.0179441962,
0.0625757724,
-0.0097465403,
0.026474582,
-0.0410986803,
-0.0184383281,
0.0557954498,
0.0113770496,
-0.0106473519,
0.0299691148,
0.0073318696,
0.0270934515,
0.0325321071,
0.01115725,
-0.010084657,
-0.0292169489,
-0.1135004461,
0.0075303074,
-0.0187523291,
0.0205933526,
-0.0131256748,
0.0482537039,
-0.0080882097,
-0.0089100683,
-0.0227017235,
-0.007433726,
0.007081857,
0.012630078,
0.0065914174,
-0.0236274768,
0.0270240866,
-0.0437167957,
0.0030675519,
0.0354476161,
0.0735093355,
-0.0316092521,
-0.010290849,
-0.0170720946,
0.0109577244,
-0.0445950404,
0.0018103993,
-0.0173731539,
-0.0319748856,
-0.0142237134,
0.0264575258,
0.038819544,
-0.0124164745,
-0.0002797141,
0.0081947222,
0.028026633,
0.0451801047,
-0.0190606825,
-0.0126748262,
-0.0481126569,
0.0014064215,
0.0027108483,
-0.0259848144,
0.0168316998,
0.0804422945,
0.0276167933,
-0.0223476328,
-0.0432797559,
-0.0189915095,
-0.0531131513,
-0.0046731243,
-0.0126782246,
0.0189920217,
0.0096549755,
-0.0042270585,
-0.0371013209,
-0.047815457,
0.0649051666,
0.0027059708,
-0.0060815807,
-0.0869006291,
-0.0305981413,
-0.0561629273,
0.0353945717,
-0.026806511,
0.0228600334,
-0.0371916629,
0.0254315659,
-0.0206476953,
0.0190837737,
0.0438884199,
-0.0146610206,
0.0474672541,
0.0095756222,
-0.0093966834,
0.0013938202,
-0.0567320362,
-0.0029928668,
-0.0243487284,
0.0011839225,
-0.0030960958,
0.0589021705,
-0.0108538438,
-0.0549029335,
0.018436322,
0.0180094689,
0.0289066359,
-0.0002912337,
0.000879251,
0.0397983715,
0.0278667789,
-0.0065140948,
-0.0187342819,
0.0090838661,
-0.049145218,
0.0090012057,
0.0283459835,
0.0007016947,
-0.0162207596,
-0.02742422,
-0.0194904394,
0.0211867522,
0.0002629207,
-0.0477371179,
-0.0456455089,
0.0339882374,
-0.0130971922,
0.0314322263,
0.1012299508,
0.0185880549,
-0.0827903748,
0.009539553,
-0.0430471078,
0.0289013386,
0.0124418009,
-0.0176835358,
-0.0374262631,
-0.0223852973,
-0.0366888605,
-0.0005624816,
0.0185138639,
0.0146883903,
-0.0151803708,
-0.0984818637,
0.0016484058,
-0.0055533494,
-0.0524958335,
-0.0402456596,
-0.0777476355,
-0.0117796892,
-0.0262889378,
0.0115009481,
-0.0662989467,
0.0176764131,
-0.0376164429,
0.0298848394,
-0.0363837779,
-0.0768202543,
0.0000935529,
-0.0256573204,
-0.0223263428,
0.02214198,
0.0205187742,
0.0020518212,
-0.009801181,
-0.0057852608,
-0.0115139587,
-0.0113307703,
-0.0091121346,
0.0377590917,
0.0147026246,
-0.0270224437,
0.0145593816,
-0.0107324217,
-0.0634577796,
0.0139832608,
-0.0109551298,
0.0567399263,
0.0063791205,
-0.0213882066,
-0.0156234056,
-0.0264653675,
0.0070180828,
0.0435129851,
0.0024357627,
-0.0401225649,
0.0147301592,
0.0179901421,
0.0269386228,
-0.0100169834,
-0.0324977525,
0.0161772072,
-0.0261460301,
-0.0288886875,
-0.0630810782,
-0.0775261968,
0.0014427757,
-0.0136019038,
-0.0335794576,
0.0153137771,
0.034152519,
-0.0115934554,
-0.0662337616,
0.0449874178,
0.0335528105,
-0.0102031901,
-0.0208231155,
-0.0536294468,
0.0620314293,
-0.0042834566,
-0.0285049491,
-0.0332295299,
-0.0814231113,
-0.0543016717,
-0.0175959896,
0.0120880138,
0.0058035296,
0.0331043154,
0.0508173108,
-0.0258322265,
0.0306137372,
0.0255767442,
-0.0042733029,
0.0058026598,
0.021791568,
-0.0175722968,
-0.0114572197,
0.0278338492,
-0.018190952,
0.0797093585,
-0.004133272,
-0.029158283,
-0.0504718237,
-0.0056139003,
-0.02498018,
-0.0630882308,
0.0510808825,
-0.0343568251,
-0.0698705986,
-0.0790232271,
-0.0083905095,
0.0347495042,
0.0154021429,
-0.0225305427,
0.0035332325,
0.0314729325,
-0.0277894735,
-0.0160283949,
0.0334821455,
0.0159079395,
-0.0387657285,
-0.035464,
0.0697510242,
0.0372468829,
0.0106792413,
-0.0238336213,
0.051573962,
-0.0011529184,
-0.0094762482,
-0.0122671807,
-0.0065741157,
-0.0373627432,
0.009594935,
0.0166306142,
0.0231340639,
0.015850829,
0.0547671542,
0.0139243389,
-0.0181176718,
-0.0229750611,
-0.0155066727,
0.0745641291,
-0.0545269959,
0.0835413262,
0.0117441323,
-0.0109415473,
0.0130821262,
0.014283671,
-0.029147476,
-0.0154758673,
0.0031841022,
0.0043937168,
-0.0297881663,
0.0397266559,
0.0890231207,
-0.0295292884,
-0.004528821,
0.0230050609,
0.0101769976,
-0.0319165774,
0.0091750845,
0.0744083747,
-0.0032997215,
-0.0006365587,
0.0255653802,
-0.017129248,
-0.0680625513,
0.0238253251,
-0.0382022634,
-0.0147040682,
0.0437144078,
0.0511248372,
0.0705695674,
-0.0046988176,
0.0459897071,
-0.053607583,
-0.0498672798,
-0.0279036313,
-0.019046478,
0.0062106168,
-6.35642105e-33,
0.0241434984,
0.0153507954,
-0.0396567211,
0.0121404771,
0.0203940999,
0.0282426625,
-0.0301883519,
0.0215108804,
-0.0296497699,
0.0373495556,
0.0134872375,
-0.005798202,
0.0135970702,
0.0558639206,
0.0075510866,
0.03552109,
0.0293378979,
0.0360346176,
-0.0050092405,
0.0362425335,
0.0463648438,
0.0475072376,
0.0923357382,
-0.0905270502,
0.037991371,
-0.0306341387,
0.0041655367,
-0.0175981615,
0.0706153587,
0.0984548777,
-0.025923444,
0.0768113136,
0.047651846,
-0.0602615364,
-0.0090644583,
-0.0172306895,
-0.0276704077,
-0.0395512618,
-0.0022457747,
0.0166561957,
-0.0168443676,
-0.0013002414,
0.0156673826,
0.0054194112,
-0.0058430615,
-0.0271374322,
0.0449263491,
-0.0227650777,
-0.0083583593,
-0.0413116552,
-0.0797192305,
0.0408141129,
0.0281413253,
-0.0200731158,
0.0399530977,
0.0666802675,
-0.0239321459,
0.0336431265,
-0.0579006486,
0.0271315072,
-0.0371085405,
0.0537622981,
0.0359822549,
0.0099441223,
-0.0280629098,
0.076145716,
0.0231274478,
-0.0127564324,
0.0192814153,
0.0050989748,
0.0393883064,
-0.0184172783,
0.0405151099,
0.0789908022,
0.0500032678,
-0.0484862961,
-0.073759228,
0.0494910777,
0.0348444134,
-0.0032881689,
0.0545973741,
0.0168559421,
-0.0255035553,
-0.0421740711,
0.0079238415,
-0.0109369513,
-0.0182223096,
-0.0153362127,
0.0074569839,
0.0140437689,
-0.0278262626,
0.0225731097,
0.0195994079,
-0.0328083821,
-0.0137481848,
0.0368003212,
-0.0118035004,
0.0317079276,
0.0225901939,
0.0005817332,
-0.0592604652,
-0.025268482,
-0.0280814599,
0.0070278537,
0.0198179688,
-0.0039463048,
0.0687349364,
0.0115048448,
-0.0728867799,
0.025210185,
0.0044920715,
0.0163797606,
-0.0306737293,
0.1023844704,
-0.017168561,
-0.0088326205,
-0.018488653,
0.0795586556,
0.0372345522,
0.0163967088,
-0.0042205513,
0.0128664011,
-0.0248914901,
0.024611773,
-0.0289775841,
-0.0275312215,
-0.0341190323,
0.0042944192,
0.0255954843,
-0.0594505779,
-0.0239208601,
-0.0140909692,
2.811e-7,
0.020819556,
0.0299979504,
-0.0145324096,
-0.0291703809,
-0.013881702,
0.0456091985,
0.0114941951,
0.0070328666,
-0.0024554664,
0.0362305678,
-0.021736769,
0.0361265615,
0.0484206863,
0.0609301068,
-0.0731724799,
0.0410860144,
-0.0597536527,
-0.0023218752,
-0.0277513321,
-0.0033100371,
-0.0100044962,
0.1538253725,
-0.0127734514,
-0.0319342688,
-0.0610883497,
0.0018950106,
0.0726124421,
-0.0519228987,
-0.0338529348,
0.0174308773,
0.0112574138,
0.0436472706,
-0.0313103646,
-0.0295765735,
-0.047544349,
0.0387324728,
0.0260253847,
-0.0005099425,
-0.0194917824,
-0.0326659083,
0.0465717353,
0.0356265754,
-0.0514184535,
-0.0451773033,
0.0274801459,
-0.0357899517,
-0.0271267444,
-0.0740332454,
0.0198137835,
0.0558687337,
0.0496738516,
-0.0309523176,
-0.0344776884,
0.0160215441,
0.0298300888,
-0.0769133419,
-0.0258290637,
-0.0368518494,
-0.0218412969,
0.0475093722,
-0.0144885909,
0.0074380026,
0.0175688975,
0.009473864,
0.0311344974,
-0.0016169822,
0.040088553,
2.379256127e-34,
0.0144470101,
-0.0057397494,
0.0053596902,
0.030991951,
-0.0049966634,
-0.0283477772,
-0.0627797768,
-0.0096772155,
-0.0233270172,
0.0103926621,
0.0205458179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15264v1 | Towards Possibilities & Impossibilities of AI-generated Text Detection: A Survey | 2023-10-23T18:11:32 | 2023-10-23T18:11:32 | Soumya Suvra Ghosal, Souradip Chakraborty, Jonas Geiping, Furong Huang, Dinesh Manocha, Amrit Singh Bedi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized the domain of natural
language processing (NLP) with remarkable capabilities of generating human-like
text responses. However, despite these advancements, several works in the
existing literature have raised serious concerns about the potential misuse of
LLMs such as spreading misinformation, generating fake news, plagiarism in
academia, and contaminating the web. To address these concerns, a consensus
among the research community is to develop algorithmic solutions to detect
AI-generated text. The basic idea is that whenever we can tell if the given
text is either written by a human or an AI, we can utilize this information to
address the above-mentioned concerns. To that end, a plethora of detection
frameworks have been proposed, highlighting the possibilities of AI-generated
text detection. But in parallel to the development of detection frameworks,
researchers have also concentrated on designing strategies to elude detection,
i.e., focusing on the impossibilities of AI-generated text detection. This is a
crucial step in order to make sure the detection frameworks are robust enough
and it is not too easy to fool a detector. Despite the huge interest and the
flurry of research in this domain, the community currently lacks a
comprehensive analysis of recent developments. In this survey, we aim to
provide a concise categorization and overview of current work encompassing both
the prospects and the limitations of AI-generated text detection. To enrich the
collective knowledge, we engage in an exhaustive discussion on critical and
challenging open questions related to ongoing research on AI-generated text
detection. | [
0.0920515358,
0.0345004089,
-0.0403112061,
0.0651375577,
-0.065540038,
0.0016200243,
0.0179372579,
0.0329975337,
0.0596164688,
-0.056154564,
-0.0142083028,
-0.001814773,
-0.0122757237,
0.0435052402,
0.0188563634,
0.0307578444,
0.0232060663,
-0.0006342034,
0.0297772083,
0.0180336889,
0.0172863081,
0.0208216943,
0.0201658625,
0.0197404437,
-0.0285406411,
-0.010660708,
0.0172247086,
0.0005466815,
-0.0009091236,
-0.0084149903,
-0.0060811769,
0.0341339819,
-0.0093059223,
0.1084236577,
0.0000018809,
-0.0274194255,
-0.030906627,
-0.0112002483,
-0.0453489833,
0.0051447358,
0.075331755,
-0.0304839127,
-0.0228419118,
0.0093008038,
-0.0426152945,
0.0233166683,
-0.0042616418,
0.0337903388,
0.0415191352,
0.1048246399,
-0.0320520625,
-0.0025027127,
0.0787504315,
0.0162956491,
-0.0108347917,
-0.0252504405,
0.0556695014,
-0.0248550698,
-0.0004793461,
0.0229087509,
0.0243426543,
0.0311397947,
0.0021592546,
-0.030011218,
0.0017145523,
-0.00326004,
-0.0153262904,
-0.030874446,
-0.0484903418,
0.003430156,
-0.047471758,
-0.0840493813,
0.054292012,
-0.0247252379,
0.0216125213,
0.018804118,
0.0295018796,
0.0590658523,
-0.0485903621,
0.0039432547,
0.0389310941,
-0.0036536232,
0.0218722541,
0.0672607794,
0.0277806465,
0.0378818363,
0.0110858185,
-0.062501289,
-0.029291613,
0.0011517061,
-0.0013112329,
-0.053612113,
0.0681117326,
0.0405080244,
0.0215735361,
0.0034182558,
-0.0912553146,
-0.0781481192,
0.0386658534,
-0.0507585704,
0.0297280345,
-0.0161978528,
-0.0025776038,
0.0368064046,
-0.044402156,
0.065678969,
-0.0618949197,
-0.0013452296,
-0.0046574012,
-0.0023502221,
0.0067117312,
-0.052212216,
-0.0197898261,
0.0176609494,
-0.0090813991,
-0.0366800986,
-0.0201211367,
0.0127547197,
-0.0033433114,
0.0232980587,
-0.0587453395,
-0.0300159212,
-0.0040792348,
-0.013331986,
0.0051180832,
-0.0347628556,
0.0288162902,
0.038596075,
-0.0259364676,
-0.0598231927,
-0.0043754424,
0.0752053782,
0.0051536965,
0.0033579995,
0.0151960002,
0.0609934404,
0.0037074925,
-0.0619214922,
-0.0386066772,
-0.0712190121,
-0.0318087451,
-0.0390529521,
0.0238879789,
-0.0609500892,
-0.0364503898,
-0.0155579904,
-0.0086035859,
-0.0436279327,
0.0031859314,
0.0377575606,
-0.0062849675,
0.0346308798,
-0.0231664851,
0.005999913,
0.0571290143,
-0.0028960602,
-0.0055946647,
0.0380100086,
0.0297364742,
0.0808706805,
0.0717974454,
0.0421329066,
0.048744265,
0.0492467843,
0.013850051,
0.0018025239,
0.016429659,
-0.0200033858,
-0.0322377086,
-0.0036316256,
-0.0106850639,
0.0659755543,
0.0171932895,
-0.0427977741,
0.0661254823,
0.0588629395,
-0.0233523808,
0.0246223938,
0.0711584985,
0.0390265062,
0.0290853251,
0.0369090214,
0.0055308295,
-0.0412280485,
-0.0556822196,
-0.050990805,
-0.0204523094,
0.0253043473,
0.015925182,
-0.0338516384,
-0.0090288119,
-0.0330924578,
0.009950663,
-0.0317008309,
0.0533752851,
0.0136045413,
-0.0142455967,
-0.0691729859,
-0.0156369004,
-0.027333308,
0.0353369676,
-0.0889860913,
0.0478046201,
0.0404188931,
0.0697660595,
-0.0247170385,
0.0723261982,
-0.0164334122,
-0.0092812395,
0.0586150251,
0.0244157109,
-0.0085205743,
-0.0482951254,
0.0025680189,
0.0081472397,
0.0013000764,
0.0171601567,
0.0011585616,
0.0495902225,
0.0234330799,
0.0216317177,
-0.001477791,
-0.0489404686,
0.0514277592,
-0.0280554164,
-0.0004214571,
-0.0060227043,
0.0112197362,
0.0187915992,
0.0198798552,
-0.0316537619,
0.0157732479,
0.0522632115,
-0.0542863682,
-0.0435715169,
-0.0515604615,
0.0264747124,
0.0074274447,
0.0040330305,
-0.0114635192,
-0.0219772868,
0.041286055,
0.0128336186,
-0.0013675634,
-0.0106863389,
-0.058331579,
0.0000122831,
-0.0631582066,
0.0219217278,
-0.0206111353,
0.0249288827,
-0.0236590765,
0.0720069632,
-0.0198030174,
-0.021816887,
0.0216692854,
-0.0026693761,
0.0410090983,
-0.0176009964,
-0.0168135557,
-0.0161481742,
-0.0102783125,
0.0290670674,
0.0272716992,
-0.0086640529,
0.0031368602,
-0.0439708382,
-0.0377293676,
-0.0120668598,
-0.0154522611,
-0.0057590581,
0.0316197611,
-0.0401710793,
-0.0156538635,
0.0119920038,
-0.00374054,
-0.02858763,
0.0686967745,
0.0044577979,
0.04134918,
-0.0200662911,
0.0168991908,
-0.0205209479,
0.023582967,
-0.0443603173,
0.0330861509,
0.0601463057,
-0.0781979486,
-0.0608645454,
0.0404515862,
0.0091729816,
0.0257332232,
-0.0175919812,
-0.0198118798,
-0.0327365957,
-0.0260207467,
0.004916823,
0.1126325503,
0.0306054261,
0.0189272687,
0.0270788316,
0.0533694811,
0.007388853,
-0.0156219611,
-0.0152877131,
0.0443084762,
-0.0240816157,
-0.0489298552,
0.05566407,
0.0230765324,
0.0223287046,
-0.0138484295,
-0.0124484198,
0.0450265221,
-0.0261730421,
-0.0536187924,
0.0296848565,
-0.062886402,
-0.0192080345,
0.0435273163,
-0.0292468518,
-0.0698454753,
0.04010313,
-0.044044368,
0.0476523452,
-0.0511805154,
-0.0312315151,
-0.032949619,
0.0052706925,
0.0126634398,
0.0473074429,
-0.0007574955,
0.0246661585,
-0.0081217829,
0.0041226316,
0.0089938277,
-0.0239403881,
0.0103605278,
-0.0151422303,
0.017910393,
0.0108035896,
-0.0025708773,
-0.0579456799,
-0.0710104927,
-0.0192415938,
-0.0088698678,
0.034297049,
-0.0480394252,
-0.010974776,
-0.0025463684,
0.0232060477,
0.0524926223,
-0.0128874443,
0.0092616566,
-0.0392218865,
0.0739269182,
0.0439891033,
-0.0578134209,
0.0490120463,
-0.0318719186,
-0.0055514891,
0.0537190996,
-0.0035155988,
0.0292600282,
0.0113552157,
-0.0285495818,
-0.0001298378,
0.00890237,
0.0028441455,
-5.275e-7,
0.0065127616,
-0.0449023433,
-0.002430445,
0.0760132968,
0.0314470343,
-0.0432332493,
-0.014520932,
-0.0129537322,
-0.0147202499,
-0.0052652084,
-0.0195399616,
-0.0506802239,
-0.0086928997,
0.0111674909,
-0.0139131518,
-0.0779422969,
0.0010213451,
-0.0097834058,
-0.0804570243,
0.0212365482,
-0.0130641703,
0.0226788279,
-0.0349653214,
-0.0259631947,
-0.016904505,
0.0298565123,
-0.051426325,
-0.0499305539,
0.0051137265,
-0.013870351,
-0.0003146722,
-0.0285662375,
-0.0349143296,
-0.0156404283,
-0.0365255028,
0.0266671926,
0.0735487938,
0.0742609948,
-0.0162636321,
-0.0139060346,
-0.0048986073,
-0.0100081777,
-0.006731763,
-0.007408957,
0.0407625474,
-0.0276961979,
-0.0019846014,
-0.0094851935,
0.0417276248,
0.0022114923,
0.0147489943,
0.0457236618,
0.058798328,
-0.0025904917,
-0.0635367185,
-0.0474415794,
-0.0151284551,
0.0249876734,
0.0747075751,
0.003097005,
-0.0504941642,
-0.0535474196,
-0.0043811495,
0.0433889367,
-0.0402740054,
-0.0573619269,
-0.0039474987,
0.0086566107,
-0.0148754874,
-0.0683623999,
-0.0213195626,
-0.0371321179,
-0.022957975,
0.0252880249,
0.0239457786,
0.0151687013,
-0.0098513579,
-0.0190084726,
-0.056795422,
-0.0572074503,
0.0482516363,
-0.0395252481,
0.0013708058,
-0.0011121288,
-0.0554584451,
-0.0023939132,
0.0374039114,
-0.0906206518,
-0.0394849814,
0.0108506167,
-0.0084996726,
0.0227302127,
0.0102133807,
-0.0444750115,
-0.0487288199,
0.0884591714,
0.0288908891,
-0.0304096602,
0.0336911939,
0.003272495,
-0.0113723362,
-0.0081876554,
0.019173177,
-0.0240714736,
0.0281343572,
0.035165675,
-0.0419349894,
-0.0400630161,
-0.0117300479,
0.0326522738,
0.0216923188,
0.0041949423,
-0.0186284389,
0.0181809571,
-0.0186598375,
-0.029715389,
-0.0199118257,
-0.0271451268,
-0.027905615,
0.0095598223,
0.0341817588,
0.015849581,
-0.0015786218,
0.0309686009,
-0.0259543322,
0.0403260589,
-0.0112976106,
0.014880144,
0.0047036279,
0.0697235614,
0.0070337411,
-0.0178543366,
0.0181025341,
0.0626545399,
-0.0285518914,
0.0173513368,
0.0242584776,
0.0400436744,
0.0268298183,
-0.0618546493,
0.0012887061,
0.031147277,
-0.0817562863,
0.000104664,
-0.0284414962,
0.0262091495,
0.0293425564,
-0.0003054138,
0.0138524156,
-0.0477030575,
-0.027253516,
-0.0262447074,
-0.0069879214,
0.0331991613,
-0.0184506327,
-0.034575507,
-0.004607691,
-0.0328387544,
0.0194219947,
0.0618280619,
0.0386062004,
0.0583893843,
0.013348069,
-0.0474602096,
-0.0366480127,
-0.0343019217,
0.0117208976,
-0.0161325037,
-0.0141543644,
0.0414440222,
-0.0635866225,
-0.0567833446,
0.0425331704,
-0.0010520532,
0.0381635353,
-0.0321434475,
-0.0425674878,
0.0741811544,
-0.0055586221,
0.0337329879,
-0.0660796985,
0.0270876493,
-0.0134900324,
-0.0224793963,
-0.0248099677,
-5.323828241e-33,
0.01143259,
-0.0971875861,
-0.0281675514,
0.0184617657,
0.0258058999,
0.0492511019,
0.0001575433,
-0.0438646264,
-0.0174640492,
0.003565223,
-0.0099336132,
0.0350130275,
-0.0114257392,
0.0085108029,
-0.0457574092,
0.0119553208,
0.0424837805,
-0.034340512,
-0.0398032404,
0.0113661969,
0.0339411423,
-0.0290616658,
-0.0243317187,
-0.0626050979,
0.008197397,
-0.0392999314,
-0.0387317427,
0.0280441474,
-0.0496768467,
0.0650416464,
-0.0403042287,
0.0360155478,
0.0441695265,
0.0230207592,
0.0012325415,
0.0684524104,
-0.0078489035,
0.0145249134,
-0.0175498724,
-0.0128415963,
-0.004712923,
-0.0497328937,
0.0364954099,
-0.0286310017,
-0.0194123797,
0.0574313216,
0.0504589826,
-0.0254164468,
0.0285431761,
-0.0174607616,
-0.0529565662,
0.0192434471,
0.0235884525,
-0.0032167013,
0.0367546566,
0.0382116176,
0.0344989598,
0.0409120098,
-0.0743427947,
0.0244142599,
0.0058273561,
-0.0101088425,
0.0092920968,
-0.0117240632,
-0.017516911,
0.0287311058,
0.0413396135,
0.0269188136,
-0.0334524177,
-0.0405488051,
-0.0145336641,
-0.0189682413,
0.0874600634,
0.0785413831,
0.0010833869,
-0.0272431914,
-0.0398910604,
0.0000051092,
0.0151732145,
-0.0140962303,
0.0533058122,
-0.0346509255,
-0.072972104,
0.0072598173,
-0.0078358408,
-0.0751793087,
-0.0347505398,
0.0142194843,
0.0239144899,
0.0514305569,
-0.0429147519,
0.0050262874,
-0.0006816727,
-0.0633450523,
0.0194026213,
0.0218212325,
-0.0199531168,
0.0201130584,
0.0250114519,
0.0404174142,
-0.054835815,
-0.0125741065,
0.028365057,
0.0082851965,
0.014948721,
-0.0166879296,
0.0315121748,
0.0209234245,
-0.0301530212,
0.0117489984,
0.0067509855,
0.036489401,
0.0309377667,
-0.0021829263,
0.0228940304,
-0.0182854664,
0.0020221202,
0.0017092603,
0.0416182093,
0.0311437063,
-0.0348772258,
0.0198906604,
-0.0446929857,
0.0075272699,
-0.0261139367,
-0.0079086917,
-0.0302115828,
0.0487320796,
0.0188439358,
-0.0685556382,
0.0376458243,
-0.0463406369,
2.453e-7,
0.0027927791,
0.0258303136,
0.0352295414,
-0.005983599,
0.0437746271,
0.0499017574,
0.0119212316,
0.0172849149,
-0.0335597545,
0.0089104213,
-0.0297064465,
0.0237354785,
0.0313696787,
-0.0044947444,
-0.048681099,
0.0663637295,
-0.0550442412,
0.0201768745,
-0.0673506185,
0.0025265401,
0.0585296564,
0.0544015877,
0.0166782998,
-0.0475042276,
-0.0264971834,
-0.0888490081,
0.0332536288,
0.0117382305,
0.0094113341,
0.0226985924,
0.0548062101,
0.0176240411,
0.008178643,
0.0403941981,
-0.0209917743,
0.0328373723,
0.0195073653,
0.0472206175,
0.0205164682,
0.043261826,
-0.007428193,
-0.0407728218,
-0.0110948924,
-0.0430263504,
0.071164459,
0.0064320383,
-0.0154688247,
-0.0528814346,
0.0039056886,
-0.0420125835,
-0.0008690124,
-0.0354996026,
-0.0252284892,
0.006429465,
-0.0027998509,
0.0140146837,
0.0154797193,
-0.0480278134,
-0.0016405543,
-0.0481586345,
-0.0415589176,
0.0036991134,
-0.0758669674,
0.0002126286,
0.0331643485,
-0.0605768003,
0.042468708,
2.406834785e-34,
0.0112365028,
-0.0287185907,
-0.0196047872,
0.0255624857,
0.0423902422,
0.0342520885,
-0.0413238183,
0.0095092906,
0.004406807,
-0.0459248312,
0.0161255337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15262v1 | Data Augmentation Techniques for Machine Translation of Code-Switched Texts: A Comparative Study | 2023-10-23T18:09:41 | 2023-10-23T18:09:41 | Injy Hamed, Nizar Habash, Ngoc Thang Vu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code-switching (CSW) text generation has been receiving increasing attention
as a solution to address data scarcity. In light of this growing interest, we
need more comprehensive studies comparing different augmentation approaches. In
this work, we compare three popular approaches: lexical replacements,
linguistic theories, and back-translation (BT), in the context of Egyptian
Arabic-English CSW. We assess the effectiveness of the approaches on machine
translation and the quality of augmentations through human evaluation. We show
that BT and CSW predictive-based lexical replacement, being trained on CSW
parallel data, perform best on both tasks. Linguistic theories and random
lexical replacement prove to be effective in the lack of CSW parallel data,
where both approaches achieve similar results. | [
0.0319504328,
0.0650136694,
-0.0155159961,
0.0173771493,
-0.0634752139,
0.02775985,
0.0286549442,
0.0166393295,
-0.0296067409,
-0.0382313542,
-0.0099567184,
-0.0418885574,
0.0564776808,
0.0166908503,
0.0726722702,
0.0004297514,
0.0223568231,
-0.0439273342,
-0.0435893126,
0.022904234,
0.0151999462,
0.0327736475,
0.0126486542,
0.0025118433,
0.0159816556,
0.0057895915,
-0.0130596189,
0.0261883195,
0.0330498889,
-0.0109484363,
-0.0031384311,
0.0295352098,
-0.0202273056,
0.0740410909,
0.0000020329,
-0.0303562563,
-0.0784500018,
-0.0048050485,
0.010488281,
0.0175331905,
0.0620349608,
-0.0949726775,
-0.0349119343,
0.0212595668,
-0.0094458014,
0.0034410986,
0.0754963979,
-0.0079659922,
0.0342205428,
0.0712824911,
-0.0147529952,
-0.030889282,
0.0203180034,
-0.0254450757,
-0.0019517103,
-0.0120183593,
0.0236061178,
0.0037400764,
-0.0131999692,
0.0393786766,
-0.0278479531,
0.0727019757,
0.0015383742,
-0.0109182866,
0.0190364104,
-0.0106864562,
-0.036660172,
0.0013158724,
-0.0107879592,
0.0224774331,
-0.0287666526,
-0.0450565703,
-0.017640207,
-0.0276497491,
-0.0199610107,
-0.031674657,
-0.0085890768,
0.0361759067,
-0.0117448652,
0.014780404,
0.0191199202,
0.0046326844,
0.0375752859,
0.0134659549,
-0.0684631765,
-0.0172441769,
0.0284126643,
-0.0515648425,
-0.0034378378,
0.0298565403,
0.0220137201,
-0.0261120033,
0.0254763458,
-0.0080908779,
-0.0103190178,
0.0168193541,
-0.0429248698,
-0.0852718577,
0.0155777549,
-0.0647060871,
0.0338094942,
0.0726490617,
-0.0398700275,
0.0032913275,
-0.0487237461,
0.0260565821,
0.0170705654,
0.0057735615,
-0.05340188,
0.0430126153,
-0.0361531824,
0.0011114303,
-0.06835448,
-0.0134877888,
-0.048806116,
-0.0020742349,
-0.0572581999,
0.0051316731,
0.0330758914,
-0.0198692176,
0.00679537,
-0.0312565193,
-0.0637335703,
0.0150631685,
0.0433240868,
-0.0180543158,
0.0166751314,
-0.0020686982,
-0.013859611,
-0.0874806866,
0.0116049247,
0.0263811778,
0.006234752,
-0.0112815024,
-0.0305896085,
0.0543295518,
-0.0542232953,
-0.0240248218,
-0.0324462727,
0.0192855634,
-0.0174022019,
0.0017266308,
-0.0572605692,
-0.067402631,
0.0107424296,
0.0040161349,
0.0060994881,
-0.0281241089,
0.0191840753,
0.0000816728,
-0.0012436153,
0.0651777834,
-0.0531993546,
0.0008195894,
0.0281654913,
-0.0318737067,
0.0019216234,
0.0755941346,
0.064561151,
0.0099752638,
0.0238494538,
0.0052304789,
0.0198279805,
0.0475467369,
-0.0176103339,
0.0351036005,
-0.0486690812,
-0.0401973613,
0.0376535356,
0.0747023672,
0.0009838372,
0.0520522334,
-0.0463501029,
0.0099974964,
0.0350866988,
-0.0179731939,
0.0042116758,
0.056357488,
0.0449676216,
0.011188603,
0.0137096709,
0.0048741871,
0.0178716909,
0.0139654828,
0.0218354017,
0.011612908,
0.0386546291,
0.0117751602,
0.0072174738,
-0.0530725457,
-0.0012005136,
-0.0126268538,
0.0915827453,
-0.0537459739,
0.0491774231,
0.0343874097,
-0.046431262,
-0.0521354266,
-0.0146746868,
-0.0440229736,
-0.0096373446,
-0.0487674437,
-0.0951322019,
0.1054656059,
0.0498034693,
0.0329572558,
-0.0336995497,
-0.0080811754,
-0.0116687361,
0.0581631549,
0.02444694,
0.0318017229,
0.0171491783,
-0.0626457036,
-0.0010760908,
-0.0021334945,
-0.0170432981,
0.0277212076,
0.0304156598,
0.0505532734,
0.0389638096,
0.0189467352,
-0.0928037241,
0.0410746485,
-0.063897498,
0.020619655,
0.0208427515,
0.0081898626,
-0.0278347787,
0.0044354354,
-0.0190919209,
0.0301007051,
-0.0141565409,
-0.0221562069,
-0.0428405888,
0.0374752842,
-0.0082098451,
-0.019441681,
0.0263363943,
-0.029992139,
0.0265186261,
0.0218047239,
-0.0036165933,
-0.0460249968,
0.0368047394,
-0.073428683,
0.0629378855,
-0.0217711125,
0.0802384093,
0.0039918534,
0.0062827915,
-0.0222472213,
0.0214168187,
-0.0026378985,
-0.0103676766,
0.0090176547,
0.0086344089,
0.0561462715,
-0.0083675152,
0.0044731186,
0.0081572309,
0.0101354597,
0.0159309264,
0.0202113241,
-0.0057338723,
-0.0336769298,
-0.0432141162,
-0.0445013568,
-0.0028320875,
-0.0106578348,
0.0254756846,
0.0263357703,
0.0334240906,
0.0001239423,
-0.0151558872,
-0.0267975535,
-0.0201846268,
-0.006015447,
0.0180939157,
0.029017048,
0.001720153,
-0.0178664066,
-0.0342863053,
0.0049043908,
0.0353695527,
0.011832118,
0.054455284,
-0.0372855701,
-0.055639077,
-0.0110150874,
-0.0127900857,
-0.0089708976,
0.0253594313,
-0.0533633083,
0.0363061987,
-0.0226920079,
0.0164226275,
-0.0168775469,
0.0110606533,
-0.0221027769,
0.0136260986,
0.0053262631,
-0.0338353962,
-0.0373376384,
0.0128514636,
-0.0747707263,
-0.023177648,
-0.0791446567,
0.0034112681,
0.0229627211,
0.0083130924,
-0.0129709449,
-0.0650251359,
-0.0351048186,
-0.0184230078,
-0.022812305,
0.0194836818,
-0.0189640522,
-0.0076459278,
0.0848502964,
-0.0298731625,
-0.0358026512,
0.0433084294,
-0.0201401282,
0.0105251167,
-0.070849143,
0.0135272965,
-0.0343442112,
-0.0167647228,
-0.0200434253,
0.0187698957,
-0.0124518005,
-0.0272925422,
-0.0269007869,
0.0192869678,
-0.0110480497,
-0.0316168144,
-0.0176063571,
-0.0598077253,
0.0208895765,
0.0090114623,
-0.0177833419,
-0.0226148702,
-0.0194734391,
0.0038227658,
-0.0283011198,
0.0987442508,
-0.0402445309,
-0.0022189468,
0.015542578,
-0.0096586458,
0.0651265308,
-0.0226067323,
-0.0068330336,
0.0012267565,
-0.0246024095,
-0.0178706292,
-0.0181617849,
-0.0250591002,
-0.026274737,
-0.0116360011,
0.0111712357,
-0.0470603146,
-0.020174522,
-0.0803804174,
-0.0003898344,
0.0300861709,
-0.0117716677,
-0.0456732698,
-0.0569222532,
-0.0155438958,
-0.054269135,
-0.0123075601,
0.0560007542,
0.0197607856,
-0.0547893383,
-0.0088548325,
-0.0091548273,
0.0072867251,
-0.0058936416,
-0.0075742491,
-0.1029758379,
0.0103748553,
-0.0041311914,
0.0760121346,
-0.0115926936,
0.0221752226,
0.0046046199,
-0.0729787052,
-0.0023123338,
0.0361824371,
-0.0990193188,
-0.0551717542,
0.0200454108,
0.0039644297,
-0.0137843918,
-0.0371731892,
-0.0042754784,
0.0060719978,
0.0338748805,
0.0467743725,
0.0283456929,
-0.0225719307,
-0.0801147521,
-0.0162354186,
0.0300729945,
0.0993841887,
0.023832038,
-0.0189008974,
-0.0332808457,
-0.0112647805,
-0.015890602,
-0.0163664334,
-0.0108889444,
0.0456972159,
-0.013169962,
-0.0065194792,
0.0306897834,
0.0078048483,
0.0125603806,
-0.0029083989,
0.0123152379,
-0.0034702932,
-0.0079232287,
0.0412347019,
0.0235752314,
0.013257117,
0.0397580899,
0.0011531921,
0.0028142959,
-0.0438795462,
-0.0035953736,
-0.0350658968,
0.0126625048,
-0.1002760753,
0.0086029992,
0.0067178668,
-0.0250831787,
-0.0563701764,
-0.1015688553,
-0.0360514633,
0.0146022923,
0.0369783416,
0.0430450812,
0.0640936643,
-0.0117416363,
-0.0053217034,
-0.0284604188,
-0.0517091043,
0.0008377222,
0.0158863384,
-0.0284878742,
-0.0623079017,
-0.005367117,
-0.0848142207,
0.0621192679,
0.0079205623,
-0.0977640897,
-0.0553204641,
0.0290825069,
-0.0016774138,
0.0204920713,
0.0495387986,
-0.0177524965,
-0.0354093164,
-0.0111353323,
0.0083705513,
-0.0323821306,
0.0392713994,
0.0424550697,
0.0393512584,
-0.0166256242,
0.0405081548,
0.007414734,
-0.0161206909,
0.0127918515,
0.0175969023,
-0.0314453021,
-0.0478649102,
0.0242575556,
-0.0074274321,
-0.0033731041,
-0.0655338317,
-0.0359544307,
-0.004124783,
0.0385892317,
-0.0226671528,
0.0038201157,
-0.0286723487,
0.00366942,
0.0576151907,
0.0244715437,
-0.002409237,
-0.0078871986,
-0.0368516073,
-0.0450930707,
-0.0030860247,
0.0337143466,
-0.0113585079,
0.0463864021,
0.0364100114,
0.059081912,
0.0050776508,
-0.0082922392,
-0.0009652352,
0.0224660207,
-0.0325543955,
0.0183905344,
0.0257144608,
-0.0019629966,
0.0035264767,
0.0603485554,
-0.0605192967,
-0.0293451771,
-0.0095950365,
0.0190786496,
-0.0002901648,
0.007237751,
0.1040627137,
-0.0125051243,
-0.0123275649,
0.0145766782,
0.0288516805,
-0.0080718128,
-0.0012516398,
-0.0602254607,
-0.0186029579,
-0.0108228503,
0.0476524495,
0.0529417507,
-0.0089145536,
-0.0058574057,
-0.020217441,
-0.0230931602,
-0.0121959848,
0.0175918303,
0.0527192689,
-0.0114315655,
-0.0130569655,
-0.0302515328,
-0.0138979023,
-0.0671906471,
0.0140775787,
0.040561568,
0.0162556879,
-0.0136744846,
-0.0008349222,
0.071912013,
0.0020375222,
0.0462780893,
-0.0763041899,
0.0385275893,
0.0673246831,
-0.0547456853,
-0.0300191399,
-5.572110648e-33,
0.0261037052,
-0.0001286759,
0.0094501497,
-0.0220568459,
-0.0298038591,
-0.0064873639,
-0.0324755721,
0.0025783053,
0.0484712236,
-0.0149213625,
-0.0114550469,
-0.0036747388,
0.0207257196,
0.0070868288,
0.0572240166,
0.0329473279,
0.0519790724,
-0.0031224489,
-0.0204802938,
0.0272024758,
0.0395126007,
0.0447329544,
0.0679001808,
-0.045139458,
0.0798057467,
-0.0383245945,
-0.0230564047,
-0.0341404676,
0.0073767314,
0.0285103898,
0.0184572749,
0.009736537,
0.0105333021,
-0.0391999148,
-0.0214938819,
-0.0081650047,
-0.03053765,
0.0333338827,
0.0209936276,
0.0655370057,
-0.0262024403,
-0.0389779769,
0.0325578228,
-0.0552996546,
-0.0165293664,
0.0555247962,
-0.0070145358,
-0.0605362356,
-0.0182570294,
0.0179366749,
-0.1284647435,
0.0439071953,
-0.0169715639,
-0.0017301083,
0.0409591645,
0.0766445771,
-0.0392982736,
-0.0069429963,
-0.0509957001,
0.0287831407,
0.0592797995,
0.0142573165,
0.0437864885,
0.0413793474,
-0.0426422618,
-0.0007228339,
0.0377551578,
-0.0029783661,
0.051343672,
0.0536645316,
0.0414135829,
-0.0284751672,
0.0407198071,
0.06184268,
0.0543673597,
-0.0506067835,
-0.0203746762,
0.0293039158,
-0.0255328137,
-0.0194697697,
0.0312762372,
0.0344920866,
-0.0542870983,
-0.0194191504,
-0.0064096721,
-0.0465138182,
-0.0077550951,
-0.0465474613,
0.0032882397,
0.0245479476,
-0.0617697835,
0.0516452119,
0.0088291653,
-0.0102771474,
0.0203939285,
-0.0012227556,
-0.0425284877,
0.0381257124,
-0.0100049842,
0.035446424,
-0.0362248421,
-0.022392882,
0.0566671155,
0.0437157191,
0.0328788199,
-0.0172025096,
0.0439896435,
0.0290266406,
-0.0519834273,
0.0186399072,
-0.0366661102,
0.0007744952,
0.0000743805,
0.0019361244,
-0.00596342,
-0.006786508,
0.0129032647,
-0.0015443866,
0.0231079645,
-0.0169750378,
-0.0351669602,
-0.0388411544,
0.0069004609,
-0.0096707456,
-0.0516421683,
0.018190071,
-0.013606647,
0.0214655418,
0.0323174261,
-0.0615099892,
-0.0230794623,
0.0290339161,
2.88e-7,
0.0705866069,
0.0304332022,
0.0284458566,
-0.0345088802,
-0.0040022931,
-0.0203743335,
-0.026083922,
0.0054623964,
0.0552327484,
0.0519982986,
0.0321814753,
0.0166311823,
0.0811256915,
0.0039046186,
-0.0390603058,
-0.0454789959,
0.0036532423,
0.0543387309,
-0.051095143,
-0.0086699845,
0.0620328672,
0.098099649,
-0.0271944292,
0.0028310977,
-0.0067946496,
0.01433641,
0.0176077243,
-0.0088315858,
0.0054030591,
-0.021485636,
-0.0020994882,
0.0353057049,
-0.0300865844,
0.0077853575,
-0.0468921736,
-0.0173329506,
0.0556445718,
0.0288530942,
0.0192461181,
0.0345177464,
0.0147042042,
-0.0045205723,
-0.0166377053,
-0.0420525968,
0.0531815328,
0.0109816408,
0.0205542427,
0.0050500594,
-0.0137037449,
0.0714340135,
0.0156549253,
-0.0557793118,
-0.0396605022,
0.0270475652,
0.0540241338,
0.0372493267,
-0.0328221843,
-0.0148773566,
0.0098585142,
-0.040874403,
0.008136129,
-0.0482787192,
-0.0376542583,
0.0301749781,
-0.0197082572,
0.0014891833,
0.0111088669,
2.231946021e-34,
0.0464325398,
-0.0241853688,
0.0066788611,
-0.0229998548,
0.0403397232,
-0.0209975019,
0.0237450898,
0.0613396503,
-0.0015656169,
-0.0328169391,
-0.0260735713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15259v1 | Reference Free Domain Adaptation for Translation of Noisy Questions with Question Specific Rewards | 2023-10-23T18:08:01 | 2023-10-23T18:08:01 | Baban Gain, Ramakrishna Appicharla, Soumya Chennabasavaraj, Nikesh Garera, Asif Ekbal, Muthusamy Chelliah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Community Question-Answering (CQA) portals serve as a valuable tool for
helping users within an organization. However, making them accessible to
non-English-speaking users continues to be a challenge. Translating questions
can broaden the community's reach, benefiting individuals with similar
inquiries in various languages. Translating questions using Neural Machine
Translation (NMT) poses more challenges, especially in noisy environments,
where the grammatical correctness of the questions is not monitored. These
questions may be phrased as statements by non-native speakers, with incorrect
subject-verb order and sometimes even missing question marks. Creating a
synthetic parallel corpus from such data is also difficult due to its noisy
nature. To address this issue, we propose a training methodology that
fine-tunes the NMT system only using source-side data. Our approach balances
adequacy and fluency by utilizing a loss function that combines BERTScore and
Masked Language Model (MLM) Score. Our method surpasses the conventional
Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) based fine-tuning approach, which relies on
synthetic target data, by achieving a 1.9 BLEU score improvement. Our model
exhibits robustness while we add noise to our baseline, and still achieve 1.1
BLEU improvement and large improvements on TER and BLEURT metrics. Our proposed
methodology is model-agnostic and is only necessary during the training phase.
We make the codes and datasets publicly available at
\url{https://www.iitp.ac.in/~ai-nlp-ml/resources.html#DomainAdapt} for
facilitating further research. | [
0.0455252677,
0.0446577333,
-0.0134201366,
0.0486758538,
-0.0189843662,
0.0285928808,
0.0271875914,
-0.0125254923,
-0.0036526716,
-0.0193849728,
-0.038946934,
-0.0266566109,
-0.0265315417,
0.0009745774,
0.026178509,
-0.0273434445,
0.0204144493,
-0.0022751444,
-0.0312103685,
-0.0108603109,
-0.0023919817,
0.0175660308,
0.0008372547,
0.0173827037,
0.0174608137,
0.0115139242,
0.0201827977,
0.0440086164,
0.0344805941,
-0.0072358875,
0.0447223373,
0.0300751589,
-0.0041075866,
0.0681235045,
0.0000020191,
-0.083496809,
-0.0274687614,
0.0115981624,
-0.0217576399,
-0.0326486938,
0.0128074363,
-0.0196723901,
0.0189342462,
0.0532299988,
-0.0507656932,
-0.0181616247,
0.0474875271,
0.0094740754,
0.0697523728,
0.0904735029,
-0.0097112302,
-0.0165983401,
-0.0234410111,
-0.0394232422,
-0.0150994696,
-0.0658536255,
0.0029192474,
-0.0011246827,
-0.0274625123,
0.0101663396,
0.0085826283,
0.0464545153,
0.0263300184,
-0.0448601879,
0.0013379231,
-0.0161357895,
-0.0126497084,
-0.0218239594,
-0.0100918617,
0.0928415656,
-0.0191932861,
-0.0134464651,
-0.0051083202,
0.009770452,
0.0358791165,
0.0155345509,
-0.0488169529,
-0.0005119764,
0.0200564377,
-0.0298116896,
0.0062074568,
0.0125752594,
0.0158308465,
-0.0163413715,
-0.0347009376,
0.0174790006,
0.0226189625,
-0.0247301776,
0.0063887513,
0.0239027068,
-0.0351553932,
-0.0072443062,
0.0779034793,
0.0226431917,
-0.0191619731,
0.0243212823,
-0.0235297885,
-0.075539276,
-0.0034140756,
-0.0655414611,
0.010144515,
0.029318057,
-0.0223642513,
0.0611559153,
-0.0351823233,
0.026064761,
-0.0271774586,
0.0282967631,
-0.064243108,
-0.0468160287,
-0.0192692,
0.0171209164,
-0.0375852287,
0.0299404114,
-0.0657122806,
0.0312970243,
-0.0142832166,
0.0276239868,
0.0184789151,
0.0108368574,
0.0486789569,
-0.0060685994,
-0.0581645817,
-0.0147514176,
-0.0171899386,
0.0572725944,
-0.0416680612,
-0.0050396957,
0.0103914188,
-0.0499970168,
-0.0236563887,
0.0276395176,
0.0193554293,
-0.0460497551,
0.0096396012,
0.0615701862,
-0.0000519866,
-0.022227535,
-0.0123696849,
0.0070522614,
-0.0175429769,
-0.0220954809,
0.0203420781,
-0.0510946326,
0.0568194464,
-0.0012227163,
0.0225405768,
-0.031932205,
0.0054887459,
0.0198221877,
0.0058501363,
0.0606431924,
-0.0211395286,
-0.0111015309,
0.0837435424,
-0.0024784615,
0.0093151173,
0.0568884462,
0.0350627452,
-0.0088918917,
0.0268810708,
-0.0152043458,
-0.0176303722,
0.0425987728,
0.0278685652,
0.0072312201,
0.0207766891,
0.0681627914,
0.0036285885,
0.0335712433,
0.0231806617,
0.034593489,
-0.0015590223,
0.0000603619,
0.0407176167,
0.0125265019,
-0.0169052389,
0.0139164915,
0.0120620886,
0.0050934302,
-0.0144302603,
-0.0179239921,
-0.0203974079,
0.0174438618,
-0.0230429806,
-0.0191375092,
0.0230048653,
0.0247582626,
-0.0388492532,
-0.0479672812,
0.0015588448,
-0.0161515716,
0.0116683245,
0.0146486508,
0.0381151885,
0.0360474922,
-0.024863461,
0.0414470807,
0.0034887448,
-0.0239218418,
0.0450334176,
-0.0228365585,
-0.010620431,
-0.014337441,
0.0380724296,
-0.0325014032,
-0.0483213514,
-0.0612379909,
-0.0063437615,
0.0965235531,
0.04421461,
-0.0108898217,
0.013400685,
-0.0511898659,
-0.0125799775,
0.0132939722,
0.0010495839,
0.0249247607,
-0.0006686738,
0.0110566448,
0.0324441828,
-0.0508757383,
-0.0589062348,
0.0201420169,
-0.0299648922,
-0.0419318676,
0.0552847609,
0.0072226212,
0.0099377604,
0.0385085344,
-0.0030083458,
-0.021535119,
0.0128740119,
-0.0471635088,
-0.0442810468,
0.0032210534,
-0.0428342856,
-0.0672684684,
0.0442313738,
-0.0578380972,
-0.0288279932,
0.0809751451,
-0.0579888411,
-0.045032654,
-0.0072923782,
-0.0385711156,
-0.024682492,
-0.0389178507,
0.0105225202,
0.0000978981,
-0.0146885421,
-0.0649893731,
0.0396972708,
-0.0006778616,
0.0224677939,
0.0050704181,
-0.0230269898,
0.0435574688,
-0.0168996695,
-0.0013712905,
0.0080953892,
-0.0228317641,
0.0334635489,
0.0461963788,
0.0432237685,
-0.0510665849,
-0.0044115321,
-0.0567898005,
0.0250134468,
-0.0421353169,
0.0534935519,
0.0727408156,
0.0697919205,
-0.0087335417,
-0.0325697288,
-0.0670485646,
-0.0045174761,
-0.0120993983,
-0.0057684481,
0.049870871,
0.0082592806,
0.043527469,
-0.0151644722,
-0.0073435833,
-0.0054983101,
0.011275026,
0.0229867958,
-0.0283328947,
-0.0804094523,
0.0471007377,
-0.0188066252,
0.0182559378,
0.0133379623,
-0.0487483107,
-0.0256751347,
-0.0218917001,
0.0509409942,
0.0357819945,
0.001532599,
-0.0301144402,
-0.0104675842,
0.0396441594,
-0.0628862008,
0.0257836934,
-0.0482956767,
-0.0489669666,
-0.0439201333,
-0.0436195359,
0.0559959747,
0.018312186,
-0.0005173869,
-0.0195602793,
-0.0749948919,
0.0193337258,
-0.0471341312,
-0.0205528121,
-0.0563827008,
0.0563816242,
0.0057552387,
0.0379082896,
-0.0048377817,
0.0092953593,
0.0699636266,
0.0063071107,
-0.0065007419,
-0.1074384004,
0.0097336508,
-0.0551631115,
-0.0151579464,
-0.0242976043,
0.040480867,
-0.0014991005,
-0.0661422238,
-0.0419799015,
0.0085632754,
0.0043667685,
-0.0133540314,
0.0006986223,
-0.0478313193,
-0.011339834,
-0.0087960325,
-0.0469965376,
-0.0316536129,
-0.0116140265,
0.0156639684,
-0.0133517077,
0.0095206089,
-0.0111707821,
-0.0242561605,
-0.0109029729,
0.01918591,
0.0778327957,
-0.0219821427,
-0.0088836662,
-0.0229206905,
0.0849562585,
0.0521347411,
0.0642316192,
0.0424241722,
-0.0445446633,
0.0059463647,
0.0156972315,
0.0316002965,
-0.0071530915,
0.0217373148,
-0.0318099447,
0.050395038,
-0.0201033056,
0.0036942894,
-0.0057384525,
0.0834594071,
-0.0131167928,
-0.0542277358,
0.1166757196,
0.0300404504,
-0.0377969779,
-0.0295570008,
-0.0576478206,
0.0331778489,
0.0303772558,
0.0506910123,
-0.0743484125,
-0.0130394753,
-0.0176412817,
0.0715234056,
0.0340069868,
0.0070065442,
0.0047780438,
-0.1229946613,
0.005574734,
0.0006392144,
-0.0315675214,
-0.0324111693,
-0.0304407701,
0.0016917079,
-0.0199740455,
0.0364567898,
-0.0150731849,
0.0387916453,
-0.0108495438,
0.0388692319,
0.0195225365,
-0.0586014614,
-0.0234729201,
-0.0548141375,
0.0459297337,
0.069652386,
0.0203690939,
-0.0254034903,
-0.0020723129,
0.0344256908,
-0.0483237728,
-0.0147071583,
-0.0211362951,
0.029373765,
0.0194729958,
-0.0274629295,
0.0123177692,
0.0313514471,
-0.0491869748,
0.0683650672,
0.0518883839,
0.0530117378,
0.0071910196,
0.0118822297,
0.0228874087,
-0.0314150378,
0.0072010383,
0.0497383587,
0.0236147437,
-0.0605829842,
0.0370634571,
-0.0189068485,
-0.0306084566,
-0.0567830391,
-0.0049026129,
0.0252366979,
-0.012140899,
-0.0227249544,
-0.1059138477,
-0.0801659673,
0.0317741111,
0.0336000286,
0.0212736819,
-0.0232597347,
0.0263549797,
-0.0126191974,
-0.0213218313,
0.0419986248,
-0.0663236901,
-0.0014784571,
-0.0593560264,
0.0272440258,
0.0082633989,
-0.0371513367,
-0.0097231986,
-0.0031351051,
-0.0838229656,
-0.0537919849,
-0.0180236734,
0.0817972496,
0.0148964133,
0.0286851395,
-0.0715116784,
-0.0535926335,
-0.0013242821,
0.0170470439,
-0.0208061356,
-0.0138585977,
0.018665662,
0.0016214038,
-0.0195436329,
0.0428392403,
-0.0306759514,
-0.002915598,
0.0239458084,
0.0557842664,
-0.0098240459,
-0.0321755446,
0.0586118512,
0.0322532542,
0.0254613664,
0.0119203357,
-0.0252558645,
-0.0433621146,
0.0334603339,
-0.0084112985,
-0.0132857915,
-0.0209279209,
-0.010144229,
0.0582376868,
-0.0174234752,
0.0007573667,
-0.0032773779,
-0.0420890227,
0.003739994,
-0.0604965538,
-0.0076077296,
-0.0003272418,
0.0312677063,
0.0032183232,
0.003226734,
-0.0224075373,
0.0270477366,
0.0359753035,
0.0568388551,
-0.0138816545,
0.0545459092,
0.0222915486,
-0.0016836185,
0.0510523245,
0.025729185,
-0.014085548,
-0.0173873492,
-0.0228487216,
0.012169471,
0.0537081137,
0.02527586,
0.091278635,
0.0139386235,
-0.0122195426,
-0.0085757738,
0.019011097,
0.0335720517,
-0.0073907729,
0.0418204367,
-0.0148432748,
0.0096006952,
0.0013899201,
0.0513084568,
-0.0265996698,
0.0152515741,
0.0110471332,
0.0280652065,
-0.0646977797,
0.0145115294,
0.0062290267,
0.0082071358,
-0.0268791411,
0.0131833404,
-0.0061851121,
-0.0583567061,
-0.0040353481,
0.0057174917,
0.0068007186,
-0.0094325477,
0.0248169936,
0.0479584895,
-0.0432985127,
-0.0206934866,
-0.0423335508,
0.0393909961,
-0.0185857136,
-0.0266265348,
-0.0268501453,
-6.663696743e-33,
-0.0235360358,
0.0041042059,
-0.0032956144,
-0.0331611335,
0.0127740605,
-0.0407810137,
-0.0347200818,
-0.0212791581,
-0.045725219,
-0.0166167822,
-0.0117332591,
0.0313164927,
0.0176460687,
0.0314657427,
-0.0232731048,
-0.0555561259,
0.0401057899,
0.0027487716,
-0.0286159366,
0.0376866274,
0.0038109252,
0.0344283096,
0.0786358193,
-0.0752407536,
0.0621614605,
-0.020582756,
-0.0071123717,
0.0654310435,
0.029476719,
0.0174162239,
0.0020400505,
0.0366648957,
0.0263606105,
-0.0314052068,
0.0016382156,
-0.0028770971,
-0.0985974148,
-0.0205875821,
0.0088098748,
0.0424819626,
-0.0288947131,
-0.0440278128,
0.0458605886,
-0.0300158579,
0.0288197212,
0.0039058789,
0.0279765166,
-0.0339200422,
0.0258994941,
-0.0361428112,
-0.0304867048,
0.0129805477,
-0.0103956694,
-0.0189565308,
-0.0378635488,
0.1089012623,
-0.0198061801,
-0.0094893975,
-0.0787406117,
-0.0186191257,
-0.0057749492,
0.0419846736,
0.0593281165,
0.0119779473,
-0.0349027701,
-0.021563638,
0.0110890875,
0.0187508017,
0.0524630211,
-0.0013039733,
0.0218136162,
-0.0440105125,
0.0845150799,
0.0442297161,
0.0305609964,
0.0012211401,
-0.0859132111,
0.0642621294,
-0.0118888756,
-0.0096639208,
-0.0080664046,
-0.004445279,
-0.0255838372,
-0.0029620079,
-0.0403745435,
0.0240111593,
-0.0439680219,
-0.008142041,
0.0351190455,
-0.0278767124,
-0.0571177006,
-0.0174264405,
0.0242158249,
-0.0145598343,
0.0297323931,
-0.0188089125,
0.0362907238,
-0.0027225425,
-0.0011697913,
0.0656169578,
-0.0159278102,
0.0033507731,
-0.0051818117,
0.0224365294,
-0.0014625633,
0.016471602,
0.0283846352,
0.0038262238,
-0.0532862581,
-0.0014077871,
-0.0387469232,
0.036407534,
-0.019647425,
0.0599511564,
-0.0061554429,
0.0035989329,
0.0046235989,
0.0231746379,
0.0520570688,
-0.0133752199,
-0.0246926881,
0.0340972915,
0.0174528304,
0.0168185867,
-0.0515379235,
-0.0197831877,
-0.0146423159,
0.0575375482,
0.0146681154,
-0.0830163583,
-0.0202228129,
-0.0399845988,
2.831e-7,
0.0648717657,
0.0683727339,
-0.0064424672,
0.0187828559,
-0.0155010382,
0.0259326659,
-0.001502495,
0.0573232546,
0.0554104634,
0.018783249,
-0.0025398002,
-0.0156933907,
0.0670087859,
0.0026800367,
-0.1197373942,
-0.0766462758,
0.0008756657,
0.0375022739,
-0.0216217507,
0.0404076613,
0.0436863825,
0.0744873509,
0.0094199143,
0.0040127276,
-0.0261502173,
-0.0544287413,
0.0433046855,
0.005175862,
-0.0391539484,
0.0106453793,
0.0287985243,
0.0313401744,
-0.0116304923,
-0.0061616316,
-0.0282101743,
0.0406203531,
0.0282958392,
0.0552551076,
0.0118884761,
-0.019930426,
-0.0021444608,
-0.0141545208,
0.0170543585,
-0.046365533,
0.0403796919,
-0.0620419569,
-0.0258573759,
0.0240470357,
-0.0148101831,
-0.0215622634,
0.0233586151,
-0.0473720506,
-0.0484864861,
-0.0038726905,
0.0557922088,
-0.004824392,
-0.0089226607,
-0.0416129865,
-0.0217978507,
-0.0270888414,
-0.0173174143,
-0.0480120666,
-0.0090456214,
0.0122091146,
-0.0425429717,
-0.0407472998,
0.0375432968,
2.54890292e-34,
0.0443060435,
0.0014791398,
-0.0011295794,
0.0010404775,
0.0306143202,
-0.0231158007,
-0.0008625219,
-0.0153980786,
0.0292074624,
-0.0804631859,
-0.0150266299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15258v1 | Breaking the Language Barrier: Improving Cross-Lingual Reasoning with Structured Self-Attention | 2023-10-23T18:06:38 | 2023-10-23T18:06:38 | Negar Foroutan, Mohammadreza Banaei, Karl Aberer, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we study whether multilingual language models (MultiLMs) can
transfer logical reasoning abilities to other languages when they are
fine-tuned for reasoning in a different language. We evaluate the cross-lingual
reasoning abilities of MultiLMs in two schemes: (1) where the language of the
context and the question remain the same in the new languages that are tested
(i.e., the reasoning is still monolingual, but the model must transfer the
learned reasoning ability across languages), and (2) where the language of the
context and the question is different (which we term code-switched reasoning).
On two logical reasoning datasets, RuleTaker and LeapOfThought, we demonstrate
that although MultiLMs can transfer reasoning ability across languages in a
monolingual setting, they struggle to transfer reasoning abilities in a
code-switched setting. Following this observation, we propose a novel attention
mechanism that uses a dedicated set of parameters to encourage cross-lingual
attention in code-switched sequences, which improves the reasoning performance
by up to 14% and 4% on the RuleTaker and LeapOfThought datasets, respectively. | [
-0.0232120641,
0.0177132878,
-0.0266136266,
0.0573902763,
-0.065377757,
0.0135859344,
0.0545937046,
-0.0319485813,
0.0422834307,
-0.038508568,
-0.0289159883,
0.0029646156,
-0.0281034727,
0.0183980949,
0.0433557145,
-0.0163511131,
0.0761616677,
-0.0727568343,
0.022957541,
-0.0221789386,
-0.0139907459,
-0.0140213007,
0.0307675023,
0.0000968794,
0.0028653536,
-0.0369428471,
-0.0108538093,
-0.009673899,
0.0175528023,
-0.0174357649,
-0.0090873474,
0.0404465944,
0.01075524,
0.0123407738,
0.0000020499,
-0.0439887531,
0.0027370923,
-0.0388955623,
0.0032256567,
-0.0192813631,
-0.0364056751,
-0.0190831535,
0.0028997408,
-0.0049637719,
-0.0374022759,
0.0028339401,
0.0272083301,
0.0150554664,
0.051749438,
0.0689030811,
0.0012143576,
-0.0300382022,
0.0025637201,
-0.0482164249,
0.0360850953,
-0.0473414585,
0.0091569424,
0.0507776216,
0.00925186,
0.0042454405,
-0.0297877435,
0.0506871976,
0.0641303435,
0.0105658062,
-0.0320685841,
0.0270631034,
-0.0460398905,
0.0048847562,
-0.0012530874,
0.0605491176,
-0.076120764,
-0.0501700938,
-0.027534185,
-0.0043230834,
0.0173697844,
-0.0353992246,
-0.0426429212,
0.0384612903,
-0.0001678518,
0.0052357707,
0.0752374157,
-0.0057913326,
0.0287353694,
-0.0255577117,
-0.0738132223,
0.1399776042,
-0.0090286825,
-0.0351625569,
0.0126457745,
-0.0144891981,
0.033531446,
-0.0541445389,
0.0035086682,
0.0297516566,
0.0103723342,
0.0259274282,
-0.025349509,
-0.011555383,
0.0038381629,
-0.0406178162,
0.0103258695,
0.042969577,
-0.0329098888,
0.0893112794,
-0.0663066879,
0.0352988504,
-0.0242730752,
0.0711483285,
-0.020881597,
-0.0244874395,
-0.0259048138,
-0.0012944385,
-0.0494857393,
0.0037873492,
-0.0127175953,
0.0003553659,
-0.0057786675,
0.026120102,
-0.0145396236,
-0.0007859576,
-0.0027433843,
-0.0515142754,
0.0014546731,
-0.0525522158,
-0.0063509666,
0.0250240956,
-0.0619892105,
-0.017681852,
0.0201461408,
-0.0489692837,
-0.0366663001,
0.0075024851,
-0.0228801761,
-0.0402704626,
0.0069580129,
0.0758509412,
-0.0079258271,
0.0031543248,
-0.0493578389,
-0.0137853334,
0.001689148,
-0.0720493346,
0.0346397199,
-0.0719915628,
0.02853713,
0.0014190495,
-0.0082913078,
-0.0515688099,
0.0148866456,
0.0178269222,
-0.0100152744,
0.0632156357,
0.0267161373,
0.0090819737,
-0.0200441144,
-0.0223994851,
-0.0449372493,
0.0909843221,
0.0147061264,
-0.0311531425,
0.0319158584,
-0.0473355725,
-0.0167226009,
0.0131942285,
0.0390111282,
-0.014691731,
-0.0213402957,
0.0258548111,
0.0112115918,
-0.0007542379,
0.0175928306,
0.0093370127,
-0.0153768901,
-0.0252518635,
0.0148347057,
0.0358145535,
0.045956742,
0.0273064431,
0.0360545218,
-0.0480989926,
-0.0319873989,
0.027643051,
-0.078291811,
0.0905637294,
0.0083869742,
0.0163043849,
0.0023064106,
0.0381487533,
-0.0411098674,
-0.0578821935,
0.0076904902,
0.0010711643,
0.0426468663,
0.0468358435,
0.0569835827,
0.0135010378,
-0.0064588753,
0.0452810302,
0.037806496,
-0.0565656908,
0.0010915926,
-0.0299478602,
0.0236391574,
0.0338909142,
-0.0195121076,
-0.0207660757,
-0.0234470125,
-0.0146504436,
0.0446969904,
0.0117768757,
0.0486892723,
0.0290721543,
0.0046599195,
-0.0351638198,
-0.0036367909,
-0.0544966273,
-0.0194872692,
0.0498137325,
-0.0182865467,
0.0324614756,
-0.0094373487,
-0.0188867059,
0.0106901936,
0.0143907182,
-0.053046409,
0.0113120284,
-0.0061967461,
0.0204725545,
0.0035872404,
-0.0004451826,
0.0338680483,
0.0374945514,
0.0184661578,
-0.0521043427,
-0.0312162545,
0.0218046177,
-0.0584553257,
-0.0535831191,
0.0294013638,
-0.047990296,
-0.0384227559,
0.004242375,
-0.0055192341,
-0.0340229049,
0.0485846289,
-0.0182882883,
0.0091778841,
-0.0310783386,
0.0211514235,
0.0349496379,
0.0289333854,
-0.0096501121,
0.0766910091,
-0.0057578934,
0.0292146485,
0.007988384,
-0.0002641357,
0.0395281054,
-0.0387645438,
0.0239594504,
0.0406543091,
-0.026524622,
-0.0169702508,
-0.0060054921,
0.0203531254,
-0.0495352782,
0.0006979653,
-0.0282779038,
0.0015212867,
-0.0452667177,
0.0145841707,
0.0007378587,
0.0129613383,
0.0036267124,
-0.0336468406,
-0.0731532052,
-0.0101167466,
0.0007433127,
0.0309265424,
0.0229215026,
-0.0407133475,
0.0298423935,
-0.0053845281,
-0.0384165309,
-0.029883733,
0.0322973281,
-0.0119625283,
0.004276643,
-0.0648771152,
-0.015792001,
-0.052547805,
0.0099779051,
-0.0382019803,
-0.0164844729,
0.0013774122,
-0.0042831874,
0.0365604572,
0.123822853,
-0.0329770409,
-0.049498003,
0.0822621956,
-0.022346722,
-0.0484018363,
0.0745069906,
0.0255511776,
0.0275710821,
-0.014450416,
-0.0060389219,
-0.006696098,
0.0665093809,
-0.0259769633,
-0.0118380841,
-0.0841092095,
0.0130811809,
0.0103992932,
-0.0320743173,
-0.0077816844,
0.0207399949,
0.0088564996,
0.085236229,
-0.0294831786,
-0.0109431976,
0.1016615108,
0.0207767133,
-0.0298243184,
-0.0641074777,
0.0319834538,
-0.0495455265,
0.0449283272,
-0.0045081051,
0.0363115259,
0.0087449737,
-0.0129070664,
-0.0489798412,
-0.0057721017,
0.0221705381,
-0.0015186891,
0.0768996626,
-0.0201192312,
-0.0055118715,
-0.0175837763,
-0.0538245961,
-0.0228048209,
0.0303330906,
-0.030723175,
-0.0065029347,
-0.0125203487,
0.0098358644,
-0.0333667435,
0.0060782661,
0.0365092121,
0.0334564224,
-0.0032921603,
0.0148922326,
-0.0009924618,
-0.0127818212,
0.0041678539,
0.0058090058,
0.004215674,
-0.0204886682,
0.0337796733,
0.0293143038,
0.0150726922,
-0.0277792308,
0.0278777163,
0.0260604043,
0.0349711627,
-0.0129294414,
-0.0263298806,
-0.00143234,
0.0643228665,
-0.0831816345,
-0.0049466519,
0.0733825713,
0.0209067669,
0.0025681534,
-0.0051210602,
-0.0920036584,
0.0219722223,
0.046248544,
0.0466432609,
-0.0624290891,
-0.0442097411,
0.0143283913,
-0.032474041,
0.0442661829,
-0.0229942892,
-0.0025079029,
-0.0976004899,
0.0107107051,
0.020170575,
-0.0666694865,
-0.0505386032,
-0.0220211241,
-0.0140467072,
0.0158115234,
-0.0078829033,
0.0095256623,
0.0181959737,
-0.0215510577,
-0.0194732994,
0.0044727921,
0.0055366368,
0.0581047498,
-0.0223052464,
0.0136221359,
0.0404590927,
0.0258959159,
-0.0013894228,
-0.086066775,
0.0183514059,
-0.0056527047,
-0.0075891726,
-0.0124353832,
0.0187238436,
-0.005090273,
-0.0264366064,
0.0116525833,
0.0344744064,
-0.0297264494,
-0.023246659,
0.0386140123,
0.1078697369,
0.0249738321,
-0.0580903031,
-0.0122171668,
0.0195489023,
-0.0268862303,
0.0526463315,
0.0283470619,
-0.0302257929,
-0.0468526818,
-0.0556086823,
-0.0135326218,
-0.0601727478,
-0.0307210162,
0.0374117382,
0.0246143676,
-0.0539781675,
-0.0403798968,
-0.0759570152,
0.0433395877,
0.0275577996,
0.0069753705,
0.0060572792,
0.0187751669,
-0.0027002196,
-0.0057683969,
0.0169777144,
-0.0478903316,
0.0070792385,
-0.0380264819,
0.0146169625,
-0.0065836068,
-0.0289440695,
0.0037664811,
0.0091407765,
-0.0510747284,
-0.0598567724,
-0.0224689376,
0.0632617548,
0.0123387286,
0.0513426289,
-0.0213628411,
-0.0126187429,
-0.0339143798,
-0.0585292913,
-0.0189990271,
-0.0048525366,
0.0775790513,
-0.014974012,
0.0230617486,
0.070948042,
-0.0177376587,
0.0227648448,
0.0148863886,
0.046262417,
-0.0468644239,
-0.0003780296,
0.0181439873,
0.0001969059,
0.0235372111,
0.0328675807,
-0.003876488,
0.0023123953,
0.0554397777,
-0.0258848183,
-0.020922659,
-0.0024477958,
-0.0114919133,
-0.0013560549,
-0.0542451553,
0.0246936884,
0.0003867438,
0.0036943511,
-0.0476706736,
0.0024040414,
0.065681681,
0.035772562,
0.058675766,
0.0089797024,
-0.0247062761,
-0.012506892,
0.0023799012,
-0.0078961682,
0.0509519503,
-0.034272898,
0.0594747812,
0.0198175851,
-0.0069861156,
0.0023211709,
-0.0263746511,
-0.069813095,
-0.051728297,
0.085510157,
-0.050731454,
0.0620214902,
-0.0062643895,
0.0161449835,
0.0166539364,
-0.0224901978,
-0.0094397655,
0.0412645489,
0.0427597053,
-0.0400641151,
0.0150576271,
0.0168545153,
0.0038906278,
-0.0322385579,
0.0482862964,
-0.0288231671,
0.012765442,
0.0168391075,
0.0113186818,
-0.0331495292,
-0.0192463957,
-0.0135149704,
0.0008659184,
-0.0154229952,
0.0331177637,
-0.0501143038,
-0.0885992274,
0.0096835531,
0.0441502258,
0.011966398,
0.0072701066,
-0.0052836565,
0.0778356269,
0.006298048,
-0.0341640897,
-0.0334669016,
0.0419580489,
0.0323943086,
-0.0288705174,
-0.0145704607,
-5.726562157e-33,
0.002657698,
-0.0044611502,
0.0275874957,
-0.0096641276,
0.0241617523,
-0.0482738018,
-0.0622109249,
0.002934671,
-0.0574409328,
0.002301777,
-0.0233981609,
0.0178888403,
0.000282465,
0.0117018232,
0.0394459665,
-0.0337417163,
-0.006508511,
0.0202231426,
-0.0258252118,
0.0048637739,
0.0161755718,
0.0156116914,
0.0692158192,
-0.0046644891,
0.0276600812,
0.014999751,
0.0357843488,
0.0077341958,
-0.0715708807,
0.0443669483,
0.0274830349,
0.0022961106,
0.0317413807,
-0.0277515743,
-0.0251798984,
0.0215677898,
-0.0893379077,
-0.0542442948,
0.0435166471,
-0.0033592533,
-0.0354991145,
-0.0537712052,
0.0243897755,
-0.0028814874,
0.0435505994,
-0.0642433539,
0.0129026854,
-0.0223830342,
-0.0102500515,
0.0159689281,
-0.0512149036,
0.0172827654,
-0.0311198831,
-0.0115078315,
0.0409969687,
0.0774566159,
-0.0024467083,
0.0158758648,
-0.0451790281,
0.0384369716,
-0.011174242,
0.0069119949,
0.0825112462,
-0.0130760232,
-0.0083999662,
0.0082585802,
0.0464748107,
0.0083740447,
-0.0075552207,
-0.0056501734,
0.0325922631,
0.0393009037,
0.0617674999,
0.0203106441,
0.0079737809,
0.0029926302,
-0.097365357,
-0.0453492925,
-0.0085232425,
0.04590296,
0.0157105289,
0.0034664955,
-0.0347026885,
-0.0031132142,
-0.0262439586,
-0.0096229827,
-0.0470765084,
-0.0461077206,
0.0344496779,
-0.0339965634,
0.0094045075,
-0.0086272731,
0.0537313186,
-0.0158333462,
-0.0194969848,
0.0401873253,
0.0287011545,
-0.0160176195,
0.0063115247,
0.0724973679,
-0.0517377667,
0.0225863755,
-0.0186327491,
0.0068758274,
0.0249231756,
0.0142701846,
0.0744544342,
0.0048752162,
-0.0649807304,
-0.0407845154,
-0.0532272235,
0.015907608,
0.0121526737,
0.0494989343,
0.0525971539,
0.0285329148,
-0.0046626562,
0.0385257788,
0.0102989553,
-0.0586499795,
-0.0790590271,
0.0117551414,
-0.0090301838,
0.0510704592,
-0.0115799904,
-0.0026056629,
-0.0770353228,
0.0397914015,
0.0139234224,
-0.0316705108,
-0.0202339981,
0.0774012506,
2.635e-7,
0.0252109561,
0.0226014871,
-0.0278590973,
0.0465991572,
0.0127308462,
0.0314908586,
-0.0730325952,
0.0009246403,
0.0428212322,
-0.0208183732,
-0.0443249382,
0.0635419637,
0.0310941506,
0.0209231339,
-0.0760575756,
-0.0119664269,
0.0136754541,
0.0007296734,
-0.0079002799,
-0.0166949239,
0.0503294356,
0.0864081085,
0.0009255875,
0.0303425528,
0.0275138952,
-0.0189619213,
0.0348576382,
-0.0107218334,
-0.0140297003,
-0.0200022142,
-0.0167408809,
-0.0079690386,
-0.0113758836,
0.0451818779,
-0.0063358145,
0.0078548416,
-0.0012176033,
0.0631820858,
-0.0090635819,
-0.0135914739,
-0.0346419849,
-0.0127203828,
-0.021841649,
-0.0775054917,
0.0976901948,
-0.0359975398,
-0.022627309,
0.0126189319,
0.0013837136,
0.0234331246,
0.0415660404,
-0.0020372148,
-0.0449596047,
0.0031410905,
0.0307430755,
-0.0147247659,
0.0337431468,
-0.063239567,
-0.0394012481,
0.0083558764,
-0.0080619939,
0.0119086523,
-0.0504382849,
-0.0031432975,
0.0258366261,
-0.0216503851,
0.0021093541,
2.156456325e-34,
0.0153923463,
-0.0158933122,
0.0061648088,
0.0073331809,
0.0230150204,
-0.0570310839,
-0.0141131505,
0.0018118022,
0.0250525009,
-0.0286796819,
-0.0251910333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15239v1 | CRoW: Benchmarking Commonsense Reasoning in Real-World Tasks | 2023-10-23T18:00:23 | 2023-10-23T18:00:23 | Mete Ismayilzada, Debjit Paul, Syrielle Montariol, Mor Geva, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent efforts in natural language processing (NLP) commonsense reasoning
research have yielded a considerable number of new datasets and benchmarks.
However, most of these datasets formulate commonsense reasoning challenges in
artificial scenarios that are not reflective of the tasks which real-world NLP
systems are designed to solve. In this work, we present CRoW, a
manually-curated, multi-task benchmark that evaluates the ability of models to
apply commonsense reasoning in the context of six real-world NLP tasks. CRoW is
constructed using a multi-stage data collection pipeline that rewrites examples
from existing datasets using commonsense-violating perturbations. We use CRoW
to study how NLP systems perform across different dimensions of commonsense
knowledge, such as physical, temporal, and social reasoning. We find a
significant performance gap when NLP systems are evaluated on CRoW compared to
humans, showcasing that commonsense reasoning is far from being solved in
real-world task settings. We make our dataset and leaderboard available to the
research community at https://github.com/mismayil/crow. | [
0.0303609576,
0.0891610757,
-0.004474422,
0.0355190374,
-0.0553116351,
0.0154256811,
0.0001520886,
0.0076670903,
0.0403700918,
-0.0240104776,
0.0309180841,
0.0266539734,
0.0124197332,
0.0046277889,
0.0088417083,
-0.0145016545,
0.044464983,
-0.0009454377,
-0.0432236381,
0.0192593578,
-0.0065373015,
0.021005448,
-0.0217220373,
0.0302526113,
-0.0189721845,
-0.0047364724,
0.0379028618,
-0.0186150838,
0.0465026647,
-0.0259957127,
-0.0154093243,
0.0275429934,
0.0404461175,
0.0433749221,
0.0000017938,
-0.0217701625,
0.0408811048,
0.0134809213,
-0.0155829862,
-0.0213076267,
0.0333929323,
-0.0346113481,
0.0145312371,
-0.0174209457,
-0.0572003424,
0.0379949063,
0.02160725,
0.0284790769,
0.0475036986,
0.0570120476,
-0.0085128937,
-0.0369507894,
-0.0270930491,
0.0024813777,
0.0215666797,
-0.0592943989,
0.0097143017,
0.0426855981,
0.017997928,
-0.034686055,
-0.0087939892,
0.0157756228,
0.0287641883,
0.0055525471,
-0.0367906615,
0.0444237366,
-0.0671216026,
0.0250658691,
-0.0227713026,
0.1139445379,
0.0202710964,
-0.0415699743,
0.0068018017,
0.0030137061,
-0.0035213637,
0.016288748,
-0.019341005,
-0.0254790168,
0.0051927492,
0.0336011499,
0.0167400688,
0.0119847693,
0.0302625466,
0.0659429953,
-0.0021358475,
0.0922756493,
-0.0252588298,
-0.0124581717,
-0.0070829825,
0.0104311518,
0.0064235772,
-0.0251675583,
0.0272679534,
0.0389083028,
-0.0340173133,
0.0095356684,
0.0060701119,
-0.0060116821,
0.0116831912,
-0.0461083911,
0.0216971226,
0.0368454754,
0.0027637095,
0.0776665583,
-0.011651298,
0.0225237478,
-0.0067469813,
0.0290715024,
-0.0071337027,
-0.0087837242,
-0.0938874036,
0.0091269901,
0.0126602417,
0.0008392913,
-0.0653676614,
-0.0105553819,
-0.0240887124,
-0.0375664346,
-0.0199954528,
0.0295262951,
0.0333860926,
0.0541301854,
-0.0528036729,
-0.020616008,
-0.0485259108,
0.0041839131,
-0.0763663203,
0.0490739495,
0.0215776097,
-0.0327226557,
-0.023101639,
-0.0303280614,
0.0233808123,
-0.0486911274,
0.0087237908,
0.0338456929,
-0.0017200642,
0.0063574645,
-0.0621315688,
-0.0150067993,
0.0137148928,
-0.0467844047,
-0.0227984805,
-0.0412616357,
0.0588798746,
0.0079689603,
-0.0286833812,
-0.0112295616,
0.0042537171,
0.007995802,
-0.0149336746,
0.110007301,
0.0217591226,
-0.0099301795,
-0.0060244752,
0.0258344114,
0.0187965613,
0.080890432,
0.0001519864,
-0.0328941718,
0.0505391955,
0.011687303,
0.0014441592,
-0.0111490693,
0.0178799126,
-0.0111558391,
-0.0127945496,
0.0254097842,
-0.039870698,
0.0513154157,
0.0349708982,
-0.0011236233,
-0.0210397616,
-0.0557613969,
0.0357455909,
0.0795856789,
-0.0443044975,
0.0089731133,
0.0230930876,
0.0082508959,
-0.0049212226,
-0.0089615714,
-0.0731048957,
0.016594829,
-0.0355963521,
-0.02850632,
-0.0377284773,
0.0201613829,
-0.0106760915,
-0.0010327263,
-0.0268725064,
0.0049226815,
0.0447443128,
-0.0234768987,
0.0396602228,
0.0051243268,
-0.012420224,
0.051544439,
0.0267123319,
-0.0414577052,
-0.0022364256,
0.0162477698,
-0.0298529863,
0.0433409885,
0.058098793,
-0.0370813422,
-0.0499664284,
0.007653703,
0.020587543,
0.0349328518,
0.0445264801,
-0.0259455722,
0.0369500779,
-0.0327186137,
-0.0055242148,
0.0228163581,
-0.0036375886,
-0.0160902496,
0.0494687781,
0.0272442047,
-0.0026566642,
-0.0612929724,
-0.0121278334,
0.0391357616,
-0.0223602317,
-0.0252140351,
-0.0224144515,
-0.0184106398,
0.0371802896,
-0.0167174265,
0.0056852521,
0.0001886433,
0.0189164318,
-0.0249492619,
-0.0184693653,
0.0667599589,
-0.018384438,
-0.0841588303,
0.0526700951,
-0.0339388251,
-0.0767122433,
0.0788640976,
-0.0486207679,
-0.0169420112,
0.0148847448,
-0.0083603598,
0.0220740661,
-0.043378938,
-0.0528463796,
-0.014345672,
0.0035310367,
0.0036148804,
0.1016254351,
-0.0394835398,
-0.0030169557,
-0.0222260561,
0.0008182253,
0.0081706867,
-0.027422281,
-0.0090747578,
-0.0067657474,
-0.0286742952,
-0.014608684,
-0.0173612256,
0.0036575149,
-0.0669633001,
0.0215317551,
-0.0705149844,
-0.0116854385,
0.0019688548,
-0.0056050261,
-0.0120135294,
-0.0330776572,
0.0004160678,
-0.0180054642,
-0.0103877494,
-0.0023318166,
0.0119253751,
0.032266032,
0.0602365062,
-0.0041089123,
0.0098888446,
-0.011385709,
-0.0118454983,
-0.0527777597,
0.0295839645,
0.0020767127,
0.0676287636,
0.0014009771,
-0.0098192012,
-0.0552353002,
0.0265406948,
0.0026199254,
-0.0377425328,
0.0169005543,
-0.0103596784,
0.010130289,
0.0712966323,
-0.0138292331,
0.0226581041,
0.0251142364,
-0.0298772082,
-0.0250500422,
0.0292643942,
-0.0330121927,
0.0365174711,
-0.0258168913,
0.0042972993,
-0.0334913172,
0.0167761296,
-0.0001767197,
0.0020718069,
-0.0430503562,
0.038866248,
-0.0215836633,
-0.0216460153,
-0.0498667248,
0.0429755226,
0.0010321394,
0.0597978309,
-0.046754092,
-0.0143024996,
0.0761241689,
0.0018947877,
0.0142095359,
-0.0499730445,
0.0234501548,
-0.0160492174,
0.0799708292,
-0.0305729806,
-0.0035199674,
-0.0104694478,
0.0058911354,
-0.0066492776,
-0.044848565,
0.0377067029,
-0.0217072237,
0.0183027275,
-0.0537189059,
0.0403173193,
-0.0113641955,
-0.0710184947,
-0.0103461985,
-0.0540829301,
-0.0194965675,
-0.0094800163,
-0.0087183928,
-0.0385572612,
-0.0369233191,
-0.0125208627,
0.0002164338,
0.0401620679,
0.0155581217,
-0.0279712863,
-0.0042500501,
0.0341585502,
0.0238886569,
0.0619451702,
0.0343044251,
0.0526365675,
-0.0120460773,
0.0417767093,
0.0845339522,
-0.0265212245,
-0.0177677441,
0.0643670708,
-0.0028872988,
-0.0110659115,
0.0364169516,
0.0161456652,
0.0734413937,
-0.0597008318,
-0.0357502475,
0.0620925948,
0.0493226945,
0.0313862972,
0.0364053696,
0.0008930077,
-0.0134678269,
0.0167813525,
0.0091752717,
-0.0531235412,
-0.0666171536,
0.0266629346,
-0.0044563855,
-0.0155337909,
-0.0946303159,
0.0102399737,
-0.1087053567,
0.0241125338,
-0.0101701962,
-0.0630044863,
-0.0373603404,
-0.084295541,
0.0028421942,
-0.0537151322,
-0.0256034546,
-0.0217660628,
0.0303745139,
-0.0113793015,
-0.0019638326,
-0.0082770558,
-0.0999840572,
0.0680024922,
-0.0406556949,
0.061657045,
0.0304832868,
0.0761175156,
0.0111177079,
-0.0895918533,
-0.0328625515,
-0.0455693528,
0.0133255385,
-0.0347312689,
0.0172147714,
0.0121079814,
-0.0237691328,
-0.0154544599,
0.0635496527,
-0.1017729789,
-0.0435166433,
-0.0132493563,
0.09634047,
-0.007245414,
-0.0015472568,
-0.0438031964,
0.0084693283,
0.0300568305,
0.0934698731,
0.0087238615,
0.047167033,
-0.0425504893,
-0.0208538231,
-0.0472373366,
-0.0597335771,
-0.0348512381,
-0.020207148,
0.0595801249,
0.0032627741,
-0.0544882938,
-0.0284382496,
0.0155618247,
0.052502092,
-0.0139452694,
0.0101513853,
0.028893128,
0.0251526292,
-0.0661233738,
0.0665717721,
-0.0293213557,
0.0060981908,
0.0172646418,
-0.0028503682,
0.0187177788,
0.0169402827,
-0.0390988104,
0.0533715338,
-0.0650218278,
-0.0502476878,
-0.0196876004,
0.0275666825,
0.0222559199,
0.0209632535,
-0.0473546088,
0.0161592364,
0.0237716697,
0.0558165684,
-0.0584904552,
-0.0056648953,
0.0379787646,
-0.0105768917,
0.023668563,
0.0696294457,
0.0125101516,
-0.0139892781,
0.0158324055,
0.0583396479,
-0.0489785969,
0.0375992693,
-0.0153204901,
-0.0009766463,
0.0196663998,
0.0078473268,
-0.0201475732,
-0.008568977,
-0.0252660103,
-0.025270313,
-0.0482973866,
-0.00258769,
0.0143751549,
0.0384212397,
0.0018342659,
-0.0388777964,
0.0504779294,
-0.0160085652,
0.0168757699,
-0.0382612348,
-0.0064013749,
0.0675229207,
0.0150043666,
0.0098749902,
-0.0256499704,
-0.0071085878,
-0.0184529833,
-0.0459222458,
0.0370012037,
-0.011447371,
0.0490612909,
0.0609637462,
-0.0135381687,
-0.0277098101,
-0.0182003472,
-0.0850341618,
0.0335259475,
0.0248768646,
0.0343532749,
0.0299190488,
-0.0481992252,
0.0020110505,
-0.0167715121,
-0.0154123371,
0.0142142382,
0.0287364013,
0.031937439,
-0.0064190906,
0.0205209926,
0.0199437831,
-0.0205802862,
0.0084790336,
0.0654889494,
-0.0551652983,
0.0390563495,
0.0404095575,
-0.0348390676,
-0.0220464803,
-0.0462411009,
0.0003516752,
0.0172396358,
0.0240110513,
0.0238063745,
-0.0855582505,
-0.0587853156,
0.0160999205,
0.0203948412,
0.0150519218,
0.0140590901,
-0.0004595414,
0.0761624724,
0.0281118322,
-0.042355381,
-0.0080224276,
-0.0006891097,
-0.0789496154,
-0.0028696486,
-0.0446090177,
-6.103188343e-33,
-0.0136161419,
-0.0328193679,
0.0148526281,
-0.0204962492,
0.0070911106,
0.014137879,
-0.0530258827,
-0.0434680656,
-0.0294714589,
0.0298523847,
-0.0379492715,
0.0516759679,
0.0057992088,
0.0115977637,
0.0182803404,
-0.0314684957,
0.0074230004,
-0.0012502272,
-0.0323881246,
-0.0199903138,
0.0761635602,
-0.0124543225,
0.0177892223,
-0.0233795214,
0.0130399521,
0.0248025134,
-0.0019504507,
0.0454932563,
-0.0492919534,
0.0394988917,
-0.0169795956,
0.0576033741,
0.0229117498,
-0.0405371562,
0.0118977064,
0.0135588851,
-0.0840989947,
-0.0684441924,
0.0142887365,
-0.0045081167,
-0.0285083391,
0.0250865296,
0.0100272652,
0.0274705123,
-0.0084281657,
-0.0071463967,
0.0123669757,
-0.0424070433,
0.0111501897,
-0.0126072951,
-0.0287901275,
0.0333306268,
-0.0379933156,
-0.0154403001,
-0.0080020269,
-0.0204286892,
-0.0087959515,
0.0022756734,
-0.061998859,
0.0018507356,
0.0009485435,
-0.0110862097,
0.0489222966,
-0.0513828285,
0.0216366742,
0.0527570769,
-0.0377575941,
0.0030237976,
-0.0757739544,
0.0361888856,
0.028580239,
0.0626891851,
0.052874364,
0.0732495859,
0.0444391072,
-0.0100434767,
-0.0515339747,
0.0443693772,
0.0106377611,
0.0503075868,
0.0091197146,
0.0221097246,
-0.0492596999,
0.0053630238,
-0.0397873335,
-0.0115948422,
-0.0247926023,
0.020631317,
0.0050027668,
-0.0077875322,
-0.0368520245,
0.0683812425,
-0.0023426262,
-0.0123052476,
-0.0026830132,
0.0553105623,
0.0180720836,
-0.050930474,
0.0326751247,
-0.0036229382,
-0.044709634,
-0.0080772936,
0.0350571759,
0.0260387566,
0.0293152351,
-0.013340814,
0.0441775322,
0.0027324778,
0.0017993761,
-0.0246599205,
-0.0302805882,
0.0182611905,
-0.019541759,
-0.0018481708,
0.0530028865,
0.0168262273,
0.0041317642,
0.0102557605,
0.0109737674,
0.0009821395,
-0.0130376853,
0.0499218181,
-0.0007683061,
0.0150275687,
-0.0014267595,
-0.006109349,
-0.0558170415,
-0.0690323636,
0.0226326175,
-0.0283414684,
-0.0003232272,
0.0499165207,
2.427e-7,
-0.0084775174,
0.0489706844,
0.0264938269,
0.0203237534,
0.0069537829,
0.0435270108,
-0.0307595395,
0.0158217363,
-0.0381021313,
-0.031677749,
-0.0125080701,
0.075459078,
0.0458691455,
0.0532896332,
-0.0228197686,
0.005371158,
-0.051724758,
-0.0210279003,
-0.064167358,
-0.0148845045,
0.0451515056,
0.0528474413,
0.0508905277,
-0.0266705249,
0.027373014,
-0.0712758824,
0.0122917164,
-0.032450892,
0.0149633763,
-0.0266142283,
-0.0073890821,
-0.0026099812,
0.0184217002,
0.0659438968,
-0.0308947284,
-0.0080236364,
-0.0066521848,
0.0539770052,
-0.0259667914,
-0.0374678448,
-0.0392571092,
-0.0562118851,
-0.0051898491,
-0.0449975766,
0.0946992785,
-0.0408704877,
-0.0356638841,
-0.0134682357,
0.0095310193,
0.0149694271,
0.0144140152,
0.0141750015,
-0.0055679544,
-0.0179870129,
0.0181934182,
-0.0113251125,
-0.0158953238,
-0.0838970467,
-0.0078500165,
0.0202618074,
-0.0009059349,
-0.0218250435,
-0.0386102535,
-0.0192405283,
0.0460629351,
-0.0676926672,
-0.0279179327,
2.109145892e-34,
-0.0171095878,
0.0248413235,
-0.000358046,
-0.0272011422,
0.0468358956,
0.0013432896,
-0.0317803696,
-0.0175329708,
0.0056222039,
-0.030021932,
0.0317831486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15166v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15166v1 | Large Language Models are Visual Reasoning Coordinators | 2023-10-23T17:59:31 | 2023-10-23T17:59:31 | Liangyu Chen, Bo Li, Sheng Shen, Jingkang Yang, Chunyuan Li, Kurt Keutzer, Trevor Darrell, Ziwei Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual reasoning requires multimodal perception and commonsense cognition of
the world. Recently, multiple vision-language models (VLMs) have been proposed
with excellent commonsense reasoning ability in various domains. However, how
to harness the collective power of these complementary VLMs is rarely explored.
Existing methods like ensemble still struggle to aggregate these models with
the desired higher-order communications. In this work, we propose Cola, a novel
paradigm that coordinates multiple VLMs for visual reasoning. Our key insight
is that a large language model (LLM) can efficiently coordinate multiple VLMs
by facilitating natural language communication that leverages their distinct
and complementary capabilities. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our
instruction tuning variant, Cola-FT, achieves state-of-the-art performance on
visual question answering (VQA), outside knowledge VQA, visual entailment, and
visual spatial reasoning tasks. Moreover, we show that our in-context learning
variant, Cola-Zero, exhibits competitive performance in zero and few-shot
settings, without finetuning. Through systematic ablation studies and
visualizations, we validate that a coordinator LLM indeed comprehends the
instruction prompts as well as the separate functionalities of VLMs; it then
coordinates them to enable impressive visual reasoning capabilities. | [
0.0453956947,
0.0334929153,
-0.0095313713,
0.047833398,
-0.0274139494,
0.0090975026,
0.0278734379,
-0.0084215887,
0.0245200247,
-0.0699105486,
-0.0253963228,
0.0040836749,
0.0071083433,
0.0156681351,
0.034279827,
-0.049163375,
0.027042022,
-0.0573414378,
-0.0106646959,
0.007879572,
0.022839224,
0.0245490391,
-0.0012101871,
0.041683279,
0.0016382294,
-0.0352442823,
-0.0049987035,
0.007756196,
0.015035768,
-0.000348637,
-0.0123078823,
0.0251546577,
0.0672743469,
-0.0242301505,
0.0000019954,
-0.0124832327,
0.0296924692,
-0.0082110893,
0.0229398329,
0.0001091673,
-0.0347986706,
-0.0274093095,
0.0404376797,
0.0061799712,
-0.0375290141,
0.0122529678,
0.0691503212,
0.0088483337,
0.0723188594,
0.0210468881,
-0.0067634583,
-0.0114078661,
-0.0047336812,
-0.012965994,
0.0089120865,
-0.0432010368,
0.0049719741,
0.0364265069,
0.0243625008,
0.0032433937,
-0.0768767819,
0.0479237102,
0.027345201,
-0.007204941,
-0.0047424543,
0.0493867435,
-0.040658161,
-0.0235172585,
-0.0416067429,
0.0694149584,
-0.0030347395,
-0.0155571187,
-0.0198565982,
0.029105911,
0.0210610889,
0.0145575767,
-0.0610232726,
0.0549638458,
-0.0205095746,
-0.0020798617,
-0.0334803946,
-0.0105999364,
0.0002515232,
0.0204355419,
-0.01414763,
0.0280709043,
-0.0054306015,
0.0254567824,
-0.0192985684,
0.0142594604,
-0.0657938719,
-0.0501039252,
-0.037905816,
0.0534879155,
-0.0289247129,
0.0101422239,
-0.0195560716,
-0.0095635308,
-0.0173406303,
-0.0163230598,
0.0929635614,
0.022978805,
-0.0356184281,
0.0956701711,
-0.0409585424,
0.0650739372,
-0.0173689499,
0.0603615902,
-0.0238117818,
-0.0289096721,
-0.0535462983,
-0.02383787,
-0.0347346142,
0.0097724637,
-0.0699278265,
-0.0634666905,
-0.0041765911,
0.0249597002,
-0.025510557,
0.0056462176,
-0.0010687234,
0.0313332267,
0.0027329547,
-0.0332230963,
-0.0439814441,
0.0664032698,
-0.0303094108,
0.0209593326,
-0.0092454543,
-0.0346763916,
-0.0204532631,
0.0416918173,
-0.0006184079,
-0.0143033992,
-0.0001914605,
0.0392206758,
-0.0487353578,
-0.0034188484,
-0.0058640274,
-0.0204106644,
-0.0129133435,
-0.0575551204,
0.0134676928,
-0.0707885846,
0.0235392991,
0.0180000067,
-0.0006326058,
-0.0201842058,
0.004854158,
0.0115005057,
-0.0289436989,
0.0894815847,
0.0120724877,
0.0173805319,
0.0070489324,
0.0226322226,
0.0047177789,
0.0777001157,
0.0152750909,
0.006418658,
0.0318451822,
0.0145876696,
0.0159495212,
0.028509004,
0.0041175149,
0.0031538121,
-0.0512494855,
0.0167960227,
0.007320221,
0.0219862685,
0.031181246,
0.0317195803,
-0.0403603911,
-0.0363698676,
0.0597296804,
0.0486785956,
0.0013364407,
-0.0472019874,
0.0260492079,
0.002244208,
-0.0047985143,
-0.0156493541,
-0.0574154034,
0.0752518624,
-0.0453224108,
-0.0124257738,
0.0113795474,
0.0195961222,
-0.0431563891,
-0.0285599139,
-0.0171276033,
0.0002975585,
0.0039962376,
0.052697856,
0.0367351137,
0.0102299694,
-0.038069468,
-0.0118420627,
0.0214724336,
-0.0309068821,
-0.0093092518,
-0.0184001457,
0.0493381284,
0.0683599636,
0.0444452949,
0.0230144113,
-0.0128070014,
0.0101923123,
0.0662991032,
0.0348686874,
0.00486557,
-0.0013283296,
0.0164612066,
-0.0495241769,
-0.0357326344,
-0.0355488434,
-0.0148878815,
0.0082379077,
0.0342170373,
-0.0284783859,
-0.0224782862,
-0.0212882739,
0.0188428108,
0.0083818622,
0.030580692,
0.0206454061,
-0.0631520599,
0.0238261204,
-0.019850919,
-0.0404898822,
-0.0053165643,
-0.0055318424,
0.0059814393,
-0.0464007892,
-0.00248531,
0.0154380528,
-0.0413101465,
-0.0565418825,
0.0162793156,
-0.0424147733,
-0.0223203078,
-0.0020108055,
-0.0422678813,
-0.0016165314,
0.0232738182,
-0.0086003533,
0.0035868245,
-0.0411330163,
-0.0353707224,
0.0246629268,
0.0003073905,
-0.0192451067,
0.0729179904,
-0.0372204036,
-0.0311673135,
0.0022762527,
0.0048674103,
0.0105454978,
-0.0121947415,
0.0157603621,
0.0127125951,
0.0145123163,
0.022010969,
-0.0211865194,
0.0144950226,
-0.0416946001,
-0.0230024122,
-0.1024350449,
-0.015858246,
-0.0180686843,
-0.0492096357,
-0.009205576,
-0.0134628993,
0.0152653949,
-0.0376008786,
-0.0285634194,
0.0418376178,
0.0178795569,
0.0269576479,
0.0301494971,
0.0041963435,
-0.0101202289,
0.0029916188,
-0.0048818802,
0.0080282986,
0.090925701,
0.0254761241,
-0.0087317247,
-0.0492636897,
-0.0182205159,
-0.0641549602,
0.0501092002,
-0.0190430153,
-0.01594216,
0.0212345626,
-0.0375092439,
0.0125855682,
0.1144148186,
-0.026344385,
0.0314695127,
0.0265803784,
-0.0033385118,
-0.0387923121,
0.0165002458,
0.0106820464,
-0.0466713794,
-0.0101758093,
0.0178850833,
-0.0508175939,
0.0102189705,
-0.0215350334,
-0.0109017743,
-0.0749375373,
0.051254645,
0.0348620266,
-0.0507329106,
-0.0989310965,
-0.0183723569,
0.0418489613,
0.050172396,
-0.0547324046,
-0.0637864321,
0.0591290258,
-0.0000085386,
-0.010204996,
0.0022905448,
0.002197369,
-0.0404737592,
0.0908271745,
0.0177156925,
0.0212759785,
-0.0275508538,
-0.0037263383,
-0.0595203675,
-0.0308523197,
0.030615449,
-0.0043541174,
0.0546735972,
-0.0915952697,
0.0238140244,
-0.0186138228,
-0.0552694425,
-0.0190978274,
-0.0145650879,
-0.0408342034,
0.0296259075,
-0.0584530495,
-0.0274633635,
-0.0446063988,
0.0384483151,
0.0457295999,
-0.0028911899,
-0.0060819308,
0.0002294282,
-0.0250055175,
0.0201218501,
0.053674344,
0.0520106331,
-0.0374023244,
-0.0546245165,
0.0022076727,
0.070172444,
0.0127002485,
-0.0224481858,
-0.0323027521,
0.0441226698,
0.0205391496,
0.0438386947,
-0.0090161664,
0.0233474933,
0.0702357367,
-0.0523073599,
-0.0185591076,
0.0727661327,
0.0334677026,
-0.0124702426,
-0.0281094927,
-0.0051639327,
0.0421073399,
0.0438260399,
0.036805369,
-0.0698515326,
-0.0605453886,
-0.0178942643,
-0.0184933804,
0.0296335779,
-0.0226421021,
-0.0296809934,
-0.0911679715,
0.053857211,
0.0062926658,
-0.0123060327,
-0.0332797393,
-0.0024565826,
-0.0033538335,
0.0239987802,
-0.0394550487,
0.002048461,
0.0135605233,
0.0068484335,
-0.0120012825,
0.0413248092,
-0.0100480188,
0.0479019172,
-0.0629376993,
-0.0172788277,
0.0526517704,
-0.0075692683,
0.0325849354,
-0.0828358978,
0.0021603901,
-0.0146477558,
0.0361320674,
-0.0210003667,
0.0277296789,
-0.0162914451,
-0.0464958064,
0.0142009947,
0.0418273918,
-0.0303185303,
-0.019633295,
-0.0151141798,
0.0650998801,
-0.0101793287,
-0.0100379158,
-0.0238842163,
0.0332567655,
-0.0125755779,
0.056061253,
0.0227752943,
-0.0308119617,
-0.0386364236,
-0.0267950688,
-0.0558739416,
-0.0454826653,
-0.0080465227,
0.0105476491,
0.0628948808,
0.0144933816,
-0.0555557124,
0.0212763157,
0.0836444795,
0.0658451468,
-0.0080802198,
0.0009830765,
-0.0288804155,
0.0345580615,
-0.0395761132,
0.0761458576,
-0.038077075,
0.0220524967,
-0.0356976502,
0.0028485544,
0.0017988896,
-0.0279103983,
-0.0341528393,
0.0355450846,
-0.0511699282,
-0.0479804203,
-0.0625006258,
0.0691309348,
0.0170984156,
0.0304223839,
0.0176354907,
-0.0495045595,
0.0152891185,
0.0646838322,
0.034287408,
0.056434311,
-0.0121455062,
-0.0302202422,
0.0170040447,
0.0353658535,
-0.0232502781,
0.0083498098,
0.0152388308,
0.0269733239,
-0.0149770398,
0.0104914382,
0.0051502199,
-0.0164552853,
-0.0027324243,
-0.0043354812,
0.0171034783,
-0.0140730441,
-0.0005608628,
0.0055320403,
-0.0263126288,
-0.0638624579,
0.0281278342,
0.0231546499,
-0.0333139598,
0.0270822681,
0.0297780316,
0.0474745966,
0.0196275767,
-0.0277036857,
0.0022281175,
0.0399313197,
-0.0109776603,
0.0149914604,
0.0162355676,
-0.0021919741,
0.0185610373,
-0.0476287119,
0.0394286215,
0.0035814869,
0.088998422,
0.0504261144,
-0.0221645813,
-0.037225388,
0.0311986879,
-0.0581492484,
-0.0657833219,
0.0305339862,
0.0698219389,
0.0521271303,
0.0333359353,
-0.0101903547,
-0.02267728,
-0.0275791902,
-0.0111113666,
0.037492618,
0.0169746485,
-0.0574658029,
0.074038811,
0.0437552854,
0.0094795432,
-0.0153032383,
0.0450334884,
-0.0127151255,
0.0081398273,
-0.0048739072,
-0.0083329156,
-0.0265794955,
-0.0263530686,
0.0260593835,
0.0197590049,
0.0347231589,
0.0768817067,
-0.0408078656,
-0.0336545147,
0.004614152,
0.0474799089,
-0.0112336297,
0.0104319323,
0.0302907191,
0.0461268798,
0.0304359347,
-0.0565635562,
-0.0109356986,
-0.0062020379,
-0.0330007859,
0.0064805765,
-0.0040305778,
-6.16649202e-33,
-0.037476439,
-0.0424766652,
0.0551891066,
-0.0257274248,
0.0261082705,
0.0024201316,
-0.0211868454,
0.0019431186,
-0.0369816385,
-0.0070683421,
0.0124622639,
0.0221419763,
-0.0153696705,
0.047251083,
-0.0070049497,
-0.007938249,
0.0116362553,
0.0098652476,
-0.0416537337,
0.0081018927,
0.0499439538,
-0.0137428325,
0.0203856267,
-0.0087164603,
-0.0433421209,
0.0174152236,
-0.019694766,
0.0476239249,
-0.0434355102,
0.0735177398,
-0.0027976641,
-0.0043105902,
0.0108614434,
0.0386229381,
-0.0224834047,
0.041545704,
-0.0753300264,
-0.019513743,
0.0597076416,
0.0033123479,
-0.1005972847,
0.0056374683,
0.0137481485,
-0.0104644829,
0.0148201957,
-0.0593725704,
0.0345493853,
-0.0281513985,
-0.0086500049,
0.0249759741,
0.0033370806,
-0.014776309,
-0.0166239683,
-0.0550502427,
-0.0078018052,
0.0214285236,
0.0099120429,
0.0515181608,
-0.0353569537,
0.0212133098,
-0.0129021145,
0.0105734328,
0.0959740356,
0.05446136,
0.0185493398,
0.0467686541,
-0.0224154964,
-0.0216809791,
-0.0742230341,
-0.0226788837,
-0.0021667874,
0.0761471465,
0.0498858057,
0.0378546678,
-0.016391702,
0.0382110365,
-0.0451052412,
-0.0048250128,
-0.0605016612,
0.0529098697,
0.0227965154,
0.0076871184,
-0.0063909343,
-0.0224851239,
-0.0586257242,
-0.0064611598,
-0.0472500585,
0.0245127771,
0.0733607858,
0.0194852762,
-0.0054565095,
0.0266070385,
0.0533974022,
-0.0572353303,
0.0028346614,
0.0523968488,
-0.0118469661,
0.0547701828,
0.0051724454,
0.0265458878,
-0.0376289412,
0.020653218,
0.0445901565,
-0.0004238702,
-0.0219180826,
0.0200688522,
0.0581115931,
-0.0029301196,
-0.0341444872,
-0.0079296725,
-0.0460694395,
0.011859403,
-0.0239851624,
0.0053518293,
0.0257356782,
0.0291349273,
-0.0492421985,
0.0130790016,
-0.0314018466,
-0.0546732806,
-0.0055667004,
-0.0316625871,
-0.0309146289,
0.018088093,
-0.0081802169,
0.0159727819,
-0.067885831,
-0.0414289311,
0.0014563485,
-0.0481545255,
-0.0120696789,
0.0732380971,
2.593e-7,
0.0161136463,
0.0170704592,
-0.0141094718,
0.0281980336,
0.024647411,
0.0350932218,
-0.0294058006,
0.0111033218,
0.0240420811,
-0.0564833283,
-0.0328171663,
0.1072488949,
0.0192051399,
-0.0221203323,
-0.0050811148,
0.0510901958,
-0.0046675499,
-0.0214554295,
-0.0686508417,
-0.0185384359,
0.0445498191,
0.0446477421,
0.0057628099,
-0.0115925279,
0.0480339713,
-0.0831473693,
0.0876728445,
-0.0214092545,
0.0117272967,
-0.0257587954,
-0.0175856147,
0.0103160832,
-0.0071632043,
0.0483898707,
0.0267052557,
-0.0092621222,
0.0103670824,
0.0413284227,
-0.0237945486,
-0.0184311271,
-0.0516902022,
0.0083649205,
-0.0370440781,
-0.0551541783,
0.0973418355,
-0.0659970269,
-0.0050555589,
0.0011104265,
0.0044910279,
-0.0141076557,
0.0200014785,
-0.0026669987,
-0.0336171947,
0.0114415633,
0.0259512067,
-0.0323962308,
-0.0014025179,
-0.0756966546,
-0.0053668232,
-0.0015789618,
-0.0178263821,
-0.0419500694,
-0.047776442,
-0.0031574471,
0.028235605,
-0.0309136212,
-0.0717843026,
2.147398131e-34,
0.0317972116,
-0.0157217756,
0.0181234684,
0.0016907142,
0.0340140499,
-0.0364971459,
-0.0474780388,
-0.009642804,
0.0346654989,
-0.0810679644,
-0.0099239107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15164v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15164v2 | LINC: A Neurosymbolic Approach for Logical Reasoning by Combining Language Models with First-Order Logic Provers | 2023-10-23T17:58:40 | 2024-02-14T18:56:03 | Theo X. Olausson, Alex Gu, Benjamin Lipkin, Cedegao E. Zhang, Armando Solar-Lezama, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Logical reasoning, i.e., deductively inferring the truth value of a
conclusion from a set of premises, is an important task for artificial
intelligence with wide potential impacts on science, mathematics, and society.
While many prompting-based strategies have been proposed to enable Large
Language Models (LLMs) to do such reasoning more effectively, they still appear
unsatisfactory, often failing in subtle and unpredictable ways. In this work,
we investigate the validity of instead reformulating such tasks as modular
neurosymbolic programming, which we call LINC: Logical Inference via
Neurosymbolic Computation. In LINC, the LLM acts as a semantic parser,
translating premises and conclusions from natural language to expressions in
first-order logic. These expressions are then offloaded to an external theorem
prover, which symbolically performs deductive inference. Leveraging this
approach, we observe significant performance gains on FOLIO and a balanced
subset of ProofWriter for three different models in nearly all experimental
conditions we evaluate. On ProofWriter, augmenting the comparatively small
open-source StarCoder+ (15.5B parameters) with LINC even outperforms GPT-3.5
and GPT-4 with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting by an absolute 38% and 10%,
respectively. When used with GPT-4, LINC scores 26% higher than CoT on
ProofWriter while performing comparatively on FOLIO. Further analysis reveals
that although both methods on average succeed roughly equally often on this
dataset, they exhibit distinct and complementary failure modes. We thus provide
promising evidence for how logical reasoning over natural language can be
tackled through jointly leveraging LLMs alongside symbolic provers. All
corresponding code is publicly available at https://github.com/benlipkin/linc | [
0.028178066,
0.0917686671,
0.0092068575,
0.0406771936,
-0.0531014539,
0.0285906438,
0.0175564121,
-0.0095689157,
0.0068530729,
-0.0075077862,
-0.008612209,
0.0251347069,
0.0209569186,
0.0513430238,
0.038816385,
-0.0083764261,
0.0465871356,
-0.049138993,
0.0281826146,
-0.0370828807,
-0.0399509221,
0.0032091588,
-0.015457876,
-0.0001875145,
-0.0321332701,
-0.0204950757,
-0.0001422492,
-0.0125424201,
-0.0043441658,
-0.0350551307,
-0.0337116383,
0.0345367752,
0.0418537259,
0.0530693792,
0.0000022023,
-0.0480156057,
0.0321821347,
0.0346429422,
-0.0375035852,
-0.0059451279,
0.0011209948,
-0.0281255208,
0.0235925503,
0.0123354122,
-0.0386479534,
-0.0071725301,
0.0367453098,
0.0447242856,
0.0380106084,
0.0559944734,
-0.0021873713,
-0.0533861034,
0.0580271892,
-0.0057017156,
0.0310427025,
0.0207653958,
0.0059512379,
-0.003386688,
0.0230676048,
-0.033534009,
-0.0128632234,
0.049753055,
0.0952786207,
-0.0065514152,
-0.0455223769,
0.0776744336,
-0.0571288131,
0.0137560209,
-0.0241582189,
0.0242970921,
-0.0001137049,
-0.0298311785,
-0.0191806499,
0.0334054828,
-0.0111919632,
-0.0044956938,
-0.0382924303,
0.0796024203,
-0.0168895498,
-0.0035142829,
0.0545315035,
-0.0399665944,
0.0468364283,
0.0025049178,
-0.0148598934,
0.1188533977,
0.0206796918,
-0.0462612621,
0.0369317867,
0.0235346053,
-0.0438958704,
-0.0662050247,
0.0275552962,
0.0383864865,
-0.0047872863,
0.004512372,
-0.0210091285,
-0.002021376,
-0.0095173744,
-0.0106984088,
0.0269805547,
0.074108474,
0.0203235783,
0.0260331053,
-0.0679988563,
0.0142313838,
-0.03926038,
0.0630537719,
0.0251123626,
0.0032657338,
-0.0411405936,
-0.0228890367,
0.0071770665,
0.0591926612,
0.0048121531,
-0.0054385527,
-0.010838842,
0.0270309243,
-0.0122334044,
0.0274589416,
-0.0292621516,
-0.0020810205,
0.0078891609,
-0.0145536223,
-0.0587160289,
-0.0064797592,
-0.0474403054,
0.0202431884,
0.0347650684,
-0.0528779216,
-0.0530486293,
0.0175036304,
-0.0297347605,
-0.0128638688,
0.0593283214,
0.0598733239,
0.0019319796,
-0.009569589,
-0.060742449,
-0.0367499441,
0.0072710831,
-0.0668370277,
0.0173320528,
-0.1012552604,
0.0379431807,
0.0355529115,
-0.0429781415,
-0.0451359898,
-0.0036092754,
0.0228570066,
0.0273386147,
0.066962637,
-0.0259222202,
-0.0169908218,
0.0287881047,
-0.0005610555,
-0.0593871176,
0.0115544591,
0.0469814613,
0.0272348411,
-0.0132269235,
0.0406685658,
0.003300085,
-0.015486246,
0.0137247676,
-0.0272795837,
-0.0509489514,
0.0123975575,
-0.0061533586,
0.0404768996,
0.0326311775,
0.0662938729,
-0.04087051,
-0.0359067209,
0.0437551215,
0.0615839548,
-0.0122744916,
0.0105213718,
0.0512057059,
-0.047904592,
0.0201329533,
-0.0199981201,
-0.1045427769,
0.083396256,
-0.0499944985,
-0.0039751837,
0.0182641447,
0.0381773151,
-0.0271874536,
-0.0649545193,
0.0168199185,
-0.0143289678,
-0.0074545285,
0.0236664899,
0.0421396531,
-0.0243737455,
0.0038798873,
0.035123229,
0.0232223067,
-0.0368853211,
-0.0122329276,
-0.0472044572,
0.0389697775,
-0.0039911023,
0.0410591438,
-0.0234159697,
-0.0097881751,
-0.0300448816,
-0.050846383,
0.0984358862,
0.0088643115,
-0.0027937442,
0.0220861267,
-0.0242153853,
0.0034974064,
-0.0550841279,
0.0010673803,
0.0187403411,
0.0240620505,
0.0280166138,
-0.0034573872,
0.0116855567,
-0.0097371461,
0.0570772327,
-0.0277816914,
-0.0096231243,
0.0222282317,
-0.0146916583,
0.0488021336,
-0.0296235401,
0.0037866121,
0.0296498295,
0.014018585,
-0.0397211686,
-0.0441467278,
-0.0199688375,
-0.0350108854,
-0.1141947284,
0.0431507975,
-0.0363778621,
-0.0353631638,
0.051449161,
-0.0497752689,
-0.0202138163,
0.054575339,
-0.0537032373,
-0.0189535543,
-0.0415820219,
-0.0145247709,
0.0218781177,
-0.0041962229,
0.0223547406,
0.062044777,
0.0026902542,
-0.0329095572,
0.0130581083,
0.0014874532,
0.0080396151,
-0.0583192594,
-0.0207846817,
0.0158554763,
-0.0139215095,
-0.0159996208,
-0.0035441602,
0.0107895061,
-0.0068904017,
-0.025633445,
-0.0715687722,
0.0138667049,
-0.003218086,
0.0136420876,
-0.011531854,
-0.0352202244,
0.0102292942,
0.0037614943,
-0.0254362673,
-0.0081910528,
0.0088723106,
0.0267005153,
0.0434801206,
-0.0128332842,
-0.0173724126,
0.0085960887,
-0.0272377692,
-0.058348,
0.0373217426,
0.0175199546,
0.011765114,
-0.0290563796,
-0.0001727294,
-0.0627005994,
0.0287305787,
0.0100260703,
0.0164699871,
0.0736836344,
0.0008102084,
0.0094753876,
0.1323058456,
-0.00764615,
-0.0266668182,
0.0564594008,
0.0015792745,
-0.0156342797,
0.0321312249,
-0.0170702636,
0.0534452759,
-0.0109965699,
-0.0238763541,
-0.0171593186,
0.0286762845,
0.0086713592,
-0.0055527491,
-0.0459889099,
0.0479540043,
0.0105548715,
-0.0277799945,
0.0060334071,
-0.0055763554,
-0.0005573476,
0.0535884909,
-0.0091734622,
-0.0534155108,
0.1093809679,
-0.0078296755,
-0.0132134827,
-0.0255897436,
-0.015379373,
-0.0650116131,
0.0666123033,
-0.0032643874,
-0.0110267624,
-0.0040562213,
0.0029940836,
-0.0293252785,
-0.0342314579,
-0.0005137267,
-0.0002663594,
0.0300591234,
-0.0530964211,
0.0130080283,
0.015035334,
-0.0666456819,
-0.0263272859,
0.0043479502,
-0.047658205,
0.0036103858,
-0.0359387361,
-0.022372907,
-0.014861499,
-0.0071424358,
0.047297705,
0.0393167771,
-0.0374503694,
-0.0273632985,
-0.0346303992,
-0.0190169103,
0.0015305204,
-0.0097344797,
0.0716376081,
-0.0242675096,
-0.0066728997,
0.0430989079,
-0.0393754244,
0.0278296992,
-0.0487627424,
0.0682407841,
-0.0139254062,
0.0056690462,
-0.0094923461,
0.0258410163,
0.0179791655,
-0.0634158924,
-0.0040323604,
0.1118301079,
-0.0051800194,
-0.026672814,
-0.0006214607,
-0.0434397683,
-0.0003578118,
0.0034796104,
0.0471175425,
-0.0687560588,
-0.0501522534,
0.0201669894,
0.01198796,
-0.0051375492,
-0.0355866514,
-0.0331144221,
-0.094372645,
0.0310034845,
-0.0091529973,
-0.0144460285,
-0.0022926291,
-0.0544651113,
-0.0002598411,
-0.0047873873,
-0.0520670041,
0.027085878,
0.0303261075,
0.0336696655,
-0.0332435332,
0.0013530105,
0.0103652366,
0.066910252,
-0.0422813855,
0.0304063912,
0.0096777529,
0.0007293421,
-0.023771083,
-0.0561956242,
0.0215461142,
0.021892136,
-0.0250669662,
-0.0417699404,
0.0115747759,
0.00434143,
0.0110004749,
-0.030276075,
0.0432855636,
-0.0383728817,
-0.0359746478,
0.0237293765,
0.076227352,
-0.010687572,
-0.0625060573,
-0.0297191683,
0.0403593928,
-0.0422385372,
0.0687863752,
0.0156425368,
-0.003776507,
-0.0581955202,
-0.046492558,
-0.0579882748,
-0.0158553217,
-0.0170205478,
-0.0087545617,
0.0774581656,
-0.030407358,
-0.0190689284,
-0.0302606672,
0.0345587507,
0.0180967022,
-0.0053154076,
-0.0107146911,
0.0281575229,
-0.0214947667,
-0.0330829434,
0.0396510363,
-0.0414914042,
0.0076279268,
-0.0510803498,
0.0274421033,
-0.006819115,
-0.0136987176,
-0.023922272,
0.0398386382,
-0.0429498814,
-0.0626995862,
-0.0466590226,
0.0470591486,
0.0262964256,
0.0278190672,
0.002429771,
-0.0160385072,
0.0056633665,
0.0837047473,
0.0044145528,
0.022126222,
0.0254090261,
0.0070958706,
0.022609869,
0.0050421818,
0.006786475,
0.0200458635,
0.0350149013,
0.0631180927,
0.0092660459,
0.0033491468,
0.0279434472,
0.0644548684,
0.0258646235,
0.0099361222,
-0.0119409338,
-0.0005578563,
-0.0243821982,
-0.031666901,
0.02107233,
-0.0341792516,
0.0176703725,
0.0047161551,
0.0363652445,
-0.0065871081,
-0.0406532809,
0.0245138891,
-0.0014946647,
0.0191082917,
-0.0282247104,
-0.0082299486,
0.0336120948,
0.0089709405,
-0.029443454,
-0.0252993312,
-0.0011895805,
-0.0239847191,
0.0492778346,
-0.0341199897,
0.0501278788,
0.0609897226,
0.0155914128,
-0.0382373743,
0.0105430931,
-0.0831308439,
-0.0357391015,
0.0399971232,
-0.0216753781,
0.0064510382,
0.0554230995,
-0.0142788365,
-0.0792240947,
0.0061875535,
0.013520699,
0.0197258797,
0.0182184745,
-0.0248189233,
0.0540280305,
0.0227165055,
-0.003165175,
-0.0740634501,
0.0273059867,
-0.0141225457,
0.0230209641,
0.0253409855,
0.0313005894,
-0.0281073172,
-0.049587056,
-0.0270829909,
-0.013509566,
-0.0139581105,
0.0032128072,
-0.0524124578,
-0.0584918745,
0.0483063646,
0.0422075689,
0.0096252831,
-0.0104007935,
0.0186246447,
0.0443754978,
0.019890178,
-0.0803126246,
0.045030959,
0.0307858139,
0.0197785627,
-0.0504881702,
-0.048703175,
-6.425696605e-33,
-0.0173717197,
-0.0275041368,
0.0629978999,
0.0340603553,
-0.0131867081,
-0.023850292,
-0.0703792423,
-0.0107468935,
-0.0116224512,
0.0200149696,
-0.0198659208,
0.062133681,
0.0022179577,
0.0184918549,
0.0234587248,
-0.0133864684,
-0.0121538006,
0.0022328857,
-0.0611920357,
0.0039179646,
0.0222948212,
-0.015636703,
0.0404452607,
-0.0335419104,
-0.0014025114,
0.0086665517,
0.0227653738,
0.0313618034,
-0.0966123864,
-0.0173973609,
-0.0354506262,
0.0260091443,
0.0175598208,
-0.0130240219,
0.0106608719,
0.0301755611,
-0.0308895595,
-0.0546795949,
0.0346433185,
-0.035758324,
-0.0589363761,
-0.0482887253,
0.0509970449,
0.0139806978,
-0.0186463073,
-0.0443538651,
0.0040523037,
-0.0190988015,
0.0029956235,
-0.0190074462,
-0.0300387349,
0.0072354227,
0.0104637407,
-0.0131847849,
-0.0101943845,
0.0116769355,
-0.0393008143,
0.0033014596,
-0.0507362112,
0.027168544,
-0.0038706118,
0.0055860719,
0.0537044331,
-0.0182187948,
0.0199418757,
0.0268474501,
0.0205683466,
-0.0059326552,
-0.0622818507,
0.0207116194,
0.0335042104,
0.0481918715,
0.0746179149,
-0.0084489938,
0.0543632917,
0.0347057879,
-0.0537282862,
-0.0078475522,
0.0435290895,
0.0412283503,
0.0489313193,
-0.0206420515,
-0.0043975324,
-0.0422130637,
-0.027060084,
-0.0178330429,
-0.029942153,
-0.0160016529,
0.0082938801,
-0.0206112638,
0.0145880627,
-0.0336998329,
0.0017762829,
-0.0209890939,
0.0252826754,
0.0172980316,
0.016891541,
0.0053623822,
0.014247762,
0.0321374424,
-0.0286930967,
0.014097278,
0.0031860273,
0.0106245996,
0.0432595275,
0.0193736255,
0.0248543639,
0.0559492074,
0.0022213946,
-0.0099258851,
-0.0464122295,
0.01329601,
0.0326561779,
-0.0015730319,
0.0119339358,
0.0490762182,
-0.0115376962,
-0.008513716,
-0.0208382457,
-0.0019291746,
-0.0540848523,
0.0520460755,
0.018096514,
0.0301406514,
-0.0122310985,
-0.0013272556,
-0.0639007092,
0.0051454501,
-0.0111240773,
-0.0886343718,
-0.0023518377,
0.0308942553,
3.027e-7,
0.0055417167,
0.030113183,
0.0290167276,
0.0684145018,
0.0303396564,
0.0298327841,
-0.0108053088,
-0.0231384598,
0.0425894447,
-0.0747346133,
-0.0317528434,
0.0843321681,
0.032169044,
0.0461258888,
-0.0352778845,
0.0169508699,
-0.0518854596,
-0.0340926982,
-0.0456515066,
0.0307908747,
0.0613634549,
0.0512411147,
0.0512622446,
-0.0427763015,
0.0204466805,
-0.0173107889,
0.0557330661,
0.0256256163,
0.0155270454,
-0.0386258215,
0.0002185188,
-0.0091411537,
0.0222348236,
0.0465833731,
0.021561034,
0.0007592863,
-0.0566708632,
0.0534380451,
0.0092002898,
0.0048536356,
-0.0148028769,
-0.03887707,
-0.0251169465,
-0.0485865921,
0.0656809956,
-0.0730517805,
-0.0589197427,
0.0064635216,
0.0044905329,
-0.0343134403,
0.0227261018,
-0.0162317809,
0.0020345082,
-0.0172644276,
0.0037078073,
0.0068462412,
0.0109082498,
-0.0514592305,
-0.0177711006,
0.0195588544,
-0.0494582541,
-0.0072169872,
-0.0481012352,
0.0107073691,
0.0441200621,
-0.0711235106,
-0.0366366953,
3.090686659e-34,
0.0264693461,
-0.0102492766,
0.0109722922,
0.00206769,
0.0600690618,
0.0073267855,
-0.0412598103,
-0.0102492105,
0.0278979782,
-0.0905448124,
-0.0601660311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15154v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15154v1 | Linear Representations of Sentiment in Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T17:55:31 | 2023-10-23T17:55:31 | Curt Tigges, Oskar John Hollinsworth, Atticus Geiger, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Sentiment is a pervasive feature in natural language text, yet it is an open
question how sentiment is represented within Large Language Models (LLMs). In
this study, we reveal that across a range of models, sentiment is represented
linearly: a single direction in activation space mostly captures the feature
across a range of tasks with one extreme for positive and the other for
negative. Through causal interventions, we isolate this direction and show it
is causally relevant in both toy tasks and real world datasets such as Stanford
Sentiment Treebank. Through this case study we model a thorough investigation
of what a single direction means on a broad data distribution.
We further uncover the mechanisms that involve this direction, highlighting
the roles of a small subset of attention heads and neurons. Finally, we
discover a phenomenon which we term the summarization motif: sentiment is not
solely represented on emotionally charged words, but is additionally summarized
at intermediate positions without inherent sentiment, such as punctuation and
names. We show that in Stanford Sentiment Treebank zero-shot classification,
76% of above-chance classification accuracy is lost when ablating the sentiment
direction, nearly half of which (36%) is due to ablating the summarized
sentiment direction exclusively at comma positions. | [
0.0208008923,
0.0139308162,
-0.0170056485,
0.0318137407,
0.001805786,
0.0419126451,
-0.0399483107,
-0.0060305009,
0.00404491,
-0.0463255867,
-0.0309526864,
-0.0237234123,
0.0009580395,
0.0182708949,
0.0158799849,
-0.0555709153,
0.0160352141,
0.0639911667,
0.0517496243,
0.0056286585,
0.0400091223,
0.0080523053,
0.0358242318,
0.0303025376,
0.0004203405,
-0.0390308462,
0.0060779671,
0.0181602463,
0.0175494738,
-0.0147495233,
0.012662719,
0.0338065177,
0.0039014886,
0.0134257125,
0.0000017837,
-0.0068085548,
0.0167297442,
-0.0291377362,
0.0130667128,
0.0023115706,
0.0653807148,
-0.0386954211,
0.0027616427,
-0.0177734513,
-0.0077836141,
-0.01071095,
0.0446306542,
0.083221212,
0.0550519042,
0.0842516273,
-0.0078159142,
-0.0354461744,
-0.0031511444,
-0.0250695124,
0.0172139499,
0.0249049589,
0.0026418334,
-0.0332003795,
-0.0487069935,
0.0001248728,
-0.0333656333,
0.0011690473,
-0.0027320704,
0.0175325722,
0.0274454877,
0.0342282578,
-0.0260615293,
0.0034709508,
-0.0018933574,
0.0687139481,
-0.0009799864,
-0.0324076749,
-0.0084702605,
-0.0046614697,
0.0083193341,
-0.0627579987,
-0.0396140665,
0.0341114588,
0.0178806782,
0.0729084015,
0.0216252934,
0.0146120023,
0.0215342399,
0.026093062,
-0.0180367976,
0.0239567254,
-0.0490744561,
-0.0577903539,
0.0133277299,
0.0533208773,
-0.0291915666,
-0.0077542146,
0.0069655511,
-0.0233161133,
0.0384676047,
0.0023854524,
-0.0062332684,
-0.0030176812,
0.020002909,
-0.1040811911,
0.0298398528,
0.0277017485,
-0.0027344252,
0.0574914999,
-0.0130707175,
0.0254672132,
-0.0137588158,
0.0088811098,
-0.014230717,
0.0117617808,
-0.0320885479,
-0.0127558894,
0.0491695739,
0.0395305566,
-0.0130014326,
-0.0109343566,
-0.0680953935,
-0.0048162714,
-0.0377367623,
-0.0522175729,
0.0120715881,
0.0425350331,
0.0397254862,
-0.0077456706,
-0.0376157165,
0.0594718009,
-0.0465370379,
0.0236522146,
-0.0209954418,
-0.0101083023,
-0.0300546773,
0.0650187358,
-0.0019942282,
-0.0153336292,
-0.0013204548,
0.0292971916,
0.0232809298,
-0.0378810279,
-0.0220239032,
-0.0398500711,
-0.0509885028,
-0.0432852544,
0.0280527826,
-0.0343408957,
0.0017423512,
0.00594057,
-0.0046585947,
0.0027466218,
0.0066824369,
0.0013267563,
-0.0579078458,
0.0560821407,
-0.0014938525,
-0.0248184446,
-0.0275740307,
-0.0215551071,
0.0059882863,
0.0260392595,
0.0074822647,
0.0653560311,
0.0122774364,
0.0163291898,
0.0064772335,
-0.0122485282,
0.0271467883,
-0.0343152769,
-0.0449581742,
-0.0304302908,
-0.0649007112,
-0.0010291272,
0.0510605574,
0.0189971682,
-0.0258763302,
-0.0397928581,
0.0592690036,
0.0493412055,
-0.0469863191,
0.0362918153,
-0.0338591225,
0.0030345004,
0.001350392,
-0.0027683654,
-0.0640841722,
0.0451345071,
-0.0421251804,
0.0102353776,
0.0332917608,
-0.0130443592,
-0.0261749215,
-0.0577985793,
-0.0184315816,
-0.0199525952,
0.0255594905,
-0.0057953908,
0.028491497,
-0.0132145463,
-0.0421518199,
0.0270113759,
0.0350012034,
-0.0821698979,
-0.0291958787,
-0.020084627,
0.0310399663,
0.0560749099,
-0.0052501806,
-0.0112375673,
-0.028872598,
-0.0067799329,
-0.0013992746,
0.0500170738,
0.0261552576,
0.02231423,
0.0099699954,
-0.0275848303,
0.0046133138,
-0.0098156855,
0.0375258103,
0.0203020424,
-0.0399839394,
-0.0227186363,
0.0087895505,
0.0035498284,
-0.030199768,
0.0107538113,
0.0180124622,
-0.0409862101,
0.016969841,
0.0162834674,
0.0528462641,
0.0270774905,
-0.0185003579,
0.0210928749,
0.0308456626,
-0.0467648469,
-0.0584366582,
0.0387329496,
-0.0291306432,
-0.0238826629,
0.0151654473,
-0.028056046,
-0.0321866609,
0.0504644997,
-0.0350938141,
-0.0273258667,
0.0517374165,
-0.0304291043,
0.0176969618,
-0.0066696974,
0.00288216,
-0.0092164781,
0.0340229608,
-0.020425532,
0.0629561394,
-0.0178481359,
-0.006755264,
-0.0229416322,
-0.0277877524,
0.011994103,
0.0210081208,
-0.0374411494,
-0.0054028556,
0.0520598814,
-0.0070638089,
0.0295673367,
-0.0389158651,
-0.0472549908,
-0.0296319611,
-0.1077649668,
-0.0068464833,
0.0056414986,
0.020414168,
0.0249527507,
-0.0167213641,
0.0141411191,
0.0077119074,
-0.0350102223,
0.007017815,
-0.0218227394,
0.0365311354,
0.0490842611,
-0.0293175243,
0.0319627039,
-0.0809698626,
-0.0204905886,
-0.0365229733,
0.039019756,
-0.0246846974,
-0.0278423224,
-0.0202840008,
0.0460390933,
-0.0190692302,
-0.0055828425,
0.0065588299,
-0.0708670393,
0.0213225521,
-0.0308101345,
0.0301602315,
0.0734734833,
-0.0062654284,
0.0442593172,
0.0335130133,
0.0269110315,
-0.038631469,
0.0048539559,
-0.0411576144,
0.0621826388,
-0.0011620353,
-0.0066015227,
-0.0290236399,
0.1169393957,
0.0103514036,
-0.0104589257,
-0.0522060208,
-0.0091681844,
0.0029578919,
-0.0090366974,
-0.0331293046,
-0.0070112944,
-0.0272078607,
0.0123402784,
-0.0424683504,
-0.0437965654,
0.0436605997,
0.0233948324,
-0.0070512784,
-0.0252760276,
-0.0020287775,
-0.0541760027,
0.0835248679,
0.0241898037,
-0.013025065,
0.0000711154,
-0.004755843,
-0.0242574215,
-0.0431931317,
-0.0276527535,
-0.0139404666,
0.0378785729,
-0.002359418,
-0.0042569325,
0.0060259821,
-0.0331654586,
0.0189138111,
-0.0751899406,
-0.0513435714,
-0.0013124933,
0.0119480416,
-0.0185197908,
-0.0163402893,
-0.0323713273,
0.0250671767,
-0.0142080933,
-0.0330474228,
-0.0126616228,
0.0150117176,
0.0193129461,
0.0121426303,
0.0059852758,
0.0496307164,
-0.0179236699,
-0.0068749054,
0.0560175106,
0.0055030743,
0.0377294123,
-0.0164469387,
-0.0051347823,
0.0135983676,
-0.0099664247,
-0.0487662181,
-0.0441067293,
0.0272884089,
-0.0510028861,
0.0088748205,
0.1199191436,
0.0353943817,
-0.093002744,
-0.005472898,
0.0079465229,
0.0123607768,
0.0453362651,
-0.0054719225,
-0.0396646895,
-0.0385651812,
-0.0284793247,
0.0017122383,
0.010734641,
-0.0061965538,
0.0103506213,
-0.1185244173,
-0.0029462329,
0.0001866893,
-0.0317119434,
-0.0367281362,
-0.026433317,
-0.0195867028,
0.0043116002,
-0.0045579541,
-0.0201735366,
0.0069996929,
0.0049256664,
0.0296873227,
-0.0364884026,
0.0104429666,
0.0094067948,
-0.0328674316,
0.0352918096,
0.0599724203,
0.0878276378,
-0.0042476244,
-0.010309089,
0.0382627212,
0.0040703318,
0.0206466671,
-0.0227144714,
0.0827447549,
0.0036306083,
-0.0170516204,
-0.0256322511,
-0.0030815639,
-0.0658436939,
0.0117709003,
-0.0397095047,
0.0525383726,
0.0003554119,
-0.0427905805,
-0.0526331291,
0.0492036343,
-0.0143554276,
0.0656125769,
0.0383647755,
-0.0430972278,
-0.0535336211,
-0.0220940039,
0.002395072,
-0.0373672955,
-0.0565854572,
-0.0228981338,
0.0088406578,
-0.0322477072,
-0.0728529617,
-0.0763491094,
-0.00407294,
-0.0356024951,
-0.028281549,
-0.0223718956,
-0.0234531853,
-0.024220787,
-0.031249797,
0.0464856289,
0.020028457,
0.0069604889,
0.0057875076,
-0.02942314,
0.0460649319,
-0.0100413533,
-0.026072938,
-0.0300783943,
-0.0391290598,
-0.0497560799,
0.0031945368,
0.052343376,
0.0149192633,
0.0178207643,
0.0170546044,
-0.059633702,
0.0099535622,
0.0683803409,
-0.0186741594,
0.0271452889,
0.034537863,
0.0538416319,
0.0068469117,
0.0376751088,
-0.0117606474,
0.0584426634,
0.0202491544,
-0.0097515658,
-0.0339816846,
-0.0015150867,
0.0052349567,
-0.0047592791,
0.1101547405,
0.0288285036,
-0.032571964,
-0.0084023857,
-0.0116925603,
-0.0204465128,
-0.0335000791,
-0.0216157939,
-0.0276489537,
0.0032244176,
-0.0102366991,
-0.0639148578,
0.0077444655,
-0.0164321344,
0.0262144767,
-0.0369266719,
0.0119274538,
0.0164397415,
-0.0193781815,
-0.0374902524,
0.0435910486,
-0.0295910258,
0.01644665,
-0.011476459,
-0.017363267,
0.0207887385,
0.0145174731,
-0.0163188912,
0.0401422791,
-0.0238091536,
0.019447865,
-0.0753721595,
0.0022311485,
0.0199931432,
0.0088203857,
0.0276525822,
-0.0199396629,
0.0792564377,
-0.0092764832,
-0.0002128168,
-0.0047895024,
-0.004659628,
-0.0194087829,
-0.0103928149,
0.0158173684,
0.0225361437,
-0.030979773,
-0.0455544777,
0.067942284,
-0.0576110408,
0.034849979,
0.0257504154,
0.0088343974,
-0.0133158052,
-0.0208224207,
0.0530861653,
0.0069037336,
0.0168318953,
0.0411718562,
-0.0847221538,
-0.0451822914,
0.0607279427,
-0.0233100634,
0.0438514464,
-0.0426260866,
0.0291019045,
0.025068786,
0.0075203958,
0.0354861915,
-0.0350064412,
0.0084761502,
-0.0525502674,
0.0042875009,
-0.0490203239,
-6.218344545e-33,
0.0033891443,
0.0072746305,
-0.0447497293,
0.0336033702,
-0.0191866439,
0.0209117215,
-0.0377517641,
0.0542931221,
0.0056537879,
0.0685916692,
-0.0212001763,
0.0655359626,
-0.0091202082,
0.0265715383,
0.0468099415,
-0.0144755263,
0.0383513719,
-0.0325958058,
0.0019863201,
0.028767122,
0.0636306033,
0.0112560615,
0.0651720166,
-0.0864148811,
0.0592446253,
-0.0078960247,
-0.0255323574,
0.0134260049,
0.0136614861,
0.048210144,
-0.0151799554,
0.0704079345,
0.0463522039,
-0.0190159045,
-0.0157018416,
0.0322534218,
0.0047612353,
-0.0325495265,
0.0148719391,
-0.0011179646,
-0.0272577256,
-0.0535159297,
0.0665345043,
0.0165473595,
-0.0208867453,
-0.0197720136,
0.0333953798,
0.0028410044,
-0.0173019357,
-0.0887273178,
-0.0481185876,
0.0160253774,
-0.0068599856,
-0.0163188204,
0.0188342594,
0.0276848748,
0.0065079993,
0.0935288519,
-0.0337629728,
0.0221784264,
-0.0189700648,
0.035340365,
-0.023660684,
0.0012289103,
0.0149775455,
0.1109965518,
0.0521708466,
0.0499871224,
-0.0625914037,
0.0280236714,
0.0100689717,
-0.0111833885,
0.0639795586,
0.0488351882,
0.0743981525,
0.0039336639,
-0.0214454103,
-0.0054246481,
0.0457201563,
0.0021096729,
0.0404163487,
0.0056606741,
-0.0136723751,
-0.0173478164,
-0.0041891173,
-0.0338000096,
-0.058678139,
-0.011871337,
-0.0131824771,
-0.0174894389,
0.0021911289,
-0.0231359433,
-0.0007133764,
-0.0380288176,
-0.0016956213,
0.0590857342,
-0.0127868718,
0.0378926918,
0.0463663191,
-0.0277825072,
-0.0462500192,
0.0020629324,
-0.0319227912,
-0.0029730848,
0.0203057416,
0.0282313768,
0.0726975799,
0.0060761534,
-0.0662459284,
-0.0233403742,
-0.0122830961,
-0.0009422586,
-0.0148159508,
0.0720579326,
-0.0078901984,
0.022358926,
0.0054133991,
0.0427667573,
0.0240020677,
0.0411827676,
-0.0078326454,
0.0049965116,
-0.0102898628,
0.0216689724,
-0.0436262898,
-0.0429137908,
-0.0221666321,
0.0070181275,
0.0000897516,
-0.0925561562,
-0.0199896954,
-0.0064469841,
2.591e-7,
0.0531140156,
0.080739148,
0.0058661113,
0.0207508374,
0.0453257523,
0.0608495809,
0.0004110448,
0.0310038123,
0.0351429544,
-0.0282122567,
-0.0041353512,
0.0085481834,
0.0287808701,
-0.0050908001,
-0.1262925565,
0.0217633713,
-0.0399885662,
0.0390344113,
0.0334163979,
0.0173218213,
0.0927632451,
0.1124531478,
0.0252570435,
-0.0143357702,
0.0058310195,
0.0202307869,
0.0675824061,
-0.0570661686,
0.01106981,
-0.0280927755,
-0.044098638,
-0.0407612883,
-0.0369326435,
-0.0291035324,
0.0003990528,
0.0062290845,
-0.003530879,
0.0664013177,
-0.0100405719,
-0.063794367,
0.0101024434,
0.0078697596,
0.0117673129,
0.0136633292,
0.046528168,
-0.0670633912,
-0.0464562364,
-0.0692364797,
-0.0075631505,
0.0145012429,
0.0489294752,
-0.0041684527,
-0.0229555257,
0.004081205,
-0.0201182105,
-0.0350944772,
-0.0201541129,
-0.1126959547,
-0.0673555881,
0.0053569521,
-0.0269919429,
-0.0297629014,
-0.0068068723,
0.0564525276,
0.0347241759,
-0.0426414907,
-0.0109619731,
2.092123953e-34,
0.0671374723,
-0.0307340678,
0.0019147871,
0.0326847881,
0.0094788317,
-0.0154179167,
-0.0328146741,
-0.0213176701,
0.0723219514,
-0.0549653061,
-0.0065067811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15213v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15213v2 | Function Vectors in Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T17:55:24 | 2024-02-25T18:32:18 | Eric Todd, Millicent L. Li, Arnab Sen Sharma, Aaron Mueller, Byron C. Wallace, David Bau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We report the presence of a simple neural mechanism that represents an
input-output function as a vector within autoregressive transformer language
models (LMs). Using causal mediation analysis on a diverse range of
in-context-learning (ICL) tasks, we find that a small number attention heads
transport a compact representation of the demonstrated task, which we call a
function vector (FV). FVs are robust to changes in context, i.e., they trigger
execution of the task on inputs such as zero-shot and natural text settings
that do not resemble the ICL contexts from which they are collected. We test
FVs across a range of tasks, models, and layers and find strong causal effects
across settings in middle layers. We investigate the internal structure of FVs
and find while that they often contain information that encodes the output
space of the function, this information alone is not sufficient to reconstruct
an FV. Finally, we test semantic vector composition in FVs, and find that to
some extent they can be summed to create vectors that trigger new complex
tasks. Our findings show that compact, causal internal vector representations
of function abstractions can be explicitly extracted from LLMs. Our code and
data are available at https://functions.baulab.info. | [
-0.0192178898,
0.0421230383,
-0.040007662,
0.0250588469,
-0.0211115573,
0.0280407425,
0.0162351821,
-0.0076271375,
-0.0448470712,
-0.036882367,
-0.0334976166,
-0.0190544855,
0.022192454,
0.0309527982,
0.0696622208,
0.0019253277,
0.0425944552,
-0.0419031791,
-0.0380127318,
0.0036202187,
-0.0272972845,
-0.0113036679,
0.0070688301,
0.0819984376,
-0.0027590038,
-0.0209664088,
0.0279978514,
-0.0156084048,
-0.0061869407,
0.017390918,
0.0019024262,
0.0218751803,
0.0318826959,
0.0430317968,
0.0000021946,
-0.0294919964,
-0.0027825877,
-0.0214257054,
-0.0236309655,
-0.0128878346,
0.0131802326,
-0.0235779397,
-0.0119329942,
0.0047738696,
-0.0304604862,
-0.0272172857,
0.0604822114,
0.0010415792,
0.0068099722,
0.0856329873,
-0.0033480327,
-0.0596848354,
0.0216360241,
-0.0466037728,
0.0224679746,
0.0044604582,
0.0120902602,
-0.0222714562,
-0.0390207544,
-0.0051428708,
-0.0644236356,
0.0536589548,
0.0456282794,
0.0054858103,
0.0320597775,
0.0501101278,
0.0320923626,
-0.0248563215,
0.0203047674,
0.0448449552,
-0.031151481,
-0.0767697692,
0.0025559776,
-0.0025582775,
0.0043957951,
0.0268009081,
-0.0754951164,
0.0290791783,
0.0347452201,
0.0253437553,
0.0715241581,
0.0000883376,
0.0428814963,
-0.0117435055,
-0.0250357054,
0.0123899579,
0.0104717026,
-0.0137281446,
-0.0359425284,
0.0059839068,
-0.0125207771,
-0.0348307155,
-0.0002831907,
0.032726571,
-0.0019601986,
0.0418551639,
-0.0168804843,
-0.0554135814,
-0.0044133011,
-0.0311735515,
0.0498251431,
0.0550264381,
-0.0114499135,
0.0250949804,
-0.0732880682,
0.0900348574,
-0.0711509958,
0.032231126,
0.0006023551,
0.0195614696,
-0.024060702,
-0.0493424796,
-0.0105718058,
0.0104555478,
-0.030260602,
-0.0277847033,
-0.0023034993,
0.0439533442,
-0.0274502523,
-0.0135650327,
-0.0140107917,
0.0010306041,
-0.0322982259,
0.0192896742,
0.0001506808,
0.0608320311,
0.0044282689,
0.0069802739,
-0.005246684,
-0.0387212969,
-0.0294665992,
0.0105742151,
0.0133075034,
-0.0408389159,
-0.0287924148,
0.0588286184,
-0.0129264314,
-0.0235953797,
-0.0002674804,
-0.0375470333,
-0.0059581613,
-0.0366797596,
0.0489599183,
-0.0654266402,
-0.0091120545,
0.0234011691,
0.010665793,
-0.031293951,
0.0162937194,
0.0250022057,
-0.0641209409,
0.0427022092,
0.0446831957,
0.0077079153,
0.005526809,
-0.0103353057,
0.0346000642,
0.0387062766,
0.0258480366,
-0.0085741896,
-0.0117168743,
-0.0025400869,
0.0078227399,
0.0422022454,
0.0511572808,
0.0159668159,
-0.0231066141,
-0.0435435176,
0.0102677271,
0.0153241605,
0.0628333762,
0.0054265657,
-0.0221219901,
-0.0225806478,
0.068401143,
0.0326345488,
0.0466546901,
0.0288734827,
0.0564546287,
-0.0416097119,
-0.0016979061,
0.0235675815,
-0.0820075572,
0.0531563535,
-0.0285628252,
-0.002634583,
-0.0052958541,
-0.0107308431,
-0.0225002002,
-0.033248283,
0.0177198183,
0.0153426835,
-0.0193851665,
0.0003421656,
0.0608389266,
0.0589375012,
-0.0407049954,
0.0332964137,
0.0023127701,
-0.0357730649,
0.013816393,
-0.0403084606,
0.0298554394,
0.00503504,
0.0479522124,
-0.0238415208,
-0.0041008363,
-0.0144980839,
0.0191449542,
0.0361758322,
0.0079631396,
0.0118410671,
-0.0196548533,
-0.0336065814,
-0.0003575212,
-0.0213299412,
0.034883488,
-0.0013312979,
-0.0229126122,
-0.0360197946,
0.0053971931,
0.0142993545,
-0.0280121583,
0.0325083509,
-0.0489107259,
-0.0435128063,
-0.0119657135,
0.0089346636,
-0.0023074674,
-0.0160815977,
-0.0117155155,
0.0537408479,
0.011797525,
-0.0647632256,
-0.0069396771,
0.062201485,
-0.0840192214,
-0.0195756089,
0.0067306403,
-0.0043809717,
0.0083738789,
0.03737076,
0.0004240485,
-0.0429114364,
0.0715353042,
-0.0645578057,
0.0546237864,
-0.0120896958,
0.0150438491,
0.0131923333,
0.0188082624,
-0.0340066403,
0.0453746952,
0.007648732,
0.0062407749,
0.0207822826,
0.0426411889,
-0.0188923888,
0.0091420608,
0.0050546047,
-0.0124718966,
-0.0114185214,
0.0029710175,
0.0221476685,
-0.0290084276,
-0.0151879294,
-0.0089851739,
-0.0426238328,
0.0044458592,
-0.0363981389,
-0.0095239729,
0.0377642326,
0.0108248154,
0.0386091545,
-0.0070624412,
-0.0160652325,
0.0207959414,
-0.0154029392,
0.0274992418,
0.0256477352,
-0.0303010382,
-0.0103205936,
-0.0460385941,
-0.0229036286,
-0.0533243753,
0.091719076,
-0.0085555529,
-0.0111140497,
-0.0371114872,
0.0337979607,
0.0181435123,
0.0074854628,
-0.0460535958,
-0.0261683576,
0.0176318027,
-0.0259958692,
0.0700682402,
0.0730417967,
-0.0207196828,
0.0274848714,
0.0443653762,
-0.0008645551,
-0.0752256215,
0.0038804179,
-0.0448734537,
-0.0193676427,
-0.0441295765,
0.0161324292,
0.0013885645,
0.0997761562,
0.0072591896,
-0.008144686,
-0.0626550019,
0.0122241639,
-0.0079641333,
-0.0183012802,
-0.0169961732,
-0.0348516144,
-0.0666126758,
0.0293495059,
-0.0436987691,
-0.0627561361,
0.0304802377,
-0.0019770637,
-0.0426428765,
-0.0036778715,
0.0101756295,
-0.0264672432,
0.0690299198,
0.0456174426,
-0.0064485958,
0.0264584702,
-0.0394448973,
-0.0675661266,
0.0432878137,
-0.00327554,
-0.0210840907,
0.0571025163,
-0.0330495834,
-0.0018916624,
0.0077274516,
-0.0152974809,
-0.0403638519,
-0.0176069718,
-0.0065703434,
0.0266772993,
-0.0126600275,
0.0156603418,
-0.0145192547,
-0.0237039905,
0.056161318,
0.0673597232,
-0.0295501035,
-0.0101153534,
-0.0340207927,
-0.0077224271,
0.0285849795,
0.009884269,
0.0463266224,
-0.0325075984,
-0.0115863197,
0.002466718,
-0.0048008701,
0.0198302828,
-0.0468557999,
0.0205032695,
0.0291390829,
-0.0046328693,
-0.030353982,
-0.0036264677,
0.0526228771,
-0.0858335495,
-0.0452192686,
0.0743482262,
0.0124380272,
-0.0731496587,
0.0128593249,
-0.0200824477,
0.0018645945,
0.0462472253,
0.0148335639,
-0.0817389637,
-0.0179012809,
0.0279126428,
-0.0289917998,
-0.0006497702,
-0.0115543352,
0.0333468318,
-0.1153027415,
0.0312093776,
0.008482676,
-0.0296397246,
-0.0244257692,
-0.021350801,
0.0191197228,
-0.0004733276,
-0.0122740492,
0.0005583027,
-0.0336647555,
0.0041501014,
0.0054694428,
-0.0066918693,
-0.0255831107,
-0.0102428924,
-0.0238090232,
0.0380939543,
0.0888029784,
0.0153892711,
0.0116724567,
-0.0384983197,
0.0437198505,
-0.0111652724,
0.0159925576,
-0.0046004206,
0.0323093645,
0.0234106127,
-0.0287081599,
0.0141693112,
0.0311400872,
-0.0377560779,
-0.0322650708,
-0.0451490656,
0.0869869962,
-0.0301664621,
-0.011256434,
-0.000685917,
-0.0010707587,
-0.0247888528,
0.053436067,
0.0742076412,
-0.0307461247,
-0.0349065475,
-0.0275737476,
0.0138618918,
-0.0299302712,
-0.0899762437,
-0.0146849276,
0.0493660271,
-0.0490628257,
-0.0508694574,
-0.0235825405,
0.0307354089,
0.0022530067,
-0.0018596399,
-0.0298245139,
-0.0142262392,
-0.034687113,
-0.0425733402,
0.0165774431,
-0.031497281,
0.0376491472,
-0.0310793463,
0.0091698375,
0.0072294385,
-0.0448339731,
-0.0270966254,
0.041716475,
-0.0814689249,
-0.0593780987,
0.0260806531,
0.0654274002,
0.0195962489,
0.0242106933,
-0.0282879304,
-0.0472046584,
0.0680045709,
0.0053762966,
-0.0431127883,
0.0343460813,
0.0252545625,
-0.0236451048,
0.004674003,
0.0607585125,
-0.0325644724,
-0.0143057378,
0.0331265219,
0.0522936061,
-0.0033066433,
0.0499514788,
0.0316008478,
-0.036700312,
0.078247495,
-0.0007012584,
-0.0090725031,
-0.0251114443,
-0.016943885,
0.0077693015,
-0.0105421832,
-0.0425825454,
0.0074441629,
0.0330212973,
0.0383354053,
0.0165128931,
-0.0091956817,
0.0400096029,
0.0272290781,
-0.0038050544,
0.0244893692,
-0.0020213013,
0.0250443723,
0.0117225591,
0.0645015016,
0.0069713322,
0.0288280305,
-0.0021527964,
0.0120578799,
-0.0088762455,
0.0391014442,
0.0239855889,
0.0196393989,
-0.0464206524,
-0.0137692988,
-0.1058309898,
-0.0220268406,
0.0213437956,
-0.0363429636,
0.0785198584,
-0.0495359302,
0.089883849,
-0.029012233,
-0.0041578286,
-0.0109931156,
0.0176146496,
0.0007747768,
0.0067210095,
0.0320756286,
0.0203398075,
-0.0100201517,
-0.0360545628,
0.0714004561,
-0.0119121298,
0.0364185199,
0.0056318911,
0.0449331813,
0.0019469351,
-0.022948971,
0.0215588436,
0.0189093892,
-0.0171008576,
0.0119849779,
-0.054401733,
-0.0570777282,
-0.0034574049,
-0.0324806646,
0.0023817923,
-0.0641820505,
0.0210451744,
0.0308642965,
0.004333342,
0.0031219865,
-0.0385694429,
0.0107487598,
-0.0026073076,
-0.0289967693,
-0.0488278642,
-6.674347456e-33,
-0.0154128317,
-0.0388432518,
0.0079500163,
0.0268206857,
-0.0209132545,
0.0481009334,
-0.0567299314,
0.0023582049,
0.0007326883,
0.0219166726,
-0.0075400416,
0.0231281538,
-0.0081428252,
0.0147899017,
0.0400262773,
-0.0277818888,
0.0384253711,
-0.0231723785,
-0.023621738,
0.0147708599,
0.049914401,
0.0338914357,
0.076764062,
-0.0440165922,
0.0211908463,
0.018349614,
-0.0008283855,
0.0357562937,
-0.0168555491,
0.0561095923,
-0.0212278534,
0.0335314982,
0.0335863344,
-0.1060020551,
-0.0347953402,
0.0388554409,
-0.0879566222,
-0.0386856273,
0.0551492497,
0.0043740124,
-0.0626440942,
-0.0684753805,
0.0911392644,
-0.0066640978,
0.0014881069,
-0.0374359414,
0.0244006794,
-0.0096225934,
-0.0319758728,
-0.0473830067,
-0.1077347398,
-0.0075904084,
0.0080586849,
-0.0192700401,
0.0440657251,
0.0504145287,
-0.0246357359,
0.022506671,
-0.0455315001,
0.006431289,
-0.0568013377,
0.0530507974,
0.0354853533,
0.0570631176,
0.0344043635,
0.0355440006,
0.0089152176,
0.0186084099,
-0.0790675133,
-0.0129641006,
0.0604326054,
0.0260610413,
0.0432864316,
0.0075702816,
0.0499246977,
0.0047865245,
-0.0181920119,
-0.0397762805,
0.0172514189,
0.0466968156,
0.0309576187,
0.0102310767,
0.0255113374,
-0.018732639,
-0.0584954657,
-0.0331691727,
-0.0487157218,
-0.0091492925,
0.0068522645,
0.0262561459,
0.0419727713,
0.0101105403,
0.0341610983,
-0.0430247262,
0.0236689597,
0.0278458241,
-0.0118535636,
0.0371663459,
0.0190108605,
-0.0056721801,
-0.0551409759,
0.0091321403,
0.0038171704,
0.007441672,
0.0444777869,
0.0202205256,
0.0490905046,
0.0237849932,
-0.0418896377,
-0.033515729,
-0.0715062544,
-0.0020046332,
0.0138014965,
0.0354509018,
0.0441360772,
0.0228385124,
-0.0204087608,
0.0072712186,
-0.000557602,
0.013138622,
-0.0071094222,
0.0089775538,
-0.0520161204,
0.0384832881,
-0.0681810305,
-0.0476241596,
-0.0679140836,
0.0801641867,
0.0818515122,
-0.0595872663,
-0.0292501785,
0.0026617178,
2.976e-7,
0.0579494089,
0.0440853313,
0.0063847462,
0.0356690846,
0.0459824391,
0.0040470297,
0.0019786733,
0.0339999683,
0.0380697884,
0.0107573345,
0.0004589405,
0.0113999341,
0.0816660002,
-0.000198058,
-0.0598223768,
-0.0352234021,
-0.0710850582,
0.0112077445,
0.0025221687,
-0.0097203776,
-0.0155066801,
0.0965581015,
0.0352017842,
0.0041202824,
0.0185721759,
-0.0001444502,
0.0620294362,
-0.0437816978,
0.0193743352,
-0.025365537,
-0.0415905192,
0.0170723535,
-0.0227742083,
-0.0215492807,
0.0016579177,
0.0261405259,
-0.0142367342,
0.0429866426,
0.006142247,
-0.0318127982,
-0.0205379222,
-0.0235395506,
0.0012804337,
-0.0610367134,
0.0242363699,
-0.1005762815,
-0.027165195,
0.0014524249,
-0.0106096072,
0.0365018398,
0.0152282873,
0.0284596924,
-0.0300889947,
0.0052225795,
0.0099285534,
0.0271712001,
-0.0029515384,
-0.0833588094,
-0.0608560443,
0.037839178,
-0.031421598,
-0.0215946287,
-0.0615342222,
-0.031323839,
0.0100973835,
-0.0273007322,
-0.0214181524,
3.077529847e-34,
-0.0016137656,
0.00123285,
0.0309982337,
0.0059259408,
0.018722795,
-0.0452205576,
-0.0173303913,
0.0367899984,
0.043767672,
-0.0861780643,
-0.0257952157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15151v1 | Verb Conjugation in Transformers Is Determined by Linear Encodings of Subject Number | 2023-10-23T17:53:47 | 2023-10-23T17:53:47 | Sophie Hao, Tal Linzen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Deep architectures such as Transformers are sometimes criticized for having
uninterpretable "black-box" representations. We use causal intervention
analysis to show that, in fact, some linguistic features are represented in a
linear, interpretable format. Specifically, we show that BERT's ability to
conjugate verbs relies on a linear encoding of subject number that can be
manipulated with predictable effects on conjugation accuracy. This encoding is
found in the subject position at the first layer and the verb position at the
last layer, but distributed across positions at middle layers, particularly
when there are multiple cues to subject number. | [
0.0004097461,
0.0353829525,
-0.0325541198,
0.0191711485,
-0.020815216,
0.0076700579,
-0.0027987116,
-0.0050838017,
-0.0552162193,
-0.0654600561,
-0.0271937586,
-0.0189612731,
-0.0196743011,
0.0113267377,
0.0329111256,
-0.0063810246,
0.0801223367,
0.0231479332,
0.0233008489,
-0.0101515595,
-0.0273518767,
-0.0308028292,
-0.0410026349,
0.0460662879,
-0.0347584486,
0.0026045816,
0.0008671043,
-0.0152711319,
-0.0119352918,
0.0362748541,
0.001646739,
0.0289003886,
0.0167865064,
0.0206372198,
0.0000017066,
-0.0363812335,
-0.0178792924,
-0.0133299567,
-0.047506012,
0.0296827313,
-0.0509252325,
-0.0153368358,
-0.0453421474,
0.004050693,
-0.0302839912,
0.0083816079,
0.0547171868,
0.0520755276,
0.0351208821,
0.0903081149,
-0.0257783961,
-0.0189942569,
0.0393664129,
-0.0173802972,
-0.0255364515,
0.0139096109,
0.0150247421,
-0.0662714466,
-0.0574086457,
-0.0105322814,
-0.0713687018,
0.0013184773,
0.045819588,
-0.0067953123,
-0.030535778,
-0.0003337299,
-0.0470941439,
-0.0318751857,
0.0218820702,
0.0453306474,
-0.0136980647,
0.0124537107,
0.0111160642,
0.0074718408,
0.0214497633,
0.0287540331,
0.0013760267,
0.0174150951,
0.0505483933,
0.0246526729,
-0.0016585231,
-0.0426788516,
0.0209818222,
-0.0016866763,
-0.0360865332,
0.0784133226,
0.037490733,
-0.0236751251,
-0.0299004391,
0.0464815199,
0.0136531452,
-0.021880053,
0.0050012656,
-0.0107606333,
-0.0388789102,
0.0238450374,
0.0051729507,
-0.0534714572,
-0.0116081396,
-0.0344541632,
0.0261354838,
0.0279771201,
-0.037151251,
-0.0123262852,
-0.0478793047,
0.0508683138,
-0.0545891412,
0.1178956404,
-0.0502884388,
0.0047332086,
0.0019267249,
-0.0421452112,
-0.0646641701,
0.0104940534,
-0.0350393802,
-0.0207296666,
-0.0555535667,
0.0499637909,
-0.0005473859,
-0.04873522,
-0.0374486148,
-0.0056741894,
-0.0426612198,
0.010100713,
-0.0136052407,
0.0640973076,
-0.0188941881,
0.0559892021,
-0.0181659441,
-0.074199982,
-0.0163758639,
-0.0091614546,
0.0076341704,
-0.0573809184,
-0.0161791667,
0.0521041937,
-0.0146958325,
-0.0575157814,
-0.0021968368,
-0.0123400614,
-0.0320758037,
0.0065384698,
0.0733172596,
-0.0215893034,
-0.0179142691,
0.0101526193,
0.0105582764,
-0.0426566303,
-0.002092585,
-0.0132020367,
-0.0147041781,
0.0365430973,
0.0298489928,
-0.0366039947,
-0.007702291,
-0.0219659489,
0.0098149385,
0.0408629403,
0.060090974,
0.0072840624,
0.014209413,
-0.0269508921,
0.0297246501,
0.0217469279,
0.036565356,
0.006175865,
-0.0368832871,
-0.0654480904,
-0.0067205243,
0.0132545298,
0.0185682699,
0.0183242857,
-0.0194158722,
-0.0008031897,
0.062828429,
0.0323878676,
0.0087061618,
-0.0077470178,
0.0277917814,
-0.0392441489,
0.0085067283,
0.0412573144,
-0.0539688207,
0.0346891023,
0.0011340274,
-0.0445809253,
-0.069470942,
0.0190286338,
-0.0221937578,
-0.0175382663,
-0.005794392,
0.0147224842,
0.0042341487,
-0.0454676785,
0.0520355776,
0.0503779911,
-0.0000807795,
0.0816131458,
0.000753745,
-0.074292466,
0.039256528,
-0.0532454588,
-0.0068586143,
0.0028217339,
0.031886477,
-0.0213826932,
-0.0331998654,
0.0040854579,
-0.0235858075,
0.0169050824,
0.0343117304,
0.0145120956,
0.0241314154,
-0.0213661939,
-0.0186251365,
-0.0118701085,
0.0451832339,
-0.0114222802,
-0.0523008853,
-0.0562936328,
-0.0122646568,
-0.0129428171,
0.0430109203,
0.041810032,
0.0133016603,
-0.022830233,
0.0145288724,
0.0401770994,
0.04984558,
-0.0001739614,
-0.0014132641,
0.0425704569,
0.0337516591,
-0.0257998165,
-0.0617242381,
0.0610318556,
-0.0245999135,
-0.0371697657,
0.0111532621,
-0.041237995,
-0.0249413755,
0.0757550374,
-0.009628552,
-0.0548388958,
0.0479193479,
-0.1120410189,
0.0971756279,
-0.0103720743,
0.0222094469,
0.0196971092,
0.0201480985,
-0.0297027137,
0.0331342481,
0.0099113565,
-0.0000234326,
0.0081466632,
-0.0059498996,
0.030500859,
0.0120009109,
-0.0114307702,
-0.0032591783,
-0.0073336428,
-0.0208187923,
0.0433378629,
-0.0693969205,
-0.0380563401,
-0.0063277981,
-0.0341983624,
-0.0365996324,
-0.0261586662,
0.0369471237,
0.0145767219,
0.0177968554,
0.0323906541,
-0.0056220251,
-0.0202496145,
0.018611243,
-0.0049775653,
0.0454232246,
0.0387490503,
-0.0234518237,
-0.0595696494,
-0.0312369261,
-0.0291857943,
-0.0477646925,
0.0465298966,
0.0043624281,
0.0271159988,
-0.0120599465,
-0.0797544941,
0.0115768071,
0.0328556225,
0.0000199276,
-0.0890943706,
0.0214005355,
0.0036336042,
0.0653082579,
0.0468565822,
-0.0041198744,
0.0819432586,
0.0117084133,
0.0087850718,
-0.0486771911,
-0.0063087177,
-0.0600293167,
-0.0312056299,
-0.067711547,
-0.0150557635,
0.0022813224,
0.1066023186,
-0.0080022244,
-0.0130370902,
-0.0641538128,
-0.03566074,
-0.0029817042,
-0.026152594,
-0.0039398079,
-0.023547899,
-0.066390194,
0.0180855449,
-0.0275632516,
-0.0354189985,
0.0664700046,
0.029777132,
-0.0163489748,
-0.0324454159,
0.0386786051,
-0.0075408462,
0.0507859848,
0.046057336,
0.0041059684,
-0.0027000692,
-0.0473279655,
-0.0630696863,
0.0142266434,
0.022955576,
0.0055668089,
0.0695959106,
-0.073392421,
0.0097250473,
0.0136432787,
-0.0457970686,
-0.045908317,
-0.0414180495,
-0.0096233999,
0.0274322331,
0.0715079457,
-0.0457292944,
-0.0424842611,
-0.0760412887,
0.0293717701,
0.0363055356,
0.02782383,
0.0167848002,
-0.0449967869,
0.0010504484,
-0.0042642127,
-0.0086296676,
0.0308951326,
-0.0332653858,
-0.0347889327,
0.0292594768,
-0.0286811385,
0.0355971493,
-0.0505718626,
0.0259875972,
0.0430398621,
-0.0239532404,
-0.0211986136,
-0.0390175283,
0.0467552915,
-0.022206476,
0.0078152083,
0.0441799201,
0.0338504016,
-0.0339805633,
0.048076462,
-0.0139208781,
-0.0085578309,
0.0250796862,
-0.0039224066,
-0.0785449892,
-0.0236174408,
0.0115131456,
-0.0316995308,
0.0056595462,
0.0014460305,
0.0085245753,
-0.1005795076,
0.0122490898,
-0.0204789694,
0.0083699469,
-0.0169578996,
-0.026275197,
0.021866262,
-0.0223270115,
0.0397035889,
0.011013275,
0.0159942023,
-0.0098849339,
0.0261598863,
0.0057962886,
-0.0308441687,
-0.0265166834,
-0.0411551446,
0.0545954704,
0.052785337,
0.0281097125,
-0.0485201292,
-0.0613197312,
0.0389816798,
0.0012933126,
-0.0041672108,
0.0326619484,
0.062186338,
0.030130554,
-0.0422710441,
-0.0249413438,
0.0222586747,
-0.0239239503,
-0.0339962654,
-0.0663781092,
0.0576334894,
-0.0359163769,
0.0131775951,
0.0044274307,
-0.024377374,
-0.027579451,
0.0277356729,
0.0243500397,
-0.0337414667,
-0.0093563953,
-0.0216749627,
-0.0258314684,
-0.0097070085,
-0.0342449248,
-0.0234338958,
-0.0228469893,
-0.0675246865,
-0.0876718089,
-0.0241439119,
0.0189847462,
-0.0297170393,
0.0038213157,
-0.0569123924,
0.0437175967,
-0.0197281409,
-0.0062904088,
0.0535205305,
0.0199255534,
0.0671994835,
-0.0627772808,
-0.0252414327,
0.0633105412,
0.0079480521,
-0.0118991174,
-0.0155550083,
-0.0119847022,
-0.0383625627,
0.069890663,
0.0239030253,
0.0136752287,
-0.0047755376,
0.0006161382,
-0.0351543725,
-0.0317239575,
0.0020737736,
-0.0102541931,
0.0295143649,
0.0615983605,
-0.0178127978,
-0.0038374176,
0.0578516573,
-0.0355573893,
0.0434775651,
-0.0162188448,
0.0269258097,
-0.0498535037,
0.0066054659,
0.0525201969,
0.0047639781,
0.1054450125,
0.0040147686,
0.0308636874,
-0.0100730285,
0.0317014419,
-0.0314992554,
0.0026327111,
-0.0301878918,
0.0274138413,
0.0192603301,
0.0308116432,
-0.0181245413,
0.0218897946,
-0.0140392277,
0.0100492416,
0.0022464609,
0.0301204268,
0.0202863738,
0.0001409264,
-0.0031265903,
0.0481164679,
0.0244303998,
0.0669617727,
0.0129956678,
0.0185639989,
0.0063759657,
0.0102711581,
0.0404190794,
0.0323448405,
-0.0682395548,
-0.0143039273,
-0.0697634742,
-0.0024975282,
0.034173917,
-0.0131025724,
0.0358986557,
0.0048686238,
0.0658085793,
-0.0455089733,
-0.0059477841,
0.012052916,
-0.0050425865,
-0.01409264,
0.0263540205,
0.0463200621,
0.00404895,
0.00818404,
-0.0109547917,
0.0676534548,
-0.0518432334,
0.0677329525,
-0.0757808164,
0.0275744293,
-0.0079177963,
-0.0352892205,
0.0651375875,
-0.0020066667,
-0.0178865045,
0.0311030317,
-0.0377972238,
-0.0519214123,
0.0192681067,
-0.0192929953,
0.0516385324,
-0.0663769469,
0.044068221,
0.039437715,
-0.0171469487,
-0.0458481982,
-0.0256141964,
0.0076327561,
0.0024029191,
0.0068795895,
-0.0221689828,
-6.077348405e-33,
-0.0294422023,
0.0023437296,
0.0142511912,
0.0195477884,
-0.006527381,
0.0115335323,
-0.0218343083,
0.019450862,
-0.0022282554,
0.0872173011,
0.0046319836,
0.0318042301,
0.0131935263,
0.0390736721,
0.0280850213,
-0.045927871,
0.0286567733,
-0.0161113162,
-0.0284353457,
-0.0332525671,
0.0519911572,
0.02398514,
0.089307785,
-0.064418368,
0.0090445578,
0.0420202613,
-0.0469948463,
0.0391128547,
-0.0694841519,
0.0243142601,
0.0108614378,
0.0225622766,
0.0183358304,
-0.0677999258,
-0.0064508184,
0.0506515466,
-0.0327792913,
-0.0350441448,
0.0414570868,
0.0480181165,
-0.0790309235,
-0.0364671871,
0.0478289463,
-0.0196173564,
-0.0193792656,
0.0275869295,
0.0160260908,
-0.0053579272,
-0.0017516616,
-0.0155081432,
-0.0606110543,
-0.021602463,
-0.0276864897,
-0.0483605228,
-0.0169310663,
0.0550066233,
-0.0276988279,
-0.0243503042,
-0.0292095523,
0.0173422694,
-0.031096207,
0.0259840917,
0.019695513,
0.0267944615,
-0.0283873715,
0.0405267999,
0.0545384958,
-0.0211054534,
-0.0225112028,
-0.0333617479,
0.0336432718,
0.0575694032,
0.041550599,
0.0181620959,
0.0432960987,
-0.0030516649,
-0.0288280006,
-0.0392644033,
0.0548579767,
0.0099268081,
-0.0162350722,
-0.0034346362,
0.0005329537,
-0.0298588667,
-0.0269992463,
0.0067048613,
-0.0332193337,
-0.0006165012,
-0.0061758603,
-0.005209473,
0.0107213035,
0.0125588393,
0.0291897915,
-0.0155390287,
0.018691333,
0.015424924,
-0.0279347133,
0.0416081399,
-0.0038258433,
-0.0085715866,
-0.0372679569,
-0.0382455513,
0.0188113041,
0.0129426029,
0.0161633547,
0.0497483201,
0.0643750429,
0.0135469697,
-0.0189070962,
-0.0050481842,
-0.0373214893,
-0.0417913087,
-0.002357343,
0.0333666801,
0.0192232523,
0.0269292556,
-0.0160475485,
0.0209262241,
0.0068261437,
0.0585431047,
-0.0299726687,
0.0134861441,
-0.0165878236,
0.0140369339,
-0.0150110023,
-0.0338024758,
-0.0284844283,
0.0742510632,
0.0229461286,
-0.0789549574,
-0.0134056685,
-0.0254870132,
2.693e-7,
0.0931032449,
0.0420453176,
0.0395740718,
0.0247173291,
0.025381837,
0.0080468589,
0.0048182649,
0.0433037356,
0.0241524614,
0.0213877894,
0.0215914212,
-0.0146259898,
0.0001202793,
0.0036888248,
-0.0177207422,
-0.0290058888,
-0.0538400896,
-0.0081737852,
0.0195240583,
0.0419569425,
0.044654008,
0.1011801064,
0.0454594046,
-0.0206755642,
0.0054661315,
0.0218662806,
0.052652806,
-0.0183780901,
0.0058789738,
0.0233743787,
0.0014241998,
-0.0283284169,
0.0013917194,
0.0369730294,
-0.046975743,
0.0368888266,
-0.0098937964,
0.0544268861,
-0.0331226215,
-0.0440064557,
-0.0264851134,
-0.0375965759,
-0.0110478662,
0.0586141683,
0.0054884823,
-0.065885514,
-0.0338998437,
0.043762546,
-0.0182083771,
0.0432264656,
0.0238054879,
0.0181507599,
-0.0129634794,
0.0064215921,
0.0297296718,
0.0015994227,
-0.0191548318,
-0.0936893895,
-0.0433836244,
-0.0199679043,
-0.0587238967,
-0.054404296,
-0.0048174202,
-0.0475693531,
0.0261988305,
-0.0076332465,
-0.0175090618,
2.080746453e-34,
0.0292997304,
-0.0005099226,
0.0618379675,
0.0242343228,
0.0058270721,
-0.0355628245,
0.0470648669,
0.056446325,
0.0250656959,
-0.0478575118,
-0.011786202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15147v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15147v2 | S3Eval: A Synthetic, Scalable, Systematic Evaluation Suite for Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T17:52:06 | 2024-04-06T15:20:18 | Fangyu Lei, Qian Liu, Yiming Huang, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to great
strides in model capabilities like long-context understanding and reasoning.
However, as LLMs are able to process longer contexts, it becomes more
challenging to evaluate whether they have acquired certain capabilities, since
the length of text (e.g., 200K tokens) they can process far exceeds what humans
can reliably assess in a reasonable duration. In this paper, we propose using
complex synthetic tasks as a proxy evaluation method, and present S3Eval, a
Synthetic, Scalable, Systematic evaluation suite for LLMs evaluation. The
synthetic nature of S3Eval provides users full control over the dataset,
allowing them to systematically probe LLM capabilities by scaling text length
and varying task difficulty across diverse scenarios. The strong correlation
between S3Eval and real-world benchmarks demonstrates the soundness of using
S3Eval for evaluation of LLMs. S3Eval provides a flexible and infinite
long-context data generation method. We have generated a comprehensive dataset
called S3Eval-Standard, and experimental results have shown that it poses
significant challenges for all existing LLMs. | [
0.0219265856,
0.0300490819,
-0.0063940203,
0.0663462952,
-0.0524862409,
0.0170924831,
0.0476659611,
-0.0264377277,
-0.0156060969,
-0.0355893187,
-0.0375031717,
-0.0593031049,
-0.0130500477,
0.0574613512,
0.0298014991,
-0.0284575839,
0.0406933576,
-0.0624881834,
-0.0066910954,
0.0117791994,
-0.0086260401,
0.0042536864,
0.0013752318,
0.0371453874,
0.0026838495,
-0.0251430944,
-0.0114375874,
-0.0122484351,
-0.0051121563,
-0.0310982279,
-0.0023613381,
0.072807543,
0.0262380354,
0.0397259854,
0.0000019586,
-0.0709586367,
0.0073637776,
-0.0045050853,
-0.0584310666,
0.0210710652,
0.0590418838,
0.0195595231,
-0.0027774004,
0.0240392126,
-0.0490407124,
0.0019606287,
0.0149252769,
0.0279566459,
0.0538352616,
0.0683305189,
0.000526806,
-0.0210043117,
0.0055852481,
-0.0375570431,
0.0246695392,
-0.0531123206,
0.0194634646,
-0.0014438955,
0.0525413714,
0.0174068641,
0.0088261645,
0.0362412892,
0.0767697692,
-0.0306709073,
-0.0087732719,
0.0332424641,
-0.0632500127,
-0.0083778501,
-0.0009662908,
0.0660479963,
-0.0053193374,
-0.019043982,
-0.0136608826,
0.0097566275,
-0.0092354883,
-0.0292657558,
-0.0401756279,
0.0121479938,
0.0034326888,
0.002745857,
0.031766545,
0.0060494589,
0.0437088497,
0.0144355921,
-0.0437674113,
0.0694234669,
0.0129431738,
-0.0323547907,
-0.0114826206,
-0.0008582417,
-0.0309052244,
-0.0580822006,
-0.0036229761,
0.017531829,
-0.0799442679,
0.0179912243,
-0.0399140231,
-0.0437756926,
0.0400499143,
-0.0365853086,
0.0292469822,
0.0176899694,
-0.0324234255,
0.0767335668,
-0.0428272225,
0.0638443008,
-0.0175571945,
0.0286247004,
-0.036086116,
-0.0308550838,
-0.0454684608,
0.0074297478,
-0.0150269587,
-0.0079597766,
-0.0632470027,
-0.0204373617,
-0.0269582756,
0.0141822714,
-0.0177584235,
0.0119689209,
0.0337719209,
0.0022116019,
-0.0067364001,
-0.0211561844,
-0.0254735406,
-0.0082743755,
-0.0504381992,
0.016249584,
0.0110509759,
-0.0506401621,
-0.0037958657,
0.0284766071,
-0.0074480898,
-0.0412903875,
0.0093604904,
0.0727293938,
0.0061108307,
-0.0170433205,
-0.0227693953,
-0.0161431115,
-0.0167775955,
-0.091064848,
-0.0104495706,
-0.0871155635,
0.034469679,
0.0180419516,
-0.0193939991,
-0.0032634807,
-0.0097932108,
0.0141274305,
0.0091708032,
0.072180748,
0.00504618,
0.0090511693,
-0.0075502368,
0.0137360571,
-0.0123365866,
0.0872078463,
0.005284213,
0.032831423,
0.0332693495,
0.0048467182,
0.0043607,
0.0495554805,
0.0125331767,
0.009951314,
-0.0287882648,
0.0538901687,
0.0126623036,
0.0408521406,
0.0121940682,
0.0679831132,
-0.0007500899,
-0.0334366187,
0.0321538337,
0.0524283499,
0.0498437509,
0.0034087566,
0.0843094215,
-0.0173859131,
-0.000515442,
-0.0125582526,
-0.0735651925,
0.0018978791,
-0.0063876016,
0.0214542057,
0.0107618794,
0.0254190303,
-0.0174485296,
-0.0365229212,
-0.0181412864,
0.0076312209,
-0.0058637946,
0.0149666285,
0.0549471378,
0.0111236591,
-0.0237680562,
0.045387052,
0.0062246853,
-0.0580751449,
0.0147257969,
-0.0527336001,
0.0309603401,
0.0952538699,
0.0413771272,
-0.0234746076,
-0.0094188275,
-0.0030760486,
0.0354828686,
0.0570058003,
0.0276025254,
-0.0132091613,
0.0199651327,
-0.037178997,
-0.0258507375,
-0.0094415667,
0.0115742059,
0.004044286,
0.0413762853,
-0.003287164,
0.0289987549,
-0.0810662135,
-0.0062695248,
0.0362977013,
-0.0589942969,
-0.0227687173,
-0.0155446324,
0.0018314602,
0.0249203332,
0.0174959395,
-0.0039739939,
0.0265153721,
0.0266127735,
-0.0493688211,
-0.0065611666,
0.0078736246,
-0.0656801686,
-0.0259811692,
0.0420001149,
-0.0150920404,
-0.0323878564,
0.0369441696,
-0.0357666202,
-0.0535256304,
0.0163227711,
-0.0177215151,
0.0132775921,
-0.0374054164,
0.0154650193,
-0.0268892571,
0.0197739787,
-0.0282683391,
0.072622858,
-0.004303169,
0.0286050215,
0.0303266477,
0.0401169993,
0.0004371406,
-0.0296562985,
-0.0440717079,
0.0082240328,
-0.0211300105,
-0.006098167,
-0.0060931668,
0.0333292708,
-0.0711127073,
-0.0216952097,
-0.1167870015,
0.0257260483,
-0.0457518175,
0.0421119332,
0.0274067149,
-0.0095900251,
-0.0117898146,
0.0153367175,
-0.0307805035,
-0.0234634504,
0.0165054668,
0.0195758026,
0.0128509793,
0.0124255372,
-0.0427010842,
-0.0357287638,
-0.0196794178,
-0.0268881004,
0.0731811747,
0.0083842399,
0.0211774949,
-0.0363554098,
0.0301298518,
0.0105005912,
0.0170734599,
-0.0120373685,
-0.0222752672,
0.0236226562,
-0.0278749615,
0.0617937744,
0.0413989015,
-0.0000242911,
0.0184810981,
0.0218434557,
-0.0100999074,
-0.0304108113,
0.0089480206,
0.0053401943,
-0.0176993217,
-0.0606768131,
-0.0130753471,
-0.012730157,
0.0622436181,
-0.0195495822,
0.0007893838,
-0.0318083055,
0.0101363249,
-0.0287444144,
-0.0327323787,
-0.0395485498,
-0.0027268734,
-0.0220324043,
0.0440058783,
-0.0572104342,
-0.0395383127,
0.067547448,
-0.0597137809,
-0.0143584106,
-0.0347683504,
-0.0183004458,
-0.0549857132,
0.0994590372,
-0.0146544697,
-0.0090174368,
-0.0409455858,
-0.0107866703,
-0.0265950039,
-0.0025585971,
-0.0291259382,
-0.0169743653,
0.0608513877,
-0.0512510762,
0.021507632,
-0.0132308844,
-0.0357788429,
-0.0370512046,
-0.0218896978,
-0.0381387174,
0.0456199758,
0.0222364627,
-0.0120647205,
-0.023761088,
0.0072805677,
0.0198735315,
0.0593601875,
-0.0182732642,
0.0013347175,
-0.0149569185,
0.0216922555,
0.0369293801,
0.0178772807,
0.0229847692,
-0.0345957838,
0.0534675866,
0.0448592119,
0.0592149869,
0.0053898264,
-0.0537079684,
0.0095132962,
-0.0051049953,
-0.0320193358,
0.0124252364,
0.0090801697,
0.0512503162,
-0.0851521045,
-0.0210815128,
0.1322173625,
0.0142642176,
-0.0388285592,
0.0184025932,
-0.0286888052,
0.021057833,
0.0465823635,
0.0064375577,
-0.0997360125,
-0.0412598886,
0.0074798227,
-0.007714489,
-0.0092135184,
-0.04356388,
0.0066103316,
-0.1204668507,
0.0308836214,
-0.0117181521,
-0.0622005835,
-0.004197055,
-0.0408957079,
-0.0035168102,
-0.0011754106,
0.0436323583,
0.0252744742,
-0.007047045,
-0.0173803251,
0.0026832614,
0.00425898,
-0.0835554674,
0.0998114049,
-0.0431617498,
0.0684108213,
0.0204088874,
0.0020750402,
0.0024134375,
-0.0173918176,
0.0659333467,
-0.029309582,
0.0113254255,
0.0044854339,
0.0212179665,
0.0022613259,
-0.0207413621,
-0.007168489,
0.0276932139,
-0.049853839,
-0.0172558874,
0.0186675005,
0.0991163552,
-0.0011921701,
-0.0101776971,
-0.0235468466,
-0.0285717808,
0.0262919851,
0.077412203,
0.0623161793,
-0.0435043797,
-0.0455578603,
0.0012858608,
-0.0588511787,
-0.081018731,
-0.0208596252,
0.0299675595,
0.0278648734,
0.0010431346,
-0.0430460647,
-0.037119057,
0.0539876856,
0.029844977,
-0.0227185376,
0.0224380195,
-0.0169498511,
-0.0055132383,
-0.0648585334,
0.0635175928,
-0.0415464081,
0.0591440946,
-0.0536570773,
0.022298919,
0.0086502405,
-0.0030600631,
-0.0241134558,
0.0295595936,
-0.0893138945,
-0.058442574,
0.0030271225,
0.0352077633,
0.027440846,
0.0149562471,
-0.039051313,
-0.0537211969,
0.0501147099,
0.0039127115,
-0.0494023412,
0.001163122,
0.0085970275,
0.0176699646,
0.0117250104,
0.0512104817,
-0.0359084532,
0.013876521,
0.0019509252,
0.0356021449,
0.0122329937,
0.0004574239,
-0.0106641036,
0.0056345076,
0.014524986,
-0.0014570305,
-0.0099778324,
-0.0178471953,
0.0183902979,
-0.0518555939,
-0.0111786267,
-0.0355922915,
0.0103471866,
0.0178551357,
-0.017797675,
0.0253026783,
-0.0036258947,
-0.0196050294,
0.0084669832,
-0.0217104852,
0.0490617007,
0.0012351339,
0.0188084152,
0.037143264,
0.0016949549,
-0.0198094621,
-0.0212665163,
-0.0352449715,
0.0291844793,
-0.02223593,
0.0386676714,
0.0184675884,
-0.0008843771,
-0.0226601027,
0.0439379811,
-0.0671817809,
-0.0184541196,
-0.0002405968,
0.0293207522,
0.0580050275,
-0.0073833489,
0.0399769507,
-0.0061835437,
0.0005978336,
-0.0357650444,
0.0293510482,
-0.0129760755,
-0.0399693921,
0.0137168309,
0.0546914525,
-0.0175468568,
0.0083297715,
0.0759136453,
0.0210096482,
0.0215842985,
0.0312002599,
0.0140234632,
-0.0372789949,
-0.0409807563,
-0.0321321376,
0.0051535745,
-0.0316677354,
0.0074568843,
-0.0427860208,
-0.0981456712,
-0.00680592,
0.052316267,
-0.0179206692,
0.0110190203,
0.0299882572,
0.0818637237,
-0.004676261,
-0.0058347061,
-0.0134064453,
0.0060319505,
-0.0065310369,
-0.0390370637,
-0.0253000744,
-6.538391983e-33,
-0.0019905302,
-0.0465374626,
0.0483639389,
-0.0635474995,
-0.0285349898,
0.0230042636,
-0.0533379838,
0.0058820639,
0.0017742885,
0.0165302549,
-0.0181091968,
0.0103445239,
0.0140025895,
0.051814381,
0.0071794083,
-0.0275344942,
0.026250476,
0.0101836957,
-0.0060025719,
0.0331241675,
0.0411686227,
0.005762808,
0.0429084823,
-0.0517700016,
0.0225703418,
0.0009625481,
0.0005764486,
0.0475834943,
-0.0273105241,
0.0863448232,
-0.0176471695,
0.0323482342,
0.0544903316,
-0.0718173236,
-0.0230022259,
0.0272015613,
-0.0608067773,
-0.0048548118,
0.0437227711,
-0.0109074125,
-0.0611054376,
-0.0222729966,
0.0433220863,
-0.0003033915,
-0.0025098256,
-0.00288869,
0.0233340748,
-0.0149600739,
0.005745139,
-0.0093083838,
-0.050769791,
0.0316174217,
-0.0085434048,
-0.0117091183,
0.0006900451,
0.019051373,
-0.0114021739,
0.003527313,
-0.0264828447,
-0.0160932373,
-0.0273252204,
0.0365772173,
0.0952544957,
0.0253184438,
0.0070495061,
0.0515469462,
0.0082003437,
0.011844283,
-0.0326782838,
-0.0314605646,
0.0391519144,
0.0641018674,
0.0547994301,
0.0600678362,
0.0211877264,
0.000983267,
-0.0565165691,
0.0058783907,
0.0140225021,
0.0437096134,
0.0359627716,
-0.0009450393,
-0.0158847887,
-0.0111886486,
-0.0585454069,
0.0134624494,
-0.0537305437,
-0.0139513677,
0.0623365268,
-0.009576492,
-0.0100658424,
-0.0142025156,
0.042299971,
-0.0338357016,
-0.0107951229,
0.0367301516,
0.0072386768,
0.0281008594,
0.0097267777,
0.0426041596,
-0.034057565,
-0.0222779755,
0.0126050422,
0.042626828,
0.0169885326,
-0.0222472418,
0.023923222,
0.0098082284,
-0.0544151999,
-0.0003712034,
-0.0659032166,
0.0315223187,
-0.0295213219,
0.0431290083,
0.0461042002,
0.0062976629,
-0.0173277333,
0.0383966863,
-0.0040311404,
-0.0073798141,
-0.0132438224,
0.0066032452,
-0.0009043095,
0.0161139667,
-0.0220348965,
-0.0072573354,
-0.0603556968,
0.0123381326,
0.0500924326,
-0.0389697738,
0.0108965589,
0.026627196,
2.589e-7,
0.0375961289,
0.0393646099,
0.0227405317,
0.0220277645,
0.0294934642,
0.0193293169,
-0.0074649332,
0.0144414091,
-0.0135762161,
-0.026023522,
-0.021669168,
0.048788242,
0.0645096302,
0.0290545039,
-0.0930293873,
0.0061806249,
-0.0783788785,
0.0014750478,
-0.0680988878,
0.0110180974,
0.047847148,
0.0924364477,
0.0017578836,
-0.0160505828,
-0.0052199536,
-0.0766600594,
0.0213250574,
-0.0380176343,
-0.0102474168,
0.0099608563,
0.0114247296,
0.0271821339,
0.0328416489,
0.0146952849,
0.0091983806,
0.0263809115,
-0.0208181161,
0.0747283176,
0.0181696527,
-0.0284743123,
-0.0090927025,
-0.0508247726,
-0.0018263273,
-0.0694143102,
0.0783065781,
-0.0423600748,
-0.0268139206,
-0.0387246013,
0.0210471675,
-0.012982483,
0.0054235035,
-0.00220973,
-0.0082125822,
0.0317796618,
0.0315065458,
-0.0372589231,
-0.0223689321,
-0.0914289355,
-0.0492832437,
0.0085996184,
-0.0684935525,
-0.0243881214,
-0.0611627139,
-0.0039750063,
0.0235892199,
-0.0641207099,
0.0176515058,
2.525918103e-34,
0.0498776548,
0.0043209218,
0.0215557963,
-0.0000783875,
0.044162523,
-0.0137826838,
-0.0252751019,
0.0074682469,
-0.0045569865,
-0.0806239694,
-0.0050314791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15141v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15141v2 | SpecTr: Fast Speculative Decoding via Optimal Transport | 2023-10-23T17:47:34 | 2024-01-18T04:42:34 | Ziteng Sun, Ananda Theertha Suresh, Jae Hun Ro, Ahmad Beirami, Himanshu Jain, Felix Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DS, cs.IT, math.IT | Autoregressive sampling from large language models has led to
state-of-the-art results in several natural language tasks. However,
autoregressive sampling generates tokens one at a time making it slow, and even
prohibitive in certain tasks. One way to speed up sampling is
$\textit{speculative decoding}$: use a small model to sample a $\textit{draft}$
(block or sequence of tokens), and then score all tokens in the draft by the
large language model in parallel. A subset of the tokens in the draft are
accepted (and the rest rejected) based on a statistical method to guarantee
that the final output follows the distribution of the large model. In this
work, we provide a principled understanding of speculative decoding through the
lens of optimal transport (OT) with $\textit{membership cost}$. This framework
can be viewed as an extension of the well-known $\textit{maximal-coupling}$
problem. This new formulation enables us to generalize the speculative decoding
method to allow for a set of $k$ candidates at the token-level, which leads to
an improved optimal membership cost. We show that the optimal draft selection
algorithm (transport plan) can be computed via linear programming, whose
best-known runtime is exponential in $k$. We then propose a valid draft
selection algorithm whose acceptance probability is $(1-1/e)$-optimal
multiplicatively. Moreover, it can be computed in time almost linear with size
of domain of a single token. Using this $new draft selection$ algorithm, we
develop a new autoregressive sampling algorithm called $\textit{SpecTr}$, which
provides speedup in decoding while ensuring that there is no quality
degradation in the decoded output. We experimentally demonstrate that for
state-of-the-art large language models, the proposed approach achieves a wall
clock speedup of 2.13X, a further 1.37X speedup over speculative decoding on
standard benchmarks. | [
0.0394643545,
0.0939023495,
-0.0295628104,
-0.0086426931,
-0.0762322918,
0.0062558819,
-0.0334811844,
0.0408531912,
-0.0644728839,
-0.0150601333,
0.0341018811,
-0.0920560881,
0.006588629,
0.0452424996,
-0.0053010555,
-0.035000883,
0.019572001,
-0.0883072615,
0.0133001544,
-0.0187788606,
-0.0162852257,
0.0067245443,
-0.0099189188,
0.0193242952,
0.0026782465,
-0.0010038934,
-0.0297739245,
-0.0176979676,
-0.0379911363,
-0.0324325897,
-0.0425089113,
0.0599622428,
0.0117667671,
0.0184562057,
0.0000024704,
-0.0072893063,
-0.0667068511,
-0.0095064109,
-0.035440769,
-0.0089876503,
0.0413859636,
-0.0267713889,
-0.0226852559,
0.017437581,
-0.0100344326,
-0.0277175661,
0.0694081709,
0.0064099692,
0.0046153422,
0.0465371683,
0.0024213167,
0.015867155,
0.0255501997,
0.0106445849,
-0.0473954603,
-0.0680929348,
0.0241990238,
-0.0111153023,
-0.006369153,
0.0196104459,
-0.0466808192,
0.0244689826,
-0.00767698,
-0.0186728127,
0.047713086,
0.0253187679,
-0.0531003624,
-0.0259068739,
-0.024354754,
0.050283879,
0.0124940211,
-0.0506150573,
0.0021335823,
0.013276617,
-0.054319758,
-0.0149855074,
-0.0382603556,
0.0118758855,
-0.024973277,
0.0431970097,
0.0415379368,
0.0247231685,
0.0379224047,
0.0075081252,
-0.056500826,
0.0757268593,
0.0279958583,
-0.0184513535,
-0.0092442911,
0.0369713306,
-0.0360321105,
-0.0516105257,
0.0409892872,
-0.0427344479,
-0.0711569041,
-0.0150341475,
-0.0372455195,
-0.0843959674,
-0.054969687,
0.0363553725,
0.0270347018,
0.0293614361,
0.0667454973,
0.0316148885,
0.0122745549,
-0.0259402692,
-0.0181289241,
-0.0133595765,
-0.0402460136,
-0.0153445695,
-0.012408237,
0.0005927071,
-0.0847331882,
0.0761320665,
-0.0716283619,
-0.0353756025,
-0.0176231842,
0.0156191923,
0.0150943194,
-0.0327239744,
0.0276187193,
-0.0232122336,
-0.0604080968,
0.0068143983,
0.0231061131,
-0.01738769,
-0.0196243431,
0.0053755152,
-0.0068764659,
-0.0157140456,
-0.0379771888,
0.0091601247,
0.0188378729,
-0.0446639694,
-0.0575749166,
0.08735843,
-0.014341834,
-0.0076212804,
0.0032989592,
-0.0171446763,
-0.0058608651,
-0.0354114622,
-0.0137205105,
-0.0596154816,
0.0368318222,
0.0029748993,
0.0242555887,
-0.00283425,
-0.0388172939,
-0.0044677267,
-0.0238165855,
0.0575934574,
-0.0142029198,
0.0003022188,
0.0047376901,
-0.0185736138,
-0.0219426807,
0.095870927,
0.0121790916,
0.0379369892,
0.0351559184,
-0.0163068306,
-0.0060280319,
0.0713985711,
0.023456756,
0.0211507902,
-0.0044440785,
-0.0276275314,
0.0455172285,
-0.0015515161,
0.0520834401,
0.0619707182,
-0.0822600126,
-0.0003419297,
0.0299316123,
0.0600285977,
0.0426778011,
0.0050672824,
0.0226735529,
0.0542609915,
-0.0214854609,
0.020793654,
0.0137330964,
0.0034211422,
-0.0061936709,
-0.0235274993,
0.0547284447,
0.0351810604,
-0.0067226742,
0.0172696542,
0.0186734051,
-0.0163775589,
0.0207373146,
-0.016529562,
0.0936803892,
0.0073617883,
-0.073650606,
0.0564345606,
0.021839356,
-0.0074057807,
0.0169477835,
-0.013645892,
-0.0121797863,
0.0264787823,
0.0584869832,
0.0186373927,
0.0460389927,
-0.0168464929,
-0.0282678548,
0.0233147442,
0.0224178731,
-0.0138708102,
0.0277898014,
-0.0451068394,
-0.0185171217,
0.083189033,
0.0050575659,
0.0304621104,
0.0132045923,
0.0247501768,
-0.021817768,
-0.0191620328,
-0.00036548,
0.0282750968,
0.0323777534,
-0.0238728411,
0.0411955602,
0.0175152794,
0.0809752047,
0.0215748269,
-0.0015399319,
0.0210995283,
0.0240264982,
-0.0462985076,
-0.0282134023,
0.0199407823,
-0.0295233615,
-0.0416387394,
-0.0077208299,
-0.0400356017,
-0.044642102,
0.0436441973,
-0.0056573157,
-0.0498276502,
0.0508534536,
-0.0393882841,
0.0412236229,
-0.0391909331,
0.0510394461,
0.0121969245,
0.0144897355,
-0.0099150352,
0.0418649018,
0.0056849048,
0.0075732321,
0.0114346566,
-0.0337112695,
0.013819336,
-0.0736338496,
-0.0224162675,
0.0379033387,
-0.0324351713,
0.0118615432,
0.0375089757,
-0.0196893048,
-0.0012810166,
-0.0157285538,
-0.0751718357,
0.0125287613,
-0.0193920229,
0.0270537511,
-0.0223768689,
0.0227134656,
0.0123169441,
0.0134358639,
-0.0078502344,
-0.0156311709,
-0.0236816816,
0.0037314391,
-0.0000305625,
-0.0020708505,
-0.0269080456,
0.0154305855,
-0.03987737,
0.0134865567,
0.016005028,
-0.0193017367,
-0.034025304,
-0.0757616907,
0.0056147547,
0.0385164768,
-0.0090555632,
0.0164525937,
-0.0347529575,
-0.0186506175,
-0.0442660935,
-0.0216636993,
-0.0082540438,
0.0021123064,
-0.0143673318,
-0.0153795555,
0.0012796792,
-0.0291452352,
0.0002942524,
-0.0371781774,
0.0393151008,
-0.0303771142,
-0.0332899354,
0.0467133,
0.0697623938,
0.031772878,
-0.0062350258,
-0.0716538206,
-0.0139306253,
-0.044677835,
-0.0470442064,
-0.0170182846,
-0.0190066397,
-0.0243354533,
0.0598473102,
-0.0280630756,
-0.0112803532,
0.0697146505,
-0.0423425734,
0.0057612001,
-0.0607986972,
0.0110700615,
-0.033511091,
0.0182872396,
-0.0020880592,
0.0132518206,
-0.0116354013,
-0.053061448,
0.0192634184,
0.0153140714,
0.0239706915,
-0.0142411198,
0.0404248908,
-0.0317466408,
0.0563670732,
0.0016617507,
-0.0605998375,
-0.0040354757,
-0.0590367168,
-0.0118411453,
-0.0233569965,
0.0574720614,
0.0027453024,
-0.0228134897,
0.0285074245,
-0.0548796766,
0.0339900218,
-0.0138347223,
0.0257467814,
-0.0171493292,
0.0331565663,
0.0395873226,
-0.0453325249,
0.0293216072,
-0.031751737,
0.0466826223,
0.0638572127,
0.0683743656,
0.0479094274,
-0.014611993,
0.0282967538,
0.0597168766,
-0.0116592925,
-0.0386171751,
0.02580286,
0.0712155476,
-0.0163180679,
-0.0344888531,
0.0778975859,
0.0022116988,
-0.0250826068,
0.0085859522,
0.0566193126,
0.0605611391,
-0.0524947271,
0.0121208914,
-0.0610320047,
-0.0226786956,
0.0544286966,
0.023044873,
-0.0170258004,
-0.0478761308,
-0.0057097711,
-0.1116259322,
0.0392109156,
0.032239031,
-0.0328989327,
0.0200453866,
-0.043507643,
-0.0247664824,
-0.0174713153,
0.0294655487,
0.0239124261,
0.0225241203,
-0.007855163,
0.0286248494,
-0.0007317234,
0.0181712136,
-0.007655785,
-0.0108189778,
0.0896832868,
0.0387921035,
0.0314402804,
-0.0092542032,
0.0104622608,
0.0324352682,
-0.0227862485,
-0.0348672122,
-0.0173343122,
0.0176532492,
0.0117306877,
0.0075126449,
0.0161051545,
0.0183485523,
-0.0529449619,
-0.0196301136,
0.0025568374,
0.0605501831,
-0.0064008571,
-0.0351980552,
-0.0151169766,
-0.0099875983,
0.0432710201,
0.0778492689,
-0.0095276656,
-0.0411236174,
-0.0154115064,
-0.0512784719,
-0.0076974337,
-0.118110396,
0.0126826391,
-0.0066147223,
0.0239201263,
-0.0090641864,
-0.0863420367,
0.0239989832,
0.0540881492,
0.0892851651,
-0.0057041259,
0.1027777046,
0.0138452081,
-0.0173138492,
-0.028482154,
-0.0194312967,
-0.0606844872,
-0.0047778208,
-0.0511546172,
0.0092922095,
-0.0037376299,
-0.0300952811,
-0.0349090956,
0.0068511348,
-0.0886137187,
-0.0709236562,
0.0190284941,
0.0182898436,
0.033633437,
0.0073708533,
-0.0464840196,
-0.0436844192,
0.0395693481,
0.014191485,
-0.065286532,
0.0039538988,
-0.0099618649,
-0.0268615615,
-0.0086593321,
0.033597786,
-0.0240188316,
0.0106375702,
-0.0084740315,
0.0452188142,
0.0035093718,
0.0019049289,
0.0325012729,
0.0372695141,
0.0205801744,
-0.0124303699,
-0.0035007519,
0.0100653749,
0.0381956547,
0.0027291442,
-0.0036851652,
-0.0360214561,
0.0358048677,
0.0268495921,
-0.0361498296,
-0.0215015523,
-0.0342016853,
0.0262285359,
0.0236439407,
0.0353284255,
-0.0140895396,
0.0004667843,
0.0139280008,
0.0919291601,
0.0022406005,
0.0022233012,
0.0009792115,
0.0267905388,
0.0471109226,
-0.0197858214,
-0.0191250332,
0.0371456258,
0.0291913021,
-0.025677735,
-0.0332391933,
-0.058346726,
-0.0478786901,
-0.0141115673,
0.03618294,
0.0123304147,
-0.0316273719,
0.02657355,
-0.0055295671,
-0.0040970058,
-0.0310092848,
0.0103818672,
0.0171565898,
0.0012081689,
0.0230282564,
0.0236306135,
-0.0205111261,
0.0167583991,
0.050143946,
-0.0085271886,
0.0389740616,
0.0014134303,
0.0036793961,
-0.0440542102,
0.008474295,
-0.0453992225,
0.0456591919,
-0.0250712689,
0.0201503728,
-0.0330558494,
-0.0557540394,
0.0361076258,
-0.0120890038,
0.0186631195,
-0.0055915667,
0.0489555299,
0.0356099755,
0.0085521322,
0.0051114233,
-0.03836767,
-0.0161772892,
0.0418788642,
-0.0311221387,
0.0041517257,
-7.378944647e-33,
0.0026180386,
-0.0240267385,
-0.0264702681,
-0.0145066362,
-0.0019663158,
-0.0081740171,
-0.0159081258,
-0.0438498929,
0.0313976146,
0.0083777914,
-0.0392357223,
-0.0028933738,
0.0338185839,
0.0533647016,
0.0057743904,
0.0308506563,
0.0664735883,
-0.0316471606,
-0.0300709438,
0.0039703506,
0.042713698,
0.0356552564,
-0.0146184368,
0.0173801798,
0.0048079318,
-0.0241026785,
-0.0128428666,
0.0248627439,
0.0511369668,
0.0627743453,
-0.0164224431,
0.0175489336,
0.0207851361,
-0.055600252,
-0.0358805358,
0.0287774149,
-0.0996734798,
-0.0187324546,
0.0297536757,
0.0104762595,
-0.0069600013,
-0.0355904587,
-0.0153158111,
-0.0066196774,
-0.0372577868,
0.0059155533,
-0.0177785475,
-0.0050863065,
-0.0461674593,
-0.0152489906,
-0.0238153636,
0.0236776285,
-0.0065131094,
0.0478284955,
0.1111015156,
0.0182461068,
-0.0165288951,
-0.0086608352,
-0.0266263168,
0.0321886465,
-0.0434334911,
0.0471606702,
0.0175992735,
-0.0214727782,
0.0074505676,
0.0553198643,
0.0201503709,
-0.052440282,
0.0034176933,
-0.0259863082,
0.0109790657,
-0.0138114113,
-0.0387622863,
0.0373330303,
0.0831471905,
-0.0417443365,
-0.0475237854,
-0.0078478837,
0.0165008437,
0.0070046554,
0.0483053587,
0.024775682,
-0.0551641732,
-0.052026011,
-0.0899496824,
-0.0392462015,
-0.011796304,
-0.0178358685,
0.032245066,
0.0286361445,
-0.051045265,
-0.0401010066,
0.0615713336,
-0.0349793285,
-0.0549118966,
-0.0027105338,
-0.0080299424,
0.0061711622,
-0.0208946522,
0.0291953497,
-0.0202358011,
-0.0150111802,
0.0153454812,
-0.0217196252,
0.0029516083,
0.0079110786,
0.0218793303,
-0.0083745252,
-0.0545643754,
0.0079215113,
-0.0419120304,
0.0285402834,
0.0252204854,
0.0306562725,
0.0696389526,
0.0145547641,
0.0188329313,
0.0176922735,
0.0004857159,
0.0099176057,
-0.0225437339,
0.0301661752,
0.0035796908,
0.0230439156,
-0.0136302272,
0.0042587523,
-0.0231227223,
0.0058431281,
0.0680288598,
-0.0585271753,
-0.0285820067,
0.0479865447,
3.128e-7,
0.0356664918,
0.0487111807,
0.0685489774,
-0.0083335834,
0.011378984,
0.0217519365,
-0.0245836321,
0.023872491,
0.0261474028,
0.0126335332,
-0.0024249351,
0.0326153077,
0.0451874174,
-0.0058845803,
-0.1485616267,
-0.0115183238,
0.0167338364,
0.0083659366,
-0.0409329534,
-0.0469268486,
-0.0032868416,
0.0942587256,
-0.0146356532,
-0.0229692012,
-0.0025201291,
-0.0169763844,
0.0179084893,
-0.0229060091,
-0.02447588,
0.0360911898,
-0.0229009409,
-0.0265148319,
-0.0104150362,
0.0269641727,
-0.0277419426,
-0.0077976943,
0.0377850309,
0.0495240614,
-0.0112143783,
-0.0290037431,
0.0122537259,
-0.0096536474,
-0.0024754172,
0.0070207748,
0.0400101542,
-0.0355842002,
-0.0359318331,
-0.0155502809,
-0.0346251763,
-0.0178195611,
-0.0294744316,
0.0200613607,
0.0301218182,
0.055848226,
0.0377587229,
0.0521453805,
0.0103868973,
-0.0482057407,
0.0236665327,
-0.0375305898,
-0.0566982627,
-0.0342515744,
-0.0163136013,
0.0218595341,
0.0481849276,
-0.0842072219,
-0.0029136522,
3.165475421e-34,
0.0797953159,
0.0107067069,
0.0239496883,
0.0491768271,
0.0076499418,
-0.0340375043,
0.0321021453,
0.0393044651,
0.0080770999,
-0.0880172849,
-0.0285595432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15140v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15140v2 | AutoDAN: Interpretable Gradient-Based Adversarial Attacks on Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T17:46:07 | 2023-12-14T06:22:51 | Sicheng Zhu, Ruiyi Zhang, Bang An, Gang Wu, Joe Barrow, Zichao Wang, Furong Huang, Ani Nenkova, Tong Sun | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Safety alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) can be compromised with
manual jailbreak attacks and (automatic) adversarial attacks. Recent studies
suggest that defending against these attacks is possible: adversarial attacks
generate unlimited but unreadable gibberish prompts, detectable by
perplexity-based filters; manual jailbreak attacks craft readable prompts, but
their limited number due to the necessity of human creativity allows for easy
blocking. In this paper, we show that these solutions may be too optimistic. We
introduce AutoDAN, an interpretable, gradient-based adversarial attack that
merges the strengths of both attack types. Guided by the dual goals of
jailbreak and readability, AutoDAN optimizes and generates tokens one by one
from left to right, resulting in readable prompts that bypass perplexity
filters while maintaining high attack success rates. Notably, these prompts,
generated from scratch using gradients, are interpretable and diverse, with
emerging strategies commonly seen in manual jailbreak attacks. They also
generalize to unforeseen harmful behaviors and transfer to black-box LLMs
better than their unreadable counterparts when using limited training data or a
single proxy model. Furthermore, we show the versatility of AutoDAN by
automatically leaking system prompts using a customized objective. Our work
offers a new way to red-team LLMs and understand jailbreak mechanisms via
interpretability. | [
0.0216620266,
0.0830183402,
-0.0216933228,
0.0619570166,
-0.0001742706,
0.0015695335,
0.0318022259,
-0.0096675502,
0.0192239881,
-0.0184861645,
-0.0433994941,
-0.0147915119,
0.0230512805,
0.0230874959,
0.0531219766,
-0.0174265113,
0.0528074205,
-0.0417486243,
-0.0329135209,
-0.0043523232,
0.0205107015,
0.0031788356,
0.0220302008,
0.0539723299,
0.0105516706,
-0.0419180505,
-0.0204839092,
0.0260828026,
0.0111975325,
-0.0160135981,
0.0006601656,
0.045961529,
-0.0118674738,
0.0884448066,
0.0000020332,
-0.0140746739,
-0.0498636067,
0.009093334,
-0.0530799627,
0.0474875197,
-0.0168341491,
-0.0595090836,
-0.0364811569,
-0.0039400305,
-0.0335498564,
0.0088466825,
0.0325162932,
0.0449943505,
0.0925575644,
0.0840444937,
0.0063294116,
-0.0123855779,
0.0433899574,
-0.0408996269,
-0.0029560926,
-0.0871342793,
0.003359661,
-0.0362309888,
-0.0345572345,
0.019222891,
-0.02759373,
0.0196822379,
0.0340956673,
-0.009804735,
-0.0447911583,
-0.0100958571,
-0.0011287743,
-0.0347863622,
0.0052046292,
0.0848372951,
-0.0649089962,
-0.0103623094,
0.0112877218,
-0.0009162208,
0.0236779749,
-0.0095336139,
-0.0118183279,
0.0145911854,
0.0193401091,
0.0114150522,
-0.0045374595,
-0.0188741852,
0.0740446225,
-0.0149266953,
-0.0263388641,
0.0481113829,
0.0049949531,
-0.0052746497,
-0.0108052408,
-0.0442011617,
-0.0029289483,
-0.0504321791,
0.001112568,
-0.0096247792,
-0.0255672205,
0.0251495726,
-0.1063000932,
-0.0386211537,
0.0216343217,
-0.0045385989,
0.051749412,
0.016496893,
-0.0193280559,
0.0413851812,
-0.0115163457,
0.0343752168,
-0.0561246723,
0.0465673879,
-0.0087319724,
0.0085011246,
0.0166703947,
-0.0359742306,
-0.0007516796,
-0.0060399091,
-0.0319427326,
-0.006297552,
-0.0305438228,
0.0143891927,
-0.0206879079,
0.0304065067,
-0.0358674005,
0.0036494986,
-0.0208204705,
-0.0159686264,
0.0389913991,
-0.0353641175,
-0.0014071373,
-0.0339810662,
0.0043215035,
-0.0587041713,
-0.0457231775,
0.0144349616,
-0.0617264695,
-0.0271555819,
-0.0311680082,
0.1281983256,
0.0250419788,
-0.0062082116,
-0.0393851809,
-0.0720954016,
-0.0400479101,
-0.0346333385,
-0.0023422008,
-0.0431086831,
-0.0072282315,
-0.0207036845,
-0.0096688317,
-0.0904656202,
0.0191571414,
0.0120073352,
-0.0189559832,
0.0778413564,
0.0166344196,
-0.0248913672,
-0.0114054251,
0.0400665104,
0.0048193405,
0.0737335384,
-0.0008347889,
0.0695095435,
0.058875978,
-0.00753017,
0.0173070282,
0.0494761951,
0.0369478762,
0.0245646015,
-0.0230657291,
-0.0231895279,
0.0338656381,
0.0075255861,
0.0140719889,
0.0465666912,
-0.00913285,
-0.0582783669,
0.0684084743,
0.0319199413,
-0.0271118302,
0.0382519625,
-0.0047787279,
-0.0222455394,
0.0034623793,
0.0106133251,
-0.0831402019,
-0.0097218761,
-0.0461210757,
-0.0263109859,
0.0099292668,
0.0354947224,
-0.005295339,
-0.0315115042,
0.0186216012,
-0.0154898129,
-0.0028698565,
0.0110377623,
0.0274019782,
0.0204376094,
-0.0261784177,
0.0495407619,
0.0085061425,
-0.0094929682,
-0.0207116343,
-0.0763762146,
0.0113557642,
0.0468256734,
0.0560640693,
-0.0167501047,
0.0270151366,
-0.0178632103,
0.0165231787,
0.0129845971,
-0.008186548,
0.0195600055,
0.0390114002,
-0.0295237396,
-0.009549614,
-0.0306680743,
0.0405039452,
0.0356667079,
-0.0017933332,
-0.0069238311,
0.0047708647,
-0.0104983579,
-0.0501763858,
0.033772625,
-0.0037723037,
-0.0558115467,
0.0254290067,
0.0376394205,
0.0011062924,
0.0065068542,
-0.0291411206,
0.024490973,
0.0420415998,
-0.029399896,
0.0290949959,
-0.0188412778,
-0.0470300652,
-0.0263857767,
0.0161812771,
-0.0160706118,
-0.0496234968,
0.0847085789,
-0.0589848123,
-0.0051129819,
0.0558334738,
-0.0222145617,
0.0207546987,
0.0145087875,
0.0144932624,
0.0091966251,
0.05707445,
-0.0276481975,
0.0269743986,
-0.0314189643,
-0.0217738431,
-0.0111547895,
0.0135308784,
0.0293243229,
-0.0181105491,
-0.0554830432,
0.011469976,
-0.0346142836,
0.0088531552,
-0.0039017587,
0.0006260256,
0.0011426148,
-0.0111328578,
-0.014400214,
-0.0120100612,
-0.0296678655,
0.012640045,
0.046663288,
0.0125692012,
-0.0062429486,
-0.0235133264,
0.0057963561,
0.0062593534,
-0.0153948199,
-0.0040718177,
0.0063125417,
-0.0158986952,
-0.0383399948,
-0.033241082,
-0.023891218,
-0.0099508194,
0.0658147633,
-0.0254253987,
-0.0136655876,
-0.0307980124,
-0.0168757308,
0.027389301,
0.0351919606,
-0.035957057,
-0.0515463501,
0.0384357162,
0.0267934408,
-0.0174032766,
0.1140716448,
-0.0003889709,
0.0949907154,
0.052754458,
0.0195483081,
-0.0251828805,
-0.0135502368,
0.0478857867,
-0.0272421762,
-0.0438551269,
-0.0539989397,
0.0156446006,
0.0795272291,
0.0341848582,
-0.0003859914,
-0.0347150043,
0.0471665524,
-0.0165831521,
-0.0397820026,
-0.0359486602,
-0.0194638167,
-0.0440056436,
0.0201198459,
-0.0229550339,
-0.0717933476,
0.0644921288,
-0.0431166776,
0.0112883514,
0.0150138084,
-0.043419648,
-0.0022005348,
0.0682464615,
-0.0258062594,
0.0248026773,
0.0237709377,
-0.035749644,
-0.0517363138,
-0.029601194,
0.033947248,
-0.0133982301,
0.0571173243,
-0.0467614308,
-0.0178332888,
-0.0021854343,
-0.0284390673,
-0.0632780343,
-0.0618531667,
-0.0188935436,
-0.0212863851,
0.0553941131,
-0.053365346,
-0.0286775995,
-0.0223269425,
0.0268576816,
0.0030371337,
-0.0332500823,
0.0243839286,
-0.0370379575,
0.0136779165,
0.0609274544,
-0.0512578897,
0.0288323425,
-0.0358716846,
0.0503533632,
0.0856319293,
0.0096208686,
0.0345869772,
-0.0101786125,
-0.0051058452,
0.0172313303,
0.023931371,
-0.0168345738,
0.0094049219,
0.0529051237,
-0.0525030978,
-0.014618706,
0.0398911089,
0.0063825529,
-0.0154057574,
0.0367833599,
0.0213916656,
0.0337679237,
-0.0079274746,
0.0031529195,
-0.0630583614,
-0.0422172546,
0.028230343,
0.0642983094,
-0.0053175786,
-0.0026196179,
-0.039181143,
-0.0705035701,
-0.0068999729,
0.0369566381,
-0.0389305502,
-0.0165914278,
-0.009992362,
-0.0352582298,
0.007544945,
0.0449022651,
-0.0105905822,
0.0194722749,
-0.0082219196,
-0.0030704238,
-0.0143592404,
-0.0312392563,
0.0077797328,
-0.0072813327,
0.0639113709,
0.1036000848,
0.0003927331,
-0.0167271495,
-0.0014015506,
0.0723376498,
-0.0104329158,
-0.0015141435,
0.0182219446,
0.0254236013,
0.006609688,
-0.0298293568,
-0.0013787749,
0.062430907,
-0.0191754997,
-0.0205773897,
0.0260548685,
0.0375049151,
0.0051939194,
-0.0175091401,
-0.0181540009,
-0.0243911538,
0.032776054,
0.0577338859,
0.0373292789,
-0.0567912757,
-0.041830536,
-0.0772649571,
-0.0174562801,
-0.0712937713,
-0.0598787814,
0.0287820026,
0.0353852659,
-0.0447743051,
-0.0316919126,
-0.0197516978,
-0.0354996212,
0.0432737917,
0.0214940198,
0.0024061743,
-0.0322867222,
0.004401091,
-0.0176744387,
0.014107313,
0.0009435476,
0.0480647944,
-0.0652582645,
0.0099089276,
-0.0119534861,
-0.0127643282,
-0.0301990453,
0.023019487,
-0.0682764202,
-0.0903866217,
0.0368380994,
0.0515050106,
0.0220105648,
0.0277242195,
-0.039057184,
-0.0694184527,
0.0501539707,
0.0756758973,
-0.0197271984,
0.0137359854,
0.0703188553,
-0.0249305572,
0.0099627804,
0.0638945773,
-0.0486580916,
-0.0213515088,
0.0629627183,
-0.0056974418,
-0.0321150571,
0.0215386581,
0.0210560802,
0.0150764976,
0.0377201699,
-0.0134714274,
-0.0075192861,
0.0095096147,
0.0242752992,
-0.0110408813,
-0.0297763832,
-0.0267030224,
0.0150901536,
0.0445612073,
-0.048447039,
0.0153443422,
0.0014024117,
0.0275194887,
-0.0036739758,
0.0050411746,
0.0278578904,
-0.0054931697,
0.0702682957,
0.0564334393,
0.0207320824,
-0.0237452034,
0.0789829791,
-0.020744551,
0.0336707421,
-0.0000981417,
0.0384750292,
0.0188238081,
-0.0177637096,
-0.0351287387,
0.0596777163,
-0.0813523158,
-0.0618511476,
0.0065074745,
0.0430761501,
0.0166294239,
-0.0007881014,
0.0114285983,
-0.0094339643,
-0.0051362775,
-0.0289894864,
-0.0019892305,
0.0096309213,
-0.0303521045,
0.0355925113,
-0.0019565907,
-0.0028179151,
0.015822975,
0.0860316232,
0.019012874,
0.0293205716,
0.0454742648,
-0.0054224948,
-0.0369701385,
-0.017593924,
0.050524801,
0.0127305472,
-0.0523902886,
-0.0197866745,
-0.0457885228,
-0.0957329273,
-0.0456342809,
0.0285143144,
-0.0023024471,
0.0102375532,
-0.0384063534,
0.0446246639,
0.0004192396,
0.0253242794,
-0.0432522297,
0.0549916737,
-0.0018869598,
-0.0662974715,
0.0091342134,
-6.167671187e-33,
0.0241688006,
-0.0345140174,
-0.0540215895,
-0.0636052042,
0.0170370974,
0.0052106255,
-0.0333720706,
0.0097700208,
-0.0292226374,
-0.0041817739,
-0.0088895634,
0.007968436,
-0.0043481179,
0.0222568493,
-0.0317220502,
-0.0474103354,
0.0219596736,
0.0100758905,
-0.0274633188,
0.0409778655,
0.0533573329,
0.0309077688,
0.0194754805,
-0.056043867,
0.0618027039,
-0.029482916,
-0.0298943408,
0.0227856468,
-0.0291122068,
0.0600240603,
-0.0077642496,
0.0118192984,
-0.0126212267,
-0.0215975437,
-0.0103362417,
0.0401082002,
-0.0169291236,
-0.0014152782,
0.0107846521,
0.033183217,
-0.0418683477,
-0.0485514998,
0.0307663772,
-0.0166943874,
0.0037582777,
-0.0207730271,
0.0001852194,
-0.0027535663,
-0.0156309903,
0.011173781,
-0.0272535514,
0.0176712368,
-0.0310855098,
-0.0399670005,
0.0007519628,
0.0086773084,
0.0293112714,
0.0083827572,
-0.0391007401,
-0.0021320705,
0.0011713566,
0.0167194717,
0.0787778795,
0.0195132978,
0.0052723028,
0.0735448599,
0.0210327748,
-0.0359858982,
-0.0193946045,
-0.0159317404,
0.009602854,
0.0335034803,
0.0451346934,
0.0792101696,
0.070368886,
-0.0318609439,
-0.0839686841,
-0.0087708868,
-0.0260098893,
0.0325230658,
0.0235033706,
0.0131111853,
-0.0517119393,
0.0051032729,
-0.0133777466,
-0.0767997205,
-0.0234879535,
-0.0352601893,
0.0293475036,
-0.0083884215,
-0.045973707,
-0.0391024463,
-0.0011244983,
-0.0633143485,
-0.0292401519,
0.0364311077,
0.0064975885,
-0.0325505137,
0.0023546293,
0.0434702113,
0.0044537601,
0.0098067503,
0.0127160735,
-0.0394286141,
0.0580721721,
0.0186758954,
0.0476297997,
0.0203959998,
-0.0473945551,
-0.0060416576,
-0.0367454886,
0.0298591834,
0.0176069383,
0.0098815467,
0.0510354824,
-0.0111341076,
-0.0220146906,
0.01445264,
0.0172723457,
0.0125426734,
-0.01749973,
0.0280146506,
-0.037463069,
0.0238099955,
-0.0162965674,
-0.0228091087,
-0.0032103858,
0.0296765454,
0.0574195422,
-0.0869476572,
0.0082780067,
-0.0067465696,
2.725e-7,
0.0055240355,
-0.0034541932,
0.0208531227,
0.0006858025,
0.0299017485,
0.0734077692,
-0.0220498703,
0.0688283965,
-0.0367164724,
-0.0327596851,
-0.0315383337,
0.0100597916,
0.0730319917,
0.0273774248,
-0.0419564843,
0.0464396067,
-0.0640777573,
0.0275766775,
-0.0582649484,
0.0008959445,
0.035745196,
0.1217701063,
0.0125370929,
-0.0143013,
0.0375985391,
-0.0465053841,
0.0001188971,
-0.0137786148,
0.0301570967,
-0.021580264,
0.0278010201,
0.0049431892,
0.0082754875,
-0.002793649,
-0.0162268505,
-0.00471015,
-0.0264889468,
0.040419884,
-0.0025242171,
-0.0320127271,
-0.0439352952,
-0.0246092174,
-0.0105248205,
-0.0737983212,
0.0666460469,
0.0003502764,
-0.0287830122,
-0.046017319,
0.0347689353,
-0.0328096375,
0.0384106897,
-0.0249159168,
-0.0137223992,
0.0067283702,
0.0192072,
-0.0047537754,
0.0249178205,
-0.0787581354,
-0.0240777805,
-0.0254339911,
-0.0192945562,
-0.0161121432,
-0.0406705514,
0.0387263484,
0.0434076265,
-0.0302150715,
-0.0009396379,
2.588856412e-34,
-0.0003928759,
-0.0562072843,
0.0200367272,
0.0070171156,
0.0251972545,
0.0058513097,
0.0126937376,
0.0054897587,
0.0208790693,
-0.0446173325,
-0.0442006513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15135v1 | Quantifying the Dialect Gap and its Correlates Across Languages | 2023-10-23T17:42:01 | 2023-10-23T17:42:01 | Anjali Kantharuban, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Historically, researchers and consumers have noticed a decrease in quality
when applying NLP tools to minority variants of languages (i.e. Puerto Rican
Spanish or Swiss German), but studies exploring this have been limited to a
select few languages. Additionally, past studies have mainly been conducted in
a monolingual context, so cross-linguistic trends have not been identified and
tied to external factors. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation
of the most influential, state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) across
two high-use applications, machine translation and automatic speech
recognition, to assess their functionality on the regional dialects of several
high- and low-resource languages. Additionally, we analyze how the regional
dialect gap is correlated with economic, social, and linguistic factors. The
impact of training data, including related factors like dataset size and its
construction procedure, is shown to be significant but not consistent across
models or languages, meaning a one-size-fits-all approach cannot be taken in
solving the dialect gap. This work will lay the foundation for furthering the
field of dialectal NLP by laying out evident disparities and identifying
possible pathways for addressing them through mindful data collection. | [
0.0139404573,
0.110812895,
-0.026895551,
0.0263771806,
-0.0327969193,
0.0051691858,
0.0305770747,
-0.0280343387,
-0.0264806375,
-0.036348179,
-0.0327633694,
-0.0352431089,
0.0671490058,
-0.0112561313,
0.0260228794,
-0.0471703783,
0.0139533654,
-0.0274831243,
-0.0401904359,
-0.0347243734,
0.0074706129,
0.012383623,
0.0354714394,
0.053958077,
0.0076383674,
0.0186942834,
0.0254599582,
0.014203121,
-0.0088359378,
-0.0063390872,
-0.0074577485,
0.0203849301,
-0.0079865148,
0.0720274672,
0.000001994,
-0.0786292851,
-0.001646537,
-0.0022310668,
-0.0287062023,
0.0621252693,
0.0617397949,
-0.0403588191,
-0.0312523656,
0.0247764215,
-0.0285937265,
-0.0256078914,
0.0690604299,
-0.0169599578,
0.0327313058,
0.0082703931,
-0.0165811181,
-0.0613406263,
-0.0086480174,
-0.0308475234,
-0.0875128806,
-0.0057551228,
0.0099340137,
-0.0078831669,
-0.0112340804,
-0.0377308987,
-0.0333341025,
0.0560325906,
0.0051091793,
-0.0066026417,
-0.0479596816,
-0.0052498914,
-0.0613312088,
-0.029369697,
-0.0121448226,
0.0358652882,
-0.0180775803,
-0.0422882959,
0.0064055738,
0.0262884349,
-0.0239828713,
0.0151543301,
-0.0349514522,
0.0244656969,
0.0114261778,
0.0235292986,
0.0419953018,
0.0276138056,
0.025484575,
-0.003678302,
-0.0417709984,
0.0485611223,
0.0356935076,
-0.0277098008,
0.0076878727,
0.0372425355,
-0.0301447734,
-0.0285257325,
0.024289446,
-0.0181213021,
-0.0161943175,
0.016391119,
0.0284751318,
-0.00240347,
0.0170962997,
-0.0232762415,
0.0158467032,
0.0224363785,
-0.031519901,
0.0220466275,
0.0098324977,
0.0185789876,
-0.0126306294,
0.0088742031,
-0.038092006,
-0.0344715342,
-0.0328030139,
0.0142665859,
-0.0324199609,
-0.0301109888,
-0.0509652719,
0.0346841924,
-0.0018641076,
-0.0181083828,
0.0073222923,
0.0054959166,
0.0453371145,
-0.0214602947,
-0.037515495,
-0.0118939308,
0.0015757576,
0.0734628066,
-0.0139997685,
-0.0138260378,
-0.0400568098,
-0.0800825655,
0.0410033129,
0.0035024693,
-0.0290956907,
-0.0318100601,
-0.0035346805,
0.0205286015,
0.0126038948,
-0.0228206739,
-0.0860849768,
0.0122875189,
-0.0673065856,
-0.0821859092,
-0.0366708785,
-0.0824047029,
0.034338586,
0.0190948844,
0.0232316051,
-0.0315653794,
-0.0205966979,
-0.0303233806,
-0.0146888867,
0.0186013784,
-0.0104391417,
0.0389059037,
0.0693171546,
-0.0328813978,
0.0257245768,
0.0987085551,
0.017103266,
-0.0402477905,
0.0611559339,
-0.029175695,
-0.0697364584,
0.0586529337,
0.0070552053,
0.040401727,
-0.0591835193,
-0.0113308765,
-0.019010989,
0.0062623774,
0.0490776971,
0.0656578764,
0.0105791008,
-0.0120323729,
0.0930879936,
0.0610213727,
0.0135119455,
0.0090435315,
0.0394803137,
0.0745887756,
-0.0144217825,
-0.0182325095,
0.0245768726,
-0.0599247515,
-0.0057144514,
0.0044364552,
-0.0018733999,
0.0887887627,
-0.0246265884,
-0.0363425612,
-0.0258895978,
0.0091819223,
0.0085513769,
0.0252975486,
0.0806923509,
-0.021980904,
-0.0015566275,
0.043102365,
0.0474740602,
-0.013388739,
0.0210028533,
-0.0347720794,
-0.0147403367,
0.0394860581,
0.0172444135,
0.0271773152,
0.0302228816,
-0.0041930457,
0.0175183546,
0.0531759635,
0.0481098071,
-0.0029296703,
0.0365124419,
-0.0453889109,
0.0331816524,
0.0436611362,
0.0320334584,
0.0429889522,
0.0264253821,
0.0343581624,
0.0022118082,
-0.0499343462,
-0.0257733874,
-0.0047851056,
-0.0360600911,
0.0056624897,
0.0182201881,
0.0009824091,
0.0242400691,
0.0534836277,
-0.0415218398,
-0.0168894194,
0.0024545572,
-0.0131623717,
0.0319174752,
0.069637835,
-0.0026421577,
-0.0347638093,
0.0107454807,
0.0050695851,
0.0000438636,
-0.0224713106,
0.0137746269,
-0.0481176451,
0.0518612415,
-0.043819651,
0.0761622936,
-0.0478764176,
0.0473225303,
-0.0366972759,
0.0079683131,
-0.056264665,
0.0187435932,
-0.0198360961,
-0.0026098632,
0.0223901514,
-0.01728734,
0.0118810078,
-0.0418142602,
-0.0256947055,
0.0467228182,
-0.0049285912,
0.0285478067,
0.0047204164,
0.0058517703,
0.0275847074,
-0.0237450786,
-0.0925973728,
0.0054930495,
-0.0431309976,
0.0086090462,
0.0120760389,
0.0198940225,
-0.0251115561,
0.010797509,
0.0206985306,
-0.0157713443,
0.0210034046,
0.0269887764,
-0.0085125053,
0.0026588596,
0.0048511373,
-0.0399396271,
-0.0112410765,
0.0317392163,
0.0484429821,
-0.0204933677,
-0.0450398624,
-0.0268423837,
0.0232771672,
-0.0109541798,
0.031303484,
-0.0140003292,
-0.0481761284,
-0.0157382116,
-0.0104454793,
0.0564408191,
0.0360724628,
-0.026317548,
0.0054198173,
0.0205426589,
-0.0539277643,
-0.0587508902,
-0.0173600763,
-0.0148117775,
-0.0244726371,
-0.0717933103,
-0.0797237456,
-0.0069901077,
0.1237512305,
0.0129204607,
-0.0138242785,
-0.0312734209,
-0.0111999782,
-0.0601965301,
0.0013939932,
0.011755242,
0.0518768728,
-0.0178975705,
0.0548568964,
-0.0413960889,
-0.056168437,
0.0235500298,
-0.0618676133,
-0.0069018709,
-0.0251006186,
-0.0452566557,
-0.0595130697,
0.0427732989,
-0.0063696522,
0.0207506698,
-0.0122734625,
-0.0441580676,
0.0013791852,
-0.0053658686,
0.0156620536,
0.0025818567,
0.0811190754,
-0.0668061823,
0.0275765713,
-0.0081466986,
-0.0427017845,
0.0214596167,
-0.0293052774,
-0.0620914958,
-0.0193282012,
0.0693798512,
-0.0375570171,
0.0191626493,
0.0405221656,
-0.0161266997,
0.0406341851,
-0.0044745104,
0.0147682047,
0.0046746638,
-0.0035373012,
0.0144906733,
0.0339680091,
0.0294427071,
-0.027546281,
0.0394005775,
-0.0396538861,
0.0212384649,
0.0287608318,
-0.0181060713,
-0.0141726555,
0.03711766,
-0.0197063666,
-0.0387960002,
-0.002656186,
0.0645975992,
-0.0187692437,
0.017507812,
0.0758146942,
0.0216295626,
-0.0100708986,
0.0101287998,
-0.0310065262,
0.0778290257,
0.0213586371,
0.0142541565,
-0.06182345,
-0.0066743861,
0.0306348503,
0.0363565125,
-0.0049691801,
0.0015899867,
-0.0177351404,
-0.1212006137,
0.0119364168,
0.0087034358,
-0.0135252755,
0.0031878336,
-0.0006760643,
-0.0397806019,
-0.0591795892,
0.0232900828,
-0.0142055862,
-0.0270139314,
-0.0110287089,
0.0582525246,
-0.0632230863,
-0.0939795151,
0.012369018,
-0.0353298783,
0.0241210386,
-0.0046806638,
0.013327728,
-0.039614398,
-0.0194734558,
0.0188880581,
-0.0089080753,
0.0079292143,
-0.0180322994,
0.0050534066,
0.0308021344,
-0.0272217747,
-0.022168085,
-0.0120383669,
-0.0232620388,
0.0377626009,
0.0293345712,
0.0179867893,
-0.008004888,
0.0218864195,
0.0327227786,
-0.0145898852,
-0.0218558311,
0.0317226797,
0.022617301,
-0.0511720888,
-0.0170680657,
0.0028511558,
-0.012714698,
-0.008284932,
-0.0086469706,
0.0367175676,
-0.0089762872,
-0.0499836989,
-0.0249436274,
-0.0519757867,
0.0258111972,
0.0197266843,
0.0397459716,
0.006415938,
0.0454587303,
-0.0140496911,
-0.0315442532,
0.0490272678,
-0.0264024958,
0.0161109511,
-0.054252658,
-0.0212596636,
0.0375727899,
-0.0356137939,
-0.0064079431,
-0.0273457505,
-0.0997787192,
-0.0817735419,
0.0299332365,
0.0069120671,
0.0295976624,
0.0348575711,
-0.0204097852,
-0.0559103601,
-0.0113351448,
0.000928906,
0.0186290145,
0.0032139788,
0.0330189578,
-0.0043350928,
-0.0098192738,
0.0246902052,
0.0110056615,
0.0060647395,
-0.0242172647,
0.0404578112,
-0.0835185796,
-0.0325788073,
-0.0122715859,
-0.0114680901,
0.0273777451,
-0.0482676663,
-0.0102775237,
-0.0552376546,
-0.0183464717,
0.0056520794,
0.0333142281,
-0.0282990616,
-0.0288826078,
0.0596902817,
0.0280545615,
-0.0351427905,
0.0254080053,
-0.0225140117,
0.0224229023,
-0.0111675141,
0.0514832437,
0.0005798128,
0.0243741386,
0.0356466509,
0.02150557,
-0.0014447342,
0.075762406,
0.0037232088,
0.0499503389,
0.0040893359,
0.0559668019,
-0.0273010191,
-0.0110869249,
0.0376822539,
0.0173055995,
0.0117253726,
-0.0293451808,
-0.0075651482,
0.020260334,
0.0897507742,
-0.0236222036,
0.0879724175,
0.0212518442,
-0.001247097,
-0.0251621474,
0.0285085496,
0.0250067785,
-0.0308708865,
-0.0031525926,
-0.0151279587,
-0.0449782759,
0.0509744771,
0.0656187907,
0.0605164655,
0.0105791213,
0.007039459,
0.0020373417,
-0.0003937698,
-0.0446266159,
0.0310210641,
-0.0279386956,
-0.0518294908,
-0.0262396093,
-0.1011285111,
-0.0580325723,
-0.0197735988,
-0.0256128218,
0.0128608998,
-0.0212983191,
-0.0178239457,
0.0640223771,
-0.0195269138,
0.0016851887,
-0.071721144,
-0.0043887915,
-0.023413863,
-0.0092699789,
0.0015994036,
-6.093170927e-33,
-0.0086027775,
-0.0293945335,
-0.002498108,
-0.063987419,
0.0035030839,
0.0104296915,
-0.0206669383,
0.0012462944,
-0.0283864774,
-0.018090155,
-0.0142154917,
-0.0182047151,
0.0277179778,
-0.0001997959,
0.0357532799,
0.0155861974,
0.0370351374,
0.0179791469,
0.0283668377,
-0.0165760778,
0.0061268485,
0.0126002505,
0.0702743232,
-0.0510210097,
0.0231877491,
-0.0129190041,
0.0079620248,
0.0029519021,
0.0198363811,
0.0417045839,
-0.0127505576,
0.0639301017,
0.0174747705,
-0.0421105064,
-0.019138366,
-0.0311727412,
-0.0454036854,
0.0046073264,
0.0415788703,
0.0599827729,
0.0409785621,
-0.0098499246,
0.0149941538,
0.000830592,
-0.0433124416,
0.0263861213,
-0.0014420907,
-0.0070513566,
-0.0107670063,
-0.00918118,
-0.0350241549,
0.0686545745,
-0.0021643674,
-0.003199731,
0.0506937616,
0.0411457457,
-0.0348705538,
-0.0012020923,
-0.0465473644,
0.0073715975,
0.0601833463,
0.0339344628,
0.0824347958,
0.0130364951,
-0.0001491783,
0.0024545565,
0.0521821305,
0.0020435883,
0.0399608798,
0.0079577351,
0.071291469,
-0.0085950969,
-0.006131588,
0.0546709299,
0.0357802287,
-0.0499865562,
-0.0038200291,
-0.031533096,
0.0326068401,
-0.0094778175,
-0.0044316077,
-0.0057910406,
-0.0543656647,
-0.0393443033,
-0.0562994108,
-0.0813382789,
0.0153876869,
-0.0069853426,
0.0458416305,
-0.0004732988,
0.0053051896,
0.0531487055,
0.0791910812,
-0.0286047757,
-0.0534171499,
-0.0244053379,
-0.0069415057,
0.0027784156,
-0.0309638139,
0.0620588996,
-0.0891558006,
-0.0124899587,
-0.0266108494,
0.0627337024,
-0.0117165847,
-0.0213519465,
0.0225615762,
0.007558248,
-0.0436751246,
0.0354952998,
-0.0172194466,
0.0332558677,
-0.0458493419,
0.0829662606,
0.0455126055,
-0.0142519874,
0.0034002799,
0.0521237031,
0.0309491977,
0.0007617369,
-0.0149869053,
0.0075022085,
-0.0004265085,
0.0319169983,
-0.0085220104,
0.0242948197,
-0.0037905001,
0.00041552,
0.0181426406,
-0.0079152742,
-0.0002445917,
-0.0214977376,
2.647e-7,
0.0181432497,
0.0602174029,
-0.0021512986,
-0.0119476244,
0.0264445543,
-0.0021080901,
0.003533293,
-0.0272113141,
-0.0092017995,
0.0111622829,
-0.0243551694,
0.0096101975,
0.1126700342,
0.0431369692,
-0.0835434198,
-0.0336328857,
-0.0658790991,
0.0156779829,
-0.0669320598,
-0.0048231157,
0.0090765134,
0.1124649793,
-0.0062726107,
-0.0153166661,
-0.0094540054,
-0.0343865044,
0.0527338721,
-0.0292233992,
-0.0449302532,
0.0334513597,
0.0149025498,
0.0127857765,
-0.0173086338,
-0.0152039109,
-0.0163936745,
0.0392785259,
-0.007221323,
0.0765641332,
-0.0052630063,
-0.0081163486,
0.0291990191,
-0.0459092557,
-0.0636886209,
-0.0685530081,
0.058263395,
-0.0135784699,
-0.0161906388,
-0.0080976579,
-0.0065972744,
-0.0072008022,
0.0159524102,
-0.056007687,
-0.0040316028,
0.0040338193,
0.0392014794,
-0.0671904013,
-0.0175741538,
-0.0226873998,
-0.0345969349,
0.0344324708,
-0.0136474157,
-0.0479506776,
0.0141420225,
0.0336324126,
-0.0203747582,
-0.0217474345,
0.0140851364,
2.5791494e-34,
0.0451722071,
0.0085054208,
0.0322905369,
-0.0104487268,
0.0422318503,
-0.0007305866,
-0.0328314379,
0.0212574694,
-0.0482075103,
-0.0128357206,
0.0124886148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15129v1 | Location-Aware Visual Question Generation with Lightweight Models | 2023-10-23T17:33:31 | 2023-10-23T17:33:31 | Nicholas Collin Suwono, Justin Chih-Yao Chen, Tun Min Hung, Ting-Hao Kenneth Huang, I-Bin Liao, Yung-Hui Li, Lun-Wei Ku, Shao-Hua Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work introduces a novel task, location-aware visual question generation
(LocaVQG), which aims to generate engaging questions from data relevant to a
particular geographical location. Specifically, we represent such
location-aware information with surrounding images and a GPS coordinate. To
tackle this task, we present a dataset generation pipeline that leverages GPT-4
to produce diverse and sophisticated questions. Then, we aim to learn a
lightweight model that can address the LocaVQG task and fit on an edge device,
such as a mobile phone. To this end, we propose a method which can reliably
generate engaging questions from location-aware information. Our proposed
method outperforms baselines regarding human evaluation (e.g., engagement,
grounding, coherence) and automatic evaluation metrics (e.g., BERTScore,
ROUGE-2). Moreover, we conduct extensive ablation studies to justify our
proposed techniques for both generating the dataset and solving the task. | [
0.0105138626,
0.0533301793,
-0.0067650508,
0.0060460013,
-0.0078406921,
0.0112598259,
0.0309897996,
-0.0215590186,
0.0111653367,
-0.0191902202,
0.0026320165,
-0.010770537,
-0.0113720549,
0.0421079993,
0.0431013703,
-0.0699790418,
-0.0232363064,
-0.0138014471,
-0.0277969651,
0.0124614937,
0.0098000057,
0.0099781025,
0.0001667725,
0.0392317846,
-0.0370786786,
-0.0045238268,
-0.0449125469,
0.0488585234,
0.0431492627,
-0.0789785758,
0.0114055071,
0.0259550698,
0.0339156166,
-0.0048437817,
0.0000018692,
0.0163109265,
0.0065604122,
-0.0106571075,
0.0200421587,
-0.0497625172,
0.0002643741,
0.0215738975,
0.0359494723,
0.0397407524,
-0.0647142529,
-0.0080442112,
0.0272615738,
0.0197445825,
0.0790465027,
0.0461150147,
-0.0305825975,
0.0112102786,
-0.0092643723,
-0.0136671728,
0.0735822544,
-0.0115144197,
-0.0450559556,
0.0299694445,
0.0076149693,
0.0136037832,
-0.0019102584,
0.0124526219,
0.0590303019,
0.0233884025,
0.0174938887,
0.0425251797,
-0.0723414347,
0.0014191427,
-0.0152376695,
0.0978152528,
0.0002786549,
0.0056582927,
0.0170290675,
0.0149603868,
0.0327764601,
-0.0240537971,
-0.0860695317,
-0.0182497744,
-0.0115745412,
0.0190690625,
-0.0488877371,
0.0211865883,
-0.0037663416,
-0.0063415375,
0.0185906775,
0.0018871524,
0.0197196081,
-0.0095218532,
-0.0753625929,
0.0546338335,
-0.0687575936,
-0.0670160875,
0.005395724,
0.0175688062,
-0.0207428187,
0.0087549277,
-0.0255232919,
0.0391748287,
-0.0143024186,
0.009209509,
0.0392352082,
0.008645975,
-0.0506213419,
0.0289940424,
-0.0053319125,
0.045713447,
-0.0037238207,
-0.0228455551,
-0.0378895365,
0.0094612082,
-0.0285195522,
-0.0153947044,
-0.0490251184,
0.0207611751,
-0.0677616745,
-0.0287663769,
-0.019184595,
0.0259689353,
0.0079356963,
0.0103837866,
-0.020717876,
0.0636746511,
-0.031330131,
0.0110883182,
0.003521448,
0.0378379934,
-0.0598138049,
-0.0032784848,
0.039996732,
-0.0385587476,
-0.0066032461,
0.0328182057,
0.0587544963,
0.0042539272,
-0.0201573279,
0.0027586638,
-0.0143670691,
-0.0292801,
-0.0497726761,
-0.0469856523,
-0.0058793137,
-0.0406421423,
0.0156193674,
-0.0584274828,
-0.0038579507,
-0.0134414034,
-0.0323128961,
-0.0173242167,
0.0115256105,
0.043711599,
0.0326857306,
0.048307132,
0.0094318241,
0.0137353968,
0.0533378161,
0.0045905565,
0.0091480445,
0.0507004,
0.0398588069,
0.0895688832,
0.0388931185,
-0.0085992636,
0.0297888014,
0.0220998619,
0.0340297483,
0.0086271306,
0.0020160764,
0.0283982158,
-0.0393251665,
0.0453777276,
-0.0271975491,
0.0490995757,
-0.034331128,
0.0328569263,
0.1000684202,
0.029026296,
-0.0327206627,
-0.0094082868,
0.0338408314,
0.0309208166,
-0.0513258241,
0.0213134643,
-0.0409645736,
0.0566692278,
-0.0207571387,
0.0145335682,
0.0197119415,
0.0403637029,
-0.0556877442,
-0.0589046553,
0.017978156,
0.0094839511,
0.028159406,
0.043552205,
0.0045808456,
0.0058153053,
-0.0469773337,
0.0164474398,
-0.0279786102,
-0.0576079749,
0.0088752154,
-0.0082642175,
0.0630269349,
0.0134602943,
0.0439583026,
0.0453330539,
-0.0649590418,
-0.0068053515,
0.0405298397,
0.0273607336,
0.0239857696,
-0.018308904,
0.0307091717,
-0.0720901713,
-0.0472143665,
-0.0297054239,
0.0102521684,
-0.0087022828,
0.0602351576,
0.0177979395,
0.0410631709,
-0.073568657,
0.000025847,
0.0010826917,
0.0298508499,
-0.0576263145,
0.0188978389,
0.0322605669,
-0.0474914759,
0.0110166473,
0.0157031231,
0.0075513767,
0.0357666649,
-0.0177002978,
0.0427394584,
0.0440742001,
-0.0281659104,
-0.0401355252,
0.011799111,
-0.0514639243,
-0.0193658173,
0.0317845568,
-0.0389574729,
-0.0212872047,
0.0184371639,
-0.0273160096,
-0.0109682754,
-0.0293281488,
-0.0151050938,
0.05886022,
0.0303824898,
-0.0353663489,
0.0521299392,
0.0080340961,
-0.0052719396,
0.0153203318,
0.030395193,
0.0411071517,
-0.0549901947,
0.0054691806,
-0.0358678363,
-0.0218018163,
0.0149520952,
0.0052321823,
0.0426052883,
-0.0755955204,
-0.0293929074,
-0.1059245765,
0.0265328344,
-0.0215600524,
-0.0001088604,
0.043286223,
0.0370388702,
-0.0278515629,
-0.0548380204,
-0.1059470773,
-0.0077167307,
0.0279108677,
0.0056462297,
0.0460716933,
-0.0264458768,
0.0362590738,
-0.0061919792,
0.0157318674,
0.0297750849,
0.0418839082,
0.0244639087,
0.0573827736,
-0.0137443114,
-0.067898199,
-0.052362103,
0.0097103044,
0.0336813778,
-0.0023853406,
0.0496225655,
-0.0201356169,
0.0363230444,
0.0375661179,
-0.0170689821,
0.0152991507,
-0.0238332245,
-0.0327387005,
-0.0239619259,
0.0139201591,
-0.0344637744,
-0.002180493,
-0.0064587439,
-0.0452059172,
-0.0168955345,
0.0071122912,
-0.01386787,
0.0078100781,
-0.0379217304,
0.0540229417,
-0.0077723507,
-0.0085962117,
-0.0652015433,
0.0601036549,
-0.0013617486,
0.0561334714,
-0.0431596749,
-0.0802420378,
0.0400229543,
-0.0098345838,
-0.0078713996,
-0.0158736091,
0.0162949171,
-0.0175317992,
0.0953360349,
0.0034440898,
0.0110789007,
-0.004119026,
-0.033874426,
-0.0555934832,
-0.0251750331,
-0.0079144835,
-0.0339900255,
0.0096181249,
-0.0538256541,
-0.0396736264,
0.0088699954,
-0.0728083849,
-0.052456703,
-0.0231966786,
0.0071624801,
-0.030747097,
-0.0233731102,
-0.0291663781,
0.0076651927,
0.0169965215,
-0.0231738128,
0.0387269482,
-0.0442666821,
-0.0167038646,
-0.0084962705,
0.1250010133,
0.1160661802,
0.0706002787,
-0.0198687371,
0.000046565,
0.004095593,
0.0538353026,
0.0245514922,
0.0081912437,
-0.0234258175,
0.0813729838,
0.0254138578,
0.0393475369,
0.00675896,
0.035980165,
0.0895501524,
-0.0369786434,
-0.0703342631,
0.0835829377,
0.0530727096,
-0.0133184083,
-0.0146210622,
-0.0129183074,
0.0651380569,
0.017368393,
0.0486183986,
-0.055732809,
-0.0251920186,
-0.0210298263,
0.0281477161,
0.0184808597,
0.0060364059,
-0.0109772105,
-0.0952446088,
0.0887695104,
0.006487736,
-0.0064895703,
-0.0068648937,
0.0176855009,
-0.0201009884,
0.0133751323,
-0.0194413811,
-0.0118688624,
0.0070473421,
0.0285796281,
0.018811008,
-0.0089889448,
-0.0253298879,
-0.0056348452,
-0.0284495261,
-0.0141975377,
0.0623819456,
0.0285201445,
0.025783129,
-0.0767054632,
-0.0247654263,
0.0037529655,
-0.0059317639,
-0.0013395327,
0.0282318629,
0.0118608233,
-0.0336654037,
-0.017709842,
0.0769214034,
-0.0128245633,
-0.0035455539,
0.0442950092,
0.0372090414,
-0.0208943579,
0.0160612408,
-0.0102530448,
0.0195955299,
0.0432438664,
0.023239959,
0.0517704822,
-0.0347248875,
-0.0194093361,
-0.0165183842,
0.0053535486,
-0.0881994441,
-0.0028128831,
-0.0064293533,
0.0628121346,
-0.0109597677,
-0.114035666,
-0.0429907627,
0.0716501698,
0.0543192662,
-0.0306520909,
-0.0392374136,
-0.0253115371,
0.0180520024,
-0.0665729046,
0.0667558163,
0.0057062325,
-0.021825105,
-0.0270813107,
-0.0037887157,
-0.009600536,
-0.0859796926,
-0.0100550978,
0.0471213125,
-0.1093715802,
-0.0196051244,
-0.0362729803,
0.0548702776,
0.0166793223,
0.0286777746,
-0.0295654982,
0.0029559929,
0.0075736153,
0.0266228318,
0.0027729038,
-0.021983156,
-0.0448638238,
0.0035165474,
-0.0042967512,
0.0034119436,
-0.0206037052,
0.0224365722,
0.002755393,
0.0463316627,
-0.0408596396,
-0.0076903161,
0.0420205966,
0.0085895406,
0.0448232666,
-0.033747483,
-0.0126061123,
-0.012851283,
-0.010820617,
0.0070810528,
-0.0202219207,
-0.0726867318,
-0.0041346448,
0.0012959514,
0.0258191843,
-0.0051765661,
-0.0263836645,
-0.0117329489,
0.0174626764,
-0.0687562451,
-0.0521626584,
0.0048119696,
-0.0004503069,
-0.0209890269,
0.0006655151,
0.0051944419,
0.0115920389,
-0.0302349385,
0.0378216952,
-0.0018107992,
0.0699188262,
0.0002898468,
-0.002372371,
-0.014625879,
0.0629869923,
-0.0376168899,
-0.0402826369,
-0.0488485023,
0.0527690053,
0.0365637653,
0.013068649,
-0.0018284031,
0.0104664788,
-0.0114039257,
0.0065887612,
0.0353715718,
0.0206822325,
-0.0571016148,
0.0444338433,
0.0230651833,
-0.0135257998,
-0.0116217509,
0.0562348589,
-0.0002191099,
0.007612552,
0.0289561097,
-0.0180748068,
-0.0573020242,
0.0116585661,
0.0458139889,
-0.0000037601,
0.0114693735,
0.0667708442,
-0.0172669049,
-0.053181611,
-0.014591259,
0.0371933766,
-0.0076562348,
-0.0047637019,
0.0546522066,
0.0362613946,
-0.0331749246,
-0.0220710766,
-0.0444537401,
0.0098210545,
-0.0796633884,
-0.0307744052,
-0.010632202,
-6.351954906e-33,
-0.0280993599,
-0.0706100464,
0.0538223013,
-0.0445528179,
-0.0494058765,
0.020856848,
-0.0357020237,
0.01405071,
-0.0060497941,
-0.0155690126,
-0.0025260772,
-0.0057111774,
0.0055892421,
0.0803169757,
-0.0340616368,
-0.0416124202,
0.0309865214,
0.0104085635,
-0.0228518303,
0.0449072197,
0.0121293701,
0.0065273135,
0.011240093,
-0.0274995845,
-0.0377757512,
-0.0244077668,
-0.0526425913,
0.0205141399,
0.0039022192,
0.0458677188,
-0.0338846967,
0.0074040582,
0.0177884735,
0.0041405964,
-0.0005323314,
0.0262844544,
-0.0486891866,
-0.0286071394,
-0.0202615242,
-0.0091815479,
-0.0807080939,
-0.0053764391,
0.0071317418,
-0.0224063694,
0.017842425,
-0.008702429,
0.0362394601,
0.0031080972,
-0.0358313955,
0.004334046,
-0.0160110611,
0.0083692735,
-0.0225890912,
-0.075947687,
-0.0275129043,
0.0823055133,
0.0200427547,
0.0115687326,
-0.0161719415,
0.0516722724,
0.0079714013,
0.0280520171,
0.0385455117,
0.0141853895,
0.006450986,
0.0303162392,
-0.0018787858,
-0.0289768465,
-0.0453417115,
0.0016935359,
-0.026696492,
0.0870178565,
0.0450701378,
0.0227665547,
0.0235092528,
0.0147795249,
-0.0223452002,
0.0687347203,
-0.0478211828,
-0.0089679724,
-0.019686386,
-0.0323367491,
-0.002103819,
0.009143536,
-0.0286248419,
-0.0243107434,
-0.0527232215,
-0.0379050709,
0.0779601187,
0.0292241033,
-0.0293308124,
0.0474950932,
0.0331501327,
-0.0030810912,
0.0331199877,
-0.013414558,
-0.025220409,
0.0452964455,
-0.0012876975,
0.014746814,
0.0150541347,
0.0222515948,
0.0177942868,
0.0282872859,
-0.0235166308,
0.0421184637,
0.0092399707,
0.0201078057,
-0.032380078,
0.0066645853,
-0.0472915396,
0.0539521277,
-0.0520727076,
-0.0074434434,
0.0054548616,
0.0048666843,
-0.0478014983,
0.0218232479,
-0.0108391633,
0.0223739352,
-0.0082532763,
-0.049273897,
-0.0073537473,
0.0587789603,
-0.0216825977,
0.026152337,
-0.0434463024,
-0.0205205828,
0.0027431899,
-0.0515051819,
-0.0308468416,
0.0146436635,
2.623e-7,
-0.0204579495,
0.0126666995,
0.0006010153,
0.0303368177,
-0.0202166568,
0.0180965606,
0.0075716903,
-0.0015348918,
0.0232151505,
-0.000184066,
0.0279122908,
0.0327994451,
0.0504725985,
0.017088186,
-0.0786403641,
0.0470693186,
-0.0418104455,
0.0111647965,
-0.0408727527,
0.0190228093,
0.0619602129,
0.0356201045,
-0.0079625463,
-0.0224565119,
0.0697113946,
-0.0046534361,
0.0607205369,
-0.0141222402,
-0.0375233889,
-0.0220214725,
0.0184097681,
0.0153897917,
-0.0061428826,
-0.0287954658,
-0.0377079397,
-0.0303558931,
0.0512880459,
0.0134067796,
0.0239950269,
-0.0452005528,
-0.0180599187,
0.0187894683,
0.0123011954,
-0.0653493479,
0.0568070523,
-0.0369503014,
-0.0335648023,
0.0087354584,
-0.0244577415,
-0.0239569098,
0.0124464137,
-0.014736264,
-0.0660770088,
-0.02853949,
0.0591220222,
-0.0108887311,
0.0138939563,
-0.0256564133,
-0.0323265493,
0.0007911979,
-0.0220193863,
-0.0227088109,
-0.070204176,
0.0062619201,
-0.0326384977,
0.0017770138,
-0.0508785062,
1.920716902e-34,
0.0163602252,
0.0015618906,
0.0104135182,
-0.0013594087,
0.0211945698,
-0.0139331156,
-0.003582052,
-0.0454632156,
0.0256803688,
-0.0383398533,
-0.0033160199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15127v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15127v2 | Open-Ended Instructable Embodied Agents with Memory-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T17:31:55 | 2023-11-20T18:51:29 | Gabriel Sarch, Yue Wu, Michael J. Tarr, Katerina Fragkiadaki | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | Pre-trained and frozen large language models (LLMs) can effectively map
simple scene rearrangement instructions to programs over a robot's visuomotor
functions through appropriate few-shot example prompting. To parse open-domain
natural language and adapt to a user's idiosyncratic procedures, not known
during prompt engineering time, fixed prompts fall short. In this paper, we
introduce HELPER, an embodied agent equipped with an external memory of
language-program pairs that parses free-form human-robot dialogue into action
programs through retrieval-augmented LLM prompting: relevant memories are
retrieved based on the current dialogue, instruction, correction, or VLM
description, and used as in-context prompt examples for LLM querying. The
memory is expanded during deployment to include pairs of user's language and
action plans, to assist future inferences and personalize them to the user's
language and routines. HELPER sets a new state-of-the-art in the TEACh
benchmark in both Execution from Dialog History (EDH) and Trajectory from
Dialogue (TfD), with a 1.7x improvement over the previous state-of-the-art for
TfD. Our models, code, and video results can be found in our project's website:
https://helper-agent-llm.github.io. | [
0.0275298357,
0.0277505796,
-0.0020052502,
0.0469619818,
-0.0103770103,
0.0089032305,
-0.0156218195,
-0.0246285424,
0.0338323861,
-0.0542279482,
-0.0309992339,
-0.0059485151,
-0.0233688615,
0.042215012,
-0.0165239107,
-0.072192125,
0.0371948779,
-0.0652182102,
-0.0044633541,
0.0153262364,
-0.0019762653,
-0.0129752737,
-0.0370302647,
0.0451320522,
0.0043875491,
-0.008547293,
-0.0775959715,
0.0158788078,
0.033761315,
-0.0375276953,
-0.0382880457,
-0.0013753453,
0.0655779466,
0.0104266591,
0.0000020153,
-0.0546515919,
-0.0149558429,
-0.0482673272,
-0.0268860888,
-0.0187887345,
-0.0016868069,
0.0064908131,
-0.0189966075,
0.005738589,
-0.017880816,
-0.0196077488,
0.0452426523,
0.0164229181,
0.0872229859,
0.081501089,
0.0072934721,
-0.0071655614,
0.0061561684,
0.0191696417,
0.0353906639,
-0.0053456859,
0.0054545947,
-0.0044124848,
0.0413151234,
0.0209528953,
-0.046132654,
0.015351247,
0.038024202,
-0.0507878736,
-0.0485609174,
0.0374343619,
-0.0042560333,
-0.0323832631,
-0.0420829281,
0.0736419111,
0.0211756341,
0.0098115792,
0.0208111368,
0.000879063,
0.0417104475,
0.0119332857,
-0.0372157358,
0.0700142011,
-0.0119564096,
-0.0300879776,
-0.0302023701,
-0.0126971584,
-0.0077482569,
0.0018716878,
-0.0209491812,
0.0450262316,
-0.0018757497,
0.001685162,
-0.0088418312,
-0.0470175184,
0.0049443129,
-0.0562685691,
0.0271225981,
0.0672244951,
-0.0544816256,
0.0332017094,
-0.0531087629,
0.0023131191,
-0.0436142609,
-0.0052222889,
0.0485576764,
0.0528353006,
-0.0244239531,
0.0329469293,
-0.0243614092,
0.1279735863,
-0.0115621286,
0.0323852636,
-0.0384586602,
0.0211063791,
-0.0309278313,
0.016479237,
-0.0586893968,
0.0068461392,
-0.0716839284,
-0.0394566096,
0.0200168341,
0.0528498031,
-0.0165258478,
0.0244639795,
-0.0227714535,
0.0208867099,
-0.0316486731,
-0.009041545,
-0.0607720427,
-0.0232955106,
-0.0103713749,
0.0077265925,
0.0323928408,
-0.0185706578,
-0.0272718202,
0.0323644727,
-0.0032911694,
-0.0037862223,
-0.0097400742,
0.0942331925,
-0.0368268229,
-0.0092996927,
0.0120109962,
0.0139034959,
0.0071096499,
-0.035538666,
0.0346633494,
-0.0662956312,
0.0073675145,
-0.0247534774,
0.0025107237,
-0.0183972716,
0.0220105164,
0.0054989848,
-0.000728423,
0.0729364455,
0.0241060648,
0.0380679742,
0.0147128776,
0.0145524004,
-0.0096037341,
0.0394617915,
0.0526775382,
0.0292369984,
-0.0073188618,
0.0140073523,
0.0214330461,
0.0432314165,
-0.0476748236,
-0.007554702,
-0.029103145,
0.0175970774,
0.0328674167,
0.0688916966,
0.007949926,
0.033229135,
-0.0269992836,
-0.0050875894,
0.0029353928,
0.0374069661,
-0.060434036,
-0.0625464916,
0.0548806228,
0.0086163888,
-0.005415692,
-0.0431438051,
-0.0579503886,
0.0558869876,
0.0198391918,
-0.0126396678,
-0.0314628743,
0.0092712576,
-0.0281145722,
-0.0360610336,
0.0408834778,
0.0056545208,
0.0430478118,
-0.0039267433,
0.0108207706,
0.0473868623,
-0.0747011304,
0.0381838493,
-0.023207821,
-0.0469447821,
-0.0238947235,
-0.0337487645,
0.0037721021,
0.0909137651,
-0.0168963745,
-0.0117214676,
-0.0541207418,
-0.0075401417,
0.0211355779,
0.0287487619,
-0.0102078607,
-0.0145131703,
0.0248292685,
-0.010403988,
0.0025440354,
-0.0254629236,
-0.0108301705,
0.0470461696,
0.0302726757,
0.0159169734,
0.0019060626,
0.0458632298,
-0.0013866867,
0.0313744918,
-0.0332824737,
0.0002677769,
-0.0112140644,
-0.0058743455,
0.0206857696,
0.022628691,
-0.019982079,
-0.0188685674,
0.0660858154,
-0.0228235554,
-0.0077633867,
0.0278217457,
-0.0559694692,
-0.0500395671,
0.0253951494,
0.0011077091,
-0.0208851472,
0.0013500699,
-0.0331139527,
-0.0389659181,
-0.0056340378,
-0.0117472745,
0.0119639579,
0.0044896752,
0.0310319588,
0.0332237035,
-0.0710348263,
-0.034206111,
0.0189716853,
-0.0295464769,
-0.0151025234,
0.0596665293,
0.0549830534,
-0.0176129602,
-0.0606107377,
-0.0125374356,
0.0557329208,
0.0115509899,
-0.0051384051,
0.010232931,
0.027420748,
-0.0584565774,
-0.0263722166,
-0.0900159031,
-0.0071171299,
-0.015659621,
-0.0411393754,
0.0019297996,
-0.0147794178,
-0.0227358229,
-0.0246197321,
0.0186044909,
0.0450259224,
0.0151960272,
-0.0045097228,
0.0199339911,
0.0313883722,
-0.032801792,
-0.0298529901,
0.0351387523,
-0.0057656509,
-0.0017979332,
0.0161481481,
0.0009997895,
-0.0593254156,
0.0522613712,
-0.0278228372,
0.0395791419,
-0.0377429612,
-0.039574232,
0.0495838039,
-0.0430280305,
0.0335525461,
0.1201995686,
-0.0122388778,
0.0242610089,
0.0633622035,
-0.0409745276,
-0.0696115047,
0.0341535397,
0.0023131976,
-0.0553185269,
-0.0334247611,
0.0311407577,
0.0019219343,
0.0018289534,
0.0046010599,
0.0524281338,
-0.0529046953,
0.0044136769,
-0.0043078018,
-0.0489383005,
-0.0207001138,
-0.0029293767,
-0.0619323589,
0.0179932117,
-0.0340203084,
-0.040363159,
0.0538279787,
-0.0249777865,
-0.020924598,
0.0212171003,
-0.0040298053,
-0.0028206569,
0.0949574485,
0.0240855981,
0.0186786503,
-0.007134439,
-0.013968776,
-0.0139519162,
-0.0065563042,
-0.0165821817,
-0.0088021504,
0.0393448099,
-0.0865064934,
-0.0097016152,
0.0049531446,
-0.0341138355,
-0.0436883382,
0.0033913429,
-0.0207360592,
-0.0104759345,
-0.0532097779,
-0.0576433837,
-0.0321027152,
-0.0140788518,
0.0443952605,
0.0672937855,
-0.0085104862,
0.0050493088,
-0.0398434475,
-0.0486838296,
0.0566364452,
0.0607460588,
-0.0734289736,
-0.0365368649,
0.0644247159,
0.0370504558,
0.0454384759,
-0.065084964,
-0.0544115268,
0.0054319794,
0.0025741672,
0.0107286815,
0.0272804946,
0.0555094145,
0.0760576949,
-0.0395893082,
-0.0290766116,
0.0946495011,
0.0182623211,
0.0145606063,
-0.0027440358,
0.0068635647,
0.0319157168,
0.0406961553,
0.01623125,
-0.0462910421,
-0.0325098298,
0.0089657018,
-0.0033040652,
0.0407146849,
-0.0274760984,
-0.0085901581,
-0.1458461732,
0.0565872714,
0.0129855983,
-0.0521152355,
-0.0365084447,
-0.0015226936,
0.0054783621,
0.0134816999,
-0.0218035746,
0.0257213395,
0.0071195546,
0.0027574005,
-0.0044483552,
0.0124978079,
0.0199915878,
0.0108127892,
-0.0254594963,
0.0477235354,
0.0539510734,
0.020000292,
-0.0077003133,
-0.0282475017,
0.0111614205,
0.0322014093,
0.0257250443,
0.002967458,
0.0011766757,
-0.0280841161,
-0.0131003456,
0.0161703713,
0.0493784696,
-0.0218749475,
-0.0524669699,
0.013980167,
0.0621890053,
-0.056410145,
0.0281829946,
-0.0284386445,
-0.0153717818,
0.0049646809,
0.0650835559,
-0.0218904708,
-0.0320523791,
-0.0247146729,
-0.0448715985,
-0.0340388454,
0.0092288097,
-0.0360132419,
-0.005418011,
-0.0269039962,
-0.0044910414,
-0.0602338798,
-0.0268223789,
0.0642140657,
0.0664765164,
0.0126587022,
-0.0331319757,
-0.0089355279,
0.0366907194,
-0.0424080715,
0.0456095412,
-0.0148518421,
0.0039945999,
-0.0605235286,
-0.0246641319,
0.0325940289,
-0.0096072527,
-0.0033929262,
0.0110231731,
-0.0065873647,
-0.0507641174,
-0.0030380471,
0.0749992654,
0.014171754,
0.0602403022,
0.0359894335,
0.014421422,
0.025887087,
0.031864509,
-0.0000354753,
0.0203526001,
0.0074736825,
0.0757676437,
0.0081399707,
0.0251243524,
-0.0732496381,
0.0004602464,
-0.0113390936,
0.027064817,
-0.0182138234,
-0.0618706867,
0.0246936996,
0.019934427,
0.0624702424,
-0.0170003753,
-0.0065079811,
-0.0293124449,
0.029049648,
-0.0294799022,
-0.0200474709,
-0.0716305301,
0.027203232,
0.0242460351,
0.0094853714,
0.0534951389,
-0.0049184277,
0.0251430441,
0.0160684139,
-0.0125053739,
-0.0025397965,
0.051933825,
0.0231626611,
0.031228466,
0.0426071733,
-0.0031615174,
0.0344566479,
-0.0130345002,
0.0659056008,
0.0241386723,
0.1034768373,
0.0202203225,
-0.0040787752,
-0.0167856868,
0.0350219011,
-0.0649098009,
-0.1166776642,
0.0160168055,
0.020806836,
0.0336976722,
-0.0119600268,
0.0266933814,
-0.0512338541,
0.0199431721,
-0.0222516358,
0.0365867652,
0.0405772552,
-0.0690208599,
0.0443844162,
0.0279972479,
0.0041618394,
0.0153951636,
0.0279686134,
-0.0188944191,
0.0651509389,
0.0155877313,
0.0097812461,
-0.0479160659,
-0.0384757705,
0.0023457331,
0.0059931385,
0.0195866488,
-0.0201927181,
-0.0103598731,
-0.0356090851,
-0.031669464,
0.0521420576,
-0.0295680799,
-0.0213693995,
0.0614066049,
0.0054351892,
-0.0002646213,
-0.0323973112,
-0.0191418398,
-0.0117465155,
-0.0149838002,
-0.0479709096,
-0.044811856,
-5.244469516e-33,
-0.071486406,
-0.0208533201,
0.0531001166,
-0.0226018298,
-0.0115325926,
-0.0332067385,
-0.0456913412,
0.0173248108,
0.0001742571,
0.0017875789,
0.0144964717,
-0.0118427295,
0.0057958704,
0.014654465,
0.008775034,
-0.0184602533,
0.0211449265,
-0.0050902767,
-0.0467150174,
0.013014474,
0.0579830892,
0.0216843504,
-0.0100072734,
-0.0442396626,
0.0087874867,
-0.0063588987,
-0.0133490739,
0.0683206096,
-0.0015341481,
0.0437297374,
0.0161614902,
-0.0146303698,
-0.0196965393,
-0.0193904638,
-0.0218602177,
0.022643568,
-0.0461719707,
-0.0274400171,
0.0192919225,
0.0135777332,
-0.051001586,
-0.028323872,
0.0165434852,
-0.0088850083,
-0.0279778019,
0.0128390593,
-0.0085553853,
0.004748059,
0.0377415866,
0.0534792393,
-0.0262355339,
-0.0202320069,
-0.0077792755,
-0.0740147457,
0.0270522162,
0.0345843658,
0.00723266,
-0.0021822471,
-0.0355178863,
-0.0024236499,
-0.0116747022,
-0.0103324847,
0.0721416771,
0.0319178104,
0.0165748037,
0.0773353428,
0.0190890376,
-0.0031765641,
-0.0075846198,
0.0052911625,
-0.0019615842,
0.0739370733,
-0.0142037803,
0.030971922,
0.0017103035,
0.0276593231,
-0.0182132851,
0.0296397414,
-0.0231474359,
0.0556069426,
-0.011053713,
0.0451308489,
-0.0314147733,
0.0004170426,
-0.0410687812,
0.0491188616,
0.0028044039,
-0.0207853075,
0.0649392158,
0.0137819834,
0.0276328288,
-0.104059726,
0.0673211142,
-0.0131283868,
0.0258248392,
0.0099409092,
-0.0506296381,
0.0183330849,
-0.0194497649,
0.0349285975,
-0.0412341133,
-0.0401660837,
0.0724362209,
-0.032838054,
0.009124672,
0.0348097607,
-0.0319074877,
0.0698801801,
-0.0412726179,
-0.000849884,
-0.025646355,
-0.0009433428,
-0.0161078069,
-0.0054722461,
0.0329754353,
-0.0016213938,
-0.0531390943,
0.069824554,
-0.0243323985,
-0.0608670004,
-0.0296786875,
-0.0265786592,
-0.0139839118,
-0.026811257,
-0.0417944677,
0.0033558402,
-0.0135093378,
0.0166417509,
0.0006231875,
-0.0490110368,
0.0155277345,
0.0371712148,
2.805e-7,
-0.0157916117,
0.0114043783,
0.0004551272,
0.0275641866,
0.023426963,
0.0549595132,
-0.0466117822,
0.0357075259,
0.0027839325,
-0.0403591283,
-0.0027696525,
0.0568518788,
0.0149915107,
-0.0341888331,
-0.0832188204,
-0.014891346,
-0.0101635186,
-0.0615638979,
-0.0858206302,
-0.0039280462,
0.0622352362,
0.0858371407,
-0.0147632351,
0.0313829854,
0.0023268671,
-0.0293687601,
0.0246942416,
-0.071706064,
-0.0032723208,
-0.034783639,
-0.0112339016,
0.0098696854,
-0.0323166177,
0.0053252596,
0.0091422088,
-0.000075255,
0.0018294515,
0.0895031318,
-0.0204804447,
-0.0506616123,
-0.0130762625,
0.0164140519,
-0.0247701202,
-0.0152927125,
0.0290746707,
-0.048987411,
0.0129052456,
0.0022686515,
-0.0314832963,
-0.0162228793,
-0.0196238589,
-0.0017541222,
0.0174895693,
0.0007726828,
-0.0007162679,
-0.0125336489,
-0.0105562806,
-0.0495379008,
-0.0177785512,
-0.0199297667,
-0.052152697,
-0.0284991264,
-0.0361306854,
0.0065402887,
-0.0185298845,
-0.0120973615,
-0.0082292799,
2.290289342e-34,
-0.0017941397,
0.0167503338,
0.0105287628,
0.034818422,
0.0611488372,
0.0114747938,
0.0006573922,
0.0289822556,
0.0344473347,
-0.0765501857,
-0.0543230698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15123v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15123v2 | Branch-Solve-Merge Improves Large Language Model Evaluation and Generation | 2023-10-23T17:29:48 | 2024-06-07T16:08:49 | Swarnadeep Saha, Omer Levy, Asli Celikyilmaz, Mohit Bansal, Jason Weston, Xian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are frequently used for multi-faceted language
generation and evaluation tasks that involve satisfying intricate user
constraints or taking into account multiple aspects and criteria. However,
their performance can fall short, due to the model's lack of coherence and
inability to plan and decompose the problem. We propose Branch-Solve-Merge
(BSM), a Large Language Model program (Schlag et al., 2023) for tackling such
challenging natural language tasks. It consists of branch, solve, and merge
modules that are parameterized with specific prompts to the base LLM. These
three modules plan a decomposition of the task into multiple parallel
sub-tasks, independently solve them, and fuse the solutions to the sub-tasks.
We apply our method to the tasks of LLM response evaluation and constrained
text generation and evaluate its effectiveness with multiple LLMs, including
Vicuna, LLaMA-2-chat, and GPT-4. BSM improves the evaluation correctness and
consistency for each LLM by enhancing human-LLM agreement by up to 26%,
reducing length and pairwise position biases by up to 50%, and allowing
LLaMA2-chat to match or outperform GPT-4 on most domains. On a constraint story
generation task, BSM improves the coherence of stories while also improving
constraint satisfaction by 12%. | [
0.0432092808,
0.0269729625,
-0.0146189602,
-0.0022612833,
-0.0522169434,
-0.0207141396,
0.0077505349,
-0.0327523798,
0.0138415499,
-0.0595030338,
-0.0124364831,
-0.0379439779,
0.0104910843,
0.0687684193,
-0.0001537348,
-0.0550281107,
0.0275438614,
-0.033522591,
0.0190491341,
0.0013227299,
0.0155385938,
0.040479973,
-0.0052458872,
0.0491688438,
-0.0149642825,
-0.0222753845,
-0.0119945491,
-0.0025372051,
0.0159225278,
-0.026196925,
0.013281052,
0.0421752669,
0.0046581118,
0.0071583292,
0.0000022443,
-0.0567881018,
-0.0203033257,
-0.0218128059,
-0.0030878957,
0.0204924513,
0.0544400997,
-0.0044427142,
-0.0131357983,
0.0352507941,
-0.0335706398,
-0.0019110421,
0.0205480903,
0.0484397709,
0.0888522714,
0.0590265431,
-0.0139636556,
-0.0257394314,
-0.0173498951,
-0.0139319766,
-0.0153522454,
-0.0338453017,
0.008106837,
0.0160775445,
0.0702100173,
-0.0214314181,
0.0253738966,
0.0071012536,
0.0337556675,
-0.0214183684,
-0.0042746672,
0.0393803716,
-0.0476956144,
-0.043456696,
-0.0355535373,
0.0565560311,
0.0038568508,
-0.0132309524,
0.0107782139,
-0.0131935272,
0.0055731158,
-0.0098260911,
-0.052358374,
0.053327892,
-0.0151954237,
0.0067377761,
0.0093409857,
-0.0067648324,
0.0116574159,
0.0253001433,
-0.000135134,
0.0444368683,
0.04065134,
-0.0102158589,
-0.0366699845,
0.0141820004,
-0.0421180353,
-0.1065860391,
0.0336367339,
0.056238234,
-0.0879420713,
0.00858285,
-0.0848056674,
0.0007821182,
0.0228736326,
-0.0420429856,
0.0253163036,
0.0278416406,
0.0280845612,
0.0182717759,
0.0158282183,
0.0965426937,
0.0057659582,
-0.0419894792,
-0.0588676147,
0.0089565916,
-0.0402636044,
-0.0158203281,
-0.0369083881,
0.0393518768,
-0.0623552538,
-0.0455981046,
-0.0513721928,
0.0292822924,
0.0115795126,
0.0033562283,
0.0069030751,
0.0152772702,
-0.0272510573,
-0.0180748776,
-0.021060789,
0.0258884188,
-0.0263797473,
0.0085432203,
0.0278289188,
-0.0016346708,
-0.0016490001,
0.0415316448,
-0.0056104329,
-0.026797099,
-0.0013339134,
0.045542568,
-0.0375519246,
0.0222731791,
-0.0245010611,
-0.0699006096,
-0.0474091172,
-0.1004289314,
-0.0503631607,
-0.0791236535,
0.0376615711,
-0.004498567,
-0.0192078222,
-0.0160198584,
0.0257288627,
0.036790546,
-0.0106415255,
0.019231908,
-0.0055058775,
0.0104966192,
0.0487686619,
0.0341383517,
0.0081206402,
0.0563804619,
0.0607673116,
0.064542003,
-0.0005143908,
0.015328316,
0.0216308609,
0.0422097743,
-0.0108372429,
-0.0178819187,
0.0263999104,
-0.0184087642,
-0.0107110888,
0.0419450216,
0.0135578606,
0.0863479301,
-0.023563806,
0.039185185,
0.0707079843,
0.0286912192,
0.0283258483,
0.0136225279,
0.0543256402,
0.0216894504,
-0.0044309814,
0.0443522297,
-0.0338448733,
0.0265734531,
-0.0106735602,
0.0300800037,
0.0328851044,
0.0620531701,
-0.0213542767,
-0.0374368206,
-0.0287462808,
0.0004091882,
-0.0199552663,
-0.0172928907,
0.0119521767,
0.0004894448,
-0.068971768,
0.0536160767,
0.0141324047,
-0.0689141005,
0.032793086,
-0.0030754127,
0.0335547104,
0.0956478491,
0.0605540164,
0.0173825808,
-0.043489594,
0.0010607074,
-0.0012060308,
0.0573069826,
0.0299652815,
0.0028953033,
-0.0050054379,
-0.0609041825,
-0.0080688382,
-0.0341274031,
0.0042298716,
0.0210259706,
0.0324399024,
-0.0066160844,
0.0272364914,
0.0281925946,
-0.027434798,
0.0105279731,
-0.0585315265,
0.003022064,
-0.0096044745,
-0.0145909097,
0.0263396986,
0.0211366359,
-0.0155801708,
0.0315942429,
0.0154384701,
-0.0384686776,
-0.0367190391,
0.0323127098,
-0.0546674728,
-0.036272686,
0.0356629193,
-0.0319285132,
-0.0141621875,
-0.0082464218,
0.0014916983,
-0.0576574765,
0.0277257506,
-0.0470334142,
-0.0036272132,
-0.0392008163,
0.0350176618,
0.0364855602,
-0.0149455732,
-0.0388498977,
0.0713197738,
0.0225538127,
-0.018023653,
0.0180581808,
-0.0141068706,
-0.0131395282,
-0.0282746796,
-0.0068723261,
0.0194661748,
0.0020824303,
0.0054433541,
0.0184360016,
0.0408211648,
-0.0431892611,
-0.0646490604,
-0.1062538326,
0.0498156287,
-0.0003668622,
0.0124795977,
0.0268610474,
0.0004805131,
-0.0175758079,
0.0354762003,
-0.052251,
-0.0171100032,
0.0612432174,
0.005590871,
0.0145517606,
0.0206936151,
-0.0153914671,
-0.0498754457,
0.0294134207,
-0.0070133074,
0.040002536,
0.0606371164,
-0.016693268,
-0.063556239,
0.0506132543,
-0.057049349,
0.0168378763,
0.015050821,
-0.0381206349,
0.0165902358,
0.0129370475,
0.1081550419,
-0.0152114248,
0.0094190873,
0.0358372107,
0.0758337229,
-0.043435812,
-0.029210683,
0.0195786208,
-0.000407389,
-0.0120037785,
0.0247638132,
-0.059183415,
0.0354165845,
0.0709241033,
0.0322319865,
-0.0008767574,
-0.0695428327,
0.0288704652,
-0.0190689377,
-0.01882785,
0.0113868564,
-0.0654564947,
-0.0285890847,
0.0454785898,
-0.0372210704,
-0.0428662114,
0.0682392493,
-0.0584615581,
0.0045584147,
-0.0482397638,
-0.0085994387,
-0.0609554052,
0.0568394624,
-0.0075368346,
0.0412329175,
0.0225221794,
-0.0088969143,
-0.0509448759,
0.0003013971,
0.0100421254,
-0.0281586349,
0.0418395065,
-0.0877772495,
0.0072274683,
-0.0138551481,
-0.0377816111,
-0.0434564054,
-0.0422712453,
-0.0149506452,
0.0131896753,
0.065502435,
-0.0103484867,
-0.0213878751,
0.0273848139,
0.0267487634,
0.0158400126,
-0.0238330625,
-0.0030019269,
-0.0295432396,
0.0204041339,
0.0809498578,
0.0451121889,
0.0047427695,
-0.0453541875,
0.0206841566,
0.0365102179,
0.016487712,
0.0305485111,
-0.0092859073,
0.0148834065,
0.0215118416,
-0.0254310556,
-0.0169134662,
0.0133869238,
0.0394555181,
-0.0367786475,
-0.0121187577,
0.1081066951,
0.0436635837,
-0.0236939602,
-0.0051600682,
-0.0365252942,
0.0601088777,
0.0103852684,
0.0466533527,
-0.0875334367,
-0.0212021023,
0.0119744139,
0.0006873151,
0.0052002985,
-0.018212961,
-0.0554481409,
-0.1237219349,
0.0371066406,
0.0384942107,
-0.0215251315,
-0.0152280489,
0.0218149871,
-0.0290860478,
0.0391484685,
0.0189251732,
0.0131870946,
-0.0251388364,
0.0094822431,
-0.0034891588,
-0.0033480565,
-0.0104287723,
0.0029393304,
-0.0457007065,
0.0474256091,
0.0557110421,
0.013943987,
0.0435472727,
0.0063121798,
0.0432041399,
0.0156255197,
0.0032280672,
-0.0150285261,
-0.007964191,
0.0183387864,
0.0048897644,
-0.0397541076,
0.0301373955,
-0.0084130429,
-0.0476862751,
0.0358216502,
0.0621499494,
-0.0106925992,
-0.0159196444,
-0.007919834,
0.0612990335,
0.0002885397,
0.078398481,
0.0293288976,
-0.0389012545,
-0.051480934,
-0.0077437288,
-0.0155606885,
-0.0584821403,
0.0019423105,
0.0153551186,
-0.0392162092,
0.0213371478,
-0.0992438197,
-0.0439440683,
0.0290660169,
0.0295658913,
0.0274751447,
-0.0027437017,
0.018144507,
-0.0188710392,
-0.007573735,
0.0130035337,
-0.0156568419,
0.0137395607,
-0.0506345406,
0.0294082705,
-0.0109757315,
-0.063847594,
0.0167615134,
0.0731069744,
-0.0873860195,
-0.0835866854,
-0.0420777835,
0.0258972868,
0.0262802672,
0.018549867,
0.0108447252,
-0.051261846,
-0.0262829233,
0.0158430338,
-0.0597312227,
0.0440475605,
-0.0337384455,
0.0382926948,
-0.0056317919,
0.013020644,
-0.0277393349,
0.0004021461,
-0.0397568345,
0.0749759376,
0.0015400848,
-0.0315911323,
0.0224863589,
0.0265314989,
-0.0327836238,
-0.0320866853,
-0.028237585,
-0.0344698913,
0.0024065131,
-0.0485516898,
-0.0349591449,
-0.0475310758,
-0.0087239146,
0.0108277779,
-0.0219598748,
0.0208618231,
-0.0011413401,
-0.0347481295,
0.0141002629,
-0.0212433748,
-0.0106505165,
-0.0092856893,
-0.0215957332,
0.0315321721,
-0.0219814647,
-0.0201723166,
0.0147211775,
-0.0338859484,
0.0157581586,
-0.0186517369,
0.0598188564,
-0.0069110906,
-0.0066315369,
0.0006834502,
0.0259019937,
-0.0248895176,
-0.0362024158,
-0.0050012846,
0.0010851577,
0.0646010339,
0.0268519204,
0.0918237343,
-0.0312869065,
0.0123084961,
-0.0271946751,
0.0522333644,
0.0130872047,
-0.0163128041,
0.020868754,
0.0236230139,
-0.0125422627,
-0.025745092,
0.0775996819,
0.0231017675,
0.0118535627,
-0.0020437092,
-0.0139631042,
-0.0324114598,
-0.054868903,
0.0070409845,
-0.0032160387,
-0.01807799,
-0.0328123346,
-0.063738279,
-0.0234631673,
0.0099893268,
0.0149353882,
0.0021382149,
-0.0045032063,
0.033513166,
0.0454563163,
-0.0248268899,
-0.012472773,
-0.029309392,
0.0069802324,
-0.0143746007,
-0.0197329018,
0.0089300498,
-6.822237135e-33,
-0.0602431707,
-0.0750563815,
0.0610589758,
-0.0183725599,
-0.0526778996,
0.0043071923,
-0.0639589876,
0.0135222115,
0.0447632186,
-0.0097475499,
0.0226012785,
-0.019493077,
0.0007736608,
0.0145429121,
-0.0038393785,
0.0138024352,
0.0405920148,
0.0270657707,
-0.0509671234,
0.0148169547,
0.0295907613,
0.0009042639,
-0.0020678022,
-0.0127974618,
0.0016438989,
-0.0135951135,
-0.044100333,
0.0108476458,
-0.017896004,
0.0584366359,
-0.0298727117,
0.0159485992,
0.0223497003,
-0.0287669897,
-0.0321931764,
0.0304945875,
-0.0038063666,
-0.0269715227,
0.0659617707,
-0.0309125558,
-0.0119224386,
-0.0640768558,
0.0457959771,
-0.0121086007,
-0.0146761816,
-0.004435203,
0.0219160412,
-0.0054385634,
0.0050636358,
-0.0238066372,
-0.0946783721,
0.0177000538,
-0.0037641795,
-0.0477795415,
-0.0100096604,
0.0800833628,
-0.0066241012,
-0.0105568049,
0.0082811806,
0.0397718661,
0.0439615659,
0.0316725709,
0.0830837637,
0.0006305913,
-0.0512899086,
0.0653746352,
-0.0300384685,
-0.0239874106,
-0.0611531809,
0.0042326828,
-0.0285899471,
0.0565008298,
0.0477513,
0.0644384548,
-0.0207847003,
0.0133156599,
-0.048734352,
0.0664481968,
-0.0056246938,
0.039315097,
0.0295274295,
0.0218202174,
-0.0055383695,
-0.0279849041,
-0.0240082983,
0.0195141546,
-0.0524377339,
-0.0349439085,
0.0383512862,
0.0110779908,
-0.0247216839,
-0.0219908264,
0.0242556855,
-0.0040221382,
-0.0103155058,
0.0182731152,
-0.0474859774,
0.0319398828,
-0.0186536275,
0.0311375502,
-0.0336128585,
-0.000905354,
0.0449660942,
0.0229137298,
0.0243889671,
0.0377551988,
-0.0084719611,
0.0211185776,
-0.0365261212,
0.0367972553,
-0.0519706942,
0.0412153155,
-0.0077581191,
-0.0086684544,
0.0325446092,
-0.0254168883,
-0.0277415179,
0.012926979,
0.0020042113,
-0.0322848745,
-0.0359818712,
0.0019515553,
0.013105168,
0.0296159945,
-0.0113995764,
0.0470563062,
-0.0059276926,
0.0087893782,
0.01404492,
-0.0245393608,
-0.028718587,
0.002587832,
2.932e-7,
-0.00437879,
0.0447355881,
0.0220212378,
0.026950527,
0.0018611329,
0.0209303871,
-0.0148979593,
0.0219761711,
0.0078405067,
0.0109330304,
-0.0120121697,
0.0254909843,
0.059570685,
0.045440264,
-0.0635387599,
0.0116447229,
-0.0511065423,
-0.0219227429,
-0.0894503221,
-0.0244867299,
0.1031492203,
0.0374112166,
0.0021073995,
-0.0069006635,
-0.0148174521,
-0.0335607231,
0.0689065754,
-0.0299951937,
-0.0698408782,
0.03761461,
-0.0268901065,
-0.0121889208,
-0.0271635558,
-0.0178935286,
-0.0239382368,
-0.0126290852,
0.0232453067,
0.0895433575,
0.0307872016,
-0.0085907402,
0.038175974,
0.0079340423,
-0.0134108951,
-0.070100151,
0.0446480736,
-0.0411342718,
-0.0221760198,
-0.0328328386,
0.0137995183,
-0.0373414196,
-0.0136613827,
-0.026194796,
0.0007865798,
0.0328126326,
0.0054605212,
0.0097847031,
-0.0264568571,
-0.0305107813,
-0.045294974,
0.0226855688,
-0.059584558,
-0.0071327942,
-0.0522490293,
0.0131079732,
-0.0153923389,
-0.0792918056,
0.0045816991,
2.951860547e-34,
0.0200999286,
-0.0132998703,
0.0287451055,
0.0343251117,
0.0398185365,
0.0144517291,
-0.0381572992,
0.0331869237,
0.0106640523,
-0.0673271194,
-0.0280701928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15117v1 | Causal Inference Using LLM-Guided Discovery | 2023-10-23T17:23:56 | 2023-10-23T17:23:56 | Aniket Vashishtha, Abbavaram Gowtham Reddy, Abhinav Kumar, Saketh Bachu, Vineeth N Balasubramanian, Amit Sharma | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | At the core of causal inference lies the challenge of determining reliable
causal graphs solely based on observational data. Since the well-known backdoor
criterion depends on the graph, any errors in the graph can propagate
downstream to effect inference. In this work, we initially show that complete
graph information is not necessary for causal effect inference; the topological
order over graph variables (causal order) alone suffices. Further, given a node
pair, causal order is easier to elicit from domain experts compared to graph
edges since determining the existence of an edge can depend extensively on
other variables. Interestingly, we find that the same principle holds for Large
Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4, motivating an automated
method to obtain causal order (and hence causal effect) with LLMs acting as
virtual domain experts. To this end, we employ different prompting strategies
and contextual cues to propose a robust technique of obtaining causal order
from LLMs. Acknowledging LLMs' limitations, we also study possible techniques
to integrate LLMs with established causal discovery algorithms, including
constraint-based and score-based methods, to enhance their performance.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach significantly improves
causal ordering accuracy as compared to discovery algorithms, highlighting the
potential of LLMs to enhance causal inference across diverse fields. | [
-0.0022537252,
0.083898671,
-0.0299009141,
0.0347699076,
-0.0197219886,
-0.0142729171,
-0.0140285389,
0.0083623473,
0.0488016531,
-0.0127177164,
0.054406248,
0.0232430771,
0.0044034175,
0.0220941454,
0.0434017181,
0.0137720685,
0.0421327651,
-0.0309596639,
-0.0032256392,
-0.0255601257,
-0.0297213253,
-0.0041880943,
0.0023472349,
0.0351027846,
-0.0091649154,
0.0186747368,
0.0046184226,
0.0303802341,
0.0144368466,
-0.0371904746,
-0.0280660428,
0.0502984412,
0.0170052815,
0.0441524498,
0.000002189,
-0.0198440813,
-0.0494704396,
0.0158644971,
0.0140887341,
0.0063517909,
-0.0453200601,
-0.0073093097,
0.0176501442,
-0.0017388641,
-0.023486102,
-0.0232430939,
0.0509911925,
-0.0082321437,
-0.0053527467,
0.0811676532,
-0.0156459231,
-0.0291091539,
0.01017782,
-0.0173609219,
0.0219280571,
-0.0200567748,
0.0410568938,
0.0094989315,
0.0158361662,
-0.0227144267,
-0.0342993028,
0.0154105602,
0.0127662709,
0.0057085147,
0.0024990733,
0.0060203979,
0.0403018184,
-0.0011084978,
0.024123352,
0.0966206715,
0.0804584101,
-0.0411841907,
0.0453571156,
-0.0193962604,
0.0228956193,
0.1073869094,
-0.0504970141,
-0.0020002513,
-0.010068615,
0.0028619859,
0.0551716425,
0.0059316605,
0.0866626054,
0.0094348239,
-0.0351617225,
0.1568469256,
0.0088962149,
-0.0340879187,
-0.0292805322,
0.0153379627,
-0.0148561522,
0.0063402574,
-0.0149823595,
-0.040665593,
-0.0406768136,
0.01942176,
0.0411487892,
0.0245935693,
-0.0211015046,
0.0086662043,
0.0321310498,
0.0201128125,
0.0145819765,
0.0062961061,
-0.0057769944,
0.0539001487,
-0.052544266,
0.0387714952,
-0.0013458111,
0.0395494327,
-0.0312102437,
-0.0302354228,
0.0117067304,
0.0146120498,
-0.0105713615,
0.0225015022,
-0.0528800972,
0.041005753,
-0.0368700363,
-0.0260299109,
0.0129919555,
-0.0318989493,
-0.0051990799,
0.0046291528,
-0.0074542365,
-0.0064889495,
-0.0231549256,
0.052662041,
-0.0550941601,
-0.0156317335,
-0.0108534852,
0.0091122687,
-0.0021243677,
-0.0419141091,
-0.0085376343,
0.1081489846,
0.0667404383,
-0.0231295582,
0.0037201738,
-0.0589652285,
-0.0215703156,
-0.0383306742,
0.0415976122,
-0.0624063611,
-0.0128199738,
0.0469580926,
0.0019603039,
-0.0510419272,
0.001349385,
-0.0542436279,
-0.0754729584,
0.0247310884,
-0.0244065598,
0.047018487,
-0.0415844806,
-0.0101087512,
0.006571732,
0.0381332561,
0.0261141919,
-0.0032157109,
0.0141833108,
-0.015297275,
0.0035095087,
0.0392855778,
0.0318542086,
0.0284873676,
-0.0107564256,
-0.0535924062,
0.0064673335,
-0.0050118482,
-0.0242750216,
-0.0006637804,
-0.0275102016,
0.0060464572,
0.0474047549,
-0.00843977,
0.0008837245,
-0.03275574,
0.0319557078,
-0.030676093,
-0.0384420194,
0.0502594858,
-0.0750531256,
0.0098347571,
-0.0292957611,
-0.0113593051,
0.0393502153,
-0.028675938,
0.0199336261,
-0.0442317352,
-0.0097442782,
0.0159859844,
0.0045330604,
0.0022508092,
0.0631363019,
0.0035260094,
-0.0339011848,
0.0166644268,
0.0363976806,
-0.0437285528,
-0.0269791801,
-0.0288923495,
-0.0116378106,
0.0560256243,
0.0744483247,
-0.0685091317,
-0.0199148487,
0.0355079658,
0.0103917187,
0.0031013982,
-0.0073280395,
-0.0126887001,
-0.0124313561,
-0.0020733511,
-0.0180887282,
0.0056093135,
0.0287401341,
0.053927049,
0.0480387844,
-0.0308695547,
-0.0103008421,
-0.0412096269,
-0.0202862434,
0.0061487439,
0.0072781662,
-0.0011576846,
0.0123538682,
0.0079243314,
0.0348334052,
0.0350403152,
-0.0476675592,
0.0265428685,
0.0125167612,
-0.0216032937,
-0.0402034447,
0.0431971848,
0.0069315899,
-0.0185289029,
0.0063560801,
-0.0645816177,
-0.0200647227,
0.0406383574,
-0.0379218571,
-0.0503398702,
0.0961573422,
-0.0081290277,
0.0283271596,
0.0116939452,
-0.0048081502,
0.0047272267,
-0.0433903448,
-0.0176953208,
0.0583533868,
0.005875296,
0.0293235965,
0.0303642023,
0.0164686628,
0.0066364557,
-0.0250730682,
0.01013711,
0.0009370384,
-0.0196869485,
-0.0152661409,
0.0606302395,
-0.0362323858,
0.0025981669,
-0.0142391045,
-0.0644007623,
-0.0125870751,
-0.0161284003,
0.0179597959,
-0.0058735539,
0.0122704804,
-0.0136396745,
-0.0206678417,
-0.0012794426,
0.0080120303,
0.012202356,
0.0415168628,
0.0237350632,
-0.0154548055,
-0.0324310772,
-0.0472787246,
-0.027321212,
-0.0973444059,
0.0411699526,
0.0412562303,
-0.0787932053,
-0.0166751686,
0.0200011823,
-0.023766093,
0.014181301,
-0.0482579134,
-0.0261980183,
0.0230943225,
-0.0266665816,
0.0372497365,
0.0442196652,
-0.0553725176,
0.0263975319,
0.0673793778,
-0.0289177783,
-0.0456192978,
-0.0209977888,
-0.073436588,
-0.0024611158,
-0.018539425,
-0.0509051234,
-0.0340577513,
0.0722608492,
0.025568489,
-0.033993721,
-0.052035071,
0.0115824491,
-0.0269292463,
0.0025970251,
-0.0104219764,
-0.0296055414,
-0.0165452156,
0.0413645953,
-0.0139198788,
-0.0886746719,
0.0506709665,
-0.005936549,
0.0243809037,
0.0144833932,
0.002000412,
-0.042153012,
0.0470932499,
0.0612338781,
0.0132817775,
0.0047871973,
-0.0325563364,
-0.0402285717,
0.0071436954,
0.0689731911,
0.014971015,
-0.002766679,
-0.073257491,
0.0712847486,
0.0147465812,
-0.0540801995,
-0.025569072,
-0.0242252797,
0.0084146755,
0.0001132682,
0.0319176838,
-0.0289188102,
0.0174850076,
0.0050790166,
0.0174046084,
0.0257781073,
-0.0401747711,
0.0091330511,
-0.0388879925,
-0.0328673385,
0.0091482829,
-0.080161877,
0.0173890442,
-0.047701899,
-0.0134267146,
-0.0025749779,
-0.0057310052,
-0.0146746691,
-0.0131186582,
0.0076307524,
-0.0175449345,
-0.0003484345,
-0.0091816457,
0.0209898017,
0.0084693637,
-0.0272167381,
0.0194787011,
0.0684506819,
0.0204988848,
-0.0454338193,
0.0199698582,
0.0360477269,
-0.014012944,
0.0317941122,
-0.0073222807,
-0.1161707416,
-0.0180942938,
0.0061034169,
-0.0012154419,
-0.0334792733,
-0.0374818742,
0.0162825584,
-0.0796673521,
0.0448631458,
0.0100006172,
-0.0217802823,
0.0069213202,
-0.0823047981,
-0.0113604451,
-0.01630776,
-0.05584158,
-0.0299161114,
0.00562802,
0.0188464373,
0.0002553291,
0.0040922198,
-0.0519655868,
-0.0232944619,
0.0213953108,
0.0418928564,
0.0380952209,
0.0039099627,
-0.0376786143,
0.0177959576,
0.0208902471,
0.0702259988,
0.0080453083,
-0.0314556956,
0.0416726731,
0.0248607099,
0.0031882885,
-0.0189100485,
0.0179325454,
-0.0221544597,
-0.0192877818,
-0.0197018255,
0.0900786147,
-0.0107377069,
-0.0369340144,
0.019481739,
-0.0052418867,
-0.0090542827,
0.0393957086,
0.0051418291,
0.0179440267,
-0.0326486826,
-0.0358083956,
-0.0114007629,
-0.0137001565,
-0.0896821022,
-0.0443625003,
0.0224128198,
-0.0275674704,
-0.0294803772,
-0.0040094969,
0.0112672038,
0.005915002,
0.0109714782,
0.0276175942,
0.0148614552,
-0.0285895783,
-0.0638444722,
0.044413697,
-0.0287941135,
0.0482728146,
-0.0370430872,
-0.0197470188,
0.0277722701,
-0.0034261155,
-0.023930328,
0.0548548028,
-0.0298419986,
-0.1055700183,
-0.0245134737,
0.0508911237,
0.022335846,
0.0437706709,
-0.008078956,
-0.0278460588,
0.0089815902,
0.0328945667,
-0.0208016261,
-0.002385539,
0.0474420562,
-0.0547725782,
-0.0036267298,
0.0180081911,
-0.0505129322,
0.0335558653,
0.0183970798,
0.0408868454,
-0.0286810119,
0.006522662,
0.0251615662,
0.0473109297,
0.0865739211,
-0.0153676393,
-0.0216410831,
-0.0661617219,
0.0073919236,
-0.0503158532,
-0.0305258278,
-0.0237084851,
0.0577921309,
0.0088634491,
0.0412227437,
-0.0027058227,
-0.059540078,
-0.0404237323,
-0.0000981414,
-0.0438223705,
0.0317830741,
0.0058468785,
0.0271946136,
0.0716729984,
-0.0144315576,
0.0244024321,
0.0493579172,
0.0329902433,
0.0521719195,
-0.0091668973,
0.028517168,
0.0250719581,
0.0096103922,
-0.0336920954,
-0.0099650137,
-0.0923012421,
0.0039427173,
0.0092980638,
0.0107621299,
0.0815891251,
0.0281397533,
0.0720587298,
-0.0460320264,
0.0122529948,
0.0023038522,
0.0486454181,
0.0372074656,
-0.0050345263,
0.0145938853,
0.0179937873,
-0.0226534829,
0.0357434861,
0.0690861568,
0.077915974,
0.0605035163,
-0.0262715165,
-0.0210867822,
0.0236071348,
-0.095005326,
-0.0168349873,
0.0379908755,
-0.0488210283,
0.009781668,
-0.0935566649,
-0.0636426061,
-0.0519489497,
-0.0077653429,
0.0099361278,
-0.0138852326,
-0.0156784188,
0.0080639794,
0.021313794,
-0.0281521026,
-0.0322858989,
-0.0140054356,
-0.0426400825,
-0.0363419876,
0.0013851507,
-6.843369585e-33,
-0.0242923088,
-0.0666849613,
0.0176488794,
0.0223683771,
0.0221010316,
0.0146811316,
-0.064293161,
0.0196253806,
0.0107567292,
0.0225621164,
0.024670139,
0.0263656359,
0.0138798198,
-0.0341942869,
0.0058568665,
0.0260159355,
0.0001457036,
0.0340083912,
-0.0199044719,
0.0377740748,
0.0284515638,
0.0106343897,
0.0508383848,
-0.0878471509,
0.0551077649,
0.0091481693,
0.013287886,
0.019516388,
-0.0764763579,
0.0172899645,
0.0261123348,
0.0053681876,
0.0262351688,
-0.0670680702,
0.012561298,
-0.0387905911,
-0.0173791405,
-0.0313950703,
0.0829832181,
-0.0209406968,
-0.0215982478,
-0.0543368533,
-0.01284956,
0.0206710827,
-0.0178413838,
-0.0170339681,
0.0300173312,
0.0160909556,
-0.0159911849,
-0.0139427986,
-0.0675850883,
0.0347097106,
-0.0270338524,
0.0381692275,
0.0298404098,
0.0016314904,
0.0139874853,
-0.0027778214,
0.0263639353,
0.0760917068,
0.0312173273,
0.0111864032,
0.0327204503,
0.0280652009,
0.008706538,
0.0338347703,
-0.0210396405,
0.0223193783,
-0.0033016475,
-0.0041253455,
0.0054714633,
0.0583763272,
0.0283684041,
0.0310882609,
0.00015201,
0.0297259577,
-0.1065386608,
0.0014521262,
0.0200105831,
-0.0417523831,
0.0326117203,
-0.0044783428,
-0.0601123273,
-0.0564979427,
-0.030683862,
-0.0192447156,
-0.0352130607,
-0.0225782823,
0.0280914083,
-0.016995104,
-0.0223722737,
-0.0337946825,
0.0249002147,
-0.0607055835,
-0.029107675,
0.042407833,
-0.055855684,
0.0045216838,
-0.030682724,
0.0235518422,
-0.0538804904,
-0.0227507465,
0.0002195986,
0.0137853185,
0.0701824799,
0.0252636801,
0.0073190387,
-0.011021045,
-0.0200716555,
-0.0112290112,
-0.0443098024,
-0.0318948962,
-0.0096789887,
-0.050184533,
0.0381590687,
0.0303710885,
0.0062610484,
0.0502993278,
0.066867955,
0.0554609783,
-0.0125514753,
-0.0172266494,
-0.0397770442,
0.0198728368,
-0.0455327071,
-0.0289819743,
0.0055810898,
0.0480190255,
0.0249345545,
-0.0267876051,
-0.0363882482,
-0.0133768413,
2.992e-7,
0.0579623356,
0.0509358831,
0.0213717092,
0.0783699676,
0.009585226,
-0.0062715486,
0.0009649499,
-0.0020077499,
0.0250781327,
0.0079580229,
0.0535512976,
0.0153744919,
0.0409138389,
0.0021851182,
-0.057534568,
0.0269142315,
-0.023949597,
-0.0305647515,
-0.0276345573,
0.0025069499,
0.0189033318,
0.0206231624,
0.0266458318,
0.0347284786,
-0.0324652977,
-0.0099750683,
0.0392821841,
-0.0213544667,
-0.0141800744,
0.003628812,
-0.0246126316,
-0.0397728495,
-0.0273439605,
0.0431831777,
-0.0083238203,
0.0066423151,
-0.0339950584,
0.0218928531,
-0.0060233548,
0.0153306546,
-0.0254753828,
-0.0621631257,
0.0243229475,
0.0025268898,
0.0589281991,
-0.0308201071,
-0.0460999645,
0.0629171133,
0.0004692005,
-0.0282242652,
-0.0126336999,
0.001958922,
0.0178352389,
0.0282500554,
-0.0088776089,
0.0030696855,
0.0203634612,
-0.0487013347,
-0.0345291719,
0.0289756134,
0.0047790613,
-0.1024385318,
0.0100457361,
0.0137110846,
-0.0149561083,
-0.0091673406,
0.0090470398,
3.444559821e-34,
0.0364503227,
0.0278046429,
0.0276499428,
-0.0302986838,
0.0788283646,
-0.0344359688,
-0.043014098,
0.0316051058,
0.0389510319,
-0.1046272591,
-0.0301416907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15114v1 | How To Build Competitive Multi-gender Speech Translation Models For Controlling Speaker Gender Translation | 2023-10-23T17:21:32 | 2023-10-23T17:21:32 | Marco Gaido, Dennis Fucci, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | When translating from notional gender languages (e.g., English) into
grammatical gender languages (e.g., Italian), the generated translation
requires explicit gender assignments for various words, including those
referring to the speaker. When the source sentence does not convey the
speaker's gender, speech translation (ST) models either rely on the
possibly-misleading vocal traits of the speaker or default to the masculine
gender, the most frequent in existing training corpora. To avoid such biased
and not inclusive behaviors, the gender assignment of speaker-related
expressions should be guided by externally-provided metadata about the
speaker's gender. While previous work has shown that the most effective
solution is represented by separate, dedicated gender-specific models, the goal
of this paper is to achieve the same results by integrating the speaker's
gender metadata into a single "multi-gender" neural ST model, easier to
maintain. Our experiments demonstrate that a single multi-gender model
outperforms gender-specialized ones when trained from scratch (with gender
accuracy gains up to 12.9 for feminine forms), while fine-tuning from existing
ST models does not lead to competitive results. | [
0.0159817841,
0.066609621,
-0.0054454445,
0.0134251406,
0.004283946,
-0.0180331413,
0.061425887,
-0.0488815457,
-0.0775797591,
-0.0145304315,
-0.0587325133,
-0.0753265098,
0.0515588112,
-0.0194869637,
0.0472763442,
-0.0212243348,
0.0191811193,
-0.0008700496,
-0.0037171685,
-0.0316979475,
-0.0007177346,
0.0221691467,
0.025947988,
0.0318527147,
0.0057897205,
-0.0119277863,
0.0176174957,
0.0665394291,
-0.0027873227,
0.0442853384,
0.0492589921,
0.0308833104,
0.0075787953,
0.0380713306,
0.0000018814,
-0.0424561612,
0.0089650089,
0.0404873565,
-0.0159323774,
-0.0013811744,
0.006590114,
-0.0050562057,
-0.0373223238,
0.0296146553,
0.0071562985,
-0.022011755,
0.0541484393,
0.0095030209,
0.046326533,
0.049200289,
-0.0221750233,
-0.0116129154,
-0.0441869944,
-0.0832345933,
-0.0207751375,
-0.017045388,
-0.0116470354,
-0.0552369878,
-0.0717807636,
0.0184251219,
-0.0110779926,
0.056287881,
-0.0361320712,
-0.0207956247,
-0.0173198171,
-0.0045253169,
-0.0027426819,
-0.0514034741,
0.0071324534,
0.0612405427,
-0.0095531633,
0.0419050828,
0.0199258178,
0.0322032124,
-0.0078512812,
-0.0183667969,
-0.0270266198,
0.0027000194,
0.0223777182,
-0.0357644968,
-0.0002050041,
0.0039448165,
0.0359794758,
0.0186595302,
-0.0485902689,
0.0803828761,
0.0096382797,
-0.0377768576,
0.0378006771,
-0.0273569617,
-0.0080215298,
-0.0062327655,
0.0561480336,
-0.0218358058,
0.0189594366,
0.0054819626,
-0.0290013589,
-0.0706762224,
-0.0121363141,
-0.0823137164,
0.0117450431,
0.0527165607,
0.0105936332,
0.0253321026,
-0.0427633338,
0.0479069985,
-0.0390271209,
0.0206351914,
-0.0553948991,
-0.0833387524,
-0.0181788709,
0.01395291,
-0.053524036,
-0.0032674379,
-0.041930072,
0.0271500722,
-0.0162320714,
-0.0024038889,
-0.0294743571,
0.0099939844,
0.0178421158,
-0.0167886242,
-0.0339505672,
-0.0145118628,
0.0313842371,
0.0516311266,
-0.0468191952,
0.0256887432,
-0.0088020843,
-0.0713751093,
-0.0245452151,
0.0265483949,
-0.0043290583,
-0.022226043,
-0.0055514718,
0.0136992102,
-0.002698394,
0.0058908779,
-0.0305511132,
-0.0095982514,
-0.0581894107,
-0.0758816451,
0.0251064766,
-0.0558738671,
0.0411912501,
0.0131207919,
0.0271170866,
-0.0383985043,
-0.006127506,
0.0023391647,
0.0015161597,
0.0446704179,
0.069437623,
0.0159688964,
0.0859652609,
0.0043434096,
-0.0399625786,
0.066175662,
0.0816551968,
-0.0088794036,
0.0002953272,
-0.0039396016,
-0.0391282625,
0.0965713114,
0.0692435801,
0.0482478105,
-0.0368931964,
0.0060150535,
0.0154676875,
0.0838414133,
0.0931528062,
0.0045912331,
0.0202772152,
-0.018334182,
0.0607991517,
0.0582814068,
0.05519123,
0.055665195,
0.0569085479,
-0.0193074383,
-0.0121682249,
-0.0133710606,
-0.040808782,
0.0077414494,
0.0134400949,
-0.0408956558,
-0.013762977,
0.0269776601,
-0.0399692282,
-0.0316515565,
0.0196473468,
-0.0129574714,
0.0024417124,
0.0026489631,
0.0052705067,
0.0392887704,
0.0014194505,
0.0733759552,
-0.0034362113,
-0.0569970794,
0.0317193493,
-0.0436547548,
-0.0465747379,
0.0215000659,
-0.0032195332,
-0.0161093902,
-0.0403235145,
-0.0581887476,
-0.0207922067,
0.0409932509,
0.0742960051,
0.0393851399,
0.067172274,
-0.068814829,
0.0133753335,
0.0362546854,
0.0174468029,
0.0604790039,
0.0006716107,
0.0511951298,
0.0406211801,
-0.0031304066,
-0.0649858862,
0.0170140415,
-0.0011324427,
-0.0223194864,
0.083818756,
-0.0017546071,
0.0244228803,
0.0311729368,
-0.0256292,
-0.0021615536,
-0.004095118,
-0.0350211747,
-0.0042684097,
0.0251581762,
-0.0275514554,
-0.0094286082,
0.0020635526,
-0.0357846208,
-0.0434990488,
0.0286628734,
-0.0189746004,
-0.0600556992,
0.0444296338,
-0.0294167921,
-0.0396397561,
-0.0334262587,
0.0161622278,
0.0370279923,
0.0282680206,
0.0043996954,
-0.027661901,
-0.0120757837,
-0.0574024357,
0.029475702,
-0.0069307922,
-0.0042425673,
-0.1004350632,
-0.0576560497,
0.0630358607,
0.0097210221,
0.0234113038,
0.0226703268,
-0.0245829113,
0.0042603337,
-0.0356055163,
-0.0211717673,
-0.0034167706,
-0.0123040657,
0.00714347,
-0.010565591,
0.0460363403,
-0.0008990836,
-0.0100737028,
-0.023756614,
-0.0407552794,
-0.0192809217,
-0.019800676,
0.0114698056,
0.014042926,
0.0244209282,
-0.0259942338,
-0.0061719143,
-0.0204612631,
0.0522231646,
-0.014075228,
-0.0298880208,
-0.0352914222,
-0.0084233861,
-0.0061572199,
0.0034610352,
-0.0057361377,
-0.0471737236,
-0.0155694848,
0.0029170767,
0.0496679246,
0.0839451402,
0.000747534,
-0.0222306792,
0.0256662462,
-0.0087472983,
-0.0844507888,
0.0254879389,
0.029607743,
0.0241174307,
-0.007356815,
-0.0412284434,
0.0103144739,
0.0115684159,
0.0072948723,
-0.0066195754,
-0.0457790606,
0.0042112241,
-0.009144051,
-0.0509849936,
0.002042504,
-0.0073608169,
0.0052155228,
0.0133546852,
-0.0319901109,
0.0179828405,
0.0291982796,
-0.0629900172,
-0.0453005098,
-0.0217046309,
-0.0247008204,
-0.0579330772,
0.0173172187,
-0.0728204921,
0.0334603414,
-0.0039894711,
0.0015734525,
-0.0582017563,
-0.0540459193,
0.041805923,
-0.0231888536,
0.0248389188,
-0.0354553424,
0.0097909989,
0.0078790365,
-0.0200972389,
-0.0105137471,
0.0163341109,
0.0115567576,
-0.0004114169,
-0.0062797456,
-0.0326649472,
-0.0140122306,
0.0329475552,
-0.0077799256,
0.0661978647,
-0.0248497631,
0.0279531907,
-0.0097092977,
0.010952374,
0.0025618093,
0.038049724,
-0.0255461987,
-0.0332320854,
-0.0028232827,
-0.0029457991,
0.0009209343,
0.0079532154,
-0.0314767994,
-0.0090211788,
0.0383009501,
-0.0077847284,
-0.0508828983,
-0.0570856109,
0.0202763733,
-0.0582607724,
0.0071678665,
0.1129592955,
0.0063496619,
-0.0490740985,
-0.038594123,
0.0026484749,
0.0425999239,
-0.0002595961,
0.0376236886,
-0.0413697399,
0.007913461,
0.0407752581,
0.0249853004,
0.0172396936,
-0.0055084424,
-0.0759133399,
-0.0905948281,
0.0160233453,
0.0677549541,
-0.0480911918,
-0.0440463424,
0.0129340235,
-0.0205482189,
-0.046751108,
0.0281510148,
-0.0194478594,
0.0362870619,
-0.0281790141,
0.0043841037,
-0.0116246957,
-0.0331040844,
0.0232860073,
-0.0676659271,
0.0957578272,
0.0317474529,
0.052207768,
-0.0348186381,
0.0054904041,
0.0281700753,
0.0169559941,
-0.0072610509,
-0.0146210501,
-0.0077418173,
-0.0125397407,
-0.0162216797,
-0.0108159762,
0.0411883593,
0.0643856674,
0.0346470289,
-0.0013362414,
0.0052152341,
0.0089144176,
0.019361984,
-0.0262012351,
-0.0040507913,
0.0279444028,
0.0629558861,
0.0227257255,
-0.0739364475,
-0.0138732996,
-0.003679913,
0.0054557612,
-0.0289455913,
-0.0273234658,
-0.0063576596,
0.0351983048,
-0.0573698394,
-0.0554114766,
-0.0417522714,
0.0047544632,
0.0190873407,
0.0071788444,
-0.057057485,
0.0143753188,
0.0116530107,
-0.0286585148,
0.0377647802,
-0.0253796205,
0.0304335319,
-0.020253662,
-0.0141523937,
0.0245225467,
-0.0395703502,
0.0007449423,
0.0457784235,
-0.0319548249,
-0.062288072,
0.0205798429,
0.0597772859,
0.0242986232,
0.0716689453,
-0.0565330833,
-0.0627150908,
0.027249435,
0.0120617319,
-0.0500234663,
-0.0045940634,
0.0868693441,
0.0319662541,
-0.012868749,
0.0467176102,
-0.0220547114,
0.0395132452,
-0.034663979,
0.0218100622,
-0.0097821327,
-0.0651167259,
0.0095354486,
0.0413910225,
-0.0230729692,
-0.0348000489,
0.0140418606,
-0.032393679,
0.0277748108,
-0.0066873129,
-0.0059405798,
-0.0231466889,
-0.0196366441,
0.0592909046,
0.0142022688,
0.02933711,
-0.0422445387,
-0.0014035535,
-0.0364032201,
0.0024699618,
-0.0336143747,
-0.0053606383,
0.039974764,
-0.0261121057,
0.058887545,
0.0023267462,
0.0198769588,
-0.0036730275,
0.0268126149,
-0.005412518,
-0.0104540009,
-0.0018186236,
0.022758536,
-0.0053196475,
0.0176471006,
-0.0459847786,
-0.0045700776,
-0.0358865149,
0.0123826396,
0.0244795755,
0.0346187018,
0.1070394665,
0.014535618,
-0.0044222102,
0.0035293919,
0.0122637888,
-0.0161308646,
0.0409202911,
-0.00084624,
-0.0048295949,
0.0429650471,
-0.0219850559,
0.0201986991,
0.0493424572,
0.04168218,
-0.045415733,
0.0018625042,
-0.0343987346,
-0.0222304817,
-0.0435277522,
-0.065778859,
-0.0414294451,
-0.0387472175,
-0.041187454,
-0.0368689559,
0.0325337164,
-0.0152599774,
0.0177177712,
0.0072727087,
0.0087771919,
0.04262444,
-0.0478746705,
-0.0204205196,
-0.0326468088,
-0.0180806424,
0.0534212999,
-0.0372349545,
-0.0342223719,
-5.798453922e-33,
-0.0609395206,
0.0150843412,
0.022629505,
0.0124423103,
-0.0402326733,
-0.0263584647,
-0.0184126142,
-0.0230378844,
-0.0069183903,
-0.0097506773,
0.0078239944,
0.0308510922,
0.0252892766,
-0.002155483,
-0.0138936089,
0.0135086523,
0.0938024074,
0.0332239009,
-0.0207132697,
-0.0280100163,
0.0048500816,
0.032754045,
0.0514171906,
-0.0732125267,
0.0646613017,
-0.0150835756,
-0.0627450868,
0.0035499847,
-0.0294602048,
0.0155284368,
0.0315673649,
0.0166203957,
-0.0301540513,
-0.0417971537,
0.0097493473,
0.0583992898,
-0.1096142232,
-0.0116481129,
0.0039359247,
0.0638443157,
0.029059859,
-0.0345410481,
0.0610998161,
-0.0015138392,
-0.0014080922,
-0.0337790549,
0.0219545383,
-0.0044176322,
0.0345554873,
-0.0105649736,
-0.0371595174,
0.0194507707,
-0.0166937634,
-0.019312283,
0.0630676672,
0.0776713416,
-0.042415522,
-0.0255816169,
-0.1102841869,
0.0375034325,
-0.0396512114,
-0.000691442,
0.0245753806,
0.0476236902,
-0.0056563565,
-0.0331679173,
0.0818273947,
-0.0095570805,
0.0205126088,
-0.047175806,
0.0531363636,
-0.0068743536,
0.0474837348,
0.029151218,
0.0097193299,
0.0028717224,
-0.0709815919,
-0.0211839769,
0.0164088141,
-0.003987852,
-0.0114489403,
-0.0173238013,
-0.0433981344,
-0.0159629043,
-0.0682345331,
-0.0897679031,
-0.0120226415,
-0.0016897948,
0.0070721037,
-0.0074763768,
-0.0653683767,
0.0039590672,
0.0540353842,
-0.0475008152,
-0.0009150806,
-0.0279349815,
-0.0049128267,
-0.0139869684,
0.0071948604,
0.0568841733,
-0.0074454853,
-0.0287920218,
0.0242518131,
0.0257315338,
0.0228766426,
-0.0000771812,
0.0217336416,
0.0678108111,
-0.0532092974,
-0.0143259512,
-0.0426005982,
0.0248452984,
-0.0362621397,
0.0308085103,
0.009967559,
0.0353094079,
-0.0051304568,
0.0186104216,
0.0534532145,
0.0685451403,
-0.0095791854,
0.0045275618,
0.0444712229,
0.0512378924,
-0.0450991951,
0.0038622366,
0.022962898,
-0.0063669505,
0.0587927923,
-0.0300040524,
-0.0092161028,
-0.0219994113,
2.604e-7,
-0.0141196065,
0.0450327024,
0.0307878572,
0.0106282244,
0.0201300643,
0.0338484943,
-0.0230847411,
0.0350237563,
0.0425948724,
0.0230034888,
-0.0072265035,
0.032309752,
0.0440339334,
0.0460555889,
-0.0708796233,
-0.0282939039,
-0.0577341169,
0.050720498,
0.0040776716,
-0.0053967973,
-0.013124641,
0.0774710104,
0.0211302452,
-0.0052623553,
-0.025731435,
-0.0076287282,
0.078805387,
0.0077569671,
-0.0228993706,
0.0106660854,
0.0105063953,
0.0118840216,
-0.0371426679,
0.0050468384,
0.0064554936,
0.0375606753,
0.0315856636,
0.0654296353,
-0.0145229558,
-0.0143910591,
-0.0255456083,
-0.0071551595,
-0.0382889472,
-0.0064146277,
0.0322423987,
-0.0163792167,
-0.0247629993,
-0.0189621337,
-0.016344117,
0.0638033599,
0.0722300932,
-0.0412130058,
-0.0094416523,
0.0158189777,
0.0385329612,
-0.0035993515,
-0.0229329243,
-0.0361180492,
-0.0485138632,
-0.0206910968,
-0.0246505532,
-0.0225684103,
-0.0220409092,
0.0220928825,
0.0200980473,
-0.023028139,
0.0190883782,
1.62846226e-34,
0.0124320816,
0.0034530067,
-0.014933208,
-0.0016789148,
-0.0143401623,
-0.0258612223,
-0.0058063054,
0.0128962779,
0.0430170484,
0.0203631315,
-0.0449536853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15113v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15113v2 | Counting the Bugs in ChatGPT's Wugs: A Multilingual Investigation into the Morphological Capabilities of a Large Language Model | 2023-10-23T17:21:03 | 2023-10-26T11:45:28 | Leonie Weissweiler, Valentin Hofmann, Anjali Kantharuban, Anna Cai, Ritam Dutt, Amey Hengle, Anubha Kabra, Atharva Kulkarni, Abhishek Vijayakumar, Haofei Yu, Hinrich Schütze, Kemal Oflazer, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently reached an impressive level of
linguistic capability, prompting comparisons with human language skills.
However, there have been relatively few systematic inquiries into the
linguistic capabilities of the latest generation of LLMs, and those studies
that do exist (i) ignore the remarkable ability of humans to generalize, (ii)
focus only on English, and (iii) investigate syntax or semantics and overlook
other capabilities that lie at the heart of human language, like morphology.
Here, we close these gaps by conducting the first rigorous analysis of the
morphological capabilities of ChatGPT in four typologically varied languages
(specifically, English, German, Tamil, and Turkish). We apply a version of
Berko's (1958) wug test to ChatGPT, using novel, uncontaminated datasets for
the four examined languages. We find that ChatGPT massively underperforms
purpose-built systems, particularly in English. Overall, our results -- through
the lens of morphology -- cast a new light on the linguistic capabilities of
ChatGPT, suggesting that claims of human-like language skills are premature and
misleading. | [
0.023565203,
0.0668405443,
-0.046938695,
0.0220787898,
-0.0639248565,
0.022602886,
0.0202712342,
0.0378688164,
-0.016772788,
-0.0167184193,
-0.0466379337,
-0.1022811532,
0.0337219052,
-0.0135438694,
0.0878989622,
-0.0207574051,
0.0547607467,
-0.0502934605,
-0.0274578258,
0.0055186683,
0.0165326148,
-0.0056751641,
-0.0021397714,
0.0327999443,
-0.041181881,
0.0039183516,
-0.0045968923,
-0.037527319,
-0.0247086007,
-0.0092285974,
-0.0230578762,
0.0219262987,
-0.0387583673,
0.0389334969,
0.0000016204,
-0.0609957799,
0.0560036115,
0.0013964813,
-0.0095930966,
0.0602082312,
0.0843342915,
0.0047441861,
-0.0410826169,
-0.0125182178,
-0.0137061141,
0.0144356592,
0.0597730987,
0.0070364662,
-0.0140068121,
0.0535566919,
-0.014272863,
-0.0395058654,
0.0628003925,
-0.025385417,
-0.0243619531,
0.0198746417,
0.0195976365,
-0.0093376422,
0.0555742607,
-0.0296216123,
-0.0160275009,
0.0403466709,
-0.0004234527,
0.0119695999,
-0.0847409666,
0.0420914553,
-0.0346645936,
-0.0503042601,
0.0497434475,
0.0118216127,
-0.0079800989,
-0.0466516018,
0.0226452444,
0.0266198758,
0.0210981015,
0.0120515525,
-0.0541891865,
0.0427477136,
-0.019979503,
0.0354374237,
0.0900632814,
-0.0121202786,
0.0085454946,
0.0135359075,
-0.002959227,
0.0681045577,
0.0498556681,
-0.0092564542,
-0.0131498054,
0.0204033107,
-0.045880422,
-0.062107861,
-0.0172700249,
-0.0079379017,
-0.0419816338,
0.0082278224,
0.0111539299,
-0.005387119,
0.0490908474,
-0.0432673134,
0.0359346494,
0.0000639224,
-0.0218741484,
0.0239843447,
-0.0053841891,
0.0529155843,
-0.0031520596,
0.0043713651,
-0.0423890539,
-0.0050565549,
-0.0398793779,
-0.029906176,
-0.0142262559,
-0.0285156667,
-0.0281893499,
0.0212381985,
-0.0353765786,
0.0033454055,
0.0204784237,
-0.0352110676,
0.0037607278,
-0.0246545821,
-0.0602224506,
0.0040359776,
-0.0018852366,
0.0047023944,
-0.0099380733,
-0.0141309239,
-0.0179856587,
-0.0841526613,
0.0072726654,
0.0308262426,
-0.0274300314,
-0.0278729424,
-0.0096520595,
0.0812525824,
0.0019236498,
-0.0257162787,
0.0277119651,
0.0169805884,
-0.0844126195,
-0.0554259419,
0.0021237996,
-0.0488250405,
0.0011506815,
0.0245692059,
-0.0298934784,
-0.0076001319,
-0.0106413728,
0.0054220906,
-0.0297368243,
0.0307225678,
0.0095096827,
0.0228530932,
-0.0055035288,
-0.0252779331,
0.0123488912,
0.0305198692,
0.0239463598,
-0.0109753236,
0.0391015485,
-0.0098113893,
-0.0011197051,
0.0654067472,
-0.0453542583,
0.0086071016,
-0.0451033004,
-0.0175817739,
0.030124981,
0.0180318691,
0.0322027504,
0.089985162,
-0.0018213602,
-0.0404738262,
0.0355897099,
0.0863413736,
0.0106309019,
0.0572135672,
0.0360903442,
0.0164963547,
0.0509442575,
0.041759029,
-0.0113631161,
-0.0449454486,
-0.0483449735,
0.0437076166,
-0.0621072985,
0.0630227327,
0.0146794021,
-0.010334135,
-0.0418722034,
-0.011277576,
0.017839184,
-0.0504132994,
0.0700044334,
-0.0068656784,
-0.0127537241,
0.0064679803,
0.0778932422,
-0.0331709459,
0.0162607115,
-0.0708081424,
0.0460976139,
-0.014933046,
0.0177198593,
0.0016403258,
-0.0015111191,
0.0407034196,
-0.0064644939,
0.0648707673,
0.0329930224,
0.0063602109,
-0.0088304533,
-0.0095525756,
0.053657081,
-0.0028228401,
0.0390890464,
0.0232028607,
-0.0511263311,
0.0332453251,
-0.0225221422,
-0.0147869783,
-0.0348977856,
0.017276071,
-0.0201025456,
0.0414710045,
-0.0455586724,
-0.0394159406,
0.015952101,
0.0023754144,
-0.0531743765,
0.0553969927,
0.0115819685,
-0.0540772006,
0.014734,
0.0225143582,
-0.0404346474,
-0.0270973071,
0.046448864,
-0.0079560922,
-0.0141697219,
-0.0071578543,
0.0338405073,
-0.0256902091,
0.0323913656,
-0.0636510476,
0.0654579103,
-0.0465064496,
0.0530618168,
-0.0034462481,
0.0246397331,
-0.0571385026,
0.0519859046,
0.0317993835,
0.0335496776,
-0.020800516,
-0.017351931,
0.0146354018,
-0.0422564074,
-0.0219666306,
0.0451513268,
0.0022652335,
-0.0067469892,
0.0085152006,
0.0161527283,
-0.0391186625,
-0.0711961463,
-0.1280025095,
-0.0142522398,
-0.0190078262,
0.0446138009,
0.0181489456,
-0.0181436613,
-0.0268960223,
0.0320925079,
-0.0197521765,
-0.0090784747,
0.0426890105,
0.0192986224,
0.0490649045,
-0.0292777643,
-0.0181784704,
-0.0239818953,
-0.0333020017,
-0.0156362802,
0.0327112041,
0.0326168984,
-0.0416956358,
-0.0336731449,
0.0072854129,
-0.0297395196,
-0.0104277469,
-0.0046085538,
-0.0761559382,
0.0223319214,
-0.0042276229,
0.074583374,
0.0273701567,
0.0149028283,
0.0160216745,
0.0073827896,
-0.0285953097,
-0.0068661133,
-0.0395688862,
-0.013799726,
-0.0252387617,
-0.0649793223,
-0.0258048382,
-0.004118151,
0.1041933894,
-0.0091350907,
-0.0232004151,
-0.0159783214,
0.0515298918,
-0.0790730864,
0.0120826159,
-0.0132064084,
0.0259686112,
-0.0526738986,
0.0474508516,
-0.0249239206,
-0.0354000553,
0.0315410197,
-0.063452594,
-0.0320156887,
-0.028004745,
-0.0215972979,
-0.0327325799,
0.0521843396,
0.0324302986,
-0.0105662942,
0.0397286564,
-0.0262395404,
-0.0459065363,
0.0562447757,
0.0039089983,
-0.0125199072,
0.0080480454,
-0.0685399547,
-0.0036837405,
-0.0054554329,
-0.0567772537,
0.0038321498,
-0.0298571922,
-0.0363937318,
0.0341730155,
0.0497173071,
-0.0416808017,
-0.0141176051,
0.0482180193,
-0.0041613337,
0.0011759964,
-0.0274481364,
0.0177386757,
-0.0013856776,
0.0381236374,
0.0383732244,
0.0449305885,
0.0072734873,
-0.005376067,
-0.0045963614,
0.037856698,
-0.0290630721,
0.0321088992,
0.0195375644,
0.0224284474,
0.022103399,
-0.0344544202,
-0.0910997093,
-0.016417101,
0.0607825294,
-0.0223276261,
-0.0056115878,
0.081955336,
0.0368823558,
0.0387947597,
0.0508870371,
-0.0128468089,
0.0429221056,
0.0292040352,
0.0151716545,
-0.0423305221,
-0.0104299719,
0.020309262,
-0.0331482068,
0.0037892053,
-0.0278511234,
0.0053373296,
-0.0990950465,
0.0330644213,
0.0140608614,
-0.0568157695,
0.0532177351,
-0.0050509172,
0.0095723458,
-0.0181445032,
0.0346342735,
0.043136064,
-0.0475376248,
0.0299857724,
0.0332291536,
-0.0661055818,
-0.0423052125,
0.012402555,
-0.0379670337,
0.0152100353,
0.0119221713,
0.0302428622,
-0.0507305935,
-0.0524515696,
0.0557475276,
-0.0027689708,
0.0226886123,
-0.0001997337,
0.0158562511,
0.0367808156,
-0.0381832011,
-0.0797670633,
-0.0068390039,
-0.0155281685,
0.0017129951,
-0.0235287063,
0.0686576962,
0.0169447046,
-0.0400751643,
0.0255870484,
-0.0296148472,
-0.0503695756,
0.0405891463,
0.0217627808,
-0.0745014176,
-0.044912912,
-0.0248336196,
-0.0405614749,
0.0189404842,
-0.0909988508,
0.016489625,
-0.0006372216,
-0.0396556444,
-0.0890486762,
-0.0491883159,
0.0324532241,
-0.0031182813,
-0.0038735056,
-0.0084737828,
0.0020077324,
-0.0258894246,
-0.0084563587,
0.0284735542,
0.0110799232,
0.0184738412,
-0.0893496722,
-0.0020495653,
0.0709117278,
0.0002102683,
-0.0378818214,
-0.0069363816,
-0.0343110003,
-0.0780794472,
0.0311368816,
-0.0168185905,
0.0245958902,
-0.0434286483,
-0.013469615,
-0.0350320451,
-0.0145343514,
0.0214229897,
-0.0278440323,
0.0603005812,
0.0052628643,
-0.0032373762,
0.0177259557,
0.0462296307,
0.0077121668,
0.0169334561,
-0.0071032289,
0.0336967595,
-0.0222381055,
-0.010058051,
0.0309100915,
0.051752165,
0.0419703797,
-0.035603486,
0.0125981951,
-0.0262145866,
-0.0531799048,
-0.0032786592,
0.0154071422,
-0.0374499112,
-0.0171703752,
0.0414279662,
0.0257545635,
-0.0363791436,
-0.0174685474,
-0.0241734795,
0.0412590019,
-0.0101864254,
0.0185358636,
0.0093456386,
-0.0103108231,
0.0099732904,
0.0323946252,
0.0127217006,
-0.0056644641,
-0.0575166084,
0.0392737091,
-0.0409106128,
0.0333836116,
-0.0202116128,
-0.0056288484,
0.0116039868,
0.0353524163,
-0.0057032378,
-0.0303721521,
0.0229259171,
0.0631167144,
0.0553588606,
-0.0227260608,
0.046583645,
-0.0705311522,
0.0088440152,
-0.0561263748,
0.0284980964,
-0.0170826353,
-0.0010156452,
0.0070469994,
0.0066336235,
-0.0573447458,
-0.0184543412,
0.0671931207,
0.0283686761,
-0.0042031077,
0.0196562354,
-0.0053821299,
-0.014897895,
-0.0431800745,
-0.0098453471,
-0.0286418721,
-0.00790672,
0.0316047929,
-0.0839064047,
-0.0923356414,
-0.0436686128,
0.033229012,
0.0348593704,
-0.018587118,
-0.0122755878,
0.0297725517,
-0.0086041465,
0.0094346944,
-0.0350285135,
-0.005019886,
0.0140076,
-0.0014221104,
-0.0089131333,
-5.457494806e-33,
-0.0024911806,
0.0124012614,
-0.0255535394,
-0.0116039282,
-0.0037558151,
-0.0378111005,
-0.0106601398,
0.073811166,
-0.0011506886,
0.0276286751,
-0.0313528851,
-0.0071269488,
0.0069829258,
0.0015459827,
0.0392566398,
0.0324973278,
0.0035714435,
-0.0225876048,
0.0145872748,
-0.026620863,
0.0060553695,
-0.007982933,
0.0871374756,
0.000744807,
0.0196931791,
-0.0250760373,
0.023935318,
0.0072706835,
-0.0339497142,
0.0497384965,
-0.0247895829,
0.0428635851,
0.0341620632,
0.0001671939,
-0.0205661561,
-0.0091098556,
-0.038866207,
-0.017465692,
0.0563856922,
0.0116887949,
-0.0005105376,
-0.015877312,
0.0018082218,
-0.0278772414,
-0.0584744364,
0.0253371894,
0.0075516836,
-0.0064227916,
0.0031205532,
0.0321112424,
-0.0391009599,
0.0409426801,
-0.0007321926,
0.030360816,
0.0085072117,
-0.0334198177,
-0.0091899335,
-0.0341136083,
0.0048620892,
0.0006022088,
0.013225955,
0.0517314114,
0.064188242,
-0.0281466953,
-0.0134693338,
0.0426858477,
0.0703539923,
0.0023959577,
0.0286614671,
0.0076397113,
0.0590755381,
0.0240519308,
0.0381303094,
0.0185824372,
0.0516532585,
-0.0229813289,
-0.0298297051,
-0.0388411433,
0.0361434259,
0.0526757874,
-0.0178492442,
0.0196528584,
-0.0629569665,
-0.0362312905,
0.0146021955,
-0.0123313805,
0.0042917747,
-0.0135638472,
0.0298110899,
-0.0487480015,
0.0359846242,
0.004765172,
0.0142403077,
-0.028526172,
-0.0268625189,
-0.038962841,
-0.0281879753,
0.0411093533,
-0.00531661,
0.0297432542,
-0.0301845912,
-0.0101639116,
-0.0286716726,
0.0547733568,
0.0327553302,
0.0017158597,
0.0054920083,
-0.0005412138,
-0.0630903989,
0.0033151177,
-0.0051669106,
0.0101715624,
0.0043749274,
-0.0190599672,
0.0696188137,
-0.0112062674,
0.0046559181,
-0.0291069038,
0.0264261179,
-0.0194300618,
-0.0459877402,
0.0086552771,
-0.020599898,
-0.0140932389,
0.0045188814,
0.0119729741,
-0.0181195438,
0.0511366725,
0.065762043,
0.0043314304,
-0.0057009193,
0.0187067352,
2.461e-7,
0.0348260626,
0.0804965794,
0.0053842864,
0.01802429,
0.0333600715,
0.000208762,
-0.0634369329,
-0.0173205417,
-0.0034931384,
0.0084537622,
-0.0220418666,
0.0032657818,
0.0625994503,
0.0106205298,
-0.0747884959,
0.0135368127,
-0.0886465609,
0.0023654231,
-0.0642869547,
-0.0073644803,
0.0178520381,
0.0993387774,
-0.0111090858,
-0.0109966462,
-0.0132388007,
-0.0728310272,
0.0575319007,
-0.041592706,
-0.029335238,
0.0172792971,
0.0549767241,
-0.0351669118,
0.0301902313,
0.0325634331,
0.0023098574,
0.0334918164,
0.0256889239,
0.0339008942,
-0.0096947933,
0.0491469689,
0.0403799899,
-0.0241454337,
-0.0237180684,
-0.0618128031,
0.0494343266,
-0.0298349373,
-0.0393784232,
-0.006563067,
0.0185656361,
0.0255900305,
0.0071602878,
0.0036079562,
-0.0176672824,
0.0253599957,
0.0518546961,
-0.0441755615,
-0.0100178262,
-0.0348017626,
-0.0051211277,
0.0490997508,
-0.0401438624,
-0.0750918537,
-0.0160130374,
0.0362886898,
0.0241581388,
-0.0148470402,
-0.0202411339,
2.121873144e-34,
0.0433105901,
0.0086211571,
0.0540624149,
0.0030681021,
0.0528836027,
0.006628749,
0.0614936799,
0.0701912493,
-0.0035768903,
-0.0640161633,
-0.023701245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15109v1 | GRENADE: Graph-Centric Language Model for Self-Supervised Representation Learning on Text-Attributed Graphs | 2023-10-23T17:18:35 | 2023-10-23T17:18:35 | Yichuan Li, Kaize Ding, Kyumin Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Self-supervised representation learning on text-attributed graphs, which aims
to create expressive and generalizable representations for various downstream
tasks, has received increasing research attention lately. However, existing
methods either struggle to capture the full extent of structural context
information or rely on task-specific training labels, which largely hampers
their effectiveness and generalizability in practice. To solve the problem of
self-supervised representation learning on text-attributed graphs, we develop a
novel Graph-Centric Language model -- GRENADE. Specifically, GRENADE exploits
the synergistic effect of both pre-trained language model and graph neural
network by optimizing with two specialized self-supervised learning algorithms:
graph-centric contrastive learning and graph-centric knowledge alignment. The
proposed graph-centric self-supervised learning algorithms effectively help
GRENADE to capture informative textual semantics as well as structural context
information on text-attributed graphs. Through extensive experiments, GRENADE
shows its superiority over state-of-the-art methods. Implementation is
available at \url{https://github.com/bigheiniu/GRENADE}. | [
0.0152383484,
0.0272682365,
0.0232425798,
0.0346074402,
-0.0346003063,
-0.0013033884,
-0.0127421804,
-0.0312438291,
0.067523852,
-0.0458528586,
-0.0396834314,
0.0196710452,
-0.0247974675,
0.0323003754,
0.0348334797,
0.0102136517,
0.020144973,
0.0339355171,
0.0231143981,
-0.0170172155,
0.0234419219,
0.042979192,
0.0307048876,
-0.0031242827,
-0.0197710358,
-0.0263993405,
-0.0046913889,
0.0422145799,
-0.0160935353,
-0.0390120819,
-0.0107100895,
0.0130227134,
0.0219101738,
0.0075959289,
0.0000017758,
-0.0128137292,
-0.0291147996,
-0.0135199074,
-0.0207019914,
-0.0018525929,
0.0707619265,
-0.0094881486,
0.0152852247,
-0.0180337168,
-0.0484724827,
-0.0451548398,
0.0613948219,
0.0556053407,
0.0581217632,
0.0682491586,
-0.0319941305,
-0.055219695,
-0.0078839995,
-0.0270123929,
0.0181319322,
-0.0444119312,
0.0250017587,
0.0361132361,
-0.0176725835,
0.0313169546,
-0.0575802103,
0.0237295777,
-0.0044116504,
-0.0078256177,
0.0520423278,
0.0330987945,
0.0020700316,
0.0496293902,
-0.004933103,
0.1320751458,
-0.0187244453,
-0.0516768955,
0.0092007145,
-0.0237217024,
0.0045465766,
-0.0005266234,
-0.0216137022,
-0.0281842016,
0.0137460697,
0.033962179,
0.023493195,
0.0090892855,
0.0604071431,
-0.0180642176,
0.001854254,
0.0465097129,
-0.0215847846,
0.0099311704,
-0.0026027353,
-0.0083797975,
-0.0003317519,
-0.0254891869,
0.0002061985,
0.0348480158,
0.0072985427,
0.0186839085,
-0.0387624092,
-0.0245865248,
-0.0095975576,
-0.0200691111,
0.0251288153,
0.0105490768,
-0.0016182053,
0.0544972494,
-0.0369648188,
0.047740452,
-0.0319923386,
0.0729378313,
-0.0418948904,
-0.0067181089,
-0.0627121255,
-0.0123277288,
-0.0633131862,
0.0298772771,
0.0255841967,
-0.059107542,
-0.0290187635,
0.0556414649,
-0.021480836,
0.0052977609,
0.039908234,
0.0363144949,
-0.0234015658,
-0.0251867715,
0.021680586,
0.0433642976,
0.0235849526,
-0.0074265632,
-0.0136564933,
0.0198093802,
-0.0100827059,
0.0045355372,
0.0581969023,
-0.0335631445,
0.0188901834,
0.0774639398,
0.034648858,
-0.0207175463,
0.0085808225,
0.0160917751,
-0.024614064,
-0.051242616,
0.0174476188,
-0.0649083555,
0.0432266518,
0.0287274532,
-0.0068681766,
-0.0662201494,
0.0223252475,
-0.0181929395,
-0.0422960818,
0.0770095214,
-0.0277986303,
0.0010225311,
-0.0161997955,
-0.0281773005,
-0.0166160334,
0.0278147217,
0.020675296,
0.0226021241,
0.0094686467,
-0.001698512,
-0.0230869129,
-0.0110400496,
0.0495672338,
0.0084593771,
0.0044286037,
0.0142207127,
0.0047602491,
0.0177075602,
0.017110439,
0.0462211184,
-0.0087511763,
-0.0350299068,
0.0642486364,
0.0261825528,
0.0045651784,
0.0067374082,
0.0366600119,
0.0472443737,
-0.0019028884,
0.009069195,
-0.0536806211,
0.0254258458,
0.014875493,
0.0294678025,
-0.0132364221,
-0.0096830055,
-0.0574345849,
-0.0198055785,
0.0207707491,
-0.043814905,
0.0853984877,
-0.0016875102,
0.0633829609,
0.0381133519,
-0.0600748435,
-0.0009953131,
0.0309645776,
-0.0176049471,
0.0138293905,
0.0081430692,
-0.0189791191,
0.0481921509,
0.0266718268,
-0.0397120267,
-0.0456807204,
0.0022321423,
0.0078356564,
-0.0183059089,
0.0148700178,
-0.01051002,
-0.0044651031,
-0.0337668136,
-0.0512922555,
-0.075656563,
-0.0115035195,
0.018156033,
-0.0374126062,
-0.0140815992,
0.0132939909,
-0.0970320255,
-0.0541012436,
0.0299053099,
0.0222196132,
-0.0239862464,
0.0043276902,
0.023401035,
-0.0284083262,
0.0299342703,
-0.000901265,
0.0241388939,
0.0194178615,
0.0075545264,
-0.0271476768,
0.0067941323,
-0.0600343831,
-0.0867884904,
0.0483246744,
-0.0328500457,
-0.0569969118,
0.0142906466,
-0.0567856692,
-0.0579467155,
0.0709505305,
-0.0586394481,
0.0184042491,
0.0024068654,
0.0128329694,
0.0060521043,
-0.0047229514,
0.0091955466,
0.0683286414,
0.0275539942,
-0.0043033538,
-0.035552647,
0.0555242822,
0.0197966527,
-0.0247449912,
-0.0013463118,
-0.0194981452,
0.008801451,
0.0196633134,
0.0459774807,
0.0006526913,
-0.0283411499,
0.0292414278,
-0.0706507191,
0.0004681148,
-0.0024701958,
0.0101478435,
0.0325390436,
0.0019228883,
0.0259196162,
-0.0425511189,
-0.0765241683,
0.0143534755,
-0.0086520743,
-0.0085723568,
0.0350034647,
-0.0346108228,
0.0274804495,
-0.0323179029,
-0.0316970572,
-0.0316341408,
0.0832364857,
0.0320973396,
-0.0313736051,
0.0031216587,
0.0120108481,
-0.0417574681,
0.0410757884,
-0.0027668099,
-0.0179049596,
-0.0175982397,
-0.0152836377,
0.0350100547,
0.0527476817,
-0.0323544368,
0.0083484082,
0.0391395129,
0.0103172502,
-0.0257427096,
-0.0286444742,
-0.0605515763,
0.0326141678,
-0.0170714352,
0.0025591278,
-0.0211378206,
0.065827623,
0.0192318857,
-0.016250914,
-0.0535605736,
-0.026639333,
0.0064145448,
0.0246879943,
-0.007929814,
-0.0233715679,
0.0111364797,
-0.0463583134,
-0.0711088255,
-0.0115192086,
0.0746086314,
-0.0069273845,
0.0121723739,
0.0241992883,
-0.022462545,
-0.0562309958,
0.0696767345,
0.0573052056,
0.0479938909,
0.0141973533,
-0.0297529437,
-0.0481738113,
0.0004222214,
0.0442661233,
-0.0325974487,
-0.0165059157,
0.0262521897,
0.0421308763,
0.0224776156,
-0.0273041334,
-0.0105913663,
-0.0204203054,
-0.0083119506,
0.0438139737,
-0.0018698282,
0.0104231881,
-0.0006055025,
0.0074235694,
-0.0241069589,
0.0498319976,
-0.0178790689,
0.001964702,
-0.0443742685,
0.0465746596,
0.0343082696,
-0.0645509139,
0.0002090923,
0.0082378099,
0.0027513616,
0.0481257476,
0.0464700125,
-0.0458988547,
-0.0394158922,
0.024038136,
-0.0039166245,
-0.0330587886,
-0.0065545184,
-0.0306207258,
0.0524712466,
-0.0147682736,
-0.0072870827,
0.0594435707,
0.0180254895,
-0.0483913906,
0.0062770345,
0.0253901519,
-0.0165350661,
0.0371656343,
0.0018528614,
-0.0877640173,
-0.0261206068,
-0.0384952761,
-0.0089261252,
0.0458969697,
-0.0392478555,
-0.0019468542,
-0.0890847072,
-0.0177716147,
0.0374973975,
-0.0160077196,
-0.0445887707,
-0.0306288339,
0.0062080864,
-0.0438752398,
-0.0271648727,
-0.0199595988,
-0.0171604604,
-0.0049472833,
0.0105535826,
-0.0241814312,
-0.00396463,
0.0180297941,
-0.0437602699,
0.0178603604,
0.0063338215,
0.0420377515,
0.0175282955,
0.0287756994,
0.0247465279,
-0.0169625524,
-0.0198228639,
0.0001937506,
0.0598122738,
-0.0377616361,
-0.001941254,
-0.0035799507,
0.0146034062,
-0.0517857336,
-0.0134921558,
-0.0665696263,
0.0683857054,
-0.0012900458,
-0.0033744646,
-0.0031980297,
-0.0258375518,
0.0364990756,
0.0259211864,
0.031163644,
-0.0139678447,
-0.0704736412,
-0.0309149288,
0.0330593735,
-0.0493025072,
-0.038397748,
0.0294470619,
-0.0447818004,
0.0033919276,
-0.0476277731,
-0.0308254268,
0.0084158909,
0.0056873495,
-0.0078382827,
0.0138753168,
0.0280598644,
-0.0673901439,
-0.1034414768,
0.0068944134,
-0.0475959927,
0.007483311,
0.0165582132,
-0.0376403295,
0.0464413464,
-0.0319249183,
-0.0028085993,
0.0289415363,
-0.0404182523,
-0.0684898794,
-0.0087323757,
0.0253353789,
0.0028220543,
0.071303755,
-0.0525538549,
0.0018138883,
0.0414855741,
0.0300018154,
-0.0410779752,
-0.0264781378,
0.0220202543,
-0.0147519615,
-0.0075969375,
0.0285027195,
-0.0620225556,
0.0484498739,
0.0642070696,
0.0443458445,
-0.0337138623,
-0.0514974296,
0.0403766818,
0.0359475315,
0.0441747271,
0.017080104,
0.0624389686,
-0.0547740608,
-0.0474127121,
-0.0246058255,
-0.0469895415,
-0.0341528878,
-0.0109780505,
0.0035629398,
-0.0161164347,
0.010439896,
-0.0293342825,
0.0000736558,
0.0357737578,
-0.0409229957,
-0.0423952416,
-0.0262135491,
-0.0116192671,
0.0073136003,
0.0181534048,
-0.0021795454,
0.0214661974,
0.0341628939,
-0.0095480625,
-0.0044803279,
0.008852616,
0.0399877653,
0.0001383755,
-0.0710850358,
0.0318502374,
-0.0423687063,
0.0242005587,
-0.0452189445,
-0.0403423607,
0.0559063554,
-0.0118557056,
0.0350970179,
-0.0187199172,
-0.0165034402,
-0.0128377434,
0.0943127573,
-0.0051169442,
-0.0362415947,
0.0358151682,
0.012058273,
-0.0023824149,
0.0200195704,
0.0430118516,
0.0648578554,
0.0345106833,
0.0160724837,
-0.0470666513,
-0.0327821821,
-0.0136268213,
-0.0179356486,
0.0388494618,
-0.0140583646,
0.0078377388,
-0.0303977244,
-0.1068821549,
0.0277555771,
0.0010636646,
-0.0140983388,
0.0230062325,
0.0395136513,
0.0059686727,
0.0281051937,
-0.0035546676,
-0.0457136966,
0.0522369221,
-0.0049918569,
-0.0048805415,
0.0104505531,
-5.931595187e-33,
-0.0192173291,
-0.0671612546,
0.0089276163,
0.0106353965,
-0.0464592502,
0.0322972499,
-0.069387801,
-0.0063591357,
-0.0263962857,
0.0334806591,
0.0083663762,
0.0113388048,
-0.0057148682,
0.0210481677,
-0.0357516147,
-0.029183872,
0.0013909783,
0.0033971202,
0.0051996633,
0.0449998192,
0.0345584005,
0.027074866,
0.0686207786,
-0.1156437844,
0.0044029863,
-0.0391162485,
0.007338916,
0.0123253064,
0.0741890892,
0.0402631238,
0.0031645361,
0.0555824414,
0.0169955082,
-0.0142237507,
-0.0035523497,
0.003905063,
-0.0983964428,
-0.0525378659,
-0.0053250999,
0.0026992606,
-0.0572066046,
-0.0254936162,
0.0463690795,
-0.0102681154,
0.0230145436,
-0.0254940707,
0.0601982251,
0.0206744764,
-0.0300210286,
0.0004038458,
-0.0525138229,
0.0202965196,
-0.0246536471,
0.0000660908,
0.027178131,
-0.0082353037,
0.0316738486,
0.0148963351,
-0.0646464527,
0.0242355485,
-0.0953069478,
-0.0210593157,
0.0183548816,
0.0433698632,
0.0392734334,
0.0396067537,
0.0061554145,
0.0169886183,
-0.0408959463,
0.0232022945,
-0.0044725044,
0.0599157177,
0.0145345954,
0.0097266939,
-0.0288218725,
0.0086031733,
-0.0889265016,
-0.0031300285,
0.0029601527,
0.0064986511,
-0.0016905445,
0.0337572619,
-0.0209666099,
-0.0393680483,
-0.0155221717,
-0.0391479954,
-0.0263990462,
-0.0230738539,
-0.0157056693,
-0.0266285948,
-0.0409270637,
0.0687523857,
-0.0118996128,
-0.0812366232,
-0.0131174764,
0.0871253312,
-0.026767483,
0.0400745235,
-0.0268949736,
0.0240988322,
-0.0574586689,
-0.046197664,
0.0131272795,
0.0048486013,
0.0258088391,
0.0240101218,
0.0643291697,
0.0264659561,
-0.0260859765,
0.002341839,
-0.048309803,
-0.0471217781,
-0.0264883079,
-0.0249186791,
0.0567114651,
0.0556797013,
-0.0149525395,
0.0557214394,
0.0804483965,
0.001242644,
0.0098622683,
0.0080081457,
0.0051033809,
0.0377726555,
-0.0354578421,
-0.012433934,
-0.0325142816,
0.0244757887,
0.0107327625,
-0.0623770319,
-0.0306658261,
-0.003760064,
2.456e-7,
0.0761687234,
0.0052531944,
0.0597118735,
0.0347698033,
0.0073226858,
0.0422676392,
-0.0127281239,
0.0503565744,
-0.0013420655,
-0.0095997676,
0.0596861057,
0.0856206939,
-0.0237284433,
-0.006938186,
-0.0384995751,
0.0929136649,
-0.0624222457,
0.0147334337,
-0.0084054517,
0.0531768203,
0.030759234,
0.0498186685,
0.049888365,
-0.0011116653,
-0.0229390897,
-0.0414441712,
0.0792033896,
0.0177855603,
0.0028047215,
0.0256993249,
-0.0216208789,
0.011680047,
-0.0666324273,
0.0121851247,
-0.0037225988,
0.0267975852,
0.0577282496,
0.0259747617,
-0.0472905673,
-0.0143641625,
0.0039633648,
-0.0309015028,
0.0258385595,
-0.0066719363,
0.0677943304,
-0.0828848705,
-0.0443324149,
-0.0139330775,
-0.0545983985,
0.0007413164,
0.0062924949,
0.0253040437,
-0.0193102174,
0.0114837363,
0.0325233154,
-0.0032616509,
-0.0292451605,
-0.0608976148,
-0.0273990855,
0.0313918665,
0.0162165854,
0.0041295062,
0.0321402363,
0.0524449721,
0.0434746705,
-0.0484267846,
0.0285005271,
1.984312984e-34,
0.0049391706,
-0.0041392683,
-0.0366572104,
-0.0060506854,
0.001471985,
-0.0390347838,
-0.0165977329,
0.0206624698,
0.044944644,
-0.064753145,
-0.0192796718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15100v1 | LLM-in-the-loop: Leveraging Large Language Model for Thematic Analysis | 2023-10-23T17:05:59 | 2023-10-23T17:05:59 | Shih-Chieh Dai, Aiping Xiong, Lun-Wei Ku | cs.CL | cs.CL | Thematic analysis (TA) has been widely used for analyzing qualitative data in
many disciplines and fields. To ensure reliable analysis, the same piece of
data is typically assigned to at least two human coders. Moreover, to produce
meaningful and useful analysis, human coders develop and deepen their data
interpretation and coding over multiple iterations, making TA labor-intensive
and time-consuming. Recently the emerging field of large language models (LLMs)
research has shown that LLMs have the potential replicate human-like behavior
in various tasks: in particular, LLMs outperform crowd workers on
text-annotation tasks, suggesting an opportunity to leverage LLMs on TA. We
propose a human-LLM collaboration framework (i.e., LLM-in-the-loop) to conduct
TA with in-context learning (ICL). This framework provides the prompt to frame
discussions with a LLM (e.g., GPT-3.5) to generate the final codebook for TA.
We demonstrate the utility of this framework using survey datasets on the
aspects of the music listening experience and the usage of a password manager.
Results of the two case studies show that the proposed framework yields similar
coding quality to that of human coders but reduces TA's labor and time demands. | [
0.0590128154,
0.0656982586,
-0.0239447877,
0.032105267,
-0.0101208296,
0.0299268328,
-0.0018705991,
-0.0309553854,
-0.0286189243,
0.0053084255,
-0.0479714498,
0.0230586305,
-0.0086693782,
0.0097877001,
0.0152188223,
-0.0113879293,
-0.0118779587,
-0.0394167416,
0.0359555297,
0.0176102687,
0.0171740893,
0.0279523935,
0.0017469492,
0.0605175346,
0.0062020323,
-0.0051785,
-0.0298529267,
0.0068273139,
0.0101842238,
-0.0541630983,
0.0060673621,
0.0633270293,
0.0453006476,
0.0470761359,
0.0000021234,
-0.0331068113,
0.013481251,
0.0134081366,
0.0173804127,
-0.0080095232,
0.0445680544,
0.0275918134,
-0.0105043678,
0.0284763724,
-0.0473079197,
0.0026197017,
0.053322006,
-0.0105696758,
0.0639391914,
0.0153500363,
-0.0104288403,
-0.0382459685,
-0.0308170822,
-0.0194050744,
-0.0041911709,
-0.0218333155,
0.002745105,
0.0058421055,
0.0386547297,
0.0418073572,
0.0208035503,
0.0370540246,
0.0190986246,
-0.0092089335,
0.0568586327,
0.0163700972,
-0.0630680099,
-0.042174127,
0.0098502906,
0.0620235987,
0.0655295327,
-0.0068473932,
0.0066878237,
0.0109635005,
0.0140583441,
0.0212110337,
-0.0492300391,
0.0295791626,
0.0060047614,
0.0185425635,
-0.0308559593,
0.0174533091,
0.0287509989,
-0.0018824763,
0.0108550852,
0.0333232917,
-0.0270123444,
-0.032586664,
0.0147078345,
0.0302823,
0.0132627394,
-0.0348949581,
-0.0054894923,
0.0083214706,
-0.0524586104,
0.0031192945,
0.0155949732,
-0.0209123846,
0.0238119569,
-0.043265529,
0.0350591503,
0.0071206,
-0.0050820457,
0.035204988,
0.0299666133,
-0.0313581713,
0.0068325549,
-0.0122509804,
-0.0184844378,
-0.0171581563,
-0.0730684847,
-0.0133079542,
0.0100951428,
0.0055219396,
0.0012035799,
0.0058470373,
-0.018715797,
0.0315458961,
-0.0180425029,
0.0238055997,
-0.0449189246,
-0.0144611336,
0.0008442544,
0.0053577474,
0.0096848933,
0.0129547054,
-0.0322974101,
0.0687553734,
0.0028452335,
-0.0155050373,
0.0655012205,
0.0146833919,
-0.002553365,
-0.0029015266,
0.0179362372,
0.0059577581,
0.009839341,
0.0115695847,
-0.0743955523,
-0.0368855186,
0.0135545917,
-0.0256270543,
-0.0252951849,
-0.0907544717,
0.0328103192,
0.0289520249,
-0.0108940266,
-0.0387909673,
-0.0030128753,
0.0257758424,
-0.0165135767,
0.0739787295,
-0.0362764336,
0.0419620238,
0.0542668849,
0.0398151614,
0.0271155555,
0.0691982657,
0.0500590801,
0.0357857011,
0.0179807227,
-0.0453683473,
0.0036103989,
0.064113155,
-0.018724069,
0.0082648136,
-0.0238779616,
0.0017087257,
-0.0051121255,
0.022727685,
0.0199055113,
0.0634420961,
-0.0207362082,
0.0627280623,
0.0823217779,
0.1110742763,
0.022979755,
0.0398110598,
0.0088882353,
0.0206433386,
-0.0030625167,
-0.0513813756,
0.011898133,
0.0129576586,
0.0163706075,
-0.0151141398,
0.0585295409,
-0.0266525429,
-0.0154620772,
-0.0219515283,
-0.0154313548,
0.0076058744,
0.015085537,
0.0385778025,
0.018187141,
-0.0250677131,
-0.0021784957,
-0.0190044343,
0.0029662941,
-0.0740958229,
0.0192584042,
-0.0466583818,
0.0637537539,
0.093616426,
0.0303100515,
-0.0000031951,
0.049051173,
-0.0449107401,
0.0289389752,
0.0302426554,
0.0084806327,
-0.0472145043,
-0.0619027652,
-0.0287069343,
-0.0422819965,
-0.0023376078,
-0.0209221393,
0.0156318564,
0.0112400092,
-0.004708359,
-0.0039557433,
-0.0051762322,
-0.0584749356,
-0.0000277153,
-0.0281866584,
-0.0287239179,
-0.0003070686,
0.0138342902,
0.0291257203,
0.075200282,
-0.0244776942,
0.0243672971,
0.0220932495,
-0.0423711203,
0.0029153554,
0.0148823652,
-0.0043138661,
0.0452537127,
0.0216437466,
-0.0554270931,
-0.0178547408,
0.0298900865,
-0.0036941192,
-0.0093694944,
0.0241972562,
-0.0204483233,
0.0438001305,
-0.0281244367,
-0.0326804146,
-0.0236508735,
-0.0175465364,
-0.0047482685,
0.0280796587,
-0.001577315,
-0.0020274993,
-0.0088667702,
-0.0104507934,
0.0093924096,
-0.0280591231,
-0.0313654765,
0.0239726938,
0.0221810527,
0.055804003,
0.0447781272,
0.0063961935,
-0.0519186743,
-0.0307445731,
-0.136553511,
-0.0065829889,
-0.0168365911,
0.0154103944,
0.0345554203,
-0.0019088812,
-0.0201490745,
-0.0143103134,
-0.0316293575,
-0.0470789112,
-0.0205981005,
0.0501988605,
-0.0002585653,
0.0242677089,
0.0059125144,
0.0014666279,
-0.007439306,
-0.0206974894,
0.0057810866,
0.066784583,
-0.0347044729,
-0.0531294085,
-0.0132806441,
0.0038300764,
-0.0460866801,
0.0141584696,
-0.0037464858,
0.0405616574,
-0.0029092189,
0.0751582682,
0.025978392,
-0.0089941379,
0.0487551987,
0.0449727178,
-0.0075005,
-0.0271042045,
-0.0090336362,
0.0180145297,
-0.0415907986,
-0.0312322769,
-0.0574601777,
0.0316823125,
0.0596453063,
0.0052951197,
0.0236159861,
-0.0522037223,
0.008283738,
-0.0557869934,
-0.0135658346,
-0.0907643959,
-0.0464304723,
-0.0553870536,
0.0909204707,
0.0135394912,
-0.022874251,
0.0368321948,
0.0173857901,
0.0079972511,
-0.03783058,
-0.0513516627,
-0.0537474677,
0.0527116656,
-0.0707549006,
0.0005657864,
-0.0150906788,
-0.0277650822,
-0.0007958414,
0.0066462504,
0.0062165144,
-0.0630191639,
0.0191472955,
-0.0680195615,
-0.0190730542,
-0.0153313503,
-0.0353481732,
-0.0051697129,
-0.0319885164,
-0.0893295631,
-0.0093462765,
0.0056299889,
-0.001597916,
0.0107630035,
-0.0176371541,
0.0272522345,
0.0322020762,
0.0369254015,
-0.0231953692,
-0.0050801453,
0.0036212686,
0.0145833166,
-0.0129750073,
-0.0143051166,
-0.0303722266,
0.0068120873,
0.0414990708,
0.0301027652,
-0.0093657887,
-0.0231383909,
0.0017011398,
0.0361179449,
0.007889661,
-0.0091482429,
0.0637292787,
0.0458249003,
-0.050971847,
0.022832334,
0.1108699515,
0.0221133027,
-0.1104175299,
-0.0047131819,
-0.0314787924,
0.0342093371,
0.0185172204,
0.0002618421,
-0.0837026983,
-0.0229397584,
0.0226164181,
0.0795614347,
-0.0030608252,
-0.0440756902,
0.0125220213,
-0.102407597,
0.0559932441,
-0.0013077654,
-0.0236883368,
0.0107472725,
-0.0712979212,
0.0050595826,
-0.0233429372,
-0.0186639763,
0.0069532068,
-0.007025437,
0.0216476899,
0.0462094396,
-0.0577212013,
-0.0602558181,
0.0395443626,
-0.0436579436,
0.0667506531,
0.0965353921,
0.0352204144,
-0.0292077158,
-0.0575411096,
0.015597024,
0.0090194875,
0.015376145,
0.0182017982,
0.0050442307,
0.0027368669,
-0.0009466948,
-0.0064789378,
0.0920764282,
-0.0862342045,
-0.0221693274,
0.058478348,
0.0855209231,
0.0258260407,
0.0201320257,
-0.0168086421,
0.0031899151,
0.0217514466,
0.0684677139,
0.0567622483,
-0.0824949965,
0.0181321185,
-0.0236812141,
-0.0100250626,
-0.0059651234,
-0.0820296928,
-0.0082400767,
0.0165438242,
-0.0129964631,
-0.0170758478,
-0.049910482,
0.0754994303,
-0.0057407613,
0.0188086145,
0.0165629052,
0.010199463,
-0.0284662116,
-0.0674549788,
0.042167373,
-0.0389043577,
0.0527766533,
-0.0473276787,
-0.0307338554,
-0.0103805708,
-0.0094996691,
0.0056157527,
0.0106409453,
-0.106124118,
-0.0498369969,
0.0231071003,
0.0124380356,
0.0220718216,
0.0444803275,
0.017031448,
-0.0764328167,
-0.0004240706,
0.0524460413,
-0.085749954,
0.0195127148,
-0.0052374704,
0.0585088432,
-0.0021214839,
-0.0165669918,
-0.0378709994,
-0.0182360802,
-0.007603664,
0.0191585235,
-0.0499484688,
-0.0210745241,
0.0268472992,
0.0024472696,
0.0463802703,
-0.0441581458,
-0.020707991,
-0.0263836998,
-0.0348123275,
0.0000389342,
-0.0448992476,
-0.0429998115,
-0.0354862921,
0.0059760301,
-0.0282960329,
-0.0140972817,
0.017509602,
-0.0110204658,
0.003816369,
-0.0419976339,
0.0776522234,
0.0306003895,
0.0208930988,
0.0385915153,
-0.0072089955,
-0.0197151471,
-0.0012451367,
0.0040998831,
0.0248210486,
0.0336417183,
0.0307354704,
0.004313848,
0.005403195,
0.0540086478,
0.043532379,
-0.0212076213,
-0.0600796081,
0.0087004062,
-0.0051345299,
0.0091879489,
0.0142288124,
0.006453204,
-0.0373832919,
0.0020291586,
-0.0251987223,
0.0242036283,
-0.0556035489,
-0.0187728424,
0.0117720868,
0.0162269622,
-0.0320096426,
-0.0160004441,
0.0826197788,
0.0000231009,
0.0000989951,
-0.0334834158,
-0.0308896601,
-0.038127128,
0.0137063274,
0.0260085445,
0.0154471295,
-0.0403398126,
-0.00177063,
-0.0776614025,
-0.0612687357,
-0.006267936,
-0.0198508222,
0.0120433616,
-0.0314804316,
0.0276693758,
0.0385390073,
-0.0414105728,
0.0097449608,
-0.0458415784,
-0.0095132096,
-0.0049412968,
-0.0322072245,
-0.0013512465,
-6.693161243e-33,
-0.0064718286,
-0.0744694993,
0.0370314345,
0.0049066735,
-0.0191139746,
-0.0024984258,
-0.0392678268,
0.0318429992,
0.0248453207,
0.0030590231,
-0.0056450358,
-0.0051223054,
0.000609836,
0.0083342213,
0.092701517,
0.0108499266,
0.0693453923,
-0.0095282923,
-0.0051177866,
0.0305435434,
-0.0029081416,
0.0098205414,
0.0027209823,
-0.1010209024,
0.0608042032,
-0.0326423533,
-0.012721166,
0.0108451312,
0.0458730571,
0.0108456025,
-0.0288905688,
0.0175620336,
0.0175871011,
-0.0378928147,
-0.0041790223,
0.0451434627,
-0.0680904984,
-0.0125067728,
0.0022678068,
0.0111550288,
-0.0034578892,
-0.0453245938,
0.0379337594,
-0.0132026281,
-0.0465643629,
0.0007146552,
0.0394050702,
-0.0263383053,
-0.0092661111,
-0.0616011247,
-0.0286226496,
0.0221131481,
-0.0497061014,
-0.0207254607,
0.0248160344,
0.0167753994,
-0.0432977267,
0.0266059358,
-0.0671258643,
0.0561056212,
-0.007560743,
-0.0306736417,
0.0566358343,
0.0130530437,
-0.0051228767,
0.0485291146,
-0.0046226196,
-0.0101448316,
-0.0463929921,
0.0080207307,
0.0031121941,
0.0409153402,
0.0224869642,
0.0746744946,
0.0029741547,
-0.0020434398,
-0.0185528584,
0.0356952921,
-0.0264519174,
-0.0019636278,
0.0227753855,
0.0425708443,
-0.051401291,
-0.0452386737,
-0.0275864806,
-0.0131170489,
-0.0221053958,
-0.0273101516,
0.0186247583,
-0.0219767205,
-0.0417156368,
0.0127926795,
0.0186502058,
-0.0476510748,
-0.0089401184,
-0.0038432325,
-0.0187713262,
0.0312886201,
0.0061202957,
-0.007907073,
-0.09256161,
0.0309974272,
-0.0048437603,
0.0498272963,
0.0678280592,
0.0000790877,
0.0240179393,
0.0372230299,
-0.0686733723,
-0.0114144096,
-0.0018261371,
0.0180347525,
0.0209010448,
-0.0321968421,
0.0495651849,
-0.0010527164,
-0.0032132023,
0.0607193559,
0.0093883835,
0.0217077937,
-0.0138030779,
-0.0141895302,
-0.0382991061,
-0.0274718385,
0.0013522564,
-0.0152344033,
-0.0191817693,
0.0076712114,
0.0777323395,
-0.0010319784,
-0.0339987017,
-0.0195383746,
2.962e-7,
0.02168555,
0.0474545509,
-0.0247088522,
-0.0360415056,
0.0293514486,
0.0434081443,
-0.015408827,
0.0130564161,
0.0310226325,
-0.0001052496,
0.0423092581,
0.0242700297,
0.070805721,
0.0714125633,
-0.0987371504,
0.013321802,
-0.0839923844,
0.0304338466,
-0.0808814168,
0.0247288905,
0.0238965098,
0.0345399715,
0.012976489,
-0.0160169341,
-0.0074148634,
-0.0448058173,
0.043747481,
-0.0488124639,
-0.0069108992,
-0.0128554869,
-0.0269647948,
0.0193334818,
-0.0066267718,
-0.0114666708,
-0.0146105858,
-0.0130000794,
0.0204023086,
0.0440993197,
0.0294974577,
-0.003285513,
0.0024215952,
0.0012132933,
0.0056349691,
-0.0538521037,
0.0487707108,
-0.0512279682,
-0.0768841058,
-0.0218417998,
-0.0011176077,
-0.04669578,
0.0145223569,
-0.0235471837,
0.0125608556,
-0.0153493909,
0.0101823928,
-0.0122407191,
-0.0268648621,
-0.0323631093,
0.0184730273,
-0.015989745,
-0.0380782411,
-0.070115231,
-0.0181532856,
0.0311751273,
-0.0327446051,
-0.039354559,
0.0713894665,
2.241954943e-34,
0.0290030465,
0.0053078616,
-0.0086241281,
0.0430967957,
0.0451757275,
0.0189280491,
-0.0298130661,
0.0127739543,
0.042705752,
-0.0368538573,
-0.0030666913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15080v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15080v3 | Federated Learning of Large Language Models with Parameter-Efficient Prompt Tuning and Adaptive Optimization | 2023-10-23T16:37:59 | 2024-02-11T11:59:52 | Tianshi Che, Ji Liu, Yang Zhou, Jiaxiang Ren, Jiwen Zhou, Victor S. Sheng, Huaiyu Dai, Dejing Dou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Federated learning (FL) is a promising paradigm to enable collaborative model
training with decentralized data. However, the training process of Large
Language Models (LLMs) generally incurs the update of significant parameters,
which limits the applicability of FL techniques to tackle the LLMs in real
scenarios. Prompt tuning can significantly reduce the number of parameters to
update, but it either incurs performance degradation or low training
efficiency. The straightforward utilization of prompt tuning in the FL often
raises non-trivial communication costs and dramatically degrades performance.
In addition, the decentralized data is generally non-Independent and
Identically Distributed (non-IID), which brings client drift problems and thus
poor performance. This paper proposes a Parameter-efficient prompt Tuning
approach with Adaptive Optimization, i.e., FedPepTAO, to enable efficient and
effective FL of LLMs. First, an efficient partial prompt tuning approach is
proposed to improve performance and efficiency simultaneously. Second, a novel
adaptive optimization method is developed to address the client drift problems
on both the device and server sides to enhance performance further. Extensive
experiments based on 10 datasets demonstrate the superb performance (up to
60.8\% in terms of accuracy) and efficiency (up to 97.59\% in terms of training
time) of FedPepTAO compared with 9 baseline approaches. Our code is available
at https://github.com/llm-eff/FedPepTAO. | [
0.0160903409,
0.0638887882,
-0.0067706006,
0.0124120042,
-0.0334452726,
0.0047151283,
0.0781210139,
-0.0076301298,
0.0102390451,
-0.039942354,
-0.0737186074,
-0.0548095703,
0.0431731381,
-0.0062154406,
-0.0258408394,
-0.0287435595,
0.033412002,
-0.018296849,
-0.0228818264,
-0.0606728159,
-0.0185799561,
0.0047926665,
-0.0044584465,
0.0164224897,
0.0169642512,
-0.0502711795,
-0.021302212,
0.0147045469,
-0.0105583528,
-0.0066295471,
0.0479146652,
0.0689347461,
0.017965721,
0.0750095844,
0.0000021204,
-0.0227850154,
-0.0499760397,
0.003535463,
-0.0128253633,
0.0728080645,
0.0391053595,
0.0186832957,
-0.0279127993,
0.0568226539,
-0.0231163315,
-0.0137797389,
0.043087814,
-0.0190598853,
0.0448226519,
0.0780329108,
-0.0009442251,
-0.0116761168,
-0.0255427863,
-0.0248659849,
-0.1313192844,
-0.0181910861,
0.0177237857,
-0.0302288197,
-0.0179249328,
-0.0012986902,
-0.0213783756,
0.0169983152,
0.011566747,
0.0303877443,
-0.0050712246,
-0.0074257157,
-0.0400999263,
-0.0327516422,
-0.0667528212,
0.0640874133,
0.0046854848,
-0.0062717451,
0.021104753,
-0.0373931862,
-0.0409121923,
0.0399571806,
-0.0077485382,
-0.0165749192,
-0.0111626061,
0.0240080059,
-0.0265126899,
-0.0417647585,
0.0259919725,
0.0080604479,
-0.0014543078,
0.1009912193,
-0.0055586863,
0.004267639,
-0.0346439183,
-0.0308458097,
-0.0244645774,
-0.0354448147,
0.0394931883,
0.0455610007,
-0.0438727327,
0.0011960765,
-0.0354027003,
-0.0740080848,
0.0078507243,
-0.0229562558,
0.0586337484,
-0.0072510783,
0.0214558057,
0.031210335,
-0.0138926301,
-0.0080900863,
-0.0019049654,
0.00254539,
-0.0245473012,
0.0437134542,
-0.0711402297,
0.0090975305,
-0.0306238867,
0.0263211615,
-0.0221299846,
-0.0134091536,
0.0103043746,
0.033472769,
0.0186576284,
0.0034762935,
0.0301717594,
-0.0193035696,
-0.0265346933,
-0.014142869,
0.0159470644,
0.0620282218,
-0.0337040052,
0.0167476404,
-0.0027797467,
-0.0669601709,
0.0095727723,
-0.00837027,
0.0018258875,
0.0241656378,
-0.0068558007,
0.0141617088,
0.0077995146,
-0.0021317375,
-0.0145636313,
-0.0249638725,
0.0399830192,
-0.041118104,
-0.0158559848,
-0.0457725003,
0.0199400298,
0.0090187173,
0.0173311457,
-0.0473005399,
-0.0148401223,
-0.0119498847,
-0.0217884891,
0.0609459989,
-0.0736983716,
0.0236399285,
0.0413949937,
-0.0134405652,
-0.0422393568,
0.1339142919,
0.0362152122,
0.0001701571,
0.0672537163,
-0.0060369927,
-0.0587505102,
0.0488612205,
0.0443868861,
0.0544670448,
-0.0035990328,
-0.0178514179,
0.0211528968,
0.0503306948,
-0.0231273714,
0.024804173,
0.0075995931,
0.0042847241,
0.0657328442,
0.0479733273,
0.0491149016,
0.0013682361,
-0.0266611073,
0.0485676564,
0.0067485766,
0.0133004412,
-0.0487559885,
-0.027084237,
0.0003893932,
-0.0129380152,
0.0176684707,
0.076182805,
-0.0410412624,
-0.0298936162,
-0.0172500536,
-0.0331839807,
-0.0590928718,
0.0259220246,
0.0186338499,
-0.0147838686,
-0.031917844,
0.058532998,
0.0476733446,
-0.0332711078,
-0.0183021277,
-0.0040868721,
0.0115771843,
0.0420876257,
0.0427305102,
-0.0198374353,
-0.0397277251,
-0.022774253,
0.0464166515,
0.0019968671,
0.0315097198,
-0.0138215395,
0.0270790122,
-0.0486240983,
-0.0627761856,
0.083786346,
-0.0133005036,
0.0168301817,
-0.0293124914,
0.0086363517,
-0.0260325149,
0.0228171721,
-0.0310841575,
0.0172500815,
0.0019632292,
-0.0006125472,
0.0230797008,
0.0365242399,
0.0354310609,
-0.0041944082,
-0.0055033835,
-0.0249830075,
0.0123875877,
-0.0090639694,
-0.0214832854,
-0.0081507061,
-0.0174202528,
-0.0153142978,
0.0295992754,
0.0559267625,
0.0237306971,
0.0305247549,
-0.0616027825,
-0.0401318148,
-0.009940681,
0.0045234929,
0.0406299084,
-0.0018718978,
0.0318188816,
-0.025836762,
0.046508234,
-0.0047185924,
0.0240782965,
-0.0186849702,
-0.0043244432,
0.0009638893,
0.0232909694,
0.0376706049,
-0.0313283131,
0.046921581,
0.0341111124,
0.0221022684,
0.0145455925,
0.0029419896,
0.0127981976,
-0.0036780369,
0.0093106134,
-0.0297247749,
0.0234399531,
-0.0690893009,
0.0330404863,
0.0235135034,
0.0268380549,
-0.0305843577,
-0.0639444739,
0.0000201649,
0.0550581999,
-0.0438714437,
0.0298543479,
-0.0245259069,
0.0098979324,
-0.0584307425,
0.0041965898,
-0.014900825,
0.0134109044,
0.0270242188,
0.0107883224,
-0.0319409333,
-0.0997194573,
-0.0161519125,
-0.0617812239,
0.032961119,
0.015775485,
-0.0061169141,
-0.0076298011,
0.027358193,
0.0110239116,
0.0329262018,
0.0012647841,
-0.0210039709,
0.0388158299,
0.0309499744,
-0.065681912,
-0.001269882,
-0.0275153406,
-0.0373869874,
-0.028086029,
0.0136505999,
0.0332532674,
0.0593513884,
-0.0274599679,
-0.0211480465,
-0.0422921367,
0.0249576382,
-0.0184865817,
-0.0201871395,
-0.083392784,
0.031502258,
-0.019712083,
0.0259746853,
0.0273459498,
-0.0751098096,
0.0577618033,
-0.0299936906,
0.0184192155,
-0.0679331422,
-0.0361941978,
-0.0434229076,
0.019586537,
-0.0107991835,
0.0280807167,
0.0079917377,
-0.0553441308,
-0.0200694259,
0.0212315712,
0.0411076248,
-0.0171567276,
-0.0291915182,
-0.0071050772,
0.0121750133,
-0.0321056992,
-0.0621833801,
0.0162706003,
-0.0704392046,
-0.0451460965,
0.0049055419,
-0.0166785698,
-0.0180030856,
0.0031863181,
0.0356046595,
-0.0271274485,
0.0452993475,
-0.0344105847,
0.022791123,
-0.0332657807,
0.0067219827,
0.0254273117,
-0.0163751673,
-0.018615583,
-0.0249471217,
0.0206547063,
0.0372864418,
0.0957448334,
-0.0317604616,
-0.0039319997,
-0.0150341773,
0.0348559134,
-0.0501638465,
-0.0294989906,
0.00965825,
0.0463835374,
-0.0215322841,
0.0130377552,
0.0988970324,
0.0109576425,
-0.0911474228,
-0.0063095866,
-0.038890224,
0.0771566406,
-0.0001600515,
0.0101930723,
-0.0440234132,
-0.0344400071,
0.0337285586,
0.068320252,
0.0282509252,
-0.0167910662,
-0.0507242717,
-0.0863583386,
0.0064686108,
0.0193950813,
-0.0286763888,
-0.0173003003,
-0.0658022389,
0.0072405301,
0.0184601229,
0.0500055701,
0.030359054,
0.012710535,
-0.0018157297,
0.0431559347,
-0.0471561253,
-0.061099112,
-0.0233331397,
-0.041649878,
0.0752276778,
0.0217346121,
-0.0030774074,
0.0208556,
-0.0510042831,
0.0062800325,
0.0258410517,
-0.0308067035,
-0.0517136902,
-0.0196010396,
-0.0294621754,
-0.0029350042,
0.0198698323,
0.0295857266,
0.0088582123,
0.0169373658,
0.0295169149,
0.075270921,
0.0002358539,
0.0268977657,
0.0183260702,
0.0004191735,
0.0612558499,
0.0195511915,
0.0138880368,
-0.0373889431,
-0.0217945911,
0.025897311,
-0.0173401721,
0.0146993529,
0.0361974612,
0.0276153926,
-0.0317101404,
-0.0021456075,
-0.0536602214,
0.0196395703,
0.0166282635,
0.02813573,
0.0297244787,
0.0714061484,
0.0271707345,
0.0163656734,
-0.0190646145,
0.0192090441,
-0.0269694179,
0.0245070476,
-0.0874936059,
-0.0294007491,
0.0263762251,
-0.004129854,
-0.0002349225,
0.031551525,
-0.0850351155,
-0.0853191987,
0.0195615254,
-0.006387658,
0.0136341937,
0.0566146597,
-0.0257100631,
-0.0967663303,
0.040944837,
0.0177243371,
-0.0376650691,
0.0236148257,
0.033059746,
-0.0206994638,
0.0007016111,
0.0522891805,
-0.0580806807,
0.0024708516,
0.0291184876,
0.0128235715,
0.0134983342,
-0.0729813799,
-0.0220983066,
0.0476207621,
0.0623407587,
-0.0319804363,
-0.0263771694,
-0.0206326507,
0.0684798434,
0.0275112763,
0.0200125687,
-0.0250729378,
0.03476597,
-0.0249871276,
-0.0381278507,
0.0060266121,
-0.0100492593,
0.0478960052,
-0.0200007185,
-0.0053055575,
0.0221088715,
-0.0067995382,
-0.0283653662,
0.0667659119,
0.0100710252,
0.0127181886,
0.026695678,
0.0351561159,
0.0303574745,
-0.0445473492,
0.0513453819,
0.0054210396,
0.0238981862,
-0.0571174994,
0.0342835672,
-0.0519132689,
-0.1107729003,
-0.0017970502,
0.0470771901,
0.0466337316,
0.0506194532,
0.0103232926,
-0.0332706794,
-0.0038244652,
-0.0385502316,
0.0236956589,
-0.0401225947,
-0.0289667696,
0.0523836017,
-0.0041866903,
-0.0170996245,
0.095928818,
0.08387281,
-0.0002935196,
0.0295386352,
-0.0369736701,
0.022156734,
-0.055461891,
0.0189122297,
0.0245322026,
0.0231191274,
-0.0701918527,
0.0016255028,
0.0068919561,
-0.0359325781,
0.011449256,
-0.0094975587,
-0.0058517917,
-0.0309808291,
0.0353278667,
0.0302048586,
-0.0147957504,
0.017745357,
-0.0680002719,
0.0126399724,
0.0006478942,
0.0096945567,
0.0202863328,
-6.612958733e-33,
-0.02111689,
0.0183344409,
-0.0055296947,
0.0243627951,
-0.0296337754,
-0.0035171197,
0.0103281923,
-0.0137208328,
0.0225318111,
-0.0154413451,
-0.0615734123,
0.0175221637,
0.0435900986,
0.0158398356,
-0.0151381595,
-0.0212538838,
0.048879467,
-0.0582865328,
-0.0581525378,
0.0197049025,
0.0621326268,
0.0674815252,
0.0260029193,
0.0031941789,
-0.0047089071,
-0.025656987,
0.0091211013,
0.0321950018,
-0.0214233045,
0.0072921668,
-0.0025674989,
0.0244703256,
-0.0109325564,
-0.0349626914,
-0.0368085317,
0.0059895408,
-0.0448720492,
0.018300999,
-0.0241220277,
0.0599179082,
-0.0347566046,
0.0054023485,
0.0320615098,
-0.0000393528,
-0.0363153368,
0.002778461,
0.0167966336,
0.0023584077,
-0.082275413,
0.0056766281,
0.0104227122,
0.0158292204,
0.0306881294,
-0.0027848936,
0.0200986583,
0.0363358594,
-0.0143592646,
-0.0234590378,
-0.0624945648,
0.005052533,
0.0209167507,
0.0343839005,
0.0338077322,
0.0480487235,
0.0091505414,
0.0223527569,
0.0621077567,
-0.009413694,
-0.0012086402,
0.0112025505,
0.0226680934,
0.0141588347,
-0.0012233972,
0.0150256436,
-0.0281900801,
-0.0498550497,
-0.0355973579,
-0.0147073474,
0.0853637978,
-0.0274490844,
0.0053865691,
0.0102362679,
-0.0208364632,
-0.0319116898,
-0.0335389711,
-0.0167139601,
-0.0015990373,
-0.0245449953,
0.0130158942,
0.0075931158,
-0.0250667334,
-0.0568836108,
0.0459371544,
-0.0322422013,
-0.0195815675,
-0.0079595828,
0.0552864447,
0.0177550521,
0.0116273975,
0.0352219529,
-0.0727516338,
-0.0244658515,
-0.0462165438,
-0.0135583617,
0.0143519789,
-0.0143310698,
0.0403319933,
0.0489330031,
-0.0454751626,
0.010817905,
-0.0096360892,
0.0132576395,
-0.0065140664,
0.0303431079,
0.0668940991,
-0.0418057442,
0.0125261461,
0.0457634889,
0.0044025742,
-0.0197889023,
0.0003727968,
-0.0319471657,
0.0013726394,
0.0215797201,
-0.0186760835,
0.0101544829,
-0.0518693775,
0.0227676593,
0.0369220152,
-0.0166952647,
-0.0102257039,
-0.0413502976,
2.879e-7,
-0.0096919676,
0.0376287773,
-0.0234419424,
-0.0425424762,
0.0366500691,
0.0131224245,
-0.056509871,
0.0383408852,
0.0092946384,
0.0226951204,
0.0102368714,
-0.0082185306,
0.0586735494,
-0.0140712522,
-0.0877748802,
-0.0209652372,
-0.0921606198,
0.0947773531,
-0.0348463804,
-0.0411869101,
-0.0526058413,
0.0606479533,
0.0251702331,
-0.0256868564,
0.0093835928,
0.0163068697,
0.0273697712,
-0.0230057649,
-0.0446702279,
0.0049151517,
0.0378523208,
0.0366048813,
-0.0188535731,
-0.0193717871,
-0.0195479896,
0.0426596217,
-0.0381538756,
0.0492172763,
0.0320628174,
0.037936192,
0.0100212554,
-0.0159804933,
-0.0367389843,
0.0049960357,
0.0716642141,
-0.0070348955,
-0.0190023687,
-0.0212677512,
0.0502051041,
-0.0496996455,
0.0445151068,
-0.0181031823,
-0.0190758817,
0.0229744054,
0.0107795186,
-0.025708938,
-0.0288146827,
-0.0748320669,
0.012456622,
-0.0265011285,
-0.0354735069,
-0.0605507828,
-0.0442616716,
0.0226817429,
0.0182361715,
-0.0405817851,
0.0137418425,
2.54422482e-34,
0.0345162079,
-0.0453608111,
0.0009507012,
0.0399747938,
-0.0188753493,
-0.0677340403,
0.044783581,
0.0270581637,
0.0225294083,
-0.0391425602,
0.0102546588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15079v1 | Affective and Dynamic Beam Search for Story Generation | 2023-10-23T16:37:14 | 2023-10-23T16:37:14 | Tenghao Huang, Ehsan Qasemi, Bangzheng Li, He Wang, Faeze Brahman, Muhao Chen, Snigdha Chaturvedi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Storytelling's captivating potential makes it a fascinating research area,
with implications for entertainment, education, therapy, and cognitive studies.
In this paper, we propose Affective Story Generator (AffGen) for generating
interesting narratives. AffGen introduces "intriguing twists" in narratives by
employing two novel techniques-Dynamic Beam Sizing and Affective Reranking.
Dynamic Beam Sizing encourages less predictable, more captivating word choices
using a contextual multi-arm bandit model. Affective Reranking prioritizes
sentence candidates based on affect intensity. Our empirical evaluations, both
automatic and human, demonstrate AffGen's superior performance over existing
baselines in generating affectively charged and interesting narratives. Our
ablation study and analysis provide insights into the strengths and weaknesses
of AffGen. | [
0.045730181,
0.0052280617,
-0.0290615838,
-0.0013162763,
-0.0272595268,
-0.010525303,
-0.0145343933,
-0.004117392,
0.0031812768,
0.0071918452,
0.0050952295,
0.001012024,
-0.0166104734,
0.0964543074,
-0.0177839473,
-0.0849578008,
-0.0049701044,
0.0151456119,
0.0624339059,
0.0169472564,
-0.0235363338,
0.0157963187,
-0.0114507945,
0.0184977334,
0.0234546699,
0.0433098152,
-0.0030200731,
0.013183767,
0.0569163486,
-0.0893346146,
-0.0138662038,
-0.0119377561,
0.0242164247,
-0.0055765305,
0.0000018974,
-0.056659244,
-0.0231809914,
-0.0355459005,
0.0229799543,
-0.015255197,
0.0821860731,
0.0512011722,
0.0118244812,
0.0010618565,
-0.0274913628,
0.0092515275,
0.0448972061,
0.0548758283,
0.0152549697,
0.0663346797,
-0.0054903934,
-0.0166667495,
0.005144875,
-0.0235079341,
0.0785244107,
-0.0171741471,
-0.0061758542,
-0.0256193038,
0.0493627004,
-0.0303497855,
-0.0410410278,
-0.0151073113,
0.0151483295,
0.0143721094,
0.0484421551,
0.0703738555,
-0.0298633035,
0.012767951,
-0.0076594418,
0.0420530625,
-0.0220944043,
0.0168744251,
0.024548972,
-0.0436583757,
0.0253035463,
-0.0180295706,
-0.0467310958,
0.0427773446,
-0.0068500973,
0.013338929,
0.0186557397,
0.0671024844,
0.0116666285,
-0.005644415,
0.0675199851,
0.0114392564,
0.0203893073,
-0.0143232755,
-0.0214403886,
-0.0101779271,
-0.0222529843,
-0.0629412308,
0.0476309396,
0.0054746671,
-0.009571841,
0.0238268804,
-0.0273687579,
0.0215694401,
-0.0134804761,
-0.0286140107,
0.0109632509,
0.0098823924,
0.0105308434,
0.0049928287,
0.0102711525,
0.0313756168,
0.0433728769,
-0.0526906326,
-0.0594755001,
0.0624698661,
-0.0168332197,
0.0197091717,
-0.0136526981,
0.0385247171,
-0.057657823,
-0.0612564906,
-0.0663959309,
-0.0104445592,
0.0206178688,
-0.0201693177,
-0.0479248427,
0.0556019619,
-0.0332595073,
0.0196722616,
-0.0295904186,
0.0040061679,
-0.0526222289,
-0.0179250222,
0.0373637863,
0.0261670258,
-0.0201340411,
0.0161613449,
0.0113472687,
-0.0575998463,
0.0294601806,
0.0317846201,
-0.0094104093,
-0.0544081889,
-0.0352825671,
-0.0344109423,
-0.0225956421,
-0.0044635641,
-0.0069225733,
-0.0406572074,
0.0301679596,
-0.0134863593,
0.0087561645,
-0.0012293966,
0.0346480608,
0.0136860302,
-0.0172091257,
-0.0049382481,
0.0203225389,
-0.02422552,
0.0171717256,
0.0102025149,
0.0015224998,
-0.0156917125,
0.0738873333,
0.1228606254,
0.0544515513,
0.0422667786,
0.0694517195,
-0.032593634,
-0.0323051251,
-0.0087268855,
0.0549895465,
-0.032839559,
-0.0130809685,
0.0974255577,
0.0170483794,
-0.00076681,
-0.0628622472,
0.0255364142,
0.0635563582,
0.0167869832,
0.0234463271,
0.0248297565,
0.0551385991,
-0.004114463,
-0.0450395793,
0.0635259971,
0.0058346638,
0.0546245649,
-0.0192530956,
-0.007325836,
0.0071704378,
0.0416413248,
0.0072691054,
-0.0250935778,
0.0211878289,
0.019805586,
0.0178803094,
-0.0046642432,
-0.0237163696,
0.0162530821,
-0.0650553852,
-0.0281504951,
0.0398895219,
-0.0738816112,
0.0263026766,
-0.0116775418,
0.0053888154,
0.0796721876,
0.0853673816,
-0.0268242378,
-0.0173501968,
-0.0080537619,
-0.0137746548,
0.0280558765,
0.0130438218,
-0.0099032633,
0.0263033658,
-0.0456601121,
0.019480437,
-0.0476395302,
-0.0069024116,
0.0241648071,
-0.0222073104,
0.0220160019,
-0.0203636605,
-0.0173688233,
-0.0434910245,
0.0362043977,
-0.0674993545,
-0.0443961211,
0.0278749075,
-0.0220404174,
-0.043871142,
-0.0205454938,
-0.0235042293,
0.0069080233,
0.0258208029,
0.0059688496,
-0.0282519832,
0.0511000343,
-0.0500797816,
-0.0412113518,
-0.032229647,
-0.0805775151,
0.0419654213,
-0.0560046844,
0.0128162894,
-0.0152501231,
0.0570589602,
-0.0530953035,
-0.0098492829,
-0.0185935237,
0.0220989641,
0.0096708396,
0.0201973487,
-0.0466561578,
0.0788105056,
-0.0029626875,
0.0321322381,
-0.036876224,
-0.027803855,
-0.0106673455,
-0.0607560091,
0.007022108,
0.0130713508,
0.0239528436,
-0.0262229983,
0.0343992151,
-0.0121523142,
-0.0270513948,
-0.0726018623,
-0.0577681735,
-0.0010889292,
0.0488996804,
-0.0328054838,
0.0114481319,
0.0124808373,
-0.0349174701,
0.0167389642,
-0.0381701775,
-0.0460568517,
0.0121922046,
-0.0235499348,
0.0143737271,
0.0391223691,
-0.0038166444,
-0.0424875543,
0.0033724119,
-0.0162798874,
0.0455805212,
0.058585085,
0.0236444958,
-0.0442781672,
0.0144085372,
-0.0303172525,
-0.0250250585,
-0.0273821838,
-0.0157209374,
-0.0015591116,
0.0302908197,
0.0477630533,
0.0777835175,
0.033708889,
0.0627180412,
0.0581436716,
-0.0411129445,
-0.0099316826,
0.0124993343,
-0.0123643456,
0.0486250594,
-0.0087697348,
-0.0797071233,
0.0239226539,
0.0469876155,
0.050496202,
0.0262480006,
-0.0300189015,
0.0133517655,
0.0257727057,
-0.0501713827,
-0.0026549459,
-0.0372253098,
-0.0332918949,
0.0386537723,
-0.0030041079,
-0.0145166786,
0.1083451957,
0.0209480915,
0.0165607668,
-0.0522859953,
0.0219883341,
-0.0353429131,
0.0326688364,
-0.016255537,
0.0389464684,
0.0171277858,
0.0041103619,
-0.0481121913,
-0.03646354,
0.0377169028,
-0.0246995687,
-0.0159084164,
-0.0203212239,
-0.0604361892,
0.0410245024,
-0.0334739685,
-0.0318553671,
-0.0703417137,
0.020359315,
-0.0236288421,
0.0585963391,
-0.0157386661,
-0.0717618912,
-0.0255711712,
0.0577914454,
-0.0109032197,
-0.0062947064,
-0.04364077,
0.0128601072,
0.0718289688,
0.0628242344,
-0.0308866128,
0.0564009994,
-0.0380144194,
0.0092353029,
0.0065294858,
0.0228668377,
-0.004412102,
0.0364931002,
0.0313043185,
-0.0072725709,
-0.0439584479,
-0.0301765483,
0.0056570517,
0.0119623588,
-0.0233404972,
-0.0186779946,
0.0659683123,
0.049593363,
0.0046636509,
0.0492689312,
-0.0005029662,
0.0329522081,
0.0007502834,
0.0503255911,
-0.0426614434,
-0.0020484629,
0.0096976319,
0.041134648,
-0.0466657802,
-0.060392715,
-0.0394555442,
-0.0866781399,
0.0509204455,
0.0195252299,
0.0424190275,
-0.0009200937,
0.0085751032,
-0.0201293491,
0.0089202821,
-0.0580802634,
0.0284232367,
-0.0223665107,
0.051080592,
-0.032184232,
0.0036077891,
0.0027968802,
0.0256201029,
-0.0301023237,
0.0301947258,
0.055003088,
0.0775472298,
0.0139977979,
-0.0116791362,
-0.0977553353,
0.0351774991,
0.0147118252,
0.0059401407,
0.0439428911,
-0.0176447071,
0.0102634653,
-0.0556451418,
0.0514553376,
0.0380966961,
-0.0622736551,
0.0079993298,
0.0399335362,
-0.0210286845,
-0.0363135263,
-0.0102691362,
0.031265717,
0.0320424512,
0.0645956248,
0.0140031343,
-0.0512646176,
-0.0016883153,
-0.0205755588,
0.0332058258,
-0.0755807832,
-0.0333921164,
-0.0305626076,
-0.0107466783,
0.0364120156,
-0.1065308526,
-0.0334810875,
-0.009498002,
0.0625257865,
-0.0185358115,
-0.0013876359,
-0.0661798418,
0.0098861232,
-0.0188428257,
-0.0099784471,
0.0131221227,
-0.0031504554,
0.0238050446,
0.0025249252,
0.006194626,
-0.096144259,
-0.0243202876,
0.061734885,
-0.0362636149,
-0.0247198995,
0.0266408976,
0.011461514,
0.0190177821,
-0.0104407156,
0.0338812955,
-0.043733336,
0.0162925068,
0.0078060585,
-0.0103491079,
0.0548230037,
-0.0250091832,
0.051820837,
0.0024418917,
-0.025461195,
-0.0154073136,
-0.0113021396,
0.0184759796,
0.0521099642,
0.0123959742,
0.0037084364,
-0.0120305046,
0.0234141219,
-0.0241101533,
-0.0970332623,
-0.0435881168,
-0.0568583794,
-0.0296831205,
-0.0140937697,
-0.0026120371,
-0.0279609356,
0.0090236226,
0.0003750294,
0.0239306353,
-0.0391380452,
-0.0028353869,
-0.061592292,
-0.0257734638,
-0.0893756151,
-0.0006983039,
0.0407376401,
-0.057692606,
0.0135559905,
0.0295646582,
0.0128539605,
0.0384606048,
-0.0239856448,
0.0790035203,
-0.021258371,
0.0137334066,
0.0147056263,
-0.0350567177,
0.0004307071,
0.0331451632,
-0.062283691,
0.0414921008,
-0.0383506641,
0.0275274459,
0.0271853283,
-0.0062300535,
0.0197496936,
-0.0146921566,
0.033762753,
0.01122972,
-0.0388052203,
-0.033896476,
-0.0603541471,
-0.0486456305,
0.031604819,
-0.0046831435,
0.0301985461,
0.0676499158,
-0.0541569106,
0.0443895422,
0.0163387116,
-0.0117200455,
-0.0272041988,
-0.0043650493,
0.052148398,
0.064727217,
0.0195387173,
-0.0124253361,
-0.0723808184,
0.0248642396,
0.0737353191,
-0.007439191,
0.0216280837,
-0.0615165941,
0.0388723537,
0.0250518937,
-0.0115849152,
0.0110325189,
-0.0520602986,
0.0032530834,
-0.0327011272,
-0.0227019452,
-0.0355629995,
-5.626951133e-33,
-0.0099452361,
-0.0157414339,
-0.0010590557,
0.0263372082,
-0.0719204843,
-0.0110143824,
-0.0295115579,
0.0159204192,
0.035200987,
0.0292145107,
-0.0044371509,
0.0058551403,
0.0002449626,
0.0007976887,
-0.0206180885,
0.0070715118,
0.0109717939,
0.0262069888,
-0.0673397556,
0.0293786786,
0.0253410526,
0.0371128954,
0.0134438481,
-0.0482367873,
-0.0062560411,
-0.0026450483,
-0.0390290208,
-0.0251060687,
0.0497785732,
0.0286506489,
-0.0104621872,
0.0321737714,
-0.0042483024,
-0.0431136861,
-0.0134306233,
-0.0499259718,
0.0150711238,
-0.0353315361,
0.0045334836,
-0.0538162515,
-0.0080340561,
-0.0419953316,
0.012289335,
-0.0106937615,
-0.0473825224,
-0.0028658595,
0.0292381588,
-0.0074564484,
-0.0098747136,
-0.0374757573,
-0.0338001288,
0.0051077604,
-0.0109439613,
-0.0435248539,
-0.0354997888,
0.0103725009,
0.0307672303,
0.0136397658,
-0.0053417855,
0.0700410083,
0.0237972476,
0.0336264744,
-0.0264713708,
-0.0185543709,
-0.0186783522,
0.0760476589,
0.0506821051,
-0.0078643914,
-0.0007042904,
0.0693345964,
-0.0165935252,
0.0239691772,
0.0600502789,
0.0596772656,
0.0235667191,
0.0021366181,
-0.0181797966,
0.0682485923,
0.0366279148,
-0.0097661167,
0.0626052022,
0.0293177869,
-0.0039098342,
-0.0266663618,
-0.0200114679,
-0.0292514283,
-0.0133446855,
-0.0440913439,
0.0051290807,
0.0237013977,
0.0026636771,
-0.0063575413,
-0.0143117122,
-0.0118029714,
0.0394284427,
0.0212366134,
-0.0591441579,
0.0468235463,
-0.0050282502,
-0.0044522476,
0.0121655473,
0.0261551496,
0.0750381052,
0.0329183899,
0.0376973487,
-0.0143653061,
-0.0399535894,
0.0337854326,
-0.0222612787,
0.0171442609,
0.0017389078,
0.0274803713,
0.0008852612,
-0.0383928195,
-0.0216921419,
-0.0119130407,
-0.0223146453,
-0.0476921573,
0.0374202952,
0.027032055,
-0.039720837,
-0.0589411594,
-0.025137404,
0.0524616502,
-0.0187320597,
0.0443036519,
-0.0020091701,
-0.0377287865,
-0.0230786446,
-0.0404949971,
-0.0338399112,
0.0028148114,
2.731e-7,
-0.0444499217,
0.0411911123,
0.0042362497,
0.0047679492,
0.0054430026,
0.0351939388,
0.0060691987,
0.018254159,
0.0276628546,
-0.0371733196,
0.0202985201,
0.0093720919,
0.0110084293,
0.0246875938,
-0.0579782538,
0.051303152,
-0.0594693087,
0.026199054,
-0.0221588016,
-0.0523617305,
0.0734545663,
-0.0038248745,
0.0314483866,
-0.009667106,
0.0266456287,
-0.0187718198,
0.0293678697,
0.004357575,
-0.0353453234,
0.026322322,
-0.0435714275,
-0.0104229227,
-0.0444304682,
-0.0529391617,
-0.0291737523,
0.004048977,
0.0250221826,
0.0039925366,
-0.0219817199,
-0.0563399978,
0.0251062457,
0.0268845297,
-0.0283899177,
-0.0129762385,
0.0234697405,
-0.0250925142,
-0.0067290468,
0.0068857502,
-0.0019752723,
0.0077955872,
0.018029036,
-0.0580842644,
-0.0277357865,
0.0296567604,
0.0123159662,
0.0521247499,
-0.011324835,
-0.0464211814,
-0.027218258,
0.0224195924,
-0.028266523,
-0.008071458,
-0.0426244661,
0.0211950932,
-0.0345818549,
-0.0815547034,
0.0033996599,
2.615166134e-34,
0.0227753092,
0.0219214484,
-0.0283426866,
-0.0255957562,
0.0513795242,
0.040058326,
-0.0389935076,
-0.0106425444,
0.0557712391,
-0.0492365398,
-0.0419477038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15077v1 | 'Don't Get Too Technical with Me': A Discourse Structure-Based Framework for Science Journalism | 2023-10-23T16:35:05 | 2023-10-23T16:35:05 | Ronald Cardenas, Bingsheng Yao, Dakuo Wang, Yufang Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Science journalism refers to the task of reporting technical findings of a
scientific paper as a less technical news article to the general public
audience. We aim to design an automated system to support this real-world task
(i.e., automatic science journalism) by 1) introducing a newly-constructed and
real-world dataset (SciTechNews), with tuples of a publicly-available
scientific paper, its corresponding news article, and an expert-written short
summary snippet; 2) proposing a novel technical framework that integrates a
paper's discourse structure with its metadata to guide generation; and, 3)
demonstrating with extensive automatic and human experiments that our framework
outperforms other baseline methods (e.g. Alpaca and ChatGPT) in elaborating a
content plan meaningful for the target audience, simplifying the information
selected, and producing a coherent final report in a layman's style. | [
0.0371975675,
-0.0078920396,
0.0025427372,
-0.0438816287,
-0.0164044518,
-0.0187229197,
0.0056186868,
-0.0102229146,
-0.0288916733,
-0.0445465557,
0.0055900067,
0.0712573081,
0.0005213189,
0.0694534183,
-0.0022721596,
-0.0780384839,
0.0025458999,
0.0039329021,
0.0504753813,
-0.019456815,
0.0243240055,
0.0163268335,
-0.0098482333,
0.0056500072,
0.0215340909,
-0.0185811389,
0.0055088634,
0.009863737,
0.0249755587,
-0.0538980551,
0.0192847662,
0.0565062612,
0.0196129549,
0.02608083,
0.0000016994,
-0.0475663468,
0.0007735486,
0.0466697402,
0.0211235713,
0.0503144525,
0.0254130643,
-0.0301359091,
0.0069015129,
-0.0095529603,
-0.019526558,
-0.0017608105,
0.0314211138,
0.0066785677,
0.0429118164,
0.0375629961,
-0.0042571393,
-0.0344399139,
0.0180129651,
0.0211457759,
-0.0073864362,
0.0067476793,
0.0024774801,
0.0749330297,
0.058421161,
0.072729364,
0.0644472092,
0.0604796819,
0.0015792636,
-0.0628436878,
0.017333148,
0.0465068705,
0.0103214141,
-0.0100406352,
-0.0076002888,
0.0465457328,
0.093079403,
-0.0582637265,
0.0711488798,
0.0010464486,
-0.0197733156,
0.0318868682,
-0.0896995813,
0.0239156187,
-0.011723862,
-0.0351134613,
0.0114111397,
-0.0155677451,
-0.0178313702,
0.0401266925,
0.0446246229,
0.0502862483,
0.0084414575,
-0.0182060599,
-0.0489707664,
-0.0060510268,
0.0533604324,
-0.0903466195,
0.0143940346,
0.0511542074,
-0.0078148479,
-0.0017800779,
0.0007794927,
-0.0523757748,
0.0460004471,
-0.0551243313,
0.0128474813,
0.0006219684,
0.0173811428,
0.010452277,
0.0075100926,
-0.0366848782,
-0.0282566864,
0.0057684858,
0.018456243,
0.0151553983,
-0.0611477569,
-0.0469597727,
-0.0128986249,
0.0373441577,
-0.0331235193,
-0.0229439922,
-0.0050384211,
0.0060347975,
0.0238282848,
-0.0015572219,
0.0118974,
0.024884481,
-0.0841367617,
-0.0292448811,
0.0017610264,
0.0306282882,
-0.0346152261,
-0.0023331544,
0.0289289858,
0.0251961257,
-0.0167428441,
0.0439790301,
0.0053183283,
0.0432768874,
-0.0381952003,
0.019240424,
-0.0154997492,
0.0224310774,
0.0117360558,
-0.0727909505,
0.0235074367,
-0.0457661189,
0.0121295732,
-0.0459698774,
0.0368949398,
0.0349790975,
-0.0175735671,
-0.0736871511,
-0.0215665605,
0.0269799381,
-0.0107617239,
0.011235619,
-0.0798329338,
-0.0145623544,
0.076913543,
0.0256178789,
0.0212696586,
0.0342418179,
0.021364579,
0.0030293907,
0.0255487915,
0.0009331318,
0.0362944193,
-0.0484801531,
0.0202229954,
-0.0062563797,
-0.0045250971,
0.0242278371,
-0.0386251472,
0.0440947525,
0.0104982639,
0.0266229268,
-0.0265437141,
0.0493576452,
0.0129192006,
0.0279487967,
-0.0027490323,
0.0173316319,
0.0448921025,
0.0311817769,
0.0197665617,
0.0405602753,
0.0354462452,
0.064500615,
-0.0220024753,
0.0288634636,
0.0261212196,
0.0226531792,
-0.0129797654,
-0.0242992491,
-0.0038283917,
0.0158876218,
0.0317772068,
-0.0449965894,
0.0020174156,
0.0269528851,
-0.0061270553,
0.033605054,
0.0563468225,
0.0126207042,
0.0186072495,
0.0042063105,
0.0554451942,
-0.0245724618,
0.0428773426,
-0.0117439087,
-0.0232706927,
0.0025628463,
0.0560459271,
0.0648683608,
0.0212648734,
-0.0361810513,
-0.0745245516,
-0.0241423976,
-0.0276586413,
-0.0637343004,
0.0116041387,
0.0011265472,
0.0140014924,
-0.0206719525,
0.0214256942,
0.0319186561,
-0.0776942074,
0.0285097845,
-0.0702520907,
0.0039294222,
-0.0112776374,
-0.0442923084,
0.026562931,
0.0158711262,
-0.0086134514,
0.0450235121,
0.0394589864,
0.0024496634,
-0.0112846531,
0.0255527068,
0.0383789465,
0.0257930122,
-0.0035340982,
-0.1019402519,
0.0016388732,
-0.0140050156,
-0.0085834572,
-0.0340723619,
0.0238999315,
-0.0562063381,
-0.0396578796,
-0.004525993,
-0.0328369401,
0.01511834,
-0.0177816246,
-0.0067518633,
0.0150164962,
0.0363646224,
0.0226177499,
0.0473118089,
-0.0659792125,
-0.0126977013,
-0.0324117355,
0.0226915702,
0.0098310979,
0.0174054019,
-0.0258778166,
0.0598768182,
-0.0335426927,
-0.0023177864,
-0.0040415279,
-0.0441202261,
-0.0104911579,
-0.0011268934,
0.0080961091,
0.0627848282,
-0.0287302304,
0.0025374158,
0.0050528604,
0.003416732,
-0.0231255908,
0.0015602388,
-0.009799459,
0.0680361018,
0.0368358865,
0.0137465196,
-0.0235965196,
-0.0005103814,
-0.0580624491,
0.0264270678,
0.0906990021,
-0.0383879133,
-0.0981868878,
0.0187314413,
-0.033043813,
-0.0501403883,
-0.0035186547,
-0.0123908101,
0.019592125,
0.02662104,
-0.0177051406,
0.0595660508,
0.0328264274,
0.025589617,
0.038980525,
0.0232126638,
-0.0327422656,
-0.0074571013,
-0.0469686426,
0.0564028658,
-0.0014551114,
-0.0416679867,
0.0656621158,
0.0019660867,
-0.0051773712,
0.0511888228,
-0.0136584993,
0.0597163327,
-0.0241632406,
0.027345676,
0.0700541064,
-0.0365370885,
0.0292550437,
0.065853253,
0.0342171304,
0.0268732496,
0.0553832352,
-0.008741946,
0.0011359547,
-0.0731269792,
0.0056026927,
-0.030890651,
0.0097268419,
-0.0380620994,
0.0418705679,
0.0620928332,
0.0017607035,
-0.0156204822,
-0.0331203192,
0.0231990553,
0.0124023985,
-0.0335822329,
-0.0637699366,
0.0177529324,
0.0162664056,
-0.0168968756,
0.0415480025,
-0.009890914,
-0.010893845,
0.0450820923,
0.036147166,
-0.052932702,
-0.060782209,
0.0198385548,
0.105902344,
0.0188481249,
-0.0360686406,
-0.0109649748,
-0.0200884938,
0.056057509,
0.04817928,
-0.0125017604,
0.0029727132,
0.0159710199,
-0.0154500464,
0.0653586388,
-0.0619283617,
0.0553183183,
0.0112137198,
-0.0750544071,
-0.0171408989,
-0.0573452525,
-0.0417077877,
-0.0084024211,
0.0481102839,
-0.0357005112,
-0.0076406877,
0.0720074475,
0.0385369323,
0.0100978957,
-0.0167188998,
0.0192620903,
0.0076198955,
0.0072663026,
0.0420050062,
-0.06379769,
0.0381158367,
-0.0190152191,
0.006904684,
-0.0387910083,
-0.0297938026,
-0.027257124,
-0.0051222923,
0.0320489518,
0.0118171526,
0.0082347868,
0.0048293024,
-0.1014928445,
0.0021780974,
0.0015299828,
-0.0441509373,
0.0262321997,
-0.0160932224,
-0.0107130958,
0.0328711011,
-0.0677123666,
-0.0658020154,
-0.0174715817,
0.0067389011,
0.0105018187,
0.0240848232,
0.0428790227,
-0.0324930176,
0.0146032134,
-0.0076372926,
0.0197214037,
-0.0073361853,
-0.0215599723,
0.0185197722,
-0.0110304253,
0.0196901932,
-0.0543302111,
0.0781934038,
0.0190211777,
0.0078430511,
0.0211742893,
0.0310456734,
-0.0155174974,
-0.025355,
-0.0644977093,
0.0261038393,
0.0005978683,
0.0779895857,
0.0496757329,
-0.0018305413,
-0.0371502377,
-0.0425548144,
0.0166652706,
-0.0150782717,
-0.0465335175,
-0.0373341925,
-0.0283747856,
-0.0147457505,
-0.0639717132,
-0.0565584712,
-0.0013026677,
0.0103251673,
0.0280418787,
-0.0195105467,
0.0267609935,
-0.008145608,
-0.0570184812,
-0.0217073802,
0.0116221122,
-0.0409830995,
-0.0219465494,
-0.0289148707,
0.0854253471,
0.0181801878,
-0.0456139147,
-0.0014698576,
0.0313759148,
-0.0758059397,
-0.0283085182,
0.0150252394,
0.0298181903,
0.0179789066,
-0.0090967836,
-0.0448631458,
0.0609148256,
0.0739967152,
-0.0443221889,
0.0013402386,
-0.0049878722,
-0.0349305756,
-0.0243023708,
-0.0323326811,
-0.0030344923,
0.0233008265,
-0.0544380769,
0.024393091,
-0.0580408275,
0.0056230295,
0.0407612883,
0.0364476182,
-0.0077836122,
-0.0376348421,
0.0009192748,
-0.0115649113,
-0.0221124813,
-0.0561394766,
-0.0119337719,
-0.0186638497,
0.0568837821,
-0.0337446406,
-0.0008936921,
0.0274203476,
0.0629638359,
-0.0717074573,
0.0417966805,
-0.032444004,
0.0442899168,
-0.006909878,
0.0085285157,
0.0071820896,
-0.0344361551,
-0.0462427326,
-0.0098268036,
-0.0561766438,
0.0261473805,
-0.0103429742,
-0.011135078,
0.0559669472,
0.0064920662,
-0.0214704033,
0.0059940475,
-0.0951502398,
-0.0262599979,
-0.0683688372,
0.0642443374,
-0.0167381559,
0.025923362,
0.0506716631,
-0.0641530082,
-0.0396485478,
-0.0078843376,
0.0711239204,
0.0151620666,
0.0107775163,
0.0413300358,
0.0222596787,
-0.0315670259,
-0.0584177077,
0.067178309,
-0.0122046946,
-0.0069083548,
0.0172529891,
-0.041019965,
-0.0251197815,
-0.0460837819,
-0.0134331565,
0.0091220764,
0.0051912819,
-0.0366185755,
-0.0425348952,
0.0163643826,
0.0315032043,
0.0307955444,
0.0086230701,
-0.0547079258,
0.0204521939,
0.0416818894,
0.0169410724,
-0.045740135,
-0.0324181765,
0.0090959156,
-0.0311600491,
-0.0726480037,
0.0058303252,
-5.999230928e-33,
-0.0104666995,
-0.0323624648,
0.0005657863,
0.0510684773,
0.00309161,
0.033406999,
-0.0897628963,
-0.0285862926,
0.0085840682,
0.0494554788,
-0.0114484932,
-0.0070822225,
-0.0090637747,
-0.041063536,
0.018195508,
0.0341453068,
0.0305842776,
-0.0056517222,
-0.0350490026,
0.0683165267,
0.0279535018,
-0.0069793058,
0.0214821938,
-0.050650429,
0.0472688675,
-0.0106741386,
-0.0130129242,
-0.0211811662,
0.0471847765,
0.0397836939,
-0.0078935931,
-0.0344508179,
0.0226260554,
-0.0423993617,
-0.0184491388,
0.0308393445,
-0.0687974989,
0.003805784,
0.0305124652,
-0.0542791598,
-0.0433121547,
-0.0069417208,
0.0128706247,
-0.0423045792,
-0.0220711958,
-0.0231930632,
0.0535737239,
-0.0073922402,
-0.030489983,
-0.0624007061,
-0.0421656556,
0.0132019669,
-0.0257248301,
0.004933577,
0.0102507779,
0.0333581306,
-0.0041081323,
0.0426684134,
0.0004666205,
0.0523967743,
0.0139594544,
0.0263623949,
0.017109219,
-0.0644426718,
0.0224074237,
0.0184534416,
0.0124602811,
0.0231680702,
-0.0332187638,
0.0206080452,
-0.0239844415,
-0.0027614255,
0.026152445,
0.027074486,
0.0115106162,
-0.0074573481,
-0.07908535,
0.0388717353,
-0.0097519895,
0.0393111445,
0.0130123831,
-0.0138174882,
-0.0043789498,
-0.014334945,
0.0109669771,
-0.0264149625,
0.01766623,
-0.0694835037,
-0.0385012701,
-0.0322078206,
-0.0627815053,
0.0384062305,
-0.0162103213,
-0.0006272295,
-0.0350554176,
0.007280828,
-0.0086094914,
0.0465440638,
-0.0089256633,
0.0104950638,
-0.0677430853,
-0.0127890771,
0.0011933267,
0.0514101498,
0.0184029713,
-0.0103833489,
0.0284421891,
0.0163649172,
-0.0055478346,
0.0013419067,
0.0041338904,
-0.0180858877,
-0.0065378742,
-0.0291515477,
-0.0062229382,
0.0586184785,
0.0240253787,
0.0030592445,
0.0131983096,
0.0312290005,
-0.011701921,
-0.0093593374,
0.0098152906,
0.0728397295,
0.0043664337,
0.0055840667,
-0.0296974555,
0.0088297864,
0.0132269152,
-0.0122698992,
-0.0048890426,
0.0029570092,
2.521e-7,
0.0368366428,
0.064370364,
0.0335602798,
0.0216068458,
0.0171589274,
-0.0289736018,
-0.0110942982,
0.0235076174,
-0.0103747873,
-0.0543981791,
0.0221438147,
-0.0059427936,
-0.0125688994,
0.0275812484,
-0.0997742787,
-0.0387660116,
-0.0909739211,
-0.0585822649,
-0.0488236658,
-0.020827068,
0.029579632,
-0.0655073524,
-0.0362524614,
0.020768119,
-0.0150593547,
0.0042646313,
0.0600126684,
0.0218148958,
0.0206629038,
0.1034946516,
0.0222211443,
-0.0161120053,
-0.0049200291,
-0.0121597843,
-0.0278935432,
-0.042491585,
-0.0335301496,
0.0448641218,
0.0384333022,
-0.0049922615,
0.041557882,
0.0046675615,
0.048989106,
-0.0261291433,
-0.0064178426,
-0.0828960836,
-0.0502213053,
-0.0441884622,
-0.0617977679,
0.0092493454,
0.0198089201,
-0.0211518761,
-0.0231005941,
0.0358179845,
-0.0592967384,
-0.006396567,
0.0254532099,
-0.0546076447,
-0.0196092427,
0.0287875701,
-0.0391456932,
-0.0174891427,
0.0141457375,
-0.0450827591,
-0.0058491034,
-0.0462392792,
0.0317388289,
2.128040586e-34,
0.0736491829,
-0.0047489996,
-0.0333259813,
0.0268305,
0.0258160084,
0.0255618822,
0.012990444,
-0.0138891889,
0.0264641624,
-0.0271429811,
-0.0144239059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15075v1 | TableQAKit: A Comprehensive and Practical Toolkit for Table-based Question Answering | 2023-10-23T16:33:23 | 2023-10-23T16:33:23 | Fangyu Lei, Tongxu Luo, Pengqi Yang, Weihao Liu, Hanwen Liu, Jiahe Lei, Yiming Huang, Yifan Wei, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table-based question answering (TableQA) is an important task in natural
language processing, which requires comprehending tables and employing various
reasoning ways to answer the questions. This paper introduces TableQAKit, the
first comprehensive toolkit designed specifically for TableQA. The toolkit
designs a unified platform that includes plentiful TableQA datasets and
integrates popular methods of this task as well as large language models
(LLMs). Users can add their datasets and methods according to the friendly
interface. Also, pleasantly surprised using the modules in this toolkit
achieves new SOTA on some datasets. Finally, \tableqakit{} also provides an
LLM-based TableQA Benchmark for evaluating the role of LLMs in TableQA.
TableQAKit is open-source with an interactive interface that includes visual
operations, and comprehensive data for ease of use. | [
0.0389958695,
0.0338160582,
-0.0065224902,
0.0158900004,
-0.0544590726,
0.0278501473,
-0.0062127328,
-0.0029993341,
-0.0062621622,
-0.0198058244,
-0.0314347558,
0.0158086419,
-0.018824771,
0.0275058951,
0.0369412228,
0.0228010081,
0.0467827171,
0.0084941126,
-0.042339284,
0.000533166,
0.0127715459,
0.0048943749,
-0.0361670963,
0.0147823775,
-0.0024163851,
-0.0196390972,
-0.0247208532,
-0.0294263028,
-0.0261291619,
0.0121171633,
0.0015760541,
0.0828423575,
0.0122910626,
0.0135228233,
0.0000020579,
-0.0252130628,
-0.0528851785,
-0.0231058225,
-0.0324090272,
0.0033478248,
0.0257894006,
-0.0019720709,
0.0269444883,
-0.0010641442,
-0.0710469782,
0.0209874082,
0.0135753751,
0.0623139553,
0.0646735057,
0.028739376,
0.0188681241,
-0.0436465703,
-0.0260723066,
0.0255078264,
0.016810203,
-0.0541396104,
0.0135096312,
0.0487193055,
0.0303527247,
-0.0396894664,
0.0151303252,
0.0416700095,
0.0207856167,
-0.0028386849,
0.0029317511,
0.029692689,
-0.0483825877,
0.0084969969,
-0.0014212319,
0.0977605954,
0.0614715368,
-0.0415932797,
0.0170814674,
0.0209249146,
0.0182765033,
0.010821986,
-0.0691974387,
-0.001949258,
0.0002824366,
-0.0268205311,
0.0194585621,
-0.0129180001,
-0.010511972,
0.0138346776,
-0.0295969434,
0.0843831524,
-0.0114809768,
-0.0336948484,
-0.0053145816,
-0.0314430594,
-0.0317130461,
-0.0405740179,
0.0221398529,
0.0700593218,
-0.0244509857,
0.0310598351,
0.0343945101,
-0.0294123851,
0.0394598208,
-0.0687135234,
-0.0050929347,
0.0337607265,
-0.0123591265,
0.035893213,
-0.035106156,
0.0175989196,
0.0093342364,
0.0170093663,
-0.0436937362,
-0.0216097198,
-0.041442696,
-0.0174729135,
-0.0469075963,
0.0336341001,
-0.0528154001,
-0.0152580114,
0.0091871517,
-0.0009817269,
0.0007726903,
0.0027477492,
0.0491571389,
0.0422663763,
0.0015197574,
0.0270626489,
-0.0482627191,
0.0109610707,
-0.0788384154,
0.0283188745,
-0.0426173545,
-0.0729514658,
-0.0220044721,
-0.0174449775,
0.0327462368,
-0.0194049589,
0.0617838018,
0.0693648756,
-0.0183003638,
-0.0086583784,
-0.0273411386,
-0.0135222645,
-0.0412641317,
-0.06893453,
-0.0323009342,
-0.0633065104,
0.0509018637,
0.0423561931,
-0.0146880737,
-0.0378887877,
0.0301135425,
0.0653731078,
-0.0167413857,
0.0526078753,
0.001903654,
0.0375924483,
0.0428226516,
-0.0036193633,
-0.007290428,
0.0874791592,
0.0312048569,
0.0003548645,
0.0062200339,
-0.0273107179,
-0.0343780294,
0.0399551839,
0.0323784873,
-0.027001312,
-0.0125271091,
0.0737386793,
0.0011211331,
0.021185061,
-0.0246723741,
0.0142612085,
-0.004859996,
0.0277966671,
0.0183642711,
0.0642210022,
0.0038162884,
0.0549688302,
-0.0199055746,
-0.0084068561,
0.0465460345,
0.0107069463,
-0.0220227353,
0.0629209802,
0.0013832774,
0.021743618,
0.0276668463,
0.0021486606,
0.0000842217,
-0.066808477,
-0.0049073016,
0.0228967182,
0.0060488684,
0.0107815107,
0.0478278324,
0.0219078269,
-0.0655769855,
0.0235651415,
0.001215276,
-0.0704316571,
-0.0321870558,
-0.0005961724,
0.0661806017,
0.0415468402,
0.0395366587,
-0.0664797649,
-0.0063164937,
0.0045546135,
0.0179416351,
-0.0048900801,
0.0046350998,
-0.0305183288,
-0.0089779757,
0.002804097,
-0.0039878581,
0.0350977927,
0.0102848606,
-0.0323186889,
0.0368713476,
0.0103565184,
-0.025654003,
-0.0456425324,
-0.0146961641,
0.0292264596,
0.0391567051,
-0.0069637182,
-0.0309299696,
-0.0097756349,
0.0178949423,
0.0306490287,
0.0076450664,
0.048945006,
0.0478030741,
-0.0262736659,
0.0049250047,
-0.0096465377,
0.0030337924,
-0.0129923131,
0.0375695489,
0.0073427539,
-0.0524377301,
-0.0074622063,
-0.0257989597,
-0.0384174958,
0.0182652734,
-0.0410452411,
-0.043094784,
-0.0569820777,
-0.0081448369,
0.008841997,
0.0247285645,
-0.0173759516,
0.0913600475,
0.0091713769,
0.0326489061,
0.0011256858,
-0.0703034475,
0.0178571604,
-0.0190126281,
0.0568779521,
-0.0376771577,
-0.0432050861,
0.0042689159,
0.0054373997,
0.0289932657,
-0.0704228282,
-0.0069534131,
-0.1088558137,
0.0387270376,
-0.0389922224,
0.0434950888,
0.0342934169,
0.0022596191,
-0.0289983153,
-0.0224656947,
-0.028810814,
-0.0069678924,
0.0249292497,
-0.0049948567,
0.0606808066,
-0.0246579275,
-0.0090170465,
-0.0557512417,
-0.0150945019,
-0.015482042,
0.0366770439,
-0.032654725,
-0.0534694754,
0.0154567035,
-0.0356686115,
-0.0221386496,
0.0097436355,
0.0367658399,
-0.0361178294,
-0.0170121919,
-0.0070885401,
0.0274188537,
0.0314459726,
-0.0114698056,
-0.0011989112,
0.0272692088,
-0.010966666,
-0.0324576981,
0.0182451364,
0.0017494267,
0.025442224,
0.0267757494,
-0.0734993219,
0.0301251225,
0.0258210115,
0.0004155832,
-0.0047286325,
-0.0044973455,
0.0365705974,
0.0093354657,
-0.0054850574,
-0.0777609721,
0.049672097,
0.0008985734,
0.0325389877,
0.006347938,
-0.0029466841,
0.0202290453,
-0.0391231775,
-0.0011229607,
-0.0504469201,
-0.0046595167,
-0.0652510673,
0.0780716613,
-0.0160129368,
0.009216696,
-0.0301825032,
-0.0144192353,
-0.0384358093,
-0.0305845477,
0.0103540514,
-0.0513108894,
0.0948534906,
-0.0540402979,
0.0395645909,
-0.0240398478,
0.0160644874,
-0.0101597765,
-0.0228402894,
-0.06989564,
0.0153850811,
0.0228813756,
0.0082799392,
-0.0038942499,
-0.014154274,
0.0290537439,
0.0251007881,
-0.0207298249,
0.0054585319,
-0.0265434999,
0.0627897605,
0.0629646555,
0.0423145108,
-0.0017611795,
0.0363952182,
0.0506334119,
0.0604471415,
-0.016436018,
0.0062259878,
-0.0050534164,
0.0151888533,
0.0138993319,
-0.0442068093,
0.0187167171,
0.0246046409,
-0.0171941575,
-0.0574504323,
-0.0076882686,
0.0936205462,
0.0445478894,
0.037881691,
0.0051412261,
-0.0249704793,
0.0182839017,
0.0183546543,
0.0616114773,
-0.1057580411,
-0.0460301638,
-0.0123227658,
-0.0160583667,
0.0044341399,
-0.0199914556,
-0.0187102482,
-0.076035589,
0.0153891286,
-0.0368837267,
-0.0682498366,
-0.0921965763,
-0.0430660844,
-0.0097909374,
-0.0216061007,
0.0150269903,
0.0623247176,
-0.0318039022,
0.0325596742,
0.0182049125,
-0.0467656441,
0.0032380936,
0.0078462427,
-0.0474981628,
0.0342184491,
0.0574651174,
0.0403522328,
-0.0211816467,
-0.004274982,
0.002451044,
-0.0389736928,
-0.0081206989,
-0.0196274873,
0.0223935563,
0.0312834531,
-0.0031678609,
-0.034407936,
0.0019744141,
-0.0401192345,
0.0021650719,
0.0530922599,
0.0540560298,
-0.0268322974,
-0.0171606708,
0.0064261775,
0.0249059517,
-0.0214936379,
0.0972721055,
0.0463222079,
0.0243575387,
-0.0702160597,
-0.0145619744,
-0.0652222037,
-0.0590113252,
-0.018435644,
0.0474507362,
0.0037700664,
0.0153908217,
-0.0684064701,
0.0085016256,
0.0650022626,
0.0239485167,
-0.0153250704,
0.070961684,
-0.0555082709,
0.0167634487,
-0.0511343479,
-0.0182723831,
-0.0379478298,
0.0249832179,
-0.0150436955,
-0.0090857586,
0.0232485533,
-0.0203074887,
-0.0360052548,
0.0266653076,
-0.0580502599,
-0.0212929156,
-0.0288055278,
0.0213311147,
0.0163236093,
-0.0220317487,
0.0088509582,
-0.0109809116,
-0.0124024646,
-0.0223147701,
-0.0761174038,
-0.0294758715,
-0.0143047944,
-0.0195825025,
0.0071246391,
0.0439097136,
-0.0308888331,
-0.019132575,
-0.0299596824,
0.071762152,
-0.0133110434,
0.0320949517,
0.0501727276,
-0.0153112113,
-0.0238961652,
0.056285467,
-0.0611490384,
-0.0012331095,
0.0331223533,
-0.0489048362,
-0.0475052707,
0.0111518474,
0.0221185051,
-0.017601043,
-0.032909099,
-0.0320693403,
-0.0241658483,
-0.0106271151,
0.0325191207,
-0.0108005973,
0.0292400513,
0.0417177528,
-0.0441196263,
-0.0230578799,
-0.0468971319,
-0.0161732007,
-0.0319806375,
0.0060108136,
0.038885802,
-0.0055722171,
0.028866617,
0.0015665446,
-0.0515307188,
-0.026575977,
0.0410040282,
-0.0385795608,
-0.0604515448,
0.0133984415,
0.0098239705,
0.0332516246,
-0.0048887008,
0.0108849611,
0.0030765045,
-0.0202433653,
0.017547369,
0.0030277837,
0.0219707433,
0.0202944651,
0.0502915047,
-0.0054815616,
-0.0071193879,
-0.0253266711,
0.0748610944,
0.0248403158,
0.0116230398,
0.0212040097,
-0.0064769224,
-0.0447039977,
-0.0251883287,
-0.0206505079,
-0.0044021662,
-0.0347911268,
-0.0120100314,
-0.0070130108,
-0.0364319123,
0.0196070764,
0.0276540183,
-0.0432062,
-0.0040755342,
0.032820724,
0.052258756,
0.0734300017,
-0.0384496339,
-0.048788216,
0.074968636,
-0.0182883646,
-0.0292408504,
-0.0297647361,
-6.696612054e-33,
-0.0318946578,
-0.0375848114,
0.0186658837,
-0.0647073463,
0.0245683771,
-0.026407918,
-0.0397715867,
-0.0401171036,
-0.0184766259,
-0.000024875,
-0.0239642914,
0.0508843437,
0.0133399777,
-0.0132017434,
0.0055838251,
-0.0994353518,
-0.0141485864,
0.0108084781,
0.0051966165,
-0.0081120403,
-0.0027937884,
0.0381475724,
0.0313300453,
-0.0059019979,
0.0334301293,
-0.0036927182,
-0.0046094712,
-0.0076954952,
-0.0157694891,
0.0528324395,
-0.0318494812,
0.0258499477,
0.0243688598,
-0.0497703515,
-0.0014953812,
0.0481609926,
-0.1426496208,
-0.0258935429,
0.0309528261,
0.0159057081,
-0.0170018636,
-0.0407585017,
0.0260606185,
0.0017883598,
-0.0228087418,
0.0025715267,
0.0281961467,
-0.0356268212,
0.0027369109,
-0.0002578862,
-0.0104727736,
0.0180894695,
-0.0378455222,
0.0076244809,
0.0247243959,
0.0583757386,
-0.0014442146,
-0.0354097486,
-0.0347347222,
0.0127874771,
-0.0006549043,
0.0164717473,
0.0568070933,
-0.0380313434,
0.0242254026,
-0.0036075639,
-0.0001254344,
-0.0372627228,
-0.0326788053,
-0.0086355638,
-0.0533270948,
0.05667473,
0.0879744589,
-0.0026617341,
0.0175873358,
0.0141074127,
-0.0777637139,
0.0547625534,
0.0052378392,
0.0457741767,
-0.0210309289,
-0.0278373118,
-0.0143527249,
-0.0136778625,
-0.026406005,
0.0264765676,
-0.034504056,
-0.01047849,
0.0159234684,
-0.0415414684,
0.0098407976,
-0.0132260369,
0.0068749008,
-0.0048645716,
-0.0183430221,
0.0559983216,
0.0269958675,
-0.0100611057,
0.0375987105,
0.0381297357,
-0.012568105,
0.0238662157,
0.0171415396,
-0.0415030755,
0.0301708598,
0.0337798186,
0.0183615666,
0.0031730135,
-0.051962886,
-0.0227416381,
-0.0238225479,
0.0362985171,
-0.0183562897,
0.0177951008,
-0.0017186723,
0.030307591,
0.0099283699,
0.0339893624,
0.0130112153,
0.0211491361,
-0.0278857611,
-0.008532878,
-0.0045123384,
0.0080321711,
0.0013729362,
0.044034116,
-0.0562580489,
0.0386743546,
-0.0130836833,
-0.0323591344,
0.0154480068,
0.0224217903,
2.596e-7,
0.1039551795,
0.0208737832,
0.0516023412,
0.0554002002,
-0.01019153,
-0.0233303905,
-0.0045559211,
0.0097144367,
-0.0199451186,
-0.0275542308,
0.0312535316,
0.0127929114,
0.0525763519,
0.0235148687,
-0.0290900134,
-0.0440272354,
-0.0869951099,
0.0049154935,
-0.064344041,
0.0245630704,
0.0344864614,
0.0813858807,
-0.057310123,
0.0048261783,
-0.0506540202,
-0.0127764847,
0.0113057038,
-0.0482985638,
0.0557679087,
0.0303798765,
0.0512480959,
-0.0464964174,
0.0367470086,
0.0380480438,
-0.0247201361,
0.0106110508,
0.0255225021,
0.0404846109,
0.0078279451,
0.0102437409,
-0.0290460289,
-0.0786366835,
0.0481822416,
-0.0768451616,
0.13975209,
-0.0261265989,
0.0078963116,
0.0336357988,
0.0154978894,
0.0107154865,
0.0035742561,
0.0146767981,
-0.000267086,
0.0354713574,
0.0426253602,
-0.0150131127,
0.002789764,
-0.0399971046,
-0.028109448,
0.015443895,
-0.0142987175,
-0.0070027243,
-0.0114466846,
-0.0317282751,
-0.0266662575,
-0.0363674536,
-0.0442116298,
2.348406747e-34,
0.0258187503,
0.0125968009,
0.0193728115,
0.0897115245,
0.0670444742,
-0.0475530364,
0.0248160642,
-0.0214041285,
0.025405949,
-0.1075534075,
-0.0052061025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15066v1 | Localizing Active Objects from Egocentric Vision with Symbolic World Knowledge | 2023-10-23T16:14:05 | 2023-10-23T16:14:05 | Te-Lin Wu, Yu Zhou, Nanyun Peng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The ability to actively ground task instructions from an egocentric view is
crucial for AI agents to accomplish tasks or assist humans virtually. One
important step towards this goal is to localize and track key active objects
that undergo major state change as a consequence of human actions/interactions
to the environment without being told exactly what/where to ground (e.g.,
localizing and tracking the `sponge` in video from the instruction "Dip the
`sponge` into the bucket."). While existing works approach this problem from a
pure vision perspective, we investigate to which extent the textual modality
(i.e., task instructions) and their interaction with visual modality can be
beneficial. Specifically, we propose to improve phrase grounding models'
ability on localizing the active objects by: (1) learning the role of `objects
undergoing change` and extracting them accurately from the instructions, (2)
leveraging pre- and post-conditions of the objects during actions, and (3)
recognizing the objects more robustly with descriptional knowledge. We leverage
large language models (LLMs) to extract the aforementioned action-object
knowledge, and design a per-object aggregation masking technique to effectively
perform joint inference on object phrases and symbolic knowledge. We evaluate
our framework on Ego4D and Epic-Kitchens datasets. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework, which leads to>54%
improvements in all standard metrics on the TREK-150-OPE-Det localization +
tracking task, >7% improvements in all standard metrics on the TREK-150-OPE
tracking task, and >3% improvements in average precision (AP) on the Ego4D SCOD
task. | [
0.0299254321,
0.0522302315,
0.0185736492,
0.0246940963,
-0.0227765981,
-0.0067044878,
0.00424182,
0.0084173372,
0.0001626817,
-0.1072112173,
-0.0188609194,
-0.0343052745,
0.0074773636,
0.018071996,
0.0170932636,
-0.035772793,
0.0409585573,
-0.0384721495,
-0.0535286851,
0.0111549627,
0.0009671511,
0.0033298044,
-0.0278182421,
0.0366641358,
-0.0445936546,
0.0092941727,
-0.0291300379,
-0.0176117755,
0.060297668,
-0.0325547084,
-0.0089723738,
0.0554990545,
0.061121922,
-0.0240259822,
0.0000022319,
-0.0356056541,
0.0162668452,
-0.0137042161,
-0.0105964374,
-0.0208223611,
-0.0173875839,
-0.0588035099,
0.0328782201,
-0.0100913318,
-0.0291799568,
0.0035669853,
0.0437497348,
0.0709268674,
0.0308508351,
0.0381103866,
-0.02872077,
0.0232309327,
-0.0007553056,
-0.0075664138,
0.0182519127,
-0.0334606916,
0.0441593081,
0.0099132592,
-0.033335682,
0.0330856889,
-0.0364982225,
0.0038336013,
0.0064964429,
0.0084024249,
0.0101475446,
0.062162064,
-0.0189761166,
0.0075116879,
-0.0174485762,
0.0694146454,
0.0140038794,
-0.0149797304,
0.0178954434,
0.0173950065,
-0.0021099525,
-0.0161922369,
-0.0287208091,
0.0414176807,
-0.0054281438,
0.0084759565,
-0.0368170924,
0.0404242352,
-0.0208931621,
0.0244699996,
-0.0186115652,
0.0145774446,
-0.0015551371,
0.0260153804,
-0.0129519701,
0.012720841,
-0.0380179659,
-0.0736550018,
0.016882034,
0.0315490738,
0.0158364363,
-0.0022035383,
-0.0731239766,
0.0476020053,
-0.0455224738,
-0.0404722728,
0.0627115071,
0.0510937236,
-0.0399907716,
0.087315321,
-0.0262995251,
0.0701740086,
-0.0268988889,
0.0415109172,
-0.0289962236,
0.0101716034,
-0.0604210533,
0.0249372963,
-0.0196690019,
0.025716044,
-0.0547344871,
-0.0357448123,
0.0312316399,
-0.0044119614,
-0.0131156398,
-0.0138585996,
-0.0198266469,
0.0409460962,
-0.0281067882,
-0.0238785986,
0.0086281952,
-0.0154865123,
-0.0124467062,
0.0339067318,
-0.054702308,
-0.03738584,
-0.0080529908,
0.0217709895,
0.0202121362,
-0.0068810671,
0.0056241485,
0.0743479729,
0.0045338757,
-0.0709187835,
-0.00736605,
-0.006934661,
-0.031146057,
-0.0395893194,
0.0353766792,
-0.0644229949,
0.0273059495,
-0.037975166,
0.017535314,
-0.0500985458,
0.0443532281,
0.0143962139,
-0.0049444181,
0.0744468719,
0.0016972611,
0.0136960391,
-0.0144293085,
0.0225079153,
0.0151750846,
0.0518497303,
0.0278221387,
0.0425858088,
0.0237393007,
0.037194334,
0.030302085,
0.0300487913,
-0.0275706071,
0.0663842857,
-0.0473991036,
0.0084472643,
-0.0184790343,
-0.0065784021,
0.0114554549,
0.0203984361,
-0.006365804,
-0.0152398469,
0.0723103285,
0.0445824265,
-0.1102771014,
-0.0436969213,
0.0426337011,
0.0143434536,
-0.011805106,
-0.0274720602,
-0.0671537519,
0.0486936755,
-0.0109860813,
-0.0460439026,
-0.0583672188,
0.0079124263,
-0.040207997,
-0.0462329499,
-0.001441699,
0.0000451253,
-0.001560382,
0.0319142267,
0.0518396646,
-0.0051411893,
-0.0239550099,
0.0539883673,
0.0067353938,
-0.03552806,
0.0035468892,
-0.0048280316,
0.0031900709,
0.0285613351,
-0.00822281,
-0.0331944413,
-0.0474633873,
0.0033218996,
0.0748951063,
0.0180367101,
-0.0335053131,
-0.0116759762,
0.04179978,
-0.0267238487,
-0.0518504903,
0.0041720006,
0.0061147925,
0.0220021661,
0.0480327979,
-0.0020421995,
0.0197614599,
-0.0043927385,
0.0040505752,
0.0673352629,
0.0404274501,
-0.0105846785,
-0.0210030079,
0.0130801741,
-0.0166767314,
0.0048145526,
-0.0097874533,
-0.0164992772,
0.0413834341,
-0.0411201492,
-0.0243288074,
0.0480885617,
-0.0069500632,
0.0009675599,
0.0456211008,
-0.0351729691,
-0.0228393953,
0.0186605547,
-0.0210309979,
-0.0389394127,
0.0109317806,
-0.0307570081,
-0.0075377598,
0.0254505724,
0.0062088999,
0.0303674638,
-0.0127086909,
-0.0244962312,
0.0463691019,
-0.0534938388,
-0.0148864789,
-0.0036022956,
0.0170172416,
0.0336614512,
-0.0060046054,
-0.0058280397,
-0.0333070382,
-0.0020160642,
-0.0026997915,
0.033484593,
0.010952224,
-0.0205036476,
0.0035161837,
-0.1260404587,
-0.0129598519,
-0.0233490635,
-0.0202236958,
0.0419304371,
-0.0256554,
-0.0104140695,
-0.020807961,
0.0069766776,
0.0018195681,
-0.0284702312,
-0.0007221671,
0.0080989962,
0.0072964258,
-0.0366789661,
-0.0505454317,
0.0333929583,
-0.0169714,
0.0008430739,
0.0151928635,
-0.0695778579,
-0.055830691,
0.0070166364,
-0.0052414108,
0.0754681155,
-0.0408550315,
-0.0177441966,
0.0170628093,
-0.0231106933,
0.0218910538,
0.0880455151,
-0.0418155193,
0.049152907,
0.0501176417,
-0.0431322344,
-0.0519151613,
-0.007352774,
0.0037929963,
-0.0083301133,
-0.0384836718,
-0.0262738746,
0.0171347968,
0.0708044544,
-0.0004348907,
0.0085405745,
-0.0635486245,
-0.0108592315,
-0.049862884,
-0.0586251095,
-0.0512553602,
0.0271963552,
-0.0180944055,
0.0296474937,
-0.0428421199,
-0.0402375162,
0.0121028153,
-0.0252412315,
0.000486078,
0.0373257324,
-0.008067593,
-0.011960228,
0.0942660496,
0.0410778821,
0.040999487,
-0.000581921,
-0.006720298,
-0.0474591404,
0.007361399,
-0.0459135585,
0.0104558514,
0.0278978124,
-0.1022239625,
0.027935788,
0.003636145,
-0.0258227047,
-0.0207057092,
0.0023088281,
-0.0187429488,
-0.0027750838,
-0.0653716922,
-0.0365385376,
-0.0298297592,
0.0229694266,
0.0020727746,
0.0394551121,
0.0084207086,
-0.0073818313,
-0.037591327,
-0.0093436036,
0.0803828239,
-0.0148228286,
-0.0654443726,
-0.0264715422,
-0.0030594487,
0.0969210342,
0.0390721075,
-0.0106455106,
-0.0390104912,
0.0364186056,
0.0344389156,
0.0220919382,
-0.0204522945,
0.0294601787,
0.073558569,
-0.0167319924,
-0.0578961596,
0.1024855077,
0.0445816815,
-0.0297463201,
-0.0089916121,
0.0440633968,
-0.0626833364,
0.0406529158,
-0.0085731586,
-0.0216632374,
-0.0400294028,
0.0091410391,
-0.0399445929,
0.0233050585,
-0.0445341021,
-0.0088437796,
-0.0854028836,
0.0430436842,
0.0150200408,
-0.0550284237,
-0.0662199557,
0.0029737742,
0.0560023636,
-0.0242209025,
-0.0430600978,
-0.0405680612,
0.0166220684,
-0.0310269035,
0.0169831701,
0.0041457606,
-0.0237213634,
0.0077434923,
-0.0538134053,
-0.0019118577,
0.0099211428,
0.030530449,
0.0053465553,
-0.0259288605,
-0.0153882829,
0.0434249006,
0.000676066,
0.0137088466,
0.03239391,
-0.0588300154,
-0.0140819829,
0.0087242872,
0.0595957749,
-0.0523419641,
-0.0512983166,
-0.0124017196,
0.0337182917,
-0.0288208444,
0.0442835502,
-0.0442514494,
-0.0126686851,
0.0262121391,
0.0579807796,
-0.0322238989,
-0.0328780003,
0.0220522434,
-0.0069419378,
-0.0134359915,
0.0039359438,
-0.0390893333,
-0.0088367732,
-0.0489308871,
-0.0101039764,
-0.0913282037,
-0.0163107198,
0.113410078,
0.0729581565,
0.0265030917,
-0.0245138817,
0.0217295215,
0.0095371008,
-0.063028343,
0.0525070615,
-0.0647470281,
0.0397987328,
-0.0041711032,
-0.0040316735,
0.0617852472,
0.0201440286,
-0.0242360253,
0.0463908762,
-0.0583515577,
-0.0627024546,
-0.0017618922,
0.0588681661,
0.0169742908,
0.0392257646,
-0.0239946414,
-0.0072485977,
-0.0269121323,
-0.0209519137,
-0.0061208773,
0.0414864421,
-0.0006816668,
-0.0239622556,
-0.0042600133,
0.030740805,
-0.0453782789,
0.0369795114,
0.0467467457,
0.0126845967,
-0.081002295,
-0.0517469756,
0.0369122997,
-0.0514285192,
0.058109019,
-0.0088984231,
0.0027467816,
-0.015085076,
-0.0191611499,
-0.019702591,
-0.0359695777,
-0.0698089749,
0.0506923795,
0.0268157087,
0.0244122911,
0.0129184434,
0.0469519608,
0.0104516223,
0.0101385266,
-0.0183659364,
-0.0601242036,
-0.0127768898,
0.0026188346,
-0.0028601005,
0.0479411706,
-0.0057489355,
-0.0008363628,
-0.0071161413,
0.0309627876,
0.0267459545,
0.0586286224,
0.0287478175,
-0.0248058457,
-0.0878928825,
0.035074003,
-0.0472290181,
-0.008450469,
-0.0220797323,
0.0738106221,
0.0687241033,
-0.0666951314,
0.0168525018,
-0.0446522459,
0.0045066103,
0.0107921679,
0.0258015934,
0.0116025629,
-0.0181636531,
0.0336173959,
0.0482896715,
0.0048784143,
0.0258759912,
0.0707557425,
0.0187623762,
0.0633007661,
0.0178542398,
-0.0057620234,
-0.0328681208,
0.0023701307,
0.0682541132,
0.0460619032,
0.0059147589,
0.0541803464,
-0.0219160151,
-0.0522441939,
-0.0169824678,
0.0170797613,
-0.0204685405,
-0.0018711115,
0.0487323962,
-0.006254836,
-0.0021371562,
-0.0368842632,
-0.0366923921,
-0.049254436,
-0.0082134493,
-0.0066248514,
-0.0433744341,
-6.0247634e-33,
-0.059630651,
-0.0448227376,
-0.001474029,
0.0272283852,
-0.0143933808,
0.0464451425,
-0.014443187,
0.0064375652,
0.0219986867,
0.0359836556,
0.0110551249,
0.027746303,
0.0191940833,
0.0065119197,
-0.007325904,
-0.0021395003,
0.0267568156,
0.0110600684,
-0.0244037472,
-0.0242409427,
0.0561768338,
0.0092610884,
0.0826093778,
-0.083100982,
0.0164464898,
0.0363607816,
-0.0246897656,
0.0336927772,
0.0091170957,
0.0120942974,
-0.0398233645,
-0.0010127621,
0.0071903951,
0.0019508469,
-0.0206564441,
0.025597766,
-0.0572303832,
-0.0022296598,
-0.0062733036,
0.0560243018,
-0.0494123697,
0.0041424236,
0.004503015,
0.0017238962,
-0.0187198799,
0.0105944648,
0.0276597161,
-0.0111012477,
0.0051117055,
0.0199952982,
-0.0527383536,
0.0114077451,
-0.0024974474,
-0.0732465833,
0.0190005582,
-0.0412881561,
0.0500713624,
-0.0358836986,
-0.0451680794,
0.0004745762,
-0.0491669104,
0.0164097156,
0.0278232675,
0.0355307199,
0.0237492584,
0.1006956547,
0.011466831,
-0.0071320739,
-0.0223114491,
-0.006841497,
0.007464461,
0.0680643022,
0.0422149822,
0.0163043346,
0.0124876546,
0.0518353134,
-0.0268899761,
0.0328782164,
-0.0436004698,
0.0493637323,
0.0166051649,
0.0158423372,
-0.0618086271,
0.0130732264,
-0.0191098992,
-0.0019206617,
0.0008439595,
0.0176597741,
0.0503252968,
0.0382138528,
-0.0647549927,
-0.0026324315,
0.0279838741,
-0.0203261357,
0.0085899988,
-0.0131985722,
0.0238147732,
0.0586778633,
0.0055635357,
0.0163778421,
-0.0470005572,
-0.018282881,
0.0451235212,
-0.0062530693,
0.0139265843,
-0.0004852171,
-0.0062891589,
0.0354755856,
-0.030314764,
-0.0263034087,
-0.0364781655,
-0.0214307941,
0.0290591419,
0.0093282051,
0.0487195402,
0.0229471866,
-0.0292082261,
0.0624720119,
0.0035319801,
-0.043636594,
0.0101595828,
-0.0264434498,
-0.0037766157,
0.0075905938,
0.0012443373,
-0.0198772289,
-0.051304061,
-0.0226614159,
0.0423837602,
-0.0395639129,
-0.01578236,
0.0121891443,
2.978e-7,
0.0066094114,
0.0102861123,
0.0345875807,
-0.0209842995,
-0.0204736423,
0.047724247,
-0.0016092749,
0.0471907035,
-0.027207965,
-0.0478689633,
0.0271383282,
0.0649673194,
-0.002925626,
-0.0006435368,
-0.0652792081,
0.0180401299,
0.0240386613,
-0.0382954702,
-0.0578396469,
0.0096142478,
0.0185584947,
0.0736446977,
0.0185992587,
0.0076416493,
0.008464912,
-0.0888818949,
0.061002668,
-0.0347718783,
0.020821156,
0.0111741973,
0.0301621258,
0.0347695313,
-0.0306022242,
0.012870688,
0.0065522883,
0.014293775,
0.0529671982,
0.0436913595,
-0.0582956076,
0.0235066283,
-0.0559349693,
0.0170968622,
-0.0090857595,
-0.0139325317,
0.0721226409,
-0.077038981,
0.0070027108,
-0.0282560959,
0.022259403,
-0.0014536667,
-0.0144580035,
0.0300050993,
-0.0231462847,
0.0029274041,
0.0146291023,
-0.0053336252,
-0.030550763,
-0.1064143926,
-0.0239635576,
-0.0062083751,
-0.0144671369,
0.0259129312,
0.0156233152,
-0.0109146442,
-0.0146080544,
-0.038678091,
-0.0538271479,
2.57429819e-34,
-0.0251150932,
0.0243628006,
-0.0149900271,
0.0438989438,
0.0454299487,
-0.0176924206,
-0.072724849,
0.0068073128,
-0.0047618579,
-0.0338529348,
-0.0113554103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15061v1 | The BLA Benchmark: Investigating Basic Language Abilities of Pre-Trained Multimodal Models | 2023-10-23T16:05:13 | 2023-10-23T16:05:13 | Xinyi Chen, Raquel Fernández, Sandro Pezzelle | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Despite the impressive performance achieved by pre-trained
language-and-vision models in downstream tasks, it remains an open question
whether this reflects a proper understanding of image-text interaction. In this
work, we explore to what extent they handle basic linguistic constructions --
active-passive voice, coordination, and relative clauses -- that even preschool
children can typically master. We present BLA, a novel, automatically
constructed benchmark to evaluate multimodal models on these Basic Language
Abilities. We show that different types of Transformer-based systems, such as
CLIP, ViLBERT, and BLIP2, generally struggle with BLA in a zero-shot setting,
in line with previous findings. Our experiments, in particular, show that most
of the tested models only marginally benefit when fine-tuned or prompted with
construction-specific samples. Yet, the generative BLIP2 shows promising
trends, especially in an in-context learning setting. This opens the door to
using BLA not only as an evaluation benchmark but also to improve models' basic
language abilities. | [
0.00327855,
0.0683240294,
-0.0089771682,
0.0324213915,
-0.0232975297,
-0.0099150529,
0.0352655835,
-0.0086659491,
-0.0640878752,
-0.0847982988,
-0.0635949299,
-0.0414398052,
0.0265984163,
0.0356325805,
0.0112330522,
-0.08747188,
-0.0013864397,
-0.022308629,
-0.0237524267,
0.0095939748,
0.0185768865,
0.0052140323,
-0.0439934283,
0.0615896322,
-0.0726108178,
-0.0022167757,
-0.0092639457,
0.0325510576,
0.0048162453,
-0.0119456649,
0.0015197154,
0.0631980598,
-0.0009343742,
0.0349557474,
0.0000018943,
-0.0287328381,
0.0240127668,
-0.019015491,
0.0287811086,
-0.0188277289,
0.0639012232,
-0.0459193103,
-0.0159203205,
-0.0134562766,
-0.0394558683,
-0.0201959684,
0.0809976757,
0.0298303366,
0.0479793884,
0.0416092649,
-0.0409237742,
-0.0091097783,
0.0008619434,
-0.0199709516,
0.0294653699,
-0.0143248662,
-0.0072477292,
0.0039199456,
0.0357875414,
-0.0002438323,
-0.0598317981,
0.049364578,
0.0329930484,
-0.0298517644,
-0.023216432,
0.0325193778,
-0.021233229,
-0.0610002093,
-0.0359994918,
0.0888434649,
-0.043048352,
-0.0238609463,
-0.0269329697,
-0.0149193751,
0.0098942909,
0.0206718892,
-0.0332094356,
0.0484805591,
0.0036074927,
0.0037195936,
-0.0896107033,
0.0014690183,
-0.0060651843,
-0.031261839,
0.0088780476,
0.006090764,
0.0211490169,
0.0331471488,
-0.018823117,
0.0454321802,
-0.0062230802,
-0.0502308458,
0.007013049,
-0.002204207,
-0.0186281968,
-0.0036731174,
-0.0613561794,
-0.0294771604,
-0.021519985,
-0.0030890945,
0.0522310585,
0.0184423998,
-0.0877530575,
0.0514739826,
-0.0184155256,
0.0622879229,
-0.0105589991,
0.0719045028,
-0.0086643901,
0.0012183656,
-0.0354170911,
-0.01912334,
-0.0212074611,
-0.0166268684,
-0.0617725439,
-0.0567872636,
-0.0314522535,
-0.0073416056,
0.0018361855,
-0.0206285119,
0.0082058441,
0.0269593857,
-0.032899987,
-0.0149734588,
-0.0136630721,
0.0323968418,
0.0125096301,
0.0507184044,
-0.0109547479,
-0.0627354458,
-0.0093863523,
0.0333282948,
0.0347465463,
-0.0155353909,
-0.0273939427,
0.0611079223,
-0.0602486655,
-0.0661853626,
0.0157800466,
0.0197875965,
-0.0511855893,
-0.0628221557,
0.0498218425,
-0.0406947248,
0.0242808796,
-0.00004664,
0.0117400512,
-0.0272230562,
0.0063685142,
0.0184706207,
0.0052094343,
0.0838619024,
0.0274928063,
-0.0098729189,
-0.0010738202,
0.0185947325,
0.0051173251,
0.0673742369,
0.0371771231,
-0.000231578,
0.005564265,
0.0085206237,
0.0251913406,
0.0730172098,
-0.021076683,
-0.0176042542,
-0.0345427506,
-0.0377138704,
-0.009074769,
0.015613188,
0.0236277562,
0.0453667529,
-0.029524399,
-0.0202588793,
0.1113244146,
0.0506052896,
-0.0308758728,
-0.0276192892,
0.0560763292,
0.0041601872,
0.0229624007,
-0.002865656,
-0.037955597,
0.0476638302,
0.0091667362,
-0.0130251879,
-0.0335985832,
0.0629833564,
-0.0293169059,
-0.025859803,
-0.0199593659,
-0.022224294,
0.0142810736,
-0.0113505647,
0.0534216054,
0.0841321275,
-0.0528697744,
0.0425029844,
-0.0120390262,
-0.0613769852,
-0.0134674935,
-0.0282912739,
-0.0215161555,
-0.0198374428,
0.0215341076,
0.0175771434,
-0.007664436,
0.0061242981,
0.0191378444,
0.0963444039,
-0.0170887168,
0.0231763069,
0.0624267235,
-0.0375356749,
-0.0306968428,
-0.0283704903,
0.034583386,
-0.0032842231,
0.0047407737,
-0.0086742826,
-0.0081667816,
-0.0194100197,
0.0313985422,
0.0653372034,
0.0225144513,
0.0100594237,
-0.0408779904,
0.0174423587,
-0.0060557742,
-0.020226175,
-0.0132008595,
-0.0131678665,
0.0204896107,
-0.017331738,
0.0069036498,
0.0739582554,
-0.0333894119,
-0.0543632582,
0.0130342143,
-0.0538517348,
-0.0090240166,
0.029548252,
-0.0073641911,
-0.0170112159,
0.014049463,
-0.0215375703,
0.0180210005,
-0.0351452157,
0.0301085562,
-0.0037832025,
0.0218230914,
-0.0183540098,
0.0184131972,
-0.020288486,
-0.0084778219,
0.0071106455,
0.0010847688,
-0.0048132348,
-0.006772765,
-0.0391264334,
0.013121997,
-0.0106064454,
0.0157784279,
0.0094901165,
0.0159893911,
-0.0505188443,
-0.0195648521,
-0.073070094,
-0.0423798859,
-0.025865918,
-0.0297932029,
0.016582327,
-0.0141165284,
0.0050039729,
-0.0322975293,
-0.0018273453,
0.0292898398,
0.0055494863,
-0.0048483694,
0.0257648434,
0.0066278791,
0.0186347961,
-0.0335430615,
0.0138809914,
0.0200348161,
0.0703741685,
0.021778455,
-0.0048157792,
-0.0069605862,
-0.0060516121,
-0.006350243,
0.0135184946,
-0.0269134883,
-0.0398894772,
0.059769921,
-0.0177936684,
0.0617973618,
0.0757185742,
0.0000246192,
0.0356988497,
0.0114861913,
-0.0170107186,
-0.0405644886,
-0.0061143809,
-0.0168066006,
-0.0390017219,
-0.0478003696,
0.0111101801,
-0.0046923133,
0.0928628668,
-0.007106198,
0.0411418937,
-0.079865776,
0.0406007171,
-0.0036073115,
-0.0609181523,
-0.035668686,
0.0160897933,
-0.0218886938,
0.0217766389,
-0.0525584593,
-0.0558865853,
0.009482665,
-0.0578110144,
-0.0694508553,
0.0172889829,
0.0407262705,
0.0105775492,
0.0761410892,
0.0584914349,
0.0196553599,
-0.0058798864,
-0.0046274774,
-0.0850339755,
0.0144706666,
0.0080715148,
0.0048796153,
0.0405056253,
-0.0378863923,
0.0010490654,
-0.0094528524,
-0.035899017,
-0.0286355577,
-0.0115837064,
-0.0263333432,
-0.0076911547,
-0.0159701519,
-0.0458354875,
-0.0316035338,
0.0156067442,
0.03305424,
0.0557000227,
0.0065405653,
-0.0262566321,
-0.0210639797,
0.0298531111,
0.036334157,
0.0064974949,
-0.0285965968,
-0.0638653114,
-0.0158427693,
0.0626781806,
0.0006074937,
-0.0209120773,
-0.061394114,
0.0347597413,
0.0247399025,
0.0590292849,
0.0043652789,
0.0240582284,
0.0727155358,
-0.033085119,
-0.0077980021,
0.0218071695,
0.0132014668,
-0.0138061177,
-0.0095580863,
0.0022352452,
0.0279046278,
0.0101091564,
-0.0138028981,
-0.0783904791,
-0.0599530414,
-0.0044263271,
-0.024001142,
0.0455487818,
0.0072505651,
-0.0216220319,
-0.1057752073,
0.0462790988,
-0.014609199,
-0.0313500352,
0.0099855214,
0.0465436354,
0.0286562908,
0.0017878732,
-0.0009766348,
-0.0066088494,
-0.0065783886,
-0.0023525285,
-0.0059635574,
0.0140877105,
-0.0624155551,
0.0110218609,
0.0015465997,
-0.0123336231,
0.0221023522,
0.0078013805,
-0.006713348,
-0.033065062,
0.034699142,
0.0247974358,
0.0006188567,
0.0139674433,
0.0678092837,
-0.0197401438,
-0.0415367708,
0.017414799,
0.0254703909,
0.0127557069,
-0.0462460741,
-0.0450131148,
0.0006520368,
-0.0044995481,
-0.034244366,
-0.0162789002,
0.0257336963,
0.0095419725,
0.0281586889,
0.0239004008,
-0.0641319677,
-0.0274130534,
0.0017113801,
-0.0022043248,
-0.0619427636,
-0.0696955249,
0.0082551669,
0.0243611187,
-0.0069650891,
-0.0875917077,
-0.01516678,
0.0415742844,
0.0608944558,
-0.0153780505,
-0.0481963009,
0.0005175819,
0.0293238424,
-0.0316776894,
0.0754936263,
0.0095290607,
0.028660154,
-0.0691681355,
-0.0105187893,
0.0322015099,
-0.0452657565,
-0.0283793397,
0.011779869,
-0.1105309278,
-0.0414794758,
0.005371572,
0.0803933218,
0.0216864031,
0.0297126938,
0.0025120515,
-0.0356843211,
0.0384346545,
0.0587205961,
-0.0053989878,
0.0396154597,
0.0212280825,
-0.049353905,
-0.0130106276,
0.0153881526,
-0.0287171807,
0.0361753739,
0.0146866944,
0.0168370232,
-0.032928858,
-0.0417307876,
0.0123940883,
-0.0410159566,
0.0720739141,
-0.0277598668,
0.024166232,
-0.0306738298,
0.0003137148,
-0.0202425662,
0.0242503081,
-0.1061496511,
-0.0003572738,
0.0181497149,
0.0528915823,
0.0181732755,
0.0103204232,
-0.0073990212,
0.048491925,
-0.0223787948,
0.0213007983,
0.0094173383,
-0.0058523128,
0.0098188287,
0.049014695,
0.0273293611,
0.0314109586,
-0.0252286606,
0.0499493964,
-0.0013897992,
0.0648740456,
0.0194888078,
-0.0204866305,
-0.0135831116,
0.0396882184,
-0.0339238197,
0.0018788356,
-0.0430219918,
0.0159578472,
0.0626498163,
-0.0163453668,
0.0561797917,
-0.0330795422,
-0.0127765602,
-0.006553127,
0.0666297004,
0.0192669798,
-0.0425813384,
0.0441603586,
-0.0068440833,
0.0061664353,
-0.0085733663,
0.0525529534,
-0.0082549807,
0.0161403362,
-0.0066994005,
0.0394276865,
-0.0493898652,
-0.0520608798,
0.0404173471,
-0.0157866683,
0.0081290314,
0.0414225757,
-0.0286752246,
-0.0551848039,
0.0061207516,
0.0233143307,
-0.0082362425,
-0.008765948,
0.0554689467,
0.0243579,
0.0095002446,
0.0042954911,
-0.0150358658,
-0.0444592014,
0.0336333402,
0.0168980155,
0.0126272598,
-5.84812517e-33,
-0.051418446,
-0.0300144348,
0.0185129214,
0.0054581151,
0.0038791443,
0.025968492,
-0.0422933884,
0.0462835655,
0.0031594636,
0.024629565,
0.0127088185,
-0.0042770319,
0.0182121359,
0.0398209542,
-0.0261442903,
0.0043365434,
0.0338781066,
-0.0251373425,
-0.0210149121,
-0.0344087407,
0.02772847,
0.0051511386,
0.0636828318,
-0.0345275961,
-0.0289671086,
0.0216112416,
-0.076938957,
0.0033470534,
0.0047505768,
0.0743084401,
-0.0008697673,
-0.0011921377,
-0.0035020614,
-0.0022747952,
-0.0333170556,
0.0321538523,
-0.0516510755,
0.0148362964,
-0.0020299142,
0.0544909239,
-0.1055800691,
0.0385965593,
0.0442251526,
-0.0299501009,
-0.0068450952,
-0.0323842838,
0.0512597375,
-0.0139357969,
0.0128414398,
-0.0039620879,
-0.0817342252,
-0.0017694533,
-0.0198648535,
-0.0408838056,
0.0424812287,
0.0645953119,
0.0079610869,
0.0060266093,
-0.054135412,
0.022406416,
-0.0265533198,
0.0272430945,
0.0768659115,
0.0540545583,
0.0026679642,
0.0712056607,
0.0124308448,
-0.0220994987,
-0.0229564197,
-0.0014568319,
0.0815814137,
0.0572562031,
0.031814944,
0.085367389,
0.0273112766,
0.0283778477,
-0.0324910879,
0.019012725,
-0.0092533892,
0.0457098186,
0.0005501137,
0.0061304253,
0.0125799375,
0.0177480243,
-0.0431298167,
-0.0047816858,
-0.0309923142,
-0.0080802236,
0.0490258746,
0.0289237984,
0.0171821043,
-0.0031522596,
0.0737954602,
-0.0152270477,
-0.017606562,
0.0049939724,
-0.0471580587,
0.0751448497,
-0.0126558421,
0.0113966595,
-0.0359685309,
-0.015421587,
0.0726982132,
0.0555164777,
0.0310110766,
0.0257756636,
0.045132108,
0.0302147791,
-0.0508578569,
-0.0081425393,
-0.0145230843,
0.0275280569,
-0.0071358662,
0.0454005152,
0.0483975038,
-0.0106484778,
-0.0895693377,
0.026036825,
-0.0300321504,
-0.0254587922,
-0.0396655053,
-0.0177546293,
0.0029054137,
0.0225846283,
-0.0300196633,
0.0032864173,
-0.0404160619,
-0.0122551294,
0.0534721427,
-0.0563676581,
-0.0228511691,
0.0381324664,
2.54e-7,
0.064926438,
0.0267035775,
-0.0019511562,
0.0181652103,
0.0092459684,
0.0443861224,
-0.0489241667,
0.0201179143,
0.0010898019,
0.0008628782,
-0.0138904341,
0.0306260958,
0.0712146685,
-0.0073446599,
-0.0394336805,
0.0076207626,
-0.0501326658,
0.0033964931,
-0.0338801518,
-0.0040668463,
0.0455647968,
0.0445639268,
-0.035351906,
-0.0227661226,
0.01850852,
-0.0434329398,
0.0873366743,
-0.0265642907,
0.0127047505,
-0.0141249876,
-0.0080825565,
-0.0029430697,
-0.0156679396,
0.0145069417,
-0.0274640117,
-0.0081453109,
0.0560223758,
0.0362543985,
-0.0284549035,
-0.0411546156,
-0.0035869014,
0.0545391142,
-0.0325203016,
-0.0379897542,
0.0510031469,
-0.0990027264,
-0.0004329795,
-0.0045860447,
-0.035363771,
0.0118329488,
0.0167186651,
-0.0185459573,
-0.0586797819,
0.0213832613,
0.0472714417,
-0.003050915,
-0.0460375622,
-0.0755601004,
-0.0681013241,
0.000867645,
-0.0359581523,
-0.029875299,
-0.0632148013,
-0.0225022044,
0.0176372193,
0.0041561471,
-0.0455893613,
1.905363729e-34,
0.0063614543,
-0.0008966256,
0.0422650315,
-0.0028842378,
0.0011016885,
0.0053237076,
0.0166640505,
0.0078088846,
-0.0150162196,
-0.0394682847,
0.0003607196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15055v1 | Towards Conceptualization of "Fair Explanation": Disparate Impacts of anti-Asian Hate Speech Explanations on Content Moderators | 2023-10-23T15:57:41 | 2023-10-23T15:57:41 | Tin Nguyen, Jiannan Xu, Aayushi Roy, Hal Daumé III, Marine Carpuat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Recent research at the intersection of AI explainability and fairness has
focused on how explanations can improve human-plus-AI task performance as
assessed by fairness measures. We propose to characterize what constitutes an
explanation that is itself "fair" -- an explanation that does not adversely
impact specific populations. We formulate a novel evaluation method of "fair
explanations" using not just accuracy and label time, but also psychological
impact of explanations on different user groups across many metrics (mental
discomfort, stereotype activation, and perceived workload). We apply this
method in the context of content moderation of potential hate speech, and its
differential impact on Asian vs. non-Asian proxy moderators, across explanation
approaches (saliency map and counterfactual explanation). We find that saliency
maps generally perform better and show less evidence of disparate impact
(group) and individual unfairness than counterfactual explanations.
Content warning: This paper contains examples of hate speech and racially
discriminatory language. The authors do not support such content. Please
consider your risk of discomfort carefully before continuing reading! | [
0.0791688487,
0.0437135659,
-0.049055066,
0.0018140671,
0.0268460661,
0.0299365129,
0.0977409557,
0.0004991379,
-0.0159688871,
-0.0226790346,
0.0200385153,
-0.0015951084,
0.0141970655,
-0.0152165601,
0.0010723755,
-0.0763830021,
-0.0166934822,
0.0402812064,
0.0653890222,
-0.0023130167,
0.0485721566,
0.0058351029,
0.0177209228,
0.0645332187,
-0.03513401,
0.0012348988,
0.0341086537,
-0.0126684867,
0.0363583341,
0.014443703,
-0.0132488767,
0.0196609311,
-0.0024485048,
0.0122095076,
0.0000019801,
-0.0361820944,
0.0006077352,
0.0015767268,
-0.0187441614,
0.020866463,
0.0215928983,
-0.029055642,
0.0126036983,
0.0429851487,
0.0284721255,
0.0551490188,
0.0344340466,
0.0309355576,
0.0482548028,
-0.0028766815,
-0.0164642427,
-0.0074425801,
-0.0694928691,
0.0062937136,
0.003824675,
0.0081240721,
0.0143863596,
-0.046649307,
-0.0694966689,
-0.0704482719,
-0.0315366723,
-0.0265009739,
0.0381265581,
-0.0040248875,
0.0265495833,
-0.0429771952,
0.0074760253,
-0.0276444033,
0.0192274116,
0.0472620577,
0.0262387972,
0.0193410013,
0.0144820549,
-0.0069948626,
0.024304999,
0.0354181491,
-0.0366966911,
0.0040239496,
-0.0380874351,
0.0033997616,
0.0208815038,
0.012429365,
0.0567028299,
0.0671278089,
0.0476150736,
0.0478328206,
-0.0208291281,
-0.0248699561,
-0.0468832068,
-0.0202405266,
0.0195338819,
-0.0215153079,
0.0340167955,
0.0370591506,
-0.047798954,
0.0171122551,
0.0274225567,
-0.0361392796,
0.0055508944,
-0.0622189119,
0.0230412129,
0.0645218045,
-0.033253178,
0.0147440946,
0.0503966287,
0.0857812911,
-0.0182661209,
0.0507332124,
0.0095838914,
-0.01411313,
-0.0012015484,
0.0191417038,
0.0243913084,
-0.0490183011,
-0.0250499006,
0.0584549829,
-0.0281561054,
-0.0192965679,
-0.0816588029,
-0.0203524902,
0.0073172804,
-0.0019753492,
-0.0122706639,
0.0038801765,
-0.0619552508,
-0.0000667043,
-0.106323719,
0.006153943,
0.008385173,
-0.0419998802,
-0.0118249413,
0.0396609679,
-0.0358209647,
-0.0110406475,
0.0026654026,
0.0312196594,
0.0486201234,
0.0203263406,
-0.0445741527,
-0.0223729592,
-0.015867969,
-0.0581920929,
-0.0070978589,
-0.0046118246,
0.0126760835,
-0.0045779017,
-0.0258626007,
-0.0406256467,
-0.012251473,
-0.0065997625,
-0.0235796906,
0.0741384029,
0.0159837641,
0.0244604908,
0.0289263669,
0.0675256103,
-0.0590117052,
0.0412585661,
-0.0031615421,
0.0372697189,
0.0419465825,
-0.0479542501,
0.0121902125,
-0.0217143837,
0.0098000458,
0.0233690739,
-0.0283936411,
0.0143312607,
-0.0877314806,
-0.0093868906,
0.0227399357,
0.0306887124,
-0.0100788837,
-0.0031325964,
0.0145666692,
0.0622350238,
-0.0369343832,
0.0501401909,
0.0502998792,
-0.0049194461,
-0.0486828163,
0.0315201618,
-0.095842734,
0.0181981791,
-0.0069818241,
-0.0510100387,
0.0493063889,
0.0471298099,
-0.0467997901,
-0.0660474449,
-0.0268478002,
-0.0013741176,
0.0763381571,
0.0005522142,
0.0075839753,
-0.0040833247,
0.0105136083,
-0.0000049291,
0.0422326773,
0.0157620031,
0.0247450303,
-0.0703167021,
0.0142938057,
0.0683820844,
-0.0141431419,
-0.0249558799,
0.0280372445,
-0.0432279147,
0.0140319187,
0.0466707684,
0.0767413303,
0.0027319076,
-0.0142105855,
-0.0200895146,
-0.030245604,
-0.0007655043,
0.0349915996,
0.0430931896,
0.0379438959,
0.0127650723,
-0.000033174,
0.003626382,
-0.0436895527,
0.0194156859,
0.04306053,
-0.0265842229,
-0.0356055237,
0.0183272455,
0.0558033586,
0.028392639,
-0.0071609351,
-0.0157805569,
-0.0284717493,
0.008185436,
-0.0300140213,
0.0508215576,
-0.0523205958,
0.0632654652,
0.0196033232,
-0.0444788523,
-0.0016657856,
0.0304729603,
0.0107802153,
0.0264462754,
0.0512154289,
0.0426757559,
-0.0400944799,
-0.0134883467,
-0.0072856313,
-0.0614866503,
0.0209564939,
-0.0246884059,
0.0467799157,
-0.0279770903,
0.0301255099,
0.0520435236,
-0.0674466789,
0.0317292288,
0.0353882834,
-0.0044648284,
-0.0212237742,
-0.0395928062,
-0.0106851999,
-0.0031227495,
-0.032645233,
-0.019283969,
0.0519598462,
-0.0718416274,
-0.0317388736,
-0.0414959639,
-0.0100333085,
0.0219310708,
-0.0029107982,
-0.0134306643,
0.0013206064,
0.0040354007,
-0.0475077815,
0.0040924735,
0.0390193574,
0.0029372957,
-0.0293295383,
-0.046930287,
-0.038772095,
-0.0258291345,
-0.0338761099,
0.0032844907,
0.0578973517,
-0.0248495266,
-0.0233131368,
-0.053910356,
-0.0564012714,
-0.0251598302,
-0.0175549462,
-0.0560173206,
0.0340130143,
0.0549267121,
-0.0260310099,
0.0200143717,
0.0506803878,
0.1017288044,
0.0424282178,
0.0343394466,
-0.000729481,
-0.0149735175,
0.0069220741,
0.0128142638,
-0.0168991014,
-0.058165241,
-0.0100124851,
0.0840025842,
0.0386236757,
-0.0009871472,
-0.0741031542,
-0.000482293,
-0.0964476317,
-0.0708116367,
-0.021312369,
-0.1006212011,
-0.0072086486,
0.04487231,
-0.0541281328,
-0.0511661842,
0.0663298815,
0.0034050543,
0.0235776566,
0.0073269713,
-0.0105319023,
-0.0237630736,
0.032915961,
-0.0544235259,
0.0373547152,
-0.0019389188,
-0.0222060718,
0.0108992914,
-0.0691019669,
0.0776913241,
-0.0271060504,
-0.0281041712,
-0.0274490602,
-0.0288890377,
-0.0031958537,
-0.0282884669,
-0.0517686009,
-0.0500019304,
-0.0282731466,
-0.0071084583,
0.0368195474,
-0.0080631059,
-0.0249919165,
0.045074746,
0.0448272675,
-0.0368024036,
0.0101668555,
-0.0059474288,
0.0532844104,
-0.1054362655,
-0.0267638471,
0.0731020719,
0.0569177903,
-0.0360159539,
0.0215312093,
0.016981557,
0.0002062552,
-0.0063683004,
0.0430728942,
0.0151362959,
0.0046699564,
-0.0075861076,
0.0021421115,
0.0076061445,
0.0695063993,
-0.0139860893,
0.0384146273,
0.0753307194,
0.0251420606,
-0.0381691754,
-0.0097523276,
-0.0341839083,
-0.027837567,
0.0155930109,
-0.0153941717,
-0.0598138869,
-0.0028136317,
0.0229768734,
0.0428808145,
-0.069501467,
-0.030912295,
0.0277754609,
-0.0054808855,
0.0342280418,
-0.0060115536,
-0.02435592,
-0.0766101852,
-0.0489571691,
0.0084881168,
-0.0041029099,
0.023760207,
-0.0284792203,
0.0812143162,
0.0063025812,
0.0256399866,
-0.0370103382,
0.0066709556,
0.0041223653,
-0.0392746888,
0.0126808304,
0.0066793286,
0.0333522484,
-0.0066196583,
-0.0086957486,
0.0235314947,
0.0046862466,
0.002151289,
-0.0292986967,
0.056895785,
0.0133762453,
-0.0217970312,
-0.0450330116,
0.0490570255,
0.0008886794,
0.0175268184,
0.0038473685,
0.0608321689,
0.0575182438,
-0.0004452434,
-0.0354583189,
0.0000141087,
0.0108593265,
0.0681006983,
0.0601332635,
-0.0424952395,
0.0320245624,
-0.0912458226,
0.001725252,
-0.0275827255,
-0.0679674596,
0.018248817,
0.0288358666,
-0.0224680994,
0.0072769905,
-0.0546140373,
-0.0267502293,
0.0000395805,
0.044804275,
-0.0317753553,
-0.0262017623,
-0.0299067255,
-0.0071602268,
0.0216502808,
0.0122625185,
0.0385697484,
0.0337913744,
-0.0134900073,
-0.0797444135,
-0.0232825186,
-0.0065366733,
0.0076217838,
0.0336676128,
-0.0122493356,
0.0594783016,
0.0215807669,
0.0203070454,
0.0215655491,
-0.0107869646,
-0.0312374234,
-0.003014503,
0.0016845881,
-0.0112098986,
-0.0155781405,
0.0523384809,
-0.0093843509,
0.0322332755,
0.0109330211,
-0.0150295654,
0.0289270878,
0.034321323,
-0.0223686229,
0.002178299,
0.0059878197,
0.0065232562,
-0.0061866976,
0.0144162411,
-0.0234805699,
-0.0816687495,
-0.0119597288,
-0.0379575193,
0.0087715043,
-0.0459471121,
0.0179184657,
-0.0224832334,
-0.0065481588,
-0.0228504706,
-0.0236345343,
0.0170156825,
-0.0385377444,
-0.0379700102,
-0.048695121,
0.0523315072,
-0.0235476959,
0.0342155136,
-0.0310362447,
0.0282586645,
-0.0105106467,
0.011923505,
-0.0013964985,
-0.0032681446,
0.021760907,
0.0640720949,
0.0324732475,
0.033563707,
0.0290828329,
-0.0560693927,
-0.0101476703,
-0.0417223424,
0.0455984883,
-0.0146719366,
0.0106475065,
-0.0335281454,
0.0009726083,
0.0471734889,
-0.0194390062,
-0.0007993544,
0.0267948247,
0.0227494687,
-0.0061785681,
0.0228853058,
0.020356074,
-0.0068429923,
0.0018665814,
0.0013220276,
-0.0280947369,
0.0217209794,
-0.0110932663,
-0.065217942,
0.0173013657,
-0.0159019232,
-0.0138753839,
0.0611704588,
0.0088066133,
-0.0073035234,
-0.0974501669,
-0.0306007136,
-0.0557692274,
-0.0338189043,
0.0184888709,
-0.0327691734,
-0.0305939447,
0.0713885203,
-0.0143582514,
-0.0077192527,
-0.0056378213,
0.0219075438,
-0.0424877591,
-0.0066144047,
0.017950071,
-6.16967467e-33,
0.0031899989,
-0.063675724,
-0.0286810212,
-0.0195703432,
-0.0038816852,
-0.0184695087,
-0.0092064831,
0.0075609065,
-0.0432763062,
0.0359280221,
0.0012830828,
0.0204254463,
0.0082340632,
-0.0308258198,
-0.01315575,
-0.0569564998,
0.0364644378,
0.003674417,
-0.0400984921,
0.0284511633,
-0.0177210886,
-0.0122974329,
-0.0027102304,
-0.0691675842,
0.0746961087,
0.0324073322,
0.003513023,
0.0156619828,
-0.0113880215,
0.0667425841,
-0.0063575567,
0.0868514106,
0.0525525734,
-0.016245747,
0.0298767351,
0.0232127663,
-0.0641692206,
-0.005457426,
0.0797129571,
0.0018699691,
-0.0095516527,
-0.0197237022,
0.0109489011,
0.0231263135,
-0.0196220167,
-0.038372878,
0.0459723398,
-0.0120007424,
0.0182694066,
0.0067647616,
-0.0295959227,
0.0094084656,
-0.0595942885,
-0.007402468,
0.0010422643,
0.0329460762,
0.0208582189,
0.0325434469,
-0.0270370729,
-0.0152511643,
0.0035305452,
-0.039109353,
0.0226352401,
0.0126208551,
0.0033317844,
0.0375723466,
0.029352136,
0.0671595484,
-0.0893702731,
-0.0632765666,
-0.0006235838,
-0.0053719259,
0.052491378,
0.0573558956,
0.0538674556,
-0.0943156779,
-0.0395709351,
0.00214314,
0.0012226847,
0.0130916201,
0.0357440412,
-0.0028518096,
-0.0916613117,
-0.0307451952,
-0.0305403452,
-0.057126902,
-0.0557023063,
-0.0152199613,
0.038440451,
-0.0008107891,
-0.0581075661,
-0.0293491818,
0.0207278766,
-0.0377861261,
0.0565387495,
0.0399227105,
0.0322461538,
-0.0414310247,
0.0437942296,
-0.0199001823,
-0.0363001749,
0.0049687088,
-0.0246506929,
0.0089100199,
0.0565968081,
-0.0136564234,
0.0236232113,
0.0301902946,
0.003804245,
0.0148698818,
-0.0300601069,
0.0155111207,
-0.0195515137,
-0.0049909875,
0.0098335212,
0.0595803037,
-0.016374262,
-0.0486542098,
0.0673264489,
0.001718143,
-0.0147692114,
0.0040964219,
-0.0424530432,
0.0068471595,
-0.0378622748,
-0.0368722193,
0.0192171615,
-0.0060747606,
0.0291113053,
-0.0679593459,
-0.0045917598,
-0.0698636696,
2.616e-7,
-0.0085327309,
0.0093511725,
0.011032464,
-0.0131945834,
0.0425897352,
0.0257565379,
0.0430167355,
-0.0104110921,
0.0014986027,
0.0001718212,
0.0047153342,
0.0778385997,
0.0287989601,
0.0116943121,
0.0459134504,
-0.027261693,
-0.0243312232,
0.0170868859,
-0.0290184896,
0.0542023517,
0.0028514033,
0.0047556683,
0.0443078354,
-0.0004242518,
-0.0091235423,
0.0077046487,
-0.0124790287,
-0.049317684,
0.0372538753,
-0.0309295636,
0.0798791721,
0.0253030974,
0.0239639282,
-0.0082112616,
0.0260368753,
0.0129624503,
-0.0018234409,
0.0202369634,
0.0202459656,
0.0177732706,
-0.0236927234,
-0.0014534545,
0.0349034816,
-0.0717163831,
0.0399821699,
0.0168121979,
-0.0532074235,
-0.0329758786,
-0.018865196,
-0.0376895256,
0.0221410785,
0.0174200665,
-0.0256117918,
-0.0187883601,
-0.005537265,
0.0045365901,
0.0232962333,
-0.0519163758,
-0.0339685269,
-0.0445792452,
-0.0065281116,
-0.0176422168,
-0.0241804514,
-0.0374962874,
0.0142688612,
0.0282410439,
0.0506368801,
2.094585144e-34,
0.015772555,
0.0095946733,
0.0085961465,
-0.0362400934,
0.0324976519,
0.030262975,
-0.0452160388,
-0.046585314,
0.0556802191,
0.0047028298,
-0.0376175046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15040v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15040v1 | SLOG: A Structural Generalization Benchmark for Semantic Parsing | 2023-10-23T15:39:09 | 2023-10-23T15:39:09 | Bingzhi Li, Lucia Donatelli, Alexander Koller, Tal Linzen, Yuekun Yao, Najoung Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | The goal of compositional generalization benchmarks is to evaluate how well
models generalize to new complex linguistic expressions. Existing benchmarks
often focus on lexical generalization, the interpretation of novel lexical
items in syntactic structures familiar from training; structural generalization
tasks, where a model needs to interpret syntactic structures that are
themselves unfamiliar from training, are often underrepresented, resulting in
overly optimistic perceptions of how well models can generalize. We introduce
SLOG, a semantic parsing dataset that extends COGS (Kim and Linzen, 2020) with
17 structural generalization cases. In our experiments, the generalization
accuracy of Transformer models, including pretrained ones, only reaches 40.6%,
while a structure-aware parser only achieves 70.8%. These results are far from
the near-perfect accuracy existing models achieve on COGS, demonstrating the
role of SLOG in foregrounding the large discrepancy between models' lexical and
structural generalization capacities. | [
0.0376557112,
0.0442064553,
0.0187598448,
0.0174219087,
0.0201922748,
0.0441418625,
-0.0298049934,
-0.0335515887,
-0.057625968,
-0.0273851939,
-0.0309482832,
0.0114070065,
-0.0425527953,
0.019117061,
0.0190734807,
-0.0408164263,
0.0542053021,
0.0092753507,
-0.0117606353,
0.0250573773,
-0.0000055528,
0.0150026316,
0.0258114692,
0.0364158936,
-0.042125836,
-0.0224379674,
-0.0116918404,
0.0058000199,
-0.0172727983,
-0.0310244672,
0.0243095085,
0.0117623955,
0.0002255608,
0.0175960511,
0.0000018803,
-0.056375172,
-0.0442943946,
0.0106079616,
-0.0094620995,
-0.0218475722,
0.0355825014,
-0.101238355,
0.0174413081,
-0.024296822,
-0.0468145311,
-0.0618401505,
0.035685882,
0.0429418087,
0.052533105,
0.0994417071,
-0.0192618296,
-0.072748214,
0.0115134111,
-0.0324604809,
-0.0014418248,
-0.0263185203,
-0.0066123963,
0.0277524665,
-0.0441531241,
-0.0214320868,
-0.0432792902,
0.0159034207,
0.0233551972,
0.0064193509,
0.0160297994,
0.01827324,
-0.0504135713,
-0.0263544526,
0.0113673164,
0.0508138202,
-0.0036144038,
-0.0310119037,
-0.0007768833,
-0.001169908,
0.015108862,
-0.0076946756,
-0.058010608,
0.0305574276,
-0.0188907236,
0.0299363192,
0.0478524491,
-0.0159661416,
0.0294259749,
0.0057115112,
-0.0260838978,
0.09089946,
0.0065557002,
-0.0230997577,
0.0395293497,
0.0505758598,
-0.0355562866,
-0.0156564526,
0.0039872988,
-0.0046701338,
-0.0528509766,
0.0073752506,
-0.0335480087,
-0.0466248468,
-0.0118943006,
-0.0196624137,
0.029608462,
0.0349897705,
-0.005629661,
0.0470112786,
-0.0397076048,
0.0691647828,
-0.0400070623,
0.0601228923,
-0.0679169372,
-0.020633895,
-0.0725391954,
-0.0045199487,
-0.05808869,
0.0700874627,
-0.0340002403,
-0.0194378905,
-0.0392150916,
0.0045583234,
-0.0073764701,
0.0244143121,
0.0407113805,
0.0235500988,
-0.0789411888,
0.0123084616,
0.0225996356,
0.0200070199,
-0.0345269553,
0.0095734568,
0.0141992243,
-0.038371332,
-0.0249733962,
0.0051532337,
0.0213822331,
-0.0403144248,
-0.0059459144,
0.0372850262,
-0.0224941876,
-0.0055892579,
-0.0185715836,
-0.0188832711,
-0.0172797274,
-0.0228521544,
0.0298616365,
-0.0464703701,
0.0306005422,
0.0147383278,
0.023790786,
-0.0084108124,
-0.0174950026,
0.0002882244,
0.0019212239,
0.0323157571,
0.0112175774,
-0.0206092577,
-0.0314808153,
0.0020307514,
-0.0289512146,
0.0506730787,
-0.0075995359,
-0.0226347819,
0.0186074954,
-0.0096615078,
-0.0393812433,
0.027020853,
-0.0200549774,
-0.0283879805,
0.0186148174,
-0.0010287263,
-0.0107770683,
0.0012180313,
0.0305055473,
0.0310253445,
-0.0394372791,
-0.0262781214,
-0.0089502214,
0.0216906238,
0.0053355815,
0.0284828208,
0.0821672305,
-0.0044609192,
-0.0064497809,
0.0133449584,
-0.0748800114,
-0.0633657947,
-0.0065815398,
0.0334876478,
-0.074430868,
0.014892363,
-0.0179482736,
-0.0125972955,
-0.0061158803,
-0.020083461,
0.0270240866,
-0.0575937703,
0.0610470399,
0.0886031911,
-0.0064249928,
0.0724125057,
0.0356150828,
-0.0640684962,
0.0090459445,
0.0122182835,
0.0190095399,
0.0044476911,
0.0250244532,
-0.0301059745,
-0.0356330127,
-0.0068816887,
0.0223176051,
0.0047803223,
0.0336013511,
-0.0248050056,
0.0572050251,
-0.0276765004,
-0.007684906,
-0.0345084034,
0.0428033471,
-0.0059510795,
0.0173382685,
-0.0561351776,
0.0283477679,
-0.0582856089,
0.0043509444,
0.0519387461,
-0.0071660588,
0.0006850121,
-0.0212558452,
-0.0244840942,
0.012783125,
0.0131400349,
-0.0001342001,
0.0092959646,
0.0220952723,
-0.048772078,
-0.0288179088,
0.0420138761,
-0.0653508678,
-0.0472311638,
0.033132609,
-0.0581112877,
-0.0165978577,
0.0422465317,
-0.0741049051,
-0.0268236622,
0.0176277328,
0.0022965674,
0.0622444898,
-0.0006796691,
0.0265727751,
0.0233465396,
-0.0095326845,
-0.039988704,
0.0487519056,
-0.0115268324,
0.0112956725,
-0.0193430632,
-0.0198716428,
0.0064551695,
-0.0312301144,
-0.0522432737,
0.0136677409,
-0.0432939939,
-0.0448787659,
0.0081780981,
0.0223175045,
-0.0808222219,
0.0017073209,
-0.0703482181,
-0.0084194122,
-0.0303550344,
0.040715266,
0.0760017186,
0.0075172586,
0.0254736841,
-0.0300463345,
-0.0094254268,
-0.0102550332,
0.0042113243,
0.0079756901,
0.0343062356,
0.0050210361,
-0.0263615865,
-0.0431795418,
-0.0280794837,
-0.0343171805,
0.0678279623,
0.0105814394,
-0.0114785992,
-0.0106694382,
0.0077585592,
-0.0015412249,
0.0214935448,
-0.0098821018,
-0.0127423443,
0.0057756943,
-0.0444823429,
-0.0124552315,
0.0386434756,
-0.053461697,
0.0007920566,
-0.006774548,
-0.0120674744,
-0.064438507,
0.006012796,
-0.0248197541,
0.0000899008,
-0.0807706341,
0.0031759986,
0.0199966319,
0.1292195171,
-0.0027827285,
0.0286606904,
-0.0229205899,
-0.013092787,
-0.0649256408,
-0.0235210396,
0.0042748251,
-0.0100678904,
-0.003556062,
-0.0017316864,
-0.0437463485,
-0.0078364331,
0.0341426022,
-0.0064004669,
-0.0534916557,
-0.0385521539,
0.006467009,
-0.0466150679,
0.0762565061,
0.040476948,
0.0010483388,
0.0250513405,
-0.0587098636,
-0.0327245556,
0.0009022183,
0.0309401546,
0.0127621749,
0.0723575428,
-0.0362818502,
0.0111539317,
-0.0016426821,
-0.0466807373,
-0.0204211473,
-0.0222251285,
-0.0485933684,
-0.0046250885,
0.021082256,
0.0016897338,
-0.011938341,
-0.0387884565,
-0.0418171957,
0.048787158,
0.0184777342,
-0.0241991505,
-0.0258015953,
0.0238416791,
0.0205614194,
0.0246569291,
-0.0031919968,
-0.0119659575,
0.0160037819,
0.0744527429,
0.0034096409,
-0.0215142313,
-0.0723353624,
0.0230129957,
0.0034062902,
-0.0262965821,
-0.052526515,
-0.0211195536,
0.0593735017,
-0.0527428612,
-0.0327737741,
0.095686473,
0.0447776504,
0.0077151111,
0.0345021077,
-0.0015982798,
0.0412165001,
0.0480177626,
0.0039542913,
-0.0871833265,
-0.0505896322,
0.0323914662,
-0.0293385442,
0.0207688175,
-0.0445682779,
0.0244000163,
-0.0938262716,
0.0021333257,
0.0055009867,
-0.009549994,
0.0282172486,
0.0101892473,
-0.0112691326,
-0.0811606869,
-0.0009891866,
0.0019987361,
-0.0433290042,
0.0248108897,
0.0267534219,
-0.0464914106,
-0.002151934,
0.0021845764,
-0.0423680209,
-0.0137349693,
0.0439766683,
-0.0349309109,
-0.0160210244,
-0.0046037892,
0.083247222,
0.0305394139,
0.0277568623,
-0.0124649657,
0.0200977456,
0.0118561117,
-0.0083055878,
0.0256733485,
0.0330591798,
-0.0613171943,
-0.0149150938,
-0.0125625618,
0.0461004712,
0.0186796114,
-0.0210696515,
0.0114693092,
-0.0068545369,
-0.0423995443,
0.0507193841,
0.0288579985,
-0.0029365085,
-0.0523847453,
-0.0707263947,
0.0174291227,
-0.044481758,
0.0221424326,
0.0530316792,
0.0381270014,
0.0067285709,
-0.0808954909,
-0.0455273464,
0.0243764501,
-0.0147642074,
-0.0281802677,
-0.0431783237,
0.0105065918,
-0.0358741693,
-0.0194465797,
0.0605893694,
-0.0276660714,
-0.00624855,
-0.0500579625,
0.0206279904,
0.011504828,
0.0093870033,
-0.0715256557,
-0.0270237233,
-0.085382469,
-0.044936195,
0.0529572032,
0.0486849472,
0.0198531691,
0.0446498729,
-0.0354148783,
-0.010673617,
-0.0212470908,
-0.0018124337,
-0.0563188978,
0.0409859531,
0.0663933009,
-0.0136661958,
0.0272675529,
0.0339197181,
-0.0265993588,
0.0263410639,
0.0125661492,
0.0449672602,
0.0067819268,
0.0403753407,
0.0652361885,
0.0406522825,
0.0339659676,
0.0304146875,
0.0754235387,
0.001566988,
0.0179565735,
-0.0099231284,
-0.0155678866,
-0.069039911,
-0.0043019117,
0.066333808,
0.0148644224,
0.0088661006,
0.0366822705,
-0.0191517677,
0.0703860149,
-0.0704176202,
-0.0093082581,
0.0586440302,
-0.0295388084,
0.0087564532,
0.0125914225,
-0.0104778325,
0.0184035171,
-0.0072898176,
0.0104088839,
-0.0208771694,
-0.0094384532,
0.0154171223,
0.0355511121,
-0.045096565,
-0.0112250242,
-0.0468406416,
0.0035360414,
-0.0147890467,
-0.0416343957,
0.0417772867,
-0.0352639556,
0.080859594,
0.0122131919,
-0.0028763278,
0.0030993745,
0.0460287444,
-0.0075659384,
-0.0311033502,
0.0569288544,
0.0024514152,
-0.0063560391,
-0.0463083163,
0.0822002366,
-0.0043860222,
0.0571309812,
-0.0016957633,
0.0147541407,
-0.0494473055,
-0.0287773833,
0.0056623011,
0.0073254881,
-0.0155218737,
-0.0083464477,
-0.0142850978,
-0.0380205847,
0.0114727626,
-0.00390011,
0.0142390793,
-0.0077580269,
0.0430587977,
0.0670072213,
0.0124121001,
-0.043040935,
0.0222452916,
-0.0703736842,
0.0404125378,
-0.0034334646,
-0.0425838605,
-6.078169047e-33,
-0.0056733685,
0.035825979,
0.00787869,
-0.004897105,
-0.0144886319,
0.0050471467,
-0.0288878102,
0.0287717283,
-0.0216834527,
0.0467903651,
-0.0137316659,
0.0261755381,
0.0167403314,
0.053549476,
0.0456321836,
-0.0320059583,
0.0567739643,
-0.0016323768,
-0.0026921663,
-0.0231259782,
0.0159137361,
0.0517230779,
0.1108928323,
-0.0411291309,
0.0078015248,
0.0334635638,
-0.0274937451,
0.0175966062,
0.0125279976,
0.0518177077,
0.0273382366,
-0.0000241046,
0.0421501733,
-0.0254521836,
-0.0390965305,
-0.0101020252,
-0.1086542532,
-0.0132874362,
0.0366944633,
0.0287238285,
-0.0638494268,
-0.0172060765,
0.028037671,
-0.0206278078,
0.027194269,
-0.0294343885,
0.0157696847,
-0.0198189486,
0.0091298623,
-0.0227135308,
-0.043039877,
0.0270761717,
-0.0188741796,
0.0487810187,
-0.0086581996,
0.0402057692,
-0.0190808438,
0.0462085307,
-0.0237072837,
-0.0044653742,
-0.0157807712,
0.0247331001,
0.0407178625,
0.0088197654,
-0.0151185496,
0.0435801782,
0.0050505185,
-0.0374929458,
-0.0324700437,
0.0333580375,
-0.0092056347,
0.0669098794,
-0.0004484387,
0.0268671233,
0.0508664176,
0.029017549,
-0.0515446551,
-0.013696894,
-0.0036493267,
0.084205389,
-0.0233141948,
0.0296435654,
-0.0200934689,
-0.010629829,
-0.0473135151,
-0.0067037735,
-0.0108179003,
-0.0162051897,
0.033219222,
0.020654114,
-0.0042125527,
0.0291477107,
0.0115396976,
-0.0493440256,
0.0278497711,
0.0136061944,
-0.0038701764,
0.014820707,
-0.0041084811,
0.0026735803,
-0.0514994636,
-0.066347681,
0.0164503865,
0.0012546063,
0.0393592976,
-0.0148028741,
0.0851829499,
0.0096325418,
-0.0331189185,
0.0154000493,
-0.0349259153,
-0.0055943779,
-0.0321110226,
0.0456729233,
0.0509526618,
0.0156699345,
-0.0468154177,
0.0736514851,
0.0125220129,
0.0410475284,
-0.0354379341,
0.0209000707,
0.0408159345,
0.035736803,
-0.0016986192,
-0.0200987235,
-0.0122566521,
-0.0351348817,
0.0841122419,
-0.026184734,
-0.0141775394,
0.0272357073,
2.547e-7,
0.0903540403,
0.0151297851,
0.0442127846,
0.007105113,
0.0176168494,
0.0155938314,
-0.0004898805,
0.0271797068,
-0.0221870858,
-0.0318841413,
-0.0265652556,
-0.012227051,
0.0241364948,
0.0210093446,
-0.0868836343,
0.0095479414,
-0.0900313631,
-0.0152024794,
-0.008119517,
0.0053892317,
0.0130569786,
0.1086249575,
-0.0156612862,
0.0029945036,
-0.0025519328,
-0.0692597777,
0.0516625196,
-0.02300849,
0.0008328096,
0.0385545082,
-0.0132134045,
0.0243554916,
0.0318047553,
-0.0022106636,
-0.0109807784,
0.0390414931,
0.0404139794,
0.052137278,
0.0072810343,
0.0554809719,
0.0218271688,
-0.0376198813,
-0.005576869,
-0.0323948823,
0.0537316352,
-0.0970584676,
-0.0000055242,
0.0026910133,
-0.0553863831,
0.0380751826,
-0.0234191418,
-0.0038558829,
0.02843263,
0.0139755532,
0.0616341569,
-0.0061108205,
-0.0459145829,
-0.0366222039,
-0.0600472763,
0.0160998013,
-0.00649396,
-0.006223687,
-0.0068452884,
-0.0214604046,
-0.0033254232,
-0.026338039,
-0.0340076946,
2.305637349e-34,
0.0328731127,
0.0054686191,
0.0380603373,
0.0183558762,
0.0458606407,
-0.0340978391,
-0.0485385433,
0.0036969974,
-0.0265823416,
-0.0748010203,
0.0220093094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15021v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15021v2 | Efficient Data Learning for Open Information Extraction with Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-10-23T15:19:24 | 2024-06-26T08:23:10 | Zhiyuan Fan, Shizhu He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open Information Extraction (OpenIE) is a fundamental yet challenging task in
Natural Language Processing, which involves extracting all triples (subject,
predicate, object) from a given sentence. While labeling-based methods have
their merits, generation-based techniques offer unique advantages, such as the
ability to generate tokens not present in the original sentence. However, these
generation-based methods often require a significant amount of training data to
learn the task form of OpenIE and substantial training time to overcome slow
model convergence due to the order penalty. In this paper, we introduce a novel
framework, OK-IE, that ingeniously transforms the task form of OpenIE into the
pre-training task form of the T5 model, thereby reducing the need for extensive
training data. Furthermore, we introduce an innovative concept of Anchor to
control the sequence of model outputs, effectively eliminating the impact of
order penalty on model convergence and significantly reducing training time.
Experimental results indicate that, compared to previous SOTA methods, OK-IE
requires only 1/100 of the training data (900 instances) and 1/120 of the
training time (3 minutes) to achieve comparable results. | [
0.0615310594,
0.0814287886,
0.0456023365,
0.0413432494,
-0.0527616926,
0.0160693843,
-0.0089968387,
0.0055742925,
0.0107739735,
-0.0793570355,
-0.0332784466,
0.0055284109,
-0.0526681393,
0.0654165968,
-0.0290562958,
-0.0121337883,
0.0356681049,
-0.0232540164,
0.0261441395,
0.0123311151,
-0.0252566095,
0.0215715487,
-0.0050370889,
-0.0166783966,
-0.0032513153,
0.0166862458,
-0.0149100777,
-0.0206819177,
0.00194614,
-0.018297758,
0.0156530607,
0.0540877059,
0.0002130292,
0.0218934771,
0.000001992,
-0.0624250658,
-0.0652690083,
0.014280146,
-0.0526942387,
-0.0041044625,
0.0264428239,
-0.008946809,
0.0056779836,
0.0087736826,
-0.0357503444,
-0.0530310832,
0.0549454316,
0.0831204429,
0.048470702,
0.0960354954,
-0.0199939273,
-0.0502677932,
0.0269580372,
0.0035044891,
-0.007028061,
-0.0099138543,
0.0460766405,
-0.0177835543,
-0.0337280445,
0.0275678299,
0.0368745327,
0.0111668743,
0.0200886466,
0.0240964293,
0.0160386208,
0.0607375205,
-0.0403432809,
-0.0304597877,
-0.0558844022,
0.1132248119,
-0.0122849923,
-0.0094016194,
0.0203651432,
0.0028485614,
-0.0238615759,
-0.0032815346,
-0.0349488892,
0.0395934768,
0.0039487276,
0.0479429103,
0.0484980047,
0.004074485,
-0.0073513943,
0.0113604805,
-0.0395917259,
0.0854583085,
0.0181314535,
-0.0431081764,
0.0491859727,
0.0169915091,
0.0008341941,
-0.0261574257,
0.0028350058,
0.0060384786,
0.0146309324,
0.0192249138,
-0.0472474471,
-0.0586501285,
-0.0206903405,
-0.0420127697,
0.0325105451,
0.0016922532,
-0.0512850918,
0.053354159,
-0.0455503054,
-0.0156831238,
-0.0277291033,
0.0289681442,
-0.0381949916,
-0.0112917824,
-0.0321849622,
-0.0013094456,
-0.0487270243,
0.0847783312,
-0.0758410096,
-0.0438691042,
0.0005268561,
0.02717961,
0.0138519285,
-0.0360835381,
0.010915935,
-0.0056645027,
-0.0187459663,
0.0003762616,
0.0008140102,
-0.0058842241,
-0.0080788676,
0.0071523213,
-0.0132593075,
-0.0491828881,
-0.0365407765,
0.0142502077,
0.0559458211,
-0.0019897183,
0.0099752331,
0.0194202606,
-0.00565144,
-0.027539758,
-0.0589026436,
-0.046877455,
0.0189299732,
-0.0509473532,
0.0139224073,
-0.063103281,
0.0290970486,
0.0067347018,
-0.0474512354,
-0.0261994563,
0.0407306477,
0.0175651759,
-0.0619331859,
0.0333089679,
-0.0676558092,
-0.0282703619,
-0.0237814579,
-0.0115236258,
0.0625315756,
0.0502444021,
0.0031467127,
0.0343255699,
0.0411029384,
0.0314500071,
-0.0085280873,
0.0467426032,
0.0508823767,
-0.0239138268,
0.035210494,
0.0266724825,
0.0419161767,
0.0133396843,
0.0277343187,
0.0671334639,
-0.0143835107,
0.0309828427,
0.0367515832,
0.0131438626,
0.0248018708,
-0.0097723901,
0.029964136,
0.0260506887,
0.0014855746,
0.0022857578,
-0.0094919773,
-0.0131209698,
-0.0282864347,
0.0272424705,
-0.0146595966,
0.0238480438,
-0.0020895782,
-0.0287996791,
-0.0174316186,
-0.0194211546,
-0.0374661461,
-0.0030450055,
0.0502878726,
0.0395732671,
-0.0572803356,
0.0755906329,
0.0604725815,
-0.0627723113,
-0.0359323323,
-0.0426766463,
0.0389262959,
-0.0233600084,
0.0131984213,
-0.0668107048,
-0.0125269936,
-0.0153376264,
0.0120727634,
0.0278792251,
0.0400328487,
-0.0094946949,
0.0011315509,
-0.0213537905,
-0.0269290302,
0.0066666077,
0.0006742199,
0.0042579849,
0.0343491919,
-0.0057582892,
0.0444764234,
0.0339588076,
-0.0165931042,
0.0673428923,
0.0119043598,
-0.0566472895,
0.0374096297,
0.0213927515,
0.0545895323,
0.0191531442,
-0.0304213241,
-0.0114680938,
0.054081548,
-0.0194357876,
-0.023856245,
-0.0100799119,
-0.0483792908,
-0.0334802307,
0.0278770253,
0.0173815507,
0.001522043,
0.0181682557,
-0.0636356175,
-0.0232747532,
-0.0048514376,
0.0263275243,
0.0424239412,
-0.0519350469,
-0.0054246443,
0.0595536269,
0.0114689991,
-0.0486170389,
0.0965384617,
-0.0051531214,
-0.0089527192,
-0.0013923978,
-0.0373837799,
-0.0036100443,
-0.0021000523,
-0.0056807436,
0.0185365938,
-0.0103281522,
-0.0048350855,
-0.004526611,
0.0413265936,
-0.0655247271,
-0.0508759022,
-0.1104551628,
0.0308842007,
-0.0304891281,
0.0453302898,
0.0229974091,
0.0411482155,
-0.0348641537,
-0.0094410684,
-0.0288835708,
-0.0027343256,
-0.0074852994,
-0.0121073127,
0.0232999362,
0.058096204,
-0.0241633151,
-0.0058084549,
0.0066081365,
-0.0157169476,
0.0618674941,
0.0070769493,
-0.0169491395,
-0.0148097444,
0.0325765349,
-0.0289413277,
0.0611558147,
0.0275047012,
0.0088415109,
-0.0168801975,
-0.0440576226,
0.037946701,
0.0438441001,
0.0046009207,
0.0520733893,
0.014659211,
-0.013074425,
-0.0081409551,
0.0237968769,
-0.0552630424,
0.0027240426,
0.0156936646,
0.0154744042,
0.0418453999,
0.0154594025,
0.0243275445,
-0.0060184374,
0.0191365704,
0.0205549672,
-0.0049155331,
-0.034500964,
-0.0389074571,
0.0249077212,
-0.0286623593,
0.0206947103,
-0.0374216735,
-0.0035532068,
0.0354826525,
-0.0219427533,
0.0019092116,
-0.0501949675,
0.0089903325,
-0.0645685866,
0.0650159642,
0.007062641,
0.0268369298,
0.0528632849,
-0.0283737369,
-0.0061290255,
0.0110795721,
-0.0060319169,
-0.0135547193,
0.0250150841,
-0.0532678477,
-0.0099610109,
-0.0047574104,
-0.0236153174,
-0.0442194305,
-0.0689884871,
-0.0066305916,
-0.0060030469,
-0.0189691987,
0.0180768967,
0.0008542874,
-0.015514303,
-0.014118162,
0.0623498,
-0.0158954225,
0.0171578303,
-0.0333229601,
0.0597070344,
0.0498369746,
-0.017976325,
-0.040195819,
-0.0180016346,
0.0152284009,
0.0557667241,
0.0191142093,
0.0004845452,
-0.0173972994,
0.0027108428,
0.0255242698,
-0.0575273149,
-0.0133905029,
0.0018113959,
-0.0002317565,
-0.0301256832,
-0.0042028623,
0.121335417,
0.056234993,
0.026768608,
-0.0209730007,
0.0100728096,
0.0624764413,
-0.005263438,
0.0078388052,
-0.0900000781,
-0.0427459665,
-0.0125694238,
0.0175526217,
-0.0133402133,
-0.0323502161,
-0.023513237,
-0.1177213639,
0.0509002991,
-0.0096211415,
-0.0551934242,
-0.0116041675,
-0.0160453729,
-0.0012843363,
-0.0325331427,
-0.0272258222,
0.0420378447,
-0.0338493921,
0.0322466977,
0.0094537521,
0.0231440142,
-0.0250531621,
0.0033264123,
-0.0417015031,
0.0179671794,
0.0186310075,
-0.0111411912,
0.0001457876,
-0.0019213971,
0.034332335,
0.0112150405,
-0.0330511332,
-0.0490303971,
0.0636741892,
-0.0366312042,
-0.0056341956,
-0.0326678641,
0.0472345874,
-0.0084303524,
0.0148102101,
-0.023433309,
0.0578806587,
0.0368933454,
0.0221038125,
0.0194598492,
-0.0272109658,
0.0169953406,
0.0700181946,
0.0075533376,
-0.0456134118,
-0.0236616917,
0.0193445366,
0.0030110758,
-0.0374650434,
-0.0163311344,
0.0054739164,
-0.0397946574,
-0.0866158605,
-0.079369463,
-0.0079274392,
0.0171960853,
0.0550622679,
0.0143650696,
-0.0170040634,
0.0104475599,
-0.0002270416,
-0.0415165164,
0.0220082495,
-0.0295618549,
-0.0515287481,
-0.0675056055,
-0.0121997511,
0.0451742075,
-0.0306795165,
-0.0413527079,
0.0281580687,
-0.0616615601,
-0.0388632007,
0.0309154671,
0.0343609303,
0.0122026717,
0.0169605874,
0.0078123072,
0.0225698333,
0.0300335493,
0.0637192875,
-0.0531917512,
-0.0149785765,
0.0443418734,
-0.050406076,
0.0301028769,
0.0230709389,
-0.03995407,
0.0291469786,
0.0213545822,
-0.0015346609,
-0.0254919734,
-0.0192036126,
0.0547905266,
0.0697528571,
0.0955176726,
0.0173061416,
-0.0070573715,
-0.0643653795,
0.0091929138,
-0.039952077,
-0.0395972095,
-0.0725145414,
0.0531216636,
-0.0007697725,
0.0118928235,
-0.0169603433,
0.0075916196,
0.0046393508,
0.0337214991,
-0.0302821621,
-0.0256236531,
0.0189752169,
0.0450757518,
0.016075382,
-0.0275074318,
-0.0533629097,
0.0224031359,
-0.0002043207,
0.0022418275,
-0.0494198352,
0.0457199365,
0.0065610423,
-0.0001831241,
-0.0127733648,
0.0278995242,
-0.0366999917,
0.0344363898,
-0.0548877716,
0.031971477,
0.0194771215,
-0.0207182411,
0.0390600264,
-0.0397008583,
-0.0257851891,
0.0044512246,
0.0710685477,
-0.0088466592,
-0.026557127,
0.0101263048,
-0.0110589555,
-0.0270791519,
-0.007344075,
0.0549505204,
0.0023800521,
0.0338994041,
0.0043338272,
-0.0108739194,
-0.0656650662,
0.012037294,
0.0182771757,
0.0010189409,
-0.0058672153,
0.0255913287,
-0.0254737344,
-0.0035062735,
0.0082240021,
0.0139806205,
-0.01464477,
0.0272107925,
0.0667700469,
0.0651676804,
0.0036750594,
-0.060138315,
-0.052203346,
-0.0156833716,
0.0375727378,
-0.0572814383,
0.0273372829,
-6.526786916e-33,
-0.0440957099,
0.0173704941,
-0.0057317386,
0.0682210773,
-0.0434711501,
0.0142293973,
0.0083524436,
0.0077980678,
0.0069338419,
-0.0186157096,
-0.0015676938,
-0.0205267854,
0.0316713229,
0.0337296203,
-0.0481545404,
-0.0107076438,
0.0072402442,
-0.0345871523,
-0.0175766274,
0.0010777805,
0.0590389147,
0.0412536934,
0.059662994,
-0.0836932287,
0.0040907827,
-0.0118783796,
-0.0089508304,
0.0143277813,
0.0350571908,
0.0151028521,
-0.0066729076,
0.0302584898,
0.0056271912,
-0.0490434393,
0.0179301687,
0.0275861081,
-0.1310979575,
-0.0247626361,
0.0208559725,
0.0076519884,
-0.0436317995,
-0.0252488535,
0.010448602,
-0.0255690664,
0.0294296816,
-0.0031943689,
0.0031695552,
-0.0162751283,
0.006514451,
-0.0053746253,
-0.0865175799,
0.0357903838,
0.0284663457,
-0.0134098725,
0.0159557015,
0.0220960788,
0.0116832107,
-0.0336663462,
-0.0113704391,
-0.0064453762,
0.0287563987,
0.0234038848,
0.0240898542,
0.0251080319,
0.0062702065,
0.0496441014,
-0.0001033088,
-0.0633244067,
-0.060590826,
0.0063433358,
0.0096787745,
0.0900950804,
-0.0200115368,
-0.0019772043,
0.0272430573,
-0.0086515965,
-0.1144024953,
0.0010815294,
-0.0077296854,
-0.0007813064,
-0.0233290624,
-0.0201786309,
-0.0320714712,
0.025951881,
0.000976266,
-0.006910875,
-0.0214853846,
0.0006765719,
0.0401291847,
0.0196165778,
-0.0683713481,
-0.0211897604,
0.0353287086,
-0.0081401765,
0.0420392528,
0.0271616168,
-0.010363834,
0.0157180857,
-0.0577599332,
0.002925222,
-0.1096899658,
-0.043177288,
0.0023605227,
0.0158654694,
0.0035479981,
-0.0038336117,
0.0367357843,
0.009477715,
-0.0723144189,
0.0183704644,
-0.0303188562,
0.0420964696,
0.0022614435,
0.0162615273,
0.0398954675,
-0.008181354,
0.0032920542,
0.0563102029,
0.0435826704,
0.0109106246,
-0.0571412407,
-0.0699228272,
0.0390609466,
-0.0014406221,
0.001809407,
0.0255719665,
0.0148666445,
-0.009136376,
-0.0261226483,
-0.0288638268,
0.0074679763,
0.0611981042,
2.741e-7,
0.0377056673,
0.0180287119,
0.0327636637,
0.0529742502,
-0.0284090899,
0.0249729399,
0.040704269,
0.0371020511,
-0.0029927522,
-0.000195516,
0.0131896678,
-0.0107014319,
0.0042206063,
0.0108750761,
-0.0972197503,
-0.0273532644,
-0.0480465442,
-0.0323781818,
-0.0562535897,
-0.040788766,
0.0804549679,
0.1006025523,
0.0160098877,
-0.0059102257,
-0.0527393557,
-0.0414884277,
0.0559974685,
0.0108461427,
-0.0211798269,
0.0168008283,
0.0558606051,
0.0262681246,
-0.0222723447,
0.0171938352,
-0.0136636263,
0.0383844934,
0.0204010196,
0.0392206758,
0.0206595231,
-0.0158088934,
0.0288014747,
-0.0343038961,
0.0026870109,
-0.0272196438,
0.0976687968,
-0.0196795557,
0.0055887569,
-0.0076389331,
-0.0294770766,
-0.0061515537,
-0.0370312557,
-0.0409494154,
0.0002343598,
0.0438173264,
0.0299233738,
-0.0483969264,
-0.047308173,
-0.0740627572,
-0.0249400828,
-0.02356443,
0.0096409349,
-0.0182558019,
0.0270452369,
-0.0219787918,
0.0279495995,
-0.0582478642,
-0.0046404656,
2.824751037e-34,
-0.0065379688,
-0.0085995272,
-0.0191295631,
0.0417597182,
0.0263786986,
0.001016059,
0.0111007756,
-0.0170691833,
-0.0392540395,
-0.0751884654,
-0.0027759133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15019v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15019v2 | Meta learning with language models: Challenges and opportunities in the classification of imbalanced text | 2023-10-23T15:14:55 | 2023-10-24T15:15:38 | Apostol Vassilev, Honglan Jin, Munawar Hasan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Detecting out of policy speech (OOPS) content is important but difficult.
While machine learning is a powerful tool to tackle this challenging task, it
is hard to break the performance ceiling due to factors like quantity and
quality limitations on training data and inconsistencies in OOPS definition and
data labeling. To realize the full potential of available limited resources, we
propose a meta learning technique (MLT) that combines individual models built
with different text representations. We analytically show that the resulting
technique is numerically stable and produces reasonable combining weights. We
combine the MLT with a threshold-moving (TM) technique to further improve the
performance of the combined predictor on highly-imbalanced in-distribution and
out-of-distribution datasets. We also provide computational results to show the
statistically significant advantages of the proposed MLT approach.
All authors contributed equally to this work. | [
0.0433510952,
-0.0137922904,
-0.0081827911,
-0.0221769139,
-0.0235285722,
0.0314414985,
-0.0074223941,
-0.0063542309,
-0.0647882074,
-0.0866402015,
-0.0171779599,
0.0365061797,
0.0225169957,
0.0259196125,
-0.046143245,
-0.0499728397,
0.0255365036,
-0.0056150169,
0.0166413411,
-0.02060467,
0.0198390037,
0.0116893658,
0.0244888421,
0.027790688,
0.0502734073,
-0.0020417618,
0.0466158092,
0.0084753055,
0.058920078,
-0.012889808,
0.0409338027,
0.0338684954,
-0.0042140917,
0.0722904354,
0.0000021469,
-0.030402191,
0.0029725567,
0.0155528067,
0.0012954113,
-0.0448676422,
0.0436437577,
-0.0221933816,
-0.0230743587,
0.0713814273,
-0.015801724,
0.003130981,
0.0559692942,
0.0244340748,
0.052649416,
0.0524500571,
-0.0253346898,
0.0145199392,
0.0121775623,
-0.0080649015,
0.0024651799,
0.0159270857,
0.0506110266,
-0.0358404145,
-0.0304307509,
-0.0426685922,
0.0035611526,
0.0297848172,
-0.0027267009,
0.0311426409,
-0.0127868336,
0.0139815453,
-0.027038889,
0.0081301555,
-0.046416685,
0.055204764,
-0.0768934339,
-0.0232603122,
0.0089063868,
-0.0278895348,
0.0328851677,
0.0619426481,
-0.006924883,
0.0291274916,
-0.0062601701,
0.0268746372,
-0.0225775559,
0.0255628936,
0.0298575461,
0.0074766926,
-0.0451858714,
0.0290486086,
-0.0173267014,
-0.0545925014,
0.0133700483,
-0.03214873,
-0.0159702674,
-0.0177945718,
0.0097550089,
0.0076911999,
0.0072931182,
0.0056565837,
-0.0514337942,
-0.0554836243,
0.0442588367,
-0.0877400264,
0.0468233563,
-0.0088545419,
-0.047528021,
0.0335191227,
0.0195119716,
-0.0250018761,
0.0576478094,
0.0396118723,
-0.0165003967,
0.0222495869,
-0.0521552265,
-0.0113007883,
-0.0056758402,
0.0549618341,
-0.0041738842,
0.0327875987,
-0.0768093541,
-0.0138726011,
-0.0355071761,
-0.0427501053,
0.0211260021,
-0.0110863345,
-0.0089061037,
-0.0132360961,
0.0230522603,
0.0161401555,
0.0207022633,
0.0468088873,
-0.0283832103,
-0.0291709211,
0.0131215528,
0.0468519144,
-0.0536690615,
-0.0124879582,
0.0223878752,
0.0534867942,
0.0372633673,
-0.0454495624,
-0.0402401015,
0.0044713817,
-0.0366185643,
-0.0297904294,
-0.0177474432,
-0.0561908558,
-0.0343178585,
-0.0162384678,
0.0052827131,
0.0054197749,
0.0085371155,
0.0184249189,
-0.0116157383,
0.0422704406,
-0.0364354067,
0.0015983994,
0.0271866415,
-0.0143540101,
-0.0253922306,
0.0776610002,
0.055474896,
-0.0125397863,
0.0197449438,
0.0039856811,
0.0198293272,
0.0286787879,
0.0008158057,
0.0012669677,
-0.0210319478,
-0.0454561971,
0.0254255962,
-0.0473916568,
0.040244054,
0.0233379025,
0.0085775517,
-0.0158095174,
0.0686349124,
0.0264715701,
-0.0266087875,
-0.0109712137,
-0.0070169135,
0.0318209529,
-0.0286030713,
-0.020918848,
-0.0110352067,
-0.0245432928,
-0.0381997302,
-0.0335600935,
0.0234305095,
0.067752555,
-0.012054977,
-0.0414320156,
-0.0107060326,
-0.0099326791,
-0.0376342721,
-0.0052454337,
0.0519221202,
-0.0010443905,
0.0053133979,
-0.0084484182,
0.0492274985,
-0.005605964,
-0.0023737333,
-0.0568496659,
-0.0592996329,
0.0387465879,
0.0181267355,
-0.0757408142,
0.0356697254,
-0.0674936846,
0.0037026866,
0.0429237932,
-0.021161709,
0.0206193458,
-0.0113818049,
-0.0575926378,
0.0036325871,
0.0474921651,
0.0252401121,
0.0194666758,
-0.0589040257,
0.0156416688,
0.0192979742,
-0.0495308042,
-0.0574400835,
0.0448821709,
-0.0011190991,
-0.0008398504,
0.0493547767,
0.0064263442,
0.0070211836,
-0.0192668028,
-0.0339052752,
-0.0152249187,
-0.0013040595,
-0.0253911149,
-0.044748649,
0.0266112145,
-0.001123498,
-0.0410731025,
0.0454244018,
-0.0475896895,
-0.0079672337,
-0.0060045854,
-0.0303433314,
-0.0278812181,
-0.0036541966,
-0.0458471254,
0.0492486693,
-0.0554353297,
0.0115747815,
-0.0287782215,
0.0259001777,
-0.0576744266,
0.0761936009,
-0.0297366604,
-0.0207370687,
0.0173080359,
-0.1202656627,
0.0183748566,
-0.0202772375,
-0.0172781833,
0.0170150436,
-0.0198592786,
0.0459403656,
-0.0103364885,
-0.0037414522,
0.0149811124,
-0.0249396674,
-0.0601413585,
-0.0237439051,
-0.0546211414,
-0.0041877842,
0.0170153361,
-0.0032078631,
-0.0147625031,
-0.0104728062,
0.0061610453,
-0.0357077792,
0.0338374004,
0.0007795168,
0.010447084,
-0.0059371097,
0.0009623397,
-0.0118012466,
-0.0103575531,
-0.0136287007,
0.0737735853,
0.0157071576,
-0.0427914746,
-0.0208928902,
-0.0009110132,
0.0071231709,
0.0064283721,
-0.0148558002,
-0.0136394221,
-0.0491507016,
0.0170255974,
-0.0027874829,
0.0171001125,
0.0509101301,
0.0169718992,
0.0883709863,
0.0369668044,
-0.0139335366,
-0.021462556,
0.0098387459,
0.0157301016,
-0.0241688155,
-0.0191424098,
0.0186358541,
0.020743968,
0.0334296077,
0.0144427773,
-0.0323651433,
-0.0071359095,
0.0106101818,
-0.0197191592,
-0.0366484001,
0.0210249405,
-0.0314154774,
-0.0041597611,
-0.022430364,
-0.0724194944,
0.0525488704,
0.0430960543,
0.0344436094,
-0.0527900234,
-0.0437888727,
-0.0252557807,
-0.036466796,
-0.0360374153,
0.044155281,
0.0197948236,
-0.0093879821,
-0.0245431215,
-0.0790941417,
0.03724356,
-0.0263159331,
0.0100887353,
-0.0265733022,
0.031692937,
0.0170052126,
-0.047408361,
-0.0266298223,
-0.0492725819,
-0.0055231294,
-0.0017604278,
-0.0647277236,
-0.0201011095,
-0.0783353671,
-0.0006303779,
-0.0198001936,
0.0410673842,
-0.0211998373,
-0.0216246303,
0.0156634711,
0.0063617807,
0.0294036698,
-0.0338577367,
-0.0092086308,
-0.0242510438,
0.0401506014,
0.0150956837,
0.0095377006,
0.0423635021,
-0.004057283,
-0.0131699592,
0.0251157004,
-0.0396452472,
0.0122327004,
0.0256315004,
-0.0310569629,
-0.0376887023,
0.0105925566,
0.1025252864,
0.0572921187,
-0.0567095019,
-0.0139483735,
-0.0324544311,
0.0315872505,
0.0252932515,
0.0052184472,
-0.0066446639,
-0.0414064936,
0.0206151549,
0.0567264967,
-0.0642969236,
0.0036391667,
0.0060664751,
-0.0826101899,
0.0298746824,
0.0150813106,
-0.0174560715,
-0.0631629601,
-0.0298230834,
-0.0030496889,
-0.0285963565,
0.0126233278,
-0.0017949443,
-0.0411459915,
-0.0007561911,
0.0258667767,
-0.0622334741,
-0.0760591626,
0.0232910328,
-0.0082503036,
0.058976952,
0.0666102022,
0.0388993733,
-0.0562817864,
0.013276686,
0.1114991084,
0.0019084832,
-0.0157912169,
-0.0132517014,
0.091441825,
-0.0485607125,
0.0079459846,
-0.0201780591,
0.0428801775,
-0.0321016982,
-0.0120164212,
0.0245584846,
0.0673958957,
-0.0038108155,
-0.0108057912,
-0.0531622693,
0.024497252,
0.0483554751,
0.0641671643,
0.0067050066,
-0.069086723,
0.0026318463,
-0.0466148555,
-0.0251127295,
0.0298297852,
0.0286475569,
0.0757612064,
0.0308986884,
-0.0564178713,
-0.0488173924,
-0.0121080372,
-0.0154978251,
-0.0017644184,
0.039481204,
0.0442006923,
-0.0355609693,
0.0222625434,
-0.045477327,
-0.0297558662,
-0.0226661712,
0.0277085677,
-0.0605342202,
0.0007009073,
0.0160923433,
-0.0471734405,
-0.0484820195,
-0.0200263131,
-0.0251019355,
-0.0558861382,
0.0088033918,
0.0327938944,
0.0189743098,
-0.0337524489,
0.0136874039,
-0.0474567227,
0.1447542459,
0.1096820459,
-0.0049569667,
-0.0110993013,
0.0758852512,
-0.0348425917,
-0.0156120704,
0.0062545747,
-0.0132118659,
0.0340126157,
0.0138225416,
-0.0413489677,
-0.0526326373,
0.0269115511,
0.0195194166,
-0.0247903746,
0.0419325642,
-0.0146315088,
-0.070194602,
-0.0402514786,
0.0048964159,
0.0320473015,
-0.0185543112,
-0.0152055686,
0.0274951737,
0.0396508761,
-0.0061422437,
-0.0276340321,
0.0083291531,
-0.0372193865,
-0.0236796327,
0.042377796,
0.0587013587,
-0.0342355035,
0.0605839975,
-0.0013155558,
-0.0045077568,
0.0141261723,
0.0192815717,
0.0237922929,
0.0048928559,
0.0148262121,
0.0135508664,
0.0362496153,
0.0139464894,
-0.0140058398,
0.0228700265,
-0.0529257581,
0.0208870955,
-0.0327591226,
-0.006669262,
0.0351022482,
0.0411879122,
0.0047394214,
-0.0035112405,
0.000211509,
-0.0501888879,
0.0260102898,
-0.0010157356,
0.0267206356,
-0.0007860566,
-0.0049822186,
-0.047396142,
0.0093635805,
0.0692739561,
0.0052791624,
0.04052867,
0.0013176992,
-0.0321080387,
-0.035858959,
0.0077480236,
-0.0187940635,
0.0239346437,
0.0061830594,
0.022024693,
-0.0864420459,
-0.0348518789,
0.0564987324,
0.0060953624,
0.0496542677,
0.0171284955,
0.0140156718,
0.0368745886,
-0.0275442675,
0.03224409,
-0.0245729722,
-0.0416752324,
-0.0047035022,
-0.0242963862,
-0.0186675917,
-6.026118158e-33,
-0.0202810839,
-0.0344341658,
-0.023338303,
0.0056083235,
0.0257846024,
-0.0234672986,
0.0167423319,
-0.0090567432,
-0.010756148,
0.0115660196,
0.0135963717,
0.0102489088,
0.0103359073,
0.0279077347,
-0.0302487984,
-0.0131883118,
0.0319537036,
-0.0132634034,
-0.0287230797,
-0.0102841016,
0.0602371022,
0.0473694727,
0.0300493836,
-0.0320444815,
-0.0034764074,
0.048155766,
-0.041279953,
-0.0021653466,
-0.0283746924,
0.0366618372,
0.0143935969,
0.1068654358,
0.0322299227,
0.0375047699,
-0.000958727,
0.0373345464,
-0.0211042892,
-0.024739027,
0.0041363174,
-0.0159473978,
0.0761933252,
-0.0284956433,
0.0321398377,
0.0185959451,
-0.0073407022,
-0.0645664483,
0.0937400833,
-0.0526615381,
-0.0237330627,
-0.0283717476,
-0.0382571742,
0.0560901165,
-0.0248663686,
0.0150227332,
0.0239642989,
0.0306401923,
-0.0071032583,
0.0245203786,
-0.0011358063,
0.0308940485,
-0.011236365,
0.0448618457,
-0.0173261203,
0.0505191535,
-0.0079814186,
0.0861882642,
-0.0099944277,
0.0062017031,
0.0592377856,
-0.0041457242,
0.0439952649,
-0.0171430763,
0.0217686202,
0.075056918,
0.0927209035,
-0.0255774725,
-0.0756856427,
0.0411201045,
-0.0117877061,
0.0025723195,
0.0366353057,
-0.0342138149,
-0.0481373779,
-0.0338602737,
-0.0579418652,
-0.0956477746,
-0.0147354146,
0.0118310163,
0.0269922409,
0.0211714599,
-0.0306443088,
0.000194472,
0.0071371733,
-0.0314924158,
-0.0183110517,
0.0067464141,
-0.0225890316,
0.021532895,
0.002950734,
0.0009951367,
-0.0424319208,
-0.017103795,
0.0338771231,
0.0399347432,
0.0100572268,
-0.0377537236,
0.0788273513,
0.0053638578,
-0.0861351639,
0.0224815551,
0.0402738266,
0.0390958451,
-0.0104098115,
0.059551429,
-0.0071595958,
0.0043003,
0.0011386549,
-0.028623119,
-0.0181172024,
-0.0483603589,
-0.023164466,
0.0013473273,
-0.0523906015,
0.0222526882,
-0.020461034,
0.0369546041,
0.0200851299,
-0.0073423106,
0.0844988227,
-0.06268356,
0.0014198354,
-0.0367246643,
2.838e-7,
0.0436149985,
0.0495730154,
0.0010359782,
-0.0324290991,
-0.0052908217,
0.0431470945,
-0.0052104318,
0.0325488262,
0.0426166393,
-0.0286103841,
0.0196800027,
0.0321653783,
0.0282362159,
0.0081969853,
-0.0591173843,
0.0329181552,
-0.0642996505,
0.0049049729,
-0.0311732907,
0.0003600614,
0.0167654306,
0.0817661658,
0.0279546417,
-0.0566042662,
0.0216187853,
-0.0017390131,
0.0498365611,
-0.0448718034,
0.0367135853,
-0.0142265242,
-0.0070829503,
0.0019418995,
-0.0112349046,
0.0478642732,
-0.0165985897,
0.049162861,
-0.0073237484,
0.037171647,
-0.027980864,
-0.0007353669,
0.0069688777,
0.0470652282,
-0.0138691915,
0.0140818823,
0.0372578129,
-0.0214192476,
-0.0230851881,
-0.0744358599,
-0.0582595989,
-0.0243889708,
0.0762582943,
-0.0430525206,
-0.0290733837,
0.02396884,
0.0074614845,
0.0081759598,
0.020309547,
-0.0681656078,
-0.0137877529,
0.0045130653,
-0.0368985236,
-0.0426175594,
0.00174198,
0.0133717703,
0.028163882,
-0.0796028078,
0.0578883998,
2.677907915e-34,
0.0614546835,
-0.0296531226,
-0.00813914,
-0.0476083606,
-0.0294608176,
0.0186455883,
-0.0120963827,
-0.0019304412,
-0.0000982682,
-0.0485859029,
0.015280325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15010v1 | Statistical Depth for Ranking and Characterizing Transformer-Based Text Embeddings | 2023-10-23T15:02:44 | 2023-10-23T15:02:44 | Parker Seegmiller, Sarah Masud Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL | The popularity of transformer-based text embeddings calls for better
statistical tools for measuring distributions of such embeddings. One such tool
would be a method for ranking texts within a corpus by centrality, i.e.
assigning each text a number signifying how representative that text is of the
corpus as a whole. However, an intrinsic center-outward ordering of
high-dimensional text representations is not trivial. A statistical depth is a
function for ranking k-dimensional objects by measuring centrality with respect
to some observed k-dimensional distribution. We adopt a statistical depth to
measure distributions of transformer-based text embeddings, transformer-based
text embedding (TTE) depth, and introduce the practical use of this depth for
both modeling and distributional inference in NLP pipelines. We first define
TTE depth and an associated rank sum test for determining whether two corpora
differ significantly in embedding space. We then use TTE depth for the task of
in-context learning prompt selection, showing that this approach reliably
improves performance over statistical baseline approaches across six text
classification tasks. Finally, we use TTE depth and the associated rank sum
test to characterize the distributions of synthesized and human-generated
corpora, showing that five recent synthetic data augmentation processes cause a
measurable distributional shift away from associated human-generated text. | [
0.0297103114,
0.0323091224,
-0.0209621713,
0.0485089272,
-0.0086653344,
0.0195395034,
0.0116817541,
-0.0083779376,
0.0264388062,
-0.0210192744,
-0.0179785565,
-0.031332761,
0.0126980459,
0.019144861,
0.0471115336,
-0.0349405557,
0.0033879371,
0.0325528085,
-0.0441725701,
0.0103730727,
-0.0023843604,
-0.0001874027,
0.0240137037,
0.0370332412,
-0.0018631597,
0.0257262867,
0.0192383155,
-0.0067055295,
0.0435142592,
-0.0077422545,
-0.0041516949,
0.0689537153,
0.0396801755,
0.0471164435,
0.0000017214,
0.0052315192,
-0.0080169858,
0.0002806329,
-0.0233857315,
-0.0109921731,
0.0220145676,
-0.0644374937,
-0.014538575,
0.0171486735,
-0.0007941465,
-0.0329025388,
0.0471810102,
0.0347925238,
0.0022932941,
0.0558132231,
-0.0120817786,
-0.0431138873,
0.0590287112,
-0.042202767,
-0.0253354479,
0.0168964323,
0.0127565535,
-0.0392978415,
0.0062600197,
0.0895284936,
-0.0404731669,
0.0228001215,
0.0380826928,
-0.025559688,
0.0276937373,
0.0420558155,
0.0058853654,
0.0163295213,
0.0285692327,
0.0821506456,
-0.0209692027,
-0.0316647179,
0.0173825789,
-0.0036161758,
0.0307268128,
0.0445744507,
-0.0289136935,
0.0222096182,
0.0121506052,
0.0009676795,
0.0001594693,
0.0655251071,
0.0215572212,
-0.0081422646,
-0.0469435267,
0.0327513926,
0.0220947787,
-0.0668130144,
0.0031615861,
0.0344335847,
-0.003414253,
-0.0213571358,
0.0237810314,
-0.0495738909,
-0.0112472195,
0.0130145047,
0.0014220035,
-0.0469289385,
0.0102964099,
-0.046631854,
-0.0083261458,
0.0242605992,
-0.0318303145,
0.0116706928,
-0.0321913213,
0.0607948452,
-0.0052068532,
0.0531596802,
-0.0246939175,
0.0005147103,
0.0024971331,
-0.0171088167,
-0.0226744432,
-0.0149657996,
-0.054427214,
-0.025933167,
-0.0608574003,
0.0376408473,
-0.018679766,
0.0034630371,
0.0175210722,
0.0326472893,
-0.0146805132,
0.0241301432,
-0.0013385757,
0.0128109548,
-0.0439346582,
0.0089288885,
-0.0203483887,
0.0019819227,
-0.0132076116,
0.0260183234,
0.0250889268,
-0.0389147215,
-0.0277312025,
0.0384206064,
-0.0041438784,
-0.0592668317,
0.0318291038,
0.0344982222,
-0.0486128405,
0.0030268056,
-0.0027620129,
-0.0700198188,
0.0302196536,
0.015090134,
0.0117678465,
-0.0174666476,
-0.0248914547,
0.0391618647,
-0.0214187857,
0.0556682944,
0.0388924554,
-0.0191516355,
0.0376113914,
-0.0002482537,
-0.0024622597,
0.043665912,
0.0164513029,
0.0308683235,
0.0567822307,
-0.0416841283,
0.0042020706,
0.0218322314,
-0.0151737519,
-0.0056228554,
0.0016173632,
-0.0284545794,
-0.0349721685,
0.0479935817,
0.0339715108,
0.0002687328,
-0.0376212746,
-0.0377474502,
0.0469671078,
0.1031671688,
0.038453389,
-0.0321723633,
0.0711511225,
0.0258786287,
-0.0293302108,
0.0575018823,
-0.028696226,
0.0326987691,
0.0046166573,
-0.0096261976,
0.0554325618,
0.0252463501,
-0.0220819768,
-0.0164897386,
0.0146564366,
-0.00619826,
0.0235706456,
-0.0431661345,
0.0261278637,
0.0386262052,
-0.0127494689,
0.0200384911,
0.0108131506,
-0.0544362254,
0.019210007,
0.0207113512,
-0.0158104971,
0.0348188207,
0.0478265807,
-0.0376949795,
0.0630897284,
-0.0033332487,
0.0081821475,
0.0645010322,
-0.0050683022,
-0.0275469515,
-0.0009476101,
-0.0210785046,
-0.0265377592,
0.0006897124,
0.0264760237,
0.0398230553,
0.0019204149,
-0.0048661483,
0.0189075433,
-0.04797801,
-0.0045733987,
0.0358535312,
-0.0613420531,
-0.0046731522,
0.0269072615,
0.023534989,
-0.0059978897,
0.0208551213,
-0.0237048175,
0.010933754,
0.0263587348,
-0.0462318622,
-0.0536281131,
-0.0036519766,
-0.0403071903,
-0.0482992195,
-0.0338533446,
-0.0565936975,
0.0002320119,
0.0533270985,
-0.0470073707,
-0.0174292512,
0.035382323,
-0.0285398383,
0.0233185347,
-0.0526280478,
-0.0034605719,
-0.0050994912,
0.0363821685,
-0.0482051298,
0.0747251362,
-0.0010579465,
0.0644698068,
0.0261528753,
0.0197567753,
0.0090555344,
-0.0276786052,
-0.0327393748,
0.0108237453,
0.000759971,
0.0124298576,
0.0245168861,
-0.0406490676,
-0.021571923,
-0.0291479379,
-0.0847055689,
-0.0009705278,
-0.040194124,
0.0037101875,
0.0166420601,
0.0041353228,
0.0133852372,
-0.0091901524,
-0.0215411391,
-0.0376185328,
0.0084505016,
0.0288762469,
0.0624248795,
-0.0152496537,
0.0227766484,
-0.0133641725,
-0.0314867422,
-0.0172584392,
0.0976850986,
0.0015838953,
0.0053375424,
-0.0608722754,
0.0076642926,
0.0017441598,
-0.0120988116,
-0.0152390897,
-0.031925045,
0.001511102,
0.0173967462,
0.0428957567,
0.0561743751,
0.043408867,
0.0538587756,
0.0152858738,
0.0323397741,
-0.0428048633,
-0.0321292505,
-0.0406411886,
0.032669805,
-0.0365854427,
-0.0011519302,
0.0303406995,
0.0795717016,
0.017499961,
-0.0232739989,
-0.0581179969,
-0.0005960687,
-0.0395257547,
-0.0011975291,
-0.0203223638,
0.0057928828,
-0.0420184657,
0.013889675,
-0.0295627769,
-0.0295425579,
0.0683159009,
-0.0419281088,
0.0189100876,
-0.051837191,
-0.0149560319,
-0.0441808552,
0.0069979522,
0.0213659927,
0.0094257295,
-0.0506835133,
-0.0560009964,
-0.0358641632,
0.0591336302,
0.0117356889,
-0.0107921502,
0.05823908,
0.0013943994,
-0.0048502395,
-0.0204968732,
-0.0456873849,
-0.0296254326,
-0.0737098157,
0.020475734,
0.0190243032,
0.0517579094,
-0.0453595668,
-0.0201015789,
-0.0270668548,
0.0350085907,
0.0780404508,
-0.0046725636,
-0.0201544538,
-0.0342976451,
0.0556137748,
0.0057364185,
0.0303209722,
0.0123680318,
0.0128594413,
0.0124013405,
0.035982918,
-0.0282712635,
0.0061740843,
-0.012349504,
-0.0188418254,
0.0183126666,
-0.0420756973,
-0.0235268604,
-0.0125738094,
0.0087882346,
0.0081501305,
-0.0277828369,
0.0950596705,
0.0488116369,
-0.0477458835,
0.0255064145,
0.0366191864,
0.0340719782,
0.0245274063,
0.0279330835,
-0.0753706396,
0.0079619866,
-0.0324099101,
-0.0015654309,
-0.0157189798,
-0.0399359688,
-0.0025718897,
-0.1428247392,
0.0171902291,
-0.0354844145,
-0.0402242392,
-0.0365453139,
-0.0719153211,
0.0308460984,
0.014044458,
-0.0005703541,
-0.0334648937,
0.0063942382,
-0.0209695827,
0.0214319862,
-0.0331304967,
-0.0871701315,
0.0053733131,
-0.0351571776,
0.000466673,
0.0064119431,
0.0507713817,
-0.0405157991,
-0.0189270247,
-0.032417085,
-0.0657158047,
0.0010002326,
0.0290229432,
0.0895014256,
-0.0228602886,
-0.0053249956,
-0.0148824984,
0.0026666776,
0.0083145313,
-0.0027008804,
-0.0441495776,
0.0730399191,
0.0084956344,
-0.0217732266,
-0.0114987744,
0.0176008716,
0.0052961293,
0.0646172687,
0.0221277867,
-0.047131706,
0.0068933642,
-0.0559506938,
0.0428154506,
-0.014241646,
-0.0363012068,
0.0147853447,
0.025697764,
-0.0313903466,
-0.1131001115,
-0.0073236455,
0.0116469394,
0.0432416648,
-0.0103110792,
-0.0001712194,
-0.0235498603,
-0.0648416281,
-0.0114860199,
-0.0074017742,
-0.00103924,
0.0280165076,
-0.0267026313,
0.0170637239,
0.0284214914,
-0.0169849563,
-0.0524980538,
-0.0314622559,
-0.0378735997,
-0.07305336,
-0.0166728608,
-0.0026309832,
0.0118021481,
-0.0048347474,
-0.0290113539,
-0.0667125061,
0.1118507162,
0.0371440835,
-0.0384727903,
0.0037770183,
0.027502751,
-0.032006111,
-0.0224698856,
0.0345348381,
-0.0380890556,
0.0211881995,
0.0132786958,
0.0036231189,
0.0039454475,
-0.0333218053,
-0.0115747824,
-0.0317348018,
0.0423835255,
-0.0037783007,
0.0144454008,
-0.0639901534,
0.0193606447,
-0.069731459,
-0.0234798882,
0.00612074,
-0.0053077321,
0.0525522754,
-0.0010430843,
-0.0137891769,
0.060221307,
-0.0088351639,
0.0496521406,
-0.0457720943,
-0.0035633524,
0.0592855997,
-0.002020906,
-0.0070004016,
0.050081972,
-0.0174962431,
-0.0134879742,
-0.0086657135,
0.0521856993,
-0.0212452784,
0.0189372487,
0.0056059812,
-0.0166452602,
-0.0427882522,
0.0662901103,
-0.1154164672,
0.0041248701,
0.0020778314,
0.0115593644,
0.020692585,
-0.0634931475,
0.0343675241,
-0.0131191453,
-0.0185834076,
-0.0012392508,
0.003232541,
0.0016119123,
-0.0273324065,
-0.0057012425,
0.0120088365,
-0.0213508774,
0.0257162824,
0.0810715556,
0.0204312392,
0.0008112834,
-0.0232263599,
-0.0233202223,
-0.0097811064,
-0.0010291321,
0.0252177045,
0.0564117394,
-0.0091450224,
-0.0066688526,
-0.068849802,
-0.0664140359,
0.0325061679,
-0.0203773398,
-0.0145708919,
-0.0027448107,
0.0177836604,
0.0638423413,
0.013245495,
0.0461526252,
-0.0478697158,
-0.0009702796,
-0.0050573265,
-0.050792139,
-0.0301680695,
-5.984949039e-33,
0.0016032498,
-0.0199722182,
-0.0464859195,
-0.0400567576,
-0.0082444297,
0.0456111096,
-0.0226406883,
-0.0143039161,
-0.0007078051,
0.0318342,
-0.0435574539,
0.0055466471,
-0.0003790847,
0.0329318084,
-0.0161137488,
0.0020395636,
0.0151946461,
0.0002857584,
-0.0365758017,
0.0188200474,
0.0735935122,
0.022981856,
0.0642481595,
-0.023854401,
0.0410156138,
0.0232735816,
0.0500073209,
-0.0124859419,
0.0325193889,
0.0506588519,
-0.0093766423,
0.0653026849,
0.0326974615,
-0.0930253342,
-0.0062750475,
0.0723201632,
-0.0387538336,
-0.0300133061,
-0.0303626843,
-0.0182088148,
-0.0417762138,
0.0175958965,
0.0267464425,
-0.039685756,
-0.0039181402,
-0.0558800623,
0.0536526367,
0.0053514079,
-0.009302251,
-0.0532272607,
-0.0530257151,
0.0180775877,
-0.015765816,
0.0134729603,
0.0235759225,
0.0059910519,
0.053578563,
0.0548959076,
-0.0348056592,
0.0201083478,
-0.0638218373,
0.0103781763,
0.0342037082,
-0.0060622916,
-0.0005885003,
0.0797633603,
-0.02407456,
0.0397335067,
-0.0172205847,
-0.0247483086,
0.0022405037,
0.0054388442,
0.0367916711,
0.1020829231,
0.0364066325,
-0.0183012299,
-0.0542777441,
0.0648211166,
0.0033340368,
-0.035746906,
0.0116354199,
0.0000899597,
-0.0579762347,
-0.0500593558,
-0.0307235662,
-0.04024259,
0.0108038075,
-0.0246210061,
0.0121450229,
-0.0059382133,
-0.0305064414,
-0.009720359,
0.0311709642,
-0.0660084188,
-0.0177272949,
0.0473520122,
-0.0113036493,
0.0251822006,
0.0232829247,
-0.0079649892,
-0.00843562,
0.0014988768,
0.0472932421,
0.0035684754,
0.0228969604,
-0.0007234449,
0.0640232638,
-0.0075468752,
-0.0653042272,
0.016027268,
-0.0119334925,
-0.0221912246,
-0.0326051451,
0.0765890479,
0.0098854164,
0.0072627873,
-0.0032593571,
0.0338578075,
0.0403119512,
0.0398302637,
-0.0208443217,
0.0153028015,
-0.0129617741,
-0.0047931531,
-0.0305159763,
-0.0048311441,
-0.0131946951,
0.0362892449,
0.0659718588,
-0.0770612657,
-0.0110412333,
-0.0254364926,
2.512e-7,
0.0439470671,
0.0399242081,
0.0590993203,
-0.0273933355,
0.0430681072,
0.0143806422,
0.0284971111,
0.0814074129,
-0.0030279739,
-0.036893867,
-0.0024164356,
-0.0150996791,
0.0252460744,
0.0035630399,
-0.1193988845,
-0.0141618587,
-0.0933502614,
0.0151505144,
-0.0353463888,
-0.0214150213,
0.045480974,
0.1026003659,
0.0033785747,
0.0123632252,
0.0082503129,
-0.0336274765,
0.0464839116,
-0.0060709519,
0.0274304561,
0.0019666918,
0.0344532952,
-0.0360873602,
0.0352726914,
0.0254727639,
-0.0431077369,
0.0361947566,
0.0503328927,
0.0354987159,
0.0211729016,
-0.008153813,
-0.0138135906,
-0.0108149126,
0.0027835851,
-0.0753688291,
0.0471865833,
-0.0770815313,
-0.0129494006,
-0.00494802,
-0.0426431075,
-0.0109425206,
0.0314299501,
-0.0154118845,
-0.0188438594,
0.0276291985,
0.0373955891,
0.0337864757,
0.0119780954,
-0.0894037336,
-0.019104274,
-0.0103941122,
-0.0492920987,
-0.0294754766,
-0.0295579303,
-0.0526028648,
0.0438018627,
-0.0134674273,
0.0151848141,
2.696323228e-34,
0.0151418643,
0.0413491502,
0.0229559597,
-0.0471893437,
0.0247859005,
-0.0228840578,
0.0732925907,
-0.0041807941,
0.0322172008,
-0.0970080867,
0.0019870703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15007v1 | Did the Neurons Read your Book? Document-level Membership Inference for Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T15:00:46 | 2023-10-23T15:00:46 | Matthieu Meeus, Shubham Jain, Marek Rei, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | With large language models (LLMs) poised to become embedded in our daily
lives, questions are starting to be raised about the dataset(s) they learned
from. These questions range from potential bias or misinformation LLMs could
retain from their training data to questions of copyright and fair use of
human-generated text. However, while these questions emerge, developers of the
recent state-of-the-art LLMs become increasingly reluctant to disclose details
on their training corpus. We here introduce the task of document-level
membership inference for real-world LLMs, i.e. inferring whether the LLM has
seen a given document during training or not. First, we propose a procedure for
the development and evaluation of document-level membership inference for LLMs
by leveraging commonly used data sources for training and the model release
date. We then propose a practical, black-box method to predict document-level
membership and instantiate it on OpenLLaMA-7B with both books and academic
papers. We show our methodology to perform very well, reaching an impressive
AUC of 0.856 for books and 0.678 for papers. We then show our approach to
outperform the sentence-level membership inference attacks used in the privacy
literature for the document-level membership task. We finally evaluate whether
smaller models might be less sensitive to document-level inference and show
OpenLLaMA-3B to be approximately as sensitive as OpenLLaMA-7B to our approach.
Taken together, our results show that accurate document-level membership can be
inferred for LLMs, increasing the transparency of technology poised to change
our lives. | [
0.0487132184,
0.1076454744,
-0.019305015,
0.0691303089,
-0.0494066291,
0.0096906489,
0.0588347614,
-0.0119793257,
0.0486537926,
-0.0467283428,
-0.0348982289,
0.0056640795,
-0.0033904316,
-0.0060123424,
0.0341600776,
0.0437986776,
0.057062,
-0.0311049763,
-0.0021016595,
-0.0269372258,
-0.0241683498,
0.0028880939,
0.0338384211,
0.0144111468,
0.0215457231,
-0.020546753,
-0.0085933851,
-0.0086391456,
0.0092998706,
0.0065249479,
0.0194804929,
0.0569559149,
0.0351098031,
0.1052046493,
0.0000018307,
-0.0419059135,
-0.0458466411,
0.0253138617,
-0.0141429752,
0.0356460586,
0.0546718165,
0.0002945226,
0.0235282015,
0.0142753944,
-0.0131759299,
0.0329893939,
-0.0065182834,
0.0458002239,
0.0019962357,
0.103142418,
-0.0115279965,
0.0165426396,
0.0396681689,
-0.0170479231,
0.0294290856,
-0.0305725951,
0.0236064997,
-0.0543166101,
-0.0130346399,
0.0100410981,
0.0194210727,
0.0581985563,
0.0257677808,
0.0043185349,
0.0086501362,
0.0426211581,
-0.0171595346,
0.0058067068,
0.0016715566,
0.0074838316,
0.0301450305,
-0.017948376,
0.0295514632,
0.0148214018,
0.015120971,
0.0326800123,
-0.0304207243,
0.0361867175,
-0.0020307121,
0.0153997112,
0.0250176694,
-0.0161646102,
0.0617807657,
0.0066076117,
0.0174674094,
0.0679255426,
0.0252940375,
-0.0252511092,
0.0057414682,
-0.0090411399,
0.0161389951,
-0.0473975204,
0.0327077843,
-0.0172532853,
0.0638670772,
0.03337254,
-0.0801233575,
-0.0393092111,
0.0283194333,
-0.0541773587,
0.047782138,
-0.0281655211,
-0.0358579941,
0.0715694651,
-0.0176402833,
0.0062404308,
-0.022806637,
0.0463951342,
-0.0001277838,
0.0163296554,
0.0208545979,
-0.0184013862,
0.0192057304,
0.0411540233,
-0.0071889879,
-0.0298178643,
-0.0431612432,
0.0103923157,
0.0175072253,
0.0263979975,
-0.0442015417,
-0.0084748678,
-0.0155019481,
-0.0218240079,
-0.0082599251,
-0.0547939241,
0.0116585633,
0.027813822,
-0.0174046643,
-0.0617818572,
-0.014715068,
0.0029010074,
-0.0146874273,
-0.0174531713,
0.0111786835,
0.0524361618,
0.0195898358,
-0.0793837234,
-0.0401519053,
-0.0769948736,
-0.0040176581,
-0.0761454627,
0.0248631667,
-0.0601752847,
-0.0016195942,
0.0014243459,
-0.0000206167,
-0.0533696935,
-0.0046429904,
0.0278041735,
-0.0250815712,
0.0565843992,
-0.0036814825,
-0.0174669214,
0.0067318301,
0.0212899521,
0.0105395187,
0.0430592634,
0.0047833719,
0.0271430332,
0.0721603334,
0.0205625426,
0.0262078736,
0.0473648757,
0.0252953898,
-0.0203767698,
0.0057895323,
-0.0156385321,
0.0077221915,
-0.0266692918,
-0.0200553574,
0.0368392132,
-0.0095973052,
-0.0536491424,
0.0982230529,
0.088573195,
-0.024926845,
-0.0042970595,
-0.0505811572,
-0.0017622391,
0.0297080483,
0.022230858,
-0.0505407304,
-0.0190766063,
-0.0599086322,
-0.0382993296,
0.0126545876,
0.0012026016,
0.0081172222,
-0.0128074856,
0.0142044323,
-0.0379793383,
-0.0136165665,
0.0063790279,
0.033896897,
0.0030366993,
0.0188204013,
0.0486891158,
0.0347177163,
-0.0632582977,
0.0075407857,
-0.039475888,
0.0552977547,
0.0140942205,
0.0710391253,
-0.0440859236,
0.0454864651,
-0.0258080773,
0.0084750531,
0.0447453111,
0.018521985,
0.0061168303,
0.033888489,
-0.0421041809,
-0.010380974,
-0.0278333891,
0.0460436456,
0.0314759985,
0.0423518792,
-0.0204421859,
0.0283724442,
-0.0632590652,
-0.0377778485,
0.0394917652,
-0.0526763648,
-0.0409989804,
0.0135336025,
0.003827624,
0.027164761,
0.0142746493,
-0.0072538126,
-0.0049867108,
0.0260889363,
-0.0174877793,
-0.0021974184,
-0.0151984068,
0.0117851868,
-0.0096016126,
0.0097805047,
-0.0193780903,
-0.0146933682,
0.0818497017,
-0.0174257979,
-0.0088587906,
-0.0009812029,
-0.0182667226,
0.0521646552,
-0.0393857732,
-0.0114093637,
-0.0221636444,
0.0298316851,
-0.0219988544,
0.0555357151,
-0.0189209376,
0.0059033735,
0.015571693,
-0.0579692423,
0.0286074057,
-0.0385453254,
-0.0643818304,
-0.0071700704,
-0.0184278395,
-0.0023793033,
0.0179116204,
-0.0256484393,
-0.0294152945,
-0.015608795,
-0.0489518046,
0.0051058317,
-0.0062105162,
0.0412938818,
0.0018966801,
-0.0287504084,
-0.023769144,
-0.0253067594,
-0.0209683329,
0.0100475615,
-0.0279445294,
0.0229969379,
0.0272676479,
-0.0261602923,
-0.0154126137,
-0.0309359524,
-0.0280270278,
-0.0358501934,
0.0630957931,
0.000174529,
-0.0047887345,
-0.0182582159,
0.0489634946,
-0.0045062737,
0.0231513977,
-0.0317348465,
0.0064526172,
-0.0076763052,
-0.0105056502,
-0.0431396216,
0.0886113718,
0.0037673921,
0.0116067007,
0.0550429001,
0.0153240124,
-0.0309446361,
-0.0154758729,
-0.0033829091,
-0.0179194435,
-0.0649142936,
-0.0231764261,
0.0367108807,
0.0357525684,
0.0060039265,
-0.0336105525,
0.007273417,
0.0262697097,
-0.0280982088,
-0.0509161204,
-0.0066659888,
-0.0015048977,
-0.0178063158,
0.0362642035,
0.0066807857,
-0.0716407225,
0.0415337123,
-0.061284367,
0.0273907334,
-0.0187022444,
-0.0202456936,
-0.0060029537,
0.0660229549,
0.0547887422,
0.0342178382,
0.0522854403,
-0.031347543,
-0.0342840403,
0.0087348036,
0.0577981472,
-0.0230418853,
0.0257912688,
-0.0154091418,
-0.0007371866,
0.0048095267,
-0.0237238128,
-0.051116541,
-0.0592004135,
-0.0232997183,
-0.0197800584,
-0.0056668753,
-0.0529138036,
-0.0633689016,
-0.0506164469,
0.0359875746,
0.0253991932,
-0.0439187735,
-0.0110660261,
-0.0257072821,
0.0650272444,
0.057657294,
-0.0346343108,
0.0484215058,
-0.0621482283,
-0.0447533466,
0.0793360993,
0.0068144756,
0.0596789047,
0.0067118104,
-0.0485519357,
0.0167967342,
-0.0155676426,
-0.00716927,
0.0218175519,
0.0196421407,
-0.0702805072,
-0.0021475987,
0.0932533443,
0.0119562903,
-0.0720217228,
-0.0295932274,
0.0085524851,
-0.0014615514,
0.0082844384,
0.0059299525,
-0.1021061391,
-0.0085505946,
0.029706575,
0.039342057,
-0.0336889885,
-0.0350429155,
-0.022924047,
-0.0942646116,
0.0245154854,
0.0091596013,
0.0029575485,
0.0064340038,
-0.020462852,
-0.0023179336,
0.0081263091,
0.0170367081,
-0.0085001914,
-0.008824788,
-0.0197541416,
-0.0185103919,
-0.0259041041,
-0.0406732485,
0.013977346,
-0.0285027046,
0.0429798625,
0.0396312661,
0.0164505206,
-0.0235860497,
-0.0082032559,
0.048869431,
-0.0074591902,
-0.030839894,
0.0309995599,
0.0683785081,
-0.0313947015,
0.0203724951,
-0.0125066787,
0.0789118856,
-0.0045981915,
-0.0124442047,
0.0232679658,
0.0311335716,
0.0088439379,
-0.0320950896,
-0.0268566366,
-0.006877617,
-0.0156057468,
0.0684620216,
0.0213426761,
-0.0087131755,
-0.0019771031,
-0.0361875854,
0.0287567396,
0.0277469568,
0.0024402176,
0.0151325641,
-0.0201746263,
-0.0526718497,
-0.0338090844,
-0.0054389886,
-0.0067291292,
0.0105805891,
0.0195564795,
0.0196047779,
0.0417174324,
-0.055427365,
-0.0178400837,
0.0076016374,
-0.0795028806,
0.0074796942,
-0.0437628888,
0.0086707743,
0.0139317317,
0.017146131,
-0.0351537615,
0.0034398697,
-0.0964202285,
-0.0951316059,
0.0163464826,
0.0332882591,
0.0221685451,
0.0295001995,
-0.0315167792,
-0.0801432729,
0.0974283591,
0.0511114746,
-0.0420862176,
0.0387111716,
0.0423098095,
-0.0454514064,
-0.0155201359,
0.0377361327,
-0.0400246419,
-0.0218251292,
0.0401453227,
-0.0605161712,
-0.0163159054,
-0.0190198105,
-0.0018185227,
0.0209364668,
0.044925455,
0.005735686,
0.0387660451,
-0.0624569543,
0.0416067131,
-0.0262148697,
-0.0091833379,
-0.0121936603,
-0.0472924262,
0.0290068891,
0.0056775794,
-0.015958894,
0.019786099,
0.0086142942,
0.0668312684,
-0.0492562838,
0.0067799073,
0.0478106663,
0.010437144,
0.0180813614,
-0.019680595,
-0.0125355916,
0.0533717051,
-0.0177125353,
0.0643573701,
-0.0009473645,
0.0315371118,
-0.0103260782,
-0.0070238919,
-0.032154046,
0.0080851009,
-0.0861206055,
-0.0202947594,
0.0032739947,
0.0399272069,
0.0150062619,
-0.0239045285,
0.0320110507,
-0.0443206355,
-0.0250545219,
-0.027327491,
-0.0011715743,
0.0039366009,
-0.0381594747,
0.0382507183,
0.0040999861,
-0.0175467338,
0.0423259884,
0.0834275186,
0.0490145609,
0.0274767969,
-0.0095882891,
-0.0500465967,
-0.0160820317,
-0.0301871598,
0.036236845,
0.0294538476,
-0.037488617,
-0.0075126737,
-0.0553004555,
-0.0662638322,
0.013083078,
0.0130129904,
0.0091566397,
-0.0211808868,
-0.0135151111,
0.0590672642,
0.0152813913,
-0.0414419509,
-0.0442826264,
0.0153313559,
-0.0084694745,
-0.0232358761,
0.0040401155,
-6.038894679e-33,
-0.0088866176,
-0.0394624248,
-0.0430578962,
0.0285792258,
0.0327840336,
0.0347771198,
-0.01537266,
-0.006190307,
-0.0118140262,
-0.0154441204,
-0.0491041392,
0.0360318609,
-0.0017001113,
0.0401004329,
-0.0146792829,
-0.0252976436,
0.0407076254,
-0.0173396971,
-0.0310711544,
0.0151547967,
0.0531337894,
0.0393713787,
0.0494167805,
-0.0562991463,
0.0395060666,
-0.0151009103,
-0.0184948482,
-0.0058090086,
-0.0596474446,
0.0419537835,
-0.019095907,
0.0205312651,
0.0136093739,
0.0023730397,
0.0157196205,
0.0380647108,
-0.0389110744,
-0.0130716721,
0.0084586171,
-0.0045947204,
0.0045113633,
-0.0437852107,
0.0439404994,
-0.0194281247,
-0.0063386038,
-0.0397468507,
0.0363069065,
-0.0140376594,
-0.0256278235,
-0.0451155975,
-0.0323578455,
0.0141041661,
0.0082655773,
0.0244772024,
0.0277137291,
0.0071224114,
0.017430244,
-0.0013512162,
-0.046146825,
0.0264372975,
0.045431789,
0.0251993816,
0.0336821489,
-0.0167215597,
0.0163304303,
0.0524863452,
0.0498141646,
0.0260131173,
0.0029512402,
-0.0107400715,
0.0372291245,
0.0247074049,
0.0167697482,
0.0732975826,
0.0287528746,
0.0009237036,
-0.0493778102,
0.0025493354,
0.0142195858,
0.0123491911,
0.0702817217,
-0.0156394113,
-0.0389384143,
-0.0141859418,
-0.036040172,
-0.0246220175,
-0.0229922887,
0.0041040988,
0.0163787734,
0.0033613446,
-0.0524667315,
-0.0753731728,
0.0093729096,
-0.0528033413,
-0.0462530069,
0.0364384204,
0.0127268489,
-0.0070339274,
-0.011234656,
0.0265295208,
-0.0765622184,
-0.0081934072,
-0.0184207801,
-0.053512603,
0.0216904134,
0.0044469973,
0.0681179166,
0.0200111587,
-0.0594679862,
-0.0093853362,
-0.0180145353,
0.0183650274,
0.0416596644,
0.0369363762,
0.0486220382,
-0.0175097808,
0.0220243502,
0.0121449865,
0.009370626,
0.0351569019,
-0.0578668304,
0.002460527,
-0.0245325603,
-0.0057679894,
-0.0134028541,
-0.0265937615,
-0.0122566512,
0.0419294387,
0.0773974359,
-0.0541028157,
0.0248475485,
-0.0075606313,
2.705e-7,
0.0278884582,
-0.0029069053,
-0.0182479341,
0.0240576994,
0.0237278435,
0.0715077892,
-0.0177615564,
0.0707118809,
0.0088521251,
-0.0259406995,
-0.0171625447,
-0.0032146228,
0.0629438162,
0.0281182323,
-0.0839553326,
-0.0139828669,
-0.0480261184,
0.0284853969,
-0.0745311677,
-0.0183178335,
-0.0058563086,
0.0909782127,
0.0447785519,
-0.0234908108,
0.0011562024,
-0.0798924342,
0.0450533554,
-0.0442845933,
-0.0602304004,
-0.0072446153,
0.0979054794,
0.037599843,
-0.0073733344,
-0.0080889147,
-0.0281361938,
0.039398279,
-0.0440222248,
0.0558687039,
0.0445376374,
0.0027225653,
-0.0108165015,
-0.0392939262,
-0.0229809135,
-0.0305232406,
0.0657952949,
0.0102936104,
-0.0463172868,
-0.0600266308,
0.0201836266,
-0.1013385877,
0.0347172655,
-0.01699071,
-0.0173499212,
0.0019481588,
-0.0096815908,
-0.0332937278,
0.0215177406,
-0.0872102156,
-0.0136131346,
-0.0427546985,
-0.0318682529,
-0.0345467106,
-0.0185355786,
0.0129167959,
0.0083310818,
-0.0475411639,
0.0478838943,
2.653917728e-34,
0.0149320411,
-0.0003938925,
-0.0300480295,
0.0365673192,
0.035296537,
-0.0140332021,
0.0357753001,
0.0016352778,
-0.0057945182,
-0.102968514,
-0.0063394792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15004v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15004v1 | When Language Models Fall in Love: Animacy Processing in Transformer Language Models | 2023-10-23T14:57:52 | 2023-10-23T14:57:52 | Michael Hanna, Yonatan Belinkov, Sandro Pezzelle | cs.CL | cs.CL | Animacy - whether an entity is alive and sentient - is fundamental to
cognitive processing, impacting areas such as memory, vision, and language.
However, animacy is not always expressed directly in language: in English it
often manifests indirectly, in the form of selectional constraints on verbs and
adjectives. This poses a potential issue for transformer language models (LMs):
they often train only on text, and thus lack access to extralinguistic
information from which humans learn about animacy. We ask: how does this impact
LMs' animacy processing - do they still behave as humans do? We answer this
question using open-source LMs. Like previous studies, we find that LMs behave
much like humans when presented with entities whose animacy is typical.
However, we also show that even when presented with stories about atypically
animate entities, such as a peanut in love, LMs adapt: they treat these
entities as animate, though they do not adapt as well as humans. Even when the
context indicating atypical animacy is very short, LMs pick up on subtle clues
and change their behavior. We conclude that despite the limited signal through
which LMs can learn about animacy, they are indeed sensitive to the relevant
lexical semantic nuances available in English. | [
0.0390788652,
0.0343826488,
-0.0665363222,
0.0526404195,
0.0207408015,
0.0245914273,
-0.0003322762,
-0.0091114528,
-0.0402407758,
-0.0436396301,
-0.0514898784,
-0.0406566821,
-0.0133474506,
0.007534266,
0.0238760654,
-0.0663670897,
0.0525839627,
-0.010634385,
-0.0300697498,
-0.0039093965,
-0.0442070849,
0.0195625592,
0.0017035517,
0.0056158109,
-0.0283877831,
0.012794937,
-0.0445378497,
-0.0088688079,
0.0059238039,
-0.0090178624,
-0.0295668021,
-0.0129708042,
0.0312450677,
-0.0018158414,
0.0000017221,
-0.046918042,
0.0291861035,
-0.0236450601,
0.0251363348,
-0.0206681043,
0.0479764938,
-0.0275071673,
-0.0129739838,
-0.0450524054,
-0.0460251682,
0.0106202113,
0.0772375837,
0.013145783,
0.0152304638,
0.0471164472,
-0.0146015426,
-0.0195276346,
-0.0294354651,
0.0025948852,
0.0151418317,
0.0331502035,
0.0185222309,
-0.0365068987,
0.0231754724,
-0.0105940988,
-0.0751471519,
0.0391413569,
0.0580774136,
0.0038259302,
-0.015784964,
0.0278609376,
0.0118690422,
-0.0608785674,
0.0094661079,
0.0271048527,
-0.0122156618,
-0.0102396719,
-0.0097168647,
0.0005150506,
0.0314842165,
0.0414236598,
0.0053042881,
0.044253327,
0.0228569899,
0.0297282394,
-0.0214601997,
-0.0266104657,
0.0046119876,
0.0253051817,
0.0101350099,
0.0682832301,
-0.0040787226,
-0.0056779305,
0.0113598863,
0.0280546807,
-0.0352043957,
-0.008455921,
0.0455561765,
0.0276405532,
0.018199835,
0.0209805928,
-0.0351894461,
0.0316073671,
-0.0143464915,
-0.1010249183,
-0.0404747277,
-0.0069052833,
-0.0799282864,
0.0350399576,
-0.018082926,
0.0409483835,
0.0085484823,
0.0695385411,
-0.0404692441,
0.0436828546,
-0.0027040211,
-0.0209988374,
-0.0341922455,
0.0290949997,
-0.0017060654,
0.0043960232,
-0.0108532012,
0.0167482644,
-0.0301018134,
-0.0433658808,
-0.0445086882,
0.0304453876,
-0.0367858633,
-0.0031641235,
-0.0631564334,
0.0173075926,
-0.0141309798,
0.0406289622,
-0.0555507392,
-0.0750281066,
-0.014598418,
-0.018258417,
0.0060036383,
-0.0155452276,
-0.0086911768,
0.0264721848,
0.0322907604,
-0.0617778674,
0.0201085936,
0.031388998,
0.0008283285,
-0.0336583555,
0.0182425827,
0.0002209009,
0.0050415578,
-0.0085371071,
0.0366824567,
-0.0787072405,
0.0193324145,
-0.0089946343,
0.0095157633,
0.0875199065,
-0.0000909863,
0.0343734324,
-0.0328445248,
0.0217412952,
0.0697155595,
0.0782677829,
0.0349061005,
0.0163993295,
0.0079535656,
-0.0363954306,
0.011313593,
0.0048889583,
-0.031382177,
0.0124674141,
-0.0063797967,
-0.0214975532,
-0.0272167847,
0.0310301278,
0.0485815741,
0.0563825965,
0.017656669,
-0.0629319102,
0.0599990524,
0.0171503797,
-0.066175282,
0.0205335934,
0.085263364,
-0.0255383588,
0.0175645929,
0.0550883785,
-0.0665738657,
0.0511280373,
0.0039438619,
-0.0179401413,
-0.055354666,
0.0538893715,
-0.0357248932,
-0.0254067406,
-0.0331600234,
-0.0038779455,
0.0216897633,
-0.0220924877,
0.0084504206,
0.0766976029,
-0.0256262198,
0.023159517,
0.005458829,
-0.0394322947,
0.0292700008,
-0.0323239341,
0.0004622411,
0.0185158402,
0.0067478223,
-0.0217224732,
-0.0133338515,
0.0196755715,
-0.0223095566,
0.1042331606,
0.0030435526,
0.0060501071,
0.0076728649,
0.0151286824,
0.0524453484,
-0.0289649758,
0.0323172547,
-0.0088587562,
-0.0554358624,
0.0156478342,
0.0017059749,
-0.0095493216,
-0.0208646581,
0.0678661317,
-0.0490369089,
0.0081087742,
-0.0554392636,
0.0102096507,
0.0088816453,
-0.0463833921,
0.0137865916,
-0.0057879766,
0.0298274793,
0.0045117666,
0.0062968698,
0.1023453027,
-0.0499959514,
-0.0016299431,
0.0339311585,
-0.0107460478,
-0.0103769423,
0.0235035922,
0.018978199,
0.0116248783,
0.0252438337,
-0.0773400143,
0.0548565611,
-0.0169457737,
0.0844669268,
-0.0221175365,
0.0206787772,
-0.0014045658,
0.0035593167,
-0.0107513908,
0.0390161499,
-0.0200957153,
-0.0061550643,
-0.026401056,
-0.0203937255,
-0.03798474,
0.0415614247,
0.0135445595,
-0.0220651794,
-0.0391239673,
-0.0334302299,
-0.0665980279,
-0.0209118668,
-0.0340136029,
-0.0393433794,
0.0451828651,
0.0071445205,
0.0185600389,
-0.0237280931,
-0.0190188698,
0.0216736328,
-0.0131134652,
0.0652780309,
-0.0191403497,
0.0294654593,
0.0077990126,
-0.0091172261,
-0.0251202099,
-0.0063168677,
0.0212568603,
-0.0206867531,
0.0301008597,
-0.0041758665,
-0.0133813815,
-0.0363856219,
0.072832644,
-0.0647977144,
-0.0142984483,
0.0138113564,
-0.0590595119,
0.0325064734,
0.0102920048,
0.0377160721,
0.0752823353,
0.0160388295,
0.0678498521,
0.0839898884,
-0.0386246927,
-0.0281925276,
0.0023106646,
-0.0208955649,
-0.0143736368,
-0.0329605751,
-0.037847966,
0.0175503176,
0.1182118133,
-0.0150545537,
-0.0185534079,
-0.047609441,
0.0677734837,
-0.0224408507,
-0.0383930504,
0.0333299227,
-0.0035192873,
-0.0047128578,
0.0245091561,
-0.0174297635,
-0.0393273793,
0.0848949179,
-0.0058313473,
-0.0643335953,
0.0017327891,
0.0552523024,
0.0075869909,
0.0640274882,
0.0505314767,
0.0014779398,
0.0542024113,
0.012495013,
-0.0886052921,
0.0071146968,
-0.0406844579,
-0.0350404382,
0.0528273024,
-0.0379794799,
-0.0071684062,
0.0132607762,
-0.0077687507,
-0.0371382758,
0.0255469382,
-0.0328821316,
0.0054002223,
-0.0434445366,
-0.024819592,
-0.0411996692,
-0.0060936566,
-0.0065676249,
0.0225331653,
0.0034360404,
-0.0356488265,
-0.0051126662,
-0.0276212692,
0.0494927503,
0.0363913812,
0.0403880291,
-0.0404928587,
0.0425713621,
0.0483325049,
-0.0457611233,
-0.0110023525,
-0.0247775838,
0.01142684,
0.0062805032,
-0.027774442,
0.0069926544,
0.003989453,
0.0171082206,
-0.0573186129,
-0.0940278098,
0.0607740059,
0.0389876813,
0.0205408838,
0.0574820973,
-0.0280220769,
0.0134067321,
0.0213465989,
0.0164917372,
-0.060212668,
0.0105028627,
0.0092591997,
-0.0181808099,
-0.0009296756,
-0.017427545,
-0.0023111668,
-0.0838906839,
0.0406967886,
-0.0098495865,
-0.0213014726,
-0.0119837234,
0.0151577471,
0.0291317087,
-0.0048696054,
0.0298345517,
0.0178004205,
-0.0375121757,
0.0005430183,
-0.0122070024,
0.0573122576,
-0.0280409139,
0.0077841152,
0.0068419403,
0.036666058,
0.003508294,
0.0510243811,
-0.0443278514,
-0.0520159118,
-0.0077922097,
0.0539792664,
-0.002944855,
-0.0103157228,
-0.0119106965,
0.0030613062,
-0.0085094627,
-0.0335059799,
-0.0190100893,
0.0288418755,
-0.0540542416,
-0.0128576541,
0.0445384644,
-0.0422931723,
-0.097876884,
-0.0130654993,
0.0318791345,
-0.0319210403,
0.0731943846,
0.0353605561,
-0.0749874935,
0.0096456707,
-0.0164908879,
-0.0000230149,
0.0282619819,
-0.1256444156,
0.002308721,
-0.0182210598,
-0.0180458408,
-0.1085506454,
0.0048666531,
0.0135110607,
0.0348331593,
0.0560068265,
-0.0596467815,
0.0413841568,
-0.0358810499,
-0.0327721238,
0.0388166457,
-0.0013616846,
-0.0206098463,
-0.0116936164,
-0.0323261544,
0.0677340254,
-0.0464405306,
0.0158799216,
-0.022068955,
-0.0461730212,
-0.0401198789,
0.0735237449,
0.0347298272,
0.0307717603,
0.0003905241,
0.0008235389,
-0.0300790332,
0.029102847,
0.0740190521,
-0.0058075236,
0.0584070906,
-0.0040738881,
0.0082849441,
-0.0125511428,
0.0227433946,
0.0019690376,
0.0268454552,
0.0236458723,
-0.0178491268,
-0.0271120872,
-0.0276577976,
0.0229060873,
-0.0018829898,
-0.0030976823,
-0.0021270507,
0.0010608326,
-0.0272987802,
-0.0249696895,
-0.0112236449,
0.0020659734,
-0.02422777,
-0.0415982455,
0.0275060441,
0.0911244527,
-0.0015536391,
-0.0520981438,
-0.0157774519,
-0.0172494613,
0.0366408899,
-0.0501052327,
0.0446619429,
-0.03805672,
-0.0283571836,
0.0471742414,
0.0187732112,
0.0162427686,
-0.0477050059,
0.0714717731,
0.012312795,
0.0545010678,
-0.0067741219,
-0.0112540629,
-0.0297797769,
-0.0011476883,
-0.0177083332,
0.0247735046,
-0.0137110315,
0.0092094513,
0.0357081592,
-0.0563519709,
0.0496514738,
-0.0649219453,
0.020117376,
0.0073980992,
0.0013054628,
0.035446737,
-0.0412935913,
0.0122244395,
0.0195049923,
-0.0111574354,
0.0042950283,
0.0236494597,
-0.0388688743,
0.0648625717,
0.0115588047,
-0.0091747139,
0.007252499,
-0.0332753435,
-0.0425881334,
-0.0501085855,
-0.0129970517,
-0.0106376354,
-0.0356339552,
-0.0629842356,
0.007171148,
-0.0079344055,
-0.0010136272,
-0.0731643736,
0.033411514,
0.0137064382,
0.0077796709,
-0.0327538438,
-0.0368423983,
0.0043273796,
0.0240377877,
0.0150707718,
-0.0049995268,
-5.426624488e-33,
-0.0829155892,
-0.0060871388,
-0.0318831652,
0.0023238959,
-0.0256438293,
0.0270152669,
-0.0416670181,
0.0178356394,
-0.0074987952,
0.0286571849,
0.0259227678,
0.0247565266,
0.0073683402,
-0.0214811042,
0.0222437307,
-0.0117224352,
0.0054149418,
0.0079493467,
-0.0203829147,
-0.0412285104,
0.0059421794,
0.0011178189,
0.061494112,
-0.0405006334,
0.0388888903,
0.0427221097,
-0.0505607501,
0.0030860719,
-0.0228642859,
0.0300280564,
-0.0444500484,
0.0254656244,
0.0286486354,
-0.0061580269,
-0.0278162379,
-0.0057338476,
-0.0307850931,
-0.0068580951,
0.0536204688,
0.0354443528,
-0.0622134656,
-0.0267696753,
0.0791585892,
-0.0203744397,
-0.0254455376,
0.0204864684,
0.0246588048,
-0.0601239614,
0.048761759,
-0.0143998004,
-0.063989535,
-0.0553658269,
-0.0070984629,
-0.0129008135,
0.0583961755,
-0.0294820853,
-0.028536424,
0.0001945959,
-0.0483732671,
0.0194499604,
-0.0130028958,
0.0127814524,
0.0296274107,
0.0140133845,
0.0197008196,
0.0957885534,
0.0317203812,
0.0381498337,
-0.0574962534,
0.0299437363,
0.0857186764,
0.0441280901,
0.0599669442,
0.0341797359,
0.0400375091,
0.0106430324,
0.0052987277,
0.0252876636,
-0.0026332489,
0.051526729,
0.0487321354,
0.0034751121,
-0.0177503731,
0.0066119735,
0.0172276646,
-0.0265966412,
0.0008109253,
-0.0512951873,
-0.0328670368,
-0.0252174269,
-0.0118795866,
0.0107254414,
0.0147850281,
-0.0159131512,
-0.0299122669,
-0.0328531191,
-0.0452095456,
0.0333551392,
-0.0174240842,
-0.0149152102,
0.0127621479,
-0.0479967967,
0.0462394729,
0.0437388271,
0.0358029306,
0.0462102033,
0.0199309215,
0.0275773183,
-0.0636381879,
-0.0079772361,
-0.0206770655,
-0.0274086446,
0.0011935636,
-0.0054266187,
0.0208630245,
0.0068726777,
-0.0183433685,
0.0061564334,
0.03561588,
-0.0276873671,
-0.0822473466,
0.0577666759,
-0.0479289889,
0.0383518003,
-0.0612278357,
-0.035791643,
-0.0362410955,
0.0291434508,
0.0397677198,
-0.0877144411,
-0.0175627023,
-0.0216813069,
2.642e-7,
0.0209823698,
0.0212303009,
-0.0026047025,
-0.0266434513,
0.0444966853,
0.0204179361,
-0.0109197814,
0.0242286567,
0.0623184741,
-0.0254074782,
-0.0099952482,
0.0059489426,
0.0360256359,
0.0488765128,
-0.0698920935,
0.0122274589,
-0.0241682157,
0.0436204895,
-0.0415373705,
-0.0205629133,
-0.0319216214,
0.05865198,
0.040417742,
-0.0086833015,
-0.026855167,
-0.0104941279,
0.0252469294,
-0.0535767823,
0.0249813311,
0.0110177435,
-0.0192923937,
0.0422726758,
0.024901187,
0.0059432518,
-0.011461298,
0.0073814807,
0.0115486123,
0.0336360894,
-0.0043287631,
0.0092386752,
0.0185750276,
0.0185983144,
-0.0354394168,
-0.0296365041,
0.0584216714,
-0.081513986,
-0.0343076326,
0.0459715985,
0.0093814405,
-0.0316295996,
-0.0189637803,
-0.022244757,
-0.042166844,
0.0339131579,
0.001105888,
0.004857847,
-0.0229257345,
-0.0314878859,
-0.0357661843,
-0.0223922711,
-0.0376966186,
-0.029171722,
-0.0130705517,
-0.0012406008,
-0.0110810529,
-0.0440629162,
-0.013225344,
1.786041525e-34,
0.0104670096,
0.0507015511,
0.0420854464,
0.0552428178,
0.010856675,
-0.004873544,
0.100526832,
0.0174714234,
0.0222210754,
-0.0221093297,
0.0014025527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14997v1 | Simple Hardware-Efficient PCFGs with Independent Left and Right Productions | 2023-10-23T14:48:51 | 2023-10-23T14:48:51 | Wei Liu, Songlin Yang, Yoon Kim, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Scaling dense PCFGs to thousands of nonterminals via a low-rank
parameterization of the rule probability tensor has been shown to be beneficial
for unsupervised parsing. However, PCFGs scaled this way still perform poorly
as a language model, and even underperform similarly-sized HMMs. This work
introduces \emph{SimplePCFG}, a simple PCFG formalism with independent left and
right productions. Despite imposing a stronger independence assumption than the
low-rank approach, we find that this formalism scales more effectively both as
a language model and as an unsupervised parser. As an unsupervised parser, our
simple PCFG obtains an average F1 of 65.1 on the English PTB, and as a language
model, it obtains a perplexity of 119.0, outperforming similarly-sized low-rank
PCFGs. We further introduce \emph{FlashInside}, a hardware IO-aware
implementation of the inside algorithm for efficiently scaling simple PCFGs. | [
-0.0190165807,
0.0398458987,
0.001783423,
0.0172442086,
-0.0534779616,
0.0276709478,
0.0482544489,
-0.0154898278,
-0.038707152,
-0.0266355518,
-0.0237791985,
-0.0580835752,
0.0088640861,
0.0486487933,
0.0013482497,
-0.0118652247,
0.0707527548,
-0.0665392503,
0.0017451233,
0.0266670883,
-0.0049707196,
0.0013146658,
-0.0600360408,
0.0168108456,
-0.0264745615,
-0.0335619561,
-0.0389936492,
-0.0046541509,
-0.0319355354,
-0.0065985816,
-0.0727598593,
0.0411154553,
-0.0189085808,
0.0206305962,
0.0000017792,
-0.027001895,
-0.0302978624,
0.0268460736,
0.0556174144,
0.0215641279,
0.0438856184,
-0.0080338102,
-0.04603035,
-0.0199650433,
0.0020081827,
-0.0288036391,
0.0564872399,
0.0535904579,
-0.0099873599,
0.0902358815,
-0.011096702,
-0.0298622642,
0.0121290619,
-0.0012549886,
-0.0618520789,
-0.0081773819,
-0.0104451841,
-0.0637473986,
-0.0160417743,
-0.0311898384,
-0.0283637885,
0.0079873176,
-0.0181035679,
-0.028735809,
0.0283826143,
0.0108422153,
-0.0414473563,
-0.0019758719,
0.0106091136,
0.0503954515,
-0.0167481918,
-0.0370983742,
0.0346970707,
0.009302347,
-0.046244368,
-0.0353195257,
-0.0356030203,
0.0664233565,
-0.0411735997,
0.0200306587,
0.076786682,
-0.0052257553,
0.020986177,
-0.0350363553,
-0.0282707736,
0.0899902359,
0.0485870279,
-0.0195544604,
-0.0396006778,
0.0052436851,
-0.0566657595,
0.0110843927,
0.0415218994,
-0.0363211334,
-0.0138604278,
-0.014397786,
-0.0171161145,
-0.027882373,
-0.0327706896,
-0.0504663028,
0.0640710294,
0.0689748898,
0.0192343853,
0.0327507034,
0.0095079895,
-0.0096539846,
-0.0280965194,
-0.0093080811,
-0.0851670876,
0.0193296876,
-0.0252592452,
-0.0110117085,
-0.0536316894,
0.0428489111,
-0.0682634711,
-0.0513505079,
-0.0362146981,
-0.0196879283,
0.0004991895,
-0.0576473586,
0.0539970174,
-0.0278419424,
-0.0290348865,
0.021555448,
0.0440973081,
0.0858791694,
-0.0043790201,
-0.0512483157,
-0.0105429403,
-0.0507157743,
-0.0402916744,
0.0364315324,
0.0296575036,
0.0075872573,
-0.0264091622,
0.0191529747,
0.0010632562,
-0.0262685083,
0.0046036113,
-0.0116033703,
-0.0193738788,
-0.0277083106,
0.0013528127,
-0.0567871667,
0.034293551,
-0.0066279368,
0.0019441063,
-0.0043277121,
-0.0015928713,
0.0527303182,
0.0234122742,
0.0386586003,
0.0306793321,
-0.0098506035,
-0.0026731875,
-0.0074366,
0.0023653014,
0.045242548,
0.0283820983,
-0.0359279849,
0.0306053609,
-0.0259079095,
-0.0334874466,
0.0716227964,
-0.0406198688,
-0.0341970213,
-0.0263528507,
-0.0476600192,
0.0120459246,
0.0095232651,
0.0787841007,
0.0601404496,
-0.0198271535,
-0.0076582003,
-0.0008749835,
0.0384578221,
0.0014917023,
0.009549628,
0.0616324469,
0.0119449208,
-0.0122496812,
-0.0079608597,
-0.0036615327,
-0.0490038209,
-0.0098333508,
0.0077377968,
-0.006946682,
0.032619983,
0.0084071858,
0.0295579098,
0.016210353,
-0.0325851813,
0.0134722367,
-0.0411046706,
0.1052200422,
0.003842222,
0.0012591326,
0.0489772037,
0.0138164703,
-0.0585658811,
-0.0339251198,
-0.0062505025,
0.0333830975,
0.0364434868,
0.0554786809,
-0.0095970854,
0.045041278,
0.0330613106,
0.0293319095,
0.0251741298,
0.009798592,
0.0212557167,
0.0127998749,
-0.0364878699,
0.0104137203,
0.0579342209,
0.0077422606,
0.0330652222,
-0.0094490377,
-0.0001513476,
0.0024255353,
-0.0161755644,
0.040110603,
-0.0015804087,
0.0437326431,
0.0155443093,
0.0305697266,
-0.0336957648,
0.0506843217,
0.0371581651,
-0.0143756894,
0.0788190514,
0.0455268994,
-0.0679841042,
0.0383833982,
-0.0000744396,
-0.0590718761,
-0.0426750556,
0.048363708,
-0.0204284396,
-0.0002338497,
-0.0162747372,
0.0120425737,
-0.0418333001,
0.0482208766,
-0.028206028,
0.0348467752,
-0.0448428988,
0.0214384105,
0.0406387411,
0.0122478455,
-0.0463951528,
0.0552273765,
-0.0140975751,
0.0238450877,
0.0231244061,
0.0191640723,
0.0351117998,
-0.0531370081,
-0.0295524467,
0.0323062949,
0.0117239235,
-0.0449413471,
-0.0183506012,
-0.0295512583,
-0.0287053287,
-0.0008605798,
-0.0901328847,
0.0025236448,
-0.009317331,
0.0319714248,
0.0437789522,
0.0413637571,
0.0215361621,
-0.0080262758,
-0.0072747464,
-0.001891278,
0.0183516387,
0.0263736174,
-0.0049582575,
-0.0070519452,
-0.0536477976,
0.0025165712,
-0.0464337766,
-0.0210045688,
0.0051054549,
-0.0181769058,
-0.024820473,
-0.0670477301,
0.0290529579,
0.0094439918,
0.0425121114,
-0.0181051977,
-0.0046745478,
0.0211546998,
-0.0712203309,
0.0355078951,
0.0142341079,
-0.0229770746,
-0.0196716376,
0.0155667104,
-0.0405124128,
-0.0078520952,
-0.0038212631,
0.0205770377,
0.0139886253,
-0.0174919292,
0.0194798727,
-0.0149493283,
0.0631012172,
0.02984819,
0.0125280749,
-0.0166354254,
-0.0339953676,
-0.0424397476,
-0.0439622439,
-0.0112592988,
-0.0459247716,
-0.0197694246,
0.0302712284,
-0.006239811,
-0.0298550427,
0.038183786,
-0.0744081736,
-0.0168767422,
-0.0511656441,
-0.0064443713,
-0.038026344,
0.0647941306,
0.0238706321,
0.0193544403,
-0.0316208526,
-0.0470399521,
0.0176095534,
0.0289031919,
0.0209952556,
-0.0389220566,
0.0146536017,
-0.0831803456,
0.0270519536,
-0.0062451931,
-0.040027909,
0.0013092598,
-0.0656588078,
-0.0263583101,
0.0014707784,
0.0325832777,
-0.0410045311,
0.0198961049,
0.0885188654,
0.0126699042,
0.0249091852,
-0.0010274113,
0.0149507895,
0.0019172756,
0.0538116135,
0.0379283912,
0.0123150833,
0.0085000247,
0.0184483547,
0.0048114867,
0.0816395953,
0.031819839,
-0.0138656646,
-0.0220100135,
0.0398280658,
0.0028805977,
0.0018771063,
-0.0808858126,
-0.0017579983,
0.0034768276,
-0.0467398986,
-0.0363198407,
0.1279834956,
0.0315985642,
-0.0421473533,
0.0160648897,
-0.0007545054,
0.0406165794,
-0.0132830068,
0.0237126332,
-0.0832662284,
-0.0103113158,
0.0176841132,
0.0348615684,
0.0286318008,
-0.0365419984,
0.0172209013,
-0.1130544767,
0.0430782773,
0.0586109385,
0.0397848822,
-0.0348217972,
-0.0392085575,
-0.0501322076,
-0.0161430407,
-0.0210922658,
0.0453494005,
-0.0316683911,
0.0391839966,
0.0385921896,
-0.0522003695,
-0.012689135,
-0.0053740712,
-0.033402767,
0.038847886,
0.0413376167,
-0.0617492944,
-0.0215337463,
-0.0455172025,
-0.0004637924,
-0.0294183232,
0.0244901218,
-0.0635641962,
-0.049393937,
0.011819928,
-0.024433665,
-0.0225169268,
0.0028703036,
-0.04044348,
-0.0129265236,
-0.037676964,
0.0481735654,
-0.0296392944,
-0.0064571607,
0.0082088411,
0.0113059748,
-0.0122783119,
0.0682267398,
0.0058345124,
-0.0049820836,
-0.0350807346,
-0.0136477863,
0.0030745151,
-0.0162914265,
0.0052620913,
-0.0196673106,
0.0416435786,
-0.0617491119,
-0.0419278368,
0.0157387666,
0.0348395929,
0.061163079,
-0.0504316241,
0.0260379687,
0.0245933887,
0.0262977127,
-0.0414960124,
0.035589885,
-0.0189114865,
0.0161867179,
-0.0689202622,
0.0065156412,
0.0479358472,
0.0300587267,
-0.0307697486,
0.0362060815,
-0.0198637787,
-0.0368916132,
0.0577383004,
0.0233953781,
0.0190102439,
0.0140783861,
-0.0264426619,
-0.0119260186,
-0.040174026,
0.0239128731,
-0.0295882709,
0.0607878715,
-0.0010678091,
-0.0264277551,
-0.0010940646,
0.0178573262,
-0.0040828953,
-0.0043083248,
-0.0445322022,
0.0848321691,
-0.0266902857,
-0.0401161723,
0.0330957733,
0.0603706352,
0.0699648261,
-0.0322556235,
0.0391934291,
0.0042905975,
0.0004280734,
-0.0607411154,
-0.0014367484,
-0.0689629987,
0.0125788087,
0.0235471614,
-0.0254529137,
-0.0181630924,
-0.0315832607,
-0.0083956318,
-0.0207799654,
0.0382886082,
0.004103418,
0.0127609307,
-0.0395855978,
0.0112577751,
-0.0192013215,
-0.0077693453,
0.0046818592,
0.0046049906,
0.015887944,
-0.0627253205,
0.0363016985,
0.0160071831,
-0.0014264416,
-0.0750568062,
0.0252647996,
-0.0231936872,
0.0300627332,
0.0085641807,
-0.0222329162,
0.0773649737,
-0.0124384211,
0.083640106,
-0.0123632969,
-0.0076483935,
-0.0255864039,
0.0334674865,
0.0399174243,
0.0169346463,
0.0285767894,
0.0066697733,
-0.0194334593,
-0.0073148631,
0.0725880042,
0.0147782676,
0.0199073348,
0.0137289278,
0.0000074636,
-0.0434377901,
-0.0106605571,
-0.0579556376,
0.0959138647,
-0.0415699221,
-0.0228123888,
-0.0145968804,
-0.0204959065,
-0.0262283795,
0.0323909223,
0.0008053178,
-0.0365950242,
0.0442826711,
0.0331817567,
-0.0206377879,
-0.0400226526,
0.0025486026,
0.0227336641,
0.0375924855,
-0.0630458668,
-0.0302604344,
-5.610263888e-33,
-0.0359988213,
0.0360997431,
-0.0016111258,
0.0313357301,
-0.0027470675,
-0.0147699025,
-0.0254163463,
0.0603652857,
0.0470986702,
0.0176543742,
-0.0256602373,
-0.0123497183,
0.0330050737,
0.0378302671,
0.0363484174,
0.0096044736,
0.0689289719,
-0.0576624759,
0.0285567902,
0.0206712261,
0.0310222376,
0.041497007,
0.0398893431,
-0.0404874869,
-0.0313200653,
-0.0169369783,
-0.0301851537,
0.0337062664,
0.0010089779,
0.0432705283,
-0.0149028804,
-0.0043203756,
0.0045930385,
0.0211397242,
-0.0284350235,
0.013800052,
-0.108426407,
-0.0017607937,
0.036922805,
0.0171660297,
0.0093353204,
-0.0035391389,
-0.0169982165,
0.016494533,
-0.0101463897,
0.0294873081,
-0.0285085458,
-0.0099189626,
-0.0043969173,
-0.005457921,
0.0158949457,
0.0472068042,
0.0059460779,
0.0456510112,
0.0657331273,
-0.0393208936,
-0.0457023457,
-0.000533678,
-0.0445976034,
0.0207037628,
-0.0119319363,
0.0597285107,
0.0775096491,
0.0063393107,
0.0119474269,
0.0174894612,
0.0639898032,
-0.0538917482,
-0.0397769809,
0.0240754858,
-0.0079737566,
0.0141819734,
-0.0069967895,
0.0188944787,
0.0604264736,
0.0450108908,
-0.0604549684,
-0.0068710535,
0.06472978,
-0.0005955482,
-0.0009690984,
0.0225346014,
-0.1095284149,
-0.0489709526,
0.0219099987,
-0.0217264257,
-0.0160174426,
-0.0258265063,
0.029997943,
-0.0063078306,
-0.0119049707,
-0.0099952221,
0.0384617783,
-0.0381091163,
-0.0082578668,
-0.021405777,
0.0383143723,
0.0492899641,
-0.0108299609,
-0.0149240205,
-0.0618309416,
-0.0465595722,
-0.0005432175,
0.0243646335,
0.0101308692,
-0.0108576231,
-0.0049405321,
0.0275005847,
-0.0738138556,
-0.0123195508,
-0.0110687288,
-0.0020327815,
-0.0280203763,
0.0598778278,
-0.0073606716,
-0.015054537,
0.0054960116,
0.0076904902,
-0.0181755964,
0.0373753086,
-0.0044754827,
-0.0087248469,
0.0209748652,
0.0183403362,
0.0104998928,
-0.0016916322,
-0.0126480712,
0.0363591649,
0.0759740919,
-0.0374343172,
-0.0169539787,
0.0787542388,
2.55e-7,
0.068783775,
0.01575532,
0.0614912026,
-0.027529452,
0.0489995666,
-0.0021614986,
0.02354322,
0.0056581311,
-0.0231566131,
0.0299963821,
0.0013947195,
0.0108008189,
-0.0000700104,
-0.0026180639,
-0.0778701156,
0.0015330572,
-0.0418391079,
0.0341028646,
-0.0225385018,
0.0001102852,
-0.00478215,
0.1101230532,
-0.0313585028,
-0.0034601518,
0.0299310535,
-0.0120425997,
0.0070310524,
0.0117298486,
0.0110206557,
-0.0336032435,
0.0132946568,
-0.0261461027,
0.0107146101,
0.0185955837,
0.0058415369,
0.0188552272,
0.0118417498,
0.0739221498,
-0.0307578035,
0.0341320597,
0.0471437462,
-0.0265907887,
-0.0080773151,
-0.0410568751,
0.0438431092,
0.0088922884,
-0.0065713977,
-0.0272842105,
-0.0444451645,
0.0006719144,
-0.0530472957,
0.0278534275,
-0.0246925652,
0.0224143751,
0.0526150092,
-0.0378687717,
-0.0246633831,
-0.0203383416,
-0.0486936904,
0.000623743,
-0.0283729639,
-0.0554885305,
-0.0164814014,
0.0275295582,
0.0272334833,
-0.0249179937,
-0.038074553,
2.638819743e-34,
0.0637858286,
-0.0145141836,
0.0035181504,
-0.0093483068,
0.0241309106,
-0.0363440588,
0.0078843627,
-0.0020423129,
-0.0493813977,
-0.1338042468,
-0.0363101661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14993v1 | Understanding the Inner Workings of Language Models Through Representation Dissimilarity | 2023-10-23T14:46:20 | 2023-10-23T14:46:20 | Davis Brown, Charles Godfrey, Nicholas Konz, Jonathan Tu, Henry Kvinge | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | As language models are applied to an increasing number of real-world
applications, understanding their inner workings has become an important issue
in model trust, interpretability, and transparency. In this work we show that
representation dissimilarity measures, which are functions that measure the
extent to which two model's internal representations differ, can be a valuable
tool for gaining insight into the mechanics of language models. Among our
insights are: (i) an apparent asymmetry in the internal representations of
model using SoLU and GeLU activation functions, (ii) evidence that
dissimilarity measures can identify and locate generalization properties of
models that are invisible via in-distribution test set performance, and (iii)
new evaluations of how language model features vary as width and depth are
increased. Our results suggest that dissimilarity measures are a promising set
of tools for shedding light on the inner workings of language models. | [
0.0118511654,
0.0399116538,
-0.0422196165,
0.0783405602,
-0.0410145372,
0.0095693879,
0.0266031362,
0.0121691525,
-0.0290269554,
-0.0449797362,
-0.0490192771,
-0.0798322186,
0.0412039235,
0.0516591519,
0.0431686938,
-0.0319636352,
0.0613166168,
-0.0242864303,
-0.0043602972,
-0.0092118559,
-0.0051709777,
-0.0105097825,
0.0475315787,
0.0719421059,
0.0600284413,
-0.0187432393,
0.0045689391,
-0.016514603,
-0.0210364927,
0.0101120314,
-0.0236118119,
0.044826068,
0.0163309984,
0.0628113598,
0.0000017208,
-0.0577607825,
-0.0097648306,
-0.005687682,
-0.0011063536,
0.048395928,
0.032667648,
-0.0335727073,
-0.0014396447,
0.0092725214,
-0.0120140361,
-0.0130611248,
0.0612344705,
0.0111447126,
-0.0083739776,
0.0385528803,
-0.0094449632,
-0.0079513453,
0.0033208039,
-0.0178172383,
-0.0050529768,
0.0000814711,
0.0229632482,
0.0099313492,
-0.0276216306,
-0.0289924126,
-0.0345041603,
0.0097760223,
0.0010647458,
0.0096634785,
-0.0194443688,
0.0214149691,
-0.0030408141,
-0.0105275083,
0.0167980529,
0.0182041842,
-0.0328226723,
-0.0672385246,
-0.0183626115,
-0.0087532382,
-0.0122447237,
0.0720655546,
-0.0424921326,
0.0065624006,
0.0239109863,
0.0297431964,
0.0228052996,
0.0096652778,
0.0505272076,
-0.0443900041,
-0.0366126858,
0.0680633932,
0.0302081611,
-0.0089646764,
-0.0365922712,
-0.0226077661,
-0.0268726088,
-0.056380339,
-0.004044882,
-0.006034473,
0.0077967755,
0.0150571689,
0.0036432464,
-0.0166616347,
0.0347561724,
-0.0527149253,
0.0800031871,
0.0363657027,
-0.0272243377,
-0.0023741608,
-0.0356874056,
0.1197423264,
0.0011018278,
0.0366361924,
-0.0330476314,
0.0298228413,
-0.0668414831,
-0.040823184,
0.0029089376,
-0.0020157192,
0.0033903669,
-0.0153838182,
-0.0278825071,
0.0219728742,
-0.0204518959,
0.0008345436,
0.0054419716,
-0.0399187393,
-0.0151121188,
0.0221254807,
-0.026759211,
0.0063877371,
-0.0341991223,
0.0057381908,
-0.0341740698,
-0.0699913278,
0.0019560696,
-0.0093429908,
-0.0249868315,
-0.0194959529,
-0.0419350788,
0.0723383501,
0.0149573255,
-0.0269331038,
-0.0130981887,
0.0094637079,
-0.0456352755,
-0.0656130761,
0.0232382715,
-0.0634257719,
-0.0095658433,
0.036924541,
-0.0075377133,
-0.0582099482,
-0.0211587213,
-0.0222145468,
-0.003508159,
0.0362684987,
0.006254212,
0.0285757445,
-0.01547872,
-0.0077455509,
0.0261120014,
0.0730568618,
-0.0004690669,
-0.0193967335,
0.063139528,
-0.0162152462,
0.0147644095,
0.0315686278,
0.0017549199,
0.0279182941,
-0.061757721,
0.0006775051,
0.0303656943,
-0.027285438,
0.0293380488,
0.0506522655,
-0.0224652477,
-0.0394181795,
0.0574616194,
0.0575493276,
0.041564431,
0.0062671215,
0.0219298285,
-0.0035124908,
0.0030182274,
0.0415228568,
-0.0368130654,
-0.0228633229,
-0.0277578402,
0.0319456942,
0.0006978658,
0.0365117602,
-0.0089375125,
-0.0181869771,
-0.0515980534,
-0.0121235605,
0.0591919944,
-0.0410039388,
0.043811366,
-0.0020258855,
-0.0022127707,
0.0611484163,
0.0231400896,
-0.048813805,
-0.0170320533,
-0.0704499111,
0.0266173389,
0.0250775479,
0.004580738,
-0.0170622636,
0.0297587998,
0.0275558364,
-0.0463622659,
0.0375817381,
0.0356784873,
-0.0074318657,
0.0140107097,
-0.018413784,
-0.0039828978,
-0.0360872746,
0.0563000888,
0.0322337262,
-0.0253920108,
-0.0193497334,
0.0163319055,
-0.089359805,
-0.0306735132,
0.031595014,
-0.0258710515,
0.0263151675,
-0.0372628123,
0.0023276911,
0.0184555296,
0.0113766296,
-0.0073214043,
0.0338329189,
-0.0066367597,
-0.0154810958,
0.004069211,
0.0261620395,
-0.0255990569,
0.0041891364,
0.0450564101,
-0.0058454848,
0.0428877585,
0.0520504229,
0.0117852697,
-0.0288965795,
0.0655951723,
-0.0278232843,
0.0829728544,
-0.030559767,
0.0632887781,
-0.0820481628,
0.0191840269,
-0.0318240225,
0.0618638359,
-0.0329113491,
0.021147605,
-0.0133115416,
0.0097889407,
0.0583434291,
-0.0170261897,
-0.0115880184,
0.0459748842,
-0.0037134239,
0.0062307809,
0.0301436167,
-0.0340325311,
-0.0028429744,
-0.0120351054,
-0.0537971258,
-0.0201345123,
-0.0215938985,
0.0279189777,
0.0563571975,
-0.0074712168,
-0.0068225395,
0.0158248097,
-0.0136641171,
-0.0184485186,
0.0088864425,
0.0363390297,
0.0268684942,
-0.0219609495,
-0.0742890984,
-0.0594036616,
-0.0361829698,
-0.0372055769,
0.1197176427,
-0.0361334383,
-0.0042426991,
-0.0782630742,
0.0294646882,
-0.0485869311,
0.0307659954,
-0.0134286527,
-0.0575321019,
0.0236799326,
0.0198392607,
-0.0036879196,
0.0323503017,
-0.0117743667,
0.0376050882,
0.0758961961,
0.004100576,
-0.0448472761,
-0.0445405766,
-0.015680762,
-0.0040681767,
-0.0345535763,
-0.0578096882,
-0.0201806054,
0.079203032,
0.0439455397,
-0.0267172754,
-0.0516145118,
0.0246326178,
-0.0393641889,
-0.0154318726,
-0.0075952429,
-0.0384165533,
-0.0231511239,
0.0575506464,
-0.0321270525,
-0.0938378349,
0.0334621668,
-0.0741162971,
0.0169268828,
-0.0358317159,
-0.0100499019,
-0.0476321727,
0.0844498202,
0.0041517299,
0.0225562323,
0.0182508063,
-0.0399977453,
-0.0346548632,
0.0173526499,
0.0213268325,
-0.0139461821,
0.0789358541,
-0.0267837644,
0.0057230378,
0.0221249536,
0.0108893104,
-0.0066319578,
0.004519911,
-0.0122069772,
0.043862287,
0.0244668983,
-0.0285816062,
-0.008094999,
0.0684676468,
-0.0111185284,
0.0203150008,
-0.0153059261,
0.0195343401,
-0.0302901641,
-0.0136486497,
0.0091989413,
-0.0215127841,
0.0402280837,
-0.0463868342,
0.0102236392,
-0.0143541275,
0.0034218517,
0.0302929413,
-0.0541645661,
0.0127547355,
0.0149118928,
-0.0225688294,
-0.0247424748,
0.011206679,
0.0584016033,
-0.0354465283,
-0.0235183779,
0.0952528343,
0.0343287401,
-0.0179499425,
0.0658611134,
-0.0276806224,
0.046021875,
0.0536759496,
-0.0140965106,
-0.0084355194,
0.0120028658,
0.016437592,
-0.027836103,
-0.0271278992,
0.0013307938,
0.0082657058,
-0.0967991054,
0.0048700054,
0.034034878,
-0.0672018602,
-0.0534157269,
-0.044799529,
0.0198109616,
0.0176069774,
0.0635861158,
0.0144797163,
-0.0254684389,
0.0054858578,
-0.0083860857,
-0.0327599756,
-0.0869529098,
0.0253062602,
-0.0183093045,
0.0235971604,
0.0730118304,
0.0197004508,
-0.0109613976,
-0.0217774902,
0.0138428723,
0.0120366253,
0.0188315883,
0.01451007,
0.0357689597,
0.0413299538,
-0.0095064575,
0.0068791313,
-0.0015434027,
-0.0078016329,
-0.0054108589,
-0.0612177737,
0.0296899714,
-0.0042167618,
-0.0672945902,
0.0030498516,
-0.0323575325,
0.0217597224,
0.0751790628,
0.0780013725,
0.0009816219,
-0.029702222,
-0.0314410068,
-0.0077545843,
0.0317145996,
-0.0711606592,
0.0257304888,
0.037560001,
-0.0252676383,
-0.0501276888,
-0.0162912197,
-0.0265750289,
0.0023909116,
0.013591446,
0.0097996471,
-0.0235676896,
-0.0375762843,
-0.0321781375,
0.0106358137,
-0.0072276019,
0.0167045407,
-0.0050973142,
-0.0067850607,
-0.0189027805,
0.0080024758,
-0.0626841635,
-0.0324355662,
-0.0837317556,
-0.0838006735,
-0.0044231825,
-0.0194665622,
0.0373087563,
-0.0176843051,
0.0156436041,
-0.0647751912,
0.0279533509,
-0.032654196,
-0.0251305196,
0.0415900312,
0.0217107702,
-0.0516250096,
-0.0041326112,
0.0564532168,
-0.0326230004,
0.0209565219,
0.0252716336,
0.0230250545,
0.0064511592,
-0.0153957894,
0.0139247663,
0.0247033667,
0.0492592417,
0.0169532672,
-0.039544411,
-0.0391455851,
-0.0040234546,
-0.0356673375,
0.0072180685,
-0.0259662047,
0.0014882353,
0.0379310474,
0.0424453728,
-0.0039743721,
-0.0200005472,
-0.0120420717,
0.0238547791,
-0.0288200397,
0.0046988875,
0.029700065,
0.0358073339,
-0.002215276,
0.0275668092,
-0.0128036346,
0.0302010328,
-0.043033395,
0.0116911409,
-0.0073152198,
0.0326424614,
0.0079929233,
0.0232388712,
-0.0254614763,
0.0182427969,
-0.0492724665,
-0.0522460006,
-0.0227105767,
-0.0010033797,
0.0155962985,
-0.0254063047,
0.0686382502,
-0.0152132716,
0.0071452926,
-0.0447501317,
0.0017342232,
0.0014491469,
-0.016073091,
0.0256004874,
0.0009376116,
-0.036829982,
0.0124849733,
0.0917695537,
0.0296396874,
0.0348965377,
-0.0428849086,
-0.005518693,
-0.0196508951,
-0.0138084907,
0.0379275084,
0.0289712828,
-0.0383051038,
-0.0119158076,
-0.0819642842,
-0.0692286715,
0.0071291188,
0.0170603115,
0.0144037791,
0.0050336928,
-0.0011752215,
0.0877708867,
0.0091372048,
0.0003472593,
-0.0366934352,
-0.0600920022,
-0.0285695922,
0.0321133882,
-0.0301589984,
-5.837126217e-33,
-0.0166789107,
-0.0150767257,
-0.0470283739,
-0.0617283061,
0.0206597541,
-0.0022978922,
-0.0419118628,
0.0368246399,
-0.0312337037,
0.0035276145,
0.0280285366,
0.0208958872,
0.0032141183,
-0.0166144241,
0.0101009458,
0.0097161056,
0.0355861299,
0.0150544504,
-0.0509537347,
-0.0018286378,
0.0577359907,
-0.0007650359,
0.0820123628,
-0.0637425482,
0.0488219187,
-0.0169636365,
0.0132779665,
0.0036281736,
-0.0169357508,
0.0774642006,
-0.0297423657,
0.0517071709,
0.0330165885,
-0.0229318161,
-0.0505596176,
-0.0198007748,
0.0080384007,
-0.0301881786,
0.0680457875,
-0.0166725833,
-0.0146573037,
-0.0217127912,
0.0392736048,
-0.0171125215,
-0.034769021,
-0.0254073683,
0.0203896333,
-0.0191180222,
0.0070812018,
0.0366747789,
-0.0769730359,
0.016110206,
-0.0200534444,
0.032407213,
0.0334205553,
0.0117678186,
-0.0079389932,
0.0262851194,
-0.0218974333,
0.0222140513,
0.023265468,
0.0565543771,
0.0880399495,
0.0247102696,
0.0076798405,
0.0754796043,
0.0326456502,
0.0060695219,
-0.0063920147,
-0.0252255145,
0.0970272645,
0.0330247506,
0.0555495024,
0.0400935188,
0.0444658883,
-0.012541879,
-0.0606457256,
-0.0132212695,
0.0231843591,
0.0125049958,
0.0529984534,
0.0346871689,
-0.0566803068,
-0.0230273549,
-0.0606331713,
-0.0514763221,
-0.04798875,
-0.0613197088,
0.0565528534,
-0.04068112,
-0.0272226725,
-0.0058779875,
0.0329668224,
-0.0504822806,
-0.0353889503,
0.0103798611,
-0.0177924987,
0.0165093504,
0.0109006427,
0.0041623646,
-0.0236134659,
-0.0536840633,
-0.0176270809,
0.0328600816,
0.0340951048,
0.0003388293,
0.0053418567,
-0.0019333883,
-0.0441848636,
0.0097860256,
-0.026258098,
-0.0710163638,
0.0043258122,
0.0198525786,
0.0402287357,
-0.0105728637,
-0.0067977798,
0.0214964375,
0.0286369771,
-0.018400928,
-0.0450748131,
0.0352429971,
-0.0200703107,
0.0439202152,
-0.0160857979,
-0.0417680442,
-0.0520476364,
0.0296298135,
0.103305757,
-0.0033746287,
-0.0208510999,
-0.0015838009,
2.448e-7,
0.0646489263,
0.0380989984,
0.0145452404,
0.0192290656,
0.0380675346,
0.0179279111,
-0.0353306234,
0.0134069705,
0.0168587863,
-0.0342008732,
-0.0238409489,
0.0080984002,
0.0326257013,
0.0146864299,
-0.0094034607,
0.0365490355,
-0.0861898214,
-0.0030246913,
-0.034065064,
0.001411034,
-0.0068109538,
0.087682046,
-0.0021034183,
0.0284253377,
-0.0149041312,
-0.0600761287,
0.0491177179,
-0.0398975797,
0.0243391898,
0.0509339832,
-0.005626631,
-0.0023003886,
0.0268070437,
0.035308402,
0.0325099677,
0.0671295673,
0.0297082197,
0.0193344429,
-0.017244542,
0.0099753998,
-0.0316714235,
-0.031421721,
-0.0156040248,
-0.0984659791,
0.0432197042,
-0.0245538075,
-0.0350206755,
-0.0512526333,
0.018355472,
0.0033352126,
0.0450285487,
-0.0065413914,
0.0027309265,
0.0588597581,
0.0083664488,
-0.0197020825,
0.0073204706,
-0.0458354503,
-0.0587882027,
0.0106735975,
-0.0410303287,
-0.0350199081,
-0.0362752117,
-0.0115151927,
0.0014231964,
-0.0305140484,
0.031197587,
2.739378464e-34,
0.0379773229,
0.0210435111,
0.0210554991,
0.0106190592,
0.0573953912,
-0.0587824322,
-0.0064931526,
0.0337405279,
-0.0103210639,
-0.0614717491,
0.0033992843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14985v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14985v3 | LLM-Based Agent Society Investigation: Collaboration and Confrontation in Avalon Gameplay | 2023-10-23T14:35:26 | 2024-03-07T08:41:58 | Yihuai Lan, Zhiqiang Hu, Lei Wang, Yang Wang, Deheng Ye, Peilin Zhao, Ee-Peng Lim, Hui Xiong, Hao Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper aims to investigate the open research problem of uncovering the
social behaviors of LLM-based agents. To achieve this goal, we adopt Avalon, a
representative communication game, as the environment and use system prompts to
guide LLM agents to play the game. While previous studies have conducted
preliminary investigations into gameplay with LLM agents, there lacks research
on their social behaviors. In this paper, we present a novel framework designed
to seamlessly adapt to Avalon gameplay. The core of our proposed framework is a
multi-agent system that enables efficient communication and interaction among
agents. We evaluate the performance of our framework based on metrics from two
perspectives: winning the game and analyzing the social behaviors of LLM
agents. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework in
generating adaptive and intelligent agents and highlight the potential of
LLM-based agents in addressing the challenges associated with dynamic social
environment interaction. By analyzing the social behaviors of LLM agents from
the aspects of both collaboration and confrontation, we provide insights into
the research and applications of this domain. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/3DAgentWorld/LLM-Game-Agent | [
0.0323232934,
-0.0147884348,
-0.0408342704,
0.0279878769,
-0.021533519,
-0.0137955975,
-0.0006921102,
-0.0037189161,
-0.0143224876,
0.0267298892,
-0.0436884947,
0.0323659629,
0.0128297862,
0.0213533808,
0.0166351888,
0.0268294849,
0.0069059883,
-0.0073303911,
0.0396857597,
0.0117393369,
-0.0130730197,
-0.0374919437,
-0.0263072494,
0.0105308248,
0.0449983478,
-0.0169402547,
-0.0579009429,
0.0050831814,
0.0680302382,
-0.0283322837,
0.0022558747,
-0.0499583296,
0.0359690189,
-0.0110827824,
0.0000020378,
-0.0579966381,
-0.0160293877,
-0.0197912809,
0.0053103087,
-0.0416658074,
0.0289377589,
0.0708604902,
0.0201001707,
0.0155044235,
-0.0617407411,
-0.0159436669,
0.0163053814,
-0.0186661594,
0.081654951,
0.033078175,
-0.0007011807,
0.0284247175,
-0.0283047203,
0.0116375471,
0.0040349807,
-0.0240895953,
-0.0031203544,
0.0142668085,
0.0560608059,
-0.0253505334,
0.0313624106,
-0.0072029871,
-0.0231539365,
0.0010155769,
0.0326155573,
0.0425510295,
0.0280902795,
-0.0433590375,
-0.0159456246,
0.0293229576,
0.0814067796,
0.0112184742,
0.0503925011,
0.0318554677,
0.0354878567,
0.0252532326,
-0.0082930271,
0.0216330104,
-0.0161631834,
-0.0079588499,
-0.0111164823,
0.0288155209,
-0.0181014221,
-0.024357792,
-0.0100339735,
0.0590276048,
-0.0191298779,
0.0273892749,
-0.0497845672,
-0.0094752545,
0.0707400143,
-0.0414875634,
-0.0290866103,
0.0411558896,
-0.0421323441,
0.0008712062,
-0.0161377639,
0.0587587208,
0.0170289688,
-0.0336530507,
0.0169533025,
-0.0127376551,
0.0123028681,
0.0350950062,
0.0191668775,
0.0133513818,
0.0440298356,
-0.0192271657,
0.033705961,
0.0116961878,
-0.0216816794,
0.0008027618,
-0.0116217695,
0.0809113458,
-0.0029898193,
0.0045355288,
0.0211039707,
0.0308061522,
-0.04268419,
0.0402426235,
-0.0433523282,
0.0104054846,
0.0320370533,
0.0366563015,
-0.0232939385,
-0.0529975854,
-0.0596193261,
0.0123466011,
-0.0053866082,
-0.0585517883,
0.0192200895,
-0.0369757637,
0.010096604,
0.0156202093,
0.0187528152,
0.105123505,
-0.0073417965,
-0.0448435508,
0.0191040654,
-0.00837739,
0.0667192265,
-0.0450374857,
-0.0117035052,
-0.0410701074,
0.0329619087,
-0.0280681513,
-0.0053529516,
0.001488691,
0.0163558833,
-0.0170135126,
0.0495934635,
0.064223066,
-0.0346764289,
0.0574008636,
0.0606650151,
0.0499323606,
-0.0039808559,
0.0144818155,
0.0760548934,
-0.0118078329,
0.0131783225,
0.0055477843,
0.0607108995,
0.0383311249,
-0.0262821037,
0.0009059394,
0.0549758859,
-0.0245316587,
-0.0284499396,
0.0605935566,
-0.0309723448,
-0.0057101697,
-0.0557025746,
-0.0326301679,
0.0664795861,
0.0342348292,
-0.0138668763,
0.0182574224,
-0.0020987897,
0.0424733795,
-0.0080939382,
-0.0381697305,
0.0149748661,
0.0444681942,
-0.0236410629,
-0.0302595291,
-0.0711596161,
0.0327061936,
0.0021743041,
-0.0478885919,
0.0311610438,
-0.0093053253,
0.0456832126,
0.0189604964,
-0.0035651808,
-0.0000147627,
-0.0431842022,
-0.0102074584,
0.0006088866,
-0.0684652478,
-0.001270066,
-0.0890738741,
0.0939833224,
0.0583407544,
0.0539033972,
-0.0405350477,
-0.0887527317,
0.0095871808,
0.0117527461,
0.0377585813,
-0.0228623878,
-0.017040113,
0.0558854416,
0.0053768368,
-0.0285875872,
0.0088107167,
-0.0294296611,
0.0860379636,
-0.0154551808,
0.0198202599,
-0.0440690331,
0.0294932127,
0.0233376846,
0.019780362,
-0.0250366405,
-0.0020254937,
-0.0339346267,
0.0140715968,
0.0263659563,
0.0080795912,
-0.0309670456,
-0.0289147496,
0.0238920711,
-0.0121634724,
-0.0312232114,
0.0441361517,
0.0436849371,
0.0381903648,
0.0364197195,
-0.0347338058,
0.0385497622,
-0.0084463367,
0.0382933021,
0.0421075225,
0.0318427049,
0.002108946,
0.0559007302,
0.0240262263,
-0.0094663408,
-0.0217678286,
0.0010655272,
-0.0051694051,
-0.0034707587,
0.0061432612,
-0.0675877929,
-0.0105348462,
-0.0061821602,
0.0270230211,
-0.0244442895,
0.0818507597,
0.0121738436,
0.0067623686,
-0.0299378932,
0.029459279,
0.0297187343,
-0.0360787921,
-0.0309229307,
-0.0150282942,
-0.0274436567,
-0.0126457848,
-0.0196341462,
-0.0052870233,
-0.0241470356,
-0.0168786794,
0.0366013534,
-0.0052107465,
0.0834661648,
0.0572018549,
-0.0210143961,
0.0508062467,
0.0424939208,
-0.0670411289,
-0.0515506901,
0.0544073507,
-0.0019189878,
0.022463575,
0.0073468513,
-0.0384397507,
-0.0382408537,
0.0242291037,
-0.0786689818,
-0.0069375839,
-0.0472447611,
-0.0885661468,
0.0500414409,
-0.038927827,
-0.02418443,
0.0250223465,
0.0157867409,
0.0666624084,
0.0577869862,
-0.0578517541,
-0.0386030599,
0.0354587473,
-0.0039528036,
0.0328941308,
-0.0635775998,
-0.0489062555,
0.0360059477,
0.0392723903,
-0.0425784588,
0.0262103975,
0.0021859969,
0.0253664143,
0.0498353168,
-0.0684895441,
0.0220458806,
-0.0304125249,
-0.0141947092,
0.0028034474,
-0.0175537579,
0.0402467959,
0.0424533822,
-0.0289805178,
-0.0260638818,
0.0183388367,
-0.0266802087,
-0.0156090269,
0.0659640506,
-0.0468471758,
-0.0177995693,
-0.0086272238,
-0.0260191541,
0.0135171022,
-0.0846776813,
0.041164808,
-0.0247093905,
0.0267921854,
-0.0751016364,
-0.030758895,
0.0358132049,
-0.0143301953,
0.0178040881,
-0.0010038801,
-0.0194203034,
-0.0068439147,
-0.0642358884,
-0.0195802934,
-0.0480879657,
-0.0264620967,
0.0363428779,
-0.0381093286,
0.0188019983,
-0.0145833353,
-0.0384762846,
-0.0528044999,
0.0330665037,
0.0670799389,
0.0156115564,
-0.0254422519,
0.0444597118,
0.0376829356,
-0.0271689016,
-0.0694808364,
-0.0188730136,
-0.0259187222,
0.0408922359,
0.008539388,
0.0101202847,
0.0040508159,
0.0258362666,
-0.0142622171,
0.001643093,
0.0588979758,
0.0087569868,
0.0034932084,
0.0024547384,
-0.0581605099,
0.0232137032,
0.0049178666,
0.0015048902,
-0.0227901936,
0.0077280486,
-0.0106187267,
-0.0061950963,
-0.0166009068,
-0.028131986,
0.0146190012,
-0.0517858714,
0.0046688984,
-0.013853332,
-0.0303187277,
-0.0038484042,
-0.0148853222,
0.0233110469,
-0.0007730447,
-0.0349728242,
-0.0163577627,
0.0560277738,
-0.0378483832,
-0.0052757021,
-0.0373377688,
0.0443549231,
-0.0061224946,
-0.0741175041,
0.1214410737,
0.0098361932,
0.0729823783,
-0.0203865059,
-0.0328839757,
-0.0288106967,
0.0457391627,
0.0458706394,
-0.0084564183,
-0.0213863496,
-0.0226898249,
0.0264203846,
0.0093126623,
-0.0506331995,
-0.0006359095,
-0.0070845787,
0.0696968213,
0.0038610741,
-0.0407067016,
-0.0252291337,
-0.0275237635,
0.0494597964,
0.0456022397,
0.0250790566,
-0.0270895045,
0.0022380166,
0.0045121294,
0.01744009,
-0.0136547033,
0.0127526326,
-0.0288626738,
-0.0546387807,
0.0038958814,
-0.01420944,
-0.0635266155,
-0.0796326101,
0.0131332092,
0.0106236553,
-0.0236034151,
-0.0094750607,
-0.0194118693,
0.0716997609,
0.047075849,
-0.0522065982,
-0.0132247759,
0.0124036651,
0.0289847888,
-0.0204068422,
-0.0043569966,
-0.0681471005,
0.0309126917,
0.0097435014,
0.0034921663,
-0.010771201,
0.03624456,
0.040706072,
0.0156545769,
-0.0099606654,
0.0040354985,
-0.0029790434,
0.0276591051,
-0.015983114,
0.0052879024,
0.053168565,
0.0024434011,
0.0218661707,
0.0280766599,
-0.010361529,
-0.0434333906,
-0.0155277606,
-0.0013720174,
0.0072822366,
-0.088328205,
-0.0643850639,
-0.041787304,
-0.0051058033,
-0.0128127383,
-0.0145191476,
-0.024861088,
0.0210778005,
0.0075676902,
-0.0508805923,
0.0402800776,
-0.0156211061,
-0.0244406611,
-0.0636283532,
-0.0006187922,
0.0331918448,
0.0185113698,
-0.016983537,
0.0000762324,
0.0098428465,
0.0803647414,
0.0303777661,
-0.0320308357,
-0.0160117615,
0.0314616784,
0.0311375242,
0.0278533231,
0.0041292412,
0.0177081656,
0.0214902367,
0.0228221454,
0.0066500856,
-0.064928636,
-0.0129563808,
0.0506897978,
-0.0239723064,
-0.0218274351,
0.1081209853,
0.1030252874,
0.0384134911,
0.0947964713,
0.0199365374,
-0.0229540877,
0.0312594511,
-0.0059412657,
-0.0367104672,
-0.0020078898,
-0.0438514575,
-0.0073485631,
0.0459063612,
-0.0295608323,
-0.0014170725,
0.0030336007,
0.0169993322,
0.037216533,
-0.0137153389,
-0.0055384496,
-0.0384424478,
0.0010211391,
0.0328044742,
0.0081699649,
-0.0200510975,
-0.0094837472,
-0.0531108603,
0.027383877,
-0.0129464949,
0.0947889462,
0.0031917151,
-0.0543552563,
-0.0052313609,
0.0133893806,
0.0170978419,
-0.0310297143,
-0.0566654392,
-0.000585338,
-0.074044548,
0.0086342171,
0.0055607618,
-5.221385378e-33,
-0.034347374,
-0.0487270877,
0.0695552006,
0.0351405554,
-0.0532912016,
-0.0332097262,
-0.0564132184,
-0.0157801285,
-0.0199358966,
-0.0228271056,
-0.003407832,
0.0135552268,
-0.0009157446,
-0.0629185215,
-0.0055624056,
-0.0332496241,
0.0084291985,
-0.0067856116,
-0.0462284014,
-0.003826329,
-0.0361766703,
0.0131696947,
-0.0021040053,
-0.0692789778,
0.0037011392,
-0.0018572279,
-0.0274509452,
0.0204398539,
-0.0223668478,
-0.0068799336,
0.0323386714,
-0.0349081643,
0.0094809113,
0.0190062076,
0.0254383367,
-0.0253047924,
-0.0212125704,
-0.045216769,
-0.0187444109,
-0.0246068388,
-0.0223628245,
-0.0417404175,
-0.0250469521,
0.0432233922,
-0.0381392986,
-0.0152093424,
0.0595205687,
-0.0260115042,
-0.0037995146,
0.0056471,
-0.0257280767,
-0.0008074255,
-0.0358544402,
-0.0146631729,
0.0021407027,
-0.0182843041,
-0.0123987207,
0.0142412689,
-0.0466600694,
0.0496326014,
-0.0490881167,
-0.0628474504,
-0.009275171,
0.0346142352,
0.0617162026,
0.0321964435,
0.0188619643,
0.0487599857,
-0.0448770039,
-0.0163676664,
0.02659503,
0.1009404883,
0.0199324396,
0.0770306364,
-0.0986744091,
-0.0107112322,
-0.0125870118,
0.0525048822,
0.0701217502,
0.0097845225,
0.0090877712,
0.0061714994,
-0.0282855276,
0.016831493,
0.0428079031,
0.0167909041,
0.0144361276,
-0.0240939129,
-0.0075556468,
-0.0257127155,
-0.0025229442,
-0.0694928989,
0.025982216,
-0.0110704079,
-0.006521238,
-0.0006797544,
0.0078120469,
-0.0066429116,
-0.0066997604,
-0.0384312496,
0.0044796825,
-0.0205600709,
-0.0387996323,
-0.0019495814,
0.0523283705,
0.0208563842,
-0.0288335159,
0.062164031,
0.0218520723,
-0.0069005541,
0.0180826206,
0.0393787175,
0.0358132273,
-0.0459084399,
-0.0094744656,
-0.0589519367,
0.0138986791,
-0.0347270556,
0.0028244725,
-0.0030155228,
0.0091583766,
0.0128406798,
-0.0424980596,
0.0007826627,
-0.0503631383,
0.0001647332,
-0.0652974695,
0.0733736083,
0.0160043444,
0.0177387893,
-0.0320652276,
-0.0728766397,
2.843e-7,
-0.0885064974,
0.0392801426,
0.0178856477,
0.0324331969,
-0.0016404951,
0.0672425851,
-0.0140239624,
0.0415044762,
-0.006028688,
-0.0653527305,
0.0870171487,
0.0481461212,
0.0015243189,
-0.0017896295,
-0.0498332381,
-0.0005996409,
0.012600719,
-0.0452091582,
-0.00554635,
0.0139124608,
0.0327515975,
-0.0446453318,
0.0376391299,
-0.0050939908,
0.0354199335,
-0.0075879632,
-0.0468992181,
-0.0838478059,
-0.0002520807,
0.023660766,
-0.0164387599,
-0.0212014169,
-0.0312925577,
-0.042236641,
0.0097996844,
0.0148531767,
-0.0465488583,
0.04203761,
-0.0249068588,
-0.030803794,
0.0011522111,
-0.0111325644,
-0.0095132152,
0.0095492024,
0.0030738246,
0.0210427195,
-0.0104667991,
0.0236381143,
-0.0224118084,
-0.0408388674,
-0.0718120113,
-0.0242217965,
-0.0143195549,
-0.0383383296,
-0.0352119654,
-0.0305601899,
-0.0109186368,
-0.0425036885,
0.0555065349,
-0.0146937836,
-0.0187728871,
-0.0766136721,
0.0038812517,
0.0064449543,
-0.0042414828,
0.0079269363,
-0.0123612657,
1.899482814e-34,
-0.0687974021,
-0.0099588335,
-0.0222378597,
0.0488670878,
0.059676569,
0.0286279451,
-0.0559457727,
0.0037082855,
0.0397098325,
-0.0185540076,
0.0116360774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14981v1 | Fidelity-Enriched Contrastive Search: Reconciling the Faithfulness-Diversity Trade-Off in Text Generation | 2023-10-23T14:27:45 | 2023-10-23T14:27:45 | Wei-Lin Chen, Cheng-Kuang Wu, Hsin-Hsi Chen, Chung-Chi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we address the hallucination problem commonly found in natural
language generation tasks. Language models often generate fluent and convincing
content but can lack consistency with the provided source, resulting in
potential inaccuracies. We propose a new decoding method called
Fidelity-Enriched Contrastive Search (FECS), which augments the contrastive
search framework with context-aware regularization terms. FECS promotes tokens
that are semantically similar to the provided source while penalizing
repetitiveness in the generated text. We demonstrate its effectiveness across
two tasks prone to hallucination: abstractive summarization and dialogue
generation. Results show that FECS consistently enhances faithfulness across
various language model sizes while maintaining output diversity comparable to
well-performing decoding algorithms. | [
0.0299576893,
0.0591729358,
0.0035693005,
0.0141881006,
-0.0422612429,
-0.0130978432,
-0.0418506451,
-0.0041644005,
-0.0320791751,
-0.0312722288,
0.0083185527,
-0.0588663109,
0.0404618233,
0.0341695063,
0.0168281812,
-0.0703914985,
0.0363005139,
-0.0071996511,
-0.0155386534,
0.0064531681,
0.0029044333,
0.013199959,
0.013247055,
0.0589024685,
-0.0127548119,
-0.0089123957,
-0.0179634765,
0.0202818438,
0.0292997863,
-0.0275606047,
0.0071532605,
0.0553062372,
0.0039827316,
0.0273164883,
0.0000019782,
-0.0272515006,
-0.0389969796,
-0.0127263758,
0.0273811407,
-0.0126404725,
0.0524714701,
-0.0164705086,
0.0055855727,
0.0247983858,
-0.0095276525,
-0.0032565428,
0.0641500354,
0.0706902742,
0.0561963655,
0.0663498864,
0.0007799835,
-0.0300948508,
0.0235376339,
0.0079224035,
0.0121511677,
0.008418534,
-0.0230418425,
0.0191201773,
0.0043318565,
-0.0030271688,
0.0105309021,
0.0266331974,
0.0141724274,
0.0129661923,
0.0071822009,
0.0491796844,
-0.0364530347,
-0.0054227244,
0.0159226395,
0.0478649624,
-0.023601599,
-0.0518555157,
0.0050558676,
-0.0022408986,
-0.0071603758,
-0.007219546,
-0.0433414839,
0.0514739417,
-0.0424566902,
0.0261465199,
0.0658341497,
0.0094338814,
0.0139164953,
0.0123475539,
-0.0381954946,
-0.0103886817,
0.0263217688,
-0.0069616996,
-0.0327559449,
0.0067101372,
-0.0634845793,
-0.0478600413,
0.0267576054,
0.0246854965,
-0.077019453,
-0.0023807797,
-0.0793455243,
-0.0567544587,
0.020428827,
-0.0306903459,
0.0026684073,
0.0445716456,
-0.0238679312,
-0.0035522003,
-0.011296479,
0.0196012724,
-0.0067292894,
-0.0125774788,
-0.0547862016,
-0.028480269,
-0.016627606,
-0.0201058425,
-0.0621095635,
0.0481424518,
-0.0279078148,
-0.0436574779,
-0.0211579166,
0.0271453895,
0.0007271508,
-0.0007008307,
-0.0129423141,
0.03646373,
-0.0346138962,
-0.0164510738,
0.0241108648,
-0.0044003096,
-0.016063327,
-0.0220349953,
0.0592298023,
-0.0440801382,
-0.0342375971,
0.0328106359,
0.0305082966,
-0.0160111114,
-0.03024978,
0.0390117988,
-0.0219369344,
-0.0399136841,
-0.0346786976,
-0.0371346064,
-0.0216555241,
-0.037872538,
-0.0566163361,
-0.0706855804,
0.0136062205,
0.0008368342,
-0.0236455556,
-0.0494871214,
0.0187230837,
0.0390346572,
-0.0168259311,
0.0297030397,
-0.0474271551,
-0.0016891087,
0.0612847134,
0.0088971211,
-0.0168317221,
0.065593496,
0.014391019,
0.0356009938,
0.0039066202,
0.0255614668,
0.0238487739,
0.0132033108,
0.0080613373,
-0.0240547396,
-0.0048735403,
-0.0240321811,
-0.0213071369,
0.0205380451,
0.054068543,
0.0868119672,
-0.0690591484,
0.0386381596,
0.0541177578,
0.0280668121,
0.0256132968,
0.0151386345,
0.0504105575,
0.0280192066,
-0.031375207,
0.0844017267,
-0.0272872113,
0.0364432745,
-0.005286247,
0.0410841331,
0.1104195416,
0.0422245972,
-0.008845076,
-0.0345660932,
0.0052288244,
-0.0073625515,
-0.0011369949,
-0.0248701535,
0.0152716339,
0.0437982827,
-0.0845155716,
0.0407796949,
0.0109593431,
-0.0468447581,
0.022686556,
-0.0156789348,
0.0310083237,
0.0933102965,
0.0801685825,
0.0194939822,
0.019923225,
-0.0032800809,
0.0098320013,
0.073250331,
0.0522839054,
-0.0025046407,
0.0170419142,
-0.0628641248,
-0.0285121668,
-0.0175936334,
0.0124171004,
0.0220558792,
-0.0132785495,
-0.0028771614,
0.0495610088,
0.0098733129,
-0.0606441423,
0.0358737223,
-0.0439176001,
-0.0021421728,
0.0072776922,
-0.0036924724,
-0.0174546521,
0.0145638762,
-0.0157616045,
0.0468549617,
-0.0178482365,
-0.0592765138,
-0.0052038338,
0.0242937114,
-0.0722588971,
-0.0527450219,
0.0048210253,
-0.0556963533,
0.0161207858,
0.0206622481,
0.0108024208,
-0.0428257622,
0.0351620354,
-0.0748118907,
0.0350825898,
-0.0402870439,
0.0356755406,
0.0207857341,
0.0244340375,
-0.0358989462,
0.0857827738,
-0.0136133125,
0.0053507285,
0.0519442186,
0.0138753261,
0.0054381201,
-0.0636420101,
0.0061023692,
-0.0106836762,
-0.0122936014,
0.0060661966,
0.0468607768,
0.0044731349,
-0.0208799522,
-0.0294868443,
-0.0416433439,
0.0149953505,
-0.0362266153,
-0.0275538601,
0.0512198955,
0.0326510854,
0.0183171108,
0.0281696543,
-0.028643772,
-0.0373482369,
0.042388238,
0.0158232506,
0.0183425453,
0.0206337646,
-0.008499247,
-0.0262305588,
0.0092201913,
0.028317444,
0.0427159742,
-0.0085223578,
0.0243241545,
-0.0917802006,
0.07671123,
-0.0250693187,
-0.0129325064,
0.0154777551,
0.0089101689,
0.0065088589,
0.0149094481,
0.0597822629,
0.0031959449,
0.0561936311,
0.035900671,
0.0336112045,
0.0095948279,
-0.0370037183,
-0.0102758277,
-0.034840323,
0.0297153629,
0.040317595,
-0.0607006028,
0.0646559075,
0.051715143,
0.0643155202,
0.0370691307,
-0.0673644692,
0.0415036604,
-0.0117792217,
-0.0455472581,
0.0153145697,
-0.0398572795,
-0.0206456576,
0.0412168093,
-0.0399039797,
-0.0408229791,
0.0706493407,
-0.0283931345,
0.0370644405,
-0.0291625038,
0.0017040555,
-0.0142925791,
0.0079543702,
-0.0253165793,
0.0429516323,
-0.0033122955,
-0.0404963791,
-0.0365944654,
0.0039001727,
0.0243617408,
-0.0372421406,
0.0793864205,
-0.0281434171,
-0.0114076147,
0.0081619862,
-0.0301659852,
-0.0704810917,
-0.0152024748,
0.0251912456,
0.0131182214,
0.0597169474,
0.0116369389,
-0.0431799516,
0.0276672803,
0.0072771404,
0.0523659736,
-0.0370691754,
-0.0275289547,
-0.0104926527,
0.0664034113,
0.0730003938,
-0.017949108,
0.0512674749,
-0.053104993,
0.0341173075,
0.0439746343,
-0.010662578,
-0.0101658683,
-0.003661663,
-0.0267277118,
0.0097225923,
-0.0223259516,
-0.0454284959,
0.0197910573,
0.050855957,
-0.0370059647,
-0.0678620189,
0.1064648628,
0.0245468114,
-0.0419991463,
0.0157826487,
-0.0571441948,
0.0961676911,
-0.0065787481,
0.0012141082,
-0.064964965,
-0.0072720037,
-0.0029274481,
0.0408992469,
-0.0006251446,
-0.0267842039,
-0.0292925294,
-0.0872190222,
0.0359505229,
0.0478811786,
-0.0530617982,
-0.0698727444,
-0.015697768,
-0.0190027952,
0.010809062,
0.0440876111,
0.0354252644,
0.0191344917,
0.0241296273,
0.0156772602,
-0.014268619,
-0.0340327434,
-0.055815421,
-0.0473433919,
0.0212591905,
0.0790009871,
0.0196770988,
0.0327364765,
-0.0155259967,
-0.0018851273,
-0.0495155267,
0.005456253,
-0.0182015393,
0.0336806625,
-0.0019165485,
0.0099039935,
-0.0074329763,
0.0202415567,
0.002802273,
-0.0568488389,
-0.0067270817,
0.0058450857,
-0.0335564204,
-0.0168230496,
-0.0150062554,
0.0322039276,
0.03995746,
0.0762529597,
0.0491734333,
-0.0201453995,
-0.0472889505,
-0.0588162579,
0.0479119346,
-0.1151736379,
0.0078343973,
0.000132289,
0.0438746065,
0.0033472343,
-0.0995571986,
-0.021167215,
-0.0090881009,
0.0189593527,
-0.0246523004,
0.0306072608,
-0.0508400835,
-0.0230371617,
-0.0304046199,
-0.0045743408,
-0.0006305941,
-0.0047712266,
-0.0474418066,
-0.0267020091,
-0.0178711582,
-0.080717884,
0.0084926812,
0.0624753758,
-0.060464032,
-0.0619637184,
-0.0166387707,
0.0168800317,
0.0152964685,
0.0730714127,
0.0097503681,
-0.0226696581,
0.0233423207,
0.0414937064,
-0.0061100754,
0.0183996353,
-0.0022832877,
0.0135272881,
0.0015276757,
0.0202330612,
-0.0445009619,
-0.012251284,
-0.0141904289,
0.0892410427,
0.0607217997,
-0.0252592396,
0.0657787472,
-0.0078019141,
-0.0073888809,
-0.0650034249,
0.035993427,
-0.0236251075,
-0.0293296203,
-0.0158636812,
-0.0235282276,
-0.0438454226,
0.0504170023,
0.0150262052,
0.0035991629,
0.0046191351,
-0.0196883269,
-0.0180362221,
0.0565549098,
-0.0352624394,
-0.0329899639,
-0.0337753184,
0.0090916185,
0.0296097491,
-0.0292253885,
-0.0376549326,
0.0108381314,
-0.0558134466,
0.0371634252,
-0.0275899433,
0.0483891778,
0.0137303369,
-0.0271340199,
0.0017375431,
0.0292395968,
-0.0497585721,
-0.0301452093,
-0.0719721019,
-0.0363007486,
0.0558510087,
-0.0154066812,
0.0675978735,
-0.0464771613,
0.0206970163,
-0.0153260333,
0.0312403664,
0.0273303334,
-0.0618363731,
-0.0214476883,
0.0244714227,
-0.0133623155,
-0.020195486,
0.1010657027,
-0.0390714146,
0.0142639345,
-0.0191688165,
-0.0078182975,
-0.0475201085,
-0.0433764793,
-0.0025986582,
0.0565840304,
-0.0215004906,
-0.0122503219,
-0.026387196,
-0.0398509912,
0.0471897386,
0.0116164368,
-0.0018489598,
0.0007067029,
0.0538948216,
0.0458648577,
-0.0309033766,
0.003847206,
-0.0328261405,
-0.0004635576,
0.0200922396,
0.002530711,
-0.0268187542,
-6.074738073e-33,
-0.022913279,
-0.0402138345,
0.0007555666,
-0.0328735746,
-0.0196315125,
-0.0255204979,
-0.0605554543,
-0.0099303685,
0.0249021072,
-0.0069798543,
0.0147190541,
0.0008485823,
0.0032515025,
0.0473103486,
-0.0239193793,
0.0203600321,
0.0562818795,
0.0201112535,
-0.0595377348,
0.0499562286,
0.0527391136,
0.0124716386,
0.009191433,
-0.0325941667,
-0.0188357607,
-0.0170441624,
-0.0194065906,
0.0079946071,
0.0415073149,
0.0528728329,
-0.0291158594,
0.0265772119,
0.0155979255,
-0.0353926457,
-0.0592222922,
-0.0132468399,
-0.0213599391,
-0.0074611339,
0.0281245764,
-0.0324754156,
-0.0441388562,
-0.0606015585,
0.0218333974,
-0.0349895619,
0.0009241675,
-0.0076113991,
0.0240910072,
-0.0515549593,
-0.0497521386,
-0.0262950193,
-0.063022241,
0.0403263047,
-0.005330903,
-0.0132460827,
-0.0184101705,
0.0684111044,
-0.0081517389,
0.000729653,
-0.0269118007,
0.0529238023,
0.0198877789,
0.03788637,
0.0563677251,
0.035593152,
-0.0102363452,
0.077453576,
0.0197502431,
-0.0140138036,
-0.0021679245,
-0.0099842763,
-0.0236157756,
0.0284244791,
-0.0097760605,
0.0433395058,
0.0294467341,
-0.0104323691,
-0.0100408671,
0.0459437855,
-0.0603993796,
-0.0206207968,
0.0711253509,
0.0162060354,
-0.0221212115,
-0.0317155272,
-0.0239578262,
0.0047440273,
-0.0296399184,
-0.0427980535,
0.036959108,
0.0441479534,
-0.0179313216,
-0.0516300574,
0.0442511141,
-0.0053320727,
0.0127789378,
0.058507666,
-0.0577592328,
-0.0048842258,
-0.0168549884,
0.0005979928,
-0.0107746227,
-0.0137047898,
0.0473745391,
0.0134457499,
-0.0005852805,
0.0342488661,
0.0042046024,
0.0121160978,
-0.0493551642,
0.0083016213,
-0.0383506306,
0.0275344271,
-0.0159631297,
-0.0206843968,
0.0293448418,
-0.0298381392,
-0.0188945644,
0.0567266382,
0.0020274089,
-0.0255996529,
-0.048201289,
0.0015097444,
-0.0111095998,
0.0289708134,
-0.0217609908,
0.020265054,
-0.0319869295,
-0.009375643,
0.0322929583,
-0.0493907034,
-0.0302596558,
0.0083179418,
2.578e-7,
-0.0081585683,
0.0166350137,
0.0389602892,
0.009130029,
-0.0101537341,
-0.0001324558,
0.0227524918,
0.0154692233,
-0.0117601333,
0.0046835924,
0.012513252,
0.0171194393,
0.0645363107,
0.0029407011,
-0.0812280402,
0.0189383607,
-0.0754410401,
-0.0114190979,
-0.0451368317,
-0.0312536769,
0.0552877672,
0.072194919,
-0.0424082465,
-0.0001092306,
0.0225924905,
-0.0171803702,
0.0660350844,
0.0088457335,
-0.0094350306,
0.0146213975,
0.0111472337,
-0.0147644142,
-0.0045528263,
-0.016487876,
-0.021314336,
-0.0160174817,
0.0396275595,
0.0218216609,
0.0391803384,
-0.0536542051,
0.0139933564,
-0.0050146203,
0.003195358,
-0.0493849739,
0.0296042413,
-0.0414962396,
-0.0100586163,
-0.0424559675,
-0.0464274921,
0.0048277532,
-0.0040713307,
-0.0294039641,
-0.0409027301,
0.0348956324,
0.0075837965,
0.0528355651,
-0.0254443325,
-0.0335172005,
-0.0460731164,
0.0066719227,
-0.0355990641,
-0.0263581667,
-0.0345802158,
0.0058071148,
0.0415288657,
-0.0408172347,
0.0136743719,
2.638543548e-34,
0.0605858862,
-0.0208489504,
0.0026128814,
0.0248676818,
0.0347785316,
-0.006036195,
0.0420365185,
0.0344536491,
0.0142069561,
-0.046706073,
-0.0288209114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14979v1 | ACTOR: Active Learning with Annotator-specific Classification Heads to Embrace Human Label Variation | 2023-10-23T14:26:43 | 2023-10-23T14:26:43 | Xinpeng Wang, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Label aggregation such as majority voting is commonly used to resolve
annotator disagreement in dataset creation. However, this may disregard
minority values and opinions. Recent studies indicate that learning from
individual annotations outperforms learning from aggregated labels, though they
require a considerable amount of annotation. Active learning, as an annotation
cost-saving strategy, has not been fully explored in the context of learning
from disagreement. We show that in the active learning setting, a multi-head
model performs significantly better than a single-head model in terms of
uncertainty estimation. By designing and evaluating acquisition functions with
annotator-specific heads on two datasets, we show that group-level entropy
works generally well on both datasets. Importantly, it achieves performance in
terms of both prediction and uncertainty estimation comparable to full-scale
training from disagreement, while saving up to 70% of the annotation budget. | [
0.030489875,
0.0552485958,
0.0023171376,
-0.0134864952,
0.0182900932,
0.0425172895,
0.0185174178,
-0.021594109,
-0.0012169159,
-0.0376727358,
-0.020689901,
-0.061479032,
-0.0068748021,
-0.0545209311,
0.0057356167,
-0.0706810802,
0.0184387174,
0.024351351,
0.0400688797,
-0.0392442979,
0.0144500472,
-0.0395132229,
0.0053933691,
0.0402250104,
-0.049400989,
0.0450826101,
-0.0186318308,
0.001794957,
0.0449540839,
0.0158348065,
0.0419832654,
0.0723479018,
0.0007450841,
0.0602156818,
0.0000018551,
-0.0093567874,
-0.0331472456,
0.0267932378,
-0.0127344932,
0.0068957554,
-0.0038277812,
0.0807157084,
-0.0064318171,
0.0061634863,
-0.0230924822,
-0.0430660397,
0.0616101921,
-0.0004827206,
0.0514494777,
-0.0100915898,
-0.016814556,
-0.0370492227,
-0.0138411364,
-0.0654996857,
0.0339073576,
-0.0460866317,
0.0121522462,
-0.0114709092,
-0.0800513923,
-0.0135877989,
0.0119926445,
0.0148468642,
0.0224128533,
0.0110909911,
0.0396378711,
0.0406346321,
-0.0239583254,
-0.0543682911,
0.0147902463,
0.037034791,
0.0403830707,
0.0323011503,
0.0050360821,
-0.0606235527,
0.0381563567,
0.0278473757,
0.0174932797,
0.0131596383,
-0.0180365499,
0.0245066751,
-0.0480316132,
0.0241584219,
0.0002210964,
0.0082194591,
-0.0018985579,
-0.0067692026,
-0.0267963186,
-0.019057177,
0.0531923063,
0.0666562319,
-0.0767426789,
-0.0116947331,
-0.017332036,
0.0127569893,
-0.0349298008,
0.0060594864,
-0.0091692433,
-0.0259606875,
0.0407222696,
-0.0926241279,
0.0040294994,
-0.0170484167,
-0.0168616865,
0.0600832589,
0.0776497796,
-0.0330757722,
0.0151814166,
0.0424998589,
-0.021253027,
-0.0068224352,
-0.0230216905,
0.0145615228,
0.0073419609,
0.0359496847,
0.0138204955,
0.0444296561,
-0.05078578,
0.0119280424,
-0.0458555184,
0.013936311,
0.0069557615,
0.0274115801,
-0.0170698762,
0.0165196564,
-0.0249297749,
0.0345198251,
0.0001195863,
0.0467518233,
0.0061722235,
-0.0274422672,
0.0340945311,
0.018784659,
-0.0137770372,
-0.0060313391,
0.0119306799,
0.0177690294,
-0.0093954578,
-0.0202929135,
-0.0043073157,
0.0000421585,
-0.010262941,
-0.0424345136,
-0.0086834328,
-0.0364491642,
0.0362584889,
-0.0169738866,
0.0223543923,
-0.0457950048,
-0.0060634729,
-0.0105086025,
-0.0030545054,
0.0710307136,
-0.0013046223,
-0.0317657515,
0.0775547698,
-0.0093564345,
-0.0269416757,
0.0999884233,
0.0118247569,
0.0315752961,
0.0211123694,
0.0075228573,
-0.0336404778,
-0.0250051375,
0.0178232137,
0.0200926792,
0.0161468145,
-0.0287391245,
0.0005861021,
-0.0433863923,
-0.0420170203,
0.0454806425,
-0.0377338454,
-0.033786431,
0.0446173549,
-0.0276578516,
-0.0341274925,
-0.0596681461,
-0.0266347732,
0.0041803606,
0.0338342078,
0.0094536729,
-0.0317185409,
0.0378585495,
-0.0350678936,
-0.0279186741,
0.0232750271,
-0.0149095114,
-0.0406092294,
-0.086220257,
-0.0428939983,
-0.0066327751,
-0.0196441114,
0.0413033068,
0.0436644852,
-0.0237977244,
0.0361742079,
0.016406592,
0.0786975324,
-0.0517413244,
-0.0115152206,
-0.0330583006,
0.0174807683,
-0.0120784892,
-0.0013135312,
-0.0416628309,
-0.0476068631,
-0.0230417959,
0.0050535863,
0.0018051167,
0.062820226,
-0.0326719135,
0.0160156563,
-0.0595453605,
-0.0733647272,
0.0714715421,
0.0376190096,
0.0318081416,
-0.0063816295,
-0.036323335,
-0.008916948,
0.0361977667,
-0.0238341745,
0.0421772674,
0.0278022345,
0.0017669027,
0.0279204063,
0.0201664362,
0.0881503001,
-0.0128424354,
-0.0476069786,
-0.0143181728,
0.0392204896,
-0.0057036178,
-0.0655974075,
0.0019187231,
0.0190821309,
0.0129557634,
0.0235632379,
0.0049260161,
-0.0421621799,
-0.0466933548,
-0.0351998135,
-0.0299705826,
-0.0588687509,
-0.0302460082,
-0.0442401022,
-0.0670457929,
0.0037948899,
-0.0426858291,
-0.0102634868,
-0.1017638892,
0.0643900856,
-0.031863559,
-0.0208126772,
-0.0291920546,
-0.069591485,
0.0354362167,
-0.0229958743,
-0.0330978744,
0.0019418524,
0.0311205462,
0.0227297433,
0.0683945045,
-0.0198928937,
0.0024316646,
-0.0175741967,
-0.027994154,
-0.0012017334,
-0.0111708743,
-0.0086814128,
-0.0308406912,
-0.0016769232,
0.0292629004,
-0.0048994222,
-0.0261687618,
0.0429562405,
-0.0416713357,
0.0357366838,
0.0055906363,
0.0321681499,
-0.0026950198,
-0.0477099195,
-0.0273573715,
0.0103127398,
0.0179206617,
0.043288596,
-0.0267379023,
-0.0203577504,
-0.0032773179,
-0.0429170802,
0.0146692134,
0.0049411128,
-0.0041797627,
0.0236780178,
-0.0430359431,
-0.0415688194,
0.044430498,
0.0359845757,
0.0482845269,
0.0599844381,
0.0102202734,
-0.0380407274,
0.0141866151,
-0.0505408645,
-0.0178874619,
-0.0269212443,
-0.0440284014,
-0.0110222325,
0.0332726762,
-0.0186851285,
-0.008897095,
-0.0683505312,
-0.0203616768,
-0.0138920601,
-0.0612183921,
-0.0585009493,
0.0328150392,
-0.0119386418,
0.0527442843,
-0.0000181449,
-0.0271303132,
0.085585691,
0.0255782176,
-0.0041268431,
-0.0159703698,
0.0267261937,
0.0031241816,
0.0063716159,
0.0181542747,
0.0158137474,
0.0182763077,
0.0394372381,
-0.047049325,
-0.0422899909,
0.1058842167,
-0.036155019,
0.0185596365,
-0.0267719645,
0.0080180531,
-0.0327704735,
-0.0587149933,
-0.0321277417,
-0.0092853745,
0.002229623,
0.0143839372,
0.0272518583,
-0.02078362,
-0.0292605255,
-0.0083689159,
0.0080749188,
0.0075378758,
0.0098535717,
-0.0266883932,
0.0106037008,
0.0007163603,
-0.0048710085,
0.0078809969,
-0.0022282721,
-0.0517525673,
-0.0087560685,
0.0780102611,
0.0398125164,
0.005034287,
0.0036582863,
-0.0193320923,
0.0574742742,
-0.0188176297,
0.0010987027,
-0.0058563813,
0.0644529983,
0.0033340536,
0.019895127,
0.0721822605,
0.0303871576,
-0.0907516778,
-0.0505862497,
-0.0063943919,
0.0785848796,
0.0047133984,
-0.012078491,
-0.0145819699,
-0.0312162805,
-0.0068570506,
0.0638784692,
-0.0080618905,
-0.0306114443,
0.0210801121,
-0.0411520489,
0.0391707681,
0.0026308515,
-0.0672749504,
0.0355047807,
-0.0512503758,
0.0297838133,
-0.0709180608,
-0.0024632905,
-0.0225904398,
0.0455516651,
0.0185509939,
0.0696350634,
-0.0439892523,
0.0007747397,
-0.0130349109,
-0.0281162784,
0.0408360846,
0.0627440438,
0.0199705362,
0.0031509763,
-0.0270570591,
0.05299481,
-0.0802053735,
-0.0250827931,
-0.0195394773,
0.092444703,
0.0131849153,
-0.001012995,
-0.0063703828,
0.0144373989,
0.0136775784,
0.0073585827,
-0.0191592816,
0.0277716555,
-0.0244369544,
0.0597029105,
-0.0388071388,
-0.0233563352,
0.0269754026,
0.0139598241,
-0.0068230564,
-0.0523507707,
-0.02047663,
0.0134266634,
0.0142754698,
0.0185911786,
-0.0160010699,
0.0431617163,
-0.062466424,
-0.1085820198,
-0.0383705497,
-0.0370867066,
0.0026096203,
0.0766715109,
-0.0164880194,
-0.0052265874,
0.0296454038,
0.0272327606,
-0.0249204468,
-0.0048566456,
0.0222060569,
0.0231563039,
-0.0194061119,
-0.0863220766,
0.0348134525,
0.0120478785,
-0.0382154696,
0.0460005589,
-0.025000887,
-0.0850734562,
0.0506779626,
0.0452618003,
0.0259096343,
0.0339911431,
-0.0046682786,
-0.0546812266,
0.000883267,
0.0588934571,
0.0476494916,
0.0144231282,
0.0477641299,
-0.0027915898,
-0.0367368683,
0.0162275843,
-0.0380065702,
0.0499709733,
0.0510094613,
-0.0370624624,
-0.0666374639,
-0.0685882717,
0.0160623398,
-0.0061343894,
0.0617491268,
-0.04999483,
-0.0245533679,
0.0081010954,
0.0167200044,
0.0570886619,
-0.0102515854,
-0.0163822565,
-0.0440065041,
0.0046292553,
-0.0257505029,
-0.031094322,
0.0729319528,
0.0739195868,
0.0675567687,
-0.0244041905,
0.0072066458,
0.0142056793,
0.0227134917,
-0.0116303479,
0.002576713,
-0.0025229573,
0.03208353,
0.022433389,
0.0384086035,
0.0522581451,
0.0147575792,
0.0306239966,
0.0358312838,
0.0045939595,
0.0265596639,
-0.0969396159,
-0.0436025299,
-0.0366171896,
0.0198164228,
0.0146516291,
0.0260872263,
0.0323218517,
0.0021789658,
-0.0198235977,
-0.0248174109,
-0.0096470704,
-0.0039310711,
0.0101192985,
0.0273953974,
0.0251577888,
-0.0040997933,
-0.0100159766,
0.0577127747,
0.0082173841,
0.002766032,
-0.0814637542,
-0.0083565414,
-0.0247464124,
0.005323288,
0.0096698049,
-0.0032766589,
-0.0054804403,
-0.009791458,
-0.0461444817,
-0.0227273386,
-0.0230852384,
-0.0159270801,
0.0284761749,
0.0442920849,
0.0268113986,
0.0344645008,
-0.0132981874,
-0.0285894889,
-0.0121800192,
-0.0168961231,
0.0009321072,
0.0360291786,
0.0202045739,
-6.20077972e-33,
-0.0315285549,
-0.0063323709,
-0.0586846583,
0.0181375071,
0.0103531247,
-0.0031814266,
0.00908574,
0.0239646621,
0.0182444844,
0.0296951756,
0.0128038395,
-0.0058298013,
0.0221295618,
0.0007533517,
0.0600750633,
-0.0284397285,
0.0627670288,
-0.0030890836,
0.0080188029,
0.0322449282,
0.0373540185,
-0.0269912127,
0.0123692024,
-0.0936232135,
0.0321929976,
0.0405276716,
-0.0350069217,
-0.0025134615,
-0.0469388813,
0.0073640635,
0.0290425885,
0.0430586487,
-0.0146704679,
-0.0366008691,
-0.0254952349,
-0.0506089814,
-0.0780377463,
-0.0124524226,
-0.0661223233,
0.0520920344,
0.0145581728,
0.0149643794,
-0.0028436782,
0.0046738316,
-0.0181182381,
-0.026497623,
0.0460436046,
-0.0047946959,
-0.0207673274,
-0.0766262934,
0.0239954814,
0.0366147719,
-0.0187629685,
0.017743241,
0.008271669,
0.0103382897,
0.0199602824,
-0.0181169715,
-0.071474798,
0.032698147,
-0.0140085034,
-0.0331682935,
-0.042795945,
0.032686498,
0.0108894575,
0.0419236869,
0.0745272413,
0.0019116,
-0.0441403985,
-0.0151034202,
-0.0349876434,
0.0278094634,
0.0449180342,
0.0625367761,
0.0292909853,
0.0000467448,
-0.0565696061,
0.0675503761,
0.0533400811,
-0.0199566577,
0.0011038475,
0.0645693839,
-0.0312523022,
-0.0256900825,
-0.0151658524,
-0.0516220182,
-0.0066250702,
0.0123935826,
-0.0117513984,
0.0322591588,
-0.0552083962,
0.0345069617,
0.0273514818,
0.0058050794,
-0.0134982634,
-0.0134608513,
0.0212398563,
0.0397428423,
0.0103588914,
-0.0576115474,
-0.0289034396,
-0.043062523,
0.0522779115,
0.0256325994,
-0.0070993509,
0.0161344279,
0.046572879,
0.018131962,
-0.0438478515,
-0.0063961167,
0.0049342783,
-0.0031876911,
0.0021470331,
-0.017911179,
0.0294527914,
-0.027246153,
-0.0153169418,
0.0176830404,
-0.0161880404,
0.0285262931,
-0.0145978676,
0.0236139093,
-0.0446925946,
0.0000394983,
0.0148924943,
-0.0264444482,
0.0328365825,
-0.0793276429,
0.0214624293,
-0.0205758102,
-0.002593152,
-0.0477740541,
2.554e-7,
0.0294131059,
0.0042238347,
-0.0230550058,
-0.0641688034,
0.0260103904,
0.0849957988,
-0.0106818946,
-0.0262346715,
0.0276347697,
-0.0257889647,
0.0148732318,
0.0360132083,
0.0050427029,
0.0478402972,
-0.0298990104,
-0.0839431286,
0.0031664702,
0.0381734818,
0.0007105806,
0.0249834545,
0.0253899917,
0.0789017454,
0.0534607992,
-0.0437577888,
0.045461718,
0.0125739649,
0.0487479903,
-0.0149014965,
0.0190643258,
0.0230296925,
0.0470998511,
-0.0450243391,
-0.0016823845,
0.0688337162,
-0.0240937229,
-0.0308587402,
-0.0024665718,
0.0188854877,
-0.0237039011,
-0.0209012888,
-0.003510135,
0.050947804,
0.0415260829,
0.0058228513,
0.070129998,
-0.0260746684,
-0.0724984556,
-0.0215552244,
-0.0196846835,
0.0009634231,
0.0728908256,
0.0523844138,
0.0130697703,
0.0103665516,
-0.0551389158,
0.0320548452,
-0.0401807651,
-0.0875562429,
-0.0086666271,
-0.034620408,
-0.0532568246,
-0.0710203499,
0.0140280994,
0.0326221809,
-0.01771833,
-0.027158536,
-0.0118052484,
1.890343116e-34,
0.0432083458,
0.0248632263,
-0.0037119735,
0.0485339388,
-0.0254622884,
-0.0003146365,
0.0032007841,
-0.0074146641,
0.0173767321,
0.0077427314,
0.0168902315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14971v1 | Penalty Decoding: Well Suppress the Self-Reinforcement Effect in Open-Ended Text Generation | 2023-10-23T14:20:04 | 2023-10-23T14:20:04 | Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The decoding algorithm is critical for open-ended text generation,
transforming latent representations into coherent and meaningful outputs. This
paper investigates the self-reinforcement effect in text generation and the
effectiveness of a repetition penalty to mitigate it. However, determining the
optimal repetition penalty value is challenging. To tackle this, we propose a
forgetting mechanism that disregards distant tokens, reducing the burden of
penalty selection. In addition, we introduce a length penalty to address overly
short sentences caused by excessive penalties. Our penalty decoding approach
incorporating three strategies helps resolve issues with sampling methods
deviating from factual information. Experimental results demonstrate the
efficacy of our approach in generating high-quality sentences resembling human
output. | [
0.0296602082,
0.0416064486,
-0.0054073324,
-0.0218937155,
-0.0159005132,
-0.0212101378,
-0.0150105264,
0.007884685,
-0.0326042026,
-0.0211122055,
0.025333548,
-0.0049927565,
0.0150704859,
0.0199190881,
0.029609913,
-0.0605623238,
0.0239073075,
-0.0385850929,
0.0284050144,
-0.0133018317,
0.0362498388,
-0.0085076066,
-0.0107200621,
0.0301215779,
-0.0246293489,
-0.0220816936,
-0.0227185171,
-0.0168305505,
0.0021838869,
-0.0507585444,
0.0102392081,
0.0442187041,
-0.0075066639,
0.0176153183,
0.0000019998,
-0.0350100175,
-0.0279167555,
-0.0349518061,
0.0003184606,
0.016582882,
0.0421181321,
-0.0335704423,
-0.000884745,
0.0212755762,
-0.0109943729,
0.0182492565,
0.056910269,
0.0573876463,
0.0637243167,
0.0478416309,
0.0053534806,
0.0012833494,
-0.0061436794,
-0.0166317578,
0.0205443036,
0.0309667271,
-0.0060572443,
0.0019460025,
-0.0137694683,
-0.0069310651,
-0.0147114489,
0.0227917228,
0.0315861478,
-0.0067469841,
0.0332167409,
0.085472621,
0.0127652762,
-0.0273819249,
-0.0240616575,
0.0143183172,
0.0020569339,
-0.0346519649,
0.0221868567,
-0.0401228592,
-0.0038981019,
-0.0326725692,
-0.0455756411,
0.0846119598,
-0.018998187,
0.02912746,
0.0376037396,
0.0524808541,
-0.027532693,
-0.007252668,
-0.0167438444,
-0.017700037,
0.0241037179,
-0.0528004654,
-0.0140624121,
0.0200000349,
-0.0013834761,
-0.07262633,
0.0198463146,
0.0261824895,
-0.0388955958,
0.0094378861,
-0.0741480365,
-0.0671588406,
0.0213246346,
-0.0193507951,
0.0269168708,
0.0400757194,
-0.003234457,
-0.003147485,
-0.0330509283,
0.0313733295,
0.0026287469,
0.0084139928,
-0.0141165564,
0.0731541589,
-0.0071462435,
-0.047857523,
-0.0538338609,
0.0838652775,
0.0065173511,
-0.0291920807,
-0.0561993234,
0.0283673014,
0.007275912,
-0.0114587126,
0.0087438636,
0.0129538011,
-0.0505926423,
0.0278984588,
-0.005116032,
-0.0106189428,
-0.047675278,
-0.0122514535,
0.0463919379,
0.0088370228,
-0.0508538298,
0.0164437294,
0.031321004,
-0.0105709815,
-0.0433772281,
0.0608275197,
-0.041132018,
-0.0153481252,
-0.0147941383,
-0.0715702027,
-0.0381384976,
-0.0359239317,
0.0094200047,
-0.047146067,
-0.0064671547,
-0.0105349822,
-0.0144268833,
-0.0289350636,
0.0217398051,
0.0270798448,
0.0075888205,
0.0038672767,
-0.0131978719,
-0.0347666591,
0.0215862822,
0.0073321443,
0.0297899824,
0.0494011752,
0.0235733557,
0.0784639791,
0.0000331653,
0.0293548312,
0.0249326788,
0.0070332317,
0.0485784151,
-0.0170735624,
-0.007273546,
-0.0190349035,
-0.0057920599,
0.052193407,
0.0729674622,
0.0744728073,
-0.056080997,
0.0522258729,
0.0414171852,
0.0304237735,
0.004717424,
0.0094769867,
0.0535589829,
0.026594054,
-0.0133123454,
0.0759173483,
-0.0189496167,
0.0647422001,
0.0293924138,
0.0386516862,
0.0611173771,
0.0018633192,
-0.0175048728,
-0.0370526798,
0.0342525318,
-0.0180706233,
0.0192566458,
-0.0468339175,
0.0170782041,
0.0407879725,
-0.0611162744,
0.0552286021,
0.0153661054,
-0.0699234903,
0.0174439382,
-0.0155792702,
0.0628172457,
0.0728999674,
0.0666337386,
-0.0071510966,
0.0320748277,
-0.0076005422,
-0.0187333021,
0.0609262548,
0.0173467062,
0.0176825542,
-0.0021697932,
-0.0413861834,
-0.0140529433,
-0.0129425805,
0.0031570606,
0.0018172985,
-0.0043265102,
0.0145541672,
0.0236678887,
0.0070255087,
-0.0340706706,
0.0504506268,
0.0069969636,
-0.0512155704,
0.0192253198,
0.0023339354,
-0.0200154018,
-0.0031850061,
0.000460217,
0.0476518646,
0.0243675187,
-0.041255869,
-0.0199520905,
-0.0012118606,
-0.0943386778,
-0.0974553302,
-0.0158373117,
-0.0504534692,
0.0069329878,
0.0075785215,
0.0218378548,
-0.0415831394,
0.0054120268,
-0.0658679083,
0.0517878383,
-0.0505668595,
0.0176758934,
0.0229156483,
0.0042482307,
-0.0211033691,
0.0530423857,
-0.024227269,
0.000528621,
0.0080231829,
-0.0322271436,
0.001559604,
-0.0836621746,
-0.0036892695,
-0.0236224364,
-0.0263728295,
0.0089100441,
0.057788983,
0.0423080772,
-0.0467473641,
-0.0553688817,
-0.0304519963,
0.0073098852,
-0.0165994968,
-0.006125282,
0.0220540632,
0.0035929638,
-0.0112581216,
-0.0107682822,
-0.0330823511,
-0.0272275228,
0.0361373872,
0.0055539608,
0.0598163232,
0.0016018697,
-0.0037635285,
-0.0010520724,
-0.0034055447,
0.0070790891,
0.0347368717,
0.0146211525,
-0.0108495336,
-0.0625071749,
0.0782100931,
-0.0254521426,
-0.0325354449,
0.0127603393,
-0.0199873205,
0.0420799032,
0.006938478,
0.0784902126,
0.0492547192,
0.0480515994,
0.0505952202,
0.0341465287,
0.0099371597,
-0.0303647388,
-0.0092078345,
-0.052650582,
0.0124477819,
0.0329719447,
-0.0355428532,
0.0623738915,
0.0398776904,
0.0706620514,
0.0514288247,
-0.0762065426,
0.0571607649,
-0.0195332542,
-0.0720811635,
-0.0063623046,
-0.0078422483,
-0.0436571352,
0.0108862072,
-0.0196274035,
-0.0449424908,
0.0473558269,
0.0089683859,
0.0220538452,
0.014768349,
0.0564539246,
0.0041110865,
0.0253031757,
0.0106405467,
0.0265227128,
0.0449726693,
-0.0525269471,
-0.0245872885,
0.0234656818,
0.0432007574,
-0.0116523858,
0.0018817764,
-0.0276940241,
-0.0263056811,
-0.017036777,
-0.0600289926,
-0.0591857471,
-0.0498763435,
0.0436251946,
-0.0287195649,
0.0246132594,
0.0099761486,
0.018743515,
-0.0219877884,
0.0457306355,
0.0146632129,
-0.0434927084,
-0.003930728,
-0.0345477015,
0.0291014072,
0.0523032323,
-0.0203011706,
0.0000121157,
-0.0516453832,
0.0193583425,
0.0498038232,
-0.0096779941,
0.0486978628,
0.0225766879,
0.0202658623,
0.0059901602,
-0.0225370247,
-0.0168479774,
0.0778595656,
0.0640964806,
-0.0335611105,
-0.0517526194,
0.0768495649,
0.0038558692,
-0.0091201449,
0.0201828573,
-0.0027999764,
0.0926960185,
-0.0256994776,
0.0042503332,
-0.0928177685,
-0.0046564247,
0.0016700201,
0.0560860075,
-0.0302975196,
-0.0127478177,
-0.0174487885,
-0.0811879784,
0.0439619794,
0.0188577976,
-0.0449057445,
-0.0112164738,
0.0006759245,
-0.0519291088,
0.0158733521,
-0.0179347899,
0.061794173,
-0.0235971939,
0.0491821803,
0.0391979888,
-0.033940535,
-0.0122793699,
-0.0408825949,
-0.0173432808,
0.0411139242,
0.056436412,
0.0175509304,
0.0210136231,
-0.0258215312,
-0.0110750115,
-0.0245038774,
0.021009706,
-0.0137268882,
0.0432294123,
0.0122955246,
0.0041483757,
-0.0595638342,
0.0496391729,
0.0060225539,
-0.0389096998,
0.0219751224,
0.0315579772,
-0.0198455937,
-0.018708745,
-0.0085243732,
0.0008454056,
0.0310379732,
0.0734621361,
0.0392848551,
-0.0339206234,
-0.0796034634,
-0.0374540798,
-0.0023108488,
-0.1379336268,
0.0033672946,
-0.0137411281,
-0.0030203082,
-0.0190405734,
-0.1004910395,
-0.0635820702,
0.0004092284,
0.0280953459,
-0.0049883137,
0.0084440317,
-0.008572178,
-0.0187820401,
-0.0379851758,
-0.0499851257,
-0.0348585434,
-0.0249713529,
-0.0396186709,
0.0097003356,
-0.0550830439,
-0.0651794672,
0.0133775696,
-0.0182589795,
-0.0825317502,
-0.0552677773,
0.0301056467,
0.0646930635,
0.0160352904,
0.0430368148,
0.0318387412,
-0.0266333912,
0.0694340318,
0.0530828871,
-0.0444614291,
0.0529811084,
0.0168341044,
0.0361426584,
0.0107820453,
0.0320084952,
-0.0250619352,
-0.0210538656,
0.0333579928,
0.0638339892,
0.013547861,
-0.0005878413,
0.0703991577,
0.0286671259,
-0.0241230894,
-0.0513070449,
0.0219182279,
-0.0511173233,
-0.0142639549,
-0.0408239551,
-0.0061259544,
-0.0271335356,
0.0553842746,
0.010744852,
0.0018768584,
-0.0041265013,
-0.0040304703,
-0.0340217836,
0.0247327667,
-0.0257939305,
-0.0132332994,
-0.019149255,
0.0401185304,
0.0307241771,
-0.009504403,
-0.0438115634,
0.0149520151,
-0.0626172125,
0.024132384,
-0.0277519878,
0.0323604494,
0.0388297439,
0.0079768207,
-0.0247339867,
0.012171587,
-0.0288929436,
0.0400918201,
-0.0155763375,
-0.0190024544,
0.0198363308,
0.028289495,
0.057820823,
-0.0410024934,
0.0248881113,
-0.0018991826,
0.0733041391,
-0.0054767169,
-0.0349155553,
-0.0258683339,
0.0056448579,
-0.0246508475,
-0.0694860518,
0.0765972733,
-0.034306936,
-0.0184754804,
-0.0008535996,
0.0195318069,
-0.052313786,
-0.0214022938,
0.0039212359,
0.0058383704,
-0.0001127831,
-0.0225100406,
-0.0361038856,
-0.0139972512,
0.0141128143,
0.0490677506,
0.0224574897,
-0.0164142363,
0.0349195227,
0.0045191259,
-0.0310571976,
-0.0259869788,
-0.0352972038,
0.0454252176,
-0.0197565742,
-0.0251262989,
-0.0561718345,
-6.25083227e-33,
-0.0484229848,
-0.0351978503,
0.0221629944,
-0.0123048313,
-0.0521148182,
-0.015372429,
-0.0537958592,
0.0167905986,
0.0935482383,
-0.0039639575,
-0.0222626217,
-0.0323532298,
0.0123902392,
0.0160658397,
0.0289350804,
0.024239976,
0.0564352423,
-0.0282705016,
-0.0874864161,
0.0272482447,
0.0545718744,
0.0419496894,
-0.0010321105,
-0.003891285,
0.0265252702,
-0.0195482932,
-0.022506902,
-0.029179357,
0.0247084629,
0.0461812764,
-0.0228682961,
0.0150019145,
0.0286720004,
-0.0363180861,
-0.0535786822,
0.0485387146,
-0.0706443936,
-0.0425068028,
0.0040592062,
-0.02259578,
-0.0523985177,
-0.0694405288,
-0.0008150024,
-0.0430249088,
-0.0174393579,
0.012692716,
0.0094362525,
-0.010899025,
-0.038309209,
-0.0397182703,
-0.0682685375,
0.0067899246,
-0.015287091,
0.0015762921,
-0.031750679,
0.0203250591,
-0.0211392902,
-0.0019342786,
-0.0256830454,
0.0473311096,
0.0302068219,
0.0376695767,
0.0139035275,
0.0150246862,
0.0097125564,
0.0535789691,
0.0100276908,
-0.0005395781,
-0.0410983786,
0.0016068812,
0.0182714481,
-0.0198058616,
0.0134660825,
0.0405820124,
0.0677598342,
-0.0552513078,
-0.0486981161,
0.0271035843,
-0.0372347124,
0.0048016575,
0.0370325111,
0.0203293636,
-0.0089694355,
-0.0363218822,
-0.0208163597,
0.0102053508,
-0.0067340964,
-0.0352996103,
0.0639629737,
0.0556238033,
-0.0173775926,
-0.0701525584,
0.0142538575,
0.0194944944,
0.0245570019,
-0.013468843,
-0.0301277004,
0.001286594,
-0.0397718027,
-0.0290202964,
-0.0460728034,
-0.0172007196,
0.0395039916,
0.0069698016,
0.0233990159,
0.0357921049,
0.0379512869,
0.0200607479,
-0.0451409854,
0.0194539111,
-0.0355170891,
0.0433357842,
0.0279899146,
-0.0387859643,
0.0250011906,
-0.0119745489,
-0.0137848882,
0.0211322885,
0.0041480497,
-0.0286337472,
-0.0679485798,
0.0047586546,
0.0241784696,
0.0310557224,
-0.030697139,
0.0282973312,
-0.0270901844,
0.0649409816,
0.0272820015,
-0.0645480156,
-0.0149416495,
0.0120860599,
2.587e-7,
-0.0145435855,
0.0164707992,
0.0772160366,
0.0201816261,
0.0128428591,
0.0191877093,
0.0232824534,
0.0578658022,
-0.026199609,
0.0386801399,
0.0100968843,
0.0083414828,
0.0262420345,
-0.0057581002,
-0.0590364486,
0.0385201201,
-0.0694109425,
-0.0169676337,
-0.0377205275,
-0.0180596001,
0.0929855481,
0.0034059265,
-0.0185757577,
0.0230770111,
0.0282174703,
-0.0079698786,
0.068425782,
0.0346556157,
-0.0108447839,
-0.0148337726,
0.025886843,
-0.0308747049,
-0.0026885371,
-0.0249398369,
-0.0101249404,
-0.0495382734,
0.0116866939,
0.0157578606,
0.0184620861,
-0.0344130881,
0.0543281101,
0.005839623,
-0.0121762007,
-0.0117724054,
0.0196427405,
-0.0488702878,
-0.0094901258,
0.0029568472,
0.0197330564,
-0.0051477621,
-0.0044468748,
-0.0230351705,
-0.0413221344,
0.0034693577,
0.0175375473,
0.0629210398,
0.0207305998,
-0.0350333303,
-0.041488573,
-0.0130583039,
-0.034436252,
-0.0407913923,
-0.0722247884,
0.0354450308,
0.0200161114,
-0.0863787085,
-0.0207230337,
2.425394739e-34,
0.0153445862,
-0.0356748812,
0.0226154625,
-0.002194002,
-0.0007847941,
-0.0038315756,
0.028014645,
0.0431961864,
0.0371155031,
-0.0413066857,
-0.0695928857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14970v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14970v1 | Towards LLM-driven Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-10-23T14:15:28 | 2023-10-23T14:15:28 | Yujie Feng, Zexin Lu, Bo Liu, Liming Zhan, Xiao-Ming Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue State Tracking (DST) is of paramount importance in ensuring accurate
tracking of user goals and system actions within task-oriented dialogue
systems. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) such as GPT3 and ChatGPT
has sparked considerable interest in assessing their efficacy across diverse
applications. In this study, we conduct an initial examination of ChatGPT's
capabilities in DST. Our evaluation uncovers the exceptional performance of
ChatGPT in this task, offering valuable insights to researchers regarding its
capabilities and providing useful directions for designing and enhancing
dialogue systems. Despite its impressive performance, ChatGPT has significant
limitations including its closed-source nature, request restrictions, raising
data privacy concerns, and lacking local deployment capabilities. To address
these concerns, we present LDST, an LLM-driven DST framework based on smaller,
open-source foundation models. By utilizing a novel domain-slot instruction
tuning method, LDST achieves performance on par with ChatGPT. Comprehensive
evaluations across three distinct experimental settings, we find that LDST
exhibits remarkable performance improvements in both zero-shot and few-shot
setting compared to previous SOTA methods. The source code is provided for
reproducibility. | [
0.042054899,
0.048307918,
-0.0204376373,
0.0452165268,
-0.0357234962,
-0.0100995675,
0.0048223655,
-0.0174144264,
0.0383796953,
-0.0406875052,
-0.043057058,
-0.0656861141,
-0.0123059982,
0.0623790324,
-0.004944881,
-0.0501084588,
0.0620249584,
-0.0496132523,
-0.0259050261,
0.0176126305,
0.0301426649,
0.0137113454,
-0.0550446026,
0.0730371252,
0.0149381347,
-0.0277751852,
-0.0515280738,
0.025198536,
-0.0163370017,
-0.0083217993,
-0.0021457938,
0.0303817801,
0.034746103,
0.0500223674,
0.0000021564,
-0.0513071977,
-0.010513965,
0.0072326269,
-0.0358381048,
0.02008681,
-0.0141583551,
0.0427078642,
-0.0373473912,
0.0428269021,
-0.0295416191,
0.002373863,
0.03123511,
0.0114783552,
0.0814385787,
0.0499356277,
0.0001048635,
0.0188143402,
0.0096080638,
-0.0131106814,
-0.000770257,
-0.0785068944,
-0.0085918074,
0.0112655945,
0.0249999836,
0.0097081373,
0.0119310301,
0.0326703787,
0.0003507383,
-0.0239472706,
-0.0530328862,
0.0103357732,
-0.028148314,
-0.0209501665,
-0.0461714827,
0.0596177131,
0.060152892,
0.0290672053,
0.0287377723,
0.0122904405,
-0.0113904811,
-0.0127709676,
-0.0574180335,
-0.0387437642,
-0.0455279239,
-0.0081760753,
-0.0297502801,
0.0009583525,
-0.0238419324,
-0.0104476698,
0.016897412,
0.0594516583,
0.0165583249,
-0.0185524933,
-0.0742164627,
-0.0186735783,
0.0258690957,
-0.0815513805,
0.0292269345,
0.0320083536,
-0.0570118949,
0.0434143282,
-0.0563703328,
0.0266906023,
-0.0020439592,
-0.0228973273,
-0.00195642,
0.0787429214,
-0.0096353432,
0.0526233017,
0.0538576469,
0.0876840129,
-0.0186278019,
-0.0206962544,
-0.0115627553,
-0.0040221452,
-0.0584910102,
0.0034418332,
-0.0502160303,
0.0286328625,
-0.051522404,
-0.0522622354,
-0.0234936904,
0.0802354962,
0.0448806658,
0.0303870533,
0.0000138799,
-0.0208491012,
-0.0230111349,
0.0092655579,
-0.0266375076,
0.0468059592,
0.0068156505,
-0.0056714355,
0.0134925498,
-0.0548770875,
-0.0055277962,
0.0001409626,
-0.0077331983,
0.0041269665,
-0.0319333449,
0.0726199076,
0.0069299843,
-0.0337285846,
-0.0059601325,
-0.0216290783,
0.0019771133,
-0.0652443692,
-0.0252017267,
-0.0271854419,
0.0393297002,
0.0159484763,
-0.0098951077,
-0.0202021543,
-0.0013293568,
0.0478922166,
0.0123031717,
0.0346166305,
-0.0324700475,
0.0218723863,
0.0158126894,
0.0311939958,
0.0001584565,
0.0549744964,
0.0447015315,
0.0280401167,
0.0450954698,
-0.0259207413,
0.0197894759,
0.0457393639,
-0.0196631011,
0.0134910662,
0.0123946676,
0.0458270758,
-0.0087456172,
-0.0092181358,
-0.0093801338,
0.0575672127,
-0.0220921263,
-0.0049466724,
0.0859611258,
0.0929717198,
-0.0052795894,
-0.016485624,
0.0112107322,
0.05465075,
-0.0033525219,
-0.0127623808,
-0.0172372051,
0.0312410463,
-0.000300047,
-0.0097373994,
0.0305589102,
0.0218443349,
-0.043569129,
-0.0089159347,
0.0017670543,
-0.0064552249,
0.0003423974,
0.0285921246,
0.0355867073,
-0.0342518874,
-0.059472166,
0.0535583049,
-0.0031646504,
-0.055365406,
-0.0431065038,
-0.0520579368,
0.0150110917,
0.1018764526,
0.0737112388,
-0.0177965984,
-0.0748400241,
-0.0347457044,
0.0116169108,
0.0402464494,
0.033445131,
-0.0023375538,
0.0280480571,
-0.0316246003,
-0.0198087376,
0.0046890178,
-0.0086068464,
0.0330056883,
0.0142866233,
-0.022730859,
-0.0028427262,
0.0083036125,
0.0461372174,
0.0018221743,
0.0142538818,
-0.009881624,
-0.0177084263,
-0.0101632932,
0.0547401123,
0.0328696966,
0.0066059697,
-0.0289637819,
0.0155076245,
0.0315907709,
0.01595583,
0.0411821194,
-0.043302156,
-0.0191932023,
0.0278876722,
0.0575660951,
0.0093305223,
0.0113980379,
-0.0210145786,
-0.0580407083,
0.0126697719,
-0.0419199243,
0.0324495398,
-0.0439150184,
0.0153933177,
0.0117549943,
-0.0150022553,
-0.0210642293,
-0.0125320116,
0.0012122637,
-0.0239786264,
0.0217735153,
0.0243682563,
0.0343217887,
-0.0240866039,
0.0071878247,
0.0145108569,
-0.0214301031,
0.0177138373,
0.0021097967,
0.0106727527,
-0.0449759699,
-0.0078165885,
-0.1113881916,
0.0360589996,
-0.0257943012,
0.0425990708,
0.0078808358,
0.0534498468,
-0.0356576517,
-0.0149435773,
-0.0176992752,
-0.0060479054,
0.0434356034,
-0.0099836187,
0.0063713444,
0.0186997913,
-0.0584408492,
-0.0542763136,
0.029724488,
-0.0024951976,
-0.02709819,
-0.0510014296,
-0.0507446639,
-0.0822923183,
0.0421969034,
-0.0308913533,
0.0513355434,
-0.0414041691,
-0.0436106138,
0.0555604286,
0.0184356067,
0.0222269278,
0.0310295392,
-0.0162404124,
0.0146349492,
-0.0011391758,
-0.0536782108,
-0.0644896775,
0.0436955132,
-0.001776351,
-0.0008249167,
-0.0432301387,
0.0271803532,
0.0300237257,
0.0354714058,
0.0134222861,
0.0259712301,
-0.0592005663,
-0.0099809989,
-0.0126378797,
0.0056008594,
-0.0105474144,
0.0021524457,
-0.0632930994,
0.0215478744,
0.0008432855,
-0.0554909073,
0.0423334353,
-0.0637220889,
-0.0491506085,
-0.0295447502,
-0.0198720843,
-0.0388646312,
0.0610870011,
-0.0233851299,
-0.0054601287,
0.056821879,
-0.0577819347,
0.0066637564,
0.0043371078,
0.0169685762,
-0.0596635416,
0.0553815179,
-0.069925189,
0.0231454819,
-0.0216430798,
-0.0402187593,
-0.0433441289,
-0.0252572112,
-0.034230426,
-0.0113962935,
-0.0111192111,
-0.0312039461,
-0.0008322533,
0.0422860682,
0.0354106985,
0.050223019,
-0.0019633977,
-0.006525863,
-0.040424116,
-0.005174594,
0.0423388369,
-0.0261431821,
-0.0443184488,
0.0064527816,
0.0476374812,
0.0719575882,
0.0680529475,
-0.0239512511,
0.0101925321,
-0.0478413291,
0.0503736027,
-0.0075238072,
-0.0334278569,
0.0326612554,
0.0961768329,
-0.0430227742,
-0.0107306978,
0.1245717853,
0.01953917,
-0.0377330743,
-0.0267580561,
-0.0158488583,
0.036458496,
0.0329402164,
0.0160829425,
-0.0977072418,
-0.0459487289,
0.0102144163,
0.0459689237,
0.0014866891,
-0.011252,
-0.0451791398,
-0.0740187764,
0.00578873,
-0.0192421153,
-0.0326770432,
0.0076358961,
-0.0059971921,
0.0433688015,
0.0253505968,
0.0241987202,
0.0192457046,
0.0154071581,
-0.0205291342,
0.0069999555,
-0.0524536259,
-0.0124043813,
0.0253116302,
-0.0237989668,
0.0940583348,
0.0797732547,
0.0280053299,
0.0335656032,
-0.010105419,
0.0266612377,
0.0147689963,
-0.0006806075,
-0.0094213653,
0.0022459007,
-0.0232062433,
-0.0057996148,
-0.0307117067,
0.023744259,
-0.0390670337,
0.0120323943,
0.0388857834,
0.0268051159,
-0.0633945018,
0.0514970236,
-0.007661575,
-0.0115460828,
0.0288829133,
0.0559774339,
0.0132319005,
-0.0597073212,
-0.0130652562,
-0.0314981453,
-0.035335917,
-0.0152509566,
-0.0061587067,
-0.0286954325,
-0.0007651521,
0.0217300784,
-0.0486200526,
-0.0290403217,
0.0191443749,
0.0218488835,
-0.0136673097,
0.0263896864,
0.0232683029,
0.0111390362,
0.0220273174,
-0.0015447648,
-0.065546006,
0.0263740811,
-0.0707124472,
-0.0191706531,
0.0547976494,
0.0092136236,
0.0164962485,
0.0346549377,
-0.067615658,
-0.0641037747,
-0.0252070744,
0.0708502978,
0.0226251911,
0.0111476369,
-0.0130155487,
0.0012703633,
-0.064349182,
-0.0076429434,
-0.0145411044,
0.0014789528,
0.0299799573,
0.0422632024,
-0.022322394,
0.0155064464,
-0.0319928005,
-0.0040086042,
-0.0191751923,
0.0311566051,
-0.0543832481,
-0.0708632395,
-0.0082713692,
0.0035830494,
0.0572277047,
0.0022739549,
-0.0208416041,
0.0026466686,
0.0490973592,
-0.0493952222,
0.0022177575,
-0.0730194896,
-0.0148316864,
-0.0387110673,
-0.0421938784,
0.0158496406,
-0.0149417678,
-0.0658164993,
0.01745723,
-0.0416257791,
0.0013189245,
-0.0168369692,
-0.0085111363,
0.0216942821,
-0.0144534223,
-0.0172795504,
0.0365269221,
0.029987134,
0.032308083,
-0.0191583,
0.1285914779,
-0.0223213453,
-0.0270211734,
0.0446351282,
0.0589290597,
-0.0564957,
-0.0443868637,
0.0054621887,
0.0415329449,
0.0477003008,
0.0465396009,
0.0561184995,
-0.0157188736,
0.0199940931,
-0.0375251658,
0.0590616018,
0.0053915908,
-0.029640343,
0.0060052732,
0.0198569614,
-0.0146524413,
-0.0139754666,
0.0602771565,
0.0203773528,
0.0088719269,
0.0135243414,
-0.0175459944,
-0.0557080284,
-0.0286386684,
0.0007700822,
0.0321446359,
-0.0194098298,
-0.0108004333,
-0.0558221824,
-0.0193429925,
-0.0204688013,
0.0018245149,
0.0017842113,
-0.0420330949,
0.0463645309,
0.028786255,
-0.0051932423,
-0.0072046076,
-0.0436411314,
-0.0411827713,
-0.0442360826,
-0.0048214928,
-0.0172740705,
-5.80500216e-33,
-0.0371817648,
-0.024903059,
0.0534356013,
0.0298755579,
-0.0500504263,
-0.0215223078,
-0.0393023044,
0.0097434549,
-0.0164729767,
-0.0641441494,
-0.0268783923,
0.0375518128,
0.0144216064,
0.0109622572,
-0.0411920995,
-0.0236530714,
0.0435203575,
-0.0066632316,
-0.0316015556,
0.0503693894,
0.0524713397,
0.0093054492,
0.0358196124,
-0.0901424214,
0.0116785849,
-0.0011098408,
0.0186633132,
0.0117643299,
0.0094347745,
0.0309374332,
-0.0095014889,
0.0173123926,
0.0011231864,
-0.0567591079,
-0.0016435405,
0.0256391633,
0.0321931653,
-0.0065668952,
0.0521348193,
0.0244423747,
0.0211102199,
0.0217433181,
-0.0283604972,
-0.0103574898,
0.0004203496,
0.0363281146,
-0.0231422521,
0.0194169842,
-0.0273738075,
0.0080676014,
-0.052707132,
0.025676962,
-0.0006866117,
-0.0812887922,
-0.0124295531,
0.0375117548,
0.02614085,
-0.0687088966,
-0.0017487749,
0.0030029337,
-0.0116769327,
0.0044014966,
0.0619961359,
0.0348555334,
0.0284913313,
0.0619256236,
0.026000753,
0.0349344984,
-0.0247084387,
-0.0328579284,
-0.0211575497,
0.0311389342,
0.0391233079,
-0.0068875556,
-0.0518497452,
-0.004548646,
-0.0215910431,
0.0158470664,
0.0420381799,
0.0247320365,
0.0160965975,
0.0458468683,
-0.0713906586,
0.0069230585,
0.0067928731,
0.0461333357,
0.0027479127,
-0.0310920533,
0.049632296,
0.0044777473,
-0.0072718267,
-0.0306009836,
0.0623662882,
-0.0050409818,
0.0059470418,
0.0206792019,
-0.0218701437,
0.0213328134,
-0.035210222,
0.009356413,
-0.0435896665,
-0.0099766543,
0.0237865131,
0.0170743316,
0.0207688771,
0.0050190091,
-0.0433206297,
0.0198425818,
-0.0409772471,
0.005959725,
-0.0483467393,
0.0654662922,
-0.049901057,
0.0198112838,
0.045937378,
-0.0230117198,
-0.0139100542,
0.1007328704,
0.0101251379,
-0.0645721853,
-0.0673186257,
-0.0313730389,
0.0060049677,
-0.0221470892,
-0.0241437498,
0.002726712,
-0.0243708361,
0.0050049783,
0.0021521321,
-0.0144381598,
0.0027175446,
-0.0260287318,
2.902e-7,
-0.0197920259,
0.0309999399,
0.0351072885,
0.0308989752,
0.0301411338,
0.061698731,
-0.0131793218,
0.040332038,
0.048990801,
-0.0129711349,
-0.0079964288,
0.0081963427,
0.057777755,
0.0239489563,
-0.1156207398,
-0.037780568,
-0.0237500258,
-0.001809385,
-0.0505866483,
0.0446700454,
0.033760868,
0.0367913432,
0.0177152883,
0.0155144669,
0.020643292,
-0.0093273204,
0.0332599469,
-0.0278839953,
-0.0361687951,
0.0189596824,
0.0096099107,
0.018109791,
-0.0145293381,
-0.0144519033,
0.0024640937,
0.0206189211,
-0.0261885058,
0.0961400494,
-0.0067016031,
-0.0577397458,
-0.0161995068,
-0.0211872924,
-0.0000622826,
-0.0259639584,
0.0474865809,
-0.0117803104,
-0.0043138843,
-0.0280615222,
0.0317845643,
-0.0411158465,
-0.0146617126,
0.0156104974,
-0.0171286389,
-0.0101790074,
-0.0079332953,
-0.020494001,
-0.0169471223,
-0.0585277379,
-0.0068703052,
-0.0570311137,
-0.0472438,
-0.0576621443,
-0.0494337715,
-0.0219106544,
-0.0380388796,
-0.0124164606,
-0.019381687,
2.588103591e-34,
0.0068394174,
-0.0156869162,
0.0297647137,
0.057348378,
0.0309224948,
0.029305933,
0.0128035359,
0.0041614058,
0.0670941249,
-0.0592337996,
-0.0196695738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14954v2 | Key Frame Mechanism For Efficient Conformer Based End-to-end Speech Recognition | 2023-10-23T13:55:49 | 2023-10-28T14:38:46 | Peng Fan, Changhao Shan, Sining Sun, Qing Yang, Jianwei Zhang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Recently, Conformer as a backbone network for end-to-end automatic speech
recognition achieved state-of-the-art performance. The Conformer block
leverages a self-attention mechanism to capture global information, along with
a convolutional neural network to capture local information, resulting in
improved performance. However, the Conformer-based model encounters an issue
with the self-attention mechanism, as computational complexity grows
quadratically with the length of the input sequence. Inspired by previous
Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) guided blank skipping during
decoding, we introduce intermediate CTC outputs as guidance into the
downsampling procedure of the Conformer encoder. We define the frame with
non-blank output as key frame. Specifically, we introduce the key frame-based
self-attention (KFSA) mechanism, a novel method to reduce the computation of
the self-attention mechanism using key frames. The structure of our proposed
approach comprises two encoders. Following the initial encoder, we introduce an
intermediate CTC loss function to compute the label frame, enabling us to
extract the key frames and blank frames for KFSA. Furthermore, we introduce the
key frame-based downsampling (KFDS) mechanism to operate on high-dimensional
acoustic features directly and drop the frames corresponding to blank labels,
which results in new acoustic feature sequences as input to the second encoder.
By using the proposed method, which achieves comparable or higher performance
than vanilla Conformer and other similar work such as Efficient Conformer.
Meantime, our proposed method can discard more than 60\% useless frames during
model training and inference, which will accelerate the inference speed
significantly. This work code is available in
{https://github.com/scufan1990/Key-Frame-Mechanism-For-Efficient-Conformer} | [
-0.0276587345,
0.0294304099,
0.0312983617,
0.0327549949,
0.0140352799,
-0.0221132282,
0.0223535523,
-0.022414621,
0.0018165804,
-0.0016605668,
-0.0453478135,
-0.0075045023,
0.0336327665,
0.0600278489,
-0.0115122106,
-0.0556644276,
0.0012353251,
-0.0111953551,
0.0132986475,
-0.0177065693,
-0.033684954,
-0.0143241771,
-0.019918358,
0.022665685,
0.003140755,
-0.0103214467,
-0.0478880927,
0.006397584,
0.0171293207,
-0.0329710506,
-0.0144086033,
0.0137222651,
0.0298160259,
0.0023661249,
0.0000023748,
0.0238886978,
-0.0037778283,
-0.0179791581,
-0.0503178723,
0.0290909596,
-0.0253135189,
0.0210986529,
-0.0262117703,
0.0097723054,
0.001788145,
-0.0282759946,
0.0380805992,
0.0687717572,
0.0218833312,
0.0384432562,
0.0067763692,
-0.0702755228,
0.0185332093,
-0.0308620166,
-0.0173338186,
-0.0424167216,
-0.0196967516,
-0.0415023156,
0.0125609552,
-0.0573674068,
-0.0514258891,
0.0605965815,
0.0500913151,
0.0062491479,
0.0419198386,
0.0430861525,
0.0275678914,
-0.0339015909,
-0.0154111423,
0.0800271258,
-0.0124520026,
-0.0276490506,
-0.0020890851,
-0.0033288484,
0.0020290457,
-0.0329510234,
-0.0331785567,
0.0043532522,
0.0306191724,
0.0043977653,
-0.0145962154,
0.0653770864,
0.0082434285,
-0.036811959,
-0.0457795635,
-0.0193279255,
-0.010203355,
-0.0138858836,
-0.0081480574,
-0.0500726253,
0.0070190849,
-0.0268316679,
0.0266214311,
0.0166508108,
0.0444376692,
-0.0515519157,
-0.0463483557,
-0.0229852721,
-0.0369179808,
-0.0695885867,
-0.0407896303,
0.068813324,
-0.0139224119,
0.0142621882,
-0.0540788509,
0.0862131715,
-0.0219912007,
0.047442887,
-0.0246277954,
0.0161756035,
-0.0048418175,
0.0083467858,
-0.0496618487,
0.0356254131,
-0.0219561998,
-0.034102764,
-0.0099077579,
0.0078157708,
-0.0117237819,
-0.0112738442,
0.0037006822,
0.0340734348,
-0.032990098,
-0.033629097,
0.0506173074,
0.0816493854,
-0.0393932126,
-0.0007250601,
-0.0236937311,
-0.0573162548,
-0.0522911027,
0.0382551514,
0.0503388904,
-0.0066791805,
0.011637439,
0.0478625819,
-0.0047781202,
-0.027442025,
-0.0204096027,
0.0145764379,
-0.0364599153,
-0.0301937163,
0.0228603221,
-0.0477623045,
0.0183328092,
-0.0047601336,
0.024096353,
-0.0738527179,
-0.0033231394,
-0.0135060027,
0.0204429366,
0.0450099669,
0.0288554002,
-0.0246893428,
0.0400455222,
-0.0071857031,
0.0470978096,
0.029077176,
0.0601777695,
0.0020299053,
-0.0314640515,
-0.0437187776,
-0.0285172649,
0.0118515296,
0.0293239206,
-0.0045129615,
-0.0686934367,
-0.0214531608,
0.0741954222,
0.0385472216,
0.0649374351,
-0.0059303599,
-0.0150927464,
-0.046345517,
0.0507224649,
-0.0028163653,
0.0384111628,
0.0086709829,
0.0197975859,
0.0509679802,
-0.0113862436,
0.0016224734,
-0.0147110857,
0.0796433836,
0.0158019047,
0.0137249455,
0.0456313752,
0.0057420051,
-0.0558414869,
-0.0149148498,
0.0195297189,
-0.0052699521,
0.0035545735,
0.0051361322,
0.0578337237,
0.001750957,
-0.0587390102,
0.0661832988,
-0.0200115759,
-0.0293200724,
0.0034998849,
-0.0075984332,
0.0043242411,
0.0246444289,
0.0079225181,
0.0015987366,
-0.037583854,
-0.0373981483,
0.0065420419,
0.0083200326,
0.0106281359,
0.0194612779,
0.0151601089,
-0.0489677303,
-0.0586216114,
0.0193935689,
-0.0282121506,
0.0588807203,
-0.0178888161,
0.0428001173,
0.0135531044,
-0.0127159515,
0.038892068,
-0.0079993894,
0.0218562558,
-0.0228514001,
0.0357287563,
0.0584024973,
0.0478237495,
0.0413535945,
-0.0001521861,
-0.0033219913,
0.0684016496,
-0.0604198612,
0.0095639871,
0.0329569541,
-0.0953691229,
-0.0276194401,
0.0327972174,
-0.0063672829,
0.0345515124,
0.0553501025,
0.0252092872,
-0.1024811938,
0.0662209913,
0.0066790311,
0.0663603917,
-0.0116229411,
0.0305299833,
0.0481767356,
0.0274253562,
0.0254817456,
-0.0065185139,
-0.0164565463,
0.0026240139,
0.001138058,
-0.0026529767,
-0.0084958207,
-0.0647319034,
-0.0277753882,
0.0467186235,
-0.0355787054,
-0.0196744967,
-0.0119314594,
-0.0251771174,
0.0071062474,
-0.015146018,
-0.0262609683,
-0.0124669606,
-0.0049540848,
0.0185247492,
-0.024542354,
0.0257174484,
0.0140118981,
-0.0474921875,
0.0151275937,
-0.0309950598,
-0.0442915671,
-0.0177214667,
-0.0477453992,
0.0239183344,
-0.0505332984,
0.0350427665,
-0.0041964347,
0.0468419231,
0.0201628376,
-0.0238139443,
-0.0556194447,
-0.0275276396,
-0.0346203819,
0.0550895147,
0.0334549919,
-0.008251776,
-0.035698995,
-0.0261225477,
0.0109343305,
-0.034297362,
0.055766955,
0.0241879877,
0.0040298253,
0.0199086685,
0.015898129,
-0.0318158455,
0.0512334071,
0.0084816869,
0.0525035486,
-0.0009059442,
0.0312943086,
-0.0451131351,
0.0690324381,
0.0064436779,
0.0556198433,
-0.0806399137,
-0.0347235166,
0.0398545302,
-0.0312439296,
-0.0227651503,
0.0063912338,
-0.0410859026,
-0.0140871396,
-0.0032502769,
0.0024939284,
0.008813181,
-0.05028731,
-0.0631907135,
0.025608182,
-0.0190590564,
0.0058874795,
0.0480811559,
0.0151945902,
-0.0123824356,
0.0262205563,
-0.0676579624,
-0.0039569889,
-0.0029206509,
0.0017995507,
-0.0029872148,
0.0456017926,
0.0036669327,
0.0081112059,
-0.0268991441,
-0.0108476821,
-0.0406386666,
-0.0084383711,
-0.0369956121,
0.0095530273,
-0.0471392274,
-0.034111768,
-0.0676052123,
0.0427408963,
-0.0069048093,
0.0799427107,
-0.0007721393,
0.04408326,
-0.016729435,
0.0708261952,
-0.0035726435,
0.0515793972,
-0.0021074172,
0.0069810967,
0.0550372936,
0.0429255888,
0.0316794477,
0.0119327214,
-0.0244027004,
-0.0253083054,
0.0236117058,
-0.0039863228,
-0.0063806567,
0.027333755,
0.0264479928,
-0.0792713538,
0.0165928341,
0.1008521765,
-0.0182583965,
-0.0509830192,
-0.0197720528,
0.0259514935,
0.0223246142,
0.0103004482,
-0.0186536405,
-0.0329495892,
-0.0641262382,
0.0514692478,
0.0359932967,
0.0234468132,
0.0183531642,
-0.020609986,
-0.05638941,
0.0393960178,
0.0319881774,
-0.0361586474,
-0.0743912458,
-0.0216536205,
-0.0344891809,
-0.018150704,
0.0230944082,
0.0133341495,
-0.0180847123,
-0.0424094349,
0.0186479315,
-0.0469011627,
-0.0171209406,
0.0225564931,
-0.0030655803,
0.0645928383,
0.005488161,
0.0210953131,
-0.0076998081,
-0.0318267606,
0.0357439145,
-0.044535473,
-0.0043257843,
-0.0076506492,
0.0025852113,
-0.020715436,
-0.0267774519,
0.0672565773,
0.0282207858,
-0.0600494035,
0.0246944241,
0.0057767453,
0.0761894509,
-0.0123407273,
0.0070847194,
0.0352987051,
0.0190283563,
-0.0076700845,
0.0791922882,
0.0458272398,
-0.0111857997,
-0.0184200741,
0.0100999456,
-0.0016245171,
-0.0414101109,
0.0093919244,
-0.0373370983,
0.0295973197,
-0.0528859831,
0.0036230956,
-0.0083635785,
0.012253494,
-0.0004911407,
-0.0031133995,
-0.0307003353,
-0.0157191213,
0.0266512297,
-0.0739454404,
0.0023300445,
-0.0423085093,
0.0009843477,
-0.1017501503,
0.0305316374,
0.0166219417,
-0.0545899943,
-0.0046382169,
0.0580089912,
-0.0307603311,
-0.0234871041,
0.014746164,
-0.0296238214,
0.0014222196,
0.1235434562,
-0.0242645368,
0.0395154208,
0.0389060676,
-0.0115767196,
-0.0386376381,
0.0227435846,
0.0704357997,
-0.0793622509,
-0.0237885471,
0.0274063386,
-0.0399159826,
0.012780048,
-0.0106622996,
0.0130194621,
-0.0201692972,
-0.0224894658,
0.0112644555,
-0.0131688556,
0.0309429634,
-0.002516313,
0.0431786329,
-0.0094241686,
0.0662619919,
0.0181881655,
0.0481272042,
-0.0462326929,
-0.0031499646,
-0.0151293045,
0.0177637748,
0.0203844961,
0.0610467196,
0.0178245008,
-0.0594857372,
0.0376497023,
0.0588586852,
-0.0408917479,
0.0299809519,
0.0018241575,
-0.0335936174,
-0.0003227072,
0.0102510862,
0.0494924486,
0.0264363568,
-0.0430875197,
-0.0104501322,
0.0148741845,
0.0216748603,
-0.0503910668,
0.0071982988,
-0.0277870614,
0.0169074927,
-0.0353840813,
-0.0065170699,
0.0213220455,
-0.0100200381,
0.0131484317,
0.0240409561,
-0.0172138419,
-0.0237828363,
0.0179755092,
-0.0401271768,
-0.0109433876,
0.0263309311,
0.0026634077,
0.009871616,
0.0052416804,
0.0163626317,
-0.0154087227,
0.0417090207,
0.0018133619,
0.0405516922,
-0.0394055396,
-0.0133265592,
-0.0520669632,
0.0014826462,
-0.0115378294,
0.0155234514,
0.0353466906,
-0.0299565345,
0.0820035785,
-0.0580306761,
0.0079896385,
-0.019214252,
0.0308948774,
-0.0310180988,
0.0099576721,
-0.0070096464,
0.0206031837,
-0.0213381108,
0.0205897186,
-0.0215607919,
-0.001633512,
-6.850539366e-33,
-0.037326023,
-0.0194100812,
-0.0128798261,
0.0113874963,
-0.0437237062,
0.0035425543,
-0.0330463983,
-0.0002116324,
0.0050393408,
-0.0072107115,
-0.0111277914,
0.0179697014,
0.0375872403,
0.0208551064,
0.0183225796,
-0.0209976621,
0.0997301415,
-0.0398730524,
-0.0005445756,
0.0331546068,
0.0539359897,
0.0381667055,
0.0489399806,
-0.0069103581,
-0.0517700762,
0.012853859,
0.0135022989,
-0.0080346735,
0.0362406671,
0.0145989303,
-0.001273988,
0.0017405044,
-0.0063442448,
-0.0673815683,
-0.0122790374,
0.0031068956,
-0.1401915699,
-0.0098790824,
-0.0537314937,
0.0467689596,
0.014117348,
-0.0509691238,
0.0551439039,
0.0396180972,
-0.0166102443,
-0.0755158439,
0.0211375356,
-0.0285960641,
-0.0633621812,
0.0164127685,
0.0018411444,
0.0468417592,
-0.0372326002,
-0.035063304,
0.0535382107,
0.0676705465,
-0.0295354798,
-0.0279115383,
-0.081056878,
0.0330786631,
0.0294592734,
0.0218707621,
0.0376549214,
0.0272214506,
0.0054886499,
0.0044724741,
0.011656384,
-0.0748161897,
-0.0305441152,
-0.0082401913,
0.0168730989,
-0.0126266107,
0.0248390604,
-0.0113951955,
0.0533569716,
-0.0422902554,
-0.0379414447,
-0.0114361541,
-0.0253818054,
0.0688460693,
0.0198633503,
0.0150749041,
-0.0632317513,
0.0071941954,
-0.0355642475,
-0.0412579589,
-0.0297104903,
0.0012468506,
0.0287891105,
0.0288299285,
0.0048293495,
-0.0313902348,
0.0590234026,
-0.0210986119,
0.0989993438,
0.0203419365,
0.0145363109,
0.0173395071,
0.0171291139,
-0.013100435,
-0.0300213471,
0.0238970965,
0.0537367649,
-0.0247740652,
-0.0006193876,
-0.04689705,
0.0132192578,
0.0826457292,
-0.047322005,
-0.0406837389,
-0.0013732276,
0.0167970061,
0.0189635735,
0.0071300343,
0.0611708872,
-0.0118559059,
0.0148949716,
0.0678990185,
-0.0693647042,
0.0468745306,
-0.0143547263,
-0.0033872058,
0.0601568334,
0.0421660841,
-0.03265227,
0.0197542645,
-0.0243137348,
-0.0135256387,
0.0277134907,
-0.0324452892,
-0.0162480827,
0.0064185169,
3.206e-7,
-0.0631661415,
-0.0460875779,
0.04841296,
-0.0478388742,
0.019716084,
0.0180202294,
0.015060164,
0.0086848037,
-0.0180257764,
0.0279830806,
0.0560384989,
0.0095340293,
0.0554507226,
-0.0281801093,
-0.0928278565,
0.0386622585,
-0.0445774421,
0.0176015589,
0.0344905853,
-0.0103273895,
-0.0236614533,
0.0702164546,
-0.0072922572,
-0.0119225951,
0.0233986676,
0.025893135,
0.0285295043,
0.03108472,
0.0188364405,
-0.0494070053,
-0.0010629682,
-0.0166166406,
-0.0534347594,
0.0078201098,
-0.0290230773,
0.0192241706,
-0.0188041907,
0.0360812806,
0.0049303342,
-0.083462961,
0.0117421839,
0.0468918234,
-0.027488362,
0.0136939753,
0.077196084,
-0.0563967042,
-0.048600167,
-0.0191800706,
-0.0622123256,
0.0305831693,
-0.0019113891,
0.0094101569,
0.042757526,
-0.0241314545,
0.0113052186,
-0.03172848,
-0.0103367278,
-0.067085132,
0.0223270766,
-0.0143127842,
-0.0725948066,
0.0334639102,
-0.0716675669,
-0.0650347099,
0.065782465,
-0.0023749438,
-0.03246044,
2.406128341e-34,
0.0133192027,
-0.0258819088,
0.0150257852,
-0.0300039742,
-0.0439355038,
-0.0511784181,
0.0164354797,
-0.0057373303,
0.0110450089,
-0.0535362102,
-0.0447812453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14947v1 | System Combination via Quality Estimation for Grammatical Error Correction | 2023-10-23T13:46:49 | 2023-10-23T13:46:49 | Muhammad Reza Qorib, Hwee Tou Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Quality estimation models have been developed to assess the corrections made
by grammatical error correction (GEC) models when the reference or
gold-standard corrections are not available. An ideal quality estimator can be
utilized to combine the outputs of multiple GEC systems by choosing the best
subset of edits from the union of all edits proposed by the GEC base systems.
However, we found that existing GEC quality estimation models are not good
enough in differentiating good corrections from bad ones, resulting in a low
F0.5 score when used for system combination. In this paper, we propose GRECO, a
new state-of-the-art quality estimation model that gives a better estimate of
the quality of a corrected sentence, as indicated by having a higher
correlation to the F0.5 score of a corrected sentence. It results in a combined
GEC system with a higher F0.5 score. We also propose three methods for
utilizing GEC quality estimation models for system combination with varying
generality: model-agnostic, model-agnostic with voting bias, and
model-dependent method. The combined GEC system outperforms the state of the
art on the CoNLL-2014 test set and the BEA-2019 test set, achieving the highest
F0.5 scores published to date. | [
0.0715618581,
0.0299190655,
-0.0044243075,
-0.0048695146,
-0.0300055854,
0.0065103602,
-0.0285057351,
-0.0049587395,
-0.029296862,
-0.0628928393,
-0.0119232107,
-0.0208023451,
0.0612549074,
-0.0196178146,
0.0137121892,
-0.0426750742,
0.0704474375,
0.0295214429,
-0.0208062232,
-0.0009833816,
0.0243657529,
0.006881746,
-0.0062918062,
0.0474708267,
-0.0357325897,
-0.0330407098,
0.0058921278,
0.0478270128,
0.0318348855,
0.0046492727,
0.0487552062,
0.0608627982,
-0.0489141718,
0.0704968274,
0.0000018715,
-0.0618610047,
-0.0423366763,
0.0107597709,
0.0013174415,
0.0450633466,
0.0325318277,
0.0018216994,
-0.0799405351,
0.0139431274,
0.0065023685,
0.0114935469,
0.0451012328,
0.0306135193,
0.0822719932,
0.0756779015,
-0.0070002172,
0.0053769797,
0.0085671432,
0.0094265472,
-0.0656851605,
-0.0070691411,
0.0329023004,
0.0197524112,
-0.0095138289,
-0.0204173457,
0.0123022292,
0.0434879251,
0.0026208472,
-0.0759765878,
0.0075075803,
-0.029572919,
-0.0156041253,
-0.0062235007,
-0.0060914056,
-0.018646691,
0.0163022205,
-0.0240201745,
-0.029543275,
0.0004361763,
0.0345084332,
0.0057727247,
-0.0231635589,
-0.0243478306,
0.0113966102,
-0.009985907,
0.0384899899,
-0.0776456371,
-0.0146082016,
0.0226249378,
0.0330844037,
0.0544165596,
0.0280280001,
-0.0568153448,
-0.0488875434,
0.0523248091,
-0.0221236739,
-0.0562150292,
0.0389650762,
-0.0221148003,
-0.0552670695,
-0.0282459781,
-0.0372128785,
-0.0708823875,
0.012227729,
-0.0531031378,
0.0048051598,
-0.0222487133,
0.0037438942,
0.0214124881,
-0.007743746,
0.0436996333,
0.0463643707,
0.0065738284,
-0.0078519695,
0.0229228623,
-0.0391352698,
0.0183185134,
-0.0350070931,
0.0347077288,
-0.0509386584,
0.035618417,
-0.0941547528,
-0.0159642454,
-0.0102898702,
0.0189841799,
0.040006604,
-0.0017377889,
-0.0254504494,
-0.0373421349,
-0.0093388679,
0.0272839982,
0.0074050776,
0.0539595485,
-0.0037978836,
-0.0270564854,
-0.00279015,
-0.0159205068,
0.0611165166,
-0.0001536092,
-0.0149839809,
-0.0244499017,
0.0018673119,
-0.0284741484,
-0.0264189951,
-0.0003340725,
-0.0443915538,
-0.0296243373,
-0.0809474066,
-0.0502198152,
-0.0316676721,
-0.0170171093,
0.0329075232,
-0.011787557,
-0.0194490869,
0.0010637275,
-0.0021670631,
0.0189213566,
-0.0630611181,
0.0272835344,
0.005739247,
-0.0311807469,
-0.0012657143,
0.0061519681,
0.0355428122,
-0.0498129688,
0.0664149374,
0.0345032327,
0.0310993474,
0.0029149889,
-0.0781222507,
-0.0068420172,
0.0302902963,
-0.0344790556,
0.0072347252,
0.0025449046,
0.0044331499,
0.0696333721,
-0.0050684246,
0.0523477532,
0.0735846832,
-0.0198778845,
0.039247293,
0.0042306483,
0.005802108,
-0.0453113317,
0.0471192077,
0.0137041323,
-0.0206125192,
-0.007630561,
-0.0459807888,
0.0036984521,
0.0510008,
0.0162511226,
0.0154943885,
-0.0745848641,
-0.014776404,
-0.0078884931,
-0.0176645983,
-0.0634859428,
0.0362930447,
0.0125025427,
-0.0191141628,
-0.0166119803,
0.0108135855,
-0.087266393,
0.0162043534,
-0.021646278,
0.0035942879,
0.0796103925,
0.0894950554,
-0.0017283206,
-0.0029634754,
-0.0319842137,
-0.0339316875,
0.0305217542,
0.036997959,
-0.0246183481,
-0.0125365984,
-0.037920922,
-0.0079698199,
0.0305852424,
0.0488746949,
-0.0274423398,
-0.0071860948,
-0.014167035,
0.0054622279,
0.005285209,
-0.0769522265,
0.0124841612,
0.0576839112,
0.0346480794,
-0.0038824007,
-0.0157765001,
0.0289251972,
0.0129195582,
-0.0490899049,
0.0011953064,
-0.0328187682,
0.0081607029,
-0.0410234816,
-0.0034229993,
-0.0019334041,
-0.0454705954,
0.0486552045,
-0.0200706199,
-0.028687438,
0.0341454931,
-0.0107306018,
-0.0538751036,
-0.0252695754,
-0.0805293843,
0.0180386566,
-0.0559414327,
0.0740899444,
-0.0206707343,
-0.0440949649,
-0.0301857796,
-0.0070275296,
0.0072668628,
0.007636792,
-0.022726465,
-0.0309403259,
0.0267005451,
-0.0422930643,
-0.0706937164,
-0.0032248085,
-0.0187112931,
0.036830321,
0.0377634726,
0.024489738,
-0.0385776162,
-0.0405430049,
-0.0592411682,
-0.0102139814,
-0.0414846912,
0.014443039,
0.0448037051,
0.0037514234,
-0.0079773907,
0.0035600481,
0.0474499874,
-0.0106859319,
0.0123077128,
0.0177678745,
0.0508022234,
-0.0098217167,
-0.0101506636,
-0.1037449762,
-0.0043416233,
-0.0351973623,
0.0133076357,
0.0381266102,
-0.0344202183,
-0.0572951324,
0.0684428066,
-0.0322815664,
-0.0043835673,
0.0714844242,
-0.0927540511,
-0.0111794891,
0.0185635798,
0.0699979067,
0.0278743524,
-0.0058118529,
-0.0382533334,
0.0021031499,
-0.0359887481,
-0.0126470784,
-0.0113873435,
0.0190429296,
-0.0285692699,
-0.0150556741,
-0.0136568109,
0.0334464461,
0.027024122,
-0.0014702305,
-0.034448307,
-0.0269573219,
0.0272332691,
-0.0577522889,
-0.0131665329,
0.0083538145,
-0.01001429,
-0.0180083625,
0.020393787,
-0.033258263,
-0.0223425329,
0.0474712998,
0.0123143103,
0.0086137243,
-0.0579834878,
0.0167945437,
0.0038550757,
-0.0460963473,
-0.0065785064,
0.0429158099,
-0.0133488066,
-0.0230046436,
-0.0396652892,
0.0060882689,
0.0948285013,
-0.0228540264,
0.0385437757,
-0.0630126297,
0.0162168965,
0.0235728733,
-0.0407294929,
0.0060927579,
0.0047760806,
-0.0192617439,
-0.0052779438,
0.0197005272,
-0.0243740864,
-0.0096056862,
-0.0095921755,
0.0177585501,
0.0450019687,
-0.021167526,
-0.0069119898,
-0.0099621499,
0.0091272946,
-0.006717422,
0.0034799778,
0.0155954547,
-0.0017978945,
0.0341719724,
0.0454461724,
0.0261830688,
0.0402791761,
-0.0151448967,
-0.0133852242,
0.0348533317,
-0.0349778682,
-0.0533458851,
-0.0136007629,
0.0530014262,
-0.0470119007,
-0.0206658822,
0.1097846627,
0.0465388857,
-0.0138134845,
-0.0372347273,
-0.0255902577,
-0.0195486005,
0.018776916,
0.0320041962,
-0.0248893108,
-0.0007911095,
0.0532715283,
0.0163268317,
-0.0258991495,
-0.001033943,
0.0204819459,
-0.1162587702,
0.048357144,
0.0355380364,
0.020535212,
-0.0501709878,
-0.0222817678,
0.037142653,
-0.0063534249,
-0.019576937,
0.0622155629,
0.0078194337,
0.0049784351,
-0.0041646259,
-0.0746914223,
-0.063450478,
-0.0406773202,
-0.0572153106,
0.0323868282,
0.0819884315,
0.0419312082,
0.0077946419,
-0.0484600216,
0.0444554426,
-0.0399343222,
-0.0215454698,
-0.006201088,
0.0284205023,
0.0051631136,
0.0205378979,
-0.0320677198,
0.0025887308,
0.0392444432,
-0.0113589074,
-0.0188827571,
0.0577451065,
0.0038425298,
0.0394715145,
0.0160148498,
-0.0080936728,
0.0020208815,
0.0102231428,
0.0408731624,
-0.0429464839,
-0.0149782076,
-0.0597022809,
-0.0127125112,
-0.0302142389,
0.0418437533,
0.0300735086,
-0.0432575941,
-0.0339573435,
-0.104902938,
-0.0413997211,
0.0060193152,
-0.002646358,
0.016799571,
-0.0224351585,
-0.0114323813,
0.0050445851,
0.0496841334,
-0.0594706461,
0.0076188436,
0.0378263704,
-0.0844543278,
0.0425289236,
-0.0062205889,
0.0704301447,
-0.0201573875,
-0.0182349533,
0.0184261706,
-0.0543269143,
0.0439020135,
0.052288115,
0.0099045951,
-0.0198848639,
-0.0264630001,
-0.0747214481,
-0.0232343189,
0.0149754034,
0.010954814,
0.039690543,
0.0366783552,
-0.0387370177,
-0.019472165,
0.0237330869,
-0.023614563,
-0.0014783005,
0.0156479552,
0.069762826,
-0.0013557801,
-0.0266905576,
0.0476288423,
0.0465535372,
0.0462633446,
-0.016515905,
-0.0253410507,
-0.050524924,
0.0215631649,
-0.0358646624,
-0.0279492047,
-0.0064379163,
0.0372799002,
-0.0040285503,
-0.011075817,
-0.0415092334,
0.0284099057,
-0.0405213535,
0.0207970347,
-0.0106367301,
0.0048121195,
0.0345076621,
0.0088238921,
0.0021509847,
-0.0000229699,
-0.009953103,
-0.0219231136,
0.0452707857,
0.015551988,
0.000271388,
0.0092922505,
0.000288115,
-0.0070143575,
0.0061545768,
0.0401220731,
-0.0543007255,
0.0638293177,
-0.0461523347,
0.02029364,
0.1136682332,
0.0109454356,
0.1182108968,
-0.0014834477,
-0.0338157378,
-0.0537572391,
0.0487418249,
0.0254448503,
0.0091828136,
-0.0284727067,
-0.0017349563,
0.0030022771,
-0.0197429396,
0.0053376774,
-0.077285789,
0.0212804042,
-0.0573134497,
-0.0428307168,
-0.0040307455,
0.0152795333,
-0.0457510166,
-0.0278947204,
-0.0094261831,
-0.0263210647,
-0.0462930016,
-0.0309648328,
0.0220613759,
0.0705463588,
0.0319148377,
-0.0080796871,
-0.0279100034,
0.0319245905,
-0.0141193829,
-0.0127749005,
-0.0454791971,
-0.0603715628,
0.0004171547,
-0.005562475,
-0.034136042,
-5.470589813e-33,
-0.0500926599,
0.0086040068,
-0.0579928048,
-0.0204797368,
0.0040233624,
0.003361667,
-0.0216640197,
0.0112752942,
0.0589431673,
0.0532856658,
-0.0382698402,
0.0265878197,
0.013843854,
-0.0203365032,
0.052417513,
0.0480408445,
0.0852598548,
0.0226871837,
-0.0261211637,
-0.0474133939,
0.02788564,
0.0290357023,
0.0868306533,
-0.0256574303,
0.0575039797,
0.0473081432,
-0.0319390856,
0.01700137,
-0.0107974149,
0.0535990149,
0.0841438621,
0.0519119427,
0.018268723,
-0.0063565145,
-0.0353728905,
-0.0186316781,
-0.0255392287,
-0.0101976348,
0.0117112622,
0.0273890868,
0.0165163651,
-0.0259549282,
0.0266909692,
-0.0087346053,
-0.0548434891,
-0.0027998637,
0.0280314349,
-0.0452786125,
0.0328545533,
0.0058046281,
-0.0039244802,
0.0319709294,
0.0225647017,
0.0045179473,
-0.0394388214,
0.0470086411,
0.0022629781,
-0.0336195119,
-0.0494966283,
0.0094773769,
0.0319486223,
0.0589028075,
0.0056717028,
-0.0587231293,
-0.0368417352,
0.011285292,
-0.0260880701,
-0.0078118052,
0.005162715,
-0.0020868434,
0.0000387083,
0.0186981298,
0.0764763281,
0.089719899,
0.0000956287,
-0.0352683254,
-0.0229135659,
0.0387430079,
-0.0383637175,
0.0734800175,
-0.0353040583,
0.0167685319,
-0.0399778038,
-0.0300166234,
-0.0491550863,
-0.0060567604,
0.004235636,
-0.0090871714,
0.0361787789,
0.0051669334,
-0.0202117153,
-0.024413541,
0.0011046075,
-0.0139642684,
-0.018136831,
-0.0188099332,
-0.0171006508,
0.0414483622,
-0.0179388262,
0.006477721,
0.0001318901,
0.03818826,
0.0187901612,
0.0458334424,
0.0029769528,
-0.0368400849,
0.0546705164,
0.0214849412,
-0.0901029482,
0.0388356261,
0.0234806687,
-0.0058978233,
-0.0243405662,
-0.047208,
0.0052347863,
-0.0150211453,
0.0132753197,
-0.0032729935,
0.0121798888,
0.0436725616,
-0.0322173759,
-0.0215811729,
-0.0003928957,
0.0170276612,
0.0055219783,
0.0098132929,
-0.0159254093,
0.0047948891,
0.0307875723,
0.0092558945,
-0.0136629809,
-0.0220339969,
2.588e-7,
0.0193493012,
0.0695947856,
0.0056684301,
-0.0148294996,
-0.0045690588,
0.0237776134,
-0.0153396502,
0.0003396068,
0.0485075116,
0.0561705381,
0.0095130512,
-0.0341673456,
0.0465583839,
0.0176046677,
-0.0310759768,
-0.0243003741,
-0.0563592613,
0.0154282115,
-0.0172740202,
-0.0254513919,
0.0446062349,
0.0061169192,
0.0387539454,
0.011706328,
-0.0314991325,
-0.0404743738,
0.033277452,
0.0043798615,
-0.0602502748,
0.0369292237,
0.1093517095,
0.0000600754,
0.0526432618,
0.0218351185,
-0.0488599725,
-0.0009832783,
0.0262849703,
0.0229344666,
-0.0447567552,
0.0643604994,
0.0170653239,
0.0267270394,
0.0012022428,
-0.0161706656,
0.0255305972,
0.0113858329,
0.0356341414,
-0.0259653218,
-0.0494767316,
-0.0078412471,
0.0302108768,
-0.0171002559,
-0.0483805463,
0.0043922914,
0.023352826,
0.0583299063,
-0.0022966105,
-0.0271014366,
-0.0255508851,
0.0356465317,
0.0533758588,
-0.0447838306,
0.0286372323,
-0.0159766097,
-0.0003131803,
-0.0623826012,
0.0072920397,
1.879208751e-34,
0.05012431,
-0.010038198,
0.0675505251,
0.0173947364,
0.0395302847,
-0.0050126775,
-0.0105272345,
-0.0254737809,
-0.0140508898,
-0.0322137289,
-0.0215013959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14928v1 | Unveiling A Core Linguistic Region in Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T13:31:32 | 2023-10-23T13:31:32 | Jun Zhao, Zhihao Zhang, Yide Ma, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Luhui Gao, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Brain localization, which describes the association between specific regions
of the brain and their corresponding functions, is widely accepted in the field
of cognitive science as an objective fact. Today's large language models (LLMs)
possess human-level linguistic competence and can execute complex tasks
requiring abstract knowledge and reasoning. To deeply understand the inherent
mechanisms of intelligence emergence in LLMs, this paper conducts an analogical
research using brain localization as a prototype. We have discovered a core
region in LLMs that corresponds to linguistic competence, accounting for
approximately 1% of the total model parameters. This core region exhibits
significant dimension dependency, and perturbations to even a single parameter
on specific dimensions can lead to a loss of linguistic competence.
Furthermore, we observe that an improvement in linguistic competence does not
necessarily accompany an elevation in the model's knowledge level, which might
imply the existence of regions of domain knowledge that are dissociated from
the linguistic region. Overall, exploring the LLMs' functional regions provides
insights into the foundation of their intelligence. In the future, we will
continue to investigate knowledge regions within LLMs and the interactions
between them. | [
0.0242105052,
0.0333896764,
-0.0633195639,
0.0207302403,
-0.0215641577,
0.0378297865,
0.014488684,
0.0064812228,
0.0089027118,
0.0076245419,
-0.0440311655,
-0.0134007717,
0.0067536328,
0.0140591729,
0.0742429942,
-0.0201811697,
0.0321748704,
-0.0543733947,
0.0148589602,
-0.0408062115,
-0.0384566337,
-0.021982763,
-0.0029469391,
0.01551235,
0.0131699741,
-0.0143104373,
0.0153218592,
-0.04790112,
-0.0170310177,
0.008028239,
-0.050204169,
0.0327817537,
0.0265041403,
0.0163389798,
0.0000019778,
-0.0711923987,
0.0513273403,
-0.0082511771,
-0.0196127668,
0.0142500922,
0.0084899878,
0.0023541504,
-0.0061152624,
-0.0045760656,
-0.0201752689,
0.0057579852,
0.0092893532,
0.0298338737,
-0.0070578656,
0.0432649143,
-0.0085984822,
-0.0084753921,
0.0440771841,
-0.0305042528,
0.0172063857,
-0.0271832105,
0.0284288265,
0.0384327285,
0.0018527082,
-0.0071003339,
-0.0418888181,
0.0275420751,
0.0329133272,
-0.0005817247,
-0.04277936,
0.0305063613,
0.0205760468,
0.0029546102,
0.0354168899,
0.0031924797,
0.0085316328,
-0.0343307368,
-0.0080742799,
0.0345859304,
0.0369820185,
0.01194371,
-0.0794518366,
0.0270748623,
0.0531233847,
0.0290866587,
0.0500147752,
-0.0186661314,
0.0449746512,
0.0080399327,
-0.0213142596,
0.0999102443,
0.0128162215,
-0.0318059437,
-0.0230396409,
0.0017794829,
-0.0460885614,
-0.0169007108,
-0.0079205809,
0.0230169948,
0.011211169,
0.0169866793,
-0.000744479,
0.0147667788,
-0.0156753026,
-0.0394677967,
0.037945509,
0.0296749752,
0.022027785,
0.047883302,
-0.0421661474,
0.0733760595,
-0.0452074185,
0.0645925999,
-0.0329643711,
-0.0317269005,
-0.0379254483,
-0.0603991151,
-0.0037205615,
0.0063440446,
0.003867585,
-0.0280649476,
-0.020380402,
0.0076848273,
-0.0202030111,
-0.055317115,
-0.0149477879,
0.0349341184,
0.0002393809,
-0.0185321439,
-0.0539584868,
0.0030195101,
-0.0327315144,
0.0470751971,
-0.0224962123,
-0.003857265,
-0.0165215153,
0.0276187323,
-0.0267716944,
-0.0246250704,
0.0005075507,
0.0558506101,
0.016150577,
-0.0143538257,
-0.0346348286,
0.0078752209,
-0.0039203702,
-0.0395351835,
0.0361553878,
-0.0432550162,
-0.0019726197,
0.0334672332,
-0.03644339,
-0.0809031203,
-0.0248811487,
-0.008588315,
-0.0723549724,
0.0106972037,
-0.0097383354,
0.0485789403,
0.0523964129,
-0.0112661188,
-0.0042656595,
0.0311045237,
0.0432036333,
-0.0388225093,
-0.0216515828,
0.0025071693,
-0.0416530035,
0.0298038647,
0.009174116,
-0.0004423762,
-0.0544893742,
-0.0324001834,
-0.0054041338,
0.0321326405,
0.0665509254,
0.0245907232,
-0.0173865296,
-0.0105946613,
0.0585602932,
0.0944276527,
-0.0034929935,
0.0399540924,
0.0305404011,
-0.0037362915,
0.0208871178,
-0.0036783365,
-0.0767175108,
0.0368121006,
-0.0323599428,
-0.0102773216,
-0.0216758829,
0.0202127416,
-0.0303585753,
0.0094898278,
-0.0023188093,
0.026350446,
-0.0058619347,
0.0130672147,
0.0488004573,
0.0098018842,
0.0341487229,
0.0457018726,
0.0249116253,
-0.0039605596,
0.0114340764,
-0.0535946973,
0.0105498768,
-0.0012522867,
-0.0107865417,
-0.0028861573,
-0.0120981317,
0.0294367429,
0.0266559646,
0.0726807863,
0.0259583071,
0.007462441,
-0.0176726766,
-0.0005820167,
0.0124680251,
-0.0200841613,
0.0055492125,
-0.0161120053,
-0.0304010585,
-0.0116574075,
-0.0285571031,
-0.0341350585,
-0.0051148338,
0.0239912551,
-0.0834812969,
0.0227175038,
-0.0371237919,
-0.0176522899,
0.0305551682,
-0.0251263659,
-0.0182125326,
0.03518885,
0.0044587539,
-0.0475588404,
-0.0197413806,
0.0500662513,
-0.0142749576,
0.0311373938,
0.0605147593,
0.0148703502,
0.0029957409,
0.0054142652,
0.0474651977,
-0.0288424324,
0.0976198316,
-0.0450038537,
0.0648696944,
-0.0101291901,
0.0455285646,
-0.0663177893,
0.019488005,
-0.0398277901,
0.1027419195,
-0.0135836024,
0.0164440218,
0.0237369705,
-0.0176941641,
0.0249445383,
-0.0355705097,
-0.0018881269,
-0.0318705961,
-0.0213426128,
-0.0064885276,
-0.0211581234,
-0.0246319529,
-0.0034412893,
-0.0110590374,
-0.0478558429,
-0.003714181,
0.0366876349,
0.0081912205,
0.0390112773,
-0.0355309024,
-0.0230640713,
0.0079740649,
-0.0045080818,
0.0042388602,
0.0404893979,
0.010489312,
0.0249716993,
-0.0230659042,
-0.0363869444,
-0.0122866165,
0.000772151,
-0.0518964715,
0.0470143594,
0.0005065674,
0.0075750644,
-0.0587941445,
0.056059923,
-0.0268544853,
0.0342835337,
-0.0109320367,
-0.0204542764,
0.043866612,
0.0072043627,
0.0213378761,
0.0783605948,
-0.017007824,
0.0538659431,
0.0604086518,
-0.0176820811,
-0.0304713193,
-0.0113901123,
-0.0277788769,
0.0450167544,
-0.0846062228,
-0.0330111831,
-0.0318297595,
0.1200690642,
0.0429320522,
-0.0231700148,
-0.0092263781,
0.0787753761,
-0.03272181,
-0.03448686,
-0.0109363096,
0.0063057845,
-0.0350282416,
0.0720635355,
-0.0543556474,
-0.0399961546,
0.0161340795,
-0.0087969024,
0.0344763324,
-0.0101822177,
-0.0036203726,
-0.0095173968,
0.0656952262,
0.0148256971,
0.016864812,
-0.0293136518,
-0.0291695278,
-0.0647800788,
0.0028451846,
-0.021276651,
-0.0002923879,
0.0012039414,
-0.0572374798,
-0.0188458171,
0.0184086598,
0.0023100392,
-0.0099081304,
0.056647066,
-0.0233520158,
0.0471449718,
0.0449427031,
-0.0353895873,
-0.0642857924,
-0.0321410857,
0.0637649894,
0.0185240377,
-0.0206478629,
0.008517514,
-0.0062421644,
-0.0073877345,
0.0614043139,
0.050465256,
0.0343315303,
-0.050188411,
0.0194433481,
0.0283953995,
-0.0312849246,
0.0518939123,
-0.0253739469,
0.032324329,
0.0339668728,
-0.0234399326,
-0.0300858989,
-0.0038672944,
0.0301313344,
-0.0097810123,
-0.0348912589,
0.1077420563,
0.0344609618,
-0.0201602466,
0.0259724427,
-0.039596051,
-0.0239457767,
0.0813918933,
0.0292898025,
-0.0027899253,
0.0237396844,
-0.0003905262,
-0.0540359505,
-0.021090433,
-0.0425468646,
-0.0000518094,
-0.0678862706,
0.0150623089,
-0.0143268751,
-0.0751522183,
-0.0423256904,
0.0185843408,
0.0151702585,
0.0335486755,
0.0280176494,
0.004282597,
0.015655838,
-0.0117047736,
0.0034229478,
-0.0136752687,
-0.0581696294,
0.0226612166,
-0.0206223447,
0.1017722413,
0.0247364007,
0.0287769325,
-0.034587469,
0.0092777936,
-0.0044736923,
0.0340457186,
0.019295536,
0.0135209551,
0.0220575389,
0.0599793345,
0.0002395367,
-0.0570958406,
0.015272757,
-0.0126553839,
-0.0391054526,
-0.0239696074,
0.096715048,
-0.028477896,
-0.0298186783,
-0.0011749454,
0.0162369721,
-0.0660447776,
0.0606507435,
0.0564096272,
-0.0696206838,
-0.018509822,
-0.020837158,
-0.0216668155,
-0.0019807159,
-0.0902137309,
0.0357757658,
0.0459986553,
0.0068788207,
-0.0492182411,
0.0403812267,
0.0415829718,
0.0097815301,
0.0337290168,
-0.0062168031,
0.0189335421,
-0.0917680264,
-0.0116834296,
0.0188434739,
-0.0359923765,
-0.028423069,
-0.0500342473,
-0.026766846,
0.0301483963,
-0.0821619034,
-0.0305040963,
0.0129878428,
-0.0292617362,
-0.0766158924,
0.0239130761,
-0.0003773949,
0.031754747,
0.0008185676,
0.0026744988,
-0.0868534967,
0.0541130044,
-0.0377959311,
-0.0176627059,
0.0637223944,
-0.0596842989,
-0.002003402,
0.023581557,
0.0407794788,
-0.0164820254,
0.0257466454,
0.0325667337,
0.0261826422,
-0.0254078154,
-0.0088962978,
0.0048435414,
0.0057237716,
0.0475269295,
0.023435574,
-0.0103208395,
-0.0386363864,
-0.0273641516,
-0.0295822918,
-0.0046398938,
-0.0232098605,
-0.0362124443,
0.0795627683,
0.0450118221,
0.0195109751,
-0.0449589677,
0.0307468455,
0.0121577708,
0.0332357958,
-0.022139756,
-0.0420032591,
0.0153118102,
0.0015423499,
0.0609875619,
0.0359548628,
0.0390652083,
-0.0725294575,
0.0337376148,
0.0117859934,
0.0558856353,
-0.0127999382,
-0.0101736346,
-0.0605391636,
-0.0130288862,
-0.0641138554,
-0.0779814199,
0.04298063,
0.0230739452,
0.0329857022,
-0.012977819,
0.063972421,
-0.0372160189,
-0.0075182393,
-0.0008511957,
-0.0113478312,
-0.0026448285,
-0.061335437,
0.0406663083,
0.0301077031,
-0.0109242164,
0.0057745818,
0.0463979803,
0.0084241051,
0.0393032469,
-0.0511050746,
-0.0240144208,
0.0053704316,
-0.0323012173,
0.0407705344,
0.0063111028,
-0.0513475053,
0.0450212359,
-0.0569144227,
-0.0779120699,
-0.0081657777,
0.0201900285,
-0.0198753607,
-0.0287953969,
0.0057775518,
0.0275872275,
-0.0292140525,
-0.0361711383,
-0.0101940641,
-0.0085445903,
-0.0253760908,
-0.0345674269,
-0.0186760016,
-6.028319638e-33,
-0.0237590689,
-0.0315795206,
0.0185619593,
0.0164264534,
0.0093373219,
-0.0284555294,
-0.0401263274,
0.0450692102,
-0.0465052761,
0.0251663662,
0.009242815,
0.0008114899,
-0.0075874017,
0.0154461339,
0.0102185933,
0.0361980125,
-0.0335710123,
-0.0236470625,
0.0096868044,
-0.0001883825,
0.0452691913,
-0.0028179954,
0.0763148665,
-0.0813905373,
0.0048386282,
0.0145617221,
0.0205787662,
0.0473420247,
-0.0535205454,
0.0387288257,
-0.0490745232,
0.0470629409,
0.0400446914,
-0.048728276,
-0.017688809,
-0.0387142822,
-0.0250685401,
-0.0329948328,
0.0597714707,
-0.0117254909,
-0.0103693139,
-0.0536941998,
0.0611047558,
-0.0135530615,
-0.0127619887,
-0.0191678908,
0.0556184053,
-0.0278044194,
-0.0024174224,
0.0352000743,
-0.1111214012,
-0.0280310512,
-0.0238997415,
0.0004161011,
-0.0191970207,
-0.0393128172,
-0.0388593823,
-0.0297098663,
-0.0336990207,
0.0099862712,
0.0059053586,
0.0302321333,
0.046521835,
-0.0083241314,
0.0519439764,
0.0727344677,
0.0722475052,
0.0231489688,
0.0113367764,
-0.0049306201,
0.0925901011,
0.0363156833,
0.0237393863,
0.0070018228,
-0.0188455954,
-0.02346218,
-0.0378330275,
-0.0429512449,
0.0390753262,
0.0329529569,
0.0460614637,
-0.0321424045,
0.0231918246,
-0.0143079534,
-0.0275295153,
-0.0234121699,
-0.0307496656,
-0.0363565162,
0.023968704,
-0.0386913978,
0.0147980396,
-0.0426159129,
0.0197233576,
-0.0494860709,
0.0209439639,
-0.0011527851,
-0.0021380293,
0.0468616672,
0.0211502369,
0.0057766717,
-0.0408059098,
-0.0482441299,
-0.0469335243,
-0.0021630127,
0.0302350968,
0.0331564099,
0.006443019,
0.0246877093,
-0.0082456963,
-0.0012347328,
-0.0173121355,
-0.039438121,
0.0410127379,
0.0154974386,
-0.0093060238,
-0.0216352902,
-0.0155453123,
-0.0415256731,
0.014600141,
0.0001197668,
-0.0188616104,
0.0124909459,
-0.0286245197,
0.0228487514,
-0.0334257819,
-0.0082167601,
-0.0457325131,
0.0182608385,
0.0320797563,
-0.0579926483,
-0.0224890225,
0.006606325,
2.831e-7,
0.0714188591,
0.0722604245,
-0.0039071208,
0.0238343365,
0.0550962985,
-0.0118691539,
-0.0166420694,
-0.0232756268,
0.0442775004,
0.0140905296,
-0.0301431585,
0.0433829986,
0.0150687518,
-0.0020870946,
-0.0876251981,
0.0239013154,
-0.0284945238,
0.0151109053,
-0.0120686358,
-0.0005445015,
-0.0237653088,
0.0393991657,
0.0109511809,
-0.0232317541,
-0.0096361907,
-0.0708821267,
0.071014449,
-0.0358078554,
0.0265624858,
0.022785943,
-0.0130249457,
-0.0083335992,
0.0082395608,
0.0342230126,
0.0461647585,
0.0677712783,
-0.0134847993,
0.0334987342,
0.0049299472,
0.0468551368,
-0.0070526833,
-0.0167019572,
0.0022703784,
-0.0613318011,
0.0498550199,
-0.1001596898,
-0.0966169983,
-0.0123370383,
0.0169169195,
-0.0035229789,
0.0137677137,
0.0006405899,
0.0063069412,
-0.0206636693,
0.0232645608,
-0.0064623277,
-0.0000854522,
-0.0420951098,
-0.029089408,
0.0311665013,
-0.07278198,
-0.0353007913,
-0.0337361023,
-0.008250759,
0.0537800714,
-0.0380537771,
0.0228932649,
2.539255831e-34,
-0.0206419732,
0.02030956,
0.0505465306,
-0.0010501973,
0.0351524428,
-0.0116701378,
0.0053730379,
0.0114509491,
0.0156646948,
-0.0764418319,
-0.0164799523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14921v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14921v2 | PartialFormer: Modeling Part Instead of Whole for Machine Translation | 2023-10-23T13:25:54 | 2024-06-05T17:12:04 | Tong Zheng, Bei Li, Huiwen Bao, Jiale Wang, Weiqiao Shan, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The design choices in Transformer feed-forward neural networks have resulted
in significant computational and parameter overhead. In this work, we emphasize
the importance of hidden dimensions in designing lightweight FFNs, a factor
often overlooked in previous architectures. Guided by this principle, we
introduce PartialFormer, a parameter-efficient Transformer architecture
utilizing multiple smaller FFNs to reduce parameters and computation while
maintaining essential hidden dimensions. These smaller FFNs are integrated into
a multi-head attention mechanism for effective collaboration. We also propose a
tailored head scaling strategy to enhance PartialFormer's capabilities.
Furthermore, we present a residual-like attention calculation to improve depth
scaling within PartialFormer. Extensive experiments on 9 translation tasks and
1 abstractive summarization task validate the effectiveness of our
PartialFormer approach on machine translation and summarization tasks. Our code
would be available at: https://github.com/zhengkid/PartialFormer. | [
0.0185250267,
0.0285617281,
0.0075174537,
0.0392625481,
-0.0038542564,
-0.0144524062,
0.0860014632,
-0.0234667808,
-0.0491754897,
0.0179202873,
-0.0609072708,
-0.0796215683,
0.0551460981,
0.0219219197,
0.0191015396,
-0.0530962721,
0.0032059427,
0.0148005486,
-0.0605398752,
-0.0050289691,
-0.0155135673,
0.0059661018,
0.0270568375,
0.0326025225,
-0.0344582237,
0.0093717864,
-0.0408653207,
0.0112112723,
0.0489765257,
0.0360377766,
0.0052409736,
0.0226726998,
0.0085330158,
0.0730004013,
0.0000023163,
0.0323131345,
0.0033957125,
0.008908065,
0.0173832662,
0.0240434948,
0.0202145297,
-0.0455248095,
-0.0221511424,
0.002874362,
0.0046137376,
-0.0575440191,
0.0507110134,
0.0600141473,
0.0464964882,
0.0549696311,
-0.0136196548,
-0.0579369217,
0.029336663,
-0.0611760467,
0.0002126237,
-0.0195957627,
-0.0313969404,
-0.0429049842,
-0.0687099919,
0.0070952792,
-0.0147853559,
0.0676249862,
0.046362821,
-0.0035599729,
0.00161929,
0.0027584755,
-0.0552009493,
-0.0568372011,
0.014261106,
0.0618330762,
-0.0307008699,
0.0044652009,
-0.0101182219,
-0.0328570977,
-0.0041261879,
-0.0115069887,
-0.0660660788,
0.0319278874,
0.0217915531,
-0.0349532329,
-0.0112365037,
0.0593538098,
0.0369600728,
-0.0141838901,
-0.0423001498,
-0.0109149441,
-0.0088236341,
0.0022081656,
-0.0356695242,
-0.0034973011,
-0.0157751907,
-0.020247085,
0.0508178286,
0.0355275236,
0.0127607854,
-0.0016340626,
-0.0361427255,
-0.0969445258,
-0.0018077181,
-0.0914751589,
0.0241769347,
0.0447187722,
-0.0153531972,
0.0182054117,
-0.0432839356,
0.042710539,
-0.0305670407,
-0.0098408591,
-0.0382956713,
-0.0152994068,
0.019151995,
0.0203357171,
-0.0705187693,
0.017510308,
-0.0674654022,
-0.0563134961,
-0.0013729349,
-0.0008538794,
0.0007368558,
0.0051692165,
0.0486181378,
0.0230552852,
-0.0673452914,
-0.0100470837,
0.0516504049,
0.0890332535,
-0.0319736265,
-0.0387596004,
0.0416368209,
-0.0468629897,
-0.0581690222,
0.0108684311,
0.0204550903,
-0.0260111727,
-0.020410683,
0.0581521131,
-0.0002255308,
-0.0451020934,
0.0125195291,
0.0053992616,
-0.0290522631,
-0.045965191,
0.0238904767,
-0.0435528941,
0.0682344809,
-0.009176434,
0.0136385625,
-0.017620692,
0.0132030454,
0.0395533741,
0.0099238176,
0.019928962,
0.0120838415,
-0.0293815061,
0.0319404155,
-0.0006936485,
-0.0111486837,
0.0585418083,
0.0516862199,
0.0891345218,
-0.0079282084,
-0.026584303,
-0.0619558617,
0.0180172864,
0.0227469802,
-0.0097588282,
-0.0139124393,
-0.0356322713,
-0.0121392524,
0.0372181609,
0.0120114144,
0.0397600494,
-0.0079691904,
-0.0088524073,
0.0783891529,
0.0275393687,
0.0504536964,
0.0893982127,
0.0552213378,
0.0462665185,
-0.0137583194,
0.0044497396,
-0.014260903,
0.0914656147,
0.0153158735,
-0.0117176045,
0.0450308807,
0.0472641625,
-0.0457395799,
-0.0190570336,
0.0090362346,
0.0023298999,
0.0056063286,
0.0043647443,
0.0117331771,
0.048499871,
-0.0466497988,
0.0792269185,
-0.0235076677,
-0.0743854716,
-0.015255956,
0.0038458956,
-0.033317022,
0.0046286397,
0.021137692,
-0.0221238788,
-0.0454583839,
-0.0034775855,
0.025357496,
0.0309798103,
0.098058261,
0.0436094441,
0.0399168953,
-0.0498969182,
-0.0011957294,
0.0142115625,
-0.008269906,
0.0182882063,
0.0024546136,
-0.0079389215,
0.0337466896,
-0.0006659385,
-0.0336776003,
0.0221359208,
-0.0107943993,
-0.0033540556,
0.0467249714,
0.0271341242,
0.0082109543,
0.0298836678,
0.0108721387,
0.014676366,
0.0216892734,
-0.030525174,
-0.0052830959,
0.0232540853,
-0.0358225256,
-0.0132925464,
-0.0124020167,
-0.0051349192,
0.0143912537,
0.0510138087,
-0.0286550242,
-0.0605990887,
0.0537236333,
-0.0594909713,
0.0131231844,
-0.0109444642,
0.0163627006,
0.009762791,
0.0419345237,
-0.0013918226,
-0.0087982323,
-0.0165832713,
0.0130043598,
-0.0194109324,
-0.0326432027,
-0.01058356,
-0.0518104322,
-0.0147998659,
-0.0013114448,
0.0073188092,
-0.0047061136,
0.0057925922,
-0.0134925479,
0.0107341791,
-0.047731854,
-0.0151030505,
0.0143749435,
-0.0236534793,
0.0172215272,
0.0299167261,
0.0744095668,
0.0406440608,
0.0205014478,
-0.0374749415,
0.0490298532,
-0.0203591809,
-0.0204005912,
-0.0029862591,
0.0117218038,
-0.0049430043,
-0.0186515152,
-0.0425810367,
0.0309125409,
0.0680515021,
0.0180500168,
-0.0239834357,
-0.034191411,
-0.0327585004,
0.0048064752,
0.0071242359,
0.0118494965,
-0.0368639827,
-0.0180542041,
-0.019188622,
-0.0162182339,
0.0458321236,
-0.0061301114,
0.0021525456,
0.0221026149,
0.0123461904,
-0.0414320305,
0.0408475548,
-0.0276971366,
0.0353677943,
0.0122471154,
0.0028398149,
-0.0024554892,
0.0509926677,
-0.0082297893,
-0.0068550636,
-0.0686125383,
0.0061921114,
0.0323786288,
-0.0172448009,
0.0247181989,
-0.0084458813,
0.0095854802,
0.0121102603,
-0.0317336544,
-0.0251496676,
0.0383717008,
-0.0500195548,
-0.0214796532,
-0.0150723625,
0.0022451263,
-0.040502917,
0.0335234255,
0.0038317032,
0.0339922719,
-0.0247107111,
-0.0477472357,
-0.0295745861,
0.0652248487,
-0.0017967303,
0.0032163742,
0.0810050741,
-0.0105595915,
-0.020283876,
-0.0471965,
-0.0066527212,
-0.010011673,
0.0060586063,
-0.0137126865,
0.0479787737,
0.0284230839,
-0.0438446403,
-0.1047228202,
0.0206800047,
0.0542112067,
0.0828165486,
-0.0248767156,
-0.0110544655,
-0.0016431422,
0.0101363221,
-0.0357882939,
0.0496042632,
0.0763135254,
-0.0637580752,
0.0338773727,
0.0428410918,
-0.0035579985,
-0.023698302,
-0.0402339883,
-0.0599728748,
0.0245972592,
-0.0191815868,
-0.0079281535,
-0.0141827548,
0.0995171741,
-0.0866185054,
0.0079029007,
0.0745335817,
-0.0039192517,
-0.0410916805,
0.0139954621,
0.0203630626,
0.0220315326,
0.0135175027,
0.0334878415,
-0.0257974528,
-0.0156989284,
0.0108400946,
0.0368372165,
0.0474038348,
0.0006388777,
-0.0116357747,
-0.037530344,
0.0454440787,
0.0367686823,
-0.0727199093,
-0.0487959981,
-0.0014533995,
-0.0036234276,
-0.0168188959,
-0.0037127642,
-0.0233630966,
-0.0017538229,
-0.0524862409,
-0.0193716399,
-0.0006307623,
0.0153382691,
-0.0218833964,
-0.0115946643,
-0.0125208069,
0.0163304545,
0.0024912809,
-0.0113550937,
-0.0674776137,
0.017211169,
-0.0188852269,
0.0397745408,
-0.0049805166,
0.0473339036,
-0.0002208188,
-0.0205597989,
0.0133009488,
-0.0169716682,
-0.0340595916,
0.0100969849,
-0.0359448679,
0.040308997,
-0.0166581683,
-0.0161836818,
0.0068762708,
0.0352249853,
-0.0259383079,
0.0356777683,
0.0678124651,
-0.0398299508,
-0.0012425195,
-0.0077864653,
-0.0151967211,
-0.0886717066,
-0.0318478346,
-0.024762217,
0.0227447692,
-0.0843181387,
-0.0355660208,
-0.0331857875,
0.0282878727,
0.0343866982,
-0.0095803896,
-0.0724865794,
0.036247693,
-0.0014023957,
-0.0422323048,
0.0343776569,
0.011720595,
0.0083704134,
-0.0297507923,
0.0167842507,
0.0254376587,
-0.043758329,
0.0186539292,
0.0414675586,
-0.1249500066,
-0.0345367193,
-0.0024557887,
0.0598731339,
0.0073155072,
0.0054960917,
-0.0090911891,
-0.0316008367,
-0.0151289105,
0.0082514528,
-0.0158419963,
0.0419958644,
0.0503066778,
-0.0409031771,
-0.0224368684,
0.0345541015,
-0.0155560533,
0.0109057035,
0.0413763821,
0.0637792498,
0.0049429554,
-0.0313483849,
-0.0120838219,
-0.0131968213,
0.0313769914,
-0.0006565977,
0.0349020101,
-0.0157425366,
0.0309951771,
-0.006797221,
0.0304085035,
-0.0639303848,
-0.0202301107,
0.0124774463,
0.021278359,
0.0242677312,
0.0399763696,
0.0252495352,
-0.0417169705,
-0.0336234048,
0.0551084988,
-0.0751553252,
-0.0179443173,
-0.0285112057,
0.0268334188,
-0.0498584323,
-0.0133951437,
0.0146546261,
-0.0066204676,
-0.0089174854,
0.0314360745,
0.0027024881,
0.0480474196,
-0.0590430275,
0.0411835611,
-0.0783005729,
-0.0384319872,
-0.0522027649,
-0.0086681759,
0.0155349262,
-0.0109186796,
0.0468132868,
0.0267304834,
-0.006347036,
-0.0256639943,
0.0332877003,
-0.0128368381,
-0.0403825417,
0.0076323096,
0.0159573033,
0.0222661197,
-0.0199098196,
0.0568072572,
-0.0612750426,
-0.0101788137,
0.0019327777,
0.0224828925,
-0.0231605656,
-0.0441904776,
-0.0049459143,
0.0178909861,
-0.0055090138,
-0.0053096199,
-0.0416687392,
-0.0477044284,
0.0052859513,
-0.0229766034,
0.0181523412,
-0.0332368352,
0.0411287807,
-0.0032630672,
0.0107724052,
-0.015623698,
0.0063631441,
-0.0017305767,
0.0247393586,
-0.029290216,
-0.0201500319,
-6.474921901e-33,
-0.0355692208,
0.0176301282,
-0.0143283429,
0.0182682946,
-0.0477868542,
0.0350036323,
-0.0517411679,
-0.0003652498,
-0.029294936,
0.0096412217,
-0.0209308676,
0.0155309504,
0.0171556585,
0.0269605853,
0.0158947613,
0.0066253566,
0.0731841177,
-0.0092199408,
0.0058775987,
0.0321345553,
0.0284310468,
0.025608791,
0.0517889708,
-0.0250890646,
-0.0337567516,
0.0046837437,
-0.0044867778,
-0.004905012,
-0.0027127783,
-0.0008505935,
0.0084658796,
0.0021457928,
0.0099854516,
-0.0775353909,
-0.0640993044,
0.0089718634,
-0.0698677599,
-0.0117656989,
-0.0180659946,
0.0328670293,
-0.0291677099,
-0.0275497492,
0.0741846412,
-0.0003069043,
0.0329443589,
-0.0910144225,
0.0012582059,
-0.0096931159,
-0.0570441596,
-0.0546266511,
-0.0361010991,
0.0125549575,
-0.0102201095,
-0.0076669888,
0.0444412939,
0.0516200028,
-0.0348234996,
-0.0205676034,
-0.0843864232,
-0.0032084831,
0.0072579766,
0.0358100347,
0.0392621532,
0.0346257612,
-0.0019990804,
0.0125875203,
0.0579370968,
0.0087335268,
-0.0645961761,
0.0362568498,
0.0246870331,
0.0064524459,
0.0726034492,
0.0030536484,
0.0581335239,
-0.0071621281,
-0.0421042182,
0.0158837456,
-0.0329346098,
0.0398294367,
0.0102999881,
0.0132385362,
-0.0021295703,
0.007468394,
0.0023515006,
-0.0058481968,
-0.0349729918,
-0.0112422407,
-0.0035350849,
0.0195381623,
-0.0257022083,
-0.0217329711,
0.0343257114,
-0.0431490652,
0.105726324,
0.0032131667,
0.0295398366,
0.0567413718,
-0.0033473822,
-0.0395305194,
-0.0175633747,
-0.0102689052,
0.0237144791,
0.0446859375,
0.0155198397,
-0.0109781884,
0.0312264506,
0.0665608719,
-0.0367682055,
-0.0388823748,
-0.0388186909,
0.0110062491,
0.0153784193,
0.0828787461,
0.0279244296,
-0.0205291212,
-0.0138048241,
0.0210296921,
-0.0436131135,
0.0079969317,
-0.0110935261,
0.0589587241,
0.0444052555,
0.0483370312,
-0.0649144575,
0.0120825814,
-0.0407363586,
0.0325290561,
0.0774837509,
-0.0554458238,
-0.0656597167,
0.0306752715,
3.037e-7,
0.02530865,
0.0216323435,
0.0339262076,
0.0079806922,
0.0250956193,
0.0057709813,
0.0352929868,
0.0484288894,
-0.0131784724,
0.0512296595,
0.0264118444,
0.0228340272,
0.0558678173,
0.0121525256,
-0.1013603956,
-0.0665818974,
-0.0524641089,
0.0304253772,
0.006079359,
-0.0100502605,
-0.0075904024,
0.1011766642,
-0.0131233446,
0.0028005184,
0.0079914341,
0.0420131832,
0.0363724381,
0.0173789132,
0.0216776356,
0.0034686809,
0.0097511997,
0.0017384823,
-0.075363934,
-0.0111032622,
-0.0206160173,
0.019240519,
0.0168890264,
0.0725296885,
0.0046598068,
-0.0204022937,
0.0326023065,
0.0046014842,
-0.0318774059,
-0.0265336465,
0.0124377543,
-0.0854646564,
-0.0362719409,
0.042633418,
0.0137784965,
0.0314567015,
-0.0207160637,
-0.0055764779,
0.0162985269,
0.0162605569,
0.0235177837,
-0.0423740782,
0.0014771638,
-0.0648287609,
-0.0254734959,
-0.0068926471,
-0.0437914245,
-0.0234839264,
-0.0522020794,
-0.0738344938,
0.0310683791,
0.0470267832,
-0.0685020387,
2.721021466e-34,
0.0420710556,
-0.0209045447,
-0.0313505419,
-0.0172955468,
0.0044647986,
-0.0595284775,
0.0056535336,
-0.0259842966,
0.0094757816,
-0.057217706,
-0.0451940075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14909v1 | Linking Surface Facts to Large-Scale Knowledge Graphs | 2023-10-23T13:18:49 | 2023-10-23T13:18:49 | Gorjan Radevski, Kiril Gashteovski, Chia-Chien Hung, Carolin Lawrence, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Open Information Extraction (OIE) methods extract facts from natural language
text in the form of ("subject"; "relation"; "object") triples. These facts are,
however, merely surface forms, the ambiguity of which impedes their downstream
usage; e.g., the surface phrase "Michael Jordan" may refer to either the former
basketball player or the university professor. Knowledge Graphs (KGs), on the
other hand, contain facts in a canonical (i.e., unambiguous) form, but their
coverage is limited by a static schema (i.e., a fixed set of entities and
predicates). To bridge this gap, we need the best of both worlds: (i) high
coverage of free-text OIEs, and (ii) semantic precision (i.e., monosemy) of
KGs. In order to achieve this goal, we propose a new benchmark with novel
evaluation protocols that can, for example, measure fact linking performance on
a granular triple slot level, while also measuring if a system has the ability
to recognize that a surface form has no match in the existing KG. Our extensive
evaluation of several baselines show that detection of out-of-KG entities and
predicates is more difficult than accurate linking to existing ones, thus
calling for more research efforts on this difficult task. We publicly release
all resources (data, benchmark and code) on
https://github.com/nec-research/fact-linking. | [
0.036531046,
0.0161419176,
0.0183668472,
0.0696106404,
-0.0236768406,
0.0225731879,
-0.0425699428,
-0.0007973856,
0.0358394906,
-0.0703488812,
0.0290151443,
0.0329115503,
0.0042668195,
0.040532954,
-0.0082285265,
-0.0199273154,
0.0587310605,
0.0239527021,
0.0237716194,
0.0134151382,
-0.0063806167,
0.037531957,
-0.0228367206,
-0.0321513899,
-0.0384125002,
0.013683958,
-0.0067817513,
-0.0127373273,
0.0219264086,
-0.0036291776,
-0.0570898689,
0.0346892662,
-0.0240802784,
0.0427156873,
0.0000020477,
-0.0761726275,
-0.0333538428,
0.0216344558,
-0.062708728,
0.0109488079,
-0.0054616607,
-0.0287754741,
0.0100575844,
-0.034815643,
-0.0374425948,
-0.0588257685,
0.0383756869,
0.0497041643,
0.0235127434,
0.0507375821,
-0.0135843465,
-0.0150418058,
0.0290496591,
0.0250922665,
0.0016799084,
-0.0421884954,
0.0277851075,
0.0015977944,
-0.0383675806,
0.0131987296,
-0.0047885398,
0.0234726444,
-0.0106440475,
0.0136931725,
0.0018047248,
0.0287919454,
-0.0490606651,
0.0038551285,
0.0148994178,
0.1176989153,
0.0276736896,
0.0067699957,
0.0186224133,
0.0053849267,
0.025895562,
0.0491431057,
-0.0020131366,
0.0088334763,
-0.051972609,
0.0027240939,
-0.0010163519,
-0.0238071587,
0.033540342,
-0.004078296,
-0.0253887456,
0.0473228283,
-0.0173861682,
-0.0288616586,
0.0789630711,
0.0170379225,
-0.0110947844,
-0.0407250114,
0.0040234239,
-0.000770421,
-0.0176449399,
0.0372802876,
-0.0437232852,
-0.0132266479,
-0.0047247405,
-0.0534429178,
-0.0046553835,
0.0032033576,
-0.0092383437,
0.0510132425,
-0.0263696425,
-0.0011692209,
-0.0191947166,
0.0037216335,
0.001776565,
-0.0351271741,
-0.0334750377,
0.0353582129,
-0.0296614468,
0.0356484987,
-0.0284630135,
-0.0130724907,
0.0144942654,
-0.0107448557,
-0.0297009293,
0.0627999678,
-0.027414687,
-0.0193889961,
0.0096094701,
-0.0086768819,
-0.0663420856,
0.0247817859,
-0.0319169462,
-0.0182503983,
-0.0373683237,
-0.0273097511,
0.0098243244,
-0.0134886364,
0.0268871561,
-0.0208862051,
0.0168413501,
0.0592725985,
0.0222482309,
0.0229870304,
-0.0522994436,
-0.0785586014,
0.0059049176,
-0.0546061769,
-0.0205585845,
-0.0762998462,
0.0314024314,
0.0325978212,
-0.0300926473,
-0.0443159416,
0.0283274781,
-0.008148619,
-0.0853205696,
0.0559769459,
-0.0598146468,
-0.027120214,
-0.0079096174,
0.0080337673,
0.0290934648,
0.0455828607,
0.0257426612,
0.0012173147,
0.0667619407,
0.0362009257,
-0.0357396677,
0.0152097074,
0.055640135,
0.0003462215,
0.0787363797,
0.0268634781,
0.0493781492,
0.0286433008,
0.0213279352,
0.0581169426,
-0.0002924853,
-0.0535969138,
0.0161942784,
-0.0231558662,
-0.0245843325,
0.0211801864,
0.0555053987,
0.0191709045,
0.0539978705,
0.015969269,
-0.0597016998,
-0.0322081484,
-0.0376311205,
0.0311091263,
-0.0020960984,
0.0327517614,
0.025894912,
-0.0275576673,
-0.0401423834,
0.0125182932,
-0.0183597915,
-0.0095666926,
0.0564997792,
0.0125739137,
-0.0164432153,
0.0918219835,
0.0426942818,
-0.0136779761,
-0.0100987535,
0.005838152,
-0.0011873837,
0.0281499606,
0.0351731703,
-0.043818254,
-0.0429981463,
0.0167855434,
-0.0116562294,
0.0327767916,
0.0409425795,
-0.0448360033,
0.0231169574,
-0.0094606299,
-0.018208636,
0.0066615534,
0.0100803515,
-0.0002345581,
0.0499987081,
0.0318474099,
0.0201770756,
-0.0668643489,
0.0342232287,
0.0317593217,
0.0314599164,
0.0011366407,
-0.0248595569,
0.0225931648,
0.0105512766,
0.0342523679,
0.0006189253,
-0.0311199445,
0.0387470573,
-0.0080394736,
-0.0305631571,
0.0041142679,
0.0179056935,
-0.0188091099,
0.048953861,
-0.011131335,
-0.0502195656,
0.0101602292,
-0.0531214885,
-0.0248804297,
0.0027579926,
0.0118406545,
0.056758821,
0.0140824439,
-0.005791408,
0.0280072074,
-0.010972905,
0.0045697857,
0.0980420113,
-0.0032854208,
-0.0045548878,
0.010920763,
-0.0391919911,
0.0450906008,
-0.0361787416,
-0.0106022228,
0.007239494,
-0.012259651,
-0.0003732045,
-0.0112541281,
-0.0128376065,
-0.0890387744,
0.0207100604,
-0.0906388089,
0.0592368767,
-0.0051394706,
0.0481137335,
0.014118162,
0.0066280728,
-0.0029191256,
-0.00805349,
0.0023836389,
-0.00151115,
-0.0264264811,
0.0049910597,
0.0431625694,
0.0284001008,
0.0187744964,
-0.0161436945,
-0.000442555,
-0.0454932526,
0.0706952065,
0.0196869019,
-0.001534079,
-0.0114935329,
0.0418497585,
-0.0651968494,
0.0275916401,
0.0052637146,
0.0499085858,
-0.022701839,
-0.0088139595,
0.0474440083,
0.0588847287,
-0.0455223918,
0.0135556422,
0.0298214145,
-0.032177154,
-0.0205046386,
0.0091618439,
-0.0176324267,
0.0112739671,
-0.0406858176,
0.0227393322,
0.0295303687,
-0.0291897077,
0.0015215111,
-0.0169028882,
-0.0053305947,
0.0242839474,
-0.0000099288,
0.0078864181,
-0.0360265113,
0.0271455403,
0.0297319945,
-0.0034060478,
-0.0213142931,
0.0102391494,
0.0220702142,
-0.0201036818,
0.0506782308,
-0.0035906693,
0.0159155652,
-0.0248484407,
0.1044379398,
-0.0025484718,
0.0158976614,
0.0166472048,
-0.0344710536,
-0.01089352,
0.0152766546,
0.0380239487,
-0.0110912332,
0.0320983604,
-0.0619008765,
0.0482707843,
0.0073280591,
-0.0228705052,
-0.0143556679,
-0.0306663327,
-0.0424147397,
-0.0020936939,
-0.019807376,
-0.0353882387,
-0.0125016104,
-0.0243888851,
0.0110143553,
0.0033580221,
0.0260072872,
-0.0271715447,
-0.0021048621,
0.0380944461,
0.0275661126,
0.0334646739,
0.0080393506,
0.0433335751,
-0.0027214498,
0.0751529485,
-0.000087779,
-0.0112937801,
0.0186010003,
-0.0045222631,
-0.0265530944,
-0.0541011877,
-0.0203763302,
-0.0139258858,
0.013296959,
-0.0630758181,
-0.0084760021,
0.107338056,
0.0340469219,
0.0059890533,
-0.0112789338,
0.0136867287,
-0.0026154702,
0.0077008111,
-0.0012196634,
-0.1066869795,
-0.0412272587,
-0.0035713403,
-0.002155148,
-0.0034208624,
-0.0690786317,
-0.0160925705,
-0.1083818227,
0.0005408997,
-0.023203468,
-0.0717143714,
-0.0725445971,
-0.0709854886,
0.0403961167,
-0.0495658889,
-0.0555342138,
-0.0059855646,
-0.0128753735,
0.0234119706,
-0.0279670805,
0.0089311181,
-0.0334043652,
0.0275566839,
-0.0667201877,
0.0123130176,
-0.0331277139,
0.0344534069,
0.0125263827,
0.009037599,
-0.0232196972,
-0.0126359053,
-0.057198517,
-0.0334219933,
0.0874677077,
-0.0171444155,
0.0199217033,
-0.0519405603,
-0.0025899711,
-0.017209433,
0.0112662977,
-0.0086417412,
0.0973294452,
0.0312397368,
0.0001146888,
0.0216846149,
-0.0366416089,
0.0112944832,
0.0834701583,
-0.0154464617,
0.0260985922,
-0.0111593623,
-0.0458098203,
0.0025837123,
-0.0013002692,
-0.0618892983,
0.049246721,
-0.0860195681,
-0.0361599587,
-0.0770437568,
-0.0167751927,
0.0317907184,
0.0463858917,
-0.0024184573,
-0.0032103884,
0.070202373,
0.0075879921,
-0.0835618973,
0.0125329811,
-0.0663462654,
0.0137887662,
0.0005249928,
0.0017742577,
0.0080547556,
0.0056705838,
-0.0453051366,
0.0378808193,
-0.0434708111,
-0.0309276655,
0.0330909304,
-0.0381957665,
0.0193883367,
0.0405436233,
-0.0246290322,
0.0341389328,
0.025459338,
0.0604883842,
-0.0277022291,
0.0159845762,
0.0225636959,
-0.0382618047,
0.0145032406,
0.0337904729,
-0.0469678231,
-0.0214415081,
-0.0111421011,
0.0250475239,
-0.0566171855,
-0.024460962,
0.0196196027,
0.0664249212,
0.0216538403,
0.0359274708,
-0.0148546444,
-0.0423250906,
-0.0080716051,
-0.0088443719,
-0.0247281659,
-0.0213219542,
0.0231552124,
0.0023577164,
0.0277573559,
-0.0075209639,
0.0329925418,
0.0204285886,
0.0320989192,
-0.0241413414,
-0.0752293915,
0.0060211313,
0.0096466579,
0.0220933165,
-0.0508621819,
-0.0348358676,
0.0242840592,
0.0058141872,
0.0325457305,
-0.0608782619,
-0.0015621685,
0.0314045884,
-0.0417436771,
-0.0090429783,
0.0009405655,
-0.0254833475,
0.0227441788,
0.0106800636,
0.0414513126,
0.0525257401,
-0.0104499068,
0.0438122228,
-0.0228374451,
-0.025221277,
0.0174661726,
0.013117725,
-0.0011287787,
-0.0217611622,
0.0165476333,
0.0087541584,
-0.0393278189,
0.0286125857,
0.0272511709,
-0.022275947,
0.0672150403,
0.0045641973,
-0.0486033075,
-0.0249104518,
-0.0305059347,
-0.029693095,
0.0205367971,
-0.0009996003,
-0.0074772215,
-0.0970884115,
-0.0466786176,
0.0137007628,
0.0285097249,
-0.0028149725,
0.0158057343,
0.0283287279,
0.0447125621,
0.0694918558,
-0.0648744851,
-0.0058170138,
0.0266405419,
-0.0646252707,
-0.0181580875,
-0.0173912123,
-6.326017623e-33,
-0.0498055592,
-0.0278851874,
-0.0203973334,
0.0429417975,
-0.0571683347,
0.026557086,
0.0137490742,
-0.0077412883,
-0.0690917596,
0.0446794592,
0.0114694908,
0.030987503,
0.0135464007,
-0.0238137562,
-0.0386192575,
-0.032124117,
0.0205297321,
-0.0067809336,
-0.0341135375,
0.0029215899,
0.0916076675,
-0.0087033799,
0.061505165,
-0.1046681181,
0.0369427279,
-0.0210370682,
0.0042860173,
0.0427448899,
0.0087810056,
0.0307681374,
0.0128970426,
0.0388448201,
0.0087888539,
-0.0355144031,
0.0208216663,
-0.0083530266,
-0.1455447525,
-0.0435241982,
0.0398176499,
0.0327697881,
-0.0069749509,
0.0037298882,
0.0273882262,
0.0151776085,
0.0445171408,
-0.0517532639,
0.0273822416,
-0.0017606056,
-0.0188383944,
-0.0255404767,
-0.0419425108,
0.0435378999,
0.0377709344,
0.0253044963,
-0.0147806481,
-0.0639258474,
0.0213400703,
-0.0408332013,
-0.0536962003,
-0.0167439599,
-0.0217795875,
0.0032647355,
0.0207327977,
-0.0180932395,
0.0120291701,
0.0491473339,
-0.028640341,
-0.009497717,
-0.0315337405,
0.0523280837,
-0.000646243,
0.0687331036,
-0.0241432432,
0.0555396192,
0.054019697,
0.0221771728,
-0.1041230559,
-0.0001908487,
-0.0118141575,
0.0030824747,
-0.0798611119,
-0.0280500613,
-0.0439522602,
-0.0026464008,
-0.041145131,
0.0450047851,
-0.0116130169,
-0.0042231288,
-0.0049738903,
-0.028999202,
-0.0134821879,
0.02167462,
-0.0246809311,
-0.0037748485,
0.0159851294,
0.046954412,
0.0136691052,
0.0318382978,
-0.0159087256,
-0.001918588,
-0.0590293854,
-0.0370160043,
-0.0011611875,
-0.0102690812,
0.0296910498,
0.0200089198,
0.0345797315,
-0.0075538298,
-0.0415731817,
0.0179744326,
-0.012820065,
-0.0240908191,
-0.0361862928,
-0.0294214617,
0.0424840078,
0.0335909538,
-0.0013114699,
0.0096333474,
0.0549171492,
0.0422870331,
-0.0464502126,
0.0066489326,
0.0198735259,
0.001082181,
0.0008867927,
-0.0039194436,
-0.0312156472,
-0.0559592955,
-0.0069947904,
-0.0517566502,
-0.0036528101,
0.0208628643,
2.842e-7,
0.0282248966,
0.0143384747,
-0.0104925213,
0.0701574609,
-0.0154890846,
0.0339745171,
0.0532156415,
0.0250933003,
-0.0136246169,
-0.0354328938,
-0.0214264542,
0.031407021,
-0.0154377231,
0.0703546926,
-0.0830440968,
-0.0047257249,
0.0145739093,
-0.0722685829,
-0.0405581631,
-0.0007839889,
0.059804827,
0.027697634,
0.0778231621,
0.0207409877,
-0.0134973889,
-0.0623216629,
0.0225421879,
0.0244461391,
-0.019692922,
0.0159671213,
0.0785646215,
0.008662845,
-0.0240646508,
0.060246978,
-0.0003775471,
0.0271464866,
0.0023113324,
0.0313119777,
0.0235583149,
0.0473678634,
-0.046487812,
-0.1047949493,
0.0051046163,
0.0332003832,
0.0678521246,
0.0026334412,
-0.0115164761,
0.0152744213,
-0.0198634118,
0.0049151834,
-0.0348324217,
0.0185139738,
-0.010462882,
-0.0025597818,
-0.0054056146,
-0.0240973365,
-0.0048493366,
-0.0412746444,
-0.019387655,
0.0497066975,
0.0355914794,
-0.0697771087,
0.0490643345,
-0.0586279444,
0.037434347,
-0.0625582412,
-0.0121706109,
2.511472379e-34,
-0.0046613109,
0.0190446861,
-0.0040202229,
-0.035705559,
0.0466073863,
-0.03089213,
-0.0253191236,
-0.0439894386,
-0.0169527419,
-0.0426819436,
0.0346593335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14892v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14892v3 | Air-Decoding: Attribute Distribution Reconstruction for Decoding-Time Controllable Text Generation | 2023-10-23T12:59:11 | 2023-11-02T03:14:47 | Tianqi Zhong, Quan Wang, Jingxuan Han, Yongdong Zhang, Zhendong Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Controllable text generation (CTG) aims to generate text with desired
attributes, and decoding-time-based methods have shown promising performance on
this task. However, in this paper, we identify the phenomenon of Attribute
Collapse for the first time. It causes the fluency of generated text to rapidly
decrease when the control strength exceeds a critical value, rendering the text
completely unusable. This limitation hinders the effectiveness of decoding
methods in achieving high levels of controllability. To address this problem,
we propose a novel lightweight decoding framework named Air-Decoding. Its main
idea is reconstructing the attribute distributions to balance the weights
between attribute words and non-attribute words to generate more fluent text.
Specifically, we train prefixes by prefix-tuning to obtain attribute
distributions. Then we design a novel attribute distribution reconstruction
method to balance the obtained distributions and use the reconstructed
distributions to guide language models for generation, effectively avoiding the
issue of Attribute Collapse. Experiments on multiple CTG tasks prove that our
method achieves a new state-of-the-art control performance. | [
-0.0361998752,
0.0719135329,
0.0050861076,
0.0087863998,
0.0026214113,
-0.0100187138,
-0.0108718025,
0.0201473199,
-0.0659750775,
0.002031432,
-0.0143446662,
-0.0238410961,
0.0322247222,
0.062781401,
0.032374572,
-0.0319080427,
-0.008055768,
-0.0232763179,
0.0179623608,
0.0068550529,
0.0307401326,
0.0079096276,
-0.0017500235,
0.0346107408,
0.0026690846,
0.0022347677,
-0.033766415,
0.0026496856,
0.0228958335,
-0.0070879548,
0.0022887841,
0.0320456475,
0.0098404456,
0.014362515,
0.0000021756,
0.0394113734,
-0.0295075979,
0.0084370989,
-0.008143764,
0.0095898015,
0.1119343787,
0.0031394919,
-0.0209610406,
0.0260711908,
-0.0440371297,
-0.0148709165,
0.0572604388,
0.0372649319,
0.0625665411,
0.0597706363,
-0.0125662601,
-0.019252276,
0.0152242836,
-0.0321068615,
0.0582852028,
-0.0408194214,
-0.0275725629,
-0.0306936204,
0.0266071502,
0.0201608408,
-0.0310841147,
0.0662132427,
0.0064006457,
-0.0031270189,
0.0417547971,
0.0477312878,
-0.0142689366,
-0.0116948821,
-0.0365320146,
0.0420050062,
-0.0167893711,
-0.044740133,
0.0293117557,
-0.0241923407,
-0.0053632408,
-0.0422338396,
-0.0194204412,
0.0212699063,
-0.0286612734,
0.0212248098,
0.0252463035,
0.035923779,
0.0149361091,
-0.0285482761,
-0.0220308024,
0.0105032818,
0.0052988469,
-0.0232504942,
-0.0465627797,
0.0384958237,
0.0019149607,
-0.060011778,
0.025040593,
0.0093405284,
0.0040215035,
0.016174715,
-0.1055961773,
-0.0867265835,
-0.0310126934,
-0.0129181119,
0.0703732446,
0.0286106057,
0.0216148756,
-0.0120899929,
-0.046358142,
0.0422789939,
-0.0194111206,
-0.0037913665,
-0.0391148143,
0.0372248404,
-0.0448301025,
-0.0532048009,
-0.0583189912,
0.022966845,
-0.0404840931,
-0.0311875157,
-0.0478062108,
-0.0137573481,
0.0024346421,
-0.0267828312,
0.0455018766,
0.0123130232,
-0.0729032829,
0.0005965487,
0.0443718284,
0.0003747353,
0.0066776699,
-0.0067020115,
0.0470883064,
-0.0130987503,
-0.0165011007,
0.0132496664,
0.0523400754,
0.0059560458,
-0.0368639454,
0.0163527932,
-0.0787508041,
-0.0058325077,
-0.0050500683,
-0.036924962,
-0.0083894217,
-0.0066511519,
-0.0196212344,
-0.0435764156,
0.0088082291,
0.0081806965,
-0.0240342729,
-0.08087641,
0.0268447679,
-0.0006847905,
-0.0028500287,
0.0513892472,
-0.0408035852,
-0.0033022002,
0.0386317521,
0.0121587981,
0.0250692721,
0.0168134775,
0.0394870602,
0.0582849197,
-0.0323797278,
0.0345079303,
0.0469552837,
0.0132751223,
0.0618338995,
0.0092270114,
-0.042419143,
-0.0693352669,
-0.0273262542,
0.0329768993,
0.0466595143,
0.0418826267,
-0.0525965206,
0.0169404019,
0.0748163164,
-0.012708188,
-0.0137993628,
-0.0067074792,
0.0737821087,
0.0346161351,
-0.021613244,
-0.002858462,
0.0137861921,
0.0098754894,
-0.0108478842,
0.0333620943,
0.0060139303,
0.028647447,
-0.0128929531,
-0.0720631182,
0.0248378199,
-0.0335075818,
0.0554790832,
-0.0233491063,
0.0268753301,
0.061529085,
-0.0599230267,
0.0023418195,
0.010372078,
-0.0455867015,
0.0227159169,
-0.01634055,
-0.0125072775,
0.0622741915,
0.0448609963,
0.0250588562,
0.0080396263,
0.0053667184,
0.0189825017,
0.0571883656,
-0.0088983765,
0.0107616913,
0.0054608341,
-0.0610938109,
-0.0346167311,
0.0017940842,
0.0163693931,
0.0265268963,
-0.0330037512,
0.033646062,
-0.0006101836,
-0.0004505929,
-0.0581949502,
0.0359184518,
-0.0124845486,
-0.0135255801,
0.0341796428,
-0.0090017235,
-0.0034031488,
0.0048825638,
-0.038495969,
0.034695603,
0.0002224294,
-0.0509363562,
-0.0446471758,
0.0080786785,
-0.0442606285,
-0.0339061655,
-0.0287092049,
0.0017084801,
-0.0156950429,
-0.0139536401,
0.0163662676,
-0.0669181496,
0.0191486795,
-0.043382287,
0.0529319979,
-0.0065106559,
0.035787981,
0.0348678268,
0.0253439005,
-0.0180587322,
0.0511196777,
-0.0212521851,
-0.0321852826,
-0.0162805486,
0.0979539603,
-0.0107574239,
-0.0288872402,
0.0087055285,
-0.0106462417,
0.0016143502,
0.0044862553,
0.0478362367,
0.0243546888,
0.0352683738,
-0.0228010919,
-0.0037500565,
-0.0045217797,
-0.0107475622,
-0.0006172906,
-0.0143510364,
0.0047838939,
0.0086052222,
0.0035848047,
-0.0669149607,
0.0145240314,
0.0129438229,
-0.0400295407,
0.0278426576,
0.0061515248,
-0.0351981968,
0.007826671,
-0.0053755371,
0.0273682196,
0.0199793782,
0.0332195014,
-0.0007957257,
-0.0661962926,
0.0330544636,
-0.0117273899,
0.0080898525,
0.0187352318,
-0.0483251177,
0.0162679255,
-0.0135607393,
0.0274303965,
0.0584246032,
0.0358807109,
0.0528373159,
-0.0073542511,
0.0253551994,
-0.0260439944,
0.0027637878,
-0.0284171887,
0.0023682367,
-0.0141372029,
-0.0223101657,
0.057988245,
0.1091215909,
0.0581093132,
0.0375711247,
-0.084558107,
0.0378819369,
-0.0255395211,
-0.0474481732,
0.0121461721,
-0.0049054651,
-0.0136052417,
0.0353357717,
-0.0610869937,
-0.0366375931,
0.0494149402,
-0.0522676483,
0.0016561945,
-0.0008532554,
0.0129932677,
0.0068079405,
0.0137062296,
0.0251398757,
0.029910164,
0.0832096115,
-0.0413826704,
-0.0159015153,
0.0124695543,
0.0405701548,
-0.0337057523,
-0.0098814266,
-0.0524726771,
0.0084472615,
-0.0144176865,
-0.0656182691,
-0.0131393503,
0.0279443562,
0.0343272872,
-0.0198550541,
0.0323362611,
-0.0510109216,
-0.0288569424,
-0.0115229702,
0.0274708346,
0.0246849377,
-0.0321682915,
-0.0197908599,
-0.0229367912,
0.0533593222,
0.0230321642,
-0.0347530916,
-0.0219892822,
-0.0420301072,
-0.0508061647,
0.035751801,
0.0114240618,
0.0455630049,
-0.0034713987,
0.0560140461,
0.0211916044,
0.0307408776,
-0.0297055803,
-0.0049845092,
0.0354206823,
-0.0536485799,
-0.0400261544,
0.0575589761,
0.0259901062,
-0.0170488935,
0.002445651,
0.0432631448,
0.0428741612,
-0.0180821624,
-0.0033575001,
-0.0882874131,
-0.0062933904,
-0.0087720379,
0.063480176,
0.0027228366,
-0.003299969,
0.0108016888,
-0.0699655786,
0.0353063121,
0.0298828669,
-0.0474604368,
-0.0540788509,
-0.0011483864,
-0.0448707826,
-0.0127808759,
-0.0046973443,
0.0243901778,
0.0356492586,
0.0259886552,
0.0421058573,
0.0284048021,
-0.0433194861,
-0.0343843028,
0.0281513128,
0.0601224862,
0.0750672519,
0.0316064656,
0.0082290517,
-0.0246774163,
-0.0648274794,
-0.0095864888,
-0.0168212466,
-0.0305981617,
-0.0262585599,
0.0006627777,
-0.0416703336,
0.0115485583,
0.0604186468,
0.0131725427,
0.0061200559,
-0.0164582636,
0.0102574937,
-0.0091897771,
-0.0274410248,
-0.0190204065,
-0.0657330304,
0.057977777,
0.0412410349,
0.0104532177,
-0.0507542007,
-0.0888241455,
-0.0425854623,
-0.0125617972,
-0.1119807363,
-0.072341457,
0.0165520646,
-0.0015979616,
-0.0670851469,
-0.1262836754,
0.0079452451,
-0.0017216033,
0.0527995713,
-0.0213022474,
0.0484271795,
0.0168281589,
-0.0096218903,
-0.0880093127,
-0.0772977918,
-0.0069173872,
0.0269003883,
-0.0486835055,
-0.0677130371,
0.006219924,
-0.0513336547,
0.0042666402,
0.080558829,
-0.034925703,
-0.0419421047,
0.0531334691,
0.0456828848,
0.0196999274,
0.0414552353,
-0.025568258,
-0.0641720966,
0.059020035,
-0.0074376334,
-0.0553629622,
0.0364972539,
0.0236857608,
0.0007845086,
-0.0158392098,
0.0316035077,
-0.0262167379,
0.0486796573,
0.0249425117,
0.0261439122,
-0.0008211115,
0.007715473,
0.0098229153,
-0.0137629062,
-0.0755958483,
-0.039055258,
0.0166856125,
-0.002951795,
-0.0277660172,
-0.0217019375,
0.0151402494,
-0.0645673275,
0.037786752,
0.0105254631,
-0.0077252127,
0.0149433007,
-0.0299924407,
0.0345738642,
0.0362000428,
-0.0082968567,
0.0176125802,
-0.0698038563,
0.03973037,
0.0567986257,
0.0093602352,
0.0131931501,
0.0019313541,
-0.0167367272,
0.0080715101,
-0.0198084209,
0.012903722,
0.0348215103,
0.0142937945,
-0.0436774045,
0.0234960001,
-0.0100431517,
0.0828110054,
-0.0415195152,
0.0391906947,
0.0032890264,
0.0452208333,
0.0658304468,
-0.0500877202,
0.0095291017,
-0.013517715,
0.0409917533,
0.0025338228,
-0.0260442328,
-0.0084295152,
-0.0005455919,
-0.0023758316,
-0.0512191243,
0.0985739827,
0.0541860349,
0.0008934756,
-0.0395750739,
-0.0039074188,
-0.0416650288,
-0.0058380663,
-0.0022727414,
-0.0206392575,
-0.013202711,
-0.0004713728,
-0.0535328351,
-0.040561296,
0.0257640202,
0.0287933722,
0.0375114232,
-0.0230414215,
0.030561287,
0.0291301459,
-0.0368982069,
0.0191754363,
-0.0275170095,
-0.0192735996,
-0.0230889171,
-0.0191294122,
0.006636946,
-6.220002726e-33,
-0.0623451658,
-0.0049585351,
-0.0002957184,
-0.0042600343,
-0.0620138757,
0.0254331809,
-0.0619736053,
0.0063233981,
0.0492362157,
0.002883943,
-0.007825138,
-0.0076499977,
0.0065301284,
0.0379422382,
0.0233585984,
0.043796435,
0.0490273014,
-0.0272262581,
-0.0379168689,
0.0805267692,
0.0479946248,
0.0423189849,
0.0170582552,
-0.0398448408,
-0.0284889378,
-0.0230700783,
-0.0160079505,
-0.0289344359,
0.0365095548,
0.0227558538,
-0.0175880995,
0.0276068226,
0.0065456559,
-0.0643960834,
-0.060324274,
0.0105603011,
-0.0793694779,
-0.0046582376,
-0.0160045382,
-0.0120193511,
-0.013578278,
-0.034598507,
0.0075569279,
0.0015886965,
-0.0252048522,
0.0291854087,
0.0183727462,
-0.0339808613,
-0.0328527912,
-0.0840102881,
-0.0560418293,
0.040298257,
-0.0070166751,
-0.0063977814,
0.0354251228,
-0.064586103,
-0.0322015807,
-0.0334462188,
0.0051013469,
0.0129976207,
0.0563395731,
0.059340179,
0.0168628804,
0.0601198822,
0.0157429893,
0.0308867916,
0.0413844101,
0.0186482817,
-0.0220786873,
0.0484046526,
0.0273265876,
0.0154633783,
0.0117205409,
0.0562579222,
0.0108227553,
-0.0580055974,
-0.0060422942,
0.0232044682,
0.0091391448,
0.0089105247,
0.0316990614,
0.0397571251,
-0.032950338,
-0.0042356695,
-0.0111642582,
0.0043408191,
-0.001417295,
-0.0220343489,
0.0407959148,
0.0845078826,
-0.0599240251,
0.0272567235,
0.0435126312,
0.0120545775,
-0.001110875,
0.0130661251,
-0.0047739143,
0.038168259,
-0.033886455,
-0.0357090048,
-0.0282223523,
-0.0315356292,
0.0344284773,
0.0466084406,
-0.0007601764,
0.0019628515,
-0.0075577176,
0.036512468,
-0.0193139464,
0.0109389694,
-0.0378511064,
0.0305698104,
0.027579613,
0.0181885622,
0.0289450306,
0.0043585054,
-0.0136962757,
0.0143558076,
-0.0220030844,
-0.0407255851,
-0.0330875218,
-0.0291343369,
0.0164861139,
0.0310985986,
-0.0705306977,
0.0138694569,
-0.0507171676,
-0.0056348988,
0.0422241911,
-0.0906108096,
-0.0226571653,
0.0182208158,
2.78e-7,
0.0074721826,
0.0031830529,
0.0993289575,
0.0044168793,
0.0062081157,
0.0044478476,
0.0052265218,
0.042891819,
-0.0384214371,
-0.012774027,
0.0018259841,
0.0170821082,
0.0593857467,
-0.0101580666,
-0.0649118498,
0.0592317171,
-0.0177884698,
0.0378472507,
-0.0463339165,
-0.0327943973,
0.0505622923,
0.0258723721,
-0.0437828824,
0.0099455835,
0.0497335382,
0.053380996,
0.0364492536,
0.0511919372,
0.022705432,
0.0138546517,
0.0050979238,
-0.0067442749,
-0.0442057922,
-0.0273363143,
-0.0433785133,
-0.0276990142,
0.0435015969,
0.0581900589,
-0.0112653133,
-0.0008073041,
0.0302419588,
-0.0317607895,
-0.0073302882,
-0.0058808215,
0.0102892518,
-0.0403515846,
0.025997607,
0.0041919663,
-0.0425801091,
0.0157016031,
-0.0540884547,
-0.0080226967,
-0.017212661,
0.0274615455,
0.0112583116,
0.0424093567,
0.020484576,
-0.0730450004,
-0.0360668562,
-0.0210043732,
-0.031716805,
0.0011292252,
-0.0766859278,
0.0239165239,
0.007897892,
-0.0521151088,
-0.0390103944,
2.498519212e-34,
-0.0216719825,
-0.0270530917,
-0.0128888497,
0.0306772701,
-0.0054561212,
0.000724084,
0.055153504,
0.0397332795,
0.027237013,
-0.0101954117,
-0.0342052802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14883v1 | Non-autoregressive Streaming Transformer for Simultaneous Translation | 2023-10-23T12:52:24 | 2023-10-23T12:52:24 | Zhengrui Ma, Shaolei Zhang, Shoutao Guo, Chenze Shao, Min Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Simultaneous machine translation (SiMT) models are trained to strike a
balance between latency and translation quality. However, training these models
to achieve high quality while maintaining low latency often leads to a tendency
for aggressive anticipation. We argue that such issue stems from the
autoregressive architecture upon which most existing SiMT models are built. To
address those issues, we propose non-autoregressive streaming Transformer
(NAST) which comprises a unidirectional encoder and a non-autoregressive
decoder with intra-chunk parallelism. We enable NAST to generate the blank
token or repetitive tokens to adjust its READ/WRITE strategy flexibly, and
train it to maximize the non-monotonic latent alignment with an alignment-based
latency loss. Experiments on various SiMT benchmarks demonstrate that NAST
outperforms previous strong autoregressive SiMT baselines. | [
-0.0116581321,
0.0520339832,
0.0194846634,
-0.006492388,
-0.0176357459,
0.0335287638,
0.0076550525,
-0.0209399629,
-0.0714901984,
0.0081035113,
-0.0093072886,
-0.0535089038,
0.0210092682,
0.0486057661,
0.0162621643,
-0.0384465344,
0.0349839814,
0.0116885006,
-0.0128538385,
-0.0112411017,
0.0008707768,
-0.0094916001,
-0.0125554968,
0.0044571748,
-0.0386955626,
-0.0338411853,
-0.0292183608,
0.043218106,
0.0316615701,
-0.0432636738,
-0.0055486164,
0.0336297043,
0.0199698862,
0.0449101329,
0.0000021141,
-0.0007302453,
-0.0327261761,
0.003988164,
0.0211420339,
-0.0137494737,
0.0314739421,
-0.0585764274,
-0.0376722962,
0.0470276363,
-0.0052262591,
-0.061855983,
0.0630360767,
0.0081916563,
0.0683993697,
0.070709303,
-0.0338997915,
-0.0392367505,
0.0162382647,
-0.082384102,
-0.0547599755,
-0.0136679886,
-0.026402235,
-0.0188867431,
-0.086717099,
0.0002524425,
-0.0534955971,
0.0718602687,
0.0496936738,
-0.0169300716,
0.009878804,
0.0218311474,
-0.0279458221,
-0.0392116681,
-0.0333510302,
0.0212406702,
-0.0476208255,
-0.0012110512,
-0.0127005782,
-0.0280574095,
-0.0298186261,
-0.0554440692,
-0.0259547327,
0.0319332592,
0.0025783144,
0.0154768936,
-0.0068812794,
0.0438686162,
0.0240341909,
-0.0370120704,
-0.0264805667,
-0.0575712733,
0.0395887569,
-0.021526847,
-0.0378174447,
0.032960441,
-0.0239161048,
-0.0109773241,
0.0455199033,
-0.0070279874,
-0.018960895,
0.0155943399,
-0.0414287113,
-0.0339138471,
-0.0090895426,
0.0044652605,
0.0240977574,
0.093291603,
-0.0047242469,
0.0155286798,
-0.0467316806,
0.0697192922,
-0.0464418828,
0.0025343366,
-0.0573192164,
-0.0180593561,
0.0175784659,
-0.0157095958,
-0.0213356428,
0.011745234,
-0.0417733602,
-0.0255536698,
-0.0181086641,
0.0408857912,
0.0076638758,
-0.0071425322,
0.0305938181,
-0.0111004356,
-0.0943714529,
-0.0266538355,
0.0180977825,
0.0913300812,
-0.0064027752,
-0.0149218151,
0.0235329531,
-0.0735996142,
-0.0391489603,
0.0316134878,
-0.0033885627,
-0.0252382234,
-0.0310479384,
0.0360610113,
-0.055968482,
-0.0033772439,
0.0124247735,
0.0067583034,
0.0061270255,
-0.033546295,
0.0254355818,
-0.0336904936,
0.0821136013,
0.0242406279,
0.0235026591,
-0.007872683,
-0.0019763908,
0.0145208882,
0.0460943989,
0.0299675707,
0.003659131,
-0.0068018539,
0.0177069828,
-0.0077037741,
-0.0124921193,
0.079511337,
0.0305320919,
0.0162360743,
-0.0004022537,
0.023626497,
-0.0423612855,
0.0528214127,
0.0109709846,
0.0245888587,
-0.0102524227,
0.0011374817,
0.0363005064,
0.022241341,
0.0584906004,
0.0635938644,
-0.0136511512,
-0.0113350702,
0.0635398701,
0.0220958944,
0.0130053507,
0.0433336757,
0.0612231195,
0.0203361046,
-0.045376312,
0.0199750531,
0.0117458422,
0.0694081113,
0.0937505364,
0.0215482041,
0.0529883616,
0.057279706,
-0.0389037281,
-0.0104239713,
0.0010909137,
-0.0265877992,
-0.0213872697,
-0.0371845365,
0.0333749317,
0.0184683967,
-0.0809855759,
0.0395503752,
-0.0408531427,
-0.0512665696,
0.0086748637,
-0.0149175283,
-0.0739482194,
0.0378851444,
0.0322305262,
0.0384843349,
-0.051818531,
-0.0373185612,
0.0001753259,
0.04885225,
0.0172004141,
0.0341953672,
0.037199825,
-0.0459015816,
-0.0251623206,
0.0446441136,
-0.0068346597,
0.0513724349,
-0.001552382,
0.068518959,
0.0364849977,
0.0411237851,
0.0167975035,
0.0181572158,
-0.0305591058,
0.0091945007,
0.0284547005,
0.0096395891,
0.0391757898,
0.0111866947,
-0.0068325335,
0.0021342013,
0.0432352908,
-0.0537348352,
-0.0199929271,
0.07421574,
-0.1093170196,
-0.0387884453,
0.0197174344,
-0.020703895,
0.0069855326,
0.0736993402,
-0.0011937071,
-0.0724869967,
-0.0106394179,
-0.0357374102,
0.0218772925,
-0.04251967,
0.0303283446,
0.0442740917,
0.0139013054,
0.0142473299,
-0.0020000439,
-0.0216629412,
0.0125412205,
0.0055688289,
-0.0187089574,
0.0142564196,
-0.057118997,
-0.0333020017,
0.0338535085,
-0.004000436,
-0.0170126706,
0.030349303,
-0.0105633698,
0.0057681156,
-0.0480920933,
-0.0334877372,
0.0127765136,
-0.0349662751,
0.0411651768,
0.0206040107,
0.0478974096,
0.0069662365,
-0.0114038782,
-0.0348341577,
-0.0102325296,
0.0242734328,
0.0130665731,
0.0126985544,
-0.0017618568,
0.008733633,
0.0265291557,
-0.0215154514,
0.0169005394,
0.0272327326,
-0.0047463956,
-0.0067085866,
-0.0657471716,
-0.0614600778,
0.0190798584,
0.0137856016,
0.006613133,
-0.0509605445,
0.011326435,
0.0185346361,
0.0499985069,
0.0226122495,
0.0348283611,
0.0027949642,
-0.0384743884,
-0.0077450988,
-0.0235850383,
0.0227805264,
-0.0241747033,
-0.0088297203,
0.0016653537,
-0.0181536041,
-0.0087965811,
0.0531220213,
-0.0116188331,
0.014578619,
-0.0835155398,
-0.0394779481,
0.0142502859,
-0.0273463279,
0.0162209645,
-0.0071256724,
-0.0229591299,
-0.0129400138,
-0.0186870918,
-0.0513462201,
0.0210707877,
-0.0449780487,
-0.0583904423,
-0.0239097886,
0.0496568009,
-0.0344545171,
0.0457069091,
0.0034340636,
-0.00119953,
-0.0502814539,
-0.0562059768,
-0.011688699,
0.0610169955,
0.0056657363,
-0.0192838237,
0.0281944145,
0.0151372869,
-0.0072043175,
-0.0294294786,
-0.0251374077,
-0.019697329,
0.0014877382,
0.0241116658,
-0.0009455078,
0.0732984766,
-0.0134329069,
-0.0521248765,
0.0229834616,
-0.0185739826,
0.0822754949,
-0.0319582149,
-0.006410744,
-0.0209126472,
0.0459880717,
0.0208429024,
-0.0172092672,
-0.0000361336,
-0.0595887341,
0.0351199843,
0.0379854962,
0.0350077376,
-0.0230465829,
-0.0298836436,
-0.0034774998,
0.0414676666,
0.0033151056,
0.0021221526,
-0.0240010303,
0.0262522977,
-0.0369522162,
-0.0156817362,
0.0876744986,
-0.0090987366,
-0.0477043241,
-0.0109627526,
0.0059709526,
0.0611644872,
0.0025750108,
0.0037666557,
-0.0748538002,
-0.026030859,
-0.0117232595,
0.0288237035,
0.0526664928,
0.0284615643,
-0.0491388664,
-0.0710386112,
0.0180625729,
0.0365248583,
-0.0487652868,
-0.0291164201,
-0.0224220194,
-0.0654899552,
-0.0457004942,
0.0329277292,
0.0266216192,
-0.000235849,
-0.0016479912,
0.0113869114,
-0.0208930336,
-0.0388512984,
-0.0424737893,
-0.054979004,
0.0417014584,
0.0517757349,
-0.0008762468,
0.0168087464,
-0.0357820131,
0.0634932369,
-0.0408672355,
0.001295673,
-0.0046339724,
-0.0281467456,
-0.0503829271,
-0.0217114426,
-0.0092153605,
-0.0165660605,
-0.0199604072,
0.0124183642,
-0.0023335812,
0.054559119,
0.0125659676,
0.0089407414,
0.0004189273,
-0.0276242066,
-0.009474406,
0.0442704782,
-0.031278152,
-0.0299743023,
-0.0253948085,
-0.01655728,
0.0292889141,
-0.0419841968,
0.0251247585,
-0.0069590076,
0.0147803444,
-0.1034549922,
-0.0520019419,
-0.0414710268,
-0.0077074897,
0.0522409901,
-0.0031838727,
0.0169049948,
0.0121326754,
0.0056914468,
-0.0535394102,
-0.0097236736,
0.0041024582,
-0.0126461135,
-0.0696892962,
0.022363428,
0.0259113479,
-0.0102737257,
-0.0028685166,
0.0091590649,
-0.1314705014,
-0.0654899254,
-0.0031779255,
0.0265508611,
0.0086256089,
0.0755270496,
-0.0171381291,
0.0127550457,
0.0069621284,
0.0314573906,
-0.052446682,
0.0067080716,
0.0133790169,
-0.0232871994,
-0.0118234288,
0.0129295429,
-0.00665206,
-0.012525171,
-0.0379907787,
0.0502465181,
0.0199956782,
0.0095984805,
0.0078372946,
0.0018653476,
0.0311361942,
-0.0162746347,
0.0074664699,
-0.0003265964,
0.0544836931,
-0.0222226288,
0.033208482,
-0.0470531471,
0.0240650289,
0.025114296,
0.0021049888,
-0.0161031969,
0.0461878441,
0.0068570403,
-0.0459541567,
0.0186931528,
-0.0069005359,
-0.0523310639,
-0.0133877639,
-0.0113020223,
0.012506186,
-0.0173725095,
-0.0141750677,
0.0233909097,
0.0018102275,
-0.0623794571,
0.0253199805,
0.0272584837,
0.049648203,
0.0316001102,
0.0370743088,
0.0008544606,
0.0188832935,
-0.0523145869,
-0.016352525,
0.0546018332,
-0.0032162708,
0.101858221,
0.0073614423,
0.025889365,
-0.01366466,
0.0222705975,
-0.0242186487,
-0.0364437588,
-0.0072235032,
0.0076570977,
-0.0211060569,
0.0064222845,
0.0412816033,
-0.0223409887,
-0.0137622347,
-0.0115274144,
0.0003207768,
-0.0187013224,
-0.0113322185,
-0.0083119739,
-0.0423993357,
-0.003865767,
-0.0237291381,
0.0422378592,
-0.0187205765,
0.0102569908,
0.0061474275,
0.0118993158,
-0.0046681883,
0.0023623849,
0.0664854497,
-0.0485065691,
-0.0328263976,
-0.0159504749,
-0.0138935661,
0.028808102,
-0.0055858195,
-0.006243289,
-6.991263672e-33,
-0.0186611358,
0.0070277527,
0.0059802737,
-0.0545043387,
-0.048345536,
0.0398607217,
-0.0021669287,
-0.0400111713,
0.010210623,
-0.0001172383,
-0.0013970975,
0.0332507156,
0.0396350548,
0.0284110904,
0.0119956834,
0.0078165121,
0.1008706093,
-0.0095234513,
-0.0325471386,
0.0163767859,
0.0310679041,
0.0201042239,
0.0424291715,
-0.0021195351,
-0.0220418293,
-0.0331782326,
-0.0109286858,
0.0054277093,
0.0372808874,
0.0076020518,
0.0126096457,
-0.011916331,
0.0128789525,
-0.0662050918,
-0.0201730281,
0.0065012844,
-0.1082554311,
0.0170039926,
-0.0075893197,
0.0714372024,
-0.0114625711,
-0.0318456739,
0.0222919583,
-0.0177918673,
-0.0279725399,
-0.0551666282,
0.0001389901,
0.0057584844,
-0.0215199608,
-0.0567565784,
-0.0287501346,
0.0251055658,
-0.007096298,
0.0037362224,
0.026251331,
0.0513547473,
0.0117370514,
-0.0084372191,
-0.100370653,
0.0199810658,
-0.0201726779,
0.0789766535,
0.0730275884,
-0.0024706007,
0.0089918748,
0.0032706724,
0.011704741,
-0.0191064179,
0.0236337837,
-0.0008464241,
0.0074091805,
-0.0348499529,
0.0426632091,
-0.0250713695,
0.0959255621,
-0.0131136347,
-0.0243135244,
0.0231164191,
-0.0076473732,
0.0181374419,
0.0409269743,
0.0260944888,
-0.0146563686,
0.0046212049,
-0.0193905868,
-0.0193021577,
-0.0168852452,
-0.0336986966,
0.0384909809,
0.0582126342,
0.0159435123,
0.0313840844,
0.1011737138,
0.025394626,
0.0227935333,
0.0041357405,
-0.0186531655,
0.0178365856,
-0.0503801741,
0.0366016589,
-0.014248034,
-0.0261747986,
0.0347611904,
0.0193375964,
-0.0064776056,
-0.0183306467,
0.0255178157,
0.0698927417,
-0.0825636908,
-0.0058054747,
-0.026350379,
0.0607393235,
0.0054194652,
-0.0337185226,
0.0443277806,
-0.0176209081,
-0.0151994592,
0.0744166076,
-0.0194055419,
-0.0084091695,
-0.0242951456,
0.02671347,
0.0238871835,
0.0425281823,
-0.0268085171,
0.0546136238,
-0.0164518915,
0.0393339805,
0.0259340629,
-0.0767998397,
-0.0474907421,
0.0367216691,
2.78e-7,
0.0209722575,
0.0502077788,
0.0679254085,
-0.0053663808,
0.0241994299,
-0.000206841,
-0.0260784701,
0.0478295982,
-0.0037739999,
0.0686788037,
0.0216704775,
0.0048315874,
0.0614518486,
0.0201503169,
-0.0891570598,
0.0103600295,
-0.1065597981,
0.0470772311,
-0.0283878874,
-0.0033806427,
0.0413963273,
0.0709946305,
-0.0531811751,
0.0145982942,
0.0176312048,
0.0048380201,
0.0640079901,
0.0283256508,
0.0136437304,
0.000871475,
-0.0030260759,
-0.0076851374,
-0.0398880467,
-0.0181543697,
-0.0421013944,
-0.0037338017,
0.0350667164,
0.0570202209,
-0.0054623797,
-0.03598544,
0.05869174,
0.0420547277,
-0.0430431813,
-0.0092398729,
0.0688740015,
-0.0600523949,
-0.0158273466,
0.0131007591,
-0.0763999894,
0.0490080975,
0.0076204338,
-0.001913323,
-0.0365528166,
0.043256823,
0.0491651222,
0.0361599624,
-0.0096565979,
-0.0433397256,
-0.0162798353,
-0.041967243,
-0.0485729538,
-0.0109339403,
-0.0832433701,
0.0206920337,
0.0295267906,
0.0019244432,
-0.0361308157,
2.622871591e-34,
0.0404991433,
-0.031227082,
0.0190511812,
0.0082555683,
0.0071523064,
-0.049792368,
-0.0042820266,
0.0339034759,
-0.0557868667,
-0.0247827023,
-0.0714559332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14880v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14880v2 | Can ChatGPT Perform Reasoning Using the IRAC Method in Analyzing Legal Scenarios Like a Lawyer? | 2023-10-23T12:51:49 | 2023-11-03T03:50:07 | Xiaoxi Kang, Lizhen Qu, Lay-Ki Soon, Adnan Trakic, Terry Yue Zhuo, Patrick Charles Emerton, Genevieve Grant | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have drawn a lot of attentions
recently in the legal domain due to its emergent ability to tackle a variety of
legal tasks. However, it is still unknown if LLMs are able to analyze a legal
case and perform reasoning in the same manner as lawyers. Therefore, we
constructed a novel corpus consisting of scenarios pertain to Contract Acts
Malaysia and Australian Social Act for Dependent Child. ChatGPT is applied to
perform analysis on the corpus using the IRAC method, which is a framework
widely used by legal professionals for organizing legal analysis. Each scenario
in the corpus is annotated with a complete IRAC analysis in a semi-structured
format so that both machines and legal professionals are able to interpret and
understand the annotations. In addition, we conducted the first empirical
assessment of ChatGPT for IRAC analysis in order to understand how well it
aligns with the analysis of legal professionals. Our experimental results shed
lights on possible future research directions to improve alignments between
LLMs and legal experts in terms of legal reasoning. | [
0.05907166,
0.0228406042,
-0.0130218659,
0.0128368456,
-0.1077588275,
0.0340656303,
0.0135692647,
0.0101049459,
0.0129742371,
-0.0743092895,
0.0177115817,
-0.0202566553,
-0.0223326366,
-0.0121791139,
-0.0152803883,
-0.0325761773,
0.0239309501,
0.0110230958,
0.0734309107,
0.0136210332,
0.0448823869,
0.0335696377,
-0.0108891679,
0.0313460492,
-0.025878422,
-0.0372814573,
-0.0423197858,
0.0069882697,
-0.0000639691,
-0.0106063634,
-0.0113574406,
0.0666973963,
0.0286486596,
0.0243321992,
0.0000016934,
-0.0562028289,
-0.0069013396,
0.0004172113,
-0.0063960776,
0.0324730724,
0.0329421312,
0.0113443825,
-0.0182265565,
0.0066862935,
-0.0585356802,
0.0455002114,
0.0050768293,
0.0317249894,
0.0576536804,
0.0997869596,
-0.0201773178,
-0.0515353903,
0.025386503,
-0.0110456711,
0.0039205379,
-0.0307143405,
0.0143570257,
0.0410112329,
0.061558567,
-0.0053697419,
0.0519793332,
0.0109277144,
0.0446083397,
-0.067135565,
-0.0644305348,
-0.0023953561,
-0.0642185658,
-0.0039544734,
0.0099423015,
0.0075902366,
0.0565113723,
-0.0191343054,
-0.0181739647,
-0.002221141,
0.045087453,
0.0464897864,
-0.0335468911,
0.0643454567,
-0.026130354,
0.0198382959,
0.042435579,
0.0256376639,
-0.0192108862,
0.022550717,
-0.0144820027,
0.0612113774,
-0.0230482742,
-0.0371251442,
0.0032524217,
0.0084940493,
0.0031365287,
-0.091086641,
0.0231208894,
0.0596963167,
-0.0045001907,
0.0385610946,
-0.0089300657,
0.0043683494,
0.0719000399,
-0.07855957,
-0.0083513465,
0.0328881145,
-0.0261933059,
0.0728624612,
-0.009431175,
0.0042315749,
-0.0257314797,
0.0130760418,
-0.0009425511,
-0.0066108843,
-0.0782112554,
-0.0363680907,
-0.0491696894,
0.0408225879,
-0.0698138177,
0.0080997208,
-0.0040590698,
0.0256465599,
-0.0158752035,
0.0042367084,
0.021122098,
-0.0048979195,
-0.0105503565,
-0.02764263,
-0.0839027464,
-0.0739358142,
-0.0511582866,
0.0574011542,
-0.0056848424,
-0.0198947433,
0.0212927274,
0.0231896844,
-0.0211522356,
-0.0137441196,
-0.0222642645,
0.0883853287,
0.002290241,
-0.0011605588,
-0.0198119339,
-0.075818561,
-0.0103615206,
-0.093948707,
-0.0210594535,
-0.0713778213,
0.0092134448,
-0.010540477,
-0.0256737508,
-0.019883804,
0.0195346214,
0.0333359875,
0.0099260183,
0.0641965866,
-0.0054462859,
-0.0149515159,
-0.0266714897,
0.0320498087,
0.0238263067,
0.0354020372,
0.0168647226,
-0.0071247607,
0.0019081909,
0.015980592,
0.0194257218,
0.0499910861,
-0.0518997423,
0.0293533523,
-0.0024908825,
0.0318716466,
-0.0498178862,
0.0218357164,
-0.0191817377,
0.0438615568,
-0.0258801226,
-0.0147612831,
0.0114326458,
0.0743048564,
0.0055574086,
0.08278732,
0.0241587702,
0.0071323127,
0.0319573767,
0.0317809209,
-0.0265808776,
0.0154537959,
0.0057226922,
-0.012373927,
-0.0571745299,
-0.00852405,
-0.0233582184,
-0.0541074872,
-0.0065575349,
0.0012749752,
0.0007747079,
-0.0306108482,
0.0156310778,
0.0131467599,
0.0135760112,
0.0350425355,
0.0001954296,
-0.0442499034,
-0.0541510358,
-0.0547491424,
-0.0211893991,
0.0254486222,
0.0639576092,
-0.0506387912,
-0.0436287075,
-0.0231150929,
-0.0106827328,
0.0794226527,
0.0510264784,
-0.0077915187,
-0.0608614795,
-0.0180156175,
-0.0287560392,
0.0219214987,
0.0145897111,
0.0026262782,
-0.0036596579,
-0.0203262381,
0.0192012489,
-0.0268746931,
0.0391737036,
0.0313039385,
-0.0256398711,
0.0059063374,
-0.0024922763,
-0.0290459916,
0.0526088215,
0.0383837,
0.0055252225,
0.0311884321,
0.0348531678,
0.0045707682,
-0.0178141836,
0.0414686464,
-0.0192311238,
-0.0160100423,
0.0497913621,
-0.0481110103,
-0.0122080855,
-0.0032840534,
-0.0270019453,
-0.0174381938,
-0.0519790165,
0.0001272881,
0.0417112149,
-0.0608682744,
0.0077382457,
-0.0165840574,
-0.0328717418,
-0.0194473956,
0.045346234,
0.0111521287,
-0.0362146199,
-0.0190176461,
-0.0036292293,
0.0377356187,
-0.0254921801,
-0.0089105703,
-0.0351378396,
-0.0067333109,
-0.0011497998,
0.0228495114,
0.0222552232,
-0.0453260913,
-0.0442327671,
-0.1228458136,
0.0297831409,
-0.0175380576,
0.0164126381,
0.0173309371,
-0.034942437,
-0.0197364315,
-0.0053582797,
-0.0373100862,
0.0019279103,
-0.0164925326,
0.0150220599,
0.0179023948,
-0.0299351998,
-0.0224493984,
-0.0020590264,
-0.0101461438,
-0.0575106591,
0.0239625238,
0.0704620853,
-0.0333717428,
-0.0297689792,
0.0552103259,
-0.0194122568,
-0.0074452986,
-0.013779358,
0.0041911816,
0.0199552663,
0.0173356477,
-0.0303213205,
-0.0116022248,
0.0222529583,
0.0272966083,
0.0128765721,
-0.0206416789,
-0.0443877392,
-0.0043250686,
0.0294200107,
0.0272389725,
-0.0422322191,
-0.0159989167,
-0.0145839481,
0.0421452746,
-0.0094378833,
0.009764201,
-0.0290772598,
0.006449054,
-0.0067946147,
0.0155550521,
-0.0155044599,
-0.0588617064,
-0.0277621541,
0.0527220704,
0.0293185581,
-0.0336355232,
0.0550144501,
-0.0109641412,
0.0373622142,
-0.0775845349,
-0.0032263454,
-0.0489761122,
0.0843722299,
-0.0170113835,
-0.0121754976,
0.0176298153,
-0.0251057465,
0.0034679298,
-0.022070894,
0.056659475,
-0.0208733939,
0.0766039565,
-0.0517072082,
0.0545555167,
-0.015692329,
-0.033220306,
-0.0277290698,
-0.0625115037,
-0.0020362001,
0.0607056208,
0.0041905991,
0.0238738693,
-0.0169300083,
0.0237087067,
-0.0243105181,
-0.0055338475,
0.0147519568,
-0.0314725563,
-0.0366629511,
0.0156927593,
-0.000969581,
-0.0267607532,
-0.0060242848,
0.0304317363,
0.0394297205,
0.035369698,
-0.0185447708,
0.0226853918,
-0.0140165146,
0.0138403429,
-0.0340398215,
-0.0419460647,
-0.0246647634,
-0.0013086083,
-0.0033199191,
-0.0554273203,
0.0128393508,
0.0958877876,
0.0385823548,
-0.0459803827,
-0.0067109172,
-0.0413687974,
0.0189412516,
0.0229908079,
0.021122871,
-0.1113840863,
0.0297241211,
-0.0071762367,
-0.0402945615,
-0.0594861731,
-0.0436446629,
-0.0078766271,
-0.0664869919,
0.1062056422,
0.0157337543,
-0.0033753687,
0.0023858179,
0.0068724374,
0.0007013541,
0.000867248,
-0.0045424118,
0.0191958956,
-0.002079959,
-0.0182346627,
0.0135596814,
-0.0475569591,
0.0356110334,
0.0389306322,
-0.0315303318,
0.0417129882,
0.0286817122,
0.0370520055,
-0.0098971417,
0.0152825797,
0.0248784553,
0.0389890969,
0.0140174618,
0.0230277516,
0.0030675575,
0.0193485767,
0.0185359381,
-0.0491739623,
0.0252254046,
-0.0325071029,
-0.0404791236,
0.065096654,
0.0964941606,
-0.0583922751,
0.0142191239,
-0.0161119588,
-0.0053995335,
-0.001876283,
0.0532655269,
0.0100463899,
0.0044739139,
-0.0392998196,
-0.0370322168,
-0.040062245,
-0.0330115184,
-0.0259071346,
-0.0098042153,
-0.0001716544,
-0.0084237698,
-0.0167351365,
-0.0464022644,
-0.005853402,
0.0419193357,
0.0011924712,
0.0153245786,
0.0422482677,
-0.0103342906,
-0.0126232617,
0.0057103527,
-0.0424705744,
-0.0001890227,
0.0353077352,
0.0198875275,
-0.0090789516,
0.0249453448,
-0.0098798191,
-0.0394255258,
-0.0072979769,
-0.0428840481,
0.0018205921,
-0.0184278656,
0.0281326044,
-0.0014920818,
-0.0402939171,
-0.0402723216,
0.0230202209,
-0.0007452549,
-0.023752477,
-0.007290049,
0.0484414808,
-0.0005264629,
-0.0044002486,
0.0034071985,
0.0197041407,
0.0093973828,
-0.0074767973,
0.0557454117,
-0.0462819785,
-0.0101494519,
0.043010015,
0.0367598273,
0.0111694904,
0.0149399377,
-0.024472557,
-0.0213025454,
0.0110106636,
-0.0420580767,
-0.0196312163,
-0.0252190884,
-0.0120495623,
0.0188245196,
-0.041236598,
-0.0270633008,
0.0438684411,
-0.0736125857,
-0.0076485146,
0.0077938689,
0.0585595928,
0.0401395261,
0.0075965803,
0.0205716044,
-0.0535546988,
-0.0082099102,
0.0095705353,
-0.0406042077,
0.0331654586,
-0.0289992448,
0.0829900429,
0.0150696309,
0.0049346401,
0.0198258795,
0.0175675992,
-0.0068244864,
-0.043951083,
0.0076808347,
0.0836289898,
0.0271460935,
0.0111594973,
0.012949165,
-0.0440179408,
0.0068612224,
0.0059693018,
0.0175593179,
0.0167600363,
-0.0361839645,
0.0460048243,
0.0293911453,
-0.0325890779,
0.0189503487,
0.0231797267,
-0.0377998129,
0.0101717822,
-0.021078581,
-0.0334822983,
-0.0293457899,
-0.0564817227,
0.0093053794,
-0.0013874853,
-0.0083657727,
-0.0321116596,
-0.0857406557,
-0.043844223,
-0.0387438722,
0.0169160236,
-0.0172977988,
0.0217807293,
0.0073680184,
0.0473437421,
0.0238085538,
-0.0184504203,
-0.058438953,
0.0194749404,
-0.0503444113,
-0.0044806753,
-0.0321895331,
-5.00830719e-33,
-0.0392182171,
-0.0364008956,
0.0411737077,
0.015450648,
-0.0153885046,
-0.0371952318,
-0.0114846975,
0.0121684968,
-0.0130075924,
0.0408589691,
-0.0165339466,
0.0579301044,
0.0248324983,
-0.0355833061,
0.0219474379,
-0.0090168864,
-0.0146283247,
-0.0059013958,
-0.0045417803,
-0.0044914326,
-0.024433976,
-0.0290378854,
0.0130113168,
-0.0952596888,
0.053674899,
0.0022157615,
-0.0129002919,
-0.0051118964,
-0.0771461129,
0.0754246414,
-0.0331101343,
0.0150714656,
0.0308630839,
-0.0112875011,
0.0046605412,
0.0664282665,
-0.0436237194,
-0.0046763411,
0.0301445629,
-0.0198973548,
-0.004534544,
-0.0307091642,
0.0199948251,
0.0080986172,
-0.0102859084,
-0.0141122378,
0.0165209733,
-0.0417775065,
-0.0141082937,
-0.0232871976,
-0.0916663781,
0.0575445704,
-0.0328790285,
0.0155501151,
0.0215868577,
0.0231706295,
0.0049944012,
0.006676903,
-0.0334576741,
-0.0095487274,
-0.0368121155,
-0.0224303603,
0.045510266,
-0.0924945027,
-0.0061730072,
0.0464910045,
-0.0199512802,
0.0230296981,
-0.0430080444,
-0.0015005455,
0.0007564306,
0.097387068,
0.0326312482,
0.0303513538,
-0.0096210353,
0.0191022102,
-0.0636286959,
-0.0105246063,
0.0472782031,
0.0727595091,
0.0392075479,
-0.0022836048,
-0.0448199473,
0.0004994021,
-0.0272358414,
-0.02286743,
-0.0045143277,
-0.032780502,
0.02128396,
-0.0259845667,
0.0430687442,
-0.0133619141,
-0.0035202694,
-0.0359436236,
0.0137688406,
0.0168991406,
0.0017064422,
0.0058782287,
-0.019330658,
0.0601901114,
-0.0197282322,
-0.0245601516,
0.0203684829,
-0.0307907015,
0.0179168582,
-0.0009505007,
0.0550971739,
-0.0152501073,
-0.0470591113,
-0.0278748199,
-0.0238906629,
0.0103297587,
0.0190043692,
0.0184155572,
0.0053900364,
0.0390849262,
0.0087893466,
0.0104663018,
0.0270780623,
-0.0284433737,
-0.0405643322,
-0.0263437983,
-0.0173518471,
-0.0358127542,
-0.0002882567,
0.0004507731,
0.0158269517,
0.0502543934,
0.0485825539,
0.0104159201,
0.0157234762,
0.0752235577,
2.354e-7,
0.1106995568,
0.0387700908,
0.0073170164,
0.0119565092,
0.0056738057,
0.0221107341,
-0.0066199196,
0.0222163163,
0.0420493074,
-0.0144401398,
0.0349270962,
0.0081610437,
0.057447508,
0.0923404172,
-0.0712936893,
-0.0336985886,
-0.0453839004,
-0.0585292727,
-0.0542398281,
0.0541400649,
0.106012851,
0.0649569184,
0.0342545249,
0.0005603107,
-0.0241742488,
-0.0602228455,
0.0443608873,
-0.0147636449,
-0.0377206132,
0.0131801926,
0.065245837,
-0.0513251461,
0.0066617848,
0.0600939952,
0.0246688258,
0.0426297002,
-0.0420486405,
0.0707325414,
-0.0253371652,
0.0337699689,
-0.0132276258,
-0.0716881976,
0.0239253696,
-0.0473786034,
0.0619803928,
-0.0284209959,
-0.0181715172,
-0.02794246,
-0.0067496281,
-0.0538448766,
0.0165852811,
0.0342574008,
-0.0151503254,
0.004150359,
0.0196932722,
-0.0149732269,
-0.010580752,
-0.0798051134,
-0.0061273961,
0.0437303968,
-0.0462367497,
-0.003430512,
0.0063542253,
0.003885627,
0.053738188,
-0.0620520413,
0.0314484462,
1.751570612e-34,
0.0191445537,
0.0169556085,
0.0109300818,
0.0825660005,
0.05811942,
0.052495122,
0.0160381366,
0.0498886667,
-0.0055818711,
-0.0774594545,
0.0308680031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14870v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14870v2 | We are Who We Cite: Bridges of Influence Between Natural Language Processing and Other Academic Fields | 2023-10-23T12:42:06 | 2024-07-01T12:31:46 | Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Mohamed Abdalla, Bela Gipp, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | Natural Language Processing (NLP) is poised to substantially influence the
world. However, significant progress comes hand-in-hand with substantial risks.
Addressing them requires broad engagement with various fields of study. Yet,
little empirical work examines the state of such engagement (past or current).
In this paper, we quantify the degree of influence between 23 fields of study
and NLP (on each other). We analyzed ~77k NLP papers, ~3.1m citations from NLP
papers to other papers, and ~1.8m citations from other papers to NLP papers. We
show that, unlike most fields, the cross-field engagement of NLP, measured by
our proposed Citation Field Diversity Index (CFDI), has declined from 0.58 in
1980 to 0.31 in 2022 (an all-time low). In addition, we find that NLP has grown
more insular -- citing increasingly more NLP papers and having fewer papers
that act as bridges between fields. NLP citations are dominated by computer
science; Less than 8% of NLP citations are to linguistics, and less than 3% are
to math and psychology. These findings underscore NLP's urgent need to reflect
on its engagement with various fields. | [
0.0506208763,
0.0437287875,
-0.0245894715,
-0.0232153349,
-0.021349486,
-0.0153689981,
0.0332286395,
0.0014677668,
0.0297683794,
-0.1072984636,
0.0248906333,
0.0431667604,
0.0312051475,
0.0267683696,
0.0253495686,
-0.0475490838,
0.0087536518,
0.0093535976,
0.0467452295,
0.0089437179,
-0.0100433677,
0.0197526012,
0.0009829941,
0.0747073293,
0.0282266103,
-0.034829136,
0.029588677,
-0.0412573256,
0.027430309,
-0.0374288,
0.0098626418,
0.0163500197,
0.0060439375,
0.0496459454,
0.0000016716,
-0.0667195097,
-0.0089303404,
0.0384687409,
0.0088726487,
-0.0135870371,
0.0233285446,
0.0025027061,
-0.0130736893,
0.0182859115,
-0.0488333069,
-0.00436344,
0.0571131222,
0.0310662575,
-0.0091775237,
0.0307104569,
0.0080062812,
-0.0574689992,
0.0513116419,
0.0347914696,
-0.0115132732,
0.0042778691,
0.0302173458,
-0.0251651853,
0.0033945907,
0.0207659993,
-0.0194649957,
0.0328487083,
-0.0355592743,
-0.0288426336,
0.054826878,
0.074213542,
-0.0285843909,
0.0236905273,
0.0104067558,
0.0020164177,
0.030602267,
-0.0147311836,
0.0493249334,
-0.0095380861,
-0.002743016,
0.035900455,
-0.036925707,
0.0419344082,
-0.0124108288,
-0.0171058718,
0.0390764587,
0.0106155286,
0.0198216327,
0.0584638193,
0.0096094534,
0.0417064168,
-0.0156741552,
-0.0428236648,
0.0578899421,
0.0311922096,
0.041202534,
-0.0291925352,
0.0062328381,
-0.0217327122,
-0.0004873565,
0.0019034341,
0.0324311294,
-0.0291510187,
0.028742915,
0.0145162996,
0.0021338863,
-0.0159989577,
-0.0131652309,
0.036492411,
0.0157665312,
-0.0468028262,
-0.0242918674,
-0.0341297947,
0.0403344035,
0.0133734485,
-0.0939913616,
-0.0337222628,
0.0111464188,
-0.0031244908,
-0.0129936468,
0.0102171255,
0.0026347188,
0.0080793863,
-0.0628929138,
-0.0351304151,
-0.0184966717,
0.033481285,
-0.0034565937,
0.0620729253,
-0.0029626503,
0.0595606491,
-0.0257426593,
0.0526528545,
-0.0137348305,
-0.0414882191,
0.0393331982,
0.0014048907,
0.01720904,
-0.0486139953,
0.0221950561,
0.0428076275,
0.0326598026,
-0.0189987011,
-0.0287695415,
-0.0345549993,
-0.005530132,
-0.0462993309,
0.0559642315,
-0.0649254769,
-0.0146172177,
0.0400110893,
0.0222077221,
-0.0607299134,
-0.0054675271,
0.0186930019,
-0.0428972542,
0.0308161732,
-0.0676702335,
-0.0274295453,
0.028494155,
-0.0125381947,
0.0134361004,
0.0556448288,
0.0166614354,
-0.0452945232,
0.0561977215,
0.0022229638,
0.0031092325,
-0.0308200344,
-0.043070972,
-0.015937306,
0.057634104,
-0.0357160792,
-0.0523363575,
-0.0097446283,
0.0132604856,
0.0308013931,
-0.021097336,
0.0019028389,
0.0263614655,
0.0994980931,
-0.0023426786,
0.0478590131,
0.0299045574,
0.0254817568,
0.0172462761,
-0.0277260672,
-0.0060315295,
-0.0096282586,
-0.0343081169,
-0.0043650474,
0.0187580325,
0.0388319194,
-0.0123068029,
-0.0250424594,
-0.0086625405,
0.0253386628,
0.0406812429,
-0.0384630784,
0.0273497161,
-0.0165544692,
0.0216715671,
0.0242467932,
0.001341357,
-0.0168528035,
-0.0022815366,
0.0327832885,
-0.0124786943,
0.0039723222,
0.0228774883,
-0.0142351435,
0.0487721376,
-0.0626720414,
-0.0254105125,
0.0505194105,
-0.0167565849,
0.0140053937,
0.0058480711,
0.0179003533,
-0.0056011043,
-0.0025186364,
0.011384109,
-0.0072853798,
0.023701733,
0.0297550745,
-0.0282697435,
-0.0396527164,
-0.0549992248,
0.0301023256,
-0.007579098,
-0.0037285057,
-0.0268017724,
-0.0140134497,
0.0283344164,
0.0649582744,
-0.0391810611,
0.0117951585,
0.0273168012,
-0.0104549145,
-0.0220866241,
0.023157781,
0.0534863696,
0.0607811771,
0.0341136269,
-0.0994905904,
-0.033050634,
-0.0132230446,
-0.0269475244,
0.0018354031,
0.0932150483,
-0.0361250006,
0.0250256434,
0.0266964976,
-0.0152481273,
-0.0480002314,
0.0089798458,
-0.0405223519,
0.0440226607,
0.0211236458,
0.0402254574,
-0.0020774237,
-0.0266994461,
0.03058156,
0.0296229888,
-0.0285202973,
0.0162042584,
-0.0037153941,
0.0192921292,
0.0880839601,
-0.0347585119,
-0.0579654202,
-0.0028282949,
-0.0187542494,
-0.0291186459,
0.018101383,
0.0026638599,
0.0108399736,
-0.0310143214,
-0.0021021159,
0.0251107588,
0.0335327499,
-0.053122662,
0.0044498253,
0.0107010398,
0.0422101915,
0.0112583004,
0.0445875153,
-0.0280981008,
-0.0070984033,
-0.046545811,
0.0387401208,
0.0522891991,
-0.0495809056,
-0.0684625357,
0.0239509046,
-0.0114295045,
0.0048732948,
-0.0094347792,
0.0361027494,
0.0125105008,
0.0514332615,
-0.0111335348,
0.0490368046,
-0.0113683483,
0.0170614403,
0.041355446,
0.0062450115,
-0.0372361839,
0.0046326909,
0.0059293676,
-0.0010049953,
-0.0195365455,
-0.0294677522,
0.0608627163,
0.011359103,
-0.0258846022,
-0.0209453665,
0.0277143605,
-0.0000189613,
-0.0417626351,
-0.0134420162,
-0.0273077935,
-0.0422674417,
-0.0215866603,
0.0649620742,
0.0256242566,
0.0019661777,
0.0180722643,
0.0060750279,
0.0127354851,
-0.0829152092,
-0.0147481011,
-0.0250679906,
0.0643003955,
0.0030533385,
-0.00781168,
0.0865759552,
-0.0355302207,
-0.0286654159,
0.00239571,
-0.0020454007,
-0.0079472996,
0.0196872633,
-0.0240083057,
0.015450228,
-0.0330477692,
0.0098964786,
-0.0123616969,
0.0027344462,
-0.0522434525,
0.0293973088,
0.0658190772,
-0.0597171709,
-0.0367406793,
-0.0490778275,
0.0733415857,
-0.0103748087,
0.007677441,
-0.0456245244,
-0.0167957228,
0.0414608009,
0.033237569,
0.007853305,
0.0644785985,
0.0342124701,
-0.0676165223,
0.0227414165,
0.0185331646,
0.0093937013,
-0.0323759243,
-0.0167076215,
0.0183028523,
-0.0945313871,
-0.0192989744,
0.0041680238,
0.0389873348,
-0.0321432091,
0.0225927141,
0.044398725,
0.0169932675,
-0.0227012932,
-0.0150898965,
-0.0275109801,
-0.010322826,
0.0390522927,
0.0151837002,
-0.0674970448,
0.0085107023,
-0.0123495953,
-0.0303779896,
-0.0709430873,
-0.0691999123,
-0.0030543052,
-0.1124993339,
0.0372435898,
-0.0456518382,
0.0074428152,
-0.0302258674,
-0.0750378445,
-0.0028407485,
-0.0016748115,
-0.0175930634,
-0.04786814,
-0.0510379337,
0.0211817622,
0.0416007005,
-0.0640270263,
-0.0393911712,
0.0123999948,
-0.0548002943,
0.0401317328,
0.0048652594,
0.0793726593,
-0.0637869686,
-0.0142469471,
-0.008668947,
-0.0153215053,
-0.0072234189,
0.0034615772,
0.0565853044,
0.0165258087,
0.0144963721,
-0.0253505185,
-0.0094559006,
-0.0332767852,
0.0045215418,
0.0138046117,
0.0787689164,
0.0155939776,
0.0004101047,
-0.0371881016,
0.014847598,
-0.0251584947,
0.0265219063,
-0.0049784589,
-0.0105896899,
-0.0326826833,
-0.0665847212,
0.0209057722,
-0.0143271014,
-0.0813942552,
-0.0063005742,
-0.0325975642,
-0.0193545185,
-0.0201228969,
-0.0435172692,
0.02032548,
-0.0118553052,
0.0264943335,
0.0612535253,
0.0588425435,
-0.0039039527,
-0.0509373918,
0.0201331973,
-0.0083411792,
0.0326383151,
0.0391898975,
-0.0217504334,
0.0019676324,
0.0430918038,
-0.031063702,
0.0302141067,
0.0183964223,
-0.033612933,
0.0038815259,
-0.0167117603,
0.0182035174,
-0.0037268321,
-0.0074760392,
-0.0290733166,
0.0123364776,
0.0901887715,
-0.0246434286,
-0.0053712255,
0.0165997148,
-0.0345844962,
0.0149949649,
-0.0207152236,
-0.0280794222,
-0.0342254452,
0.0079991771,
-0.0055538751,
-0.0136277769,
-0.0116925053,
-0.0105763404,
0.0015579105,
0.0411698148,
-0.0536034778,
0.0442558527,
-0.0036931632,
-0.0643735304,
0.020020213,
-0.0072297282,
-0.0010192003,
-0.0305611026,
-0.0001407224,
0.0168239325,
-0.0189129412,
0.0840144157,
-0.0193896815,
0.046743989,
-0.0309228376,
0.0658250377,
-0.0001217314,
0.0915589258,
-0.0234507602,
-0.0248608366,
-0.0027914857,
-0.0410060734,
-0.0194310881,
0.038914185,
0.0275570583,
0.0069424179,
-0.0002256572,
-0.0212533884,
0.012480597,
0.0053358162,
-0.0973350108,
-0.0367404893,
0.0252602659,
-0.0276591238,
0.0436105654,
-0.0015442281,
0.0412472785,
-0.0313023366,
0.0055412375,
0.0062760431,
0.016882224,
0.0122510502,
0.0050663622,
0.0141667286,
0.0126780327,
-0.0467350259,
-0.0104956878,
0.038813848,
0.045000419,
-0.0013406464,
0.0233153068,
-0.0320468619,
0.0279395804,
-0.0400309414,
-0.0450523421,
0.0555330999,
0.0193608347,
0.0226140209,
-0.0461406633,
-0.0312080756,
0.020837279,
-0.0433504805,
0.043839965,
-0.0530647412,
0.0223916303,
-0.00466904,
0.0106275231,
-0.0167712849,
-0.0494226962,
0.0557713546,
-0.0042934222,
-0.0329478346,
-0.0191550311,
-5.859442977e-33,
0.0104545895,
-0.0527904183,
-0.0039999234,
-0.003317998,
-0.0337112211,
0.0131199546,
-0.0207764283,
0.0412099957,
-0.0647630244,
0.0138665931,
-0.0602663346,
-0.0016895564,
0.0058910791,
-0.000452447,
0.0924605504,
0.0115537476,
0.0153654916,
-0.0005373704,
0.0103665171,
-0.0198984277,
0.0175793972,
-0.0104551036,
0.093099229,
-0.1549683809,
0.0724544674,
0.0244897921,
0.0051182513,
-0.0479367077,
0.0784222409,
0.00343274,
-0.0151559077,
0.0650511384,
0.0193422642,
-0.1048977822,
-0.0098415473,
0.0099816201,
-0.05623357,
-0.0270882118,
0.0624373741,
-0.0028100291,
0.0140248211,
-0.0229878724,
0.0384981036,
0.0079749674,
-0.03583261,
-0.0159879439,
0.0831195042,
-0.0197687,
0.0142146777,
-0.0407721549,
-0.062404003,
0.0189406052,
-0.0469387993,
0.0809072778,
-0.0121840108,
0.0424596183,
-0.0051823026,
0.0684473068,
-0.0903996974,
0.0111368364,
-0.0090262871,
0.0122602247,
0.0073683523,
-0.0504955351,
0.0184999518,
0.054955326,
-0.0184430331,
-0.0140662342,
0.0326895975,
-0.0645647198,
0.0090494221,
0.0472534373,
-0.0157002416,
0.0825538933,
0.0563218668,
-0.0259833261,
-0.0429805368,
0.0117364358,
0.039944604,
0.0108189713,
0.0128399916,
-0.0094913663,
-0.0071328939,
-0.0466309674,
0.0157753229,
-0.0437831357,
0.0252286252,
-0.0168416314,
-0.0230283272,
-0.0401033461,
0.0186229926,
0.0432822108,
0.0234915689,
-0.0743589401,
-0.0593087673,
0.0416108929,
-0.005793578,
0.0526497811,
0.020325752,
-0.0276378337,
-0.0944702923,
-0.0250364486,
-0.0232199747,
0.0510331653,
0.0404582396,
-0.0192859247,
0.0155066662,
-0.0173466541,
-0.0328811742,
-0.0261827856,
-0.0091669997,
0.0192436483,
0.0178996939,
0.0278087296,
0.014309912,
0.0409562662,
0.0254453197,
-0.0284452382,
0.0747325271,
0.044558838,
0.0021863212,
0.0094767911,
-0.0356226973,
0.0051058093,
-0.0334242508,
-0.0416794457,
-0.0353759974,
0.0593807586,
0.0291436408,
-0.0330672264,
-0.0319471955,
-0.0713796616,
2.541e-7,
0.0639999509,
0.0269920342,
-0.0127339326,
-0.0159769319,
0.0337409712,
0.0363392308,
0.0235180948,
0.0378328562,
0.0336543173,
0.0126341125,
-0.0459351912,
-0.0325712562,
-0.0185459908,
0.0222002584,
-0.0899363831,
-0.0239792243,
-0.0436583236,
-0.0149984993,
-0.0454516821,
0.0185980555,
-0.0191100929,
0.0021468755,
0.010720823,
0.0166281275,
-0.0565927625,
-0.0265156906,
-0.0019136723,
-0.0241555609,
0.0677058101,
0.0127969049,
-0.0010062928,
0.0202201046,
0.0423873104,
0.0165314786,
-0.0128954547,
0.0170572437,
-0.0081080087,
-0.0367106237,
-0.0136539284,
0.0141741894,
0.0292382836,
-0.0374748409,
0.0115214149,
-0.049985949,
0.0106554739,
-0.0107052913,
-0.0649299249,
-0.0683152229,
-0.0610791706,
-0.0055657588,
0.0232150778,
0.0012738925,
-0.0225544572,
0.013739381,
-0.0262532849,
-0.0225863531,
-0.0273809601,
-0.0500504225,
0.0004937825,
0.040189974,
0.0025462026,
-0.0542714149,
0.0118445717,
-0.0156728178,
0.0522339121,
-0.0281690434,
0.0344296135,
1.946380102e-34,
0.023010103,
0.005024543,
0.0279160682,
0.0522889681,
0.0366163291,
0.0292343255,
-0.0527358577,
0.0126559576,
0.0064656632,
0.0110263536,
0.0000555577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14868v1 | Assessing Step-by-Step Reasoning against Lexical Negation: A Case Study on Syllogism | 2023-10-23T12:40:41 | 2023-10-23T12:40:41 | Mengyu Ye, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Jun Suzuki, Goro Kobayashi, Hiroaki Funayama | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) take advantage of step-by-step reasoning
instructions, e.g., chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. Building on this, their
ability to perform CoT-style reasoning robustly is of interest from a probing
perspective. In this study, we inspect the step-by-step reasoning ability of
LLMs with a focus on negation, which is a core linguistic phenomenon that is
difficult to process. In particular, we introduce several controlled settings
(e.g., reasoning in case of fictional entities) to evaluate the logical
reasoning abilities of the models. We observed that dozens of modern LLMs were
not robust against lexical negation (e.g., plausible ->implausible) when
performing CoT-style reasoning, and the results highlight unique limitations in
each LLM family. | [
0.046656251,
0.005928576,
-0.024328012,
0.046876777,
-0.0739212111,
0.0311838388,
0.043750871,
-0.0146509772,
0.006474969,
-0.0460722633,
-0.0033751726,
-0.0295535829,
0.0060724774,
0.0055445004,
0.0141843492,
-0.0039411713,
0.0497231856,
-0.0339294672,
0.0273292996,
-0.0183387548,
-0.0398886316,
0.0404078588,
-0.0403235555,
-0.0069649266,
0.0134611167,
-0.0401096493,
-0.0255188812,
0.0317635685,
0.0119247241,
-0.0625184402,
-0.0464241728,
0.0452225246,
-0.0166906063,
0.0791541412,
0.0000021045,
-0.0737121031,
0.0184234921,
-0.0040987623,
-0.0413929224,
0.0142968791,
0.0034794759,
0.0017508194,
-0.0207512826,
-0.0047431998,
0.0002124868,
0.031834729,
0.0301541071,
0.0591053255,
0.0332406014,
0.0516618714,
0.005609904,
-0.035322085,
-0.0109586343,
-0.0200254619,
0.004345587,
-0.0116402097,
0.0059704999,
0.0035440258,
0.0339927673,
-0.0104580009,
-0.0271971636,
0.0480764359,
0.0418982096,
0.0158993062,
-0.0528377779,
0.0320179798,
-0.0154015627,
-0.0507830083,
0.0309878048,
0.0476509966,
0.0182217639,
-0.0456875227,
-0.0174767114,
0.0118983025,
-0.0075630392,
0.0401675254,
-0.0051618628,
0.0468708165,
-0.0107995812,
0.0006480709,
0.0389511287,
-0.0000150994,
0.0403443277,
-0.0003378015,
-0.0611825697,
0.1057098582,
0.0077145603,
-0.0412927791,
0.0232998393,
-0.0004803606,
-0.0322131701,
-0.0675706714,
-0.0067860154,
0.0234116204,
-0.0455560088,
0.0470951013,
0.0166077279,
0.0286056735,
0.0432593115,
-0.0475550406,
0.0094849104,
0.0184506401,
0.0203446262,
0.0721653178,
-0.0409844071,
-0.0069275037,
-0.0377884433,
0.0306355599,
0.0089271208,
0.0157445055,
-0.0406332687,
-0.0262879357,
-0.0128233321,
0.0569627471,
-0.0365993157,
-0.0068517136,
0.018403722,
-0.0326787271,
-0.03877059,
0.0332530886,
-0.0037574195,
0.020002177,
0.0314846635,
-0.035576161,
-0.0915183574,
-0.0124121541,
-0.0508617051,
0.0399946235,
-0.0154546406,
-0.0201927889,
-0.000537488,
-0.0328977145,
-0.0202063676,
-0.0173855182,
0.0320165157,
0.0318237357,
0.011854806,
-0.0047102398,
-0.0326572992,
-0.0327829942,
-0.0070163812,
-0.1203915104,
-0.0186901018,
-0.0609094389,
-0.0338297859,
0.0308225341,
0.0194139387,
-0.0197080914,
0.0205323528,
0.0220648348,
-0.0397238024,
0.090578042,
-0.0107817678,
-0.0101871733,
-0.0285898186,
0.0251361169,
0.0134446081,
0.0410248563,
0.0319941454,
0.0141107291,
0.0121068489,
0.0426928699,
-0.0141395861,
-0.0002955449,
0.0100166444,
-0.0002605217,
-0.0576840043,
0.0200881213,
-0.0494051725,
0.0172713343,
-0.0137091698,
0.0581501201,
-0.0122379465,
-0.0348850563,
0.0386580788,
0.0170726795,
0.0124731082,
0.0232705902,
0.0718142614,
-0.0526631102,
0.0130430125,
-0.0010786245,
-0.0731086433,
0.0266582835,
-0.0455298424,
-0.0018026688,
-0.0336135849,
-0.0140586905,
-0.0119794365,
-0.0371150337,
-0.0261492822,
0.0188778304,
0.0203847196,
0.0022183612,
0.0574088842,
0.0197102148,
-0.0397788212,
0.023682056,
0.0023269008,
-0.0506430641,
-0.0200066399,
-0.0315846205,
0.0417688675,
0.0267925244,
0.0660398081,
-0.0108770952,
-0.0404856354,
0.0149262408,
0.0023759948,
0.0623962171,
0.0027865579,
0.0082283234,
-0.0119772702,
-0.0242154747,
0.0036668289,
-0.0129531808,
0.0364943147,
0.0247560982,
-0.0312000792,
0.0321817584,
0.0003609736,
-0.0056547681,
0.0360041931,
0.0255926978,
-0.0426753461,
-0.0071980306,
-0.0388076194,
0.0011976162,
0.0243138727,
0.0282086059,
-0.0126946922,
0.0306176823,
0.0372864082,
-0.0301507171,
-0.0332005396,
0.0082861353,
-0.0368466936,
-0.0423441716,
0.0489037372,
-0.0400108881,
-0.0050236732,
0.0218779873,
-0.001058884,
-0.0233562104,
0.0202143583,
-0.0130478088,
0.0314312354,
-0.0390183739,
0.0650892481,
-0.0233370475,
-0.0120241996,
-0.0175629687,
0.0970184803,
-0.0160218086,
0.0562722273,
0.0369726866,
0.0480208583,
0.0372704826,
-0.0368397087,
-0.0251408089,
0.0374088958,
0.0272551812,
-0.0256167594,
0.0012487172,
-0.0253762268,
-0.0447007008,
-0.0270671789,
-0.0687684417,
-0.0176925063,
-0.0004950138,
0.023397658,
0.0182226747,
-0.0460272953,
0.0054689622,
0.0004220887,
0.0055460539,
0.0198089723,
0.0198312569,
0.0105417361,
0.0030070911,
-0.0344900228,
-0.0631940737,
0.0088104289,
-0.0004620425,
-0.0167928636,
0.0418704189,
0.0050146347,
0.0253485292,
-0.0135123674,
0.0407613069,
-0.1038341522,
0.0011886174,
-0.0027425932,
-0.0063442416,
0.0400230587,
0.0038667028,
-0.0349198282,
0.0284225568,
-0.0126650333,
-0.0190071166,
0.0688048974,
-0.0414587669,
0.0058924495,
0.0139780641,
0.0151214534,
0.0229319818,
-0.0383247957,
-0.0454618186,
-0.0461544208,
0.071646601,
0.0015712471,
-0.0016761293,
-0.0487290882,
0.042917259,
-0.0023966406,
-0.024823403,
0.0190850012,
-0.0228651501,
-0.0034806838,
0.09821821,
-0.0091638686,
-0.0027552913,
0.0584488064,
-0.0287002958,
-0.0014854782,
-0.0249570794,
0.0231112987,
-0.0248631313,
0.0825387463,
-0.0094030797,
0.0073632919,
0.0413742885,
0.0181222018,
-0.0339695141,
-0.0490816943,
0.0300996415,
-0.0173532311,
0.032654766,
-0.0328686759,
0.0061798687,
0.0010510845,
0.0062625729,
-0.0428785533,
0.0032732193,
-0.0724569559,
-0.0044958079,
-0.0273009632,
-0.0031993075,
-0.0220219754,
-0.0023592585,
0.0053929621,
0.0143328523,
0.0334945545,
-0.0211420432,
-0.0227231961,
-0.0001196453,
0.0409107134,
0.0016033819,
0.0705490932,
-0.0159639437,
0.0495068841,
0.0684147999,
0.0143671008,
0.0238975454,
-0.0111607853,
0.0055159028,
-0.0213532057,
-0.0095476834,
-0.0229826439,
0.0081060017,
-0.0178576242,
-0.037570633,
-0.0092174783,
0.1116151959,
0.0662373081,
0.006467842,
0.0361415558,
-0.0375165977,
0.0490157232,
0.0339324549,
-0.0211789291,
-0.0711935237,
-0.021692805,
0.0291259233,
-0.0267829783,
-0.0397638418,
-0.0829604194,
-0.0369085632,
-0.0958502963,
0.0367263295,
-0.0083758282,
0.0238261521,
-0.0063975374,
-0.0475347452,
0.0181882996,
-0.0030550603,
-0.0267652366,
0.0557634011,
0.0000573942,
-0.0004651882,
-0.0501645431,
0.0254584309,
0.0282448679,
0.0479808636,
-0.0211486407,
0.0268709902,
-0.0029232779,
0.0366719067,
0.0017701132,
-0.0139977485,
0.0499081612,
-0.0416046418,
-0.0138264047,
-0.0373020209,
0.016814081,
0.0153101701,
0.0202235859,
-0.0455726646,
-0.0058519198,
-0.0291591026,
-0.0436289981,
0.0194556806,
0.0974030569,
-0.0293671973,
-0.0507324226,
-0.0419556983,
0.0478513539,
-0.031992279,
0.0835562721,
0.0122278119,
-0.0066033825,
-0.068926543,
-0.007292808,
-0.0528401546,
0.0428125933,
-0.044188641,
-0.0033455549,
0.0303423293,
-0.0065336633,
-0.0631395951,
-0.053158585,
-0.0162321106,
0.0609053597,
-0.0081656892,
0.0203800518,
0.0326103196,
-0.0049567297,
-0.0135563677,
-0.0131536843,
-0.0252208859,
0.0394210406,
-0.0131155755,
0.0652855113,
0.0055659725,
-0.025724804,
0.0005644271,
0.0217268262,
-0.0446872227,
-0.0398474224,
-0.0227783192,
-0.0016089636,
0.0424939021,
-0.0049058204,
-0.0460816808,
-0.0170577224,
0.0586259253,
0.0364187472,
-0.0053080572,
0.0402158052,
0.0434587859,
-0.0010530488,
0.0121937152,
0.0465377197,
0.0166514218,
0.0433300994,
0.0138720525,
0.0640582219,
-0.0418965779,
-0.0063347495,
0.0202381313,
0.0135591906,
0.0044679591,
0.0133522451,
-0.0170679688,
-0.0018577636,
0.0375843868,
-0.052926749,
-0.039089933,
-0.0099202422,
0.0199275445,
0.0130497199,
-0.0104881125,
-0.0318400562,
-0.0643446073,
-0.0497026816,
0.0442807712,
0.0251110438,
-0.0078867897,
0.027060926,
0.0184620749,
0.0050697397,
-0.0395305455,
-0.0063622328,
-0.0093526021,
-0.0594784394,
0.050916519,
0.000571701,
0.0741720796,
0.0352558158,
-0.0126474639,
-0.0696562976,
0.0027332348,
-0.0665739551,
-0.0042925104,
0.0492403358,
0.0245350115,
0.0358605683,
0.0015963974,
0.0351901762,
-0.0558345579,
-0.0047221053,
0.013712015,
-0.0019069047,
0.0492697433,
-0.0181476511,
0.0139467334,
0.020030411,
0.002471772,
0.0180011764,
-0.0012262503,
-0.0037732332,
0.0169575699,
0.0288270768,
-0.0337826572,
-0.0326430127,
-0.0810452551,
-0.0737048388,
0.0104515003,
-0.0092833107,
0.0140260309,
-0.1346388459,
-0.0898746699,
0.0008620754,
0.0074273944,
0.0194946509,
-0.0253567975,
-0.0162584819,
0.0743414834,
0.0208578054,
-0.0296516363,
-0.0210525244,
0.0082475487,
0.0174583439,
0.0024020665,
-0.0299173594,
-6.064830493e-33,
-0.0192476586,
-0.0232240949,
0.0235116892,
-0.0049180724,
-0.0074928044,
-0.0159407668,
-0.0599209554,
0.0244820546,
-0.0137681868,
0.0514019392,
-0.0080704819,
0.019079145,
0.0073953248,
-0.0156407245,
-0.038678173,
0.0018481222,
0.0235946607,
0.0338362046,
-0.0316518769,
-0.0163827688,
0.0456470326,
-0.0166696347,
0.0076712393,
-0.0765247047,
0.0400071405,
-0.0092156967,
-0.0160150919,
0.0154235978,
-0.0697893575,
0.0231758859,
-0.0117337173,
-0.0140632195,
0.0300812777,
-0.0393136777,
0.0314665474,
-0.0274241101,
-0.0467289016,
0.0051101968,
0.0778024048,
-0.0508450232,
-0.0240397118,
-0.0198190343,
-0.0009833445,
0.0345434025,
-0.0280058198,
-0.0154891629,
0.0098942416,
-0.0278590675,
0.0137326401,
0.0236439072,
-0.0916221514,
0.0338490419,
0.0040192474,
-0.0211363845,
-0.0042686383,
0.0295360051,
-0.0261995252,
-0.0186978616,
-0.0567477681,
0.0273846574,
0.0024470747,
-0.0513322689,
0.0586817935,
-0.0110911727,
-0.0207096916,
0.0555135198,
0.0403667763,
0.0026064904,
-0.0672784448,
0.0333339572,
0.0183641184,
0.0577063672,
0.0765932202,
0.0370455235,
0.036316894,
0.0421824269,
-0.0724724531,
-0.046706818,
0.0045741149,
0.0600075535,
0.0839034393,
-0.0306457896,
-0.0342380665,
-0.0079160258,
-0.0497380644,
-0.0227491446,
-0.0384937674,
-0.0139233787,
0.0120395711,
-0.0092100473,
-0.0407789722,
-0.0058062067,
0.010354965,
-0.0044841249,
-0.0147303715,
0.0523623228,
0.0057171821,
0.0105928099,
0.014844154,
0.0477873422,
-0.0262861755,
0.0354608297,
0.0321037844,
0.013604302,
-0.0074914456,
-0.0140781142,
0.0105772996,
0.0047198655,
-0.0562862195,
-0.0063222335,
-0.0464824699,
0.0018577967,
-0.0346191786,
-0.012157375,
0.0510568246,
-0.0078752087,
-0.0036233491,
-0.0269136224,
0.0142888399,
-0.032005962,
-0.054662969,
0.0983334333,
-0.0136827091,
0.0052052387,
-0.0139578301,
-0.0381552316,
-0.0377129577,
0.0143123586,
0.0420523733,
-0.0755833834,
-0.0054089525,
0.0108545097,
2.788e-7,
-0.0150822485,
0.0354458131,
0.0003603098,
0.042685166,
0.0371319726,
0.0512316525,
-0.0238451976,
-0.0073661073,
0.0333916098,
-0.0860688463,
-0.0097299945,
0.0378838703,
0.0054379054,
0.0506677032,
-0.0243572332,
0.0177749358,
-0.0476117767,
-0.0239113346,
-0.055748757,
0.019135125,
0.0467700213,
0.0653049275,
0.0492467694,
-0.0188667383,
0.0189769026,
-0.0485074855,
0.0225585159,
0.0091555044,
0.0190444943,
-0.0122750448,
0.0192858689,
-0.0267530866,
0.0261939559,
0.0461150631,
0.0310629979,
0.0222779494,
-0.0320203863,
0.0400178134,
-0.0272255018,
-0.0070023392,
-0.0187574234,
-0.0567017868,
-0.0152776968,
-0.0996701047,
0.1013623327,
0.0023458626,
-0.0251534991,
0.0380980968,
-0.0084911697,
0.0172941536,
0.0024759832,
0.0318426155,
-0.035761673,
0.0024598704,
0.0185036398,
-0.0163624231,
-0.0043788585,
-0.0875495747,
-0.0326450095,
0.0276313275,
-0.0324841887,
-0.0656831637,
-0.006204051,
0.0215917546,
0.031802699,
-0.0830848292,
-0.0094559137,
2.759269343e-34,
0.0421567187,
-0.0085756658,
0.0275789984,
-0.0033831291,
0.0584889427,
0.0116091762,
0.0071981181,
0.0089679556,
0.0560944565,
-0.0888994634,
0.0036051429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14863v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14863v2 | Paraphrase Types for Generation and Detection | 2023-10-23T12:32:41 | 2024-07-01T12:32:37 | Jan Philip Wahle, Bela Gipp, Terry Ruas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current approaches in paraphrase generation and detection heavily rely on a
single general similarity score, ignoring the intricate linguistic properties
of language. This paper introduces two new tasks to address this shortcoming by
considering paraphrase types - specific linguistic perturbations at particular
text positions. We name these tasks Paraphrase Type Generation and Paraphrase
Type Detection. Our results suggest that while current techniques perform well
in a binary classification scenario, i.e., paraphrased or not, the inclusion of
fine-grained paraphrase types poses a significant challenge. While most
approaches are good at generating and detecting general semantic similar
content, they fail to understand the intrinsic linguistic variables they
manipulate. Models trained in generating and identifying paraphrase types also
show improvements in tasks without them. In addition, scaling these models
further improves their ability to understand paraphrase types. We believe
paraphrase types can unlock a new paradigm for developing paraphrase models and
solving tasks in the future. | [
0.080300048,
0.0264135469,
-0.0036171356,
0.0589163862,
-0.0468585677,
0.0196716134,
-0.0105259577,
0.0621884689,
-0.0287475642,
-0.0990035906,
0.025623899,
0.0313224643,
-0.0054880925,
-0.0250496864,
0.0289209597,
-0.0546246693,
0.0399808958,
0.0140884975,
-0.0069100983,
0.0314164683,
0.0153467031,
0.0534191839,
0.0225780699,
0.0660442114,
0.0335537158,
-0.0116703846,
0.0162417088,
0.0287454184,
0.0085968599,
0.0033327627,
0.0477177463,
-0.0018319942,
0.0342582315,
0.0444303676,
0.0000014389,
-0.0357287563,
-0.0150365764,
-0.0278034341,
0.0041258782,
0.0033965874,
0.0826973692,
-0.0285741873,
0.0402690023,
0.0401428379,
-0.0062176739,
-0.0325195342,
0.0091992207,
0.0317712314,
0.0509160683,
0.0290749967,
-0.0080443192,
-0.0431265011,
-0.0219674688,
0.0273211114,
-0.0069034682,
-0.0036617587,
0.0054153795,
-0.0339934118,
-0.0179157853,
0.0480191559,
0.0275148079,
0.0020664069,
-0.0313349329,
0.0564742647,
-0.000611963,
0.0068526408,
-0.0286496766,
-0.0111280484,
-0.0024078186,
0.0367948078,
-0.0487793759,
-0.0735512748,
0.0425489284,
-0.0149369519,
0.0122971423,
0.0368371382,
-0.0196295362,
0.013065286,
-0.0372836031,
0.0239274371,
0.0190021154,
0.034757074,
-0.0266178697,
0.044296179,
-0.0093047591,
-0.0030569155,
0.0206684992,
-0.0182033982,
-0.0244069733,
0.0010570018,
-0.0435501263,
-0.0173740685,
-0.0138973584,
0.0188739747,
0.0130859483,
-0.0048895315,
-0.0734723806,
-0.0509398989,
0.0819479525,
-0.0681355819,
0.0552750826,
-0.0062456313,
0.0084887967,
0.0149586005,
-0.0507560149,
0.0361299552,
-0.0248589348,
0.0528934039,
-0.0323936306,
-0.0180660971,
-0.0431644954,
-0.003001749,
-0.0665562302,
0.0578406639,
0.018380899,
-0.05465471,
-0.0427426994,
0.0202710014,
0.056283582,
0.0296708439,
0.0089642806,
0.0597111322,
-0.0271765012,
0.013036469,
0.0182746612,
-0.0271157287,
-0.0344243124,
0.0526764467,
-0.0205539949,
-0.0299039651,
-0.006902298,
0.0587039627,
0.0475779697,
-0.0448254459,
0.0145660527,
0.0258377232,
-0.0049139098,
-0.0345393158,
-0.0625074506,
-0.0638817325,
-0.0389080383,
-0.0525424667,
-0.0138636651,
-0.0587033257,
0.000524351,
0.0179316849,
-0.0080739614,
-0.0027640967,
0.0233479477,
0.0241184719,
-0.0502755046,
0.0428812169,
0.0123999771,
-0.0372738913,
-0.0029563915,
-0.0164081268,
-0.0177458376,
-0.0008905097,
0.0165260229,
0.0304958876,
0.0649414286,
0.0164648723,
-0.0060938764,
-0.0121584227,
0.0210601836,
0.0105019854,
-0.019453207,
0.0188890714,
-0.0004818817,
0.0172904115,
-0.0021697702,
0.0412696414,
-0.029396411,
-0.0537282005,
0.0582898185,
0.0605039597,
-0.0282657985,
0.0594568327,
0.0822319537,
0.0609225184,
-0.0083640385,
0.0477778465,
-0.003992198,
-0.022535786,
-0.0079916706,
0.0431856439,
-0.0011102062,
0.0453292429,
-0.0300797373,
-0.0231964216,
-0.0576086454,
-0.0126054808,
-0.015860416,
-0.0474044234,
-0.0314596072,
0.043332845,
-0.0388785973,
0.0678793639,
-0.0466156602,
-0.0598709881,
-0.0332689062,
-0.0427991115,
-0.0012080435,
0.0554279014,
0.0434912965,
-0.0076881698,
-0.0023147999,
-0.0246869884,
0.0168028958,
0.0396020748,
0.0309310444,
-0.0052798302,
0.0145737575,
-0.037410453,
0.0114536872,
-0.0406490192,
0.0424239524,
-0.0252244938,
0.0107829859,
-0.0075395857,
0.0304255262,
-0.0309785027,
-0.0622585341,
0.0454156846,
0.036230728,
-0.0264528189,
0.0099227279,
-0.0005790039,
0.0147373956,
-0.0046026991,
0.0093248114,
0.0312990807,
-0.0085708499,
-0.0672323406,
-0.0378486365,
0.0731734559,
0.0223862175,
-0.0478522331,
-0.0030325938,
-0.0305930767,
0.0154054025,
0.0237146635,
-0.0334460437,
-0.0128968544,
0.0348445475,
-0.0659786761,
0.0501702316,
-0.0763533786,
0.0271508601,
-0.0485972427,
0.0149076898,
-0.0275910348,
0.0739893615,
0.0058529098,
0.0111720199,
-0.0152721079,
-0.0323818587,
0.0672219396,
0.004982057,
-0.0051226332,
-0.0305890292,
0.0151396412,
0.0005430122,
0.0163024273,
0.0033415554,
-0.0441830344,
-0.036500033,
-0.0931147039,
0.0031482151,
-0.0200317465,
0.0001195971,
0.0495396778,
-0.0039696824,
0.0095034977,
-0.0148880389,
-0.0004182295,
0.0135424687,
0.0282159224,
0.0283794831,
0.0801685527,
0.0059962384,
-0.0028711285,
-0.0713109821,
0.030294342,
-0.0393286981,
0.0719101131,
0.0280011073,
0.0149006136,
-0.0609719232,
0.0226480942,
-0.0249474291,
-0.0059543718,
0.0426068194,
-0.0341157913,
0.0007151507,
-0.0089306142,
0.0177397318,
0.0452157669,
0.0431245267,
-0.0046045398,
0.0237429999,
0.0374642424,
-0.0768145546,
-0.0157535207,
-0.0126532158,
-0.0304352399,
0.0075183427,
-0.0467144102,
0.0377474315,
0.0508339107,
0.0486359969,
-0.0154457493,
-0.0714696497,
0.0627331138,
0.030688215,
0.0295463763,
-0.011649482,
-0.0018957368,
-0.0146874562,
-0.0188126899,
-0.0188280884,
-0.0260269493,
0.0582769364,
-0.0384277403,
0.0247372631,
-0.0673544183,
-0.0512815379,
-0.0450790599,
0.0340199172,
-0.0168126356,
0.0515937358,
0.0042930562,
-0.0014242324,
-0.0419794805,
-0.0065452545,
0.0411184765,
-0.009525137,
0.0452050529,
-0.0301986225,
0.0138185294,
-0.0024188526,
-0.0540037751,
-0.0440425463,
-0.0798192099,
-0.0070936773,
-0.0097755659,
-0.0167865586,
-0.0193445329,
-0.006393346,
-0.0157333594,
-0.026230095,
0.0397042222,
-0.0275000725,
-0.0123465629,
-0.0612892658,
0.0694090724,
0.0835328475,
0.028503783,
-0.0097117675,
-0.0071911332,
0.0066094836,
0.0170201305,
0.0162911527,
0.0522116758,
-0.0444125682,
-0.0362367518,
-0.002737744,
-0.0367771573,
-0.0268179663,
-0.0130609805,
-0.0062133507,
-0.0201635584,
-0.0228968244,
0.089289166,
0.0411666818,
-0.0177445691,
0.0003227967,
-0.0195090938,
0.0574051924,
0.0153597705,
0.0041501275,
-0.0281984527,
-0.0442747623,
-0.0484824292,
-0.0212996732,
-0.0318217836,
0.0045055351,
-0.023871582,
-0.0391503125,
0.0189616121,
-0.0070729931,
-0.0226264633,
-0.0366366059,
0.0214861948,
-0.0273599699,
0.0184784848,
-0.02043253,
-0.0222031251,
-0.0615921281,
0.0205927193,
-0.0091960235,
-0.0055777105,
-0.0188121833,
-0.0114547368,
-0.077917777,
-0.0275718439,
0.0191310886,
0.0581127554,
0.0179361906,
0.0040000053,
-0.0081413249,
-0.0669602454,
-0.0119319083,
0.019367829,
0.0456757173,
-0.0143238576,
0.0254369322,
0.0143353045,
0.0269624423,
-0.0344487093,
0.0154619869,
0.0162463859,
0.0295268949,
-0.0131266844,
-0.0449647494,
-0.0481293611,
0.0512791127,
-0.0046300613,
0.1064511985,
0.040733207,
-0.0050725588,
-0.066405721,
0.0181904901,
0.0331751443,
-0.0889717489,
-0.0350423194,
-0.0055791731,
0.0045422269,
0.0533450581,
-0.1083609238,
-0.0192476436,
-0.0389198996,
-0.019304717,
-0.0096063334,
0.0495103411,
-0.0270612817,
-0.017928239,
-0.0670286715,
-0.0258100517,
0.0083557013,
-0.0070209159,
0.0273880381,
-0.0143385343,
0.0750954077,
-0.0064073023,
-0.031963557,
0.0340898484,
-0.1323385388,
-0.0295413248,
-0.0288731568,
0.0168094821,
0.0132584199,
0.0163944475,
0.0108082397,
0.0022443517,
0.0395422913,
0.0210211147,
-0.0164641012,
0.0333786011,
0.0086985566,
0.0359191895,
-0.0091399504,
0.0573111475,
-0.0164049268,
-0.0268655345,
-0.0007360682,
0.0159039032,
-0.0481071249,
-0.0289805681,
0.0539961904,
-0.0154492781,
-0.0054045091,
0.0007885164,
0.0175889768,
-0.0071662394,
0.0242987368,
0.0210973993,
-0.0193450172,
-0.0384506881,
0.0167688914,
0.0247160345,
0.0191230867,
-0.0274441522,
0.0165744871,
-0.0459172688,
0.0890576914,
-0.0152053051,
-0.0183344204,
-0.0297994744,
0.0346859992,
-0.0525332242,
-0.029365439,
-0.0524898767,
0.0532365032,
-0.0416697636,
0.0057578301,
-0.0007889916,
0.0434059352,
0.0101111857,
-0.0477784052,
-0.0798156559,
0.0465662442,
-0.0471386313,
-0.0477262177,
-0.0273197051,
0.025921084,
0.0297015868,
-0.0143156145,
0.0399545096,
-0.0341570303,
-0.0325659178,
0.0109625496,
0.0461217277,
-0.0251174495,
0.0055498388,
0.0159982108,
0.0062028458,
-0.0303188711,
-0.0027478007,
0.0565034114,
0.0607682392,
0.035573788,
-0.0016163539,
-0.0299629066,
-0.0248329584,
-0.0386764221,
0.0358659551,
0.0284161288,
0.029062666,
0.0428244658,
-0.0720739812,
-0.0211038515,
0.0310246777,
0.0048230523,
0.0218461752,
-0.0095101362,
0.0395177044,
0.0434703417,
-0.0160720889,
-0.0540635586,
-0.0697632357,
0.0296940953,
0.0000728204,
-0.0072888471,
-0.0816534609,
-5.484479748e-33,
0.0022458558,
-0.011740935,
-0.0122507252,
0.0047871326,
0.0217929929,
-0.0260817204,
0.0069671418,
-0.046161186,
-0.0068379426,
-0.0041450146,
0.0219216645,
0.0224989727,
0.0081479922,
0.0287479665,
0.0304663926,
-0.0375167616,
0.0692023188,
-0.0147041157,
-0.0312926248,
0.0043290672,
0.0538548045,
-0.0197811741,
0.0131783225,
-0.0583950356,
-0.0242273044,
-0.0475427508,
-0.0081531079,
-0.0161400624,
0.0061525591,
0.0716109872,
0.0005451243,
0.042501796,
0.0278481673,
0.0236904994,
0.0056674392,
0.0126926759,
-0.0348764807,
0.0016046097,
0.0009575748,
-0.0200645328,
-0.0530616716,
-0.0770124868,
0.0373365283,
-0.0501319431,
-0.0033074277,
0.0073534586,
0.0552592427,
-0.0199096277,
0.0345413759,
-0.0071884566,
-0.0614629239,
-0.006617466,
0.0196980182,
0.0474764444,
-0.0328884423,
0.0785256624,
-0.0151426401,
0.0820477456,
-0.0253220238,
0.0253749415,
-0.0113666989,
0.0187797714,
-0.0311244447,
-0.0205991045,
-0.006190992,
0.034109775,
-0.0289813895,
-0.0411526486,
-0.0019030042,
0.0435264222,
-0.0365131348,
0.0438581258,
0.0351584554,
0.0824062228,
0.0417197533,
0.0273160469,
-0.0045960797,
0.0128367916,
0.0416244082,
-0.0097278999,
0.0302026402,
-0.0365340039,
-0.0175886936,
0.0212016255,
-0.0346333347,
-0.018095687,
-0.0321132615,
-0.0327285379,
0.0466406867,
0.0303997137,
-0.0202928763,
-0.0062583331,
0.0289932005,
-0.0133165652,
-0.0135218864,
0.0070650936,
-0.0267731864,
0.0105109857,
0.02243286,
0.0123787476,
-0.0182753187,
-0.0585850552,
0.0322947241,
-0.0032836264,
0.0330637135,
0.0134948632,
0.0378615856,
0.0061083729,
-0.0511822812,
0.0189495478,
-0.0130230701,
-0.0363833979,
-0.0782941207,
-0.0327422135,
-0.0088904155,
0.0281671342,
0.0123083703,
0.0017642183,
0.0053440337,
-0.0228826087,
-0.000154889,
-0.0128692919,
0.0107342666,
0.0444521345,
0.0119640939,
-0.0107490383,
-0.0155439144,
-0.0043284376,
-0.0201363824,
-0.0582619607,
0.0293322094,
0.000114498,
2.206e-7,
0.0219120365,
0.0327836089,
0.0153892403,
-0.0140842777,
0.0059274817,
0.0277120098,
0.0574770533,
0.055927664,
-0.0378706381,
0.0035414041,
0.0261238832,
0.0168387797,
0.0103347935,
-0.0160226431,
-0.1118939966,
0.0110329408,
-0.086864613,
-0.0000898783,
-0.0675145164,
-0.0417388491,
0.087023899,
0.0934995264,
0.0033341397,
-0.0106672468,
0.0158755071,
-0.0503370613,
0.0801874474,
-0.0117584849,
-0.0120179746,
0.0252216235,
0.0084714908,
0.022716077,
0.0035684279,
0.0165961646,
0.0376531668,
0.0198829509,
0.0430589542,
0.0406152382,
0.0260728169,
-0.0126531469,
-0.043923296,
-0.0413522832,
0.0069174529,
-0.085850358,
0.031222254,
-0.0440143459,
0.0389702059,
-0.0094541376,
0.0092012305,
0.0512132123,
0.0243618973,
-0.0414105207,
-0.0415638871,
0.0214567911,
0.0279233977,
-0.0037496157,
-0.0071430989,
-0.0512637645,
-0.0013959124,
0.0199134219,
-0.0336676762,
0.0013604517,
-0.0267027803,
0.0239100251,
0.0433629639,
-0.0755264983,
0.0031569963,
1.97119038e-34,
0.0269628689,
-0.0016649738,
0.0117886625,
0.0190953612,
0.0219882298,
-0.0090690795,
-0.0136616649,
0.0124332262,
0.0098375883,
-0.0044329707,
0.0145583292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14859v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14859v3 | 3M-TRANSFORMER: A Multi-Stage Multi-Stream Multimodal Transformer for Embodied Turn-Taking Prediction | 2023-10-23T12:29:10 | 2023-12-21T18:19:58 | Mehdi Fatan, Emanuele Mincato, Dimitra Pintzou, Mariella Dimiccoli | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Predicting turn-taking in multiparty conversations has many practical
applications in human-computer/robot interaction. However, the complexity of
human communication makes it a challenging task. Recent advances have shown
that synchronous multi-perspective egocentric data can significantly improve
turn-taking prediction compared to asynchronous, single-perspective
transcriptions. Building on this research, we propose a new multimodal
transformer-based architecture for predicting turn-taking in embodied,
synchronized multi-perspective data. Our experimental results on the recently
introduced EgoCom dataset show a substantial performance improvement of up to
14.01% on average compared to existing baselines and alternative
transformer-based approaches. The source code, and the pre-trained models of
our 3M-Transformer will be available upon acceptance. | [
0.0234157685,
0.0380405746,
-0.0108021675,
0.0080929594,
-0.0154681522,
0.0079703806,
-0.0014542168,
-0.0094192019,
-0.0350786,
-0.0358810425,
-0.0745244771,
-0.0727380812,
0.0375589095,
0.0257836506,
0.0559628159,
-0.0479062311,
0.0434379652,
-0.0080855228,
-0.0391601548,
-0.0025132138,
0.01085841,
0.0056636343,
-0.060337007,
0.055903282,
-0.0439095981,
0.033010941,
-0.0481949635,
0.0065553226,
0.0066214725,
-0.0423801541,
-0.0166473575,
0.0388249457,
0.061828889,
0.0403804407,
0.0000018222,
0.0087646302,
0.0369909815,
-0.0560355522,
0.0039032525,
-0.0690396577,
0.0299143717,
-0.0282275956,
0.011682597,
0.0134780379,
-0.0577748604,
-0.0488595366,
0.0275694598,
0.1042599678,
0.0505280383,
0.0368675068,
-0.0202835239,
0.0023448588,
0.0121571701,
-0.0323371217,
-0.0209096204,
0.0039956402,
0.0255690478,
-0.0346642546,
-0.0223435294,
-0.000335235,
-0.0633401871,
0.0132060321,
0.0161669105,
-0.0164200086,
-0.015107342,
0.0690471902,
-0.0124042919,
-0.0365468971,
-0.0257652029,
0.079099372,
0.0090636425,
0.0198347159,
0.0073515852,
-0.0022805652,
0.0110068237,
-0.0465275124,
0.0120124072,
-0.004914498,
-0.0065590302,
0.0061000907,
-0.088395834,
0.05146119,
-0.0383365117,
-0.0334282927,
-0.0191214066,
0.0560121387,
-0.0162245575,
-0.0197228268,
0.0438541844,
0.0061025852,
0.0490230136,
-0.0184904654,
0.0155379083,
-0.0206883661,
-0.0253711101,
-0.0121103218,
-0.038467817,
0.0488086417,
-0.024772061,
0.0022905334,
0.0190521777,
0.0352136008,
-0.0085206367,
-0.0078858268,
0.021882968,
0.0302386377,
-0.0457732454,
-0.0066485107,
-0.0028599643,
0.0000915347,
-0.0304352194,
0.0040144962,
-0.0162313115,
-0.0253353212,
-0.010247332,
-0.0658764616,
-0.0241528023,
0.0502491109,
-0.0001367862,
-0.016237732,
0.0234696101,
0.0460408106,
-0.0095679872,
0.0245819632,
0.0016367598,
0.0593402125,
0.0226394385,
0.0442935564,
-0.010775351,
-0.0898424387,
-0.0176107958,
0.0500670336,
-0.0031595933,
-0.0147431754,
-0.0176654328,
0.0554119162,
-0.0104178078,
-0.0513232574,
0.0503305458,
0.0409857705,
-0.0339665562,
-0.0216482077,
0.0575765707,
-0.0219912007,
0.0452814139,
-0.0098866839,
0.0104089379,
0.0188231263,
0.0059724329,
-0.027165249,
0.028035406,
0.0591604449,
0.0512325168,
0.0237885509,
0.0244381744,
-0.0199521221,
0.0007564684,
0.0425745323,
0.0516840816,
-0.0058355741,
0.0032031119,
-0.017662175,
0.0169603229,
0.0756239742,
-0.0240767822,
-0.0248515829,
0.0501620919,
-0.0086723352,
-0.007453525,
0.0543778874,
0.0450915843,
0.0295699779,
-0.0279867779,
-0.0508803092,
0.0690196306,
-0.0136101767,
-0.0342178307,
-0.0260974392,
0.0317514539,
0.0088888016,
-0.0117126713,
-0.0055454145,
-0.0583929718,
0.0835687071,
0.0476748273,
-0.0287961811,
0.0196727626,
0.0211041048,
-0.0383460671,
-0.0059088361,
0.0256920941,
0.0176635124,
-0.0084776739,
-0.0272241309,
0.0121879047,
0.000277541,
-0.0390495397,
0.0134792011,
-0.0224552229,
-0.0302888323,
-0.0067308573,
0.0106869554,
-0.0308195688,
0.0133473286,
-0.016037086,
0.0037002934,
-0.0329436958,
-0.0360913649,
0.0014618097,
0.0479346029,
-0.0088476008,
-0.0081387945,
0.0601707175,
-0.0184178296,
-0.0500179119,
0.0423474498,
-0.0098176254,
0.0161843728,
-0.0085868053,
0.0010152364,
-0.0158328284,
0.0651053786,
0.0573165976,
0.0390479006,
-0.0231516548,
0.0214128532,
-0.0247698706,
0.0158266239,
0.0563450828,
-0.0248982031,
-0.0201274697,
-0.0112442775,
0.0298461523,
-0.0176811926,
-0.0174587928,
0.0902946815,
-0.0411633812,
-0.0537202023,
0.0213948917,
-0.0662477687,
-0.0376740545,
0.0384648629,
-0.0113338027,
-0.0471898466,
0.0015776997,
-0.0669070259,
0.0180945974,
0.0025861734,
0.0253542326,
0.0771318525,
0.0328939594,
0.0032149407,
-0.0477799438,
-0.0488171391,
0.0102099925,
0.0117036924,
-0.0497226827,
0.0112225637,
-0.046981968,
-0.0140468152,
0.0248904284,
0.0071193785,
-0.0428532101,
0.0147097129,
-0.0180146564,
-0.024200866,
-0.0361456014,
-0.0791516975,
-0.0532760136,
-0.0101846168,
-0.0025172194,
-0.0115356203,
-0.0242427923,
0.0002163663,
-0.0163276028,
-0.0366819352,
0.0200603064,
0.0355228744,
0.0139081227,
-0.0189970154,
-0.0012077652,
-0.0228772704,
-0.0072513926,
0.010135578,
-0.0060739019,
0.0371635072,
-0.0005173487,
-0.0286394209,
-0.0354395546,
-0.066819191,
-0.0100067016,
0.0624254905,
-0.0577538237,
0.0038325891,
0.0256438665,
-0.0272636358,
0.0488084145,
0.0047497917,
0.046689406,
0.0159135982,
0.0303029232,
-0.0564932711,
-0.0320688635,
0.0025959013,
-0.0321371593,
0.0300926194,
-0.0377103724,
-0.0199669637,
-0.0073876628,
0.0282332115,
0.0149382185,
0.0295711011,
-0.0693309009,
-0.0632687211,
0.0242459606,
-0.0810928345,
0.0241975486,
0.0147734378,
-0.0477918051,
-0.0156698078,
-0.0143511239,
-0.0188415926,
0.0346897393,
-0.0400705524,
-0.0669921488,
0.0640920848,
0.0431123339,
0.0076728663,
0.0590367429,
0.0269516911,
-0.0067518232,
-0.017386863,
-0.0100285197,
-0.055773396,
0.0550633334,
-0.0033866006,
0.0030715521,
0.013012886,
-0.0108417319,
-0.0156339779,
-0.0067099854,
-0.0182893723,
0.0028368908,
-0.0147614935,
-0.0216397792,
-0.0115130451,
0.0169089325,
-0.0343300961,
-0.031815581,
0.0155522907,
0.007786951,
0.021318512,
-0.0176782068,
-0.0170075856,
-0.0069433716,
-0.0313535184,
0.0526277646,
0.0607444197,
0.010244309,
-0.0535552017,
0.0143602528,
0.0620090105,
0.0620882995,
-0.0236923508,
-0.057156872,
0.0018143147,
0.0475427397,
0.0201454535,
-0.0190513693,
0.0110744853,
-0.0064523048,
0.00315379,
0.0048144748,
0.0803954825,
0.0007472229,
-0.0723001957,
0.0006011605,
0.0098279864,
0.0025430135,
0.0301823542,
-0.005824619,
-0.0245125368,
-0.0364396907,
-0.0179690886,
0.0066898498,
0.0389657728,
-0.0207423698,
0.0016130479,
-0.0779845193,
0.0380589142,
-0.0132171782,
-0.0553132482,
-0.0543650351,
0.0008651352,
0.0365006328,
-0.0315416455,
-0.0326448195,
0.0220992398,
-0.0067976145,
-0.0335368998,
0.0210210662,
-0.0366047621,
0.0001435308,
0.0137211485,
-0.0066732201,
0.0244367104,
0.0197394788,
0.0481989942,
-0.0080996361,
-0.0518100895,
-0.0373526476,
-0.0141262189,
0.0224276856,
-0.0235894602,
0.0677741468,
-0.0658921897,
-0.0101084085,
0.0110602332,
0.0356562845,
0.0064118886,
0.0046283887,
-0.0190083385,
0.0297304634,
-0.1186107099,
0.0085573839,
-0.0073625045,
0.0443346463,
0.0193794984,
0.0420378409,
-0.0057012606,
-0.0453689955,
-0.0070613013,
0.0258801412,
-0.0059577194,
0.0086264601,
-0.0601079091,
-0.0288019273,
0.0227717273,
-0.0737117231,
-0.0388464667,
-0.0188876167,
0.0480052307,
0.0373169966,
0.003126319,
-0.0538144484,
0.0406499319,
0.0081316829,
-0.0493745059,
0.0003150721,
0.0217276271,
0.0546491966,
-0.0427502766,
-0.0027736423,
0.0560746454,
-0.0288129915,
0.0239355769,
0.0371749327,
-0.0539015159,
-0.0403790176,
0.0261488669,
0.0484204814,
0.012946534,
0.0650568902,
0.0197023209,
-0.0143383406,
-0.0020091794,
0.0024828559,
-0.0053844689,
0.0591101944,
0.0445541106,
0.0384737179,
-0.0286615789,
0.0333622918,
-0.0158302784,
0.0213217139,
-0.0160741284,
-0.0041747792,
-0.0614029653,
-0.1009472311,
-0.0122863157,
-0.0277969576,
0.116578877,
-0.0209012106,
0.0595069565,
-0.0121500185,
0.014940124,
-0.009214785,
0.0237854756,
-0.0662009567,
-0.0061654439,
0.0070988624,
0.0269735269,
-0.0273638368,
0.0277093146,
-0.0330960639,
-0.0461429022,
-0.0326774456,
0.0029622475,
-0.0011854088,
-0.0166139901,
-0.0199038144,
0.0271147769,
0.0131941298,
-0.0013606142,
0.0186014604,
-0.0090974178,
0.0408451036,
0.0901621878,
0.0494784117,
-0.0031545525,
0.0028020113,
0.0525561497,
-0.0573764034,
0.0232813917,
-0.0026615211,
0.0126791745,
0.008120914,
-0.0029210211,
0.0165971369,
-0.0131772514,
0.0370809101,
-0.0071310918,
0.0768998414,
-0.0284373369,
-0.0380692147,
0.0801522508,
-0.0143997334,
-0.0176835153,
0.0117860492,
0.0408302024,
-0.0415543802,
0.037288513,
-0.0079088984,
0.0220870972,
-0.0729075298,
-0.0391760208,
0.0114493081,
-0.0256958567,
-0.0041936198,
0.0186065231,
-0.0261334181,
-0.0239993241,
-0.0122858863,
0.0235014204,
0.0097183837,
-0.0370719656,
0.0636080131,
-0.0046106838,
0.0326467566,
-0.049546808,
-0.0509328619,
-0.0430211648,
0.0073560611,
0.0000376749,
-0.0448030867,
-5.395938207e-33,
-0.0431335941,
-0.0009891792,
0.0175021403,
0.0624541715,
-0.0836384371,
-0.0275855269,
-0.0319267139,
0.0254357271,
-0.0000583187,
0.00606512,
0.0044463696,
0.0151445493,
0.012037755,
-0.0155666284,
0.0352442376,
0.0206781533,
0.0154496636,
-0.0424029529,
-0.0253330301,
0.0157548748,
0.0512859896,
0.0110554295,
0.0664109811,
-0.0777823254,
-0.0219791904,
0.0138240904,
-0.0440962203,
0.0355526917,
-0.0417390838,
0.0028843384,
0.0013174718,
-0.0259018149,
0.0008925768,
-0.0805121362,
-0.0100385351,
0.020928951,
-0.0219543502,
-0.0045059882,
-0.0284202062,
0.0717305094,
-0.0509458929,
0.0474474691,
0.0169132408,
-0.0197635982,
-0.0219082274,
0.0016778718,
0.0193671193,
0.0023007891,
-0.0060854056,
-0.0313681327,
0.0098069115,
-0.0006488059,
-0.0284092128,
-0.0535737686,
0.0633316562,
0.0952657163,
0.0007753622,
-0.0137845436,
-0.0487280525,
0.0358581245,
-0.1017485857,
0.0002621688,
0.0426075608,
0.0361859538,
0.0461204126,
0.0489426441,
0.0287112724,
-0.0345580839,
-0.0309749674,
-0.0148105603,
0.0121501619,
0.0984565094,
0.005329526,
0.0350926146,
-0.0363067016,
-0.0084403828,
0.0320818312,
0.0631628782,
0.0236908384,
0.0343914106,
-0.0075169974,
-0.0077982387,
-0.0148997074,
0.0018850161,
0.0026813147,
-0.0301638674,
0.0244322568,
0.0176704023,
-0.0136730978,
0.0200166404,
0.0378942564,
0.0192961339,
0.1096587777,
-0.0191954188,
0.0089243734,
-0.0092704166,
-0.0258640014,
0.049541831,
0.0002694189,
-0.013866161,
-0.0610616393,
-0.0169057492,
0.0571836606,
-0.015606368,
0.0271246973,
-0.0011042228,
-0.0114118597,
0.0659253001,
-0.0504520386,
-0.0409899056,
-0.0049746088,
0.0403691269,
0.0055301175,
-0.0152525678,
0.0595017672,
0.0038428344,
-0.0588393547,
0.0046508261,
-0.0392606147,
0.0050679096,
-0.0320735201,
-0.0096996622,
0.0367800295,
0.0431324206,
-0.0242313631,
0.001907985,
-0.0324144475,
-0.0343451314,
0.0178621337,
-0.0434293561,
-0.0178434085,
0.0597447529,
2.671e-7,
-0.0104179559,
0.0458339602,
0.0323756896,
-0.0082744332,
0.052315589,
0.0493730009,
-0.0318691693,
0.057527829,
0.0033783943,
-0.0094832797,
0.05567839,
0.0216792785,
0.0654977113,
-0.0050001196,
-0.0548733622,
-0.0469676442,
-0.0473165214,
-0.0109287817,
0.012438938,
0.0067252256,
0.0626661554,
0.0648553595,
-0.0072066705,
0.0053084269,
0.0266320799,
0.0752861649,
0.053340245,
-0.0223630704,
0.0469340384,
-0.0331424661,
0.060475979,
-0.064411819,
-0.0302139446,
0.0502133109,
-0.012789581,
0.0131857106,
-0.0255804062,
0.0194362085,
-0.0272792056,
-0.0436044633,
0.031933289,
0.0632750392,
-0.028914474,
-0.0084169647,
0.0295580775,
-0.0741482452,
-0.0226212237,
-0.0310372245,
-0.0510762446,
0.0295351222,
0.0189603753,
0.0338261835,
0.0194373,
0.0239600483,
-0.0051751444,
-0.0244873241,
-0.0098249307,
-0.0686105043,
0.0064721778,
-0.0443790592,
-0.0831590146,
-0.0085489824,
0.0159851052,
-0.0352910943,
0.0064545609,
-0.0009538624,
-0.0711981207,
1.494053894e-34,
-0.0018071248,
0.0014198922,
0.0140498709,
-0.0004697045,
-0.0060509448,
-0.0329471566,
0.0277711321,
0.0183052421,
0.0018407386,
-0.0511180162,
-0.0358175822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14855v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14855v2 | Contextual Refinement of Translations: Large Language Models for Sentence and Document-Level Post-Editing | 2023-10-23T12:22:15 | 2024-03-18T20:11:03 | Sai Koneru, Miriam Exel, Matthias Huck, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLM's) have demonstrated considerable success in
various Natural Language Processing tasks, but they have yet to attain
state-of-the-art performance in Neural Machine Translation (NMT). Nevertheless,
their significant performance in tasks demanding a broad understanding and
contextual processing shows their potential for translation. To exploit these
abilities, we investigate using LLM's for MT and explore recent
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques. Surprisingly, our initial
experiments find that fine-tuning for translation purposes even led to
performance degradation. To overcome this, we propose an alternative approach:
adapting LLM's as Automatic Post-Editors (APE) rather than direct translators.
Building on the LLM's exceptional ability to process and generate lengthy
sequences, we also propose extending our approach to document-level
translation. We show that leveraging Low-Rank-Adapter fine-tuning for APE can
yield significant improvements across both sentence and document-level metrics
while generalizing to out-of-domain data. Most notably, we achieve a
state-of-the-art accuracy rate of 89\% on the ContraPro test set, which
specifically assesses the model's ability to resolve pronoun ambiguities when
translating from English to German. Lastly, we investigate a practical scenario
involving manual post-editing for document-level translation, where reference
context is made available. Here, we demonstrate that leveraging human
corrections can significantly reduce the number of edits required for
subsequent translations (Interactive Demo for integrating manual feedback can
be found here:
https://huggingface.co/spaces/skoneru/contextual_refinement_ende). | [
0.0644953698,
0.048663877,
0.0104354378,
0.0420150608,
-0.0100288279,
0.0025141812,
0.02565502,
-0.0392870232,
-0.0250344072,
-0.0531901009,
-0.0313348398,
-0.0415540151,
0.0116357673,
-0.0159396064,
0.0286401007,
-0.0433297679,
0.0387528837,
0.0013711386,
-0.0182338916,
0.0149825336,
-0.0196328405,
0.013834889,
0.0423825607,
0.0489035361,
0.0102353133,
-0.0236283448,
0.0059240577,
0.0642879978,
0.0275371596,
0.013206644,
0.0198594406,
0.0438889116,
0.0045713307,
0.073565647,
0.0000021964,
-0.0306142662,
-0.0468863472,
0.0113427946,
0.0021250197,
0.0410421714,
0.0378083661,
-0.0445944928,
-0.0489303693,
-0.0014155011,
-0.0124012111,
0.0168887377,
0.040203467,
0.0384966619,
0.0690162554,
0.1162289307,
-0.007391464,
-0.0308045596,
0.0262377448,
-0.0707392767,
-0.011658066,
-0.0719343275,
-0.0031185618,
-0.0352388583,
-0.0386197679,
0.029792279,
-0.005973334,
0.0577699915,
0.0389532708,
-0.0272718556,
-0.0025771635,
-0.0189681128,
-0.029177215,
-0.0347265229,
-0.0256566778,
0.0852391124,
-0.0396213979,
-0.002271506,
-0.0099966461,
-0.000398271,
0.021975819,
-0.0433252677,
-0.0077731968,
0.0348624028,
0.0061154678,
-0.0009619218,
0.0153741715,
-0.0106986845,
0.0409767143,
0.021246478,
-0.040321406,
0.0235808138,
0.0335326269,
-0.0265352689,
-0.0034952641,
0.0113537936,
-0.0632013232,
-0.0428990312,
0.0389498733,
0.0005334779,
-0.0340967663,
0.0150921354,
-0.0714872628,
-0.0672301427,
-0.0066037416,
-0.0308936909,
0.0576482937,
0.0622442886,
-0.0016562172,
0.0572871305,
-0.0213884227,
0.0749416202,
-0.0317165777,
-0.0179759357,
-0.0700451434,
-0.0178318359,
-0.0197026469,
0.0302955527,
-0.050854478,
-0.001571599,
-0.0850376859,
-0.0032434606,
-0.0330969058,
0.0375332981,
0.0212894548,
0.0238788873,
-0.0043915147,
-0.0107171983,
-0.0546623468,
-0.0288126208,
0.0065205228,
0.0665614754,
0.0009645521,
-0.0155879026,
-0.0031481315,
-0.0375377238,
-0.0039372249,
0.0032948677,
0.0012995846,
-0.0592776537,
-0.0027590455,
0.0497062318,
-0.0272119176,
-0.0345330015,
-0.0068333228,
-0.0198876858,
-0.02784965,
-0.0577182472,
-0.0217671134,
-0.0344468914,
0.0516687371,
0.0007752485,
0.0105226124,
-0.0797356293,
0.0216300506,
0.0043590362,
-0.0324649774,
0.0560652129,
0.0111443885,
0.0067895241,
0.0115359044,
0.0103001241,
0.0170186218,
0.0263083689,
0.0636901557,
0.0257792063,
0.0357698314,
0.0012853644,
-0.0200598184,
0.0662099123,
-0.0053401398,
0.0115227234,
-0.0151538393,
-0.001584336,
0.0208061617,
0.0533607192,
0.0517144985,
0.0566061884,
-0.0112690385,
0.0078729959,
0.0760969073,
-0.0114710219,
0.0226739235,
0.0393276028,
0.0453634039,
-0.0018198346,
0.0011828621,
-0.0204570666,
-0.0693858415,
0.0281950198,
-0.0207843948,
0.008156999,
0.0293705259,
0.0446782,
0.002289142,
-0.0294842254,
0.0088106832,
0.0085232211,
0.012356285,
-0.0221173018,
0.0116717024,
0.0112744821,
-0.0651592463,
0.0491287671,
-0.0124982409,
-0.0595882647,
0.0043393136,
-0.0145186,
-0.029996248,
0.0658675805,
0.056790445,
-0.0225077532,
-0.0609905012,
-0.0402515382,
0.0202746205,
0.0608337633,
0.0886040404,
0.0234798491,
0.0314469449,
-0.0344978236,
-0.0208677575,
-0.0304075871,
0.0089435317,
0.0250428412,
0.0265758559,
0.0076269964,
0.0553208739,
-0.0273689386,
-0.0669341236,
0.0270339549,
-0.0216110554,
-0.0340462849,
0.0377952307,
0.0113237584,
0.0113469586,
0.003970901,
-0.02876205,
-0.01558463,
0.0092470031,
-0.0329025798,
0.0152122416,
0.001868394,
-0.0356402397,
-0.0454105064,
0.0261546224,
-0.0061439602,
-0.0534545258,
0.0144080808,
-0.0739721134,
-0.0457625389,
-0.0346953608,
-0.0265543852,
0.0066742101,
-0.0320995003,
0.0486832894,
0.0081770141,
0.0054205568,
-0.0294467881,
0.0086308764,
-0.0058936179,
-0.0128762703,
0.0383217447,
-0.0060999198,
0.0092668766,
-0.0286943801,
-0.0474653244,
0.009912475,
0.0053269165,
0.0303346813,
0.0318154953,
0.0409264341,
-0.0157006681,
-0.0557337478,
-0.0768192336,
0.0309959687,
-0.0298778601,
0.0181685034,
0.0284425616,
0.058207918,
-0.0065874979,
-0.0145605998,
0.0088968202,
0.0118186921,
-0.0010421451,
0.0042626397,
0.0357612185,
0.0065516965,
-0.0005775088,
-0.0482336208,
0.0063933898,
-0.0020372607,
0.0231668688,
0.02775025,
-0.0161937624,
-0.0538688302,
0.0314285755,
-0.0256941337,
0.0187510028,
0.0034987361,
-0.0676630065,
-0.0299808476,
-0.0118765002,
0.0710760355,
0.0980455577,
0.0010005235,
0.0138748912,
0.0378020667,
-0.0009976766,
-0.0307946447,
0.0330589153,
-0.0031724798,
-0.0487925969,
-0.0460342243,
-0.0355556794,
0.0432487465,
0.0656993166,
-0.0188147947,
-0.0133440336,
-0.0474806689,
0.0271156654,
-0.0120675284,
-0.027978586,
-0.015096426,
0.0089100236,
-0.0083679128,
0.033913821,
-0.0396839753,
-0.0124828117,
0.0771385506,
-0.0199023448,
-0.0075237695,
-0.0388084576,
-0.0019115278,
-0.0411080681,
0.0446083732,
-0.0084889885,
0.0230522472,
-0.0158828758,
-0.008559417,
-0.0579289496,
-0.0094408477,
-0.0121334568,
-0.0014174678,
0.0444334932,
-0.0795051977,
-0.0089377742,
-0.036033392,
-0.0552802943,
-0.0075408053,
-0.0543517582,
-0.0086500207,
0.0156094003,
0.0040330538,
-0.0353782848,
-0.0345752612,
-0.0245660506,
0.018373441,
0.0851493329,
-0.0406416021,
-0.0095461598,
-0.0489226915,
0.0230080653,
0.0147804841,
0.0413368866,
0.0248207934,
-0.0361924954,
0.0271985941,
0.0321276002,
0.0089300349,
0.0018935178,
-0.0294207521,
-0.0051334803,
0.0068432661,
-0.030335566,
-0.0390116163,
0.0000281672,
0.0792282894,
-0.0968703404,
-0.0165039282,
0.1322291195,
0.0369793698,
-0.0391359366,
-0.0163512658,
-0.0150792403,
0.0323878638,
0.0128631294,
0.0553452186,
-0.0900108814,
-0.0446298458,
0.0151847154,
0.0214316789,
-0.0056091738,
-0.0061714388,
-0.017659707,
-0.0971730426,
0.0357529521,
0.0359795392,
-0.0644705966,
-0.0250432529,
0.0183778536,
-0.0013965409,
-0.0106183672,
0.0373386033,
0.0197104476,
-0.0013429937,
-0.0146410018,
-0.0220093373,
0.0423934087,
-0.0678793192,
0.0206412263,
-0.0540968552,
0.0250662211,
0.0699110702,
0.061085768,
0.0181557611,
0.0044716699,
0.0757429898,
-0.0377025902,
0.0235729888,
-0.0185372625,
-0.0059687113,
-0.0079837153,
-0.0100873103,
0.0155328736,
0.0165818464,
-0.0041518393,
0.0095409229,
0.0252702404,
0.0470136106,
-0.0189379994,
0.015397667,
0.0228845365,
-0.0130847115,
-0.0027723333,
0.0687333345,
0.0387026481,
-0.0687260702,
-0.0273875762,
-0.0412875302,
0.0003785981,
-0.0629731044,
0.0158433504,
-0.0227398071,
-0.0535196736,
0.0075061377,
-0.0796498656,
-0.0577763095,
0.0217452757,
0.0069750817,
0.0296796747,
-0.0241440795,
0.0072083087,
-0.0271764547,
-0.0322834402,
0.053796351,
-0.0264777634,
0.0206943769,
-0.0577054806,
0.0406380892,
0.0234010909,
-0.0346115716,
-0.0072438372,
0.0305501744,
-0.0690711886,
-0.0653181374,
-0.0013587052,
0.0564380363,
0.0187787674,
0.0679411367,
-0.0387458205,
-0.0718869567,
-0.0177000351,
0.0378158092,
-0.0244722106,
0.0357592255,
0.0339286365,
0.0374715403,
-0.0321861543,
0.0557507761,
-0.0281148907,
-0.008987681,
0.0277427025,
0.0485666245,
0.0069268141,
-0.0911810473,
0.0163745992,
0.0091683054,
-0.0006543251,
-0.004235507,
-0.0047020325,
-0.0227981862,
0.0439552441,
-0.0199211296,
-0.0231139623,
-0.039442312,
-0.0163972117,
0.0380558483,
0.0045275218,
-0.0210932549,
0.017844405,
-0.0038327631,
0.0071415426,
-0.0496292971,
-0.0087549379,
-0.0084506664,
0.0037966992,
0.0199186765,
0.0180650521,
-0.0153092295,
0.042156145,
0.023239769,
0.0404025465,
-0.0499745943,
0.0505878441,
0.0145646306,
-0.0179386567,
-0.0346677005,
0.045142062,
-0.0774063617,
0.004029389,
-0.0127884392,
0.0159398764,
0.0686338842,
0.0102044288,
0.0982545912,
-0.0293498617,
-0.0290761385,
-0.0142465904,
0.0252372641,
0.019873254,
0.0095877927,
-0.0095269959,
-0.0078438101,
0.0105362935,
0.0457700156,
0.0334243923,
0.0016927837,
0.0429372415,
0.0074193981,
-0.0094142165,
-0.0472786613,
-0.0045508924,
-0.0288958829,
-0.0112742921,
-0.0265165083,
-0.016739374,
-0.028492054,
-0.026966406,
0.0274599958,
-0.0012465509,
-0.0156075647,
-0.0215442572,
-0.01850418,
0.0602898672,
-0.0417523533,
-0.0146519728,
-0.0415964536,
0.0151994871,
0.0115713365,
-0.0396890715,
-0.0460710712,
-6.635484143e-33,
-0.0541745052,
-0.0099620828,
0.0097904718,
-0.0256421547,
-0.0631278902,
-0.0123215672,
-0.0681708902,
-0.0361051634,
0.0034161427,
-0.003105944,
-0.0265846029,
0.0170230679,
0.0165697876,
0.0218077525,
-0.0151554234,
0.0196109619,
0.0981438234,
0.0287301242,
-0.0288440045,
0.0103562959,
0.0242647901,
0.0197677333,
0.0475661457,
-0.0330273956,
0.029538339,
0.0192068405,
-0.0276795626,
0.0412547588,
-0.0146314679,
0.022600729,
0.0212541465,
-0.0023806985,
0.0116824489,
-0.0093420232,
-0.0084365178,
0.0028257016,
-0.104975991,
0.0098302225,
0.0107343663,
0.0253714658,
-0.0111428732,
-0.0858675241,
0.079213962,
-0.0313150436,
-0.0140625071,
-0.0024389636,
0.0058210017,
-0.0373945497,
-0.0070993337,
-0.0228090882,
-0.0667235702,
0.0067263972,
-0.0098118102,
-0.0129419761,
-0.0001875787,
0.0524310358,
-0.0186243523,
0.01271699,
-0.08628387,
-0.0081687979,
0.0024690661,
0.042739585,
0.0347357951,
-0.0073285233,
-0.0112960003,
-0.0025391704,
0.0154428994,
0.0212685596,
0.0057473867,
-0.0056062858,
0.0285791866,
0.0039713592,
0.0495555103,
0.0599189848,
-0.0081502888,
0.0114359967,
-0.0504625067,
0.023286514,
-0.0327113271,
0.0128263533,
0.0160130318,
0.0058305096,
0.0166555252,
0.0037839366,
-0.0613041706,
-0.0383152366,
-0.0350989625,
0.0079691419,
0.0290804487,
0.025808936,
-0.0294240564,
-0.0053839055,
0.0646638349,
-0.0211296156,
0.0400703847,
0.0104295379,
-0.0274595656,
0.0406962261,
-0.0088438913,
0.0332146026,
-0.0168086905,
-0.0033064045,
0.0282444414,
0.0035650956,
0.0091097718,
-0.02000615,
0.0465006493,
0.016377382,
-0.0554290861,
0.0116644967,
-0.0386253372,
0.0325743631,
-0.0268667191,
0.0186545104,
0.0122102676,
0.0081711551,
-0.0006932252,
0.0319716521,
0.04468292,
0.0161212161,
-0.0128248958,
-0.0059099356,
0.0296345502,
0.0474875346,
-0.0366576761,
0.0291907545,
0.0081669092,
0.0441399738,
0.0295343567,
-0.0558800511,
-0.0302807521,
-0.0184696428,
2.865e-7,
0.0533431545,
0.0769173428,
0.012113099,
-0.0098943543,
0.0112462705,
0.023368232,
-0.007674309,
0.0072615421,
0.0145123526,
0.0564166866,
0.0448675379,
0.0131911635,
0.0783585906,
0.0039173099,
-0.0658885837,
0.0024273361,
-0.0492851734,
0.0319001824,
-0.0806792676,
-0.0049482496,
0.023061296,
0.0887652859,
0.0119712017,
-0.0077408724,
-0.0183327664,
-0.0488597192,
0.0816646367,
-0.0253383666,
-0.0338569619,
0.0209470466,
0.0347980373,
0.0395349488,
-0.0214449149,
-0.0120142614,
-0.0160231702,
0.019875044,
0.0103429081,
0.1056937948,
0.008780973,
0.0247986019,
0.0043466324,
-0.0103260092,
-0.0045148898,
-0.0564106926,
0.0645719245,
-0.0617448464,
0.0000349887,
-0.0093856417,
-0.0194349848,
-0.0115393372,
0.0325081944,
-0.0622034855,
-0.0121542234,
0.014431105,
0.0409350544,
0.0029718997,
-0.0420031026,
-0.0470375977,
-0.0511547737,
0.0154486066,
0.0014193943,
-0.0359028317,
-0.0388219133,
-0.0133318705,
0.0121004237,
-0.0559359379,
-0.0034602527,
2.859579189e-34,
0.037175592,
-0.0109023592,
0.0194759704,
-0.0098451721,
0.0507103503,
0.0141049959,
-0.0309200566,
-0.0055858488,
-0.0088291923,
-0.0884802416,
-0.0238965601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14853v1 | Adaptive Policy with Wait-$k$ Model for Simultaneous Translation | 2023-10-23T12:16:32 | 2023-10-23T12:16:32 | Libo Zhao, Kai Fan, Wei Luo, Jing Wu, Shushu Wang, Ziqian Zeng, Zhongqiang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simultaneous machine translation (SiMT) requires a robust read/write policy
in conjunction with a high-quality translation model. Traditional methods rely
on either a fixed wait-$k$ policy coupled with a standalone wait-$k$
translation model, or an adaptive policy jointly trained with the translation
model. In this study, we propose a more flexible approach by decoupling the
adaptive policy model from the translation model. Our motivation stems from the
observation that a standalone multi-path wait-$k$ model performs competitively
with adaptive policies utilized in state-of-the-art SiMT approaches.
Specifically, we introduce DaP, a divergence-based adaptive policy, that makes
read/write decisions for any translation model based on the potential
divergence in translation distributions resulting from future information. DaP
extends a frozen wait-$k$ model with lightweight parameters, and is both memory
and computation efficient. Experimental results across various benchmarks
demonstrate that our approach offers an improved trade-off between translation
accuracy and latency, outperforming strong baselines. | [
0.0509270802,
0.0634720027,
-0.0087541994,
-0.0148327714,
-0.0221907627,
0.0303856749,
0.0467014126,
0.0112039223,
-0.0258837361,
0.0270802975,
0.0047924384,
-0.0732847676,
0.0218117107,
-0.0060694409,
-0.0126322145,
-0.0560504384,
0.0175180547,
-0.0124339005,
0.0143251913,
-0.0173326395,
0.0080104889,
0.0091134543,
0.0097114686,
0.0250089541,
0.005388137,
0.0153549779,
-0.0316817015,
0.0347440876,
0.0737613961,
-0.0365877897,
0.0166084114,
0.0473729335,
0.0356096365,
0.0792380124,
0.0000020104,
-0.0067147529,
0.0129485894,
0.0139991799,
0.0334304869,
0.0222142227,
0.0434059277,
-0.0685741827,
-0.0256836116,
0.0073003238,
0.001434929,
-0.0115418648,
0.0633315891,
-0.0026140697,
0.0684507266,
0.0659252852,
0.0001020006,
-0.0528140664,
-0.0188049916,
-0.0991491675,
-0.0110315718,
-0.081600599,
-0.0106054619,
-0.0363935754,
-0.0616477653,
-0.0023914776,
-0.0131705469,
0.0651537403,
0.0243460238,
-0.0179462936,
-0.0457764044,
0.0165880378,
0.0276647601,
-0.0521958247,
-0.0475774929,
0.0507753938,
-0.0600535758,
0.0178053062,
0.0218791272,
-0.0629453436,
-0.0312372278,
-0.0329344682,
-0.0127031533,
0.0343279727,
-0.0242276601,
-0.0269119963,
0.0140150348,
0.0498082899,
0.0658512712,
-0.0181329437,
-0.0356467217,
-0.0426737554,
0.0213492364,
-0.0282394812,
-0.0054991888,
0.0490483306,
0.0040183221,
0.0092063546,
0.0901705623,
-0.0035684668,
-0.0187840089,
0.0206385925,
-0.0451937728,
-0.0632540509,
-0.0076877628,
-0.0446398705,
0.0551513322,
0.0928086191,
-0.0129266446,
0.0464417189,
-0.0068110591,
0.0357316472,
-0.0425578058,
-0.0124576828,
-0.0292395633,
0.0364378318,
-0.0035321373,
0.0047592348,
-0.0168051645,
-0.024790775,
-0.0509637259,
-0.0116315149,
-0.0197613258,
-0.005497423,
-0.0137777049,
-0.0090228571,
0.0730094612,
-0.0183452535,
-0.1097096354,
0.000245436,
0.0011878897,
0.0442976244,
-0.0044239569,
0.0072939568,
0.0237741675,
-0.0096355332,
-0.0265810378,
-0.0175976809,
-0.0127603253,
-0.0144535443,
-0.0021022891,
0.0524142645,
-0.0299363807,
0.0008875403,
-0.0068359901,
0.0042209798,
0.0080268625,
-0.0731075555,
0.0234172642,
-0.0410363115,
0.1005254313,
-0.0141488621,
0.0088323643,
-0.0549930446,
-0.0224614143,
-0.0047688116,
0.0106402421,
0.0638162121,
0.0320752338,
-0.0014551794,
0.0543099195,
0.0192939471,
0.014671416,
0.0655485764,
0.0256341118,
-0.023159774,
0.025006514,
0.0366976075,
-0.0473278835,
0.0716311783,
0.0357305743,
0.0566254109,
-0.0164248385,
-0.002521751,
0.0046494878,
0.0538311936,
0.0227852631,
-0.0021910893,
-0.030275045,
-0.0175002944,
0.0570222326,
0.0436295457,
0.00568103,
0.041397959,
0.1011037752,
0.0171544328,
-0.0576057024,
-0.0046045911,
0.0061749099,
0.0352670737,
0.0551496595,
0.0054767174,
0.0372544564,
0.0727056861,
-0.009118109,
-0.0263506379,
0.025636984,
-0.0130318701,
-0.0079880431,
-0.0199139286,
0.029881293,
0.008436651,
-0.0526532531,
-0.0042793397,
0.0138327349,
-0.0325247347,
0.0011695435,
0.010813877,
-0.0582407154,
0.0811271071,
0.0019419448,
0.0346621647,
-0.0602521636,
-0.0195496399,
-0.0116543993,
0.0524202995,
0.074142836,
0.0232277755,
0.0577114783,
-0.034566015,
-0.0467952713,
0.0622329228,
0.0044186143,
0.0401126631,
0.0187458862,
0.057630796,
0.0574412085,
0.0466962866,
-0.0249106884,
0.028403962,
-0.0652594566,
0.003129452,
0.0169612151,
0.0167563651,
0.0455123484,
0.0142836682,
-0.028183125,
-0.0049006245,
0.0318967327,
-0.0122635886,
-0.006704601,
0.0523307845,
-0.0693846196,
-0.0378064439,
0.0356727429,
0.0398570783,
0.0004726064,
-0.0045192963,
-0.0094592255,
-0.0459073484,
0.002284029,
-0.0006081256,
-0.0307405833,
-0.0211227462,
0.0096400725,
0.0168648493,
-0.0097224619,
-0.0189636648,
0.012768466,
-0.0235717464,
0.0044051944,
0.0170679651,
0.0347071625,
-0.0285125878,
-0.0372321792,
-0.0180935785,
0.0518221743,
0.0287368782,
0.0430053994,
0.0364196524,
0.0237357318,
-0.0032893876,
-0.0233205575,
-0.0320202708,
0.0257418472,
-0.023603553,
0.0179096069,
-0.0116476882,
0.0300260037,
-0.0093847485,
-0.0226375982,
-0.0025042668,
0.0397882387,
0.0309519842,
-0.0099622551,
-0.0436695479,
0.0346314497,
0.0124427378,
0.0037451719,
-0.0358256064,
0.0349175073,
-0.00759556,
0.0066811643,
0.0092051784,
-0.048241578,
-0.041695632,
-0.0257390663,
0.0095054507,
0.0007158868,
-0.0526611134,
0.0119988052,
-0.0672206208,
0.0247249529,
0.0177779794,
-0.0076864492,
0.0094961738,
-0.0118764741,
-0.0304543972,
-0.0312294196,
0.0321272537,
-0.0539341718,
-0.0179822855,
-0.0547991954,
-0.0198984183,
-0.0206107385,
0.0544201285,
-0.0156569872,
0.0107026836,
-0.1051006988,
-0.0467865877,
0.0096956054,
-0.0424035639,
-0.0014563575,
0.0299462397,
-0.0059238784,
-0.0090125315,
-0.0263445675,
-0.0356267355,
0.0650908649,
-0.0262860339,
-0.0243980158,
-0.0661370903,
-0.0205408055,
0.0057931547,
0.0633474439,
-0.0106959771,
0.0182331763,
-0.0446531326,
0.0046828664,
-0.0174748488,
0.0414028764,
0.0239362437,
-0.0087949531,
-0.0045652785,
-0.03402289,
0.003573315,
-0.0276943967,
-0.0296123251,
0.0198590644,
-0.0113525996,
-0.0423767641,
-0.0200616773,
0.0070081516,
-0.0718387216,
-0.0335646868,
0.0002170168,
0.0110555235,
0.1339145452,
-0.0210794751,
-0.014240684,
-0.023000598,
-0.0230189618,
-0.0167317409,
0.013186235,
-0.048400227,
-0.0722684562,
0.0320478529,
0.0273348019,
0.0464259014,
-0.0623451136,
-0.0257817302,
0.0025229054,
0.0578062423,
0.022158226,
-0.0147316521,
0.0120183155,
0.0058177682,
-0.095722802,
-0.0065801064,
0.0373951569,
-0.0169171337,
-0.0416900665,
-0.0198445283,
-0.0145532154,
0.0489925109,
-0.0101742689,
0.0103030046,
-0.0351771936,
-0.0306088924,
-0.0079451511,
0.0558756255,
0.0302642789,
0.0169778578,
-0.0266851708,
-0.067912519,
-0.0011290034,
0.0442610569,
-0.0822601095,
-0.0314772502,
-0.0140057737,
-0.0467429832,
-0.0361999981,
0.0166701674,
0.0340481177,
0.0372132957,
-0.0097250864,
-0.0078072497,
0.0685377344,
-0.0396214277,
-0.0172143355,
-0.0302498955,
0.0148676112,
0.0806171447,
-0.0220037438,
0.0139084104,
-0.0166635662,
0.0288568195,
-0.0525201075,
0.0063549411,
-0.0271403007,
-0.0205777753,
-0.0048365276,
-0.0205593854,
-0.0209570713,
-0.0164246578,
0.0025208592,
0.012203211,
0.0228237323,
0.0395444408,
-0.0278158393,
-0.0185496993,
0.0055879597,
-0.013952041,
0.0333561637,
0.0028510252,
-0.0306564532,
-0.064025566,
-0.0136720184,
-0.0288827401,
-0.003410585,
-0.1037738398,
-0.0144897755,
-0.028171692,
-0.0615598224,
-0.0641366988,
-0.0476815738,
-0.0332301036,
-0.0126696713,
0.0708684027,
0.0020210482,
0.0330688544,
0.0209463648,
0.0198668838,
-0.0592440777,
-0.0100953663,
-0.0017636258,
-0.001782779,
-0.026414521,
0.0197506454,
-0.0054044588,
-0.0082724793,
-0.0233442616,
0.0382087752,
-0.089744851,
-0.0965348184,
0.0101384157,
0.0790284947,
0.020271698,
0.0393217355,
-0.011996991,
-0.0408586971,
0.0156812537,
0.0030719852,
-0.0299621206,
0.0214552991,
0.0228208117,
-0.0289880019,
-0.0184112582,
0.0252275541,
-0.0067311195,
-0.0193107482,
-0.0270219333,
0.0411915183,
-0.0049496009,
-0.0472227968,
-0.0445415303,
-0.0128867729,
0.0042795544,
-0.0211757775,
-0.0078564724,
-0.0327146351,
0.0175053291,
0.015548843,
0.0003934548,
-0.0507516861,
0.0046668146,
0.0363870412,
-0.0258234944,
0.0247299187,
0.033415366,
0.0453103296,
-0.0547424182,
-0.0521336831,
-0.0194620043,
-0.0056772134,
0.0272206236,
0.0445227437,
0.0167375654,
0.0215195604,
0.013330644,
-0.0020808661,
-0.0208628662,
-0.0397538245,
0.0181452483,
0.0452109464,
0.0303983763,
-0.0072371159,
-0.0121540092,
-0.0368199274,
-0.0482130498,
-0.0127335507,
0.0564718023,
0.0821924061,
0.0043988265,
0.0924590379,
-0.0337609537,
-0.010853244,
-0.019233929,
0.0148740457,
0.0047859889,
-0.0476137437,
0.0160861835,
0.0008830821,
0.0090907132,
0.0293682013,
0.0386508889,
0.0045184954,
0.0459108353,
-0.0247151684,
-0.006416067,
-0.0274417792,
-0.0328336731,
-0.0268128756,
0.0154684596,
-0.0172215458,
-0.0008313435,
-0.0014595856,
-0.0338913389,
-0.0113268802,
0.0030735426,
-0.0068438579,
-0.0363732576,
0.0071749431,
0.0497946739,
-0.038923353,
-0.0098321792,
-0.0334238671,
0.0130486246,
-0.0280935187,
-0.0048865983,
0.0104185892,
-6.201568771e-33,
-0.0110156769,
-0.0211014319,
0.0044285799,
-0.0602031909,
-0.0710128099,
-0.0075335801,
-0.0347288698,
-0.0344711654,
0.0296270587,
0.0171918049,
-0.0167962722,
0.0465783328,
0.0373391323,
-0.0166737121,
0.0189339165,
0.0322066844,
0.0818137005,
-0.02238396,
-0.0440815948,
0.0353317,
0.0546286479,
0.0166384093,
0.0628924966,
-0.0209989976,
0.041324757,
-0.0327066183,
-0.0259477403,
-0.0250919312,
-0.0309083723,
0.0437530242,
0.0367391557,
0.017472947,
-0.0131026031,
-0.0547312796,
-0.0401339009,
0.0049639498,
-0.062009614,
0.023453908,
-0.0102186622,
0.0370298214,
-0.0294094421,
-0.0324415788,
0.0113892229,
-0.0112998327,
-0.0126754753,
-0.0255432557,
-0.0105273416,
-0.0203803033,
-0.0230611041,
-0.0299152024,
-0.024956841,
0.0360179543,
-0.0134069268,
0.02335071,
0.0853767991,
-0.014537598,
0.0026646249,
-0.0054514105,
-0.058649309,
0.0035263328,
-0.0155282756,
0.0724123195,
0.0538527146,
-0.0019938478,
0.0047291135,
0.0220569521,
0.0040807561,
0.0048789689,
0.0327998176,
-0.0302425455,
0.0065499316,
-0.0108718378,
0.0430685356,
0.0263127405,
0.0356264487,
-0.0528294407,
-0.0480397157,
0.0297792628,
0.0275573265,
0.0147966174,
0.0469658412,
0.0128527079,
-0.0100569548,
0.0038392264,
-0.05357223,
-0.0232103355,
-0.0111504383,
-0.0139008621,
0.0355099253,
0.0893365815,
-0.0016931558,
0.0208134912,
0.0989758596,
0.0290862154,
0.0359241404,
-0.0019638774,
-0.0274355598,
0.0007790131,
-0.0071204021,
0.0287323184,
-0.015317359,
-0.0417311043,
0.0091905342,
0.0092924451,
-0.0292534549,
-0.0206886567,
0.0261687636,
0.0262567662,
-0.0397397317,
0.0117528681,
-0.0214253236,
0.0471821912,
0.0159062892,
0.0272260159,
0.0502450615,
-0.0199740492,
-0.0020021694,
0.0311230086,
0.0340561382,
-0.0366862342,
0.0096103549,
0.0261926372,
0.0158489812,
0.0358232446,
-0.0433158353,
0.0527792163,
-0.0137853548,
-0.0013993705,
0.0186021905,
-0.0592392571,
-0.0390349403,
0.0379885286,
2.568e-7,
0.0060946406,
0.0201757345,
0.0249444712,
0.0176345054,
0.0233849008,
0.0213957094,
-0.0539299212,
0.0232823398,
-0.0075981622,
0.0546452962,
0.0103710126,
0.0242962129,
0.062074963,
-0.0050989236,
-0.0596779883,
-0.0117501635,
-0.0570848957,
0.0746250749,
-0.0584674515,
-0.0278923344,
0.0049514668,
0.0383392051,
-0.0234527923,
-0.006185702,
0.0320618898,
0.0109884171,
0.0815053657,
0.0017222315,
0.018782543,
-0.0333348066,
0.0595625006,
-0.0114877969,
-0.045305334,
-0.012080349,
-0.0541317351,
0.0199656095,
0.0343972109,
0.1400993019,
0.0248287152,
0.0026685838,
0.0635305792,
0.0172877852,
-0.0223063007,
-0.0324282646,
0.0482269339,
-0.0264560003,
0.0002979827,
0.0176620781,
-0.0174544342,
0.00621399,
0.0329009369,
-0.0170411188,
-0.0358079374,
0.0110959904,
0.0422666222,
0.028145887,
0.0034794542,
-0.0525221452,
-0.0315756276,
-0.0179771911,
-0.0300607514,
-0.025991641,
-0.0701226592,
0.0136234667,
-0.0064320769,
-0.0048697875,
-0.0279195085,
2.165405006e-34,
0.0632196143,
-0.0399502777,
0.0153733296,
-0.0050583803,
-0.02022947,
-0.0176487323,
0.0147472713,
0.0446300097,
0.0177110936,
-0.041837763,
-0.0712104961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14849v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14849v1 | Universal Domain Adaptation for Robust Handling of Distributional Shifts in NLP | 2023-10-23T12:15:25 | 2023-10-23T12:15:25 | Hyuhng Joon Kim, Hyunsoo Cho, Sang-Woo Lee, Junyeob Kim, Choonghyun Park, Sang-goo Lee, Kang Min Yoo, Taeuk Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | When deploying machine learning systems to the wild, it is highly desirable
for them to effectively leverage prior knowledge to the unfamiliar domain while
also firing alarms to anomalous inputs. In order to address these requirements,
Universal Domain Adaptation (UniDA) has emerged as a novel research area in
computer vision, focusing on achieving both adaptation ability and robustness
(i.e., the ability to detect out-of-distribution samples). While UniDA has led
significant progress in computer vision, its application on language input
still needs to be explored despite its feasibility. In this paper, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark for natural language that offers thorough viewpoints of
the model's generalizability and robustness. Our benchmark encompasses multiple
datasets with varying difficulty levels and characteristics, including temporal
shifts and diverse domains. On top of our testbed, we validate existing UniDA
methods from computer vision and state-of-the-art domain adaptation techniques
from NLP literature, yielding valuable findings: We observe that UniDA methods
originally designed for image input can be effectively transferred to the
natural language domain while also underscoring the effect of adaptation
difficulty in determining the model's performance. | [
0.0379148349,
0.0706719458,
-0.0193467699,
0.0306439288,
-0.0124437818,
0.0207319893,
-0.0379492044,
0.0212873854,
-0.031638138,
-0.0597091503,
-0.0011493831,
-0.0398158245,
-0.0048358687,
0.0420252271,
-0.0048931167,
-0.0489061177,
0.0385115556,
-0.0118687041,
-0.02619306,
0.02245217,
0.0204457827,
-0.0263342392,
-0.0178298596,
0.0175774284,
-0.0205201134,
-0.0239891447,
0.0004571924,
0.0361589678,
0.0259195752,
-0.0066460152,
-0.0002646471,
0.0219211448,
0.0212741923,
0.0025588945,
0.0000018673,
-0.044440113,
-0.0349957533,
-0.0119995475,
0.0097888922,
-0.0210300907,
0.0405158848,
-0.0749181584,
-0.0297256727,
0.0118932351,
-0.0514575131,
-0.0167446993,
0.091645658,
0.0328924581,
0.0135102272,
0.111491777,
-0.03016451,
0.0086396392,
0.0020288988,
0.0045266896,
-0.0900083482,
-0.0454833023,
0.042914357,
-0.0363432169,
-0.0134421559,
-0.041263476,
-0.0684868917,
0.0033059227,
-0.0228099618,
-0.0047569326,
-0.0154470233,
0.0118269296,
-0.0522934645,
-0.0008336448,
-0.0303442795,
0.0765593499,
-0.0374997333,
-0.0120509248,
-0.0027266664,
-0.0316134468,
0.0024560667,
0.0649951026,
-0.0143314544,
-0.0250179991,
0.0187001973,
0.0335517414,
-0.0372156687,
0.0028901775,
0.0324849896,
0.0213955119,
-0.0375849865,
0.0471663103,
0.0038846284,
-0.0232891198,
0.0103767831,
0.0168602169,
-0.058900442,
-0.0210244786,
0.0177881084,
0.02379453,
-0.0261868984,
-0.0018117272,
-0.0642550588,
-0.0495540239,
-0.0246396251,
-0.0267644394,
0.08506836,
0.0063032489,
-0.0649632365,
0.0470835529,
0.0322119556,
0.0568285286,
-0.0460718311,
0.0149809038,
-0.0257927477,
-0.0075361207,
-0.0495279767,
0.0254198685,
-0.0088455928,
-0.0089979591,
-0.0534728318,
-0.0122617744,
-0.0061791544,
0.0438310131,
-0.0058392868,
-0.0459150374,
0.0129758418,
0.017640857,
-0.0423915833,
-0.015374681,
-0.0166139323,
0.0654290691,
-0.0200301688,
0.0290961694,
0.0002519805,
-0.0500575565,
-0.022945974,
0.0524540618,
0.0084357588,
-0.0324259363,
-0.0159087814,
0.1200538501,
-0.0001816435,
-0.0261611678,
-0.0510599837,
0.0304592922,
-0.0714926422,
-0.0278685149,
0.0486964621,
-0.0475309901,
-0.0155622074,
-0.0044281273,
-0.0001552817,
-0.0703007132,
-0.0004097897,
-0.0016437314,
-0.0280154608,
0.0979561433,
-0.0108186016,
-0.0064029642,
0.0035607661,
-0.0326360725,
-0.0122360494,
0.0965947211,
0.0195092577,
-0.0391823575,
0.0531353317,
0.0029044952,
0.0445278063,
0.0639500096,
-0.0209315587,
0.0241942815,
-0.0133218486,
0.0132354554,
-0.009218174,
0.0232458189,
0.0587984696,
0.0017439586,
0.0158232395,
-0.0594522357,
0.0768677741,
0.0145133827,
0.0005068817,
-0.025244521,
0.0018957489,
-0.0285481978,
-0.0341262259,
0.0061645871,
-0.0777645558,
-0.0219356213,
-0.0106322262,
-0.0207320135,
-0.0420070514,
0.0060813501,
-0.0122235343,
-0.0328430086,
-0.0304364637,
0.000874667,
0.020096913,
-0.028850574,
0.0645980537,
0.037042547,
-0.0221690871,
0.0379270725,
0.0483762845,
0.0044545257,
0.009126395,
-0.0064775436,
-0.0056814449,
0.0264221579,
0.0193996783,
-0.0615440011,
0.0195604227,
-0.0029658221,
0.0612518825,
0.0599010661,
0.0072061722,
0.0167890601,
0.0262578931,
-0.0308092255,
-0.0191634372,
0.038303405,
0.0405260362,
0.0154345669,
0.017248638,
0.0254104938,
-0.0134471776,
-0.0794353858,
-0.0003620843,
0.0487764403,
-0.0119472304,
-0.0284643807,
0.0278318804,
0.0145510277,
0.0140232863,
-0.010005123,
-0.0284845382,
0.0040849904,
0.0093493005,
-0.0271129422,
-0.0457424223,
0.0123802945,
-0.0130952094,
-0.0170755498,
0.0547064915,
-0.0621289015,
0.0124166394,
0.0607591048,
-0.0592302978,
-0.0026328224,
0.0393541381,
-0.0021105676,
-0.0000459091,
-0.0162208248,
0.0200630669,
0.0109813521,
0.089319773,
-0.0538262576,
0.0540168993,
0.0039869589,
-0.0328639671,
-0.0136013199,
-0.0014223709,
-0.0009115479,
-0.013378771,
0.0113626393,
0.0363698527,
-0.0257428233,
0.0361496881,
0.0045804861,
-0.0213979799,
-0.0462103412,
-0.0026544349,
-0.0405795798,
0.0131216981,
-0.0478346944,
0.035049051,
0.0286611915,
-0.0034219141,
-0.0269598216,
-0.0311009977,
-0.002736496,
0.0133049637,
-0.0046136957,
0.0251330435,
0.0586978048,
-0.0068156836,
0.0157346819,
-0.0376493186,
-0.0045796917,
-0.012229464,
0.0741771907,
-0.039035596,
-0.0524966046,
-0.0522414595,
0.0238311384,
0.000422164,
0.0651972964,
-0.011064738,
-0.0006452223,
-0.0324092694,
0.0267340131,
0.0419106409,
0.0485525616,
0.0149306916,
0.0205302611,
0.0247323718,
-0.0036665294,
0.0002797594,
-0.0029617415,
-0.0297965761,
-0.0393785872,
-0.0353487357,
0.025700761,
0.0339390188,
0.0413952097,
-0.0274627805,
-0.0192580372,
-0.0335820951,
0.0096773021,
-0.0491369478,
-0.0323092602,
-0.0045503806,
0.027483765,
-0.0281700604,
0.0394763164,
-0.0176208522,
-0.0305638183,
0.0252627414,
-0.0010203405,
0.0325933136,
-0.0372187085,
-0.0355763733,
-0.0274993069,
0.0343700908,
0.0201663356,
-0.0187983364,
0.0340194628,
-0.0279012658,
-0.0497124605,
-0.028566312,
0.0178311579,
0.0129196113,
0.0797557309,
-0.0809102878,
0.0157879163,
-0.0199687202,
-0.0385875478,
-0.0441540219,
-0.042638842,
0.0116801066,
-0.0049161478,
-0.0587414689,
-0.0467410833,
-0.062485911,
0.0014546859,
-0.0439803824,
0.0464048125,
-0.0150786731,
-0.0095081106,
-0.0166292582,
0.0766760707,
0.0547197871,
0.0498241708,
0.0014235129,
0.0047221924,
-0.0361419097,
0.0427264683,
0.0061949426,
-0.000174929,
-0.0417908318,
0.015628757,
0.0115337195,
-0.0146147665,
-0.0095817158,
0.0272352099,
0.0609188192,
-0.0127549553,
-0.02715105,
0.0606637895,
0.0163589362,
-0.014097794,
0.0271323584,
0.0010498062,
0.0387456641,
0.0298045129,
0.005032544,
-0.0565867834,
-0.0441999398,
-0.0119866952,
0.0031428516,
0.0041842214,
-0.0570682809,
0.024371691,
-0.1163665205,
0.0189014561,
0.0040782709,
-0.0356993861,
-0.0425018668,
-0.0390247181,
0.0461384431,
-0.0340350084,
0.0303203203,
-0.0402358919,
0.0021457677,
-0.01412863,
0.0394257121,
-0.0131439548,
-0.0650339648,
0.0056174402,
-0.0553435683,
0.0064139813,
0.055277098,
0.0211291742,
-0.0339315012,
0.0027861707,
0.0363849886,
-0.0177556537,
0.015569645,
0.0080569917,
0.0712938234,
0.0006121743,
-0.0260539055,
0.0453812778,
0.0082546752,
-0.0613730401,
-0.0069701201,
0.0139074167,
0.0730310008,
0.0060010497,
-0.0224621315,
-0.0599263236,
-0.0330971926,
0.0257742554,
0.0358270034,
-0.0069585606,
-0.051504463,
-0.035289377,
-0.0154591184,
-0.0228774268,
-0.0127659822,
-0.0227908306,
0.0285672881,
0.0187577549,
-0.0658701137,
-0.1205042452,
-0.017570924,
-0.0386573449,
0.0407215841,
0.0312243439,
-0.0267632604,
0.0281675812,
-0.0030723535,
-0.0777431503,
0.0291576367,
-0.0251377989,
0.0267068595,
-0.0308868717,
0.0331113786,
0.0191392526,
0.0196529049,
-0.0285389964,
0.0376978628,
-0.0541817918,
-0.0643139705,
0.014021026,
0.0055540022,
0.0181789007,
0.0316389464,
-0.0209700055,
-0.0112116728,
0.0450321771,
0.0663938969,
0.0242852196,
0.0437742397,
0.0236370564,
-0.0551572293,
-0.0219154302,
0.0346418694,
-0.0374673791,
0.0285346154,
0.0287990477,
0.0099838646,
0.0012104041,
-0.0413476303,
0.0120541779,
-0.0486696586,
0.0701564997,
0.0135649182,
-0.0511451699,
0.0140146734,
-0.010490126,
-0.0038967738,
-0.015169126,
-0.0111170979,
-0.0130277425,
0.0264519937,
0.0184574667,
-0.0273944344,
0.038184423,
-0.0206192806,
0.0350130275,
-0.0262847878,
-0.0055442364,
0.0947573483,
0.0313017629,
-0.0156645607,
0.0322830677,
0.0157710612,
-0.0050664442,
-0.0011179482,
0.0454727449,
-0.0040582647,
0.0387341157,
0.0236702263,
0.0080336276,
-0.0115296915,
0.0045433939,
-0.0565046705,
0.0212817304,
-0.0265653152,
0.0316872075,
0.0455127992,
-0.0548969842,
0.0310976636,
0.0134555586,
-0.0097535299,
-0.0547821373,
0.0188244935,
0.0186165422,
0.0176230054,
0.055574581,
0.0171320438,
-0.0161254629,
0.0248652846,
0.046297051,
0.029856896,
0.0612949096,
0.0091231652,
-0.0061510587,
-0.0356355868,
-0.0124319335,
0.003767672,
-0.0366554111,
0.0088672992,
0.0174183752,
-0.0357172601,
-0.0680299997,
0.0125553189,
-0.0126516894,
0.0295062941,
0.0244503841,
0.0247266218,
0.0672930405,
0.0107040387,
0.0023333412,
-0.0150609547,
-0.0082103088,
0.0063740318,
0.0136770364,
-0.0356824137,
-5.909809971e-33,
-0.014100831,
-0.0246849302,
-0.0048091337,
-0.0252364445,
0.0159961134,
-0.022065999,
0.0067847446,
0.0257506669,
-0.0427417122,
0.0175936613,
-0.0051058903,
0.0279849581,
0.0260480791,
0.0132859349,
-0.0253773741,
-0.0377957746,
0.0370034836,
-0.0054835472,
-0.0344711021,
-0.0443159826,
0.0104241418,
0.0448567942,
0.0826391056,
-0.0917945802,
-0.0023654897,
0.0389729701,
-0.0214366503,
0.0201605801,
0.0530176945,
0.0555946082,
0.0001225939,
0.0707609132,
0.0291067176,
-0.0193559956,
-0.0160564538,
0.0131691508,
-0.066218555,
-0.003335753,
0.0031294809,
0.0599947795,
-0.0009855423,
-0.0132384142,
0.0484364964,
-0.0111334519,
0.0010311076,
-0.0660516694,
0.0608150661,
-0.0661310926,
-0.0122642033,
-0.0077022854,
-0.0820020437,
0.0461988151,
-0.0014641414,
-0.0083527397,
-0.0166923031,
0.0374848507,
0.0301439613,
-0.0175115895,
-0.0364230983,
-0.0177515056,
0.0213705078,
0.049244605,
0.0449089408,
0.0171974245,
-0.0418901406,
0.0539933629,
-0.0167777538,
-0.0119500468,
0.0213275366,
-0.0502214357,
0.0366170928,
0.0113728046,
0.0264077429,
0.0921064988,
0.0525311604,
-0.0101839639,
-0.0786852986,
0.0046633212,
-0.0447196998,
-0.0046942448,
-0.0237601791,
0.027285533,
-0.0579365119,
0.0042626895,
-0.0036840993,
0.0060104621,
-0.0303457975,
-0.0253389571,
0.069356896,
0.0016319703,
-0.0067254626,
0.0603366122,
0.0067697517,
-0.0712509379,
-0.0293802079,
-0.003346927,
-0.0147452336,
0.0037154909,
0.0087463576,
-0.0039266399,
0.0065716607,
-0.0421083868,
0.0224774238,
0.0446331799,
0.0277884398,
-0.0345675163,
0.0557886101,
0.0282346401,
-0.0743894204,
-0.0058697304,
-0.0005288555,
0.0143151246,
0.0069152331,
0.1037451252,
0.0165484343,
-0.0048143631,
-0.0306618977,
0.0404068381,
0.0325696953,
-0.037487559,
-0.0214785971,
0.0630400106,
0.0019577486,
0.0237312168,
-0.0473115407,
-0.0346779935,
0.0192869678,
0.0349395871,
0.0233830903,
-0.0704468861,
-0.0193650704,
-0.020242719,
2.566e-7,
0.0824672878,
0.0635074675,
0.02476817,
-0.0188279543,
0.0180924218,
0.0306312349,
-0.0372701287,
0.057770703,
-0.0190995745,
-0.020413382,
-0.0097951666,
0.0069652372,
0.0156481583,
-0.0103231389,
-0.0580375008,
-0.037858367,
0.0106314551,
0.0150779001,
-0.0311637577,
-0.0252793841,
0.0634762049,
0.1171590537,
0.0161371976,
-0.0278224517,
0.0073086601,
-0.0846136361,
0.0611939095,
-0.0126749454,
0.0134929568,
-0.03268978,
-0.0134136835,
0.0105385492,
0.0028888294,
0.0245619658,
-0.0210466702,
0.0277058836,
0.0323222913,
0.0490854569,
-0.0405780748,
-0.0083729057,
-0.0306171421,
0.0277695321,
-0.0010651817,
-0.0252998136,
0.0643140674,
-0.0596509464,
-0.0228178278,
-0.0514088161,
-0.0459512882,
-0.0001859304,
0.0261047874,
0.0226306412,
-0.0049488037,
0.0289931893,
0.0542021468,
0.0281030796,
-0.0452335067,
-0.0760436431,
-0.0285185967,
0.007889118,
-0.0183653068,
-0.0051158438,
-0.0229123533,
0.0070761344,
0.0417794771,
-0.0602877364,
0.0108276429,
2.259990745e-34,
0.0310012698,
0.0269440468,
-0.006910292,
0.0020137785,
-0.005778078,
-0.0065902532,
-0.0109385531,
-0.0157248676,
0.0035129376,
-0.0259120651,
0.0157663003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14840v1 | Transparency at the Source: Evaluating and Interpreting Language Models With Access to the True Distribution | 2023-10-23T12:03:01 | 2023-10-23T12:03:01 | Jaap Jumelet, Willem Zuidema | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a setup for training, evaluating and interpreting neural language
models, that uses artificial, language-like data. The data is generated using a
massive probabilistic grammar (based on state-split PCFGs), that is itself
derived from a large natural language corpus, but also provides us complete
control over the generative process. We describe and release both grammar and
corpus, and test for the naturalness of our generated data. This approach
allows us to define closed-form expressions to efficiently compute exact lower
bounds on obtainable perplexity using both causal and masked language
modelling. Our results show striking differences between neural language
modelling architectures and training objectives in how closely they allow
approximating the lower bound on perplexity. Our approach also allows us to
directly compare learned representations to symbolic rules in the underlying
source. We experiment with various techniques for interpreting model behaviour
and learning dynamics. With access to the underlying true source, our results
show striking differences and outcomes in learning dynamics between different
classes of words. | [
0.0059286151,
0.1034702882,
-0.0295952316,
0.040002089,
-0.0500801541,
-0.0029222982,
-0.00856396,
-0.0061179758,
-0.0509814061,
-0.0213282984,
0.0065754019,
-0.0544109978,
-0.0182948709,
0.0623801835,
0.0505524874,
-0.0042316616,
0.0646231398,
-0.035146974,
0.0197410248,
-0.0026729489,
-0.0055429544,
-0.003227294,
-0.0084275389,
0.0591648892,
-0.0320993029,
0.0020408863,
-0.0022275455,
-0.0032378545,
-0.0524293296,
-0.0239040107,
-0.0238062385,
0.0426007695,
-0.0146606332,
0.0742238313,
0.0000020073,
-0.0367082581,
0.0020113005,
0.0120292613,
-0.0282029752,
0.0283412784,
0.0580333471,
-0.0097865239,
0.0048714993,
-0.0029890996,
-0.0539386012,
-0.0430469885,
0.0666970462,
0.026254965,
0.0414878987,
0.0828654692,
0.0013732056,
-0.0303089339,
0.0386770479,
-0.0505357757,
-0.0108981002,
-0.0226467755,
0.0143072642,
-0.0225940067,
-0.0243340079,
-0.0265496224,
-0.0357932001,
0.0190390609,
0.0422100984,
0.0094106365,
-0.0061753434,
0.0356699377,
0.0126158549,
-0.0395267345,
0.0062471605,
0.0603020862,
-0.03109123,
-0.0381253287,
0.0075761392,
-0.0175025016,
-0.0076484792,
0.0040403348,
-0.0161392502,
0.0063077137,
0.0149581907,
0.0600780919,
0.0327091925,
0.0032680144,
0.0742168427,
0.0131474119,
-0.0471997447,
0.0450714715,
0.0269270334,
-0.0070411023,
-0.0417764522,
-0.0253110658,
-0.0320262238,
-0.0180230755,
-0.0008275224,
0.0048781391,
0.0030949761,
0.0391103141,
-0.0283325501,
-0.0428043045,
0.0212045796,
-0.046099145,
0.0414646491,
0.0184627939,
0.0046345904,
0.0575860366,
-0.004463979,
0.03835354,
-0.0221044943,
0.0540835485,
-0.0238460731,
0.0206507053,
-0.0518389456,
-0.0337252282,
-0.0281079449,
0.0087895021,
-0.0530950055,
-0.030536348,
-0.0165627599,
-0.03540067,
-0.011585989,
-0.0034663766,
0.0264960341,
-0.0113657741,
-0.0407394879,
-0.0078014112,
-0.0119866198,
-0.0052914363,
-0.0132013476,
0.0086737461,
0.0162436422,
-0.0590668619,
-0.0358902588,
-0.0131180678,
-0.0093532326,
-0.0079451753,
-0.0109250741,
0.0652687326,
0.0249960497,
-0.0262668431,
0.0187411699,
-0.0276476834,
-0.0237411838,
-0.040970657,
0.0128886662,
-0.0437136292,
0.0247745775,
-0.0159301665,
-0.0138129033,
-0.0628691092,
0.0329855606,
0.009221266,
-0.0071368273,
0.0922272205,
0.0094691301,
0.018266663,
-0.0114880558,
0.0049473918,
0.0305651072,
0.0667382106,
0.0501762182,
-0.0344210044,
0.028354872,
-0.0299144853,
0.018959647,
0.031783849,
0.0303592402,
-0.0262992531,
-0.0433341078,
-0.0522911288,
0.0082662664,
-0.0109900227,
0.029332906,
0.0569942407,
-0.0380512588,
-0.025358364,
0.0286420397,
0.0105562564,
-0.0027303556,
0.0215615146,
0.0326820314,
0.0209837705,
0.0133078033,
0.0057425355,
-0.0432560518,
-0.0345630571,
0.018919047,
0.0163425747,
-0.000533855,
0.0117395269,
-0.0097114416,
-0.0473250337,
-0.0008846855,
-0.0160479136,
0.0599919669,
-0.0184951406,
0.0847260058,
0.0455147326,
-0.052125968,
0.0851598531,
0.0548002757,
-0.03486396,
0.0416417532,
-0.0500389934,
0.0043407604,
0.0547854453,
0.0672483221,
-0.0290616527,
0.0141272843,
0.0315721817,
-0.0214321185,
0.0515147857,
0.0064620827,
0.0421695486,
0.0552141033,
-0.0218575448,
0.0173120592,
-0.0221693311,
0.0500429422,
0.0189245008,
-0.0068149148,
-0.026697671,
0.0106138792,
-0.055851277,
-0.0170429349,
0.0728462264,
-0.0381938554,
-0.0292610396,
-0.0011000902,
-0.0185569972,
0.0329498127,
-0.0028012064,
-0.0318138078,
0.077121608,
0.0290503353,
-0.070322074,
0.0183650348,
0.0149182538,
-0.0490595959,
-0.0237378832,
0.0487580225,
-0.0417751446,
0.0272462908,
0.0579749905,
-0.0257444978,
-0.0287488196,
0.076397188,
-0.0475922599,
0.0686129853,
-0.0680280775,
0.0122820875,
-0.0057663303,
0.0492452607,
-0.0502521172,
0.0554369576,
-0.0201539323,
0.0389110968,
-0.0159162041,
-0.0020648569,
0.0536805987,
-0.0137104504,
-0.0157738477,
-0.021852117,
-0.0208735112,
-0.0092905443,
-0.0196922868,
-0.0007143674,
-0.0166607648,
-0.0350626223,
-0.032606367,
-0.0479902253,
-0.001180363,
0.0063414457,
0.0191225149,
-0.0213594828,
0.0054453709,
-0.0078517227,
-0.0054310514,
0.0003677445,
0.0114913071,
-0.0102792336,
0.0466616005,
0.023195684,
-0.0761831179,
-0.0691141412,
-0.0324816816,
-0.0380302258,
0.0796608701,
0.0122706499,
-0.0098218527,
-0.052344881,
0.0215621069,
-0.0257503204,
0.0562054999,
-0.0318490565,
-0.0635359213,
0.0180450846,
-0.0432591066,
-0.0206613615,
0.0224409159,
-0.0236232448,
0.0217166711,
0.0501420163,
0.0015685892,
-0.0518475436,
-0.0130142448,
-0.0588585846,
0.0081921993,
-0.0357150845,
-0.006514011,
-0.0119098574,
0.0716547668,
0.0324743427,
-0.0379161797,
-0.0744846538,
0.0521715768,
-0.0344872735,
-0.0547534972,
-0.0085629141,
-0.0142836608,
-0.0357119441,
0.0420177206,
-0.0528597236,
-0.0651388019,
0.0542291552,
-0.0311106443,
0.0099412305,
-0.0229516216,
0.0083872229,
-0.0386384465,
0.0850925148,
0.0438075624,
0.0233486425,
-0.0117555289,
-0.0291787665,
-0.0464993641,
-0.0117729129,
0.0067207115,
-0.0369013324,
-0.0028018414,
-0.0662884638,
0.0104515441,
0.0350340679,
-0.0292687621,
-0.0348200649,
-0.0855345353,
-0.0209024698,
0.0265177339,
0.0504388623,
-0.0079946658,
0.0075208531,
0.0172128156,
-0.0026421682,
0.0371174403,
0.0185390282,
0.0139757078,
-0.0226374455,
0.0038855735,
0.0375359021,
-0.0259173699,
0.0318473056,
-0.029898027,
0.0047388026,
0.0340532549,
0.0241447054,
0.0633919761,
-0.040803425,
0.0002896861,
-0.0156780072,
-0.0085336603,
-0.0124862064,
0.0172762852,
0.0067916135,
-0.0734368041,
-0.052164115,
0.1085474864,
0.0413398556,
-0.0489544608,
0.0485459305,
-0.0065486096,
0.0189787559,
0.0087643815,
0.0293797962,
-0.0645224825,
-0.003085149,
0.0017907341,
0.0006799813,
0.0191793982,
-0.0206122287,
-0.0070745936,
-0.1212873161,
0.0026656457,
0.0108313141,
-0.0211916342,
-0.0283147395,
-0.0461712368,
-0.0323098898,
0.006728081,
-0.0166004505,
0.0161296949,
0.0266442616,
0.0151276207,
0.0259259883,
0.0018780488,
-0.0393140763,
0.0053949696,
-0.0401817299,
0.0470325947,
0.0789926797,
-0.0113168946,
-0.0187763292,
-0.0621123277,
0.016028937,
0.0033736862,
0.0070334901,
0.0113236262,
0.0308837257,
0.0464493223,
-0.0440405756,
-0.0036101444,
0.0001258899,
-0.0398667753,
-0.011514822,
-0.0379506126,
0.0496635213,
0.0067615379,
-0.0340911895,
0.0059135663,
0.0053627975,
0.0105030667,
0.0794801638,
0.0655004606,
-0.0366615802,
-0.0359978825,
-0.0219053626,
0.0445886515,
-0.0425451994,
-0.0288577359,
0.0187073816,
0.0612086691,
-0.0388796553,
-0.0654209182,
0.0060725566,
-0.0122481957,
0.0425320677,
0.0184315499,
0.0133441314,
0.0173941422,
-0.0127336169,
-0.0239181127,
0.0126468977,
-0.0062082573,
0.0274557788,
-0.0375060253,
-0.037165232,
0.0319148973,
-0.0015206812,
-0.038121637,
0.0029913457,
-0.0716924146,
-0.0655862316,
0.039727848,
0.0438554175,
0.0275388807,
0.0111222807,
-0.0320917219,
-0.053213384,
-0.0068356646,
0.032875143,
-0.0261998866,
0.0384435952,
0.039659325,
-0.0126609001,
0.0154278297,
0.0623669662,
-0.0349880084,
0.0044585727,
0.0113284262,
0.0658292472,
-0.0238838363,
0.0228962582,
0.0298455395,
0.0332841389,
0.0526693091,
-0.0305897146,
0.0009538382,
-0.0262334496,
-0.0055843988,
-0.0313306302,
-0.0032951389,
-0.0762477815,
0.0004532893,
0.049688559,
-0.0099383118,
-0.0027986914,
-0.0283335671,
0.0038029472,
0.0535107814,
0.0054707252,
-0.0259450767,
-0.0142936641,
-0.0213085134,
-0.002322302,
0.0049336487,
-0.00339897,
0.0375453196,
-0.0435980819,
0.0104462784,
-0.0249972865,
0.0124605875,
0.0264039747,
-0.0024460978,
-0.0833585486,
0.0024125143,
-0.0504291691,
-0.0210950393,
0.0174117815,
-0.0211767573,
0.0374915786,
0.0187133197,
0.0345570445,
-0.0222237632,
-0.0061796536,
-0.0113095473,
0.0312391687,
0.0282184463,
-0.0436184965,
0.0340781249,
0.0210157167,
-0.0065287855,
-0.0289242081,
0.1229529604,
0.0549958721,
0.0430596843,
0.0011687158,
0.0319166593,
-0.0224397089,
-0.0022870128,
-0.0096894782,
0.0615848973,
-0.0192232411,
0.0291556492,
-0.0537716486,
-0.102189444,
-0.0186017193,
0.0323456898,
0.0168780424,
-0.0122443475,
0.0300735179,
0.0267161708,
-0.0216589216,
-0.0190278906,
-0.038434241,
0.0239956751,
0.0275340043,
-0.020178983,
-0.0562362559,
-6.70544222e-33,
-0.0115769813,
-0.0222279467,
-0.0124560855,
0.0089727733,
-0.0065890327,
-0.0173723847,
-0.0635053292,
0.0231270697,
-0.003648513,
0.0251243971,
-0.0003727881,
0.0367612839,
0.0001336228,
0.0477866419,
-0.0224323999,
-0.0333434753,
0.0197765063,
-0.0247907229,
0.0284656957,
-0.0023239497,
0.0077033588,
0.0370155387,
0.0493886136,
-0.0844495967,
0.0018200764,
0.0107943136,
-0.0267088134,
0.0360444151,
-0.02083911,
0.0629310459,
-0.0313617177,
0.0218024123,
0.0057354206,
-0.0308716614,
-0.0152243292,
-0.0331656151,
0.0001584734,
-0.0345760807,
0.0444249883,
-0.0115184737,
-0.0217496306,
-0.0276393406,
0.0582263023,
-0.0344033986,
-0.0273777898,
0.0364852957,
0.0103463354,
-0.0126589732,
-0.0359981731,
0.0014007229,
-0.0333504975,
0.0310044885,
0.0050512888,
-0.0001325458,
0.0150608215,
-0.0010459397,
-0.0413696133,
0.0213511605,
-0.0272875894,
0.0116956513,
0.0303364247,
0.0443703718,
0.0495141931,
0.0414146222,
0.045813892,
0.0719846487,
0.0762158483,
-0.013395655,
-0.0692957267,
-0.000026305,
0.077743426,
0.0492543802,
0.0619138442,
0.0339993164,
0.0609622709,
0.0069234297,
-0.0807098001,
-0.052324906,
0.0035045191,
0.0115391808,
0.0374867804,
-0.0075552193,
-0.0739153996,
-0.0471692197,
-0.0716146603,
-0.0385342315,
-0.0289078839,
-0.0009499862,
0.0325437821,
0.0182241704,
-0.0210346151,
-0.0567028038,
-0.0105838832,
-0.0626031533,
-0.0169512592,
0.0244229324,
0.0121715125,
0.0112180552,
0.0042598173,
0.0078396974,
-0.0505851991,
-0.0258954018,
-0.0125112338,
0.006498063,
0.0227694977,
-0.0145798502,
0.0182645321,
0.0032153116,
-0.035172835,
0.0028249007,
-0.035622295,
-0.0165380407,
0.0339310393,
0.0138966953,
0.0410781614,
0.0143889543,
-0.0180483274,
-0.002073247,
0.0438369587,
0.0311330669,
0.0061320527,
0.0457657576,
0.0174939539,
0.0444278866,
-0.0077132117,
-0.0429037586,
-0.0362864658,
0.0230242908,
0.0760079771,
-0.0599924512,
-0.0161328521,
0.035207022,
2.782e-7,
0.0801770613,
0.0448688418,
0.0175142847,
0.0539215952,
0.042377539,
0.0108636543,
-0.0080920784,
-0.0059628012,
-0.0444697291,
-0.02238857,
-0.0267536882,
0.0443065353,
0.0505171679,
-0.0004523451,
-0.0628547594,
0.0069814138,
-0.0351786315,
0.0208140351,
-0.023371134,
-0.0099109309,
0.000490258,
0.1264050305,
0.0076769162,
0.0133785373,
0.0126877194,
-0.0726035163,
0.0401451886,
-0.0252423938,
0.0136772487,
-0.0034957058,
-0.0059614885,
-0.0162635036,
0.0229664575,
0.0099498862,
-0.0053435341,
0.042574957,
-0.0029574817,
0.0578834005,
-0.019809654,
-0.0336416364,
-0.0082809189,
-0.0268625524,
-0.0185881425,
-0.0487967841,
0.0317894295,
-0.0401897542,
-0.0304227658,
-0.0098673096,
-0.030644482,
-0.0037352988,
0.0199243352,
-0.0028385262,
-0.0633368418,
0.0023674502,
0.0242482405,
-0.0293027814,
0.0121580092,
-0.0397037491,
-0.0484358035,
-0.0571367703,
-0.0459648445,
-0.0229085535,
-0.0239246599,
0.0076356102,
0.0354855284,
0.0028330332,
0.0249199346,
2.800354708e-34,
0.0735267028,
-0.0323755294,
0.0103693428,
0.0144787114,
0.0421015732,
-0.0000770857,
0.0035188431,
0.0130143845,
0.0247154646,
-0.1028795019,
-0.0094570098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14829v1 | Characterizing how 'distributional' NLP corpora distance metrics are | 2023-10-23T11:48:23 | 2023-10-23T11:48:23 | Samuel Ackerman, George Kour, Eitan Farchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | A corpus of vector-embedded text documents has some empirical distribution.
Given two corpora, we want to calculate a single metric of distance (e.g.,
Mauve, Frechet Inception) between them. We describe an abstract quality, called
`distributionality', of such metrics. A non-distributional metric tends to use
very local measurements, or uses global measurements in a way that does not
fully reflect the distributions' true distance. For example, if individual
pairwise nearest-neighbor distances are low, it may judge the two corpora to
have low distance, even if their two distributions are in fact far from each
other. A more distributional metric will, in contrast, better capture the
distributions' overall distance. We quantify this quality by constructing a
Known-Similarity Corpora set from two paraphrase corpora and calculating the
distance between paired corpora from it. The distances' trend shape as set
element separation increases should quantify the distributionality of the
metric. We propose that Average Hausdorff Distance and energy distance between
corpora are representative examples of non-distributional and distributional
distance metrics, to which other metrics can be compared, to evaluate how
distributional they are. | [
0.0218791552,
0.0487926565,
-0.0273492187,
0.0236753244,
-0.071754925,
-0.0043046209,
-0.0408255793,
0.0572327487,
-0.0639670268,
-0.0540415309,
-0.0105927754,
-0.0274169557,
0.0427538045,
-0.0412660278,
0.0034831245,
-0.0597705171,
0.0087687429,
0.031921003,
-0.0288943667,
0.0107783666,
0.0283370465,
-0.0401529744,
0.0031757397,
0.027213661,
0.0385941528,
0.0040163952,
0.0019557832,
-0.0055302302,
0.0336001441,
-0.0000583872,
0.0357682407,
0.0267429594,
-0.0292538945,
0.0243239664,
0.0000013812,
-0.0567101836,
-0.0154327797,
0.003711228,
0.0567720644,
-0.0303402469,
0.0506520085,
-0.0386034325,
0.0100385342,
-0.0026679644,
-0.0008241021,
-0.0257957969,
0.0670422912,
-0.0320719108,
0.0135334106,
0.0410647579,
-0.0105711799,
-0.0449044406,
0.0308022182,
-0.0037484344,
-0.0071553737,
0.0093848053,
-0.0095059052,
0.0165892821,
-0.0134506496,
0.0156441852,
-0.0443723388,
0.027303908,
-0.0413611494,
0.04308879,
0.0486297682,
0.0186329912,
-0.042746827,
-0.0270007383,
0.0124663562,
0.0495724306,
-0.0173892546,
-0.0379191935,
0.0171827842,
-0.0016525881,
-0.0351492092,
0.0814103708,
-0.0004719396,
0.0053473986,
-0.0408670604,
0.0110810325,
-0.0011157624,
0.041926112,
0.0077671879,
0.0093685174,
-0.0190070849,
0.0132245533,
0.0273344535,
-0.0369863473,
-0.0042827292,
0.0369739868,
-0.0120069291,
-0.0312064961,
0.0262342524,
-0.007299352,
0.0232028477,
0.0054355604,
-0.00270752,
-0.0446916893,
0.0413846858,
-0.0406858698,
0.036095351,
-0.0040480485,
0.0014881697,
0.0222495273,
0.0077821035,
0.0273207556,
-0.0094272383,
0.010237894,
-0.040059343,
0.0059745722,
-0.0859223753,
0.0331848636,
0.0163183678,
-0.0125334989,
-0.0142453089,
-0.0345011055,
-0.0100497054,
0.0169928167,
-0.0049122437,
-0.0016731531,
-0.0015099793,
-0.0217841808,
0.0182576552,
0.0437629819,
-0.0399317034,
-0.0075559849,
-0.0856688619,
0.0111338785,
-0.0759220347,
0.0048763198,
-0.0006180933,
0.0477488786,
0.0204621367,
-0.0181410275,
0.0013792854,
0.012522771,
0.0294211563,
-0.0408129133,
0.0008407781,
0.0299603287,
0.0167099964,
-0.0394250043,
-0.0001151466,
-0.1093638986,
0.0186446141,
0.0119935321,
-0.0251132082,
-0.0087821204,
-0.0145442132,
0.0126469517,
-0.0602336638,
0.0534796417,
-0.0113780517,
0.0304852426,
0.0243895538,
-0.03465534,
0.0315101147,
0.0268234499,
0.0204189979,
-0.0555638671,
0.0942882448,
0.006709978,
-0.0448740087,
-0.0061569987,
0.0098727793,
0.0109633896,
0.0000476229,
0.025058873,
-0.037542738,
0.0294182301,
0.0110603198,
0.0288903601,
-0.0562953353,
-0.0246359706,
0.0404426083,
0.1106127501,
0.0338338949,
-0.0411102138,
-0.0090646418,
-0.0077340123,
-0.0223187841,
0.0413355045,
0.0137532931,
-0.0646756887,
-0.0089435643,
0.0173262917,
0.0727843791,
0.0455723777,
0.00268545,
-0.0419006795,
-0.0327942707,
-0.0697748512,
0.0053172251,
-0.0954900458,
0.0023061689,
-0.019554317,
0.0101524945,
0.0433879718,
0.0020158745,
-0.0166056715,
0.0015862996,
0.0505572893,
-0.0090328287,
0.0159183443,
0.0028452517,
-0.0309285112,
0.0298692305,
0.0085299267,
-0.0422394536,
0.0270546731,
-0.0147437463,
-0.0092861773,
0.0058194478,
-0.0040939748,
0.0010155364,
0.0035831393,
0.0259992555,
-0.0225483272,
0.0044635967,
0.0407617576,
-0.0014398977,
-0.0919723585,
0.0257391632,
0.0295257475,
0.0032047543,
0.035140194,
-0.0173796043,
0.0246060807,
0.0182842314,
0.0312714912,
-0.0342753716,
0.0256537441,
-0.0240003355,
-0.0563608371,
-0.0427987538,
0.0271717273,
0.0299053136,
-0.0013582319,
0.0330867209,
-0.0505822152,
0.0644863769,
0.0074770837,
-0.0113816438,
-0.0056321933,
0.0239714924,
-0.0221385118,
0.0244162716,
-0.0407265387,
0.0557274744,
-0.0352307782,
0.0183595065,
-0.0758600384,
0.0731333047,
0.0097179767,
0.1117675304,
-0.0407560952,
0.0492284633,
0.0726637617,
0.027002709,
0.006393319,
0.0100077689,
0.0252134148,
0.0071995151,
0.0609427094,
-0.0132213701,
-0.0372656249,
-0.0289329346,
-0.0146750137,
0.0438006856,
-0.0063309758,
0.0419642217,
0.0672933161,
0.0015325209,
-0.0262497086,
0.0105840527,
-0.007629761,
0.0035417737,
0.0023934641,
-0.0001346837,
0.1040166989,
-0.0005472616,
-0.030593697,
-0.0471379347,
-0.0262194257,
0.0205010362,
0.0438007005,
-0.0205534063,
-0.0000536938,
-0.0614910163,
0.0628271624,
-0.0671499223,
0.0408120453,
0.0246172231,
-0.0478740893,
-0.0008885472,
0.010930445,
0.0346076749,
0.0445506722,
0.0418441743,
-0.012001479,
0.0482794456,
0.0149721876,
-0.0496282838,
-0.0437294953,
-0.0421917439,
0.0190130118,
-0.0333832875,
0.0162861366,
0.0457812101,
0.0358904079,
0.037659198,
-0.0553707331,
-0.0269134268,
0.0231022798,
-0.0367496759,
0.0338345841,
0.0072108451,
0.0147413071,
-0.0301326122,
0.0493481904,
0.0019018082,
-0.0501110628,
0.026442131,
-0.0432406366,
0.0775946379,
-0.0909348428,
-0.0506616086,
-0.0417960398,
0.007285093,
0.0081422953,
0.0041836319,
0.0026949279,
-0.0223273765,
-0.0223008022,
0.022857219,
0.0339908041,
0.0019906766,
0.0267055053,
-0.0169671755,
0.0038446875,
-0.018466888,
-0.024935266,
0.0036792725,
-0.0422600061,
0.0395544879,
-0.0099819181,
0.0469881371,
-0.0414193012,
-0.0001597667,
0.0141692646,
0.0018700045,
0.0387898386,
0.02151547,
-0.0057518226,
-0.036599081,
0.1072490364,
0.0244475342,
0.0365400352,
-0.0209989827,
0.0045958231,
-0.0647042617,
0.015374193,
0.0229447912,
0.0358290002,
-0.0119454628,
-0.0298688132,
0.0097355777,
-0.0386474505,
-0.0702857375,
-0.0205252096,
0.0643114299,
0.0491619408,
-0.0355186425,
0.1008150727,
0.0470454618,
-0.0303585716,
0.0277444068,
0.0056630191,
0.0739901662,
0.0107711041,
-0.0350079089,
-0.049988918,
0.0132203316,
-0.0043864078,
-0.0057938467,
-0.0259272363,
-0.0436198749,
-0.0147279184,
-0.0690325648,
-0.0476977788,
-0.0075087175,
-0.0175797604,
-0.0444881395,
-0.0632508174,
0.0477942042,
0.0305326991,
-0.0616509542,
-0.0514502861,
0.0014353634,
0.0402387902,
0.0162875894,
-0.061515294,
-0.0797406286,
-0.0178209618,
-0.0617758818,
-0.0089893201,
0.0053347154,
0.050108932,
-0.0117219416,
-0.0364506319,
-0.0725632533,
-0.1033087224,
0.002730153,
0.0239279289,
0.0508845448,
0.0086139534,
0.0110681513,
0.0011214468,
-0.003783569,
-0.0213117152,
0.001384975,
0.0218346324,
0.0254296064,
0.0201400053,
-0.0278739594,
-0.0301064122,
-0.0121553307,
0.0247432888,
0.0480925813,
-0.0060117133,
-0.0003582685,
-0.035478007,
0.0304413158,
0.0571712889,
0.0142962225,
-0.0139393089,
0.0097502628,
-0.0079896292,
-0.020618597,
-0.1046248227,
-0.039238669,
-0.0999067202,
0.0569149181,
0.0015244668,
0.0317579024,
-0.0155457342,
-0.022812793,
-0.0336717181,
-0.0248902366,
0.0220542103,
-0.0055349316,
0.0037258712,
-0.0145202363,
0.0174548961,
0.0695858002,
-0.0643664896,
-0.0182076618,
-0.0978497863,
-0.0690074936,
-0.0422351733,
-0.0390116759,
0.0242894776,
-0.0044675665,
-0.019667564,
-0.041355487,
0.0628525168,
0.0535779707,
-0.0432280488,
0.0245548263,
0.0254518781,
-0.0397011042,
0.013511694,
0.012756777,
-0.0417006649,
0.0038637531,
-0.0162911788,
0.0450950749,
-0.0207220726,
-0.0381854437,
0.0015847062,
0.0099902637,
0.0399415307,
-0.0303962529,
-0.012133277,
-0.0124816848,
-0.017216444,
0.0100806039,
0.0129536092,
0.0160777345,
-0.0249978155,
0.0534448363,
0.0118180336,
-0.0380836464,
0.0942940935,
-0.0049827294,
0.0519461222,
-0.0049006776,
0.0048485738,
0.0901304558,
0.0237192493,
-0.0312148146,
0.0303776171,
-0.0018788313,
-0.0608682893,
-0.0211092401,
0.0118335132,
-0.0362038948,
0.0281180199,
0.0394308493,
-0.0068745124,
0.0192089248,
0.0739303902,
-0.0694472939,
0.0392382666,
0.0249777585,
0.0349958129,
0.0356452726,
-0.038705606,
0.0258907117,
-0.0035828897,
-0.0096111372,
-0.009622978,
0.0189454835,
0.0000423894,
0.0207028985,
0.0184482429,
0.0097443005,
-0.010438839,
0.0500372648,
0.1014641374,
-0.0267282259,
0.0216980241,
-0.0230530575,
-0.0408205166,
-0.0169697423,
0.0215699412,
0.0063344641,
-0.0062803244,
0.0092820777,
0.0232829638,
-0.0337908231,
-0.0323131941,
0.0407092385,
-0.0059181605,
-0.0006304723,
0.0282056835,
0.0208599642,
0.0801081732,
0.0028245186,
0.0250483714,
-0.0478717089,
0.0074093137,
-0.0348767079,
-0.0039504278,
-0.0355859138,
-5.276276923e-33,
-0.0054464098,
-0.0090330737,
-0.0749455243,
-0.0256116781,
-0.0223777089,
0.0104489718,
0.0136253927,
-0.0087356949,
-0.0445808135,
-0.0022026417,
0.0230748393,
0.0302091576,
-0.0018342293,
-0.0339257382,
-0.0223508105,
0.0035300227,
-0.0156512689,
0.0170017574,
-0.0412243307,
-0.0197990667,
0.0357769057,
0.0079688756,
0.036232587,
-0.0697479546,
0.0596035235,
-0.0313607827,
0.0543767549,
-0.0024839472,
0.0953831375,
0.0529362038,
-0.0241135824,
0.0857787281,
0.0298671089,
0.0010421614,
-0.0071798638,
0.0143364463,
-0.0320517123,
-0.0659475401,
0.0420591198,
-0.0142921973,
-0.0234164689,
-0.0077083763,
0.0213166326,
-0.0073265065,
-0.038410347,
-0.0339888819,
0.0745644793,
-0.0150856534,
-0.0125218583,
-0.0068858308,
-0.0095619513,
0.0497259349,
-0.0315300561,
0.0293860268,
-0.0022269359,
-0.0338626802,
0.0241902843,
0.0221194308,
-0.0396275483,
0.025666533,
-0.0110968733,
0.0815312937,
-0.0044754138,
-0.0439945161,
0.0196965877,
0.0632286742,
-0.0037390937,
-0.0402859449,
0.0017462054,
0.0137372576,
0.0256179459,
-0.0013015051,
-0.0207503978,
0.0833867863,
0.0323539525,
0.0039941515,
-0.0627833381,
0.0182991885,
-0.0015113287,
-0.0223463885,
-0.0021327855,
0.007368654,
-0.0438233763,
0.0091690132,
-0.0083326278,
-0.0500865616,
0.0065161162,
-0.0493237711,
0.0073610921,
-0.0246844888,
0.0237153377,
-0.0043437853,
-0.0152131217,
-0.0218935031,
-0.025448814,
0.0416671224,
-0.0048812814,
0.0179822911,
0.0024699885,
-0.0017091691,
-0.0108724041,
-0.0491909832,
-0.0414318033,
0.0564634949,
0.0596882962,
-0.030469805,
0.0080197603,
-0.0103008207,
-0.0470218547,
-0.0184990298,
0.0024471718,
-0.0531898402,
-0.0659266785,
-0.0282077771,
0.0037368117,
0.0205296539,
-0.0041433233,
0.054992523,
0.0660415441,
0.0206845831,
0.005115415,
0.0278626345,
0.0036303988,
0.0260031503,
-0.0140454648,
-0.0245813895,
-0.0302455351,
0.0544261001,
0.0228270497,
-0.025686387,
0.0015077689,
-0.0458888113,
2.327e-7,
0.0565060414,
0.0508242622,
0.0338098034,
-0.0264514983,
0.0063118255,
-0.005933186,
-0.0051219789,
0.0370569676,
-0.0543425344,
-0.0592227951,
0.0015133119,
-0.0199917536,
-0.0178063661,
0.0046011447,
-0.0578820594,
0.0227620751,
-0.0702973604,
-0.0277059376,
-0.0468350537,
0.0215838812,
0.0311691072,
0.0416358635,
0.0330358334,
0.0315815173,
-0.0365068279,
-0.0735393167,
0.0363916531,
-0.0270102173,
-0.0099208811,
0.0373208337,
0.003776991,
-0.0488112308,
0.0263546072,
0.0277111158,
0.0122720301,
0.040730264,
0.0618701428,
-0.0019286018,
0.0112218028,
0.0063618775,
-0.0377563313,
-0.041825369,
-0.0171249602,
-0.0402747951,
0.0381622389,
0.03160524,
-0.0536874272,
-0.0024659054,
-0.0317875557,
0.0308304466,
0.0424810573,
0.0293969065,
-0.0459429286,
0.0012324452,
0.0053851162,
0.0283656716,
0.0080865435,
-0.0414076708,
-0.0362928733,
0.0516841821,
0.0033589271,
-0.0332208425,
0.0231817551,
-0.0121063786,
0.0413430631,
-0.0404740386,
0.019437544,
1.759927413e-34,
0.0196989626,
0.0183989052,
0.0188134406,
-0.0250254218,
0.0101026865,
-0.0357991345,
-0.0057394109,
-0.0126089295,
0.0036154622,
-0.0097395666,
0.027086474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14820v1 | ALCUNA: Large Language Models Meet New Knowledge | 2023-10-23T11:40:05 | 2023-10-23T11:40:05 | Xunjian Yin, Baizhou Huang, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid development of NLP, large-scale language models (LLMs) excel
in various tasks across multiple domains now. However, existing benchmarks may
not adequately measure these models' capabilities, especially when faced with
new knowledge. In this paper, we address the lack of benchmarks to evaluate
LLMs' ability to handle new knowledge, an important and challenging aspect in
the rapidly evolving world. We propose an approach called KnowGen that
generates new knowledge by altering existing entity attributes and
relationships, resulting in artificial entities that are distinct from
real-world entities. With KnowGen, we introduce a benchmark named ALCUNA to
assess LLMs' abilities in knowledge understanding, differentiation, and
association. We benchmark several LLMs, reveals that their performance in face
of new knowledge is not satisfactory, particularly in reasoning between new and
internal knowledge. We also explore the impact of entity similarity on the
model's understanding of entity knowledge and the influence of contextual
entities. We appeal to the need for caution when using LLMs in new scenarios or
with new knowledge, and hope that our benchmarks can help drive the development
of LLMs in face of new knowledge. | [
0.0451502688,
0.0414996929,
-0.0205788985,
0.0926285088,
-0.0191490743,
-0.0018551223,
-0.0053904047,
-0.0003329428,
0.0128082689,
-0.0600448921,
-0.0444358326,
-0.0265739802,
-0.0389618911,
0.0178830512,
0.0252050422,
0.0119085386,
0.039847184,
-0.0136480648,
0.0015979066,
-0.0070296144,
-0.0020074786,
0.0149114495,
0.0052279276,
0.0086430181,
-0.0159139577,
-0.0157388505,
0.0005858435,
-0.0053820671,
0.014951136,
-0.0455452949,
0.0014914233,
0.0407944694,
0.0150464708,
0.0742909983,
0.0000021988,
-0.0783135295,
-0.0405962653,
0.0012726866,
-0.0486606844,
0.0168362632,
0.0076189754,
-0.0055308733,
-0.0044664522,
-0.0181613173,
-0.0695556402,
-0.0269094035,
0.0421926193,
0.0265509132,
0.0275768451,
0.083201319,
-0.0162733905,
-0.0415171608,
0.0082289511,
-0.0323512219,
0.0048409426,
-0.0688543096,
0.0484318472,
0.0129058147,
0.0245184861,
-0.0061407099,
-0.0047655636,
0.0468563698,
0.0129112946,
0.0028263864,
0.0470692106,
0.0442678928,
0.0112284692,
0.0193890221,
0.0074695298,
0.0779686496,
-0.0102760857,
-0.0238054842,
0.0164477173,
0.0082794353,
-0.0183620621,
0.000898357,
-0.015816506,
-0.0184653234,
-0.0106500518,
0.0149539821,
0.0333256871,
-0.0077928212,
0.0527503416,
0.0417212807,
-0.0438603871,
0.0516034663,
0.0313912369,
-0.0203886777,
-0.0150001235,
0.0044787284,
-0.0352277458,
-0.062391378,
-0.0003389739,
0.0591469929,
-0.0229061693,
0.0464014858,
-0.0331632271,
-0.0008651684,
0.0309194941,
-0.0751913786,
0.0296266768,
0.0148948021,
0.0151993949,
0.0802244991,
-0.0620322526,
0.0560474433,
-0.0436501689,
-0.0140057225,
-0.0025494907,
-0.0178652871,
-0.0751520619,
-0.0214761104,
0.0013990405,
0.047545556,
-0.033206962,
-0.0130958548,
0.014237538,
0.0465419367,
-0.0011023319,
0.0545546636,
0.016992351,
-0.0288521294,
0.0098898159,
-0.0367506556,
-0.0703430697,
-0.0006001927,
-0.0506437235,
0.0129206749,
-0.0329026543,
-0.0556408651,
0.0183387939,
-0.0390726589,
-0.0118199913,
-0.026154384,
0.0112656709,
0.0816295967,
0.0085852491,
-0.0183340907,
-0.0383313373,
-0.0104719074,
-0.0230505448,
-0.074724108,
-0.0036553545,
-0.0727351904,
0.0349684656,
0.0256124195,
-0.0095219426,
-0.078497678,
0.0142724682,
-0.0156758092,
-0.0384035297,
0.0492010415,
-0.0281276535,
0.0413501114,
0.0278100781,
0.0200957917,
0.0315336362,
0.0817798153,
0.0165152475,
-0.0327831469,
0.0378070176,
0.0042804079,
-0.0305208657,
0.0498915873,
-0.0011387843,
0.0140419658,
-0.005318183,
0.0311336108,
-0.0033460427,
0.0446630269,
0.0178665388,
0.0639143288,
-0.005236879,
-0.0399926454,
0.0737007633,
0.0046430263,
-0.0150076915,
0.0298153535,
0.0499833114,
-0.0091425339,
0.0178823713,
-0.0221391935,
-0.0236539077,
-0.0000430555,
-0.0310662743,
-0.0054446184,
-0.0064774449,
0.041150976,
-0.0278179124,
-0.010078053,
-0.0168229435,
0.0002421726,
-0.0226829145,
-0.0206786264,
0.0435506441,
0.0433170944,
0.0186392609,
0.0718107074,
0.0379171558,
-0.0181002505,
0.0034374702,
-0.0342013165,
0.050506629,
0.0538452566,
0.0542214401,
-0.0467277803,
-0.0398833118,
0.0066513773,
-0.055919122,
0.0666089207,
0.049705632,
-0.0419000089,
-0.0033375819,
-0.0147556327,
0.0106143579,
-0.0179892704,
0.0294524282,
0.0326287374,
0.0430606976,
0.0150838951,
0.0118273655,
-0.0711565539,
0.0048270533,
0.0451178215,
-0.0780032575,
-0.005986663,
-0.0039839568,
0.0097148502,
-0.0056082369,
0.0565324351,
-0.0068383962,
0.0069388128,
0.0273193549,
-0.0360706225,
-0.0363113619,
-0.0004363781,
-0.0154389013,
-0.0228168443,
0.0588164404,
0.0161222592,
-0.0113247233,
-0.0122337658,
-0.001033198,
-0.0185529236,
0.0299079809,
0.0118764052,
0.096322611,
-0.0300568845,
0.0471499376,
-0.019617429,
0.0061615161,
-0.0241179112,
0.1061272249,
0.0101694698,
0.01540701,
0.0178887937,
0.0127214603,
0.01050709,
-0.0033557487,
-0.044899933,
0.0125177475,
0.0136223631,
-0.0021991485,
0.0200209636,
-0.0050865286,
-0.0560391955,
-0.0338855125,
-0.0639743134,
0.0370264724,
0.0001833201,
0.0348995961,
0.0408478118,
0.0074363942,
-0.023942465,
0.0001031335,
-0.0171803404,
-0.0004817427,
-0.0270703267,
0.0110084331,
0.0391804427,
0.034267664,
-0.0214617681,
-0.0416189879,
0.0202206653,
-0.0110262521,
0.0643705428,
-0.0011334971,
-0.0105144633,
-0.0430338494,
0.0605738536,
-0.0629135743,
0.0513726436,
-0.0112429503,
0.0080169914,
-0.0253194347,
-0.0315971226,
0.0571951829,
0.0376264229,
-0.0089153927,
0.0167609006,
0.0312086567,
-0.0227750558,
-0.0694729611,
0.010478559,
-0.0234170053,
-0.0124954795,
-0.0720883235,
0.0057617291,
-0.0046727876,
0.0698660538,
-0.0287234392,
-0.043842189,
-0.0344660357,
0.0465723649,
-0.027035078,
-0.0226682611,
-0.00587598,
-0.0103742247,
0.0147130983,
0.0170632135,
-0.036084801,
-0.0101244841,
0.0579413474,
-0.033162266,
0.0091733243,
-0.0215185769,
-0.003036357,
-0.0555433035,
0.0805097073,
0.008106512,
0.0262034498,
0.0092638964,
-0.0039118887,
-0.0329482667,
0.0388559885,
-0.0196544733,
-0.0420285054,
0.0818566009,
-0.0739213452,
0.0396857001,
0.0251813103,
-0.0347278975,
-0.0640037134,
0.012532861,
-0.0255568083,
0.0221615639,
0.0033781382,
-0.0272053462,
0.0140299024,
-0.0006509101,
0.0145117426,
0.0171476994,
0.0156300291,
-0.0192703344,
-0.0365752205,
0.0348390006,
0.0480737314,
-0.0017783145,
0.0132082235,
-0.0200053435,
0.0611991622,
0.0189768132,
0.0096731996,
-0.0485131592,
-0.037268497,
0.0011479517,
-0.008109591,
-0.0461409241,
-0.020321019,
-0.0063955886,
0.0307765771,
-0.0536600649,
0.0010938884,
0.1264059097,
0.0318127722,
-0.0347841345,
0.0185002424,
0.0129950475,
0.0154996552,
0.0325199775,
0.0330974646,
-0.0794714317,
-0.0211983752,
-0.0100332303,
-0.0468340255,
-0.0096713798,
-0.0922583938,
-0.0275778957,
-0.1414791644,
-0.0300611835,
-0.0357469395,
-0.0764786899,
-0.020763319,
-0.0408666246,
0.0271655358,
-0.0060690744,
-0.0011475373,
-0.0228112936,
-0.0167834908,
-0.0133351292,
0.0054653827,
-0.014567663,
-0.0661078691,
0.0248796865,
-0.0470593013,
0.0877650604,
0.054104805,
0.0456920937,
0.0014930587,
0.0145196104,
-0.025694333,
-0.0219748747,
0.0052313856,
-0.0232893117,
0.0359354094,
-0.0126815271,
-0.0150006153,
0.015209822,
-0.0201962776,
-0.0341731757,
0.000778707,
0.0152719216,
0.0626228899,
0.0190949086,
-0.0320803076,
0.0002946152,
-0.0410053916,
0.0150281936,
0.1013860554,
-0.0068829036,
-0.0161030274,
0.000871725,
-0.0175247956,
-0.0067357761,
0.0001664032,
-0.0310993064,
0.00422737,
-0.0244079772,
-0.0016681849,
-0.084083654,
-0.0268645175,
0.029272832,
0.0094603403,
0.0424809419,
0.0382037908,
0.0273169689,
-0.0370513313,
-0.0570773631,
-0.00341922,
-0.0482515879,
0.0266813114,
-0.0166387483,
-0.0204347372,
0.0540847816,
-0.0117505556,
-0.0314160474,
0.0134186866,
-0.0977390036,
-0.0798604637,
0.0042615701,
0.0020306706,
0.030428635,
0.0487992093,
-0.0383400507,
-0.0567708127,
0.0146573177,
0.0007197991,
-0.0502276085,
0.0194670297,
-0.0188725758,
0.01862932,
0.0087091336,
0.0559936427,
-0.0427393503,
0.0185915455,
0.0518048368,
0.0443971828,
-0.0602920465,
-0.065542385,
0.0149177946,
0.0337379538,
-0.0444590077,
0.0074158814,
-0.008574686,
-0.0330054238,
0.0074268784,
-0.0405594148,
-0.0166146606,
-0.0171316694,
-0.0307776611,
0.0358502194,
0.0371978693,
-0.0029892349,
0.0385012999,
0.0256312303,
0.0428529643,
-0.0224732328,
-0.0229499526,
0.015117269,
0.0206780955,
0.0320231952,
-0.0037376883,
0.0008592161,
0.0133476416,
0.0296685137,
0.0452437252,
-0.0600497685,
0.0531050153,
0.015479303,
-0.042173028,
-0.0116358837,
0.0219643321,
-0.0405725054,
-0.0358161107,
-0.0025326798,
0.0597374588,
0.0509051494,
-0.0205637328,
0.076571241,
-0.0404767133,
-0.0018510589,
-0.0182539597,
-0.0025991246,
-0.0083025396,
-0.0319969878,
0.0185670853,
0.0192100424,
-0.0211890433,
0.0373008847,
0.0756087825,
-0.0084544914,
0.0865496323,
-0.0239224024,
0.0116672115,
-0.0466018468,
-0.0017663483,
0.036377959,
-0.0343735702,
-0.0310159978,
0.0429152586,
-0.0762561634,
-0.0578654744,
0.0143745486,
-0.0030100695,
-0.0098965904,
0.010244227,
0.0304778069,
0.0366840549,
0.0112524843,
-0.0241036713,
-0.0436295159,
-0.0088463631,
-0.0281984154,
-0.0033461037,
0.0002661107,
-6.650807447e-33,
-0.0340573341,
0.0007055648,
0.0352765471,
-0.0409214906,
-0.0365511104,
0.032930322,
-0.0421418957,
-0.0096531175,
-0.0447716042,
0.0002143529,
-0.0070777307,
0.0161760673,
-0.0041087074,
0.0044562276,
-0.0132450303,
-0.0361696482,
0.0446291342,
0.0134574911,
0.0129911723,
0.0161264222,
0.0308702681,
0.0166296083,
0.0425965935,
-0.0567910746,
0.0239692815,
-0.0109460233,
-0.0140387872,
0.0482278466,
0.0110819554,
0.0628657863,
-0.0589289516,
0.0118564535,
0.0280469265,
-0.0488309078,
-0.0078976173,
-0.0489472859,
-0.0789188072,
-0.0130091775,
0.0236365851,
0.0002348149,
-0.0026459373,
-0.0358625352,
0.0391894393,
0.0322038345,
-0.0089050801,
0.0140030384,
0.0368496403,
-0.0464741848,
0.0113971736,
-0.0179242324,
-0.0804721415,
0.0351287387,
-0.0104497075,
0.0125149246,
0.0483488888,
-0.0401065052,
0.0189660769,
-0.0080620628,
-0.0760797188,
0.0257340856,
0.0033892407,
0.0153478216,
0.0645181164,
0.0059050061,
0.0027590015,
0.0681494847,
0.0172981992,
0.00868876,
-0.0184091683,
0.0140653579,
0.0322487392,
0.0611918718,
-0.0152637269,
0.0571406297,
-0.0097302571,
0.0076211561,
-0.0686614811,
0.0189314,
0.0248492993,
0.0080632139,
0.0345478207,
0.0011943546,
-0.0481976122,
0.0006650419,
-0.0455001704,
0.0131669948,
-0.0409332328,
-0.023029143,
0.0334366374,
-0.0087262364,
-0.0053582857,
0.0240552705,
-0.0098537523,
-0.0721357539,
-0.0488370359,
0.0158492718,
0.0065794326,
0.0104193604,
0.0116290515,
0.0295658875,
-0.0843430609,
-0.04771116,
0.0189664681,
-0.0004005806,
0.0094221625,
0.0078087212,
0.0188871771,
-0.0035148591,
-0.0700675771,
0.0024296422,
-0.0267041512,
0.0038629677,
-0.0280144271,
0.0015196215,
0.0029916826,
0.0161564481,
-0.0092235645,
0.0356799848,
0.0818814784,
-0.004965669,
-0.0042419313,
0.0316244774,
0.0352351107,
0.0127476836,
-0.013839337,
-0.0097847134,
-0.0173199512,
0.0069085895,
0.0362394415,
-0.0253475774,
-0.0126522314,
-0.0184733961,
2.908e-7,
0.05884514,
0.0425262637,
0.0245264955,
0.0186241213,
0.0336663797,
0.0340606831,
-0.0300103035,
0.0284197107,
-0.0081445808,
-0.0254926458,
-0.0149091939,
0.0476512462,
0.0249141548,
0.0251487289,
-0.0968609378,
0.0088670328,
-0.0388976038,
-0.0289359204,
-0.067653209,
0.006998823,
0.0175542124,
0.0671005249,
0.0286343955,
0.0011967436,
-0.0343376324,
-0.0434238017,
0.0515515953,
-0.0243282057,
-0.0113667734,
0.0646017492,
0.026763469,
0.0380535275,
0.0052651973,
0.0291526448,
-0.0196441058,
0.0441324078,
0.0197737087,
0.0447241664,
0.0036949639,
0.0107066995,
-0.0153271249,
-0.04813179,
0.0013371592,
-0.0619515888,
0.073554486,
0.0021344807,
-0.0319552533,
-0.0076818732,
0.002228722,
0.0072332858,
-0.0450050868,
-0.0168954991,
-0.0332133025,
0.0021729805,
0.0159354173,
-0.0169933978,
-0.0366246179,
-0.0796871781,
-0.0260573961,
0.0111889932,
-0.0370860547,
-0.044828061,
-0.0183598213,
-0.0045544938,
0.0098896232,
-0.0665458664,
0.0415159725,
2.66324546e-34,
-0.0083525572,
0.0493480191,
-0.0097509976,
0.0583284944,
0.0312704742,
-0.0160961077,
-0.0474245399,
0.0216008648,
-0.0199205782,
-0.0831594467,
0.021007821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14819v1 | Analyzing Multilingual Competency of LLMs in Multi-Turn Instruction Following: A Case Study of Arabic | 2023-10-23T11:40:04 | 2023-10-23T11:40:04 | Sabri Boughorbel, Majd Hawasly | cs.CL | cs.CL | While significant progress has been made in benchmarking Large Language
Models (LLMs) across various tasks, there is a lack of comprehensive evaluation
of their abilities in responding to multi-turn instructions in less-commonly
tested languages like Arabic. Our paper offers a detailed examination of the
proficiency of open LLMs in such scenarios in Arabic. Utilizing a customized
Arabic translation of the MT-Bench benchmark suite, we employ GPT-4 as a
uniform evaluator for both English and Arabic queries to assess and compare the
performance of the LLMs on various open-ended tasks. Our findings reveal
variations in model responses on different task categories, e.g., logic vs.
literacy, when instructed in English or Arabic. We find that fine-tuned base
models using multilingual and multi-turn datasets could be competitive to
models trained from scratch on multilingual data. Finally, we hypothesize that
an ensemble of small, open LLMs could perform competitively to proprietary LLMs
on the benchmark. | [
-0.0031641999,
0.0183079094,
-0.0237502065,
0.0355437323,
-0.0566301085,
0.0283687115,
0.0605460852,
-0.0125897769,
0.0122571262,
-0.0665533841,
-0.0464098677,
-0.0607821047,
0.0065629003,
-0.0401615761,
0.0388377272,
-0.0117521528,
0.0281810462,
-0.06767793,
-0.0222820472,
-0.0247157738,
-0.0180970617,
0.0297460929,
-0.0252140854,
0.0446458161,
0.0377507955,
-0.0452064238,
-0.0080278143,
0.0038023307,
-0.0044636726,
0.0023993449,
0.0032412177,
0.0535512939,
0.0011616086,
0.0293893684,
0.0000019004,
-0.0533069186,
0.0098414561,
-0.0055856993,
-0.0343530141,
0.0018680237,
0.0214445759,
-0.0209231619,
-0.0231120847,
0.0258762334,
-0.0412801318,
0.0040493766,
0.0134021547,
0.011601706,
0.0165206939,
0.0621510111,
0.0322061442,
-0.0158722848,
0.0300346203,
-0.0170176197,
-0.009377134,
-0.0438017137,
-0.0059416238,
0.031261418,
0.0200423598,
-0.0086774267,
-0.0460176207,
0.0320832618,
0.0270732101,
-0.0086578438,
-0.0596616641,
-0.0033991402,
-0.0440343842,
0.0295416247,
0.0097145867,
0.039017763,
-0.0263575278,
-0.001496203,
-0.0310259387,
0.0005017543,
0.0179835018,
0.0040331176,
-0.0427768007,
0.0680789575,
-0.002325854,
0.0059357607,
0.0370460302,
-0.0208321437,
0.023032777,
0.0001939445,
-0.0710672513,
0.0943341181,
0.0268332157,
-0.0424648151,
0.0565967709,
0.0219871644,
0.0221611671,
-0.0246633552,
-0.0112628359,
0.0057923258,
-0.0436003171,
0.0232272111,
-0.002395045,
0.0157012586,
0.0210635047,
-0.0524012372,
0.0533483736,
0.0795310959,
-0.0169969909,
0.045438163,
-0.0149982125,
0.0587635078,
0.0165462382,
0.0610002838,
-0.0604696982,
-0.0141446637,
-0.0621386208,
0.0003641924,
-0.0010033473,
0.0340519287,
-0.0645897388,
0.0433641039,
-0.0614172183,
0.0231643692,
-0.0009026703,
0.0228030812,
0.0263351183,
-0.0552972704,
-0.0145964483,
-0.0214215107,
-0.0405575261,
0.0319973677,
0.0136216329,
0.0031424798,
-0.028739227,
-0.1211672872,
0.019544309,
0.003894337,
-0.0433669314,
-0.0333292522,
0.0178542417,
0.0788127631,
-0.0457851477,
-0.0411797091,
-0.0523209609,
0.0197258256,
0.0120630125,
-0.0868230611,
-0.0008833366,
-0.0596619584,
0.0575860217,
0.0337347314,
0.0100374362,
-0.0124892928,
-0.0032406349,
0.0370547064,
0.013399695,
0.047403805,
0.0577461086,
0.0090531539,
0.0404183902,
0.0096855657,
-0.0037888943,
0.1138072014,
0.0276172142,
-0.030901717,
0.0249731056,
-0.0298407748,
-0.0126260621,
0.0865391344,
-0.0098518413,
0.0123812575,
-0.0009258516,
0.0345113687,
0.0343268476,
0.0609574579,
-0.012991365,
0.0251584109,
-0.0103330286,
-0.0094004367,
0.0372942872,
0.0399950445,
0.0137879513,
-0.001063542,
0.0539953895,
-0.0033324549,
0.0407066755,
0.0343002304,
-0.0436898731,
-0.0028055627,
-0.0080764312,
0.0138824135,
0.0048182122,
0.0609253831,
-0.0369575992,
-0.0504357368,
-0.015204085,
0.0016664698,
0.0007518484,
0.0163661148,
0.0847827941,
-0.0343607552,
-0.0606409982,
0.0352375992,
0.013161473,
-0.0260930117,
0.0048733512,
-0.0576131903,
-0.028590275,
0.0479906984,
0.0140140532,
-0.0011261435,
-0.0492020324,
-0.0182639379,
0.0075874794,
0.0452784933,
0.0531254821,
-0.01610169,
0.0253862552,
-0.0487434156,
-0.0298633445,
0.0121029364,
0.0026600901,
0.0257730298,
-0.0011163142,
0.0350929387,
0.0026366764,
-0.0670596212,
-0.0201344695,
0.0241523981,
-0.0755368322,
-0.0188068543,
-0.0086550564,
0.0124634122,
0.0354634933,
0.0260253139,
0.004530089,
-0.0087217465,
0.0358170532,
-0.0212185364,
-0.0034186558,
0.0052916585,
-0.0438168198,
-0.0221680216,
0.0556552745,
-0.0313455835,
-0.0481770895,
0.0203923639,
-0.0318039097,
-0.0595234297,
0.0119789056,
-0.0034961884,
0.0222902689,
-0.0426428244,
0.042888958,
-0.0012682936,
-0.02059591,
-0.0283188745,
0.051921092,
-0.0295982473,
0.0538440421,
0.0018374157,
-0.0356397294,
0.0469932221,
-0.0561990589,
-0.0255282391,
0.0287864208,
0.0088324668,
0.0277727414,
0.005214429,
0.0390949473,
-0.0542881191,
-0.0429089293,
-0.0768915936,
0.0025776387,
-0.03269317,
0.0435694195,
-0.0030360725,
-0.0157100875,
-0.015241893,
0.0116382316,
-0.0474166945,
-0.0426717661,
0.0295738373,
0.0429357663,
-0.0032577699,
0.0111455647,
-0.024857996,
-0.027931964,
-0.0372228362,
0.0013142317,
0.0366908871,
0.010890821,
0.0358416289,
0.0050801942,
-0.0173381306,
-0.0190124176,
0.0131746121,
-0.0281259511,
-0.0144567396,
0.0420549326,
-0.0123195499,
0.012012206,
0.0653018877,
-0.013448542,
0.0002506359,
0.0415578112,
-0.025786452,
-0.0645372421,
0.0283358376,
0.0126931146,
-0.0501213595,
-0.0796314552,
-0.0580906048,
-0.0317911245,
0.0235925056,
0.0047247335,
-0.0066404226,
-0.047571227,
-0.0331249796,
-0.0273053236,
-0.0359211676,
-0.039603103,
0.0509017259,
0.0060801939,
0.0490010083,
-0.0039225942,
-0.0443839505,
0.0160587318,
-0.0161536466,
-0.0042407569,
-0.0072365361,
0.0093022194,
-0.0413528197,
0.0130000087,
-0.0291932449,
0.0016798151,
-0.0626851469,
-0.0515843965,
-0.0718143433,
0.0021683914,
0.0164139364,
-0.0544282943,
0.0746940374,
-0.0673885569,
-0.0025994012,
-0.0193488859,
-0.0346042514,
-0.0194052979,
0.0529433154,
-0.0287041292,
0.0177812018,
0.0277577899,
-0.0105592292,
-0.0691132396,
0.0065270616,
0.030860031,
0.0125241652,
-0.0050011463,
0.0032637918,
-0.0059278798,
-0.0472969264,
0.0151609862,
0.0222095884,
0.0011062582,
-0.064946115,
0.0353135951,
0.029502891,
0.0210031569,
-0.058848951,
-0.0354754254,
-0.0061923619,
0.0805199146,
-0.0408983231,
-0.0409335494,
0.0037506369,
-0.0041174041,
-0.0368792787,
0.0173947215,
0.1196901277,
0.0216135327,
-0.0201102793,
-0.0154352086,
-0.045074515,
-0.0087008225,
0.0209035724,
0.0157433357,
-0.0880563036,
0.0014218237,
-0.0073717702,
0.0275795404,
0.0267007854,
-0.0029093495,
0.0140623748,
-0.147113204,
0.0268556923,
-0.0095279356,
-0.0600724295,
-0.0208255127,
-0.0037744176,
-0.0090366537,
-0.0322861597,
0.0554750189,
-0.012688336,
-0.02408568,
0.0081033343,
0.0417660065,
0.0113091962,
-0.0616832301,
0.0390314497,
-0.0187043231,
0.0125845484,
0.0139819123,
-0.0011286628,
-0.0306637809,
-0.0503872633,
0.0316872336,
-0.0269275587,
-0.0133899041,
-0.0169190634,
0.0098485807,
-0.0101127466,
-0.0061633429,
-0.0133108394,
-0.0219179988,
-0.043000821,
0.028892139,
0.0327017233,
0.0713074505,
-0.0337043814,
0.0184073877,
0.0142945396,
-0.0250585414,
-0.0197932404,
0.0698477924,
-0.007421392,
-0.0499030128,
-0.0261944383,
-0.0316729508,
-0.0305282511,
-0.0592818335,
-0.0250111651,
0.0284856111,
-0.0102549037,
0.0384180099,
-0.0318493471,
-0.0563946813,
0.0471082665,
0.0339594297,
0.0129841017,
0.0429307446,
0.0221391618,
-0.0003400955,
-0.002160274,
-0.0076215137,
-0.0306115113,
0.0345421955,
-0.108417064,
-0.0136255501,
0.024427142,
-0.0625317022,
-0.0090946928,
-0.0123486174,
-0.0519635081,
-0.0498046242,
0.0001374417,
0.0342178158,
0.0204093084,
0.0181623511,
0.0161505993,
-0.0378343724,
0.0048462022,
-0.0032050468,
-0.0187419504,
0.0457867943,
0.0375621058,
-0.0012861283,
-0.0286401678,
0.0308723301,
-0.018263191,
-0.0056917281,
0.0275559518,
0.0214220732,
-0.0320380032,
-0.0593219139,
0.0101052206,
0.0177437346,
0.0142029924,
-0.0217134804,
-0.0174968634,
-0.0224609878,
0.0430206545,
-0.0164006576,
0.0091289664,
-0.0319863111,
-0.0208171736,
0.023636749,
-0.0010518058,
0.0065983599,
0.0009995486,
-0.0094902422,
0.0112425033,
-0.0394751243,
0.0335443467,
-0.0078819711,
0.0146126179,
0.0159048066,
0.0170081034,
0.0074305907,
-0.0279313736,
0.0110540204,
0.0555112883,
0.0113053266,
0.0706517473,
-0.0022670652,
0.0400106199,
0.0508976132,
0.0242209528,
-0.0204160362,
-0.0508760624,
0.0210362319,
0.0424596928,
0.075193882,
-0.0263316203,
0.040943373,
0.0104020499,
0.0051348568,
-0.0369780622,
0.014566754,
0.0127240652,
-0.0053520408,
0.0552037768,
0.0106410319,
0.0146421781,
0.015587749,
0.0778433233,
-0.001228127,
0.0238222852,
0.0186628718,
0.0124851139,
-0.0391319692,
-0.0623477772,
0.0189542305,
-0.0099773491,
-0.0248637889,
0.0236089975,
-0.0710111931,
-0.0714377761,
0.0069084908,
0.0352848656,
-0.0020789078,
-0.0099613518,
0.0257173758,
0.0927746296,
-0.0086425385,
-0.015023455,
-0.064626582,
0.0122031802,
0.0032500883,
-0.0251520202,
0.0004604745,
-5.967137361e-33,
-0.0294622891,
-0.0213423353,
0.0606780872,
-0.0023249965,
0.0260345079,
-0.0333516486,
0.0010836908,
0.0223209355,
-0.0450979061,
0.0035910676,
-0.0380217656,
0.0125833955,
0.0261570737,
0.013912837,
0.058687523,
-0.0085009737,
-0.0003581272,
-0.0172208454,
0.0020192435,
0.0173665322,
0.0265723467,
0.0043600937,
0.1048794165,
-0.0525016375,
0.0425446667,
-0.0471803546,
-0.0178394057,
0.0080131199,
-0.0673519149,
0.0918849632,
0.0002491031,
0.0464487188,
0.0333663337,
-0.0607040115,
0.0071523283,
-0.0498734377,
-0.0277825091,
-0.0201074444,
0.0528418832,
0.0438982993,
-0.0020486712,
-0.0270907208,
-0.0042895572,
0.0047060302,
-0.0634118021,
-0.0135683035,
0.0169715527,
-0.0258304123,
-0.0205227192,
0.0090851635,
-0.0470793992,
0.0320643596,
-0.0191138294,
0.0121570053,
0.0164615903,
0.0324135125,
-0.0091179786,
-0.0018663813,
-0.0582146719,
0.0180272684,
0.0360483639,
0.033089038,
0.0996008739,
-0.0031256918,
-0.0374354869,
0.0139871668,
0.0036355439,
-0.0096371034,
0.0588801317,
-0.0095100179,
0.0333366729,
0.0244417191,
0.0414517038,
0.0640296489,
0.0043099979,
0.020239193,
-0.0950073525,
0.0377082303,
-0.0080554197,
0.0343912728,
0.0076185321,
-0.0178873613,
-0.0367372483,
-0.0140825156,
-0.0386027917,
0.0219458397,
-0.0089977812,
-0.0050973208,
0.04486458,
-0.0081926752,
0.0324991569,
-0.0055009462,
0.0452196561,
-0.0103528136,
-0.0033360233,
-0.0098714596,
-0.0101292599,
-0.0050737583,
-0.0038118719,
0.0627851114,
-0.0629062578,
-0.0599772222,
-0.0228376407,
0.0011151909,
0.013322873,
0.016014345,
0.0168547388,
0.0254095253,
-0.0879977793,
0.0139605114,
-0.034677811,
0.0318678841,
0.0023203979,
0.026489336,
0.0322154053,
-0.0229871776,
-0.0032145611,
0.0602486692,
-0.0049441839,
-0.0531807765,
-0.0283141583,
-0.0376833826,
-0.0018297314,
0.0006492753,
-0.0128574325,
0.03878038,
-0.0143239582,
0.0056443047,
0.0323028006,
0.0012815782,
0.0034957961,
0.0371786915,
2.61e-7,
0.0819236636,
0.0360442102,
-0.0140721286,
0.0500861146,
-0.0245646704,
0.0156988911,
-0.0539584458,
-0.0091462759,
0.0280958172,
0.0177149437,
-0.0014175138,
0.0179224759,
0.0659113154,
0.0156660788,
-0.0763988793,
0.0076093944,
-0.0083636865,
0.0444568358,
-0.0492477678,
0.0198082384,
0.0412325785,
0.0917155221,
-0.0449188091,
-0.0091199959,
-0.0503314212,
-0.0398672931,
0.0691055357,
-0.0522216856,
-0.0207137838,
0.022665929,
0.0697293952,
0.0030056953,
0.0198493041,
0.0493377224,
-0.0248091836,
0.0130817313,
0.0375546776,
0.0914974585,
0.0184752997,
0.0073320391,
0.0368361995,
-0.0316470861,
-0.0303639211,
-0.0483341664,
0.0637840927,
0.025437979,
-0.0049223532,
0.0257131755,
-0.0225653686,
-0.0092906784,
0.0371070616,
-0.0242432412,
0.0059622824,
0.0245670918,
0.0292738639,
-0.0354158506,
0.0060723238,
-0.0087373527,
0.0215704516,
-0.0116024567,
-0.0252486914,
-0.0611857958,
0.0069506923,
-0.0013677635,
-0.0166227911,
-0.0106204618,
-0.0241505671,
2.096041426e-34,
0.0502625853,
-0.0010526803,
0.0487765409,
0.0238196515,
0.026069846,
-0.011575087,
-0.0560427532,
0.0052382443,
-0.0133884037,
-0.0799141973,
-0.0063320198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.15205v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.15205v2 | DISC-FinLLM: A Chinese Financial Large Language Model based on Multiple Experts Fine-tuning | 2023-10-23T11:33:41 | 2023-10-25T05:56:13 | Wei Chen, Qiushi Wang, Zefei Long, Xianyin Zhang, Zhongtian Lu, Bingxuan Li, Siyuan Wang, Jiarong Xu, Xiang Bai, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Multiple Experts Fine-tuning Framework to build a financial large
language model (LLM), DISC-FinLLM. Our methodology improves general LLMs by
endowing them with multi-turn question answering abilities, domain text
processing capabilities, mathematical computation skills, and
retrieval-enhanced generation capabilities. We build a financial
instruction-tuning dataset named DISC-FIN-SFT, including instruction samples of
four categories (consulting, NLP tasks, computing and retrieval-augmented
generation). Evaluations conducted on multiple benchmarks demonstrate that our
model performs better than baseline models in various financial scenarios.
Further resources can be found at https://github.com/FudanDISC/DISC-FinLLM. | [
0.0385593399,
0.0418817028,
-0.0070125298,
0.0102750612,
0.0229359213,
0.0172603019,
0.0462551564,
0.0204273686,
-0.0089505091,
0.0064784316,
-0.0618283115,
-0.0170658268,
-0.0280410536,
0.0271156989,
0.0494012274,
-0.0353311077,
0.0154637117,
-0.0251426473,
0.059444014,
-0.0573493317,
0.0324510522,
-0.0214828793,
-0.0015439999,
0.0110292779,
0.0214576274,
-0.0246364307,
0.0059913844,
-0.0031583835,
-0.008234717,
0.0199348982,
0.0244977269,
0.0347369649,
0.0327230543,
0.0163486339,
0.0000020537,
-0.0441851392,
-0.0428328738,
-0.0013511985,
-0.0267433804,
0.0065341671,
0.0027645533,
0.0032966495,
0.0737383515,
0.0106131434,
-0.0588806905,
0.0372026525,
0.0322518274,
0.0677535385,
0.1009110734,
0.0964180678,
0.0130305011,
-0.0681814253,
0.0080717709,
-0.0504785366,
-0.0067232386,
-0.0927457288,
0.0228702314,
0.0717700794,
0.0001703149,
0.0097772796,
-0.0295384172,
0.0272440761,
0.0064570648,
0.0268715024,
0.0273098294,
-0.0113648782,
0.0031286597,
0.0187392812,
-0.0239280704,
0.056468118,
0.0405681692,
0.0492725857,
0.0200978275,
-0.0064643645,
0.0145806661,
0.0426965617,
-0.0695992708,
0.0402170196,
0.0067324294,
-0.032179866,
0.0001458151,
-0.0378186889,
0.0024776247,
0.0170446374,
-0.0399053916,
0.0517113693,
-0.0134531269,
-0.0296165254,
-0.0063788416,
0.0074717742,
-0.0261676088,
-0.009615601,
0.0329539068,
0.0483036153,
-0.0142942406,
-0.0048359283,
-0.002074929,
-0.0307777543,
0.0111054676,
-0.0126923323,
0.048807662,
0.0312105995,
-0.0085192062,
0.0414009541,
-0.0416594297,
0.0326561891,
-0.0153649887,
-0.0356101207,
-0.0488528572,
0.0026853206,
-0.0710106343,
-0.0307914261,
-0.067126736,
0.085339427,
-0.0390533805,
-0.0409614369,
-0.0690205395,
-0.0070241145,
0.0090979682,
-0.0007049619,
0.0190080665,
0.0090181381,
-0.0431559831,
-0.0188206434,
-0.068145223,
0.0360705219,
-0.0818933845,
0.0115078175,
0.0113525242,
-0.0020247241,
0.0209952556,
0.0325021818,
-0.0484192744,
-0.0382614583,
0.037741676,
0.0756023452,
0.0180985685,
0.0110441204,
-0.0258973632,
-0.0632662252,
0.0038896999,
-0.0341915525,
-0.0002337766,
-0.0647001043,
0.0232373327,
0.0051127924,
-0.0127439527,
-0.0077250423,
0.0043411991,
-0.0024020041,
-0.0060537518,
0.0298484471,
0.0042265882,
-0.0052372357,
0.0376132838,
-0.0310608391,
-0.0127409929,
0.0366853215,
0.0047899554,
-0.0002567875,
0.02574265,
-0.0062458143,
-0.0033948256,
0.045073688,
-0.0012356399,
-0.0383287184,
0.0050480571,
0.0569990762,
-0.0177523158,
0.0127706397,
0.0597934164,
0.0164601803,
-0.0473640822,
0.0084985197,
0.0480772816,
0.0179707427,
0.072645478,
0.0336925946,
-0.0052442201,
0.0583709478,
0.0393144004,
-0.0061076256,
0.0014353868,
0.0542109311,
-0.0443460569,
0.0575739443,
0.0067176712,
0.0014435409,
-0.0431981944,
-0.0258002784,
0.0344485492,
0.003720552,
-0.0365331881,
0.0509774648,
0.0303097982,
-0.0361986272,
-0.0363579206,
0.069407776,
0.0134682618,
0.0058233077,
-0.0141267423,
-0.0489322953,
0.0380980782,
0.0639080331,
0.0222913325,
-0.0014891033,
0.0185982566,
-0.0128865959,
0.0125358682,
0.0486116558,
0.0560826361,
0.0130373091,
-0.0628688037,
-0.0650011301,
-0.0084364042,
0.0087400172,
-0.0009031571,
0.0314754359,
0.03052775,
-0.0279515199,
0.0031501318,
-0.0040289685,
-0.0177744012,
-0.0126764299,
-0.0164011735,
-0.0440164991,
-0.0144432234,
-0.0093851974,
-0.0201024003,
0.0080962013,
-0.0208426788,
0.0240158178,
-0.0085718846,
0.0035710617,
-0.0506639257,
-0.0414648838,
-0.0671221316,
0.0163847357,
0.0236903857,
-0.0397826359,
-0.0012483089,
0.0005167411,
-0.0418240465,
-0.041810587,
-0.0141111873,
-0.0124038374,
-0.0093287881,
-0.0680282936,
-0.0144190779,
0.0296088047,
0.0080603883,
-0.0234618224,
0.0952751487,
0.0021750426,
0.0339169726,
0.0013642448,
0.0526704825,
-0.0234089382,
-0.0846136734,
0.0210868716,
-0.0431102403,
-0.0099881534,
0.0699195936,
0.034751568,
0.032661058,
-0.0166554209,
-0.0503062829,
-0.040620178,
-0.0133301737,
-0.0101606306,
0.0170115959,
0.0086542303,
-0.0348578319,
-0.0034583367,
0.0021816618,
-0.0535671078,
0.0148170311,
-0.0063183676,
0.0046374239,
0.0392709076,
-0.0027584836,
-0.0147758313,
-0.0414325558,
-0.0161365103,
0.0152432602,
-0.0105338572,
0.0415504687,
0.0048120096,
-0.0122317541,
-0.0369986966,
-0.0291301031,
-0.0116468966,
-0.0100068012,
0.0164616797,
-0.0029348056,
-0.0295992624,
0.0473509543,
0.0433614552,
-0.0043094121,
0.0430450514,
-0.0528365634,
-0.0333486944,
-0.0596769527,
0.0314137712,
0.0016545969,
-0.0423791036,
-0.0312058181,
0.0208361875,
0.0038720432,
0.0420923978,
-0.0097687198,
-0.0104156462,
-0.0459868573,
0.0358387008,
0.0148569327,
0.003633701,
-0.0358209796,
0.0298367869,
-0.0160276555,
0.0390006676,
-0.0059563615,
-0.0133731915,
0.0672165081,
0.0074582328,
-0.0228793435,
-0.0309754983,
-0.0315331146,
-0.0530013517,
0.0077761621,
-0.0431035347,
0.0222146362,
-0.0332508422,
-0.0389427245,
-0.0558765717,
0.0014722764,
0.0420419872,
-0.0327379964,
0.0545839854,
-0.0311880969,
0.0121069998,
-0.0056467643,
0.0023995489,
0.0103720026,
-0.056575302,
-0.0286545046,
0.0413609333,
0.0705206022,
-0.0593596697,
-0.0735178068,
0.0200997256,
0.0269032661,
-0.0278893113,
-0.0368374325,
-0.0180134457,
-0.0011966012,
0.0086638257,
0.0801397711,
0.0354147218,
0.0031950127,
-0.0899045244,
0.0529336445,
0.019941492,
0.0262240935,
-0.0267558303,
0.0386413559,
-0.0114846537,
0.0047496124,
-0.0691667348,
-0.0086073186,
0.0455276854,
-0.0183909703,
-0.0691581815,
-0.015046468,
0.1101036221,
0.0121363299,
0.0145716527,
-0.0209289379,
-0.0324910656,
0.0244772397,
0.0100040166,
0.0623722784,
-0.1063167676,
-0.0251190607,
-0.0043202764,
0.0332633518,
0.0298415814,
-0.0454451442,
0.0006924213,
-0.1133285239,
0.0410807766,
-0.0229270458,
-0.0078380527,
-0.0238146409,
0.0060929898,
-0.0403824933,
0.0043325606,
0.0405270271,
0.0426431596,
-0.0287580453,
0.0271024071,
0.0288486164,
-0.0210260917,
0.0053490498,
0.0450086407,
-0.0142583624,
-0.0058388244,
0.0318811946,
-0.0212877523,
-0.0282683056,
-0.0188542604,
-0.046320159,
0.0084284265,
0.025530247,
-0.0056911996,
0.033683762,
-0.0339970849,
-0.0163767301,
-0.0070072813,
0.0294521917,
-0.0217715502,
0.0671432242,
0.055295039,
-0.0119470991,
-0.0218008589,
-0.010196167,
-0.0025543983,
0.0248924121,
-0.0387010351,
0.0774154961,
0.016164152,
-0.0676284358,
-0.0276437309,
-0.0432937816,
-0.0533427708,
-0.0568247288,
-0.0161404572,
-0.0002010161,
0.0304868538,
0.039871335,
-0.0762778968,
-0.0418362096,
0.039984338,
0.0412137806,
-0.0041790297,
0.0031886543,
0.0361736268,
-0.0113188466,
-0.018008342,
0.0153658623,
-0.0899016485,
0.0182208065,
-0.0835805014,
0.0019337299,
0.0422811694,
-0.0478398316,
-0.044470787,
0.0257848483,
-0.06619367,
-0.0256395899,
0.0044796821,
0.0292237233,
0.018789012,
-0.0403284803,
-0.0218315814,
-0.0238219555,
0.0182545912,
0.0325375609,
-0.0877778158,
0.0068369135,
0.0359830633,
-0.0006762253,
-0.0089615174,
0.0296471659,
-0.0673588216,
0.0192402173,
0.0082482249,
0.0765011907,
-0.0681643486,
-0.0061995876,
0.0034307763,
0.0411760136,
-0.0054358346,
0.0377876014,
0.0119672362,
-0.0213768687,
-0.0050548115,
0.0090899058,
-0.0026068937,
-0.0202107336,
-0.0416162983,
0.0459216572,
-0.0403783992,
0.035921935,
0.0275259018,
0.0518530533,
-0.0318110883,
-0.0011773142,
0.0234052185,
-0.0139162075,
-0.0045771068,
0.0154191386,
-0.0262947418,
0.0076633594,
-0.00939338,
0.0347080454,
0.0288269036,
0.0352418944,
0.0648790598,
0.0057538575,
0.0177935082,
-0.0176870096,
-0.0475654043,
-0.0270151887,
-0.1084806621,
0.0196838491,
0.0227240436,
0.0525280125,
-0.0130902519,
-0.0146587081,
-0.0447742864,
0.008719272,
-0.0115139876,
0.0049413904,
0.0249690525,
-0.0440749563,
0.0380969159,
0.0206494909,
-0.0296430122,
-0.0538929105,
0.1246147007,
0.0176137388,
-0.0041742991,
-0.0404668972,
0.000793964,
-0.0474547893,
-0.0540084653,
0.0083958684,
0.0395035669,
-0.0071526598,
0.0214132164,
-0.0591691732,
-0.0408025533,
-0.0310898572,
-0.0032420319,
-0.0176871736,
-0.0077162483,
0.0436228588,
0.0616272315,
-0.0374260992,
0.0116448971,
-0.015734816,
0.026655199,
-0.0088148443,
0.0039873435,
-0.033657752,
-6.201570975e-33,
-0.0377488919,
-0.026831001,
0.0715870336,
-0.0187170058,
0.0528080761,
-0.0015642446,
-0.0112767452,
0.0080854399,
-0.0335496515,
-0.0110916998,
-0.0041037067,
0.0106925415,
0.0104422132,
0.0262339897,
0.0169705842,
0.0063360003,
0.0299174637,
-0.0168236159,
0.0020200268,
-0.0203306414,
0.0197978728,
0.0818764642,
0.0725467056,
-0.0413085297,
0.0026088026,
-0.0192168616,
-0.0147699527,
0.0136096478,
0.0167044587,
0.0606376193,
0.0112427641,
0.0393682346,
0.003486837,
-0.0989241153,
-0.0333137661,
-0.0412468575,
-0.0474073738,
-0.0347090326,
0.0200305078,
0.0198101792,
0.0009457307,
-0.0134083359,
0.0346992798,
-0.0144473482,
0.0102651296,
-0.0293874219,
0.0380663835,
-0.0266774502,
0.0112817893,
-0.0289826598,
-0.0363676064,
0.0250874478,
0.0130375158,
0.0378793702,
-0.0113902735,
0.0354188271,
-0.0245578196,
0.0097142262,
-0.0320377536,
0.0053534391,
0.0489716493,
0.0331763178,
0.0344226174,
0.0060795606,
-0.0171263777,
0.037831746,
0.0083622159,
-0.0076901419,
0.0139153367,
-0.0304700993,
0.0224165563,
0.0592424087,
0.0259728897,
0.0496079847,
0.0051289615,
-0.0186229795,
-0.0181828327,
0.0180730969,
0.0283188839,
0.0616786703,
0.0358462632,
0.0233089253,
-0.0322301462,
-0.0364511684,
-0.0300895423,
0.0563918762,
-0.0372402892,
-0.0238172021,
0.0400927365,
0.0046606609,
-0.0192795191,
-0.0002089929,
0.031023955,
-0.0424737819,
-0.0331166126,
0.0068501108,
0.0093587153,
0.0115678953,
-0.0167449582,
0.0206792857,
-0.0801178142,
-0.0379191078,
-0.0230677743,
-0.0176126044,
-0.0290604532,
0.0115677258,
0.0047039213,
-0.0047239638,
-0.0493956879,
-0.0163483452,
0.0045657689,
0.005783061,
0.0232936684,
0.033228647,
-0.0116996663,
0.0209244583,
-0.0064654951,
0.0080439476,
-0.0303744879,
-0.0244837087,
-0.0159436669,
-0.0394515693,
-0.0041185077,
0.0310980119,
0.0259304084,
0.0522033647,
-0.0157808531,
0.0231333915,
0.0338562094,
0.0035355396,
-0.0135439951,
0.0631668493,
2.773e-7,
0.0518765002,
0.0779157877,
0.0006135648,
0.0347629227,
0.0024390598,
0.0284611527,
-0.0171303395,
-0.0135940444,
0.0268594939,
0.0040837564,
0.0366337411,
0.0753955916,
0.0614322461,
-0.0296946336,
-0.0801460072,
-0.0518391803,
-0.0554088578,
0.0455911495,
-0.046205081,
0.0224656649,
0.0023802693,
0.0612194762,
-0.0124632642,
-0.0243347157,
-0.0018329222,
-0.0819567218,
0.0603490584,
-0.0179853607,
-0.0141333295,
0.0356315449,
0.0309608784,
0.0361367427,
0.0008855391,
0.0412794687,
0.016029641,
0.0254054405,
0.03119497,
0.0783184245,
0.0413831137,
0.0078987973,
-0.0033426627,
-0.0148632415,
-0.0226624981,
-0.0337134935,
0.0153919542,
-0.0768390968,
-0.0392794572,
0.0007719623,
-0.0699400455,
-0.0094536589,
0.0127359508,
-0.015760757,
-0.0090436172,
0.007364078,
0.009851411,
-0.0300186016,
0.0089728758,
-0.0269174092,
-0.0116204293,
0.0576840043,
-0.0489094928,
-0.0163726062,
-0.0368315317,
-0.0079686875,
-0.0026975113,
-0.0584075525,
-0.0023827816,
2.36489007e-34,
0.0589175113,
-0.0011465336,
-0.0191453472,
0.045590885,
0.070299685,
0.0189239979,
-0.0651069954,
0.0392172784,
0.0155117093,
-0.1044397429,
-0.0239261128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14806v1 | Leveraging Timestamp Information for Serialized Joint Streaming Recognition and Translation | 2023-10-23T11:00:27 | 2023-10-23T11:00:27 | Sara Papi, Peidong Wang, Junkun Chen, Jian Xue, Naoyuki Kanda, Jinyu Li, Yashesh Gaur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The growing need for instant spoken language transcription and translation is
driven by increased global communication and cross-lingual interactions. This
has made offering translations in multiple languages essential for user
applications. Traditional approaches to automatic speech recognition (ASR) and
speech translation (ST) have often relied on separate systems, leading to
inefficiencies in computational resources, and increased synchronization
complexity in real time. In this paper, we propose a streaming
Transformer-Transducer (T-T) model able to jointly produce many-to-one and
one-to-many transcription and translation using a single decoder. We introduce
a novel method for joint token-level serialized output training based on
timestamp information to effectively produce ASR and ST outputs in the
streaming setting. Experiments on {it,es,de}->en prove the effectiveness of our
approach, enabling the generation of one-to-many joint outputs with a single
decoder for the first time. | [
-0.038825985,
0.0336987749,
0.0161779076,
-0.0037045628,
-0.037383277,
0.0197181962,
0.0483518876,
0.0102322865,
-0.0774862021,
-0.013571173,
-0.0184368324,
-0.0343291052,
0.0554336049,
0.0509241633,
0.0120621007,
-0.0566439927,
0.0443924144,
-0.009477064,
-0.0477443039,
-0.0067799622,
-0.0289089326,
0.0314200595,
-0.032610245,
0.0405827984,
-0.0155376084,
0.0068432945,
-0.0153176803,
-0.0116560757,
0.0255611539,
-0.0192576032,
-0.0772441402,
0.0226604566,
0.0623737201,
0.0765972957,
0.000001859,
0.0114733269,
-0.0542841628,
0.0191996749,
-0.043968372,
-0.0252029505,
0.0326845124,
-0.0255674124,
-0.035581138,
0.0465084426,
-0.0238454193,
-0.0781439394,
0.0566937365,
0.0000991992,
0.0151378727,
0.0418740287,
-0.026688844,
-0.0592325777,
0.0275329836,
-0.0025013231,
-0.0508058593,
-0.0302675813,
-0.0350893401,
-0.0258243419,
-0.0334348977,
-0.0139115937,
-0.0068796277,
0.0733184144,
0.0122300498,
-0.0286799464,
0.0224373806,
-0.0234304946,
-0.057938572,
-0.0440199338,
-0.0746045262,
0.0313838162,
0.002038588,
-0.022690719,
-0.0020059196,
0.0135746831,
-0.0256186817,
-0.0590335168,
-0.0090407012,
-0.0160937887,
-0.0018427941,
0.0255732872,
-0.003322328,
0.0396245867,
0.0071068243,
-0.0398028046,
-0.019490594,
-0.0353159197,
0.0258559398,
0.0157039333,
-0.0362813585,
0.0111579783,
0.0249683894,
0.0077919262,
0.0745588094,
0.0300554615,
-0.023324769,
-0.018567754,
-0.0103641981,
-0.0774172693,
-0.0458046719,
-0.0055147391,
0.0334476158,
0.0751521066,
-0.0231507439,
0.0025610307,
-0.0350776687,
0.073824577,
0.0012131286,
-0.0229781102,
-0.0450136513,
-0.0398109965,
-0.0274490807,
-0.0244200602,
-0.0338683799,
0.0135557866,
-0.0526756234,
-0.0296973959,
-0.0267818477,
0.0190323405,
0.0199656207,
0.015015264,
0.0083752954,
-0.0528110489,
-0.0647801384,
-0.0038557488,
0.0554059744,
0.1001665518,
0.0106623303,
0.0080738747,
0.0046963617,
-0.1029312313,
-0.0067925537,
0.0224281978,
0.0492559858,
0.0240522828,
-0.0335470214,
-0.0020773038,
-0.0498971492,
-0.0034911481,
-0.0091296034,
0.0062933336,
0.0004144867,
-0.0001666991,
0.0096414266,
-0.0752039403,
0.0632092506,
0.0208807681,
0.0277978927,
-0.0016574587,
0.0013964835,
-0.0530390032,
0.0536348186,
0.0679513589,
0.0072854161,
0.0383542255,
0.0449431613,
-0.0289217476,
0.016882373,
0.0609808899,
0.0539316833,
-0.0458413698,
0.0027532668,
-0.0280508604,
-0.0409866273,
0.0806984678,
-0.0219718367,
-0.004864471,
-0.0298579298,
-0.0066591986,
0.0555373915,
0.0084012086,
0.0000907957,
0.0312504023,
-0.023959361,
0.0572390482,
0.0387887843,
0.0437259115,
0.0058084186,
0.0352207497,
0.0755055472,
0.0079202028,
-0.0185301714,
-0.0002068431,
0.047422301,
0.0169960856,
0.0743304938,
-0.0087236026,
0.0168435872,
0.0583932735,
-0.0400818028,
0.0192799903,
0.0094970874,
-0.0304247346,
-0.0080433069,
-0.0062431293,
0.0621785223,
0.0174803901,
-0.0615153424,
0.0557571761,
-0.0209355541,
-0.0482592545,
0.0400015451,
-0.0241310596,
-0.0584110357,
0.0533528626,
0.0131301135,
-0.0012835106,
-0.0221121013,
-0.0394534729,
-0.0101020681,
0.0491009988,
0.0457371175,
-0.0291483495,
0.0640952364,
-0.013045866,
-0.0085506607,
0.0743583217,
-0.0127087906,
0.0788704678,
-0.0152570112,
0.0454601981,
0.0173434354,
0.0046726554,
0.0181708429,
0.0039049373,
-0.0010165983,
-0.0084563112,
0.0359688923,
0.0131545477,
0.0595828071,
0.0409850404,
-0.0047813863,
-0.0023336143,
0.0418494344,
-0.0616093688,
0.0070686564,
0.103250064,
-0.0599998757,
-0.035482578,
0.0258373618,
-0.0006224748,
-0.0104115168,
0.0488091335,
0.0116178691,
-0.0841996148,
-0.0025509857,
-0.025543062,
0.0379966758,
-0.0240208115,
0.0581230596,
0.0146355378,
-0.019388102,
0.0244801976,
-0.0264160726,
0.0202905647,
0.0056965761,
-0.0016731279,
-0.0650959238,
0.009489093,
-0.0683374926,
-0.000598949,
0.0538295954,
-0.0161923934,
-0.0303850789,
0.0079889102,
-0.0069864118,
0.0043607601,
-0.0205283761,
-0.068463631,
-0.0264405701,
-0.0197223201,
0.0430117324,
-0.0036395949,
0.0522939786,
0.0423095003,
-0.0306261089,
-0.031074347,
-0.0247462895,
0.0322990417,
-0.0075552748,
-0.0194569137,
-0.0017341274,
-0.0318402313,
0.0130786682,
0.005976717,
0.0252191443,
0.0283385348,
0.0064872131,
-0.0378119238,
-0.080804117,
-0.0490317307,
0.0339905806,
0.0306835901,
0.0198517907,
0.0028382654,
0.012402256,
0.0233035497,
0.0376369916,
0.008725292,
0.0158269294,
-0.0015636206,
-0.0043447977,
-0.0245834701,
-0.075072147,
-0.005012909,
-0.0174375791,
-0.0022952338,
-0.0178166647,
0.005499918,
-0.0077846353,
0.0066228951,
0.0027350774,
0.0361194797,
-0.071445927,
-0.0650475472,
-0.0166893285,
-0.0375533886,
-0.0153995175,
-0.0274237003,
-0.0436539464,
-0.0173997581,
-0.0019157632,
-0.0460187607,
0.0284623262,
-0.0570547432,
-0.0470095836,
-0.0267072935,
-0.0016508421,
-0.0185246784,
0.0737071484,
-0.0254570749,
0.0245136525,
-0.0323215909,
-0.0599741489,
-0.0055030365,
0.0500558503,
0.0006017695,
-0.0551408902,
0.0062751612,
-0.036152903,
-0.0122154942,
-0.0361605212,
-0.0484274253,
0.0085963281,
0.0035878988,
-0.0158525109,
0.0263072848,
0.0258254334,
-0.0296462085,
-0.041130133,
0.0424326919,
0.0015876614,
0.0470913351,
-0.0042787897,
0.0061921305,
-0.0261455346,
0.0377998725,
-0.0173837077,
-0.0011698343,
-0.0281418134,
-0.010649452,
0.0467314012,
-0.0102334721,
0.1077467576,
0.0044580461,
-0.051846046,
-0.0139278155,
0.0638835877,
0.0068739187,
-0.027259754,
-0.0159063078,
0.0383222662,
-0.0226534232,
0.0100551676,
0.1106412932,
-0.01143103,
-0.0349196047,
-0.0322596319,
-0.0080397436,
0.0095576299,
-0.0093890056,
0.0155888591,
-0.0815197304,
-0.0138174426,
0.0257644728,
0.0454086475,
0.0368408561,
0.0331213847,
-0.0324479975,
-0.0574830025,
0.0106612435,
0.0617319494,
-0.0376074128,
-0.0533517823,
-0.0408399329,
-0.0696951002,
-0.0083736954,
0.0314708985,
-0.006975519,
0.0113092801,
-0.0226678327,
0.030128561,
-0.016514156,
-0.0447696857,
0.0128717469,
-0.024335077,
0.0592391416,
0.058456935,
0.049635902,
0.0040996824,
-0.0096889036,
-0.0156558212,
0.0252545178,
-0.0125603089,
-0.0188852493,
-0.0427015498,
-0.005797423,
-0.0140639832,
0.0375074893,
0.0189511832,
-0.0060189185,
0.0201199204,
-0.0045603006,
0.0547740012,
0.0037143484,
0.0233266931,
0.0516217351,
-0.0344898328,
0.0216314644,
0.0354521014,
-0.0237824116,
-0.0069546131,
-0.0026125112,
0.0048871697,
0.044125177,
-0.0304817017,
0.0070929267,
-0.0195160732,
-0.0069913585,
-0.0792610347,
-0.0428903289,
0.0142678143,
0.0332692042,
0.006985228,
0.0181070995,
0.0165929981,
0.0329898261,
0.0305761229,
-0.0161717422,
-0.0062923543,
-0.0010655037,
0.034134537,
-0.0871421546,
-0.0125488546,
0.0258870255,
-0.0409453362,
0.0101007968,
0.030704027,
-0.092797108,
-0.0544719882,
0.0120790396,
-0.0273192804,
0.0109194266,
0.0549094453,
-0.0421450511,
0.0303095188,
0.0126637938,
0.0236676857,
-0.0244584288,
-0.0162644982,
0.0490260869,
0.0014653188,
-0.0277102534,
0.0152780963,
-0.0418647863,
0.0201368742,
-0.0557737537,
0.0096611399,
0.0002760195,
-0.0220197681,
0.012383312,
0.0421932228,
0.0527882762,
-0.023647787,
0.022280179,
0.0248278826,
0.0232897792,
-0.0129111167,
0.0502007827,
-0.0549123921,
0.0223379359,
0.0166616663,
0.0001004272,
-0.0076049878,
0.04147771,
0.0350838304,
-0.0677899271,
0.0085922917,
0.0326204449,
-0.0017932589,
-0.0310549401,
0.0118673146,
0.0115405498,
-0.0321194232,
0.0073546376,
0.048848968,
-0.0080738654,
-0.0496661663,
0.0067765233,
0.0038516077,
0.0455852486,
0.0453691557,
0.0190889966,
-0.02059591,
0.0141233699,
0.001096047,
-0.0155521203,
0.0646025911,
0.0183931757,
0.0930262059,
0.0026867539,
0.0290468857,
-0.0423900448,
0.0653104037,
-0.0336770788,
-0.0241584256,
-0.0224139728,
-0.0165748112,
-0.0189740844,
0.0383761898,
0.050704103,
-0.0321726017,
0.0018284338,
0.0036882008,
-0.004786259,
-0.0212555807,
-0.022437837,
-0.0398298874,
-0.058411736,
-0.032143794,
-0.0305238962,
0.0254321825,
-0.0113078281,
0.0356742367,
-0.025461264,
0.0186255798,
-0.0416786671,
-0.0029379101,
0.0306916479,
-0.0318704844,
0.0011293784,
-0.0156325568,
-0.0232803505,
0.0661437362,
0.0043945764,
-0.0141594615,
-5.746371441e-33,
-0.0278878491,
0.0184349436,
-0.0133728003,
0.0100710597,
-0.0280089304,
-0.0039508385,
-0.0215507951,
-0.0167477857,
-0.0218286905,
-0.0381272584,
-0.0045461697,
0.0205963366,
0.0488876626,
0.0035417026,
0.0084987003,
0.0120791439,
0.0932917148,
-0.0414663851,
-0.0069556083,
0.0364009961,
0.0646592975,
0.0171112381,
0.0420074761,
-0.0078442087,
-0.031961523,
0.0041756937,
-0.0068323785,
0.0091712503,
0.0452429652,
-0.0070005092,
0.0320345946,
0.0126398234,
-0.0066203065,
-0.0699883997,
-0.0362493843,
0.0326085091,
-0.1171286628,
0.020779524,
-0.0185653977,
0.0854918212,
0.0259649083,
-0.0130890077,
-0.0101663172,
-0.0042989277,
-0.0167925842,
-0.0345587246,
-0.0244212672,
-0.012370606,
-0.0337869115,
-0.0851939023,
-0.0026458763,
0.0222034249,
-0.0258405898,
-0.0070423945,
0.0739416704,
0.0692092404,
-0.0004225351,
-0.0631138533,
-0.0788735673,
0.0709527135,
0.0096961977,
0.0336893313,
0.0492707938,
0.0096197044,
0.0015571347,
-0.0148188649,
0.0018674548,
-0.0758041441,
0.0134453131,
0.0210650023,
0.017010035,
-0.0187811144,
0.0227679387,
-0.0323572345,
0.0428242236,
-0.0502834618,
-0.0033993174,
0.0050015361,
0.0435345098,
-0.0149551947,
0.0363773406,
0.0182149839,
0.0132627403,
0.0183945969,
-0.0488499254,
-0.0081129335,
0.0106783323,
-0.0082926266,
0.0118645318,
0.033746466,
0.0068724719,
0.009174685,
0.113974385,
0.0197475962,
0.0033417321,
-0.0266435836,
-0.0002466516,
0.026289016,
-0.0390872024,
0.020978447,
-0.0215589236,
-0.0310319271,
0.0499977656,
0.0147316549,
0.01417524,
-0.004231751,
0.0255880281,
0.0894462466,
-0.0563786291,
0.0023250931,
0.0056741098,
0.0165878125,
-0.0187998023,
-0.0055317511,
0.0586136281,
-0.0114218211,
0.0104555357,
0.0108011533,
-0.0308607239,
0.0297305863,
-0.0183081776,
-0.0008460803,
0.0278075542,
0.0522321947,
-0.0329142995,
0.0320434049,
-0.0485569909,
0.034429118,
0.0541012697,
0.0254840571,
-0.0431392007,
0.006460845,
2.685e-7,
-0.0045768037,
0.0155422064,
0.0418839753,
-0.0156768281,
0.0296407323,
-0.002337534,
-0.008025907,
0.0170298759,
0.0109467022,
0.0680931062,
0.0039339848,
-0.0322412774,
0.121599786,
0.044089403,
-0.0744124949,
-0.0576293357,
-0.0674229041,
0.0395193957,
-0.0277584475,
0.0021515426,
0.028510252,
0.065553382,
-0.0267932154,
0.0142499292,
0.0218477454,
0.002457404,
0.0415546447,
0.0076279524,
0.039396923,
-0.0110267326,
-0.005132338,
-0.0162738506,
-0.0492649004,
0.0001674559,
-0.0576568134,
0.0247746632,
0.0158312861,
0.0402840823,
-0.0327219255,
-0.0291178208,
-0.0169195104,
0.0114175677,
-0.0595400147,
0.001070218,
0.0326817371,
-0.0306334421,
-0.0113115469,
-0.0034749531,
-0.0592260212,
0.0436342582,
-0.0370884202,
0.0102493465,
0.003040435,
0.0458988659,
0.0131419003,
0.0006542583,
-0.0250373632,
-0.0193836093,
0.0001908134,
-0.0463419445,
-0.0451462418,
-0.0249805152,
-0.0452208593,
-0.0030124679,
-0.0151621727,
0.0075938813,
-0.0271326471,
2.314409935e-34,
0.0088322302,
-0.0034355132,
0.0019655591,
0.0161356144,
-0.0101781292,
-0.0465060361,
-0.0187740661,
0.0468446128,
-0.0326224156,
-0.0186133012,
-0.0431299321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14805v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14805v2 | Cross-Modal Conceptualization in Bottleneck Models | 2023-10-23T11:00:19 | 2023-12-17T09:40:52 | Danis Alukaev, Semen Kiselev, Ilya Pershin, Bulat Ibragimov, Vladimir Ivanov, Alexey Kornaev, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs) assume that training examples (e.g., x-ray
images) are annotated with high-level concepts (e.g., types of abnormalities),
and perform classification by first predicting the concepts, followed by
predicting the label relying on these concepts. The main difficulty in using
CBMs comes from having to choose concepts that are predictive of the label and
then having to label training examples with these concepts. In our approach, we
adopt a more moderate assumption and instead use text descriptions (e.g.,
radiology reports), accompanying the images in training, to guide the induction
of concepts. Our cross-modal approach treats concepts as discrete latent
variables and promotes concepts that (1) are predictive of the label, and (2)
can be predicted reliably from both the image and text. Through experiments
conducted on datasets ranging from synthetic datasets (e.g., synthetic images
with generated descriptions) to realistic medical imaging datasets, we
demonstrate that cross-modal learning encourages the induction of interpretable
concepts while also facilitating disentanglement. Our results also suggest that
this guidance leads to increased robustness by suppressing the reliance on
shortcut features. | [
0.0053208321,
0.067069456,
-0.0036826709,
0.0070108557,
-0.0059056613,
0.0414681025,
0.0147005022,
0.0259558689,
-0.0232453123,
-0.0114415055,
0.0007772704,
-0.0289510619,
0.0015527541,
0.0677251592,
0.0107843643,
-0.1169548705,
0.0099183014,
-0.0169461258,
-0.0175164863,
-0.0267314222,
0.0078789666,
-0.0358101614,
-0.0014701193,
-0.0037310377,
-0.0420447066,
-0.0097654127,
0.0235517453,
-0.0027362648,
0.0036933976,
-0.0272663906,
-0.0432717316,
0.0733434856,
0.0409892537,
-0.0125400033,
0.0000024295,
-0.0150823388,
-0.0239451174,
0.011964553,
-0.0451838784,
-0.008367084,
-0.0022781421,
-0.1229781657,
0.0273285694,
-0.0491842739,
0.0134427641,
-0.0536861829,
0.0510708652,
0.1303338856,
0.0258440264,
0.018642392,
-0.044491224,
0.0231414903,
0.0189037044,
-0.0360832736,
0.0423507541,
-0.0301466566,
0.0180979539,
0.0237245876,
-0.0254517309,
0.0205230881,
-0.063398093,
0.0375656188,
0.0245620012,
0.030393891,
0.0590033866,
0.0790956989,
0.0298881792,
-0.045517154,
-0.0015838696,
0.0646234751,
0.0200581942,
0.005117726,
0.0084639834,
-0.0397297442,
0.0076691499,
0.075544633,
-0.0515941791,
-0.0362586379,
-0.0209397227,
-0.0066617029,
-0.0301961396,
0.0198032781,
0.0311900396,
-0.011224241,
-0.0024666402,
-0.0424729548,
-0.010461634,
-0.0073790699,
0.0343858711,
0.0319350511,
-0.0359189063,
-0.0312168356,
-0.0217905268,
-0.0054759476,
-0.0056173536,
0.0143376766,
-0.0294032861,
0.0103541911,
0.0372656696,
-0.006902948,
-0.010677279,
-0.0274168588,
-0.0502857268,
0.0774251819,
-0.0121209305,
0.0146416891,
-0.0485069677,
0.0459795706,
-0.0120841516,
0.0229254644,
-0.0598484389,
-0.0026213129,
0.0128812836,
0.0113171125,
0.0383907445,
-0.016831208,
-0.0269030686,
-0.0013978145,
-0.0121242506,
0.0098333042,
-0.0183187686,
0.032086879,
-0.0594565384,
-0.0049390369,
-0.0281256568,
0.0126764439,
-0.0211516377,
0.0448667891,
-0.0529998019,
-0.02825021,
-0.009192883,
0.0212455783,
-0.0217093062,
0.0062793191,
0.0024382945,
0.0320230126,
-0.0257293917,
0.0051529869,
-0.044874873,
-0.0733839869,
-0.0407870263,
-0.0459999554,
0.0468390845,
-0.0471523702,
-0.01812087,
0.0220319424,
0.0396902189,
-0.0068848059,
0.0026154409,
-0.0363008082,
-0.0624429621,
0.0780699402,
-0.0226073712,
-0.0123199308,
0.0174518824,
0.0521051809,
-0.0159267485,
0.0545971021,
-0.0049824375,
0.0347457305,
-0.0112943416,
-0.0317783058,
-0.0005636928,
0.0023748612,
0.0302929301,
-0.0070452774,
-0.0526246503,
-0.0116050448,
0.0317622386,
0.0576756708,
0.0108378446,
0.0068379412,
-0.0461947285,
0.0196699463,
0.0202607475,
0.0057172608,
0.0531113036,
0.0249861646,
0.0007254455,
-0.0068539237,
-0.0377888456,
0.0416119881,
-0.0297456849,
0.061060071,
0.0310168546,
0.0200451352,
-0.0090532461,
-0.0056095384,
-0.0395790227,
-0.0664619133,
-0.0114110503,
0.0011260168,
-0.0590711646,
0.0043087602,
0.0839658231,
0.0118709141,
0.0120894164,
0.0118964687,
0.0409056395,
0.0427162908,
-0.0275742654,
-0.0308334604,
-0.0307571441,
0.0280975457,
0.0082026627,
-0.0158214476,
-0.012820906,
-0.0105752349,
0.0341486819,
0.0291245934,
0.0287494846,
-0.001871928,
-0.0016201314,
-0.0165540017,
-0.0583646744,
0.0282824337,
0.013349493,
-0.0107970135,
-0.0293404013,
-0.0015688167,
-0.0279293265,
-0.0340582393,
0.0207039528,
0.0572090819,
0.0034442225,
-0.0020170577,
-0.0085363323,
0.0405006446,
0.0171161853,
-0.0212675761,
-0.0282695182,
-0.0444382951,
0.0127798878,
-0.0265343618,
-0.0165571589,
0.0235892143,
-0.0527448542,
-0.0009190732,
-0.0278668217,
-0.0548169911,
-0.0219640788,
-0.0209224559,
-0.0066857222,
-0.0472094938,
0.0131201278,
-0.0069409674,
0.0107166283,
-0.0334838703,
-0.0194385406,
0.0313555822,
0.004223214,
0.0090174023,
0.0705227926,
-0.028102519,
-0.014447799,
0.0316239037,
-0.0243274346,
0.0313724838,
0.0320386924,
-0.0123038422,
0.0124757653,
0.0076125343,
-0.0030465524,
-0.0102785788,
-0.0305482876,
-0.0254933499,
-0.0110554025,
-0.0383404307,
-0.0266925041,
0.0151424669,
-0.0406131111,
-0.0164320916,
-0.0079697641,
0.0043358644,
-0.0482255556,
0.0142178759,
0.0391253568,
0.0187305622,
0.0246153232,
0.023257507,
0.0495520793,
-0.0167093817,
-0.000160868,
0.0247534811,
-0.0017396495,
0.0444057211,
0.0270426478,
-0.0580709539,
0.0241094902,
0.0477006733,
0.028006075,
0.0107129989,
-0.0177104417,
0.0033914493,
0.003410076,
-0.0044237892,
-0.0371417217,
0.0453206748,
-0.024877293,
0.0376171507,
0.0356977656,
0.001080535,
-0.0224780757,
-0.016322555,
-0.015561169,
-0.0158149805,
0.0025491235,
-0.0334500447,
-0.0199835878,
0.0843674913,
0.0116465259,
0.0021938307,
-0.0640814453,
0.0285909921,
-0.005270347,
-0.0265455879,
-0.0969836861,
0.0295279287,
0.0113348728,
0.0281684753,
-0.0439903028,
-0.0464643463,
0.093817316,
-0.0025531903,
0.0260832682,
0.0316020176,
-0.018652603,
-0.0168450139,
0.0289975516,
0.0244968142,
0.0255903136,
0.1055338085,
0.0179957654,
-0.04929775,
0.0358725265,
0.0411873534,
0.0040394105,
0.0152383791,
-0.030652687,
-0.0092902835,
-0.0175986141,
-0.0381832123,
-0.0396070257,
-0.0199839734,
0.0335463323,
0.0116854357,
-0.0187198408,
0.0208205581,
-0.0625972822,
0.0019553048,
0.0095914705,
0.0182656124,
-0.0182949752,
-0.0273381919,
-0.0092297848,
0.0618697926,
0.0287910551,
0.0182054304,
-0.0574702322,
-0.0478246845,
0.0197293293,
0.0543203317,
-0.0174449198,
0.0189994536,
-0.0144167347,
0.0379447229,
-0.023354914,
0.0305642001,
-0.0319194272,
-0.0052157473,
0.0131957978,
-0.0228168145,
-0.0190529879,
0.044987075,
-0.0077073807,
-0.0290380605,
-0.0217528287,
0.0292696655,
0.0567841418,
0.0079365717,
0.0048201885,
-0.020421721,
-0.0381550975,
-0.0259039551,
0.0189028457,
-0.007965601,
0.0310383998,
0.0102817733,
-0.0101813721,
0.0413116477,
-0.0069029774,
-0.0850983337,
-0.0346816629,
-0.0439222902,
-0.0150821945,
-0.0234854706,
-0.0504134595,
-0.0456596799,
-0.0092806686,
-0.0006935488,
0.0213677213,
-0.0218477678,
-0.0779029503,
-0.0162742995,
-0.0310939364,
-0.0015821332,
-0.0078957258,
-0.0109215649,
-0.0299552921,
-0.0282895863,
-0.0363903902,
-0.0237573273,
0.0284021627,
0.0171382353,
0.0839281827,
-0.0116419373,
-0.0120628476,
-0.003861852,
0.053862147,
0.0075913263,
-0.0325733609,
-0.0193048883,
0.077660419,
-0.00035951,
0.0059136949,
-0.0545110591,
0.0211086366,
0.0154517489,
0.0420198441,
0.0068988865,
-0.0282936264,
-0.0280965287,
-0.0047740154,
0.0606714003,
0.0191080719,
-0.0261593051,
0.0583007857,
-0.0510067642,
-0.043943733,
-0.0297738295,
-0.0224444512,
-0.0147590116,
0.0188243687,
0.0429455563,
0.0360755846,
-0.0728773549,
-0.0153601868,
-0.064748317,
0.0927292854,
0.0441985577,
-0.027309034,
-0.0049597831,
-0.0466237329,
0.0666211173,
-0.0642777532,
-0.01454092,
0.0274902638,
-0.0233615302,
-0.0102811186,
-0.0237649698,
0.0155898603,
0.0151189771,
0.0758162215,
0.035654664,
-0.0568089262,
0.0800338387,
0.0531370603,
-0.036905773,
0.0036927089,
0.017570667,
-0.0489788987,
-0.0312996954,
-0.0076839123,
-0.0041046855,
0.043162819,
0.0153685445,
-0.0511798933,
-0.1009254679,
-0.0069462266,
0.0298954062,
-0.0263264962,
0.0737121329,
-0.0369210243,
-0.0344890021,
-0.0239885133,
-0.0032242869,
0.0459492952,
0.0067512514,
0.0024351666,
-0.0313788503,
0.0420251414,
0.0039025072,
-0.0052194768,
0.0265786089,
-0.0027542799,
-0.0004945397,
-0.0173373409,
0.0036136222,
0.0358107798,
-0.0028330411,
-0.0140803242,
-0.0000017566,
0.014738556,
-0.0154137369,
0.013527452,
0.0117063904,
-0.0092218993,
0.0626293868,
0.0239514671,
0.0512340404,
-0.0317909978,
0.0123991566,
-0.0381089747,
-0.025374731,
-0.0376926064,
0.0182907358,
0.0246888977,
-0.0165699739,
-0.0148837315,
-0.0458252057,
-0.0107372049,
0.0080410084,
0.0311285052,
-0.008766856,
0.0155845089,
0.070973523,
0.0118744057,
0.0299388394,
0.0038306632,
0.0854030326,
0.0467093475,
0.0376662016,
-0.0233835876,
-0.0008097459,
-0.071856983,
0.0063426374,
0.0750506744,
0.0044020223,
-0.0099806199,
0.0332677662,
-0.067199111,
-0.0285473671,
0.0327338204,
-0.001816929,
0.0039263978,
0.0177622642,
0.0359635539,
0.0486069508,
0.0038056639,
-0.0620795265,
-0.0186196901,
0.0050512427,
0.0108627575,
-0.0013662998,
0.0141205937,
-6.596032349e-33,
-0.0222915299,
-0.0067820279,
0.0273627415,
0.0105374493,
-0.0114419395,
0.0420264415,
-0.0216470864,
-0.0035113904,
0.0271182619,
0.0348674916,
-0.0102805216,
-0.0205705464,
0.0072601456,
-0.0019956646,
0.0029152913,
0.0172445755,
0.0647103041,
-0.0302954372,
-0.0086394427,
0.0267142244,
0.0208910946,
0.0161964707,
0.0046116207,
-0.1133990362,
-0.0121334894,
0.0095480867,
-0.0111948745,
0.0027701622,
0.0129117155,
0.051722303,
-0.0714642704,
-0.0008710799,
0.0378578678,
-0.086666204,
-0.0035527169,
0.0500374921,
-0.058149267,
0.0117849987,
-0.0151880328,
0.0228402968,
-0.0597745776,
-0.0375765115,
0.0580314547,
-0.0319994576,
0.0217824969,
-0.0241951458,
0.0765116438,
-0.0455324166,
-0.0300817564,
-0.0194743648,
-0.0558945835,
0.0455371588,
-0.01884971,
-0.0065170662,
0.0611420535,
-0.0084496951,
-0.007152346,
0.0215770397,
-0.0269228127,
0.0448138118,
0.0485843718,
0.0431442522,
0.0437457077,
0.0203257184,
-0.0078979684,
0.0869398266,
0.0481275879,
-0.0596472397,
0.0098104551,
-0.0007622161,
0.0176785812,
0.0658939183,
0.0145832207,
0.1067315415,
0.1142205596,
-0.003883539,
-0.0770677924,
0.0400634892,
-0.1298014075,
0.0431199968,
-0.0111829489,
-0.0067231813,
-0.0252861325,
-0.0146705033,
-0.0403576642,
-0.0188027862,
-0.0247591771,
-0.0074913171,
0.0125137875,
0.0462906882,
-0.0476096831,
-0.0021646167,
0.0084384894,
-0.0054738163,
-0.0026013569,
-0.0354944989,
0.0486718751,
0.050904654,
-0.0012418143,
-0.0350792333,
-0.067656897,
-0.0517726578,
0.0635706857,
-0.002358441,
0.0618566126,
0.0063557164,
0.0532695651,
-0.0200837646,
-0.0254175402,
-0.0114810839,
-0.0131536685,
-0.0129312072,
-0.0185076632,
-0.0198422689,
0.0558446273,
-0.0048742942,
-0.0370505787,
0.0069376533,
0.0085522179,
0.0124462135,
-0.0196355227,
-0.0234384667,
-0.0258708727,
0.0242405441,
-0.0054549258,
-0.0310179144,
0.0039428044,
-0.0830580592,
0.0771098733,
-0.0665606707,
-0.0211269483,
0.0520274714,
3.03e-7,
-0.0074768304,
0.038727846,
-0.0033065155,
-0.0505115539,
0.0571736768,
0.0656197444,
-0.038441591,
-0.0020367049,
-0.0233951919,
-0.0874174833,
0.039801646,
0.0402309038,
0.010338041,
0.0289660078,
-0.0390146449,
0.0210678466,
0.0346686691,
0.0140671404,
-0.0244466513,
-0.0279945657,
0.0493883044,
0.0608809367,
-0.057506457,
-0.0390834138,
0.0452316478,
-0.0088773612,
0.0752785355,
-0.0579359494,
0.0035153667,
-0.0073104985,
0.0020449068,
0.0247894786,
-0.0307377093,
0.1018610597,
0.0041227224,
-0.0337605663,
0.0199440904,
0.0129073812,
-0.001108703,
-0.0181810185,
-0.0233187098,
0.0694934353,
-0.0031962493,
-0.0091009513,
0.0547669791,
-0.0784074515,
-0.0312366243,
-0.0036829659,
-0.0063123386,
0.0135350823,
0.0481631048,
0.0013065947,
-0.0211312231,
0.0029115933,
0.0074312007,
0.0096253464,
-0.0217988454,
-0.037954025,
0.0163897816,
0.0297236666,
-0.0389254093,
-0.0082049482,
-0.0015068921,
-0.0267213043,
0.0250723846,
-0.0163517892,
-0.0540943183,
2.661767827e-34,
-0.0019360619,
-0.0165656265,
0.0228481703,
-0.0246608071,
-0.020817358,
-0.0208736602,
-0.024738377,
-0.0086528482,
0.0033066256,
-0.0581263565,
0.0261338223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14804v1 | Large Language Models can Share Images, Too! | 2023-10-23T10:59:21 | 2023-10-23T10:59:21 | Young-Jun Lee, Jonghwan Hyeon, Ho-Jin Choi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper explores the image-sharing capability of Large Language Models
(LLMs), such as InstructGPT, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, in a zero-shot setting,
without the help of visual foundation models. Inspired by the two-stage process
of image-sharing in human dialogues, we propose a two-stage framework that
allows LLMs to predict potential image-sharing turns and generate related image
descriptions using our effective restriction-based prompt template. With
extensive experiments, we unlock the \textit{image-sharing} capability of LLMs
in zero-shot prompting, with GPT-4 achieving the best performance.
Additionally, we uncover the emergent \textit{image-sharing} ability in
zero-shot prompting, demonstrating the effectiveness of restriction-based
prompts in both stages of our framework. Based on this framework, we augment
the PhotoChat dataset with images generated by Stable Diffusion at predicted
turns, namely PhotoChat++. To our knowledge, this is the first study to assess
the image-sharing ability of LLMs in a zero-shot setting without visual
foundation models. The source code and the dataset will be released after
publication. | [
0.0343557522,
0.0383044071,
-0.0312358998,
0.0636522919,
-0.0554794818,
0.0034115941,
0.0345036052,
0.0501723625,
0.0387006886,
-0.0271306466,
-0.0305922236,
-0.087851733,
0.0014517478,
0.0478319079,
0.0347020403,
-0.0995805264,
0.0113629922,
-0.0441622548,
-0.0069760811,
-0.0212640949,
0.040785376,
0.0018638911,
-0.0010932119,
0.0385852121,
-0.0225177594,
-0.024718117,
-0.0376076177,
0.0311632268,
-0.0226074066,
-0.0222120695,
-0.0634041652,
0.0788917392,
0.0204183534,
0.0246884469,
0.0000019146,
-0.0359075554,
0.034880694,
-0.0361583456,
-0.0205450673,
0.0038774542,
0.0535766147,
-0.0267704334,
-0.0216336735,
-0.0061211758,
-0.0329238288,
0.0159265585,
0.0862098858,
0.0363416113,
0.0761407688,
0.0407247543,
-0.0253590103,
0.0026024126,
0.0052210563,
-0.0326802693,
0.0496919341,
-0.0205850136,
0.0066483677,
0.0001072941,
0.0310738329,
0.0287085939,
-0.0414108932,
0.0556096844,
0.0247113984,
-0.0411823802,
0.0044202409,
0.069801569,
-0.0213777367,
-0.0841400474,
-0.0480557047,
0.0902841613,
0.0003292595,
0.0094329715,
0.0082193026,
-0.0215470325,
0.0059582791,
0.0350265428,
-0.099405624,
0.0300725754,
0.0076348823,
0.0106783118,
-0.0638331324,
0.0075570522,
0.0088650212,
-0.0046811323,
0.0240803286,
0.005260082,
0.0334479809,
-0.0026790074,
-0.0484624431,
0.0027968008,
-0.0359431095,
-0.0945612267,
0.002857835,
0.0243271347,
0.0026751591,
0.035857562,
-0.0524408855,
0.018667195,
0.025189409,
0.0016327926,
0.0382195599,
0.0174045619,
-0.0269925352,
0.0606446899,
0.0171912815,
0.0372287929,
-0.0161217693,
0.0060458905,
-0.0179011021,
-0.0064900946,
-0.0439026095,
-0.0263750367,
-0.0577882938,
0.013622826,
-0.0256770886,
-0.0680353791,
-0.0395037234,
0.0664125755,
0.0061824284,
-0.0060110302,
0.0316094905,
-0.0133578405,
-0.0124443639,
0.0096493261,
-0.0023006713,
0.019318454,
0.0010259215,
-0.0482931584,
0.0180133842,
-0.0873580202,
-0.0030840803,
0.0091304835,
0.019772226,
-0.0193758998,
-0.0459731966,
0.071111165,
-0.0191506147,
-0.0367397033,
0.0384498127,
-0.032428652,
-0.0210558232,
-0.045874279,
0.0170661565,
-0.0482197329,
0.0361417495,
0.0100847455,
0.0126016214,
-0.0018076822,
-0.0051446287,
0.039263919,
-0.0372359902,
0.0919061378,
-0.0134440176,
0.026850516,
0.0108666392,
0.0466870554,
-0.0206396915,
0.0700092688,
0.00755121,
0.0322426111,
0.0506264195,
-0.0246188063,
0.0343060978,
0.090804778,
0.0153349144,
0.0303381924,
-0.011113124,
-0.0175698735,
0.0108952783,
0.0033670177,
0.0063737272,
0.0675964132,
-0.0630776212,
-0.0244078245,
0.1004444808,
0.0955310687,
-0.0038920741,
0.00250624,
0.0328413546,
0.0342754312,
-0.0168744363,
0.0222686604,
-0.0536192246,
0.0524451919,
0.0023072208,
0.0126832249,
0.017270796,
0.0079813693,
-0.0573697463,
0.0022131945,
-0.0039231447,
-0.0123474048,
0.0278569199,
-0.0019934492,
0.0048075784,
0.0193027128,
-0.0359743908,
0.054099597,
0.0061184699,
-0.0437432081,
-0.0197922569,
-0.0466012657,
0.0410045907,
0.0950539187,
0.0514172614,
0.0520228371,
0.0037264447,
-0.0017328749,
0.0389707796,
0.0282404087,
0.0340128541,
0.0097267115,
0.0112947719,
-0.0448878482,
-0.0071590911,
0.0035385098,
-0.0159308035,
0.0104571506,
-0.0160548016,
0.0196965653,
-0.0013749591,
0.0329809077,
0.0180029776,
-0.0063355211,
0.0098506166,
0.0098258359,
-0.0304893702,
0.0151390536,
-0.0134868817,
0.0080560902,
-0.0019802605,
0.004685251,
-0.0002527419,
0.0243925583,
-0.0202394649,
0.0442796163,
-0.0946329683,
-0.0432110615,
0.0198495518,
-0.0120098423,
-0.0192287229,
-0.0214209929,
-0.0250166543,
-0.0350066498,
0.0320245661,
-0.0111866007,
0.0425607115,
-0.0494376421,
0.0251087565,
0.0286819413,
0.0400801934,
0.0224738717,
0.041380614,
-0.0077809258,
-0.0155947525,
0.0459018908,
0.0246851258,
-0.0067878319,
-0.0548016056,
-0.0224019084,
0.0339689441,
-0.0058048982,
0.0083365655,
0.0149893677,
0.0379054956,
-0.0466971062,
-0.0021333939,
-0.1199349687,
-0.0295204856,
-0.0181374326,
-0.0140399821,
0.0186151862,
0.0360612571,
-0.0113640819,
-0.0208073482,
-0.0584407561,
0.028411556,
0.0263384841,
0.0456352606,
0.0292086042,
-0.0047534266,
-0.0171213709,
-0.0260684472,
-0.0225206893,
0.0244935993,
0.0494489968,
0.0003329806,
-0.0287225004,
-0.032569807,
0.0385621041,
-0.0122430595,
0.0330322422,
-0.015438538,
-0.0223386604,
0.0176434424,
-0.0109568955,
0.0310681965,
0.0238698628,
0.0073612584,
0.0198327079,
-0.025589617,
-0.0349558257,
-0.0430549756,
-0.006472249,
-0.0121986158,
-0.0150982719,
0.0073090894,
-0.0364824533,
-0.0089104259,
0.0524145104,
-0.0105140405,
0.0315021835,
-0.0788654462,
0.0207838397,
0.0023940913,
-0.0284753498,
-0.0523329973,
-0.0084252479,
-0.0155621711,
0.0263043102,
-0.0480919965,
-0.0938318372,
0.0422021113,
-0.0610821657,
-0.0562179871,
0.0476239286,
-0.0063488698,
-0.0071569518,
0.0876179785,
0.0425240658,
0.0047890507,
0.0489034876,
-0.0046116007,
-0.0305906348,
0.0045479806,
0.0234228838,
-0.0039672265,
0.0036126669,
-0.0535429865,
0.0088409334,
-0.0157018416,
-0.0195451137,
-0.0066134734,
-0.0715889856,
-0.0262368787,
-0.0081141749,
-0.0294979345,
-0.0287989024,
0.0524174199,
0.0557639971,
0.0075389035,
0.0014829078,
-0.019912919,
-0.0041773384,
-0.040167354,
0.0346606448,
0.0720136538,
-0.0313282683,
-0.0708875805,
-0.0585039705,
0.0640403256,
0.0721251592,
0.0301244818,
0.0031923742,
0.0002938728,
0.0082668597,
0.0134882005,
0.0534321927,
-0.0528961532,
0.0422722325,
0.0695112124,
-0.0113874925,
0.0056147221,
0.0972000137,
0.0211717263,
-0.0576432347,
-0.0176133756,
-0.0074199568,
0.0466028787,
0.0127213756,
-0.0061246995,
-0.119105421,
-0.0242935754,
0.0010160108,
-0.0493846871,
0.004429664,
-0.0058910684,
-0.0393741131,
-0.1114738435,
0.0517959967,
-0.0045297132,
-0.0187513828,
0.0267829821,
0.0153109692,
-0.0014800146,
0.0069987685,
-0.0088361297,
-0.0241125114,
-0.0153677044,
-0.0111137563,
-0.0104308901,
0.0120875305,
-0.0218941811,
0.0432030261,
-0.0347154625,
0.0359802358,
0.0433731899,
0.0251767877,
0.0331107639,
-0.0467023812,
0.0132809803,
-0.0032342435,
0.0125764692,
-0.0126918936,
0.0735912025,
-0.0048069386,
-0.0169388689,
-0.010593568,
0.0128343711,
0.0221081171,
-0.0279286988,
-0.0189640969,
0.0589363649,
-0.0253987573,
-0.0246225018,
-0.0027014245,
0.0126907425,
0.0284740292,
0.0618161522,
0.0423400924,
-0.0420130417,
-0.0308255572,
-0.0208217856,
0.0107477605,
-0.0334213264,
-0.0429403596,
-0.0214388277,
-0.0031886918,
-0.0302039012,
-0.069581531,
-0.0230131727,
0.0199097022,
0.0187635068,
-0.005555856,
0.0022694252,
0.0006031154,
0.00469568,
0.0134515604,
0.00156745,
-0.0698522478,
0.0176338442,
-0.053150855,
-0.0119461836,
0.0109848585,
-0.0320486426,
0.0122512598,
0.0203682706,
-0.098757945,
-0.071911782,
-0.0515794829,
0.0487032682,
0.0269382261,
0.0371669643,
-0.0135349091,
-0.0732250586,
0.0486624725,
0.0166204311,
0.011047258,
0.010478355,
0.0250259638,
0.0142055424,
-0.0039957818,
0.0309876818,
-0.0064004851,
0.005636394,
0.0000536609,
-0.022440441,
-0.0538745262,
-0.0393541642,
-0.0055602142,
0.0130725084,
0.0130719235,
-0.0104488488,
0.0279241111,
-0.0032000067,
0.0164421909,
-0.0407819636,
0.0212611835,
-0.0746025443,
-0.0000786136,
0.0095018921,
-0.0181966182,
0.0060541159,
-0.0329159871,
-0.0411200449,
0.0218593813,
-0.0398901775,
-0.013037106,
0.0240424816,
-0.0192331281,
0.0269407183,
0.0058770981,
0.0236243848,
0.0181403253,
-0.0086189723,
0.0118938005,
-0.0218977798,
0.0969074816,
0.0033262693,
-0.0424689278,
0.0207665414,
0.0545525625,
-0.0295892414,
-0.0634242594,
0.0012298346,
0.0703329146,
0.0601104908,
0.0107024061,
0.0305133313,
-0.0439693891,
0.005352119,
-0.0147127379,
0.0441571623,
0.0028724985,
-0.0862920359,
0.0459185988,
0.0180225335,
-0.0062043727,
0.0080932388,
0.0578072816,
-0.0014981678,
0.0134844584,
0.020504538,
-0.0160239935,
-0.0305241589,
0.0182102323,
0.0511985794,
-0.0278245732,
-0.0021238432,
0.0308703184,
-0.0478782952,
-0.0707609802,
-0.0077473153,
0.0109237619,
-0.0091797682,
0.0000526678,
0.0620452501,
0.0335878171,
0.0048351879,
0.0089643011,
-0.0174693801,
0.0004342309,
-0.0071377154,
0.0001473582,
-0.0320311114,
-6.15160769e-33,
-0.0094182007,
-0.0276789758,
0.0367055871,
-0.0101001421,
-0.0140896505,
-0.0006898814,
-0.0487509854,
0.0038458458,
0.0159657877,
-0.0126050804,
-0.0339479931,
0.0144563159,
0.0170006454,
0.0307265166,
-0.018555833,
-0.0127186421,
0.0339567475,
-0.0222949404,
-0.0227355994,
0.0447633229,
0.0168427993,
-0.0037237024,
0.024289716,
-0.0187613424,
-0.0056799352,
-0.0273420829,
-0.0165727492,
0.0024461043,
0.0243983958,
0.0575708896,
-0.0251629651,
0.0162291899,
0.0152746886,
-0.0252633486,
-0.0357286297,
0.0679216459,
-0.0270234104,
-0.0208426993,
0.0432665981,
0.021553304,
-0.0635844767,
0.0004651689,
-0.0024642283,
-0.050872121,
0.009264498,
-0.0046895454,
0.0073481202,
0.011518036,
-0.0104909241,
0.0467886813,
-0.0388935357,
0.0066887201,
-0.0077106617,
-0.060724318,
0.0377971753,
0.0409652069,
0.029995149,
0.0096442839,
-0.0348821878,
0.064677909,
0.0058997874,
0.0231052376,
0.0797580779,
0.0218044873,
0.0404177047,
0.041829031,
0.029991908,
0.0150351459,
-0.0066657481,
-0.0117857037,
0.0006535685,
0.0628889799,
0.0196968447,
0.0383573472,
0.0161582902,
-0.0140930638,
0.0126448758,
-0.0111170849,
0.001873745,
0.0174369384,
0.0098579181,
0.0405601747,
-0.0246529393,
-0.010930717,
-0.0207869653,
-0.0285972767,
-0.0514179058,
-0.0631488338,
0.0271317586,
0.0212184954,
0.000242555,
0.0109246429,
0.0802351609,
-0.0340046138,
-0.0517346412,
-0.0044012354,
-0.0261203963,
0.0629425645,
-0.0042444831,
0.0097309044,
-0.0399722382,
-0.0334600359,
0.0517855883,
0.0237615909,
0.0045105708,
0.0653929412,
0.0407507382,
0.0139582818,
-0.0446338542,
-0.0093638999,
-0.0365680419,
0.0301111955,
-0.0211583804,
-0.021328982,
0.0299671851,
-0.0035524315,
-0.0764057115,
0.0286043957,
0.0017944919,
-0.0374315642,
-0.0443314239,
-0.0319253206,
-0.0331889503,
0.0078393584,
-0.0356144346,
0.0175203253,
-0.0564442128,
0.0101340879,
0.0551394187,
-0.0438928567,
-0.022122981,
0.0173559003,
2.652e-7,
-0.0153274834,
0.0099837091,
0.0219989177,
0.0382758342,
0.0418388434,
0.03196612,
-0.0329989791,
0.0348316617,
0.0139810815,
-0.0327394567,
0.0080457767,
0.033701133,
0.0487254113,
-0.0203049462,
-0.0897443071,
0.0093233129,
-0.0899303555,
-0.0285165589,
-0.0282426961,
-0.0062009473,
0.0562936999,
0.0877839997,
0.0077051721,
-0.0068457816,
0.0349263996,
-0.0364657454,
0.0824180543,
-0.0476894565,
-0.0245571472,
-0.0134045929,
0.0076278266,
-0.0031532696,
-0.012295003,
0.0213747211,
-0.015309792,
-0.028142076,
0.0101856804,
0.0204427671,
-0.0084713753,
-0.0100478344,
-0.0127536785,
-0.0193528198,
-0.0420338213,
-0.0547179356,
0.0697326437,
-0.0537506007,
-0.0377460793,
-0.0155859245,
0.0018520907,
-0.0342257917,
0.0354791358,
-0.0303021781,
-0.0449712835,
0.0307182446,
0.0184214506,
-0.0113813812,
-0.0271573439,
-0.0548330396,
-0.026187053,
-0.0581653044,
-0.0256050043,
-0.0555336326,
-0.0886212066,
-0.0360110514,
0.0144485468,
-0.0229188763,
-0.0211437494,
2.059985892e-34,
0.022853585,
-0.0058099069,
0.0330493748,
0.0354944281,
0.0320224948,
0.0069514289,
0.0174408965,
0.0292590279,
0.0225488413,
-0.055874005,
-0.0359095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14799v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14799v1 | Cross-lingual Prompting: Improving Zero-shot Chain-of-Thought Reasoning across Languages | 2023-10-23T10:56:03 | 2023-10-23T10:56:03 | Libo Qin, Qiguang Chen, Fuxuan Wei, Shijue Huang, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-thought (CoT) is capable of eliciting models to explicitly generate
reasoning paths, thus promoting reasoning accuracy and attracting increasing
attention. Specifically, zero-shot CoT achieves remarkable improvements in a
wide range of reasoning tasks by simply instructing the LLM with the prompt
"Let's think step by step!". Despite the success of zero-shot CoT, the existing
zero-shot prompting techniques remain limited to a single language, making it
challenging to generalize to other languages and hindering global development.
In this work, we introduce cross-lingual prompting (CLP), aiming to improve
zero-shot CoT reasoning across languages. Specifically, CLP consists of two
main components: (1) cross-lingual alignment prompting and (2) task-specific
solver prompting. The cross-lingual alignment prompting is responsible for
aligning representations across different languages, whereas the task-specific
solver prompting is used to generate the final chain of thoughts and results
for the reasoning task. In addition, we further introduce cross-lingual
self-consistent prompting (CLSP) to ensemble different reasoning paths across
languages. Our experimental evaluations on several benchmarks demonstrate that
CLP and CLSP significantly outperform the existing prompting methods and
achieve state-of-the-art performance. We hope this work will inspire further
breakthroughs in cross-lingual CoT. | [
-0.0158622935,
-0.0078835785,
0.0080387415,
0.0631305203,
-0.0572615676,
0.0229311958,
0.0379071757,
-0.0377984829,
0.0088298256,
-0.0045042732,
-0.0234403498,
-0.0166827533,
-0.0132203605,
-0.0001142198,
0.0157117117,
-0.0110836746,
0.0485773422,
-0.0597382635,
-0.0200679488,
-0.0417498685,
-0.0009554103,
0.0111876596,
-0.043376036,
0.0232789833,
0.0065931734,
-0.058402326,
-0.066001147,
-0.0011324739,
0.0450678356,
-0.0271254852,
-0.0302637555,
0.0580872744,
0.0180207752,
0.0432114229,
0.0000021202,
-0.0564864315,
-0.0128226578,
-0.0214606654,
-0.0538886711,
-0.0516910367,
-0.0459154956,
0.0123857567,
-0.0070183189,
0.0010481589,
-0.0412889794,
0.021769125,
0.034748137,
0.0400796905,
0.0423250757,
0.059252426,
0.0092023863,
-0.0156753156,
-0.016919829,
-0.0065827691,
0.0509437397,
-0.0362907313,
-0.0255991537,
0.0058850632,
0.014398423,
-0.0054198699,
-0.0143593671,
0.0397565588,
0.0571343079,
-0.0080228746,
-0.0218842831,
0.0279031321,
-0.0490612835,
-0.0253445711,
-0.028028179,
0.0760051236,
-0.0053766011,
-0.0187201258,
-0.0282144267,
-0.0044589685,
0.0096015539,
-0.0181355402,
-0.0530498102,
0.0566240773,
0.0075279707,
0.0216790922,
0.0342755653,
0.0340296961,
0.0188185461,
0.0070442944,
-0.0305304974,
0.1104593948,
-0.0081822872,
-0.0363649204,
0.030147152,
0.0216668379,
0.0392115116,
-0.0793703496,
-0.019083038,
0.0449484028,
-0.0494892746,
0.009455598,
0.0113526955,
-0.0093482258,
0.0094750207,
-0.0038198107,
0.0402863622,
0.0699902624,
-0.0440202467,
0.0729195699,
-0.0619999655,
0.0467527546,
-0.027640786,
0.0057009608,
-0.0300628934,
-0.0241183694,
-0.0621827506,
0.0034896082,
-0.0266238973,
0.0345027111,
-0.0400448479,
0.0049437764,
-0.046596095,
0.0322167203,
-0.0159385558,
0.0508096404,
0.0103990613,
-0.0044921902,
0.006818308,
-0.0275416207,
-0.0326520428,
0.0418605134,
-0.0663605109,
-0.014110608,
0.0312549733,
-0.034785375,
-0.0341845267,
0.0080159102,
-0.0362321138,
-0.0328031145,
0.0166182555,
0.0735626146,
-0.0155885732,
0.020118067,
-0.0200752411,
-0.0375632942,
-0.0022089314,
-0.1138635427,
0.0311838426,
-0.0988658741,
0.042852968,
0.0172410049,
-0.0179330818,
0.0059052426,
0.009409111,
0.0099898623,
-0.0014205549,
0.0625438318,
-0.0065065837,
-0.0147483787,
-0.0280982777,
0.0078164171,
-0.0328874737,
0.1046410352,
0.0137177911,
0.020283917,
0.0164354146,
0.0207973775,
-0.0064611956,
0.0200714003,
0.0222478285,
-0.0034701671,
0.0072339964,
0.0131338676,
0.0197892282,
0.0291991197,
-0.0015636554,
0.0073352228,
-0.0204981267,
0.0273758918,
0.007664179,
0.0396842957,
0.0107136304,
0.0001352677,
0.0528607741,
-0.0424936712,
-0.028037535,
0.0155136799,
-0.0699528307,
0.089593716,
-0.0470892303,
0.0187592376,
0.0193908717,
0.0485172831,
-0.0418890826,
-0.033578787,
0.0004849036,
0.0389614627,
-0.009372971,
0.0322889872,
0.0285452399,
-0.0046415124,
-0.0079030627,
0.0591076948,
0.0207485389,
-0.0760640875,
-0.0384408049,
-0.0138989631,
0.0430095755,
0.0477916524,
0.0096205007,
0.0043004751,
-0.0749201998,
-0.0123264063,
0.0368245728,
0.0316151232,
-0.0004233173,
0.0018744341,
0.005041922,
-0.0489982888,
-0.0455712453,
-0.0266843587,
-0.0152632026,
0.0183456335,
-0.0060341028,
0.028596431,
-0.0017929469,
-0.0157680511,
0.0279120747,
0.0005931993,
-0.0249192677,
0.0094130905,
0.0120673897,
0.0507475547,
-0.0056656473,
0.0345378853,
0.0225340072,
0.0117106792,
0.0111153228,
-0.0445549376,
-0.0301252529,
0.0352758691,
-0.0431835689,
-0.0897459909,
0.0455441438,
-0.0309312586,
-0.0579914637,
-0.0560110025,
-0.0525576286,
-0.0411184132,
0.0208292399,
0.0280089006,
-0.023660602,
-0.0312975943,
0.0210444741,
0.0154767958,
-0.0181506909,
-0.0223717112,
0.0842016265,
0.0024461127,
0.0276071876,
0.0488951132,
0.0045663319,
0.0582984909,
-0.0480862595,
-0.006444681,
0.0416141972,
-0.0027884983,
-0.0345933847,
0.0071523041,
0.0432273336,
-0.0615080595,
0.0054408694,
-0.0831387714,
0.0253964309,
-0.0150160249,
0.0268836729,
0.001660321,
0.0042668367,
0.0010962228,
-0.0188661106,
-0.0879816264,
0.0151299676,
0.0351741016,
0.0228694379,
0.0316043757,
-0.0249981061,
-0.0077007576,
0.0023679917,
0.0177212935,
-0.0283310898,
0.0379107073,
-0.011032314,
-0.0309411753,
-0.0480657332,
0.0288238861,
-0.0754698589,
0.0048450246,
-0.0175201837,
0.0022253606,
0.0312575698,
0.0088596288,
0.0481588803,
0.059971001,
-0.0527143367,
-0.0648156777,
0.0688976273,
-0.0393466391,
-0.05853194,
0.0403786786,
0.0119379088,
0.0027482938,
0.0181465819,
-0.0178810041,
-0.0312039778,
0.0467107967,
-0.0219289288,
0.004637144,
-0.0586718842,
0.0049084369,
0.0052736169,
-0.0258328356,
-0.0512736104,
0.0070230206,
0.0187575128,
0.09004163,
-0.0201781765,
-0.0009705365,
0.0962918475,
-0.0168802496,
-0.0210062284,
-0.0378395878,
0.0213737898,
-0.0469595008,
0.0547018945,
-0.0439674631,
0.0237064343,
0.0231578052,
0.0047618579,
-0.0706241429,
-0.0184614677,
0.0359750614,
-0.0010138478,
0.0585657693,
-0.0194185544,
-0.0045056157,
-0.0388224162,
-0.0685289577,
-0.0554381683,
0.0063609476,
-0.0314263962,
0.0168360285,
-0.042362649,
-0.0091740107,
-0.0092394287,
-0.0105362516,
0.0557763651,
-0.0050412253,
-0.0250401516,
-0.0079030944,
-0.017391758,
0.0077343741,
0.0191345699,
0.0077528907,
0.0357311517,
-0.0192809757,
0.0643690526,
0.0571010485,
0.0296395738,
-0.0150976544,
-0.0149049563,
0.0354914814,
0.0073057455,
-0.0053094737,
-0.0160792992,
-0.0089680664,
0.0622196123,
-0.0550967567,
0.0184967741,
0.0971177295,
0.0259243939,
-0.0342141278,
-0.0142280953,
-0.0850049034,
0.0328858458,
0.029984124,
0.0532887876,
-0.1252073199,
-0.0532251075,
0.023823712,
-0.0408835821,
0.0093028285,
-0.0391267389,
0.0042111841,
-0.127311781,
0.0451535545,
0.015922321,
-0.0122831753,
-0.0049537704,
-0.0243049655,
-0.0026944091,
-0.003127415,
-0.0030629577,
0.0169840343,
0.0207497515,
-0.0063594743,
-0.0085556014,
0.0226919577,
-0.006954819,
0.0360309854,
-0.04788284,
0.0174008645,
0.0483244844,
0.0169740021,
0.0340265967,
-0.0574946925,
0.0059098313,
0.0038796233,
0.0176500417,
-0.0261096507,
-0.0040590698,
0.0241762344,
-0.019945005,
-0.013258419,
0.0183396209,
-0.0243201014,
-0.0323418491,
0.0325733908,
0.1191413701,
-0.0132760881,
0.0127587654,
-0.0078270668,
0.0380786322,
0.0043749735,
0.0743478388,
0.0119408621,
0.0108554885,
-0.0466419123,
-0.0368292257,
-0.0641307086,
-0.0459094942,
-0.0136949737,
0.0069927708,
0.002209862,
-0.0089517878,
-0.0426883101,
-0.0623590536,
0.0571280494,
0.0471462756,
0.0006363291,
-0.002000351,
-0.0586886518,
0.0117303459,
-0.0283099823,
0.0238084812,
-0.0362344496,
0.0145208212,
-0.0226918031,
0.0486247651,
-0.0174004491,
-0.0250242744,
0.0092270207,
0.0387810767,
-0.0652374625,
-0.0767926052,
-0.0664937049,
0.0577110052,
0.0185672827,
0.0486497097,
0.0055940612,
-0.0012297377,
0.0256591737,
0.0226498973,
0.018044576,
-0.0039011776,
0.0365890339,
0.0407419056,
0.0185143445,
0.0556621477,
-0.0324706957,
0.0045935805,
0.0064147846,
0.0761349648,
-0.0329381116,
-0.0108734826,
0.0325386114,
0.0170044415,
0.0135262264,
-0.0300330222,
0.0049040383,
-0.0220082998,
0.0504109003,
-0.0314019285,
-0.0545211546,
-0.0113482764,
0.0192807727,
-0.0177101064,
-0.0457490608,
0.0556280725,
0.009281653,
-0.0269852318,
-0.0133254332,
-0.02222367,
0.0150688374,
0.0265312213,
0.0426576436,
0.0166070033,
0.0153988339,
-0.0197751448,
0.0073380922,
0.0269626528,
0.039568726,
-0.0337108634,
0.0880335197,
0.0339323319,
0.0096956315,
-0.0389794298,
0.0196324568,
-0.0503646992,
-0.0567778684,
0.0527338348,
-0.0065768892,
0.0887430832,
0.0139146317,
0.0252666958,
-0.0053476309,
-0.0175341535,
0.0458939783,
0.0419461243,
0.0152884284,
-0.0380224697,
0.0242607482,
0.0314801745,
0.0180518869,
-0.0318395458,
0.0388056971,
-0.0678992718,
0.011234113,
0.0106558288,
0.017249871,
-0.0264924858,
-0.018763788,
-0.0018327972,
-0.0163083412,
-0.0109043075,
0.0069124168,
-0.0724584833,
-0.0719966143,
-0.0003869949,
0.0232718345,
-0.0207664333,
0.0324368589,
0.0398368351,
0.0685158074,
0.0169156697,
-0.025384333,
0.0098430822,
0.0109432638,
-0.000250695,
-0.0455523059,
-0.0349878594,
-6.247549702e-33,
-0.019673422,
-0.0177027881,
0.0757140815,
0.0000145174,
-0.008432948,
-0.0211161189,
-0.0491884202,
0.0215879269,
-0.0222902838,
0.0385235362,
-0.0273690391,
-0.0253752135,
0.0109547162,
-0.0152214607,
0.0380922966,
-0.0248765219,
0.0082261078,
0.0080382982,
-0.0388042778,
-0.0072959019,
0.0567242801,
0.0045697833,
0.0684848279,
-0.0210149232,
0.0530971065,
0.0001261826,
-0.0124966037,
0.0521852709,
-0.0204630904,
0.0285791382,
-0.0004111856,
0.0094650695,
0.0296530779,
-0.0153261535,
-0.0069166915,
0.0024383964,
-0.0420897454,
-0.0628643483,
0.0465483442,
-0.0132505661,
-0.0651392788,
-0.0434794389,
-0.0166481305,
-0.0168128442,
-0.011721829,
-0.0233085938,
-0.0001877401,
-0.0253127366,
0.0042871875,
0.0091555668,
-0.0560901463,
-0.010116972,
-0.0242751669,
-0.04398771,
0.0421811827,
0.1034635976,
-0.009486706,
-0.0117761455,
-0.0424093269,
0.0283722356,
-0.0061568604,
0.0014426041,
0.1136093959,
-0.0169486199,
-0.0132100107,
0.0369425267,
0.0210567228,
-0.0158073995,
-0.0552905537,
0.0120807635,
-0.0195630565,
0.0409265459,
0.064003244,
0.0396068096,
0.0179464053,
0.0815264881,
-0.0798783898,
0.0191845056,
0.0267042909,
0.0421746597,
-0.0024832403,
-0.0055349334,
-0.037406452,
-0.014939528,
-0.0229552276,
-0.0250358302,
-0.0446774587,
-0.0545144379,
0.02095614,
-0.0220142249,
-0.0017100895,
-0.0221309438,
0.0450292639,
-0.0030413694,
0.0085878801,
0.0366828367,
0.0093166782,
0.0079397177,
0.0167088471,
0.0216193758,
-0.0296648759,
0.0011928095,
-0.0271353107,
0.0172741618,
0.0301325768,
0.0139731234,
0.0600646473,
-0.0013271936,
-0.037591666,
-0.0074678096,
-0.082123369,
0.0241960529,
-0.0052952543,
0.0189696476,
0.0126712872,
0.0036113088,
-0.0186239239,
0.0390168503,
0.0003076763,
-0.0434639789,
-0.0181369949,
0.0248928275,
-0.0116779292,
0.0324148796,
-0.0082737505,
0.0136820851,
-0.0283465814,
0.028109055,
0.0198048223,
-0.0455290638,
-0.0117204357,
0.0451063477,
2.789e-7,
0.00726646,
-0.0048874915,
0.0068934611,
0.0334864631,
-0.0083987145,
0.0437011383,
-0.0569986552,
-0.0255349837,
0.015707029,
-0.0522509925,
-0.0227575172,
0.0770513564,
0.0294922516,
0.0390540734,
-0.0909701064,
0.0050873938,
-0.0108364448,
-0.0357440785,
-0.0383021384,
-0.0064561879,
0.0420669876,
0.0357766338,
0.0007996903,
-0.011919992,
0.0134163806,
0.0172896776,
0.0516214967,
0.0001518562,
-0.0159744453,
-0.0049692141,
-0.0192743354,
-0.0278536566,
0.0002506899,
0.0264266841,
0.0082132714,
0.0178500973,
-0.0237011649,
0.0183292963,
0.0090284031,
-0.0260427874,
-0.0164522361,
-0.0312136337,
0.0083369594,
-0.056172166,
0.0747091994,
-0.0306310654,
-0.0164439771,
-0.0038189832,
0.0055604498,
0.0102421045,
0.0523235612,
-0.0008508827,
-0.0201525595,
0.0193380546,
0.0330166221,
-0.0136414533,
-0.0131231509,
-0.0373593569,
-0.0464869626,
-0.0027995277,
0.0007883302,
-0.002706026,
-0.0180868693,
0.0057088463,
0.0028291014,
-0.0497487262,
-0.0297011435,
2.564973214e-34,
0.0120197935,
-0.0202593058,
0.0408146717,
0.0473826565,
0.0149457455,
-0.0228151921,
-0.0485209674,
0.0031046208,
0.0258382186,
-0.0429605208,
-0.0391855277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14793v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14793v1 | What do Deck Chairs and Sun Hats Have in Common? Uncovering Shared Properties in Large Concept Vocabularies | 2023-10-23T10:53:25 | 2023-10-23T10:53:25 | Amit Gajbhiye, Zied Bouraoui, Na Li, Usashi Chatterjee, Luis Espinosa Anke, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Concepts play a central role in many applications. This includes settings
where concepts have to be modelled in the absence of sentence context. Previous
work has therefore focused on distilling decontextualised concept embeddings
from language models. But concepts can be modelled from different perspectives,
whereas concept embeddings typically mostly capture taxonomic structure. To
address this issue, we propose a strategy for identifying what different
concepts, from a potentially large concept vocabulary, have in common with
others. We then represent concepts in terms of the properties they share with
the other concepts. To demonstrate the practical usefulness of this way of
modelling concepts, we consider the task of ultra-fine entity typing, which is
a challenging multi-label classification problem. We show that by augmenting
the label set with shared properties, we can improve the performance of the
state-of-the-art models for this task. | [
-0.0088566216,
0.0310200211,
-0.0184983127,
0.0340828747,
-0.0000944225,
0.0375327207,
-0.0557209738,
-0.0191888046,
-0.0378240049,
-0.0815928206,
-0.0116390828,
-0.0235568322,
0.0057283803,
0.032752417,
0.053991396,
-0.0499707498,
0.0191505346,
0.0405687243,
-0.021033084,
0.0047417502,
0.0305953603,
-0.0037989714,
0.0190184135,
0.0427972749,
-0.0193778221,
-0.0375058353,
-0.0167350397,
-0.0312341861,
0.0259255525,
0.0013331793,
0.0267015696,
0.0427274853,
0.0256669037,
0.0113407495,
0.0000019302,
-0.0393285751,
0.0037674059,
-0.0154138869,
0.0233517084,
0.0223838575,
0.0105807334,
-0.0238581132,
0.0421559215,
-0.0153694339,
-0.0029578332,
-0.0548571572,
0.058378797,
0.0587819144,
0.0235161446,
0.0036495016,
-0.0137717174,
-0.0486318804,
0.0066401204,
-0.0162849557,
0.0379886478,
-0.0385636725,
0.0355114192,
-0.016434567,
0.0186696965,
0.0605913587,
-0.0140507808,
0.0177757759,
-0.0108960308,
0.0338350385,
0.0693582371,
0.0541160777,
0.0076006399,
-0.0093233045,
0.0137278931,
0.0922473148,
-0.0019864489,
-0.018241033,
0.020065587,
0.0153400246,
-0.0033124024,
-0.0265744552,
-0.0161783025,
0.0121566644,
-0.0100231497,
0.0268792696,
0.0343037844,
0.0226030927,
0.0539441928,
0.0009378067,
-0.0409498364,
-0.0047906782,
0.0206768252,
-0.0233574882,
-0.0376993418,
0.0030806263,
-0.0584058911,
-0.0426267609,
-0.0194289107,
0.0184153449,
0.0085417861,
0.0090782652,
-0.0367964581,
0.0033222737,
0.0481294841,
0.0045348653,
0.0216485914,
-0.0098576713,
-0.0109320385,
0.0738965571,
-0.0117478734,
-0.0075076525,
-0.0153296832,
-0.0072787069,
-0.0065283901,
-0.0279815998,
-0.0959395021,
-0.0027673207,
-0.0116222203,
0.0874368995,
0.0319694616,
-0.0247950386,
-0.0071117193,
0.0198427625,
-0.0238833018,
0.0473116562,
-0.0189798586,
-0.0143741919,
-0.0016469663,
0.0070817182,
0.0132229589,
0.0059700632,
-0.0676407143,
0.0008086486,
-0.0060665817,
-0.02704891,
0.0057733189,
-0.0360716172,
0.0035286169,
-0.0287339259,
-0.0152331013,
-0.0219274331,
0.0249102786,
-0.0309604928,
-0.019507613,
-0.0194548797,
-0.0319244862,
-0.0299299285,
-0.0012645659,
-0.0638602152,
0.0413659364,
0.0050824368,
0.0158179905,
-0.0709129721,
0.0023622301,
-0.0173258092,
-0.0345372595,
0.1415974349,
-0.0144629311,
-0.0026594098,
0.0210091732,
0.0332284123,
0.0175927505,
0.0441390499,
0.0132075706,
-0.0266370885,
0.053448543,
-0.0178294368,
-0.0180395246,
0.0082290769,
0.0049019922,
-0.0008999356,
-0.0129205491,
-0.015970258,
0.0251577012,
0.0531119518,
0.0022377118,
0.040720474,
-0.0122791035,
-0.0008800002,
0.0463967957,
0.0256426018,
-0.0157124437,
0.0196001995,
0.0353644341,
-0.0019189019,
-0.0382345803,
0.0010228424,
-0.026790306,
0.0007326574,
0.0089832162,
0.018036237,
0.0396494605,
0.0558447987,
-0.0449597314,
-0.0041452241,
-0.0143195344,
-0.0252523143,
-0.0124328667,
-0.0411003567,
0.0254768673,
0.0061508003,
0.0001884697,
0.0165469665,
0.0486309826,
-0.0113054067,
-0.0149952713,
0.0031989836,
-0.0060439794,
0.0466342643,
0.0235444289,
-0.031606853,
-0.0194439311,
-0.0410333686,
0.0120121008,
0.0292981453,
0.0591393374,
-0.0367163382,
-0.0099738436,
-0.0253680982,
-0.0298287626,
-0.0105938818,
0.0447583646,
0.0280146692,
-0.021654252,
0.0132933091,
0.0300371796,
-0.0816131383,
0.0626478717,
0.0451400056,
0.0008135994,
-0.00525783,
0.0002764499,
0.050728526,
0.0031703094,
0.0411152169,
-0.0016519484,
0.0174771212,
0.0208571665,
-0.0572877526,
-0.0350788198,
-0.0397631004,
0.0137436371,
-0.0192125347,
0.0498298667,
-0.0081440005,
-0.028969923,
0.0149276881,
-0.03161202,
-0.0281216297,
-0.0190793406,
0.012334927,
0.0184378996,
-0.0374363065,
-0.0061870301,
-0.0041549089,
0.0084486715,
-0.0223949589,
0.0718421862,
0.0202474725,
0.0392792076,
-0.0728124157,
-0.007493414,
0.0284969825,
-0.0089368001,
-0.0840482712,
-0.0018722317,
0.0229132641,
0.0335459784,
0.0181855317,
-0.0223357994,
-0.0070921625,
-0.0155356238,
-0.065433532,
0.0059140516,
0.0335263759,
-0.013298912,
-0.005816217,
-0.0042220056,
0.0373727754,
0.0302163865,
0.0003369355,
-0.0280912183,
-0.0576135404,
0.0464034975,
0.0510726087,
-0.0228022207,
-0.0806050524,
-0.0185163952,
0.0010134309,
-0.0411655009,
0.0745350271,
-0.021445157,
-0.0279884301,
0.0028092805,
0.0571050234,
-0.0397606157,
0.0035584006,
0.0191868022,
-0.0130068678,
-0.0005364856,
0.0128986221,
0.0015789644,
0.0537842661,
0.0012230339,
0.0011888032,
0.0204214584,
0.0067989794,
-0.0245813727,
0.0008055282,
-0.0242769253,
0.0277682189,
0.009502545,
-0.0031777029,
-0.0107070208,
0.0837964341,
-0.035774406,
-0.0399655178,
-0.0818187371,
0.0346677415,
-0.0041959058,
0.0122636026,
-0.0753386617,
0.0089303087,
0.0153882429,
0.012324702,
-0.0124371182,
-0.0037379491,
0.0637047067,
-0.0174416564,
0.0175828449,
0.0206077695,
-0.0222849771,
-0.0258564446,
0.087089166,
0.0177748278,
0.0209601633,
0.0593583696,
0.0147828273,
-0.0561984852,
0.0379774235,
0.015544462,
-0.0047646756,
0.0386724547,
0.0158120766,
0.0030501445,
0.0133641437,
-0.070123136,
-0.0356745012,
-0.0148977656,
-0.0331577361,
0.054538101,
0.0072763888,
-0.016138643,
-0.031941589,
0.0206202678,
-0.0277718902,
-0.015098148,
0.0436861478,
-0.0066885701,
-0.0365069509,
0.0423453338,
0.057822071,
-0.0282562282,
-0.0079454705,
-0.0066493312,
0.0214173719,
0.0056752334,
0.0216202382,
-0.0071828542,
-0.0159704592,
-0.0030438344,
0.0020193572,
-0.040755257,
-0.0786566734,
0.001429829,
0.0046313321,
0.0143993087,
-0.0120541574,
0.1183658466,
0.0432284102,
0.0149627598,
0.0266386718,
0.0250679255,
0.0696238875,
0.0373867452,
-0.0224716309,
-0.0734890848,
-0.0368831754,
0.020981485,
-0.0519110523,
0.026434904,
-0.0668939576,
0.0071684499,
-0.0803788677,
-0.0098610083,
0.0069957008,
-0.0660954788,
-0.045455236,
-0.0405046269,
0.0012796808,
-0.0170651395,
-0.0295746867,
-0.0436698049,
0.0269431919,
0.0166123398,
-0.0084074363,
-0.0264700353,
-0.0469830744,
0.0812719688,
-0.0602746755,
0.0370828807,
0.0258811936,
0.0519414283,
-0.0135280509,
-0.0164977219,
-0.0272272695,
-0.1112444028,
-0.0420395173,
0.0439853668,
0.0311603099,
-0.074847959,
-0.0222623032,
0.0071251527,
0.0244946834,
-0.0670933202,
-0.0385176539,
-0.0056844889,
0.0884388238,
-0.0105299689,
-0.0212672241,
-0.0344327427,
-0.0387776718,
0.0192998201,
0.0945060179,
0.0503577702,
-0.0504328161,
0.0027245681,
-0.0285466891,
0.0110464655,
-0.0032740429,
-0.0141439224,
0.0076787677,
-0.0122590913,
-0.0176650677,
-0.0574341714,
-0.0648391768,
0.0560553521,
-0.0129613951,
0.0090390313,
0.0326796845,
-0.0119626578,
-0.0115386536,
-0.06278947,
0.0230967477,
-0.0048118527,
0.0230146423,
0.0051723644,
-0.0184806176,
0.0446314663,
0.0355970003,
-0.0703935325,
-0.0110709015,
-0.0639138892,
-0.0595849752,
0.0019720197,
-0.0026820679,
0.0055580004,
-0.0026603236,
-0.0001614029,
-0.0617921092,
0.0633141324,
0.0497655682,
-0.0417617597,
0.0153718041,
0.0226101913,
-0.0078509906,
0.0299618877,
0.0684405342,
-0.0528445952,
0.0329748504,
-0.0029315415,
0.0604084097,
-0.0361364372,
-0.0642258748,
0.0270483233,
-0.018019449,
0.0273378436,
-0.0052288068,
-0.0155435782,
-0.0299469791,
-0.0242816266,
0.0188390911,
-0.0413513929,
-0.0339947008,
-0.0326224566,
0.0148732141,
-0.0002847525,
-0.0047515444,
0.0330300741,
0.020039225,
0.0887648463,
0.0139256958,
-0.0142731657,
-0.000735409,
-0.0179983582,
0.0172876045,
-0.0266800281,
-0.0033581704,
0.0149353975,
-0.0431230851,
-0.0246267933,
-0.037758179,
0.0093408143,
0.0318111889,
0.0235028081,
-0.0449610315,
0.0148862628,
-0.0101841092,
-0.0086409133,
-0.0154189132,
0.0274942555,
0.0524093397,
-0.0008303586,
0.01074332,
-0.0440188199,
-0.0444724597,
-0.0281976908,
0.0441376343,
-0.0202821195,
-0.003711276,
0.0637980774,
0.0447662733,
-0.0359412879,
-0.0311387554,
0.0821707323,
-0.0169263091,
0.0618423447,
0.0164708756,
0.0085051116,
-0.0306127965,
0.02033858,
0.0283988956,
0.0376708172,
0.0144285271,
0.0321247801,
-0.0710674748,
-0.0650781766,
0.0399747789,
-0.0029376331,
-0.0464864448,
0.0455686487,
0.0326899365,
0.0289772805,
0.0039089322,
-0.0160591137,
-0.0139601044,
-0.0085421484,
0.011084957,
-0.0239899661,
-0.0117508257,
-6.075892262e-33,
-0.0259195007,
-0.0134020904,
-0.0093073165,
0.0146605484,
0.0166906845,
0.010333159,
0.0199212432,
-0.0055911378,
-0.0322987251,
0.0398259871,
-0.005141662,
0.03652706,
-0.0123181269,
0.0140399523,
0.0239015725,
0.007894801,
0.0481720418,
0.0125345355,
0.0049883132,
0.0014920419,
0.0006774846,
0.0149024827,
0.0311301257,
-0.0756899863,
0.0107843494,
-0.0234808307,
-0.0095763467,
0.0085904896,
0.059777692,
0.0829452872,
-0.0405910313,
0.0336986668,
0.0140781738,
-0.029182313,
-0.0072971545,
0.0524768494,
-0.0802908167,
-0.0483925603,
-0.0360730104,
-0.0330964848,
0.0150014432,
-0.0464935191,
0.0120627806,
-0.0041567544,
0.0459770784,
-0.059755668,
0.0597893894,
-0.0226091892,
-0.0232191999,
-0.031226296,
-0.0294208061,
0.0344756246,
-0.0037279492,
-0.0001935944,
0.0573192351,
-0.0497454815,
0.023355959,
0.0160875712,
-0.0603664257,
0.0565606877,
0.0122572239,
0.0221024733,
0.0058985152,
-0.018315766,
0.0174219701,
0.0607535206,
0.0094304988,
-0.0080282995,
-0.0411715209,
0.0030300424,
-0.0048199161,
0.0391917005,
-0.0042000688,
0.0805180743,
0.0345141031,
0.0154238101,
-0.0556830652,
0.0229616184,
-0.0379526205,
0.0023951097,
-0.008023941,
-0.0000139971,
-0.0420507491,
-0.0256177131,
-0.0686397627,
0.0194392949,
-0.0388572179,
-0.0035777728,
0.0324840359,
-0.0142566701,
0.0122222686,
0.0346318856,
-0.0165429693,
-0.0666167736,
-0.080291532,
0.0143177174,
0.0151019562,
0.0152872428,
0.0063615339,
-0.0049105096,
-0.0496342592,
-0.0785688832,
0.013715391,
-0.0146734677,
0.0171571169,
0.010979685,
0.073923789,
-0.0083145015,
-0.0533516817,
-0.0180192739,
0.0092935236,
-0.083438389,
-0.0476804301,
-0.0237537082,
0.0292424094,
0.0246234741,
0.0054961508,
0.0279184468,
0.0766220167,
-0.0088531682,
0.0015074438,
-0.0180046968,
0.0152984429,
0.0288650692,
0.0201646071,
-0.0449270681,
-0.0279583577,
-0.033029899,
0.0622587129,
-0.0070715942,
-0.0119111259,
-0.055489298,
2.689e-7,
0.0500190854,
0.0278915204,
-0.0070823976,
-0.0013870598,
0.0143815987,
0.0947028473,
0.0280939713,
0.0481202565,
-0.0820798576,
-0.0743958727,
0.0322957635,
0.0249997918,
0.0192838963,
0.0138077401,
-0.0637130067,
0.0165598132,
0.0009841926,
-0.0141234016,
-0.0703763962,
-0.030445043,
0.0485403985,
0.1130954176,
0.0553373396,
0.006426564,
-0.0078614829,
-0.0362075157,
0.0468209088,
-0.0431993641,
0.0017659698,
0.0398914814,
0.0006696393,
0.0154344849,
0.0033885376,
0.0516039431,
-0.0050242385,
0.0348033719,
0.0603314266,
0.024515463,
-0.0326667018,
0.0185458586,
-0.0325466059,
-0.040523909,
-0.0356082544,
-0.0699420273,
0.0616220422,
-0.0801391602,
-0.0230146237,
0.0061584013,
-0.0166209824,
0.0390493385,
0.0282446593,
0.005269336,
-0.0334405005,
-0.0126153948,
0.0121953012,
0.0062404815,
-0.0011835411,
-0.1032086089,
0.0154153379,
0.0818969756,
-0.0347630233,
-0.0209242944,
-0.0016243152,
-0.0236414708,
0.0626948327,
-0.0685478002,
-0.0085482197,
2.881455553e-34,
-0.000495273,
-0.0062327934,
0.0076815672,
0.0197988972,
0.0487033688,
-0.0629776418,
-0.042369049,
-0.0005550855,
0.0319103524,
-0.0398945622,
0.0203611869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14777v1 | Geographical Erasure in Language Generation | 2023-10-23T10:26:14 | 2023-10-23T10:26:14 | Pola Schwöbel, Jacek Golebiowski, Michele Donini, Cédric Archambeau, Danish Pruthi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) encode vast amounts of world knowledge. However,
since these models are trained on large swaths of internet data, they are at
risk of inordinately capturing information about dominant groups. This
imbalance can propagate into generated language. In this work, we study and
operationalise a form of geographical erasure, wherein language models
underpredict certain countries. We demonstrate consistent instances of erasure
across a range of LLMs. We discover that erasure strongly correlates with low
frequencies of country mentions in the training corpus. Lastly, we mitigate
erasure by finetuning using a custom objective. | [
0.0373105258,
0.101681605,
-0.021710325,
-0.0069093378,
-0.0089478344,
0.0200095028,
0.0375253186,
-0.0179695245,
0.0034454172,
-0.0182383601,
0.0118516684,
-0.0567045547,
0.0089330301,
0.0011590432,
0.0572762825,
-0.0441890359,
0.032617569,
-0.0079609314,
0.0002378115,
-0.0339865647,
-0.0339098312,
0.010702705,
0.0528702512,
0.0398828797,
-0.0027024292,
0.0355548374,
0.0088564474,
-0.0245272964,
-0.0178516228,
-0.0069839554,
0.0221179277,
0.0235185232,
-0.0318316966,
0.021917481,
0.0000019656,
-0.0359216928,
-0.0229245387,
-0.0215843711,
0.0165187903,
0.0510878116,
0.0126262428,
0.0101727704,
-0.0073229242,
0.0243411753,
-0.0095908986,
-0.0217665546,
0.0314272121,
-0.0068133106,
0.0385319702,
0.0636670962,
-0.0025043471,
0.0177048892,
-0.0215698089,
-0.0207423232,
-0.024736343,
0.0339698195,
0.0466180854,
0.0103747016,
-0.0427030474,
-0.0028440435,
-0.0205185562,
0.0217828956,
-0.0026851045,
0.0106390137,
-0.0197260287,
0.0302275028,
-0.0720257312,
-0.021716468,
0.0335564651,
0.0000191034,
0.006924612,
-0.0469777472,
0.0613517761,
0.0152214644,
-0.0165086668,
-0.0104978606,
-0.0093167555,
0.0546856783,
0.0007283599,
0.0485085957,
0.0231690258,
-0.0304512084,
0.0233328193,
0.0395453647,
-0.0207449216,
0.0792824626,
0.0234636571,
-0.0177492052,
-0.0651448071,
0.038899038,
-0.0316254422,
-0.0616411082,
0.0079363156,
0.0311597697,
-0.001148638,
-0.002388543,
-0.0366034061,
0.0435741059,
0.0280495267,
-0.0339896902,
0.0152190309,
0.00029525,
-0.0102870502,
0.012353302,
-0.0362723395,
0.0334224291,
0.004420639,
-0.020397881,
-0.0233861916,
-0.0377644524,
0.0138295479,
-0.0130225895,
0.007938493,
-0.0201989822,
0.006658351,
0.0501832776,
-0.0611665137,
0.0089253755,
-0.0329149254,
0.0304781236,
-0.0553927906,
0.0294611324,
-0.0505602807,
-0.03493765,
-0.0150386803,
0.0027142214,
-0.0056217504,
0.0153326159,
-0.0285273977,
-0.0240622368,
0.0133128092,
0.0155556602,
0.0134002734,
0.005017668,
-0.0062974654,
0.0480564684,
0.0240153521,
-0.0021381571,
-0.0701186731,
-0.0456277318,
-0.0274848621,
-0.0228724889,
0.0265109036,
-0.0606315881,
0.0088382829,
0.0069178436,
-0.019280225,
-0.0758131593,
-0.0212574191,
0.0043476503,
-0.0396027602,
-0.0370173566,
-0.0258898865,
0.0340234861,
0.0686562881,
-0.0124327615,
0.0027087301,
0.0783773661,
0.0106370449,
0.0290393904,
0.036480397,
-0.0185322519,
0.0075248452,
0.0482038744,
0.0454824269,
0.0505982488,
-0.0386354551,
-0.0444929823,
-0.0150562385,
-0.0106618777,
0.0797591731,
0.0349507853,
-0.0036196494,
0.0261303689,
0.0814216062,
0.0200291835,
-0.0245516282,
0.034421701,
0.0314765573,
0.0095757935,
-0.0662824586,
0.023079766,
-0.0512052961,
-0.0261219833,
-0.0399517901,
0.0203863773,
0.0247774664,
0.0644688308,
-0.0316439569,
-0.001214339,
-0.0069734845,
0.006167158,
0.0015658702,
0.0028117015,
0.0735411942,
0.0123940008,
0.0147837056,
0.092748113,
0.0645036846,
-0.041529119,
0.0615297444,
-0.0117958942,
0.0163175259,
-0.0009302185,
0.0249824114,
0.0229031201,
0.0190458745,
-0.0050843186,
0.0322220549,
0.0268658232,
0.0489628278,
-0.0324354246,
0.0073561748,
-0.0141770318,
-0.0268440135,
0.0333206467,
0.0240855031,
0.0066604777,
0.0679322556,
0.0304335244,
0.0545195118,
-0.0611427985,
-0.0264524631,
0.0034588657,
-0.07812123,
-0.0029191175,
-0.0180845745,
-0.0007940805,
-0.0001603167,
0.0076936488,
-0.0402256884,
-0.0140880579,
0.0045434395,
-0.0137546845,
-0.0074377032,
-0.004000226,
-0.0214545522,
0.0029156525,
0.0467415825,
-0.0392586626,
0.0231961142,
-0.0033596607,
-0.0140077835,
-0.0191465821,
0.0362772867,
-0.021074459,
0.0768441781,
-0.0294215027,
0.035794314,
-0.0273942854,
0.0011048387,
-0.0230672825,
0.0742006749,
-0.0243250374,
0.0197844356,
0.0081901019,
-0.0295467302,
0.0300472081,
-0.0247170776,
-0.0144593222,
-0.0220041014,
-0.0254570488,
-0.0092110019,
0.0598170273,
-0.0151385926,
-0.0275886636,
-0.0413486362,
-0.0645642653,
-0.0027546932,
-0.0290330388,
0.0184744,
0.0183578357,
-0.0107899755,
-0.0175957326,
0.0182226505,
-0.0490027294,
-0.0275195241,
0.0296633802,
0.0292756725,
0.0061295703,
-0.0386632718,
0.0133989882,
0.0030998148,
0.0132168746,
0.0191243216,
0.0445324294,
-0.0197414514,
-0.0062346957,
-0.0564580113,
0.0377544239,
-0.1023075059,
0.0084021045,
-0.031341292,
-0.0430067517,
-0.0217016209,
-0.0149228927,
-0.0129704671,
-0.0141376182,
-0.002039708,
-0.0196841527,
0.0804526955,
-0.0240340363,
-0.0415019542,
-0.0311909113,
-0.0415906124,
0.0048999996,
-0.0019638266,
-0.0850604549,
-0.0200823694,
0.0959629044,
0.0369141996,
-0.0071372488,
-0.0041426616,
0.0438561179,
-0.0734539479,
0.0018136853,
-0.0025458315,
0.0044840048,
-0.0250308476,
0.0792902708,
-0.04480955,
-0.0803024173,
0.0207987241,
-0.006844148,
0.0339296237,
0.0234082025,
-0.0129587539,
-0.0039836518,
0.0261169244,
0.0184123628,
0.0479091033,
0.0607478395,
-0.0059731761,
-0.0513808466,
-0.0067791031,
0.0226670168,
-0.0195651017,
-0.0154542923,
-0.0481834784,
-0.0005309805,
-0.0049286732,
-0.0347736962,
-0.049903743,
-0.0281682238,
0.0211172737,
-0.0112409424,
0.0538315363,
-0.0308368653,
0.0276859961,
0.0076368358,
0.0133027826,
0.0387367122,
-0.0154596996,
0.0213707872,
-0.0007635358,
0.0071359891,
0.0841354951,
-0.0120407771,
0.0250444803,
-0.0429585464,
-0.0394604579,
0.0061000269,
0.0051239519,
0.0307417866,
0.036350783,
0.0168213248,
0.0437371358,
-0.0293839667,
-0.0554753877,
0.0119169308,
0.0553176925,
-0.0139778294,
-0.022278294,
0.1020965055,
0.0292328279,
-0.0206986908,
0.0350914262,
0.0029405109,
0.0631656423,
0.0325914361,
0.0297225621,
-0.0584828332,
0.0400934145,
0.011930461,
0.0015441433,
-0.0593249537,
-0.0313904323,
-0.036836639,
-0.1414046288,
0.048936557,
0.0501808003,
-0.0228053089,
-0.0147084175,
-0.0154479537,
-0.021655051,
-0.0002645581,
0.0125939557,
-0.0010468366,
-0.0094795385,
0.0168718696,
0.0365421213,
-0.0598569736,
-0.0554738678,
-0.026671838,
-0.0342338383,
0.0529984646,
-0.0085873464,
0.0479683615,
-0.0026420103,
0.0154655911,
0.0005373541,
0.0052882563,
-0.0155567788,
-0.009056204,
0.046113681,
0.0637091622,
-0.0378326327,
0.0057472461,
0.0117612397,
0.0083172414,
-0.0094370162,
0.0223254114,
0.0480293892,
-0.0178260151,
-0.0068507334,
0.0341440476,
0.000897043,
0.0194285363,
0.0522711687,
0.0139106726,
-0.0248729121,
0.0029220304,
-0.0545276105,
0.0167091154,
-0.0360922366,
-0.0058107977,
0.0366786458,
-0.0310066435,
-0.0422319211,
-0.078071706,
-0.0328923017,
0.0075802063,
0.0275786761,
0.0392203294,
-0.0077881468,
0.0255815238,
-0.0540285744,
-0.0327911153,
0.0236638021,
-0.0569256842,
-0.0598071143,
-0.0176700689,
-0.0244461466,
0.0081386315,
-0.0693909749,
-0.0013480973,
0.040748246,
-0.0718506575,
-0.0838969871,
0.0622523092,
0.0373564325,
0.0187112875,
0.048070889,
0.0305127539,
-0.0486098044,
0.0902754664,
0.0105832387,
-0.0097993445,
0.0558715984,
-0.0207998063,
-0.0191834774,
0.0037495466,
0.0392856002,
-0.0574873947,
0.0225186627,
0.0417634137,
-0.0150184138,
-0.0396418311,
0.0321937017,
-0.004385876,
-0.0145073701,
0.0546990894,
-0.0955619738,
-0.0174248051,
-0.0310075376,
-0.0229292791,
-0.0328855552,
-0.0118510146,
0.002176661,
-0.0129127707,
0.0253303535,
0.0090713538,
-0.0095091322,
0.017346045,
-0.0059543448,
0.0283527616,
-0.0149216782,
-0.0155855138,
-0.0226099249,
0.0352347903,
0.0564003624,
0.0222790577,
-0.004936289,
0.049968645,
-0.0159120653,
0.0496403426,
-0.0248047393,
0.011084266,
-0.0081417775,
0.026031388,
-0.0377361327,
-0.0184326395,
-0.0285983887,
-0.0574688725,
-0.0398309231,
-0.0121912258,
0.0965317935,
-0.0506463759,
0.0666487515,
-0.0120080393,
-0.0107871555,
-0.0194678511,
0.0085587893,
0.0020736295,
-0.0728884414,
-0.0637987405,
-0.0331593305,
-0.0611152463,
0.0622018278,
0.0892231837,
0.0529424511,
0.0628809556,
-0.0084941639,
-0.0364472046,
-0.0210728459,
-0.0224249549,
0.007377659,
-0.0148123112,
-0.029527802,
-0.0050558271,
-0.057703346,
-0.080710806,
-0.0298515074,
-0.019916866,
0.0009305993,
-0.0114804972,
0.0189291164,
0.0277042519,
-0.0722086132,
0.0155435465,
-0.0789128691,
0.011244894,
-0.0117482655,
0.0028023864,
0.0069598174,
-6.599910011e-33,
-0.0020468982,
-0.0446467623,
0.0278395079,
-0.0338053554,
-0.0065876376,
0.0030457883,
-0.0410297364,
0.0177681521,
-0.0081494199,
0.0099885091,
-0.0140589327,
-0.0381498896,
0.0117721027,
0.0485417619,
0.0072946572,
0.0282888561,
0.031216085,
0.0159755331,
-0.0207821596,
0.0550808646,
0.0860836431,
0.0155566577,
0.0697637796,
-0.0589549057,
-0.0075479359,
0.0121765742,
-0.0377638973,
-0.0055692419,
0.0231530275,
0.0168607384,
-0.025219515,
0.0579465292,
0.0112351896,
-0.0278228801,
-0.0267022792,
-0.0643902868,
-0.0252529103,
-0.022027595,
-0.0172747374,
0.0108497338,
0.0571875386,
-0.035667263,
0.0474681593,
-0.0163747054,
-0.0191669948,
0.0337117463,
0.0430366099,
0.0167164579,
-0.063372232,
-0.0076468298,
-0.0509462319,
0.0319323726,
-0.00661672,
0.0242156256,
-0.0013334486,
0.0296429023,
0.0235576648,
-0.0172860604,
-0.0148303565,
0.0407522097,
0.0544178113,
0.0734413266,
0.0659675226,
0.0253265034,
0.00833032,
0.0851948485,
0.0269322246,
0.0536557063,
0.0273356549,
-0.0268422905,
0.0584372543,
-0.0212679841,
-0.0280800778,
0.0640511885,
0.0060388786,
-0.0743407309,
-0.027797509,
0.0232570246,
-0.0237664599,
-0.0214447752,
-0.0037175703,
-0.048778113,
-0.0107141761,
-0.0626281947,
-0.0367462933,
-0.0928932428,
0.003660213,
-0.0117653906,
0.0215825327,
0.0094334604,
-0.009383549,
-0.0113066537,
0.0377535224,
-0.0226124283,
-0.0494891964,
0.0231911913,
-0.0340783931,
-0.0225819778,
-0.003845267,
-0.0064012567,
-0.0258827414,
-0.048557952,
-0.0458024442,
0.0168261249,
-0.0087509444,
0.0201968569,
0.0034823213,
0.0136855785,
-0.0643811598,
0.0371303745,
-0.0543647334,
0.0328873061,
0.0281627327,
-0.0020913663,
0.0195384789,
-0.0257459767,
0.0087905303,
-0.0387861244,
0.0710059255,
0.0184289441,
0.0067678015,
0.0000406108,
-0.0072943536,
0.0573250167,
-0.0275255367,
-0.0076941294,
-0.0194568466,
0.0617512167,
0.0641933754,
-0.015720753,
-0.0083031924,
-0.0355940387,
2.69e-7,
0.0232256092,
0.0800568163,
-0.0131518105,
0.0002009173,
0.0231683701,
0.0174427554,
0.0130272638,
0.0127043631,
-0.0061404207,
0.0262276176,
-0.0129349642,
-0.0165210757,
0.0416982584,
0.0528222919,
-0.1265126318,
0.0550887398,
-0.0605503358,
0.0258410834,
-0.0493549071,
0.0076025962,
-0.0173021965,
0.0505283661,
0.028035773,
-0.0406881049,
-0.000466254,
-0.0422245674,
0.0486722961,
-0.0388653949,
-0.0301174279,
0.0378367789,
0.0274751447,
-0.0061899074,
0.0217688326,
-0.0245692264,
-0.0483147725,
-0.0052893288,
-0.0478052646,
0.0420816354,
0.0241791215,
0.011336945,
-0.0028873864,
0.0000202247,
-0.0025864108,
-0.092947945,
0.0415668674,
0.0100684064,
0.0005067387,
-0.0442844294,
-0.0161276739,
-0.006004578,
0.0069572777,
-0.0362834036,
0.0026607192,
0.0085117929,
-0.0138369761,
0.0270218309,
-0.0213062987,
-0.0464517847,
-0.0393405557,
0.0094176373,
-0.0372408405,
-0.0631300434,
0.0096906563,
0.0223455075,
-0.0000058387,
-0.0368962921,
0.0343869254,
2.618879043e-34,
-0.0172153004,
-0.0160216726,
0.0123583982,
-0.0128140841,
0.0464960709,
0.0044519086,
0.0340825133,
0.0243267007,
-0.0118239922,
0.0111623397,
0.0054979771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14771v1 | Evaluating the Knowledge Base Completion Potential of GPT | 2023-10-23T10:15:13 | 2023-10-23T10:15:13 | Blerta Veseli, Simon Razniewski, Jan-Christoph Kalo, Gerhard Weikum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Structured knowledge bases (KBs) are an asset for search engines and other
applications, but are inevitably incomplete. Language models (LMs) have been
proposed for unsupervised knowledge base completion (KBC), yet, their ability
to do this at scale and with high accuracy remains an open question. Prior
experimental studies mostly fall short because they only evaluate on popular
subjects, or sample already existing facts from KBs. In this work, we perform a
careful evaluation of GPT's potential to complete the largest public KB:
Wikidata. We find that, despite their size and capabilities, models like GPT-3,
ChatGPT and GPT-4 do not achieve fully convincing results on this task.
Nonetheless, they provide solid improvements over earlier approaches with
smaller LMs. In particular, we show that, with proper thresholding, GPT-3
enables to extend Wikidata by 27M facts at 90% precision. | [
0.0472280458,
0.0366778113,
-0.0054150522,
0.0422190018,
-0.0372592807,
-0.0012169372,
-0.0509730913,
0.0431319661,
0.0776776224,
-0.024634758,
0.0310712811,
-0.0097554866,
-0.0068156365,
0.0164908767,
-0.0025431453,
-0.0457220823,
0.0282629915,
-0.012336174,
-0.0028592774,
-0.0478173271,
-0.0347334445,
0.0198753756,
-0.0054504983,
-0.0202925373,
0.0016682531,
-0.0051827691,
-0.0108311865,
-0.0216078479,
-0.0157298949,
0.0181926452,
0.0081121856,
0.051310759,
0.0012005164,
0.0226917304,
0.0000019942,
-0.0217201412,
-0.0039217602,
0.0084637953,
-0.0193297192,
0.0551219024,
-0.0251928978,
-0.0151039483,
-0.0076600402,
-0.0139413513,
-0.0392303355,
-0.0207175855,
0.0131718889,
0.0502247699,
0.0154933445,
0.0342534818,
0.015936004,
-0.029204607,
0.0882152319,
-0.0304360185,
0.0384524874,
-0.0386898667,
0.0477924831,
-0.0063343798,
0.0051648072,
0.026276255,
-0.0148118949,
0.0372552536,
-0.0325253271,
0.0345531851,
0.0019445731,
0.0482976548,
-0.0531645603,
0.01819616,
0.0446592085,
0.0406658985,
0.0266051274,
-0.0000126763,
0.0325187929,
-0.0022140164,
-0.0179264788,
0.0276629031,
-0.0328637697,
-0.0086920373,
-0.0421678573,
0.0211204309,
-0.026677927,
-0.0422964729,
0.0502354093,
-0.0033260318,
-0.0054102107,
0.1356690675,
0.0169470925,
-0.0241550822,
-0.0268061198,
0.0138639687,
-0.0204246975,
-0.042202089,
-0.0084658507,
-0.0302436743,
0.0205139332,
0.0369926132,
-0.0255241282,
0.041816216,
0.0256381296,
-0.0030022948,
-0.0657177344,
0.0184882786,
-0.0118016833,
0.0751603842,
-0.0126521373,
0.0111958561,
-0.0509337038,
-0.0281503648,
-0.0197415035,
-0.0123071522,
-0.0849053562,
-0.0051863175,
-0.0137748942,
0.0388052389,
-0.0067383195,
-0.0073113851,
-0.016946163,
0.0024724314,
0.0078855157,
0.0280296784,
0.0368114114,
-0.0299884845,
-0.0443048775,
-0.0237168092,
-0.0546731427,
0.0384022221,
-0.0309340823,
0.0155241257,
-0.0318119116,
0.0079682702,
0.0098590702,
-0.0217297841,
0.0329246819,
-0.0283231288,
0.0259602685,
0.0254050083,
0.0276879929,
-0.0314250402,
-0.0718311071,
-0.0306932647,
-0.0183795318,
-0.0409530401,
-0.0247191601,
-0.071623899,
0.0559552722,
0.0213829018,
0.0035654192,
-0.0295192599,
0.000557246,
0.0230281781,
-0.0878906026,
0.0832430422,
-0.0673190206,
0.0058223391,
0.0122092133,
-0.00813423,
-0.0237505268,
0.0619234331,
-0.0014556457,
0.0273733828,
0.0703304484,
0.0028833898,
-0.0361940227,
0.0134373903,
0.0568016917,
0.0460885875,
0.0597053394,
0.018639721,
-0.0025439053,
0.0078222333,
0.0022840367,
0.0289881527,
-0.0275123827,
0.0066809841,
0.0413787551,
0.0304684844,
0.0015886091,
0.047684554,
0.0125601748,
0.0335511528,
0.0237240233,
0.040468622,
-0.0497684069,
-0.0312307421,
-0.0748765022,
0.0389869437,
0.0509031154,
0.0340923332,
-0.0214165784,
0.0025212958,
-0.0015544043,
-0.0201525092,
-0.008442102,
-0.0090338802,
0.0935869515,
0.0122069344,
-0.0162739828,
0.0948134884,
0.0602718294,
-0.0385081768,
0.0538015068,
-0.0065126112,
0.01412002,
0.0759492591,
0.0666226,
-0.0753550008,
-0.0226743594,
0.0167044438,
-0.0162243601,
0.0179226883,
-0.0008203174,
-0.0174426455,
-0.0167474225,
-0.0251360349,
-0.0412105396,
0.0196176544,
0.0311163627,
0.009766086,
0.0530432984,
0.0412035882,
0.0352559201,
-0.1045756787,
0.0354976319,
-0.0076434282,
-0.0140449395,
0.0032140578,
-0.0173417479,
-0.0137427645,
0.0126598217,
0.0385056362,
0.0056379605,
-0.0250859447,
0.0203485414,
-0.0205792859,
-0.0501938984,
-0.0510930084,
0.0442344882,
-0.0305896364,
0.0540788434,
-0.0223904159,
0.022621192,
0.0239837077,
-0.030893065,
-0.0553108416,
-0.0051557496,
-0.0285829939,
0.0836211592,
-0.033799205,
-0.0045943819,
0.0066189072,
-0.0307369474,
-0.0008326977,
0.1008285955,
-0.0198014807,
-0.001687438,
0.0232776236,
-0.0602518283,
0.0175181329,
-0.016326664,
-0.0571221113,
0.0068338234,
0.0178436022,
0.0182406437,
0.0537999235,
-0.0345614366,
-0.0661446229,
-0.0248495005,
-0.1009606346,
0.0193536505,
-0.000409577,
0.0337315202,
-0.0057926388,
0.0253253635,
0.0025421777,
0.0031318022,
-0.0279905051,
-0.0090519041,
-0.0410674699,
0.0327293687,
0.0186751448,
0.048200652,
-0.0018373856,
-0.0554720163,
-0.0535372794,
-0.0001341327,
-0.0089350939,
-0.0186125841,
0.0006414336,
-0.0244133212,
0.0402775221,
-0.0541888289,
0.0161569621,
-0.0196866784,
0.0023033388,
-0.0061427276,
-0.0481008217,
0.0289168246,
-0.0173543375,
-0.0271662995,
-0.0340524279,
0.0263915062,
-0.0157744549,
-0.0353448689,
0.0221324135,
-0.0398652367,
-0.0103246542,
-0.0276080277,
0.0071100583,
-0.007274393,
0.0228606872,
0.0047756373,
-0.0272505358,
-0.0962269008,
0.0072341789,
-0.003107999,
0.0591533668,
-0.0684287027,
0.0256770253,
0.0046354211,
0.0366685987,
-0.003485702,
-0.0282767676,
0.0521599837,
-0.0282032881,
0.0291062165,
-0.0132487295,
0.036946144,
0.0001379276,
0.0752285719,
0.0455405489,
0.003652452,
-0.0149482908,
-0.0144525571,
-0.013390542,
0.0190631077,
0.0481118821,
-0.0315823816,
0.0348702744,
-0.0060497131,
0.0455469713,
0.024241291,
0.0010786344,
-0.014575243,
-0.0070910589,
-0.0155312959,
-0.0321893394,
0.036670588,
-0.0338459909,
0.0250314921,
-0.0119239297,
0.0372322649,
0.0345800705,
0.0393477678,
-0.0026880337,
-0.0430984423,
0.0242403075,
0.0630238131,
-0.048004739,
0.0031421646,
0.0371711329,
-0.025030503,
0.049168691,
0.0780747682,
-0.0099603012,
0.0351404771,
-0.0190082919,
0.0264185201,
-0.0605607666,
-0.0976567045,
-0.0118110143,
-0.0149207376,
-0.0124806287,
0.031769149,
0.0990283862,
0.0103599895,
-0.0443072654,
-0.0101674758,
0.0120468345,
-0.008509702,
0.0017020213,
-0.0063119326,
-0.0662697107,
0.0103335036,
0.0049277623,
0.0236013383,
0.0292226281,
-0.0549183749,
0.0053613656,
-0.0893642828,
0.0150436498,
0.0151127325,
0.00604939,
-0.0236263983,
-0.0541631728,
0.010821024,
-0.0318779126,
-0.0383499898,
0.0184778702,
0.0030031186,
0.0271649603,
-0.0494350456,
-0.0475802235,
-0.0863024965,
0.0607833229,
-0.0424839333,
0.0456200987,
0.0363458917,
0.0255156085,
-0.0408947617,
-0.0329751708,
-0.0401786938,
-0.0049639884,
-0.0300984588,
0.01186861,
0.0575059019,
0.0054455819,
-0.0124212205,
-0.0231536496,
0.002820546,
-0.0456578024,
0.0017981738,
0.0319043919,
0.1235821918,
0.0414369702,
-0.007652103,
0.0053972085,
-0.0590856783,
-0.0063863741,
0.0632788911,
-0.0114370752,
0.0010800873,
0.024655005,
-0.0147389593,
0.0058798078,
0.0127868662,
-0.0219072364,
0.017905226,
-0.0262736417,
0.0059948508,
-0.0765297189,
-0.0460466594,
0.0353932306,
-0.007926465,
-0.0197544303,
0.06372343,
0.0164413583,
-0.0051692631,
-0.0315751769,
0.035029728,
-0.0484647714,
-0.0094336756,
-0.0542031415,
-0.033739768,
0.0235702228,
-0.0354817323,
-0.0057901577,
-0.0109753041,
-0.0383526646,
-0.0597373322,
-0.0216385592,
0.0189928114,
0.0198232085,
0.0377836116,
-0.0467029512,
-0.0260350443,
0.0522768348,
0.029886838,
-0.0532388054,
0.0161229428,
-0.0081069041,
-0.0314734802,
0.0107329823,
0.0602925904,
-0.0596480295,
-0.0177880023,
-0.0520370416,
0.048472032,
-0.0324686281,
-0.0019851502,
0.0254682023,
0.0515473448,
0.0372084342,
-0.0065321163,
0.019793313,
-0.035792578,
0.0145331202,
-0.0226122774,
0.0125182169,
-0.0323455893,
-0.008688719,
0.0330832042,
-0.0213273074,
-0.0111221028,
0.0070134085,
-0.0374839008,
0.0277269408,
-0.0466001779,
-0.0593606941,
0.012093734,
-0.0061305128,
0.0749035254,
-0.050858777,
-0.0206050575,
-0.0339456387,
-0.0084443903,
0.0236772392,
-0.045271486,
0.0028759013,
-0.0032772252,
-0.0404787548,
0.0002075658,
0.0138400625,
-0.0386928059,
-0.0320030078,
-0.0346783847,
0.0513228029,
0.0547792502,
0.0086604217,
0.0665108636,
-0.0541205704,
-0.0481268987,
-0.0203998145,
-0.0282863081,
0.03330791,
0.0120936148,
0.0092870472,
0.0463295951,
-0.0336113535,
0.054818321,
0.0979714021,
0.0197064541,
0.0701556727,
0.0001486207,
-0.0319561698,
-0.0204291325,
-0.0359283388,
-0.0382665023,
0.0601425543,
-0.0377476327,
0.0197566673,
-0.032008823,
-0.0720335841,
0.0152049009,
-0.0191046707,
-0.0494201779,
-0.0104710832,
0.0186507478,
0.0562171899,
0.0145175336,
-0.0304230917,
-0.0343215317,
-0.0003636316,
-0.0029471288,
-0.0097669028,
0.0400285758,
-6.376689511e-33,
-0.0274878945,
-0.0030858056,
0.0139385341,
0.0435746312,
0.0002535056,
-0.007403302,
0.0233172029,
-0.0086938823,
-0.0171600357,
0.0224672612,
-0.0271375012,
0.0250310078,
0.0014238902,
0.0180943515,
0.0276397057,
0.0079703173,
0.030650191,
0.0275922585,
-0.003872466,
0.0474704355,
0.0428065397,
0.0025177132,
0.0525159687,
-0.0831636786,
0.0484216139,
-0.027729176,
-0.0047738021,
-0.0070154704,
-0.0005654555,
0.0590116158,
-0.0289714243,
0.0811061263,
0.0171972346,
-0.0240741819,
0.0124041308,
-0.0658992305,
-0.0758911669,
-0.010383334,
0.0278382283,
-0.0044842777,
0.0047145723,
-0.0024864699,
0.0055801417,
-0.0170071404,
0.0624852665,
-0.027650794,
0.0209440943,
-0.0374456905,
-0.0370102599,
0.000325081,
-0.0037000477,
0.0403577983,
0.0581370518,
0.0329660401,
0.0027024259,
-0.0258741118,
0.0162143484,
-0.0050278585,
-0.0703708753,
0.0223773587,
0.0626940355,
0.0404876992,
0.0166706219,
-0.054464329,
0.0189150497,
0.0110249529,
-0.0119822184,
-0.0137835732,
-0.015858883,
-0.0179072786,
-0.0281092208,
0.0448888242,
-0.0044517242,
0.0504575223,
-0.0025898935,
-0.0141788507,
-0.0219640303,
0.0135113085,
-0.0001184394,
0.0171114374,
-0.0120651806,
-0.0005673234,
-0.0616221279,
-0.0336971395,
-0.0327899642,
0.006939128,
-0.023051396,
-0.0548672341,
-0.0018025982,
0.0000228613,
-0.0303833354,
-0.0247096866,
-0.0454788655,
-0.0266741235,
-0.0088451095,
0.0463762619,
-0.0150173521,
0.0089911046,
0.0003952433,
0.0279437602,
-0.0452958159,
-0.020938443,
-0.0079253111,
-0.0432569459,
-0.0477995723,
0.0201091152,
-0.0222937167,
0.0473851711,
-0.021020487,
0.004953478,
-0.0032647117,
-0.0193639137,
0.0032201244,
-0.0356783047,
0.0496760868,
0.0140259815,
0.0208362769,
0.0139683019,
0.0843927562,
0.0179738961,
-0.0201826356,
-0.0327743441,
0.0063142548,
-0.0148823876,
0.0200840849,
0.0029421938,
-0.0195780471,
-0.019777298,
0.0106649641,
-0.0009424498,
0.0004584775,
-0.0053087408,
2.784e-7,
0.0052610803,
0.0163960736,
0.0112438146,
0.0200153254,
0.0051643783,
0.0060491413,
0.0155611411,
0.0474751145,
-0.0072159991,
-0.0638048127,
0.0152976746,
-0.0243021213,
0.0014823215,
0.0435026325,
-0.0930220857,
-0.0057752631,
0.0100225313,
-0.0450044274,
-0.0552289635,
-0.0312202238,
0.0070482497,
0.0552351661,
0.0685153157,
0.0057828547,
0.0235109013,
-0.0379775353,
0.0846179575,
-0.0413262099,
-0.0356704965,
0.0287865028,
0.0595037416,
0.0593178123,
-0.0119008087,
0.0434895419,
-0.0080017513,
0.0236698687,
0.0387345999,
0.042816028,
0.0204773806,
0.0286725182,
-0.0242059268,
-0.0795999765,
-0.0006085457,
-0.0188375022,
0.10718593,
-0.0208668429,
0.0363012254,
0.0744403601,
-0.0405883789,
-0.0436597951,
-0.0123465303,
-0.0250692163,
-0.0095466841,
-0.0014177106,
-0.0154517181,
0.0332095362,
0.0072020958,
-0.0394144505,
0.0290397722,
0.0212688446,
-0.0445836633,
-0.0553800166,
-0.0121788783,
-0.0627989173,
-0.0186929684,
-0.0644811243,
0.0302833375,
2.262654434e-34,
0.0406277105,
-0.0100412751,
0.0204372704,
-0.0392868556,
0.0093677128,
-0.0235371888,
-0.0168550629,
-0.0074575865,
0.0068928027,
-0.0852070227,
-0.0113255745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14757v1 | SuperTweetEval: A Challenging, Unified and Heterogeneous Benchmark for Social Media NLP Research | 2023-10-23T09:48:25 | 2023-10-23T09:48:25 | Dimosthenis Antypas, Asahi Ushio, Francesco Barbieri, Leonardo Neves, Kiamehr Rezaee, Luis Espinosa-Anke, Jiaxin Pei, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite its relevance, the maturity of NLP for social media pales in
comparison with general-purpose models, metrics and benchmarks. This fragmented
landscape makes it hard for the community to know, for instance, given a task,
which is the best performing model and how it compares with others. To
alleviate this issue, we introduce a unified benchmark for NLP evaluation in
social media, SuperTweetEval, which includes a heterogeneous set of tasks and
datasets combined, adapted and constructed from scratch. We benchmarked the
performance of a wide range of models on SuperTweetEval and our results suggest
that, despite the recent advances in language modelling, social media remains
challenging. | [
0.0587621816,
0.0513996407,
0.0059158993,
0.0131150745,
-0.0223649368,
0.0152760185,
-0.0290695298,
0.0232631732,
-0.0042627449,
-0.0520550609,
-0.0018191572,
-0.0315689258,
-0.0173605885,
0.0414924547,
0.0209771078,
-0.0204400122,
0.0159670729,
0.013130323,
0.0369866081,
0.0053906655,
0.0593882315,
0.0154763404,
-0.0073341257,
0.0341688655,
-0.0604469329,
0.0107600354,
0.0459671356,
0.0141575206,
-0.0115444362,
-0.0267309807,
0.0431221128,
0.0546814203,
0.0009044398,
0.0653631166,
0.0000016275,
-0.014663931,
0.0024812033,
-0.0140665183,
-0.0062617268,
0.0029761163,
0.0771596804,
-0.0534035191,
0.0187158659,
0.0042138579,
-0.0599184297,
0.0181080997,
0.0268508662,
0.0235853978,
0.0419706777,
0.077598244,
-0.0284189973,
-0.0185212344,
0.0277762152,
-0.0327723026,
-0.044760745,
-0.0602307692,
-0.0130624054,
-0.0167860854,
0.0199251082,
-0.0004714615,
0.0299466848,
0.0670087561,
0.0028030325,
0.0011802432,
0.0161003284,
-0.0197700653,
-0.0339190774,
-0.0052182302,
-0.0260054301,
0.092905052,
-0.0121331504,
-0.0281557422,
0.012903654,
-0.0080318069,
-0.0433665588,
-0.0009429654,
-0.0519884601,
-0.0082756309,
0.0387649015,
0.0353084132,
-0.0042812694,
0.0496920012,
0.042396754,
0.0532178506,
0.0522397235,
0.0465639904,
-0.0047400431,
-0.0128207449,
0.0252909344,
0.0389677472,
-0.0614748485,
-0.015625909,
0.041012764,
0.0054237177,
-0.0358811095,
0.0125407353,
-0.0171642359,
-0.0303563513,
0.0338424183,
-0.0541537516,
0.0225423966,
-0.0108705834,
0.0233795382,
0.0720042065,
0.0189052131,
0.0175923929,
-0.0277043227,
-0.0176566932,
0.029657105,
-0.0272684358,
-0.0758855343,
0.0031987485,
-0.0185655039,
0.0043739327,
-0.0438786969,
-0.0381212756,
-0.0200612545,
-0.0065260781,
-0.0116534298,
-0.0162330624,
0.0242259428,
0.0350213051,
-0.0133339651,
-0.0102021638,
-0.0024389483,
0.0205192491,
-0.0546939187,
0.0134776495,
-0.0035379101,
-0.0431939252,
0.0251752976,
0.020658711,
0.0343739167,
-0.0283907633,
-0.0217267312,
0.0519340858,
0.0307735112,
-0.0383285582,
-0.0311678723,
-0.0155621488,
-0.0213079527,
-0.0663719252,
-0.0151019162,
-0.0871167481,
0.0778774023,
0.0385534652,
-0.0018381694,
-0.0304587148,
0.0015135809,
0.0209443439,
-0.0212525763,
0.0546518378,
-0.0125146778,
0.0232827906,
-0.0034214086,
0.0202041082,
0.0198609103,
0.0901335627,
0.0222336482,
0.0441300161,
0.0747025087,
0.0115883164,
0.0275492035,
0.0359488241,
0.020356752,
0.0098116025,
-0.0218687188,
0.0112868007,
-0.0451255739,
0.0232801698,
-0.0282649137,
0.0740963444,
0.0033944233,
-0.0003031062,
0.0726664662,
0.0343564376,
-0.0209931023,
-0.0025199431,
0.0374964587,
0.0473750159,
-0.0028714777,
-0.0317716077,
-0.0215460304,
0.0191408265,
-0.0245967004,
-0.0250435844,
0.0148801999,
0.0021156608,
-0.0368245542,
-0.0046240333,
-0.035454005,
-0.0108178686,
0.029774636,
-0.0067672576,
0.0071297758,
-0.0098508894,
-0.023309391,
0.0631329715,
0.0248756427,
-0.0631010011,
0.0160604436,
-0.0156897698,
-0.0174059868,
0.0164904986,
0.0318530053,
-0.0217324365,
0.0193586051,
-0.0197991505,
0.049768392,
0.0657423288,
0.0281060264,
0.0038090958,
0.0299795922,
-0.0077622193,
0.0027242447,
-0.0051817656,
0.0281375181,
-0.0410876982,
0.0657251552,
0.0101344697,
-0.0016137335,
-0.0388826281,
-0.0403041132,
0.0116824489,
-0.0096005583,
0.0047588353,
-0.0272788741,
-0.0139142182,
-0.0133692659,
0.0591340587,
-0.0077694585,
-0.0116553903,
0.0155297061,
-0.0304650366,
-0.0428972803,
-0.0273951497,
-0.0231175609,
-0.0359435752,
0.03905873,
-0.0223928597,
-0.0266270544,
0.0756196678,
-0.0475945584,
-0.0161142368,
0.0724392086,
-0.0381585993,
0.042007599,
-0.0085607246,
-0.0049983724,
-0.0300027411,
0.0286468808,
-0.0106003424,
0.0508614331,
-0.0066510863,
0.0069662766,
0.0027386909,
-0.0240676906,
0.0064257714,
0.0051310565,
-0.0352562703,
0.0319632813,
-0.013834727,
0.0426440351,
0.0340916105,
-0.0041494453,
-0.0854283422,
-0.0562565848,
-0.0753405988,
0.0117556825,
-0.0519987494,
0.0119993491,
0.0258767679,
0.0164031591,
0.0050539803,
0.0012079254,
-0.0292367898,
0.0015125264,
0.0140217207,
0.0269087981,
0.0276038516,
0.0021701076,
0.0492893308,
-0.0776770487,
-0.042976588,
0.0242933109,
0.0306930318,
-0.0201966539,
-0.0629079491,
0.0606394112,
-0.0056949169,
-0.0232847203,
-0.0021315776,
-0.0153586678,
-0.0206055623,
-0.0049923034,
-0.0057379305,
0.0345210694,
0.0023575982,
0.0229319464,
0.0397974737,
-0.0368092321,
-0.0052213687,
-0.0654831454,
0.0006581007,
-0.0447501838,
-0.0323230699,
-0.0231683999,
0.0150174638,
-0.0028903838,
0.0646657944,
-0.0185189676,
0.0329311118,
-0.0467415527,
0.0266477913,
-0.0641524345,
-0.0080348961,
-0.0212140493,
-0.000650732,
-0.0359327048,
0.0168535374,
-0.0628067106,
-0.0159627572,
0.0339383483,
-0.0133644538,
-0.0040224115,
-0.0058277352,
-0.0461709015,
-0.0356981196,
0.0596838556,
0.0039845677,
0.0011418546,
-0.0140265524,
-0.0138634853,
0.0333484225,
-0.0282310918,
0.0028680698,
-0.0625046492,
0.0277356245,
0.0346895717,
0.0478551127,
0.0158069544,
-0.0305672102,
0.0193976108,
-0.0777299032,
-0.0628827363,
0.0085263513,
-0.0093626743,
-0.0463585369,
-0.0169812497,
0.0026350056,
-0.0143149281,
-0.0371959545,
-0.0228795968,
-0.0180974957,
-0.0006298657,
0.0642306358,
0.073126398,
-0.0178180207,
0.0062458981,
0.0198189914,
0.0166044235,
0.0367832892,
0.0683384389,
0.0132188648,
-0.0383881032,
0.0025942675,
0.0056704455,
-0.020114731,
0.0188591648,
-0.042793408,
0.1120745167,
-0.0058253021,
0.0332003795,
0.1078076363,
0.0336680114,
-0.0050980314,
0.0071459287,
0.0676569045,
0.013696352,
0.0035446777,
-0.0102370204,
-0.0718061253,
-0.0523024127,
-0.0210115761,
0.0358740054,
0.0340064354,
-0.0345253758,
-0.002770029,
-0.0740971491,
-0.0374509208,
-0.0272246487,
0.0038027428,
-0.0002885231,
-0.016502019,
-0.0083770314,
-0.0770886391,
0.0219550524,
-0.0428838655,
-0.0094318744,
0.0175744109,
0.0230787415,
-0.0438538007,
-0.0614232346,
0.0655914098,
-0.0621603802,
0.0512159504,
0.0162525512,
0.0200889781,
0.0200903229,
-0.008384929,
0.0317487642,
-0.0004772996,
0.0043657394,
-0.0323387459,
0.057631366,
-0.008771251,
-0.0194193497,
-0.0215618163,
-0.021892814,
-0.0604267828,
0.011030593,
-0.0615788326,
0.0296772495,
0.0602831915,
-0.03873704,
-0.0243370105,
0.0125823542,
0.0253970567,
0.0588411577,
0.0431820452,
-0.0080881007,
-0.0181319639,
-0.011874482,
0.0137971388,
-0.0706310645,
-0.0664032251,
-0.0212943237,
0.0505086184,
-0.0310626067,
-0.044280488,
-0.0467183962,
0.031793341,
0.0219268184,
-0.0217032507,
0.0107497945,
-0.0019782882,
-0.0459726043,
-0.0497426577,
0.0454973616,
-0.0147397164,
0.0441030748,
-0.0266122203,
-0.0253925528,
0.0404330939,
0.0397826061,
0.0129647832,
0.0255941711,
-0.1204270199,
-0.0839073583,
-0.0021641867,
0.0046945359,
0.0239429995,
-0.0129357791,
-0.0578792579,
-0.1191629693,
0.0034354739,
0.0647177547,
-0.0516621135,
0.0092456155,
0.0109519549,
0.0174139533,
0.010708739,
0.0643309802,
-0.0267352108,
0.0016220731,
0.0023120132,
0.0404511727,
-0.0137636578,
0.0280084368,
-0.0048667849,
0.0023133445,
0.0489225574,
-0.0040277978,
-0.0522685386,
-0.0112022171,
-0.0974827632,
-0.0068032946,
-0.0202706419,
-0.0581227615,
0.0172286909,
0.0278291255,
0.0434529074,
-0.0690053105,
0.0247938707,
-0.0063796714,
0.049950324,
-0.0503656939,
0.0394713432,
0.0140363732,
-0.0224371292,
-0.0160045791,
0.0247079916,
-0.0181462839,
0.0075655798,
0.0105824582,
0.0085952505,
-0.0177959502,
-0.0136507042,
-0.0203403644,
0.0026928356,
0.0234303325,
0.0403494388,
-0.0221706759,
-0.0333729088,
-0.0161410701,
0.0017812353,
0.0691639259,
-0.0332358591,
0.0760248229,
0.0244826917,
-0.0082779787,
-0.0101662409,
0.0107548004,
-0.0060475077,
-0.0172328576,
0.0160918962,
0.0064199935,
-0.0299479533,
0.0395748727,
0.0638017133,
0.0036305848,
0.0140247485,
0.066095449,
-0.0015871996,
-0.0162527487,
0.0081203654,
-0.0223212782,
0.0440041013,
0.0041282028,
0.0487173647,
-0.0353122912,
-0.073221989,
0.0022898335,
-0.0430650078,
0.007849114,
0.0299589336,
0.0284226406,
0.0636320934,
0.0246814955,
0.0388128459,
-0.0591691397,
-0.0360077284,
0.0291393586,
-0.0311851054,
-0.0177837238,
-6.833075928e-33,
0.0305871852,
-0.0242112558,
-0.018408861,
-0.0099183181,
-0.0269538071,
0.0227238014,
-0.0324166268,
0.0302268155,
-0.0459853448,
0.0016208165,
-0.0223934706,
0.0304424632,
0.0076035825,
0.0160763804,
0.0025296763,
-0.0258309394,
0.015663391,
-0.0178374331,
-0.0230303612,
0.0244884435,
0.0090352492,
0.0182489417,
0.0622018911,
-0.0950315669,
0.0116239721,
0.0028700582,
-0.0179702956,
0.0185888484,
0.0914415121,
0.0462202616,
-0.0364861526,
0.0848920345,
0.049884133,
-0.034114711,
0.0015307798,
0.0166547373,
-0.0241651405,
-0.0294227116,
0.0174843874,
-0.0127125587,
-0.0456787497,
0.0290966295,
0.0216450226,
-0.0028175563,
-0.0524782985,
-0.0045827073,
0.0112722022,
0.0316797271,
0.0221941248,
-0.0089164106,
-0.0633433238,
0.0690649673,
-0.0061046388,
-0.0165838208,
0.0312626809,
-0.004501286,
0.0083370013,
0.0433209129,
-0.0451273769,
0.0154195502,
-0.0306836702,
0.0256141033,
0.0508447811,
-0.0278545562,
-0.0353364497,
0.0591710396,
0.0032372519,
0.0388137512,
0.0046168673,
0.003623524,
-0.0071979086,
0.0552610047,
0.0645361915,
0.0715015084,
0.0132405218,
-0.0240274649,
-0.0169401225,
-0.0046102605,
0.0808693245,
-0.0062951744,
-0.0103167016,
-0.004708183,
-0.0258392915,
-0.0141835101,
-0.0371976756,
-0.0212147236,
-0.0577030443,
-0.0228043031,
0.0003493213,
0.0315460898,
-0.0052716937,
0.071807541,
0.0039622053,
-0.0526582003,
-0.0501300916,
0.0331934392,
0.0077548581,
0.0274893772,
0.0299854204,
0.0424597226,
-0.0408082269,
0.0074545983,
-0.0108642923,
0.0612764433,
-0.0037656548,
-0.0463852957,
0.0194372423,
0.0332420506,
-0.043329794,
0.0167441107,
-0.0293514226,
0.0265405234,
-0.0758487731,
-0.0318418965,
0.0168595463,
0.0113284057,
-0.0412880033,
0.0502955131,
0.0440015458,
0.0112221055,
-0.0004405328,
-0.0110975476,
0.0067916731,
-0.0065347697,
-0.0013228691,
-0.0066744685,
-0.0407368019,
-0.0098340558,
0.0058598672,
-0.0240119882,
-0.004155736,
-0.0233944431,
2.363e-7,
0.0560754985,
0.0636790469,
0.0077884546,
-0.0057627307,
0.0360237807,
0.0288726483,
-0.0081997924,
0.0204545856,
-0.0323646404,
-0.0265836269,
-0.0531607643,
0.0291878954,
0.074945733,
-0.0064499825,
-0.0394820981,
-0.0039119781,
-0.1092520654,
0.0073566511,
-0.052886419,
-0.0202744007,
0.0185601786,
0.0758404136,
0.0280100033,
-0.0238535646,
-0.0477512144,
-0.0738314763,
0.0629220977,
-0.0371263288,
-0.04540997,
0.0107141864,
0.0232177544,
0.0219442435,
0.0259472132,
-0.0507452749,
-0.0342299715,
0.0038134106,
0.0414078161,
0.0381506607,
0.0290882383,
-0.0560347214,
0.0173607655,
-0.0239123963,
-0.0055540111,
-0.0497422218,
0.0581615567,
-0.0305199604,
-0.0719952881,
-0.0345384926,
-0.0288725998,
0.0145229204,
0.0277335756,
-0.0194541961,
-0.0642674565,
0.0083474098,
0.011008882,
0.0168683957,
-0.060362462,
-0.0917571038,
-0.0095037008,
-0.0102399448,
-0.0058412538,
-0.006358074,
-0.0405227989,
0.0070445556,
0.0210341327,
-0.0299361162,
0.0205806959,
1.635354399e-34,
0.039491944,
-0.0023139061,
0.0382168368,
-0.0247448757,
0.0051352549,
0.0430742949,
-0.0223449692,
-0.0211869627,
-0.0022567918,
-0.0467443801,
0.038209144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14747v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14747v3 | MCC-KD: Multi-CoT Consistent Knowledge Distillation | 2023-10-23T09:32:53 | 2023-12-20T06:50:20 | Hongzhan Chen, Siyue Wu, Xiaojun Quan, Rui Wang, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable capabilities in
complex reasoning through chain of thought (CoT) prompting. Recently, there has
been a growing interest in transferring these reasoning abilities from LLMs to
smaller models. However, achieving both the diversity and consistency in
rationales presents a challenge. In this paper, we focus on enhancing these two
aspects and propose Multi-CoT Consistent Knowledge Distillation (MCC-KD) to
efficiently distill the reasoning capabilities. In MCC-KD, we generate multiple
rationales for each question and enforce consistency among the corresponding
predictions by minimizing the bidirectional KL-divergence between the answer
distributions. We investigate the effectiveness of MCC-KD with different model
architectures (LLaMA/FlanT5) and various model scales (3B/7B/11B/13B) on both
mathematical reasoning and commonsense reasoning benchmarks. The empirical
results not only confirm MCC-KD's superior performance on in-distribution
datasets but also highlight its robust generalization ability on
out-of-distribution datasets. | [
0.0174354985,
0.0660716966,
0.000853743,
0.031834919,
-0.0353816897,
0.0176407285,
-0.0023675035,
0.0002600224,
-0.029596068,
0.0026919059,
0.0070152888,
-0.0148565853,
-0.0090009943,
0.0214899108,
0.0089540491,
-0.050104674,
0.0057445467,
-0.0599893555,
0.026060218,
-0.0416654572,
-0.0082310801,
0.0074686669,
0.0035488838,
0.0038736735,
0.0246810336,
-0.0395889357,
-0.0206827708,
-0.0268790852,
0.0286881905,
0.0046593831,
-0.0120219579,
0.0500236526,
0.0273592938,
-0.0133489296,
0.0000025315,
-0.0517346933,
-0.0101509774,
0.0003016264,
-0.0582165718,
0.0094265379,
-0.0539705716,
0.0077160653,
0.0672010407,
0.008082632,
-0.029857669,
0.060403619,
0.0091441274,
0.0387916639,
0.0764008388,
0.02361333,
0.0169869661,
-0.0698546246,
0.0112236738,
-0.0142074479,
-0.011859999,
-0.0461509489,
0.0295893494,
0.063859798,
0.0113019021,
0.025656702,
-0.0307084657,
0.0250654444,
0.048970744,
0.0108724041,
-0.0127180181,
0.0325697623,
-0.0353296138,
-0.0240455419,
0.0141534647,
0.0983235985,
0.0082690008,
-0.0359212309,
-0.0012022391,
0.0023020788,
0.0135855023,
0.0245096646,
-0.0667242706,
0.0190651044,
-0.0036292383,
0.0164509453,
0.0291223899,
0.0003894925,
0.0257286988,
0.0092255035,
-0.0801465511,
0.0549698807,
-0.0026985621,
-0.034480121,
-0.0006196582,
-0.0079072444,
-0.0830242187,
-0.0643285513,
-0.0083872257,
0.0498835109,
-0.0292695202,
0.0026568372,
0.0131175248,
-0.0082817292,
0.0051124669,
-0.0271312669,
0.0091942828,
0.03693977,
-0.0077771717,
0.0498421639,
-0.0117141828,
0.0714000165,
-0.0057173148,
0.0570612401,
-0.0177849382,
-0.0219683181,
-0.0796206668,
-0.008532525,
0.0157286171,
0.0663318112,
-0.0579506122,
0.0004756466,
-0.0213043801,
-0.0132517703,
-0.0520637855,
0.0095875636,
0.0761098191,
0.0183275454,
0.0224581435,
-0.0357101001,
-0.0579545237,
0.071337156,
-0.0895821229,
0.0259089172,
0.0432300679,
-0.0291828029,
-0.0246462952,
-0.0148753142,
0.0072306381,
-0.0204805974,
0.0204734299,
0.0221531801,
-0.0305039082,
0.0112984246,
-0.0229319744,
-0.0355841517,
-0.0186131727,
-0.0969852433,
-0.0151123172,
-0.0815165192,
0.060268227,
0.0081104273,
-0.011230696,
-0.0244191699,
-0.0047380347,
0.0028900329,
-0.0179830082,
0.0631548092,
0.0257462617,
0.0096638221,
-0.0053485199,
0.0328992233,
-0.0373514444,
0.0692304522,
-0.0236170106,
0.0002735999,
0.0301418696,
-0.002860174,
-0.0149401128,
-0.0118054468,
0.0363000035,
0.0060997191,
0.0124910772,
0.0503939949,
-0.0449290499,
0.0098909885,
0.0167170353,
0.042242825,
-0.0407786593,
0.0003258609,
0.0509034358,
0.0275996551,
0.0274079721,
-0.0034325437,
0.0255562756,
-0.0062551033,
-0.0009249445,
0.0081575001,
-0.0607049726,
0.0273793209,
-0.023771964,
-0.0018822007,
0.0216899384,
0.0499718897,
-0.0399857759,
-0.0389547758,
0.0260099843,
0.0167593602,
-0.0128181316,
0.0248502698,
0.0532184355,
-0.0197363999,
0.0123851504,
0.0846196562,
0.035835918,
-0.0296908543,
-0.0103035625,
-0.0274558105,
0.0506924465,
0.0074298489,
0.01888372,
0.0044631991,
-0.0259870719,
-0.0071519967,
0.0019053193,
-0.009839898,
0.0236793216,
-0.0337076411,
0.0040593548,
-0.0529159121,
-0.0297534671,
-0.003926896,
0.020081101,
-0.016251605,
0.0210973937,
0.0182906501,
0.0020839439,
-0.0793167353,
0.051149819,
-0.0059122178,
-0.021898279,
-0.0116145248,
-0.0333466455,
0.0056432495,
0.0430070087,
0.0186276156,
0.0208796281,
0.0128629534,
0.0072244126,
-0.0242141075,
-0.035498932,
0.0090342462,
-0.0555227101,
-0.064160794,
0.0493609197,
-0.0067329728,
-0.0112153394,
0.0111265108,
-0.0547828451,
-0.0457815118,
0.0247428771,
0.037465483,
0.0066970177,
-0.0375617705,
0.0236649644,
-0.0030201012,
-0.0232614372,
-0.002776894,
0.1197293028,
-0.049721431,
-0.0207654778,
-0.0014188131,
-0.021179311,
0.0088966209,
-0.0000402324,
0.0166121963,
0.0253194738,
-0.0213256311,
0.0022572605,
-0.0090453476,
0.0257889889,
-0.0272808596,
0.0058529186,
-0.0392358601,
-0.0041626757,
-0.0302610826,
0.0022338785,
0.0098037496,
0.0112193022,
0.0412210338,
0.0118221212,
-0.0415703803,
-0.0091604432,
0.0050045447,
0.0216315687,
0.0198254138,
0.0152805895,
0.0079561668,
0.0275723822,
-0.0299813375,
-0.0010699995,
0.0672190338,
-0.0512543544,
0.0531863272,
-0.0095707644,
-0.0084087122,
-0.0735514164,
-0.0037659106,
-0.0226902328,
0.0223082509,
0.0130394194,
-0.0110724457,
0.0152780293,
0.0406425968,
-0.0148928557,
-0.0101240482,
0.0391484089,
-0.0043884837,
-0.0499078408,
0.0323294774,
-0.0195537377,
0.0165180732,
-0.0030466677,
-0.0348148718,
-0.0228360873,
0.0605938174,
-0.0098415464,
-0.018933408,
-0.0740691945,
0.0020488566,
0.0127754305,
-0.0216935966,
-0.0674037412,
0.0013417766,
0.0091969837,
0.0780987516,
-0.0155673428,
-0.0183114335,
0.0728785247,
-0.0054417262,
0.0190895665,
-0.0526936762,
0.0049688169,
-0.0202340707,
0.0645151958,
-0.0455413051,
-0.0122888014,
0.0017455916,
0.0295999311,
-0.0551243201,
-0.0574833378,
0.0239564162,
-0.0157430526,
0.1055846661,
-0.0678405762,
-0.0141813122,
0.0078541059,
-0.0720735788,
-0.0276196692,
-0.0171651132,
-0.0484137051,
0.0193874612,
-0.0049767219,
-0.0224006381,
-0.0054383962,
-0.0073219868,
0.023969369,
0.0071001649,
0.0035565465,
0.0032078079,
-0.0071489043,
0.0554805212,
0.0561404787,
0.0403277948,
0.0427055433,
-0.019454509,
0.0419950858,
0.0637944266,
0.0089104772,
-0.0372955911,
0.0164867081,
0.0259814467,
-0.0098896381,
0.0082370704,
-0.0234708413,
0.0095744617,
0.0702223107,
-0.0303295683,
-0.0087291058,
0.0969319269,
0.0168988779,
0.0197513364,
0.0011165919,
-0.0432766154,
0.0866911486,
0.0083620828,
0.0015280982,
-0.0797693431,
-0.0497403629,
0.0220091678,
0.0065075508,
0.0133805815,
-0.0544089973,
0.0141422562,
-0.0928349793,
0.0204996075,
-0.0053693717,
-0.0057386751,
-0.046739839,
-0.0567963235,
0.0066357735,
-0.0110278493,
-0.0152095929,
0.0512586758,
0.0277045295,
0.019762855,
0.0107811457,
-0.0084420806,
-0.032551609,
0.0599063113,
-0.014830119,
0.0033626237,
-0.000486505,
0.0371316783,
0.0067586089,
-0.0879631415,
-0.0205684882,
-0.052618213,
-0.0284672156,
-0.0155843562,
0.0004581363,
0.0247582123,
0.0036617515,
-0.0231380388,
0.0731657073,
-0.0431388803,
-0.0299050342,
0.0371508747,
0.1020964086,
-0.0077094864,
-0.0670081824,
-0.0145892436,
0.0006362447,
-0.0275902115,
0.0881451219,
0.029602848,
-0.0044573299,
-0.0444141626,
-0.0287343524,
-0.0641464069,
-0.0307884719,
0.014330009,
0.005073572,
0.0271887854,
0.0232211426,
-0.047703404,
-0.0102758324,
0.0020707876,
0.0570060946,
-0.0290807355,
-0.000393159,
0.0221643932,
0.0179938525,
0.0001072854,
0.0115812859,
-0.0459983051,
-0.0099891117,
0.0064330217,
0.0501465388,
-0.0108812759,
-0.0465252399,
-0.049087707,
0.0177633781,
-0.0874788091,
-0.0518004075,
-0.0312933214,
0.0351980068,
0.0310092494,
0.0497064553,
-0.0128998868,
-0.0079420069,
0.0697659403,
-0.0108513189,
-0.01498059,
0.0251344144,
0.0280536655,
-0.0090851784,
0.0185294338,
0.0614730865,
-0.0251463428,
0.0185164716,
0.0023747198,
0.0753788799,
-0.0302311704,
-0.0009358799,
0.0059246365,
0.0345058702,
-0.0097469212,
0.018309623,
-0.0066321427,
-0.0272600148,
0.0261863582,
-0.0121569708,
-0.0164263435,
-0.0351252332,
0.0373056047,
0.0260709636,
-0.0083523337,
0.0021249303,
-0.0361971743,
0.0391548462,
0.0022129726,
-0.0025971644,
-0.0204912256,
0.0350667238,
0.0339437537,
0.0510911681,
-0.0380437933,
-0.0017810484,
-0.0037668117,
-0.0320296362,
0.0520683937,
-0.011412655,
0.0737838447,
0.0516259931,
-0.0078772837,
-0.0274975523,
-0.0066812625,
-0.0728590861,
-0.0663736463,
0.0218958408,
0.0127639761,
0.0074810423,
0.026809413,
0.0172159299,
-0.0124113318,
-0.0239510164,
0.0025216979,
0.03888027,
0.0406718738,
0.0008405961,
0.0359136052,
0.0266080946,
-0.0073348237,
0.0022347507,
0.0648059025,
-0.0502622873,
0.0202559493,
-0.0039742379,
0.0155347073,
-0.0359733887,
-0.0502103306,
-0.0432245173,
0.0338804312,
0.0169989578,
0.0030781443,
-0.0767448246,
-0.0691209584,
0.0097412178,
-0.0029742406,
-0.015879225,
0.0026542083,
0.0179527123,
0.0766332448,
0.0032071802,
-0.050975617,
0.0038164831,
0.0074236002,
-0.0414916873,
-0.007155783,
0.0010895033,
-7.17314277e-33,
0.027909942,
0.0075635291,
0.0293694995,
-0.0464831144,
-0.0136035625,
-0.018488925,
-0.0302985068,
-0.0234890059,
-0.0649493709,
0.032180585,
-0.0276354738,
0.0188381039,
0.0026773247,
0.0325796604,
0.0117083611,
-0.0331035517,
0.0255610514,
0.0266070403,
-0.0185960438,
0.0264875181,
0.0457163975,
-0.0041820952,
0.028716851,
-0.0338763855,
0.023797607,
-0.0129230795,
-0.002087842,
0.0455250703,
-0.0598196723,
0.047587622,
-0.0095804781,
0.0351700149,
0.0211470053,
-0.0373602509,
-0.0088652503,
-0.0025066179,
-0.1011589915,
-0.0468260534,
0.067551963,
-0.0462569073,
-0.0594920069,
-0.0175228342,
0.0234638229,
0.0136420978,
0.0391886272,
-0.0451764762,
-0.0002615124,
-0.0164917689,
0.0056963353,
0.0082337828,
0.0132033546,
0.0081080766,
-0.0337694995,
-0.0154479211,
-0.0218766164,
0.055777844,
-0.0085159196,
0.0254099984,
-0.0601474047,
0.0139674293,
0.0438464545,
-0.0065809144,
0.0653089732,
0.0021192175,
-0.0138650062,
0.0459492207,
-0.0643460602,
-0.0499479882,
-0.0716061816,
-0.0061913496,
-0.0088135609,
0.0984414741,
0.0461184792,
0.0421604887,
0.0429984964,
0.0194320418,
-0.0963339731,
0.0108005982,
-0.030173406,
0.0520124994,
0.0261068568,
-0.0041829306,
-0.037448056,
-0.0284847058,
-0.0604939237,
-0.0163867883,
-0.0482129678,
-0.0041122269,
0.0290067047,
-0.0021972742,
-0.0396424867,
-0.0037527622,
0.0345857888,
-0.0448475853,
0.005378617,
0.0730723366,
-0.0037781184,
0.0008491285,
0.0179652944,
0.0297711082,
-0.035496477,
0.0195424259,
0.0027455273,
0.0227217749,
-0.0112798754,
0.0240580011,
0.040014185,
-0.02310252,
-0.0061918274,
-0.0233392604,
-0.0528164394,
0.0093576107,
-0.0172921568,
0.0286647826,
0.040195331,
0.0400251634,
0.0022786974,
0.0037480064,
0.0011773065,
-0.0030576107,
-0.0066709206,
0.0464917384,
0.0193614475,
0.0260026231,
0.0012943144,
-0.0051762634,
-0.0349389277,
-0.029194884,
0.0275718477,
-0.0456256568,
-0.014345428,
0.0457146727,
3.054e-7,
0.0152269974,
0.0106505975,
0.0012420004,
-0.0182584152,
0.0026054697,
0.043421004,
-0.0007484863,
-0.0262196194,
0.0134938387,
-0.096071668,
-0.0079955431,
0.0691893771,
0.0082987128,
0.0524898916,
-0.0464558043,
-0.0129402447,
-0.0681452304,
-0.0661813021,
-0.0167169552,
-0.0296762902,
0.0730386376,
0.0652473792,
0.0390310287,
-0.0357646272,
0.0272538699,
-0.0005451759,
0.0112343626,
-0.0035597049,
0.0220633093,
0.0177389383,
0.0030500749,
-0.0311415382,
0.0411030389,
0.0499100089,
0.0006008188,
0.0038609083,
-0.016891744,
0.0804841667,
0.013679225,
-0.0219695251,
-0.0352800712,
-0.0394186415,
0.0191301666,
-0.1033330113,
0.1036781669,
-0.0327964835,
-0.0251519103,
-0.000222804,
-0.0454333052,
-0.0267653335,
0.0115880063,
0.0066896169,
0.0285766292,
0.0192989074,
-0.0070926808,
0.0027015372,
-0.0012275428,
-0.079683058,
-0.0362603925,
0.0267861933,
-0.0271958858,
-0.0658561736,
-0.0212977286,
-0.0479408726,
0.0367745757,
-0.0609503575,
0.0037988583,
3.006142672e-34,
0.0260807611,
0.0074147941,
0.0321718976,
-0.0105708484,
0.0379959643,
-0.0297435001,
-0.0664854422,
-0.016045589,
0.0264435075,
-0.0975470617,
-0.0063274512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14735v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14735v4 | Unleashing the potential of prompt engineering in Large Language Models: a comprehensive review | 2023-10-23T09:15:18 | 2024-06-18T16:21:12 | Banghao Chen, Zhaofeng Zhang, Nicolas Langrené, Shengxin Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | This paper delves into the pivotal role of prompt engineering in unleashing
the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). Prompt engineering is the
process of structuring input text for LLMs and is a technique integral to
optimizing the efficacy of LLMs. This survey elucidates foundational principles
of prompt engineering, such as role-prompting, one-shot, and few-shot
prompting, as well as more advanced methodologies such as the chain-of-thought
and tree-of-thoughts prompting. The paper sheds light on how external
assistance in the form of plugins can assist in this task, and reduce machine
hallucination by retrieving external knowledge. We subsequently delineate
prospective directions in prompt engineering research, emphasizing the need for
a deeper understanding of structures and the role of agents in Artificial
Intelligence-Generated Content (AIGC) tools. We discuss how to assess the
efficacy of prompt methods from different perspectives and using different
methods. Finally, we gather information about the application of prompt
engineering in such fields as education and programming, showing its
transformative potential. This comprehensive survey aims to serve as a friendly
guide for anyone venturing through the big world of LLMs and prompt
engineering. | [
0.0349844992,
0.0150246676,
-0.0546388179,
0.0364155471,
-0.0414897464,
-0.0092904,
0.0087032858,
-0.0274288673,
0.0507393368,
-0.034652207,
0.0085945548,
0.00999879,
-0.0216187797,
0.0553500392,
0.0046954132,
-0.0701366663,
0.0448639095,
-0.0531334728,
-0.0036356228,
0.0104724346,
0.0180853177,
0.0238146707,
-0.0094231432,
0.0523196794,
-0.0243721027,
-0.0461886041,
-0.0553294346,
0.0053391657,
-0.0197695252,
-0.0310925599,
-0.0209446792,
0.0430542193,
-0.0145541225,
0.0219242256,
0.0000022759,
-0.0782578588,
-0.0038217842,
0.0028564206,
-0.0438953079,
0.0052799284,
0.0016012824,
0.0421160944,
-0.0163637195,
-0.0025349224,
-0.0406128503,
0.0319564566,
0.0372482315,
-0.0205687154,
0.0500029437,
0.0392968431,
-0.0038461748,
-0.0065604476,
0.0195423048,
0.0261986535,
0.0363493823,
0.0084873056,
0.006544176,
-0.0160257109,
0.0890047178,
0.0445939675,
0.0022069591,
0.0497302152,
0.0321940854,
-0.0676118881,
0.042689506,
0.0181509703,
-0.0053133848,
-0.0594960898,
-0.034839645,
0.0407043882,
0.0282187518,
-0.0161649995,
0.0039130198,
-0.0361711308,
0.04518025,
0.0815882981,
-0.0436431281,
0.0480748527,
-0.00077777,
-0.0117063243,
0.0481051244,
-0.0209689774,
-0.0111477012,
0.0153505523,
-0.0162126031,
0.044282753,
0.016006209,
-0.0437948555,
-0.0175788105,
0.0017847758,
0.0337715223,
-0.0911867246,
-0.0222526155,
0.0738205761,
-0.0585133247,
0.0304194484,
-0.0166855752,
-0.0098808454,
0.0234702937,
-0.0159669034,
0.0254489519,
0.0363487601,
-0.024355676,
0.0361756235,
-0.0116147362,
0.0432928503,
-0.0036168182,
0.0320041627,
-0.0065211817,
0.0528304912,
-0.0718067139,
-0.034580227,
-0.0642004684,
0.0441142581,
-0.0148648517,
0.0031902632,
0.0150293205,
0.0835116953,
-0.0168968961,
0.0625773072,
-0.0226308126,
-0.0183730051,
-0.0005616947,
-0.0013177622,
-0.0181638412,
0.0105776219,
-0.0297204256,
-0.0260626301,
0.0325023383,
-0.0525285713,
0.0202623978,
0.0168822035,
-0.0108414041,
0.0067721908,
-0.0323246568,
0.0584110245,
0.0029374233,
-0.0054343482,
-0.026284663,
-0.0654501989,
0.0208826382,
-0.0150064016,
-0.0187701378,
-0.0889789537,
-0.0212229881,
0.0330990925,
-0.0147287045,
-0.0373684354,
0.002552781,
0.0274597611,
0.0028534124,
0.0549352989,
-0.059336096,
0.0185017381,
0.0451186746,
0.0232253484,
-0.0155456569,
0.0536261722,
0.0244392641,
0.0272110738,
0.0340784267,
-0.009766642,
0.0446459651,
0.0412600674,
-0.0336665288,
0.0064456766,
-0.0181251299,
0.0210957676,
0.020556327,
0.017282892,
-0.0635657385,
0.0304261297,
-0.0133130914,
0.0910486802,
0.0384895392,
0.0448082946,
-0.0003549245,
-0.0016434552,
0.0895252228,
0.0358926356,
0.0098993601,
0.0461008623,
-0.0300128311,
0.0286599118,
-0.0236178637,
0.0146016898,
-0.0100990795,
0.0503540859,
-0.0022434324,
-0.0743842199,
-0.0033153929,
-0.00835359,
-0.0085759964,
-0.0045680446,
0.0305366796,
0.0307732318,
0.0018032492,
0.0141244717,
0.0069269356,
-0.0366147496,
0.0190649033,
-0.0725903958,
0.0384475291,
0.0997717306,
0.0714071244,
-0.0556781553,
-0.0214619972,
-0.0066236309,
0.0120779844,
0.0503548384,
0.0407466702,
-0.0489708483,
-0.066988267,
-0.0237047859,
-0.0127162542,
-0.0279946979,
-0.0061929715,
0.0263078194,
-0.0237181056,
-0.0158235952,
-0.0050307843,
0.0510769449,
-0.0442546383,
0.0504344404,
-0.0613241009,
-0.0310468618,
-0.0279493742,
0.0397406667,
0.0002461331,
0.0259899907,
-0.0096009402,
0.0257134121,
0.0243292172,
-0.0077406219,
-0.01945021,
-0.0172809381,
-0.0226515643,
0.0108580915,
0.0395869091,
-0.013351826,
-0.0089714117,
-0.0468224622,
-0.0121116517,
-0.0482020564,
0.0054320577,
-0.0182372387,
0.0219965838,
-0.0154443244,
0.0436766408,
-0.0282925088,
-0.0374275148,
-0.0400414132,
0.0461002961,
0.0206979252,
-0.0000307898,
0.1001073718,
0.0460177884,
0.0166018046,
0.0003547519,
-0.0209815986,
0.0302312598,
0.0028423956,
0.0151171796,
0.0405585244,
0.0380340107,
-0.0359262973,
-0.0388148725,
-0.043790374,
-0.0325588584,
-0.010094122,
-0.0130126812,
0.0122604091,
0.0125531331,
-0.0282362849,
-0.0001785278,
-0.0364823043,
-0.0074951486,
-0.0002776476,
0.0075847446,
0.0421668962,
0.0204619132,
-0.0412918031,
-0.0035331403,
0.0052274861,
-0.0324199982,
0.0233264063,
0.0527134873,
-0.0551739819,
-0.0932390988,
0.0359865762,
-0.0024742377,
-0.0170916002,
0.0182394926,
-0.0071586072,
0.0364868715,
-0.0108808251,
0.08349704,
0.0310038682,
-0.0169520043,
0.0284437444,
0.0615994222,
-0.0111234877,
-0.0383223221,
0.0033292512,
0.0048261639,
-0.0091873202,
-0.0058727958,
-0.0366344303,
0.0277447365,
0.0460836403,
0.0115581453,
0.0050175283,
-0.037368767,
0.0578521676,
-0.0183676053,
-0.0167349856,
-0.0108776763,
-0.0765304267,
-0.0287832413,
0.0845293254,
0.0120190727,
-0.0483511202,
0.0962602347,
-0.0427387469,
-0.0011330239,
-0.0214647818,
-0.0072372635,
-0.0315316617,
0.0467935205,
0.0100668082,
0.0010117356,
0.0217890106,
-0.0181928854,
-0.067366913,
0.0278965496,
0.0147969183,
-0.0165776107,
0.0251693819,
-0.0362760052,
-0.0135826645,
0.000062834,
-0.0222634561,
-0.0585251302,
-0.0277708638,
-0.0042955643,
-0.0113796499,
0.0149824619,
0.0152811361,
0.0282283016,
-0.0120144421,
0.0301482845,
0.020629365,
-0.0021903575,
-0.028266931,
-0.0363226905,
0.031401135,
0.0183776766,
-0.0082384627,
0.0148521373,
-0.0299229175,
0.0856492668,
0.0206591096,
-0.0149466582,
-0.0126666324,
-0.0033875802,
-0.0164819956,
0.0310072396,
-0.0522842519,
-0.0367298648,
0.0543267876,
0.0374050587,
-0.0606724471,
-0.0373251438,
0.0950991735,
0.0544220395,
-0.0535297245,
0.0019906445,
-0.0667726099,
0.0170321334,
0.0295781698,
0.0597840175,
-0.0943998396,
0.013395451,
-0.0040303008,
-0.0002663258,
-0.044102814,
-0.0086710863,
-0.0117852464,
-0.1154111028,
0.0549670793,
-0.0225644261,
0.006916522,
0.0200866144,
0.006055837,
0.0024510759,
0.059065938,
-0.0279909167,
0.0117611988,
-0.0309823416,
-0.003474175,
0.024129821,
-0.0352879874,
-0.0218260866,
-0.0312355049,
-0.0176476873,
0.0654731095,
0.0709329396,
-0.0026038024,
0.0036138152,
-0.0273747202,
0.0122766327,
0.0023404823,
0.0362552889,
-0.0145123731,
0.0206852928,
0.0022149258,
0.0047180844,
-0.0176956896,
0.0130034033,
0.0008422988,
-0.0526635461,
0.0606863312,
0.1078070253,
-0.039052479,
0.0028539919,
-0.0685527772,
0.0008918641,
0.0108374776,
0.0529246479,
0.0667347983,
-0.0656153113,
-0.0220937897,
-0.0677975267,
-0.0205243751,
-0.0121991811,
-0.0449733287,
0.0129075032,
-0.0058881468,
0.0115136569,
-0.0600819439,
-0.0476810746,
0.0491672754,
0.0229493231,
0.0546138808,
-0.0001487981,
0.0149440579,
0.0026022154,
-0.0033228321,
0.0088944081,
-0.0439744443,
-0.0071158754,
-0.0471637137,
-0.0472054482,
-0.0083880713,
-0.0794727132,
0.0167043656,
-0.0209044516,
-0.0131819118,
-0.0653280616,
-0.0074728387,
0.050593242,
0.0346200764,
0.028289238,
-0.0161888283,
-0.0582040809,
0.0485915877,
0.038438201,
-0.0501149148,
-0.0149772605,
-0.0122553464,
0.0329044275,
0.0012882603,
0.0174984764,
-0.0553385466,
0.006675275,
-0.012379949,
0.0013279172,
-0.0283519961,
-0.0380689017,
0.0420759805,
0.0610338934,
-0.0273800883,
-0.0239766184,
0.0194623489,
-0.0531710126,
-0.004609731,
-0.0418624878,
-0.0518261418,
-0.0271274019,
0.0188433677,
-0.0060225343,
-0.011066433,
0.046094995,
-0.0194290504,
-0.055121839,
0.0275256056,
-0.0272755735,
0.0416750461,
-0.0031004508,
0.050804954,
0.0421527401,
0.0048292498,
-0.0285644289,
0.0316248387,
-0.0122451046,
0.0219543073,
0.0004877563,
0.1016453281,
0.0208083205,
-0.0049403547,
0.0164684653,
0.0388679951,
-0.0523709618,
-0.0834911242,
-0.0056125517,
0.0519621484,
0.0120633822,
0.0183228701,
0.0080408473,
-0.0397614874,
0.0061677722,
0.031011859,
0.0039856671,
0.0605535097,
-0.0663348883,
-0.0180654135,
0.0290661268,
-0.0156699643,
-0.0529346429,
0.0386598036,
-0.0568404496,
-0.0141250398,
0.0071955696,
-0.0022434287,
-0.0565495118,
-0.0174372699,
0.0130259702,
0.0071977731,
-0.0333167352,
-0.0114456657,
-0.1004191712,
-0.0298401117,
-0.007617861,
0.0373566002,
-0.0083136838,
-0.011917674,
0.0348999575,
0.0441449657,
0.0306350756,
0.0013916228,
-0.0221906919,
0.0096805291,
-0.0315636806,
-0.0301100295,
0.0063127624,
-5.819400496e-33,
-0.0499312915,
-0.0614576004,
0.0448097847,
0.0291589331,
0.0098478673,
0.0159555357,
-0.0434370078,
0.0218386669,
0.0098402053,
0.0075746472,
-0.0242359396,
-0.0348476805,
0.0026127242,
-0.0017937542,
0.0547175929,
-0.0006353128,
0.0486762188,
-0.0022766613,
-0.0180962346,
0.0322099477,
0.0014285061,
-0.0150728552,
-0.0116234291,
-0.0165394451,
0.0679684803,
-0.0498524196,
-0.0091106854,
0.0032939697,
-0.015156785,
0.0503598861,
-0.0138808498,
0.0442068204,
0.0195390899,
-0.0284101907,
-0.0326771475,
0.0607044734,
-0.0329556316,
-0.0566911884,
0.0222969018,
-0.0088978373,
-0.036548242,
-0.0558085665,
0.0165388025,
-0.044505626,
-0.006451908,
0.0317812972,
0.0566961206,
-0.0118518351,
0.0217816178,
-0.0077633937,
-0.1063030437,
0.0030305155,
-0.0296453685,
-0.0140536772,
0.0237947945,
0.0428249948,
0.0141753303,
0.0105145629,
-0.0108646397,
0.0424699001,
0.0213318691,
0.0283957943,
0.0796864703,
0.0133182481,
-0.0164925605,
0.0479321256,
0.0238806345,
0.0450431071,
-0.0429995507,
0.0010793213,
0.0045094234,
0.0297852661,
0.0571936518,
0.0377757698,
-0.0106374826,
0.0020992665,
-0.0122600617,
0.0237816516,
0.022693783,
-0.0197274555,
0.0072533842,
-0.0227531567,
-0.0394838117,
-0.0150603382,
-0.009646154,
-0.0248110052,
-0.0136914607,
-0.044802621,
0.0210215226,
-0.0467520319,
-0.0306720398,
-0.0244404469,
0.0019155571,
-0.0182874724,
0.0086197685,
0.0151834916,
-0.0227459669,
0.0551362634,
-0.0118643502,
0.0303465892,
-0.0233111028,
-0.0174761061,
0.0101341652,
-0.021707071,
0.0314751156,
0.0653907657,
-0.0088403523,
0.0378433168,
-0.0511051491,
-0.0013833127,
-0.0495541915,
0.0249638855,
0.0014875545,
-0.0253701843,
0.0305736493,
0.0057707955,
-0.0029688599,
0.0225538574,
0.0314630009,
-0.0489761047,
-0.038045384,
0.0194744561,
-0.0198066663,
-0.016729394,
-0.0376329832,
-0.0173178613,
-0.050182011,
0.0538870208,
0.0480896793,
-0.0535766743,
-0.0180649608,
0.0165663417,
2.984e-7,
0.0153348204,
0.0516247936,
0.0287405774,
0.0245281179,
-0.0059976578,
0.0000235172,
-0.0138076069,
-0.0336838067,
0.0155162802,
-0.0329244956,
0.0056082173,
0.0194815733,
0.0135378158,
0.0434910022,
-0.1305937171,
-0.0113672204,
-0.0236840453,
0.018805854,
-0.1058965623,
0.0327357687,
0.1081227362,
0.0170017406,
0.0048494814,
-0.0004352564,
-0.0285327248,
-0.0202679727,
-0.0167708043,
-0.0174266808,
0.0046507097,
0.0450462252,
0.0065313294,
0.0040445607,
0.0047776955,
0.0216630008,
0.002804877,
0.0014605012,
-0.0161651578,
0.0399590209,
0.019179387,
0.0208371617,
0.0219435953,
-0.0388109237,
0.0045541008,
-0.0643975884,
0.0306959487,
-0.0358567946,
0.0078812055,
-0.0245448202,
-0.0442144796,
-0.0526333824,
-0.0117289741,
-0.0306819025,
0.0132032009,
0.0309045035,
-0.0267223399,
-0.0218727328,
-0.0060545928,
-0.0341863744,
-0.0153724598,
-0.0179708302,
-0.0135583803,
-0.0379658937,
-0.045282986,
-0.0101073738,
0.0146184759,
-0.060770914,
0.0083218189,
3.060972596e-34,
0.0114025483,
-0.0375758931,
0.0535730124,
0.0459034443,
0.0121499375,
0.0190081634,
-0.0141494125,
0.0308493841,
0.0436053164,
-0.0675263554,
-0.0424045958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14732v1 | Generating Prototypes for Contradiction Detection Using Large Language Models and Linguistic Rules | 2023-10-23T09:07:27 | 2023-10-23T09:07:27 | Maren Pielka, Svetlana Schmidt, Rafet Sifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce a novel data generation method for contradiction detection,
which leverages the generative power of large language models as well as
linguistic rules. Our vision is to provide a condensed corpus of prototypical
contradictions, allowing for in-depth linguistic analysis as well as efficient
language model fine-tuning. To this end, we instruct the generative models to
create contradicting statements with respect to descriptions of specific
contradiction types. In addition, the model is also instructed to come up with
completely new contradiction typologies. As an auxiliary approach, we use
linguistic rules to construct simple contradictions such as those arising from
negation, antonymy and numeric mismatch. We find that our methods yield
promising results in terms of coherence and variety of the data. Further
studies, as well as manual refinement are necessary to make use of this data in
a machine learning setup. | [
0.0582356378,
0.0832368433,
-0.0277413707,
0.0740552396,
-0.0601106212,
0.0232315976,
0.0209395867,
-0.0092940554,
-0.0029876279,
-0.0759996548,
0.0467985459,
-0.0288228411,
-0.019561667,
0.0456188507,
0.0239035953,
-0.0130967004,
0.0735030696,
0.0286440812,
0.0405016877,
-0.0127229448,
0.0185757261,
0.0236920621,
-0.0087652691,
-0.0085781738,
-0.0700025782,
-0.0164267886,
0.0018148851,
0.0246154424,
0.0105328215,
-0.0331003554,
-0.0048790718,
0.0335313492,
0.0114203226,
0.135597989,
0.0000019372,
-0.0561109446,
-0.0177924689,
0.0121385884,
-0.056096103,
0.0055132215,
0.0772273168,
-0.0357178189,
-0.0286909528,
-0.0020771262,
-0.0345015228,
0.0008092838,
0.0516345315,
0.0837185234,
0.0791248754,
0.076612398,
-0.0007974207,
-0.013777595,
0.0054317145,
-0.0079158787,
-0.0159024484,
0.0195016451,
0.0246155206,
0.0319805592,
-0.0257955473,
0.0328967683,
-0.0069946158,
0.0028655997,
0.0240177736,
-0.0005342961,
-0.0579475649,
-0.0079681929,
-0.0731471479,
-0.0282481611,
0.0240752902,
0.0547872633,
-0.0156798549,
-0.0526911318,
-0.0080635091,
0.0144804502,
-0.0064922119,
-0.0225036144,
0.0070519126,
0.0242571663,
-0.0248866249,
0.0388029553,
0.038739074,
-0.0300515369,
0.0228985604,
-0.0243569594,
-0.0438448936,
-0.0114449589,
0.0159372278,
-0.0445366316,
-0.0045311283,
-0.0180478916,
-0.0680167153,
-0.0417149924,
-0.0175314937,
-0.0240963064,
-0.0146456482,
-0.0042227148,
-0.0598296188,
-0.0499062799,
0.0653751567,
-0.0762331188,
0.034129262,
-0.0129681667,
0.0068613859,
0.0490940548,
-0.019151004,
0.0334219635,
-0.0049327696,
0.0209254641,
-0.0072529148,
-0.0283641759,
-0.0072916178,
-0.0039196126,
-0.0234781988,
0.0075789285,
-0.0535951145,
0.0044347974,
0.001274364,
0.0137111954,
-0.0596181862,
0.0516968891,
-0.0396312624,
-0.0024514501,
0.0072953808,
-0.007641138,
-0.0242914781,
-0.0288253464,
-0.0272325464,
0.0317248926,
-0.0318995006,
-0.0732419491,
0.0110267056,
0.0013834566,
-0.0486337245,
0.0020472431,
0.0176746659,
0.068263188,
0.0148342056,
0.0185834467,
-0.0194368288,
0.0202175751,
-0.0474509522,
-0.072615765,
-0.0232132357,
-0.0730751231,
0.0332166962,
-0.0061844611,
-0.0118652582,
-0.0443271622,
0.0123137403,
0.0111557487,
0.0079900566,
0.0821696743,
-0.0263298936,
-0.016973434,
0.038376648,
-0.0316339843,
-0.0152614731,
0.0364401042,
0.0004800159,
-0.0315314718,
0.062332157,
0.0179493539,
-0.0179888271,
-0.0063534924,
-0.001107882,
0.0205967706,
-0.0518212579,
0.0256286077,
0.0299717896,
0.0104608089,
-0.0198969282,
0.0868165791,
-0.0190513898,
-0.0846309662,
0.0119118905,
-0.0395429656,
-0.0118600708,
-0.0020830659,
0.041738309,
0.0229854211,
0.0089416439,
-0.0216716155,
-0.0211098772,
-0.0279711019,
-0.0269108936,
-0.0101944497,
0.010976919,
0.0723024011,
-0.0043369299,
-0.0627658516,
-0.0451107174,
0.0053429613,
-0.0226286892,
-0.0402629375,
0.0252681375,
0.0086136945,
-0.0202241093,
-0.0034483441,
0.0378941782,
-0.0776820555,
-0.0295580234,
-0.0239344221,
0.015231682,
0.0555360876,
0.0332860984,
-0.0244819354,
-0.0012196942,
-0.0221566055,
-0.0034959537,
0.0547278784,
0.053947065,
0.0098016132,
-0.0133248409,
-0.0367674306,
0.0264010504,
-0.0625628307,
0.0592432916,
-0.0293617118,
0.0147939883,
0.0330407806,
0.0203265212,
-0.049262166,
-0.0299701318,
0.0543427169,
0.0091433972,
-0.0229665097,
0.004985319,
0.0163904484,
0.0005454118,
0.0220669545,
-0.0559309795,
0.0141587015,
0.0386281833,
-0.0366009325,
-0.0257456563,
-0.0206336882,
0.0172869395,
-0.0542914495,
0.0617482066,
-0.0519127138,
-0.0432144329,
0.0214012861,
-0.0575811304,
0.0032813537,
0.0181177408,
-0.0487590395,
0.0101846932,
-0.0362440422,
0.0204139743,
0.0028600586,
0.0229527559,
-0.0234043375,
0.0438677259,
-0.0227924604,
0.0384729989,
0.0160174184,
0.0143849291,
0.0617592111,
-0.0258016493,
-0.0022484493,
0.0145821013,
0.0035174987,
0.0242155958,
-0.0121786539,
0.0003495385,
0.0029724066,
-0.0721808448,
-0.0291811526,
-0.0094012795,
0.0024485968,
-0.0053644818,
0.0301983654,
-0.0469209291,
-0.0015235229,
-0.0007345352,
0.0502325408,
-0.001928923,
0.0502557531,
0.0028461646,
0.0522378162,
-0.0250603557,
-0.0322192647,
-0.0382649824,
0.0019862631,
-0.0330693088,
0.0628704801,
-0.0020809129,
0.047275234,
-0.0000923011,
-0.0315994322,
-0.0503160879,
0.038572304,
-0.0023091345,
-0.0171321277,
0.0415245965,
0.0045992984,
0.030704638,
0.0246842355,
0.0448245928,
0.0745270252,
0.0490734093,
-0.0387503244,
-0.0254115388,
0.0124154352,
-0.0058256467,
0.0259298086,
-0.0101915561,
-0.0324390903,
0.0279123597,
0.0227368344,
0.0161331221,
-0.019012874,
-0.0316290632,
0.1208456233,
-0.0391355604,
0.0066475542,
0.0227606669,
-0.0194504559,
-0.0091105336,
0.0222809445,
-0.0018691286,
0.0011185502,
0.0633073524,
-0.0366031937,
0.0246991981,
-0.0565089099,
-0.0326369926,
-0.0447559357,
0.0562089197,
-0.0106101781,
0.0229458492,
0.0402569026,
0.052596394,
0.0070252763,
0.0049108611,
0.0592468828,
-0.0178767815,
0.027488878,
-0.0301466696,
-0.008204055,
-0.0103226034,
-0.0540144891,
-0.0712978691,
-0.0488853008,
-0.0041584014,
-0.0127851665,
0.0131656202,
0.006019826,
-0.0497022979,
-0.0115862032,
-0.0527197942,
-0.0058619813,
0.0260356106,
-0.0168592129,
-0.0318625048,
-0.0006044804,
0.0246895477,
0.032423608,
0.0515215322,
-0.0075258859,
-0.0102487644,
0.0171000846,
-0.0337550081,
0.011210274,
-0.0034201269,
-0.0143213086,
-0.0271291658,
0.0053251246,
0.009389963,
-0.0179146249,
-0.0207277946,
-0.0379224569,
0.0007836918,
0.0828094557,
0.054441113,
0.0323712789,
0.0188498851,
-0.0369180329,
0.0243820138,
0.0243829135,
-0.0051751193,
-0.1005632207,
-0.0169897024,
-0.0011690593,
-0.0213035308,
-0.0226240084,
-0.0237500537,
-0.0196573026,
-0.11065685,
0.0387840159,
0.0326783918,
-0.0363080278,
-0.0830574185,
-0.0056728455,
-0.0070803682,
-0.0019879721,
0.008491993,
0.0255685151,
-0.0016635817,
0.0227881111,
-0.0139821153,
0.0142917819,
-0.0292470772,
-0.0030483657,
-0.0272384528,
0.0365284644,
-0.0073736678,
0.0469658747,
0.004433821,
-0.0005109288,
0.0128080612,
-0.0144985029,
-0.0533045158,
-0.0104709361,
0.012537376,
-0.0097521553,
-0.0191989392,
-0.042689614,
0.0138144139,
-0.0270366743,
-0.0251930412,
0.0190669131,
0.0541039519,
-0.0078067537,
-0.0375430658,
-0.0463967361,
0.0219765659,
0.0177182145,
0.0725776032,
0.0050281375,
0.0116864061,
-0.0530235209,
-0.0575897917,
0.0036681397,
-0.020278234,
0.0128083518,
-0.0216270201,
0.052353505,
0.0382111892,
-0.0732439607,
-0.0197693426,
-0.0200809482,
-0.0030176933,
-0.0050342469,
-0.0303678047,
-0.0345276482,
-0.0226699281,
-0.0386237167,
-0.0260005742,
0.0182794128,
0.0313952565,
-0.0155840078,
0.0093296198,
0.0115289623,
0.0255807806,
-0.0116587318,
0.0570586137,
-0.0439656489,
-0.0716607347,
0.0438651368,
0.0036892612,
0.010366749,
0.0269936044,
-0.0165918004,
0.0426518545,
-0.0429886058,
0.1111426726,
-0.0280634128,
0.0499101095,
0.0634050742,
-0.0044650654,
-0.0000307049,
0.0439811833,
0.0138356965,
0.0179919358,
-0.0119222533,
0.0258121565,
-0.0661900118,
-0.0659816265,
0.0336308554,
0.0115009248,
0.0012404275,
0.0303348172,
-0.016092997,
-0.0278531108,
0.0087056477,
-0.0328472331,
-0.0520456396,
-0.0155667476,
-0.0002087355,
-0.0155964755,
-0.0106911985,
-0.0315434709,
0.0229222141,
-0.0071077491,
0.0687981844,
0.0168940034,
0.0160723384,
0.0494068041,
0.0308382083,
0.0004519554,
-0.0554113947,
-0.0218037404,
0.03255881,
-0.0394924469,
0.0104042673,
-0.0164644215,
0.0270041283,
0.0395409353,
-0.0377536789,
-0.05662838,
-0.0266749617,
-0.0146852406,
-0.0086769769,
-0.0252759978,
-0.0074541126,
0.02850434,
0.0196570531,
0.0174249075,
-0.0314310044,
-0.0440700576,
-0.025709426,
0.0269333627,
0.0388281159,
-0.029197624,
0.0419084541,
0.0261684489,
-0.040025074,
-0.0288369954,
0.0169986952,
0.002935526,
0.0588774793,
0.0371871069,
0.0110619524,
-0.0456809066,
-0.0301792156,
-0.0076647596,
-0.0020463662,
0.0188567825,
0.0463315994,
-0.0984493122,
-0.0529105663,
0.0252023321,
0.0524949245,
0.0242283102,
0.0391864814,
-0.0084263552,
0.0713860989,
0.0188787561,
-0.0053159585,
-0.0201357566,
0.0529197566,
0.0028971334,
-0.0062937853,
-0.0347978994,
-5.479374062e-33,
-0.0402087048,
-0.043907091,
-0.0132816723,
-0.0258342009,
-0.0071896841,
-0.0342699364,
-0.0175654162,
-0.0237272289,
-0.0264361836,
0.0543593466,
0.0291656014,
0.0335762836,
0.0067100115,
0.0091867652,
-0.022402104,
-0.0027521159,
0.088684909,
0.0232234411,
-0.0008558957,
-0.0352078564,
0.0712112933,
-0.0377425812,
0.0096938461,
-0.0818552598,
0.0185691826,
-0.0319793522,
-0.0369660854,
0.0523971021,
-0.0296319071,
0.0409687385,
-0.0309328604,
0.0708358884,
-0.0085136406,
0.0120027848,
0.0100375023,
-0.0409875326,
-0.0165431835,
-0.0248259697,
0.0222157668,
-0.0254414398,
-0.0094550503,
-0.032643076,
0.0118994284,
-0.0066595986,
-0.0150986407,
0.0110702589,
0.0214551762,
-0.0217313692,
0.0497915894,
0.0165372528,
-0.1083879545,
0.0485079661,
-0.0134450607,
-0.0056793955,
-0.0286143105,
-0.019708436,
0.0175688416,
-0.0408395343,
-0.0564480349,
0.0242162328,
0.0452428535,
-0.0041417624,
-0.0113896737,
-0.0288187191,
-0.0113164447,
0.0529242344,
-0.024045106,
0.0179540813,
-0.0166397039,
0.027520502,
-0.0094911978,
0.0517643318,
0.0501302779,
0.1002615467,
0.0210268684,
-0.0133657204,
-0.0421834253,
-0.0401273705,
-0.000899699,
0.0182681829,
0.035856802,
-0.0227260981,
-0.0265040211,
0.0013538199,
-0.0358850025,
-0.0187480189,
-0.0311087295,
0.010363536,
0.0378827937,
0.014921423,
-0.0420588925,
-0.0412518792,
-0.007138154,
-0.0463756025,
-0.0414615795,
0.0320088491,
-0.0226749498,
-0.0321784653,
0.0390035175,
0.0094662122,
-0.0271808896,
-0.0259640589,
0.0556594692,
0.0135058183,
-0.0075268024,
-0.0272579473,
0.0308968797,
-0.0014667736,
-0.0735476837,
0.0270176921,
0.0131552313,
0.0340477638,
-0.0334852338,
-0.0507282838,
0.0220112503,
0.0227508601,
-0.0157253239,
0.0143041564,
-0.0134605356,
-0.0165114813,
-0.0632236823,
0.0730534792,
0.0056036594,
0.04081323,
-0.0094705448,
0.0085946228,
-0.0482826158,
0.0272622276,
0.0063129459,
-0.0555829518,
0.0078567658,
-0.0086920699,
2.491e-7,
0.028029684,
0.0402436256,
0.0504327565,
0.0271401796,
0.0182125382,
0.0479175597,
-0.0123165948,
0.0044655092,
-0.0434970148,
0.0326429158,
-0.037550427,
0.0536784641,
0.0291956551,
0.0361335501,
-0.0008808825,
0.0886812285,
-0.0449219309,
-0.0584240742,
-0.0636302531,
0.0178646035,
0.0819114819,
0.1308453828,
0.0472788587,
-0.0001630039,
-0.0012557446,
-0.0327039175,
0.0618196726,
0.0093620224,
-0.0186720844,
0.0070690545,
0.0302826092,
-0.0352059901,
0.0353185199,
0.0162853207,
0.0000511797,
-0.0013393572,
-0.01729027,
0.0375376157,
-0.0018680888,
0.0184894875,
-0.031191038,
-0.036656443,
-0.034015011,
-0.0753775612,
0.0564868264,
-0.0210090149,
-0.0048319772,
-0.0389940813,
-0.012975459,
0.0052796318,
0.0503013469,
-0.0193838514,
-0.0451361202,
-0.0108653922,
0.0222960021,
0.0013724562,
0.0134389624,
-0.0386442281,
0.009318212,
0.0329440013,
-0.0257789157,
-0.0202080775,
0.0196463205,
0.050967183,
0.0649790689,
0.025693493,
0.0441595763,
2.376791721e-34,
0.0927578658,
-0.0071638543,
0.0244177431,
-0.0316177867,
0.0526237413,
0.0133893574,
-0.036502447,
0.0115765454,
-0.0012531092,
-0.0115106748,
0.0338399671
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.